 FACTSHEET WHAT IS AIDS? 
 AIDS (Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome)  is a condition caused by a virus called HIV (Human Immuno Deficiency Virus). 
 This virus affects the body's defence system so that it cannot fight infection. 
 How is infection transmitted? 
 through unprotected sexual intercourse with an infected partner. 
 through infected blood or blood products. 
 from an infected mother to her baby. 
 It is not  transmitted from: 
 giving blood/mosquito bites/toilet seats/kissing/from normal day-to-day contact 
 How does it affect you? 
 The medical aspects can be cancer, pneumonia, sudden blindness, dementia, dramatic weight loss or any combination of these. 
 Often infected people are rejected by family and friends, leaving them to face this chronic condition alone. 
 Did you know? 
 there is no vaccine or cure currently available. 
 10 million people worldwide are infected with HIV. 
 you can be infected for between 10&ndash;15 years without realising it. 
 7 out of 10 people infected are heterosexual. 
 women are twice as at risk from infection as men. 
 In the UK 
 16,000 reported infections (it is probable that there are between 40&ndash;60,000 people actually infected). 
 there are nearly 5,000 reported cases of AIDS, of which nearly 3,000 have already died. 
 1 in 500 Londoners are believed to be infected. 
 The Future 
 The World Health Organisation projects 40 million infections by the year 2000. 
 &bquo;We are just at the beginning of the worldwide epidemic and the situation is still very unstable. 
 The major impact is yet to come.&equo; 
 &mdash; Professor Jonathan Mann, former director of the WHO Global AIDS Programme and ACET's International Adviser. 
 Useful Contacts: 
 ACET &mdash; Practical home care, schools education and training &mdash; 081 840 7879 
 Mildmay Hospital, Hackney Road, London E2 7NA &mdash; Hospice care &mdash; 071 739 2331 
 Catholic AIDS Link &mdash; Spiritual, practical and financial support &mdash; P O Box 646, London E9 6QP 
 National AIDS Helpline &mdash; Counselling and confidential advice &mdash; 0800 567 123 
 Bureau of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine &mdash; Overseas development &mdash; 071 636 8638 
 Haemophilia Society &mdash; Serving the interests of Haemophiliacs &mdash; 071 928 2020 
 SCODA &mdash; HIV and drugs &mdash; 071 430 2341 
 Immunity &mdash; HIV and legal issues &mdash; 081 968 8909 
 FACTSHEET PUT THE FUN BACK IN FUNDRAISING! 
 Raising money for your favourite charity can be fun. 
 You can do it on your own or you can get together with family and friends. 
 There is no limit to the number of ways to raise money. 
 Whether the final total is &pound;5 or &pound;5,000, it is all very much needed. 
 Below I've listed some ideas which many people have already carried out. 
 None of them is new and they are all straightforward. 
 1. 
 CAR BOOT SALE 
 &mdash; Why not have a clear out? 
 I did and I was absolutely amazed at how much stuff I sold and the kind of things people bought. 
 It can be fun as well. 
 2. 
 JUMBLE SALE 
 &mdash; A bit like a car boot sale but for clothes and it happens indoors. 
 You need to involve your friends collecting jumble. 
 Don't plan on selling too much at more than 10p an item. 
 3. 
 SPONSORED RUN 
 &mdash; For the keen fun runner, why not get your next full or half marathon sponsored. 
 4. 
 HAVE A DISCO 
 &mdash; At your local club or church why not put on an evening for young people? 
 It's hard work but very rewarding. 
 5. 
 A PARACHUTE JUMP 
 &mdash; Not for the faint-hearted. 
 But why not pluck up the courage to do what you've always wanted? 
 It's all in a good cause. 
 6. 
 SPONSORED SLIM 
 7. 
 HOLD A COFFEE MORNING or  BAKE CAKES 
 to sell to work colleagues. 
 8. 
 KIDDIES' SPONSORED SWIM 
 9. 
 Organise a  SPONSORED WALK OR RAMBLE 
 for your church or youth club. 
 10. 
 SPONSORED DISCO MARATHON or  FOOTBALL 5-A-SIDE. 
 If I can help further please do not hesitate to contact me on 081 840 7879 Peter Fabian Director of Fundraising  
 FACTSHEET BECOMING AN ACET HOME CARE VOLUNTEER 
 About ACET's Home Care 
 Many people with AIDS have to spend long periods of time in hospital unless there is someone at home who can help and look after them. 
 ACET volunteers work as part of a team and provide help in many different ways to ensure that people don't spend time in hospital unnecessarily. 
 What do ACET volunteers do? 
 Transport clients to and from hospital 
 Housework 
 Shopping including collection of prescriptions 
 Daysitting and nightsitting 
 How much time to I need to give? 
 The simple answer is as much or as little as you feel able to give. 
 Many of our existing volunteers have families and jobs and are often very busy. 
 You don't have to make a firm commitment but obviously we like you to give us some idea of your availability. 
 This is so we can respond effectively to the needs of our clients. 
 Do I need any training? 
 Yes &mdash; but you are not expected to be a nurse. 
 You will be asked to complete an application form and subsequently to attend an ACET training course one evening a week for six weeks. 
 The subjects covered will include: 
 Death and Dying 
 Grief and Loss 
 Sex and Sexuality 
 Medical Aspects of HIV/AIDS 
 Race and Racism 
 Practical Issues 
 What if I find certain issues or situations difficult? 
 Your course leader will be available to help you. 
 You are also asked to keep your church leaders informed of your involvement so that they can ensure you are adequately supported. 
 After every client visit you are asked to call the office so that you can report how the visit went. 
 We also hold regular meetings of volunteers to discuss issues of concern and encourage one another. 
 Volunteers visiting an ACET client have immediate access to professional nursing support through our 24 hour on call facility. 
 I would like to be an ACET volunteer so what do I do now?   
 Telephone or write to Christine Catlin or Janet Sutton and ask for an application form. 
 ACET P O Box 1323 London W5 5TF Tel: 081 840 7879 
 Newsletter AIDS CARE, EDUCATION AND TRAINING Issue No. 7 
 Cliff is New Patron 
 CLIFF RICHARD and Head of Salvation Army, General Eva Burrows are the first patrons of ACET. 
 In the charity's Ealing offices, Cliff, with BBC newsroom South East television cameras in attendance, cut a cake to help celebrate ACET's third birthday during June. 
 After a short interview with the BBC, Cliff went to meet ACET client Tony Chapman at his home, together with HIV Community Nurse, Sue Lore. 
 A trip to an ACET AIDS education class at Abbeylands School, Addlestone in Surrey, completed Cliff's visit. 
 Cliff said, &bquo;I am pleased to support ACET in the world they are doing. 
 The care of people in the community, with are ill with HIV infection and AIDS, together with the education of schoolchildren to help prevent the spread of this terrible disease is becoming more and more urgent.&equo; 
 &bquo;I believe it is especially important that ACET represents the Church working in the front line to provide real and practical support. 
 So often Christians are criticised for not getting involved.&equo;  
 Cliff with Dr Patrick Dixon, Director of ACET 
 Glasgow Home Care 
 ACET opened its Glasgow Home Care service in late June after receiving confirmation of a grant from the Greater Glasgow Health Board to fund the work. 
 The Ruchill Hospital Social work team and the AIDS Resource Unit were particularly helpful in identifying the need for this service. 
 Home care Coordinator, Margaret Gillies, currently has a team of 20 volunteers from a variety of churches providing practical help to a number of clients already referred. 
 Strathclyde Regional Council may provide further funding and consideration is being given to the possible employment of a part-time nurse. 
 Margaret Gillies says, &bquo;We are discovering the extent of the need for the kind of help that ACET offers from other support agencies including Scottish AIDS Monitor and Body Positive as well as hospital contacts and local counselling services.&equo; 
 Chris Southwick, director of ACET (Scotland), said, &bquo;With the opening of this office in Glasgow, ACET's volunteer home care is now available to 95&percnt; of those infected with the HIV virus in Scotland.&equo; 
 Most Churches Unprepared for Aids 
 &bquo;Most churches are completely unprepared for the shock of finding an established member of the congregation is infected with HIV or dying with AIDS, even though this is increasingly common.&equo; 
 ACET Director, Dr Patrick Dixon, recently told the National Symposium on Teenage Sexuality at Swanwick. 
 The conference was attended by 300 church youth leaders and school workers from across the UK. 
 Dr Dixon said, &bquo;With up to 20 years from infection to illness, we just have to ask how many of our congregation have been added during that time? 
 Three-quarters of the AIDS problem is in London and much of the rest in Scottish cities. 
 Churches in these areas particularly need to be informed, involved in community care and supporting Christian workers seeking to prevent new HIV infection in schools.&equo; 
 The Symposium considered how the Church can communicate more effectively to young people today for the benefit of their safety and emotional health. 
 &bquo;Many churches are responding. 
 Those involved with ACET are now helping provide home care for one in four of all those dying with AIDS in the UK and up to 4,000 school pupils a month are now receiving education on the subject. 
 Both programmes are the largest of their kind in the country.&equo; 
 ACET is currently offering speakers to inform, motivate, train and support. 
 Churches wanting a speaker should contact the West London offices on 081 840 7879. 
 Third Annual Report Published 
 The third annual report for 1990/91, subtitled &bquo;Bringing it Home&equo; was published on 21 June this year. 
 Official figures suggest that ACET provided care at home for up to one in four of all those who died of AIDS in the UK last year. 
 24,000 pupils were also seen by ACET educators.  
 Bulletin Board 
 ACET will shortly be opening a new office in the east end of London to serve clients in North and East London. 
 Nurse Kay Hopps will have responsibility for the running of the office. 
 The numbers of men, women and children covered by home care with 24 hour on call has doubled in a year. 
 ACET South (based in Portsmouth) will move into its new accommodation during July. 
 Purchased by the Portsmouth and South East Hampshire Area Health Authority, the building will be home to two other AIDS charities. 
 The team is caring for growing numbers ill on the South Coast, including Brighton. 
 The 24-page full colour schools booklet &bquo;HIV &mdash; It's Your Choice&equo; is now available to members of the public at a price of 50p each. 
 Last year ACET educators saw 24,500 pupils in face to face presentations. 
 The ACET Conference in May at the Ealing YMCA was well attended by both staff and volunteers from London, the South East, Northern Ireland, Scotland, Romania and Uganda. 
 UK Director and organiser of the Conference, Peter Johnson, said, &bquo;For many, the day provided a reaffirmation of the vision for ACET and a marvellous sense of unity. 
 It was the first time our national and international network had gathered together in one place and made us all realise just how much the work has grown.&equo; 
 Three visitors from Frankfurt, Germany, recently visited ACET's offices before returning home to begin a similar service, Christian AIDS Help (CAH). 
 Interest was expressed in all of the organisational aspects of home care including nursing, equipment loans and the volunteer programme. 
 Like ACET, CAH will give both medical and practical help to AIDS patients in the home. 
 Letters to the Editor 
 Letters would be welcome. 
 Any contributions may be edited. 
 Please write to: THE EDITOR, ACET NEWSLETTER, P.O. 
 BOX 1323, LONDON W5 5TF. 
 Be an ACET-Link for your Church 
 Dear Friend 
 As the number of people ill with AIDS increases so does the need for volunteers to care for them. 
 Over the last three years, our volunteers have provided much love and care to many hurt and lonely people. 
 The support our volunteers provide cannot be measured in purely practical terms and their continuing contribution is vital if we are to provide an ongoing service. 
 In recognition of their importance and the need to train more volunteers, we want to develop links with individual churches. 
 To do this, we would like to recruit people who are willing to be an ACET-link in their church. 
 An ACET-link person, possibly an existing volunteer, would keep their church informed about our work and encourage people to consider becoming volunteers, help with fundraising ideas and circulate newsletters. 
 An ACET-link will play a vital role as our work is growing so rapidly. 
 If you would like to know more about being an ACET-link, please contact Chris Catlin/Peter Glover on 081 840 7879 or write to ACET, PO Box 1323, LONDON W5 5TF. 
 Peter Johnson UK Director  
 Tear Fund Support Ugandan Work 
 Anthony Kasozi's work as ACET's Director in uganda has recently received financial support form Tear Fund which has enabled him, together with ACET General Manager, Maurice Adams, to identify a number of church-based projects for the coming year. 
 These include: pedal cycles for a clinic allowing nurses to get out to outlying villages; health care kits to help with the care of patients in their own homes; training for different agencies; and a variety of education initiatives. 
 Returning from a visit to Uganda, where he met with patients in the villages and with other agencies, Maurice Adams said, &bquo;It is a beautiful country which is being devastated by a disease which can be stopped.&equo; 
 &bquo;The population in general is very well educated about AIDS,&equo; says Anthony Kasozi, &bquo;thanks to the commitment of the Ugandan Government who have done well in raising awareness. 
 The need here is to convince people that they must change their behaviour. 
 We are seeking to find out what local people want, because they must own the work themselves. 
 In this way, with a little money but much commitment, a great deal can be done.&equo;  
 HIV Community Nurse, Sue Lore, takes an education class with the help of patron, Cliff Patron. 
 Living with AIDS by John Creedy 
 You can be perfectly well with HIV and at other times chronic debility makes it hard to do even the basic things. 
 In the early days the stigma of being HIV positive had driven away about 60&percnt; of my circle of friends. 
 Despite the publicity giving the facts surrounding the transmission of the disease, ignorance was such that they became afraid of normal social contact. 
 It soon became clear that I could no longer rely on friends for help with everyday chores like shopping and housework when I needed it. 
 While deciding to stay as independent as possible, I contacted ACET who I knew provided practical care at home. 
 I had previously spent about two years asking local social services and friends for help and not having it happen, so my flat had become pretty run down. 
 There was also the question of my own exhaustion. 
 Even a weekly visit by a local authority home help &mdash; when it was finally arranged &mdash; was not enough. 
 Help provided by ACET volunteers eventually go the flat ship-shape again and life became easier. 
 Illnesses, including chronic muscle debility, herpes, tremors and eye infections, have come and gone. 
 Recently I have experienced serious and potentially fatal fevers. 
 Basically every day is an effort, that's the reality, and there's a great tendency to want life to be as it was. 
 I have far fewer friends and I am partially sighted, which makes me a lot more vulnerable; but whatever happens physically, I have always said that it was what happened mentally that mattered. 
 Being aware of the stress and pressure that many people and their families experience when AIDS or HIV is first diagnosed, I became involved in counselling. 
 I have also campaigned for the Government to give AIDS greater recognition, not as a disease affecting specific sectors of the community, but as a social problem for which there must  be adequate welfare provision. 
 Organisations like ACET need this support to enable people like myself to retain maximum control and continue to live at home as independently as we can. 
 I have in recent years edited a self-help journal for people with AIDS, written for the national press and researched a variety of medical material for television. 
 Without the help of ACET and other direct service organisations and charities, I would not have been able to continue and maintain my independence. 
 By working co-operatively, long-term, with the people around me, I hope to continue for some time yet. 
 On Air 
 Director, Dr Patrick Dixon, was involved in numerous radio broadcasts during June, in addition to his appearance on BBC Newsroom South East's magazine programme as part of our third birthday celebrations. 
 Pre-recorded broadcasts were made by BBC Radio News for Radio 4's &bquo;World at One&equo; and by Independent Radio News (IRN) for broadcast during the week of the 7th International Conference on AIDS in Florence. 
 Just before leaving to attend the Conference itself, Patrick fitted in a live broadcast on Radio 4's &bquo;Today Programme&equo;. 
 During the week the BBC took the opportunity to broadcast part of another pre-recorded interview on Radio 4's &bquo;File on 4&equo;, while Capital Radio broadcast a four-part feature on AIDS, again including a &bquo;canned&equo; interview with Patrick. 
 Two BBC World Service broadcasts at the end of the week with Patrick giving his assessment of the Conference. 
 Patrick's attendance at the Florence Conference was sponsored by the pharmaceutical firm, NAPP. 
 Changes 
 Congratulations to Brian Harris, former Manager of the Education Department, on his new appointment as Manager of a housing project for the Shaftesbury Society in Kilburn. 
 Brian was one of the very first members of the ACET team and will be greatly missed. 
 Denise Jones, responsible for grants and equipment loans, left at the end June to develop her own business, the Belgrave Beauty Clinic in Chiswick, West London. 
 Maurice Adams, formerly Deputy Director with responsibility for new developments in the UK and overseas, is now General Manager of Acet with responsibility for all ACET operations. 
 Rev J Powrie, 22 years Minister of Chalmers &mdash; Ardler Parish Church, Church of Scotland, has recently been appointed as member of ACET's Advisory Council.  
 Volunteer Needed 
 The need for volunteers from churches, particularly in London and Scotland in the day-time, is an ever constant one. 
 Volunteer Manager, Chris Catlin, says, &bquo;We have traditionally recruited volunteers from across the denominations including Anglican, Methodist, Baptist, Catholic and House Churches. 
 After spending some time, often years, with us, people move on to other things and we need to fill the gaps.&equo; 
 All volunteers are trained in a programme designed to: &mdash; give a broad knowledge of HIV and AIDS &mdash; equip an individual on an emotional and practical level to enable them to give compassionate and unconditional care &mdash; equip them to give practical support 
 The training programme itself covers key subjects including: &mdash; death and dying &mdash; sex and sexuality &mdash; responses and reactions &mdash; medical facts &mdash; grief and loss 
 In London, volunteer training programmes will now take place every September and February and will require an individual's time for one evening a week over a six-week programme. 
 Programmes for the four London areas will take place as follows; &mdash; South West Thames &mdash; 9th September North West Thames &mdash; 25th September North East Thames &mdash; 2nd October South East Thames &mdash; Date to be fixed during September/early October All enquiries should be directed to Chris Catlin on 081 840 7879. 
 Romania 
 Maurice Adams, ACET General Manager, and Overseas Development Worker, Kate Bristow, have recently returned from Romania. 
 Kate has been overseeing an AIDS education course in Constanta together with a local representative, Ana Ureche. 
 A similar course held at the beginning of the year in Brasov, attended by sixty people including teachers, nurses and doctors, was particularly encouraging as much of the material was, in turn, passed on to other colleagues for their use. 
 The success of the initial pilot programme has been recognised by the Ministry of Health and the Institute of Health Education and led to Maurice, Kate and Ana meeting with Government officials and representatives from UNICEF to establish a long-term training programme in five Romanian regions, starting in November of this year. 
 The attitude of many Romanian health professionals was summed up recently in the words of one doctor in Constanta who said &bquo;Health Education is the only &bquo;vaccine&equo; we have to fight against HIV.&equo; 
 Kate Bristow commented, &bquo;It is a real privilege for ACET to be asked to work with such people as they look for ways to develop an effective strategy.&equo; 
 International Adviser 
 Professor Jonathan Mann, former director of the WHO Global AIDS Programme, has given his backing to ACET by joining Dr Everett Koop the former US Surgeon General, as an International Adviser. 
 Speaking recently at the 7th International AIDS Conference in Florence he said: 
 &bquo;I am delighted to support ACET's developing international AIDS programme. 
 Ten years after the discovery of AIDS we are entering into a new era in the global pandemic, with growing concern about our ability to confront it successfully. 
 New approaches are needed, with close partnerships between local communities, non-government agencies, governments and international organisations. 
 I believe ACET has an important part to play in this process.&equo; 
 He added, &bquo;We are just at the beginning of the worldwide epidemic and the situation is still very unstable. 
 The major impact is yet to come. 
 Over the next decade a global approach is going to be essential.&equo;  
 Superintendent Trobridge of Ealing Police Station hands a cheque for &pound;400 to Karen Russell, ACET Trust Manager. 
 The money was part of the proceeds from the sale of unclaimed property sold under the Police Property Act. 
 ACET NEWS AIDS CARE EDUCATION &amp; TRAINING 
 ACET IN THE COMMUNITY 
 Issue 1 
 AIDS In London Changing Fast 
 MAJOR CHANGES in the pattern of HIV disease occurring in the capital which are not obvious from published statistics. 
 The biggest changes are in the length of time people ill with the disease are now surviving and in the nature of the illnesses themselves. 
 Between 1984 and 1986 those with AIDS died on average some ten months after diagnosis. 
 Between 1987 and 1989, however, the survival period has already doubled to twenty moths. 
 Patients diagnosed more recently are probably surviving an average of longer than two years. 
 Cause of death 
 The &bquo;cause of death&equo; figures are also changing beyond all recognition. 
 The classical pneumocystis pneumonia used to be the final event in the disease process in almost half (46&percnt;) of those with AIDS in 1986. 
 While pneumonia is still a common occurrence, current preventative measures and improved treatment have reduced the numbers dying as a result to only 3&percnt; by 1989. 
 This change has big implications for health planners and for those caring for people with AIDS. 
 With the pneumonias, the interval between early chest infection and death could be as little as 12 hours in someone outwardly fit and well. 
 Planning was often difficult or impossible and the need for home care was less. 
 The commonest cause of death is now advanced Kaposi's Sarcoma (a kind of cancer). 
 Slowly growing internal lesions can produce great difficulties in the lung and the gut, causing shortness of breath and other problems. 
 Internal Kaposi's Sarcoma can be very painful. 
 Surviving longer 
 Over a year or two, therefore, we have shifted from a population of recently diagnosed AIDS patients, often reasonably well but with lives dominated by a threat of pneumonia, to a population surviving longer and developing a range of further complex problems of a chronic debilitating nature. 
 As London's largest independent provider of community care for people ill with AIDS, staff at ACET have seen these changes unfold in the home. 
 While numbers of new AIDS cases reported officially each month have remained relatively steady, there has been a big increase in those needing expert medical and nursing advice at home with a 24-hour on call back up. 
 The numbers with pain are also higher. 
 Those at home often need opiates (morphine-like medicines) for pain, while one in five will also need a special battery-operated syringe pump, especially if they are too weak to swallow. 
 Specialist care 
 The picture then has changed and we now need to plan for increasing numbers of those with chronic illnesses needing specialist community care &mdash; not just volunteers, although volunteers continue to have a vitally important role to play. 
 Until the numbers of deaths each month has risen to equal or exceed the number of new diagnoses, the numbers needing care will continue to rise fast, even if the number of new cases reported in official figures is relatively constant or falling. 
 These factors help explain some of the reasons why the total number of ACET clients covered at any one time by our on call service in London has more than doubled from 70 in April 1990 to over 150 by March 1991; and why the nature of the services required has become so much more sophisticated. 
 Professionally-based community care is here to stay and is increasingly needed, backed by access to respite and long stay hospice beds and acute ward facilities. 
 Forward planning and good communication are the two foundation stones that must be in place to guarantee that people ill with HIV have the best choices and continue to enjoy the very best quality of life, wherever they choose to be.  
 &bquo;Members of the London Home Care Team from i. to r. &mdash; Kay Hopps, Archie Ferguson, Cedria Clifton, Jackie Sears (Team Manager), Sue Lore and Janet Sutton.&equo; 
 NOTICE BOARD 
 Three ACET staff members, Peter Fabian, Director of Resource Development, Sue Lore, a specialist HIV community nurse and Peter Glover, Press and Information Officer, featured on Radio Thamesmead, North Kent, in an hour-long chat show in April, speaking on AIDS and AIDS care in the community. 
 ACET's Scottish Office was also featured on &bquo;Songs of Praise&equo; on BBC1. 
 Care-link units, designed to provide remote signalling of distress via the telephone systems, are currently on loan with seven clients in London. 
 Designed originally with the needs of the elderly in mind, those ill with HIV/AIDS at home are also finding them enormously valuable. 
 Help can be summoned from ACET or other services merely by pressing a button on a pendant worn around the neck. 
 This can make all the difference to someone who feels unsafe alone at home or to partners or friends. 
 Referrals to ACET for Home Care in the London area have increased in the last six months by 50&percnt;. 
 At the present rate of referral, numbers are more than set to double during the year. 
 Around 85&percnt; of those cared for in the capital are gay men, with an increasing number of women and children. 
 Referrals of African men and women infected heterosexually abroad are also increasing. 
 ACET News aims to &mdash; inform Boroughs, Health Authorities, and voluntary agencies of the work of ACET in the community. 
 For more information about ACET's Home Care Service please call us on 081 840 7879 and ask for Jackie Sears. 
 UK OPERATIONS DIRECTOR APPOINTED 
 Peter Johnson, 38, has been appointed UK Operations Director, with responsibility for ACET's existing operations and for new developments within the UK. 
 The rapid growth of ACET since its inception in 1988 has made the creation of this new post a priority. 
 &bquo;I was impressed by the care given to our clients in London and elsewhere,&equo; explained Peter, &bquo;and the lengths to which ACET staff go to try and meet the needs of clients. 
 I feel that working in partnership with the client, and with other agencies, is the most effective way of ensuring the needs of our clients are met.&equo; 
 Peter studied astronomy at University College, London, and worked in accountancy for a short spell before deciding upon a career in nursing. 
 He spent three years at Charing Cross Hospital School of Nursing before qualifying as a Registered General Nurse in 1983. 
 Work on a medical ward and as a health visitor followed until in 1988 he became a Neighbourhood Nurse Manager for Wandsworth Health Authority. 
 &bquo;I basically managed district nurses, health visitors, school and family planning nurses,&equo; he said.  
 Kay, an ACET nurse, visits a client to administer Petamadine to help prevent him developing pneumocystis corinii pneumonia (PCP). 
 CHILDREN WITH HIV 
 The plight of children infected with HIV was recently highlighted by Princess Diana when she presented a report by the National Children's Bureau to a London conference on the impact of AIDS on family life. 
 ACET already has experience in caring for children ill with the disease, particularly through its Scottish office. 
 In the experience of ACET staff and volunteers, practical care in the home not only benefits the HIV infected individual but the whole family, which can often mean three generations. 
 At least 60&percnt;of the individuals being cared for by ACET in Tayside also have children themselves. 
 Some of these children are infected, but those who are not are still affected by HIV. 
 ACET believes that specialist and volunteer home care is a vital factor in helping to keep families together and lessening the trauma involved when family members are diagnosed HIV positive. 
 PORTSMOUTH OFFICE 
 Portsmouth and South East Hampshire Area Health Authority has recently purchased a building in Portsmouth for the use of AIDS agencies covering the South East Hampshire area. 
 ACET Home Care, which moves into the building in July, will share the offices with two other AIDS charities, P.A.L.S. 
 (Portsmouth AIDS Link Support) and the Link Project. 
 The Health Authority has provided funding for the running of ACET's office including volunteer co-ordinator, Anne Hutchins. 
 Hampshire County Council has provided &pound;20,000 to furnish the building. 
 P.A.L.S. 
 provides counselling and general family support, the Link Project deals with drug-related problems and gives general advice, while ACET provides practical home care not only to the Portsmouth area but also along the South Coast. 
 Living with AIDS by John Creedy 
 TWO AND A HALF years ago I was diagnosed as being HIV positive. 
 It was no particular shock when I found out; I had expected the test to be positive. 
 I was a very happy gay man. 
 There was clearly a need to adapt my lifestyle, but playing the role of victim was never among my plans. 
 You can be perfectly well with HIV and at other times chronic debility makes it hard to do even the basic things. 
 In the early days the stigma of being HIV positive had driven away about 60&percnt; of my circle of friends. 
 Despite the publicity giving the facts surrounding the transmission of the disease, ignorance was such that they became afraid of normal social interaction. 
 It soon became clear that I could no longer rely on friends for help with everyday chores like shopping and housework when I needed it. 
 Whilst resolving to stay at independent as possible, I contacted ACET who I knew provided practical care at home. 
 I had previously spent about two years asking local social services and friends for help and not having it happen, so my flat had become pretty run down. 
 There was also the question of my own exhaustion. 
 Even a weekly visit by a local authority home help when it was finally arranged was not enough. 
 Help provided by an ACET volunteer eventually got the flat ship-shape again and life became easier. 
 Illnesses, including chronic muscle debility, herpes, tremors and eye infections, have come and gone. 
 Recently I have experienced series and potentially fatal fevers. 
 Basically every day is an effort, that's the reality, and there's a great tendency to want life to be as it was. 
 I have far few friends and I am partially sighted, which makes me a lot more vulnerable; but whatever happens physically, I have always said that it was what happened mentally that mattered. 
 Being aware of the stress and pressures that many people and their families experience with AIDS or HIV is first diagnoses, I became involved in counselling. 
 I have also campaigned for the Government to give AIDS greater recognition, not as a disease affecting specific sectors of the community, but as a social problem for which there must be adequate welfare provision. 
 Organisations like ACET need this kind of support to enable people like myself to retain maximum control and continue to live at home. 
 I have in recent years edited a self-help journal for people with AIDS, written for the national press and researched a variety of medical material for television. 
 Without the help of ACET and other similar organisations I would not have been able to continue and maintain my independence. 
 By working co-operatively, longterm, with the people around me, I hope to continue for some time yet. 
 NOTICE BOARD 
 Maurice Adams, General Manager of ACET, has recently returned form Uganda where he has been discussing planning for future projects with ACET's African Director, Anthony Kasozi. 
 Next year's work has been partly funded by the charity TEAR Fund. 
 Following the running of an AIDS educational course for 60 people including doctors, nurses and teachers in Brasov, Romania, earlier this year, a follow-up day was held in April. 
 ACET's local representative, Ana Ureche, reported that she was &bquo;greatly encouraged&equo; that course participants had been lecturing to schools and other groups and had passed much of the literature obtained form the course to other colleagues for their use. 
 Alison Maunsell, ACET's East Midlands regional co-ordinator based in Northampton, has been invited to join H.I.V. T.E.S.P.I. (Training, Education, Support &amp; Public Initiative), a forum run by the local health authority. 
 Alison will represent ACET and the interests of clients. 
 ACET's London Home Care team will shortly be strengthened by the arrival of a new nurse, Catherine Murphy, to help manage the increasing number of referrals. 
 Catherine qualified in general nursing at Dr Steeven's Hospital, Dublin. 
 Midwifery training at Epsom &amp; Surrey followed and she has recently completed a course in tropical nursing at the London Hospital for Tropical Diseases. 
 Catherine, who is on a three-month contract with ACET, is looking forward to caring for people with HIV/AIDS. 
 Letters to the Editor Letters would be welcome. 
 Any contributions may be edited. 
 Please write to: THE EDITOR, ACET NEWS, P.O. 
 BOX 1323, LONDON, W5 5TF. 
 Area Profile EALING 
 IN JANUARY 1988 a small group of 50 would-be volunteers met in the Ealing YMCA to learn about AIDS. 
 This was the beginning of ACET. 
 Many of the first group completed a training course to provide practical help in the home for a small number of people ill with HIV/AIDS. 
 The first referrals came from Ealing, Acton and surrounding areas. 
 This was coordinated from the living room of a local doctor. 
 The remit of this fledgling group was to provide the highest standards of unconditional care to men, women and children ill at home with HIV/AIDS. 
 Within a short space of time referrals were regularly coming in. 
 In June 1988 ACET was officially launched as a registered charity. 
 Over the next six months this small group of professionals and volunteers provided practical care for 15 people living in or around the Borough of Ealing. 
 To date ACET has provided professional nursing care or practical help to over 400 individuals across London, excluding  hardship grants and equipment loans. 
 In Ealing alone we have received over 30 referrals for Home Care. 
 It has always been ACET's policy to work with and complement statutory and other voluntary organizations. 
 In Ealing, social workers, H.E.A.R.S (Hounslow &amp; Ealing AIDS Response Service) and the Ealing Home Support team have made referrals to ACET to provide for needs where a single agency cannot give all of the support required. 
 Likewise ACET has also involved other agencies on behalf of the client. 
 Both the Borough and Health Authority have supported the work of ACET in Ealing by being among the first to provide financial support. 
 ACET is currently working with the Health Authority to develop a service level agreement for 1991/92. 
 A Day in the Life of an ACET Volunteer 
 Monday 8.55am  &mdash; I arrive at the office for what looks like a quiet day catching up on necessary office work and telephoning some of our low-dependency clients to see how they are. 
 There's a message on the answerphone from Tony's brother. 
 Tony has been unwell over the weekend. 
 One of the nurses rings back, discusses the situation and says she will ring the hospital and/or his GP to see what can be done. 
 I am asked if I can be on standby if transport is needed? 
 9.32am  &mdash; Diary check &mdash; a general discussion of appointments and availability for the week follow with Janet, our Co-ordinator. 
 This includes nurses and volunteers. 
 At the moment it looks like my usual stint of ironing on Thursday and shopping on Friday are the main fixtures, but anything can happen before then. 
 10.10am  &mdash; Still no decision about Tony. 
 We are now waiting for the specialist to phone back. 
 Meanwhile, another cry for help. 
 Westminster Hospital, say that Andrew, on of their patients, needs to be admitted but they are unable to find transport as no ambulance is available. 
 No other organisation can help. 
 We agree to help and perhaps I can combine the two visits. 
 11.00am  &mdash; Tony has been given an appointment at the local hospital. 
 I will be able to take him and continue into London to pick up Andrew. 
 At least I'll be able to have lunch first and not be munching my sandwich in a traffic jam. 
 1.04pm  &mdash; Tony, and his Mum, are still getting ready to arrive. 
 He is not at all well, very breathless, and by the time we are in the care he is gasping for air. 
 1.05pm  &mdash; Having left Tony and his Mum at his appointment, I set off in the direction of the A4. 
 2.30pm  &mdash; I arrive at Andrew's house. 
 Although he is suffering from a type of septicaemia, he is clearly having a good spell. 
 We make the most of this and scoot off to the hospital. 
 3.35pm  &mdash; Arrive back at hospital no.1. 
 Tony is to be admitted but&hellip; wait for it&hellip; to yet another hospital! 
 If I can't take him he will have a two-hour wait for an ambulance. 
 I've heard of a pub crawl&hellip; but a hospital crawl? 
 4.00pm  &mdash; We set off again; this time via Tony's home to collect a variety of possessions, finally arriving at hospital no.3. 
 4.55pm  &mdash; Tony is ushered into a side ward with three doctors and I stay outside with Mum. 
 The only problem is, she is Ugandan and speaks very little English, has no idea how to get home and has no money for transport. 
 I try to explain that, unlike her home country, she will not be staying in with him. 
 Nobody seems to have explained this to her, but finally she understands. 
 Her daughters have however been contacted so I agree to keep her company until they arrive. 
 5.45pm  &mdash; They finally turn up. 
 As the doctors are still with Tony, I explain the position to the daughters and hand Mum over to them. 
 6.30pm  &mdash; Home at last! 
 Of course, I still need to catch up on that necessary office work, maybe tomorrow&hellip;  
 Cedria is a full-time volunteer and one of national network of volunteers. 
 Both full- and part-time work is carefully organised according to the availability and skills of each volunteer. 
 All volunteers are carefully selected and trained. 
 What is ACET? 
 ACET is a national and international AIDS charity with the following objectives: 
 To develop appropriate local responses to the global problem to HIV/AIDS 
 To provide professionally-based practical home care to men, women and children at home with HIV/AIDS related illnesses. 
 To enable people who are ill with HIV/AIDS to live and die at home, if that is their wish, and appropriate to their needs. 
 To reduce the number of new HIV infections by giving young people the facts about AIDS. 
 AIDS Care Education and Training is a company limited by guarantee. 
 Reg. 
 No. 2245302 and a registered charity No. 299293. 
 Registered Office 318 St Paul's Road, Duke Street, London N1 2LP. 
 HIV IT'S YOUR CHOICE 
 Every day the virus causing AIDS is infecting more young people. 
 A friend can infect you without your knowing.  
 No cure for AIDS 
 Once you're infected the virus may destroy your natural defences for over 10 years without you realising. 
 And you an pass on the infection again without knowing. 
 There is no cure. 
 Once infected, you will &mdash; sooner or later &mdash; develop fullblown AIDS. 
 Friends or partners may soon be ill too.  
 The truth about AIDS 
 THE DOCTOR SAYS: &bquo;HIV IS THE VIRUS THAT CAUSES AIDS.&equo; 
 HIV spreads between people who have sexual intercourse together, or who share needles when injecting drugs, or from mother to unborn child. 
 The most common way for the virus to spread is through unprotected sexual intercourse between two people, one of whom is infected. 
 You can be tested for infection at a special hospital clinic. 
 But remember you have to wait at least 12 weeks after the possible infection for the test result to be accurate. 
 THERE IS STILL NO CURE, NO VACCINE, NO WONDER DRUG, FOR HIV INFECTION OR AIDS.  
 SAFE! 
 YOU CAN'T CATCH HIV IN ANY OF THESE WAYS: 
 from a toilet 
 from mosquito bites 
 from giving blood 
 from a swimming pool 
 from kissing 
 from day-to-day contact 
 It's very safe receiving blood transfusions. 
 The chance of getting infected from a pint of blood is less than 1 in a million.  
 What is AIDS? 
 Risky sex or dirty needles send HIV into the blood. 
 The virus, HIV, enters a &bquo;soldier&equo; cell. 
 The soldier cell is programmed to make up 1000s of new HIV particles. 
 Then it bursts, dies, and releases all these viruses into the blood. 
 Over the next 5&ndash;15 years, 1000s more soldier cells in the body get infected. 
 They make millions of viruses, before they too die off. 
 A new germ enters the body. 
 Now there aren't enough &bquo;soldier&equo; cells to beat the germ, so it multiplies. 
 The body is seriously infected. 
 Hospital treatment is needed. 
 Some die of the infection. 
 Most recover gradually. 
 Until the next germ arrives&hellip; 
 Sex and AIDS 
 &bquo;I've been to fifteen funerals of my friends this year. 
 They all died through AIDS. 
 Now it's my turn.&equo; 
 J.L., London 
 Tom is a lorry-driver. 
 He's infected with the virus causing AIDS, but doesn't know. 
 (He could have been infected by 1 of at least 3 different ways. 
 What are they? *)  
 * Answer:  a.  
 He could be infected by sexual intercourse with an infected woman. 
 b.  
 He could be infected by injecting drugs using a shared needle and syringe. c.  
 He could be infected by sex with a man or boy. 
 Tom has in turn infected Mary and Sam &mdash; he's bisexual. 
 Still not knowing he's infected, Tom marries Janet. 
 A year later, she's infected too. 
 One day Tom is rushed to hospital with an unusual type of pneumonia. 
 Now the doctor tell shim he has AIDS. 
 Tom has infected at least 6 people &mdash; thought he has never even met Jane, Mark and Alan. 
 Over a period of time they will all be ill.    
 When sex can cause disease 
 Rapid spread 
 Until recently it was reckoned that men and women on average had sex with 6 different people in their lifetime. 
 And those 6 partners with 36 more&hellip; 
 So one person could receive sexually-transmitted diseases (STDs) from up to 40,000 other people! 
 &bquo;But I've only had sex with one person,&equo; you say. 
 It only needs one  person to pass on an infection. 
 Sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) 
 Each year in the UK hospital that more than 500,000 new cases of STDs. 
 These include gonorrhoea, syphilis, herpes, genital warts, chlamydia, and now, HIV infection. 
 Some of these diseases are becoming more and more resistant to treatment. 
 For most of them there is a cure; but as yet not for HIV infection. 
 Sexually transmitted diseases can prevent women from conceiving children. 
 It's possible that a sexually-transmitted infection might cause cancer of the cervix &mdash; especially if you're under 20. 
 Tell-tale signs 
 Soreness in the groin, or a discharge from the genitals, can be a sign of some sexually transmitted diseases. 
 But often the person infected doesn't notice anything wrong. 
 What to do 
 If you're worried that you've recently take a risk, go to the special STD clinic at your local hospital. 
 They will check you, and treat you if necessary. 
 They're used to these diseases. 
 Don't hesitate to go.  
 Two experts discuss HIV in front of hugely-magnified projection of soldier cells. 
 Those coloured red are infected. 
 Sex: It's your choice 
 SAFE 
 Close relationships that stop short of sexual intercourse. 
 Staying a virgin till you meet the right person &mdash; also a virgin &mdash; and&hellip; staying faithful to that one person for the rest of your life. 
 Also, neither of you ever injecting drugs. 
 LOW RISK 
 Sex with a condom that contains nonoxynol spermicide. 
 HIGHER RISK 
 Sex without a condom. 
 (How can you be sure your partner isn't infected?) 
 VERY HIGH RISK 
 Injecting drugs with a shared needle and syringe. (20 people can get infected in a single evening this way.) 
 Why do people get into drugs? 
 &bquo;It looks cool&hellip;&equo; 
 There's a party. 
 Stuff is getting passed round. 
 It can seem hard to say &bquo;No&equo;! 
 Particularly if you're not feeling confident. 
 &bquo;I'm curious&hellip;&equo; 
 People climb mountains &bquo;because they're there&equo;. 
 They make parachute drops &bquo;to see what it's like&equo;. 
 Why not drugs? 
 Because  shooting your brain to bits isn't worth it! 
 &bquo;I'm looking for meaning to life&hellip;&equo; 
 Some people think drugs can help you find God, or discover the meaning of life. 
 OK &mdash; when you're in a dazed state, drugs may make you think  you understand it all. 
 But  some drugs cause bad, disturbing flashbacks. 
 &bquo;I can't cope with life&hellip;&equo; 
 Many people who use drugs regularly find it difficult to exist in a drug-free world. 
 They can become crippled psychologically and hooked physically. 
 Even after &bquo;drying out&equo;, they may feel strongly pulled back into the drug world. 
 Drugs often make people feel  they're coping, when they're really not coping at all. 
 Trading Death 
 A big problem 
 Drugs are never cheap. 
 The effects never last long and you always want more. 
 A paper round or weekend job doesn't pay enough. 
 Stealing, cheating and lying become the only way to pay. 
 It's always on your mind 
 You can't look your family in the eye. 
 Your friends begin to wonder what is wrong. 
 You begin to hate yourself for what you're doing. 
 Things are always on your mind. 
 Trying to feel better by using more never seems to work for long. 
 Drugs and AIDS 
 Drugs damage your body. 
 They can kill, and injecting drugs with a shared needle or syringe can be the fastest way to get HIV &mdash; even if you only do it once. 
 Why you should say &bquo;NO&equo; to drugs! 
 Once you've taken the drug, your next decision could be influenced by  that drug. 
 It could ruin your entire life. 
 Some drugs can hook you almost instantly. 
 If you say YES &mdash; that could be your last free decision. 
 Drugs are no substitute for real living. 
 They can't give you a purpose or meaning in life. 
 No-one has the right to pressure you. 
 You're always free to say NO!   
 &bquo;I think I'm in love&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;How do I know if I've met the right person?&equo; 
 Most experts say that the happiest &mdash; and longest &mdash; relationships are based on close friendship and shared interests, not just strong feelings. 
 It take s lot more than just physical attraction to make a lasting, happy marriage.  
 Strong friendship takes time to build. 
 Many people say that sex is most fulfilling when it expresses the commitment, care, security and understanding of an exclusive friendship. 
 Friendship takes time. 
 In most happy marriages, husband and wife continue to make time to be with each other, and to understand each other.  
 How does AIDS affect you? 
 We say someone has AIDS when the virus has weakened the body so much that certain new illnesses are developing. 
 For example, if the &bquo;soldier&equo; cells are weakened, the chest can be infected. 
 It gets harder to breathe &mdash; and you may die. 
 Your gut can get infected, so you can't absorb the goodness in your food. 
 You lose weight, you feel very weak, and pass motions up to 10 times a day.  
 This person with the HIV infection has developed a sore mouth 
 Cancers may grow. 
 For example, there is a skin cancer called Kaposi's sarcoma. 
 If you have AIDS, a germ can destroy your eyesight. 
 You can also find it hard to remember things, because germs are multiplying in your brain. 
 People with AIDS are often well for long periods between times of illness.  
 A woman receiving urgent hospital treatment for AIDS. 
 How to keep healthy 
 Never share a needle or syringe if you're injecting drugs. 
 Always use a condom (unless you're absolutely sure your partner is not infected) *.  This reduces the risk of infection &mdash; it doesn't eliminate it. 
 Reduce the number of partners you have sex with. 
 Aim at having only 1 sexual partner for the rest of your life 
 If you would like to take to someone about matters covered in this booklet, there is a free and confidential service: National AIDS HELPLINE: Freephone 0800 567 123 
 * How can you be sure? 
 See page 12.  
 Text&copy; Patrick Dixon 1990 Design&copy; Three's Company 
 First published 1990 by ACET P.O. 
 Box 1323 London W5 5TF ISBN 0 95 16386 0 2 
 All rights reserved. 
 No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted, in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission in writing of the publisher. 
 Photographs by ZEFA UK Illustrations by Kate Taylor Designer P Wyart 
 Created by Three's Company 12 Flitcroft Street, London WC2 Produced by Angus Hudson Ltd, Mill Hill, London Typeset by Watermark, Cromer Printed in Great Britain  
 The cost of this booklet has been met by World in Need. 
 AIDS a caring response  ACET 
 THE CHALLENGE 
 The chronic nature of AIDS means that people's needs are many and varied. 
 For many a stay in hospital is in appropriate but they are often too weak or ill to care for themselves properly. 
 For some this makes hospitalization inevitable. 
 When someone is ill with AIDS they are often in pain. 
 Exhaustion is a permanent feature preventing the completion of even the most simple task. 
 Friends and family often reject them, leaving them free to face this chronic condition alone. 
 Without ACET's practical support at home they could spend long periods of time in hospital unnecessarily. 
 The reality of AIDS is that the person can die at any time. 
 The person's need to know &bquo;when and how&equo; is sometimes overwhelming. 
 One of the difficulties is that every person's situation is different. 
 The medical aspects can be dementia, sudden blindness, loss of mobility, thrush, shingles, Kaposi's sarcoma (a type of cancer), weight loss, or any combination of these. 
 The person's circumstances may change rapidly, from owner occupier to homelessness; from a good income to living on sickness benefit; from young and active to housebound and disabled. 
 ACET'S HOME CARE SERVICE 
 ACET provides a dedicated Home Care service using a team of doctors and nurses backed by a trained and active network of over 400 volunteers. 
 The service includes pain and symptom control and nursing advice. 
 Volunteers cook, clean, nightsit and carry out DIY and many other tasks. 
 Our aim is to enable people to live and to die at home if that is their wish and appropriate to their needs. 
 The stigma still associated with AIDS means that often those who have the disease are isolated. 
 ACET can't replace family and friends but can provide the practical care and support to enable people with HIV/AIDS related illnesses to stay at home. 
 EDUCATION 
 ACET through its schools education programme aims to reduce the number of new infections by giving young people the facts about AIDS. 
 We have already visited over 90 schools and reached 36,000 pupils. 
 OVERSEAS 
 ACET has already been drawn overseas and is working in Romania, Uganda and Tanzania, in partnership with local church-based projects and in conjunction with government programmes. 
 Our assistance is offered sensitively and in a culturally appropriate way. 
 THE FUTURE 
 In the UK we have offices in London, Portsmouth, Northampton, Belfast, Dundee and Edinburgh. 
 If we are to continue providing unconditional practical care on such a wide level then we need your support today. 
 It costs about &pound;2,000 to care for someone between referral to ACET and their death. 
 This works out at the equivalent of just &pound;10 per day. 
 All our programmes need your continued support. 
 Despite the fact that we don't hear so much about AIDS these days the problems are increasing. 
 If you would like to support the work of ACET then please complete the coupon and return it to us today. 
 Thank you. 
 AIDS  a caring response  
 ACET &mdash; AIDS Care Education and Training is a national and international church-based charity with offices in the UK, Romania and Uganda. 
 The charity was launched in June 1988 by Dr Patrick Dixon, a specialist in care for the dying and author or two books on the subject of AIDS. 
 Initial sponsorship was provided by World in Need, a charity which also helped launch Action Aid and Help the Aged. 
 ACET is committed to the unconditional care of all those who are ill with HIV/AIDS regardless of race, religion, lifestyle, sex, sexuality or any other factor. 
 We provide professionally based practical home care to men, women and children who are ill at home with HIV/AIDS related illness. 
 Since launching our UK service we have received over 1,200 requests for practical help. 
 This makes us the largest independent provider of practical home care to people with AIDS in the UK. 
 DONATION 
 Yes, I would like to make ACET's Home Care service and Education Programmes more widely available and enclose a donation of:  
 COVENANT 
 COVENANT 
 COVENANT GIVING TO ACET? 
 This leaflet tries to answer some of the questions you might have on giving to ACET by covenant. 
 Is a covenant the only method of tax-effective giving? 
 No. 
 Since 1987 it has been possible to ask your employer to deduct regular sums from your pay through the PAYROLL GIVING SCHEME up to a maximum of &pound;600 per annum (not all employers offer their employees this facility). 
 From lst October 1990, there is also a new scheme called GIFT AID which allows you to give sums of &pound;600 or more to a charity tax-effectively (with a maximum of &pound;5 million for your total charitable donations in any one tax year). 
 A separate leaflet gives details of that scheme. 
 Is a covenant complicated? 
 Not really. 
 A Deed of Covenant is a legal document which needs to be correctly drawn up and signed. 
 The law relating to covenants is quite complex but basically a covenant is a legally-binding document by which you transfer some of your income to a charity for a stated period. 
 ACET is a charity, registered with the Charity Commission under Registration Number 299293. 
 As far as you are concerned, a covenant can be exceedingly simple. 
 There is a simple covenant form attached to this leaflet which is quite sufficient. 
 All you have to do is to fill in the details, including your name and address and the amount you wish to give, and sign and date the document in front of a witness. 
 You will also be asked to sign a Certificate of Deduction of Tax once a year confirming that you are a UK taxpayer. 
 This is all you need do for the tax benefit of covenant giving to work. 
 The value of your gift then increases by 33.3&percnt; in ACET's hands, with the blessing of the Inland Revenue. 
 How long does a covenant have to last? 
 At the time you enter a Deed of Covenant, the covenant should be capable of lasting for more than 3 years , and there should be the intention by you that it does so. 
 This is why the normal period for a charitable covenant is 4 years. 
 But it is possible to have a covenant which lasts for a longer period, provided that the period is specified in the Deed.  
 Do I need to go to a lawyer? 
 No. 
 It does not need a lawyer either to draw up any document or to advise you although you may wish to consult a professional adviser if a particularly large sum is involved or if there are complicated conditions surrounding the gift. 
 How should I make my payments? 
 You can pay by cash or by cheque. 
 If you pay by cash you will normally obtain a receipt as proof of payment. 
 If you use the covenant form attached to this leaflet you can make each annual payment at any time, or by any instalments, you wish as long as you make the full annual payment by the end of each 12-month period. 
 Since you are agreeing to make regular payments over a number of years, it is probably easier for you to pay by Banker's Order or Direct Debit Mandate when the payments will automatically be made from your bank account. 
 There is a Banker's Order form attached to this leaflet which you can use. 
 Make sure that the amount of the payment is the net sum mentioned in the Deed of Covenant or the appropriate proportion of that net sum if you wish to pay by quarterly or monthly instalments. 
 Also make sure that the Banker's Order terminates with the final covenant payment. 
 Can I increase my covenant payment? 
 The simple answer is No. 
 The amount of the annual covenant payment is specified in the Deed, and this is the sum that is payable each year. 
 If you wish to increase your support, you can simply write a cheque for the additional amount you wish to give. 
 But this is not tax-effective and ACET will not benefit from the additional 33.3&percnt; increase in value. 
 You can use the GIFT AID scheme if you wish to give another &pound;600 or more. 
 Or you can enter into a second Deed of Covenant committing yourself to make payments under both the existing and new covenants. 
 As a further alternative, you can enter into a Supplemental Deed. 
 This has the effect of cancelling your existing covenant and in return you commit yourself to making payments under the new covenant. 
 This procedure is perfectly acceptable provided that your new commitments are at least as great as the remaining commitments due under the  orignal  covenant. 
 Can I extend my covenant, if I wish to continue making payments over a longer period? 
 Again the answer is no. 
 The length of the covenant will have been specified in the Deed, and it will terminate when the last specified annual payment has been made. 
 At that stage you can enter into a new covenant.  
 How much can I covenant? 
 Covenant payments are made out of your income and are not capital payments. 
 You could covenant all your taxable income if you wished &mdash; remember though that a part of your total income will not be subject to tax, because of the various tax allowances you enjoy (personal allowances, mortgage interest relief, etc.) 
 If you are planning to give a particularly large sum, it is always more advantageous to give out of income by covenant than to give a capital sum. 
 You can spread the payments over as long a period as you like. 
 Using the &bquo;Deposited Covenant&equo; procedure you can pay over the whole of the donation in one go, and we can give you full details of how to do this. 
 Alternatively, you could use the GIFT AID scheme (see separate leaflet). 
 What happens if I do not pay UK Income Tax? 
 This can cause problems, since you agree under the terms of the covenant to make payments out of income from which tax has been deducted. 
 If you have not paid tax, then you would not be able to sign a Certificate of Deduction of Tax and ACET would not be able to reclaim tax on the covenant. 
 If ACET did somehow reclaim tax on the covenant then you would be liable to pay income tax to the Inland Revenue on the amount of your covenant payment. 
 So if you are not a UK taxpayer you are advised not to enter into Deeds of Covenant, but to make your regular charitable payments by simple Banker's Order without any covenant. 
 You may in fact find that you do pay some tax in the UK. 
 If you have dividend or receive bank or building society interest on which tax has been paid, tax will have been deducted at source, and this will enable you to sign a Certificate of Deduction of Tax so that ACET can obtain the advantages of covenant giving. 
 Which spouse should enter into the covenant? 
 Since 6th April 1990, married couples have been taxed independently, and each spouse is responsible for paying tax on his/her own income. 
 If you do not pay income tax, but your spouse does, you should not enter into a Deed of Covenant on your own. 
 Either you should ask your spouse to enter into the covenant or you could enter into a Joint Deed of Covenant signed by both you and your spouse. 
 In either event your spouse should actually make the covenant payments, not you. 
 In the same way, if your spouse pays income tax at the higher rate and you pay tax at only the (lower) basic rate, then in order to obtain Higher Rate Tax Relief, your spouse should enter into the covenant, or into a Joint Deed of Covenant with you, and he/she should actually make the covenant payments. 
 This Higher Rate Tax Relief will save 20&percnt; of the cost of the covenant payments.  
 COVENANT FORM FOR UK TAX PAYERS 
 Can I backdate a covenant to cover donations I have already made? 
 The answer is No. 
 A covenant is a legally binding document to make regular donations, and such donations must be made under the terms of an existing Deed of Covenant for tax to be reclaimable. 
 Thus, the first payment should be on or after the date on which the Deed of Covenant is signed. 
 You cannot simply draw up a covenant (or a Deposited Covenant Agreement) to cover a donation you have already made in the hope that ACET can obtain tax advantage on the sum given. 
 However, it can be possible for the documents to be signed after you have sent a payment by cheque provided that you arrange for us to hold the cheque and not pay it into the bank until we have received the signed Deed of Covenant. 
 What happens if I have difficulty in continuing to make payments? 
 If this unlikely situation arises, you should discuss the problem with us. 
 Although ACET, like any charity, does not have the power to release you from the agreement it is likely to be sympathetic. 
 For instance we can suggest ways of rescheduling the payments over a longer period. 
 Whatever happens, any tax relief obtained on donations you have already made will not be lost. 
 It is possible to include in the wording of the Deed that the covenant will cease if certain conditions occur &mdash; for example, if you become unemployed or your income falls below a certain level. 
 But, unless you are considering a particularly large donation, it is unlikely that you would need to include any complicated form of wording. 
 The Inland Revenue will not accept &bquo;escape&equo; conditions which would effectively enable you to terminate the covenant of your own volition. 
 GIFT AID 
 GIFT AID 
 GIVING TO ACET BY GIFT AID 
 This leaflet tries to answer some of the questions you might have on giving to ACET through the Gift Aid scheme. 
 1. 
 What is Gift Aid? 
 Gift Aid is a scheme which gives tax relief for &bquo;one-off&equo; contributions to charity and it came into force on 1st October 1990. 
 Until then an individual could obtain income tax relief for a gift to charity only if the gift was made under a Deed of Covenant. 
 2. 
 How does Gift Aid work? 
 The mechanism of Gift Aid is very simple. 
 Provided the gift is at least &pound;600 it will be regarded as having been paid net of basic rate tax. 
 The charity is able to recover the basic rate tax &bquo;deducted&equo; and the donor can, if appropriate, obtain higher rate tax relief on his payment. 
 Say, for example, you pay &pound;750 to ACET under Gift Aid. 
 The net payment is equivalent to a gross sum of &pound;1,000. 
 ACET an claim repayment of &pound;250 so it received the full &pound;1,000. 
 If you pay tax at the higher rate you will personally obtain further relief of 15&percnt; on the gross figure, so making the net cost of the payment to you &pound;600. 
 (The tax rates cited are those in force in 1990/91). 
 The key to the working of Gift Aid is a certificate which must be signed by the donor. 
 Without that certificate, the charity cannot obtain the repayment of the basic rate tax and the donor cannot get higher rate relief. 
 The Inland Revenue form R190(SD) contains the certificate and the form requires the donor to state that he satisfies all the conditions relating to Gift Aid (as to which, see 4 below), including the fact that he has paid, or will pay, tax equal to the basic rate on the gross amount of the gift. 
 In the above example the gross amount of the gift was &pound;1,000, so the donor would have to certify that he would be paying tax of at least &pound;250. 
 This last point must not be overlooked and may prevent large capital sums being passed under Gift Aid (but see 6. below). 
 You also need to bear in mind that you may have other payments under existing deeds of covenant or other payments made under Gift Aid in the same tax year, and you will need to have a taxable income at least equal to the gross  amount of all these payment, as well as the Gift Aid payment being contemplated, otherwise you will have to account to the Revenue for some tax.  
 3. 
 What are the advantages of Gift Aid over a Deed of Covenant? 
 There are several differences: 
 (i) 
 To be effective for tax purposes a Deed of Covenant has to turn for a period capable to exceeding three years. 
 The intention of a Gift Aid scheme is to encourage giving without the donor being tied to a particular charity for this length of time. 
 (ii) 
 Under Gift Aid there are no formalities at the time of the gift, just a cheque or cash gift to the charity. 
 The certificate on form R190(SD) must be completed but this can be done at any time and amounts to little more than a claim procedure. 
 With a payment under covenant, The Deed of Covenant has to be filled in corrected before a payment is made. 
 (iii) 
 Since Gift Aids applies to a single gifts it can be a very useful means of making a charitable gift towards the end of the tax year when your taxable income for the year can be estimated with some degree of precision. 
 This applies particularly to self-employed persons. 
 But to gain the advantages of the Gift Aid scheme certain conditions have to be complied with. 
 4. 
 What are the conditions to Gift Aid? 
 (i) 
 Cash only. 
 Only payments of cash of at least &pound;600 fall within the scope of Gift Aid. 
 Cash includes cheque payments, bank transfers and credit card payments. 
 Thus the transfer of an asset to a charity e.g. a work of art, will not qualify (although there are other ways for a charity to obtain tax relief on the gift of an asset). 
 Nor will it be possible to make  a  regular contributions below the &pound;600 limit (though see 5. below). 
 (ii) 
 No repayment. 
 A payment only qualifies under Gift Aid if it is a &bquo;gift&equo;. 
 Thus it must be made absolutely with no conditions about repayment. 
 (iii) 
 No debt cancelled. 
 Gift Aid may not be used by a donor as a means of writing of a debt or loan owed to him by the charity. 
 (iv) 
 No benefit. 
 Any benefit enjoyed by the donor or a &bquo;connected person&equo; as a consequence of making a gift under Gift Aid must not exceed the lower  of &pound;250 or 2&frac12;&percnt; of the value of the gift. 
 A &bquo;connected person&equo; broadly speaking means any close relative.  
 (v) 
 Not connected with acquisition of property. 
 A payment will not qualify under Gift Aid if it is made to enable the charity to purchase a property, or other assets, from the donor or from a &bquo;connected person&equo;. 
 (vi) 
 UK resident. 
 The donor must be resident in the United Kingdom at the time that the gift is made. 
 If a nonresident wishes to make a tax effective gift out of UK source income he should use a Deed of Covenant. 
 (vii) 
 Minimum and maximum amounts. 
 The minimum donation which an individual can make under the Gift Aid is &pound;600. the total donations which an individual may make under Gift Aid in any tax year must not exceed &pound;5,000,000. 
 5. 
 What if I wish to give small amounts regularly over a period? 
 Payments qualify for tax relief under gift Aid only if the donation is for &pound;600 or more. 
 If you wish to give small amounts regularly, e.g. monthly, you could accumulate the money in a separate account and then convert this to a gift to ACET every time the amount reaches &pound;600. 
 In this way your gift to ACET will qualify for Gift Aid relief even though the monthly payments would be too small to do so. 
 Thus if you set aside &pound;25 per month it would take two years to accumulate the &pound;600 minimum for the Gift Aid scheme. 
 If for any reason you wanted to give each monthly payment direct to ACET, we could hold the money in an account in your name until the amount accumulated reaches the &pound;600 threshold. 
 Care would be needed with the wording used in any such scheme and ACET can give you more details about this. 
 6. 
 What if I wish to give a sum of capital or a sum in excess of my annual taxable income? 
 If you wish to give a capital sum to ACET (e.g. from an inheritance your have received) or an amount of money that exceeds your taxable for the tax year of the gift, ACET can still get tax relief on your gift if you enter into a Deposited Covenant arrangement. 
 This is quite separate from Gift Aid and details can be supplied on request. 
 Likewise, if you wished to make a single gift to ACET of less than &pound;600 then &mdash; assuming that you are a taxpayer &mdash; you can enable ACET to get the benefit of tax relief by the same Deposited Covenant arrangement.    
 DONATION 
 7. 
 What happens if I do not pay UK income tax? 
 This can cause problems because if you do not pay tax then you will not be able to sign the Certificate on form R190(SD) and ACET would not be able to re-claim basic rate on the payment. 
 If ACET did somehow reclaim tax on the payment then you would be liable to pay income tax to the Inland Revenue on the amount of your Gift Aid payment. 
 So if you are not a UK taxpayer you are advised not to make a payment under the Gift Aid scheme but to make a straight payment by cash or cheque. 
 You may in fact find that you do pay some tax in the  UK If  you have dividends or receive bank or building society interest on which tax has been paid, tax will have  beed  deducted at source, and this will enable you to sign a Certificate so that ACET can obtain the advantages of the Gift Aid scheme. 
 8. 
 Which spouse should make the Gift Aid payment? 
 Since 6th April 1990, married couples have been taxed independently, and each spouse is responsible for paying tax on his/her own income. 
 If you do not pay income tax but your spouse does, then your spouse should make the Gift Aid payment. 
 Similarly, if your spouse pays income tax at the higher rate and you pay tax at only the (lower) basic rate, then your spouse should make the Gift Aid payment in order to obtain the higher rate relief. 
 LEGACY 
 LEAVING A LEGACY TO ACET 
 Why should I make a Will? 
 If I don't make a Will, then the distribution of what you possess when you die may not be as you would wish. 
 Many people wrongly assume that all they have automatically goes to their loved ones. 
 This isn't necessarily so and by neglecting to make a valid, legal Will families put at risk the security and future of their nearest and dearest. 
 Also, by making a proper Will you could well save your dependants from paying an unnecessary amount of inheritance tax (death duties). 
 Moreover, death is a time of great stress to those you love most. 
 Not to have made a Will can only add to that stress. 
 How do I make a Will? 
 There is nothing complicated about it. 
 A Will is simply a clear statement about how your money and possessions are to be divided when you die. 
 But do not make one without the advice of a solicitor. 
 He will help you draw up accurately what you need to say. 
 He will help you to observe the legal requirements and to name Executors to carry out your instructions, to appoint guardians if necessary and to cancel any previous Wills. 
 He will advise you on the inheritance tax your estate might incur and ways in which this may be reduced. 
 He will be able to remind you of beneficiaries you might otherwise forget.  
 Who will deal with my estate when I die? 
 It is most important to appoint at least one Executor when you make your Will. 
 It is in fact advisable to name more than one Executor in case one of them dies before you. 
 Choose people you know well and trust and with whom you can share the details of your affairs. 
 A solicitor or accountant can act as an Executor if you so wish. 
 It doesn't matter if your Executor stands to benefit from the Will. 
 How can I reduce the amount of inheritance tax payable on my estate? 
 At present, the first &pound;128,000 of any estate is free of inheritance tax. 
 Anything over this amount is, basically, liable to inheritance tax at 40&percnt;. 
 There are exemptions for gifts to spouses and to charity. 
 Of course, taking account of the value of a house and its contents and personal savings and investments it is not surprising that a great many people have estates that exceed the inheritance tax threshold. 
 However, a gift to ACET is completely free of inheritance tax, due to the fact that ACET is a charity. 
 Money that is otherwise destined for the Inland Revenue can instead go to ACET. 
 And &pound;400 of tax can be saved for every &pound;1,000 that you give. 
 (Figures correct as at Feb. 1991).  
 An example 
 Let's say that your estate is worth &pound;140,000, net of liabilities. 
 As this is over the inheritance tax threshold, it would bring a tax bill of &pound;4,800. 
 By leaving &pound;5,000 to ACET, however, the taxable  value of your estate is reduced to &pound;135,000 and this would give a tax saving  of &pound;2,000. 
 What form of words should I use for a legacy to ACET? 
 It might be helpful to take to your solicitor a form of words to cover your gift to ACET and we suggest the following: &bquo;To ACET of Paramount House, 71/75 Uxbridge Road, Ealing, London W5 for its general purposes (one of these alternatives):&equo; 
 1. 
 &bquo;&hellip; the sum of &pound;&equo;. 
 2. 
 &bquo;&hellip; all the residue of my estate&equo;. 
 3. 
 &bquo;one share of the residue of my estate&equo;. 
 &bquo;And I declare that the receipt of the Treasurer or other proper officer of ACET shall be a sufficient discharge to my Executors&equo;. 
 LONDON HOME CARE AIDS CARE EDUCATION &amp; TRAINING 081 840 7879 
 WHAT IS ACET HOME CARE? 
 In London we have a team of 4 specialist nurses backed up by 2 doctors. 
 Whether you need medical or nursing advice or practical support in the home we can help. 
 Nursing 
 Our nurses have been extensively trained in symptom control, home care and HIV/AIDS related issues. 
 If you refer for our service you will be visited by one of the team who will discuss your needs with you. 
 This means that you can decide on your own care support. 
 Practical Support 
 ACET volunteers are available to help whenever you need them, as long as you make arrangements with our volunteer coordinator and give us as much notice as possible. 
 ACET volunteers carry out the following tasks as well as many others: 
 &bull; 
 Housework 
 &bull; 
 Transport 
 &bull; 
 Collecting Prescriptions 
 &bull; 
 Shopping 
 &bull; 
 Nightsitting 
 In an emergency  you can reach an ACET doctor or nurse through our 24 hour on call facility. 
 This means you can get professional help any time of the day or night, and at weekends. 
 We also have a limited number of Care-link telephones for installation in individual homes. 
 These enable you to call for help from anywhere in your house or flat. 
 This can bring security and peace of mind to those who are ill but living on their own. 
 Medical Equipment  ACET can loan specialised medical equipment after consultation with your doctor. 
  For information about our home care service call Janet Sutton on 081 840 7879   
 Janet Sutton 
 DOES ACET'S SERVICE COST ME ANYTHING? 
 We are given some financial support from the government but this doe snot cover all our costs and we therefore depend on gifts from trusts, companies and individuals. 
 If you would like to help us financially why not ask one of our Home Care team for details. 
 MEETING YOUR NEEDS 
 ACET recognises that people can have needs in many areas. 
 We are committed to the practical care of all those who are ill with AIDS/HIV regardless of race, religion, lifestyle, sex, sexuality or any other factor. 
 Our trained workers find that some of those we care for want to talk through emotional and spiritual issues. 
 ACET is a church-based organisation whose primary concern is practical care  rather than counselling, and so these areas are only covered if they are raised by our clients.  
 HOW CAN I BENEFIT FROM ACET'S SERVICES 
 To be eligible for ACET Home Care you must be HIV positive and require assistance  because of this. 
 Once you have decided you would like practical help from ACET just ring 081 840 7879 and ask for Home Care. 
 If appropriate one of our specialist nurses will then arrange to come and see you to discuss your practical needs and see how ACET can help. 
 CAN I REFER TO ACET EVEN IF I AM USING OTHER SERVICES? 
 Yes. 
 ACET works with partners, family, friends and other voluntary and statutory organisations to ensure that people get all the care they need in the way that they need it. 
 We work closely with GP's  and clinics to ensure co-operation and efficiency for every situation. 
 IS ACET'S SERVICE CONFIDENTIAL? 
 Our service is completely confidential  and only with your permission do we liaise with others involved in your case.  
 WHAT DO OTHERS SAY? 
 &bquo;One of the nurses has been coming in to give me injections every day. 
 They've liaised with other organisations to make sure I've got somebody coming in, even if it's only to make me something to eat. 
 I don't know what I'd do with them.&equo;  
 Tony C London W4 
 WHAT DO I DO NOW? 
 Telephone Janet Sutton during office hours if you would like to know more about us, and how we might be able to help you. 
 The numbers is: Wandsworth Office:  
 081 840 7879 
 071 498 7588 
 ACET HOME CARE TEAM 
 WHAT IS ACET? 
 We are a national charity, founded in 1988, dedicated to providing care at home for men, women and children with AIDS/HIV related illnesses. 
 This leaflet explains how ACET Home Care in London would help you, or someone you know. 
 A CHRISTIAN RESPONSE TO AIDS AIDS CARE EDUCATION AND TRAINING 
 Why do we need a Christian response to AIDS? 
 AIDS is the biggest health challenge we have had to face this century. 
 Already more children may be dying with AIDS than from famine and 11 million are carrying the virus HIV, 1 in 250 of all adults worldwide. 
 AIDS touches areas of sickness, death and personal behaviour. 
 It brings out prejudice and fear, and people with the disease are often isolated and rejected. 
 Meanwhile health campaigns have largely failed so far to change behaviour. 
 The church should be able to respond to these urgent needs more effectively than any other group and provide clear leadership. 
 The church can give care and compassion to those affected by AIDS and help prevent infection.  
 World Health Organisation figures. 
 Volunteers Provide Transport Daysit Nightsit Housework Cook Collect Prescriptions Befriend 
 ACET Home Care 
 ACET is a Christian response to AIDS. 
 We are the largest independent provider of practical home care to people with HIV/AIDS in the U.K. From 7 regional offices we have provided practical care to over 1000 people in the lat 3 years and in the last 12 months we cared for at least 1 in 5 of those who died of AIDS in the U.K. 
 Our Home Care teams are made up of doctors and nurses backed by a network of trained and active volunteers. 
 Our staff and volunteers are drawn from churches of all denominations. 
 Without their commitment we would not be able to provide such an extensive service.  
 Regional Offices London Edinburgh Glasgow Dundee Portsmouth Northampton Belfast Kampala, Uganda Constanta, Romania 
 Schools Education 
 Sexual activity among teenagers is increasing fast &mdash; even in our churches. 
 A recent survey of church youth groups shows that 1 in 4 have had sex by the time they are eighteen years old, 1 in 10 under the age of sixteen. 
 Outside the church the statistics are higher still. 
 Prevention of infection is a major part of our response to HIV/AIDS and we are the largest independent provider of schools classes on AIDS. 
 Our aim is to reduce the number of new HIV infections by giving young people the facts about AIDS and by encouraging them to think about their future. 
 So far we have visited over 100 schools and talked to more than 50,000 pupils. 
 Survey of 150 church youth groups across the denominations &mdash; 1729 interviewed (Agape 1991) 
 Overseas 
 By the turn of the century 9 out of 10 with HIV will be in developing countries &mdash; some 36 million people. 
 Many churches overseas are struggling to meet the AIDS challenge. 
 In some countries one third of all adults in towns and cities are already infected. 
 The effect in the future will be devastating. 
 ACET's work with the churches in Africa and Romania has been recognised and supported by UNICEF, the World Health Organisation and by TEAR Fund. 
 We run training programmes in Romania and support care and prevention programmes in Uganda and Tanzania.  
 What can your church do? 
 Your church can become a partner with ACET. 
 If we are to continue to meet the rapidly growing needs of those who look to us for care and prevention, we urgently need you to share the challenge with us. 
 This is why we are asking your church to link with ACET in a Christian response to AIDS both at home and overseas. 
 Churches working together 
 ACET can help your church with 
 &bull; 
 Speakers for services, seminars or workshops. 
 &bull; 
 Training church members as community volunteers. 
 &bull; 
 Information, newsletters and advice. 
 ACET can help your church with 
 &bull; 
 Making members aware of our work. 
 &bull; 
 Appointing a member of your church as an ACET-Link representative. 
 &bull; 
 Encouraging volunteer involvement. 
 &bull; 
 Supporting us financially. 
 &bull; 
 Praying regularly. 
 ACET Aims 
 &bull; 
 To provide practical care and support to men, women and children with AIDS, irrespective of race, religion, lifestyle, sexual orientation or any other factor. 
 &bull; 
 To reduce the number of new HIV infections by giving young people the facts about AIDS. 
 &bull; 
 To help provide a local response to a global problem. 
 &bull; 
 To equip the Church to make an effective Christian response to AIDS, respecting the historic teachings of the church and providing unconditional care. 
 PATRONS:  The most Reverend and Right honourable the Lord Archbishop of Canterbury Dr George Carey BD Mth Phd Cliff Richard OBE General Eva Burrows OA Head of Salvation Army 
 on behalf of a client 
 &bquo;On behalf of the family of my late brother, Robert, I wish to thank you for the compassion and care shown to him by your organization during his long and difficult illness. 
 Please convey our gratitude to the volunteers concerned. 
 Robert found peace and assurance before his death and I believe such was achieved partly by the demonstration of the love of Jesus shown by you.&equo; 
 on behalf of a client 
 &bquo;Thank you for all the help you gave to us and to Bob during the last few days of his illness &mdash; I only wish we'd been put in touch with ACET sooner. 
 I was particularly impressed by the way you managed to organise all the available services so efficiently &mdash; just at the time when we were beginning to wonder how we'd manage.&equo; 
 Dr S J Bowcock Former Senior Registrar in Haematology, Hammersmith Hospital 
 &bquo;I would like to thank you and your Team for all the effort and resources you have put into providing a home care service for our patients. 
 Your Team has been invaluable in providing psychological as well as practical support for these patients which have been grossly lacking through the conventional channels. 
 I hope that you might be able to continue to help our patients in this manner.&equo; 
 Villiers High School 
 &bquo;I would like once again to thank you for the major contribution you've made to our AIDS education programme this year. 
 I feel that this is reflected not just in the increased knowledge of the students but also in a change of attitude and a few greater degrees of empathy.&equo; 
 Roger Stephenson Fairlight Christian Centre 
 &bquo;If there is to be an effective Christian response to AIDS we need to support organisations like ACET who are in the front line giving practical care and support.&equo; 
 Peter Ronayne St Lukes, West Norwood, Church of England 
 &bquo;ACET is working in this field because, like Jesus, they are getting alongside those in need and helping the rest of us to understand and minister to those both infected and affected.&equo; 
 David Wise Greenford Baptist Church 
 &bquo;Members of my church have been working with ACET since it started 3 years ago. 
 I have seen for myself the value of ACET's work in the community and I would  whole heartedly  recommend other churches get behind the work in any way they can.&equo; 
 If you would like to know more about us and about our work please telephone or write to: 
 Peter Glover or Peter Fabian ACET, PO Box 1323, London W5 5TF Tel: 081 840 7879 
 ACET AIDS CARE EDUCATION AND TRAINING 
 ANNUAL REVIEW 1990/91 bringing it home 
 Contents 
 Chairman's report 
 1 
 Director's report 
 2&ndash;3 
 London Home Care 
 4&ndash;5 
 ACET Scotland 
 6&ndash;7 
 ACET education 
 8&ndash;9 
 ACET overseas 
 10&ndash;11 
 Financial report 
 12 
 ACET offices and personnel 
 13 
 CHAIRMAN'S REPORT ACET &mdash; MEETING THE CHALLENGE OF AIDS 
 The last 12 months have seen further dramatic growth for ACET at home and overseas. 
 After only three years we are now caring for one in four of those dying with AIDS in the UK. 
 The growing number of men, women and children with AIDS and the fact that people with the disease now survive longer, have made ever more pressing demands on our Home Care teams. 
 In the schools the needs for AIDS education has never been greater. 
 To meet the challenge we have strengthened our management team to provide the foundation for further soundly based growth. 
 It is now more than ever clear that every section of society needs to be involved in responding to AIDS, including the churches. 
 ACET is a Christian initiative supported by all denominations. 
 It is the churches that provide our volunteers; without their support we would not be able to provide a service at all. 
 The work they do is an inspiring example of what loving community care is all about. 
 Governmental organisations support us financially. 
 So do companies and trusts, and churches and individuals. 
 We thank them. 
 AIDS is here to stay. 
 In 1991/92 we shall need support even more. 
 Every donation does help. 
 That help makes all the difference to people sick with AIDS who want to stay at home, rather than spend time unnecessarily in hospital. 
 Please help! 
 SIR JOHN FORD KCMG MG CHAIRMAN OF TRUSTEES 
 ACET's mission 
 To give practical care to men, women and children ill at home with HIV/AIDS. 
 To prevent new HIV infections through a schools education programme. 
 DIRECTOR'S REPORT 
 THE GROWING PROBLEM 
 Travelling to several countries over the last year, has brought it home to me how disastrous are the effects, worldwide, of the virus causing AIDS. 
 During the past year at least 1.5 million more men, women and children have become infected with HIV. 
 AIDS affects over 160 countries and is now taking an increasingly heavy toll. 
 By the year 2000 the World Health Organisation estimates that up to 40 million people will be infected with HIV . 
 Despite public perceptions, across the world 7 out of 10 infections are heterosexual. 
 WHO press release April 1991. 
 In the UK the spread of infection has slowed down but the numbers ill and needing care are continuing to rise and this is a reflection of levels of infection some years ago. 
 HOME CARE IN THE UK 
 The need for a national and international AIDS charity has never been greater. 
 As the UK's main independent AIDS home care provider, we cared for around 25% of all those who died of AIDS last year . 
 In London, demand for our Home Care services doubled over the last twelve months. 
 We are the largest independent provider of professional home care in the capital giving pain control, nursing and medical advice, 24 hour on call, emotional support and practical volunteer help, including nightsitting. 
 I expect demand for this service to continue to grow over the coming year. 
 AIDS deaths: April 1990 &mdash; March 1991, UK total (CDSC figures &mdash; 584 April 1991.) 
 Our Home Care teams saw 141 AIDS related deaths last year 
 In Scotland rapidly growing numbers of ill men, women and children at home have stretched our Edinburgh and Dundee teams to the limit. 
 Complex social problems have to be tackled including homelessness, imprisonment, birth of an infected child and death of one or even both parents. 
 I am pleased to report further extensions of home care over the last year to meet the growing needs in Glasgow and also to cover a greater area of the South Coast and the East Midlands. 
 This means that around 70% of all those with AIDS in the UK live in areas served by ACET Home Care. 
 PREVENTION IN SCHOOLS 
 Every day more young people are infected with HIV &mdash; often completely unaware they have been personally at risk &mdash; and risky behaviour is on the increase again. 
 Effective prevention has never been more urgently needed, especially in schools. 
 ACET educators see up to 4,000 pupils a month in face-to-face school presentations. 
 This year a total of 24,000 attended compared with 14,500 in 1989/90. 
 Every educator has a personal story to tell from working in our home care teams. 
 Evaluations show these educators  have a high impact and real credibility with 13 to 18 year olds. 
 School teachers and parents know they need help to make AIDS real. 
 Our new 24 page full colour schools booklet has been widely acclaimed by teachers and pupils as the best AIDS resource they have ever seen. 
 In Northern Ireland our work has been warmly received by both communities and their churches. 
 AFRICA &mdash; WHERE DO YOU START? 
 With possibly one in three of adults in some African towns and cities already HIV infected, it is hard to know how to begin to help. 
 Whole communities are being shaken by large numbers of deaths among young adults and young children. 
 Half a million babies have already been born with HIV in Africa. 
 Ten million children with be AIDS orphans by the year 2000 . 
 WHO press release April 1991. 
 We are seeking to provide urgent help to churches and Christian organisations in their prevention campaigns and care programmes, working closely with Tear Fund, the World Health Organisation, UNICEF and governments. 
 As a result of preparatory work, programmes will be starting in the next few months in Uganda and Tanzania. 
 CHILDREN IN ROMANIA 
 Romania has been hit by a major tragedy with hundreds of young children HIV infected through hazardous medical or nursing treatments. 
 New children are being put at risk every day because many care workers still do not know how to protect people from HIV. 
 Over the last year we have moved therefore from care support to urgent training of Romanian people who can then become effective educators. 
 In 1990/91 we carried forward a substantial reserve which allowed us to meet greater than expected demands. 
 In recognition of the importance of our work, I am pleased to report that our Central Government grant was increased last year to &pound;140,00 with guaranteed funding for the next three years. 
 In addition, local boroughs and health authorities fund us through grants and service contracts. 
 The balance of funding has come from trusts, companies, churches and individuals. 
 Despite these commitments, the last quarter was a difficult time with the recession and the changes in local government financing both having their effects. 
 However, we are able to enter the 1991/92 financial year with a firm financial base, a strong management team and a greater than ever determination to be an effective caring Christian response to this global epidemic wherever it is most needed.  
 ACET LONDON: HOME CARE SERVICE 
 COMMUNITY CARE FOR THOSE DYING WITH AIDS 
 &bquo;You can be perfectly well with HIV but at other times it's hard to do even basic things. 
 In the early days the stigma of being HIV positive drove away 60% of my circle of friends. 
 Despite the publicity on transmission of the disease, ignorance was such that they became afraid to even visit me. 
 It soon became clear that I could no longer rely on friends for help with everyday chores, like shopping and housework, when I needed it. 
 I contacted ACET who I knew provided practical care at home.&equo; 
 &bquo;Illness, including chronic muscle debility, herpes, tremors and eye infections have come and gone. 
 Recently I have experienced near fatal fevers. 
 Every day is an effort. 
 That's the reality; you want life to be as it was. 
 But without the help of ACET and other voluntary organisations I would not have been able to maintain my independence.&equo;  
 Three quarters of the nation's entire AIDS problem is to be found in London and the pattern of need is changing fast. 
 As London's largest independent provider of community care we have seen these changes unfold at first hand . 
 Between 1984 and 1986, those with AIDS died on average some ten months after diagnosis, but by 1987 to 1989, the survival period had already doubled to twenty months . 
 Today, each person with AIDS is surviving on average longer than two years, needing more care than ever before. 
 AIDS deaths: April 1990 &mdash; March 1991 totalled 430 in four Thames regions (CDSC figures April 1991) of which 15&ndash;20 (estimated) died outside M25 area. 
 Our London Home Care service saw 103 deaths in the same area. 
 British Medical Journal (Source: BMJ 1991); 302: 203&ndash;7) 
 The &bquo;cause of death figures&equo; are also changing beyond all recognition. 
 In 1986, the classical pneumocystis pneumonia used to be the final event in the disease process in almost half (46%) of AIDS related deaths. 
 While pneumonia continues to be a common occurrence, by 1989 improved treatment had reduced the numbers dying as a result to only 3% . 
 Instead, people are developing other problems are developing other problems such as cancers which give rise to the need for long-term community support. 
 British Medical Journal (Source: BMJ 1991); 302: 203&ndash;7) 
 These factors help to explain why the total number of clients covered at any one time by our London 24 hour on-call service more than doubled from 70 in April 1990 to 150 by March 1991; and why the provision of service has had to become so much more sophisticated. 
 For example the numbers needing opiates to control pain are rising and up to one in five will need special battery-operated syringe pumps to deliver medication in the home . 
 Over the next twelve months we expect a further increase in those needing our Home Care service to enable them to live and die at home.  
 P. Dixon, Postgraduate Medical Journal (in paper No 17/Napp July 1991). 
 Help to stay at home: 
 Nursing and medical advice 
 Pain and symptom control 
 24 hour on-call 
 Practical volunteer help 
 ? 
 Nightsitting 
 Specialist equipment loan 
 Emotional support 
 The commonest cause of death now is advanced Kaposi's Sarcoma &mdash; a painful cancer. 
 Slowly growing lesions can produce difficulties in the lung and the gut, causing many problems including shortness of breath, and periods of continuous pain. 
 ACET SCOTLAND: &bquo;WHO WILL CARE FOR MY CHILDREN WHEN I DIE?&equo; 
 It is hard to fathom the pain felt at the death of a son or daughter, husband or wife, partner or friend. 
 But it is a pain that many families are having to live with as the number of those dying of AIDS increases. 
 We already support over 70 children from the families we visit. 
 Over the last year ACET's centres in Dundee, Edinburgh and Glasgow have been asked to care for a growing number needing practical help to stay at home. 
 In addition to illness, homelessness is a key issue. 
 Often entire families including young children need practical home care, continuing if necessary after mum or dad has died. 
 CHILDREN WITH HIV 
 One of the saddest aspects of AIDS is the plight of children infected with HIV. 
 For many families in Scotland, homecare plays a big part in alleviating some of the huge problems the face. 
 Two out of five ACET clients in Scotland are women and therefore we anticipate an increase in the number of children needing care. 
 We already support over 70 children who belong to the families we visit. 
 Practical support in the home means that family members may not have to spend so long in hospital. 
 Families can stay together through an extremely difficult period &mdash; but this can only happen if organisations like ACET are sufficiently funded. 
 YOU CAN'T PROVIDE HOMECARE TO THE HOMELESS 
 In other cases people don't even have homes to lose. 
 Men and women discharged from hospital with nowhere to live, or released from prison back into the community, are having to sleep rough or doss down wherever they can find a willing friend. 
 It is hard for those wanting to make a fresh start, maintain good health and stay off drugs. 
 Although we are often successful in securing accommodation, it is a problem which stretches our resources to the full and we are urgently raising money to buy emergency short term accommodation for people with HIV/AIDS. 
 PREVENTING NEW INFECTION 
 In Scotland the AIDS problem is largely drug related with HIV spreading rapidly through the communal use of syringes and needles during the mid 1980s. 
 As a result there is now a large group who are at a similar stage of HIV infection at any one time. 
 ACET is in touch with around 300 infected individuals of which about 130 need support to stay at home. 
 Drug use is an emotive issue. 
 But for many people, the slide into drug use has been to escape other problems &mdash; poor living conditions, no real job prospects and broken relationships at home which all lead to feelings of hopelessness and despair. 
 People are still injecting and sharing dirty equipment. 
 ACET's response has been to provide clients with special tubes for the disposal of dirty needles and syringes or help them if they wish to cease injecting. 
 To help reduce infection, our community care workers also provide clean needles and syringes to those clients who are known injectors &mdash; an operation which has full medical supervision. 
 We also educate young people in schools about the dangers of drug use.  
 Over the next decade a real challenge will be the effective provision of care for children and families affected by HIV/AIDS. 
 Ultimately death itself may be seen as a release. 
 However the process of dying can be marred by guilt and rejection. 
 On the other hand it can bring about reconciliation between families and friends and a new appreciation of life's true values. 
 ACET EDUCATION: AIDS IN OUR SCHOOLS 
 Every day, despite massive health campaigns, thousands of young people are still taking serious risks. 
 Tragically, more are becoming HIV infected, and many of those we care for with AIDS today were infected as teenagers. 
 With many sexually active before their sixteenth birthday and with drug taking on the increase, education needs to start young. 
 AIDS is a sensitive area which many schools are unsure how to tackle. 
 But if we are to reduce the number of new infections and protect our young people, they must be given the facts about AIDS/HIV and given the opportunity to discuss the issues openly. 
 ACET is in a unique position to meet the need by carrying a high impact message aimed at changing high risk behaviour. 
 Videos and literature are not enough. 
 Official materials and guidelines do not always find favour with parents and governors. 
 Very often they are pleased to invite ACET in as a church-based agency. 
 Our educators present a personal message, each one having had experience of caring for those dying with AIDS at home. 
 Furthermore our work in Uganda and Romania adds a wider perspective. 
 The content of each lesson is agreed beforehand in consultation with teachers so it can be tailored to the priorities and individual needs of the school or class. 
 Prejudices are challenged and myths exposed &mdash; for example that only homosexual men and drug users are at risk. 
 Pupils are encouraged to consider how they might feel if they were carrying the virus and how they might care for people with HIV/AIDS, especially those with unfamiliar lifestyles. 
 Over the last year, 24,000 pupils attended ACET class presentations, as against 14,500 in 1989/90. 
 The aim of our schools programme is quite simple; to reduce the number of new infections and to encourage positive attitudes towards those with AIDS. 
 An educator only has to prevent one new HIV infection a year to save the NHS his or her entire salary in future AIDS treatment costs alone. 
 Our programme has been extended to parts of Scotland and Northern Ireland making it the largest of its kind in the UK. 
 We hope to be able to increase its reach even further in the coming year.   
 HIV/AIDS education is placed in the context of lifeskills or health education &mdash; the most common slot is &bquo;personal and social education&equo;. 
 Our latest schools booklet has been enthusiastically received by many pupils and teachers. 
 In a follow-up survey, the great majority rated it the best AIDS resource they had seen. 
 This is one lesson that could save their lives. 
 ACET OVERSEAS: THE RACE AGAINST TIME 
 In Constanta, alone, there are over 550 children with AIDS. 
 By the year 2000, of the 40 million expected to be infected with the virus causing AIDS, 36 million will be in the developing world. 
 The global dimension of AIDS requires individual organisations and communities to rapidly develop their own local approaches and responses to the problem although often with limited resources. 
 Seven million are already HIV infected in sub-Saharan Africa, increasing by over one million a year. 
 Our work in the African continent centres on Uganda and is supported by Tear Fund. 
 We also have a community care and education programme in Tanzania. 
 UGANDA 
 In Uganda, the number of people estimated to be HIV infected is 1.3 million, representing over 1 in 8 of the entire adult population. 
 Indicates are that this figure is continuing to rise. 
 There is a great deal of individual suffering with deaths in almost every family in some areas. 
 ACET aims to be a practical resource to local churches and Christian organisations seeking to prevent new infection and provide basic community care. 
 Over the next twelve months we will be providing support to a growing number of new and existing local programmes, identified as a result of an extensive survey we have just completed. 
 There is an urgent need for further prevention work. 
 Practical help is also needed for those who are dying and for orphans left behind. 
 Uganda is a developing country with neither the wealth nor the health service infrastructure to cope with the problem adequately. 
 ROMANIA &mdash; CHANGING OLD HABITS 
 It is well known that many children in Romanian hospitals have been infected with HIV through reused needles, syringes and infected blood transfusions. 
 In Constanta alone there are over 550 children with AIDS. 
 Adults are also infected. 
 Last year ACET provided urgently needed medical supplies to the worst affected areas. 
 We were also invited by the Chief Inspector of Preventative Medicine in Brasov to hold and HIV/AIDS Health Education course for doctors, nurses and teachers in the Brasov district. 
 At the same time we appointed a Romanian, Ana Ureche, to coordinate and represent our work. 
 The aim of the course was primarily to train Health Educators, who in turn can train others in hospitals, schools and communities, reducing the risk of further infection. 
 Our first and subsequent courses have been a success and are part of a long-term commitment to AIDS prevention. 
 In the future we hope also to be able to assist further with practical care.   
 ACET is involved in the planning and implementation of a Mobile Home Care project with the Church of Ireland Missionary Society and Diocese of Mwanza, funded by WHO. 
 This will help prevent the spread of infection in local Tanzanian villages as well as provide basic community care. 
 The Romanian Government, WHO and UNICEF have taken a great interest in our education programme and are actively looking for ways to use it as a model for Health Education in Romania. 
 AUDITORS' REPORT TO THE MEMBERS OF AIDS CARE EDUCATION AND TRAINING 
 We have audited the above financial statements in accordance with Auditing Standards. 
 In our opinion the financial statements give a true and fair view of the company's affairs at 31 March 1991 and of its deficit and source and applications of funds for the year then ended and have been properly prepared in accordance with the Companies ACT 1985. 
 Neville Russell Chartered Accountants, Spencer House, Grove Hill Road, Harrow, Middlesex.  
 ACET UK has 40 paid staff and relies on volunteers in the office as well as in the community. 
 A full set of audited accounts is available on request.  
 ACET OFFICES AND PERSONNEL 
 Here are some of the people involved in providing ACET's home care and educational services.  
 AMNESTY Journal of the British Section of Amnesty International No 51 June/July 1991 
 AMNESTY INTERNATIONAL 30 YEARS OF STRUGGLE FOR HUMAN RIGHTS 
 CONTENTS 
 REGULARS 
 1 
 International News 
 8 
 Home News 
 18 
 Prisoner Letter Writing Campaign 
 30 
 Group News 
 32 
 Letters 
 FEATURES 
 10 
 Global Warning By Norma Johnston 
 12 
 Freedom Come 
 16 
 Don't Forget to Write 
 20 
 Team Work By Michael Crowley 
 22 
 US Death Penalty: Back Yard Blues By Piers Bannister 
 24 
 Sri Lanka: Paradise in Turmoil By Peter Nicholls 
 26 
 Morocco: Speaking in Shadows By Dan Jones 
 28 
 South Africa: Righting the Record By Brian Dooley 
 29 
 Refugees: Jumping the Hurdles By Jan Shaw 
 Josef Beran, one of AI's earliest releases. 
 Page 9 
 2,300 inmates of America's death row. 
 Page 22 
 The Oufkir family, released in February 1991. 
 Page 26 
 Billy Connolly and the groups break out! 
 Page 30 
 Amnesty International is a worldwide human rights movement which works impartially for the release of prisoners of conscience: men, women and children detained anywhere for their beliefs, colour, ethnic origin, sex, religion or language, provided they have neither used nor advocated the use of violence. 
 Amnesty International opposes torture and the death penalty in all cases without reservation and advocates fair and prompt trials for all political prisoners. 
 Amnesty International is independent of all governments, political factions, ideologies, economic interests and religious creeds. 
 It has formal relations with the United Nations (ECOSOC), UNESCO, the Council of Europe, the Organisation of American States, and the Organisation of African Unity. 
 Amnesty International was the recipient of the 1977 Nobel Prize for Peace. 
 CLASSIFIED ADS 
 NATURAL FRIENDS is a unique friendship/contact agency. 
 If you seek other sincere people who share your important concerns, there is a very good chance that we can help. 
 For details please send a stamped addressed envelope to:  
 PENUMBRA, a new fiction poetry magazine, is now on sale, price 70p from Dave Leggett  
 NEWS 
 AFRICA 
 Malawi 
 Two prisoners formerly featured in the Letter Writing Campaign, Thoza Khonje and George Mtafu, were among at least 21 political prisoners released in Malawi between January and March this year &mdash; all of them long-term detainees held without charge or trial. 
 It is not yet clear how many of the almost 80 other prisoners freed at the same time were held for political reasons. 
 Thoza Khonje, a 43-year-old area sugar company manager, was arrested on 28 February 1989, reportedly after being overheard criticizing policy decisions by Life-President Hastings Kamazu Banda. 
 George Mtafu, Malawi's only neurosurgeon, was arrested the same month after refusing to apologise for challenging public criticisms of northern Malawians made by Life-President Banda. 
 Other northern Malawians arrested between February and May 1989 are thought to be among those set free. 
 Others freed included William Masiku, detained since 1980, Brown Mmpinganjira, detained since 1986, Margaret Marango Banda, detained since 1988, and Blaise Machira, also detained since 1988. 
 The releases mark the first improvement in the human rights situation in Malawi for several years. 
 however, other prominent prisoners of conscience remain behind bars. 
 For example, Goodluck Mhango, a veterinary surgeon arrested in September 1987, has been rejected for release by a committee established to review the cases of political detainees. 
 Amnesty International has welcomed the releases, but is urging the government to release all remaining prisoners of conscience immediately and unconditionally. 
 Swaziland 
 Five prisoners of conscience held in Swaziland since November 1990 under renewable 60-day administrative detention orders were released on 22 March 1991. 
 The five were previously imprisoned from June until October 1990 for allegedly organizing a political party &mdash; all parties are prohibited. 
 The releases occurred shortly before two AI representatives arrived in Swaziland for talks with the government. 
 Mauritania 
 In April AI called on the Mauritanian Government to investigate reports that up to 200 political prisoners had died or been killed in military or police custody &mdash; some executed without trial and many others as a result of torture. 
 The victims were among some 3,000 black Mauritanians arrested late last year. 
 The authorities claimed they were conspiring to overthrow the government, which is dominated by a different community, the Moors, but offered no evidence to substantiate this claim. 
 It took AI several months to compile details of the killings, but prisoners released in March 1991 provided information and themselves bore scars from torture. 
 In a few cases, prisoners are reported to have been deliberately executed without trial. 
 Most of the reported deaths, however, were due to torture in both military barracks and police stations. 
 Torture of political detainees in Mauritania has been routine since 1986, but it has never before been used on such a scale. 
 After the March 1991 releases, over 70 detainees were still held and were apparently due to be brought to trial in April. 
 However, the trial has been postponed indefinitely. 
 Mali 
 Over 150 men, women and children were killed by Mali's security forces in March, after a wave of pro-democracy demonstrations and riots. 
 In the wake of the killings the government led by President Moussa Traor&eacute; was overthrown. 
 At least 40 people were killed in Bamako on 22 March after a student demonstration was stopped by the security forces and rioting broke out. 
 A state of emergency was declared but at least another 40 people were killed the following day. 
 Some were shot dead when thousands of women, protesting against the killings, tried to march on the President's residence. 
 Up to 65 protesters were reported to have been burned to death when security forces set fire to a shopping centre in which they were seeking refuge. 
 Soldiers also shot at mourners burying the dead at two cemeteries in Bamako. 
 Amnesty International called on the Malian Government to halt the killings. 
 Following a general strike and calls for his resignation, the President was arrested on 26 March by fellow army officers. 
 Some 50 others associated with the former government were also detained. 
 The authorities promised early elections, and said the former president and others arrested would be brought to trial. 
 Rwanda 
 Amnesty International has received information about nearly 300 Ugandan nationals currently detained for political reasons in Rwanda. 
 They have not been charged or tried and may be imprisoned because of their nationality, in retaliation for the Ugandan authorities alleged support of the armed opposition group, the Rwandese Patriotic Front.  
 Relatives and friends of a man shot dead during pro-democracy demonstrations in Bamako, with the body in a hospital morgue. 
 AMERICAS 
 Guatemala 
 In a breakthrough case on 20 March this year, four policemen in Guatemala City were convicted of the murder of a 13-year-old street child and sentenced to between 10 and 15 years' imprisonment. 
 Naham&aacute;n Carmona L&oacute;pez was attacked by the four policemen on 4 March 1990 in Guatemala City. 
 He died in hospital several days later of multiple injuries, including a ruptured liver, six fractured ribs, two broken fingers and severe bruising to 70 per cent of his body. 
 (See Amnesty  Oct/Nov 1990). 
 The four members of the National Police were arrested in June 1990. 
 At their trial, the judge is believed to have added 25 per cent to each sentence specifically because the police had carried out the attack while operating in their official capacity. 
 In April AI learned that warrants had been issued for the arrest of two police officers and a civilian in connection with the killing of 17-year-old Anstraum Aman Villagr&aacute;n Morales. 
 Anstraum Villagr&aacute;n was shot and killed on 25 June 1990 in Guatemala City by two uniformed police officers. 
 The three are also believed to be implicated in other cases of serious violations against street children. 
 Thirty-six other lawsuits against 35 National Police officers, three Treasury Police officers, 10 civilians and three judges for a wide range of abuses against street children are reportedly pending in Guatemalan courts. 
 A BBC1 Everyman programme entitled &bquo;They Shoot Children Don't They?&equo; screened in January this year focussed on the plight of the children. 
 The producers worked closely with an AI researcher and concentrated on the work of Bruce Harris, a human rights worker in Guatemala. 
 Viewers wishing to help were given the address of AI at the end of the programme: over 1,500 letters were subsequently received at the AI office. 
 In response, AI sent out information packs on the case of Naham&aacute;n and people to write letters to the relevant authorities. 
 With letters still coming in, AI will be sending out information on other street children's cases in Guatemala &mdash; many of Naham&aacute;n's friends who witnessed the attack have been subjected to harassment from the police. 
 Brazil 
 A proposal for constitutional reform to allow a national plebiscite on the reintroduction of the death penalty in Brazil, for kidnappings, burglaries and rapes resulting in the victim's death, was approved by a Congressional Commission of the House of Deputies in December 1990. 
 AI has appealed to Brazilian parliamentarians expressing its concern over the moves to reinstate the death penalty. 
 The death penalty was excluded from the Brazilian Penal Code in 1890 and its abolition is enshrined in the 1988 Constitution. 
 El Salvador 
 Death squad killings, &bquo;disappearances&equo;, illegal arrests and torture persist in spite of the Government and the Farabund Marti National Liberation Front signing the Agreement on Human Rights in July 1990, under the auspices of the United Nations. 
 At least nine people were killed between November 1990 and January 1991 by death squads linked to the Armed Forces. 
 Some of the bodies showed signs of torture and in many cases personal documents had been removed to prevent identification. 
 There have also been some reports of &bquo;disappearances&equo; following arrests by the military or police since July 1990. 
 Of particular concern is the pattern of abductions by armed men in plain clothes in security force style operations, most of which took place at night. 
 Amnesty has received repeated reports of violation of detention procedures. 
 Military units have frequently carried out arrests and failed promptly to hand over detainees to the police &mdash; a number have been held beyond the 72-hour-limit. 
 Torture is still being used to intimidate detainees. 
 Peru 
 AI has appealed to President Alberto Fujimori for a prompt investigation into a bomb attack on Dr Augusto Z&uacute;&ntilde;iga opened a letter bomb which blew off his left hand and forearm. 
 At the time, Dr. Z&uacute;&ntilde;iga was working on the case of student Ernesto Castillo P&aacute;ez, who &bquo;disappeared&equo; after he was reportedly detained by police on 21 October 1990 in Lima. 
 The case received wide publicity when a habeas corpus petition was upheld by two lower courts. 
 However, the Supreme Court subsequently annulled the habeas corpus on grounds of procedural  irregularites . 
 Dr. Z&uacute;&ntilde;iga was warned that the police might seek reprisals against him, but although he informed the authorities of this, novo specific measures of protection were apparently offered to him.   
 ASIA 
 People's Republic of China 
 As AI launched a campaign in March 1991 against the extensive use of the death penalty in China, a nationwide drive to crack down on crime continued unabated. 
 AI has recorded a bout 100 death sentences each month since the beginning of 1991. 
 During 1990 AI recorded almost 1,000 death sentences, of which at least 750 resulted in executions. 
 In the official press, Chinese politicians, as well as senior members of the judiciary, have repeatedly urged that instructions to &bquo;punish criminals heavily and rapidly&equo; be strictly adhered to. 
 Some prisoners who would not normally have received the death sentence may have fallen victim to political interference in the judicial process. 
 Increased official emphasis on speedy investigation and sentencing in death penalty cases is likely to have further undermined the rights of defendants to a fair trial. 
 On 14 March 24-year-old Han Weijun was executed. 
 He had first been found guilty of setting fire to an armoured personnel carrier commandeered by students and a car during the 19898 pro-democracy demonstrations in Beijing. 
 His was the first reported execution in several months for an offence related to the &bquo;counter-revolutionary rebellion&equo;. 
 A court notice reported the economic loss of the two vehicles, but did not mention any military casualties. 
 The death penalty is routinely used in China for serious economic crimes which involve no personal violence. 
 Afghanistan 
 Hundreds of Afghan political prisoners have reportedly been held without charge or trial for up to nine years in interrogation centres and segregated prison blocks operated by the Ministry of State Security. 
 In a recent report, AI called on the Afghan Government to end the torture and long-term detention without trial of political prisoners. 
 The detainees include individuals suspected of involvement in armed opposition or non-violent anti-government activity. 
 They are initially held in isolation cells for periods lasting as long as several months. 
 During their isolation, they are reportedly denied access to legal counsel and family visits and are at risk of systematic torture and ill-treatment. 
 Sri Lanka 
 Two AI delegates were recently invited as guest speakers to a week-long conference in Colombo on trade unions and human rights. 
 The delegates met several senior government officials and discussed possibilities for future access by AI to Sri Lanka. 
 AI was last permitted access to the country in 1982. 
 Among those the delegates met were the Adviser to the President on International Affairs, the Secretary to the Ministry of Defence, the Inspector General of Police, and the Commissioner General of Rehabilitation. 
 The government subsequently announced to the press that &bquo;a research visit to Sri Lanka would be considered favourably if a formal request were made&equo; by AI. 
 Taiwan 
 In the April/May letter writing campaign, there was an error in the appeal on behalf of Taiwanese prisoner Huang Hua. 
 As there is no Embassy of Taiwan in the UK, please do not copy any appeals to another embassy, as proposed on the letter writing page. 
 We apologise sincerely for this clerical error, and regret the confusion and inconvenience it has caused. 
 Indonesia 
 More than 130 political prisoners from Irian Jaya are currently serving lengthy prison terms for advocating the province's independence from Indonesia. 
 Most have been convicted since 1988 under Indonesia's sweeping Anti-Subversion Law, accused of attempting to establish an independent state of &bquo;West Papua&equo;. 
 Amnesty International believes that their trials were unfair. 
 The organization has already adopted two of the prisoners as prisoners of conscience and believes that some 80 others may be POCs. 
 Among the possible prisoners of conscience are 37 people sentenced to up to 20 years' imprisonment for their involvement in a peaceful flag-raising ceremony in the town of Jayapura on 14 December 1988. 
 A woman alleged to have sewn the flag was sentenced to eight years in prison and her husband, who led the ceremony, to 20 years. 
 In 1990 a police officer accused of distributing copies of a patriotic song to high-school students was sentenced to 13 years' imprisonment by a military court. 
 Four men who allegedly planned demonstrations in December 1989 to commemorate the 1988 flag-raising, were sentenced to terms of between six and 12 years. 
 In addition to imprisonment, those believed to have advocated Irian Jaya's independence, whether through peaceful or violent means, continue to be at risk of torture, ill-treatment, &bquo;disappearance&equo;, and extrajudicial execution by Indonesian security forces. 
 This pattern of human rights violations is described in a recent AI report, Indonesia: Continuing Human Rights Violations in Irian Jaya, available from the British Section office.  
 EUROPE 
 UN Commission on Human Rights 
 After two years of taking no action in response to reports of grave and widespread violations in Iraq, the Commission on Human Rights has appointed a Special Rapporteur to investigate the human rights situation there; another special Rapporteur has been appointed to examine violations committed by Iraqi forces in occupied Kuwait. 
 The Commission also took a stronger stand in respect of two other countries on its agenda: Cuba will not come under special scrutiny by a representative of the UN Secretary-General and the Expert on Equatorial Guinea, a country which receives assistance under the UN Advisory Services Program, has been requested to study the human rights situation there. 
 Another significant development to emerge from the latest session of the Commission, held in March 1991, was its decision to establish a Working Group on arbitrary detention. 
 This will be the first UN mechanism with a clear mandate to examine cases of detained prisoners of conscience anywhere in the world. 
 It will fill an important gap in the framework of protection established by the Commission's existing &bquo;theme mechanisms&equo; on &bquo;disappearances&equo;, torture and summary or arbitrary executions. 
 However, it was disappointing that a new international instrument on &bquo;disappearances&equo; was held over for further study. 
 Another new instrument that the Commission will be considering next year is a revised draft of the Optional Protocol to the UN Convention against Torture, which would set up an international system of visits to places of detention, aimed at preventing torture and ill-treatment. 
 The Commission kept under review the human rights situation in Afghanistan, Romania, El Salvador and Iran but sent a clear signal that it may terminate special scrutiny of the latter two countries at its next session. 
 It decided to transfer Haiti to the Advisory Services Program and also to keep Guatemala under this program for a further year despite AI's appeals for stronger measures. 
 Turkey 
 A new &bquo;Anti-Terror Law&equo;, which combines a number of new provisions for the investigation and trial of persons suspected of acts of political violence or association with violent political opposition groups, was approved by President Ozal on 17 April. 
 This law includes amendments to the penal code and the conditional release of approximately 38,000 prisoners. 
 Most of those released are non-political prisoners convicted of criminal offences, but a number of prisoners of conscience will also be released. 
 Many political prisoners who had been sentenced to death or life imprisonment after unfair trials following the 1980 coup will continue to serve sentences of up to 20 years. 
 Amnesty warmly welcomed the release of prisoners of conscience and the repeal of certain articles, but has urged that the legislation be extended to include reform or repeal of further articles of the Turkish Penal Code, under which POCs may be held. 
 The new law may in fact increase the already serious risk of torture facing political detainees. 
 Suspected torturers are permitted under the new law to continue to interrogate detainees while charges against them are outstanding. 
 Police officers who have taken statements from detainees will also be exempted from being questioned in court unless they agree to do so, making it difficult for detainees to challenge the validity of any confessions made under torture. 
 There has been a marked increase in reports of deaths as a result of torture in Turkish police stations. 
 Nine such cases have been reported to AI since 25 November 1990. 
 USSR 
 Statistics on the death penalty in the USSR have been made public for the first time since 1934. 
 Figures on its use from 1985 to 1989 were announced by the Minister of Justice at a press conference on 16 January 1991. 
 These show a progressive decrease in death sentences from 770 in 1985, of which 20 were commuted, to 271 in 1988 with 72 commutations. 
 The 1989 figures indicate a reversal of this trend with 276 death  setences  passed and a sharp reduction of commutations to 23. 
 The 1990 figures, provided more recently by the Ministry of Justice, show a dramatic increase to 447 death sentences, mostly for murder under aggravating circumstances. 
 The same source reports that 190 executions took place last year. 
 AI welcomes the publication of statistics on the death penalty, as well as current proposals to limit its scope. 
 However, it remains concerned that there has been no stay on sentences or executions pending the review of existing legislation.  
 15 villagers including three minors were killed and 19 others, including several children, wounded when soldiers opened fire on a crowd of unarmed people on 2/12/90. 
 Well-known broadcaster and journalist Richard de Zoysa was abducted and murdered in February 1990. 
 See pp 24&ndash;25 
 Free at last: after 16 years of wrongful imprisonment the &bquo;Birmingham Six&equo; enjoy their first taste of freedom. 
 Pictured above with UK parliamentarian Chris Mullin (centre) who campaigned for their release, from left to right are John Walker, Patrick Hill, Hugh Callaghan, Richard McIlkenny, Gerard Hunter and William Power. 
 One of many arrests that occurred on Labour Day when police dispersed a peaceful rally in Istanbul, May 1988. 
 CLASSIFIED ADS AI member and stamp collector offers free stamp packets (limited number) to AI groups for sale at their book sales, stalls, etc. 
 SAE appreciated.  
 MIDDLE EAST 
 Iraq 
 In April AI appealed to the Iraqi Government in the strongest possible terms to put an immediate end to the mass deliberate killing of unarmed civilians and the summary execution of government opponents and their suspected supporters. 
 The appeal followed numerous reports that Iraqi Government forces were committing these and other human rights violations following the recapture of cities and town in the northern Kurdish and southern Shi'a areas of the country. 
 Many Kurds and Arab Shi'a Muslims were reportedly deliberately killed by Iraqi forces as they fled to Iran, Turkey and the then US-occupied region of southern Iraq. 
 In its appeal AI also expressed dismay at reports that Iraqi Kurds who returned to Arbil in northern Iraq following a government announcement of an amnesty for Kurds on 5 April were arbitrarily arrested, summarily executed or subjected to forms of cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment. 
 AI also sent urgent appeals to the governments of the United States, Kuwait and Saudi Arabia in April, urging them to ensure that Iraqi refugees then under the control of United States-led coalition forces were guaranteed effective and durable protection against human rights violations by Iraqi Government forces. 
 AI stated that it strongly feared that the refugee population would be at risk of certain torture, &bquo;disappearance&equo; or execution if returned to Iraqi Government control. 
 Kuwait 
 A public appeal to the Emir of Kuwait to intervene personally to end the wave of arbitrary arrests, torture and killings in the country since the withdrawal of Iraqi forces, was issued on 19 April by Amnesty International. 
 Reporting back after a two-week visit to Kuwait, an AI fact-finding team said scores of victims had been killed and hundreds more had been arbitrarily arrested, many brutally tortured by Kuwaiti armed forces and members of &bquo;resistance&equo; groups since 26 February. 
 On the highly publicized issue in AI's December report of the baby deaths, Amnesty said that although its team was shown alleged mass graves of babies, it was not established how they had died and the team found no reliable evidence that Iraqi forces had caused the deaths of babies by removing them or ordering their removal from incubators. 
 The plight of some 600 detainees acknowledged by the authorities was also giving cause for concern. 
 They had been held in the Military Prison outside Kuwait City, some for over a month, reportedly in deplorable conditions. 
 Medical care was virtually non-existent, food and water often withheld, and torture rife. 
 The authorities were not granting full access to detainees by independent bodies, such as the International committee of the Red Cross, and relatives were not being informed of detainees' whereabouts. 
 As a result, the fate of many victims remained unknown. 
 Tunisia 
 Dozens of people are reported to have been tortured while held incommunicado in prolonged garde &agrave; vue detention by the Tunisian police since January 1991. 
 Garde &agrave; vue detention allows the police to detain suspects for interrogation for a period of up to 10 days. 
 Recent information from former detainees, lawyers and human rights activists indicates that suspected political opponents of the government, including boys under 18, have been detained in garde &agrave; vue well beyond the maximum 10-day period and without obtaining further authorization after four days as required by Tunisian law. 
 AI is concerned that the Tunisian Government, by its failure to investigate allegations of torture brought to its notice, appears to be condoning the use of torture. 
 AI welcomed the formation by the Tunisian Government of an official human rights council on 9 April 1991, although the organization remained concerned at continuing reports of torture and ill-treatment of political detainees in garde &agrave; vue detention. 
 Bahrain 
 On 9 May AI published Bahrain: Violations of human rights . 
 The report describes how in recent years hundreds of political activists or suspected activists, including prisoners of conscience, have been subjected to arbitrary arrest and torture and sentenced after unfair trials. 
 Many are held for months or years in administrative or pretrial detention, usually incommunicado. 
 It is during this time that torture most commonly occurs. 
 Some detainees have been held for as long as seven years without charge or trial. 
 AI has repeatedly called on the Bahraini Government to ratify and implement international human rights treaties as a matter of urgency. 
 Saudi Arabia 
 Salih al-'Azzaz, a prominent writer and journalist, was released uncharged on 4 March. 
 In November 1990 he had been arrested in connection with a protest by women in Riyadh against a ban on women drivers. 
 He was held in solitary confinement in the General Intelligence headquarters in Riyadh and was reportedly tortured. 
 He had previously been arrested in May 1982, when he was editor-in-chief of al-Yawm newspaper, and was held without charge or trial until he was released following an amnesty at the end of 1982.  
 A Kurdish mother and her sick child at Isikveren refugee camp on the Iraq/Turkish border, April 1991. 
 HOMENEWS 
 30 years ago on Trinity Sunday, 28 May 1961, the British Lawyer, Peter Beneson (right) started Amnesty International. 
 This year on Trinity Sunday, a candle-lighting ceremony with music, poetry, banners and balloons was held on the steps of St Martin's-in-the-fields church to mark AI's anniversary. 
 Special Amnesty forget-me-not badges were worn to commemorate all the prisoners on whose behalf Amnest was founded. 
 Joseph Beran (right), former Archbishop of Prague, was one of the eight prisoners featured in the original Observer article. 
 One of Amnesty's earliest releases, in 1964 he came to London to light a candle for Amnesty. 
 Keep the candle burning in the '90s 
 Keep the 30th Anniversary log flying around the country for Amnesty's anniversary. 
 Arnold Rose from Brighton is raising money through being sponsored for a 24-hour pot-throwing marathon. 
 The Lincolnshire County Council recreational services are organising a concert for Amnesty at Lincoln Castle in aid of Amnesty on 17 August. 
 The Ealing Group held a &bquo;Recorder Concert&equo; in a Sloane Square church, raising &pound;265.00. 
 The Flesh It Out Theatre Company from East London are doing a show at the Edinburgh Festival on behalf of Amnesty. 
 MA in human rights 
 A new MA degree in human rights is being offered by the University of Essex. 
 Unique in the UK, and probably in the world, the MA is a one-year course beginning in October 1991. 
 It is intended both for those who want to do practical or legal work for human rights organizations, and for those who would find it an outstanding preparation for research degrees in Law, Philosophy and Politics.  
 Best Cards in the Biz 
 Amnesty has been given Greetings Magazine's &bquo;Best Charity Card of the Year&equo; award. 
 This award was presented to Amnesty International following the decision of an independent panel of judges drawn from members of the public nationwide and chaired by a representative from the greetings card industry. 
 The design itself was commissioned by Trading Officer Craig Methven and painted by Sheila Moxley, who has designed Amnesty's 1992 Human Rights Calendar. 
 Free at last! 
 BBC2 TV &bquo;Prisoners of conscience series Nov/Dec 1990 &mdash; update 
 As in previous years the response to the &bquo;prisoners of Conscience&equo; programmes shown on the BBC in November/December 1990 has been tremendous and effective, and we are still answering 10 enquiries a week about prisoners. 
 In addition we are still receiving enquiries about prisoners featured in the first two  series in 1988 and 1989, and we have recently received a copy of a letter from Alattin Sahin, the Turkish prisoner of conscience in the 1988, which someone has received on his release. 
 The programmes, which this year featured 19 prisoners of conscience or &bquo;disappearances&equo;, received 15,000 phone calls and letters. 
 All those who have written to the prisoners will be pleased to know that Henrick Gjoka from Albania, Reverend Lawford Imunde from Kenya and Ernesto Diaz Rodriguez from Cuba have been released. 
 Hong Song-dam from South Korea has had his prison sentence reduced while Khalid el Kid from Sudan has been moved to Kober Prison, Khartoum, Sudan. 
 If you have had your letters to Dr Nguyen Dan Que from Vietnam returned, could you please send them to Dr Que's brother, Dr Nguyen Quoc-Quan, . 
 From the letters we have been receiving this year it appears that the Jehovah's Witness from Greece Andreas Christodoulou has been passing some of the cards on to his colleagues who are also imprisoned Jehovah's witnesses, who want to correspond with people in the U.K. Fortunately we have someone in the office who has been able to translate their letters. 
 Please continue to write until all the prisoners of conscience in the series are free, or until there have been satisfactory investigations into those who have &bquo;disappeared&equo;.   
 Artists for Rochdale 
 Do you support human rights in Rochdale? 
 You can &mdash; in a positive way &mdash; by helping the Rochdale Group make their Auction of Artists' Work a huge success. 
 The group is inviting artists to contribute paintings, illustrations, sketches &mdash; artwork of all kinds &mdash; to be auctioned off by the Mayor of Rochdale on Saturday 19 October at 7 pm at the Rochdale Art Gallery. 
 All contributions should be framed or mounted on board and deposited with Jill Morgan at the Rochdale Art Gallery from Saturday 12 October 1991. 
 Collection of artwork can be arranged by ringing Trevor Hoyle, on 0706&ndash;843677. 
 Any surplus music? 
 If AI members have any surplus sheet music, would they consider letting George Jackson have it for his stall? 
 The music can be of any sort, of any age, and no matter how tattered or torn. 
 Parcels should be addressed to . 
 The Anniversary Raffle 
 When is an item worth over &pound;60,000???&hellip; when it's a prize in an Amnesty raffle. 
 Thinking ahead to our Christmas raffle and prizes. 
 We have had very generous responses to previous requests to our membership. 
 Can anyone can offer a holiday cottage? 
 Persuade their firm to donate a hi-fi system!, a voucher!, bicycle!, yacht! etc. etc. they will receive a mention on the ticket and publicity material and obviously a warm altruistic glow. 
 Please contact Noreen at the British Section with any possible offer. 
 Solo show in Tewkesbury 
 Eric Taylor's sixth annual Exhibition of Oil Paintings in aid of Amnesty and the Medical Foundation is being held in Tewkesbury Abbey, Gloucestershire, from 19&ndash;26 June inclusive. 
 So far Eric Taylor has raised a magnificent &pound;2,900 by donations and profits. 
 Though supported by the Cheltenham Group, this is an entirely solo effort, and all types of subject are covered. 
 Please support generously! 
 Ex-Services Amnesty Group starts! 
 At a meeting in February, the Ex-Services Group of the British Section of AI was officially launched. 
 Its members will help Amnesty with specialist knowledge of military experience and expertise (in the same way that the Lawyers' Group and the Medical Groups function in their specialist fields). 
 The Group will work on behalf of service and ex-service personnel whose human rights are being abused and will be involved in the development of human rights awareness in armed services training. 
 it has an ex-RAF man as its Secretary and a Major and a Wing Commander among its participants. 
 If you have served in the armed forces and would be willing to assist in the work of this group, or if you can assist with contacts in ex-service organisations like the British Star Association, please write to: .  
 GLOBAL WARNING 
 No matter where in the world human rights violations occur &mdash; from India to Iran, Chile to Czechoslovakia &mdash; Amnesty International is there to warn the world. 
 In this, its 300th anniversary year, its role as human rights watchdog is as vital now as ever it was. 
 By Norma Johnston 
 Santiago, Chile: On a warm autumn evening in 1990 international rock star Sting dances on stage with a group of Chilean mothers and grandmothers of the &bquo;disappeared&equo;. 
 The event, organized by the Chilean Section of Amnesty International, is entitled &bquo;An Embrace of Hope&equo;. 
 Moscow, USSR: At the same time, 12,000 miles away, a delegation from Amnesty's International Secretariat is making plans for a fledgling Moscow Group to participate in the Women in the Front Line campaign. 
 To outsiders, the two events may seem little more than an international organization at work, but for Amnesty members these events are charged with significance. 
 The Cold War was at its height when Peter Benenson, the British lawyer, founded Amnesty, and three decades later it is hard to believe that the Moscow AI Group finally has permission to become part of Soviet life. 
 Similarly, the idea that a human rights concert should be held in the very stadium in Santiago where Allende's officers rounded up thousands of Chileans in 1973, prior to committing gross violations, stretches the powers of credulity. 
 But incredulous, or not, the events happened (millions of television viewers worldwide watched the Chilean concert) and as such they typify the massive changes that Amnesty has undergone in its 30-year history. 
 Sadly, one thing has not changed in 30 years: certain governments of the world still falsely imprison, torture and execute their citizens, regardless of internationally agreed standards that expressly forbid such abuses. 
 Around the world today, more than 100 countries still retain the death penalty, and two out of every three human beings live under governments that use torture and other cruel, inhuman and degrading treatment against them. 
 For this reason the campaigning elements of the organization &mdash; and that includes many of the 80,000 British members who undertake to be active on Amnesty's behalf &mdash; have increased and refined their methods over the years. 
 In practical terms this means that  although letter-writing to governments regarding prisoners continues to be the cornerstone of the campaign work other methods have been introduced to enhance the effectiveness of the hundreds of thousands of letters that Amnesty members write each year. 
 The Regional Action Network illustrates how campaigners have refined their methods. 
 Members working on behalf of a prisoner learn a lot about that country &mdash; its culture and political allegiance for example &mdash; knowledge that is no longer useful when the case is closed. 
 Such knowledge could, however, continue to be useful when used in a regional context, which is what the RANs do, enabling members to react to a wider range of human rights violations in any given region. 
 At group level, the days have gone when three prisoners per group (one from the West, the East and a non-aligned country) were obligatory. 
 Nowadays, impartiality need not be expressed quite so crudely, and a look at any group's case load will show that a balance is always maintained. 
 In the 1961 Observer article that launched Amnesty, Benenson listed the aims of the organization. 
 They included: &bquo;to enlarge the Right of Asylum and help political refugees to find work.&equo; 
 Adherence to this stated principle has never faltered, but other areas of concern took precedence and it was not until the late 1970s that this area of work was developed. 
 In 1985 work on behalf of refugees took its place in the statute of Amnesty. 
 The British Section refugee office has played a leading role in this area of work, processing some 4,000 cases since 1980. 
 The public perception of Amnesty has also changed and this has not happened by accident. 
 For a long time deemed a white, Western organization, the setting up of section sin countries like Tunisia, Algeria and South Korea, are ample illustration of Amnesty's worldwide stature. 
 As a multi-lingual movement the human rights message can be conveyed via dozens of reports, books and audio-visual materials to audiences from Japan to Nigeria. 
 Amnesty is global in name and nature. 
 The very life blood of Amnesty is its research teams &mdash; there are currently 40 based at the International Secretariat in London. 
 Things have changed for them too, says Anne Burley, Head of Europe Region at the IS. 
 &bquo;I joined Amnesty in 1968 when there weren't any teams or even research regions. 
 In those days there was a small core of paid research staff who were responsible for a large number of countries &mdash; if you did the Soviet Union, you were also responsible for Eastern Europe and half of Western Europe as well!&equo; 
 Volunteers worked on research alongside their paid counterparts and Burley recalls the hundreds of Spanish and Portuguese POCs on whose behalf Amnesty worked at that time. 
 Of course, none of the work carried out by Amnesty could continue without money and it is in this respect that sections, particularly the larger sections like the British, have a vital role to play. 
 The annual budget for 1990 was &pound;11 million, which represents only a third of the money raised worldwide on Amnesty's behalf. 
 It excludes the contributions made by individuals who finance the sending of telexes and telegrams as well as the funds required to support national sections. 
 Professional fundraisers utilize the powerful medium of advertising in their national press, an advertisement issued by the British Section in autumn 1990 about Iraq's treatment of Kurds and its human rights record over a decade, was the most successful advertisement ever run by the Section. 
 It recruited 4,000 new members and raised &pound;70,000. 
 Add to this the monies raised by new members the length and breadth of the British Isles who contributed to the Section's annual turnover of &pound;2.25 million with their cultural events, sponsored walks and street collections. 
 From a handful of POCs in the early Sixties, the number of cases taken up by Amnesty now stands at 42,000 of which 38,000 are now closed. 
 Full-scale Amnesty sections are now operational in 44 countries, with active groups in another 16, and a total membership of more than one million spread across 150 countries. 
 The list of laws that have been amended, the treaties that have been ratified, and prisoners' conditions that have been improved is a long one. 
 However, it is not long enough. 
 In the years since 1961, Eastern European dictators have come and gone, moves afoot in South Africa hold hope for the future, and countries abolishing the death penalty are on the increase. 
 Globally however, much work lies ahead. 
 In Benenson's words: &bquo;The gradual change over the last 30 years in the public perception of the value of human life is a measure of Amnesty's influence. 
 But we will not have finished until cruelty, be it killing or torture, is seen as obscene and impermissible.&equo;  
 Above: (top) A historic breakthrough &mdash; Amnesty arrives at the Moscow Book Fair in September 1989; (bottom) Kalkini AI Group, Bangladesh, April 1988. 
 Opposite: A concert crowd in New Delhi, during the Human Rights Now! 
 Campaign in 1988. 
 FREEDOM COME 
 AN UPDATE ON SOME OF THE 92 PRISONERS OF CONSCIENCE FEATURED IN THE LETTER WRITING CAMPAIGN IN 1989 AND 1990 &mdash; 39 ARE NOW FREE! 
 In 1962 AI's first ever journal had good news on its front page. 
 A prisoner of conscience had been freed in Spain. 
 A Christmas card sent to him by an AI member in Switzerland had been returned marked &bquo;Consigned is free&equo;. 
 Since then, every issue of the journal has published appeals for the release of other prisoners of conscience. 
 Many of these prisoners are now free. 
 Some have thanked AI, but we take no credit for anyone's freedom. 
 We know from experience that many factors &mdash; some of which may never be apparent to outside observers &mdash; determine whether a prisoner of conscience is released. 
 Today the terrible injustice done to those prisoners reaches a mass audience. 
 Amnesty sections all over the world include the Prisoner Letter Writing Campaign cases in the magazines and newssheets they publish in many other languages, from Faroe to Banlga. 
 In many countries, regional and national newspapers report on these prisoner cases &mdash; the Slovenian Catholic weekly Druzina , the French national daily Le Monde , and the Pakistani daily The Muslim , to name but a few. 
 Year in, year out, the Prisoner Letter Writing Campaign provides a unique window into the harsh and desperate world of the prisoner of conscience. 
 Hundreds of thousands of people have appealed for their freedom. 
 And the prisoners themselves know that they are not alone, that the world has not forgotten them. 
 The 1990s began with a dramatic upturn of the fortunes of thousands of prisoners of conscience across eastern and central Europe. 
 In Czechoslovakia former prisoner of conscience Vaclav Havel became President of his country. 
 In many of these countries the new respect for human rights was embodied in the repeal or revision of laws used to imprison prisoners of conscience. 
 But there are still prisoners of conscience in Europe, and in every other region of the world. 
 39 of the prisoners featured in the letter writing campaign have been released; about 50 remain in prison. 
 None of these people should ever have been prisoners of conscience. 
 Our task today is to increase the international pressure on behalf of the thousands of prisoners of conscience all over the world, to make tomorrow the day their freedom is restored. 
 Africa 
 Francisco Bonifacio Mba Nguema remains in prison in Equatorial Guinea. 
 He is serving a 20-year sentence imposed in 1988 by a military court which found him guilty of attempting to overthrow the government. 
 Hew was convicted on the basis of confessions he had made under torture and because he had read The Dogs of War , a novel about a coup in an imaginary country widely thought to be based on Equatorial Guinea. 
 In Kenya Harris Okong'o Arara continues to serve a five-year sentence imposed in 1988 under a law which makes it a criminal offence simply to possess literature critical of the government. 
 Mulugetta Mosissa, a former civil servant, remains in detention without trial in Ethiopia. 
 He was arrested in 1980, with hundreds of other members of the Oromo ethnic group who were suspected of links with an Oromo guerilla group. 
 Although many of these detainees were released in 1989, including Mulugetta's wife and son, he is one of 50 still held. 
 The Americas 
 Three Colombian prisoners featured in the Letter Writing Campaign remain &bquo;disappeared&equo;. 
 Dr Alirio de Jes&uacute;s Pedraza Becerra, a 40-year old lawyer and human rights worker, was abducted by eight heavily armed men on the night of 4 July 1990 in Bogot&aacute;. 
 A judicial inquiry has been initiated into his case but to AI's knowledge, no progress has been made. 
 The police deny its agents were present. 
 Tarcisio Medina Charry, a 21-year-old student, &bquo;disappeared&equo; after being arrested in 1988. 
 A judicial investigation into his case ordered the arrest of a member of the national police. 
 However the case was passed to the military courts who revoked the arrest order. 
 The investigation continues. 
 Isidro Caballero, a 33-year-old teacher, &bquo;disappeared&equo; after being detained on 7 February 1989 by an army patrol. 
 A judicial investigation implicated three members of the Caldas Battalion of the army. 
 The Procurator Delegate for the Armed Forces is conducting a separate investigation. 
 Luis Miguel Sol&iacute;s Pajarito was 25 when he &bquo;disappeared&equo; in Guatemala on 3 May 1990. 
 He was a leader of the National Council for the Displaced. 
 Despite assurances from government officials that an investigation is in progress, his whereabouts remain unknown. 
 Elizardo S&aacute;nchez Santa Cruz, President of the Cuban Commission of Human Rights and National Reconciliation (CCDHRN), who was sentenced to two years' imprisonment in 1989 for &bquo;spreading false news with the aim of endangering the prestige or standing of the Cuban state&equo;, is still serving his sentence in Ag&uuml;ica Prison: he is due for release in August 1991. 
 Asia 
 Alexander Warouw and Manan Effendi have been imprisoned in Indonesia since 1965. 
 Both in their 70s, they continue to serve life sentences imposed in connection with an abortive coup in that year which was blamed on the Communist Party of Indonesia (PKI). 
 Although both were linked to the PKI, there is no evidence that either of them had knowledge of the events leading to the coup. 
 Their cases were featured in a British Section Christmas card campaign in 1990 and they received 1,704 cards as a result of the appeal. 
 In early 1991 AI received a letter directly from the two men. 
 They had copied out the names and addresses of everyone who wrote to them and enclosed the list with a message of thanks and good wishes, asking that it be sent on. 
 Also in Indonesia, Agil Riyanto bin Darmowiyoto, a law student, continues to serve a 15-year sentence imposed for  subversion in 1987. 
 He is one of a group of seven young Muslim activists in Brebes, Central Java, convicted on charges arising from their involvement in Muslim groups known as usroh , aiming to deepen awareness of Islamic teachings. 
 Agil Riyanto bin Darmowiyoto is serving his sentence in an island prison, far away from his home and family. 
 Another of the seven students, 20-year-old Wahyudi, a prisoner featured in the April/May 1989 issue, is still serving a seven-year sentence in Cilacap, Central Java. 
 Kayathiri Vino Sangaralinigam was 10 years old when she was arrested in Jaffna District, Sri Lanka, in 1987 with her mother and two older sisters. 
 They all &bquo;disappeared&equo; after being taken into custody by members of the Indian Peace Keeping Force. 
 No investigation is known to have been carried out either by the Indian or Sri Lankan authorities. 
 Two prisoners of conscience in Laos have been held for over 15 years for &bquo;re-education&equo;. 
 Tiao Sisoumang Sisaleumsak and Houmphanh Norasing, both detained since 1975, are among 33 detainees still held in Laos' northeastern province of Houa Phanh. 
 Their living conditions are harsh with poor provision of housing, food and medicines. 
 The South Korean authorities wrote to AI in response to its appeals for imprisoned artist Hong Song-dam and publisher Chang Ui-gyun. 
 The authorities said that Hong Song-dam was not imprisoned merely for sending his paintings to North Korea and books to Koreans in Germany, but because his paintings and contributions to a magazine Art Movement  were aimed at promoting a Marxist-Leninist revolution. 
 In September 1990 the Supreme Court dismissed the charges of espionage and returned the case to a lower court. 
 In January 1991 Hong Song-dam was sentenced to three years' imprisonment for producing material benefiting North Korea. 
 Chang Ui-gyun continues to serve an eight-year sentence for espionage. 
 The authorities denied that his arrest in 1987 was solely because he had met pro-North Korean people in Japan and claimed that he had acted on North Korean orders to collect documents on South Korean opposition groups, and to infiltrate dissent groups in order to create social unrest. 
 They also stated that he had received funds from North Korea. 
 AI had reviewed these accusations, but had found them unsubstantiated. 
 Father Thadeus Nguyen Van Ly, a Roman Catholic priest in Viet Nam, was arrested in May 1983 after trying to organize an unauthorized pilgrimage. 
 In December 1983 he was sentenced to 10 years' imprisonment for &bquo;opposing the revolution&equo;. 
 He remains detained at Camp &bquo;Three Stars&equo; in Ha Nam Ninh province. 
 Aung Din, a 26-year-old student leader, was arrested by the martial law authorities in Myanmar on 24 April 1989. 
 AI has received reports that he was sentenced to four years' imprisonment after an unfair trial by a military tribunal. 
 Naya Min, a lawyer in his 40s, was also arrested under martial law in Myanmar. 
 He continues to serve a 14-year sentence because of reports he sent to the British Broadcasting Corporation and for &bquo;possession of anti-government literature&equo;. 
 The four prisoners from China featured in the Letter Writing Campaign in 1989 and 1990 are still in prison. 
 Zhang Jingsheng was sentenced to 13 years' imprisonment in December 1989 for &bquo;counter-revolutionary&equo; crimes during the 1989 pro-democracy demonstrations. 
 Xiao Bin, a 42-year-old worker from Dalian, is serving a 10-year sentence for &bquo;counter-revolutionary incitement&equo; during the pro-democracy demonstrations. 
 Song Yude, a 34-year-old Protestant evangelist, was sentenced to eight years' imprisonment in 1986 for carrying out unofficial religious activities. 
 In Tibet Ngawang Buchung, a monk from the Drepung Monastery in Lhasa, is still serving a 19-year sentence imposed at a mass sentencing rally in November 1989. 
 Ngawang Buchung was sentenced to long terms of imprisonment for activities in support of Tibetan independence, which included circulating Tibetan translations of the Universal Declaration of  Human Rights. 
 In the Philippines, there have been some encouraging developments in the case of Zosimo Alpino. 
 He was one of 25 farmers arrested in November 1987 and accused of membership of the New People's Army (NPA), the armed wing of the outlawed Communist Party. 
 Zosimo Alpino was released on bail on 13 December 1990. 
 The previous May, 13 of his co-defendants were acquitted and released unconditionally on the grounds that there was insufficient evidence for prosecution. 
 Middle East 
 Abdul-'Aziz al-Faris, &bquo;Ali Al-Lail, Salah Nisfan, Hussein Subait and Hatim al-Saddiq are Shi'a Muslims in Saudi Arabia. 
 AI believes they are held because they opposed the government's policy towards the Shi'a community. 
 Three Moroccan prisoners of conscience remain in prison. 
 Ali Idrissi Kaitouni was given a 15-year sentence for writing poems about social injustice and political oppression in Morocco, deemed by the state to constitute a crime against internal security. 
 Mohamed Srifi, a literature student, was sentenced in 1977 to 30 years&equo; imprisonment for advocating that Morocco become a socialist republic. 
 Assistant teacher Habib Ben Malek was sentenced in the same trial in 1977 to 20 years' imprisonment. 
 They are all serving their sentences in Kenitra Central Prison. 
 Among the hundreds of those held without charge or trial in Syria are the following who have appeared in the Letter Writing Campaign: Hakem Sultan al-Faiz, a 61-year-old Jordanian national and former member of the National Command of the Arab Socialist Ba'th Party, who has been held for almost 20 years; Ahmad &bquo;Abd al-Rau'uf Roummou, a 55-year-old teacher, arrested in 1975; Muhammad Nabil Salem, an engineer, arrested in the wake of a one-day national strike in 1980 and Mahmud Jalbut, a Palestinian arrested in 1980. 
 AI has received no new information about six members of the Islamic Liberation Party imprisoned in Libya since 1973 for belonging to an illegal organization. 
 &bquo;Ali Muhammad al-Akrami, al-Ajili Muhammad &bquo;Abdul Rahman al-Ashari, &bquo;Ali Muhammad al-Qajji, Salih Omar al-Qasbi, Muhammad al-Saadiq al-Tarhouni and &bquo;Abdul Qadir Muhammad al-Ya'qubi are believed to be in Abu Salim Prison in Tripoli, although AI received reports that &bquo;Abdul Qadir Muhammad al-Ya'qubi had died at the end of 1988. 
 In Iran Marian Firouz, a writer and translator in her mid-70s, has remained imprisoned since 1983 for her non-violent political activities. 
 Ali Ardalan, a retired civil servant in his mid 70s arrested in June 1990, remains in prison and there is growing concern over his ill-health. 
 His &bquo;crime&equo; was to sign an open letter to President Rafsanjani criticizing government failures to uphold rights and freedoms guaranteed by the constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran. 
 Zikri Nafkhosh Mustafa, Nabi Muhammad Shukr, Jabbar Rashid Shifki and Ja'far Tamar Mahmud are four of 315 Kurdish children and youths who &bquo;disappeared&equo; after being arrested in Iraq in August 1983. 
 Appeals on their behalf have been suspended because of the current situation in Iraq. 
 Europe 
 Daniel, Panayiotis and Pavlos Xidis, three Jehovah's Witnesses, are still serving four-year sentences in Greece for refusing to perform military service. 
 They are not due for release until 1992, and are among some 400 young men held in Greek prisons for their refusal on religious grounds to perform military service. 
 FREE IN AFRICA 
 Kwame Karikari, Ghana: released December 1988.  
 Oumarou Aman, Cameroon: released from labour camp in January 1991 after being held for more than six years without charge or trial. 
 Thoza Khonje, Malawi: released February 1991, having been detained for two years after making remarks which were interpreted as critical of the Life President. 
 Dr George Mtafu, Malawi: released January 1991. 
 He is Malawi's only neuro-surgeon. 
 FREE IN EUROPE 
 Bohdan Klymchak, USSR: pardoned and released November 1990. 
 He no longer wishes to emigrate and is planning to write his memoirs. 
 Ismail Mehmedov Hyuseyinov, Bulgaria: released from exile, May 1989. 
 FREE IN THE AMERICAS 
 Manuel Gonz&aacute;lez and Lidia Gonz&aacute;lez Garc&iacute;a, Cuba: released on expiry of their sentences, Manuel in January 1990 and Lidia in November 1989. 
 FREE IN ASIA 
 Baha bin Mohamed, Brunei: released January 1990 after swearing an oath of allegiance to the Sultan, the Government, and the laws of the state of Brunei Darussalam. 
 Vincent Cheng and Two Sho Lung, Singapore: conditionally released in June 1990. 
 FREE IN THE MIDDLE EAST 
 Photos, opposite page: (top row) Mahamat Abdoulaye; Ismail Mehmedov Hyuseyinov with his wife; Mihai (Creanga; (middle row) Kevin De Souza and friend; Zikri Nafkhosh; Ilkere Demir and his daughter Sinem; (bottom row) Ladji Traor&eacute;; Miram Abi Cobas Nunez; Daniel Kokkalis. 
 Amos Masondo, detained without trial from August 1986 to February 1989. 
 He was finally released on 19 October 1989. 
 DON'T FORGET TO WRITE 
 THE CRIMES THAT GOVERNMENTS COMMIT ARE AN OUTRAGE AGAINST ALL HUMANITY. 
 BUT EVERY DAY WE HEAR THE SAME EXCUSES FROM GOVERNMENTS. 
 THE VICTIMS DESERVE IT. 
 THE END JUSTIFIES THE MEANS. 
 MIND YOUR OWN BUSINESS. 
 TWO OUT OF EVERY THREE GOVERNMENTS STILL TORTURE THEIR OWN PEOPLE. 
 Amnesty International does not want to hear any more excuses, from governments or from anybody else. 
 The horrors must be stopped everywhere once and for all. 
 Human rights can be won &mdash; even against overwhelming odds. 
 We have seen it happen. 
 Change is possible. 
 Amnesty International is launching its 30th Anniversary appeal for 30 prisoner cases around the world in 1991. 
 Tens of thousands of Amnesty members and supporters in over 100 countries will be writing letters to governments about these particular cases. 
 Out of the list we have selected the following five cases for appeals by members of the British Section. 
 Please write courteous letters to the heads of the governments indicated &mdash; and let us know of any replies that you receive. 
 MOROCCO 
 MOHAMED SRIFI 
 Sentenced to 30 years for his peaceful political views 
 Write to:  
 Tell the King that you are concerned about the case of Mohamed Srifi, currently in Kenitra Central Prison, Casablanca, who was arrested in 1974, tortured, brought to trial in 1977 and jailed for 30 years after a blatantly unfair trial. 
 He was accused of calling for the violent overthrow of the monarchy. 
 Srifi was a member of a banned left wing group Ila'l-Amam (Forward). 
 Tell the King that Mohamed Srifi's only crime seems to have been the expression of his peaceful political views. 
 Ask that he is released immediately. 
 MALAWI 
 VERA CHIRWA 
 Jailed for believing that her country should be run differently. 
 Write to:  
 Vera Chirwa and her husband Orton are British-trained lawyers, who played a leading role in the struggle for Malawi's independence in 1964. 
 They went to Tanzania for 17 years following Orton's sacking as a cabinet minister after a dispute with the President, and lived there for 17 years. 
 Orton Chirwa formed an opposition party in exile. 
 The couple returned to Malawi in 1981. 
 The authorities claim they entered to try and overthrow the government. 
 The Chirwas say they came to see a sick relative. 
 They were tried, convicted of treason and sentenced to death, later commuted to life imprisonment. 
 Tell the President that you have read about their case, that their trial was unfair &mdash; even the Appeal Court agrees on this &mdash; and ask that they are released immediately. 
 PHILIPPINES 
 MARIA NONNA SANTA CLARA 
 &bquo;Disappeared&equo; with a colleague while  
 working for a community organization. 
 Write to:  
 Draw her attention to the case of ecumenical community worker Maria N. Santa Clara and her colleague Angelina Llenarasas who were arrested by men in plain clothes in a village near Naga City on 26 April 1989. 
 Maria was last seen shouting for help inside a military jeep that evening. 
 Her family heard she had been taken to the Regional Command Military camp in Legaspi City. 
 She has not been seen since. 
 Members of her family have received death threats. 
 Ask the President for prompt government action to establish her whereabouts, and an independent enquiry into the &bquo;disappearances&equo; and the death threats. 
 CHINA 
 WANG XIZHE 
 Jailed since 1981 for advocating democracy 
 Write to:  
 Wang Xizhe, a factory worker from Guangzhou, was an activist in the pro-democracy movement in China who helped to write and put up a 100-metre newspaper wall in his city in 1974 which attracted worldwide interest. 
 He was arrested and jailed for two years in 1977. 
 In April 1981 he was again arrested for articles he had written in association with democracy activist Xu Wenli, tried in May 1982 and sent to prison. 
 Xishe's wife is allowed to see him for 45 minutes twice a year. 
 Tell the President that you have not forgotten about Wang Xizhe and other Pro-Democracy Movement activists who are still jail for the peaceful exercise of their right to freedom of expression. 
 Ask that they are released immediately. 
 ISRAEL 
 &bquo;ABD AL-RU'UF GHABIN 
 Reported being tortured 
 Please write to:  
 Bookshop owner Abd Al &mdash; Ru'uf was arrested by Israeli security forces in the Beach Refugee Camp in August 1990. 
 He was accused of distributing leaflets for an outlawed Palestinian organization, the PLFP, which he denies. 
 He was taken to the Interrogation wing of Gaza Prison. 
 He was denied access to a lawyer for over three weeks. 
 He stated that during this period he was interrogated and beaten on a daily basis. 
 He was denied sleep for five days on end. 
 His hands were manacled behind his back except when he ate or slept. 
 Tell the President that you have read about Abd Al-Ru'uf's allegation that he was tortured, and about his lawyer's complaint. 
 Ask for this claim to be investigated, and find out whether anyone has been found responsible and brought to justice.  
 PRISONER LETTER WRITING CAMPAIGN 
 Each of the people whose story follows is a prisoner of conscience. 
 Each has been arrested because of his or her religious or political beliefs, colour, sex, ethnic origin or language. 
 None has used or advocated violence. 
 Their continuing detention is a violation of the United National Universal Declaration of Human Rights. 
 International appeals can help to secure the release of these prisoners or to improve their detention conditions. 
 In the prisoners' case, letters to the authorities should be worded carefully and courteously. 
 You should stress that your concern for human rights is not in any way politically partisan. 
 In no circumstances should communications be sent to the prisoner. 
 TUNISIA 
 Hamadi Jebali: a 51-year-old newspaper editor from Sousse, he was sentenced by the military court in Tunis on 31 January 1991 to one year's imprisonment for publishing an article calling for the abolition of military courts. 
 The article, entitled &bquo;When will military courts, serving as special courts, be abolished?&equo; and written by a Tunisian lawyer, was published in 27 October 1990 in Al-Fajr (Dawn), the official newspaper of the non-recognized Islamic group Hizb al-Nahda (Renaissance). 
 Hamadi Jebali was charged with defamation of a judicial institution under the Tunisian Press Code, under which prior authorization by the Ministry of Interior is required to publish any newspaper or periodical. 
 The Press Code further requires that the first printed copy of each issue be submitted to the Ministry of Interior which can then intervene to stop distribution. 
 The issue of Al-Fajr in which the article appeared was apparently approved by the Ministry of Interior. 
 However, the Ministry of Defence decided to prosecute Hamadi Jebali. 
 The Tunisian authorities ordered the newspaper Al-Fajr to close until further notice on 8 February 1991. 
 Hamadi Jebali's sentence was confirmed on 6 March 1991 by the Cassation court. 
 This is the only court of appeal for cases tried by the military court, and looks only at points of law and not at facts and findings, thus providing a restricted appeal. 
 In October 1990, Hamadi Jebali, who is a member of the executive council of Hizb al-Nahda, had received a six month's suspended sentence and a fine of 1500 dinars for publishing an article entitled &bquo;The people of the State or the State of the people?&equo; in Al-Fajr in June 1990. 
 This sentence may be added to the new one-year term. 
 Please send courteous letters appealing for his immediate and unconditional release to:  
 MOROCCO 
 Mohamed Abbad: a 37-year-old student and ex-president of the Union Nationale des Etudiants Marocains (UNEM), National Union of Moroccan Students, he is serving a 15-year prison sentence in Safi Prison. 
 Mohamed Abbad is one of 31 people tried in May 1984 in Marrakech following demonstrations in January 1984 against price rises and the imposition of an examination fee for the baccalaureate examination. 
 They were reportedly arrested without warrant several days after the demonstrations, held incommunicado and tortured in garde &agrave; vue detention. 
 Mohamed Abbad was sentenced to 15 years' imprisonment on charges including conspiracy to overthrow the government and possessing leaflets aimed at disturbing internal security. 
 The prosecution's evidence consisted of statements allegedly extracted under torture, and confiscated literature. 
 He denied all the charges against him except possession of the literature which he said was either on sale in public bookstores or did not advocate violence. 
 Mohamed Abbad remains in prison with 17 of the original 31. 
 He was originally held in Safi Prison, where he developed diabetes in 1988, but was then transferred to Marrakech where his family lives, and so could visit him regularly and provide him with the food necessary for his diabetic diet. 
 On 26 March 1991 he was returned to Safi Prison and in protest he began a hunger-strike which resulted in his falling into a coma, due to his illness, a few days later. 
 He is now held in hospital in Safi. 
 Please send courteous appealing for his release, if possible in French or Arabic to:   
 PEOPLE'S REPUBLIC OF CHINA 
 People's Republic of China Father Jin Dechen: the 71-year-old Catholic Vicar-General of Nanyang diocese, Henan Province, he was sentenced in July 1982 to 15 years' imprisonment for &bquo;counterrevolutionary&equo; offences. 
 Fr Jin was first arrested in the late 1950s, when many Catholics were detained for proclaiming their loyalty to the Vatican. 
 The detentions followed the formation of an official Patriotic Catholic Association (PCA), independent of the Church of Rome, intended to bring Catholic affairs under the control of the Chinese Government. 
 Fr Jin was released in 1973, but kept under strict surveillance. 
 He was arrested again in December 1981. 
 As well as maintaining his allegiance to Rome, Fr Jin is reported to have spoken out against government policies on contraception and abortion. 
 The authorities are reportedly prepared to release Fr Jin if he appeals for clemency on grounds such as ill-health. 
 Fr Jin has apparently refused &mdash; he is in good health despite his age &mdash; and is not prepared to admit to any criminal activity to secure his release. 
 He is currently held at the No. 3 provincial prison at Yuxian in Henan. 
 Please write courteous letters appealing for Fr Jin Dechen's release to:  
 CUBA 
 Orlando Azcu&eacute; Rodriguez: a 33-year-old cigar factory technician, he is serving a three-year sentence for advocating free elections. 
 Orlando Azcu&eacute; Rodriguez was arrested on 5 April 1990 in Havana and brought to trial on 12 October on charges of making &bquo;enemy propaganda&equo;. 
 He was found guilty and sentenced to three years' imprisonment. 
 Orlando Azcu&eacute; was one of 12 political prisoners in Combinado del Este Prison in Havana who signed a letter dated 1 January 1991, calling for peaceful political change and respect for human rights, that was smuggled out of the prison. 
 The 12 also refused to wear their prison uniform. 
 As a result, they were transferred to different prisons. 
 Orlando Azcu&eacute; and two others were taken to &bquo;Kilo 7&equo; Maximum Security Prison in Camaguey where, on 17 January, they went on hunger-strike. 
 They were said to have been forcibly dressed in the prison uniform and held for at least 17 days with their arms chained to the cell bars to prevent them from removing the uniform. 
 Orlando Azcu&eacute; was also said to have been beaten by prison guards on at least three occasions. 
 In early February he was transferred to Pinar del R&iacute;o Provincial Prison after agreeing to give up his protest and end his hunger-strike. 
 However, he again refused to wear his uniform and was forcibly dressed and handcuffed to the cell bars. 
 On 6 March he was transferred to the prison infirmary suffering from skin problems and a dramatic fall in his blood sugar level resulting from the earlier hunger-strike. 
 As of mid-April, he remained in the infirmary. 
 Please send appeals requesting his immediate and unconditional release to:  
 YUGOSLAVIA 
 Nijazi Beqa: an ethnic Albanian from Kosovo, aged 29, he is serving a four-year prison sentence in Dubrav prison near Istok. 
 Nijazi Beqa, a student of physics, married with one child, was one of 10 ethnic Albanians from the area of Urosevac in Kosovo arrested in September 1988. 
 They were charged with having formed a &bquo;hostile&equo; organization aimed at securing republic status for Kosovo province. 
 Kosovo, a province of the Yugoslav Republic of Serbia, borders on Albania and most of its population are ethnic Albanians. 
 Nijazi Beqa and his co-defendants were accused of having joined an illegal organization, of having distributed &bquo;hostile propaganda materials&equo; and of organizing petitions of a &bquo;hostile&equo; nature to officials in and outside Yugoslavia. 
 At their trial in Pristina in February 1989, all were found guilty and sentenced to imprisonment. 
 The Yugoslav federal criminal law was changed in 1990 and many people convicted for similar non-violent political activity were released. 
 It is reported that on 22 March Nijazi Beqa and five other political prisoners there went on a hungers-strike against their conditions. 
 Please write appealing for the immediate and unconditional release of Nijazi Beqa to:  
 CAMEROON 
 Olivier Nwaha Binya'a: a Jehovah's Witness, he has been detained without charge or trial since May 2984 because of his religious beliefs. 
 Olivier Nwaha Binya'a appears to be held in indefinite administrative detention without any opportunity to challenge his imprisonment. 
 A 1970 presidential decree banning the movement was apparently prompted by the mass abstention by Jehovah's Witnesses from voting in a presidential election. 
 Since 1970 hundreds of Jehovah's Witnesses have been detained without charge or trial for up to five years. 
 In 1983 AI learned of the release of a group of Jehovah's Witnesses who had been held without trial since 1978. 
 In December 1984 at least 80 Jehovah's Witnesses were arrested in Limb&eacute;, southwest Cameroon, after holding an unauthorized religious meeting. 
  which is used mainly f or political prisoners and others held in administrative detention. 
 His health has deteriorated; the prison diet is poor and medical treatment inadequate. 
 Please send courteous letters appealing for his immediate release to:   
 RELEASED! 
 TEAM WORK 
 FINDING THE FACTS 
 HOW DOES AMNESTY SET ABOUT ESTABLISHING WHETHER A PRISONER IS INDEED A PRISONER OF CONSCIENCE? 
 WHAT ARE OUR SOURCES OF INFORMATION? 
 BY MICHAEL CROWLEY 
 Governments, as a rule, do not publicize their human rights violations. 
 On the contrary, using the tools of censorship, intimidation, disinformation and propaganda, they surround them with walls of silence and lies. 
 Amnesty's job is to breach these walls, to discover the truth within, and then to act. 
 The immense task of gathering, analysing and confirming allegations of human rights violations from around the world falls to the Research Department at the International Secretariat, Amnesty's headquarters in London. 
 &bquo;We are obviously not there when someone is being tortured or killed. 
 When we hear of such cases, we investigate and draw on as many sources as possible to find out what happened&hellip; 
 In one sense it's very much like good investigative journalism,&equo; explains Malcolm Smart, Head of Research at the IS. 
 The information comes to the IS through myriad channels, some of them formal &mdash; over 1,100 newspapers, journals, government bulletins and transcripts of radio broadcasts are sifted &mdash; and others that are less predictable. 
 The plight of an Argentinian clerk, Perico Rodriguez, imprisoned and tortured because of his criticisms of the military government, was brought to Amnesty's attention by an English couple who had previously befriended Rodriguez two  years earlier when they were hitch-hiking across Argentina. 
 Each Amnesty member participating in letter-writing actions and each local group involved in adopting or investigating a prisoner case is a researcher of potential new information: as part of their campaign to free Sudanese POC Bashir Abdelrahim, members of the Leamington and Kenilworth group wrote to the Prison Commander at Shalla Prison, where Bashir was held, in the remote Western Sudan. 
 No reply was received but the group later heard that Bashir had been released. 
 Time passed. 
 Then earlier this year the group received a reply from another prisoner at Shalla who had been given their letter to Bashir by mistake. 
 AI discovered from his letter the appalling living conditions at Shalla, including a water shortage and rampant diseases. 
 The letter-writer is an orthopaedic surgeon who was taken off a plane as he was about to make a short visit to the UK where he had been a post-graduate student. 
 This was in September 1989 and he has been in prison since. 
 He enclosed a list of the 28 political prisoners still at the prison. 
 A vital source of first hand information is generated by the many missions and research trips Amnesty sends to countries each year for on-the-spot investigations and to observe trials, meet prisoners and talk to government officials. 
 During the first 11 months of 1990 AI sent 68 delegates to 50 countries ranging from Jordan to Nepal, from the USA to Romania. 
 Despite the difficulties of getting into and travelling around many of these countries &mdash; due to poor roads, curfews, civil wars, monsoons &mdash; researchers often uncover information and testimony they would never otherwise obtain. 
 In the Philippines last year, an investigation team found two &bquo;disappeared&equo; women who had been missing for several months. 
 The government had not acknowledged their arrest but the team had heard rumours of the women's whereabouts in a military camp and in fact found them there. 
 When Amnesty International visited Yemen in October 1990 to prepare for government talks, they heard reports of thousands of Yemenis being expelled from Saudi Arabia, some after being tortured. 
 The delegates went to the border and spent three days there screening hundreds of people and conducting in-depth interviews with many of them. 
 The organization urgently appealed to the Saudi king to stop the torture and brought the plight of the victims to international attention. 
 On several occasions, however, delegates have faced obstruction and harassment in carrying out their research. 
 An AI mission to Argentina in November 1976, led by Lord Avebury, was followed everywhere by twenty plainclothes policemen who questioned, intimidated and even detained a number of people whom they meet. 
 On one official visit to two refugee hostels, the delegates were accompanied by four pick-up trucks containing sixteen armed men, whose presence did little to reassure the refugees and encourage communications. 
 In one notorious case in July 1966, Nils Groth, a Danish lawyer on an AI mission to Guinea to enquire about prisoners of conscience became one himself. 
 He was arrested shortly after his arrival and was detained without trial until September when he was sentenced to ten years' hard labour for alleged espionage. 
 He was released 22 hours after sentencing under a special amnesty declared by the President, Seku Torre. 
 AI delegations have been expelled from countries after discovering evidence of human rights abuse and several countries, such as China, have refused Amnesty entry. 
 However even when frontiers are closed fast to Amnesty, information still gets out &mdash; via refugees or victims who have fled in fear, &bquo;friendly&equo; foreigners or nationals inside the country, church, trade union and human rights organizations, journalists or travellers, or from letters smuggled across the border. 
 Even from the jails themselves, the cries of hope, of despair, implorings not to be forgotten escape: Muriel &bquo;Rucia&equo; Dockendorff was seized by Chilean security police soon after the bloody coup of 1973 and &bquo;disappeared&equo;. 
 The Chilean Government denied all responsibility for her detention. 
 However in October 1974 this message &mdash; addressed to a former inmate &mdash; was smuggled out of the infamous prison, Cuatro Alamos, on the inside of a cigarette packet. 
 Dearest Sandra, 
 I remember when I first met you at the house of terror; what you gave me, all that you gave me. 
 In those moments when a light was a dream or a miracle, you were light in that darkness. 
 We were one in adversity. 
 Today &mdash; a thousand trials later &mdash; I see you as before, as I know you are today, somewhere, always looking to the future. 
 We will meet again one day through the fog that we will clear. 
 Do not forget me dear comrade. 
 Rucia. 
 Of course, all sources of information must be confirmed as credible &mdash; sources could be using AI as a propaganda tool. 
 &bquo;We are well aware of this danger and don't blindly accept what people say,&equo; states Malcolm Smart. 
 &bquo;It comes down to applying a judgement based on the background knowledge we've acquired from 30 years of monitoring and reporting human rights&equo;. 
 Amnesty knows, for example, what the long term pattern of abuse is in a country: the known torture methods, the likely victims, the agencies regularly implicated in violations. 
 This background experience is coupled with knowledge of a country's laws, constitution and judicial process and political and historical background. 
 &bquo;When you've done research on a country for years, you also get a sense of which groups have vested interests or political agendas, who can be trusted and who has given us reliable information,&equo; said Smart. 
 Amnesty also has its own checks which ensure that all its major reports are passed through several levels of approvals, often up to the Secretary General himself. 
 It is also AI's practice to give its material to governments before publication for their views and additional information and the organization will publish these in its reports. 
 &bquo;I'd be delighted if governments could prove all our reports wrong, if that means that human rights aren't being violated,&equo; Smart said. 
 &bquo;but invariably, even when we have needed to correct or update details in our reports, the sad fact remains that the overall portrait of horror has been shown to be true and if anything, understated.&equo;  
 Above: AI staff members in Northern Thailand en route to interview Burmese refugees. 
 Opposite: (top) AI delegation to Bangladesh, 1988; (left) Secretary General and researchers interview POC Raul Diaz Tejera in Cuba; (right) Queue of people waiting to present testimonies to AI delegation in Guatemala. 
 US DEATH PENALTY 
 Back Yard Blues 
 There are over 2,300 inmates on America's death rows: all have found themselves caught up in the nightmare that is the US capital law system. 
 By Piers Bannister. 
 Three years of being a member of the Campaign Team at AI had not prepared me for seeing human rights abuses first hand. 
 President Bush's recent pronouncements on what is just and moral during the Gulf war left me feeling empty and bitter. 
 having been in the US's &bquo;back yard&equo; I know how little attention is paid to those issues there. 
 The violence in America is frightening. 
 Homicides reached 23,000 in 1990, an increase of 15 per cent on the previous year. 
 Drugs, poverty and the availability of hand guns all play their part. 
 But rather than address these basic problems, politicians look for the quick &bquo;fix&equo; &mdash; anything that sounds good in a sound-bite will do. 
 Unfortunately, increased use of the death penalty appears to be the most popular solution. 
 The definition of capital murder &mdash; which carries the death penalty &mdash; varies from state to state: in Alabama, a capital murder is one that occurs during the course of a robbery, or where the victim is kidnapped or raped; or, where the perpetrator is on parole or has escaped from custody; or where the crime is particularly cruel. 
 In practice, however, issues such as the colour and social standing of the victim will also play a major part. 
 Since 1973, in Columbus, Georgia, a death sentence has been sought for 43.8 per cent of those accused of killing a white female and only 2.6 per cent of those accused of killing a black female. 
 Also, if the DA is coming to the end of his/her four-year term, seeking the death penalty may improve their chances of re-election. 
 Once accused of capital murder, the defendant will almost certainly have a problem finding an attorney. 
 Capital law is much more complicated &mdash; but far less lucrative &mdash; than &bquo;ordinary&equo; criminal law, so attorneys not specialise in defence work and are reluctant to take cases. 
 Also, attorneys may be putting themselves up for huge amounts of emotional strain, knowing that their clients stand to lose more than their liberty. 
 Since almost all those on death row come from impoverished backgrounds they lack the funds to hire their own attorney and will be appointed counsel by the Court. 
 There are numerous examples of the poor quality of court-appointed lawyers; John Young went to his death even though his trial lawyer had signed an affidavit admitting he had been ill-prepared at trial due to drug use, the recent break-up of his marriage and the discovery of his own homosexuality; another attorney had his breath checked by the judge for signs of alcohol, another was found to be in contempt of court after arriving back from lunch drunk&hellip; and so I could go on. 
 When the case comes to trial the inexperienced attorney (a good lawyer may have managed to get the charge reduced to straight murder) will be faced by a prosecutor who may well specialize in capital law. 
 The first part of proceeding will be the jury selection, known as the vior dire . 
 The jury will be &bquo;death qualified&equo; (in the case of Alabama capital law): all jurors have to believe in capital punishment, and be prepared to sentence someone to death. 
 Since black people in the southern states have suffered more injustices at the hands of the law they tend to be less likely to hand out death sentences. 
 Therefore the prosecution will strike blacks from the jury. 
 Although this is technically against the rules, it is still common practice. 
 If challenged to justify why blacks are struck from the jury, prosecutors offer the most ridiculous reasons &mdash; &bquo;he looked dumb&equo;, &bquo;he lived in the same part of town as the defendant&equo; (most blacks live in the same part of town), &bquo;he was a mason and I was worried about masonic links&equo; (the prospective juror was a stone mason by profession). 
 Amazingly enough, all these reasons were found acceptable by the judge. 
 Open racism in court may continue throughout the trial: one defendant was defended by an attorney who regularly used the term &bquo;nigger&equo; to describe  his client and, it later transpired, was the local Grand Wizard for the Ku Klux Klan. 
 If you are found guilty, the trial enters into its next very complicated part &mdash; the sentencing phase. 
 A good defence lawyer would now be armed with all the mitigating circumstances of your life: mental records, character witnesses,&hellip; any reason why your life should be spared. 
 In reality, most attorneys have made almost no preparation for this phase and do not really understand it. 
 Jurors in the case of Dalton Prejean were unaware of his long-term mental problems when sentencing him to death. 
 At least one member of the jury said he would not have given a sentence of death (which must be unanimous) had he known that Prejean had suffered prolonged mental and physical abuse from his guardians. 
 Once sentenced to death the nightmare gets worse: very little care is taken with the inmate's emotions. 
 When Roger Collins was sentenced to death aged 18 he had no idea what would happen next. 
 He recalls, &bquo;When I was sentenced I thought I'd be killed straight away. 
 Even when I went to prison it wasn't explained to me. 
 I sat in my cell expecting to be called out for execution at any moment. 
 I remember feeling really happy when I was told I had at least six or seven years to live. 
 That makes me angry now.&equo; 
 Conditions on most death rows are appalling. 
 In Alabama's West Jefferson Prison inmates are kept in tiny cells, with the bare minimum of furniture. 
 There is no outside view of any sort and the only time they leave the cell is for weekend visits from relatives, bi-daily showers or for 45 minutes' daily exercise. 
 It is not surprising that many inmates want to give up their appeals. 
 The hardest two hours of my life were spent trying to persuade David Nelson to take up his appeals. 
 David had decided to seed &bquo;voluntary&equo; execution &mdash; to drop all appeals and allow his execution to take place. 
 His attorney had managed to get him to take them up again and I went to the prison to have the necessary papers signed. 
 During the interim period the prison authorities had taken David's favourite visitor off his visiting list causing him to drift into despair. 
 After two hours Ii managed to get David to sign the papers knowing full well that, after over 12 years of living in those conditions, I would probably want to die myself. 
 Those awaiting execution will spend their last days almost entirely alone. 
 They will be moved to the &bquo;death house&equo; into a room that is often adjacent to the electric chair where they may hear the chair being tested at regular intervals. 
 Some states even go to the trouble of having two switches, one a &bquo;dummy&equo;, so that everyone can say, &bquo;it wasn't me who actually killed him&equo;. 
 It is a separate tragedy altogether that, in a country where there is no nation health service, anything up to three million dollars can be spent killing someone. 
 While over 2,300 people wait on death rows countrywide to see if they will die or not, we can only hope that the US comes to its senses soon.  
 Prisoners executed in Arizona during the 1920s. 
 The gas chamber, Maryland Penitentiary. 
 A checker game on death row. 
 SRI LANKA 
 PARADISE IN TURMOIL 
 Amnesty's major Sri Lanka (September-December 1990) succeeded, against considerable obstacles, in bringing the tragedy of Sri Lanka to the attention of the world, and helped generate some fresh signs of change. 
 By Peter Nicholls 
 The Government of Sri Lanka has shown itself to be increasingly sensitive to the outcry over its appalling human rights record over the last decade. 
 However, it has yet to take concrete steps to stop atrocities, or bring their perpetrators to justice. 
 No effort has been made to investigate the tens of thousands of murders and &bquo;disappearances&equo; that have occurred over the past three years: in February, Sri Lankan human rights activists estimated that 40,000 people had &bquo;disappeared&equo; since 1987. 
 These dreadful events took place in the south of Sri Lanka, which is dominated by the majority Sinhalese population. 
 From 1987&ndash;1990 an uprising by the Sinhalese Janatha Vimukthi Perammuna (JVP) Movement was ruthlessly suppressed by the government. 
 The repression continues today, albeit on a smaller scale. 
 At a recent meeting in London on human rights in Sri Lanka, MP Fernando Pulle Jeyaraj gave a graphic description of the torture and detention houses in which JVP &bquo;suspects&equo; are held by the security forces. 
 &bquo;Disappearances&equo; occur daily in Sinhalese parts of the island and mutilated bodies are still found dumped along road sides. 
 Along with the thousands of appeal letters sent as a result of Amnesty's campaign, perhaps the clearest direct pressure is being exerted by the Sri Lanka Aid Consortium, made up of donor governments and multi-lateral institutions. 
 They have made it clear that from October 1991 aid disbursements will be conditional on improvements in the human rights record of the Sri Lankan government. 
 This aid money &mdash; worth US&dollar;1 billion per annum &mdash; is crucial to the fulfilment of the government's economic policies. 
 There have been some events which give qualified cause for optimism. 
 Perhaps most important is the development of a &bquo;Mothers&equo; Front&equo; to campaign for investigations into the mass &bquo;disappearances&equo;. 
 Modelled on similar organizations  in Argentina and Central America, it consists mainly of mothers whose husbands, sons and daughters have &bquo;disappeared&equo; or are known to have been murdered by the government or the JVP. 
 Although headed by opposition MPs, it has grown independently on a national basis and held its first large scale rally in Colombo in late February 1991. 
 Based in the Sinhalese south of the island, the Mothers' Front has nonetheless stated its intention to embrace those affected by the thousands of &bquo;disappearances&equo; in the Tamil-dominated areas of the north and east of the country. 
 One of the inspirations behind the Front is Dr Manorani Saravanamuttu whose son, the well-known journalist and broadcaster Richard de Zoysa, was abducted and murdered in a February 1990. 
 Dr Manorani spoke at a number of Amnesty meetings last autumn. 
 The Sri Lankan government has moved to try to counter the criticisms of its human rights record. 
 In November, a Presidential Task Force on human rights was set up, consisting of senior figures close to President Premadasa. 
 Its main function, however, appears to be to present a better image of Sri Lanka to the outside world. 
 More promising was the inauguration in January 1991 of a Commission of Enquiry into new cases of &bquo;disappearance&equo;. 
 This Commission consists of five senior members of the judiciary and legal profession. 
 Its 12-month brief is to investigate all new reports of &bquo;disappearance&equo;. 
 While falling way short of Amnesty International's request for investigations into all &bquo;disappearances&equo;, this initiative is welcomed as a modest first step in the right direction. 
 The government has at last acknowledged that &bquo;disappearances&equo; do take place and that it is a problem which needs addressing, and Amnesty International expects to be submitting cases for investigation by the Commission. 
 Two AI delegates attended a conference in Colombo from 11 to 16 March on trades union and human rights in South Asia as guest speakers. 
 While there, they also met government officials and discussed possibilities for future access by AI to Sri Lanka. 
 Amnesty was last permitted access to the country in 1982. 
 The government subsequently announced that &bquo;a research visit to Sri Lanka would be considered favourably if a formal request were made&equo;. 
 This pattern of greater flexibility toward outside investigation of human rights abuses is also shown by the Sri Lankan government's acceptance of visits by both the UN Rapporteur on Extra-Judicial Executions and the UN Working Group on Disappearances. 
 These are now due to occur in 1991, having been postponed on several occasions over the past few years. 
 Such developments, along with the continuing work of the International Committee of the Red Cross within the country, are welcome in themselves and also give some evidence that the Sri Lankan Government is responsive to criticism from outside the country. 
 Unfortunately, even these modest advances apply only to the south of Sri Lanka, the primary focus of Amnesty's campaign last autumn. 
 While the situation in the south remains a major concern, greater violations of human rights are now occurring in the North and Eastern provinces of the island, where government security forces are engaged in a full-scale civil war with elements of the Tamil-minority population. 
 The main opposition group in this region is the armed Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) whose political aim is a separate Tamil homeland (Eeelam) in North-East Sri Lanka. 
 The conflict has continued, with varying degrees of intensity, for over 10 years. 
 Predictably, the main sufferers since fighting flared once more in June 1990 have been the civilian populations &mdash; Tamil, Sinhalese and Moslem. 
 The population in the north and east are now living in terrible conditions. 
 With hundreds of thousands of people displaced from their homes by the conflict, the economy of these areas has been devastated and government forces are laying siege to many parts of the north, often involving inaccurate and indiscriminate bombardments of civilian population centres. 
 The LTTE has also been responsible for massacres, both of Sinhalese and Moslem civilians, since June 1990 and against rival Tamil political groups who, in some cases, have now aligned themselves with the government's forces. 
 Repression by the Sri Lankan security forces in the eastern province has been savage and widespread. 
 The rule of law in Sri Lanka has been seriously eroded: in the past three years, over a dozen lawyers have been murdered because of their involvement with human rights cases and at least 20 others have been forced to flee the country after receiving death threats. 
 Only concerted action and investigation by the government can right these tragic injustices that continue to occur.  
 Above: A Jaffna schoolboy shows a drawing he made of helicopters strafing his home town. 
 Left: A hired gunman at a United National Party election rally in late 1989. 
 Buddhist monk covers his eyes amid tear gas fired by the security forces during a demonstration against the Indo-Sri Lanka accord in Colombo, 1987. 
 An LTTE leader in Vavuniya, carrying a cyanide capsule around his neck. 
 The LTTE instructs its cadres to swallow cyanide if captured. 
 MOROCCO 
 SPEAKING IN SHADOWS 
 I had seen her face before, but only in silhouette, anonymous, as she spoke out about the inhuman conditions of political prisoners in Morocco's forgotten dungeons. 
 By Dan Jones 
 We met on a wild, windy day near the Ferry in a port on the South Coast. 
 She is a small, passionate, very striking young woman with deep shining black eyes and a glittering smile, talking ten to the dozen in a strong Moroccan accent. 
 She told me that she was eight years old, the eldest of six children, when the security men came to the army camp to arrest her father, an officer in the Moroccan army, in 1972. 
 He was accused of involvement in one of two failed military coups in Morocco which had attempted to overthrow King Hassan II. 
 Her mother was only about 21 at the time &mdash; she had been married when only 13. 
 The family were then living in the military camp at Harmoumou. 
 A number of the officers arrested were executed almost immediately. 
 Her father was sentenced to death. 
 The young woman remembers how her mother would leave home at 5am day after day, and wait in the Marmoura forest near where the King used to play golf in an effort to plead with him for her husband's life. 
 Despite being repeatedly arrested and brought back home, bruised and beaten by the police, she finally got to see the King by throwing herself into the road in front of the Royal car. 
 &bquo;There is nothing I can do,&equo; said the King, as she was dragged away, &bquo;I can see those in charge, but it's now in the hands of the Justice people.&equo; 
 However, the father's sentence was changed to one of life imprisonment. 
 At first the men were held in Kenitra Central Prison. 
 The family were able to visit him once or twice a week. 
 There they would meet many other relatives of the arrested men. 
 A close relationship developed among the visitors. 
 One day in August 1973, without warning, visitors were not allowed to enter the prison. 
 They were told that the prisoners were not there any more. 
 The relatives of the 61 men who had vanished lobbied ministers and the King's sister and brother. 
 It was an extremely sensitive matter, they were told. 
 But there was absolutely no news of the men. 
 At last, in 1975, the wife of one of the prisoners, a former air force pilot, telephoned the young woman's mother to come to her house quickly. 
 The woman showed her a bundle of tiny packages, secret notes, from some of the disappeared men, smuggled out of their secret jail by one of the guards. 
 The guard was still in the house. 
 The young woman's father was one of the letter-writers. 
 His note consisted of a few words, impersonal, noncommittal, on a tiny scrap of paper written with a burned matchstick. 
 But he was alive. 
 In his note he asked for medical help &mdash; some vitamins, eye-drops, &bquo;as I can't go out&equo; &mdash; and for some money. 
 It seemed that the men pooled their money to help survive. 
 Her mother tried to persuade the woman who had received the letters to let her talk with this guard; a man who was actually in touch with her husband. 
 Perhaps he could tell how he was, or where? 
 She could see him through the shutters &mdash; a big man, a Berber, a kind-looking man with bright blue eyes and tattoos. 
 But the woman said he would simply not risk meeting her &mdash; it was too dangerous. 
 One of the group of relatives, an old woman who walked very slowly, also had a letter. 
 Her son was very ill. 
 She decided to try and visit him. 
 They had a vague idea where the place was. 
 It was a very long journey right across the Atlas mountains and down to the  edge of the desert. 
 Long before she reached the place, the car was stopped by the military. 
 &bquo;There is no prison here. 
 Turn back! 
 Who told you there was a prison?&equo; 
 They were taken away for questioning. 
 &bquo;Who is spreading these rumours?&equo; they wanted to know. 
 The old woman's son was one of the many prisoners who have subsequently died in the prison. 
 A year later a second note was among another smuggled group of notes that arrived for the relatives. 
 &bquo;I received the materials that you sent.&equo; 
 In 1977 another letter came, then a long silence until 1981, then a letter in 1984. 
 Sadly, the notes referred to money and medicines that had been sent by the family but not received in the prison. 
 Everything exchanged in the secret correspondence has to be tiny so it can be hidden in the palm of the hand: pills, passport sized pictures of the family. 
 The little notes are coded. 
 There is little real information. 
 You have to read between the lines. 
 The smuggled letters take three days' journey to Rabat from the prison: some never arrive. 
 In November 1990, a further letter arrived, saying the young woman's father was ill: he wanted 150,000 Dirham, and his wife should give 100,000 Dirham to the guard. 
 &bquo;Send me photographs of the children.&equo; 
 He wrote that he was lying on a concrete floor; he mentioned acute rheumatism, chronic bronchitis; &bquo;My ribs are tight, I have a lot of fever, I cough all the time. 
 I am exhausted&hellip; 
 I cannot sleep at night&hellip; my heart is weak&hellip; my feet are heavy&hellip; 
 I am unable even to say my prayers upright.&equo; 
 Twenty-nine of the prisoners have already died, Pilot Mohammed El Shamey has lost his mind, one has taken his own life. 
 Recently, an anonymous note, clearly composed from a dialogue between a prisoner and a sympathetic guard, was smuggled out. 
 It described where the prisoners were held:; the people of Tazmamert appear to be hardly aware of it or too frightened to talk about it. 
 It is said that the prison director steals the fuel to warm his own house in Meknes. 
 The note describes the walk downstairs to visit the cells. 
 You use a torch to see anything. 
 This first cell is now empty, and a second, and a third. 
 In the fourth cell there is a man with long dishevelled hair. 
 His clothes are in rags, and do not even cover his private parts. 
 &bquo;they are denied medical care. 
 They sleep on the floor without mattress or bedcover. 
 The smell is so terrible you want to throw up. 
 The men have been locked up in their cells since day one of their imprisonment.&equo; 
 Clothes are changed once every three years. 
 They are unshaven, there is no barber. 
 The food is &bquo;maigre&equo;; cold coffee in the morning, with half a piece of bread, lunch a thin soup of rotten vegetables, the evening meal boiled pasta and the same stinking soup. 
 Tazmamert has been the great forbidden subject in Morocco. 
 The prisoners have been held incommunicado for eighteen years. 
 The sentences of most of the military prisoners were completed years ago, but nobody is released. 
 No journalist will risk prison to put an article in the paper. 
 According to King Hassan II and his government, the prison does not exist &mdash; or, even if it does, the people all love the King so much it would be unsafe to release the prisoners &mdash; they might be killed by the populace. 
 We finished our coffee and watched the seagulls whirling and shrieking over the harbour in the spring sunshine.  
 In some cases of &bquo;disappearance&equo; the whole family is held responsible for the &bquo;crime&equo; of one of its members. 
 One notable example involved the &bquo;disappearance&equo; of eight members of the family of General Mohammed Oufkir. 
 Following his death in suspicious circumstances in 1972, his widow and six children, together with a female cousin, &bquo;disappeared&equo;. 
 Nothing was heard of them for fifteen years. 
 In February 1991, they were released, but are still subject to restrictions on freedom of movement and association. 
 Right: A demonstration in the early 1980s by families of political prisoners. 
 Political prisoners do not receive fair trials in Morocco. 
 SOUTH AFRICA 
 RIGHTING THE RECORD 
 Confidence is the key. 
 President de Klerk said so in London at the end of April. 
 By Brian Dooley 
 If de Klerk can convince the world that South Africa has come far enough in improving its record on human rights, sanctions will be lifted and crucial foreign capital will start flowing into the country. 
 However, the State President is not as confident as he would like to be. 
 To coincide with his latest visit to Europe, Amnesty released a document outlining the apparent lack of accountability of the security forces. 
 Deaths in detention are not phenomena of the distant past: last year two people were reported as having died in custody. 
 In February this year, the Minister of Law and Order declared that the government would not repeal its most notorious detention law, section 29 of the Internal Security Act, which permits indefinite, incommunicado detention in solitary confinement for the purposes of interrogation. 
 Those who dies last year were held under this provision. 
 Detentions under section 29 continue, and the government acknowledged on March 18 that 16 people were then held under that provision. 
 Even more prisoners, about 60, are currently being held under equivalent provisions in the nominally independent &bquo;homelands&equo; of the Transkei and Bophuthatswana. 
 Two months ago Amnesty submitted testimony to the UN which noted that the de Klerk government &bquo;was failing to take adequate steps to investigate and bring to justice members of the security forces implicated in the torture and killing of government opponents&equo;. 
 The death of one 16-year-old under interrogation at a police station in January 1990 has yet to be properly investigated. 
 A closed hearing held in February this year concluded that no-one could be held responsible for the death. 
 De Klerk dismissed suggestions that he can't control his security forces by pointing out that he appointed 10,000 police officers last year, and claims that the new influx will go a long way in helping subdue township unrest. 
 However, with various groups suggesting police complicity in township violence, many blacks will find little security in a larger police force. 
 Despite the political reforms, many members of the security forces are carrying on business as usual. 
 In March, a judicial inquest into the death of 42 people in Sebokeng township in September 1990 concluded with the presiding judge finding members of the South African Defence Force criminally responsible for the deaths of four people and rejected claims that the concerned were provoked to shoot in self-defence. 
 Both Sebokeng inquiries exposed a pattern of unlawful behaviour by members of the security forces and lend weight to allegations of unprovoked use of lethal force by security forces, like in Daveytown on 24 March when 12 members of the ANC were shot dead by the police. 
 Accusations continue of security force involvement in covert assassinations. 
 On March 27, in Alexandra township outside Johannesburg, at least 14 people were killed when men armed with automatic weapons opened fire on mourners at a night-time vigil. 
 The police had been asked by the organizers of the vigil to provide protection after an incident earlier in the evening when about 200 suspicious-looking men appeared outside the house where the vigil was being held. 
 According to those at the vigil, the police only checked on the hose twice before the massacre occurred at 4am. 
 The apparent failure of the police to act promptly and effectively, including their failure to apprehend a large group of armed men under conditions of curfew in the township creates the suspicion that police were colluding with the attackers. 
 Despite the hype over the release of political prisoners, reports of police misconduct do not inspire confidence in the majority of South Africans, or in those all-important foreign investors.  
 Police attack black workers in Johannesburg. 
 REFUGEES 
 JUMPING THE HURDLES 
 Asylum-seekers attempting to enter the UK encounter many difficulties with our refugee-determination procedures. 
 By Jan Shaw 
 &bquo;Please don't send me back. 
 Kill me here&equo;. 
 This was the plea of a young Eritrean boy as he was being dragged back to the plane that had just brought him to the UK, when in September 1990, he and his sister were denied access to the asylum procedure. 
 He was afraid of being sent back to Ethiopia, where close family members had been imprisoned and tortured. 
 Prior to this incident, in April 1990 three Sri Lankan Tamils attempted to seek asylum in the UK. 
 Before their arrival at Heathrow, their passports and tickets were confiscated; when the British Airways plane landed, they were separated from the other passengers, put into a van and driven around for several hours before being forced back on the plane and sent out of the UK. 
 Unfortunately these are not isolated incidents. 
 Other cases are known to Amnesty International, where asylum seekers travelling without valid travel documents have been prevented by airline personnel, sometimes with the knowledge of Immigration Officers, from applying for political asylum in this country. 
 Also in April 1990, six Sri Lankan Tamils were prevented by Egyptair staff from disembarking at Heathrow: in August 1990, four Eritreans were prevented from leaving a Czechoslovak Airlines plane. 
 There can be little doubt that such examples represent the tip of an iceberg. 
 What has forced airline staff to take on this policing role of checking the travel documents of would-be asylum seekers? 
 In 1987 the British Government introduced legislation which imposes fines on airlines bringing passengers to the UK without valid documents. 
 The Immigration (Carriers' Liability) Act provides for a fine of &pound;1,000 per passenger lacking such documentation. 
 It is thought that the Government may soon double this fine. 
 Since its implementation, fines totalling more than &pound;24 million have been imposed under the Act and clearly some airlines have adopted practices aimed at minimizing the number of penalties incurred. 
 The fining of airlines plus the fact that the nationals of many refugee-producing countries now need visas to travel to this country, has made it extremely difficult for many people wishing to apply for asylum, to reach the UK. 
 When people are fleeing from fear of imprisonment, torture or death, they will use any means available to reach a safe country. 
 For many people attempting to escape from state persecution, it is impossible to apply for a passport to the very authorities who are inflicting the persecution. 
 The need to obtain an entry visa from an embassy often situated far away could be dangerous and could therefore hinder departure. 
 Instead of introducing procedures which can be relied upon to identify and protect all those at risk of human rights violations in their own country, Government has introduced a range of measures which create obstacles in the path of those seeking asylum in the UK. 
 In particular in recent years, the Government's response to large numbers of people fleeing from state oppression is to impose visas on nationals of that country. 
 During the period of 1984&ndash;5, more than 2,800 Sri Lankans sought asylum in the UK and in May 1985, a visa requirement was imposed on the nationals of Sri Lanka, the first time such a requirement was imposed on the nationals of a Commonwealth country. 
 Subsequently in June 1989 a visa requirement was imposed on Turkish nationals after more than 3,500 Turkish Kurds had sought asylum at UK ports. 
 In 1989 more than 2,600 Somalis sought asylum in the UK; from August 1990, Somali nationals could no longer transit the UK without visas. 
 In April 1991 a visa requirement was imposed on nationals of Uganda; from January to September 1990, some 1,960 Ugandan nationals sought asylum in the UK. 
 As there is no provision in the UK immigration rules for issuing visas to asylum seekers overseas, in an embassy or High Commission, there is a contradiction in the requirement of visas for asylum seekers to enter the country. 
 It is to be regretted that many of the Government's measures relating to its asylum policy introduced in the past few years, have been to discourage new arrivals. 
 Amnesty International has asked the Government on many occasions to lift those measures which place obstacles in the path of asylum seekers attempting to gain access to the refugee-determination process. 
 In November 1990, the Government conceded that the Immigration (Carriers Liability) Act and associated visa requirements &bquo;do indeed prevent some asylum seekers from coming to the UK&equo;, but further stated that it &bquo;has no obligation to encourage or assist would-be asylum seekers&hellip; to come here and enter our procedures&equo;. 
 We hope that in line with our recommendations, the Government will amend its procedures which obstruct the access to the refugee-determination process of those escaping from violations of their basic human rights.  
 Tamil protest at Heathrow in 1987 
 GROUP NEWS 
 30 YEARS OF LOCAL GROUPS! 
 TODAY THERE ARE 4,200 LOCAL AMNESTY GROUPS AROUND THE WORLD. 
 315 OF THESE ARE IN THE UK, WORKING ON BEHALF OF 318 INDIVIDUALS AND RAISING MORE THAN &pound;260,000 A YEAR TO FURTHER AMNESTY'S WORK. 
 How did it all begin? 
 Peter Benenson, in his original article in the Observer  in 1961, envisaged a central &bquo;library&equo;, providing information on prisoners of conscience &bquo;to any group, existing or new, in any part of the world, which decides to join in a special effort in favour of freedom of opinion or religion.&equo; 
 The response to this call was and has continued to be overwhelming. 
 Perhaps this is because, as a member of the Abingdon Group put it: &bquo;In a group there is the fun and companionship&hellip; and the awe at saving a life, supporting a prisoner through years of isolation, getting your prisoner free.&equo; 
 The first local Amnesty groups (the still-running Eltham and Hampstead among them) were formed only months after the launch in May 1961. 
 From then on the number grew impressively fast. 
 By the end of 1961 there were 11 groups, nine in the UK, one in Norway and one in Australia. 
 In February 1963 there were already 180 groups worldwide. 
 The increase was even felt to be too great: in 1964, when British groups reached 212, it was decided to slow down the growth in the UK &mdash; not to &bquo;act upon the ephemeral  enthusiasms of an odd individual&equo;, but to go for quality. 
 There was also concern that groups were growing faster in the UK than in the rest of the world. 
 The number of UK groups reached 300 in the early 1980s and has remained around that level ever since &mdash; groups of very high quality and certainly not based on &bquo;ephemeral enthusiasms&equo;! 
 These early groups were called &bquo;Threes Groups&equo; because each adopted three prisoners, one from the East, one from the West and one from Afro-Asian countries. 
 In many cases a group would divide into sub-groups and work on more than three at a time. 
 At one point Manchester University group was working on 39! 
 It came as something of a shock in the late 1970s, when developments in the human rights situation around the world and the increase in groups worldwide and the increase in groups worldwide led to fewer prisoner cases being available for UK groups. 
 This did not mean, unfortunately, that human rights were being respected, but that regimes around the world were using new methods of repression such as &bquo;disappearances&equo; and extrajudicial executions. 
 Amnesty groups' work responded to the challenge with new techniques such as networks focusing on abuses in specific areas of the world and campaigns on whole countries or themes. 
 For example, a &bquo;Murder by Governments Campaign&equo; in October 1983 resulted in funeral marches with black &bquo;coffins&equo;, drumbeats, and candles in Diss, Norwich, Bognor Regis, and London. 
 How to find the money necessary to carry out Amnesty's work has always been a worry, and from the very beginning the Section Office asked groups for help in this area. 
 However, in the first few years groups did not appear to consider fundraising a priority. 
 A newsletter in 1964 complains that &bquo;it is clear that the requested &pound;10 per annum is more than one group can manage.&equo; 
 It is extraordinary to consider that nowadays groups manage a contribution of &pound;600 per annum! 
 The next year, 19675, however, fundraising was already improving &mdash; Kensington Group arranged a film show at the Kensington Public Library and raised &pound;81.15.0d. 
 There are some aspects of group work which never change &mdash; the satisfaction felt on receiving a letter such as this, for example: 
 &bquo;&hellip; suddenly I became free by some secret action, and now I am so happy I found your letter concerning my person. 
 I am thankful and happy that there was a strange and foreign soul caring about the destiny of a political prisoner in East Germany&hellip; when we passed the border last night, I just cried.&equo; 
 (From a student released from an East Berlin jail in 1964) 
 Anniversaries have also been celebrated before. 
 In 1971 groups were busy thinking up ways to mark Amnesty's 10th birthday. 
 The Bristol group collected the signatures of 46 international figures to sell for Amnesty funds. 
 They tried 60 well-known personalities. 
 Harold Wilson was the first to reply &mdash; by return post. 
 Groups were still being run by a very small section office. 
 A 10th Anniversary article in the Observer referred to it as &bquo;a small back-room in an alley off London's Fleet Street,&equo; and within days the office was getting letters addressed to &bquo;Amnesty, Alley Off Fleet Street&equo;. 
 On 28 May 1986, Amnesty's 25th Anniversary, St Clement Danes Church in the Strand, London, rang 5,000 chimes, roughly one for every POC case Amnesty had worked on during the year. 
 Groups went in for all kinds of sponsored walks, knit-ins, beard-shavings, and even silence. 
 The 25th Anniversary campaign had dramatic results: individual membership increased from 25,000 at the end of 1985 to 35,000 at the end of 1986: a full 30 per cent increase in one year. 
 This year's 30th Anniversary could be our chance to make the 90s the decade in which groups shoot ahead. 
 Help us achieve this: join your local group! 
 Write to   
 Above top: Putney Group celebrated the release of their POC &bquo;Slava&equo; Cherepanov in July 1989. 
 Below: Procession in 1983 in Trafalgar Square before the Memorial Service in St Martins in the Fields organised by Amnesty International for the victims of political killings by governments. 
 Opposite: In April 1985 groups all over Britain get together to take part in a sponsored jailbreak from the Tower of London. 
 Without using any money, some of the escapees got as far as North Wales, Yorkshire, and Scotland. 
 LETTERS 
 DISTURBING MEASURES 
 I have just received David Bull's appeal for funds, with the short version of Amnesty's report on Human Rights Violations in Iraqi Occupied Kuwait (since August 1990) enclosed. 
 I am afraid that by taking the extraordinary measure of stapling this report &bquo;because some of the contents are so disturbing&equo;, Amnesty has again given credence to the belief that recent torture in Kuwait has been more terrible than in any other part of the world, whereas the repugnant patterns of pain-infliction described are all too familiar from Iran, from Myanmar, Amin's Uganda, a South America, South Africa etc. 
 Although we may claim that we simply publish an objective report, the inference that exceptional evil existed during the occupation of Kuwait will naturally be made by those trying to justify the devastating Allied bombardment of Iraq, now retrospectively. 
 I feel Amnesty has to provide a quiet, more balanced overview of a region in order to maintain its impartiality and credibility, and to operate effectively. 
 ANGELA MACTAVISH, Bognor Regis 
 OFFICIAL PRAYERS? 
 Participating as a group delegate and individual member in the vigorous AGM at Liverpool, I was surprised to see a religious service on the printed agenda, with the order of service available at the official information counter. 
 As a private activity there could be no objection to Christian members calling their fellow-believers to prayer, and I suppose that I and fellow-members of the British Humanist Association could have similarly organized a non-official meeting. 
 But the universal character of Amnesty should surely bar the incorporation of any religious observance into its official procedures. 
 ARTHUR JACOBS, Sevenoaks 
 GREAT INSIGHT&hellip; 
 I was delighted to see you had chosen a young man and woman with Down's Syndrome to model shirts in the Spring 1991 catalogue. 
 I have worked for 14 years as a care assistant in a special school, and although the general attitude towards individuals with a mental handicap is gradually changing, it is both reassuring and encouraging to see youngsters such as these becoming a more regular part of &bquo;everyday life&equo;. 
 I applaud your decision to employ them, and shall leave your catalogue in the staffroom tomorrow. 
 Congratulations on your insight. 
 JEAN MARTIN, Manchester. 
 &hellip; 
 IS WELCOME 
 As parents of a four-month-old daughter with Down's Syndrome we have only recently become very aware of how handicapped children and adults are kept to the sidelines&hellip; your catalogue makes a very welcome change. 
 JULIA MARKUS AND PAUL JORDAN, Shaftesbury. 
 DURING PRISONER OF CONSCIENCE WEEK 1990, SECOND YEAR PUPILS OF PEEBLES HIGH SCHOOL HEARD ABOUT AMNESTY'S LETTER WRITING CAMPAIGN FROM THEIR LOCAL AMNESTY GROUP. 
 THE PUPILS GOT THE MESSAGE, AND GOT WRITING. 
 HERE ARE TWO RESULTING LETTERS&hellip; 
 Your Excellency, 
 I am writing to you about the case of Im Su-Kyong, who was arrested for ten years for attending a peace march from North Korea to South Korea. 
 The thing is, she was arrested for ten years for going to North Korea without government permission. 
 I feel that this sentence is far too harsh. 
 For a woman, Kim Hyun-hui, was arrested and was to receive the death sentence for planting a bomb on a Korean Boeing 707, killing all 115 people. 
 Yet she was pardoned, because she was an internationally famous actress. 
 Can you see the point I am trying to make? 
 I hope so. 
 I am thirteen years old, and if ten years of my youth were taken over by four plain walls and nothing to do, I know how I would feel. 
 Try and think how you would feel if that happened to you. 
 Please, I am begging you, let her free. 
 Yours respectfully and sincerely, ALISON HENDERSON. 
 Your Excellency, 
 I am writing as I'm puzzled as to why you have released Kim Hyun-hui who planted a bomb on a plane and killed 115 people but have imprisoned a girl for taking part in a peace march. 
 To me this is odd as if I were the president of South Korea I would have imprisoned Kim Hyun-hui and released Im Su Kyong as to me Kim Hyun-hui committed the more serious crime. 
 I would like this to be explained to me as I just don't understand it. 
 Yours respectfully and sincerely, CHRISTOPHER SETH. 
 NEEDLES IN HAY: IS IT ART CRITICISM? 
 TWO QUESTIONS 
 What is art ? 
 Leo Tolstoy asked the question, and in 1898 his remarkable book with that title gave his reply. 
 He underlined the need for art to communicate what the artist has felt: 
 Art is a human activity consisting in this, that one man consciously by means of certain external signs, hands on to others feelings he has lived through, and that others are infected by these feelings and also experience them. 
 Art is not, as the metaphysicians say, the manifestation of some Idea of beauty or God; it is not, as the aesthetic physiologists say, a game in which man lets off his excess of stored-up energy; it is not the expression of man's emotions by external signs; it is not the production of pleasing objects; and, above all, it is not pleasure but it is a means of union among men joining them together in the same feelings, and indispensable for the life and progress towards wellbeing of individuals and humanity. 
 There are many more definitions of art besides Tolstoy's own and those which he denounced. 
 For the purposes of this book, just two assertions will have to content us: first, some works have been intended by their makers to be seen as art; second, there is a consensus today that other works are to be described as art. 
 Since art critics have these working assumptions in mind, and it is with their writing we shall be mainly concerned, we need to proceed without being distracted. 
 We shall not  look into the myriad issues springing from problems of definition which are vital for philosophers and aestheticians. 
 Is it criticism ? 
 There is a massive amount of writing about art, only some of which can immediately be identified by a reader as criticism. 
 Writing by the art critic of a newspaper is self-evidently criticism, in parallel with the writing of music and theatre critics; an exhibition can be treated almost in the same way as a performance. 
 Articles in magazines are less certainly described as criticism, for their main topics may be personalities or history, and art may be only a small part of the writers' account. 
 Books and catalogues may contain criticism; but their writers may think of themselves as art historians, philosophers, aestheticians, anthropologists, historians or biographers, and there are many other possibilities; their books may never be identified as art criticism. 
 As the following chapters will show, the useful and helpful functions of art criticism will receive preference in the choice of what is quoted or discussed. 
 Is the text or part of the text written so that a reader will benefit in a future encounter with a work of art? 
 Some writing which is called art criticism will be helpful, some will not; other writing will also be valuable, although whether it can be described as art criticism may be disputable. 
 A REVEALING INSTANCE 
 A famous passage of art criticism can be cited as one example entirely beyond dispute. 
 The author spent much of his life as a bachelor Fellow of Brasenose College Oxford; his cloistered life was devoted to writing, notably on classical antiquity and the Italian Renaissance. 
 Walter Pater was a master of atmosphere; he had been inspired as a young man by Ruskin, and his idealism about art and his fine prose were in turn much admired by a younger generation of aesthetes, among whom Oscar Wilde was a prominent figure. 
 One of Pater's subjects for a perceptive essay was Leonardo da Vinci; it gave special prominence to the painting now generally known as the Mona Lisa . 
 The following critical passage comes from this piece, first published in the Fortnightly Review  in 1869, and then in 1873 in Pater's book, Studies in the History of the Renaissance . 
 La Gioconda  is, in the truest sense, Leonardo's masterpiece, the revealing instance of his mode of thought and work. 
 In suggestiveness, only the Melancholia  of D&uuml;rer is comparable to it; and no crude symbolism disturbs the effect of its subdued and graceful mystery. 
 We all know the face and hands of the figure, set in its  marble chair, in that circle of fantastic rocks, as in some faint light under sea. 
 Perhaps of all ancient pictures time has chilled it least. 
 Pater's measured prose goes on to connect the picture with drawings by Verrocchio, speculate on the artist and the sitter, and wonder about how long the picture was in progress. 
 Then comes the peroration. 
 The presence that rose thus so strangely beside the waters, is expressive of what in the ways of a thousand years men had come to desire. 
 Hers is the head upon which all &bquo;ends of the world are come&equo;, and the eyelids are a little weary. 
 It is a beauty wrought out from within upon the flesh, the deposit, little cell by cell, of strange thoughts and fantastic reveries and exquisite passions. 
 Set it for a moment beside one of those white Greek goddesses of beautiful women of antiquity, and how would they be troubled by this beauty, into which the soul with all its maladies has passed! 
 All the thoughts and experience of the world had etched and moulded there, in that which they have of power to refine and make expressive the outward form, the animalism of Greece, the lust of Rome, the mysticism of the Middle Ages with its spiritual ambition and imaginative loves, the return of the Pagan world, the sins of the Borgias. 
 She is older than the rocks among which she sits; like the vampire, she has been dead many times, and learned the secrets of the grave; and has been a diver in deep seas, and keeps their fallen day about her; and trafficked for strange webs with Eastern merchants; and, as Leda, was the mother of Helen of Troy, and, as Saint Anne, the mother of Mary; and all this has been to her but as the sound of lyres and flutes, and lives only in the delicacy with which it has moulded the changing lineaments, and tinged the eyelids and the hands. 
 The fancy of a perpetual life, sweeping together ten thousand experiences, is an old one; and modern philosophy has conceived the idea of humanity as wrought upon by, and summing up in itself, all modes of thought and life. 
 Certainly Lady Lisa might stand as the embodiment of the old fancy, the symbol of the modern idea. 
 Pater's book is a classic, and easy to find in a library. 
 But if the books are arranged by subject, there is no certainty that The Renaissance  will be put under &bquo;art criticism&equo;. 
 Several other headings are equally possible, say aesthetics, English literature or Italian history. 
 The library user who looks for books of art criticism is not necessarily going to have an easy task. 
 Let us picture a girl entering through the impressive doors of the New York Public Library. 
 Her interest has been aroused by some new paintings which she has seen in a SoHo gallery, which a friend has compared unfavourably with the work of Lee Krasner. 
 This comparison has fazed  her, as she only knows about Lee Krasner as the widow of Jackson Pollock; so the library visit is intended to check out reproductions of Lee Krasner's work, to see if she has to concede that her friend may be right. 
 The resources available to her are excellent; the library has an extensive stock of books, long runs of periodicals, press cuttings, and up-to-date facilities to find relevant material. 
 Among the sources she will find are critical reviews, articles, catalogues and books about New York painting of the 1940s and 1950s, which will remind her that Pollock died in 1956. 
 There is no shortage of writing about Pollock; like other star artists, he has an embarrassingly large number of apologists, but fortunately there are select bibliographies which can guide her to key publications. 
 There may, however, be questions in her mind about the choices open to her: how will the information in a catalogue differ from what is to be found in a monograph? 
 How much of the books about Pollock will be biography and how much will be about his art? 
 Among the magazine articles, which are most likely to be interesting to her? 
 Will she find good reproductions of Lee Krasner's work? 
 Our American friend's cousin in London is an art student. 
 Her college library has interesting books, as well as the latest art magazines. 
 Her course teacher has given her a reading list, and the library staff are good at helping students with all sorts of interests. 
 As part of the course, she has to choose a subject of her own about which to write a paper; one of her difficulties is to know how to form her own views, not just copy already received opinions. 
 She is looking for critical views against which to pitch her own; it seems that she may have chosen the wrong sort of topic, since on a holiday in Italy she had been stunned by the newly renovated Michelangelo ceiling in the Sistine Chapel in Rome, and although there were plenty of books about it, many of them went into extravagant detail. 
 Happily her supervisor has guided more than one student through topics about Michelangelo, and has a route map prepared, including introductory and background books, but also passages from longer scholarly works. 
 If the two girls compare notes one day, the New Yorker will complain about the useless articles she read; the newspaper articles were almost always short, written maybe by hard-pressed critics who were only allowed short articles, further cut down by sub-editors. 
 Still, by reading, and looking at Lee Krasner's pictures in New York galleries, she was able to defend an independent liking for her SoHo artist. 
 In London, it was a rather different story, since the literature available needed discrimination, much of it being historical and iconographic, establishing data of little interest to the art student. 
 To her surprise, there proved to be perceptive judgements about qualities in Michelangelo's work, almost hidden in catalogue entries; more than one art historian, apparently, was not only learned but had an eye.  
 ART CRITICISM AND ART HISTORY 
 Do art historians write about the past, while art critics write about the present? 
 Things are not so simple, as some art historians write well about the present, with a generosity of feeling and approach enriching to contemporary culture. 
 They are capable of assessing modern art in its own terms, partly from experience gained through judging work of other periods within quite different terms. 
 Meyer Schapiro, who had a specialist concern with Romanesque art, was an open-minded historian of this sort. 
 He wrote enthusiastically about the later work of Arshile Gorky: &bquo;Gorky's atmosphere, veiling the hard opaque wall of the canvas, evokes a nocturnal void or the vague, unstable image-space of the day-dreaming mind.&equo; 
 And he remembered the painter: 
 I used to meet him most often in the museums and galleries fixed in rapt contemplation of pictures with that grave, searching look which was one of the beauties of his face. 
 As some poets are great readers, Gorky &mdash; exceptional among painters &mdash; was a fervent scrutinizer of paintings. 
 No interesting touch or invention of form escaped his eye. 
 He was equally at home in the Metropolitan Museum and the Museum of Modern Art, keen in discerning what was good in the arts of many ages and styles. 
 As for working art critics, their newspapers need reviews of every sort of exhibition, whether modern or historical. 
 Even though critics may not be as learned as their art-historical colleagues, there is no good reason for their practised eyes to cloud over when looking at art of other periods. 
 Furthermore, artists who are also critics are especially likely to make vivid comments on the methods and techniques of old art. 
 The guards on the frontiers between art history and art criticism shoot neither intruders nor escapers. 
 Indeed, there are some who feel that there should be no border, thinking back nostalgically to days when there was only one domain of art. 
 In some writing today, too, it is possible to find the words critic and historian being used interchangeably. 
 Art is after all the subject of attention for both critic and historian, even though the functions and methods of the two sorts of writer have drawn apart. 
 Fifty years ago they were in closer touch. 
 It was in 1936 that the first American edition of Lionello Venturi's History of Art Criticism  was published, containing material which could equally have found a place in a book about art history. 
 Venturi was a university teacher, son of a famous father, Adolpho Venturi, who had made a substantial contribution to the publication of documents of Italian art. 
 Venturi's survey started with classical times, the uncertainties of writing by Xenocrates, lists of lost works such as the treatise by Apelles, and settled down to comment on  two fundamental categories of criticism, the lives of artists, and the critic's encounter with the work of art. 
 For the latter he quoted a sentence by Lucian, the second-century Greek rhetorician: &bquo;A work of art requires an intelligent spectator who must go beyond the pleasure of the eyes to express a judgement and to argue the reasons for what he sees.&equo; 
 For Venturi, an important development in art criticism came in the eighteenth century which saw the foundation of aesthetics and the rise of philosophies for which art was an indispensable ingredient. 
 Writing as he was in the 1930s, he expressed his pleasure at the extensive documentation and reference material available to the student of art, instancing the growth of libraries and art historical teaching. 
 If he were alive today, he would have even more cause for satisfaction. 
 Some of the main efforts of historians in the first decades of the twentieth century had been directed to putting order into a mass of material, analysing works and documents, and establishing historical data. 
 German art historians had begun much more systematically on this task than others. 
 Several art historians wrote syntheses of art historical information, which became standard works. 
 Histories of art appeared in sequences of volumes by different authors, there were several series of books about artists and on museum collections, besides which the most comprehensive biographical dictionary of artists by Ulrich Thieme and Felix Becker started its long publication process in 1907. 
 Roger Fry acknowledged German scholarship as a precursor of serious art historical studies in this century. 
 Fry was a connoisseur of Renaissance art, but also he defended Post-Impressionism (a term he invented), was a painter, and published a monograph on C&eacute;zanne. 
 In 1933 he wrote as follows in a lecture at Cambridge University: 
 An enormous amount of work has been done and perhaps still more remains to be done in arranging works of art in exact sequence of time. 
 It is here that the Germans have done so much pioneer work, and indeed the whole tendency of their art historical studies has been to regard works of art almost entirely from a chronological point of view, as coefficients of a time sequence, without reference to their aesthetic significance. 
 The title of the lecture in which these words appeared was Art-history as  an Academic Study, but those were early days for the subject in the British Isles; only in London was there undergraduate teaching, at the Courtauld Institute which opened in 1933. 
 His unusual topic gave Fry trouble with the title of his lecture: &bquo;The mere fact that we have no word to designate that body of studies which the Germans call Kunstforschung &mdash;  a body of studies of which the actual history of Art is only a part &mdash; is significant. 
 I  am obliged to use the awkward and inadequate word &bquo;Art-history&equo; for it. 
 Critical appreciation was desired by fry as a necessary part of a course in art history;, and is today naturally included. 
 An English handbook written in 1980 even went so far as to state: &bquo;The enjoyment of looking (what we call the aesthetic experience) is, in fact, the core of the discipline known as Art History.&equo; 
 Later in the 1980s an American handbook took a more comprehensive view: 
 The goal of art history is first to place the work of art in history and then assess it in the light of its unique position. 
 Modern art historians strive to analyze, interpret, and evaluate works of art by identifying their materials and techniques, makers, time and place of creation, and meaning or function. 
 They inquire about the who, what, when, where, and why of the art object; often the object itself suggests which of these questions should be pursued. 
 But the function of art history today is not only to make such identifications, but also to relate an individual work humanistically to other works of the same school, period and culture, while remaining sensitive to its salient aesthetic qualities. 
 According to this American guide, &bquo;Art criticism is a many-levelled activity that comprises the historical, the recreative, and the judicial. 
 In all cases it seeks to pronounce value judgements, an exercise shunned by art history.&equo; 
 The signs are that the next few years will see some extensive soul-searching about art history; several books have already appeared. 
 From Germany there is The End of the History of Art ; from Britain a group of essays describe The New Art History ; from the United States has recently come Rethinking Art History: meditations on a coy science ; and from Canada there is a forthright title Art History: its use and abuse . 
 Art criticism seems more likely to remain in the shadows, out of the spotlight of academic controversy. 
 WRITINGS ON ART 
 Apart from art criticism and art history, there exist several other types of writing about art. 
 There is the theory of art, and there is aesthetics; there is writing about artefacts which may or may not be categorised as art, but are in the hands of the archaeologist or the anthropologist; and there is art appreciation. 
 A guide to art reference books published in 1969 had 2,500 entries, some of which referred to series; for example, there was a single entry for the series of monographs on individual artists, called Klassiker der Kunst , also published in French as Classiques d'Art , in which there are thirty-eight books. 
 This guide was extensively revised over nine  years, and was republished in 1980 as a Guide to the Literature of Art  History, intended for &bquo;persons doing serious research in the field of art history&equo;. 
 Another sort of writing about art is what artists themselves have written, either about their own work or about other artists. 
 This may be by way of theory, or on more matter-of-fact lines about technique or such questions as composition. 
 Some writing by artists takes the form of instruction; in every period manuals on how to do it, whether drawing, making sculpture or other technical tasks are found, though their incidence is irregular, and such treatises are often the work of minor artists, rather than the great; Leonardo is an exception. 
 Teachers of art are more likely to write books of instruction, and in their efforts to educate their students may make comments about the traditions they admire and from which they hope their students will learn. 
 One lesson for practical students is to analyse works. 
 A teacher's list for analysing pictures may be something like that of the American educationalist Thomas Munro: first impressions of the picture as a whole, line, light and dark, colour, mass, space, unity of design. 
 Books on art appreciation will also concern themselves with formal questions, as they have done since the beginning of the century. 
 In a book called How to Appreciate Pictures  by R. C. Witt, written in 1902, the chapter headings are not so different: drawing, colour, light and shade, composition, treatment, methods and materials. 
 A supplementary approach to school art instruction is to draw attention to the types of subject in art, such as portraiture, narrative, landscape. 
 This thematic method is combined in many introductory courses with formal analysis which is closer to the way that many artists describe pictures. 
 An example of an artist acting directly as a critic is Bridget Riley, who selected a show of pictures from the collection at the National Gallery in London, in a series called &bquo;The Artist's Eye&equo;. 
 Bridget Riley came to prominence as an artist in the 1960s, when her dazzling patterned paintings were a clear success in British Op Art. 
 Her National Gallery choices of pictures were examples of problems posed to artists by colour, and in a video talk she demonstrated how these artistic problems had been solved. 
 Connections with her own practice as a painter were evident, even though her abstract compositions were very different in subject from the works of her chosen artists, who included Veronese and Poussin. 
 Her argument was that the subjects of the old master paintings could be disregarded by a painter who wished to find lessons for the present in the artistic practice of the past. 
 Bridget Riley had no intention of either presenting an account of Poussin's aims and procedures, or of demonstrating Veronese's debts to his predecessors in Venetian art, as a historian would have felt a duty to do. 
 The artist as critic in this case deliberately avoided the historical context  of the pictures she was discussing. 
 Any art critic may take such a position, but a historian almost never. 
 Even if historians are specifically interested in form, it is likely to be the history of forms, or the development of styles which will have attracted their attention. 
 It would be too crude a generalisation, though, to say that critics are concerned with form, while historians are interested in the context of art; both the forms and contexts of art are common ground for the critic and the historian. 
 The ground has been thoroughly explored over the last 250 years, which is one estimate of the span of art critical and art historical activity. 
 Some authorities might argue for a shorter span, giving Baudelaire a title as father of modern art criticism or W&ouml;lflinn the key part in the development of art history. 
 It is in the last hundred years or so that theories have been advanced to justify critical or art historical practice, the creation of such theories being made more urgent in the last fifty years by a struggle to establish and then uphold the status of art history as an academic discipline. 
 The study of Oriental art in the West has fared less well. 
 A firm basis for the study of Oriental art came more slowly, and as we shall see, some of the differences of approach between East and West still require wider recognition. 
 Moreover, other cultures, such as those of Africa, have had to wait until even more recent times for recognition. 
 It is literature within the last three centuries, then, that provides the main choices for a reader. 
 The advice offered here is that a reader should ignore what category of writing a book or article may come under, since helpful art criticism may be found in all sorts of sources. 
 There is no need to be intimidated by the formality of a staid institution's catalogue, or to neglect popular magazines; as for writing in various academic disciplines, there ought to be no barrier to learning about an interesting topic. 
 The reader's question of a book or an article should be what function the writing is able or unable to perform? 
 Writing of many types may assist a reader who looks forward to an encounter with a work of art. 
 A RULE OF THUMB 
 It will by now have become evident that this book takes an unorthodox approach to art criticism. 
 There will be no attempt to define exactly what art criticism is, or to set out a theory of criticism, beyond the suggestions of some differences in writings on art which have already been made. 
 Nor will a history of art criticism be attempted. 
 The stress of the book falls on a viewer's encounter with a work of art, and how a prior reading of a piece of art criticism can improve that encounter. 
 To put the matter in a slightly different way, reading art criticism is a preparation for an aesthetic event. 
 James S. Ackerman, the architectural scholar, makes use of this phrase in writing about art and communication: &bquo;What a work of art communicates can be described only in terms of an interaction between  an object and a subject; it communicates nothing at all unless someone is there to look at it. 
 In other words, there are no aesthetic objects, only physical objects, which, when observed, are capable of stimulating an aesthetic event.&equo; 
 We can return for a moment to talk to the girl who went to Italy, and was overwhelmed by Michelangelo's Sistine Chapel ceiling. 
 Her idea of the value of art criticism was a simple one. 
 In her mind there was a set of events which includes reading about a work of art and looking at it. 
 There was a crucial sequence. 
 Michelangelo painted the ceiling. 
 Critics have visited the chapel and written about it. 
 This writing was discovered by her; she read some material before her visit, which prepared her a little for what she would see. 
 When she came to writing for her college project, she found other material; this will enable her to enjoy the work more fully on a second visit. 
 In her reading about the Sistine Chapel, we can imagine our friend using a rule of thumb to distinguish what was helpful to her. 
 According to this, art criticism has three indispensable elements. 
 These are description, interpretation, and judgement. 
 Walter Pater's account of the Mona Lisa  can be used as an example. 
 The description is rather slender, but Pater was able to assume some existing knowledge on the part of his reader: &bquo;We all know the face and hands of the figure, set in its marble chair, in that circle of fantastic rocks, as in some faint light under sea.&equo; 
 Pater's interpretation is justly celebrated, with its cornucopia of cultural references to Troy, Greece, Rome, the Middle Ages, as well as to Pagan gods and Christianity. 
 It is a memorable evocation, casting a spell over the reader: &bquo;She is older than the rocks among which she sits; like the vampire, she has been dead many times, and learned the secrets of the grave; and has been a diver in deep seas, and keeps their fallen day about her&hellip;&equo; 
 Pater's judgement is decisive, that this picture is Leonardo's masterpiece. 
 Art criticism at its most helpful does not stint the reader of any one of these elements. 
 As four chapters will demonstrate, there are different places to find art criticism; a monograph will afford the greatest opportunity for full critical treatment, while a brief newspaper article is most likely to omit one or more of the three helpful elements, perhaps through the writer's assuming prior knowledge on the reader's part. 
 To be aware of the limitations of different forms of publication is an advantage for the reader, who can by this means avoid unnecessary disappointments. 
 Description, interpretation and judgement are the subjects of separate chapters, where they are considered in more detail. 
 Without anticipating this fuller discussion, it is worth making two or three points immediately. 
 Description is a heading which includes both a description of the work itself and of the critic's response to it. 
 Interpretation is the heading which is the most wide-ranging of the three elements, including questions of  form or style, but perhaps additionally considering the work's historical background, and technical, thematic or other questions, including the artist's biography. 
 The evaluation is a summing up which places the work in the experience of the critic, and helps the reader to form a judgement. 
 The plan of the book, then, is simple. 
 After the first two chapters, it discusses where and how to read art criticism. 
 While this first chapter has outlined what that criticism is, the next gives sketches of half a dozen critical types. 
 So, it is to the critics themselves we turn next.  
 AMUSING AND POETIC: THE BEST CRITICISM 
 A FATHER OF MODERN CRITICISM 
 The qualities of a good critic are clear perception, fine sensibility and eloquence. 
 These same qualities are needed by lecturers, so it is no surprise that some excellent critical writings, such as many of John Ruskin's books, were first read out from a lectern. 
 An art critic also needs a gift for persuasion, perhaps rather more than a head for exposition and argument. 
 Evocative description can be an effective weapon in the armoury of a critic, besides which a light touch of wit or some conversational sparkle do no harm. 
 We can start with Baudelaire, sometimes considered to be a father of modern criticism. 
 He earned this disputable title by his thoughtful approach to critical issues and the undeniable distinction of his critical practice. 
 His writings on art include several reviews of the Paris Salons, which were either published in booklets or in journals such as the Revue fran&ccedil;aise . 
 The custom of writing about the Salons was well established, and had inspired brilliant writing by such an important figure in the eighteenth century as Diderot. 
 By the 1850s the tradition had declined, so that Baudelaire was seeking to give new life to a decayed literary genre. 
 He asserted that a modern artist should be in tune with his times, careful to avoid hackneyed subjects. 
 Typically, a laudatory essay he wrote was called The Painter of Modern Life  on the subject of the illustrator Constantin Guys; this gifted if minor artist was accurately targeted by Baudelaire as being in the mainstream of contemporary social and political life. 
 Guys' drawings appeared in such papers as the Illustrated London News , a very successful venture begun in 1842, the decade which also saw the founding of satirical journals like  Punch  or Kladderadatsch . 
 The illustrated periodical was a phenomenon of a world which Baudelaire saw as reborn on Guys' paper: 
 Natural and more than natural, beautiful and more than beautiful, strange and endowed with an impulsive life like the soul of its creator&hellip; 
 He is looking for that quality which you must allow me to call &bquo;modernity&equo;; for I know of no better word to express the idea I have in mind. 
 He makes it his business to extract from fashion whatever element it may contain of poetry within history, to distil the eternal from the transitory&hellip; 
 By &bquo;modernity&equo; I mean the ephemeral, the fugitive, the contingent, the half of art whose other half is the eternal and the immutable. 
 Modernity also had other manifestations. 
 In his review for the Salon of 1846, Baudelaire wrote: &bquo;To say Romanticism is to say modern art &mdash; that is spirituality, colour, aspiration towards the infinite, expressed by every means available to the arts.&equo; 
 The real benefit of reading Baudelaire himself on the art of his contemporaries is the chance of recovering some of the excitement the poet felt. 
 It is an additional pleasure to recognise his prophetic power of divining where the best art was to be found. 
 Baudelaire argued for modernity, but he also strongly believed that a critic has the right to be partisan. 
 He asserted the plain fact of the existence of differences in taste. 
 In writing about Delacroix, he placed his hero in a pantheon of artists who were acknowledged masters of great decorative painting: 
 Which is the greatest of these great men who differ so much from one another? 
 Each must decide as he pleases, according to whether his temperament urges him to prefer the prolific, radiant, almost jovial abundance of Rubens; the mild dignity and eurhythmic order of Raphael; the paradisal &mdash; one might almost say the afternoon  colour of Veronese; the austere and strained severity of David; or the dramatic and almost literary rhetoric of Lebrun. 
 The critic, too, according to Baudelaire has a right to be independent, and to work without a system &bquo;which is a kind of damnation which forces one to a perpetual recantation&equo;. 
 He wrote: 
 The best criticism is that which is both amusing and poetic; not a cold, mathematical criticism which, on the pretext of explaining everything, has neither love nor hate, and voluntarily strips itself of every shred of temperament. 
 But, seeing that a fine picture is nature reflected by an artist, the criticism which I approve will be that picture reflected by an intelligent and sensitive mind. 
 Thus the best  account of a picture may well be a sonnet or an elegy&hellip; as for criticism properly so-called&hellip; 
 To be just, that is to say, to justify its existence, criticism should be partial, passionate and political, that is to say, written from an exclusive point of view that opens up the widest horizons. 
 THE ADVOCATE 
 A partial and passionate critic also writing in the middle of the nineteenth century was John Ruskin, as devoted to Turner as Baudelaire was to Delacroix. 
 He may be taken as an example of a first type of critic, the advocate. 
 Ruskin was a deeply observant man, a close student of the natural world, and capable of a profound and subtle interpretation of Turner's art. 
 This is a passage about The Slave Ship , painted by the artist in 1840; it comes from Modern Painters . 
 It is a sunset on the Atlantic, after a prolonged storm; but the storm is partially lulled, and the torn and streaming rain-clouds are moving in scarlet lines to lose themselves in the hollow of the night. 
 The whole surface of the sea included in the picture is divided into two ridges of enormous swell, not high, not local, but a low broad heaving of the whole ocean, like the lifting of its bosom by deep-drawn breath after the torture of the storm. 
 Between these two ridges the fire of the sunset falls along the trough of the sea, dyeing it with an awful but glorious light, the intense and lurid splendour which burns like gold, and bathes like blood. 
 Along this fiery path and valley, the tossing waves by which the swell of the sea is restlessly divided, lift themselves in dark, indefinite, fantastic forms, each casting a faint and ghastly shadow behind it along the illumined foam&hellip; 
 Purple and blue, the lurid shadows of the hollow breakers are cast upon the mist of night, which gathers cold and low, advancing like the shadow of death upon the guilty ship as it labours amid the lightening of the sea, its thin mast written upon the sky, in lines of blood&hellip; 
 I believe, if I were reduced to rest Turner's immortality upon any single work, I should choose this. 
 Its daring conception, ideal in the highest sense of the word, is based on the purest truth, and wrought out with the concentrated knowledge of a life, its colour is almost perfect, not one false or morbid hue in any part or line, and so modulated that every square inch of canvas is a perfect composition; its drawing is as accurate as fearless; the ship buoyant, bending, and full of motion; its tones as true as they are wonderful; and the whole picture dedicated to the most sublime of subjects and impressions&hellip; the power, majesty and deathfulness of the open, deep, illimitable sea. 
  Ruskin wrote fluently and seriously, often at length. 
 He was a successful lecturer, much in demand, and put lectures together to make up books; certainly a book is the ideal medium for a critic's extended advocacy of an artist. 
 Nowadays appreciations are often condensed, perhaps into a catalogue introduction, or possibly fitted into the preface for a book of illustrations. 
 These sites of criticism are cramping for persuasive advocacy, even if excellent use is sometimes made of them. 
 The critic as advocate has been fortunate in twentieth-century France, where a climate of culture has brought art and literature together; also art and philosophy, in the case of Jean-Paul Sartre's advocacy of Giacometti, in whose emaciated figure sculptures the philosopher saw a metaphor of human struggle, even, as he wrote in an article in Les Temps modernes  in 1948, &bquo;the fleshless martyrs of Buchenwald&equo;. 
 The connections and friendships of Surrealism can also be instanced as opportunities for advocacy. 
 Parisian cultural life between the wars was close-knit; writers and artists gave each other mutual support. 
 At the beginning of Surrealism it was argued that there was no Surrealist painting, but this dogma was soon reversed. 
 Surrealist painting had publicity value, especially when executed by a showman like Salvador Dali, who married the former wife of the poet Paul &Eacute;luard. 
 The internal politics of Surrealism were complicated by rivalries and ideological disputes; in the case of Andr&eacute; Breton's association with Dali, his earlier support gave way to a denunciation of the artist, who was expelled from the group. 
 Another famous figure, Joan Mir&ouml;, initially praised by Breton as &bquo;the most Surrealist&equo; painter, later described his Surrealist phase as having lasted only for a matter of months. 
 A personal friend of an artist may have a real advantage in writing criticism, as he may learn about artistic intentions which are not explained to others. 
 This places a critic in a privileged position, but also with a responsibility to make clear whether views expressed are those of the critic or those of the artist. 
 This distinction can be limpid if the artist is directly interviewed, and the interview is verbatim; but there are problems of evidence with filming and tape recordings, as well as with interviews, since the viewer or reader is unlikely to know how they have been edited. 
 THE PROGRESSIVE 
 A second type of critic may be called the progressive. 
 The archetype here is Guillaume Apollinaire, special pleader for modernism before the first World War. 
 Apollinaire has been aptly called a company promoter of the avant-garde, responsible, as it were, for the successful flotations in Paris of Cubism and futurism. 
 He welcomed the varied responses of artists and writers to modern life, and in his own poetry explored innovations. 
 He believed that Paris was seeing a forward surge in the arts. 
 Writing on  were unaffected by French bourgeois taste. 
 Like Apollinaire, they saw a rift between the old century and the new. 
 Gertrude Stein later wrote a book on Picasso, in which she put the point like this: 
 One must never forget that the reality of the twentieth century is not the reality of the nineteenth century, not at all and Picasso was the only one in painting who felt it, the only one. 
 More and more the struggle to express it intensified. 
 Matisse and all the others saw the twentieth century with their eyes but they saw the reality of the nineteenth century, Picasso was the only one in painting who saw the twentieth century with his eyes and saw its reality and consequently his struggle was terrifying, terrifying for himself and for the others, because he had nothing to help him, the past did not help him, nor the present, he had to do it all alone and, in spite of much strength he is often very weak, he consoled himself and allowed himself to be seduced by other things which led him more or less astray. 
 In its slightly earlier day, pointillism had also had a progressive artistic programme. 
 The critical promoter of the work of Seurat and his friends was F&eacute;lix F&eacute;n&eacute;on, a subtle stylist who varied his methods according to the work he was describing; he used expository language for Degas, but he dropped logical connection in language, even verbs when discussing Monet's spontaneous art. 
 In arguing for pointillism, he quoted the scientific treatises consulted by Seurat and even printed mathematical equations. 
 F&eacute;n&eacute;on possessed a dry wit, honed to a sharp edge by journalism; he was a specialist in the sort of notes usually titled as &bquo;News in brief&equo;, but in France called &bquo;faits divers&equo; (Sundry facts). 
 He made these three-liners into sardonic comments which undercut the banalities of the newspaper in which they appeared. 
 As a critic, his descriptions of paintings were phrased with exceptional care. 
 For example, this is how he evoked Seurat's scene of the Parisian suburban resort known as La Grande Jatte . 
 &bquo;Beneath a sultry sky, at four o'clock, the island, boats slipping past its flank, stirring with a casual Sunday crowd enjoying the fresh air among the trees; and these forty or so figures are endowed with a succinct, hieratic line&hellip; 
 The atmosphere is transparent and uncommonly vibrant; the surface seems to flicker or glimmer.&equo; 
 F&eacute;n&eacute;on, like other excellent critics, was a valued friend of artists, and so he remained all his life even though he gave up writing criticism after a decade of working on the Revue blanche  from 1893 to 1903. 
 He accepted a position in a dealer's gallery, where Matisse was among the artists who benefited from his judgement. 
 A thumbnail sketch by a friend brings F&eacute;n&eacute;on to life: &bquo;He did not thrust himself upon you. 
 First of all, he knew how to listen &mdash; which is very rare. 
 But at the same time he was both  transmitter and receiver, so to speak. 
 He asked questions, and between his questions and the painter's answers, there was a discovery of the painting itself. 
 Even more, there was a sort of mimesis between F&eacute;n&eacute;on and the artist.&equo; 
 A friend to artists in England after the war in which Apollinaire had fought was another combatant, the poet and critic Herbert Read. 
 In 1933 Read published an even-handed book called Art Now , eclectic in its selection, with discussions of Expressionism, Abstraction and Surrealism. 
 Art Now  had started life as a lecture series, but Read was a frequent reviewer of exhibitions, and a contributor to the Listener , from which some short essays were published under the title The Meaning of Art . 
 Read was a progressive without being wholly partisan. 
 He disobeyed Baudelaire's instruction to be partial, or obeyed it only in so far as he took a stand against conservative taste. 
 He did not take sides against Abstraction, even though he was one of the organisers of a Surrealist exhibition in London in 1937. 
 This was difficult to understand for impassioned artists who saw Surrealism and Abstraction as struggling for the soul of modern art. 
 Read's account of the work of Paul Klee is characteristic. 
 He judged that it would be difficult to persuade readers of the artistry of Klee's art, which appeared similar to children's drawings, so he stressed the work's imaginative content. 
 This passage was written, incidentally, at a time when he was not well informed about Klee's own ideas. 
 It stands as a sympathetic appraisal by a critic who is trusting largely to his own intuitive sense of quality: 
 He wants to suggest the exclusive nature of that subliminal world &mdash; to dwell there, and to forget the conscious world. 
 He wants to escape to the world of memory-residues, of disconnected images, for that is the world of fantasy, the world of fairy-tales and myths&hellip; 
 (Klee's art) denies the reality or sufficiency of normal perception&hellip; 
 The eye of the artist is concentrated on his pencil; the pencil moves and the line dreams. 
 THE POLITICIAN 
 A committed critic writes from a social, nationalist or political conviction, which interacts with an aesthetic response to a work of art. 
 The extreme of critical judgement is to destroy the work concerned, as bulldozers destroyed a Russian exhibition of experimental art in 1974; or to forbid an artist to work, as was the practice in National Socialist Germany, where another form of criticism was used in 1937 by making an exhibition of art to be repudiated by its visitors. 
 This exhibition of &bquo;degenerate art&equo;  in Munich showed Abstract and Constructivist paintings which were stated to express &bquo;total madness&equo; and the &bquo;height of degeneracy&equo;. 
 National or political fervour can alternatively be the motor force of remarkable artistic achievements. 
 The murals of Diego Rivera for the Secretariat of Public Education in Mexico City are admitted by the critic Antonio Rodriguez not to be all of an equally high standard, &bquo;but what poet could keep up the same lyrical flow for a thousand verses? 
 Among some of his frescoes there are some which are imprinted on the memory for ever.&equo; 
 In these 239 murals, covering a surface of 1,585 square metres, there are traces of many influences making up a popular and forceful imagery: &bquo;The codices, pre-conquest sculpture, popular art, the study of living people, the colour of nature as well as the paintings of the misnamed Italian Primitives, together with the modern artistic tendencies to which Rivera himself had contributed during his stay in France, all went to form his own peculiar style, which is apparent for the first time in these frescoes.&equo; 
 This is art, as Lenin wished, for the people. 
 In the USSR itself, art flourished at first in experiments after the 1917 Revolution, but became confined to social utility after 1922. 
 Art was subordinated to a social theory, and the result was &bquo;Socialist Realism&equo;, the realistic portrayal of heroic workers and everyday life in a representational style. 
 &bquo;Socialist Realism&equo; has been described by Ernst Fischer as implying &bquo;the artist's or writer's fundamental agreement with the aims of the working class and the emerging socialist world&equo;; in short, this is a stance of political progressivism. 
 Commentary or criticism of such art within the country concerned necessarily takes the same position. 
 In modern China an attempt has also been made to create a national art, in this instance by partly discrediting tradition. 
 In 1942 Lu Hsun was quoted by Mao Tse-tung as asserting that the aim of a modern Chinese artist should be: &bquo;By selection to accept the historical legacy of Chinese traditional art; to absorb the best style and technique from foreign art; and thus to establish a new national art in accordance with the demands and needs of the masses.&equo; 
 Mao added: &bquo;To study the development of this old culture, to reject its feudal dross and assimilate its democratic essence, is a necessary condition of our new national culture.&equo; 
 The critical distinction between feudal dross and democratic essence subsequently proved difficult to make. 
 This brief diversion into the cultural and political history of Germany, the USSR and China has been made to emphasise the way that a state may determine artistic production, and thence art criticism. 
 In other political states during the twentieth century, there has been strong support for the view that art should serve a social purpose. 
 This took such forms as the praise of regionalism in the United States in the 1930s, Marxist criticism in London or New York, or Communist positions taken by Italian critics after the Second World War. 
 An English critic who attempted the task of  keeping a balance between his political convictions and his aesthetic responses was John Berger, who wrote in the 1950s for the New Statesman . 
 He argued against an excessively formalist type of analysis of art, by pointing out how everyday emotions and ideas also affect the viewer of paintings or sculpture. 
 Many of his readers approved his sensitive and appreciative understanding of paintings, though without sharing his political views. 
 THE COMPILER 
 A fourth type of critic can be called the compiler, whose criticism is implied in choices for collections or exhibitions. 
 The compiler's main critical medium is the catalogue, and rather less often articles or a book. 
 Alfred Barr, the first director of the Museum of Modern Art, New York, is exemplary. 
 In 1936, for example, the Museum put on two crucially important exhibitions, on Cubist and Abstract Art , and Fantastic Art, Dada, Surrealism . 
 For the latter catalogue Barr chose the Surrealist writer Georges Hugnet to write a historical essay, but it was Barr's intelligent advocacy and choice of works that made the show such a significant affair. 
 In place of the aggressive approach of the early years of Surrealism itself, Barr's commentary is in moderated phrases pointing to similarities between Surrealism and works firmly within the tradition of Western art: 
 The explanation of the kind of art shown in this exhibition may be sought in the deep-seated and persistent interest which human beings have in the fantastic, the irrational, the spontaneous, the marvellous, the enigmatic, and the dreamlike. 
 These qualities have always been present in the metaphors and similes of poetry but they have been less frequent in painting, which in the past was largely concerned with reproducing external reality, with decoration, or, as in the more advanced movements of recent years, with the composition of  color  and line into formal design. 
 On Dada he wrote: &bquo;With robust iconoclastic  humor  the Dadaists mocked what they considered the sorry shams of European culture. 
 They even attacked art &mdash; especially &bquo;modern art&equo; &mdash; but while they made fun of the pre-War Cubists, Expressionists and futurists, they borrowed and transformed many of the principles and techniques of these earlier movements.&equo; 
 Barr, in what used to be a general policy for museum curators, was not writing a passionate defence of the work his museum exhibited. 
 Rather, &bquo;the Museum does not intend to sponsor a particular aspect of modern art, but rather to make a report to the public by offering material for study and comparison&equo;. 
 Barr's European equivalents flourished in the 1950s rather than the  1930s &mdash; Jean Cassou at the Mus&eacute;e d'Art Moderne in Paris, Wilhelm Sandberg at the Stedlijk in Amsterdam, Pontus Hulten at the Modern Museum in Stockholm and then at the Pompidou Centre in Paris. 
 These men were taste-makers, whose judgements were important; but the time available to them for writing was limited by the demands of negotiation and administration, so that they tended to write essays more than books, catalogue entries rather than articles. 
 THE TRADITIONALIST 
 Some stress has been thrown thus far on modernism and its advocacy, but a traditional critic may write as well or better than a modernist. 
 Our fifth type must therefore be the traditionalist, for whom it is a pleasure to find the past living on in the present. 
 A traditional critic has the advantage of being able to turn to standards and values inherited from the past. 
 The highest praise can be given to works which match up and accord with these. 
 A traditional critic may be a practising artist; if so, there is an excellent chance that any technical assessment included in a piece of criticism will be thorough. 
 Joshua Reynolds' comparison of Michelangelo with Raphael can serve us as an example: 
 Michelangelo's works have a strong, peculiar and marked character: they seem to proceed from his own mind entirely, and that mind so rich and abundant, that he never needed, or seems to disdain, to look abroad for foreign help. 
 Raphael's materials are generally borrowed, though the noble structure is his own. 
 The excellency of this extraordinary man lay in the propriety, beauty, and majesty of his characters, the judicious contrivance of his composition, his correctness of drawing, purity of taste, and skilful accommodation of other men's conceptions to his own purpose. 
 Nobody excelled him in that judgement, with which he united his own observations on nature, the energy of Michelangelo, and beauty and simplicity of the antique. 
 To the question, therefore, which ought to hold the first rank, Raphael or Michelangelo, it must be answered, that if it is to be given to him who possessed a greater combination of the higher qualities of the art than any other man, there is no doubt but Raphael is the first. 
 But if, as Longinus thinks, the sublime, being the highest excellence that human composition can attain to, abundantly compensates the absence of every other beauty, and atones for all other deficiencies, then Michelangelo demands the preference. 
 Reynolds was here addressing students at the Royal Academy of Arts in London in 1772. 
 It was the fifth of those lectures he gave from 1769 to 1790, known as his fifteen discourses. 
 In them he took &bquo;every opportunity  of recommending a rational method of study&equo;, and incidentally inculcating his views of sound critical taste; it would have been a brave student who dared to admire Carlo Maratta, after hearing that he had: 
 no great vigour of mind or strength of original genius. 
 He rarely seizes the imagination by exhibiting the higher excellencies, nor does he captivate us by that originality which attends the Painter who thinks for himself. 
 He knew and practised all the rules of art, and from a composition of Raphael, Carracci, and Guido, made up a style, of which the only fault was, that it has no manifest defects and no striking beauties; and that the principles of his composition are never blended together, so as to form one uniform body original in its kind, or excellent in any view. 
 Reynolds was a notable conversationalist, well able to stand up to his friends, who included Samuel Johnson and Edmund Burke. 
 It is in this more informal context that his draft for a sixteenth and ironical discourse should be read. 
 It attacks his constant enemy, the idea of genius: 
 Gentlemen: It is with great regret that I see so many students labouring day after day in the Academy, as if they imagined that a liberal art, such as ours, was to be acquired like a mechanical trade, by dint of labour, or I may add the absurdity of supposing that it could be acquired by any means whatever. 
 We know that if you are born with genius, labour is unnecessary; if you have it not, labour is in vain; genius is all in all. 
 It was wittily said by a bright genius, who observed another to labour in the composition of a discourse he was to deliver in public, that such a painstaker was fitter to make a pulpit than to preach in it. 
 Genius, as it disdains all assistance, so it defies all obstacles. 
 The student here may inform himself whether he has been favoured by heaven with this truly divine gift. 
 If he finds it necessary to copy, to study the work of other painters, or any way to seek for help out of himself, he may be sure that he has received nothing of that inspiration. 
 Reynolds' weighty irony was wielded with more address than arguments put forward by later traditionalists. 
 But his views were dismaying to one of the readers of his discourses, the poet and artist William Blake. 
 &bquo;Having spent the Vigour of my Youth and Genius under the Oppression of Sir Joshua &amp; his Gang of Cunning Hired Knaves Without Employment &amp; as much as could possibly be Without Bread, the Reader must Expect to Read in all my Remarks on these Books Nothing but Indignation and Resentment.&equo; 
 As to genius, &bquo;Reynolds&equo; opinion was that Genius may be  taught &amp; that all Pretense to Inspiration is a Lie &amp; a Deceit, to say the least of it. 
 For if it is a Deceit, the whole Bible is Madness. 
 This Opinion originates with the Greeks' calling the Muses Daughters of Memory.&equo; 
 THE THEORETICIAN 
 The last type of critic to be distinguished in the present chapter will be the theoretician. 
 Today, theory is in high fashion at Western universities, and varied in scope. 
 Literary theory, drawing on other disciplines, including semiotics and linguistics, seeks for underlying structures and meanings in literature. 
 The medium of an art critic as theoretician is the magazine or journal article, not necessarily in a publication specialising in art. 
 theories are interdisciplinary, and the specific quality of a painting or a sculpture may not be spotlighted by the theoretician, whose writing is likely to be long on interpretation but short on description. 
 A theoretician is well prepared to consider what the most apt questions about works of art may be. 
 There is, after all, a rich plurality of means and intents in a painting. 
 Paul Val&eacute;ry wrote that a painter: 
 has brought together, accumulated and assimilated by means of the physical materials of his art a host of desires, intentions, and conditions coming from all regions of his mind and being. 
 Sometimes he was thinking of his model, sometimes of the mixing of his pigments, his tone, his oils; sometimes of the flesh itself and sometimes of the absorbent canvas. 
 But, though independent, these objects of his attention coalesced, inevitably, in the act of painting when all the discrete, scattered moments, followed up, caught on the wing, suspended or elusive, were in process of becoming the picture  on the easel. 
 Even such richness may not be enough for a theoretician. 
 Victor Burgin explained, for example, in The End of Art Theory  that he was unwilling to be limited to an aesthetic response to &bquo;the art object , which in turn is representative of the sensibility of the artist&equo;. 
 He described this aesthetic response as the bed-rock of conservative criticism. 
 For him, critical writing has to take up wider issues than enjoyment of a picture or a sculpture. 
 A different sort of response to art is to use it as a means of learning more about the society in which it was produced; this may be felt by a theoretician to be more important than to know the artist's intentions, which, it can be argued, are determined by society. 
 Or, the effect of a painting may be compared with those of other means of communication, such as photography, film or television. 
 there is every reason to welcome such studies, though a reader hoping for judgements about quality may be disappointed by a theoretical writer's greater stress on interpretation. 
  Theorists may also be more difficult to follow in their arguments because of a current of polemic with which a reader may not be familiar. 
 For example, the writing of Rosalind Krauss has mainly been published in two journals, the American October  and the French Macuba , both advancing a special interpretation of twentieth-century art. 
 This stance is partly a reaction against what Krauss saw as a dominant position in American criticism, by which &bquo;the art of the last hundred and thirty years, the art of modernism, is not being well served by writing that promotes the myths through which it can be consistently misread&equo;. 
 Her particular target for attack was the formalist interpretation of abstract art by Clement Greenberg. 
 Post-modernist interpretations evolved in her articles between 1973 and 1983, and were published in The Originality of the Avant-Garde and  Other Modernist Myths in 1987. 
 One of the articles is about the abstract artist Sol LeWitt, who was in Krauss's opinion misinterpreted by three critics as serving &bquo;as triumphant illustration of the powers of human reason. 
 And, we might ask, what else could Conceptual Art be?&equo; 
 How such as Donald Judd and Robert Smithson, was that they saw &bquo;a false and pious rationality&equo; as &bquo;the enemy of art&equo;. 
 From her knowledge of the artists' attitudes to their work, she pointed to the part that uncertainties played in the process of making their sculpture.  
 AERIAL VIEW: SURVEYS 
 CHRONOLOGICAL SURVEYS 
 &bquo;The White Rabbit had put on his spectacles, but he did not know where to start. 
 &bquo;Begin at the beginning,&equo; the King said gravely, &bquo;and go on till you come to the end: then stop.&equo;? 
 Many art books follow this plan, especially those aiming to take in a national culture or a whole civilisation. 
 Art histories often make an attempt to keep to chronology, although the difficulties include the crucial fact that in art there is no clear sequence of events. 
 Unlike old-fashioned narrative history, art has no decisive battles, no international treaties, and no changes of government. 
 This is perhaps a more useful analogy than might at first sight appear. 
 Newer approaches to history can give accounts which do not have landmark events and which tell us about different aspects of the past, such as social conditions. 
 Deciding where is the beginning can be a trouble for an art historian. 
 In Europe, classical times are a beginning for historians, but not for archaeologists. 
 For some art historians, the Renaissance is a new beginning, though medievalists can point out convincingly that no one event divides the Middle Ages from the Renaissance. 
 In writings about the Renaissance, its beginning may be seen to waver from the thirteenth to the fifteenth century. 
 One of the major accounts of the Renaissance in Italy was published in 1860 by a Swiss history professor at Basel University. 
 Jacob Burckhardt sensibly avoids pedantry about a starting date, but stresses the revival of antiquity as a main characteristic of the period. 
 His book entitled The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy  avoids a chronological sequence, since his plan of arrangement was to build up a mosaic of characteristic  material. 
 As he explained: &bquo;My starting point has to be a vision, otherwise I cannot do anything. 
 Vision I call not only optical, but also spiritual realization; for instance, historical vision issuing from the old sources.&equo; 
 A more mundane project for a survey writer is to scan Western art, which has often been attempted in series of books, many of them, as Roger Fry's comments implied, by German historians. 
 A few single volumes have had deserved success. 
 One of the best was made out of lectures at the &Eacute;cole du Louvre by the French historian Salomon Reinach, first published in English in 1904 (with 600 illustrations). 
 An American work on the same lines was first published in 1926 by Helen Gardner. 
 She called it Art Through the Ages . 
 Neither of these works, nor two more which are to be discussed, have attempted to integrate Eastern with Western art. 
 The limitations of surveys can be demonstrated by two examples of well-respected books. 
 A subtle mind and a firm editorial hand were essential ingredients in the success of The Story of Art  by E. H. Gombrich, first published in 1950. 
 Gombrich's book is a fine example of a survey, ambitious in scope, clear-sighted in its emphasis on the history of styles, and judicious in appraisals of the work of individual artists. 
 It is relatively brief, as can be seen by comparing it with a more recent competitor for the same market, H. W. Janson's A History of Art , which is more than twice the length and has more illustrations (928 in 1962). 
 Both surveys contain art criticism; Janson uses his advantage of extra space to include more quotations from artists. 
 For example, this is a passage of interpretive description of a Van Gogh self-portrait: &bquo;&hellip; his emaciated, luminous head with its burning eyes set off against a whirlpool of darkness. 
 &bquo;I want to paint men and women with that something of the eternal which the halo used to symbolize,&equo; Van Gogh had written, groping to define for his brother the human essence that was his aim in pictures such as this.&equo; 
 In other passages, the reader may find more difficulty in following Janson's judgement. 
 Here is a passage which shows that a survey can benefit from being used with other books (even though three of the sculptures mentioned are illustrated by Janson). 
 Antoine Coysevox, a less self-conscious classicist than Girardon, was another sculptor employed by Lebrun at Versailles. 
 In his large stucco relief in the Salon de Guerre, the victorious Louis XIV retains the pose of Bernini's equestrian statue. 
 Coysevox's bust of Lebrun repeats &mdash; again with a certain restraint &mdash; the general outlines of Bernini's bust of Louis XIV. 
 The face, however, shows a realism and subtlety of characterization that are Coysevox's own. 
 He is the first of a long line of distinguished French portrait sculptors. 
  Without comparative material, the reader is in serious difficulty about knowing whether to agree with this three-way discriminative judgement. 
 Gombrich's scholarly work includes many papers on meaning and interpretation in the visual arts, so that the broad but thin scope of his story of art is instructive; by writing a survey he inevitably limited himself to a narrow range of comment. 
 His book stresses the history of styles, which he describes in sequence, Baroque for example being followed by Rococo, and Neo-classicism. 
 An unwary reader might think that the book is a history of the changes in Western art, whereas it is in fact only a selection of some changes. 
 The Story of Art  highlights change and development, sadly at the expense of art which is less varied, of however high a quality. 
 In other words, stylistic change is at a premium; in Gombrich's book the dramatic innovations of Caravaggio do well, but a distinguished painter, say Bonnard, who is not so bold or challenging an artist was omitted until additions were made to the text in 1971. 
 As for a varied painter, only one work is likely to appear in a survey. 
 The imperative for a writer of a chronological survey is that a defined period of time is covered; this may be linked with a theme, such as the history of styles in Gombrich's case, but it is unlikely to be linked solely with a spotlight on quality. 
 Excellence is not necessarily a criterion for including a picture or a sculpture in a chronological survey. 
 The author may choose to use a characteristic work, something typical of its time and place. 
 A work of outstanding quality is a pinnacle; it is not typical. 
 There are also technical limitations. 
 A well-known picture book of Italian art alone contains more than 4,000 reproductions, yet histories of art, as we have seen, contain fewer, sometimes much fewer than 1,000 plates. 
 Of the illustrations in any general book relatively few are in colour; a careful author is bound to consider which works suffer least from being reproduced in black and white. 
 Again, the need for the deeply interested reader to supplement a survey with other books becomes evident. 
 The presenter of a television series has some advantage over a writer, since filming is more flexible than book production. 
 A demonstration of the point is to compare Civilisation  by Kenneth Clark in its forms as television and book. 
 The television series is a much richer visual experience, and filming has a completely decisive advantage in being able to explore architecture, inside and out. 
 Nevertheless, the limitations of writing a script to accompany images on the screen become clear on the printed page. 
 The pace of television favours simplifications, generalised statements, witticisms, and short sharp judgements on artists' performances. 
 A presenter, after all, knows that a viewer has the visual evidence to check on what is being said. 
 As for planning, drama is relished in television, no doubt an incentive for Clark to describe the precarious survival of Western  civilisation in an episode on the Dark Ages as being saved by &bquo;the skin of our teeth&equo;. 
 Some commentators have complained that Clark's title, Civilisation , was misleading, as only Western arts were treated; but even if Clark had been willing to take on world art, costs would no doubt have prevented such a grandiose project. 
 A single-volume history has recently been courageously and skilfully attempted by Hugh Honour and John Fleming, which inevitably suffers from the problem of compression. 
 Other civilisations are treated in separate studies. 
 One parallel to the scope of Janson's book on Western art, Sherman Lee's A History of Far Eastern Art , was first published in 1964. 
 This contains sixty colour plates and 656 black and white plates. 
 Lee makes firm judgements, as in this comment on a cave painting from the seventh century: &bquo;The most famous figure at Ajanta is in Cave 1 and has been often described as the &bquo;Beautiful Bodhisattva&equo;. 
 It represents Padmapani holding a blue lotus, and is located at one side of a cell entrance. 
 the figure is much destroyed from the waist down; but the noble torso, and especially the head, express that compassion and humility which is the great achievement of Buddhist art.&equo; 
 What is true for general histories also applies to surveys of more limited periods. 
 A typical decision for planning a survey is to take a century, or the reign of some sovereign to delimit a period; this is a device with no relationship to the artistic activity of the time. 
 In our rapidly vanishing century, decades are also taken as periods of time to be commemorated. 
 In a dispassionate view, a century seems to have several advantages, as being more than a lifespan and being an evident but arbitrary division. 
 Art is not alone in failing to conform contentedly to such chronological schemes, indeed, some might say that poetry or music are even less amenable. 
 An alternative to dates is to use a term like Romantic, even if its meaning seems to alter from writer to writer. 
 Who means today what Baudelaire meant? 
 Attempting to capture the spirit of a period is another planning strategy for a survey, though this philosophical notion of a Zeitgeist  is notoriously elusive. 
 It is perhaps more the stuff of epigrams than analysis. 
 The idea that there is such a thing as the spirit of a time can be awkwardly challenged by asking, &bquo;Whose time?&equo; 
 No prizes can be offered for pointing out that at a given moment there are artists of several generations working and in very different ways. 
 A further, and rather extreme way of dealing with a chronological survey of art is to eliminate the artists. 
 &bquo;Art history without names&equo; was a phrase used by Heinrich W&ouml;lflinn, in his introduction to The Principles of Art History  first published in 1915. 
 W&ouml;lflinn was Burckhardt's successor as professor at Basel, but his later successful career took him to Berlin, Munich and Z&uuml;rich, a major art historian whose interests were primarily in the Renaissance and the Baroque. 
 W&ouml;lflinn was naturally not ignorant  of artists, but the famous phrase indicated an interest in the sequence of art seen as forms which develop as if of their own volition. 
 W&ouml;lflinn's writings are strong on observation; this can be understood from his choice of terms to describe tendencies in form; linear as against painterly, plane surface as against recessional depth, closed against open form, composite clarity against fused clarity, or absolute clarity against relative clarity. 
 Such polarities were evidently valuable aids to several generations of W&ouml;lflinn's pupils who could benefit from his personal teaching as well as the rather more rigid theory in his books. 
 W&ouml;lflinn used such terms to distinguish epochs; they are only partly useful as interpretation, since W&ouml;lflinn tended to be more interested in art as an independent phenomenon than as having meaning intended by the artist. 
 W&ouml;lflinn wrote Renaissance and Baroque  in 1888, which in the preface he described as follows: 
 The subject of this study is the disintegration of the Renaissance. 
 It is intended to be a contribution to the history of style rather than of individual artists. 
 My aim was to investigate the symptoms of decay and perhaps to discover in the &bquo;capriciousness and the return to chaos&equo; a law which would vouchsafe one an insight into the intimate workings of art. 
 This, I confess, is to me the real aim of art history. 
 In 1964 Peter Murray wrote an introduction to a new edition, in which he made an observation about the passage on Bernini's St Teresa , the sculptural group in Rome which is a key work of the Baroque: 
 Bernini is evidently attempting to render something quite transcendental and something which had never been attempted by a sculptor before that date. 
 Indeed, it is possible to argue that St Teresa's mystical ecstasies are themselves something entirely new in the spiritual life of Europe&hellip; 
 W&ouml;lflinn himself describes the Bernini statues at some length but at no point does he ever mention the subject&hellip; 
 W&ouml;lflinn was trying to isolate a visual denominator which, he claimed, was common to all works produced at the same time. 
 The history of forms in art has had some distinguished advocates, some of whom have been concerned with the transformation over time of one form to another; others have been more attracted to problems of values, arguing either that styles in art change and decay, or that in a particular period there is an artistic will to produce work in a style of its own. 
 These are matters which border on philosophy. 
 Eternal values can also be sought in art, as they were by the French art historian &Eacute;lie Faure, whose open mind accepted disparate arts, a view which he expressed like this: &bquo;It is  not paradoxical at all to affirm that an Ivory Coast mask and the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel express the same need to manifest a harmonious rapport which exists between mankind and the universe.&equo; 
 A reader today can judge the validity of these claims through the means of photography. 
 Extensive records enable us to visit what Andr&eacute; Malraux called a Mus&eacute;e imaginaire , in which the arts of many cultures and civilisations can be compared. 
 Malraux's books, like thousands of picture books since, emphasise details and similarities across boundaries of time and place. 
 Photographs can reduce the scale of a monument or enlarge a detail for scrutiny. 
 The unfriendly comment of Edgar Wind in Art and Anarchy  was: &bquo;What has optimistically been called a &bquo;museum without walls'&equo; is in fact a museum on paper &mdash; a paper-world of art in which the epic oratory of Malraux proclaims, with the voice of a crier in the market place, that all art is composed in a single key, that huge monuments and small coins have the same plastic eloquence if transferred to the scale of the printed page, that a gouache  can equal a fresco.&equo; 
 GUIDE BOOKS 
 A tourist may ask many questions about an unfamiliar scene. 
 The answers include history, perhaps technology and sometimes art criticism. 
 There is no shortage of guide books in the modern world, nor of travel books which regale readers with accounts of what travellers have seen. 
 Occasionally a book has almost achieved immortality, like John Ruskin's Stones of Venice , but even more modest books can call up the spirit of a place; and a private letter may illuminate both a person and a work of art. 
 It is easy to sympathise with a traveller who writes: &bquo;I have seen a quantity of things here &mdash; churches, palaces, statues, fountains and pictures; and my brain is at the moment like the portfolio of an architect, or a print-shop, or a common-place book.&equo; 
 This is from one of the letters written by Shelley in Italy, which goes on to describe the painting of St Cecilia by Raphael: 
 You forget that it is a picture as you look at it&hellip; 
 There is a unity and perfection in it of an incommunicable kind. 
 The central figure, St Cecilia, seems rapt in such inspiration as produced her image in the painter's mind; her deep, dark, eloquent eyes lifted up; her chestnut hair flung back from her forehead &mdash; she holds an organ in her hands &mdash; her countenance, as it were, calmed by the depth of its passion and rapture, and penetrated throughout with the warm and radiant light of life. 
 So vivid a response by a great poet must inspire respect and possibly a curiosity to see if the reader can match the experience. 
  Guide books customarily take a lesser role, informing the traveller and listing things to see. 
 These functions have been well carried out by Baedeker guides since the foundation of the German firm in the first part of the nineteenth century. 
 Old copies are now collectors&equo; items, with their entertaining instructions and hints. 
 In 1909: &bquo;The unattached cyclist on entering Italy with his wheel must deposit 42 fr. 60c. with the custom-house authorities, which sum is returned to him (though seldom without difficulties) when he quits the country.&equo; 
 Baedeker acquired a reputation for serious standards, and the traveller who missed a double-asterisked attraction had clearly journeyed in vain. 
 Baedeker in 1909, like Reynolds in his fifth discourse, hesitated between two great masters and their works. 
 &bquo;Whether the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel or the Stanze of Raphael should be regarded as the culminating effort of modern art, has long been the subject of controversy&equo;; but they both received double asterisks. 
 A star system in guide books is still common practice today. 
 As art criticism, it has the merit of making a judgement, though description and interpretation may be meagre. 
 Some rankings have more than the approval of the author of a guide, and are attested by other authorities, local or even national. 
 In Czechoslovakia works of importance are graded as national treasures, and while the Japanese have a similar system, they also rank places. 
 For example, the shrine of Miyajima, a temple approached by water through a famous red gateway, ranks number three in Japan. 
 More informal guidance can be found in books with a personal approach, in which class the Companion Guide to Rome  by Georgina Masson is exemplary (first published in 1965). 
 There is adequate historical data about the Sistine Chapel, but there is also a personal response: 
 More, probably, has been written about this great hall-like chapel than any other building in the world; but in fact no description, picture or photograph conveys the impact which it makes. 
 Perhaps the first, and in the end the most lasting, impression that one carries away, is of the contrast between the golden-cream light and space and the exquisite feeling of harmony engendered by the ceiling as opposed to the deep blue darkness and turmoil of the &bquo;Last Judgment&equo;. 
 Georgina Masson's special gift was her ability to disentangle and evoke in Rome three different cities, of Classical Antiquity, of the Renaissance, and of the Baroque. 
 Not every city would be suited to this approach, it must be admitted. 
 In Rome a visitor can stand in front of a Baroque church, but a few minutes later, having walked only a short distance, may have plunged back in time to Antiquity. 
 This is not true in Philadelphia, where a new city decisively overwhelms the old. 
 The Liberty Bell and the  Court House are attractions which repay attention, but have far less power of historical recall. 
 Guide books are arranged to suit the convenience of the traveller, for whom routes round a city or a site are often suggested. 
 In an art museum, the works may be described from room to room, whether in a book or on a sound guide. 
 A sound guide has an edge over the printed page, since the listener is looking at what is being described, interpreted and judged. 
 However, the limitation of the sound guide is equally evident: only a small number of works can be given such exceptional treatment. 
 GEOGRAPHICAL SURVEYS 
 The tourist may find guide books excellent value, but an armchair traveller may be better served in other ways. 
 A favourite choice is a book selected on geographical lines, say on Egypt, Mexico, or China, to mention three civilisations; France, Australia, or Brazil, to take three nations; and Norwich, the Hudson River, or Tuscany to name three areas. 
 Books on any of these topics are likely to have a chronological framework, but the first principle of selection is place. 
 The art discussed may still be in situ , or at least in the country of its origin; hence the immense attraction of travel to the sites of great civilisations such as Egypt or Mexico. 
 Surveys of art on geographical lines are a commonplace of policy for publishers. 
 Among recent successes is the notable pelican series, whose titles are varied between civilisations (say, Japan), countries (say, France, 1500 &mdash; 1700), and international themes ( Ars Sacra , about medieval Christendom). 
 The art criticism in such books generally has a slant, questioning whether the country or places have had a determining influence on art. 
 Robert Paine, writing in the Pelican volume on Japan, had an answer: 
 There can be no doubt that the climate of Japan imposed on her artists a different attitude towards art problems. 
 The city of Kyoto, the imperial capital, lies surrounded by hills and is frequently bathed in mists. 
 The visibility, lower than that of the drier climate of many parts of China, has caused the artist in Japan to be more concerned with the strength of outline than with the subtleties of depth sought for by his Chinese neighbour. 
 The decorative flatness and the higher colour of Japanese art also follow as products of the same climatic necessity. 
 Similar passages of critical reflection or speculation can be found in many books. 
 Formal differences in art have been linked to places in varied ways, one of the best-known Renaissance contrasts being the stress on line  evident in Florentine art as against the colourist approach of the Venetians, a city on water. 
 Does an English liking for watercolour spring from the country's climate? 
 Does the flat landscape of the Netherlands impose a special sort of vision on Dutch artists? 
 The reverse of the coin is internationalism, a feature, some might say, of twentieth-century art; not so uncommon either in other periods, where art historians struggle heroically to identify differences between the art of one country and another. 
 Some of these struggles have been inspired by base motives &mdash; desires to appropriate art to a national or a political cause. 
 But some such efforts can have sympathy, as in those stirrings of national spirit in central Europe before 1914, when literature, language and music were fuel for Czech, Polish or Hungarian aspirations. 
 Consider Czech art, which might be said to have existed only since the beginning of the Czechoslovak state after the first World War. 
 The beauty and achievements of Bohemian art can perhaps be called Czech only with an effort, but there is no doubt of the attachment of a people to the heritage that they can rightly claim. 
 Yet Prague was always an international city, whose culture was dependent on native and external traditions alike. 
 Let us walk with a visitor through the city, a veteran of the Second World War who values it as one which was almost unscathed from the bombing which devastated so many European cities. 
 He starts at a medieval Gothic window, a remnant of the first university in central Europe (founded 1348); he pauses at the rebuilt Bethlehem Chapel, the site of where the Mass was first allowed in Czech, and Jan Hus preached before being burnt for heresy in 1413; he pays respects to the relics of the Jewish quarter with its ancient and crowded graveyard; to cross the river he uses the Charles Bridge, lined with Baroque statues (many between 1700 and 1720), and climbs the hill to the Castle where art and architecture of all periods again further embellish the golden city of central Europe. 
 In the evening our friend has supper in the art nouveau  interior of the Hotel Europe, before going to a performance at the National Theatre, built in the 1880s as a monument to the Czech national spirit, pinioned under the Austro-Hungarian Empire. 
 As he has enjoyed his day, he sleeps soundly without a nightmare about what was specifically Czechoslovak in the sights. 
 The truth is that nationality in art has limited importance. 
 At no time will this be more true than in the 1990s, when the art critic confronts an increasingly international community of art. 
 Of course, surveys will continue to be written about American painting or German art, British sculpture or Australian print-making; this fact of publication does not mean that these activities have an inner coherence. 
 Any reader is entitled to ask what purpose such national anthologies serve; their best justification is making art more accessible, enabling those living artists represented to find and hold on to audiences for their work. 
  The reader can beware of an element of self-interest in such anthologies, whether in the form of books or exhibitions. 
 For one thing, a government agency may have commercial or political aims in commissioning surveys or anthologies. 
 An international cultural agreement is made in parallel with a trading agreement; trade, it is hoped, will follow the art exhibition. 
 Not a new situation, for there are ample historical parallels. 
 For the reader, however, an art defined as national, made as cohesive and marketable as possible, may be less than convincing as an entity; it may be that within a survey or an anthology there are just a limited number of interesting and attractive works. 
 SURVEYS OF TECHNIQUES 
 Surveys of technique often include more rewarding art criticism than either chronologically or geographically based books. 
 The writer is able to measure artists not only against each other but also against standards of technical achievement. 
 Here is a passage from a classic work on etching and engraving, about D&uuml;rer: 
 He was solid, scientific, conscious in all his creating, learning his art from masters who were still in the youth of artistic development, his whole work shows a progress towards an ideal which the trammels of Gothic tradition never left him free to attain without a struggle. 
 By the very energy spent in its realisation, his accomplishment is all the more intense in its expression. 
 He recognised the truest limits of the medium in which he worked, never allowed technical virtuosity to have the better of the central aim of significant composition, and established a balanced style which remains the most perfect model of the line-engraver's art. 
 The author is the English scholar Arthur Hind. 
 His working life was spent in the British Museum, whose print collection was his special care. 
 He first published a short history at the beginning of the century, but the passage quoted comes from the enlarged edition of 1923. 
 In discussing D&uuml;rer, he treated him as the most versatile artist of a triumvirate, whose other members were Marcantonio Raimondi and Lucas van Leyden. 
 Of the latter he wrote, &bquo;Lucas van Leyden is an artist of frailer calibre than D&uuml;rer, and prone to lose himself in imitation of stronger men, each of his contemporaries in turn dominating his style.&equo; 
 Another book about the age of D&uuml;rer, but on a different topic, is The Limewood Sculptors of Renaissance Germany , by Michael Baxandall, published in 1980. 
 The author started his career in the Victoria and Albert Museum, where there is an important group of this sculpture; his book had a double origin in a museum exhibition and a series of lectures. 
  Divisions in the book are unusually clear, separate chapters being given to topics such as function, the market, or the historical and political background of the subject. 
 He makes a particular point of technique. 
 In the chapter on technique the author describes the process of carving a figure from a wood with particular properties. 
 First the hard heartwood was removed, making the intended figure hollow at the back; the sculptor avoided solid masses, unstable in wood (though preferred by sculptors in a material like sandstone); finally in the carving, forms were decided partly to avoid the hazards of the sapwood shrinking and splitting. 
 Limewood is contrasted with oak, and the chapter finishes: 
 The properties of the material made limewood sculpture a special medium. 
 It was a medium of the grand form and of the surface, whether polychrome or monochrome; it was not a positive medium of the middle forms, like oak, or even usually of the assertive instrument, as bronze can be. 
 The grand form offered a scale of more or less assimilation to the form hidden in the wood, the surface a scale of textures, on both of which the sculptors played, and they are a source of specific qualities of the genre. 
 A final chapter is devoted to four case studies: Michael Erhart of Ulm, Tilmann Riemenschneider of Wurzburg, Veit Stoss of Nuremberg, and Hans Leinberger of Landshut. 
 These short studies are in part historical, but partly art criticism; the study of Leinberger is particularly relevant, as it comments both on an encounter with a sculpture and the problems of reading about it. 
 The best preliminary plan may be for the reader to open the book upright at (the illustration) and then go to the other side of the room, to be imposed on from a distance: it is the nearest the book can offer to the proper first encounter with the figure. 
 There is no one way of looking at a sculpture by Leinberger and similarly there is no one angle or distance from which we see it anything like whole, but there is something like a normal sequence of approach. 
 This begins with the figure impinging powerfully from a distance, in this case as one walks into St Martin's at Landshut, more powerfully than other things in the field of view. 
 What carries most punch here is, of course, the gilt y-shaped motif of the folds offered by the Virgin's mantle&hellip; to stretch a phrase, a Leinberger sculpture is a permanent possibility of cumulative sensation. 
 For, once we have made the first approach to the Landshut Virgin and acquired a first set of impressions, the changeableness of the figure begins to work on us further, now less in the dimension of greater or lesser distance and more in the angle of view. 
  In comparison, &bquo;One's relation to Riemenschneider's Altar of the Holy Blood is a little passive: one waits and the shift of light will change its mood and meaning.&equo; 
 This extended critical evaluation is a rarity in a survey, but very welcome in the way it spells out a connoisseur's response in formal terms to a work of art. 
 It has the added value of being firmly rooted in a thorough understanding of technique. 
 Surveys of painting, it has to be admitted, are more fallible in this respect, partly because of the relative simplicity of the means used. 
 Differences exist between the media of tempera and oil, or oil and acrylic, but they do not have the importance of contrasts in other material processes. 
 Nevertheless, there is one group of surveys of painting which have a special interest: those which form part of handbooks or, more grandly, treatises on how to paint. 
 A practitioner's assessment of other artists' work, often in the light of making similar attempts, can make intriguing reading. 
 Drawings are quite often given survey treatment. 
 The specialist field of old master drawings has received extremely detailed study; the drawings are interesting both in their own right and as a means of knowing more about artists' practices. 
 The connoisseur also hopes to have in a drawing an authentic work by an artist's own hand, which in the case of an oil painting may not be so assured. 
 European studio practice from the Renaissance to the nineteenth century included the master's employment of assistants, and the use of specialists for parts of pictures, such as drapery or landscape. 
 Watercolours are also treated in surveys. 
 Here the writer is likely to be a practitioner, and the approach may defer to the popularity of the medium as a pastime for amateurs. 
 Print-making has had the advantage of some careful scholars, but an excellent book is by a practitioner, Stanley Hayter. 
 It is modestly titled About Prints . 
 In it this English master printmaker wrote lucidly and well about the range of possibilities in his profession. 
 His memories of his Paris studio add spice to his account, for the facilities there were used not only by his students but in addition by such major artists as Mir&oacute; and Picasso. 
 The technical survey is above all a category of book in which the writer will have closely observed the material discussed. 
 This observation has direct bearing on questions of authenticity, since a detail may be the way that the true can be separated from the false. 
 William J. Ivins was curator of prints at the Metropolitan Museum from 1916 to 1946. 
 In How Prints Look , first published in 1943, he wrote &bquo;an elementary introduction to the appearances (the outward and visible signs) of prints&equo;, and cautioned that: &bquo;Most of the time spent over it should be given to looking at its pictures.&equo; 
 The caption material under two images reads as follows: &bquo;In the middle nineteenth century, before photography was in general use, Pilinski of Paris was famous (and notorious) for the deceptiveness of his  copies of old woodcuts. 
 This is an enlargement from an original fifteenth-century woodcut. 
 On the opposite page is Pilinski's wood-engraved copy.&equo; 
 &equo; Pilinski had to redraw his copy of the old and valuable original because he could not paste the original on his block and engrave through it. 
 Every line is different &mdash; every line is stupid &mdash; and the whole character has changed. 
 In a number of places Pilinski completely misunderstood the &bquo;indications&equo; of the original.&equo; 
 THE SURVEY WITH A THEME 
 Themes in art have a fascination, since they add a subject interest to a viewer's enjoyment of artistic qualities. 
 The portrait is an endlessly interesting example, a theme redolent with social connotations and artistic references. 
 In Dostoevsky's opinion, &bquo;The portrait painter seeks the moment when the model looks most like himself; in the capacity to find and hold this moment lies also the talent of the portraitist.&equo; 
 The novelist in search of character thus finds a fellow-worker in the painter. 
 This hope for a natural quality in portraits, however, is frequently disappointed, since many sitters are eager to be flattered. 
 A powerful sitter may also impose a requirement that the portrait looks impressive, so that an amused spectator can look for traces of the consequent power struggle in a picture; Queen Elizabeth I of England was as firm as the Emperor Augustus about the principle that a ruler's actual appearance matters less than the imprint of authority. 
 The artist's self-portrait is a special case in portraiture and deservedly part of the collecting policy of art museums including the Uffizi, Florence. 
 A successful description of a self-portrait may not be difficult, but an illuminating interpretation may call on many references, especially other artists' pictures of themselves. 
 What can be deduced from a self-portrait is often controversial; a critic is especially likely to read into a self-portrait some opinion held about the artist. 
 When, as in the cases of Rembrandt and Van Gogh, there is a whole series of pictures to choose from, books can be written on the self-images of one artist alone. 
 This theme is a useful one for assessing the quality of a critic's writing, since it tempts the rash into speculation, while an impoverished eye will miss relevant and useful comparisons. 
 A theme where personal psychology is necessarily absent is the Christian subject of the Madonna and Child. 
 Again, much interest attaches to interpretation, as an impassive hierarchical image of the Madonna is softened through the centuries into a more human and tender figure. 
 The multitude of Madonnas for Italian worship in the Renaissance made this a fruitful theme for connoisseurship which has taken on the task of distinguishing authentic works from those by followers or copyists. 
 An art critic may have difficulty in deciding how far the picture needs  to be considered as devotional imagery, and how far discussion can be limited to artistic merits. 
 An extremist view expressed by a twentieth-century artist is what Matisse had to say about his responses to murals by Giotto. 
 &bquo;When I see the Giotto frescoes at Padua I do not trouble to recognise which scene in the life of Christ I have before me, but I perceive instantly the sentiment which radiates from it and which is instinct in the composition in every line and  color . 
 The title will only serve to confirm my impression.&equo; 
 In a different context, but also on the issue of religion, an American book on the Aztecs by the archaeologist Vaillant commented tartly: 
 The Aztecs did not have a term for &bquo;fine arts&equo;, nor did they speculate about aesthetics, nor make objects to be contemplated for their beauty alone. 
 They had none of the socially sterile attitude towards art which we adopt in our own culture. 
 Instead, they recognised the value of superior workmanship and used its products to honour the gods who were intermediaries between man and the infinite power of the universe. 
 The list of themes and their varied fortunes is a long one. 
 For example, landscape painting had only a gradual success as a theme in European painting. 
 Kenneth Clark demonstrated this development of an evolving sensibility to nature in his lectures, Landscape into Art , published in 1949. 
 His introduction remarks, incidentally, that: 
 anyone who expects this book to be a treatise on the history of landscape painting will be disappointed&hellip; in spite of copious rewriting, lectures these pages remain. 
 One may remove the words &bquo;next slide please&equo; from the text, but not from the sequences of thought. 
 The publication of lectures is a well-known form of literary suicide. 
 I indulge in it now because the audiences who heard them endured, with much patience, extremes of heat and cold. 
 I am grateful, and can only show my gratitude by giving them the text to criticise under more agreeable conditions. 
 A characteristic two pages of the text are given to Corot's landscapes, five pictures being cited, though the reader is less fortunate than the lecture audience, as only two are illustrated. 
 Here is Clark's description of Corot's late style: 
 From all his great range of delicate visual experiences Corot came to be satisfied with one &mdash; shimmery light reflected from water, and passing through the delicate leaves of birches and willows. 
 He concentrated on it because he loved it, and he thereby proved  once more his extreme simplicity of character. 
 For he had revealed one of the eternally popular effects of nature, one which is still quoted by simple people as a standard of visual beauty. 
 Animals make up a category of painting with an uneven reputation, though the theme is one of obvious importance and interest in sculpture. 
 Animal Painting in Britain  was the title of a book by Basil Taylor, where he explained in his first chapter that the topic had been neglected since it was either assumed to be about sporting pictures, or about pictures of horses by such specialists as Sartorius. 
 He quoted the dismissive comment of the writer of the volume on British Painting 1530&ndash;1790  in the Pelican History of Art : &bquo;To discuss the Sartorius tribe and such painters is no business of the historian of art, no matter how bitter the accusations of neglect are wont to be from those specialist writers who sometimes confuse the history of art with praising famous horses.&equo; 
 Such a frank exclusion from the domain of art is not a solitary instance. 
 Exclusion, though, is rather less general a problem than a low status for some categories of painting. 
 Academies of art, whether in the West or in the Orient, have had lists of priorities in themes of art, in which there are many similarities. 
 For example, in twelfth-century China, a catalogue of the Imperial collection had ten headings: Taoist and Buddhist subjects, human affairs, palaces and other buildings, foreign tribes, dragons and fishes, landscapes, animals, flowers and birds, ink bamboos, and finally vegetables and fruit. 
 This sort of listing is worth knowing by a reader, who may occasionally notice that it underlies the degree of attention being paid to a theme by a critic. 
 THE SURVEY WITH A THEORY 
 The last type of survey to be considered has a basis in theory. 
 If a critic has a very decided political or religious point of view, this can override other considerations in judgements about art; the viewpoint may also give a bias to the description or interpretation made. 
 A remarkable Marxist interpretation, for example, was made of Florentine painting from Giotto's time to the fifteenth century, by Frederick Antal in the 1940s. 
 Later writers, even those sympathetic to Antal's thesis, have admitted that the argument about class conflict in the period was exaggerated, but this does not exclude the possibility that an equally unexpected approach may not throw light on some apparently exhausted topic. 
 Of course, a theorist may damage an argument through bias, perhaps excluding relevant evidence inconvenient to the case being made; but this is not a danger exclusive to theorists. 
 Omissions are most patent perhaps in surveys made with a political bias. 
 We have already mentioned in passing the state policies regarding the arts in Germany, the USSR and  China; there have been writers who followed the party lines by giving attention to those artists favoured by patronage, while neglecting others. 
 A recent survey with a viewpoint is by the American art historian, Whitney Chadwick. 
 Women, Art and Society  is a synthesis of work that has been progressing for twenty years about women and the visual arts. 
 Some women have acquired status as heroines; Rosalba Carriera, Angelica Kauffmann, Rosa Bonheur, Berthe Morisot, Paula Modersohn-Becker and K&auml;the Kollwitz have found places in a pantheon of major talent from which there ought never to have been any question of their exclusion. 
 But Chadwick makes some sensible points about the questions raised by her account which challenge common assumptions about art and society. 
 Some are connected with writings about literature, philosophy and politics which are called post-modern or post-structural. 
 Post-structuralist texts expose the role of language in deferring meaning and in constructing a subjectivity which is not fixed but is constantly negotiated through a whole range of forces &mdash; economic, social and political. 
 They have undermined long-cherished views of the writer or artist as a unique individual creating in the image of divine creation (in an unbroken chain that links father and son as in Michelangelo's God reaching towards Adam in the Sistine Chapel frescoes), and the work of art as reducible to a single &bquo;true meaning&equo;&hellip; 
 Now artistic intention can be seen more clearly as just one of many often overlapping strands &mdash; ideological, economic, social, political &mdash; that make up the work of art, whether literary text, painting, or sculpture. 
 The most difficult theoretical surveys are those which seem to promise to answer difficult questions about art in general, perhaps especially in the modern world. 
 As in books on the philosophy of art, or aesthetics, many do not in fact contain any art criticism, in the sense of description, interpretation and judgement of individual works. 
 Their strengths are rather in clearing the ground of preconceived ideas about the arts, and putting new points of view. 
 When works of art are described only those aspects of an image important to the argument are included. 
 It is in this arena that some of the fiercest intellectual fighting about art is taking place, though the contests range wider than the visual arts to politics and economics. 
 For example, Chadwick states: &bquo;There can be no simple category defined as &bquo;feminist art history&equo;, since the effect of new ideas is that &bquo;much recent scholarly writing has shifted attention from the categories &bquo;art&equo; and &bquo;artist&equo; to broader issues concerning ideologies of gender, sexuality, and power&equo;. 
 In short, from some books the reader may gain moral or political  enlightenment, but will be disappointed of developing a personal taste. 
 David Talbot Rice describes such development of taste as follows: 
 It is far better to like and admire something that is wrong, or to like and admire for the wrong reason, provided we do so sincerely, than to follow slavishly the dictates or ideas of some other person. 
 If our admiration be true, genuine, and progressive we will in the end come to admire the good and cease to admire the bad. 
 We will learn by our own experience what is best, and not by following the dogmatism of another. 
 But a subtle critic may well save us a great deal of time, pain and trouble in the learning, for he can set us aright at the outset, and by his example rather than by his assertions show us how to avoid admiring that which is unworthy. 
 ZOOMING IN: THE MONOGRAPHS 
 Monographs on Painters 
 Dictionaries describe a monograph as an account of a single subject; by this definition monographs make up one of the most common categories of art publishing. 
 A book on a single painter, for example, is a monograph. 
 There is some doubt in a grey area of differences between monographs on the one hand, and catalogues or biographies on the other. 
 For convenience, biographies will be included in the present chapter, while catalogues will be treated in the next. 
 There is a boom in publishing books about individual artists, especially those who are already well known. 
 The potential reader of a monograph on a minor artist may not find a book easily, but there are plenty of publications on Leonardo, Rembrandt or Picasso. 
 It might be thought that this was a natural consequence of the popularity of great artists, but in fact the economics of publishing result in some bizarre decisions about art books. 
 The reader with a love of art is not always at the front of a publisher's attention. 
 Art books are expensive to produce, especially if they contain colour illustrations. 
 One way for a publisher to finance the publication of an art book is to act with other publishers who will share costs; an alternative is to find a subsidy. 
 Both these strategies affect choices of subjects for art books. 
 Other publishing houses in other countries will naturally prefer artists who are already internationally well known. 
 Subsidies are available from a limited number of sources, such as government agencies, charitable foundations, and, today very rarely, private individuals; there is a factor of prestige to be counted in this sponsorship, mediated by the decisions of committees. 
  This aside, when the reader has found a monograph, what will it contain? 
 An older book, that is one published before around 1900, will only have black and white plates, which are unlikely to be photographs. 
 This applies, for example, to the book on Delacroix published in 1885, selected by A. Robaut and with an essay by Ernest Chesnau. 
 By the 1920s a characteristic book, as for example C&eacute;zanne: a study of his development  by Roger Fry, published in 1927, had black and white photographic illustrations only. 
 In either case, the absence of colour gave an incentive to the authors to provide evocative descriptions. 
 These descriptions were vital to writing about these two artists in whose work colour plays so important a part. 
 At the end of the twentieth century, at least some colour illustrations are likely to find places in a monograph. 
 They may, however, not be exactly what the author would have preferred, as a colour plate which is readily available (perhaps having been used in another publication) is much cheaper to use than a new plate which has to be commissioned. 
 The reader can thus be aware that a writer may have written round what happens to have been offered. 
 This may be important in assessing how well a writer illustrates an argument. 
 The standards which can be obtained in colour reproductions today are high, but not always attained. 
 Comparison of illustrations of the same picture in several publications will demonstrate this truism, while the best test of looking at a reproduction in front of the picture itself can be a disheartening experience. 
 A lecture audience looking at a slide projection, incidentally, may also suffer from seeing distorted colours, though art museums take some care to sell transparencies of a satisfactory quality. 
 Considerations of illustrations aside, the reader will be hoping for enlightenment from the text. 
 It is probable that this will have much to offer. 
 Monographs are a main source of considered art critical writing. 
 The author has had time to consider and reflect, so that descriptions, interpretations and evaluations will have been carefully formulated. 
 There are many choices of arrangement and treatment available to a monographer. 
 An art historian may choose to elucidate the social context of the art, or trace its sources in the work of other artists; these choices will be reflected in the illustrations as well as the text, while sketches, other versions of pictures and related material will be available for the reader to make comparisons. 
 Roger Fry, in writing about C&eacute;zanne, took a different route. 
 A painter himself, he was attracted to the problems he believed that C&eacute;zanne had faced and solved in composition and technique. 
 Fry's opening words are: &bquo;Those artists among us whose formation took place before the war recognise C&eacute;zanne as their tribal deity, and their totem.&equo; 
 Fry thought that in C&eacute;zanne's mature work:  
 The ultimate synthesis of a design was never revealed in a flash; rather he approached it with infinite precautions, stalking it, as it were, now from one point of view, now from another, and always in fear lest a premature definition might deprive it of something of its total complexity. 
 For him the synthesis was asymptote towards which he was for ever approaching without ever quite reaching it; it was a reality, incapable of complete realization. 
 An example of Fry's description of C&eacute;zanne's development dealt with colour: 
 When C&eacute;zanne uses colour we note that at each nodal point of the interplay of planes, C&eacute;zanne marks this sequence by a series of small washes of various colours, modulating generally from violet to greenish, or bluish grey. 
 His aim in this was as far as possible to translate changes of tones into changes of colour, feeling that only by this method could the full saturation and pressure of colour be realized. 
 I cannot doubt that this peculiar method which gave such valuable results in water-colour, influenced C&eacute;zanne to apply it at least to the early stages of his oil paintings, and that gradually it grew to be his habitual practice in the succeeding period. 
 In proportion, then, as we advance in the chronological sequence of his works, we find his material become less and less pastose, his touches more and more liquid and transparent, more like watercolour. 
 The change is gradual. 
 Nor is it so regular that we can trust to it altogether to fix the exact date of any given work. 
 There are returns to the impasto, but thin painting certainly predominates towards the end of the century. 
 From description to formal interpretation, we can cite part of an analysis of a portrait, Monsieur Geoffroy : 
 Its success must be partly due to the extraordinary number of sittings to which his admiring and clear-sighted sitter submitted. 
 The construction here is more erudite than in the Madame C&eacute;zanne . 
 It is less removed from the ordinary conception of a portrait arrangement. 
 The movements here are more complex, there is a less complete frontality of presentment and symmetry of design. 
 The equilibrium so consummately achieved results from the counterpoise of a great number of directions. 
 One has only to imagine what would happen if the books on the shelf behind the sitter's head were upright, like the others, to realize on what delicate adjustments the solidity of this amazing structure depends&hellip; 
 He it was who first,  among moderns at all events, conceived this method of organizing the infinite complexity of appearance by referring it to a geometrical scaffolding. 
 Though it must be remembered that this is no a priori  scheme imposed upon the appearances, but rather an interpretation gradually distilled from them by prolonged contemplation. 
 Whether Fry was justified in his interpretations of C&eacute;zanne is not our present question. 
 What is valuable is to see that here is a critic writing at the top of his bent. 
 And Fry was straightforward about his own perceptions. 
 &bquo;The critic, I hold, should be loyal enough to his own impressions to confess to what is probably due to his own defects. 
 I must admit therefore that there is one passage in this otherwise consummate design ( A Fruit Dish ) of which the meaning escapes me. 
 I cannot see the necessity of the shadow cast by a half-opened drawer in the kitchen table., It is encouraging to find Fry underlining a point about critical writing &mdash; that with a description of a work of art it can be useful to be given an explicit account of how the critic responds. 
 Another point is also made explicitly.: his difficulty is assessing C&eacute;zanne's work at the end of the century. 
 &bquo;It is more difficult to be precise about this than about the earlier phases, partly because the pictures are rarer and less accessible, and have not been adequately photographed, partly because it includes considerable variations.&equo; 
 Fry's book contains rather little biographical information, the focus being firmly on C&eacute;zanne's work. 
 There is almost nothing about the artist's contemporaries. 
 This not an invariable pattern for monographs, but readers can usually expect that the central figure of a book will receive prominence at the expense of any other artists. 
 If comparisons are included they may be with an artist whose work is considered by the author to be inferior to the subject of the monograph. 
 Biographical information is another issue. 
 A biography is not a monograph, and, indeed, there are biographies of painters which do little justice to art. 
 In such books the artists&equo; incidental activities receive undue emphasis. 
 the question of what balance can be attained in a book is a familiar problem to literary critics, who are divided in their views into at least two camps, one favouring attention being paid mostly to the text itself, while the other prefers to take other questions into account, including the effect the writer's life may have on the text. 
 Some see the conflict as having been crystallised by Proust, who wrote an attack on the critic Sainte-Beuve in 1908 (though it was not published until 1954). 
 Sainte-Beuve, as one of the most widely-read critics of the late nineteenth century, had perfected a conversational essay in which personal anecdotes, quotation, literary judgements and reflections were intermingled. 
 Proust took the view that writers should be judged by their works alone, rather than be interpreted through biography. 
 Ironists reflect  with pleasure that nevertheless one of the great literary biographies of the century has subsequently been written about Proust. 
 How valuable biographical information is to literary or art criticism is a question that will never receive a decisive answer; but a commonplace observation can be made, that circumstances alter cases. 
 Some artists separate their art from their lives, some are articulate about their aims, others are gruffly evasive. 
 C&eacute;zanne was not forthcoming in his letters or his conversation. 
 His dealer Ambroise Vollard wrote a book of reminiscences about the painter, including a famous passage about his portrait. 
 &bquo;After a hundred and fifteen sittings, C&eacute;zanne abandoned my portrait to return to Aix. 
 &bquo;The front of the shirt is not bad&equo; &mdash; such were his last words on parting.&equo; 
 The personal characters of artists cannot be infallibly deduced from their work. 
 &bquo;Art is a rum business&equo;, thought Turner, and the attentive reader of a book about artists called Born under Saturn  cannot avoid thinking that artists are unpredictable while reading through its sections on misers, criminals, celibates, debauchees, suicides, melancholics and eccentrics. 
 The authors are Rudolph and Margot Wittkower, and their theme is that while some artists succeed in financial and social circumstances without strain, other artists tend to Saturnine temperaments. 
 &bquo;Saturn is the planet of melancholics, and Renaissance philosophers discovered that the emancipated artists of their time should have the characteristics of the Saturnine temperament; they were contemplative, meditating, brooding, solitary, creative.&equo; 
 Comparable ideas about artists can be discovered in other cultures, but also very different views. 
 Even in Europe, Saturn is not the only planet under whose influence it is possible to be born. 
 &bquo;Mercury is the patron of cheerful, lively men of action. 
 According to ancient tradition, craftsmen, among others, are born under his sign.&equo; 
 Beyond which, a disbeliever in astrology can find quite other ways of categorising artists. 
 A final caution about using monographs about painters is that they can seldom be read alone. 
 Historical background is only compressed in a monograph; biographical material may be more extensive in other sources; the painter's contemporaries will not receive much attention, and may be slighted. 
 Even illustrations may not be adequate, details of pictures often being poorly represented, leaving an artist's techniques, materials and handling to be discovered from more specialist studies. 
 The reader can hope, all the same, that the writer will give an account of the special merits of key pictures, and it is these art critical passages which can be of most help in enjoying or appreciating the chosen artist's achievement.  
 BIOGRAPHIES 
 A biography of an artist is a tricky proposition for a writer, since the artist may prefer to be judged through art, not life; the incidentals of an everyday activity, not altogether under the artist's control, are rather unimportant compared to the artist's concentrated effort to create paintings or sculpture. 
 The biographer may come up against problems of concealment, both written records and works having been destroyed. 
 Early work is often missing from an artist's oeuvre, while student work or juvenilia may be saved only by chance or possibly by a devoted family. 
 Lionello Venturi considered lives of artists made up a basic category of art criticism, buttressing his opinion with accounts of writings by Vasari and others. 
 However, if biographies of artists are carefully examined, it will be found that they do not necessarily contain much art criticism at all; a biographer may prefer not to express personal views about the artist's work; a book's main thrust may be to describe the artist's own aims and ideas. 
 This will result in the book evading the task of art criticism altogether, though the critical views of the artist may be recorded. 
 A deferential biographer is especially likely to take this line. 
 An exception may be illustrated by a passage from a classic biography, that of John Constable by Charles Leslie. 
 Leslie was himself a painter, and thus comments in his own right on his friend's art, as here on a painting of Hampstead Heath: 
 I have before noticed that what are commonly called warm colours are not necessary to produce the impression of warmth in landscape; and this picture affords, to me, the strongest possible proof of the truth of this. 
 The sky is of the blue of an English summer day, with large, but not threatening, clouds of a silvery whiteness. 
 The distance is of a deep blue, and the near trees and grass of the freshest green; for Constable could never consent to parch up the verdure of nature to obtain warmth. 
 These tints are balanced by a very little warm colour on a road and gravel pit in the foreground, a single house in the middle distance, and the scarlet jacket of a labourer. 
 Yet I know of no picture in which the mid-day heat of Midsummer is so admirably expressed; and were not the eye refreshed by the shade thrown over a great part of the foreground by some young trees, that border the road, and the cool blue of water near it, one would wish, in looking at it, for a parasol, as Fuseli wished for an umbrella when standing before one of Constable's showers. 
 Such a passage is exceptional in Leslie's book, which, in the Victorian manner, was a memoir with extensive quotations from Constable's letters. 
 Constable's own personality and opinions are thus the main gain of a  reader from Leslie's book. 
 To borrow a phrase from a biography of Van Gogh, the writer had had the advantage of having the artist as a coauthor. 
 This phrase comes from Carl Nordenfalk's book, The Life and Work of Van Gogh , first published in 1943 (in English in 1953). 
 Nordenfalk starts his preface as follows. 
 Van Gogh's life has so often been made the subject of literary treatment that the art historian is strongly inclined to leave the biographical matter severely alone and concentrate exclusively on the artistic aspect. 
 But he is soon forced to the conclusion that in this case it is impossible to keep the aesthetic side entirely apart from the biographical. 
 The reason is that with Van Gogh art and life are not merely conditioned by each other to a greater degree than with any other artist, but actually merge with each other. 
 In a sense, Van Gogh's life is itself an artistic creation. 
 Van Gogh as the subject for a biographer is thus a test case. 
 Nordenfalk's book includes the scrupulous examination of visual evidence always welcome and often found in writing by a museum curator. 
 Here he describes the impact of Impressionism on Van Gogh's work in the spring of 1887: 
 He had resolutely abandoned his old palette and the method of mixing complementary colours to dirty intermediate tones of grey. 
 Instead, he put a rich range of clear rainbow colours on his palette, replacing the dirty ochre colours with light and more luminous chromium colours, with the addition of Veronese green, ultramarine and lacquer colours, and following the Impressionist recipe in not mixing these colours with anything except white or closely allied colours. 
 Interpretation of the artist's work, however, depends on the artist's own account, since Nordenfalk had &bquo;the deliberate intention of presenting Van Gogh the writer and thinker&equo;. 
 The sober intentions of his book were very different from the novels, plays and films which have created a mythical figure in modern culture of the artist as isolated and neglected, recognised only after his death, and whom the phrase &bquo;genius and madness are near aligned&equo; seems to fit. 
 The novel Lust for Life  by Irving Stone, published in 1934, is the most famous of these productions, popularising a vein of interpretation established early in the century by some of Van Gogh's first advocates, such as the taste-maker Julius Meier-Graefe, who defended Van Gogh in 1906, and went on to write a book in his praise in 1921 called Vincent . 
 But this was a drama, the story of the circumstances of Van Gogh's life; &bquo;No attempt has  been made,&equo; wrote Meier-Graefe, &bquo;to make a critical analysis of the pictures, which enter upon the scene only in so far as they concern the drama directly or indirectly.&equo; 
 ARTISTS&equo; OWN WRITING 
 Van Gogh is famous not only for his art, but for his writing. 
 He did not write an autobiography, but his letters have been a source of fascination to a wide audience, especially artists. 
 Luckily, he had a correspondent in his brother Theo in whom he could confide and with whom he could explore ideas about art; the letters are thus an invaluable source of interpretation. 
 From the distance of a century, some of Van Gogh's enthusiastic appraisals of the art of his time look curious; but then, this artist acting as a critic was especially vulnerable to admiring art with a moral purpose, or work from which he was able to draw inspiration. 
 Private letters are like a conversation overheard, often more revealing than an autobiography, or than a diary which may have been written with more than half an intention of allowing it to be published. 
 What private letters from an artist can do best is to elucidate what was uppermost in an artist's mind at the time, often artistic aims which would be difficult to discover otherwise. 
 Besides which, there are some artists whom it is a pleasure to know even a little better from their letters. 
 Many readers must have sighed with regret that so few of Gainsborough's letters have survived, since the charm of his style is so fresh; it is easy to sympathise with him writing about his professional commitment to portraiture, on behalf of two fine ladies, his daughters: 
 I'm sick of Portraits and wish very much to take my viol-da-gamba and walk off to some sweet village, where I can paint landskips and enjoy the fag-end of life in quietness and ease. 
 But these fine ladies and their tea-drinkings, husband-huntings, etc., etc., etc., will job me out of the last ten years, and I fear miss getting husbands too. 
 But we can say nothing to these things you know Jackson, we must jog on and be content with the jingling of the bells, only d &mdash; it, I hate a dust, and kicking up a dust, and being confined in harness while others ride in the waggon, under cover, stretching their legs in the straw at ease, and gazing at green trees and blue skies without half my Taste . 
 Artists on their travels sometimes write letters which are good value, whether in praise or censure of what they see. 
 Lawrence, for example, was in Parma in 1820, in ecstasy over the work of Correggio: 
 Four times I went on long visits to the St Jerome, his finest work. 
  How beautiful, how devoid of everything like the handicraft of art it is &mdash; the largeness, and yet ingenuity of its effect &mdash; the purity of its colour &mdash; the truth, yet refinement and elegance of the action, particularly of the hands (in which he particularly excels); and then, a lesson to all high-minded slovens, the patient vigilance with which the whole is linked together, by touches, in some instances small almost as a miniature, but like the sparkling of water. 
 Diaries are perhaps more often a vehicle for complaints. 
 Here is an American artist writing about his dismay at the work he saw at Paris in 1831: 
 Although I had been informed that the present French artists were low in merit, I did not expect to find them, with little exception, so totally devoid of it. 
 I was disgusted in the beginning with their subjects. 
 Battle, Murder, and Death, Venuses and Psyches, the bloody and voluptuous, are the things in which they seem to delight: and these are portrayed in a cold, hard, and often tawdry style, with an almost universal deficiency of chiaroscuro; the whole artificial,  labored  and theatrical. 
 Thomas Cole was not a diarist on the scale or with the range of one of the French painters, surely respected even by him, Eug&egrave;ne Delacroix. 
 Delacroix's journal is articulate, concerned with other arts as well as painting, besides containing much comment on contemporary life. 
 A passage of analogies in painting and poetry comes from September 1847. 
 &bquo;I see in painters prose writers and poets. 
 Rhyme, measure, and the turning of verses, which is indispensable and which gives them so much  vigor , are analogous to the hidden symmetry, to the equilibrium at once wise and inspired, which governs the meeting or separation of lines and spaces, the echoes of  color , etc.&equo; poetic painting was Delacroix's preference, but &bquo;David's picture of Leonidas at Thermopolae  is masculine and vigorous prose, I admit&equo;. 
 In another passage in 1853, this time about The Bathers , a painting by Courbet, he invokes the aesthetic standards of music. 
 He did not like Courbet's subject. 
 &bquo;The commonness and the uselessness of the thought are abominable; and if only his idea, common and useless as it is, were clear&hellip; 
 Oh, Rossini! 
 Oh, Mozart! 
 Oh, geniuses inspired in all the arts, who draw from things only such elements of them as are to be shown to the mind! 
 What would you say before these pictures!&equo; 
 Artists' writing on art can naturally be more practical or technical, even in defining their own aims. 
 The virtue of artists' writings for the reader of criticism is that it can often serve as a touchstone for judging the worth of mediators, particularly those presenting views of what the artist intended; what the artist said may be more to the point.  
 SCULPTURAL MONOGRAPHS 
 Books about sculpture have problems all of their own. 
 The first and most obvious difficulty is that a three-dimensional object cannot fit satisfactorily on to a flat page. 
 Different views of a sculpture can be presented, but you cannot move round a sculpture except with a film camera. 
 There is also the problem of settings. 
 Some sculptures are designed for their sites, and the relationship between site and sculpture is difficult to capture in a book. 
 Sculpture parks are an enjoyable innovation of the late twentieth century, or perhaps it would be better to say a welcome adaptation of an existing practice. 
 In the seventeenth century Louis XIV had a sculpture park at Versailles, but it surrounded his palace, and was more formally designed by Le N&ocirc;tre, who needed sculptures for the focal points of his avenues. 
 Twentieth-century sculpture parks are less rigidly planned, and intended to accommodate sculpture by artists in many different styles. 
 The site can be adapted to suit the sculpture, which has a dominant role, unlike sculpture destined for the decoration of palatial gardens. 
 Commemorative figures in city squares, portrait busts, tomb or cemetery furniture have also been traditionally restricted by the terms of commissions. 
 A consequence of this tradition is that the sculptor's own personality may receive less prominence in a monograph than a painter's, as the effect of patronage given or withheld can be decisive in a sculptor's career. 
 The other major role of the sculptor is in the service of religion, where a high degree of interplay between artist and patron is not necessarily so important, making the sculptor's situation into one which is more like the painter's. 
 Writing on Auguste Rodin can make the point. 
 According to George Heard Hamilton, Rodin became &bquo;a figure of international significance, the most admired, prolific, and influential sculptor since Bernini&equo;. 
 His secretary, the poet Rainer Maria Rilke, wrote with feeling about his work, but during the 1920s Rodin was less regarded, and not until after the Second World War did his reputation revive under the stimulus of exhibitions and increasingly careful cataloguing of his work. 
 A decline of the sculptor's reputation derived not only from the political discredit into which the regimes of the years before 1914 had fallen, but also from a distaste for allegory, and a revulsion from naturalist sculpture (which the young Brancusi expressed forcefully as a dislike for &bquo;beefsteak&equo;). 
 With the rise of modernism, Rodin's reputation fell; with the decline of modernism, Rodin's fame is growing again. 
 Rodin was a skilful salesman of his work, making careful use of photography in establishing and maintaining his good name. 
 After 1900, he insisted that no photography of his work was allowed without his permission. 
 There was a healthy demand for prints and postcards, which  added to his income from the arrangements he had with photographers and agencies. 
 As Albert Elsen has noted: 
 We know that with major sculptures such as The Burghers of Calais  and the Balzac , Rodin did not claim that they were equally successful from all points of view. 
 He believed that these monuments succeeded compositionally from five or six angles. 
 Given Rodin's collaboration with his photographers, these old photographs go far in answering the question from which points of view and from what distances they should be seen. 
 What was true of Rodin's sculpture is also worth consideration by any reader of a sculptural monograph. 
 Another aspect of the matter is the question of scale. 
 Reproduced to a uniform size on the printed page, sculptures which are monumental in size cannot be distinguished from those which are mere studies or maquettes. 
 There is the possibility of misinterpretation by the reader. 
 Some compensation may exist in sketches and preliminary drawings, where they exist, and which are easier to study on a page. 
 These may take either the form of related drawings, or in Rodin's case, a free style of drawing which demonstrates his power of vivid creative improvisation with the human figure. 
 A further issue is how well sculptures are suited to their sites. 
 Sculptural monographs often contain little information on this topic, and photographs of sculptures in situ  are missing. 
 Further, public response to works in prominent positions is rarely commented on. 
 Yet for a work in a public square this is an interesting aspect of art criticism. 
 Perhaps in the last decade of this century something of a change in attitude to sculpture is becoming evident. 
 The spaces in a city are more valued, and their enhancing is more a matter of public concern. 
 Sculptures in cities are a part of cultural history, and can be the symbols by which the cities are known or remembered. 
 Rome is distinguished by the statue on the Capitoline Hill of Marcus Aurelius; New York, even the United States, is symbolised by the Statue of Liberty; Copenhagen is remembered for its mermaid. 
 Also, the history of sculpture includes some account of the abortive plans for sculpture, just as the history of architecture is incomplete as a history of ideas without a knowledge of rejected proposals. 
 Even though the same might be argued for painting, the technical obstacles to be overcome for painting are very much less than for sculpture. 
 Again, this is where sculpture is closely aligned to social and political history.  
 MONOGRAPHS ON INDIVIDUAL WORKS 
 An art monograph need not be about a person, but can be about an individual work or a scheme such as a mural decoration. 
 This is a fine opportunity for a sustained piece of writing, calling on a range of historical and artistic data, and including the art critical views not only of the author, but also criticism written at other periods. 
 A recent monograph of Jacob Epstein's memorial sculpture to the naturalist W. H. Hudson at Hyde Park Corner may be used as an example. 
 Terry Friedman's book contains fourteen chapters, which chart the development of the work and its public reception &mdash; a stormy one. 
 The topics include the first design, the sculptor's aims, the carving of the work, the memorial's defenders and attackers, and a final general reflection on the standing of great art and how it is likely to provoke opposition. 
 The monograph is accompanied by a facsimile of a sketchbook for the memorial, and documented by letters and printed sources, including articles in the press. 
 the art criticism of the day is fully described in the monograph, and some of the underlying reasons for its mainly aggressive character are outlined; these include anti-Semitism and the fierce dislike of the monument by some academic sculptors. 
 A guide to London public sculpture described the monument as &bquo;A masterpiece by the much-advertised apostle of Ugliness&equo;, a view shared by those who felt that Hudson the nature lover was ill commemorated by a sculpture which showed nature in so raw a state. 
 Comparisons of the sculpture with other contemporary works are included, and a summary conclusion implies the eventual security of the controversial sculpture in its Hyde Park home. 
 The Hudson memorial is not widely known, but the scope of this monograph is exemplary. 
 Similar treatment can be found in works on great monuments and schemes, perhaps especially in the Italian Renaissance, when such projects as the Sistine Chapel or Tintoretto's Scuola di San Rocco achieved a personal artistic unity of the highest standard. 
 for art historians, incomplete schemes or dismembered works such as altarpieces have the attraction of needing detective work; but a critic takes an interest in a reconstruction only if it throws new light on surviving art. 
 The main strength of this sort of monograph is its potential for detailed interpretation. 
 As a book on a single subject, there is a good chance that the need for description will be reduced by extensive illustration, while a favourable judgement on the work has already been implied by the choice of the subject for a monograph. 
 The interpretation of imagery, the circumstances of production, the place of the work in the artist's career, the historical context, the precise information about the work's appearance and condition, these are things that can be fully discussed in a monograph.  
 VERSATILE ARTISTS 
 A monograph on an artist who practises in several fields can be unusually interesting, since the writer's brief is to write with equal competence on different topics. 
 Occasionally the challenge is too daunting, and teams of writers combine forces rather than one author attempting to rival the knowledge and skills of a Leonardo. 
 More frequently work in different media is split up into specialist studies, so that although there are general studies of Gauguin's work, there are also specialist monographs on his prints, and on his sculpture and ceramics. 
 The versatile artist raises the question of relationship between the arts, and how far they can be considered to have the same or similar aims. 
 In the nineteenth century it was Richard Wagner whose extraordinary ambition it was to make a complete artistic environment, in which the arts would blend. 
 Historians can point to the philosophical views which underlay this ambition, and artists and sculptors were in various ways affected by the demonstration of its realisation in the theatre built for the composer at Bayreuth. 
 The collaboration of artists with the stage was also brought to a high point by Serge Diaghilev, in his commissions to artists for the Russian Ballet. 
 This connection between painting and the theatre was important to earlier European art in religious as well as secular performances. 
 Critics no less than artists have wide interests in the arts, and may introduce comparisons in their interpretations. 
 In the nineteenth century to say that a picture was poetic was a common term of praise. 
 In the present century emphasis on formal qualities in the visual arts have made musical comparisons more frequent, emphasised by the use by artists of musical terminology, as when Kandinsky chose to call his works Improvisations and Compositions. 
 According to this formalist approach art aspires to the condition of music, a phrase employed by Pater, but deriving from classical Greece. 
 Clearly artists working in several media have a wide range of references. 
 The art critic is thus bound to consider with care what standards of comparison should be used. 
 In the late twentieth century artists working in performance pose difficulties for the critic, though some observers find it refreshing rather than troublesome to consider work beyond the easel picture and the individual sculpture. 
 In sum, then, the monograph is a major site for art critical writing, and, moreover, the place where the most extended criticism is likely to appear. 
 The reader may be disappointed by the standard of what is written, but unlike other sites of criticism, this cannot be attributed to the form of publication, only to the limitations of the author. 
 In a monograph, the author has the best chance of a free hand.  
 PANNING ANGLES: THE CATALOGUES 
 CATALOGUES RAISONN&Eacute;S 
 The second half of the nineteenth century saw new standards achieved in art historical scholarship, both through the careful study of documents and by close scrutiny of works of art. 
 The results of these studies were published extensively in catalogues of private and public collections, and in what in French are termed catalogues raisonn&eacute;s , that is to say complete lists of artists' works. 
 Such catalogues were important to scholarship and also to the art market. 
 If a scholar authenticated a work as by a major artist, then its price was certain to be higher. 
 A hero of this period was Giovanni Morelli, a remarkable Italian connoisseur who started publishing essays on pictures in public collections in 1874. 
 His decisive opinions about the correct attributions of authorship in pictures were founded on a personal method, partly inspired by his medical training. 
 He paid close attention to characteristics in a painting so apparently insignificant as the shape of a nostril or the lobe of an ear, arguing that such details were too unimportant for a follower to copy exactly. 
 For example, Morelli wrote: &bquo;In all those works by Raphael in which the execution is entirely his own , the ear, like the hand, is always characteristic, and differs in form from the ears of Timoteo Viti, Perugino, Pinturicchio, and others.&equo; 
 Typically, Morelli participated in one of the Swiss glacial expeditions organised by Louis Agassiz. 
 Agassiz later became the foremost zoological teacher in the United States, basing his teaching practice on the observation of nature. 
 Agassiz discouraged the use of books, except for research work. 
 One story about his teaching is that a new student would be told to observe a fish in a tank. 
 After some time the student would return to  report. 
 &bquo;Look again,&equo; he would be told. 
 After a week, Agassiz's object lesson in respect for examining nature had made its impact. 
 Morelli's insistence on observation was a comparable approach to learning. 
 Morelli's method was extended by other scholars, and joined to systematic examination of documents. 
 One of Morelli's youthful students was Bernard Berenson, whom Morelli described in 1890 as &bquo;an extraordinarily scholarly young man who had already advanced far in the study of art&equo;. 
 The young Berenson was a polymath, whose brilliant career at Harvard led his friends to pay for him to visit Europe to continue his studies. 
 It was in Berlin that he first read Morelli's work. 
 Four years after their meeting he published an account of Venetian painters of the Renaissance, where he acknowledged &bquo;his indebtedness to the first systematic writers on Italian painting no less than to the perfectors of the new critical method, now adopted by nearly all serious students of Italian art&equo;. 
 Berenson had found his vocation: &bquo;to be sure that every Lotto is a Lotto, every Cariani a Cariani, every Santecroce a Santacroce&equo;. 
 His book on Lorenzo Lotto, published in 1895, was subtitled &bquo;An Essay in Constructive Art Criticism&equo;. 
 He spent the rest of his life in expertise, painstakingly cataloguing the pictures and drawings of his favoured period, the Italian Renaissance, and in giving advice, notably to the great Bostonian collector, Mrs Gardner, and the main dealer of the period, Joseph Duveen. 
 Berenson's decisions on attributions are listed in a reference catalogue, The Italian Paintings of the Renaissance . 
 The Morellian method had opponents, among them some of the German scholars of whom Morelli made fun by his articles. 
 His judgements were impressive nevertheless, so that some critics were reduced to agreeing with his conclusions while denying the validity of his system. 
 Before his day, and after it, there were scholars who relied more on intuition. 
 Max Friedlander, an outstanding scholar of Northern European art, took the view that accepting a work into an artist's oeuvre was like recognising a friend, not a matter of measurement or detailed scrutiny. 
 The reader is thus relying on Friedlander's eye. 
 A difference between Morelli and Friedlander is that the former explains his method, while the latter does not. 
 More than a hundred years have passed since Morelli started writing; in that time many problems of authorship have been solved, while about others tacit agreement has been reached. 
 The results of this process can be read in detail in catalogues raisonn&eacute;s, which often give a blow-by-blow account of the arguments of scholars over the years. 
 Here is a summary account of Manet's favourite painting by Tintoretto, the self-portrait in the Louvre. 
 It comes from a book on Tintoretto by Hans Tietze (the references are left out). 
 On the engraving of the picture made by Gisbert van Geen in 1588, for which Pozzoferrato supplied the ornamental framework and  which Ridolfi reproduced in his biography, Tintoretto is described as being seventy years old. 
 According to this the picture must have been painted about 1588, with which the style and the age of the sitter agree. 
 From a letter to Francesco Gonzaga, written in 1622 and published by A. Luzio, in which among others a self-portrait of Tintoretto is offered to him, Pittalunga argues that the Paris picture may have been the one mentioned and which formed part of Rubens's estate. 
 This sort of reading is only for the dedicated follower of the history of taste, though any reader particularly interested in a picture may find within a single catalogue entry an acutely discriminating judgement or interesting facts; for example, Tietze's entry also points out that Manet so much admired the Tintoretto self-portrait that he made a copy of it. 
 The catalogue raisonn&eacute; continues to be a key document for authentication of an artist's work. 
 As the decades have gone by, scholarly work has piled up, so that this category of book has taken a larger, longer and much more expensive form than before. 
 Today catalogues raisonn&eacute;s are often divided into two; one volume is for an introduction and plates, while the other has the detailed catalogue. 
 Disputes over authorship are fiercely fought, and in the nature of things, frequently impossible to resolve with finality. 
 However, the reputation of the cataloguer may be in some instances considered decisive; the picture is by Van Gogh if it is in the book by de la faille; a painting by Berthe Morisot needs to be approved by Bataille and Wildenstein; an authentic work by Picasso will be found in Zervos. 
 Problems of authenticity are not so great or modern art as for other periods, even if a gifted forger like the painter Elmir de Horty can fool some of the people for some of the time. 
 Catalogues raisonn&eacute;s of modern artists do not depend on scholarly guesswork at attributions, and thus lack the laconic critical judgements reached by connoisseurs. 
 In compensation, pictures or sculptures may be accompanied by comments from the artists. 
 Additionally, the cataloguer will be sure to make comparisons, which will be useful to the reader, for the format is one of the few in which a generous number of illustrations can be included. 
 Any compiler of a catalogue raisonn&eacute; will have seen and compared all the works listed, or will scruple to state if some work has proved inaccessible. 
 At this level of personal and intimate experience there is little competition from other observers; only a handful of people in the world will ever see all the works in a catalogue raisonn&eacute;. 
 The scholar who completes such a work thus has an edge on other writers, so a preface can be read with the respect due to a first-hand account of the works concerned and a considered piece of reflective criticism.  
 EXHIBITION CATALOGUES 
 Exhibitions are major arenas for spectators of art, as well as for artists' struggles to achieve reputations and recognition. 
 This section will consider not what the critics write in reviews of exhibitions, but the criticism which is contained within the exhibition catalogues; not the commentary from the box, but the programme of events. 
 A first broad division between types of exhibitions needs to be made. 
 There are shows which could be grouped under the heading of historical exhibitions; there are mixed exhibitions and group exhibitions of works by living artists; and there are exhibitions in dealers' galleries, notably solo shows. 
 The catalogues which accompany these events have rather different characters, for although there are entries for the exhibited works in each sort of catalogue, and usually an introduction, historical catalogues often have additional essays. 
 Catalogues of major shows have also become bigger and more expensive in recent years, usually through the help of national, industrial or commercial sponsorship. 
 A characteristic historical exhibition may be called something like &bquo;The Age of Rembrandt&equo;, or &bquo;Shock of Recognition; the landscape of English Romanticism and the Dutch seventeenth-century school&equo;; both of these are actual titles. 
 Such catalogues include accounts of relevant historical research, and may cause new original historical work to be done. 
 Individual works may be studied more carefully for a catalogue entry than ever before. 
 In several ways, then, a catalogue may be in advance of any other publications. 
 The corollary is that some catalogue information has only a limited life, since it may in its turn be overtaken by new research. 
 In the introduction or other essays there may be some writing which will not date, such as art criticism which documents the personal experience of the writer. 
 Take, for example, this record of a personal response to Picasso's sculpture The Man with a Sheep  by the critic Tim Hilton in the catalogue for &bquo;Picasso's Picassos, in 1981: 
 The Man with a Sheep  is said to be humanitarian; that is far from one's experience in front of it, and the assertion is not much supported by the iconographical evidence. 
 Is this a king who is the shepherd of his people? 
 Or a priest of some unknown religion who strides towards us, implacably set on some atavistic rite? 
 In the drawings the lamb appears to have bound feet, and the purport of the piece is surely more to do with sacrifice than deliverance. 
 Some art criticism in a catalogue may be included so as to document the history of taste. 
 For example, in &bquo;The Shock of Recognition&equo; John Constable's love for the work of van Ruisdael is highlit. 
 Another entry, for  The Ancient Oak  by Jan van Goyen (painted in 1642) seeks to explain a later English attitude to a seventeenth-century work: 
 The ancient, weathered oak is the main motif, a theme as much used and loved by the Romantic poets and painters as the old willow tree. 
 The execution, however, and this is typical of the 17th century Dutch masters, is more minute; and the composition, completely determined by a diagonal, is stricter than that of the English painters. 
 According to 18th century principles the painting is &bquo;sublime&equo; in the roughness and irregularity of the tree, as well as &bquo;beautiful&equo; in the smoothness of the water. 
 An instructive and recent example of a historical exhibition is &bquo;Making Their Mark&equo;, toured in the United States during 1989. 
 The subtitle of the show was &bquo;Women artists move into the mainstream, 1970 &mdash; 1985&equo;. 
 The catalogue is 300 pages long with eight essays, as well as artists' biographies. 
 In this instance the individual exhibited items are unnumbered and put in a check list; the main critical writing is within 136 pages, written in ten sections by Judith E. Stein (six sections) and Ann-Sargent Wooster (four sections on video). 
 Such a catalogue inevitably tends to describe and characterise artists rather than evaluate them, while interpretation is likely to be left to quotations from the artists. 
 Here is a passage about a picture by Judy Rifka: &bquo; In Square Dress , a dancer, seen from above, is set off against an exuberant field of abstract  color  patches and architecturally evocative lines and circles. 
 Segments of the athletic composition push forward into the viewer's space because Rifka has affixed additional forms onto the surface plane.&equo; 
 Elsewhere, Thomas McEvilley writes: &bquo;One day in 1970 fifty thousand women marched down fifth Avenue in New York. 
 It is said to have been the biggest women's gathering since suffrage days, a little more than half a century before&hellip; 
 H. W. Janson's History of Art , the standard college textbook, did not at that time mention a single woman artist&equo;; and in discussing the period reviewed by the exhibition, various choices of media made by women artists are chronicled, for, &bquo;Many women artists eschewed painting &mdash; especially abstract painting &mdash; as a domain polluted by long saturation with male dominant values, and developed their themes in performance.&equo; 
 On the central issue raised by the subtitle of the show, art in or out of the mainstream, some statistical study was made of the representation of women artists and the milestones in their careers. 
 The catalogue as a whole is thus a document in the history of taste, a historical account, and at the same time contains some art criticism, not always explicit in evaluating the works shown. 
 &bquo;Making Their Mark&equo; could equally well have been called a mixed exhibition; but this is a term more often used for a show put on by an  exhibiting society, that type of artists' organisation whose importance in Europe was created by the middle classes, who sought in the eighteenth century to buy pictures rather than give commissions, as aristocratic patrons had been accustomed to do. 
 Mixed exhibitions tend to have rather perfunctory introductions and catalogue entries; the same is often true of exhibitions arranged by groups of artists, though they may have statements of aim or even an artists' manifesto. 
 Generally, art criticism connected with mixed and group exhibitions is commentary from outside, so that we shall return to them, with only this brief mention here, in the next chapter. 
 We can consider solo exhibitions instead, in either public or commercial galleries. 
 Major art museums may devote considerable resources to an individual artist's exhibition, on the same scale as a historical show. 
 But one feature of a catalogue of an exhibition for a living artist which is different is the likely inclusion of reminiscences from colleagues and members of the artist's family, who may make enlightening comments. 
 A dealer will have chosen his critic with special care for an introduction, an ideal candidate often being a sympathetic friend, perhaps a curator. 
 In 1904 Sidney Colvin was Keeper of Prints and Drawings at the British Museum. 
 Colvin had known Burne-Jones, and was persuaded to write a preface for a London gallery show. 
 His text preserves a careful balance between deference, quotation and his own selective critical comment: 
 The nature of Burne-Jones's aims and predilections in art are well-enough known by this time, and have been defined by himself absolutely fitted to this thought: &bquo;I mean by a picture a beautiful romantic dream of something that never was, never will be &mdash; in a light better than any light that ever shone &mdash; in a land no one can define or remember, only desire.&equo; 
 If any one element in his style is to be singled out as predominant, it is that haunting expression of far-away desire never absent from the eyes and lips, and conveyed in every gesture, feature and attitude. 
 Giacometti was an artist with very different artistic aims, clearly expounded by Valerie J. Fletcher in a catalogue for an exhibition at the Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden, Washington, in 1988. 
 Writing about a small bust on a column, a thin sculpture in a series of four busts of which the others were fuller in form, she comments that &bquo;the extremely thin proportions of the head contrast with the solidity of the base. 
 So delicately modulated are the forms of the head that the human element appears ephemeral. 
 This tenuous fragility contrasts with the three later busts on a stele, which have substantial anatomical forms.&equo; 
 The sculptor had decided that he wanted this bust to confront the observer. 
 &bquo;In these sculptures I tried to make an eye. 
 I raised the head on a base until the eye  is at eye level. 
 You see an eye.&equo; 
 This intention differed from the sculptor's frequent artistic aim to make his small figures appear remote. 
 The catalogue has the additional interest of a memoir by Silvio Berthoud, who had sat as a boy between five and eight for his uncle: 
 I have very unpleasant recollections of sitting for him, for it was of utmost importance not to move but to fix him right in the eye and listen to him complain, saying as he always did that he was getting nowhere. 
 It was not much fun, particularly at my age&hellip; 
 Things would deteriorate rather quickly, for Alberto would return to his hotel in the evening with a sculpture eight to twelve inches tall under his arm and come back the next day with a piece no more than three or four inches high&hellip; 
 I later realized that I had posed during a crucial period, and the tiny bronzes that resulted (for that size prevailed) continue daily to touch me. 
 Another example from the 1980s allows us to hear a conversation between the critic Norbert Lynton and the painter Ken Kiff. 
 Kiff set out to make an image of a man writing. 
 Mayakovsky's poem &bquo;An Amazing Adventure of Vladimir Mayakovsky&equo; surfaced as he worked. 
 It celebrates creativity amid doubt and despondency &mdash; creativity as energy but also as a duty, work to be done by man as it is the sun's task to shine. 
 I have pointed out to him that his picture echoes the medieval and Renaissance formula for St John on Patmos writing the Book of Revelation and for the evangelists writing the Gospels, itself derived from Greco-Roman author portraits. 
 This was not his intention but iconographical echoes of this sort do not surprise him. 
 The writer goes on to make further points about the picture's elements. 
 These examples of catalogues containing helpful art criticism could be contrasted with many others which are limited to lists of exhibitions, details of the artist's career, and entries for the works displayed. 
 There are other hazards for the readers of catalogues. 
 Some publications are less impartial than they might appear, erring on the side of generosity. 
 Museums with exhibitions of art from other countries are especially likely to be respectful in commentaries on works of art which have been borrowed. 
 All the same, museum curators will have carried out a critical task in selecting the exhibition, in some instances having fended off proposals for inclusions with a political or a particular cultural bias. 
 In a commercial gallery, the size of the rooms is decisive. 
 It might make artistic sense for the gallery to borrow some key picture to enhance the look of an exhibition, but a picture which is not for sale is an expensive  use of wall space. 
 Finally it is safe to predict that in any catalogue there will be more information than art criticism. 
 AUCTION CATALOGUES 
 Buying and selling art is at its most dramatic in an auction, a fact that auction houses are quick to exploit. 
 In the last three decades there has been considerable success for auctioneering, both in terms of money and also in prestige. 
 The idea that a price at auction is a definitive market price has even become quite generally accepted, although in fact auctions are subject to manipulation like other markets described by some economists as free. 
 An undeniable attraction of an auction is the possibility that some undervalued item may be for sale. 
 The auction houses employ considerable skill to ensure that the best possible prices are obtained for their clients, but all the same, a good eye and a well-stocked memory may still outwit their expertise. 
 An occasional exploit deservedly catches the newspaper headlines, like the case of a picture spotted by a London dealer, David Carritt. 
 Sothebys were unfortunate enough to misattribute a French eighteenth-century picture, which was in fact by Fragonard. 
 Carritt bought it, correctly identified it as a lost early work, and magnanimously sold it to the National Gallery, London, far below the market price. 
 Auction catalogues do not carry critical comments on individual items for sale, but there are sometimes introductions with criticism. 
 An example is the catalogue of paintings by No&euml;l Coward, which was prefaced by a memoir of the playwright, describing his interest in painting. 
 In marketing a sale of rather little-known works, too, there may be some explanatory text. 
 It would be wrong to dismiss this sort of criticism as mere sales talk, particularly in grand auctioneers' catalogues, though there is little danger of such publications being reticent. 
 Part of the charm of a sale is that the financial result is in itself a sort of critical judgement, reflecting even if not defining the taste and mood of the moment. 
 But an auction is mainly a bullish market; vendors are trying to improve their prices, and few except dealers are selling on the market's way down, in order to rebuy. 
 This bearish tactic does not work as well as in a stock market, for art works are widely dispersed, and decisions to buy or sell may be thoroughly unpredictable. 
 One view of the art market is that it is like a staircase with several landings. 
 Only dealers sell on the steps, while private owners prefer the more certain floor of a landing of clearly established prices for a category of work. 
 Correct descriptions are important to auctioneers, as can be exemplified by the coding used to list paintings. 
 This is the system used by Sothebys: 
 (a) references to signatures, inscription and dates refer to the present state of the work;  (b) the term &bquo;bears a signature&equo; and/or &bquo;date&equo; and/or &bquo;inscription&equo; means that in our opinion the artist's name and/or &bquo;date&equo; and/or inscription have been added by another hand; (c) the term &bquo;signed&equo; and/or &bquo;dated&equo; and/or &bquo;inscribed&equo; means that in our opinion the signature and/or date and/or inscription are from the hand of the artist. 
 Such caution is prudent in a business where errors of judgement can be extremely expensive; at least the reader of an auction catalogue knows clearly what view has been taken by the cataloguer on a number of questions. 
 The auction catalogue can also quote from other authorities, which will be inevitable in a case where a scholar has written a catalogue raisonn&eacute;, and advantageous if the context of the work is made clearer by the artist's correspondence or other publications. 
 Long catalogue entries recall the cynical remark that the price of a painting is in ratio to the length of the bibliography in the sale catalogue. 
 Besides seeking to establish the authenticity of works in the sale room, auctioneers are also concerned that the title to ownership is secure. 
 The indirect evidence of critical approval by a succession of owners may be interesting to a reader, though admittedly this demands some special knowledge about the standing of the collectors concerned. 
 Luckily for the curious, this historical sideline can be followed up in a number of publications, both about individuals and institutions. 
 The authentication of works of art from other parts of the world can be problematic. 
 For African art, say, the difficulties are complicated by lack of written or other corroboration, and knowledge that extensive copying has been done. 
 Thefts of art works are also an international problem, especially poignant in the case of objects with cultural and religious significance. 
 Occasionally auctions contain items so interesting that critics in newspapers comment on their quality, not just the prices they might fetch. 
 More often auctions are not reviewed; this is a pity, since the management of markets in art deserves scrutiny. 
 The visitor to an auction may be caught up in the excitement and drama of the event, but the climate of opinion in which it takes place has been created by scholars and critics as well as businessmen. 
 MUSEUM CATALOGUES 
 Casual visitors to art museums generally prefer short guides to the official catalogues. 
 Some guides are indeed very brief, suggesting visits at breakneck speed where only a few items or rooms will be seen. 
 Is it Tuesday between eleven o'clock and noon? 
 This must be the Albertina. 
 A museum catalogue is an imposing task for a curator, so daunting indeed that some museums never publish one. 
 Difficulties can be many,  at the top of the list being the number of items to be catalogued. 
 Happy indeed is the curator of a select collection like the Mauritzhuis in The Hague, where one collector's policy was to limit his collection to thirty excellent works, lesser works being discarded to make way for better. 
 The curator's nightmare is somewhere like the Smithsonian Institution in Washington, where the number of items is like grains of sand on the sea shore. 
 A model for art museums is the catalogue of the National Gallery, London. 
 Divided into national schools, in separate publications, the gallery also publishes short guides, souvenir guides, books of details, a complete photographic record of the pictures, specialist publications on conservation, and educational material. 
 The keystone of the arch of publications must be the catalogue itself, from which the authority of other writing derives. 
 The catalogue of the earlier Italian schools was written by Martin Davies, and published in 1951. the strength of the gallery's holding of works by Giovanni Bellini made it worth the author's while to write a preliminary note about difficulties of attribution: 
 A definition of Bellini's oeuvre is one of the hardest problems in the history of painting. 
 The first difficulty is, despite the destructions, the enormous number of existing pictures, many of them signed, and in one way or another more or less Bellinesque. 
 It is obvious that Bellini had assistants to help him in his studio; indeed, there is documentary proof of that. 
 But the question of what pictures are entirely or for practical purposes Bellini's own is answered largely by personal taste; there is therefore a considerable divergence of view. 
 The catalogue of the German school was published in 1959, and written by Michael Levey. 
 The entry for number 291, a portrait of a woman, is a fair example of method: &bquo;The quality of (the picture) seems sufficiently high for it to be acceptable as from Cranach's own hand. 
 It is associated by Friedlander and Rosenberg with a group of similar female portraits, and shows clear analogies of handling.&equo; 
 The connoisseurship demonstrated in these two examples is built up from an accumulation of work by many scholars, but in the end, the cataloguer has to make a judgement, which for number 291 is in favour of Cranach's authorship. 
 Sometimes subjects require considerable explanation or interpretation, and in these cases the museum catalogue can give definitive help. 
 Interpretation of iconography, the historical context of works, or personal information about sitters for portraits are only a few of the varied topics which can be spelt out in catalogues. 
 The level of detail may seem much the same as in a catalogue raisonn&eacute;, but the stress falls in a different way. 
 In  a catalogue raisonn&eacute; an individual work is related primarily to other works by the artist, while a museum catalogue entry will extend to other contextual information and comparisons. 
 Some of the work for a museum catalogue may have already been done before the acquisition of a picture. 
 It may, for example, have been part of a private collection which itself was catalogued, especially if the collector in question was rich. 
 In this respect, the scholarly standard of a private collection's catalogue will be very high, and the sort of information which a reader can expect will be the same. 
 The collection will not, however, be accessible as public collections are. 
 In an art museum works can be studied at leisure, and will receive attention from scholars and experts of many kinds. 
 Besides, works can gain by the company they keep in a museum collection, a landscape being in a group of works of similar date and intentions, or a portrait seen among contemporaries. 
 One of the important features of museum collections is the function they have as touchstones of quality and authenticity. 
 paradoxically, it is in museums that the market in art is defined, since permanent collections place limits on what is available for collectors to purchase. 
 Further, on the basis of knowledge about museum collections, artists can find help in choosing ways of developing the art of the present. 
 The museum is also the place where the closest consideration can be given to the troublesome problems of fakes and other forms of inauthenticity. 
 Museums are at an advantage in making close examination of works in their own collections showing evidence about a picture, say, which can only be discovered by the newest scientific and technological methods. 
 A critic walking for the first time into a gallery may describe a colour in a picture as blue; it will have been the scrupulous task of a conservator to have established that the particular colour in question was Prussian blue, and thus cannot date before the eighteenth century. 
 Old-fashioned amateurs used to admire colours with a golden glow, which conservators have demonstrated were the effect of discoloured varnish. 
 The shape of a picture may have been altered, and the museum, though not a stray visitor, will know the fact. 
 In short the pictures in an art museum have been closely monitored, often through decades and in a few cases for centuries, so full descriptions that appear in the catalogues have a thorough-paced authority. 
 It is also through observation that fakes are unmasked. 
 Some have been living for a disconcertingly long time in museums; but once doubted, the evidence of inadequacy in a fake is quite often soon in coming. 
 The Metropolitan Museum in New York, for example, proudly owned an early Greek bronze horse, which a sharp-eyed administrator on the staff noticed one day had a ridge. 
 This vital fact proved its method of manufacture did not correspond to its supposed date. 
 The museum made the best of a bad job. 
 Joseph Noble, the observant administrator, announced to an audience  of eight hundred, &bquo;It's famous, but it's a fraud.&equo; 
 More than that, it was &bquo;one of the most important classical art forgeries ever discovered&equo;. 
 Some museums have prudently kept a collection of mistaken purchases, and even bought some forgeries deliberately. 
 CRITICAL PATHS 
 A climate of artistic opinion is as tricky to predict as the English weather, and also quite as changeable. 
 Both writers and readers are affected by generally accepted ideas, without necessarily having given them independent thought. 
 One difficulty in describing a climate of opinion is this fact: that many shared views are not stated openly, but assumed. 
 A set of assumptions may be challenged by an outsider, and at this moment these shared views come into focus. 
 To look at the work of an art critic in this way we have to turn to historians of taste for the past and to journalists for the present. 
 When we do this, we find that a critic's range of activities varies from place to place and period to period. 
 Let us look at the second half of the twentieth century. 
 In Paris art critics are often directly associated with particular galleries, and exhibition reviews may be negotiated for a fee between a magazine or a newspaper and the artist's representative. 
 In London historians and critics are solicited for opinions by the auction houses, sometimes but not always accepting a fee; commissions for articles are independent decisions by editors. 
 In New York, gifts of pictures by artists to critics may follow a favourable review, though a critic is likely to refuse payment, even for a catalogue introduction, from a dealer. 
 The variations and exceptions to these brief generalised statements can be found in a number of books, some by investigative outsiders, some in memoirs by dealers and others interested in the market. 
 For other periods, historians are slowly making studies which document the connections of critics and historians with the markets. 
 In 1959 Dore Ashton was dismissed by the New York Times , the charges being that her articles were not aimed at a wide newspaper audience, and her articles on work by artist friends gave evidence of bias (her husband, whose work she was forbidden to review, was a painter and print-maker called Adja Yunkers). 
 John Canaday, the incoming editor of the newspaper's art page and responsible for the dismissal, had made a challenge to a climate of opinion in which Dore Ashton's criticism was valued for its sensitivity, and where the art which she praised was accepted. 
 Her supporters included Thomas Hess, Meyer Schapiro, Leo Steinberg, Harold Rosenberg, and Peter Selz, and their intervention, asserting that Canaday had offended Ashton's &bquo;rights and responsibilities as a critic&equo;, resulted in Canaday's being censured by the American art critics' association. 
 A case of unwitting collusion by a critic in a manoeuvre by an art  dealer occurred in 1961, when Leo Steinberg wrote an article about Jasper Johns. 
 Johns was a puzzling phenomenon for Steinberg, as one of the artists of Pop Art, then hardly begun. 
 The article appeared in an Italian magazine Metro , who had intended to pay &dollar;300 for an article; but when Johns' dealer, Leo Castelli, knew that Steinberg was considering an article, he arranged for the magazine to offer &dollar;1,000, paying the difference of &dollar;700 himself. 
 Steinberg knew nothing about it. 
 The underlying question for a reader of criticism is what influences are exerted on the critic; but as in this instance, for long it may be impossible to know the truth. 
 One noticeable feature of American art life is the link between art historical teaching and criticism, not so common elsewhere. 
 The practice of American art historians reviewing or curating exhibitions, not only historical shows, is a normal feature of art life. 
 Part of the reason for this is that the American professoriat is the largest in the world, while the American market for current art is unprecedented; it is evident that the turnover of the American art market as a whole is the largest in the world. 
 The persuasive tax advantages for the rich to contribute works of art to public collections also play a part, contributing a measure of prestige shared between artists and the powerful in society. 
 Critics can also be invested with a degree of respect deriving partly from their academic connections. 
 Another sort of authority derives from money, which a reader of art criticism may find it difficult to dissociate from an object. 
 Historical knowledge is the surest cure for this damaged intellectual condition, as the history of taste will show many examples of the irrelevance of monetary value to artistic quality. 
 Incidentally, the good art critic should be the reader's friend in refusing to be impressed by art market prices. 
 The English art critic Peter fuller had an honourable record in this respect; despite Julian Schnabel's financial success, he refused to be intimidated by market values. 
 Whatever flickerings of potential this young tyro possesses, they cannot cover up the fact that he is a painter with the imagination of a retarded adolescent; no technical mastery; no intuitive feeling for pictorial space; no sensitivity towards, or grasp of, tradition; and a colour sense rather less than that of Congo, the chimpanzee who was taught (among other things) a crude responsiveness to colour harmonies by Desmond Morris in the late 1950s. 
 However, potentially educable as a painter Schnabel may or may not be, his work is just not worthy of serious attention by anyone with a developed taste in this particular art form. 
 Readers need also to be wary of the existence of special markets. 
 The explosive prices for Teddy Bears in the last few years indicate how a  market can be created, in this case by a mix of merit and nostalgia. 
 What is clearly a dealers' market is often signalled by the invention of a brand name to group together a variety of material, perhaps rather disparate. 
 Pop Art is an example. 
 Or a brand name may already exist ready for exploitation by a market-maker; Impressionism, for example, was ready to hand for British dealers to invent a new category of art which they could stretch to calling British Impressionism. 
 The influence of an international market is not easy to be precise about, though the appearance of work in a Biennale or an art fair can be impressive in itself. 
 The critic here may be acting as an exhibition organiser or co-ordinator, critical decisions being mainly limited to selection. 
 Private collections are examples of critical judgement in action, so that both their catalogues and the opinions expressed by collectors are worth consideration. 
 The collector may have pronounced views. 
 Albert Barnes, the rich American industrialist who formed an outstanding collection between the wars, certainly promoted his personal theories. 
 Barnes possessed excellent paintings by C&eacute;zanne. 
 In a combative book, The Art of C&eacute;zanne , he expounded a theory of rhythm in art which he advanced as the key to C&eacute;zanne's success. 
 Barnes wrote on scientific principles, he said. 
 Here is a passage: 
 The rhythmic movement of volumes and planes in space is so basic in C&eacute;zanne's design that it usually extends to the treatment of the background &mdash; whether that be sky, wall or drapery &mdash; and makes it serve the dual purpose of a screenlike area or space boundary and of a rhythmic sequence of semivoluminous planes which continue the movement of the units in the middleground and foreground; this sequential ordering thus contributes to compositional unity in the widest sense as well as to the expressive movement of the total form. 
 Another collector with a firm sense of the importance of the pictures he had bought was Douglas Cooper. 
 He specialised in collecting the work of four artists he considered to be the true Cubists, Picasso, Braque, Leger and Gris. 
 In 1971 he was asked to organise, at the Tate Gallery, an exhibition which he called The Essential Cubism . 
 The catalogue amusingly contains some entries with such comments as &bquo;Compare and contrast this painting with two works of the &bquo;analytical phase&equo;. 
 It would be worth knowing how many exhibition visitors obeyed these examination instructions. 
 Finally, the critic may well face an issue of authenticity. 
 Here is a description by a French expert of a visit to the painter and etcher, Dunoyer de Segonzac. 
 The artist was shown a watercolour:  
 I don't know what to say. 
 I painted this bit here several times over; that hill too. 
 But there's a lack of unity. 
 Is the thing a fake? 
 I can't be sure. 
 Perhaps I wasn't on form the day I painted it. 
 The worrying thing is my signature, which is extremely hard to counterfeit. 
 But this one looks impeccable. 
 There's only one solution, and that is to destroy the picture. 
 It's second rate, in any case (he added smiling), so the artistic loss to the world will be nil. 
 As for the purchaser, tell him to come to my house and choose another picture &mdash; something that both he and I like. 
 SNAPSHOTS: THE ARTICLES 
 THE SOLO EXHIBITION 
 The acid test for art criticism is the solo exhibition. 
 This is the occasion when a reader can visit the same show and make a personal assessment of how helpful the art critic has been. 
 At its best, art criticism will enable the reader to enjoy or appreciate an exhibition better. 
 This fuller appreciation may result from a short or a long article, even occasionally some unexpected insight or well-phrased judgement; but it will not come from a brief comment off the cuff, an item of gossip, or a mere listing. 
 The only virtue of these latter newspaper techniques is to bring an event to the attention of a reader. 
 A solo exhibition can vary in scope from the minimum, that is to say a show of recent work, through a more extended selection to the apogee of a retrospective exhibition. 
 We have already looked at writing in catalogues, and can now turn our attention to the critical responses which appear in articles. 
 The scope or character of a piece of criticism is naturally related to the magazine or newspaper in which it appears, as we noticed in the case of Dore Ashton's dismissal from the New York Times  because it was asserted that her work could not be understood by the paper's readers. 
 The first rule for a reader of articles is thus to find a sympathetic publication. 
 Some trial and error should eliminate the laziest papers, whose critics do no more than pillage catalogue introductions, or even press releases. 
 Some latitude can be allowed to serious critics who write for periodicals which go to press a long time before a show is on view; these critics will not be able to comment on how the exhibition actually looks, as their articles will have been written before the show's installation. 
 They  nevertheless will have seen some, perhaps all the works included, and can thus comment usefully on the artist's standing, aims and achievements. 
 The content of an article will tend to be determined by its length; no newspaper article is likely to be more than 1,000 words, which precludes any chance of detailed analysis. 
 Indeed, an article at this length will frequently avoid mentioning any work of art by name, being limited instead to a generalised description of an artist's work. 
 For example, this passage in an article on Giacometti by the American critic Hilton Kramer: 
 shape a figure or a head from the scrutiny of the model who sat before him, was felt to be an &bquo;impossible&equo; assault on an objective guaranteed to elude his grasp&hellip; 
 This &bquo;difficulty&equo; was the moral  center  of his art, the very fulcrum of his style. 
 To it we owe that nervous, spidery line of the drawings &mdash; so quick, so attentive, yet so despairing &mdash; that alerts us to the elusiveness of the subject at the same time that it perseveres in the attempt to render it. 
 The article, called &bquo;Giacometti's moral heroism&equo;, is about a retrospective show of the sculptor's work ten years after his death; it does not include the name of any single work. 
 Or an article can be centred on a motif, as this passage about Rothko by Harold Rosenberg indicates: 
 By 1950, Rothko had conceived his conclusive insigne of a disembodied absolute. 
 This icon consisted of the rectangle of the canvas as a one-colour ground visible along the edge of &mdash; and occasionally through an opening between &mdash; three or four horizontal blocks of  color  with brushed surfaces and furry borders. 
 For the next twenty years, Rothko's work consisted of reanimating this pattern with the substance of his emotional life. 
 It was as if he had conceived a latterday, visual version of the sonnet or the haiku . 
 Except that (and this is decisive in regard to the situation of the one-idea painter) his format was private &mdash; almost, one might say, the framework of another self, or of himself in another form &mdash; and unavailable to others. 
 A further way of treating an article about an exhibition is to make a comparison with another artist. 
 The painter Patrick Heron wrote for the New Statesman  in London in the 1950s, and used this technique for writing about Braque, whom he compared with Picasso. 
 The quotation is from an article of 1954, at a time when Picasso's reputation was very high. 
 Heron was anxious to point out Braque's qualities, so he trailed his coat openly.  
 To suggest, as I do, that Georges Braque is the greatest living painter is to remind a contemporary audience, fed to satiety on brilliant innovation, frenzied novelty and every sort of spontaneous expression, that, after all, permanence, grandeur, deliberation, lucidity and calm are paramount virtues of the art of painting&hellip; 
 The rival genius of Picasso has proved to the world that our age may be epitomized by works which (show) his unfailing sense of visual drama, his protean invention and his power of investing his creations with a hallucinatory poetry. 
 Heron shows in his article a deep sympathy with Braque's work, which, incidentally, was a sort of painting he himself was seeking to practise at the time. 
 He argued that Braque enhanced objects: 
 He is infinitely kind to all the things that go into his pictures. 
 Indeed, the kind of life which he bestows on his coffee-pot or coffee-grinder, his table, his chair and window, is just the sort of life we feel these things are really living! 
 The personality with which Braque invests his jug is something that the jug possesses in its own right. 
 In other words, Braque divines the essential spirit &mdash; one might almost call it the &bquo;soul&equo; &mdash; of each object that he paints. 
 For this reason we have the feeling that a Braque jug is just as real and valid, just as much a distinct unity, as the jug that comes from the potter's wheel. 
 PERSONALITY PROFILES 
 A profile of the artist is another form in which to review an exhibition. 
 When such an article rises above the level of a gossip column, the artist's profile can be a valuable format. 
 One source of interest can be a description of where the interview has taken place, perhaps a studio, or maybe the artist's home. 
 After the Second World War, for example, the photographer Alexander Liberman decided to visit the studios of artists who had contributed to a century of painting in France, painters and sculptors closely connected with the School of Paris. 
 He commented on his project: &bquo;The more I explored, the more I became absorbed with the mystery of the environment. 
 Why should France have become the focal  center  of painting and sculpture at this particular time? 
 What relationship exists between the painting and the vision of reality that the artist has before his eyes? 
 At no time have I believed that environment is a complete explanation of art. 
 I am sure, however, that it plays an important role.&equo; 
 The photographs were taken over a period of ten years, and eventually they were brought together in a book in 1960; ten of the book's essays originally appeared in Vogue , where the appealing mix of an artist's conversation along with Liberman's descriptions and commentary  succeeded well. 
 Here is one of the descriptions from the profile on Georges Braque: 
 He insisted that I visit the church and marine cemetery at Varengeville. 
 The small twelfth-century edifice, built right above the steep cliffs that dominate the northern beaches of France, and the cemetery with its hundred tombs and crosses are in harmony with Braque's  colors . 
 The church is gray; the cemetery crosses are of white marble. 
 The stained-glass windows inside, and the black wrought iron and living or artificial flowers outside, contribute vivid accents. 
 The steel-gray expanse of the northern pebbled beach, overcast with the shadows of the high cliffs, creates the dominant black of Braque's marines. 
 I understood how much Braque had absorbed the countryside around him. 
 The New Yorker  has a good record of commissioning articles. 
 Braque was profiled by Janet Flanner, who also wrote evocatively about Picasso and Matisse. 
 Flanner is rather sparing about details of Picasso's personal life, knowing it to be so extensively documented. 
 But her selected information has a welcome sharpness: 
 Even the opening report of him comes from an unusual source &mdash; his own vivid memory of how he learned to walk. 
 More than sixty years after the event, while watching a child of his own try out his first steps, he suddenly stated in reminiscence and satisfaction to his most intimate Spanish friend, &bquo;I remember that I learned to walk by pushing a big tin box of sweet biscuits in front of me because I knew what was inside.&equo; 
 What must have distinguished him as being beyond normal was his unconventionally high state of consciousness. 
 Magazine profiles may be carefully written and prepared, though their facts are unlikely to be as thoroughly checked as in books. 
 Newspaper profiles are quite likely to be based on interviews, which have an immediate attraction, though a reader will naturally be wary about how accurately the interview may have been recorded. 
 Even taped interviews can only be read with caution, since they may have been edited, and the reader will not be told how. 
 Besides, it is an everyday experience that people are sometimes wrong in conversation, and may not remember events well. 
 Where personal profiles have a strength, however, is in what the critic says about personal reactions to artist and work. 
 One incidental advantage of personality pieces is that the magazines in which they appear may be able to afford good-quality colour reproductions. 
 Unluckily, this may be of little help to the reader if the pictures  illustrated are used as mere decoration, and not the subject of critical discussion. 
 This is as unsatisfactory as reading about a picture which is not illustrated. 
 The crux of a personality article is that it aims to satisfy a reader's curiosity. 
 An editor's directions to the writer of an article may be to take a populist approach, suitable for a wide audience. 
 The article written to this brief is likely to have an element of sensationalism; curiosity about sex or money may be deliberately aroused; conflicts in an artist's life are likely to be dramatised. 
 An amusing parallel in the film business is an account given by the director Ken Russell of how he sold the idea of making a film about Tchaikowsky; he described it to his potential backers as the story of a homosexual who fell in love with a nymphomaniac. 
 Similarly, the personal lives of artists may be believed by editors to sell more newspapers than reflective criticism. 
 GROUP SHOWS 
 Reviews of group shows make hard reading. 
 The critic may choose to write about common features in the work of the artists exhibiting; this may lead to generalisations about the group which take little account of the individual qualities of the artists. 
 Indeed, the assumption that they have characteristics in common may be mistaken or misleading. 
 The alternative, of choosing between artists, is also hazardous, since it refutes the idea that they have a reason for exhibiting together, even if what the critic writes is favourable. 
 A hostile article is even less likely to be satisfactory to a reader. 
 There is no problem for an antagonistic critic to find incoherence and inconsistency in a group exhibition. 
 To begin with, the reasons for which artists show together are varied. 
 An obvious reason is financial, since to share costs of a show is easier for the participants. 
 Another financial incentive is that sales may be generated by the naming of a group. 
 At the end of the twentieth century group exhibitions perhaps do not have the importance that they have had earlier in the century. 
 There are many galleries through the world, and it is no longer so difficult for an artist to show work independently. 
 Solo shows and mixed exhibitions are more common, with the group show playing a less important role in the market. 
 Artists who group together for financial reasons may choose a name which is no more explanatory than a number or numbers. 
 Thus in London at different times there have been groups which have called themselves the Society of Twelve , the Seven and Five , and One/Four . 
 It could be argued that these groups were formed as much for sociability as for making money, being made up of friends or acquaintances, but at any event their reasons fell short of promoting definite artistic programmes. 
 A word of caution is in order, though, about the names of exhibiting  groups. 
 Sometimes a number conceals a genuinely significant programme, such as the Group of Seven  had in Canada. 
 This distinguished alliance of landscape artists sought to invigorate their country's artistic life by bold treatment of wild Canadian subjects. 
 Tom Taylor, mentor and leader, had died before the group had its first exhibition, but remains classed with his friends. 
 They subsequently developed individual styles and separate interests, as is true of most groups of artists, but their initial appearance was defined by a programme. 
 Another sort of title for a group is exemplified by Der Blaue Reiter  (The Blue Rider). 
 Forty-three works by fourteen painters were shown in 1911 at the &bquo;First Exhibition by the Editorial Board of The Blue Rider &equo;, the publication concerned being an almanac which appeared in 1912 with a drawing of a horseman by Kandinsky on the cover. 
 The second exhibition included thirty-one artists. 
 The main need of these artists was for good opportunities to exhibit their work; unlike the equally celebrated group Die Br&uuml;cke  (The Bridge) they did not work closely together. 
 Nor did they plan portfolios of prints, as Die Br&uuml;cke  did; a practice, by the way, followed by a variety of artists' organisations including the Senefelder Group in England, which has sold its members' lithographs from the nineteenth century to the present day. 
 Impressionism is the most familiar group with an artistic programme in the nineteenth century. 
 Several features of its history are worth notice. 
 for one thing, the group did not choose the name, which came from a reviewer's description of a painting by Monet. 
 Then, the artistic aims of members of the group were quite varied, and some personal animosities caused the alliance to break up. 
 Further, the name was partly kept alive by dealing, primarily by the man most heavily committed, Durand-Ruel. 
 What was perhaps most crucial to the success of Impressionism in financial terms was its modern stance, as closely identified with contemporary life at the turn of the century as Romanticism had been fifty years before. 
 In artistic terms, this modern stance inevitably attracted competition. 
 Seurat and his colleagues argued that Pointillism was a scientifically modern style, while the Symbolists asserted that spiritual values were preferable to artistic programmes of perception. 
 The unfavourable reception of Impressionism by the French critics is notorious; but Impressionism was not the only group to gain a name from a review &mdash; the Fauves and Cubism share this. 
 From a critic's point of view, a label, whether ending in &bquo;ism&equo; or not, is convenient. 
 The critic writing in a newspaper with very limited space needs such a label to give the reader a general idea of what is on display. 
 Using such a shorthand description leaves space for other topics. 
 Another consequence of the labelling of Impressionism and other groups by critics was that some artists naturally decided that they themselves could do the same job better than the critics. 
 In Western art there  had been artistic programmes and manifestos before Impressionism, but in the twentieth century they proliferated. 
 Part of the critic's task in the nineteenth century, as now, was to interpret art for the lay public; but what, artists asked themselves, if we interpreted our own work? from such a thought sprang statements of artistic aims and manifestos, some using the new device of naming a group with a progressive title, such as futurism. 
 De Stijl is an especially bold assertion of identity, the Dutch word for style implying that there is no other style worth considering. 
 The reader in this situation has a choice: the work in an exhibition can be measured against the artists' manifesto; or the critic's interpretation and assessment can be used. 
 The critic necessarily has to take a manifesto into account. 
 Indeed, there is an implicit struggle between critic and artist; an artist's manifesto can be seen as a deliberate attempt to pre-empt critical comment and evaluation. 
 One puzzling decision for a critic to make is to decide whether to isolate any one artist as the leading figure of the group. 
 When this is done, there is a tendency for other artists to be compared with the leader to their disadvantage. 
 It is a nice matter of judgement to decide how to treat the various personalities with justice. 
 Sometimes the teacher is absent from the group, as Gustave Moreau was absent from the painting exhibited by the Fauves; or, like Tom Taylor of the Group of Seven , he may be dead. 
 Only time and scholarship eventually sort out the various relationships of artists who worked together. 
 Artists can be at a disadvantage in group exhibitions as only a small part of their activity can be seen. 
 A small gallery may have space to show work in only one medium; this may have a distorting effect on the activity of the group as a whole or of versatile individuals. 
 It may also give a misleading impression: for example, the work of German Expressionist painters under the banner of the name Die Br&uuml;cke , Kirchner, Nolde and Pechstein was affected by their practice as print-makers, where some motifs and treatment originated. 
 A show of their painting tells only part of their story. 
 The knowledge of a critic is useful here for filling in relevant background information. 
 The critic is also likely to spot the gaps in a group show, when the best works are not being shown, say perhaps because they are in private collections. 
 The politicising of Western art gives the existence of a manifesto special relevance. 
 If the aim of an exhibition is political, the evaluation of art on purely aesthetic grounds is possible, but considered an irrelevance by the exhibitors. 
 In the longer term, it may be something aesthetic will be seen in what was intended as pure politics. 
 The prime example is the Dada movement, whose nihilistic work is now admired for qualities of imagination. 
 It was originally reviled, as the artists intended, for its rejection of conventional values of art and society.  
 MIXED EXHIBITIONS 
 Mixed exhibitions are ideal for spotting talent ahead of the market, as well as being a significant source of income for many artists. 
 The most common sort of mixed exhibition is the exhibiting society, whose history is entwined with the development of art in Europe since the eighteenth century. 
 The shows put on in Paris at the Salon, and in London at the Royal Academy, were a means of creating sales for artists at a turning point in the history of patronage; as there developed a middle-class market for literature, so there developed a comparable market for art. 
 Denis Diderot gained lasting fame as the energetic editor of the French Encyclopaedia , but he is also rightly celebrated as an art critic. 
 It was in 1761, that he first wrote an account of one of the Salons, which was circulated with his other correspondence in the fashion of the time by his friend Grimm. 
 Diderot's standards were those primarily of a moralist, questioning how morality might be fashioned through painting, but he was sensitive to artistic aims; his essay on painting was admired both by Goethe and Baudelaire. 
 Here is a description by Diderot of a Russian country scene by Le Prince, from criticism of the Salon in 1767. 
 An old man has been playing the guitar, but he has left off playing to listen to a young shepherd piping. 
 The old man is sitting under a tree, and a young girl is near him; I think he is blind &mdash; at least, he ought to be. 
 The youth is sitting at a little distance, his shepherd's pipe in his mouth; there is a charming simplicity in his dress and appearance; he has a fine head. 
 The old man and the girl are listening attentively. 
 On the right are some rocks, and at the foot of them the sheep are feeding. 
 This picture goes straight to my heart; I should like to lean against that tree between the old man and the girl and listen while the youth played. 
 And when he had left off playing I would go and sit by him, and a little later we would all lead the good old man to his cottage. 
 A picture that affects one thus cannot be a bad picture. 
 You may say that it is feeble in colour and monotonous in tone &mdash; it may be so, but it touches the heart, it arrests the attention; and what is the use of all your correct drawing and pure tints, and skill in light and shade, if your subject leaves me cold and unaffected. 
 Painting is the art of reaching the soul through the eyes, but if the picture appeals to the eyes and never reaches the soul, the painter has fallen far short of his aim. 
 In person, incidentally, Diderot was an encouraging critic. 
 Sainte-Beuve tells us that David  always spoke of Diderot with gratitude. 
 It seems that David had at first great difficulty in making his way with the public, and was several times unsuccessful in his efforts after fame. 
 It was at this time that Diderot, who often strolled into the artists' studios, paid a visit to David, and saw a picture which the artist was just finishing. 
 He admired it and talked about the artist's meaning, and the noble ideas he attributed to him. 
 David listened and frankly avowed that he had not been conscious of all these grand ideas. 
 &bquo;What,&equo; said Diderot, &bquo;you did it from instinct without knowing what you were doing! 
 That is better still!&equo; 
 David was greatly encouraged by this warm admiration expressed by a celebrated man, and it helped to develop his talent. 
 Reviews of exhibiting societies' shows have constantly presented difficulties to critics, as it is only possible to give brief comments on some of the artists' work; how could it be otherwise when an exhibiting society shows several thousand works? 
 During the nineteenth century to be noticed was good fortune, while to be praised was a professional advantage. 
 Exhibiting societies, once established, bred rivals; the most remarkable rivalry in the nineteenth century was in Paris, where the choice of pictures for the Salon in 1866 was so generally considered to be unfair that the rejected pictures were shown in a Salon of their own. 
 This enabled some major figures to show work for the first time. 
 By the end of the century, a pattern emerged through Europe of societies of artists breaking away from official organisations, creating seceding groups, of which one in Austria adopted the word as a title, Sezession . 
 The problem of criticising the work in exhibiting societies' shows is how little space is made available in newspapers for its coverage; the critic has time to mention a painter or a sculptor, make a brief observation, and then passes on. 
 In this case selection is all, or almost all, as space does not allow for extensive description or interpretation. 
 Nor is there much point in attempting to give a general impression of a show, as there is nothing to hold it together, unlike a group show with a programme or a manifesto to consider. 
 The only possible general comment is limited to a comparison of one year with another, or of one exhibition with some comparable one. 
 The phrase-maker is thus king. 
 An apt combination of noun and adjective, a bon mot , an evocative phrase, is as much as an artist can hope for and a reader can expect. 
 The reader's only remedy is to go to the exhibition. 
 In Victorian Britain or France during the Second Empire the critic had some influence over taste. 
 It is doubtful how much influence a critic has today, though high claims are made for Clement Greenberg as the promoter of American Abstract Expressionism. 
 A cynic will remember that research into the opinion-forming powers of newspapers has tended  to conclude that readers expect to have their existing views confirmed. 
 If so, the power of critics may be no more than the listings services offered in the papers or on posters, while real power can be found in the organisation of the art market. 
 A different sort of exhibition which has had some success in attracting attention, and thus newspaper coverage, is the prize competition. 
 Here the critic is absolved from making judgements of his own by the need to report what a jury has decided about prizes. 
 The critic's standing is thereby reduced, and the description or evaluation of the prize works is less than likely to be uninfluenced by their new position. 
 How then is the reader of art criticism best advised to use criticism to follow the fortunes of artists? 
 One policy is to try to see more than one review of any exhibition. 
 The notice board at a show where notices are pinned up will give the general idea of what sort of reviews have been written. 
 It is a usual feature of such a comparison that there is a basic level of information which is common to most of the reviews, and it is the mark of a skilful critic to have worked in some personal assessment of works, or some individual response to the show as a whole. 
 The data common to all reviews can be discounted as being neither criticism nor evaluation. 
 The nuggets of real criticism are those views which are evidently based on personal reactions and responses. 
 THEMES AND ARGUMENTS 
 Articles on exhibitions sometimes glide away into topics which have little to do with the art on display. 
 This will be disappointing for a reader who expects at the least some evaluation of the shows. 
 The arguments put forward can be interesting in themselves, but their drift is often towards making the context of the art shown more understandable. 
 Art politics or cultural history are favourite themes for such reviewers, apart from the spectrum of cognate disciplines which may be the specialities of writers who are only occasionally concerned with art. 
 Thematic articles are likely to be found in two sorts of periodicals, general magazines and academic journals, either interdisciplinary or of specialist disciplines. 
 Valuable interpretive ideas may be found in journals of psychology, aesthetics, philosophy, history, religion, sociology, anthropology, even medicine and biology, although these may not be matched up with descriptions and evaluations of art. 
 Such articles may not start with art; as Rudolf Arnheim said about his book, Art and Visual Perception , he applied principles of visual perception to examples taken from the arts. 
 Only in his more recent work The Power of the Center , published in 1988, has he been looking from art to the resources offered by psychology. 
 One of the intriguing questions about any thematic article is what  motivated the writer? 
 Some articles are clearly written as a by-product of teaching, perhaps adapted from lectures or intended to form part of a book. 
 Others are contributions to a current debate, using art as a theme, in discussing political issues, for example. 
 Some thoughtful articles aim to make connections, perhaps across national and language frontiers, or between disciplines. 
 The reader's criteria for judging articles will vary accordingly. 
 Art politics can prove a rewarding topic for a journalist. 
 Tom Wolfe's book The Painted Word  is a witty example of the genre; it originally appeared in Harper's Magazine , before being made into a book in 1975. 
 There are good satirical illustrations by the author, paralleled by a text which makes fun of American criticism, Abstract Expressionism and Pop Art. 
 Wolfe puts his argument as follows: &bquo;What I saw before me was the critic-in-chief of the New York Times  saying: In looking at a painting today, &bquo;to lack a persuasive theory is to lack something crucial&equo;. 
 I read it again. 
 It didn't say &bquo;something helpful&equo; or &bquo;enriching&equo; or even &bquo;extremely valuable&equo;. 
 No, the word was crucial . 
 In short: frankly, these days, without a theory to go with it, I can't see  a painting.&equo; 
 This overpraise of criticism justifies the book's title, The Painted Word ; elsewhere, the book has racy descriptions of New York art life, and a headcount by the author of those he considers care about art. 
 A diagram of the art world, according to Wolfe, would be made up, in addition to the artists, of &bquo;about 750 culturati in Rome, 500 in Milan, 1,750 in Paris, 1,250 in London, 2,000 in Berlin, Munich, and D&uuml;sseldorf, 3,000 in New York, and perhaps 1,000 scattered about the rest of the world. 
 That is the art world &mdash; a mere hamlet &mdash; restricted to les beaux mondes  of eight cities.&equo; 
 What Wolfe provides is art criticism in a sardonic mode, created by parodying others. 
 One of Wolfe's targets is the critic Greenberg, about whom an apologist has gravely asserted: &bquo;The significance of Clement Greenberg cannot be overestimated. 
 He is the designer and subtle manipulator of modernism, which is the single most important and influential theory of modern art.&equo; 
 Greenberg wrote exhibition reviews for The Nation  during the 1940s, but his lasting reputation comes from a collection of his articles, including some more thematic pieces for Partisan Review , in a book published in 1961 with the title Art and Culture . 
 Greenberg's name has a special glamour because of his successful advocacy of Abstract Expressionist artists against &bquo;the dominance of the School of Paris&equo;, as Barbara Reise wrote. 
 Moreover, &bquo;His role shifted easily from the alienated critic writing art columns for intellectual magazines to an impresario in the New York art-world judged by his commitment to a specific type of art and respected for its ultimate (commercial and influential) success.&equo; 
  Greenberg's articles are marked by a confident authority, as in the following passage. 
 Looser paint-handling, combined with what remained an essentially Cubist sense of design, drawing, layout, was what artists as different as Gorky and Pollock had in common during the mid-1940s. 
 If the term &bquo;Abstract Expressionist&equo; means anything verifiable, it means painterliness: loose, rapid handling, or the look of it; masses that blot and fuse instead of shapes that stay distinct; large, conspicuous rhythms; broken  color ; uneven saturations or densities of paint; exhibited brush, knife, finger or rag marks &mdash; in short a constellation of physical features like those defined by W&ouml;lflinn when he extracted his notion of the Malerische  from Baroque art. 
 As we can now see, the displacing of the &bquo;linear&equo; and quasi-geometrical as the dominant mode in New York (and Parisian) abstract art after 1943 offers another instance of that cyclical alternation of non-painterly, or linear, and painterly which has marked the evolution of Western art since the sixteenth century. 
 A more political theme for an article is the issue of subsidies for the arts. 
 The sticking point is, generally, who should get this encouragement? 
 The National Endowment for the Arts in the United States has been under heavy fire for its choices, as is usual for Ministries, whether in nineteenth-century France or the present-day USSR. 
 Choices for subsidies are in themselves art critical judgements, just as commissions are, and public debate can become enflamed over commissions. 
 The art critic has no decisive voice in such controversies, though arguments can be made by analogy from existing art to what may be done. 
 Another form of article which can include art criticism is a theoretical paper. 
 For example, the cultural theory of the 1970s, according to an article by Victor Burgin on The End of Art Theory , drew predominantly on feminism, Marxism, psychoanalysis and semiotics. 
 In his view the independence of modernism in art has been &bquo;further subverted by the demonstration of the necessarily &bquo;intertextual&equo; nature of the production of meaning&equo;. 
 Cultural history and theory, it has to be said, have very extensive agenda, and art criticism is perhaps only a sub-paragraph under a secondary heading. 
 The reader may be doomed to disappointment in reading through an article with wide contextual terms of reference if looking for something as simple as descriptions of works of art, their interpretation and evaluation. 
 Articles of synthesis between art and other subjects may include important art criticism. 
 Literary theory is at present in demand as a point of reference for writing on the visual arts. 
 Articles on this sort of theme may appear in art periodicals, but are just as likely to be found in other  journals, on literature, say, or history. 
 What is most likely to be useful in such material is the chance that inferences can be drawn by the reader, seeing a similarity in a problem elsewhere with a question in the visual arts.  
 AS THINGS ARE: DESCRIPTION 
 THE OBJECT OF ATTENTION 
 The description of an object is not a simple task. 
 An art object is especially difficult for the critic, as there are many ways in which its description can be approached. 
 Let us take a sculpture, depicting a girl's nude figure, of bronze, sixty-three inches high, called The Dance Step , by the Italian sculptor Giacomo Manz&ugrave;. 
 The girl's slim figure, small breasts, and pony tail haircut are those of an adolescent, while her pose, one foot at right angles to the other, is just a little away from the third position in classical Western ballet. 
 Eduard Trier chose to illustrate this figure in Form and Space , in which he limits himself to two observations: it is a product of refined artificiality (in comparison with the elemental force of Marino Marini's sculpture), and the girl (in comparison with a figure by Marcello Mascherini) is &bquo;more reserved, displays a leisurely elegance in her arrested dance step&equo;. 
 Manz&ugrave;'s girl is thus described by Trier first as an artefact, and then as a person; his terms of reference are the characteristics of two other sculptors. 
 This skimpy description is not unusual in a survey, and the missing positive evaluation he might have made is only implied in his choice of the sculpture for inclusion in his book. 
 No other information is given about the work itself, although there is a brief biographical note about the sculptor. 
 There are a number of other ways in which the work could 
 The pose, expression and figure of the girl could have been more fully interpreted in several ways beyond the comparisons with the work of two of Manz&ugrave;'s Italian colleagues. 
 Who is she? 
 We do not know her name, though it is unlikely that the sculptor did not have a model. 
  The girl is anonymous, just as are the models for some religious scenes described by Giorgio Vasari. 
 He wrote about the famous frescoes by Giotto in the church of St Francis of Assisi: 
 In truth the work exhibits great variety, not only in the gestures and postures of the different figures, but in the composition of each subject, besides which it is very interesting to see the various costumes of those times and certain imitations and observations of Nature. 
 One of the most beautiful of these represents a thirsty man, whose desire for water is represented in the most lively manner as he kneels on the ground to drink from a spring, with such wonderful reality that one might imagine him to be a real person. 
 Vasari praised Giotto's ability to represent things visible, a highly usual expectation in the tradition of Western art. 
 Paintings which describe the natural world are indeed easiest for the critic to describe, since any observer can compare an object seen with the same thing depicted. 
 This comparison may form the crucial part of a description; later on, using comparison as a criterion, that a portrait should look like the sitter, that landscape should look natural, and the objects in a still life should be identifiable, a critic can use it as part of an evaluation. 
 A still life is in some ways an ideal picture to describe, as a firm basis can be found in a catalogue of its components. 
 A list can even rise to evoking the mood of a picture, as in this description by the Goncourt brothers of Chardin's subjects; &bquo;He introduces into his pictures his wash-basin, his mastiff puppy, the objects and the creatures to which he is accustomed in his home&hellip; the pure simple features of the working middle class, happy in its tranquillity, its labour and its obscurity. 
 The genius of the painter is the genius of the home.&equo; 
 People in pictures can be more problematic to describe, since they may not be identifiable, a special difficulty with portraits. 
 The activities of people in pictures can be equally puzzling. 
 Indeed, if the story enacted in a picture is not known, quite wrong inferences can be drawn from what is perceived. 
 The reader of a description needs therefore to be careful about accepting as a description anything more than is actually visible on the canvas or in the sculpture. 
 Within a particular culture, a description can naturally go further in identifying a devout picture of a Virgin and Child, or a dancing figure with six arms as Siva. 
 The Christian painting may be at once a holy picture and a convincing representation of a woman tenderly cradling her son, seen in front of a north Italian landscape. 
 The Siva statue has no such direct representational reference. 
 A critic unfamiliar with a culture will have trouble in formulating a description of a work. 
 Take African sculpture, much admired by European  artists in the twentieth century for its bold forms, not representational of the human figure in a Western sense. 
 Frank Willett in African Art  comments: 
 African sculpture has been commonly described as frontal, i.e. the figures are symmetrically disposed about a vertical axis. 
 There are, of course, exceptions to this, but asymmetrical pieces are uncommon. 
 Because of their frontality African figure sculptures are commonly photographed or drawn full face, concealing the fact that the sculptor has paid a great deal of attention to the profile view. 
 Then he says something about the formal appeal of this sculpture to twentieth-century Western taste, because of its freedom from the canon of realism: 
 It is easy enough to analyse the formal characteristics of African sculpture in terms of vertical, horizontal or diagonal emphases; of relative naturalism or abstraction; of rounded, angular or cubic elements; or in terms of tensions, rhythm and movement, and this is certainly an enjoyable and satisfying experience, since African sculptors have achieved a remarkable level of expression in what has been called &bquo;purely sculptural&equo; form. 
 This account raises two significant issues about description; one is parallel to comments on photography which have already been made. 
 In seeing African sculpture reproduced, the reader can remember that this art is to an extent being misrepresented by photography. 
 Secondly, the formal analysis which is second nature to a Western critic can be fruitful, even though it could be argued that this is a way of interpreting the objects of an unfamiliar culture rather than a description. 
 A further type of difficulty arises in descriptions of works produced in far Eastern cultures. 
 While a Western eye is familiar with the process of looking, as it were, through an image to what it represents or means, an Eastern critic looks also at the surface of a painting or a drawing, in which a poem or other calligraphic element may form an integral part of the work. 
 Chinese painting and calligraphy are visual arts on much of an equal footing. 
 A Japanese example is the surimono , a friendly greeting for the New Year through a drawing and a message which complement each other. 
 Here a measure of interpretation is integral to the work itself. 
 The long-standing popularity of Japanese woodcut prints in the West has somewhat disguised differences in approach. 
 The undeniable and striking formal qualities of composition in works by such masters as Hokusai and Hiroshige have had demonstrable effects on late-nineteenth-and twentieth-century European art. 
 Nevertheless, such prints are not  justly reduced even in description to mere compositional terms. 
 The materials used, for example, merit attention rarely given to paintings in the West whose science is intended to create an illusion. 
 What the reader of criticism deserves, in sum, is an appropriate description. 
 There are some aspects of a work of art which can be measured, for example its size, natural or chemical composition, and some facts can be discovered about works through specialist techniques such as infra-red photography. 
 These may or may not have significance; what needs to be certain is that descriptions are accurate, for if they are wrong, deductions from them will be valueless. 
 A fragment from an altarpiece cannot be appraised in just the same way as an independent portrait; and a craftsman's skill is esteemed more accurately when the materials used are rightly identified. 
 PERCEPTION 
 How a spectator views an object is also not a simple matter, despite this century's increased knowledge of the psychology of perception. 
 A difficulty is that psychology has narrow terms of reference which can give only a few useful results, for example on the question of illusion. 
 A classic example of exposition, though not uncontroversial, is E. H. Gombrich's Art of Illusion . 
 This usefully explores some of the resolvable questions, in particular those of crucial interest to students of landscape and the human figure. 
 One aspect of illusion is perspective, much valued in the Western tradition. 
 Three sorts of perspective are identified by Leonardo da Vinci in his treatise on painting, as follows: 
 The first deals with the reasons of the (apparent) diminution of objects as they recede from the eye, and is known as Perspective of Diminution: the second contains the way colours vary as they recede from the eye: the third and last explains how objects should appear less distinct in proportion as they are more remote. 
 And the names are as follows: Linear perspective, the perspective of colour, the perspective of disappearance. 
 The Renaissance became enamoured of perspective, indeed Vasari thought that Paolo Uccello took it too seriously. 
 He wrote: 
 Paolo Uccello would have been the most delightful and imaginative genius since Giotto that had adorned the art of painting, if he had devoted as much pains to figures and animals as he did to questions of perspective, for, although these are ingenious and good in their way, yet an immoderate devotion to them causes an infinite waste of  time, fatigues nature, clogs the mind with difficulties, and frequently renders it sterile where it had previously been fertile and facile. 
 But when Uccello died in his eighties, &bquo;He left a daughter who could design, and a wife who used to say that Paolo would remain the night long in his study to work out the lines of his perspective, and that when she called him to come to rest, he replied, &bquo;Oh what a sweet thing this perspective is!&equo; 
 Mathematical perspective of a Renaissance sort had not been used in European medieval art, where the size of a figure often derives from the person's importance, God the father never being small. 
 A perspective may be used which reverses the convergence of lines in the distance; instead, lines of perspective converge in front of the viewer, an unexpected phenomenon for a twentieth-century spectator used to photographs. 
 Again, in Chinese art perspective is different from its treatment in the West. 
 There is one sort of Chinese perspective, seen as in the West from a level viewpoint, but this is only one of three treatments of space representation. 
 It can be identified with p'ing yuan , when one is able to see &bquo;from the near parts to the furthest parts&equo;. 
 In this, as in Western perspective, the horizon line is somewhere below the middle of the picture. 
 One alternative Chinese perspective is shen yuan , in which the viewer is placed as if on a hill, and the horizon line is thus high up, almost a bird's eye view. 
 The third perspective is Kao yuan , in which the viewer is looking up towards a mountain scene, as William Willetts puts it, &bquo;through successively receding heights represented by flat parallel planes, each with its own horizon&equo;. 
 The point of making these comparisons is that artistic practices affect how a critic should describe a landscape. 
 Suppose a scene is said to be in correct perspective? 
 This description could mean several different things. 
 Yet such a comment may need to be made, nevertheless, to point out the quality of a picture. 
 The critic who pays little notice to perspective or other means of representing the natural world will deprive a reader of help in enjoying the exceptional beauty of the natural appearance of Impressionist pictures, whose qualities are inspired by scientific understanding of light and its effects. 
 In a different sort of context, what appears to be an abstract design, devoid of reference to the natural world, may in fact be a stylisation of a person, an animal or an imagined figure. 
 The totems of American Indians, the carvings of Inouk, ancient bronze ritual vessels from China, and many more examples can be found through the world and the centuries. 
 Most African sculpture is not in this category, as characteristically the masks and ritual objects of Africa are more evidently human or animal in appearance. 
 Care has to be taken by a critic in any of these cases to describe works as definitely as possible. 
 A totem, for example, can be described  first as it appears, then as an object which has stylised figures in the sculpture. 
 A further example of abstract form which is not mere pattern is Tantric art. 
 A Tantric painting or drawing has a spiritual purpose, to assist the user in meditation. 
 As a sound is a mantra, so an image is a yantra, the two used together making a powerful combination for spiritual exercises. 
 A description of a Tantric painting as a linear diagram may seem uninteresting, but then the effect of such a picture is not meant to be pleasure for the eye alone, but for religious use. 
 WAYS OF DESCRIBING 
 We have thought so far mainly about verbal descriptions, the stock in trade of the art critic. 
 There are other ways of description, which may incidentally be employed by a critic, or can be useful to a reader as a check on the validity of a verbal description. 
 In chapter 4, on monographs, there were some comments on the photography of art as a complement to criticism; there are some other issues about how accurate or misleading photographs can be. 
 Perhaps this is the more important in the late twentieth century now that this means of image-making is so familiar that some people actually imagine that a photograph shows the world as it is. 
 In truth, the camera is a ruthless editor of visual information; this can be made plain by looking at a picture, say of the eighteenth century, and comparing it with a contemporary print, perhaps an aquatint, and a modern photograph. 
 The images carry different information. 
 The physical make-up of dots in a photograph differs from the lines and granular surface of the aquatint; the aquatint's variations describe the picture more eloquently. 
 The art of civilisations other than that of the West are now more readily visible through photography, and within the limitations of the medium, usefully so. 
 But what do tourists actually see during a visit to India? 
 Are they able to look without too dominant a preconception coming from the Western tradition? 
 There are amusing archaeological records in the nineteenth century of the inability of even trained artists to record what they saw; Assyrian figure sculptures, for example, were recorded as having unmistakably classical Greek features by an artist in the employ of the archaeologist Sir Henry Layard. 
 A different sort of description is an artist's copy of a work. 
 Copying was a well-paid occupation in nineteenth-century France, since private collectors and travellers were happy to have copies of pictures in famous collections like the Louvre. 
 Copying was also part of an artist's training, practised by Delacroix and G&eacute;ricault, C&eacute;zanne and Renoir. 
 At the age of sixty-eight Ingres made copies of masterpieces. 
 Accurate copies might be made, but there is in addition a category of interpretive copy, where the  artist copies those elements which most appeal to him. 
 This sort of copy is at the same time description and interpretation, the salient points being brought out by the copyist, who gains greater understanding of a masterpiece by his work. 
 It is not altogether satisfactory to call a print by an artist on the same theme as one of his paintings a description. 
 After all, it is an original work in itself. 
 Nevertheless, the differences between painting and print may be instructive, and help the interpretation of both. 
 By other forms of reproduction an image may be more or less degraded, so that nothing can be learnt from them. 
 There remains the courtesy paid by one art to another, as in the poem which Baudelaire suggested might be a high form of critical writing. 
 Or it may be music, as in Mussorgsky's composition which he entitled &bquo;Pictures from an Exhibition&equo;. 
 These forms of art, however, can generally be believed to have only a friendly connection with their inspiration, which, indeed, is normally only the starting point for the exercise of the talent of the musician or the poet. 
 It was a Romantic notion that there were resonances in the natural world and art; and it was Schiller who argued that music, the visual arts and poetry &bquo;always become&hellip; similar in their action on the mind&equo;. 
 THE AESTHETIC EXPERIENCE 
 Describing the object is not the only sort of description that a reader can expect from a critic. 
 The critic may be willing to share an experience with the reader, sometimes only of the circumstances in which a work was seen, as might be included in a personality article; but on other occasions the critic may give a fuller account of a personal response to a work of art. 
 This then becomes not a description of the object itself, but of the critical appreciation or dislike that the work gives rise to. 
 A hairline distinction exists between this description of personal experience and the evaluation of a work. 
 In an evaluation the critic may put personal feeling aside. 
 What is an aesthetic experience? 
 The question has puzzled generations of Western historians, critics and philosophers for at least two centuries because of the difficulty of disentangling the aesthetic from other responses. 
 A pragmatic view is that an aesthetic experience is what is described as such, and as there are varieties of religious experience, so there may be varieties of aesthetic experience. 
 Let us join an American educationalist talking to children about their understanding of art. 
 Michael J. Parsons describes his work in How We Understand Art . 
 He can introduce us to some American girls and boys who spoke up about what they noticed and liked. 
 If Andy thought a drawing by Paul Klee looked &bquo;sort of funny&equo;, he said so. 
 Parsons has some  sensible reflections about how the children's comments can be connected with psychological theory. 
 Parsons outlines five stages of cognition, which he has based on the scientific work of Kohlberg. 
 Other writers have used different theories, for example those of Piaget. 
 Herbert Read in his book Education through Art  took up the categories of types put forward by Jung. 
 But for our present purpose, Parsons' young friends will be good witnesses for us. 
 At first, Parsons tells us, &bquo;young children rarely find fault with paintings, no matter what their subject or style&hellip; they allow associations and memories freely to enter their response. 
 The common characteristic is the happy acceptance of whatever comes to mind&hellip; paintings are a stimulus to pleasant experience.&equo; 
 This personal and inner satisfaction gives way at the next stage to taking account of the viewpoints of others, and the experience of others. 
 Following this, the children come to realise that pictures are part of a tradition; finally, children may be prepared to make a judgement going beyond an individual culture. 
 This subtle scheme has advantages over simpler divisions. 
 Picasso's Guernica  is &bquo;OK for some but I don't like it&equo;, as a young boy put it. 
 The first stage starts with a simple liking, &bquo;I love blue&equo;, &bquo;My favourite colour is yellow&equo;. 
 In the next stages there is pleasure to be found in identifying subjects, and in discovering that pictures can convey messages expressively. 
 The idea that art is part of a tradition is a further step. 
 Whereas in stage two, detail is a pleasure, in stage four the refinement of imagery and simplicity may be enjoyed. 
 Comparisons between cultures become possible in the last stage. 
 This theory of stages in understanding art is helpful, and it will immediately be realised that the first two stages fit in with description, the next two with interpretation, while the final stage is judgement. 
 The theory is not so useful in defining the quality or strength of responses, and is no help in analysing the interactions of responses. 
 The theory is nevertheless of a sort which can be of real use in a classroom. 
 Perhaps the most usual description of aesthetic experience in the last hundred years has occurred when the critic has been faced with the need to react to one isolated work of art. 
 It was Roger Fry's contention that an object, say a bunch of carrots on a market stall, could be viewed in a practical way as something to eat for supper, or aesthetically. 
 This distinction can be backed up by philosophy and aesthetics, and descriptions can be found of the resultant moments of vision or epiphanies. 
 Our concern, however, is not with the difficulties of aesthetics, but only with what a critic writes of aesthetic experience, and how useful such an account may be. 
 This is an aspect of description, while it can be suggested that other religious, political or social concerns are more properly matters of interpretation. 
 Unfortunately it is often the case that writers do not allow themselves  to be so free in autobiographical disclosures as to say exactly how they felt on seeing some work of art. 
 While they may describe the work, they avoid describing their own responses to it. 
 Two honest critics can be given as exceptions, the first a Japanese who recorded a negative reaction to a picture which did not come up to his standards of meaningful symbolism. 
 He is Toru Torada, and the picture, Blue , by Kumai Sugai. 
 &bquo;Suddenly I was confronted by a huge and altogether indescribable blue figure wearing a red hat. 
 But the painting said nothing at all to me as I stood gazing at it. 
 It fulfilled none of my expectations and seemed to be merely trying to make me laugh at the fact that it had left me standing there grasping at nothing. 
 And that was all there was to it.&equo; 
 By contrast, here is a comment by an anthropologist who went to see the work of Mark Rothko. 
 &bquo;At the end of the exhibition, looking at a painting entitled Black on Grey , and dated 1970, I tried to pay attention, &bquo;bare attention&equo;, to its visual forms. 
 But what I knew and felt kept interfering.&equo; 
 What the anthropologist Jacques Maquet knew was that a few weeks after finishing this sombre painting, Rothko committed suicide. 
 Questions and comments, feelings and comparisons kept interrupting his attempt at contemplating the work. 
 Then, &bquo;Instead of struggling in vain to prevent them from reaching my consciousness, I stepped back, as it were, and let thoughts and feelings come and go. 
 I noticed their appearance and also noticed that, left alone, they disappeared too. 
 My previous attempts at getting rid of them had had the effect of reactivating them. 
 I was still overwhelmed by the painting, but I was now aware that I was overwhelmed, and this, somehow, seemed to establish a distance between this emotion and me.&equo; 
 BACKWATERS 
 IN the course of the 1970s V. S. Naipaul published two novels &mdash; Guerrillas  in 1975 and A Bend in the River  in 1979 &mdash; which address the theme of alienation, marginality. 
 The orphan modes apparent in the novels are those, respectively, of vengeance and flight. 
 And there are also orphan countries there &mdash; poor places, backwaters, as it might seem, at opposite ends of the earth. 
 Early in 1972, two corpses were found in graves dug in the garden of a house near Port of Spain, Trinidad. 
 The house belonged to a hustler called Michael de Freitas, latterly known by his Black Muslim names, Michael X and Michael Abdul Malik. 
 In London, where he spent a number of years, he had gained a reputation as a crook and as a threatener of whites and defender of the coloured-immigrant population. 
 One of the corpses was that of a local youth, the other that of an English girl, Gail Benson, who had come to the West Indies as the slavish lover of an American Negro, Hakim Jamal, &bquo;God&equo; to his friends, who was eventually to be shot dead in Boston. 
 It turned out that Gail Benson had been stabbed and buried alive. 
 De Freitas was tried, with others, for the Trinidad killings. 
 Kate Millett and William Kunstler went about the world protesting against the trial on the grounds that it was &bquo;political&equo;. 
 In May 1975, De Freitas was executed. 
 With these events in mind, Naipaul wrote a novel. 
 He is of Hindu stock, grew up amid the elaborate racial estrangements of Trinidad, and now lives in England. 
 He is a writer of rare gifts, and among his gifts is a capacity to wound. 
 He had previously written a journalistic piece about the killings, in which De Freitas figured as shabby and contemptible, and Gail Benson as a silly upper-class woman whose accessibility to the knife might almost have been construed as a last desperate act of Sixties modishness: an antic exported from Swinging London. 
 In a second article on the killings, Naipaul's wife Patricia used the word &bquo;antics&equo; to characterise the behaviour of the De Freitas set, which she firmly separated from the serious politics of the Caribbean.  
 I knew Gail Benson slightly when she was a schoolgirl, and remember a pretty moon face, big eyes, a freckled complexion deepening to russet, dark hair parted down the middle &mdash; a nut-brown maid and modern miss who must have wanted to be away from the French Lyc&eacute;e in South Kensington, shy, uneasy, wound-up. 
 I was curious to see what shrift she would receive in Naipaul's novel: the work of a man who has been spoken of by an old friend, the novelist Paul Theroux, as having in earlier times been &bquo;merciless, solitary, and (one of his favourite words) unassailable&equo;. 
 Well, it can be said that he does not allow his mercilessness to go undetected on this occasion. 
 And yet the treatment of his characters is not exactly what that prefatory article of his might have led one to expect. 
 Guerrillas  is set in an imaginary Caribbean country, whose capital city is by the sea. 
 There are mountains nearby. 
 Inland, a great plain. 
 The landscape yields three centres of activity. 
 First of all, outside the city, next to a growth of forest, there is Thrushcross Grange. 
 Named after the mansion in Wuthering Heights , this is a desolate agricultural commune run by Jimmy Ahmed, back from London, where he has been in some vague way a celebrity. 
 He has extracted land and money from business interests, but his revolutionary experiment has foundered from the start. 
 Nathaniel Hawthorne spoke of the &bquo;phantasmagorical antics&equo; he had played in describing the socialist community which appears in The Blithedale Romance : the antics played in the commune conceived by Ahmed could also be called phantasmagorical. 
 A nut-brown man by South Kensington standards, he is light-skinned in the West Indies: he is a Chinese Negro, who thinks of himself as a hakwai  Chinee &mdash; hakwai , he explains, being &bquo;Chinese for nigger&equo; &mdash; and who has not failed to notice that Emily Bront&euml;'s Heathcliff is rumoured to be the Emperor of China. 
 He is also a self-styled haji, or Muslim holy man. 
 He has gathered about him a defecting company of slum boys, with one of whom, Bryant, of the distorted face, his hair done up in small Medusa pigtails, he sometimes makes love. 
 The polluted landscape, and the heat in which it languishes, are important to the novel. 
 The heat, and the drought, have set this country on fire. 
 The hills smoke, mounds of rubbish smoulder, the verges of the roads are charred. 
 All this is felt to  testify, not just to a general rankness and decay, but to a conflagration of another kind &mdash; to what will happen if the political and racial tensions of the island can no longer be contained. 
 Gangs and guerrillas are talked of Wealthy people are talking of escape from a Caribbean version of James Baldwin's &bquo;the fire next time&equo;. 
 A white woman named Jane has come here from London, drawn by the glamour of the Third World, supposing herself to have arrived where the action is, where the &bquo;doers&equo; are. 
 She is, as she acknowledges, &bquo;playing with fire&equo;. 
 For a while she believes that Peter Roche is a doer. 
 Tortured by the regime in South Africa, Roche has written a book about it, and now, in the Caribbean, has joined the firm of Sablich's as a welfare worker, whose job is to define and to publicise the firm's good intentions toward the community. 
 It does not take long, however, for Jane to become disillusioned. 
 She &bquo;knew&equo; that &bquo;she had come to a place at the end of the world&equo;, a backwater where there was no action at all. 
 She lives with Roche above the city in a &bquo;Californian&equo; company house on the Ridge: this suburb, barricaded, fireproof perhaps, but lived in by prospective quitters of the country, supplies a further scene for the events of the novel. 
 Every so often, wild disordered men, with matted hair and &bquo;unseeing red eyes&equo;, are glimpsed &bquo;tramping along old paths, across gardens, between houses, and through what remained of woodland, like aborigines recognising only an ancestral landscape and insisting on some ancient right of way&equo;. 
 One of them has taken up residence in a hut in Roche's garden. 
 When Jane has Roche inspect the hut, the wild man, with his black face and his pigtails, has gone, leaving behind him &bquo;only a vague warm smell of old clothes, dead animals, grease and marijuana&equo;. 
 Perhaps he will be back &mdash; next time. 
 The novel's third scene or zone is the city itself. 
 The automobile has turned the city inside out, ranging new communities around the periphery and letting the centre rot: not far from the centre is an old slum district where the gangs operate. 
 They are a reality, whereas the guerrillas are only a dream &mdash; phantasmagorical. 
 But they are a reality which Naipaul treats in such a way that they, too, can at times seem phantasmagorical. 
 Everywhere, transistors give off the Reggae beat, making the place a party that never stops, and that might catch fire.  
 A sense of mystery and futility is imparted by events at the Grange and on the Ridge, and that sense is heightened by what takes place in the city when the party catches fire and rioting breaks out. 
 Politicians rush to the airport with their loot. 
 Then American military helicopters drift about the sky: a show of strength which is meant to secure American interests on the island, to make it safe for the bauxite investment. 
 Ahmed does not lead this revolution. 
 No one does. 
 It is not a revolution. 
 It is a mystery. 
 A journalist politician, Meredith Herbert, is made a minister &mdash; perhaps in order that he should be damaged by having to deal with the people on the streets; he is, perhaps, physically beaten up. 
 His role in relation to the disturbances is never really clarified, nor is that of Stephens, an intelligent boy who deserts the Grange, is in touch with the gangs, and is murdered. 
 The gangs exist as intimations of a power which cancels Ahmed's claim to be a revolutionary leader. 
 That power is located in the slums, in the kinship and solidarity which prevail there, in sanctions which welfare workers will not be able to comprehend. 
 The angle from which the riots are studied makes them appear distant and unimportant, while also worrying. 
 The same angle was conspicuous in the title story of Naipaul's previous book, In a Free State , where a coup in a new African country was studied, as it were, out of the corner of an eye; and it also occurs elsewhere in his work. 
 On these occasions the eye discerns a kind of visibility in &bquo;an area of darkness&equo;: this, in fact, is the title of the book which records Naipaul's &bquo;experience of India&equo;. 
 Enthusiasts for explanation, however, might want to explain that this &bquo;darkness visible&equo; tends to obscure and diminish what deserves to be understood, and that, for him, there are important countries and unimportant countries, and that the coups and riots of the latter are severely diminishable. 
 Here, he surrounds the politics of his imaginary country with darkness, distinguishes between its politics and what might be seen as the antics of bystanders, and concentrates on these bystanders. 
 At the same time, the reader can be made to feel that, on closer inspection, the country's politics might prove to be antics too. 
 Naipaul may in consequence be open to the charge of trying to diminish both the Michael X murders and the politics of the  Caribbean. 
 It can be said in his favour that the Michael X set seemed very like a fraud and a circus, and that these people had no deep connection with the politics of Trinidad. 
 In that last respect, however, they were like practically everyone else on the island, which may in itself be a reason why we should not be quick to decide that their behaviour lacked political significance, and consisted of antics. 
 Guerrillas , then, is shaped in order to accommodate its three zones, and in accordance with a distinction between the political and the phantasmagorical, though there are moments when phantasmagoria, futility, threatens to envelop the island &mdash; Grange, Ridge, gangs, government, politics and all. 
 It is shaped, besides, in accordance with a dramatic momentum which reaches successive peaks with the two sexual encounters between Jane and Jimmy Ahmed. 
 The encounters are separated by the riots and the second is followed by Jane's death. 
 Jane is a disgruntled, mean and worldly woman who presents herself as the victim of the men she sets out to attract and soon sees through and rejects. 
 For all her action-seeking, caring cosmopolitanism, she is imperial-insular in outlook, and soon sees through the Third World. 
 When she goes to bed with Ahmed, it is a fiasco. 
 He looks at her in fear: &bquo;the cleft was like a dumb, stupid mouth.&equo; 
 Her kiss is hard and wild; it goes with her &bquo;screaming&equo; eyes. 
 The later encounter is prefaced by advice from Jimmy, whose leadership pretensions are by now in ashes: &bquo;Be calm. 
 You're too greedy. 
 You give yourself away when you kiss like that. 
 A woman's whole life is in her kiss.&equo; 
 Whereupon he calmly buggers her. 
 In Argentina, according to Naipaul's journalism, such an act belongs to the fantasies of machismo: here, at the end of the world, and of Ahmed's tether, it bears the mark of defeat. 
 Sodomy is then compounded by a somnambulistic, almost involuntary murder, in which Bryant deals the blows. 
 The novel breathes a certain animus against Jane. 
 In contrast, the portrait of Ahmed has none of the disdain which could be observed in the writer's article about Michael X. Ahmed's bluffs are called, but they are understood, and carefully related to his earlier life on the island. 
 His words about kissing are worth hearing. 
 The airmail letters which he exchanges with his liberal friends in England tell a worse story of them than they  do of him, and hark back in fine style to that golden time when such friends used to kneel in London mosques with Michael X and other celebrities, squinting up at the Heavyweight Champion of the World's effulgent arse. 
 Jane is unlikely to earn much sympathy by virtue of the attention given to the environment which produced her dabbling in eventfulness and her poor kiss, and yet the two environments have more in common than would once have been thought possible. 
 It is a quite Caribbean Britain that has made her: a Britain at the end of the world which it used to rule. 
 Ahmed's revulsion from Jane sometimes seems to be shared by the writer. 
 It is possible to think that this plebeian has been lent some part of Naipaul's aristocratic fastidiousness, some part of his hostility, while also suffering the consequences of an exposure to these qualities, and to recall that both Ahmed and the author of An Area of Darkness  are preoccupied with the hanks of human shit that litter certain landscapes. 
 Ahmed's revenge is too bad to be condemned by the writer, who condemns his taste in furniture, and who condemns Jane. 
 The tragedies of miscegenation have never been simple &mdash; ever since Othello did what he had to do to Desdemona. 
 But it seems clear that this one bears the marks of defeat and despair, and of a reprisal directed at the liberal England which has let the violator down. 
 Naipaul's Caribbean country has been looted and exploited in the past, and it is still being looted and exploited. 
 Together with its stultifying racial enmities, this seems to have brought it to a halt, and placed it beyond history. 
 The behaviour of Naipaul's hustler-hero, his greedy white woman, his pseudo-guerrillas and mysterious gangs, his grafting emergent politicians with their State of Emergency, can be divided into the phantasmagorical and the political. 
 But these dimensions, as I have said, often appear to coincide. 
 His leading characters are seen to be, in some sense, petty and peripheral: but peripheral to what? 
 To standards of conduct attained in other countries, metropolitan standards, or to something on the island? 
 The island's public affairs and significant politics can occasionally be seen, out of the corner of an eye, to be no less invaded by contingency and incomprehensibility and futility than the life and times of Jimmy Ahmed, to have the status of rumour, to be little more than a remote and indecipherable response to a  random outbreak of violence. 
 There may be readers who object that the novel makes a mystique of darkness and futility in the course of saying that the whole island is peripheral, arrested. 
 This is a possibility to which an admirer of the novel keeps having to revert. 
 Times have changed since Naipaul began to write about the societies of the Caribbean: these are now less apt to seem, to the outsider, petty and remote. 
 His early comedies might have been taken to represent an unheard-of civility from the back of beyond. 
 Then, in 1961, came A House for Mr Biswaf : a rich, spacious novel of emergence from backwardness, indeed from slavery, an emergence which is invested with irony. 
 Since then, he has written, among other things, The Mimic Men : while relatively unsuccessful, this is the novel which most resembles Guerrillas , and it undoubtedly &bquo;diminishes&equo; the politics of emergent countries by raising doubts about the character of their independence and the motives of their leaders. 
 Over the intervening years, however, the West may be thought to have let him down by declining, diminishing, to the condition of the West Indies: by becoming a backwater, with its Watergate and Ulster, its economic arrests and somnambulistic states of emergency. 
 Naipaul's readers could well have become inclined to ask why it is that his novels seem to say that there is nothing to be done in, or with, the countries of their concern. 
 What are other countries doing? 
 Naipaul has long been a reader of Conrad, and Guerrillas  can make you think of Nostromo . 
 The geographies are similar. 
 Conrad's novel is about a fire-prone seaside South American republic, with foreign investors and their concessions: its silver has its lightly rendered counterpart in Naipaul's bauxite. 
 And the Conrad cry of &bquo;Inconceivable!&equo; may be weighed against Naipaul's insistence upon areas of darkness. 
 Compared with what we find in Naipaul's novel, however, Conrad's Costaguana is a country of the mind: it has the air of having been built to accommodate his meanings. 
 What we find in Guerrillas  is a narrative of unfailing fascination which delivers to the senses of the reader a country very like the countries he knows in the real world: equally, his experience of that country is very like his experience of Naipaul's India, in being rarely subdued by an awareness of the writer's more deliberate meanings. 
 It is  characteristic of the novel that climate and vegetation should count for no less than its comedy of manners, in which the Jewish businessman Harry de Tunja plays an enjoyable part, and that neither of these two elements, so far as they can be distinguished from the rest of the novel, should count for less than the opinions which they help to convey. 
 This is a very different work from Biswas . 
 It is brief and fast: it moves to the rhythms of a single drama, and the pace is perfectly judged. 
 Either book could be considered the masterpiece of someone whom I think of as among the most gifted authors now at work in England. 
 It might appear that the whole life of the later novel is in its sting, but there is more to it than sting. 
 Conrad said of The Secret Agent , another book about revolutionaries, cranks, crooks, somnambulists, peripherals and phantasmagoricals, that it was written &bquo;in scorn as well as in pity&equo;, and the same could be said of Guerrillas . 
 But in passing, as they may be thought to have done, from journalism to fiction, Naipaul's feelings, and their objects, underwent a change. 
 There is less scorn in the novel than there had been in the article, and a pity that must have come as surprise to readers of his work. 
 Some readers were upset by the hostility shown towards the murdered woman, and by the sympathy shown towards Jimmy &mdash; the sympathy of an author noted for his sceptical attitude towards revolutionaries, who had been hostile, in print, to all of the participants in the historical events which supplied part of his plot. 
 There must also have been readers who were led to reflect on Othello's self-righteous murder of Desdemona, and to reflect that Shakespeare's play expresses a view of mixed marriages which is both encouraging and discouraging. 
 In both Guerrillas  and A Bend in the River  the description of a coup, of an emergent country's state of emergency, is put together with the description of a sexual relationship between people of different races: an affinity is suggested, also apparent in the novella In a Free State . 
 In Guerrillas , the rebellion is mysterious, cryptic, while the sexual relationship is fully lit: a contrast also apparent, but somewhat different, in A Bend in the River . 
 Both novels see the world in colonial colours &mdash; as determined by empires, in the furtherance of which races have defeated and enslaved each other, in which they have met and married, in which a black mercenary might marry a daughter  of Venice. 
 For much of its course, the later novel takes all this for granted. 
 It is what is likely to occur. 
 Races insult each other, and make war, and make love, and they may mix these activities up. 
 At the same time, the novel finds more to object to in the less objectionable aspects of these activities than many readers might anticipate. 
 It is the work of a writer for whom, in successive fictions, the theme of sexual dealings between people of different races has necessitated the representation of violence. 
 Rapes and murders occur in this area, and may, of course, have to be treated. 
 And the theme is obviously of high consequence for the portrayal of any society where race is a trouble and where one race has subdued another. 
 The society may be symbolised by such dealings, and experienced through them. 
 Hardship and discontent may declare themselves there, in a victim's revenge. 
 In addressing itself to such possibilities, however, A Bend in the River , for all its air of simplicity, is never simple. 
 Its narrator and chief human presence is by no means straightforwardly a victim, and the difference between oppressor and oppressed can be hard to identify. 
 The novel is narrated by a Moslem of Indian origin, whose family has been settled on the east coast of Africa, as traders. 
 Salim leaves them, takes off on the first of a series of &bquo;flights&equo;, and treks to the interior, to a country which appears to be compounded of the Congo and of Uganda, in order to earn a living from a store which he has acquired from a man whose daughter he is expected to marry one day. 
 Reading Salim's palm, the man points out that he is &bquo;faithful&equo;. 
 Salim can be designated a Kenya Asian: the name we give to those hard-working aliens who have been driven out of African countries, and who include the shopkeepers and merchants expropriated in Uganda by Amin. 
 Kenya Asians are now working hard in the darkness and grime of British cities, where Patel is among the commonest names in the telephone directory. 
 Salim is bound by certain of the rules and assumptions of kinship. 
 His kin are entrepreneurs, a wandering bourgeoisie: they have known what it is to be strangers in tight corners, as he himself is a stranger in this tight African town. 
 At the same time, he has wandered some distance from his kin, in spirit. 
 So he is both doubly an outcast and no outcast at all. 
 Unlike many of the towns through which he has bribed his way in his Peugeot  from the coast, this one isn't &bquo;full of blood&equo;. 
 But it is between coups, or unrests, and has lately been smashed and looted. 
 It is the sort of place which will always revive and rebuild, and in such a place Salim's part is to make good, carry on. 
 The country, formerly a colony, now &bquo;independent&equo;, is controlled by a black &bquo;big man&equo; in the capital down-river. 
 An atavistic, tribal, magical resistance spreads about the bush: starveling rebels are hunted by an army, but magic bends the army's guns. 
 There is far less of the mystification which can be attributed to the account of the troubles in Guerrillas : what we get is the mysterious politics of forest and township as observed by an outsider, by an African Asian who understands a good deal of what is going on. 
 Salim buries his valuables &mdash; from another point of view, his ill-gotten gains &mdash; and an ominous silence descends on the town: 
 Sometimes I thought I could hear the noise of the rapids. 
 It was the eternal noise at that bend in the river, but on a normal day it couldn't be heard here. 
 Now it seemed to come and go on the wind. 
 At midday, when we shut the shop for lunch, and I drove through the streets, it was only the river, glittering in the hard light, that seemed alive. 
 No dugouts, though; only the water hyacinths travelling up from the south, and floating away to the west, clump after clump, with the thick-stalked lilac flowers like masts. 
 Outside the town, a polytechnic and seminar centre has been planted by Presidential fiat. 
 It is headed by the big man's white man, the Belgian scholar Raymond, who has lost favour with his patron and is sinking into ceremonies of highly-placed sagacity, Salim has an affair with the white man's white woman, his stylish wife Yvette: radical chic persuades him that he &bquo;never wanted to be ordinary again'. 
 Hitherto a shameful brothel man, Salim is uplifted by their meetings in his flat: &bquo;My wish for an adventure with Yvette was a wish to be taken up to the skies.&equo; 
 Blood flows within the town; Raymond's work on a collection of the President's speeches, which could restore him to favour, languishes. 
 Presently the affair ends in insult: Salim beats Yvette and spits on her, and flies to London, where he gets to know his intended bride. 
 When he returns to the town, he is arrested, but is set free by Ferdinand, an African promoted from the bush whose patron he has once been. 
 Salim makes  good his escape on the steamer &mdash; bound, we take it, for his bride. 
 The family slave boy, Metty (the name means half-caste), who had come to live with him, is firmly left behind. 
 Salim is now homeless in the sense that he has shed an old tendency to nostalgia: &bquo;the idea of going home, of leaving, the idea of the other place&equo;, he takes to be weakening and destructive. 
 This feeling is added to a previous illumination, to a stoicism which believes in &bquo;the unity of experience and the illusion of pain'.&equo; 
 Salim tells Salim's story. 
 It is not Naipaul's; it does not constitute the author's testament or confession on the subject of race relations and the rest of it. 
 The novel (or so I hope) signals a separation between author and narrator with its very first sentence: &bquo;The World is what it is; men who are nothing, who allow themselves to become nothing, have no place in it.&equo; 
 An early passage separates this man, who does not want to be nothing, from the trading elders of his family &mdash; pessimists who could take risks, and were consoled by their religion. 
 I could never rise so high. 
 My own pessimism, my insecurity, was a more terrestrial affair. 
 I was without the religious sense of my family. 
 The insecurity I felt was due to my lack of true religion, and was like the small change of the exalted pessimism of our faith, the pessimism that can drive men on to do wonders. 
 It was the price for my more materialist attitude, my seeking to occupy the middle ground, between absorption in life and soaring above the cares of the earth. 
 Elsewhere Salim separates himself from the doers and makers of the big world beyond him, of whom it is said: &bquo;They're making cars that will run on water.&equo; 
 Such people are &bquo;impartial, up in the clouds, like good gods&equo;. 
 The men in the bush are watched by gods who are barely a jump above their heads: these white gods are more remote. 
 Salim reads about their doings in his magazines of popular science, and letting Ferdinand into the secret of his interest, he feels he is revealing his &bquo;true self&equo;. 
 But if his &bquo;true nature&equo; is to be romantically on the rise, and to have &bquo;ideas&equo;, it is also his nature to occupy the middle ground. 
 It isn't lost on him that his reading matter &mdash; popular science, pornography &mdash; is &bquo;junk&equo;. 
 For much of the time, he is the achiever who tries for a reasonable percentage return.  
 Salim presents himself in a light which requires the reader to be told that, although he himself has been making good, he is grieved, or affects to be, by the discovery that the slavish Metty has been getting on: &bquo;You've been very much getting on as though you're your own man.&equo; 
 Their relationship has tenderness in it, and treachery. 
 Metty betrays his master and is then left in the lurch, predicting a future whose likelihood the novel does not lead us to discount: &bquo;They're going to kill and kill.&equo; 
 Metty is a misfit, as Golding's Matty is in Darkness Visible , a novel which appeared at the same time as Naipaul's. 
 English fiction loves such people; it never tires of the lurch, of such areas of darkness. 
 Salim's outlook incorporates a version of that of his friend Indar, who teaches in the polytechnic for a while, and lends himself to the philanthropic white-liberal cultivation of the African experience, where some of the best comedy in the book is located. 
 At one point Indar recounts his struggles and illuminations. 
 &bquo;Raised&equo; from the ruck, originally, by his family's wealth, he doesn't want to &bquo;sink&equo;, and rejects &bquo;the idea of defeat&equo; that prevails in the Third World: &bquo;I'm tired of being on the losing side. 
 I don't want to pass. 
 I know exactly who I am and where I stand in the world. 
 But now I want to win and win and win., Salim, too, wants to win, and his affair with Yvette is a victory: All my energy and mind were devoted to that new end of winning the person.&equo; 
 In possessing her, he is both taken out of, and placed in possession of, himself: &bquo;She gave me the idea of my manliness I had grown to need.&equo; 
 When the friendship begins to fail, he says: &bquo;What she drew out of me remained extraordinary to me.&equo; 
 The affair seems to him to belong to the town, to have no future, and they are parted when the town comes under fear and hazard. 
 He finds himself &bquo;considering the idea of flight&equo;, and the idea of defeat: &bquo;1 suppose that, thinking of my own harassment and Raymond's defeat, I had begun to consider Yvette a defeated person as well, trapped in the town, as sick of herself and the wasting asset of her body as I was sick of myself and my anxieties.&equo; 
 But the fit of jealousy in which he beats her would appear to mean something more than these words of explanation enable one to understand. 
 This jealousy may be felt to be like Othello's in having more to do with difference of race, and with the jealousies of race, than  the jealous man, or than the work he belongs to, seems disposed to state. 
 Three of literature's myths underlie the narrative. 
 They are myths of the foreign woman, which bring together achievement and betrayal, achievement and desertion. 
 Of the stories I have in mind, Othello and Desdemona, Samson and Delilah, Dido and Aeneas, only the third is spoken of, and it is spoken of oracularly. 
 The town has two Classical mottoes, one of which consists of 
 Latin words carved on the ruined monument near the dock gates: Miscerique probat populos, et foedera jungi . 
 &bquo;He approves of the mingling of the peoples and their bonds of union&equo;: that was what the words meant, and again they were very old words, from the days of ancient Rome. 
 They came from a poem about the founding of Rome. 
 The very first Roman hero, travelling to Italy to found his city, lands on the coast of Africa. 
 The local queen falls in love with him, and it seems that the journey to Italy might be called off. 
 But then the watching gods take a hand; and one of them says that the great Roman god might not approve of a settlement in Africa, of a mingling of peoples there, of treaties of union between Africans and Romans. 
 That was how the words occurred in the old Latin poem. 
 In the motto, though, three words were altered to reverse the meaning. 
 According to the motto, the words carved in granite outside our dock gates, a settlement in Africa raises no doubts: the great Roman god approves of the mingling of peoples and the making of treaties in Africa. 
 There is irony here. 
 We are made to feel that the reversed meaning is wrong. 
 This is a book which takes for granted, and which has doubts about, the mingling of peoples, and it is a book which takes pride in its chosen people &mdash; Salim's people and, in some measure, Naipaul's. 
 Virgil's Aeneas leaves a burning Troy to go on his adventures, effect his betrayal, and arrive at the Tiber, where an empire is to rise. 
 Salim is an Aeneas who makes it to London, where those of his blood are founding a way of life, and he has his Dido both in Yvette and in Metty. 
 Perhaps this much can be said without suggesting that the book is an epic for Kenya Asians, which tells of a people threatened by nobodies, nothings, and managing to survive. 
 Nor is it a one-sided account of the injustices suffered by this people, or a defence of the energetic stranger.  
 The myths are not all equally available to the novel, and they are not enough to explain it. 
 This lucid and candid prose, strong in the detail of a particular time and place, often ignores, and can on occasion seem to depart from, the sense of the literature it embodies. 
 The offended looks of the muzzy black citoyen  who is put in to own Salim's store when trade is politicised are funny, and important, and owe nothing to the Aeneid . 
 But those who would prefer to explain the book as a comedy of manners, or as current affairs, might have difficulty in explaining the prominence given to the love affair. 
 The plot states that an attachment to a strange woman, a woman who does not belong to this community of strangers, is succeeded by a return to the community, and by the dispersal, and survival, of the community. 
 Salim states that he was having a rough time, and was tired and suspicious of Yvette: he does not say that a tribal god commanded him to leave her. 
 It may be that neither statement need be held to subtract from the other, but there could well be some dispute as to which of the two is the more deeply entrenched in the novel. 
 Salim gets out of Africa, and as he does so, there seem to be allusions to the journey upriver in Conrad's Heart of Darkness , which also ends (though by no means hopefully) with an Intended. 
 When his steamer quits the town, it is attacked by rebels, but manages to fight clear. 
 Meanwhile, in this closing scene, the water hyacinths proceed towards the sea, as they have been doing throughout the action. 
 They keep coming, like immigrants, or refugees, like the South-East Asian boat people subsequent to the novel. 
 Salim's flight to whatever is to become of him can be compared to the movement of these flowers, and to the Romeward journey in Virgil. 
 His fortunes are those of a solitary who is due to return to his people and to chance it with them in a further foreign place. 
 And they are those of a hero, as well as a drifting hyacinth. 
 He is a hero, with a hero's faults: an achiever and an adventurer who is also a victim and an outcast, a shameful man and a faithful family man. 
 Subtly mythic and ethnocentric, the novel is one of Naipaul's most rewarding. 
 It speaks of the separation of races, and of a world which mixes them up. 
 But if it sometimes seems to be saying, on Salim's behalf, that race or kinship wins, it is also the case that it is full of losers, that it has a lively feeling for the Africans of market  and bush, and for their African troubles, and for the situation of Salim as someone evolved or emerged from a tribal narrowness to an experience of sexual love which is liberating and dramatic, and that it does justice to Metty's last state, left behind in the dangerous town at the bend in the river.  
 Poor Boys 
 RONALD Fraser's In Search of a Past  was published in 1984, and Ralph Glasser's Growing up in the Gorbals  in 1986. 
 These are books by middle-aged semi-Scots who have chosen to publish accounts of their early lives which lay stress on the troubles they experienced, on the troubles inflicted, within their respective environments, by poverty and servitude, and on the responsibility of relatives for some of what the writers had to suffer. 
 The question could be thought to arise of whether they are seeking revenge. 
 Authors are not supposed to avenge themselves in their writings, but they do, and if they were to be prevented, there would be far fewer books. 
 I am not confident that either book may be said to be well-written; that question, too, could be thought to arise. 
 In Search of a Past  affects not to be written at all &mdash; so much as researched, recorded and compiled. 
 But the editorial method which is applied to the data has much to display that is well-spoken. 
 They are both interesting books because they tell interesting stories, and are arranged to dramatic effect in interesting ways. 
 Juliet Mitchell has called Fraser's book &bquo;a miniature masterpiece&equo;, while, according to Chatto, Glasser's &bquo;may well become a classic of modern autobiography&equo;. 
 Both men made for the Mediterranean eventually, for reasons which may have involved a respite from British miseries and injustice. 
 These were located, in Fraser's early life, amid the flatlands, and the privileged high ground, of Southern England, and, in Glasser's, amid the antique squalor and grimness of the Gorbals district of Glasgow, now erased by developers and replaced by the squalor of the high-rise estate. 
 Fraser was to be the author of Blood of Spain , an oral history of the Civil War. 
 Glasser was to be the author of a study of a Calabrian village, and the Spanish war bears a bleak meaning in the story he tells here. 
 His adult life has been spent as a psychologist and economist, engaged on problems of development in the Third World. 
 He has published a second volume of autobiography, in which he deals with his years as a student at  Oxford before and after the world war, and is now bursar of one of the colleges there. 
 Ronald Fraser's book arranges a marriage between Freud and Marx. 
 One law for the rich and another for the poor, as the two systems can be made to seem, are laid down together in a book which commemorates a desertion, on the author's part, of the rich for the poor. 
 He had hit on the &bquo;aim of combining two different modes of enquiry &mdash; oral history and psychoanalysis &mdash; to uncover the past in as many of its layers as possible&equo;. 
 He is saying this &mdash; outlining the aim &mdash; to his analyst in the course of the therapeutic sessions whose speech forms part of the oral record that constitutes almost all of the book. 
 He is to learn about the troubles of his early life by interviewing the servants of the family and by submitting to the interviews of psychoanalysis. 
 The analyst had previously referred to their sessions as a &bquo;voyage of inner discovery&equo;: Fraser thinks that his tape-recordings make possible a &bquo;voyage into the social past&equo;. 
 The latter trip may enable him to discover the &bquo;external objects&equo;, the analyst thinks: &bquo;now, through analysis, you're seeking the internal objects.&equo; 
 &bquo;And the two don't always coincide&equo;, Fraser replies: &bquo;That's my split vision. 
 Formed by the past, a person is also deformed by it.&equo; 
 The exchange has roused the analyst to contributions that are firmer and more energy-consuming than those he generally vouchsafes: &bquo;it's not the past but what we make of the past that shapes our future and present.&equo; 
 Fraser observes that &bquo;analysis is more limiting because it recreates the past only in the forms in which it was internalised or repressed., 
 Not every reader of his book can have come to it believing the chauvinistic claims that have sometimes been issued on behalf both of psychoanalysis and of oral history, or prepared to believe that these pursuits could be successfully combined. 
 But it does not take long to decide that the experiment is being conducted with skill, and that the pursuits have at least a little in common. 
 A piece of oral history may be meant to do without a presiding historian in much the same way in which an analytic session may be meant to do without a presiding analyst; theoretical presuppositions are subject in each case to a show of suspension, though it is clear that the theories of Freud and others will be present in the consulting-room, and that oral historians may be sympathetic to socialism and to the methods of  Marxist historiography. 
 Fraser's book is not without its evident presuppositions, and not every reader will feel that this autobiographer, having perused and digested his tape-recordings, talked to his analyst and completed his inner and outer voyages, knew something radically different about his past from what he had known before: that something had been found, or proved. 
 He had lived with his past for the best part of fifty years, and his book tells what he had come to know of it over that interval of time, with help from the theories of Marx and Freud. 
 And in so doing it can often convey that a past is not a thing to be discovered. 
 As the analyst said, it is not discovered but made. 
 Ronald Fraser was not trying to determine, like certain historians of former times, what his past &bquo;really was&equo;. 
 But there is some question of a pathogenic secret, of the recovery of material hitherto repressed which influenced his perception of his mother: and his understanding of the past would certainly appear to have been enlarged by his researches. 
 He talks of himself as &bquo;split&equo;, and as implicated in splits of a wider incidence. 
 A split appears to be spoken of in the conversation from which I have just quoted: formed by the past, he is also deformed by it. 
 But this is only one aspect of the bifurcation he describes. 
 Fraser's fork took several forms, as I say: or one might prefer to say that there was more than one fork to reckon with. 
 Born in Hamburg, he was transferred to the Manor House at Amnersfield, the son of a remote German-American mother and of a sour, withdrawn, irritable Anglo-Scottish father, who would retreat behind the Times  and spend the evening in lonely state, smoking his pipe in his kilt. 
 He was never to say hello to you, and he once said that he would not be interested in his child &bquo;until he can go out shooting with me&equo;. 
 (Elsewhere, another angry gentleman of the period, Evelyn Waugh, had waited for his children to be of an age to converse with him, before taking an interest.) 
 The household shot, and it rode, to hounds and in all directions, but Ronald Fraser had no love for horses. 
 The poor little rich boy was looked after by a second mother in the person of strict Ilse, from Germany: this did a great deal, but not enough, to relieve the isolation he felt &mdash; which, as his researches disclosed, was to be a factor in the isolation and rejection suffered in turn by his younger brother,  who also left for the Mediterranean. 
 When friendships finally became possible for him they were with children of the lower orders. 
 His parents did not get on and parted during the war, which put an end to the old hierarchic world of Amnersfield, where you were not to look at your masters when they came up the drive, but to hoe on regardless. 
 Mrs Fraser was suspected in the neighbourhood of being an enemy spy; presently she remarried &mdash; her new husband a jolly, but for the son disturbing wing-commander. 
 The testimonies in the book were obtained mostly from the underlings of the house, led by sly, supportive Bert, a man who was able to take and to give pleasure &mdash; a fine portrait, which is also a self-portrait, of a second father. 
 Bert's testimony, and Ilse's, are probably paramount. 
 &bquo;The image you give&equo;, Fraser tells Ilse, meaning the image she gives of himself as a boy, &bquo;is one of dependency, extreme docility. 
 It was my natural character, you think, evident from birth&hellip; 
 &equo;. Ilse had been trained in an orphanage, and he then tells her, with a smile: &bquo;I wouldn't claim any privilege that an orphan wasn't entitled to.&equo; 
 He reverts to the point with the analyst: &bquo;Supposing I didn't have what a child objectively should be entitled to&hellip;&equo;. 
 In coping with the unsaid and unsayable, oral history is impelled towards aposiopesis. 
 The analyst's response is apt to consist of an &bquo;&hellip;&equo; 
 But if the work is oral history, it is literature too &mdash; a disclosure of predicament and bereavement. 
 The enigmatic three dots to which it is impelled are those of a romantic orphan, as well as those of his reticent doctor. 
 A romantic orphan, though, who was able to accept that he had caused his brother to suffer. 
 In all this there was plenty of scope for an awareness and endurance of contradiction. 
 Contradictions, splits, can readily be perceived, by those minded to perceive them; pursuits that can be married, like oral history and psychoanalysis, can be found to separate. 
 What matters is what happens when the individual, who incorporates his past, incorporates and transforms the divisions which are part of that past. 
 Fraser reflects: &bquo;Two mothers and I'm torn between them&hellip;&equo;. 
 Torn between &bquo;the distant star and the cold, close moon&equo;. 
 And neither of the women was to prove &bquo;sufficient&equo;. 
 &bquo;You split them&equo;, prompts the analyst, &bquo;into the good and the bad mother.&equo; 
 The analyst proceeds: 'All mothers have to be frustrating as well as loving. 
 But  being consoled by another mother who seems unfrustrating makes it harder to reconcile the two&hellip;&equo;. 
 This appears to be a key point, but it is one that is left controversial. 
 It is possible to imagine that for some people such consolation might make it easier to reconcile the two, and to wonder what it was that made the difference in Fraser's case. 
 There were other things that had to be reconciled, and we hear presently of &bquo;a role of inherent superiority which came to me from outside, from the servants among others. 
 Inside, however, I felt inherently inferior, inadequate to fill the role. 
 That was the split&hellip;&equo; 
 (Fraser's dots). 
 He asks the daughter of the refugee cook, remembering the days when he made love with this daughter, if she had known two different boys. 
 Later in the book Mr Fraser recognises that he has talked both of rubbing out the past and of preserving it: &bquo;The aims seem contradictory, don't they? 
 But they're the same. 
 I kept the past alive out of a desire for revenge. 
 One day I would write it &mdash; and them  &mdash; off the face of the earth&hellip;&equo;. 
 He is referring to his parents, I think. 
 Later still, the analyst suggests that Fraser may want to offer reparation, by writing this book, for the guilt he had felt in relation to his father, and Fraser asks: &bquo;For wanting to destroy him so I could have my mother to myself?&equo; 
 &bquo;Uh-huh&hellip;&equo;. 
 &bquo;And for wanting&equo;, Fraser adds, &bquo;to destroy her&hellip;&equo;. 
 Is the book, then, a &bquo;monument to destruction&equo;? 
 The servants, who did much of the living which is commemorated here, and his parents, who did so little of it, are placed well within reach of an impartial sympathy in a work which nowhere feels  vindictive, and which declines to settle for any final understanding of what went on. 
 Despite its title, and for all Fraser's grave and civil investigative demeanour, the book does not exhibit this past as something to be searched for, uncovered, so much as something which is unfindable, interminable. 
 Understanding is deferred, rather as it is in certain recent theoretical accounts of the way literature works. 
 But this does not diminish the importance of the provisional discoveries which it contains, which the writer has moved to incorporate. 
 From the point of view of the people of the Gorbals in the Thirties, fox-hunting and psychoanalysis would have been practically indistinguishable concerns of the rich in the Sassenach South, of the &bquo;high heid yins&equo; of the world &mdash; an expression of  the poor in Scotland then, which Ralph Glasser uses. 
 And there is a point of view from which Ronald Fraser might be seen as a man of Marxist leanings who paid a professional adviser what may have been a fair whack of a working man's wages to enquire with him into the deficiencies of his affective life. 
 This is a split that can rarely have been witnessed in Glasgow &mdash; which does not indicate that he was at fault in consulting his analyst, but does indicate that these autobiographies are sited in very different places. 
 Nail on the Banister  by R. Stornaway, alias R. Scott, is an eloquent Scots joke of the Thirties, and it allows one to say that Glasser's banister was a bed of nails, but that his slides may have been less painful than Fraser's. 
 He could well have been called a victim, and his book consigns itself, as Fraser's does, to that large literature in which the sufferings of victims are recounted: but he does not see himself as a romantic orphan. 
 He belonged to a family of immigrant Jews which had fled to a Glasgow tenement and a community of Yiddish-speakers within the city. 
 Round the corner was Dixon's Blazes, a blast furnace, and the Workers' Circle, where dreams of socialist emancipation were debated &mdash; dreams which were soon to fade for Glasser. 
 Nor was he able to believe in the religion of his community. 
 Anti-Semitism was not, it appears, a major threat in an environment where many kinds of threat and affliction &mdash; such as its gangster debt-collectors, the &bquo;menodge men&equo; &mdash; competed for consciousness. 
 His mother died early, worn out by making ends meet and by her husband's gambling. 
 Glasser still stands in awe of this formidable, feckless man. 
 His sisters were to flee the family, precipitating an ordeal of severance which compounded others and marked him to the quick. 
 He wants to go to university, turns up to listen to Einstein, studies hard; but his father won't have it, and at the age of 14 he becomes a soap boy in a barber's and then a presser in a garment shop. 
 The Gorbals comes across, in careful descriptions, as a ferocious place. 
 It should be seen for what it was, and especially by those who feel like regretting its erasure, and alleging that its replacement has made an environment which may be even worse &mdash; of tower blocks filled with heroin and despair. 
 The trouble is that the allegation has begun to seem convincing. 
 &bquo;The hovels and the vennels&equo; of the nineteenth-century Scottish  city have been projected into the sky; the lower depths of the Thirties have not gone from urban Britain. 
 And we have a government which has been slow to worry whether the people there die of Aids. 
 At one stage Glasser is invited to look at a tenement close &mdash; by Bernard, a Communist who was to fight in Spain and return with an altered mind. 
 In Spain Bernard questioned the principle that the end justifies the means &mdash; &bquo;the human price was too high&equo; &mdash; and it had almost &bquo;cost him his life&equo;. 
 (But can this be said to have been what happened? 
 The book has explained that, having been a murderer of unreliables for the Republicans, he was shot at by a rival and went straight back to Glasgow.) 
 At this earlier stage Ralph goes into the close and takes a look at the human price of capitalism. 
 Nearly all the stone steps in the first flight up to the half-landing were broken, with jagged edges where bits of tread had fallen away. 
 Some had almost no tread left. 
 Plaster had come away from the walls from ceiling to floor, and along the lower part the bared cement, originally grey, was stained yellow and smelt of urine. 
 On a patch where the rough surface of brickwork was exposed, someone had vomited, probably a passing drunk whose sense of propriety, demanding privacy, had deterred him from being sick in the street; or a returning resident who could not wait to climb the few steps to the communal toilet on the first half-landing. 
 The detritus had stuck to the pitted surface in a wide streaky band as it slid lumpily from chest height to the floor. 
 Judging by the strength or its smell, a mixture of beer and fish and chips, the vomit was recent. 
 Another powerful smell, of decaying rubbish, came mainly from the ash-pits at the far end of the corridor, but also from a deposit scattered over the floor. 
 Despite the cold wet wind blowing in hard from the street, the cloud of mephitic vapours lingered stupefyingly about our heads. 
 &bquo;Mephitic&equo; might be compared with Fraser's &bquo;ulcerous&equo; in &bquo;Resentment wells up like an ulcerous vapour&equo;. 
 Glasser's vapours are different from Fraser's. 
 They stink, while Fraser's are mental. 
 Both men lived through the Depression, but Fraser's depressions were only indirectly linked with the hardships of people he knew. 
 At the same time, these hardships are a focus of his attention. 
 The two words carry a note of declamation &mdash; a note otherwise absent from Fraser's account. 
 Glasser's prose is sometimes  declamatory and sententious in an old-fashioned sort of way, and sometimes awkward (&bquo;Hidden in the near future, he was to be proved right&equo;). 
 But it rises to many of its ferocious and grievous occasions. 
 We are in the Scotland of TB, pneumonia and drink, in which sex is spoken of as a matter of men attacking women. 
 At the end of the corridor which he describes, before you get to the rubbish, is the place where the young make love. 
 Their elders make it upstairs in the flats, attended by small children &mdash; brothers and sisters who grow up in the Gorbals, Glasser says, to try it with each other. 
 About these matters it seems to me that he writes really well, in a manner that might suggest the intent translation of a Latin author anxious to tell the truth. 
 Afterwards she parted the curtains and came out naked to lift the unsleeping, finely aware child back into bed, to lie between her and the man lying open-mouthed in post-coital sleep. 
 And then mother and child might lie awake for a while, locked in unique perplexities. 
 She, her body prompting her still, with no finality in her, turned her world over and over again in her mind's restless fingers. 
 The child, possessed by wonder and nameless hauntings, tried to join together the heavings and creakings and groans and gasps and little cries he had heard as he lay on the floor, his mother's disturbed concentration now, his father's stillness as if felled, and the sticky warmth in which he lay between them, something more than the sweat that was there before, a substance he divined as elemental, mysterious, newly decanted, that touched his flesh and his senses with profound, unattainable meaning. 
 At the beginning of the book a dear friend, Charlie, another immigrant boy, leaves for Russia with his family &mdash; for the land, they hope, of the free. 
 Ralph strives to address &bquo;the high heid yins of Russia&equo; to solicit news of the family, and receives his letter back from the Embassy in London, stamped: &bquo;Communication not permitted.&equo; 
 And the family was never heard of again. 
 Glasser orders his events thematically, while also wanting to tell a story and to spring surprises. 
 Charlie's departure is the first of several, and this event is succeeded by the announcement of a further theme when the rabbi's thunderings pass over the heads of his congregation and the writer notes: &bquo;in later years I would wonder how different my life might have been if a few people, those closest to me, had  been frightened &mdash; just  a little.&equo; 
 Among those closest who should have been frightened was Annie, his girl for a while. 
 Annie left him, and then, pregnant, offered herself in order to saddle him with someone else's child &mdash; and this when he had just received a telegram awarding him a scholarship to Oxford. 
 Just when his ship was coming in she might have set fire to it. 
 He condemns her for trying this trick, which is followed by a terrible fall downstairs in the course of an attempt to end her pregnancy. 
 She had known that his love for her would remain, and &bquo;for her to have acted on that knowledge&equo; in resorting to the deception &bquo;made her deed unforgivable&equo;. 
 Those closest to him who should have been too frightened to behave as they did include his father, but they also include his sisters, who struck out for themselves in a fashion which has him siding with his father. 
 Lilian, the older sister, errs by studying hard to become a money-minded businesswoman with a grudge and a smart flat, and by blackmailing her employer, also her lover, by means of an abortion. 
 Glasser talks of her as if, in walking out, she had gone on to walk the streets. 
 She is seen to suffer for what she did, and Mary, the other sister, likewise &bquo;paid heavily&equo;: let down by an Indian student with whom she had been having a long affair. 
 &bquo;She set higher store by emotional security&equo; than her sister, &bquo;and thought she would find it with a man soft-hearted and caring and pliant, far removed, as she thought, from father's toughness and uncontrollability.&equo; 
 Glasser thunders on: &bquo;Both Lilian and Mary invested too much emotional capital in their opposition to father, whose influence naturally remained dominant, try as they might to escape; and this imbalance distorted their view of relationships and of the world.&equo; 
 This is a male view of the matter, in which women are attacked, and which had me admiring these ugly sisters. 
 It is made clear that the boy was exposed to serious danger by his father's irresponsibility and by his sisters' departure: but his sisters had been exposed to this father too, and had had to defend themselves. 
 A father's influence which has been revealed as destructive and all but disastrous is thought to have remained dominant &mdash; as was only natural &mdash; until the women broke away for good. 
 An author is taking his revenge in setting down these judgements, begrudging the grudges of  others &mdash; while uttering, this once, the cry of the deserted child. 
 Neither of these books, however, could be said to be intent on revenge. 
 Glasser presents a full picture of the behaviour, good and bad, which he encountered in an area of maximum difficulty, and it is not often that such a picture has been presented. 
 The familiar and approved accounts of Scottish life have long favoured a country of hills and fields and firesides, where braw lads and bonny lasses dance reels and go on, after early struggles, to better things; where the best thing of all is the kind landed family that comes up from London to visit them, famous for its stables, castles and ceremonies. 
 Another fallacious account comes to mind. 
 The literary naturalism of the last century went to the poor and itemised their way of life, producing for adversity truthful, distressing inventories and interiors &mdash; as in George Moore's novel of the Nineties, Esther Waters , which starts with a manor-house, servants and horses, and travels to Soho for compulsive gambling and a fatal cough. 
 In Glasser's book, and in Fraser's, the activities of the poor can be seen as activities which had been performed, and written about, in the past: but these are books which intimate that the lists and specifications of a caring naturalism &mdash; features by which they have indeed been influenced &mdash; were never exhaustive: that the truth-tellers did not tell it, and that the omissions were systematic. 
 The sexuality of the past, and the extent of the intimidatory violence, were only very faintly registered. 
 Esther had quite as hard a time of it as Annie, one might feel, but even so, Moore's spirited novel can be thought to settle for an anodyne poverty. 
 To say this is not the same as complaining of his acknowledgement that poor people can have a good time. 
 No lie in that. 
 There were pleasures for both boys in the course of their growing-up. 
 For Glasser, there was Annie, study, socialist hikes and camp-fires in the hills outside the city; for Fraser, there were model aeroplanes, and a mute attraction shared with a boy of lower status, and there was Bert and Ilse. 
 But what is most striking about both books is the sense they give of how desolate and enclosed an adolescence could be, at opposite ends of the society. 
 The better things presumed to be in store for Glasser when he went off as a scholarship boy to a glamorous university in  the South of England are, in a sense, the subject of Gorbals Boy at Oxford , his second volume of autobiography. 
 The refugee from Glasgow saw through, and stood up to, some famous middle-class progressives, was asked to spy on student Communists, was asked, by a girl at a party, to &bquo;do something! 
 Julian's got a knife.&equo; 
 At another party, in the South of France, a reefer is placed between his lips by a girl whose trousers fall down. 
 &bquo;I had scaled magic heights and found obscurantism, absence of hope, a world infinitely darker than I had ever imagined possible from where I had stood in the Gorbals.&equo; 
 I can only hope that the bursar now inhabits a wholly healthy Oxford.  
 Long live pastiche 
 PETER Ackroyd's novels Hawksmoor  and Chatterton  do much to explain one another. 
 Both books mingle old times and new times, and both give expression to fantasies of replication, with Hawksmoor  a hard act to follow. 
 Its old times are brilliantly rendered, and its appeal is in part generic. 
 The biographer of T. S. Eliot, who was himself to speak of the &bquo;dark&equo; experience, of the &bquo;rude unknown psychic material&equo;, incorporated in his poem The Waste Land , can be seen in Hawksmoor  to contribute to the tradition of romantic fabulation which began with the Gothic novel &mdash; a tradition in which darkness is privileged, in which a paranoid distrust is evident, in which can be read the evergreen message that the deprived may turn out to be depraved, and in which there can be two of someone. 
 Hawksmoor  speaks the words of romantic duality, and is in a number of ways a double book. 
 It consists of two alternating narratives, one of which is set in the eighteenth century and the other in the present, with the earlier delivered in the first person. 
 Each of the two principal actors glimpses his double in passing, as a reflection in a glass, and each stands to the other in the same relation &mdash; a relation which presupposes, as in many other Gothic texts, some sort of metempsychosis or rebirth. 
 Both of these men are disturbed or mad. 
 Nicholas Dyer is imagined as the builder of Nicholas Hawksmoor's churches in the East End of London; the enlightened edifices of a rational Christianity are thereby ascribed to a devil-worshipper, while the name &bquo;Hawksmoor&equo; is assigned to the Detective Chief Superintendent who, in the later narrative, frets himself into a delirium over a series of stranglings which takes place in the vicinity of the churches. 
 The later crimes duplicate those committed by Dyer, who has wished to baptise his churches with the blood of young victims. 
 Dyer thinks of himself as &bquo;a stranger to mankind&equo;; his life is led apart, &bquo;in a Corner&equo;. 
 He has grown up as one of &bquo;the orphans of the plague&equo; who roam the streets of the city in the aftermath  of the plague and of the fire that followed it. 
 The romantic equation of orphan and monster makes a Satanist of this forlorn Dyer: &bquo;nor can we but by doing Evil avoid the rage of evil Spirits.&equo; 
 His is a theology in which Adam is unredeemed, and life itself a plague. 
 London is a necropolis, its every corner the site of a murder, its soil a pudding of blood and tears. 
 Out of this soil soar elegant churches, each of which encodes the symbols of an alien religion. 
 The St So-and-So's which Dyer has been commissioned to build are so many secret temples of Moloch. 
 The experiments, proofs and improvements espoused by such scientists as Christopher Wren, Dyer's patron in the building trade, Dyer pisses on. 
 The homicides and postmortems in the book permit the new religion of science to exercise its power: but they also occasion the necrophile broodings which exude from Dyer. 
 Much of this material &mdash; this archaic London, the Hawksmoor churches, their magical meaning, and the tramps who haunt them &mdash; comes from the striking poem Lud Heat  by Iain Sinclair, where the churches are taken to be geometrically interrelated in the form of a pentacle, the sorcerer's five-pointed star. 
 The poem is dark, dense and learned &mdash; Yeatsian, and maybe also Yatesian, in inspiration, amid much else. 
 It is hard to be sure how much of this dark stuff Sinclair believes &mdash; as it is hard to be sure how much Eliot believed of the lore which accompanies the dark stuff of The Waste Land , another London poem. 
 The two poems could be thought to occupy a common ground which goes some way beyond topography, and includes a stretch of the common ground occupied by imitation. 
 Sinclair's, at all events, is the work of a Modernist, and is unlikely to be that of an occultist. 
 This makes it, in a sense, compatible with Hawksmoor . 
 But Hawksmoor  is a different beast. 
 The novel suggests itself as the work of a novelist intent on a gruesome entertainment. 
 Both works, however, may be thought to share a secret, and a set of clues, which bear witness to the recrudescence of a hippy magic. 
 Peter Ackroyd is all of the formidable pasticheur that he is praised for being, and Dyer's tale, which affects to be that of someone who lived in the eighteenth century, and in which the element of imitation, present in writing of every kind, is more obtrusive than it is in the other tale, is the livelier of the two. 
  Pastiche is a dualistic activity, and it is an activity which can lend itself to the expression of paranoid feelings and unacted desires. 
 A writer is copied by &bquo;someone other&equo; than himself, and that &bquo;someone other&equo; can in a manner of speaking become the writer he copies: the biter bit. 
 The expression I am quoting is uttered by Dyer, and it is an expression which Ackroyd is given to using in his books. 
 In pretending here to be someone other than himself who keeps murdering people, he does a tremendous job: this is a more than serviceable argot for the age in question and for the wizard in question. 
 The suffering and self-conscious first-person singular manifested in Dyer could be considered a creation of the Gothic novel that came after him, and Dyer can also bring to mind the magus of a time before. 
 But there is no nagging sense of anachronism. 
 How could there be? the novel seems to be saying. 
 There is no such thing as anachronism. 
 All ages are one. 
 The later stranglings look like a copy of what happened, at the hands of a sorcerer, in the loamy past, and Peter Ackroyd is very interested in copies. 
 As is usual in such cases, the copy is not exact. 
 Dyer's doings are the same as but also different from those investigated by the fretful man he resembles, just as Hawksmoor's investigative Scotland Yard is the same as but also different from the architects' department of that name attended by Dyer. 
 Ackroyd has given some readers the impression that the modern narrative, the paler of the two, is paler on purpose &mdash; in obedience, presumably, to the doctrine of time, of its runnings-down and recurrences, which figures in the novel. 
 The pale Hawksmoor is an inhabitant of the present day who reminds one not only of Dyer but of P. D. James's character Inspector Dalgliesh &mdash; one of her novels, A Taste for Death , published a few months after Hawksmoor , has a church murder in London, draped in the poses of this sensitive, cultivated policeman, and it also has, like Hawksmoor , a suspected tramp. 
 Both inspectors are presented as more interesting than the colleagues and suspects they move among. 
 With the James, we are told who did it; in the Ackroyd, the matted fellow who is the chief suspect is never very securely identified as the author of the crimes &mdash; it is almost as if the inspector could have done it: so that Ackroyd's is an authorially uncertain work in which the authorship of its crimes is uncertain too. 
 Meanwhile the  interesting Hawksmoor is less interesting than Dyer, and may be meant to be. 
 &bquo;Time will tell, sir&equo;, a colleague remarks, and Hawksmoor replies: &bquo;Time will not tell. 
 Time never tells.&equo; 
 Once more he raised his arm involuntarily, as if in greeting.&equo; 
 It is hard to think that the novelist intended  the reader to find this even more gnomic and exasperating than the colleague seems to find it. 
 But there may indeed be some such aim. 
 Can the author be detected in this novel &mdash; come upon in his dark corner? 
 The attitude to time might tell us what he thinks, but it is the most inscrutable aspect of the novel. 
 Hora e sempre  &mdash; this motto is inscribed on the front of Hawksmoor's, the real Hawksmoor's, Classical house at Easton Neston in Northamptonshire: Easton Neston has been reputed or imagined to be the original of Mansfield Park, which may be described as a house imagined by an opponent of the Gothic novel. 
 The motto refers to a dynastic permanence; but it could be stolen for this novel, where a &bquo;now and always&equo; is on show. 
 We may be meant to think that time is simultaneous, in a way that may owe something to the simultaneity propounded, &bquo;perhaps&equo;, in Eliot's Four Quartets , where &bquo;History is now and England&equo;; or that it is cyclical, a turning wheel, with human depravity paling into insignificance as the wheel turns into modern times. 
 Interpretation is allowed to copy what it finds, and to distort it, and it may be that the novel can be interpreted as an entertainment which conveys that doctrines of science and improvement can't encompass what happens in a frightening world, where motive is dark and ill-will ubiquitous. 
 The Gothic novel was shaped to take account of such a world, and to do so, very often, in the guise of entertainment. 
 Since its arrival in the eighteenth century, this is a literary mode which has recurrently been pronounced dead but which has been capable of renewal, and now Ackroyd has given a further turn to the wheel. 
 Once again, a sufferer is seen to be mad, and his fearful sense of what he is up to can be seen to dominate the book in which it is in the end defeated or controverted. 
 Such a book has to be divided &mdash; between hope and fear, improvement and depravity. 
 It will be the work both of one hand and of the other. 
 And one of these hands may wield the instrument of pastiche. 
 Hawksmoor , which came out in 1985, was preceded by the Eliot biography of 1984, which was preceded by The Last Testament   of Oscar Wilde of the year before, and in 1987 these annual events were pressed upon by Chatterton . 
 All four books reveal a steady concern with imitation and interpretation, and to read them together is to be clearer about what it is that the writer intends us to think that he thinks about things. 
 He would appear to believe in an invented truth, an invented reality &mdash; a Rortyan reality, one might be inclined to call it at times. 
 He believes that a writer will often find himself through exposure to some other writer. 
 And it is apparent that Ackroyd has found himself in this manner &mdash; through exposure to Wilde, Eliot, and now Chatterton. 
 This brings with it the corollary that it is not always apparent whether the beliefs he expresses are Ackroyd's or those of the writer to whom he is exposed, or both. 
 Interpreters must therefore beware, a little, in doing what they are generally allowed to do. 
 All four books speak of a &bquo;someone other&equo;. 
 In Hawksmoor  Ned the tramp encounters a &bquo;someone other&equo; in his double, and in Chatterton  Charles Wychwood's double is another &bquo;someone other&equo;. 
 Eliot was able to &bquo;recognise himself through someone other&equo; &mdash; a changeable other, but at one point it was the Frenchman Laforgue. 
 &bquo;The first law of the imagination&equo;, states Ackroyd's Wilde, is that &bquo;in his work the artist is someone other than himself.&equo; 
 Greek love is virtuous, Wilde is also represented as saying, because &bquo;men can live in perfect equality, each finding in the other the image of his own soul&equo;. 
 It is plain that there are many ways of being and of imagining a someone other. 
 Art may imagine one, and Greek love may. 
 Paranoia imagines one, and so does pastiche. 
 And Ackroyd comes to vivid life as a pasticheur. 
 &bquo;The truest Plagiarism is the truest Poetry&equo;, claims Thomas Chatterton, warming to Ackroyd's theme, and perhaps overdoing it, along with Ackroyd's Wilde, who had been able to believe that &bquo;almost all the methods and conventions of art and life found their highest expression in parody&equo;. 
 Still, such claims do seem to have force when fitted to the case of the writer who is making or mediating them. 
 Ackroyd's truest prose occurs when he applies himself to the imitation of ancient and recent writers &mdash; a repertoire of others. 
 This, of course, is what Chatterton, Wordsworth's &bquo;marvellous boy&equo;, did in the plagiaristic eighteenth century. 
 Like Chatterton, Peter Ackroyd is, in the words of his novel  about Chatterton a &bquo;great Parodist&equo;, a &bquo;great Plagiarist&equo;. 
 It is deemed to follow from such claims that human history is &bquo;a succession of interpretations&equo;, a piling-up of imitations, an accumulation of metaphor which will be perceived as reality. 
 And literature will amount to the same thing: all writers are copycats. 
 Those who prefer to believe in an indivisible single self capable of originality will be sceptical of the Ackroyd scepticism. 
 They will make less than he does of that part of Eliot which was a &bquo;good ventriloquist&equo;. 
 And they will undoubtedly object to the more unbridled formulations that enter the three fictions; the biography of Eliot has plenty to say on the subject, too, while maintaining a comparative, and suitable, reserve. 
 They won't accept with Charles Wychwood that &bquo;everything is copied&equo;, and won't accept his opinion of Chatterton: &bquo;Thomas Chatterton believed that he could explain the entire material and spiritual world in terms of imitation and forgery, and so sure was he of his own genius that he allowed it to flourish under other names.&equo; 
 The second half of this can be seen to coincide with the opinion of Chatterton which is expressed by Ackroyd's Wilde: &bquo;a strange, slight boy who was so prodigal of his genius that he attached the names of others to it.&equo; 
 Peter Ackroyd has here performed the not impossible feat of plagiarising himself &mdash; while leaving the reader in doubt as to whether the writer shares this implausible estimate of Chatterton's marvellous buoyancy. 
 As Ackroyd's ventriloquised Wilde makes clear, Wilde was a great exaggerator and, like his friend Whitman, a great contradictor of himself; and he is certainly a great source of dualistic formulations, in all their slippery bliss. 
 He is the artist's friend, and a friend of the mimic and poseur, in a world of masks, multiplicities, contraries and successive interpretations. 
 The Wilde apocrypha contains a joke which says it all &mdash; or a fair part of it. 
 Some good thing had been voiced, and Wilde had remarked that he wished that he  had said it &mdash; and was then told:. 
 &bquo;You will, Oscar, you will.&equo; 
 The Marquis of Queensberry may be judged, in this context, to have made an involuntary and uncharacteristic joke in accusing Wilde of &bquo;posing as a  somdomite &equo;: a phrase that smells of the multiple self, and of the uncertainty of interpretation &mdash; and indeed spelling (Ackroyd, as it happens, interprets him as something other than a sodomite). 
 Ackroyd's  Wilde complains of the &bquo;sordid&equo; interpretations of his conduct which had influenced the outcome of his trial, while himself, on other occasions, interpreting his conduct as sordid. 
 He also confounds his own dualistic zeal by recalling the wise words (as one may truly think them) of the dualistic  mage  Paracelsus: &bquo;Be not another, if thou canst be thyself.&equo; 
 In the literature of duality it is the outcast or victim who has dealings with a double, and in the second of the two novels Charles Wychwood is an outcast whose condition copies that of Thomas Chatterton, who committed suicide in 1770 at the age of 17, having invented a medieval monk, Rowley, and written poems for him. 
 Romantic poets were keen to vindicate Chatterton, and to cherish his untimely death as that of a sacrificial victim: here was a spilling of young blood that might have watered the purlieus of a church. 
 Charles belongs, moreover, to a cast of outcasts, monsters, hustlers and impostors which composes a literary London reminiscent of the early novels of Muriel Spark, and far from brutally inauthentic. 
 The queen of the authors is Harriet Scrope, novelist, plot-stealer, and ferocious egotist, whose war against the world she inhabits extends to her best friend and her cat. 
 As a comic portrait of the artist, Harriet scores high. 
 She is estranged and she is hostile. 
 She is a bit like Dyer. 
 &bquo;Tho&equo; I was young Thomas Chatterton to those I met, I was a very Proteus to those who read my Works': Chatterton's story is mostly told by himself, and with a felicity of cadence and of reference which can be caught in the sentence I have just quoted. 
 His story is interwoven with, and is replicated by, a modern tale, in which Charles Wychwood's comet-like career is featured. 
 He too, dies the early death of romance &mdash; en po&egrave;te , as the poet Burns put it with reference to his own fate &mdash; and his end is enveloped in the consequences of his supposing that he has lit upon some Chatterton manuscripts. 
 Charles is touchingly done &mdash; a frail unpublished poet kept going by his wife and son (the wife is called Vivien, presumably by design, though she is no copy of the first Mrs Eliot), their household a breath of fresh air in the conniving, phrase-making milieu to which Charles clings. 
 Then there is a third story. 
 Chatterton is as much as anything the famous painting of his death in a Holborn attic done in the 1850s by Henry Wallis &mdash; with the poet lying across  the bed in a kind of frozen entrechat . 
 It looks like an enlargement of the postcard which, in an age of mechanical reproduction, it was to become, commemorating the tourist attraction which it was also to become. 
 The third narrative tells how George Meredith modelled for the corpse in the painting and how his wife then ran away with the painter (see also the sonnets in Meredith's Modern Love ). 
 The three tales are deftly assembled and get on very well together. 
 Chatterton is represented in the novel as an accidental suicide &mdash; slain by a cocktail of arsenic and laudanum swallowed for a venereal infection. 
 Poor Charles brings him to life again, however, for some further plagiarisms: a nest of antique-dealers, of antic disposition, in Chatterton's native Bristol, have passed to Charles a cache of papers which, together with the discovery of what seems to be the portrait of an adult Chatterton, persuades him that the poet lived on. 
 The portraits of Chatterton have something of the importance to the novel that the living and ageing likeness has in The Picture of Dorian Gray . 
 Like Hawksmoor  and The Last Testament of Oscar Wilde , this novel is a tour de force . 
 And it could be said that not only is it about imitation &mdash; it is also, as are other tours de force , itself an imitation of something. 
 Like other tours de force , it is done in a spirit of play and of emulation. 
 It is a contender: a colleague of Ackroyd's on The Times  announced that it was a &bquo;sure contender&equo; for the Booker Prize of 1987 (which it didn't receive). 
 It observes one of Wilde's principles of literature in responding to the importance of not being &bquo;serious&equo;. 
 It shows what the writer can do rather than what he thinks. 
 In order to find out more of what this writer thinks about imitation, we are in a position to consult a work by him where a treatise on the subject is developed at intervals and where he writes in propria persona . 
 In Ackroyd's life of Eliot we read about a major poet who was a good ventriloquist; a man of multiple personality who swore by a principle of impersonality in art which he was later to unswear by locating The Waste Land  in the stresses of a domestic life, and whose art bears the indelible signature of that distinctive protean character of his; a man who was often miserable and tormented. 
 The book says that Eliot's truest poetry was a form of plagiarism, in the benign sense that &bquo;it was only in response to other poetry that Eliot  could express his own deepest feelings&equo;. 
 A little earlier, a view of Eliot's has been paraphrased: that &bquo;there is no &bquo;truth&equo; to be found&equo; in the world, &bquo;only a number of styles and interpretations &mdash; one laid upon the other in an endless and apparently meaningless process&equo;. 
 Ackroyd notices that the Eliot who had once called poetry a &bquo;mug's game&equo; was eventually, in his play The Elder Statesman , to use the same expression for forgery. 
 Ackroyd warns us not to jump to a conflation here, but he is intrigued by the coincidence, and it might almost serve as an emblem of his concern throughout the biography with the connection between poetry and feigning, and with the potency of parody. 
 The biography suggests that Eliot was never to lose the divided sense of his youth that human life is futile and meaningless &mdash; that man is &bquo;a finite piece of reasonable misery&equo;, in the words of William Drummond of Hawthornden, a good poet who was also a great plagiarist, and a great seeker of shelter in books &mdash; but that an eternal order might be felt for, or invented. 
 That order was eventually discovered in the teachings of Christianity. 
 When he turned to God it was to someone other: he was surrendering to &bquo;something outside oneself&equo;. 
 The book depicts Eliot as a parodist, a plagiarist, a responder to other people's poems, and as a seeker of shelter. 
 And yet in its closing passages we learn that as a poet he had &bquo;no real predecessors&equo;. 
 He was his own man, after all. 
 The book is cursory in its treatment of Eliot's literary background: there is no mention, for instance, of Wallace Stevens, Ivy Compton-Burnett, of Empson or Leavis, and no adequate picture of what Eliot meant to later generations of intellectuals in Britain. 
 In other respects, however, this is a cogent and sensible account (which was constrained by a barbarous embargo on quotation). 
 I don't think that its readers can have had much trouble in finding in the life and work the responsiveness Ackroyd finds in them. 
 But perhaps it is the paradox conveyed by that closing glimpse of a parodic but unprecedented Eliot which carries the sharpest conviction of any feature of the book. 
 Eliot comes across as the sad man who sees double, as a living embodiment of the proposition that the double has to do with pain and with relief from pain, with the search, in such circumstances, for someone other. 
 From the ordeal of his first  marriage to the late happiness of the second, the book locks, at one level, into a recital of misfortunes and a medical record. 
 Influenza after influenza. 
 Constant debilitating &bquo;work&equo;, in publishing and public life, and a constant invocation of the claims of such work. 
 Lecture after lecture, accompanied by complaints about the futility of lectures and his reluctance to give them. 
 The book makes one conscious of Eliot in the sarcophagus of his upper-class eminence; of a sad face of clerical cut &mdash; once the face of a delightful shy child &mdash; bleakly sprouting from a sartorial apparatus that resembles the mourning clothes of a cabinet minister; of a masterly poseur, an honoured invalid and recluse, of someone snobbish and sometimes selfish and inhumane, who sought relief in literature and in imitation, and who also embodied the opposite of these qualities. 
 It is almost as if we are confronted here by a replication of the poor Tom described in Ackroyd's novel by another poor Tom of later times. 
 And perhaps we might imagine that they are the same but different. 
 Eliot was to tell the poet F. T. Prince: &bquo;Not everything you write is very interesting .&equo; 
 This could be said with some emphasis of Chatterton, but not of Eliot himself, who moreover survived, who grew to be famous, who did not kill himself, though he was to wonder how one might set about dying. 
 Chatterton died the romantic and traditional early death of the divided, the invaded man, while Eliot did not. 
 It isn't that Ackroyd asks us to compare these two poor Toms, in pursuit of a theory alleging the importance of imitation. 
 But they are brought together, in successive books, by the force of this preoccupation, and the reader has to make what he can of the resemblance between two figures quite remote from one another in any coarser understanding of the matter, to do this while adjusting his sight to a vista of copycats, impostors and successive interpretations &mdash; a vista which is far from unfamiliar now and can be caught, for instance, in the productions and reproductions of contemporary literary theory. 
 Imposture is shown in Ackroyd's novel, in this burlesque of the literary life, to be an interesting business, but it is unlikely to cause Chatterton's reputation to inch back towards what it was in the retrospects of the Romantic period. 
 He was worshipped then for his talent and untimely death &mdash; perhaps a little as Eliot was to be worshipped, in the 1940s and '50s, for his  saintly abstention from the world. 
 Keats placed him among the stars, where Keats himself, for similar reasons, was to be placed by Shelley. 
 Chatterton became a topos, and the numbers lisped: &bquo;O Chatterton, how very sad thy fate&equo;, &bquo;Flow gently, sweet Chatterton&equo;, &bquo;Good for you, Chatterton&equo;. 
 Readers can be expected to spot which of these quotations are forgeries, and they must also have doubted in their time whether this writer was as good as the early tributes made out. 
 It seems clear, however, that Chatterton needn't have had prodigious talent for the talent expended in the novel to take effect. 
 It is a novel which communicates the notion that talented and untalented meet in that country of the mind where everyone copies and steals from everyone else, where everything is reproductive or reminiscent of everything else, where one thing leads to another and this person passes into that. 
 It plays with such ideas, to a Shavian pitch of exaggeration: but it is not a novel of ideas, any more than it is a heartless game. 
 It has people in it, with lives to live. 
 It has Charles in it, whose plight is more touching than anything in the nineteenth-century retrospects of Chatterton. 
 It has its predecessors in the romantic tradition &mdash; a tradition which includes the self-important single self nevertheless prone to dispersal and division, invasion and impersonation, which includes the victim and his alter ego. 
 At the same time, both here and in Hawksmoor , Ackroyd, too, is his own man. 
 For all his standard procedures, I don't think he is actually imitating anybody.  
 Ariel goes to the police 
 REVOLUTION, literature and love, and the roads and side-roads which join them together, are concerns which join together the Czech writers Milan Kundera and Ivan Klima, whose name is used by Kundera for the uxorious philanderer of his novel The Farewell Party . 
 They are writers who have parted company, but who are in some ways at one. 
 There is a sense in which the hero of Kundera's novel Life is elsewhere , published in Britain in 1986, is also the hero of Klima's collection of stories My First Loves , published here in the same month of the same year. 
 These are portraits of the artist who grows up in an age of revolutionary socialism and who has to make what he can of it. 
 Revolution, and its betrayal by a regime which both prescribes and proscribes literature, are described in both works. 
 Both men are interested in the subject of remembering and forgetting. 
 In the books they write, music is heard in country places &mdash; trumpets, fiddles, the cimbalom &mdash; and love shows its face in country hotels, pleasant places, set down beside a stretch of water. 
 Klima may perhaps be a common name in Czechoslovakia, and Kundera has become a common name in the conversation of Western readers, who are drawn to these reciprocal concerns of his. 
 In the days before glasnost  &mdash; which his fictions may be thought to have rehearsed and predicted, but which could well mean that his fictions will no longer be for the West what they have been so far, when the thing that they deplore was still there in its entirety to be deplored &mdash; Kundera was forced into exile in the &bquo;free world&equo; of the time. 
 So far, the free world has liked him both for having been, and for having ceased to be, a communist of a sort, for the freedoms he seeks in matters of literary form, for the modern inventiveness and manipulation of the literary games he plays, games that none the less commemorate, as he acknowledges, Cervantes, Sterne and Diderot, and for the sexual games which he plays in an age when, as he once put it, sexuality has ceased to be taboo. 
 We have liked him for being into free speech and free love, and for what he  has to say about convergences of the two, and about the curbs which revolution and its regimes has placed on them. 
 The West has been grateful to Kundera, extravagantly so at times, and has shown an impulse to beat itself with his playful fictions. 
 Heads have been turned, and have begun to swim, amid the flow of invention, delivered in works which have been Englished in rapid succession and which are not always easy to tell apart. 
 Which is the one that has litost  &mdash; a form of self-pity &mdash; and what does he mean by &bquo;unbearable lightness of being&equo;? 
 Which of these two conceptions, for that matter, we may even sometimes wonder, is which? 
 But it seems safe to say that there are circumstances in which litost  and glasnost  can be recognised as enemies, and that this enmity can be recognised in the novel Life is elsewhere . 
 His fertility, narrative gift, gift for experiments and impromptus, are such as to bewilder the attempt to form a judgement of any particular work. 
 Not that he can mind that. 
 What he does seem to mind &mdash; and what even the most arbitrary-seeming, the most ludic, of his ironic and erotic diversions and excursions show that he minds &mdash; is the regime that came to power in his native country after the revolution of 1948. 
 Many of his most memorable literary effects attest to this. 
 In The Unbearable Lightness of Being , the Czech exile Sabina disturbs her French friends by being unable to last out a parade held to protest against the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968: &bquo;She would have liked to tell them that behind Communism, Fascism, behind all occupations and invasions lurks a more basic, pervasive evil and that the image of that evil was a parade of people marching by with raised fists and shouting identical syllables in unison.&equo; 
 The British reader, who is likely to have been spared certain of the varieties of suffering which are spoken of in the writings of Kundera and Klima, where a joke, or no joke, or nothing whatever, can sequester you for years from the people you grew up with, is in a position, for all that, to know what Sabina means here. 
 The British reader has only to listen to the sounds that protest makes in his own streets, to the cruel, brutal voices that bellow over loudhailers about injustice and the disadvantaged. 
 In thinking about what Stalinism brought to his country, Kundera thinks of the support this despotism has received from the writers of his country, and of other countries. 
 Literature,  with its store of memories, is suspected by the state: and yet the state is served by certain writers. 
 In books and interviews he has reminded the world that the French Surrealist poet Aragon, having praised Kundera's excellent novel The Joke  in 1968, and having fulminated against the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia &mdash; his legs would &bquo;refuse&equo; to take him to Russia any more &mdash; made it to Moscow four years later; and that another French poet, Eluard, abandoned his Prague friend, the Surrealist Kalandra, to the executioner. 
 Nowadays, people all over the world unequivocally reject the idea of gulags, yet they are still willing to let themselves be hypnotised by totalitarian poesy and to march to new gulags to the tune of the same lyrical song piped by Eluard when he soared over Prague like the great archangel of the lyre, while the smoke of Kalandra's body rose to the sky from the crematory chimney. 
 Tyranny is a force which locks writers up and which self-serving lyrical writers may assist. 
 Eluard's soaring &bquo;lyricism&equo; helped to perpetuate a tyranny, and is the kind of thing which led Kundera to employ the title The Lyric Age  for the work which first came to him in the mid-Fifties, and which his publishers prevailed on him to retitle Life  is elsewhere when it was completed in 1969. 
 It was published in America in 1974, translated by Peter Kussi, who has revised his translation for the new edition of 1986 which I am discussing here. 
 The provisional title referred to the life-span of Jaromil, who dies young, as lyric poets will, but also to the enforced, mass-produced, writer-proclaimed revolutionary ardours which ensued in 1948. 
 At the outset, Jaromil's lyricism is a Modern affair in which biological compulsion and biographical reference &mdash; peeps at the maid Magda in her bath, for instance &mdash; are enveloped and disguised in a poetry which his doting and self-pitying mother finds inscrutable. 
 His first loves &mdash; to make use of Klima's title &mdash; prove to be his last, but prove as engrossing to him as the lyrics in which his emotional development is encoded. 
 Jaromil is not so much a character as a type, and is not unlike the Shelleyan poet in Shaw's Candida , Eugene Marchbanks. 
 Aerial creatures, these, ineffectual angels. 
 Eugene, &bquo;so uncommon as to be almost unearthly&equo;, wants to go &bquo;up into the  sky&equo;. 
 His brow is &bquo;lined with pity&equo;. 
 He speaks with &bquo;lyric rapture&equo;. 
 But he is all right when you get to know him. 
 &bquo;Don't say that Jaromil is a bad poet!&equo; 
 Kundera's 1986 Postscript implores. 
 He is a &bquo;sensitive young man&equo; &mdash; a monster too, but the same monster is in you and me. 
 And the same monster was in Shelley, and Rimbaud, and Victor Hugo. 
 Jaromil and his mother are portrayed, we learn from the Postscript, quite without any satirical intention. 
 In that respect, Kundera could have fooled at least one of his readers; but I do see that it belongs to the point of it all that the uncommon Jaromil should be thought humanly representative. 
 By a painter who befriends him, and who sleeps for a while with his mother, Jaromil, already self-perceived as exceptional, original, is introduced to modern art, which &bquo;had not yet become the shopworn property of the bourgeois masses and retained the fascinating aura of a sect, a magical exclusivity fascinating to childhood &mdash; an age always daydreaming about the romanticism of secret societies, fraternities and tribes&equo;. 
 Soon he is writing modern poems. 
 &bquo;This verse described a boy who had been trembling in front of the bathroom door, but at the same time this boy was swallowed up by the verse; it surmounted and survived him. 
 Alas, my aquatic love , said another line, and Jaromil knew that the aquatic love was Magda; but he also knew that nobody else could find her in that line&hellip;&equo;. 
 These lines are short and do not rhyme. 
 They are free. 
 Magda was lost in a poem which was &bquo;as independent and unintelligible as reality itself. 
 Reality does not discuss, it simply is. 
 The independence of the poem provided Jaromil with a marvellous world of concealment, the possibility of a second  existence.&equo; 
 Jaromil has discovered that writing can be what reading has familiarly been for the ordinary person: an escape, a shelter, a door to the alternative self. 
 Much later we read: 
 Everything seemed to indicate that Jaromil's enormous yearning for newness (the religion of the New) was only the disguised longing of a virginal youth for the unimaginable experience of the sex act. 
 When he first reached the blissful shore of the redhead's body, a peculiar idea occurred to him: he now knew at last what it meant to be absolutely modern; it meant to lie on the shore of the redhead's body. 
 By now he has also reached &bquo;the realm of real life&equo; &mdash; by which he &bquo;understood a whirling world of parading throngs, physical love and revolutionary slogans&equo;. 
 It turns out that real life rhymes, that the revolution wishes its poetry to do so. 
 There is a magical power in rhyme and rhythm. 
 &bquo;Can a revolution dispense with repeated affirmation of the new order? 
 Can a revolution dispense with rhyme?&equo; 
 By now free verse has been exposed as decadent, and modern art as the shopworn property of the bourgeois masses. 
 Lyricism, then, is the poetry which sings along with the triumph of the proletariat, and with the repressions which accompany its triumph. 
 What is required is a poetry which does not analyse or criticise, and is suitable for throngs and parades: we are in a situation where the self-portraits of the lyric author can be displayed like placards. 
 Lyricism is inexperience, and it is the desire for glory. 
 Such poems &bquo;need not be stimulated by real-life events&equo; such as the plight of the Marseilles dock-workers, which has effaced the sight &mdash; darkly limned in Jaromil's juvenilia &mdash; of Magda in her bath; and if the poet who displays his ignorant, indifferent self-portrait is hoping for applause, there is a chance for him to do well in the new world of revolution, which rings with applause, and with blame. 
 By the end of the novel Jaromil has forsworn his artist friend, who is under the ban of the regime and compelled to paint by candlelight: &bquo;The whole world of his pictures has been dead for years. 
 Real life is elsewhere!&equo; 
 We are told that these last four words are Rimbaud's and the Surrealist Andr&eacute; Breton's, and that in 1968 they were a slogan of the protesting Sorbonne students. 
 They are words that can be made to mean different things, and are applicable as such to the story of Jaromil's poetic progress from private to public, which can also be recognised as a simultaneity of the two, based on an enduring self-engrossment. 
 Kundera asks us to join together two things that are often kept apart: lyrical effusions and public poetry. 
 The quoted words point back to the privileged second existence which poetry had once promised Jaromil, and they point ahead: the old meaning has been reversed, with the claim that real life resides in a revolutionary solidarity. 
 Just before this snarl about real life, he has betrayed his redhead to the police, by swallowing a lying excuse of hers concerning a subversive brother.  
 The poets Czeslaw Milosz and Donald Davie have been bothered by the insufficiency and irresponsibility of the lyric genre, and it could be felt that Kundera goes further than they do in denouncing the lyric, and fares worse. 
 The lyricism that sells out to a state-ordained reality and solidarity is not the only lyricism we know, and it is the opposite of much of what we know by that name. 
 Youthful as some of them are, the lyrics of Heaney do not embody the genius of inexperience, whatever some of Shelley's may do. 
 In other words, Kundera's novel isolates certain tendencies in the behaviour of poets (and others) in order to prosecute an attack on Stalinist Czechoslovakia. 
 It will be clear to most people here that the attack is deserved, and that writers sold out. 
 Jaromil's adventures, moreover, are shrewdly observed. 
 Lyricism can indeed be very like this description of it. 
 Poetry has often been a form of self-pity and a means of self-advancement, and it has often pretended otherwise: Kundera's book rumbles such pretence, as in the comedy he stages of an embassy of poets to a college of policemen and a debate there about the aesthetic of the socialist love-poem. 
 But he does all this at the cost of suspending a due sense of the tendency there has also been for poets to see further than their noses, and to speak out, and to go to the wall for it. 
 His Postscript evokes the aim of a white-coated Doctor Kundera &bquo;to solve an aesthetic problem: how to write a novel which would be a &bquo;critique of poetry&equo; and yet at the same time would itself be poetry&equo;. 
 This aim has a sweepingness and a suspendingness which are apparent, too, in the novel to which it relates. 
 Many poems contain a critique of poetry, just as many contain a critique of the self-portrayed poet, and of his intention to serve a social or doctrinal system, or of his claim to be a special case. 
 The lyric is not generically debarred from standing out against the state, or from taking a generous interest in what goes on in the world. 
 Mandelstam's lyric about the &bquo;Kremlin mountaineer&equo; &mdash; Klima's &bquo;great Generalissimo&equo;, Stalin &mdash; sent him to the camps. 
 Ivan Klima could be called a lyric author, and the notion of what it is to be such an author is examined in My First Loves , whose gentle and deliberate stories read as if they have been grown and stored before being made public. 
 The boy poet  Klima loves literature, and pities himself, in a work which pities those around him. 
 There is a lot to pity them for &mdash; the stories touch on ghetto hardships, on murders and deportations. 
 His father, devoutly socialist, is jailed by the socialist regime whose discipline replaces that of the SS. 
 Klima's first loves have a way of not working out; and what may have been his longest affair is the one about which least is said. 
 In the opening story Miriam distributes milk to the tenement building and favours the boy with an extra helping: but he never gets to tell her that he is the lyric author of poems &bquo;about love. 
 About suicide.&equo; 
 The second story is set in and around a country hotel, where the wife of a coarse doctor takes a more than kindly interest in a Klima wide-awake to the sights and sounds of this paradise. 
 The story ends at a funeral, hovered over by a surreal balloon, from which hangs a fancied female acrobat. 
 The boy's hand is squeezed by the weeping wife. 
 He is in two minds. 
 &bquo;I was able to soar up, to fly, I could rock in the air like that balloon, I could fly away with it, choose any of the four points of the compass, but I remained where I was, I stopped above this small, painful, blessed piece of earth.&equo; 
 Then there is the tale of a lying girl, as she may be, with whom he makes love, and who alarms him with word of a threatening German &mdash; a former SS man, perhaps. 
 He has her report the matter to the police. 
 This is a lapse on his part, but is hardly comparable with Jaromil's treatment of his mendacious redhead. 
 Klima's girl disappears into the Prague bars, leaving him with an imaginary address. 
 She is rather like a lyric author herself, a bit of a lyre. 
 The last story has to do with the girlfriend of a friend. 
 Literary, second-sighted, sick, she holds out a hand to him: he clasps it, but then decides he can't go on. 
 Is Klima, as the angry friend alleges on this occasion, a flirt, who goes from girl to girl? 
 The stories do well to return an uncertain answer. 
 Through them, somewhat in the spirit of Chagall, runs the aerial preoccupation of romantic escapism. 
 Balloons float, a high-wire circus act teeters. 
 In the last story Klima comes to see &bquo;the connection between heights and vertigo, ecstasy and ruin, soaring and falling&equo;. 
 The literary girl waxes lyrical. 
 A person who accepted love was like a passenger. 
 Maybe on a boat, at  night, on some vast lake. 
 Whichever way you looked there was nothing but calm black water. 
 It was true that the water might rise and swamp you. 
 But to love someone meant to fly, to rise above the earth yourself. 
 So high that you could see everything. 
 Even if the world looked different from that height, even if it looked changed, even if what on the ground seemed important was transformed into insignificance. 
 She'd say, moreover, that you could always get out of a boat and go ashore, but from that height you could only crash. 
 The blessed piece of earth over which float these balloons, over which are poised these acrobats, is a corner of painful Czechoslovakia. 
 Klima's stories breathe a delicate patriotism &mdash; which is not absent, either, from Kundera's accounts of a country which is harder to inhabit, or remain in, or return to. 
 For both men, Czechoslovakia is both painful and blissful. 
 It is not surprising that the Czech novelist Josef Skvorecky should be keen on My First Loves . 
 Skvorecky left his country to teach in North America &mdash; as did the Dubcekite Klima &mdash; and has improved the shining hours of a Canadian exile. 
 But Klima has gone back. 
 It has been said of him that he would rather live in his native country, and not be allowed to publish, than go elsewhere and be free to do so. 
 Reality is in Czechoslovakia? 
 A challenging attitude on his part, if the story in question is correct. 
 It should not persuade us that this writer has yielded or sold out, any more than it should persuade us that the boy poet Klima is in every sense the boy poet Jaromil. 
 It is possible to suggest that the two poets resemble one another. 
 Each is inexperienced, youthful. 
 Each fancies a second existence, wants to float free. 
 Each feels sorry for himself. 
 Each is lyrical. 
 But the lyricism of the character &bquo;Klima&equo; can be considered an element in the lyricism of Ivan Klima, and be thought to encounter there its own critique. 
 As for that business of going to the police, I am sorry I mentioned it. 
 There is nothing in the stories to suggest that either of these lyrical Klimas has the makings of the hero of the state imagined by Kundera.  
 Kapuschinski 
 WE live at a time when reporters go to foreign countries where there is trouble and come back to write books in which they say that it was hard to make out what was going on. 
 When they say this, they are apt to be called writers. 
 Writers don't know what is going on. 
 But they can be good at conveying what it was like for them to be there, and to be writing it down. 
 The journalists to whom I am referring can more solemnly be said to be practising a modern art of indirection, of the unintelligible and the interminable. 
 It is as if the war, crisis, living hell or chaotic backwater can never be known and will never end. 
 After a while you fly out. 
 A leading exponent of these mysteries is the novelist and journalist V. S. Naipaul, whose foreign countries are, as we have already seen, areas of darkness, where coups and crises are glimpsed but may remain enigmatic. 
 Another is Ryszard Kapuscinski, an expert in what he calls &bquo;confusion&equo;, who has attended twenty-seven revolutions in the Third World. 
 These revolutions, he believably reports, have been confusions. 
 There he sat in his writer's hotel room, venturing out into a series of tight corners, filing his copy, then leaving for Warsaw to compose his short books &mdash; objects physically slight but charged with these confusions. 
 They are marvellously done, and they have caused a stir of approval in this country, while also raising doubts. 
 In the New Left Review , Benedict Anderson has made sharp criticisms of the work of the journalist and poet James Fenton which compare it with that of Kapuscinski and Naipaul. 
 These three writers are tagged as representatives of two hardly very different types or crisis-fancying, Third Worldly literary tourist. 
 Kapuscinski exercises a personal charm which must have helped him to establish friendly relations with the people he met, and to gather material, and which can seem to befriend the Western reader. 
 Born in 1932, he retired as a foreign correspondent for the Polish Press Agency in 1981, by which time his three books had started to come out. 
 They describe  three falls: that of the Emperor Haile Selassie, that of the Shah and that of the colonial masters of Angola. 
 No fall from power within the Eastern bloc of nations is mentioned in any of the books. 
 The Ethiopian book, published in Britain in 1983, showed him to be a writer interested in &bquo;autocrats&equo; &mdash; in absolute power and in the transformation of that power into its indistinguishable opposite. 
 He says that it is &bquo;difficult to say when omnipotence becomes powerlessness&equo;. 
 Not that the stories of Haile Selassie and the Shah are any great advertisement for the omnipotence of omnipotence. 
 Both rulers had reason to fear. 
 Both of them, though, were rulers whom Western journalists used to admire: they were jewels in the crown of freedom, and yet endearingly autocratic. 
 Kapuscinski's first two books will serve to deter any cult of the dear dead kings in question. 
 In The Emperor  he writes: 
 For the starvelings it had to suffice that His Munificent Highness personally attached the greatest importance to their fate, which was a very special kind of attachment, of an order higher than the highest. 
 It provided the subjects with a soothing and uplifting hope that whenever there appeared in their lives an oppressive mischance, some tormenting difficulty, His Most Unrivalled Highness would hearten them &mdash; by attaching the greatest importance to that mischance or difficulty. 
 The Emperor  has something of the technique of comic and fantastic exaggeration that we associate with Dickens, and something of the manner, too, of Dickens's reader, Kafka: 
 In the courtyard where the Emperor s retinue awaited him, there were tens, no, I say it without exaggeration, hundreds eager to push their faces forward. 
 Face rubbed against face, the taller ones squelching down the shorter ones, the darker ones overshadowing the lighter ones. 
 Face despised face, the older ones moving in front of the younger ones, the weaker ones giving way to the stronger ones. 
 Face hated face, the common ones clashing with the noble ones, the grasping ones against the weaklings. 
 Face crushed face, but even the humiliated ones, the ones pushed away, the third-raters and the defeated ones, even those &mdash; from a certain distance imposed by the law of hierarchy, it's true &mdash; still moved toward the front, showing here and there from behind the first-rate, titled ones, if only as  fragments: an ear, a piece of temple, a cheek or a jaw&hellip; just to be closer to the Emperor's eye! 
 It is not easy to know how far Kafka's fictions can be thought to answer descriptively to the historical realities of his time, let alone to those which his fictions are often thought to have predicted. 
 And it is not easy to know how far Kapuscinski's book is a book about a bygone Ethiopia. 
 Is it a book about Poland? 
 It purports to be based on the recollections of courtiers and retainers hunted up after the fall: but I have heard it suggested that the author did not take to the Picador edition's cover display of a picture of Haile Selassie, perhaps on the grounds of a misleading particularity. 
 The reader who believes he is learning things about Imperial Ethiopia may be equally inclined to tell himself that this is a country of the mind, constructed on principles not very different from those of the Samuel Johnson who devised, for the Abyssinia of Rasselas , just representations of general truths and of a common humanity. 
 From Abyssinia Kapuscinski passed to Persia. 
 From Rasselas, as it were, to Ozymandias. 
 Present in the second book as the occupant of an Iranian hotel room sifting through his papers, photographs and cassettes, Kapuscinski recites the history of the region, which has thrust the Shah of Shahs into the sand in the posture of the statue of the &bquo;King of Kings&equo; in Shelley's tyrannophobe poem. 
 The Shah had made a showplace of his country with his colossal purchasing of weapons, and look what it had all come to: &bquo;If you drive from Shiraz to Isfahan even today you'll see hundreds of helicopters parked off to the right of the highway. 
 Sand is gradually covering the inert machines.&equo; 
 Shortly after the point at which the recital ends, sand was to cover some more helicopters &mdash; those sent by President Carter to liberate the American hostages seized in Teheran, where Kapuscinski catches a glimpse not of them but of their place of confinement. 
 At this palace, as at the other, servility shows its face and performs its tricks. 
 Foreign statesmen revere an oil-rich omnipotence: &bquo;Now the whole world was at his feet. 
 Before him were bowed heads, inclined necks and outstretched hands.&equo; 
 Kapuscinski speaks of the liberals who lost out when the Shah was expelled, but Bakhtiar is not particularised. 
 Bani Sadr he  does mention, with sympathy. 
 He says of the liberals that they were placed in a predicament by the fall: &bquo;A democracy cannot be imposed by force, the majority must favour it, yet the majority wanted what Khomeini wanted &mdash; an Islamic republic.&equo; 
 The suggestion that democracy cannot be imposed by force has the force of a generalisation. 
 Kapuscinski is a seeker of general truths who is sparing with his generalisations, and who likes certain kinds of particularity but not others. 
 The kind he likes he calls &bquo;detail&equo;, as opposed to &bquo;long shots&equo; &mdash; the equivalent, that is, of the long shots over-used by cameramen of the Iranian Revolution: &bquo;it is through details that everything can be shown&equo; &mdash; that truth can be shown. 
 But in The Emperor  no detail is adduced that might bring out what differences there could have been between the courtiers and petitioners of Ethiopia and their counterparts elsewhere in the world. 
 Kapuscinski's courtiers and petitioners are about as black as Johnson's Prince Rasselas, who is about as black as he is white. 
 In the second book, a photograph is spoken of which &bquo;shows the pulling down of a monument to one of the Shahs (father or son) in Teheran or some other Iranian city. 
 It is hard to be sure about the year the photograph was taken, since the monuments of both Pahlavis were pulled down several times, whenever the occasion presented itself to the people.&equo; 
 Here the confusions or uncertainties are the point of the passage: it doesn't matter that the particulars of the caption are missing since this sort of thing was always happening. 
 It matters less and less as we move into an enjoyable account derived from a vocational puller-down of statues of the Shah and his father. 
 The Shah was equal to these demolitions: &bquo;If we pulled one down, he set up three.&equo; 
 The wrecker explains that, one way or another, &bquo;it's not easy to pull down monuments&equo;. 
 Kapuscinski then generalises. 
 The Shah's regime was a transplant that the system had rejected: &bquo;The rejection of a transplant &mdash; once it begins, the process is irreversible. 
 All it takes is for society to accept the conviction that the imposed form of existence does more harm than good.&equo; 
 I am not sure how much work these last words are doing, and if there is tautology here, it is compounded by what follows. 
 Rejecting the Shah was 
 A great experience, an adventure of the heart. 
 Look at the people who  are taking part in a revolt. 
 They are stimulated, excited, ready to make sacrifices. 
 At that moment they are living in a monothematic world limited to one thought: to attain the goal they are fighting for. 
 Everything will be subjugated to that goal&hellip; 
 Kapuscinski's way with words entails adding, repeating piling up, for the space of a slim volume. 
 But the &bquo;and's&equo; and &bquo;or's&equo; and the more and more rarely irritate, and are triumphant in the great set-pieces which mean so much to all three books &mdash; like that palimpsest of faces in Addis Ababa. 
 In 1975, the year after the fall of Haile Selassie, and four years before the fall of the Shah, the witness of revolutions turned up in Angola for the abandonment of their colony by the Portuguese: the subject of the third of these books of his. 
 Agostinho Neto, politician and poet, the leader of the MPLA, is about to preside over the new state, but two enemy armies are converging on the capital, Luanda: the FNLA under Holden Roberto and Unita under Jonas Savimbi. 
 All three have international sponsors, and Kapuscinski is to find out that the South Africans have invaded in the south of the country, having fallen in love with Savimbi. 
 As in the earlier books, the bravura set-piece dominates, and the most memorable concerns the crates in which the Portuguese have packed up their belongings, and which were eventually shipped out of Africa &mdash; Kapuscinski was to stumble on a few of them in Portugal, sunk, as it were, in the sand. 
 He writes of them as they stay for waftage: 
 Some crates were as big as vacation cottages, because a hierarchy of crate status had suddenly come into being. 
 The richer the people, the bigger the crates they erected. 
 Crates belonging to millionaires were impressive: beamed and lined with sailcloth, they had solid, elegant walls made of the most expensive grades of tropical wood, with the rings and knots cut and polished like antiques. 
 The passage takes off thereafter in ecstatic inventory. 
 At the start of the book there are false notes, those of a Hemingway war correspondent: &bquo;Every knock at the door could mean the end for me. 
 I tried not to think about it, which is the only thing to do in such a situation.&equo; 
 But matters are mended with the arrival of the crates &mdash; antiques that epitomised an antique land, brief monuments to the old Angola.  
 Benguela, in the south, is one of Kapuscinski's ghost towns. 
 A deserted European quarter is twinned with an African settlement out in a desert &bquo;white and glimmering like a salt spill, without a blade of grass&equo;. 
 These Africans have not moved into the houses of the Portuguese. 
 They are passive, we are told; moral scruples don't come into it. 
 Kapuscinski generalises: &bquo;the degree of consciousness that drives one to demand justice or do something about obtaining it hasn't yet been reached.&equo; 
 From Benguela, Kapuscinski and a film crew travel to a scene of carnage, guided by Carlotta, a heroine of the MPLA. 
 When the Europeans decide to return, their guide decides to stay, and is immediately killed. 
 &bquo;We are all culpable in Carlotta's death, since we agreed to let her stay behind; we could have ordered her to return.&equo; 
 A colonial &bquo;could&equo;. 
 Kapuscinski is soon in a still hairier place, further south, where he is told of the South African intervention. 
 This is a scoop, and he fights his way back through wildernesses, road-blocks, threats of ambush, to inform Warsaw. 
 The last Portuguese leave Luanda. 
 Independence is declared, and Neto's position as head of the hard-pressed MPLA improves. 
 By now Kapuscinski is on his &bquo;last legs&equo;, and he telexes Warsaw to say that he wants to leave and that it is &bquo;more or less clear&equo; that &bquo;the Angolans will win&equo;. 
 Neto's, and Castro's, Angolans, presumably. 
 On the following page we read that &bquo;things were going badly&equo; for Neto. 
 Since then, for the thirteen years since Kapuscinski's departure, things have gone badly for the Angolans, and they are still suffering terribly. 
 But at last, in the summer of 1988, negotiations are in hand which may end the war. 
 It is a war which has begun to embarrass the interveners. 
 According to the Guardian , the New Year's Honours list of 1988 in Britain contained a knighthood for &bquo;Professor Albert Maillard, the Oxford historian&equo;. 
 Two of the several names owned by another recipient had strayed into someone's word-processor to create a further deserving don, the knowing reference to whom must have ruined the new year for more than one senior scholar. 
 I feel that Albert Maillard, if he existed, would have no time for Kapuscinski's impressionism, for his absence of dates, figures and state papers, and that Albert Maillard would be wrong. 
 There is history in the  accounts Kapuscinski gives of the confusions and uncertainties which he has experienced and which he has tried to interpret. 
 All is not dark in these accounts, and indeed they can be said to gleam with a quality of reflected light. 
 I think of him as an artist who writes history, and I take it that the history he writes includes the history he has principally suffered &mdash; that of Poland. 
 An autocrat falls in the first two books; but the only one in the third is the author-autocrat of the hotel room who sallies into the bush, as if on impulse, to visit the mysterious, moveable &bquo;front&equo;. 
 At the same time, he is a shrewd observer who writes compellingly about the people and the landscapes he encounters. 
 A benevolent despot. 
 The same description would not, in my view, be grossly inapplicable to the present ruler of Poland &mdash; which has, as it happens, a smaller population than the Ethiopia of chronic famine. 
 General Jaruzelski bears no obvious resemblance to the Third World autocrats discussed in the first two books. 
 But it can scarcely be in doubt that these books have in them home truths, and an ironic obliquity or duplicity, which richly relate to the world of Jaruzelski's predecessors, and indeed to the experience of other countries where literature and opinion have been repressed. 
 Their writing coincided with the rise of Solidarity. 
 They are books which bring together all three of the worlds we inhabit, and they are books which appear to thrive on being seen through &mdash; on the transparency of their suggestion that tyrannies, that sycophancy, conspiracy and repression, courts and courtiers, are all on the royal right, and in the bush, and running into the sand.  
 Heroine of Our Time 
 SUICIDE was thought damnable in the Middle Ages, and I expect there are those who have been brought to feel by a book called The Monument  that the Middle Ages had a point. 
 T. Behrens's book commemorates a young couple who lived together for seventeen years in a solitude &agrave; deux  and who then took their own lives &mdash; incompetently and lingeringly. 
 Representatives of the few people they had come to know in the course of their wanderings round the world were left to clear up. 
 Suicide tends now to command sympathy, even when the reasons for it are hard to understand. 
 Not everyone who reads the book will be able to sympathise with Justin and Ursula, or to believe that they understand them. 
 But there will also be those who will stay with it for its relish of damnation. 
 This is one of the many books which address the snobbery of the English, which flash at their readers the lawns of country houses, the baize of gambling-tables, which tell tales of those virtuosos of ostentation and disregard who have in common a contempt for commonness, for the middle class; and it could be said of such books that their chief resource is the eccentricity which has long amounted to a convention of upper-class life. 
 Literary careers can be founded on the impersonation and adulation of privileged behaviour; but the literary works which have been written and inspired by English snobs and sports are by no means all boastful or complicit. 
 The supreme text of recent years is James Fox's account of Lord Lucan and his set, with their boffes de politesse . 
 Patrician insolence has quite often appeared to express a perception of the activities of the levelling Labour governments which have come and gone since 1945. 
 Behrens's book, however, pays no attention to politics or to public matters. 
 His story begins at a time when, as at other times in this century, the patriciate, and the merely rich, had slipped down into marked collusion with the smart, with upstarts and bohemians. 
 The well-born and the well-off have been apt at such times to turn, for diversion and instruction, to foreigners and to  members of the working class. 
 These strangers have been sexual, artistic. 
 Theirs was the charm of not being bourgeois, and the foreigners among them could be, or could come across as, princes, pretenders to a throne, descendants of a khan. 
 What survived, in the late Fifties, of the Chelsea set welcomed a refugee from Hungary, after the Soviet invasion of that country. 
 This was Ursula of the long blonde hair and double-barrelled baronial-barbaric surname (withheld by Behrens), who had fled what survived of ancestral estates &mdash; on one view of the matter &mdash; and had made her courageous way across Europe, shot at and winged by border guards, to Vienna, and on to London, where she fell among art historians and was counselled by Anthony Blunt. 
 As did the author of the book, who is a painter and who was then at the Slade, she discovered, he tells us, that &bquo;the people with the beautiful faces were also, mysteriously, the ones it was most fun to be with&equo;. 
 The self-proclaimed &bquo;honesty&equo; of the wild, well-born stranger was doubted, but her fascination prevailed. 
 She married an art dealer, Kenelm, understood to be seriously ill, and conducted daring affairs, one of them on the Metro with her friend Monique's friend Gianni: 
 Gianni and Ursula leapt on just as the doors were closing, but Monique, who was now a few yards behind them and whose movements were hampered anyway by her arthritis, was left standing there as the train moved out. 
 Ursula and Gianni got off at the next station but one, having brought their growing mutual admiration to a startling climax wedged solid among the rocking mass of sober commuters. 
 After a quick tidy-up they took the next train back to the Gare de Lyon where Monique had only twenty minutes to wait. 
 Were the other passengers all  sober? 
 Startling the commuter is a game in which it is best to think so. 
 Chapter Five opens with the information: &bquo;Ursula and Kenelm had known my parents for some time, having been introduced originally by a mutual friend. 
 Kenelm had then sold my father a pair of eighteenth-century cupboards.&equo; 
 And so it was that Ursula met Justin, the writer's moody adolescent brother, and ran away with him. 
 Away! 
 They were off on their seventeen years of Tristan and Isolde. 
 Justin, who would appear to have lost some of his old  charisma, became the straight man of the act &mdash; always mending things. 
 They lived frugally but in style. 
 They rented a flat in Rome and built a house in Greece. 
 Here they are, unisex and colour-supplement-magnetic in an Italian &bquo;working-class&equo; restaurant: &bquo;Justin and Ursula, with their measured dignity and impeccable, interchangeable clothes &mdash; perhaps soft leather waistcoats over silk shirts and linen trousers in colours that rarely overstepped the narrow arc of the spectrum between cream and ochre &mdash; were immediately noticeable.&equo; 
 They turned nomadic and mingled with the nomads of the Sudan, where they were to consider building a further house and perhaps settling down. 
 They swam, they talked, they wrote their diaries and stories, and were at ease in a succession of remote and sticky places. 
 Ursula's bad back was religiously exposed to unmanageable African horses and jolting lorry rides. 
 England's wealthy and wonderful &mdash; their scams and scrapes, their portfolios, clubs, night-clubs, champagne and cocaine, the Cockney accents of their young ones, their gossip-columnists and their art historians, their Lucan-like zombies and their zoos and safaris &mdash; were avoided. 
 T. Behrens kept up with the fleeing lovers, at intervals. 
 He visited them in Egypt, accompanied by a girl he'd met in a bar, who proved to be a lesbian. 
 His own vicissitudes in love are a feature of the story he tells, as is his attempt to understand his disconcerting brother and to produce reflections on the meaning of it all. 
 Ursula's diary is reflective too, but is at its best in its evocations of place &mdash; of the nothingness of the desert, especially. 
 She can, against the odds, be funny: &bquo;Dinkas in the market have long, brass-bound pipes. 
 One of these smokers wears a T-shirt with the words &bquo;ever ready&equo;. 
 He looks less ready than anyone I've ever seen.&equo; 
 One of her sententious entries reads: &bquo;Tactlessness is often taken for sincerity, and sincerity is in turn often taken for a compliment. 
 Let no one ever be sincere with me &mdash; it is a failure of respect, and respect is a thing one can never get enough of. 
 And the only kind of respect worth having is the insincere kind.&equo; 
 Another reads: &bquo;Where would we be without that much-maligned virtue, vanity!&equo; 
 These upper-class pens&eacute;es  lighten the load of an odyssey whose ports of call, for all her evocations, are barely distinguishable  from one another. 
 Struggling with his maps, the writer is forced into sheer itinerary: 
 They drove directly south-west into Algeria through Guelma, Bou Saada, Ain Sefra, Colomb B&eacute;char near the Moroccan frontier, Tindouf, into Mauritania through Chinguetta, and reached the Atlantic coast at Nouakshott. 
 Then down the coast to St Louis in Senegal. 
 At Dakar they cut sharply back into Mauritania through Kiffa, then south again to Kayes in Mali. 
 On to Bamako, then eastward into Upper Volta through Bobo Djoulasso and Ouagadougou. 
 But this, too, is upper-class, this recital of exotic place-names &mdash; so often the spoor of the doughty, ascetic, astringent English traveller who has left his privileges behind. 
 As the years go by, Ursula's body becomes a bore, and she experiences a fear of ageing: &bquo;I shall have to die fairly young, because I won't be able to live with the infirmities of old age.&equo; 
 She is indeed ready to die, and it is a difficulty that Justin may feel that he has to do the same. 
 In the Sudan she declares: &bquo;My time is up.&equo; 
 She is infatuated with a handsome police chief, goes rather grimly to bed with him in the time he can spare from gambling sessions, and then kills herself. 
 Justin goes back to England for a while, and then, having broken some hearts, arrives in the Sudan to perform his own suicide. 
 They now lie together in a single lot in a local cemetery. 
 The headstone is inscribed with the words: &bquo;Ursula and Justin &mdash; One&equo;. 
 &bquo;One&equo; was a word of the Chelsea set for the first person singular, and one might perhaps venture the thought of a pun in the words of the inscription. 
 These two people had enacted what we have long been accustomed to think of as a romantic programme, whereby love and death converge, and dying young is the thing to do, whereby other people, and common life, are a thing to be escaped from, and a tension develops between the duty to a partner and a cultivation of the self, between the dictates of an amour fou  and an amour de soi . 
 &bquo;Most people addicted to romancing are their own heroes&equo;: when a second person enters the solitude in question, Louisa Stuart's maxim becomes harder to apply. 
 But I have the impression that Ursula was very much her own heroine. 
 T. Behrens is considerably baffled by this strange case, by the question of what it was that determined Ursula's adherence  to this programme, and of what it was that caused her to bring to an end her loving friendship with Justin. 
 Guesses are hazarded, and are quoted from interviews he conducted. 
 A hint of child abuse may seem to be imparted by his account of a Gothic moment which came about during a walk with her father, at nightfall, in a setting of peasants and forests. 
 Ursula figures as &bquo;some sort of Hungarian countess&equo; whose parents were estranged and who was to be estranged from her ominous father. 
 There she once sat in some sort of castle, or not, reading, for sure, the literature of Romanticism, and growing up to resemble &mdash; in the opinion of the writer's aunt, the historian C. B. A. Behrens &mdash; a character out of Lermontov. 
 Lermontov, for his part, was a character out of Byron, and so was Pechorin, the &bquo;hero of our time&equo; in Lermontov's novel of 1839, one of those people &bquo;who are fated to attract all kinds of unusual things&equo;. 
 Pechorin is a cold-hearted, stylish fatalist, experimentalist, existentialist and divided man, a traveller, gambler, heart-breaker and forgetter of old friends, who loves to ride &bquo;a spirited horse through the long grass against a desert wind&equo;. 
 Blond and beautiful in his leg-ribbons, his high-heeled shoes, &bquo;fitted with the greatest possible exactitude&equo;, his &bquo;long white tunic&equo; and &bquo;dark-brown Circassian coat&equo;. 
 Byron's is not the only ghost to be detected here: the cold hearts of his precursors Lovelace and Laclos's Valmont are present in Pechorin, who has succeeded in attracting a certain princess. 
 I'll tell you the whole truth,&equo; I answered the Princess. 
 &bquo;I won't excuse or explain my conduct. 
 I don't love you.&equo; 
 The colour faded from her lips. 
 &bquo;Leave me alone,&equo; she said, barely audibly. 
 I shrugged my shoulders, turned, and walked away. 
 The shrugger doesn't care whether he lives or dies &mdash; and the designer duel arranged for himself by this divided and indifferent man is a form of Russian roulette. 
 The duel in which Lermontov was soon to die is said to have been patterned, so far as its arrangements went, on the one in the novel: the outcome, however, was perceptibly different. 
 V. G. Kiernan's recent book on the history of duelling &mdash; the work of a historian who is able to grasp, as many historians now are not, that the literature of the past is evidence of the  past &mdash; discusses Lermontov's real and imaginary duels. 
 The book indicates that duelling and gambling have been co-ordinate activities: both, we may feel, are poised on a knife-edge between accident and intention. 
 If there is an element of design on Pechorin's part in the duel he fights, an element which incorporates a knowledge of the loaded dice to be employed by his opponent in the form of an unloaded pistol, the outcome can still be ascribed to chance, in a sense that must be meant to characterise the hero's fine indifference. 
 Kiernan reports suggestions that Lermontov's own death (like Pushkin's in another duel a few months before) may have been murder, a murder planned by court reactionaries. 
 Outcomes are uncertain, games of chance can be rigged &mdash; but this is not what we are conscious of in reading about Ursula. 
 We read that she intended, in Hamlet's words, to &bquo;leave betimes&equo;, and that she did what she intended. 
 That there was a pattern for her in Lermontov's novel is conceivable: but it can't be claimed that it fits her with exactitude, or that it provides an explanation of her conduct. 
 It is clear enough, none the less, that the hero of that time is like the hero of some other times, including Hamlet's. 
 Shakespeare's play has an arranged duel which miscarries, and which takes off a divided, gambling man who has wondered whether or not it might be better to end his life. 
 Here, too, the uncertainty of a duel utters the uncertainty of internal division. 
 Those who pursue comparisons of the kind I am referring to are likely to be impressed by the staying-power of a literary preoccupation to which a variety of temperaments and compulsions has been attracted, and could well be inclined to believe that Pechorin's duel and indifference may have been among the precedents that weighed, a century later, with a woman bent on contriving her appointment with destiny. 
 Not much is made, however, in the book she has become, of the cultural provenance of this Russian-style belle dame sans merci . 
 She is present in the book as narcissistic, driven and depressive, with the fascination of such people, as the enigma of an exceptional vitality drawn towards &bquo;laziness&equo; and extinction, as a suicidal survivor, her life a chapter of escapes. 
 But she was also, among other literary things, the wonderful and baleful orphan or isolate who is seen to advantage in the books  she read: and it may be that cultural history is especially worth attending to in cases such as hers, where the subject is a dedicated reader, and the basis for a directly psychological account is even more than usually insecure. 
 Not that T. Behrens sets up as a psychologist. 
 To read about her here is like being shown someone's snaps or scrapbook &mdash; perhaps an underrated pleasure. 
 It is like an evening spent in a restaurant &mdash; let's say Olwen's French Club, mentioned on page one, a latter-day refuge of the Chelsea set &mdash; listening to a story of mutual friends. 
 And it is a trip in its own right, on the teller's part. 
 T. Behrens gives the impression that he has more to say about himself than the progress of this mad love &mdash; to which he did not stand all that close at the time, brother as he was &mdash; has allowed him to come up with. 
 It is also possible to feel, and to be told in London, that there was more to be said about the mad love than he allowed himself, or was in a position, to come up with. 
 And it may be that Justin, too, has more to say, from beyond the grave. 
 Waiting in the wings is a book by him about Ursula, entitled Style , which, according to Graham Greene, who was sent the manuscript, could be edited for publication. 
 There may be a cult in the making &mdash; and one could imagine a film by Antonioni, whose script-writer, Mark Peploe, was intrigued by J. Behrens in his last days.  
 Kingsley and the Woman 
 A RECENT photograph of Kingsley Amis shows him with a cat, which is standing beside his typewriter. 
 The author's face wears a witch's smile of appreciation. 
 He is clearly familiar with and fond of that cat. 
 The smile may have come as a surprise to connoisseurs of the pictures of him which have been issued to the world. 
 These pictures, rarely cordial, have become more and more baleful: it is as if he is holding himself back from physical assault on a reader supposed to be a trendy and a lefty, which is, indeed, what many of his readers have always been. 
 The smile contrasts, moreover, with the expression to be imagined on the face of the male lead, Patrick Standish, in Amis's novel of 1988, Difficulties with girls , when the cat in Patrick's life pays him a visit. 
 You feel at first that on a bad day (there are quite a few) Patrick might give it one of the kicks that the novelist seems about to direct at his readers. 
 Then it turns out that Patrick rather likes it after all. 
 But then it turns out that the female lead, his wife Jenny Standish (n&eacute;e Bunn), unreservedly cherishes their cat. 
 All this could suggest that Kingsley Amis isn't altogether sold on Patrick Standish. 
 Readers of Amis can be expected to remember Patrick and Jenny from the past. 
 They appeared in his novel of 1960, Take a girl like you , in which Patrick gives freezing looks, and a group of children wears the &bquo;expression of being proud of being serious, like some famous author photographed in the Radio Times &equo;. 
 The new novel has married the pair and moved them on into the mid-Sixties and from the provinces to London, where Patrick works misgivingly in a fashionable publishing-house. 
 And there are other reappearances from the earlier novel. 
 Each of the novels has an alluring Wendy. 
 Graham McClintoch of &bquo;the indefensible ginger-coloured suit&equo; has returned, and there are commemorative mentions of a ginger this and a ginger that. 
 Patrick is still having difficulties with girls: the married man keeps going to bed with them, not liking it very much and not liking the distress it brings to a wife whom he does  like and who is carefully crafted to be likeable.  
 I reviewed Take a girl like you  when it came out, and took pains to convey how much I enjoyed and admired its incendiariness. 
 The review seemed to think that the swinging Sixties contained a readership, among others, that would be shocked by the novel's candour and scabrousness about sex &mdash; &bquo;no doubt he has touched himself on the raw. 
 He will touch everyone on the raw&equo; &mdash; while the young would receive it as an account of what they were up to. 
 But it was clear, and is clearer still in retrospect, that on a number of occasions an old decorum had been deferred to, or embraced. 
 Jenny's Jack the Lad is addressed by her as &bquo;my lad&equo;, and she firmly refuses to rush into bed with him. 
 The narrator may not wholly be in jest when he refers to sexual intercourse with a certain girl, 17 or thereabouts, as &bquo;the ultimate indecorum&equo;, and rereaders of the novel are likely to be mindful of the survival here of an old England lived in by people like the middle-aged T. S. Eliot, exponents of a disgusted chastity. 
 It seems appropriate that the language of Four Quartets  should enter the novel at one point &mdash; appropriate, too, of course, that it should be mocked. 
 So the piece was solicitous in trying to alleviate the shocks by explaining that the novelist himself was shocked. 
 And I think it was right to argue that the book has its &bquo;strict disclaimers&equo; and that goodness of heart, chiefly Jenny's, is defensively displayed amid a welter of misconduct. 
 There is a bleakness which centres on Patrick's infidelities: but it may also be true that the rudeness and aggression with which Jenny, their sex object, is treated by various chuntering males has grown grimmer with the years than it was reckoned to be, by the author, by me and by many of his readers, at the time. 
 The review predicted that &bquo;any eventual mating&equo; between Patrick and Jenny &bquo;will have something permanently bitter and irresolute about it&equo;. 
 A linguistic point was made in the course of the review &mdash; that Julian Ormerod's lounge-bar slang is &bquo;continuous, in a way, with Patrick's cool utterance&equo; &mdash; and the review also made out that Ormerod's overdone good heart is continuous, in a way, with Jenny's. 
 &bquo;No wonder we like them&equo;, said a poem of Amis's once. 
 The poem says that women are &bquo;much nicer than men&equo;. 
 But the novels were soon to exhibit an interest in misogyny, and to see a connection between &bquo;the old hoo-ha&equo; and &bquo;the old last end&equo; &mdash;  expressions used by Ormerod and Standish respectively, in Take a girl like you , for sexual intercourse and death. 
 Thinking about women is a way of avoiding the thought of death &mdash; and yet women may be the end of you. 
 No wonder we fear them. 
 A paranoid reproach is aimed at all females by an Amis-like figure, who then reproaches himself, or is reproached by some other Amis agent detectable in the novel. 
 At times a golden girl is present in the vicinity of the discussions of the subject that keep happening, and is felt to restore a balance. 
 Fairly early in Take a girl like you , Patrick delivers himself of an unqualified condemnation of women, which is followed by a sentence from the narrator concerning and presumably condemning Patrick's attitude to Jenny at that stage, as a girl to be taken and left: &bquo;He wanted more than his share of her before anybody else had any.&equo; 
 These &bquo;Jenny-dealings&equo; have now, after nearly thirty years, incurred a sequel, in which the discussion, and the former comedy and bleakness, are resumed, and in which the question of continuity of utterance within the novel once again arises. 
 The beauty of the earlier prose is, in part, a beauty of grace notes, the pointing of sentences, charged elegance and buoyant, intelligent wit. 
 In Take a girl like you  a great sentence falls like the dew from heaven during one of the scenes in Amis when a terminally drunk man endures a sexual turmoil and fiasco, is stunned by a stunning but not very nice girl. 
 This particular girl, a model, is putting Patrick in his place by going on about cars: &bquo;Most of my friends have them on the firm,&equo; she said, with the sort of lift of the old proud head that he could hardly believe had not accompanied a limiting judgment on Villiers de l'Isle Adam.&equo; 
 In Difficulties with girls  there are passages which recall that lift of the old proud head. 
 &bquo;In silence, the two almost bowed almost stiffly to each other, behaving rather like two &mdash; well, two somethings-or-other, thought Patrick. 
 Two climatological dendrologists or career torturers, pre-eminent in their respective domains but divided on some technical points.&equo; 
 The new prose, however, is in general less embellished, more elliptical, even quite taxingly so on occasion, and yet more colloquial too. 
 There is less style, of the kind known to Villiers de l'Isle Adam. 
 Fewer jewels. 
 Excellent use is made of the text of Tom Jones , but it is now less detectable that this is a writer who has  done his stint of teaching English literature at university level. 
 The voice of the novelist is heard continually in the speech of his characters. 
 Patrick is a lord of language, as he was in the previous novel. 
 But this novel has not just one but two barmen who could also at a pinch be hailed as lords of language. 
 Even school-teaching Graham, who is meant to be amusingly boring, is good with words, in one of the ways that teachers sometimes are. 
 And even Jenny, who is meant to be a mistress of plain speech, is allowed, in this comparatively austere book, a quiet felicity of phrase based on the justice of her perceptions. 
 The lordship in question is the novelist's, not only in the usual sense, often forgotten, that every word of the novel is his, but also because the speech of its characters can be like that of the narrator, and indeed like that of the writer of Kingsley Amis's discursive prose. 
 This is not the first time that such considerations have arisen for readers of his fiction. 
 Readers of The Old Devils  have asked: are its Welsh Welsh? 
 Its characters have been said to sound English. 
 (Northern Jenny Bunn, incidentally, sounds, to me, Welsh.) 
 There may be a matter of principle here for some of those who wish their authors to be concealed: such authors should not sound like the characters they invent, any more than they should express opinions. 
 But the raconteurs of the extra-literary world are permitted to shape and turn the speech of the characters in their stories, and to play the pervasive evident author. 
 And anyone who doubts whether the method can safely be transferred to literature should consult one of Amis's best novels, Ending up . 
 Raconteur and raisonneur , in his art as in his personal life, he is a concealed author who is evident enough in his hotly opinionated fiction: he is not given to expounding his own passionate opinions there, but can be recognised without difficulty in almost every aspect of every one of his novels, including the speech assigned to his often disputatious characters. 
 There is a sense in which each novel of his is an opinion of his, coextensive with the work itself and rather hard, as a rule, to read off in summary. 
 These considerations affect the difficulties which attend Difficulties with girls , and which come to the fore with the most Amis-sounding of its characters, the male lead. 
 Amis's novels have always been full of opinions, and have, I think, become  prone to a marked ambiguity of effect, especially with regard to questions of gender and race. 
 Patrick has plenty to say on such subjects, and he says it in the lordly way which does much to furnish the book with its presiding idiom. 
 But are we meant to sympathise with what he says? 
 Here and elsewhere, the method, for all that Amis would hate to hear it, is dialectical. 
 In the novels I am thinking of he attributes certain ideas to certain characters and utters them in the prevailing manner of the novel, while also submitting them to question within it. 
 He can appear in so doing to have his opinions and to eat them too. 
 And he can also appear to place the novel in a state of suspension. 
 If the state was not present in his novels from the first, it is there in One Fat Englishman , and in Jake's Thing . 
 It is there in Stanley and the Women , which persuaded Marilyn Butler &mdash; somewhat against the odds, but none the less intelligibly &mdash; to interpret it in the London Review  as a critique of male supremacy, but which has left a very different impression on others. 
 It is compatible with the canon of artistic detachment, but it can cause controversy. 
 Heirs to the freedoms which, on the threshold of the Sixties, Take a girl like you  may be thought to have assisted in inaugurating, but which it also contrived to criticise, young people now seem to feel that the old Patrick belonged to a sexist work, and they may well feel that the old Adam has surfaced again in the new Patrick. 
 But a solicitous critic (Amis has had his share, for all the faces he makes) could perhaps be counted on to demonstrate that the novelist is sorry that Patrick is sexist. 
 Take, for example, the Jewish question as it arises in the novel. 
 Patrick has been hired by an obnoxiously trendy mismated publisher. 
 He labours scornfully for this Simon Giles, faintly comforted by a corner in Classical studies which has been granted him for reasons to do with the firm's image. 
 Between Patrick and Mrs Giles there flows, or gutters, a current of dreary sexual electricity. 
 He fancies that Simon is Jewish, and that he gives off &bquo;a slight hot smell&equo;. 
 We are later tolerantly informed &mdash; in the presiding idiom of the book, by a narrator keen, as ever, to monitor Patrick's impressions &mdash; that the smell was not atrocious: &bquo;not strong but easily perceptible, like a large zoo passed at a distance.&equo; 
 By then, however, Patrick  has been informed, by an office placeman and fuddy-duddy who believes that trendiness has ruined everything, that smelly Simon, though he may be obnoxious, is not Jewish. 
 This is a bad day for Patrick, who had volunteered that Simon was &bquo;one of a certain&hellip; persuasion&equo;. 
 According to the narrator, Patrick is &bquo;so far from being anti-semitic that a couple of his best friends really were Jews&equo; (but who can these two best friends be &mdash; can Ormerod, unmentioned in the later novel, be one?). 
 And now he has been put down, made to seem anti-Semitic, by a probable anti-Semite. 
 The encounter could be read as establishing that he has been silly, while clearing him of a certain&hellip; imputation. 
 But it could also be read very differently. 
 For some, it may serve as a reminder of the Kingsley Amis who once unambiguously remarked, in the course of a berating of Philip Roth, that &bquo;Jewish jokes are not funny&equo;. 
 Then there is the woman question, which arises in the novel in a fashion which sets us wondering, as in the past and as in the case of the above encounter, which parts of the bad behaviour on display Amis quite or largely likes. 
 The woman question is treated together with the homosexual question. 
 This is the mid-Sixties, and homosexuals are being released from the closet by a law enacted by Parliament late in the novel. 
 Patrick is far from anti-homosexual, though not entirely patient with the relevant practices and pretensions. 
 This standpoint is gathered up with others in a book which is free with descriptions of creditable and discreditable dealings on the part of those of that persuasion. 
 Two, or three, of them are in, or moving into, the far from populous row of flats, just over the river in South London, which is inhabited by Patrick and Jenny, and by a stunning, boring wife who affords Patrick one of the novelist's turmoils in a vulgarly-appointed borrowed flat some miles to the north. 
 Among the few Standish neighbours on the row is Eric, long gone from the closet and married to Stevie, a he-man former semi-film-star, whom he eventually stabs. 
 Eric is represented as sympathetic, and the counsel he imparts to Patrick on the subject of gender might almost have been imparted by Patrick: 
 You and I are by nature, by our respective natures, males who are irresistibly attracted by a non-male principle. 
 In your case,  straight-forward, women; in my case not straightforward, not women &mdash; but , non-male, except anatomically. 
 And it's the clash between male and non-male that causes all the trouble. 
 They're different from us. 
 More like children. 
 Crying when things go wrong. 
 Making difficulties just so as to be a person. 
 But when Patrick says that sort of thing to Jenny, he adds that she  is an exception to this law of nature. 
 She is not, as he puts it, &bquo;that sort&equo; of woman. 
 Meanwhile the also sympathetic but Grahamly maddening Tim is struggling to move into a flat on the row, while supposing himself to be struggling to come out of the closet. 
 A third homosexual on the row? 
 What he has to come out with is not initially clear, but it becomes clearer when a taste of gay night-life turns him off, and he trails back to his dull wife. 
 This could be termed an uncomely version of what happens to Patrick, whose wife discovers that, at long last, she is pregnant. 
 She is sure that this will settle them for the foreseeable future. 
 Their relationship is still unresolved, as wise heads had foreseen in 1960: but their marriage has gained a lease of life. 
 The woe that is in marriage is not all that bad really. 
 Jenny has urgently advised Tim to return to his dull wife, telling him that her dullness is the &bquo;whole point&equo;. 
 Those who think that Jenny herself is a little dull at times might conclude that Patrick has impaled himself on that point, like one of those Romans whose language he used to teach. 
 He is to do a lot less swinging. 
 &bquo;She was going to have him all to herself for at least three years, probably more like five, and a part of him for ever&hellip;&equo;. 
 The novel is no persuasive advertisement for marriage, or for Jews and gays. 
 But it isn't plain sailing either to claim it as racist and sexist. 
 There is a difficulty with Jenny, of a kind that came with the innocent of the previous novel. 
 She now knows more, but the iron has not entered her soul. 
 Amid the general ventriloquism she does often manage to speak for herself. 
 The novelist is less inward, less collusive, with her than he is with her husband &mdash; a relation fully consonant with Eric's law of nature &mdash; but he wants her view to be respected, and works it too hard as a purchase on wrong thinking. 
 Amis is still soft on her, a sentiment which is likely to strike most of his readers as natural too. 
 She is entrusted, on one occasion, with what might seem a  rudimentary version of one of his own opinions. 
 On this occasion she is at a posh party, where she has taken a glass of champagne, but only &bquo;to be sociable&equo; &mdash; a motive which in anyone else would have driven Patrick to contemplate another of the umpteen blows he feels like unleashing &mdash; when the novelist unleashes one of his phonological jokes, which play on vagaries of pronunciation. 
 A man, back from Spain, addresses her in tones that approximate to what the Independent  thought was the &bquo;well-educated voice&equo;, and to what the Guardian  thought was the &bquo;assured accent&equo;, transmitted by the Intelligence chief responsible for the shooting of the IRA bombers in Gibraltar which preceded the arrival of the novel. 
 Jenny understands him to say that he has had trouble on his travels &bquo;with the Reds&equo;. 
 &bquo;Oh, I thought they'd taken care of them,&equo; said Jenny. 
 &bquo;Since that war they had there.&equo; 
 &bquo;They haven't, believe me. 
 Well, not up anything you could call a&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I suppose that's where they would tend to hole up.&equo; 
 Where can Jenny have been, in the course of her adolescence, to be willing, if only out of nervousness, to accept that the Reds in Spain have been swept out from under the bed and up into mountain caves? 
 It's a very funny joke, but it works at the expense of treating her like a child, which is not at all what the novel usually intends. 
 Amis writes here, as he has written in other books, about the distance between men and women; here, too, is the trouble that awaits the rational hedonist who deceives the woman he lives with and loves. 
 It isn't every comic genius who would undertake to send his talent into such painful places. 
 Both this novel and the one which it resumes are &bquo;hung&equo; books, in the sense that Parliaments are said to be hung. 
 Adultery has been a hanging matter &mdash; both in this and in the usual sense of the phrase &mdash; for the literature of the past, and perhaps it could be suggested that both senses may at times be presented to the mind by what Amis does with the subject, and that there is no striking difference in this respect between what he did in the Sixties and what he has done in the Eighties. 
 I don't think this means that there is no saying what he is getting at in these  works; opinions can and will be formed, and for the extent of the present discussion I have been attempting to express one. 
 Any such attempt has to look closely at their chastened but ultimately unchastenable hero, at his hostility, at his stylistic authority and command of the books he belongs to. 
 Maybe there will one day be a novel from Amis which portrays the Patrick Standish of the Eighties &mdash; more baleful, no doubt, on certain subjects, nicer to his cat, surrounded by the monuments of the New Right and by the debris of the swinging past to which he had once been a contributor. 
 The two Patrick books are stations in a progress &mdash; what Amis has encouraged us to call Lucky Jim's turn to the right. 
 This is a progress which has found its haven in the achievements of Mrs Thatcher, and the Patrick of the Eighties will have to deal with that. 
 It will be difficult for him to be baleful about the Millennium. 
 I would like to say a last word about Amis's voices, and about the long words which have been or might be laid on his confident art &mdash; a terminology for which he is unlikely to be grateful. 
 There is a poem by his friend Philip Larkin, entitled &bquo;Letter to a Friend about Girls&equo;, which was never published during Larkin's lifetime but was retrieved for the Collected Poems  of 1988. 
 It is dated December 1959, and may therefore have been written at the time that Take a girl like you  was being completed. 
 And it might almost be the work of Graham McClintoch. 
 To imagine this is to be aware that the aggressive term which I have applied to Amis's novelistic method, &bquo;ventriloquism&equo;, has the drawback of suggesting that when an author throws his voice, the character who receives it will necessarily be found to be inanimate, a dummy. 
 This is not, of course, the case. 
 Dummies can come to life in books, as it seems they can do for their masters on the stage: and this miracle depends, not only on the author, but also on the people he knows, who may indeed be thought to participate in what he is, and who are likely to participate in his ventriloquism. 
 It may be that Larkin's poem and the person we meet there participate in the ventriloquism of Amis's novel. 
 At a mid-point in the novel there occurs McClintoch's complaint that people are divided into the &bquo;attractive&equo; and the &bquo;unattractive&equo;, rather as, according to Disraeli, as Graham  duly notes, Victorian England was divided into the two nations' of rich and poor. 
 There is a &bquo;barrier&equo; between the attractive and the unattractive &mdash; between, as Graham puts it on a later occasion, the &bquo;beggars&equo; and &bquo;choosers&equo; of the sexual life. 
 Convinced of his own plainness, Graham is here engaged in taking Jenny out and making a mess of kissing her. 
 Jenny is nice about the mess, but disturbed by what he tells her &mdash; in words that call to mind the language, and the drift, of this poem and others by Larkin, and of passages in Larkin's fiction where Jack is denied his Jill. 
 You can't imagine what it's like not to know what it is to meet an attractive person who's also attracted to you, can you? 
 Because unattractive men don't want unattractive girls, you see. 
 They want attractive girls. 
 They merely get  unattractive girls. 
 I think a lot of people feel vaguely when they see two duffers marrying that the duffers must prefer it that way. 
 Which is rather like saying that slum-dwellers would rather live in the slums than anywhere else &mdash; there they are in the slums, aren't they? 
 Larkin's poem complains in concert; it takes up the question of what it is to be sexually debarred. 
 The letter it sends is to an attractive friend who goes about &bquo;bagging birds&equo;, and who belongs to a world in which the beautiful say yes to the beautiful and wildly misbehave, a world which is said to be &bquo;described on Sundays only&equo;, in papers like the News of the World  &mdash; but which is also described in Take a girl like you . 
 The poem begins: 
 After comparing lives with you for years 
 I see how I've been losing: all the while 
 I've met a different gauge of girl from yours. 
 Grant that, and all the rest makes sense as well&hellip; 
 As for the different &bquo;sort&equo; of girl known to the loser: 
 They have their world, not much compared with yours, 
 But where they work, and age, and put off men 
 By being unattractive, or too shy, 
 Or having morals &mdash; anyhow none give in&hellip; 
 By now, the reader may be on his way to deciding that this is the better world of the two, and to wondering if the poet is trying to get his own back.  
 The poem might be thought self-pitying if it were more believable. 
 Can this  ever have been the trouble with Larkin? 
 But then I'll be told that it's not about him  at all, in that silly sense. 
 Whether it is or not, the poem can be called distinctive &mdash; distinctive both of Larkin and of Amis. 
 The mutualities of their friendship have been incorporated in the two worlds in question as they figure in Amis's novel, where unattractiveness is a category as definite as mumps and the unattractive are absolutely and permanently unattractive to one another. 
 These two worlds, moreover, are like the two worlds of men and women in Amis. 
 Between men and women, too, there is said to be a barrier. 
 And there are, in fact, several barriers in his writings: that between Jenny and the Reds could be considered another. 
 In all this sharp distinguishing, in all this enemy thing that Amis has, there are elements of anxiety, and of misrepresentation. 
 Many of the actions performed by many women, according to the misogynists he likes to write about, are performed by many men, and many ugly people would appear to be just as happy, and just as emotionally fulfilled, as many lovely ones. 
 Amis also likes to write, as Larkin liked to write, about the fear of death, and it may be that this fear can be detected in the failure to notice here that both sorts of people are subject to it, as to other unavoidable misfortunes, and that both sorts die. 
 Amis and Larkin are the same but different. 
 The poem and novel I have attributed to them respectively can also, for certain purposes, be attributed to them both. 
 They are pieces of writing which are distinct in law; the author of the one could not be sued for the other, or for collaborating in it. 
 Nevertheless a togetherness is apparent, of a kind that characterises colluders &mdash; or friends &mdash; rather than collaborators. 
 It can be said of these strong-minded and independently gifted accomplices that their work shows a dimension of reciprocity and replication, of the production unit, which stands at an appreciable remove from parody and plagiarism, and from the mimicry of other people's voices which is comprehended in the term &bquo;ventriloquism&equo;, which Amis goes in for in private, among friends, and which is also a pleasure of the novels he writes. 
 Their work bears witness both to the power of partnership and to the powers of expression which we feel able to attribute to groups, to some circle of friends or literary &bquo;school&equo; &mdash; in this case, the group which was  at one time drunkenly designated the scholarship boys, angry young men or hypergamists of the Fifties. 
 I have applied the term &bquo;ventriloquism&equo;, in this book, to the fictions of Peter Ackroyd and Kingsley Amis. 
 Elsewhere, Frank Kermode has applied it to the fictions of Evelyn Waugh and Muriel Spark (&bquo;no matter what the characters say they all speak in some version of her voice&equo;), while linking it with Bakhtin's distinction, well-known now both in Russia and in the West, between the &bquo;monologic&equo; and the &bquo;dialogic&equo; imagination. 
 The former is ventriloquial; the latter gives &bquo;a carnival sense of the world&equo;, and is the more hopeful. 
 True art, or the best art, has a dialogic structure, many voices, and so has the good society. 
 This is an author who has contributed to the Russia which has come after him &mdash; to the emergence there, at the present time, of the demand for a lawful Opposition, for the duality of democracy. 
 The difference yields a political meaning, in other words, and it would also appear to relate to the old theory of the difference between an author who tells and an author who shows, and who employs a medley of voices in order to do so. 
 It is a distinction which may in the end prove more suggestive than serviceable: the author who tells, and who can be accounted something of a ventriloquist, may well, for instance, be more than capable of carnival, and may even be every bit as plural in his works as his dialogic counterpart. 
 But it is possible to believe that the idea of ventriloquism which lies at the heart of it may be successfully applied both to some sorts of contemporary author and to some of what went before. 
 The status of comedy is crucial to the debate, and we can at least be sure that Kingsley Amis would not object to having his practice compared with Waugh's, or to being placed with him among the monologists of the Right. 
 Against this monologic Amis can be set, by way of alter ego, the modernistic Amis of Barbara Everett's discussion of Difficulties with girls , which occurred in the course of an essay on Hugh Kenner's fantasy of a British betrayal of Modernism, and which springs the surprise of conveying that Amis, so often supposed an enemy of Modernism, is really a Modernist. 
 She begins by recalling a remark made to her a long time ago by Larkin, about difficulties encountered in his private life &mdash; a  remark which consisted of a joke to do with &bquo;the impossibility of relations between men and women&equo;, followed by the notion that &bquo;women ought really to marry each other&equo;, followed by &bquo;but that would be wrong, wouldn't it?&equo; 
 And she notes that the same remark, or the same sentences, can be found in Amis's novel. 
 What interests her, apparently, is not the remark itself, but &bquo;the degree to which the piece of recall&equo; &mdash; her piece of recall, presumably &mdash; &bquo;failed to affect the novel in any way&equo;. 
 The novel was left &bquo;curiously unaffected&equo; by this discovery. 
 It is as if the discovery could have no meaning for anyone experiencing the novel &mdash; which would certainly be curious. 
 Barbara Everett's subtle and disconcerting essay proceeds to say that &bquo; Difficulties with girls  is much more like The Waste Land  than Kenner leaves room for guessing it is&equo;, in the book by him which she is examining. 
 &bquo;This theoretically realistic and humorous novel is not unlike The Waste Land , the showpiece of Modernism and Impersonality&equo; &mdash; which gives the impression that the realistic and humorous can only be deemed compatible with impersonality if they can also be deemed theoretical, and that the novel may not be very funny. 
 Soon afterwards, though, she writes: &bquo;I don't want to suggest that Difficulties with girls  and The Waste Land  really have much to do with each other.&equo; 
 So the two works are said to be both like one another and unlike. 
 What they have in common is that each escapes &bquo;the limitations of the personal&equo;. 
 Everett explains: 
 All knowledge of life and lives, and indeed of history, is a good in itself, and seems likely to inform literary intelligence; and in addition Amis's novels would rather confuse if thought to be the work of an early Tudor writer. 
 Beyond this, the use of biography, its actual ability to throw light (rather than just to be entertaining and nice to have around), seems to be a fantasy. 
 Kenner's fantasy is being discussed in terms of the view &mdash; with which Kenner can be expected to be very familiar &mdash; that the goals of a biographically-minded criticism are in some measure fantastic. 
 &bquo;Beyond this&equo;, however, leaves indefinite the point at which, or frequency with which, the use of biography deserves to be called by that name. 
 She is saying that this good thing, this knowledge, can be used &mdash; to tell us, for example, that Amis  is not a Tudor writer: but she is rather more moved to say at the same time that it can't or can hardly be used, devoted as she is to the thought of a separation between, in this case, Amis's friendships and politics, his life &mdash; and his art. 
 His novel is art all right. 
 It has the sui generis  of art. 
 It has art's power to translate, to abstract from the circumstances in which it originates. 
 There is no biographical key with which it can be unlocked &mdash; and I have not been trying to turn one in this essay of mine, which does not believe it, for that matter, to be locked. 
 Nevertheless it is an utterance of the Amis who has made himself known on other occasions, and it can be none the worse for being read by those who are able and disposed to pay intelligent attention to this range of information &mdash; which is not to imply that the information may not be disastrously misunderstood. 
 The choice here may in a sense be one between knowing more and knowing less. 
 Should Amis's friendship with Larkin &mdash; which goes unstated in Amis's fiction, but which is not absent from it &mdash; matter to the reader of that fiction? 
 Why should it not, if there are grounds for thinking that it matters to the fiction? 
 The report that Eliot was eventually to say of The Waste Land  that &bquo;to me it was only the relief of a personal and wholly insignificant grouse against life&equo; is no more a licence to treat the poem as totally and unreservedly autobiographical than it is a conclusive estimate of its significance. 
 But the report is worth knowing by those who want to know the poem. 
 Both Amis and Eliot can be considered seasoned disapprovers, and it is probable that Amis shares the other writer's distaste for the biographical critic, whose activities may be responsibly conducted, and are generally acknowledged to have been successful at times, but have often been reckoned to fail. 
 But if this is so, it can be seen to make possible biographical connections of a usable kind. 
 It connects the two writers, and it connects each one of them with their works. 
 The two works of theirs which Barbara Everett compares are neither of them an escape from the spacious confines of the personal. 
 In this respect they are alike, and like all other works of art. 
 But in many respects they are very different, and they come from different times: they are separated from one another by three-quarters of a century. 
 It would take someone who was very much intent on a punishment of biography to think of pointing  the way to Difficulties with girls  by mentioning its proximity to The Waste Land .  
 Polymorphous Roth 
 AUTHORSHIP can be called, if anything or anyone can, dual, equivocal. 
 The works of authors are replicas, and they are unique. 
 They are and are not autobiographical. 
 An author is and is not his book. 
 In the later years of the Eighties a series of events and episodes has served to direct the attention of British readers to the issue of authorship and its autobiographical character or constituent. 
 I am thinking of the death of Primo Levi, an autobiographer, and by certain standards an amateur; of the threatened death of the novelist Salman Rushdie; and of the discovery of the fascist sympathies formerly exhibited by the literary theorist Paul de Man. 
 And I am also thinking of the identification of Rahila Khan &mdash; a novelist supposedly Asian and female &mdash; as an Anglican vicar; and of the attempt to thwart a biography by the Englishman Ian Hamilton of the American J. D. Salinger, whose novels tell the story of his life, but who does not want anyone else to do so, preferring to keep his facts to himself. 
 Soon after Hamilton's battle-scarred book came out, moreover, in the spring of 1988, there appeared in Britain a kind of memoir entitled The Facts-A Novelist's Autobiography  in which the issue was addressed in some passages of exceptional interest &mdash; the gaze and forehead of Olympian Zeus after the outcries and the special and professional pleading which had surrounded all but one of these other events. 
 The novelist was Philip Roth, no stranger to outcries himself, whose fictions reveal a multiple self which corresponds to the multiple self of Philip Roth. 
 They can be said to determine and to indetermine, both to record, and to distort and desert, the facts of his life. 
 He has now told the same story &bquo;straight&equo; &mdash; or comparatively straight. 
 &bquo;On the pendulum of self-exposure that oscillates between aggressively exhibitionistic Mailerism and sequestered Salingerism, I'd say that I occupy a midway position&equo;, explains Roth in The Facts  &mdash; in a prefatory letter to his alter ego of earlier books, the novelist Nathan Zuckerman, who is granted a letter of reply at the end of this one and a perusal of the intervening  narrative. 
 Roth also explains that he was &bquo;educated to believe that the independent reality of the fiction is all there is of importance and that writers should remain in the shadows&equo;. 
 As the world knows, Roth grew up in Newark, New Jersey, a second-generation American Jew, and he was to turn into a citizen of the world, a famous cosmopolitan author. 
 In middle age he has experienced a breakdown, an identity crisis, which followed a long illness and an operation. 
 He felt a need to discover who he was, and to write directly about that, and about his books, to step out of the shadows. 
 His first book, the collection of stories entitled Goodbye, Columbus , fixed him in the popular mind, from 1959, as an &bquo;enemy of the Jews&equo; &mdash; a condition aggravated by the onanistic bravura and scandalous mad success of the grotesquely imaginative Portnoy's Complaint  (1969), and not much improved in recent years by The Counterlife  (1987), in which various escapes from Jewish America, including an escape to Israel, are projected, and in which Zuckerman and his dentist brother Henry are both imagined to have ailing hearts and to undertake gruesome surgery in order to restore the sexual potency suspended by their medication. 
 Defenders of the Jewish American pieties and proprieties, and those in Israel for whom the Diaspora Jew is a rootless cosmopolitan, had marked Roth as a bad man, and in their eyes he has yet to turn into a good one. 
 In the fine and fairly straight title-story of the first collection, a well-to-do Jewish family expels a poor boy to whom they feel they have been &bquo;nice&equo; and who has repaid them by sleeping with their daughter. 
 The poor boy, who resembles Philip Roth, tells the story in which he takes part, and does so in a manner that can be considered uncontroversial. 
 In the fictions that lay ahead, however, the relationship between the author and his characters is subjected to an intense elaboration. 
 It became, in a sense, the story Roth now had to tell. 
 A dance ensues in which he and his characters exchange identities. 
 The poor boy continued to fight with propriety in these fictions. 
 But now there's the possibility of a truce. 
 The Facts  shows signs of a wish to be &bquo;reconciled with the tribe&equo;, and indeed to be a &bquo;nice fellow&equo;. 
 At the same time, though less abrasive, the book is only intermittently less sophisticated than those that preceded it. 
 The &bquo;distrustful fellow&equo; of the past is present, and not just as a  commemorative item. 
 A multiple Roth is once again in evidence. 
 He knows how important to the power of his writings had been his fight with the Jews and the outrageous candour of his sexual descriptions, and in the recent writings this knowledge is conveyed by the proximity of an imagined truce to an imagined impotence. 
 Nathan Zuckerman is a persona's persona: Roth begat Peter Tarnopol &mdash; who begat Nathan Zuckerman &mdash; in the novel of 1974, My Life as a Man . 
 Zuckerman has enabled Roth to deal with the question of the offence he has given to righteous Jews, and to come to terms with the rebellious, psychedelic, philo-Semitic Sixties, when Roth's writing went, with the times, derisive and fantastic. 
 The Zuckerman books are a medley of differences and affinities between what we are able to infer about Roth's life and what he has made of it in art. 
 In propria persona , Roth discourses in The Facts  about his relationship with his younger brother, Sandy. 
 The tone is judicious and kind. 
 This is a nice fellow speaking. 
 Because Sandy was embarked on a marriage and a career pointing him in a more conventional direction than mine, planning the sort of life that looked to me to have more obviously evolved from the background I'd put behind me, it didn't seem to me that he would have had the wherewithal &mdash; &bquo;morally&equo;, as I would have been quick to say then &mdash; to help me through my predicament or, if he did, that it was possible for me  with my values , to solicit his assistance. 
 This was hubris, pure and simple&hellip; 
 Zuckerman's relationship with his brother Henry is, in contrast, often sanguinary, as gruesome as their respective operations. 
 Zuckerman Unbound  (1981) reaches its climax at one of Roth's frequent funerals &mdash; in this case, that of Zuckerman's father &mdash; after which Henry charges Nathan with killing their parent by writing &bquo;that book&equo;, the liberated Carnovsky , and with believing like the bastard he is that fiction doesn't have consequences. 
 Nathan is a swinger, who is blamed for whoring after and mistreating gentile women. 
 &bquo;Even your shiksas go down the drain when they don't tickle your fancy anymore.&equo; 
 Meanwhile The Counterlife  attributes to Henry the verdict that &bquo;exploiting and distorting family secrets was my brother's livelihood&equo;.  
 Philip Roth's contribution to The Facts  is (as distinct from Nathan Zuckerman's) significantly milder, in relation to family matters, than what we get in these abrasive comic fictions: but then the fictions can be nice too. 
 The conversation in Zuckerman Unbound  between the novelist and his mother, in which he tenderly instructs her in how to field the intrusions that arise from the Carnovsky  outrage, reads authentically, autobiographically, enough, while showing a good Jewish son. 
 The Zuckerman books help one to imagine how Roth has faced the reproach that he has derided his family and sold their secrets. 
 But perhaps it is not too simple to suggest that we are also conscious of Zuckerman as a deflection of the wrath over Roth which works by making Zuckerman responsible for the outrage. 
 We are conscious of what Zuckerman does for Roth: when he helps a man to gather his spilt heart pills, it is Roth helping himself by assigning a small mercy. 
 In The Facts , the tough guy with his shiksas, the supposedly &bquo;self-hating&equo; Diaspora Jew, can be &bquo;tenderised&equo; &mdash; a word Roth likes, for all the awkwardness it imparts to the operations to which it refers &mdash; into a sort of uxorious submission where his parents are concerned. 
 This is a state which Zuckerman experiences and which he sends up. 
 In the fictional conversation about adverse publicity a good mother meets a son anxious to reassure her, while alive to the comedy of it. 
 &bquo;As long as you know what you're doing&equo;, she ventures, adding: &bquo;And as long as you know that it is right.&equo; 
 &bquo;I do&equo; and &bquo;It is&equo;, replies Zuckerman. 
 The Facts  is the more filial book of the two. 
 The facts show a good son, one who is less quick to see the jokes. 
 Shiksas were to promise an escape from Jewish America, as the promised land of Israel was eventually to be evoked as doing for Henry Zuckerman. 
 The Facts  is preoccupied with one shiksa in particular: the deadly Josie, whom Roth marries, who forces his hand in the matter by faking an abortion, who comes near to destroying him, and who may have been, according to the Zuckerman letter at the end of the book, an alcoholic. 
 When Josie dies in a car crash Roth feels relief. 
 Her death delivers him from the ordeal of divorce, as frequent as funerals are in his books. 
 He had left her and gone to live with an upper-class woman, had soared to the opposite end of the scale from Josie, whose attraction for him had been that of a splenetic  victim from the lower depths of the goyim: but Josie had refused a divorce and the ordeal had dragged on. 
 At one stage no less a person than Bobby Kennedy, soon to accompany Josie to the grave, had offered to help Roth gain his freedom. 
 In the liberated world of radical chic, we may be intended to think, favours could be done for the right person. 
 The Facts  says that the &bquo;crack-up&equo; of 1987 had induced &bquo;fiction fatigue&equo;, a need to &bquo;demythologise myself and play it straight&equo;. 
 Leaving off with the &bquo;imaginative fury&equo; might make it possible to &bquo;unlock meanings that fictionalising has obscured, distended, or even inverted&equo;. 
 At the same time, he accepts the &bquo;obvious&equo; fact that &bquo;facts are never just coming at you but are incorporated by an imagination that is formed by your previous experience&equo;. 
 At the end of the book, though, Zuckerman confronts Roth with the opinion that the latter has made a mistake in trying to tame or to shed his imagination in the foregoing text, that fiction is superior to fact, and that the factuality of The Facts  is specious. 
 Roth would appear to believe both the claim and the counter-claim as to the value of the text, and to believe, too, both that the Roth part of the book does not represent an exercise of the imagination and that it does. 
 It seems reasonable to think that The Facts  is imagined, and that it could promote a benevolent view of the literal or faithful &mdash; as opposed to the fantastically transgressive &mdash; imagination, which may or may not, in any given case, be directly concerned with the facts of the author's own life. 
 It is a work which might well shed a tender light on the novella &bquo;Goodbye, Columbus&equo;. 
 Later in the present book there is a discussion of Roth's regard for the literalism of Primo Levi, who is at his most imaginative when least imaginary, who was not all that successful at imagining things in the style commended in the Zuckerman letter: and in The Facts  a related meaning is apparent. 
 Portnoy's Complaint  is a work of the furious imagination spoken of, and rendered debatable, in The Facts . 
 It is seen in The Facts  to belong to the times in which the writer lived when he wrote the novel, when opposition to the Vietnam War, and to a President Johnson perceived as monstrous, took to the street-wisdom of a farcical obscenity. 
 The Facts  is able to treat the historical conditioning of Portnoy's Complaint  in a way in which the novel itself was not in a position to do. 
 It has the  benefit of hindsight. 
 But it would also appear to know its own place in history in a way which an exercise of the furious imagination in art can sometimes seem to prevent. 
 Different genres, different imaginations. 
 Roth has left off with his mythologising fury &mdash; and his memoir lets us know that the benefits that come to the writer who tries, or even seems, to stick to the facts may amount to something more than those of hindsight. 
 It informs us of the &bquo;forces&equo; which shaped Roth's tours de force  of the Sixties and early Seventies, and it informs us of how he came to be where he is now. 
 He has travelled from the liberated past, when imagination took power, to the liberation of an interest in fact &mdash; a state which may or may not prove to have been, for Roth, partial or provisional, and which The Facts , in its totality, manages to enclose in an ironised uncertainty. 
 He can look here at times a little like a man who has taken the first steps in a descent from the high ground of Self-consciousness, impersonality,  fantastication  and ironic indirection &mdash; not that this has lately been, or has ever been, literature's only ground. 
 But perhaps it will come to be thought by his readers that these successive attitudes to the autobiographical, and to plain speaking, in art are equally valid, equally reversible. 
 This is a view which would accord with the dualistic tradition to which his novels predominantly belong. 
 The Facts  presents, among its various dualities, the reminder that the one and only Philip Roth is like Saul Bellow. 
 Bellow supported Roth's early work, and Roth's work was to bear a resemblance to Bellow's. 
 They are two of a kind, it seems to me, authors of a paranoid comedy of the dualistic imagination, while also different. 
 Roth got to know Bellow in Chicago, where Roth worked as a university teacher, finding it a lively place. 
 It was lively enough to marry Bellow to a &bquo;stylish Radcliffe graduate&equo; of whom Roth had been &bquo;enamoured&equo; &mdash; if we are to assume that The Facts  has not imagined the connection. 
 It is a connection not unlike some of those made in the fiction of both authors. 
 The memoir sets us asking if Philip Roth knows who he is. 
 He is angry, suspicious, overbearing; he can be very like the Zuckerman berated in the fiction as &bquo;this unsatisfiable, suspect, quarrelsome novelist&equo;. 
 And yet he is nice. 
 He is tough and he is tender, wrathful and ruthful. 
 This mixed condition he shares  with many others, not all of them writers; it is a condition we are entitled to call traditional. 
 And it is a condition which can be recognised in the reception of his work. 
 There are readers whom, as Zuckerman is the first (or second) to acknowledge, he can drive to the complaint that he has sex, and family matters, and Jewish matters, on the brain: &bquo;I want him to take his manuscript and mail it to his mother&equo;, as I have heard them cry. 
 There are times when his world can appear to consist of Jews and of those to whom a Jew might wish to escape &mdash; such as America's well-heeled Wasps, or the semi-imaginary anti-Semites of Gloucestershire who figure affluently in The Counterlife . 
 But he is also a writer of remarkable ability who has managed to capture and to keep the readership he has bewildered and delighted and offended, and whose work is strong in an intelligent and generous-hearted awareness of public matters, some of them quite remote from the Family Roth: The Counterlife , for instance, carries a telling serio-comic critique of the hard line in Israel, the Israeli toughness, that refuses to &bquo;give ground&equo;. 
 In The Facts  he examines his own vexed state with reference to the vexed question of whether it is better to make things up, and to distort them, and by contemplating his earlier re-invention of the time-honoured dualistic account of literature and human nature. 
 His shiksas and replicas, hostilities and escapes, have taken part in a great game of long duration, and he can be said to be reviewing the state of play. 
 Escape, he thinks, is Jewish. 
 He knows that it is also dualistic. 
 The dualistic ambience in literature has long been influential, but has remained controversial, and it is both influential and controversial in these annals of the House of Roth. 
 Zuckerman's proposal of marriage to Maria in The Counterlife  is an indication of its importance, and of the importance of escape both for the tradition and for the unsatisfiable Roth. 
 &bquo;Because I've decided to give up the artificial fiction of being myself for the genuine, satisfying falseness of being somebody else. 
 Marry me .&equo; 
 Here, it is as if both the single and the plural accounts of human nature were specious. 
 In general, though, he has been faithful, in most of what he has written, to a version of the mobile and multiple, mysterious and fugitive self. 
 At the end of The Counterlife  there is a letter from Nathan Zuckerman to Maria on this subject which has the force of a  statement of allegiance on the part of Philip Roth. 
 The reader knows that it is Zuckerman's statement too, that it is fiction, and is likely to remind himself that it could well belong to the infinite regress of the dualistic indeterminable, where claim and counter-claim alternate indefinitely. 
 There can be no claim that this is what Roth really thinks: the affidavit that might have been contained in The Facts  has been withheld. 
 It may be that he really thinks there is nothing that he really thinks. 
 But if Roth dissents from the statement, then imagining how he came to write most of his books becomes a problem. 
 Zuckerman tells his Maria: 
 Being Zuckerman is one long performance and the very opposite of what is thought of as being oneself . 
 In fact, those who most seem to be themselves appear to me people impersonating what they think they might like to be, believe they ought to be, or wish to be taken to be by whoever is setting standards. 
 So in earnest are they that they don't even recognise that being in earnest is the act . 
 For certain self-aware people, however, this is not possible: to imagine themselves being themselves, living their own real, authentic, or genuine life, has for them all the aspects of a hallucination. 
 I realise that what I am describing, people divided in themselves, is said to characterise mental illness, and is the absolute opposite of our idea of emotional integration. 
 The whole Western idea of mental health runs in precisely the opposite direction: what is desirable is congruity between your self-consciousness and your natural being. 
 Zuckerman is seeking to deny the traditional connection between illness and psychic division which is reaffirmed in the novel as a whole, and which is also reaffirmed in The Facts , and at the same time to deny that there is a traditional belief in division or multiplicity, a long-standing sense of selfhood as a chimera. 
 He goes on to say to Maria that 
 it's all  impersonation &mdash; in the absence of a self, one impersonates selves, and after a while impersonates best the self that best gets one through. 
 If you were to tell me that there are people, like the man upstairs to whom you now threaten to turn yourself in, who actually do have a strong sense of themselves , I would have to tell you that they are only impersonating people with a strong sense of themselves &mdash; to which you could correctly reply that since there is no way of proving whether I'm right or not, this is a circular argument from which there is no escape.  
 All I can tell you with certainty is that I, for one, have no self, and that I am unwilling or unable to perpetrate upon myself the joke of a self. 
 The man upstairs, the first husband whom Maria is to leave, is not &bquo;self-aware&equo; &mdash; unlike Zuckerman, who declares, on behalf of the self-aware, that he has no self and that the self is a joke. 
 But Roth must know that it is likely to be no joke to those who are reading his book. 
 Zuckerman says here that performance is all there is, that person and persona are one. 
 But we may feel on reading this that it takes two to perform &mdash; that performance requires, in however regressive or circular a fashion, the self that so many people believe they have, and that this epistolary Zuckerman exhibits here, in a display of inadvertence which may or may not implicate Philip Roth. 
 This is a self which there may be &bquo;no way of proving&equo;. 
 It is a self which is proving, for philosophers, hard to prove. 
 But it is a self which readers of the book can only rarely have found it hard to experience. 
 The novelist referred to himself once as &bquo;amorphous Roth&equo;. 
 &bquo;Polymorphous Roth&equo; might be nearer the mark. 
 I think that many of his readers would be prepared to bear witness to the sense that somewhere in there among the changing shapes is the usual nonpareil. 
 In the ambience and tradition to which I am referring personality is defined in terms of breadth and contrast; the effect is at once stereophonically-internal &mdash; a number of speakers has been installed, so to speak &mdash; and invasive. 
 There is more than one Roth. 
 And in what Roth writes Roth and Bellow meet. 
 But neither of them is incapable of pursuing the artificial fiction of being himself. 
 No one would lightly believe that either of them has ever found it hard to tell the difference between himself and somebody else. 
 Dualistic explanations are moving, and intriguing: but they are often thought, even by proponents, to be far-fetched, fictional, theoretical, counter-intuitive. 
 That Bellow, this participant in Roth's inner life, can also be said to be out there in the world as his friend, and perhaps his rival, is a fact which does not help one to decide whether or not to trust the reports of literary duality &mdash; what comes in has to have been out &mdash; but it is very much in the tradition. 
 The tradition gives many convincing pictures of the inwardness and invasiveness of friends and rivals. 
 Brothers may be rivals, and they may be  internalised. 
 Roth's fiction internalises the brother identified in The Facts . 
 In The Counterlife  Henry, the &bquo;distrustful fellow&equo; who distrusts his distrustful brother's &bquo;wallowing heroes&equo;, is at one with the creator of those heroes, and with the heroes, and with the creator's creator. 
 Nathan enters Henry and Henry enters Nathan. 
 Maria bursts into italics (and out of character) to say to Nathan: &bquo; You are your brother !&equo; 
 And Nathan says to Henry: &bquo;We are all each other's authors.&equo; 
 A universal fellowship obtains. 
 The definition of personality which is harboured in such procedures has moved and influenced several generations of writers. 
 The art that comes of them is one in which imagination takes power, the power to distort and exaggerate, in which difference of person is suspended, in which the experience of time is as it is in dreams. 
 The story that is told is a story which never ends &mdash; and which risks losing shape and momentum &mdash; because it is a story told of himself by a living author, an author who has yet to end, whose isolate's imaginative fury lives on to tell another tale, some more of his own story. 
 This fury can look like an onanistic or a solipsistic fury. 
 Mail that  to your mother! 
 It goes without saying that the definition has been responsible for a major literature. 
 But about many of its manifestations there can be something ominous &mdash; something that is acutely understood and eloquently exposed in The Counterlife . 
 This is a generic something: I am speaking here of a literary practice long and widely and variously undertaken, in relation to which Roth is both critic and executant. 
 But it should also be said that some elements of this description of mine could be taken to characterise the activity, sometimes ominous enough in its human implications, of all imaginative writers, however remote they may be from the dualistic confederacy. 
 The caveats expressed in The Counterlife  apply to all occasions when, in whatever genre or style, autobiography imposes itself upon, overwrites, the world. 
 By Roth, as by his predecessors in the dualistic art, this definition has been correlated with breakdown, madness, though, as we have seen, Zuckerman seeks to exert a counterclaim in his letter to Maria. 
 And it has evolved in contrast with character &mdash; that other, earlier product of the literary imagination  &mdash; and with purpose and achievement. 
 There are times when it might seem that this is a definition which can produce the sense of a self which is both amorphous and autonomous, of a doubtful self which also serves to cast doubt on the human world that lies beyond the subjective individual &mdash; a world which some writers are, and some are not, very cunning in, and which is inhabited by people with a working knowledge of who they are and what they are doing. 
 This is a knowledge which has been impugned in literature, and which has deteriorated there. 
 The books I am speaking of are, among others, books which pursue the idea of an escape from personality and from society, and in which personality and society are seen &mdash; as in Zuckerman's letter to Maria &mdash; to be aspects of a single threat. 
 Roth's turn towards fact &mdash; admittedly, an imagined and far from indisputable fact &mdash; will appear to some to signal a turn towards the self and towards the outside world. 
 Such a reading could well be found to have attributed too much to a recoil, a respite, a provisional position. 
 He is unlikely to have lost his distrust of the self; and he is likely (and welcome) to resume his furious fictions. 
 But when he does resume them, when the time comes for him to make his next leap, the suggestions made in the course of this affair of his fiction fatigue and literal turn &mdash; suggestions which receive both rebuttal and support from within the shape-changing dialectic represented by The Counterlife &mdash;  will not deserve to be forgotten.  
 Levi's Oyster 
 THE Italian writer Primo Levi died on 11 April 1987, to the dismay of his readers. 
 There was a time when it must have seemed to many of them that he would never receive a bad review, or even a cross word. 
 His first book, If this is a man , about his months in Auschwitz, and its sequel, The Truce , were hard to fault, and the successive publications of his middle age have been greeted by an admiration responsive both to his skills as a writer and to his character as a man.i In October 1985, however, the chauvinistic American Jewish magazine Commentary  did succeed in performing the outlandish act of disparaging Levi and his books. 
 &bquo;Alas&equo;, wrote Fernanda Eberstadt, a German-American, the later ones are inferior to the first two, and alas, the personal character imparted by his writings &mdash; freely imparted, one might add, and yet not unreservedly &mdash; is flawed. 
 &bquo;Reading Primo Levi&equo; is in some respects a strong essay. 
 The later books are in large measure accurately described, and the experience of the assimilated Jew in Italy, where the Jews came to harm under Mussolini but where they were never the strangers they have been in several other countries, is summarised in a well-informed and pertinent fashion. 
 At the same time, the article is tainted by what seems to be a desire to inflict damage on Levi's reputation, of a kind which may be thought to serve the ideological tendency of the magazine in which it appeared. 
 So what is wrong with Levi and his Levi-like writings? 
 It is made to seem that he was a stranger, a gentleman, a &bquo;watcher from the sidelines&equo;. 
 He was &bquo;cursed with a tin ear for religion&equo;. 
 He could not get on with the believing Jews from Eastern Europe whose religion and traditions he neither shared nor understood. 
 As a result, there are &bquo;no Jews as such&equo; in his Auschwitz book. 
 But many Jews are not believers, and are still, for most people, including themselves, palpably Jewish. 
 He also had, the article conveys, a tin ear for the ordinary man. 
 He is like the poet Ausonius, alas &mdash; that Silver Age abstainer from the world and connoisseur of oysters.  
 Literary criticism is doing here what it often does: it has gone for the faults and, in so doing, inverted the truth. 
 When is a Jew not a Jew? 
 When he does not accept the religion revealed in the Old Testament. 
 The Primo Levi who is read by Fernanda Eberstadt is a man who is unable to write about Jews &mdash; though he does in fact write about them with great sympathy, believers and unbelievers alike &mdash; and who has no feeling for people whose background and abilities are different from his own, though the joy of Levi's work, for other readers, is very often that he has  such feelings, that he knows himself to be, while also knowing himself not to be, an ordinary man, a worker, a man who worked as an industrial chemist and who was no less of a worker when he wrote books. 
 The Levi who emerged from a regime of cruelty and humiliation with his judgement intact, his mind not closed, neither vengeful nor forgetful, and who wrote a noble and rational book about what had happened to him, is mentioned only cursorily and as if concessively by Fernanda Eberstadt. 
 It is not the case that all her objections are mistaken. 
 But their accumulation is very far from the complicated truth. 
 The article leads you to wonder about her religious faith, if she has one, and about where it stands in relation to the outlook of the editor of Commentary , author of a book about his ambitions for worldly success: Making it  must be the least pious book that has ever been written. 
 The stress on Levi's insensitivity to religion is allowed to suggest that all Jews are religious, and there are readers for whom this might signal the corollary that all Jews are Zionists, and are likely to be supporters of Israeli government policy. 
 By these standards, Levi would appear to be an imperfect Jew, and this could well be an opinion that underlies the talk about his later books being not nearly as good as his earlier ones. 
 Here is an assimilated Jew, a Diaspora Jew, unsound on Zion. 
 Among the principal references to Israel in Levi's writings is one which is, from a Zionist point of view, tin-eared. 
 The reference occurs in The Drowned and the Saved , of which a translation was published in 1988, on the anniversary of his death. 
 In this collection of pieces which revert to themes pursued in If this is a man  Levi writes: &bquo;Desperate, the Jewish survivors, in flight from Europe after the great shipwreck, have created in the  bosom of the Arab world an island of Western civilisation, a portentous palingenesis of Judaism, and the pretext for renewed hatred.&equo; 
 There are those for whom it is not Jewish to speak in this way about Israel. 
 It is odd to speak of the creation of a state as the &bquo;pretext&equo; for anything: the translator may possibly be responsible for the oddity here, as for the orotundity that precedes it. 
 But the passage certainly suggests that there was a distance between Levi's view of Israel and the views that Commentary  chooses to publish. 
 The second sentence of the issue of May 1988 refers to the first twenty years of the state: &bquo;Threatening to &bquo;push the Jews into the sea&equo;, the Arab world reformulated the Nazi theory of Lebensraum  in Mediterranean terms: there was no room in the region for a Jewish homeland.&equo; 
 Arabs who had been expelled from their land and thrust into the condition of Jewish refugees are hereby reformulated as imperialist aggressors and as Nazis. 
 This is reminiscent of the sort of inversion a fault-finding literary criticism can produce &mdash; which is not to deny, which is indeed to admit, that the Arab leaders and polemicists of the region have had their faults, including some of those which have been identified over the years by Commentary . 
 The magazine's line on such matters would also appear to be remote from, and distinctly harder than, that taken in its dying days by the Reagan Administration. 
 George Schultz travelled to the Middle East in the summer of 1988 to spread the word that &bquo;the continued occupation of the West Bank and Gaza and the frustration of Palestinian rights is a dead-end street. 
 The belief that this can continue is an illusion.&equo; 
 It is a measure of the grim recalcitrance of the region's problems that Schultz's message was reported to have been saluted by a strike called in protest among the Palestinians of the occupied territories. 
 Meanwhile Fernanda Eberstadt has been practising as an expert on captivity and escape, and on the beliefs established for later generations by the children of Israel. 
 She has written in the same magazine (June 1987) on the Book of Exodus, warning that a reading of the Bible as literature, rather than as sacred text, &bquo;cannot lift heavenward&equo;. 
 In the article on his work which appeared in 1985 Levi is at one point examined with reference to Leviticus. 
 She takes exception to a story of his about a Jewish Communist, an inhabitant of the camps, who  fasts there on Yom Kippur. 
 She observes that the prisoner is following a prohibition laid down in the Old Testament, but that a rabbinical ruling had allowed Jews to eat in the camps on Yom Kippur in order to stay alive. 
 It is not clear why this is a reproach to Levi, whose story concerns a man whose piety is idiosyncratic, especially severe. 
 Two years after this, in February 1987, she praised a Gulag memoir by Gustav Herling. 
 A World Apart  is a &bquo;truly golden&equo; work, despite the presence in it, apparently, of a foul anti-Semitism. 
 Herling is thought to resemble Dostoevsky, whose Prototypical prison book, The House of the Dead , has in it a mansion tenanted by obnoxious, caricatured Jews. 
 A World Apart  is, &bquo;despite&equo; its author's socialism, a &bquo;deeply religious book&equo;, in which she has at times the sense of &bquo;a man talking to God&equo;. 
 She displays more sympathy for this anti-Semitic Moses, for this religious man who is against Jews and against the Soviet system, than she does for Jews who are not religious. 
 Whether or not she has talked to God, she has certainly been reviewing for him. 
 Levi, the expert on metals, would have had no difficulty in telling the difference between gold and tin. 
 I have heard that he was saddened by these writings of Fernanda Eberstadt's, in which his own writings are faulted. 
 Two months after the Herling piece was published Levi committed suicide, throwing himself down the staircase of the house in Turin where he was born and grew up, where he wrote about his life in the camp at a desk which stood where his cradle had stood, a house he shared with his wife and mother. 
 He was 68 years old. 
 I don't suggest that these unfavourable writings pushed him to do what he did, though I don't mind suggesting that the bigotry and vicarious piety they may be reckoned to contain could be classed among the negative experiences of the last months of his life. 
 I have in fact no explanation to offer as to how he came to die, and it may be that no trustworthy explanation will ever be achieved. 
 Levi was an author who, without detriment to the other people who figure in his books, wrote all the time about himself, both in autobiographical and in fictional form. 
 The modes which he adopted were such as to  license  elisions and lacunae, to enable him to leave out bits of his life &mdash; a procedure  which would seem to be connected with his scepticism about what can be known about people by biographers. 
 In Moments of Reprieve  he remarks: &bquo;What the &bquo;true&equo; image of each of us may be in the end is a meaningless question.&equo; 
 In The Periodic Table  he mentions a woman &bquo;dear to my heart&equo; who was murdered at Auschwitz: but the book on Auschwitz does not discuss his relationship with her. 
 In The Wrench  he creates the rigger Faussone, the practical man whose cranes girdle the world and who keeps returning, a little heavy-footed, to the house in Turin where two old aunts fuss over his welfare: Faussone was spoken of as &bquo;my alter ego&equo;, and the book has to struggle to accommodate him as a second person, available for interview by Levi. 
 These omissions and transpositions indicate that Levi could well have kept to himself any plan he may have formed to end his life. 
 During the meeting with him a few months before his death which was recorded in an article published in the London Review , Philip Roth found him as keen as mustard: here was someone who listened, with the intent stillness of a chipmunk. 
 Levi had a high opinion of the grain of mustard, and of salt. 
 Fascism did not like these substances. 
 He associated the grain of mustard with his own activities, with Roth's, with Jews generally, with the awkwardness and tartness and wholesomeness of idiosyncrasy and dissent. 
 It was, or could be called, an impurity. 
 It was the taste of the stranger &mdash; who might at the same time be rooted, as he himself was, in some national life. 
 Back in Italy, after his departure from Auschwitz and his wanderings through Europe, he found that &bquo;the things I had seen and suffered were burning inside of me&equo;, and that he wanted to write about them. 
 These words of his, in The Periodic Table , refer to some words of the past. 
 &bquo;I felt like Coleridge's Ancient Mariner, who waylays on the street the wedding guests going to the feast, inflicting on them the story of his misfortune.&equo; 
 He beg an work as a chemist in a paint factory. 
 Then came the meeting with the woman whom he was to marry, a meeting about which he writes in the same book. 
 In a few hours I felt reborn and replete with new powers, washed clean and cured of a long sickness, finally ready to enter life with joy and vigour; equally cured was suddenly the world around me, and  exorcised the name and face of the woman who had gone down into the lower depths with me and had not returned. 
 My very writing became a different adventure, no longer the dolorous itinerary of a convalescent, no longer a begging for compassion and friendly faces, but a lucid building, which now was no longer solitary; the work of a chemist who weighs and divides, measures and judges on the basis of assured proofs, and strives to answer questions. 
 These remarks concerning If this is a man  do not describe the kind of book which runs easily to sequels, and which is easy to live up to. 
 Nor do they describe the sort of thing we are supposed to like very much. 
 The first two autobiographies, that is to say, are the kind of book to which a tradition of literary interpretation has been inimical, imagining for itself a literature of impersonality, in which autobiography is subsumed, invisible. 
 Philip Roth's article refers to this issue in referring to the later book If not now, when ? &mdash; Levi's &bquo;Eastern&equo;, an adventure story of Jewish partisans during the closing months of the war, led by the Communist fighter-fiddler Gedaleh. 
 &bquo;With his left hand he snatched the gun from the Pole's hands, and with his right he gave him a violent blow to the ear.&equo; 
 Roth says to Levi in the course of the interview embodied in his article: &bquo;Your other books are perhaps less &bquo;imaginary&equo; as to subject-matter but strike me as more imaginative in technique. 
 The motive behind If not now, when ? seems more narrowly tendentious &mdash; and consequently less liberating to the writer &mdash; than the impulse that generates the autobiographical works.&equo; 
 Levi explains that he had amused himself by writing a &bquo;Western&equo; and that he had wanted to write a hopeful book. 
 I wished to assault a commonplace still prevailing in Italy: a Jew is a mild person, a scholar (religious or profane), unwarlike, humiliated, who tolerated centuries of persecution without ever fighting back. 
 It seemed to me a duty to pay homage to those Jews who, in desperate conditions, had found the courage and the skill to resist. 
 I cherished the ambition to be the first (perhaps the only) Italian writer to describe the Yiddish world. 
 I intended to &bquo;exploit&equo; my popularity in my country in order to impose upon my readers a book centred on the Ashkenazi civilisation, history, language and frame of mind, all of which are virtually unknown in Italy, except by some  sophisticated readers of Joseph Roth, Bellow, Singer, Malamud, Potok, and of course yourself. 
 Levi's explained intention does not mean that there is no autobiography in the book. 
 The wish to evoke a Jewish resistance to Nazism relates to a history which comprehends his own writings and example. 
 And in the portrayal of the mechanic Mendel there is a portrayal of Levi. 
 Philip Roth is right, however, to point to the limitations of the book, and to point to a law of Levi's work in general: the less imaginary it is, the more imaginative &mdash; the more literal the better. 
 Let us praise, more than we do, and as we can here, the literal writer. 
 But there is no doing so unless we accept that the literal writer has an imagination. 
 Levi can sometimes appear incapable of fiction, but it is no less apparent that everything he wrote was fiction. 
 He was well-aware of the sense in which he made up what happened to him, imagined his misfortune. 
 In calling his recent book about his own early life by the name of The Facts , Philip Roth is issuing a challenge &mdash; expecting his readers to know that there are no bare facts, and obliging them to think hard about what happens in the recounting of the facts of a life. 
 Levi would have understood that challenge, just as I think he would have been happy to agree that it is possible to speak without contradiction of the literal imagination. 
 Levi's words to Roth about the adventure story If not now, when ? bring to mind the art of the Russian Jewish writer Isaac Babel, who rode with Budyonny's Red Cavalry after the Revolution, through scenes of hardship and atrocity. 
 Babel's art is imaginative, figurative. 
 It has been said, by Dan Jacobson, that he &bquo;aestheticises&equo; his response to violence. 
 This tendency has no counterpart in Levi, and it may be doubtful whether it could live with the subject-matter of the camps. 
 Babel's bad times could be turned into art &mdash; an art which has been seen to release him, as it were, from his subject, and which has also been seen to hesitate. 
 He felt imprisoned by his religious upbringing in Odessa, and was to remember &bquo;the rotted Talmuds of my childhood&equo;. 
 And he was drawn to the grace and violence to be found among his Cossacks. 
 But he was also drawn to the Jews whom he met in their Polish villages, victims of persecution and war, &bquo;old Jews with prophets&equo; beards and passionate  rags', to their ruined ghettoes and synagogues. 
 To such scenes his narrator is introduced by the shopkeeper Gedali, believer in a peaceful Revolution. 
 Levi's Gedaleh and Babel's Gadali are opposing faces of the Central European Jew in times of crisis. 
 Action, power, are thought to be contrasted, in Babel's stories, with learning, devotion, resignation, suffering &mdash; those Jewish things. 
 His ambivalence is a bespectacled look at the long legs of the divisional commander, which were &bquo;like girls sheathed to the neck in shining riding-boots&equo;. 
 The image &mdash; summoned by a narrator whose exhausted dreams are filled with girls &mdash; is like nothing we would ever meet in the literal Levi. 
 But the literal Levi is a writer who has his own way of interesting himself in the contrasts which have been attributed to Babel. 
 Levi was interested in action, purpose, work, and capable of them: and the capacity may have been formed in contention with a desire to withdraw and perhaps to give up. 
 I think myself that this was the case, and that it scarcely makes him very different from many other hard-working people. 
 The desire can be surmised, without recourse to hindsight, in some of what he wrote, but is far from being the point of what he wrote. 
 Work is the supreme subject in Levi. 
 &bquo;We can and must fight to see that the fruit of labour remains in the hands of those who work, and that work does not turn into punishment.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps the most accessible form of freedom, the most subjectively enjoyed, and the most useful to human society, consists of being good at your job&hellip;&equo;. 
 These statements are from The Wrench , where Faussone is good at his job and Levi is good at getting this across. 
 There can be no doubt that he had an ear for what such people have to say for themselves. 
 Faussone talks about &bquo;the way we bent our elbows&equo; &mdash; an expression (for eating or drinking) which I have heard spoken in English, but which I had never before seen written down in a book. 
 Book-writers, Faussone says, produce works &bquo;which may be beautiful and all that, but, on the other hand, even if they were a bit defective, excuse the expression, nobody would die, and the only loser is the customer who bought them&equo;. 
 I have heard that before too, but not from any writer. 
 A builder friend of mine once talked to me about mistakes made by builders. 
 These mistakes mattered &mdash; whereas &bquo;in the arts it doesn't matter if you foul up.&equo;  
 Levi's double life as chemist and writer suggests that if art and work need to be separated, according to a certain sense of what it is to be a Jew, art and work are nevertheless very often the same. 
 I like to think that he would have accepted that art is work, that the work that frees us, and is not just &bquo;punishment&equo;, is art, and that anyone who uses his imagination is an artist. 
 The categorical difference of the modern world, between artists and others, does not come well out of his reports. 
 His chemistry is intriguing from this point of view. 
 Here was a second double life &mdash; that of a scientist who was also an artist, a chemist who was also an alchemist, a businessman who was also a magician. 
 He was as keen as mustard, and as Doctor Faustus. 
 The Periodic Table  reveals that the ancient magic of transmutation and alembics persisted in Levi's laboratory. 
 The book has fumes, stinks, bangs and fiascos. 
 There is more than a hint of the search for the philosopher's stone. 
 It takes its structure from a set of correspondences between elements and persons, and the old definition of temperament as a mixture of qualities is present to the reader's mind &mdash; the same definition that permits us to think of Faussone as a part of Levi, or as his alter ego. 
 Levi's paints actually manage to come to life as human beings in The Wrench , a less fanciful book which nevertheless claims that &bquo;paints resemble us more than they do bricks. 
 They're born, they grow old, and they die like us; and when they're old, they can turn foolish, and even when they're young, they can deceive you, and they're actually capable of telling lies, pretending to be what they aren't: to be sick when they're healthy, and healthy when they're sick.&equo; 
 The work that Levi valued is of an order to which Auschwitz &mdash; with the lying motto over its gates, Arbeit macht frei  &mdash; was built to be antithetical. 
 In the camps, work was imposed on the prisoners with the aim of exploiting and of destroying them. 
 It bore a hideous resemblance to the blighting, punishing sorts of work which are common in the world at large. 
 And yet there was a work of survival to be attempted in the camps. 
 Intelligence, vigilance, practicality, cunning, luck, friendship &mdash; Levi was crucially helped by donations from an Italian workman he barely knew, and by the exercise of his skills as a chemist &mdash; kept you going and, in some few cases, made you free. 
 But most of those who stayed alive were &bquo;prominents&equo;, or Kapos, prisoners  who were placed in authority, or members of the Special Squads who assisted with the killings. 
 One of the late pieces in The Drowned and the Saved  casts doubt on this work of survival: &bquo;the worst survived&equo;, he writes. 
 In 1946, a &bquo;religious friend&equo; told him that he, Levi, belonged to an elect: &bquo;I, the non-believer, and even less of a believer after the season of Auschwitz, was a person touched by Grace, a saved man.&equo; 
 The friend felt Levi had survived &bquo;so that I could bear witness&equo;. 
 Levi goes on to insist that the real witnesses are those who died in the camps, and that those prisoners who did not were mostly compromised people or privileged people: Solzhenitsyn is cited as making the same point about the pridurki  &mdash; the &bquo;prominents&equo; of the Gulag system. 
 The book is no sequel to If this is a man , but its explications are never without interest. 
 &bquo;In the Lager, colds and influenza were unknown, but one died, at times suddenly, from illnesses that the doctors never had an opportunity to study. 
 Gastric ulcers and mental illnesses were healed (or became asymptomatic) but everyone suffered from an unceasing discomfort that polluted sleep and was nameless.&equo; 
 There is a chapter which discusses the letters from Germans &mdash; &bquo;good Germans&equo; in the main &mdash; which were sent to him in response to his book about the camps. 
 An eager public woman appealed to him with the story of her cleaning woman, who had proved herself at fault. 
 The husband of the cleaning woman had been a soldier, and she had said that he had had no choice but to obey his orders to shoot Jews. 
 The correspondent explained: &bquo;I discharged her, stifling the temptation to congratulate her on her poor husband fallen in the war.&equo; 
 There is a &bquo;Middle Eastern&equo; recalcitrance here. 
 Another chapter, on the Kapos and the Special Squads, exhibits what must surely be judged an analytic understanding of the concentration-camp system set up by the Nazis &mdash; an understanding Eberstadt is inclined to deny him, believing that the camps are insufficiently construed in the Auschwitz book as an institutionalised anti-Semitism peculiar to Germany and politically-determined: she thinks it is soft of him to see them as belonging to a universal latent hostility to strangers. 
 The chapter exposes a factor of complicity, and regards it, one might think, as a German invention. 
 The Special Squads were the  Nazis' &bquo;most demonic crime&equo;, representing &bquo;an attempt to shift on to others &mdash; specifically the victims &mdash; the burden of guilt, so that they were deprived even of the solace of innocence&equo;. 
 He never forgave the Nazis; they were always his enemies. 
 This was not, however, &bquo;personal&equo;. 
 He is among the least ego-bound of book-writers, the least ego-bound of autobiographers, at all times able to look beyond himself and his community. 
 Two occasions in the book about his partisans quietly illustrate what he is for his readers in this respect. 
 In the partisan book Line has been Leonid's woman, and has gone with Mendel. 
 By then a &bquo;desperate man&equo;, Leonid is sent as such on a desperate mission, and is killed. 
 Who can be said to have killed him? 
 Mendel tells Line: &bquo;The two of us.&equo; 
 Not long afterwards, his attention fixed on the sufferings of those Poles who had caused their Jews to suffer, Mendel falls silent, thinking: &bquo;Not only us.&equo; 
 For Fernanda Eberstadt, Mendel is &bquo;a worrier afflicted with an ability to see his enemy's side of the question&equo;. 
 Those she doesn't like are &bquo;cursed&equo; or &bquo;afflicted&equo;. 
 There's religion in that. 
 Levi's statement to Philip Roth about If not now, when?  did not mention Babel, but it did mention another Isaac &mdash; the Yiddish writer, Bashevis Singer. 
 There is a story of Singer's &mdash; one of a collection, The Death of Methuselah , published in Britain in the autumn of 1988 &mdash; in which Levi, or a part or perception of Levi, is perhaps faintly distinguishable. 
 &bquo;The Jew from Babylon&equo; is an enthralling tale about a Jewish sorcerer, a believer in the faith, hated by demons and disapproved of by rabbis, who in old age endures a turmoil which ends his life. 
 Singer is a writer of standing in the matter of when, in what he sees as the &bquo;disappointing&equo; modern world, a Jew is not a Jew. 
 Modern Jews, he affirms, are greedy creatures, tormented by their too many opinions. 
 It could well be asked if his is an Orthodox fiction. 
 Is it that of a vicarious believer, if such a person is possible? 
 Is he an aesthete of the subject? 
 Everything he writes is Jewish in the sense that everything he writes is conscious of the Jewish faith, if that can be said without relinquishing the thought that there are such persons as unbelieving Jews. 
 But there is some instability in the accounts he gives of dark professions of faith, in his acerbities and fatalities. 
 In one of the new stories a &bquo;recluse&equo;, formerly a womaniser, says: &bquo;One step away from God and one is already in the dominion of Satan  and hell. 
 You don't believe me, eh?&equo; 
 Do we believe him? 
 Is this some Jewish joke? 
 Singer can, after all, be very funny. 
 His religion is as much as anything the regression to a past of obedience, disobedience, sin and doom. 
 Such things are celebrated in his stories with a richness and unction which might appear to make a renegade of Babel and certainly of Levi. 
 Singer's religion is also a feeling for the power of the community to censure and reject. 
 This power is apparent in the story of his sorcerer. 
 It is a story in which the case of Primo Levi, that of a dissident, gifted, magical, mustardly Jew, might at moments be thought to be implicated. 
 But then so might that of the writer of the story, who may be less obedient than the gentile reader immediately recognises. 
 The story celebrates both the sorcerer and his rejection. 
 We mourn his fall. 
 &bquo;In the morning they found him dead, face down on a bare spot, not far from the town. 
 His head was buried in the sand, hands and feet spread out, as if he had fallen from a great height.&equo;  
 Glasgow Hamlet 
 STUDYING the West Coast of Scotland from the yacht Britannia , the Queen is said to have remarked, not long ago, that the people there didn't seem to have much of a life. 
 James Kelman's stories make clear what life is like in Glasgow, and what James Kelman's life is like. 
 They are not going to change the royal mind. 
 This is the queen who was greeted, on a visit to a Scottish university, by the sight of a student emptying down his throat, at top speed, the contents of a bottle of alcohol. 
 One of Kelman's stories, &bquo;Greyhound for Breakfast&equo;, the last in the collection of that name which appeared in 1987, is, to my mind, a masterpiece. 
 It's about a fellow called Ronnie, who is on the dole. 
 His son has gone off to London, and he worries that he may lose touch with him. 
 He has dumped down the notes for a greyhound, has given his heart to the beast, and is derided for this by his friends in the pub. 
 He takes it for a walk &mdash; such walks have long been a ritual activity of the country's more optimistic male poor, the dog more expensively jacketed than the chap. 
 &bquo;It stopped for a piss. 
 Ronnie could have done with one himself but he would have got arrested.&equo; 
 Its withers will never win any of the races Ronnie had been telling himself about, and he is reluctant to return from this long, defeated, dark-thoughted walk to break the bad news or his adventure to his wife and daughters. 
 The story is wonderfully funny and depressing. 
 Ronnie, I think, could be held to be a precursor of P for Patrick Doyle in Kelman's novel of 1989, A Disaffection . 
 Both works end on a possible return, on what might look like a bleak diminuendo but is really an anxiety state. 
 There are important differences, though. 
 Kelman stands much closer to the new hero, and more is made of what happens in that hero's head. 
 The new book is funny and depressing at considerable length, and there are moments when a wee terror comes of its expanded universe. 
 A Disaffection  is a problematical book &mdash; because of this closeness: we learn very little about how Doyle is seen by companions, very little about the standpoint of those who surround  him, those with whom he has his tender and abrasive dealings, with whom he airs his invectives and bitter ironies, with whom he conducts his antagonisms and ingratiations. 
 It's almost all Doyle. 
 If this is a problem, however, it is one the novel shares with many of the novels we now read. 
 We are aware, in the novels we read, both of an authorial identification with the leading character or the first-person narrator, and of material that might constitute an authorial judgement in that respect: but we don't know what the verdict is. 
 A Disaffection  shares in that uncertainty, and in so doing acknowledges a connection with a certain whether-or-not that we meet with in the plays of Shakespeare. 
 Doyle &mdash; &bquo;Patrick&equo; to his author &mdash; is of the fantastic-depressive, angry-and-otherwise Scots-Irish clan. 
 He is a schoolteacher, 29 years old &mdash; the age of Christ at Calvary, whose name is often in his mouth, averse though he is to &bquo;deities&equo;, and perhaps of Hamlet, whose words enter the novel. 
 This Glasgow Hamlet is the latest in a long line of impersonations, and his soliloquies are  the novel he inhabits, or most of it. 
 Doyle's greyhound is a pair of electricians' pipes, which he lights upon, paints and plays, producing a doleful sound that soothes him &mdash; it is like mumbling your mantra or telling your beads. 
 He needs soothing. 
 He has passed into crisis. 
 He is lonely. 
 His aged parents bore him (&bquo;Are all parents boring?&equo;). 
 His brother Gavin frets him, and he has a longing for Gavin's wife, together with a more urgent one for a teacher at the school, Alison Houston, who could be felt to lead him on a bit but doesn't want to have a &bquo;relationship&equo; with him. 
 With Doyle it's &bquo;fucking&equo; this and &bquo;fucking&equo; that and the system this and the system that. 
 He is against &bquo;  Greatbritain &equo;, with its aristocratic capitalists, its MI5 and its MI6. 
 Society is a stench. 
 Shite is everywhere. 
 Crassness is everywhere. 
 He is a schlemiel of the subject. 
 In such a setting, he believes, his work as a teacher can only be betrayed. 
 His work as a teacher doesn't involve much in the way of teaching. 
 Homework is a thing of the past. 
 His classes are soliloquies and Socratic teases in which his interest in Classical Antiquity, in Pythagoras and Heraclitus, and in H&ouml;lderlin, Hegel and Marx, and in James Hogg, is imparted to the young ones. 
 He is the sort of Sixties dominie who used to inveigh in class against the system. 
 His relationship with the kids is one between equals, but they also seem to expect him to be a wise  man, and this is what he sometimes expects of himself. 
 The kids are presented as decent and thoughtful, and there's an Arcadian absence of the stress and violence which some might look for in a class where the teacher swears and free-associates, and throws up and bunks off into the bargain. 
 If the Queen's telescope had been able to reach into Patrick's classroom, there would have been a surprise in store for her &mdash; but not for Patrick, who at least affects to believe the story that Orwellian minders are peering at the punters from the screens of the punters' television sets. 
 Kelman makes Doyle charming, and it is impossible to read the book without gaining the sense of a fully-developed authorial fellow-feeling. 
 Not that Doyle isn't taxing and maddening too. 
 His consciousness delivers paranoid images of aggression and hostility. 
 He is against racism and sexism, but is capable of reflecting: &bquo;He was in love with Alison Houston. 
 And he wanted to grab a hold of her.&equo; 
 His crisis is precipitated by word of his transfer to another school; he staggers towards resigning from the school he's at, and maybe from the profession, and then bunks off for a long afternoon's superlager, home-brew and whisky with his brother, who is on the dole, and two of his brother's mates. 
 Eventually, stone-cold-sober-seeming but perhaps too drunk to drive, he treks off through the dubs of a drizzle (Thales said the world was made of water, the &bquo;primary element&equo;, and he handni even been to Glasgow) back to his bachelor's tenement flat (Coelebs still in search of a wife). 
 On the way, he is chased, or fancies he is chased, by Police who hate him. 
 Kelman projects Doyle's state of mind virtually without framing or critique. 
 The Queen will certainly need a glossary, but even then she may well be uncertain as to just how much Kelman likes his unlikely lad. 
 This kind of thing has been said about Hamlet, to whom, as I say, Kelman alludes, and more than alludes. 
 At one point, &bquo;all he sought was death&equo;; and the next paragraph has him aching to be &bquo;out of the road of trouble and strife and all things rotten and putrefied and shitey&equo;. 
 Later he reproves himself for an impulse to be rude to a &bquo;good auld guy&equo; encountered during his terminal search for a bus, and we think of the prating &bquo;good old man&equo; Polonius. 
 And on the facing page he breathes some more of Shakespeare's words: &bquo;To return to Gavin's or not. 
  Whether it is nobler.&equo; 
 Whether he is sober enough to go back and fetch his dilapidated car, or should soldier on, is the question here, or at any rate part of it. 
 Hamlet kills his good old guy, as it happens. 
 He makes mistakes and causes havoc, in pursuit of the right course. 
 So does Doyle. 
 A high point in the novel is the altercation and huff with Gavin and his mates which precedes this: about the long holidays teachers get, or don't get, about the homework they withhold, and about the rights of weans &mdash; children &mdash; and the rights of parents. 
 Patrick said: Do you know what I tell parents Arthur? 
 I tell them to go and fuck themselves. 
 Patrick held both hands up in a gesture of peace, he smiled for a moment; I'm no trying to get at you personally but I just fucking feel that you cant expect the teacher to be the everything, the heavyweight boxing champion of the world. 
 Arthur stared at him. 
 Know what I mean, I'm just being honest with ye. 
 I  dont  think ye should expect the teacher to do everything. 
 If you want your weans to get homework then give it to them your tucking self. 
 Gavin said: That actually sounds quite right-wing ye know. 
 Well it's meant to be the fucking opposite and it is the fucking opposite. 
 Gavin nodded. 
 Then: 
 Gavin gazed at him, then laughed briefly. 
 He looked at Pat but Pat looked away. 
 Nor was Pat going to say anything further because he was fucking off home as soon as he swallowed what he had lying. 
 There was no point sitting here yapping to a bunch of fucking prejudiced right-wing bastards. 
 And Gavin turned on him once more: What d'you mean ye deny ye get long holidays? 
 I deny I get long holidays, that's what I mean. 
 Back it up. 
 What d'you mean back it up? 
 Show me what you're talking about? 
 Naw. 
 You show me what you're talking about. 
 I think I know what Paddy means, said Davie. 
 Good, tell me, replied Gavin. 
 I think I know what you mean Paddy. 
 Pat nodded. 
 Ye  dont  think ye get long holidays because when you're off from  the school you're still doing other things connected with it, making up timetables and all that. 
 Patrick nodded. 
 By the end of it you're no all that sure whether teachers get long holidays or no (they do, though most of them have to work hard for it), and whether parents should go and fuck themselves. 
 Soon after this we learn that Doyle thinks he has sold his rights by serving the system as a teacher for &bquo;a large wheen of pennies&equo;: &bquo;He was an article that was corrupt&hellip; corruptio optimi pessima&hellip;&equo;. 
 This, as he recognises, is a form of self-praise. 
 Throughout, Patrick is both the &bquo;King of the World&equo; that he wants to be &mdash; Glasgow belongs to him &mdash; and an abject sinner. 
 The rage of the novel's males can sometimes be made to appear the rage of those who believe themselves permanently beaten and cheated. 
 The women are the vessels of a better spirit; the injury to them is greater, and it is their own men who are responsible for some of that injury. 
 Patrick rages and scorns in proportion to his frustration: Hamlet's &bquo;weakness&equo; has its counterpart here. 
 &bquo;Patrick couldni find a pen. 
 It is most odd indeed how objects disappear in rooms wherein the only moveable entity is oneself.&equo; 
 (He slides into English here for a laugh.) 
 Objects disappear, and for a man of 29 he seems to have grabbed hold of very little of anything except a glass and a book. 
 Drink figures in the novel, in precisely rendered scenes, as a bastion of the culture which is also a slow death. 
 And yet this man is very far from useless. 
 What we are reading is the Book of Patrick Doyle. 
 Whether or not it can be seen as Kelman's self-portrait, it is the portrait of an artist. 
 The shortest stories in Greyhound for Breakfast  owe a lot to Kafka's briefer parables, though they are apt to be more difficult to understand; and there can be no doubt that Beckett's solipsistic tramps have left an impression on the earlier writings. 
 These influences, however, would appear to have receded, or to have been digested. 
 The speech of Glasgow people is the big thing in the novel. 
 This is a good Scots which is at once distinctly literary and faithful to the speech of the city. 
 The deferred &bquo;but&equo; as in &bquo;There again but&equo; is a particular pleasure. 
 There are many such verbatim effects, and indeed the oral dimension of the novel is very important. 
 This can be reckoned to contain the  succession of anecdotes that occurs and the fine detail of working-class life that is provided. 
 Doyle, for instance, thinks to himself a Scottish thought: &bquo;Would his grandparents ever have had sexual activity in the parlour?&equo; 
 Elsewhere, &bquo;he put a teaspoonful-and-a-half of coffee granules into his mug and exactly the same into hers.&equo; 
 The measure expresses a mean between saving and lashing-out, and it has remained a feature of my own Scots-Irish domestic economy which I would bet is widespread in northern parts. 
 There is good Scots, too, in The Book of Sandy Stewart , which contrasts poignantly with the Book of Patrick Doyle. 
 Stewart is a traveller, one of the people of the road &mdash; among them, tinkers, pipers and folk-singers &mdash; in whom an oral culture has survived to the present day. 
 Here, too, there is an antiquity to be aware of. 
 The book is a succession of anecdotes carefully transcribed in fidelity to his broad Scots, and largely concerned with the long-since of his early days. 
 A story that would appeal to Kelman concerns some killer donkeys. 
 One of these creatures once slew a butler whose toff gear had proved a red rag &mdash; quite a smack, this, at the system. 
 This gentleman bocht the donkey fae MacGreigor &mdash; it was afore my day though &mdash; an it wes two or three days in the field at the front door. 
 This day the butler went oot tae gie it a piece an it tore him doon wae its feets an mooth. 
 They say that it wes the different claes that done it &mdash; the way the butler dressed &mdash; an it hed looked at the claes an taen a bad wey o the claes. 
 It hed run intae him an tore him at yinst. 
 An they say the butler wes gaithert up intae a white sheet aff the field. 
 Kelman's work forms part of a flowering of talent which has come about in the urban Scotland of the last few years. 
 These books and plays and films reveal a humanity which surmounts, as has been said, the hardship and brutality they describe &mdash; surmounts it, as a rule, by laughing at it. 
 The Glasgow they evoke is a very hard and a very lively place. 
 And yet Stewart's small wandering world could well be thought the richer of the two environments. 
 He seldom responds to matters of personality, or individual psychology, is hardly ever in the least &bquo;inward&equo;; much depends on the turn of the tale. 
 They are tales, moreover, which don't do all that much to summon the nostalgic reader. 
 They don't direct us to the late survival of a gypsy  paradise. 
 Nevertheless, they contain persuasive evidence to indicate that there was more for his people to do, and talk about, that there was more fun, than there is now in some parts of urban Scotland. 
 Less persuasively, a people which has had to defend itself against an enduring hostility is shown, for the most part, as free from fear, and, in particular, from the fear that exceeds and mistakes its objects. 
 Those under threat in the cities have not always been so lucky. 
 But then the travellers, too, may not have been quite as lucky as Stewart, in his old age, can sometimes suggest. 
 I remember these nomads myself, from a long while ago in Scotland. 
 I remember dark, solemn and suspicious looks, as a travelling family was given tea in the back-garden of a house in the country. 
 I peered at them round the end of the house. 
 They could not be let into it, but there was a duty to entertain them, and, as I was told, not to stare. 
 They were like spirits, and I loved them.  
 So you want to be an Actor? 
 Everyone who wants to act professionally should try to see as much drama as they possibly can &mdash; and this means in the broadest sense, watching television, cinema, visiting the theatre and looking at the actor's work carefully and analytically. 
 It is also important that you try and evaluate the dramatic  experience of these different forms of presentation &mdash; this is worthwhile, because it will make you think about the different ways in which an actor can work and the various ways in which his skills are used. 
 Clearly, there is a difference in scale and dimension between the stage, the television screen and the cinema screen, which demand changes in direction and in acting technique. 
 One of the things you will notice when watching the television is that close-ups are used very effectively, and so it is of vital importance that the actor has absolute control over his/her face and expression. 
 You should also look at the ways in which the physical movements of the actor are organised to suit the restraints of the small screen. 
 When we turn to the theatre the question of scale is also significant. 
 The theatre is &bquo;larger than life&equo;, not in terms of physical scale, but because movements and speech are comparatively emphatic and intense, even when a play simulates everyday natural surroundings. 
 Some people find this makes theatre less &bquo;believable&equo; &mdash; less true to their own experience and therefore less convincing than the more restrained performances seen on television and cinema. 
 Theatre invites you to give your full attention to what is happening on stage &mdash; the theatrical experience is a very concentrated one and you as a member of the audience are vitally connected to what is going on. 
 As part of the audience you are as much a part of the entertainment as the performance itself, and this is something that dramatists are aware of and have always written for. 
 Sometimes you will be directly addressed by the characters &mdash; this is something which happened a great deal in Greek and Elizabethan theatre (for example, look at the speech by Chorus in Act 4, scene 1 of Henry V , which draws the audience into the atmosphere before a battle enormously effectively). 
 It is also used as a dramatic device by many contemporary playwrights.  
 The film is a very distinct dramatic medium. 
 As you become interested in film acting it is likely that you will also become interested in film making, for the actor's work depends so much on the technical decisions of the director and editor. 
 A film is made up of a series of shots that may be photographed over various periods of time; a &bquo;take&equo; that may have originally started out as three or four minutes in length may eventually be edited to a ten second shot. 
 The film is therefore built up in pieces, a process which makes particular demands of an actor &mdash; who is also vulnerable to technical problems with cameras, lighting and editing in a way which is quite removed from the stage actor's experience. 
 All in all, it's more difficult to evaluate an actor's work on screen, particularly as actors are usually cast in a film for their total credibility in a role and the camera work is such an intrinsic part of the final effect. 
 So, what can you learn from looking so closely at the actor on stage, TV and cinema? 
 In the first place you will start to think about how an actor's work differs according to the demands of the medium. 
 And you will become aware of technical skills &mdash; noticing economy of effect and style, seeing and hearing how an actor interprets a script, and how his thinking comes across in a performance. 
 Of course, if an actor is doing his/her work well, you will have to work really hard to notice all these things &mdash; for the effect will be seamless. 
 Reading 
 It's very important that you read widely, both novels and playscripts, and don't just confine yourself to an exam syllabus. 
 After all, an actor's life is spent working with words, and it will be valuable for you to have a reasonable background in the English literary and dramatic traditions. 
 Novels have been a rich source of material for the film industry since the talkies were introduced, and it's very interesting to see how both classic and contemporary novels require skilled adaptation of the dialogue to make sufficient dramatic impact in a film. 
 As you read you will probably be aware of a character's potential as a role for the actor &mdash; particularly with those who have already an established place in theatrical tradition (Dickens is full of such characters). 
 Reading plays is an essential part of your career preparation &mdash; the more plays you read the more you will understand of the  theatre's development. 
 Academic study of drama as such is not necessarily useful for the actor, but an awareness of playwrights and their various styles is  of practical value. 
 A play is primary a piece of action and although a script contains some scenic and character description, the essential interest lies in the dialogue and the action arising from it. 
 A play really demands to be read aloud -it needs the sound of the human voice to bring it alive. 
 It takes imagination and a lot of practice to read a play to yourself in the same time as it would take to see it on the stage. 
 Surprisingly, this is true of both the classical and modern play, though you might expect that the obscurities and difficulties of words and expression would prove more of a stumbling block in, say, Shakespeare or Ben Jonson. 
 Here is a suggested first reading list, which I've put together to provide a broadly representative selection of significant periods in the theatre's development. 
 There is a danger in reading the classics, in that they can come to be regarded simply as literature &mdash; so always try to look at them as plays for performance  &mdash; and, it goes without saying, try to see as much theatre as you can. 
 It's worthwhile reading some pre-Shakespearean drama; you could read Everyman , a great morality play of the late Middle Ages, and Gammer Gurton's Needle , first performed in 1566 and thought to be the second oldest English comedy. 
 You should try to read as much as you can of the great Elizabethan and Jacobean dramatists; Shakespeare, Marlowe and Ben Jonson, Beaumont and Fletcher, Tourneur, Webster, Middleton. 
 Shakespeare's A Midsummer Night's Dream  and Hamlet  would be a good starting point &mdash; As You Like It, Twelfth Night  and Julius Caesar  you may already be familiar with, as they are often set for O level courses. 
 Marlowe's Dr Faustus  and Ben Jonson's Volpone  and The Alchemist  are frequently revived. 
 You might well enjoy Beaumont and Fletcher's rumbustious The Knight of the Burning Pestle &mdash; The Maid's Tragedy  is a good choice, too. 
 The Jacobean dramatists created a world of passion and violence &bquo;vividly theatrical. 
 Two of the best plays to read from this period are Tourneur's The Revenger's Tragedy , and Webster's The White Devil . 
 Theatres were closed during the Cromwellian period, but with the restoration of the monarchy in 1660 came Court comedy and the beginning of the &bquo;comedy of manners&equo; which has, in one way or another, been popular right up to the present day. 
 William Congreve's Love for Love  and The Way of the World  are highly  decorated in language, and sharp in wit; to compare with these, you could look at William Wycherley's more &bquo;basic&equo; comedy, The Country Wife . 
 Perhaps the most &bquo;modern&equo; of the Restoration writers is George Farquhar; period artifice is not so obtrusive in his plays, the best known of which are The Recruiting Officer  and The Beaux Stratagem . 
 It would also be a good idea to read something by the French dramatist, Moli&egrave;re, their great contemporary, who satirises the hypocrisies of cultivated society; I recommend Tartuffe  about a religious imposter and La Malade Imaginaire , a satire on the medical profession. 
 Sheridan and Goldsmith continued to write comedies of manners during the eighteenth century &bquo;with their famous plays The Rivals  and She Stoops to Conquer , and this tradition finds its most successful twentieth-century exponents in Noel Coward and Somerset Maugham; Private Lives  and The Circle  are frequently revived by present day repertory companies. 
 Have a look at these. 
 The nineteenth century was, by and large, an unexciting time for theatre writing, until the end of the century when Oscar Wilde and George Bernard Shaw make their entry. 
 Wilde's The Importance of Being Earnest  is a must  and of the large Shavian canon I suggest you read St Joan  and The Doctor's Dilemma  or Major Barbara  to get a clear idea of his style and the kind of demands he makes of actors verbally. 
 The most vital explosion of British theatre writing since the Second World War came with the foundation of the English Stage Company at the Royal Court Theatre in London, under the direction of George Devine: the first season mounted there included John Osborne's Look Back in Anger . 
 Arnold Wesker's famous trilogy of plays Chicken Soup with Barley, Roots  and I'm Talking About Jerusalem  was also performed at the Royal Court. 
 You should be aware of this period and I recommend reading all four plays and also The Theatre of George Devine  by Irving Wardle. 
 Harold Pinter occupies a unique place in contemporary theatre as a distinctive stylist, and I suggest you read some of his early short plays like The Room  and The Dumb Waiter  before going on to his major plays like The Birthday Party  and The Caretaker . 
 Two of the most outstanding of recent playwrights are David Hare and Tom Stoppard, and I have included extracts from their work in the audition piece selections, p 31. 
 I recommend that you read Hare's trilogy The History Plays , which include Knuckle, Licking Hitler  and Plenty  &mdash; and perhaps his earlier play Teeth 'n' Smiles . 
 Stoppard's  most popular play is probably still Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead , and he has had notable success with Jumpers, Travesties , and, more recently, The Real Thing . 
 Two other contemporary writers whose work was first performed by the English Stage Company are Nigel Williams, author of Sugar n' Spice  and Paul Kember, author of Not Quite Jerusalem  (which has recently been filmed). 
 It's worth reading these two plays. 
 And you should also read Steven Berkoff, a high stylist and writer of abrasive poetic theatre, who stands quite alone. 
 Look at East, Greek  and Decadence . 
 I haven't yet mentioned the development of the Theatre of the Absurd, which has been a strong force in European drama since Alfred Jarry's Ubu Roi  was first performed in 1896. 
 Read Ubu , and you can see the connections with Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot , and Ionesco's The Chairs  and The Bald Prima Donna . 
 Martin Esslin's book The Theatre of the Absurd  is a very valuable background on this subject. 
 Of the British playwrights, Pinter is often thought to be on the edges of &bquo;absurdism&equo; and you could also read N.F. Simpson's One Way Pendulum  and Cresta Run . 
 All of these recommendations, however, are only to give you a first taste of the scope of theatrical writing. 
 You should read as much as you can of European and American drama, both historical and contemporary, for by doing so you will certainly set yourself up well for both drama school training and your subsequent acting career.   
 Approach to drama training 
 One of the questions you may be asking yourself is &bquo;Can I be taught to act?&equo; 
 This is something everyone wonders when starting out, even if they are not intending to make a living out of acting. 
 The answer is, of course, no. 
 No-one can actually teach  anyone to act. 
 That has something to do with the indefinable thing called talent. 
 You either have it or you do not &mdash; talent is certainly not something which can be taught. 
 But talent can be developed and trained and provide a sound basis for you to give of the best there is inside you. 
 So at this moment it's as well to look at your present experience and see how you can help yourself to extend it, before applying to audition at a drama school. 
 First training opportunities 
 Your local amateur society is always a good beginning. 
 Being nervous and taking risks are two of the main things you will have to face as an aspiring actor, and that first time you read a play with a group of strangers, rather than in a classroom or among friends is when you confront your first hurdle. 
 But you may not actually learn  much, simply because the main object of the group will not be to help you but to get on and do the play, relying on the skills available and hoping that the audience will give adequate support. 
 So what else can you do? 
 In recent years the amateur actor has had more opportunity for classes in theatre work, including voice and movement training as well as performance and directing skills. 
 These facilities differ in all parts of the world, but in Britain the evening class is probably the most accessible form of training. 
 London is obviously where most of the opportunities abound. 
 Notable here are the courses offered during both day and evening by the City Literary Institute. 
 Classes at the &bquo;City Lit&equo;, as it is affectionately known, are handled by a highly competent team of tutors, many of whom teach at the drama schools too. 
 There are classes in movement, dance, acting and improvisation, as well as more specialist areas like mime, clowning, and playwriting. 
 The classes are on certain days of the  week only, but enrolment is not expensive given that a term is structured over the usual academic year. 
 The term can be approximately twelve to thirteen weeks long, and advanced classes will in all probability do a production over that time which will be mounted and produced in the Institute's own theatre. 
 Such an exercise might even spread over two or three terms. 
 What should you do if you don't live in London, and find that it is financially difficult to pay for such courses? 
 The best way to find out about what is available to you more locally is to contact your County Drama Adviser and also the Regional Arts Association for your area, who will have details about part-time training for young actors (see Appendix A). 
 Amateur theatre flourishes almost everywhere, and when you're beginning it cannot be stressed too strongly that it is desirable to obtain some actual stage experience before jumping into the big pool of drama school, or even summer school. 
 Once again, the Regional Arts Association will know the leading amateur companies in your area, and this should certainly help you in looking for the kind of group to which you are best suited. 
 The British Theatre Association, mentioned in the first edition of this book, has for decades offered professional and all-embracing training courses for actors, directors, and young people. 
 It is currently, in 1990, fighting for its life. 
 Due to lack of governmental or any other official support this unique and valuable organisation has had to suspend its training activities temporarily, whilst trying to secure for itself a sound and permanent financial basis for the future. 
 It is hoped that courses on a limited basis may restart in the Autumn of 1990. 
 Meanwhile, the BTA is still the custodian of the finest theatre library in Europe. 
 It would be a tragic loss to theatre if such an important organisation were to go to the wall. 
 It's been the cradle and help of many actors, directors and playwrights. 
 The summer school 
 The summer schools or workshops offered by the drama schools last approximately five weeks, and give a clear idea of what full-time drama training involves. 
 And one of the main advantages of these very compressed and arduous courses is that they give students approaching drama school entry an opportunity of seeing what will be required of them should they gain a place at drama school.  
 The workshops run daily from 9.30 a.m. to 5.00 p.m. 
 (Monday to Friday), giving a taste of the kind of stamina that will ultimately be required over a much longer period. 
 (At drama school the full-time course will frequently require the student to work until 9 p.m. and later when productions are being mounted.) 
 Because summer schools generate enormous interest overseas, there is nearly always a strong emphasis on the classical theatre, usually on Shakespeare, and there will quite probably be classes on classical texts and mini-production exercises arising from these. 
 You may find yourself doing quite a bit of &bquo;line learning&equo;. 
 The daily schedule can be something like this: 
 9 a.m. 
 Movement/dance 
 10 a.m. 
 Voice/Speech class where students try out their own interpretations 
 Noon 
 Improvisation 
 1 p.m. 
 Lunch 
 2 p.m. 
 Make-up class 
 3 p.m. 
 Rehearsal of course project 
 5.30 p.m. 
 End of classes for the day 
 The five weeks is structured to provide a fairly comprehensive picture of actor training though even so it can only provide an outline of classes at drama school. 
 There is not much time for academic work, though some courses include lectures on theatre history. 
 Some of the courses include a limited number of visits to the theatre, and discussion of these productions will be included in the overall schedule. 
 But acting and all that it means is very much a doing thing, so the emphasis is always on practical work. 
 Anyone can participate in summer schools, as no auditions are required, only completion of an application form. 
 But often students attending do  have previous experience, either in the amateur theatre &bquo;or in university or school productions. 
 On the whole there is no real age limit, and the level of experience can be very mixed. 
 Classes are led by experienced staff, usually by staff at the drama school where the course is held, and at the end of the five weeks groups will present mini-production projects to each other, on which they will be assessed, and they will usually be given a certificate for having attended the course. 
 In some cases students wishing to take an open audition for the full-time  course may do so without paying the usual audition fee. 
 The cost of training at a summer school over a five-week period will vary with the different establishments, but the overall fee is likely to be around &pound;700 (1990 prices), for all students, whether from Britain or overseas. 
 For details about applying to summer schools, see Appendix C on p 134.  
 Going to drama school 
 Vocational training for the actor as we know it has only existed in England for the last eighty years. 
 The starting point was the formation by Sir Herbert Tree of a training school at His Majesty's Theatre, London, in 1904. 
 The school later moved to Gower St, was granted a royal patent, and eventually became the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art. 
 Eighty years doesn't seem a very long time when you consider the art of acting has been prospering in Europe over the last four hundred or so years, quite apart from the great traditions of ancient Greek drama. 
 But it is certainly true that in the last sixty years the various schools and academies of acting have had a significant effect on the climate of acting. 
 It's significant, too, that while Herbert Tree was laying the foundations of drama training in England, the famous partnership of Stanislavsky and Danchenko in Russia was beginning, and saw the first developments towards the establishment of the Moscow Arts Theatre. 
 Stanislavsky's ideas on acting became central to modern drama training, and many of the most interesting and powerful concepts in actor training developed from his work. 
 Choosing your course 
 Most people applying to drama school will be seeking to enrol on the full-time diploma course, which usually runs over a three-year period. 
 The average age of entry for the diploma course is between 18 and 20, though some schools accept entrants as young as 17, others students up to 30: age between these limits is not likely to be a problem provided the candidate shows talent, flexibility and motivation. 
 Some schools offer a two-year course for students who have more experience, particularly those from overseas. 
 Two-year course students may be a little older, and have already studied drama at university level. 
 A limited number of schools offer post-graduate courses which are scheduled over one year. 
 LAMDA (London Academy of Music and Drama) runs a one-year course for overseas students only, which although not set up as a post-graduate course may include a  number of students with extensive university theatre experience as well as some professional experience. 
 Drama Studio London also runs a one-year course for post-graduate students or in some cases students with other professional skills or theatrical experience. 
 Obviously, sorting out the courses which are on offer can best be done by writing for the prospectus but with any application the question that will be of overriding importance is how you are going to finance your training. 
 Payment of fees and grants 
 Fees set by each drama school do differ slightly, though they can be considered basically similar. 
 In general, it's wise to think of each term's tuition fees as costing from &pound;1300 to &pound;1600 (prices current in 1989/90). 
 Expect a general rise in fees of some 7&ndash;9% for the academic year starting September 1990. 
 For an eight-term diploma course the total cost will be around &pound;11&ndash;12000. 
 These fees are quite distinct from the money you will need for living, travelling, buying books, etc., which will probably account for a further &pound;3500 to &pound;5000 (these figures are based on 1989/90 standards). 
 Three-year and two-year diploma students should bear these figure in mind so they have some idea of what is going to be involved when they make an application for a further education grant to their local authority. 
 Application for a grant should be made at the same time as the application for an audition in order that you can be sure of your position should you be fortunate enough to be offered a place. 
 It is true that some local authorities will not say whether you are eligible or not until a place has been put on offer to you, but it's still very much worth your while to find out all you can from your local education authority. 
 Discretionary grants for further education have suffered in the climate of recent economic cuts and local government spending allowances can affect the number and level of grants awarded. 
 Generally, a local authority will aim to cover the full cost of fees and a living allowance &bquo;although this can be subject to your personal circumstances and will vary depending on whether you will live with your parents during term time, or in rented accommodation. 
 It is possible that your local authority may ask you to audition for them after you have been offered a place. 
 This seems an odd  way of going about things, but the advising panels do carry a professional adviser so that talent is not merely being judged by local civil servants. 
 The object of this rather clumsy piece of administration is to place some check on the expenditure of local money on the arts &mdash; and also to provide a further checkpoint on students who have already received educational grants for other careers. 
 Having worked on interview panels with the now defunct ILEA I can say that the object has not been to block the drama school selection so much as to see that the grant is well justified. 
 Scholarships are an entirely different matter. 
 Some schools do provide for students to be granted a scholarship towards the cost of tuition, but there are not many endowments of this kind. 
 RADA offers two to three scholarships per year for UK students, Webber Douglas offers two, RSAMD offer a small number of scholarships and Guildford School of Acting offers one to an acting student, for fees only. 
 LAMDA have a small number of awards &bquo;some of which can give financial assistance. 
 Two scholarships are available for American students at RADA, which provide the total fee, or, according to parental income, part of it. 
 Drama schools in Britain 
 There are seventeen drama schools in Britain which constitute the &bquo;Conference of Drama Schools&equo; and most of these have courses which have been accredited by the National Council for Drama Training. 
 This means they have been inspected by a team of professional experts and the standard of their work has been approved. 
 Drama training is under constant review through the accreditation system, so that standards are maintained and new developments assessed, and schools which may not be in the accredited list today may well be there soon. 
 Any potential student will naturally wish to see what is offered by the different drama schools and a concise summary of the aims and policies of the seventeen main schools can be found in Appendix B on p 119. 
 There are, of course, many schools other than those listed in the appendix, and also a great many private coaches, all of whom may be found in the publication Contacts , a trade book everyone interested in joining the profession should obtain from the office of The Spotlight , 42&ndash;43 Cranbourn St,  London WC2H 7AP. 
 In the 1984 edition a further one hundred and thirty-four addresses were listed, which includes ballet schools, mime tuition courses, and others. 
 There are still those who prefer to take their chances in the profession without any formal training. 
 This used to be a lot easier to do than it is now: for one thing, working in the profession means that you have to belong to the actors' union, Equity. 
 Yet students who have completed expensive training face the same difficulties as an untrained actor in qualifying for an Equity card. 
 This question is discussed later in the book, but it is still relevant to the potential drama student. 
 Becoming an actor has to be thought of in realistic terms right from the beginning and all possible problems do need to be faced. 
 The post-graduate course 
 The post-graduate course is not offered by all drama schools, and places are therefore limited. 
 As far as grants are concerned, students who apply for a place are almost certain to have used at least three years' worth of their local authority grant entitlement while studying at university or polytechnic, and may only be eligible for a further one-year entitlement if they have been accepted at a drama school. 
 And it has been said that local authorities are not always very sympathetic to acting as a choice of career and sometimes obtaining a grant may be more difficult if a student has evidently changed his or her career tack. 
 The case of a physics teacher who wanted to become an actor is interesting in showing the kind of problems which accompany a late entry into drama school. 
 The local authority to which he applied refused to provide the necessary grant, and the person was sadly compelled to turn down a place on a one-year post-graduate course which had already been offered to him. 
 The grounds were that he had used up his grant entitlement in qualifying to be a teacher. 
 The three or four terms offered to post-graduate students condense the technical work of a three-year course; on the whole there is greater emphasis on training the voice, movement, acting technique, fencing and dance, etc. since students will presumably have developed a fair amount of performing skill through their university drama departments or societies. 
 This means that there is usually only one &bquo;show-case&equo; production at the end of the year for  agent and production managements to see. 
 The one-year course is only to lay down the foundations of good technical training &mdash; and it is widely recognised that the course simply pushes the student into the profession with enough practical experience to find his or her feet. 
 There is an optional second year which students can apply for which &bquo;joins up&equo; with the two-year diploma course. 
 Students don't automatically proceed to this &mdash; it depends on the talent of the individual concerned, and of course it means that an extra year's funds have to be found. 
 There is really no way of knowing how long it takes to develop an actor who has already gained a lot from work in university. 
 University acting can be very good and technically aware, or it can be immensely self-indulgent and over-academic, full of theory and sparse on craft. 
 That is why the post-graduate course exists &mdash; to shape intellect and enthusiasm and provide practical and professional skills. 
 The overseas student 
 All major drama schools audition in the USA, and offer places to students who can show talent and raise the money to accept a place. 
 This is one field of higher education where in some cases the fees from the overseas student are no higher than they are for British nationals. 
 In all cases students taking a course (which is usually either a two-year diploma course or a one-year course) are expected to return to their country on completion of training. 
 Students can also apply from any part of the world, and audition in the UK, but need to remember that a high standard of fluency in the English language will be expected. 
 There will always be problems when working with an English vernacular text using cockney or other dialects, but students from overseas have to expect to take this in their stride (and usually do). 
 Undoubtedly one of the best ways the overseas student has of seeing what is required in British theatre training is to apply for one of the summer schools offered by the drama schools, and find out what it's all about before committing him- or herself to a long and expensive stay. 
 It's important that a student is prepared to understand and work with the prevalent theatrical traditions in UK schools. 
 And with so much theatre training available in the United States, New Zealand, Australia and Canada, it is interesting to ask why  British theatre training is thought to be so beneficial. 
 I can only put it down to the strong classical emphasis which prevails in the courses offered in the UK, although many of the university drama courses in the USA do stage Shakespeare and the European classical authors. 
 America has had many unsuccessful attempts to form a national repertory theatre, performing the classics of the English language, and one wonders whether it will ever be possible to get this going effectively. 
 It's often thought that previous attempts have failed because there aren't enough well-trained classical actors in the USA to make such a repertory company feasible, but this is increasingly not the case: American drama students are eager to train in the UK, and the percentage of successful auditions held is relatively high. 
 In Great Britain the ear becomes accustomed to the native British voice handling the classical text, but this really should not hinder American actors; they need not become totally &bquo;accentless&equo; in order to play classical verse. 
 Instead they need to find out the rhythms of speech which make the music of the verse work in dramatic form. 
 Many American students working in British drama schools find the answer to this question by using what is called &bquo;standard American&equo;, and this approach is being used now in training on both sides of the Atlantic.  
 The drama school audition 
 By now you will have made a definite decision to become an actor &mdash; no matter what the problems or obstacles. 
 The next step is to prepare for the audition at a drama school and find the right kind of textual material which will allow you to show the best of yourself. 
 On obtaining a prospectus and asking for an application form, you will find that every drama school will require an audition fee, and this can vary between &pound;15 and &pound;25. 
 If you can afford to, it's generally best to spread your auditions around the drama schools so that you are seen more than once. 
 When auditioning for most schools you will be asked to present at least two contrasting speeches and possibly give some idea of your attitude to improvisation and, perhaps, to singing. 
 It's usual to make a choice from the classical and modern repertoire. 
 Some schools will stipulate a number of Shakespearean speeches from which you may select, but in the main the choice of work is left entirely to you. 
 Your choice of material 
 A lot will depend on your current theatre experience and whether you have done much acting, but finding the right kind of character to work in an audition is going to mean some careful thinking and planning. 
 Always think what the chosen piece is doing for you  &mdash; after all, the audition is about you, the naked ape, as well as that inner spark of inspiration you may have. 
 Your  bones, your  eyes, your  hair, your  teeth are all going to be scrutinised by a panel of judges who are looking for your all-round potential, not just an impressive academic display. 
 Acting is very much a physical business. 
 Remember that there may be some twelve to eighteen places at any one of the drama schools, and the number of auditions may number up to fifteen hundred for the leading schools. 
 Don't be daunted by that, but recognise that like everything else in the acting business, it is highly competitive. 
 No drama school panel is looking for the ultimate in audition technique but candidates  should possess a noticeable degree of competence and self-awareness. 
 Not all auditions have just two speeches, classical and modern. 
 You may well be asked to sing something unaccompanied, or do a short improvisation and you may well be asked to perform one of the speeches in a different way. 
 In some schools you will be asked to participate with other students in basic class work over a weekend (as happens at the Bristol Old Vic drama school) and in some you may find yourself being judged partly by senior students of the school who will be sitting with the faculty panel (which is something that happens at Drama Centre). 
 The point of preparation is to be well tuned and at the same time flexible to new interpretations and ideas. 
 Rigidity of approach is something to be avoided at all costs &mdash; there is no point in being able to do a &bquo;party piece&equo; one way and be unable to take in new direction on the same material. 
 Everyone on the audition panel is prepared to be on your side and supportive. 
 They are not looking for you to fail &mdash; every audition panel wants you to be good. 
 That's why there are contrasting pieces; not everyone is going to be marvellous with the classics (Rex Harrison once avowed that he was &bquo;no good at Tudor verse speaking&equo;). 
 But you are expected to be competent with such material even if you feel this is not what you would eventually choose to work with. 
 The classical text is for the panel to see your present abilities, your imaginative range and your capacity as a thinking actor. 
 And while you are not expected to be perfect (who is, ever?) you are expected to have something to offer. 
 The classical audition 
 Shakespeare is the most widely known and read of the classical playwrights and it is for this reason that a piece from one of his plays is nearly always obligatory at a drama school audition. 
 This is not simply to force people into speaking blank verse, but to see how a person responds to the essential humanity of a character &mdash; for Shakespeare, of all the classical writers, is probably the most human, whose work is blessed with both grandeur and the common touch. 
 The plays are full of characters that soliloquise &mdash; that is, speak solo without other characters around them, thinking aloud about their aims, their problems, their ambitions, loves and hatreds. 
  These soliloquies occupy a unique area of dramatic speech (although the solo aria is something modern dramatists are now using more frequently). 
 There are a host of audition pieces to be derived from the soliloquies and monologues, many of which are well tried favourites, and almost any selection will be reasonably well known. 
 But when you are looking for a suitable speech you can't really reject anything familiar solely because you think it might bore the panel. 
 It's true that extracts such as Phoebe's &bquo;Think not that I love him&hellip;&equo; from As You Like It  (Act 3, Scene 5) or Viola's &bquo;1 left no ring with her&hellip;&equo; from Twelfth Night  (Act 2, Scene 2) may be all too well known to a panel, but I cannot agree with an adjudication policy that would ban these pieces from the audition. 
 The selection is right if it truly works for the competing student, and it is the quality and force of the imagination that will carry off the performance of the piece. 
 The most important thing is your firm knowledge that the selection is within your present range. 
 It's not much use arriving somewhere at ten in the morning clutching the collected works under your arm and wishing you had a wig and been born thirty years earlier in order to play Lear &mdash; or for that matter the Duke of Gloucester. 
 Major roles for older women are not so common in Shakespeare, but I think it is better not to choose a character such as Queen Katherine from Henry VIII , who needs a richness of seniority to convey the dramatic interest. 
 If you do want to portray an older figure, it would be preferable to try Hermione in The Winter's Tale  &mdash; she is a more fantastical character, without the added complications of historical authenticity, and so allows for greater flexibility of characterisation. 
 Her trial scene (Act 3, Scene 2) which begins 
 Since what I am to say must be but that Which contradicts my accusation&hellip; 
 is a familiar but effective choice. 
 In Shakespeare there are many young men to choose from. 
 Romeo is a good choice, and there are many speeches to look over and consider, but think also about the not so familiar young lover Troilus; Bassanio, Lorenzo and Graziano, from the Merchant of Venice  all make good choices too. 
 And of course there is Petruchio, lively in humour and making a confidante of his listeners. 
 All of them have speeches that are rich in passion, character and intensity, which can sustain the actor in solo flight. 
 The point is that they are  all vital young men with love on their minds, full of colourful words to express their feelings, and all are within the range of the eighteen to twenty-five year old student actor. 
 And then there are the tougher types: Edmund from King Lear , a romantic macho figure with a wide eye for fame and fortune. 
 You might also think about that other bastard son, Philip, in King John , a merry, pranking, politically astute fellow, with a wry, salty style. 
 He has a famous eulogy on status: 
 A foot of honour better than I was 
 But many a foot of land the worse&hellip; 
 Act 1, Scene 1 
 Much in the same vein is Henry V  who has several well known &bquo;set&equo; speeches, full of fireworks, as well as the difficult and testing soliloquy on the responsibility of leadership that begins &bquo;Upon the King&hellip; 
 &equo; (Act 4, Scene 2). 
 This is a major meditative speech brooding on the loneliness of the man caught between action and passivity &mdash; thinking aloud in much the same way as Hamlet does in his many renowned arias on the soul and the theme of revenge. 
 And remember there is no need to be afraid of Hamlet. 
 He is, after all, an actor's part and perfectly accessible &mdash; he prefers, too, to be acted rather than to be read. 
 Years of scholarship and so many contentious performances mean that the character is now regarded as &bquo;difficult&equo;, when it can in fact benefit from the freshness and vitality of the natural actor, who will quickly find the comic qualities of the man as well as his serious side. 
 Ophelia is often ignored for audition material simply because she doesn't seem to have much in the way of a sustained speech until she goes mad. 
 Yet her earlier speech, where she describes Hamlet's condition and behaviour, has great tenderness and awareness: 
 He took me by the wrist, and held me hard, 
 Then goes he to the length of all his arm, 
 And, with his other hand thus o'er his brow, 
 He falls to such perusal of my face 
 As he would draw it&hellip; 
 Act 2, Scene 1 
 The speech is short but very telling and can be effective in a solo audition, even though the actual scene does involve other characters. 
 The question of selection is very personal; after all, what makes  you choose the character that you are going to do? 
 There must be some affinity between you and the man or woman on the printed page &mdash; something that you recognise not because you are &bquo;just like that&equo; but because you feel that you can interpret the situation with those words. 
 Let us look at Romeo and Juliet . 
 One thing you can be sure of is that the panel will know the words of these characters very well (they will probably be able to prompt you at any given moment should you &bquo;dry&equo;) but each and every time the lines are spoken by a new voice they are different in their texture, humour, drama and music. 
 Bernard Shaw once described Romeo and Juliet  as &bquo;the impetuous march of music&equo;, and if ever there was a play of rich language, this is it. 
 The music of the words is there to be used &mdash; but not at the expense of the sense and emotional content. 
 Although every moment of the lovers' experience is drenched in imagery, there is still a fine feeling of reality about the characters which gives them bone and muscle. 
 Yet it is not the reality of a naturalistic drama, such as we would find in, say, Ibsen or Chekhov. 
 We cannot explain the motivations of Romeo in terms of today's values, but we can bring a contemporary handling to the words that will make the imagery blaze afresh each time it is spoken. 
 You will find the speeches scattered like jewels throughout the text, but it is perhaps as well to keep to the simpler ones for your audition piece &mdash; those where Romeo and Juliet are directly enthralled by love and the declaration of love to another person. 
 These are better than the poison-taking and tomb scenes. 
 In any case, keep your chosen speech short and contained, for it is better to end when those auditioning would have you continue. 
 Brevity truly is the soul of wit. 
 Reading around for background to Shakespeare is valuable, and you can't do better than begin with the Harley Granville Barker's Prefaces to Shakespeare , which analyse the plays from both a scholarly and dramatic angle, without being ponderously academic. 
 John Barton's Playing Shakespeare  is a fine follow-up. 
 Barton does investigate the actor's work in a more contemporary way and the book is based on the TV series of the same name. 
 The modern audition 
 Selections from the modern theatre may include characters that have been created over the last sixty years, from Noel Coward to  Steven Berkoff. 
 Which is a very big range. 
 Interestingly, though, most of the audition selections are chosen from work of the last twenty years; most young students will go for contemporary work. 
 Therefore the pieces that have been put together in the following pages as possible audition selections are from writers who have gained, or are now gaining, a major place in contemporary theatre. 
 In my suggested audition pieces, I have not included any of the well known speeches from such modern classics as Look Back in Anger , by John Osborne, or Roots, by Arnold Wesker although these plays are revived frequently in many theatres. 
 Neither have I suggested anything from Noel Coward, Somerset Maugham or Terence Rattigan, even though their plays are continually being performed. 
 The technique required in presenting characters from these plays is usually more delicate than can be achieved in a first audition, whereas the work of Tom Stoppard, David Hare and Barry Keefe (for example) is more easily grasped by the young actor. 
 Finding characters for yourself will, 1 think, depend a good deal on your personal taste in theatre at the time you are auditioning. 
 And your choice of audition piece is often largely decided by the contrast it provides with the classical selection you have made. 
 The question of accent is important too &mdash; you need to be confident of the accent with which you are working, and it is always advisable to present an accent you are familiar with or at least can work with comfortably. 
 The first piece of advice that's necessary is that you shouldn't just try to be fashionable by choosing juicy speeches that catch your eye without knowing the whole play and having a working idea of how to perform the speech. 
 And don't let your search for material lead you to choose the obscure for obscurity's sake, so you feel you will be sure to stun the panel with a piece that has no good professional background. 
 Similarly, extracts from Agatha Christie or general run of the mill commercial theatre very rarely have enough substance on which you can work. 
 A piece to be presented should have something more than a surface narrative quality in the characterisation. 
 Writers such as C. P. Taylor, David Halliwell, Peter Nicols, Caryl Churchill and Louise Page have a great deal to offer. 
 But there are many more, of course, and listing playwrights is useful only insofar as it presents a few guidelines, primarily to help you look in the right places. 
 There are also many opportunities for audition pieces in the American repertoire. 
 Arthur's Miller's plays such as All My Sons   and Death of a Salesman  are now regarded as virtual classics, and so are Tennessee William's Cat on a Hot Tin Roof , The Glass Menagerie  and A Streetcar Named Desire . 
 American theatre is well known and well regarded here, and to choose a piece from any of those just mentioned is thoroughly viable. 
 Sam Shepard and Edward Albee are also good choices, and there are interesting selections to be made from the play of the book One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest , by Dale Wasserman. 
 One of the most electric and abrasive of contemporary dramatists is Steven Berkoff, who uses big classical rhythms in his work, which calls for the sustaining power of &bquo;total&equo; theatre, rather than naturalistic treatment. 
 Berkoff demands high technical skill, but is wide open to raw interpretations, and as such offers a lot to the auditioning student. 
 If you try him I suggest you select from Greek  or East  rather than, say, the more recent Decadence : the latter play contains enormous speeches, usually much longer than you will need, and is fearfully difficult material to cut. 
 Berkoff makes particular demands on the actor. 
 There are no character notes of any kind in the text, which is written as a complex rhyming scheme that looks like prose at first glance. 
 He sets up long, colourful and emotional speeches that are in turn both funny, beautiful and violent, and his work cannot be compared with anything that has preceded him. 
 Finding a style in these parts without having seen a production of the play can be a problem, but as with absurd drama, there is a lot of room for personal interpretation. 
 Few auditions seem to be chosen from the works of Samuel Beckett &mdash; Waiting for Godot  and Endgame  are the only two which seem to offer possibilities. 
 On the other hand, Harold Pinter's characters Mick and Aston from The Caretaker  are familiar, and both of them are still young and exciting enough to make good choices. 
 Remember that anything which excites and interests you is a possibility and the greater the contrast with your first classical choice, the better you will enable the panel to see your present range. 
 Coaching and presentation 
 You will now perhaps be wondering whether or not you should be coached for your audition. 
 Coaching can be a great help &mdash; but it can also get in the way, for slavishly following a pedantic  teacher can produce very strange results, with the candidate ending up trying to sound like someone he or she isn't. 
 Your natural ability is the thing that should emerge, and if you have been well coached the coaching won't show. 
 If you have been badly coached it will show everywhere. 
 So it's another of those difficult personal decisions. 
 Choose your coach with care; be sure that they know what they are doing for the theatre and actor of today. 
 There are plenty of good coaches about just as there are a multitude of nice misguided types who seek to portray themselves through other people over and over again. 
 You are the actor on show at your audition &mdash; no-one is interested in auditioning your coach. 
 Valuable coaching can often come from drama school tutors who can give a fair assessment of the possibilities you may have prior to auditioning. 
 A list of such tutors is contained in Contacts  (address is given on p 17). 
 It can be well worth the additional expense of some private tuition for the audition and gaining one to one advice on your material. 
 Your own presentation is another thing you need to be aware of. 
 Clothes are important &mdash; you should wear something which enhances your own self esteem and creates the right kind of impression. 
 This is sometimes regarded as old fashioned thinking, unfortunately, and it's a shame, for although clothes don't actually make you perform better a good comfortable appearance does give the panel a chance to see how you see yourself and how your body uses clothes. 
 When presenting a classical and a modern piece women may use a practice skirt for one selection which can be used over jeans, or another skirt. 
 Men may wish to use a jacket for one piece and only a sweater for the other. 
 And props; what do you do about them at your audition? 
 Well, anything that can be carried and produced without a lot of fuss is permissable &mdash; pipes, cigarettes, mirrors, handbags, fans, matches, etc. 
 But the less elaborate you can be the better. 
 Try to think of the essentials, as any good coach will tell you. 
 For example, if you are embarking on Julia in Two Gentlemen of Verona  and her Proteus letter, it is as well to have a sheet of paper that you can tear up to make the scene start with a dramatic focus and give the lines some action. 
 Learning thoroughly the piece which you are going to do is important. 
 Auditions are  nerve-wracking for everyone who does them (and for that matter, for everyone who watches them) but  being sure of your text is the least you can do. 
 Should that unthinkable thing happen, and you forget your lines, don't despair. 
 A sympathetic panel may well ask you to start again. 
 But there is no trick to the business of learning lines, as you will find out as you go on &mdash; although learning lines for an audition is different from memorising a part in a play for production, because then you will be operating with other actors around you. 
 On the whole, acting in isolation is a peculiar feature of the audition system, which is why the pieces you choose in either the classic or modern text need to be reasonably well contained and lend themselves to being performed as a one man show. 
 If you have done any class work before attempting the drama school audition, most of the teachers will at some point in their sessions have talked about &bquo;relaxation&equo;. 
 A lot has to do with how you breathe and how you react physically to moments of tension. 
 You will be tense at the audition because a lot is at stake, but if you trust to your own natural resources, the degree of panic can be reduced. 
 I would suggest that if you are sure of your pieces, don't read them over and over again on the way to the audition &mdash; once will be quite enough. 
 Nerves afflict everyone in some way, and without them acting would be the poorer. 
 The dead calm actor is, on the whole, dead boring. 
 Stage nerves are unlike anything else in the whole world, and many good actors will confess to them right through their careers. 
 Stage fright is something else &mdash; but it is usually self-induced and can be overcome, finally, with much rehearsal practice. 
 When dealing with nerves, the most important single thing is to have a centre of concentration. 
 Concentration has nothing to do with gritting your teeth and braving it out; it's the secret of being more and more relaxed and aware of everything that is going on at the same time. 
 You will not only be sure of the text, but, more than this, of the character you are portraying. 
 With well written characters the words fit and flow so that the actor can ride with ease, and the thoughts, no matter how disjointed, have a natural quality that is at once &bquo;actable&equo;. 
 No-one can hope to have a command of all these things at a first audition. 
 But they are guidelines to what acting is basically about.   
 Audition selections 
 Here is a selection of speeches for both men and women that may be recommended for auditions at drama schools. 
 It can't be stressed enough that you should know the entire play from which you select your audition piece; not only that, but have thought carefully about the characters and their inter-relationship. 
 The classical text 
 Romeo and Juliet by William Shakespeare. 
 Mercutio is in high spirits, teasing Romeo about his love as they prepare to go to the Capulet masked ball. 
 He speaks to both Romeo and others around him, about dreams and dreamers. 
 MERCUTIO 
 O then I see Queen Mab hath been with you. 
 She is the fairies' midwife, and she comes 
 In shape no bigger than an agate stone 
 On the forefinger of an alderman 
 Drawn with a team of little atomi 
 Over men's noses as they lie asleep. 
 Her chariot is an empty hazelnut 
 Made by the joiner squirrel or old grub, 
 Time out o' mind the fain-es' coachmakers; 
 Her waggon-spokes made of long spinners' legs, 
 The cover of the wings of grasshoppers, 
 Her traces of the smallest spider web, 
 Her collars of the moonshine's watery beams, 
 Her whip of cricket's bone, the lash of film, 
 Her waggoner a small grey-coated gnat, 
 Not half so big as a round little worm 
 Prick'd from the lazy finger of a maid; 
 And in this state she gallops night by night 
 Through lovers' brains, and then they dream of love; 
 O'er courtiers' knees, that dream on curtsies straight; 
 O'er lawyers' fingers who straight dream on fees; 
 O'er ladies' lips, who straight on kisses dream, 
 Which oft the angry Mab with blisters plagues 
 Because their breaths with sweetmeats tainted are.  
 Sometime she gallops o'er a courtier's nose 
 And then dreams he of smelling out a suit; 
 And sometime comes she with a tithe-pig's tail, 
 Tickling a parson's nose as a lies asleep; 
 Then dreams he of another benefice. 
 Sometime she driveth o'er a soldier's neck 
 And then dreams he of cutting foreign throats, 
 Of breaches, ambuscados, Spanish blades, 
 Of healths five fathom deep; and then anon 
 Drums in his ear, at which he starts and wakes, 
 And being thus frighted swears a prayer or two 
 And sleeps again. 
 This is that very Mab 
 Act 1, Scene 4 
 Comment 
 This is a very well known piece, which needs vivacity and spontaneity in presentation; Mercutio is enjoying himself, weaving his way through a fantastical set of images. 
 The problem lies in sustaining the speech, for Mercutio is a hearty and boisterous character, seemingly at odds with the mischief and delicacy of this speech. 
 Would such a man talk of fairies like this? 
 Yet he obviously loves taunting Romeo about the &bquo;sickness&equo; of love. 
 King John by William Shakespeare 
 Philip the Bastard, half brother to Robert Faulconbridge, and son of King Richard the First, discovers himself in a position of authority when King John knights him and dubs him Sir Richard Plantagenet. 
 Left to his own reflections, he reveals himself to be a bright, keen opportunist. 
 BASTARD 
 Brother, adieu: good fortune come to thee! 
 For thou wast got i'the way of honesty.  
 A foot of honour better than I was, 
 But many a many foot of land the worse. 
 Well, now can I make any Joan a lady. 
 &bquo;Good den, Sir Richard!&equo; &mdash; &bquo;God-a-mercy, fellow!&equo; &mdash; 
 And if his name be George, I'll call him Peter; 
 &bquo;Tis too respective and too sociable 
 For your conversion. 
 Now your traveller,  
 He and his toothpick at my worship's mess, 
 And when my knightly stomach is suffic'd, 
 Why then I suck my teeth, and catechize 
 My picked man of countries: &bquo;My dear sir,&equo; &mdash; 
 Thus, leaning on mine elbow, I begin, 
 I shall beseech you,&equo; &mdash; that is Question now; 
 And then comes Answer like an Absey book: 
 &bquo;O sir,&equo; says Answer, &bquo;at your best command; 
 At your employment; at your service, sir:&equo; 
 &bquo;No, sir,&equo; says Question, &bquo;I, sweet sir, at yours;&equo; 
 And so, ere Answer knows what Question would, 
 Saving in dialogue of compliment, 
 And talking of the Alps and Apennines, 
 It draws toward supper in conclusion so. 
 But this is worshipful society, 
 And fits the mounting spirit like myself; 
 For he is but a bastard to the time 
 That doth not smack of observation; 
 And so am I, whether I smoke or no. 
 And not alone in habit and device, 
 Exterior form, outward accoutrement, 
 But from the inward motion to deliver 
 Sweet, sweet, sweet poison for the age's tooth: 
 Which, though I will not practise to deceive, 
 Yet, to avoid deceit, I mean to learn; 
 For it shall strew the footsteps of my rising. 
 But who comes in such haste in riding-robes? 
 What woman-post is this! 
 Hath she no husband 
 That will take pains to blow a horn before her? 
 O me! &bquo;tis my mother. 
 How now, good lady? 
 What brings you here to court so hastily? 
 Exeunt all but the bastard 
 Act 1, Scene 1 
 Comment 
 The character talks freely about himself, and what he hopes to gain from his new rank. 
 The jokes and the conversations end abruptly with &bquo;But this is worshipful society&equo; and at that point he shows his real toughness and ambition. 
 The piece needs to be taken at a good pace and in high spirits.  
 The Merchant of Veniceby William Shakespeare 
 Lorenzo with his Jessica await the return of Portia, remaining out in the still night rather than returning to the house. 
 LORENZO 
 Sweet soullet's in, and there expect their coming. 
 And yet no matter: why should we go in? 
 My friend Stephano, signify (I pray you) 
 Within the house, your mistress is at hand, 
 And bring your music forth into the air.  
 How sweet the moonlight sleeps upon this bank! 
 Here will we sit, and let the sounds of music 
 Creep in our ears &mdash; soft stillness and the night 
 Become the touches of sweet harmony: 
 Sit Jessica, -look how the floor of heaven 
 Is thick inlaid with patens of bright gold, 
 There's not the smallest orb which thou behold'st 
 But in his motion like an angel sings, 
 Still quiring to the young-ey'd cherubins; 
 Such harmony is in immortal souls, 
 But whilst this muddy vesture of decay 
 Doth grossly close it in, we cannot hear it:&hellip; 
 For do but note a wild and wanton herd 
 Or race of youthful and unhandled colts 
 Fetching mad bounds, bellowing and neighing loud, 
 Which is the hot condition of their blood, &mdash; 
 If they but hear perchance a trumpet sound, 
 Or any air of music touch their ears, 
 You shall perceive them make a mutual stand, 
 Their savage eyes turn'd to a modest gaze, 
 By the sweet power of music: therefore the poet 
 Did feign that Orpheus drew trees, stones and floods; 
 Since naught so stockish, hard and full of rage, 
 But music for the time doth change his nature, &mdash; 
 The man that hath no music in himself, 
 Nor is not moved with concord of sweet sounds, 
 Is fit for treasons, stratagems, and spoils; 
 The motions of his spirit are dull as night, 
 And his affections dark as Erebus: 
 Let no such man be trusted: &mdash; mark the music. 
 Exit Stephano 
 Act 5, Scene 1 
 Comment 
 This extract is made up of two consecutive speeches to Jessica; either  speech can be played for an audition, but if you have the time to do them both together the extract works well. 
 Remember that this is an intimate scene with Jessica, and you should identify her clearly throughout. 
 Allow the freshness of the thoughts to dominate, letting one idea lead into another. 
 Love's LaboursLost by William Shakespeare 
 Berowne confesses to his love for Rosaline, with a good deal of witty, self mockery. 
 BEROWNE 
 O! and I forsooth in love! 
 I, that have been love's whip; 
 A very beadle to a humorous sigh; 
 A critic, nay, a night-watch constable, 
 A domineering pedant o'er the boy, 
 Than whom no mortal so magnificent! 
 This wimpled, whining, purblind, wayward boy, 
 This senior-junior, giant-dwarf, dan Cupid; 
 Regent of love rhymes, lord of folded arms, 
 The anointed sovereign of sighs and groans, 
 Liege of all loiterers and malcontents, 
 Dread prince of plackets, king of codpieces, 
 Sole imperator and great general 
 Of trotting paritors: O my little heart! 
 And I to be a corporal of his field, 
 And wear his colours like a tumbler's hoop! 
 What! 
 I love! 
 I sue! 
 I seek a wife! 
 A woman that is like a German clock, 
 Still a-repairing, ever out of frame, 
 And never going aright, being a watch, 
 But being watch'd that it may still go right! 
 Nay to be perjur'd, which is worst of all; 
 And among three, to love the worst of all; 
 A whitely wanton with a velvet brow, 
 With two pitch-balls stuck in her face for eyes; 
 Ay and by heaven, one that will do the deed 
 Though Argus were her eunuch and her guard: 
 And I to sigh for her! to watch for her! 
 To pray for her! 
 Go to; it is a plague 
 That Cupid will impose for my neglect 
 Of his almighty dreadful little might.  
 Well, I will love, write, sigh, pray, sue, and groan: 
 Some men must love my lady, and some Joan. 
 Act 3, Scene 1 
 Comment 
 Berowne almost seems to revel in his own discomfiture here, in his desperate last stand for freedom -he clearly enjoys the sensation of falling in love, even though he presents the experience as a disaster! 
 Invite the audience to listen to your dilemma, and keep the pace quick, for there is nothing solemn about Berowne. 
 Titus Andronicusby William Shakespeare 
 Aaron is a Moorish soldier of fortune, who with his mistress, Tamora, has been captured by the Romans in their war against the Goths. 
 AARON 
 Now climbeth Tamora Olympus' top, 
 Safe out of fortune's shot, and sits aloft, 
 Secure of thunder's crack or lightning flash, 
 Advanc'd above pale envy's threat'ning reach. 
 As when the golden sun salutes the morn, 
 And, having gilt the ocean with his beams, 
 Gallops the Zodiac in his glistering coach, 
 And overlooks the highest-peering hills; 
 So Tamora. 
 Upon her wit doth earthly honour wait, 
 And virtue stoops and trembles at her frown. 
 Then, Aaron, arm thy heart, and fit thy thoughts, 
 To mount aloft with thy imperial mistress, 
 And mount her pitch whom thou in triumph long 
 Hast prisoner held, fett'red in amorous chains, 
 And faster bound to Aaron's charming eyes 
 Than is Prometheus bound to Caucasus. 
 Away with slavish weeds and servile thoughts! 
 I will be bright, and shine in pearl and gold, 
 To wait upon this new-made empress. 
 To wait, said I? to wanton with this queen, 
 This goddess, this Semiramis, this nymph, 
 This siren that will charm Rome's Saturnine, 
 And see his shipwrack and his commonweal's. 
 Holla! what storm is this? 
 Comment 
 This is one of the great roles for a black actor (not that black actors in these days are not eligible to play practically any character in Shakespeare, with the exception of Desdemona!). 
 Aaron, lover of Tamora, has been brought to Rome a captive, then freed. 
 He is relishing his future. 
 He is a witty, ruthless adventurer: a strange and exotic outsider in Rome, and a villain on the grand scale. 
 To scan, Semiramis should be pronounced SeMIRamis not SEMiramis. 
 Love's Labours Lostby William Shakespeare 
 Rosaline chides Berowne, and taxes him with certain conditions he must fulfil if he is to gain her hand (the Princess and her ladies have responded to the death of the King of France by postponing any further romance for one year). 
 ROSALINE 
 Oft have I heard of you, my Lord Berowne, 
 Before I saw you, and the world's large tongue 
 Proclaims you for a man replete with mocks; 
 full of comparisons and wounding flouts, 
 Which you on all estates will execute 
 That lie within the mercy of your wit: 
 To weed this wormwood from your fruitful brain, 
 And there withal to win me, if you please, 
 Without the which I am not to be won, 
 You shall this twelve month term from day to day, 
 Visit the speechless sick, and still converse 
 With groaning wretches; and your task shall be, 
 With all the fierce endeavour of your wit 
 To enforce the pained impotent to smile. 
 BEROWNE 
 To move wild laughter 
 LORENZO 
 in the throat of death? 
 It cannot be; it is impossible: 
 Mirth cannot move a soul in agony. 
 ROSALINE 
 Why, that's the way to choke a gibing spirit, 
 Whose influence is begot of that loose grace 
 Which shallow laughing hearers give to fools. 
 A jest's prosperity lies in the ear 
 Of him that hears it, never in the tongue 
 Of him that makes it: then, if sickly ears,  
 Deaf'd with the clamours of their own dear groans, 
 Will hear your idle scorns, continue then, 
 And I will have you and that fault withal; 
 But if they will not, throw away that spirit, 
 And I shall find you empty of that fault, 
 Right joyful of your reformation. 
 Act 5, Scene 2 
 Comment 
 It's important to pick the right vocal note for Rosaline, as her wit and sexuality need to be put across here. 
 Rosaline is very much a match for Berowne; this is her last challenge to him, at a moment in the play when death has blown all comedy away. 
 Her challenge is, in itself, almost cruelly witty, and Rosaline must be seen to relish the situation, rather than becoming priggish. 
 Essentially, what she wants is for Berowne to discover what is serious in life, and to stop fooling all the time. 
 Measure for Measureby William Shakespeare 
 Isabella has visited Angelo to plead for her brother's life. 
 Angelo offers her a bargain: if she will sleep with him her brother shall live. 
 This speech is her shocked reaction to Angelo's &bquo;proposal&equo;. 
 ISABELLA 
 To whom should I complain? 
 Did I tell this, 
 Who would believe me? 
 O perilous mouths, 
 That bear in them one and the self-same tongue 
 Either of condemnation or approof, 
 Bidding the law make curtsey to their will, 
 Hooking both right and wrong to th' appetite, 
 To follow as it draws! 
 I'll to my brother. 
 Though he hath fall'n by prompture of the blood, 
 Yet hath he in him such a mind of honour, 
 That had he twenty heads to tender down 
 On twenty bloody blocks, he'd yield them up 
 Before his sister should her body stoop 
 To such abhorr'd pollution. 
 Then, Isabel live chaste, and brother, die: 
 More than our brother is our chastity. 
 I'll tell him yet of Angelo's request, 
 And fit his mind to death, for his soul's rest. 
 Act 2, Scene 4 
 Comment 
 Isabella can very easily come across as a prig. 
 Her virtue is so important to her that she can more easily contemplate her brother sacrificing his life to save her virginity than that she might sacrifice herself for him. 
 Isabella perceives clearly the game Angelo is playing: here she is angry and frustrated &mdash; don't try and make her too &bquo;nice&equo; a character. 
 Two Gentlemen of Verona by William Shakespeare 
 Julia with a letter in her hand, speaks first to Lucetta. 
 Some lines previous to the main speech have been incorporated here. 
 JULIA 
 This babble shall not henceforth trouble me. 
 Here is a coil with protestation.  
 Go, get you gone; and let the papers lie. 
 You would be fing'ring them, to anger me.  
 Nay, would I were so anger'd with the same! 
 O hateful hands, to tear such loving words; 
 Injurious wasps, to feed on such sweet honey, 
 And kill the bees that yield it, with your stings! 
 I'll kiss each several paper, for amends. 
 Look, here is writ &bquo;kind Julia&equo;: &mdash; unkind Julia! 
 As in revenge of thy ingratitude, 
 I throw thy name against the bruising stones, 
 Trampling contemptuously on thy disdain. 
 And here is writ &bquo;love-wounded Proteus&equo;. 
 Poor wounded name: my bosom, as a bed, 
 Shall lodge thee till thy wound be thoroughly heal'd; 
 And thus I search it with a sovereign kiss. 
 But twice, or thrice, was &bquo;Proteus&equo; written down: 
 Be calm, good wind, blow not a word away, 
 Till I have found each letter, in the letter, 
 Except mine own name: that some whirlwind bear 
 Unto a ragged, fearful, hanging rock, 
 And throw it thence into the raging sea. 
 Lo, here in one line is his name twice writ: 
 &bquo;Poor forlorn Proteus&equo;, &bquo;passionate Proteus&equo;. 
 &bquo;To the sweet Julia&equo;: that I'll tear away. 
 And yet I will not, sith so prettily 
 He couples it to his complaining names.  
 Thus will I fold them, one upon another: 
 Now kiss, embrace, contend, do what you will. 
 She tears the letter. 
 Lucetta leaves 
 Act 1, Scene 2 
 Comment 
 The essential qualities of this character are her impulsiveness and her youthful alertness. 
 How far does she commit herself to Proteus, and does she really criticise herself? 
 Think out your actions so that they enhance the text. 
 As You Like It by William Shakespeare 
 Rosalind, disguised as a young man (Ganymede) speaks to Phoebe, who clearly considers her to be an attractive male. 
 Rosalind comments shrewdly upon her own sex in her admonishment of Phoebe. 
 ROSALIND 
 And why I pray you? 
 Who might be your mother, 
 That you insult, exult, and all at once, 
 Over the wretched? 
 What though you have no beauty &mdash; 
 As by my faith I see no more in you 
 Than without candle may go dark to bed &mdash; 
 Must you be therefore proud and pitiless? 
 Why what means this? 
 Why do you look on me? 
 I see no more in you than in the ordinary 
 Of Nature's sale-work. 
 &bquo;Od's my little life, 
 I think she means to tangle my eyes too! 
 No faith proud mistress, hope not after it. 
 &bquo;Tis not your inky brows, your black silk hair, 
 Your bugle eyeballs, nor your cheek of cream, 
 That can entame my spirits to your worship. 
 You foolish shepherd, wherefore do you follow her 
 Like foggy South puffing with wind and rain? 
 You are a thousand times a properer man 
 Than she a woman. 
 &bquo;Tis such fools as you 
 That makes the world full of ill-favour'd children. 
 'TIS not her glass but you that flatters her, 
 And out of you she sees herself more proper 
 Than any of her lineaments can show her. 
 But mistress, know yourself, down on your knees, 
 And thank heaven, fasting, for a good man's love; 
 For I must tell you friendly in your ear,  
 Sell when you can, you are not for all markets. 
 Cry the man mercy, love him, take his offer; 
 Foul is most foul, being foul to be scoffer. 
 So take her to thee shepherd. 
 Fare you well. 
 Act 3, Scene 5 
 Comment 
 A very well known audition piece, but nonetheless valid for all that. 
 Don't, on any account, go for a heavy-handed male impersonation here &mdash; Rosalind is an intelligent woman, with a sense of humour, and she is enjoying herself responding to Phoebe's rather obvious games. 
 A Midsummer Night's Dream by William Shakespeare 
 TITANIA 
 These are the forgeries of jealousy: 
 And never, since the middle summer's spring, 
 Met we on hill, in dale, forest or mead, 
 By paved fountain, or by rushy brook, 
 Or in the beached margent of the sea, 
 To dance our ringlets to the whistling wind, 
 But with thy brawls thou hast disturb'd our sport. 
 Therefore the winds, piping to us in vain, 
 As in revenge have suck'd up from the sea 
 Contagious fogs; which, falling in the land, 
 Hath every pelting river made so proud 
 That they have overborne their continents. 
 The ox hath therefore stretch'd his yoke in vain. 
 The ploughman lost his sweat, and the green corn 
 Hath rotted ere his youth attain'd a beard; 
 The fold stands empty in the drowned field, 
 And crows are fatted with the murrion flock; 
 The nine-men's-morris is fill'd up with mud, 
 And the quaint mazes in the wanton green 
 For lack of tread are undistinguishable. 
 The human mortals want their winter cheer: 
 No night is now with hymn or carol blest. 
 Therefore the moon, the governess of floods, 
 Pale in her anger, washes all the air, 
 That rheumatic diseases do abound. 
 And thorough this distemperature we see 
 The seasons alter: hoary-headed frosts  
 Fall in the fresh lap of the crimson rose; 
 And on old Hiems' thin and icy crown, 
 An odorous chaplet of sweet summer buds 
 Is, as in mockery, set; the spring, the summer, 
 The childing autumn, angry winter, change 
 Their wonted liveries; and the mazed world, 
 By their increase, now knows not which is which. 
 And this same progeny of evils comes 
 From our debate, from our dissension; 
 We are their parents and original. 
 Act 2, Scene 1 
 Comment 
 The piece includes a great deal of descriptive colour; only try it if you feel you can bring something of your own imagination to it, and be prepared to risk some indulgence. 
 Keep Titania tough, springy and challenging: this speech is an accusation, and the expression of her grievance against Oberon. 
 The Beaux' Stratagem by George Farquhar 
 Mrs Sullen is a young gentlewoman, living in the country much against her will, and chafing against marriage to a drunken brute. 
 MRS SULLEN 
 Country Pleasures! 
 Racks and Torments! dost think, Child, that my Limbs were made for leaping of Ditches, and clambring over Stiles; or that my Parents wisely foreseeing my future Happiness in Country-pleasures, had early instructed me in the rural Accomplishments of drinking fat Ale, playing at Whisk, and smoaking Tobacco with my Husband; or of spreading of Plaisters, brewing of Diet-drinks, and stilling Rosemary-Water with the good old Gentlewoman, my Mother-in-Law&hellip;. 
 Not that I disapprove rural Pleasures, as the Poets have painted them; in their Landschape every Phillis has her Coridon, every murmuring Stream, and every flowry Mead gives fresh Alarms to Love. 
 &mdash; Besides, you'll find, that their Couples were never marry'd: &mdash; But yonder I see my Coridon, and a sweet Swain it is Heaven knows; &mdash; Come, Dorinda, don't be angry, he's my Husband, and your Brother; and between us both is he not a sad Brute?  
 O Sister, Sister! if ever you marry, beware of a sullen, silent Sot, one that's always musing, but never thinks: &mdash; There's some Diversion in a talking Blockhead: and since a Woman must wear Chains, I wou'd have the Pleasure of hearing 'em rattle a little. 
 &mdash; Now you shall see, but take this by the way &mdash; He came home this Morning at his usual Hour of Four, waken'd me out of a sweet Dream of something else, by tumbling over the Tea-table, which he broke all to pieces, after his Man and he had rowl'd about the Room like sick Passengers in a Storm, he comes flounce into Bed, dead as a Salmon into a Fishmonger's Basket; his Feet cold as Ice, his Breath hot as a Furnace, and his hands and Face as greasy as his Flanel Night-cap. &mdash; O Matrimony! 
 He tosses up the Clothes with a barbarous swing over his Shoulders, disorders the whole Economy of my Bed, leaves me half naked, and my whole Night's Comfort is the tuneable Serenade of that wakeful Nightingale, his Nose. 
 &mdash; O the Pleasure of counting melancholly Clock by a snoring Husband! &mdash; But now, Sister, you shall see how handsomely, being a well-bred Man, he will beg my Pardon. 
 Comment 
 Mrs Sullen is anything but sullen. 
 She describes the horrors of matrimony with vivacious comic indignation, dazzling wit and choice of expression, and with breathtaking eloquence. 
 She is young and pretty, and filters her fury through irresistible humour. 
 She is not bitter, cynical, languid, or camp. 
 I've left the original spelling and orthography to give a feel of the vigour of the language. 
 It must be one of the funniest speeches ever written for an actress, and needs a bubbly, light touch. 
 Not for the novice, but still worth attempting. 
 The Relapse or Virtue in Danger  by John Vanbrugh 
 Lord Foppington arrives at the London house of Loveless and Amanda. 
 Foppington recently &bquo;bought&equo; his peerage; he was formerly known as &bquo;Sir Novelty Fashion&equo;, and he speaks with gusto and effrontery, his speech deliberately affected, turning his &bquo;o&equo; s to &bquo;a&equo; s.  
 FOPPINGTON 
 Far to mind the inside of a book, is to entertain one's self with the products of another man's brain. 
 Naw I think a man of quality and breeding may be much better diverted with the natural sprauts of his own. 
 But to say the truth, madam, let a man love reading never so well, when once he comes to know this tawn, he finds so many better ways of passing the four-and-twenty hours, that 'twere ten thousand pities he should consume his time in that. 
 Far example, madam, my life; my life, madam is a perpetual stream of pleasure, that glides through such a variety of entertainments, I believe the wisest of our ancestors never had the least conception of any of 'em. 
 I rise, madam, about ten a-clock. 
 I don't rise sooner, because 'tis the worst thing in the world for the complexion; nat that I pretend to be a beau; but a man must endeavour to look wholesome, lest he make so nauseous a figure in the side-bax, the ladies should be compelled to turn their eyes upon the play. 
 So at ten a-clack, I say, I rise. 
 Naw, if I find 'tis a good day, I resalve to take a turn in the Park, and see the fine women; so huddle on my clothes, and get dressed by one. 
 If it be nasty weather, I take a turn in the chocolate-hause: where, as you walk, madam, you have the prettiest prospect in the world; you have lookingglasses all round you. 
 &mdash; But I'm afraid I tire the company. 
 Act 2, Scene 1 
 Comment 
 A rich restoration character, not recommended unless there is some reasonable experience working in the style. 
 Foppington is the King of Fops; hard and witty, not soft and camp; relish the tartness of his delivery, his enjoyment of the spoken word. 
 The modern text 
 Not Quite Jerusalem by Paul Kember 
 Mike, a Cambridge undergraduate who is working on a kibbutz is talking to the Jewish girl Gila and explaining why he left university to end up in Israel. 
 He finds it difficult to describe his feelings and says at first &bquo;I just walked out.&equo; 
 Gila presses him to explain his reasons to her.  
 MIKE 
 I don't know, I was just sitting on the grass one day, down by the river. 
 Everyone else was lying around and I just thought: &bquo;That's it, I've had enough&equo;. 
 And I just walked away leaving everything &mdash; clothes, money, records, books&hellip; 
 Pause 
 And I walked. 
 I just kept walking. 
 Walking and walking in the pissing rain. 
 I just walked. 
 Nothing momentous. 
 No dead birds fell from the trees. 
 No portents. 
 I just walked, all the way along Trumpington Road. 
 I got as far as Grantchester and I thought, fuck it, yes, why not? 
 Do it. 
 Pause 
 The heart of England trip. 
 Get in touch with the true essence of England, what it is to be English. 
 Let the village atmosphere seep into your pores. 
 See if you can make contact with it, this magical thing called Englishness. 
 I wanted to see if I could experience it. 
 The place was deserted. 
 I kept walking, past the old mill, right up around the bend to where the council property starts, and I thought, oh, shit, council houses. 
 I'm never going to find the spirit of true Englishness there. 
 So I headed back to the village. 
 Looked at all the usual things; the cottages, the rectory and so on and, eventually ended up in the churchyard; the one where Rupert Brooke is buried. 
 And there's the poem presumed to be about the clock stopping. 
 And it's all so wonderful and idyllic. 
 And I was scouting around vaguely aware that, in fact, I'd actually located it. 
 The English ideal. 
 That this essence of Englishness was actually there in my possession&hellip; 
 And suddenly I caught sight of this&hellip; prat sailing down the Cam back towards Cambridge in a punt, with a girl doing all the work, while he reclined at the exact angle, trying to play a chord and strum a tune&hellip; 
 There was this idiot, sailing along desperately trying to simulate an atmosphere of&hellip; 
 Christ knows &bquo;Some vague recollection of tranquillity from his grandfather's scrapbook.&equo; 
 It was all there. 
 The spires in the background, the river, this typical English village &mdash; and this prat &mdash; this arch tit &mdash; sailing through the stillness of centuries &mdash; absolutely fucking clueless. 
 I walked out of the village, got to the main road, turned right instead of left and here I am. 
 How do you put that in a letter? 
 Are you any wiser? 
 Pause 
 Pause 
 Comment 
 No particular accent is asked for, but Mike is not the conventional public school type who has gone to Cambridge. 
 He speaks with really quite a small vocabulary which suggests he is unused to expressing himself eloquently. 
 Part of the time he may almost be unaware that he is speaking to another person &mdash; after all Gila doesn't understand English very well and it is unlikely that she would fully understand the references to Rupert Brooke and the poem &bquo;The Old Vicarage, Grantchester&equo;. 
 (Suggest that you read that poem as a background.) 
 Not Quite Jerusalem by Paul Kember 
 Carrie is in her mid to late twenties and comes from Birmingham. 
 She talks incessantly and seems over-enthusiastic about nearly every aspect of life &mdash; prattling on without caring much about the kind of responses she gets from other human beings around. 
 In this speech (comprising in fact two consecutive speeches) she talks to Mike about herself and impressions of the kibbutz life. 
 CARRIE 
 Oh, yes. 
 I must say, I had certain ambitions for higher education myself, but when you receive the call, as they say, those cherished dreams just have to go by the board. 
 Not that I would have attempted to scale the academic heights of an Oxford or a Cambridge, of course, but they do do some very stimulating courses at the Birmingham Polytechnic. 
 Mind you I've taken the precaution of leaving all my nursing manuals at home. 
 If you're going to take a break it may as well be a clean one. 
 Incidentally, have you been to the kibbutz library yet? 
 Tuesdays seven to nine p.m. 
 They've got some very interesting works. 
 Unfortunately most of them are in Hebrew. 
 But there's quite a stack of paperbacks left behind by other volunteers. 
 It's pretty lightweight, most of it and what isn't lightweight is salacious, so I wouldn't think you'd find much to stimulate you there, but you could try. 
 I was in there last night trying to get some ideas for Volunteers Day. 
 Not that I managed. 
 You know, of course, we had our second meeting last night? 
 Needless to say, nobody turned up. 
 I sat for half an hour outside the dining room like a pickle in a jam factory. 
 Oh, don't worry, I'm not getting at you. 
 You were probably busy working, I appreciate that. 
 It's the others I'm worried about. 
 Comments 
 This is a straight comedy speech (though the character does not find herself funny). 
 She is a busybody who likes talking and has cultivated her own style. 
 Her Birmingham background is hinted at and if you can manage a Birmingham accent it might be useful, but it is not essential in finding the character. 
 Teeth'n Smiles by David Hare 
 Arthur is a twenty-six year old song writer in the world of rock music, c . 
 1975, (the date the play was first performed at the Royal Court Theatre). 
 ARTHUR 
 Where I first met Maggie. 
 She was singing in the Red Lion. 
 She was sixteen, seventeen, a folk singer. 
 Let us go a pickin' nuts, fol de ray, to Glastonbury Fair, a tiddle dum ay. 
 I had to carry her over the wall, can you imagine, to get her to my rooms. 
 They build walls here to stop undergraduates making love. 
 Well, we got caught, of course, by this very Mr Snead coming in satirical German manner, even shining a torch, an English suburban stormf&uuml;hrer. 
 He hauled me up to my tutor, who said, do you intend to marry the girl? 
 I said, not entirely. 
 He said, as this is a first offence you will not be sent down, instead, I fine you ten pounds for having a girl on the premises. 
 I said what you mean like a brothel charge? 
 I was furious, I was out of my mind.  
 He takes another cigarette 
 Thanks. 
 And everyone told me: don't waste your energy. 
 Because that's what they want. 
 They invent a few rules that don't mean anything so that you can ruin your health trying to change them. 
 Then overnight they redraft them because they didn't really matter in the first place. 
 One day it's a revolution to say fuck on bus. 
 Next day it's the only way to get a ticket. 
 That's how the system works. 
 An obstacle course. 
 Unimportant. 
 Well, perhaps. 
 Comment 
 This is reflective speech; the character seems rootless and so there is no definite accent or background indicated. 
 We gather that he comes from the university where they are now playing the concert. 
  After taking the cigarette (an important prop in this speech) Arthur changes tack. 
 He seems to be talking in a series of jumpy thoughts. 
 For this reason the speed of the speech may be slower than it looks, the cigarette smoking being used to punctuate it. 
 Teeth'n Smiles by David Hare 
 Maggie, in between numbers at a rock concert, talks to Laura about the young student who has just made love to her. 
 MAGGIE 
 He was in a bit of a state, I couldn't believe it. 
 I think he must have juiced himself up. 
 He said your thighs are so beautiful, your thighs are so beautiful, well, Laura, you seen my thighs. 
 I said please let's not&hellip; 
 I'd rather you just&hellip; 
 He said your body is like a book in which men may read strange things, a foreign country in which they may travel with delight. 
 Your cheeks like damask, the soft white loveliness of your breasts, leading to the firm dark mountain peaks of your, Laura, now I'm dreading which part of my body he will choose next on which to turn the great white beam of his fucking sincerity. 
 Between your legs the silver comets spiral through the night, I lose myself, he says&hellip; he says&hellip; how beautiful you are Maggie and how beautiful life ought to be with you.  
 Pause. 
 She cries 
 Then eventually&hellip; 
 I say please, faking. 
 He says yes of course, he stops talking. 
 We wait. 
 For thirty minutes. 
 For thirty minutes it is like trying to push a marshmallow into a coinbox.  
 Pause 
 Then he manages. 
 In his way. 
 Afterwards he says it's his fault. 
 I say no mine, perhaps the choice of location&hellip; he says it can't be your fault, you have made love to the most brilliant and beautiful men of your generation, you have slept with the great. 
 I say there are no great, there is no beautiful, there is only the thin filth of getting old, the thin layer of filth that gets to cover everything. 
 So. 
 Off he goes. 
 Ta ta. 
 Comment 
 Maggie is a young, burnt-out pop singer. 
 The piece requires delicacy, to express the real awfulness she senses in her life. 
 The phrasing needs particular care.  
 The Real Thing by Tom Stoppard 
 Debbie, the teenage daughter of the writer Henry, talks with her father about his work and about her own life. 
 In this extract three speeches have been linked together. 
 DEBBIE 
 What, House of Cards ? 
 Well, it wasn't about anything, except did she have it off or didn't she? 
 What a crisis. 
 Infidelity among the architect class. 
 Again. 
 Most people think not  having it off is fidelity . 
 They think all relationships hinge in the middle. 
 Sex or no sex. 
 What a fantastic range of possibilities. 
 Like an on/off switch. 
 Did she or didn't she. 
 By Henry Ibsen. 
 Why would you want to make it such a crisis? 
 It's what comes of making such a mystery of it. 
 When I was twelve I was obsessed. 
 Everything was sex. 
 Latin was sex. 
 The dictionary fell open at meretrix , a harlot. 
 You could feel the mystery coming off the word like musk. 
 Meretrix ! 
 This was none of your mensa-a-table , this was a flash from the forbidden planet, and it was everywhere. 
 History was sex, French was sex, art was sex, the Bible, poetry, penfriends, games, music, everything was sex except biology which was obviously sex but obviously not really  sex, not the one which was secret and ecstatic and wicked and a sacrament and all the things it was supposed to be at one and the same time &mdash; I got that in the boiler room and it turned out to be biology after all. 
 That's what free love is free of &mdash; propaganda. 
 Act 2, Scene 7 
 Comment 
 A seventeen year old, bright and intelligent enough to put herself on an equal footing with her father. 
 She does have affection for him but is not over-impressed with his success as a writer and she speaks directly from her own experience rather than any vicarious sensations. 
 Be careful not to create anyone with a phoney Chelsea &bquo;Sloane&equo; accent or anything outrageous. 
 She speaks good standard English without any affectation.  
 The Real Thing by Tom Stoppard 
 Henry, a successful playwright, is being pushed by his wife to re-write or adapt a play by a raw young man called Brodie, who is in prison. 
 Henry has no wish to do this and chooses to explain to Annie why he finds Brodie's work clumsy and ill-constructed. 
 HENRY 
 He holds up a cricket bat. 
 Shut up and listen. 
 This thing here, which looks like a wooden club, is actually several pieces of particular wood cunningly put together in a certain way so that the whole thing is sprung, like a dance floor. 
 It's for hitting cricket balls with. 
 If you get it right, the cricket ball will travel two hundred yards in four seconds, and all you've done is give it a knock like knocking the top off a bottle of stout, and it makes a noise like a trout taking a fly&hellip; 
 What we're trying to do is to write cricket bats, so that when we throw up an idea and give it a little knock, it might&hellip; travel&hellip; 
 Now, what we've got here is a lump of wood roughly the same shape trying to be a cricket bat, and if you hit a ball with it, the ball will travel about ten feet and you will drop the bat and dance about shouting &bquo;Ouch!&equo; with your hands stuck into your armpits. 
 This isn't better because someone says it's better, or because there's a conspiracy by the MCC to keep cudgels out of Lords. 
 It's better because it's better. 
 He clucks his tongue to make the noise. 
 He clucks his tongue again and picks up the script. 
 Indicating the cricket bat. 
 You don't believe me, so I suggest you go out to bat with this and see how you get on. 
 &bquo;You're a strange boy, Billy, how old are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Twenty, but I've lived more than you'll ever live.&equo; 
 Ooh, ouch!  
 He drops the script and hops about with hands in his armpits, going &bquo;Ouch!&equo; 
 Act 2, Scene 2 
 Comment 
 A mature man, Henry speaks with style and wit about the art of playwriting to his wife (who is prepared to listen!). 
 The speech is rich in comic sensitivity. 
 Taking a cricket bat to the audition isn't a bad idea although you can get the same effect with an umbrella. 
 In fact the props of the speech are important and not too difficult to use to help your presentation.  
 Night and Day by Tom Stoppard 
 The play is set in a imaginary African Republic, Kambawe. 
 In this scene the country's president, Mageeba, talks with an Australian journalist. 
 The president is finely educated and is capable of talking like a professor and behaving like a despot. 
 This piece includes several speeches edited together. 
 MAGEEBA 
 At the time of independence the Daily Citizen  was undoubtedly free. 
 It was free to select the news it thought fit to print, to make much of it, or little, and free to make room for more girls wearing less and less underwear. 
 You may smile, but does freedom of the press mean freedom to choose its own standards?&hellip;  down, as I would have been obliged to do had it not been burned  down during the state of emergency which followed independence. 
 But what to put in its place? 
 The English millionaire folded his singed tents and stole away the insurance money, which didn't belong to him since I had nationalized the paper well before the fire was out. 
 Material missing from transcription at this point; cannot correct or quantify, as original not available and book out of print 
 Never mind &mdash; the field was open. 
 I did not believe a newspaper should be part of the apparatus of the state; we are not a totalitarian society. 
 But neither could I afford a return to the whims of private enterprise. 
 I had the immense and delicate task of restoring confidence in Kambawe. 
 I could afford the naked women but not the naked scepticism, the carping and sniping and the public washing of dirty linen which represents freedom to an English editor. 
 What then? 
 A democratic committee of journalists? &mdash; a thorn bush for the editor to hide in. 
 No, no &mdash; freedom with responsibility, that was the elusive formula we pondered all those years ago at the LSE. 
 And that is what I found. 
 From the ashes there arose, by public subscription, a new Daily Citizen , responsible and relatively free. 
 He leans towards Wagner 
 Do you know what I mean by a relatively free press, Mr Wagner?&hellip; 
 I mean a free press which is edited by one of my relatives. 
 He throws back his head and laughs. 
 Act 2 
 Comment 
 For a black actor this speech gives a major opportunity to convey power and style. 
 Mageeba makes no concessions to the white  political world yet he understands a great deal about it. 
 Ask yourself about the current African political scene and read round it to find interesting parallels, since Mageeba represents a mixture of the kind of African leadership to be found. 
 A Lily in Little India by Donald Howarth. 
 Alvin Hanker is in his room. 
 He has just broken one of his records deliberately and is on his knees picking up the pieces as he talks to himself. 
 ALVIN 
 You're silenced forever if your groove's not joined. 
 I'm sorry I broke you in sacrifice. 
 Never mind. 
 I'll get you another one again. 
 &bquo;If only you'd read for once or play cards. 
 Find yourself a hobby like other people, go to the pictures, the night school, the dancing, the football, the&hellip; 
 &equo; Night school. 
 He rises and puts the pieces into the drawer of the chest of drawers 
 He mimics his mother's voice 
 If I went to night school I'd be a student. 
 Alvin student. 
 There are too many. 
 Students all trying. 
 Besides, there's only one for the top of the class. 
 I might look well with a hobby. 
 If you have a private sideline, that's it. 
 No-one expects you to present the result. 
 You can do it when you come home from work and you're all right at week-ends. i could dance. 
 I could be taught. 
 &bquo;Bert Shutt's Palais's no good for dancing with Alvin Hanker.&equo; 
 A dance floor's for partners. 
 Four legs behave as two on the ballroom boards. 
 Never mind dancing. 
 Too many dance. 
 Too many legs on ballroom floors, crowding each other out on to the pavements. 
 Dancing's overcrowded like the pavements. 
 All going to the pictures. 
 I like the pictures. 
 Sitting in the pictures &mdash; getting dark and warm and watching with the music all the time playing from nowhere. 
 Film stars are real and all first class with big faces &mdash; and they're good at it. 
 I get on well at the films. 
 It would be sitting at the pictures if I could have the money to do it fill time. 
 I could borrow. 
 But there's the travelling to get to the one the night after and seeing a different one every middle of the week. 
 I couldn't afford the fares into town as well as a reasonable seat for sitting in. 
 Playing at cards isn't  for one, except Patience. 
 But I cheat so that's out. 
 I could read. 
 It's quiet. 
 I could read a lot. 
 Seven books a week. 
 He sits in the chair 
 He mimics a young woman's voice 
 He rises and takes on imaginary partner 
 He dances 
 He steps on his partner's toes 
 He sits 
 Library books. 
 Long books &mdash; full of quiet reading far from Mrs Raistrick's ears, Books with photographs beside the print, beautiful, like film stars, but quiet. 
 Slender, thin-backed books with titles, books on buildings, books on ships, on bridges, books on end, books on wardrobes never dusted, books on gardening books. 
 Flower books on flowers. 
 Act 1 
 Comment 
 This character has a northern accent and the fact is important to the handling of the piece. 
 He is on his own and definitely talking aloud to himself in the privacy of his room. 
 There is no need to over-play the slightly pathetic quality but seek out the eagerness of his search for something to do. 
 His imitations of other voices calls for a good sense of mimicry, and should bring the dreariness of his life into focus. 
 Perhaps you could have two pieces of broken gramophone record with you as a prop to start the extract. 
 Not about Heroes by Stephen Macdonald 
 This is a play for two characters, Siegfried Sassoon and Wilfred Owen, the World War One poets, and it would obviously be a good thing to read some of their poetry as a background to performing this piece. 
 Sassoon survived the war and died in 1967. 
 Owen, seven years younger, was killed one week before the war ended. 
 The play is an imaginative reconstruction of their friendship. 
 SASSOON 
 By the 8th June, I was back in the front line. 
 Our mission was to take back from the Boche those few miles of battered ground that we'd bought with half a million lives in those Battles of the Somme, two years before. 
 i found myself in the same place where I'd been wounded in Easter, 1917. 
 Hundreds of thousands of lives had bought nothing, had proved nothing. 
 i wonder&hellip; what was I trying to prove? just that I was not a sheep , waiting to be slaughtered, at their command. 
 And nor would i lead my company to be slaughtered, at their command. 
 Another Protest, I suppose. 
 Even more ineffectual than the first. 
 All I did was to out on a raid &mdash; unofficially. 
 And when the sun came up in no-man's-land, it was hot. 
 A beautiful summer  morning. 
 I took off my tin hat to feel the sun on my face. 
 And I didn't hear the bullet leaving the rifle. 
 One moment I was revelling in the astonishment of being alive, and the next &mdash; I was lying flat on my face, with what felt like a very large hole in the right side of my skull&hellip; 
 They carried me back to England in the middle of July. 
 My war seemed to be over. 
 I couldn't understand why I'd not been killed when there were so many others who&hellip; 
 It took me a long time to accept the fact that now I should not be killed &mdash; that I should be one of the survivors. 
 After all that I was going to live on&hellip; alone&hellip; to write the &bquo;Memoirs&equo;&hellip; to listen to Mozart in Salzburg. 
 OWEN 
 &hellip; 
 In a village near Amiens, I found a shop where you can still get tea, and enough cakes to make a schoolboy sick for a week. 
 I'll remember when (go up the line&hellip; 
 That will be any hour now. 
 I feel confident because I know I came out to help: directly, by leading them as well as an officer can; indirectly, by watching their sufferings so that I may plead for them as well as I can. 
 I have done the first&hellip; 
 Very dear Siegfried. 
 I have been in action some days. 
 Our experience passed the limits of abhorrence: I lost all my earthly faculties and fought like an angel. 
 You'll guess what happened when I say that I am now commanding the Company &mdash; and in the line I had a seraphic boy-lance-corporal as my sergeant-major. 
 I have mentioned my excellent batman, Jones. 
 In the first wave of the attack he was shot in the head and thrown on top of me. 
 He lay there dead, his blood soaking my shoulder for half an hour. 
 It's still there, crimson, on my tunic. 
 i can't say I suffered anything &mdash; having let my brain grow dull. 
 My nerves, then, are in perfect order. 
 My senses are charred. 
 I shall feel again as soon as I dare, but now I must not. 
 I don't take the cigarette out of my mouth when I write &bquo;Deceased&equo; across their letters&hellip; 
 Siegfried, I don't know what you'll think, but I've been recommended for the MC &mdash; and I've recommended every single NCO who was with me. 
 I'm glad of it &mdash; for the confidence it will give me at home. 
 I think it's all over for a long time. 
 Moreover, the war is nearing an end. 
 Do you know what you will do? 
 What are you doing now? 
 Can you tell me? 
 (In this extract several pieces of Owen's dialogue have been put together.) 
 Comment 
 Sassoon Sassoon was a public school man (read his book Memoirs of a Fox-hunting Man ) and his slightly cold style is only a front for his real feelings. 
 It is probably best to take this piece seated, to suggest a character looking back reflectively at the events recalled. 
 Owen Owen was from Shropshire, from a less smart background than Sassoon. 
 Don't try to play the speech poetically. 
 There are many shifting thoughts to be considered in this extract, and there is colour too; you need to convey the spurts of energy vocally. 
 The Apple Cart by George Bernard Shaw 
 The play is a fable, of an England ruled over by King Magnus. 
 Orinthia is his mistress and this speech is taken from an amusing scene between Orinthia and Magnus. 
 Orinthia replies to Magnus's words, &bquo;It must be magnificent to have the consciousness of a goddess without ever doing anything to justify it.&equo; 
 ORINTHIA 
 Give me a goddess's work to do; and I will do it. 
 I will even stoop to a queen's work if you will share the throne with me. 
 But do not pretend that people become great by doing great things. 
 They do great things because they are great, if the great things come along. 
 But they are great just the same when the great things do not come along. 
 If I never did anything but sit in this room and powder my face and tell you what a clever fool you are, i should still be heavens high above the millions of common women who do their domestic duty, and sacrifice themselves, and run Trade departments and all the rest of the vulgarities. 
 Has all the tedious public work you have done made you any the better? 
 I have seen before and after your boasted strokes of policy; and you were the same man, and would have been the same man to me and to yourself if you had never done them. 
 Thank God my self-consciousness is something nobler than vulgar conceit in having done something. 
 It is what I am, not what I do, that you must worship in me. 
 Comment 
 There is more to this speech, but this seems a good place to stop for a short and effective audition. 
 Orinthia is an expansive, richly styled character, based on the exotic personality of actress Mrs Patrick Campbell. 
 The voice needs to be rich and varied, flirtatious and worldly wise. 
 A Mad World, My Masters by Barry Keefe 
 This is a modern version of the Elizabethan &bquo;City&equo; comedy, a panorama of town life, teeming with villains, mugs, lechers and madmen. 
 The atmosphere is rich and steamy, Superintendant Sayers tries with little success to keep order. 
 SUPT. 
 SAYERS 
 Hello Hello&hellip; hardly what you'd call grief with a large G. I smell a con. 
 I smell it as surely as I smell a knocked off car, a crooked log book. 
 One previous owner? 
 Who's that &mdash; Julius Caesar? 
 My wit numbs them to speechlessness. 
 Then I pounce with devastating questions to expose their guilt. 
 Like Magnus Magnusson I am. 
 An intrepid interrogator. 
 Twenty five years in the service, 43 murder cases. 
 All that, and I still can't get a mortgage. 
 No home, no mortgage, that's me. 
 I've seen the places I want. 
 Lovely little mock Tudor semis in the wog-free suburbs. 
 But these mortgage companies, they don't want to know&hellip; 
 Nor the councils. 
 They say no, 'cause I've got a police house. 
 Look, mate, I've got nothing against these Indians, Chinese, Pakistanis, Blacks you name 'em I've got nothing against them &mdash; apart from them being here. 
 But what I want to know is this &mdash; how come a Pakistani hot off the banana boat can get a mortgage when a decent cop with 25 years service in the force cannot? 
 Look mate, what this country needs is someone to look up to. 
 Someone to stop all this weak kneed nancy pancying pussy footing soft balls hard luck Jim have another large scotch. 
 I went to Northampton to try and get a mortgage. 
 I heard they was dishing out council mortgages left right and centre up there. 
 If you so much as parked on a yellow line they stuffed a mortgage application under your windscreen wipers. 
 What did they say to me? 
 Oh yes, you guessed it. 
 I'll follow the Sprightlys. 
 Observe them. 
 From a safe distance. 
 Comment 
 Sayers is a comically baleful disappointed copper. 
 The ultimate Ogre-Cop: racist, sexist, fascist and reactionary. 
 From his bowler to his riding-mac to his moustache to his highly-polished shoes he embodies spleen and dodginess. 
 He speaks like a quietly sinister sergeant-major. 
 Sugar and Spice by Nigel Williams 
 Carol is one of a party of young punk girls. 
 She and her friend Sharon have been pursued by some boys, who are taunting Carol to take her clothes off. 
 Sharon tells Carol she is making a spectacle of herself &mdash; and Carol turns on her friend in the following speech. 
 CAROL 
 Ah, leave off me Sharon. 
 I wanner be me if you wanner know an' woss so wrong wiv vat. 
 An' if you mus' know I like wearin' nice clothes an' I like the way boys look at me when I go down the schtreet an' I like to look sexy an' I like lipstick an' showin' meself off an' all that I enjoy it. 
 O.K.? 
 Thass wot I call livin' if you mus' know. 
 An' I dunno 'ow long I'll be livin' 'fore I'm sick like yore ol' lady 'angin' rahnd ver launjrette an' waitin' up fer ol' man an' 'avin' Gawd knows 'ow many kids 'angin' rahnd me an' &bquo;Mummy this&equo; and &bquo;Mummy that&equo; my Gawd if you mus' know Sharon all my life all I fuckin' wanner do is shine up there like a dancer or sunnink. 
 Like sunnink reely glamorous that everyone wants an' I can't see woss so wrong wiv vat. 'Cos I ain't gonner get no kitchen wiv pitcher winders an' some geezer wiv a pipe like you was on abaht am I now? 
 I be lucky I get any bloke fer more'n two monfs togewer like my ol' lady I suppose an' if I get a bloke 'e'll be aht a' work or 'e'll set me ter the bleed'n game like 'er I wouldn't be surprised but if you reely want ter now jus' fer now for this minute I wanner enjoy it. 
 I wanner go up in a pile a smoke an' flames an' eye shadder an' levver shoes an' dancin' an' all that I'll go like them girls in the magazines Sharon an' you ain't goin' ter stop me. 
 O.K.? 
 Act 2 
 Comment 
 This speech in the cockney vernacular reads almost like a foreign language, but it has a well defined construction and rhythm. 
 Notice  how some of the words when repeated are better spoken than at other times, according to the level of passion in the delivery. 
 The absence of punctuation is also a part of the style -but in spite of this you can sense the character struggling to articulate her thoughts clearly. 
 Educating Rita by Willy Russell 
 Rita is a young, married, working-class hairdresser, who rebels against her circumstances, and decides to acquire a higher education. 
 She's talking to Frank, her university tutor. 
 RITA 
 What? 
 Do you mean like that working-class culture thing? 
 I don't see any, y'know, culture. 
 I just see everyone pissed, or on the Valium, tryin' to get from one day to the next. 
 Y' daren't say that round our way like, cos they're proud. 
 They'll tell y' they've got culture as they sit there drinkin' keg beer out of plastic glasses. 
 They're not content with it, cos there's no meaning. 
 They tell y' stories about the past, y' know, the war, or when they were fightin' for food an' clothin' an houses. 
 Their eyes light up as they tell y', because there was some meanin' to it. 
 But the thing is that now, I mean now that most of them have got some sort of house, an' there's food an' money around, they know they're better off but, honest, they know they've got nothin' as well. 
 There's like this sort of disease, but no one mentions it; everyone behaves as though it's normal, y' know inevitable that there's vandalism an, violence an, houses burnt out an' wrecked by the people they were built for. 
 There's somethin' wrong. 
 An' like the worst thing is that y' know the people who are like supposed to represent the people on our estate, y' know the Daily Mirror an' The Sun, an ITV an' the Unions, what are they tellin' people to do? 
 They just tell them to go out an' get more money, don't they? 
 But they don't want more money,; it's like me, isn't it? 
 Y' know, buyin' new dresses all the time, isn't it? 
 The Unions tell them to go out an' get more money an' ITV an' the papers tell them what to spend it on so the disease is always covered up. 
 I'm just tellin' y' about round our way. 
 I wanna be on this course findin' out. 
 You know what I learn from you, about art an' literature, it feeds me, inside. 
 I can get through the rest of the week if I know I've got comin' here to look forward to. 
 Comment 
 Rita is a lively observer of her world, and describes it with vivid insight. 
 She has seen who's pulling the strings. 
 The speech is not a lamenting &bquo;downer&equo;, it's full of irony, humour and compassion and honest indignation. 
 She bursts with vitality and raw intelligence. 
 Though she has had little education, her vocabulary is excellent: she fountains out ideas and observations at breathless speed. 
 A smart, sexy, brave and warm young woman. 
 The locale is described as a university in the north of England, it could be anywhere from Nottingham to Newcastle, but seems more likely to be Lancashire or Merseyside. 
 The accent must be scrupulously well done: it's her truth, her vocal identity, her prison.   
 Training at drama school 
 All training for the theatre is aiming to produce a person with all-round performing skills, equipped and ready to work in the world of entertainment. 
 It is easy to understand this, but it's not so easy to evaluate the different elements of theatre training, and see just how they contribute to the making of that elusive thing, &bquo;a compleat actor&equo;. 
 I have always considered drama training to be based on simple precepts, for acting is not a complicated art. 
 It may be difficult, but it is not complicated, and if it gets complicated there is something quite wrong. 
 Above all acting is not an intellectual occupation, though a good mind is needed to respond imaginatively and practically to the work of authors and directors. 
 An actor can wear his cap as an academic in private conversation as well as the next person, but once on stage the actor responds to the requirements of a scene being played, and works through from moment to moment. 
 And the fact that you already have a good instinct for acting will probably have been the main reason why you passed your entrance audition for drama school. 
 What you will eventually be working towards is a fusion of instinct and technique, and training is very largely to do with improving technical skills. 
 At drama school, there is constant attention to a student's control of both voice and movement, and the different departments work at developing a student's overall acting technique. 
 The emphasis will be on developing an actor's mental and physical concentration, and giving him/her sufficient craftsmanship to sustain a performance. 
 Classes 
 The first term is always an unsettling time, and it generally takes a few weeks before students become familiar with each other, and work together effectively. 
 Classes are carefully time-tabled throughout the day, and occasionally stretch into the evenings. 
 It is usual for a class to consist of between 12 and 16 students divided approximately equally between male and female, and this size of class is likely to be maintained throughout the  training course until the finals period in the last two terms. 
 The two-year diploma course student will, of course, join the finals group earlier than the three-year course student. 
 But in the first term all students start from the base line, and take many classes, individual tutorials and work on production projects. 
 The classes will generally be in voice, movement, improvisation, dancing, fencing, mask-work, make-up and acting exercises. 
 There will probably also be some classes in radio, television and film techniques and perhaps singing too, but by far the largest proportion of time will be allotted to the production exercise which is part of every term's work. 
 Most classes last for an hour or perhaps an hour and a half. 
 In the first term, rehearsals for the production project will usually be around two hours in length, but progressively more time will be spent on this aspect of the course as the student advances. 
 Ideally the classes support the work done on the production project and it is particularly valuable if there is strong liaison between voice and movement tutors with the director of a project &mdash; not least in helping students see how the instructional classes connect with their own performances. 
 If drama schools do not incorporate a stage management course, basic lectures and some participation in production work may take place in the senior terms. 
 It is always useful for a student of acting to have some practical knowledge of stage management, helping him/her to appreciate the need for efficient technical support for any production. 
 And it can be particularly useful to have some background in this area, as a first job may often be that of an &bquo;acting ASM&equo; &mdash; particularly if you join a small touring group or a Theatre in Education company. 
 The voice and the body 
 It's not much use thinking of the voice without the body, even though each is the subject of a separate training class. 
 The days when the voice was trained to be a beautiful sound in itself are no longer with us; instead, the emphasis is on a more natural approach, with each actor discovering the true quality of his/her own voice, and extending its range as much as possible. 
 After all, the voice is an actor's number one asset, and it will be in use all the time. 
 posture and physical balance have a great deal to contribute to 
  vocalisation, a point which is stressed in Cicely Berry's standard book, The Voice and the Actor , which is used as a basic text in drama schools. 
 The use of the voice in conjunction with the body is an important feature of training, too, for when acting you will need to be physically free enough to do several things at once. 
 But besides this more obvious point, there are subtler connections between voice and body: Cicely Berry observes that &bquo;an introverted and thoughtful person often finds more difficulty in speaking and does not carry the thought through into the physical process of making speech&equo;. 
 She says, too, &bquo;you have to relate the mental intention to the physical action&equo;. 
 Most drama training works on the assumption that there is something called &bquo;standard English&equo;, which is generally considered to be the &bquo;straight&equo; delivery of words without affectation or regional variation. 
 This means that actors are expected to be able to control any regional or foreign accent which is natural to them, and deliver a text in what may best be called &bquo;the classical style&equo;. 
 It doesn't mean that your regional accent is going to be bullied out of you, so that you are unable to use it ever again &mdash; on the contrary, your accent may in all probability be your most interesting and valuable possession. 
 And good voice training will make your natural delivery sound ten times better than when you first started training. 
 A word here about singing &mdash; some schools have courses in choral singing, and may also run individual classes; not all students are singers, obviously, but it is always a useful addition to other vocal training. 
 And a trained singing voice is undoubtedly a valued asset &mdash; there may well be some competition for a place on singing tutorials. 
 The first production 
 The text for the first term's production will usually be selected for the purpose of getting a new group to work together rather than trying to go for detailed individual performances. 
 The range is obviously very wide, and you may find yourself in a Greek tragedy, or even a modern &bquo;exercise&equo; play such as Games  by James Saunders, where the student may add to the text by research material which can be incorporated in the project. 
 Either way, the main intention will be to establish a way of working, and to begin assessing students' voice and movement abilities. 
 The language of a classical play is challenging but it does give the student chance to see how early voice training can be used with a very demanding text.  
 Most of these exercises are double cast so that there are good opportunities for several readings of the main characters. 
 Depending on the school, a full term's work of ten to twelve weeks may be spent on one production project during the first term, with either a workshop or text study area at the end of the period. 
 Later on there will be a regular division of the term into two projects. 
 The new student does not perform to audiences immediately, and the first term's production project will probably only be attended by staff teaching voice, movement and acting to enable individual assessments to be made on training. 
 Improvisation 
 There have been many books written about improvisation and if I were asked to choose just one it would be Keith Johnston's Impro  which is straightforward, understandable, and theatrically aware. 
 Nowadays, nearly every young person has probably had some experience of basic improvisation at their school or through the extensive TIE (Theatre in Education) tours. 
 In drama schools, improvisation is about finding a way of expanding the imagination and liberating the senses, which can get too confined if students work entirely from a text all the time. 
 The use of impro in training has gone through many phases; it still conjures up the traditional, hackneyed image of a student being asked to be a tree or an icecream. 
 But it's possible to go way beyond these limited, obvious exercises, and impro can be immensely exciting for young actors, allowing them to grasp situations and emotions imaginatively, perhaps for the first time. 
 Here is an example of an impro exercise for two actors: &bquo;An actor is asked to assume the character of a close family friend who arrives at the house with the news of the death of the wife's husband in an accident. 
 He has hurried to get there and tell the wife before the police arrive.&equo; 
 This may prove more effective if the girl playing the wife has no idea of what the scene is going to be about. 
 What an impro of this kind does is confront the actors with a situation where they have to be emotionally truthful. 
 Without a text to assist them they may prevaricate too long before facing the brutal truth. 
 Improvisation can mean having the guts to experience anything which is asked of you. 
 Can you truthfully become a child again? 
 Improvisation should not, in any way, be confused with the rather  general idea of &bquo;making things up as you go along&equo;, which has no real purpose beyond that of entertainment. 
 Improvisation, if used properly, is intended to seek out something in you, and hopefully find an imaginative and emotional response. 
 Acting exercises 
 Acting &bquo;exercises&equo; differ from improvisation in that students work in a less open-ended way; the aim is to follow the intentions and actions of a character in a particular scene, often quite minutely. 
 Of all the classes this is closest to what happens in an actual rehearsal, since it is much more concerned with the technical means of presenting a character. 
 And class work in this area is usually referred to as &bquo;technique&equo; or simply &bquo;acting&equo;. 
 For example, one exercise which I have used in class is a play called Justice  by John Galsworthy. 
 Here a single actor plays an imprisoned man, and performs in silence, and the scene culminates in an emotional breakdown where the prisoner beats on the door of his cell. 
 Galsworthy gives very precise details on the dimensions of the cell, the things that are in it and the character's sequence of actions. 
 The piece tests the actor's awareness and imagination to the full, but nevertheless makes precise demands on him: he must follow exactly what the author says. 
 Throughout drama school there will be continuous work on acting solo pieces, and both singing and acting tutorials are usually conducted on a one to one basis (more on tutorials in chapter 7). 
 Of course the student also needs to learn how to co-ordinate dialogue with all of the necessary actions and movements which are part of the natural traffic of performance, and learn about prop handling. 
 Classes help the actor to gain confidence in dealing with many things happening at the same time, and this is an important part of student work. 
 Radio, television and film classes 
 Most schools now offer classes on radio, television and film techniques. 
 Radio acting makes specific technical demands on an actor, and classes are usually held by professional tutors who have a wide experience of radio drama and its production. 
 Getting used to acting with the voice only and knowing how to use the microphone are basic features of good radio technique. 
  Students may compete for the BBC Carlton Hobbs award which is given annually to two students from any of the drama schools; the award offers a six month contract with BBC radio, as well as guaranteeing that vital entry into British Equity. 
 The facilities available for television training differs from school to school; filming and television work is expensive to organise, and really there is not so much opportunity as one would like to see for students to gain experience in these vital areas. 
 However, where facilities are available for use over short periods of time, the rudiments of camera acting are taught in a structured way. 
 (Some schools have been able to co-ordinate work with the National Film School, where a script has been written for the personalities in a group and then filmed on location, and this worked effectively.) 
 But it's true to say that most actors feel their drama school training has left them inadequately prepared for working in television and film by the time they graduate. 
 Your drama school experience 
 The work of a drama school is necessarily highly disciplined &mdash; and indeed self discipline is an essential requirement in all acting. 
 It is possible, though, that in the early stages of training you may feel that all your creative skill is being stripped from you, and that the whole system is ganging up on you. 
 It's certainly true that the pressure on you builds up as the terms go on &mdash; but training is not  designed to destroy you, but to challenge you. 
 Remember this when the pace hots up! 
 Students usually find that the first term's work is relatively gentle. 
 At nearly all schools no stage performances will be seen by an audience until at least the end of the second term. 
 Sometimes students get anxious about this, and believe they are not making audience contact early enough; but if you think about it, the reasoning is clear. 
 Most of your technical tutors will be seeing everything you do, and deriving what they need to know from it; they don't want to find you confused by criticism from senior students which might not be helpful to you at this point. 
 Ultimately, there are things in your training which you will accept &mdash; and those you may reject. 
 And this is true of all training in the arts because nobody &mdash; no tutor, no establishment, however excellent,  can finally lay down rules. 
 They can only suggest concepts and invite you to use them. 
 The drama school training will only lay the foundations and prepare you for the profession you are joining. 
 You will know about using the voice and body and know how not to exhaust yourself. 
 Good training is there to support you and help you grow as an actor &mdash; and usually, it works. 
 And at the end of the day I have always found that the training programme is open to genuine ideas &mdash; in all the classes the aim is to build and shape the existing talent so that the actor can work effectively and truthfully when faced with any situation. 
 Finally, here are some reminders &mdash; it may sound like a do's and don'ts column, but these are important things to remember. 
 So I'll just list them: 
 1 
 Don't be late &mdash; anywhere or for anything. 
 Punctuality is not just a drama school fetish, it's preparation for a profession where time really does cost money. 
 2 
 Learn lines accurately &mdash; and always carry a pencil with you. 
 3 
 If you have a question about acting, think about it before you ask it. 
 4 
 Read newspapers, and don't assume that the whole world is as interested in acting as you are. 
 5 
 Don't neglect your health. 
 And don't imagine that you are too sick to attend classes that you don't like. 
 6 
 Think about your appearance, and how you present yourself as a person. 
 7 
 Watch how other people behave; remember everything is useful to the actor. 
 8 
 Go the theatre whenever you can. 
 The final year 
 The final terms at drama school are vital and exciting. 
 This is the time you have worked towards, when you will be working on the &bquo;showcase&equo; productions which will provide opportunities for you to be seen publicly. 
 The last three months particularly are charged with electricity &mdash; and you are suddenly involved both in the throes of final productions and the &bquo;business&equo; of acting; it all comes together in a thrilling rush, and the time goes quickly. 
 There don't seem to be enough hours in the day to do all the things you have to do, quite apart from your laundry! 
 &bquo;Showcase&equo; productions 
 Depending on the school's theatre resources, a full term of productions may mean that at least three or more plays will be staged, giving agents, directors and casting pundits a chance to evaluate your work. 
 Students may find themselves performing in final productions over two full terms, which means they have the opportunity to play twice as many parts, but this depends on the school's policy and how they think you have progressed. 
 At this stage, too, the allocation of parts and the standard of performance is becoming a lot more competitive &mdash; a foretaste of the profession itself. 
 In many cases students will also tour in productions mounted by the school, and this gives good audience experience away from the greenhouse of school performances, where the people who sit in the audience are usually either professionally interested, or are fellow students and friends. 
 Any programme of final drama school productions will present a variety of styles and the casting is aimed at giving students a chance to do well in suitable roles. 
 Naturally, with a cast of actors who are all approximately the same age, the casting of heavy character parts has to be considered very carefully, and of course not all plays are teeming with characters of similar age. 
 Both classical and contemporary plays will be chosen, but problems are often encountered with the modern play which frequently has a short cast list. 
 A finals company usually means  there are some fourteen or sixteen students, or more, to be placed. 
 It is possible for two productions to be mounted so that numbers are divided &mdash; possibly four productions may be put on, if that is thought worthwhile. 
 Arguably the modern play with a limited cast is more effective in drawing in professional agents and casting directors since there are fewer &bquo;bit&equo; parts for students to get lost in. 
 (On the other hand, plays like Tom Stoppard's Jumpers  or Max Frisch's Andorra  offer good opportunities for large numbers of students.) 
 Quite clearly the most important thing about final presentations is that the play suits the talent available in the group. 
 Yet every now and again a student emerges who shows exceptional talent and it is quite natural that a drama school will make sure that his/her ability is given a good stretch in public with a major role, perhaps playing Hamlet  or Hedda Gabler . 
 Some students, there is no denying, are more charismatic and powerful on stage than others &mdash; and it is always very difficult for the system to be absolutely fair. 
 However, one thing worth mentioning at this point is that the larger parts are not always a guarantee of an agent's interest &mdash; quite often big roles will attract attention, but a student who has been very well cast in a smaller role may hit the mark just as effectively. 
 Many drama schools regard musical productions as a main attraction, and shows such as Cabaret, Guys and Dolls  and Chicago  often get presented very well, with good choreography and musical direction which supports the cast very well. 
 The ability to sing and dance has become increasingly important in the profession nowadays, and there are few actors who don't possess some musical and dance skills. 
 Productions such as Oh, What a Lovely War  offer many opportunities for voice and body training to be displayed effectively, particularly as the quick character sketches in this show mean that an actor may play several parts in one evening. 
 Press notices are, however, exceptionally rare these days. 
 Once The Stage  covered all finals productions from the drama schools, but now they may write up a play perhaps once a year. 
 This is a pity, as it means that students find it harder to get their names known, and it means they lose out on a degree of publicity. 
 The private tutorial 
 In the last terms of the diploma course students often find tutorials, where they are given opportunity to talk about work in progress, enormously valuable. 
 The tutorial is completely  distinct from an &bquo;audition&equo; class; the object of the tutorial is to help a student concentrate on speeches and scenes which may extend aspects of characterisation or improve his/her vocal range, and also to increase confidence. 
 They are personal work-out sessions. 
 Altogether, tutorials take place over a period of about twenty-four weeks in the last year of a course, and usually by the last twelve tutorials a student has a much clearer idea of what he or she is about. 
 Where the tutorial focuses on current productions, I have found that students will work hard on their performances and be open about their work and any problems they may be having with the characters they are playing. 
 A director may have made it plain that he has a definite intention for a character, but the student may not always see this straight away. 
 Discussing a character and finding an outline of what is required in a half hour tutorial can save a lot or time on a tight rehearsal schedule. 
 But a tutorial need not be directly connected with a production in rehearsal. 
 The student may want to find out more about the kind of parts he/she may play in the future, or indeed may have played during the time already spent at drama school. 
 Perhaps certain parts played in the past have not succeeded, and it may be possible to investigate why. 
 It is common for students to return to a part that has given them many ideas, and to rework a passage fruitfully. 
 And in tutorials there is opportunity to take well judged risks &mdash; by which I mean being unafraid of going for the character and seeing where it leads &mdash; even with well known speeches. 
 Some students will use the time to try out major speeches they have never attempted before, and find out where this may take them. 
 So the tutorial is a place for ideas as well as practice, and if they are well used they can help an actor to be more objective about the craft. 
 Agents 
 Drama school productions are staged with an awareness of the kind of demands the profession will make, and students are naturally anxious to be seen in the final production by people who're likely to offer them work. 
 Unfortunately, it is often difficult to get agents to attend these productions. 
 Most drama schools final productions are staged over a similar sort of  schedule, which means agents are asked to see students' work over a fairly compressed period. 
 Agents are notified of performances by the schools, and they also receive hundreds of letters from students inviting them to see particular performances. 
 Remember, though, that badgering agents is quite useless; if they want to come they will come, but telephoning them and overselling yourself can be just as useless as not letting them know that you're alive and working. 
 It will be the same story for many moons to come. 
 Most of the drama schools now include a presentation of auditions for agents and managements at the end of the final term, in addition to the finals productions. 
 This means that students then have the chance to present themselves as they would at a working audition, and this is often quite a good place to attract attention. 
 Although an agent may be very impressed by the talent he sees, there are practical difficulties which affect how much agents can do for young actors. 
 The whole thorny question of Equity membership is linked with the step from drama school to agent's office &mdash; and indeed applies equally at the audition for the first job. 
 But the positive interest of an agent is some guarantee that your work is not passing by unnoticed. 
 An agent looking at a student actor makes a reasonable commercial judgement; he considers whether a decision to take on an actor will be financially justified. 
 Agents don't want deadwood and if they are interested in you it is because they feel they can sell you into the market, so that you can go on and make money both for yourself and them. 
 They are not artistic philanthropists, but business people who are necessary to the profession. 
 If that makes the agent sound unpleasant it is only because you are still seeing the profession through rose-coloured spectacles. 
 As a student in your last term you will begin to send out letters and photographs of yourself to all possible valuable contacts. 
 Who are these? 
 Well, the agents and the casting directors are one thing, then there's an amorphous list of anyone who seems to be connected with theatre, film and television. 
 If any professional person has shown an interest in your work don't let it go, but try to cultivate their interest, however tenuous it may seem &mdash; you will soon know if it's going to be any use for the future. 
 In the first place you are your own agent. 
 You are entering the market for the first time when you write a letter about yourself to  either agent, casting director, producer or director. 
 If an agent is interested in you he may well have useful comments on the photo you send of yourself, on your style and how you present yourself. 
 Remember this will be a professional opinion from someone who is interested in the qualities you now have to offer, so bear such comment well in mind. 
 The drama school will give you some advice on when and where to write to, and how you organise your letters, but outside advice is very important in helping you to see yourself in perspective. 
 Letters and the curriculum vitae 
 Writing letters about yourself is never easy &mdash; we tend either to say too much or too little. 
 Nobody wants a florid letter from someone they have never seen before but as an actor your style and personality must come through sufficiently &mdash; a bare list of parts played won't convey much. 
 Prepare details on a separate sheet of paper: your name, height, colouring, and the parts you have played in training. 
 The accompanying letter needs to be personal and brief and should certainly not be sycophantic or name dropping. 
 If you have particular skills like dancing, singing, fencing, acrobatics, or mime, be sure they are on this information sheet. 
 I've even known fire eating, sword swallowing, skiing and judo to be useful, and they are certainly eye-catching &mdash; but be sure you really can do what you claim! 
 Photographs 
 Photographs are all-important. 
 It's very difficult, though, to say what the right kind of photograph is, for obviously actors are very different, but remember that a good photograph is not necessarily an art photograph. 
 The main thing is that it needs to look like you! 
 Not everyone suits the same kind of photographic style, and it may take several tries before you find a picture that eventually gets you noticed. 
 You will probably, therefore, end up with a selection of varying pictures which could well be useful. 
 Getting a good set of prints is not cheap, although there are less expensive rates for students and most actors have a stock of postcard size prints that they can send off at the merest rumour of work. 
 You will need to send a photograph to Spotlight ,  too. 
 Quality in photographs costs money but it is an outlay that is never wasted for casting directors and producers do look at volumes of Spotlight  repeatedly. 
 In recent years, photographs of newcomers to the profession have been put together in a volume expressly produced for that purpose, by Spotlight . 
 The drama school will know about this, and make sure your picture is sent at the right time before you finish training. 
 Equity 
 We have already mentioned Equity, and for a number of reasons the entire question of how to enter the actors' union needs discussion at this point. 
 Briefly, the organisation British Actors' Equity exists so that only bona fide members of the profession may apply for work: and those members must abide by the contractual rulings established by the Union in negotiation with managements in theatre, television and film. 
 Equity is important in that it fights for improvements and fairness in pay and working conditions, and with over 44,000 members competing for probably some 5&ndash;7,000 jobs in any given working week, it tries to ensure that the work goes to professionally accredited people, those with training or suitable professional experience. 
 Equity entry is of crucial concern to the large numbers of trained and talented drama school finalists seeking to enter the business every year. 
 Membership of Equity, then, is no guarantee of employment &mdash; it simply gives the member a chance to be considered for the work that is available. 
 No new actor should expect more. 
 There are those who think that all drama students who graduate from drama school should be given an Equity card when they receive their diploma; to me, this is naive. 
 The present situation in 1990 is that would-be members can become provisional members by the following means; by being offered an engagement by any company or management which operates under the &bquo;Quota&equo; system by agreement with Equity and the Theatre Managers' Association. 
 That is, the employer will have places for a very small number of newcomers to the profession who are not yet union members. 
 On taking up the job, the applicant will be granted provisional membership of Equity. 
 The employers with a quota will mainly be Regional Repertories, children's theatres, touring companies, theatre-in-education, or young people's theatre companies, and strangely, the Royal Shakespeare Company at Stratford and Chichester Festival Theatre. 
 There is no quota for  the West-End Theatre, The National Theatre, television, commercials, films or radio. 
 Those with training in other performance skills, variety, singers and dancers, should consult Equity about the means whereby they could qualify for membership. 
 Summer seasons, pantomime and certain Fringe or small-scale companies also have a quota for performers and assistant stage managers and acting ASMs. 
 In addition to the quota system, Equity have compiled a &bquo;Graduate Register&equo;. 
 The drama student, on successfully completing an acting or stage management training course at an NCDT accredited school registers with Equity, thereby becoming eligible for membership of the union if offered an engagement in any of the areas of work listed above. 
 It's tough to get into the union, and it's tough to earn a living in the profession. 
 An Open Sesame to all comers would make it even tougher. 
 The ball is not with the union or the performer but with those who fund the Arts. 
 A determined, skilful young actor can get an Equity card and a first job. 
 What comes after is the problem.   
 The new actor 
 Once you have left drama school your attention will be on the immediate problems of survival and making progress with your work. 
 Most new actors have tremendous optimism, as indeed they must, for without belief in themselves training is just a huge waste of time. 
 Remember that drama school has only prepared  you to work. 
 Your diploma is a mark of that preparation &mdash; nothing more and nothing less. 
 Clive Swift, in his admirable and essential book The Job of Acting  says that when you were at drama school &bquo;you were a big fish &mdash; now you're a tiddler&equo;. 
 But being in an overcrowded profession doesn't mean that you won't be considered. 
 New faces are arriving all the time and in some cases actors make a quick start with a first job or they may have a relatively long wait before they get off the mark. 
 This is true in more ways than simply obtaining an Equity card. 
 If you are fortunate enough to have secured an agent you will have someone with whom you can talk. 
 Your agent will want you to be working, but they cannot perform miracles for you. 
 It will be up to you to write constantly and make contacts everywhere and you will largely be responsible for yourself. 
 You always have your agent to refer to should anyone make you an offer. 
 If you have had problems finding an agent, you might consider the possibility of applying to join a co-operative where actors work together and run their own agency. 
 These can offer real support to new actors seeking their first taste of work and such co-ops do show enormous interest in the work of drama students in their last term. 
 It's difficult to evaluate how successful such co-ops are but many do seem to gain work on a fairly reasonable basis for their members, and they are certainly worth considering. 
 Most students find that the first job does eventually come along, and even that elusive Equity card is attainable. 
 Your first Equity card will be a provisional one; to become a full member you need to have worked for at least 30 weeks, not necessarily consecutively, Nevertheless, it's only realistic to assume that you may face longish periods of unemployment and to be prepared to deal with this constructively.  
 Isolation is one of the biggest problems for the unemployed actor, for acting is something which needs communication with others. 
 The actor is dependent on the stimulus of other faces and voices. 
 Quite a number of new actors form small fringe groups and work in plays on a profit sharing basis &mdash; and work opportunities may grow from such schemes. 
 Small, little-known groups don't generally muster a large audience, of course, but they are often a good way of commanding interest from future employers. 
 Certainly the new actor should never remain idle but create chances wherever possible. 
 This may sound like cold comfort when you're desperately hoping for something to come along and get you going &mdash; but continuing your work and maintaining skills is vitally important. 
 Above all you need new audience experience now you are out of drama school. 
 And, although nobody wishes to be exploited with low wages and very difficult conditions, it is frankly better to find the ways and means of presenting yourself somehow, than not perform at all. 
 The new actor is generally operating in top gear and if this momentum is stopped it can be very damaging to the morale and can result in an actor's technical skills going rusty &mdash; something to be avoided at all costs. 
 To speak of further training programmes now may sound like a mere desperate remedy, but it doesn't mean anything as arduous or as expensive as the full training of your drama school. 
 Actors who are serious about their work always look on the voice and movement class as an important part of their life. 
 It is, and keeping yourself in trim is very important when you're not working. 
 A ballet dancer who does not practise every day loses a lot of skill, as does a musician. 
 The actor is no different, although for some reason it is often thought that you are somehow ready to act, magically, the moment you enter a stage door. 
 Look after yourself, and particularly your voice and your memory, for without these you are dead meat. 
 So much of professional life is spent in the competitive atmosphere of interviews and auditions that a chance to work on themselves constructively and together is something actors relish. 
 Since 1980 professional training courses have proliferated and many can be found in and around London. 
 All of them take the working actors' problems into account and attempt to create classes which can make free hours both disciplined and profitable. 
 The Actors' Centre in Covent Garden has functioned since 1980, and offers a variety of professional classes in a relaxed atmosphere. 
 It also caters for those who want more intensive sessions. 
 For  movement and dance, the Pineapple Studios in the same part of town seems to be one of the best there is, though it is not intended primarily for dancers and actors &mdash; people from all sorts of professions come along to keep fit. 
 RADA holds regular annual classes for the professional during vacation periods; they offer refresher classes in both voice and movement which many actors find extremely valuable. 
 Everything in this chapter may seem terribly grey and pessimistic, but the truth is that acting is probably the most optimistic of all professions &mdash; it is the nature of actors to hope. 
 However tough things seem, it's vital that you should keep your spirits up, and remember that acting is an art and a thrilling one &mdash; though sometimes when you are struggling with the frustrating process of building a career, this can all get a bit obscured.   
 Conversations 
 The following conversations with a handful of actors centred mainly on their attitudes to drama training, and their opinions about the audition system. 
 Different generations are well represented here, from the newest professional at the beginning of her career to two who have been in the business for the last forty years. 
 Interestingly enough, having once entered the profession itself, age ceases to be a barrier, for actors of any age may easily teach each other something and share emotions honestly. 
 All the actors interviewed seemed to feel, and state quite naturally and simply that there was really nothing else for them to do but act. 
 None of them were particularly concerned with &bquo;glamour&equo;. 
 What does stand out is that everyone believes that the profession, its standards and its aims, matter , and they all feel an excitement about the job of acting. 
 All are concerned with practical issues such as the accessibility of the union to those who are coming into the profession and the need to find sensible ways of selecting actors for parts. 
 They voice real criticism of the way things are managed both artistically and in terms of employment. 
 I wish to express my sincerest thanks to &bquo;all those taking part&equo;, and for giving me their time. 
 For fairly obvious reasons the conversations begin with one of the most recent entrants to the profession, and ends with the two most senior actors. 
 Jenny Funnell 
 Trained at Webber Douglas Academy. 
 She won the 1984 Carlton Hobb's Radio Award at the BBC and completed a contract with the Repertory Company in July 1985. 
 Prior to this she played Ophelia in both Hamlet  and Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead  for Theatr Clwyd and on tour. 
 Also played Anna in Self-inflicted Wounds  by Tom Kempinski. 
 A.R. 
 Although you won the BBC radio competition for a place in the BBC Repertory company straight from drama school, you  decided to start your career by playing Ophelia in Hamlet at Theatr Clwyd. 
 Do you feel that was the right way round for you? 
 J.F. 
 Yes, I do. 
 I was terribly excited of course, to win the BBC competition but I do feel that going into the theatre first was a great help. 
 Doing Ophelia on stage before taking up the BBC contract meant that I went there with a little track record &mdash; I'd been blooded, if you like, and it made the whole thing a lot better. 
 A.R. 
 Tell me about your audition to get Ophelia. 
 J.F. 
 Well, I'd thought a lot about the part. 
 I knew I wouldn't play her as a wimp and the whole audition was based on the speech where she goes mad &mdash; the flowers, rosemary for remembrance and the whole bit. 
 George Roman read me and after I'd done the first reading he asked me about my own attitudes to the Part and then told me his as a director, which were completely different. 
 So I asked if I might go through it again and try some of the ideas he talked about. 
 A.R. 
 Did you find it easy to take direction from someone whom you didn't know? 
 J.F. 
 Yes. 
 Because that's where I realised that the drama school training helped a lot. 
 When you're training you have ideas shoved at you continually and are expected to change quickly &mdash; which is a very good thing. 
 A.R. 
 Did your experience at drama school come as a great surprise to you? 
 J.F. 
 Well, it did really. 
 I hadn't a clue what was expected. 
 I hadn't done &bquo;drama&equo; at school, thank God, so I was completely open coming straight from school. 
 There were a lot of people older than me with more experience of life. 
 A.R. 
 Do you think it a good idea coming into drama training direct from school? 
 J.F 
 It was for me. 
 I'd been trying to get into training since I was fourteen. 
 A.R 
 That's a bit early. 
 J.F. 
 I realise that now. 
 But it's all I ever wanted to do. 
 Most of my family is in the medical profession and doctors always seem to be full of drama. 
 My twin sister is a nurse and I suppose all the blood and thunder of things took me a different way. 
 It was  three years later that I did finally audition, at seventeen. 
 I did the well trodden path, with phoebe in As You Like It . 
 A R 
 Did you ever play that part? 
 J.F. 
 No. 
 When the school did do a production I played Celia. 
 A.R. 
 So you played quite a bit in the classics during training. 
 J.F. 
 I finished by playing Isabella in a production of Women Beware Women  in a 1950's style which may have helped when I came to my Ophelia, which was loosely based on a Princess Di concept. 
 But I think my most rewarding part at drama school was Carol in David Storey's play Sisters . 
 A.R. 
 Do you have a preference for classical acting or the modern theatre at the moment? 
 J.F. 
 I always wanted to do the heavy parts. 
 But I love playing comedy and then I'm not very tall. 
 Perhaps radio will allow me to play all the unsuitable roles that I can't do visually in the theatre, where it's just the voice and the character. 
 A.R. 
 What did you do for the BBC competition? 
 J.F. 
 We had to do four pieces with different accents and a piece of real sight reading of poetry without any time to look at it. 
 And then six of us did an extract from Great Expectations . 
 A.R. 
 What about television training? 
 Did the drama school include any of that? 
 J.F 
 Oh, yes. 
 We did a fortnight's production which I enjoyed immensely. 
 I hated seeing myself at first &mdash; we all did. 
 But it wasn't as bad as I thought it might be. 
 A.R. 
 Do you think drama school should include more training for television and film? 
 J F Definitely more for television. 
 But I prefer the stage really. 
 I like the feeling of doing it &bquo;now&equo; rather than it being a recording. 
 A.R. 
 Can you say what the best things are from your drama school experience and what has been of most value to you during your first year in the profession? 
 J.F. 
 The voice teaching and knowing how to keep yourself ready vocally; that really is the most important thing, which you don't realise when you start out. 
 And singing is part of that too &mdash; I didn't sing before I went into training even though I am  musical and play both the piano and the flute. 
 But being trained to use your singing voice is really good. 
 Perhaps some of the voice teaching was repetitive in the second term, but when there was a change in voice tutor who developed pieces of your own choice rather than just vocal exercises the whole thing came alive and interesting. 
 I think that drama school stops you playing safe too early on in life and encourages you to take risks. 
 I think if you don't go to train and still find your way into the profession some of the essential things you need to know about and be able to do will take that much longer to achieve. 
 Amanda Root 
 Trained at Webber Douglas Academy. 
 Her first job was in 1983 with the Leeds Playhouse Company, playing Essie in The Devil's Disciple  by Bernard Shaw. 
 She followed this by joining the Royal Shakespeare Company on tour playing Juliet and later repeating this performance in the Other Place at Stratford upon Avon. 
 While in Stratford she also played Jessica in The Merchant of Venice  and Moth in Love's Labours Lost . 
 Recent work includes a television play This Lightning Always Strikes Twice  and the play Dragons . 
 A.R. 
 Were you surprised how soon you got into the RSC &mdash; and that you have now ended up after only just over a year and a half in the profession playing Juliet and Hermia? 
 AMANDA 
 I was amazed! 
 It all happened so quickly &mdash; sometimes I think it may have been too quickly. 
 The only other experience I had was playing Essie in Shaw's play The Devil's Disciple  at Leeds&hellip; 
 A.R. 
 For which you auditioned with your drama school prepared pieces or by reading for the part? 
 AMANDA 
 No. 
 By reading for the part and an interview. 
 My first audition, as such, was actually for John Caird who wanted me to do a piece of Juliet. 
 I only had twenty four hours' notice and then I sat up all night learning a speech and then dried flat at the audition. 
 So they asked me to go away and come back again in a week which gave me breathing space and time at least to learn it properly. 
 A.R. 
 What speeches did you choose to do?  
 AMANDA 
 For Juliet I did &bquo;Thou knowest the mask of night is on my face&equo; and for Hermia I did the &bquo;puppet&equo; speech. 
 You know, all aggro and spirit. 
 And that got me into the last three so I had to do it all again at the Barbican which I think was to see if I could fill that theatre with enough presence and vocal range. 
 It was all terrifically exciting and when I got the parts I could hardly believe it. 
 A.R 
 On reflection, do you think the audition process is a good one? 
 AMANDA 
 Well, I haven t had enough experience of it yet. 
 Having been lucky with the only real audition I did which was for the RSC, I can't really complain about it. 
 But I think it's probably different for different people. 
 I mean, sight reading is another thing and not everyone is good at that, but it helps if you are. 
 My audition for Leeds was a sight reading job and it's something that you get from drama training &mdash; work that helps you cope with the sight reading at an audition &mdash; yes. 
 I mean, radio work classes helped a lot in that respect. 
 A R 
 Did you have any experience of a kind that helped you before you came to drama school? 
 AMANDA 
 It's very daunting to have to go to an audition for the first time in your life. 
 And you're not sure what is expected. 
 I mean I had no idea that by doing &bquo;I left no ring with her&equo; by Viola I was doing something that must have been heard a hundred times that day &mdash; I had no idea. 
 A.R. 
 Had you always wanted to be an actor? 
 AMANDA 
 Well, yes, I think I must have done. 
 I used to watch television and think &bquo;I want to do that&equo;. 
 All very clich&eacute;d but true. 
 At school I did English and Art, and looked at theatre design in art &mdash; it was all pointing the same way, really. 
 Of course at school they always tell you that you should do a secretarial course, which was absolutely dreadful, and they put you off the idea of a career in the theatre just as much as they can. 
 A.R. 
 Is classical training the most important ingredient for today's student? 
 You have come into a classical company which makes sense of that training but what other ingredients do you think vital? 
 AMANDA 
 I think in a company like the RSC you are privileged and you go on learning all the time. 
 It's like an extension of your training, with bigger resources and bigger audiences with which to practise and share the way you work. 
 That's what's  so marvellous. 
 Particularly in doing a great part like Juliet which we toured in all kinds of places before coming here to the Other Place venue. 
 A.R. 
 As a new young actor do you find that at Stratford you become part of a house style? 
 AMANDA 
 I don't think there's a style of voice, thank goodness. 
 But there is the chance of working with Cicely Berry, who is so wonderful at adding in a positive, performance orientated way to all the things you have learnt about voice. 
 And of course holding together a part like Juliet with long gaps between the performance nights and no real rehearsal in between is difficult to do &mdash; that can be rather hairy. 
 Sometimes you're a week away from the last performance you gave and then find yourself out there &mdash; so that the voice and understanding of the part does need constant refreshing. 
 That's the big lesson. 
 One is always in a state of learning &mdash; if you stop learning it's hopeless, I feel. 
 A.R. 
 What do you feel about working in the more modern style of play after your classical work with Stratford? 
 AMANDA 
 Yes. 
 There's lots of new plays being written that I look at and say &bquo;Oh yes &mdash; there's lots of opportunities there&equo;. 
 I mean, Sugar and Spice  for example by Nigel Williams; I'd love to have a go at doing the part of Sharon sometime, I think anything that is well written &mdash; that's important. 
 A.R. 
 Being well written? 
 AMANDA 
 Yes. 
 Perhaps doing Shakespeare spoils you for that, but I think having a text that is good is important. 
 We ought to do more modern work at drama school, as well as the classics. 
 I remember doing the Stoppard play Undiscovered Country  which was a great help and drama school needs to do more of that sort of thing. 
 We need to be of &bquo;now&equo; and maybe that's a better way of playing &bquo;then&equo;. 
 A.R 
 The past is often reflected by something called documentary drama, which uses improvisation before arriving at a script in its final state. 
 What do you feel about that? 
 AMANDA 
 Yes. 
 I loved all that. 
 But improvising round a text and its written characters, finding out about their intentions is very exciting too. 
 When I went to drama school it was all very new to me so I didn't have any real comparisons to make &mdash; which is a good thing. 
 I think you have to see what the system is and then see how you get it to work for yourself.  
 A.R. 
 Are there aspects of training that you find to have been missing or superficial now that you have had the chance of putting your technical skill to the test? 
 AMANDA 
 I think the training has been basically good. 
 I do think there's a greater need for other aspects to be included &mdash; like the Alexander technique, which helps with your body control. 
 For example, I had no idea about playing scenes on a raked stage, which can throw your weight out in placement very considerably. 
 Being technically aware of your body is very important and the more drama school does about that the better. 
 Kenneth Branagh 
 Trained at RADA. 
 Played Judd in Another Country  as almost his first job, following this with Francis , the title role in a new play at Greenwich Theatre. 
 joined the Royal Shakespeare Company playing Henry V, Laertes and King of Navarre in Love's Labours Lost  at Stratford upon Avon and in the Barbican Theatre, London. 
 Television includes Too Late to Talk to Billy, To the Lighthouse  and The Boy in the Bush . 
 A.R. 
 Did you go straight from school into actor training? 
 K.B. 
 Yes. 
 I thought it was better going to drama school direct rather than via a university and if you're going to act I think that's the way. 
 Before going to RADA I had been encouraged at my school in school plays, which included Oh, What a Lovely War . 
 I also did a great deal of amateur acting with the Progress Theatre in Reading. 
 A.R. 
 Was getting into RADA an audition process that you enjoyed, coming as you did straight from school. 
 K.B. 
 Well, I must admit there's a bit of me that thrives slightly on the exam syndrome &mdash; something that gets the adrenalin flowing rather like &bquo;first nights&equo;. 
 A bit gladiatorial, I suppose one might say &mdash; a sort of us and them feeling. 
 But getting into RADA was quite a searching process and I remember doing four one-hour work sessions with some of the tutors there, including the Principal, before finally being accepted for the three-year course there. 
 Now I think that's the right way to get to know the kind of talent there is, rather than a straight knock-down audition. 
 It was more humane.  
 A.R. 
 Once you had been through the three years what did you find had developed most for you as an actor? 
 K.B. 
 Leaving drama school you do feel as though you are really in control of your destiny. 
 You can at least organise your life around your aims and ambitions. 
 I must have prepared some twelve pieces for possible auditions. 
 A.R. 
 That's quite a lot &mdash; quite a programme of work. 
 As a young actor you obviously went for a great deal of variety in characters and accents. 
 K.B. 
 Oh, yes&hellip; my American piece, my Irish and the modern funny and modern serious &mdash; the same with the classics. 
 Always varied. 
 As an auditionee I knew I worked best if I attempted something outrageous so I prepared Lord Foppington from The Relapse  and you just have to let go with his Lordship otherwise there's no point to it. 
 I also put together an adaptation of my own from The Pickwick Papers  in which I took on four characters all travelling in a coach together, then mixed it with the narration, rather as they did with the production of Nicholas Nickleby . 
 I enjoyed doing this because it took people by surprise. 
 A.R. 
 Did you get your first job from an audition? 
 K.B. 
 Well, my first job came during four weeks of my last term at RADA when I had applied and been chosen for a television play called It's Too Late to Talk to Billy  which was set in Belfast &mdash; which is where I came from originally. 
 So the accent was no problem and I was the right age. 
 It gave me a temporary Equity card &mdash; mind you they took it away again as soon as I had done the four weeks work. 
 A.R. 
 And when you went back to RADA you finished your final term with what? 
 K.B. 
 I played Hamlet, which was a wonderful chance. 
 It got me noticed here although I think the one-man show I did outside on my own was the real deciding factor with the RSC. 
 A.R. 
 What was the one-man show about? 
 K.B. 
 I took the dramatic Poem Maud by Tennyson &mdash; all fourteen hundred lines &mdash; and learnt them and presented them working with two friends, a designer and a lighting man. 
 It was a great experience. 
 A.R. 
 Your first stage part was in something quite different from the classical roles, wasn't it?  
 K.B. 
 Yes. 
 I had the chance to audition for the transfer to London cast of Another Country  which requires young actors to play seventeen-year-olds. 
 Again, there were difficulties with Equity when I was selected and the whole thing had to go to arbitration because the company stood out for the casting it wanted. 
 A.R. 
 Equity seems to have been prominent in your career very early on. 
 Do you think the entry into Equity for drama students is unfairly organised? 
 K.B. 
 I do think there should be better arrangements for students leaving to audition and get Provisional cards and not always be intimidated by the &bquo;Equity only&equo; requirement at auditions. 
 If not a provisional card another way of permission to be seen properly at meaningful auditions. 
 After all, having a card isn't 
 Pamela Salem 
 Trained at the Central School of Speech and Drama in London, which was followed by repertory theatre in various parts of the country, national tours, and theatre abroad, Vienna, Stockholm, the Caribbean, and a British Council tour of Betrayal  in Switzerland and Portugal. 
 Her recent television credits include leads in the series Buccaneer, The Professionals, The Consultant, Into the Labyrinth, Lytton's Diary, Magnum, Seagull Island , and her film credits include The First Great Train Robbery, The Bitch , Morecambe and Wise's Night Train to Murder , Miss Moneypenny in Never Say Never Again, Universal City, After Darkness , and she has just completed Salome , playing Herodias. 
 A.R. 
 Would you say that things have changed a great deal from the days when you finished your drama school training at Central in 1966? 
 P.S. 
 I think the profession has changed because the opportunities are different. 
 first of all I'm absolutely against having the controlled entry into Equity. 
 It is much worse these days than it was in 1966. 
 Things should be made easier; after all actors come from all walks of life and we shouldn't keep them out. 
 They should have a provisional card for Equity at the beginning of their career.  
 A.R. 
 You mean that drama students who are graduating from training should have the chance to join Equity? 
 P.S. 
 Certainly they should. 
 Actors who train and go to drama school are usually on grants from local education authorities and to deny them the chance to join the profession &mdash; or at least compete properly &mdash; is ridiculous. 
 After all, becoming a provisional member of Equity doesn't give them work, it merely gives them the opportunity to work in the career for which they have trained. 
 A.R. 
 We've plunged in with the practical details rather than training itself. 
 Do you think that training is essential? 
 P.S. 
 Some kind of training is vital. 
 I'm not so sure about drama schools, sometimes. 
 The voice and movement work is very important but the professional requirements have changed, particularly in respect of film and television and there should be more training in this area. 
 We had next to none when I was at drama school and young actors need to know more about what will be expected of them on film sets and television studios. 
 And young actors have a greater instinct these days for film than they do for the stage, though this is not to say that stage training is not equally important; nevertheless as working actors we are getting more and more camera conscious in our acting and will continue to do so. 
 A.R. 
 Would you say that with so much emphasis on film and the camera, theatre training is becoming less important? 
 P.S. 
 No. 
 We have to remember that many of the new actors will find their first work in the theatre. 
 I think there are questions of style and dimension which come down to what type of theatre you are talking about. 
 Many actors start in the fringe productions &mdash; in small theatres almost as intimate as television, material concentrating on highly detailed reality. 
 Personally I'm not sure that highly detailed reality is what the theatre is truly about. 
 The film does that so much better. 
 A.R. 
 The theatre is always larger than life, isn't it? 
 P.S. 
 Much. 
 Which is why I think naturalistic plays with domestic situations need very careful handling. 
 They are so like the television it's sometimes hard to see why they are being done on a stage. 
 Yes, the stage is larger than life and it is about emotions that are big enough to wrap round you. 
 The theatre is at it's best being spectacular and for experimental new plays &mdash; I certainly don't think the theatre should be like television.  
 We have problems on British television because our theatrical tradition gets in the way, so-that characters talk too much, as though the medium is only half way from the stage. 
 Quite often the stage element in TV plays sounds phoney. 
 And all of this is a problem facing the new actor coming out of training. 
 A.R. 
 What do you think existing kinds of drama training do for the new actor? 
 P.S. 
 It centres the classical traditions in a way that no other kind of training can do. 
 Drama school isn't going to teach anybody to act but it does give the vital techniques with which to act and gives you a chance to make mistakes, experiment and find out about yourself. 
 But it should do more these days about practical matters &mdash; like the tax system and keeping yourself together while you're out of work and waiting for the next job, for that is fifty percent of what you'll be doing. 
 And, of course, working with professional directors who won't say things like &bquo;Your uvula isn't relaxed enough&equo;, but simply &bquo;I can't hear you&equo;. 
 A.R. 
 Getting into drama school is highly competitive and requires an audition and interview. 
 Later on in the profession itself the process goes on at a different level. 
 What do you think of the audition system generally? 
 P.S. 
 Awful &mdash; but what else can one do? 
 For drama school it is the first taste of things to come and on the whole a good thing. 
 Later in the profession it can vary a great deal. 
 If you feel you have done well at an interview and everyone seems to like you it is quite likely to find that you haven't got the part. 
 A cold and depressing interview can mean the reverse. 
 A.R. 
 Have you had that experience recently? 
 P.S. 
 I had an alarming reading for an Agatha Christie film where I was given several sheets of script to sight read without any logical link up in the scenes being read and no-one to read with, except an office assistant who couldn't read dialogue. 
 What was interesting was the director who said to everyone auditioning &mdash; &bquo;Look I know you are all good actresses. 
 I just want to get the looks right&equo;. 
 The audition was simply acting by numbers. 
 A.R. 
 And you got the part? 
 P.S. 
 I got the part. 
 A.R. 
 What would you say is the toughest time after finishing drama school?  
 P.S. 
 The second year. 
 The first year you're running on adrenalin and you're going to take on the world. 
 The second year you realise that it's terribly, terribly hard. 
 I remember when I left Central School in 1966 they said the average life for a woman in the theatre was three years and seven for a man before giving it up. 
 So after four years I thought I'd survived. 
 A.R. 
 What do you feel about actors keeping themselves in step with training once they are in the profession? 
 P.S. 
 I think it's very important but I think a lot of us are very lazy. 
 But you do need to do good voice and movement workouts &mdash; it's like going back to the keyboard for a musician. 
 Americans are much better at this than we are. 
 They enquire more. 
 They are not content to just rest on their laurels. 
 On the whole we are, until suddenly panic reigns and we must rush to a class again and limber up. 
 A.R. 
 So in a way we never stop training. 
 P.S. 
 And that means in a way one never stops working. 
 Patrick Ryecart 
 Trained at Webber Douglas Academy. 
 first major West End role was playing Marchbanks to Deborah Kerr's Candida in 1977. 
 Co-presented the play The Beastley Beatitudes of Balthazar B  as well as starring in it. 
 He followed this with Jack Absolute in The Rivals  at the National Theatre and David Mamet's A Life in the Theatre  with Freddie Jones at the Open Space. 
 His television includes Romeo in the BBC Shakespeare series and most recently Silas Marner . 
 His latest theatre has included Oberon/Theseus in A Midsummer Nights Dream  and the fascinating double Hugo/Frederick in Anouilh's Ring Round the Moon  at the open air theatre in Regent's park, London. 
 A.R. 
 What do you recall that's most important from your days as a drama student &mdash; which are about ten years ago? 
 P.R. 
 I can remember everything. 
 And I've rejected nothing, but the things that happen when working expand the horizons and the understanding. 
 The absolute discipline of drama training is one of the major things that helps you all the time. 
 I had already been part of the theatre working as an ASM at the Cambridge Arts Theatre, not with the University but with the  
 Prospect Theatre Company at a very exciting time. 
 When I came to train properly I was already aware of the professional background. 
 A.R. 
 Did you go into drama training straight from school? 
 P.R 
 Well, no. 
 I tried an abortive term at Durham University Drama Department and that made me realise even more that I wanted the real thing; by then I had, in any case, worked the AIM stint and I didn't need theory; I wanted practice. 
 A.R. 
 Would you say that drama school is necessary if you have already made some professional contact? 
 P.R. 
 I think the whole thing of being a student over three years &mdash; the camaraderie if you like, is vital. 
 The sharing and growing up without much money and finding a belief in yourself and the work. 
 The student life is very important &mdash; in perspective. 
 A.R. 
 You went to Hornchurch Rep for your first job? 
 P.R. 
 That's right. 
 It was the part of Sabbo in Rope ; mind you, I had been offered two leading roles at other reps that couldn't give me the vital Equity card &mdash; so Sabbo it was. 
 A.R. 
 So you would say the audition work proved successful? 
 P.R. 
 Not auditions as such. 
 People had seen me in my drama school finals. 
 No. 
 I'm quite hopeless at the set auditions, I think. 
 I know it's silly but I find it hard to take them seriously and really concentrate and not be distracted by the local cat cleaning himself on a window ledge or some such thing. 
 I nearly always dry. 
 Or did. 
 A.R. 
 Your first big stroke of fortune was playing Eugene Marchbanks in Shaw's Candida  with Deborah Kerr in the West End. 
 P.R. 
 And that was a tense business. 
 It took several months for that to come home and safe. 
 It was then that I became fully aware of how your personality is really at stake. 
 That the audition process was one that examined you totally &mdash; your private behaviour as well as your theatrical ability, the two feeding into each other to find a way to suit the requirements of the part and the particular aspects that were being looked at by the director, Michael Blakemore. 
 So achieving Marchbanks was a gradual and thoughtful affair &mdash; I remember being taken aside by the director and given a whole day after we had been rehearsing for two weeks and simply talking together about the play and about ourselves which was the real making of the  part over the next weeks of final rehearsal. 
 The audition had been one thing, the work&ndash;g through the part another &mdash; which is something it seems very hard for the audition process to make proper allowance for. 
 A.R. 
 Would you say that this way of casting and rehearsal is a luxury almost exclusive to the major nationally subsidised companies like the National Theatre or the RSC? 
 P.R. 
 Usually, I suppose, but Candida  and Marchbanks belonged to the commercial theatre &mdash; a straight West End run. 
 A.R 
 Did that part lead to the next in any way? 
 P.R. 
 Yes, it did. 
 Although the story of my doing Balthazar B and the Beastly Beatitudes  is a bit strange inasmuch as I ended up playing the part that was completely opposite from the one I was originally intended to do. 
 That had more to do with management and the presentation of the play to those who were backing it &mdash; so instead of playing Beefy, who is described as &bquo;the world's most beatific observer&equo; I played the opposite number who was &bquo;the world's last shy elegant young man&equo;. 
 Which was right be had no resemblance to what is commercially thought of a typecasting in any way &mdash; it's just that the mixture was right with Simon Callow. 
 A.R. 
 And later &mdash; much later at the National Theatre playing the young Captain Absolute &mdash; did that grow out of being seen in these performances? 
 P.R. 
 I'm sure it did. 
 The NT is obviously interested in new talent but also in staying power &mdash; track record in sustainment, as indeed they should. 
 Playing a big classic like The Rivals  is enormously demanding. 
 A.R. 
 Do you think typecasting is inevitable in one's early days as an actor? 
 P.R. 
 I think there is always an element of typecasting that is sensible, I mean it doesn't have to be restrictive. 
 In any case one person's typecasting isn't always another's. 
 But, yes &mdash; I read plays and I can see actors in the parts &mdash; I hope I can see what is suitable to their personalities. 
 Perhaps that is why I'm not all that much attached to being part of a permanent company for too long &mdash; I get bored by being around in one place for too long. 
 I think you need a great variety of experience to build your work and need to fail as well as succeed sometimes. 
 New actors need to try and widen their range all the time and in the same breath find a way of being  commercially as well as artistically viable. 
 I have been very lucky; the right opportunities have come along and yet every time you take them you are looking forward immediately to the next challenge. 
 I mean the most exciting moment of all is when you are actually chosen for a part &mdash; after that initial excitement it's a bit downhill &mdash; not because the work isn't marvellous but because the first challenge is the peak. 
 I think everyone needs the director to be vitally interested in the work well beyond the first week of actual performance. 
 In the West End there seems at the moment a tendency to rely too much on the goodwill of actors which is often accompanied by a failure to maintain a true interest in what is going on for the actor. 
 Perhaps directors in particular need to realise how much their vitality means to the continuing performance &mdash; that it isn't enough to be left up on a stage merely doing it night after night. 
 A.R. 
 Is that something that you feel may come from the &bquo;hothouse&equo; atmosphere of drama school in the first place? 
 P.R. 
 Maybe it does. 
 But it's no bad thing &mdash; we should take the two way traffic of actors and directors more seriously than we do. 
 And a production should not just be a matter of getting a good notice and leaving it to go to seed slowly. 
 David Suchet 
 Trained at LAMDA. 
 Has worked a great deal with the Royal Shakespeare Company playing the leading roles of Shylock in The Merchant of Venice , Achilles in Troilus and Cressida , Bolingbroke in Richard II  and Iago in Othello . 
 His performances on television have been as varied as Freud, and as Blott in Tom Sharpe's Blott on the Landscape . 
 He won the BBC best radio actor award in 1979 for the Kreutzer Sonata . 
 His films include Song for Europe, Greystoke  and The Little Drummer Girl . 
 A.R. 
 Did you always want to be an actor? 
 D.S. 
 No. 
 Originally I wanted to be a doctor like my father, but it was soon clear I didn't have the intelligence for that &mdash; that's to say I wasn't any good at mathematics and physics and that sort of thing. 
 A.R. 
 No actor seems to be. 
 I wonder why?  
 D.S. 
 Stanislavsky says it's the multiplication table syndrome. 
 He gives an example about lifting a heavy weight and doing a multiplication sum at the same time and says you can't do it. 
 Well, I was one of the people who couldn't do it even if I wasn't lifting a heavy weight. 
 A.R. 
 You didn't do that exercise in drama school? 
 D.S. 
 Not that I can remember. 
 I went to drama school having done all the correct things that drama students are supposed to ignore &mdash; like going to public school (Wellington) and dressing in conventional clothes. 
 The teachers gave me a rough time for a couple of years because my student and acting image didn't fit. 
 I still don't feel it's necessary to wear scruffy clothes to be an actor. 
 A.R. 
 Had any of these attitudes been generated by your first experience with the National Youth Theatre under Michael Croft? 
 D.S. 
 Not at all. 
 I can remember doing Bartholomew Fair  at the Royal Court Theatre with the NYT and seeing all the scenery and lighting down on the stage at the end of the last performance and thinking how exciting it was to belong to the world of make-believe. 
 A.R. 
 And was that your reason for becoming an actor? 
 D.S. 
 It was then. 
 After that came my training at LAMDA and the realisation that make-believe or not, acting was hard work. 
 And because, as I say, of my conventional background there seemed at the time a tendency to think of me as a reactionary young man. 
 A.R. 
 Did you think of yourself as a classical actor in those days? 
 D.S. 
 Certainly not. 
 In fact I found Shakespeare very difficult to get on with and wasn't at all sure that I wanted to. 
 So the first thing I did was to spend ten years with the Royal Shakespeare Company! 
 A.R. 
 In which you played a lot of leading parts, as the days went by. 
 D.S. 
 That's right. 
 And I discovered the language and size of the plays in which I was working with all their complexities. 
 You can't possibly hope to get that in your early days as a student. 
 The real work of acting takes on a different dimension. 
 It's not a matter of theorising &mdash; hard work never is. 
 Acting can be both  pleasure and torture &mdash; but it is not fun and people are sometimes more concerned with the image of being an actor &bquo;at work&equo; rather than just working. 
 A.R. 
 Can you say that your drama training has served you well? 
 D.S. 
 One of the great things about drama school is what you learn to reject as much as what you actually learn. 
 When I visit drama schools now &mdash; and I firmly believe the professional actor is someone who should remain in touch with students &mdash; it's a matter of trying to help future actors to gain a clearer focus on the profession they are joining. 
 There are so many things that matter. 
 Health and stamina, plus a constant awareness of building the voice. 
 Training is about trying to put the component parts together &mdash; the physical and the mental, working towards an agility in both. 
 A.R. 
 What would you advise the new actor or the student to concentrate on in terms of auditioning? 
 D.S. 
 My word of advice is this. 
 Don't worry about going out there to give the greatest performance of any particular speech and then come away depressed because you know you've done it badly. 
 I would say always remember that what is on show is oneself, not necessarily the ability to perform brilliant characterisations. 
 The things to remember are the practical ones about yourself. 
 &bquo;Next please. 
 Mr Suchet!&equo; 
 You go out there with trembling knees, and they are already noticing those trembling knees. 
 The greatest acting role in an audition is to appear just to be yourself. 
 A.R. 
 Oscar Wilde said the most difficult pose was the natural one. 
 D.S. 
 Absolutely. 
 And even more difficult in an audition situation where they are looking at your height, weight and how much stage you can fill by your very presence. 
 Does he engage me? 
 That is probably the most important question the panel are asking themselves. 
 And the next thing will be &bquo;what is his attitude to this audition &mdash; is it positive?&equo; 
 Always remember that they have asked to see you and that is what they want to do. 
 So dress the part. 
 Don't go along in a dirty T shirt and floppy gym shoes or try to over-impress or be antagonistic. 
 But just remember that you are being judged even before you speak a word. 
 This is the first big lesson to learn. 
 The next important lesson is to never apologise for being there. 
 The number of auditions I have taken and staffed with the familiar question &bquo;what would you like to do?&equo; 
 And the reaction has been one of slight stuttering, saying &bquo;Er, erm,&hellip; well&hellip; 
 I'm  sorry but er&hellip; well I've got two pieces that er won't take long. 
 The first speech is from Shakespeare and it's taken from the Chorus in Henry&hellip; 
 Henry V and the second piece I'd like to do is a contract if&hellip; if, that is, we have time.&equo; 
 OK, by now you've lost valuable time and probably irritated the entire panel by dithering instead of being sure of what you're going to say, quite apart from getting on with the actual pieces you have learned. 
 A.R 
 Of course you cannot teach confidence but you can teach a way of acquiring it. 
 We always want to see and hear confident actors. 
 D.S. 
 Exactly that, although God knows confidence is difficult enough to hold on to. 
 But you do  have a right to be there and to be heard. 
 Announce yourself clearly and think of what you intend to do. 
 Take your time &mdash; and do it. 
 Linda Marlow 
 Trained at Central School of Speech and Drama. 
 On leaving she joined the Repertory Company at Worthing and played a great deal on the repertory circuit. 
 Since those days she has done a great deal of work with Steven Berkoff &mdash; particularly in his play for two people, Decadence  which she has played in London, Los Angeles and Dublin. 
 She co-founded, wrote and performed with a rock group in the early 70's called &bquo;The Sadista Sisters&equo;. 
 In films She has recently completed a feature role in Mr Love  for David Puttnam. 
 A.R 
 What do think is the most important thing for an actor to keep uppermost in mind when working in the profession? 
 L.M 
 Gauging the kind of people you are going to meet in the way of giving you work. 
 It is your personality and your personal care that is going to be noticed all the time. 
 If you're up for a &bquo;tart&equo; part you must be prepared to present a flavour of the role as you see it. 
 If it's a general audition, be prepared for anything; look good and concentrate like mad on your work &mdash; always do that anyway. 
 A.R 
 Do you think actors need to keep in training once they have graduated from drama school? 
 L.M. 
 I think most actors are conscious of the need to keep in  training. 
 It's a very physically demanding business; dancing is a wonderful way of keeping in training and also gives you a bigger scope in theatre these days. 
 I think dancers can teach actors a lot and vice versa. 
 A.R. 
 Have you done any drama teaching yourself? 
 L.M. 
 Yes. 
 At the East 15 Drama School I have taken audition technique sessions, which was all fine and large but I encouraged them to write their own material as well as having stock pieces to do. 
 Writing your own pieces can be very exciting &mdash; if you have a talent for writing &mdash; and can be more suitable to show off your personal talents. 
 That and sight reading which is probably the most important thing of all. 
 Auditioning makes me very nervous but sight reading &mdash; maybe because I'm better at it &mdash; inspires me with more confidence. 
 In filming you have a lot of this to do where you read a script through once and then have go. 
 A.R 
 In the theatre you've worked a lot with Steven Berkoff and his own plays. 
 Has this been something special in acting for you? 
 L.M. 
 Yes. 
 Very special. 
 I know Steven's method of working very well now. 
 We did Decadence  in London and America together &mdash; and we've made a film for Channel 4 television. 
 There is Something very physical as well as verbally strong about Steven's plays. 
 But I think it's always a case of what you bring to acting &mdash; bring to the parts that are being offered to you. 
 When I did Nurse Ratchett in One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest  up in Manchester I read the novel and found a speech in the book that was really wonderful on the character and I asked the director if I could read it for him. 
 I got the job and the speech became included in the play itself. 
 I think you do have to do your homework as an actor. 
 A.R. 
 There are not the chances around these days as there were some years ago. 
 Do you think actors now leaving training face greater difficulties? 
 L.M. 
 Without doubt they do. 
 When I got my first job out of training it was at Worthing in a juvenile leading role and I got my Equity card because I had been chosen. 
 That doesn't happen any more with young actors coming out of drama school. 
 Twenty years ago it was expected that if you trained you would surely be accepted into the membership of your trade union and be given the chance to compete for the roles that were suitable. 
 It was the last days of the old tradition, I  suppose and I'm glad I was lucky enough to be part of them. 
 Now there is no guarantee that a career actually exists and Equity are not making it all any easier for the new young actors to establish themselves. 
 And with the theatre running into difficulties about subsidy it's not getting any more hopeful. 
 A.R. 
 In fact the dream that we all had about Great Britain acknowledging it's theatre and funding it properly has suffered a lot of setbacks since the &bquo;sixties&equo;. 
 L.M. 
 Yes. 
 I think the present Government has a lot to answer for. 
 After all we knew that subsidy didn't exist to subsidise empty seats but rather the necessary and new ideas that were wanted at the time. 
 That is what subsidy is really all about. 
 A.R. 
 So for new actors coming into the business of acting what do you advise as the best possible course of action? 
 L.M. 
 To be ready to work at all times. 
 Auditions are a painful necessity of life and not a fair judgement on your career but you have to go through them. 
 It's all experience and that's what you have to have a lot of before getting your own way about anything. 
 A.R. 
 Or &bquo;you don't go through an experience; an experience goes through you&equo;? 
 L.M. 
 True &mdash; like a dose of salts! 
 But as to advice &mdash; well, don't just sit around waiting for the telephone to ring. 
 Actors must be prepared to create their own work. 
 Anywhere &mdash; on the fringe &mdash; forming small companies and producing their own work. 
 Letting people see them at work. 
 &bquo;Nothing will come of nothing&equo;, as King Lear said once upon a time. 
 Anthony Sher 
 Trained at Webber Douglas Academy. 
 Born in South Africa. 
 Repertory seasons at Liverpool Everyman Theatre, Nottingham playhouse, Edinburgh Lyceum. 
 In London played in Teeth &bquo;n&equo; Smiles  and Cloud Nine  at the Royal Court Theatre. 
 John, Paul, George, Ringo and Bert, Goosepimples, Gone West  (National Theatre) King Lear, Tartuffe, Mayday, Richard III  and Red Noses  with the Royal Shakespeare Company. 
 Television includes The History Man  and films Shadey . 
 He is also author of the book Year of the King . 
 A.R. 
 How did you come to be an actor? 
 A.S. 
 Well, I was always going to be an artist and it was always assumed that I would leave South Africa and go to somewhere like Italy and study at an art school. 
 I'm not sure how that ambition changed course in Cape Town. 
 I was always terribly shy and I was sent to what were known as elocution lessons &mdash; to get me out of myself. 
 A.R. 
 Did Shakespeare cross your path early on? 
 A.S. 
 Well, not really. 
 I remember the elocution teacher was very keen on the modern plays that were being published then &mdash; and I know we worked on Pinter which actually led me to use the part of Mick in The Caretaker  for my subsequent auditions in England for a place in drama school. 
 But I had very little idea of anything at the time and I didn't do very much acting. 
 A.R. 
 When you came to London to audition finally was it your first visit here? 
 A.S. 
 Yes, and my parents had booked the audition for the Central School and found me a bed-sit in Swiss Cottage and being completely naive it was assumed that this was where I would be going. 
 Two days later in what was a completely strange country I found myself doing this audition piece and I can remember very clearly sitting in the antechamber afterwards and the registrar popping her head round the door and saying balefully to a group of us sitting there, &bquo;Sorry, none of you&equo;. 
 A.R. 
 An immediate rejection. 
 A.S. 
 Absolutely shattering. 
 In fact I refused to believe it and went back to check, feeling &bquo;they couldn't mean me&equo;. 
 Luckily we were still in time to get into the RADA auditions, which I did and got a letter from them saying &bquo;not only are you rejected but we strongly advise you to think about another career&equo;. 
 So there I was &mdash; a bit stranded, not knowing where to go next. 
 I finally made it into Webber Douglas where I finally realised that this was where I belonged. 
 It seemed to suit me and I seemed to suit it and I felt comfortable. 
 A.R. 
 Can you remember anything of that audition? 
 A.S. 
 I can remember doing my Mick again from The Caretaker  and for Shakespeare I did an outrageous choice of Cardinal Wolsey from Henry VIII , which I don't think I shall ever be suited to playing. 
 A.R. 
 On reflection, what do you feel about drama training?  
 A.S. 
 I think it's terribly important for people to train. 
 Acting is not a profession where you can simply stroll on &mdash; although I know a lot of fine actors have done that. 
 I learnt an enormous amount and felt then as I do now that there really isn't enough training. 
 Particularly the physical side of the work &mdash; where there isn't nearly enough. 
 I think we are under-trained physically here, unlike the Continental or the American actor who are trained as acrobats of gymnasts. 
 In England we concentrate on the voice. 
 A.R. 
 Playing Richard III  combines both of these features for you in a way that makes your point. 
 A.S. 
 Yes, it does. 
 Playing Richard is so bound up with physical attitude, and I think that as actors we are not well enough equipped to meet that kind of physical thinking in that kind of role. 
 The Alexander technique would be invaluable if it were properly included in all drama training programmes. 
 And I think you find it goes beyond drama school, in say a company like the RSC, where we have the top person in voice but do not have the equal in physical advice and guidance. 
 A R. What you are saying is that everyone seems to miss the work of Litz Pisk &lsqb;a legendary movement teacher at Central School&rsqb; who had such movement sense. 
 A S. I remember when I was working as a dogsbody in the 59 Theatre Company in Manchester a group of Central School students came to be the spirits in a production of The Tempest  and these were Pisk trained and had, it seemed to me then, a marvellous range of body language. 
 You do see this much more in foreign companies and I think if we in Britain could match the physical and the vocal more we would really be on top with our training resources. 
 A.R. 
 Are you saying that this combination of vocal and physical training stems from the demands of the classical play, like Richard III , or do you think a different approach is needed for the modern writer? 
 A S. No, I don't think so. 
 The big difference is the dimension of verse, obviously, and you have to live through that differently. 
 Classical acting is really quite a recent thing for me so it's a case of speaking the verse as naturally as possible but observing it &bquo;s rhythms and structure. 
 A.R. 
 How do you feel about young people wanting to become actors, these days?  
 A.S. 
 When it comes to acting people will always say &bquo;Don't &mdash; you're going to get hurt&equo;, and of course you won't believe them. 
 And you will get hurt. 
 I think it's a terribly cruel profession &mdash; it's always YOU that is being rejected, the meat market side of the business. 
 It's hurtful when you see good actors out of work and the way in which their confidence is corroded by the system. 
 I think there should be a more stringent system of entry into the drama schools so that there is a higher standard of work achieved by the time they come to join the profession. 
 Auditions are quite unreal &mdash; I mean, how can anyone show what they are about by coming into a room and doing the opening speech of a play? 
 In playing a part you have a whole journey of rehearsals behind you. 
 A.R. 
 So how would you recommend that actors are cast? 
 A.S. 
 In the profession I would much prefer to see work generated by the directors, and the casting directors taking more trouble to go round and see the actor at work, taking people on the basis of work they had already seen. 
 Even the interview system is not an ideal one &mdash; once again you're having to sell yourself &mdash; and if you're a character actor like I am I cannot show myself without being somebody else. 
 One has very little to offer in an interview and one sits there feeling rather embarrassed. 
 A.R. 
 That sort of system is not so easy for actors looking for their first job but easier when you are well known. 
 A.S. 
 Well yes, but let me say that I gave up going to auditions well before I became well known through The History Man , on television. 
 I gave up because I felt insulted. 
 I think you have to stand by what you believe. 
 I have been lucky, I suppose. 
 One job has  led to another but I do remember a particular film audition which I walked out of, much to the concern of everyone, my agent, and the casting director. 
 I was thought to be getting above myself because I refused to sight read a scene. 
 I offered tapes of myself. 
 But it was useless. 
 No, I do not believe in the audition system. 
 A.R. 
 Well, you're obviously not asked to audition now. 
 A.S. 
 It is a privilege; and one doesn't forget that. 
 Working with the  on the work in hand. 
 I must confess I find being a complete freelance is a strain and I love the family feeling of a company. 
 Material missing from transcription at this point; cannot correct or quantify, as original not available and book out of print 
 But some actors prefer the risks. 
 They like to live dangerously.  
 A.R. 
 Rather than act dangerously. 
 Would you say that you are building a reputation in eccentric roles? necessarily eccentric &mdash; that just sounds a gimmick. 
 Finding a character that is true in every moment is quite another matter. 
 Michael Denison and Dulcie Gray 
 Met at drama school, married in 1939, honeymooned in weekly rep in Aberdeen and have starred together in more West End productions than any living theatrical partnership. 
 These include Candida  and Heartbreak House  by Shaw; The Wild Duck  by Ibsen; Where Angels Fear to Tread , from E.M. 
 Forster; On Approval  by Frederick Lonsdale and Bedroom Farce  by Alan Ayckbourn (for the National Theatre). 
 Michael Denison's best known film role was Algie in The Importance of Being Earnest  and he appeared with Dulcie in My Brother Jonathan . 
 Recently they have both played in a major revival of The School for Scandal  and have toured the Near and Far East. 
 Dulcie is the author of twenty-two works &mdash; seventeen crime stories, two novels, two plays and a book on the conservation of butterflies. 
 She and Michael have collaborated on a &bquo;young person's guide to the theatre&equo; and Michael has written two volumes of joint memoirs &mdash; Overture  and Beginners and Double Act . 
 A.R. 
 You both went into the theatre together from the same drama school? 
 M.D. 
 That's-right &mdash; the Webber Douglas Academy. 
 We went into weekly rep in Aberdeen. 
 D.G. 
 At first it was only Michael that was going but on hearing that we were hoping to marry they decided to have me as well. 
 A.R. 
 And since then you've worked a great deal together? 
 M.D. 
 In sixty-four stage productions, so far &mdash; starring in twenty-six of them in London. 
 But first, for me everything was interrupted by six years of army service after which like so many others I had to start again. 
 Fortunately for us both, Dulcie had become a star both in theatre and films.  
 A.R. 
 When did you start acting? 
 M.D. playing female parts at school &mdash; until my voice broke. 
 D.G. 
 For me it was also at school playing Sir Andrew Aguecheek. 
 So we both started by playing the opposite sex. 
 But I think I got into drama professionally in the first place by accident. 
 I was told there was an acting scholarship going and I was broke so I took an audition and by a marvellous chance, won the scholarship. 
 A.R. 
 Can you remember what you did? 
 D.G. 
 Absolute total recall &mdash; it was Portia's famous &bquo;The quality of mercy is not strained&equo; from The Merchant of Venice  &mdash; and mercy was what I was asking for, literally, at that moment. 
 Anyway the moment I trod the stage I felt completely at home. 
 I can't explain it more than that. 
 A.R. 
 What was the training about in those pre-war days? 
 M.D. 
 Much as today, I would think. 
 There was a lot of concentration on the voice and good diction. 
 I came to the school with considerable amateur experience of Shakespeare with the Oxford University Dramatic Society and had even played in a real theatre in Oxford. 
 So the school's first job was to cut me down to normal proportions &mdash; which they did. 
 I think the persons who helped me most were the professional actors who were playing in the West End and came to us as teachers during the day. 
 D.G. 
 Ellen O &bquo;Malley, though she had long retired, was a wonderful teacher too. 
 She was marvellous at getting people to let go of inhibitions I remember. 
 She had played a lot of Shaw including Candida ; and created Ellie Dunn in Heartbreak House , named after her by Shaw. 
 M.D. 
 And perhaps even more to us as modern actors was Alison Legatt, then playing with No&euml;l Coward and Gertrude Lawrence every evening. 
 D.G. 
 Yes, she was the first person who made me realise that acting was more than just speaking and doing. 
 You had to understand and project what made your character tick. 
 A.R. 
 When you work now with young actors do you notice great differences in their approach to acting from your own? 
 M.D. 
 Well, the majority have begun on TV rather than weekly rep &mdash; resulting in a gain in &bquo;reality&equo; and a loss in audibility. 
 They  have also had to face greatly increased competition both to get into drama school and into the profession. 
 When I went to Webber Douglas they practically fell on any man as a rare species. 
 I remember there was seventy-five girls to seven men at the time. 
 A R. So getting a good part in the end of term productions was much more competitive for you, Dulcie? 
 D.G. 
 Oh, much; just like the profession itself in a way. 
 I believe the ratio of men's jobs to women's is 8 to 1. 
 A.R. 
 Would you say that most of your professional careers have been spent on the stage? 
 D.G. 
 Yes. 
 Perhaps the best decade was the sixties when we played a lot of Shaw, Wilde and Ibsen. 
 These included Candida, Heartbreak House, The Wild Duck  and An Ideal Husband  in which we agreed to play the dreadful Chilterns. 
 A.R. 
 Why dreadful? 
 M.D. 
 As you know, Wilde's full names were Oscar Fingal O'Flaherty Wills Wilde. 
 It was said of An Ideal Husband  that the characters of Lord Goring, Lord Caversham and Mrs Chevely were the work of Oscar Wilde and Sir Robert and Lady Chiltern of Fingal O'Flaherty. 
 A.R. 
 Has the position of the director changed in theatre for you over the years? 
 M.D. 
 I think it has changed. 
 Directors are more autocratic and powerful than they were &mdash; particularly in casting. 
 More autocratic and more absentee than before. 
 Sometimes they give you the feeling that they have done you a great favour by attending rehearsals and at the end of the rehearsal period it's &bquo;Bye-bye loves, now you do your thing and I'll go off and do another&equo;. 
 Directors should keep their finger on the pulse of a production throughout it's run. 
 A.R. 
 Which leads to the usual problems associated with casting and auditioning. 
 Do you think there's a better means of selection, other than what seem generally to be regarded as a rather barbaric system? 
 M.D. 
 Of course it's barbaric. 
 But what alternative is there if you are unknown to a potential employer? 
 It's a kind of exam &mdash; and it's important to school yourself to be good at exams. 
 A R. One of the biggest questions for young actors today is the problem of becoming members of Equity in order to work in  the business for which they have trained. 
 Michael, you have done a lot of work both with and for Equity, what do you feel about the present day students' dilemma? 
 M.D. 
 Well, it is a dilemma. 
 I've never entirely agreed with the policy of restricted entry, although one knows all the arguments why this has been necessary. 
 I think we have to remember at all times that we belong to a profession in which there cannot be qualifications. 
 The individual's employment involves a subjective judgement on the part of someone else. 
 I would like to think that the problem of entry into Equity could be resolved in the future &mdash; difficult as it is. 
 Perhaps graduates of a number of drama schools might be given a provisional Equity card requiring a minimum number of engagements (and/or weeks) to be worked within the two or three years of it's validity, if the holder is to be accepted into full membership. 
 A.R. 
 Is it true that within the membership of Equity there is a fair proportion of deadwood? 
 M.D. 
 Well, with a membership of 32,000 and an unemployment level of 70% it follows that there are many members who get little or no work within the profession. 
 It would be harsh, however, to stigmatise them as deadwood. 
 A performer can only prove his talent by performing &mdash; meanwhile by their subscriptions members play an important part in making Equity effective. 
 A.R. 
 Has the profession become too large? 
 D.G. 
 There will always be more people wanting to act than there are jobs available. 
 M.D. 
 The acting profession has actually grown smaller since, say, 1900. 
 Provincial cities which had ten to twelve theatres now have one or two and probably there were double the number of actors at that time. 
 Standards were variable, of course, and first the cinema and then television wiped out a lot of bad theatre as well as some good. 
 A R. 
 Do you think the training of young actors should be more orientated towards television? 
 D.M. 
 It is the most important medium for getting known by the general public and affecting the attitude of employers but the theatre is still the best place for learning your trade. 
 As Richard Attenborough once said to me, &bquo;If you haven't learnt to play to an audience that is present, how can you expect to play to one that isn't?&equo;   
 States, Religions, and Ruling Ideas 
 Catholic Nationalists and Protestant Loyalists Today 
 STATES AND RELIGIOUS INSTITUTIONS 
 The chief purpose of the chapter is to outline how the two opposing groups in Ireland developed their dominant beliefs in the context of the new states of Ireland, and moulded the states to support them, strengthening antagonisms between the two groups. 
 What changed with the partition of Ireland in 1920 was that the two dominant alliances were internally reorganized. 
 In particular the protestant bloc lost the Southern protestant landowning gentry. 
 The two alliances were ascribed territories in which to produce their social structures, political institutions, coercive bodies, informal and interpersonal networks of maintaining influence, and more clearly defined hegemonic cultures. 
 The two societies gave expression to their own dominant interests as far as possible unhindered by each other's interference. 
 The process was assisted in the North by the self-exclusion of Britain from internal Ulster affairs by setting up the Stormont parliament which survived from 1922 to 1972. 
 Protestant &mdash; loyalist domination, successor to the ascendancy, was circumscribed to one corner of Ireland while the catholic &mdash; nationalist alliance asserted total domination in the remainder. 
 The Catholic &mdash; Nationalist State 
 The direct consequences of this dramatic political change differed in each state, but paralleled each other, consolidating each alliance's power. 
 The Southern state became more catholic and nationalist in character. 
 Its protestant groups declined in numbers, wealth, power, and cultural importance (K. Bowen 1983; Walsh 1970). 
 The Northern state became wholly dominated by protestant loyalists and became extremely coercive in its dealings with the substantial catholic &mdash; nationalist remnant within its borders. 
 It was the failure to incorporate the catholic &mdash; nationalist remnant into  the consensus of the Northern statelet which resulted in sporadic violence, institutionalized and structural on the one side and insurgent-guerilla on the other. 
 The two alliances succeeded in creating sufficient structures of hegemony and coercion to maintain social control for a significant number of years. 
 But Northern reliance on force, necessary if the character of the state was to be absolutely preserved, was the weakest point and the eventual undoing of the apparent stability achieved by the partition settlement. 
 The Southern protestants have diminished greatly in numbers since 1911, because of the loss of life in the 1914&ndash;18 war, some emigration, and probably mixed catholic &mdash; protestant marriages (Walsh 1970; White 1975; Ch. 7, below). 
 In 1911, the protestant population in the South was 10 per cent. 
 By 1925 it was down to 7 per cent and in 1971 it stood at around 4.1 per cent. 
 Over the same period, the Church of Ireland experienced continuing rounds of church closures and became top-heavy in numbers of clergy. 
 Statistics up to 1971 showed it as having an old-age structure and to have been in continuing decline, though there are recent signs of improvement (Census of Ireland 1981). 
 Southern protestants do not appear to be particularly oppressed by the state (White 1975: 169), but they would clearly change aspects of the constitution and legislation if they were in a position to do so. 
 They have always retained a low political profile. 
 They have also never been perceived by the state as a threat, perhaps because of the revolutionary pedigree of some of their &eacute;lite. 
 As such, their own life-styles, societies, and schools have been relatively protected, but perhaps at the expense of political action. 
 A practical ideology for a catholic Ireland was worked out and the aim of a society uncontaminated by the outside world was pursued. 
 Both church and state functioned symbiotically. 
 For his part, de Valera, prime minister for most of the period from 1932 to 1959, pursued isolationist policies, economically, politically, and culturally, seeking at once self-sufficiency, neutrality, the restoration in part of Gaelic culture through the minimal enforcement of the Irish language, and the control of media consumption. 
 In concrete terms, de Valera was acting on behalf of the established economic interests of rural Ireland, in particular the small landowners and small businessmen. 
 The commitment to the eradication of rural and urban poverty, while not entirely  forgotten, was subordinated to the goal of economic independence from Britain. 
 The path pursued particularly matched the clergy's vision of the profanity of towns and sacrality of rural life. 
 This was despite the fact that the reform of Irish catholicism in the nineteenth century sprang mainly from urban areas. 
 One must also remember that the bulk of the clergy both in Ireland and in the remainder of catholic Europe came from rural backgrounds, where the sense of God is, or was, part of the air one breathes (Acquaviva 1979). 
 From de Valera's point of view &mdash; and the majority of the nation and its politicians would have concurred &mdash; the fact that the Free State was over 90 per cent catholic meant that its moral and social outlook would reflect catholic beliefs. 
 This was seen to be the democratic process at work. 
 The results of isolationism in terms of human suffering were massive emigration (some 20,000 every year to Britain up to the 1960s), and industrial and commercial underdevelopment until the late 1950s. 
 But there were undoubted benefits to both church and state in this set of policies, for they were to the mutual advantage of nationalism and catholicism as these were perceived by their respective institutional representatives, namely the politicians and the hierarchy. 
 They were the result of catholic &mdash; nationalist success in establishing a separate state, so separate that the protestant tradition as a political force had been excised from the thinking of the entire catholic grouping in the South, from church to state to popular consciousness. 
 This occurred despite the continuity of the catholic hierarchy in Northern Ireland and despite the war experience of those catholics who had been involved in the army. 
 Armistice Day is still only celebrated in Southern Ireland by protestants: as late as the early 1970s, you could still tell a protestant by his poppy on 11 November. 
 The commemoration of the dead in the First World War was seen as a triumphalist commemoration of those who died for Britain. 
 The very existence of the catholic state in all but name, the realization, if only in part, of the territory of Ireland as both catholic and nationalist, had a significant and continuing impact on both the clergy's practical theology and the laity's day-to-day perceptions of social reality. 
 Similarly, the de facto  existence of the protestant enclave in the North and its pursuit of protestant dominance in that state may have even reinforced a similar, though integralist, approach in the South.  
 With independence the Irish Free State developed a type of political party organization on modern lines, but without the genuinely class-based politics one finds in other European countries. 
 The party structure followed was based on the Irish civil war antagonism of 1922&ndash;3, with the pro-Treaty party more or less in power until the anti-Treaty party entered politics in 1930. 
 However, both sides developed a centralized party organization, with politicians following the party line. 
 The Protestant &mdash; Loyalist State 
 The condition of the Northern catholic &mdash; nationalist minority has been very different from that of the majority in the South. 
 The Northern minority has been feared throughout the period by protestant loyalists for two main reasons. 
 On the one hand, force has been required to subordinate it, and, on the other, it has always threatened to outbreed protestant loyalists, an outcome which has only been avoided by catholic &mdash; nationalist migration over the past seventy years. 
 The loss of numerical superiority by protestants would result in the collapse of their statelet. 
 Disappearance of their dominance would lead to a unified Ireland or else the restructuring of a new statelet with smaller geographical boundaries in which their dominance was again reassured. 
 In any case, repartition is not out of the question. 
 Recent work on the religious demography of Northern Ireland by Compton and Power (Compton 1985; Compton and Power 1986; Ford 1986; Commins in Clancy, et al . 
 1986) indicates a separating out of protestant and catholic, with the catholic population drifting westwards and vice versa. 
 The majority of the Roman catholic remnant in the North still believe in a united Ireland. 
 They demonstrate this partially by their support for the two nationalist parties, Sinn Fein and the Social Democratic and Labour Party, though support for the latter does not necessarily imply nationalism. 
 Despite the official socialist tendencies of these two parties, a substantial number of their voters do not appear to question the maintenance of a capitalist-type class structure in a new Ireland. 
 The Workers' Party still fails to command many votes in elections north or south of the border. 
 The provisional movement is divided on the issue of capitalism but, for  the time at least, has an openly declared policy of achieving an island-wide socialist republic by the combined means of violence and the democratic process. 
 The SDLP, still the main party of catholic nationalists in Ulster, has dropped much of its socialist platform and maintains a delicate balance between nationalism and pragmatism in its politics. 
 Despite frequently heard voices to the contrary, total catholic &mdash; nationalist domination would be the likely outcome of a united Ireland unless a confederal structure were implemented. 
 This is partly because of the structure of catholic nationalism in the Southern state and partly because the national unity sought by significant numbers of Northern catholic nationalists is still on the basis of the reversal of protestant &mdash; loyalist hegemony rather than a power compromise. 
 Solidarity with Southern nationalists is still a major Northern nationalist perception, despite the fact that they view their Southern compatriots at best with indifference and at worst as traitors who sold them out to the loyalists. 
 McGreil (1977: 363&ndash;408) has shown that though Dubliners find the English more acceptable than the Northern Irish, Dubliners still seek a solution to the Northern problem within an all-Ireland state. 
 Also, there can be no doubt that the South would intervene in the North on behalf of the catholic &mdash; nationalist minority if Britain withdrew and civil war broke out. 
 Equally, Southern catholic nationalists prefer a unified Irish state, though a majority of 54 per cent would accept a federal one based on the present two state units. 
 One can therefore conclude that there is a sense of unity throughout the catholic &mdash; nationalist population as a whole, though one in which certain groups, namely farming interests and the church, at both clerical and popular levels, have strategically dominated, at least until recently. 
 By 1914, the protestant &mdash; loyalist group was well established and ready for war against catholic nationalists should it have proven necessary. 
 Issues of class conflict within the group were to remain largely subordinate, as the matter of the nature and defence of loyalism itself was to dominate the scene right down to the present day. 
 There was to be an expression of a certain solidarity between members of both the catholic and protestant working classes in the Belfast demonstration of 1932 against the inadequate poor relief during the period of particularly high unemployment. 
 But such cooperation was rare and quickly taken over by sectarian issues.  
 Protestant &mdash; loyalist and catholic &mdash; nationalist politics in the Northern statelet differed from those in the South. 
 McAllister (1980) describes that political culture as traditionalist, and dominated by clientelism, parochialism, local attachment, and ascription: politicians were elected on the basis of local reputation and solely with reference to local issues. 
 During the period of the Stormont parliament, half the seats were uncontested. 
 This was frequently true of Westminster elections too. 
 It would seem that the special state character of Northern Ireland, with its very legitimacy always under threat, has been the main reason for the maintenance of this pattern of politics. 
 Up to the late 1960s, catholic nationalists were split between two main political groupings. 
 There was the Nationalist Party, a weak organization for which local priests had to provide some kind of legitimation. 
 As a party, it really only exercised a modicum of power in relation to the Stormont administration. 
 Then there were the republican parties who focused their attention on Westminster elections. 
 The disorganized nature of catholic &mdash; nationalist politics was only turned round with the emergence of the civil rights movement of 1968 and the subsequent forming of the SDLP in 1970. 
 However, during the 1970s, the socialist element was weakened with the departure of labour leaders. 
 The remaining leadership represented a modified nationalism in which new middle-class moderates held the upper hand. 
 The party as a whole tended to represent the employed and the over-thirties. 
 The unemployed and the under-thirties have lately tended to support Sinn Fein since its adoption of an electoral strategy in the 1980s (Bew and Patterson 1985; O'Dowd, Rolston, and Tomlinson 1980; Moxon-Browne and Irvine 1989). 
 The Unionist Party became the central political organization of the protestant &mdash; loyalist alliance. 
 True, there was some fragmentation of members on class issues. 
 The occasional independent unionist and independent Orange-lodge representative in politics were a feature of politics from 1880 to 1972. 
 The Northern Ireland Labour Party also was the principal organization representing protestant trade unionists. 
 But none of these groupings ever came near to threatening the dominance of Unionist Party organization, much less the solidarity of protestant loyalists, which always appeared total on the issue of incorporation into a united, independent Ireland. 
 It was only with &bquo;the Troubles&equo;, from 1968, that unionists  broke ranks. 
 Yet, despite the splintering, they have succeeded in allying the present two main parties against the Anglo-Irish agreement of 1985. 
 The Alliance Party of Northern Ireland, formed at the time of the abolition of the Stormont parliament, represents those catholics, protestants, and others who disavow the twin alliance of Ireland but retain at least a practical attitude on sovereignty. 
 They prefer British to Irish rule and seem unlikely to move from that position. 
 While the party contains many who actively seek peace and reconciliation, it would be wrong to think of them in any sense as overcoming the basic conflictual components of bloc power in Ireland. 
 &bquo;Castle catholics&equo;, those who found a place in the Stormont administration and developed a stake in the union, have also voted alliance, but are probably now, in 1989, switching their allegiance to the newly found conservative associations, which are seeking to bring British party loyalties to Ulster. 
 The Northern Ireland statelet was founded on an alliance between the protestant loyalists of Ulster and British imperial and capital interests, particularly as represented by the conservative party. 
 But that is what the arrangement was: an alliance rather than a consolidated interest or a genuinely shared culture. 
 Protestant loyalists dominated the statelet from its formation. 
 The British government only obtained certain concessions from the Stormont government in implementing measures of the welfare state variety after 1944. 
 In a detailed study of the Stormont archives, Bew, Gibbon, and Patterson (1979) have shown that there were indeed different currents within the Stormont administration but the ones which predominated belonged to those among the ruling protestant classes who were bent on preservation of the status quo for their own purposes, including their own dominance of the protestant alliance as well as their particular sectional interests. 
 The range of tactics used to keep catholic nationalists subordinate was quite comprehensive. 
 At the political level, proportional representation was abolished for local elections in 1922 and for Stormont elections in 1929. 
 This minimizing of catholic &mdash; nationalist representation was aided by the gerrymandering of electoral boundaries for local government elections, which concentrated the catholic &mdash; nationalist vote in a smaller number of constituencies. 
 At the level of law and order, total control of the subject population was achieved in two ways. 
 Firstly, the Ulster Special Constabulary,  invented to supplement the main police force, was derived largely from the former Ulster Volunteer Force. 
 Divided up into three groupings, the A, B, and C special constabularies, according to diminishing power, responsibility, and time commitment, the force was soon cut down to class B only and these came to be known as the &bquo;B Specials&equo;, a thoroughly armed, militant, semi-private, and sectarian army. 
 It could be called upon at any time and indeed was from time to time. 
 Secondly, through the enactment of a special powers Act in 1922 Stormont gave itself and its police force the powers of detention without trial. 
 These were used copiously over the years of Stormont rule. 
 Catholic nationalists could be and were arrested with little suspicion, detained, frequently beaten, and all with little or no possibility of redress. 
 The British government over the water could have been a million miles away (for detailed accounts see Arthur 1984; Buckland 1979; Farrell 1976; for a summary see McAllister 1983; for a summary of all forms of discrimination adopted, see Whyte 1983; Hillyard 1983). 
 But the British government was still involved in the reproduction of antagonisms in the Ulster statelet, rather than passively accepting the perpetuation of inequalities and discrimination against the catholic &mdash; nationalist minority. 
 O'Dowd, Rolston, and Tomlinson (1980) point out that when the centralized state comes in simply to administer and maintain law and order, it tends to reproduce relationships which pre-exist its intervention. 
 When the British state began its policies of social interventionism from 1945, it succeeded in fragmenting the local power base of unionism by centralizing the sources of welfare and making them at least in part available across the sectarian divide. 
 There was thus some impact on discrimination. 
 However, when Stormont was abolished in 1972 and central government took over entirely the responsibility for local administration, it adopted the technocratic, non-policy making approach to its new role. 
 Part of the reasoning behind the move was the search for an effective policy to contain the violence within Ireland and prevent it from spreading to Britain. 
 It was also hoped that bureaucratic impartiality would reduce discrimination further. 
 But the technocratic approach did not lessen discrimination but reproduced it in a subtler form. 
 The continuation of inequality is still clear in the fields of income, housing, wealth, and employment but most of all in the protestant &mdash; loyalist alliance's embargo on the minority ever holding political office.  
 At least up to 1985, the British government submitted to the threat of violence from the loyalist community and accepted the protestant &mdash; loyalist veto on any change in the constitutional structure of their state. 
 With the Anglo-Irish Agreement at Hillsborough in 1985, it has sought to lay aside that veto, and establish in principle its political right to modify the structure of power and control in Ulster by involving the Republic of Ireland in a common policy on security. 
 However, in the interests of Western European stability and its own financial position, the British government is perhaps still putting off the final offer &mdash; either British withdrawal or some form of power-sharing with catholic nationalists &mdash; in the hope of loyalists coming round to what is seen as a more reasonable position. 
 The class structure of Northern Ireland is predictably dominated by protestants. 
 Of course, with the development of international monopoly capital and multinational companies, additional sources of power have been brought into play. 
 But it is likely that the professionals who have been responsible for the running of such companies at local level will have been allied to the more liberal group among the upper protestant classes, as represented by such families as the O'Neills, who have looked to the English public schools for the right sort of education. 
 Wallis, Bruce, and Taylor (1986) list this mainly landed gentry among the cosmopolitans of Ulster society. 
 Also cosmopolitan in outlook are a variety of traditional professions, particularly university lecturers. 
 Many of these moved their allegiance to Ulster's alliance party on its foundation in the mid-1970s. 
 The limitations on the power of these liberal groups within protestant loyalism are demonstrated by the fact that they have only been allowed to function among the leadership of the people so long as they obeyed the basic tenets and values common to the alliance as a whole. 
 This is shown in the protestant &mdash; loyalist rejection of Terence O'Neill and O'Neillism, and of his successors, Major Chichester-Clark and Brian Faulkner, as prime ministers of Northern Ireland (1968&ndash;74). 
 As Eversley (1989) has recently shown, while only 2 per cent of Roman catholics hold managerial and professional positions compared with 4 per cent of protestants, they are over-represented in the bottom third of the Northern class structure, but generally within the framework of a traditional dual protestant &mdash; catholic labour market. 
 Those members of the catholic population who  sought to advance up the class structure had to adjust to more marginal roles among the professional classes. 
 Those becoming solicitors, barristers, university lecturers, and doctors had to accept limitations on their careers if they stayed in Ulster. 
 Catholic civil servants usually had to abandon any practical political project if they wished to proceed through the ranks. 
 Even so, those who had any career success were extremely few in number. 
 In terms of the acceptance of law and order, the bulk of the catholic &mdash; nationalist remnant form a part of the civil society of Northern Ireland, though as much as a third of the remnant can defect from this consensus, as when supporting the Provisionals over the &bquo;H&equo; -Block prison issue. 
 But in terms of the protestant &mdash; loyalist philosophy, the overwhelming majority of catholics oppose the state's legitimacy. 
 This does not mean that there is no cultural convergence at all between the two alliances in Ireland. 
 Apart from basic agreements on the necessity for law and order for survival purposes, an issue which will be treated later in the chapter, there are a number of similarities which should be mentioned. 
 Both sides are based on capitalist activity and both governments have followed modernization rather than self-development strategies since the 1960s More particularly, despite some continuing differentiation in industrial specialisms, such as the declining presence of heavy engineering in Ulster, the types of industrial activity are increasingly similar as are the economic and unemployment problems, population growth, and productivity, with the probability of higher deficits in the North (FitzGerald 1972: 63&ndash;85; New Ireland Forum 1983&ndash;4: ii. 
 8&ndash;13; O'Dowd and Wickham in Clancy, et al . 
 1986). 
 Also, investment patterns in both parts of Ireland are increasingly similar, being a mixture of British, international, local, and cross-border companies. 
 Internal commerce, from heavy machinery to domestic goods, largely ignores the border, and the high street banks are the same throughout Ireland. 
 The main economic differences reflect the different structures of the state and the different state policies adopted by the British and Irish governments at any one time, though with a significantly higher state sector of employment in Ulster. 
 There is likewise considerable overlap in cultural areas. 
 There are strong similarities in inter-family and inter-gender relations. 
 There  is a recognizably similar personal style to all face-to-face interaction throughout Ireland (for the North, see Harris 1972; Easthope 1976). 
 There are similar strengths to kinship networks. 
 Catholic and protestant church organization straddles the border. 
 There are certain common features in ethical attitudes: puritanical attitudes in sexual matters, conservatism, friendliness, &bquo;down-to-earthness&equo;, sense of duty to neighbours, critical attitudes to officialdom, and similar judgements as to what constitutes good and bad conduct (Harris 1972; Leyton 1966; 1975; Buckley 1984). 
 Public events sometimes confirm these viewpoints, as has appeared in the continuing joint catholic &mdash; protestant political opposition to the abolition of the criminalization of homosexuality. 
 However, the existence of a certain level of common values is no indication by itself of a ground for peace. 
 It may even be possible to obtain approval from opposing groups for a set of moral maxims such as peace, justice, and freedom &mdash; see the lists of values in McKernan's (1980) research, for which he found a high level of acceptance among both Northern Ireland communities. 
 But when it comes down to concrete moral judgements and commitments, such abstractions will be found interpreted in opposing ways. 
 Religion 
 The Roman catholic church retained a unified hierarchical organization for the whole of the island with its bishops meeting periodically at Maynooth. 
 In 1927, 1929, 1956, and 1960, there were plenary synods and councils. 
 Since then, the hierarchy has met more or less three times per year, but usually in secret sessions. 
 In the North, the bishops pursued the Irish catholic community's interests in what could only be called a spirit of &bquo;pillarization&equo;. 
 This is the arrangement in Holland whereby various institutions such as media, schools, cultural organizations, welfare services, and hospitals are duplicated, and run by the separate catholic and protestant communities. 
 In Holland there is even a third or state sector. 
 In Ulster a full panoply of institutions emerged from the dual pressure of the church's concern for its people, and the Northern state's discrimination against catholics. 
 The clerical and lay leadership also experienced a third pressure, that of protecting the faithful from the proselytizing activities of a number of evangelical protestants mainly among the young. 
 The church obtained a separate school system, funded mainly by the Northern  Ireland government, similar to the system of catholic schools in Britain. 
 It also set up its own scouting organizations, clubs both sporting and social, with Irish music, Irish dancing, and Irish or Gaelic games. 
 These games were and still are much loathed by the majority within the Northern protestant community. 
 Priests continued to act as sponsors of the local catholic &mdash; nationalist political structure, chairing meetings of the party and permitting the political use of the parish hall. 
 The parish structure and school became the heart of the Northern catholic &mdash; nationalist community, rendering culture, politics, and religious identity as interchangeable for members of the in-group. 
 Employment patterns, which followed the routes of enforced segregation in favour of protestants &mdash; for they controlled the greater part of the job market and especially the major industrial enterprises and the entire government sector of civil servants and police &mdash; were even reinforced by the system of job references provided by the parish priests and catholic notables. 
 The church certainly had to follow this path in the face of the external constraints; but the practice did strengthen its status, power, and the structure of political divisions. 
 In the South, the church hierarchy pursued the path of full cultural control. 
 Conditioned by church canon law, participation by clerics in politics was forbidden. 
 But at the same time, an enormous sense of responsibility to protect the church, the family, and the minds and hearts of the faithful from incursions by the state was perceived to be the basic duty of the church leaders. 
 The leadership of the state knew in large measure what was wanted: it was part of the national &mdash; popular consciousness as well as being itself a result of the convention between church and Irish parliamentary party in the previous century. 
 What had been convention became part of the natural, common-sense universe of catholic &mdash; nationalist ideology. 
 No real consultation would have been necessary on that score. 
 As will be seen in the next chapter, when the republican wing under de Valera took over as the Fianna F&aacute;il party in the 1930s, constitutional law was restructured, according to both a reformed republican ideology and current Roman social teaching, and in those areas where the high clergy thought it necessary. 
 In addition the church promoted strong centralized relationships between itself and government and actively discouraged the spread of power to the periphery or local level.  
 Within the ranks of the clergy and religious orders themselves, there was a far from complete, centralized structure, but rather a dual one. 
 Apart from small orders, usually of nuns, set up by local bishops for local needs, religious orders have always had considerable independence from the bishops. 
 Part of this independence must be attributed to their ownership of houses and schools, paid for directly by their benefactors, payers of school fees, or investment funds. 
 This has sometimes led to disputes between religious and secular clergy, between orders and bishops. 
 For example, in the Northern context, the previous bishop of Down and Connor, Dr Philbin, refused for most of his period of leadership in Belfast to have Jesuits visiting or residing in his diocese. 
 Not that the prohibition always succeeded. 
 It began to be violated in the late 1960s by Fr. 
 Michael Hurley who on one occasion addressed the presbyterian general assembly in Belfast against both the bishop's private wishes and Ian Paisley's open and defiant demonstrations. 
 The dual division of ecclesiastical power has also been important because the religious orders have often been the vehicle for innovative theologies differing from the Roman line. 
 Because such religious orders are themselves controlled from Rome, Roman discipline is conveyed via a route other than by the bishops. 
 Even so, some orders still remain slightly independent from Rome, particularly the religious orders of solemn vows, whose existence preceded the reformation. 
 Their numbers include the Augustinians and Dominicans, both of whom have been influential in Ireland and have produced theologians of liberal or left persuasion. 
 Despite their dependency on Rome, the jesuits too have been important innovators on the contemporary scene in Ireland, particularly in the areas of education for ecumenism and industrial relations. 
 Nevertheless the predominant catholic power lies with the hierarchy and secular clergy. 
 Thus, while it is possible to identify liberal catholicism in Ireland from the late nineteenth century to the present, and though there has grown up a climate of liberal dissent and criticism of conservative catholicism, it is still possible to assert the prominence of conservative catholicism, particularly in its alliance with nationalism. 
 The predominant political religious form was and remains, with some modifications and with increasing opposition, a centralizing and conservative catholicism. 
 The protestant churches in Ireland also retained their island-wide organization after the political partition of the island. 
 The church  of Ireland still has one all-island synod, the presbyterians a single general assembly, the methodists one conference. 
 Even Ian Paisley's free presbyterians, who have communities in County Cavan and Dublin, are centrally organized, though this may reflect the practical situation in Ireland and the role of the &bquo;big man&equo; himself within the church he founded. 
 The annual meetings of the churches' central bodies are a forum for religious political debate and have been known to express tensions between the values of the majority Northern and minority Southern protestants. 
 In the Northern statelet, the power of the main protestant churches at present remains subordinate to that of the fundamentalists and the religious political societies. 
 The societies of the Apprentice Boys, the Black Preceptory, and the Orange order, in conjunction with protestant paramilitary groups, could still form the basis for protestant political power if Britain withdrew from Ulster. 
 From its domination by the old ascendancy, the Orange order in particular came to embrace protestants from all classes and churches. 
 In fact, in rural areas today, the Orange hall has frequently been the only place where protestants of all shades have met to renew their belief and commitment to Ulster protestant loyalism (Harris 1972: 162&ndash;5). 
 It is important to note that these organizations are internally stratified. 
 Those nearer the top, particularly in the Black Preceptory, the inner sanctum of the society structure, are there because of their moral and religious standing in the local community: wealthy farmers, businessmen, good churchmen, or at least of known moral probity. 
 They tend to represent the &bquo;religious&equo; as opposed to the &bquo;rough&equo; end of the protestant spiritual spectrum. 
 Fundamentalist religious groups have increased their power in Ulster in recent decades, especially the free presbyterians. 
 Their small church membership of around 10,000 hides the wider appeal Paisleyite politics has for the small businessmen and farmers of protestant Ulster. 
 The setting up of a new form of Ulster Club organization involving paramilitary activity in the wake of the Anglo-Irish accord of 1985, is an added dimension to the struggle for power within the alliance. 
 It is likely that the inner core of local church laity, such as select vestry members of the Church of Ireland and presbyterian elders, provided and still provide one of the links between the material and spiritual interests of the groups in the alliance, as these laity were and are active in the business and commercial fields also.  
 THE DOMINANT BELIEFS OF THE TWO ALLIANCES 
 As we examine the dominant beliefs of the two alliances, it must be stressed that we are not looking at beliefs possessed by each and every person who identifies to a greater or lesser extent with either set of traditions. 
 Rather we are looking at those beliefs, supported by significant power bases within each bloc, which have won out in the political process in the past seventy years and still appear to be doing so, in some cases with much decreased vitality. 
 The dominant beliefs of the catholic &mdash; nationalist bloc still are that the group forms a people who are Gaelic-Irish, constitute a nation, are republican, and populate an island which has a natural, inner political unity. 
 We reiterate: the dominant beliefs of the alliances which we have termed historical blocs are not necessarily shared by all but are promoted successfully by dominant groups and have some grounding in the consciousness of the wider membership. 
 Thus, Irish nationalism is conceived by most members in an abstract way, but it has concrete import for key groups. 
 Equally, a particular type of catholic identity may not belong to all but remains politically dominant for similar reasons. 
 The outcome of the dominance of both is that historically there have been critical mediations between religion and politics for catholic nationalists. 
 As will be seen in the remaining chapters, a particular form of Irish catholicism known as monopoly catholicism has assisted in the concrete success of the mix of the beliefs with economic beliefs in capitalism, ownership of land, and inheritance, helping to bring the elements to an explicit formulation in the 1937 Irish constitution, which has ever since shown considerable resistance to reformulation. 
 The prevailing protestant &mdash; loyalist beliefs stress the existence of the people of Northern Ireland, who are distinguished by their Ulster protestantism and democratic values, and by their claim to a flexible territory of Ulster. 
 Despite some socialist groups within the alliance, the dominant economic belief is capitalist. 
 A further central belief has recently begun to appear as equivocal, namely  loyalism itself. 
 Related to this is the final principal belief element, the conviction of the legitimacy of force in maintaining the subordination of catholic nationalists within the statelet. 
 A fuller account of these two groups of dominant beliefs benefits from some comparison between the two. 
 &bquo;We, the People&hellip;&equo; 
 The only way catholic nationalists can fulfil their present aspirations as a people is by extending the Republic of Ireland to the entire island. 
 This would mean containing within their state one million persons to whom such a national identity would be totally antithetical. 
 The Irish people are defined primarily by their allegiance to the present restricted or future enlarged republic, but it is popularly understood that they will normally have the further characteristics of Gaelic Irishness. 
 The belief is still popular that such a race exists, rather than there merely being a cultural group based on nationalist, republican, and catholic religious sentiment. 
 It is a belief which has intellectual credence in Ireland (O'Tuathaig 1986 and M. M. Ireland's responding letter, Irish Times , 8 Dec. 1986). 
 Theoretically, one would expect the Northern catholic community and the six counties of Ulster to be considered a lost remnant, unredeemed from British rule, and indeed this is by far the most popular interpretation. 
 But, of course, the problems that arise out of this interpretation are twofold. 
 Firstly, there is the problem of the protestant population itself in the North. 
 Their position as Irish people is ambiguous. 
 For the hard-line republican position, there is even a duality: protestant loyalists are taken as foreigners with an alien culture, and as either a pariah group &mdash; the mere instrument of British imperialism &mdash; or simply not there. 
 Their culture has no rights, no claim to an alternative identity. 
 Intellectually,  the problem is the British presence in Ireland. 
 But emotionally, the non-people are hated or at least detested. 
 Clare O'Halloran (1986) has shown how the social reality of Northern Ireland remained a continuing blind spot for Southern Irish nationalists particularly from the founding of the state to 1949. 
 We aim to show in Chapter 5 that this blindness was in part promoted by the religious elements in their beliefs. 
 Secondly, there is the problem of the Northern catholic community, which tends to be taken as a monolithic nationalist community. 
 Apart from the fact that there has been significant support for the alliance party over the last dozen years or so among the catholic middle classes, there is also a further factor. 
 Rose's (1971) survey, conducted in 1968 on the verge of &bquo;the Troubles&equo;, found that as many as 30 per cent of the catholic population were &bquo;explicitly prepared to endorse the constitution&equo; of Northern Ireland, which then included the Stormont parliament. 
 Catholics, however, did not vote for the Unionist Party. 
 This indicates an acceptance of the state structures, or a recognition of a need for the separation of Northern Ireland from the remaining state structure of Ireland, but at the same time a continuing opposition to protestant &mdash; loyalist dominance. 
 One can also add that there is something in the present policies of the SDLP which suggest a need to maintain a somewhat fragile unity in respect of the national question. 
 Seamus Mallon, MP of the SDLP may have seen the Hillsborough agreement of 1985 as a step towards a united Ireland, but some of his co-politicians in the party would not share that view. 
 Perhaps one should note the care with which the present leader of the party, John Hume, chooses his words over the future of the North. 
 He is careful not to promote the theme of reunification, but talks of discovering &bquo;a new way&equo;, setting up structures of co-operation in the North between the two Northern Communities, with the support of the Southern government. 
 However, the policy is seen as ambiguous. 
 Those who wish, both unionists and nationalists, can interpret it as the beginnings of absorption into an all-Ireland state. 
 But those who wish for a basically Northern solution, even a dual national state with inputs both from the Republic and Britain, can interpret the policy as suiting their needs, and can thus find space on the ballot paper for the SDLP. 
 While in the last century there was still some attempt to embrace  all people in Ireland as the Irish nation, now the nation subsists in the Irish catholic population. 
 The ambiguity present in O'Connell has arguably aided catholic nationalists over the years in the justification of their policies. 
 They have sometimes stressed religious elements why certain political changes were not possible, such as in legislation on public morality, schooling, marriage, divorce, and adoption. 
 At other times, they have stressed the cultural, ethnic, historical, and geographical reasons why Ireland should be unified politically. 
 At the same time, in theory they wish to accept that Ulster protestants form part of the Irish people while they actually do not accept them in practice. 
 Indeed, until the ecumenical era of the 1960s, few catholics in Ireland were prepared to put before themselves some of the political religious issues which would have to be resolved if a united Ireland or accommodation to a separate political entity in Ulster were to become a possibility. 
 The other alliance in Ireland, the protestant &mdash; loyalist, does not thus far perceive itself as a nation. 
 The view that they are one appears mainly in the writings of the British and Irish Communist Organization (1972; 1973). 
 However, there can be little doubt that significant numbers of protestant loyalists see themselves as a distinct, almost ethnic group. 
 Clearly, they can be seen to have a particular self-concept, a sense of what Weber termed social honour (Wallis, Bruce, and Taylor 1986). 
 A group which perpetuates itself by endogamous sexual reproduction usually has some perception of ethnic identity. 
 It tends to have an active or passive belief, whether articulated or not, that it is either superior to, or rightfully distinct from, other similar groups. 
 The theoretical or articulated ground for this awareness is a set of abstract beliefs and moral dicta particular to the group. 
 One of these beliefs may be racial superiority, but does not have to be. 
 The distinctive feature of the beliefs is that they assert or imply the honour or prestige due to the group over and against another or other groups, and consequently motivate the group to achieve such honour on the field of social conflict. 
 Of course, such beliefs can be religious. 
 It may be that in the protestant &mdash; loyalist case this ethnic tendency may have priority over the British component of identity or be in conflict with it. 
 The contradiction can be viewed in two ways. 
 Either there are two different groups among the loyalists, subscribing to two different loyalisms. 
 Or there is really only one group, but sharing a dual identity, with now one dominating their consciousness,  now the other. 
 The truth of the matter probably lies somewhere in between. 
 As Miller argues, there is a long tradition among the protestants of Ulster of viewing the British state ambiguously. 
 It is clear that in the past many of them have considered loyalty to be a two-way process, a contract or covenant, and that the state could be a traitorous party as well as the people. 
 The tradition proved of crucial importance in forming the basis for the strategy of the alliance from 1911 until British recognition of their separate political claim in 1914. 
 If the tradition still exists today &mdash; and it appears that it very much does so &mdash; it implies that the United Kingdom does not have for many loyalists a natural character of statehood in the way the Southern state has for catholic nationalists. 
 Covenant politics has come to the forefront again with the Hillsborough agreement of 1985 and shows the extent to which the populist politics of the Democratic Unionists is rooted in protestant &mdash; loyalist tradition. 
 This foundational belief gives meaning to the more popular belief in the right of the people to violence. 
 Rather than such force being seen as a prerogative of the state, it is seen by many in the alliance to inhere in the people of Ulster who over and over again need to assert their autonomous rights. 
 Increasingly it is seen as the only option left in the face of the continuing Anglo-Irish agreement. 
 Continuing or worsening strife could solidify covenant beliefs into a separate Ulster identity absolutely dominant over the British component, and demanding its own independent state form. 
 It is important to note that in 1912&ndash;14 the protestant &mdash; loyalist group saw their right to violence as prior to that of the official state. 
 It is also important to note that they saw the taking of law into their own hands as temporary, and pending the recognition by that state of its mistaken attitude towards them and their right to a degree of autonomy. 
 It appears to be increasingly the case that there are two major traditions of identity perception among protestant loyalists. 
 One tradition is the covenant one and is antagonistic to a straightforward nationalist sentiment. 
 It is adhered to by increasing numbers who have become disillusioned with British identity and have seen Paisley's words about the traitorous nature of British governments become reality as protestant &mdash; loyalist domination in Ulster has been continuously eroded. 
 These are probably more likely to vote for Paisley's democratic unionism and to come from  either religious, fundamentalist backgrounds or populist working-class and lower middle-class backgrounds. 
 The other tradition remains British identity and still would seem to dominate the values of the official unionists. 
 It is likely that a good many protestant loyalists oscillate between the two and still have to come to their moment of decision, one that is likely to be forced on them by future events. 
 The Monopoly of the Majority 
 The notion of the majority occurs frequently in Irish politics. 
 In the South, protestant loyalists are accused of subverting the wishes of the majority in the island by not consenting to a united Ireland. 
 In the North, protestant loyalists accuse catholic nationalists of not accepting the rights of the majority in the statelet to govern as it sees fit. 
 In both cases, democracy is invoked. 
 But it is the theory of democracy as the right of the majority to rule which is seen as central, rather than democracy as the preservation of minority rights. 
 In the North, the belief comes via the British parliamentary tradition of the two-party system and its accompanying electoral process of &bquo;first pass the post&equo;. 
 For protestant loyalists, the majority means themselves. 
 In addition, protestant &mdash; loyalist politics has always been a zero-sum activity: one either has a monopoly of power or concedes it to the opposition. 
 Because the opposition is the catholic nationalists, concession means the end of the statelet as such. 
 The meaning of democracy shifts even further once it is interpreted within the terms of the Calvinist principle of the Godly society, where it is the lot of the just to assume power and to guide the citizens in the paths of righteousness. 
 With this religious overtone in Northern Ireland, the belief in majority dominance has justified ignoring the rights of the catholic &mdash; nationalist minority within the Ulster statelet. 
 From 1985, it has been continually invoked by Paisley and Peter Robinson in their attempt to subvert the Anglo-Irish accord. 
 The Republican and Nationalist Components 
 It is important to note that the political party system in the Republic of Ireland is largely based on the divisions in the  national-popular consciousness which occurred at the time of the Irish civil war. 
 To simplify a rather complex historical phenomenon, it can be said that the present political division between Fianna Fail and Fine Gael originates in positions taken by opponents in that war. 
 The civil war was not fought over the partition of the island as is popularly believed. 
 It resulted from one group, the republicans, not accepting the oath of allegiance to the royal sovereign of the United Kingdom, a requirement of the constitution of 1922. 
 Though the republicans lost the war, they eventually won their case with their successful introduction of the republican constitution of 1937. 
 This shows the extent to which the republican ideal gained ground once independence was in place, furthering the ideological divide between protestant loyalism and catholic nationalism. 
 Despite this development, the struggle between the two previously warring factions has continued, the original republicans developing a populist, nationalist party, and the former treaty party developing a concern with law and order, and moderation on the national question. 
 But the fight did not prevent the fundamental beliefs in the nation and &bquo;the historic integrity of the island of Ireland&equo;, as nationalist parties described it in their New Ireland Forum (1983 &mdash; 4: i. 28), from remaining basic to the perceptions of both parties. 
 The Gaelic-Irish Component 
 From the early years of the Southern state, cultural nationalism was deliberately developed by government means. 
 There were deliberate attempts to develop elements of both high and popular culture in music, poetry, dance, and games. 
 In particular, Gaelic games were promoted by the independent Gaelic Athletic Association. 
 This association constitutionally still seeks to implement 
 the organization of native pastimes and the promotion of athletic fitness as a means to create disciplined, self-reliant, national-minded manhood which takes conscious pride in its heritage of unrivalled pastimes and splendid cultural traditions as essential factors in the restoration of full and distinct nationhood. 
 By this means, the association believes the cause of national unity will be furthered &bquo;until a complete nationhood is achieved&equo; (Gaelic Athletic Association Rule Book (1970), quoted Hickey 1984: 40). 
 Within this statement, which is rhetorical for some but deadly serious for others within the GAA, lies precisely the reason why the protestants of the North are so opposed to the development of  Gaelic games and seek to oppose their extension if and when they can. 
 The re-establishment of the Irish language as the first official language of the state became the national policy of the Irish government under de Valera and has only toned down in recent years. 
 It was made a compulsory subject in the schools, an essential part of the Leaving Certificate, and it was necessary to pass an exam in the language to enter the civil service. 
 A similar exam is still compulsory for anyone seeking to enter the teaching profession without the required Leaving Certificate pass, even if they are never to teach the subject. 
 One immediately recognizes the active construction of the national ideal as promoted by principal currents in nineteenth century European nationalist thought (see Kedourie 1985). 
 Another aspect of this form of cultural nationalism is that it was been strongly supported in the Irish national school system and Northern catholic school system by the clergy and religious orders. 
 Not all the clergy and all the religious orders have been actively engaged in the pursuit of this ideal, but one or two orders have been; for example, the Christian Brothers are devoted to the ideals of a Christian and catholic education, and supporters of the concept of a nation dedicated to God and at the same time distinctly Irish. 
 In making this comment, one is merely pointing out particular ideological characteristics in hard-working, deeply religious, and committed people. 
 However, in the practical context of an Ireland divided between two power blocs, such a nationalist form is profoundly ethnic and exclusivist, whatever its believed aims and ideal content. 
 There is an elective affinity between this cultural vision and the religious vision of the Roman catholic church prior to the second Vatican Council, in its exclusivist attitude towards other Christian churches, an attitude which is far from overcome at the level of popular Roman catholicism. 
 The Suppression of Class by the Dominant Beliefs 
 In the South, the marginality of the third main political party, the Irish Labour Party, is an indication of just how successful the articulation of capitalism to religious and national beliefs is. 
 The South is not a classless society, but its class nature has been well hidden in consciousness and dominated by the procedures of the capitalist-democratic process. 
 Despite the principal duality of Irish party political power, the bourgeois structure of the state has rarely  been questioned, only the degree of state intervention in the bourgeois economy. 
 Also, the clerical church has been particularly antipathetic to socialism in any form. 
 It showed itself to have a horror of socialism already in the nineteenth century. 
 But its opposition also had a base in the property-owning, rural peasantry, and middle-classes, who had in the nineteenth century paid a heavy price for their liberation from oppression and whose status became rooted in their property, land, and livestock. 
 Their attitudes were shared by their priest-sons, who in their turn were supported by Rome, whose solid opposition to socialism until the 1960s was very clear (e.g. Pope Leo XIII, 1903). 
 From 1911 to 1914, the Irish high clergy made successive attacks on the trade union movement and on socialism. 
 Rumpf and Hepburn (1977) view the activity of the church during this period as quite decisive in limiting the appeal of socialism for the Irish subordinate classes until the 1950s. 
 The emergence of a new pro-capitalist party in the South from the end of 1985, the Progressive Democratic Party, might show the extent to which political divisions based on the treaty and within the nationalist component of hegemony may have become problematic, to be partially replaced by an even more explicit concern with increasing the popular wealth and prosperity. 
 Indeed, in the Irish general election of 1987, progressive democrats took 14 seats, and 11.8 per cent of the total vote, which is sizeable for a young political party. 
 The decline of the labour element in the SDLP in the North, however, does indicate a trend to the style of politics in the Republic, that is towards the suppression of class politics and identity in line with the dominant ideology of the alliance. 
 The national question as such still remains a central preoccupation for catholic nationalists. 
 Because the nation is seen as only partially liberated, and particularly by the membership of the largest party Fianna F&aacute;il, the animus of the national-popular consciousness is focused on this issue, to the detriment of class-based politics. 
 There has, therefore, been little chance in the past for a political growth of class consciousness among subordinate groups. 
 What socialism there has been among the catholic &mdash; nationalist tradition has always tended to be allied to republicanism, especially in the period 1913 to 1930 (Rumpf and Hepburn 1977: 13). 
 The trade union movement was a case in point. 
 The labour movement  in Ireland was made up of two organizations. 
 One of these was James Larkin's Irish Transport and General Workers' Union, the ITGWU. 
 It came to have Connolly's support and was on the way to becoming thoroughly nationalist and republican under Connolly's influence. 
 The other was the Irish Trades Union Congress. 
 Before 1914, it became the Irish TUC and Labour Party and was neutral to the Easter rising of 1916. 
 The ITGWU became a member of the ITUC in 1909, but had very distinct and separate policies to the moderate ITUC which sought to keep its links with Northern protestant workers. 
 Socialists tended to be republicans, though only some republicans were socialist. 
 The republicanism of Irish socialist nationalists was of course logical in so far as they interpreted imperialism as an enemy of the indigenous population and as an expropriator of the people. 
 But it was thereby alien to Ulster protestant socialists. 
 A duality of class interests within republicanism has remained, with forms of bourgeois and rural peasant-owner republicanism existing side by side with socialist republicanism. 
 This combination still exists in the provisional movement especially in the South despite the officially socialist policies of Sinn Fein, as well as in the Fianna F&aacute;il party. 
 In parallel with the Republic, class politics has flourished even less on the protestant &mdash; loyalist side, despite the periodic strength of protestant trade unionism (Patterson 1980). 
 There did exist the small Northern Ireland Labour Party which disappeared after the fall of Stormont; but it had been based on industrial workers, particularly in the shipyards, and remained much smaller in size than its Southern counterpart. 
 As Gibbon has noted, the cases of both Irish nationalism and Ulster unionism remain &bquo;the two most spectacular class alliances in the political history of the British Isles&equo; (1975: 3). 
 The cause in both cases appears to be the strength of catholic &mdash; nationalist and protestant &mdash; loyalist popular consciousness and the way in which the cultural and material interests of the subordinate classes appear to be represented by the alliances themselves and their institutions. 
 By providing core beliefs, and by reinforcing their separateness for both alliances, religious beliefs and institutions equally suppress class divisions, become embroiled in cementing alliances, and help retain the overall divisional structure of Ireland as a whole.  
 The Religious Component of Catholic Nationalism 
 There is nothing theoretically which hinders religion being an ingredient, or even predominating in the nationalist mix. 
 Roman catholicism and protestantism constitute, in different ways and to varying degrees, nationalist and loyalist beliefs in Ireland. 
 This is even official in the case of loyalism. 
 In the case of Irish nationalism a specific relationship with catholicism has been formulated. 
 Catholic identity is not essential for membership of the catholic &mdash; nationalist group, but consent to the understanding that catholic values will predominate in the public sphere is essential, for these religious values are viewed to be eminently suitable, natural, and self-evidently of high moral quality, safeguarding the fabric of state and public morality. 
 The link between Irish catholicism and Irish nationalism is deeply rooted. 
 For centuries the Roman catholic church and faith were the bread of life to the subordinate classes in Ireland, deprived of their land, civil rights, and education. 
 The church not only provided solace and comfort in those long years, but also a vigorous identity which enabled its people to hold up their heads amid the persecution and oppression. 
 It provided intellectual and spiritual leadership and some alleviation from hunger and starvation. 
 The clergy were the only source of education apart from the &bquo;hedge school&equo; teachers (Dowling 1968) and provided a significant moral and organizational resource. 
 Several aspects of catholicism became particularly important in the nineteenth century. 
 As has been seen, partially as a result of Cardinal Cullen's nineteenth-century reforms, the church became more organized and developed in its numbers of clergy and religious. 
 Its spiritual life underwent a considerable transformation. 
 An important component of this religious renewal was its individualistic orientation; it was the individual rather than the group or its activity in the world which was the subject of this religious activity. 
 Like all the religious renewal of catholicism in the post-Tridentine period, it was predominantly pietistic. 
 The importance of conversion to Christ and subsequent pursuit of the way of perfection was the centre. 
 It was strongly influenced by the development and multiplication of the religious congregational system developed by Ignatius of Loyala, founder of the Jesuits and of the famous spiritual exercises or retreat system. 
 The exercises  were specifically directed to obtaining this effect. 
 A main real difference in the experience which marked it off from fundamentalist and some pentecostal forms of conversion experience was that the outcome was not the assurance of being saved, but rather a spirituality of trust in Christ based on repentance and the conviction that God forgives repentant sinners. 
 In this respect, it paralleled some forms of evangelicalism, particularly methodism. 
 The trust implied fidelity or commitment, together with an abandoning of the old ways of sin and indifference for a total dedication to God's will in Christ. 
 But if this was the ideal placed before the clergy and members of religious orders, the reality for the people was generally somewhat different. 
 There can be little doubt, however, that a sense of God's presence and of the supernatural in general were long-standing characteristics of Irish popular religion, along with magical and semi-magical local religious practices. 
 There can also be little doubt that the devotional revolution had a significant impact on the life of local catholic communities, especially as social life came to have a very strong relationship to the local parish and its priests. 
 The transformations effected by the second Vatican Council of 1962&ndash;5 in liturgy, sacrament, scripture, and so on led to the accelerated decline of traditional rituals such as wakes and pilgrimages to local shrines. 
 There has also been a significant decline in the cult of the saints, and many of the practices which characterized the devotional revolution of the mid-nineteenth century. 
 This has been assisted by the continuing process of urbanization and delocalizing of religious experience. 
 Local folk religion still continues in some forms. 
 Its resistance is exemplified by the recent &bquo;moving statues&equo; devotional upsurge of 1985 in South-West Ireland, where statues of Mary were believed to have changed their posture, wept, and bled (Tobin 1985). 
 National centres of devotion remain relatively strong &mdash; the shrine to Mary at Knock, the annual climbing of Croagh Patrick, pilgrimage and penance at Lough Derg. 
 In fact, whereas the parallel protestant movement of evangelical revival was for all people, and the issue tended to be decisive, catholic spirituality diverged on both points. 
 The principal one was that conversion and growth were particularly directed at the clerical-religious &eacute;lite, where the annual retreat system formed the annual or biennial centre of the individual spiritual life. 
 The retreat consisted, and still does, of anything from five to thirty days of  spiritual exercises, usually in an atmosphere of silence and contemplation apart from listening to the preacher when there is one, but with additional features of both vocal and silent prayer. 
 The laity had a pale reflection of this programme in the parish mission, designed to convert the laity or at least bring them back to regular church practices. 
 Morality was for the laity, whose life was dominated by the battle against mortal sin, and who therefore lived under the threat of hell and were always at risk. 
 Spirituality was the lot of the clergy and the religious, who were judged to have left this crude level of human religious existence behind, through conversion and a subsequent, progressive spiritual change. 
 They were seen to succeed in living a sexually pure life as part of this. 
 There was some extension of the pietistic ideal. 
 Sodalities, such as the Legion of Mary, Opus Dei, and Christian Life communities, have partially extended this form of commitment to some, particularly more middle-class laity, and continue to have an important role in activating laity for what are judged to be religious goals both personally and socially. 
 But generally speaking the ideal has always tended to accentuate the gap between the clerical world view and the lay world view within catholicism. 
 Even though the gap between clerical and lay religious intellectuals has closed, with clergy being left behind in some areas, the clerics remain the true cognoscenti  in religious matters, and are expected to be so by the laity. 
 This has always added to the clergy's spiritual authority and status, and has tended to merge with the authority claimed by the clergy in matters of faith and morals, with the high clergy deciding what constitutes matters of faith and morals. 
 The attitude towards authority within the church partnered the perception of the spiritual life. 
 The clergy were and still are in a special position, holding power over the laity because of it. 
 This is one of the special characteristics of catholicism, and is found to a much lesser extent in non-episcopal traditions. 
 Failure to conform to directives of priests and bishops were seen to break the very fabric of communion and to allow sin to enter in. 
 This remains particularly so today where an objectivist stance on morality prevails in a national or local culture anywhere in the catholic world. 
 From within this perspective bishops and clergy lay down rules for the laity to follow in any given situation and the teaching of the church is seen as absolutely clear and devoid of problematic. 
 Rules are enforced rather than principles declared.  
 In terms of the Irish catholic &mdash; nationalist context today, pietism and authoritarianism have tended to structure the religion of the people to a significant extent, though the numbers subscribing to its world view appear to be declining. 
 The clergy are seen as above criticism in their religious statements, and such criticism can cause considerable distress to many people. 
 In his analysis of the popular culture which appeared among the promoters of the Pro-Life Campaign, set up to achieve a constitutional ban on abortion in the Republic in 1983, O'Carroll pin-points certain characteristics, which can be abbreviated here: a monolithic and absolute view of the world, with its accompanying intolerance, derived in part from the direct consultation of clerics and politicians on public moral issues and the subsequent failure to develop an ethos of public debate; a localized belief system, rooted in family and communal authority and issuing in a spirit of absolute conformity; sexual prudery, a product partly of the inheritance problem; and the development of acute anxiety when such beliefs &mdash; inhering partly as they do in their practice and shaping of society &mdash; are threatened. 
 The absoluteness of the vision excludes all alternatives, and requires external validation. 
 This can be provided by the magic power or words, such as inscribing prohibitions into the nation's constitution, and by manifestations of the divine in terms of either retribution for failing to uphold the truth, or grace for upholding the truth, with rewards &bquo;such as oil finds and victories in the World Championships&equo;. 
 O'Carroll sees such positions exemplified by the protagonists' refusal to accept that certain therapeutic abortions already permitted in Ireland were actually abortions and by their predictions of social chaos should they fail in their fight: &bquo;Hence phrases such as &bquo;the opening of the floodgates&equo;, &bquo;the thin end of the wedge&equo;, &bquo;the slippery slope&equo;, &bquo;the permissive society&equo;, and &bquo;the abortion mentality&equo;&equo; (1983: 12). 
 It is important to point out that these expressions which interpret Irish social reality and events are also used by the high clergy. 
 They are thus not simply a mentality derived from popular religion but from a traditional Roman catholicism which held sway in catholic Europe from the post-Reformation period and remained unchallenged until the 1960s. 
 As will be seen in Chapter 5, understanding this religious social consciousness requires some grasp of the traditional catholic teaching on the natural order and the good society, and how the nation is to respect the divine order  established by God. 
 An example of this can be taken from the recent contraception controversy in the Republic, which began in the 1960s. 
 At that time, the Roman catholic archbishop of Dublin intervened in a pastoral letter in the following revealing terms: 
 If they who are elected to legislate for our society should unfortunately decide to pass a disastrous measure of legislation that will allow the public promotion of contraception and an access hitherto unlawful to the means of contraception, they ought to know clearly the meaning of their action, when it is judged by the norms of objective morality  and the certain consequences of such a law&hellip; 
 It may well come to pass that&hellip; legislation could be enacted that will offend the objective moral law . 
 Such a measure would be an insult to our Faith; it would without question prove to be gravely damaging to morality, private and public; it would be, and would remain, a curse upon our country . 
 (Abp. 
 McQuaid of Dublin, letter to all the churches of the archdiocese, Mar. 1971, quoted Wright 1973: 224; italics added) 
 It is the specific effect this religious form has in Ireland which is under scrutiny. 
 But the form as a whole should be recognized as inimical to protestants, especially when pursued in the arena of politics. 
 This will be considered in the remaining chapters. 
 The Protestant Element of Protestant &mdash; Loyalist Beliefs 
 The dominant religious element in protestant &mdash; loyalist beliefs is a form of pan-protestantism. 
 It has so far overcome at the political level the doctrinal and organizational divisions between protestants. 
 It is based on the theme of protestant liberty, which is consciously contrasted with catholic authoritarianism. 
 There are, however, many strands within this protestantism and they are frequently conflicting. 
 One has to remember that well into the nineteenth century British identity was predicated first of all of the English. 
 It also tended primarily to be Anglican and only secondarily reformed. 
 Even when non-Anglican protestants had become accepted as citizens in England and Ireland towards the end of the eighteenth century as they already were in Scotland and Wales, English and Irish catholics remained politically suspect. 
 They remained so throughout the nineteenth century and were not normally trusted with public office. 
 Also, Irish catholics were represented in the dominant culture as an inferior race, ridiculed, and considered incompetent and beastly (Curtis, Jr. 
 1968). 
 The idea of defending a  protestant heritage is not solely an Ulster phenomenon but rooted in the British tradition. 
 Whereas in Britain, with the growth of suffrage, catholics could never be perceived as a political threat because of the smallness of their numbers, in Ireland, with the growth of the home rule movement and its accompanying nationalism, they could only be perceived as politically, religiously, and nationally subversive and suspicion of them remained. 
 The issues of freedom of conscience and freedom from Roman hegemony lie at the centre of Northern Ireland fundamentalism and are meshed in with its evangelical tenets. 
 They are at their clearest in the teachings of the appropriately named free presbyterians: 
 Liberty is the very essence of Bible protestantism. 
 Tyranny is the very essence of popery. 
 Where protestantism flourishes Liberty flames. 
 Where Popery reigns Tyranny rules. 
 As Liberty and Tyranny have no common meeting place, so protestantism and popery cannot be reconciled&hellip; popery is tyrannical in every sphere of life&hellip; protestantism, at a stroke, cuts down all the shackles of superstition and priestcraft. 
 The soul is free to commune with its Maker. 
 There is one mediator between God and man &mdash; the man Jesus Christ. 
 Protestantism hands out an unemployment card to every Papist priest&hellip; 
 The protestant's home is his castle. 
 He brooks no interference from Pope, priest, pastor, preacher or prelate&hellip; 
 No one can control the protestant's education or the books which he shall read. 
 He is free born and trembles not at priestly threats or the papal curse&hellip; 
 At the ballot box the protestant exercises complete liberty&hellip; 
 (Ian Paisley, Protestant Telegraph , editorial, 28 May 1966, quoted Wright 1973: 224) 
 Despite this common, oppositional identity, protestants in Northern Ireland retained institutional, class, and doctrinal divisions. 
 Presbyterians retained a consciousness of their Scottish origins and came to have a significant presence in the local economy and finance institutions, predominating in the North and East. 
 Church of Ireland members, largely of English origin though less conscious of it, predominated in the south of Ulster and still constitute the majority among the protestant farming community. 
 The small denominations and sects are province-wide, but are particularly strong in Belfast. 
 They are more fundamentalist both in religion and in politics &mdash; though some eschew political activity &mdash; and are frequently more politically volatile. 
 Both Church of Ireland and presbyterian political ethics in the North are supportive of the union and the forces of law and order, whereas the sects have a more flexible respect for state authority.  
 One is not talking about a lack of breadth in theologies and points of view within presbyterianism and the Church of Ireland. 
 Both have their liberals, religious intellectuals, and deeply committed ecumenists. 
 There is a tradition of strong social consciousness in the Church of Ireland, evidenced by its building of hospitals, the support of some of its leadership for the locked-out Dublin workers in 1913 and their activities in other works of mercy without a proselytizing aim. 
 A number of higher clergy in Ulster and many of its lay intellectuals stand a long way off from protestant &mdash; loyalist politics and are in fact politically dissociated from them. 
 In the South the church accepts the status of the independent republic and is loyal to it. 
 But the bulk of its laity and Northern clergy, and probably more so its industrial and farming classes, are low church and evangelicals, the more protestant and anti-catholic end of the Anglican synthesis. 
 One must also remember in this respect that a key feature of Church of Ireland organization is the local select vestry, which involves the laity in debate and discussion with clergy. 
 When placed alongside the house of laity in the synod of the Church of Ireland, the power of the laity in church decision-making, including statements on political ethics and positions on public local issues, is quite considerable. 
 A similar statement can be made of the presbyterian community, which is almost wholly Northern, and whose main Southern presbytery is in the counties of old Ulster which remain in the Republic &mdash; Donegal, Cavan, and Monaghan. 
 The organization of presbyterianism rests strongly upon the local community, with its division of authority between minister and elders. 
 The elders are individuals of good-standing drawn from the local laity, who both appoint their minister and have considerable control over his or her activities &mdash; there is at present one woman minister with a congregation in Northern Ireland. 
 The sentiments among the majority of Northern lay presbyterians are biased towards those elements in the Westminster Confessional  which are antagonistic to Roman catholic practice and belief: the evils of the papacy and priesthood and the suppression of Christian liberty, the evils of the mass and devotions to the saints, all of which combine to turn Christians to superstition and idolatry and away from almighty God and true salvation in Christ. 
 An example of the strength of this animus occurred in 1982&ndash;3 in the celebrated case of the Revd David Armstrong, censured by the elders of his congregation for entering  the Roman catholic church across the road to offer its worshippers Christmas greetings, and eventually forced to leave his ministry (Armstrong and Saunders 1985). 
 Though the case is complex and the minister has joined the Anglican communion, the elements of the case at the time are quite significant. 
 Ministers, both presbyterian and Church of Ireland, suffer similar pressures in many other local communities, except that they often stay silent rather than risk conflict, personal hardship, or violence. 
 An added fear is losing church members to sects or the free presbyterians. 
 Protestantism has a deeper significance in Ulster than it has had in Britain for over two hundred years. 
 The very phrase &bquo;the Ulster people&equo; refers to those who originally set up the true faith in Ireland and colonized the land accordingly. 
 This religion of the people has some similarity to Calvin's theology of the city of God on earth, though in a more modern and less rigorous setting than the one which Calvin tried to realize in his lifetime in the city of Geneva: 
 Civil government is designed, as long as we live in this world, to cherish and support the external worship of God; to preserve the pure doctrine of religion, to defend the constitutions of the church, to regulate our lives in a manner requisite for the society of man, to form our manners to civil justice, to promote our concord with each other, and to establish general peace and tranquillity&hellip; 
 (Wright 1973: 225, quoting Calvin 1960: 46) 
 Calvin viewed his interpretation of the function of the state as the only Christian one. 
 This mode of political religious action no longer starts out from a universal centre and figure, such as the papacy, but rather from the national or local church within the state, whose &bquo;magistrates&equo; &mdash; Calvin's term for lay political leaders &mdash; are ideally Christians of moral rectitude, who perform this duty as one ordained by God. 
 Wright is correct to see Paisley's interpretation of liberty as a development of this view. 
 Both reject papal centralization and papal authority as a means for discerning just government. 
 Wright is also correct to distinguish between a general interpretation of &bquo;salvation by grace&equo; &mdash; the teaching of the reformers &mdash; and its fundamentalist variant, which he terms &bquo;salvation by grace through faith&equo;. 
 Perhaps &bquo;salvation by grace, experienced in listening to the preaching or reading of the biblical word, and in affirming the literal interpretation of that word&equo; might be a better if clumsier phrase. 
 In its effort to avoid all church mediation of the revealed word of God, the fundamentalist version relies on the  literal interpretation of the Bible, but one which imposes a contemporary Western culture on to the different perceptions of a past culture. 
 It is this characteristic which renders fundamentalist religion open to large numbers of fissures in communities, with preachers or sections of congregations shaking the dust from their feet and moving off to build or buy another church. 
 Fundamentalism is radically anti &mdash; catholic in its refusal to accept any form of priestly mediation. 
 Hickey (1984) and Wright (1973) grasp the point that both fundamentalism and Calvinism have monopoly tendencies in the public sphere. 
 The consequent interpretation of liberty is anti-libertarian and anti-pluralist. 
 The implementation of liberty can stretch to keeping places of recreation closed on Sundays, upholding the rights of preachers to speak in public places even if it causes an affray, and opposing the development of catholic schools because their teachers do not communicate the Bible without priestly mediation. 
 At the level of the unchurched popular consciousness, particularly in the urban protestant working classes, liberty may have slightly different significances. 
 It may also mean freedom to purchase &bquo;Playboy&equo; magazine, to indulge in the vulgarities of verbal and visual displays of the sexual and sexist types, though at a much lower level than those current in Scotland or England at soccer matches and in public houses. 
 But there remains a strong respect for the religious leadership of the protestant &mdash; loyalist bloc. 
 There is a resonance of protestant beliefs in their unchurched experience, their rough, straight-from-the-shoulder speech, their interpretation of history and tradition, and solidarity at the economic level based on their dependency upon the leadership of the group as a whole for their work and welfare. 
 The working classes are strongly bound into the total if ambiguous ideology of protestant loyalism. 
 With the emergence of the statelet in 1922, covenant politics was subordinated to the Stormont alliance only to re-emerge after Stormont's collapse in 1972. 
 In 1971, a new covenant was signed by over half a million men and women, committing protestants to a renewal of the covenant political ideal. 
 Miller (1978) suggests that the contractarian element was no longer ever so solid. 
 Be that as it may, it may turn out that the preparedness not to acquiesce in any all-Ireland solution is decidedly stronger than most commentators until recently were prepared to accept, except for the work of Bew, Gibbon, and Patterson.  
 Thus, protestant loyalists fight incorporation into a united Ireland for the reason that their perception of protestantism and their values of polity contain a powerful rejection of catholic monopoly, which they identify with catholicism tout court . 
 Their deeply held view on this matter is bound up with their interpretation of political realities. 
 The South is seen as dominated by the Roman church. 
 They point to the laws against divorce, abortion, and contraception, the power of the church in the education sector and past evidence of a hot-line between bishops and politicians as the proof of their contention. 
 As will be seen in Chapter 5, this interpretation is not without foundation. 
 The ethnic identity or contractarian ideology of the Ulster loyalist is clear in its origins, motivated by powerful economic, ethical, and religious convictions, all of which are interrelated, mutually supporting, and validated by the existence of a dominating catholic &mdash; nationalist bloc in the Republic of Ireland. 
 The sense of solidarity has developed and hardened over the years. 
 The popular slogan &bquo;This we will maintain&equo;, that is the union with Britain, can be equally applied to the religious and moral values the loyalists pride so much and which they see as embodied in the protestant &mdash; loyalist statelet, with its appropriate state apparatus of coercion and alternative paramilitary units. 
 For this reason, they feel that the siege of Londonderry has never been lifted and they are prepared to die to defend that heritage. 
 What the protestant loyalists in effect seek to maintain is protestant &mdash; loyalist domination within a flexible territory, one which they feel justified in calling their land and ruling according to their conscience. 
 The Key Mythical Structures of Protestant &mdash; Loyalist Popular Religion 
 It could be argued that the myths of Ulster protestantism and the institution of the Orange order take the place of the more centralized clerical organization of Roman catholicism in providing some element of overall religious unity among protestant loyalists. 
 By myth is meant here what has generally come to be accepted within sociology and social anthropology since the work of Levi-Strauss: an account of the origins of a society or of particular crucial events in its life, which unite the cosmos to the social structure by actively shaping everyday life perceptions. 
 The historical consciousness of Ulster protestants in this sphere is also a  faith consciousness. 
 The salvation history of the Bible is coupled with what is seen as a significant period in the history of the protestants of Ireland. 
 The key event in the history of Ireland which appears to encapsulate Ulster protestant faith in God through Christ and the destiny of Ulster protestants as a people, is the war of 1689&ndash;91. 
 William of Orange is seen to have worked the decisive victory at the Battle of the Boyne in 1690. 
 However, that myth is not quite the one which appears to have penetrated everyday life, perhaps because the place of the victory is located within the borders of the Southern state. 
 The most powerful myth affecting everyday life narrates the less decisive defence of the city of Londonderry in 1689. 
 The protestant refugees, inhabitants, and garrison of the city, which was built deliberately with a wall lest a catholic rebellion should ever occur, held the city for fifteen weeks against a poorly equipped catholic Irish army led by James II, the exiled king. 
 The besieged were led by a soldier and a clergyman. 
 A further particularity stressed in the protestant &mdash; loyalist account is the initiative and bravado of the local protestant apprentice boys who defied the city's governor, Robert Lundy. 
 He had ordered the opening of the city gates and capitulation. 
 The boys barricaded the gates and mounted the city walls, a move probably as much a result of a popular rebellion against Lundy's action as a defiant gesture. 
 Once the blockade of the river leading into the city was broken by English ships, James and his besiegers lost heart and abandoned the siege. 
 The mythical value of the siege for the construction of protestant &mdash; loyalist hegemony should not be underrated. 
 In his highly condensed and powerful analysis, Buckley (1984) details how the siege becomes interpreted by today's protestant loyalists according to a key paradigm mediating their experience of the world. 
 They may be talking about membership of Ulster's protestant secret societies, particularly the Orange order, the Royal Black Preceptory, and the Apprentice Boys' Club; or about religion &mdash; being saved, being a church member, or even a non-practising protestant; or what appear to them to be key ethical issues such as drink, tobacco, and money; or they may simply be describing in ordinary everyday language life in the family, on the farm, and in the village. 
 But in all these instances, similar categories of differentiation occur &mdash; the insiders and the outsiders, the religious and the rough,  the parent and the child, the female and the male. 
 At one point, the protestants who are involved in violence are rough as opposed to religious, especially if they drink and smoke and do not follow the norms of thrift. 
 Shift the context and the same men become insiders as opposed to outsiders such as catholics and, presumably, even castle catholics. 
 The rough insiders are on the walls, defending God's true believers from Romanism and immorality. 
 As Buckley points out, it is also the rough who penetrate the virgin city &mdash; the British fleet, breaking the boom across the river to bring food supplies to the stricken protestants within and ensuring the city's survival and the faithful people's triumph. 
 One can recognize here, with L&eacute;vi-Strauss (1968), the importance of ambiguous mediators in relating the opposites within one's cultural universe and one can add the Apprentice Boys to L&eacute;vi-Strauss's shortlist of tricksters and twins in this role. 
 Despite Buckley's reluctance to play up the siege of Derry as a key myth and his preference for general categories of interpretation derived from various historical experiences, it does seem that the siege has particular significance. 
 Those who still seek compromise with catholic nationalists today are still known to the erudite leadership of the DUP as Lundies. 
 One should add that Buckley takes the Christian myth for granted, as backdrop to the discourse. 
 But one must remember that the divergent reading of the Christian myth by Reformation and Counter-Reformation is at the heart of the religious as opposed to the rough interpretation of the conflict. 
 The importance of the protestant variant should not be underestimated given the extent of religious practice and the power of religious men within the protestant &mdash; loyalist bloc and the grave importance of conceiving of one's position as absolutely irreproachable, depending as it does on a divine source. 
 At the heart, or within the innermost wall of the protestant &mdash; loyalist alliance, is the man of God &mdash; not woman, not rough, and not immoral &mdash; be he soldier, clergyman, businessman, or farmer. 
 After the account of creation and redemption, which despite the variance among intellectual accounts in the past probably has slightly less relevance as a divider at the popular level, the two main variants begin (for popular accounts, see Harris 1972; Leyton 1975). 
 In the Roman catholic account, Christ appoints Peter to lead the church he has founded. 
 In the other, the church is founded but taken over early on by the Popes in Rome and by priests who use magic and ritual to gain control of God's  people, thus profaning his divine word. 
 For the one version, the Reformation is the catastrophe by which half Christendom defects from the church, the church itself remaining intact and faithful to Peter. 
 This version still predominates among Roman catholic laity in most countries. 
 For the popular protestant version, one which is still shared probably by a majority of clergymen within the protestant denominations of the North, the church re-emerges after centuries of misguidance only with the Reformation. 
 The protestant version has variants as to how pure this church is or whether it remains sinful, but the evangelical version which is the basic one in the North of Ireland opts absolutely for &bquo;Jesus Saves&equo;; the community, no longer medium of salvation, tends to take on a visible, earthly role, an occasion of grace and a support for religious &bquo;this-worldly&equo; activity. 
 Rome is seen to continue on its headlong path to misery and sin, a symbol of the rejection of Christ for the sake of human idols. 
 However, the earthly role of the community, be it protestant or catholic, is not seen as secondary to the religious message, but as either in continuity with or against it. 
 The Calvinist vision of an earthly city in which pastor and politician work in harmony to exclude evil from the lives of all those within the city walls remains a religious outlook for a significant number of protestant loyalists. 
 This is a totalizing view of society, and implies a certain anti-pluralism: freedom of belief and action within certain parameters, which are to be decided either by those who appear righteous in the sight of God or by those who, at least, conform in their lawmaking to the advice given to them by the righteous. 
 The very drift of the account of Christian myth and religious political ethics has certain parallels of structure with the siege of Londonderry. 
 These should be noted, before one views the siege as baseline myth for the interpretation of everyday life. 
 Religion and Violence 
 It is frequently denied that there is a relationship between religion and violence in Ireland. 
 Here it will be argued that an indirect, and occasionally a direct, relationship does exist. 
 Before applying the general analysis to Ireland, and in order to get to the heart of the matter, it is first necessary to understand the close relationship between beliefs and violence within the context of the state in general. 
 It is the state which properly exercises the use of force in order to maintain social control, whereas it is in civil society &mdash; the family,  school, work-place, church, and other non-state institutions &mdash; that hegemony operates. 
 However, the state also performs certain hegemonic functions too, justifying its own existence and authority in the rhetoric of the courts and in its celebration of the nation. 
 The civil sphere can also be an arena for coercion, through the activities of vigilantes, private armies, and mobs, irrespective of individual criminal activity. 
 Even so, force is, in the ideal state, primarily an exclusive instrument of the state, though even here force diffuses outwards from the state to civil society and to sections of its population and, as such, is intimately connected with hegemony. 
 This is already true at the level of the institutions of law. 
 These express the beliefs of law and order, and justice and freedom, hegemonic beliefs necessary for both citizen and state in any society aspiring to some model of equality. 
 This ideology of the state is coercively implemented in the policing, arresting, trying, convicting, and imprisoning of those found to default. 
 But this coercive role is partly performed by citizens too. 
 Sections of the population assist the police in the performance of their duties not just by taking on gunmen or robbers but also by making telephone calls to the police. 
 They thus form an extension of the coercive dimension of the state. 
 They consider such actions as their duty as citizens. 
 Put in another way, force is underpinned by dominant values extensively shared by the population and which support the operation of the state. 
 Citizens then act as witnesses in the courts and finally may compose the jury &mdash; the real judge of guilt and innocence. 
 In all capitalist democracies there are two sources for the legitimacy of the state, namely statehood itself and the ideology specific to the state in question. 
 It will be argued that when the second source is threatened as well as the first, the power to coerce can devolve on the civil sphere in a substantive way. 
 The conclusion to the argument will be that there is a specific form of violence of a political kind outside of state control which cannot be reduced to crime. 
 The specificity of this form of violence or coercion has to be recognized, however one feels about the terrible consequences of it for the innocent. 
 This form of political violence requires political answers and not just an anti-criminal, police-oriented, coercive response. 
 But also because such violence can have some hegemonic justification &mdash; derived in Ireland from the threat of the alternative alliance &mdash; the beliefs too must be scrutinized for their contribution, religious beliefs as well.  
 We can look at the twin sources for the state's legitimacy in the context of the Republic of Ireland. 
 First there is the fact of statehood, with the implied acceptance of law and order by the people. 
 Second, there is the unifying dominant beliefs of Irish catholic nationalism. 
 The distinct importance of the two sources appears in the way in which state and society in the republic treat the provisional movement. 
 PIRA is a proscribed organization and there is also a law preventing the national radio and television, RTE, from giving air time to members of the movement. 
 The intention is to impede the divulgation of its aims. 
 At the same time, despite the popular support for many of the activities of the provisionals north of the border, there is almost no popular support for terrorist activities against the established government in the South. 
 The legal position of the IRA is thus indicative of the inviolability of the statehood of the Republic in the national &mdash; popular consciousness. 
 An anti-state force such as the provisionals, who do not recognize the statehood of the twenty-six county state, cannot achieve support in the South for this essential policy. 
 The power of the element of statehood among the dominant beliefs appears to have been sufficient to neutralize the provisional movement in the South, even though it was severely tested by the event of Bloody Sunday in 1972, when thirteen demonstrators were killed by British soldiers in Derry, and by the provisional hunger strikes of 1981. 
 Any further attempt to violate the principle of statehood by the new Northern-led leadership, it could be presumed, is unlikely to succeed &mdash; indeed, in certain circumstances could result in a reduction of support for their Northern campaigns. 
 Secondly, and in contrast with this respect for the state's monopoly of violence, because the provisionals seek to destroy the Northern dominance of protestant loyalists with a view to restoring &bquo;the historic integrity of Ireland&equo;, there is and will remain substantial support from among the Southern population for the violence the provisionals actually commit in the North. 
 The belief in the integrity of Ireland is central to the unifying dominant beliefs of the alliance and is clearly distinct from the specificity of statehood. 
 The dual source of the state's role in hegemony helps us understand the limitations of the state in respect of the alliance whose power it also represents. 
 This is why collections by the provisionals in public houses were having partial success in the  1970s without too much interference by the Garda, the Republic's police force. 
 The collections indicated a wider hidden culture of support for &bquo;the lads&equo; who were at the forefront of the battle to restore national unity, in addition to the much smaller party political support they enjoyed in the South. 
 The Roman catholic church, in episcopal statements, unequivocally condemns violence North or South. 
 As seen in Chapter 3, this was also true in the nineteenth century, despite lower clergy support particularly for the Fenian movement. 
 Cardinal Cullen succeeded in getting three of the four religious provinces of Ireland to deny the sacraments to the Fenians, and only Archbishop McHale of the province of Tuam failed to toe the line. 
 Generally speaking, there is evidence that the church has always tended to support the hegemony of the state qua  state. 
 It supported the British state for most of the nineteenth century in Ireland, then supported constitutional politics for home rule; and when independence came in 1921, it supported the pro-treaty faction in Southern Ireland and opposed the civil war because that faction was the state. 
 It would appear that the popular religious consciousness makes a distinction between violence against the Southern state, whose statehood cannot be questioned, and violence for liberation in the North. 
 Though the extent to which such a consciousness exists is not clear, one aspect of it is beyond dispute: 35 per cent of McGreil's random sample of Dubliners and 46 per cent of the males in the sample, including a spread from the younger age groups and the more educated, supported the view that &bquo;the use of violence, while regrettable, has been necessary for the achievement of non-Unionist rights&equo; (M&aacute;c Gr&eacute;il 1977: 387). 
 In any event, there is likely to be significant variation in views as to how far one should condemn or condone this liberationist violence in the North. 
 One can now see how the preliminary data dealt with in Chapter 1 on good and bad religiosity among Roman catholics is indicative of a long-standing historical contradiction. 
 Irish catholics find themselves in an ambiguous relationship to Irish nationalism. 
 Having become the political expression not just of the state appropriate to Ireland but of Irish catholics as well, the Irish nationalist tradition contained and still contains within its confines a culture of violence antithetical to the church's traditional teaching. 
 Catholic nationalists who support or condone the killing of protestant loyalists do so on the grounds that members of the  Northern police force and part-time army are either agents of British imperialism or maintaining alien protestant &mdash; loyalist power in a part of Ireland. 
 Some more theologically articulate members of the provisional movement justify violence on traditional Roman catholic ethical grounds, the theory of the just war against the unjust oppressor. 
 For this faction, the term &bquo;just war&equo; has secular as well as religious appeal, an ambiguity which permits them to communicate their cause in direct fashion to left-wing British and right-wing American groups at one and the same time. 
 This culture of violence is complex, and needs wider and deeper research. 
 One is not simply alluding to the tradition of Padraig Pearse, one of the leaders of the Easter rising of 1916, who paralleled national violence and bloodshed to the salvation effected by the blood offering of Christ. 
 That tradition was frequently eschewed by later republicans. 
 The broader tradition is a typically nationalist one, seeing national liberation through war as honourable and singularly justified. 
 To a degree it is widespread among many not just in the provisional movement but also in the Fianna F&aacute;il party, and in general among those who see their history as one of liberation through blood. 
 The statue in the market square at Dundalk, a Provisional Sinn Fein memorial, of the Irish liberator rising up behind the phoenix, is an image with much wider appeal. 
 The Easter rising of 1916 as an act of national liberation, unquestioned in the dominant catholic &mdash; nationalist culture from 1922 until well into the 1960s and 1970s, still holds a cherished place in the hearts of the majority of the people. 
 It is possible for such sentiments of approval of this past to coexist with abhorrence for most current acts of violence. 
 But the political significance of this culture is that where opinion counts and where the catholic &mdash; nationalist remnant actually experiences the coercive power of protestant loyalists and the British army in the Northern statelet, there violence has all the more support. 
 When it does, it tends to be a reaction to perceived injustice, such as internment without trial, or the conviction of a son by a sole judge in a trial held in total secrecy and on the evidence of unseen witnesses, or a simple case of one's house being badly mauled by careless soldiers searching for arms. 
 This reactive violence is thus justified by its subjects and the justification subsists  in consciousness along with their Roman catholic profession of faith and identity. 
 The provisional IRA's commitment to violence against the British and against the protestant &mdash; loyalist alliance, which the provisionals rhetorically and conveniently subsume under the term &bquo;the British&equo;, is frequently assumed to be based on either Marxist or nationalist principles and in both cases to be secularist or areligious. 
 Yet some provisional leaders and rank and file members are committed to their Roman catholic religious belief and practice. 
 These beliefs can in fact contribute to the motivation of their struggle. 
 As Gramsci points out, the religion of the clergy is not necessarily the religion of this or that social group of laity, whose religious interpretation is also related to their own concrete world of experience. 
 Catholic morality approves of the view that to repel an aggressor is to engage in a just war. 
 It just so happens that Irish national &mdash; popular consciousness interprets the presence of the British state in Ireland as a form of aggression and hence feel justified in repelling the British from Ireland. 
 Catholic morality also approves of a proportionate degree of violence to overthrow tyranny. 
 Many Irish catholic nationalists also consider the British and their Orange allies to have established tyrannical government in a part of Ireland. 
 Therefore they find it just to overthrow the Northern statelet by whatever degree of force proves necessary. 
 Of course, some beliefs in violence are unrelated to catholic moral teaching. 
 Some Irish nationalists hold that it is just to unite the nation by force &mdash; a typical view of secular nationalism throughout the nineteenth and twentieth centuries in Europe. 
 But traditional catholic moral doctrine would oppose this on the grounds of the legitimacy of the state qua  state. 
 Doubtless some protestant paramilitaries &mdash; though there have been fewer religious persons among them than in the case of the provisionals &mdash; hold to similar religious understandings of the necessity of violence under certain circumstances. 
 Covenant theology itself empowers the people to take action against the state in certain and specific circumstances, and Ian Paisley and many of his supporters both within and without the Orange order have frequently used bully-boy tactics, and approved paramilitary processions, marching, and drilling. 
 From Carson to Paisley one finds the argument that it is legitimate to fight to regain one's fundamental freedom if the sovereign with whom one has  covenanted one's allegiance betrays that allegiance and conducts one into slavery. 
 The argument is clearly inspired by a religious motivation and shows Ulster protestantism to be a vigorous form of political religion, approving whatever defensive measures are necessary to avoid submission to Rome rule. 
 Ulster protestantism is not contained within churches but spills out on to the streets. 
 Religion is also involved in the violence indirectly. 
 Indeed, this is the most significant aspect of the role of religion in the divisions and conflicts in Ireland and goes to the heart of the matter. 
 In the remaining chapters, it is argued that religion in Ireland basically solidifies the opposing alliances in an exclusive way and precludes a common state form, thus providing the structure of violence which such divisions entail. 
 This will be shown to be particularly the case in the next chapter on the relationship between catholicism and the Irish constitution. 
 CONCLUSION 
 It would be true to say that catholic nationalism was at its most formidable in the years between independence and the rise of pragmatic politics in the Republic under Sean Lemass in the late 1950s. 
 In that period of the early development of the state, the nationalist ideal was almost totally unquestioned. 
 But now, on the basis of a number of well-documented opinion polls, W. Harvey Cox (1985) argues that the majority in the Republic of Ireland favouring reunification is barely two to one, and that in the island as a whole it is three to two. 
 What is more, Cox suggests that support in the South is at best lukewarm. 
 None the less, the characterization of catholic &mdash; nationalist ideology I have just documented would seem to fly in the face of this sort of evidence. 
 The general data presented by Cox are undeniable, but interpretation of the data rests on certain assumptions, principally that people act on an individualistic basis rather than as groups, and according to attitudes expressed in the quiet of their homes rather than in response to major events. 
 One remembers the substantial surge in Provisional support in the North on the occasion of the hunger strikes of 1981, and the impact they had on Northern catholic &mdash; nationalist consciousness, one which Cox himself acknowledges. 
 One also remembers the effect &bquo;Bloody Sunday&equo; had on Southern attitudes, resulting in the burning of the British Embassy  in Dublin, in 1972. 
 Though opinion in the South gradually softened, there can be little doubt that the obverse would have been the case had the British government not changed tack and demurred at an openly repressive strategy. 
 Public opinion responds to the conjunction of culture and event and solidifies either old or burgeoning values as might be the case. 
 What has been attempted in this chapter has been the clarification that so far  the traditional values of catholic nationalism are still dominant among the Roman catholics of Ireland, even if they are severely contested by a significant minority from among them and lukewarmly subscribed to by a further significant minority. 
 There is as yet no shift in the overall direction of the group, which remains dominated in terms of political action by its monopoly catholic and nationalist constituencies. 
 Cox sees the growth of modernity and pragmatism as the likely direction for the group, with the consequent and gradual dissolution of catholic nationalism. 
 That is indeed a possibility. 
 But more likely is the possibility that it will continue to respond to events, in the way it has done in the past &mdash; and there is no guarantee that the evolution Cox envisages will be any more natural than the modernization of Iran seemed to be in the 1970s. 
 The comparison is a little strong, but only with the intention of making an important point. 
 In 1985 Cox's paper was timely and asked for shifts in American Irish and British labour politics in a wholly correct way. 
 But the optimism for change in the Republic of Ireland remains somewhat unqualified.  
 Religion and Law in the Southern State 
 Shoring up Monopoly Catholicism 
 INTRODUCTION 
 One of the key institutions which embodies the values of dominant alliances in states is the institution of law. 
 It is important particularly because it draws together both coercion and hegemony in the state. 
 The dominant religion can also be mediated through law. 
 In fact, in the Republic of Ireland, catholicism is doubly important. 
 Not only does it form a part of the dominant beliefs of catholic nationalists, but their state form gives catholic social teaching coercive and hegemonic support. 
 Catholicism is present in everyday life through state law, as well as through authoritative statements by clergy and through the national &mdash; popular consciousness. 
 The clearest example of law as mediator of political religion in Ireland is the Irish constitution of 1937 and its subsequent interpretation. 
 part of this interpretation has been by politicians and clerics as well as by judges. 
 The interaction of these powerful figures in the life of the Republic has been significant for the preservation and development of the catholic &mdash; nationalist world view. 
 Religious leaders have developed ideologies of natural law and the common good to reinforce the Roman catholic element. 
 Sections of the catholic &mdash; nationalist population have also combined their own popular nationalism and religion with aspects of the clerical interpretation already invested in the law, particularly in the anti-abortion movement of the early 1980s. 
 Other areas where political religion helps to solidify one or both of the alliances are separate education and catholic-protestant marriages. 
 These will be dealt with in Chapters 6 and 7. 
 The three areas can be described as ones of political &mdash; religious mediation occurring at different levels of social process. 
 They help solidify state, church, and common people of varying classes into two opposing blocs from whose grasp it is difficult to escape.  
 RELIGION AND LAW, 1922&ndash;1972 
 The Irish Constitution and Roman Catholic Teaching 
 Sown into the constitutional fabric of the Republic of Ireland is a local and time-bound Roman catholic ethos which has changed perhaps in only minor ways since the founding of the state. 
 The Irish state apparatus is certainly secular: priests have no role in it. 
 The Roman catholic church is financed out of voluntary contributions. 
 The state has no role in the appointment of bishops and the juridical processes of church and state are kept entirely separate, though it will be seen that a number of administrative procedures reflect a direct link. 
 We will see that this mode of constructing monopoly catholicism is alien to the Concordat period of Roman catholic church &mdash; state relations recognizable in arrangements, for example, with Spain, Portugal, and Italy. 
 A dislike by Irish clerics for such an explicit and direct church &mdash; state relationship has a long tradition and comes out best in De Tocqueville's (1957) conversations with Irish clergy on his visit to Ireland in 1834. 
 When asked if they would like subventions from the state to aid their stipends and church buildings, a move which was being seriously considered by the British government at the time, priests and bishops were united in rejecting the idea on the grounds that it would drive a wedge between clergy and people, identifying clergy with the principal enemies of the people. 
 De Tocqueville's notes reveal not only the conscious opposition to such a mode of religious power but also how deep the solidarity between clergy and people was, the degree to which the poor, half the catholic population at the time, looked to the clergy for material and spiritual leadership, guidance, and assistance, and how much they trusted them. 
 However, with the emergence of the Southern Irish state, it soon became clear that this secularization of the state form was not to signify an absence of Roman catholic power in the construction of public morality, but rather an indirect recognition of the sovereignty of the church in most areas of moral concern besides education. 
 In fact, precisely because Roman catholic power was to be accepted as normative in an entirely natural way by the catholic &mdash; nationalist population, the church's part-active and part-passive  acceptance of the capitalist system of government and thorough opposition to socialism had a significant legitimating function for the Irish state-form. 
 But this will not be the main focus of attention here; to make the general point requires tracing only the impact of the specific church teaching of the period on constitutional law and its implementation in Ireland. 
 A Roman catholic ethos is not only present in the constitution of 1937 but has penetrated into affairs of state, legislation, and decisions over the destinies of individuals with frequency. 
 A significant aspect of the religious hegemonic role can be seen in the translation of religious preoccupations into law via the concept of natural law. 
 This mediation of ethics makes indirect one's access to the problem of the relationship between the religious faith of some and the morality of the many, particularly on the issue of the freedom of the individual versus the intervention of the state. 
 In this respect, it is useful to pay attention to what we might now term the human rights' issue as one examines the handling of public &mdash; private morality in the Irish constitution. 
 The first constitution of the Southern state was the Constitution of the Irish Free State of 1922. 
 Under the treaty with the United Kingdom, the twenty-six counties which were to become the independent state were to remain within the British Empire with dominion status, and the British monarch was to remain head of state. 
 These principles were embodied in the constitution. 
 The prime reason for bringing in a new constitution in 1937 was the return to dominance of the republican grouping, the side which had lost the civil war, and which had retained the intention of establishing a republic. 
 The new Fianna F&aacute;il Party, under the leadership of Eamon de Valera, was intent on asserting Irish independence to the full by leaving the empire and providing a president to replace the monarchy, thus becoming the Republic of Ireland. 
 The 1922 constitution approved by Britain was considered a model of libertarian democracy. 
 The preamble of the new constitution of 1937 proclaims: 
 In the Name of the Most Holy Trinity&hellip; 
 We, the people of Eire, 
 Humbly acknowledging all our obligations to our Divine Lord, Jesus Christ, Who sustained our fathers through centuries of trial, 
 Gratefully remembering their heroic struggle to regain the rightful independence of our Nation&hellip; 
 Do hereby adopt, enact, and give to ourselves this Constitution. 
 Clearly, the spirit of the laws of this Irish state was to be a religious one and therefore one which would not take account of the then one thousand, and now ten thousand or more of the population in the Southern state who professed no religion. 
 But it was also an explicitly Christian spirit &mdash; unfortunate therefore for the four thousand Jews and for the tiny but now increasing numbers of Hindus, Buddhists, Muslims, and Taoists. 
 The preamble was reinforced by Article 44, paragraph 1: 
 The State acknowledges that the homage of public worship is due to Almighty God. 
 It shall hold His Name in reverence and shall respect and honour religion. 
 The presidential oath (Art. 
 12) also embodied this principle by calling on God's name explicitly. 
 Church teaching was already having an impact. 
 The spirit of papal statements throughout the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries was that it was the duty of the state to oppose freedom of conscience in matters of religion and freedom of worship and to celebrate openly the worship of God &bquo;in that way which he has shown to be his will&equo;, namely Roman catholicism (Leo XIII 1903: 111&ndash;12). 
 In a sense, the new Irish constitution was going against the spirit of this approach. 
 As already mentioned, the Irish bishops had for some time found the separation of church and state both a workable and desirable solution. 
 In addition, paragraph 3 of the same article recognized the main protestant churches then existing in Ireland. 
 However, this was a fairly necessary compromise: paragraph 2 had already conferred on the Roman catholic church a &bquo;special position&equo; in the state, on the grounds that the church was &bquo;the guardian of the Faith professed by the great majority of its citizens&equo;. 
 The concept of the majority is an important one in both British and Irish politics as already seen in Chapter 4. 
 What matters for the moment is to examine the contention that the Roman catholic church had this special position only because of this matter of fact. 
 It is true that the constitution was explicit in recognizing important personal rights in Article 40: equality before the law, the non-recognition of nobility privileges, defence of person and property, liberty, no detention without trial, freedom of speech and assembly. 
 In fact, some of the paragraphs reproduced in summary  form the personal rights articles of the constitution of 1922 and thus could claim to maintain the latter's libertarian heritage. 
 Yet the articles which followed qualified certain of these rights in a typically catholic way and in the terms of the papal teaching of the day. 
 Consider Article 41: 
 The State recognises the Family as the natural primary and fundamental unit group of Society and as a moral institution possessing inalienable and imprescriptible rights, antecedent and superior to all positive law&hellip; 
 This has a clear relationship with Pius XI's teaching, eight years earlier on the same subject: &bquo;the very fountainhead from which the State draws its life, namely, wedlock and the family&equo; (1929: 14), and with the dispositions of the then current Code of Canon Law  which had come into effect in 1917: &bquo;The marriage of baptized persons is governed not only by divine law but also by church law. 
 The civil power only has competence in matters regarding the effects of such marriages&equo; (Code of Canon Law 1917: 1016). 
 The dispositions of the Irish constitution were clearly designed to accommodate such a position in full. 
 The implications were spelt out in Article 41, paragraphs 2 and 3, which pledged the state to protect marriage and the family and forbade divorce. 
 Thus were re-echoed the papal teachings of the indissolubility of both Christian and non-Christian marriage and of the state's obligation to reinforce that indissolubility (Leo XIII 1903: 68, 77, 78 &mdash; Arcanum Divinae  1880; Pius XI 1930: 4, 16; Code of Canon Law 1917: 1013). 
 Article 42 recognized that &bquo;the primary and natural educator of the child is the family&equo;. 
 Again, this view is related to Pius XI's, as expressed in Divini Illius Magistri : &bquo;The family holds directly from the Creator the mission and hence the rights to educate the offspring, a right inalienable because inseparably joined to the strict obligation, a right anterior to any right whatever of civil society and of the State&hellip;&equo; (1929: 14). 
 Article 42 went on to give an almost supplementary right to the state in providing for a child's education by acknowledging the right of parents to school their children in their own home should they wish it. 
 The article as a whole is strangely lopsided but seems to follow on from the logic of this position, embodying the agreement made between clergy and politicians towards the end of the nineteenth century outlined in Chapter 3.  
 The article now left the way open for the full expression of the teaching of Pius XI that, though the family had &bquo;priority of nature and therefore of rights over civil society&equo;, education belonged &bquo;preeminently to the Church, by reason of a double title in the supernatural order, conferred exclusively upon her by God himself; absolutely superior therefore to any other title in the natural order&equo; (1929: 5&ndash;6). 
 The double title consisted of the church's mission to teach under infallible guidance and her &bquo;supernatural motherhood&equo; by which the church &bquo;educates souls in the divine life of grace&equo; (1929: 7). 
 As the church owned and managed the majority of the schools its faithful attended, and had a role in the management of the bulk of the remainder, the Roman catholic laity were left mainly on the receiving end of the educational policy thus legitimated. 
 More was to follow. 
 There had been no mention of the individual's property rights in the 1922 constitution. 
 In the new one, as if to repeat the church's social teaching against communism that &bquo;every man has by nature the right to possess property as his own&equo; (Leo XIII 1903: 210), Article 43 announced: 
 The State acknowledges that man, in virtue of his rational being, has the natural right, antecedent to positive law, to the private ownership of external goods. 
 Not only did the church's social teaching directly enter into the definition of rights, wrongs, and obligations within this nation state, but it was also to affect one aspect of the structure of government. 
 The senate was to have 60 members: 11 were to be directly appointed by the Prime Minister, or Taoiseach, and 49 by election. 
 Six of the latter were to be elected by the two Irish universities. 
 But the remaining 43 were to be elected by local and national politicians on a vocational basis: that is, they had to be elected to five panels for which they would qualify by having the requisite vocational expertise &mdash; administrative, cultural &mdash; educational, labour, industrial and commercial, and agricultural. 
 A somewhat unusual system one might think: but not according to the papal encyclical Quadragesimo Anno  of 1931. 
 It sought to overcome conflict within capitalist societies by encouraging Christian leaders to reconsider Leo XIII's suggestion of introducing &bquo;industrial associations&equo;. 
 These were to be intermediary between capital and labour and based precisely upon types of vocational expertise in a way similar to medieval guilds (Leo XIII 1903: 240&ndash;7; Pius XI 1931: 32&ndash;4).  
 Reasons for the Political Religious Synthesis: first Conclusions 
 The way these various aspects of current Roman catholic social teaching were presented in the Irish constitution can hardly be taken as fulfilment of the need to reflect the opinions of the majority of the republic's population. 
 The confessional and moral articles were largely the work of the constitution's architect, the then prime minister Eamon de Valera. 
 He certainly felt that the culture of the state should reflect the fact that it was 93 per cent Roman catholic. 
 But it is hardly possible to reconcile this with the claim of the constitution in Article 2 that the new state was the legitimate means of government for the entire island, which included over one million dissenting protestants, forming some 20 per cent of the total population. 
 Their culture was not to be considered at all in the constitution. 
 One is faced here with the blind spot of the dominant form of Irish nationalism, already so apparent in the preamble to the constitution itself, a blindness made possible by the ideological differentiation of state and religion combined with the ideological unity of the people, seen at once as both nation and catholic. 
 De Valera was continuing the now dominant culture recognized by Eoin MacNeill and Douglas Hyde when, in his St Patrick's Day address to the United States of America, broadcast in 1935, he underlined the spirit of that preamble: &bquo;Since the coming of St. Patrick, fifteen hundred years ago, Ireland has been a Christian and a Catholic nation. 
 All the ruthless attempts to force her from this allegiance have not shaken her faith. 
 She remains a Catholic nation&equo; ( Catholic Bulletin , 25/4 (Apr. 1935), p. 273, quoted Whyte 1980: 48). 
 To the link catholicism-nation de Valera was also adding Gaelic identity in the form of the state promotion of the language: 
 The Irish language as the national language is the first official language. 
 The English language is recognised as a second official language. 
 (Constitution of Ireland 1937: Art. 
 B, paras. 
 1, 2) 
 De Valera, was, however, openly aware of the alienation of Ulster protestants which such an affirmation of language implied: 
 I would not to-morrow, for the sake of a united Ireland, give up the policy of trying to make this a really Irish Ireland &mdash; not by any means. 
 If I were told to-morrow, &bquo;You can have a united Ireland if you give up your idea of restoring the national language to be the spoken language of the majority of the people&equo;, I would, for myself, say no. 
 (Quoted Laffan 1983: 119) 
 Whether or not he was equally aware of a similar alienation process in asserting the catholic nature of the nation is perhaps more open to debate. 
 In any case, the practical attitude clearly excluded the protestant population of the island and left protestant loyalists in no ambiguity as to their place in any future united Ireland. 
 If Ireland was a catholic nation, then its law and government would be correspondingly so whatever the disposition of church &mdash; state relationships, theocratic or secular. 
 The second likely reason for the deliberate use of church teaching in formulating parts of the constitution is implicit in the presence of the papal-oriented articles of the constitution themselves. 
 Pius XI had made it clear in 1930, subsequent to the success of the Vatican-Italian Concordat of 1929, that good sons of the church with political power were to look to the church itself for guidance in their statesmanship: 
 Governments can assist the Church greatly in the execution of its important office if, in laying down their ordinances, they take account of what is prescribed by divine and ecclesiastical law, and if penalties are fixed for offenders&hellip; 
 As Leo XIII has already so clearly set forth: &bquo;&hellip; 
 The dignity of the State will be enhanced, and with religion as its guide, there will never be a rule that is not just&hellip;&equo; (1930: 64) 
 In fact, de Valera and the civil servants he appointed to assist in the work, consulted Irish theologians on matters of society and church &mdash; state relations (Longford and O'Neill 1970: 295&ndash;6; Whyte 1980: 379; Keogh 1987; Faughnan 1988). 
 The most important was John Charles McQuaid, a Holy Ghost priest and later archbishop of Dublin. 
 Jesuits and other Holy Ghost priests were also involved. 
 Papal encyclicals came to be consulted by this route, as did the current treatises of Ius Publicun  on church &mdash; state relations. 
 These were heavily biased towards the view that there were two perfect societies, both supreme in their own orders, with the church supreme in spiritual and moral matters (see Pius IX's Syllabus of Errors  in Freemantle 1956: 145&ndash;6, 152; Leo XIII 1903: 114; Pius XI 1930: 65; for typical treatise approaches see Van Noort 1960: 235&ndash;41; Bender 1960). 
 Of course, it was for the church  to decide what constituted a spiritual or moral matter. 
 But, to his credit, de Valera toned down the catholicism in the drafts suggested to him by the clergy, consulted Rome, and was successful in getting it at least to be neutral about his preferred formulations (Keogh 1987:. 
 43&ndash;53). 
 He also consulted protestant church leaders on the religious elements of the new constitution, a step unprecedented in catholic Ireland of his day, and gained their support on the basis of the recognition of their churches the constitution was to give. 
 But there is a third and underlying reason which must have motivated de Valera and the religious and political intellectuals in this religious pursuit of an allegedly secular and public morality which mirrored Roman catholic teaching. 
 The issue of heeding the church was not simply one of seeking a mediator of divine guidance on matters of Christian conscience. 
 For the Roman catholic social teaching of the day laid down certain things as of natural law which anyone who was reasonable and honest was supposed to be able to recognize. 
 The advice of the church's moral experts and authoritative clerics was thus pertinent to the entire population of the world, let alone that of Ireland. 
 The conscientious lay person was simply involved in a two-way process of having his or her conscience informed, while at the same time being protected from making unintended errors of judgement. 
 The church was acting on behalf of all, and had a prime obligation to push for a public morality which matched its perception of the natural law lest the very fabric of society be torn asunder and its members cast on the road of moral decline. 
 What was good for catholics was also good for protestants, and Ireland was to be no exception. 
 In fairness to de Valera, it must be said that he opposed any attempt to incorporate the church into the apparatus of the state and in this was, as already noted, going against the form of relationship preferred by the Popes of the day. 
 But his attitude was by now part of the common sense of clergy and people alike. 
 There appeared to be no reason to upset long-established routines in this respect. 
 But that did not mean that the ethos of a Roman catholic state would be in any way diminished, only that the form of political religious power would be different. 
 An important aspect of the successful implementation of these parts of the constitution was that the political opposition did not object to them. 
 They really were part of the unquestioned reality of the culture of the state. 
 Part of this culture was a certain distinction  between what made up the sacred and what made up the profane spheres. 
 If guidance were to be sought in matters which hovered on the boundary between the two, it was likely that the church would be seen by people and politicians as authoritative in resolving the issue. 
 But there was in any case no doubt that the areas of the family, education, and public morality constituted part of the sacred sphere. 
 One explicit guiding principle of papal teaching which came to influence the Irish constitution and successive debates culminating in the church &mdash; state imbroglio of 1951, dealt with below, was that of &bquo;subsidiarity&equo;: that no &bquo;secondary&equo; institution such as the state should take on duties which &bquo;primary&equo; and &bquo;intermediate&equo; ones, such as the family, could assume. 
 Secondary institutions were also expected to assist primary ones in fulfilling their essential tasks. 
 The principle took on particular importance in the light of the development of totalitarian communism, and the Roman church saw the threat to be endemic in the growth of the modern state apparatus, including its welfare institutions. 
 It is also important to notice how easily such a principle supports personal enterprise and property in its contemporary form, capitalism. 
 Aspects of the Irish constitution and its implementation are clearly oppressive as well as offensive to other minorities besides the protestant ones. 
 The structure of this oppressive power contained not the Roman catholic church as state executive, but as what Gramsci termed &bquo;an organic intellectual&equo;, as a planner and co-executor of the ethos of the state, merging this public aspect of the catholicism of the day with ideological elements from more recognized sources of catholic-Irish nationalism: the language movement, anti-imperialism and, generally, catholic-Irish domination. 
 The purpose of detailing the relationship between the Irish constitution and the papal teaching of the period has not been to ridicule seemingly outdated church &mdash; state dispositions. 
 The writings of Leo XIII (1878&ndash;1903), on which those of Pius XI (1922&ndash;39) were frequently constructed, are remarkable expressions of a papacy dragging itself up by its bootstraps from centuries of neglect in the field of social, economic, and political issues. 
 It had continually opposed socio-political change and had had little understanding of the industrialization process up to that time. 
 The growth of the catholic social movements and activity of Roman  catholics in trade unions and politics was rooted in this dramatic revival, which gave rise to Catholic Action and the development of catholic social studies groups around the world. 
 The birth of sociologie religieuse  and the initial contributions of catholic institutions both in Europe and the USA to the founding of departments of sociology are rooted here rather than in the work of the founding fathers of the discipline, though clearly there are links between de Bonald, Maistre, and Durkheim on the nature of social solidarity and the concept of society, and authoritative Roman catholic social theorists. 
 Equally, the stress on the negative influence of Irish catholicism is not meant to imply a negation of its positive aspects: its sustenance of the people during long years of oppression, the dedication of its clergy and religious orders, both in education and in welfare, not to mention the contribution of its missionaries to the fight for social justice in third-world countries. 
 Its lay politicians have equally made important contributions. 
 De Valera himself resisted right-wing pressures to enhance the role of the church in the Irish state and successfully opposed tendencies to fascism apparent in Irish paramilitary movements of the thirties (Manning 1970). 
 The Pre-Constitutional Ethos.: The Case of the Protestant Librarian of County Mayo and Issues of Sexual Morality 
 Was the Irish constitution merely an abstract one, without actual social consequences? 
 It was not only a constitution which really was and is effective in the running of the state, but which was itself the product of the hegemonic culture already established. 
 Whyte (1980) provides several instances of the influence of the Roman catholic moral code in both state decision-making and in public behaviour from 1922 through to the 1950s. 
 The most interesting one, in which clergy, local people, and the D&aacute;il all played their part, was the case of the protestant librarian in County Mayo, 1930&ndash;1. 
 A woman protestant was appointed as county librarian, but when the county library committee met to ratify the appointment, it refused to do so by ten votes to two. 
 The committee was largely made up of Roman catholic clergy, and they clearly opposed the appointment on the grounds that a protestant could not be trusted to safeguard the catholic morals of her charges in her purchase and loaning of books. 
 Though the Cosgrave government then in power insisted on the appointment, the local population and authorities boycotted  the operation of the library, and the government had to concede by moving the librarian elsewhere. 
 When the matter was debated in the D&aacute;il, Fianna F&aacute;il opposed the government view, and de Valera himself supported the local population's opposition on the same religious grounds. 
 From the point of view of the issue of law, there can be no doubt as to the influence both of the constitution of 1937 in the period following its enactment and of the influence of Roman catholic teaching on legislation prior to that date. 
 But these were all in areas circumscribed by the church as spiritual matters. 
 The church's greatest denunciations were reserved in the early period for sexual immorality and the dangers to the people coming from modern society: from the cinema, literature, radio, and, above all, from dance-halls (Whyte 1980: 25&ndash;34). 
 Already in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, there had been a powerful alignment between rural cultural ethics and church teaching. 
 On the sons and daughters of the farming family was imposed the strict necessity of abstaining from sexual activity other than for the first born, so as not to impair the integrity of land succession. 
 From the church came a dual impulse strengthening this morality: the prevailing teaching on sexual abstention outside of marriage under pain of mortal sin, and the rigorous life of a clergy pledged to chastity and preaching the need for an unmarried laity to practise the same degree and kind of circumspection in sexual matters which the clergy had been taught to impose upon themselves. 
 If anything, the return of the land to the practising farmers by the land Acts would have strengthened such a morality. 
 It is also interesting to note that the issue of land inheritance was a key reason why the Irish population voted &bquo;no&equo; in the referendum on divorce in 1986. 
 That the local priests continued to play a significant part in the regulation of local sexual morality from the beginning of the state is shown by accounts of &bquo;boy meets girl&equo; from the 1920s. 
 For example: &bquo;In 1931 we got a new P&lsqb;arish&rsqb; P&lsqb;riest&rsqb;. 
 He condemned dancing in every form, even the kitchen dances were sinful and against the wishes of our Church. 
 Boys and girls should not be on the road after dark. 
 The C&lsqb;atholic&rsqb; C&lsqb;urate&rsqb; was sent out to patrol the roads and anybody found or seen on the roads had to give their names. 
 The people who allowed boys and girls into  their home to dance were committing a grave mortal sin&hellip; 
 Dancing was the devil's work&hellip; 
 (Kavanagh 1954, quoted Whyte 1980: 29&ndash;30)&equo; 
 The Irish state apparatus assisted public and family morality by the fairly heavy censorship of books, magazines, newspapers, and films. 
 It also banned the making, importation, or distribution. 
 of contraceptives, and the distribution of any literature informing on such matters. 
 The reaction of the first D&aacute;il to successive attempts to introduce legislation for divorce was to change standing orders so that such a bill could not be introduced again. 
 Since the new constitution was enacted in 1937, the prohibition on divorce has become so strict that couples who have been granted a nullity decree by Roman catholic canonical tribunals have found that they may still not be recognized as single by the state, and are thus unable to remarry in the Republic. 
 There has been a degree of attenuation of this rigidity in some respects, but only in favour of the church's interpretation. 
 People seeking to remarry must first get a divorce abroad &mdash; which in practice means Britain. 
 Naturally, apart from the accusation of hypocrisy and of letting Britain solve its marriage problems, the government ends up being accused of allowing divorce for the wealthy and none for the poor, as the cost of going to and staying in Britain and paying for the legal procedures is beyond the pockets of the majority. 
 An additional concern of the church remained the fear of socialism. 
 The labour party, which still had some of the socialist leanings of its founder James Connolly, was forced by its own lay members to amend its draft constitution in 1940 in order to fall in line with current papal social teaching. 
 Phrases such as striving for the setting up of a &bquo;Workers&equo; republic' and the establishment of &bquo;public ownership&equo; were excised, as they were seen by the members of an affiliated teachers' union, and ultimately by the bishops, to counter church doctrine (Whyte 1980: 82&ndash;4; Keogh 1982: 7, 77 n.5). 
 The teachers' union even submitted the draft constitution to the bishops so as to get it right. 
 It is to be noted that, in this, it was the laity who took the initiative.  
 Testing the Alliance 1: The Adoption Controversy 
 The way in which the morality received by the state from the Roman catholic church could create conflict within the state but still be transferred into the coercive sphere of state activity can be seen in two cases in particular. 
 They are indicative not only of the strength of current Roman catholic social rules and sense of obedience on specified issues at the level of popular religion, but also of the direct power of the hierarchy operating through the state in affairs they considered sacred. 
 The two cases also show that change is a possibility, but that it has mainly been in the past through change in the hierarchy's and clergy's attitudes as well. 
 The cases equally indicate the boundary beyond which the church was seen as abusing its definitions of the sacred. 
 The first of these incidents occurred with the attempt to introduce a law on adoption. 
 During the period 1947&ndash;51, an inordinate delay on the part of the government was experienced in bringing forward the requisite bill legalizing adoption, despite considerable pressure from prospective adoptive parents and adoption agencies. 
 In the new state, fostering was the only way to provide a home for orphaned and otherwise parentless children. 
 It became clear that the relevant government ministers were deliberately hindering the progress of the necessary bill. 
 When both the Minister for Justice, General McEoin, and the Attorney General, Mr Charles Casey, made it clear that they considered the legislation inopportune, pressure for an explanation eventually brought forward a response from Mr Casey. 
 He argued that Article 42 of the constitution claimed the primary right of care for the natural parents and was inalienable: it could not be delegated. 
 In addition, he argued that legalizing adoption was against the teaching of &bquo;the church&equo;. 
 He further argued, or at least implied, that to permit a &bquo;non-catholic&equo; to adopt children would be wrong because it might put such children's eternal salvation in jeopardy (Whyte 1980: 188&ndash;9). 
 It later became clear that the two ministers had consulted the Roman catholic archbishop of Dublin before delivering their judgement on the matter. 
 An adoption bill eventually became law two years later, in 1952, under the next administration. 
 Mr Casey and the archbishop were  judged to have followed a conservative catholic viewpoint and the 
 1952 solution was adopted because it reflected what had become a more theologically certain position on the matter. 
 But even the new bill limited adoption to parents possessing the same religious identity as the child. 
 This meant that couples who had married across the religious divide were not allowed to adopt at all. 
 As will be seen in Chapter 7, this itself could only have been due to current Roman catholic social teaching on mixed marriage. 
 It was 1974 before that particular form of discrimination was removed by a new Adoption Act. 
 Testing the Alliance 2: The Mother and Child Scheme Controversy 
 The second case reveals even more the extent to which the legitimation of the state was a Roman catholic affair, at least as one of the two principal sources of power in the alliance. 
 From the early 1940s, the Irish government began to work towards the introduction of a comprehensive health service for mothers and children in line with other legislative developments in Western countries. 
 There can be no doubt that the lack of such a programme bore heavily upon the poor, and that poor health and mortalities were a consequence. 
 In 1946 there were already signs of clerical opposition to any socialization of welfare in queries about Fianna F&aacute;il's proposals from Archbishop McQuaid and the Confederation of Convent Schools. 
 As has already been seen, it was the style of both church and politicians to avoid their mutual consultations being known, which tells us that the secularity of the state at that time was partially a fa&ccedil;ade, but one which it was felt by both interested parties had to be maintained, probably so as not to confuse the faithful. 
 In a letter to the Irish premier in 1947, while an extensive health bill was going through parliament, the bishops &bquo;pointed out that to claim such powers for the public authority, without qualification, is entirely and directly contrary to Catholic teaching on the rights of the family, the Church in education, the rights of the medical profession and voluntary institutions&equo; ( Irish Independent , 12 Apr. 1951, quoted Whyte 1980: 143). 
 It appeared that one of the main sources of the bishops' opposition was the authoritarian nature of the legislation. 
 That the bishops were  affected by the opposition of the medical profession to the scheme &mdash; clearly they stood to lose money and independence if such a scheme were implemented &mdash; seems likely. 
 Whereas similar provisions in other countries were mainly designed to provide facilities which could or could not be used, the Irish ones were to be compulsory and there was to be no choice of doctor. 
 The hierarchy feared the move as the thin end of the wedge of secularism and the totalitarian state. 
 It appears they feared the appointment of secular medical personnel who might educate mothers in family planning and their children in sexual matters. 
 Additionally, they feared the full development of a national health service, viewed by them as unacceptable socialism. 
 A change of government in 1948 found the new administration equally committed to health reform. 
 The new Minister for Health, Dr Noel Browne, a dedicated reformer of the health services and much concerned in particular with the eradication of tuberculosis in Ireland, modified the earlier bill to exclude the compulsion elements. 
 But by March 1951, it was clear that even this reform did not satisfy the Irish hierarchy who had also been lobbied by the Irish Medical Association to oppose the scheme. 
 Grounds for the bishops' opposition were that only parents and not the state should have the right to provide for the health of their children, that the state had no role to play in the physical education of children and mothers, and that individual privacy would be threatened by public use of their private health records (Whyte 1980: 213&ndash;14). 
 Later the hierarchy made it clear that the basis for their objections was the increase in power by the state vis-&agrave;-vis  the liberty and self-reliance of its citizens which such legislation would entail. 
 Perhaps the most revealing aspect of the whole affair is the way Dr Browne handled it. 
 The members of his party appeared to know nothing about the opposition of the hierarchy to the earlier Bill, and Dr Browne only found out in October/November 1950. 
 When he was told of the hierarchy's opposition to any bill of this kind, Dr Browne, himself secularly inclined, submitted his proposals and arguments to the hierarchy for approval, just as a previous Health Minister, Dr Walsh, had consulted Archbishop McQuaid on a similar matter in 1946. 
 If a man of such convictions felt it necessary to follow this course, how much more would have his religiously  devoted colleagues. 
 In fact, his cabinet colleagues, already unsure about public support for the bill and alienated from Dr Browne by his provocative politics, were not prepared to go against the hierarchy's condemnation and refused to support the proposal. 
 They moved that a new scheme should be prepared, in conformity with catholic social teaching. 
 Dr Browne was forced to resign. 
 Dr Browne has been something of a maverick in Irish politics even up to this present time. 
 He took the unprecedented step of going public on the issue, an action of which Whyte does not sufficiently stress the importance. 
 He handed on the correspondence between himself and the Bishops to the Irish Times , the recognized liberal and &bquo;protestant&equo; newspaper of the republic. 
 It was a contentious gesture. 
 Many were shocked and surprised at the interference of the bishops in the parliamentary process. 
 Others resented Dr Browne's tactics, for the church was clearly not to be brought into such public disrepute. 
 Again, it was clear that the ministers and their parliamentary colleagues, many of whom in any case disliked the scheme, would not pass into legislation any bill which had been declared contrary to church teaching by the bishops. 
 At this level, the power of the Roman catholic church bore directly on the institutions of government. 
 D&aacute;il members would act on a decision of the hierarchy once that hierarchy had said the teaching of the church was at issue, providing of course that the area in question was a grey one, a new territory not previously covered by the generally accepted sacred-profane spheres. 
 In such an unclear area, it was not to be left to D&aacute;il members to decide, irrespective of whether it still remained an appropriate public measure. 
 Even if D&aacute;il members had thought otherwise, it must by now be clear that the ethos of the Irish Republic was still one in which it was impolitic to be in conflict with the church. 
 Reasons for the Political Religious Synthesis: Second Reflections 
 When the next government under de Valera introduced a very limited scheme of public health assistance in 1952, the hierarchy still opposed its introduction, and by direct methods as well. 
 Only de Valera's personal intervention convinced them of their lack of perception and judgement. 
 It was the 1960s before the bishops began to distance themselves from direct relationships with the government of the day. 
 It could be argued that such a strategy was in any case unnecessary. 
 However, it was not simply a strategy, but  embodied a particular ideology: the belief that the bishops were the church above all, and that they, not the laity, were the ones to communicate with the state. 
 The desire to make arrangements covertly could well have been affected by a double pressure. 
 On the one hand, the laity would not understand the complexity of the issues because of their poor understanding of Christian doctrine and the intricacies of morality; on the other, the area of the sacred in the political arena was clearly defined, and clear guidance from the clerical church was both necessary and expected by good Christian politicians. 
 What the bishops and the politicians had come up against in the Mother and Child controversy was that this paternalistic conceptualization was intrinsically at odds with the common understanding of democracy. 
 This appears to be the first contradiction which the bishops later sought to resolve by withdrawing from the direct contact method. 
 It indicates that a real change did eventually take place after all, in so far as freedom of information and the inappropriateness of direct consultation without public mediation eventually became accepted as something which, at worst, had to be risked and something which, at best, formed an essential task of the construction of a Christian conscience in a Christian society. 
 This, however, was the only contradiction which appears to have been solved by the 1960s. 
 The popular disquiet had deeper roots. 
 One was the detestation by the liberally oriented of religious paternalism, a mild form of anti-clericalism. 
 The other was the sense of injustice experienced by the subordinate classes at seeing the scheme dropped. 
 Many of these had just as much sense of loyalty and devotion to the church as the middle classes. 
 Large sections of the population, the subordinate classes specifically, were desperately in need of improved health care. 
 Many of them appear to have been angered and disappointed at the church's suppression of the proposed scheme. 
 The fact that it was not long after that similar if lesser welfare legislation was introduced is indicative of the public demand and that clerical socio-moral theory did not tally with the people's experience of reality. 
 The case reveals the extent to which the church as an institution was coupled with the nation. 
 Part of the state's legitimate authority rested on this acknowledgement and it was built into its hegemonic structure and consensus. 
 The case highlights the extent to which it was possible for the religious intellectuals to misjudge exactly  where the consensus lay, as well as the extent to which an evolving historical situation which created areas for new decision-making provided the field for a new power contest. 
 It was then more than a misjudgement: it revealed the extent to which the religious intellectuals' theory of church and state was outdated and incoherent. 
 What might have been the nature of the inner religious conflict? 
 One could try to approach it with the notion of spheres of competence. 
 The actual sphere of competence the church had sought to monopolize had been that of sexual morals, temperance, the semi-private sphere of the family, and education. 
 It was when the semi-public nature of family matters became the subject of attention that the sources of the legitimacy of the state &mdash; the Irish nation, the church, democracy &mdash; were brought into conflict. 
 To be more precise, the conflict was between the felt need of interventionism by the majority of the population and its politicians and the particular social theology of the churchmen. 
 The churchmen had failed to provide another theology suited to the case. 
 They failed to see that the principle of subsidiarity as interpreted was inadequate to a modern society. 
 The process of industrialization and the accelerated growth of the division of labour had already wrested from the family, including its rural variant, its monopolistic role in the processes of production. 
 The family had changed, and its various functions of education, food production, and the manufacture of clothing were already in part relinquished to a variety of institutions whose smooth functioning rested on the intervention and guidance of the nation state. 
 The change in the socio-moral context was hardly recognized, and the corresponding change in religious social ethics had remained unformulated. 
 In the case of the Mother and Child scheme, it was rather through withdrawal from the scene that first the politicians and later the churchmen avoided further trouble. 
 As will be elaborated now in further contexts, it appears that the underlying reality to such difficulties was, and remains a complex contradiction which the catholic &mdash; nationalist alliance has still failed to solve. 
 On the one hand there were the beliefs in the nature and extent of the clergy's political religious power and how that power was to be exercised in the state. 
 There was also the general assumption that the fact of a state populated by catholics must perforce imply a heightened degree of institutionalized catholic  value in law. 
 On the other hand, there was the nationalist theory of democracy, which derives power from the people and not from an &eacute;lite group of religious intellectuals. 
 The next section will show the way in which this contradiction continued to be shared by a large number of clergy and laity even into the 1980s. 
 It should be added here that the high clergy hardly recognized that they had actually been exercising a political religious power of a specifically sectarian or monopolistic type. 
 Hence when Irish clergymen stated that church and state were separate, they meant they themselves had no legislative or executive role in the state. 
 But they did and still do remain the authoritative conscience of the nation. 
 In addition, the clergy appear to have considerable difficulty in recognizing the transformation which theoretical positions on Christian belief and morality undergo as they are concretized in historical human relationships, doubtless also because of the strong essentialist bias in their perception of socio-ethical issues. 
 Part of the overall argument of this book is that, as the Roman catholic church is principal validator or legitimator of the Southern state along with the concept of the national entity, what that state goes on to do in the field of social ethics cannot be separated out from the responsibilities of the church. 
 This structural link between politics and religion is underlined by the legitimacy the church gives to the state as a whole, by recognizing it simply as society. 
 However, it is the further legitimation given to a particular socio-ethical form of political religion in the constitution and to the implied authority of religious intellectuals in deciding in concreto  what must be taken by the state as in the interests of the common good which gives to conflict in Ireland between the two alliances its political religious dimension in the sphere of law. 
 It is almost as if the catholic Irish people become a people of God in Old Testament terms, in a way similar to the Northern Calvinists, a people which have overriding power to set up their domain. 
 The continuing permeation of civil society by this particular variant of the Roman catholic ethos was most natural. 
 As already stated, the clergy had sustained the catholic &mdash; nationalist populace over centuries of oppression. 
 Furthermore, the ranks of that clergy were drawn from the common people themselves. 
 But a key element remained the considerable filial loyalty the catholic nationalists showed towards their clergy, bishops, and Popes. 
 The  authority of the clergy had been second to none during the years of persecution and this appears to have strengthened as a direct result of Roman centralization from the 1850s onwards. 
 This respect for authority has appeared throughout the examples given, but it has also been shown to be a respect within certain limits. 
 RELIGION AND LAW IN THE SOUTHERN STATE, 1973&ndash;86 
 Minor Indications of Political Religious Changes 
 There is a strong case for arguing that the dominance of Roman catholic high clergy in the determination of key value ingredients in catholic &mdash; nationalist consensus in the South is in a state of change, and that certain aspects in particular are being challenged. 
 From the 1950s onwards there was considerable improvement to the standard of living. 
 As Ireland opened up to foreign investment under de Valera's successor, Sean Lemass, another element in the value structure came to prominence, namely the obligation to achieve and retain full employment within the context of a modernized economy and a satisfactory level of housing, welfare, and medical care for all. 
 The economic growth of the 1960s and early 1970s came to grief because of the western economic slump of the last decade and the massive increase in the Southern population. 
 This grew from three to three and a half million by 1981 and was created by a combination of net immigration, earlier and more frequent marriage, and the maintenance of relatively high levels of childbirth. 
 This is a major reason, in addition to state interventionism, why economic matters precede the issue of Northern Ireland both theoretically and practically in contemporary Irish politics. 
 A further change has been the growth of liberal theology within the Irish Roman catholic intelligentsia. 
 The influence of the second Vatican Council (1962&ndash;5) has enabled theological discourse to become dominated by non-hierarchical models of the church and a generally eirenic theology in which all the churches in Ireland share. 
 Roman catholic theologians teach at Trinity College, former bastion of protestant Ireland, and Roman catholic writers, including clergy, question the agreed wisdom of the Irish catholic hierarchy. 
 But, as will be seen, such liberal theologians have yet to achieve power within the political religious establishment. 
 Criticism of the Irish constitution itself from both clergy and laity  produced one first change in the constitution. 
 The famous paragraph of Article 42 intending to give pride of place to the Roman catholic church in the state was removed by referendum in 1972, along with the accompanying paragraph recognizing other existing religious groups. 
 The Roman catholic hierarchy declared that they had no opposition to this particular change, but one wonders how the vote would have gone if they had. 
 Also, in 1974, an adoption Act made it possible for couples of mixed denominational or religious origin to adopt. 
 But Roman catholic adoption agencies, the source for the majority of children awaiting adoption, are not obliged to assign baptized Roman catholic children to such couples, and whether they do or not is not a matter of public knowledge. 
 The episode shows, as Whyte says, &bquo;not a clash between Church and State but a shifting consensus involving them both, (1980:399). 
 A further significant change in political religious attitudes occurred with the liberalization of legislation prohibiting contraceptives to be bought or sold, or even imported into the state. 
 A campaign begun in 1971 to repeal the ban dating from 1935 culminated in the famous appeal of Mrs McGee to the Supreme Court to declare she had a right to use contraceptives. 
 The supreme court found in her favour in 1973 and declared the relevant section of the 1935 Criminal Law Amendment Act to be unconstitutional. 
 However, a law dealing with the national situation as a whole was only introduced in 1979. 
 The Act, while permitting the sale of contraceptives, restricted sellers to chemists and only on the production of a medical prescription. 
 This did not prevent the Family Planning Association in its Dublin and Cork clinics from providing contraceptives freely and students at University College, Dublin from installing a condom-dispensing machine in their Union building. 
 In fact, the need to liberalize the law was mainly because it was inoperable: thousands of people were already using contraceptives. 
 A committee of the Irish Medical Association put the numbers of women using the contraceptive pill in 1978 as 48,000; and the Family planning Association saw 30,000 people in 1976 and more than 53,000in 1978 (Whyte 1980: 403&ndash;4). 
 It is quite possible that a number of other political changes would have got under way more recently were it not for the direct intervention of Pope John Paul II and the Vatican. 
 In 1985, Rome declined to follow the convention of choosing the new archbishop  of Dublin from the names submitted by the clergy and notables of the diocese, and imposed a known conservative and former president of Maynooth College, Dr Kevin MacNamara. 
 No clearer way of indicating the path to be trod could have been made. 
 It is possible that such authoritarian actions will occur again as soon as another crucial appointment to the hierarchy comes up. 
 Of course, Irish clergy and laity are sometimes at the forefront of political religious change in other countries, and a lively Irish intellectuals&equo; religion will continue: but whether or not it will eventually affect the structure of power is another matter. 
 Major Indications of Conflict: The Abortion Debate 
 The shifting consensus of church and state was not the major feature of the period. 
 The two changes which took place in law and constitution before 1980 were at least permitted by the clerical church in that it agreed with the abolition of the special position of the Roman catholic church, and did not oppose the limited introduction of contraceptives. 
 They were both cases expressing the consensus of politician and priest. 
 The major debates after that time have tended to show a split between church leadership and a large section of its laity on the one hand, and a significant proportion of Roman catholic laity, other churches, and secular groups on the other. 
 In this confrontation, the traditional religious forces, which support the old monopoly religious structure, have so far prevailed. 
 The first major demonstration of this was in 1983, in the controversy over the abortion amendment. 
 Two years previously, a campaign to write into the Irish constitution the existing legislation criminalizing abortion had got under way under the name of the Pro-Life Amendment Campaign. 
 It is difficult to describe this body accurately. 
 The bulk of its organizers were members of traditional organizations of the old sodality type: members from the Legion of Mary, the Knights of Columbanus, and one or two other organizations of more recent origin devoted to the strengthening of catholic morality. 
 Having acquired a sufficient number of signatures, the Campaign submitted their referendum proposal, which the government of the day, the Fine Gael &mdash; Labour coalition under Garret FitzGerald which had come into power that year, decided  to submit to the populace. 
 The Roman catholic bishops supported the wording of the referendum and, as the referendum approached, said it was legitimate to oppose the amendment even if one was against abortion, which was in any case still immoral and was &bquo;the direct taking of an innocent life&equo; (Irish Bishops' Conference statement, quoted O'Carroll 1983). 
 However, on the eve of the referendum, the majority of priests preached against abortion. 
 The nexus appears to have been made for a sufficient number of the laity, as those who eventually voted in the referendum voted in favour of inscribing an appropriate anti-abortion clause in the constitution. 
 Article 40, paragraph 3, section 3, now reads: 
 The State acknowledges the right to life of the unborn and, with due regard to the equal right of life of the mother, guarantees in its laws to respect, and, as far as practicable, by its laws, defend and vindicate that right. 
 (Ninth Amendment of the Constitution Act, 1984) 
 Several points of note should be made. 
 Firstly, only slightly more than half the electorate voted, when other turn-outs for referendums have been around two-thirds; and despite considerable pressure from the clergy, only one-third of the total electorate actually voted for the measure. 
 There is the suggestion, therefore, that the traditional popular religion is in decline, albeit still responsive enough to hierarchical religious leadership to produce the necessary political religious results. 
 Secondly, anti-abortionism is the view of the great majority of the population in both parts of Ireland, as well as the various churches. 
 The appropriate committee of the presbyterian church in Ireland opposed the extension of the British Abortion Act of 1967 to Northern Ireland (Presbyterian Church in Ireland 1930&ndash;86, Annual Report  (1982), pp. 194&ndash;6). 
 In consequence, it was resolved &bquo;That the General Assembly is firmly opposed to indiscriminate abortion, but does not believe it is wise to insert a clause banning abortion into the Constitution of the Republic&hellip;&equo; 
 (Presbyterian Church in Ireland 1930&ndash;86, Annual Reports  (1983), p. 9). 
 Its position on abortion itself was hardly ambiguous: the minutes of the Assembly meeting for 1982 point out &bquo;&lsqb;the Assembly's&rsqb; opposition to abortion on demand for purely social reasons, or as a means of birth control&hellip; &lsqb;and&rsqb; that in exceptional circumstances, where medical abortion might be necessary, the most stringent safeguards should be provided to  prevent abuse&equo; (Presbyterian Church in Ireland 1930&ndash;86, General Assembly (1982), p. 61). 
 The Church of Ireland maintains its adherence to the Lambeth Conference decision of 1958 to oppose abortion on anything but the most exceptional grounds (Church of Ireland Submission to the New Ireland Forum (1984), p. 2). 
 The Methodist Church in Ireland was in session during an unsuccessful attempt by the government to quash the running of the referendum. 
 It welcomed 
 a belated attempt to meet minority principles in a plural democracy by avoiding any definition and by restoring ultimate power of decision to the Oireachtas &lsqb;Parliament&rsqb;. 
 The Conference regrets the failure of the attempt. 
 It regrets that the previous Government &lsqb;of Fianna F&aacute;il, under Charles Haughey&rsqb; made no concessions to protestant appeals for a more open position&hellip; 
 The Conference would wish all who may take part in the referendum to recognize that Protestant Churches are pro-Life but anti-amendment and to query whether they wish a clause in the constitution unacceptable to Protestant churches. 
 (Methodist Church in Ireland 1983: 48) 
 The position taken by the protestant churches, and the newspaper articles and television debates which preceded the referendum appear to have affected public opinion. 
 Caught between the preaching of the Roman catholic clergy and appeals from protestants and liberal Roman catholics &mdash; including Dr FitzGerald &mdash; not to constitutionalize the issue, it would appear that many voters simply stayed away rather than vote against the proposal. 
 As mentioned, it was already forbidden by law to procure an abortion. 
 Its constitutionalization is a direct result, not of this already widespread opinion, but of Roman catholic pressure of the monopoly type. 
 The writing into the constitution of the prohibition did not mark the end of the campaign for some groups. 
 Legal action was taken in 1986 by the Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child (SPUC) to prevent the two family planning clinics in the Republic from counselling abortion. 
 The high court decision, announced at the end of December in that year, found on behalf of SPUC and declared such counselling by the Dublin Well Woman Centre and the Open Line counselling service to be illegal and ordered them to cease their public information service on the issue by 12 January 1987. 
 As the ruling only applies to the institutions named, SPUC intends to get further banning orders made against other groups  and named individuals as and when it becomes &bquo;necessary&equo; ( Irish Times , 30 Dec. 1986). 
 It should be noted that contraceptives which can result in an abortion, often termed &bquo;abortifacients&equo; and including devices such as the coil and spermicidal lubricants and jellies, remain illegal in Ireland. 
 The Roman Catholic Hierarchy and the New Ireland Forum 
 The next significant event of constitutional relevance was the important initiative taken by the nationalist parties in Ireland in 1983&ndash;4, the New Ireland Forum. 
 This was an initiative sponsored by the SDLP at first intended to bring together politicians from both catholic &mdash; nationalist and protestant &mdash; loyalist groups to discuss the future of the island as a whole. 
 In reality only the major nationalist parties participated. 
 Loyalist parties refused to join in, and the Provisional Sinn Fein was excluded by the fact that the ground rules for the forum only allowed parties accepting constitutional, nonviolent politics to participate. 
 The forum completed its consultations and reported in the Summer of 1984. 
 There was one vital breakthrough for the nationalist consciousness, though there still remains some doubt as to how deep this was for the Fianna F&aacute;il party: all the parties committed themselves to the recognition of the protestant &mdash; loyalist group as having legitimate aspirations and affirmed the need for the recognition of &bquo;two sets of legitimate rights&equo; coexisting in the island as a whole: &bquo;Constitutional nationalists are determined to secure justice for all traditions&hellip; 
 The new Ireland must be a society within which, subject only to public order, all cultural, political and religious beliefs can be freely expressed and practised.&equo; 
 This was made explicit in terms of the sense of British identity which protestant loyalists experience: &bquo;This implies in particular, in respect of Northern protestants, that the civil and religious liberties that they uphold and enjoy will be fully protected and their sense of Britishness accommodated&equo; (New Ireland Forum 1983&ndash;4: i. 22&ndash;3). 
 For the very first time, the leadership of all the major constitutional nationalist parties in Ireland, representing 90 per cent of the nationalist population, had abandoned the concept of the tyranny of the majority will. 
 The people of Ireland were not identified as the catholic &mdash; nationalist population. 
 There were still traces of ethnocentrism in the nationalist viewpoint elsewhere in the report: for instance, they still referred to &bquo;the historic integrity  of Ireland&equo; (New Ireland Forum 1983&ndash;4: i. 28), implying an almost naturalistic concept of Irish unity, when as a political unit Ireland only ever existed as a British-administered territory. 
 But whether the statement is rhetoric or reality, particularly for Mr Charles Haughey and the rest of the Fianna F&aacute;il leadership, we will have to wait and see. 
 The Irish Roman catholic church leadership also submitted statements on its political religious position. 
 While preparing an early draft of the present chapter, the writer heard Bishop Cathal Daly of Down and Connor, a leading moderate among the bishops, respected by all except PIRA, repeat the adage that the Irish constitution was secular, implying that there really was little to be done for the moment. 
 This in fact was the main tack in the bishops' attitude to the forum. 
 There appears to have been a general feeling among them that there was no real problem on this score. 
 Concessions would only be required once a united Ireland was being negotiated (New Ireland Forum 1983&ndash;4: xii. 
 11). 
 Via the channels of public announcements at times of political decision-making, the bishops seek to enforce official Roman catholic morality on all members of the state. 
 Their intention to continue with this strategy remains. 
 Both in the Forum Report (New Ireland Forum 1983&ndash;4: xii) and in their written submission (Irish Episcopal Conference 1984), they not only repeated their oft-stated attitude to catholic schools, defending them from any contribution to sectarianism in Ireland, but opposed the introduction of divorce and any weakening of legislation which they felt protected the family. 
 They explicitly quoted sections of Article 41 or the 1937 constitution so as to support the view of including its provisions in any new all-Ireland constitution. 
 They further expressed reservations about the concept of pluralism and maintained an objectivist stance on the relationship between the Roman catholic understanding of the natural law, as the Irish bishops saw it, and the duties of the modern state: 
 It must&hellip; be kept in mind that &bquo;the moral law&equo;, &bquo;the common good of all&equo; and &bquo;the objective moral order&equo; are not derived simply from the teaching of the Catholic Church. 
 They are largely accessible to human reason&hellip; 
 They oblige all, including non-Catholics, because they proceed from right reason, and not because they are taught by the Catholic Church. 
 They are also an invitation to those who exercise political power to reflect on the nature of man and of human society and in the enactment of laws to  eschew the often brilliant attractions of pragmatism, of relativism or of short-term solutions in favour of lasting concern for the common good of all. 
 (Irish Episcopal Conference 1984: 18) 
 They also expressed reservations over the concept of minority rights: &bquo;Britain, for example, does not allow polygamy even though certain of its citizens accept it from their religious convictions&equo; (Irish Episcopal Conference 1984: 18). 
 However, they did state that, in a united Ireland, Northern protestants would not lose any &bquo;civil and religious rights&equo; (New Ireland Forum 1983&ndash;4: xii. 
 2). 
 This was generally understood by the media to mean that the hierarchy would not oppose the introduction of divorce in a future united Ireland, indeed that they might be prepared to budge on the issue even now. 
 But the bishops' statement does not say so. 
 When forced into a debate on the matter by Seamus Mallon of the SDLP and Senator Mary Robinson, the four church representatives, Bishop Cathal Daly, Bishop O'Mahoney, Bishop Cassidy, and Mrs McAleese, retained the right of the church to enter into public debate on the evils of divorce. 
 Bishop Daly then said: 
 there must be, there has to be a separation between Church and State and we totally endorse and emphatically reiterate that, but the separation between Church and State does not mean a separation between conscience and the electorate's responsibility in voting. 
 We cannot expect voters to leave their conscience behind them when they go to the polling booth. 
 Inevitably we would expect that those who freely accept the teaching of our Church will vote according to their consciences. 
 This is all we ask of them. 
 But we must have the right to carry out our duty to impart the moral convictions, the moral teaching of our Church to our own members. 
 I should have thought that is part of the reality with which legislators are faced, part of the situation within which they operate. 
 (Cathal Daly, New Ireland Forum 1983&ndash;4: xii. 
 13) 
 An examination of the documentation shows that there is, in fact, no real change in the bishops' view of the relationship between their perception of the good of the state and public morality, and what was to be de facto  permissible in the state. 
 There is therefore no elaboration in the forum proceedings on hierarchical directives to their faithful on constitutional matters. 
 Events were to confirm the bishops' implied intent to oppose the granting of divorce as a civil right.  
 The Divorce Debate 
 Almost as if to test the political religious alliance of catholic nationalists in the South, the constitutional issue of divorce arose in 1986 as part of Dr Garret FitzGerald's constitutional crusade (see Cooney 1986) to make the Southern state more palatable to Northerners. 
 FitzGerald had been determined as far back as 1964 (1964; 1972) to make constitutional changes to those articles which appeared to alienate Northern protestant opinion. 
 After arriving in office as Taoiseach for a second time in 1983, he proceeded to collect opinions on such issues from various quarters. 
 From the Roman catholic hierarchy, he solicited the response that the church believed in the indissolubility of marriage. 
 Further, &bquo;the Catholic Church does not ask that the law should enshrine any particular provision because it accords with Church teaching&equo;. 
 The statement then went on to oppose the introduction of divorce on the grounds of the protection of &bquo;the common good&equo; by the state. 
 In taking this position, the bishops were also following the lead of Pope John Paul II who, on his visit to Ireland in 1979 had argued: &bquo;Divorce, for whatever reason it is introduced, inevitably becomes easier and easier to obtain and it gradually comes to be accepted as a normal part of life&equo; (1979). 
 From this FitzGerald could be in little doubt as to the likely course the bishops would take once a referendum campaign got under way. 
 Already, in expectation, the four archbishops had produced a pastoral letter in which they condemned the legalizing of divorce on the grounds of the preservation of &bquo;the common good&equo; and because they feared the tendency that people had to accept as right that which was legally permissible (Irish Episcopal Conference 1985). 
 On the basis of privately commissioned opinion polls showing an increasing majority in favour of some measure of divorce legislation, FitzGerald agreed with his cabinet to proceed with a referendum on whether to change the constitution so as to allow divorce for marriages irretrievably broken down, though only after a period of five years' actual breakdown and legal  separation. 
 The government bill moving the referendum was published in the D&aacute;il on 23 April 1986. 
 Opposing pressure groups were already in existence and preparing for the campaign: in favour, the Divorce Action Group; and against, such groups as Family Solidarity, Women in the Home, and the Knights of Columbanus. 
 These last were soon replaced, on 9 May, by a more specific and highly organized pressure group headed by many who had previously mounted the Pro-Life Anti-abortion Campaign. 
 Of particular importance to the anti-divorce campaign was a lawyer, William Binchy, who had already produced a book in 1984 on the subject. 
 Large publicity campaigns began and the Irish Times  also lent its weight to the pro-divorce argument, campaigning in its columns until the eve of the referendum in late June. 
 Though the coalition government were allowing their TDs &mdash; the Irish equivalent for MPs &mdash; a free vote on the issue, its parties, Fine Gael and Labour, officially sponsored the campaign for the constitutional change. 
 Fianna F&aacute;il appeared to be equally divided on the issue. 
 The new progressive democrats came out in favour of the referendum proposal on 14 May. 
 Of the smaller parties, the Workers' Party was the most decisive in favouring the change. 
 Other public bodies who actively campaigned on behalf of the constitutional amendment were the Irish Congress of Trade Unions and the Irish Council for Civil Liberties. 
 The presbyterian and methodist churches in Ireland, along with the Church of Ireland, welcomed the proposal. 
 They too had been consulted by FitzGerald and had responded favourably. 
 The four Roman catholic archbishops replied on 28 April that they opposed divorce in general, and particularly the type of what they considered to be unrestricted divorce proposed in the constitutional amendment ( Irish Times , 28 Apr. 1986). 
 Though in the statement it was mentioned that statistics from other countries were too unreliable to say that pro-divorce legislation increased the instability of marriages and led to an ever-increasing number of breakdowns, Archbishop McNamara was already preaching by 6 May that divorce &bquo;makes stable and permanent marriages more difficult for everyone&equo; ( Irish Times , 7 May 1986). 
 This was the line already adopted by Binchy (1984) who interpreted world-wide statistics in this direction. 
 Divorce was seen to be harder on the women than the men, who could get out of their family  responsibilities so much more easily with divorce than without it. 
 In opposing the arguments marshalled by the anti-divorce groups, the pro-divorce group argued that, despite the existence of divorce legislation in Northern Ireland, there was still a low divorce rate. 
 The period of separation in undefended cases was two years, and five years had to run if one of the parties opposed the divorce. 
 That men in particular do not benefit from the procedures was suggested by the fact that twice as many women as men filed for divorce. 
 It was argued that the pattern in other countries was that laws permitting divorce followed social trends in the numbers of marriage breakdowns rather than vice versa and that the fears of societal breakdown promoted by opponents in Ireland were unfounded in fact. 
 Despite the position of the church leadership, there were dissenting clerical voices. 
 A priest from County Galway, in a letter to the Irish Times , informed that Dr Enda McDonagh, a noted Roman catholic moral theologian, had told priests of the Tuam archdiocese in January that it was possible to make a distinction between the church's teaching on the ideal of marriage and divorce as a civil right. 
 The priest himself, Fr. 
 Stand&uacute;n, intended to vote in favour at the referendum along with &bquo;many clergymen&equo; ( Irish Times , 10 May 1986). 
 Fr. 
 Pat O'Brien addressed the Divorce Action Group in Galway on 27 May, supporting their campaign on the grounds of religious freedom for minorities ( Irish Times , 29 May 1986). 
 Professor Sean Freyne of Trinity College, a former Roman catholic priest, published an article in the Irish Times  favouring the constitutional amendment, and suggesting that the Irish bishops' attitude to marriage, despite some signs to the contrary, was eminently legal and contractual in orientation ( Irish Times , 5 June 1986). 
 An opinion poll conducted on 28&ndash;9 April and sponsored by the Irish Times  showed 57 per cent in favour of the divorce amendment with only 7 per cent undecided. 
 But, one week later, this had fallen to 49 per cent in favour (see Irish Times , 5 May 1986 and Sunday Press , 11 May 1986).  
 Already by 14 May, the Roman catholic hierarchy had responded to the pressure with the production and projected distribution of one million copies of a pastoral letter against divorce (Irish Episcopal Conference 1986). 
 In it they asserted quite clearly that permitting divorce would certainly affect the stability of all Irish marriages because it rendered every Irish marriage dissoluble: &bquo;It is as though the legal availability of divorce builds up a social pressure which, for large numbers of people, becomes stronger than moral or religious resistance&equo; (abridged version, Irish Times , 14 May 1986). 
 In effect, they were tending to the view that the very change in law brings about a change in the nature of society and human relationships within it. 
 The bishops also argued that any so-called restricted form of divorce was impossible to maintain in practice and that divorce might solve the partners' problems but only created them for the children. 
 The pro-divorce camp were quick to spot the traditional Irish view that written laws and authoritative words have a radically structuring effect on reality. 
 As Alan Dukes TD argued in the D&aacute;il in response to the pastoral letter: 
 It is wrong to contend that divorce legislation &bquo;defines&equo; all marriages as being dissoluble. 
 It does no such thing; rather it defines the circumstances and conditions in which a marriage has ceased to be a source of happiness and strength to those involved and may be brought to an end&hellip; 
 There is no compulsive power in this amendment, nor will supporting legislation contain any obligation on those who do not wish to do so to use the mechanism it will set up. 
 (D&aacute;il debate, 14 May 1986, as reported by Dick Walsh, Irish Times , 15 May 1986) 
 When it fell to Dukes to introduce the second stage of the Bill empowering the referendum, he was forced to address himself specifically to the bishops' arguments in their letter (text, Irish Times , 15 May 1986). 
 Similar remarks were made by Senator Mary Robinson, who also challenged the hierarchy's intent in their statement to the New Ireland Forum that the civil rights of Northerners would not be infringed by any pressure from the Roman catholic church in an eventual united Ireland. 
 TDs who opposed the amendment, such as Oliver J. Flanagan on 13 May and Dr Michael Woods on 14 May, began to call on &bquo;the silent majority, to make their opposition to divorce known. 
 The speech of Dr Woods of Fianna F&aacute;il was a particularly important intervention. 
 It indicated that Charles Haughey in particular, and Fianna F&aacute;il in  general were moving behind the anti-divorce lobby. 
 One might be forgiven for thinking that the bishops&equo; letter had something to do with it and that Haughey was intent on constructing an alliance between those heeding the teaching of the hierarchy and the party faithful. 
 In early May, two-thirds of Fianna F&aacute;il TDs from the West had already indicated they would campaign in their constituencies against the amendment ( Irish Times , 2 May 1986). 
 The Woods' speech also introduced an important new argument which may have had some considerable effect on Irish voters. 
 It suggested that second marriages would substantially infringe the rights of inheritance of the members of the first family. 
 In a society of extremely strong rural, traditional values on rights of inheritance, the suggestions that &bquo;constitutional Frankensteins&equo; would devour &bquo;constitutional orphans&equo; ( D&aacute;il Debates , 14 May 1986) were clearly calculated to raise a moral panic, having produced the appropriate folk-devils. 
 In the ensuing debate, Alan Shatter, TD of Fine Gael, author of a book on family law, pointed out the better provision being made under the projected divorce law for a first wife than existed at present, and that children of the first marriage would maintain their present rights, though they would have to share with children of the second marriage. 
 There was also much legal debate over the intention not to allow divorce unless adequate and proper provision was made for the dependants. 
 Many critics, including William Binchy, saw this as likely to be an ineffectual provision and subject to the whims of judges. 
 Proponents of the changes did, however, find the prognostications of their adversaries far too pessimistic and polemical. 
 It is interesting to note that the debate centred on the concrete social consequences of divorce legislation rather than on its intrinsic morality. 
 In the D&aacute;il debate of 20 May, Padraig Faulkner, TD of Fianna F&aacute;il argued that the introduction of divorce would indeed end up as divorce on demand anyway, and Charles Haughey indicated his &bquo;personal view&equo; that divorce was bad for &bquo;individual stability&equo; ( Irish Times , 21 May 1986). 
 The next stage in clerical campaign strategy was introduced by  Archbishop MacNamara of Dublin who instructed the clergy of his diocese to preach on the indissolubility of marriage on the six Sundays from 18 May until the eve of the referendum. 
 He also instructed his parish priests in a letter, leaked to the Irish Times , to have the bishops pastoral Marriage, the Family and Divorce  distributed to every home in the archdiocese along with special bidding prayers invoking divine protection for marriages and the guidance of Holy Spirit &bquo;at this critical time of decision for families and our country&equo; ( Irish Times , 17 May 1986). 
 An anti-divorce video was released by the Catholic Communications Institute of Ireland and placed on sale in the Veritas Bookshop in Dublin. 
 By the end of the month, it was reported to be &bquo;selling well&equo; ( Irish Times , 30 May 1985). 
 In an interview with the popular intellectual magazine Magill  in June, Archbishop MacNamara found he could not accept that the state had the power to determine the meaning and nature of marriage and compared the effects of divorce to the recent Chernobyl nuclear disaster. 
 In pastoral sermons, the archbishop continued to oppose civil divorce, claiming that the weak would suffer as a consequence, along with the well-being of society. 
 He also continued to affirm that the introduction of divorce would make it more difficult for people to lead &bquo;good moral lives&equo;. 
 Divorce has this effect because it suggests that remarriage in the lifetime of one's first partner is socially and even morally acceptable' ( Irish Times , 6 June 1986; also 31 May 1986; 14 June 1986). 
 This same interpretation appeared in the Irish bishops' next statement in mid-June. 
 Voters had to decide in conscience &bquo;whether other factors outweigh the damage which divorce would certainly cause to individuals, to families, to children and to the whole of society&equo; ( Irish Times , 13 June 1986). 
 The bishops claimed, however, they were making it clear that people could in conscience vote for the introduction of divorce without incurring moral blame provided they made the decision in a reflective and conscientious way. 
 Some incidents at local level are worth recording. 
 The parish priest of Brackenstown, Swords, County Dublin, distributed a newsletter at all masses on Ascension Thursday, 22 May &mdash; though before he had read Archbishop MacNamara's guidelines on how to conduct the campaign &mdash; claiming that no-fault divorce was first introduced by Nazi Germany and that it had since wreaked &bquo;more havoc on the Allied countries than any German army or air force  ever did&equo; ( Irish Times , 28 June 1986). 
 On Sunday 17 June in Cork a priest was reported to have preached and behaved as follows: 
 At the sermon, Father McKenna introduced one of his altar boys, Colm by name, and got him to tell the story about how he and his altar boy teammates had recently beaten another altar boys' team by eight goals to five. 
 When he asked Colm over the microphone how many goals he had scored the boy proudly replied &bquo;Four&equo;&hellip; 
 Finally, Father McKenna said he had one last question to ask. 
 The question was would Colm like his mother and father to get divorced. 
 Colm said &bquo;No&equo;. 
 ( Irish Times , 17 May 1986) 
 Protestant churches were not unaffected by the spirit in which the campaign often appeared to be conducted. 
 Some members of the anti-abortion lobby had apparently been indicating the &bquo;weak&equo; moral stance of protestants on the issue. 
 The Church of Ireland appears to have had this in mind when it invited the well-known English Roman catholic marriage consultant, Dr Jack Dominian, to provide a report on divorce for the Church of Ireland General Synod. 
 As Bishop Empey argued to the synod: &bquo;Somehow we have to nail the lie that permissiveness flows from the Church of Ireland and that morality is the sole possession of but one Church in this land&equo; ( Irish Times , 22 May 1986). 
 In submitting his report, Dominian stated: 
 I have to say that if this room was filled by the Roman Catholic bishops of Ireland and they were pushing me very hard about divorce, I would have to say very clearly that their fear that civil divorce will make marital breakdown worse, or enhance or facilitate it &mdash; my answer would be: No, it will make very little difference. 
 But in justice I think a society needs civil divorce and that the real concern of the Church and the community should be to work at understanding prevention. 
 ( Irish Times , 22 May 1986) 
 Dominian's remarks were probably important to the Irish Roman catholic bishops. 
 They had in fact used material gathered by him, and some of his reflections of the sanctity of marriage, in their pastoral letter on marriage in the previous year. 
 At its annual meeting in Belfast, the Presbyterian General Assembly received a report promoting the amendment as implementing a rightful civil liberty ( Irish Times , 6 June 1986). 
 Further criticism came from Roman catholics in Britain. 
 An editorial in the Catholic Herald and Standard  on 25 May &mdash; it is distributed in Ireland as The Standard  &mdash; criticized the Irish bishops' apparently  low esteem of their laity's ability to remain constant in their marriages. 
 Also a call from the Alliance Party in the North was made by John Cushnahan, party leader. 
 He found it ironic that anyone who supported the Anglo-Irish Agreement could oppose a modest measure to introduce divorce ( Irish Times , 28 June 1986). 
 Perhaps an important counter to the archbishop of Dublin's interventions was the well-known lay liberal catholic and Head of Information at RTE, Louis McRedmond. 
 He used the columns of the Irish Times  to inform Roman catholic consciences of permitted interpretations of state divorce on the grounds of religious liberty, interpretations which were diametrically opposed to that of the Irish bishops. 
 By mid-June, the projection of the opinion polls was already suggesting that the majority favouring a measure of divorce legislation was declining so rapidly that by the time of the poll, the noes would have it. 
 By the week of the referendum, an Irish Times  opinion poll had a clear and substantial majority against the amendment, 45 per cent for and 55 per cent against ( Irish Times , 25 June 1986). 
 The referendum proposal was as follows. 
 The present constitution in Article 41.3.2 stated: 
 No law shall be enacted providing for the grant of a dissolution of marriage. 
 The proposed change involved the deletion of this and its substitution by the following: 
 Where, and only where, such court established under this Constitution as may be prescribed by law is satisfied that &mdash; 
 i. 
 a marriage has failed, 
 ii. 
 the failure has continued for a period of, or periods amounting to, at least five years, 
 iii. 
 there is no reasonable possibility of reconciliation between the parties to the marriage, and 
 iv. 
 any other condition prescribed by law has been complied with, 
 the court may in accordance with law grant a dissolution of the marriage provided that the court is satisfied that adequate and proper provision having regard to the circumstances will be made for any dependant spouse and for any child of or any child who is dependent on either spouse. 
 The referendum was finally held on 26 June 1986. 
 The appearance of the results of the Irish Times  opinion poll on the same day  predicting the failure of the proposal may well have affected the turn-out. 
 In any event, the constitutional proposal to replace the existing prohibition on divorce by a provision to allow it was rejected. 
 &bquo;Turnout for the poll was 62.5%. 
 Of those voting, 63.3% voted against the proposal&equo; ( Ireland Today , No. 1030, p. 15). 
 The biggest percentages favouring the proposal occurred in the urban centres, particularly Dublin and Dublin County, where there was a slight margin in favour. 
 But the country areas and particularly the West were overwhelmingly against the proposal. 
 It would seem that catholic &mdash; nationalist morality is to remain a feature of the Southern state and of any future all-Ireland state, if the clerical church's wishes continue to prevail. 
 If an effective will to de-alienate Northern protestants in their attitudes to the republic existed, and if there had been a real change in the Irish catholic hierarchy's position on such matters, then they would indeed have taken positive steps to support FitzGerald's attempt to introduce such constitutional changes. 
 In other words, on the divorce question the Roman catholic clerical leadership were still using their joint authority, which is legitimate in the eyes of the majority in the Southern state, to press into civil legislation their views of public morality, and to use the informed conscience of the faithful as the primary vehicle. 
 They were failing to recognize or were positively discounting the rights of those dissenting from their particular views of public order, and subjecting that dissent to the full coercion of the state. 
 In other words, when the New Ireland Forum was being assured by Bishop Daly of the intention of the Roman catholic church in Ireland to support full civil and religious rights for Northern Ireland protestants, the bishops were effectively reserving to themselves, as a body of luminaries with a direct access to the inner structures of social reality, the right to declare what actually constituted a civil and religious liberty or right and they were doing so on the grounds of what they considered good for society. 
 There can be no question that the bishops are not in any way aware of this arrogation, as it is mediated in consciousness by their belief in, and conceptualization of, a static natural law which is accessible, even if with difficulty, to the conscience of everyman; which same natural law no one should be allowed to violate, even if in error, when that law, if broken, is seen to threaten the very moral fabric of society. 
 The bishops, conceiving of themselves as a body supported by the Holy Spirit in their proclamation of morality and  seeing themselves as following the equally and divinely guided line laid down by Pope John-Paul II, were assuming that the opposition to state legislation permitting divorce was of a similar standing and status to the Christian belief that Christian marriage was forever. 
 Therefore, informing consciences on the evil social consequences of divorce was seen by them to be of a similar standing to informing the consciences of catholic lay people on the sanctity and indissolubility of Christian marriage. 
 It is in this way that the Roman catholic bishops of Ireland, as intellectuals organizing the beliefs of catholic nationalists, continue to be aligned to the forces of conservatism within the alliance, forces which in practice do not recognize important protestant civil rights in Ireland. 
 The alliance is cemented by that traditional political religion, forged in the previous century, which sees the natural law as most accessible to true believers, that it is obligatory to enforce its practice by law, and that those holding other views only have rights to put their views into practice when they are not seen by the bishops to do harm to the social fabric. 
 This monopoly position is therefore totally beyond criticism. 
 One might speculate that an impending solution to the Northern Ireland problem would split off from the clerical leadership those groups for whom the present position is only accepted on pragmatic grounds. 
 Hence the traditional alliance between catholicism and nationalism might be split at the popular basis with the ensuing growth of a degree of anti-clericalism. 
 However, as the very existence of the catholic &mdash; nationalist alliance impedes progress towards such a solution, one should perhaps view such a possibility as unreal. 
 The Roman catholic leadership in Ireland has first to change and radically evaluate its monopoly beliefs, thus permitting the dissolution of one of the most antagonistic aspects of catholic &mdash; nationalist hegemony.  
 Schooling as Political Religion 
 Systems and Counter-systems North and south 
 INTRODUCTION 
 A second area where political religion has hegemonic power and structures the popular consciousness throughout Ireland is in the shaping and running of the institutions of education, particularly primary and secondary schools. 
 This chapter outlines the way in which the schooling systems were shaped from the early nineteenth century by a combination of church and state politics, developing in both the North and South as expressions of catholic nationalism and protestant loyalism. 
 They are therefore predominantly sectarian in political religious form, and attempts to modify this sectarian structure are at the moment opposed mainly, though not exclusively, by the Irish Roman catholic clergy. 
 An outline of the church's dominant political theology on the issue is therefore also explored. 
 EDUCATION AND THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE ALLIANCE BETWEEN CLERGY AND POLITICIANS 
 A primary education system was established throughout Ireland as early as 1831 (see Akenson 1970; Lyons 1973; Miller 1973). 
 It was basically envisaged to be of national proportions as well as non-denominational, with religious instruction given in separate classes. 
 There was, however, controversy from the start. 
 The Church of Ireland withdrew its schools from the plan which threatened that church's dominance over the primary sector. 
 The presbyterians also had misgivings, and only came back into the system in 1838 when they were practically guaranteed control of their own schools within it. 
 The Church of Ireland rejoined in 1860, because it lacked funds to continue its own system. 
 Many Roman catholic clerics were unsettled by the plan. 
 The  Christian Brothers, founded in the early part of the century, withdrew from the scheme and unilaterally developed their own system. 
 The concern of Roman catholic clergy about the system was not without grounds. 
 Some feared the use of the schools by proselytizers to indoctrinate the children in protestant principles, especially as the local managers were at first mainly clergy of the established church. 
 There was division among the Roman catholic episcopate as well and as many favoured the system as were against it. 
 The archbishop of Dublin, Daniel Murray, had accepted a position on the National Education Board responsible for the schools. 
 The controversy was so deep that an appeal was made to Rome by the combatants. 
 Archbishop McHale, who opposed the non-denominational system, was hoping for a verdict to support his views. 
 The verdict from Rome, which came in 1841, favoured both and neither. 
 It asked the participants to stop haggling in public and permitted each bishop to take a decision either way for his own diocese (Murphy 1959). 
 It is noteworthy that at this time (when secularised education was patronised by nearly all the governments of Europe including those that were nominally Catholic) this query was dealt with as a matter of discipline by the Congregation of propaganda, and not as a matter of doctrine by the Congregation of the Inquisition. 
 (Gaine 1968: 163) 
 One could perhaps specify further: it was normal for disputes in Ireland to be referred to the Congregation of Propaganda, as Ireland, being part of a protestant state, fell under its jurisdiction. 
 However, it is likely that it was not felt necessary to refer the matter anywhere else as, according to current practice, it was  a matter of discipline. 
 It is quite clear that Rome did not have a policy on catholic schooling at this time, and certainly not one requiring attendance at such schools as a religious duty. 
 This falls in with Gramsci's understanding of the stages of the development of catholic monopoly. 
 The phase of cultural catholicism was to develop somewhat later. 
 Over the next fifty years, a significant change in policy took place. 
 Catholics and protestants became more and more segregated by school, as the Roman catholic bishops sought to bind in their flocks from outside influences, on the one hand to protect them  from proselytism, and on the other to use the schools as a vehicle for the maintenance and development of faith. 
 An indicator of the growing importance of this totalizing view of education was contained in the 1841 rescript from Rome. 
 It announced that, if doctrine as opposed to Bible stories was to be a part of school education, then such religious education could not adopt a common denominator approach between the churches, but had to be total in its presentation of what the Roman catholic church considered to be the truth, otherwise such an approach would be &bquo;dangerous&equo; for the children (Gaine 1968: 164). 
 The implementation of this policy was the work in part of the new Roman episcopal appointees, from Cullen onwards, though the growing hatred of the ascendancy because of the famine and their continued landownership must have provided ample cause for separate schools for the majority of Roman catholic clergy. 
 Already in the 1850s, Roman catholic bishops attacked the setting up of the &bquo;model schools&equo;, intended for the pursuit of educational experiments within a multi-denominational setting. 
 In 1860, the rules on the composition of the National Education Board was changed to permit equal protestant and catholic representation. 
 When state-supported secondary education was introduced in 1878, a denominational system was officially set up, though at this time the system was only availed of by the few families who could afford to lose the labour of young teenagers. 
 So extensive became the control of the catholic sector, both primary and secondary, that priests had extensive powers of dismissal over the teachers until the end of the nineteenth century. 
 From 1899, the intention of the clergy to assume and maintain absolute control of their schools led a number of them to refuse to appoint members of the Irish National Teachers' Organization so as to avoid trade union interference. 
 The result was that the union became subordinated for some time to the hierarchy and a breakaway union of protestant teachers was formed. 
 Despite the curtailment of some of the clergy's powers, friction between the teachers' associations, particularly the INTO, and the Roman catholic clergy has remained until this day. 
 Clergy control of the schools had indeed become a priority for the church leadership. 
 The understanding reached between them and the catholic &mdash; nationalist lay leadership resulted in schooling in the future state being allocated to the domain of the church, in exchange for the legitimation of that state by the church leadership. 
  It was also agreed that supplementary financial aid would come from the state. 
 The agreement came about through a delicate set of potentially dangerous encounters between the Irish party and the Roman catholic bishops during the first two decades of the present century. 
 It proved to be a period of strained relations with the English liberals, who were allies of the Irish party, but who were also in favour of bringing schooling more and more under state rather than church control (Miller 1973: 81&ndash;7, 120&ndash;38, 268&ndash;92). 
 By this time, the schools frequented by Roman catholics in Ireland were also largely under the direct control of the church's clerics. 
 But secularizing moves by the English liberals &mdash; over the Education Bills of 1902, 1906, and a private member's Bill of 1911 &mdash; led the Irish hierarchy to question some of the political intentions of the Irish politicians, who it was feared might sell out the church's interest in schools. 
 According to the Liberal-Irish alliance, the Irish party was supposed to abstain from the 1901 Conservative bill, aimed at bringing denominational schools in England and Wales into the national education system while at the same time absenting them from local government control: that is, giving finance while maintaining the system of denominational clerical control. 
 With the Irish party abstaining, both English and Irish Roman catholic bishops began to pressurize the leader of the Irish party, Redmond, and his associates to support the Conservative bill. 
 Added upset came in the same year from a speech by Dr W. Starkie, the commissioner of National Education in Ireland, who attacked school managers for not being up to their job. 
 The attack was within the context of a speech largely praising the Roman catholic church in Ireland. 
 But the church's clerics still took offence, particularly at the point that local people should be encouraged to take an interest in the schools by having some financial responsibility for them through local government. 
 As priests controlled the local school directly, this was seen to be a direct attack on their role in the school system. 
 Eventually the Irish party was forced to return to Westminster to see to it that the appropriate denominational interests in England were strengthened and to show the Irish political leadership's compliance with the similarly organized Irish system (Miller 1973: 77&ndash;85). 
 This controversy was immediately followed by another. 
 A specially appointed English school inspector reported negatively on certain aspects of Irish schools. 
 He concluded that the division into  different schools by denomination, sex, and age resulted in an economically inefficient system. 
 He attributed the inefficiency in part to the managerial system of independent clerical control. 
 Local accountability, state ownership of the properties, and a form of local authority supervision of teaching salaries were advocated as remedies. 
 The Conservative government, through its Irish Office secretary, George Wyndham, then indicated its intention of reforming the Irish system and devolving power to local, lay control, working in partnership with a central government department. 
 The Irish hierarchy immediately campaigned against what was for them a drastic solution. 
 They declared, rightly, that the very power of the clergy in education was being attacked, and, probably wrongly, that the reform of the faults of the present system was only the apparent reason. 
 Possibly in response to the stimuli given by the bishops' public statements, the bishops found that local councils were coming to their aid and support in opposing the proposed educational revolution. 
 The campaign to prevent change of clerical control of the school system was also linked to the contemporary campaign to set up catholic university colleges. 
 The bishops were successful in urging the Irish party to accept the church's programme for Irish education as a whole. 
 Their success was founded on a dual strategy. 
 On the one hand they subscribed to the annual Irish parliamentary party fund and, on the other, they publicly praised the Irish party as the true political representatives of the Irish people and its interests in the British parliament. 
 Even a &bquo;Castle&equo; bishop such as Archbishop Healy, now announced his conversion to the nationalist cause. 
 In other words, support for the education policies of the church were the quid  the Irish party had to give in order to obtain the quo  of the bishops' endorsement of the party as the genuine political representatives of the Irish people or nation. 
 The agreement over education was so clear that when the first revolutionary Irish government set itself up in 1918, prior to negotiated independence, there was no Minister for Education. 
 And when the Irish Free State did emerge in 1921, practically the entire school system was under the control of the churches.  
 STRUCTURES OF OWNERSHIP AND CONTROL: THE CLERIC-CIVIL SERVANTS AXIS 
 The present interrelationship between control of the schools and the two alliances varies in each part of Ireland, though one should also bear in mind the additional underpinning of the alliances both North and South by one of the traditional values of bourgeois capitalism, private and selective schooling. 
 Throughout Ireland as a whole, there has generally been an anti-comprehensive ethos in the education system supportive of both class and sectarian divisions in schooling and which is now eroding only in part. 
 In Northern Ireland, the catholic schools' sector is provided for out of state funds, and remains under the governorship of the local clergy, now assisted by laity and members of the local educational and library boards. 
 Many Roman catholic schools up to 1968 were financed for capital expenditure by the local church as part of the church's determination not to lose control of them. 
 The chairman of the board is usually the parish priest or his curate. 
 With the exception of a small group of public schools, there is the apparently simple distinction between state schools and Roman catholic schools which occurs in Britain. 
 However, it would be n&auml;ive to think that control of the state sector, its general ethos, and the teaching of religious education was non-denominational. 
 These schools are protestant, though nothing else is perhaps to lie expected when protestant &mdash; loyalist teachers teach protestant &mdash; loyalist children. 
 Religious education in these schools is officially non-denominational or biblically based and loyalist sentiments are promoted. 
 But religious education has been known to be fundamentalist and in some cases anti-catholic, depending on the teacher. 
 It is important to note that, since the system began in the late 1920s, there has never been a significant move to split up the schools for use by the separate denominations, something which would have been feasible in the larger towns. 
 The Northern public-sector schools come from the partly voluntary system of pre-Partition. 
 In 1928, these schools entered the system of maintained schools, whereby, in exchange for full payment of current costs and 65 per cent of capital expenditure, the former owners and managers, usually churches, were allowed two-thirds representation  on the local board of management, with the other third coming from the local authority. 
 From 1968, these schools received the same benefits as the Roman cathodic sector. 
 Up until the late 1970s, 98 per cent of children raised in Northern Ireland experienced schooling only on their own side of the divide (Darby, et al . 
 1977). 
 Two major exceptions to the general divide were the secondary schools in Fivemiletown and Ballycastle, where shortage of catholic equivalents resulted in de facto  integration. 
 In 1978, the mould was broken with the setting up of a private interdenominational primary school in Belfast, enabled by a special act of Parliament. 
 This was followed by setting up of a voluntary multi-denominational school at secondary level, Lagan College, in 1981. 
 The school was granted public funding from 1984, since which time a further four similar schools have opened. 
 All of this change was brought about by pressure from the integrated education movement discussed in the next section. 
 In the Republic, the unwritten church &mdash; state accord on education was maintained, and subsequently reinforced, by the emergent catholic &mdash; nationalist ethos. 
 The primary state sector, the &bquo;national schools&equo;, is paid for by the state, but is effectively under the control of the churches, with a local priest or minister as manager. 
 Since the late 1970s management boards have been set up consisting of three diocesan nominees, including normally the parish priest, two parents, and the head teacher. 
 Until the mid- and late 1970s, there were simply no rules whereby groupings of parents could obtain a state-financed, multi-denominational school, as the only channels of communication in these matters were those between the Department of Education and the relevant diocesan department or other church board. 
 For example, a new housing estate would be built, the diocese would be informed of the development at the planning stage, and the diocesan office would put in for a school, or an extension for an existing school. 
 The arrangement had been unchanged since the early years of the state and had become entirely natural. 
 Similarly for the protestant community: the school plant is owned by the church, or appropriate church body. 
 The main owner of such schools is usually and indirectly the Church of Ireland, and current expenditure and salaries are provided by the state, with the board of governors presided over by the local minister. 
 The secondary sector in the Republic is hardly so simple in  structure. 
 For present purposes, three items in particular merit comment. 
 Firstly, it was not until the 1930s that a substantial sector of education arose which was not directly under church control. 
 Even then, this was the sector of vocational or technical schools, which were the schools of the politically and economically less influential classes. 
 These were not able to afford education or were unable to pass the necessary scholarship or entrance exams, or they were the sons and daughters of artisans seeking similar type craft training for their offspring. 
 About one-third of pupils have traditionally attended them since that time. 
 These schools come under the control of the Department of Education, through locally appointed committees. 
 They are organizationally secular schools, though some clergy are members of the local governing committees and this has always been a feature. 
 The &bquo;community&equo; or comprehensive-type schools which are beginning to replace vocational and local church schools have a more religious flavour, as they may include the interests of a former convent, which the new school is in part replacing, a former vocational school, and possibly a former diocesan boys' school as well. 
 The churches have never objected to the existence of the vocational schools since their establishment in the early 1930s. 
 It must be added that vocational schools have traditionally had low status. 
 They took what was left after the church schools had creamed off the more academic pupils and the upper classes. 
 Admittedly, the Christian Brothers' schools were open to all, but they tended to be academically inclined in curriculum and ethos. 
 Vocational school pupils in the cities come mainly from the urban working class. 
 In the country, they come largely from rural small holders and farm labourers. 
 In 1978, at least a dozen of these schools were attended by protestants in numbers of between 5&ndash;20 per cent of the total (Fulton 1982). 
 It is also true that the religious practice of those who attend vocational schools has been significantly inferior to those who attended catholic secondary schools, at least in the 1970s (Nic Ghiolla Phadraig 1980). 
 It is likely that this is caused not by having less religious education, but by the fact that they tend to be peopled by children of classes who have traditionally fewer links with the church, and include parents making active decisions to keep their children out of the clergy's grasp. 
 Secondly, there are twenty-eight protestant secondary schools in the Republic. 
 With the steady decline in the Southern protestant  population until recently, it was only possible to have government funds for such schools if these schools were reasonably economical. 
 Most of these schools are private, though parents receive assistance with the fees from a committee which is funded directly by the government and which allocates grants by means test. 
 Some of the larger schools, however, are comprehensives, taking in the whole range of abilities, and are government funded for their current expenditure. 
 The consequence of having such large schools with small protestant catchment areas was that those funded from the state had to make up numbers by accepting non-protestants. 
 The Roman catholic element in all the republic's protestant second-level schools varies from one school with 0 per cent to one school with 40 per cent of the total. 
 But some of the headmasters have a deliberate multi-denominational policy in terms of ethos and curriculum and the schools do provide multi-denominational settings which, if researched, could throw light on debates about denominational and shared schools. 
 The current expansion and urban growth in the Southern population has also affected the protestant community, and the increased pressure on schools in urban areas, such as Dublin, is likely to lead to a diminution of the protestant-catholic character of most protestant schools, unless deliberate decisions are taken to preserve the balance. 
 What emerges from this brief overview is the dominant role of the clergy in Southern education. 
 Clergy have a prime role in setting up schools and a favoured position of direct relationships with the appropriate state institutions. 
 One must remember that it was specifically this issue of clerical power over schools which was the nub of the controversy in the 1900&ndash;14 period. 
 In the North, clergy dominate the catholic sector, while a protestant and loyalist culture predominates in the state schools &mdash; albeit with a developed secular and liberal aspect in many of them. 
 THE TOTALIZING EDUCATION SYSTEMS UNDER THREAT: THE INTEGRATED EDUCATION MOVEMENT 
 The separation of the two opposing alliances in Ireland is thus replicated at the level of schooling. 
 This remains a fact no matter how one seeks to explain or excuse it. 
 It is largely the case that  catholic nationalists go to one set of schools which have a visible catholic and nationalist ethos, and protestant loyalists go to another, some of which have a less visible protestant ethos, but all of which have a loyalist ethos as well. 
 Some catholic nationalists in the South mix with a proportionally much larger number of Southern protestants who, however, are loyal to the Southern state. 
 Part of the reason why Roman catholics go to their own schools is because they believe they are obliged to do so. 
 The belief is to some degree affected by being told so by their authoritative pastors. 
 It has even been described as a fundamental moral precept by more than one Irish catholic cleric: &bquo;The law of the Church is quite definite, quite universal in this matter. 
 It is that there is an obligation to go to Catholic school&hellip; 
 It is the same in Northern Ireland as any other part of the world&equo; (Bp. 
 Philbin, Belfast, in an interview on RTE, 3 Oct. 1976, quoted Mark 1979: 10). 
 This prescriptive approach has been repeated as recently as October 1988, when the director of the Council for Catholic Maintained Schools in Northern Ireland said that people who sent their children to integrated schools rather than catholic ones were breaking the law of the church. 
 There is also strong central support from Rome which places catholic education at the centre of its cultural catholicism ideal. 
 It should be noted that the largest threat to totalizing control of schools in Ireland has so far come from the integrated schooling movement. 
 This movement has a double constituency, one in the Northern, the other in the Southern, state. 
 Their membership, mainly middle-class, have met considerable difficulty in trying to achieve their limited goals &mdash; integrated schooling for the children of those parents who wish it &mdash; though some of the membership in the early days were aiming at a total integration of the schooling system. 
 Until recently, catholics in the North were practically forbidden by their clergy to attend state schools, exceptions being made in certain outlying areas. 
 Bishop Edward Daly in Derry liberally interpreted the needs of his Roman catholic pupils from the mid-1970s, allowing greater freedom and seeing to it that some alternative religious education was provided. 
 At the same time, the late Bishop Philbin began to refuse the sacrament of Confirmation to Roman catholic children attending state schools. 
 A number of clergy in his diocese refused religious instruction to these children. 
 The reason given was that children would not be religiously and  educationally prepared for the reception of Holy Communion and Confirmation because they had not been educated at a catholic school, irrespective of their parents' alternative provisions: in one area, parents had set up their own Sunday schools as an alternative. 
 The measures were felt to be particularly harsh by those catholic parents who were getting involved with the All Children Together movement. 
 Some of its parents had begun sending their children to the less protestant dominated schools within the state system, shortly before the movement was formed. 
 They were doing so on largely political religious grounds. 
 They felt that it was partly their responsibility to bring up their children in an atmosphere of knowledge and understanding of protestants, as they believed part of the difficulties of life in Ulster were caused by this lack of contact. 
 At the same time, they were keen to bring up their children as Roman catholics. 
 All Children Together, or ACT, was formed in the early 1970s. 
 It draws its membership from across the spectrum of religious and non-religious groupings, though they are generally middle-class and mostly committed Christians. 
 They remain dedicated to the task of setting up a group of integrated schools as a sector of education complementary to the existing system. 
 An appeal made to Rome in 1977 by the Roman catholic parents concerned with the Confirmation ban appeared to have been answered in their favour, as Bishop Philbin changed his pastoral policy and these children were allowed to go forward for confirmation in 1978&ndash;9. 
 A notable achievement of ACT has been the passing of the Education (Northern Ireland) Act of 1978, permitting the establishment of multi-denominational schools where such is desired by adequate numbers of parents. 
 The Act is an enabling one and does not affect the existing system unless the leadership of the churches wish to co-operate in a reshaping of the system or of schools in any particular area. 
 In addition, such schools have to be self-financing until they have an adequate complement of pupils. 
 In the Republic, as in the North, a parents' movement to set up integrated schools was started around the same time. 
 It grew up originally in the Southern middle-class suburb of Dalkey, County Dublin, and around the Church of Ireland national school there. 
 A dispute with the local rector and manager led to a group of parents withdrawing their support from the school and coming together to form the Dalkey School Project. 
 The organization  claimed membership from all parts of the South, and its membership contained education specialists, lawyers, people from the media, and civil servants, at least one of whom knew something of the existing channels of power and communication between church and state in the national school system. 
 Energy was directed mainly to the primary sector, where, until recently, it was impossible to have anything but a church-sponsored school if it was to be funded by the state. 
 In 1978, on the basis of their professional knowledge of schooling and civil administration, the organization succeeded in obtaining the necessary government permission to open in Dalkey a multi-denominational school governed principally by the parents, the mode of religious instruction to be determined by them. 
 It opened the following September. 
 Another project at Marley Grange in South Dublin was less successful, due in part to the Church of Ireland deciding to support its own primary school in the area, and in part to the open opposition of the local Roman catholic clergy. 
 At Firhouse, in South-West Dublin, a third project was in the making in 1975. 
 In a survey with a 75 per cent response rate undertaken by the residents' association on its new housing estate, some two-thirds of the respondents favoured the setting up of a multi-denominational school. 
 The present writer, who was not connected with the survey, estimated that there was about a 15 per cent non-Roman catholic element on the estate at the time. 
 There seemed to be the fairly uncomplicated desire among the community to see all the children attend the same school, as an expression of relationships existing within the community. 
 It is likely that children have the important function in a new housing area of bringing parents and neighbours together, particularly when there is a lack of other social amenities &mdash; a characteristic of new housing areas in and around Dublin in the 1970s. 
 The children probably appear as a source from which to develop new relationships and the immediate perception is to translate this experience into scholastic terms. 
 The absence of a non-Roman catholic school in the immediate area and the na&iuml;ve belief that they were empowered in some way to have a say in what type of school should appear on their housing estate &mdash; there was a small Roman catholic school which was to be expanded to cater for the growth of the population &mdash; may have sharpened catholic parents' interest in having an integrated school. 
 There were at this point no apparent difficulties experienced between the majority of estate members and  no significant source of conflict, that is until the question of a multi-denominational school itself became such a source. 
 The two Roman catholic priests, who were in all respects dedicated pastors and much liked by many in the local community, immediately opposed the idea, preaching against it at Sunday masses in the local convent and the school hall. 
 The burden of the message was that good catholic parents sent their children to catholic schools. 
 The curate added to this that those promoting the integrated project were in fact promoting secularism. 
 The fact that a prominent member of the current community council and an integrated education supporter was a member of official Sinn Fein, the Workers' party, appeared to figure in the reasoning, as this party has always been suspected to be an anti-clerical and secularist force. 
 In residents' association meetings, the clergy's point of view received vocal support from one or two members of the older village community which preceded the housing estate. 
 The total of those favouring denominational schooling in the initial survey was less than one-third. 
 But, since the open opposition of the clergy, many of those attracted by the original idea were clearly dissuaded and the majority opposition dwindled away. 
 The clergy had informed the people's conscience on the basis of what they considered to be the essential religious interests of their flock. 
 Alternatively, from another perspective, the clergy had acted to preserve the old divisions. 
 Unfortunately, the one is an inevitable corollary of the other. 
 ROMAN CATHOLIC VERSUS INTEGRATED SCHOOLING: INTERPRETING REALITY 
 The clearest opposition to the achievement of a measure of integration has been from the Roman catholic church. 
 But where other churches have owned their own schools, as does the Church of Ireland in the South, a similar position has been adopted, though the reasons for the position have been on different grounds. 
 A proposal before the Church of Ireland synod in May 1979 to support interdenominational education was defeated, despite pressure from its ecumenical lobby. 
 The main grounds appeared to be  the danger which it might pose to the small Southern protestant minority by encouraging mixed marriages. 
 However, no evidence favouring such a contention has ever been produced. 
 Harry MacAdoo, then the Church of Ireland archbishop of Dublin, on several occasions put forward the argument that Southern protestants were a minority group with their own culture and traditions, and thus deserved to have schools for themselves in order to hand on their own traditions. 
 When considering the merit of this argument, one does have to bear in mind the particularly precarious nature of the Southern protestant grouping. 
 Protestant opposition to integrated schooling is sometimes heard in the North, particularly from the fundamentalist camp, who not only fear catholic infiltration of state schools but are opposed to anything other than Bible protestantism in religious education. 
 But usually the opposite is the case and popular protestant support for integration is expressed. 
 perhaps if integrated schooling were more widespread in the North, more protestant voices would be heard against it, particularly if there was a possibility that a nun or priest might show up as a teacher in such an integrated school. 
 There is also evidence of hardline evangelical indoctrination by some protestant teachers in state schools. 
 In addition, Roman catholic schools in Ireland, in continuity with the belief and practice of Roman catholics in a number of other countries, have a different concept and practice of teaching religion in the schools from that of the majority of protestant traditions. 
 This ranges from the presence of religious symbols in the classrooms and corridors of the schools to religious services such as mass or the saying of the rosary, and finally to the specific form of religious education which is praxis oriented. 
 Learning, singing, and praying are rolled up into one: catechesis, as opposed to dialogue or concerned interest for religious matters. 
 Children are prepared in the classroom for their first communion, confession, and confirmation. 
 The Controversy over the Reality of Schooling 
 Extensive public debate on integrated and segregated education has taken place throughout Ireland. 
 Bishop Cahal Daly has argued  that the debate on multi-denominational schools has effectively taken people's attention away from the central issues in Northern Ireland, namely social injustice, fundamental political inequality, and the violence. 
 In reaction to this, one can say that the very way in which the church leaders view the subject is itself revealing of significant mediations between religion, state, and national ideology in the institutions of schooling. 
 In the debates over the last twenty years there has been considerable interplay of theological and sociological reasoning, with social scientists also contributing to papers and discussions. 
 What has been seen as an aspect of the Roman catholic intellectual opposition to divorce in Chapter 5 can also be recognized as a feature of the defence of catholic schools too: the opposition contains an interpretation of the moral nature of contemporary society and of what happens to catholics who are not to some degree protected from it. 
 In this writer's view, the arguments against multi-denominational education and in favour of catholic schools support an overall political theology which is strongly based on authority within the church. 
 Hierarchy and clergy are seen almost to monopolize the teaching and wisdom about life. 
 They are both directors of souls and minders of the public conscience. 
 Put together with a faith vision of the contemporary social world as inherently secularist and radically subversive of Roman catholic values, the combination is significantly reactionary and ethnocentric. 
 The aspects of this political theology will be discussed later. 
 First it is necessary to consider the arguments used in the public debates. 
 While the arguments of the defenders of catholic schools have a theological basis, those of the promoters of integrated schooling have been founded on what they see to be the results of the present system, namely a violent and destructive society. 
 But there has been some attempt also to undercut the basic level of the defenders' case. 
 It has been argued that catholic schools do not do the job for which they were set up, that is educate Roman catholics sufficiently to keep them in the church. 
 Irish bishops have been well aware of Spencer's (1968) research. 
 Using traditional measures of religiosity, he has pointed out the apparent failure of English catholic schools to produce better catholics and fewer ex-catholics than state or  other schools, and has inferred the likelihood of the same for Irish schools. 
 Spencer's argument has been banded about from time to time. 
 This is not unnatural, as in the 1970s and early 1980s Spencer was at the Queen's University, Belfast, and an active member of the All Children Together Movement. 
 Support for this line of approach has been found in Greeley and Rossi's (1966) survey in the USA on the effectiveness of catholic schools. 
 Based on statistical data for Roman catholics educated in both Roman catholic and other schools, Greeley and Rossi noted as one of their findings that there was little difference in adult religious practice between the two groups. 
 There was a group among former Roman catholic school pupils who exhibited a more intense level of practice, but these were also children of fervent Roman catholics. 
 The causal inference adopted by Greeley and Rossi was that Roman catholic schools only had a clearly identifiable and reinforcing effect on the belief and practice of this group. 
 Clearly, Greeley and Rossi's findings could be used both ways, and in fact both camps in the Irish debate have found it supportive of their case. 
 In a similar survey undertaken in 1974, Greeley found the effectiveness of catholic schools either the same or slightly increased. 
 In the decline the church had experienced in the intervening years, fewer catholic school children had opted out. 
 In addition, whether or not one had attended a catholic school may have had little effect on sexual values or mass attendance but it did increase catholic activism and racial tolerance (Greeley, McCready, and McCourt 1976). 
 In the light of W. McCready's findings in another study that the religious behaviour of the father had a greater impact on children, Greeley considered the fact that catholic schools were having an increasing influence on men to be of significant importance for the future of Roman catholicism in the USA (1976: 173&ndash;5). 
 Clearly, the follow-up study was more favourable to the defenders of catholic schools than to opponents. 
 However, Greeley and Rossi's work also has been used to uphold the defenders' argument that, though Roman catholic schools varied in their efficiency, they were certainly better than any possible alternative in terms of producing good Roman catholics. 
 Thus, both sides have tended to use social scientific research to make statements in general about catholic schools which have been drawn from other countries and, therefore, beyond the cultural confines within which Irish catholic schools exist. 
 This is something  for which surveys, including that of Greeley and Rossi, are not and cannot be intended. 
 Another point worth bearing in mind is the very generalizing character of Greeley and Rossi's studies. 
 There was nothing in the studies on the differences between individual catholic schools, either in terms of pupil experiences or the varieties of educational practice and personnel in each school. 
 A black-box approach to the schooling process was used with no direct investigation of processes within the schools. 
 Finally, while it could be argued that Greeley and Rossi tell us something of catholic versus state schooling in the US, they have nothing to tell us about catholic versus Christian, multi-denominational schools, which is what most of the argument in Ireland is about. 
 But the central and substantive argument that defenders of Roman catholic schools have had to deal with is that the dual school system in Northern Ireland encourages, supports, or at least reinforces the sectarian divide, and that it forms part of the vicious circle maintaining conflict in Ulster. 
 It has been argued that one could help to break that circle by integrating the school system (Fraser 1974; Heskin 1980). 
 A small number of empirical studies actually done in Northern Ireland have been invoked in the course of the debate. 
 Rose (1971) pointed out that those with a mixed schooling background showed marginally less extreme political views than those educated separately. 
 Unfortunately, Rose did not elaborate on the nature of such mixed schooling experiences. 
 They  could even have proven to be the negative experience of small ethnic enclaves defending themselves in hostile environments, but even this viewpoint can only be speculation. 
 Murray (1983; 1985) advised not to expect too much of schools on the basis of his own in-depth research into two primary schools, one from each Northern group. 
 He has also sought support for this view from studies of separate and mixed schooling of different ethnic groups in other countries. 
 Such studies, he argued, have shown that joint schooling is not necessarily successful in lowering prejudice. 
 Consequently, one has to improve relationships within Northern Ireland without trying to merge the entire school system. 
 However, curricular changes, joint teaching projects, and overall greater contact were seen necessary. 
 Roman catholic church leaders have used additional local studies to refute arguments which treat Roman catholic schools as part of the Northern problem. 
 They have interpreted Salters's study of Belfast secondary schools as showing catholics to be less prejudiced than protestants. 
 Even if this were so, the implication has been made by catholic school supporters that catholic schools have not promoted or reinforced any measure of prejudice, and that no other possible type of school could improve on them (Daly 1975). 
 Unfortunately, the necessary link to warrant this second conclusion &mdash; a control group of catholics in a multi-denominational situation &mdash; was simply not available to Salters, and so the argument is void. 
 Use has also been made of Russell's work on the teaching of civics in Northern Ireland schools. 
 The work led Russell himself to conclude that the teaching of the subject had no effect whatsoever on pupils' political outlook. 
 This can be taken either as a criticism of the actual teaching of the subject or as a remark on the ineffectiveness of schooling on such attitudes in the Northern Ireland context. 
 Russell tended to support the latter view. 
 This has been taken to mean that teaching children together with the aid of a definite programme to reduce prejudice would not work, thus invalidating any proposed integration of schooling. 
 This, of course would have to be seen. 
 But both Salters's and Russell's work in Northern Ireland schools have been used by catholic schools supporters to aid a general principle, also derived from the work of some sociologists of education: namely that schools have little impact on children in terms of their basic values anyway, and one should recognize parents and community environment for the real  source of these. 
 The tradition in educational studies which seems to aid such views stresses that you cannot change society with the school. 
 Schools cannot have a real effect on children's basic values because these have been instilled earlier by the process of primary socialization in the home and in the wider social community. 
 Of course, other studies could just as easily be cited to state the opposite. 
 Schooling, according to Eggleston (1974) and Shipman (1972), has a definite effect on human behaviour and values, and, according to Bronfenbrenner (1972) can even enter quite profoundly into the socialization process. 
 The debate is now largely &bquo;old hat&equo; in the sociology of education and there is a general consensus that schools do indeed impart values, but these are usually modified or developed versions of already existing dominant values of the society of which they form a part, including a number of parental values. 
 Needless to say, any such denial of this would be a denial of the power of education as a whole to mature individuals in their intellectual and moral perceptions. 
 Again, according to Bernstein (1975), Ball (1981), and many more, schooling can have opposite effects on children according to whether children have been socialized into working-class or middle-class aspirations, and according to the actual way the schooling process is structured by the state, the teachers, and the subject-disciplines. 
 At the same time, sociologists of education generally hold to the view that schools can have an important role in both conservation and social change. 
 Consequently, the intricate role they play in the North or South of Ireland is for the investigator to find out.  
 I began work on the big glass on 27 July 1967, wrote Harsnet. 
 Goldberg, images of their last meeting in the narrow entrance of the elegant little Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art dancing in his head, slipped a sheet of A4 into his old Olivetti portable and started to transcribe. 
 I began work on the big glass on 27 July 1967, he typed. 
 I had been preparing myself for that moment for a long time, he typed, as Harsnet had written. 
 I had been preparing myself for as long as I can remember, preparing myself (though I did not always realize it) from the day that I was born, preparing myself, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), but always aware of the dangers of beginning too soon. 
 For there is nothing worse, he wrote, than beginning too soon. 
 It is much worse to begin too soon, he wrote, than not to begin at all. 
 Much worse to begin too soon than to begin too late. 
 Much worse to begin too soon and realize one has begun too soon than to begin too late and realize one has begun too late. 
 Much worse to begin too soon and realize one is inadequately prepared than to begin too late and realize one is over-prepared. 
 Much worse to begin too soon and reach the end too quickly, typed Goldberg, squinting at the manuscript before him, than to begin at the right time and reach the end too quickly. 
 Much worse to begin too soon and feel one has begun too soon than to begin at the right time and discover one has nothing to begin. 
 That is why, wrote Harsnet, I have been preparing myself for that moment for a long time, that is why I have cleared the decks  and prepared the ground , because unless the decks are cleared  and the g round prepared  there is little hope of succeeding in what one has planned to do, little hope of achieving anything of  lasting value, though lasting is a relative term and so is value and whatever it is one has planned to do is certain to be altered in the process, which does not of course mean, he wrote, that one can start anywhere at any time. 
 It is just because  whatever one has planned to do is bound to be altered in the process that it is important to start at the right moment, he wrote. 
 It is just because  whatever one has planned is bound to change as one proceeds that it is fatal to start too soon or too late, though it may be no less fatal, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), to start at the right time, for then there is no excuse, no excuse whatsoever. 
 I have done with excuses, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), I have done with excuses towards myself and towards others, that is the meaning of the right time, he wrote, that I have done with excuses, that I have used up all the excuses and reached the bottom of excuses, that I have wrung the neck  of excuses, that I have settled the hash  of excuses. 
 To begin at the right time, he wrote, means to be done with excuses once and for all. 
 Excuses , wrote Goldberg in the margin of his typescript with a felt-tip pen, an end to excuses . 
 There has to be a time, wrote Harsnet, and Goldberg, laying down the pen, began to type again, there has to be a time when excuses are no longer necessary, will never again be necessary, there has to be such a time in everybody's life, when too soon and too late no longer mean anything, a time, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), when one starts because one starts and for no other reason. 
 But to arrive at that moment, he wrote, it is necessary to be patient, it is necessary to hold back, it is often necessary to do nothing. 
 All my life, he wrote, I have been preparing myself for this moment, but if I have prepared myself correctly then it is so that when the moment came I should not be encumbered with the sensation of having waited for it all my life, for such a sensation, wrote Harsnet, is too heavy a burden for anyone to carry. 
 The right moment to begin, he wrote, is the moment when right and wrong are no longer an issue, it may even be the moment, he wrote, when the realization dawns and is at once accepted that another moment might have been equally  valid, and when this no longer matters. 
 This is the moment and that is all. 
 There is also the practical element to be considered, he wrote. 
 There is the clearing of the room, the removal of any trace of what had previously filled it. 
 There is the laying by of all the necessary materials. 
 Not, he wrote (and Goldberg went on typing), that here in London one is cut off from such supplies in the normal course of events, but that work cannot begin until one knows one will not have to bother with such things, for a while at least. 
 It is not a question, he wrote, of drawing up an inventory of all that is required, because that suggests that one can know exactly what will be required. 
 Everything possible must be done, he wrote, and yet it must be as though nothing had been done. 
 For unless there is the sense that nothing has been done there will be no work. 
 And yet, unless everything has in fact been done, there will also be no work. 
 Without the materials, he wrote, without the paints and the brushes, the pencils and the paper, above all without the panels of glass, there could have been no beginning, and I want to record here, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), that there was a beginning, at 5.30 p.m. on Thursday 27 July 1967. 
 I do not mean to imply, he wrote, that nothing existed before that moment, no plans, no designs, no sketches and no notes, of course there were plans and designs, sketches and notes, how could there not be, he wrote, when my whole life has been nothing but a preparation for this beginning, not only in the sense that everyone's life is always a preparation for every beginning in that life but in the quite specific sense that my own life has always been a preparation for this  beginning, nothing but a preparation for this beginning, both consciously and unconsciously, with everything I have done as well as everything I have thought, everything I have felt as well as everything I have suffered. 
 Not that I wish to say, he wrote, that everything is inevitable, on the contrary, I wish to assert emphatically that nothing is inevitable and nothing was inevitable, neither what I did nor what I thought, neither what I felt nor what I suffered, yet everything was necessary, a necessary beginning and necessary  Harsnet (typed Goldberg) is misleading, since it was only after I had begun that I knew I had begun, while before I had begun, before the 27 July 1967, there was no beginning, as there was no end, there was no time and there was no freedom from time, only endless cups of coffee, endless cups of tea, endless biscuits and endless bacon sandwiches. 
 Endless, he wrote, because I could see no end to them and because I could envisage no beginning. 
 Endless, he wrote, because without hope. 
 There is hope, he wrote, where there is making, and there is no hope where there is no making. 
 There is no hope, he wrote, where there is no possibility of going wrong, where you can unthink in the afternoon what you have thought in the morning, think back in the evening what you have unthought in the afternoon. 
 Senza speme vivemo in disio , he wrote, the saddest line ever written. 
 I am not suggesting, he wrote, that this period was particularly unpleasant. 
 It was neither pleasant nor unpleasant, though the endless peeing, he wrote, the endless getting up in the middle of the night when the ice clung to the windowpanes and the taps were frozen, that was more unpleasant than pleasant, but it was not that, he wrote, these things - will not change, my bladder will not improve and next winter the ice will still cling to the panes and the taps will still freeze, but I will not notice them . 
 I will get up and pee once every two or three hours, as I have always done, but then I will return to my bed and sleep, I will return to my room and work. 
 It is only during the time of waiting, wrote Harsnet, during the time without hope, that these things assume significance, only during the time without hope that one is conscious of them, that one remembers them with despair, that one anticipates them with dread. 
 But I do not mean to suggest either, he wrote, that it was all waiting and no doing, all sitting and no action, for though it was impossible to tell when the beginning would come, indeed, he wrote, there could not have been a real beginning if it had been possible to tell, for if it had been possible to tell that would have meant that there had already been  a beginning,  no, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), occasionally things were done, work was begun, though it was soon abandoned, it added up to nothing, it only showed me that I had been mistaken in thinking that I had indeed started. 
 In my own case, he wrote, and I can speak only for myself, in my own case and in my own life there have been very few genuine beginnings, only three or perhaps four. 
 There was the revulsion at the fluidity  of life and the first tube of paint, the revulsion at the meticulousness  of painting with a brush and the first pot of paint, the revulsion at the viscousness  of paint and the first readymade, the revulsion at the arbitrariness  of the readymades and the first use of glass. 
 Perhaps, he wrote, that is enough for a lifetime. 
 Four real beginnings, wrote Harsnet, and four real rejections: the rejection of a life without art, the rejection of art, the rejection of any form of making, and the final rejection of all absolutes and the acceptance of compromise. 
 Four beginnings, he wrote, each prompted by a sense of revulsion. 
 Four beginnings , scribbled Goldberg in the margin of his typescript, four revulsions . 
 So that behind the changes of direction, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), this has always been a constant, the feeling of disgust in the pit of the stomach. 
 I have often tried to describe it to myself, he wrote, but never with much success. 
 For when it comes it is more violent, more annihilating, more interminable than I can remember it, this feeling in the pit of the stomach, this physical pain and physical desire to retch, to want to get rid of something, of everything, to want to make all that is inside emerge and disappear, drain away, mingle with the rest of the detritus of the world, but it is not only physical , a physical sensation, he wrote, it is physical  but it is also something else , not moral, not psychological, not spiritual, but something else , something other than the purely physical. 
 Nor is this feeling only provoked by the sight or the thought of art, he wrote. 
 I also experienced it (it came upon me) when I signed the marriage register as well as when I saw the pig slaughtered. 
 That is a fact, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), one of the few facts I can swear to, though I find it impossible to explain. 
 And it  has to be said, he wrote, that its opposite, a feeling of elation, equally physical, equally extra-physical, has also been a constant feature of my life, manifesting itself regularly though impossible to predict, a reeling in the chest this time, the chest and perhaps the throat, a feeling of the heart leaping and the blood pumping, it came when I first took up a brush and made a mark on paper, it came when I picked up the first readymade and felt it transformed by that very action, it came when Madge rang to say she could not go on, when Annie wrote to say she was not coming back, when the idea of the glass first popped into my head. 
 So, wrote Harsnet, there is continuity as well as discontinuity, but that does not mean, he wrote, that there exists what is called character, personality, character , Goldberg wrote in the margin, personality , as they seem to think, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg went on typing), when they say you have such a generous character if you would only recognize it, or you have so much to offer, or it is not for myself I speak but for you, not for myself I mourn but for the waste of all that generosity, when they pour those words over you, character, generosity, warmth, looking sad, shedding tears, putting on a brave face, saying don't pay any attention to me, or, it's nothing, forget it, I'm crying for the waste, meaning waste if it's not directed towards them, but you have only to see what happens when one lets oneself be persuaded by that sort of thing, wrote Harsnet, you have only to see what happened to Hutchinson, MacMahon, Rollins and Goldberg. 
 Taken in by the image of yourself they present you with, wrote Harsnet, instead of waiting in patience for the beginning, instead of waiting and then beginning, though beginning, having begun, he wrote, is not everything, is far from everything. 
 It is quite possible, he wrote, that it will lead nowhere, even when one has begun at the right time in the right spirit, or at least not at the wrong time, in the wrong spirit, with the wrong plans and having made the wrong preparations, with the wrong tools and the wrong principles, on the wrong surface and with the wrong conception. 
 Though it may well be, he wrote, that one actually achieves  more working with the wrong plans and in the wrong spirit, with the wrong tools and the wrong principles, on the wrong surface and with the wrong conception, it may well be, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), that one achieves more than working with the right plans and in the right spirit, with the right tools and the right principles, on the right surface and with the right conception, though right and wrong and more and less are relative concepts and what seems right at one moment to one person may seem wrong at the same moment to another Person or at another moment to the same person, and what seems more to one person at one moment may seem less to another person at the same moment or at another moment to the same person, right, wrong, more, less, relative concepts , scribbled Goldberg, in the margin, panting slightly as he bent over his old Olivetti Portable, there is only the beginning, wrote Harsnet, or rather, there is only having begun, beginning , scribbled Goldberg, aware now of the black stains on his hands left by the felt-tip pen, having begun , there is only the feeling in the pit of the stomach or the feeling in the chest, wrote Harsnet, the feeling of sickness or the feeling of elation, those are not relative, he wrote, those are absolute. 
 Yet is it possible to assert, he wrote, that work done with a lifting of the heart is better  than work done with a contracting of the stomach? 
 No, he wrote, it is not possible. 
 It is only possible to assert that work begun with a lifting of the heart is likely to go on for longer  than work begun with a contracting of the stomach, that work done with a lifting of the heart will develop further  than work done with a contracting of the stomach, but there is nothing to indicate that the small amount of work which is the result of a contracting of the stomach will not be better than the large amount of work done with a lifting of the heart, than the rich development which is the likely result of work undertaken with a lifting of the heart, always bearing in mind, wrote Harsnet, and Goldberg, poring over the pages covered in his friend's tiny handwriting, wiped the sweat from his forehead with his sleeve, glanced up at the sheet in his typewriter, always  bearing in mind, he typed (as Harsnet had written), that better and worse are relative terms, and that one man's better is another man's worse, one age's better is another age's worse, one civilization's better is another civilization's worse, better, worse, relative values , scribbled Goldberg in the margin, always bearing in mind, wrote Harsnet, that in the long run it all comes to the same thing, long run , scribbled Goldberg in the margin, same thing . 
 But for us on earth, wrote Harsnet, the run is not long but short. 
 We are here, he wrote, with our needs and desires. 
 We are here, for a brief while, with our energies intact, our needs and desires. 
 What is required, he wrote, is to find an outlet for those energies, for those needs and desires, so that they do not turn inward and rend you to pieces, an outlet, he wrote, but never to imagine that what we do is ever going to be an everlasting achievement. 
 Outlet , scribbled Goldberg in the margin, folly of belief in permanence . 
 The trouble is, wrote Harsnet, that if you start with this insight it is difficult to go on and then the energies, the needs and desires, turn inward and eat you up. 
 On the other hand, he wrote, if you don't see this clearly at the start you only produce more crap and there's enough in the world already. 
 Honest crap you can flush down the lavatory, he wrote, but dishonest crap, of the kind produced by so-called artists, is more difficult to dispose of. 
 Our civilization has at least this to its credit, he wrote, that it has found a way of rounding up this dishonest crap and incarcerating it in morgues, in fortified places with guards and alarm bells and the rest, thus keeping it off the streets, protecting decent citizens, and now, he wrote, there are even moves afoot to repel intruders by making them pay hard cash to enter these fortified places. 
 It would have been simpler and more effective, he wrote, to lock the doors and seal up the entrances, simpler and more effective and cheaper than manning the whole building. 
 But the shit proliferates, he wrote, and there is still much to be done. 
 I myself am guilty, he wrote, in that I want the glass to be seen , I want it placed in a morgue and I want people to come in and see it, pay money and  come in and see it, if needs be. 
 First to make it, he wrote, and then to show it, and then to bring things to a finish. 
 Those are the three steps, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), first to make it, then to ensure that it is seen, and finally to finish with everything. 
 Never in my life, he wrote, have I known so exactly what step to take after the step I am in the process of taking, and then what step to take after the step I will take after the step I am in the process of taking. 
 Never before, he wrote, have I seen so clearly how to end. 
 Now I have finally begun, he wrote, I have only to go on and the end will arrive. 
 And to think, he wrote, that with all my previous work I barely knew what step to take first, let alone what step to take second, let us not talk about the third. 
 Though it has to be said, he wrote, and Goldberg, his eye racing down the page covered in his friend's tiny handwriting, paused to sip from the glass of fresh orange-juice at his side, wiped his forehead and went on typing, it has to be said that I have occasionally had the illusion  that I knew what step to take first and even, occasionally, what step to take second, I will not talk about a third. 
 There is of course no logical reason why things should be different this time, wrote Harsnet, why this too should not be an illusion, the illusion of imagining that I know not only what step to take first but also what step to take second and even what step to take third. 
 No logical reason, he wrote, but that will not make me change my plans once I have begun. 
 Night, he wrote, work on the big glass and on the notes for the big glass, day, sleep and write this freewheeling commentary on the entire project, viz. on the big glass and on the notes for the big glass. 
 Night , scribbled Goldberg in the margin of his typescript, work on glass, day, work on freewheeling commentary . 
 It is sometimes thought, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg) that, because  there is no discernable principle of order in the universe or in our lives we should live in disorder. 
 I, on the other hand, he wrote, have always held that precisely because there is no discernable principle of order in the universe or in our lives  we should live in the greatest possible self-created  order. 
 The greatest possible self-created order, he wrote, compatible of course with the freedom to work, which may mean very little order indeed or may mean a great deal of order, depending on the individual and the circumstances. 
 It is up to each one of us, he wrote, at every point in our lives, to decide how much order and how much disorder, how much discipline and how much freedom we need for the best realization of our project of the moment, even though that project may turn out to be flawed or even utterly mistaken in the short run, of course I am only talking about the short run, he wrote, in the long run, as I have already said, both success and failure are quite without meaning, the notion of meaning is quite without meaning. 
 Long run , wrote Goldberg in the margin, wiping the sweat from his forehead with his sleeve, no meaning . 
 The real question, wrote Harsnet, is where the short run ends and the long run begins, since in the long run long and short are also without meaning. 
 But that, he wrote, is part of what the big glass itself will try to explore, with its notion of delay. 
 Big glass , wrote Goldberg in the margin, delay . 
 That, wrote Harsnet, is part of the reason why I have chosen glass and not canvas or wood, that is why in my notes I have called it a delay in glass , which is to say a refusal of shit. 
 I will perhaps call it a constipation  in glass, wrote Harsnet, not a delay  in glass, but an advance , he wrote, on my last readymade, the hard stool, my present to Goldberg on the occasion of his third wedding. 
 We will see, wrote Harsnet, whether he parts with it or not, whether his greed gets the better of his sentimentality. 
 A project is a project, he wrote, and once it is begun it should be carried through to the end, regardless of doubts about meaning, doubts about long runs, or doubts about anything else, unless the body screams for you to stop, of course one cannot go on for long against the screaming of the body, but then that merely means one has miscalculated, it merely means one has begun too soon or too late or perhaps that the entire project was a miscalculation. 
 That does not mean, he wrote, that if the body does not protest the project necessarily has any value, though  for reasons I have gone into already it is necessary to put such thoughts out of mind, they cannot help, they can only hinder, they cannot water, they can only blight. 
 But it has to be said (it has to be said!) wrote Harsnet, and Goldberg, typing, smiled to himself, it has to be said, wrote Harsnet, that if every project is likely, if not certain, to result in the addition of a little more shit to the shit that already exists, there is also the possibility, faint it is true but real, of the unexpected, and this is what delay makes possible and what the onward rush of time, the ever-increasing acceleration of time, perpetually denies, and in addition to the possibility of the unexpected appearing in the coils of delay, in addition to that, it has to be said, he wrote, that whatever the project, however trivial, however exalted, it will always say more than its maker knows, and, if genuine  (I will return to genuine), something will emerge which is distinct from whatever came before, from whatever elements went to make up the whole, a tone, a voice, which is not the tone or the voice of the maker but something else, something which, in my more optimistic moments, or perhaps my less clear-sighted moments, seems to be distinct from the shit though inseparable from it, a tone, a style, which links it to its maker's other genuine (I will return to genuine) productions. 
 But just as the mere thought of the long run is liable to blight any work on which one is engaged, so the thought of a tone distinct from though inseparable from the shit is guaranteed to bring even the most promising project to a halt. 
 We will leave it to Goldberg to disengage the tone from the shit, he wrote, we will leave it to Honeyman and McGough, much good may it do them, though I will no doubt come back to the question before my project is completed, the big glass and the notes to the big glass, these two to be worked on at night, and this freewheeling commentary on both to be written by day, putting down whatever comes into my head after a night's work, no correction, no revision, whatever comes into my head, the first two to be worked on by artificial light, the strategy clear, this by natural light wherever possible, no strategy at all, the first to be exhibited,  the second to be published in the form of sheets in a box, a blue box or a red box, I have not yet made up my mind, in a limited edition, not a luxury edition but a restricted edition, five hundred boxes perhaps or even two hundred and fifty, all that will become clearer in the course of my work on the big glass, of my work on the notes to the big glass, now I have finally embarked on the major project of my life, the climactic project of my life, leading to the end of my life, all will grow clearer, wrote Harsnet, whether to try and call back and destroy all I have done till now or let it be, whether to burn this commentary or let it be, or perhaps leave it to Goldberg to do whatever he wants with, all these things will no doubt be resolved before the work is completed, that is the beauty of being in the middle of a project, that time itself, which had seemed such an enemy before I started, rushing forward and dragging me with it, impervious to my pleas, has suddenly turned friendly, flops down at my feet, licks my ankles, lets me know it is on my side. 
 And how much more, wrote Harsnet, when the project on which you are engaged is the major project of your life, the project of your life. 
 It is funny, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), how reluctant I was to say anything like that here in the first few days, how instinctively I felt it might endanger the entire project, how everything might collapse around me the moment I said that. 
 It must be a measure of my confidence, he wrote, that I can now say, in these notes, without any kind of trepidation, that this is the major project of my life, that beside it the rest pales into insignificance, if it was not insignificant anyway, beside it or anything else. 
 Which is not to say, he wrote, that the present project has any value over and above the others, mine and those of everyone else, I have been into the question of value already and will not return to it now, has any value or that its outcome has any value, I have to repeat this, simply that now, for me, today, after the things I have done and given the time left me, it is the most important thing, it is what, from the time I first picked up a pencil and made a mark on a piece of paper, everything has logically led up to. 
 I do not  want, wrote Harsnet, to try and trace this logic or to dwell, in these notes, on the nature and direction of my earlier work, especially, he wrote, as I have always held that any new work worth its salt should be essentially different from all that has gone before, all that others have done and all that you have done, just as the deeds of each new day must never simply repeat those of the previous day or days. 
 Nevertheless, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), I think that this needs saying, quite calmly and objectively, in this commentary, which will not spare me when I have done badly or in the wrong spirit or left half-done, but will not either, in a spirit of false modesty, gloss over those things in my life and work which have been a success, even, mildly, a triumph. 
 And by this stage in this commentary, he wrote, there is no need to qualify the words success , triumph , and the rest, qualifications can be taken as read. 
 Besides, he wrote, now that I am at last working on the big glass and have set up the two panels and locked them into their metal frame, notions like success  and failure  are no longer pertinent, there is only the project  and its outcome , project , scribbled Goldberg in the margin, outcome , and words like success  and failure  can safely be left to others, wrote Harsnet. 
 But that is not quite right either, he wrote. 
 The fact is that the project itself will call into question the notion of success  and failure , my theme in the big glass, he wrote, is, after all, the calling into question of such terms as success  and failure , the calling into question of such notions as project  and even work . 
 The big glass and the notes for the big glass, he wrote, not the big glass by itself and the notes by themselves, the big glass and  the notes for the big glass, the notes for the big glass and  the big glass, he wrote, never the one alone or the other alone, for neither by itself has any meaning, neither by itself will have any force, but always both together, not as text  and gloss , not as image  and caption , but always as exchange  and delay , mirror  and reflection . 
 The temptation of magic and mystery, he wrote. 
 How often this century. 
 Dali, he wrote. 
 Roussel. 
 Pessoa. 
 But Dada opposite error. 
 Anarchy no answer. 
 Lucidity , he wrote. 
  Always lucidity . 
 Even in the dissection  of lucidity . 
 Even in the undermining  of lucidity . 
 As in my little essay, The Death of Images . 
 As in all I have ever attempted. 
 That is why it is important to work at night, he wrote. 
 Not to be warmed by the sun. 
 Cold light of the fluorescent tube. 
 No way of escape. 
 Alone with the glass under the cold light. 
 No thoughts. 
 No feelings. 
 No painterly skills. 
 The hand moves. 
 The eye measures. 
 The hand picks up. 
 Places. 
 Basta. 
 That is the point of the glass, he wrote. 
 Not a surface  to be covered . 
 Not an object  to be made . 
 Not a picture of , he wrote, and not the thing itself . 
 Shadow  and projection , he wrote. 
 Present  and absent  at the same time. 
 Existent  and non-existent . 
 A shadow has to be cast by something, he wrote. 
 Every shadow implies an object and a source of light. 
 On the glass the shadow, but shadow of what? 
 What will the viewer see? he wrote. 
 Something on the glass. 
 And the glass. 
 And something through the glass. 
 The wall of the gallery, the other exhibits hanging on it. 
 People moving, standing, leaning forward. 
 And his reflection. 
 Himself bending forward and looking. 
 Looking at. 
 Looking through. 
 Looking back at himself looking. 
 Shadow of what ? wrote Goldberg in the margin, cursing under his breath as his elbow dislodged the pile of typewritten sheets stacked on the desk beside the typewriter, tapping them back to neatness, wiping his brow with his sleeve, typing on. 
 The assembled elements of the glass, he typed (as Harsnet had written). 
 Bride above, bachelors below, cooler between them. 
 Condemned never to meet. 
 The gaze of the bachelors, wrote Harsnet. 
 It strips her bare. 
 She solicits the gaze, he wrote. 
 And it leads to her flowering, to her escape from her condition. 
 Glass as shadow of fourth dimension he wrote Patience, he wrote Do not run ahead of yourself. 
 Do not substitute the idea for the object .  
 But do not fetishize the object either.  
 Glass and  box, he wrote.  
 Box and  glass.  
 Leave explanations to Goldberg, he wrote.  
 To Honeyman and McGough.  
 To Goldman and Golding.  
 To Pizzetti and Baiocchi.  
 To Moss and McGrindle.  
 Of course, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), there may be nothing to leave,  nothing to explain, nothing to understand, even though I have prepared long enough and only started when the time was ripe, even though I began full of confidence and managed to persuade myself, for a while, that I was well under way.  
 But the fact of the matter is, he wrote, that none of it is right, or rather, that what has so far been accomplished is wrong and what has not yet been accomplished is only right because it has not yet had the chance to be proved wrong.  
 1 lb. tomatoes, he wrote, 1 cauliflower, 2 packs date biscuits, 1 pack butter, 1 lemon, 3 tins sardines, 1 tin tuna.  
 Days getting perceptibly shorter, he wrote, nights colder.  
 To clear the mind, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), to reach the peak, one last effort for one last time, one supreme effort, total concentration, and then the end.  
 Maximum clarity, he wrote, for as long as it takes.  
 Total elimination of all that is irrelevant, he wrote.  
 Keep shit at bay, keep warmth at bay, those maggots of feeling, breeding in the shit, sooner or later it gets to them all, even Hilda, love at last, her very words, who would have thought it.  
 Goldberg I had known it would attack, he wrote, and sooner rather than later, the soil was ripe for the sprouting of concern, refugees, famine, the bomb, you only had to look at him, sentiment inevitable, despite my efforts, despite my scorn.  
 But Hilda, wrote Harsnet, a major disappointment.  
 Love at last, so she said.  
 At last?  
 I said.  
 At last?  
 In the case of Goldberg, he wrote, unfortunate upbringing accounts for much.  
 But no excuse for Hilda.  
 I realized I had not been fair to myself.  
 I realized I had not properly understood my own needs.  
 I couldn't believe my ears but she repeated it: I realized I had not properly understood my own needs.  
 The words of my sister, wrote Harsnet, a major disappointment.  
 After that, what was there to say?  
 After that, after those words, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg typed), what possible relationship could exist between us?  
 The comfort of having the big glass here at last, he wrote, of living in the shadow of its coldness, its emptiness.  
 No Hildas.  
 No Goldbergs.  
 No words.  
 Just the glass.  
 Cold to the touch.  
 Cold to look at.  
 Peace.  
 First the glass, he wrote, and then the show and finally the end.  
  Not forgetting the notes in the blue box, he wrote, number the slips perhaps or leave unnumbered, each slip to record date and place of purchase of one element of the glass, size and shape and substance before incorporation, brief history of its purchase, tube ticket, bus ticket, receipt, weather on day of purchase and weather on day of incorporation, temperature on day of purchase and temperature on day of incorporation, 1 tin peaches, bread, marmite (small), remember laundry, one day like any other (and Goldberg, pausing in his typing, picked up his pen and put a small question mark in the margin of his typescript and then carried on), now winter has come, but every night like every other, walking round the glass under the cold light, measuring the glass, preparing the glass.  
 Time will only enter where I want it, wrote Harsnet.  
 An artefact is lost in its timelessness, he wrote.  
 The pretence  that this is not so is what makes me sick, he wrote, when I look at the works of the past.  
 The pretence that it exists in your time and my time.  
 If the glass has any virtue at all, he wrote, it is that it refuses to pretend . 
 If it has to tell a story, he wrote, it will be the story of the machine inside the ghost, of the ghost animated by the machine. 
 And us? he wrote. 
 Desiring machines. 
 Nothing more, nothing less. 
 Thus glass perhaps not too far from old realism. 
 Female suspended in non-space in top panel, he wrote. 
 Bachelors strung together like pegs on a line on lower panel. 
 They can never touch, he wrote, yet act upon each other from their separate worlds. 
 The machine does not  function, he wrote. 
 The desired outcome is delayed . 
 Does that mean that one day it will happen? 
 Or is the delay perpetual ? 
 And yet, he wrote, the impact of the whole must be that of a storm. 
 A hurricane. 
 Storm , scribbled Goldberg in the margin. 
 Hurricane . 
 The time for gentle breezes is over, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg typed), the time for the oohs and ahs, for the oh so beautiful and the ah so expressive, for the deep humanity and the flesh-coloured tints, for the sensitive and the profound, for the exquisite and the brilliant. 
 Nothing but a hurricane will do now, he wrote. 
 It must be impossible to stand up against it, he wrote, impossible to  draw breath before it. 
 It must knock your legs from under you, pound the breath from your body. 
 No more learned monographs from Sweeney and McGough, he wrote, from Pizzetti and Baiocchi, from Goldman and Golding, from Rosenblum and Honeyman. 
 No more notes, he wrote, no more queries, no more space in the work of X and time in the work of Y, no more symbolism, no more allegory, no more influence of X and legacy of Y, no more background and no more foreground, no more social this and political that, no more Heidegger and no more Heisenberg, no more still life and no more portraiture, no more collage and no more frottage, no more lines and no more surfaces, no more genius and no more talent, no more creation and no more mechanical reproduction, no more African masks and no more Cycladic figures, no more clowns and no more nudes, no more museums, no more galleries, no more group shows, no more one-man shows, no more public commissions, no more prizes, no more shit and no more vomit. 
 It is not, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), that I am under any illusion on this score. 
 There will of course always be critics and there will always be oohs and ahs, there will always be shit and there will always be vomit. 
 I exaggerate, he wrote. 
 There will not always be critics and the rest, just as there will not always be man and the rest. 
 But they will be there for long enough, long enough. 
 I am under no illusion on that score, he wrote, I am under no illusion that the big glass will in an instant blow all that away, flatten the critics against the walls, tear paintings from their places, bring the galleries tumbling to the ground. 
 Nor am I under the illusion that I alone am free of illusion. 
 But that is the effect , he wrote, that is the effect I am aiming at. 
 Cold cold cold but with the impact of a hurricane. 
 That is the effect. 
 First the making of the glass, he wrote, then the showing of the glass, and finally the end. 
 Leave this notebook in the safe keeping of Goldberg? he wrote. 
 Or destroy? 
 See how it goes, he wrote. 
 I am under no illusion as to effect, he wrote. 
 But the aim must be high, extreme. 
 Infinite slimness, he wrote. 
 Picture as infinite slimness. 
 Not so glass. 
 For glass no longer surface  of infinite slimness but shadow of fourth dimension, seen by us as three, reproduced as two. 
 Shadow of another world, he wrote, and Goldberg, picking up his pen, wiping his forehead, wrote in the margin, infinite slimness, fourth dimension . 
 2 packs date biscuits, wrote Harsnet, 2 avocados, 1 cauliflower, 6 eggs (fr.r.), 
 1 lb. onions, 1 lettuce (cos), 1 bag oranges, 1 Pack sugar, 1 pack salt. 
 Projection of another dimension or dimensions as when the sun breaks through a cloud and washing-up powder, launderette, what else was Jacob's ladder? he wrote, and Goldberg, staring at his friend's manuscript all those years later, typed that in and put a little question mark in the margin of his typescript. 
 Before 1500 possible to put ladder into image, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), no longer so now. 
 Shadow of ladder yes, ladder no. 
 Dali's error. 
 Why he remains a mere titillator. 
 Magritte closer but still too clever. 
 Subject too important for tricks. 
 Magritte like man who learns to somersault backwards from standing position and keeps on doing it. 
 You begin by admiring but it soon grows boring. 
 So Harsnet. 
 And Goldberg, pushing the sweat out of his eyes with the sleeve of his pullover, grabbed the pen and put another question mark in the margin by the whole passage. 
 Magritte, like Dali, wants you to admire him, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg, laying the pen aside, began to type again). 
 Nobody to be admired when big glass shown, he wrote. 
 Not admiration but anxiety, wonder, disgust, terror. 
 Shadow of Other, he wrote, reflection of spectator, window onto room behind. 
 On the glass or in the glass? he wrote. 
 You lean forward to see more clearly and see only your own reflection. 
 Come too close and you lose it altogether. 
 As for Diana, the arrival of Actaeon in the cave the beginning of the end. 
 All Metamorphosis  about Narcissus, he wrote. 
 Ovid by the Black Sea, cut off from native speech, he wrote. 
 Mind of Antaeus remains unchanged , he wrote. 
 That is the horror. 
 Mens tantum pristina mansit . 
 And Goldberg, pushing back his chair, stepping over the piles of papers and magazines littering the floor of his study, scanned the bookcase, found what he wanted, brought the book back to his  desk, licked his middle finger and turned the pages, found the passage and copied carefully into the margin: only his mind remains unchanged . 
 The whole world changes but your mind does not, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg typed). 
 Kafka's Metam , he wrote, The Death of Ivan Ilych . 
 Metam as delay, he wrote. 
 The beauty of glass, he wrote. 
 You are forced to ask: Do I stop here or do I go on through? 
 Christ as mediator in older art, he wrote. 
 Romantic desire for unmediated  world. 
 Anxiety of Friedrich leads to anxiety of Schoenberg, anxiety of Wordsworth leads to anxiety of Stevens. 
 Eradicate anxiety, he wrote, and Goldberg, in the margin, anxiety . 
 Eradicate anxiety in the image , wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg typed), for that leads to contentment in the spectator. 
 Substitute anxiety in the spectator , he wrote, brought about by nothing other than the apparent lack of anxiety  in the image. 
 In an anxious world serenity as cause of heightened anxiety, he wrote, and Goldberg, seizing his felt-tip pen, bent over the typewriter and wrote in the margin anxiety? serenity ? 
 Anxiety will get you nowhere, wrote Harsnet. 
 Anxiety no guarantee of authenticity. 
 The right conditions for serenity, he wrote. 
 Laundry! he wrote in the margin of his page, and Goldberg, alter a moment's hesitation, typed it in and added, in brackets, margin ! 
 Romanticism, he wrote, not a wet Romanticism. 
 Wet R as (half-hearted) belief that energy equals salvation, he wrote. 
 There is no answer, he wrote, because there is no question. 
 No answer , scribbled Goldberg in the margin of his typescript, because no question . 
 He dropped the pen and went on typing. 
 Dada as despair, he typed. 
 So Swiss. 
 So Protestant. 
 Despair as despair at lack of salvation, wrote Harsnet. 
 But salvation from what? 
 What we have is all  we have, he wrote. 
 Why this need to nudge the world into being other than it is? he wrote. 
 Goldberg and his books. 
 Hilda and her lovers. 
 Always the same old story. 
 You inhabit a world without hope, she says to me. 
 Such coldness, she says. 
 I shiver in your presence. 
 Such heat, I tell her. 
 I watch you fizzle and burn. 
 Fire, she tells me, has always been a source of goodness. 
 Think of a piece of paper, I tell  her. 
 Watch it burn and smoulder, crinkle and turn to ashes, leaving nothing but a stink behind. 
 To think that the selfsame parents could have given birth to the two of us, she says. 
 Self-same! 
 Who says self-same any more? 
 Help me, she says. 
 I'm so unhappy. 
 And Goldberg too: Help me, I'm so unhappy. 
 What do they want me to do? 
 Blow their noses for them? 
 And why me? 
 Why me? 
 Distinguish between energy and passion, he wrote. 
 Do not be taken in by current usage. 
 Clarify, he wrote. 
 Clarify, clarify. 
 Do not stop. 
 What looks like a dead end may only be the result of personal weakness. 
 The bachelors, he wrote. 
 Policeman, judge, delivery boy, priest, referee, commissionaire. 
 The uniform is  the man, he wrote. 
 Uniform as sign of virile youth, he wrote. 
 Women and uniforms, he wrote. 
 Anna and Vronsky. 
 Bachelor society. 
 Rites of passage. 
 Man with dog at launderette, he wrote. 
 How dog leapt onto one of the machines and curled up there. 
 Nippy little feller, man said. 
 I agreed. 
 He offered me a cigarette. 
 I declined. 
 Won't let me out of his sight for a minute, he said. 
 Not since the missus died. 
 I helped him fold his sheets. 
 He let them trail on the ground. 
 Filth at the edges. 
 He didn't notice. 
 Dog waited till we were done, then jumped off. 
 C'mon you, he said, and held the door open for him. 
 Dog at his heels as he went off down the road. 
 Diana, he wrote (and Goldberg typed). 
 Melampus. 
 Ichnobates. 
 Pamphagus. 
 The wooded vale. 
 The spring. 
 The cave. 
 Right hand side still too empty, he wrote. 
 The mechanical Diana, he wrote. 
 Difficulty of devising a structure that will stand firm yet will not be over-heavy, he wrote. 
 Difficulty of welding glass to metal frame. 
 Calamity if glass breaks. 
 And if it topples over it certainly will. 
 Last ten days trying to devise way to stabilize frame, he wrote. 
 Always a solution, only a question of finding it, he wrote. 
 Hadn't reckoned with weight of glass in my calculations. 
 Check Higinbothams, he wrote. 
 Last night almost a disaster, he wrote. 
 Difficult to stay calm, he wrote. 
 With panels of glass this size in such a small room bound to be problems. 
 Yet I like it like that. 
 I like the sense of its filling the room and yet also, in a way, of its being non-  existent. 
 I have always liked to work in a simple room, he wrote. 
 A natural part of a house. 
 No fuss. 
 Bare boards. 
 Bare walls. 
 Naked bulb or neon lighting. 
 Studios for the Production of art-crap, he wrote. 
 Studios nothing but shit-houses. 
 I have never been in the business of producing art-crap, he wrote. 
 Except perhaps at the start. 
 No excuse then except age. 
 And the fact that I soon got away from it. 
 No virtue attached to that though. 
 Simply the sense of physical disgust which filled me whenever I took up a brush and dipped it in paint. 
 So strong that merely stopping was no solution. 
 Desire to make, he wrote, but physical revulsion at the falsity of all making. 
 Had to satisfy that desire, he wrote, yet find a way of doing so that would not have that physical effect on me. 
 The history of art, he wrote, is the history of dead-ends transformed into springboards. 
 What's the matter with me? wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg). 
 What am I doing pontificating about art and history? 
 That too is crap, he wrote, though harmless crap. 
 Yet who would have thought I would talk to myself in this way in these notes? he wrote. 
 Is it because the right hand side is going so badly? 
 Too much there or too little? 
 Something is missing, he wrote. 
 I need to introduce a different dimension and I am at a loss. 
 Have been for over a week. 
 Rang Danny and he said to come round. 
 Good game, usual outcome. 
 Beat back a pawn storm on Queen side and eventually turned it round. 
 His attacks always violent but uncoordinated. 
 Contrived elegant check on the hour. 
 But it did nothing for the glass. 
 Same Problem, same lack of ideas. 
 Boiled cauliflower. 
 Struck as always by its resemblance to human brain. 
 Very tasty as salad, lemon dressing. 
 The joys of false analogies, he wrote. 
 Of the almost precise correspondences. 
 Jake. 
 And how upset they were when he took off his hat and smiled. 
 A very pleasing day. 
 And Goldberg, pushing the typewriter to one side, seized his pen and pad and wrote: Jake. 
 What happened was this. 
 Harsnet was due to get married. 
 The date was fixed. 
 I was best man. 
 All waited in registry office. 
 Where was H? 
 Eventually he arrived, with minutes to spare, wearing a ridiculous sort of check hat. 
 Nobody said any-  thing. 
 Then, just before stepping up to sign the register, he took off his hat. 
 His hair was bright red instead of H's black. 
 We all looked again and it wasn't H. The bastard had met this Jake a year or two back and at once noted the resemblance. 
 Kept in touch with him, waiting for the right occasion to use him. 
 He was quite frank about the whole thing, told us H. had given him a fiver to turn up, asked Madge if she wanted to go through with it, which of course she didn't. 
 Her father furious. 
 Herself in tears. 
 When I got back home there was H., in the living-room, pleased as Punch. 
 Write up? wrote Goldberg. 
 Appendix? 
 Or note at foot of page? 
 He pushed the pad aside, drew the typewriter towards him and began to type again, squinting down at his friend s tiny handwriting. 
 I hear about these artists, so-called, he typed (as Harsnet had written), who work all day and all night, whose work is their passion. 
 Paint all over their clothes, all over the studio, external mark of intrinsic worth. 
 I sometimes feel sorry, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), that I am not of their kind. 
 That I grow bored after an hour or two. 
 That I can do most of my work in my suit without getting dirty. 
 If they are looking for salvation, he wrote, they will find it. 
 How easy to rest in the bosom of the Lord, he wrote. 
 Worthy men, he wrote, full of the mystery and importance of their Calling. 
 On the other hand, he wrote, there are people like Goldberg, like Moss and McGrindle, who believe in nothing, except perhaps in personal power and glory, though they would like to believe in something &bquo;higher&equo;. 
 I frankly do not know which I prefer, wrote Harsnet. 
 Sometimes I think the latter, sometimes the former. 
 Do I have to choose between goat's cheese and chocolate cake? as Queneau used to ask. 
 It is the right hand side on both panels that is worrying me, he wrote. 
 Nothing has gone right on that side from the moment I began. 
 I need to move slowly across from the left and see where things start to go wrong, he wrote. 
 Except that I cannot work like that. 
 I have made my plans and I must stick to them. 
 Even in the plan, though, I now realize, he wrote, there was a certain vagueness about the right hand side of both panels. 
  Perhaps because in painting as in writing we start from top left hand side, so that the right is always  less clear. 
 Interesting to examine the old masters from that point of view, he wrote. 
 However, he wrote, for that very reason, the right hand side should have been even more  solid, even more  thought through than the left. 
 But there it is, he wrote. 
 The plans are made, work has begun, there is no going back. 
 Work as the fancy takes me, he wrote. 
 A little bit here, a little bit there. 
 Wherever there is interest on the day in question. 
 The absurd idea, he wrote, that a work of art grows from nothing into something, from acorn into oak. 
 Fostered by illusion of paint, which spreads out over the surface. 
 I want to pick up and put down, he wrote, not spread out in gooey mass. 
 Simple elements, he wrote, complex whole. 
 Infinitely simple elements, infinitely complex whole. 
 Yet retain even in final product sense of simplicity of elements, of possibility of dismantling. 
 Penny my heroine, he wrote. 
 Weave through the day, unweave at night. 
 Give each viewer the chance to do just that. 
 Each element, he wrote, must be honest , and Goldberg, in the margin, each element: honest . 
 He pulled the notebook towards him and wrote: Check early drypoint, Heroin for a Penny , refs. 
 Penelope. 
 He pushed the pad aside, took a sip of orange juice, wiped his forehead, and went on typing. 
 No element, he typed (as Harsnet had written) should ever pretend to be more or less than itself. 
 No mystery, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), no magic. 
 Big glass like big engine. 
 You will enter my machine, he wrote, and the trip will consist in the discovery that we cannot even get started . 
 Desire alone never enough to get machine started, he wrote. 
 Desire never enough to confer meaning where there was none, to transform simple elements into work of art. 
 Into Work of Art. 
 Desire , scribbled Goldberg in the margin. 
 Machine . 
 Remember All-Bran, wrote Harsnet, remember milk. 
 And Goldberg, pulling the pad towards him and seizing his felt-tip pen, began to write. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, you may keep your door closed and not answer when I ring the bell, you may refuse to answer my letters or return my calls when I leave a message  on your answering machine, but sooner or later we are bound to meet and this time I will not let you fob me off with a smile. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, you have been seen doing circuit training with Korchnoi and the Brighton and Hove Albion football team. 
 If I am to do what you asked, he wrote, you will have to co-operate. 
 We will have to meet and discuss some of the problems. 
 He pushed the pad aside and began to type again. 
 There are those who imagine, he typed (as Harsnet had written), that because they know the machine will not start they can afford to ignore it. 
 But what if the motorless machine is what it is all about? 
 Goldberg, pushing back the typewriter and drawing the pad towards him, began again. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, you may be amused to hear that one of my sons spotted you the other day training with Korchnoi and the Brighton and Hove Albion football team. 
 We all knew of your friendship with Korchnoi, he wrote, how could we not, the papers have been so full of it. 
 We have also followed his preparations for the world title bout with Karpov, some of us, it must be confessed, with a certain amount of incredulity, since, however much these world championship matches are now dependent on stamina rather than brilliance, it has struck more than a few people that a chess player is not a footballer, in particular a fifty-year-old self-exiled Russian Grandmaster is not a footballer, and that to think that by training like one he will become as fit is not only an illusion, it is a dangerous illusion. 
 Besides, wrote Goldberg, you have only to see where Brighton are placed in the League to wonder at the wisdom of associating with them in any capacity. 
 Even so, he wrote, what might, &agrave; la rigueur , be acceptable for a Russian Grandmaster seems merely perverse in a retired artist. 
 However, wrote Goldberg, turning the page and tearing it slightly in his eagerness to go on, my son is rather short-sighted, something he has inherited from his mother, and recently, during a school trip to Dieppe, he dropped his glasses and cracked one of the lenses. 
 He is also prone to jump to conclusions. 
 So it may not, after all, have been you he saw. 
 In which case forgive me for writing as I have  done. 
 He pushed the pad aside, took out his handkerchief and wiped his face, stuffed the handkerchief back in his pocket and began to type again. 
 Desire, he typed (as Harsnet had written), a most boring subject. 
 Yet, wrote Harsnet, I keep coming back to it. 
 The question, he wrote, is how to make desire interesting. 
 Even amusing. 
 If my lady can be said to be amusing. 
 For more and more she is coming to resemble a mechanical praying mantis, frozen there in the glass, he wrote. 
 Colour not yet quite right, he wrote. 
 Need more silver, more white. 
 But something is happening in that upper panel. 
 More than can be said for the lower one, he wrote. 
 Though distinctions between the two growing more apparent. 
 precise definition, clear articulation, accurate perspective below, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), fluidity, flatness, cloudiness above. 
 The big glass as the end of art, he wrote. 
 No point in not being ambitious. 
 Though ambition has been the grave of many minor artists, it is also that without which no artist can be called major &mdash; with all the provisos about art, artists, major, minor, already touched on. 
 There is a point in everyone's life, he wrote, when all caution must, as they say, be thrown to the winds, all doubts stilled, when the most extreme risks have to be taken. 
 It is the moment, he wrote, when a man suddenly realizes that there is no tomorrow , no second chance , only today, this chance, now. 
 Is this the moment of truth , he wrote, or the greatest temptation?  
 I have been preparing myself for this for the whole of my life, he wrote.  
 I can say without embarrassment that I have been training  for this for a long time, that I have learned to breathe the rarefied air , that I now know when to stand still  and when to move forward , when to attack  and when to retreat , when to leave a problem to resolve itself  and when to go on working at it  till the solution  emerges.  
 I have learned to keep going , wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), even when the voices scream at me to stop, to lie down, to turn to something else.  
 Blake, he wrote, If a fool persist in his folly, etc.  
 I have also learned, he wrote, to heed the voices when necessary.  
 Though it is never possible to be sure one is doing the right thing, he wrote.  
 There  are always moments of doubt .  
 After the initial impetus has run out, he wrote, and before one has got in so far that it is easier to finish than to go back, it is then that it becomes hard to be sure of your footing , hard to know why you are doing what you are doing, hard to know if you are doing correctly what you are doing.  
 That is why so few books on the middle game, he wrote, though plenty on openings and endgames.  
 None of that would of course be comprehensible to Moss and McGrindle, he wrote, to Pizzetti and Baiocchi, to Goldman and Goldstein, though Goldberg, to his credit, has had an inkling, has to some extent faced the thought that he might be wasting his whole life , for that's what it comes down to in the end, he wrote, wasting a whole life when something useful might have been salvaged, something valuable perhaps, it is the refusal of those alternatives that occasionally makes one shiver.  
 One? wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg).  
 The darkness?  
 Well well well, he wrote.  
 Do not retreat into irony, he wrote.  
 One last thought on the subject and then basta: they &mdash; Moss and McGrindle, etc.  
 &mdash; imagine that something drives one on, a clear vision, that one knows  what one is doing.  
 The difficulty is that it does not, one does not &mdash; not in one's art, not in one's life.  
 Yet one grows restless doing nothing.  
 Scratching one's balls.  
 So where does the desire to be up and doing come from?  
 Too complicated, he wrote.  
 All there in the big glass anyway, let others tease it out.  
 Keep going, he wrote.  
 Buy shirt.  
 Bulb.  
 Establish rhythm.  
 The density of the glass, he wrote.  
 The intractability of the glass.  
 Have to get to grips with what this does to the image.  
 Its refusal to respond , as canvas and paper respond.  
 Tried projecting negative of Bride from holograph enlarger, he wrote, but image thin and weak where I want it strong (though indeterminate).  
 Near asphyxiation last night, he wrote.  
 Acid.  
 Try fuse wire.  
 I sometimes think, he wrote, that if in one sense I am back in the nursery trying to make a big toy with nothing but wood and string, in another I am back in the classroom fiddling with bunsen burners while Mr Alexander walks round sniffing with his long distinguished nose in the air.  
 And playing in the mud,  kicking a ball, he wrote.  
 What greater happiness than that?  
 It is a matter of finding out how to adapt, he wrote.  
 How to keep doing what one enjoyed doing as a child but adapting it to the changing circumstances.  
 Bless relaxes, he wrote, roll down the socks.  
 Paz visit yesterday, dinner McVittie's, wrote Harsnet.  
 Excellent meal.  
 Gave me first edition of Alekhine's Best Games  picked up in Delhi.  
 In his usual fine form, doing 1003 things.  
 Invited me to his reading tomorrow, I drew the line at that.  
 We walked till 3 a.m., Embankment, West End, Soho, he talked of India, temple sculpture, smell, then of Breton, L&eacute;vi-Strauss, Soupault, interconnection between Surrealism and ethnography in France between the wars, Mexico, death, Leiris, Roussel, etc.  
 After India, Poland, Munich, quick trip to Milan to see Berio and Eco, Paris, Queneau unwell, Butor planning book on Diabelli Variations, that man is an interpretative machine, Paz said, whatever you feed him he devours in a few months and a year later out comes a book.  
 Always a masterpiece of criticism, empathy.  
 A mind that can turn faster and keep going longer than that of anyone I know, so Paz, wrote Harsnet.  
 He is in a class by himself, Paz said.  
 The rest of us are running a different race &mdash; by choice perhaps.  
 In Munich, Paolozzi, more like a Minotaur than ever, obsessed now with plaster casts.  
 Also Beuys, passing through, hat and horse, quite mad.  
 He sent me a card, Paz said, just one line, Did Dada do dis or did e do dat?  
 I wrote back, Paz said, I told him, Dada dead as dodo eat your hat.  
 He hadn't, Paz said.  
 Not when I saw him.  
 It was still on his head.  
 I told him, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg) it was people like him who kept the idea of art going, kept the opera houses of the world open, kept the bookshops of the world open, they ought to take you out and shoot you, I said to him.  
 They tried, he said.  
 If you came from Mexico, he said, you would give up this shallow cynicism and understand just how important it is to keep the bookshops open, to keep the galleries open, even to keep the opera houses open.  
 The trouble with you is, he said, that you've grown fat in your little cocoon here in London, cut off from the realities of  the world.  
 He knows I never argue, so he left off and praised the food.  
 We finished up on the track.  
 At least the telly hasn't yet cottoned on to the dogs, I told him, but he said in Mexico it had.  
 Backed Tiny Thomas and took home &pound;4.  
 Did you know, Paz asked me, that Thomas Aquinas was only four foot ten?  
 I didn't.  
 His collected works, he said, probably fill four foot ten of shelf space.  
 All written by hand by candlelight.  
 We embraced.  
 When I got back I sat in front of the big glass with the door shut and the lights off, till dawn.  
 Something missing lower right hand side.  
 Keyhole to peep through?  
 But what if glass breaks as I make it?  
 Paint hole on glass and charge to see through?  
 Here Prospero discovers Ferdinand and Miranda playing at chess.  
 A most high miracle.  
 A magic peep-hole, wrote Harsnet. pay extra and you may see Ferdinand and Miranda playing at chess.  
 Or you may see exactly what you would see by looking through the glass at any point.  
 No, he wrote.  
 Escape from myth.  
 Escape from the literary.  
 Big glass as machine for shredding myths.  
 The Shredder of Myths or Delay in Glass.  
 And Goldberg, in the margin: The Shredder of Myths or Delay in Glass .  
 It is growing tedious, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg).  
 I am growing tired of it, he wrote.  
 That is how Autumn affects me.  
 The burning of the leaves.  
 The shortening of the days.  
 My ideal home, he wrote: no trees, no sky with fleeting clouds.  
 Underground car-park perhaps?  
 The car-park as the death of nostalgia, he wrote.  
 We will not have got rid of nostalgia, he wrote, till we have got rid of the sky.  
 Socks, he wrote.  
 Shirt.  
 6 eggs (fr. r.).  
 Cauliflower.  
 Bread.  
 1 pack butter.  
 Marmalade.  
 It is all a question, he wrote, of what we owe ourselves.  
 Do I owe it to myself to finish?  
 How deep is my boredom?  
 Is it stronger than my desire to complete what I have begun?  
 And if stronger does that mean truer?  
 What does true mean?  
 What does strong mean?  
 What is the real temptation, he wrote, to stop or to go on?  
 Show up the vagaries of causality, he wrote, the banalities of style.  
 Show up the folly of I feel this so I do that.  
 There is a story, he wrote, there is a story that is being told.  
 Somehow.  
 Somewhere.  
 Its shadow passes across the  glass.  
 The story of desire and its non-fulfilment.  
 Of the lack of relation between cause and effect.  
 Do not tell the story, he wrote.  
 Show the smile by which we respond to the story.  
 The Cheshire Cat.  
 More important even than Humpty Dumpty for understanding last hundred years, he wrote.  
 The Big Glass as Cheshire Cat.  
 That is only another way of saying Frozen Hurricane, he wrote.  
 Sense that this is now or never time, he wrote.  
 And yet, if I fail, it is only a failure.  
 Only? he wrote.  
 Only?  
 In other words, he wrote, am I right or wrong to see this as decisive?  
 Is that an insight into how things really are, or only one more passing thought?  
 My plans have been well laid, he wrote.  
 The project is well under way.  
 There is no reason to fail.  
 Sitting with the curtains open and the moon shining in on the barely begun big glass, he wrote, sitting keeping vigil with it all night after my walk with Paz, I was afraid.  
 Partly a question of its size, of the intractability of the glass, of its icy self-containment.  
 Sense of my own helplessness in relation to it, he wrote.  
 Also, he wrote, it repels me.  
 It not only frightens me, it repels me.  
 Cold glass and cold metal frame filling that room.  
 I did not know what to do with it, why I was there.  
 I felt it annihilating me.  
 I felt its coldness spreading through my body, killing off the cells, one by one.  
 And yet, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), I also knew that it was this cold that drew me, this steady destruction of body and imagination, this utter alienness, as though only that could still excite me, as though anything less alien  would only leave me indifferent .  
 Not easy though, he wrote, to submit oneself to it, to enter its orbit.  
 Always the danger of the cold spreading too fast, of my not being able to live with it.  
 And then, he wrote, there is the question of why that dread should also be a source of excitement.  
 Is it because one does not turn to art for comfort?  
 For safety?  
 Because if you want comfort and safety you keep well away from art?  
 From real art?  
 You only turn to it as people climb mountains and cross deserts &mdash; to find out what you are made of by doing what you hardly dare to do.  
 But is that an answer?  
 And what kind of answer is it?  
 A long night, he  wrote.  
 I got up occasionally and touched the cold glass.  
 Touched the metal frame.  
 Leaned my forehead against it.  
 Then returned to my chair.  
 Moonlight, he wrote.  
 Bare boards.  
 Glass gleaming.  
 I kept my eyes on it the whole time, he wrote.  
 Nothing visible on its surface, only the cold gleam.  
 As if all the work of the past four months had only been a dream, the cutting and the drilling, the painting, the moulding of the lead wire.  
 All a dream and the glass was as smooth and blank as when I first installed it.  
 Like cutting into the surface of a pond, I thought, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), like pressing paint onto the surface of a pond, with total concentration and total folly.  
 That is perhaps the point of the big glass, wrote Harsnet.  
 That it is like the mind itself.  
 Work on it is like a dream, or like thoughts of what a work would be like.  
 Yet at the same time there is  work done upon it, he wrote, and which remains, as it does not in the mind.  
 Yet it was as though that night, in the moonlight, in the silence, as though even the work, the months of steady labour, had only been an illusion, only the dream of work, the dream of progress, and I had not even begun and never would begin, though at different moments in my life I might have had the illusion that I had begun and even, perhaps, finished.  
 And yet, wrote Harsnet, it is this which excites me, this which makes me want to go on.  
 As if my whole life, he wrote, had been spent working at the glass and at the same time had been spent doing nothing at all.  
 As if even my memories of work on the glass were not memories but fantasies and fancies.  
 They say that at the moment of death the whole of one's past life flashes before one's eyes.  
 I doubt it.  
 But what if at the moment of birth the whole of one's life to come were to flash before one's eyes and then to be immediately wiped away, forgotten, while we laboriously go through all the pleasures and sorrows, all the hopes and frustrations that make up a life, meeting people and parting from them, listening to them and speaking to them, to go through tasting all we taste in the course of our long lives, seeing all we see, every leaf at every moment and every cloud at every moment, and hearing  all we hear, the hooting of every car and the singing of every bird and every performance of the Brandenburg concertos, go through all that, in time, very slowly, though we had already been through it all, every moment of it, leaf, cloud, concerto, in one brief but intense instant, everything perfectly formed but over in less than a second?  
 And the reverse of that, wrote Harsnet, the feeling that all we have already felt and seen and heard has yet to happen, is so far only a dream, a fantasy, and the sense, he wrote, that this may be a feeling we experience again and again throughout our lives, that the elements of experience have failed to catch on to the glass of our lives, or that the glass is there and waiting for the experience to be registered, that it can wait for ever, for it does not know the meaning of time.  
 All that and more went through my mind, wrote Harsnet, as I sat there in the moonlight in the silence, but it was as if it was the glass which was telling me this, that the glass was my mind as I thought that, or my mind the glass, and that was the reason for the fear and the cold and also for the sense of growing excitement and a fear then, a different kind of fear, that I would not be able to do  anything with this excitement, that it would be my failure, my failure to realize what I now saw were the real possibilities of the glass, a failure for which I would never be able to forgive myself, though a part of me would always know or perhaps only believe that it was in the nature of my insight that there could be no realization of it, that it was precisely an insight about non-realization, but by then, wrote Harsnet, it had all become too complicated, too extreme, I did not want to know any of it until it was all over, until I had made my effort, perhaps it had been a mistake to come in and sit there with the glass through the night with the moon shining so brightly, it must have been full, or nearly full, unnaturally bright anyway, something to do with the solstice perhaps, to sit in the room with the glass alone or with the moon alone might have been bearable, in the dark with the glass or in the moonlight in an empty room, but the two together, the glass and the moon, that was perhaps the mistake.  
 I had gone too far and  experienced too much, I needed to slow down, to get back to the small things, the practical things, to measuring and cutting and fixing, and it was with relief that I noticed that daylight had begun to invade the room, I kept quite still, I held the glass firmly in my gaze, gradually the elements already worked on began to emerge, some more clearly than others, some in outline only and some only when they impeded the free flow of light through the glass, until the sun came up and was reflected back from the windows of the house opposite and I could sit and look at the glass and think back through the work and the mistakes and the few successes, and sense again with that sickening feeling in the pit of the stomach that the whole of the right hand side of the lower panel was still a mess, nothing there had been resolved, but then I drew back from that, though it kept trying to pull me back to itself, and concentrated on what was beginning to work, on the left hand areas both top and bottom and on the elegance of the frame and the joy of seeing the bare walls and the wainscoting appear through the empty areas, and as I moved round so different parts of the room appeared and the relation of the surface of the glass to what lay behind changed, precision and fluidity, precision and fluidity, he wrote, choice and chance, not choice alone and chance alone but the two together, that is why delay, not stoppage and not flow but delay, delay in glass, he wrote, as when the plane is late and you should have been gone, have already arrived perhaps, but you are still there, or the sprinter beats the gun and the whole field is called back, the race could have been over but it has not yet started.  
 Now I Joseph was walking, and I walked not.  
 And I looked up to the air and saw the air in amazement.  
 And I looked up unto the pole of the heaven and saw it standing still, and the fowls of the heavens without motion.  
 And I looked upon the earth and saw a dish set, and workmen lying by it, and their hands were in the dish: and they that were chewing chewed not, and they that were lifting the food lifted it not, and they that put it to their mouth put it not thereto, but the faces of all of them were looking  upward.  
 And behold there were sheep being driven, and they went not forward but stood still; and the shepherd lifted his hand to smite them with his staff, and his hand remained up.  
 And I looked upon the stream of the river and saw the mouths of the kids upon the water and they drank not.  
 And of a sudden all things moved onward in their course.  
 1 cauliflower, 1 lb. carrots, 1 lb. onions, 1 celery, 1 pepper, shoelaces, library, memo pad, string, matches, toy-shop.  
 The question that is never asked, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), is the one that concerns the quality of life.  
 What kind of life do you wish to lead?  
 Is food and comfort the be-all and end-all?  
 Why not if you no longer believe in God or even inspiration and genius?  
 If there is only the mechanical operation of the spirit?  
 Steam engines, he wrote.  
 Every little cog plays its part.  
 Every piston moves because every little cog plays its part.  
 Eventually, it drives its load forward.  
 But a work of art, so-called, is not a machine, he wrote.  
 It can get nowhere, it can move nothing.  
 From stimulation to ejaculation, he wrote.  
 From ejaculation to insemination.  
 But not in the so-called work of art.  
 From the sea to the cloud, he wrote.  
 From the cloud back to the land as rain.  
 But not in the so-called work of art.  
 Art is not a machine, he wrote, and it is not an organism.  
 It is a pseudo  &mdash;  machine, a pseudo  -organism. 
 The Bride, he wrote. 
 The Bachelors. 
 The Pulley. 
 The Cooler. 
 The Moulds. 
 The Scissors. 
 The Grinder. 
 The Gas. 
 The Waterfall. 
 The Mist. 
 The Sieves. 
 The Beginning of Exaltations and Beatifications, he wrote. 
 Being an Effective Spirit in the Beautiful West, he wrote. 
 Being in the Retinue of Osiris. 
 Being Satisfied with the Food of Wenhofer. 
 Delay as the function of art, he wrote. 
 Nothing happens in this work, he wrote, but what of the world? 
 Round and round. 
 Up and down and up again. 
 The last imitation, he wrote. 
 How many have thought that though? 
 That theirs would be the last, the true one, and after that there would be no need for more? 
 Folly, he wrote. 
 The folly of it. 
 There is no last word, he wrote, and Goldberg, seizing his felt-tip pen, wrote in the margin no last . 
 He licked the tip of the pen and added: word. 
 Folly  of last words as of first, wrote Harsnet. 
 Always in the middle, he wrote. 
 Never never never never never. 
 Yet each to be written and spoken as though the last. 
 Each picture painted ditto . 
 And what's one more or less? 
 Goldberg's face when I told him, he wrote. 
 Where? he kept asking, where? 
 I told him, Between junctions seventeen and eighteen. 
 But why? he kept asking. 
 Why? 
 I didn't see the point, I said. 
 You didn't what? he said. 
 Fat already then, twenty-two, twenty-three, five eight but over fifteen stone. 
 You didn't what? 
 Face white, jaws shaking: You didn't what? 
 It wasn't for you to see the point, he said. 
 It was my painting. 
 If that painting is lost, he said, I will never paint another, and you will be responsible. 
 I am responsible, I said. 
 That painting was mine, he said. 
 And the other was mine, I said. 
 I dumped them both. 
 I don't give two farts for yours, he said, but you have just dumped mine on a motorway layby. 
 My best picture, he said. 
 The only one I ever felt got near to saying what I wanted to say. 
 It might have won, I said, and you know what you think of prizes. 
 You prick, he said, I should never have let you take them up. 
 I trusted you, he said. 
 What did you do it for, you &mdash;? he said, bunching his right hand into a fist and pressing it in agony into his left palm. 
 Are you crazy or something? 
 I told you, I said to him, I suddenly didn't see any point in it. 
 I suddenly agreed with you about prizes and fame and the rest. 
 Suddenly. 
 Just like that. 
 There was no point in going on then. 
 Where? he said. 
 Show me where on the map. 
 I don't know where on the map, I said. 
 I told you, between junctions seventeen and eighteen. 
 Going up? he said. 
 Going up, I said. 
 I should never have trusted you with it, he said. 
 My best picture. 
 You didn't want to win their lousy prize, did you? 
 I said. 
 You did too, he said. 
 You must have. 
 You put in for it. 
 We both wanted to win, I said, and now we've been saved from temptation. 
 He tried to hit me, kept pummelling me with his podgy fists, but he couldn't summon up the necessary enthusiasm. 
 I'll have to get out and look for it, he said. 
 I kept quiet. 
 I'll phone the police, he said. 
 Someone may have picked them up. 
 Did you leave them there on the verge?  he asked me. 
 I told you, I said to him, I just pulled in and heaved them out. 
 Down a grassy slope. 
 You shit, he said. 
 You shit. 
 It didn't stop me going on, but it stopped him. 
 Your heart was never in it, I said to him later. 
 You ruined my life, he said. 
 One moment and my whole life was ruined. 
 But later still he admitted he'd had his doubts. 
 After his first TV series I said to him: Aren't you happier as a media critic, putting shitty artists in their places, than as a failed shitty artist being put in his place? 
 Happier? he said, his blue eyes fixed on my face in that mad way he sometimes has. 
 Do I look happier? he said. 
 Yes, I said. 
 More fulfilled. 
 I had a feeling it would be for the best, I said, when I stopped on the hard shoulder that day. 
 I didn't dump them straight away, you know, I said. 
 Though I had made up my mind. 
 I stopped the car and thought for a bit. 
 Then I opened the back door and out they went. 
 I will never forgive you as long as I live, he said. 
 But he was laughing. 
 Look me in the eye, I said. 
 Look me in the eye Goldberg and tell me whether that picture was any good. 
 What if it wasn't? he said. 
 Winning the John Moores would have given me just the confidence I needed. 
 I'd have got better. 
 You'd have got better anyway, I told him. 
 If you'd gone on. 
 But you didn't. 
 Goldberg, pushing the hair out of his eyes with his forearm, dragged the pad towards him and wrote: Appendix on the real facts? 
 Or let him damn himself with his own words? 
 In a hundred years' time, I said to him, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg, putting the pad aside, began to type again), in a hundred years' time I said to him, (he typed) no one will remember either you or me. 
 In ten years' time, I said to him, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), they may still remember us both. 
 But not in a hundred. 
 That's not the point, he said. 
 It wasn't your painting, it wasn't up to you to decide for me. 
 It was in my car, I said. 
 I just don't understand you, he said. 
 I suddenly decided I didn't see any point in submitting them, I said. 
 And they weren't worth transporting all the way back. 
 I didn't feel comfortable with them in there with me, I said. 
 Exuding hope. 
 Exuding hope? he said, as if he didn't understand English any more. 
 Well,  drove all the way up. 
 Must have stopped every ten yards between junctions seventeen and eighteen. 
 Not a trace of them. 
 It was raining by then anyway. 
 Wouldn't speak to me for six months, but then his natural goodness of heart, as well perhaps as his gradual realization that I might have been right, that perhaps I had saved him from a fate worse than death, made it impossible for him to keep it up. 
 When we met at the Bacon show and I smiled at him he smiled back at once, then remembered and tried to scowl, but couldn't and we both burst out laughing. 
 I have put away my brushes for ever, he said. 
 Meaningless words. 
 It's not the stopping or the burning or the escaping to Africa that will make an end of it. 
 It has to be there in the work. 
 The end has to be built in. 
 Otherwise as meaningless as any other gesture, as deeply rooted in the moment, in how one is feeling or what one has eaten or who one has been seeing. 
 And in that case, wrote Harsnet, there is always the possibility that it will not be the end but a simple pause, a mere hiatus. 
 Whereas I, wrote Harsnet, have become something of an expert on real endings, on true endings. 
 The real end must be like counting one then two then three. 
 No doubt about it. 
 One is unique, two is double, three is infinity. 
 No need to go on after three. 
 One the glass, two the show, three the end. 
 So Harsnet. 
 And Goldberg, pushing the hair out of his eyes and wiping his face at the same time with his sleeve, pushed away the typewriter, pulled the pad towards him, seized the felt-tip pen, and wrote: He later admitted that he had merely said between seventeen and eighteen as a manner of speaking. 
 He never looked at the exit numbers, he said later, but he was sure it was between two exits on the M6 to Liverpool, roughly between seventeen and eighteen. 
 He later said &mdash; Goldberg pushed the pad aside and returned to his task of transcription. 
 It becomes clear after one has been working at something for several weeks, he typed (as Harsnet had written), that one is not going to achieve what one had hoped for. 
 The question is then, wrote Harsnet, whether to settle for less or start again. 
 But again  is always an illusion, wrote Harsnet, for it would also become clear, the second time round, after several weeks, that one was not doing what one had hoped to do. 
 Despite the hard work. 
 Despite the enthusiasm. 
 Had one hoped for too much or has something gone wrong? he wrote. 
 But why does it always go wrong? 
 Tried soaking the matches in paint, he wrote, and firing from toy cannon. 
 Three shots from three different positions. 
 Had been dreaming about this for a long time, he wrote. 
 The idea of the directed arbitrary. 
 My search for the right kind of toy cannon. 
 I knew what I wanted, but I couldn't find it. 
 But eventually did. 
 The excitement with which I brought it home. 
 Set it up. 
 I didn't go straight ahead with it. 
 Wanted to savour the pleasure of what was to come. 
 But in the end very disappointing. 
 As is often the case, some last-minute idea blossoms while what had seemed a brilliant solution and been pondered for ages falls quite flat. 
 That is why there has to be the big glass and the notes in the box, not the glass alone or the notes alone, but the box, with all my preliminary notes and measurements, all my plans and blueprints, and then the glass, with the end product of all those notes visible on its surface. 
 Consider, he wrote. 
 Where is the image? 
 Where is the surface? 
 What is the status  of the image? 
 Shadow of another reality? 
 Not imitation of shadow. 
 Not reproduction of shadow. 
 But shadow itself. 
 Always it is elsewhere, wrote Harsnet. 
 But to us it comes as echo, shadow. 
 Thus two dimensional representation of a three dimensional world, itself only the three dimensional representation of a four dimensional world. 
 Perhaps. 
 So: where is it happening? 
 Not only a question about the big glass. 
 Not only a question about art. 
 The idea that it is happening elsewhere  prevalent in our lives. 
 Is it an illusion to imagine that this is a merely modern phenomenon? he wrote. 
 That other ages did not feel this too? 
 Is it not perhaps inevitable for all creatures with imagination , all creatures which can say no ? 
 Religions purvey illusion that with enough effort and humility you can get to that elsewhere. 
 Perhaps only in the next life. 
 But you can get there . 
 Yet our art persists in trying to render  the world as though it were here, now, available, he wrote. 
 As though there were no elsewhere and no need of an elsewhere. 
 All mesmerized by this folly, he wrote, all the Goldbergs and McGrindles, the Mosses and Baiocchis, the Honeymen and McGoughs. 
 Sumptuous richness of the textures. 
 The way the drapery falls. 
 How he is in love with flesh and conveys that love to us. 
 Bah! 
 So Harsnet. 
 And Goldberg, in his pad: I have never said or written any of the sentiments attributed to me here, though I have heard them from the mouths and read them from the pens of others. 
 It is typical of painters, he wrote, to make these wild accusations, wild generalizations. 
 If he only. 
 It is canvas and paint, wrote Harsnet, and Goldberg settled himself to type on. 
 It is canvas and paint, he typed, and that is all. 
 But, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), that is no big deal either, as the Americans seem to think. 
 Why want to celebrate  the act of applying paint to canvas? 
 I can thin &mdash; k of nothing more disgusting or unpleasant, he wrote. 
 Certainly of few things more uninteresting. 
 Matched only perhaps by the uninterestingness of the minds and souls of such painters. 
 Art in America synonymous with success, he wrote, and telling the truth reduced to baring the breast. 
 The smallness of it, he wrote. 
 The dreariness of it. 
 And taken seriously not only there but here as well, by critics who themselves long for success, and long too to lay bare their own poor breasts. 
 So Harsnet. 
 The reason why I have a soft spot for this notebook, he wrote. 
 In this notebook, recording my random thoughts day after day as I work on the big glass, I can keep my distance from the big glass. 
 I report on its progress (or lack of it), that is all. 
 I mutter to myself (or curse), that is all. 
 Today, such and such. 
 Moved forward in this way. 
 Fell back in that way. 
 No more. 
 As when asked to fill in questionnaire and give details of age, sex, height, colour hair, etc. 
 That is all. 
 But the point is there can never  be any more. 
 That is what Kafka understood. 
 What is Metamorphosis  except progress report on the disintegration of a body? 
 Kafka turns the secret weapon of the novel against itself . 
 What do I mean by that? he wrote. 
 I mean that the  novel has always given the impression that third person narration can narrate what it is I am feeling. 
 (Or first person narration for that matter.) 
 What Kafka discovers is that there is no direct relation between what I feel  and what happens  to me. 
 All of Kafka nothing but report to the Academy, presented by a scrupulous and conscientious clerk. 
 Kafka's genius lies in his having grasped that this was much more true to experience, much more realistic , than the rich sensuality and feeling for the individual etc. etc. of Lawrence and his much more pathetic followers.  
 Don't tell, show &mdash; the slogan that keeps this myth from exploding.  
 The slogan of blinkered professors and dull art critics, who, as always, are a couple of hundred years out of date.  
 So Harsnet.  
 And Goldberg, on his pad: If the fool had ever bothered to read what I have written on the subject in the essay on aura and the hour he would not have flailed about as he does here.  
 Typical of artists to read nothing except what they happen upon and then to pontificate about life and art and the way the world is going.  
 He talks of responsibility, wrote Goldberg, half-tearing the page of his pad in his hurry to turn it over without breaking the flow of his thought, but where is his own sense of it?  
 My son, he wrote, moving on to a new page, my son, who is a keen footballer and a passionate supporter of our local team, Brighton and Hove Albion (the Seagulls), was surprised the other day when, looking in on one of the team's training sessions in the sports pavilion of the University of Sussex, he.  
 Pushing aside the pad he returned to his task.  
 Where does an artist like Kafka come from? he typed, squinting at his erstwhile friend's crumpled manuscript.  
 Where are the rules that can legislate for someone like that? he typed (as Harsnet had written).  
 Genius is precisely the word one does not  feel tempted to use.  
 Genius is Michelangelo at work on the Sistine ceiling.  
 Genius is Wordsworth peering down from Snowdon in the mist.  
 Genius is the bust of Beethoven and Keats dying and Shelley dying and the size of War and Peace  and poor old Sartre banging away at his trilogy and Hemingway paring it down to its essence and Monet unable to distinguish  colours any more and Picasso staring out at the camera with his chest bare and his eyes blazing and C&eacute;zanne snarling like a dog and then walking out of Aix with his canvas and paints on his back to paint that mountain and Byron dying and Pushkin dying and all the rest of it.  
 That is Genius, wrote Harsnet.  
 But no more interesting was my Picture Painted by a Genius  of 1954, no more interesting my Replica  of a Diploma Submitted in Lieu of an Original Composition for the Award of a Degree .  
 How to avoid the traps of both Genius and Whimsy? wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg).  
 How to move between pretentiousness and cynicism?  
 There are two things fatal to the development of any artist, Leiris said, one is success and the other is failure.  
 But he could equally well have said one is enthusiasm and the other is cynicism, one is facility and the other is aridity, one is gregariousness and the other is solitude, one is the belief that no one has ever done anything of value before and the other is the belief that everything has already been done, one is spontaneity and the other is cerebration, one is joy and the other is despair, one is heart and the other is mind, one is the garret and the other is the penthouse, one is sincerity and the other is irony, one is Jung and the other is Freud, one is Rimbaud and the other is Mallarm&eacute;, one is wine and the other is coffee, one is rags and the other is riches, one is women and the other is celibacy, one is health and the other is disease, one is meat and the other is vegetables, one is life and the other is death, one is everything in upper case and the other is everything in lower case, one is everything in roman and the other is everything in italics.  
 So Harsnet.  
 Fatal, he wrote (and Goldberg typed).  
 Both are fatal.  
 Tried using popgun after fiasco of toy cannon, he wrote, but that was too violent where other was too weak.  
 Trouble too on lower panel, right hand side, he wrote.  
 Waterfall clutters too much.  
 Need something different but don't know what.  
 Still hankering after round peep-hole but still afraid of damaging glass.  
 Waterfall or ladder, he wrote.  
 Steps leading from lower to higher, from higher to lower.  
 Ladder without rungs? he wrote.  
 Inverted waterfall?  
 (No Newton here.)  
  The point about the big glass, he wrote, is that there is no right way up and so there is no upside down.  
 Yet panels have to be one above the other, not side by side.  
 Elements in top panel floating in space.  
 In lower panel vanishing point clear and perspective of each element rigorous.  
 But our sense of its space will always depend on where it is placed.  
 Put against open window giving onto garden full of trees and it is one thing.  
 Place in gallery with no windows and visitors everywhere looking at pictures on walls and it is something else.  
 Place high up against open sky and moving clouds and it is something else again.  
 By introduction of glass , he wrote, relation of background to foreground radically altered.  
 Avoid the retinal, he wrote, but not the image .  
 Image-concept, concept-image, he wrote.  
 Glass/box//box/glass, he wrote.  
 Retain perspective but remove notion of window,  he wrote.  
 In top panel no perspective, shadow only, milky way, he wrote.  
 Fist and mystery, he wrote.  
 Fist strikes and time condenses: mystery glows and time dilates.  
 My ideal, he wrote, fist and mystery, both.  
 When I glimpse such a combination my heart beats faster.  
 That is all there is to it.  
 In Les Noces  and Symphony of Psalms .  
 In Dans le labyrinthe  and &bquo;Boy of Winander&equo;.  
 In Bonnard's Window  and Breughel's Children's Games .  
 All my life a preparation for my  version of this combination? he wrote.  
 See it in place, he wrote.  
 Never mind where so long as it is a public space.  
 Not this room.  
 See it installed in a public place and then bow out.  
 Not finished till installed, he wrote.  
 So long as it remains in this room, he wrote, it is not finished.  
 Yet in a public place it will not take up any space .  
 It will not elbow anything else out of the way.  
 &bquo;My space on this wall, get off&equo;, &mdash; the curse of the gallery system, of the collecting syndrome.  
 Instead, my glass will be a lens to see the rest through.  
 A means of making the visitor delay.  
 Not look at  but look with .  
 It all comes back, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), to the Kafka phenomenon.  
 I understood this the first time I read him, he wrote, in that smelly room in Hackney.  
 I could not formulate it to myself then but I felt the uniqueness.  
 Because nothing in his work stands up and  says: Look at me, look how true, beautiful, profound, etc.  
 Speculum humanae salvationis , he wrote.  
 Speculum mundi .  
 The glass of the salvation of humanity, he wrote.  
 The glass of the world.  
 Not glass to reflect  a bit  of the world, but a crystal ball to look into so as to understand  the world.  
 The big glass, he wrote.  
 Monstrous in this small room, though in the light of the day it reverts to its ordinary size, two biggish panels of glass, steel frame and stand, 227.5 x 175.8 cm.  
 (1091/4 x 691/4 inches).  
 perhaps a way should be found of ensuring that we experience both the ordinariness  and the extraordinariness  of the glass, he wrote.  
 In a gallery all by itself?  
 But then I lose what I most want from it, that it be in a room with other objects.  
 So perhaps it will have to fend for itself.  
 Its purity will protect it.  
 At a certain point, he wrote, you have to let go, he wrote, you have to let it go.  
 That is what the third part of the project means.  
 Diana unleashing the hounds, he wrote.  
 Thought yesterday of including hounds in some form or other: Melampus, Ichnobates, Pamphagus, Dorceus, Oribasos, Nobrophonos, Theron, Laelaps, Prerelas, Agre.  
 The principle I have to stick to, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg) is that of the rebus: a boat, a house, a letter, a word.  
 Mistake of the old type of interpretation was to fit all into a single story , a single world .  
 But they come from different worlds .  
 The river from the world of rivers.  
 The house from the world of houses.  
 The letter from the world of letters.  
 And so on.  
 And as they only exist, these many worlds, in dreams, so they only exist in a work of art.  
 The old painters knew this.  
 Lost with tedious Florentine allegorising.  
 Genius of Picasso to recall us to this, with his combinations of life-class drawing, cubism, collage, lettering, etc.  
 Escape from 500 years of the tyranny of the eye, the brain.  
 The I. Yet do not underestimate the pain of letting go, he wrote.  
 Do not underestimate the cost.  
 Pain and joy both, he wrote.  
 Those Picasso collages of 1910&ndash;14 the ancestors of my delays, he wrote.  
 The ego  will brook no delay, he wrote.  
 Capitalism  will brook no delay.  
 It is up to us to institute delay, he wrote.  
 In the big glass, he wrote, many stories, many half stories, many  fragments.  
 The story of the scissors.  
 Of the grinder.  
 Of the sieves.  
 Of the policeman and the judge.  
 Of the bride.  
 Of the bachelors.  
 Of Diana.  
 Of the 4D world.  
 Yet all must be precise, he wrote.  
 Self-sufficient.  
 Yet infinitely expandable . 
 Grand aims , he wrote, but no grand gestures . 
 Only that which is precise has resonance, he wrote. 
 Vermeer, not Delacroix. 
 Morandi, not Rothko. 
 Leave such comparisons to others, he wrote. 
 Leave to Goldberg and Pizzetti, Moss and McGrindle. 
 And Goldberg in his pad: N.B. his almost pathological need to denigrate critics and criticism. 
 The image of the critic as scape-goat in post-Romantic art, wrote Goldberg. 
 Keats. 
 Wordsworth at Cambridge. 
 Proust and Sainte-Beuve. 
 Monet. 
 C&eacute;zanne. 
 Schoenberg. 
 Stravinsky. 
 Develop, he wrote. 
 He pushed the pad aside and returned to his typing. 
 Letter from Marcus, he typed (as Harsnet had written). 
 Invitation for w/e. 
 Accept? 
 Work on big glass slowing down, wrote Harsnet. 
 Not to say drying up completely. 
 After all these months of forward movement only to be expected. 
 Or so I keep telling myself. 
 But do I believe it? 
 Mistake though to make fetish of work, he wrote. 
 It all depends on the intensity  of the work, not the amount . 
 But do I believe that ? 
 In recent days, he wrote, perhaps because Spring is upon us, I have been putting in the hours but the intensity  has gone. 
 Danger of harming the work. 
 Danger of doing something irrevocable and wrong because initial impetus lost and clue that will lead me to the centre not yet found. 
 As always, middle game greatest nightmare, he wrote. 
 In my early work, he wrote, I in a sense dispensed with middles. 
 The opening carried me forward straight to the end. 
 Or, with the readymades, beginnings and ends were actually one. 
 Perhaps in art today there is no longer a place for middles, he wrote. 
 Middles were all right for Veronese, but today they no longer have a role. 
 With the first stroke I have already reached the end, said Picasso. 
 I grow bored with the sheer size of the glass and have to force myself to continue, he wrote. 
 And yet, he wrote, if the glass is to be any sort of advance , it will be because of  the middle. 
 Because it is nothing but a middle , without beginning or end. 
 The  beauty of glass, he wrote, is this, that the surface does not  have to be covered. 
 Much of the middle, in fact, he wrote, will depend on where it is set up . 
 If I could only resolve that lower right hand panel though, he wrote, or even decide once and for all to leave it empty, then perhaps the boredom would disappear. 
 Boredom a sign of failure, he wrote. 
 If I am bored then I have not found the way to do what I wanted to do. 
 Bored with the assertion of the central place of boredom in human affairs, he wrote. 
 Leave that to Warhol, etc. 
 American denial of the human spirit, he wrote. 
 Already predicted by Toqueville. 
 Natural end of journey begun by Pilgrim Fathers is Warhol's Marilyn, he wrote. 
 Had they but known. 
 The real question, he wrote, is how to keep hold of a richer view of the possibilities of life while denying the consolations of an afterlife, denying the special destiny of man, denying the Value of Civilization (Nietzsche). 
 Danny, he wrote. 
 Queen's gambit. 
 Terrible trouble after bad exchange. 
 Position not unlike Morphy-Schrufer, Paris, 1859, before Morphy's knight move on B5. 
 Lost thread and lucky to draw. 
 But game did nothing for the glass, as I had hoped. 
 Block still there. 
 Delay, he wrote. 
 Neither flowing with time (materialism), nor denying time (romanticism). 
 A time for disinterested contemplation, he wrote. 
 Not just a delay in glass, he wrote, but glass as mirror of delay . 
 Glass , wrote Goldberg in the margin, mirror of delay . 
 Mirror of  delay and means  of delay, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg typed). 
 Not the bottle that guarantees to turn your grey hair black or make your bald pate sprout again, but something else. 
 A hiatus in nature. 
 As in Protevangelium ; And I looked up into the pole of the heavens and saw it standing still, and the fowls of the heavens without motion&hellip; 
 And of a sudden all things moved onward in their course. 
 Every image, of its nature, he wrote, freezes the world. 
 For centuries we have tried to pretend that this was not the case. 
 We cannot, with the coming of moving film, go on with this pretence. 
 So what can we do? 
 What must we do? 
 One solution to paint those moments when world is  frozen, when we experience time as standing still: when we look in mirrors,  or on hot afternoons. 
 Bonnard painted hot afternoons in mirrors. 
 Magritte did it by playing with paradox: day and night both; picture and landscape both. 
 Moving at best, but too often tricksy. 
 How though to get sense of whole world  pausing, before moving on? 
 Impossible if you think of painting as image of piece of world. 
 But if you think of it as model  of whole world, as great cathedrals were said to be, or physicists' models today? 
 Marcus, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg). 
 That exquisite house, not another in sight. 
 Complaining about losing his sight. 
 Black glasses even indoors. 
 Tony more subdued than I'd remembered him. 
 At 6 a.m. 
 Marcus leaps out of bed and starts to play Victorian hymns on the little portable organ he has in his bedroom. 
 Whole house starts to echo with the booming sound. 
 Impossible to sleep. 
 He comes to the end of one and without pause is off on another. 
 Sometimes plays straight, sometimes starts to distort, hardly perceptible at first, then more and more, until he is producing wild expressionist shrieks or light medieval dances, then gradually the hymn reasserts itself until all is as it should be. 
 Then all of a sudden, silence. 
 You keep waiting for more but it doesn't come. 
 He works till lunch, then wanders into the kitchen and has long argument with Tony, or perhaps a discussion about the best way to cook trout or whether or not to sack the gardener. 
 In the afternoon he starts by sleeping, then takes over the kitchen and insists on preparing extravagant five-course meals. 
 Had me take him into Salisbury to the oculist. 
 Pretends he can't go anywhere alone and this is a chance for Tony to get some time to himself. 
 Swore like a trooper under his breath as the bus swayed through the leafy lanes, saying he could no longer make out the landmarks, that he knew such and such a tree or house was in such and such a place, he'd passed it so often in the bus, but now could barely see it. 
 New little clavichord in his study, seventeenth century, and over his desk his charts and diagrams. 
 Photo of Schoenberg and Gershwin playing tennis, and reproduction of D&uuml;rer's Melancholia . 
 Phenomenal energy still. 
 After cooking supper that was more like a banquet than an ordinary meal he played  us some medieval things on the organ and then some Elizabethan things on the clavichord. 
 Left him still playing at midnight and collapsed into bed. 
 Eerie silence of the countryside. 
 Will never get used to it. 
 And then, just after I'd fallen asleep, as I thought, there was the damned organ moaning away and it was 6 a.m. again. 
 Tony in the kitchen. 
 Death of his father. 
 Long string of jokes about the funeral, as though to show how well he was taking it. 
 Painful. 
 At the door, one more joke, rather good. 
 Perelman's publishers sent Groucho Marx a copy of P's first book soliciting a puff. 
 &bquo;From the moment I picked up this book to the moment I put it down,&equo; wrote GM, &bquo;I couldn't stop laughing. 
 One of these days I intend to read it.&equo; 
 As I left I asked Marcus to remove his dark glasses so I could look at his face. 
 He refused, said the light hurt his eyes. 
 Memory of him standing there waving with two black holes in the middle of his face. 
 Wouldn't leave me all through the following night as I worked on the glass. 
 And those beautiful expressive hands of his flying over the keyboard of the little painted organ. 
 Sense of excessive energy, no outlet, as though he's going to burst into a million pieces if some inner pressure doesn't abate. 
 He wanted to play at the funeral but Tony's mother wouldn't let him. 
 Cursed the American planes. 
 Said they would force him to move again. 
 One fighter flying low overhead can ruin a whole day's work. 
 In the middle of working on a difficult piece I can almost feel my ears grow, he said. 
 I start to hear everything  much better than I normally do. 
 I hear the grass grow, for instance. 
 Look at Schoenberg's ears, he said. 
 Look at Stravinsky's. 
 Those aren't ears, he said, those are receiving dishes. 
 But why this passion for hearing more, seeing more, experiencing more? 
 Why not stay with what we normally  hear and see and feel? 
 Because it's not grand enough? 
 Not important enough? 
 The desire for transfiguration, wrote Harsnet. 
 The desire for resurrection in this life . 
 The desire for a world freed of banality, confusion. 
 Why not the triumph of the ordinary? he wrote. 
 The transfiguration of the contingent? 
 That Christian ache for redemption, he wrote. 
 I know it well. 
 I know  from where it comes and where it wishes to get to. 
 But redemption from what? 
 Even denial &agrave; la Warhol, cynicism &agrave; la Warhol nothing but inverted nostalgia for a lost transcendental. 
 As if it had ever been there. 
 All haunted by the sense of a sacred space, a sacred time. 
 Which the big glass will not only deny  but show up for what it is: narcissism, regression, the refusal to see things as they are . 
 (The Death of Images.) 
 Set up glass in centre of gallery, he wrote. 
 Not an object to be looked at and admired. 
 Not elbowing others out of the way. 
 It is and is not there. 
 It delays your approach to Klee, Picasso, Bacon, Pollock. 
 That is all. 
 A slight delay as you skirt round  it. 
 A barely perceptible delay as you gaze through  it. 
 Why this need to imagine it finished, installed, looked at by other eyes? he wrote. 
 Is it because I am at a loss as to how to go on? 
 No, he wrote. 
 My sense of how to go on determined by the vividness of my imagination of what it will be like when done. 
 A struggle to realize  what in some sense already exists . 
 Strong sense of an object , he wrote, not an image . 
 Incorporate Marcus black glasses? he wrote. 
 Yesterday set up conditions for Milky Way, he wrote. 
 Gauze over radiator photographed three times as currents moved it. 
 Sense suddenly of peace. 
 No hurry. 
 Glass guiding me where I must be going. 
 But trouble with Bride, he wrote. 
 Oxidization. 
 Need to find other method of putting her on. 
 Nevertheless, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), it is proceeding according to plan. 
 Leading me where I have always wanted to go yet never known how. 
 Understood that after w/e in Wiltshire. 
 Going away as a means of discovering what was really happening here, he wrote. 
 No need to detail now. 
 Only to say I came back and saw glass as another might see it. 
 After eight months' work it has acquired a life of its own. 
 A personality of its own. 
 Though in one sense only just begun. 
 After all the doubts and uncertainties, wrote Harsnet, most of which I did not admit to myself, or else tried to pretend were an integral part of the project, sense now that it is on its way . 
 Even bottom right may be all right as it is. 
 Key to everything the idea of the glass. 
 And then the idea (how did it come to me?) that it  must not simply be glass but big glass . 
 After that only a matter of confidence. 
 Of holding on. 
 The plans in place. 
 Strategy and tactics all there in the box. 
 Yet doubts remain. 
 Till realized difficult to know if idea is really valid. 
 Will really yield what I want it to. 
 You can dream and dream but only what happens in this room night after night is important. 
 The solution of each individual problem. 
 The solution of the problem of relating the individual solutions to each other. 
 Or refusing to relate them. 
 So much bigger  than anything I have ever undertaken, he wrote. 
 The initial terror. 
 Terror and excitement. 
 In the heart. 
 In the stomach. 
 That is the mystery, he wrote. 
 To keep it from flowing away from you and yet to keep it going . 
 To place one item, one element, in relation to all the others, and yet to keep space open for further elements . 
 Time does not exist in the big glass, he wrote. 
 Only exposure will provide it. 
 Exposure to viewer. 
 If only there was a way for each viewer to leave his mark . 
 Each eye that looks to wear away the glass a little bit. 
 My dream of a book whose print fades a little each time it is read until the pages are blank. 
 perhaps provide each viewer with specially prepared spectacles? 
 Hang those on big glass? 
 Too fussy. 
 Find another solution, wrote Harsnet. 
 Find way of treating glass so as to respond to viewer's gaze? 
 Can that be done? 
 Not to be true to the materials but false to them! he wrote. 
 Find a way of allowing each viewer to make his own impact on the glass, he wrote, to indicate that viewing is not a neutral  activity. 
 Remove passivity from the process of viewing, he wrote. 
 Bring time back into  the work, he wrote. 
 The time of viewing  as well as the time of making . 
 And yet the glass itself is about the emptiness of time, he wrote. 
 Time is not full, he wrote. 
 It is not alive with meaning. 
 A only relates to B because I have put them there. 
 It is important, he wrote, to show that there is no natural  link between them. 
 The fatal delay, he wrote, and Goldberg, seizing his pen, scribbled in the margin: fatal delay . 
 The Bride, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg went on typing), fails to get impregnated. 
 The Bachelors, he wrote, fail to achieve their desire. 
 The distance between them, he wrote, is not  so much great as unbridgeable . 
 Sex in the head, he wrote. 
 Each remains in his or her half, dreaming of the other. 
 Out of that what can come? 
 Nothing can come of nothing, he wrote. 
 That is why the glass is dedicated to Diana. 
 Why it is the colour of the moon and made in the light of the moon. 
 It all boils down, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), to the question of true causality . 
 Children begotten by arbitrary spasm, he wrote. 
 Ditto artworks. 
 Lack of relation, he wrote, between input  and output . 
 The choice is to ignore this or to draw attention to it. 
 I cannot ignore it. 
 So I have chosen to make an image of the failure of cause to relate to effect. 
 Delay in glass is delay in life, he wrote. 
 Fatal delay, he wrote. 
 Between A and B falls the shadow, he wrote. 
 If the Bachelors could impregnate the Bride, he wrote, then art would flourish. 
 Then I would be an artisan, quietly learning my trade at the feet of a master and passing it on in turn to my apprentices. 
 But that is not how it is, he wrote. 
 There is no meaning in the world , so there is no meaning in art . 
 To go on acting as though there were is to add to the layers of falsehood which already cover our (so-called) civilization. 
 What needs to be done, he wrote, is to strip away , not to add. 
 Yet all art is addition. 
 Even when it speaks of stripping it still adds. 
 How then to escape the falsity? he wrote. 
 The death of images, he wrote. 
 My catalogue essay to end all catalogue essays. 
 I copy it down here to help me go forward. 
 It was in those far-off days as they strolled through the parks and boulevards of the great cities of the West, that people first began to speak of the death of images. 
 Soon it had become one of the main topics of conversation. 
 It was discussed with passion and anxiety in small groups and in large assemblies, in salons and caf&eacute;s, in bars and in clubs. 
 Friends talked the matter over far into the night and then went home, to their families or to the loneliness of dingy bed-sitting rooms, to carry on the debate in diaries and notebooks, poems and letters. 
 No one knew what had first led to the rumour that soon images would die, nor how the rumour had grown into conviction and conviction into certainty. 
 One young man, unable to tolerate the thought,  burned himself alive in a public square. 
 A girl of twelve turned her face to the wall, refused all nourishment, and so passed away. 
 Others, more robust or less perceptive, found, on the contrary, a renewed zest for life in the perpetual animated discussions occasioned by the topic. 
 A distinguished philosopher, much admired in the profession, became a celebrity overnight when he wrote in a Sunday paper that what all the varied responses had in common was the forlorn belief that somehow, through talk or action, the decisive event would be warded off. 
 But, he pointed out, no one could possibly conceive what life would be like after the death of images. 
 Without images, he said, there would not even be the wherewithal to talk about the death of images. 
 Language itself, he said, would cease to function as it had always functioned, it would only be a strange dead thing, smouldering perhaps, but burnt out, no longer conveying any meaning. 
 That, he said, was, strictly speaking, inconceivable. 
 So long as we have language, he argued, we simply cannot conceive it. 
 And without language we would not be able to conceive it either. 
 But may it not be the case, he suggested, that images have already died and we are not aware of it? 
 You who read me, he concluded, you who think you understand me, must try to imagine what it would be like not to understand me. 
 To read me and think you understand me and yet not to understand me. 
 Only if you do that will you be able to say with confidence that I am wrong, that what I am suggesting has not yet come to pass, that there is still time. 
 His words were taken up by many who would not have dreamed of opening any of his more technical works, and he came to be in great demand as a speaker at rallies and at the numerous conferences and seminars on the death of images organized by the Universities, the Churches and the innumerable Humanist organizations which had mushroomed in the immediately preceding decades. 
 Even those who had never heard of him mouthed his words, repeating them to others as though they had just thought of them themselves, which perhaps they had, for there is surely such a thing as a spirit of the times. 
 But it  did not bring an end to the speculation and confusion which was rending the civilized world. 
 As a leading writer put it, after casting doubts on the appropriateness of the philosopher's imagery, just because his answer was probably the right one it was in effect no answer at all. 
 The summer, which was a glorious one that year, gave way to a gusty autumn, and, as is the way with these things, after the autumn came the winter. 
 That was the year when, in the parks and boulevards of the great cities of the West, people first began to talk about the death of images. 
 So Harsnet. 
 And Goldberg, seizing his pen, scribbled in the margin:. 
 Death of images &mdash; see cat.  
 Dusseldorf exhib.  
 8.10.62 . 
 Hegel, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg typed). 
 H&ouml;lderlin. 
 Wittgenstein. 
 Kafka. 
 That is why producing yet more images, he wrote, is like eating cardboard. 
 Nightmare, he wrote. 
 Found myself out in the snow but the snow had turned into cotton wool. 
 World gradually being covered in cotton wool. 
 Not cold, so at first quite pleasant. 
 Then sudden realization that it would not stop. 
 That it would never stop. 
 That it would gradually cover the earth, the trees, me. 
 Escape impossible. 
 Breathing it in through the nose, the mouth. 
 Sense of not unpleasant suffocation. 
 My horror at the fact that it was not unpleasant, that I was almost enjoying it, and that it was killing me. 
 That is what words are today, he wrote. 
 What images are. 
 Two monstrosities, wrote Borges, mirrors and procreation, for both duplicate existence. 
 In contrast, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), the big glass. 
 Set it up against the window, he wrote. 
 Or on terrace. 
 A mere delay in seeing the world. 
 Even in gallery, he wrote, it will disturb no one, merely make it a little more difficult to get from one side of the room to the other. 
 Why this urge to add, constantly to add? he wrote. 
 Pictures, he wrote, statues, books, children. 
 Goldberg and his brood, he wrote. 
 Rosenblum that day in the queue at Camisi's: What did the good Lord create us for if not to be fathers? 
 And McGrindle, very matter of fact though drunk as usual: I have sixteen children, seven by my first marriage, four by my second, my second wife had two of her own, that makes thirteen, and three from  my third, sixteen, and I am proud to say I have been able to give them all a good education and every chance in life without ever compromising my integrity. 
 As if every sentence he had ever written had not cried out to the heavens that the man had as much integrity as a rotten tree-trunk. 
 Goldberg taking out his polka-dotted handkerchief and wiping his brow, his cheeks, his neck, pushed aside the typewriter and seized his pen. 
 Dragging the pad towards him he found a clean page and wrote: Dear Harsnet, I know you never answer my letters or return my calls, and I know that you handed over your notes to me on the understanding that I could do what I liked with them and not bother you, but I have to say that while there is much in them that I admire, as I will always admire much in you, no matter what, there is also much in them that seems to me to be puerile and, to put it mildly, bigoted. 
 I have decided, however, in the interests of posterity, to cut nothing, though I may take the liberty of annotating the text here and there, putting some of the facts straight and referring the reader to related documents, such as interviews you once gave or books and articles on you which have since appeared. 
 I know none of this interests you any longer, he wrote, and that you hold yourself, or pretend to hold yourself, aloof from the world, and in particular from the world of art. 
 You are, or pretend to be, indifferent to whatever may happen to your reputation. 
 Nevertheless I feel that I have a responsibility to the public and to the world of art both to present your unpublished writings in as comprehensible a form as possible, and at the same time to correct some of the misleading impressions these might give, not of course about yourself, but about others, casually mentioned here and there in the course of your jottings. 
 I am not talking primarily about myself, he wrote, for it will be obvious to anyone who reads these notes that you have used me simply as a stalking horse for some of your more outrageous views and. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, tearing the sheet in his hurry to turn over the page, I know you never reply to letters and refuse to answer the door or the phone. 
 I respect your  privacy. 
 Who would not? 
 However, it seems to me that there is something a little perverse in leaving me your notes on the making of the Big Glass when you must have known perfectly well that they contained material I would be certain to find offensive. 
 This is the main reason why I have not until recently felt able to face the task of transcribing them and editing them in the way they. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, I am not sure if this will reach you and I know that even if it does you will not reply. 
 After all, since our last meeting, if one can call it a meeting, at the entrance to the sweet little National Gallery of Modern Art in Edinburgh, all those years ago, you have cut yourself off from your friends and well-wishers. 
 I do not. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, I want simply to tell you that work on your notes connected with the Big Glass is at last under way and that I have remained scholarly and impartial throughout what has not been an easy task, in view of what you say about me and especially about my family, and which you must have known would give offense. 
 However. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, just a brief note to let you know that work on the MSS you left with me is proceeding apace (at long last!) and will soon be ready for publication. 
 I cannot express what a privilege it has been transcribing it and entering your very mind and spirit in the throes of creativity, as it were. 
 Perhaps we can meet and talk about it all one of these days. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, my son, who is a keen supporter of Brighton and Hove Albion Association Football Club (The Seagulls), and who frequently goes to the sports centre of the University of Sussex to watch his team at their indoor training, was surprised the other day to see two figures distinctly older than the rest of the players. 
 One of them, it was pointed out to him, was the great ex-Soviet chess player, Korchnoi, who is apparently training with the team in order to reach maximum physical fitness for his world title challenge to his arch-rival, the darling of the Soviets, Karpov. 
 Imagine his surprise then, when, looking more closely, he identified the other man as. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, this is a message from the past. 
 I just want to tell you. 
 Goldberg, pushing  aside pad and pen, drew the little typewriter towards him and began to type again. 
 The procreative metaphor, he typed (as Harsnet had written), has been the bane of art. 
 It is not enough, wrote Harsnet, to deny that one conceives a work of art and brings it forth as a child is conceived and brought forth into the world. 
 Human artefacts are not children, he wrote. 
 They are made, not born. 
 The colossal error of nineteenth-century anthropologists like Tyler was to imagine that there was no difference. 
 The reaction to this of Saussure, L&eacute;vi-Strauss and their followers part and parcel of the modernist reaction to nineteenth-century art and culture. 
 But the metaphor goes on haunting us, he wrote. 
 Merely to deny it, even to prove its falsity, is not enough. 
 The organic metaphor is so deeply rooted , he wrote, that ordinary refutation is not enough. 
 In order to get rid of the whole web of interlinked concepts, myths, wishes and desires, one has to mine it from within . 
 The sterility of the Bride, he wrote. 
 The sterility of the Bachelors. 
 Bride means nothing without Maid or Virgin, he wrote. 
 Bachelor means nothing without Husband or Father. 
 World of culture, not nature, he wrote. 
 But a culture which is frozen, locked into its contradictions. 
 The grinder, he wrote. 
 The chariot and its onanistic litany, he wrote. 
 It is emancipated horizontally , he wrote. 
 Like the rest of the glass, he wrote, it defies the second law of thermo-dynamics. 
 Why? 
 Because in the imagination there is no friction . 
 By the same token, he wrote, in the imagination there cannot be movement . 
 Everything remains hypothetical . 
 That is what happens in the big glass too, he wrote. 
 But are things any different inside our culture ? 
 A sterile culture because a purely hypothetical one, he wrote. 
 No reality, he wrote, only images masquerading as reality, only dreams masquerading as the real world. 
 Is it only our culture? he wrote. 
 TV and all that? 
 Or endemic to all? 
 All those lonely brides today, he wrote. 
 All those lonely bachelors. 
 The Grinder grinds but no chocolate emerges, he wrote. 
 Glider, he wrote, Mallic Moulds, Scissors, Sieves. 
 The circulation of the gas, he wrote. 
 But it is only in the imagination of the Bride, of the Bachelors, of  the viewer. 
 It cannot make the machine work . 
 It can only generate anxiety, despair. 
 The Bride strips herself, glowing with pleasure at seeing herself seen, but it is a poor solitary exercise, for she is only impregnated by her imagination. 
 Hilda, he wrote, when I ventured to tell her all her troubles were her own fault: You are so cold. 
 As though heat were an unquestioned good. 
 You smile and remain unmoved, she said, just like father. 
 And the others: You have such warmth! 
 So much to give! 
 If only you would let yourself go! 
 Go where? 
 Go where? wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg). 
 Where did they want me to go? 
 Mushrooms grow in the dark, I said to Hilda. 
 What's that to do with it? she said. 
 Things grow in the warm darkness, I said, but I prefer it cold and moonlit. 
 Romantic claptrap, she said. 
 You think of yourself as a realist but you're really full of this romantic bullshit about the moon. 
 Cold is bad, I said to her. 
 Romantic is bad. 
 Warmth is good. 
 Realism is good. 
 Now I know, I said to her. 
 I will endeavour to act on this information. 
 Is that all you can say? she said. 
 Like Madge: Is that all you can say? 
 Hitting me with her little fists, but I couldn't get the smile off my face. 
 For some reason I couldn't, though I could see it was that which infuriated her more than anything. 
 I wanted to but I couldn't. 
 Your smile destroyed her, Goldberg said. 
 She told me it was your smile that did it. 
 Am I responsible for that? 
 I asked him. 
 Yes, he said. 
 She was a wonderful girl and your smile destroyed her. 
 You could have talked to her, he said, you could have explained. 
 What was there to explain? 
 I said. 
 Anyway, she was the one who did the talking. 
 You put up this front to protect yourself. 
 There's really no need to be afraid. 
 Which of them said that? 
 Annie? 
 No. 
 I remember the words but not the face. 
 Like the other day. 
 Buying the wire. 
 Hullo, how are you? 
 What brings you to this part of town? 
 I knew the face and knew at once that we had been intimate, but I had no idea who she was. 
 Absolutely no idea. 
 Is that a sign of age? 
 Indifference? 
 Or what? 
 When I cannot even remember the names of the women I slept with? 
 Or anything about them. 
 Only the vague sensation that I had, once. 
 Or had I? 
 Almost  as though it had all happened in another life. 
 The embarrassment of not remembering. 
 Good after that to return to the big glass. 
 Good to lock the door and settle down with it. 
 My prisonni&egrave;re . 
 The wire immediately resolved the problem of definition. 
 Nice echo too of medieval stained glass, while helping to establish principle of making the utterly new out of the old, the ordinary, the commonplace &mdash; what could be more ordinary than fuse-wire? 
 My old dream of a work which celebrates the contents of a pocket. 
 Everything a pocket has ever carried in its time. 
 Has cradled and protected. 
 Has smothered and covered in dust: the sweets of childhood, the matches of adolescence, the pills of maturity. 
 And all the rest of it. 
 My attempt at an inventory of the entire contents of a jacket pocket for 1959. 
 The surprises when I actually checked. 
 The amazing number of sheer things . 
 Mum furious that day when, aged seven, I emptied out the contents of her bag and arranged them on the table in descending order of size. 
 The selectivity of archaeology what makes it so uninteresting. 
 Then to turn the contents of a pocket into a work of art. 
 Framed. 
 Up there. 
 Selectivity of course. 
 How else? 
 But selectivity so planned as to celebrate randomness. 
 Impersonal rules, such as size, colour, alphabet, only to keep the mind from ordering in more banal ways. 
 The old problem: How to give satisfying form without denying abundance, formlessness ? 
 Wire to define contours. 
 Stick with mastic varnish, then seal with layer of lead foil pressed into wet paint and seal again with lead. 
 Cover with second panel of glass, so that contents fully visible but inaccessible. 
 Everything crystal clear but refusing to make sense. 
 The more you try to decipher the more confusing it becomes. 
 The whole problem of optimum distance, he wrote. 
  Optimun  distance of the spectator. 
 My concern over this for almost as long as I can remember. 
 Then the solution imposed by the glass. 
 All problems resolved in one go because now for the first time question of optimum distance becomes an issue for the viewer . 
 How the glass seems to be bringing together so many of my old themes, he wrote. 
 Without my even being aware of it. 
 That which is hidden is that which  is shown. 
 The mystery of tattoos. 
 Inventories. 
 Time. 
 And Goldberg in the margin: Compendium of old themes . 
 As though in every life, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg returned to his typing), if enough work has been done, enough determination shown, there is one final large summary, and that should be enough. 
 Perhaps that is the difference, wrote Harsnet, between me and someone like Goldberg, for all his energy and ambition. 
 He floats with the tide. 
 There can be no summation for him because there is nothing there to sum up. 
 The glass, he wrote, challenges the tide. 
 It interposes a delay. 
 Though in the longterm, as I have said before, he wrote, it makes little difference, the tide always wins out, sooner or later all vanishes into the sea. 
 Ignore the longterm though, he wrote. 
 Ignore deliberately. 
 Start from where you are. 
 Start from what you've got. 
 Do not look up. 
 Do not look back. 
 One step and then another and then another and then another after that. 
 Get rid of what you don't need, he wrote. 
 Make do with the absolute minimum . 
 Find the logic of each project. 
 It cannot be known beforehand, he wrote. 
 Each discovery is bought at a cost , he wrote. 
 This is what the Goldbergs and McGrindles cannot understand. 
 Not A and  B but A or B. Eliminate the soggy, he wrote. 
 Eliminate nostalgia. 
 No solution because no problem, he wrote. 
 Sleep, wake, cook, eat, go in, switch on light, examine prisoner, get down to work, finish work, write up notebook, sleep, wake, cook, eat. 
 La Tartine d'Albertine ? he wrote. 
 Child's toy &mdash; my old dream. 
 Each day a little advance, each day the surprising discovery. 
 So Harsnet. 
 And Goldberg, in his pad: Dear Harsnet, it may surprise you to hear that after all these years I am finally at work transcribing the notes you entrusted to me so many years ago, with a view to eventually publishing them. 
 You may have thought I had thrown them away, or merely, forgotten about them, and I was entitled to do either, since you explicitly said I was to do exactly whit I liked with them, that you washed your hands of them completely. 
 Or you may not have thought at all. 
 Since you are so unwilling to communicate with your old friends they can only guess. 
  The fact is I did take it out once or twice, determined to do something with it, but other things, like earning enough to keep a roof over our heads and send the children to decent schools, always seemed to intervene. 
 Do not think, he wrote, biting his lips in concentration, bending low over the page, blinking to keep the sweat out of his eyes, do not think that it was ever far from my mind. 
 In fact, he wrote, I suspect that I will produce a better edition, one more worthy of its subject, now I have had time to mull over its implications and to watch the blossoming of your reputation. 
 Do not think, he wrote, then pushed the pad aside, emptied his glass of orange juice and drew the typewriter to him. 
 The tart, he typed (as Harsnet had written). 
 Prisoner of conscience, he typed. 
 La merde, la merde, toujours recommenc&eacute;e (what a recompense apr&eacute;s what pens&eacute;e!) 
 La Re Qu'on Pense, wrote Harsnet. 
 'Ard Object, he wrote. 
 Objet Dard. 
 L'Entre Deux Verres, he wrote. 
 Why do my titles come out better in French than in English? he wrote. 
 Because I see it from the outside? 
 Xenakis last night, he wrote. 
 Picked him up at Imperial College. 
 I gave them a three-hour lecture on the basic principles of stochastics, he said. 
 Some composers today don t even understand the simple calculus, he said. 
 Can you believe it? 
 For him Stockhausen a child, Boulez a tyrant, Berio an entertainer. 
 There is one artist in every generation whose work possesses real significance, he said. 
 The rest is the chorus. 
 In this generation it happens to be me. 
 It's nothing to be proud of, just a fact. 
 Unity in his mind of architecture, music, astronomy, geology. 
 Tried to explain the real implications of quantum physics as we crossed Kensington Road. 
 Cars honking everywhere. 
 Then DNA. 
 I told him it was the size of it all disturbed me. 
 I kept seeing these double helices like two snakes winding up an invisible tree, only smaller. 
 He scratched with his stick on the ground (we were in Hyde Park by this time). 
 An attendant warned us not to deface public property. 
 He urged me to come to Paris. 
 The level of intellectual activity there. 
 Sustained intellectual activity. 
 He kept repeating: sustained intellectual activity. 
 His  current work on the concept of flow with Thom and Deleuze. 
 One to deal with its mathematical, one with its philosophical and psychoanalytic, one with its artistic implications. 
 Huge Government grant. 
 Research assistants. 
 I told him all that left me cold. 
 He looked at my pityingly, no doubt thinking that I was succumbing to the English diseases, amateurism and laziness. 
 Everywhere he goes he leaves his umbrella behind. 
 He's stuck a label on all his umbrellas with his name and address but he never gets them back. 
 There are thieves everywhere, he said. 
 Last week, sitting in the Luxembourg Gardens, he became aware of a pain in his foot. 
 He took off his shoe to investigate, then heard a noise overhead and saw a flock of starlings flying past. 
 Became fascinated by the pattern as they wheeled and changed direction. 
 Got out paper and pencil to try and think through the implications of what he had just seen, then gave up and started off home. 
 Some time later found he had only one shoe on. 
 Went back but the other had gone. 
 It's unbelievable the number of thieves there are, he said. 
 Now planning huge work to take place simultaneously in every town in Greece and on every mountain. 
 Not music but transformation of sound-waves already in the air. 
 Perhaps colour-waves too, if technology ready in time. 
 Twenty-four hours non-stop performance. 
 After that plans similar experience world-wide. 
 Perhaps to last a year. 
 Once we have landed on Mars we will be able to beam it to the galaxy, he said. 
 Speak to the entire galaxy and wait for replies. 
 Complained of pains in his back. 
 I wanted to give him supper but he said he would take sandwiches up to his room and get on with his work. 
 Greece was waiting, he said. 
 The world was waiting. 
 At the desk asked if anyone had returned an umbrella, but the clerk shook his head. 
 Asked to have breakfast brought up to his room at six. 
 I work every day from 6.20 to 9.30 a.m., he said, and then from 4 p.m. to midnight if I can. 
 I can work in any conditions, he said. 
 Any conditions. 
 I have my pocket calculator and there are always things which need doing for which there is no need for my big computer. 
 At home though he can plug himself in to other  computers all over the world. 
 I work a lot with M.I.T., he said. 
 And Stanford. 
 Also links with Japan. 
 Month in Kyoto every year with his wife. 
 Apart from Paris Kyoto is the only city she likes, he said. 
 The clerk then dug out an umbrella and showed it to him. 
 It looks like mine, he said, examining it, but there's no label on it. 
 He handed it back. 
 You see what I mean? he said to me. 
 I went home through the Park. 
 Strong winds gusting up from the South. 
 Branches down, the trees creaking. 
 Flat reasonably quiet though. 
 Sit and thought about Xenakis. 
 How he was tortured in '44. 
 He showed me the scars. 
 I concentrated on the implications of Einstein's General Theory, he said, and on the pathos of his later career. 
 So managed to get through without revealing anything. 
 He walked through the mountains for seventy-two hours after escaping. 
 My feet have never been the same since, he said. 
 I have to take off my shoes whenever I can. 
 Something still very wrong with the right hand side of the bottom panel. 
 Sat through the night and looked at it. 
 As usual the whole thing seemed immense. 
 Much too big for my abilities. 
 But gradually I calmed down. 
 Lost my anxiety. 
 It simply, became a field of force, like any other. 
 I began to see the dangers of overcrowding, over-invention. 
 The most important thing in fact the clear glass . 
 Never to forget that. 
 But many of the elements still not relating. 
 No proper tension  between them. 
 Better from the back. 
 Thought again about possibility of having it viewable equally from front and back. 
 No front and back, in other words. 
 But again dismissed idea. 
 Back should be seen as back. 
 Outlines visible but surface different. 
 The principle always that nothing should be hidden: There is only this . 
 And yet that only  should be able to stimulate dreams, create anxiety. 
 So Harsnet. 
 Is this all there is? 
 Why no more? 
 Why this? 
 Why here? he wrote. 
 Such questions should occur to the viewer, he wrote. 
 And force him to ask the same questions of his life, and to reply: This is all there is and it is enough . 
 Enough not because we must content ourselves with the minimum, he wrote, but because there is never more , if more means meaning, wholeness, salvation, redemption, all the rest. 
 The  glass itself must make that clear, he wrote. 
 But tell story too, if viewer wants a story, a story about our desire for more and the folly of that desire, the desire for more and the inevitable frustration of that desire. 
 Desire of Bride to be more than a bride, to be a mother too. 
 Desire of Bachelors to be more than bachelors, to be husbands and fathers too. 
 Hold up the glass to such viewers, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), and let them see themselves in it. 
 The bridge between the different elements that, between them, could add up to a story, is space , he wrote. 
 Let those who will fall into that space, and fall for ever. 
 The space is glass, he wrote. 
 The whiteness of delirium, he wrote. 
 The whiteness of real nothingness. 
 Not the whiteness of the whale, which is still something , but the emptiness of the glass, which is nothing . 
 The ordinary wall behind, he wrote, this  wall and no other, these  viewers and no others. 
 And so on. 
 And yet, he wrote, the wonder is that this nothing holds the elements together . 
 So that they are and are not linked in their impossible non-consummation . 
 And yet the drama lies in this, wrote Harsnet, that perhaps the Bride really wishes  to remain only a bride, at the moment of her bridity, and the bachelors only bachelors, at the moment of their bachelorhood, dangling together like pegs on a line, boys together at eternal stag party, as the bride a virgin forever in her dream of giving herself up to something else, crossing the threshold  to another existence. 
 As we all of us want to escape  ourselves and remain ourselves , want to leave ourselves behind  and take ourselves with us , want the world transfigured  and yet to remain ourselves  in a transfigured world. 
 The passage from the Virgin to the Bride a kind of death , he wrote, as is the passage from bachelor to husband. 
 Rites of passage designed solely to make transition bearable, he wrote. 
 But today? 
 Can we still talk meaningfully of rite? 
 Where is the threshold? he wrote. 
 Are we inside already? 
 Or forever outside? 
 To change is to die, he wrote, but not to change is also to die. 
 How to overcome Narcissism without self-destruction? he wrote. 
 Kafka and the blood-soaked sheets, he wrote: horror and nostalgia both. 
 Urge to build ,  to make , as compensation for anxieties of exile, he wrote. 
 Yet the more you build the greater the sense of exile. 
 On and on, he wrote. 
 On and on. 
 It is not a question of whether it is better or worse to remain a virgin or a bachelor, he wrote, but rather of bringing the terror to the surface.  
 The terror and the desire, he wrote.  
 Kafka, he wrote.  
 Always there waiting for me when I go deep enough.  
 The horror of bachelorhood  which condemns you to arid thought for ever, and the horror of marriage , which condemns you to lies and hypocrisy for ever.  
 Art itself like marriage, he wrote, as Kafka understood, with its hypocrisy  and lies, its myth of wholeness , its myth of meaning . 
 But like bachelorhood too, with its arid cranking of the  engine of thought, its empty impotence , its time drained  of all meaning. 
 The big glass, he wrote, as last work of art  and first work of non-art . 
 The big glass tells the story of the aridity of art , he wrote, of the lies of art , of the machine without the fuel to make it move . 
 The big glass as icon of aridity, he wrote, and Goldberg, in the margin, BG icon of aridity .  
 First the making of the glass, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg typed), then the showing of the glass, and then the end.  
 Apr&egrave;s moi le tinkle of broken glass, wrote Harsnet.  
 How could I ever have thought La Tartine d'Albertine would make a good title? he wrote.  
 All right as name of caf&eacute;, but no more.  
 The idea of a title, he wrote, implies an entity .  
 But what is the entity in this case?  
 Is it what is on the glass , or what is on the glass plus what is  seen through the glass, or just the glass itself ?  
 Pseudoexcitation, he wrote.  
 The Bride only pretends  to be excited.  
 The Bachelors only pretend  to be thrilled.  
 But how can we be sure? he wrote.  
 It has all happened before , he wrote, and it will all happen again .  
 There can be no title, he wrote, because there is no object .  
 There can only be description, he wrote, The Big Glass.  
 Litany of the chariot as it moves on its runners, he wrote.  
 Litany of solipsism.  
 Litany of onanism.  
 No surprises, he wrote, no hope.  
 The chariot moves back and forth , he wrote, but to no purpose .  
 No heat is engendered, he wrote.  
 Nothing happens.  
 And that  is perhaps the way they all want it.  
 For the cold is their element.  
 Timelessness is their element.  
 The hypothetical is their element.  
 Even now, he wrote, with the first heat of early summer in the middle of London, even now, with all the windows open, the glass freezes the room.  
 The sense of its otherness, he wrote, just as I wanted it, an alien object, one never before seen on our planet, not quite animal, not quite mineral, not quite vegetable, yet familiar, familiar.  
 If only we could bring it into focus, he wrote, if only we could concentrate hard enough, we might be able to understand what it is.  
 But the more we try the more the feeling of familiarity evaporates.  
 Diana, he wrote.  
 Hidden by her handmaids she is seen to blush, then turns to Actaeon and throws water in his face to blind him, to stop him seeing her naked, but that is not enough and she knows it is not enough, and soon he feels the horns growing on his forehead, dat sparso capiti vivacis cornus cervis , she caused to grow on his head the horns of the long-lived stag, as if the cost of seeing her naked had to be death, first metamorphosis then death.  
 The question is, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), does she entice him there or does he want to come?  
 Does she entice him or does he appear by chance?  
 Ovid refuses to answer, he wrote.  
 For he says, while Titania is bathing there in her accustomed pool, lo!  
 Cadmus' grandson, his day's toil deferred ( dilata parte laborem ), comes wandering through the unfamiliar woods with unsure footsteps ( per nemus ignotum non certis passibus errans ), and enters Diana's grove, for so fate would have it ( pervenit in locum: sic illum fata ferebant ).  
 How easy, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), it would have been to write: Lo, Cadmus' grandson enters Diana's grove, but no, Ovid defers the verb for a line and a half, telling us &mdash; what?  
 That, his day's toil having been deferred, he wanders through unfamiliar woods with unsure footsteps.  
 Yet where is this wandering taking him?  
 Where are those unsure footsteps taking him?  
 Where is the participle, seemingly indicating perpetual motion, errans , heading for?  
 To Diana's grove!  
 And why?  
 For so fate would have it: sic fata ferebant.   
 Sic fata ferebant , wrote  Harsnet.  
 Inscribe in glass?  
 The point is, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), that he had spent his life seeking her out, yet left his feet to do the dirty work .  
 Would the outcome have been different had he acknowledged to himself what he was doing? he wrote.  
 No, he wrote, because Diana herself does not acknowledge either that she has been waiting all  her life for him to appear.  
 That, he wrote, is the significance of the tell-tale blush.  
 Red as the clouds which flush beneath the sun's slant rays, says Ovid, red as the rosy Dawn, were the cheeks of Diana as she stood there in view without her robes.  
 She stood, Ovid tells us, turning aside a little, and cast back her gaze: in latus obliquum tamen adstitit oraque retro .  
 And her only words to him are: Now you are free to tell that you have seen me all unrobed &mdash; if you can tell!  
 - nunc tibi me posito visam velamine narres, sit poteris narrare, licet !  
 The point is, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), that Actaeon is not free to narrate what he has seen, but Ovid  is.  
 Actaeon is torn to pieces by his own dogs, but Ovid is not torn.  
 That is the pathos of the narrative, he wrote.  
 That he neither really sees nor is really torn, that he cannot enter the world of either comedy or tragedy, neither O brave new world that hath such people in it, nor Dark dark dark beneath the blaze of noon.  
 Only the story, and after that another story, and another and another.  
 Actaeon sees and Actaeon is torn, wrote Harsnet, but Ovid in his exile by the Black Sea neither sees the Goddess nor is torn by the dogs.  
 For him, wrote Harsnet, there is only the endless metamorphosis of narrative, no end except for the non-end of his death.  
 That is why only the glass will do it, wrote Harsnet.  
 Only the glass will tell the story, the story of that story, the truth of that truth, the lie of that lie.  
 That is why, he wrote, there have to be three stages, first the making of the glass, then the showing of the glass, and then the end.  
 In the Middle Ages, he wrote, the glass in the cathedral walls glowed with the fires of judgement and damnation.  
 The worshipper looked up and wondered.  
 Through the glass shone God's sun, setting the colours alight: blue, green, yellow, red.  
 The damned on Christ's left, the saved on His  right.  
 Today, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), the glass will stand in a gallery, lit by artificial light, with no right and no wrong way of looking at it, no left and no right hand, no salvation or damnation.  
 The relationship to images is destroyed, he wrote, when they are looked at only for themselves, gazed at only for themselves.  
 The truth of the museum and the gallery is a lie, he wrote.  
 Beauty is a lie.  
 Verisimilitude is a lie.  
 Masterpieces are a lie.  
 Museums and galleries as false delay , he wrote.  
 Delay of death, not delay of life, he wrote.  
 But death can only be fought with death, and life with life, he wrote.  
 Only the death of death, the unmasking of the lie of lies, he wrote.  
 The glass stands silent in the gallery, he wrote, but it burns up the lies of the gallery.  
 On the one hand, he wrote, it pushes nothing out of its way.  
 On the other it burns up everything around it.  
 On the one hand it is nothing and asks for nothing, on the other it is the secret and silent source of the destruction of everything.  
 On the one hand it makes no demands, he wrote, on the other it is the vitriol which corrodes everything with which it comes into contact, the Gorgon which turns to stone all who gaze upon it.  
 On the one hand, he wrote, it is like everything else in the gallery, on the other it is opposed to everything in the gallery.  
 It is the one because  it is the other, he wrote.  
 It is malign because  it is benign.  
 It is unlike everything else and it is the cause of the destruction of everything else because  it is no different from anything else.  
 Once installed, he wrote, it will start to do its work, and it will go on doing it, in the day-time, in the night-time, in the midst of visitors and in the empty silence, when the mausoleum is open to the public and when the mausoleum is closed to the public.  
 I will no longer be there, he wrote, but I will no longer be needed.  
 It may take five years, he wrote, or it may take ten, or a hundred or a thousand, but sooner or later everything in the mausoleum will be affected and everything in all the other mausoleums in the city, and everything in all the other mausoleums in the country, and everything in all the other mausoleums in the world.  
 And when its work is done, he wrote, it will grow quite  transparent again and then it will disintegrate.  
 Only the labels will be left, he wrote, for those who come after to examine and try to decipher, as sarcophagi and empty tombs are examined by archaeologists to try and determine who and what once lay inside them.  
 There will be no flood, he wrote, and there will be no fire, but it will do its work.  
 Negation, he wrote, once the attribute of the Devil, now the ally of the truth.  
 And when the lies have gone, he wrote, when the mausoleums lie empty, then streams will once again begin to flow and trees to bud, mountains will raise their heads again and gales will turn into gentle breezes, while the sun will only warm and never scorch.  
 Not rejection, he wrote, but seeming compliance.  
 Not offended silence but seemingly grateful speech.  
 The secret agent in his place, he wrote, the infiltrator safely ensconced.  
 For the gesture of revolt begs for understanding.  
 The gesture of rejection pleads mutely for forebearance.  
 It asks for open vindication, he wrote, but I ask only to do my task.  
 What must be done.  
 In the night.  
 In the mocking silence.  
 Narrow horizons, he wrote.  
 No favours.  
 Head down.  
 Keep going.  
 Do not listen to the tempting voices.  
 The voices which tell you to let go.  
 To give up.  
 To forget.  
 To sleep.  
 To leave it to the transforming imagination.  
 All my life, he wrote, I have used art to fight against myself.  
 To open up the darkness.  
 To make hard what is soft.  
 It had to come to this, he wrote.  
 It had to come to the nightly struggle with the big glass, like the struggle with Proteus, who must be held no matter what form he takes, bull, bear, fox, fire, water.  
 Not the strength of the body, he wrote, and not the strength of the will, but the strength of the whole self.  
 For the body by itself is not enough, he wrote.  
 The will by itself is not enough.  
 You cannot will yourself to fight against the truth, he wrote.  
 You cannot will yourself to hold out against reality.  
 If you do that, he wrote, then sooner or later the will will crack and the truth will emerge, reality will re-assert itself.  
 Only if the whole person is engaged, he wrote, only if you have the sense that the truth, in however paradoxical a form, is on your side, that reality, no matter how disguised, is what  you are working towards, only then will Proteus be defeated.  
 Not killed, not annihilated, but held fast and made to talk.  
 Kafka, he wrote.  
 Bonnard.  
 Vermeer.  
 Stravinsky.  
 Wittgenstein.  
 We each have our pantheon, he wrote.  
 We each have our team.  
 For we need all the help we can get.  
 Those for whom the whole self  is at stake, he wrote.  
 Not the preachers.  
 Not the ranters.  
 Not the inspired madmen.  
 Not the dull conformists.  
 Not the poised ironists.  
 Not the all-knowing nihilists.  
 Not those who swear only by theory or those who swear only by practice.  
 Not the splashers on of paint and not the witty designers of operatic sets, not those who claim to have their fingers on the pulse of things and not those who shut themselves up and ignore the world.  
 Not those, but the few who respect silence, who respect the world, who are prepared to listen, who are prepared to change, who are aware of human weakness and vulnerability, who are aware of the imperatives of life and the imperatives of the work in hand.  
 So Harsnet.  
 And Goldberg, pursing his lips in concentration, flicking the hair out of his eyes, typed furiously on.  
 And all this, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), in spite of the awareness, always present, sometimes blinding, of the long perspective, the common fate of all, the eventual overheating of the universe or its eventual overcooling, the end of everything.  
 Imagine an ant, he wrote, crawling up the legs of a table.  
 What sense of the table does it have?  
 Not ours, surely.  
 Does it have a sense of four legs, of the function of the surface?  
 And imagine us in our world as ants on the leg of a table.  
 Who knows but that it may look very different to bigger, different beings?  
 Another dimension, or at least our world as a single dimension among many, he wrote.  
 But how to convey this?  
 How to make the viewer perceive this?  
 Velasquez, he wrote.  
 The point of view in Las Meninas .  
 Cucumbers, he wrote.  
 Tomatoes.  
 Cauliflower if fresh and firm.  
 Lemon.  
 Olives.  
 Cream cheese.  
 Bread.  
 Two years, he wrote.  
 Two years since I started on the big glass.  
 Two years since I set up the glass and started to make marks on it.  
 The way it advanced, he wrote.  
 So much done so quickly and then nothing.  
 And  then a quick advance again and then again nothing.  
 And then the mistakes, he wrote.  
 And again the swift advance.  
 When it is done, he wrote, it should look as though it had always been there .  
 Remove all traces of process, he wrote.  
 Let it not bear the traces of work, the traces of time.  
 Shadow of reality, he wrote, yet itself reality too.  
 Not depiction of  a bride, he wrote, but bride herself .  
 Not depiction of alchemical process, but process itself.  
 First calcinatio , he wrote, then leuaosis  leading to iosis .  
 Celebration of Red (Solar) King and White (Lunar) Queen.  
 White Queen as Hanged Lady, he wrote.  
 Celebration of union of Earth and Sky, he wrote.  
 Each confined to own domain, he wrote.  
 Union cannot take place.  
 Yet at the same time mere graffito  in pissoir , he wrote.  
 The glass as a part of my life, he wrote, as a culmination  of my life.  
 The word cannot be spoken, he wrote.  
 Signs to be read only after I am gone: Know only that a message was sent.  
 The truth of the matter, he wrote, is that no one wants to be rescued.  
 We like our desert island too much.  
 We enjoy sending out our messages in bottles too much.  
 But at the same time we do  want to be saved.  
 And so on.  
 Something about that visit to the oculist in Salisbury with Marcus, he wrote.  
 Something about those magnifying glasses laid out in rows.  
 Embed magnifying glass in lower right hand? he wrote.  
 Not hole to see through but glass to alter vision?  
 Or just attach to big glass?  
 (For viewer to use if and when he wants.)  
 That visit to the Prado, he wrote.  
 Taxi from airport.  
 Straight inside.  
 Up huge stone stairs.  
 Sounds of children playing round corners.  
 As in Louvre.  
 Those huge rooms.  
 High ceilings.  
 Echos.  
 Straight through to Las Meninas .  
 The size of it.  
 Nothing had prepared me for that.  
 Photos never give any sense of size.  
 For that you have to be up against the real thing.  
 Let the eye move over it.  
 Swivel the head.  
 That combination of family snap and Last Judgement.  
 Oh my.  
 Farewell to picture as repository of meaning , welcome to picture as representation .  
 Farewell without nostalgia.  
 Welcome without enthusiasm.  
 Just the way it has to be.  
 No more.  
 No less.  
 My pathetic attempt to combine snapshot and Last Judgement  in early picture of God and his family, God in suit with cigar, Mary, white hair, Joseph ditto, child Jesus playing with dove, sailor suit.  
 First time theme  of picture excited me though.  
 Don't know why.  
 Some sort of tension I suppose.  
 What people objected to in the end was not God, as I'd thought, but the suburban house in the background and the garden out of House and Garden.  
 Taxi then from Prado and night train up to L&eacute;on.  
 Sometimes half an hour is enough.  
 Enough for a lifetime.  
 What was I reading then?  
 Waiting in Madrid Station buffet?  
 Pierrot mon ami ?  
 Feel it in my hands still, the little livre de poche edn.  
 The great thing is to keep your hands clean.  
 Not add to the pollution.  
 The evasions of someone like Goldberg.  
 The hypocrisies.  
 The self-deceptions.  
 I love you but I love her more.  
 The dictates of the heart.  
 Leaving the children will destroy me.  
 But then living with her is destroying me.  
 You don't know what it means.  
 And when I'm with the other I just feel myself to be a better  person.  
 She makes me discover things in myself I didn't know were there.  
 That can't be all bad, can it?  
 It must mean  something, mustn't it?  
 So he thinks of himself as a warm-hearted, caring human being.  
 An upright man.  
 Which in a sense he is.  
 But always this trail of slime.  
 A week's good work and then a week of drought, wrote Harsnet.  
 That seems to be the pattern.  
 But no easier to deal with for that reason.  
 When that happens, he wrote, I don't just feel I'm not moving forward, I feel I'm sliding right back.  
 That if I'm not going forward I'm going back .  
 My body just won't respond to the glass.  
 Nor my mind.  
 I get nothing from it.  
 I look at it and I don't even see it.  
 Sense of unease, he wrote, growing quickly into sense of revulsion .  
 Pain in the stomach, he wrote.  
 Not just at contemplation of the glass but at the thought of its being here, in the flat, with me.  
 Not only revulsion, he wrote, but a sense of indignity .  
 Of shame.  
 As though its presence in some way accused  me.  
 As though my relationship to it dirtied  me.  
 Not the desire to destroy it, but rather to turn time back and let me never have been involved with it.  
 I can hardly bear to enter the room where it stands, he wrote.  
 Even the flat.  
 I loiter  about outside, remember unnecessary errands.  
 All the time I would like to be somewhere  else, someone  else.  
 But I'm not.  
 I'm me.  
 I can't escape it.  
 It contaminates my sleep.  
 It destroys my digestive system.  
 How has this happened?  
 Why is it doing this to me?  
 Not despair at failure.  
 That is bearable.  
 It suggests that next time, with a little more luck, or hard work, success may come.  
 No.  
 It is much more physical than that.  
 Revulsion as the most basic of the instincts.  
 Revulsion at the thought that I am responsible for it .  
 At the thought that I could ever have imagined it had any value.  
 Stomach turning over, he wrote.  
 Sense of degradation .  
 But why?  
 Because I have wasted my time with something like that?  
 But how else should  I have spent my time?  
 Sense that in spite of everything it too only adds to the stream of lies and filth?  
 That I too have done my little bit for pollution?  
 And I dared to condemn Goldberg.  
 And Hilda.  
 Madge.  
 Helen.  
 At least they never pretended to be pure.  
 A feeling, wrote Harsnet, such as I have never experienced before, not so much of wishing I had never been born, as never been born as me .  
 And the feeling of this as the ultimate sin against the Holy Ghost.  
 The reason destroying it now would be no solution, he wrote, is that what sickens me is not the object itself  but the time and thought I have put into it .  
 Be very clear, he wrote: I do not feel that it is time and thought wasted because the end result is less than I had hoped.  
 But rather that the time and thought put into it had somehow polluted me.  
 That  can never be destroyed.  
 Denied.  
 The nights spent in the room under the cold fluorescent light.  
 The careful compiling of the notes for the box.  
 Why?  
 For what?  
 The question I return to, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), is always the same: I put everything into this, everything I had by way of mind and body and heart, and this  is what I have produced.  
 Does this then reveal to me what I am?  
 No more excuses, I said at the start.  
 If I am to live by that, he wrote, then this represents all I am capable of.  
 The best of me.  
 This rubbish.  
 This trash.  
 Who will absolve me now?  
 I want it to be as though I had never been.  
 I want it to be as though I had never taken that turning.  
 But that  cannot be.  
 There it is.  
 Ocular proof.  
 The irony of my vision of the glass burning up the rest of the exhibits in the gallery in which it is housed, when here it is, burning up everything around it in this flat, burning me up.  
 So Harsnet.  
 And Goldberg in the margin: Despair.   
 Self-hatred .  
 Days, wrote Harsnet, since I last entered the room.  
 Days spent staring at the wall.  
 Days since I opened this notebook.  
 Horror of the summer noises in the street.  
 Horror of the dogs running on the Common.  
 Days eating scraps because I could not bear to enter a shop, talk to another human being, have people see me .  
 Tried working through the Alekhine Paz had given me, but even chess filled me with disgust.  
 Yet a kind of relief now at writing all this down.  
 Yesterday I couldn't have done it.  
 Couldn't have picked up the pen and opened the notebook and faced the blank page.  
 Does my writing this down now mean that I am a little bit reconciled to myself?  
 Those words of Kafka's, which have never ceased to haunt me: Where does the strength come from to write.: I have no strength any more?  
 The question he is really asking, I think, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), is this: Is that secret strength a minus  or a plus ?  
 One more temptation or the start of a recovery?  
 Will it ever be given us to know?  
 How many bad paintings, books, pieces of music we owe to this final, mysterious strength, he wrote.  
 How many banal and clumsy, weak and foolish artists have justified their work as that which saved them from despair.  
 Is that a reason to dismiss them or their claims?  
 Not dismiss, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg).  
 I merely state the facts.  
 Fortunately, he wrote, while every person, more or less, in the Western world, has access to pen and paper and can write down a word or two, few will turn as naturally to painting or music to soothe their troubled breasts.  
 Some consolation, he wrote.  
 My loathing of terms like depression and despair, he wrote.  
 Not that buoyant optimism much better.  
 Yesterday able to enter the room once more, he wrote.  
 Not easy, but I was able to do it.  
 The physical  revulsion gone at least.  
 As always, amazed at the size of it, nine feet high and six across.  
 Approached it as lovers approach each other after  a quarrel, waiting to see how it would respond.  
 Could not stay long in the room with it, but the ice had been broken.  
 Could at least think about it, visualize it again, if not with pleasure, at least not with that sick-making horror of the past few weeks.  
 How everything stopped.  
 Even this notebook.  
 How I slept too much, and less and less well of course, but the truth was I did not want to wake up .  
 How the days, instead of each being distinct  from each other, merged  into each other.  
 May all that be behind me.  
 Another week gone by, he wrote.  
 Any idea that the bout of despair was over was quickly dispelled as the old horror came over me again in waves.  
 Dragged myself to the doctor who told me I had to expect such things at my age and prescribed vitamin pills.  
 I thanked him and tore up the prescription at the door.  
 But last two days a little better.  
 Perhaps I tried to force the pace.  
 Perhaps I should simply have left it alone for a while.  
 But alone to do what?  
 Either I work on the big glass, he wrote, or my life is not worth living.  
 Easy to see what effect sudden nausea at even the thought of the big glass would have on a life lived in this way.  
 But that is how it is.  
 No doubt if I had responded to Hilda and Annie and the rest as they told me I should respond, as they all told me my true nature, my deeper  nature was crying out to  respond, I would be surrounded today by love and wives and children and the rest. 
 Goldberg a living example of the folly of such dreams, he wrote. 
 Not so much the compromises, the deceits, the hypocrisies affecting his work, his women, his children, even his friends, but the sense of despair and failure hovering over him, as though he was trapped and didn't know how it had happened or what he should or could do. 
 So Harsnet. 
 And Goldberg, pushing the typewriter from him, dragging the pad towards him, Dear Harsnet, I am well aware of the fact that you have cut yourself off from all your old friends, and that you wish to have nothing more to do with them. 
 You will recall, however, that before you vanished from our lives you entrusted me with the notes you had kept while working on the Big Glass and the Green Box, telling me I could do what I liked  with them, and adding, in your usual sensitive way, that I could always use them to wipe my arse if the paper decided to sack me and I found myself really hard up. 
 As I wrote to you at the time (since you refused even then to see me or any of your old friends and supporters) I accepted the MS as a sacred trust and would do what I could to see that it eventually saw the light of day in the most appropriate form. 
 I had thought at the time, wrote Goldberg, turning the page, wiping his brow, taking a sip of orange juice from the glass on the desk beside him, dreaming for a moment of the cigarettes he had given up two years earlier, I had thought, he wrote, that an edited version of the text, with only those comments directly concerned with the Big Glass included, would serve you best. 
 I had to put the project aside for a while, he wrote, as the rent had to be paid, not to speak of alimony, school fees and the rest, and, coming back to it after a considerable period, much longer, unfortunately, than I had anticipated, and I will not even try to apologize since you gave me a completely free hand &mdash; anyway, he wrote, trying to ignore the damp spots left on the page of his pad by his sweaty hands, anyway, coming back to it after all that time I realized that it would be quite impossible in practice to separate the valuable and the worthless, the public and the private, and that, in a sense, one would have to think in terms of either publishing the whole thing exactly as it stood , or not doing it at all. 
 Though there is a good deal there which I found deeply offensive, he wrote, as you must have realized when you sent me the stuff, though, knowing you as I do, I suspect it may not even have crossed your mind, anyway, to be brief, I have, of course, put my feelings to one side and decided to honour the integrity of. 
 Pushing the pad aside he returned to his typing. 
 But is that not what he wanted? he typed (as Harsnet had written). 
 Do not most of us search for excuses most of the time? 
 Excuses not to do the work we think we might or should do, excuses not to be kind or considerate or whatever it is we feel we should be? 
 What he  wanted, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg) and what I wanted. 
 The difference  is that I knew  what I wanted and he did not . 
 Though, wrote Harsnet, that difference may not be as great as I sometimes imagine. 
 For what does know mean in such cases? 
 What does want mean? 
 Everything a substitute for everything else, he wrote. 
 Migration of desire, he wrote. 
 Migration of meaning. 
 Never where you think it is. 
 Only traces left. 
 Footprints. 
 Fingerprints. 
 Glass as trace of a fourth dimension, he wrote. 
 Oculist charts at bottom right hand? he wrote. 
 Not hole. 
 Not magnifying glass, but oculist charts. 
 My unease at having to cut into  the glass, at having to add to  the glass, he wrote. 
 Yet my sense that that was the place for a transformation of vision. 
 If top panel is without perspective and bottom is nothing but perspective, then is that not the place for a different kind of vision? 
 Oculist charts the answer? 
 Distinct from flatness of top and from perspective of bottom, he wrote. 
 Three types of projection then, he wrote, to go with the three rollers on the grinder, the three draft pistons, the three times three malic moulds, the three times three shots. 
 Three oculist charts, he wrote. 
 Place on top of each other in different perspective from rest of panel. 
 Slices of invisible column, he wrote. 
 Or sense of circles moving away from us. 
 Incise straight onto the glass, he wrote. 
 The idea of the witnesses keeps alive the detective story element in my work, he wrote, and especially in the big glass. 
 Private eye and myths of sky and earth, he wrote. 
 Philip Marlowe and Actaeon. 
 As always, he wrote, painting lags behind literature, which saw the connection as long ago as Poe. 
 Painting nearly always fifty years or even a hundred behind the times. 
 The world of Grosz for instance. 
 Gives the impression of being so contemporary but really plays out themes of nineteenth century, badies, goodies, etc. 
 Why we feel comfortable  with such art, however grotesque, whereas the greatest art always leaves us a little bit uncomfortable , as though the earth we stood on had given a sudden lurch. 
 A murder has been committed, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg). 
 A bride has been killed. 
 Unfulfilled desire roams unchecked, lacking a clear origin or goal. 
 Civil servant who cut up the boys he lured back to his house, burned the  pieces, buried them. 
 Smell alerted the neighbours who suspected faulty sewers. 
 Woman abducted on motorway in broad daylight while phoning AA. 
 Later murdered. 
 Man going berserk in Surrey commuter town, gunning down thirty. 
 The fruits of peace. 
 Launderette yesterday, he wrote. 
 Two women. 
 Wait till I catch up with him. 
 I'll show him what it means to walk out on his family. 
 I'll cut him up small and fry him for the kids' breakfast. 
 And on the bus: Every morning he comes out into the garden with his cup of tea and stands there, looking round. 
 I can see him from the kitchen window you see. 
 Every morning it's just the same routine. 
 He comes out into the garden and sips his tea and looks around. 
 Sometimes he looks straight at me. 
 He can't see me of course but it makes me feel funny. 
 Sometimes he walks slowly over and inspects one of his plants. 
 I never liked the look of him. 
 Work out double perspective, wrote Harsnet. 
 Select charts. 
 Find method of incising. 
 And Goldberg in the margin: Oculist charts . 
 Still a kind of fear, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg, sighing, typed). 
 Fear that all this may just be in my head. 
 Fear that when I finally go in and face it, ready to start, the old revulsion will rise up in me again. 
 Fear that I have only dreamed of moving forward, that when I go in and face it I will see that it is a mistake, not possible, uninteresting. 
 That it was never on. 
 Stay with it, he wrote. 
 The important thing is to stay with it. 
 The closer I get to completion the more I dread it, he wrote. 
 Why? 
 The more there is to go wrong, of course. 
 When you start there is a sense in which everything you do is right, there is no clear sense of wrong, though of course it is here that you may make the inevitable false move, take the inevitable wrong turning. 
 But this will only emerge much later. 
 At the time all is sweetness and light. 
 By now I have already committed myself to so much, he wrote. 
 It is myself in there. 
 Myself I am afraid to face. 
 Myself without excuses. 
 Myself after trying my hardest for three whole years. 
 Is this all you have to show for it? he wrote. 
 Is this what you imagined the culmination of your life would be? 
 Until now I could always say: this is trivial, not important, but tomorrow  I m starting the big one. 
 But now I have  started it, am well on with it, this is it, this is me, no avoiding the fact. 
 Is this then all you are? 
 All you want? 
 I have to say yes because there is nothing else. 
 I have done what I wanted, or thought I wanted, I have pushed as hard as I could, and this is it. 
 No alibi. 
 I was not elsewhere. 
 I was here. 
 It was not someone else. 
 It was me. 
 I did it. 
 Is this then the last temptation? he wrote. 
 To say: Only this? 
 After all, he wrote, who am I to judge? 
 Only? he wrote. 
 Why only? 
 Because that's what it feels like today, he wrote, and because I know in my heart of hearts that it will feel like that tomorrow as well. 
 Limit the horizons, he wrote. 
 Keep going. 
 Figure out how to incise the charts. 
 Think of that corner of the glass. 
 The blind king led by his daughter. 
 After that he is on his own. 
 Just the three parts of the project, he wrote: the finishing of the glass, the showing of the glass, and the end. 
 So Harsnet. 
 Work on the charts progressing, he wrote. 
 Working on negative, scraping away silver. 
 Slow, he wrote, but I like it like that. 
 The slower the better, he wrote, since one of the problems is the speed with which it could all be over. 
 It is beginning to transform the rest, he wrote. 
 The contiguous circles to be read as either columnar or flat. 
 Whichever way, a new perspective is introduced into lower panel. 
 Starting to make bachelor apparatus interesting again, as I hoped it might. 
 My old dream, he wrote: get away from agony of background-foreground and from the over-assertiveness usually involved in destruction of that relationship. 
 Get away from perpetual need to fill in, fill up, he wrote. 
 With us since Giotto, he wrote. 
 Yet while empty part of wall or canvas feels sloppy, unfinished, this is not the case with the glass. 
 Here transparency is benign. 
 What floats onto it floats onto it. 
 Basta. 
 Good work the past few nights, he wrote. 
 Very hot. 
 Windows wide open. 
 Drunken shouts from street, Common. 
 Peace. 
 Not that terrible assertion of the self, of what the self sees or imagines it sees or just sees in imagination. 
 Not that terrible sense of showing off. 
 Art as aggression, he wrote. 
 You will see it my  way. 
 Look how clever, profound, etc. 
 I am. 
 Admire. 
 Pay. 
 Etc. 
 All that gone with  glass, he wrote. 
 The open window, he wrote. 
 The glass on which objects float, mingling with the wall behind. 
 If you want a story, you can have one. 
 If not, not. 
 If you want to walk round it, you can do so. 
 If you want to get on with more important things , nothing stops you. 
 If you want to watch your reflection pacing beside you, there it is. 
 A narrative, he wrote. 
 Or a poem. 
 Or an enigma. 
 Yesterday, he wrote, it started to dance for me again. 
 I did not look at the rest of it, deliberately. 
 But could feel it all. 
 Sense of its presence, he wrote, but not an oppressive presence (as with For Micah , for example). 
 Benign? he wrote. 
 Perhaps. 
 Sense of buoyancy. 
 Forget titles, he wrote. 
 Big glass is enough. 
 Big drinker. 
 Big dipper. 
 But telescope not far away too. 
 Try saying big glass as you would say big game  and then as you would say big deal . 
 At last lower panel taking shape, he wrote. 
 Beginning to think now of boxing match in upper panel right. 
 Gone back to old sketches. 
 Problem is to balance movement of chariot (with its solipsistic litany). 
 In pub today, big fight on TV. 
 Fifteen dreary rounds. 
 No electricity. 
 Two tired men holding on to each other to stop themselves falling down. 
 And referee trying to prize them apart, to keep at least the pretence of a fight going. 
 Audience booing. 
 My old dream of a play set in a boxing-ring, he wrote. 
 The ape-devil who bangs his drum and shouts: Comedy! 
 Tragedy! 
 Melodrama! 
 And the six (or eight) who carry out his instructions. 
 Six-minute Hamlet , etc. 
 How he stops them. 
 Starts them again. 
 Slows them down. 
 Speeds them up. 
 Gets them to repeat moments he likes. 
 How they gradually pull away from him. 
 Carry out his orders with more and more reluctance. 
 How he grows angry. 
 Then mad. 
 Tries to force them into position. 
 They go limp. 
 Then turn on him. 
 Destroy him. 
 Mechanical operation of the spirit. 
 And my other dream: Eight foot high puppet Clytemnestra and ten-foot Agamemnon. 
 Reduplicated in three-foot puppets, on wheels, on rails running round auditorium. 
 She chases him round and round. 
 Up goes the axe. 
 Down goes the axe. 
 Three times I am struck, alas alas. 
 And Cassandra hooting and howling. 
 The chariot goes back and forth, back and  forth, chanting its litany, he wrote. 
 The water-mill goes round and round. 
 The chocolate-grinder grinds and grinds. 
 The scissors snip and snip. 
 Bring boxing-match down to top edge of lower panel? he wrote. 
 My feeling now that top panel should not be touched. 
 How it grew upon me in the night, he wrote. 
 Even at the cost of dropping duck-rabbit effect and cast shadows. 
 Everything suddenly fluid again, he wrote. 
 As though those charts have opened up the glass, made everything start to live  once more. 
 Must take care, he wrote. 
 What is there is there. 
 Too much gone through to go back now. 
 And yet? 
 The longing to start again. 
 No, he wrote. 
 Forward is the only way. 
 If there was ever a time to change things radically that time has long passed. 
 And I would not give another year of my life to a new version, he wrote. 
 I knew when I first thought of it, he wrote, when I first set it up, that it was to be the final piece. 
 I knew once I started that there would be no going back. 
 Doubts now only the result of panic, he wrote. 
 Of the sense that perhaps everything  needs rethinking, that perhaps next time  I might get it right. 
 That is the difference, he wrote, between me and Goldberg, me and McGrindle and the rest. 
 They can always start again and it doesn't matter . 
 Even Bacon can destroy what he doesn't like and start again. 
 But if you can start again it means you have not even begun . 
 I have begun, wrote Harsnet. 
 Time has closed again behind me. 
 What is there is there. 
 Put aside thoughts of altering, he wrote. 
 Time will tell. 
 Not me. 
 I will not be there to hear it. 
 Began to see last night, he wrote, that duck-rabbit effect only variant on boxing-match. 
 And anyway that area in danger of getting too cluttered. 
 The glass needs to breathe, he wrote. 
 You have to dare to let it breathe. 
 You have to listen to the nature of its breathing. 
 The rhythm of its breathing. 
 The hardest thing, he wrote, is not to go on and on. 
 L&eacute;vi-Strauss on primitive need to cover whole surface, he wrote. 
 ping-pong not boxing? he wrote. 
 Analyse, analyse, he wrote. 
 Then follow your instinct. 
 Letter from Moira Fielding, he wrote. 
 Wants to come and see glass. 
 Organizing British show at Edinburgh Festival next year. 
 Is this the right venue? 
 Why  not? he wrote. 
 Lunch with Brian, he wrote. 
 Incontinent dog. 
 Has to walk after him with little trowel and paper bag. 
 Writing television series dramatizing life of Jane Austen. 
 Filled me with depression. 
 Perhaps ask Goldberg over to see glass. 
 May help resolve remaining problems. 
 Ping-pong no solution. 
 Tried moving to right but then too close to frame. 
 But oculist charts perfect. 
 Sat and glowed with satisfaction for a few hours in silence, studying their effect. 
 How they play against wall and wainscoting behind. 
 Impossible to reconcile space suggested by charts and space of room, which is just what I wanted, but for so long didn't know how to arrive at. 
 The nights spent scraping away the silver backing among the best in my whole life, he wrote. 
 Nothing but the sound of the scraper and the joy of uncovering. 
 Yet none of that nonsense about Michelangelo and the stone. 
 In the end a false and depressing view of what man is and can be. 
 Mine the art of the cripple, the retarded, the autistic, not the beautiful and whole. 
 For who is beautiful and whole? 
 Nineteenth century tries to stifle doubts by crushing you with sheer bulk, he wrote. 
 I want my doubts to play and dance. 
 And Goldberg, drawing his pad towards him: The very words he used to excuse his behaviour at the wedding. 
 it did not pacify Madge, he wrote, and when he told her they could have another go at it the following month she told him she had had enough. 
 It didn't stop her hoping, waiting and hoping, for the next five years, he wrote, wasting her life when it was obvious he had no intention of going through with it. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, I am well aware of the fact that for some years now you have cut yourself off from your past and not deigned to reply to the letters of your friends, or even to return their calls, taking refuge in your answering machine and pretending not to be in when they rang at the bell. 
 However, I have now been through the notebook you left with me and there are a few things I wish. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, it has taken me longer than I had at first anticipated to work my way through the manuscript you. 
 Ping-pong doubles match perhaps? wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg set to typing again). 
 Relate to  hypothetical activity of roller, grinder, sieves and mill, he wrote. 
 Moira Fielding, he wrote. 
 She stood at the door and stared. 
 I told her she was the first person to see it since I started work on it. 
 I watched her with interest but felt nothing. 
 Completely detached, for some reason. 
 She tried to be casual. 
 Reeled off list of recent purchases by Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art: paolozzi, Bacon, Kitaj, Freud, Hockney, Rauschenberg, Stella, Baselitz. 
 Plans to make next year's show at the Festival the biggest ever in Britain of British art. 
 Glass would have pride of place, she said. 
 If I finish it, I said. 
 If you finish it, she said. 
 So second step taken care of, though first not yet completed. 
 Letter from her later about possible purchase. 
 Long way to go, I wrote back. 
 Told her I might decide to scrap the whole thing. 
 But I no longer believe that myself. 
 Know it's too far advanced, must make its own way from now on. 
 perhaps ask Goldberg in to test his reactions. 
 It will have to be installed either by a window or in the middle of the largest room you've got, I told her. 
 I can see just where it will go, she said. 
 Life has to be going on on both sides of it, I told her. 
 She said she understood. 
 promised to send me photos of the gallery. 
 It's very special, she said. 
 For past few nights: struggle with ping-pong idea. 
 No solution. 
 Reverted to boxing-match. 
 As so often, first idea best, though you only discover that when you've decided to discard it and try something else. 
 But tension starting to drain out of whole thing. 
 As though now I know it will get done it is already in the past. 
 Air less thin in the room. 
 Sense of glass expanding as I enter. 
 Almost of it rising to meet me. 
 No longer that fear, that ice round my heart and in the pit of my stomach. 
 But that is the inevitable second phase. 
 I have been at this job long enough, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), to know in advance what the different phases will be. 
 The second phase is: familiarity, friendliness. 
 Wait for the third, he wrote, for the return of otherness, oddity, spikiness. 
 Allowed my eyes to wander over the whole of it, he wrote, and almost with satisfaction. 
 At least without pain. 
 Sure to feel again soon that I've botched it. 
 My last chance and I've  made a mess of it. 
 But may have been through that earlier. 
 Decided on 300 as optimum print run for notes to go in Green Box. 
 A hundred to send out to specific individuals and institutions. 
 Two hundred to make their own way in the world. 
 Sense of pleasure at thought of someone trying to imagine glass only from notes in Green Box. 
 From detailed descriptions of elements out of which it has been made. 
 From biographies of the separate items: the glass, the frame, the wire, the paint. 
 In Buenos Aires perhaps, or Kinchasa. 
 Destroy glass and leave only box? 
 A kind of solution, he wrote. 
 But why not let glass make its own way? 
 To destroy perhaps to attach too much importance to it. 
 To suggest that it is worth the effort of destruction. 
 Actually, he wrote, more difficult to destroy now than myself. 
 Literally, of course, not metaphorically. 
 Moses and the Golden Calf, he wrote. 
 First break in pieces. 
 Then pulverize. 
 Then strew on water and make the people drink. 
 What energy, he wrote. 
 What anger. 
 Now, he wrote, it is in a little room in a nondescript Victorian terraced house in a side-street in South London. 
 Then it steps out into the world. 
 No fanfares. 
 Let it make its way or not, as fate determines. 
 First the making of the glass, as I always planned, he wrote. 
 Then the public exhibition of the glass. 
 And finally, for me, the end. 
 So my life: before glass, with glass, end. 
 The king is dead, long live the king. 
 But still a long way to go. 
 The bride complete. 
 Two-dimensional reproduction of three-dimensional shadow of four-dimensional creature. 
 Milky Way complete too. 
 And the three screens for the projection of the Bride's message. 
 Goldberg delighted when I told him about the gauze and the draught, he wrote. 
 Milky Way and Oculist Witnesses give me most satisfaction, he wrote. 
 No element in glass to rest on my own arbitrary decision alone, he wrote. 
 Central principle. 
 That is the trouble with the boxing-match, he wrote. 
 Why it won't get going. 
 My arbitrary decision to hang up gauze and let draught play on it, but not my decision what the result  of that play would be. 
 Shape dictated by draught, he wrote, as configuration of oculist witnesses dictated by perspective. 
 So the central  principle of the glass: find the rules to work by and then stick to them. 
 But that has always been my way, he wrote. 
 Hence revulsion at brush. 
 Too much dependent on hand, eye, mind. 
 No. 
 I knew I was on the right track when I felt that thrill of pleasure at placing  object, not painting  it. 
 Each element nothing in itself, but whole more than sum of parts, he wrote. 
 (Yet beauty of glass is that the story it tells is that the parts cannot cohere, cannot form a whole, even though they would like to .) 
 That is why it had to be big. 
 And from the start both divided and joined: two panels, one frame, yet each panel also enclosed in its own frame. 
 The questioning of boundaries . 
 The questioning of limits . 
 Failure of shots to take effect, he wrote. 
 Time spent looking for toy cannon. 
 Fun of firing paint-soaked matches. 
 Yet terrible weakness of final effect. 
 The dots could have been made in other ways, and hardly noticeable anyway. 
 Nothing in the final results leads you to sense of how it was achieved. 
 Not true of rest. 
 Once chosen, sense of uniqueness adheres to each element, each effect. 
 Resonance of result, as one plays against other and eye moves across and round and up and down. 
 One could easily get lost in there forever, Moira F. said. 
 That is why it needs to be transparent, I said. 
 A background of the ordinary. 
 Of trees growing in a garden outside window. 
 Of people walking about a room. 
 And so on. 
 Otherwise perhaps too dangerous. 
 I don't want anyone to get lost in it, I said. 
 To be unable to get back. 
 Only I do want effect of possibility  of getting lost. 
 I think she understood. 
 Death, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg). 
 Going under ground, as the Greeks said. 
 I think of it more as a diving into still water. 
 Most marks for smallest splash. 
 My recurring thought, he wrote: that the big glass will only start to breathe when I am gone. 
 There is not enough room in the world for the two of us, he wrote. 
 Set it on its feet, he wrote, and then let it go. 
 Picasso. 
 And Goldberg in the margin: for the whole of the time I knew him he had, stuck on his studio wall, a reproduction of Picasso's amazing 1943 painting of the mother teaching her child to walk.  
 That's not only what life is all about, he would say, pointing to it, it's what art's all  about too . 
 You dive in, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), and the water closes over you. 
 Silence. 
 But something is at work in the world. 
 Something is on the move in the world. 
 In a bookshop in Reykjavik someone buys a copy of the Green Box. 
 Lovers meet in front of the big glass. 
 I am not talking about the long run, he wrote. 
 I have said enough about the long run already, where there will be no more Reykjavik and no more big glass and not even any more lovers. 
 I am only talking about the next hundred years, he wrote, perhaps even only the next decade. 
 But it can only happen, he wrote, if it is totally and utterly divorced from me. 
 As though I had never been. 
 A little fuss at the time cannot be avoided, he wrote, that is obvious. 
 Whether I destroy the clothes first or fold them neatly the papers will have to have their story. 
 But that will soon be forgotten. 
 Only the glass will remain. 
 Goldberg delighted, he wrote. 
 Told him only Moira F. had seen it so far. 
 He wanted to rush round straight away but I asked him to be patient. 
 Socks, he wrote. 
 Pullover (M&amp;S). 
 Tea. 
 Moira F. on phone. 
 I reminded her how fragile it was. 
 She will send her best men down. 
 It may not be ready in time, I told her, there's still a long way to go. 
 The year after then, she said. 
 Keep working. 
 As if I needed any incentive. 
 Area of boxing-match and duck-rabbit refuses to resolve itself. 
 Is the problem that it is too much like a repetition of other areas of the glass? 
 The glider for instance? 
 Pleased with the way dust has settled on the sieves. 
 The difficult calculations there beginning to pay off. 
 Though my early dream of cones directly related to moulds and maintained in course of 180&deg; rotation had to be abandoned. 
 But enough survives. 
 And dust really beginning to look good. 
 Blissful week, he wrote. 
 And Goldberg, in the margin: sieves, dust . 
 Strange how certain areas seem to call out to me, wrote Harsnet, and working on them doesn't seem like work at all, more like simply breathing. 
 So tired, he wrote. 
 My plan of writing in here every day after night of work on glass and green box beginning to crumble. 
 Forty months of non-stop work on one project beginning to take its toll. 
 End seems as far away as ever,  he wrote, with the whole of the lower right panel still to sort out. 
 I was never in any hurry though, he wrote. 
 I always knew it would take time. 
 Mistake was perhaps to let Moira F. see it at this stage, he wrote. 
 All those people wear me out. 
 Nothing but running around and organizing. 
 Organizing, he wrote. 
 When the history of our times comes to be written, They Organized Themselves to Death will be the only possible epitaph. 
 No doubt they mean well where the arts are concerned, he wrote, but for that reason  they are the biggest menace. 
 No doubt they think they have the interests of the artist at heart, he wrote, but for that reason  they must be avoided like the plague. 
 No doubt they see themselves as devoted middlewomen, bringing the truly important work of the time to the avid masses, but all they are really doing, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg) is fucking up the lives of both sets of people. 
 They bring time into what is essentially timeless , he wrote. 
 They bring anxiety about venues and dates into what is essentially a calm and anxiety-free  activity. 
 They try to ram down the throat of the public what the public quite rightly does not want. 
 The Arts Council should be abolished, he wrote. 
 And the Royal Arts Fund. 
 And the Royal Literary Society. 
 And the Royal Ballet. 
 And the Royal Academy. 
 Especially the Royal Academy, he wrote, with its Presidents and its private views and its Signed Goblets and its Concerts of Spanish music to go with the Murillo exhibition and its Concerts of Russian music to go with its Tatlin exhibition and its Concerts of Dutch music to go with its de Hooch exhibition, and its Silk-screened Scarves and its Special Offers and its Jigsaws of the Raft of Medusa and La Grande Jatte and its Good Taste and its Tondo and its Education Department and its Restaurant with its Tasty Snacks and its Cold Buffet and its Glass of Wine and its Napkins Designed by a Living Artist, and its Proximity to Cork Street, with its Galleries and their Private Views and their Favoured Clients and their Phone Calls to New York and their Summer Shows and their Autumn Shows and their Winter Shows and their Embossed Invitations and their Highly Polished Floors. 
 There is no  end to it all, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg). 
 When you begin to think about it you grow dizzy, your stomach turns over, not just at the commercialism of it all, but at the aestheticism  of it all, not just at the chequebooks but at the Intelligent Conversations, not just at the fifty percent but at the Sensitive Responses, not just at the winks and nods but at the Hushed Silence in the Presence of Art. 
 Our civilization will be destroyed, he wrote, not by the Bomb but by its reverence for the Creative Spirit. 
 Better never enter a church, he wrote, than enter in a spirit of false awe. 
 Churches and art galleries, he wrote. 
 That funereal atmosphere. 
 False awe in the face of death, he wrote. 
 No one knowing how to react, all speaking in low tones with solemn faces. 
 It is the same with art, he wrote. 
 Now even artists work with awed expressions, he wrote. 
 Talk in whispers. 
 Ape the critics. 
 Ape the dealers. 
 Ape the organizers. 
 True art as a release from Art, he wrote. 
 The glass as freedom, not constraint. 
 As mirror of reality, not Monument to Creativity. 
 None the less, he wrote, I should not have let her see it. 
 Goldberg here last night, he wrote. 
 Fatter and more unhealthy-looking than ever. 
 Black circles round his eyes. 
 Collar invisible in folds of neck. 
 Patting his cheeks with his handkerchief all the time (till I asked him to stop it). 
 Usual stories about true love at last. 
 About need to pay for daughter's education. 
 You don't know how much a growing girl needs, etc. 
 Monograph on Motherwell to pay for year's schooling. 
 Article on Schoenberg and the Expressionist Ethos. 
 Yet the old seriousness still there, and the old laughter. 
 Asked to be left alone with the glass for a while. 
 So left him and walked down to the river. 
 Dirt everywhere. 
 Old newspapers. 
 London now part slum part consumer paradise. 
 Bellow when last here: A playground for the rich. 
 Monte-Carlo on the Thames. 
 Convinced that Chicago better because abattoir still functions. 
 Won't be contradicted. 
 Israel a disaster. 
 French writing a disaster. 
 Academics a disaster. 
 Thought of him tonight as I walked down to the river. 
 His romantic idea that gangsters closer to reality than the rest of us. 
 And, since he's friendly with a few, he too closer,  etc. 
 Preserve me from the self-confidence of a famous late middle age. 
 The myth of the immigrant kid. 
 The myth of the reality of power. 
 American belief that the more you experience the more human you are, and that experience means pain, ecstasy, etc. 
 Hadn't thought about him for years. 
 The stink of hops hanging in the air, wafted over from Wandsworth breweries. 
 Motorbikes lining the road by the hot-dog stall. 
 Police waiting in the shadows. 
 Traffic streaming non-stop over the bridge. 
 Beautiful sense of anonymity. 
 As if now Goldberg is in the room with the glass I no longer exist. 
 Joy as sheet of old newspaper whirled across the road and wrapped itself round my leg. 
 I looked down. 
 It was my leg all right, but somehow detached from me. 
 Or I was detached from it. 
 After that, strangely, for the first time began to feel the glow of achievement. 
 Not satisfaction at quality of whatever I had done, but simply at having done it at all. 
 Having stuck at it. 
 Something as big as that. 
 As ambitious. 
 Joy that my own hands had done it. 
 Something that could never be undone, only destroyed outright. 
 Sense that if I could let Goldberg see it there must be something there to see. 
 Still much to do, but main task done. 
 The leg that had stopped the newspaper had borne me up. 
 The hands in my pockets had measured and scraped, put on and taken off. 
 Something which had not been there three years ago now existed. 
 Yet that something not so much a thing  as an eye . 
 Not so much an eye as a template . 
 Or perhaps a lens. 
 Shook newspaper off and the wind sent it whirling into the railings of the park. 
 Motorbikes taking off with ear-shattering roar. 
 Strolled back along the Park, then up one of the side-streets. 
 At once in suburban London. 
 Anonymous city. 
 Thought of fat Goldberg shuffling round the glass in the little room, rubbing his unshaven cheeks, wheezing. 
 There he was when I entered, on the other side of the glass. 
 I had only seen a wall there before, and now my heart leapt when I saw, through the Bride and the Bachelors, through the Milky Way and the Chariot and the Grinder and the Sieves - someone moving. 
 (Had Moira F. not looked, not moved? 
 Why had I not felt this when she was there? 
 Perhaps I had  not wanted to feel? 
 Had not been ready to feel?) 
 The old dream realized. 
 What had been in my head for so long now out there, in the world. 
 I waited. 
 I watched him. 
 He came round to my side, stood beside me for a while, looking, puffing. 
 Then he said: This is quite something. 
 What about the right hand side? 
 I said. 
 That's what I want to know. 
 But he couldn't help. 
 Only kept repeating it was quite something, that he'd have to think about it, that it would take time to assimilate. 
 Wouldn't be drawn. 
 We've known each for long enough to know that silence is better if there is nothing specific to say. 
 Please, I said to him, no hints dropped in the course of articles on other things. 
 Let me finish in peace. 
 We had coffee. 
 I showed him the contents of the Green Box. 
 Told him there would also be something specifically for him when it was done. 
 He nodded as though he knew. 
 We went back in and looked some more. 
 I explained to him about the boxing-match and the waterfall and he went up close and examined the glass minutely, different areas of it, taking his time. 
 After a while he stepped back and puffed again at my side. 
 I think you need something on the other panel, above the oculist charts, he said at last. 
 Or perhaps just above the arms of the scissors. 
 What sort of thing? 
 I asked him. 
 He didn't know. 
 I told him the history of the charts, my initial idea for a peephole of some sort. 
 Maybe that's what you need now, he said, to restore the thrust of the vertical. 
 When he'd gone, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), I began to try out different possibilities. 
 More and more convinced he's right, but not quite sure what it needs. 
 Maybe when boxing-match problem solved this will fall into place. 
 He urged me to come and see his new place in Brighton. 
 Swore the sea air was doing his health good. 
 I couldn't take London any more, he said. 
 A sewer. 
 An absolute sewer. 
 You don't find it a sewer? he asked me. 
 I don't live in London, I told him. 
 I live in 14 Carlton Road. 
 Besides, I told him, I like sewers. 
 You don't have a family to think about of course, he said. 
 I wouldn't let the children grow up in this environment. 
 As always, he seemed to be apologizing for everything he said or did. 
 I took a photo  of him through the glass. 
 On both sides. 
 As I looked through the viewer I had the feeling, momentarily, that it really was what I had dreamed about for so long, a sort of crystal ball in which I could call up everything I had ever known. 
 But is that not what the mind is? 
 A crystal ball in which one can call up the past? 
 So is that what the big glass is perhaps? 
 Not so much an object as a place where, the means by which, the past can be called up, the future foretold? 
 It is for active use, wrote Harsnet, not for contemplation. 
 That is what I was after from the start, he wrote. 
 Having Goldberg in the room with it, as he has been in my life since that first day at college, made me grasp clearly, for the first time, just what it is I have been after, he wrote. 
 Perhaps a perfect circle just above the oculist charts? 
 But as if fixed to a wall there. 
 Big glass and glossy box, he wrote. 
 Does it need  a title? 
 Still uncertain, he wrote. 
 Have been growing less and less interested in titles that are other than purely descriptive. 
 Though there needs to be a little ambiguity to keep it interesting. 
 Moira F. phoned again, he wrote. 
 Told her definitely off for this year. 
 Or perhaps ever. 
 I am so disappointed, she said. 
 So am I, I said. 
 We both laughed. 
 There will not be a show like it, she said. 
 The biggest of its kind. 
 That's life, I said. 
 She laughed. 
 Funny how unreal it all seems at times, he wrote. 
 The work of the last four years. 
 The hours in the room under the hard fluorescent light. 
 The nightly rhythm. 
 As if my life had stopped when the glass was started and will only start again when it is done. 
 The plan, he wrote, and the execution of the plan. 
 Not to be sidetracked for any reason whatsoever . 
 Not to give in to temptation, no matter what form it takes . 
 But difficult at times to remember why I ever made such a plan, he wrote. 
 Or even if there was any plan at all. 
 Or any glass at all. 
 When I am not in the room with it, he wrote, it no longer exists. 
 The result of others having seen it? 
 Or what? 
 Goldberg, pushing the typewriter away from him, wiped his face with his handkerchief and took a sip of orange juice. 
 Then, pulling the pad towards him, he began to write. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, my son, who was only a very small boy  when you last saw him, happened the other day. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, my son Michael, whom you may not even remember, the fair one with the glasses. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, something happened recently which has prompted me to write to you in this unsolicited way, though God knows we were once. 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, why do you persist in this rigmarole of refusing even to acknowledge my existence? 
 What game are you playing? 
 Dear Harsnet, he wrote, the distance between London and Brighton is not very great, and you have even been seen in the vicinity of Brighton, so why not call in on an old friend? 
 The circle in place, wrote Harsnet (and Goldberg began to type again). 
 Locks that part of the glass together. 
 And finally gives charts the kind of breathing space they didn't quite have before. 
 And gives movement to the arms of the scissors and so back through the sieves to the chariot and the moulds. 
 Learning to work with  the glass at last, he wrote (and Goldberg typed). 
 As always happens, will have mastered it completely just when I have no more use for it. 
 Glossy Box too vague, he wrote. 
 Grand Verre/Boite Verte, he wrote. 
 Sixty-four sheets of notes. 
 Not numbered. 
 Any order. 
 Or reduce to 52? 
 Keep as they are, he wrote. 
 Do not try to tidy up. 
 Box will contain them as glass contains what is placed upon it. 
 More freedom with the box, but of course none of the joy of transparency. 
 I have been walking a great deal, he wrote. 
 Restless. 
 Tried Danny, hoping a game would calm me down, but no reply. 
 Glass dreadfully oppressive now. 
 It can be made , he wrote, but it cannot be thought . 
 The mouth is more agile than the eye, he wrote, the hand is more agile than the brain. 
 The maximum of movement, he wrote, with the maximum of stillness. 
 The maximum of passivity with the maximum of energy. 
 The maximum of sameness with the maximum of difference. 
 The maximum of silence with the maximum of noise. 
 The maximum of significance with the maximum of insignificance. 
 The maximum of thickness with the maximum of slimness. 
 All painting bas relief with maximum slimness, he wrote. 
 Wall and canvas hide that fact. 
 Glass reveals it. 
 Painting on wall or canvas the creation of alternative  worlds, he wrote. 
 Painting on glass as delay of the world. 
 Painting on wall or canvas as dream of plenitude, painting on glass as revelation of potential in poverty. 
 Painting on wall or canvas as magic, painting on glass as work in the world. 
 Work in the world as game in the world, he wrote. 
 Game in the world as delay of the world. 
 Delay of the world as truth of the world. 
 Living can damage your health, he wrote. 
 Looking at glass ditto . 
 The glass not as addition  to room, he wrote, but as subtraction  from room. 
 One hundred boxes to designated persons, he wrote, and two hundred out into the world. 
 The important thing now, he wrote, is to finish. 
 It has been going on for too long. 
 Without hurry, without pause (Goethe). 
 Do not use time as an excuse, he wrote. 
 Do not pretend that what is laziness is really patience. 
 Do not pretend that energy equals quality. 
 Every genuine work an affair of the heart, he wrote. 
 Do not prolong it beyond its allotted span, he wrote, but do not terminate it before its allotted span. 
 The burning heart, he wrote, and the smiling face. 
 Size clearly has something to do with its effect, he wrote, but not size as reflection of ego. 
 Rather, size as affirmation of confidence in artistic solution. 
 Everything visible, he wrote. 
 No secrets. 
 Description without place, he wrote. 
 Stevens. 
 Vermeer. 
 Bonnard. 
 If a work is bigger than a man, he wrote, it can mean either that it is trying to surpass  man or that it is not afraid of being looked at . 
 Cage in London, he wrote. 
 Trip to Greenwich. 
 Never separated from his plastic bag with his macrobiotic food. 
 It changed my life, he said. 
 I was wracked with arthritis. 
 Had to take twenty aspirin a day for ten years the pain was so great. 
 And within a week of switching to a macrobiotic diet the pains had eased. 
 Now it's perfectly tolerable. 
 Proud of his pink tie: I've worn a tie this shade for forty-five years. 
 The Dalai Lama admired it. 
 At the Greenwich Meridian: Every single spot on earth is the centre, that's what I've always tried to say in my music. 
 A woman fainted when he spoke the previous day, the hall was so crowded. 
 He told them to leave her be, she was in a better state to understand him than anyone else there. 
 Insisted on visiting the Isle of  Dogs. 
 Dereliction. 
 In Egypt recently: The sand is reasserting itself. 
 You can practically see it in the process of covering up the feeble attempts at civilization. 
 And it's not very different in the West. 
 Time we all moved on to Mars. 
 We need to realize what we've done to other species. 
 When you've botched a job a dozen times you don't hang around waiting to try one more time, you abandon it. 
 It may be too late for man though. 
 His father an inventor. 
 To him a few years ago: You are my finest invention. 
 Put him in taxi for Elizabeth Hall. 
 Walked most of the night. 
 His view that our character formed by our name. 
 His cage, Bach's brook, etc. 
 Experiment of speaking name aloud into machine and then finding face in image made by sound-waves. 
 All the pictures he showed me looked the same messy blur but he insisted he could make out the individual features of each person. 
 When we speak our names out loud we speak ourselves. 
 I refused to try. 
 Slept fitfully. 
 Woke up struggling to say my name but somehow unable to. 
 My tongue wouldn't get round the word or my mouth wouldn't open or something. 
 Renewed work on splash. 
 Sense of its triviality. 
 Rest of glass quite dead. 
 Sat waiting for it to come back to life. 
 All seems so long ago and far away. 
 Not even a question of the temptation to give up. 
 Rather, a wonder that I was ever interested in starting. 
 Card from Goldberg to say overwhelmed. 
 Instead of elation felt only that it was not addressed to me. 
 His enclosed article for Burlington on earlier work. 
 Most significant gesture in post-war art. 
 Legacy of Chardin. 
 Teases us out of thought. 
 Insignificance of Warhol and Beuys compared to. 
 Neveu de Rameau. 
 Nietzsche. 
 Val&eacute;ry. 
 Jarry. 
 Bataille. 
 Transgression. 
 Pornography. 
 Rhizomes. 
 All in four pages. 
 Crap. 
 Card from Moira F. enclosing dates of Festival. 
 Sense of desolation. 
 Walked most of the night again. 
 Up to Hampstead and back. 
 London compared to Paris and New York: everything shut away. 
 Everything secret. 
 Guilt and repression. 
 Effort at pleasure &mdash; the Puritan absurdity. 
 Yet my city. 
 My feeling that no project would ever hold any interest for me again. 
 Understood that quite clearly. 
 As if I was holding the  thought in my hands, looking at it, turning it about. 
 Unable to get rid of the feeling that the glass belongs to another time, another person. 
 Far away. 
 Long ago. 
 Goldberg with new suggestion about bottom right hand. 
 As though now he was more concerned with the glass than I am. 
 When I offered to let him finish it he laughed. 
 My artist days are over, he said. 
 He couldn't resist adding: Helped to the grave by you. 
 It still rankles with him. 
 But why should one incident put him off for ever? 
 We all seek reasons. 
 Excuses. 
 For our lives. 
 For how they've turned out. 
 perhaps the only thing I feel proud of is this: No excuses. 
 On my tombstone: No excuses. 
 You ruined my life (Madge). 
 You ruined my career (Goldberg). 
 So Harsnet. 
 And Goldberg, pulling the pad towards him: Not all travel as light as Harsnet. 
 Some of us have responsibilities. 
 So Goldberg. 
 And Harsnet: We do not &bquo;waste time&equo;; it is in the nature of time to be wasted. 
 We do not take &bquo;wrong turnings&equo;; it is in the nature of turnings to be wrong. 
 We do not fail, because there is no such thing as success. 
 We are never &bquo;not quite up to it&equo;, because there is no &bquo;it&equo; to be quite up to. 
 In every case, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), if we had not done what we did but something else the consequences would have been equally disastrous. 
 In every case, he wrote, if we had done something instead of doing nothing the consequences would have been equally disastrous. 
 In every case if we had done nothing instead of doing something the consequences would have been equally disastrous. 
 The big glass, he wrote. 
 Delay in glass, he wrote. 
 Another story of disaster. 
 Disaster to start it and disaster to go on with it. 
 Disaster to complete it and disaster to leave it uncompleted. 
 Disaster to be born, he wrote, and disaster to die. 
 Wherever you turn, he wrote, there is nothing but a minefield of disasters. 
 The boxing-match is out, he wrote. 
 The waterfall is out. 
 Four and a half years, he wrote. 
 I have never spent so long on a single project. 
 So there must have been something in it to hold my attention for so long. 
 Perhaps there is still something in it, but not for me, he wrote. 
 Perhaps there is still something in it, but I can no longer see it. 
 When I think about it, he  wrote, I find it difficult to remember why I ever embarked on it. 
 When I sit in the room with it, he wrote, it's like sitting in a room with a corpse. 
 I want it out of the house, he wrote. 
 I realize now that that is what I want more than anything else. 
 There comes a point in every project, he wrote, when you are tired of beating your head against the wall. 
 There comes a time in every project, he wrote, when it becomes clear that a head is no match for a wall. 
 Enthusiasm, he wrote, gives way to frustration, and frustration to anger, and anger to indifference. 
 That is the time to stop, he wrote. 
 That is the time to abandon the project. 
 That is the time to get the thing out of the house and take up evening classes in deep-sea diving. 
 Three steps fixed from the start, he wrote: making the glass, showing the glass, and ending it all. 
 But now I see, he wrote (and Goldberg typed), that I must alter the emphasis of the first part. 
 Now I see, he wrote, that I must abandon it as I have abandoned everything else. 
 There comes a moment when you know you have done what you could do with something and everything else would be fiddling. 
 There comes a moment when you lose interest so totally that to touch it again would be a physical impossibility. 
 When it is too late to go on and too late to start again. 
 From the beginning it was too late, he wrote. 
 It was too late to begin and too late not to begin. 
 Too late for me and too late for the world. 
 Too late for the Bride and too late for the Bachelors. 
 Too late for Diana and too late for Actaeon. 
 It should have been done sooner, he wrote, but the truth is it would always have been too late. 
 And now it is much too late to go on, he wrote, and much too late to start again. 
 Too late for the glass, he wrote, and too late for the showing of the glass. 
 Too late for the truth and too late to invent a lie. 
 Too late for art and too late for the denial of art. 
 Too late for salvation and too late for damnation. 
 Too late for such words and much too late to suppress them. 
 The thing about my life, he wrote, is that everything has always been too late. 
 I was born too late and I discovered what I wanted to do too late and what I did I did too late and my death is about to come far too late. 
 I always thought  it was too early, he wrote, and now I see that it is much too late. 
 The fact that there is no right time, he wrote, the fact that it is bound always to be too early or too late, that fact is little consolation. 
 The fact that I can write this is little consolation, he wrote. 
 Not only is it little consolation, he wrote, it is actually a further cause for despair, for it only shows that everything is far too late, that the glass was a dream of lateness and the work on the glass was a fantasy of lateness and the belief in the glass was the madness of one who has lost all sense of the meaning of lateness. 
 Not only did the idea come too late, he wrote, not only did the discipline come too late, not only did the resolution of individual problems come too late, but they came so late that I was not even aware of their lateness, and so they were doubly false and doubly useless and doubly meaningless. 
 The nights in the room were false and useless and meaningless and the nights walking the city were false and useless and meaningless, the notes for the box were false and useless and meaningless and this freewheeling account of the progress of the glass is false and useless and meaningless, late and doubly late and unaware of its lateness, nothing and again nothing and worse than nothing. 
 Letter from Goldberg, he wrote, but no point in replying. 
 Further letter from Goldberg. 
 Yesterday he rang the bell for a long time but no point in opening the door. 
 Xenakis in town again but made no effort to see him. 
 Note from Moira F. urging me to get in touch. 
 No point in replying. 
 As though all this had happened a long time ago. 
 Star still twinkling but long since extinct. 
 Goldberg at door again today. 
 His banging roused the neighbours. 
 Shouted that he knew I was inside. 
 Why will you not speak to me? 
 Why don't you open? 
 Are you all right? 
 Just say if you are and I'll go away. 
 Otherwise 1'11 call the police. 
 I crept to the door and, with a sudden movement, opened it wide. 
 He stared at me in surprise. 
 I invited him in. 
 He seemed, for once, at a loss for words. 
 I gave him a cup of coffee. 
 Wouldn't answer his questions. 
 Made no move to show him the glass. 
 Gradually he regained his composure. 
 Puffed at his cigarette. 
 Invited me to Brighton. 
 What  would I do in Brighton? 
 I said. 
 Come and have lunch, he said. 
 I told him I was cutting down on lunch. 
 What's the point of having a phone if you never answer? he said. 
 But then decided to ignore my actions, started telling me about himself, his latest article, latest book, latest catalogue introduction, latest love. 
 He tried before leaving, as he was looking at his watch, to press me about the glass, but we know each other too well. 
 I merely smiled and he got up, patting his face with his handkerchief, talking about the pollution of the water in London, about tests carried out and how soon everyone would have to boil drinking water first, it's turning into a third-world city, he said, a third-world country, no one will admit it but England is turning into a third-world country. 
 I had to go to Leeds for a show just after my return from Calcutta, he said, and there really wasn't much to choose between them. 
 Told me Moira F. had written to him, anxious for news about the glass, complaining that I never answered the phone, never replied to her letters, what should he tell her? 
 What you like, I said. 
 Shall I say I saw you? he asked. 
 I told him I couldn't stop him, he was a free agent. 
 He assured me he hadn't mentioned the glass to anyone, hadn't dropped any hints. 
 It doesn't concern me, I told him. 
 Feel free to say what you like. 
 You mean the ban's off? he said. 
 That I can talk about it? 
 Whatever you like, I said. 
 He was putting on his heavy overcoat, asked again casually if he could have a look at the glass. 
 I shook my head. 
 He left. 
 I sent Moira a card: Glass definitively abandoned, collect as soon as possible. 
 Two days later, card from her: Why abandoned? 
 Please phone. 
 Goldberg called again the day after that, charged by her to find out. 
 What do you mean abandoned? he said. 
 I mean I'm abandoning it, I said. 
 Like that? he said. 
 Unfinished? 
 If it was finished I wouldn't say abandoned, I said. 
 Why? he said. 
 I've lost interest in it, I said. 
 Interest? he said. 
 Then: Can I see it? 
 I took him in and watched as he studied it. 
 You haven't taken up any of those plans about the boxing-match, he said. 
 Or the waterfall. 
 I stood at the window and looked down into the street. 
 I think it's finished as it is,  he said. 
 When he had done I followed him out of the room and shut the door. 
 He repeated he thought it was finished as it was. 
 Said he liked all that empty space on the right. 
 You put that peep-hole where I suggested, he said. 
 Do you want a written acknowledgement? 
 I asked him. 
 No no, he said. 
 I'm just glad I had a. 
 Why did you abandon it? he asked again. 
 Again I told him why. 
 Sometimes it takes a little while to realize you really have lost interest in something, I said to him. 
 That it isn't that you've got up on the wrong side or eaten something which didn't agree with you or just need a few days' rest. 
 It takes a little time to sec that you're not moving forward any more, either because you don't know how or because there isn't anywhere to move forward to. 
 Of course all these things are relative, I told him, of course if you take the long perspective there's never anywhere to move forward to and all advance is illusory, but in the short perspective there comes a point when there is no option except to abandon. 
 You feel you've failed? he asked me. 
 He added quickly: Because I don't, you know. 
 No, I said, I don't feel that. 
 You've done what you wanted? he asked. 
 I no longer know what I wanted, I said. 
 Now it just bores me. 
 That's why I can't go on with it. 
 I held the door open for him. 
 I'll tell Moira, he said. 
 She'll be very excited. 
 What's the point of having a phone if you never answer it? he asked me. 
 It's awkward having to come round and not be sure of finding you. 
 I shut the door behind him and locked it. 
 Yesterday he came again, with her and Pearsall, the head man in Edinburgh. 
 I sat in the kitchen and read the paper. 
 They were in there for a long time. 
 They came out and she gushed. 
 Perfect. 
 Masterpiece. 
 And so on. 
 Should it be called abandoned? 
 She didn't feel, etc. 
 Definitively abandoned, I said. 
 Plans for Festival well under way, she said. 
 Pride of place, etc. 
 All that time, wrote Harsnet, Pearsall stood stiffly there without saying a word. 
 The sooner you get it out of here the better, I said, wrote Harsnet. 
 No problem, she said. 
 I'll arrange for the carriers to come down as soon as I get back. 
 Goldberg grinning. 
 Pearsall silent. 
 Finally they left, still not a word out of  Pearsall. 
 Goldberg was back an hour later. 
 They were in ecstasies, he said. 
 It was worth waiting for all her life, she said. 
 I didn't notice Pearsall in ecstasies, I said. 
 It's his manner, Goldberg said. 
 Deep down he was knocked out. 
 Deep down he was knocked out? 
 I said. 
 He told you? 
 Don't worry, he said. 
 I could see it in his eyes. 
 I'm not worrying, I said. 
 They are talking about buying, he said. 
 It's a question of raising the money. 
 Tomorrow I go away, I said. 
 You? he said. 
 When did you last go away? 
 You tell me, I said. 
 When we went to Siena together? 
 I shrugged. 
 Where? he asked. 
 Tunisia, I said. 
 Wonderful idea, he said. 
 Wonderful. 
 How long for? 
 I'll see, I said. 
 I'll be in touch when I return. 
 An open booking? he said. 
 An open booking, I said. 
 So got rid of him at last, wrote Harsnet (typed Goldberg), and went in to the glass. 
 Now all these other eyes have looked at it I feel different about it. 
 Now I have definitively abandoned it I begin to wonder. 
 Sat there through the night, closing my eyes at times, then opening them slowly and allowing the glass to impose itself. 
 Still half tempted to restart. 
 Funny how those old temptations return. 
 But wrong of course. 
 Too late. 
 Nothing more to be done. 
 Anything else would only be a repetition. 
 After three nights, he wrote, I again only wanted the thing out of the flat. 
 Phoned Moira and told her I wanted it out as soon as possible; if she wouldn't have it I would find someone who would. 
 Good news on the way, she said. 
 Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art on point of making offer. 
 I explained about the green box, but said nothing about this notebook. 
 Will keep till the end. 
 Then post to Goldberg. 
 Or perhaps burn. 
 Still undecided. 
 She said she would get back to me. 
 possible support from Gulbenkian Foundation. 
 Scotland would be proud to own it, she said. 
 All I want is to get it out of the flat, I said. 
 If you don't make up your mind soon I might just break it up. 
 Tried locking door and ignoring it. 
 Impossible. 
 Of course no desire to travel. 
 Walked a lot, he wrote, despite the cold. 
 Snow and slush messing up the pavements. 
 What does it mean , standing there in the empty room, bigger than a man? 
 No answers to such questions. 
 Too late to go  back. 
 Accept. 
 First part over, second part starts. 
 Must see it for myself in a public space. 
 That was the plan from the start and it remains the plan. 
 Goldberg in Guardian  today, major new work, still to be unveiled, but those who have seen it, etc. 
 Letter from Pizetti, what about MOMA next year, letter from Rosenblum, what about Washington after New York, letter from Karsten offering Hamburg. 
 Vultures. 
 Dear Moira, he wrote, we will have to reach an understanding. 
 From the moment you take the big glass off my hands you will have the sole responsibility for it. 
 Even if the Gallery does not buy it I do not wish to have anything more to do with it. 
 After the patience of the last few years, he wrote, why this sudden impatience? 
 As if now I know it will soon be off my hands time has started to move forward again. 
 Cannot wait for the end.  
 CAMRA FACT SHEET No 1 
 How beer is brewed 
 Beer seems such a simple drink that we tend to take it for granted. 
 Serious conversation about alcohol is reserved for wine and spirits. 
 Yet beer &mdash; good beer &mdash; is a highly complex product and one that arguably needs greater skill to produce than wine. 
 Wine, at its simplest, means crushing grapes and letting the wild yeasts on the  the  skins ferment the sweet juices into alcohol. 
 If you crush an ear of barley, however, you will not get beer. 
 The basic ingredient of beer needs careful nurturing and transforming into malt before it is ready to begin the slow, ruminative journey that ends with the pint in the pub. 
 When barley is harvested it is taken to a maltings where the grains are soaked in water to encourage germination. 
 As the roots begin to break out of the grains the barley is transferred to a vast hall heated with warm air and turned by large malt shovels. 
 When the maltster is satisfied that germination has unlocked the rich natural sugars in the barley, the grains are taken to a kiln room where heat stops germination. 
 The temperature of the kilning process determines the type of malt produced: the higher the temperature the darker the malt. 
 The malt is now ready for brewing. 
 In the brewery it is milled into a powder called grist and then mixed with hot water (known as liquor in breweries) in a vessel called a mash tun. 
 The thick porridgy liquid is left for several hours while the natural sugars in the malt dissolve into the liquor. 
 When the mashing has absorbed the maximum amount of sugar, the liquid &mdash; now known as wort &mdash; is run off through the slotted base of the vessel. 
 The remaining grains are sprinkled with more hot liquor to remove any last remaining sugars, a system known as sparging. 
 The wort is then run into a copper where it is boiled for an hour or more with hops. 
 Without hops, beer would be unpleasantly sweet. 
 Hops, brought to Britain in the 15th century by Dutch brewers, not only add bitterness and aroma but also act as a preservative and prevent infections in the brew. 
 After boiling the hopped wort flows from the copper into a vessel called a hop back. 
 Like the mash tun, it has a slotted base and the liquid runs out of the vessel over a bed of spent hops. 
 The wort is then cooled and run into fermenting tanks where yeast is added or pitched. 
 Yeast is made up of millions of tiny fungus cells which literally go berserk when confronted by a liquid rich with sugars. 
 Within a few hours a scum appears on top of the wort and this rapidly builds up into a great yellowy-brown crust as the yeast turns the sugars into alcohol and carbon dioxide. 
 The system used in Britain to produce mild, bitter, stout and strong ales is called &bquo;warm fermentation&equo;, using a special type of top fermenting yeast. 
 This means that the yeast, encouraged by the warmth of the wort and the temperature of the brewery, works quickly and vigorously on top of the wort to produce alcohol. 
 After 4&ndash;7 days most of the sugars have been turned into alcohol and the yeast begins to sink to the bottom of the vessel. 
 The excess yeast is saved for future use. 
 So much yeast is produced during fermentation that large amounts are sold to companies such as Marmite to be turned into yeast extract. 
 When fermentation has finished the &bquo;green beer&equo; is run into conditioning tanks for a few days. 
 The remaining yeast continues to turn the residual sugars into alcohol and also helps to purge the beer of the rough after-tastes created by fermentation. 
 Some brewers add extra sugar at this stage to encourage the continuing fermentation. 
 Caramel is sometimes added to give darker colouring to the finished beer. 
 Finings, a glutinous substance made from the bladder of the sturgeon, is added either at the conditioning stage or when the beer is in cask to fine or clear the beer. 
 The finings attract yeast and other particles and begin to drag them to the bottom of the tank. 
 Now the beer is ready for the final stage in the brewery before it leaves for the pub cellar. 
 It is run or racked into casks, made either of wood or metal, sometimes with some &bquo;priming&equo; sugar and a handful of dry hops: the sugar will encourage a vigorous secondary fermentation in the cask and the hops will add a delightful aroma. 
 After all the mashing and boiling and the heaving and frothing of fermentation we now have beer, ready for its journey to the pub cellar. 
 The description of the brewing process varies from brewery to brewery: in some mashing, boiling and fermenting taking place in open or partially-open vessels. 
 In some modern plants, the process takes place in enclosed conical fermenters or European-style lauter tuns. 
 But as long as the finished beer is left to brew naturally and is free from such unnatural processes as chilling, filtering and pasteurisation, the end result is traditional draught beer, known in the industry as &bquo;cask conditioned beer&equo; and more popularly as&hellip; real ale.  
 Hops on the vine: the oils in the hop give bitterness to beer and also act as a preservative against infection 
 A classical Victorian tower brewery where the brewing process flows by gravity from floor to floor 
 A mash tun showing the sparging arms at the top and the slotted base 
 Hops being fed into the copper where the sweet wort is boiled vigorously and the vital oils are extracted from the hops 
 Fermenting vessels showing the head of yeast developing on the fermenting wort 
 The racking line: fresh beer is run from conditioning tanks into steam-cleaned casks. 
 After filling the casks are bunged before delivery to the pubs 
 CAMRA FACT SHEET No2 
 Unreal beer 
 There is a vital difference between real ale and keg beer. 
 Keg, which includes lager, is known in the industry as &bquo;brewery conditioned beer&equo;. 
 Instead of a secondary fermentation in the cask to add a full, mature palate, keg beers are killed off in the brewery by a number of unnatural processes that affect the taste and quality of the product. 
 The aim is to produce beers quickly which, because they are sterile and have a long &bquo;shelf life&equo;, are also highly profitable. 
 Where keg milds and bitters are concerned, when fermentation is complete they are conditioned for a short period in tanks under a heavy blanket of carbon dioxide. 
 They are then chilled and filtered to remove the remaining yeast and are usually pasteurised as well to ensure that death is complete. 
 Pasteurisation &mdash; avoided by skilled brewers in both Britain and other leading brewing nations &mdash; leaves an unpleasant burnt sugar taste to beer that is most apparent in low gravity drinks. 
 As the natural brewing process has been halted, the beer cannot generate its own carbon dioxide. 
 It would be flat and lifeless if served in this condition. 
 Keg beers &mdash; so called because they are kept in sealed and pressurised containers called kegs &mdash; are therefore injected with carbon dioxide and connected to cylinders of CO 2 ; in the pub cellar. 
 When the tap on the bar is operated, gas forces the beer to the bar. 
 The end result is a fizzy, burpy product served heavily chilled to mask its lack of taste and flavour. 
 Not all keg beers are pasteurised. 
 Pubs and clubs with a quick turnover serve what is known as &bquo;bright beer&equo; from large cellar tanks. 
 Bright beer is certainly preferable to a fully-fledged keg but it still lacks the rounded flavour of a cask beer and is served too gassy and too cold. 
 The last word in keg beer is British lager. 
 CAMRA is not opposed to lager. 
 Lager beer is the traditional beer style of many countries (see fact sheet on beer styles) and there are some superb beers in such great brewing countries as West Germany and Czechoslovakia. 
 What the Campaign is against is fake, poor quality imitation lagers being foisted on unsuspecting drinkers and passed off as being genuinely European or Australian. 
 All the main brands of lager on sale in Britain are brewed here, not imported. 
 Those that carry the same names as overseas beers are produced under licence and do not necessarily adhere to the recipe or strength of the original. 
 The Whitbread version of Heineken, for example, is 12 degrees of gravity weaker than the Dutch version. 
 There is no such beer in Germany as Hofmeister; it is brewed here by Courage. 
 Lager is brewed by using paler malts and European hop varieties. 
 Lager yeast should be used but this is not always the case. 
 After primary fermentation the beer is stored (the German word is &bquo;lagered&equo;) for a short time but rarely for the month or more that is standard abroad. 
 The beer is then filtered and pasteurised and served under gas pressure and heavily chilled. 
 Unlike genuine lagers, which usually have alcoholic strengths of 4 per cent and upwards, the average British lager is often as weak as mild or standard bitter but is priced from 10 to 20 pence a pint more. 
 As brewers pay lower rates of excise duty on weaker beers, lager is a highly profitable business for the giant brewing combines. 
 CAMRA is also concerned at the way in which many keg beers are brewed and the ingredients used. 
 Mashing, boiling and fermentation are often speeded up in large breweries using such devices as continuous fermentation and high gravity brewing, both of which produce standardised bland beers of mediocre quality. 
 In order to further speed and cheapen the process, inferior ingredients such as maize, rice, triticale, wheat flour and potato starch are used and helped on their way by chemicals that hasten fermentation, cut down on the yeast head in the vessels to allow more wort to be treated, and to give a lively fake head to the finished product. 
 Beer is classified as a food stuff and yet it is excluded from the legal requirements to list ingredients. 
 Drinkers have a right to know whether the beer they are drinking is a genuine barley malt product or whether it is stuffed full of such tasty ingredients as corn syrup, propylene glycol alginate, amyloglucosidase, papain enzymes and potassium metabisulphite. 
 All these ingredients and additives were used to produce Miller Lite in the US until there was an outcry from consumers. 
 In Britain, Courage brew Miller Lite under licence but do not have to reveal the ingredients. 
 Keg bitters and lager have been enormously successful for the brewers not as a result of genuine consumer demand but due to saturation advertising. 
 Twenty years ago lager accounted for less than 10 per cent of total beer sales. 
 Today it is close to 50 per cent and giants such as Bass and Whitbread, once proud names in ale brewing, now trumpet the fact that more than half of their production goes to lager. 
 It is estimated that keg beer is twice as profitable as cask beer, lager four times as profitable. 
 Those profits are generated in part as a result of expensive marketing. 
 In 1987 British brewers spent &pound;100 million on advertising and promotion. 
 More than two thirds of that colossal amount was devoted to lager, which is still a minority brand in Britain. 
 Bass, Britain's major brewing combine, was responsible for a quarter of all advertising spending and spent &pound;15.14 million on lager compared to &pound;6.67 on beer. 
 It is marketing and money that fuel the lager bandwagon, not consumer preference.  
 Kegs in the pub cellar, the one on the left connected for serving. 
 The lifeless beer is pumped full of carbon dioxide gas, and further gas is used to force the beer to the bar. 
 Heavily-promoted but weak and gassy, UK lagers have little in common with genuine bottom-fermented beers from Europe. 
 The can is a genuine Aussie one but XXXX is now brewed on &bquo;draught&equo; and in package in Britain by Allied Breweries at Wrexham. 
 AND THIS IS WHERE THE TRADITIONAL COLOURING, FLAVOURING AND PRESERVATIVES ARE ADDED 
 I KNOW THE ADS HAVE CREATED A GOOD DEMAND. 
 JUST HOW MANY SKOLS DO YOU WANT? 
 The balloon says it all: lager has less than 50 per cent of the British beer market yet the brewers spend two-thirds of their advertising money on it.  
 Ruddles, once a proud independent, now owned by Watneys, promotes its processed beers as though they have the support of CAMRA. 
 Miller Lite, brewed under licence by Courage. 
 Described as the &bquo;nearest thing to an empty glass&equo;. 
 CAMRA FACT SHEET No 3 
 In the pub 
 Considerable care and skill are needed to handle cask beer when it reaches the pub. 
 It is not yet ready to be served. 
 Depending on its strength and the time required for it to reach maturity, a beer must stand for 12 to 48 hours before it can be drunk. 
 The usual practice is for casks to be rolled into deep, cool cellars. 
 Some pubs have their &bquo;cellars&equo; on the ground floor while a few pubs, often in rural areas, keep their casks on or behind the bar and serve the beer by gravity from a tap in the tap hole. 
 Wherever the beer is kept, the temperature must be carefully controlled. 
 The ideal temperature for serving a cask beer is 14&deg;C (57&deg;F). 
 It is wrong to say that real ale should be served at room temperature: too warm and the beer tastes tacky and rancid; too cold and the subtle palate of the beer is masked by the chill. 
 A beer cask can come in several sizes: a pin (4.5 gallons), a firkin (9), a kilderkin (18), a barrel (36) and a hogshead (54). 
 Many brewers are now using metric sizes. 
 A cask has two holes, the tap hole at one of the flat ends to which a tap and pipe are attached, and a bigger shive hole on top. 
 The cask is laid on a cradle on its side to encourage the sediment to sink to the belly. 
 A small wooden peg called a spile is knocked into the soft core of the shive. 
 Two types are used: a soft spile and a hard spile. 
 While the beer continues to ferment in the cask the CO 2  produced escapes through the soft spile. 
 When fermentation starts to slow down, a hard spile is used to control the escape of the gas. 
 Without natural CO 2  the beer would be flat. 
 When the cellarman judges that the beer is in perfect condition, he or she hammers a tap through the wooden or plastic keystone in the tap hole of the cask. 
 There are two ways in which cask beer can be stored that interfere with the vital secondary fermentation. 
 Cylinders of gas can be connected to the spile hole to keep a blanket of applied CO 2  on the beer. 
 A light covering of gas is known as blanket pressure, a heavier pressure used to force the beer to the bar is known as top pressure. 
 The aim is to keep the beer in a drinkable condition for longer but both systems interfere with the maturation of the beer and deliver an unpleasantly fizzy pint. 
 CAMRA does not recognise such pressure systems. 
 A number of brewers now use a device called a cask breather on low volume beers to prolong their life. 
 Although no extraneous gas is used, CAMRA also frowns on the breather as interfering with the natural process of maturing and serving cask beer. 
 Left to its own devices, real ale stays in a drinkable condition for about a week. 
 When the pub landlord or cellarman considers that the beer is ready to serve &mdash; it is said to have &bquo;dropped bright&equo; with the sediment of yeast in the belly of the cask, and to have matured sufficiently &mdash; a long plastic tube is connected to the tap and the beer is ready to be pulled to the bar. 
 The most familiar method of serving real ale is the beer engine, a simple suction pump operated by a tall handpump on the bar. 
 When the handle is pulled the engine delivers a half pint of beer to the bar. 
 Some pubs, mainly in the Midlands and the North, use electric pumps to draw the beer to the bar. 
 Electric pumps, either of the simple free flow type or the metered pump which delivers exact half pints, are a perfectly acceptable method of serving cask beer but they can be confused with the pressurised founts used to dispense keg beers. 
 In the North a nozzle called a sparkler is often attached to the spout on the bar to give beer the creamy head preferred there. 
 In Scotland beer is usually served in a quite different fashion. 
 Casks are placed on their ends in the cellar and a long tube known as an extractor is inserted through the tap hole. 
 The extractor is connected to the bar pump by a plastic beer line. 
 Instead of a handpump on the bar you will find a tall fount with a two-way lever. 
 When the lever is operated, the beer is driven to the bar by air pressure produced either by an electric air compressor or, more rarely, a water engine. 
 The strength of beer 
 Brewers pay tax or excise duty on the &bquo;original gravity&equo; of each brew prior to fermentation. 
 The excise officer measures the amount of fermentable material &mdash; malt and other sugars &mdash; in the wort. 
 As water has a gravity of 1000 degrees, a beer with 36 parts of fermentable material will be said to have an original gravity or OG of 1036 degrees. 
 While the gravity falls during the fermentation process, the OG does give a useful indication of the strength of beer. 
 Mild beers usually have OGs of 1030&ndash;1036 degrees, ordinary bitters 1034&ndash;1039, special bitters 1040&ndash;1048, and strong ales anything from 1050 to 1100 degrees. 
 Stouts usually have gravities in the middle 1040s. 
 Original gravity can be roughly translated into alcoholic strength as follows: a 1036 beer has approximately 3.6 per cent alcohol, a 1050 beer has 5 per cent alcohol and so on.  
 How to ruin perfection: gas connected to a cask of beer keeps the ale under a blanket of CO2, making it unpleasantly fizzy 
 Serving the perfect pint: a fine bank of handpumps in a traditional tap room. 
 Examples of different types of electric pumps. 
 The two on the left are metered pumps serving exact half-pints, the ones on the right are free flow pumps 
 The classic bank of Victorian beer engines showing the suction pumps operated by handpulls. 
 An experienced cellarman checking a cask of ale to make sure that the beer has &bquo;dropped bright&equo; and is ready to be served. 
 CAMRA FACT SHEET No 5 
 Beer styles 
 Mild  ale is one of the last surviving examples of the type of beer the whole world drank until new developments in Britain and Europe introduced lighter coloured brews. 
 Until then beer was dark in colour, though it was considerably stronger than the milds consumed today. 
 It is the increasing burden of excise duty, however, that has reduced the strength of mild: at the turn of the century the average gravity of mild ale in Britain was 1050 degrees, the strength of a powerful modern bitter. 
 Milds today have gravities ranging from 1030 to 1036 degrees. 
 The style has virtually disappeared from the south-east of England but there is still considerable demand for it in the West Midlands, Wales and the North-west. 
 Fine examples of the style include Ansells, Thwaites and Brain's Dark. 
 As the last name suggests, mild tends to be dark, either by using dark malt or the addition of caramel. 
 There are some excellent light milds, though: McMullen's AK from Hertford keeps the mild flag flying in the Home Counties. 
 Bitter  is now the premier beer style in England and Wales. 
 It developed in the early 19th century in Burton upon Trent where such brewing companies as William Bass answered the demand from the colonies for a cool, sparkling and well-hopped beer with India Pale Ale. 
 A taste for IPA spread rapidly through the home market and several large London brewers established plants in Burton to start brewing pale ale or bitter, taking advantage of the Burton waters, rich in gypsum. 
 Now brewers at home and abroad &bquo;Burtonise&equo; their water to brew pale bitters and lagers. 
 Bitters have gravities ranging from 1034 to 1040, best or special bitters &mdash; the true descendants of India Pale Ale &mdash; range from 1040 to 1050. 
 Some famous strong bitters, such as Fuller's ESB, weigh in at 1055 degrees. 
 Stout , in common with mild, is an historical throwback, the descendant of the great London beer styled called porter, which dominated the market in the 18th and 19th centuries and helped create rich and powerful commercial brewers. 
 Porter was a strong and dark beer, heavily hopped. 
 When Arthur Guinness started to brew porter in his Dublin brewery he created an insatiable demand for his beer that has never waned in Ireland. 
 Stout was the strongest or stoutest of the porter brews. 
 Stouts today are not exceptionally strong &mdash; usually in the low 1040s OG &mdash; and are distinguished by a high hop rate and by their jet black or dark brown colour achieved by the use of roasted malts and unmalted roasted barley. 
 Strong ales  come in a variety of styles and strengths &mdash; winter warmers, barley wines, Christmas Ales, Old Ales &mdash; with gravities ranging from 1050 to 1100 or more. 
 They are usually dark and sweet and heavily hopped. 
 They are often sold in the winter months from small casks kept on bar counters. 
 They are best enjoyed in small quantities. 
 Bottled beers  are usually filtered and pasteurised, the bottled version of keg. 
 Fortunately there are still a handful of splendid brews that are allowed to condition in the bottle. 
 Worthington White Shield, brewed by Bass, is a strong, nutty pale ale that has to be poured with care in order to retain the natural sediment in the bottle. 
 Guinness, a superb bitter-sweet beer, is naturally conditioned in crown-capped bottles; all other forms are filtered and pasteurised (as is the bottled version sold in Scotland). 
 Imperial Russian Stout has a powerful gravity of 1108 degrees and also conditions in the bottle. 
 Brewed by Courage, its name stems from the fact that it was once exported to Russia where it was so popular with the Czarist court that it was brewed under licence in Estonia until the 1917 revolution. 
 Thomas Hardy's Ale, brewed by Eldridge Pope, has an OG of 1126 degrees and each small bottle has to be laid down for several years before it is ready to drink. 
 Gale's Prize Old Ale (1095 OG) comes in a cork-stoppered bottle. 
 Scotland  has a different brewing tradition in England and Wales. 
 Beers tend to be darker and sweeter. 
 Hops cannot be grown north of the border and the cost of importing them from England means they are used more sparingly. 
 Good malting barley comes from the Lowlands and from England; Highland barley is better suited for distilling. 
 The darker colour of Scottish beer comes from the use of roasted barley or dark malt in addition to pale malt. 
 Low gravity beers are called &bquo;light&equo; &mdash; even when they are black or walnut brown in colour &mdash; medium gravity beers are called &bquo;heavy&equo; and strong beers are known as &bquo;export&equo;, recalling the heyday of Scottish brewing when companies such as Younger sold their beers extensively to North America, India and Australasia. 
 Pump clips often bear the names of 60, 70, 80 and occasionally 90 shilling. 
 The use of the term shilling derives from an 19th century system of invoicing beer according to its gravity &mdash; a 60 shilling ale is a low gravity beer, an 80 shilling one is considerably stronger, similar to an English special bitter. 
 Although the invoicing system is long redundant, the use of the shilling in the name of a beer does give a useful indication of its strength. 
 While handpumps are now widespread in Scotland, as Fact Sheet 3 shows, the traditional method of serving cask beer in Scotland is the tall fount primed by air pressure.  
 Michael Thomas Bass, the great entrepreneur who turned Bass into a great Victorian company and, before the rise of the American giants, the biggest brewery in the world at Burton upon Trent. 
 CAMRA FACT SHEET No 6 
 How CAMRA works 
 The Campaign of Real Ale was started in the early 1970s by a small group of beer lovers who was appalled by the heavily promoted keg beers that threatened to replace traditional draught ales. 
 The national keg brands were the result of a wave of takeovers and mergers in the 1960s and early 1970s that created &bquo;the Big Six&equo; combines &mdash; Bass, Allied, Watney/Grand Met, Whitbread, Courage and Scottish &amp; Newcastle. 
 The Campaign won media attention as a result of its outspoken criticism of the state of British beer, backed by punchy public relations, marches, demonstrations and the launch of the Good Beer Guide, which listed those pubs that still sold &bquo;the real thing&equo;. 
 Membership grew at an astonishing pace, reaching close to 30,000 in the late 1970s. 
 CAMRA produced reports on the brewing industry, pointing to the monopoly grip of the Big Six in many parts of the country and the resultant lack of choice for consumers. 
 The industry went into rapid reverse. 
 The public interest created by CAMRA made further takeovers and closures unpopular. 
 Many small independent breweries were saved from extinction. 
 &bquo;Real ale&equo; became a major talking point in pubs and the media. 
 Slowly and hesitantly, the Big Six attempted to rebuild bridges to its alienated customers by producing and promoting cask conditioned beer again. 
 When Allied Breweries unveiled Draught Burton Ale in 1976 to great acclaim, the flood gates opened and all the national combines hurried to embrace the new philosophy of &bquo;abroad portfolio&equo; of brands to please the disparate wishes of pub users. 
 CAMRA's strength lies in its style of organisation. 
 It has turned its back on the elitism of many consumer organisations and has based itself on a democratic structure in which the voluntary efforts of the members determine policy and action. 
 The Campaign is run by a National Executive elected by the Annual General Meeting. 
 NE members are volunteers who plan CAMRA's strategy through a wide-ranging committee structure. 
 Members are organised in local branches grouped together in regions that are overseen by voluntary Regional Directors. 
 Each brewery has a Brewery Liaison Officer who meets brewery executives on a regular basis to discuss policy and changes in the range of beers available. 
 The branch and regional structure is overseen by a national Branches Committee made up of Regional Directors. 
 National, regional and local beer festivals present a vast range of beers to the public and help gain many new members. 
 A small full-time staff based in St Albans looks after the day-to-day administration and finances of the Campaign and produced a monthly newspaper, What's Brewing, and the annual Good Beer Guide. 
 A subsidiary publishing company, Alma Books, has been set up to produce a number of guide books and the Campaign also works with commercial publishers to produce such titles as Classic Town and Country Pubs and Beer, Bed and Breakfast. 
 In its short history, CAMRA has produced many reports on the structure of the industry and the need to refashion it to meet consumer needs. 
 It has involved itself energetically in such issues as pub opening hours and the additives and adjuncts used in the brewing process. 
 In particular, it has lobbied both the British Parliament and the European institutions with demands to break up the brewing monopolies and to restore greater choice to pub users. 
 CAMRA's work is far from over. 
 The grip of the brewing giants is still powerful; the late 1980s has seen a worrying return to takeovers and mergers and the intensification of lager promotion. 
 The threat to choice and to the remaining independent brewers demands a strong and continuing Campaign that will fight for drinkers' rights and challenge the might of the brewing giants. 
 Membership of the Campaign will pitch you into the heart of the battle to preserve British beer. 
 For just &pound;9 a year you will receive What's Brewing every month and will get generous discounts on CAMRA and Alma Books publications. 
 You will be able to attend branch and regional meetings, the national AGM and take part in CAMRA activities. 
 It is good fun, too, for branches organise regular beer festivals and brewery visits. 
 Joining CAMRA is a commitment to Britain's best-known and most successful consumer organisation. 
 You will play your part in helping to preserve a distinctive beer style for future generations to enjoy.  
 The early days: CAMRA members demonstrating against the keg beer policies of a giant brewery 
 Offering drinkers a wide range of regional beers: one of many Campaign beer festivals 
 What's Brewing is CAMRA's monthly newspaper, sent free to every member. 
 It champions the cause of good beer and good pubs. 
 CAMRA and Alma Books offer a growing list of national and regional guides covering good beer, accommodation and food 
 CAMRA FACT SHEET No 7 
 Brew it yourself 
 Brewing beer at home is great fun. 
 Unlike building model aeroplanes or playing computer games, you can consume the finished product, which works out at a cost of 10p a pint. 
 When you compare that with the price of the average pub pint, the advantages of Brew-it-Yourself are clear. 
 The initial outlay is quite low and the information here is based on using equipment and ingredients that are freely available. 
 If you want to take home brewing to a more advanced stage, which entails mashing and boiling with malt and hops rather than extracts, you should buy &bquo;The Big Book of Brewing&equo; by Dave Line or &bquo;Brewing Better Beers&equo; by Ken Shales. 
 Both books are available from Amateur Winemaker Publications of Andover, Hampshire. 
 Basic equipment: a large white food-grade plastic dustbin with a capacity of at least six gallons; plastic tubing, about two metres long with an internal diameter of at least 10 millimetres; a wine cube &mdash; the plastic cubes used in an off-licence for selling draught wine and sherry are ideal; an air lock and rubber bung; about 40 one pint beer bottles; a corking machine and crown corks; a sterilising agent such as Chempro SDP or a mixture of sodium metabisulphite and citric acid; a 12 pint pan. 
 For basic ingredients it is best to buy one of the 40 pint size kits available from most home brewing shops or from branches of Boots. 
 A kit such as Edme Best Bitter, Tom Caxton Best Bitter, or John Bull Best Bitter will be a good starting kit. 
 You will also need a kilo bag of white sugar. 
 Brewing 
 Clean the white plastic brewing bucket with the sterilising fluid and rinse it thoroughly with cold water. 
 Set the bucket in the position where you intend to ferment the beer. 
 Now open the bitter kit and pour most of the hopped concentrated wort into the 12 pint pan. 
 Rinse the can out twice with boiling water to remove all the extract and pour the rinse water into the pan. 
 Add the kilo of sugar and stir water, sugar and wort until they are more or less dissolved. 
 Top the solution up to roughly eight pints with more hot water. 
 Place the pan on the cooker and bring the contents gradually to the boil. 
 Boil for ten minutes and then leave the pan to cool. 
 You can speed up the cooling by standing the pan in a sink full of cold water. 
 When the pan has cooled substantially pour the contents into the white plastic bucket, rinse out the pan and pour the rinsed water into the bucket. 
 Top up the level in the bucket to five gallons with cold water. 
 Check the temperature of the wort. 
 If it is below 21&deg;C (70&deg;F) you can pitch the yeast. 
 If the temperature is above 21&deg;C you must leave the liquid to cool, covered with a lid or a tight fitting material such as Clingfilm. 
 During fermentation it is best to aim for a uniform temperature of between 18 and 21&deg;C (62 and 70&deg;F). 
 Neither the airing cupboard nor the garden shed in winter are satisfactory. 
 If the temperature is too low the beer will stop fermenting. 
 If the temperature is too high, the yeast will mutate and produce unpleasant off flavours in the beer. 
 Primary fermentation takes from three to five days. 
 It is advisable to leave the bucket loosely covered and not to skim off the yeast head. 
 At first just a ring of bubbles will gather on the surface of the liquid. 
 Then a creamy, frothy head of yeast will form and cover the surface of the beer. 
 After a few days the head will collapse and leave a brownish pancake. 
 When this happens take a hydrometer reading and if the gravity is about 1010 syphon the beer into the wine cube. 
 The cube should be thoroughly sterilised and rinsed before use. 
 Saw off the tap from the large plastic screw cap, insert the bung and the airlock. 
 Syphon the beer into the cube, leaving as much of the sediment in the bucket as possible. 
 Fit the screw cap with the bung and airlock and put a small amount of water in the airlock. 
 After two or three days in the wine cube the beer will be ready for bottling. 
 Sterilise the bottles and rinse well. 
 Use the plastic tubing to syphon the beer from the wine cube into the bottles. 
 Add approximately half a teaspoon of white granulated sugar to each bottle before capping it. 
 This will give the beer a head when you pour it. 
 After a couple of weeks in a cool place the beer should have cleared and be ready for drinking. 
 It is best to chill the beer slightly before drinking. 
 Thirty minutes in the fridge will ensure a pleasant cool temperature and encourage the yeast to form a hard ring at the bottom of the bottle that does not rise to the surface when pouring. 
 With a little practice you should be able to brew 40 pints of good cheap beer in less than three hours' work.  
 The basic equipment needed to brew tasty &mdash; and cheap &mdash; beer at home 
 TROUBLE BREWING 
 PUB REFURBISHMENTS &mdash; OVER THE LIMIT? 
 A Report By THE CAMPAIGN FOR REAL ALE THE GEORGIAN GROUP THE SOCIETY FOR THE PROTECTION OF ANCIENT BUILDINGS THE THIRTIES SOCIETY THE VICTORIAN SOCIETY 
 TROUBLE BREWING 
 PUB REFURBISHMENTS &mdash; OVER THE LIMIT? 
 Written by David Gamston, CAMRA Richard Holder, The Victorian Society Nigel Langford, Langford Williams Partnership Steven Parissien, The Georgian Group Alan Powers, The Thirties Society Matthew Slocombe, SPAB 
 American . 
 &bquo;SO THIS IS A REAL OLD ENGLISH INN?&equo; 
 Barmaid . 
 &bquo;NO; BUT IT WILL BE IN A FORTNIGHT.&equo; 
 INTRODUCTION Steven Parissien  
 &bquo;The public house represents what should be the hub of our wheel of life, essential to our material need and second only to the church that stands and represents our spiritual necessity. 
 The Church is to the spirit as the inn is to the flesh, and, if good and well designed, they baulk the devil himself.&equo; 
 (Edwin Lutyens in The Builder,  15 October 1937, quoted in Claire Hunt, The Public House in Manchester: A Subject for Conservation,  unpublished University of Manchester MA thesis, 1989) 
 &bquo;When you have lost your Inns, drown your empty selves, for you will have lost the last of England.&equo; 
 (Hilaire Belloc, quoted in Christopher Hutt, The Death of the English Pub,  1973) 
 It is an often-repeated truism to say that the institution of the pub is unique to Britain &mdash; but it is still one which is well worth resurrecting. 
 It is also a fairly obvious statement to say that historic pubs have served the function well for hundreds of years. 
 As Alan Crawford noted in the SAVE/CAMRA report Time Gentlemen Please   of 1983, old pubs &bquo;are not isolated or monumental, but part of the fabric of the city, and of people's ordinary lives, street-corner history. 
 They are not arcane but easily enjoyable. 
 They are not inaccessible but quite the reverse, and they have their original working use still.&equo; 
 Often local pubs serve as a base for the local community: as Neil Richardson pointed out in CAMRA's Pub Preservation   report of 1980, &bquo;The pub is first and foremost a social centre, the best ever invented&hellip; 
 If the pubs are taken away then the community is the poorer for it.&equo; 
 It is thus both puzzling and worrying that so many brewers are still apparently obsessed with eradicating the uniqueness of the individual historic pub, effectively destroying what has been a familiar and secure social centre in their attempts to &bquo;improve&equo; upon a successful, time-honoured formula. 
 The pressure to remodel old pubs is of course nothing new. 
 The Victorian and Edwardian eras witnessed many wholesale rebuildings of modest Georgian drinking-houses; during the Interwar period even more money was pumped into enlarging and rebuilding old pubs, as well as in creating large new ones (see Alan Powers' essay below). 
 However, alterations were more often than not effected with some degree of sympathy for the existing fabric and atmosphere. 
 With the advent of postwar Modernism much of this sympathy evaporated. 
 The ascetic modernists' rejection of history in order to create a visionary brave New World was clearly incompatible with the historic pub. 
 This attitude was amply revealed in the results of the competition (&bquo;Inside the Pub&equo;) launched jointly by The Architectural Review   and The Brewers' Society in 1949. 
 In October of that year the AR   regretted that nearly all competition entries had evaded the key problem and had signally failed &bquo;to achieve the genuine pub atmosphere&equo;. 
 &bquo;Contemporary design&equo;, the magazine's editor regretted, &bquo;because it has no roots in the vernacular idiom&hellip; will not appear immediately familiar&equo;, whilst the &bquo;mock-Tudor and the mock-Georgian styles which have been so prevalent &mdash; no matter how misguided in themselves &mdash; have sprung&hellip; from a genuine attempt to preserve a traditional atmosphere&equo;. 
 As pub designer Tim May noted in his address to CAMRA's AGM of 1990: &bquo;By any objective standards, the competition was a disaster&equo;. 
 The response of the 1960s and 70s to this failure to capture the essence of the traditional pub was the ruthlessly-applied corporate image and the proliferation of &bquo;fun&equo; theme-pubs. 
 Thankfully, most of the more extreme excesses of the theme pub craze &mdash; so ably analysed by Christopher Hutt in his classic work of 1973 &mdash; have now disappeared. 
 With them have gone much of the outrageously condescending theorising expressed by professionals such as Watney Mann's head designer Roy Wilson-Smith, who declared in the early 70s: 
 &bquo; I want to give the people who use my houses a rare and primitive relationship with the raw forces of nature. 
 People love to be awed when they enter a pub by a superior natural force &mdash; a strange sort of higher masochism. 
 (Quoted in Hutt, p124)  
 The John Bull, Layerthorpe, York. 
 (David Gamston). 
 This is not to say, of course, that the age of the corporate brewery &mdash; or multinational &mdash; will not return: in SAVE and CAMRA's 1983 report, Nikolaus Boulting wisely warned that future students of interior design may find &bquo;that the cycle is complete, from company identity to corporate image and back in three generations&equo;. 
 The inappropriate implementation of the &bquo;theme&equo; doctrine has now, though, been replaced by equally disturbing challenges to the integrity of the historic pub. 
 Piecemeal change to pub exteriors and interiors, while more insidious than wholesale rebuilding, can be equally destructive. 
 This is particularly true today: even in the recession-hit 1990s, brewers are spending increasing amounts on pub refurbishment &mdash; more on pubs, indeed, than at any time since the 1930s. 
 Much of this is due to the face that, following the recent Monopolies and Mergers Commission report on pub ownership, many breweries are actually moving out of brewing itself and concentrating instead on pub management &mdash; an area where they believe they stand to make the greatest profits. 
 At the end of the 80s the famous Manchester firm of Boddingtons sold its brewing operation to Whitbread; yet during 1988 alone, Claire Hunt has noted, Boddingtons undertook the refurbishment of 50 of their tied houses. 
 More recently, at the end of 1990 the regional brewing giant Greenall Whitley announced that it was closing both its breweries at Warrington and Nottingham (formerly the independent Shipstone's brewery) to concentrate solely on running pubs &mdash; contracting out its beer to be produced by former rivals Allied Breweries. 
 The principal victims or beneficiaries of this change of direction are the historic tied houses. 
 And the principal problem facing them today is the replacement of genuine and much-loved historical features by bogus &bquo;period&equo; fittings &mdash; which are invariably couched in a vaguely &bquo;Victorian&equo; or &bquo;Edwardian&equo; sham-historical style. 
 It is this alarming development which most concerns the National Amenity Societies represented in this report. 
 In 1988 the Mintel study The On Trade Revolution   optimistically reported that, &bquo;far from disappearing, traditional pubs are being lovingly restored in most cases. 
 Natural materials, salvaged antiques and fittings, deep pile carpets and chintz are the order of the day&equo; (Hunt, p43). 
 All too often, however, such fittings and materials are not only historically inappropriate &mdash; stained tropical hardwood from razed rainforests, horse brasses and rows of unwanted Book Club volumes are no substitute for an original, atmospheric interior &mdash; but also pay scant attention to the history and development of each individual building. 
 As internal partitions and old seating are removed in favour of connected raised levels of hardwood balustrades and matching chairs, the uniqueness of the pub is generally the first casualty. 
 Rarely is the customer consulted; in far too many cases the regular is a powerless bystander as his or her pub is transformed by identikit &bquo;Victoriana&equo;. 
 As Claire Hunt observed, Chris Thompson's Beware the Barmaid's Smile   of 1985 neatly summed up the trend in pub interiors in the 1980: 
 &bquo;The transformation of the British pub currently underway has not occurred because of some conscious desertion of its doors by the public, but it is the result of some very careful planning by groups of retailers, marketing managers and accountants (back up by designers) encamped in the higher echelons of the brewing trade. 
 Far from being a conclusion of the &bquo;consumer-led&equo; revolution beloved of propagandists, the change is the child of a retail revolution which, for the consumer, constitutes only a re-arrangement of his or her individual powerlessness.&equo; 
 Disregard for the individual qualities of pub interiors can be fatal. 
 A pub, like any other old building, is far more than just its principle facade, or its four walls. 
 As Neil Richardson noted in 1980, &bquo;An old town pub is not just an attractive Victorian or Georgian facade, it is a building which is still being used for the purpose for which it was built. 
 The design of interiors&hellip; are as valid today as they were in earlier times &mdash; the vaults, snugs, parlours, each with their own character, can still provide a pleasant, varied atmosphere&equo;. 
 However, to public and professionals alike many old buildings are still regarded as representing little more than four external walls. 
 This even applies to listed buildings: there is still a worryingly widespread general belief that listing only covers the facade, or perhaps just the exterior, whereas it is of course expressly designed to protect the whole  building. 
 Of those pubs which are listed &mdash; and there are still dismally few &mdash; such an attitude inevitably leads to a total disregard for those special qualities which distinguish the pub interior.  
 Historic pub interiors, as well as pub exteriors, are vital and irreplaceable elements of our cultural and social heritage. 
 This should not obscure the obvious fact that they are also profit-making concerns, too. 
 As such, they need constant updating &mdash; especially if the perceived trend towards reduced pub-going is to be reversed. 
 (In their 1988 survey, Mintel noted that &bquo;the proportion of consumer expenditure represented by alcohol consumption has fallen steadily, whilst at the same time that spent on leisure as a whole has increased&equo; (Hunt, p42).) 
 Changes to the fabric have to be effected as new toilets are installed, or greater provision is made for food preparation facilities. 
 New and increasingly stringent fire regulations have to be accommodated and licensing magistrates &mdash; who often care little for the architectural integrity of historic pubs, but are principally concerned with good and easy supervision of the pub clientele &mdash; have to be appeased. 
 All of these factors may be detrimental to original interior features. 
 However, many breweries have taken advantage of such requirements to completely remodel their historic pubs. 
 Whilst the age of the theme pub may be over, more and more old pubs are being transformed into identical, pseudo-historical clones. 
 This is especially true of those pubs now targeted by the breweries as centres for family eating. 
 A traditional interior does not have to be incompatible with accommodating whole families, nor with providing meals; yet an increasing number of old pub interiors are being sacrificed on the altar of the identikit eating house &mdash; whether the brewer's concept be a downmarket steakhouse or part of a family restaurant chain masquerading as an independent local concern. 
 Many of the interiors created by the designers of such facilities are as forbidding as the old-fashioned spit-and-sawdust pub; any lingering atmosphere is swept away in a barrage of stained wood and fake Victoriana, and any casual visitors made to feel inordinately guilty if they do not, alas, wish to eat. 
 The subjugation of individual character in such cases &mdash; which on occasion even involves the removal of all traces of the pub's actual name &mdash; is particularly depressing. 
 The aim of this report is not to demand that brewers turn the block back to 1620, 1720, 1820 or even to 1920; pubs have to make money, and have to adapt to some extent to changing needs and expectations. 
 Nor does it pretend to provide a detailed and exhaustive analysis of the condition of Britain's pubs. 
 The aim is to present a brief overview of what is happening to historic pubs today, and to provide suggestions as to how this perceived threat to our old pubs can be effectively limited. 
 In this respect it supplements, rather than replaces, publications of the past such as the 1983 SAVE/CAMRA report and detailed regional studies such as Claire Hunt's of 1988. 
 Each of the organisations involved has its own particular viewpoint, none of which has been stifled for the sake of consistent unanimity. 
 We have also included the observations of a leading pub designer in order to give the report more breadth. 
 By presenting a broad front, which encompasses the country's official architectural watchdogs as well as the Campaign for Real Ale, we hope to alert both the general public and the brewing trade to what we believe is a growing and serious threat to our cultural heritage.   
 The Queen's Head in Little Underbank, Stockport today, after sympathetic refurbishment. 
 Winner of CAMRA's 1990 Pub Refurbishment Award. 
 (Ian Parry/Traditional Homes Magazine). 
 TRADITIONAL PUBS IN FOCUS: A CAMRA ANGLE David Gamston  
 Most people nowadays would agree that a good pub is one of our best traditions and a vital and distinctive ingredient of our national way of life. 
 One problem with this cosy consensus, and its greatest irony, is that as a nation we take our pubs too much for granted. 
 We can believe that the pub is universally respected and prized and that there is common cause and common understanding between owners, operators and users alike. 
 If so, our sense of the true and the false is too easily deceived and manipulated. 
 The modern world is one which confuses and plunders our sense of the past; one where even the concept of &bquo;heritage&equo; itself is hi-jacked and distorted. 
 And with the pub in particular some of the loudest siren voices proclaiming &bquo;heritage&equo; are often the very ones most intent on debasing its meaning for us. 
 The pub has always had to tread a difficult tightrope in reconciling its social function, as a &bquo;house&equo; for the public, with its commercial function as a retail shop. 
 Imposed fashions are certainly nothing new &mdash; as the periodic crazes for pub refurbishment, from the Victorian era onwards, clearly testify. 
 However, it is well recognised by conservationists that the modern pace and scale of change poses a threat which is quite  unprecendented . 
 In today's accountant-led brewing industry the destiny of individual pubs is often decided in remote boardrooms by managers answerable only to corporate dogmas and next year's profit forecasts. 
 We live in the fading twilight of an &bquo;overpubbed&equo; urban world; a world which, even within living memory, gave the citizens of a small city like York the choice to drink in a different pub for every day of the year. 
 Present-day reality is that pub deaths far exceed births, and the signs are that this is an accelerating process. 
 As a result, the brunt of investment pressures will have to be borne by an ever-decreasing stock of pubs; and what good pubs we have left will be more than ever exposed to the cold winds of change. 
 When the Campaign for Real Ale embarked in the early 1970s on its crusade to preserve and promote our disappearing beer heritage, three watchwords came quickly to the fore; choice, quality and tradition. 
 At once CAMRA declared itself as both a consumer and a conservationist watchdog, speaking up for citizens as well as consumers against the abuses inflicted on one of our best national traditions. 
 Exactly the same battlelines, with exactly the same watchwords and against much the same enemies, now urgently need to be drawn up to save the traditional British pub. 
 An old-fashioned, romanticised image of the pub is common fodder for our national nostalgia industry. 
 Cosy images of thatched country inns abound on glossy book covers. 
 Christmas cards, chocolate boxes and tourist literature, proclaiming a timeless tradition that is supposed to be the envy of the world. 
 Too often, though, myth and reality part company outside the door, behind the roses and the last flailing morris dancer. 
 We are not shown the acres of car park, the oversized modern restaurant extension and the gutted interior, knocked together from what were once intimate old rooms. 
 Yet if we should catch a glimpse of the fake plastic beams, the mass-produced horsebrasses, cartwheels and hunting prints there will, often as not, be unnerving claims of &bquo;genuine olde worlde atmosphere&equo; for this mishmash of bogus antiquity. 
 The myth-makers, with the tourist boards prominent among them, carefully ignore the fact that genuine historic quality has been lost forever from most of Britain's pubs. 
 In York, one of the country's major historic and tourist centres and the city best known to this writer, the visitor's search for some genuine experience of a better, bygone England will find little reward inside most of the old city's public houses. 
 There is little trace left of York's truly ancient coaching, posting and market inns, while nearly half the pubs which were standing in the 1950s, including some historic gems, have been closed down, converted, or redeveloped into oblivion. 
 Many of the pubs which are passed off as &bquo;historic&equo; to the visitor and tourist prove to be only film-set facades on what are now little more than youthful amusement arcades or glorified fast-food cafes.  
 Fewer than ten of the sixty or so pubs occupying old buildings in central York have completely escaped assault by post-war &bquo;improvements&equo;, and in none of these is the surviving pub interior any older than late Victorian. 
 Indeed what we are now seeing in some cases as &bquo;the genuine article&equo; are quality brewery refurbishments dating from the 1920s and 1930s, good Brewers &bquo;Tudor, maybe, but hardly the stuff of the ancient, inglenooky world that the modern myth-makers &mdash; the brewers and the tourism industry &mdash; would have us believe still exists. 
 Most of York's old central pubs have fallen victim to drastic recent remodelling with yawning spaces, often indistinguishable from one pub to another, replacing the old rooms and idiosyncratic nooks and corners that previously gave individuality and preserved genuine historic character. 
 That two dozen of these interiors are in buildings statutorily &bquo;listed&equo; for their special architectural or historic interest say much for the low regard paid to pubs in the exercise of listed building control and indeed for the listing process itself. 
 A striking example of this is the list description for The Blue Bell in Fossgate, the last perfectly-surviving Victorian pub interior in York and one of only two pubs left in the city of truly national importance. 
 The premises is described as follows; 
 &bquo;Circa 1600 with later additions. 
 Refronted in brick early C18: 2 gables: 3 storeys: 5 sash windows (generally minus glazing bars): dentil and modillion eaves cornice: modern shop front&equo; 
 Reality, in York as elsewhere, means precious little public protection for our pubs and heavy reliance on the better nature of the brewers credit &mdash; brewers such as Samuel Smith's, for  for  their loving and appropriately &bquo;benign neglect&equo; of a low-barrelage, unpretentious gem like The Wellington Inn in Alma Terrace, York. 
 Some enlightened companies, like Joshua Tetley in the 1980s, even started their own special designation schemes for the best historic pubs in their tied estates. 
 The Fox in Holgate Road, York was an outstanding beneficiary of the &bquo;Tetley Heritage Pub&equo; initiative of that time. 
 It is a quite perfect example of pub conservation, combining careful preservation of the Victorian compartmented interior and servery arrangement, with judicious enhancement and enlargement of drinking areas. 
 This kind of move came at a time when Tetley's, along with other arms of Allied Breweries, espoused and encouraged a culture of well-informed and caring in-house designers. 
 Times change, however, and today, under a somewhat different corporate regime, &bquo;Heritage&equo; starts to smack of yesterday's fashion, and one is not entirely sure what commitment remains. 
 Already the other Tetley Heritage Pub in York, The Swan, is out on lease to an independent retailing chain. 
 Moreover, the very same Tetley's who so lovingly restored The Fox are now building, in the heart of a residential suburb not two miles away, an open-plan eating barn that contravenes all the accepted standards of enlightened and community-sensitive pub design. 
 Reliance on the brewers' better nature is a precarious sort of dependency, where today's Jekyll can be tomorrow's Hyde. 
 Our pubs are forever at risk of corporate gimmickry and catchpenny fashions. 
 And not only are the major brewers at fault. 
 Countless independent &bquo;free house&equo; owners have copied brewers' fashions and wrought untold havoc with unassuming old country pubs before moving on to pastures new. 
 Philistinism is rife, and it is high time for some loud restatement of the old conservationist maxim that ownership is no more than a temporary rental on the nation's heritage. 
 That any of our pubs can, at a stroke, be shut down or altered by uncaring owners, without any proper consultation with users or the community, is little short of a continuing national disgrace. 
 Our perception of the pub has to work at a number of levels &mdash; mostly obvious, but nonetheless worth clarifying. 
 First of all, the pub is an establishment where particular kinds of activity take place &mdash; the most important of which is informal social drinking, particularly of beer, our national drink. 
 It is quite unlike any other public, social or recreational establishment. 
 Entry is free, no membership is required, and it is open to any adult to enter, be served a drink and relax. 
 Pubs are, to quote Ben Davis, &bquo;the public buildings in which people feel most at home&equo;, and in its truest sense the public house is exactly what it says &mdash; a house   for the public  . 
 This is the pub as social institution, so much more than just a place for drinking. 
 The loss or senseless alteration of the many &bquo;ordinary&equo; pubs that serve these functions can deal a serious blow to the quality of life of their users and the well-being of the wider community. 
 This is especially the case in rural communities, many villages depending entirely on just one pub. 
 For these very reasons, the care of our nation's pubs is much more than an exercise in architectural conservation.  
 If the pub as an institution expresses itself in a rich variety of ways, the same is true of the physical forms it takes. 
 One very obvious but important observation is that a pub is first and foremost an interior. 
 There are, of course, countless buildings that were purposely designed as pubs, yet many more occupy buildings intended for some other, usually domestic, use. 
 To this extent it is not especially helpful to see pubs as a category of buildings, but rather to keep a clear distinction in mind between interior and exterior. 
 To do otherwise is to play into the hands of the facadists and myth-makers. 
 Our country has more than enough pubs whose ruined interiors fail to live up to the promise of attractive historic frontages. 
 A number of modern pub designers attempt to rescue a sense of intimacy and defensible space by dividing these open-plan arenas into token drinking areas. 
 Yet a proper compartmentalisation of pub interiors means real choice for customers. 
 It enhances a pub's ability to cater for the different and sometimes conflicting activities and tastes of different customers under the same roof, and in so doing it keeps alive the healthy social and age mix that is a traditional hallmark of the true pub. 
 The current obsession with pseudo-Victorian and other bogus &bquo;historical&equo; styles imposed willy-nilly and quite regardless of the true age of the pub, seems to suggest two things; firstly that pub designers and fitters have completely lost their way, both in recognising and respecting what is genuinely old and in looking for a wholeheartedly modern pub style; secondly that there is   some  king  of awareness, correct but misguided, that people like their pubs to look old and feel familiar. 
 The great pity of this is that most pubs are   old, yet the proper opportunity to celebrate this has already been squandered.  
 There appears to be no creative public vision which will help the survival of the pub or help ensure a healthy and varied pub stock. 
 History, indeed, tends to show that public intervention can have the effect of reinforcing rather than curbing market excesses. 
 It was the licensing system and licensing controls, after all, which helped to foster Britain's peculiar &bquo;brewery tie&equo; and concentrate pub ownership in the hands of the brewers in the first place; and it was the same system which connived at and partly encouraged the modern contagion of open-plan pub designs. 
 In addition, the 1989 MMC Report, conceived as an attack in the public interest on the monopoly power of the major brewers and requiring the &bquo;untying&equo; of large chunks of their tied estates, may have devastating consequences for traditional pubs. 
 For despite their other shortcomings, most of the major brewers have been able and willing to cross-subsidise many less profitable houses. 
 Equally, the brewery-tie system has sheltered much pub property in tied tenancies from the harsh winds of the Market. 
 Investment in these has often been minimal &mdash; which, in the equation of pub conservation, has been a benign force for preserving many of our best traditional pubs. 
 All this is now due to change and it is, not surprisingly, the smaller, less profitable and traditionally-run tenanted houses that are in the front line for disposal. 
 There are still some genuinely old pubs remaining, as yet untouched by crass modernisation, which appeal to our true instincts of heritage and our craving for some sense of permanence and continuity in a fast changing world. 
 By far the best service that can now be done to these pubs, both for ourselves and future generations, is to leave well alone.  
 The Wellington Inn, Alma Terrace, York  (David Gamston). 
 The Church Inn, Newton Road, Lawton, near Manchester: above, cement render and plastic windows; below, partitions and other historic features removed from the interior in its conversion to a single-room bar  (Claire Hunt). 
 The bar at The Lighthorseman, Fulford Road, York. 
 This Late Georgian and Victorian pub is currently a prime candidate for listing; it is also, however, earmarked for disposal by its current owners, Bass. 
 (David Gamston). 
 MEDIEVAL AND EARLY MODERN PUBS Matthew Slocombe  
 A house of sin you may call it, but not a house of darkness for the candles are never out, and it is like those countries far in the north where it is as clear at mid-night as at mid-day&hellip; 
 To give you the total reckoning of it: it is the busy man's recreation, the idle man's business, the melancholy man's sanctuary, the stranger's welcome, the Inns of Court man's entertainment, the scholar's kindness and the citizen's courtesy. 
 (John Earle 1628). 
 As today, drinking establishments held an important social and cultural position in medieval and early modern England. 
 These establishments were divided into inns, alehouses and taverns which had separate and distinct functions. 
 The inn was generally the largest of the three, providing accommodation as well as beverages, and was typically located in market places or on through routes. 
 Architecturally, the inn was often distinguished by an inner courtyard, sometimes with gallery, reached through an archway in the facade. 
 Some examples from the pre-reformation period, such as the magnificent George Inn at Norton St. Philip, Somerset, originally constructed in the 14th century, were established by monasteries for pilgrims and travellers; but after the dissolutions of the 1530s all were held in secular hands and subsequently catered for the increasing number of road travellers in the 16th century and the stage coach trade that first appeared in the early 17th century. 
 William Harrison noted in 1587 that: 
 In all our inns we have plenty of ale, beer and sundry kinds of wine and such is the capacity of some of these that they are able to lodge two hundred or three hundred persons and their horses. 
 In the medieval period the church was also involved in the brewing of its own church-ales, which were made on an occasional basis and produced a useful income supplement; in late medieval times these were often served in the Church House that frequently adjoined the churchyard. 
 The church-ales provided competition for the secular supply of beverages from the taverns and alehouses. 
 Both these establishments seem to have had an architectural form very similar to the ordinary domestic buildings of their area, and the hall provided the communal eating and drinking space. 
 The tavern was a meeting place, usually in the centre of the town or village, where wine was normally served. 
 According to John Earle, writing in 1628, the inn was a superior establishment to the alehouses and was &bquo; a degree or (if you will) a pair of stairs above an alehouse, where men are drunk with more credit and apology &equo;. 
 The alehouse in its most basic form was simply a domestic building where ale was sold to generate additional income for the household, although David Lupton observed in 1632 that the alehouse keeper &bquo; defies a wine tavern as an upstart outlandish fellow, and suspects the wine to be poisoned. 
 Her ale, if new, looks like a misty morning, all thick .&equo; 
 During the 20th century an &bquo;historic&equo; architectural character &mdash; perhaps most typically that of the timber framed building &mdash; has become popular with, and desirable to, both publicans and brewers. 
 In many cases this has resulted in the introduction of faked features and the associated destruction of existing features which, though often of architectural and historic interest in their own right, do not fit in with the designer's concept of the pub's ideal form. 
 Artificial plastic beams are frequently introduced, ceilings are stripped of plaster to reveal floor joists that were never intended to be seen, other timbers are artificially blackened to create a supposedly &bquo;traditional&equo; though in fact inauthentic &bquo;black and white&equo; effect and render or plaster is removed from walls to produce &bquo;rustic&equo; charm. 
 At the Saracen's Head at Towcester, for example, a recent proposal to historicise the pub involved extensive destruction of genuine historic fabric and the introduction of the worst cliches of &bquo;traditional&equo; pub detail, such as bulls-eye glass and copper lanterns. 
 In recent years serious damage to the historic interiors of pubs has resulted from the creation of the open-plan which now seem to be pubs' standard internal layout. 
 Often the creation of the open plan interior requires the removal of walls, chimney breasts, stairs and other internal features of interest, which is highly destructive of the building's historic character. 
 The owner of &bquo;The Hollybush&equo; at Elstree proposed to infill an original coach arch in the pub's facade and to demolish the timber framed side walls of the passageway behind in order to form a larger and open interior, even though it was this feature that distinguished the building as an historic inn. 
 In the most extreme cases the existing building is so different from the &bquo;historic&equo; pub concept that a virtual rebuild is proposed. 
 At the Huntsman's Inn in Ide, Kent, the refurbishment proposals were to involve demolitions so extensive that all but a portion of the building's external wall would be destroyed, the planned reconstruction included an extension that would double the size of the original structure. 
 It seems most surprising that the breweries consider the large open space to be the pub's ideal internal form, or believe the artificial, standardised &bquo;historic&equo; pub interior to be preferable to genuine historic detail, when the original internal divisions and features are essential elements of the historic character that customers expect when entering such a building.  
 The Duke's Arms at Presteigne in Powys provides the perfect illustration of how the misguided quest for the ideal &bquo;traditional&equo; pub character can seriously threaten genuine historic features. 
 This pub was originally a 17th century timber frame jettied building; in the early 19th century its front was removed and a new rendered facade added. 
 Although the loss of the original front is regrettable, the present facade is in accord with the general architectural character of the street and retains original late-Georgian features, such as its sashes with glazing bars. 
 The pub's owner, however, wished to remove the 19th century facade and undertake a conjectural restoration of the jetted, timber framed front (the design of which included various historically inaccurate details). 
 The public clearly believed that this &bquo;restoration&equo; would enhance the building's interest despite destroying an historic element; he must also have felt that a new timber framed facade, despite its inauthenticity, would give the pub an &bquo;historic&equo; character that was more readily recognisable and instantly attractive to potential customers. 
 If pub owners were prepared to emphasise the interest of genuine historic features, regardless of period, then this type of fakery, which disappoints or sadly deceives the customer in search of the traditional pub and irreparably removes much of a building's interest for future generations, could be avoided.   
 Georgian frontage of The Duke's Arms, Presteigne, Powys  (Andrew Arrol). 
 Cruck Barn at Pincents Manor, Reading, Berkshire: the ludicrous spectacle of a bogus &bquo;half-timbered&equo; bar in the midst of a genuinely medieval timber-framed barn  (Kenneth Major). 
 THE GEORGIAN PUB Steven Parissien 
 The modern pub is essentially a Victorian creation. 
 However, many of the features of the pub as we know it today were developed during the Georgian period; at the same time, many Georgian pub buildings &mdash; or at least Georgian architectural fittings &mdash; still survive today. 
 As communications improved during the 18th century, so the number of coaching inns or pubs situated at turnpikes increased. 
 To cater for the expanding coaching trade, many inns erected large carriage entrance on the street front and stables at the rear to facilitate the changing and housing of horses. 
 Those coaching inns which already existed were frequently refronted or even remodelled in the latest Georgian style. 
 At the other end of the scale, many rural or urban homes were adapted to serve as simple beerhouses, with little internal alteration. 
 By 1830 the pub had become comparatively sophisticated, responding to the changing demands and the technological advances of the industrial revolution. 
 &bquo;Shop-taverns&equo;, serving the passing trade as well as the locals, had become common in many towns, whilst many pubs had been partitioned into two distinct areas &mdash; the bar room and the tap room. 
 Modern serving equipment &mdash; including beer machines and even slop trays &mdash; had appeared. 
 And the bar on which they stood had evolved from a simple counter or hatch to something approaching the form we know today: in his Encyclopaedia of Cottage, Farm and Villa Architecture   of 1833 J C Loudon described the ideal bar (the place &bquo;from which all orders are issued&equo;) as being &bquo;of some size&equo;, with &bquo;commanding views of the front entrance hall and back entrance&equo;. 
 By the end of the Regency period the pub was becoming a far more attractive proposition for the government, too. 
 Wellington's Beerhouse Act of 1830 represented the most blatant attempt to eradicate the gin shop by promoting beer &mdash; and pubs &mdash; as a healthier alternative, abolishing the duty on beer and taking beerhouse licenses out of the control of the licensing justices. 
 Thus many of the elements of the familiar Victorian pub were already in place at the time of William IV's death in 1837. 
 Inevitably, few Georgian beerhouses or coaching inns survive in anything like their original form, having been comprehensively extended or altered in subsequent decades. 
 Given the propensity of many modern breweries and their designers to impose an overall, single-period &bquo;look&equo;, however, the Georgian fabric that does exist is often the first thing to be swept away &mdash; to make way for a sham-Victorian world of clumsy stained glass and ugly stained hardwood. 
 Georgian windows, for example, are especially vulnerable to replacement by plastic (UPVC) examples. 
 The visual result can be seen in the accompanying illustration of Watneys' Crown at Haddiscoe in Norfolk: two-dimensional windows with flat, reflectant glass and sham glazing-bar strips which wholly fail to capture the depth and character of the original openings. 
 Despite what brewers' architects often allege, the life expectancy of such plastic window units is proving remarkably short &mdash; as little as five years for the fittings, and twenty years for the plastic itself, which is exhibiting distinct tendencies to warp and discolour with age. 
 Thus the arguments for easier maintenance and greater longevity of plastic windows appear to have little foundation in fact &mdash; an argument often ignored by the brewers.  
 Given their prime location in the centre of towns and on major thoroughfares, Georgian coaching inns are frequently prime targets for refurbishment. 
 Such redevelopment is often unnecessary and detrimental; the end product of such schemes is all too often a sham-historical parody, re-creating an idealised, sanitised Britain that never actually existed. 
 In SAVE's 1983 report Mike Pearce observed that many of the pubs in Winchester's historic city centre &bquo;have been modernised and remodernised to present the tourist with open-plan fast-food interiors modelled in the character of some mythical Merrie Englande&equo;. 
 Nor do Georgian country pubs escape, either. 
 Many emerge from &bquo;refurbishment&equo; with little of their original partitions, fittings or even masonry remaining. 
 A good example of this can be found in the sleep village of Buckland in Oxfordshire! 
 The Lamb, a picturesque village pub closed some years ago by Allied, was reopened in 1989 as a free house after an extensive remodelling &mdash; which involved the complete gutting of the original unexceptional but characterful, partitioned interior. 
 Now nothing remains whatsoever of the old fittings, features or proportions; in their place is a vast, open-plan space with bright white walls, bistro furniture and cheery chintz. 
 A similar treatment was recently meted out by Allied's Tetley Walker subsidiary to what remains a fundamentally Georgian pub in an urban setting near Manchester &mdash; the Church Inn at Lowton. 
 Having applied cement render over the external brickwork, attached a hideous modern porch and added an extension in jarring and inappropriate modern materials, the brewery designers have gutted the interior. 
 As at Buckland, all of the original divisions have been removed to make one long, characterless room, from which all trace of its former features has disappeared. 
 Countless other pubs which date from the Georgian period, or at least incorporate a significant element of Georgian building work, have suffered similar fates. 
 National brewing giants such as Allied or Whitbread, though, are not the only villains; small independent firms can be just as insensitive in their treatment of their tied houses. 
 Claire Hunt, for instance, noted in 1988 of North Western brewers Robinsons that they &bquo;appear on the whole to be fairly oblivious to the individual merits of their historic pubs.&equo; 
 One key problem with the more domestically-scaled Georgian pubs is that they were often originally conceived as, or converted from, modest homes. 
 The numerous internal partitions that result have often proved anathema to modern-day breweries. 
 In 1988 Courage's Head of Design disdainfully referred to such ramshackle, unplanned buildings as &bquo;an abundance of licensed living rooms&equo;; many of his contemporaries have enthusiastically destroyed the internal room plan of such cosy and comfortable buildings in order to install in its place a series of short flights between ascending levels &mdash; an increasingly common solution originally devised by pub designer Roy Wilson-Smith in the 1970s.  
 A typically problematical situation is currently faced by Samuel Smiths at their London flagship of the Olde Cheshire Cheese in Fleet Street. 
 This atmospheric Grade II building &mdash; dating from the late 17th century but with a primarily Georgian bar and substantial Victorian additions &mdash; is a prime tourist attraction. 
 However, whilst its cramped and dark interiors are highly evocative of past centuries, they are also difficult to manage and flout modern fire safety regulations. 
 As such, the brewery has resolved to &bquo;improve&hellip; the operational efficiency of the building generally&equo; by remodelling the cellar area and the annexe building to the north and by giving the pub a frontage on Fleet Street. 
 Inevitably, this will entail losing some of the irreplaceable character of this unique building. 
 The new street elevation proposed by the architects (Waterhouse Ripley Adie Button) has been sensitively treated; however, the extension to the north will necessitate diluting much of the pub's evocative and cosy proportions, and it remains to be seen whether the design of the newly-created bar areas survives comparison with the adjacent historic interiors. 
 Work on this refurbishment is due to begin in May 1991. 
 An additional problem faced by many Georgian pubs &mdash; particularly historic coaching inns &mdash; is the treatment of re-use of stables and other related outbuildings. 
 As Matthew Saunders noted in the 1983 SAVE/CAMRA Report: 
 &bquo; The freestanding stable wing, the coachmen and ostlers&equo; accommodation, the skittle alley and cobbled yard can be of the greatest interest and yet are very vulnerable to the ubiquitous need, often enforced by the planning authorities, for adequate car parking space. 
 Indeed such is the pressure for adequate car parking that there are a surprising number of cases where brewing companies have applied for permission to demolish not only outbuildings but adjacent cottages, some of them listed&hellip; &equo;  
 A number of the larger Georgian pubs originally accommodated outbuildings to the rear. 
 One such example is the Grade II Pen and Parchment on Bridgefoot in Stratford-upon-Avon, where the barn at the back of the pub was used as a theatre throughout the 18th century. 
 Such appropriately Stratfordian associations have, however, been totally disregarded by Whitbread in their recent cavalier remodelling of the complex. 
 Not only are the pub interiors themselves of the nondescript, open-plan kind, but the barn to the rear has been wholly mutilated. 
 Fortunately, not all recent pub refurbishments have been in this vein. 
 A number of the big breweries have recently made encouraging moves towards a more sympathetic attitude to their historic pubs. 
 Allied's Tetley Walker subsidiary have established a further subdivision, Peter Walker, catering exclusively for their historic outlets, while Grand Metropolitan's Group Estates Director recently assured the Georgian Group that &bquo;we will always consider historic and aesthetic considerations in all our refurbishments.&equo; 
 Even so, such vague promises are no grounds for satisfaction, let alone complacency. 
 Much needs to be done. 
 The multi-roomed and historically-eclectic pub needs to be protected against the ravages of the all-over designer look. 
 As has been frequently pointed out, it is no use providing excellent beer or food if the pub in question has lost all of its charm and atmosphere; and surely a multi-roomed pub, with a number of differing environments, is the best way to serve what is after all always a very diverse and unstandardised community. 
 In 1976 the Lord Chief Justice, dismissing Bass Charrington's appeal against a proposal to &bquo;open up&equo; the interior at the Romans Hotel in Southwick, Sussex, declared that it might be &bquo;undesirable in the public interest to see more public bars disappearing and more mergers of public and saloon bars of the kind in question here&hellip;&equo; 
 In addition, far better liaison needs to be established between the breweries and local authority Conservation and Planning Officers, English Heritage, the National Amenity Societies, local civic bodies and, of course, pub landlords and their clientele over planned pub refurbishments. 
 In particular, licensing magistrates and fire and health authorities should be made more aware of the character and needs of historic buildings. 
 In order to help effect this, far more pubs of historic importance need to be specifically listed &mdash; and listed as pubs, not simply as buildings with noteworthy features. 
 As Claire Hunt recently suggested: 
 &bquo;&hellip; is would be helpful if the Listing Division of the Department of the Environment could revise their own guidelines in order that certain pubs could receive more protection as an integral whole. 
 Also, if there was any way of legally protecting historic furnishings, this could be recommended&hellip; 
 Perhaps some consideration might be additionally given to the current situation regarding the lack of protection for the current situation regarding the lack of protection for the interiors of unlisted buildings within conservation areas&hellip;&equo; 
 Ms Hunt noted that, in the whole Greater Manchester area, only 83 pubs out of a total of 3,712 were listed &mdash; and then, all but one just grade II. 
 Without sufficient protection, both the exteriors and interiors of historic pubs are still very much at risk. 
 TROUBLE BREWING  
 A typical Georgian coaching inn with large carriage arch: The George and Dragon, High St, Cheadle, Cheshire  (Claire Hunt). 
 Disfiguring plastic UPVC window units at Watney's The Crown at Hiddiscoe in Norfolk  (Roger White). 
 The Lamb, Buckland, Oxfordshire: its exterior charm remains (left), but inside (right) little remains of the former interior. 
 (Rebecca Katkin). 
 The Cheshire Cheese, Fleet Street, City of London. 
 Top left, projected plan, showing additional areas to the top and right; right, the projected frontage to Fleet Street  (Waterhouse Ripley Adie Button); bottom left, the old front to Wine Office Court in February 1991  (Steven Parissien). 
 Left, the exterior of The Pen and Parchment, Stratford-upon-Avon: Georgian windows masked by large blinds on the left, with what remains of the Georgian barn on the right. 
 Right, the ruthlessly stripped interior retains very little evidence of its Georgian glory  (William Hawkes). 
 The Grade II-listed George and Dragon in Chesham, Buckinghamshire: a fine Early Georgian refronting to the High Street, but inside little remains of its Georgian or Victorian fittings. 
 (Steven Parissien). 
 In Chesham's Church Street a fine listed Georgian pub which has been sensitively modernised: Brakspear's Queen's Head. 
 (Steven Parissien). 
 VICTORIAN PUBS Richard Holder  
 The Victorian period not only established the modern popular image of public houses, but also saw the involvement of specialists and well-known architects in their design. 
 The 19th century witnessed the evolution of public and saloon bars; the introduction of bar, or counter, rather than waiter, service; and the legal licensing of premises, all of which had profound effects on pub design. 
 As a result of the constant remodelling of premises through the period, most of the Victorian pub interiors which survive are late 19th century in date, and most attempts to create &bquo;Victorian&equo; interiors concentrate on the grander survivals; this, combined with the common inability to create a sympathetic design, has led to a stereotype of the Victorian pub which is inaccurate. 
 The limited design vocabulary used in modern refurbishment and pub design has led to a proliferation of etched and &bquo;stained&equo; glass; dark mahogany-stained bars; marble-topped cast-iron tables; shelves of unread books, bottles, plates and brasses; deep-buttoned plush upholstery; patterned carpets and wallpaper; and brass ceiling fans. 
 This creates an interior that no Victorian would recognise. 
 The rich variety of pub types created during the 19th century has subsequently been largely lost by redevelopment and remodelling. 
 This not only makes an understanding of the nature of Victorian pubs difficult, but also means that those which do survive merit special care and attention. 
 One of the most important changes in pub design during this period was in the plan. 
 Pre-Victorian pubs were largely run on the basis of waiter-service, following from the original concept that the pub was a house open to the public for refreshment &mdash; hence the term &bquo;public house&equo;. 
 Thus the introduction of bar service was a revolution. 
 Bar service enabled various different rooms, or cabins within rooms, to be served from a central point; many late-Victorian pubs had a sequence of separate private bars serve from a single bar-counter, in total contrast to the current fashion for single-room pubs. 
 The modern desire for open-plan has led to the removal of many bar-partitions, destroying the character of original interiors and distorting any attempt to create a truly &bquo;Victorian&equo; interior. 
 The small private bars not only created intimate areas within a pub for small groups of people, but also enabled a wide variety of people to be served in the same building. 
 A 1907 description of a &bquo;typical suburban pub&equo; with six bars featured omnibus drivers and conductors in the &bquo;four-ale&equo; bar, &bquo;horny handed sons of toil and lady customers&equo; in the bar opposite, with other woman in the &bquo;bottle and jug&equo;. 
 The private bar contained those who wanted to avoid the &bquo;mutable many&equo;, and the saloon bar contained the &bquo;lads of the village&equo; and their ladies. 
 The niceties of these social distinctions were not lost on the pub designer of the period, as they boosted pub taking by enabling such a wide range of people to be served in the same building. 
 Except for the late 19th century saloon bars, Victorian pubs were, in contrast to modern &bquo;Victorian-style&equo; pubs, normally very plainly furnished and fitted. 
 Thus walls were often covered with, and the bar partitions made of, tongue-and-groove boarding, which was often grained. 
 Floors were frequently made from bare wooden boards or stone slab. 
 The exception was in the treatment of the bar itself, which was often treated as a decorative eyecatcher. 
 This approach to design could formerly be seen in the Public Bar of the White Swan, Bradford Street, Deritend, Birmingham (owned by Allied's Ansells division). 
 This 1900 pub has a tongue-and-groove dado, about which the walls are covered with glazed tiles. 
 The focus of the design was the decorative bar and its back display area, whose strong lighting made it the centrepiece of the pub. 
 This concept has, however, been ruined by the introduction of a bar overhang with secondary lighting which obscure views of the back-bar display. 
 Bookshelves for unread books have also been introduced. 
 It is a pity that the brewers did not follow the example offered by The Clements Arms, Coventry Road,  Bordesly , Birmingham, where there is an interior of the 1870s which was restored in the mid 1980s by cleaning and a lick of paint. 
 This unaltered, restored pub now attracts a large custom, demonstrating that expensive refurbishments are not necessary to guarantee profits.  
 Richly-decorated Saloon Bars more closely approximate to the modern idea of a Victorian pub. 
 However the Saloon Bar was only one section of the pub, and only originated as part of the trend of the 1890s towards gentrification. 
 Its misapplication can be seen at Allied's The Tabard in Turnham Green, West London, designed by Richard Norman Shaw. 
 Shaw's Tabard Inn formed part of the Bedford Park Garden Suburb, a speculative development in the new &bquo;Queen Anne Style&equo;; The Tabard, set at the centre of the development, forms part of the &bquo;Village Street&equo; opposite the Church of St. Michael and All Angels. 
 Bedford Park is regarded as the first Garden Suburb in England, and thus has an international importance, while Shaw is one of the most important architects of the Victorian period, best known as the designer of the old New Scotland Yard building on the London Embankment. 
 One would thus hope that the treatment of The Tabard would reflect its key role in the area and the importance of its architect. 
 However a recent redecoration has demonstrated the brewery's lack of awareness. 
 After a fire in the 1960s the pub was sympathetically restored; however, in 1990 it was proposed to remove the central bar, which divides the Saloon and Public bars. 
 Although persuaded to drop this proposal, the brewery redecorated in the most unsympathetic manner, using metallic glazed fabrics and crude reproductions of Morris wallpapers and carpets &mdash; destroying any attempt at a period interior (which the 1960s restoration had, ironically, tried to create). 
 The Victorian pub is now threatened in two ways: because it is not understood as a historic document, and because certain isolated elements in Victorian pub design have been overemphasised at the expense of others. 
 Surely it is time that breweries understood the importance of their Victorian pubs, and turned to conservation rather than mutilation.  
 The Public Bar at the White Swan in Bradford Street, Deritend, Birmingham  (The Victorian Society). 
 Far left: The arrival of the Saloon Bar &mdash; plan of the Fox and Hounds, Sydenham, London &mdash; by T H Smith, 1892  (from Mark Girouard, Victorian Pubs). 
 Left: The Queen Victoria, Southwark Park Road, London of 1891: before (left) and after (right) alterations. 
 Note the changed internal spaces. 
 The Tabard, Bedford Park, London: exterior and interiors  (Rebecca Katkin). 
 THE INTER-WAR PUB Alan Powers  
 The history of the inter-war pub stems from the beginning of state interference under the Central Control Board (Liquor Traffic) set up in 1915. 
 This established licensing hours for the first time, and put brewers on the defensive. 
 The prohibitionist thinking which affected America in the 1920s was not without supporters in Britain, and the practical result in architecture was that pubs emphasised their domestic image, and encouraged the serving of more food, as against the all-male tradition of &bquo;vertical drinking&equo; at a bar. 
 New styles of management, in an Arts and Crafts setting, were tried out in the state-owned pubs in Gretna and Carlisle during the war. 
 The inter-war period saw the construction of a large number of new pubs to serve the needs of growing suburban communities and reconstructed city centres. 
 These usually reflected Tudor or Georgian styles, sometimes with intentional accuracy, more often in an impressionistic way. 
 The spread of motoring caused a revival of interest in the tradition of wayside coaching inns, since these were rediscovered as charming nostalgic examples of bygone days, and the charm of the wayside inn was celebrated in the verses of Hilaire Belloc and Rupert Brooke. 
 Running a modern-day coaching inn became a fashionable activity after the painter John Fothergill took on the Spread Eagle at Thame in the 1920s and, later, the Three Swans at Market Harborough. 
 A melancholic figure dressed in black, he seems to have specialised in overhung jugged hare and insults to his customers. 
 Subsequently Clough Williams-Ellis bought the handsome inn outside the gates of Attingham, Shropshire, which he renamed the Mytton and Mermaid and promoted as a staging post for guests en route to Portmeirion. 
 The illustrator Cecil Aldin developed a romantic Dickensian view of the coaching inn in the 1920, which must have been influential in ensuring that &bquo;Brewers&equo; Georgian&equo; was a favoured style. 
 Even the revered classical architect Professor Albert Richardson wrote a book on pubs, establishing their soundness and Englishness in the age of American cocktails. 
 Examples of neo-Georgian pubs can be found in the suburbs of Liverpool (often designed by Quiggin and Gee, two former pupils of Professor Reilly) and in many other places. 
 They are often associated with the rebuilding of former houses, like the Freemason's Arms, Downshire Hill, in Hampstead. 
 Some five village pubs were built in vernacular style, such as the Red Lion at Grantchester by Basil Oliver; while the rather artificial Drum Inn at Cockington in Devon by Sir Edwin Lutyens is a continuation of the Edwardian tradition of grand &bquo;Estate&equo; pubs. 
 Many brewers, of course, built fine half-timbered Tudor pubs, a style which neatly conveyed the message of &bquo;Merrie England&equo; and which for customers in the suburbs could represent a kind of home from home. 
 Fine examples are found throughout the country &mdash; notably Brighton's The Ship, by Ernest R Barrow in 1933. 
 Much re-Tudorisation of genuinely ancient buildings was carried out, as at the Greyhound and Punchbowl in Bilston, Staffs. 
 Tudor was favoured for roadhouses, too, such as the Ace of Spades on the Kingston by Pass, and the Thatched Barn on the A1 (now demolished). 
 These offered a variety of recreational activities, swimming, sports, dancing and so on in addition to basic victualling, and borrowed from the ordinary pub the  opprobium  of encouraging immoral behaviour. 
 The pubs of the Birmingham suburbs by local architects such as Bateman and Bateman, Buckland and Haywood and Holland W. Hobbiss were brick Tudor,  occasionaly  neo-Georgian, rather more restrained externally, and often situated on traffic roundabouts. 
 Some were convincingly disguised as country houses, with entrance gates and spreading lawns, such as the Black Horse, Northfield, Birmingham or the Hare and Hounds, Kingstanding Road, Perry Barr. 
 They were very well built, and included stained glass, decorative painting and other examples of the continuing Arts and Crafts tradition of Birmingham. 
 These styles are still sufficiently popular to survive, although any attempted &bquo;re-fit&equo; would be likely to sweep them away as a matter of principle.  
 The increasing stylistic simplification of the 1930s led to a &bquo;moderne&equo; style being adopted for pubs, although this was not always wholly at the expense of Tudor or Georgian. 
 The desire for a homely effect meant that pitched roofs remained, even if tucked behind parapets, while the windows adopted horizontal Crittall glazing. 
 A pub like the Nag's Head in Bishops Stortford, by E B Musman in 1935, is in the modernist style of the London Underground, with curved ends and flat roofs, yet its ethos is the same rather high-mindedness of the earlier neo-Georgian style, with a wooden post on the roadside to carry the signboard. 
 Examples like the County Arms at Blaby in Leicestershire (Pick, Everard, Keay and Gimson) is more in the Tudor style, while Oliver Hill's Prospect Inn at Minster in Thanet of 1938 is perhaps one of the most completely modern pubs of the inter-war period in its organic planning and use of floor decoration. 
 The antiseptic, do-gooding pub of the 1930s fell completely out of fashion in the post-war period, partly because of customers' understandable preference for cosiness, and partly thanks to the campaign in favour of Victorian pub decoration conducted by the Architectural Review   from the wartime period onwards, and exemplified in the glorious in-house pub &bquo;The Bride of Denmark&equo; in the AR's  offices in Queen Anne's Gate. 
 Pubs of the 1950s occasionally adopted a &bquo;contemporary&equo; Festival of Britain look, but this was easily fused with Neo-Victorian, and has usually been swamped by later changes. 
 Some delightfully crazy pubs were built, such as the Windsock in Dunstable (Smith and Wilson-Smith, 1965), and some refined and elegant ones, like Jack Straw's Castle in Hampstead by Raymond Erith, 1962. 
 Built for Charringtons, this blended surprisingly well with the company's corporate identity as determined by Milner Gray of the Design Research Unit, an identity which itself reflected an early 19th century graphic feeling. 
 While the majority of pub buildings from the post-1914 period survive, however, it is virtually impossible to find an unaltered interior in any of them. 
 This could be seen as a sign of healthy growth and change; yet the new fittings and equipment installed are usually totally insensitive to the design quality of the original. 
 1930s pubs are frequently &bquo;themed&equo; as Art Deco, with the crudest caricature versions of the style. 
 (The Paviours Arms in Page Street, Westminster is a good example, having originally been a showpiece of restrained and elegant design.) 
 Art Deco is offered as a &bquo;sensitive&equo; alternative to Victoriana, otherwise virtually the only decorative style currently in the pubfitter's repertoire. 
 Where interiors have survived, it has been through benign neglect. 
 The Nag's Head still has its decorative painting on glass by Cosmo Clark over the fireplace in the public bar, and some original chairs. 
 The Prospect Inn has two of its decorative lino floors intact, although the owners, Whitbread, destroyed the original pole sign outside when the tenants asked for it to be repaired. 
 The Comet Hotel, Hatfield (E B Musman, 1934) has lost all its fine interior fittings &mdash; such as an etched mirror glass wall with aeroplane vapour trails &mdash; some years ago.  
 The Thirties Society has tried to counteract the brewers' failure to understand the potential assets represented by their 20th century buildings, but since so few pubs are listed many cases escape our notice. 
 The County Arms at Blaby was subject to a proposal for &bquo;theming&equo; as a Beefeater steakhouse some years ago, which was rejected by the local authority with support from the Thirties Society although the building is not listed. 
 More recently, the Prospect Inn was threatened by an enlargement scheme by Whitbread which would have totally destroyed the remaining original features of the building, and its remarkable plan. 
 Fortunately, the Thirties Society was able to get the Prospect listed in May 1990, and alternative development plans are awaited. 
 The Prospect Inn, which could be restored a major tourist attraction, is also threatened by a road widening proposal by Kent County Council, although the local authority, Thanet, understand its importance and value the building. 
 Road widening is an inevitable and current threat to many former roadhouses, such as the former &bquo;Chez Laurie&equo; on the A299 near Herne Bay (W M Bishop, 1936). 
 The listing of pubs is made more difficult by the fact that they have almost always been altered. 
 The Comet was listed after the damage had been done, and with the Prospect Inn it was necessary to itemise all the things that had not changed, since the superficial impression of change was predominant. 
 The Vale, a moderne pub at Woodthorpe, Nottingham by Cecil Howitt, the favourite architect of the Home Brewery, was refused listing because it had been overly altered in 1968, although Gedling Council managed to prevent the application of &bquo;Victoriana&equo; signage. 
 The John Bull in Layerthorpe, York (B Wilson, 1937) was a Tudor-style pub remarkable solely through having survived unaltered, but not listable simply on these grounds. 
 The needs of pub management in the 1980s have been hard to contain in pubs originally segregated into saloon and public bars, if not into further distinct spaces.  
 This has been the experience of the Thirties Society in fighting for the retention of the main plan features of the Nag's Head, one of the few listed pubs of the period. 
 Designed as a demonstration of bi-partite segregation between public and saloon, it lends itself poorly to unification, and the restorable public bar would have been lost in the process. 
 The Thirties Society negotiated a compromise scheme with the architects acting for Ind Coope which the owners found  unnacceptable , threatening closure of the pub. 
 Having appealed against East Herts' refusal of listed building consent, they withdrew from a public inquiry at a late stage after their intended expert witness informed them that they did not have a strong enough case. 
 The previous scheme is now to be re-submitted. 
 Problems like these arise from a lack of imagination in house management, but it must be acknowledged that the drinking public behaves in a very inflexible way and fails to adapt to the qualities of different buildings. 
 Brewers may underestimate the sophistication of their potential audience, however. 
 The availability of a period pub, particularly one representing the highly popular 1930s, could create a new market where none existed before. 
 This is the only hope for the conservation of pubs from a period with planning ideas so remote from our own. 
 A more straightforward case is that concerning Jack Straw's Castle, which was listed after a scheme was submitted to cover the courtyard with a new restaurant. 
 The new emphasis was to be on dining rather than drinking, and the design was as sensitive as it could have been. 
 Due to the circumstances of the original build, there are some strange anomalies in the plan, but the courtyard remains a key part of the design, much enjoyed by visitors in the summer, sitting under a fine specimen walnut tree. 
 The scheme was taken to Public Inquiry in October 1990, in which the Borough of Camden was supported by the Thirties Society and Lucy Archer, Raymond Erith's daughter and biographer. 
 The appeal was dismissed. 
 It remains now for Charringtons to upgrade the decoration and general management style of this marvellous pub, and make the most of its fine architectural qualities. 
 Inter-war interior design depended on  subtelty  and understatement, neither of which are much valued in the running of a pub today. 
 Yet buildings like the Nag's Head and the Prospect Inn are among the most delightful of their period, and their careful restoration might inspire similar and much needed projects elsewhere.  
 The Prospect Inn, Minster-on-Thanet, Kent by Oliver Hill in 1939  (Alan Powers). 
 The Nag's Head, Bishop's Stortford, Hertfordshire of 1935: left, the exterior of the public bar; right, original 30s furniture in the public bar  (Alan Powers). 
 The former &bquo;Chez Laurie&equo;, Herne Bay, Kent by W M Bishop in 1936&ndash;7  (Alan Powers). 
 POSTSCRIPT: A DESIGNER'S PERSPECTIVE Nigel Langford  
 Langford and Williams' work with renowned listed pubs since 1987 puts the company in a favourable light with conservation societies such as The Victorian Society, SPAB, and the Georgian Group; we have even been known to win a few CAMRA awards yet at the same time the firm has also brazenly converted redundant pubs to caf&eacute;-bar concepts. 
 Consistent with  conversationist  bodies, however, we are appalled by much of the development of our pub heritage carried out during the 1950s and '60s. 
 In his address to the 1990 CAMRA AGM, Tim May of Design House succinctly highlighted the irreconcilable conflict between the functional modernist tendencies of the 1950s and the historical vernacular pub tradition. 
 This, in the context of pub development as it stands in 1991, in turn suggests an irreconcilable conflict between historic pubs and the brewers' profit motive. 
 However, such an assumption is possibly too glib and generalised. 
 Our experience of working with the major breweries throughout the 1980s is that, undeniably, mistakes were made &mdash; sometimes on a very grand scale indeed. 
 However, over this same period the converse was also true, with a significant record of successful developments consistent with the aims and ideals of conservation bodies. 
 Sadly neglected examples of classic pub architecture were restored to their former glory at no small expense. 
 This was not altruism on the part of the brewers, but was born out of a realisation that preserving the best of their heritage could make them money. 
 A classic example of this attitude can be found in the small but highly profitable Taylor Walker-run chain J &amp; W Nicholson. 
 Nicholsons' pubs for the most part are architectural gems in their own right and include The Blackfriar and The Argyll Arms in Central London and the Prince Alfred in Maida Vale amongst their number. 
 And Nicholson's have not been slow to realise the commercial potential of this classic heritage; Langford &amp; Williams' design brief from them was to restore what could be restored and to reinstate in sympathy with the building where necessary. 
 This brings us to the &bquo;Catch 22&equo; situation that we, as designer, find ourselves in with regard to conservation bodies. 
 When we are not being accused of ignoring the vernacular pub tradition with the abomination of caf&eacute;-bars and so on we stand accused of creating &bquo;pastiches&equo; when we get involved with restorations &mdash; no matter how conscientiously researched a project. 
 Often such schemes unashamedly make vast concessions to the demands of the modern pub customer. 
 Modern &bquo;task lighting&equo; systems are used to supplement the decorative fittings; air conditioning ducts are incorporated; bottle displays are refrigerated. 
 These are not just fizzy lager joints, but environments where a bank of six beer engines can sit happily on the bar counter offering a wide selection of real ales. 
 In the true tradition of the pub boom at the turn of the century, although decidedly grand, most of these refurbishments do not take themselves deadly seriously. 
 The alabaster  freizes  of monks with  scatalogical  Latin inscriptions created by Henry Poole for the Blackfriar in c.1905 come from the same tradition as the eclectic and irreverent use of ethnic imagery and architectural detail built into the new Horniman at Hays Galleria of 1986. 
 It is right and proper that the brewers and their designers should address the challenge represented by imported concepts. 
 French-style caf&eacute;-bars have been a runaway success over here because they address a market which had previously been actively excluded by the &bquo;pub tradition&equo; &mdash; namely women. 
 Likewise, American family eating concepts such as Whitbread's TGI Fridays have received a warm welcome from the paying public. 
 They represent a very real challenge to the pub traditional client base. 
 As it becomes increasingly unacceptable for the man to remove himself to the predominantly adult male preserve of the pub, leaving wife and children at home, it becomes imperative for outlets to be found which can cater to the demands of the whole family. 
 This is the challenge for the brewers and their designers &mdash; to survive in the long term they must, in certain instances, address this radically broadened target market. 
 This need not necessarily be antipathetic to &bquo;pub values&equo; as we recognise them. 
 Indeed, Langford and Williams are currently developing family pub concepts for a major brewer which take as their starting point perceived elements of the vernacular pub: highly detailed joinery, &bquo;honest&equo; and tactile finishes, and the bar counter as a focus. 
 Just as important as establishing what to include is deciding what to exclude, and it is here that the purists may find cause to tar and feather us. 
 There will be no brass footrail, dark corners, etched-mirror backbars, or dartboards, and there will definitely be no hint of a smell of the heady cocktail of Real Ale and the Gents urinals. 
 Our theory &mdash; if we are in the business of expounding a theory on the subject of pub design &mdash; is that each pub must be treated individually and on its own merits. 
 We contest that there are no laws written in stone, and that there is room for hybrids. 
 As regards restoration, just as we would not dream of stripping out the original interior of the Blackfriar, by the same token we would not seek to preserve a Thirties estate pub which had long since ceased to address the needs of the community it was built to serve. 
 It is in our interests as designers in this field to ensure that the &bquo;pub tradition&equo; that we all hold so dear remains a living   tradition. 
 As was so chillingly illustrated by the postwar period of mass destruction and misconceived redevelopment, it is possible to throw the baby out with the bathwater. 
 However, to entrap our pub tradition within a rigid set of rules and guidelines is at best to condemn it to becoming an anachronism, if not to extinguish it altogether. 
 Arguably brewers are still as constrained by the profit motive as ever before. 
 This may lead to the destruction of further historic pubs which are considered redundant; conversely, this may well lead to the further restoration and conservation of the best historic sites. 
 It may be an unpalatable thought, but we suspect that to an increasing degree throughout the 1990s brewers and conservationists will find themselves standing on the same side of the fence.  
 The Antelope pub in London's Belgravia; Langford and Williams' refurbishment of the exterior. 
 (Rebecca Katkin). 
 5&ndash;11 SEPTEMBER 1991  CATERER  &amp; Hotelkeeper &pound;1.15 
 SMOKING  Banning the weed?  
 SOLUTIONS  Training and support  
 PLUS  Chef magazine  
 NEWS 
 OPINION 
 PRESSURE GROWS FOR CHANGES TO BANK HOLIDAYS 
 ARE HOTELIERS GEARING UP FOR THE NEW EC FIRE SAFETY DIRECTIVE? 
 TELEPHONE CHARGES COME UNDER ATTACK AGAIN 
 INTERNATIONAL  Eire's National Food Centre report stresses need for quality 
 INDIA WOOS FOREIGN INVESTMENT WITH FAVOURABLE LEGISLATION 
 LETTERS 
 PEOPLE  Forte Hotels announces overseas management reshuffle 
 VIEWPOINT: SAVERIO BUCHICCHIO  What colleges should be doing to support the industry 
 JOE HYAM  On unhealthy obsessions with diet 
 BUSINESS 
 BANKING ON THE EUROPA GATWICK HOTEL 
 QMH EXPERIENCES DIFFICULT TIMES 
 PROPERTY  Westminster City Council rejects Harrods hotel plan 
 FOOD PRICES 
 FOOD COST INDEX 
 PERSONNEL  Personnel chiefs are gaining seats on company boards 
 FEATURES 
 MENUS  American food and wine is Frances Bissell's theme this week 
 CHINESE TEACHINGS  Norwich Hotel School is enlightening its pupils to Chinese cuisine 
 SOLUTIONS 
 Twelve-page technology supplement, including news, new products, a viewpoint, data back-up, training and a Catering &amp; Allied case study 
 WHAT'S NEW 
 LIQUID ASSETS  Italian wines &mdash; a fresh approach 
 DRINKS NEWS  Wine &amp; Spirit Association to deal with complaints about EHOs 
 POLISH UP ON CUTLERY  How to recognise, source and maintain quality cutlery 
 TAKING SHAPE  We highlight the versatility and variety of pasta 
 INDEX TO ADVERTISERS 
 EC FOOD HYGIENE DOCUMENT CRITICISED AS TOO WEAK 
 FOOD 
 CLASSIFIED 
 YOUR NEXT MOVE: ALL THE BEST JOBS AND PROPERTY 
 NEXT WEEK 
 LANGUAGES, EUROPE AND 1992 
 NATIONAL LEISURE CATERING PROFILE 
 INTERIORS &mdash; FOCUS ON DANESFIELD HOUSE, BUCKINGHAMSHIRE, (above) 
 OPINION 
 Why holidays mean more work 
 THE tourism and leisure group of the National Economic Development Council (NEDC) has proposed that the UK reorganise its public holidays (see page 11). 
 Good idea: this would extend the tourist season into late summer and autumn and bring Britain more into line with its European neighbours. 
 The British Tourist Authority likes it. 
 The Government, however, has &bquo;no immediate plans&equo; to change the public holiday set-up. 
 The industry has marketed Britain energetically as a year-round destination, with many attractions that do not leave the visitor at the mercy of our fickle weather. 
 The public holidays should reflect that. 
 Families with children tend to be restricted, for their main holiday, to one of the three main school breaks. 
 But if the children's autumn half-term coincided with a bank holiday weekend for their parents, that would make sense both for families and for the tourist and leisure industry. 
 At the other end of the tourist season, Britain has a log-jam of holiday weekends, particularly if Easter is late, when it is followed closely by May Day and not much later by the spring bank holiday. 
 The NEDC Committee suggests that one of these could be transplanted to October &mdash; but why not move them further apart, and add another in the autumn? 
 Even then, we would trail behind other European Community members, such as Germany, France and Italy, each with 11 public holidays a year, Spain and Portugal with 13 each, and Denmark with 10. 
 Britain has just eight statutory days off. 
 The prosaic explanation for the Government's inaction is an insult to tourism: manufacturers have told Government that they want an uninterrupted flow of production between the August bank holiday and Christmas. 
 The fear is that if this is broken. 
 Britain becomes less competitive. 
 But that hasn't happened to our European competitors, who have more bank holidays than the British. 
 Tourism is our second biggest contributor &mdash; after North Sea oil &mdash; to gross domestic product. 
 Out of this money machine the Government collects many hundreds of millions in VAT, corporation tax, income tax and national insurance contributions. 
 It is asked to put very little back. 
 To have ideas like this one taken seriously and to be treated with respect is surely a reasonable request.  
 NEWS 
 THE &pound;86m Dartford Bridge, set to open in October, is being welcomed by the marketing consortium the M25 Meetings Group. 
 Members of the group of hotels, conference centres and stately homes hope to use the bridge as a strong marketing tool. 
 A survey among the group's 16 founder properties found that 4,000 conferences were booked in 1990, attracting 90,000 delegates. 
 The group's first bridge promotion began this week with the launch of M25 Meetings Month. 
 Pictured from left to right are: Felicity Thompson, sales officer at Hever Castle, Kent; Charles Blowfield, managing director of Down Hall Hotel, Bishop's Stortford, Herts; Basil Sanderson, proprietor of Selsdon Park Hotel, Croydon, Surrey; Jean Glover, business development manager at the Gatwick Hilton; and Barbara Dadouche, sales manager at Oatlands Park Hotel, Weybridge, Surrey. 
 Financial Qs &amp; As 
 ARE you an independent hotelier or restaurateur experiencing problems with your bank? 
 Or perhaps you have a good relationship with your financial backers? 
 Caterer , in association with Reed Catering, is undertaking a confidential telephone survey on the relationship between the banks and our industry, in preparation for a forthcoming forum. 
 &bquo;Facing the Financiers&equo;. 
 Would you be prepared to contribute? 
 If so, please write to Amanda Howell, Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper , Quadrant House. 
 The Quadrant, Sutton, Surrey SM2 5AS. 
 Please include a daytime telephone number. 
 Authors of the first 100 replies received will be invited as guests to the forum on 1 October at the Savoy, London. 
 Conservative pressure group calls for HIV-staff ban 
 PROPOSALS from a right-wing pressure group to ban HIV-infected staff from working with food have been criticised by personnel chiefs in the industry. 
 The report by the Conservative Family Campaign called for restrictions on AIDS sufferers and those carrying the HIV virus, including preventing them from working with food for the public. 
 The advice from the group once again raised the sensitive issue of employing staff who admit to being, or are discovered to be infected. 
 Sutcliffe Catering personnel director Peter Davies said: &bquo;This sort of advice really turns back the clock. 
 It is most regrettable and of no help to the industry. 
 There is no reason to have such a ban, in view of the medical knowledge now available.&equo; 
 Since 1987, when caterers were inundated with information about their legal and moral duty in dealing with HIV-infected staff, the topic has receded from the headlines, although the number of those infected has increased. 
 About 4,600 people in Britain have contracted AIDS, of whom half have died, compared with about 600 four years ago. 
 In addition, there are 15,000 people known to be HIV-positive and twice as many believed to be carrying the virus without requesting medical help. 
 But Mr Davies said: &bquo;We have had cases of people who we have suspected of being infected and the degree of compassion and humanity among other staff has been remarkable.&equo; 
 Phil Philips, deputy secretary of the British Hotels, Restaurants and Caterers Association, said: &bquo;People in the industry are much better educated about AIDS than they were in 1987.&equo; 
 Many within the industry admit privately, however, that they may be less inclined to appoint someone who declares their infection at their interview. 
 Another senior personnel manager said: &bquo;It would not be a moral judgment, but we have to consider the practicalities of appointing someone who could be off work for long periods.&equo;  
 NEDC presses for longer summer holiday season 
 BANK HOLIDAYS 
 RENEWED pressure has been placed on the Government to lengthen the summer season by bringing Britain up to European standards for public holidays. 
 A report by the National Economic Development Council (NEDC) points to the creation of a bank holiday in October as a way of extending the tourist season into the autumn. 
 The Harvest Holiday, as the report suggested, would be introduced in late October and would be the first of a series of changes to age-hold British holiday customs. 
 Many in the tourism industry believe the revenue created would far outweigh any protests that it was just another excuse for a day off. 
 The NEDC's tourism and leisure industries sector group, which studied the issue of &bquo;seasonality&equo;, pointed out that Britain lagged behind most of Europe in the number of public holidays. 
 However, it suggested that the October holiday should replace an existing holiday. 
 Angus Crichton-Miller, managing director of the Rank Organisation's holidays and hotels division and a member of the study group said: &bquo;It is not an efficient system to have such changes between busy and quiet periods and it would be better if we could flatten prices over a longer season, rather than have such high-peak-season prices.&equo; 
 The October bank holiday proposal has received a muted response from Employment Minister Michael Howard, who said he was open to persuasion but had no plans to make changes. 
 As well as suggesting an autumn boost for the tourism industry, the group also proposed changes at the beginning of the season by introducing a fixed-date Easter holiday. 
 By creating a more definite starting and finishing point to the season, members of the group believed that the growing trend of out-of-season holidays and short breaks could be accelerated. 
 The proportion of holidays of four nights and above between October and April has grown from 14% in 1976 to 22% last year, while August holidays have slipped from 24% to 20% and July from 25% to 18%. 
 In addition to the hotel income which a bank holiday encourages, the group was also aware of its importance in generating day-trip revenue which, at &pound;5b a year, provides nearly a third of tourism expenditure by Britons in this country. 
 During the season, the NEDC group sees further benefits in amending the traditional school summer holiday, staggering the starting dates to avoid the sudden rush of tourist traffic. 
 A more even spread of half-term holidays over three weeks of October would offer the industry the incentive to open beyond September. 
 Chinatown gets ready for Food Act 
 CHINATOWN'S restaurateurs are upgrading staff hygiene training in preparation for draft requirements of the Food Safety Act coming into force. 
 Westminster City Council community liaison officer David Tan set up a training session last week, with a Cantonese interpreter at the Man Fu Kung restaurant in London's Leicester Square. 
 With Westminster College, Mr Tan has organised basic food hygiene courses for the Chinese community. 
 About 150 people have already taken part in these day-long courses since April. 
 These include exam papers in Chinese for people who are unable to speak or write English. 
 Westminster City Council has also issued leaflets in Chinese giving basic food hygiene rules. 
 Mr Tan said: &bquo;This training is to upgrade and spread food hygiene consciousness.&equo; 
 Westminster chief environmental health officer Maggie Tomlinson said: &bquo;Any effort made by the Chinese community to improve food hygiene training and tailor courses to their specific needs would be welcomed.&equo;  
 Westminster City Council community liaison officer David Tan helps Chinatown restaurateurs with food hygiene 
 E. Midlands shows worry over UBR 
 A SURVEY of the tourism industry in the East Midlands has highlighted concern over the Uniform Business Rate (UBR). 
 And with 1992 and the dismantling of trade barriers within Europe fast approaching, the spring East Midlands Tourism Business Survey  also reveals a disturbing lack of interest in language training. 
 The survey, sponsored by Pannell Kerr Forster, the East Midlands Tourist Board (EMTB) and Nottingham Polytechnic showed that 63% of all hotels in the region believed the UBR had a detrimental effect on business. 
 And among medium-sized hotels with a turnover of between &pound;100,000 and &pound;1m, 54% were concerned about the impact of the UBR. 
 &bquo;General opinion is that the rate will result in increased tariffs, which under the present economic conditions will serve only to reduce competitiveness,&equo; the survey said. 
 &bquo;This must therefore be considered as having a detrimental effect overall on the tourism market.&equo; 
 LANGUAGES 
 The survey asked firms what sort of advice and assistance would be helpful in developing business and was surprised by the low level of demand for language training. 
 &bquo;It is most surprising that in the tourism industry the necessity for language training to meet the growing demand for overseas visitors is not felt to be important,&equo; the report said. 
 There was also very little demand for help on legal matters and employment issues. 
 EMTB development manager Andrew Keeling said the survey's findings would provide a background to a regional tourism strategy to be published in March 1992. * Look out for &bquo;Mind your language&equo; in Caterer , 12&ndash;18 September.  
 Study shows UK fast food boom 
 FAST food now accounts for almost one meal in every 10 served in the UK. 
 The boom in fast food is providing strong competition for both staff restaurants and school meal services. 
 The UK has become the largest fast food market in Europe &mdash; by 1990 there were about 1,500 fast food outlets in the UK. 
 When compared with 1985 figures, there was an overall increase of 40%. 
 The figures come from the latest study, Restaurant Chain Market in Europe , compiled by GIRA SIC, a market research company affiliated to the Geneva International Research Associates group, which concentrates on service industries and catering. 
 For the study, a fast food outlet was defined as one with highly systemised operations, normally with counter service, and a high volume of customers. 
 Using these criteria GIRA SIC found that chains produced more than 70% of the UK's fast food meals in 1990, with American groups dominating the market. 
 Hamburger outlets are by far the most important, representing almost 80% of total turnover in the fast food market. 
 In the UK, franchising has always played a significant role, although relations between franchisor and franchisee have not always been smooth, according to the report. 
 GIRA SIC stated that it was a reflection of the UK market that McDonald's delayed setting up its own franchise scheme in the UK. 
 Nevertheless, at the end of 1990 almost two-thirds of UK fast food units were franchised. 
 The report forecasts that the UK fast food market is set to continue growing through the 1990s at between 5% and 6% at constant prices, compared with 10% value growth in turnover during the mid-1980s. 
 Packed lunch ruling &bquo;illegal&equo; 
 HOTELIERS have slammed as discriminating and illegal the confirmation that VAT is to be levied on packed lunches. 
 This follows representations by the British Hotels, Restaurants and Caterers Association (BHRCA) which learnt of the proposed change in May. 
 Customs &amp; Excise introduced the changes, which will be back-dated to 1 July, after it found hotels had been treating the supply of packed lunches to guests as zero-rated ( Caterer , 27 June&ndash;3 July). 
 It ruled that packed lunches are supplied &bquo;in the course of catering&equo; and are liable for the 17.5% standard rating of VAT. 
 The back dating of all VAT not charged on packed lunches could lead to hefty bills for hoteliers. 
 When VAT was introduced on hot takeaway food in 1987, amendments to the Finance Act were made after Parliamentary consultation. 
 Packed lunches remained zero-rated. 
 The arbitrary change to existing law was made by Customs &amp; Excise Commissioners. 
 They decided that packed lunches should be standard-rated from 1 July. 
 However, the most up-to-date leaflet available to the catering industry &mdash; leaflet 709 published in February 1990 &mdash; clearly states that cold takeaway food is zero-rated in hotels. 
 &bquo;Their new interpretation is illegal,&equo; said Martin Hill, proprietor of the Coul House Hotel in Ross-Shire. 
 In most cases, the hotels Caterer  spoke to had offered guest prices that were inclusive of VAT or the tax was simply added to their bill. 
 Hotel marketing consortium MinOtels UK chairman Jon Redfern said his 200 members were virtually unaware of the changes. 
 &bquo;It's grossly unfair and discriminatory that cold take-out food should carry VAT from a hotel but not from anywhere else. 
 Customs &amp; Excise is adopting a wholly dictatorial approach,&equo; he said. 
 The irony is that no VAT would be levied if hoteliers were to set up a separate sandwich bar business next to their property and handed out sandwiches and drinks. 
 As yet no new VAT leaflet or instruction has been supplied. 
 Trade associations have been informed but Customs &amp; Excise said it was up to industry bodies to inform their members. 
 The BHRCA has now received what Customs &amp; Excise said was its final stand on the issue. 
 It said the effective date of introduction will remain 1 July and has advised the BHRCA to inform all members.  
 THE Smugglers' Kitchen, above, is being given away because its owner cannot sell it. 
 Bill Murray spent &pound;50,000 on setting up his restaurant at Telegraph Hill, near Exeter, Devon, two years ago but said the business started to go downhill when he handed it over to a manager to run. 
 Mr Murray now wants to give away the Smugglers' Kitchen so that he can channel his efforts into another property &mdash; the Dartmoor Inn at Bovey Tracey, also in Devon. 
 He has identified the need for a fish restaurant in the surrounding area. 
 However, interested parties have to fulfil the following prerequisites: 
 &bull; 
 Be young, enthusiastic and part of a team, with some experience of the catering industry; 
 &bull; 
 Able to pay the &pound;270 per week business rates and insurance; 
 &bull; 
 Have good references and some financial backing. 
 Mr Murray hopes to make a decision this month. 
 FIRE SAFETY 
 A US government decision to ban its employees from using hotels which do not have adequate fire protection by 1996 could have a knock-on effect in Britain. 
 Meanwhile, work is under way on a European Commission draft directive which could tighten up demands already implicit in UK fire safety regulations. 
 Dorset Fire Safety Committee senior fire prevention officer Ian Clark said: &bquo;One of the biggest problems with hotels is that they do not maintain the requirements of the Fire Certificate.&equo; 
 Under the Fire Precautions Act 1971, there is no requirement for fire authorities to re-inspect a certified building. 
 Mr Clark said legislation ensuring re-inspection could come into force within the next few years and he warned that it could result in hotels being prosecuted if they contravened their Fire Certificates. 
 The Home Office told Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper  that consultation was under way on an amendment to the Fire Safety and Safety in Places of Sport Act 1987, giving mandatory powers of re-inspection. 
 US BAN 
 Director of the UK's Fire Protection Association, Stewart Kidd, said the US law would require a smoke detector in each room and a sprinkler system for hotels more than three storeys high. 
 &bquo;By 1996, 90 of all nights spent by Federal employees in hotels must be spent in those which comply with this law,&equo; he said. 
 Any conferences, conventions or meetings paid for from Federal funds will be held only in hotels complying with this law. 
 Mr Kidd said that he did not think the UK Government would follow suit, but believed pressure from a more demanding American market could encourage British hotels to upgrade their precautions beyond the legal minimum. 
 He pointed out that large groups such as Hilton and Holiday Inns were already investing in fire protection beyond the minimum requirements. 
 Mr Kidd said he already had anecdotal evidence of US conventions pulling out of the UK: &bquo;One conference of surgeons and one group of insurance sales staff, who planned to come to London for two weeks, could not find a hotel they were happy with.&equo; 
 Mr Kidd is also chairman of a working party which reports on the state of hotel fire safety across Europe and reviews the effectiveness of existing EC recommendations. 
 The working party has authority to form a draft EC directive. 
 The whole issue is to be debated as a conference in Luxembourg in September 1992. 
 Mr Kidd said the committee was producing a draft guide for management which would include a review of existing legislation in six European countries. 
 &bquo;It is clear that UK standards are the highest at the moment. 
 I would have thought the UK hotelier would have nothing to fear from a European directive,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It is possible an EC directive would be at the same level or just below UK standards.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;You only have to look at the figures for fire deaths in hotels to see this is not a problem. 
 We have had a substantial reduction over the past 10 years.&equo; 
 But he said it could mean duties of managers/owners &mdash; such as keeping a hotel plan or ensuring staff are trained to use the fire fighting equipment &mdash; implicit in UK laws &mdash; would have to be spelt out. 
 UK Fire Certificates might say hotels must have a warning system but might not specify the means, Mr Kidd said. 
 &bquo;The directive will say hotels of a certain size will have to have an automatic fire detection system permanently linked to a manned location for calling the fire brigade.&equo; 
 He added that a draft directive standardising safety signing &mdash; making a lot of UK signs obsolete &mdash; could also be included in his committee's report.   
 MAFF guides lose out to coup 
 FOOD Minister David Maclean has blamed the KGB for poor publicity surrounding the launch of a series of food safety guides from the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries &amp; Food (MAFF). 
 He told Caterer  that the launch of the leaflets had been overshadowed by the events in the USSR. 
 The leaflets aim to inform consumers about healthy eating, food safety, additives, labelling and protection. 
 Mr Maclean denied that the renewed emphasis on food safety was part of a campaign of consumer legislation in the run-up to a general election. 
 He also ruled out Government assistance for caterers who needed to buy equipment to comply with the Food Safety Act, as part of an election giveaway. 
 &bquo;It would not be fair on those people who have already bought the correct equipment. 
 Caterers should see that it is a good investment in their business,&equo; he said. 
 MAFF is looking at revising rules governing the labelling of cooked food on menus. 
 Mr Maclean said outbreaks of Salmonella enteriditis and reports of Bovine spongiform encephalopathy had stabilised but also recognised that the problem had not disappeared, just that interest had waned.  
 Maclean: coup in USSR took limelight 
 TELEPHONE CHARGES COME UNDER ATTACK 
 UK HOTELS have once again come under fire over the amounts they charge for telephone calls. 
 An English Tourist Board (ETB) spokeswoman said the board was concerned about the charges, particularly because of problems experienced by overseas visitors. 
 The ETB's comments follow reports of a visitor from the USA being charged more than &pound;200 for a 45-minute telephone call to Los Angeles. 
 Bruce Doblin, a doctor at the University of California, said he was stunned by his bill from the Academy Hotel in Gower Street, London. 
 He subsequently received a discount of just over &pound;50 after complaining about the telephone charge. 
 Mr Doblin claimed that no-one at the hotel seemed to know what the cost of a telephone call should be. 
 The cost of the call via BT would have been &pound;29.25 at the cheap rate after 8pm, BT confirmed. 
 Academy assistant manager Mette Doessing promised to look into Mr Doblin's case, but said the hotel received few complaints about telephone charges. 
 She added that all rooms contained details about the charges in an information directory. 
 The ETB has been critical of hotel telephone call charges for many years. 
 It now requires all Crown scheme participants to display charges beside telephones. 
 And a British Hotels, Restaurants &amp; Caterers Association (BHRCA) spokesman said a code of practice advised that customers should be notified of charges by signs in bedrooms. 
 The code was agreed by a variety of organisations including the AA, RAC, BHRCA and British Resorts Association. 
 Telephone charges at hotels vary considerably. 
 All those surveyed by Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper  made sure charges were displayed and also offered guests the choice of using telephone call boxes in the hotel lobby. 
 Bernard Antoine, general manager of the Novotel in Hammersmith, West London, said he had received no complaints about charges. 
 He claimed the charges covered such costs as staff to man the switchboard and rental of equipment. 
 Stefan Drechsler, assistant general manager at the Copthorne Tara in Kensington, London, said the hotel's telephone charges were kept to a minimum. 
 &bquo;We have 850 bedrooms and need a number of staff to deal with calls coming in and out,&equo; he said. 
 Edinburgh's Caledonian Hotel has the latest in telephone technology to prevent mistakes. 
 At De Vere all hotels now have telephone loggers to make sure no mistakes are made.  
 Gwent declares war on home caterers 
 ENVIRONMENTAL health officers (EHOs) in Gwent have shut down a &bquo;backstreet kitchen&equo; operating from a terraced house after a salmonella outbreak. 
 A local council spokesman said the council had declared war on large-scale home catering because of the outbreak. 
 Food for more than 100 guests at two wedding receptions was alleged to have been prepared at the kitchen. 
 So far 39 people have suffered from Salmonellosis. 
 Two people are being treated in hospital. 
 EHOs said the domestic kitchen was completely inadequate for cooking on such a scale. 
 The wedding receptions were held at the Crown Hotel in Varteg, Gwent, and Talywaun Rugby Club, Gwent. 
 The salmonella has been traced back to contaminated Scotch eggs. 
 Councillor Anne James, spokeswoman for the Torfaen Environmental Health Committee, criticised the private caterers' approach to food preparation with limited resources. 
 &bquo;That's not the way you do catering properly. 
 Not for 100 people, or 30 or 40 people,&equo; she said. 
 Gwent Health Authority is preparing to take legal action against the private caterers involved: Valerie Shaw, Denise Shaw and a helper, Jean Robinson. 
 The council spokesman also said there were not enough professional caterers in the area to meet demand.  
 INTERNATIONAL 
 VISITORS to the Disney theme parks near Orlando, Florida, have a wealth of new-build state-of-the-art hotels to choose from, but none reaches the gaudy heights of the Walt Disney World Dolphin Hotel. 
 The picture (left) may look like a model of the hotel but is, in fact, the real thing. 
 Service at the hotel is provided by ITT Sheraton. 
 The hotel has just completed its first year of operation, which it celebrated with a month-long daily cake-cutting ceremony. 
 Eire needs quality food 
 EIRE's rapidly growing catering industry still has plenty of room for investment, according to a report published by the country's National Food Centre. 
 Urgently needed are suppliers which can guarantee prime quality meat and poultry to hotels and restaurants: the report says there are not enough of these to meet demand. 
 Fresh, unprepared potato suppliers are also few and far between. 
 The report clearly stresses that the catering industry is more interested in quality than price. 
 The number of establishments in retail catering has almost doubled over the past 20 years, with licensed restaurants the fastest growing sector. 
 The country has more than 800 hotels and guesthouses, about 1,157 licensed restaurants and 255 hospitals, which spend about IR&pound;237m (&pound;216m) a year on food alone. 
 The Irish splash out more than IR&pound;240m (&pound;219m) on hotel and restaurant meals each year. 
 The report &mdash; Market Size and Market Requirements for Food Suppliers in the Catering Sector  &mdash; provides hints about investment opportunities, based on its findings. 
 Although it emphasises that the opportunities are not guaranteed to find success, market-orientated businesses should find them worth considering. 
 The study explains that in the hotel and licensed restaurant sectors there are opportunities for meat suppliers which are able to guarantee the supply of tender beef. 
 There are also openings for suppliers of tender, low-fat lamb in the hotel, licensed restaurant and contract catering sectors, while free range and maize-fed poultry are in demand by hotels and licensed restaurants. 
 Fresh, unprepared potatoes are urgently required in the hotel, guesthouse and licensed restaurant sectors and there are also opportunities for supplying fresh, exotic mushrooms to the same sectors. 
 * The report is available from the National Food Centre, Dunsinea, Dublin 15. 
 Tel: Dublin 383222. 
 Murder raises tourist fears 
 WORRIED tourism chiefs have moved swiftly to counter potentially harmful publicity following the murder of a German holidaymaker in Dublin. 
 They were alarmed that the continuing growth in the number of foreign tourists could be jeopardised by an isolated serious incident. 
 The recent killing of Georg Plappert in the city; s Phoenix Park caused particular concern to Eire's tourism industry because the victim came from Germany, one of its important tourism markets. 
 About 178,000 German tourists visited Eire in 1990. 
 Tourism authorities responded quickly to reports of the attack by issuing assurances that policing of Dublin streets had increased significantly during the past year and that crime against tourists had dropped by a third. 
 However, there have been an estimated 900 crimes against tourists in Dublin this year and the growing popularity of the city as an upmarket destination during its year as the European City of Culture has unfortunately attracted a hard core of criminals. 
 Jordan faces Iraqi influx 
 JORDANIAN hoteliers who saw their business decimated by the Gulf War are now suffering the ultimate irony of relying on Iraqi visitors to bolster their flagging industry. 
 Tourism income in Jordan ebbs and flows with the political mood of the Middle East, but it has been hit particularly hard by the most recent turmoil. 
 In Amman, hotel occupancy stood at only 40%&ndash;50% before war broke out in January. 
 This would have plummeted to single figures but for the influx of wealthy Iraqi &bquo;refugee holidaymakers&equo; now fleeing Saddam Hussein's regime. 
 Jordan is fighting to regain the &pound;400m annual income by appealing to foreign visitors to provide high quality accommodation. 
 Following the appointment of a new Minister of Tourism, the Jordanian Tourism Consortia, which incorporates hoteliers, tour operators and transport companies, is preparing a marketing campaign aimed at luring back some of the missing millions of tourists and business travellers, particularly from nearby Arab states. 
 Before the Gulf conflict, about two million Arabs and 250,000 non-Arabs visited Jordan each year.  
 India aims to woo foreign investors 
 INDIA is hoping to revitalise its failing economy by making the country more attractive to foreign investors &mdash; especially hoteliers. 
 Last year the government introduced a number of tax concessions to bring private capital and expertise into the hotel and tourism sectors. 
 Now it wants to stimulate more investment by reducing the bureaucracy and allowing foreigners to have a controlling interest in hotel and tourist developments. 
 According to Har Govind, a former chief commissioner of income tax, the existing limit of 40% will be increased to 51% under industrial legislation put before the Indian Parliament last month. 
 Mr Govind said the finance minister had announced that 100% equity would be allowed on some developments if they utilised advanced technology and were in the country's interest. 
 Other changes to the 1956 Industrial Policy Resolution include scrapping the rule that foreign equity has to be accompanied by foreign technology. 
 The government is also expected to make it easier for foreign investors to take profits out of the country. 
 Richard Jarram, senior economist at the Economist Intelligence Unit in London, explained that the changes were designed to help India reach an agreement with the International Monetary Fund (IMF). 
 &bquo;The IMF will not lend any money unless India shows it is doing something about putting its house in order,&equo; he explained. 
 He added that the government was also helping local businesses to expand and invest by cutting down on red tape: &bquo;If people in business try to expand it is very, very bureaucratic and government approval is needed for most projects.&equo; 
 The loosening-up of regulations could lead to more hotels being developed in India. 
 Hilton International chairman and chief executive Michael Hirst said the country was a target area for the group. 
 &bquo;We feel the arrangements will assist in development opportunities,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;However, from a management company perspective, we feel that doing business there very much depends on associating with the right partner.&equo; 
 Mr Hirst added that Hilton had been discussing the possibility of moving into India and had already evaluated properties in Delhi and Bombay with the aim of a management contract with a small amount of equity. 
 Pannell Kerr Forster senior management consultant Nick van Marken said he did not think the changes would result in a dramatic increase in hotels. 
 &bquo;It all boils down to supply and demand,&equo; he explained. 
 Taj Group sales and marketing vice-president Pankaj Balija said if hotel companies came to India they would find stiff competition. 
 &bquo;Hotels here are of an international standard,&equo; he said. 
 Taj has 36 hotels in India already and plans to open a budget chain of properties across the country by 1992. 
 BANGKOK CHOICE 
 CHOICE Hotels International has opened its first hotel in Thailand, the Quality Hotel Pinnacle in Bangkok. 
 The newly constructed 166-bedroom hotel is situated in the business district and boasts a business centre, restaurant, poolside gardens and 24-hour limousine service. 
 Choice Hotels is looking to expand in Thailand with a target of 30 hotels in the country within 10 years. 
 US SHOW 
 THE 1991 International Hotel/Motel and Restaurant Show will run from 9&ndash;12 November at the Jacob K. Javits convention centre in New York. 
 As well as an exhibition of food-related products, the show will include a series of seminars covering quality assurance and customer relations. 
 DIET CONFERENCE 
 FOODSERVICE Systems Beyond the Year 2000 is the futuristic title of a conference of the International Congress of Dietetics to be held next year from 29 to 31 March in Jerusalem. 
 Contact the Conference Secretariat by fax on 972-2-868165 or by writing to POB 574, Jerusalem 91004. 
 Flying toques 
 CHEFS travelled in convoy recently to sacrifice their headgear on the stones of Tiananmen Square (left). 
 They were celebrating the opening of the Holiday Inn Crowne Plaza, Beijing, the third Holiday Inn property in the capital. 
 The 400-bedroom Holiday Inn Crowne Plaza is situated close to Tiananmen Square and the Forbidden City. 
 It brings to 10 the number of hotels operated by Worldwide Inns in China, with a further five properties under construction.  
 LETTERS 
 ACADEMY MENU WAS BLAND AND FAT-LADEN 
 I AM staggered that Frances Bissell should have chosen to praise the Academy of Culinary Arts/Charles Heidsieck awards menu ( Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper , 22&ndash;28 August). 
 Was she actually there and, if so, did she actually eat any of the food? 
 My scepticism relates both to the planning and execution of this menu. 
 First, I do not understand how anyone can possibly think that a menu which features one fat-laden course after another &mdash; foie gras, creamy soup, fat-wrapped lamb, pan-fried potatoes, cheese and more cream in the mousse &mdash; is a well-planned menu. 
 Apart from the health considerations, it is simply too enervating. 
 Second, most of it was bland in the extreme. 
 I did not know it was possible for foie gras to be tasteless, but the complete omission of seasoning certainly showed I was wrong. 
 Any hope for the flavour of leeks in a soup, which was again under-seasoned, was drowned in the excessive amount of cream used. 
 The lamb was fine, but the caul was raw &mdash; and the mousse was pink. 
 I have great admiration for all those involved in the Academy of Culinary Arts and think it a fine, courageous and important creation, but can someone explain how a meal of such ineptitude can be served in its name, and how some of the best chefs and restaurateurs in the world can have eaten it without public comment? 
  RUTH WATSON Fox and Goose, Fressingfield, Near Diss, Norfolk.  
 LEISURE DESIGN IS IMPORTANT 
 WHY is it that hotel owners and operators put so much emphasis on recruiting professional &bquo;hotel designers&equo; to create the right hotel, but, when it comes to the inclusion of leisure facilities, then they appear to approach any designer, with the impression that it can be addressed from a design viewpoint just like any other area? 
 In fact the leisure facility is a minefield of safety, legal, and operational problems that, unless addressed in a professional manner, can cause catastrophic consequences. 
 It is often said that the two most difficult and specialist design areas within a hotel are the kitchen and the leisure facility. 
 The number of hotel-based leisure complexes that do not take into consideration the operation of a facility at the same time as its aesthetics are plain for all to see. 
 It takes more than design flair and understanding to produce a leisure complex. 
 It also requires the experience gained from having operated the facilities to understand where the pitfalls are and how they can be avoided. 
 So if you are contemplating the inclusion of leisure facilities at your hotel then do, please, think seriously about recruiting a specialist. 
 Ask to see examples of their work and contact references from their past projects. 
  JOHN DIBBLE Partner, Atlam Design Partnership, Portland House, Portland Street, Leamington Spa, Warwickshire.  
 RESPONSES FOR EC PURCHASING 
 I HAVE recently joined a National Economic Development Council working party on European public purchasing, which is seeking to contribute to the opening up of public sector purchasing in the EC. 
 It is investigating any barriers to this and ways to overcome them. 
 As the only catering industry representative on this working party, I would be interested to hear from any companies which have any experience, or knowledge of any examples, which make them feel that this is an area that needs to be examined quickly and subjected to public debate. 
 Of particular relevance to the industry is the sub-group on local authority purchasing and the research project looking at small- and medium-sized suppliers and the public sector purchasers which deal with them. 
  CHARLES ALLEN Managing Director, Compass, Queens Wharf, Queen Caroline Street, London W6.  
 THE COLOUR OF MONEY 
 ONE of our bar staff recently came into the kitchen to ask if she could look in the soup kettle to see what colour the soup was. 
 &bquo;It's green,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;It's broccoli and ham.&equo; 
 She then came back to tell me the customer didn't like green so wouldn't be having the soup. 
 &bquo;What colour did she expect broccoli and ham soup to be?&equo; 
 I pondered. 
 The customer ordered a salad instead! 
  JEAN NOLAN Manager, Ye Jolly Crofter, Chorley Old Road, Horwich, Lancashire  
 INDUSTRY NEEDS POSITIVE ATTITUDE 
 I WOULD like to respond to James Stewart's letter ( Caterer , 22&ndash;28 August). 
 I, too, have been employed in the catering industry for approximately eight years and hold similar qualifications to those of Mr Stewart. 
 The difference being that I have been fortunate to find a career that I love and, what is more, get paid reasonably for it. 
 I have always had reasonable live-in accommodation (having inspected it before accepting a position) and, although on certain days I have worked non-stop, on others I have been very quiet and still received the same salary. 
 I think this is a fair balance. 
 As for sociable hours, I would not be in this trade if I expected to work nine to five, Monday to Friday. 
 True, in some instances the USA does offer better conditions than the UK, but Americans also possess a positive mental attitude towards success and achievement. 
 My advice to young people thinking of going into catering is to gain as much information as possible, try it and judge for yourself. 
 My advice to Mr Stewart is to think carefully before entering into a career in medicine, as this is also a field which requires a lot of dedication, perseverance and long hours if one is to achieve anything worthwhile. 
  LOUIS RIGNEY Food Services Manager, Golden Lion Hotel, Lower Briggate, Leeds, West Yorkshire.  
 PUBLIC COMPLAINT WAS UNFAIR 
 EVERYONE is entitled to their opinion, and while I agree with Joe Hyam's concerning service charges ( Caterer , 15&ndash;21 August), I feel he is taking unfair advantage of his position to have a go at people who do not do things the &bquo;Joe Hyam&equo; way. 
 If the restaurant in question adds a service charge, then that is between it and the customer. 
 Complaining in print about one restaurant's service charge policy &mdash; giving both the restaurant and proprietor's name &mdash; could cost that establishment a great deal of money in bad publicity. 
 Mr Hyam can choose not to pay the service charge or pay it under duress, stating so, but to complain like this in a magazine read by thousands is unfair and childish. 
  TOM MURRAY Glasgow House, Lanark Road, London W9.  
 NO-SERVICE CHARGE WORKS 
 I THOUGHT Joe Hyam would like to know that we changed our menu four months ago to the fixed-price system. 
 In doing so we felt that casual passers-by, looking in the window at the menu, would be more likely to come in knowing what price they would have to pay. 
 It seems to have worked. 
 During the summer months our casual trade has been fairly steady and a number of these casuals are now regular customers. 
 We don't charge extra for coffee, service or bread, which is home-made and devoured in vast quantities, and the majority of our customers leave a generous gratuity, obviously happy with the meal and service. 
  GILLIAN SCOTT Bistro Montparnasse, Palmerston Road, Southsea, Portsmouth.  
 PUTTING DUBLIN RIGHT 
 WHILE complimenting David Tarpey on an interesting article on tourism in Dublin ( Caterer , 22&ndash;28 August), I would like to point out that Dublin's millennium was in 1988 not 1989. 
 However, the foreign exchange earnings on tourism did increase in 1989, not from IR&pound;150m but rather by this figure. 
 Foreign exchange earnings in 1988 were IR&pound;841m up from IR&pound;731m in the previous year. 
 In short, the increase in earnings from tourism happened in the year after the millennium. 
 The former Jurys property in Ballsbridge was previously an Inter-Continental Hotel, not Holiday Inn. 
 While the latter's name has been associated on many occasions with Dublin, to date it has not operated here. 
  RONAN KING Abbey Court, Irish Life Centre, Lower Abbey Street, Dublin.  
 GMS NEEDED FOR MONITOR 
 Y0UR publication has carried reports on the two editions so far published of our quarterly Horwath Business Review , and in particular on the results of our business monitor which it contains. 
 This confidence survey is conducted among UK hotel general managers and is based on a sample of almost 100 drawn from different classes, sizes and styles of hotels geographically spread across the country. 
 We would now like to extend its scope and analysis and we invite any general manager, not already participating, to do so. 
 I would be very pleased to hear from anyone willing to accept this invitation. 
 We would send a copy of our most recent edition with a short, explanatory letter. 
 Participation is not time-consuming. 
  JONATHAN BODLENDER Chairman, Horwath Consulting, 8 Baker Street, London W1M.  
 TECS RESPONSE A BIG HELP 
 FURTHER to your article TECs slammed over funding red tape ( Caterer , 22&ndash;28 August), I thought you might be interested to hear the other side of the coin. 
 As an individual who worked for over 10 years in relatively senior positions for two of the &bquo;major brewers&equo;, I thought it ironic that here was one set of red tape specialists accusing another. 
 As the managing director of a recently formed company with, to date, only one outlet, I was quite naturally looking for any help I could get, advisory or financially or both. 
 I was pushed in the Bradford TEC's direction by the local Chamber of Commerce. 
 Bradford TEC responded immediately, helped me understand its systems and guided me in the right direction on form-filling, etc. 
 Lo and behold, after further meetings, I am now the proud owner of a &bquo;grant&equo;. 
 If all TECs are as helpful and supportive as Bradford, then long may they flourish. 
  HUGH MANTLE Managing Director, Castlebridge Inns, Station Road, Steeton, Keighley, West Yorkshire.    
 TRAINING 
 CHINESE teaching 
 Norwich Hotel School has set up a Chinese cookery course to inspire future chefs. 
 Kate McDermid reports 
 TAKE a piece of fish, cook for 20 minutes until it has a wood-like texture, marinate for two days in soy sauce and sesame oil, then serve. 
 This ancient Chinese process is a fish preserving method comparable to smoking, and is just one of the techniques that catering students from the Norwich Hotel School will soon be taught. 
 It's part of the school's Chinese cookery awareness course &mdash; craft-based and designed to meet the City &amp; Guilds' new ethnic element. 
 Later this month it will be a permanent feature of full-time courses at the hotel school. 
 All craft students will spend about 30 hours a year in the Chinese cookery centre, which is sponsored by British Gas (Eastern) and Far East Industries. 
 The centre, which will also offer short courses for industry, boasts &pound;7,000-worth of state-of-the-art, mobile equipment including a steamer, duck oven and water-cooled, four-wok burner. 
 The course will be run by Norwich lecturer Martin Jermey. 
 The centre was christened in July with an adult education summer school and a series of master classes aimed at the professional caterer and taught by Jermey's Shanghai Institute of Tourism counterpart chef Xu Zhengcai, on his first visit to Britain, and Professor Dai Xin-Huan, his colleague and interpreter. 
 As a water-testing exercise these courses were successful, attracting &bquo;students&equo; from all over the country and even one from Saudi Arabia. 
 The other task in July for Xu &mdash; he is one of China's most highly regarded chefs, consultants and writers, the Chinese equivalent of Victor Ceserani &mdash; was to teach the Norwich staff and advise on setting up the course. 
 The idea for such an ambitious (but surprisingly nightmare-free) project was first mooted in 1989 when Professor Dai came to Norwich to attend a post-graduate degree course in tourism. 
 Head of the school Mike McKechnie later visited Shanghai to seal a friendship agreement and discuss the course content, a scaled down but otherwise authentic version of that taught at the institute. 
 Jermey's aim is not to turn out chefs who can produce Chinese wedding feasts, but adventurous chefs who can borrow techniques where appropriate and incorporate them into their own style: &bquo;They'll see new ways of finishing dishes, new combinations of flavours.&equo; 
 Assistant head of the hotel school, John Staples, adds: &bquo;They won't be experts but they'll have a good understanding of what it's all about. 
 There's no reason why they shouldn't be able to develop their own dishes. 
 There are tens of thousands of Chinese recipes and shades of flavour. 
 We talk about sweet and sour but they may have five different sweets and five different sours.&equo; 
 Another key difference between styles is in heat control, inextricably tied in with the equipment used. 
 Any standard piece of Western catering equipment simply cannot produce the heat needed. 
 &bquo;That's the crucial difference in keeping the flavour,&equo; says Jermey, for whom an important concern has been authenticity. 
 &bquo;The main differences between the two styles of cuisine is in the way the Chinese blend ingredients, how they introduce colour into the food, and that up to 90% of the work is done prior to cooking.&equo; 
 Importing the ingredients through wholesalers has not been a problem. 
 The lotus leaf needed to line the bamboo steamer for the Szechwan dish of steamed beef and rice flour was examined with interest, as were the ingredients used to make the rice flour &mdash; short grain rice, cinnamon bark, star anise and &bquo;special&equo; wild pepper &mdash; which were then saut&eacute;ed dry for 15 minutes and ground into a semolina-type texture after the removal of the bark and anise.  
 Left and above, chef Xu Zhengcai demonstrates to professional caterers at a master class 
 Xu's ingredients are fresh and he uses just one board 
 Even the duck used for Tai Bai Duck (a dish handed down from generation to generation and named after the Tang dynasty poet Li Tai Bai) despite being supplied by Cherry Valley, is, promises Jermey, authentic, because the company supplied much of China's duck breeding stock. 
 (Xu has willingly dropped monosodium glutamate after learning of its decreasing popularity here, admitting that it occasionally &bquo;covered a multitude of sins&equo;.) 
 Xu says he is impressed with the standard of fundamental craft skills he found among both staff and students at Norwich. 
 &bquo;Chinese and Western cuisines have very different styles, but since I've been here, I've realised that once chefs have the chance to exchange views and work together, it's very easy to adapt to a new style of cooking. 
 &bquo;China has a long history of cuisine, a vast territory and abundant natural resources, many nationalities and a large population that has many regions and local diets and customs,&equo; he explains, adding that Chinese chefs tended to create new dishes daily, as each cooking method, each style and the range of ingredients could be used to make up different combinations &mdash; traditional menus contained a minimum of 100 dishes named after methods. 
 Xu's generation is now categorised as &bquo;middle-age&equo; &mdash; chefs who have gained their qualification through professional training which enhances areas of traditional standards and techniques passed down through the generations. 
 But older generations of chefs learned to cook through long apprenticeships of five to nine years. 
 Among those noting Xu's habit of using just one board (ingredients are so fresh and so quickly prepared that food poisoning is not considered a threat) is Keith Mitchell, team captain of the British chefs competing at the culinary Olympics in Frankfurt next year, and head chef at the Grand Hotel, Eastbourne, East Sussex. 
 &bquo;One board, one knife, one hand,&equo; he comments while watching stir-fried beef with carrot and onion being prepared. 
 Mitchell, rather than recreating Chinese dishes, uses some Chinese methods and ingredients and is particularly impressed with the handling of flavours. 
 &bquo;Pick up a piece of chicken and all the flavours of that dish are on that piece of chicken. 
 The way we do things, you need your knife and fork to put the sauce on the meat or you haven't got the flavours. 
 In Western-style cooking, it's up to the consumer to combine the ingredients. 
 In Chinese cooking, everything's in the dish.&equo;  
 Stir-fried beef with carrot and onion is one dish which required &bquo;one board, one knife, one hand&equo; to prepare 
 SOLUTIONS 
 INDEPENDENTS GET BREAK FROM BRAVO by David Goymour 
 BRAVO, a new on-screen booking system which puts British hotels and tourist attractions on travel agents' counters, has entered its launch phase. 
 It is said to offer independent hotels the kind of exposure which hotels in big groups can derive from international booking systems &mdash; owned, typically, by the big airlines. 
 Selected branches of travel agents Thomas Cook and AT May are using the computerised system, with the details of about 100 selected hotels. 
 Bravo is planning to have 1,000 hotels on the system by 1 November, and 2,000 by March 1992. 
 Majority shareholder in Bravo is Cable &amp; Wireless (C&amp;W), which also owns Mercury, the communications company. 
 C&amp;W's partners are British Airways and Finite, a technology specialist. 
 &bquo;Bravo will distribute &bquo;UK Ltd&equo; worldwide, and give the travelling public access to the total UK product,&equo; said Bravo spokesman John Roussel. 
 &bquo;The international chains have access to systems like Sabre and Galileo, but any hotel can join Bravo.&equo; 
 Hotels taking part need not necessarily have computerised property management systems &mdash; a facsimile machine can be used as the link. 
 Participating hotels pay a subscription starting at &pound;175 a year, up to a ceiling of &pound;575. 
 This is based on the number of rooms in the hotel, not its tariff. 
 From the beginning of 1992 there will also be a joining fee of &pound;150 per hotel, but businesses joining before the end of the year avoid that. 
 Bravo levies a transaction charge for each booking, starting at &pound;1.80 to a maximum of &pound;3.30. 
 Hotels whose computer systems can interface automatically with Bravo pay lower rates. 
 The promoters are collecting feedback from the travel agents which are testing the system, and selling the idea to the travel trade with the slogan &bquo;Book Britain through Bravo&equo;. 
 If it catches on, Roussel sees it developing along several possible paths. 
 &bquo;Essentially it's an electronic brochure, but it could be used to promote a branded product, such as a hotel consortium or Agatha Christie weekends. 
 &bquo;As part of the Mercury communications empire, it can do anything: why not order beer through Bravo?&equo; 
 PETER Einstein, director of network development for MTV Europe, has announced the appointment of Tony Wawryk as satellite music and television (SMATV) hotels manager. 
 Mr Wawryk will be responsible for building on the channel's current base of more than 110,000 hotel rooms and for increasing the number of households able to receive MTV Europe. 
 The number of European households connected at the end of June stood at 24.4 million.   
 Postmaster wins Thames TV contracts 
 PABULUM Consultants and its Postmaster point-of-sale system has won the contract at the three Thames Television sites at Euston, Teddington and Tottenham Court Road, London, operated by Sutcliffe Catering. 
 The installation was part of a review of catering operations, conducted by Food Service Designs. 
 This is Pabulum's second installation in the broadcasting marketplace. 
 Foodmaster has been running at the BBC catering department for two years. 
 The three systems at Thames run on IBM 4684 hardware and are networked, allowing sales reports to be consolidated from each terminal. 
 CRS report 
 THE rapidly growing crisis in labour supply and the impact of new technologies, notably central reservation systems (CRS), are identified as two major challenges to the world's hotel industry. 
 The Economist Intelligence Unit highlights CRS systems in a special report: Competitive Strategies for the International Hotel Industry . 
 Price: &pound;195 (Europe, Middle East and Africa), from EIU, 40 Duke Street, London W1A 1DW. 
 Partnership 
 ANN Brough, Maureen Coulton and Shirley Taylor, who previously worked together in the systems and control department of the former Trusthouse Forte Hotels, have formed a partnership offering accounts and control support services to the hotel industry. 
 The company, called Systems 4 Control, is based at Unit 61, Northwick Business Centre, Blockley, Morton-in-Marsh GL56 9RF. 
 Tel: 0386 700896; fax: 0386 701069. 
 THORN SOFTWARE STAFF BUYOUT 
 THORN EMI Software, the computer services division of the electronics and entertainment group, has been bought out by its staff and management in an &pound;82m deal and has taken a new name. 
 From two of its existing operations &mdash; Software Sciences, which produces the CHAMPS hotel management system and Datasolve, which manages other companies' data facilities &mdash; the new company has taken the name Data Sciences. 
 The existing management, headed by chairman and chief executive Mike Smith, and all 1,950 staff, will remain intact. 
 With turnover of &pound;117m last year, the company accounted for only about 5% of Thorn EMI sales, but Data Sciences is number two in the UK computer services league. 
 CHAMPS will be one of the vertical-market products developed further by the independent company &mdash; and an announcement is expected in the autumn. 
 BAA Hotels recently installed the system at its three British hotels and one Belgian property &mdash; the Sterling hotels at Heathrow and Gatwick, the Stansted Harlequin, and at Ghent, Belgium. 
 Commenting on the Heathrow installation, BAA Hotels managing director Jeremy Logie said: &bquo;The primary role of technology is to give the guest a better experience at the hotel. 
 The CHAMPS installation will certainly meet that aim, and the interface of all its facilities allows us to manage the hotel while enabling guests to deal with their affairs in a quick and effective manner.&equo; 
 Data Sciences also supplies software for other sectors, notably financial, manufacturing, and aerospace. 
 The company is expected to offer shares to its employees when it is allowed to do so, and a Stock Market flotation could follow in &bquo;two, three or four years' time&equo; according to Mr Smith. 
 High-tech investment at Fairfield Manor 
 YORK-based Croft Hotels is investing &pound;80,000 in training and presentation equipment for its Fairfield Manor Hotel, near York. 
 The investment will provide the hotel with some of the most comprehensive and up-to-date training and presentation facilities in North Yorkshire. 
 It forms part of a &pound;6m redevelopment programme for Fairfield Manor, which will be completed next spring. 
 &bquo;One of the priorities in redeveloping Fairfield Manor Hotel is to cater for business users,&equo; said Croft managing director Keith Pope. 
 &bquo;We are taking every care to provide the latest technology and a quality environment.&equo; 
 Fairfield Manor's suite of meeting rooms will include a training room, conference room and two syndicate rooms. 
 The training and conference rooms will each house a screen, one 2.5sq m and the other 1.5sq m. 
 A simple, cordless, hand-held remote control will operate 35mm slides with merge facility, overheads, television, satellite television, U-matic tape and VHS video tapes on one or both screens. 
 It will also control lighting, curtains and the audio system with compact disc player. 
 The two syndicate rooms will also be equipped with video cameras for role-play exercises.  
 HOTECH '91 
 HOTECH 91, the technology exhibition for the industry, offers the solutions to help you run a better business. 
 David Goymour reports 
 TELECOMMUNICATIONS will be one of the buzz words at HOTECH '91, the leading exhibition of technology solutions for the hotel and catering industry. 
 The show, presented by Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper , is at the Wembley Conference Centre, London, on 6 and 7 November. 
 Telecommunications systems for hotels now perform many more tasks than just allowing people to make telephone calls. 
 Typical of most of the systems that will be at HOTECH are wake-up and message services; posting of charges for telephone calls to the room account; facilities to advise housekeeping when bedrooms are free for cleaning; and display of the guest's name on the operator console. 
 Among the companies specialising in telecommunications is a new HOTECH exhibitor, Digital Telephone Systems. 
 DTS will show the Harris 20&ndash;20 Accommodator hotel communication system for the first time at the show. 
 DTS claims the Accommodator system, as well as handling telephone traffic and the facilities mentioned above, makes an important contribution to housekeeping, maintenance and billing functions. 
 A DTS spokeswoman explained: &bquo;Once a guest has checked out, the room telephone is automatically disabled to prevent unauthorised use, and the room status changes to &bquo;requires cleaning&equo;. 
 The room maid can enter maintenance requests into the system via the telephone, saving time in tracking down members of staff.&equo; 
 Other telecommunications companies which have booked space at HOTECH '91 include: Western Telecom, now part of the Alcatel group; GPT Sales &amp; Services; Ascom Telecommunications; 3C Communications, which is establishing telecom links with an increasing number of other suppliers' systems; and Mitel Telecom, which was involved in the refit at The Dorchester, London. 
 A special branch of communications which is also increasingly important to the hotel and travel industry, and which will be featured at HOTECH, is the on-line hotel bookings system. 
 One of these, PC-Hornet, which has been developed over the past 10 years, will be shown for the first time by McDonnell Douglas. 
 Latest developments to PC-Hornet include on-line communications between central booking office and hotel, and links to other reservation sources, such as airline systems and hotel syndicates. 
 Another on-line system recently launched in Britain is Bravo (see news report on page 55). 
 This is aimed at independent hotels, and will put them alongside chain properties on travel agents' terminals. 
 Bravo is part of Cable &amp; Wireless &mdash; like HOTECH exhibitor Mercury Communications. 
 Mercury has not yet disclosed what announcements it will be making at the show. 
 &bull; For further information about HOTECH '91 contact the organiser, First Event, tel: 071&ndash;252 6459.  
 HOTECH is an opportunity for the industry to see technology first hand 
 THE DATABASE GOLD MINE 
 THE hotel business is no stranger to information technology (IT). 
 Yet it is easy for pioneer users and IT investors to remain with the tried and tested applications and miss out on the cutting edge opportunities just around the corner. 
 The information already held on computer for regular operations is only yielding a fraction of its true potential &mdash; potential to contribute directly to the bottom line, if analysed with a marketing strategy in mind. 
 Few organisations have yet tapped the power of knowing their customers through a marketing database. 
 Those which have are reaping impressive rewards simply by identifying precisely the services or products customers want; looking at their most lucrative areas; finding out what clients really value; and establishing what would make them move to a competing hotel. 
 This fundamental marketing information can easily be gleaned from the vast stores of historic customer data which hotels possess. 
 As a seasoned business traveller I am constantly amazed at all the lost opportunities to build customer loyalty. 
 For example, I have never received a personal letter following my stay to thank me for my custom. 
 Maybe I could have been offered a discount if I brought my wife next time. 
 And why do reception staff often ask if I've stayed with them before when I'm booked on a regular customer discount? 
 If information is there it needs to be filtered and passed on &mdash; via senior management &mdash; into all areas of the operation. 
 The real power of computerised data lies in a deeper, more sophisticated analysis of the information which already exists. 
 This isn't just customer care: this is better margins and hard profit. 
 Those who embark on this deeper, marketing-centred analysis find it necessary to separate this process from the regular tactical use of the database for sales mailings. 
 To identify the complex yet crucial inter-relationships between customers and their characteristics demands sophisticated statistical and marketing knowledge. 
 Accepted marketing wisdom says that 20% of customers represent 80% of one's business. 
 Yet few organisations adjust their marketing effort and their management priorities accordingly. 
 With proper use of a database this is easy, with benefits directly on the bottom line. 
 Not only are the most profitable customers encouraged to return, but subtle features are identified and fed into the operation so that guests feel personally cared for. 
 When analysed at this more fundamental level, the database will also give clear guidelines about overall corporate image. 
 But there is also the flip side of the coin. 
 Customers return because they feel food about the product or service. 
 So it is just as important to know what it is about your organisation that customers value so that you can promote it fully. 
 The older a database is, the richer it becomes as a reference about customers and their views of you. 
 Isn't it time to take hold of that lead by realising their true marketing potential? 
  Charles Arthur, Managing Director, Datascope Marketing    
 Supporting cast 
 Suppliers are more than sales people. 
 Use them to the full to guarantee the effective use of your computer system by ensuring staff are aware of its potential. 
 David Goymour reports 
 BUYING a computer system for a single hotel or restaurant, or for a chain of units, involves far more than ordering and taking delivery of powerful foxes loaded with clever software. 
 That part of the package has to be right, but it's impossible to separate it from the consultation that goes on between the customer and the supplier before the sale is clinched. 
 The conversation continues after delivery, with training for the staff who are to use the system, and support services while the system is in use. 
 Technology suppliers to the British hotel and restaurant industry say that their products are often under-exploited, because too little thought has been given to what the systems are supposed to achieve and too low a priority is given to staff training. 
 One industry spokesman comments: &bquo;The overall performance of computerised management systems within the hotel industry relates more to the attitudes of managers towards training and the commitment of their suppliers than it does to the &bquo;superiority&equo; of the individual systems.&equo; 
 Two contentious issues are the cost of training to managers and the same managers' grasp of systems (or the lack of it). 
 It is claimed that catering colleges have failed to get to grips with the developments of technology, acknowledge its importance and provide students with a level of understanding based on the industry's needs. 
 How successful a computer installation is will depend largely on how clearly the customer and the supplier have defined, at the outset, what the system is supposed to achieve. 
 As Checkout Computer Systems' Tim Webb points out, people's expectations of technology often exceed the computer's remit. 
 &bquo;The most frequently asked question is: What does the customer expect to derive from the implementation of electronic point of sale (EPoS)?&equo; 
 Webb says. 
 &bquo;The answers are wildly varied but generally appertain to improvements in control and standard of service. 
 &bquo;When selling a system which has a full-control system at the heart of its operation, the first response is easily satisfied. 
 The second is not necessarily quite so easy. 
 &bquo;One must consider the fact that, in most installations, the staff are also new and frequently new to the trade. 
 Speed and standards of service are, therefore, inevitably compromised, with either the EPoS system or lack of training being cited as the culprit.&equo;  
 Fretwell-Downing Data Systems head of sales Charles Mobbs frequently points out that it is not possible to buy a piece of software and a manual from him and then walk away: partnership between supplier and customer is the approach. 
 &bquo;The software package selected for implementation should be seen as the vehicle for a solution rather than the solution itself. 
 This, therefore, demands that the purchaser and supplier of a system must be capable of working in partnership, and that the supplier has specialist skills in all areas of implementation of systems to assist the customer over this hurdle,&equo; Mobbs says. 
 &bquo;Any prospective purchaser of systems should, therefore, make themselves fully confident that their chosen supplier has the depth of skills and personnel available in all areas. 
 &bquo;For this reason, purchasing from brochures or purchasing from a system demonstration on-site is simply inadequate. 
 In-depth evaluation of suppliers, their premises and personnel structures is vitally important.&equo; 
 Potentially the customer holds the strong cards at this stage of the discussion: the hotelier or restaurateur knows what his business problems are and knows what the computer system is going to have to achieve &mdash; and the potential buyer, who has thought this through before the supplier appears, is more likely to end up with the right system. 
 Also part of the package, and defined more by the supplier, will be the equally important staff and management training, and on-going support for the hardware and software. 
 The training should be done by the system supplier, with no reliance on outside agents. 
 Some hotel and restaurant groups have their own systems trainers, who will receive instruction from the supplier and then &bquo;cascade&equo; what they have learned to operations staff at the units. 
 Either way, the training should be done on the supplier's premises. 
 Mobbs says: &bquo;On-site training is only viable where suitable facilities exist and commitment is given to releasing staff from daily duties. 
 Where either of these is not practical then off-site training is far more effective as a constructive environment can be created and release from day-to-day pressures guaranteed.&equo; 
 Initial training to teach operators how to use the system takes more or less time depending on the software, but typically this ranges from two to five days. 
 Sometimes suppliers will say this is not nearly enough. 
 Innsite Hotel Services, for example, recommends, for its Innfront front office system, an on-site training package of 11 days spread over a period. 
 This includes instruction on reservations, sales ledger, guest accounting, guest history and two days of &bquo;live&equo; cover. 
 A maximum of six delegates can be accommodated on each course, and the package includes a one-day refresher, three months after going live. 
 Innsite, however, is realistic in its view of the market, for it also offers a budget start-up package that teaches the fundamental of Innfront in five consecutive days, which can be topped up later with further training. 
  Some companies offer to do the training either on their own premises or at the client site. 
 Lodgistix, for example, will come to the hotel or accept clients' staff at its office in Croydon, Surrey. 
 &bquo;Off-site training is far more effective,&equo; &mdash; Charles Mobbs 
 As Lodgistix account manager Phillip Wanbon points out, different packages require different timescales for training, but he adds: &bquo;We do guarantee to stay on site until we are fully satisfied that all the relevant personnel within the hotel or conference centre are competent enough to run an efficient operation with minimal help from us. 
 This is of course in our own interests.&equo; 
 Training on-site can cost anything in the range of &pound;200 to &pound;350 per day. 
 Training courses at the supplier's own premises are typically charged on a daily delegate rate structured like the tariff for hotel conferences. 
 IGS, for example, quotes &pound;60 per person per day, with a minimum of four to a group. 
 Computer systems are often under-exploited, largely because the people using the systems are not aware of its possibilities. 
 Pabulum Consultants' Jennifer Rust comments: &bquo;Many companies will only invest in the minimum training required to get the system up and running; it is not surprising in these cases that the systems are not being used to their full potential. 
 &bquo;Management should regard a full training schedule as part of the total cost of the system and include this total sum in the system's payback calculations. 
 The computer system will only bring the returns that the company expects if the people using it are using the system fully, which can be guaranteed through investment in adequate training. 
 &bquo;It must also be noted that the computer systems generate information and it is how this information is used that influences the returns on the total package. 
 The onus is on the company to ensure that staff are making intelligent decisions on the information that the computer system provides and this comes from in-house training.&equo; 
 Telephone Management Systems customer care director Anne Nunn also speaks for many suppliers when she talks about the imbalance between the knowledge required of hotel staff and the time devoted to training them. 
 She catalogues some of the services guests now take for granted, and which require electronic equipment working behind the scenes. 
 &bquo;A fully up-to-date room bill must be available on demand; the telephone must allow guests access to anywhere in the world the moment they enter their rooms; the video must be instantly viewable. 
 To achieve this most hotels have a number of systems, all provided by different suppliers, on which the staff come to rely totally,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;A system failure has a knock-on effect throughout the hotel and adequate contingency plans must be in place to cope with such a situation. 
 Yet despite this, many hoteliers are reluctant to invest in sufficient training for their staff.&equo; 
 Welcome Computer Systems' managing partner Nick Chudley echoes this view: &bquo;Sadly, and we believe mistakenly, some customers decide to cut back on training as an economy measure. 
 We think it's a false economy, but we can understand that a seaside hotelier, for example, may not want to train casual, seasonal staff. 
 So the owner/manager will be trained and in turn will train a succession of staff. 
 &bquo;Ideally we would like to go back to a site a few months after installation, for a meeting with senior management to show them how they can take advantage of the system,&equo; Chudley says. 
 &bquo;The marketing manager can learn how to take advantage of the growing database and the finance manager can see how to use the special accounting systems.&equo;  
 &bquo;Operator training is fairly simple, but managers need more to get the most out of the system,&equo; &mdash; Nick Chudley 
 READ THE MANUAL FIRST&hellip; 
 THERE'S a saying in the computer industry: &bquo;If in doubt, press a few keys; if that doesn't work, ask a colleague; if in deep trouble, consult the manual.&equo; 
 There is some justification for this caricature of the typical computer user &mdash; though customers' critics might ask themselves first how well-written the manuals are, before complaining that people never read them. 
 Assuming the manual is in comprehensible English, users can avoid many unnecessary calls to the help desk by a combination of consulting its index, and using the onscreen help built into the software. 
 Pabulum Consultants' Jennifer Rust adds: &bquo;They could also help themselves by thinking through a problem before phoning the support desk. 
 In many cases a user will actually solve his or her own problem while on the phone to Neptune! 
 &bquo;Users must also be encouraged to recognise the difference between a reception problem and a computer problem. 
 We get calls from our customers, from receptionists, for example, who cannot balance at the end of the shift. 
 This is, in most cases, simply a normal, everyday problem.&equo; 
 Another way in which computer users can help suppliers to help them is to appoint a system manager. 
 This is a controversial issue: hoteliers and restaurateurs are supposed to be running hotels and restaurants, after all, not managing computer systems. 
 Hotel chains and other groups can support systems specialists, but even independents could benefit from making individuals responsible for the operation of information technology systems. 
 Realistically, most staff never will want to plough through the manuals that come with most software. 
 If the independent business has one staff member who regularly uses the computer equipment and sufficiently interested to study the manuals, that person will, given encouragement, build up expertise which can usefully be passed on. 
 The system manager would also be the contact to whom the supplier would turn when arranging suitable dates for updating software, for example, and other maintenance work.  
 Back up your data 
 Backing up data is one of the basics of any computer system. 
 Joseph Houghton offers tips for beginners 
 YOUR computer has just broken down. 
 You turned it on but nothing is happening &mdash; blank screen, no whirring noise, no beeps, no flashing lights. 
 Dead. 
 The VAT returns for the last quarter are due in, and that big (very profitable) convention which took over the hotel for three weeks last year is imminent but you can't get at your data. 
 You could type in all your accounting figures again, and recreate what you can of the customer histories from print outs in the filing cabinet. 
 Shouldn't take more than a couple of weeks at most&hellip; 
 Would you be panicking at this point? 
 If so, read on. 
 A chef would never leave a kitchen with food out on the worktops at the end of the day, and front desk is always tidied at the end of a shift, but how many managers do more than simply turn off the computer and go home at the end of a session with their spreadsheet or word processor? 
 Back up your data! 
 Everything stored in the memory of a computer can be copied on to removable diskettes. 
 It takes only a few minutes. 
 Hundreds of customers' details can be stored on one diskette, as can whole spreadsheets, and the diskettes can then be kept safely in a secure place away from the computer. 
 If anything happened to the computer and it proved impossible to get at the data inside, you could go to your back-up diskettes and simply copy the data back into the computer when it had been repaired, or replaced, or put it onto another computer. 
 This is true of all computers, whatever make, size or cost and irrespective of the programs you run on your machine. 
 Basic discipline can save you hours of wasted time, preserve years of carefully built up data and give you peace of mind. 
 The actual machine is replaceable, as are the programs which run on it &mdash; but your data is unique and cannot simply be replaced by the local computer shop. 
 Some people never have to use their back-ups, just as some people never need to claim on their insurance, but would you want to be uninsured? 
 You cannot afford to lose your data. 
 If you have no back-ups, then one day you will lose it and that could be the end of your business. 
 The most widespread type of computer in small businesses &mdash; the IBM compatible PC &mdash; can back up in several ways. 
 As data security is such a fundamental issue for all computer users, programs which enable back-ups to be taken are supplied with each PC. 
 These programs are part of the operating system &mdash; the set of commands which come with the computer and allow you to communicate with it. 
 One such command is COPY, and two more are BACKUP and RESTORE. 
 The manuals which come with the computer will explain how to use them. 
 These commands will do the job but, if you are willing to spend some money, there are programs available which will make the whole process much easier, even automating back-ups so that your data is kept fully secure at all times. 
 SHAREWARE 
 Some of these programs belong to the Shareware scheme which means that they can be used and evaluated for a few weeks, and you pay the registration fee only if you continue to use them. 
 A browse through any of the computer magazines will indicate several possibilities, and many companies will supply a demonstration version to try out before you commit to a purchase. 
 Even better, go down to your local computer shop and ask them to show you several different ways to back-up, then choose the one which seems easiest. 
 If you have large amounts of data to back-up (more than will fit on the six diskettes), consider installing a tape streamer. 
 This is a device similar to a normal cassette recorder but which takes bigger tape cassettes, each of which can hold all the data and programs on your computer. 
 These devices can back up the whole system or only those parts which you specify, and are very fast. 
 See a computer dealer for more advice and insist on seeing a demonstration before you buy. 
 Whether you go it alone, ask the computer shop expert or persuade a friend who knows about computers to help you, it is essential to set up a regular data back-up system.  
 STOCKTAKING made simple 
 The Psion Organiser: is it a fancy calculator, or a battery-powered log book? 
 One City caterer has found a novel use for it in the larder. 
 David Goymour reports 
 CONTRACT caterer Catering &amp; Allied has teamed up with systems supplier TIS to speed up and simplify the job of stocktaking at its City of London contract with merchant bank Morgan Grenfell. 
 As part of the whole process of computerising its information systems, Catering &amp; Allied is making neat use of the Psion Organiser II alongside personal computers loaded with the Caterdata software from TIS. 
 Operations manager Siobhan Hunter, who is responsible for the Morgan Grenfell contract, says: &bquo;We've been looking at computers for the past 18 months, and we went for Caterdata, having seen it in action at BE Services, the in-house caterer at the Bank of England.&equo; 
 Catering &amp; Allied took presentations from half a dozen systems suppliers, and put three possibles on trial, but the two others were found to be too complex for the company's purposes. 
 These purposes include control of the purchasing activity, minimising wastage and keeping selling prices as keen as possible. 
 Morgan Grenfell, like many Catering &amp; Allied clients, wants its staff to pay only the cost of food, plus VAT. 
 It has also set out some rules about which menu items can or cannot be increased in price. 
 Soups, salads, potatoes and other hot vegetables, hot puddings, fruit and yoghurt are fixed-priced items: main courses and the &bquo;grill bar special&equo; are among those which can be adjusted. 
 Efficient stocktaking is a key element in controlling these prices and expenditure &mdash; and that's where the Psion Organiser comes in. 
 Deputy unit manager Phil Brown, who has taken responsibility for the computer system, says: &bquo;We can do the stocktake in about half a day with the Psion Organiser. 
 Doing it manually, it had to be done over a period of two or three days, fitting it in after work.&equo; 
 The stock file on the Caterdata package allocates a code to each ingredient which Catering &amp; Allied buys from its various suppliers. 
 When the latest invoices are recorded, Caterdata looks at various sections of its filing system and updates them with the information. 
 It's a cyclical process: when the butcher delivers to the kitchens at Morgan Grenfell, Brown enters the details from the delivery note on the computer in his office. 
 At this point the number of steaks, chops and other meat ingredients are updated on the stock file. 
 When the invoice comes in for payment, this is copied on to the system as well, and Caterdata first searches for the equivalent delivery note to check that Brown is being charged for the right goods. 
 As each item from the invoice is typed into the system, the program updates the stock file to show the most recent price paid per pound for each commodity. 
 TECHNICAL DATA 
 SOFTWARE in use at Morgan Grenfell: Caterdata from TIS &mdash; licensed to Catering &amp; Allied at an entry cost of about &pound;4,000. 
 Annual charge for software support is 20% of this. 
 Hardware: Compaq PC &mdash; Morgan Grenfell property. 
 Psion Organiser II, bought by Catering &amp; Allied at a branch of Dixons. 
 Typical cost including four 128k data packs: from &pound;480, including VAT. 
 And the next time Brown compiles a menu, the costing for each dish will be based on the updated purchase price. 
 As the goods are drawn out of the larders, the statistics are adjusted downwards, and Brown can quickly check how much he needs to re-order. 
 Having this kind of information conveniently available is exactly what Catering &amp; Allied needed. 
 Hunter says Caterdata was chosen largely because it is &bquo;user-friendly, simple to use in terms of the number of keystrokes people need to make, and quick to learn&equo;. 
 However, it is one thing to scan a computer screen in the catering office: it's quite another to do stocktaking &mdash; typically this involves carrying a notebook around the various larders and coldrooms. 
 Catering &amp; Allied came up with a novel solution: copy the stock file on to one of the two 128k data packs which fit into the back of a Psion Organiser, update that file &bquo;on the hoof&equo;; and copy the updated file back to the desktop computer. 
 TIS programmed a second data pack, in a language the Psion understands, to handle the information. 
 As Brown moves round the larders, the Psion Organiser presents him with a series of ingredient names, in a preset order. 
 Each ingredient has to be counted and a quantity entered. 
 This can be done by purchase unit, standard unit or a combination of the two. 
 So, for example, if wine is being checked, it can be counted by the case or by the bottle. 
 If the system disagrees with the figure entered it will challenge it &mdash; otherwise it moves on to the next item. 
 &bquo;The first time we did it, the stock check was programmed to call up everything,&equo; Brown says. 
 &bquo;After that, on each check it only calls up those items which have been active since.&equo; 
 Brown can choose selective stock checks &mdash; concentrating either on particular commodities or on the contents of one larder. 
 Or the whole unit can be checked at a single tour, with a limit of 2,000 stock codes on the Psion. 
 The system is working happily, and the success of the Psion is sending out ripples both within Catering &amp; Allied and TIS. 
 Brown, who went on a one-day course at TIS before coming back and installing the system at Morgan Grenfell, is now teaching colleagues to use it, including unit manager Karen Goate, &bquo;Computers used to frighten me, but not now,&equo; she says. 
 This is part of the Catering &amp; Allied philosophy of &bquo;link manning&equo; &mdash; people need to be able to pick up their colleagues' responsibilities if necessary, so knowledge gets passed on. 
 Brown will probably be involved in passing it on to other sites as well as to colleagues at the Morgan Grenfell operation. 
 Within TIS, too, the work which was done to bring Caterdata and the Psion together can now be sold on to other Caterdata customers, and a section explaining how Psion works has been added to the Caterdata manual.  
 Stocktake can be done in half a day with the Psion Organiser 
 Hotel Manager offers room status facility 
 by David Goyour 
 PHILIPS' Hotel Manager is a feature of the Sopho-Systemmanager, which is now offered in either a multi-terminal, UNIX version or single-terminal PC version. 
 The Hotel Manager's room status facility allows room status to be updated by using the telephone keypad as an input terminal. 
 A room status change can be initiated either by hotel staff entering a code manually on the bedroom telephone, or automatically by the Hotel Manager if, for example, a name is entered or deleted on the guest file. 
 Status of all rooms, including those ready for use, can be displayed and adjusted at the Hotel Manager workstation. 
 Names and details of guests are stored in the guest directory as they are checked in, and room status change is indicated. 
 At check out, a telephone bill and any messages pending are printed out and the guest details are removed from the directory. 
 When all people occupying a room have checked out of the hotel, the room status is changed to &bquo;not occupied&equo;. 
 Procedures are also available to log hotel guest room changes. 
 The Hotel Manager can also provide automatic wake-up calls. 
 When the call is answered, the guest can be connected to a telephone set or to a voice announcer, for a &bquo;wake-up message&equo; or &bquo;wake-up tone&equo;. 
 If a wake-up attempt fails, an alarm report will be printed out. 
 If you would like further information contact Philips Telecom, telephone: 0223 61222. 
 Launch of IMS 90 
 QUINTEK Systems has launched a new version of its Inn Management System. 
 The package IMS 90, runs under any industry-standard operating system and can be used with EPoS devices. 
 Designed for the brewing and leisure sector. 
 IMS 90 provides management with a comprehensive reporting system and incorporates applications specific to bar and restaurant operations. 
 Using all of the system's facilities, management can analyse sales and staffing levels in multiple bars on a single site, or can view an entire operation remotely from a head office. 
 Contact Quintek Systems Ltd, 4 The Courtyard, Denmark Street, Wokingham, Berkshire RG11 2AZ. 
 Tel: 0734 771444. 
 NORTHMACE, a British company which specialises in the provision of bedroom amenity equipment to hotels, now supplies televisions. 
 The company can provide televisions on contract rental, hire purchase or outright purchase. 
 Full maintenance cover is also available. 
 Sports package 
 SIEMENS Nixdorf Information Systems has launched Club 2000, an integrated leisure management software package, for any type or size of sports and leisure club. 
 Club 2000 features an Access Control System which enables members to book and use facilities with a single magnetic strip membership card. 
 Card processor 
 PENNINE and Royal of Scotland have developed ROYNET, a software system, which eliminates the need for any device other than a standard electronic point of sale till for processing credit and debit cards. 
 Labelling system 
 KROY (Europe) has launched Duratype 210, a compact, portable handheld labelling system, for &pound;150. 
 The unit allows messages of up to 55 characters to be printed and has a repeat function which means repetitive text need not be re-keyed.  
 Gulf War spin-off aids stocking 
 INTEREST in portable computers of all kinds has been stimulated by the Gulf War, when everything from tanks and armoured vehicles to airmen's flying helmets were fitted with a range of increasingly smaller and more rugged technology. 
 Industry in general is expected to inherit many of the benefits in the future. 
 Pilots' helmets with miniature built-in video screens may not have obvious applications in hotels and restaurants, but there are several defence-led developments which do, and which will increasingly be seen around the industry. 
 Typical of these is the GRiDPad, a ruggedly built, pen-operated computer made by GRiD Computer Systems. 
 In battlefield conditions, particularly in the desert, keyboard-free devices are more likely to keep performing. 
 But in the hotel and restaurant industry, the GRiDPad's 12-hour rechargeable power pack and its genuine portability make it viable for operations like stocktaking. 
 Database files can be copied from the user's main computer system to the GRiDPad &mdash; a process which is slow currently, but will get faster &mdash; and updated in the field. 
 The updated file can then be copied back to the central system, by modem and telephone if necessary. 
 GRiD has announced a partnership agreement with Informant, a UK software development and systems integration company. 
 The two will develop and market pen and display-(PAD) based solutions to users in a wide range of commercial markets, including retailing and merchandising.  
 GRiDPad uses a lightpen to &bquo;write&equo; data directly onto the screen 
 Plan functions with Eventdata 
 EVENTDATA is a program to help the planning and control of function management. 
 The program &mdash; written to operate in a UNIX &bquo;open systems&equo; environment &mdash; includes a central diary management system with simultaneous access for several locations by multiple users. 
 This should reduce the risk of double bookings. 
 Each function has a menu screen which can be fully customised. 
 These cover inquiries and reservations; menu planning; quotations; and invoicing and updates to the customer database. 
 Further information from: CDL, tel: 0483 756813. 
 Maxial system offers accuracy and speed 
 POINT of sale terminals are now available for the Maxial advanced hotel system from General Automation (GA), and will be on show at HOTECH '91 in November (see page 59). 
 The terminal offers Maxial users a facility to enter restaurant and bar menu items with a single key stroke. 
 &bquo;GA's policy of working closely with Maxial customers to evolve enhancements has led to this highly effective facility,&equo; said John Willson, GA hotel systems sales manager. 
 &bquo;It offers users benefits through greater accuracy of input and gives them more time to respond to customers.&equo; 
 Use of the Maxial PoS terminal requires the modification of the installation's central PoS software, which receives the same string of characters as that for a transaction entered through a conventional keyboard. 
 The new PoS terminal keyboard uses fixed keys covered with a plastic membrane to guard against moisture. 
 Further information: General Automation, tel: 0753 889112.  
 LIQUID ASSETS 
 ITALY &mdash; A fresh approach 
 In the first of a two-part series, Michael Edwards selects wines which break the Italian mould 
 IN THE British restaurant scene today, there is a growing interesting in all things Italian. 
 Several of our brightest chefs, often trained in French methods, are looking to the Mediterranean for inspiration. 
 The Italian influence on British cooking has resulted in a shift away from traditional classical sauces and stocks towards an emphasis on &bquo;something exquisitely fresh, with the least amount of modification in the process of preparation&equo;, to quote from an old Tuscan cookery book. 
 The honesty and heartiness of this cooking is matched by an enviable choice of truly exciting Italian wines, which are now widely available in Britain. 
 The past 10 years has seen a dramatic improvement in Italy's wine technology led by the latest generation of gifted wine-makers. 
 No wine region is a better case study of the new Italy than Friuli-Venezia Giulia. 
 Friuli is tucked between the Alpine mountains of North-east Italy and the Adriatic and is a model of how high technology and human flair can achieve exceptionally graceful and vital white wines. 
 Wine supplier Bibendum's buyer Simon Farr says: &bquo;Friulian whites, particularly those from Collio close to the Yugoslav border, are wonderfully clean and restrained. 
 The influence of the Alpine atmosphere can clearly be felt in the best wines.&equo; 
 Typical of these is the 1990 Sauvignon Vigneto del Cero (Venica &amp; Venica) which is quite lovely. 
 So it should be at &pound;101.62 a case (all prices are quoted exclusive of VAT) from Bibendum (071&ndash;722 5577). 
 But Sauvignon does not come better than this and to my mind the del Cero Sauvignon has more grace, character and length than the much-vaunted Cloudy Bay Sauvignon from New Zealand, which is comparably priced. 
 The del Cero is an adaptable wine for food, as good with fritto misto di mare as with grilled squid and fresh chilli peppers. 
 Another Collio white of real class is the 1990 Pinot Bianco from Vittorio and Giovanni Puiatti (&pound;91.16 from Winecellars 081 871 3979). 
 The Pinot Bianco grape usually shows more character than the Pinot Grigio. 
 In the hands of Puiatti, this Pinot Bianco is a stunning wine with a tight vinous concentration and considerable elegance &mdash; and is a real rival to top-flight St V&eacute;ran which costs much the same. 
 Try it with grilled sea bass and fennel. 
 Close to Collio is the Grave del Friuli district. 
 The best wines show much the same style as their more expensive Collio counterparts. 
 Drinking brilliantly at the moment is the 1990 Cabernet Franc from Vigneti le Monde (&pound;68.94 from Bibendum). 
 This poised and slightly red wine shows great purity of Cabernet fruit and is the work of Piergiovanni Pistone-Salice, a man totally committed to quality. 
 The wine is excellent with calf's liver or plain roast veal. 
 If you drive westwards, skirting Venice you come to Verona, the home of Valpolicella. 
 In the past, this was one of the most abused red wines around. 
 Avoid cheap versions of Valpolicella (about &pound;30 a case) like the plague. 
 Pay about &pound;45 a case for a wine from the Classico hillsides and it can be a revelation. 
 Outstanding value is the 1990 Valpolicella Classico from the highly regarded Allegrini family (&pound;43.56 from Winecellars). 
 Brothers Walter and Franco and sister Marilisa have steadily improved the quality of their wine over the years. 
 The 1990 is a ripe mouthful with a youthful, blush ruby colour and delicious primary fruit which is greatly superior to many Beaujolais. 
 The Allegrini has a pleasant, bitter cherry finish &mdash; the touch of austerity making it an ideal foil to buttery pasta. 
 In the search for alternative sources of good, reasonably priced wine, have a look at Sicily. 
 The Sicilian Institute of Vine-growing and Wine-producing has launched a generic campaign in Britain to increase awareness of Sicilian wines. 
 Certainly modern methods of vinification and new grape varieties have already produced good results. 
 Cellaro is a first-rate Sicilian co-operative. 
 It bottles only 4% of its production under the Cellaro label, paying growers a bonus for healthier grapes with a better balance of sugar and acidity. 
 The white is full-bodied yet fresh, while the red provides soft, early drinking. 
 There's also a delicious ros&eacute;. 
 These wines, priced at about &pound;35 a case, would make superior house selections. 
 Ring Winecellars for details of your local stockist. 
 SWEET 
 Finally for something which is a real indulgence. 
 The remote island of Pantelleria, off the coast of Sicily and more than halfway to Tunisia, produces a superb dessert wine. 
 The Moscato di Pantelleria from Marco de Bartoli has a glistening mahogany colour and is at once aromatic, grapy and intensely rich. 
 It drinks wonderfully with chocolate desserts. 
 So go and try it at Riva's restaurant, 169 Church Road, Barnes, London SW13 (081&ndash;748 0434) where you can drink a single glass with Andrea Riva's tiramisu.  
 This Pinot Bianco can rival top-flight St V&eacute;ran 
 DRINKS NEWS 
 Association fights back 
 THE Wine and Spirit Association has threatened to take formal complaints of environmental health officers (EHOs) &bquo;deemed to have abused their authority&equo; to Government level. 
 The association said that it had heard of several cases in which EHOs had ordered unacceptable action from wine and drinks wholesalers under the 1990 Food Safety Act. 
 One Midlands wine wholesaler was ordered to clear dust from a warehouse floor used only for cased goods, the association said. 
 Association director Richard Insoll warned: &bquo;The Wine and Spirit Association will be reviewing this and other instances of apparent abuse of authority by EHOs in order to give its members the best advice. 
 Formal complaints will be lodged with the Food Minister where we deem it necessary.&equo; 
 Chinon wine 
 LOIRE producer Langlois-Ch&acirc;teau, is introducing its first Chinon wine to the UK. 
 Ch&acirc;teau de Rivi&egrave;re Chinon 1989 comes from south of the river Vienne. 
 Langlois-Ch&acirc;teau said that it would be developing a range of single domaine wines in the future.  
 LANGLOIS-CH&Acirc;TEAU 183 
 Cape wines 
 BARWELL &amp; Jones has introduced 35 South African wines from the Cape Province to the UK market. 
 The wines include Le Bonheur Blanc Fume (Sauvignon Blanc) from Stellenbosch which is unwooded with a fresh, grassy character; Fleur du Cap Chenin Blanc Sec (crisp and fruity); Witzenberg Emerald Stein (semi-sweet Fleur du Cap); and Roodebloem from the Bergkelder or &bquo;mountain cellars&equo; of Stellenbosch.  
 BARWELL &amp; JONES 184 
 Whisky 
 SUPER-premium Canadian whisky, Canadian Classic, is the only 12-year-old Canadian whisky available in the UK and is now distributed here by URM Agencies.  
 URM AGENCIES 185 
 Vintage red 
 MIGUEL Torres has released the 1988 vintage of his best-selling red wine, Coronas, in a Bordeaux-style bottle. 
 The wine, which is 85% Tempranillo and 15% Cabernet Sauvignon, is available in England and Wales from H. Sichel &amp; Sons.  
 H. SICHEL &amp; SONS 186 
 Vodka 
 ABSOLUT vodka, the third largest selling vodka and the 17th biggest-selling spirit brand worldwide, was imported to the UK last month, marketed by Rivalage. 
 Absolut is now available in the European standard 70cl bottle size, initially only at selected bars and restaurants.  
 RIVALAGE 187 
 Wine category rejig 
 DEINHARD is creating a new identity for wines from the three main wine growing areas of Germany. 
 Deinhard owns properties in the Moselle, Rheingau and the Rheinpfalz regions and, in a move to clarify wine classification, all its estate wines will now fall into two categories. 
 The Wegeler-Deinhard Vineyard Selection includes Bernkasteler Doktor Riesling Sp&auml;tlese from Moselle-Saar-Ruwer and Forster Ungeheuer Riesling Kabinett and Sp&auml;tlese from Rheinpfalz. 
 The Deinhard Estate Selection includes Wegeler-Deinhard Riesling Kabinett and Sp&auml;tlese, from Moselle-Saar-Ruwer, and Wegeler-Deinhard Riesling, Kabinett and Sp&auml;tlese, from Rheinpfalz.  
 TWO styles of hand-made port glasses, designed by Austrian Georg Riedel, are now available in the UK. 
 The tawny glass is slightly less tapered than the vintage glass (above) to emphasise the perfumes of wood-aged port. 
 Each holds about 8.8fl oz and is available from Michael Johnson Ceramics, London. 
 Academy course 
 THE Academy of Wine Service has introduced a course designed to update senior managers, sommeliers and waiters on recent developments, innovations and service skills in wine. 
 The course covers customers' expectations and needs, wine and food combinations, use of the wine list, displays and liqueur trolleys. 
 Call 081&ndash;809 4671 for further details. 
 Europa 
 EUROPA Wines UK, Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire, has been appointed sole UK distributor and importer of wines for the Kiskorosh Allami Gazdasag Vineyards, Hungary. 
 Wines available now include Ausbruch Red; dry and medium Chardonnay; Muscat Ottonel; and Blue Frankish. 
 Sole agent 
 CANTINE MezzaCorona, a wine producer in the Italian Trentino region, has announced the appointment of Ebury Mathiot Wines as sole UK agent. 
 The brand covers a large number of DOC vineyards. 
 St James' awards 
 MORE than 300 Whitbread Inns are competing for the Grants of St James' Wine Awards. 
 Success in the exclusive competition for Whitbread's managed house company will depend upon sales success with wine, evidence of good merchandising strategies, product knowledge, staff training and enthusiasm for wine. 
 The first phase of the competition runs until 12 October. 
 Pol Roger 
 POL Roger has been appointed UK agent for Pipers Brook Vineyard, Tasmania. 
 The first consignment of wines is now en route to London.  
 CUTLERY 
 Polish up on cutlery 
 Cutting through technical jargon makes cutlery purchasing no easy task. 
 Bob Gledhill outlines how to recognise and maintain quality cutlery without forking out a fortune 
 CUTLERY sales are an unlikely but accurate indicator of the trading state of the catering industry. 
 Increased sales of complete sets indicate new openings, low sales a stagnant market. 
 Top-up orders indicate the restaurant is going to have to make do with existing equipment until trade picks up enough to pay for a complete replacement. 
 There is even a seasonal indicator which occurs at this time of year. 
 This is the start of the heavy banqueting season, leading up to Christmas, which should be a busy period for a lot of hotel restaurants. 
 It is no time to run out of knives and forks, so cutlery sales should be buoyant about now. 
 But companies are reporting that orders are still down on last year, with no sign from the catering industry that it is in a position to re-equip the dining room. 
 &bquo;I honestly think there is no sign of things getting better. 
 The recession in the catering industry is not bottoming out,&equo; warns W. Lancaster managing director John Emanuel. 
 &bquo;It would be ignoring the reality of the current trading position if I said I didn't believe there were more closures to come. 
 I don't think the upswing will start before spring next year.&equo; 
 The Direct Tableware Company sales director Roger Young agrees that it will be next spring before any real growth in catering occurs, but he thinks there might be a slight upturn next month in the top-up business: &bquo;It's heading for the busy time and you can't serve customers without knives and forks.&equo; 
 The most contentious issue among cutlery suppliers is that of quality. 
 Some argue that cheap imports are a waste of money &mdash; others say widely differing prices are being charged for exactly the same product and that suppliers which criticise imported cutlery often stock it themselves. 
 Couple this with a quality assessment system which is riddled with jargon and technical description and the caterer has a hard time deciding what he or she is going to buy and from which company. 
 The decision is not made easier by constant criticism by importers and suppliers of each other. 
 There is a habit of running down the competition rather than extolling the virtues of their own ranges. 
 Catering cutlery comes in two types of metal &mdash; stainless steel and silver-plate. 
 Within those two broad areas are multiple variations. 
 Stainless steel cutlery is a mix of steel (itself a substance of variable quality), chromium and nickel. 
 The chromium and nickel are added to give shine and prevent rusting. 
 The amount of chromium and nickel added is indicated with a number, which should be part of the description of cutlery in any sales literature. 
 Sometimes it is stamped on the piece. 
 It is impossible to judge the value of cutlery without knowing the alloy content. 
 The number is divided by a diagonal stroke. 
 The figure in front of the diagonal is the percentage of chromium content, the number after indicates the percentage of nickel. 
 The three most popular mixes in catering are 18/10, which is the most expensive, 18/8 and 13/0. 
 This last alloy is the cheapest and is the material that most vexes suppliers. 
 Arthur Price chairman John Price says: &bquo;13/0 certainly looks as bright and as cheerful as 18/8 but after it has been in use for a short while it goes dull and then grey and, after a year or so, stains and pitmarks develop which cannot be removed.&equo;  
 Quality cutlery has a smooth finish, like this silver-plated look from Viners 
 But Emanuel of W. Lancaster dismisses this as nonsense. 
 &bquo;We have customers who have been using the same set for more than 20 years,&equo; he says. 
 Director of Edinburgh-based MacGregor and Company, Charles Cavaye, argues that because there is no nickel content in 13/0, there is no strength: &bquo;Hence the bent knife or the fork with prongs at odd angles. 
 Replacements will be needed within a few weeks.&equo; 
 Senior research metallurgist for the Cutlery and Allied Trade Research Association, Alan Medlock, says that it depends on what you call 13/0. 
 &bquo;These numbers are just broad descriptions. 
 There are many variations within these categories. 
 It is about personal experience of particular brands as much as looking for the numbers. 
 &bquo;I've examined some 13/0 and it has been good, yet I've found some to have as low as 10.5% chrome content. 
 That will rust. 
 It's the same with 18/8. 
 It isn't a standard product.&equo; 
 He also says that the nickel content does not, for all practical purposes, make any difference to the hardness, but that it does make it more stain resistant. 
 So if the numbers are not an infallible guide to good stainless steel cutlery, what is? 
 Medlock gives the following advice: &bquo;Examine the finish very carefully, particularly the forks. 
 That is a good guide. 
 Poor cutlery will have tiny burrs inside the fork prongs where it has been stamped out of the sheet of metal. 
 &bquo;Feel the weight and look at the thickness, that is a good clue to how strong it will be. 
 That's what causes knives and forks to bend, not the metal itself.&equo; 
 When it comes to silver-plated cutlery there are just as many confusing statements coming at the caterer. 
 The base on to which the silver is electroplated is a mix of nickel, copper and zinc, called nickel silver, although there is no silver in the alloy. 
 When it is electro-plated with silver it is called electro-plated nickel silver (EPNS). 
 The production price and toughness of the cutlery depends on the proportions in which the metals are mixed. 
 The most common way of cheapening the cost is to reduce the amount of nickel, which is the most expensive of the three metals in EPNS.  
 W. Lancaster's 13/0 stainless steel cutlery: some customers have used the same set for 20 years 
 There is the obvious price dodge of skimping on the thickness of silver, measured by cutlers in microns &mdash; which can be anything from one to 50. 
 The British Standards Institute (BSI) specifies a thickness of 30 microns for hotel use. 
 It is doubtful anything less than 20 microns of thickness would withstand the sustained use cutlery receives in the catering industry. 
 Price recommends all caterers to not only determine the micron thickness when looking at silver-plated cutlery, but also to ask for this to be specified on the invoice. 
 Since topping up, rather than full replacement, is the favoured option for caterers, the first worry is matching up. 
 There are surprisingly few popular patterns of cutlery &mdash; most caterers use the historic patterns devised in Sheffield. 
 The fact that a wide number of manufacturers work to the same pattern means that the caterer who is topping up need not return to the same source for the top-up. 
 Identify a selection of cutlery distributors, send them one of your pieces of cutlery and ask them to match it and send their sample and yours back. 
 There will be some differences, but they may be too slight to be noticed by the customers, who would normally see only one piece of each item in any case. 
 Shopping around for a top-up will allow the best price while still keeping the cutlery service in the same style. 
 One way of putting off the day of replacement is to take more care of existing cutlery. 
 Although it is robust, there are some basic cleaning rules for both stainless and silver-plated. 
 While stainless is tough and harder to scratch in the first place, once it does become marked the scratch is permanent, unlike a mark on silver-plated cutlery which can be removed by re-plating. 
 Stainless steel is also attacked by the cleaning fluids intended for silver-plated cutlery and by immersion for long periods in vinegary solutions, particularly if the vinegar has salt with it, as in the case of pickles. 
 It can also become pitted if it is left soaking overnight. 
 It is worth ensuring that kitchen staff are not tempted to leave the dirty cutlery soaking until morning. 
 Similarly, stainless steel cutlery should not be left overnight in dishwashers. 
 The intense heat of being held over a gas jet will cause immediate and permanent discolouring. 
 The everyday food stains that come from things like tea and coffee can be easily removed with fine grit polishes such as Autosol compound, usually found in car accessory shops, or any cleaning fluid designed to clean stainless steel sinks and work surfaces. 
 The cleaner should be tested on a few pieces to ensure its suitability. 
 The most common mistake with these cleaners is to be too heavy-handed, which can faintly score the surface, or to rub blades and spoon bowls in an irregular pattern and therefore cause unsightly marks. 
 With silver-plated cutlery, part of its appeal is the scratches it gets in the early period of its life. 
 This gives it a whitish sparkle as light catches millions of tiny prisms and reflects white light. 
 Tarnishing on silver-plated cutlery occurs through exposure to sulphides. 
 These are air-borne and are also present in some foods, most notably in eggs. 
 The most common method of cleaning tarnished silver-plated cutlery is to use specially formulated cleaning fluids in which the cutlery is immersed. 
 It is important to follow the manufacturer's instructions on the dilutions and immersion times to avoid damage. 
 Larger hotels may have a ball-burnisher, which is a rotating drum containing tiny ball-bearings, water and a corrosion inhibitor. 
 This brightens and hardens the surface of cutlery so it becomes more resistant to wear and it also removes minor scratches. 
 Ensure that cutlery which has been cleaned using chemicals gets a thorough washing before going back into the dining room. 
 When buying cutlery, don't buy more pieces than you need. 
 The old rule was to purchase 25% more than your restaurant can seat. 
 Cavaye of MacGregor and Company says that stock levels should reflect business and the demand for the kind of food being served. 
 Cavaye recommends that caterers buy an extra 10% to 15% more than the number of covers on main items like knives, forks and spoons, double the number for teaspoons and a little over half for fish knives. 
 Emanuel says he is surprised at the number of caterers who are unsure of the amount of cutlery to buy. 
 &bquo;Most think they need far more than they actually do. 
 &bquo;We talk to them about the style of service and food they are planning and the figure we recommend is often less than they had estimated,&equo; he says. 
 The factor that governs all cutlery sales is its cost and Young of The Direct Tableware Company warns that big Korean manufacturers are increasing the minimum orders from importers. 
 At least some of the extra cost of stockholding is likely to be passed on to the caterer. 
 Imported cutlery is also bought in American dollars and, while the exchange rate of sterling to the dollar was very favourable for Britain last year, it has dropped considerably in the past six months, making imported cutlery more expensive to buy. 
 Young thinks those who are looking to save money now and buy cutlery next year will end up paying more.   
 Poor quality cutlery can be spotted by its rough finish 
 PASTA 
 Taking SHAPE 
 Carmen Konopka highlights the variety and versatility of pasta as an ingredient 
 PASTA originated as a filling, economical and quick-to-make food. 
 Although it is associated with Italy, similar peasant foods are found in many parts of the world &mdash; from noodles in China to pierogi, the ravioli-like dish, from Poland. 
 Like so many peasant foods, the essence of pasta is its simplicity. 
 Its basic ingredients are flour and water, sometimes with the addition of eggs or oil, occasionally with spinach, tomato or colourings. 
 Yet very few British caterers attempt to make pasta themselves, possibly because of the enormous diversity of ready-made pasta available on the UK market. 
 As the table on page 88 shows, there is a huge choice of pasta as an ingredient. 
 For many years caterers could obtain only dried pasta. 
 But since the early 1980s, chilled fresh pasta has also been on the market, from large and small suppliers operating on both national and regional bases. 
 In the past five or six years, foodservice companies have also been able to supply frozen pasta. 
 John Bray, senior brand manager for Nestl&eacute; Foodservice, which supplies both dried and frozen pasta, is keen to dispel any thought that one type of pasta is better or worse than another. 
 But he emphasises that chilled and frozen pastas are different from dried pastas and need different sauces. 
 &bquo;Dried pasta is the best possible for straight and simple shapes,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;It has a firmer texture and goes well with the heavier sauces. 
 &bquo;If you want &bquo;al dente&equo; spaghetti, you really need dried spaghetti, made with good quality durum wheat and no egg. 
 &bquo;Some dried pastas do contain egg, which makes the pasta softer. 
 These originated in Northern Italy, where the pasta is traditionally flat and where they use a lot more egg and cream in their cooking. 
 &bquo;But if you put an egg tagliatelle with a heavy rago&ucirc;t, you lose all the benefits of the pasta. 
 &bquo;Frozen and chilled pasta comes into its own when you are talking about filled pasta, especially individually quick-frozen products. 
 &bquo;Generally frozen pasta has whole egg in it, giving it a softer, smoother texture which goes well with cream and lighter tasting sauces.&equo; 
 Bray adds that frozen pasta with good quality fillings is especially useful to caterers because it can be made up quickly into either single- or multi-portion dishes without waste. 
 One example is Nestl&eacute;'s Buitoni Beef Cannelloni, which has a ratio of 72% filling to 28% pasta.  
 The shape of things to come &mdash; McDougalls Catering Foods' Caribbean Chicken, Sunshine Lasagne and Veggi Surprise 
 Frozen pasta rarely has to be defrosted before use. 
 It is ideal for mix-and-match menus where, for example, five pastas are offered with five sauces for customers to combine as they wish. 
 The growing demand for pasta in the UK is illustrated both by the increasing number of specialised pasta outlets and by the growing menu presence of pasta in pizza restaurants, according to Master Foods, which markets the Dolmio brand of frozen pastas and sauces. 
 The company believes future growth for pasta will come from mid-market, non-specialist outlets, such as those in the travel and pub sectors. 
 Master Foods sector development manager Kathryn Bowler says: &bquo;Pasta is one of the fastest expanding areas of the UK's catering market and there is plenty of potential for further growth. 
 &bquo;According to the latest Euromonitor report on the international pasta market, each British consumer eats 3.3kg of pasta a year. 
 This still leaves Britain way down on the pasta-eating league. 
 &bquo;West German consumers eat 4.7kg a year, the French 6.4kg and the Italians 27.4kg. 
 In fact, only Japan lags behind us.&equo; 
 Like potatoes and bread, pasta is no longer regarded as fattening. 
 It is now established as a healthy food, with popular appeal for the ever-growing numbers of health-conscious diners. 
 As supplier The Pasta Company points out, pasta has a surprisingly low calorie count &mdash; just 140 calories per 100g. 
 Pasta contains complex carbohydrates so takes time to be digested. 
 It is often eaten by athletes who require gradually released energy for long distance events. 
 It is also low in fact and high in fibre. 
 Well known pastas such as spaghetti and lasagne are still the best-selling products. 
 However, according to many suppliers, pasta shapes are rapidly increasing in popularity. 
 As a result, McDougalls has introduced Tricolour Mixed Shells, Spirals and Animals &mdash; with the latter being aimed at caterers producing children's meals. 
 &bquo;Shapes, such as shells, twists and bows, are the fastest growing sector of the pasta market,&equo; says Teresa Cooke, product manager for the Knorr Collezione Italiana range from the Caterplan Division of CPC (UK). 
 The company has just added Flute Penne &mdash; ridged tubes which are ideal for trapping sauces &mdash; and Conchiglie Tricolore (shells) to its range. 
 Sauces cling more easily to complex-shaped pasta. 
 For this reason, some of the pasta shapes from Valerio's Olympia Group are produced with brass extruders. 
 This, according to the company, gives the pasta a home-made look and a porosity which allows better sauce absorption. 
 Some shapes also have internal ridging, which aids uniform cooking. 
 Egg pasta is another growth area identified by Caterplan. 
 The company has recently launched three varieties &mdash; Tagliatelle All' Uovo in plain and green versions and Oven Ready Lasagne All' Uovo.   
 The essence of pasta is its simplicity 
 Cooke says: &bquo;Egg pasta is certainly preferred by many chefs not only because of its excellent colour and flavour, but because it offers them the possibility of upgrading their pasta menus, thus increasing their profits.&equo; 
 ItalBrokers managing director Carlo Gambuzzi adds: &bquo;Egg pasta is more enjoyable to the palate than other pastas and remains better al dente. 
 In fact, in the mature Italian dried pasta market it is the only sector showing a substantial increase.&equo; 
 Two brands of dried pasta are marketed by ItalBrokers &mdash; Ferrari and Dallari, both of which are made with flour and eggs only. 
 The traditional Emilian recipe does not add water. 
 By contrast, the Federici range of dried pasta from Princes Catering Products emphasises the special water &mdash; from the famous Sangemini Springs &mdash; used in its manufacture. 
 The Pasta Factory, with 104 varieties of fresh and frozen pasta, specialises in designer pasta. 
 Recent launches include Ravioli with Radicchio, Ravioli with Saffron Orange Peel and Ricotta, and Black Pasta. 
 Unusual fresh and frozen pastas are also available from The Pasta Company. 
 As well as offering 21 standard items, the company makes specialist pastas for customers and has more than 500 specialist lines. 
 Dried pastas have a shelf-life in excess of a year and frozen pastas also have a long shelf-life under proper conditions. 
 And many companies have developed packaging to prolong the shelf-life of chilled, fresh pasta. 
 The Bertagni fresh pasta from Fine Italian Foods comes in controlled atmosphere packaging which, the company says, retains the texture of the pasta and prevents it from sticking together. 
 Alibert fresh pasta from Olga Catering is also in special packaging, which is said to give it a guaranteed shelf-life of 60 days. 
 Some pasta dishes, such as macaroni cheese and lasagne, have become British institutions in their own right. 
 But nearly half of all the pasta eaten in Britain is the canned variety, which often owes little to its Italian ancestry. 
 However, the more authentically Italian types of pasta are rapidly gaining ground and look set to continue in popularity. 
 According to Bray, only wholemeal pasta has been unsuccessful. 
 &bquo;It was talked about a lot, but never really came to fruition. 
 There is still a place for it, mainly in institutional catering, but most people think it tastes like cardboard.&equo; 
 For most of us, traditional Italian pastas are sufficiently healthy without imposing extra-healthy ingredients on them. 
 The conclusion has to be cook, eat, enjoy &mdash; and profit. 
 TOP 10 SELLERS 
 THERE are more than 200 pasta shapes, with more than 600 names for these shapes. 
 The following list, in order of popularity, has been compiled from suppliers' five best-selling pastas. 
 Spaghetti &mdash; sometimes also called spaghettini or spaghettoni. 
 Lasagne &mdash; most suppliers mentioned that the oven-ready varieties are most popular. 
 Green and uncoloured varieties were both nominated. 
 Fusilli &mdash; also often described as spirals or twists. 
 Maccheroni &mdash; better known as marcaroni. 
 Tortellini &mdash; these stuffed pasta shapes are also called tortelloni and tortelli. 
 Tagliatelle &mdash; both the green and uncoloured versions of this ribbon-shaped pasta. 
 Conchiglie &mdash; often called shells. 
 Penne &mdash; often sold under the English name quills. 
 Fettuccine &mdash; similar to tagliatelle. 
 Cappellitti &mdash; shaped like peaked hats and stuffed. 
 Other pastas suppliers say are popular include gnocchi, cannelloni, garganelli, torchietti, and frappe.  
 The seven varieties in the Country Range from Countrywide 
 Dolmio's Salmon Tortelloni from Master Foods 
 WHAT'S NEW 
 Leaked document not strong enough 
 by Linda Petit 
 AN EC working document on food hygiene, leaked before it had reached its consultation form, is already being criticised, for being too weak. 
 Institution of Environmental Health under-secretary, Linda Alan, said that the document was not strong enough, adding: &bquo;It leaves so much open to interpretation.&equo; 
 She said that the aim of the directive was to harmonise the hygiene practices of all the member states, and it was up to each country to interpret the directive. 
 &bquo;We would hope that in consultation it would be tightened up, but the EC might prefer it in its general form,&equo; she said. 
 The proposed EC directive, which is expected to be released for consultation by the end of the year, would affect all food business operators in Europe, including manufacturers, distributors and retailers. 
 The document stated that all food premises must &bquo;ensure that adequate safety procedures are identified, maintained and reviewed&equo;. 
 The directive included advisory regulations concerning building requirements, kitchen equipment, food waste, water supply, personal hygiene and production hygiene, but is not specific about those regulations or their implementation. 
 Deputy manager of communication services at the Hotel, Catering &amp; Institutional Management Association, Tim Knowles, said that although he welcomed the directive, it still needed a lot of work in its present form. 
 He particularly criticised the terminology in the document which he described as &bquo;woolly&equo;. 
 An example of this is when it refers to &bquo;food business operators&equo; which, according to Mr Knowles, is unspecific and far too general a definition. 
 Mr Knowles suggested the definition include the words &bquo;hotel and catering industry&equo; to avoid outlets in member countries finding a possible loophole. 
 He also criticised the reference to critical control points under which it said that: &bquo;Food business operators shall identify any process undertaken which may be critical to ensuring food safety and ensure that adequate safety procedures are identified, maintained and reviewed.&equo; 
 Critical control points were described by Mr Knowles as being &bquo;wholly inappropriate&equo; to the catering industry, which by its nature is not highly systemised. 
 Regarding training, the document said that food business operators must ensure that food handlers are fully trained or supervised commensurate with their work activity. 
 &bquo;All food handlers should be trained, not just supervised, there should be the linkage between supervisors,&equo; Mr Knowles said. 
 Former chief environmental health officer with the City of Westminster, Robert Crozier, said that there were no surprises in the document as much of the legislation was already covered in the Food Safety Act. 
 Mr Crozier said that although the UK was more advanced in hygiene than most other member states, the document was still &bquo;a step in the right direction for Europe&equo;. 
 Fast Food Fair set for success 
 THE 1991 Fast Food Fair will take place in Brighton, East Sussex, from 11&ndash;14 November. 
 This year it promises to be as big as ever, with 90% of stands space already booked. 
 The fair is being sponsored by Catering Update  in association with Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper . 
 It already has support from companies such as Nestl&eacute; Foodservice, Kraft General Food Service, and Lyons Tetley. 
 The show will host such events as the product awards for the best innovations and introductions. 
 The awards, sponsored by Catering Update , are designed to encourage new ideas throughout the industry. 
 They are divided into three categories: Quality Product of the Year, Newcomer of the Year and Equipment Innovation of the Year. 
 Entry forms are available from Reed Exhibitions. 
 Entries for the awards close at the beginning of October. 
 A series of forums for visitors and exhibitors will also be running, addressing such issues as training and management in the snack industry, trends in pizza and pasta marketing, and the potential profit of themed food and desserts. 
 If you would like further information on the show, contact the Fast Food Fair ticket hotline and registering service on 091 416 4570. 
 FLANAGAN MOVES 
 ROGER Flanagan, former sales and marketing director for equipment supplier Masters &amp; Andren, has left the company to concentrate on his own consultancy GP Consultants. 
 Together with design consultant Jackie Snaith and managing director Helen Flanagan, he will offer advice on all aspects of foodservice, including kitchen design and training. 
 Mr Flanagan said that with more choice from Europe, European legislation and the Food Safety Act, &bquo;people now want someone to look over their shoulders&equo;. 
 Telephone 0883 653345 for further details. 
 BODFARI DEAL 
 FOOD manufacturer Northern Foods has bought Bodfari Foods in a deal worth &pound;20.7m. 
 A further &pound;5.2m may be payable depending on the company's future performance. 
 Bodfari Foods is a processor and supplier of liquid milk. 
 Last year the company saw pre-tax profits of &pound;1.9m. 
 JUS-ROL INVESTS 
 POTATO product manufacturer Jus-Rol has invested &pound;1.5m in its potato manufacturing plant at Amble, Northumberland. 
 By the end of this month manufacturing capacity is expected to increase three-fold as a result, according to sales and marketing director Joe Weston. 
 IDEAL CHANGE 
 CATERING butcher Ideal Meat Supplies has moved from its Smithfield Market site to premises in North London. 
 The company has also achieved a grade A accreditation from the plant evaluation committee of the National Association of Catering Butchers.  
 FOOD 
 Vitalite spread 
 VITALITE Light is a sunflower oil spread which is said to be high in polyunsaturated fat, and low in saturated fat and cholesterol. 
 It is packaged in 2kg tubs and can be spread straight from the fridge.  
 Orient Express dessert from Kaysens 
 Eastern dessert 
 ORIENT Express is an Oriental-style dessert designed to complement Eastern cuisine. 
 The g&acirc;teau is made with moist sponge layered with sweetened red bean paste, ginger jam and lychee-flavoured cream. 
 The top and sides are sprinkled with toasted nuts and sesame seeds and it is finished with orange jelly slices and raspberry jam. 
 Orient Express comes frozen and takes between 15 and 30 minutes to defrost. 
 Ring doughnuts 
 AMERICAN ring doughnuts from The Delicious Donut Co are made from a flour which is said to give them a light, fluffy, and non-greasy consistency. 
 The doughnuts cost less than 20p each and are available in Sweet Cinnamon, Sugar &amp; Spice, White Delight and Choc-on-Top varieties. 
 Iced yogurt 
 DAIRY Crest has joined forces with Taylor Freezer to produce an iced yogurt, Piccolo, which can be stored in ambient conditions, and a soft-serve machine from which to serve it. 
 Two 2.5-litre tubs of yogurt cost &pound;11 and are available in chocolate, vanilla, peach Melba, lemon and strawberry flavours. 
 The yogurt keeps for six months in ambient conditions or two weeks &mdash; once opened &mdash; in a refrigerator. 
 The serving machines are available in a selection of sizes and can be leased or purchased. 
 Wafer cups 
 TULIP wafer cups can hold a single scoop of ice cream or desserts such as fruit and cream. 
 They are made from wafer biscuits and cost &pound;10.80 for a box of 120. 
 Sauce revival 
 G. COSTA has revived an 18th-century recipe, known as Harvey's sauce. 
 Harvey's sauce tastes similar to Worcester sauce and comes in 170ml bottles. 
 Potato flavours 
 DE-ANNE offers garlic &amp; herb, onion Proven&ccedil;ale, smoky bacon and cheese-flavoured potato powders. 
 The powders can be reconstituted with water and shaped to produce flavoured French fries. 
 The fries, made through a counter-top machine, can then be deep-fried before serving. 
 Boneless turkey 
 SMOKED Turkey Crown and Turkey Loaf are available in either smoked or unsmoked varieties. 
 The boneless turkey crown is packaged in 4kg sections and can be machine sliced. 
 Coffee creamer 
 COFFEE Rich is a frozen non-dairy creamer which can be used for whitening coffee or creaming sauces. 
 It is Kosher-approved and is available in half-ounce portions, 500g servings and 1kg cartons. 
 French p&acirc;t&eacute; 
 ROLAND Monterrat traditional French p&acirc;t&eacute;-en-cro&ucirc;te, is being distributed in the UK through Leatham's Larder. 
 The range includes salmon p&acirc;t&eacute;-en-cro&ucirc;te as well as more unusual varieties of p&acirc;t&eacute; with ingredients such as pistachio, morels, shrimp, or hazelnuts.   
 Following material is from a magazine insert 
 Chef  SEPTEMBER 1991 
 MUSTARD: Hot stuff  
 Welsh wizardry 
 Bernard Loiseau 
 WHAT constitutes value for money when it comes to food and drink? 
 This is something that the British harp on that incessantly, using it as the main reason for choosing one restaurant over another, but do we really understand what it means and are we consistent in our assessment of perceived value? 
 During a recession, the public cannot be blamed for watching pennies in the hope that pounds won't disappear quite so quickly, but most Britons eat to live rather than living to eat, no matter how the economy is doing. 
 So, has the &bquo;brasserie boom&equo; brought about good value in restaurants and, if so, is this recognised by the public? 
 On the one hand the multiplication of good brasseries in recent months has been a breath of fresh air to the restaurant industry, and the public has shown its appreciation by packing them full every night. 
 But, unfortunately, there are also restaurants cashing in on the brasserie bandwagon by serving cheap, cheerful and desperately trendy bistro food in designer surroundings &mdash; and charging the earth for it. 
 How many customers realise that the food cost of one portion of pasta with olive oil and sun-dried tomatoes is only about 25p? 
 It was not unusual in more buoyant times to see dishes like this on menus at &pound;5-plus. 
 But times have changed and chefs may not be able to get away with overcharging for simple dishes using relatively inexpensive ingredients for much longer&hellip; or perhaps they will. 
 And what about drink? 
 Generations of British people have been happily walking into pubs for years and drinking alcohol that they could buy for a fraction of the price in a supermarket or off-licence. 
 Perhaps we're not so bothered about value for money after all. 
 Or at least, not always.   
 NEWS 
 Head chef at Ken Lo's Memories of China restaurant in London, Kam Po, is visiting the St Martin's Hotel, Isles of Scilly, from 6&ndash;9 September for a special Chinese gourmet weekend. 
 Po will prepare banquets on both Saturday and Sunday and will demonstrate vegetable chopping, drawing noodles by hand, and give away the &bquo;secret&equo; ingredients of crispy seaweed. 
 The gourmet weekend, including helicopter flight from Penzance and three-night break, costs &pound;320. 
 Patrick Emmanuel, head chef at the Half Moon Bay Hotel, Antigua, will be guest chef at the Caf&eacute; Mediterran&eacute;e of London's James' Court Hotel from 16&ndash;27 September, as winner of a culinary competition organised by the recently formed Antigua Chefs' Association. 
 He and two other award-winning chefs from Trinidad and St Lucia will be cooking at the hotel during Caribbean Food Festival. 
 Dishes on offer will include one of Emmanuel's specialities &mdash; red and silver talipia fish &mdash; and other Caribbean fish, fruit and vegetables. 
 Twenty-two-year old Geoffrey Bone, demi-chef de partie at the London Hilton on Park Lane, has won the Hilton Young Chef of the Year competition. 
 His British menu of Welsh Cheddar souffl&eacute;, English gammon platter, and baked fruit in puff pastry with caramel sauce was judged to be the best overall of the six menus prepared by finalists in London last month. 
 David Land of the Bristol Hilton won the prize for best starter with his Cornish lobster poached in its shell, infused with dill, lemon and thyme and topped with a soft cheese sauce. 
 While Kirdoff of the Langham Hilton in London won the prize for the best entr&eacute;e &mdash; roast leg of Norfolk suckling pig with potato and leek rago&ucirc;t &mdash; and Elizabeth Drudge of the Hilton National in Portsmouth won the top dessert prize for her hot Banbury apple pie. 
 All the winning dishes are to be featured in a British menu for restaurants in the Hilton group which will be available in the autumn. 
 &bquo;We have achieved our two objectives &mdash; to encourage young chefs to look out for and use British ingredients in their recipes, and also to find a delicious selection of dishes to use in the British menu promotion later this year.&equo; 
 said Mary Curnock Cook. 
 UK marketing director of Food from Britain. 
 Food from Britain, the Meat and Livestock Commission, Milk Marketing Board and Express Foodservice sponsored the competition. 
 A celebration of the food and wines of Spain will take place at the Brasserie on the Park at The Park Lane Hotel, Piccadilly, London, between 16 and 29 September. 
 Dishes on offer will include alcachofas mimosa &mdash; artichokes with prawn, egg and mayonnaise; sopa de mariscos &mdash; fish soup with clams and mussels; lechon asado &mdash; roast baby pig with baked apples; and fricase de perdiz &mdash; partridge cooked with mushrooms and brandy. 
 A three-course dinner, inclusive of sherry on arrival, coffee, and liqueurs will be &pound;17.50. 
 Lunch is &pound;15.95. 
 Marjan Lesnik (above), maitre chef des cuisines at Claridge's, London, will be guest chef at the Regency Club in Los Angeles from 11&ndash;13 September. 
 He will be reproducing some of the classic English recipes from his Claridge's menus, including grouse pie, best end of lamb with mint and summer pudding. 
 A regular guest chef at the Provence restaurant in Lymington, Hampshire, is Christina Novelli, aged four-and-a-half, daughter of head chef Jean Christophe Novelli. 
 She is pictured with sous chef Mark Jordan whipping up a storm in the kitchen.  
 The Park Room restaurant of the Hyde Park Hotel has been voted Best Italian Restaurant in Britain by the Instituto Italiano Spumante Classico &mdash; a group of Italy's leading wine companies. 
 Adriano Paganini became head chef at the Park Room after training in Italy and France, with spells at the three- Michelin  starred Antica Osteria del Ponte in Milan, and under Paul Bocuse in France. 
 Paganini specialises in cucina Mediterranea &mdash; a fresh, health-conscious cuisine that features olive oil and herb-scented sauces instead of butter and cream; and which favours fish and vegetable dishes over red meats. 
 Tony May of San Domenico, New York, Mauro Vincenti of Rex in Los Angeles, and Pasquale Lavorato of Neuer Kaferkasten of Neu Isenburg, Germany, also received awards from the Italian institute. 
 Langan's Bistro in Paston Place, Brighton, has won the Perrier Best Restaurant of the Year Award. 
 Judges praised Langan's Bistro for a high standard of cooking, a wide selection of fresh vegetables, and its puddings. 
 Perrier invited consumers to nominate the restaurant they believed deserved the title of Best Restaurant of the Year in late 1990. 
 Paris House &mdash; the horse &mdash; recently won the Newbury Sales Sprint Trophy and prize money of &pound;100,000 for his owner. 
 Paris House &mdash; the restaurant &mdash; in Woburn, Bedfordshire, has been rather slack at lunchtimes lately, so owner of both, chef-proprietor Peter Chandler, has been free to visit the races and witness his horse's success. 
 &bquo;I know this is a bit of an unusual hobby for a restaurateur, but it's a little dream come true for me and I'm thrilled to bits,&equo; he says. 
 Paris House &mdash; the horse &mdash; is two years old and trained by Jack Berry at Cockeram, Lancashire, Chandler cautioned fellow chefs against betting on Paris House in the future, for fear that he could lose a lot of friends! 
 Paul Gayler, executive chef at the Rosewood Group's Lanesborough Hotel, Hyde Park Corner, London &mdash; due to open in early December &mdash; spent three weeks in Dallas last month researching other hotels in the group. 
 During his stay he cooked a five-course gala dinner for 150 at the Mansion on Turtle Creek with executive chef Dean Fearing. 
 The dinner included a mosaic of leek and shellfish with a tomato verjuice; a &bquo;nectar&equo; of mushrooms and pearl barley; salmon souffl&eacute; with cucumber and basil butter; roast duckling breast with clover honey and a saffron apple compote and iced Drambuie parfait with sour cherries. 
 Norbert Stening and Andreas Oehmiga from the Park Hotel, Seigen, Germany, joined the kitchen brigade at the Holiday Inn, Leeds, recently to celebrate 25 years of their town being twinned with Morley, near Leeds. 
 During their stay the chefs introduced Leeds gastronomes to such delights as doffeinsoabbe &mdash; a potato broth with sliced sausage &mdash; and scheankdong &mdash; prime ham served on black bread. 
 Later in the year, chefs from the Holiday Inn will visit Seigen to introduce British national and regional dishes to the Park Hotel. 
 Northampton College recently sent seven of its students on a two-week study programme to Aqui-Terme, Piedmont, Italy. 
 The students &mdash; John Frail, Michael Gayton, Jason Keeble, Dahlia Simpson, Penny Mitchell, Lisa Cotterill and Melanie Brown &mdash; who were accompanied by two Northampton College lecturers, cooked an English meal of beef in beer for Italian catering students and local dignitaries during their stay. 
 Students from Aqui-Terme will be returning the visit. 
 Claudio Notarbartolo beat three other national finalists to take the Masterchef 1991 title, sponsored by British Meat Catering Service and Dudson Brothers. 
 Notarbartolo cooked lamb cutlets with pimentos, wild mushrooms and a sharp shallot gravy to take first prize of a 40-piece Dudson china dinner service. 
 He is currently working at the Three Lions restaurant, Stuckton, Dorset. 
 Bookings are coming into the Academy of Culinary Arts for its course which begin this month. 
 &bquo;The chefs who have signed on are leading a new golden era of culinary craft,&equo; said Peter Taylor, associate director of the academy.  
 Paul Gayler (left) with Dean Fearing during his trip to Dallas 
 COLUMN 
 by Kate Smith 
 Kate Smith, joint proprietor of the Beetle and Wedge Inn with her husband, Richard, tries to define the skills of restaurant management as opposed to those or the chef 
 Chefs are very easy to identify because they actually make a statement via their food. 
 Cooking ability is tangible, therefore attention can be focused on chefs as personalities, and their food represents clear statements of their feelings and professionalism. 
 In contrast, the restaurant manager is far less easy to define. 
 I would argue that they are as charismatic as chefs and yet their skills are less tangible and harder to gauge. 
 Perhaps their essence is more difficult to grasp because they are perceived by customers in entirely different roles, depending on the customer &mdash; for example, as friend, wine expert or simple emissary of the kitchen. 
 Tact and diplomacy, knowledge and friendship define the great restaurant managers, just as a great chef is defined by his skills in producing superb food. 
 The kitchen's perception of the restaurant manager is also fragmented in that the kitchen expects that manager to feed back customer response. 
 So many chefs feel their restaurant managers fail to do this adequately. 
 Similarly, a good front-of-house manager can give the customer an insight and appreciation of the chef's ideas and foods. 
 Many guests visit restaurants with preconceived ideas of what they should eat. 
 Therefore the restaurant manager and other front-of-house staff must use their skill to talk enthusiastically and intelligently about the menu so that customers will appreciate what the chef is producing, and dare to be adventurous. 
 The restaurant manager can gain maximum exposure for the chef and enhance customers' enjoyment of the food. 
 On return visits, they will take advice readily and gain better knowledge of the kitchen. 
 The wine cellar presents a similar opportunity. 
 A good sommelier or restaurant manager can persuade the customer to choose a super bottle of wine which offers marvellous value and drinks perfectly, rather than just a grand name in a superlative vintage which, inevitably, will have a premium attached to it. 
 The restaurant manager should also anticipate problems in the kitchen or front of house and prevent any &bquo;ripples&equo; getting through to the customer. 
 The ability to produce flowers at the drop of a hat or a cake to celebrate a customer's birthday should all be at his or her fingertips. 
 Dealing with the guest who is in a delicate business situation or just a very bad mood all goes with the territory. 
 The Acad&eacute;mie Culinaire Meilleur Ouvrier de Grande Bretagne for service is exacting in its technical requirements. 
 These are the only tangibles upon which an assessment of such a profession can be made. 
 Unfortunately, the equally essential but less tangible skills which make the difference between the ordinary and superlative restaurant manager can hardly be judged in the short period of a competition.  
 PROFILE 
 WELSH WIZARDRY 
 Life-long food lover Wendy Vaughan has finally become a noted professional cook in North Wales. 
 Lorna Pettipher reports 
 &bquo;The first thing I learned about nutrition as a nurse was that white food &mdash; fish and potatoes, for example &mdash; on white plates, with a white parsley sauce is unappetising purely because of its boring appearance. 
 It's good to gladden the eye with a dish full of colour.&equo; 
 Wendy Vaughan began cooking professionally six years ago at the Old Rectory in Llansanfraid, North Wales &mdash; the family home she converted to a small hotel with her husband Michael when he sold his motor parts company. 
 They answered an advertisement to cook lunches for visiting parties of Americans to North Wales and these developed into dinner business too. 
 When they joined Wolsey Lodges &mdash; a consortium of private houses offering overnight accommodation &mdash; their transformation to hoteliers had begun. 
 On the catering side, Wendy Vaughan is completely self-taught. 
 She dreamed of becoming a chef at school, but her domestic science teacher hated her and told her that she would never be a cook. 
 So Vaughan contented herself with training as a nurse and avidly reading food books in her spare time. 
 But the evil ravages of the British educational system at its worst were not enough to keep her away from her first love forever, and she started to cook with simplicity and a straightforward style which she has maintained. 
 &bquo;I derive my enjoyment of food from its colour, texture and the combination on the plate when I eat; so these are the things that I concentrate on when cooking for customers,&equo; she explains. 
 &bquo;I feel disadvantaged as a cook because I received no formal training and didn't go to college. 
 When people write nice things about my food it always sounds like they are referring to someone else&hellip;&equo;.  
 Wendy Vaughan at work in her North Wales kitchen 
 Clockwise from left: roulade of guinea fowl stuffed with duck on a cranberry and lime sauce; courgette and wild mushroom flan; marinated fresh trout with melon and red peppers 
 But write nice things they do. 
 The Old Rectory is County Restaurant of the Year for Gwynedd in this year's Good Food Guide , and Vaughan's fare on the no-choice, &pound;22-per-head menu is described as displaying much skill. 
 Her taste for light food has increased with age and so she cooks a lot with vegetables (which she also likes for their strong colours), although supplies of fresh produce are sometimes limited in North Wales. 
 They eventually reach her via the markets in Liverpool. 
 A starter of courgette and wild mushroom flan is made by cooking potatoes, leeks and courgettes until soft and then squeezing the puree dry. 
 She adds eggs, cream, or a little cr&egrave;me fraiche, and wild mushrooms cooked with shallots. 
 The mix is baked for 20 minutes in moulds and served with a vegetable cream sauce, lentils, and saut&eacute;ed mushrooms. 
 She sometimes puts slices of smoked guinea fowl around the edge to give added texture. 
 Vaughan's eyes light up when she describes the bright greens of this flan against the buttery yellow of the sauce. 
 She also becomes quite animated when talking about the excellent local supplies of fresh fish available to her. 
 &bquo;I pay cash on delivery for fish, which the fishermen like, so they always call on me first and we get super turbot, mussels, scallops, sole and plaice here.&equo; 
 Residents at the Old Rectory eat a set dinner every evening around one large, communal table. 
 Outside diners are given a choice of fish or meat main course when they book, and sit at smaller tables around the antique-filled dining room. 
 Vaughan cooks for a maximum of 16 people at any one meal. 
 Everything from the bread to the petit fours, is home-made and she has no help in the kitchen. 
 The fixed menu idea came from Michael Vaughan, who finally convinced his reluctant wife to stop offering a choice of four dishes at every dinner two years ago. 
 This system used to result in a great deal of food wastage. 
 Due to the small size of the Old Rectory and the communal style of dining, with Michael Vaughan serving, a lot of feedback comes from its diners and the vast majority do not feel the need for a choice of dishes at dinner. 
 One advantage of the no-choice system is that Vaughan can write her menu late in the afternoon, around the dishes that she feels like cooking on the day, with the best ingredients available to her. 
 No dinner menu at the old Rectory is exactly the same twice over. 
 &bquo;There is no uniform pattern or discipline to my cooking in this sense,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;So I wouldn't last five minutes in a &bquo;proper&equo; kitchen!&equo; 
 Fish is often served with spices and vegetable sauces to enhance colour and flavour. 
 The creation of her own with which she claims to be most impressed is a roulade of guinea fowl with limes and cranberries. 
 The roulade is stuffed with a layer of blanched spinach leaves and a farce of chicken, quail, duck or pheasant; then marinated in a mix of honey, oil, coriander and lemon juice to flavour the meat before roasting. 
 The remaining marinade forms the base of a red wine sauce with cranberries, redcurrants and slices of lime. 
 Katie's Game supplies duck, quail and guinea fowl, which it also bones for its customers. 
 Vaughan loves to cook, but finds it a punishing way to make a living: &bquo;People told me that there was no job harder than nursing,&equo; recalls Vaughan, &bquo;but they were wrong! 
 We close the Old Rectory just before Christmas every year and don't re-open until February. 
 That way we can keep smiling at our customers during the rest of the year. 
 But it is difficult to cook for people every day, especially when there are no other kitchen staff to cover.&equo; 
 Vaughan's dinner cooking usually begins just as her two sons return from school in the afternoon. 
 They attend Welsh language schools and Michael Vaughan has very strong roots in Wales, although Wendy Vaughan is originally from Derbyshire. 
 The Old Rectory is quite an isolated establishment and there is little local interest in her excellent food. 
 &bquo;Twenty years ago I would have liked to have been a cook elsewhere,&equo; she admits. 
 &bquo;I was offered a restaurant in Cheltenham about five years ago, but I didn't even consider it. 
 &bquo;My husband and my children are Welsh, and my guests here appreciate what I am doing. 
 But life is not just work. 
 If you look at it in shallow terms like that you are making a mistake. 
 I do what I do to the best of my ability and hope that people will hear about it and come and visit. 
 &bquo;In another location I would probably have a full dining room every night, but that is only a part of what is important to me. 
 I do not suffer from a lack of ambition, I simply accept life as it is.&equo; 
 Many an over-stressed big-city chef could benefit from Wendy Vaughan's well-balanced thoughts, even if time constraints and geography conspire to keep them away from her equally well-balanced food.  
 Above: fillet of turbot on spinach with chive and spiced sauces. 
 Left: lemon tart 
 CONTRACT CATERING 
 Corporate cooking 
 For many chefs contract catering is a more attractive option than its higher-profile restaurant and hotel cousins. 
 Lorna Pettipher reports 
 CONTRACT caterers are sick and tired of the industry-wide view of their sector as nothing but company canteens peopled by &bquo;Doris-the-dinner-lady&equo;. 
 Another clich&eacute; that persists is that chefs work in contract catering only to avoid long hours and the tough competition of hotel and restaurant kitchens. 
 In fact, the main attraction of contract catering is the diverse opportunities for career development. 
 Sadly, many feel that such opportunities are lacking within other areas of catering, and chefs often face discrimination when trying to move from the kitchens up into management. 
 &bquo;There are too many &bquo;I-am-the-greatest&equo; type people working in hotels,&equo; says Roger Cole, who worked in several five-star hotels before joining London contract caterer High Table in 1986. 
 He is now head chef at a leading law firm with 120 partners based in the City, and feels that he has found his niche. 
 &bquo;Earlier in my career I was working in hotel kitchens all the hours God sent, and the pay was very low. 
 Being married and having young children, the range of chef's hours available within contract catering was, of course, attractive; but the main incentives were the obvious routes by which I could move upwards on joining High Table.&equo; 
 Cole has worked at a variety of catering units run by High Table in his five years with the company and has now been promoted to executive chef. 
 He has a budget generous enough to allow creative cooking with the likes of caviar, fresh asparagus and smoked salmon at his contract, and also works within an environment that he finds friendly and relatively stress-free. 
 &bquo;I used to have the impression that I should feel almost privileged to work at certain big-name establishments when I saw the size of my pay packet, and I never used to know my general manager. 
 I know all the directors at High Table because corporate catering is free of the elitism found in hotels.&equo; 
 After three weeks at his new contract, Cole has not been home before 8.30 in the evening once, so the idea that all contract catering chefs work nine-to-five is a fallacy. 
 But there really is such a thing as overtime for long days. 
 He also keeps the same brigade for years at a time because staff turnover in contract catering is not as rapid as in hotels and restaurants. 
 Opportunities exist to push for new contracts within the same company, so individuals do not always have to leave for a new challenge. 
 Steve Butler joined Compass eight years ago. 
 His training began with Strand Hotels in 1974 and block-release courses at Ealing College. 
 After his apprenticeship, he started work for a contract catering company called Partners at the Royal Opera House in Covent Garden. 
 Within a year, he was cooking for the Royal Box and state galas. 
 He has stayed on the contract/corporate side of the fence ever since because he feels that it suits his style and temperament. 
 He is now executive chef at a large firm of West End financiers. 
 &bquo;I feel that, as chefs, we have the opportunity to provide a very personal service within this sector, and to become really involved with our clients,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;We do 60-hour weeks but there are no split shifts, and we are also committed to a team spirit because people are the main asset.&equo; 
 The menus change daily in the directors' dining rooms, delibars and staff canteens that he operates because the clientele does not. 
 Dishes on offer include saut&eacute;ed chicken with truffle and cream sauce; fish rag&ocirc;ut with saffron sauce; roast duck with ginger and thyme; and glazed venison with black cherry and Kirsch sauce. 
 On average, Butler and his staff cook for 800 people a day and all the chefs have an input when it comes to menu suggestions. 
 The catering manager at Butler's contract is Neil Patterson &mdash; a chef who joined Compass six years ago and has since moved across into management. 
 &bquo;Chef managers are quite common in this sector,&equo; he claims. 
 &bquo;An apprentice chef with us could be running a small unit after four years, budgets and all. 
 You are never far away from the decision-making in this kind of work, so you learn how to manage a whole range of areas and can be involved at a high level relatively quickly.&equo; 
 At the end of the year, the finance company employing Butler and Patterson moves to Docklands and will merge all its UK offices into one complex. 
 Butler and Patterson will then manage a team of 70 staff for a clientele of 1,500. 
 Ian Lawrence, a High Table head chef for a City bank, starts work at eight in the morning and finishes eight hours later. 
 He works on a food cost budget of &pound;5.50 per head for his top-floor staff restaurant, and &pound;6.50 per head in the director's private dining rooms. 
 High Tables does not make a profit on his management of the ingredients budget &mdash; it simply charges a management fee for the entire contract. 
 Lawrence trained in London hotels and then worked in a series of upmarket casino restaurants before leaving the West End four months ago. 
 &bquo;I run the kitchen just as I would run it in a hotel or restaurant,&equo; he says. 
 With his brigade of six, he turns out daily changing menus which include noisettes of lamb with herb mousse and lentils; penne pasta with sun-dried tomatoes, olives and oregano; and escalope of halibut with courgette ribbons. 
 All p&acirc;t&eacute;s, terrines and fruit jellies are made in-house, as Lawrence believes in training his staff in these skills. 
 &bquo;Food is secondary here,&equo; he admits quite openly. 
 &bquo;I can't serve anything that needs thinking about when people are meeting to discuss big money deals &mdash; all fish must be filleted here, for example &mdash; but all the food must be good.&equo; 
 He would like to open an informal, family-run restaurant in the country one day, so he can eventually imagine returning to the long hours of hotel and restaurant work. 
 But for the time being, with a young family at home, he is very happy to have switched to contract catering. 
 CHEF PAY SCALES BETWEEN SECTORS 
 ALL the contract catering chefs interviewed believed that their rates of pay were higher than if they were working in hotels or restaurants. 
 But Roderick Henderson, who runs the chef division of recruitment consultant Berkeley Scott, does not believe that contract catering is always a financially rewarding sector in which to work. 
 He estimates that an executive sous-chef working in a top London restaurant or hotel would be earning between &pound;25,000 and &pound;27,000, whereas a head chef in contract catering at a director's dining room, for example, would be doing very well to earn &pound;20,000. 
 Brian Watts, managing director of B. E. Services, the in-house caterer at the Bank of England, pays chefs between &pound;8,000 and &pound;17,000 per year, but the financial benefits of the bank's employee package (cheap mortgages and pensions, etc), bring this up to considerably more in real terms. 
 Also, these are the basic rates of pay for a basic 35-hour week, and generous overtime rates are paid for late-night and weekend work. 
 Watts has interviewed chefs who are working an average of 90 hours per week in the West End and earning about &pound;14,000. 
 Due to the high level of &bquo;burnout&equo; common in such chefs, few are offered jobs.  
 Ian Lawrence runs his kitchen just as he would a hotel 
 MUSTARD 
 Hot stuff 
 Britons play safe with herb mustards, but the French add roses and bananas, reports Michael Raffael 
 &bquo;ENGLISH mustard holds pride of place. 
 This is far from being an indication of cultural superiority, but is due to the fact that English manufacturers extract the essential oil through their milling process.&equo; 
 This quote comes from a standard work, Le Manuel du Moutardier , by Julia de Fontenelle. 
 The fact that it is over a hundred years old does not detract from its impact. 
 Just for once, a Frenchie has conceded that the Brits do something better. 
 The difference between the French and English approaches to making mustard, technology apart, has not changed for a century. 
 In France, mustard seeds are soaked and then ground to a paste. 
 On this side of the Channel, we mill them to obtain a flour. 
 But it's too simplistic to pretend that one way is better than the other because the comparison isn't between like and like. 
 There are three kinds of seed and it helps to know the Latin names: 
 &bull; 
 sinapsis alba  (white mustard); 
 &bull; 
 brassica juncea  (brown mustard); 
 &bull; 
 brassica nigra  (black mustard). 
 &bquo;Brown&equo; and &bquo;black&equo; are not easy to tell apart because they are both a reddish brown colour and similar in size. 
 &bquo;White&equo; seeds are paler, larger and milder. 
 Chinese markets sell the juncea leaves, usually by their Cantonese name pak choi. 
 They look like young spinach and can vary in taste from bland to quite pungent. 
 The leaves can be pickled in brine (sometimes with added hot Szechuan spices) and served with pork dishes. 
 The seeds alone, as anyone who has dabbled in Indian cookery knows, are not pungent. 
 They require the catalytic action of water to release hotness. 
 Crushed and wetted, a chemical reaction occurs between the enzyme myrosin and a glucoside, a sugar-related chemical, to create the essential oil of mustard. 
 The change takes place only with cold water, a point worth remembering when preparing English mustard from powder. 
 Use hot or warm water and it turns bitter and unpleasant.  
 Garlic, cloves, chives, tarragon, peppers and even nettles are among the many ingredients often combined with mustard 
 Colman's, which enjoys a virtual monopoly of mustard powder, is a mixture of juncea and alba with added wheat flour and turmeric. 
 The company markets a wheatless version that would appeal to chefs who want an unadulterated product. 
 One the flour and water are mixed to a paste, it takes about 10 minutes for the heat to develop. 
 After an hour or so the pungency diminishes. 
 Another curious attribute of the powder is that when cooked out it helps to extract other flavours while losing its own. 
 Old fashioned cooks used to rub it over beef before roasting. 
 Martin Blunos of Lettonie's in Bristol puts some in his cheese souffl&eacute; to point up the cheesiness. 
 Julia de Fontenelle did not approve of flour extenders: &bquo;Wheatflour,&equo; she wrote, &bquo;harms the quality of this condiment. 
 This is not the case with sugar, honey, grape must, cloves and other spices which increase its merit. 
 In Provence, anchovy is mixed in with it, which gives a very good taste.&equo; 
 Her view reflected a time when mustard was enjoying a vogue similar to that enjoyed by flavoured vinegars a few years ago. 
 In 1812 one manufacturer, Maille, had 84 varieties including garlic, lemon peel, yarrow, mushroom, truffle, six berry, chive, gherkin, shallot, olive and Champagne. 
 In France today, mustards may contain roses, lovage, banana or stinging nettles. 
 The basic Dijon process can admit plenty of variations. 
 The method of preparation is to macerate the juncea or nigra seeds in a vinegar or verjuice solution until they have swollen. 
 Then they are stoneground or mechanically milled and sieved. 
 The resultant paste is cask-conditions for a few days before bottling. 
 A vinaigre d'alcool will give a different taste from a vinaigre de vin vieux. 
 A cheap industrial vinegar may be less pleasing. 
 Heat-treated mustard loses some of its pungency. 
 And the word &bquo;forte&equo; on a label is an indication of strength &mdash; usually enough to get up one's nose! 
 Dijon mustards are flavoured with spices. 
 Some have added sugar. 
 Some are more salty. 
 The colour and the texture can also vary from yellow to brown. 
 Some contain antioxidants (preservatives), potassium pyrosulphite or sulphur dioxide. 
 By far the most widespread brand, Amora, is strong tasting and useful for vinaigrettes and in some sauces. 
 But Philippe Roy of Clos du Roy, at Box outside Bath, prefers the stoneground Dijon mustards prepared by the Normandy company Champ. 
 He rates their subtlety, but points out that they can be mixed only with warm sauces or, he warns, they start to lose their delicacy.  
 A wide selection of mustards were supplied to us by Arran Provisions, Colman's and Burnham Mustards 
 Wholegrain mustard is to Dijon what wholemeal is to brown flour. 
 Its popularity stems from Moutarde de Meaux, the one in the stylist stoneware jar. 
 It has a monastic origin. 
 The recipe passed to the Pommery family in 1760, and now it's a subsidiary of Amora. 
 It's not the only moutarde &agrave; l'ancienne. 
 Both in Britain and France large food companies and tiny cottage industries produce their own interpretations. 
 In some, the outer husks remain almost whole. 
 In others they are crushed and flaky. 
 They may contain any of the basic seed varieties or a combination of all three. 
 All have a generous dose of herbs and spices, everything from chervil and celery seed to cloves and peppercorns. 
 To quote Tom Stobart's The Cook's Encyclopedia : &bquo;Some are nice; others are beastly.&equo; 
 They should never be bitter. 
 Mustard's role in a bistro or brasserie is varied. 
 As a rule of thumb, Dijon mustard ought to be presented with a pot au feu or pot&eacute;e. 
 Grilled beef can take any style providing that it's not too sweet (as German mustards are) or flavoured with an unsuitable herb such as dill. 
 Charcuterie and Dijon mustard are inseparables. 
 And English mustard, freshly prepared, goes best with cooked ham on the bone. 
 Mustard helps to emulsify a vinaigrette. 
 Philippe Roy prefers to do without, because he feels that it interferes with the flavour of a fine oil. 
 However, it improves lentil or potato salads. 
 A vinaigrette of old wine vinegar, olive oil and mustard, spooned over a warm, poached chicken stuffed with ham and Swiss chard, makes a wonderful summer dish. 
 Add diced shallots to the vinaigrette and it becomes a sauce for a jellied boeuf &agrave; la mode or an oxtail terrine. 
 Moutarde de Dijon is also a basic element of other cold sauces. 
 R&eacute;moulade has to have plenty of strong Dijon mustard in it. 
 A summery variation is to add finely chopped cress. 
 A neo-classic, sauce grelette is a blend of cream, mustard and vinegar with fresh herbs. 
 Smetana or soured cream can replace the cream- vinegar and Roger Verg&eacute; mixes in a fresh tomato coulis. 
 Except in catering colleges, as part of a training course, few chefs still prepare a sauce charcuti&egrave;re. 
 It doesn't deserve to be neglected. 
 The basic recipe is a reduction of white wine and brown fond de veau li&eacute; with a julienne of gherkins and mustard stirred in at the last moment. 
 As with all mustard sauces, the important thing is not to reboil it. 
 A more elegant, but equally traditional sauce for pork or game is made by thickening a red wine sauce with mustard and blood. 
 Again, it's vital not to overheat the liquid because it will curdle as well as lose its taste. 
 Depending on the desired strength, up to a tablespoon of Dijon mustard can go into a pint of sauce. 
 Jo&euml;l Robuchon's herb sauce for ribs of beef requires two tablespoons to half a pint of chicken bouillon. 
 Lobster thermidor does not take its name from the hotness of the sauce, but from a month of the French revolutionary calendar. 
 Nor is the lobster smeared with a mustard sauce, as most chefs imagine. 
 A little strong mustard is spread on the emptied shell of a grilled lobster. 
 The meat is put back, coated in a cream-reduction sauce and glazed. 
 This gives a lighter, cleaner taste which doesn't overpower and illustrates the fact that it is not just the obvious oily herring, mackerel and salmon which have the body to withstand a mustard onslaught. 
 Christine Frechet, a member of the Association de Restauratrices Cuisini&egrave;res (ARC), serves skate with mustard and sherry vinegar. 
 Her ARC colleague L&eacute;a Linster bastes a saddle of young roast pork with honey, mustard and coriander, a cross between Apicius and the old English way of glazing hams. 
 Italian cooks have always combined mustard with honey or syrup and fruit. 
 The most notable recipe, in historical terms, is mostarda di cremona, a 17th-century grape marmalade, made with whole grains and crystalised fruit, it is more of a hot-and-sweet preserve and good with bollito. 
 In the USA, mustard is the most commonly used spice after pepper. 
 It's time to give it more of a chance here.  
 RECIPES 
 THREE chefs provide recipes which show versatility of mustard as an ingredient. 
 Martin Blunos of Restaurant Lettonie in Bristol provided the rabbit recipe, using grain mustard. 
 The Garland's Tom Bridgeman in Bath also opted for grain mustard in his dish of lamb's liver and bacon. 
 Tarragon mustard was the type chosen by Philippe Roy of Clos du Roy, Box, in his hake recipe.   
 Saddle of rabbit with mustard 
 OVERSEAS 
 From snails to STARDOM 
 Despite the ultimate in Michelin  -starred success, Bernard Loiseau is not a chef who takes himself too seriously, discovers Roy Hayter 
 BERNARD Loiseau believes in the power of the auto-promotion. 
 It's a well-founded faith he has developed since Michelin  this year singled him out as the only French chef worthy of upgrading to the coveted three-star accolade. 
 At 40, he knows he's on the road to fortune and admits to spending more time talking with journalists than working over hot ovens in the kitchen. 
 His first book, Envoler les Saveurs , is due out in October. 
 The Loiseau phenomenon has rocked French cuisine, transforming the son of a travelling salesman into the country's most talked about chef. 
 He laughingly nicknames himself the &bquo;potato king of the world&equo;. 
 &bquo;I was one of the first chefs to put gastronomic vegetarian meals on the menu seven years ago. 
 People said I'd gone off my head. 
 But I was offering a meal that didn't run any cholesterol risks. 
 It fitted in with my policy of using fresh, natural produce. 
 And potatoes are great. 
 They give a chef the opportunity to be creative.&equo;  
 Frogs legs with garlic pur&eacute;e and a parsley jus 
 Paradoxically, Loiseau originally wanted nothing to do with cooking. 
 I always figured people became chefs when they couldn't do anything else. 
 It was the way we looked at life back in the mid-60s.&equo; 
 His father thought otherwise. 
 Loiseau senior ate regularly at a three-star restaurant owned by the Troisgros brothers at Roanne in the Loire valley. 
 &bquo;One day he returned home to Chamali&egrave;res and said I had a job with Michel and Pierre for &pound;1.50 a month. 
 I wasn't at all happy but I didn't have much choice. 
 At Roanne, Loiseau says, he started out by emptying the bins. 
 &bquo;Afterwards I went on to peeling vegetables. 
 It took a while before they finally trusted me with a little cooking. 
 It was a tough, traditional apprenticeship.&equo; 
 In 1972 Loiseau left Roanne for Paris to work with Claude Verger, owner of two prestigious city restaurants. 
 La Barri&egrave;re de Clichy and La Barri&egrave;re Poquelin. 
 &bquo;Claude taught me a golden rule: only 45% of a restaurant's success depends on cuisine. 
 The rest is determined by decor, the welcome you give and the atmosphere. 
 Our business depends on applied psychology,&equo; Loiseau says. 
 He likes to talk in terms of percentages. 
 &bquo;Rigour, dedication, personal sacrifice over 15 long years and a belief in quality produce earned 70% of those three Michelin  stars. 
 The rest,&equo; he modestly argues, &bquo;is maybe down to talent.&equo; 
 It was Verger who talked Loiseau into taking over, in March 1975, &bquo;a few tight square metres of greasy kitchen space&equo; at La C&ocirc;te d'Or in Saulieu's only main street. 
 The pink-coloured building that overlooks a municipal car park rode out glorious days under the renowned Alexandre Dumaine before crumbling into a state of tatty neglect. 
 The backwater village of 3,000 inhabitants, 250km south-east of Paris, was once an obligatory stopping-off point for travellers headed south for the Riviera. 
 But it was bypassed and quickly forgotten with the opening of the A38 motorway less than 20 miles away. 
 Loiseau took on the challenge. 
 By 1977 the gamble regained the restaurant one of its three former Michelin  stars. 
 A second was awarded in 1981. 
 Two years later he bought the property &bquo;out of love&equo; from Verger for &pound;280,000, and promptly set about a &pound;3m renovation that included a new restaurant, spacious kitchens employing 19 staff and 10 luxury bedroom suites affiliated to Relais et Ch&acirc;teaux. 
 Saulieu was back on the map. 
 In 1986 the quasi-biblical &lsqb;in France&rsqb; Gault-Millau  guide voted him chef of the year with a 19/20 rating, raised to 19.5 in 1990. 
 Loiseau says: &bquo;Awards are the life blood of this industry. 
 They can make or break a chef. 
 But at the summit there's a fast road down if you take yourself too seriously. 
 Success is relative. 
 It's about chance &mdash; today people drive for miles to eat at La C&ocirc;te d'Or, but tomorrow it might all be finished.&equo; 
 Business has almost tripled since Loiseau joined the 18 other French holders of three Michelin  stars. 
 He averages 70 covers on weekdays and doubles that number on weekends. 
 Set menus start at &pound;57 and rise sharply to about &pound;150 &agrave; la carte. 
 Talking through specialities, he cites three: frogs' legs with pur&eacute;ed garlic and parsley sauce, a colourful and popular dish. 
 Sea bream, with shallot and red wine sauce, comes a close second in the restaurant. 
 Mersault is his personal favourite wine for this dish. 
 He overcomes its characteristic darkening during preparation by throwing in a carrot. 
 Wine acidity, he explains, is swallowed up by the natural sweetness of the shallots. 
 Oyster soup with sliced sea urchin is the other original Loiseau signature dish. 
 Loiseau changes menus with the seasons. 
 &bquo;You have to respect nature. 
 In the end, we don't invent anything. 
 We just intervene. 
 I'm known for a particular dish: snails with nettle sauce. 
 I didn't discover the first snail or the first nettle that sprouted up on this planet. 
 I just arranged their marriage.&equo; 
 Loiseau goes to the Burgundy market to select produce like the wild asparagus he serves, buttered and flashed in a pan with lobster. 
 He buys rabbit and game from a local butcher. 
 His cheesemaker is situated on the outskirts of the village, but he keeps names top secret from the culinary competition. 
 Italian olive oil and vinegars, and butter and cream bought from a nearby farm are his favourites.  
 Bitter chocolate sabl&eacute; with orange 
 FEMALE CHEFS 
 WOMEN'S WORK 
 Cuisine des femmes could be the latest cooking style if some French women chefs have their way. 
 Michael Raffael reports 
 AFTER cuisine nouvelle and cuisine moderne, what next? 
 A good each way bet could be cuisine des femmes &mdash; women's cooking. 
 Members of the Association de Restauratrices Cuisini&egrave;res (ARC), a body of lady chefs, are working hard to prove that it exists and that it is a vital component of French cooking today. 
 &bquo;A woman cooks like a birds sings&equo; is their motto. 
 They claim to have an instinctive talent, as opposed to men chefs who have to learn the mechanics of their craft. 
 The idea may not stand too much scrutiny, but it has charm. 
 Christiane Massia, whose restaurant &mdash; Au March&eacute;, in Paris backstreet &mdash; reflects her convictions, argues: &bquo;Of course cuisine des femmes exists! 
 It's less technical, closer to the soil and to traditions.&equo; 
 Until recently, male chefs have shut their kitchen doors on girls wanting to learn the profession. 
 Prestigious bodies such as the Ma&icirc;tres Cuisiniers de France excludes women. 
 There are probably more Japanese working for top chefs than women in equivalent positions. 
 If the kitchen climate is changing, it's because working conditions have lost the barrack room brutality which once characterised what was a pretty sordid job in all but a handful of restaurants and hotels. 
 The difference between most ARC members and professional chefs, male or female, is that the former have not been through &bquo;the system&equo;. 
 For the most part, they are self-taught. 
 As such they belong to a distinct and long-standing tradition, that of the &bquo;m&egrave;res&equo;. 
 In gastronomy, the honorific title &bquo;mother&equo; has an almost mythical force. 
 It's identified generally with many of the glories of bourgeois cooking through the 18th and 19th centuries. 
 Specifically, it's linked to names such as La M&egrave;re Saguet &mdash; who fed Balzac, Dumas, Delacroix and half the literary and artistic establishment of the early 19th century.  
 Above: Nicole Grenier's stuffed rock crabs and courgette flowers. 
 Right: Reine Sammut, this year's ARC trophy winner 
 Chefs in any doubt as to the influence of the grand dames of the ovens should remember that the three- Michelin  -star Georges Blanc in Vonnas used to be La M&egrave;re Blanc until the son took over from his maman. 
 The late, great Alain Chapel's restaurant was once called La M&egrave;re Charles. 
 Drawing upon the culinary cred associated with &bquo;motherhood&equo;, the ARC found an Acad&eacute;mie des M&egrave;res Cuisini&egrave;res for its more venerable members in 1990. 
 To celebrate the event it launched an annual competition, Le Troph&eacute;e des M&egrave;res Cuisini&egrave;res, held in Vichy. 
 It already enjoys enough clout to attract considerable television coverage, a senator and the cream of the French gastronomic press. 
 The theme of this year's contest was Provence. 
 The five finalists had three hours to produce their creations for a jury of 12 gastronomic chroniclers (as French food-writers entitle themselves) and &bquo;m&egrave;res&equo;. 
 Watching the cuisini&egrave;res during the early stages, there was no obvious clue as to why anyone should find it necessary to draw a theoretical distinction between male and female chefs. 
 One woman was handier with a knife, another was better organised, two had marvellous raw materials, another was feeling the pressure of competing. 
 At least an hour before the cooks submitted their offerings to be judged, it was clear who was going to win. 
 Reine Sammut of La Feni&egrave;re, a de luxe bistrot in the Vauclusian hill-town of Lourmarin, had the edge. 
 Her carr&eacute; de'agneau de lait truff&eacute; en cro&ucirc;te, aux pointes d'asperges de Villelaure, combined new season Luberon lamb, the pick of the region's fresh truffles and asparagus tips in their prime. 
 It was a dish owing nothing to Sammut's sex and everything to Provence. 
 The dish was also eminently suitable for service in a restaurant, good to look at and practical to assemble. 
 Other contestants concocted dishes which did reflect a woman's touch. 
 Nicole Grenier of Le Berger des Abeilles, St Andiol, cooked favouilles et courgettes farcies et leur coulis truff&eacute;, tiny stuffed rock crabs and courgette flowers. 
 Marie Ferrand of La G&icirc;te du Tourne-Pierre, Challans, filled the plates with half a crawfish, stuffed Bouzigues mussels, spinach caillettes and a substantial shellfish cannelloni. 
 Gisele Berger of La Bonne Table, Clichy, made the traditional farcis de Provence &mdash; aubergines, courgettes, cabbage and bell peppers filled with a pork and basil stuffing and served with a garlic, olive oil and tomato sauce. 
 All these were homespun recipes, comforting rather than refined. 
 Except for the more delicate crabs, they had a provincial Sunday lunch quality. 
 While the ARC cooks were emptying crabs and boning racks of lamb, five girls were involved in their own competition for the espoir, the most promising young cook. 
 The winner, 20-year-old Benedicte Demange, is already second chef in the Michelin  -starred Les Abesses in Epinal. 
 Her patron is male and she feels no qualms about rubbing shoulders with male chefs and passing orders to a commis who may be older than she is. 
 &bquo;I prefer working with men,&equo; she admits. 
 &bquo;During the work, we're all equal. 
 If anyone makes a mistake, it's the senior person who has to carry the can.&equo; 
 Her winning entry, grillade de rouget, St Jacques et langoustines aux asperges vertes, huile d'olive et basilic, came straight off the carte at Les Abesses. 
 La Feni&egrave;re doesn't have a Michelin  star, though it rates 16/20 in the Gault &amp; Millau  guide. 
 Sammut won't be drawn into a debate as to whether Michelin  is fair to women or not. 
 However, winning the Troph&eacute;e des M&egrave;res Cuisini&egrave;res will bring her valuable publicity: &bquo;It's an important media event which is bound to attract a new clientele.&equo; 
 It also helped promote the cause of la cuisine des femmes. 
 Marguerite Trompeau, who owns La Fontaine just outside Vichy, supplied the welcoming lunch of tripe, Charolais beef grilled over an open fire, cheese and a dessert. 
 And the celebration banquet was cooked by Elisabeth Bourgeois of the Mas Tourteron near Gordes. 
 Having worked through the afternoon on the competition, Sammut handled the press and plaudits during the awards ceremony. 
 She returned to the kitchens to assist with the evening's celebration banquet. 
 About midnight she started handling interviews. 
 In the early hours, she left with her husband Guy to drive back to Lourmarin so that she could open her restaurant in the morning. 
 You certainly couldn't accuse women chefs of lacking stamina.  
 BOOKS 
 Fruit: A Connoisseur's Guide and Cookbook  &mdash; by Davidson and Knox, Mitchell Beazley &pound;25 
 Alan Davidson's previous books include two on fish &mdash; North Atlantic Seafood  and Mediterranean Seafood  &mdash; which are classics of their kind. 
 Chefs like myself have referred to them and kept them at hand since they were written over 10 years ago, along with books such as Jane Grigson's on vegetables. 
 Pat Rance's on cheese and, more recently, Jill Norman's on spices. 
 These books are timeless, not part of the changing whirl of food fashion or trend, rather part of a backbone of information and knowledge without which all cookery books are quite irrelevant. 
 Good produce is inspirational by itself. 
 The more you learn about it, the more you understand how to use it, the less likely you are to subject your raw materials to absurd or unharmonious treatments. 
 Davidson's fruit book comes into this category. 
 However, the book works on several levels. 
 The format may be that of a text book &mdash; with first fruit then nuts dealt with on a family group basis &mdash; but it doesn't read as one. 
 It's never dry or boring, but clearly and interestingly written. 
 All you will ever need to know about each variety is there: history; scientific properties; handling advice; and translations of the fruit's name into French. 
 Finnish or whatever. 
 You cannot expect a reference book to be quite as gripping as an adventure novel, but all the same I read it cover to cover. 
 The book is also a work of art. 
 The illustrations are stunning. 
 On a purely practical basis, the paintings in this instance work better than the camera lens. 
 Perhaps because no photographer's sense of composition or lighting has come between the subject and the reader, they manage to be informative as well as visually satisfying. 
 No easy task and no wonder that Charlotte Knox, who painted them, receives equal billing with Davidson for the book. 
 The third aspect to this book is it's 40-page recipe section. 
 These are mostly fairly straightforward with clear and concise instructions for jellies, jams, dumplings and suchlike. 
 There are also recipes contributed by the likes of Claudia Roden, Sri Owen and Joyce Molyneux, but even the most exotic of these &mdash; like an intriguing banana pudding from Indonesia &mdash; seem quite achievable. 
 And there are notes on subjects such as fruit crystalisation and what is possibly the best explanation published of how and why jams set. 
 Good though they are, the recipes are not central to the value of this book in the way they are to Jane Grigson's fruit book. 
 This book would still be essential purchasing without them. 
 I shall certainly buy and use it, and advise anyone else who is fascinated by the food we work with to do the same.  
 Shaun Hill Head chef Gidleigh Park, Chagford, Devon 
 MY FAVOURITE DISH 
 SEA FARE 
 Andrew Baird's preference is for poached seabass with langoustine mousse 
 &bquo;SEABASS is in plentiful supply around the islands in late summer. 
 It's caught by locals on the high tides and subsequently brought to the hotel at very competitive prices, I don't seem able to say no to it,&equo; says Andrew Baird, head chef at Longueville Manor, St Saviour, Jersey. 
 To make his favourite dish of poached seabass fillet with langoustines, he scales the fish and removes the innards, being careful not to break the connective tissue between the flakes of flesh. 
 He then slices open the fillet to add a langoustine mousse. 
 The mousse is made with a scallop meat base, which is pur&eacute;ed and combined with a reduced stock of langoustine shells, tomato, brandy and a little garlic. 
 The resultant mix is passed, seasoned and left to cool. 
 Baird rarely adds eggs to the pur&eacute;e as the scallop meat tends to be firm enough without them to absorb a fair amount of cream. 
 He leaves the mousse a little on the firm side to preserve the seafood flavour. 
 When tasted and corrected, the mousse is piped on to the fillets which are then carefully folded back together. 
 The fillets are wrapped in cling film with garden herbs and poached for six to eight minutes. 
 Once removed from the courte bouillon, the fillets are left to rest for four minutes. 
 Baird serves the fish encircled by a langoustine-flavoured cream and langoustine tails. 
 He recommends drinking a Puligny Montrachet Premier Cru, Les Referts, 1983 with the dish. 
 Baird started cooking at The Ritz on Piccadilly, London, under Michael Quinn in 1982. 
 He was one of six chosen from a brigade of 40 to accompany Quinn when he then left to work at Ettington Park, Staffordshire. 
 Baird was there for a further two years before leaving in 1987 with chef Barry Forster, who had been offered the position of head chef at Longueville Manor on Jersey. 
 Baird then returned to the mainland after two years to work as sous chef under Brian Baker at Hambleton Hall, Leicestershire, before being offered the head chef's job at Longueville himself 12 months later. 
 He leads a brigade of 13 and the hotel restaurant seats 70. 
 JACK FELL DOWN 
 H R F KEATING 
 &bquo;'TWAS on the Isle of Capreee that I found her&hellip;&equo; 
 Blithely ignoring the rocking of the little steamer in the lurching Mediterranean swell, the girl with the sun-catching cap of peroxided hair sitting hatless on the wooden bench right in the vessel's prow lifted her voice in sudden bubbling song. 
 A blurred blueness in the distance, Capri, indeed, was the little wallowing tub's destination. 
 &bquo;Really,&equo; exclaimed in heavily scandalized tones one of the few other passengers braving the last gusts of a salt-laden sirocco up on deck, an Englishwoman in an ample frock loud with different coloured daisies. 
 But, finding her exclamation had produced no reaction in the only other passenger not comfortably below, save in the stem for a scatter of peasants returning with emptied baskets from Naples, she moved nearer along the ship's greasy rail. 
 Her target was an excessively tall gangling gentleman, not very suitably clad for the Mediterranean in a suit of gingery wool with the trousers ending in tight bands round the calves. 
 He was leaning against the rail smoking a cigarette and staring with an air of melancholy towards the distant island. 
 &bquo;Not a very lady-like performance,&equo; the ample, beflowered lady pronounced, with a look of pinched disapproval in the direction of the girl in the prow. 
 Briefly lifting his cap, the ginger giant produced, in foreign-accented English, a decidedly non-committal reply. 
 The large lady was not to be put off, however.  
 &bquo;Tell me,&equo; she said, leaning forwards with a smile at once coy and overwhelming, &bquo;I must know. 
 Are you Mr Sven Hjerson, the famous Finnish detective? 
 I mean, you must be. 
 I saw your picture in the paper here just last week. 
 You've been helping the Vatican in some mysterious business or other, haven't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, madam, I must make some congratulations to you. 
 You have, as they are saying, done a fine observation.&equo; 
 &bquo;Knew I was right. 
 Generally am. 
 Buckley's the name. 
 Arabella Buckley. 
 Miss. 
 You on another case, eh? 
 The Corpse on Capri, ha?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no,&equo; Sven Hjerson was quick to reply. 
 &bquo;It is just that after much brainwork in Rome I have thought to give myself a little holiday on this famous Capri Island.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sight too famous nowadays, if you ask me,&equo; Arabella Buckley pronounced. 
 &bquo;All the fault of that dreadful song. 
 How that girl can bring herself to sit there singing it I can't imagine. 
 You know who she is, don't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I have not such pleasure. 
 And, madam, I would&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;She goes by the name of Jilly Jonathan. 
 She's one of those, what-d'you-call-'ems, stars. 
 A star of the screen.&equo; 
 &bquo;The cinema is not a place I am very much attending.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, nor me. 
 Frightfully vulgar. 
 But one gets to know about these people somehow. 
 Well, I suppose in the case in point&hellip; 
 &equo; Miss Buckley directed a vigorous glare towards Jilly Jonathan, face lifted to the sun, cheerfully carolling the sentimentally sad words of the song. 
 &bquo;Engaged to the Earl of Woodleigh, you know. 
 They announced it just a couple of weeks ago. 
 On holiday out here with him now. 
 Excelsior Hotel in Naples.&equo; 
 &bquo;And it is there that you also are staying?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no. 
 Can't afford a place like that. 
 Simple pensione  for me. 
 Appalling Italian food, of course, but beggars can't be choosers, what?&equo; 
 &bquo;You are unable to get good vegetables?&equo; 
 Sven Hjerson asked with sudden anxiety. 
 &bquo;In Rome I was in the similar predicament. 
 But I had heard that in the South things are better.&equo;  
 &bquo;Oh, the vegetables are all right, I suppose. 
 It's no porridge at breakfast that gets my goat. 
 Coffee and rolls. 
 What nonsense.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then you think that on Capri I shall be obtaining good vegetables?&equo; the detective inquired. 
 &bquo;You see, they are so important for the uttermost functioning of the brain.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, never stayed on the island myself. 
 just visited it once. 
 Last Sunday, as a matter of fact. 
 Same day as Lord Woodleigh and that &mdash; and his fianc&eacute;e.&equo; 
 &bquo;They are travelling together, just themselves?&equo; 
 Sven Hjerson asked with a sudden flicker of interest. 
 &bquo;Oh, no. 
 Good gracious me, no. 
 Woodleigh's too much of a gentleman, of course, for anything like that. 
 Though I dare say she&hellip; 
 No, there's a whole party of them. 
 Woodleigh, the girl, the Hon. Peter Horbury and Mrs Lettice Horbury. 
 He's Woodleigh's cousin, and his heir, of course, unless that's the older Horbury brother who ran off to Australia years ago and has never been heard of since. 
 And then Woodleigh's secretary even came out last week, so I gather. 
 Some trouble at home, and he sent for her. 
 No, whole thing's perfectly above board.&equo; 
 &bquo;You are most well informed, madam,&equo; Sven Hjerson said, a little drily. 
 &bquo;Oh, well, you know how it is. 
 Interesting people and all that.&equo; 
 At the prow Jilly Jonathan abruptly stopped singing and jumped to her feet. 
 She made her way, still seemingly dancing to the tune, the huge crocodile-skin handbag on her arm swaying heavily in time, to the door down to the saloon. 
 Hauling it open, she thrust in her peroxided head and called out something. 
 A moment or two later a man who, from his lanky form and fine-boned features, could only be her fianc&eacute;, Lord Woodleigh, emerged, evidently doing his best to overcome a certain reluctance. 
 &bquo;Darling,&equo; Jilly Jonathan said, her voice ringing out for all to hear, &bquo;don't fug away down there. 
 It's super up in the sun. 
 And,  look, Capree's getting nearer and nearer.&equo; 
 &bquo;Capri, old girl,&equo; Lord Woodleigh said, giving the name its Italian rather than its popular song emphasis. 
 &bquo;Oh, well, what's it matter how you say it? 
 The thing is it's there. 
 And this time we're really going to get to see the Blue Grotto. 
 You can't go to your stuffy old church today. 
 Not when it's not Sunday.&equo; 
 Lord Woodleigh smiled at her, plainly overcoming a natural reticence. 
 &bquo;Oh, my dear,&equo; he said, &bquo;you'll really have to get used to me going to Mass. 
 Every Sunday, without fail. 
 And on Holidays of Obligation, too.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, okay. 
 But this isn't a &mdash; what-did-you-call-it? &mdash; holiday of obliging. 
 It's a real holiday. 
 Time to do as you like. 
 And fancy telling me that there was an interesting stoup in that old church on the island.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's what the guide-book said, my darling. 
 They are used in Catholic churches to hold holy water.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, but I thought it must be some arch or something that everybody had to stoop to go through. 
 I didn't think even that would be very interesting, but I liked the idea of old Peter having to bend himself for once.&equo; 
 &bquo;Now, you're not to make fun of Peter. 
 He's always been a bit on his dignity, I suppose, but that's the way he is. 
 Comes of half expecting to inherit the title and half not, I dare say.&equo; 
 Jilly Jonathan gave a quick little frown. 
 &bquo;I think actually,&equo; she said, &bquo;he's terribly jealous.&equo; 
 &bquo;Jealous?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of me, darling. 
 After all, I came along when he must have thought you were safe to be a bachelor for ever and ever, and now he'll never be a lord and everything.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, that will depend on whether we have children, angel. 
 If we don't, although now you get the estate you can't, of course, inherit the title.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I would still be a lady, wouldn't I?&equo;  
 Lord Woodleigh's long ascetic face broke into another ice-cracked smile. 
 &bquo;Yes, my dear, from the moment we're married you'll be Countess of Woodleigh.&equo; 
 &bquo;And if you&hellip; 
 Well, if you were to sort of pop off, I'd go on being a countess, wouldn't I? 
 And shouldn't it be an earless anyhow? 
 And, darling, don't pop off, will you? 
 Ever? 
 Ever?&equo; 
 Again Lord Woodleigh smiled. 
 Almost grinned. 
 &bquo;Haven't I told you?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;A dozen times at least. 
 The wife of an earl is a countess, and if that earl dies his wife becomes the Dowager Lady Blank. 
 It's really quite simple.&equo; 
 &bquo;But, sweety pie, I am &mdash; what's it you keep saying? &mdash; a bear of very little brain.&equo; 
 &bquo;But a very nice little bear all the same.&equo; 
 &bquo;Brazen hussy.&equo; 
 Arabella Buckley hissed out the words, but Sven Hjerson thought it very likely they had been carried by the sticky breeze as far as the couple in the prow. 
 He was unable to observe, however &mdash; as he would have liked to do in his ever-observant way &mdash; just what the expression on Jilly Jonathan's pretty face might have been. 
 At that moment, emerging from the saloon below as if propelled from a circus cannon, there appeared a distinctly grotesque figure. 
 He was, beyond doubt, an Italian, swarthy in complexion, crowned under a battered panama with a mop of grease-shining black curls, plump with much pasta. 
 But he had chosen to dress in what he may have conceived to be a British manner. 
 He wore a blazer, not unlike the one Lord Woodleigh wore except that instead of discreet brass buttons it was decorated by no fewer than five enormous, tinselly affairs. 
 In place of the modest flannel bags Lord Woodleigh had on, this fellow had a pair of white trousers, much too short for him, stained heavily on one side and showing beneath a pair of socks in a hideous approximation to a Scottish tartan. 
 These eventually were mercifully lost in brown and white &bquo;correspondent&equo; shoes.  
 &bquo;Milord, milord,&equo; he shouted, hurling himself towards the pair in the prow. 
 &bquo;Milord, you are, yes, yes, yes, wanting hotel on Capri? 
 Yourself and the pretty lady, yes? 
 One bedroom only. 
 Yes, yes, yes?&equo; 
 Lord Woodleigh gave him a look that would have quelled in an instant any insolent groom or keeper. 
 &bquo;Certainly not,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Go away.&equo; 
 He might have been obeyed. 
 Except that Jilly Jonathan burst into unstoppable giggles. 
 &bquo;Oh, Jack,&equo; she managed at last to get out. 
 &bquo;Do let's take up the offer. 
 If only as a joke, to tell people at home when we get back.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, really. 
 It would hardly be a joke in very good taste.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, milord, milord. 
 Make that very good joke, yes? 
 Very good joke. 
 One room only. 
 Very, very pretty lady.&equo; 
 Now something more than a quelling look appeared on Lord Woodleigh's fine-bred features. 
 Cold anger. 
 &bquo;Listen, my man,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The guide-book warned us about hotel touts of your sort, and unless you make yourself scarce I shall put you into the hands of the Carabinieri.&equo; 
 The threat was enough. 
 More than enough. 
 The tartan-socked tout positively scuttled his way to the vessel's stem. 
 By the time the boat reached the island Sven Hjerson had still not succeeded in shaking off the ample, daisy-sprinkled form of Arabella Buckley. 
 From the yet more gloomy expression on his normally lugubrious face it was evident that he had resigned himself to her companionship at least as far as his hotel perched up far above the sea. 
 So it was without surprise that he found himself sharing with her one of the tinny, open-sided cars of the creaky old funicular that saved tourists the toil of climbing the seven hundred and more steep stone steps up from the Marina Grande. 
 As soon as the linked train of little open cars began its steeply angled ascent she clutched the Finnish detective by the arm.  
 &bquo;Mr Hjerson&equo; she gasped. 
 &bquo;Did you notice?&equo; 
 &bquo;It is my business always to make notices. 
 But, alas, madam, I do not in the present know what it is you are asking if I am seeing.&equo; 
 &bquo;That Italian. 
 That what-d'you-call-'em. 
 Tout. 
 He's on the funicular with us, in the next car with Miss Abernethie.&equo; 
 &bquo;Miss Abernethie? 
 She is the lady I have seen? 
 Very middle-age, hair grey, clothes most plain, pince-nez spectacles, expression always disapproving? 
 Lord Woodleigh's secretary he has sent for?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, yes, that's her. 
 But don't you understand about that &mdash; that tout?&equo; 
 &bquo;Madam, what should be understood?&equo; 
 &bquo;Why, that he's here because of Jilly Jonathan. 
 He's trying to lay his filthy hands on her, I haven't a doubt. 
 And perhaps she&hellip; 
 You must have seen how struck he was with her. 
 Very, very pretty lady, all that sort of beastly foreign stuff.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, but, madam, if the fellow is a tout &mdash; tout, is that the word? &mdash; for one of the hotels here, is it not likely he would need to be ascending like us?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, no, you see, no. 
 The thing is that it costs 40 lira to go up now, but if he had waited just one hour more, till the 11 a.m. departure, he would have had to pay only two lira. 
 It said so in the guide-book.&equo; 
 The Finn considered. 
 &bquo;Yes, madam,&equo; he said at last, &bquo;I am granting that his conducting of himself is not what might be expected. 
 But, you know, there may be many other reasons why it is important for him to get to the top so quickly. 
 It does not have to be that he has conceived what the French are calling the coup de force  for Miss Jonathan.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can tell that,&equo; said Arabella Buckley, &bquo;to the Marines.&equo; 
 It was an exclamation she might have had to clarify. 
 But at that moment their creaking conveyance gave a sudden fearsome jerk and came to a dead stop.  
 Once again Miss Buckley clutched Sven Hjerson's arm. 
 &bquo;I knew it wasn't safe,&equo; she jabbered. 
 &bquo;I knew it the moment I saw it last Sunday. 
 These Italians, you can't trust them, you know. 
 Certainly not with anything mechanical. 
 That's something it takes a sturdy British workman to understand.&equo; 
 Sven Hjerson's lugubrious face lit up in a brief smile. 
 &bquo;Then I am able to give you a reassurance, madam,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;This funicular is looked after by an Englishman. 
 You can rely upon the observations of Sven Hjerson for this. 
 I noted him working on the machinery while we were waiting to ascend. 
 He was dropping one of his tools and let forth a number of obscenities. 
 His voice was what is called, I am understanding, Cockney or perhaps Australian.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Arabella Buckley. 
 &bquo;Yes, well, that is reassuring. 
 Only&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, if he was repairing the machinery, it can't have been safe in the first place, can it?&equo; 
 Then Sven Hjerson took his revenge for the past tiresome two hours. 
 &bquo;Madam,&equo; he said, &bquo;you are right. 
 We cannot be certain. 
 Definitely not safe.&equo; 
 His mischievous words, however, were to prove within a very few minutes appallingly prescient. 
 The funicular had resumed its climb, apparently smoothly enough. 
 Arabella Buckley had released her grip on the Finn's long, ginger-suited arm. 
 Perhaps with some reluctance. 
 They sat in silence then looking out to either side of the steeply tumbling rocks interspersed with dry, hard Mediterranean shrubs. 
 But, almost at the end of the ascent, there came a new series of alarming jerks and they juddered to a halt once more. 
 At once there came, clear in the sunny air, a long piercing scream. 
 The tall Finnish detective acted with a turn of speed altogether surprising to Miss Buckley. 
 In an instant he had vaulted over the side of their car and had begun swinging himself along  towards the head of the train and the car occupied by Lord Woodleigh and Jilly Jonathan. 
 They were no longer in it. 
 The side of the car opposite the landing stage, rustily flimsy at best, had fallen or been pushed away, leaving a jagged edge all round. 
 Sven Hjerson clambered aboard and cautiously peered over. 
 &bquo;Nothing,&equo; he called at once to the others, whose view of the top car was obscured by the tall backs of their seats. 
 &bquo;But one cannot see greatly far down. 
 Perhaps they are well. 
 It is not so long till some bushes are there. 
 I see to the side a railing also. 
 Perhaps it has stopped their descent. 
 I cannot make out.&equo; 
 The remaining passengers &mdash; there were not many of them &mdash; had in the meanwhile managed to make their way, by scrambling from the outside of one car to the next, to the safety of the solid wooden landing stage. 
 They stood there in a frightened cluster. 
 &bquo;I am going to make the climb downwards,&equo; the Finn called to them. 
 &bquo;Help will be needed. 
 Would some gentleman like to assist me?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, yes. 
 Let me. 
 I'm his cousin, Peter Horbury.&equo; 
 The Hon. Peter Horbury appeared to be some ten or twelve years younger than the earl. 
 There were traces of the same fine-boned look about him, but his features were already well masked by what was likely in the course of time to become a solid layer of self-indulgent fat. 
 Nevertheless he seemed willing enough to accompany the Finnish detective in the dangerous climb down over the tumbling rocks to where his cousin and his cousin's pretty, peroxided fianc&eacute;e lay. 
 Perhaps dead. 
 Perhaps, taking into account the comparative shortness of the descent, only injured. 
 In the event it took the two of them, scrambling and sliding downwards beside each other, faces to the rocks, only some five or six minutes to reach the spot where the railing which Sven Hjerson had noticed further along had in fact stopped the  couple's fall. 
 But it had stopped Lord Woodleigh in the most horrible of ways. 
 His head must have fallen almost directly on top of one of the tall spikes that surmounted the old iron rail. 
 He had not been impaled, but the spike had been driven far upwards from near his throat before his body had slumped clear. 
 There could be no doubt at all that he was dead. 
 Jilly Jonathan had been luckier, or less appallingly unlucky. 
 She was lying not far from her fianc&eacute;, eyes closed, deathly pale but apparently hardly injured. 
 The tall Finn and Peter Horbury together raised her up and in a moment or two her eyelids fluttered open. 
 With unexpected tenderness Sven Hjerson told her what had happened. 
 &bquo;Oh, my God, my God,&equo; she said, &bquo;I was showing Jack the view out there, and I leant over pointing to something and then suddenly the whole thing seemed to tilt and&hellip;&equo; 
 She broke off, and Sven Hjerson felt her body slump again in his arms. 
 But by the time he had gathered up her handbag and Lord Woodleigh's camera, which had come to rest nearby, she was able slowly to make her way with them to the nearest point where the accident could be reported. 
 Some two hours later the whole party sat, exhausted and silent, in deckchairs on the terrace of Sven Hjerson's hotel, sipping half-heartedly at cups of abominable tea and looking without seeing anything at the wide sweep of the Bay of Naples spread out far below them. 
 Jilly Jonathan was pale but had calmed down after the bout of hysterical weeping that had overcome her once they had got her to the hotel. 
 Peter Horbury sat beside her, still looking tousled from his exertions among the rocks. 
 Next to him his wife, a tall rangy woman whom Sven Hjerson somehow saw even here as being astride a hunter, was leaning forward tapping the tips of the fingers of each hand one against the other. 
 Beside her, chair  drawn a little back, Miss Abernethie sat, her face rigid with disapproval, though of what precisely there was no telling. 
 And, to Sven Hjerson's concealed annoyance, Miss Arabella Buckley had contrived to make herself one of the group, her ample form straining the faded green canvas of a chair firmly set among the others. 
 Into the Finn's head there had strayed, not to be expelled, the words of an English nursery rhyme that a child had once recited to him. 
 Jack and Jill went up the hill to fetch a pail of water, Jack fell down and broke his crown and Jill came tumbling after . 
 The childish words went through and through his mind, blotting out all coherent thought. 
 And he felt, obscurely, that the terrible accident needed to be given coherent thought. 
 As much and as deep coherent thought as he was capable of. 
 But it had been days since he had managed to obtain a good, large dish of fresh-cooked vegetables. 
 His famous brain was stupified. 
 Perhaps this was why, uncharacteristically, he burst out aloud with the thought that at last chased the nursery rhyme momentarily from his mind. 
 &bquo;No. 
 No, no. 
 That car could not have tipped over of itself. 
 Jack and Jill went up the hill, yes, and Jack fell down with Jill tumbling after also; But it was in no manner a simple fall. 
 There must have been a push.&equo; 
 Arabella Buckley was the first to recover from the shock of that strange outpouring. 
 &bquo;Mr Hjerson,&equo; she said, &bquo;are you&hellip; 
 Well, are you sure? 
 I mean, don't you&hellip; 
 Well, don't you sometimes expect to find mysterious deaths wherever you go?&equo; 
 Sven Hjerson nodded slowly. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Yes, that is a good supposition you have made, madam. 
 I would not have thought you&hellip; 
 But, no. 
 No, it is not right. 
 Sven Hjerson is always making observations. 
 He has trained the eyes to do it. 
 I was telling you, was I not, that I was seeing with exactness what the English workman was doing while we were waiting to ascend. 
 I know how the funicular is  operating. 
 Exactly. 
 And I am repeating. 
 Jack and Jill did not tumble down the hill without somebody giving a push.&equo; 
 &bquo;But&hellip; 
 But&hellip;&equo; 
 , Peter Horbury brought out. 
 &bquo;But that means&hellip; 
 Well, that means&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Murder, Peter,&equo; his wife snapped, leaning forward in the saddle. 
 &bquo;That's what Mr Hjerson has the effrontery to be claiming has happened.&equo; 
 &bquo;Madam, there is no effrontery. 
 Yes, Lord Woodleigh has been murdered, and Miss Jilly Jonathan has been a victim beside him. 
 Sven Hjerson has said it.&equo; 
 &bquo;In which case,&equo; Arabella Buckley pronounced sturdily, &bquo;there's only one thing for it. 
 The what-d'you-call-'ems. 
 The police. 
 The Carabin-somethings.&equo; 
 It was perhaps an hour later that the island's police chief left them with a clicking heels bow. 
 Despite his almost complete lack of English and the poor Italian the others possessed, several things had emerged. 
 Only a handful of people, it had been established, had been near enough to the leading car of the funicular to have been able to give it the fatal extra push that had sent Woodleigh and Jilly Jonathan tumbling down the steep hillside. 
 These were Peter Horbury and his wife who had been in the little car immediately next to Lord Woodleigh's, and Miss Abernethie, who had been in the next car suffering the presence of the tartan-socked hotel tout. 
 &bquo;I am afraid I took pains to look out at the other side so as not to see him,&equo; she had said. 
 &bquo;But he was there. 
 He was very definitely there.&equo; 
 &bquo;So it could have been he who slipped over the side and did it,&equo; Arabella Buckley had promptly declared. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Sven Hjerson had been constrained to agree. 
 &bquo;It would have been possible for him, I think. 
 Just possible.&equo; 
 He had given Arabella Buckley a quick glance then. 
 &bquo;Just as it might have been possible for you also, madame,&equo; he had said. 
 &bquo;I, too, was regarding the view on the opposite side  from yourself. 
 I could not in the court of law swear that you had been under my observations the whole time we were making the ascent.&equo; 
 But the others, with the abominable tout in their sights, had been quick to fix the blame on him. 
 The Carabinieri chief had left at once with a promise of finding the man within the hour, to which he added, sotto voce , a pledge to get the truth out of him by whatever methods might be necessary. 
 Sven Hjerson was not, however, willing to let this convenient solution put an end to his own investigation. 
 &bquo;Ladies and gentlemen,&equo; he said when the police chiefs hurrying back was out of sight, &bquo;let us not make ourselves deceived. 
 Is it so likely that that man, however much he may have been struck by your beauty and gaiety, Miss Jonathan, would have at once decided to assassinate your future husband?&equo; 
 But Arabella Buckley, with a murderer who was not &bquo;one of us&equo; almost under her thumb, was not going to let him go so easily. 
 &bquo;Dash it all,&equo; she said, &bquo;Lord Woodleigh spoke very sharply to the fellow when we were on the boat. 
 And these Italians are fearfully hot-headed. 
 Everybody knows what foreigners are like.&equo; 
 There was a chorus of agreement. 
 It served to make the Finnish detective rather sharper than he might otherwise have been. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Let us please seek for more stronger motives.&equo; 
 Round the semi-circle of chairs quick looks flicked from face to face. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Sven Hjerson went on, &bquo;it is in fact, I am thinking, that all those people who might have given that not very well balanced car the one push needed have also possible reasons for wishing the death of Lord Woodleigh. 
 And of you also, Miss Jonathan.&equo; 
 He gave Jilly Jonathan a brief bow from his enormous gangling height. 
 &bquo;Well, I say, that's a bit rich, don't you know,&equo; Peter Horbury said indignantly.  
 &bquo;Nonsense, Peter,&equo; his wife pounced down on him as if he were a hound that had misbehaved. 
 &bquo;The man's quite right. 
 You've got a perfect motive. 
 After all, you're the Earl of Woodleigh now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good lord, so I am.&equo; 
 For a moment or two Peter Horbury contemplated his newly elevated status. 
 &bquo;But, I mean to say, I did always think I would inherit one day, with Jack being such a confirmed&hellip;&equo; 
 He broke off, blushed and tried not to look at Jilly Jonathan. 
 &bquo;And you, madam,&equo; Sven Hjerson turned to Peter's wife. 
 &bquo;You are now &mdash; I heard the belated Lord Woodleigh explaining this myself &mdash; you are now Countess of Woodleigh. 
 It is a great honour.&equo; 
 The new Lady Woodleigh looked as if she might take her riding-crop to him if he so much as uttered another word. 
 &bquo;Choose to think that would be a reason for sending old Jack into the next world if you like,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;But I'm sure there are others with better reasons for wanting to get rid of him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't see who you mean,&equo; Arabella Buckley said, a blood-red blush rising up in her cheeks. 
 &bquo;I mean, I've hardly met any of you, let alone&hellip;,&equo; 
 &bquo;I am thinking,&equo; Sven Hjerson said, &bquo;that Lady Woodleigh the new, is meaning someone else, not you, Miss Buckley.&equo; 
 He turned in his chair a little. 
 &bquo;I am thinking, Miss Abernethie, she is perhaps wondering, Like myself, why you were sent for to Naples in the middle of the new-engaged couple's holiday. 
 Is the trouble at home that I am hearing of, perhaps, that someone had been &mdash; what is the expression? &mdash; boiling the books?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 No. 
 It's a lie. 
 I haven't&hellip; 
 Why should&hellip; 
 Oh, you are all so beastly. 
 Beastly.&equo; 
 Miss Abernethie jumped from her chair, scuttled in the direction of the broad flight of steps leading to the road outside, tripped clumsily over Jilly Jonathan's big crocodile-skin handbag, fell to her feet, scrambled up again, pushed the heavy bag aside with a cry of rage that came oddly from her dumpily  respectable self and ran off out of sight. 
 &bquo;Quick, quick, after her somebody,&equo; Arabella Buckley shouted, her prejudice in favour of foreign murderers seemingly suddenly abandoned. 
 Poor overweight Peter Horbury, the new Lord Woodleigh began to heave himself from his deckchair and then sank back into it. 
 &bquo;Oh, she can't get off the island,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;No need to go chasing about.&equo; 
 He turned to Sven Hjerson. 
 &bquo;Perhaps, my dear fellow, since you're some sort of detective, you'd try to get through on the telephone to the Carabinieri. 
 They should pick her up without any trouble.&equo; 
 But Sven Hjerson appeared not to have heard. 
 He had made no attempt to pursue the fleeing secretary and was sitting as if in a trance staring somewhere between the chairs occupied by the new Lord Woodleigh and Jilly Jonathan. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; he said eventually. 
 &bquo;Yes, Sven Hjerson sees it all. 
 It is nothing so ever to do with that Australian or Cockney mechanic.&equo; 
 &bquo;I should jolly well hope you do see it,&equo; Lady Woodleigh snapped. 
 &bquo;Damn it, the dreadful woman's run off. 
 It should all be quite evident enough by now.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no,&equo; the Finnish detective said, shaking his head as if to rid himself of the last remnants of misunderstanding. 
 &bquo;No, you see, Lady Woodleigh, it was not Miss Abernethie who was responsible for the death of Jack who went up the hill. 
 Perhaps she has boiled some books, but that is another matter altogether. 
 No, the murder of Lord Woodleigh was conceived here on Capri, I am believing. 
 Perhaps because something called a stoup in a church was not so interesting enough as he had thought.&equo; 
 &bquo;What on earth,&equo; Arabella Buckley said, &bquo;has the stoup to do with murder?&equo; 
 &bquo;I will tell you. 
 Last Sunday the belated Lord Woodleigh and Miss Jilly Jonathan could not see the famous Blue Grotto on  this island because Lord Woodleigh insisted to go to Mass in a church here. 
 It was this, I am thinking, that made Miss Jonathan realize that if the marriage she was about to enter into with a man much different from herself, and older also, would not go well, she would never from a Catholic be obtaining a divorce. 
 So she decided to make away with him.&equo; 
 &bquo;But that's ridiculous,&equo; Arabella Buckley bounced out. 
 &bquo;I mean, the girl wasn't even married to him yet. 
 She'll be left with nothing now.&equo; 
 She looked across at the film star, not with a great deal of pity. 
 Jilly Jonathan was sitting just as she had been ever since they had come out on to the terrace. 
 Still as a stone. 
 &bquo;No, that is wrong,&equo; Sven Hjerson went on in his level, accented tones. 
 &bquo;You heard so much as I did, Miss Buckley. 
 On board the steamer the two of them were talking about what would happen to the title if Lord Woodleigh was to die before they had any children, and Lord Woodleigh said &mdash; Sven Hjerson's ears heard it &mdash; although now you get the estate . 
 Now, he was saying. 
 And about something as important as so much land and money he would speak with correctitude. 
 So he has already made his will, yes, leaving all already to his future wife. 
 That is the motive.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, yes,&equo; said Lady Woodleigh. 
 &bquo;But that doesn't mean she killed him. 
 She survived the fall down the hill. 
 He might have done, too. 
 Not much worse than a tumble in the hunting field.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Sven Hjerson said, &bquo;you have not thought about the wrong handbag.&equo; 
 &bquo;What wrong handbag, for heaven's sake? 
 Man's a fool.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, for some time even Sven Hjerson was a fool. 
 He saw that handbag. 
 He was even carrying it, and thinking how heavy it was. 
 But he was never saying to himself until one moment in the past that it was much peculiar that a girl as pretty and as fashionable with her peroxide hair as Jilly Jonathan was carrying on holiday a big, crocodile-skin handbag. 
 He was never saying to himself in that heavy bag what should there be?&equo;  
 At this he leapt from his chair in one long gingery streak, seized the bag and without ceremony upended it. 
 Out on to the stones of the terrace there fell a thick metal spike, not at all dissimilar to the blood-smeared one on which Lord Woodleigh had not fallen, out of sight for a few vital minutes from anyone looking from above. 
 &bquo;A clear case of premeditated murder, the conception made here last Sunday, the spiky weapon obtained from somewhere, the risk taken,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Once more Sven Hjerson has triumphed. 
 Without also fresh vegetables.&equo; 
 EXPERTS FOR THE PROSECUTION 
 TIM HEALD 
 It was a golden day in a golden age. 
 Golden lads and lasses had just breakfasted on golden toast, a little blackened at the edge in some cases, spread with golden shred or golden syrup. 
 Now they tripped merrily to a schoolhouse of golden Cotswold stone burnished by a golden English sun in a bright blue heaven inhabited by a golden English God. 
 All was right with the world. 
 Up to a point. 
 Sergeant Bramble had just returned from the Manor House upon his bicycle. 
 The sergeant was stout and pink and, after the exertion of a mile-long bicycle ride, seemed stouter and pinker than usual. 
 &bquo;Well I'll be jiggered!&equo; he exclaimed to himself as he bent to unfasten his clips, &bquo;I'll be jiggered and no mistake.&equo; 
 And so saying he went into the tiny village police station with its distinctive blue lamp and the lettering chiselled into the stone above the doorway which said &bquo;King's Magnum Parva Police Station&equo;. 
 A handwritten note stuffed into the bootscraper said &bquo;Two pints today, please.&equo; 
 Inside he filled a kettle and lit the gas-ring. 
 The Daily Express  had arrived in his absence and its front page confirmed what he had already heard from Mrs Pettifer up at the Manor. 
 &bquo;Baronet vanishes,&equo; it screamed. 
 Good headlines did scream at you in those days. 
 &bquo;Baronet vanishes! 
 Clubs abandoned at 15th green. 
 &bquo;Seemed perfectly normal to me,&equo; says Major.&equo; 
 Sergeant Bramble turned his attention to the kettle. 
 When it  had boiled, whistling with a tinny Woolworth sibillance, he warmed the pot-bellied black teapot, spooned in two piles of thick tarry Indian leaves, left them awhile as he had a scratch of the back, then poured the dark brown liquid into a plain white cup, with saucer, added milk from a bottle plus two sweetening spoonfuls of caster sugar. 
 Only then did he return to the newspaper. 
 Routine in his life was everything and he would be jiggered if anything &mdash; even the abduction of Squire Blacker &mdash; would interfere with it. 
 The article was by Percy Hoskins, the greatest Commissioners of Police and thieves and villains, who drank champagne at the Caprice, had an apartment in park lane, was an intimate of Lord Beaverbrook, yet kept the common touch. 
 Sergeant Bramble allowed himself the luxury of a fleeting smile. 
 Perhaps, who knows, the great Hoskins might yet grace King's Magnum Parva with his presence. 
 Sergeant Bramble drank some tea and wondered where Constable Quince had got to. 
 Constable Quince was new to the job and, in Bramble's estimation, unsuited for it. 
 He seemed to think that a policeman's lot should be to deal in drama. 
 He wanted excitement. 
 He aspired to &bquo;The Flying Squad&equo;. 
 He talked, misty eyed, of &bquo;The Yard&equo;. 
 He wanted to be a detective. 
 He was a fan of Sexton Blake. 
 He was a pain in Sergeant Bramble's bottom and the sooner he could recommend that Quince be transferred to somewhere more metropolitan, where robbery with violence might occur, the happier Bramble would be. 
 &bquo;Dratted nuisance that Quince lad!&equo; thought Bramble, and started to read the paper. 
 This he did with difficulty, partly on account of his bad eyesight, partly because of what in later years would come to be referred to as &bquo;a learning disability&equo; or &bquo;mild dyslexia&equo;; and partly because he simply wasn't much of a reader. 
 He didn't actually have to run his finger along the line in order to make sense of it, but he did like to mouth the  words as he got to them. 
 &bquo;Fears were growing last night for the safety of Sir Vivien Blacker, Bart. 
 of the Manor House, King's Magnum Parva who vanished from his home yesterday. 
 Eton and Sandhurst educated Sir Vivien, 28, was last seen yesterday morning at Royal Wrigglesworth Golf Club. 
 &bquo;Sir Vivien often played a round before breakfast,&equo; said Major Ernest &bquo;Tiger&equo; Bagshot, 43, Secretary of Royal Wrigglesworth, &bquo;But my suspicions were aroused when his black labrador, Bonzo, appeared at the clubhouse at approximately ten o'clock. 
 The dog seemed distressed and there was no sign of his master.&equo;&equo; 
 &bquo;Major Bagshot accompanied Bonzo to the 15th green where he found a ball and a complete set of Henry Cotton &bquo;St Andrew's&equo; clubs lying, abandoned. 
 Sir Vivien's mashie niblick was in a bunker approximately forty yards from the hole.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sir Vivien is the eleventh baronet and is the only surviving son of Sir Tregarron Blacker, the celebrated big-game hunter who died in the sinking of the Titanic , together with his wife, Lady Mabel. 
 Extensive searches revealed a series of tyre marks along the fairway leading to the 15th and there are fears that Sir Vivien, reputed to be one of the seventeen richest men in the country, may have been kidnapped and held to ransom.&equo; 
 &bquo;Our Social Correspondent writes: &bquo;Sir Vivien Blacker is a leading member of London Society whose name has been linked with many of our most nubile heiresses. 
 A familiar and dashing figure on the polo field and the Cresta Run, he is universally popular in all circles being blessed with great charm, a ready wit and debonair good looks. 
 Unmarried, his heir is his second cousin, once removed, Mr. Alfred Blacker who is believed to live in Hobart, Tasmania, where he was last heard of working as a Real Tennis professional.&equo;&equo; 
 Sergeant Bramble was so engrossed in mouthing along with the Daily Express  that he did not notice the opening of the door. 
 It was only when it shut with a rusty creak that he realized that he had company.  
 &bquo;Sergeant Bramble?&equo; 
 The query, for such it was, emanated from an elderly lady who appeared to be clad entirely in shawls. 
 Her complexion was pink and white and her eyes were very wide and of an astonishingly china blue hue. 
 She seemed vaguely familiar. 
 The sergeant deliberated for a moment and then spoke in the soft but unmistakable burr of deepest Mummersett. 
 &bquo;I am he,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Then, Sergeant,&equo; said the little old lady, &bquo;your troubles are at an end.&equo; 
 &bquo;Saving your presence ma'am, but I bain't got no troubles.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh now, dear me, Sergeant, let's not beat about the bush.&equo; 
 The lady raised an admonitory finger in rebuke and the sergeant observed, to his surprise, that despite it being a hot summer's day, she was wearing what appeared to be mittens. 
 &bquo;I have come&equo;, continued the old lady, &bquo;about the Case of the Missing Baronet.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'm don't want to be believing what they do write in they newspapers ma'am&equo;, exclaimed the sergeant, but his visitor was not listening. 
 &bquo;It reminds me of my dear father one day at Sandwich,&equo; she was saying, &bquo;when we were picnicking on the sands and we had arranged to meet him at the nineteenth hole. 
 Imagine mother's distress when she discovered there was no such thing! 
 But never fear, sergeant. 
 I shall find the body in a jiffy and we shall apprehend the guilty party before the day is out.&equo; 
 Sergeant Bramble was about to remonstrate when they were interrupted by Constable Quince wheeling his bicycle. 
 &bquo;And this must be Constable Quince,&equo; said the old lady. 
 &bquo;How do you do, Constable?&equo; 
 &bquo;Very well, thank you Ma'am,&equo; said Quince amiably. 
 &bquo;How did you know this man's name was Quince?&equo; asked Bramble with a hint of incredulity. 
 &bquo;I make it my business to know such things, young man.&equo; 
 Bramble was forty-five and had not been thus addressed for  almost a quarter of a century. 
 &bquo;Which,&equo; continued his visitor, &bquo;is why I am able to assist you with your enquiries.&equo; 
 &bquo;What enquiries?&equo; asked the policeman. 
 &bquo;Why,&equo; she exclaimed, &bquo;your enquiries into the murder of poor Sir Vivien.&equo; 
 &bquo;But&hellip; 
 &equo; Bramble began, but she silenced him with a glare from the astonishing blue eyes. 
 Strange, thought Bramble, that such an apparently dithery old lady should be able to look at you like that. 
 Bloody terrifying. 
 If you asked him she ought to be put away for she was plainly off her trolley. 
 &bquo;And now, Sergeant, I must be about my business. 
 I shall begin with the dog. 
 If you have any need of me you may enquire of my nephew the vicar.&equo; 
 And so saying she gathered up her shawl, adjusted her mittens and scuttled from the room. 
 &bquo;Phew!&equo; exclaimed the sergeant, producing a red and white spotted kerchief from his trouser pocket and mopping his fevered brow. 
 &bquo;What was all that about?&equo; asked Quince. 
 But before Bramble could answer, the door opened and another stranger entered. 
 He was a small man, distinctly foreign in appearance, with a rigidly waxed moustache and an egg-shaped head which he carried rather to one side. 
 He seemed somewhat breathless but his intelligent eyes twinkled with amusement. 
 &bquo;Allo, messieurs, I have arrived as you would have it, in the Nicholas, n'est-ce pas?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry sir, I'm not entirely with you.&equo; 
 The placid equilibrium of Sergeant Bramble's existence was suddenly being put at risk. 
 &bquo;Oh ho, m'sieur,&equo; said the little man, &bquo;I was not, as your expressive idiom puts it, born on the preceding day.&equo; 
 His eyes flashed and he presented his elegant moustaches. 
 &bquo;It is correct, is it not, that your seigneur is vanished into the air. 
 Pouf!&equo; 
 He  slapped his palms together like a conjuror. 
 &bquo;Comme &ccedil;a. 
 Without the merest trace.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well&hellip; 
 &equo; Sergeant Bramble made as if to speak, but the foreign person silenced him with a glance that would have iced coffee. 
 &bquo;The answer,&equo; he said, &bquo;lies perhaps in your game of golf. 
 Our friend played, I think, off a handicap of trois. 
 Also perhaps we should think a little of the monnaie. 
 Was our friend Sir Vivien as rich as he pretended? 
 Perhaps there was trouble with the gaming table? 
 But I shall call first at the Manor and present my card. 
 Never fear, messieurs, we shall have this mystery solved in time of nothing at all. 
 Should you wish advice from the world's greatest detective you may enquire for me at the Rose and Crown. 
 It is there that I am putting up.&equo; 
 Saying which he passed jauntily from their ken, shutting the door behind him with a flourish. 
 &bquo;What's all that about, Sarge?&equo; asked Quince. 
 &bquo;It means,&equo; said Bramble wearily, &bquo;that we are under siege from the great detectives. 
 We just have to hope your aristocracy don't read the Daily Express . 
 Otherwise we'll be up to our necks with toffs in monocles and deer-stalkers all of 'em trailing manservants and frightening the cows and horses by blasting around in they great green Bentleys they all drive.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cor,&equo; said Quince. 
 &bquo;I'll warn Mrs Pettifer they're on their way,&equo; said the sergeant, &bquo;Then you'd better keep an eye on the old lady and I'll watch the froggie geezer. 
 Make sure they don't create too much mischief. 
 I do reckon they have till sundown. 
 Then we'll have it all sorted out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorted out?&equo; said Quince. 
 He looked astonished. 
 &bquo;We're going to sort it out ourselves?&equo; 
 Bramble nodded. 
 &bquo;We'll sort it out, my son. 
 In our own good time. 
 Now let me ring Mrs Pettifer.&equo; 
 The 'phone rang for a very long time and when Mrs Pettifer eventually answered she sounded quite put out. 
 &bquo;Oh, Sergeant,&equo; she said &bquo;Thank heaven it's you. 
 I've got this  tiresome woman here asking endless rude questions. 
 She keeps wanting to know if I play golf. 
 She even had the audacity to suggest that I might have been &bquo;carrying on&equo; with Sir Vivien. 
 The idea! 
 She says she's some sort of detective. 
 But she doesn't look like a detective&hellip; 
 She says she's called on you already and she's helping you with your enquiries. 
 I tried to talk to her sensibly but she just wouldn't listen.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh dear,&equo; said Bramble out loud. 
 Privately the words he used were &bquo;I'll be jiggered. 
 Silly old bat!&equo; 
 He and the housekeeper continued to converse for a few minutes and finally he said, &bquo;Very well, Mrs Pettifer, sherry at six.&equo; 
 He spoke the words &bquo;sherry at six&equo; with a hint of menace, rather as if he had said &bquo;pistols at dawn&equo;. 
 When he replaced the receiver he regarded his subordinate for a moment and then smiled. 
 &bquo;Now, young Quince,&equo; he said, &bquo;you've always wanted a spot of real detective work to do. 
 So I tell you what. 
 You get on your bike and find that old lady what were in here just now and you don't let her out of your sight. 
 Don't you let her know what you're up to, mind. 
 Just you do prevent any serious mischief. 
 And I'll do the same for the foreigners.&equo; 
 He put down the empty tea cup with surprising force. 
 &bquo;I don't hold with foreigners,&equo; he exclaimed, &bquo;leastways not here in King's Magnum Parva. 
 Foreigners may be all right abroad but we don't want none of them and their ways here.&equo; 
 And without more ado the two officers fastened their clips about their ankles, wheeled out with velocipedes and were on their way. 
 Bramble spotted his quarry entering the post office some ten minutes later. 
 The small foreign person was walking as jauntily as ever, though Bramble realized that he did so with a pronounced limp. 
 Bramble decided to follow, and when he entered the office, which was also the village shop, he found the stranger in earnest colloquy with the postmaster, one Algy Brind. 
 &bquo;It is, ma foi, a matter only of the little grey cells, m'sieur&equo;, he  was saying. 
 &bquo;Your baronet is kidnapped. 
 Now if he is kidnapped, what may we deduce? 
 That a person has done so in order to extract the monnaie. 
 And how will this be done? 
 In order to make such an extraction a message must be conveyed. 
 And how better would a kidnapper do such a thing than to send a letter by his Majesty's Mail. 
 In such matters it is the most obvious things which are the most important and which stare at you from under the nose without being perceived. 
 And so I must ask you again to allow me to inspect the morning's mails.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Sergeant Bramble!&equo; 
 Algy was obviously relieved by the arrival of the law. 
 &bquo;This person says he's acting on your behalf and he wants to inspect all the mail. 
 Ingoing and outgoing. 
 I've explained that it's the King's personal property until safely delivered to the addressee, but he doesn't seem to understand.&equo; 
 &bquo;Now then, now then,&equo; Sergeant Bramble spoke in reassuring country tones, &bquo;what seems to be the problem?&equo; 
 &bquo;Pas de probl&egrave;me,&equo; the peculiar foreign person gave a dismissive shrug and Sergeant Bramble caught a strong whiff of musky eau de cologne. 
 &bquo;Our friend here does not seem to appreciate that the world's greatest detective is conducting a criminal investigation and that he is not to be thwarted. 
 Now that you are here he will hand and deliver.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't do that there here, I'm afraid,&equo; said Bramble affably. 
 &bquo;His Majesty's mails are not to be interfered with. 
 This isn't France.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mean Belgium.&equo; 
 The small man's eyes flashed and he looked awfully cross. 
 &bquo;Ma foi, the world's greatest detective is not to be interfered with either. 
 We are in the presence of very great evil, my friends, and the little grey cells must not be denied.&equo; 
 He paused. 
 &bquo;Did Sir Vivien perhaps purchase a licence for his dog from this office?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not at liberty to divulge,&equo; said the postmaster. 
 The detective looked from one man to another and flexed his moustaches. 
 &bquo;My friends,&equo; he said, &bquo;you will regret this very much.&equo;  
 Meanwhile in another part of the village Constable Quince had run his quarry to earth in the vegetable garden of the Manor. 
 She appeared to be taking herb samples. 
 Constable Quince hid in the potting shed and lit a Woodbine. 
 Presently the old lady came towards him, entered the shed and sniffed knowledgeably at a tin of weedkiller. 
 Constable Quince had retreated behind a stack of deckchairs and extinguished his cigarette. 
 Much good it did him. 
 She had spotted the cigarette smoke from afar and now she could see his feet protruding from under the canvas. 
 &bquo;Smoking is not good for the lungs. 
 Nor the complexion,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Size nine boots, Constable. 
 Unless you have a good reason for standing over there I should come out and get some fresh air. 
 It is a very clement day.&equo; 
 The constable emerged sheepishly. 
 &bquo;Do you play golf, Constable?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Can't say as I do,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If Sir Vivien had reached the fifteenth green at the time of his abduction and Bonzo arrived in the clubhouse at ten o'clock, we can assume that Sir Vivien himself must have begun his round at, shall we say, about half past eight.&equo; 
 Since this clearly required an affirmative the constable nodded. 
 &bquo;And as it takes half an hour to drive to Royal Wrigglesworth we must assume that Sir Vivien's Lagonda would have driven through the village at about eight.&equo; 
 Again the constable nodded. 
 The little old lady seemed pleased at this. 
 She had evidently decided that the policeman was a handsome as well as an agreeable fellow. 
 &bquo;Are you a married man, Constable?&equo; she enquired. 
 The constable said he wasn't. 
 &bquo;Nor,&equo; said his interlocutor cryptically, &bquo;is Sir Vivien. 
 Perhaps this is a case of cherchez la femme. 
 But come let us go to the garage.&equo; 
 Thus the day proceeded. 
 The two great detectives prowled up  and down the village street dogged by the two official policemen. 
 Sergeant Bramble and Constable Quince very quickly gave up trying to understand what it was that the experts were looking for. 
 It was perfectly clear to all four of them that the forensic skills, the intellectual abilities, the sheer weight of grey cellular matter, the brutalizing experience of countless similar quests, possessed by the real experts was infinitely greater than that of the mere professionals. 
 This was a case of Gentlemen versus Players in the golden age when such distinctions still applied and when it was obvious to anyone with an eighth of an intelligence that no paid journeyman could ever begin to compare with the rapier-like &bquo;amateurs&equo; who flitted with effortless superiority, solving one crime after another with a brilliant insouciance which was the dismay of the criminal fraternity, the envy of the constabulary, and a source of immense satisfaction to most of the upper middle class, especially those with an aptitude for the Times  crossword. 
 So when the great lady detective drew a hair from her head and stuck it across the lock on the front door of Sir Vivien's motor car, Constable Quince said nothing. 
 And when the great gentleman detective got hold of the village postman and subjected him to an interrogation which ranged from what he had eaten for breakfast to whether or not he possessed a wireless set and if so what he had listened to on the previous morning, Sergeant Bramble maintained a stoic countenance. 
 At luncheon all four of them fetched up in the saloon bar of The Rose and Crown. 
 A great detective might have considered this an astounding coincidence were it not for the fact that the hostelry was the only place in the whole of King's Magnum Parva where a lady or a gentleman might obtain a meal. 
 And even then it was only a matter of sandwiches or pickled eggs. 
 &bquo;Aha, my friend,&equo; said the great gentleman detective, &bquo;To pickle an egg in the English fashion is a chose extremely curious. 
 Today I would die for one of M&egrave;re Poulard's omelettes aux fines herbes. 
 But tell me, the English lady who sits with the  peculiar gloves drinking sherry wine with your colleague. 
 She is not, I think, a native of King's Magnum Parva.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Sergeant Bramble, &bquo;she's a stranger in town. 
 Just like yourself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ma foi! 
 That is a suspicious circumstance.&equo; 
 And the diminutive Belgian pursed his lips and frowned into his half pint of Old Parsnip Ale. 
 At the far end of the room the object of his attention was exhibiting a reciprocal interest. 
 &bquo;Tell me, Constable,&equo; she said, sipping her drink with maidenly primness, &bquo;the small gentleman lunching with your sergeant. 
 He is not, I think, quite English?&equo; 
 &bquo;Dunno.&equo; 
 The constable's speech was impeded by corned beef sandwich. 
 When he swallowed he said, &bquo;Leastways he bain't from these parts.&equo; 
 The old lady smiled to herself, a secret smile that implied that the final clue in her private internal crossword had slotted into place. 
 &bquo;Dear me,&equo; she said, &bquo;one is surprised to find foreigners in a place such as this. 
 That moustache is not an English moustache, the flower in the button-hole is from some foreign field and I fancy he does not care for his pickled egg. 
 There is also something about him which suggests that he is not unacquainted with evil.&equo; 
 She gave a shudder. 
 An involuntary shudder but a shudder nonetheless. 
 The police remained silent in the face of such speculation. 
 It was plain that the two great detectives were discomfited by each other's presence. 
 And both Bramble and Quince were relieved when their respective charges had finished lunch and set off again on their quest. 
 &bquo;Wild geese, mon vieux, is what you presume me to chase,&equo; said the gentleman to Bramble, &bquo;but I assure you the stable door is bolted.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh dear, oh dear&equo;, said the lady, &bquo;Nothing, but nothing, is ever what it seems.&equo;  
 And so, in the end it was time for sherry at the Manor House. 
 That sense of d&eacute;nouement, of the safety catch being taken off pistols, of seconds Leaving the ring, was almost palpable. 
 The police were baffled. 
 Never had they seen so much enquiry, so much question and answer, so much deployment of grey cells at one extreme and of gut intuition at the other. 
 Yet they were not downhearted. 
 For all was not  as it seemed. 
 Mrs Pettifer made a charming surrogate host in the absence of her master. 
 She greeted the ill-assorted quartet with genuine warmth and friendliness. 
 Nevertheless the atmosphere was somewhat fraught. 
 It was clear that the true purpose of this meeting went a great deal deeper than mere small chat. 
 It was the foreigner who broke the ice. 
 &bquo;Eh bien, my friends,&equo; he said, brushing a crumb of cheese straw from the lapel of his immaculately pressed suit, &bquo;it is time to make the beginning. 
 For in the beginning, as the bible tells us, is the end. 
 And while it may be that the tragic case of the disappearing baronet is one that appears to defy all logic, it is not a case that defies the world's greatest detective. 
 It is a case which, I am afraid to tell you, has its own beginning and middle and &mdash; alas &mdash; an end too.&equo; 
 Here, Mrs Pettifer began to interject but the small gentleman silenced her with a flap of the wrist which was altogether not very gentlemanly and proved too much for the great lady detective who made a more purposeful interjection of her own. 
 &bquo;This is very interesting,&equo; she said, &bquo;but I'm afraid that it is nothing more than a performance. 
 It is a very clever performance &mdash; what they call in theatrical circles a beautiful  performance. 
 But it is still no more than a performance. 
 Not real. 
 This person claims to be a great detective and yet he has detected nothing, nothing at all. 
 He has asked questions all over the village, but none of the answers have solved this dreadful crime. 
 And I can tell you why. 
 It is because the villain of this piece is none other than he himself.&equo;  
 There was a sudden silence. 
 You could have heard a pin drop if anyone in the room had dropped one. 
 Eventually the little man cleared his throat. 
 &bquo;Very ingenious,&equo; he said, &bquo;The classic smokescreen. 
 As soon as the villain is about to be unveiled what does she do, she throws the sand in the face of her pursuers. 
 In the chasse, messieurs, mesdames, the beast is at its most dangerous when it is cornered. 
 N'est-ce pas? 
 This little old lady is not so innocent as she seems. 
 Indeed she is not innocent in the least.&equo; 
 And pointing a trembling finger at her he said in a steely voice of condemnation, &bquo;Madame. 
 J'accuse.&equo; 
 Even as he uttered the words a strange noise could be heard from beyond the French windows. 
 At first Sergeant Bramble thought it was one of the latest Atco motor-mowers but it seemed to be coming from above them. 
 Mrs Pettifer spoke. 
 &bquo;I think,&equo; she said, &bquo;that you are about to have your problem solved. 
 Come with me.&equo; 
 And so saying she led the way on to the terrace with its beautiful scents of honeysuckle, rose and jasmine. 
 As they stood there looking east they were able to discern a small buzzing winged shape heading towards them over the immense Capability Brown park. 
 &bquo;An aeroplane!&equo; said Constable Quince. 
 &bquo;Well I'll be jiggered,&equo; said Sergeant Bramble. 
 The small bi-plane wobbled over the oaks and the elms, banked at the north end of the ha-ha and started to descend towards the huge lawn which ran, treeless along this side of the house between terrace and park. 
 It was a perfect landing. 
 The plane bumped to a halt, the engine coughed and died, and two figures in leather flying helmets swung out of the open cockpit and came towards them arm in arm. 
 One was a dashing, debonair young man; the other was a beautiful elegant girl with high cheek-bones and eyes of the purest grey. 
 &bquo;Hello auntie!&equo; called the man as they neared the little party. 
 &bquo;Hello uncle!&equo; echoed the young woman in a foreign accented voice waving cheerily.  
 &bquo;Mon dieu!&equo; said the little man, not apparently sure whether to be terribly angry or frightfully cross, &bquo;Nicole!&equo; 
 &bquo;I might have known it,&equo; said the old lady, &bquo;Vivien's such a naughty boy!&equo; 
 The couple tripped up the terrace steps and embraced their respective relatives with affection. 
 &bquo;Nicole and I are getting married,&equo; said Sir Vivien, &bquo;and we wanted you to be the first to know. 
 Mrs Pettifer, I think you can bring out that magnum of the widow now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Saving your presence sir,&equo; said Sergeant Bramble, &bquo;I tried to explain that there was nothing amiss and that you'd be back in time for supper with Miss Nicole. 
 But they wouldn't listen.&equo; 
 Nicole giggled. 
 &bquo;That's exactly what we expected, Sergeant. 
 We knew that the one way to get the world's two greatest detectives to come here would be to stage a mysterious disappearance. 
 Of course that nice Mr Hoskins at the Express  was in on our secret.&equo; 
 She turned to the two detectives. 
 &bquo;We telephoned Mrs Pettifer from Paris. 
 And she told Sergeant Bramble.&equo; 
 &bquo;I must say Nicole's a proper Amy Johnson,&equo; said Sir Vivien. 
 &bquo;She put the old kite right down in the middle of the fairway. 
 Super piece of flying, darling.&equo; 
 Mrs Pettifer came out on to the terrace with a tray, glasses and a big bottle of champagne. 
 &bquo;Paris?&equo; said the foreign detective. 
 &bquo;What better place for an engagement party &agrave; deux?&equo; said the baronet, pouring out wine. 
 &bquo;Pity we had to leave Bonzo behind, but we knew he'd be good at raising the alarm.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mes enfants,&equo; said the small Belgian person, &bquo;chers coll&egrave;gues, I am enchant&eacute; by your successes. 
 Mme Pettifer, my man Georges, I think, has consulted with you on the subject of the wines. 
 And the cooking also. 
 You, my poor dear lady,&equo; and he turned here to the other great detective, &bquo;have as one says &bquo;raided the vegetable garden&equo;. 
 We have established, have we not, that the public house is not worthy of a celebration dinner. 
 So,  with your agreement, Sir Vivien, your aunt and your uncle will entertain you at dinner chez vous.&equo; 
 &bquo;My dear Vivien,&equo; said his aunt, &bquo;I do commend you on your herb garden as well as on your choice of bride. 
 Your dear new uncle-in-law whom I was fortunate enough to encounter on the morning train from Paddington agrees that it would be nice if our friends from the constabulary were to join us.&equo; 
 &bquo;But auntie&hellip; 
 &equo; The baronet was incredulous. 
 &bquo;But uncle&hellip; 
 &equo; His fianc&eacute; likewise. 
 &bquo;You see dears,&equo; said the old lady, &bquo;no one, least of all a great detective, believes what they read in the newspapers.&equo; 
 &bquo;Which reminds me,&equo; said her friend. 
 &bquo;We took the liberty of asking our friend Percy Hoskins to join us for dinner. 
 He should be hear in a trice, for his departure from Paddington was scheduled, I believe, for nine minutes before five.&equo; 
 There was a short silence now in which anyone with good enough hearing to detect a pin-drop would have detected the sound of hundreds of little grey cells jostling and barging each other in frantic efforts to arrive at a perfect understanding of the day's events. 
 And then everyone raised their glasses in a spontaneous salute to the happy couple, to the perfect English village, to exotic foreign ladies, to the belle cuisine, to love, to life and above all, of course, to great detectives and their creator. 
 A F&Ecirc;TE WORSE THAN DEATH 
 PAULA GOSLING 
 Colonel Feather's card tricks were not going well. 
 Peggy Mitchell, seated at the rear of the Variety Tent, sighed in sympathy as, one after another, the right card failed to appear from or disappear into the deck. 
 Colonel Feather's face was getting red, and he was beginning to perspire. 
 The small audience had begun to fidget on their rickety folded chairs. 
 A child's piping question about the next &bquo;act&equo; &mdash; a professional juggler currently on the variety bill in a nearby town &mdash; was hurriedly hushed, as much by the Colonel's glare as its mother's whisper. 
 The Great Whirlo and his potential fan would have to wait &mdash; Colonel Feather was a determined man, and this was his moment. 
 Once again, he shuffled the recalcitrant deck, smiling too broadly, compelling their attention. 
 Peggy stood up and slipped out of the tent into the bright August afternoon. 
 They had been so lucky with the weather; a clear sky, and a soft breeze that kept everyone comfortable. 
 The colourful draperies of the various stands and tents billowed and flapped gently, as the denizens of Little Tuckett strolled about on the freshly clipped lawns of the vicarage garden, taking in the various delights on offer. 
 She waved to old Mr Pinkney, who was patiently manning the second-hand bookstall. 
 Hemmed in by idle readers, and knots of little boys scrabbling through the boxes of Beanos , Magnets , and Boy's Own  annuals, he waved back with a weary smile. 
 Mr Venables was overseeing the bran-bin, frowning Like an irritated camel. 
 Right next to him, Mr Doran was grinning  maniacally as he handed out squishy tomatoes for the parishioners to throw at their young vicar, trapped in the &bquo;stocks&equo;. 
 She beamed at her husband, bravely facing the barrage of produce, and winced as a particularly juicy specimen caught him right on the chin. 
 Poor daft lamb, she thought, affectionately. 
 &bquo;Oh, Mrs Mitchell! 
 Mrs Mitchell!&equo; 
 The thin, over-dramatic shriek was all too familiar. 
 Peggy turned. 
 &bquo;What is it, Peony?&equo; she asked, with practised calm. 
 &bquo;The water, ma'am, it's still  off. 
 There's none for the tea urns or the washing up or&hellip;&equo; her voice dropped dramatically. 
 &bquo;Or for the toilet, neither. 
 There's a queue built up. 
 People are complaining.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh dear.&equo; 
 She peered around at the various exhibits, squinting into the sun. 
 &bquo;I'm sure I saw Mr Clancy around here, somewhere.&equo; 
 Peony sniffed. 
 &bquo;Probably in the beer tent. 
 He has an awful thirst since he come back from serving in Egypt. 
 Maybe he thinks being a Sergeant in the Engineers makes him too good to work for ordinary folk. 
 He was supposed to come, yesterday, and never showed up. 
 Old pisser.&equo; 
 &bquo;Peony!&equo; 
 Peggy was shocked. 
 The girl was unrepentant. 
 &bquo;Well&hellip; you'd think a man with so many kids would make an effort, wouldn't you? 
 Unless maybe they're not all his.&equo; 
 She giggled. 
 &bquo;That's quite enough,&equo; said Peggy, attempting a stern approach to her audacity. 
 &bquo;I've told you before &mdash; if you want to keep your place at the vicarage, you can't go around saying such unchristian things. 
 You know Mr Mitchell doesn't like it.&equo; 
 Peony looked suitably chastened, but there was a glint in her eye that told Peggy there was plenty more she could  say, and would  say, if it weren't for the fact that she adored the Vicar with a passion that bordered on the obsessive. 
 It was only by issuing rather unconvincing threats of his disapproval that Peggy could keep the girl in line. 
 It was not easy for a spirited young woman like Peggy to be  the wife of a country vicar. 
 When she was eighteen and had actually been accepted at Chelsea Art School, she had been determined to be somebody wonderful, somebody famous, like Amelia Earhart or Margaret Mead. 
 But her girlish dreams of adventure had somehow melted under the gaze of a handsome young curate who arrived, one bright morning, at their local church. 
 They had married within a year. 
 David was a hale and hearty kind of cleric, and for a while she cherished hopes of missionary work taking them into some exotic foreign clime. 
 His rather surprising decision to accept the modest living of Little Tuckett had put an end to that. 
 Sighing over lands and wonders lost, she had accepted the inevitable. 
 She had been brought up a good Church of England girl &mdash; she knew the drill. 
 And being married to David made up for a great many afternoon teas and Women's Institute meetings. 
 But organizing and overseeing Little Tuckett Church F&ecirc;te had lowered her resistance. 
 The problem of the cut-off water supply &mdash; it had been off since eight that morning &mdash; had made it much worse. 
 Her patience in equally short supply, she found herself exasperated, not for the first time, by Peony's snide tongue. 
 But she stifled her annoyance, and smiled &mdash; the very model of a good vicar's wife. 
 &bquo;Well, I'm sorry everybody's moaning at you, Peony. 
 Tell them I said the water will be fixed, soon. 
 If I can't find Mr Clancy, maybe David can coax it to work.&equo; 
 She went to find her husband, and discovered him still laughing and ducking the tomato barrage, naked from the waist up but liberally coated with a kind of raw ketchup. 
 He was a totally happy &mdash; if less than salubrious &mdash; man. 
 It seemed a shame to disturb him, but&hellip; 
 &bquo;David?&equo; she called, over the laughter and teasing of the good-humoured crowd. 
 &bquo;The water's still off. 
 It's causing problems.&equo; 
 &bquo;Talk about Mysterious Ways,&equo; he grinned. 
 &bquo;I was wondering when I was going to be let free to do the work of the Lord.&equo;  
 &bquo;You mean the work of Mr Clancy,&equo; said Peggy, as he stood up and took the towel she gave him. 
 &bquo;And if you think you're going to get all that off without a shower, you're wrong.&equo; 
 She handed him another towel. 
 &bquo;Hurry up &mdash; I gather people are standing in line for the loo.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah &mdash; now that is  serious,&equo; he said, picking up his shirt and reluctantly easing it over the traces of tomato pulp. 
 &bquo;I'll attack the pipes with my new hammer.&equo; 
 David's approach to practical problems harked back to his days on the rugby pitch, often with similarly injurious results. 
 &bquo;I'll see if I can locate Mr Clancy,&equo; she said, in some alarm. 
 She went over to the Cookery and Refreshments Tent, but was stopped at the entrance by a pale-faced Constable Perkins. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid there's been a bit of bother, Mrs Mitchell,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Maybe you ought to wait outside, here.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why? 
 What's happened?&equo; she asked trying to see past him, 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; it's Councillor Phipps,&equo; the constable said, in a low voice. 
 &bquo;He's dead &mdash; dropped right down in the middle of the cake-tasting. 
 Doctor's looking at him now. 
 It's a shame, happening right here at the f&ecirc;te and all. 
 But we don't want to cause a fuss, now, do we?&equo; 
 Unfortunately, a fuss proved to be unavoidable. 
 &bquo;Poisoned,&equo; Dr Padgett said, standing up. 
 There was a shriek from the group of six women who stood back against the side of the tent. 
 &bquo;No!&equo; 
 Maxine Venables held her hands clasped before her as if in supplication. 
 &bquo;I never,&equo; she gasped. 
 &bquo;I never.&equo; 
 Dr Padgett looked puzzled. 
 Mr Catlett, Chairman of the Judging Committee, spoke low in explanation. 
 &bquo;He'd just tasted Mrs Venables' cake and was cutting into Mrs Feather's. 
 He was doing the cake judging for us, as he always does, every year. 
 Bit of a gourmet, he was.&equo; 
 Mr  Catlet , a plain and practical man himself, pronounced it to rhyme with poor-net. 
 &bquo;Said it were very nice, very nice indeed &mdash; and then he choked, went a funny  colour, ripped his collar open, waved his arms a bit, and dropped down dead. 
 Very shocking, it was.&equo; 
 &bquo;I never did it! 
 I never!&equo; 
 Mrs Venables insisted. 
 &bquo;All right, woman, all right,&equo; said Dr Padgett testily. 
 &bquo;I said he was poisoned &mdash; but not necessarily by your cake. 
 Did you change your recipe? 
 Use a new brand of anything?&equo; 
 Mrs Venables drew herself up. 
 She was a tall blonde woman, slightly overweight but still handsome. 
 &bquo;Not a bit,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Coffee g&acirc;teau, mine was, an old family recipe. 
 All pure ingredients from the cleanest kitchen in Little Tuckett &mdash; ask anyone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, you can see the colour of him,&equo; Dr Padgett muttered to Constable Perkins. 
 &bquo;It will mean tests, of course, but from his appearance and what Catlett described, I'd say cyanide. 
 It was very quick &mdash; he still has bits of various decorations and cherries in his mouth.&equo; 
 He turned and looked at the display of cakes on the long table. 
 There were six of them, five with small slices taken out and the sixth with the knife still in it. 
 Miss Pinkney's was a chocolate layer cake with cherries, angelica leaves, and pink sugar roses on it. 
 Mrs Doran's was a Victoria sponge with toasted almonds and walnut halves carefully arranged on the top. 
 Mrs Clancy's was a marble cake frosted white and decorated with chocolate curls and chocolate creams. 
 Mrs Yardley's was a plain sponge, but had been lacily covered with swirls and dollops and curlicues of golden buttercream icing dotted with candied violets. 
 Mrs Feather's cake was a simple white confection, quite plain in comparison with the others. 
 But then, Mrs Feather had never needed anything to brighten up her baking &mdash; she was a superb cook. 
 Mrs Venables' cake was &mdash; as she had said &mdash; a perfect coffee g&acirc;teau, smoothly frosted in caramel, with three cherries on the top. 
 A fourth cherry had been in the slice the Councillor had just removed and eaten. 
 &bquo;There was a cherry on your cake, too, Dorothy,&equo; Mrs Venables said, accusingly, to Mrs Feather.  
 &bquo;Yes, I know there was,&equo; said Mrs Feather in a soft, sad voice. 
 &bquo;That packet of cherries was the only decoration I had on hand. 
 I haven't been doing much baking lately.&equo; 
 She sighed. 
 &bquo;But I woke up in the middle of the night and couldn't get back to sleep, so I decided to bake a cake, after all. 
 I hardly had anything in the cupboard so I had to make do&hellip; 
 &equo; She trailed off, embarrassed. 
 &bquo;He could never resist a cherry,&equo; said a soft voice, and they all turned. 
 Mrs Phipps stood there, quiet, plain, dressed in dove grey, with a handkerchief clutched in her hand. 
 In the excitement, everyone seemed to have forgotten her &mdash; which was not unusual. 
 Her husband had always been the centre of attention wherever he went &mdash; large, handsome, charming: a vote-getter by trade and inclination. 
 There were tears on the unremarkable face of Mrs Phipps, but she had made no sound, from the minute of entering the tent until now. 
 &bquo;Oh, my dear,&equo; said Peggy, going to her. 
 &bquo;I'm so sorry, so very sorry. 
 Come up to the vicarage and I'll make you a cup of&hellip; 
 &equo; Then she remembered the water problem. 
 &bquo;Come and sit down&equo;, she said, and led Mrs Phipps to a chair by the useless tea-urn. 
 Constable Perkins, who had been enjoying himself at the f&ecirc;te, &bquo;patrolling&equo; the exhibits, had only by chance come into the Cookery Tent at the vital moment. 
 He'd kept the curious out while the doctor made his examination. 
 Now he drew himself up and Took Control. 
 He gazed at the women, and the small group of people who had been in the tent when the councillor actually collapsed. 
 Fortunately, most of the crowd had been drawn to the main attraction of The Great Whirlo in the Variety Tent at that particular point in the afternoon. 
 There were no teas being served and, anyway, everybody in Little Tuckett knew that either Mrs Clancy or Mrs Feather always won the Cake Competition. 
 &bquo;I'll want nobody leaving until I say so,&equo; said Perkins. 
 There were murmurs of both assent and dissent. 
 Some protested they had to get home, but their tone was half-hearted. 
 What supper  preparations could compare with this rare excitement? 
 &bquo;And nobody touching anything,&equo; Perkins went on, in a loud voice. 
 &bquo;Nothing &mdash; is that understood?&equo; 
 He glared at Mr Catlett, who quailed before this rare intimidation from a man who was normally jovial and kind. 
 &bquo;Touch nothing,&equo; Mr Catlett echoed. 
 &bquo;I quite understand.&equo; 
 &bquo;Now, I am going to make a list of those present,&equo; Perkins continued. 
 &bquo;And we shall eventually want to take statements from everyone &mdash; in particular, the six ladies who baked these cakes.&equo; 
 It did not take long. 
 One by one the members of the crowd trickled out into the f&ecirc;te, carrying with them the news of Phipps's death. 
 (&bquo;And maybe murder!&equo;) 
 Gradually there arose a faint humming from outside the tent as people gathered to talk and speculate, so it seemed as if those left inside were surrounded by a swarm of curious but not unfriendly bees. 
 Constable Perkins was torn between keeping an eye on the scene of the crime &mdash; and perhaps making a brilliant arrest &mdash; or calling up reinforcements. 
 But common sense, coupled with the prospect of the time and paperwork involved in interviewing the hundred or so people who'd been through the Cookery and Refreshment Tent during the past few hours finally defeated his hope for personal glory through brilliant deduction. 
 &bquo;I shall have to report this to my superiors,&equo; he finally said, when only Peggy remained in the tent. 
 Mr Catlett was deputized to &bquo;keep an eye on everything&equo; while Perkins went up to the vicarage to make his 'phone call. 
 Voices were raised outside as he progressed through the crowd, but he told everyone to &bquo;move on&equo; and &bquo;go home&equo;, instructions which, of course, were ignored. 
 They stayed outside &mdash; but they stayed. 
 The six competitors sat at the tea tables, together but strangely separate &mdash; each gazing at her hands or off into the distance, and never at one another. 
 Peggy and Mrs Phipps sat  together, slightly apart from the rest. 
 Peggy was determined to be sympathetic. 
 The trouble was, Mrs Phipps didn't seem to need sympathy. 
 She was perfectly calm, perfectly quiet, and had nothing to say, other than a reiteration of her previous statement, to wit, &bquo;he could never resist a cherry&equo;. 
 Was this common knowledge, Peggy wondered? 
 She asked Mrs Phipps, as delicately as she could. 
 &bquo;Why else would there be so many fal-lals and thingamajigs on those cakes?&equo; the widow said, wearily. 
 &bquo;They were all out to catch Henry's eye. 
 The fancier something looked, the better he thought it tasted. 
 Cherries, chocolates, walnuts, and anything in silver paper &mdash; Henry always wanted the best of anything and everything. 
 Thought it was his due. 
 I'm glad he's gone &mdash; I can do what I like, now.&equo; 
 It was the voice of a woman released, in more ways than one, from a life of obedient acquiescence to a stronger personality. 
 It was also the voice of innocence, Peggy thought. 
 For if Mrs Phipps been clever enough to manage her husband's murder, then she was too bright to make such uninhibited admissions, even to a sympathetic vicar's wife, other than in the knowledge that she'd nothing to hide. 
 Peggy glanced across at the six women seated nearby. 
 She had learned, over the past five years, that a vicar's wife is expected to be sympathetic, helpful, and above reproach. 
 To her credit, whatever other social solecisms the inexperienced Peggy might have committed during their stay in Little Tuckett, she had never betrayed a confidence. 
 Once they'd realized this, the villagers came to her often with their problems. 
 She had soon learned that almost everybody has something they want to hide, and something they're eager to share. 
 A great deal of gossip about the village and its inhabitants had thus come her way, from every direction. 
 It gave her a rather unique 360-degree view of the place. 
 She knew of at least one reason why each of these six women would have been glad to see Handsome Henry dead. 
 Miss  
 Pinkney's father had been nearly bankrupted through a failed business venture with Phipps. 
 Some said this loss of funds was what lay behind a recent broken engagement between the rather unattractive Miss Pinkney and the third son of a titled but impecunious family. 
 Then there was the question of the paternity of Mrs Clancy's last child: Mr Clancy had only just returned from Egypt after a two-year posting, and &mdash; as Peony had pointed out &mdash; the child was only 14 months old. 
 Mrs Doran's husband had been a loser to Phipps, both at golf and in the bedroom. 
 Had he discovered it, or was she afraid he would? 
 Doran's short temper and long memory were famous in Little Tuckett. 
 Mrs Feather's daughter Imogen had a brief, unhappy affair with Phipps, only last Christmas, and had subsequently left the village to care for an elderly aunt in Scotland. 
 Some said she'd left with a broken heart. 
 Phipps's latest conquest &mdash; he rarely went long without excitement &mdash; had been the childless and bored Mrs Venables, whose cake was the last he'd tasted, and whose husband was the local chemist. 
 Oh dear, Peggy thought &mdash; the local chemist . 
 And Mrs Yardley? 
 What about Mrs Yardley &mdash; oh, yes. 
 Of course. 
 Mrs Yardley's husband had lost his job recently, and Phipps held the mortgage on the little cottage they were so proud of. 
 They'd been in it only a year, but Mrs Yardley had lavished as much effort on it as she had on her beautiful cake. 
 Had Handsome Henry tried to foreclose &mdash; or, seeing how pretty Mrs Yardley was, had he suggested an alternative form of payment? 
 Peggy thought she knew of at least another ten people who would not really be mourning the death of Henry Phipps. 
 There could be as many more &mdash; dozens more &mdash; about whom she knew absolutely nothing at all. 
 As manager of the local estate agency and building society, Handsome Henry got around. 
 Had an enemy completely unknown to Peggy travelled to the f&ecirc;te in Little Tuckett with the express purpose of bumping off the fulsome Phipps? 
 If one such had done the deed, she could be of no assistance in the enquiries.  
 But if it was a local  person&hellip; 
 &bquo;Dear me,&equo; she murmured. 
 &bquo;I beg your pardon?&equo; asked the Widow Phipps. 
 Peggy saw with some dismay that she wore the distant smile of a woman reviewing her late husband's insurance position. 
 The tent flap drew back, and David Mitchell entered, cleaned up and resplendent in dog-collar and cardigan. 
 Apparently the water supply had been restored. 
 Peggy got up and hurried over to him. 
 &bquo;David,&equo; she whispered, drawing him aside. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid I know rather a lot of people who wanted to kill Mr Phipps.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, so do I,&equo; he said, gravely. 
 &bquo;Heaps. 
 Including me.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 She was shocked. 
 &bquo;He's been pressuring me to sell the land next to this house,&equo; David said. 
 &bquo;The very land on which he now lies dead, in fact.&equo; 
 He glanced over at the mound of tablecloths hastily borrowed from the tables of the unused tea-stall, under which the body of the late Councillor Phipps was now reposing. 
 &bquo;But &mdash; it belongs to the Church.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course. 
 But both the vicarage and the church itself are in desperate need of repair. 
 A word from me to the Commissioners might have swayed the sale in Phipps's direction. 
 He had a tame developer all poised to move in. 
 Kept saying something about building a parade of really modern shops. 
 He went on and on about it until I could cheerfully have strangled him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, fortunately for you, he was poisoned,&equo; said Peggy, in some relief. 
 &bquo;Doesn't matter &mdash; I could have done it,&equo; said David, pointedly. 
 &bquo;In fact, from what Perkins was just telling his inspector on the telephone, anybody might have slipped into the Cookery Tent before the judging and put a poisoned cherry into temptation's way for Henry Phipps.&equo; 
 &bquo;Only somebody who knew his weakness for them,&equo; said Peggy. 
 &bquo;You usually have to know someone quite well to hate them,&equo;  
 David observed. 
 &bquo;And a lot of people knew him very well indeed, believe me.&equo; 
 Peggy was all too aware of that. 
 Questions of Morality and Christian Virtue aside, she didn't really blame all the women Henry Phipps had conquered for succumbing to his wiles. 
 Life in a small village could be deadly dull, and Henry had been absolutely charming when he chose to be. 
 The difficulty was, he'd chosen to be charming so very, very often. 
 Why, even Peggy herself had been one of his targets &mdash; until he realized there was no chance for him there. 
 If David had ever learned of the things Phipps had said to her, he would probably&hellip; 
 &bquo;Oh dear,&equo; she said, again. 
 They stared at one another in dismay, the sad, small wickedness of their friends and neighbours strewn around their minds like dirty confetti from a party long past. 
 Henry Phipps had been the chief celebrant at this particular form of &bquo;get-together&equo;, and now someone had brought his priapic revels to a rather spectacular end. 
 Constable Arthur Perkins was a phlegmatic man, resigned long ago to losing his hair and his prospects for promotion as he worked out his years in an area singularly free of serious crime. 
 This was only his second murder in eighteen years, and he was somewhat annoyed by it, coming as it did during the best fishing of the year, and right at the time when his garden was at its peak. 
 Murder, he felt, was a winter occupation &mdash; dark deeds were suited to dark months. 
 Not now, and surely not here, in these gaudy summer surroundings. 
 He glared at the people who surrounded the tent, and they glared back, wanting action. 
 Well, he thought, they'll have plenty of action when my Inspector gets here. 
 Meanwhile &mdash; and he crossed his arms as it to underline the point &mdash; nobody gets in and nobody gets out. 
 Leaving David with Mr Catlett, Peggy went back to the table and sat down. 
 &bquo;The police will be here soon,&equo; she said, quietly.  
 &bquo;Constable Perkins is here,&equo; Mrs Clancy said. 
 &bquo;Yes, I know. 
 But there will be a great many more, soon, and they'll be asking a great many questions.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh dear,&equo; Mrs Feather said. 
 &bquo;And it's so hot.&equo; 
 That was true enough. 
 With the tent flap closed, the heat had been building up under the canvas. 
 Mrs Feather looked quite pale, and there was a constant and discreet pressing of handkerchiefs to the upper lips and foreheads of all the women. 
 &bquo;Perhaps if we tried to get things straight in our minds now, it might hurry the enquiry along,&equo; Peggy suggested, casually. 
 &bquo;I really don't see what good that would do,&equo; snapped Miss Pinkney. 
 &bquo;Oh, anything to get it settled,&equo; said Mrs Doran, glaring at the spinster beside her. 
 &bquo;I have a hairdressing appointment at four.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, we could start by working out exactly how and when the cakes arrived.&equo; 
 said Peggy. 
 &bquo;They're not easy things to carry, after all.&equo; 
 It transpired that each woman had packed up her own cake to bring to the f&ecirc;te. 
 Mrs Yardley had re-used a proper cake box from a city bakery; Mrs Doran, Miss Pinkney and Mrs Clancy had used their usual cake tins; and Mrs Feather and Mrs Venables had used ordinary cardboard boxes. 
 And they'd all packed them up this morning. 
 &bquo;Did anyone help you to get the cakes out of  their containers for the judging?&equo; 
 Peggy asked. 
 &bquo;I mean, I expect it's difficult to manage without harming them.&equo; 
 No &mdash; each lady had personally placed her cake on the long table &mdash; without assistance. 
 But then Mr Clancy and Mr Venables, who had been standing by to offer encouragement, had fallen into an argument concerning position. 
 Mr Doran had moved his wife's cake to the first position, and Mr Clancy had moved it back to the middle, saying the first cake tasted had the best chance, and his wife's cake would be first as it had got there first. 
 Mr Venables disagreed and made some claim about tastebuds and their &bquo;overstimulation&equo;. 
 Mr Clancy was not impressed  by this scientific distraction, and said so. 
 Vehemently. 
 Colonel Feather had then expressed a worry that children could easily reach over and scoop up a fingerful of frosting, perhaps spoiling someone's chances, so he and Mr Doran &mdash; the latter complaining mightily about his lumbago &mdash; had moved the cakes to the back of the table. 
 Agreeing that the cakes should be protected, Mr Pinkney had set up a sort of cr&ecirc;pe paper barrier along the front of the display. 
 There was one exception. 
 Mr Yardley, according to his wife, had never set foot in the tent. 
 &bquo;He just dropped me off,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;He had to go to Burford to see someone about a new job.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I  saw your husband come into the tent while you were over at the tombola,&equo; Mrs Doran said to Mrs Yardley. 
 &bquo;Oh, you couldn't have,&equo; Mrs Yardley protested. 
 &bquo;Well, I did ,&equo; said Mrs Doran, piqued. 
 &bquo;What's more, he was hanging around the cake display, looking rather shifty, if you ask me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, nobody asked you,&equo; huffed Mrs Yardley. 
 Peggy pressed her lips together. 
 Trying to find out who had direct access to the cakes had proved nothing. 
 Apparently all of the husbands &mdash; or, in the case of Miss Pinkney, her father &mdash; had had the opportunity. 
 Even young Mr Yardley had to be a possibility, if Mrs Doran was right and he had been &bquo;hanging around&equo; the tent instead of pursuing job opportunities in Burford. 
 Poison was traditionally a &bquo;woman's weapon&equo; &mdash; but would a woman bake a cake for a competition and then put poison on it? 
 Hardly likely, since tests would immediately reveal her guilt. 
 But a decoration &mdash; that was different. 
 What if it had originally been on one of the other cakes? 
 It could have been switched around by anyone, hoping to lay the blame elsewhere. 
 Or it could have been brought in and substituted. 
 Or even added to others already there. 
 She looked over at the long table. 
 The six cakes sat there, apparently innocent and, oddly enough, still appetizing. 
 In previous years the competition cakes had been  auctioned off to benefit the Belltower Restoration Fund &mdash; and that had been the intention this year, too &mdash; but there would be no bidders, now. 
 Mrs Doran smiled at young Mrs Yardley. 
 &bquo;Wouldn't be the first time your husband's come back when you didn't expect him, would it?&equo; 
 Her tone was very unpleasant. 
 &bquo;Maybe he's keeping an eye on you.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean by that?&equo; 
 Mrs Yardley demanded, her cheeks flaming. 
 Mrs Doran just smiled &mdash; and it was not a pleasant smile. 
 &bquo;That was unkind,&equo; said Mrs Feather to Mrs Doran in a reproachful tone, as Mrs Yardley began to sniffle. 
 &bquo;I'm not feeling particularly kind at the moment,&equo; Mrs Doran snapped. 
 &bquo;I'm not surprised,&equo; said Mrs Clancy. 
 &bquo;I hear your husband was blackballed when he tried to join the Country Club. 
 Wonder 
 who did that?&equo; 
 Mrs Doran stiffened. 
 &bquo;That's not true!&equo; she said, but her voice betrayed her. 
 Miss Pinkney spoke up, her small voice carrying a waspish sting. 
 &bquo;Some people never learn.&equo; 
 Mrs Doran's lips drew back in a snarl. 
 &bquo;And some people learn just in time. 
 Too bad Henry Phipps happened to mention your father's debts to that chinless wonder you had on the string. 
 That will teach your father to allow your &bquo;admirers&equo; to visit the Black Lion.&equo; 
 Miss Pinkney went scarlet. 
 &bquo;Geoffrey didn't care that we were poor, it was nothing to do with that. 
 I decided I didn't want to get married. 
 In fact, I sent Geoffrey away, if you must know!&equo; she shrilled. 
 &bquo;And now somebody has sent Henry Phipps away &mdash; for good,&equo; Mrs Venables said, and laughed &mdash; or tried to. 
 &bquo;If he'd gone away a long time ago, it would have been better,&equo; said Mrs Clancy wryly. 
 &bquo;There's altogether too much said at the Black Lion,&equo; Mrs  Yardley said darkly. 
 &bquo;And too much heard,&equo; Mrs Venables agreed. 
 Mrs Feather drew a long breath and let it out. 
 &bquo;I wish you'd all stop this,&equo; she said, rubbing her forehead. 
 &bquo;Has Dr Padgett gone? 
 I have such a headache.&equo; 
 She did look unwell &mdash; her face was pale. 
 &bquo;I haven't been sleeping well, lately.&equo; 
 &bquo;Guilty conscience?&equo; asked Mrs Clancy unpleasantly. 
 &bquo;Bad dreams?&equo; 
 Mrs Venables suggested. 
 &bquo;No &mdash; it was the telephone. 
 It rang around four o'clock and woke us up. 
 Marcus said it was some idiot wanting the Water Company.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's a burst main at Nether Hassett,&equo; Mrs Clancy said knowledgeably. 
 &bquo;They wanted my George up there, yesterday. 
 He was gone all  day, and come back late for supper.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hmmphh,&equo; said Mrs Venables. 
 &bquo;Your precious George can't have done much good if the main burst again .&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps that's why our  water went off this morning,&equo; Peggy mused. 
 &bquo;Well, they never called him back, and lucky for them,&equo; Mrs Clancy said. 
 &bquo;If it was four in the morning, he'd have told them what to do with their water main.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's usually our number they ring,&equo; Miss Pinkney said. 
 &bquo;Our number's only one digit different from the Water Company's. 
 Father's complained again and again.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, all I know is, I couldn't get back to sleep,&equo; said Mrs Feather wearily. 
 &bquo;I never can, once I'm woken. 
 My mind just goes on and on&hellip; 
 &equo; She looked bleak at the recollection of those dark hours. 
 &bquo;Well, my  conscious is clear,&equo; Miss Pinkney said archly. 
 &bquo;I sleep like a baby.&equo; 
 &bquo;You surprise me,&equo; said Mrs Venables. 
 &bquo;Considering the Council is planning to close down the Library because you can't keep track of things properly.&equo; 
 &bquo;No doubt you  take sleeping pills,&equo; said Mrs Clancy. 
 &bquo;Your husband has so many  potions and mixtures on his shelves.&equo;  
 &bquo;Oh, yes &mdash; wasn't there something about a wrong prescription last year?&equo; 
 Mrs Yardley asked. 
 &bquo;Didn't he poison  someone?&equo; 
 &bquo;How dare you!&equo; said Mrs Venables, going white. 
 &bquo;I think you're all disgusting,&equo; Mrs Doran sniffed. 
 &bquo;And poor Mrs Phipps, with her husband lying there&hellip;&equo; 
 Mrs Phipps stirred. 
 &bquo;I don't particularly need your sympathy, Hazel Doran,&equo; she said. 
 She looked at each of the women in turn. 
 &bquo;Or anyone else's.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know what you mean,&equo; Mrs Doran said stiffly. 
 &bquo;She means you're all hypocrites,&equo; said Shirley Yardley in an accusing tone. 
 Her eyes filled with tears &mdash; whether of shame, frustration, or grief it was difficult to tell. 
 &bquo;You all  had good reason for wanting Henry Phipps dead.&equo; 
 &bquo;So did your husband,&equo; hissed Mrs Doran. 
 &bquo;So did Henry's wife,&equo; snapped Mrs Venables, stung by Mrs Phipps's collective rejection of their doubtful sympathy. 
 &bquo;I don't deny it,&equo; Mrs Phipps agreed. 
 &bquo;I'm glad he's gone. 
 I'm just waiting to see who I have to thank for it.&equo; 
 She looked around the tent, her pale eyes filled with simple curiosity, and then looked back at Peggy. 
 &bquo;Who do you think I should thank, Mrs Mitchell?&equo; 
 Peggy shook her head, unable to speak. 
 Suspecting was one thing &mdash; accusing was quite another. 
 The heat in the tent, the pinched faces and the angry voices were all becoming unbearable. 
 She couldn't face them a minute longer. 
 Especially not one of them. 
 She stood up, abruptly. 
 &bquo;If the water is back on, I'll get Peony to make some tea or some nice fresh lemonade. 
 I think we all need cooling down,&equo; she said, and left them to their bitter devices. 
 &bquo;What is it, Peggy?&equo; asked David. 
 Something in her face, in her eyes, in the clenched line of her jaw, had made him hurry out of the tent after her. 
 &bquo;I think I know who did it,&equo; she said miserably. 
 &bquo;Then you must say,&equo; David told her.  
 &bquo;Not until I'm certain&equo; she said and went slowly toward the vicarage &mdash; and the telephone. 
 He was still in the Variety Tent, sitting on one of the rickety chairs. 
 Peggy sat down beside him. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid it's going to have to come out, Colonel Feather,&equo; she said gently. 
 &bquo;They'll soon find the evidence they need, once they know where to look.&equo; 
 He fixed her with a bloodshot eye. 
 &bquo;Evidence?&equo; 
 &bquo;That you killed Henry Phipps.&equo; 
 For a moment he glared at her, opened his mouth to deny everything, and then slumped in the chair, which creaked in protest. 
 &bquo;Man of action,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Always was. 
 See an opportunity, seize it. 
 That's how you win wars.&equo; 
 And lose battles, Peggy thought. 
 She waited, then spoke softly. 
 &bquo;Was it your daughter, Imogen, who made that trunk call from Scotland this morning?&equo; 
 He sighed, and shook his head. 
 &bquo;No. 
 It was my sister. 
 Imogen is dead. 
 And the baby, too. 
 It happened very quickly, she said. 
 Haemorrhage, complications&hellip;.&equo; 
 His bleary eyes filled with tears but he tilted his head back and glared at the top of the tent. 
 &bquo;I couldn't find the words to tell Dorothy, so I said it was a wrong number. 
 Was going to tell her this morning, but when I came downstairs and saw her packing up that cake &mdash; when I remembered he  was going to be there, that I'd have to see his smug damned face, hear that ghastly loud laugh of his&hellip; 
 I couldn't stand it. 
 I saw the cherry and realized an opportunity was at hand. 
 Had just the stuff in the shed. 
 Should have got rid of it years ago, but hadn't. 
 Fate, perhaps? 
 No? 
 Well, have it your own way. 
 While the wife was getting dressed I took another cherry from the packet and prepared the thing. 
 I planned to switch them when we got here &mdash; just sleight of hand, you know. 
 Work of a moment.&equo; 
 He riffled the deck of cards he still held, then faced her. 
 &bquo;I gave him an even chance, of course.&equo; 
 &bquo;An even chance?&equo; 
 Peggy asked, in some surprise. 
 &bquo;Absolutely.&equo; 
 The Colonel apparently had his own rules about  such things. 
 &bquo;I put the poisoned cherry there, I admit that. 
 If he hadn't  eaten it, I would have bought the cake at the auction and got rid of it. 
 But he did eat it, and I thought he would. 
 His own greed killed him, you see. 
 Took what didn't belong to him, as usual. 
 You could say he killed himself, really.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't think that would hold up in court,&equo; said Peggy softly. 
 Or in Heaven, she thought. 
 &bquo;No?&equo; 
 The Colonel shrugged. 
 &bquo;Well, I shall get a good lawyer. 
 We'll have a go.&equo; 
 He glanced at her. 
 There was no guilt in his eyes &mdash; only grim satisfaction. 
 &bquo;How did you know?&equo; 
 Peggy took no pleasure in the telling. 
 &bquo;I checked with the Exchange about your early morning caller and they said it wasn't local, but a connection from Edinburgh. 
 You hadn't told your wife about it, so I thought it was probably bad news, and that it might have upset you enough to &mdash; well, to do something. 
 You see, whoever put that poisoned cherry on the cake must have got sugar on his hands, but couldn't lick them because of the poison, and couldn't wash them because there was no water available. 
 Wiping them might have been enough for most people &mdash; but not for somebody who was trying to do card tricks.&equo; 
 The Colonel looked down. 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Sticky fingers.&equo; 
 He smiled at her in wry relief. 
 &bquo;Thank you, my dear. 
 for a while there I thought I was losing my touch.&equo; 
 WEDNESDAY MATIN&Eacute;E 
 CELIA DALE 
 The Regent Theatre stood halfway down Shaftesbury Avenue towards the Piccadilly end, convenient for the Trocadero or the Criterion for those who like their after-theatre supper served amid gilt and chandeliers rather than in the garlicky hinterland of Soho. 
 It was a handsome building, much embellished by scrollwork picked out in cream, and topped by a tower something between a lighthouse and a campanile on which was displayed in enormous, twinkling light bulbs. 
 CISSY SALT AND FREDDY PEPPER in RING FOR ROBSON The Cheeriest Show in Town with Marion Conroy Bunty Baird Gilbert Forbes Jack Walker 
 Beneath this an equally twinkling canopy overhung a pavement inlaid with tiles of lilies and acanthus leaves leading through swing-doors to a foyer rich in crimson carpet, mahogany, plump banquettes, frames of photographs of the cast in this or other productions, a Box Office within whose highly carved confines the Box Office manager or his assistant lurked like priests in the confessional receiving through the pinched grill the whispered wishes of communicants. 
 In the evenings they wore dinner Jackets.  
 As did the House Manager who roamed throughout performances in the foyer or the staircases, the bars of Stalls, Dress Circle and Upper Circle, keeping an eye on programme girls (most of them certainly mature) who, in their black dresses and little aprons, ushered, sold programmes and in the intervals brought trays of tea and biscuits (coffee in the evenings), while in the orchestra pit the band (tuxedoed, although who knew whether their trousers matched) played pleasing music. 
 The crimson curtain, weighted with gilded fringe and tassels, footlights glowing at its hem, promised delights. 
 Backstage, however, things were different. 
 Round a side street, down an alley strewn with the detritus from Berwick Street fruit market, a scuffed swing-door gave entrance to stone stairs and passages like those of a tenement building. 
 Straight ahead big doors led on to the wings and stage itself; up one flight the star dressing-rooms 1 and 2. 
 Above again numbers 3 and 4 &mdash; and the lavatory for all; above again, numbers 5 and 6, and a sort of cupboard where lurked the two understudies and Johnny, the callboy/Assistant Stage Manager. 
 The air was close, soured through with the smell of size, canvas and stewed tea, and, around the entrance cubbyhole of Bert, the stagedoor-keeper, Goldflake cigarettes and the chancey whiff of Flossie, his aged spaniel. 
 It was a hot August afternoon, a Wednesday matinee. 
 The smell of rotten oranges from the alley was strong as the swing-doors were pushed open. 
 Bert looked up from his Star. 
 &bquo;Afternoon, Master Conroy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good afternoon, Mr Bassett.&equo; 
 He was a stout, rather handsome boy of thirteen, grey flannelled, pulling off a school cap. 
 &bquo;Come to see your mum, 'ave you? 
 Act Three's just gone up, so she'll be a while, but Miss Baird's not on yet. 
 Be sure and tap the door, else you'll catch 'er in 'er desserbil. 
 She'd like that, I daresay, but yer mum wouldn't, and can't say as I blame 'er.&equo; 
 He inhaled sourly and broke into a glutinous cough. 
 &bquo;Thanks, Mr Bassett.&equo;  
 Conroy folded his cap into his pocket and started up the stairs, then pressed against the wall as footsteps clattered down and round the turn came Freddy Pepper himself, big ears and horn-rims that were his trademark, in tennis togs above which his ruddy make-up glowed. 
 He did not acknowledge Conroy, but hurried on down with that glazed look of someone already encased in their next entrance. 
 He had come not from his own No. 2 dressing-room but from the floor above. 
 The door of No. 1, where his wife Cissy Salt dressed, was ajar. 
 Conroy continued up to the next landing. 
 The door of No. 4 was open, the room empty; No. 3, the room his mother shared with Bunty Baird, was shut, and as he came to it he heard a sharp crack, a yelp and Bunty's voice &bquo;Oh shog off, you silly old fool, beat it!&equo; 
 As he hesitated the door opened and Gilbert Forbes came out in a rush, his make-up smudged on one side of his face, his toupee not quite straight. 
 His tall frame, in its butler's black and white, seemed to vibrate. 
 He glared at Conroy without seeing him and charged back into No. 4, slamming the door. 
 Bunty, in a rather grubby pink kimono, turned from the mirror where she was padding her face with a caked flat powderpuff. 
 &bquo;Conroy, angel! 
 How lovely to see you!&equo; 
 She twined her arms round him and kissed his cheek. 
 She smelled warm and sweet, Like a marshmallow. 
 &bquo;Mummy's on stage, you're just in time to button me up.&equo; 
 He had known his mother would be on stage and her dresser Jessie in the wings waiting to help her with her quick change, and Bunty alone; but he had not bargained for her not being dressed. 
 He stood, scarlet-cheeked, as she moved towards the screen, throwing off the kimono as she went. 
 She wore peach satin camiknickers and no stockings &mdash; it was breath-taking. 
 From half behind the screen she called, &bquo;Tell me the gossip, darling. 
 How's school?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's the holidays.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course it is! 
 Silly me!&equo; 
 Garments fluttered over her head  and she emerged more or less inside a pleated tennis dress, sailor-collared but daringly short. 
 &bquo;Be a pet and do me up, sweetie. 
 I'm on in five minutes, that old ass slowed me down.&equo; 
 It was difficult to fasten the buttons down her back as she bent and moved about in front of the mirror, powdering, moistening, curling. 
 Besides, his hands were trembling. 
 She turned, all flaxen and pink and white, haloed by the naked light bulbs round the mirror. 
 She was only a little taller than he. 
 &bquo;What a useful boy you are, darling,&equo; she said softly, &bquo;Good at all sorts of things.&equo; 
 He was dumb as an ox. 
 &bquo;Find me my shoes, there's a pet.&equo; 
 Dazedly he saw them by the sagging chaise-longue. 
 As he bent to get them she stretched out her leg beside him, smooth and wet-white bare, a shabby pink mule dangling from the toes. 
 &bquo;Put them on for me, Conroy,&equo; she said, leaning back on both hands against the dressing-table. 
 On his knees he took off the slipper, slid the white high-heeled sandal on to her foot. 
 Her toenails were varnished pink. 
 He felt as though he were going under dentist's gas&hellip; 
 The door banged open. 
 &bquo;Why, whatever are you doing, Master Conroy?&equo; 
 Jessie, his mother's dresser, sidled in, a dress and Jacket over her arm. 
 He jumped up, scarlet. 
 Jessie was small and hunched, like a white-haired mouse, hardly visible beneath the garments she carried. 
 She gave Bunty a very sharp look. 
 &bquo;You'll miss your entrance, miss.&equo; 
 &bquo;Keep your hair on, Jess.&equo; 
 Coolly Bunty turned to give a final look in the mirror; then put her fingers to her lips and, as she passed Conroy, pressed them against his. 
 &bquo;You were marvellous, sweetie,&equo; she murmured and was gone. 
 Marion Conroy was on stage until the final curtain calls and came up the stairs with the rest of the cast afterwards, observing as she did that Pepper went into his No. 2 and shut the door but that Cissy opened it and went in after him, the wide-eyed  babyish stare that was the caricaturists' joy quite absent. 
 She entered her own No. 3 to find her son reading a copy of Playgoer  and Jessie creeping about hanging up costumes. 
 Strictly speaking, Jessie's services were shared with Bunty, but Bunty had no quick changes and was also a slut &mdash; her dressing-shelf was a clutter of blunted sticks of grease-paint, dirty powderpuffs, a mangey rouge-stained rabbits-foot, caked make-up towels, and powder over everything. 
 Besides, Jessie had been with Marion for years, following her from production to production, doing sewing and little chores in between times when Marion was &bquo;resting&equo;. 
 Marion, a ripely handsome woman in her mid-thirties, who had played a season at Stratford-on-Avon and toured as Mrs Tanqueray, was extremely displeased at having to share Jessie, let alone a dressing-room, and particularly with a chit like Bunty; but the Regent was small and naturally the two Star dressing-rooms, 1 and 2, went to Salt and Pepper, that perennial and professionally married pair of comedy-thriller performers whose productions never ran for less than a year &mdash; a godsend in a profession where rehearse for three weeks, open and close in two was not unusual. 
 So Marion, back on the boards after the death of her boring solicitor husband some years ago, compressed her lips and maintained as well as possible the stately calm that so well suited her part as the Balkan Countess whose family jewels were stolen in this season's Salt and Pepper offering (Robson the butler was the master crook, in league with the Countess's French maid). 
 She greeted her son with a nod and relief that Bunty had lagged behind on the stairs, giggling with some others. 
 &bquo;Not a good audience,&equo; she declared from behind the screen as Jessie helped her out of her dress, &bquo;Typical matinee. 
 And some silly woman crashed her tray to the floor just as I made my second entrance &mdash; disgraceful!&equo; 
 She emerged in a dressing-gown and sat down to remove her make-up. 
 &bquo;Are you hungry, Conroy? 
 I don't feel I can face more than a snack in this heat&hellip;&equo; 
 The door flew open and Bunty danced in. 
 &bquo;Conroy, my pet,  are you still here?&equo; 
 His mother's voice was cold from behind the make-up towel. 
 &bquo;We shall be going out, Bunty, never fear.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh I don't care, darling, I shan't be here. 
 I'm going up to Jack's for a bite and a bubbly between shows. 
 It's too much of a fag to go out.&equo; 
 She bounced to the mirror to powder and tweak for a moment, catching Conroy's eye and giving him a wink. 
 Then she undid her dress (she could manage it quite well by herself, it seemed) and let it fall, picking up the kimono from the couch and wrapping it casually around her. 
 &bquo;So don't mind me,&equo; she said sweetly, patted Conroy's cheek as she passed, and was gone. 
 Marion and her son had an agreeable high tea of poached eggs on toast, tea and cakes, went for a little walk along Old Compton Street and bought some gorgonzola and a pound of cherries before returning to the theatre for the evening show; he was allowed to watch the first act from the wings before making his way back to Putney on his own. 
 There was plenty of time before Curtain Up at 8 o'clock, half the cast had gone out and backstage had a drowsy air about it. 
 Even Bert was not in his cubbyhole, but Flossie was and gave a languid thump of her tail. 
 There were no new notices on the wall-board criss-crossed with tape for messages, and Marion allowed Conroy to push open the big doors and go out into the cavernous darkness of the wings with their slats of scenery fencing the hollow stage, its set furniture dead beneath one working light. 
 He loved yet feared this place. 
 This empty stage, this empty auditorium beyond, agape like a hollow mouth, had more potency for his mother than ever he and his dry father had; its unreality was more real for her than their reality. 
 He could not comprehend but he could feel it. 
 The smell of canvas, dust and size pinched up his nostrils, a heady mysterious smell, sweet and sour at once. 
 He shivered. 
 And then, tearing the silence, came a scream.  
 Dressing-room doors opened, voices questioned, feet clattered on the stone staircases. 
 And on the stone staircase, a few steps up from Bert's cubbyhole, Flossie barking asthmatically from inside, lay Bunty Baird, head down, her pretty limbs ugly in disorder within the flimsy disarray of her kimono, one white sandal still on her foot. 
 Shrieks, exclamations, curses. 
 Pepper, Cissy, Dorothy, who played the comic char, the Stage Manager Bob, his Assistant and callboy Johnny, all popped out of their various rooms like gophers from their burrows to gather and shout. 
 &bquo;My God!&equo;, 
 &bquo;Christ!&equo;, 
 &bquo;She's knocked out,&equo; &bquo;Lift her up&equo;, &bquo;Don't move her&equo;, &bquo;What happened?&equo; 
 Marion pressed Conroy's face into her bosom to hide the sight. 
 Jack came rushing down from his room on the top floor and threw himself down beside Bunty, cradling her head. 
 &bquo;What happened? 
 Oh God! 
 Speak to me, do something someone&hellip;&equo; 
 Freddy Pepper pushed him aside. 
 &bquo;Give her air, for God's sake. 
 Let her breathe, man.&equo; 
 &bquo;She's unconscious&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;She's dead!&equo; from Dorothy. 
 &bquo;No she's not. 
 Move her into Props &mdash; gently, be careful&hellip;&equo; 
 Gently they lifted the bedraggled form as Bert came lumbering down from the 3 and 4 landing, with Gilbert Forbes behind him, and behind him the trembling form of Jessie, wringing her hands. 
 Pepper and Jack carried Bunty through the doors into the wings and on into the Property Room, a cavern of furniture and baskets of props, rich with the smell of dust and old beer. 
 They laid her on the couch, Jack huddled at her side. 
 &bquo;What happened? 
 Did she fall? 
 Get a doctor! 
 She'll be all right.&equo; 
 But she was not all right. 
 She had broken her neck. 
 They stood around her in the stuffy room, aghast. 
 We must get a doctor. 
 &bquo;Too late.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you sure?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh poor little Bunty!&equo; 
 &bquo;The  police&hellip; we must call the police&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Cissy Salt, her baby face hard and cold as a coin, stood back from the couch and looked round at the trembling tearful group. 
 &bquo;There's nothing we can do for her now and it's House Full tonight. 
 Police would shut the theatre and I'm not having that.&equo; 
 &bquo;But Cissy&hellip; 
 &equo; Her husband gazed at her across the body. 
 &bquo;You can't do that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes I can. 
 Rita can go on for her, and Jack's understudy can take over as the maid, Rita's part &mdash; we'll make it a footman. 
 Half-way through the last act we'll call a doctor, and the police if you like &mdash; they won't stop the show then and the delay won't harm Bunty, poor little cow.&equo; 
 &bquo;But the police&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;It was an accident, we all know that. 
 She must have caught her heel and tripped, just rotten bad luck. 
 But I'm not refunding a whole House Full just because the police come in and close the show. 
 It wouldn't do Bunty any good.&equo; 
 There was a shocked but not altogether hostile silence. 
 Then Marion, still clasping Conroy to her, spoke. 
 &bquo;It might be as well,&equo; she said majestically, &bquo;if we all said where we were when it happened. 
 Did anyone see?&equo; 
 They stirred uneasily. 
 Jack, still kneeling beside Bunty and holding her hand to his cheek, said, &bquo;She'd just left&hellip; 
 &equo; He was crying. 
 &bquo;We'd been in my room &mdash; Ronny'd gone out, he always does between shows. 
 We were &mdash; fooling about. 
 I'd got sandwiches and some gin. 
 We &mdash; we knew Ronny'd be back soon, it was near the half-hour, so we tidied up and I kissed her and &mdash; gave her a hug&hellip; 
 &equo; He gave a sob, &bquo;and she went rattling down the stairs to her room the way she always did and then I heard that awful sort of slither and Bunty's scream&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;And where was Gilbert?&equo; 
 Gilbert Forbes, still in his butler's costume but without the tail coat and his toupee, was standing at the back of the group, his bald head pallid above his painted face. 
 &bquo;I was in my  dressing-room.&equo; 
 His voice croaked. 
 &bquo;I knew she'd gone up to Jack's &mdash; she always does now if he's alone, makes no secret of it. 
 I'd shut my door, I was reading. 
 I simply heard the scream and went out and looked down &mdash; Bert can tell you.&equo; 
 They all looked at Bert, standing behind Forbes in his old tweed Jacket, nicotine-stained moustache drooping. 
 &bquo;Me? 
 I daresay that's right. 
 I was so shook up by the screeching I couldn't rightly say what happened.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why were you up there?&equo; 
 Marion asked sternly. 
 &bquo;When Conroy and I came in you were not at your post.&equo; 
 &bquo;Answered a call of nature, didn't I,&equo; he answered sourly. 
 &bquo;We're not all bleeding camels. 
 I 'as to use the bog on the landing, don't I? 
 I never saw nothing of that Miss Baird, only Mr Forbes standing there like he says, and Jessie right beside him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, yes, Jessie was there,&equo; Forbes said eagerly. 
 Where was Jessie? 
 She was sitting crying on the bottom step of the staircase outside Bert's cubbyhole with Johnny, the ASM and callboy, who had his arm round her shoulders. 
 He looked up as Marion, Conroy still clutched to her side, came out through the doors from the stage, some of the others trailing behind her. 
 &bquo;I've only just got in,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;What a bloody ghastly thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;She caught her heel, she caught her heel,&equo; wailed Jessie. 
 &bquo;Of course.&equo; 
 Cissy was with them now. 
 &bquo;Those ridiculous heels. 
 And flying up and down the stairs full of gin and nooky &mdash; no wonder she tripped and crashed all the way down.&equo; 
 Her blue eyes were cold as slate as she turned to her husband. 
 &bquo;It's a pity you didn't run into her, Freddy, on your way to the Gents &mdash; I presume you were on your way to the Gents. 
 You might have caught her.&equo; 
 &bquo;And you might have heard her, darling.&equo; 
 Freddy pepper's voice was sharp. 
 &bquo;I noticed your door was half open &mdash; I presume  you were inside?&equo; 
 &bquo;Cissy, Freddy &mdash; if I might make so bold?&equo; 
 Marion stepped forward, statuesque with Conroy held to her side like Medea in her  big scene. 
 &bquo;Curtain up is in just over half an hour. 
 We're agreed, I think, that, ghastly though it is, there's nothing we can do for that poor girl at the moment, and that Rita can go on for her. 
 And Dicky can take over as a footman &mdash; he may need a few lines changed here and there.&equo; 
 She looked round calmly. 
 &bquo;It will be a lovely surprise for them both when they come in, Rita's chance at last. 
 Then as soon as the last act goes up Bobby will ring for a doctor and say that Bunty's had an accident. 
 And if the doctor wants the police the performance will be over by then and the house cleared before they can possibly get here.&equo; 
 She paused and mostly everyone nodded. 
 &bquo;And all we shall have to do is to stick together and confess that this dreadful accident did happen a little bit earlier and we all felt devastated but there was a full house and we all felt we owed it to the public that the show should go on. 
 Yes?&equo; 
 There was a grudging, muted agreement, Cissy and Freddy too preoccupied with their personal tensions to dispute Marion's dominance. 
 &bquo;Now,&equo; said Marion, &bquo;some of us must go back to that poor girl and put her decently in order. 
 And get poor Jack away and back to his dressing-room and fit to go on. 
 Thank God for a fixed set and no stagehands, and the electricians aren't in yet. 
 And Conroy dearest, go up to Mummy's room and wait there till I come, and try to pretend that all the dreadful things that have happened are just part of the play.&equo; 
 She gave him a little push and, in a daze, he followed Dorothy and one or two of the others up the stairs to the room that had been and still seemed to be Bunty's. 
 He hardly comprehended what had been happening; the reality and unreality merged together like a nightmare or a melodrama. 
 Bunty's death &mdash; lively, stupefyingly alluring Bunty who had stretched out her bare leg to him and put her fingertips on his lips &mdash; annulled by a group of people because a performance must go on? 
 He was used to contrasts: Mother taking morning tea in bed with an old shawl round her shoulders and her hair pinned  up under a boudoir cap, her face sticky with face cream as he kissed her good bye before school; and Mother in full evening dress decked out in false pearls, her eyelashes beaded with mascara, dominating the stage in any play's Last act&hellip; 
 But this &mdash; the group decision to put make-believe before reality &mdash; he could not take it in. 
 Nor enter that dressing-room. 
 He sat down on the top step of the landing outside numbers 3 and 4. 
 The concrete was cold to his bottom, and he stared at the stairs down which Bunty had fallen, his throat and his face and his eyes seeming to swell up in a great hot surge of grief. 
 And there, on the third step, upside down in the corner by the wall, was Bunty's other sandal &mdash; dainty lacy white straps with the arched instep and the two-inch heel hanging half off. 
 He focused, stared, reached out and picked it up. 
 It was light as filigree in his hand, the heel held to the shoe only by one fragment of cleanly cut leather. 
 He held it in his hands and began to blub. 
 &bquo;Oh master Conroy, don't! 
 Don't upset yourself, lovie, don't take on so!&equo; 
 He was aware of a shuffle of shoes, thick stockings, a dark skirt, a slightly stale warm odour. 
 Jessie had come out of No. 3 and now sat stiffly down on the step beside him. 
 She put out her hand to take his but at the sight of the sandal recoiled. 
 &bquo;Oh master Conroy, she wasn't worth it! 
 She wasn't a nice girl at all, truly she wasn't. 
 She was after everything in trousers, young or old, she'd have had Mr Pepper in the end, you mark my words, and then what'd happen to the Company? 
 And as to how she behaved to your mother you'd never believe it &mdash; cigarettes, mess, gin in the teacups, and never a please or thank-you. 
 Oh master Conroy, don't upset yourself, dear!&equo; 
 He sobbed and held the shoe. 
 &bquo;Oh master Conroy, don't cry &mdash; not a big boy like you. 
 You was big enough for her, I could see, but you're only a baby still really.,&equo; Jessie was crying now too, the tears swelling slowly out above the bags and pouches of her face and running into the wrinkles. 
 &bquo;The rudeness and impudence you wouldn't believe, to  me and to your mother. 
 She'd even got Bert's back up proper, over his betting and poor old Floss. 
 And there was poor Mr Forbes gaga as a gooseberry over her, never mind she was laughing at him all the time. 
 And Mr Walker behind locked doors between every matinee and evening. 
 But when it come to you, master Conroy, and you hardly out of short trousers&hellip;&equo; 
 She looked down at the sandal and with one worn finger gently moved the heel to and fro on its fragile shred of skin. 
 Her tears were easing and she gave a long gurgling sniff, reaching, it seemed, deep into her empty body. 
 &bquo;All the same,&equo; she said, &bquo;all I meant was for her to break a leg.&equo; 
 SPASMO 
 LIZA CODY 
 It was Nanny who told me the rotten news. 
 Nanny and rotten news seem to go together if you ask me. 
 &bquo;Magnus's mother has been to see your mother,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Poor Magnus has chicken-pox, so you can unpack that suitcase, Andrew. 
 Your trip to Cowes is off.&equo; 
 She isn't my Nanny. 
 She's Annabel's. 
 She has a black hairy mole on her chin, and I hate her. 
 &bquo;It's very bad luck,&equo; Nanny went on. 
 &bquo;But don't look at me like that. 
 And don't throw your suitcase on the floor&hellip; now you'll have to pick everything up.&equo; 
 She didn't understand. 
 &bquo;Temper!&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;If you carry on like that, Andrew, I'll have to tell your father.&equo; 
 Nobody understood. 
 I would have to have my tenth birthday party in the rumpus-room with the girls. 
 The summer holiday was ruined. 
 No yacht. 
 No Cowes. 
 No Magnus. 
 It was absolutely and completely spasmo. 
 Nobody cared. 
 It was all right for Annabel &mdash; she's only six, and as long as she can feed sugar to the milkman's horse every morning she's happy. 
 Little sisters are spasmo. 
 So are big ones: Claire was going to the south of France. 
 Her  friends didn't go and get chicken-pox. 
 They were all too old for that, and too superior. 
 Magnus, I thought, was a spasmo, spotty piece of elephant dung. 
 If he was ill, bad luck, but why did he have to ruin  everything for me? 
 &bquo;Don't kick the rug,&equo; my mother said. 
 &bquo;It's Persian. 
 Don't be so selfish, Andrew. 
 Think of poor Magnus.&equo; 
 Was Magnus thinking of me? 
 Was Magnus's mother? 
 If she chose to stay in London to nurse spotty Magnus instead of taking me sailing she was worse than everyone. 
 &bquo;It's spasmo,&equo; I said. 
 I must have said that several times already because Ma fixed me with a glittering stare and exclaimed, &bquo;If you say that word once more, Andrew, just once more, I'll send you to the Science Museum again&hellip; with Annabel.&equo; 
 I should have known better. 
 Ma was always at her most unreasonable on do-days, and I must have known it was a do-day because not only did we have extra help in the house, but Nanny had been co-opted into the kitchen to make pastry. 
 &bquo;She has cold hands,&equo; Ma explained. 
 &bquo;That's why her pastry is better than anyone else's.&equo; 
 You didn't have to tell Claire, Annabel or me about Nanny's cold hands; we had suffered from them most of our lives, but what that had to do with pastry was what Father described as a &bquo;female mystery&equo;. 
 He seemed to know a lot about female mysteries and I wanted him to explain. 
 But he never had the time. 
 We didn't see a lot of Father that year because he was in the Government. 
 &bquo;He wanted something in Dominions,&equo; I heard Ma tell one of her friends. 
 &bquo;And he's not the most cultural man, but I expect he'll accept all the same.&equo; 
 Of course he did: it made him more important. 
 But, although it was something to tell the others at school, secretly I thought he was important enough already. 
 All my life I have suffered because of Father being important. 
 &bquo;Don't disturb your father, Andrew,&equo; Nanny would say, &bquo;he's an important man.&equo; 
 &bquo;Spasmo,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;And don't say that word. 
 It's not the sort of thing the son of an important man should say.&equo;  
 &bquo;Spasmo, spasmo, spasmo,&equo; I said, under my breath. 
 &bquo;Go to your room!&equo; ordered Ma. 
 She was counting silver ice buckets for the do. 
 What did she need ice buckets for? 
 All she had to do was look at the champagne the way she looked at me and you'd be able to skate on it. 
 &bquo;It's your own silly fault,&equo; Claire said. 
 &bquo;You think people have nothing better to do than listen to you.&equo; 
 I might have guessed I'd get no sympathy from Claire. 
 She's always sucking up to Ma. 
 &bquo;What's this one for, anyway?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;We had a do only last week.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't call it a do,&equo; Claire said. 
 &bquo;It's a reception.&equo; 
 &bquo;What for?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't you listen to anything? 
 It's for the Berlin Dance Company.&equo; 
 Claire was excited. 
 I could tell because she was nibbling her fingernails and then trying not to. 
 Now that she was Claire could get any sillier, but she did. 
 &bquo;The exquisite Kezia Lehmann!&equo; 
 Claire said, and sat on her hands. 
 &bquo;They say she's the youngest prima ballerina ever to dance at the Coliseum.&equo; 
 That was not really Kezia's name. 
 It's just that I could never remember it afterwards, and anyway everyone seemed to pronounce it differently. 
 At the time I was not even listening properly. 
 &bquo;Ooh, a belly dancer,&equo; I said to annoy Claire. 
 &bquo;Everyone says she's exquisite,&equo; Claire said dreamily. 
 She wasn't listening either. 
 &bquo;Spasmo,&equo; I said. 
 Magnus could have made one of his rude jokes which would really have got Claire going. 
 That might have been fun. 
 But Magnus had boring chicken-pox and Claire ignored me. 
 &bquo;A bus-load of boring belly dancers,&equo; I said, and pranced around the room. 
 &bquo;Another boring foreigner. 
 I bet she's a Jew.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're not supposed to say that,&equo; Claire said primly. 
 And she  added something po-faced about toleration and talent. 
 It was the dullest reception ever. 
 It's always the same. 
 You stand by the window with a pathetic glass of lemonade while all father's secretaries drink champagne and try to make conversation with hoards of people who don't know enough to speak English. 
 Ma and Father shake hands with everyone and look as if they are having a wonderful time. 
 Claire, Annabel and I are supposed to help distribute the food, and let me tell you, at some of these do's it's like feeding a pack of hounds. 
 These foreigners are so greedy there's never anything left over for supper. 
 I don't know why Ma and Father make us come. 
 I considered slipping away to chew a mouthful of toothpowder. 
 I could work up a good froth and then make my entrance doing an impression of a rabid dog. 
 That might wake the foreigners up. 
 Actually I quite like the Germans. 
 Their soldiers really look like soldiers. 
 I'd like to have a pair of boots like a German officer. 
 Just think, if Magnus and I went back to school in boots instead of those horrible lace-up shoes, the big boys would have to watch out. 
 Even Father says the Germans are not a bad lot really. 
 Claire appeared at my shoulder. 
 &bquo;That's her,&equo; she said, tearing at a hangnail. 
 &bquo;Who?&equo; 
 &bquo;Kezia.&equo; 
 &bquo;She doesn't look very exquisite to me,&equo; I said. 
 She was no taller than I was and she wore a grey thing that looked like a schoolgirl's dress. 
 &bquo;Everyone says her extensions are spectacular&equo;, Claire informed me. 
 She pointed her right toe. 
 Claire was wearing stockings instead of socks that summer, and her legs looked funny. 
 &bquo;She hasn't got any extensions as far as I can see,&equo; I said. 
 In the grey dress Kezia looked as flat-chested as Annabel. 
 &bquo;Not only are you ignorant,&equo; Claire said icily, &bquo;but you are also  a filthy-minded little toad.&equo; 
 She went away. 
 I looked around, and it seemed that everyone was looking at Kezia. 
 A lot of them were pretending not to, but somehow she was the centre of an invisible circle. 
 She wasn't saying anything, but Ma smiled at her as if she had done something very clever. 
 It was so unfair. 
 How could Ma look like that at someone who couldn't even speak English? 
 And why was a country like Germany interested in anything as spasmo as ballet? 
 &bquo;You are not interested in the ballet, I think?&equo; someone said, and I turned around. 
 He was tall, and he looked as if he might be good at something decent like cricket. 
 Except he was a German and they don't play cricket. 
 I was about to say ballet was spasmo, but I stopped myself. 
 &bquo;Girls are interested in ballet&equo;, I said instead. 
 I did not want any stranger thinking I could be keen on anything my sister was stupid enough to find interesting. 
 &bquo;Ah, the manly sports,&equo; he said, and smiled. 
 He was quite friendly really &mdash; for a foreigner. 
 And he was the only one not swooning over Kezia Lehmann. 
 &bquo;You should come to my country, perhaps. 
 Our  young men are better entertained.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sailing?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 I am big for my age and I didn't mind if he thought I was a young man. 
 It was about time. 
 He wouldn't make me have my birthday party in the rumpus-room with the girls. 
 &bquo;Of course, sailing,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;And much, much more.&equo; 
 &bquo;Could I have a pair of boots?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 He was being much more friendly than Father who hadn't spoken a word to me all evening. 
 While we watched, Annabel wormed her way into the circle around Kezia with a plate of smoked salmon sandwiches. 
 I was thinking how funny it would be if I had switched the smoked salmon for ham. 
 Everyone knows that if Hebrews see ham they fall writhing to the floor and all their teeth drop out. 
 I was going to tell my joke to the nice German but he had  started talking to someone else. 
 Kezia refused a sandwich but she smiled at Annabel, and &mdash; I could hardly believe it &mdash; Annabel curtsied. 
 All the grown-ups smiled in that boring way they have when little girls are being exceptionally sick-making. 
 Annabel, taking advantage as usual, wanted to know how to curtsy properly, and Kezia showed her. 
 All the grown-ups clapped their hands. 
 Claire pushed forward. 
 family made of themselves in public. 
 Just then one of Father's secretaries, who was standing right behind me, said, &bquo;Such purity of line, do you notice, even when she's only showing that sweet child how to curtsy.&equo; 
 She thought Annabel was a sweet child! 
 That's how much she knew. 
 &bquo;They say she is on borrowed time,&equo; someone else said. 
 &bquo;They say her family is being held hostage to her good behaviour. 
 Utterly tragic.&equo; 
 That was the limit &mdash; what did she know about tragic? 
 &bquo;They say she goes like a stoat too,&equo; I said loudly. 
 That is what Magnus says about girls he doesn't like and it's very funny. 
 But I never expected the reaction it got coming from me. 
 Everyone stopped talking. 
 Father spun round, took three steps towards me and smacked me on the ear. 
 I was stunned. 
 You shouldn't hit children on the head: Father says so himself. 
 But he did it, right in front of a roomful of people. 
 Tears filled my eyes. 
 He didn't even notice. 
 He grabbed my elbow and dragged me to the door. 
 &bquo;What for?&equo; 
 I cried. 
 &bquo;What have I done? 
 I like stoats.&equo; 
 Everyone was watching. 
 &bquo;Out,&equo; Father said in his quietest voice. 
 &bquo;You've disgraced yourself once too often, Andrew. 
 And this time you've disgraced us too.&equo; 
 I caught sight of Claire, bright red in the face, looking as if she were about to burst into tears. 
 What did she have to cry about, I thought as I stumbled through the door. 
 Trust Claire to act as if she were the centre of attention. 
 Although, at that  moment I could have done with a little less myself. 
 &bquo;What have I done?&equo; 
 I repeated. 
 &bquo;I only said&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I know exactly what you said,&equo; Father almost whispered, &bquo;and unfortunately so does everyone else. 
 Go straight to your room.&equo; 
 &bquo;But what am I going to do? 
 It's spasmo in my room all by myself.&equo; 
 Father looked as if he might hit me again. 
 He said, &bquo;A public insult deserves a public apology. 
 You can think about that, all by yourself in your room. 
 Because, believe me, Andrew, there will  be an apology.&equo; 
 He just turned his back and walked away, leaving me in the hall. 
 &bquo;I hate you,&equo; I shouted. 
 &bquo;You're a bully. 
 You shouldn't hit boys.&equo; 
 The back of his neck went pink but he didn't come back. 
 I went upstairs, but I didn't go to my room. 
 I sat on the gallery floor and watched through the balusters. 
 When those silly women went to the downstairs powder room, I saw them go. 
 I know what they do in there. 
 They can't fool me with that &bquo;powdering my nose&equo; act. 
 Even that spasmo Kezia has to have a wee. 
 I thought about it and it made me feel a bit better. 
 I thought about writing a letter to The Times  and telling them about an important man who beat up his children. 
 That made me feel good too. 
 Magnus would have to take notice. 
 His mother might take me away to live with her. 
 She's a lot nicer than my mother because she doesn't have any stupid daughters to distract her. 
 Magnus's mother understands me. 
 It's so unfair. 
 Magnus has a far better time than I do. 
 It's probably because his father isn't important. 
 When Magnus wants something he gets it, and his parents listen to him when he talks. 
 When I grow up, I thought, I'm going to join the Socialist Party and become a spy. 
 I could make a floor plan of Father's study, and I'm good at listening behind doors. 
 I bet if I told those Germans downstairs what I knew about Father's job they'd sit up and pay attention. 
 You don't think all those men downstairs are what they say they are, do you? 
 Half of them are spies and secret policemen. 
 Everyone knows that. 
 I could give  them the key to Father's safe and they'd be so grateful they'd have a pair of boots made specially for me. 
 German secret policemen are funny. 
 They wear black suits with baggy knees and look like wrestlers. 
 I bet they're very strong. 
 I'd like to see Father go a round or two with one of them. 
 That'd teach him something. 
 Bullies are always cowards. 
 I was beginning to feel quite happy again. 
 I screwed my wet handkerchief into a ball. 
 I was about to throw it at one of the maids as she passed beneath me with a tray of glasses, but just then Claire came out of the reception room. 
 She was saying, &bquo;You can come up to my room if you like. 
 I've got a lovely mirror. 
 It's much better than downstairs.&equo; 
 Annabel appeared too, tugging that awful Kezia by the hand. 
 &bquo;See my room too!&equo; she squealed. 
 &bquo;I've got a camel. 
 A big camel. 
 It's the biggest one you ever saw.&equo; 
 And all three of them made for the stairs. 
 That made me move in a hurry. 
 I scuttled backwards and hid behind the curtains. 
 Magnus and I call girls the &bquo;Lower Breed&equo;, along with servants and foreigners. 
 That made Kezia a &bquo;Lower Breed&equo; on two counts. 
 Apologize to her! 
 I'd rather eat cold fat. 
 But a good spy is supposed to take risks, so after a while I tiptoed along the passage to Claire's door and peeped in. 
 There were my two sisters consorting with the enemy. 
 She was sitting on Claire's bed with Annabel beside her and Annabel's disgusting camel on her knee. 
 She was pretending it could speak German, chattering away in gobbledegook, and making Annabel scream with laughter. 
 What really made me sick was Claire, who was kneeling behind her, brushing her hair. 
 Downstairs you couldn't see her hair because it was all screwed up in a knot. 
 But now it stretched all the way down her back and Claire was making it shine like black oil. 
 Claire said, &bquo;I wish I had long hair. 
 It's beautiful. 
 I wish you could stay here for ever. 
 I'd brush your hair every day.&equo; 
 Kezia said, &bquo;I wish too, I could stay forever.&equo; 
 She looked sad. 
 Girls are always trying to make you feel sorry for them, but they  can't fool me. 
 &bquo;It must be quite difficult for you,&equo; Claire said, brushing, brushing, brushing the long black hair. 
 It made me feel funny looking at that hair, and I didn't like it. 
 So I didn't hear what Kezia said next. 
 But Annabel squeaked, &bquo;Why can't you stay with us? 
 You could have Nanny's room, next to mine.&equo; 
 Well, if that meant Nanny leaving I could almost support the idea. 
 Nanny is definitely a &bquo;Lower Breed&equo;, but she doesn't act as if she knows it. 
 Except Nanny would never leave. 
 In fact I think she will live forever just to spite me. 
 &bquo;Is it your family?&equo; 
 Claire asked. 
 What did Claire care about families? 
 She is such a hypocrite. 
 &bquo;Everything depends on me,&equo; Kezia said, and I nearly laughed out loud. 
 Girls think they are so important. 
 &bquo;I must go down now,&equo; she went on. 
 &bquo;I am watched, you see.&equo; 
 You didn't have to tell me that. 
 Everyone downstairs had been gawping at her. 
 I made ready to slip away down the passage. 
 But Claire said, &bquo;I wish there was something I could do to help.&equo; 
 A silence followed that, so I sneaked another look. 
 Claire and Kezia were looking at each other and saying nothing. 
 You'd have thought they were best friends or something, except that girls don't have proper friends the way boys do. 
 And besides, they had only just met. 
 But Claire is like that: one minute she knows nothing about a subject like ballet, and the next she's a world expert. 
 You should have heard her when she got that craze for Vegetarianism and Bernard Shaw. 
 &bquo;I think you are sincere,&equo; Kezia said next, and I had to stuff my handkerchief in my mouth. 
 Anyone who thinks Claire is sincere must have a brain smaller than a mouse dropping. 
 &bquo;There is something you can do,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;It is a small thing, and for you there is no risk.&equo; 
 &bquo;What is it?&equo; 
 Claire asked, eyes wide. 
 &bquo;I have written a letter,&equo; Kezia replied in a whisper. 
 &bquo;There are  friends of my family who are refugees in America. 
 Perhaps they can help us. 
 I cannot send this letter because I am always watched and I must never be a disloyal German.&equo; 
 That finished me off. 
 The girl must have cracked. 
 &bquo;Disloyal to letter boxes,&equo; I said to myself and went down the passage where I could laugh without being heard. 
 If there's anything that is totally spasmo it's girls. 
 From my place on the gallery I could keep a watch on Claire's door and on what was happening in the hall below. 
 People were beginning to leave. 
 Not the foreigners, though. 
 They always stay till there's nothing left to eat or drink. 
 Father came out. 
 He was saying goodbye to a wrinkled old man, all smiles and handshakes. 
 But then he turned towards the stairs and his face went grim and cold. 
 Obviously he had remembered me. 
 I made straight for the curtains, and he went by me without noticing. 
 He walked past Claire's room and turned the corner. 
 He was Looking for me. 
 When he was out of sight I pushed the curtains aside and ran downstairs. 
 If I could stay hidden until Kezia and the rest of the foreigners had gone, I would be all right. 
 Father's study was locked, so I dashed to the kitchen. 
 I don't think Father has been in the kitchen in his life. 
 But I had forgotten about Nanny. 
 She caught me on my way to the back door. 
 &bquo;Can't you see we're all busy, Andrew?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;No one has time to attend to you. 
 You're supposed to be making your guests feel welcome.&equo; 
 &bquo;They're not my guests,&equo; I told her. 
 &bquo;They're all spasmo.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't you use that word,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Now get along and behave yourself.&equo; 
 She forced me back into the hall, where I was bound to run into Father. 
 There was nothing for it: I would have to run away. 
 I had nearly got to the front door when Father appeared at the top of the stairs. 
 &bquo;Andrew!&equo; he shouted in that horrible voice which means you're supposed to do what he says instantly. 
 But I opened the  door and bumped into one of the German secret policemen who was smoking on the top step. 
 &bquo;Help me,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;He'll kill me if he catches me out here.&equo; 
 &bquo;Kill?&equo; the German said, like a parrot. 
 &bquo;Andrew!&equo; called my father from inside. 
 I had a brilliant idea. 
 &bquo;He's going to kill me,&equo; I said, &bquo;and I want to change sides.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sides?&equo; 
 The German was so stupid. 
 &bquo;You know, be a refugee,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Who wishes to become a refugee?&equo; 
 A tall thin man came out of the shadows at the bottom of the stone steps. 
 I ran down to meet him, but when I got there I saw that he had narrow eyes and a mean mouth and I didn't like him one bit. 
 I tried to run past him but he grabbed the collar of my coat. 
 &bquo;Who wishes to become a refugee?&equo; he repeated. 
 His voice was mean too: mean and foreign. 
 &bquo;Not me!&equo; 
 I cried, trying to pull away. 
 &bquo;It wasn't me. 
 It was Kezia. 
 It's all her fault.&equo; 
 &bquo;Kezia?&equo; 
 His eyes were so narrow they looked like gun-slits. 
 He pinched my arm. 
 &bquo;That hurts!&equo; 
 I shouted. 
 &bquo;What have you done with Kezia Lehmann?&equo; 
 He pinched my arm harder &mdash; just above the elbow where it really hurts. 
 &bquo;Let go of me!&equo; 
 I yelled. 
 &bquo;You've got it all wrong. 
 It's that ballet dancer. 
 She's upstairs with my sisters. 
 She wants to stay forever&hellip; she's, she's disloyal.&equo; 
 &bquo;Andrew!&equo; 
 Father appeared above me on the top step and I wrenched myself out of the man's nasty fingers. 
 I ran away as fast as I could along the pavement. 
 I can run as fast as Magnus when I try. 
 I expected Father to chase me, but when I reached the corner and looked back he was just standing there talking to the thin man. 
 They seemed to be arguing. 
 I'll never go back, I thought. 
 He's not a proper father: he'd rather talk to a foreigner than come and find his own son. 
 I had to walk all the way to Magnus's house in the dark  because I didn't have any money. 
 And by the time I got there I was very cold and hungry. 
 You would have thought Magnus's mother would have been nice to me but I bet Father had already telephoned and told her lies about me, because she made me wait in the hall until Nanny came to collect me in a taxicab. 
 Father didn't even send the car. 
 It was humiliating. 
 Of course I was sent to bed without any supper. 
 What else would you expect after the rotten day I'd had? 
 But anyway, the foreigners wouldn't have left much. 
 I don't see why we can't have a proper meal after a do. 
 They go to all that trouble to feed strangers and then expect their own family to do without. 
 There was one good thing, though: in all the fuss I hadn't had to apologize to Kezia. 
 I'd got out of that because by the time I got home she was gone. 
 There was no one there but the family. 
 Ma had gone to bed with a headache, and Father was shut up in his study making telephone calls. 
 That was quite a relief too. 
 Claire wouldn't speak to me. 
 I tried to tell her about the horrible man on the doorstep but she wouldn't listen. 
 The next day I overheard her telling Mother about how that spasmo ballet company had cancelled the rest of their performances and gone home. 
 She said it was tragic because of Kezia, and the way she went on you'd have thought it was all my fault. 
 The way I see it &mdash; if I had saved the world from a lot of boring belly dancers I ought to be congratulated. 
 But nobody ever sees things the way I do. 
 It was going to be a rotten summer. 
 Totally spasmo. 
 A LITTLE LEARNING 
 SIMON BRETT 
 SIMON BRETT WRITES: 
 A few years back, I bought an old desk at an auction and, when I got it home, found that the drawers had not been emptied by its previous owner. 
 He, from the papers I found there, I deduced to have been an academic of some kind. 
 In a miscellaneous pile of documents, I came across the following essay. 
 It seems to have been submitted as part of his doctoral thesis by an American postgraduate student named Osbert Mint. 
 Keen that the fruits of his scholarship should be made available to as wide a readership as possible, I have made strenuous efforts to trace Mr Mint. 
 These efforts have proved &mdash; regrettably &mdash; to be unsuccessful, and the essay is therefore printed here for the first time without its owner's permission. 
 THE LITERARY ANTECEDENTS OF AGATHA CHRISTIE'S HERCULE POIROT 
 There is a popular misconception in academic circles that the works of Agatha Christie are simply popular jeux d'esprit  which have no connection with the mainstream of English literature. 
 This attitude both belittles the quality of the author's work and also underestimates the wide reading and research which went into the creation of her most famous character. 
 Hercule Poirot did not spring fully-formed into life on Page 34 of his first adventure, The Mysterious Affair at Styles . 
 His genesis was part of a much longer creative process and must be seen as the  culmination of eleven centuries of English literary history. 
 Though Agatha Christie was properly reticent about the breadth of her reading, it is clear to the informed student of her works that they reflect a much broader and deeper literary frame of reference than is usually admitted to this particular author. 
 My essay will trace the pattern of references to other literary sources of which the author herself was sometimes no more than subliminally aware. 
 Though there were clearly classical influences on Agatha Christie's work &mdash; most obviously in the collection The Labours of Hercules  &mdash; they are not within the province of this study, particularly since the subject has been expertly covered by other scholars. 
 It is my intention to trace only the English language sources for the creation of Hercule Poirot. 
 The first unarguable influence on Agatha Christie's writings can be found in one of the Digressions in Beowulf . 
 The killing in Hrothgar's meadhall described in the ensuing passage was clearly the origin of the many Country House murders which were to feature in Hercule Poirot's investigations. 
 (The language of the extract has been modernized to render it accessible to the general reader. 
 Those fluent in Anglo-Saxon may prefer to consult the original text.) 
 Felled on the floor limp lay the earl, 
 Blood from the blade blackening his back, 
 While all the warriors, muddled with mead-drinking, 
 Snored in their slumbers, lost like the daylight 
 That darkness has doused. 
 One of their number, 
 A murdering bondman &mdash; hated by Hrothgar 
 (Bringer of boons, mighty meat-giver) 
 And by He who made heaven (granter of goodwill, 
 Holy helper) &mdash; unfairly faked sleep. 
 Wakeful eyes worked, lurking behind lids, 
 Knowing that another, whose sword he had stolen, 
 A goodman not guilty, a worthy warrior, 
 Would be caught for the killing &mdash; unless 
 One much wiser, a righteous unraveller, 
 A reader of runes, a conner of clues, 
 Might see through the slaying, righting its wrong, 
 And finger the fiendish one. 
 Though it might be fanciful to assert that this passage heralds the arrival of Hercule Poirot on the literary scene, it is clear that the Digression prepares the way for the development of the whodunnit form, and particularly of the private detective, &bquo;the righteous unraveller&equo;, whose task it will be to solve the murder. 
 Granting that the Beowulf  reference, though tantalisingly close to unambiguity, cannot be unequivocally accepted as a primary source for Hercule Poirot, the directness of the next reference brooks no denial. 
 It is indeed remarkable &mdash; and perhaps a comment on the tunnel vision of many in academic life &mdash; that no previous scholars have looked for the Belgian detective's literary antecedents in the most obvious of sources, the Medieval Mystery Play. 
 The very word &bquo;Mystery&equo; could not provide a much heavier clue, and I am bold to assert that Agatha Christie's inspiration to write mysteries featuring Hercule Poirot sprang directly from her reading of the following extract from the Harrogate Third Shepherd's  Pay in the Hull Cycle (&bquo;as it hath been divers time acted by the Guild of Chandlers and Gardners upon the Feast of Corpus Christie,): 
 The three Shepherds wake to find the fourth Shepherd, Mak, lying still beside them. 
 1 Shep. 
 Now by good Saint Loy &mdash; and eke by Saint Beth, Why ye lie here, boy, so barren of breath? 
 2 Shep. 
 Aye, why curl up coy, so still on the earth? 
 3 Shep. 
 Oh, gone be our joy &mdash; for that stillness be death! 
 He is dead! 
 1 Shep. 
 Now deep is my dole, for lost is his life! 
 2 Shep. 
 And taken his soul &mdash; how sad be this strife!  
 3 Shep. 
 His purse it be stole. 
 We must go tell his wife. 
 1 Shep. 
 In his back there's a hole! 
 It was made by a knife! 
 How he bled! 
 2 Shep. 
 Someone foully hath played, some forsaken swine This murder hath made &mdash; by evil design! 
 3 Shep. 
 At whose door be it laid? 
 Who's the cause of the crime? 
 1 Shep. 
 Let's see whose be the blade? 
 By the rood, it be mine! 
 2 Shep. 
 So then thou must be blamed! 
 1 Shep. 
 Nay, by our lakin's grace! 
 I slept right through the night! 
 3 Shep. 
 Then why scratched be thy face? 
 Why these signs of a fight? 
 2 Shep. 
 Why be blood in this place? 
 On thy sleeve it be bright. 
 1 Shep. 
 Now, by Saint Boniface! 
 What ye think be not right! 
 I've been framed! 
 Oh, would one come, that could prove me guilt-free! 
 2 Shep. 
 Soft, now what be this hum? 
 And this light that I see? 
 An angel appears to them. 
 3 Shep. 
 Be dumb! 
 Nay, drop to thy knee! 
 Angel  Nay, look not so glum! 
 I am come to ye three, As the scripture foretells. 
 2 Shep. 
 How his bald head doth shine! 
 Like an egg it be round! 
 2 Shep. 
 His moustache be so fine, I am nigh to a swound! 
 1 Shep. 
 Show this guilt be not mine! 
 Let the killer be found! 
 Angel  Aye, that villain malign I will catch and confound &mdash; With my little grey cells!&equo; 
 The next unarguable literary reference which Agatha Christie must have responded to is found in John Skelton's Speke, Parrot . 
 This poem is generally agreed to be made up of material from different dates and there are considerable textual differences between manuscript versions. 
 The most telling one, from  the point of view of this study, was found only as recently as 1893 in the Brestimont Collection. 
 It is actually entitled Speke, Porot  and contains the following significant variants of the first three stanzas: 
 My name is Porot, a byrd of paradyse, 
 By nature devysed of a wonderous kynde, 
 Daintily dressed, so dylycate and precyse, 
 Blessed with a quyte exceptyonall mynde; 
 So men of all countreys by fortune me fynd, 
 And send me greate crymes to investygate: 
 Then Porot the culpryt wyl incrymynate. 
 Cravat curyously clynched, with sylver pyn, 
 Properly parfumed, to make me debonaire; 
 A myrrour of glasse, that I may prene therin; 
 Mustaches ful smartly with many a divers care 
 Freshly I dresse, and make blacke my haire. 
 Then, Speke, Porot, I pray you, full curtesly they say; 
 Porot hath a goodly brain, to ferrit out foul playe. 
 With my backe bent, my lyttel wanton eye, 
 Fancye and fresh as is the emrawde grene, 
 About my neck a sylke scarfe do I tye. 
 My lyttyll leggys, my spats both nete and clene, 
 I am essentyale on a murdre scene; 
 Oh perfecte Porot, the lyttyl clever sluthe, 
 The clewes wyl trace, and always fynde the truthe. 
 The evidence in this extract is conclusive, and it can therefore be definitively stated that Agatha Christie's source for the character of Hercule Poirot was Speke, Parot . 
 But the author's debts to English literature do not stop with John Skelton. 
 In her development of the character of Poirot, she was clearly influenced by her reading of Sir Philip Sidney's  Astrophel and Stella , and particularly of the following sonnet: 
 CXI 
 Why I haue ask'd you here 
 O Fate, O fault, O curse, O crime of bloode! 
 What caitif could haue caused so foul a showe? 
 What coward turn'd my smiles to sighes of woe? 
 What joye-killer haue forced my teares to floode, 
 And caused Loue's flowres to perishe in the budde? 
 What trecherie hath brought this man so lowe, 
 Stabbd deeper e'en than Cupid's darts can goe, 
 That from his hart the beat no more shall thudde? 
 Were Stella's eyes the motiue for this crime, 
 Or stolen rubies, iuorie, pearle and gold? 
 I might! &mdash; nay, will! &mdash; if you should graunt me time &mdash; 
 The secret of this heauy case unfold. 
 To shewe the villain and to make all clere 
 The reason is why I haue ask'd you here. 
 There are so many other examples of literature from the Tudor and Stuart period which influenced Agatha Christie that it would be invidious to mention any of them. 
 I will therefore move next to the Augustan Age and another undeniable source-work for the expansion of the character of Hercule Poirot, Alexander Pope's Essay on Detection . 
 Almost every line of this surprisingly underrated poem is relevant to the subject in hand, but I will limit myself to the following short extract: 
 As in the World's, so in Detection's laws, 
 All force respects the Universal Cause, 
 Which Logic's enemies does but confuse, 
 Confounding those who will not heed the clues. 
 For, from the first, a mighty endless chain 
 Links clue to crime, and crime to clue again. 
 One all-connecting, naught-excluding line 
 Draws Logic's threads within its grand design; 
 As when a bloodied sword, by Vulcan's skill 
 Framed to inflict on man the greatest ill, 
 Be found imbedded in some chilly corse, 
 Inhuman stabbed with more than human force, 
 The first thought is to find and clap in jail 
 The owner of the sword. 
 Of more avail 
 Might be to check the angle of the blow 
 And whether struck from left or right to know. 
 If from the left, you wrongly would indict 
 The owner of a sword who used his right. 
 The true Detective to such ploys is wise, 
 Nor lets the smallest thing evade his eyes. 
 Though falsely led, his true mind does not stray, 
 But follows through its thesis all the way, 
 Nor does forget, but mightily esteems 
 That One Great Truth: &bquo;All is not what it seems.&equo; 
 That Agatha Christie's reading was wide-ranging cannot now be denied, but, even so, the source of one of Hercule Poirot's favourite ploys &mdash; almost, it could be said, his trademark, the gathering together of the suspects at the climax of one of his investigations &mdash; is surprising. 
 It was only after extensive reading through the writings of many authors that I came across the work which undoubtedly gave the author this particular inspiration. 
 Here, from a late volume of The Scot Musical Museum , is the poem which clinches my argument. 
 Though published anonymously, it is undoubtedly the work of Robert Burns: 
 CA' THE BURGIES TAE THE BOGGIN CHORUS. 
 Ca' the burgies tae the boggin. 
 Whaur the willie-paugh be troggin. 
 Seel&amp;supe' a' windies&amp;supf wi' the woggin, 
 My dearie-oh, my dork.  
 When Macporrit gang a-spoolin', 
 Wi' his ganglins in his troolin' 
 He waur mair a skilfu' doolin 
 Wi' a' ca'in' roon his ha'! 
 And his baughit of the hintree 
 Was sae bree on ilka wintree 
 That he niver freemed his fintree 
 Till he spoffer'd who doon tha'! 
 Ca' the burgies tae the boggin, &amp;c. 
 I have now supplied sufficient evidence of Agatha Christie's erudition and remarkable range of source-material to silence the most sceptical critic of my thesis. 
 And I think I should definitely be awarded my doctorate as soon as possible. 
 OSBERT MINT, April 1967 
 APPENDIX I &mdash; THE NAME &bquo;POIROT&equo; 
 The much-bruited suggestion that Agatha Christie selected the name Poirot randomly is patently ridiculous. 
 Apart from its assonantic association with the heavily symbolic &bquo;parrot&equo; (discussed more fully above in reference to Skelton's Speke, Parot ), the name also reverberates with nuances from the French language. 
 The &bquo;poire&equo; or, in English, &bquo;pear&equo; is an obvious subliminal  reference to the distinctive shape of the detective's bald head. 
 That shape is again shadowed in the French word &bquo;poir&eacute;e&equo;, which means &bquo;white beet&equo; and conforms with the frequently-mentioned pallor of the detective's complexion. 
 Though &bquo;poireau&equo;, the French word closest in sound to the name Christie chose, with its double meanings of &bquo;leek&equo; and &bquo;wart&equo;, appears to have no obvious connection with the detective, the word &bquo;poirier&equo;, meaning a &bquo;pear-tree&equo; offers a much more fruitful area for investigation. 
 Its sound provided the first syllable of Poirot's name &bquo;poir&equo;, and for the second one need look no further than the French word &bquo;perdreau&equo;, meaning &bquo;a young partridge&equo;. 
 The unusual juxtaposition of these two words can only be a subconscious association in the author's mind with the well-known carol, The Twelve Days of Christmas  whose repetitive chorus ends, &bquo;And a partridge in a pear-tree.&equo; 
 The truth of this conjecture would seem to be confirmed by Agatha Christie's choice of titles for the 1938 volume, Hercule Poirot's Christmas  and the 1960 collection, The Adventure of the Christmas Pudding and a selection of Entrees . 
 APPENDIX II &mdash; THE NAME &bquo;HASTINGS&equo; 
 The name of Poirot's occasional assistant is no less carefully chosen than that of Agatha Christie's main protagonist. 
 His nomenclature has a very respectable literary history. 
 Shakespeare hinted at the essence of the character in Richard III , Act Three Scene One, when the young Prince of Wales, with a knowledge beyond his years, cries: 
 &bquo;Fie! what a slug is Hastings.&equo; 
 Goldsmith, at the end of She Stoops to Conquer  has Hastings say: 
 &bquo;Come, madam, you are now driven to the very last scene of all your contrivances.&equo; 
 - surely a parallel prefiguring (together with the Burns poem) of all those occasions when Christie's Hastings would be delegated to assemble the suspects for Poirot's latest denouement.  
 And Hastings' habit of pipe-smoking was clearly taken from Thomas Hood, who in a poem of 1839 wrote: 
 &bquo;Twas August &mdash; Hastings every day was filling.&equo; 
 SIMON BRETT WRITES: 
 Though, as I mentioned, I was unable to make contact with Mr Mint, a letter accompanying his essay did make clear the unfortunate fact that its standard &mdash; or perhaps the startling originality of its thinking &mdash; did not meet with the examiners' approval. 
 Osbert Mint was not awarded his doctorate. 
 When last heard of &mdash; in the early Seventies &mdash; he had returned to the United States and was apparently working in a fast food restaurant. 
 GOOD TIME HAD BY ALL 
 ROBERT BARNARD 
 &bquo;It was murder&equo;, said the first housemaid firmly. 
 &bquo;Murder by suffocation.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nonsense, Ethel,&equo; said Cook &bquo;We've never had murder in this house.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, there's a first time for everything, as I m sure you remember, Mrs Cornforth&hellip; 
 There was veronal on the bedside table. 
 She was probably so drugged she didn't struggle. 
 As a rule it's difficult to suffocate people, even if they're sleeping.&equo; 
 &bquo;What would you know?&equo; demanded Thomas, the under-footman, jealous that it had been she who had found the body when she went into the bedroom with the morning tray of tea and biscuits. 
 &bquo;A great deal,&equo; said Ethel with infuriating self-confidence. 
 &bquo;I wasn't with Dr Mackenzie for two years for nothing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, and I suppose he took you with him on his rounds, did he? 
 Had you by his side at his post-mortems?&equo; 
 Mr Eames the butler put up his hand in rebuke. 
 This was becoming unseemly. 
 &bquo;Let's have no more of this squabbling. 
 If it was murder we shall be informed in the Family's good time. 
 I wouldn't be surprised if Ethel isn't entirely wrong about the cause of death and the poor lady did it herself.&equo; 
 &bquo;What, after a night of passionate love?&equo; asked the irrepressible Ethel. 
 &bquo;There's been nights of passionate love in this house that have left the lovers more depressed than ecstatic,&equo; said Thomas,  who found the neurotic sex-lives of some of his betters incomprehensible. 
 &bquo;Anyway, what call have you to say that Mrs Heatherington-Scott had had one?&equo; 
 &bquo;I know her. 
 She's been here before. 
 Always insists on a room to herself with a lock on the door.&equo; 
 &bquo;She'd no call to mention that,&equo; said Mrs Cornforth. 
 &bquo;All the bedrooms in this house have locks.&equo; 
 &bquo;'Course they do. 
 The Prince of Wales used to visit.&equo; 
 &bquo;The old Prince of Wales,&equo; said Eames pedantically. 
 &bquo;The last but two &mdash; King Teddy as he became. 
 You're too young to remember, my girl.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I've heard the stories! 
 Anyway, there she was in her own room, and no call if she didn't want to to open the door to anyone, not even her husband.&equo; 
 &bquo;Especially not her husband,&equo; said Thomas. 
 &bquo;But the fact is, she did. 
 And the question is, who to?&equo; 
 &bquo; If  she did,&equo; said Cook heavily. 
 Everything about Cook was heavy, except her hand with pastry. 
 &bquo;I've heard no hevidence so far that the poor lady did.&equo; 
 &bquo;I did her room when she was here last year,&equo; said Mary, the second housemaid, and Ethel's great ally. 
 &bquo;Going by form she'll have had someone in there with her.&equo; 
 &bquo;There'd been two heads on those pillows,&equo; agreed Ethel, &bquo;and two bodies between those sheets, however hard they tried to disguise it.&equo; 
 &bquo;You noticed a lot before you ran screaming down the corridor,&equo; said Thomas spitefully. 
 &bquo;I noticed first and then I ran screaming. 
 I thought it would be expected of me. 
 Anyway, the forensic scientists will be able to confirm she had someone in with her. 
 Brilliantine leaves traces.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh ho!&equo; said Thomas. 
 &bquo;Lord Heptonstall, you mean!&equo; 
 &bquo;He uses lots of it,&equo; agreed Ethel. 
 &bquo;But all the men use some.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know what's got into you, young lady,&equo; tut-tutted Cook. 
 &bquo;You read too many of them detective stories.&equo;  
 &bquo;Well, they're more educational than Lucky Star  or True Romance , Mrs Cornforth.&equo; 
 Ethel thought for a minute. 
 &bquo;I hope the police notice the mud.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mud?&equo; 
 &bquo;A bit of hard mud, very light-coloured, by the bed.&equo; 
 This had them all looking at each other. 
 &bquo;I didn't leave no mud when I cleaned the floor yesterday,&equo; said Mary. 
 &bquo;She could have left it herself,&equo; said Mrs Cornforth. 
 &bquo;When she never went outdoors yesterday?&equo; asked Ethel. 
 &bquo;Or if she did it was no further than the grounds. 
 Too busy making a dead set at young Mr Merrivale. 
 Anyway, that wasn't Frensham earth I saw, not local.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sir William took some of the gentlemen shooting yesterday,&equo; Thomas pointed out. 
 Thomas had now got over his pique and was thoroughly caught up. 
 This was too good a thing to be distracted from by pique. 
 &bquo;So he did, Thomas,&equo; said Ethell. 
 &bquo;Harpington way. 
 Has anybody cleaned any boots today?&equo; 
 &bquo;Light mud,&equo; said Bob the odd-job boy, relishing his moment of glory. 
 Usually he was much put down. 
 &bquo;Sort of clay-y like.&equo; 
 They all looked at each other. 
 &bquo;Which side of the bed was it, the piece you found?&equo; asked Mr Eames. 
 &bquo;The far side. 
 Where the bedside table is. 
 The side she slept on.&equo; 
 &bquo;And where the window is,&equo; said Thomas. 
 &bquo;And she's a lady who always sleeps &mdash; slept &mdash; with her window open.&equo; 
 &bquo;Was the door locked when you went up this morning?&equo; asked Mary. 
 &bquo;Of course it was. 
 Otherwise whoever it was would probably have come in from the corridor. 
 I used my house key, the same as I did yesterday. 
 Hers was on the floor by the bedside table &mdash; she'd probably knocked it off when she had a glass of water, or when she took the veronal.&equo;  
 &bquo;That veronal must be strong,&equo; said Mary. 
 &bquo;Otherwise she'd have surely woken up, with someone coming in through her window.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not her,&equo; said Thomas. 
 &bquo;She was drinking and dancing till two or half past. 
 Not just last night either, but the night before as well.&equo; 
 &bquo;When I took the tray in yesterday morning,&equo; said Ethel, &bquo;she didn't register a thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, she certainly didn't today,&equo; said Thomas. 
 &bquo;So what you reckon is, she had her boyfriend in, and after he left someone climbed in the window and smothered her in her sleep?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right. 
 She'd have been too far gone to hear. 
 She always was. 
 I had orders not to take in tea until half past ten.&equo; 
 &bquo;The gentleman who'd been in with her would naturally have gone back to his room well before people started stirring.&equo; 
 &bquo;Particularly if he was a married gentleman.&equo; 
 &bquo;Particularly,&equo; agreed Thomas, &bquo;if he was a married gentleman. 
 The question is, what do we do now?&equo; 
 &bquo;Draw up a list of suspects,&equo; said Ethel promptly. 
 &bquo;Drat that bell.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thomas will see to it,&equo; said Mr Eames, who was beginning to enjoy himself. 
 &bquo;Is lunch under way, Mrs Cornforth?&equo; 
 &bquo;Everything under control,&equo; said Cook, &bquo;in spite of hinterruptions and hupsets.&equo; 
 She looked at Ethel, who had secured a notebook and pencil. 
 &bquo;I suppose we're all on this list of suspects?&equo; 
 Ethel shook her head regretfully. 
 &bquo;No. 
 It would have been lovely, but it couldn't really be one of us, could it? 
 She's only been here two weekends, and none of us had worked for her in the past&hellip; 
 No, it couldn't be one of us.&equo; 
 &bquo;She could have seduced Thomas,&equo; suggested Mary. 
 &bquo;The idea!&equo; said Mrs Cornforth. 
 &bquo;Mrs Heathington-Scott would never've gone outside her class, and neither would Thomas.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not so sure about Thomas,&equo; said Ethel, &bquo;but she'd have  stuck to her own circle. 
 An exclusive lady, Mrs Heatherington- 
 Scott, not to say expensive as well. 
 Anyway none of us went to Harpington shooting yesterday. 
 Right. 
 So that means the eight ladies and gentlemen sleeping here last night. 
 Top of the list goes to the husband, of course.&equo; 
 Ethel, who later in life wrote scripts for Mrs Dale's Diary  and Upstairs, Downstairs , licked her pencil and wrote in a bold, well-schooled hand: Captain James Heatherington-Scott. 
 &bquo;Why top of the list?&equo; asked Bob. 
 &bquo;Because in a domestic murder the husband or wife is always the obvious suspect. 
 You'll know why if you ever marry.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why wait till they are away on a weekend?&equo; asked Mrs Cornforth. 
 &bquo;Why not do it at 'ome?&equo; 
 &bquo;And be even more  the obvious suspect?&equo; asked Ethel pityingly. 
 &bquo;Besides, he may have been driven over the edge by her carryings-on. 
 Because carry on she did. 
 Though if you ask me he's a nasty piece of work who wouldn't bat an eyelid whatever she might do&hellip; 
 Then there's master and mistress.&equo; 
 She wrote again: Sir William and Lady Warboys. 
 When Cook once more expanded her bosom to protest, Mr Eames put up his hand. 
 &bquo;No, Mrs C. We must be scientifical about this. 
 All must be equally under suspicion, though we all know the master or mistress would never think of doing such a thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Anyone any idea why the master and mistress ask the Heatherington-Scotts?&equo; asked Ethel. 
 &bquo;They're a good twenty years younger, and they've only known them a year or two. 
 Yet this is twice they've been here &mdash; first last Spring, and now for the New Year party.&equo; 
 &bquo;I heard the master say that they were fun,&equo; said Mr Eames. 
 &bquo;He likes young people with a lot of life in them. 
 Not that he'd ever for a moment think of&hellip; taking advantage, so to speak, of a young woman of loose morals like Mrs Heatherington-Scott.&equo; 
 There was a brief moment of silence before Ethel spoke again. 
 Ethel knew a lot more about what the master would and would  not think of doing to a young woman than Mr Eames did. 
 &bquo;Then there's Colonel and Mrs Swanton. 
 I should think we're all agreed about them.&equo; 
 &bquo;A nice gentleman,&equo; said Mary. 
 &bquo;Always courteous, never too demanding, and generous with it. 
 His lady's a bit more fussy, but a real lady nonetheless.&equo; 
 &bquo;Right,&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;A thoroughly suspicious pair, if you went by detective stories. 
 Then there's Lord and Lady Heptonstall.&equo; 
 There was another moment's silence. 
 &bquo;I'm not one to speak ill of my betters, as you know,&equo; said Mrs Cornforth, &bquo;but her Ladyship's remarks within Thomas's hearing about my profiteroles Angels would not forgive!&equo; 
 &bquo;Mean, cross, nasty-tongued bitch, and his Lordship is if anything worse,&equo; agreed Mr Eames. 
 &bquo;Mind you, it's the first time they've been here, and if I'm any judge it'll be the last. 
 Sir William and her Ladyship have been noticing things, I can tell you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then there's Mr Merrivale,&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;Mr Raymond Merrivale. 
 I don't mind saying I think he's a lovely gentleman!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh he is!&equo; said Mary. 
 &bquo;It's always &bquo;I wonder if you'd mind&equo; with him &mdash; never &bquo;do this, do that&equo; like it is with the Heptonstalls. 
 He's smashing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Smashing!&equo; said Cook disparagingly. 
 &bquo;What kind of a word is that? 
 I suppose all this henthusiasm has nothing to do with the fact that he's a very handsome young man, has it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Everything,&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;The old sex urge, and don't run it down, Mrs Cornforth. 
 Still, he's a married man, and his wife is in her seventh month, from what I hear: that's why she had to send her apologies at the last moment&hellip; 
 Well, if you go by character it'll be the husband or one of the Heptonstalls who did it. 
 But of course you can't just go by character.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, you can't!&equo; said Thomas, coming back through the baize door positively pink with self-importance. 
 &bquo;You've got to look at evidence , that's what you've got to do!&equo; 
 &bquo;All right, out with it,&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;What's happening  upstairs?&equo; 
 &bquo;Upstairs? 
 Bill is ministering to master and mistress and the house-guests, sick as a toad that he's missing all the fun. 
 It's outside that things are happening!&equo; 
 &bquo;Outside? 
 You mean round her window?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right. 
 Five coppers from Addlesfield, and a French gentleman with moustaches you could uncork a bottle with who's staying with the Chief Constable. 
 I heard one of the constables say he was a tip-top detective from London.&equo; 
 &bquo;And what was he doing?&equo; 
 &bquo;He was looking at the marks of a ladder just under her window. 
 He asked me where a ladder like that could be found, and I took him round to the one that hangs on the side of the potting shed. 
 It had earth on one end.&equo; 
 &bquo;Be pretty funny if a gardener's ladder didn't have earth on it,&equo; commented Cook. 
 &bquo;It corresponded!&equo; said Thomas, who as talking in exclamation marks. 
 &bquo;They took it over to the rose-bed under her window and the marks corresponded. 
 And there was more of that light earth there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why did he talk to you about that anyway?&equo; demanded Ethel. 
 &bquo;I'd've thought he'd've talked to the gardeners.&equo; 
 &bquo;He wanted to talk to me anyway, the French gentleman&equo;, said Thomas, oozing conceit. 
 &bquo;He said he could see I was a young man with all his wits about him.&equo; 
 Ethel's silent opinion was that Thomas's strong point lay very much lower down than his brain. 
 She said: &bquo;But he must have had some reason  for wanting to talk to you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Because I was on last night. 
 That's why Bill is kicking himself. 
 He pulled rank and went to bed at half past eleven, leaving me on for the late-night drinks. 
 I was the one around just before they all went to bed.&equo; 
 &bquo;And?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, like I told the foreign gentleman, there was dancing in the sitting room, and this Mrs Heatherington-Scott she was  dancing with Mr Merrivale.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh &mdash; you told him that!&equo; chorused Ethel and Mary. 
 &bquo;'Course I did. 
 You've got to be truthful, like in a court of law. 
 If they are innocent they have nothing to fear, that's what they always say. 
 I told him they danced very intimate-like, with her twigging his ear and whispering in it, and dancing closer and closer. 
 I was surprised because she'd been throwing herself at him all day and not getting anywhere much.&equo; 
 &bquo;And did you tell the foreign gentleman that her husband was going mad with jealousy?&equo; 
 &bquo;No I didn't, because he wasn't. 
 He was changing the gramophone records. 
 Same as happened last year with her and Sir Harry Dexter.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes, I remember: she had him panting after her all right!&equo; 
 Mr Eames was just getting up, convinced that juniors and upstarts were usurping the stage and it was time for him to be where the action was, when he was interrupted by the bell. 
 Soon it was time for luncheon, and the whole of the downstairs staff was occupied in one way or another. 
 Any conversation there was was snatched in odd moments of repose. 
 &bquo;You were wrong about that foreign gentleman,&equo; said Mr Eames to Thomas in the kitchen between courses. 
 &bquo;He's Belgian.&equo; 
 &bquo;Same thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;It is not the same thing. 
 Don't you remember &bquo;gallant little Belgium&equo; during the war?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mr Eames I'm only twenty-three. 
 I was born the year it started.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, we'd never have called France &bquo;gallant&equo;, I can tell you. 
 France and England never pulled together, for all they might find themselves on the same side.&equo; 
 After lunch the Belgian gentleman talked to several of the below-stairs staff and they were severally repelled or enchanted. 
 Bill, the first footman, who had nothing to tell him, said his foot itched to kick him up the b.t.m., while Mary said she felt  she was being taken by one of those continental gigolos to the Strand Corner House, as a preliminary to being seduced. 
 &bquo;You shameless hussy!&equo; said Cook, and thought accordingly worse of the foreign gentleman for arousing such fancies. 
 It was gone three before they could have another real talking-over of the crime. 
 They pooled the information they had gleaned or guessed from their several interrogations, and then began in again. 
 &bquo;So far as I can see it's practically certain Mr Merrivale was in there with her early on in the night,&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;They're hardly making a secret of it, and after the exhibition they seem to have made, if Thomas is right, he couldn't deny it.&equo; 
 Mr Merrivale, clearly, had lost favour. 
 &bquo;I think the foreign gentleman thinks there may be more than one of them in it,&equo; said Thomas. 
 &bquo;He keeps going on about &bquo;grey cells&equo;.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've never been inside the local police station,&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;You wouldn't expect them to paint it pretty pink, would you?&equo; 
 She thought, looking dubious. 
 &bquo;It doesn't sound likely. 
 Why should there be a conspiracy? 
 Merrivale could have done it on his own when he was in there with her, and the gentleman who came in from outside didn't need a partner either. 
 Now, let's think a bit about this mud.&equo; 
 She turned towards Bob. 
 &bquo;How many pairs of boots were there this morning?&equo; 
 Bob blushed at his unaccustomed prominence, but said promptly: &bquo;Four, like I told the foreign gentleman.&equo; 
 &bquo;The foreign gentleman won't have a notion how things are done below stairs. 
 There may be something he's missed. 
 Whose were they.&equo; 
 &bquo;The master's, Colonel Swanton's (I know because he takes size 12), Captain Heatherington-Scott's (he had his name in his) and one pair more. 
 I think they were that Lord Something's.&equo; 
 &bquo;They were,&equo; said Mary. 
 &bquo;I found them outside his door when I took master and mistress their early morning tea.&equo;  
 &bquo;He may be a lord but he's no gentleman,&equo; said Mr Eames Loftily. 
 &bquo;We are not an hotel.&equo; 
 &bquo;And the other boots would have been just inside the baize door as usual,&equo; said Ethel thoughtfully. 
 &bquo;Given to one or other of us last night. 
 Anyone could have retrieved his&hellip; 
 Still, the fact that Lord Heptonstall had the use of his all night does rather direct the spotlight on him.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you sound Like, girl?&equo; said Mrs Cornforth. 
 &bquo;One of those books you read.&equo; 
 &bquo;There was one thing I remembered when the foreign gentleman was asking questions,&equo; said Mary eagerly. 
 &bquo;He was ever so gentle and nice, but sort of piercing &mdash; went right through you &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;That's enough of that, my girl!&equo; 
 &bquo; &mdash; well anyway, I remembered the last time she was here this Mrs Heatherington-Scott made a set at Sir Harry Destry, like Thomas said, and &mdash; well, we all know what happened that time, don't we? 
 Anyway, I was dusting in the library on the morning they all left, and I remember Mrs H.-S. and Sir Harry walking into the library, he was looking very suspicious and upset, and both were talking very Low. 
 Well, I slipped out, of course, as mistress likes us to &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;They expect servants to be invisible, but they expect the work to be done all the same,&equo; put in Ethel. 
 &bquo; &mdash; anyway they never saw me, but before I went I heard her say, in a slinky sort of voice. 
 &bquo;It would be a pity if your wife got to know. 
 I believe she's delicate &mdash; the nervous type, isn't she?&equo;&equo; 
 The reaction was gratifying. 
 &bquo;Blackmail!&equo; said Mr Eames. 
 &bquo;That's what it sounded like,&equo; agreed Mary. 
 &bquo;A bit of blackmailing on a small scale.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well!&equo; said Cook. 
 &bquo;To think of someone in that station of life resorting to blackmail!&equo; 
 &bquo;Not unknown,&equo; said Mr Eames sagely. 
 &bquo;I could tell you a thing or two about the Countess of Warwick and letters from King Teddy. 
 Had it directly from Sir Alan Lascelles's valet. 
 If  you can blackmail the R.F&hellip;.!&equo; 
 &bquo;Anyway,&equo; said Thomas, &bquo;this really puts Mr Merrivale back in the spotlight, doesn't it? 
 If she started to put pressure on&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, but she wouldn't have, would she?&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;Not till just before they all left. 
 She'd have let him get in as deep as possible and then  started the pressure&hellip; 
 Not that I've any time for him  any longer &mdash; going on like that when his poor wife was near her time.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's exactly the time many gentlemen do  go astray,&equo; said Bill. 
 &bquo;I believe when Teddy was acting the goat in this house the Princess of Wales was carrying Queen Maud of Norway as she now is.&equo; 
 &bquo;I think you'll find,&equo; said Mr Eames, &bquo;that King Teddy acted the goat pretty well irrespective.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did I hear something,&equo; said Cook frowning, &bquo;about Lady Destry having been ill?&equo; 
 Mr Eames was thunderstruck. 
 &bquo;You're right! 
 It had gone completely out of my mind. 
 I heard last summer that she'd&hellip; 
 This needs to be looked into. 
 I shall telephone Sir Harry's butler.&equo; 
 &bquo;You never would, Mr Eames,&equo; said Mary admiringly. 
 &bquo;That's two counties away!&equo; 
 &bquo;Desperate situations call for desperate measures,&equo; said Mr Eames grandly. 
 But as he departed for the pantry the bell rang for afternoon tea to be served. 
 It was five o'clock before they could hear the results of his conversation. 
 &bquo;Terrible,&equo; he told them &mdash; and to be fair it was entirely without relish that he spoke. 
 &bquo;Really shocking. 
 The lady had always been a bit flighty in her mind &mdash; nervous, delicate, taking odd fancies. 
 Last summer she had some kind of shock &mdash; nobody knows what. 
 Sent her completely overboard. 
 Bouleversed, as they say across the Channel. 
 Confined to an a.s.y.1.u.m. 
 Private, constant attendance, no expense spared. 
 Shocking!&equo; 
 &bquo;Diabolical!&equo; said Mrs Cornforth. 
 &bquo;She deserved everything she got!&equo;  
 &bquo;The question is, how often she &mdash; they, it must be &mdash; tried it,&equo; said Mary. 
 &bquo;Had they been bleeding Colonel Swanton or Lord Heptonstall dry?&equo; 
 &bquo;Or even master?&equo; put in Ethel. 
 &bquo;As far as I can see only Mr Merrivale is in the clear&equo;, went on Mary. 
 &bquo;Even if he had been out shooting, he wouldn't slip into a lady's bedroom in muddy hunting boots.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wouldn't wear muddy hunting boots if I was going to climb in through a bedroom window and murder a lady,&equo; said Ethel. 
 The words took time to sink in &mdash; to herself as much as to the rest. 
 &bquo;It's not as though a gentleman would only bring one or two pairs of shoes with him to a house-party.&equo; 
 They sat there thinking. 
 Finally it was again Ethel who spoke. 
 &bquo;It was a blind,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;That mud was a red herring. 
 It seemed to let Mr Merrivale out. 
 In fact it could simply have been broken off Lord Heptonstall's boots at any time during the night. 
 The ladder could have been put up against the wall any time of night &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Going out by the gun-room window,&equo; said Thomas, &bquo;which master announced to all of them was faulty, and that was why Rover slept there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Very good with dogs, Mr Merrivale,&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;Yes, he went out, put the ladder against the wall briefly to leave traces, threw a bit of mud through the window, and the key, and scattered more mud around the rose bed. 
 It was a red herring.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you think really happened?&equo; asked Mary. 
 &bquo;I think she was dead before he left her room. 
 I think they had their fun, she took the veronal to sleep soundly, then when she was far gone he smothered her.&equo; 
 &bquo;But why? 
 You said yourself she wouldn't have begun putting the pressure on yet.&equo; 
 Ethel shook her head in puzzlement, but a gleam had been coming into Eames's eyes. 
 &bquo;I think,&equo; he said, &bquo;I've been forgetting something.&equo; 
 He got up in his stately way and went over to his pantry. 
 He emerged with  an old edition of Burkes Landed Gentry . 
 It was very dog-eared, for he seldom took up any other book for his own amusement. 
 He thumbed through it till he came to Merrivale. 
 &bquo;Merrivale, Sir John, Knight, father to our young Raymond&hellip; 
 Married Georgiana, widow of Sir Francis Destry, Bart&hellip; 
 Let's see: Destry, Sir Francis, deceased 1914, issue: Henry Edward&hellip; 
 They were step-brothers, Sir Henry and our Mr Merrivale, with only a year or two's difference in their ages.&equo; 
 &bquo;Brought up together, most likely,&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;It was revenge, revenge pure and simple. 
 Young Mr Merrivale came here to get it. 
 I do think he's noble! 
 I expect he hoped to have as little as possible to do with her, but when she made a dead set at him, as she did at all young married men, that was no longer possible. 
 He had to improvise. 
 That was what he came up with. 
 I don't mind saying I don't blame him a bit! 
 I always did say Mr Merrivale was a lovely young man!&equo; 
 They were pulled up by the bell. 
 It was Mr Eames's, and in a moment he was back, and as much in a rush as a butler can be. 
 Drinks and snacks were required in the library. 
 Everyone was assembling there &mdash; family, house-guests, the Chief Constable, the Belgian gentleman. 
 For a time there was chaos. 
 Mr Eames and Bill and Thomas collected trays and glasses, decanters were dusted down, all variety of bottles were sought. 
 When they went up to the study Ethel and Mary waited outside with the little trays of sundries, catching glimpses of the people in the room, all of them nervously talking in high voices. 
 Bill came out swearing, on his way to look for sirop de casis . 
 Mary peeped in to get another look at those wonderful moustaches and said to herself that they were nothing like corkscrews, more like one of those curved oriental swords that would cut right through you. 
 Finally everyone was served. 
 Bill and Thomas came out, followed by Mr Eames, who shut the door behind him, but somehow not quite to &mdash; a thing never known to happen before. 
 He led Bill firmly to the baize door and down the stairs, never once looking back to see if he was being followed. 
 In the hall Thomas  looked at Mary and Mary looked at Ethel. 
 &bquo;Better stay and listen,&equo; said Ethel. 
 &bquo;Make sure he gets it right.&equo; 
 CAUSE AND EFFECTS CATHERINE AIRD 
 &bquo;Of course you must come with us, Henry, dear. 
 I insist. 
 Besides Margot will be so pleased.&equo; 
 &bquo;I really don't see why any hostess should be pleased to see a total stranger arrive at her dinner party.&equo; 
 Henry Tyler had had an unexpected few days' leave and had descended on his married sister and her husband in the small market town of Berebury in Calleshire without a great deal of warning. 
 &bquo;You're not a total stranger&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;To my certain knowledge, Wendy, I have never set eyes on anyone called Margot Iverson in my life before.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know that,&equo; said Wendy Witherington placidly, &bquo;but you're my brother and that's the same as my knowing her on her knowing me.&equo; 
 Logic had never been Wendy's strong suit. 
 &bquo;I still don't see why she should be pleased to see me on Saturday evening,&equo; said Henry Tyler mildly. 
 &bquo;Because you're a man, that's why.&equo; 
 &bquo;And may I ask if she will be so delighted to see me because I happen to be a male member of the human race&hellip;?&equo; 
 There was nothing in his face to show how much he enjoyed teasing his only sister. 
 &bquo;Or is it only that I don't understand why as a consequence of being a mere male?&equo; 
 Henry worked at the Foreign Office in London, where ambiguity had been raised to an art form. 
 Wendy's mind was a much more literal one. 
 &bquo;Because you're an extra man, dear,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Ah.&equo;  
 &bquo;And because of Arthur's Cousin Amy,&equo; went on his sister. 
 &bquo;She always upsets the table.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dipsomania?&equo; enquired Henry Tyler with interest, &bquo;or is she just a clairvoyant?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be unkind,&equo; said Wendy severely. 
 &bquo;Cousin Amy can't help being there. 
 She hasn't anywhere else to go but. 
 &bquo;The Hollies&equo;.&equo; 
 &bquo;She doesn't always have to upset the table, though, when she is there, does she?&equo; remarked Henry Tyler in a tone that at least one ambassador had been known to call &bquo;eminently reasonable&equo;. 
 &bquo;Arthur's Cousin Amy,&equo; responded his sister firmly, &bquo;works as a secretary at a girls' boarding school. 
 She's as poor as a church mouse, that's why she has to come to Arthur and Margot's in the holidays.&equo; 
 &bquo;And what happens,&equo; asked Henry mischievously, &bquo;when Cousin Amy isn't there and your friends have an extra man?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, that's no problem,&equo; said Wendy at once. 
 &bquo;Margot just asks Miss Chalder to stay on. 
 She's Arthur's dispenser and receptionist. 
 Young but quite presentable.&equo; 
 &bquo;So Arthur's a doctor&hellip;&equo; divined Henry without too much difficulty. 
 &bquo;Oh, didn't I say? 
 He's our general practitioner.&equo; 
 Wendy giggled. 
 &bquo;Actually, when she's not there Margot calls Miss Chalder their  deceptionist .&equo; 
 &bquo;Always saying the doctor's out when he's in?&equo; 
 Deception was another of the subjects that they knew rather a lot about at the Foreign Office. 
 &bquo;That sort of thing?&equo; 
 &bquo;And saying,&equo; said Wendy, &bquo;that he's been held up at a confinement when he's forgotten all about somebody.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is he a good doctor?&equo; asked Henry. 
 It wasn't entirely an idle question since Wendy and Tom Witherington had two young children upon whom their bachelor uncle doted. 
 &bquo;How does one ever know that, Henry?&equo; 
 Wendy had more intelligence than her pleasant calm looks might have led the casual observer to suspect. 
 She wrinkled her brow. 
 &bquo;There was  some trouble at the end of last year about a little gipsy child who died from a burst appendix. 
 Arthur said he'd never had their second message, and the fuss all died down, but he's always come when we've sent for him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Quite so,&equo; said Henry Tyler. 
 &bquo;I shall look forward to Saturday evening then.&equo; 
 &bquo;And I shall telephone Margot,&equo; said his sister. 
 Later that evening Henry, who was a firm believer that time spent in reconnaissance was seldom wasted, raised the matter of the dinner party with his brother-in-law. 
 &bquo;Don't worry, old chap.&equo; 
 Tom Witherington was reassuring. 
 &bquo;They do you very well at &bquo;The Hollies&equo;. 
 Very well indeed.&equo; 
 &bquo;So Dr Iverson is a successful doctor,&equo; murmured Henry Tyler (which he knew was not the same as being a good one.) 
 Tom Witherington frowned. 
 &bquo;Couldn't say, but he is sound on food and drink.&equo; 
 &bquo;How is it that their entertaining is so &mdash; er &mdash; reliable then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, you mean how is it that they can afford the pukka style if he isn't successful?&equo; 
 His brother-in-law's brow cleared. 
 &bquo;That's easily explained. 
 W.H.M.&equo; 
 Henry Tyler thought for a moment, &bquo;That's an acronym I haven't come across.&equo; 
 Tom Witherington grinned. 
 &bquo;I don't suppose it matters in the Foreign Office as much as it does in some other spheres. 
 W.H.M. stands for Wife Has Means&hellip; 
 Margot has the money and Arthur has the ideas for using it. 
 You'll see for yourself on Saturday.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can hardly wait,&equo; said Henry Tyler politely. 
 As dinner parties went, noted Henry on the night, it was neither large nor particularly intimate. 
 Ten people sat down in the dining-room at &bquo;The Hollies&equo; after partaking of a well-chosen sherry &mdash; a good Machamudo, Henry thought &mdash; in the drawing-room. 
 Margot Iverson had welcomed him most hospitably. 
 &bquo;How nice to have someone here from the Foreign Office. 
 You can tell  us what they think of Il Duce.&equo; 
 She was a plain woman with the apparent placidity of the overweight, but she didn't look as if she missed much. 
 Like those of all good hostesses, her eyes were everywhere. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid,&equo; said Henry Tyler with every appearance of regret, &bquo;That's not my Department.&equo; 
 Dr Iverson was equally welcoming, &bquo;What a pity it's dark. 
 Otherwise you could have seen the garden, although there's not much to look at at this time of the year.&equo; 
 &bquo;Arthur's garden is a delight,&equo; said Wendy at his elbow. 
 &bquo;In the summer his vegetable garden is as neat and attractive as the one at Villandry.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's mostly my gardener I have to thank for that&equo;, said the doctor modestly, &bquo;but, yes, I do take an interest. 
 Now let me introduce you to Major Anderson. 
 He's the Chairman of our local Bench&hellip;&equo; 
 The announcement about dinner being served, Henry observed with approval, had come at just the right length of time after the sherry had been drunk. 
 It followed a brief absence from the room of the doctor. 
 &bquo;Just checking on the claret,&equo; he boomed as he came back. 
 &bquo;Edith's very good but there are some things that need watching.&equo; 
 &bquo;My cousin is something of a wine connoisseur, Mr Tyler,&equo; said Miss Amy Hall as he escorted her in to dinner. 
 The doctor's cousin was a thin anxious woman with her hair drawn in two neat earphones. 
 &bquo;Now, tell me what you think of Haile Selassie&hellip;&equo; 
 The first course had been awaiting them on the dining-room table. 
 Potted shrimps in attractive little ramekins, and prettily adorned with watercress, stood on plates at each place. 
 It was clear that the Major's wife was the chief lady guest, as she was seated on Dr Iverson's right, the Major sitting on Margot Iverson's right. 
 A Mr and Mrs Locombe-Stableford made up the party. 
 Henry  had already discovered that he was a solicitor and his wife a 
 power in the Red Cross. 
 Henry found himself next to the 
 Major's wife. 
 &bquo;I hope you enjoy your visits to Calleshire,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;A very fine county.&equo; 
 &bquo;Indeed.&equo; 
 Henry passed her some thin, crustless brown bread and butter and listened to a long story about fox-hunting. 
 Across the table he could hear Mrs Locombe-Stableford talking to the doctor about someone's gall-stones. 
 (&bquo;Seven as big as marbles, the surgeon said.&equo;) 
 Edith, the parlourmaid, cleared away the first course. 
 &bquo;Jolly good tiger-frighteners, what?&equo; said the Major to Margot Iverson. 
 &bquo;He usually calls them horses' doovers,&equo; sighed the Major's wife to Henry, &bquo;which is worse.&equo; 
 &bquo;Strange how we have taken to some French words and not others, isn't it?&equo; remarked Henry diplomatically as the parlourmaid came into the room with a pile of dinner plates and the vegetable dishes. 
 &bquo;I hope you'll take to a good French claret,&equo; chimed in Arthur Iverson jovially. 
 &bquo;One of the St Emilion hill wines. 
 Ch&acirc;teau Balestard la Tonnelle, and just ready for drinking&hellip; ah, thank you, Edith. 
 Put it down here. 
 Carefully, now&hellip;&equo; 
 Obediently the parlourmaid lowered a serving dish bearing a large fillet of beef on to the table in front of the doctor. 
 He put his hands out to take up the carving knife and fork and Amy Hall murmured something to her neighbour about Arthur always having wanted to be a surgeon really. 
 &bquo;My dear,&equo; he said to his wife, &bquo;aren't you going to tell our guests about our new addition to the dining-room?&equo; 
 All eyes turned towards Margot Iverson at the other end of the dining table. 
 She almost pouted. 
 &bquo;I wasn't going to tell them, Arthur. 
 I was going to show them later.&equo; 
 &bquo;Very well, dear.&equo; 
 The doctor turned his attention back to the carving. 
 He was indeed good at it. 
 After having carefully  removed the browned edge of the fillet he sliced the meat quickly and evenly. 
 Edith took the plates to Margot Iverson's end of the table, where the vegetables were served, and then handed them in turn to the guests. 
 Henry passed the horseradish sauce and then the gravy to the Major's wife. 
 &bquo;And salt?&equo; he enquired. 
 The career of one of his Foreign Office contemporaries had been said to have foundered after he said &bquo;Pepper and salt&equo; to the wife of a diplomat with uncertainly coloured hair and a poor command of the English language. 
 &bquo;Now you really must tell us what you think of the Abyssinian question, Mr Tyler,&equo; Brenda Waters said as soon as Edith had withdrawn. 
 &bquo;Dear lady, I am but an errand boy in the Foreign Service&hellip;&equo; 
 At the other end of the table he could hear Margot Iverson exchanging stately platitudes with Mr Locombe-Stableford. 
 Henry Tyler would not have described her as a happy woman, but afterward he could not say that she had seemed at all unwell. 
 She certainly complained of nothing in his hearing. 
 Her moment came at the end of the first course when, without any apparent signal, the parlourmaid came back into the room. 
 &bquo;There,&equo; challenged Arthur. 
 &bquo;How did Margot summon up reinforcements? 
 Tell me that if you can.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps,&equo; suggested Tom Witherington slyly, &bquo;Edith was listening at the door&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you hear that, Edith?&equo; said Arthur Iverson. 
 &bquo;Well, were you?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, doctor.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bush telegraph?&equo; 
 The Major had served in Africa. 
 &bquo;Oh, do tell us,&equo; pleaded Wendy Witherington. 
 &bquo;We'll never guess.&equo; 
 &bquo;A bell-push under the carpet by my foot,&equo; said Margot Iverson calmly. 
 &bquo;Arthur got an electrician to come in and do it during the week.&equo;  
 &bquo;Clever stuff,&equo; exclaimed Tom as Edith brought in the puddings. 
 She placed a hot Normandy pudding for the doctor to serve and a cr&egrave;me br&ucirc;l&eacute;e for her mistress to offer to those who preferred it. 
 &bquo;A great nation, the French,&equo; said Mrs Locombe-Stableford, eyeing the puddings. 
 &bquo;In some ways, yes,&equo; said Henry, a Foreign Office man to his fingertips even on Saturday evenings. 
 &bquo;But not all.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mustn't forget Cook's special wine sauce with the Normandy pudding,&equo; said Margot Iverson. 
 &bquo;She's very proud of it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Or the Barsac,&equo; said Dr Iverson. 
 &bquo;I think the ladies will like it&hellip;&equo; 
 It was late by the time the meal was done and later still when the company rose from the coffee cups in the drawing-room. 
 It was early, though, the next morning when Wendy Witherington came back from answering the telephone. 
 &bquo;That was Brenda Waters,&equo; she said, looking shocked. 
 &bquo;You won't believe this but Margot Iverson died in the night&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;No! 
 Surely not&hellip;&equo; exclaimed Tom. 
 &bquo;What on earth from?&equo; asked Henry. 
 &bquo;Brenda doesn't know,&equo; said Wendy, &bquo;but apparently poor Margot started being sick about one o'clock in the morning and then had a most frightful pain in her tummy.&equo; 
 &bquo;At least Arthur would have been there,&equo; said her husband. 
 &bquo;Nothing like having a doctor in the house.&equo; 
 &bquo;He got very worried and immediately sent for one of the consultants from the hospital.&equo; 
 &bquo;I should think so&hellip;&equo; murmured Henry. 
 &bquo;And the consultant wanted to know what she'd had to eat, of course&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course.&equo; 
 Tom Witherington looked very solemn. 
 &bquo;&hellip; 
 And whether anyone else had been taken ill.&equo; 
 &bquo;Naturally,&equo; said Henry.  
 &bquo;They were just going to check that we were all right when Margot suddenly got quite excitable and delirious &mdash; so unlike her.&equo; 
 Henry nodded. 
 Margot Iverson had struck him as a very controlled woman. 
 &bquo;And then&hellip; 
 &equo; Wendy's voice began to quaver, &bquo;her breathing got very slow. 
 Brenda says she was in a coma by the time they got her into the hospital. 
 And then she just died&hellip; oh, isn't it too awful?&equo; 
 Both men nodded. 
 Wendy sniffed. 
 &bquo;I think I'll just ring Phyllis Locombe-Stableford&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Tom Witherington quietly. 
 &bquo;I don't think I would if I were you, Wendy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why ever not?&equo; 
 Wendy stared at her husband. 
 &bquo;She was there too last night.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's why,&equo; said Tom. 
 &bquo;And she may not want to talk about it. 
 Or have been asked not to by her husband&hellip;&equo; he put his arm round his wife. 
 &bquo;I think you're forgetting something about old Locombe-Stapleford.&equo; 
 She was close to tears now. 
 &bquo;What's that?&equo; 
 &bquo;That he isn't only a solicitor.&equo; 
 Tom went on steadily, &bquo;He's the Coroner as well.&equo; 
 Beyond speech now, she nodded her comprehension. 
 &bquo;Brenda said they were doing a post mortem this morning. 
 Oh, poor, poor Margot&hellip;&equo; 
 Henry Tyler said, &bquo;I have to be back in Whitehall tomorrow, Wen. 
 I must be with my Minister at ten but I'll come back for the funeral&hellip; or if anyone else wants to talk to me&hellip;&equo; 
 In the event the persons who wanted to talk to Henry Tyler went to the Foreign Office to see him &mdash; where they found his rank to be rather higher than that of errand-boy. 
 In fact he had his own office and a considerably larger area of carpet than anyone in Berebury suspected. 
 The two policemen who were shown into his room did not  appear to be daunted by this. 
 &bquo;Detective Inspector Milsom,&equo; said 
 the senior of the pair, &bquo;and my assistant, Detective Constable Bewman. 
 We are making enquiries into the sudden death of Mrs Margot Iverson.&equo; 
 Henry Tylor bowed his head. 
 &bquo;Anything that I can tell you, Inspector, I will, but my acquaintanceship with Mrs Iverson in the event was brief.&equo; 
 &bquo;It is the event,&equo; said Milsom dryly, &bquo;which interests us. 
 You were, I understand, one of the guests on the fatal night&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Indeed,&equo; said Henry, noting with the appreciation of an expert the inspector's choice of words. 
 &bquo;And partook of the complete meal?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, yes, Inspector. 
 And very good it was, too.&equo; 
 &bquo;Save for Mrs Iverson, sir. 
 It didn't do her any good at all. 
 Quite the reverse you might say.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you telling me,&equo; said Henry cautiously, &bquo;that Mrs Iverson &mdash; er &mdash; consumed&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ingested was the word the Home Office pathologist used, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ingested that from which she died at that meal?&equo; 
 &bquo;It would seem so, sir. 
 And we want you to tell us everything you remember about it.&equo; 
 Henry cast his mind back over the evening. 
 &bquo;I think we all ate the same&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;That is one of the things that is making our enquiries difficult.&equo; 
 Detective Inspector Milsom had his notebook at the ready. 
 &bquo;And from the same dishes&hellip; no, I forgot. 
 The first course was on the table when we went into the dining-room. 
 Potted shrimps.&equo; 
 He looked sharply at the policeman. 
 &bquo;Shell-fish can be dangerous in their own right.&equo; 
 &bquo;The potted shrimps were put on the table by the parlourmaid immediately before the guests entered the dining-room,&equo; said Milsom. 
 Henry hesitated: but not for long. 
 &bquo;Our host did slip out to attend to the claret&hellip;&equo;  
 &bquo;That was before the shrimp dish reached the dining-room&equo;, said Milsom, revealing that he already knew a great deal about the evening. 
 &bquo;It was &mdash; er &mdash; safely in the kitchen at that stage.&equo; 
 &bquo;And,&equo; said Henry as lightly as he felt the conversation warranted. 
 &bquo;I suppose you are sure that Edith wasn't harbouring a grudge against her mistress.&equo; 
 &bquo;As sure as we can be,&equo; said Milsom. 
 Detective Constable Bewman stirred. 
 &bquo;Besides, if you remember, sir, the potted shrimps had a solidified butter glaze on top.&equo; 
 &bquo;So it had,&equo; said Henry appreciatively. 
 The constabulary had certainly done its homework. 
 &bquo;And Mrs Iverson would certainly have noticed if that had been disturbed.&equo; 
 &bquo;I think we can go a little further than that, sir.&equo; 
 Milsom gave a faint smile. 
 &bquo;Human nature being what it is, my guess is that any maid worth her salt would have put a slightly imperfect dish in front of anyone but her master or mistress for the cook's sake.&equo; 
 &bquo;Quite so,&equo; said Henry gravely. 
 He had forgotten the old joke about a policeman being the best kitchen range-finder in the world. 
 &bquo;Well, apart from the potted shrimps I think I can assure you, Inspector, that one way and another all the other dishes were shared.&equo; 
 &bquo;This is what all the other guests say, sir, and that is what is puzzling us.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about after we all left?&equo; said Henry. 
 &bquo;The experts assure us that symptoms occur between one and four hours after this particular substance has been ingested.&equo; 
 The detective inspector went on, in tones totally devoid of emphasis, &bquo;Unfortunately Dr Iverson went out after the dinner-party to pay a late visit to a man with pneumonia about whom he was worried an so cannot tell us anything about the time immediately after the guests had left. 
 By the time he got home his wife was already beginning to be unwell.&equo; 
 &bquo;I see.&equo; 
 Henry frowned. 
 &bquo;Well, after the potted shrimps we had the beef &mdash; and very good it was, too.  
 &bquo;I understand that Cook has an excellent relationship with the butcher. 
 She got him to send round the largest and best fillet he had,&equo; said Milsom. 
 &bquo;The vegetables, as I recollect, Inspector, were Brussels sprouts and glazed carrots.&equo; 
 The man on the Belgium desk at the Foreign Office was being driven to despair by what was coming out of Brussels at the moment but Henry saw no reason to say so. 
 &bquo;We think we can give the vegetables a clean bill of health, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Finished up in the kitchen, were they?&equo; divined Henry. 
 &bquo;I say, Inspector, what about the horseradish sauce? 
 It brought a tear to my eye.&equo; 
 &bquo;Home-made, Mr Tyler, by Cook, according to Mrs Beeton's recipe with cream, white wine vinegar, a little castor sugar and some mustard &mdash; and horseradish, of course.&equo; 
 &bquo;I have heard,&equo; said Henry slowly, &bquo;that on occasion &mdash; by accident, usually &mdash; aconite has been known to have been mistaken for horseradish.&equo; 
 &bquo;Picked by Cook herself in the kitchen garden,&equo; said Inspector Milsom with evident approval. 
 &bquo;She says that when she asks the gardener for produce she feels she doesn't always get the best.&equo; 
 &bquo;Human nature doesn't always change, does it?&equo; said Henry absently. 
 They knew quite as much about human nature at the Foreign Office as they did down at any police station. 
 &bquo;Besides, coming back to your problem, Inspector, nearly everybody had some of the horseradish sauce.&equo; 
 &bquo;Exactly, sir. 
 Our problem is that while Mrs Iverson appears to have ingested that from which she died at the dinner party there is no dish from which some or all the guests did not share.&equo; 
 &bquo;Difficult,&equo; agreed Henry, &bquo;and made more so, I imagine, by the fact that both the Coroner and the Chairman of the Magistrates&equo; Bench were there.&equo; 
 Detective Inspector Milsom said with deep feeling that this had not helped in the investigation so far. 
 &bquo;They both insist that  there was no way in which their hostess could have been poisoned before their very eyes &mdash; and both the parlourmaid and the cook swear that she didn't take anything afterwards. 
 What with the doctor going straight out and the deceased going down to the kitchen to thank both staff for a very good meal there wasn't time &mdash; even if she took it herself, which is unlikely from all I hear.&equo; 
 &bquo;That means Edith and Cook liked her,&equo; said Henry at once. 
 &bquo;And I understand there were no money troubles&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;None,&equo; said the inspector stoutly. 
 &bquo;She was very well-off, was Mrs Iverson.&equo; 
 &bquo;And yet&hellip;.&equo; began Henry. 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 The policeman leaned forward. 
 &bquo;It does seem almost staged, doesn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just what the chief constable said&hellip;.&equo; the detective inspector lowered his head. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, sir, I shouldn't have said that.&equo; 
 Henry Tyler waved a hand airily. 
 &bquo;My dear fellow, we spend our time here working on things that shouldn't have been said, but unless they are,&equo; he added thoughtfully, &bquo;nobody gets anywhere. 
 That case of pneumonia?&equo; 
 &bquo;Genuine&equo;, said the inspector. 
 &bquo;The doctor had visited the man earlier in the day and said he would be back later that night when he thought the pneumonia would have reached its crisis.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mrs Iverson hadn't been beastly to Miss Amy hall, I take it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Kindness itself, I understand, sir.&equo; 
 He coughed. 
 &bquo;That doesn't mean that Miss Hall enjoys being a poor relation. 
 Very few people do, sir. 
 However, both staff agree Miss Hall fitted in as well as anyone could in the circumstances. 
 Cook is the most observant woman, and parlourmaids have to be of a noticing cast of mind, otherwise they wouldn't be any good for the job, would they, sir?&equo; 
 Henry confessed it was something that hadn't crossed his mind before.  
 &bquo;Like detective constables,&equo; said the inspector generously. 
 &bquo;Constable Bewman here pointed out that each guest had their plate handed to them by Edith but I can't see how that would give the murderer any scope.&equo; 
 Henry frowned. 
 &bquo;She would have done it in a preordained way, of course,&equo; mused Henry. 
 &bquo;The lady on the host's right first, and then the one on his left. 
 My sister was served after them, I think, and then Miss Amy and Mrs Iverson.&equo; 
 &bquo;That would have meant,&equo; said the inspector alertly, &bquo;that anyone who knew where you were all sitting would have been able work out who would get which plate in the pile.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, yes, Inspector.&equo; 
 Henry Tyler smiled faintly. 
 &bquo;It's an interesting little puzzle when you think about it like that. 
 The quickness of the hand deceiving the eye and all that. 
 Except that we don't know whose hand.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yet&hellip;&equo; responded Milsom. 
 Detective Constable Bewman scratched his head. 
 &bquo;But even if you knew beforehand who was going to get &mdash; say &mdash; the fifth plate, how could you put poison on it and not on the other plates?&equo; 
 &bquo;Difficult,&equo; agreed Henry Tyler, &bquo;isn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;But not impossible,&equo; growled Milsom. 
 &bquo;According to the pathologist, the timing is wrong for her being poisoned except at the meal. 
 He's prepared to swear to that.&equo; 
 Henry Tyler screwed up his face in an effort of recollection. 
 &bquo;There were some glazed onions and Duchesse potatoes round the fillet&hellip; our host put those on the individual plates before he handed them to Edith.&equo; 
 &bquo;We thought of that, sir,&equo; said the inspector, a touch of melancholy in his voice. 
 &bquo;Both were brought in from the garden &mdash; home grown &mdash; and never left the kitchen until Cook gave them to Edith for the table. 
 Apparently the doctor's very particular about his potatoes. 
 Never lets seed be used that's more than two years out of Scotland.&equo;  
 &bquo;Quite right,&equo; said Henry stoutly. 
 &bquo;I think the same should go for the Scots race, too.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not everyone had the same pudding,&equo; said the inspector with a certain tenacity. 
 &bquo;Some had one and some had the other.&equo; 
 &bquo;And some, Inspector, I fear, had both.&equo; 
 &bquo;And those that had the Normandy pudding,&equo; said Detective Constable Bewman, &bquo;had the wine sauce that went with it.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was a splendid sauce,&equo; said Henry appreciatively. 
 &bquo;Consisting, I understand,&equo; said Milsom heavily, &bquo;of a small glass of brandy, ditto of Madeira, a gill of water, an ounce of unsalted butter and a little caster sugar.&equo; 
 &bquo;You should try it some time, Inspector,&equo; said Henry. 
 &bquo;It was handed round,&equo; said Milsom, ignoring this frivolity, &bquo;by Edith in a sauce boat on a tray.&equo; 
 &bquo;No room for monkey business there,&equo; agreed Henry. 
 &bquo;Or with the fruit and nuts.&equo; 
 &bquo;Two bowls of each were placed within easy reach of all the guests,&equo; said Milsom. 
 &bquo;In theory, I suppose, the nearest piece of fruit could have been doctored, but I don't see myself how the murderer could have been sure the victim would have picked it.&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Henry noted how the detective inspector's speech had now widened to include words like &bquo;poison&equo; and &bquo;murderer&equo;. 
 &bquo;I can't tell you if Mrs Iverson had any port.&equo; 
 He grinned. 
 &bquo;I did and it was splendid.&equo; 
 &bquo;Vintage,&equo; said Milsom. 
 &bquo;1912 and nothing wrong with it at all.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just as well to check though,&equo; agreed Henry gravely. 
 &bquo;The doctor had decanted it himself,&equo; the policeman informed him, reddening slightly, &bquo;before the guests arrived.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't be too careful with a really crusty port,&equo; said Henry. 
 &bquo;Someone,&equo; said Inspector Milsom meaningfully, &bquo;seems to have been altogether too careful to my way of thinking.&equo; 
 Henry Tyler nodded. 
 &bquo;Careful and very clever, Inspector. 
 It takes a great deal of prestidigitatory skill to poison someone before your very eyes so to speak.&equo;  
 &bquo;That's not a word that I know sir but I think I take your meaning.&equo; 
 &bquo;We are talking of the art of the conjuror&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; said Milsom. 
 &bquo;Where did the patter come in then?&equo; enquired Detective Constable Bewman. 
 &bquo;You would have all been talking normally like, wouldn't you, sir?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes&hellip; that is, I suppose so.&equo; 
 Henry cast his mind back to the small talk of a small town. 
 &bquo;Conversation was very general. 
 The nearest thing to a conjuring trick was the new bell-push that had been fitted under the carpet for Mrs Iverson.&equo; 
 &bquo;That was the doctor's idea, sir. 
 Cook tells me he'd seen it somewhere and wanted one for his wife. 
 The parlourmaid likes it because it saves her&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Just a minute,&equo; said Henry, a thought beginning to burgeon in his mind. 
 &bquo;You, Constable, said something about a conjuror's patter.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't get that many silent ones, sir,&equo; responded Bewman stolidly. 
 &bquo;Not on stage, anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;It did occur to me that the doctor did choose an odd moment to draw attention to the bell's being there. 
 It would have been much more subtle just to have allowed his wife to demonstrate it when the time came and then to turn it into a talking point.&equo; 
 &bquo;Out of character you might say?&equo; suggested the inspector. 
 &bquo;And what, might I ask, sir, was he doing at the time he was talking about the bell?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, he wasn't doing the talking at that point, Inspector. 
 It was Mrs Iverson who was telling us about it after he mentioned it.&equo; 
 &bquo;So,&equo; reasoned the inspector, &bquo;all the guests were looking at her?&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose we were.&equo; 
 &bquo;So,&equo; said Milsom patiently, &bquo;what was the doctor doing while she was talking?&equo; 
 Henry Tyler cast his mind back to the fatal evening. 
 &bquo;He was  carving the fillet of beef. 
 He'd just begun. 
 He took off the first slice, you know the rather well-done, brown bit at the end, and laid it on one side of the serving dish and then he cut the next slice off for the first lady and so on.&equo; 
 &bquo;We can't work out how he could have killed his wife while he was sitting at the opposite end of the table,&equo; said Constable Bewman n&auml;ively. 
 &bquo;You have rather got it in for the doctor, haven't you?&equo; said Henry easily. 
 &bquo;Most male murderers are widowers,&equo; growled Milsom. 
 &bquo;What we don't like, Mr Tyler, is that Mrs Iverson was poisoned in full view of the Coroner and the Chairman of the Bench.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aye, there's the rub,&equo; as William Shakespeare so wisely said,&equo; murmured Henry. 
 &bquo;And Miss Chalder is a very good-looking girl.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, so that's the way the wind blows, is it?&equo; said Henry, his mind beginning to stray. 
 &bquo;Mind you,&equo; he added fairly, &bquo;doctors are able to get their hands on poison more easily than most of us.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, didn't I say, Mr Tyler? 
 It wasn't a medical poison that was used to kill Mrs Tyler.&equo; 
 &bquo;No?&equo; 
 If Henry thought that there was a contradiction in terms about the words &bquo;medical poison&equo; he did not Let it show in his face. 
 &bquo;More of a horticultural poison,&equo; said the inspector, &bquo;although not intended as such.&equo; 
 He consulted his notebook. 
 &bquo;The substance was called ethylene chlorohydrin if that means anything to you, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm afraid not,&equo; said Henry regretfully. 
 &bquo;Used to speed the germination of seeds and potatoes,&equo; said the inspector, &bquo;and as a cleaning solvent.&equo; 
 &bquo;And it's odourless,&equo; chimed in Constable Bewman helpfully. 
 &bquo;So there was no need to have anything highly scented or smelling strongly on the table,&equo; said Henry at once. 
 &bquo;I hope you never take it into your head to commit a murder,  sir,&equo; said the Inspector. 
 &bquo;You do seem to have an eye for essentials.&equo; 
 &bquo;And how much of this &mdash; er &mdash; horticultural poison does it take to kill a human being?&equo; asked Henry, ignoring this last. 
 &bquo;Not a lot,&equo; said the inspector quietly. 
 &bquo;Something under a fifth of a teaspoonful &mdash; say four or five drops &mdash; added to which it is highly soluble.&equo; 
 &bquo;It seems to me,&equo; said Henry Tyler, in the last analysis a Ministry man, &bquo;that this stuff, whatever it is, is something that ought to be put a stop to.&equo; 
 &bquo;Very possible, sir,&equo; said the inspector smoothly. 
 &bquo;And after the fruit and nuts?&equo; 
 &bquo;We all moved back into the drawing-room for coffee,&equo; said Henry, &bquo;and I performed my arty trick with the cream and the back of a spoon.&equo; 
 He looked up. 
 &bquo;It's not a conjuring trick, Inspector.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm glad to hear it, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a question of how to get the cream to float on top of the coffee.&equo; 
 &bquo;Very difficult, I'm sure, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not when you know how.&equo; 
 &bquo;I think that is going to be the case with the ethylene chlorohydrin, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Er &mdash; quite, Inspector. 
 Well, with the coffee it's all a matter of putting the sugar in first and stirring well. 
 That increases the surface tension on the top of the coffee &mdash; or is it the specific gravity? &mdash; so that when you dribble the cream slowly down over the back of the spoon it stays on the top.&equo; 
 &bquo;And Bob's your uncle, so to speak?&equo; said the inspector, paying unconscious tribute to an old nepotism. 
 &bquo;It worked,&equo; said Henry. 
 &bquo;Whether it distracted everyone else long enough to slip five drops of something into Mrs Iverson's coffee, I wouldn't know, Inspector.&equo; 
 &bquo;But we would, Mr Tyler. 
 You see, Mrs Iverson never drank coffee. 
 And we have it on the authority of those sitting near her  that she did not drink it that evening.&equo; 
 He coughed. 
 &bquo;If I may say so your sister was particularly emphatic on the point.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good old Wendy,&equo; said Henry, then frowned. 
 &bquo;I say, Inspector, that does rather leave every avenue explored, doesn't it?&equo; 
 Detective Inspector Milsom assented to this sentiment with a quiet nod. 
 &bquo;Every avenue that we can think of.&equo; 
 &bquo;What we want, then, Inspector,&equo; he said bracingly, &bquo;is a new avenue or fresh look at an old one.&equo; 
 &bquo;Either would do very nicely, sir.&equo; 
 With an ironic smile Milsom said, &bquo;Which do you recommend?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, a new look at an old problem,&equo; said Henry Tyler at once. 
 &bquo;We don't have new problems in the Foreign Office.&equo; 
 &bquo;The only matter which you have brought to our attention, sir, which seems to have escaped everyone else's notice was the &mdash; er &mdash; untimely mention of the footbell.&equo; 
 &bquo;Which doesn't get us very much furth&hellip; wait a minute, Inspector, wait a minute.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sir?&equo; 
 &bquo;Suppose it does?&equo; 
 Henry ran his hands through his hair in a gesture of excitement that his sister would have recognized well. 
 &bquo;Suppose it was meant to turn all eyes towards our hostess?&equo; 
 &bquo;And to take them off your host?&equo; said Milsom astringently. 
 &bquo;Exactly!&equo; 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, if it was intended as a distraction, then that must have been the moment when he poisoned his wife. 
 That follows, doesn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a thought worth considering, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Watch out, Inspector, if you can talk like that in response to one of my brainwaves we'll have you working here.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, thank you, sir. 
 We've got enough troubles of our own in Calleshire.&equo; 
 &bquo;I think you're going to have one less in a minute.&equo; 
 He brought his fist down on his desk with a bang. 
 &bquo;Inspector, until  this moment I have always felt that the benefit of a classical education was over-rated.&equo; 
 &bquo;Indeed, sir?&equo; 
 &bquo;But not now! 
 Parysatis, wife of Darius, killed Statira, wife of Artaxerxes, in much the same way as Mrs Iverson was murdered.&equo; 
 Detective Inspector Milsom leaned forward, his notebook prominent. 
 &bquo;Tell me&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Now I know what else it was Dr Iverson did when he went through to see to the claret before dinner.&equo; 
 Henry rubbed his hands. 
 &bquo;First he probably smeared a little horseradish sauce or even some colourless Vaseline on the righthand side of the carving knife. 
 Then he added a fatal dose of your ethylene stuff to it and put it back on the carving rest&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;With the other blade facing upward.&equo; 
 Detective Constable Bewman could hardly contain his excitement. 
 Then his face fell. 
 &bquo;But why didn't the first guest get the poisoned beef?&equo; 
 Detective Inspector Milsom said quietly, &bquo;Because the doctor laid the first slice of the fillet &mdash; the piece that you don't give to guests &mdash; to one side of the carving dish&hellip; 
 Mr Tyler said so.&equo; 
 &bquo;But put it on his wife's plate later without anyone noticing,&equo; said Henry. 
 &bquo;Only the left hand side of the carving knife touched the next piece of meat, while the right hand side had been neatly wiped on the outside piece, so everyone else's meat was unaffected.&equo; 
 He sat back in his chair. 
 &bquo;Parysatis did it with a chicken and I should have thought of it before.&equo; 
 THE SEVENTH BIRMINGHAM INTERNATIONAL film &amp; television FESTIVAL 20 SEPT&ndash; 5 OCT 1991  
 Contents: 
 Introductions Festival Board Festival Staff 
 Opening and Closing Films Mid-Festival Special Screenings 
 Festival Fortnight of International Cinema 
 Bertrand Tavernier Retrospective A Tribute to Muriel Box 
 Working Title: the story so far World Premiere: UB40: A Family Affair 
 Third Cinema Focus 
 The Ghatak Tradition 
 Festival Films and Events Calendar 
 Booking Information 
 Television Weekend Conference Cities and Media Forum 
 Writers Talks: Guardian Screen and TV Writers, Royal Television Society lecture, Writers Workshops 
 Location Birmingham 
 Raymond Williams Memorial Lecture Eureka Audio Visual Opening Shots Forum Awards Dinner 
 Media Business Seminars Independent Producers Forum 
 Exhibitions; Screenings and Events at other venues 
 Children's Films Fifth and Sixth Form Screenings 
 A&ndash;Z of Films and Directors Film Festival Sponsors and Acknowledgements. 
 Inside: 
 Rik Mayall in DROP DEAD FRED This year's opening film 
 STEPPING OUT The Director of SHIRLEY VALENTINE teams up with the stars of EDUCATING RITA and CABARET 
 WHO NEEDS A HEART We premiere the brand new film from the makers of HANDSWORTH SONGS 
 THE COMMITMENTS Alan Parker's new film closes the Festival. 
 &bquo;Wonderfully humorous, and bursting with life&equo; 
 FREE YOUR ESSENTIAL GUIDE TO THE FESTIVAL 
 introductions 
 the City of Birmingham has great movie traditions. 
 The inventor of celluloid, Alexander Parkes, was a Birmingham man. 
 So too was Oscar Deutsch who set up the Odeon Cinema chain from Colmore Row in the 20's and 30's. 
 Sir Michael Balcon of Ealing Studio fame, who named the policeman George Dixon in the film The Blue Lamp after his old school is also a son of the city. 
 And as last year's retrospective of the films of Tony Garnett has shown, Birmingham's impressive movie traditions are continuing. 
 It is on this splendid foundation that the Birmingham International Film and Television Festival is built enhancing the City of Birmingham as a media city. 
 The Birmingham International Film and Television Festival enters its seventh year in 1991 acknowledged as an event of national and international importance. 
 The Festival also plays a role in the artistic renaissance of Birmingham, a profile confirmed by the continuing success of the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra, under its Artistic Director, Simon Rattle, the recent move of both the Birmingham Royal Ballet (formerly Sadler's Wells Royal Ballet) and the D'Oyly Carte Opera Company to Birmingham, the newly launched &bquo;Towards The Millennium&equo; annual arts Festival and the Arts Council of Great Britain's invitation to Birmingham to launch Arts 2000, as the UK City of Music in 1992. 
 The film and television industries are important ingredients of the city's culture and the Festival reflects this life-style in its informal atmosphere, giving endless pleasure to the many cinema goers from the city and to the numerous professionals who visit the city for the Festival. 
 I wish the Festival success for 1991. 
  COUNCILLOR BRYAN BIRD Chairman, Leisure Services Committee  
 To the Festival with that 7 year itch 
 As a great movie fan, each year I try and keep a fortnight clear to spend time at the Birmingham International Film and Television Festival. 
 The Festival's come of age of late and I am more than happy that my sax playing has been the soundtrack for the Festival's cinema trailer in recent years. 
 For film lovers the Festival's the place to be in September. 
 It grows from strength to strength each year and the quality of the programme gets even better. 
 As a director myself of music films it's great to know the Festival is contributing so imaginatively to the re-emergence of Birmingham as a major city of culture. 
 After returning from a 30 month tour with UB40, I believe that Birmingham is establishing itself as Europe's leading city of the arts and media. 
 You can sense the creative buzz in the city. 
 I've set up my own production company now to harness the talent that's in the city and bring more media business to Birmingham. 
 I was going to call my new film &bquo;In Bed With UB40&equo; but Madonna got there first. 
 All the best to the Festival with that 7 year itch. 
  Brian Travers, UB40    
 opening film 
 drop dead fred 
 Our opener this year has been a runaway success in the States where the box office success of this relatively low budget film has taken everyone by surprise. 
 The Festival now brings you the chance to see for yourself Rik Mayall and Phoebe Cates, in a tale of an imaginary friend with a difference. 
 Mayall plays Fred, the obnoxious character summoned up by a mixed up young woman with hilarious and chaotic consequences. 
 Rik Mayall's name was all it took to persuade Ate de Jong to direct the film: &bquo;I knew him from his work in THE YOUNG ONES. 
 He was great to work with &mdash; I'd do anything to work with him again. 
 It's a pretty bizarre film, but it's not dark or mean spirited in its intentions. 
 Fred has a vicious quality, but he's childlike. 
 He may bring problems but he also helps to solve them&equo;. 
 DROP DEAD FRED is produced by Working Title, whose films we are celebrating throughout the Festival, so it's particularly appropriate that their latest success opens the Festival. 
 Expect the Young Ones crossed with Beetlejuice, Kevin Turvey meets the Female Brat Pack (Phoebe Cates, Bridget Fonda) and an example of how to make an Anglo-American film and make it work. 
 DROP DEAD FRED is set to be this year's A FISH CALLED WANDA! 
 closing film 
 the commitments 
 &bquo;A richly realistic, pointedly perceptive portrait of the passions and pitfalls of the local band scene. 
 Wonderfully humorous, bursting with life and packed with enough solid soul music to make the blood dance in your veins&equo;. 
 Mike Davies. 
 THE COMMITMENTS is Alan Parker's new film and represents a change of direction for him which has been phenomenally successful. 
 Somehow working with a young cast in Dublin has brought out the best in Parker as a director to create the film that is already being talked about as the best rock movie in years. 
 The story starts with Jimmy Rabbitte, a man with a vision. 
 His vision is to bring soul music to Dublin, and he sets out to bring together a band with raw potential and rough and ready talent. 
 He collects a motley crew of musicians and singers, drunken Deco, Dean with his uncle's sax, Billy, who has to have his drums redeemed from the pawnbrokers, Joey &bquo;The Lips&equo; Fagan, and the girls Imelda, Natalie and Bernie. 
 There are personality clashes in the band, and jealousies and rivalries spring up, but all dissent disappears when they perform. 
 But inevitably the break up occurs just at the band's moment of triumph&hellip; 
 &bquo;Sex, soul music, dodgy clubs, animal drummers, smarmy record company bosses. 
 All wrapped up in irresistible humour and a zest for life. 
 THE COMMITMENTS makes you want to rush out, form a band and change your name to Otis Redding&equo;. 
 &bquo;As I write, we are editing and mixing the music. 
 With luck, we might have captured a little of the spit and spunk of the working class kids of Dublin's Northside. 
 Also, I hope we've caught the wit and wisdom of Roddy Doyle's original novel. 
 Our film is set in Dublin, Ireland, but it's about the hopes and dreams, music brings to young kids everywhere, from Fingas to Philadelphia and Memphis to Minsk&equo;. 
  Alan Parker, May '91.  
 mid festival screenings 
 BOYZ &bquo;N&equo; THE HOOD 
 BOYZ &bquo;N&equo; THE HOOD, a powerful drama about coming of age in Black urban America, marks the feature film writing and directing debut of 23-year-old John Singleton. 
 It tells a poignant story about the community where Singleton grew up: of three friends growing up in a South Central Los Angeles neighbourhood, and of street life where friendship, pain, danger and love combine to form reality. 
 Tre (Cuba Gooding Jr), Dough Boy (Ice Cube) and Ricky (Morris Chestnut), are three young blacks brought up in an area where violence prevails. 
 Shot entirely on location in South Central LA, the film aims to give the first true picture of what life is like in the &bquo;LA Hood&equo;. 
 It was not uncommon during production, for police helicopters to circle above nearby houses, for gang members to object that actors were wearing an opposing gang's colours, or for police cars to speed past the set in hot pursuit. 
 But in the midst of these distractions, another side of reality was filmed &mdash; the lives of the people in the community who don't make news. 
 It is that real-life drama that Singleton decided to explore and recreate on film. 
 One scene among many that captures the ironic mix of commonplace and macabre has two kids battling over a football, just a few feet away from a dead body. 
 This uncompromising look into the choices confronting young Black Americans has aroused considerable interest in the States. 
 &bquo;It is my story, I live it. 
 What sense would it have made to have some white boy impose his interpretation on my experience?&equo; 
 YOUNG SOUL REBELS 
 Chris and Caz are two soulmates who are disc-jockeys on a pirate radio station they run from the back of a North London garage. 
 Their lives take a startling turn when a friend is murdered in the local park. 
 Winner of the Critics Prize at Cannes 1991, YOUNG SOUL REBELS takes place during the summer of 1977, a significant year, being the Queen's Silver Jubilee. 
 British nationalism was in the air and patriotic sentiments ran high. 
 Punk was at its zenith and political and cultural oppositions were intense. 
 Parallel to the highly-publicised excesses of punk was an equally important but historically invisible development, the growth of black popular culture, particularly the development of soul music. 
 &bquo;From MY BEAUTIFUL LAUNDRETTE to SOUL II SOUL, Britain's black culture has seduced the rest of the globe. 
 It has shaped those fashions, sounds and images young people around the world perceive as the essence of being British. 
 And, from Rifat Ozbek fashion reels to Neneh Cherry raps, much of this black style has been exported on radio and television. 
 Thus primed, an international market is keen to see films made by young black Britons. 
 It is against this background and out of this environment that YOUNG SOUL REBELS came about.&equo;  
 Cynthia Rose, Vogue Magazine 
 festival fortnight of international cinema 
 This year the festival brings you the chance to see a wide and varied selection of the films which will be remembered as the highlights of cinema in 1991. 
 Aside from our Opening and Closing Galas and special Mid Festival screenings, we will be putting the spotlight on the best films from the international festival circuit and some eagerly awaited new releases. 
 Amongst the British films selected are DAKOTA ROAD, the new release from the prolific Working Title company, a tale of sexual awakening set in the East Anglian fens; CLOSE MY EYES, Stephen Poliakoff's second film as director, which stars Saskia Reeves who is also in THE BRIDGE, a new film which takes an impressionist painting as the starting point of a tale of illicit passion in the repressive Victorian era. 
 We are also screening THE OBJECT OF BEAUTY, starring Andie MacDowell and John Malkovich in the cautionary story of two Americans stranded in London who discover themselves penniless, and how this affects their relationship. 
 The British production company Zenith were so impressed by Hal Hartley's first feature that they signed him up to make TRUST, which we will be screening at the festival. 
 And as part of the special mid-festival event, we will show YOUNG SOUL REBELS, Issac Julien's film about young black DJs in the London of 1977, which won the Critics Prize at this year's Cannes film festival. 
 Lastly, we are proud to be screening Derek Jarman's new film EDWARD II. 
 We are delighted to continue the festival tradition of presenting films by talented young Canadian directors: amongst the titles we will screen this year are HIGHWAY 61, by the director of last year's cult classic ROADKILL &bquo;H&equo;, a harrowing tale of a young couple's fight to kick heroin; AN IMAGINARY TALE, a weird and wonderful fantasy from Montreal; plus two short films from the Canadian Centre for Advanced Film Studies, including John Greyson's new film THE MAKING OF &bquo;MONSTERS&equo;. 
 From the States highlights include Kathryn Bigelow's new film POINT BREAK with Keanu Reeves and Patrick Swayze; AUNT JULIA AND THE SCRIPTWRITER, directed by Jon Amiel and starring Barbara Hershey and Peter Falk: the low budget smash hit JULIA HAS TWO LOVERS; PARIS TROUT, a powerful drama from the Deep South with Dennis Hopper and the ubiquitous Barbara Hershey. 
 The festival is also screening POISON, one of the most controversial American films for a long time, which has caused storms of protest in the States and will be a film that has everyone talking. 
 And our other Mid Festival Special Event is BOYZ &bquo;N&equo; THE HOOD, John Singleton's tale of kids from the black ghettoes of L.A. 
 From Europe, we present the films that have caught the eyes of critics and audiences at the major European film festivals.  
 Young Soul Rebels 
 Julia Has Two Lovers 
 Object of Beauty 
 Titles include Lars von Trier's EUROPA, shown in competition at Cannes: RECOLLECTIONS OF THE YELLOW HOUSE, which won a Silver Leopard at Venice and Claude Berri's film starring Gerard Depardieu, URANUS, screened in competition at Berlin. 
 Also screening are films from Japan and Korea: WHY DID BODHI DHARMA LEAVE FOR THE EAST?: the re-issued Kurosawa classic DERSU UZALA and CIRCUS BOYS, by talented young director Kaizo Hayashi. 
 DEATH IN BRUNSWICK is an Australian film starring Sam Neill, which Derek Malcolm named as one of the Best Ten Films in the Edinburgh Film Festival this year. 
 We are screening several of those titles, see if you can work out which ones they are! 
 Festivals are one of the few opportunities in the UK for screening short films, and we will be presenting not just this year's BFI New Directors shorts, but also programmes of short films from film schools in the UK and Canada, from the Arts Council funded schemes and films funded by the filmmakers themselves. 
 These short filmmakers are the people who will go on to be the Jarmans, Greenaways, Jarmuschs of the Nineties; see their work now and tell your friends you discovered them first! 
 There are many more titles, many more wonderful experiences of international cinema. 
 We hope that you will take the opportunity to enjoy one of the most exciting programmes available in Britain: the cinema of the world comes to Birmingham!  
 Boyz &bquo;N&equo; the Hood 
 FOR FULL DETAILS OF ALL FILMS SCREENED IN THE FESTIVAL PLEASE SEE THE FESTIVAL SOUVENIR PROGRAMME ON SALE FROM ALL VENUES AND AT OTHER OUTLETS THROUGHOUT THE CITY. 
 The Bridge 
 bertrand tavernier retro 
 One of the major retrospective strands of this year's Festival is a tribute to the French film director Bertrand Tavernier, whose latest film THESE FOOLISH THINGS starring Dirk Bogarde and Jane Birkin, has received critical acclaim and a warm reception from audiences. 
 Tavernier, who is a native Lyon, Birmingham's twin town, has had a life long love affair with cinema. 
 He originally studied law, before dropping out to devote himself to film criticism and assistant direction on films. 
 His book, 30 Ans du Cinema Americain has become a seminal text for cinephiles everywhere. 
 His films cover a wide range of subjects and genres, from the futurist science fiction world of QUE LA FETE COMMENCE and THE JUDGE AND THE ASSASSIN to the wonderful evocation of the modern day Cote D'Azur in THESE FOOLISH THINGS. 
 As a director his work embraces both the narrative traditions of French cinema and a critical awareness of the styles and conventions of Hollywood. 
 His homage to jazz music ROUND MIDNIGHT fuses these elements with Tavernier's unique ability to encapsulate time and mood. 
 &bquo;For Tavernier, the cinema counts more than anything. 
 He would live in an attic and wear threadbare clothes provides he could go on seeing and making movies&equo;. 
 This quote from Jean Aurenche, who co-scripted Tavernier's first three features, identifies the driving force which informs all the director's work, and has made him one of the leading European directors today. 
 We are delighted to announce that Tavernier, who will just have finished shooting his latest film will be in Birmingham on October 5th to talk about his work with The Guardian film critic Derek Malcolm. 
 This is a rare opportunity to listen to Tavernier's ideas about film and about the relationship between European and American cinema, a subject about which he has strong views. 
 Over the festival period we will be screening a selective retrospective of the director's work at the Triangle cinema. 
 This retrospective is sponsored by Barclays de Zoete Wedd with additional support from the British Council and the City of Birmingham.  
 Bertrand Tavernier and Philippe Noiret &mdash; Life and Nothing But 
 Watchmaker of St Paul 
 Sunday in the Country 
 &bquo;I think my films are very, very French. 
 I feel they are rooted in something that has to do with culture, with a sense of history, a sense of past, a sense of tradition. 
 I believe in stories, not plots&equo; Bertrand Tavernier in the New York Times 
 BARCLAYS de ZOETE WEDD The British Council Birmingham-Lyon 40 years 
 a tribute to muriel box (1905&ndash;1991) 
 It was to her own surprise that Muriel Box, the director of 14 modest budget feature films between 1951 and 1964, found herself an inspiration and a role model for a new generation of women film-makers, critics and students. 
 She was &bquo;rediscovered&equo; as a film-maker in the early 80's, and a series of retrospectives and tributes culminated in 1990 at the International Festival of Women's Films in Creteil, where a programme of her work was feted by capacity audiences. 
 Her first husband was Sydney Box, the writer-director who became head of production at Gainsborough Studios; and her sister-in-law was the &bquo;Miss Box Office&equo; who produced the wildly successful &bquo;DOCTOR IN THE HOUSE&equo; films over two decades. 
 But Muriel's climb to film direction was slow and gradual, and she began her apprenticeship as a typist and then continuity girl, rising throughout the studio hierarchy. 
 She wrote theatre plays, often for all women casts, which anticipated her work on Gainsborough films, with their dominant roles for women stars and strong appeal to women audiences. 
 After directing the Verity films, the company she and Sydney formed during the Second World War, she moved into independent feature production. 
 The Boxes were snapped up by Gainsborough Studios after winning a joint screenwriting Oscar for &bquo;THE SECOND VEIL&equo;. 
 After Gainsborough closed, Muriel and Sydney moved to Pinewood, part of the Rank Organisation, and eventually (in spite of Michael Balcon's pronouncement that women were unsuited to be film directors) Muriel was directing features. 
 Her films are a wry and witty commentary on the 50's, that strange watershed in British history. 
 In spite of her own feminism and socialism her films are not propagandist or didactic, as she was very well aware that: &bquo;We were not engaged to indulge our own politics or socialism, however much we would have found satisfaction in doing so&equo;. 
 What is remarkable is the extent to which she was able nonetheless to express intelligent analysis and genuine commitment even when working through apparently tame generic materials for Rank. 
 She made several &bquo;women's&equo; films for Rank, including STREET CORNER (1953) about the women police in Chelsea, which she always cited as a particularly enjoyable experience since it involved working with a mainly female crew and cast. 
 Another outstanding Box feature was SIMON AND LAURA (1956) a comedy about live television production starring Kay Kendall and Peter Finch whose wit and sharpness has not since been rivalled by films on similar themes. 
 Her films are by no means as simple as they may have first appeared. 
 They make deceptively subtle demands on their audience, and through all of them there runs a strong sense of humour. 
 Her last film &bquo;RATTLE OF A SIMPLE MAN&equo; (1964) whose commercial and critical failure ended her career, can be seen as a woman's reply to the eulogies of the working class male celebrated by John Osbourne and his like, and it does so by poking fun at the ideology of the male and his crude sexism. 
 Ironically, this film stands up better today than many of its male social realist counterparts. 
  Caroline Merz.  
 We will be screening SIMON AND LAURA as a tribute to Muriel Box on Wednesday 25 September in the MAC at 9pm. 
 The screening will follow a Guardian Talk with Lynda La Plante, one of the few women to have established herself in television drama as a writer.  
 Simon and Laura 
 Muriel Box 
 selected filmography 
 working title: the story so far&hellip; 
 One of the real success stories of British film-making in the 80's was Tim Bevan and Sarah Radclyffe's production company &bquo;Working Title&equo;, and that success is continuing into the 90's. 
 In partnership with Graham Bradstreet, Bevan and Radclyffe have, as a company and individually, produced a wide range of successful film and TV dramas and documentaries, making them one of the UK's most creative and innovative independent film and television partnerships. 
 Formed in 1984, &bquo;Working Title&equo; achieved their breakthrough with &bquo;MY BEAUTIFUL LAUNDRETTE&equo;, one of the most important films in the British cinema renaissance of the mid-Eighties. 
 But Bevan and Radclyffe quickly proved that &bquo;Laundrette&equo; was not a one hit wonder by going on to produce &bquo;WISH YOU WERE HERE&equo;, which made Emily Lloyd a Hollywood hot property, followed by the powerful and moving &bquo;A WORLD APART&equo;. 
 Chris Menges' directorial debut which received critical acclaim and festival awards throughout the world. 
 One of the strengths of the company has been their ability to produce films with a wide range of styles and subject, without losing their commitment to brave and adventurous film-making. 
 Their list of successes includes &bquo;PERSONAL SERVICES&equo; (a Zenith production), &bquo;CARAVAGGIO&equo; (produced by Sarah Radclyffe for the BFI) &bquo;SAMMY AND ROSIE GET LAID&equo;, &bquo;FOR QUEEN AND COUNTRY&equo;, &bquo;PAPERHOUSE&equo; and &bquo;FOOLS OF FORTUNE&equo;. 
 They have also set up their own television production company, WTTV, developing projects including &bquo;NEWSHOUNDS&equo; with Alison Steadman and Adrian Edmondson, which won the top prize in the Best Television Film category at last year's BAFTA awards. 
 They also produced &bquo;LORNA DOONE&equo; with Clive Owen, and are now working on a series based on the children's classic &bquo;THE BORROWERS&equo; and a major drama series adapted from Armistead Maupin's cult novels &bquo;TALES OF THE CITY&equo;. 
 &bquo;Working Title&equo; have a slate of releases for 1991 which is more than impressive: in addition to &bquo;ROBIN HOOD&equo; produced by Sarah Radclyffe for 20th Century Fox, they have also completed two American based productions: &bquo;DROP DEAD FRED&equo; with Rik Mayall and Phoebe Cates and &bquo;RUBIN AND ED&equo;. 
 Meanwhile, in the UK, &bquo;LONDON KILLS ME&equo;, &bquo;EDWARD II&equo; and &bquo;DAKOTA ROAD&equo; were all recently completed. 
 They are currently shooting their biggest budget movie so far: &bquo;A MAP OF THE HUMAN HEART&equo; with the brilliant young New Zealand director, Vincent Ward, who directed the strange and wonderful &bquo;NAVIGATOR&equo;. 
 As &bquo;Working Title&equo; continue to expand and develop, it seems a good moment to look back at some of their prolific and varied output, and we will be screening a number of titles from &bquo;MY BEAUTIFUL LAUNDRETTE&equo; through the powerful drama &bquo;A WORLD APART&equo;, scripted by Gillian Slovo, Ruth First's daughter, and underrated films like &bquo;PAPERHOUSE&equo; to &bquo;ROBIN HOOD&equo;, scripted by John Mcgrath, and then a number of their new releases: &bquo;EDWARD II&equo; (directed by Derek Jarman), &bquo;DAKOTA ROAD&equo; and &bquo;DROP DEAD FRED&equo;, which has been a huge box office hit in the States. 
 filmography 
 in production 
 SCREENING at a glance 
 WORLD PREMIERE UB40 a family affair 
 Brian Travers, founder member of UB40, launched his film production company, Brian Travers Associates, with a great start, shooting UB40 live at Finsbury Park. 
 Brum based Brian Travers, producer and director of musical films for many years, and well known saxophonist in the internationally renowned band, UB40, has already made his mark on the music industry. 
 Now B.T.A. aim to utilise the wealth of talent in our city in film and video production. 
 Pre-production began whilst UB40 were completing the final leg of their 30 month World Tour, culminating in a twelve camera shoot on Saturday 21 June at Finsbury Park in North London. 
 Director Roger Pomphrey's documentary crew filmed UB40 at home in Brum and followed them down to London with their families and friends. 
 Once at Finsbury Park, the cameras caught them at the sound check, in interviews, backstage, and relaxing before the gig. 
 Uniting music and image, this unusual concert film provides insight into the staging of the event, the comments of the fans and the band. 
 Featuring many of their greatest hits, the film captures the Brummie Band at their best, before an audience of around 35,000 eager fans. 
 Brian Travers Associates are proud to show the world premiere of this new film in UB40's home town at the Birmingham Film and Television Festival.  
 SCREENING at a glance 
 third focus 
 &bquo;colonial power, black politics, desire &amp; music&equo; 
 Over the last year thousands of films have been produced all over the world. 
 Yet what we normally get to see on British cinema screens represents a small slice of what is produced globally. 
 This has very little to do with the quality and entertainment value of the films themselves. 
 What gets investment and what is shown has far more to do with the economic stranglehold of the Hollywood studios and the distribution/exhibition chains. 
 This year's Third Focus programme aims to provide a refreshing range of films that have one thing in common; a commitment to entertaining audiences without insulting their intelligence. 
 Colonial power, religious belief, separation, racist oppression, migration, miscegenation, black politics, music, adventure, desire, passion, pleasure are the themes touched upon by some of the films being screened. 
 Set to kick off the programme at MAC on Saturday 29 September is the British premiere of MASALA an irreverent tragi-comedy set amongst Toronto's middle-class Asian community starring Saeed Jaffrey. 
 The Odeon New Street will be showing BOY'Z N THE HOOD a gritty look at the urban life of young African-Americans, and the Cannes award winning feature YOUNG SOUL REBELS which looks at sexuality, race and music in late seventies Britain. 
 The world premiere of WHO NEEDS A HEART, the new feature from award winning Black Audio Film Collective, on the life and times of Michael X is a festival must. 
 Desire, Christianity and colonial power on the Carribean island of Curacao are some of the themes of the stunning AVA &amp; GABRIEL. 
 KASBA is a new film by Kumar Shahani, who will be here to take part in the Ghatak Tradition Forum (see opposite page). 
 AMA a magical realist adventure story is set in London, drawing successfully on African traditions. 
 Some of the documentaries screening are A PLACE OF RAGE, a portrait of two inspirational African-American women Angela Davies and June Jordan, and MYSTERIES OF JULY an elegaic investigation into the issue of deaths at the hands of the police. 
 Film crazed insomniacs will be pleased to know that Vokani Film Circuit is continuing its tradition of organising a BLACK FILM ALL NIGHTER at the Triangle. 
 Films need audiences as much as audiences need films, we look forward to seeing you.  
 Who Needs A Heart 
 Masala 
 Ava &amp; Gabriel 
 A Place of Rage 
 third FOCUS television forum 
 in association with Vokani Film Circuit 
 Some recent research undertaken at the British Film Institute for a documentary on the history of black people and television has unearthed an interesting fact. 
 The earliest television broadcasts in the late 1930's featured black performers. 
 BBC Pebble Mill studios on Friday 27 September will be hosting an in depth look at more recent black participation, behind the scenes in television. 
 This historic forum will look at the development of Black-African, Caribbean, Asian &mdash; involvement in factual television, particularly in the last ten years, the era of Channel 4 and the specialist BBC Units. 
 BLACKS ON THE BOX will look at the movement of black programmes from off-peak &bquo;access&equo; magazine slots to less restricted prime time one-off specials and documentary series. 
 The forum will draw on experience of people who have worked within the industry as commissioning editors, producers and directors over the last decade. 
 The day will divide into a morning session on &bquo;Where We Have Been?&equo;, and an afternoon session on &bquo;What's Happening Now?&equo; 
 The event aims to bring together people working in television, students, trainees and those with an interest in the industry. 
 AS SPACE WILL BE LIMITED IT IS ADVISABLE TO BOOK EARLY. 
 Some of the speakers will be: John Akomfrah, Anita Bhalla, Behroze Gandhy, Narendhra Morar, Stella Orakwue, Trevor Phillips, Colin Prescod, Salim Salam, Parminder Vir, Onye Wambu.  
 Colin Prescod 
 Anita Bhalla 
 the ritwik ghatak tradition 
 a festival highlight 
 Today with the shaking up of the post-war world order the terms migrants, refugees, borders, national identity, have become part of the cultural agenda in Europe and North America. 
 For the Third World or rather the underdeveloped world these questions have existed for the greater part of this century. 
 India in 1947 saw the &bquo;largest migration in history&equo;, for at the very moment of its independence, it was divided, its western and eastern regions became the &bquo;Muslim homeland&equo; of Pakistan. 
 Partition led to the migration of ten million people across the newly established borders. 
 During this period, it is estimated that half a million people were slaughtered in the communal violence that flooded the country. 
 This year's Third Focus is highlighting, through screenings and a discussion forum, the work of Indian film maker Ritwik Ghatak and the work of those he has inspired. 
 Ritwik Ghatak was born in 1925 in Dacca, East Bengal, the capital of present day Bangladesh. 
 He was amongst those who believed Partition was not historically destined. 
 While he was young, his family moved to Calcutta. 
 It was during the period of 1943&ndash;1945 that his political awakening took place. 
 These were the years of the anti-fascist movement, the Japanese attack on Britain's Asian empire, the British retreat and the Bengal famine during which two million people died. 
 By 1946, Ghatak had become a Marxist activist, this was the year that the communal rioting leading up to Partition began in earnest. 
 In the space of two days in mid August five thousand people were killed in Calcutta. 
 Out of a desire to protest against the &bquo;oppression and exploitation&equo; he saw around him, he began to write short stories, by the time of his death over a hundred had been published. 
 He was drawn to the work of IPTA (Indian People's Theatre Association), a cultural wing of the Communist Party of India, and worked with it as an actor &mdash; playwright &mdash; director till 1954. 
 In 1953, he was voted best actor and director for his theatre work, this was also the year in which he directed NAGARIK (THE CITIZEN), the first of the eight feature films that he completed. 
 When these films made over a twenty year period have, on rare occasions, been seen by Western audiences, critics have referred to him as neo-neo-realist or post-Brechtian film-maker. 
 These labels prove to be wholly inadequate, not to say misleading, for a film-maker who managed to bring together Indian mythological symbolism, folk and musical traditions in order to raise questions about identity, nation, race, and class in a unparalleled way. 
 He was very pragmatic about why he had been drawn to cinema &bquo;I came into films not because I wanted to make films. 
 Tomorrow, if I could find a better medium, I would throw away cinema. 
 I don't love films&hellip; 
 I have used the cinema as a weapon, as a medium to express my views&equo;. 
 FORUM 
 Madam Gopal Singh, film writer and lecturer at Delhi University will be giving the Third Focus Forum keynote speech and introducing a screening SUBARNAREKHA. 
 Award winning filmmakers Mani Kaul and Kumar Shahani, who were students of Ritwik Ghatak at the FTII (Film and Television Institute of India) in the mid-sixties, will be forum participants, as will more recent graduates of the FTII Rajan Khosa, Mandira Mitra and Anup Singh. 
 Paul Willeman, former editor of &bquo;Screen&equo; and &bquo;Framework&equo; will be Forum chair. 
 SCREENING 
 Screenings of Ritwik Ghatak's astonishing films CLOUD CAPPED STAR (MEGHE DHAKA TARA), E FLAT (KOMAL GANDHAR), SUBARNAREKHA and REASON ARGUMENT AND STORY (JUKTI TAKKO AR GAPPO) will be taking place throughout the festival. 
 The films A DAYS BREAD (USKI ROTI) and SIDDESHWARI by Mani Kaul, and MAYA DARPAN and KASBA by Kumar Shahani will be shown. 
 Rajan Khosa's BODHVRIKSHA, Mandira Mitra's AYONUA and Anup Singh's LASYA will be screened in a bill of Film &amp; Television Institute Films. 
 When I first came across Ritwik Ghatak's films about ten years ago, I was puzzled. 
 I was very impressed by them, how to approach them. 
 It was only later that I discovered Ghatak was not only a director, but also, in his own, idiosyncratic way, a teacher and theorist of cinema. 
 As I have read his writings, often in photocopies lent to me by friends, or in the book on his work published in 1982, in India, I have not only come to appreciate his films in a more informed way, but I have also realized that his outlook on film-making is one which has begun to affect my own thinking. 
 There are three reasons why I think Ghatak's work is especially valuable. 
 First, there is a mixture of the personal and the political. 
 Ghatak was a committed Marxist, who began his career working in a political theatre company. 
 But his work is always marked by elements of his own life, culminating in his final film, JUKTKI TAKKO AR GAPPO, which is virtually a self-portrait, depicting his own problems with alcoholism. 
 Ghatak wanted to combine insights from Marxism with elements from India thought, as well as the work of Jung, with which he became increasingly fascinated. 
 All his political thinking is refracted in the films through personal dramas, which bear the stamp of his preoccupation with politics as something which is about individual people, rather than issues or abstractions like the masses of the nation. 
 &bquo;Film is basically a matter of personal statement. 
 All arts are in the final analysis. 
 And film seems to be an art&equo;. 
 Secondly, Ghatak always wanted to combine the global with the local. 
 He was quite at home talking about Eisenstein or Brecht, Shakespeare or Godard, but at the same time he was completely rooted in the specificity of Bengal, its history, its literature and its culture. 
 He can move from talking about Aristophanes to talking about Indian epics without any sense of discontinuity. 
 This global vision allows him to see foreign artists through Indian eyes and vice versa. 
 He reveres Tagore as the great modern writer of Bengal, but he looks at him disrespectfully, as if he was applying a Brechtian alienation-effect on him. 
 His Tagore is not a mystic or a Romantic, but a rogue, performing monkey, a user of four-letter words. 
 When Ghatak made a film about the partition of Bengal, about which he cared deeply, he was unsparingly honest, undeflected by nationalism in his vision of his nation. 
 As he himself put it, talking about his film, SUBARNAREKHA, &bquo;Refugee? 
 Who is not a refugee&equo;? 
 Within moments, he is talking about Brecht's THREEPENNY OPERA pointing out how Brecht invented an abstract London, not in order to escape from the reality of the city, but to create a generalized framework which could be relevant to audiences in many different places. 
 So, his Bengal is also an invented framework, a device, and yet a device which, he hopes, will enable him to show more of the truth than simple realism could. 
 Finally, Ghatak tried to find a way between popular melodrama and the avant-garde. 
 He returns again to the ways in which melodrama is rooted in Indian popular culture. 
 It should not be despised, Bombay talkies, any more than Mizoguchi despised the melodrama he took from the Kabuki theatre. 
 On the contrary, it offers great possibilities. 
 Here too, Ghatak made use of Jung in his thinking about popular culture, looking for ways of using psychoanalytic concepts, &bquo;unconscious&equo; motifs and images, in order to affect the audience at a deeper, less conscious level than most committed film. 
 At the same time, Ghatak believed in experiment, in the need for an &bquo;experimental cinema&equo;. 
 He was interested in the work of Norman MacLaren, the Surrealists, Godard. 
 He insisted that there were good reasons for such experimentation, from which film-makers anywhere could benefit. 
 At the same time, he remained committed to a popular cinema, a cinema of the slums and the villages. 
 Ghatak did not see any contradiction between these two approaches. 
 On the contrary, he seemed to think that popular art and literature were themselves full of devices which experimentalists were trying to recapture, as if &bquo;intellectual montage&equo; or &bquo;dream time&equo; were implicit in folk fables, riddles and jokes. 
 Experimentalism was both a rediscovery and a quest for new. 
 &bquo;Experimenters always have to be alert&equo;. 
 It was because he was so alert, so curious about the world, about books and films, that Ghatak could never take the easy way out. 
 It is quite wrong to look at him as a marginal or failed artist, a tragic case, like his country of Bengal, even though he himself sometimes seemed to see things this way. 
 &bquo;It is the nuances I am after, the elusive, fleeting nuances&equo;. 
 Ghatak saw himself as groping, experimenting with each film, trying to find a new form to say something new, now picturesque, now documentary, now epic, now experimental, now melodrama. 
 Each film has something new to tell us, something from which we too can learn.  
 Ritwik Ghatak 
 PETER WOLLEN, FILM TEACHER AND FILM-MAKER GIVES HIS VIEW OF THE SIGNIFICANCE OF RITWIK GHATAK IN THE ARTICLE BELOW. 
 IT IS REPRODUCED COURTESY OF &bquo;SIGHT &amp; SOUND&equo; MAGAZINE. 
 CLOUD CAPPED STAR (Meghe Dhaka Tara) 
 E FLAT (Komal Gandhar) 
 REASON ARGUMENT AND STORY (Jukti Takko Ar Gappo) 
 SCREENING at a glance 
 festival calendar 
 film 
 events 
 film and television 
 booking information 
 TICKETS 
 FESTIVAL EVENTS 
 FESTIVAL DELEGATE 
 &pound;75.00 incl VAT Gives free admittance to all films (Apart from Opening, Mid-Festival and Closing films at the Odeon New Street) and all events (apart from Festival Awards Dinner Evening). 
 You will also be invited to Festival receptions as a Festival guest. 
 Please note that delegates must book tickets for screenings and events by 5pm on the day. 
 Delegates cannot be guaranteed tickets after 5pm. 
 Apply to MAC to become a festival delegate. 
 HOW TO BUY YOUR TICKETS FOR FILMS AND EVENTS 
 Tickets for all Festival films and events requiring tickets are available from MAC, The Ticket Shop, The Library Ticket Shop, The Town Hall, Alexandra Theatre, Hippodrome Theatre, ICC and the Repertory Theatre. 
 Box Office for the Festival opens on September 2. 
 Cheques should be made payable to MAC not the Festival. 
 Visa and Access are accepted for credit card bookings. 
 ADVANCES AND RESERVATIONS 
 Advance bookings for all events and films available through the booking outlets listed above. 
 Please note that apart from MAC, venues will not be taking advance bookings for their own events and screenings. 
 Postal bookings are accepted up to 48 hours before the screening or event. 
 Telephone bookings accepted up to 5pm on day of screening or event. 
 Tickets booked by telephone or by post can be collected up to 5pm on the day of screening at MAC. 
 If uncollected, they will be held on the door at the venue. 
 VENUES 
 FESTIVAL INFORMATION 
 The Festival Information Centre this year is situated in Paradise Forum. 
 Visit us for all information and to buy your Official Festival Programme. 
 There will be FESTIVAL INFORMATION POINTS AT MAC AND THE TRIANGLE.  
 VENUE INFORMATION 
 MAC offers a varied programme of events (theatre, cinema, dance and music performances, literary events, festivals and puppet shows) and courses (art, crafts, music, dance and drama) for adults and children. 
 The centre is located in beautiful parkland and has a bar, cafe and free parking. 
 For people with disabilities recent improvements have made the Theatre, Cinema reception, tickets office, cafe and bar fully accessible by wheelchair. 
 There is limited access to the rest of the Centre's facilities. 
 MAC also offers induction loops in the Cinema and a Minicom service. 
 For further information and advice please contact the Ticket Office. 
 TRIANGLE CINEMA is an arthouse venue situated close to the city centre at Aston University. 
 It has coffee bar facilities. 
 The Cinema has limited wheelchair access, and people with disabilities should contact the House Manager in advance. 
 An accompanying person can be given a complimentary ticket for the screenings. 
 ODEON NEW STREET has eight screens, most with Dolby sound. 
 Other facilities include air conditioned foyer, a licensed bar, shop and fast food servery. 
 They also have a Concert Ticket agency. 
 Please contact the Odeon management for details of access for people with disabilities.  
 OFFICIAL FILM AND TELEVISION FESTIVAL CATALOGUES ON SALE HERE PLUS ALL THE FESTIVAL FACTS 
 festival information centre paradise forum open: 10am&ndash;5pm. 
 television weekend conference 27&ndash;28 september 1991 
 the spoils of sport: 
 television &amp; sport in the 1990s 
 WHAT IS SPORT WORTH? 
 ADRIAN METCALFE &bquo;IN CONVERSATION&equo; WITH BILL SINRICH 
 Are the values of sport commercial or ethical? 
 Will television dictate the future of sport or will the public demand deeper and wider coverage? 
 Can sport retain an ethical base or will its involvement with television mean that it becomes completely dominated and determined by financial considerations? 
 Adrian Metcalfe and Bill Sinrich are &bquo;In Conversation&equo;. 
 Dorothy Hobson &mdash; Chair: 
 ADRIAN METCALFE Director of Programmes Tyne Tees Television 
 Adrian Metcalfe began his career in journalism as a news reporter with the Sunday Express. 
 In 1964, he joined ITV as a reporter and commentator for World of Sport. 
 He was producer and commentator for LWT's &bquo;Sports Arena&equo; before taking up in 1972, the post of Vice President Europe of US company Marvin Sugarman Productions. 
 In 1976, he established his own Independent Production Company, AMO (Adrian Metcalfe Organisation). 
 He became Channel 4's first Commissioning Editor for Sport when the channel opened in November 1982 and went on to become Senior Commissioning Editor with responsibility for a wide range of programmes including documentaries and children's. 
 In January 1989, he left Channel 4 to become Director of Programmes at Eurosport with Sky Television. 
 Born in Bradford 49 years ago, he was educated at Leeds and Magdelen College, Oxford, where he won an Athletics Blue. 
 In 1964, he won a silver medal in the 400 metres relay at the Tokyo Olympics. 
 BILL SINRICH Senior European Vice-President, Production and Development-Trans World International (UK) Inc-(TWI). 
 Born in New York City, 21/4/56. 
 A journalist with NBC News for five years since 1982, Bill joined TWI in February 1987. 
 Executive Producer of TWI's much heralded live coverage of England's Cricket Tour of the West Indies in 1990, for Sky/BBC. 
 Pioneered Channel 4's coverage of Women's Football and developed and produced the outdoor adventure series &bquo;Conquer the Arctic&equo; for Channel 4, &bquo;Chris Evert's Wimbledon Farewell&equo; for the BBC and the two best selling Nick Faldo Golf Instructional videos. 
 Bill was also responsible for winning TWI the BSB &bquo;Sports Channel&equo; production contract, overseeing the development of the production team and Sports Channel output. 
 television weekend conference 
 This year, the Television Conference at the Birmingham International Film and Television Festival takes for its theme SPORT ON TELEVISION. 
 As terrestrial and satellite companies compete for sport and movies, the two major commodities which could ensure the future success of television, the conference will consider how the contest for the SPOILS OF SPORT will progress over the next decade. 
 How far will terrestrial broadcasters compete for the rights to SPORTS coverage? 
 How will BBC and ITV survive and how much will they need to bid against each other to acquire the major sports which audiences will wish to see? 
 Will the vast sums of money which are being asked for by the Governing Bodies of Sport mean that they will price themselves out of the market or will television continue to pay as they compete for audiences? 
 Sports and sporting figures are managed and packaged for television production and there is a fear amongst purists and some sporting fans that the spirit of sport will be lost in its relationship with television. 
 Can sport retain its ethics and its involvement with huge financial bids? 
 What will be the role of sponsorship in the future of Sport on Television? 
 Will new sports find it increasingly difficult to find a place on television and will television ever again be able to nurture the growth of new sport? 
 One session will look at the role of cities as major providers of huge new leisure facilities and sporting venues. 
 This could mean that they will become major forces driving forward the concept of sport, leisure, cultural and artistic movements during the 1990's. 
 For this to happen, cities will need to discuss and plan their events with television companies in order to ensure maximum mutual benefit. 
 How big are the audiences for sport on television? 
 The Women in Film group will produce a session with particular emphasis on Women as Audience and the Representation of Women in Sport. 
 Sport and the coverage of sport on television is a major part of the everyday life of the television audience. 
 Sport as part of &bquo;The News&equo; means that it has national significance and is part of the cultural heritage of the audience. 
 One issue which will be debated is the &bquo;ownership&equo; of sports coverage and the access to clips for News Programmes. 
 For many viewers, Television and Sport are inseparable. 
 How long could each survive without the other? 
 How long can they survive together?  
 Cities and media forum: 
 city television and channel 5 
 The Forum is sponsored by the City of Birmingham's Economic Development Committee with additional support from Central Independent Television and Telescope Video Graphics. 
 Over the last six years, the Cities and Media Forum has become an established part of the Festival and has played a substantial role in the debates about developing the media economies of regional cities in the UK. 
 In recent years, the Forum has also introduced to the British Film and Television Industry the concept of the Film Commission. 
 The 1990 Forum (Film and Commissions and the UK film industry) greatly assisted the formation of the national body, the UK Film Commission, which is headed by Sydney Samuelson. 
 The Cities and Media Forum is attended regularly by the growing band of media development agencies. 
 Many of these have adopted as a major part of their strategy over the last two years campaigns to attract bidders for Channel 5 franchises to locate in their cities. 
 With the franchise bids for Channel 3 close to completion and the date set for the advertising of Channel 5 franchises it is timely to look again at the possibilities in the new channel, and in particular at the potential for &bquo;city television&equo;. 
 The arguments for the development of the media industries of regional cities has always had both economic and cultural aspects. 
 The 1991 Forum will look at Channel 5 both as an opportunity to provide employment and economic growth outside of London and the South East and as a means of making the non-metropolitan voice heard. 
 Despite the minimalist parameters for the new channel set out in the Broadcasting Act, in profound contrast to the remit of Channel Four when it began a decade ago, we want to make an issue of the new Channel. 
 We see the allocation of the scarce resource of our last terrestrial channel as a matter worth serious discussion, and seek in it an answer to the perceived shortcomings of the existing Channels. 
 We will look at the new Channel in relation to existing television whether broadcast, satellite or cable. 
 What new programming do we want to see? 
 Will the new channel be able to provide it within its economic constraints? 
 Will its strength be a new kind of local programming with its 31 transmitters and the possibility of &bquo;city station&equo; opt outs? 
 Is this possibility genuinely different from the existing regional models? 
 Will broadcasting survive the new franchise arrangements? 
 Will it be cable that provides truly local television? 
 Are Channel 5 and Cable in opposition or will they work together occupying new spaces in a completely new industry map? 
 What sort of programmes do we want to see in the nineties and beyond? 
 What sort of programmes will we see? 
 To answer these and other questions, we have assembled franchise bidders for the new channel, members of the ITC, programme makers, analysts, consultants, representatives of media development agencies, cable operators, and local television activists. 
 Let's talk about the Channel that we want and the television we would like to see. 
 Topics to be discussed include: Channel 5 campaigns, programme content, cable media maps of the future.  
 Cities and Media Forum 1990 
 The  Guardian screen and television writing talks 
 The Festival's series of Writers Talks is in 1991 presented with the support of The Guardian. 
 LYNDA LA PLANTE &mdash; WEDNESDAY SEPTEMBER 25, 7PM AT THE MIDLANDS ARTS CENTRE &mdash; IS IN CONVERSATION WITH BETH PORTER. 
 With a career as an actress already established it was the success of Lynda La Plante's 12 part series for Euston Films, WIDOWS, (1982), which enabled her to concentrate full time on writing. 
 Nominated for two BAFTA Awards, WIDOWS was a critical and popular success turning assumptions about professional crime upside down from a woman's point of view (the widows). 
 Her novel writing (THE LEGACY and BELLA MAFIA) has also been acclaimed. 
 The success in 1991 of PRIME SUSPECT (for Granada, and starring Helen Mirren) again brought Lynda La Plante's writing talent on to the screens of 17 million viewers. 
 A police thriller with a difference. 
 Helen Mirren plays the role of Detective Chief Inspector Jane Tennison who for years has been the victim of sexual discrimination in the police force. 
 Heading a homicide enquiry is a prize which has always eluded her, until against all the odds she is appointed to head a case. 
 &bquo;I gave her a gruesome murder to deal with&hellip; homicide is new territory for women &mdash; the need for capture and revenge is largely masculine.&equo; 
 (Lynda La Plante). 
 In conversation with Lynda La Plante is Beth Porter (Script Executive, BBC Television Drama Series).  
 Lynda La Plante 
 One of the originators of the Z CARS series, the founder of 7:84 theatre company and writer of THE CHEVIOT, THE STAG AND THE BLACK BLACK OIL, THE BOFORS GUN, BILLION DOLLAR BRAIN and more recently, BLOOD RED ROSES, John McGrath has written for the stage, television and film. 
 His three plays about Scotland (THERE IS A HAPPY LAND, BORDER WARFARE, JOHN BROWN'S BODY) were produced for Channel 4 as part of a 9 hour trilogy on the popular history of Scotland. 
 He also adapted Beryl Bainbridge's THE DRESSMAKER for the cinema. 
 His most recent film work was the script for ROBIN HOOD (starring Patrick Bergin) which Working Title produced for Twentieth Century Fox. 
 (ROBIN HOOD is showing at the Triangle Cinema on Wednesday September 25). 
 John McGrath is in conversation with Mary Cutler (THE ARCHERS' scriptwriter and screen writer for Zone Productions).  
 JOHN MCGRATH &mdash; THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 26 7PM AT THE MIDLANDS ARTS CENTRE &mdash; IS IN CONVERSATION WITH MARY CUTLER 
 After an academic career Anthony Minghella has subsequently written for the stage, television, radio and film. 
 His work with Jim Henson has led to award winning series, THE STORYTELLER and LIVING WITH DINOSAURS, and his radio plays (HANG UP and CIGARETTES AND CHOCOLATE) have been equally acclaimed. 
 For television he has regularly contributed to Central's multi-award winning series INSPECTOR MORSE. 
 His first film, TRULY, MADLY, DEEPLY, which he wrote and directed for BBC Films, is currently on release. 
 A British GHOST starring Juliet Stevenson and Alan Rickman, TRULY, MADLY, DEEPLY is screened in the Festival at the Midlands Arts Centre on September 30 at 9pm. 
 Anthony Minghella is in conversation with David Edgar (playwright, dramatist and essayist).  
 ANTHONY MINGHELLA &mdash; MONDAY SEPTEMBER 30, 7PM AT THE MIDLANDS ARTS CENTRE &mdash; IS IN CONVERSATION WITH DAVID EDGAR 
 John McGrath 
 American born Howard Schuman is one of the most original and idiosyncratic script writers working in British television. 
 Brooklyn born, he gave up academia in the 70's to work in theatre and write plays. 
 He has written for Thames, LWT, ATV, Granada, BBC, Euston and Working Title. 
 His innovative hit of the 70's ROCK FOLLIES is unrivalled as a series about the pop music industry. 
 More recently, he adapted David Lodge's SMALL WORLD for Granada and UPLINE for Zenith. 
 His five part serial, SELLING HITLER, Euston films starring Jonathan Pryce and Alexei Sayle was one of this year's television drama highlights. 
 SELLING HITLER hilariously documented the story of the publishing fraud of the century in &bquo;the Hitler Diaries&equo;. 
 Howard Schuman has adapted for Working Title Armisted Maupin's TALES FROM THE CITY (1991) and written for Independents Birmingham, FUN AND DRAMA; LIFE AND DREAMS. 
 Howard Schuman is in conversation with Michael Eaton (writer of FELLOW TRAVELLER, SHOOT TO KILL and FLIGHT TERMINAL).  
 HOWARD SCHUMAN &mdash; WEDNESDAY OCTOBER 2, 7PM AT THE MIDLANDS ARTS CENTRE &mdash; IS IN CONVERSATION WITH MICHAEL EATON 
 black women writers workshop 
 The Festival has always been a popular meeting place for people interested in all areas of film and television, and this year we are pleased to host a one day workshop for BLACK WOMEN WRITERS. 
 This has been initiated by BBC Television, Drama Group and the Writers Guild and is coordinated by Women In Film. 
 The intention is to encourage new writing talent with a diverse and exciting mix of perspectives. 
 During the day the successful applicants will have their work analysed by industry professionals. 
 They will also view and discuss the recently completed work of a new writer. 
 The session will close with an opportunity to meet informally with drama commissioners. 
 Scripts discussed will be original screenplays or adaptations of the writers' own work. 
 Further details are available from:  
 scripting a feature film 
 the problems of writing a script from the writer's point of view. 
 A workshop with Hugh Stoddart. 
 A Birmingham Film and Video Workshop event in conjunction with the Festival. 
 MAC Sat 5 Oct. 
 &bquo;I don't see television as an institution, nor as a continuum of programming into which my work must be fitted. 
 I think of it more as a novelist might think of a bookshop. 
 All my work, whether original or adapted, has been written more for personal reasons than to fit any perceived format or genre. 
 It can be argued that its success with critics and failure &bquo;at the box office&equo; both stem from that fact. 
 With REMEMBRANCE I wanted to avoid the central figure, the hero. 
 Each of several characters is followed through twenty-four hours and their lives touch only at certain points in the narrative. 
 Is this flying in the face of what makes good cinema?&equo;  
 Hugh Stoddart 
 REMEMBRANCE was one of the first Film on Four projects. 
 Hugh Stoddart says of it now: &bquo;I thought of it as a film set in peacetime about the people who are the cannon fodder in wartime&equo;. 
 Its opening during the Falklands War was an extraordinary coincidence. 
 It was given only six months in the cinema and then screened in the third week of Channel Four transmission in 1982. 
 A critical examination of REMEMBRANCE will form the basis of the workshop. 
 Hugh Stoddart has also written scripts for BEGGING THE RING, THE TRESPASSER, TO THE LIGHTHOUSE, HARD TRAVELLING and WE THINK THE WORLD OF YOU. 
 REMEMBRANCE will be screened for the public in the MAC Theatre Friday 4 Oct 9pm. 
 For further details of the workshop contact:  
 novel into screen &mdash; play: adapting nice work for television 
 BBC Pebble Mill Monday 23 September 7.00pm David Lodge's novels include CHANGING PLACES (1975), SMALL WORLD, shortlisted for the Booker Prize in 1984 and NICE WORK, Sunday Express Book of the Year in 1988, and also shortlisted for the Booker Prize. 
 His new novel, PARADISE NEWS, will be published on 30 September, a week after his talk. 
 A SOUTH BANK SHOW about him and his work will be broadcast by LWT at the same time. 
 SMALL WORLD was adapted by Howard Schuman as a television serial, produced by Granada TV, in 1988. 
 David Lodge himself adapted NICE WORK as a four part serial for the BBC, broadcast in the autumn of 1989. 
 It won the Royal Television Society's award for the Best Drama Serial of the year, and a Silver Nymph for the screenplay at the International Television Festival in Monte Carlo in 1990. 
 He wrote and presented a TV documentary about an academic conference, BIG WORDS-SMALL WORLDS, broadcast on Channel 4 in November 1987. 
 His first stage play, THE WRITING GAME, was premiered at the Birmingham Repertory Theatre in 1990. 
 A novelist adapting his or her work for the screen must also adapt to the different status of the writer in the production process. 
 David Lodge illustrates this fact from his own experience of adapting his novel NICE WORK, as a drama serial for BBC2. 
 A ROYAL TELEVISION SOCIETY event in association with the Festival. 
 In association with The Guardian, the 1991 Festival welcomes to Birmingham international and UK members of the Film Critics Association known as FIPRESCI, who have chosen the Birmingham Festival as the venue for their annual symposium. 
 It is appropriate that their 1991 conference takes place in the UK as the president elect of the association is Derek Malcolm, film critic of The Guardian. 
 FIPRESCI is a world-wide critics' organisation which includes most of the leading and distinguished writers on film among its members. 
 This will be FIPRESCI's first visit to Birmingham. 
 The two day forum will consider, amongst other issues, the current role of the film critic. 
 Given the changes in the film industry world wide, do critics have an influence in determining box office, taste and value? 
 Do their reviews have too much sway? 
 Is their responsibility to art cinema or are they mortgaged to the Hollywood estate? 
 Cultural gate keepers or disseminators of information? 
 Have new television channels, satellite cable etc. made the film critic redundant and fit for an academic existence only? 
 The relationship between film makers and critics; the perils of independent film-making; a foreign view of British films etc. 
 The International Association of Film Critics meets at MAC on September 26 and 27. 
 For more information of the symposium and of FIPRESCI please contact the Festival office.  
 the international association of film critics' symposium (FIPRESCI) 
 Howard Schuman and Alan Bennett on the set of Selling Hitler 
 Anthony Minghella 
 Truly, Madly, Deeply 
 David Lodge 
 location birmingham 
 EVENTS at a glance 
 As a location for drama production, the City of Birmingham and the region has an unrivalled tradition for both the popularity of the series produced, and originality of the subject matter portrayed, for example EMPIRE ROAD, GANGSTERS, SECOND CITY FIRST, ANGELS (all BBC), CROSSROADS, MUCK AND BRASS, BOON, SOLDIER, SOLDIER, (Central Television). 
 The city's two television centres have provided popular and award winning dramas for the network schedules and this success story continues in exemplary fashion under the direction of Ted Childs (Central Films) and Barry Hanson (BBC Drama, Pebble Mill). 
 The Festival series of four drama presentations, LOCATION BIRMINGHAM, is an opportunity for the general public to discuss with the producers, directors, writers and performers (if available) their series: the origins of the idea for the series, the production background, the writers' viewpoint, audience reaction, future plans etc. 
 FAMILY PRIDE &mdash; the UK's first Asian soap opera began its initial series in June 1991 with transmission on both Central Television and Channel 4. 
 The creation of Zia Mohyeddin, who handles executive production and a major role in the series, FAMILY PRIDE is filmed on location on the streets of Birmingham. 
 The series follows the lives of rich and successful families &mdash; in this instance, and surprisingly for television, the families are Asian who run an import/export empire. 
 At the heart of the series is BB who has built the business empire from humble beginnings, and who is played by Zia Mohyeddin, whose screen appearances include JEWEL IN THE CROWN, MOUNTBATTEN, ASSAM GARDEN etc. 
 BB's lifestyle and that of the other members of the family signals that they represent powerful and successful members of the community, a role-breaking change from the traditional depiction of Asians as exotica and outsiders in other television soaps. 
 In the middle of the series' first run this presentation will provide an opportunity to consider how successful FAMILY PRIDE has been in launching onto the region's and the nation's screens the UK's first Asian soap. 
 Tony Deep (associate producer, FAMILY PRIDE) and members of both the production team and the cast will be present to discuss the series. 
 Central Television's first series of CHANCER (1990) was an irresistible item on the television schedule for many millions of viewers. 
 A very strong leading &bquo;rogue&equo; character played with great guile by Clive Owen emerged out of a solid plot supported by the matchless acting skills of Leslie Phillips. 
 The face pace of CHANCER was another leading ingredient moving the story along briskly in the best of popular drama traditions. 
 Having saved the sports car company and turned himself in at the end of series one, Clive Owen led off the second series in 1991 completing the last days of a prison sentence and abandoning the city slicker lifestyle for a battle to save a bankrupt stately home. 
 The producer, Sarah D Wilson comments&hellip; &bquo;the public and press reaction was so strong that we developed another seven programmes to conclude the story. 
 We had recently finished with the Douglas car company but wanted to keep the series topical and so developed a new setting in which our hero uses his amoral cunning to preserve part of Britain's disappearing heritage&equo;. 
 A success both in front of the box and on the critics' pages CHANCER created a vogue out of a rogue &mdash; the identity of Stephen Crane (Clive Owen's role) catching the attention of the country and reflecting the social changes in the early 90's as the enterprise culture began to take a tumble. 
 Leading the presentation of CHANCER will be Ted Childs (Executive Producer, Head of Central Films), Sarah D Wilson (Producer), Simon Burke (writer), Alan Grant (director). 
 At the time of printing it is not possible to confirm Clive Owen and Leslie Phillips will be present. 
 Please check with the Festival office for details. 
 Dorothy Hobson, Director of Birmingham Media Development Agency, will chair the discussion. 
 (Clive Owen also features in the film, CLOSE MY EYES, directed by Stephen Poliakoff, which is screened on October 2 at 9pm at MAC). 
 The BBC drama series, KINSEY, starring Leigh Lawson is featured in the section on the Media Business Seminars. 
 KINSEY centred on a Birmingham solicitor and assumed cult-viewing status in its first run this year. 
 SPECIALS is a new police drama series for BBC1 produced at BBC Pebble Mill. 
 The first transmission is on October 2, 1991. 
 The discussion of SPECIALS in the Festival on October 4 will be an immediate opportunity for the production team, the police force. 
 The discussion will take place actually on the set of SPECIALS in the BBC studio. 
 SPECIALS focuses on the lives of five ordinary men and women who are part-time officers in the Special Constabulary (the fictitious Division &bquo;S&equo; in West Midlands). 
 As part-time bobbies they juggle homes, careers and their &bquo;special&equo; beat which mixes crime fighting and community policing. 
 &bquo;SPECIALS is not another helping of car chases, sieges and shoot-outs. 
 It is a realistic human drama focusing on the problems faced by these very &bquo;special&equo; police officers&equo;. 
 Brian Degas and Harry Robertson who devised, wrote and produced SPECIALS will discuss their new series with a senior police officer of national standing, and with members of the cast. 
 Michael Eator, Royal Television Award-Winner for SHOOT TO KILL, will chair the discussion.  
 Family Pride 
 Specials 
 Chancer 
 raymond williams memorial lecture 
 alan fountain speaking on television and emancipation 
 Raymond Williams (1921&ndash;1988) described himself as &bquo;Welsh European&equo;, novelist (BORDER COUNTRY, SECOND GENERATION, THE VOLUNTEERS) and dramatist; founder of the New Left and later active in the Socialist Society; a lifelong commentator on culture, media, the arts and contemporary affairs (eg. THE LONG REVOLUTION, CULTURE AND SOCIETY, COMMUNICATIONS, TOWARDS THE YEAR 2000). 
 The Festival's tribute to the work, teaching and writing of Raymond Williams will this year feature Alan Fountain who has been invited by the Festival and the Department of Cultural Studies at the University of Birmingham to give a special talk in his memory. 
 In previous years the lecture has been given by John McGrath (1988), Simon Frith (1989) and Judith Williamson (1990). 
 The theme of the talk will be: TELEVISION AND EMANCIPATION. 
 Alan Fountain is a Senior Commissioning Editor at Channel 4, where he is responsible for Independent Film and Video. 
 Alan Fountain was deeply involved in independent film culture throughout the 1970's, at East Midlands Art, on the BFI Production Board and as a writer and director. 
 From Channel 4's inception, he has encouraged talents that never previously found a place within the mainstream television, in particular through the workshop movement, but also on an international scale through regular features and documentaries from the Third World. 
 In his position as Commissioning Editor Alan has introduced to Channel 4's schedule THE ELEVENTH HOUR, PEOPLE TO PEOPLE, CINEMA FROM THREE CONTINENTS, THE MEDIA SHOW, OUT ON TUESDAY and TELEVISION WITH A DIFFERENCE. 
 On October 5 1991, &bquo;SOUTH&equo;, a new series on Channel 4 begins, originating from Channel 4's work with film and programme makers in the Southern hemisphere over the last eight years. 
 Alan Fountain's lecture will in part draw on the philosophy behind this new series. 
 eureka audio visual: 
 Eureka Audiovisual is a Brussels-based organisation representing 27 member countries in Greater Europe. 
 The impetus to create Eureka Audiovisual was the recognition that television and cinema in Europe were dominated by non-European programmes. 
 This imbalance has led to Eureka Audiovisual establishing the following priorities for its work; the exchange and broadcasting of European works; training, to encourage competition among European companies; to assist countries with small production bases and minority languages; to promote new technologies; to create more networking opportunities for the industries of cinema and television. 
 As a flexible voluntary programme Eureka Audiovisual aims to give new impetus to the European market by promoting the establishment of networks of partners based on concrete projects, from the creation to the distribution of audiovisual and cinematographic works. 
 Karl-Gunnar Lidstrom (Brussels) will introduce the work of Eureka Audiovisual at a special presentation on Wednesday, September 25, 7pm at the Grand Hotel, Colmore Row. 
 (by special invitation only).  
 A presentation and introduction to the work of Eureka Audiovisual 
 opening shots: a forum for new directors 
 The Opening Shots Forum for New Directors is sponsored in 1991 by BAFTA/SHELL, the UK joint venture to promote British Film and Television. 
 The 1991 Opening Shots Forum considers the opportunities for new directors in a period of great change for the film and television industries, but also in a climate of fast dwindling resources. 
 The Forum will focus on four main topics &mdash; A VIEW FROM THE BROADCASTERS (reflecting on the range of schemes now available in the regions for new directors, for example, BBC Bristol's 10x10; TVS/Southern Arts &mdash; Take One; &mdash; Shoot First etc); NEW FICTIONS, NEW WRITERS &mdash; where are the opportunities for new dramas and new ways of telling tales?; 
 NEW AESTHETICS FOR NEW DIRECTORS &mdash; finding and funding new film and television directors which also points the way to the styles, subjects and emotions of the British film and television culture of the future, &mdash; LOW AND BEHOLD! 
 LIMITED BUDGETS; UNLIMITED RESOURCES? how will the new wave of regional film commissions and media development agencies (in Edinburgh, Liverpool, Newcastle, Birmingham etc.) be able to assist new directors, producers and writers, who restrained by limited budgets will want access to facilities, assistance on locations, regional support etc. 
 Each session will be led by a panel of participants representing the UK's film and television industries. 
 The Festival hosts the regional launch of the British Film Institute's 1991 New Directors programme (September 21, 6.30pm, MAC Cinema). 
 Now in its 4th year of production the BFI New Directors scheme is firmly established as an important way of locating new film and television makers.   
 media business seminars 1991 
 Wragge &amp; Co 
 A success in the 1990 Festival was the series of Media Business Seminars which were sponsored by Wragge &amp; Co solicitors. 
 The series continues in 1991 offering a Birmingham perspective on current media issues. 
 These lunchtime seminars in the heart of the Birmingham business quarter are designed for the growing network of media enterprises in the city. 
 Each seminar is led by guest speakers with a specialist knowledge of the topic. 
 The Media Business Seminars will take place in Wragge &amp; Co's conference room at Ingleby House, 11&ndash;14 Cannon Street (12.30pm&ndash;2pm). 
 This year's seminars have a European flavour, including an introduction to the European Commission's MEDIA programme and a presentation of the aims of the European Script Fund. 
 The music business is also the focus for one of the seminars. 
 A discussion on the portrayal of legal life in Birmingham, KINSEY completes the quartet of seminars. 
 The European Commission's MEDIA programme's main thrust is to enhance the strength of the national audio visual industries to member states by encouraging greater collaboration between them and wider distribution of their products. 
 Support is offered for script writing (European Script Fund), animation (CARTOON), independent production (EURO-AIM), independent producers (EAVE) etc. 
 All the MEDIA projects are run on the basis of offering limited seed money to be used as a means of attracting further funding. 
 This will be the first time that an introduction to the range of MEDIA initiatives will have taken place in the city. 
 Lori Keating, who was the MEDIA programme UK press consultant in 1989, and who now heads up Mediation UK, will be the seminar's main speaker. 
 The European Script Fund is the only one of the MEDIA programme initiatives to be based in the UK (in London). 
 Christian Routh, the Fund's Selection Co-ordinator, will discuss the aims and objectives of the European Script Fund. 
 As raising development finance for fiction projects is the most difficult stage of production for independent producers and writers, the European Script Fund provides seed money to European producers and writers in an attempt to redress the imbalance between indigenous production and the great amount of imported fictional material in European cinemas and television. 
 The Script Fund is committed to the notion that without encouraging indigenous European stories of interest for its own audiences, our screens will continue to be overwhelmed by imported products and our national audio-visual industries will suffer. 
 The grand total of awards made since the European Script Fund opened its doors in April 1989 has been 236 from over 2200 submissions received. 
 A total of &pound;3 million has now been allocated to European applicants. 
 Gordon Harris (of Wragge &amp; Co) leads the seminar on Music in the Film and Television Industries when the current issues for independent producers, broadcasters and music companies will be addressed as they relate to  copyright , clearances, liaison with PRS, MCPS, record companies and the musicians union. 
 Examples from recent television and film productions (eg. Young Soul Rebels) will be considered. 
 Following the 1990 pattern when the final seminar took a Birmingham focus, the 1991 series of Media Business Seminars closes with a discussion based on the BBC drama series, KINSEY (starring Leigh Lawson). 
 KINSEY was one of the successes of the year, not least for its semi-criminal claim-game milieu but also for its imaginative shooting of day and night time in the city. 
 But what did it say about legal life in Birmingham? 
 The producers and writer of KINSEY discuss the series under the chairmanship of Roger Taylor, Chief Executive, City of Birmingham.  
 Leigh Lawson as Neil Kinsey 
 Peter Ansorge 
 Tony Kirkhope 
 independent producers forum 
 &bquo;Independents and broadcasters: the challenge of the Nineties&equo;. 
 It is still not clear how much the Broadcasting Act has changed the face of television. 
 Until the franchise process is complete for both Channel 3 and 5 even a preliminary sketch is difficult. 
 Will regional programming continue under Channel 3 as it did under ITV? 
 Will Channel 5 be regionally based, and will it support a network of city stations with its 31 transmitters. 
 One thing is for certain &mdash; the role of the independent producer is secured. 
 What is not certain is what shape independent production will take and where it will be located. 
 Do regional broadcasters need regionally based independent producers and do regionally based producers need regional broadcasters? 
 This forum will look at these in three sessions: 
 THE NEEDS OF THE INDEPENDENTS 
 Local independents and independents from other regions outline what they want from broadcasters. 
 THE NEEDS OF THE BROADCASTERS 
 Local and national broadcasters outline what they want from independent producers. 
 THE LEGAL AND FINANCIAL INTERFACE 
 Legal and financial experts look at the crucial interface between broadcasters and independents including commissioning policy, pricing, contracts and rights. 
 The Forum is presented in association with KPMG Peat Marwick, and takes place on Wednesday 2 October, 11am at Peat House.  
 experimental film and video at the IKON GALLERY 
 Screenings of recent work from a variety of schemes funded by the Artists Film and Video Committee at the Arts Council. 
 They are followed by discussions with some of the film-makers. 
 Ikon Gallery Tues 24 Sept 6.30pm.  
 CENTRE focus  events 
 CENTRE FOCUS will be organising the following screenings and events in conjunction with the Festival: ARCHIVE CONFERENCE: &bquo;MAKING HISTORIES: the present and future value of film and video archives&equo;. 
 In collaboration with Birmingham Library Services.  
 premieres 
 CENTRE FOCUS at the IKON Friday 27 6.30pm until 8pm A chance to see some of the work from independent film and videomakers in the West Midlands region and meet the people involved. 
 Work shown will include: 
 CRASH VIDEO: pop videos from John Humphries and Crash Video 
 FREEDOM: A film about artistic liberty in a fascist state be Hussein Mirshani 
 &bquo;O&equo;: site specific three screen projection for a canal site by Colin Pearce 
 STUDIO 9: pop promos Video from Anne Parouty and Sebastian 
 THE WALRUS: A drama documentary by Dominic Frank Plus work from the Wolverhampton Lighthouse Media Centre Admission Free 
 CENTRE FOCUS is the West Midlands Independent Media Forum, supported by Birmingham City Council. 
 Video lives 
 A series of programmes about cultural identities by contemporary video and film-makers organised in collaboration with Birmingham Library Services. 
 IDENTITY AND MUSIC 
 Birmingham Museum Thur 26 Sept 12.30pm 
 Introduced by Pervaiz Khan. 
 The following titles will be screened: 
 UTTERANCE: The music of Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. 
 The history and origins of Qawaali music through the songs of one of its most acclaimed exponents. 
 (Director: Pervaiz Khan) 
 VOICES: A video which explores the views, concerns and experiences of young Asian people in Southall. 
 (Director: Prem Singh) 
 RAM TV: Why is so little reggae played on TV and radio? 
 (Director: Freddy Walters, Handsworth Viewpoint) 
 SILVERSHINE: Life and music of Jazz saxophonist Andy Hamilton (Sunandan and Yugesh Walia: Endboard) 
 IDENTITY AND HISTORY 
 Birmingham Museums Sat 28 Sept 2pm 
 Peter Harvey in discussion with Vokani Film Circuit. 
 The following videos will be screened: 
 BLACK SKIN, WHITE MASKS Part 2. 
 A film interpretation of the book which satirises black assimilation into white society. 
 (Director: Calvin Brown) 
 JEMIMA AND JOHNNY: The friendship of a black girl and white boy exposes British racism in the Sixties. 
 (Director: Lionel Ngakane) 
 TEN BOB IN WINTER: A comedy of manners set against the lives of West Indian immigrant workers in London in the sixties. 
 (Director: Lloyd Reckord) 
 BLUE TOO: The attitudes and aspirations of a boy growing up in modern Britain are explored using &bquo;Little Black Sambo&equo;. 
 (Director: Peter Harvey) 
 This event is in collaboration with Vokani Film Circuit. 
 IDENTITY AND WOMEN 
 Ikon Gallery Thur 3 Oct 6pm Tamara Wyss will be speaking about her own work and the other videos screened: 
 SEARCHING FOR MR MOSES: 
 The film documents a journey in search of Moses Mendelssohn, 18C philosopher and grandfather of the composer, which becomes a journey through two hundred years of German Jewish history and the film-maker's own family. 
 It is a film about the outsider in history, identity and assimilation and the price for it. 
 (Director: Tamara Wyss) 
 SISTREN IN PHOTOGRAPHY: 
 A highly acclaimed documentary by the women's film cooperative, about black women photographers in Birmingham (Director: Second Sight) 
 MEASURES OF DISTANCE: 
 An artist's feelings of separation from her family, as seen through a series of fragmentary communications between the artist and her mother. 
 (Director: Mona Hatoum) 
 This is a Centre Focus event in collaboration with Birmingham Museums and the Ikon Gallery. 
 Wide Angle screening day 
 A programme of innovative short films and videos made at Wide Angle this year. 
 MAC Hexagon Mon 23 Sept 10am until 4pm 
 arts council film and video at the festival: 
 The Arts Council presents an exciting programme of new work at this year's festival. 
 As in previous years, the Festival will be the launch for the new programmes made for the Black Arts Video Project, three of which this year come from Birmingham and West Midlands based filmmakers. 
 Three new shorts commissioned by the jointly funded Arts Council/Channel 4 &bquo;Eleventh Hour&equo; scheme, are being screened as part of the main festival programme and three other films form part of the programme at the Birmingham Museum and Arts Gallery which accompanies the festival. 
 In addition, there will be a series of screenings at the Ikon Gallery of new experimental work, followed by discussions with some of the filmmakers. 
 black arts video: 
 exhibitions IKON GALLERY 
 Saturday 21 September to Saturday 2 November 
 Since the 1960's, Adrian Piper has been an influential video maker in the United States. 
 In her performances, gallery installations and video work, she explores questions of sexual, racial and ethnic identity. 
 She has made a crucial contribution to the race and representation debate in the U.S. Through works of self-investigation and transformation Piper explores her own racial identity and forces viewers to question their own values and beliefs. 
 The work of this major artist has never been seen in any depth in Europe. 
 Given the current debates around cultural diversity and the exciting nature of work being produced by black artists in the U.K. this is an excellent moment to introduce Adrian Piper to a British audience. 
 mac THE CENTRE FOR BIRMINGHAM 
 (FOYLE GALLERY) 
 Saturday 14 September&ndash;Saturday 21 October 
 To mark the nationwide Japanese Festival, an exhibition of work by two artists of that nation. 
 Yukki Yaura's display of traditional Japanese ink drawings encompass traditional subjects such as landscapers, figure painting, flowers and birds. 
 Taja's work comprises slab built sculptural ceramics, with brightly coloured decoration, reflecting the simplicity of Japanese painting. 
 The Festival will be screening a number of Japanese films at the Triangle and MAC, see programme for details. 
 BULL RING ARCHIVES 
 (Bar and Gallery) Tues 24 Sept to Fri 18 Oct 
 Photographs of Birmingham's famous (or infamous depending on your viewpoint) market place and landmark, soon to be lost, as the Trust who owns the site plans to redevelop. 
 The Bull Ring Archive was founded in 1989 to complete a unique and compelling chronology of life in The Bull Ring. 
 The festival will be screening PARADISE CIRCUS, Heather Powell's film about the development of Birmingham's city centre from the viewpoint of the women who live and work in the city.  
 North of Vortex 
 Making of &bquo;Monsters&equo; 
 film &amp; television 
 childrens films 
 childrens morning movies 
 Three films which use the sea as their background will be screened at the Odeon Cinema New Street on Saturday mornings. 
 TREASURE ISLAND Director: Fraser Heston UK 1991 132 minutes 
 Set against the sweeping backdrop of adventure on the high seas, TREASURE ISLAND charts a boy's search for treasure in a time of danger and piracy. 
 Odeon New Street Saturday 21 September 10.00am 
 THE GOLDEN SEAL Director: Frank Zunoga US 1983 
 The story of an extraordinary friendship between a boy and a seal. 
 Odeon New Street 28 September 10.00am 
 WHEN THE WHALES CAME Director: Clive Rees UK 1989 99 minutes 
 A magical tale, which tells of man's disrespect for the natural world around him, as seen through the eyes of an elderly recluse and two young children on the Isles of Scilly at the outbreak of the First World War. 
 Odeon New Street 5 October 10.00am. 
 In Association with Puffin Books. 
 To celebrate 50 years of Puffin, the famous publisher of childrens' literature. 
 We will be screening, in conjunction with the Puffin Book Club, a series of films for schools at the Midlands Arts Centre. 
 Dates will be: Wednesday 25 September 10am Tuesday 1 October 10am Thursday 3 October 10am 
 The screenings at Midlands Art Centre will be free to schoolchildren and teachers should contact the Festival Office for Details. 
 childrens film and television: discussion event 
 This will take place at the Midlands Arts Centre at 5pm on Thursday 3 October, and the discussion will be led by Terry Staples, who programmes the childrens films for the London Film Festival, and Lewis Rudd, Controller Young Peoples' Programmes at Central Television, with other invited educationalists and childrens' programme makers. 
 This is an opportunity for anyone with an interest in film and television for young people to express their views on the current programmes and films available. 
 Lewis Rudd has had responsibility in his television career for DO NOT ADJUST YOUR SET (Thames), WORZEL GUMMIDGE (Southern Television), and at Central Television (YOUR MOTHER WOULDN'T LIKE IT. 
 A COUPLE OF CHARLIES and PRESS GANG). 
 He also founded the Junior Television Workshops in Nottingham and Birmingham. 
 Sandra Hastie, producer of PRESS GANG, will also participate in the discussion. 
 PRESS GANG (produced by Richmond Films for Central Television) was honoured with both a Royal Television Society Award and a British Academy Award in 1991. 
 PRESS GANG is Central's cult drama series based on a team of news hungry teenagers. 
 fifth and sixth form screenings 
 This programme of screenings focusses on films which explore areas of race and gender in a thought provoking way. 
 Each film will be introduced, and placed in context, and there will be discussions after the screening. 
 Teachers wishing to bring students to the screenings should contact the Festival Office on 021 766 6707 for further information. 
 Screenings are scheduled as follows:  
 films on central 
 For the whole of the festival period Central Television will be joining in and adding a new screen with a difference. 
 From Saturday 21 September to Saturday October 5th, in its late night/early morning slot, Central will be screening movies with connections to the festival. 
 For the first week the FILMS FROM THE URBAN JUNGLE series echoes the city themes of the festival, from the Cities and Media conference to the presentation of Tavernier films which celebrate the city of Lyon, Tavernier's birthplace, and Birmingham's twin town. 
 In the second week, the theme is THE SPORTING LIFE to link in with our Sport and TV conference event, taking place the mid-festival weekend. 
 films from the urban jungle 
 WEEK ONE 
 DATE: Saturday 21 September TIME: 0205 SCREENING: DESPAIR (1979) 
 Dirk Bogarde, Andrea Ferreol. 
 Bogarde plays a Russian emigre who runs a chocolate factory in Germany just as the Nazis begin to take power. 
 The film is adapted by Tom Stoppard from the novel by Nabokov. 
 Directed by Rainer Werner Fassbinder. 
 DATE: Monday 23 September TIME: 0025 SCREENING: THE VULTURE (1982) 
 George Caerhalmi Hedi Temessy Zita Perczel. 
 When a taxi driver is robbed by two wealthy women, he seeks revenge, outraged by the unjust crime and the refusal of the police to believe his story. 
 Directed by Ferenc Andras. 
 DATE: Tuesday 24 September TIME: 0035 SCREENING: TAKE THIS JOB AND SHOVE IT (1973) 
 Robert Hayes Barbara Hershey David Keith. 
 Workers at an old fashioned brewery, upset by a take-over, decide to start their own employee-owned brewery. 
 Comedy. 
 Directed by Gus Trikonis. 
 DATE: Wednesday 25 September TIME: 0015 SCREENING: BIG CITY (1937) 
 Spencer Tracy Luise Rainer. 
 Tracy is a cab driver who finds himself struggling against the power of the city's corrupt taxi bosses. 
 A.K.A. Skyscraper Wilderness. 
 Directed by Frank Borzage. 
 DATE: Thursday 26 September TIME: 2310 SCREENING: THE KREMLIN LETTER (1970) 
 Richard Boone Bib Anderson. 
 A complex espionage thriller set in Moscow and full of treachery and double dealing. 
 An all-star cast includes Orson Welles and George Sanders. 
 Directed by John Huston. 
 DATE: Friday 27 September TIME: 0105 SCREENING: HELL ON FRISCO BOY (1955) 
 Alan Ladd Edward G. Robinson. 
 The story of the exposure of organised crime and its dramatic implications in the underworld of San Francisco. 
 Directed by Frank Tuttle. 
 DATE: Saturday 28 September TIME: 0120 SCREENING: SMILE JENNY YOU'RE DEAD (1978) 
 David Janssen John Anderson. 
 This was the pilot for the Harry O detective series. 
 Janssen plays a private eye who, while investigating a murder, gets emotionally involved with the prime suspect. 
 Directed by Jerry Thorpe. 
 DATE: Sunday 29 September TIME: 0030 SCREENING: FEDORA (1978) 
 William Holden Martha Keller. 
 A film producer tries to persuade a famous actress back to the screen. 
 Based on a short story by Thomas Tryon. 
 Directed by Billy Wilder. 
 films from the sporting life 
 WEEK TWO 
 DATE: Monday 30 September TIME: 2240 SCREENING: NORTH DALLAS FORTY (1979) 
 Nick Nolte Mac Davis. 
 One of the best American Football films ever made. 
 Nolte is a declining star in a world he increasingly discovers is more about money and power than sport. 
 Directed, produced and written by Frank Yablans. 
 TIME: 0145 SCREENING: THE CROWD ROARS (1932) 
 James Cagney Guy Kibee. 
 The tough world of motor racing finds Cagney competing against his brother for glory and the girl. 
 Directed by Howard Hawks. 
 DATE: Tuesday 1 October TIME: 0035 SCREENING: ONE IN A MILLION &mdash; The Ron Le Flore Story (1978) 
 LeVar Burton Madge Sinclair. 
 The true story of a major league baseball star who went from the street corner to stardom and then to armed robbery but is saved from destruction by a one in a million chance. 
 Directed by William A. Graham. 
 DATE: Wednesday 2 October TIME: 0050 SCREENING: FOOTBALL CRAZY 
 Joan Collins Landa Buzzanca. 
 Collins is the amorous object of a football referee's fantasy which affects his professional life on the field. 
 DATE: Thursday 3 October TIME: 0010 SCREENING: AMERICAN FLYERS (1985) 
 Kevin Costner David Grant. 
 Two brothers compete in a cycling marathon but one of them is dying. 
 Directed by John Badham. 
 DATE: Friday 4 October TIME: 0205 SCREENING: RAGE ON ICE (1986) 
 Fast and furious ice hockey action combines with the human drama of the players in this Canadian/French production. 
 DATE: Saturday 5 October TIME: 0015 SCREENING: BANG THE DRUM SLOWLY (1973) 
 Robert de Niro Michael Moriarity. 
 Two professional baseball players find their lives drawn together in unusual circumstances. 
 Directed by John Hancock.  
 A&ndash;Z of film and directors 
 film festival thanks 
 Screen and Television Writing Talks at the Birmingham International Film and Television Festival Sept 20&ndash;Oct 5, 1991 
 Wednesday, 25 September, 7pm: 
 Lynda La Plante, writer of the successful and popular series Widows , and this year's major police drama with a difference, Prime Suspect , talks to BBC Television script executive, Beth Porter. 
 Thursday, 26 September, 7PM: 
 John McGrath, founder member of 7:84 theatre company and writer of Blood Red Roses , The Dress-maker  and Robin Hood , talks to Archers'  script writer and screenwriter for Zone Productions, Mary Cutler. 
 Monday, 30 September, 7pm: 
 Award winning writer Anthony Minghella who has recently finished directing his first film Truly, Madly, Deeply,  will be in conversation with writer and dramatist David Edgar. 
 Wednesday, 2 October, 7pm: 
 Writer of television classics such as Rock Follies, Video Stars,  and Upline , Howard Schuman who also penned the recently televised Selling Hitler  can be seen in conversation with writer Michael Eaton of Fellow Traveller  and Shoot To Kill  fame. 
 The Guardian in Conversation: 
 Celebrated French director Bertrand Tavernier will be in Birmingham straight off the set of his latest film for a retrospective look over his career and films with the Guardian's film critic Derek Malcolm. 
 The talk will immediately follow a screening of Tavernier's most recent box office hit These Foolish Things  at:  
 Derek Malcolm will also be acting as the President Elect of the ASSOCIATION OF INTERNATIONAL FILM CRITICS' (FIPRESCI), which the Birmingham International Film and Television Festival is delighted to welcome to the Midlands Arts Centre for its annual symposium on Thursday, 26 September and Friday, 27 September, from 10am onwards each day. 
 (Admission free)  
 My story starts in front of the main noticeboard in the School for Italian Studies about ten years ago. 
 It was the beginning of the summer term and on the noticeboard was that term's list of the morning lectures for the first-year undergraduates. 
 This noticeboard had already played a significant part in my life: nearly thirty years before then it had displayed the result of my own first degree (second-class honours); a few years later had come the perfunctory notice saying my doctoral thesis had been accepted by the college; and shortly after that an even briefer note to the effect that I had joined the teaching staff. 
 Then, for a quarter of a century, I displayed notices there myself: announcing seminars or little trips to galleries, requesting the return of books and so on. 
 At the start of every summer term for goodness knows how long, my name had appeared five times on the new lecture list. 
 The first-years, after a first term filled with the medieval period and a second with the Renaissance, were now going to learn about the Baroque. 
 The titles of my lectures had not changed since the early sixties: Bernini, Borromini, Carlo Fontana, Sculpture I and Sculpture II. 
 This undemanding life-cycle had never been disrupted and I read the new lecture list partly just out of habit and partly for the simple pleasure of seeing my name in print. 
 This time, however, there was a change. 
 The titles of  my lectures were all the same, but my name appeared beneath only four out of the five of them. 
 Under &bquo;Bernini&equo; was the name Professor Charles Howard, who was and still is the school's Director. 
 I stood amid a gaggle of laughing students in frozen silence, and read the list over and over again. 
 &bquo;Morning, Dorothy, what's up?&equo; 
 It was David Knell, one of my colleagues. 
 &bquo;I've been stabbed in the back.&equo; 
 Everyone stopped laughing and looked at me. 
 &bquo;What do you mean?&equo; 
 David stammered. 
 &bquo;What's the matter?&equo; 
 I said nothing, but turned away and walked as quickly as I could towards the stairs and down to the student canteen in the basement. 
 I desperately needed a cup of coffee. 
 I can see that I may have a little difficulty explaining this first part of my story, especially to anyone not acquainted with the often bizarre rituals of academic life. 
 Let me first explain Charles Howard. 
 He had become Director of the school at the start of that academic year. 
 His previous experience had been as assistant boss of one of the smaller London museums. 
 During the final year of office of the previous Director, Ralph Youngman, Charles had given a series of public lectures at the school on Canaletto. 
 These had gone down rather well, and as our Baroque painting specialist was leaving at the same time as Youngman, voices were raised to say here was perhaps both the lecturer and the administrator we were looking for. 
 A Youngman prot&eacute;g&eacute; could take over the old boy's lecturing responsibilities and everything would fit together rather nicely. 
 Charles, a relative unknown not long beforehand, became the natural choice for the top job. 
 Unfortunately for Charles, the Director's job turned out to be beyond his actually rather limited  administrative abilities and, unable to assert himself in that field, he busied himself in the teaching side of things. 
 Waiting in the wings, there was a young colleague of his from his museum days, Paul Spence, a sculpture man. 
 Charles wanted his prot&eacute;g&eacute; in and as I was the resident (and unpopular) Baroque sculpture specialist, I happened to be in the way. 
 During the second term of that academic year the knives were drawn. 
 Paul was invited to give a series of public lectures at the school, and word got around that I was on the verge of retirement and Paul would be happy to take my place. 
 &bquo;I hear you're thinking of retiring,&equo; David Knell informed me over coffee one morning. 
 &bquo;Who told you that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I heard it around,&equo; he said vaguely. 
 &bquo;Well it's absolute rubbish,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I am thinking of doing a little more writing now, but talk of retirement is nonsense.&equo; 
 Being told when you have just turned fifty that it's time you retired does rather hurt. 
 So did the next rumour. 
 &bquo;I hear you're planning to retire so you can concentrate on writing,&equo; Charles told me over tea one afternoon. 
 &bquo;I have no intention of retiring at all. 
 I merely told David Knell that I might write more in future.&equo; 
 Colleagues stopped talking to me, afraid no doubt that being on the wrong side of the new Director might prove contagious. 
 Paul &bquo;popped round&equo; for tea more frequently than was decent for a visiting lecturer, and he seemed to get on very well with everyone. 
 He was, and is, a distinctly affable chap, whereas I came across as cold, prickly and generally difficult. 
 Anyway, on the first day of that summer term, I remember sitting alone in the cafeteria, slowly drinking  my cup of coffee, and listening as all around me people welcomed each other back from their holidays. 
 Charles Howard had just delivered me a colossal snub. 
 Bernini was arguably the most important architect and sculptor in my period and Charles had effectively indicated that I was not competent to lecture on him. 
 At some point that day, everyone would look at that noticeboard and they would all understand the implications behind what he had done. 
 I had been humiliated in front of my public. 
 Nothing like this had ever happened to me before and I was determined to make a swift counterattack. 
 &bquo;Hello, Dr Streeter, how was your holiday?&equo; 
 It was one of my students. 
 &bquo;Fine thank you, Carla. 
 How was yours?&equo; 
 Carla seemed surprised by my sudden interest in her personal well-being. 
 &bquo;Oh, fine thank you. 
 I went to Florence to do the Uffizi.&equo; 
 I smiled a smile that was meant to signify interest in this excursion, but Carla was far too intelligent to believe it showed anything of the sort. 
 &bquo;I'll see you at two-thirty then, Dr Streeter.&equo; 
 &bquo;Will do.&equo; 
 I had gone for coffee in the student room in order to avoid my colleagues. 
 However, my presence was clearly unsettling its regular inhabitants so I decided it was time to make a move &mdash; and time to confront Charles Howard. 
 I remember how leaden-footed I felt, climbing the two flights of stairs to Charles's office. 
 I knew that, in the cold light of day, he held all the aces. 
 He was the Director: he could lecture on whomever he liked. 
 And we both knew that hardly anyone would be prepared to speak out and argue my case. 
 I remember trying to think of all the troops who would line up behind me,  and realizing that there was only Anne. 
 Dear Anne Collins, ten years younger than me, taught early Renaissance painting and was just about my only real friend there. 
 However, any protest she made was far more likely to lose her friends then gain me any. 
 Sadly, for reasons of social class, she was not particularly well regarded either. 
 I reached the door of Charles's office and knocked. 
 &bquo;Come in!&equo; he shouted from within. 
 That was his first mistake: he could not now avoid talking to me. 
 I marched in and strode over towards his desk. 
 Charles looked startled. 
 Clearly he had not been expecting a confrontation. 
 &bquo;Charles, what is the meaning of this outrage!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, er, hello Dorothy. 
 Can this wait? 
 I'm really rather busy at the moment. 
 I've got a meeting in a few minutes and I &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;No it can't wait. 
 Why have I been treated in such a cowardly and despicable manner?&equo; 
 &bquo;What on earth's the matter? 
 Sit down for a minute. 
 What's the problem?&equo; 
 I remained standing. 
 &bquo;You know perfectly well what the problem is. 
 Why have you taken the Bernini lecture away from me? 
 I want an answer, right now!&equo; 
 The directness of my attack clearly took him aback. 
 &bquo;Oh that,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It's only a first-year lecture. 
 I can think of more upsetting things in life.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm upset, as you put it, because you didn't even have the courtesy to warn me that I might not be giving a lecture that's due in eight days&equo; time. 
 That is no way to treat a senior member of staff and you know it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look, I just felt that it was time for a change, that's all. 
 And I thought there'd be less fuss if I &mdash;&equo; 
 I exploded. 
 &bquo;Less fuss! 
 Who's the house expert on Bernini? 
 What is everyone going to start thinking when they see how you've cut the ground from under my 
  feet like this? 
 What are my students going to think for goodness' sake?&equo; 
 He was hesitating, but I had now shot my bolt. 
 &bquo;Charles, I'm not going to let you get away with this. 
 I'm taking this matter to the highest authority.&equo; 
 He spotted the chink in my armour. 
 &bquo;You already have. 
 The problem is you can't accept that fact.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't you be patronizing with me. 
 I'll take it all the way to the Senate if I have to.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look, do you really think that the Senate of the University of London is going to care two hoots about a footling little first-year lecture? 
 You're making a mountain out of a molehill, Dorothy. 
 All that's happened is I decided I was going to give the Bernini lecture this year. 
 If you've got some new material on him that you want to share with us, I'm more than happy to arrange another lecture for you later in the term, but frankly, as you've apparently given the same lecture on him for the past ten years, I can hardly be accused of interfering with academic freedom, can I?&equo; 
 &bquo;Who on earth told you that?&equo; 
 (It wasn't quite true.) 
 &bquo;I can't remember now. 
 Look, I'm going to be snarled up in another meeting in a few minutes. 
 Can we discuss this tomorrow? 
 How does ten-thirty suit you?&equo; 
 I stood him up. 
 For one thing, I was genuinely upset by what had happened; for another, I knew it was pointless expecting him to change his mind. 
 I was diplomatically ill for a few days and then I returned to my normal work. 
 Already, though, an idea had settled in my mind. 
 Why not resign? 
 Even contemplating walking out over such a small matter may seem ridiculous, but within the context of that small world, the dispute was a major one. 
 Also, and I don't want to go on about this, I was a lonely person in those days and I had very little else to think about. 
 Anyway, on with my story, for soon other pressures were to be brought to bear. 
  First, there was the peer pressure from my colleagues. 
 Some of them turned out to be not as indifferent to my plight as I'd feared they all would be, and a few murmured that if I did really feel strongly about the way I had been treated, I should indeed take the matter up with the Senate. 
 This sympathy (and attention) hardened my resolve not to be put upon. 
 However, as a corollary to this, my increasingly strident expressions of discontent put considerable pressure on me to live up to my rhetoric. 
 &bquo;Will she take it all the way or won't she?&equo; became the talk of the senior common room. 
 From being a peripheral figure for most of my working life, I now had to adjust to being on centre stage. 
 Charles also found himself in a difficult position. 
 He now had to think of a decisive way of finishing what he had tentatively started or he too ran the risk of losing face. 
 His biggest problem was that because of the way things work in academic life, regardless of whether or not I changed my lectures from one year to the next, I was just about unsackable. 
 From his point of view, therefore, I had to resign. 
 Four weeks into the term, another little notice appeared on the noticeboard. 
 &bquo;Paul Spence has kindly agreed to give a few revision classes on seventeenth- and eighteenth-century architecture to final-year BA students: Tuesday&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you know what they are going to be about?&equo; 
 Carla asked me. 
 &bquo;No I don't. 
 I'm sorry, Carla, I really don't.&equo; 
 This time I decided to have my coffee in a little cafe not far from SIS. 
 I can still remember how good that coffee tasted, and how different it tasted from the common-room coffee I was used to. 
 I can still see myself sitting there, relaxed and comforted by the warm drink, and then there was that moment when I decided I would resign. 
 A mixed feeling of excitement and fear flowed through me as the idea took control. 
 Nothing much  had happened in my life since the publication of my Carlo Fontana book nearly twenty years earlier (though even that, as only three hundred copies were sold, was hardly a riot). 
 This, maybe, was my opportunity to escape from the torpor into which I had sunk. 
 At last people were going to see the real Dorothy, the real live woman behind that starchy old madam who'd sat in the corner for all those years, hiding from the world in general. 
 I look back on those emotions with wry amusement but also with a certain amount of self-respect. 
 We are, after all, allowed only one life in this world and I'm glad I'd decided not to let mine just drift away. 
 When that first cup of coffee was finished, a ball of fear nestled in the pit of my stomach. 
 I quickly ordered a second cup and the dreams returned. 
 I would work for one of the major charities, perhaps, or maybe go for a job in publishing. 
 That seemed like the most sensible idea. 
 I would write to all the publishing houses that regularly produced art books and offer my services to them. 
 All my specialist knowledge, all that accumulated wisdom of the ages, would surely come in useful to someone. 
 Also, academic life had not exactly left me well-off and it seemed like a good idea to try to earn a slightly larger salary so that I would have something to put towards my eventual retirement. 
 I now had to start thinking about things like that. 
 Anyway, more importantly, this was my last chance to escape. 
 I walked back to SIS. 
 Liz, the receptionist, peered at me over the top of her pink-rimmed spectacles. 
 &bquo;Professor Howard has been looking for you,&equo; she informed me. 
 &bquo;Oh good,&equo; I said. 
 I was starting to feel light-headed. 
 &bquo;Where is he?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;In his office,&equo; she replied, and she then returned her attention to her newspaper. 
 She picked up her pen and  rested its point on the page. 
 Liz did not want to speak to me, I noticed. 
 Liz had written me off. 
 Oh well! 
 I climbed the stairs to Charles's office. 
 There seemed to be people about, but I wasn't sure. 
 I knocked on his door. 
 &bquo;Who is it?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's learned something,&equo; I mused to myself. 
 &bquo;Dorothy,&equo; I answered. 
 &bquo;Can I come in?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just a minute.&equo; 
 There was a sound of scuffling from within. 
 &bquo;Maybe he's got a girl in there,&equo; I thought. 
 I heard someone coming towards the door. 
 I half expected some floosie to open it but no, it was Charles. 
 &bquo;Ah, Dorothy, do come in.&equo; 
 He walked back towards his desk and, dutifully, I followed him. 
 All that scuffling had been to move an armchair round to the front of the desk. 
 There was to be no eyeball-to-eyeball confrontation this time. 
 Without waiting for him to invite me to do so, I sat down. 
 The chair was comfortable but low and I found myself in the disconcerting position of having to look up at him while we spoke. 
 &bquo;What do you want to see me about, Charles?&equo; 
 This caught him off balance. 
 &bquo;What do you mean?&equo; he asked, flustered. 
 &bquo;I thought it was you who wanted to see me.&equo; 
 &bquo;At your bidding, Charles, only at your bidding.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah well, in that case, I'd better let you know that I've asked Paul Spence to do some of the revision classes for your part of the course.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know, I've already read the notice.&equo; 
 A thought suddenly struck me. 
 &bquo;Do you mean his revision classes are meant to take the place of some of mine?&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, play it how you like. 
 You're right, it would be pointless for the two of you to overlap. 
 Ask Paul and see what he wants to do.&equo;  
 &bquo;But Charles, these are my students! 
 What on earth has it got to do with him in the first place? 
 You're going behind my back again. 
 It's got so bad that I don't even know what to say.&equo; 
 Charles appeared somewhat embarrassed by his own behaviour. 
 The hidden speech was coming, I could tell. 
 He moved the pen lying on the blotter in front of him slightly to one side. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, I'm trying to clear it with university administration that Paul should join our staff. 
 I think he's got an awful lot to contribute to our period and I, personally, would very much like him here. 
 It would mean a reduced workload for you so I honestly can't see why you're so set against the idea.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well it's the first I've heard of it, frankly.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, it's been around the common room for some time now.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've been trying to ease me out, Charles. 
 That's what's been going around the common room and that's what all this adds up to.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, what are all these rumours about you wanting to retire?&equo; 
 &bquo;You tell me what they're about. 
 You started them.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's not fair.&equo; 
 I examined his face. 
 He looked extraordinarily weary. 
 Getting rid of me had proved too much for him and he was now trying to force through a muddled compromise. 
 Sadly, it was not going to work. 
 &bquo;What if the Senate doesn't agree to fund an extra member of staff?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 I think we've a pretty good case though &mdash; the Renaissance has three people. 
 Theirs is a much more popular course, admittedly, but we must have some sort of chance, somewhere along the line.&equo; 
 He gazed despairingly down at his blotter. 
 Charles was out of his depth and floundering. 
 He needed  someone to throw him a lifeline and I decided it might as well be me. 
 &bquo;You don't mean all this personally, do you, Charles?&equo; 
 He looked up, his face awash with relief. 
 &bquo;No I don't. 
 You're right, I don't. 
 I'm glad you can see that, Dorothy. 
 I'm not trying to hurt you, I promise you. 
 I&hellip;&equo; 
 He looked down again. 
 At this point, I desperately wanted to leave the room. 
 How could I ever work for this man again anyway? 
 And how would he be able to bear having me around, working for him? 
 It went quiet for a while, then we were both rescued by a knock on the door. 
 &bquo;Come in!&equo; 
 Charles shouted. 
 It was the Deputy Director. 
 &bquo;Oh, sorry to disturb you both,&equo; he said, warily, &bquo;but someone from the Senate has just rung up, Charles. 
 A Miranda somebody. 
 Could you ring her back when you've got a moment? 
 I've got the number here.&equo; 
 He started to walk towards us, then he hesitated. 
 &bquo;It's all right, I was just leaving,&equo; I said, and I stood up. 
 &bquo;Thank you, Charles. 
 I'll think about what you've just said.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, er, do, Dorothy. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 He hurriedly ushered me out of the room. 
 I was now at a bit of a loss as to what to do next, so I wandered upstairs to the room that housed the books covering my subject, just to check up on a few things. 
 However, I was wasting my time &mdash; my gaze slid across the surface of the pages like marbles on a shiny table-top. 
 Was this really the end? 
 I kept asking myself. 
 Had it all come down to this? 
 I decided that the best thing to do was to go home. 
 I returned the book to the place on the shelf where I had found it and walked quietly out of the room. 
 I had just about reached the stairs, when suddenly a white  door to my right burst open and a group of students tumbled out, shrieking with laughter. 
 When they saw me the laughter stopped. 
 I looked at them, they looked at me, and I turned and hurriedly made my way downstairs. 
 Gathering speed all the time, I rushed outside and hailed a taxi. 
 &bquo;I'm in everybody's way,&equo; I kept telling myself. 
 &bquo;It's no use. 
 I'm just in everybody's way.&equo; 
 When I arrived home, I sat down at my desk and wrote a letter. 
 Dear Charles, I have decided to resign from my post at the School for Italian Studies. 
 My intention is that I should leave at the end of the year. 
 I wish you and everyone else at the school every success in the future. 
 Yours sincerely, Dorothy Streeter 
 The news of my resignation was not announced until after the finals exams &mdash; at Charles's request. 
 When the news did become public, colleagues who had avoided speaking to me when the going got tough reappeared and said how sorry they were that I was leaving. 
 More sympathetic souls cautioned me against hasty decisions, but the ripples subsided fairly quickly. 
 Life did, after all, have to go on. 
 On the last day of that term, my final-year class all came up to my office to give me a &bquo;thank-you&equo; present. 
 It was a book of photographs of London between the wars &mdash; a slightly tactless gesture as I was only eleven when World War Two was declared, but the sentiments were, I sensed, sincere, so I was touched by their kindness. 
 &bquo;Are you going to stay in London after you've retired?&equo; 
 Carla asked me.  
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 That's a little way off yet. 
 I'm probably going into publishing when I leave here.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'm thinking of doing that!&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;I'll maybe see you on the circuit then,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I hope things go well for all of you,&equo; I added (with uncharacteristic generosity), &bquo;and thank you for the present. 
 I shall enjoy it.&equo; 
 The little ceremony was over. 
 They all bade me farewell and that was that. 
 Once they had left, I locked myself in, went back to my desk, sat down and buried my head in my hands. 
 &bquo;Don't you dare cry,&equo; I mumbled to myself. 
 &bquo;Listen to me, you stupid bitch, don't you dare cry.&equo;  
 Carla, inevitably, did get her job in publishing. 
 It was through a family connection, I think &mdash; anyway, as expected, she never had to ask me for a reference. 
 I (again inevitably) decided to leave job-hunting until after I had actually left SIS. 
 My final term there seemed rather uneventful after the previous two, and only Renaissance Anne showed any signs of concern about my impending departure. 
 In truth, I found her rather a pain on the subject and merely parried her constant questions about my job-hunting activities. 
 As usual, she was rather more in touch with reality than I was. 
 &bquo;Stay in teaching, Dorothy, it's all you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's why I want to get out of it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, but at fifty?&equo; 
 &bquo;I do wish everyone would stop writing me off just because I happen to be fifty.&equo; 
 It wasn't until the final two weeks of term that it really hit me that I was actually going to have to go. 
 I remember the shock of realizing that this was my last ever second-year class, then my last ever third-year class, and then people started asking me about my leaving party. 
 &bquo;Why don't you invite Paul Spence?&equo; 
 Anne suggested. 
 &bquo;Whatever for?&equo; 
 &bquo;So that you can leave with dignity.&equo; 
 I invited Paul Spence.  
 At the party, I was presented with a gold wristwatch in a cobalt-blue presentation case &mdash; a wonderfully absurd gesture which nearly had me in tears. 
 To my considerable surprise, nearly everyone decided to come. 
 In my mind, I had pictured Charles, Anne and myself standing in the middle of an otherwise empty common room, sherry glass in hand, desperately trying to think of something to say to each other. 
 Not so, though. 
 Almost as many people turned up for me as had for Youngman. 
 In his speech, Charles praised my &bquo;sterling contribution&equo; to the school and shortly after it Paul came up to me and made the touching suggestion that I should give some classes in the summer term &mdash; if I was still free. 
 I remember looking him straight in the eye at this point in order to try and fathom the motives behind his proposal. 
 &bquo;Anyway, Dorothy, I must dash,&equo; he said, embarrassed. 
 &bquo;It's my wife's antenatal class this afternoon and I've got to look after the other one.&equo; 
 &bquo;They have lessons in everything these days, don't they?&equo; 
 I observed. 
 He grinned. 
 &bquo;We'll always need teachers, that's for sure.&equo; 
 I smiled and held out my hand. 
 &bquo;Good luck, Paul.&equo; 
 He shook it. 
 &bquo;Thanks. 
 The same to you.&equo; 
 One of the great unanswered questions in my life is why Mrs Spence was going to antenatal classes that afternoon when, as she had already had one child, she presumably had a pretty good idea of what to expect. 
 She was a somewhat intense woman who probably rather enjoyed such gatherings, but I've often wondered if she secretly used them as a ruse to get her husband home to mind the little one while she nipped out for a breather.  
 Anyway, I digress. 
 After Paul left, the party broke up quickly, as though everyone felt that the business of the day had now been concluded. 
 I, in my role as hostess, lingered to the end and soon there was only Anne and myself left. 
 &bquo;Did you get The Times Educational Supplement  this week?&equo; she asked me. 
 &bquo;Yes, but there wasn't anything in it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I noticed a teaching job in Sheffield that didn't look too bad.&equo; 
 &bquo;I keep telling you, Anne, that's not the sort of thing I'm looking for. 
 I'm still thinking of going into publishing.&equo; 
 &bquo;But as I keep trying to tell you, publishing is not that easy to get into &mdash; especially at your sort of salary level when you've no experience.&equo; 
 &bquo;Money's not a problem.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, but nobody's going to consider you for a junior post any more.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not at all sure that I'd want one.&equo; 
 Statements like that used to worry Anne. 
 &bquo;Are you sure you're being realistic?&equo; she would say, and the conversation would then cease. 
 Her advice was of course extremely sensible. 
 Sadly, I didn't listen. 
 Immediately after leaving SIS, I took a long holiday in Italy. 
 I finished up in Rome, home to so many of the works I lectured on, and on my last night there I took a walk down to Bernini's Trevi fountain in order to throw in the coin that would ensure that somehow I would one day return. 
 All around me there were young couples, arm in arm, doing the same. 
 I watched the waters for a while. 
 &bquo;Bernini,&equo; I said at length. 
 &bquo;They used you, you know. 
 They wanted blood and they got it.&equo; 
 Usually when I'm in a crowded place like this, I feel very lonely, but not this time. 
 It did not really matter  who we were or where we had come from; the fountain united us all in a common purpose and that was enough. 
 I remember the strange feeling I had when I left the square that night, a feeling of finality. 
 Looking back, that square was my gateway to the real world &mdash; and the gate could only work one way. 
 I spent that night in a straitjacket of fear. 
 In fact, such was my dread of returning home, I nearly managed to miss my plane, but somehow the clockwork motor inside me brought me back in one piece. 
 On the doormat, there were a few late Christmas cards plus the inevitable letter from the bank, but no offers of job interviews. 
 As I had never actually made a cold application for a job before, I didn't really know what to make of this. 
 I had also never before been without a pattern to the future, and I was starting to realize that it might not all be quite so easy as I had imagined. 
 Months passed. 
 A detailed description of that period would be impossible, as nothing of any substance happened. 
 I applied for the occasional post that I thought might be interesting, but never heard anything back. 
 Unemployment had then just begun its big rise but there were still jobs going &mdash; I was just being silly about which ones to apply for. 
 My resolve not to go back into education hardened, if anything, rather than softened, as I became more and more determined that the sacrifice I had made was not going to be in vain. 
 Then, inexplicably, I had been out of work for over a year and my few friends were drifting away. 
 And, somehow, my savings, carefully built up over the years, were starting to run dry. 
 Falling out with Anne finally spurred me into activity. 
 She also turned out to be the last close friend I had for an awfully long time. 
 She came round for dinner one evening. 
 I had prepared an unimaginative tunafish salad for the two of us  in order to show off my new personal austerity programme. 
 While we were eating, Anne started on a familiar topic. 
 &bquo;You're still applying for the wrong jobs,&equo; she said, with more than a hint of exasperation. 
 &bquo;I keep telling you but you won't listen. 
 Jobs are scarce at the moment, so you've got to be realistic.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ever since I resigned, I've had to put up with this incessant, &bquo;You've got to be realistic,&equo; from you. 
 Realistically, I had no future left at SIS, so what did I do? 
 I got up and left. 
 Realistically, I've been applying for the sort of job that will pay me enough money to keep me going when I retire. 
 I've only eight working years left now and with all my savings gone, I simply can't afford to work for nothing. 
 If I'm not careful, I'm going to have nothing to fall back on.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, but how many of these wonderfully high-paid jobs have you been offered over the past eighteen months?&equo; 
 &bquo;There's no need to rub it in. 
 You don't know how difficult it is.&equo; 
 &bquo;I do know. 
 That's why I keep telling you to apply for teaching jobs.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, but as I keep trying to get through to you, I don't want to teach any more. 
 That's why I left SIS in the first place.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you've got to earn a living, Dorothy. 
 You'll be living on fresh air soon if you're not careful.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know that, thank you. 
 That's why we're having tunafish this evening instead of poached salmon.&equo; 
 I always was rather patronizing towards Anne. 
 &bquo;Yes, but you can't pick and choose now. 
 You've got to take whatever's going. 
 How else are you going to support yourself? 
 You're like me, Dorothy, you've got no family. 
 We're talking about how you're going to survive and it's as basic as that.&equo;  
 &bquo;You don't have to worry about me becoming a burden on you, you know. 
 I'd rather sleep in the gutter than let that happen. 
 I'm quite capable of looking after myself and I don't need you to tell me how.&equo; 
 Something inside Anne snapped. 
 &bquo;Oh, for goodness' sake! 
 I've had just about enough of this. 
 Ever since you left SIS, you've done nothing except mope around and complain. 
 You complain about your friends never coming to see you, but when they do come, you give them such a hard time it's hardly surprising they stay away. 
 And you're still dreaming this impossible dream about you and some fantastic job in publishing. 
 I mean, if it was there, I'd have it! 
 Those sort of jobs just don't exist for people like you and me. 
 They're for those upper-class twits who turn up halfway through seminars and who never bother to get their essays in on time. 
 You and I are teachers. 
 That's what we're trained to do, and nobody, but nobody, is going to train us to do anything else.&equo; 
 &bquo;As I keep saying, I don't need you or anybody else to tell me what I can or cannot do.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes you do! 
 I'm not getting through to you, am I?&equo; 
 &bquo;I understand perfectly what you're saying. 
 You're saying that I'm pretty hopeless at everything, but somebody might, just might, be prepared to put up with my teaching.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I'm not saying that at all. 
 You're perfectly capable of teaching; it's just that you've now got this thing about it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I remember when you first started at SIS. 
 The boot was on the other foot then, wasn't it? 
 But what do you care now? 
 You're all right Jack and I should be lucky for what I can get. 
 Well sorry, Anne, but I know too much about you to take this drivel.&equo; 
 She threw down her knife and fork. 
 &bquo;Right! 
 That's it. 
  I'm leaving. 
 Sort out your own life. 
 I've had enough of it!&equo; 
 She quickly left the room, took her coat off the hat-stand in the hallway and left. 
 That was the last time we spoke. 
 I can still remember the click of the latch as she shut the door behind her. 
 I sat with my head in my hands for a while, then I went over to my desk and took out a small framed photograph of Anne and myself which I always hid before she arrived. 
 It was of the two of us leaning up against the Arch of Titus in Rome &mdash; we had bullied some fellow tourist into taking it for us. 
 It's a lovely photograph &mdash; I still carry it around with me. 
 We both look so happy and relaxed in it. 
 Then, as now while I write this, tears were running down my face. 
 I knew she wasn't coming back. 
 When she first arrived at SIS as a student, Anne had an affair with some chap in her year and when it broke up, she decided she wanted to leave. 
 It was me, her personal tutor at that time, who persuaded her to stay. 
 Over the years, Anne had put up with an awful lot from me and she had now finally decided she couldn't take it any more. 
 I couldn't, and don't, blame her. 
 Anne is abroad at the moment, doing some research, but she left a message with someone that I'm to give her a ring when she gets back. 
 I'm a bit apprehensive about seeing her again, but I'm sure she'll have fun seeing the old hag in her new colours. 
 Coincidence or whatever, in the newspaper one day the following week, there was an advertisement for an art history teacher at a boys' public school (that's a private one in this country) in Oxfordshire. 
 I applied for the post and was interviewed by the headmaster, a man of about my own age who was &bquo;mad on Puccini&equo;, and consequently thrilled to bits when I recognized  
 &bquo;Nessun Dorma&equo; from Turandot  which he insisted on singing to me. 
 &bquo;We've never had a woman on the staff before,&equo; he informed me (forgetting the cleaners and caterers). 
 &bquo;It will be a whole new adventure for us.&equo; 
 And, I realized, for me too.  
 Berkeley School had taken on a little more than they had bargained for. 
 The nearly half a year between my interview and my starting there passed without incident. 
 Truth be told, I can't really remember what I did do in those six months. 
 Over the summer I did read a few books and tentatively prepare a few classes, but it was indisputably a pretty lacklustre performance on my part. 
 I had managed to convince myself that, after a lifetime of teaching at university level, this was all going to be painfully easy. 
 I decided to keep up my flat in London and find fairly basic lodgings locally. 
 The idea of leaving London for good &mdash; with its galleries, the opera and everything &mdash; was just too much for me. 
 I would go home for weekends, if I felt like it, and during the holidays. 
 It amuses me that eight years ago I had two homes &mdash; but I digress again. 
 Berkeley took boys between the ages of thirteen and eighteen, most of them boarders. 
 The fees were high and the atmosphere rarefied. 
 &bquo;Our boys&equo; were being nurtured in the belief that they were the leaders of tomorrow, the &bquo;happy few&equo; who would one day be running whatever had now taken the place of the Empire. 
 &bquo;Also, we need to give an especially big Berkeley welcome to Dr Dorothy Streeter, who's joining our art department,&equo; intoned the headmaster during my first  school assembly there. 
 &bquo;You're all to do your best to make her feel she's one of us.&equo; 
 &bquo;How?&equo; 
 I wondered, as I looked round at the massed ranks of chaps, young and old. 
 &bquo;What on earth am I doing here?&equo; 
 I asked myself. 
 &bquo;What on earth can have possessed me to take a job like this? 
 Now look at me. 
 Stuck in the middle of the Oxfordshire countryside with hundreds of noisy incomprehensible children and colleagues who make me feel about as comfortable as a walk in the rain. 
 I must have gone stark raving mad.&equo; 
 &bquo;Finally, if you have any problems, my door is always open, so don't be put off by it.&equo; 
 We all filed out of the assembly hall. 
 My brief was to teach art and history of art to all age groups. 
 I had no experience of teaching art to anyone, but the headmaster assured me that it simply involved giving the boys some paints to play with and then telling them to get on with it. 
 He expressed the hope that my presence would &bquo;give a boost to the standing of art history in the school&equo;, but unfortunately that wish was pie in the sky. 
 Art classes were seen as &bquo;free&equo; periods by the boys and any suggestion of serious work was unwelcome. 
 My slide shows did go down reasonably well, if only because while the lights were out, they had the chance to change places under cover of darkness in the hope of confusing you know who. 
 This game was a little disheartening, not so much because of the disciplinary problem, but because it showed all too clearly that few if any of them were actually listening to what I was saying. 
 My one colleague in the department was Jeff. 
 Jeff came into teaching via the practical side of art. 
 He shared his pupils' impatience with the history side but he was far too polite ever to express this prejudice in my presence &mdash; and he was pleased that there was somebody else in the department who was prepared to cover  that part of the teaching. 
 Jeff still rates as one of the nicest people I have ever met. 
 The boys all liked him, too &mdash; and some of them resented being placed under my care because of the fun they knew they could be having next door. 
 &bquo;Rapids might look more exciting, but still waters run deep,&equo; Jeff used to say to them. 
 &bquo;You can learn a lot from Dr Streeter, so give her a chance.&equo; 
 The rest of my new colleagues were less sure about what to make of me. 
 It took many of them an awful long time even to introduce themselves. 
 In their defence, I'm not the most approachable woman in the world and many of them were simply unused to female company. 
 In any event, the biggest problem for us all was my own state of depression. 
 I'm pretty sure that by this stage I was suffering from what medical people mean when they talk about &bquo;clinical depression&equo;. 
 However, I never tried to get professional help, and that may well have been a mistake. 
 Depressed people can of course make hasty and unwise decisions, and I made one such decision when, during my second term at Berkeley, I decided to give up my London flat. 
 I had lived at the same place in Hampstead for over twenty years and so, as a sitting tenant, my rent was pretty cheap. 
 However, as you know, most of my savings had vanished while I was unemployed and when I was offered a very nice flat near the school, the financial advantages of making that my single home base seemed overwhelming. 
 In addition, I no longer saw any of my old friends while I was up in London and my Hampstead flat felt rather empty without them. 
 &bquo;Adjust, Dorothy,&equo; I kept telling myself. 
 &bquo;What was that Anne kept telling you? 
 &bquo;You've got to be realistic.&equo; 
 Well, be realistic and accept what has happened.&equo; 
 The new flat was smaller than the old so I had to sell  some of my furniture. 
 However, all told, I was rather pleased with my new home. 
 &bquo;It will do,&equo; I used to say. 
 &bquo;It will definitely do.&equo; 
 Back to the school. 
 Jeff had a hard time with me. 
 It isn't easy coping with a person who is twice your age and beset by problems you have no hope of being able to understand. 
 He could have complained to the top about my basic lack of professionalism but instead he went out of his way to try and help &mdash; and sometimes got pretty short shrift in return. 
 The rest of my colleagues also sensed my unhappiness. 
 Some of them tried to make amends for their own earlier contribution to this state of affairs and moved to include me more fully in the life of the school &mdash; a few even started to invite me back home for meals and things. 
 Dorothy, I realized, had become a problem, and I resented that. 
 &bquo;How have you found us?&equo; the headmaster asked me &mdash; masochistically &mdash; one warm summer's afternoon as we sat watching a cricket match. 
 &bquo;Set in your ways.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh well played!&equo; 
 He broke off to applaud a little ball striking a boundary rope not far from us. 
 &bquo;Someone will have to explain this game to me one day,&equo; I said, mournfully. 
 &bquo;It's quite simple really,&equo; the headmaster assured me. 
 &bquo;It's designed around the principle that participation is more important than winning. 
 Twenty-two athletes spend five days for the most part watching their teammates do all the work, and at the end of it all, everyone is quite happy to settle for a draw. 
 It's rather marvellous, really, when you think about it.&equo; 
 &bquo;People do lose sometimes.&equo; 
 &bquo;True, but they have a pleasant time in the sun while they're about it. 
 What do you mean by us being set in  our ways?&equo; he asked, the tone of his voice changing when he put the question. 
 &bquo;You tend to treat life as if it were a game of cricket, for one thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do we really?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, but you have a maddening habit of pretending you do.&equo; 
 He smiled and was silent for a moment. 
 His next comment was measured in delivery. 
 &bquo;Would I be right in saying that we haven't provided you with what you were looking for when you came here?&equo; 
 &bquo;What am I supposed to have been looking for?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's rather what I'm hoping to find out.&equo; 
 The headmaster was getting a little too close to the bone for my liking, so I decided to go on the defensive. 
 &bquo;Is there something about my work that's been bothering you, Headmaster?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, you've got the wrong end of the stick entirely.&equo; 
 He paused again. 
 &bquo;Look, Dorothy, I hired you because I thought you might shake the place up a bit, so if you are unhappy here, that's at least partly my fault. 
 Stevens, tuck your shirt in! 
 I'm not asking for a few soothing words to calm my conscience; if I can, I want to help. 
 We would all, I think, like to help. 
 It's just that none of us actually knows how to go about it.&equo; 
 I was silent for a moment then I looked away. 
 &bquo;You've no need to worry,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I'm fine.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you ever do want to talk about it, please do come and see me. 
 It may be that I can't help, but&hellip;&equo; 
 In retrospect, the greatest disservice Charles Howard ever did me was the way he had somehow made it impossible for me to trust this man. 
 As he had just said, he did genuinely want to help. 
 The headmaster was silent for a while, then he stood up.  
 &bquo;Forgive me, Dorothy, I must get back to my office.&equo; 
 I made no reply. 
 He walked off and I gazed blankly at the cricket match. 
 The summer holidays that year saw me at my most apathetic &mdash; and my most miserable. 
 In fact, I went for the entire two months without seeing anyone. 
 The Michaelmas term saw me at my most hostile. 
 The boys had now decided on a nickname for me: Mona, after Leonardo's Mona Lisa. 
 Mona graffiti started to appear everywhere and the craze was fuelled by my own furious reaction whenever I discovered some new example of the genre. 
 I remember one particular occasion when, on finding &bquo;Cheer up Mona&equo; written on the blackboard when I arrived to take a class, I went absolutely potty, threatening dire punishment on the whole class &mdash; the entire school almost &mdash; unless the culprit came forward. 
 &bquo;But it was there when we got here, Miss.&equo; 
 &bquo;How many times do I have to tell you, Hawkins, my name's Doctor Streeter, not Miss Streeter; now come up here and wipe that filth off.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, Dr Streeter.&equo; 
 I simply could not understand the boys' sense of humour. 
 Although I can now see the inherent sense in glueing a book to a table, then the point was just beyond me. 
 And the noise they would make as well &mdash; it was driving me crazy. 
 &bquo;It's no good, Jeff. 
 I can't stand this any more. 
 I've got to get out of here. 
 I'm just not cut out for this. 
 I'm sorry, it's no good. 
 I've just got to get out of here.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dorothy, you're nearly fifty-four, aren't you? 
 I don't mean to be rude, but how on earth are you going to find another job the way unemployment is now? 
 It's not like it used to be. 
 No matter how talented you are, at your age employers just aren't going to want to know.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was unemployed for nearly two years before I came  here, I do know what it's like. 
 I'm sorry, Jeff, I didn't mean to be patronizing.&equo; 
 &bquo;My fault, I forgot. 
 But what are you going to do?&equo; 
 &bquo;There's still work going in London &mdash; I'll try down there again. 
 I belong in London anyway. 
 It's a world I can understand, Jeff &mdash; not this place. 
 I just can't fit in here.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's a lot you could contribute if you did stay. 
 I think you should give us another try.&equo; 
 That brought tears to my eyes and I turned away so that Jeff wouldn't be able to see them, then fought them back. 
 &bquo;Look, Dorothy, I know it isn't easy for you here, but I honestly don't think you're going to have better luck anywhere else. 
 You've got to be realistic.&equo; 
 I do wish he hadn't said that last bit. 
 Suddenly I thought of Anne and felt impelled to rebel. 
 &bquo;You're wasting your time, Jeff.&equo; 
 I turned to face him. 
 &bquo;Thanks, pet, but there's nothing you can do. 
 Look, I'll survive, don't worry.&equo; 
 He looked crestfallen, but he smiled. 
 &bquo;We all do until we die.&equo; 
 &bquo;Leave a silly old woman alone, Jeff, she's got things to do.&equo; 
 He turned and walked towards the door. 
 &bquo;Jeff.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;I meant it when I said thank you. 
 You can't imagine how much of a help you've been to me. 
 I've been difficult material to work with, haven't I?&equo; 
 He smiled. 
 &bquo;I reckon I know how Leonardo da Vinci must have felt.&equo; 
 We laughed and he left. 
 I did resign. 
 I thought long and hard about it but in the end I decided it would be for the best. 
 Although Jeff making me laugh at myself was the beginning of  the end of my depression, it wasn't enough to persuade me to stay. 
 What tipped the balance against that was my continuing dreadful performance in the classroom. 
 Anyway, Jeff had now given me something new &mdash; something really important to me. 
 It was something I wanted to try out somewhere else. 
 My colleagues seemed genuinely worried by my decision and many of them tried to convince me to change my mind. 
 &bquo;What can we do to persuade you to stay?&equo; the headmaster asked. 
 &bquo;Nothing, but I do appreciate you asking. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 On my final day at Berkeley, my fourth-form pupils presented me with some flowers and a small mounted copy of Claude Lorrain's &bquo;Hagar and the Angel&equo;. 
 My talisman. 
 &bquo;We know you don't like reproductions, Dr Streeter,&equo; Barnett said rather nervously, &bquo;but we wanted to give you something to remind you of us. 
 It's only a little thing, anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you. 
 Thank you, all of you. 
 I'll treasure this. 
 I really don't know what to say. 
 Where did you get the flowers?&equo; 
 I half expected him to say they stole them from somebody's garden but&hellip; 
 &bquo;Matthews and I got them in town, Dr Streeter. 
 I had to strap them to my bicycle, which is why they look a bit battered.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh don't worry, they're beautiful. 
 They're fine. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 I remember a tear running down my cheek and me trying to smile it away. 
 &bquo;Speech!&equo; one of the boys shouted, and we all laughed. 
 &bquo;I'm going to miss you,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Thank you, I'm going to miss all of you.&equo; 
 Jeff made his rescuing entrance.  
 &bquo;Nobody's ever given a member of staff here flowers before,&equo; he observed with a twinkle. 
 &bquo;I've been given this beautiful little picture as well,&equo; I said, and I smiled up at him. 
 He smiled back. 
 A troubled smile. 
 &bquo;Need any help clearing up?&equo; he asked, drawing the proceedings to a close. 
 &bquo;That would be nice, thank you,&equo; I said. 
 I took the flowers over to one of the sinks and put them in it. 
 Behind me, the boys collected up their things and quietly left the room. 
 Rather than watch them go, I stayed by the sink and gazed out over the playing fields. 
 &bquo;I'll miss you,&equo; I said softly to myself. 
 It hit me just how right Anne had been when she said that teaching was the only job I knew &mdash; and how horribly ill-equipped I was for anything else. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, it's time we went to Final Assembly.&equo; 
 &bquo;Coming.&equo; 
 We walked out into the sun together and across to the school hall. 
 All of a sudden I started to laugh. 
 &bquo;What's up?&equo; 
 Jeff asked. 
 &bquo;Nothing,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;It's just the vision of Matthews and Barnett buying those flowers. 
 I'm not being unkind, I'm sure they can also see the funny side of it.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can t say people haven t tried. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I can't.&equo;  
 Berkeley did after all turn out to be my last dalliance with the education system. 
 If I had elected to stay there, I probably would not have become homeless five years later. 
 However, it is important to remember the gap. 
 My becoming homeless was not a result of my dropping out of a system which probably would have supported me until retirement age; it was the result of a chain of events which took place much, much later. 
 Blame me for becoming poor if you like &mdash; I admit, I blew it &mdash; but the responsibility for the way our society treats its poorer members is not exclusively mine. 
 One immediate result of my departure from Berkeley was my giving up my flat by the school and going back to London. 
 I was disappointed to find that accommodation was scarcer and more expensive than I thought it would be and the best that I could afford was a large first-floor room in a bedsitter house on Ladbroke Grove. 
 I assured myself that it would be only temporary and I would soon be in a flat again, but &bquo;temporary&equo; turned out to be five years. 
 I was acutely aware of the urgent need to find some work to do, so I combed the national and local newspapers to see what was on offer. 
 I resolved to take the first thing that came along and from that base to look further afield if need be. 
 I was given a couple of interviews straight off which, though unsuccessful, were  useful practice and I felt confident that something would soon turn up. 
 About three weeks after I started looking, I came upon an advertisement for a receptionist to work at a local authority office building, not too far from my new home. 
 It seemed about par for the course, so I applied, was interviewed and then offered the job, all in reasonably quick time. 
 It all seemed to have gone remarkably smoothly. 
 The job paid quite well and I could perhaps at that stage have afforded somewhere slightly better to live, but I'd got used to my new home and I was still keen to try and build up some savings again. 
 The building I was now working in housed a number of statutory and voluntary social-services organizations. 
 My job was to operate the telephone switchboard, sort the morning post, direct house-callers to the appropriate organization, and that was about it. 
 The telephones kept me just about busy but the potential for job satisfaction in the tasks I was required to do was almost nil. 
 This was, I kept telling myself, just a staging post. 
 It does, however, hold the distinction of being the second-longest-running job that I have held to date. 
 I was there for about three and a half years. 
 Writing about the last two jobs felt strange, largely because of the muddled emotions they still arouse. 
 Writing about this one feels strange simply because there isn't that much to say. 
 I was the inevitable, anonymous receptionist you meet when you walk into almost any large building. 
 You say hello to her, you assume she has been reading your mail or listening in to your private telephone calls (actually I never did either), and you tell her when you do not wish to be disturbed. 
 And, if you are just visiting, you blame her if the person you have come to see isn't there, or keeps you waiting, or whatever. 
 To most people, a receptionist is an obstacle to be negotiated, and that was unfortunately how I was made  to feel for much of the time. 
 There were an awful lot of nice people working in the building, but there is sometimes a certain tone in your voice, a clouded look in your eye, which gives the impression that you're more likely to be a client than a colleague. 
 I was bored and lonely; they were suffering from compassion fatigue. 
 We very rarely mixed. 
 Bored and lonely, yes; depressed, no. 
 I was more or less resigned to the way things had turned out and just got on with life. 
 In point of fact, my mind started to wake up a bit during this period. 
 I started to read newspapers and magazines more, and, for just about the first time in my life, I began to take an interest in current affairs. 
 This new hobby developed during an interesting period for the British press. 
 The majority of the newspapers had become woefully compromised in their support for the government and good investigative journalism was one of the casualties. 
 In its place we have had ever more examples of newspapers pandering to people's baser instincts by covering the private lives of television actors and the like &mdash; the so-called &bquo;human-interest&equo; stories. 
 The result of all this has been that proponents in the press of the fashionable pro-government doctrine of &bquo;new realism&equo; have somehow found themselves spending most of their time constructing and then reporting on a fantasy world. 
 Bored and lonely, yes, but I had a reasonably pleasant time of things all the same. 
 I went out to the theatre and the opera a lot, and when I had some time off, I was usually able to get away somewhere. 
 In times past, I had tried to get across to the continent as much as possible, but now, while other people were going abroad for the first time because of all the cheap travel around, I was (without intending to be anti-social) doing exactly the opposite and taking a look around the British Isles. 
 All this did, of course, cost money, but  if you've had even a comparatively small amount of that and then lost it, you do tend to realize how transient the whole thing is and not worry so much about getting it back again. 
 Besides, I didn't think I could now save enough to make a significant difference to my standard of living when I retired, so I decided I might as well enjoy it while I had the chance. 
 In retrospect, I would probably have saved a little bit more, but there it is &mdash; I did manage to save a little bit anyway. 
 I had been employed at Jersey House for about two and a half years when I was approached to see if I might like to do a little cleaning work to earn some overtime. 
 This would involve staying behind after office hours to empty some bins and hoover around a bit. 
 I said yes, but filling all my early evenings with this would prove rather inconvenient on those occasions when I wanted to go out, so we agreed a system whereby I would do some of the work first thing in the morning and the rest of it just after I closed down the switchboard. 
 This suited everyone else, as some people like to come in early, others to leave late, and we all managed to work around each other. 
 I kept this extra stuff up until I finished there. 
 By this time, I was already leading a life which ten years earlier I would have assured you that I could never have tolerated. 
 There was snobbery in this, of course, but also a simple ignorance of life outside the ivory tower in which I then dwelt. 
 However, at this new point in my life there seemed &mdash; as of course there was &mdash; nothing remarkable about what I was doing. 
 It was my desire to be active, to earn my way in life, which encouraged me into these new fields, that is it was a positive  impulse which drove me on. 
 As for the glamour attached to some jobs and not to others: forget it, it's a sham. 
 For let me tell you something: I've respected myself far more for doing cleaning jobs well than for  doing teaching jobs badly &mdash; and it is entirely appropriate that I should do so. 
 If you look up to the university lecturer or down on the cleaner, either way you're not facing up to the truth about us all. 
 On with the story. 
 On a Wednesday there was a rumour flying around Jersey House that the building was going to be sold; on the following Monday, the rumour was confirmed as fact. 
 The local authority that owned the premises was &bquo;privatizing&equo; it, i.e. making a quick profit while there were still a fair few years on the lease. 
 All the organizations that worked there were offered alternative accommodation, which they were all sensible enough to accept. 
 The small number of us who were attached to the building itself either retired or were offered work elsewhere with the authority. 
 I was offered a cleaning job that I didn't much like the look of so I left quietly before the final curtain. 
 If I'd been a union member I might have held out for a better offer or some redundancy money, but I wasn't, so that was that. 
 I took a short break, and when I came back, I went round the local job centres to see what was going. 
 The second one I visited was the centre on Edgware Road. 
 I took down a few reference numbers from a noticeboard headed &bquo;Cleaning&equo; and then waited for my turn. 
 &bquo;How can we help, Mrs Streeter?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's Miss,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I'm looking for cleaning or receptionist work &mdash; whatever's going, really.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have you any experience as a cleaner?&equo; 
 &bquo;Part-time. 
 I was the full-time receptionist there as well.&equo; 
 &bquo;Any other experience?&equo; 
 &bquo;This and that.&equo; 
 He picked up the telephone. 
 The first number on the list was a posh-sounding hotel. 
 &bquo;Can I speak to Mrs Travers, please&hellip; 
 Ah, it's the  Edgware Road Job Centre. 
 Do you still have any vacancies for chambermaids?&hellip; 
 Fifty-eight-year-old woman with some experience&hellip; in an office&hellip; she was made redundant.&equo; 
 (He put his hand over the receiver.) 
 &bquo;What happened?&equo; 
 &bquo;They sold the building.&equo; 
 &bquo;Apparently, the offices were sold to another company&hellip; 
 Nine-thirty tomorrow morning.&equo; 
 (He put his hand over the receiver again.) 
 &bquo;Interview, nine-thirty, tomorrow morning. 
 That OK by you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine.&equo; 
 &bquo;She'll be there.&equo; 
 And, in record time, I got the job. 
 I started the day after the interview. 
 The work &mdash; cleaning guest rooms &mdash; was low-paid and pretty routine. 
 I stuck it for about a year and then moved on to another, slightly better hotel to do the same thing for marginally more money. 
 The move was really just a change for change's sake &mdash; I was simply bored to tears by it all. 
 As it turned out, rather too much excitement was just around the corner.  
 At the first hotel I worked in, I had shared an &bquo;office, with one other cleaner &mdash; a taciturn alcoholic who taught me how to keep my head down &mdash; but in my new job, there were five of us who shared the same poky little room. 
 Consequently, first thing in the morning when we were all trying to get ready, we constantly got in each other's way. 
 The atmosphere was, however, cordial, if not convivial, and the talk was of what grandchildren were up to or what Dr So-and-so said about this or that particular problem. 
 Shortly after I arrived, there arose a new topic for conversation. 
 There had been a rash of petty thefts in the hotel and we were all warned to be vigilant. 
 Who was the thief? 
 No one, to my knowledge, ever found out. 
 When we were first warned, I didn't really pay much attention to what was being said about it &mdash; the same problem had flared up at both Jersey House and the hotel I'd just left but in neither case had there been prolonged cause for concern. 
 &bquo;You've been very quiet about this, Dorothy. 
 What do you think?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 There are so many people who come and go in a place like this, it could be anyone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Someone must be doing it.&equo; 
 One of the things we had been told was to carry any  valuables we had around with us so that they couldn't go astray. 
 While we were all getting ready for work one morning, a few days after the above conversation, one of the other girls (Martha) transferred a fifty-pound note from her handbag to the pocket of her apron, which was at that point still hanging by the door with everyone else's. 
 In the bustle of everything, none of us noticed her do it &mdash; there was no reason for us to. 
 We all wore these aprons as a uniform and to protect our own clothes while we were working. 
 Why Martha transferred the money before she put her apron on I don't know &mdash; I suppose it's just that everyone has their own little routines for doing things. 
 Anyway, we were all soon off to start another morning's work. 
 The existence of this note wasn't in fact revealed until Martha made a comment during our mid-morning coffee break. 
 &bquo;I've had a fifty-pound note stolen.&equo; 
 We all looked up. 
 Martha was rummaging through her pockets. 
 &bquo;Hang on,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Let me check my handbag.&equo; 
 The search through her handbag brought no success. 
 We all watched her, unsure of what to say. 
 &bquo;Maybe you left it in your trolley,&equo; one of the others volunteered. 
 &bquo;No, I'm sure I put it in my apron pocket, but I can't have done. 
 I must have left it in my handbag and somebody's stolen it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Best to check your trolley, just in case. 
 We'll have a look round in here.&equo; 
 Martha went out to check her trolley and the rest of us, somewhat half-heartedly, searched the room. 
 &bquo;Silly idiot for bringing all that money in with her,&equo; another of the girls muttered. 
 &bquo;I expect she's left it at home,&equo; I said. 
 Martha soon came back, visibly distressed. 
 Our supervisor, the level-headed Mrs Long, was called.  
 When she arrived, she listened to the story of what had happened, teased out the relevant details, then announced that the police would have to be called and went off back to her office to do the necessary. 
 Once she had left, I reached into my apron pocket for my packet of cigarettes. 
 I felt my hand touch something feathery and I pulled it out to see what it was. 
 It was a fifty-pound note. 
 I stood there staring at it for a moment, unable to believe what I saw. 
 &bquo;What's the matter, Dorothy?&equo; somebody asked. 
 &bquo;I've got that fifty-pound note we're all looking for.&equo; 
 &bquo;What!&equo; 
 &bquo;Where did you find it?&equo; 
 Martha asked. 
 &bquo;In my pocket.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean, in your pocket?&equo; 
 I looked across at her. 
 &bquo;In my pocket, just now,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Well what were you doing with it?&equo; she asked, aghast. 
 &bquo;I don't know, I just found it.&equo; 
 I looked down at the money again. 
 &bquo;You must have put it there by accident,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;What do you mean, I must have put it there, you must have put it there. 
 You stole it!&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't steal your money, you stupid bitch, you must have put it in the wrong apron.&equo; 
 &bquo;Call me a stupid bitch, you fucking cow &mdash; you're the one who's the thief.&equo; 
 I let the money slip through my fingers on to the floor. 
 Something inside me had snapped. 
 I went across and grabbed her by the lapels. 
 &bquo;Call me a fucking thief one more time and I'll smash your fucking face in!&equo; 
 She gave me a slap and I gave her one back. 
 Then we were wrestling and the other three rushed to separate us.  
 &bquo;Get Mrs Long,&equo; one of the girls was ordered. 
 Her departure meant there was only one person left restraining me. 
 I shook her off and staggered out of the office, down the stairs and into the lobby. 
 There, I tore off my apron and sat down in one of those ridiculously soft chairs you always find in such places. 
 I had desperately wanted to rush outside and leave the whole wretched affair behind me but something told me I had to stay and face the music. 
 &bquo;Why did that stupid idiot put her stupid fifty-pound note inside my pocket?&equo; 
 I wondered as I fumbled around inside my apron for my cigarettes. 
 Then I noticed the tag on the collar. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; I said to myself. 
 &bquo;No, it can't be. 
 It's not right. 
 It can't be.&equo; 
 I had, of course, been wearing Martha's apron. 
 I felt sick. 
 I felt the courage draining out of me. 
 Mrs Long appeared. 
 Could you come down and see me in my office, please, Dorothy?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure.&equo; 
 I followed her downstairs. 
 Everyone we passed seemed to be staring at me. 
 &bquo;All I want to do is get to the bottom of this,&equo; she assured me as we entered her office. 
 &bquo;Sit down and try to relax for a minute.&equo; 
 She nodded towards a chair on the near side of her desk. 
 It was a rather rickety affair that creaked embarrassingly when I sat down in it and ever after when I moved. 
 Once Mrs Long had also sat down, she posed the obvious question. 
 &bquo;What happened?&equo; 
 &bquo;I put Martha's apron on by accident this morning. 
 She'd put a fifty-pound note in it and so she thought that it had been stolen. 
 When I found it, there was an argument and we went for each other.&equo;  
 &bquo;When did you discover your mistake?&equo; 
 &bquo;About the apron? 
 Just now. 
 I thought she'd put the money in my apron by mistake and that's why we had 
 &bquo;Can I get this straight? 
 First thing this morning, Martha put a fifty-pound note into the pocket of an apron you subsequently wore, thinking it to be yours.&equo; 
 I nodded. 
 &bquo;It's as simple as that.&equo; 
 &bquo;When did you discover the money?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just after you left.&equo; 
 &bquo;When I left to call the police, you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, just after that.&equo; 
 &bquo;How come you discovered the money at that particular moment?&equo; 
 &bquo;I put my hand in my pocket to get my cigarettes.&equo; 
 &bquo;What happened after you found the money?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, as I say, I thought she'd put the money in my apron by accident. 
 She started calling me a thief and it all went on from there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who actually started the name-calling?&equo; 
 I was silent for a moment, trying desperately hard to remember events that had happened only a few minutes earlier. 
 &bquo;I think it was me who started it,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I'm not sure. 
 Somehow it all seemed to get out of control.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who hit who first?&equo; 
 &bquo;I made a grab for her and she then slapped me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then you slapped her back?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right.&equo; 
 (&bquo;How did she know that?&equo; 
 I wondered.) 
 &bquo;Look, this is all my fault,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;She was in an impossible situation, I&hellip;&equo; 
 Mrs Long stood up. 
 &bquo;There are a few details I want to clear up with the other girls,&equo; she told me. 
 &bquo;Can you hang on here for a few moments?&equo; 
 &bquo;There's no hurry.&equo; 
 She left. 
 I sat there, numbed by what had happened. 
  Nothing seemed to make sense. 
 I'd never done anything like that before. 
 Mrs Long returned. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, I think the best thing would be if you went home now and reported to me here, first thing tomorrow morning. 
 I want to discuss this with my superiors, but I think it's only fair for me to say that it may well be difficult for us to keep you here.&equo; 
 &bquo;I never stole anything, you know.&equo; 
 She gave me a half-smile. 
 &bquo;I don't think you did, either, but unfortunately it's now more complicated than that.&equo; 
 The rest of that day was just awful. 
 I could not believe that I'd been so stupid, or that such a simple mistake was about to have such dire consequences. 
 I wandered aimlessly around the National Gallery just for something to do and then went home. 
 One thing I can remember about that evening was that I couldn't eat anything. 
 I couldn't bear to have the television on either &mdash; I just sat there in silence, trying to work it all out. 
 What on earth had got into me? 
 The night was sleepless, the morning cold. 
 Breakfast was a cup of coffee and I then went off to keep my appointment with Mrs Long. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Dorothy, but we are going to have to ask you to leave.&equo; 
 &bquo;I understand. 
 Do you mind if, technically speaking, I resign rather than you sack me? 
 It's a personal thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, no, I can't think of any reason. 
 Hang on, I'll need another termination form.&equo; 
 She pulled out a file from a drawer in her desk, took out a fresh form and began to fill it in. 
 When she had finished, she passed it over so that I could sign it. 
 I read it through, then crossed out where she had written &bquo;Miss&equo; at the top and wrote &bquo;Dr&equo; instead. 
 Mrs Long looked puzzled.  
 &bquo;I didn't know you were a doctor,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Of philosophy rather than medicine. 
 I used to be an art historian.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, that's interesting!&equo; 
 She smiled and pointed to the wall to her right. 
 &bquo;What do you think of my painting?&equo; she asked. 
 It was a reproduction of Monet's &bquo;Wild Poppies&equo;. 
 &bquo;I actually rather like Monet &mdash; especially his earlier stuff.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who did you say it was by?&equo; 
 &bquo;Claude Monet &mdash; one of the Impressionists.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh.&equo; 
 She smiled again. 
 &bquo;It must be wonderful to know things like that.&equo; 
 &bquo;It has its uses.&equo; 
 I passed back the form and just about managed a smile myself. 
 &bquo;Well, Mrs Long,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I think that is just about that.&equo; 
 She stood up and held out her hand. 
 I stood up and shook it. 
 It seemed rather an odd thing to do, but perfectly in tune with the occasion. 
 &bquo;I hope you have better luck at your next port of call.&equo; 
 &bquo;So do I. Goodbye.&equo; 
 &bquo;Goodbye, Doctor.&equo; 
 She meant it as a compliment but it made me sound like her GP. 
 I made my way up to the lobby with those final two words of hers ringing around inside my head, and all sorts of other doctor phrases started to enter my mind &mdash; people calling me Doctor Streeter, popular songs with the word doctor in them &mdash; and then all of a sudden I started to cry. 
 I stumbled out of the hotel and into the middle of the road, narrowly missing being killed by a taxi. 
 I remember the screech of the horn and the blur of the car as it passed in front of me. 
 Somehow, I reached the other pavement safely. 
 Tears were streaming down my face &mdash; everywhere.  
 &bquo;Goodbye dear,&equo; I suddenly said. 
 &bquo;Daddy would have loved to have come as I said, but he just can't get any time off at all at the moment. 
 Now, are you sure you're going to be all right?&equo; 
 My voice was strident and shrill. 
 A startled passer-by gave me as wide a berth as possible. 
 I ran down the pavement to get as far away from the hotel as I could, then I sat down in a doorway and continued crying. 
 Slowly the tears subsided and gradually I began to pull myself together. 
 I had nearly got myself killed back there: what on earth did I think I was playing at? 
 The people back at the hotel didn't know me. 
 They didn't know I wouldn't steal money like that. 
 People always blame the stranger when something like that happens &mdash; why should it be any different for me? 
 I became conscious of where I was and what I was doing so I quickly stood up and dried my eyes. 
 This was not the way to behave. 
 I had to get a grip on myself and put this whole wretched business behind me. 
 I walked on further down the street and when I spied a suitable coffee shop, I went in, sat down and ordered myself a soothing cuppa. 
 It was expensive and funds were running low. 
 I was going to have to be careful from now on. 
 I was, I must emphasize, determined to find another job &mdash; and as quickly as possible. 
 However, although unemployment was starting to come down, especially in the south-east where I was living, it was still generally pretty high. 
 I had two additional problems: my age and getting a reference from someone. 
 I didn't want to risk Mrs Long, and Mrs Travers knew where I had moved on to, so giving her name could cause problems as well. 
 Basically, if I wanted another job I was going to have to lie &mdash; and I wasn't very good at that. 
 &bquo;Maybe I should have stayed and fought?&equo; 
 I wondered. 
 No, I'd never been given that option. 
 But  anyway, there was work around. 
 I was bound to find something somewhere. 
 The next couple of days passed without incident. 
 Day three was another crisis day. 
 This time it was my landlady's turn to drop a bomb. 
 &bquo;Hello, Miss Streeter. 
 I've got some news for you. 
 I'm about to sell the house&hellip; 
 Well, with prices the way they are I'd be crazy not to&hellip; 
 No, the estate agent reckons it'll be converted into flats, so I expect the new owner's going to want you out. 
 You look shattered, What's the matter? 
 Look, you don't need to worry about it &mdash; at your age the council will give you something if you can't find anything yourself&hellip; 
 What? 
 Sacked!&hellip; 
 Well it's &bquo;easy come, easy go&equo; in those places, you should put it behind you and carry on with life, that's the best thing. 
 Rough when it happens, though. 
 Get all your benefits sorted out and then start looking around again. 
 I'm not going to chuck you out and go for vacant possession or anything, life's too short for that. 
 I'm really sorry about all this happening to you at once like this. 
 I mean, it's like what they say, trouble always comes in threes, doesn't it?&equo; 
 Mrs Hill was right about that last point, anyway. 
 A day or so later, I came down with a very nasty bout of influenza. 
 It was partly brought on, I'm sure, by the worry of all that was happening. 
 The illness did, however, convince me to accept another of the points Mrs Hill had made and I decided to apply for social security money. 
 During my earlier periods of unemployment I had always, on a point of pride, provided for myself out of my savings. 
 However, these were now too low and my prospects too poor for me to continue along that track. 
 My illness kept me out of action for a fortnight so it was fully three weeks after the demise of my job before I finally went down to my local Department of Employment offices and &bquo;signed on&equo;.  
 Somewhat na&iuml;vely, I had expected it all to be sorted out then and there, but the chap just took my name, gave me a form to fill in and told me to come back a few days later for a full interview. 
 I was surprised to learn that my claim could not be backdated, but I wrote those first three weeks' money off to inexperience. 
 Anyway, the important thing was I was now safely inside the system. 
 My full interview seemed to go reasonably smoothly so at the end of it I asked how long would it take for my money to come through. 
 She said not more than a month. 
 &bquo;A month!&equo; 
 &bquo;Keep your mouth shut,&equo; I told myself. 
 &bquo;If you argue it will take even longer.&equo; 
 She gave me another form to fill in for housing benefit. 
 I took this down to the town hall the following day and then set myself to the most urgent task in hand: trying to find another job. 
 I didn't go after anything fancy, but somehow I seemed to keep muffing up the interviews. 
 I was too anxious &mdash; far too anxious &mdash; and this put my interviewers on their guard. 
 They were suspicious about my past, my age and a picture of me that simply did not add up. 
 I was a risk, and a risk they could all get by without taking. 
 Looking for work costs money. 
 That point may seem obvious but I don't think whoever worked out the amounts given in state benefits ever took it into account. 
 Clean clothes, fares to and from the interview, possibly something to eat or drink when you're far away from home, even going around the job centres &mdash; they all cost money. 
 All these little bits and pieces were starting to add up and I was getting nowhere. 
 Admittedly I was depressed again &mdash; no, not depressed exactly, low would be a better word. 
 My plan for how  I was going to live out the rest of my days had just been torn up in front of my face and I needed time to adjust. 
 A little luck would not have come amiss, either. 
 The house was sold very quickly and the new owner immediately gave us all notice to quit. 
 Many of the residents moved out shortly after Mrs Hill announced her intention to sell, and in fact there were only four of us left when the new landlord took possession. 
 Another two moved on shortly afterwards and it was then that the intimidation began. 
 In cases of harassment, the law seems to be very much on the side of the landlord. 
 Even if you do manage to prove that he has been harassing you, there doesn't appear to be much general acceptance of the fact that intimidating someone in this way might actually constitute a serious crime. 
 Property, it seems, is more important than people. 
 At the start of my period of being harassed, I went down to my local law centre to see what help they could give me. 
 They told me the legal position and asked how hard I was prepared to fight. 
 I said I did not know &mdash; I didn't know what I was letting myself in for. 
 They told me to keep in touch and call them if I felt they could be of assistance. 
 The nature of the intimidation was at first quite subtle. 
 I don't want to give any details just in case it gives other landlords ideas. 
 My own landlord did, in fairness, give me veiled offers of money (bribes) to move elsewhere but in all honesty I simply wasn't streetwise enough to figure out what exactly he had in mind. 
 Also &mdash; and I'm quite prepared to admit this &mdash; because of all the problems I was having trying to find work, just at that moment I really didn't want the bother of hunting for a new home. 
 That, if need be, could be sorted out at a later date. 
 Anyway, there was hardly an atmosphere  of trust between the two of us so the idea of me &bquo;dealing&equo; with him was not a comfortable one. 
 Passive harassment became more and more active. 
 The other person in the house moved out and I was on my own. 
 Let me update you on my social security saga. 
 It took six weeks for the first amount of money to arrive. 
 The rent cheque was, to my surprise, a few pounds short of the amount I was actually paying &mdash; certain deductions had been made for lighting and other odd things that were technically included in my monthly rent. 
 I went to see them about this but they told me it was up to the social security people to make up the difference. 
 I went to see them as well and they told me to fill in another form. 
 All this begging for money was time-consuming and degrading so I decided to concentrate on finding work. 
 Then I received another blow. 
 They stopped my unemployment benefit. 
 I went down to find out what had gone wrong. 
 Apparently, because my employment had officially been terminated by me, I had arguably made myself voluntarily unemployed and was therefore entitled to benefit money only after a certain period. 
 They weren't sure if this applied in my case but they were investigating the matter. 
 &bquo;How long is this all going to take?&equo; 
 They would let me know as soon as possible. 
 &bquo;Yes, but days? 
 Weeks? 
 Months? 
 Years?&equo; 
 It would be as soon as possible, but they couldn't say exactly how long. 
 No longer than a fortnight, hopefully. 
 &bquo;What am I supposed to live on in the meantime?&equo; 
 They couldn't make emergency payments themselves, but if I went down to the social security office&hellip; 
 &bquo;Look, I've been bounced around like a rubber ball  between you people for a couple of months now. 
 When is someone going to straighten this out?&equo; 
 As soon as possible. 
 &bquo;Could you please at least tell them it's quite urgent? 
 I'm rapidly running out of cash&hellip; yes, I know, the social security people.&equo; 
 I was now at the stage of selling things to keep the cash flow going. 
 Most of the things I had were dated and not worth very much, so I found myself selling off my past as jumble and bric-a-brac. 
 This did grate rather, but how else was I supposed to survive? 
 I did go down to my local Citizens' Advice Bureau to see if they had any ideas, but all they could do was pass on the news that there was a squeeze on the social fund (the emergency payments fund), so I was well advised not to expect too much if I did decide to try the social security people. 
 Depressed? 
 No. 
 Heavy-hearted? 
 I was certainly becoming so. 
 The Department of Employment reinstated my benefits (joy!) and then stopped them again. 
 This time it was just a computer error they thought &mdash; apparently a fairly common occurrence when there's been some form of disruption to a claim. 
 Unfortunately, a strike was also affecting things. 
 They would of course let me know what was going on as soon as possible. 
 My landlord did get me out eventually. 
 After the big stick came the carrot: he offered to pay my first month's rent at a hostel he knew. 
 The manager there was quite happy to take people on social security so I wouldn't have any trouble about that. 
 I was even offered a van to help me move. 
 I declined the offer of a van, but otherwise accepted the inevitable. 
 The hostel could be tolerated for a month or so and during the interlude I would concentrate all my efforts on finding somewhere more permanent to live. 
 The money I was going to save on rent over the  next month could be put towards a deposit on something &mdash; always assuming the Department of Employment did eventually pay me my due &mdash; and then I would be able to start again. 
 Things could, I decided, be worse. 
 The place that my landlord had recommended was the Palace Hotel. 
 Now the Palace Hotel was many, many things, but it wasn't, by any stretch of the imagination, a palace &mdash; or, frankly, a hotel. 
 This much I could see from the outside when I went down to have a look at it. 
 I went in, explained the position I was in and asked if I could see one of the rooms. 
 &bquo;What do you think this place is, love, the Ritz? 
 It's either take it or leave it.&equo; 
 I passed over the cheque my landlord had given me. 
 He examined it carefully. 
 &bquo;If this bounces, you're out on your ear, OK?&equo; 
 &bquo;We're both going to have to trust him. 
 May I see the room now?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's up to you, you've paid for it.&equo; 
 He handed me over a key. 
 &bquo;But listen, I don't take that kind of lip from anyone, understood?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sorry if I offended you. 
 I've had a rather difficult time of it of late and it may be affecting my attitude to people.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've heard every story in the book, darling. 
 Your room's on the first floor.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're welcome.&equo;  
 When I saw the room, I immediately wanted to call the whole thing off, but the chap already had the cheque and I was on a hiding to nothing with my landlord so I would just have to put up with it. 
 &bquo;It's only temporary,&equo; I kept telling myself. 
 I went back downstairs. 
 &bquo;I'll move in tomorrow,&equo; I told the man on the desk. 
 &bquo;As you like,&equo; he said. 
 The following day I hired a van, loaded up my possessions and then handed over my keys to the landlord. 
 It was a rather extraordinary moment. 
 Stripped of his power to inflict harm on me, he seemed terribly ordinary. 
 He promised to forward my mail and wished me luck. 
 I wished him farewell and left without further ceremony. 
 As I walked down the front steps for the last time, a feeling of elation swept over me. 
 I could put all that fear behind me now and get going again. 
 After I'd checked to make sure that the back of the van was locked, I jumped up into the driver's seat and rammed the key into the ignition. 
 &bquo;OK baby, let's roll,&equo; I said, and with a roar and a lurch, I was on my way. 
 There were two scheduled stops on my journey: the first was a company that was going to hold my bulkier items in storage (a firm that my now ex-landlord had told me about which had some spare space in a  lock-up in a basement car park); the second was of course the Palace Hotel where I was going to drop off everything else. 
 It was when I got back to my new room there that I first came across my new neighbours, Jane and Mark Walsh, and their two children, Sonja and Darren. 
 I caught my first glimpse of Jane through their open door. 
 She was trying to straighten an anorak around Sonja's pitifully slight frame. 
 Sonja was as usual being difficult and her mother was trying to strike an impossible balance between calming her down and getting her to do as she was told. 
 &bquo;This is a zoo,&equo; I muttered to myself, failing to realize that I was now also supposedly less than human. 
 I dumped my things and then left again. 
 After returning the van to the hire company, I went for a long walk in Hyde Park. 
 It started to rain so I went down to Apsley House at the bottom right-hand corner of the park with the intention of having a look at the paintings there. 
 However, there was an entrance fee and I was beyond the stage of paying those so I decided to try and shelter somewhere else. 
 The question was where? 
 I couldn't afford anywhere to hide &mdash; what was happening to me? 
 In the end, I trudged down to Victoria railway station and sheltered there. 
 By early evening, I was just too bored to stick the place any longer so I went back to the hotel. 
 When I arrived back outside my room, I met Jane coming along the corridor from the other direction, clutching little Darren in her arms. 
 She smiled. 
 &bquo;Hello,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'm Jane Walsh &mdash; I hear you've just moved in next door.&equo; 
 She was so extraordinarily pleasant it knocked me quite off my balance. 
 &bquo;Er, yes,&equo; I said, and I offered her my hand. 
 &bquo;Dorothy Streeter.&equo;  
 The handshake was a stupid idea as she was still holding Darren, but she let him slide down to the floor and we shook. 
 &bquo;How long have the council told you you've got to wait?&equo; 
 &bquo;Council?&equo; 
 &bquo;You are homeless, aren't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, yes. 
 Yes, I suppose I am.&equo; 
 Suddenly I felt extraordinarily relieved. 
 I'd accepted that I'd joined the club &mdash; and there were some really nice people in it. 
 &bquo;Aren't you on the council-house waiting list then?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, not yet. 
 They haven't even got my benefits sorted out. 
 Look, you must excuse my appalling manners. 
 Would you like to come round for a cup of tea?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ooh, that would be lovely. 
 Let me get the little ones to bed and I'll be right round.&equo; 
 Everything of mine at that stage was still packed, but I had set aside a separate box for tea and coffee things so tea was easy to arrange. 
 &bquo;This is where they herd the humans, girl,&equo; I said to myself. 
 &bquo;You're the same as them. 
 Stop thinking you're some great displaced intellectual all the time. 
 You're a human being, just like everyone else. 
 Why have you never been able to accept that?&equo; 
 After about half an hour, Jane reappeared. 
 &bquo;They get worse and worse, those kids,&equo; she said, forcing a smile. 
 &bquo;Oh, you haven't had a chance to unpack. 
 Do you want me to come back another time, I &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no. 
 Sit down. 
 Excuse the mess.&equo; 
 Jane laughed. 
 &bquo;If you want to see a real mess, try our bathroom. 
 Have you seen it yet?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, the pleasure still awaits me. 
 Milk and sugar?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, please. 
 One please.&equo; 
 Jane sat in the chair. 
 I passed her a cup and then perched on the bed with mine. 
 &bquo;So how did you end up here?&equo; she asked me.  
 I told her the story. 
 &bquo;There's not a lot you can do when you come across someone like that,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;These days anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;Man is the hunter; woman is his game: The sleek and shining creatures of the chase.&equo; 
 &bquo;What was that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Tennyson,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;A bit inappropriate perhaps.&equo; 
 &bquo;How do you know about Tennyson?&equo; she asked, smiling. 
 &bquo;I used to teach. 
 A long time ago now though. 
 I'm a cleaner now.&equo; 
 &bquo;I bet you'd never leave a place in a state like this!&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;I still can't believe I'm here, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, it's hard at first. 
 Mind you, this place is just average as hostels go. 
 Average-sized rooms, average-sized cockroaches &mdash; watch out for them, by the way.&equo; 
 I grimaced. 
 &bquo;How about you,&equo; I asked. 
 &bquo;How did you get here?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mark used to work in the newspaper industry, but he got kicked out when they brought in all the new technology you hear about. 
 When that happened, we couldn't keep up with the mortgage payments so we lost the house.&equo; 
 &bquo;Couldn't he find another job?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not with a big enough wage, that was the problem. 
 Not at all, actually. 
 He's got a bad knee and without the union to keep him out of hard physical work he's stuck really &mdash; he's got no qualifications or anything.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;You must think the whole world's against you at the moment.&equo; 
 &bquo;We'd be happy with just a council flat but there aren't any going these days. 
 I mean, I'm not saying I want us to be living at the top of a tower block on some vandalized estate but there's more to life than this, I know there is.&equo;  
 &bquo;How long have you got to wait before they'll offer you something?&equo; 
 &bquo;They said it would be as soon as possible &mdash; but it takes years for some people. 
 Mark's getting registered as a disabled person, which should help speed things up, but I don't really know, I reckon the world just wants to forget about us.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've got two children, haven't you? 
 Or have you got more?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just the two. 
 Little Darren gets ill really easily at the moment and as for Sonja, she's just gone mental &mdash; I can't understand her any more. 
 It's being cooped up in this place I know, but her brain is just&hellip;&equo; 
 She fell silent and a tear started to run down her cheek. 
 I saw her as she was: a mother unable to protect her children. 
 &bquo;There just doesn't seem to be an end to it,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, look at me crying like this.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's all right, it's good to have a cry sometimes. 
 Would you like some more tea?&equo; 
 She smiled through her tears. 
 &bquo;Thanks, I'd love another one,&equo; she said. 
 I gave us both a refill. 
 &bquo;I like the way you called your children Sonja and Darren,&equo; I informed her. 
 &bquo;One Russian, one American &mdash; that was very diplomatic.&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;I hadn't thought of it like that. 
 I'll have to remember that one for Mark.&equo; 
 The tears on her face were a different colour now. 
 &bquo;How about a Chinese name for the next one?&equo; 
 I suggested. 
 &bquo;Everyone would think I'd been messing around! 
 I'd like another one, actually, but I can't see it happening now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look on the bright side. 
 You managed two more than I did.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've never been married then?&equo;  
 &bquo;No, I've kept myself to myself for most of my life. 
 It's funny, I was just thinking. 
 This is the first time I've had someone round to tea in years, and it happens on the very day I become homeless. 
 How do you explain that?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's been the other way around with us. 
 We used to have lots of friends but they all seem to have gone now.&equo; 
 &bquo;That happened to me when I first became unemployed, oh nearly nine years ago now&hellip;&equo; 
 The conversation continued for a couple of hours. 
 The Walshes had been caught in a strange yet powerful trap and it was difficult to see how they were going to be able to break free. 
 That night I lay awake, listening to the sound of children crying and thinking hard about the position that I myself was now in. 
 It made me feel very afraid. 
 I was homeless. 
 In less than a year I would reach retirement age and I had nothing to fall back on. 
 I was now at the mercy of others and nobody in a position of authority had, so far, shown any great desire to help. 
 For the next few days I was horribly inactive, gripped by a lethargy that I could not for the life of me understand. 
 Fear was there, certainly, and also an inability to come to terms with what had happened, but there was something more. 
 I see now that finally, critically, and most insidiously of all, I had started to lose my self-respect. 
 &bquo;You deserve this,&equo; I remember telling myself. 
 &bquo;This is all down to you, girl, and don't you dare forget it.&equo; 
 As the days went by, I did start to try the newspapers and job centres again &mdash; anywhere in fact that I thought might find me either a job or a home. 
 However, a new home was now the big one. 
 Ironically, the hostel was charging so much in rent that while I did have to stay there, I was better off on the dole with the housing  people picking up the bill than in cleaning work and having to pay it myself. 
 &bquo;It's a joke isn't it?&equo; 
 Jane said one day. 
 &bquo;The guy who owns this place is milking the system and we're stuck here. 
 The government would save so much money in the long run if they built us all homes instead of putting us up in this dump; it's ridiculous.&equo; 
 &bquo;Council housing doesn't fit in with their way of thinking, that's all it is. 
 Throughout history you come across stacks of politicians who would rather let any number of people suffer than admit to one lousy mistake of their own &mdash; they're in all parties, not just our current lot.&equo; 
 &bquo;They should all be forced to spend a week here &mdash; it would do them a world of good.&equo; 
 &bquo;It might do some, but it's a week here with nowhere to go afterwards that's the real problem.&equo; 
 Jane laughed. 
 &bquo;They'd probably need to go for a week in the Bahamas afterwards, just to get over it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Or forget about it.&equo; 
 My next move was a desperate one. 
 I'd had enough. 
 I had to get away. 
 Go somewhere. 
 Anywhere! 
 Although I hadn't seen her in over thirty years, there was one person in the world who might help me: my sister. 
 This is the most difficult part of my story for me to tell. 
 I have made one promise to myself about this book. 
 I am going to send it to Sarah when it's finished and the final word on its fate will be hers. 
 I have somehow to make the biggest and most important, heartfelt apology of my life. 
 I don't know how to do it &mdash; I never have known. 
 But I have to try. 
 I don't know how to approach this, but this is me, Sarah, your pathetically vile big sister, not able to find the words, but hoping you can see what I'm trying to do &mdash; what I'm trying to say &mdash; and please, please believe me when I say that I'm not trying to run away from what I've done, but if I  could change somehow &mdash; obliterate &mdash; one thing I've done in my life, one truly awful thing that I have done, it would be this. 
 This is what happened. 
 I remember being insanely jealous of Sarah when she got married. 
 It was as though I had been deprived of my rights, as elder sister, to the first go at something. 
 However, there was more to it than that. 
 There were no decent men on my own horizons and I already feared that I would be spending my life alone. 
 At the wedding, everyone but everyone came up to me to say, &bquo;It won't be long before it's your turn too,&equo; or something similar, and each time somebody said it, I grew increasingly resentful. 
 In those days, spinsterhood was seen as a mark of personal inadequacy, and I, as they probably all realized, was being left on the shelf. 
 Sarah fairly quickly became pregnant. 
 Despite this happy event, the marriage seemingly got off to a rocky start. 
 I saw a lot of both her and John in those days as I saw my parents most weekends and they often went round on Sundays as well. 
 John and I got on &mdash; and I was happy to join in with the general &bquo;Sarah's being difficult&equo; refrain. 
 I don't want to make a meal of this. 
 John came around to my flat after work one day, one thing led to another and we went to bed together. 
 The affair lasted about three weeks then he broke it off and confessed to Sarah that he had been seeing someone else. 
 She apparently threatened to leave him unless he told her who the person was. 
 Anyway, he told her. 
 I know about this bit from a telephone call from John &mdash; and I can still remember the click as the line went dead at the end of that conversation. 
 That, I knew, was it as far as my family was concerned. 
 My mother came up to London the very next day and told me that I was never to go home again, I was never to contact Sarah again and, above all, I was never, ever to see John again. 
  She brought with her in the car anything of mine that she had been able to find in the house (plus a few things that just reminded her of me) and they were all dumped in my front hall. 
 &bquo;What about Dad?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's as upset as the rest of us, naturally.&equo; 
 &bquo;But doesn't he even want to say goodbye? 
 I mean &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;He is no longer your father and you are no longer his daughter. 
 That's all there is to it.&equo; 
 My father did in fact sneak up to see me a few days later. 
 He confirmed that he did think it would be for the best if I dropped out of family life, and in my heart, I knew he was right. 
 It was the only time I can ever remember seeing him with tears in his eyes. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Daddy, I didn't mean anything, I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I know, pet. 
 If you ever need anything, you know&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I know.&equo; 
 Sarah sent me a Christmas card that year. 
 In it, she told me she'd had a daughter. 
 Her note ended with the words: &bquo;I know it's not all your fault. 
 I wanted you to know that. 
 Love, Sarah.&equo; 
 It must have taken her an awful lot to write those words, and they were why I felt I could go back and see her now. 
 My sister still lives in Berkhamsted, where she and I had grown up and where she and John had subsequently made their home. 
 A very old friend of the family wrote to me when each of my parents died, and from her I had learnt that Sarah had decided to have no more children after Emma, and that Emma had gone to medical school so she is presumably now a doctor somewhere. 
 My parents both died before I left the School of Italian Studies so I had heard nothing about my family for over ten years. 
 However, I knew that Sarah and John had to be still around. 
 On the Saturday of my third weekend at the Palace Hotel I looked their address  up in one of the telephone directories in my local library. 
 On the Sunday, late morning, I took a train up to see them. 
 I resolved to explain the situation to them as briefly as possible, make a plea for money and then very rapidly leave. 
 The train arrived at Berkhamsted station. 
 Although their house was still some distance away, I decided to finish the journey on foot. 
 It was a walk full of surprises. 
 So much had changed, so much was new, and yet so much was still my childhood Berkhamsted. 
 I was so caught up in what I was seeing that it was only when I reached the top of the close where they lived that I started to think again about what I was doing there, and it was then that my feelings of fear started. 
 I slowly made my way down the road. 
 Sarah's house was at the other end of it and I could see a couple of cars parked outside what I was sure was their home. 
 Maybe Emma was visiting for the weekend? 
 Maybe some other friends had come over? 
 It hadn't occurred to me that Sarah and John might not be alone, but here, now, I would have to be introduced and explained away somehow. 
 What did Emma know about me? 
 What on earth would she think of me? 
 I suddenly became aware of what a mess I looked. 
 Why was I doing this to them? 
 I thought I saw someone moving in the front room. 
 Instinctively I turned away, and then I realized I was walking in the opposite direction, then running, almost tripping over my own two flat feet. 
 Soon I was round the corner again and on my way back to the station. 
 Tears were flowing down my face. 
 There were no old memories around me now, just the blur of a new and frightening world. 
 When I arrived at the station, I took the next train back to London. 
 A new plan of action started to take shape. 
 I would go to Rome; Rome, where I had spent so many happy days in the past, would be my final  resting place. 
 I hadn't enough money to get there by conventional means but no matter. 
 Once I'd got on to the continent I'd walk there if I had to. 
 There was nothing left for me now &mdash; nothing. 
 I arrived back at the Palace Hotel and started to pack. 
 There was just my two suitcases and my travelling bag. 
 The suitcases I would check in at the left-luggage office at Paddington station, the bag could come with me to Rome, and Jane could inherit all my bits and bobs. 
 &bquo;Rome? 
 Why Rome?&equo; she asked when I popped round with the box of odd things to say goodbye. 
 &bquo;I've got friends there,&equo; I replied. 
 (I meant buildings, not people.) 
 &bquo;A holiday's probably just the thing for you, you know. 
 How long are you going to be gone for?&equo; 
 &bquo;For good.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mean you're moving there?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sort of.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hey, look, you are going to be OK, aren't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sorry &mdash; my way of talking. 
 Look, I've brought you some things so you can have a cuppa on me. 
 There's also a wristwatch in there somewhere. 
 It's in a dark-blue case. 
 It was given to me as a present so I'd feel funny about selling it myself, but you could maybe buy a pair of shoes for Sonja with it or something. 
 The rest is just junk, really, I &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;What's going on, Dorothy? 
 What's been happening? 
 You look really pale, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've had enough and I'm going to try my luck in a country I can actually understand. 
 If that's a sign of madness, I've gone completely crazy, but it can't be worse than this. 
 Look, could you grab hold of this box before my arms drop off?&equo; 
 She took hold of it and put it down on the floor. 
 Then she looked me in the eye and smiled. 
 &bquo;You seem to think you know what you're doing,&equo;  she said. 
 &bquo;It does sound crazy to me, though, I'll grant you. 
 Who was the watch from?&equo; 
 &bquo;A mad professor I used to know. 
 I reckon it's done all it can for me now.&equo; 
 &bquo;When are you going?&equo; 
 &bquo;Now. 
 I'm all packed up and ready for off.&equo; 
 &bquo;Will you at least let me walk you down to the station?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course.&equo; 
 Mark reappeared from somewhere. 
 &bquo;Dorothy's off to visit some friends in Italy,&equo; Jane told him. 
 &bquo;She's going to try her luck out there.&equo; 
 &bquo;How are you going to get to Italy?&equo; he asked me. 
 &bquo;Hike, I suppose.&equo; 
 He grinned. 
 &bquo;You're mental, Dot. 
 Lovable, mind you, but mental.&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;I'd best be going,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I'll need to check out first and then dump some things at Paddington before I go.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've paid in advance for another week or so, right?&equo; 
 Jane interjected. 
 &bquo;Yes, why?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, why not leave the keys with us and then if you can't get away, you can perhaps come back here &mdash; or if everything goes OK we'll use it as a playroom or something.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine by me, but won't Bryant smell a rat when he sees me walking out with all this?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well you can say you're visiting relatives or something. 
 If you've already paid for the room, what's it to him?&equo; 
 I smiled, and was lost in thought for a moment. 
 &bquo;Will you let us give you a hand with your bags, Dot?&equo; 
 Mark asked. 
 &bquo;What about your knee?&equo;  
 He grinned again. 
 &bquo;I'll carry the little one,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You girls can take the others.&equo; 
 We laughed. 
 There was quite a gang of us that went down to the station &mdash; four Walshes and me. 
 Fortunately Bryant wasn't at his desk so no awkward questions were asked. 
 The walk to Paddington was a comparatively short one and, slow as we were, we accomplished it in fairly quick time. 
 Once we were in the main concourse, I put down my suitcase and turned to say goodbye. 
 Jane and I embraced. 
 &bquo;Good luck, girl,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I really hope there's something out there for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bernini's out there,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Is Bernini a he or a she?&equo; 
 Mark asked. 
 &bquo;A he &mdash; but it's not what you're thinking.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why not? 
 I'd go for it if I were you,&equo; he said, and he gave me a little peck on the cheek. 
 The children waved solemnly and we all said our final farewells. 
 I watched them go and then went to check in my suitcases. 
 &bquo;I'm going to miss them,&equo; I missed to myself. 
 It was time to get going. 
 I made my way down into the tube station and on towards the Circle Line. 
 My destination was Victoria station where I would try and catch a boat-train to France. 
 Victoria, however, brought disappointment. 
 The next boat-train was to Ostend &mdash; a bit further north than I had anticipated travelling, but that wasn't the problem. 
 The problem was a very narrow entrance to the platform and a very efficient-looking ticket inspector. 
 I decided to try the &bquo;little old lady who's lost her ticket&equo; routine, but I was rumbled immediately and directed politely but firmly to the station manager's office. 
 I stayed for a while about twenty paces away from the platform barrier, numbed by the realization that I had fallen at the first hurdle. 
 But no I hadn't, not  necessarily. 
 There was another boat-train service that left from Liverpool Street station on the Harwich to the Hook of Holland run. 
 Why not give that one a go? 
 Without really still thinking that I had any chance of success, I went back down to the Circle Line and journeyed on to Liverpool Street. 
 When I arrived there, there was a train for Harwich just about to leave. 
 Again, there was a problem of a ticket barrier, but this time someone in front of me was arguing with the inspector so I was able to pass unhindered. 
 I remember my feeling of elation when I climbed aboard the train. 
 In no time at all it jerked forward, and there I was, on my way. 
 It wasn't long before the guard came to see us. 
 &bquo;Tickets, please.&equo; 
 Dutifully, I looked in my bag. 
 &bquo;I'm terribly sorry, I don't seem to be able to find mine.&equo; 
 I could see in his eyes that he knew. 
 &bquo;Where are you thinking of going, love?&equo; 
 &bquo;Rome.&equo; 
 &bquo;Eh?&equo; 
 &bquo;Via Harwich. 
 Would you mind desperately if just this once I paid at the other end?&equo; 
 &bquo;We never met, OK?&equo; 
 And with that he continued on his way. 
 Now that the deed was done, I had a chance to reflect on what was likely to happen. 
 The excitement of the adventure started to dissipate and I was left with the cold reality of knowing that I was on a train with hardly any money, no ticket and nowhere to go. 
 Out of the window I could see darkness falling. 
 It was now early autumn and it would be winter soon. 
 It was starting to look as though, whether I liked it or not, I simply might not survive. 
 We arrived at Harwich Parkeston Quay. 
 I watched  the other passengers go on towards the passport control and the futility of my own expedition was now only too clear. 
 The station cafe was still open so I decided that I might as well go in there. 
 The cafe turned out to be a strange garish world of sandy yellow. 
 I bought my statutory cup of tea and sat down. 
 Gradually my eyes got used to the glare and I was able to make sense of my surroundings. 
 The decor of the place was sort of pastiche California: sandy-coloured walls, low-hanging lights, brightly coloured pop-art posters and a sprinkling of lush green flowerless plants. 
 Artificiality was everywhere. 
 The linoleum tiles in the middle area of the floor were rimmed by some new type of carpet, there was a false ceiling and false blinds had been hung on the walls. 
 The table-tops were imitation wickerwork and there was a pointless trellis pattern on the curtains. 
 Only the flowers in the vase on the table in front of me seemed real. 
 I gazed at them for a while and then buried my head in my hands. 
 &bquo;Why me?&equo; 
 I kept asking myself. 
 &bquo;I know I'm not perfect, but why me? 
 I just don't understand this. 
 This is hopeless. 
 I just can't understand what's going on.&equo;   
 &bquo;Cheer up, love, it may never happen.&equo; 
 I looked up. 
 A chap with short brown hair was smiling down at me. 
 I smiled weakly back. 
 &bquo;I think you'll find, young man, it already has.&equo; 
 &bquo;It can't be as bad as all that.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm afraid it can. 
 Don't worry, I'll be all right.&equo; 
 He went away and I started to look down at my hands again. 
 A few moments later, he returned with a mug of coffee and placed it in front of me. 
 &bquo;Compliments of the chef,&equo; he informed me. 
 I smiled again. 
 &bquo;Thank you,&equo; I said. 
 He went away again. 
 I took the mug in my hands. 
 It was warm, so wonderfully warm. 
 I took a sip and the warmth went down inside me. 
 I took another one and then just sat there, warming my hands on the mug and staring at the coffee. 
 The young man had broken the spell. 
 I was now better able to concentrate and better able to take stock. 
 Travelling on would be impossible. 
 Staying would also be impossible in the long run but that young man would let me stay for a little while &mdash; until the restaurant closed, anyway. 
 That wouldn't be time enough to think but at least it would give me a chance to calm down. 
 After a few minutes, my friend reappeared. 
 &bquo;Something wrong with the coffee?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, it's lovely, thank you.&equo;  
 &bquo;Don't you like coffee, then? 
 I'll get you something else if you like.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;No, really, it's fine. 
 I just wanted to warm my hands a bit that's all.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hang on a sec.&equo; 
 He went over to pick up a coffee for himself, then came back over and sat down. 
 &bquo;Want to talk?&equo; he asked. 
 I smiled again. 
 &bquo;I'd find that a bit difficult at the moment. 
 I've got rather a lot on my mind.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, you do look pretty shaken up about something.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm homeless,&equo; I said, hesitatingly. 
 &bquo;I've got no money and nowhere to go. 
 I came here because I wanted to get away, only&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't worry. 
 We'll try and help you. 
 Just stick around here until we can think of something. 
 We're closing soon, but give us a chance, OK?&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you&hellip; 
 Who are you, if you don't mind me asking?&equo; 
 &bquo;My name's Steve. 
 How about you, what's your name?&equo; 
 &bquo;Dorothy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Like the little girl in The Wizard of Oz , right?&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;And you're Steve,&equo; I said, trying to think of a suitable Steve to name him after. 
 &bquo;Steve Adorable. 
 Steve, the adorable stevedore.&equo; 
 We both laughed. 
 &bquo;That's good, that,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'll remember that one. 
 How come you're homeless anyway?&equo; 
 &bquo;I was kicked out by my landlord and put in this hostel which was just awful and I had to get away so I came here &mdash; I don't know why, really, I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;This was all in London, right?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Sorry, I'm not explaining myself very well, am I?&equo;  
 &bquo;It's all right, I know what you're saying. 
 But why Harwich?&equo; 
 &bquo;They let me on the train.&equo; 
 He grinned. 
 &bquo;You were reckoning on trying your luck abroad, yeah?&equo; 
 &bquo;I had this crazy idea of trying to get to Rome. 
 I used to teach Italian architecture many years ago and, I don't know, I like it there I suppose.&equo; 
 &bquo;You used to be a teacher?&equo; 
 &bquo;I was a university lecturer at one time. 
 That was where Rome came in.&equo; 
 &bquo;You were once a university lecturer? 
 You're joking!&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;No, it's true,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;So how come you're now homeless?&equo; 
 &bquo;It happens. 
 The university bit was nearly ten years ago. 
 I've done more normal jobs since then.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah? 
 Like what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I've been a schoolteacher, a receptionist, a chambermaid, all sorts of things really.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't worry, a lot of people come here with funny stories behind them. 
 Look, you just hang on here a minute, I want to have a word with Katrina about something.&equo; 
 Steve disappeared again. 
 Before long, a young woman appeared: short, with short blonde hair and pale-blue eyes. 
 She brought with her another two cups of coffee and a packet of sandwiches. 
 &bquo;Do you mind if I join you?&equo; she asked. 
 She spoke with a Dutch accent. 
 &bquo;No, not at all. 
 Is all that for me too?&equo; 
 &bquo;The sandwiches are and one of the mugs of coffee. 
 You seem to have been doing rather well out of those.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm building up quite a collection, aren't I? 
 Whereabouts are you from?&equo; 
 &bquo;Near Amsterdam. 
 You?&equo; 
 &bquo;Near London.&equo;  
 She settled down to my right where Steve had just been sitting. 
 &bquo;Try and eat something,&equo; she said, offering me the sandwiches. 
 &bquo;I'm not sure that I can at the moment,&equo; I said apologetically. 
 &bquo;I've got a rather funny feeling at the bottom of my stomach. 
 Thank you, though, it's very kind of you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sure that not eating has been one of your problems,&equo; she informed me. 
 &bquo;Try some, and then if you don't like it, well it's too bad you know.&equo; 
 Dutifully, I took a nibble from one of the sandwiches. 
 &bquo;My name's Katrina by the way.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dorothy,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Dorothy Streeter.&equo; 
 &bquo;I hear things aren't going too well for you at the moment.&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, well, I've nowhere to go and it's causing me something of a problem.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well if you've no place to go you should stay here. 
 Does that sound sensible to you?&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;Eminently,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;But unfortunately I've nowhere to stay here either.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's all right. 
 We'll find a hotel where you can go for the night and then tomorrow you can come back here and talk to Kathleen. 
 She'll know exactly what you should do.&equo; 
 Katrina put her hand on my shoulder. 
 &bquo;Don't worry, Dorothy, you're lucky. 
 There are some really nice people here.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've all been very kind. 
 Look, I've no money for a hotel so I'd better make my own arrangements for tonight. 
 It's not that I want to offend you or anything, I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Whatever you like. 
 But I definitely think you should come and meet Kathleen tomorrow. 
 She's an exceptionally nice woman. 
 It's just, this isn't her shift, you know. 
  Anyway, what is this about you having no money? 
 Are you completely broke at the moment, or&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I've got a little bit, but I don't want to waste it on a hotel. 
 I don't think I'll get much sleep tonight anyway so I might as well save it for food or something.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's up to you,&equo; she said. 
 She looked worried. 
 &bquo;I think we should try and find you something tomorrow, though. 
 Kathleen will know what to do.&equo; 
 She seemed comforted by this thought. 
 Kathleen evidently ran things around here and nothing could be done without her say-so. 
 I had to make a choice, and I decided to trust them. 
 &bquo;What time will Kathleen be here tomorrow?&equo; 
 &bquo;She comes in first thing, but steer clear until about nine o'clock so I can have a chance to explain things.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't want to put you out of your way or anything, I&hellip;&equo; 
 Her hand touched my shoulder again. 
 &bquo;Hey, don't worry about that. 
 You and I have something in common you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;We both only got as far as Harwich.&equo; 
 I smiled and she took her leave. 
 &bquo;You can stay here until we close up for the night,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Then you'd maybe better go into Dovercourt or something. 
 See what you feel like.&equo; 
 She disappeared, then reappeared behind the counter and whispered something to the girl who was on duty there. 
 She in her turn disappeared out the back. 
 Katrina had obviously been assigned to &bquo;Dorothy watch&equo;. 
 I sat quietly for a while finishing my most recent cup of coffee. 
 What was I going to do between then and meeting Kathleen the following morning? 
 There wasn't a lot of choice. 
 The best thing would probably be just to walk around to keep warm and then to snatch a little  rest in a doorway somewhere if need be. 
 One night out wouldn't hurt me, and tomorrow would be another day. 
 The future depended on decisions I could not possibly predict, but at least I had now been offered a shadow of a lifeline, and that, for the moment, would have to do. 
 The catering assistants started to wind down the evening's proceedings, and Katrina and one of the other girls (Bridget) came out from around the back to tidy up the customer area. 
 They started by clearing the tables and arranging the wooden chairs on the fixed padded seats around the wall. 
 Suddenly, Katrina dropped to her knees and began scrabbling around on the floor. 
 &bquo;Chewing gum,&equo; she informed Bridget, picking at it with her fingernails as she did so. 
 Bridget made a sympathetic comment and then went off to busy herself with another chore. 
 Without thinking, I got up and went over to see if I could lend a hand. 
 &bquo;Haven't you got some of that special stuff you can freeze it with?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;Sorry?&equo; 
 &bquo;You can buy some special stuff which freezes it so it comes off more easily. 
 Attacking it with a nailfile is the next best thing &mdash; hang on, I'll show you.&equo; 
 I went back to my handbag to get my nailfile, then returned to where Katrina was kneeling and crouched down beside her. 
 A piece of chewing gum had been trodden into the funny carpet border around the edge of the room. 
 Without further ado, I set to work. 
 It was an absolute brute but eventually I did manage to dig it all out. 
 Katrina was impressed. 
 &bquo;Hey, you're good, you know,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Why don't you give me a hand with the rest of the work? 
 You might enjoy doing something like that.&equo;  
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;Sure,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 Bridget had just fetched the vacuum cleaner. 
 Katrina went over and had a quick word with her, then she beckoned towards me. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, you do the hoovering and I'll finish the tables. 
 Have you ever used one of these before?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Many times.&equo; 
 Bridget looked slightly bemused by the whole thing but wasn't going to argue. 
 She disappeared out the back again and Katrina and I had a blitz on the cleaning, finishing up behind the counter. 
 &bquo;We're a good team, you and me,&equo; she said. 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;Yes, I enjoy this sort of thing. 
 I was never any good at lecturing so it's nice to be good at something.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, Steve said you used to be a university lecturer.&equo; 
 &bquo;That was all a long time ago now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hey, you must be really bright, you know!&equo; 
 I couldn't help laughing at that. 
 &bquo;I was one of their less incandescent members of staff &mdash; they just about kicked me out actually.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't knock yourself. 
 I mean, you use words like &bquo;incandescent&equo; and &bquo;eminently&equo;. 
 I wish I could do that. 
 I'd really like to be able to speak like you, you know. 
 You may be homeless but at least you're not a dumb blonde like I am.&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, is there any more clearing up that needs doing or are you done now?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, it looks OK. 
 Look, you will come back tomorrow, won't you? 
 I mean, promise me that.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll come &mdash; but don't try and put any pressure on this Kathleen of yours. 
 Something like that could easily backfire on you if you're not careful.&equo; 
 She just laughed. 
 &bquo;You wait and see,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You know, Dorothy, I think you're OK. 
 I think if you come  and see us tomorrow, we may yet surprise you. 
 I know we're a bit mad but we try our best.&equo; 
 And with those words ringing inside my head, I went out into the night.  
 Once I was outside, I suddenly felt awfully tired. 
 It had been, I realized, an extremely long and tiring day. 
 I decided to abandon my earlier plan of just walking around until dawn and instead to try and find somewhere where I could get some sleep. 
 I had, as I have said, hardly any money left, so with no new sources of income on the horizon, the sensible thing to do was to sleep rough. 
 I left the station and started down the road to Harwich town. 
 A little way along, I saw a path running up the bank to my left and on the top of this bank there was a rather eccentric mock-Gothic porchway. 
 Curious, I went up the path to have a look at it and I discovered to my no great surprise that it marked the entrance to a churchyard. 
 The porch was only a tiny little thing but at least it had a roof and the floor was clear of rubbish. 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 I thought to myself. 
 I wouldn't be able to stretch out, but at least I could sit there. 
 And it would only be for one night. 
 I had a furtive look round then I went in and settled myself down. 
 The floor was a bit damp but I could put up with that. 
 Waves of sleep then started to wash over me and I dozed fitfully until dawn. 
 The feeling I had when I rose the following morning was a strange one. 
 It was the feeling that I had survived, and that maybe, with help, I was going to continue to  survive. 
 I felt hungry, cold and dirty. 
 Hungry and cold would have to wait until I could go back to the cafe, dirty was obviously going to be more of a problem. 
 I decided that the best thing to do was to leave the porch just in case anyone came along, and to kill the time I needed to kill somewhere else. 
 Going back to the railway station was for the moment out of the question, just in case I bumped into someone who recognized me. 
 What I actually needed to do was somehow to disappear. 
 The memory of those few hours is etched on my mind. 
 They were typical of part of what it was like to be homeless &mdash; having nowhere to go; having to avoid all representatives of authority; feeling tired and generally run-down; and needing to have my wits at their sharpest at a time when they had become critically undernourished. 
 People of all shapes and sizes became my biggest threat and a vital potential source of assistance. 
 And there was all that seemingly interminable, lonely hanging around. 
 Feeling conspicuous &mdash; embarrassed about my very existence but resentful of what had happened. 
 Eventually I ended up in the Sealink arrival lounge. 
 I could have been any little old lady waiting for a relative to arrive from Holland. 
 Nobody was quite sure. 
 In any event, I was a little old lady so I was left in peace. 
 At nine o'clock, on the dot, I went down to the station cafe to face whatever was going to happen. 
 When I arrived at the counter I asked for Katrina. 
 The person on duty disappeared out the back and I went to sit in the same seat where I had sat the night before. 
 It wasn't Katrina who next appeared, it was a slight woman of about my own age, Kathleen. 
 She stood for a moment on the other side of the room, sizing me up (and me sizing her up), and then she came over to speak to me. 
 &bquo;Hello, you must be Dorothy.&equo;  
 &bquo;Yes, that's right.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm Kathleen Harris. 
 I think we'd better have a talk. 
 Would you like some tea?&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, yes, thank you.&equo; 
 The inevitable two cups of tea appeared and Kathleen sat down. 
 &bquo;So what happened to you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I became homeless in London so I got on a train and ended up here; that's all there is to it, really.&equo; 
 &bquo;How did you lose your home?&equo; 
 &bquo;My landlord chucked me out. 
 He put me up in a hostel, but it was filthy and I&hellip;, 
 &bquo;You're shaking, girl. 
 Have some of that tea. 
 It might calm you down a bit.&equo; 
 I sipped the tea. 
 &bquo;You said you were thrown out by your landlord. 
 How did that happen?&equo; 
 I told her the story. 
 &bquo;Why couldn't the police have helped you?&equo; 
 &bquo;In court it would have been his word against mine, so what can you do? 
 Anyway he owned the place and in most people's eyes he had every right to chuck me out. 
 Me being made homeless is a minor detail.&equo; 
 She patted me on the shoulder. 
 &bquo;Cheer up. 
 You're still in one piece. 
 &bquo;This is all rather difficult for me,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I don't like being a burden on people like this.&equo; 
 &bquo;How much money have you got left?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just over eight pounds.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you on social security?&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;Sort of. 
 My benefits have been suspended.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why on earth has that happened?&equo; 
 &bquo;They think it's a computer error &mdash; but they're still checking on it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can't you get an emergency payment of some sort?&equo;  
 &bquo;Not any more. 
 They're cutting back on those, apparently.&equo; 
 Kathleen looked stumped. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; she said, &bquo;somehow you need to get back inside the system. 
 I tell you what I'll do. 
 I'll give the Salvation Army a ring and see if they can help you. 
 At least they'll know &mdash;&equo; 
 I raised a hand. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Please, no.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 I was silent for a moment. 
 &bquo;Thank you for trying,&equo; I said slowly, &bquo;but I don't really see that there's anything you can do to help. 
 I think it would be best if I went somewhere else.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where are you thinking of going?&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;To see my favourite fountain,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, you're not thinking straight. 
 Have you had any breakfast this morning?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, look. 
 I'll get you some sandwiches and some more tea and once you've eaten we can get down to some practical thinking about what you can do next.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't want to impose on you people, I&hellip;&equo; 
 She'd gone to get the food. 
 She called out to me from across the room. 
 &bquo;I'm not sure what you'd like. 
 How does ham and egg sound?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine, really I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Tea or coffee?&equo; 
 &bquo;Coffee, please. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 She came back with what I'd asked for. 
 &bquo;Right. 
 I'll catch up with you again in a few minutes. 
 No, better still, I'll stay here to stop you running away.&equo; 
 She fetched herself a packet of sandwiches from the counter and then came back to where she had been sitting. 
 &bquo;Feed the fever, starve the cold and stuff the diet, that's what I say.&equo;  
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;I've actually lost quite a bit of weight recently,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Every cloud, as they say.&equo; 
 &bquo;Someone should send Katrina on a cookery course. 
 These are terrible!&equo; 
 &bquo;She's a good-un that one. 
 What's the story behind her?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, she's been here since the beginning of the year &mdash; she came over to start a new life after she'd had problems back home. 
 I hear you gave her hand with the clearing up last night.&equo; 
 &bquo;She was having trouble with a piece of chewing gum and it was my way of saying thank you. 
 I used to be a professional cleaner &mdash; I don't want to get her into any trouble, I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm glad she had the presence of mind to help you. 
 Are you about to retire or something? 
 I still can't quite work out how this all adds up.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I'm still looking for work. 
 I'm sixty next year but I'd like to carry on for as long as possible.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sixty-one, don't worry. 
 Can't you get some more cleaning work or something?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's not only the age problem. 
 I left my last job in rather strange circumstances and that doesn't help things.&equo; 
 &bquo;What happened?&equo; 
 I told her that story. 
 &bquo;You've been in the wars rather, haven't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;All these things recently, I don't know if it's just bad luck or me being stupid or what.&equo; 
 &bquo;You being poor seems to be the immediate problem.&equo; 
 &bquo;How am I supposed to start again at fifty-nine? 
 I want to work again &mdash; to keep up my self-respect more than anything else &mdash; but it's been finding somewhere to live. 
 It's been hopeless. 
 I can't explain it to you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where did you sleep last night?&equo; 
 &bquo;In a folly.&equo;  
 &bquo;In a madhouse! 
 Where?&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;No, in a Gothic folly &mdash; a porchway somewhere. 
 Sorry, a folly is a technical term I used to use in my art history days. 
 I wasn't thinking.&equo; 
 &bquo;This was at the church just down the road from here?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, it was the best I could do at short notice.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've just remembered something. 
 I'm sorry to have to ask you this, but are you an alcoholic at all?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 She was silent for a moment. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; she then began by saying, &bquo;there must be some sort of council accommodation for people like you. 
 I'll check to see what's on offer and in the meantime, how would you like a day's pay here?&equo; 
 &bquo;How do you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well I've got a couple of people off so we're down this morning. 
 A bit more cash in your purse might be a good idea and you said you wanted to work. 
 How about it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you. 
 That's very kind of you.&equo; 
 &bquo;As I say, I'll ring up the town hall and see what they say. 
 The situation might not be as hopeless as you think.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;You're welcome to try,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;But don't get too upset if you don't get anywhere. 
 I'm not expecting anything.&equo; 
 &bquo;You won't survive without hope, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;That depends on what you mean by hope.&equo; 
 She smiled. 
 &bquo;Yes, I suppose it does. 
 Come on. 
 Come and meet the rest of the crew.&equo; 
 The morning crew were a little surprised to find they had a new colleague but none of them was unduly perturbed by the intrusion. 
 I spent the rest of the morning being shown some of the routine duties of a catering assistant. 
 The shift was in fact half over by the time I  started and I wasn't really able to do much of any value. 
 Despite this, at lunchtime Kathleen presented me with four hours' pay and pressed me for a few more details to help her with her enquiries. 
 &bquo;The room you've got at the Palace Hotel is causing something of a problem,&equo; she informed me. 
 &bquo;Technically you should go back there, but I think you've already decided against that.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you'd ever been there you'd know why.&equo; 
 She was silent for a moment. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, I don't know quite how to put this, but is there something you're not telling me that might help me understand this a bit better. 
 It's just, you're my idea of someone who this sort of thing would never happen to. 
 I mean, you've got an education, you're prepared to work, you've got the right background and everything&hellip; if you could explain more I might be able to help more.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's simple. 
 I ran out of money and places to stay. 
 That's all it took.&equo; 
 I could feel tears welling up in my eyes. 
 &bquo;It's not what you're thinking, Kathleen, I haven't done anything wrong &mdash; I promise you. 
 I'm just homeless, that's all. 
 Find me a home and I'll be fine. 
 I can find the job. 
 Look at all the things I've done &mdash; I'm not being choosy. 
 All it took was this fifty-pound note and people not giving me another chance&hellip;&equo; 
 She reached out to touch me again. 
 &bquo;OK, OK, I'm sorry. 
 Look, I've got to get back to some people I spoke to this morning. 
 Keep your chin up, girl, we're not lost yet.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;A bit homeless maybe.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's the spirit. 
 Give me until five o'clock this evening. 
 See what you think of Harwich in the meantime.&equo; 
 I wandered off to Harwich. 
 The walk was a bit up hill and down dale and it rather tired me out. 
 One memory stands out &mdash; the sound of a child crying which  I heard when I was walking past some flats. 
 It made me think of the Palace Hotel. 
 &bquo;How far have I really got?&equo; 
 I wondered. 
 &bquo;And where do I go now!&equo; 
 The thing that I found most striking about Harwich was that there was so much sky around. 
 In comparison with London, everything seemed to be in miniature. 
 I felt like Gulliver in Lilliput &mdash; or maybe Mother Courage in Toytown. 
 When I arrived back at the cafe, I found Kathleen in a perplexed mood. 
 &bquo;The system seems to be rather inflexible,&equo; she said testily. 
 &bquo;I had hoped that I might be able to find you some accommodation around here, but apparently it's the duty of your local council in London to rehouse you and nobody else wants to pick up the bill.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well Kensington isn't going to do a lot either so that solves that problem.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why are they being so inefficient?&equo; 
 &bquo;Saves them money, as you say.&equo; 
 She was silent for a moment. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;The best thing for all of us is for me just to go back to London. 
 If there is a solution to all this, that's where I'll find it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where will you go?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 But&hellip; 
 &equo; I couldn't think of anything else to say. 
 I looked at my feet and Kathleen turned away. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I need to have another think about this. 
 I've only known you since first thing this morning and I haven't had time to take everything in. 
 The thing that I'd like to do and that I really wish I could do is give you a job here but Personnel have said I'm already fully staffed.&equo; 
 She turned back to face me. 
 &bquo;I want to help you, Dorothy. 
 I want you to believe that. 
 Can you give me one more day to come up with something? 
 I'll  sleep on it tonight and tomorrow we'll go all out to get you somewhere. 
 Is that all right?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure,&equo; I said with a smile. 
 &bquo;But I'll make a deal with you. 
 We'll give it your one more day and then I'll go and plague someone else.&equo; 
 &bquo;How will you spend tonight?&equo; 
 &bquo;Alone.&equo; 
 She smiled. 
 &bquo;I'll see you tomorrow,&equo; she said. 
 There were an awful lot of tedious hours for me to kill that evening. 
 I went back to the porch and hid my night bag behind a headstone and then left for another long walk to Harwich. 
 That second night in the porch was enough and I resolved to move on the following day, whatever happened. 
 The following morning at nine o'clock I went back to the coffee shop, just to show that I was still around. 
 &bquo;How did you sleep?&equo; 
 Kathleen asked me. 
 &bquo;Not too well. 
 You?&equo; 
 &bquo;Hardly at all. 
 I'd better get on with my telephoning. 
 Why don't you stop here for the morning? 
 I'll get you some magazines. 
 It's a bit chilly out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you. 
 That would be nice.&equo; 
 She rejoined me at lunchtime and seemed in more optimistic mood. 
 &bquo;The basic position is this,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;The best bet looks to be you going into a Salvation Army hostel, them sorting out your benefits, and you using the hostel as a base from which to find something else. 
 It won't be the greatest place you've ever lived, I know, but at least it's going to be dry and&hellip;&equo; 
 I was shaking my head. 
 &bquo;What's the problem?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Look, you've got to get back inside the system somehow.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know what it's like in there and I'm not sure it's a place I want to be.&equo; 
 &bquo;What are you saying?&equo;  
 &bquo;I'm saying I'm not spending the rest of my life in a Salvation Army hostel or a DHSS hotel or any other kind of hostel. 
 I have that choice.&equo; 
 &bquo;But it would only be temporary.&equo; 
 &bquo;Until when?&equo; 
 &bquo;Until they can find you a council flat.&equo; 
 &bquo;But the days of them are gone.&equo; 
 &bquo;There are still some going and you're bound to get preferential treatment of some sort.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why? 
 Because I've had to spend a couple of nights in a porchway?&equo; 
 &bquo;Because you're a genuine case.&equo; 
 I laughed at that. 
 &bquo;The hostels of London are stuffed full of genuine cases. 
 Why pick on me?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well with us backing you we might be able to swing something. 
 You've got to be positive, or you'll never get out of this mess.&equo; 
 I paused for a moment, then said, &bquo;Kathleen, let me tell you what I think would happen if I did as you say and then you tell me where I'm going wrong. 
 I go into a Salvation Army hostel right, and then that's it, problem solved. 
 What was that you said? 
 &bquo;At least it's going to be dry.&equo; 
 Well that's what everybody is going to think. 
 She blew it and at least we've given her somewhere out of the cold. 
 Well I'm sorry but that's not good enough. 
 Look at how wealthy this country is. 
 Look at all the billions that have come in from North Sea oil and privatization. 
 Look at all this new technology there is around now, and then tell me we can't afford to give everyone a proper home. 
 Why should I let society off the hook by accepting rubbish when it's more than within their means to treat me with dignity?&equo; 
 &bquo;But maybe society isn't going to treat you with dignity, maybe that's all gone now.&equo; 
 &bquo;And you're prepared to accept that.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right. 
 So you're stuck with rubbish. 
 Or rather  you're stuck with a lot less than you could have. 
 But these Salvation Army people will at least try. 
 They'll do their best. 
 There may not be much they can do, but what else is there going for you now?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Exactly.&equo; 
 &bquo;That doesn't make it right.&equo; 
 She paused to think. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry if you think I'm getting at you, Kathleen. 
 I'm not. 
 But before I go, I wanted you to understand what's happened to me. 
 The welfare state doesn't work any more. 
 That wartime spirit has gone now. 
 What's that expression you hear youngsters using now? 
 Looking after number one. 
 That's how it's become. 
 Progress is not inevitable. 
 People forget things. 
 Things can get worse and that's what's happening now.&equo; 
 She was still thinking. 
 &bquo;There were a lot of problems with the welfare state,&equo; I said, &bquo;but that was no reason for trying to do away with it.&equo; 
 I could see an idea coming into Kathleen's head. 
 &bquo;Blow this!&equo; she said suddenly. 
 &bquo;You might have a point here somewhere. 
 Look, can you give me another couple of hours? 
 I want to try something.&equo; 
 &bquo;OK, sure.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have you ever seen Les Mis&eacute;rables ?&equo; 
 &bquo;Pardon?&equo; 
 &bquo; Les Mis&eacute;rables , the musical.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, why do you ask?&equo; 
 &bquo;Early on in that, the hero's homeless and somebody puts him up for the night.&equo; 
 She looked me straight in the eye. 
 &bquo;I don't have the courage to do that, Dorothy.&equo; 
 There was a pause. 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;Neither would I,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;What's this new scheme of yours?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll tell you later.&equo; 
 I wandered around for a bit and then came back  again. 
 I bought myself a mug of tea at the counter in order to pay for something for a change, then I sat and waited for Kathleen. 
 About half an hour later she reappeared. 
 She looked, I don't know, determined, that would probably be the best way of putting it. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, do you remember a story in the news some time ago about a chap who had somebody who was homeless living in the shed at the bottom of his garden?&equo; 
 &bquo;Kathleen, if you think I'm going to live in the shed at the bottom of your garden you're&hellip;, 
 She raised a hand. 
 &bquo;No, no, don't worry. 
 It's slightly better than that. 
 Listen, let me start at the beginning. 
 I've had another word with Personnel and they say that even though I can't have any more full-timers, I can have a part-timer to help me with making the sandwiches in the morning and clearing up last thing at night. 
 All we have to do is combine the two. 
 You work here for an hour at either end of the day, sleep in this funny little store place I've found you and during the day you can try and find something more normal. 
 Once you've got a little bit of a base, you'll be able to get going again. 
 What do you say?&equo; 
 I was stunned &mdash; absolutely stunned. 
 The scheme had an interior logic to it but in order to see it you had to be, let me see, stark raving mad, I suppose. 
 &bquo;What do you mean by a &bquo;funny little store place&equo; exactly! 
 &bquo;I've got the key, come and see.&equo; 
 I think the exact location of this store room should remain a secret. 
 Anyway, we arrived there. 
 &bquo;It belongs to the Customs and Excise mob,&equo; she told me. 
 (I thought she was joking about that, but actually she wasn't.) 
 &bquo;They're not using it any more so they've said I can use it for canteen stuff. 
 It's not much more  than a broom cupboard, I know, but what do you think of it?&equo; 
 I was peering into the gloom. 
 &bquo;It's filthy,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Well, you're a cleaner &mdash; what's the problem?&equo; 
 &bquo;Er&hellip;&equo; 
 Funnily enough, I was starting to like the idea. 
 This was potentially just about the safest &bquo;skipper&equo; in Britain. 
 &bquo;You could lose your job for this, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Stuff it, I'm sixty-one, what do I care? 
 Nobody's going to know officially and it's not as if there are hundreds of you or anything &mdash; I mean, so what if somebody does find you? 
 What's it to them? 
 Hopefully you won't have to stay here for very long anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;How much are you thinking of paying me?&equo; 
 She told me. 
 An idea suddenly dawned on me. 
 &bquo;Hey, would I be able to get cheap rail travel?&equo; 
 &bquo;I might be able to swing you a season ticket, why?&equo; 
 &bquo;You know, this might work. 
 I could work here then go up to London during the day and try to get things sorted out. 
 How much would the season ticket cost?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a quarter of the full fare. 
 There might be problems with you only being part-time. 
 If you did get one, you'd be permanently broke, which isn't quite what I had in mind. 
 Still, I take your point about London.&equo; 
 She paused for a moment. 
 &bquo;I don't see why I can't fiddle the season ticket. 
 In for a penny, in for a pound, that's what I say.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you sure about this?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm game if you are.&equo; 
 I looked back into the cupboard. 
 There was just about room to lie crossways, but not front to back, and there were no windows. 
 The door would have to be left ajar for air and that might alert passers-by. 
 However, it definitely had potential. 
 &bquo;I've got a funny feeling about this,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I think we should do it.&equo;  
 &bquo;That's the spirit!&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, you only live once.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look. 
 You can start work now, clearing this out. 
 Then it will be first thing tomorrow morning for making the sandwiches. 
 You know, this isn't as silly an idea as it sounds.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well at least it's not too far to go to get to work in the morning, I'll give it that.&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;You've got the right attitude to life, Dorothy. 
 I reckon you'll fit in here. 
 Everyone will think you're just part of the furniture.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;You never know,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Let's hope so.&equo;  
 The following day, Kathleen brought in some blankets and some candles. 
 A season ticket soon followed, paid for by Kathleen but a regular amount was deducted from my wages to pay her back. 
 After a further few days I brought my suitcases up from London. 
 One was kept in Kathleen's office and the other one, which had my regular clothes in it, I kept with me in my broom cupboard. 
 A new pattern of life now quietly started to emerge. 
 I refer to this part of my life as my grey period. 
 It starts, I suppose, with my first meeting Steve and ends some months later with another chance encounter. 
 Grey is the colour of pavements &mdash; and of the walls of the centres for homeless people which I sometimes visited during the day. 
 It's the colour of windows and blankets, of the winter sky, and of the wind, the rain and the sea. 
 Grey is the colour of the mist that shrouded my thoughts during this period. 
 It is a colour of tiredness and cold &mdash; a neutral colour, that gives us light and hope but which blocks out the sun. 
 Incongruously, this was also a very happy period for me in many ways. 
 The people at the coffee shop readily accepted me as one of their own. 
 For one hour in the morning and one at night, I was always there, seven days a week, doing my stuff and then disappearing off either to London or my broom cupboard. 
 I was part of  the furniture, yes, but I was more than that: I was part of the family. 
 And I drew a lot of strength from that. 
 Up in London, I started to sort out various logistical problems. 
 It was a matter of discovering which day centres offered what services &mdash; where I could go, for example, to have a shower or clean my clothes, or maybe have a cheap meal. 
 Survival was the name of the game and I was managing to do just that. 
 Why I didn't try to do more than this for so many months is an important question which I need to make some attempt to answer. 
 There were of course some major practical problems in the way of me relaunching myself &mdash; my age, for instance. 
 If you remember, I'd had trouble enough when I was fifty convincing people to take me on and now at fifty-nine or sixty there were hardly any employment opportunities left open to me. 
 What it came down to was this: if I was going to do anything I was going to have to take on another part-time catering or cleaning job. 
 However, after an uncomfortable night with hardly any sleep, a rudimentary wash at the station, an hour's work, a long train journey, a long walk to a day centre for a shower, and then with another long walk ahead of me, the return train journey, a further hour's hard work and another uncomfortable night, day in, day out &mdash; I'm a sprightly so-and-so but something else on top of all that did seem like perhaps too much of a good thing. 
 The sheer timing would also have been an enormous problem. 
 Facilities for homeless people are of course open only at certain times of the day and I hadn't the money to go anywhere else. 
 Any job I took would also have to be fitted around me travelling to and from Harwich. 
 It would have all been perfectly possible in ideal circumstances &mdash; but circumstances were far from ideal. 
 Inevitably, a sort of bunker mentality quickly set in. 
 I was after all surviving &mdash; and that was nothing to be  sneezed at, the way things had gone. 
 The safest course of action seemed to be to shore up the bunker and make sure I did nothing to upset the fragile eco-system that was supporting me, for however much we wanted to disguise it, I had nothing to fall back on. 
 Finally there was the grey. 
 I was tired, cold, hungry and disillusioned. 
 I hadn't given up, but that was an ever-present temptation which had to be fought. 
 The extraordinary piece of good fortune that I had been given was the opportunity to fight it my way. 
 I have given a great deal of thought as to how much I should actually tell you about this period and what just to leave to your imagination. 
 One obvious thing to do would have been to write about the facilities available to homeless people (or the chronic lack of them in key areas like medical help); however, I have decided against doing that. 
 For one thing, the criticism could easily rebound on the people who run these places, when in most cases they know how bad things are themselves but they can't do much about it. 
 The poorest people in our society are left with the poorest facilities &mdash; and that's probably the same wherever you go. 
 I am also very aware that all this is relative. 
 For one thing, I was extremely lucky in that the winter during which I was homeless was apparently the mildest this country has had for twenty years (though it was quite cold enough for me) and that was by no means the only remarkable piece of good fortune that I had. 
 In addition, when I look at the plight of the millions of people who've been made homeless recently because of flooding in other parts of the world, it does make me realize how lucky we are as a society that homelessness is still on a much smaller scale here than it is in some countries. 
 What is this &bquo;homelessness&equo;&equo; anyway? 
 Homelessness to me is a lack in any particular individual's case of  whatever their community considers to be a home, i.e. it is an economic not a psychological state. 
 Dispossession can, however, induce a psychological reaction, not least because the mind is trying desperately to make sense of what's happening. 
 I can see this in my own case, where losing a job or a home has in certain instances reopened old wounds. 
 However, to say that events that happened when I was in my late twenties somehow predisposed me to homelessness would be absolute nonsense. 
 If this was how things worked, just about every war veteran that ever was would &bquo;inevitably&equo; end up homeless because of their past. 
 Who do I mean when I talk about &bquo;the homeless&equo;? 
 I mean people who are sleeping in parks and doorways, in derelict buildings and under railway arches. 
 I mean people who are living in the old common lodging houses and in government resettlement units, people living in squats and dingy bed-and-breakfast hotels, and families living cooped up with their relatives because there's nowhere else for them to go. 
 I mean young people, old people, black people, white people, men, women and tiny children. 
 I mean people like you, whoever you are, wherever you're from and whatever you do. 
 I also have more than a thought for the people who do have homes but who are living in conditions of appalling squalor, for battered wives and abused children who stay at home because there's nowhere safe for them to go, and for the husbands who choose to stay with their families in the north rather than abandon them for crazy periods of time because they could find work only in the south, And while we're on the subject, I'm sick and tired of listening to government and commerce saying it's &bquo;uneconomic&equo; to locate businesses in the north of Britain when we're currently importing billions of pounds&equo; worth of consumer goods from the other side of the world. 
  I don't want to &bquo;politicize&equo; the homeless in a way that makes them look like the front-line infantry fighting a barbaric government, which is a line some people have taken, simply because when you're out there, it just isn't like that. 
 However, it is true that government policies (or lack of policies in some areas) have contributed significantly to our problems and some of the changes that are now in the pipeline will almost certainly make matters worse. 
 There are an awful lot of people monitoring the situation, pointing out to the &bquo;powers that be&equo; where things are going wrong and suggesting solutions. 
 At the moment, they don't seem to want to listen. 
 This is wrong. 
 We are one of the richest countries on earth. 
 We can afford decent housing, education and health-care for everyone. 
 The building bricks are there. 
 What's needed is a little thought &mdash; and a little heart. 
 There are of course some positive signs around but also a danger that I want to alert you to: a growth in what I will call &bquo;designer caring&equo;. 
 Let me try to explain what I mean. 
 &bquo;Designer&equo; seems to be the buzz adjective of the eighties. 
 It has been the word used to describe the style of today, a style that pervades everything from clothes to waste-paper bins. 
 The problem is not so much the look itself, but the attitude behind the style that appearances (and labels) are everything. 
 Add together a susceptibility to flashy packaging and a lack of any real interest in the substance of other people's problems and you're on the way to producing a &bquo;designer carer,. 
 They focus not on areas of need but on areas where they want to be seen to be giving, and that's usually where the spotlight happens for the moment to be falling. 
 They give in order to look good and to feel good but not to do good. 
 To an extent, this has always been there, but it's important to raise the issue here because the most unfashionable person to help is often the person who is dying on your own doorstep.  
 A common cop-out is to say this is all too difficult so I'm going to get my head down and forget about it. 
 Well yes, it is difficult, but so what? 
 If this bit does refer to you, open your eyes, take a look around you, see what's going on and do  something. 
 And do it now .  
 Last April, Kathleen informed us all that she was going to retire in the autumn. 
 Her husband was due to retire then and they had decided that they would both give up work at the same time. 
 This meant that there was now effectively a time limit on how long I was going to be able to stay in my broom cupboard. 
 It must be pointed out before we go any further that my friends in Harwich had a rather distorted picture of my life in that they only ever saw the best of me. 
 All my efforts were concentrated on keeping up appearances during those two hours of the day when I was with them. 
 I never overstayed my welcome and always dreamed up some excuse if any of them suggested meeting me outside working hours. 
 It wasn't that I was being purposely unfriendly, it was just that I had decided that my best chance of survival lay in my being as unobtrusive as possible. 
 Then, one day in May, Kathleen dropped a bombshell. 
 We had agreed at the start of this thing that pressing the Harwich local council for housing would probably be more trouble than it was worth: if one of their inspectors had decided to check my circumstances with the port authorities, the customs people would inevitably have found out about the way in which I had been using their cupboard (and would have had a pink fit, probably). 
 However, once Kathleen had taken her  decision about her own future, she decided that the risk had become worth taking. 
 Unbeknown to me, she made some enquiries, and then one Friday, while I was sitting in the coffee shop having a quiet read of a newspaper someone had left, she appeared by my side. 
 &bquo;Dot, I think things are finally going to start moving forward. 
 Harwich Council have offered to rehouse you.&equo; 
 I was so surprised I stood up. 
 &bquo;What do you mean?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;What's going on?&equo; 
 &bquo;They can give you a flat, girl. 
 You'll have to go into a local hostel temporarily &mdash; but that's only so they can check on a few things. 
 Don't look so worried, they're serious. 
 They can actually offer you somewhere. 
 I'm sorry to spring it on you like this but I didn't want to get your hopes up.&equo; 
 I had to sit down again. 
 &bquo;What sort of place are they going to put me in?&equo; 
 I asked after a pause. 
 &bquo;A flat. 
 They said definitely a flat. 
 The idea of the hostel is just to get you off the streets, so to speak. 
 All this is going to be over soon.&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, yes, I suppose so.&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll have to ring up their housing unit sometime today to arrange an interview. 
 Have a coffee or something. 
 You look as though you could do with one. 
 Hang on, I'll get it for you.&equo; 
 She went over to fetch a cup of coffee. 
 I sat there trying to remember all the details of what she had told me. 
 What sort of flat was it? 
 What sort of a hostel? 
 Once again, my life seemed to depend on the very words she spoke. 
 I felt powerless. 
 It felt as though someone was pulling my lifeline away from me and I was flailing around, trying to grab hold of it. 
 Suddenly, the cafe stopped being the place where I worked and once again it became the bizarre oasis that I'd happened upon all  those months earlier. 
 And suddenly, I was that same, frightened Dorothy all over again. 
 Katrina was in that morning. 
 She noticed that something was up and she came over to see me. 
 &bquo;What's wrong?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Nothing. 
 Nothing's wrong. 
 I've had rather a surprising piece of news, that's all.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why, what's up?&equo; 
 &bquo;Kathleen may have found me somewhere to live.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hey! 
 That's wonderful news! 
 Whereabouts? 
 What sort of a place?&equo; 
 She sat down beside me. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I don't really know. 
 Some sort of a flat in Harwich, I think she said. 
 She's going to ring someone up to find out more about it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Somewhere round here? 
 That would be ideal, wouldn't it? 
 I mean, you must be thrilled to pieces, no? 
 However did she find it?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 I really don't know.&equo; 
 She patted my shoulder. 
 &bquo;Hey, don't knock it. 
 This sounds all right, you know. 
 I'll see if I can find out more from Kathleen.&equo; 
 She disappeared. 
 A thousand thoughts were jostling around inside my mind. 
 It was all extraordinarily confusing. 
 I simply couldn't cope with what was happening. 
 I noticed the time. 
 I could still catch the early train if I left immediately. 
 I got up and walked quickly out of the coffee shop, up over the footbridge and on to the other platform &mdash; jumping on to the train just as it was about to go. 
 I had no idea what I was doing. 
 I was going to go back to London and see what happened then. 
 I was, however, sure about one thing: I didn't want to have to take that flat. 
 &bquo;You know, Dorothy, you and I have one thing  in common,&equo; I remember saying to myself in a Dutch accent, &bquo;we both only got as far as Harwich.&equo; 
 I don't know how many times I'd done the Harwich-to-London run, but the journey seemed different that day &mdash; like a well-known view captured in a freshly painted picture. 
 &bquo;What on earth am I going to do now?&equo; 
 I wondered. 
 I usually picked up my money on Friday evening so I was running a little short. 
 Unless I went back to Harwich, I was going to be flat broke in a couple of days and just at that moment the last thing I wanted to do was to go back to Harwich. 
 Conserving what little money I had was therefore my number-one priority. 
 I would have to live on cheap or free food, so what I really needed to do was to go and see some nuns. 
 The train arrived in London. 
 Even though I knew what I had to do, once I got outside Liverpool Street station, I just wandered off aimlessly. 
 I had started to feel very tired and I decided to try and find somewhere to have a sleep. 
 Without really being conscious of what I was doing, I ended up heading roughly north. 
 This was my first day in about eight months without my lifeline and I felt horribly alone. 
 If you have already thought up a sensible solution to my problems, that puts you one up on me as I was then, because I was completely flummoxed by the whole thing. 
 I kept wandering around for a few hours, with no idea where I was or where I was going, then somewhere along the line I chanced upon an open space where there was the odd bench scattered here and there and I used one of these for my lie-down. 
 For some strange reason, I slept like a baby. 
 I woke up late afternoon sometime with a funny taste in my mouth. 
 This would best be sorted out, I decided, by a cup of tea. 
 Not too far away, I found a street with some shops and, thankfully, a cafe. 
 I went in, bought my cuppa and  sat down. 
 The tea tasted horrible but at least it gave me the chance to have a little think. 
 &bquo;What on earth am I going to do now?&equo; 
 I kept asking myself. 
 Unfortunately, there was a row of mirrors on the wall opposite me. 
 I chanced a peek at myself. 
 I looked absolutely awful &mdash; and I felt pretty dreadful too. 
 &bquo;I passed by death,&equo; I mumbled to myself. 
 Memories started to haunt me again. 
 Memories of my childhood, memories of the School for Italian Studies, memories&hellip; 
 &bquo;It's time for us to close now, love.&equo; 
 I looked up and deep into the eyes of the cafe proprietor. 
 &bquo;But I've nowhere else to go.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well you can't stay here, love, we're closing.&equo; 
 I got up and walked quietly out into the early evening. 
 It was still light. 
 I now needed to make some sort of a decision. 
 &bquo;Head back into town,&equo; I told myself. 
 &bquo;Let's get back into familiar territory, then we can think up what to do next.&equo; 
 When I reached the Old Street roundabout, it was time to pick an ultimate destination &mdash; which basically meant choosing somewhere to stay for the night. 
 St James's Park, famous for its bird-life, would be as good a place as any. 
 &bquo;Me and all the other old ducks,&equo; I muttered to myself. 
 That cheered me up a bit. 
 I would spend the night with some dumb creature friends. 
 What was that Katrina had once said to me? 
 &bquo;At least you're not a dumb blonde like I am.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm twice as dumb as you are, girl,&equo; I mumbled. 
 Why hadn't she been able to understand? 
 And why hadn't Kathleen understood? 
 And why couldn't I find another Steve Adorable? 
 I started on my way to the West End. 
 The weather  was overcast but the chances were the rain would hold off. 
 &bquo;It had better,&equo; I thought to myself. 
 The shelter provided by my broom cupboard suddenly seemed extremely attractive. 
 &bquo;I've been very lucky,&equo; I realized. 
 &bquo;I couldn't really have been more lucky.&equo; 
 Maybe that luck was now finally going to run out. 
 Eventually I arrived down near Leicester Square, found a cafe that was still open and bought myself another cup of tea. 
 I was in cinema- and theatre-land &mdash; the part of London that never sleeps. 
 Through the cafe window I watched London nightlife pass by. 
 I watched the party-goers, the punks, the pimps, the prostitutes, the princely and the poor. 
 I watched a world that should have been behind glass and yet I was the one who was behind glass and reality was theirs. 
 I tried eating a sandwich with my second cup of tea and I just about managed it. 
 Serious inroads had now been made into my pitiful cash reserves and tomorrow I would be penniless. 
 I stayed in the cafe for as long as I felt I could and then went back outside. 
 &bquo;Yes, this is the real world,&equo; I said out loud &mdash; too loud actually; someone gave me a funny look. 
 I started to wander again, in and out of second-hand bookshops, and then into an amusement arcade. 
 I was very tempted to gamble the little money I had left in order to try and accumulate some more &mdash; tempted also to have a go just for the thrill of it. 
 But I held back. 
 &bquo;These machines are designed to make you lose, you twit,&equo; I said to myself. 
 I went back outside again. 
 I kept just killing time until it had gone eleven o'clock and all the cinema-goers had gone in for the late shows, at which point I decided to call it a day. 
 When I got down to the park, the combination of the cold and my long sleep that afternoon made me feel too restless to  contemplate actually going to sleep again, so I just sat there on one of the benches, thinking. 
 What would everyone back at the cafe have thought when, for the first time in eight months, I hadn't shown up for work? 
 Were they worried at all? 
 I honestly had no idea of what they might be thinking or what to make of it myself. 
 I thought back over all the good times &mdash; all the laughs we had shared &mdash; and all the wonderful things they had done to try to build me up and keep me going. 
 Why couldn't I let these people help me? 
 I resolved to go back and then decided I couldn't. 
 I had let them down and was no longer worthy of their friendship. 
 I decided that they simply wouldn't have understood why I'd done this and would now feel too hurt and abused ever to want to see me again. 
 I got up and started to walk around. 
 I started to think about my childhood again, about my parents and my sister. 
 Would my mother now think I'd suffered enough, I wondered. 
 Was that what she had wanted, all those years ago &mdash; for me to suffer? 
 Or was there something else she had wanted, some sign of repentance maybe? 
 Did she not realize just how awful it had made me feel? 
 Had she really simply wanted nothing more to do with me? 
 &bquo;I'm pretty hopeless at relationships, aren't I?&equo; 
 I said to myself. 
 I sat down again and lapsed into dreamland. 
 I became conscious again at about dawn. 
 I got up and had another little walk around, finishing up just over the road from Buckingham Palace. 
 &bquo;What a daft world this is,&equo; I mused to myself. 
 I reckoned that the Queen would probably have agreed with me &mdash; she'd always come across as a decent sort. 
 What was I going to do next? 
 I would definitely need to try to find some help from somewhere. 
 There was a church just to the north of there that had a reputation  for being helpful towards homeless people &mdash; I'd try my luck there. 
 First things first though: I could do with a morning cup of coffee. 
 The easiest way of solving that problem was to go down to Victoria station. 
 I dawdled around for a while and then headed south. 
 Railway stations are almost home to me now, I realized, when I eventually arrived at Victoria. 
 I picked up my coffee and savoured a sit-down in the canteen. 
 &bquo;Could I go back to Harwich?&equo; 
 I wondered. 
 What would happen if I did? 
 Would I become a burden to everyone again? 
 I really didn't want that. 
 Above all else I didn't want that. 
 They had become my friends and there was no way that I would now go back to being their problem dependant. 
 I wandered back north towards the church. 
 My plan was to sit around and wait for one of the parish team to appear and then to ask them for their advice. 
 Accordingly, when I arrived there, I settled down in a pew at the back and nodded off. 
 After a while, I was woken by the noise of preparations &mdash; something happening. 
 I chose to ignore it and continued to doze. 
 Then I remember seeing this plumpish girl, dressed in something dark moving towards me. 
 I remember seeing that smile and hearing that impeccably cheerful voice. 
 &bquo;Excuse me, we're about to have a wedding. 
 Do you think you could come back later?&equo; 
 A wedding! 
 My plan was shattered &mdash; my whole life had just been shattered. 
 Where on earth was I going to go now? 
 &bquo;You would be, wouldn't you?&equo; 
 I said, and looking her straight in the eye, I asked: &bquo;Why is everybody picking on me? 
 Why don't you pick on somebody else for a change? 
 Why does it always have to be me?&equo;  
 I smiled and looked at my feet. 
 &bquo;It's not your fault, dear,&equo; I said, then I looked up. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, I didn't mean to startle you. 
 Do you think you could pull me up and then point me in an easterly direction once we're outside? 
 I'm starting to lose my bearings a bit &mdash; and my ball-bearings as well, come to that.&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;What a wonderful expression!&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Oh, sorry. 
 I didn't mean to laugh. 
 Look, what you probably need is some fresh air. 
 Would you like to come and sit out the back with me for a minute?&equo; 
 I couldn't figure her out. 
 Was she serious? 
 I didn't know what to say, so I just held out my hand and she heaved me up. 
 &bquo;There are some benches there. 
 Why don't we go and sit down for a few minutes and then you can decide what you want to do next?&equo; 
 What got me was the way she made this rather bizarre suggestion seem so utterly reasonable. 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I'm game if you are.&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;Oh, by the way, my name's Jenny,&equo; she informed me. 
 &bquo;Dorothy,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Dorothy Streeter.&equo; 
 She bowed. 
 I was tempted to curtsey in return but I wasn't sure if my knees were up to it. 
 &bquo;Follow me,&equo; she said, unnecessarily. 
 We trooped off  round the back of the church and up into a small raised garden where there were indeed some benches. 
 Jenny selected one and we sat down. 
 Neither of us spoke for a few moments, then she asked: &bquo;Do you mind if I stay here for a little while?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, do what you like,&equo; I said, more than a little surprised to find that our roles of ward and chaperone had now been reversed. 
 A thought then suddenly struck me. 
 &bquo;Don't you want to go to the wedding?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;No, not really.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh.&equo; 
 I paused for a moment, then added: &bquo;Why did you come, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;I had to. 
 I'm supposed to be an usher &mdash; or an usherette in my case, I suppose.&equo; 
 &bquo;Forgive me. 
 I think I must be missing something. 
 Why don't you want to go back inside, where all the fun is?&equo; 
 It went quiet again. 
 Then she started to speak slowly. 
 &bquo;I'm not sure that I approve of what's happening, that's all.&equo; 
 &bquo;Whyever not?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's rather difficult for me to explain.&equo; 
 I was still trying to work this girl out. 
 &bquo;Do you want to talk about it?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 She smiled ruefully. 
 &bquo;Ignore me,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'm just being moody, that's all.&equo; 
 The conversation flagged again. 
 For some reason, I wanted to keep it going, so I chipped in: &bquo;This wedding of yours is a bit inconvenient for me, actually. 
 I was hanging around at the back of the church because I wanted a word with the vicar. 
 The trouble is, he's going to be tied up with all this now. 
 Still, I can't win them all, can I?&equo; 
 &bquo;It isn't my wedding.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I think you've just told me what your problem is.&equo;  
 She smiled. 
 &bquo;Yeah, maybe I'm just a bit jealous, that's all.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who's the groom, if you don't mind me asking?&equo; 
 &bquo;An old flame.&equo; 
 &bquo;And the bride, is she your sister?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, she's just an old flatmate of mine, that's all. 
 There's nothing funny about it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Listen to me, Jenny. 
 I have got your name right, haven't I?&equo; 
 She nodded. 
 &bquo;Listen to me, Jenny. 
 If I only ever give you one piece of advice in life &mdash; which is highly likely on the face of it &mdash; it's stay away from that man. 
 I once made the mistake you're thinking of making and I've never got over it. 
 You and him are finished now and there's the end to it.&equo; 
 She smiled again, more cheerfully this time. 
 &bquo;Don't worry, I wasn't thinking of messing around with him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fair enough. 
 But don't forget he may be thinking of messing around with you.&equo; 
 &bquo;He wouldn't.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you trying to tell me that neither of you are flesh and blood? 
 On the evidence I've seen so far I rather doubt that.&equo; 
 The smile was now back in fashion. 
 &bquo;No, we were both flesh and blood all right.&equo; 
 She swivelled round to face me. 
 &bquo;What was your big mistake?&equo; she asked me. 
 &bquo;Oh, I had an affair with my brother-in-law donkey's years ago. 
 It wasn't the sort of stuff that love stories are made of, to be honest.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did your sister ever find out about it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, he told her. 
 What exactly he told her I don't know, but that's all in the past now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you still keep in touch with her?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, but we live at a sort of peace with each other, which is good.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lisa was my best friend until she and Andy started going out together &mdash; we even shared a flat together at  one stage. 
 Andy and I had already split up before their thing got going, but even so, it makes you think a bit.&equo; 
 &bquo;You still think he's technically yours, don't you?&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;You're a perceptive so-and-so, aren't you? 
 I wasn't expecting all this.&equo; 
 &bquo;I used to be an art historian,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;You're always having to be perceptive in that line of work.&equo; 
 &bquo;An art historian! 
 You mean you used to be a museum curator or something?&equo; 
 &bquo;Worse than that. 
 I was a university lecturer.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mean you went from being a university lecturer to being a tramp? 
 Oh, brilliant!&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;It wasn't quite as simple as that. 
 Anyway, professional people can end up homeless just like anyone else. 
 It isn't a closed shop, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh sorry. 
 I didn't mean to make light of your problems. 
 It's just from the way it came out, I thought you meant you decided to jack it all in and hit the road. 
 I suppose it wasn't quite like that.&equo; 
 I laughed again. 
 &bquo;No, it wasn't. 
 But no offence taken. 
 You get used to people's misconceptions after a time.&equo; 
 &bquo;What did happen, then? 
 How come you've ended up here?&equo; 
 &bquo;I left lecturing to try and see what the big wide world had to offer, but things never worked out. 
 Then last year, everything just started running against me for some reason. 
 I'm not sure that I know how to explain it to you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look, this is a really interesting conversation. 
 Would you mind if I bought you a coffee or something?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, thank you &mdash; that would be very nice. 
 Don't you think you'd better see the body buried before you do anything else? 
 I'm quite happy to wait.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're probably right. 
 Bad manners otherwise or something. 
 Look, you stay here and I'll be back as soon as it's over. 
 Don't run away, whatever you do.&equo; 
 And  with that, she ran off. 
 Sounds of movement behind me suggested she was just in time. 
 &bquo;It won't be long,&equo; I said to myself. 
 &bquo;She'll be back.&equo; 
 I didn't have the faintest idea how this girl could help me but I knew that she was going to try. 
 I sat waiting patiently for the wedding to end. 
 It was in fact rather a nice day and my spirits were starting to rise. 
 Investing all this hope in a girl I hardly knew was, in retrospect, highly dangerous, but I was in that sort of a mood. 
 Jenny reappeared soon enough and she suggested that we nip down the road to a little p&acirc;tisserie she knew, which of course we did. 
 The shop had a little bar-type area at the back where people could sit. 
 Jenny bought two coffees and two buns and we went and sat down. 
 The conversation was wide-ranging, but gradually I told her the full story of what had happened to me over the previous year or so. 
 &bquo;I still can't understand why you won't take the flat,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I mean, I can understand you not wanting to go into a hostel, but from what you're saying, a flat's the sort of thing you want, isn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I'd still like to get married, but if someone actually proposed to me I'd probably run a mile from that as well.&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;Would you take the flat now, then? 
 They'd probably still give it to you.&equo; 
 I shook my head. 
 &bquo;It's Harwich that's the real problem. 
 I know I'm not in a position to be choosy, but I can't cope with the idea of living there &mdash; it's just beyond 
 me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where would you like to live?&equo; 
 &bquo;London, I suppose. 
 I don't have that great an affection for this place but at least it's a world I know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have you always lived here, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I was brought up in Berkhamsted and I spent a  couple of years living in Oxfordshire not so long ago, so I'm not completely inflexible about this. 
 That place was more rural, though. 
 Part of the trouble with Harwich is it's neither one thing nor the other.&equo; 
 &bquo;You will go back and see your friends, though.&equo; 
 &bquo;Tomorrow. 
 I'll go back tomorrow.&equo; 
 &bquo;Brilliant! 
 A toast I think.&equo; 
 She raised her coffee cup. 
 &bquo;To new beginnings,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;To new beginnings,&equo; I echoed, and as our cups touched, we both smiled. 
 &bquo;How about one for the happy couple?&equo; she suggested. 
 &bquo;To absent friends,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;To absent friends.&equo; 
 She took a sip of her coffee, then continued: &bquo;I think I'm going to get over him, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's the spirit!&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;This sure beats the boring old wedding breakfast,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You know what you're really lucky to be missing? 
 All those people coming up to you and saying, &bquo;Don't worry dear, it'll soon be your turn too,&equo; or some similar rubbish in that vein. 
 I remember having that at my sister's wedding. 
 It drove me spare.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, I've had some of it already. 
 In fact ever since the pair of them started going out together they've been going on about having to find poor old Jenny a new man. 
 I wouldn't mind so much but it was me who had to make all the moves when Andy and I first got started.&equo; 
 &bquo;Leave them to it,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Carry on with your own life and forget about them.&equo; 
 &bquo;We've so many friends in common, that's the problem. 
 Sorry &mdash; problem's a bit of a silly word to use in the light of what's happened to you.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;I'm sure the language can cope,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Funnily enough, that's been one of the nice things about Harwich: people haven't overburdened  everything with all my troubles and they've just been themselves. 
 Anyway, there are others worse off than me, I'm under no illusions about that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Listen, what are you going to do about tonight? 
 Do you want to check into a hostel just in case it rains or would you rather have another night in the park?&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, that would depend on the hostel. 
 They're pretty grim, a lot of them.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll tell you what. 
 If you like I'll ask around back at the church and see if I can find out what's on offer.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought you were part of the set-up there.&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;No. 
 I'd just come for the wedding. 
 It's rather ironic, really, when you think about it.&equo; 
 I laughed too. 
 &bquo;OK,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;But don't take it to heart if I don't follow your advice. 
 I can be a bit awkward about things like this.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're the one who'd end up getting wet.&equo; 
 We arranged to meet on a bench outside the Royal Academy at five o'clock. 
 I spent most of the intervening period in the National Portrait Gallery. 
 Anyway, at shortly before five I made my way to the forecourt of the RA. 
 While I was sitting waiting for Jenny, a number of well-dressed women of about my age filed past me, some of them evidently wearied by their afternoon of serious picture-watching. 
 &bquo;That was how I was once,&equo; I mused to myself. 
 &bquo;I wonder what really separates us now?&equo; 
 Suddenly it struck me just how much protection my past had given me, particularly the university lecturer bit of it. 
 Before long, Jenny showed up. 
 &bquo;Great,&equo; she said for some inexplicable reason. 
 &bquo;How's it going?&equo; 
 &bquo;Great,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;Didn't you get that the wrong way around?&equo; 
 &bquo;Pedant. 
 Look, I've found a hostel that will take you  for one night. 
 It's run by a private charity and they don't normally accept referrals from outsiders but they didn't want to be too dogmatic about that.&equo; 
 &bquo;What sort of a place is it?&equo; 
 &bquo;A converted private house. 
 You won't get your own room or anything but it's free and probably better than nothing.&equo; 
 &bquo;One more night,&equo; I murmured to myself. 
 &bquo;OK,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Let's give it a whirl.&equo; 
 &bquo;Brilliant!&equo; 
 The next thing on Jenny's mind was food. 
 &bquo;Where would you like to eat?&equo; she asked me. 
 &bquo;Shouldn't you be going to a party?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've been excused for the moment. 
 What do you fancy?&equo; 
 &bquo;Anything that isn't sandwiches.&equo; 
 We went off to a little restaurant she knew near Leicester Square. 
 Jenny, as I had already worked out, was a woman of some means and she clearly wasn't bothered by the fact she was having to subsidize me. 
 I'd taught many similarly wealthy girls during my lecturer days, so fortunately I didn't feel uneasy about this and just let her carry on. 
 She insisted on having wine with the meal, and as I hadn't had a drink in a long time, it made me feel rather tipsy. 
 &bquo;Jenny, you're mad. 
 You go to all the trouble of finding me a bed in a night shelter and you then get me so drunk they'll refuse point-blank to let me in!&equo; 
 &bquo;Have you ever been an alcoholic or anything like that?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, you don't understand. 
 People have got the wrong idea about this one. 
 Alcoholism is a social thing, not a homelessness thing &mdash; I mean, I knew a few university lecturers who were alcoholics, but they all had homes to go to &mdash; or still had, last time they ever spoke to me.&equo;  
 &bquo;Have you met any other university people out and about?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not knowingly. 
 It isn't a very common job, that's the problem. 
 I've met one or two schoolteachers, but then again they're a bigger group in society as a whole. 
 That's one of the things I've done, actually.&equo; 
 &bquo;This was when you were out in the wilds of Oxfordshire, right?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Have I already told you about that one? 
 Sorry, my mind's going or the drink's getting to me, one of the two.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sure you could still get a bit of teaching work, you know. 
 At least you would earn more than you are now.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm too old. 
 I'm already past the statutory retirement age and besides, I've enjoyed being with the people in Harwich so I'd like to stick with them if I can.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you still worried about how that boss lady's going to react when you get back there?&equo; 
 &bquo;Kathleen? 
 Yes I am, rather. 
 I really don't know what's going to happen, to be honest.&equo; 
 &bquo;I reckon they'll just be relieved to see you're still in one piece.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll find out tomorrow.&equo; 
 I paused for a moment, then added, &bquo;Would you mind if I had some pudding?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, of course not. 
 What do you fancy?&equo; 
 I studied the menu. 
 &bquo;I think I'll try some of their ice cream. 
 I haven't had any for years &mdash; not since I last went to Rome probably.&equo; 
 &bquo;Brilliant! 
 We'll both have some.&equo; 
 She summoned a waitress. 
 I sat back and relaxed for a moment. 
 The calm was a strange one &mdash; a distant memory. 
 It was like that feeling you get when the sun first hits you after breaking through the clouds. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, I've been thinking. 
 Would you mind if I made a few housing enquiries for you? 
 Sometimes a  fresh pair of eyes isn't a bad thing in a situation like this.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;Sure,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 The ice creams came and we tucked in. 
 &bquo;Cold and delicious!&equo; 
 Jenny exclaimed. 
 &bquo;You know, Dorothy, you and I will just have to dine together more often. 
 Starting with breakfast tomorrow, I think. 
 Just in case you have a bad night and decide not to go back.&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 There seemed to be no real point in arguing with her. 
 &bquo;I'll want to catch quite an early train from Liverpool Street. 
 Are you sure you'll be up in time to get there by nine o'clock?&equo; 
 &bquo;Cheek! 
 What time's your train?&equo; 
 &bquo;There's a boat-train that goes at about half-nine, I think.&equo; 
 &bquo;OK, we'll make it half-eight just to be on the safe side.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aren't you going to be tired after the party, though? 
 I won't be offended if you can't make it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't worry, a bit of body-popping won't kill me.&equo; 
 &bquo;What on earth is body-popping?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a sort of dancing. 
 Why, what did you think it was?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, you are on the big side and for a moment I had this vision of you&hellip;&equo; 
 We both collapsed into helpless giggles. 
 Coffee was next, and then it was time for the bill. 
 &bquo;How strapped are you for cash?&equo; 
 Jenny asked me. 
 &bquo;Can I lend you some at least until you pick up your wages tomorrow?&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, I'm not sure I'll have enough for the tube fare to Liverpool Street, but the rest I can manage. 
 Thanks.&equo; 
 She gave me the tip she'd put aside for the waitress and then raided her purse again to replace it. 
 This done we made our way out of the restaurant.  
 &bquo;I'm heading down to Victoria,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;How about you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I think I'll start on my way north.&equo; 
 (Pause.) 
 &bquo;Jenny&hellip; thank you.&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;Don't be silly,&equo; she said, and she bounced off. 
 I watched her go and then, shaking my head, I turned and walked the other way. 
 I was soon in Leicester Square, which was already packed with people who'd come for an evening out. 
 All around me there were cinemas. 
 Cinemas, cinemas everywhere. 
 &bquo;I bet none of them are showing anything as daft as this,&equo; I mused to myself. 
 The shelter that Jenny had found for me was in Camden Town, not too far away, so in order not to arrive there before it got going for the evening, I dawdled a little, window-shopping. 
 Up on Tottenham Court Road there were all the gadget shops, all displaying their various ranges of radios, record players, compact-disc players and videos &mdash; all of which seemed to be housed in bewilderingly similar sleek black boxes. 
 &bquo;All is conformity now,&equo; I thought to myself. 
 &bquo;All is conformity.&equo; 
 On I went. 
 The irony of the scenario was well appreciated by yours truly. 
 The me who said she'd never stay in a hostel again was now on her way to a night shelter. 
 And that same me, who twenty-four hours earlier had decided she could never go back to Harwich, would be on her way there tomorrow. 
 &bquo;What do I know,&equo; I mused. 
 The idea of going back still made me nervous, though. 
 What if it didn't work out after all? 
 &bquo;I hope you haven't bitten off more than you can chew, Jenny,&equo; I muttered to myself. 
 I had to go back. 
 I'd spent too much of my life running away as it was. 
 I arrived up in Camden Town and asked in the tube  station for directions to the shelter. 
 Somebody knew and I was soon outside the front door. 
 I knocked. 
 &bquo;Hello, how can I help?&hellip; 
 Yes, we've been expecting you. 
 Come in, come and sit in the front room. 
 Would you like some tea?&equo; 
 &bquo;Please, thank you.&equo; 
 He showed me into the lounge. 
 Somebody else was already there, a man idly reading a newspaper. 
 He looked up when I came in. 
 &bquo;How's it going?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;All right. 
 You?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not too bad. 
 Do you know much about these people?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've been here before so I know a little bit. 
 How about you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't usually come up this way, it's all a bit new to me, actually.&equo; 
 &bquo;This lot are OK, don't worry.&equo; 
 He put the newspaper to one side, then added: &bquo;Sit down, take the weight off your feet.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thanks,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I will.&equo; 
 The conversation then continued. 
 We ended up trading memories of Paris in the fifties and England before the war. 
 The young man who made the tea sat with us, occasionally contributing to the conversation. 
 The atmosphere was warm and peaceful. 
 More people arrived: more experiences were shared. 
 Stories of a bitter world, told without bitterness or self-pity. 
 I started to feel drowsy. 
 &bquo;Does anyone mind if I go to bed?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;No, go when you like,&equo; the tea provider said with a smile. 
 I wished everyone goodnight and he led me upstairs into a small dormitory room. 
 &bquo;Crash out over there,&equo; he suggested, pointing to the far corner of the room. 
  &bquo;Thanks,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Someone will remember to wake me up early tomorrow, won't they?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, we won't forget. 
 Ciao.&equo; 
 &bquo;G'night.&equo; 
 I went over to the bed, climbed on top of it, put my head on the pillow and fell asleep.  
 I slept fitfully but well enough, disturbed only by the comings and goings of my companions. 
 As promised, one of the project workers gave me an early shake and I had time enough for a coffee before I needed to set off to meet Jenny. 
 The girl who woke me also made my drink. 
 &bquo;What sort of accommodation have you got in Harwich?&equo; she asked, as we went off to sit down in the lounge. 
 &bquo;A little store room &mdash; I call it my broom cupboard. 
 It's home, though.&equo; 
 &bquo;So what were you doing up here in London?&equo; 
 &bquo;I come up here every day. 
 I work part-time at the station coffee shop at Parkeston Quay so I get cheap rail travel.&equo; 
 &bquo;It must still be pretty expensive, though?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, it gets me out of the house.&equo; 
 She paused for a moment. 
 &bquo;It's a bit of an odd way to live, isn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;True. 
 But it's how I've survived.&equo; 
 She smiled. 
 &bquo;You've had some trouble up there, haven't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;A bit. 
 That's what I'm going back to try and sort out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look, if it doesn't work out, come back and see us and we'll try to do something for you, OK?&equo;  
 &bquo;Thanks, I appreciate that.&equo; 
 She saw me off. 
 The journey to Liverpool Street station was just a trundle around the Northern Line from Camden to Moorgate and then a short walk, and I accomplished it in good time. 
 In fact, I saw from the station clock that I had timed my arrival just about perfectly. 
 So had Jenny. 
 She came up to me with, I noticed, slightly less bounce in her step than there had been the previous day. 
 &bquo;Me or the party?&equo; 
 I wondered. 
 &bquo;Hi! 
 How was the shelter?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine. 
 How was the party?&equo; 
 &bquo;Awful. 
 Just awful. 
 I don't even want to talk about it.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;What time did you get to bed?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;Can't remember. 
 Breakfast,&equo; she said emphatically. 
 &bquo;What we really need now is breakfast. 
 Did they give you any at the shelter?&equo; 
 &bquo;Only a cup of coffee.&equo; 
 &bquo;Brilliant! 
 Let's get some.&equo; 
 We went off to the canteen. 
 I was in a familiar world and I was able to explain to Jenny how everything was done. 
 &bquo;Do you get a discount?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not here, no. 
 Why? 
 Are you short of money? 
 I'm sorry, you have been subsidizing me rather a lot lately.&equo; 
 She waved a hand furiously. 
 &bquo;No. 
 No! 
 Nothing like that. 
 I was just wondering, that's all. 
 Who else showed up at the shelter?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, it was a good mix last night &mdash; we all had a nice chat. 
 Tea or coffee?&equo; 
 &bquo;Coffee.&equo; 
 Jenny paid and we went to sit down. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, for when I start looking at various housing options, what sort of thing are you actually after? 
 If you were given &bquo;carte blanche&equo; so to speak, what would you go for?&equo;  
 &bquo;A flat of my own would be the ideal thing still. 
 When something happens and I can't look after myself any more the situation will be different, but at the moment what I'd really like most is my independence back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Some sort of Housing Association thing maybe.&equo; 
 &bquo;Possibly. 
 The main thing is I don't want to go back into the private sector unless I absolutely have to. 
 There's going to be new legislation soon which will make it dead easy for landlords to kick tenants out and I've had enough of all this as it is.&equo; 
 &bquo;What we need to do is set up a regular lunch date so everyone knows what's happening. 
 I know it's basically to suit me, but how easy is it for you to get down to Victoria?&equo; 
 &bquo;Very. 
 Look, don't hold out too much hope that you're going to be successful in this. 
 I'm not expecting anything, I promise you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, there's no harm in trying. 
 Tell you what. 
 Let's meet for lunch tomorrow by Little Ben at one o'clock. 
 You can tell me how you got on today and I can start making some enquiries.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who or what is Little Ben?&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;The clock outside the front of Victoria station. 
 It's like Big Ben only littler. 
 Great! 
 That's all sorted out. 
 When's your train again?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's slightly earlier than I thought it was but we're OK still.&equo; 
 We finished our breakfast. 
 &bquo;Would you like some newspapers to read on your journey?&equo; 
 Jenny asked me as we got up to leave. 
 &bquo;That would be very nice. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 A couple of papers were duly bought and after that we parted company. 
 The bounce was now back in Jenny's step, I noticed, as I watched her head off towards the tube. 
 She had evidently decided that things were going to be all right. 
  On the way back to Harwich, the newspapers did a marvellous job of keeping my mind off things, and it was only on the last leg of the journey that the butterflies started to flutter again. 
 Meeting Jenny the following day at least gave me something else to hang on to, but I still hadn't the faintest idea how everyone was going to react. 
 I arrived to face the music. 
 Waiting for me behind the counter was Katrina. 
 She quickly disappeared out the back and came around the front to greet me. 
 &bquo;Dorothy! 
 We've been so worried about you! 
 Are you all right? 
 Come and sit down and tell me what's been happening.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where's Kathleen?&equo; 
 &bquo;She's gone to London to look for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;What!&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't worry. 
 She only went down this morning. 
 Hey! 
 We've been really worried about you, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;How are we going to be able to get in touch with her? 
 Look, seriously, do I need to get on the next train back to Liverpool Street and go and find her?&equo; 
 Katrina laughed. 
 &bquo;We'll have the pair of you spending the day waving at each other from railway trains at this rate. 
 It's all right. 
 She's ringing in around lunchtime. 
 Listen, you sit down, I'll get a couple of coffees and we'll have a chat, OK?&equo; 
 I sat down and Katrina soon joined me again. 
 &bquo;Whereabouts in London has she gone to look for me?&equo; 
 &bquo;No idea. 
 I don't think she knew either. 
 She's a really lovely woman but she's not very bright about things like this. 
 I mean, I would have gone to London to look for you too, but it's sometimes easier just to telephone, 
 &bquo;How do you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;I rang that night shelter you were at this morning  and the girl I spoke to told me you were on your way. 
 I got some phone numbers out of the Salvation Army yesterday. 
 They seemed really nice, you know, I don't know why you're so much against them.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't fancy the idea of living in one of their hostels, that's all.&equo; 
 Tears were coming into my eyes. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry that I've got you all so worried. 
 I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Hey, don't be silly!&equo; 
 She put her hand on my shoulder. 
 &bquo;You're all right, that's all we care about. 
 You don't have to take that flat in Harwich, it was only an idea. 
 Anyway, what have you been doing these past two days?&equo; 
 I told her what had happened. 
 It wasn't long before Kathleen rang. 
 &bquo;Tell her to stay there!&equo; she ordered Katrina. 
 &bquo;She's not to move. 
 I'm holding you responsible for this young lady. 
 You're not to let her out of your sight!&equo; 
 Steve Adorable rolled in about lunchtime and he too needed to be told everything. 
 &bquo;Life's never exactly dull when you're around, is it Dot?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It has its moments.&equo; 
 &bquo;You should write it all down, you know. 
 It would make a good book, this would.&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;By the way,&equo; he warned me. 
 &bquo;Kath was going a bit mental yesterday. 
 She might have quietened down a bit by now, but you know what she's like.&equo; 
 Steve's hopes were unfounded. 
 When Kathleen arrived, she burst into the coffee shop like a tornado. 
 And she was crying. 
 I couldn't believe it. 
 She was crying. 
 &bquo;There you are! 
 Honestly, girl, if you only knew where I'd been to try and find you!&equo; 
 &bquo;Where did you go?&equo; 
 &bquo;To that vile city of yours! 
 I can't for the life of me understand what it is you see in it. 
 It's filthy! 
 Absolutely  filthy! 
 I've never seen such a mess! 
 And that stupid underground. 
 They don't know their north from their east from their west from&hellip;, 
 We gave each other a long hug. 
 By now, I was crying even worse than she was. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Kath, I didn't know what I was doing. 
 I just got so scared, you know, I'm sorry, I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right, Dot. 
 It's over now. 
 Anyway, what on earth have you been up to all this time?&equo;  
 We're now into my blue period. 
 If grey was the colour that characterized the first phase of my time at Harwich, blue characterizes this next phase. 
 Blue, the colour of the sky on a sunny day. 
 The colour of railway trains, of a catering assistant's uniform, and of the unshapely denims that Jenny used to wear out of office hours, in defiance of anything that suited her. 
 It's also a colour of cold &mdash; and we haven't had much of a summer this year &mdash; but at the same time it reminds me of the warmth and tranquillity of a Claude Lorrain. 
 It is a colour of peace. 
 It's reliable, it's safe, and it's secure. 
 During my blue period my life also seemed to become a lot more structured than it had been for a while. 
 Things seemed to have more of a sense that they were leading somewhere. 
 This was partly because of events that were going on around me: Kathleen building towards her retirement and, as was to become highly significant, Katrina deciding that she wanted to make a move as well. 
 &bquo;I'm going to be doing this for the rest of my life if I'm not careful,&equo; she told me one day. 
 She had decided that she wanted to go to London, take some A-levels up there, and then, she hoped, go on to university. 
 &bquo;Why not go to some evening classes around here?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;I just think it's about time I moved on, you know. 
  London is different to me than it is to you. 
 To you it's just home, but to me it's the place I've been trying to get to. 
 Staying here is almost like still being back in Haarlem. 
 It's like I never really broke free, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why didn't you try Amsterdam?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's only just up the road, and besides, they take your money off you in Amsterdam.&equo; 
 &bquo;They make you homeless in London.&equo; 
 We were both smiling. 
 It was me who spoke next. 
 &bquo;Have you got any particular schools or colleges in mind?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, do you have any ideas about that? 
 I mean, who was good when you used to teach?&equo; 
 &bquo;Tell you what, I'll ring around some of my old university friends if you like and see if they know of anywhere. 
 It probably won't get us very far, but you never know, one of them might come up with something.&equo; 
 &bquo;Could you? 
 That would be really useful, I think.&equo; 
 I certainly could. 
 I did not, to be honest, think I would have much success &mdash; it's not the sort of thing that I would have known all those years ago &mdash; but the idea of ringing up a few of my former colleagues was just irresistible. 
 Now, who should I try first? 
 Charles Howard. 
 I had to start with Charles Howard. 
 Kathleen offered me the use of her office telephone and so, one morning, I settled down to make some enquiries. 
 The person on the SIS switchboard was, I am sure, Liz of old, but when I announced who I was there was no acknowledgement of recognition on her part. 
 &bquo;I'll see if he's in his office for you.&equo; 
 A few moments later she came back to me. 
 Charles was prepared to take my call. 
 &bquo;Dorothy! 
 What an extraordinary surprise! 
 How are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine, Charles, how are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Beset by these blasted cuts at the moment. 
 Have you  heard? 
 The Senate wants to merge us into University College and we've been told we'll have to get rid of some of our staff &mdash; it may all be very neat and tidy for the bureaucrats, but it's going to be absolutely disastrous for some people. 
 Anyway, what are you up to these days? 
 Are you still a schoolma'am?&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;No, I'm working at a caff in Harwich.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're in catering? 
 I imagine you'd be rather good at that.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right. 
 How is everyone, in spite of things?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, fine. 
 The atmosphere's a bit tense, understandably &mdash; listen, what can I do for you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I need some ideas, Charles. 
 I have a young friend in her early twenties who wants to do some A-levels at a reasonable nightschool in London. 
 Arts type of things. 
 I'm really just trying to find out if anyone knows of somewhere decent.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can't think of anywhere myself, let me think for a minute. 
 Actually, the best thing would be if I could get back to you. 
 I'll put the word around and see if anybody can come up with something.&equo; 
 &bquo;I work rather odd hours but you can always leave a message for me here at the cafe. 
 Just a minute. 
 The number is&hellip;&equo; 
 It wasn't Charles who left a message, it was, to my great surprise, his one-time prot&eacute;g&eacute;&equo; Paul Spence. 
 I felt oddly nervous when returning the call. 
 &bquo;Paul, how are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine thanks, how are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not too bad.&equo; 
 &bquo;I hear you're in catering these days.&equo; 
 &bquo;That glamorizes things rather. 
 Do you have some news for me?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, I've been making some enquiries about nightschools. 
 Listen, are you ever up in London these days? 
 I thought we might perhaps have lunch.&equo;  
 &bquo;That would be lovely, thank you. 
 Any time would be fine.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let's arrange it now. 
 How about next Thursday?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 Why not?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've recently found this really nice Greek restaurant. 
 How does Greek food sound?&equo; 
 &bquo;Terrific. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 When we met up as planned, it soon became apparent that Paul had in fact researched the matter in hand extremely thoroughly, and I had an impressive number of addresses and names of contacts to take back to Katrina. 
 &bquo;You've been to a lot of trouble over this, Paul, thank you. 
 It's very kind of you.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was the least I could do. 
 What's this catering lark you're into?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, just some part-time work in a coffee shop. 
 It keeps the wolf from the door, that's all.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you still dabble in art history?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I gave that up as a bad job years ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;Or got eased out by me, to put it bluntly. 
 None of us have ever forgotten about that, you know.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;It's water under the bridge now,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;It sounds as though life's not been too easy for you since then.&equo; 
 &bquo;There've been good things and bad things, but I've survived. 
 How about you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 That's a difficult question.&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;How do you mean?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;I think a part of me probably died when I took your job, though it may have been just the settling-down thing. 
 Anyway, I wanted it all badly enough, didn't I?&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;How's the family?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;They're all fine. 
 Still just the two kids. 
 The school fees have been a bit of a pain, but everyone finds that. 
 By the way, while I think of it, Anne was just about to  leave the country when you rang, but she says when she gets back in September you're to give her a call.&equo; 
 &bquo;How is she?&equo; 
 I proceeded to catch up on the last ten years of what everyone had been doing. 
 &bquo;You know, it really is strange to hear about you all again. 
 It's like stumbling across a whole world that you thought had gone for ever.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's on its way out, I think. 
 Did Charles tell you about the proposed merger?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, what will you do if it goes through?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not sure. 
 I'd like to try and do something completely different, but the trouble is, what?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd pay off the school fees first if I were you.&equo; 
 He laughed. 
 &bquo;Yes, you're probably right. 
 Looking at it realistically, I think I'll either go back into the museum side of things or carry on with what I'm doing now. 
 It's pretty uninspiring, really.&equo; 
 &bquo;At least you're good at it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ever popular anyway. 
 You know something, Dorothy? 
 You've changed.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;Really? 
 How?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 You seem somehow, er&hellip; younger, I suppose.&equo; 
 I laughed at that. 
 &bquo;It's because my hair's longer. 
 You look a bit more care-worn, but I expect that's the children.&equo; 
 He smiled. 
 &bquo;Just old age, I think,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It's catching up on me.&equo; 
 The information Paul provided turned out to be extremely useful. 
 One of the colleges he listed invited Katrina up for an interview and she seemed to like it there. 
 &bquo;The man who interviewed me was just so English,&equo; she informed me. 
 &bquo;He said not to worry about the language problem, which was nice of him. 
 Because they're  a private school, they can take anybody they like &mdash; which is me in this case.&equo; 
 &bquo;They've definitely offered you a place?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 I was surprised. 
 He didn't even want to consult with one of his colleagues. 
 And my father's said he's going to help me with the fees, so it's all going to work out.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;When do your courses start?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;September. 
 That's when I'll be leaving here now.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm going to miss you. 
 This place won't be the same with both you and Kathleen gone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Things might have changed for you too by then, you know. 
 Have you heard anything?&equo; 
 I hadn't. 
 The subject of a flat in Harwich had of course never been raised again. 
 Both Jenny and Kathleen were up to various things and I'd been having a go myself, but although my name was appearing on more and more waiting lists, nothing substantial seemed to be happening. 
 There was one bright spot, however. 
 Because I'd passed the magical sixty years of age mark, I was now officially an old-age pensioner and that apparently made me technically &bquo;vulnerable&equo; under the provisions of the Homeless Persons Act. 
 In consequence, according to the rule book, I now had to be taken seriously. 
 When positive news did come, it again seemed to arrive out of the blue. 
 I was meeting Jenny for lunch. 
 &bquo;Ever thought of Colchester?&equo; she asked me. 
 &bquo;How do you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;As somewhere to live.&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, not really, no. 
 Why do you ask?&equo; 
 &bquo;The Salvation Army are looking for someone to put in a training house they've got there and &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;A training house!. 
 What on earth is one of those?&equo; 
 Jenny laughed. 
 &bquo;It sounds a bit like an indoctrination centre, doesn't it? 
 Actually, as far as I can gather, it's  just their jargon for a bedsit house. 
 One person living there has to be a Sally Ann person of some sort, but otherwise it's just everyone with their own room but sharing kitchen and bathroom. 
 If you're vaguely interested I can arrange an interview with the lady I spoke to on their resettlement team, but if you don't like the sound of it&hellip;&equo; 
 I was indeed rather dubious about the whole idea, but we hadn't been getting very far and there seemed to be no harm in just finding out some more about it. 
 We rang up from Victoria station and arranged to meet Jenny's contact the following afternoon. 
 And of course, we duly kept the appointment. 
 &bquo;It would probably be best if I started from square one,&equo; the contact opened the proceedings by saying. 
 &bquo;Someone has left us a private house in Colchester in their will and we've decided to use it as a training house. 
 It's only just been finished but the plan is to have four people living there &mdash; three clients or whatever and one person sponsored by us, probably a member of staff. 
 Everyone has their own room with a little fridge and a kettle, but you do have to share kitchen and bathroom.&equo; 
 &bquo;What role does your member of staff have in all this?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;It's kept down to an absolute bare minimum. 
 They have to keep a logbook but that's only a check to make sure that nobody's leaving a mess in the common areas and we only have it because we've found that some residents can have problems because they've become deskilled in certain things. 
 It's like people sometimes have problems when they come out after a long stay in hospital &mdash; or the same sort of thing anyway. 
 The worker's really just there to check that everything's going OK. 
 The emphasis in the structure of the household is on independent living so the expectation is you'll come and go as you please.&equo; 
  &bquo;You mean as long as I clean the bath, he or she will leave me in peace, right?&equo; 
 &bquo;Er, yes. 
 That's the idea of the thing. 
 There is actually a television room as well, I think, but if you do want to keep yourself to yourself that's fine. 
 The fewer people there are to argue about which channel to watch, the better, I should think.&equo; 
 &bquo;How long would I be able to stay there?&equo; 
 &bquo;We'd expect you to stay a couple of years, but obviously there's going to be no pressure on you to move on at the end of that period. 
 If you do find something better, great, if not, stick around.&equo; 
 Jenny was bursting to say something. 
 &bquo;What do you think, Dot?&equo; she asked me. 
 &bquo;Could I see the place before I decide anything else?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 One thing, though, the other residents have to &bquo;vote you in&equo; as it were &mdash; it's just to make sure we don't set up any violent personality clashes, that's all. 
 How do you feel about everything I've said, generally?&equo; 
 &bquo;As I say, I'm quite a private person, but if that's OK with everyone else I suppose&hellip; 
 You can't really tell without seeing it, though.&equo; 
 &bquo;We can arrange a visit as soon as you like. 
 Would you like Jenny to go along as well?&equo; 
 I looked at Jen. 
 &bquo;I'd honestly prefer Kathleen to come,&equo; I said, hesitatingly. 
 Jenny laughed. 
 &bquo;Don't be silly!&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Make a day out of it.&equo; 
 I was silent for a moment, then I asked: &bquo;Is there a telephone somewhere? 
 I'd like to give her a ring if I may?&equo;  
 The house was fine. 
 I went with Kathleen to see it a couple of days later. 
 My fellow residents turned out to be a chap in his late thirties who was trying to put his life back together after the death of his wife and various other things, and a chap of about my age who had also run into problems after his wife died. 
 The Salvation Army worker living there was a young girl, Sharon, so that balanced the house up a bit. 
 &bquo;Yeah, if you want to keep yourself to yourself that's no problem,&equo; Pete, the man of about my age, said. 
 &bquo;We'll take you as we find you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Another thing is I work odd hours, which means I'm up and about at funny times of the day. 
 I'd try not to disturb anyone but you know what it's like, you can &mdash;, 
 &bquo;Oh, don't worry,&equo; Peter interjected, &bquo;that's just part and parcel of everything. 
 I do a bit of security work myself and Keith's after whatever he can get, so we're all up to something.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've got to live your life too, you know,&equo; said Keith with a grin. 
 We said we'd ring them up that afternoon to see what everybody thought. 
 I myself felt the meeting had gone pretty well &mdash; the house itself was nice and we all seemed to get on very well together. 
 Kathleen and I went off for some lunch and we then went to have a look at the castle.  
 &bquo;It isn't exactly the Tower of London,&equo; I said, &bquo;but it'll do me.&equo; 
 We went to find a call-box. 
 &bquo;How do you feel about it?&equo; 
 Sharon asked me over a slightly crackly line. 
 &bquo;I'd like to take it if I may. 
 How do you all feel?&equo; 
 &bquo;We'd love to have you here. 
 When do you want to move in?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 Tomorrow? 
 Or would that be too soon? 
 Next week maybe?&equo; 
 &bquo;Tomorrow would be great. 
 About what time do you think you'll be ready to come?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mid-afternoon &mdash; would that be all right?&equo; 
 &bquo;Perfect. 
 See you then. 
 'Bye.&equo; 
 I put the receiver down and rested my head against the back of the kiosk. 
 &bquo;It's over,&equo; I said out loud. 
 &bquo;I'm free!&equo; 
 I turned to face Kathleen. 
 She was smiling like a Cheshire cat. 
 We had a good long hug. 
 &bquo;It's going to be all right now,&equo; I told her. 
 &bquo;It's going to be all right.&equo; 
 She patted me on the back. 
 &bquo;Easy as pie, wasn't it?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Yes, in the end.&equo; 
 &bquo;Come on. 
 Give everyone a ring.&equo; 
 Katrina first. 
 She uttered something loud and incomprehensible in Dutch and told me she'd meet me at the coffee shop later. 
 Jenny poured forth a stream of &bquo;brilliants&equo;&equo; and said she was going to drive down to Harwich that evening. 
 I managed to dissuade her from that and we settled on lunch together the following day. 
 Kathleen and I then took the next train back to Harwich and when we arrived, it seemed like half the port wanted to know what had happened. 
 Everyone went wild! 
 We shut the place up early that evening and then all went round to the pub for a further celebration. 
 I'd never  seen what people drank before so that was interesting &mdash; nor did I realize quite how many of the youngsters smoked! 
 Anyway, when things had calmed down a bit, Kathleen made a quiet suggestion. 
 &bquo;Dorothy, when Katrina leaves, how about taking over her shift and working full-time? 
 It doesn't look as though Steve's going to get my job so we might start to have problems with things like your season ticket if we're not careful. 
 I know the money's not brilliant but it's better than freezing to death on a state pension.&equo; 
 I was quiet for a moment. 
 &bquo;Sure,&equo; I then said. 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 This is all going to cut you off from London a bit, but I don't see that there's really any other way at the moment.&equo; 
 I smiled. 
 &bquo;C'est la vie. 
 By the way, have you ever seen the musical Les Mis&eacute;rables ?&equo; 
 She looked taken-aback. 
 &bquo;Yes I have,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; 
 &bquo;You mentioned it during one of our first meetings so I've always had a hankering to see how they've done it. 
 We'll do something else, though. 
 When I get my first wage packet let's blow it on an outing somewhere. 
 What do you think?&equo; 
 &bquo; Les Mis&eacute;rables  was quite complicated, so I'd actually quite like a second go at it. 
 I say we hit Paris, how about you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Vive la France!&equo; 
 That night was my last one in my broom cupboard. 
 The following morning I worked as usual and then asked Kathleen if I could have a couple of days off. 
 Of course. 
 Give me a ring when everything's sorted out.&equo; 
 I borrowed some money from Katrina, packed my suitcases and my travelling bag, and took them off down to London. 
 I checked everything in at the left-luggage office in  Liverpool Street station, and then went off to make a couple of telephone calls. 
 The first one was to the house in Colchester to ask if they'd mind if I delayed my arrival by one more day. 
 &bquo;No problem,&equo; said Keith. 
 &bquo;What time do you want to come tomorrow?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mid-morning if that's possible.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're deliberately making things easy for us. 
 I'll see you tomorrow morning.&equo; 
 My next call was to the company that had been holding some of my things in storage, just to warn them that I was coming round. 
 When I got there, I found to no great surprise that very little had survived in any reasonable condition. 
 &bquo;Do you want us to get rid of it all for you?&equo; the man asked. 
 &bquo;There are some personal bits and pieces that I'd like to hang on to but you can chuck the rest, I should think.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, sure. 
 Shame about it all really.&equo; 
 &bquo;They're only things.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah &mdash; too right, love! 
 Are you wanting to take any of it now?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I need to have words with a friend of mine who's got a car before I do anything else. 
 When I've found out when she can come and give me a hand, I'll give you a ring.&equo; 
 My next stop was lunch with Jenny. 
 She was, needless to say, all agog. 
 &bquo;What's it like? 
 I want to know everything!&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a really nice house, and the rest of the people living there are very easy-going so&hellip; no problem.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's quite trendy moving to Colchester, you know.&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;Well, if it's true that I'm getting younger it'll probably suit me in that case.&equo;  
 I proceeded to pass on as many details as I could remember. 
 &bquo;When are you moving in?&equo; 
 &bquo;Tomorrow. 
 There are some other things I want to do tonight.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's a mischievous look in your eye, Dot. 
 What are you up to?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm going to start writing a book.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about?&equo; 
 &bquo;Me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ye &mdash; s! 
 Oh brilliant! 
 Am I going to be in it?&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;You can't avoid it, dear.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you going to blow the whistle on the whole lot &mdash; I mean, the university people as well?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll change a few names but that's about it. 
 Anyway, the people at SIS are big enough to take it and I respect them for that.&equo; 
 &bquo;What are you going to call this masterwork?&equo; 
 &bquo; Part of the Furniture .&equo; 
 &bquo;Why that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah-ha.&equo;  
 The end of the last chapter was, you might think, a suitable place to end the book, but it wasn't, properly speaking, the end of my blue period. 
 Taking up residence in Colchester went very well &mdash; though I was a bit surprised to find that the &bquo;de-skilling&equo; process mentioned by the resettlement officer had indeed affected me to some extent. 
 I hadn't realized just how much I'd got out of the swing of things but everyone helped as much as they could and I soon adjusted back again. 
 Kathleen, absolute brick to the end, has let me keep my season ticket for London so I've still been able to pop down there during the day when I feel like it &mdash; and the rail staff at Colchester have been quite happy to let me have a break in my journey. 
 &bquo;You hang on to that, love. 
 They can afford it.&equo; 
 In any case, once I got more and more into the swing of writing, I started to spend more time at home doing that. 
 Jenny gave me a house-warming present of a radio so I've been able to listen to music while I write &mdash; and it's been such fun! 
 About three weeks after I moved in, she invited me around to her flat for supper one evening. 
 I'd never been to her place before. 
 It's near the bottom end of Ladbroke Grove, almost due south of where I used to live up until about this time last year. 
 Where Jenny lives  is very much the smart side of town and the flat is gorgeous. 
 &bquo;It belongs to my flatmate's parents,&equo; she said, by way of an apology as she showed me around. 
 &bquo;It's an amazing place, isn't it? 
 And they ask me for hardly any rent, which is the other nice thing about it.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's no justice in this world,&equo; I said. 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;You know, I pay less than half what people are charged for staying in a night shelter. 
 Crazy, isn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;How long have you lived here?&equo; 
 &bquo;Since Christmas, just about. 
 It gets a bit crowded when Camilla's boyfriend is here, but they're on holiday at the moment.&equo; 
 The tour finished in the kitchen and she started to busy herself around the cooker. 
 &bquo;We're having fish,&equo; she informed me. 
 &bquo;It's supposed to be less fattening.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're not back on a man-prowl, are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Pathetic, isn't it? 
 This sauce, by the way, is going to be absolutely brilliant &mdash; oh sorry, I've got to stop saying that, haven't I? 
 How are you getting on with your new housemates?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine. 
 They've been a great help, actually. 
 Everyone's 
 &bquo;How about the book? 
 How's that going?&equo; 
 &bquo;OK, I think. 
 It's amazing some of the things that have come back to me. 
 Do you need a hand with anything?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I'm fine. 
 Do you really think they'll close down your old college?&equo; 
 &bquo;Probably. 
 They've got to shut something and it's as good a candidate as any. 
 It's sad in some ways. 
 Small teaching centres like that can be really effective sometimes.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is anyone going to get the push &agrave; la Dorothy, do you think?&equo;  
 &bquo;Not in quite the same way as me, probably. 
 Funnily enough it's not the people like me who usually do get the boot in academic life, it's the people with real talent who generally have a hard time.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why's that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Partly common or garden jealousy, I think, and partly because they tend not to get involved in all the politics that goes on.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where I work's the same, just about. 
 Mind you, I do all right so I can't complain.&equo; 
 &bquo;That doesn't necessarily follow.&equo; 
 She smiled ruefully. 
 &bquo;On the subject of life not being fair, I met someone else who was homeless the other day. 
 I did all the usual stuff &mdash; I gave her some money and stuck her on a tube train to a night shelter, but while I was walking out of the tube station, I thought to myself, &bquo;you complacent bitch&equo;&equo; you know. 
 It reminded me of when I used to give people money just to make them go away again. 
 There isn't an enormous difference, let's face it.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's grounded in something more now.&equo; 
 &bquo;What should I have done?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know &mdash; it changes with every person you meet. 
 The trick is, I think, to do the &bquo;compassionate&equo; thing. 
 Compassion's an interesting word &mdash; when you break it down it literally means &bquo;to suffer with&equo;. 
 If you really want to help someone, I think you have to make an effort to suffer with them &mdash; to see it from their point of view &mdash; and then to do something.&equo; 
 &bquo;I felt I could do that with you, but it was more difficult with her &mdash; partly because she was about the same age as me probably.&equo; 
 She started bringing the food over. 
 &bquo;I know you don't like homeless people being stereotyped as a bunch of alcoholics,&equo; she began, &bquo;but did you ever meet any of the real meths drinkers?&equo;  
 &bquo;People do have a fascination with that, don't they? 
 An alcoholic is a pretty unglamorous thing to be, actually.&equo; 
 She smiled. 
 Who have you met among the homeless that's surprised you?&equo; 
 &bquo;There are a lot more youngsters with the problem than I thought there were. 
 They keep getting these ridiculous benefit cuts as well, which just defeat me actually.&equo; 
 &bquo;You know why I think they do it? 
 While I was up at university, an awful lot of students from wealthy backgrounds were fiddling the dole somehow, and I reckon that the politicians and civil servants think that all they're in fact doing is cutting their own children's pocket money. 
 It hasn't occurred to them that some people might actually have to survive on any money they're given.&equo; 
 She poured us a glass of wine each. 
 &bquo;Well they need to wake up to reality a bit. 
 Thank you. 
 Another classic bit of government fantasy-think is the Community Care programme. 
 They chuck all these people out of mental hospitals on the excuse that everyone in the community is spontaneously going to start looking after them &mdash; and surprise, surprise, they start turning up on the night shelter circuit. 
 It costs a lot in human suffering, but saves money, which is what matters now, supposedly.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh brave new world,&equo; Jenny murmured. 
 &bquo;Mankind is beauteous indeed.&equo; 
 &bquo;Pardon?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's the rest of that quote. 
 &bquo;How beauteous mankind is. 
 O brave new world, that has such people in it.&equo;&equo; 
 Jenny raised her glass. 
 &bquo;Here's to us girls,&equo; she said. 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;To us girls. 
 And to the future.&equo;  
 That just about wraps it up. 
 My blue period officially ends when we have a big leaving party for Kathleen and Katrina in a couple of days' time but in fact it probably ends just about now. 
 So, what are you going to make of all this? 
 Well, however it struck you, it's a slice of life and I hope you found it interesting enough just for that. 
 What good can it do? 
 I don't know, but maybe tomorrow you will come across someone who is homeless &mdash; maybe in desperate need of help, maybe asleep and just wishing, for the moment, to be left in peace. 
 That person may have been a university lecturer, a teacher, a receptionist, a cleaner, a waitress or anything. 
 She may have made a mess of her life; she may have faced problems beyond your comprehension. 
 One thing is certain: she is human &mdash; one of God's children and equal in His eyes to you. 
 Do whatever you believe in your heart of hearts is God's will, and that will be that. 
 I'm not setting myself up as a model for anyone. 
 This applies just as much to me as it may do to you. 
 And by the way, if you think that all homeless people have it as easy as I had it, then you are living in dream world. 
 The book now goes on to my sister and what happens next is up to her.  
 I honestly can't for the life of me figure out how to express the rest so I hope you'll forgive me if I stop here. 
 The words just won't come any more, so I'm going to put my biro down and go off to the post.  
 Gardeners' World 
 BBC Advice, Ideas and Inspiration from your BBC experts 
 September 1991 &pound;1.30 
 You can win a great new patio 
 Pippa Wood How to cope with a slope 
 Bulbs plant now for spring blooms 
 Geoff Hamilton's weed solution 
 Autumn on display How to create a colourful show of late blooms 
 Apples our pick of the crop 
 BBC Gardeners' World 
 Regulars 
 Garden News 
 Dates for the dairy, news and reviews and brand new colourful seed mixtures for you to try for free. 
 And anyway&hellip; 
 The grass is always greener when 700 people haven't tramped across your lawn, reflects Alan Titchmarsh. 
 Over the fence 
 Share your gardening views and stories on our readers' letters page. 
 Garden clippins 
 We take a peek into the gardening notebook of Radio 5's Richard Jackson. 
 Action for September 
 Time to start planning ahead; be prepared and follow our garden schedule. 
 Next month 
 Our October overview shows you what's in store in next month's magazine. 
 Readers' original gardening tips 
 Has your clever idea won a &pound;50 cash prize this month? 
 Turn to our page of tips. 
 Beechgrove garden 
 As the TV series nears the end of its run, the trio of BBC experts at Aberdeen have some final words of advice and topical tips for gardeners north of the border. 
 Gardening in tomorrow's world 
 A glimpse of the future with Dr Phil Gates; could a fungus become the gardener's best friend? 
 Question time 
 Our BBC experts track down elusive edging and special spades among other queries. 
 TV and Radio Guide 
 Don't miss your favourite gardening programmes and presenters with our four-page guide to the month's broadcasts. 
 Organic gardening 
 Green gardening 
 Waging war on weeds Geoff Hamilton finds that close planting beats the weeds, and a spot of pond maintenance keeps nature's own living pest controllers happy in the organic gardens at Barnsdale. 
 Organic advice 
 Another batch of green-tinted tips from the experts at the National Centre for Organic Gardening. 
 Practical Project 
 Planting by numbers 
 Our easy to follow, illustrated guide shows you how to create a lively border of perennials for a welcome display of late summer colour. 
 Plants 
 Colour creations 
 The heavy mob Nigel Colborn demonstrates a light touch with heavy soil as he picks out plants that positively enjoy feet of clay. 
 Specialist spotlight 
 Apple appeal Graham Rice takes the graft out of choosing apple rootstocks and varieties as he visits a specialist fruit tree nursery. 
 Portrait gallery 
 Rays of sunshine Simple yet stunning, perennial daisies captivate Roy Lancaster's  discerning eye this month as he profiles some of his favourites. 
 Flower garden 
 Little wonders Early miniature bulbs bring a breath of spring to the garden; Anne Swithinbank shows that good things come in small packages. 
 Gardens by design 
 Design project 
 Straight and narrow Part one of David Stevens' new series sets out the plans for his transformation of a long, narrow garden. 
 Houseplants 
 Take the plunge 
 Follow Daphne Ledward's signposts to success with indoor bulbs for winter colour, plus our step-by-step guide for glorious hyacinth blooms on Christmas morning. 
 Living with houseplants 
 Carol Kurrein has more advice for the budding greenery genius in your home. 
 Gardens 
 Out of the woods 
 Geoffrey Smith profiles trees both native and exotic, and explains how a garden tree and its companion planting forms a focal point for the eye and, just as importantly, for wildlife. 
 TV special 
 Cope with a slope If you've got the inclination, she's got the advice; Pippa Greenwood gives a new and refreshing slant on overcoming the problems of a sloping garden. 
 Kitchen garden 
 Joy Larkcom explains the value of living, green manures to soil 
 enrichment. 
 The 60-minute vegetable plot 
 Roy Lacey returns from holiday just in time to foil the advance of an army of weeds on his hour-a-week garden larder. 
 Vegetable grow guide 
 Perfect peppers can be yours as this month's cut-out-and-keep growing guide focuses on &bquo;Gypsy&equo;, &bquo;Bellboy&equo; and their capsicum colleagues. 
 The Victorian kitchen garden 
 Though such drastic and dangerous procedures as nicotine fumigation may be a thing of the past, today's organic gardener can still learn much from Harry Dodson's traditional methods of pest control. 
 Competitions and offers 
 Competition 
 Win a patio A superb new Bradstone patio is waiting to be custom-designed and built in your garden in our great new competition. 
 Competition 
 Win a Renault Clio Solve part two of our plant identity parade and you've the chance to win a fantastic new car. 
 Subscriptions and binders 
 You never miss an issue with our brilliant 15-for-12 subscription offer, so why not treat yourself to a specially-priced binder to keep them in, too? 
 Back issues 
 Our first six issues are the gardening collectors' items of the year. 
 Order the numbers you missed with our special coupon. 
 Welcome&hellip; 
 Coping with a slope is a major headache for thousands of people. 
 While the inclination may vary from a modest rise to a mountainside, there are a few golden rules you can follow. 
 When Pauline and Chris Lloyd of Dudley moved house then took on a new garden with a 1 in 3 slope. 
 They didn't know where they were going to start. 
 When television's Gardeners' World heard of their plight they set about lending a hand. 
 This month Pippa Greenwood shows the results of their work in a special feature with some great tips of her own. 
 Get set for a bulb bonanza too. 
 Whether you're looking for bowls of bulbs to brighten the home or the best miniatures for a rock garden, now's the time to start work and Daphne Ledward and Anne Swithinbank are here to pass on a host of colourful ideas. 
 And finally, a very warn Gardeners' World welcome to Richard Jackson, who presents Garden Clippins on BBC Radio 5's Saturday breakfast programme. 
 Richard is joining us every month to pass on tips, ideas and news from the world of horticulture, and add a touch of humour too. 
 Until next month, happy reading and good gardening.  
 Dovecote deliberations in this month's Question Time, p80 
 A friendly fungus, p79 
 Violets don't shrink from a heavy soil &mdash; Nigel Colborn on clay, p26 
 Apple growing made as easy as pie 
 Anne Swithinbank's brilliant bulbs for early colour, p64 
 Pests of the past on p45 
 Robins mark out territory in this wildlife garden, p30 
 NEWS AND VIEWS 
 Garden news 
 Your monthly guide to news and views from the world of gardening 
 Complimentary colours 
 One-colour borders have been enjoying renewed popularity recently, and Mr Fothergill's Seeds has come up with the perfect quick answer to monochrome gardening. 
 The new Colour Schemes seed mixtures come in five different colour: yellow, orange, pink, blue and white. 
 They cost &pound;1.99 each and contain three sachets of seeds in shades of the chosen colour, graded by height into small, medium and large varieties. 
 We have joined Mr Fothergill's to offer 200 sets in each colour to our readers: a total of 1,000 packets to give away! 
 Each packet includes a leaflet giving full instructions for successful cultivation. 
 Send your address and colour choice (one colour only per applicant) on a postcard to: Colour Schemes/ BBC Gardeners' World Magazine  Offer, c/o Mr Fothergill's Seeds, Gazeley Road, Kentford, Newmarket, Suffolk CB8 7QB. 
 Winners will be drawn after September 7. 
 Set sale for Scotland 
 If you're always admiring unusual bulbs you seen in botanical and National Trust gardens, but don't know where to get them, head for Greenbank Gardens this month. 
 On September 14 and 15 the staff and friends of Greenbank hold a big sale of unusual bulbs for discerning gardeners. 
 Greenbank is at Clarkston, Glasgow. 
 Tel: 041&ndash;639 3281. 
 Redistribute your reading matter 
 If you've snapped up one our handsome binders you'll find, towards the end of the year, that because we've been able to pack so many pages into Britain's newest, brightest gardening magazine, things are getting, well, rather full. 
 Easy the congestion with a very special binder for our pull-out-and-keep Gardeners' Manual, and keep this invaluable reference work together and always to hand. 
 See our offer on p50. 
 Show your onions 
 Around 22,000 visitors are expected at the North of England Horticultural Society's autumn show on September 13 and 14. 
 This year the show includes the National Kelsae Onion festival and terrific nursery exhibits. 
 Tickets for Friday cost &pound;5 between 10am and 4pm; &pound;3 from &pound;4 to 8pm. 
 Saturday: &pound;4.50 at any time between 9.30am and 5pm.  
 Did you know&hellip; 
 Plant collecting has been going on for thousands of years. 
 Although the Victorian era is considered to be the great age of plant collectors, the ancient Egyptians recorded plant collecting expeditions in their hieroglyphics. 
 The earliest of these was in 1495BC, when frankincense trees were brought back from the Horn of Africa for Queen Hatshepsut. 
 Apple pie order 
 Learn everything you ever wanted to know about apples while tasting cider and trying out some scrumptious apple recipes at Priorwood Garden, Roxburghshire on September 29. 
 The Apple Day runs from 2&ndash;6pm and includes an apple question time session, with experts on hand to identify your mystery apples and diagnose any problems. 
 Priorwood Gardens are at Melrose, Roxburghshire. 
 Tel: 031&ndash;336 2157 for further details. 
 Grandad's rosy new hebe 
 This attractive new hebe is appropriately called &bquo;Rosie&equo;, after the grand-daughter of John Tooby (above), of Bransford Nurseries. 
 &bquo;Rosie&equo; grows 30cm high, and about twice as wide, in well-drained soil in sun or part-shade, and is hardy. 
 It will be available from garden centres this autumn. 
 For any further information, contact Bransford Nurseries. 
 Tel: 0886&ndash;32369. 
 Don't miss&hellip; 
 See Suttons Seeds' trial grounds at Ippleden, near Newton Abbot, Devon on their open days: August 30 and 31, 9.30an-4.30pm. 
 Suttons experts will be there to answer questions, too. 
 A town and country show 
 The Town &amp; Country Garden exhibited by the Sunday Express in association with BBC Gardeners' World Magazine  at the Royal Show can be seen again this month. 
 Designed by Faith and Geoffrey Whiten, it features both paved and lawned areas, with terracotta pots, a raised pond, colourful borders and a handsome summerhouse. 
 The Town &amp; Country Festival at the RASE Showground, Stoneleigh, Warks is on August 24&ndash;26. 
 Tel: 0203&ndash;696969 for details.  
 Torbay tip 
 The Torbay Flower Festival runs from August 23 to 26 on Paignton Green, Devon. 
 Catch nursery exhibits and question time sessions 10am-6pm Bank Holiday Monday. 
 Price &pound;2. 
 Topical topiary 
 Fancy shapes and pointed pyramids are all part of the famous gardens of Levens Hall. 
 They were laid out in the formal style 300 years ago by James II's gardener, Guillaume Beaumont. 
 Since Beaumont's days, there have been just ten head gardeners down the generations. 
 Levens Hall opens regularly through the season, and on September 23 for the National Gardens Scheme. 
 Levens Hall is 5m south of Kendal, in Cumbria. 
 Did you know&hellip; 
 The sting of a nettle works in just the same way as a hypodermic syringe. 
 The cell walls in the &bquo;stings&equo; on the stems contain silica, a glass-like substance; they puncture the skin, and then the irritant poison is released. 
 Floral arts 
 Gather the blooms of late summer and early autumn to create flower arrangements of the past. 
 Jane Newdick's recently published book, Period Flowers , draws on inspiration from medieval times onwards to make inspiring flower arrangements great and small. 
 Price &pound;16.95 from Charles Letts. 
 Autumnal delights 
 The Royal Horticultural Society's Great Autumn Show is their second largest show after Chelsea, held in their old and new halls in Greycoat St. SW1. 
 As well as fine produce displays, the show will be packed with nursery exhibits and the best of autumnal flower displays. 
 The show is on September 17 (11am-7pm, tickets &pound;3.50) and September 18 (10am-5pm, &pound;2.50). 
 Tel: 071&ndash;834 4333.  
 And anyway&hellip; 
 Phew! 
 We finally did it. 
 The garden was flung open the day before yesterday and I'm still reeling. 
 You may recall that earlier in the year I burdened you with my worries. 
 Well, after much deliberation and a family pow-wow or two we decided we'd give it a go one Sunday afternoon, between the hours of 2 and 6pm. 
 We decided not to do teas, you may remember. 
 Then one lady wrote and said that the ladies of the local church should do it for us. 
 If they refused we were to let her know and she'd write to the bishop. 
 Thankfully, it didn't get that far. 
 One of our neighbours rang to say she'd booked the village hall and she and her ladies would be doing scones and tea. 
 The proceeds would be in aid of the same charity as our garden opening. 
 Then the local Lions rang up. 
 Where were the cars going to park? 
 In the village hall car park, was the answer. 
 The Lions would provide us with signs and men to act as car park attendants. 
 Slight unease on my part. 
 This thing was growing. 
 Was the garden up to it? 
 For two days beforehand, my lady-who-does-in-the-garden and myself worked flat out. 
 Weeding, edging, mowing, prinking, pruning; we did the lot. 
 Piles of stones were moved by hands blistered by besoms. 
 Shrub roses were trussed to let people pass; signs erected to divert visitors from the non-scenic compost heap. 
 The night before, the man from the Lions rang. 
 He hadn't seen any posters in the village. 
 Would people know about the opening? 
 I worried all night, lest the listing in the local paper and in the Order of St John country handbook had not been enough. 
 I'd refrained from advertising any more for fear that we would be overwhelmed. 
 Had I actually erred on the discreet side? 
 The day came. 
 I woke to the sound of torrential rain. 
 Eventually it stopped. 
 At about 1.40pm cars started to appear and people were seen walking up the road. 
 The garden became like an ants' nest as snaking rows of people clambered up our hillside. 
 At 2.45 the car park started overflowing into neighbours' drives. 
 Have you ever seen your garden absolutely full of bodies? 
 It's quite a sight. 
 By 5.45pm it was all over. 
 We'd been visited by 700 people. 
 Nothing was pinched, nothing was moved. 
 I have not found one cigarette end or one piece of waste paper. 
 People left smiling and as I passed one lady on her way down the hill she grinned at me and said &bquo;Perfick&equo;! 
 We are shattered and so is the garden. 
 But after slaving over something for ten years, it is rather nice to show it off a bit. 
 Would we do it again? 
 You bet. 
  Alan Titchmarch  
 Sharp choice for pruning 
 Gardeners know the value of a really sharp knife for pruning as well as propagating. 
 These sharp tools are from Sandvik's range of gardening knives. 
 From left: the curved P20 pruning knife features a carbon steel blade (&pound;11.99), as does the P11 budding knife (&pound;10.99); the S4 pruning knife is in stainless steel and comes with shackle and strap and its own mini-sharpening steel (&pound;12.99). 
 For your local stocklists, contact Sandvik. 
 Tel: 021&ndash;550 4700. 
 Spring pansy 
 There was an overwhelming response to our May competition to name the new pansy from Suttons Seeds. 
 The judges sifted through over 8,000 entries and finally picked the name &bquo;Spring Ovation&equo; as the winner. 
 Seven readers wrote in suggesting this name, so one entry was drawn out of a hat: Mrs Joan Davis of Chipping Sodbury, Bristol is the winner of an Al-Ko shredder.  
 Win a patio 
 Paving the way 
 In this month's competition you could win a prize patio worth &pound;3,000, designed and built by a Chelsea medal-winner 
 Whether yours is a family garden which has to sustain the rigorous attentions of children, a more sedate garden for entertaining al fresco, or a small city garden with little room for more than a couple of raised flowers beds, a patio can give your home and lifestyle a whole new dimension. 
 High quality paving 
 Bradstone, leading producers of high quality paving and walling products, is pleased to offer out prizewinner the opportunity to do just that in this exciting competition to win a patio worth &pound;3,000. 
 Part of your prize will be a consultation with celebrated Chelsea medal-winning builder Alan Sargent, who will listen to your requirements and advise on the most suitable design. 
 You may prefer a large and simple paved terrace area, or something smaller, incorporating raised beds and a barbecue. 
 With Alan's guidance, you will choose from the Bradstone range of paving and walling. 
 Authenticity and quality are the Bradstone trademarks; many of its paving and waling products are taken from natural stone masters in order to reproduce the varying surfaces and edge details of quarried or weathered stone. 
 Colours are natural too, from the buff-coloured Wetherdale paving, reminiscent of York stone, to the weathered red Riven paving designed to complement brick. 
 Spring into action 
 Your new patio will be designed and built in time for spring when you can really enjoy it to the full. 
 Two runners-up will win Bradstone Riven paving and Cotswall walling to construct a planter seat, an instant way to add colour and character to the garden. 
 How to enter 
 Below are six requirements for a patio which we want you to place in order of importance: 
 A 
 Near to house 
 B 
 Sunny aspect 
 C 
 Slip-resistant 
 D 
 Sheltered from the wind 
 E 
 Easy to maintain 
 F 
 Paving design complementary to house 
 Send your answers (for example, 1=E, 2=A and so on) and your name and address on a postcard to: BBC Gardeners' World Magazine  /Bradstone Competition, PO Box 55, Wetherby, West Yorks LS23 7ET to arrive by first post on Friday September 13, 1991. 
 The first entry drawn after the closing date which matches the judges' decision will win.  
 Patio built using Bradstone Wetherdale paving and brick-on-edge coping 
 Authenticity is one of Bradstone's trademarks 
 Over the fence 
 Your chance to air you news, views and, of course, those gardening anecdotes 
 Letter of the month 
 An alternative use for peat alternative My mum buys your magazine, and I read about Geoff Hamilton's cocopeat trials. 
 We have cocopeat in our flowerpots and it is very good, but there is one drawback Geoff didn't mention. 
 Birds, especially blackbirds, like using the fibres for building nests. 
 They went along all our pots getting the fibres out. 
 They even tried next door, but when they discovered our neighbours don't use cocopeat, they came straight back again! 
 Helen Care (11), Grays, Essex  
 Standing up for koi: well-fed fish leave tadpoles in peace 
 Gooseberries are top of the crops when trained as standards 
 End mowing misery with with gravel in the garden 
 Koi controversy 
 I would like to take issue with Geoffrey Smith about koi in the garden pond (The living pond, June). 
 Mine don't eat tadpoles, perhaps because I feed them regularly. 
 In fact, we have watched the fish take tadpoles into their mouths, then swiftly eject them. 
 One morning there were over 2,000 tadpoles in my pond (I was bailing them out temporarily because the liner had a leak, so I was counting them too!). 
 During March there were at least 14 pairs of frogs, plus toads (and spawn). 
 Dragon flies and damsel flies are regular visitors. 
 As we live only a short distance from the Thames, we have to keep a net over the pond, as two years ago we lost 18 fish to a heron. 
 Magpies also use marginal plants to watch for fish. 
 As you may have gathered, I am a pond fanatic! 
 Mrs J Margetts, Kennington, Oxford 
 Setting a royal standard 
 Why is Prince Charles's support for organic gardening and farming continually ridicules by the daily newspapers? 
 As we gardeners know, a very high percentage of gardens are now tended this way. 
 It's no longer thought of as cranky or old-fashioned, as the press tries to make out, but as a much-needed way of helping to preserve this world by finding alternatives to chemicals and peat-cutting. 
 Mrs S R Monk, Essex 
 Born with green fingers 
 Two years ago our garden was just a desolate area of rubble left by the builders: now I dread ever having to leave it. 
 My 18-year-old son has transformed it, miraculously in such a short time, into a garden which is the envy of neighbours. 
 Best of all, the wildlife is back; ladybirds, butterflies, birds and bees, even frogs are all to be seen. 
 He seems to have a natural ability which encourages plants to grow well. 
 Would I be right in thinking that there really are people with &bquo;green fingers&equo; and should we be doing more to encourage our younger generation to take an active interest in the garden? 
 Norma Gee, Basingstoke 
 So grateful for gravel 
 I never thought I'd say that a sneak thief had done us a favour. 
 However, having carelessly left the shed unlocked, our mower and strimmer were stolen and, as we are both getting on a bit, we decided we would take up the lawn and put down gravel instead. 
 Oh, the bliss of it! 
 No more mowing and everything else. 
 Now I know what law-maintenance gardening is &mdash; fantastic! 
 Mrs Jean Wilson, Sheffield 
 Gooseberries shape up 
 I would like to let the lady looking for standard gooseberry plants (Question Time, June) know how I obtained mine. 
 I bought a really cheap gooseberry bush from a local store, making sure I picked one with good straight uncut stems (I think its variety was &bquo;Leveller&equo;). 
 I cut all but the strongest, straightest stem away close to the base and planted the resulting &bquo;twig&equo; in a pot of good compost. 
 I staked it and nipped out sideshoots as they appeared, exactly as one would when making a fuchsia into a standard. 
 When it reached about 3ft I pinched out the top to make it branch, which it did most satisfactorily. 
 It now looks very well in a 15in pot, staked against wind damage and regularly fed, and in its first year yielded a crop of more than 3lb of berries. 
 This year it looks as if I will have even more. 
 A real success story, don't you agree? 
 Shelagh Williams, Cheltenham, Gloucestershire 
 More sweet pea wrinkles 
 With reference to the article in June on breaking dormancy in sweet peas: experiments conducted over a period of several years at New College, Pontefract certainly seem to bear out Anne Swithinbank's remarks. 
 There does indeed seem to be little advantage in damaging the coat of modern varieties of sweet peas. 
 However, it has also been observed that those with wrinkled testa (coats) appear to be slower to germinate and may well benefit  from piercing, scratching or abrasion. 
 I hope this may of interest to other gardeners. 
 Martin V Dawson, Pontefract, W Yorks 
 Tips for Titchmarsh 
 May I suggest that Alan Titchmarsh does one or all of the following in order to fill his pool in summer (And anyway&hellip; 
 , July). 
 1 Plans a series of barbecues 2 Plants quantities of sun-loving plants (see Nigel Colborn, August) 3 Buys new garden furniture with a view to relaxing in the sun in style 4 Cancels foreign holiday in view of expected superb weather at home 5 Offers his garden to his local theatre company for its summer season of outdoor plays. 
 In my experience, any combination of the above ensures continuous rain for the next three months! 
 Angela Blanchard, Keighley, W. Yorks 
 Pools win 
 I enjoyed the articles on water gardening in the July issue. 
 When starting my pond, I was overwhelmed by the generosity of friends and neighbours with all sorts of pond plants. 
 Now, five years later my pond is well-stocked with plants and fish, and I am able to give out plants in turn. 
 Each spring sees frog spawn followed by tiny frogs &mdash; a tremendous bonus, because my snail and slug problem has been greatly reduced without a single pellet! 
 Rob Perdue, Hampshire 
 Cup that cheers camellia 
 We have alkaline soil, and so the growing of camellias, rhododendrons, pieris etc is not easy. 
 In these days of concern for the environment I am unwilling to use peat (though I did try it some years ago and found my plants made little headway anyway). 
 However, cold tea, and emptying the teapot around the plants has a tremendous effect; my camellia has glossy new leaves and two new flowers, and a tiny pieris is also pushing its red bracts through. 
 The trouble is that I am not a tea-drinker, and so my plants get only the occasional treat when guests visit. 
 Perhaps we could instigate a national drive to recycle on a grand scale &mdash; from restaurants, BR etc &mdash; and sell them as a peat alternative! 
 Joan Chapman, Avon 
 The editor writes: The tannic acid in tea will certainly acidify your soil, making it more agreeable to lime-hating plants. 
 However, it is difficult to generate sufficient supplies! 
 Where to write 
 Send your letters to: Over the Fence, BBC Gardeners' World Magazine , 20&ndash;26 Brunswick Place, London N1 6DJ. 
 Each letter published will win its writer a &pound;10 National Garden Gift Token, exchangeable at 1,500 garden centres, nurseries and shops all over the UK and any Interflora shop. 
 Identity parade 
 Name the plants and win a car 
 In association with Renault and the Horticultural Trades Association, we are proud to present the second instalment of our fantastic six-part competition to win a stylish new five-door Renault Clio RT 1.4. 
 And there's a fabulous &pound;1,500 worth of HTA National Garden Gift Tokens, redeemable at garden centres, nurseries and garden shops, to be shared among our monthly prizewinners. 
 How to enter 
 Pictured here is our second pair of the HTA's Plants of the Month for 1991. 
 We are publishing pictures of two of these in each issue until January 1992. 
 The first five entries drawn after September 7 1991 to identify these two plants correctly will win &pound;50 of National Garden Gift Tokens. 
 Answers to each part of the competition will be printed two months' later. 
 But that's not all. 
 Remember to keep a note of your answers, because in our January issue we will be asking you to name all twelve of the HTA's 1991 Plants of the Year. 
 If your correct entry is the first to be drawn you'll be driving away a fantastic new Renault Clio RT 1.4 voted Car of the Year! 
 Send your entries, to arrive by September 7 1991, on a postcard to: BBC Gardeners' World Magazine  /Renault Competition, PO Box 55, Wetherby, West Yorkshire LS23 7ET. 
 To catch up with the first part of the competition, the August issue can be obtained from our Back Issues Service, see p51.   
 A pond is soon established and will give years of pleasure 
 Favourite flowering shrub for early spring, vigorous and hardy 
 Slow-growing, conical conifer, with glaucous blue-green leaves 
 Garden clippings 
 In the first of a new series, Richard Jackson of Radio 5's Morning Edition looks at the quirky side of gardening life 
 Sweet scent of success 
 There are many personal reasons for choosing a rose and for me, scent is one of the most important. 
 I asked Roger Pawsey of Cants, Mark Mattock, Gareth Fryer, Ken Grapes of the Royal National Rose Society and Robert Harkness, five of the country's leading rose experts, to name their personal choice of the most highly scented hybrid teas and floribundas. 
 Top of the poll came: 
 Margaret Merril 
 A delicate blushing white floribunda. 
 Fragrant Cloud 
 The famous dusky-scarlet hybrid tea 
 Velvet Fragrance 
 A classic hybrid tea with rich, dark velvety crimson flowers. 
 Paul Shirville 
 Another hybrid tea, a subtle peach pink with romantic, ruffled petals. 
 Korresia 
 A floribunda with bright gold-yellow, wavy-edged petals. 
 To find which of the five is the most fragrant, we'll be holding a studio sniff-in on Morning Edition at 8.45am on Saturday August 31. 
 So do listen in! 
 Show for the smart and crafty 
 Some gardeners will do anything to win prizes (marrows filled with lead shot to add weight, for instance), but there's one show where cheating is positively encouraged. 
 It's the Alternative Flower Show held annually in the village hall at Beadness, near Ainwick in Northumberland. 
 Categories include Superweed, Hanging's Too Good For It (for hanging baskets), and The Most Mis-shapen Potato. 
 The craft section includes Heaviest Scones (cement was used last year) and The Fruit Cake With The Most Fruit At The Bottom. 
 This year's show takes place on Saturday 31 August between 2 and 4.30pm, but don't hang about &mdash; at 6pm sharp the Over 60's Karate and Flower Arranging Class takes over, or so I'm told. 
 I believe every word. 
 Strawberry taste on trial 
 This month we're starting a trial to discover the best-tasting strawberries. 
 We've asked Ken Muir, of the famous fruit nursery, to select eight varieties of strawberry for the test. 
 He's chosen Royal Sovereign, Tenira (his own favourite), Elsanta, Cambridge Favourite, Honeoye, Korona, Bounty and a new variety, Pegasus. 
 We're looking for ten volunteers to take part, each of whom will be sent five plants of each of the eight varieties to grow. 
 The plants will be despatched at the end of September, with full cultural instructions. 
 We'll ask the testers next summer which, in their opinion, are the best-flavoured. 
 If you'd like to take part, write to Richard Jackson, Morning Edition, BBC Radio 5, Broadcasting House, London W1A 1AA, stating why you would like to participate. 
 We'll read out the names of the chosen testers on the programme on Saturday September 21. 
 In search of oddity 
 There is just one problem with that essential book Gardens of England and Wales Open to the Public 1991  &mdash; there are over 2,600 gardens to choose from. 
 Since most sound idyllic, I seek out those with that little extra something. 
 Who could resist &bquo;One acre of reclaimed wilderness populated by a variety of plants that can withstand ignorant malpractice, all planted by the ad hoc topsy school of garden design&equo;? 
 Or the &bquo;washing-line garden&equo; or &bquo;new derelict secret garden&equo;? 
 Sussex gardens offer a glimpse of sheep, while Norfolk gardens go one better with hydraulic rams! 
 If my wife manages to elbow her way past me to the book first, she's immediately led astray by extras like &bquo;free use of private beach&equo;, &bquo;heated swimming pool&equo; or &bquo;wine-tasting&equo;. 
 And she'll travel miles for &bquo;Cream teas&equo;&hellip;  
 Tune in to Richard Jackson on Radio 5's Morning Edition every Saturday at 8.45am. 
 gardeners' Diary 
 Action for September 
 The month of berries, harvests and the autumn equinox, with the days getting noticeably shorter and the nights longer and cooler 
 The Flower Garden 
 Even before autumn sets in, gardeners start thinking about spring and putting in bulbs for next year 
 &bull; 
 Plant spring-flowering bulbs. 
 Put them between shrubs and herbaceous plants in beds and borders. 
 Choose dwarf varieties to plant in rock gardens. 
 &bull; 
 Take out faded annuals to make room for spring bedding plants. 
 In mild areas and on light soils start sowing hardy annuals. 
 &bull; 
 Plant evergreen hedges between mid-September and mid-October. 
 Water newly-planted shrubs regularly during prolonged periods of dry weather. 
 &bull; 
 Plant out hardy biennials such as wallflowers. 
 Set them out with a trowel in well watered ground. 
 &bull; 
 Harden off cuttings of rooted pinks, planting out the strongest growing in the batch. 
 &bull; 
 Continue to dead-head or cut down spent flowers of herbaceous plants where necessary. 
 &bull; 
 Feed dahlias fortnightly with a liquid fertiliser to maintain blooms and build up stout tubers. 
 Ensure plants are well staked. 
 &bull; 
 Control mildew on Michaelmas daisies and roses with Nimrod-T (ICI). 
 Ensure plants are well watered in dry weather. 
 &bull; 
 Roses may still need to be sprayed against black spot and rust. 
 Use a proprietary fungicide such as Murphy Tumbleblite (Fisons) or Systhane (pbi). 
 Remove and burn any blackspot-infected leaves. 
 &bull; 
 Take rose cuttings from strong shoots, 9&ndash;12in long. 
 Put in a V-shaped trench 6in apart above a layer of course sand. 
 Fill trench with light soil and water well. 
 Ensure that they don't dry out. 
 &bull; 
 Plant Iris reticulata  in groups 2in deep and 2in apart. 
 Plant Iris unguicularis  in free-draining, poor soil in a sheltered position. 
 &bull; 
 Prune weeping standard roses by cutting back stems which flowered this year. 
 &bull; 
 Tie in the new shoots on climbing roses, bending them over horizontally to encourage flowering side shoots. 
 &bull; 
 Prepare the ground now for planting hardy evergreen shrubs. 
 Work in plenty of well-rotted manure or garden compost into the planting area, and a handful of bonemeal fertiliser for every sq yd to assist root establishment. 
 &bull; 
 Continue to water ornamental plants in containers and hanging baskets as necessary. 
 When flowering is over clean containers and put away until next year, or pot up with winter pansies.  
 &bull; 
 This is a good month to buy new climbers at the garden centre. 
 Planting now will give them a damp season to get the roots established before next spring. 
 &bull; 
 Dig over, remove weeds and add manure to prepare new borders for planting. 
 More miniatures 
 Now is the time to start taking cuttings of miniature roses. 
 Take 3in-long shoots of this season's growth and trim to just below a leaf bud. 
 Dip the base into a hormone rooting compound and insert into a free-draining compost. 
 Keep your cutting shaded and pot on when well rooted. 
 Overwinter under cover and plant out in late spring. 
 Dead-head day lilies regularly for continued flowering. 
 Once flowers are over, cut the faded stems back to ground level. 
 Plant daffodils in informal groups; don't plant tulips until November 
 Plant bulbs of Iris reticulata  in the rock garden for spring blooms 
 Remove and burn leaves on rose bushes infected by blackspot 
 Ponds and water life 
 Fine September days with the last of the summer sun present the ideal time to build a new pond 
 &bull; 
 Supplies of live food start to decrease in September, so remember to feed fish. 
 They don't feed when the water is cold however, and will survive through winter without feeding. 
 &bull; 
 When feeding fish, give them high-protein food and a supplement of dried daphnia each day. 
 &bull; 
 This is a good month to construct pools, while there are still some fine days left to complete the work before winter. 
 &bull; 
 Hardy bog plants propagated earlier can be set out in their permanent positions at the poolside. 
 Lawns and turf 
 This is a good month for sowing seeds lawns, but make sure the ground is fully prepared first. 
 &bull; 
 Scarify the lawn vigorously by raking in two directions with a spring-tined rake or scarifier to remove debris and thatch. 
 &bull; 
 Lawn can be treated with a proprietary autumn fertiliser. 
 Don't be tempted to use up the remains of a summer lawn fertiliser, which will contain too much nitrogen. 
 &bull; 
 Spike compacted areas with a garden fork, hollow-tined fork or mechanical aerator to encourage vital air exchange at the roots. 
 &bull; 
 Mowing can usually be done less regularly during September as the grass starts to grow at a slower rate. 
 Raise the height of cut accordingly. 
 Planning ahead 
 Charles Patman 
 Plant dwarf spring flowering bulbs such as Anemone blanda , chionodoxa and snowdrops to form carpets of colour beneath established shrubs. 
 The anemones will prefer being planted in full sun, as their flowers don't open so well when put in a shady position. 
 Towards the end of the month, begin to strip down hanging baskets and replant them with winter-flowering pansies to provide colour through the darker winter days. 
 Pot up the summer's fuchsias and geraniums and store them in a frost-free position over winter. 
 Tune in to Charles Patman on BBC Radio Peterborough. 
 Quick guide to September 
 Flower garden 
 &bull; 
 Plant spring bulbs, but leave tulips until November 
 &bull; 
 Plant wallflowers in well watered ground 
 &bull; 
 Control mildew with fungicide and regular and regular watering 
 &bull; 
 Tie in new shoots of climbing roses horizontally 
 &bull; 
 Feed dahlias fortnightly to build up strong tubers 
 &bull; 
 Take cuttings of roses 
 Greenhouse 
 &bull; 
 Take cuttings of fuchsias and pelargoniums 
 &bull; 
 Remove painted shading from greenhouse windows 
 &bull; 
 Continue to ventilate and damp down when necessary 
 &bull; 
 Bring potted primulas and other plants indoors 
 &bull; 
 Plant up pots of bulbs 
 Kitchen garden 
 &bull; 
 Sow winter lettuces 
 &bull; 
 Harvest plums, allowing dessert ones to ripen first 
 &bull; 
 Hoe the beds, weekly to keep weeds under control 
 &bull; 
 Protect developing cauliflower curds 
 &bull; 
 Harvest onions and ripen in a dry, sunny spot 
 &bull; 
 Earth up around leeks and celery to blanch them 
 &bull; 
 Lift and store remaining maincrop potatoes 
 Lawns 
 &bull; 
 Scarify lawns vigorously 
 &bull; 
 Spike compacted areas with a fork or special aerator 
 &bull; 
 Mow less frequently 
 &bull; 
 Treat lawns to an autumn fertiliser for root growth 
 Dead-head any remaining spent flowers on waterlilies 
 Spike compacted lawns with a garden fork to improve aeration 
 House and greenhouse 
 This is a month of changeover in the greenhouse, with this year's plants providing cuttings for the next 
 &bull; 
 September is an important month in the greenhouse, with seeds and cuttings being prepared and plenty of bulbs ready to be planted. 
 &bull; 
 Continue taking cuttings of fuchsias, regal and zonal pelargoniums, and abutilon. 
 Take cuttings of heliotrope, coleus, impatiens and the shrubby forms of calceoaria. 
 &bull; 
 Wipe off the shading paint from the glass at the beginning of the month in Scotland and the north, and the end of the month in the south. 
 &bull; 
 Potted primulas and other plants that have been standing in frames can be brought into the greenhouse now. 
 &bull; 
 Re-pot arum lilies intended to flower in the winter. 
 Use one plant per 5in pot, or three per 8 or 9in pot. 
 Use a proprietary peat or coir-based potting compost or John Innes no3. 
 &bull; 
 Propagate lily bulbs from healthy scales. 
 Place them on a sandy layer over seed compost in trays, adding more sand to cover all but the tips. 
 Stand the tray in gentle warmth and keep the compost moist. 
 &bull; 
 Bring pot-grown chrysanthemums into the greenhouse by mid-September and spray plants with a good combined fungicide and insecticide. 
 &bull; 
 Continue to ventilate the greenhouse as necessary, watching out for hot September days and chilly nights. 
 Temperatures can fluctuate a great deal at this time of year. 
 &bull; 
 Make up pots and bowls of bulbs for Christmas and easter flowers. 
 Use a proprietary bulb fibre which will encourage good root growth. 
 &bull; 
 In some areas artificial heat may be needed from late September, so check now that your greenhouse heaters are in good working order. 
 &bull; 
 Sow antirrhinums, calendulas, clarkias, cornflowers and nemesias to be ready for early summer displays next year. 
 Autumn clean-up 
 Fred Friar 
 Now is the time to have a really good clear up in the greenhouse. 
 Remove spent tomato plants as soon as possible and put the old compost on the garden as a mulch; don't save it for using again next year. 
 Clean pots, staging and all surfaces with a solution of Jeyes fluid. 
 By cleaning out the house you can make room for overwintering plants. 
 Trim back fuchsias brought in from the garden and pot them up in a peat and sand mixture. 
 All the leaves will drop away, and should be cleared up, rather than left to rot, or they will encourage pests and diseases to build up in the greenhouse. 
 Tune in to Fred Friar on BBC Wiltshire Sound 
 New lawns from seed 
 1 
 The dug-over, weed-free site should be consolidated by raking and treading down all over with the heels. 
 2 
 Repeat the raking and treading process until a firm, stone-free level site is achieved, and rake once more. 
 3 
 Divide the area into manageable squares. 
 Sow at a rate of 1 &mdash; 1&ndash;1/2oz of seed per sq yd, as evenly as possible. 
 4 
 Sow a good 3in beyond the edges of the intended lawn and very lightly rake over with a spring tine rake. 
 Make the most of lower light levels by cleaning the glass. 
 Wipe off shading paints used over summer 
 Pot up bulbs of Nerine crispa . 
 Take offsets to grow on separately 
 Reorganise staging to make room for over-wintering plants 
 The kitchen garden 
 There is plenty of produce to be gathered in the kitchen garden, but remember to order new fruit trees as well. 
 &bull; 
 Plums can be harvested as they begin to show colour. 
 For eating, leave to ripen fully on the tree. 
 Prop up heavily-laden branches to prevent them breaking. 
 &bull; 
 Harvest pears, cooking apples and dessert apples as soon as they have ripened. 
 &bull; 
 Sow a row of turnip &bquo;Manchester Market&equo; to grow for green tops which can be harvested in early to mid-winter. 
 &bull; 
 Write off for fruit catalogues from the specialist nurseries, and prepare your order for new fruit trees and bushes. 
 &bull; 
 Earth up the stems of leeks and trench celery to blanch them. 
 Eat self-blanching celery as soon as possible as it does not keep well for long periods. 
 &bull; 
 Harvest remaining crops like potatoes and beans, clear away salads that have run to seed. 
 Put all the waste vegetation on the ever-hungry compost heap. 
 &bull; 
 Continue planting new strawberries in well prepared soil. 
 Ensure the plants have been grown from certified stock which is free from virus by buying from a reputable supplier. 
 &bull; 
 The end of August is your last chance to summer-prune cordon apples and pears. 
 &bull; 
 Place cloches over parsley to keep it growing strongly into autumn. 
 Pot up a hew clumps and bring them into the kitchen. 
 &bull; 
 Bend a cauliflower leaf over to cover and protect the young curd. 
 &bull; 
 Leave a few marrows on the plants to ripen fully, raising them up through the foliage into the sun by resting on bricks. 
 Harvest before the frost, and store in a cool place until required. 
 Marrows will store in good condition for many months. 
 &bull; 
 Sow Japanese onions in the north at the end of August and in early September in the south. 
 &bull; 
 To prevent winter brassicas rocking in the wind earth up soil round their stems. 
 &bull; 
 Lift any remaining maincrop potatoes. 
 Check for signs of damage and only store those in perfect condition in paper sacks in a cool, dark place. 
 Ensure the store is frost-free. 
 &bull; 
 Place a greaseband round the trunk of apple trees to catch the wingless female winter moth as it crawls up the tree from the soil in an attempt to lay its eggs. 
 &bull; 
 Harvest onions and lay out in a dry sunny spot to fully ripen. 
 Then clean off soil, dried roots and foliage, storing the onions in a cool, dry and frost-free site. 
 &bull; 
 Endive plants will be ready for blanching. 
 Cover them with a bucket or large flower pot, or place a dinner plate on a crown of foliage. 
 Allow about three weeks to blanch fully. 
 &bull; 
 Sow winter lettuce in rows, covering seed to a depth of 1/2in. 
 Water in and, when germinated, thin to around 8in apart. 
 Choose hardy varieties such as &bquo;Kwiek&equo; and &bquo;Valdor&equo; (butterheads). 
 Ready for the fruit harvest 
 Derek Cox 
 A daily check of the fruit trees is necessary to ensure you manage to collect fruit at its peak harvest condition. 
 Apples such as &bquo;Merton Knave&equo; and &bquo;Laxton's Fortune&equo; are very poor keepers and should be picked and eaten as soon as they are ripe. 
 Pears are best picked before they are quite ripe. 
 Twist the fruit slightly to one side and, if almost ripe, is will part from the tree. 
 Early plums should all have been picked by now, although &bquo;Marjorie's Seedling&equo; will be ripe from mid-September. 
 Tune in to Derek Cox on BBC Radio Leicester. 
 The fruit store 
 Before storing apples and pears, check that the store is free from mice and that the trays are thoroughly clean. 
 Allow timber containers to absorb some moisture outside first, so they don't draw it from the fruit and cause it to shrivel. 
 Pick fruit just ripe, harvesting preferably in the coolest part of the day. 
 Complete summer pruning of cordon and espalier apples trees 
 Ripen marrows by raising them out of the foliage and resting on bricks 
 Blanch endives by covering with a bucket, a large flower pot, or a dinner plate for three weeks 
 Plums intended for eating should be left to ripen fully on the tree 
 Harvest onions and lay them out in a dry, sunny spot where then can finish ripening before being stored 
 Houseplants 
 Take the plunge 
 Christmas may seem far away, but for a show of blooming indoor bulbs to gladden the festive season, September is the month to get to work. 
 Daphne Ledward picks out her favourites for us. 
 Though it hardly seems possible, spring-flowering bulbs are on sale again, and if we want to bring some winter cheer to the home we should be planting them now. 
 Hyacinths, narcissi, crocuses and certain types of tulips are the most widely planted bulbs for indoor displays. 
 However, many others are equally suitable. 
 Snowdrops, Roman hyacinths (which have smaller, more open flower heads and two or three stems per bulb), Iris reticulata  and Iris danfordiae  can be followed in flowering sequence by scillas, chionodoxas and muscari. 
 Bearing in mind that it takes approximately 12 weeks from planting to flowering, it is possible to grow bulbs of many species and varieties to flower at the same time for a spectacular display, and also plant for a succession of flowers if potting up is carefully timed. 
 Buy bulbs for indoor flowering as soon as they become available. 
 Choose large, firm, healthy specimens that are not visibly diseased or damaged and plant quickly, before they show signs of sprouting, as this can affect subsequent growth and flower quality. 
 To be sure of having bulbs in  flower at Christmas, it is advisable to buy specially prepared ones which have been temperature-treated for early flowering. 
 Hyacinth bulbs are the most widely available in prepared form, but prepared narcissi and tulips can also be found. 
 Certain tender varieties of narcissi, like &bquo;Paper White&equo; and &bquo;Grand Soleil d'Or&equo;, are naturally early flowering and do not need a natural or artificial cool period in order to flower quickly and healthily indoors, but they cannot be planted outside afterwards. 
 Bulbs without compost 
 Some bulbs will flower without conventional planting, which can be fun. 
 For instance, Colchicum autumnale  (naked ladies or meadow saffron), bulbs of which are available now, will flower if placed dry on a sunny windowsill. 
 After it has flowered the bulb can be planted out in the garden in the usual way. 
 Hyacinths can be grown over water in special hyacinth glasses. 
 The bulb is placed in the narrow neck of the glass which keeps it dry. 
 The base of the glass is filled with water which just touches the bottom of the bulb. 
 It sends roots down into the water, and the leaves and flowers then develop as normal. 
 Pebble dash 
 Narcissi can also be planted on pebbles. 
 Choose a watertight container at least 5in deep and cover the bottom with pebbles. 
 Arrange the bulbs close together, almost touching, on top of these, and place more pebbles around them to keep them stable. 
 Add water to just below the base of the bulbs. 
 Place the container in the dark in a cool place for 8&ndash;10 weeks, checking from time to time to see if the water needs topping up. 
 The bulbs will send roots in among the pebbles. 
 After the cool period, treat the bulbs exactly as if they were growing in compost. 
 Traditionally, however, indoor bulbs are planted in shallow ceramic or plastic bowls without drainage holes, but it is not really  necessary to use specially designed containers. 
 Providing the planting is done correctly, a variety of receptacles can be used: old baking bowls, fruit dishes, even chamberpots. 
 Ordinary plant pots can also be planted with bulbs. 
 These make cultivation slightly easier as with drainage holes, there is less risk of overwatering. 
 A special diet 
 If your container has no drainage holes, it is essential to plant in bulb fibre, which is a compost of peat or a peat substitute with crushed oyster shell and charcoal added to keep the compost sweet. 
 However, if drainage is provided, a standard potting compost may be used instead. 
 Flowers will look at their best if bulbs are placed close together in the bowl, but they must not touch each other. 
 The fibre or compost should be well moistened before use. 
 It should be damp enough to hold together when squeezed in the hand, but not so wet that water still runs out through the fingers. 
 Place the bulbs on a layer of fibre, then work in and gently firm more fibre around them. 
 Large bulbs should be only half-buried; with smaller ones, the tips should be just below the compost surface. 
 Do not mix different species of bulbs, or different varieties of one species, in the same container. 
 They are likely to flower at different times and the effect will be untidy. 
 If you want a mixture of species and colours, grow individual bulbs separately in plant pots and then plant up an arrangement using bulbs which have reached the same stage of development and look to be just about to flower. 
 Plunge power 
 It is essential that bulbs spend a period of time in cool, dark conditions before flowering (this is known as plunging) to ensure that a good root system is produced, otherwise stunted growth and deformed flowers can result. 
 Older gardening books may recommend a cool cupboard indoors for plunging. 
 But with central heating, it is now not always possible to provide an ideal plunging environment within the home. 
 An alternative is to put the planted-up bowls in black polythene sacks ties at the top and keep them in a cold greenhouse or cool, frost-free outhouse, garage or shed. 
 Underground safe 
 Another solution is to dig a hole in the garden, place the bowls in this, and cover them with a thick layer of leaf mould, peat or peat substitute, but the bowls must have drainage holes or they could become waterlogged during heavy rainfall. 
 Check the bowls periodically and give them enough water if necessary to keep the compost evenly damp. 
 After 8&ndash;10 weeks, when an inch or two of growth has appeared (prepared bulbs should need only six weeks), the containers can be brought indoors. 
 For a few days they should be given a cool,  shaded position; after that as much light as possible. 
 Water regularly; never let the compost dry out completely, though you must beware of overwatering. 
 Be ready with thin canes to support hyacinth blooms in particular if they start to bend and droop under their own weight. 
 Keep them cool 
 Flowering bulbs will last much longer in a cool room or position rather than a hot one. 
 Always bear in mind that when they flower outdoors at their natural time the temperature is unlikely to reach 60&deg;F (15&deg;C) for more than a day or two. 
 This temperature may be too low for comfort in a regularly used living room, so try and find a cooler spot for a longer display. 
 For hyacinths in bloom at Christmas, start your preparations in late September. 
 Choose good quality prepared bulbs and plant them close together, but not touching, to approximately half their depth in good, moist bulb fibre in suitable bowls. 
 Put the bowls in a dark place where the temperature does not exceed 45&deg;F (&amp;&deg;C). 
 If there is no suitable spot indoors, put the bowls in the garden and cover with 6in of peat or a peat substitute such as cocofibre, excluding rain with polythene sheeting if the bowls have no drainage holes. 
 Remember to check on them from time to time and water them carefully if the compost seems dry. 
 At the end of November, when the shoots should be about 1 &mdash; 1&ndash;1/4in high, the bulbs can be gradually acclimatised to living room conditions. 
 The flowers should open and be at their glorious, fragrant best for Christmas. 
 The bulbs can be planted in the garden afterwards to flower outdoors the following year. 
 Daffodils &amp; narcissi 
 Carlton 
 yellow 
 Cheerfulness 
 cream, tazetta 
 Dove Wings 
 cream/yellow, miniature 
 Dutch Master 
 yellow 
 February Gold 
 yellow/miniature 
 Fortune 
 yellow/orange 
 Geranium 
 white/orange, tazetta 
 Golden Ducat 
 yellow/double 
 Golden Harvest 
 yellow 
 Grand Soleil d'Or 
 yellow, tazetta, early 
 Jack Snipe 
 white/yellow, miniature 
 King Alfred 
 yellow 
 Minnow 
 cream/yellow, miniature 
 Mount Hood 
 white 
 Paper White 
 white, tazetta, early 
 Peeping Tom 
 yellow, miniature 
 Scarlet Gem 
 yellow/red, tazetta 
 Spellbinder 
 yellow/white 
 Suzy 
 yellow, miniature 
 T&ecirc;te-&agrave;-T&ecirc;te 
 yellow, miniature 
 Texas 
 yellow/orange, double 
 White Lion 
 white, double 
 Hyacinths 
 Amethyst 
 violet 
 Bismarck 
 sky blue 
 Delft 
 porcelain blue 
 Jan Bos 
 red 
 Lady Derby 
 pink 
 L'Innocence 
 white 
 Ostara 
 dark blue 
 Pink Pearl 
 rose pink 
 Rosalie 
 rose pink 
 Crocuses 
 Blue Pearl 
 pale blue with golden throats, miniature 
 Cream Beauty 
 cream with yellow throats, miniature 
 Early Perfection 
 amethyst 
 E P Bowles 
 lemon-yellow, miniature 
 Enchantress 
 blue 
 Goldilocks 
 yellow, miniature 
 Kathleen Parlow 
 white 
 King of the Blues 
 blue 
 King of the Stiped 
 amethyst/violet with lighter stripes 
 Pickwick 
 grey/lilac with purple stripes 
 Purpureus Grandiflorus 
 purple 
 Remembrance 
 blue/purple 
 Snow Bunting 
 white with mustard throats, miniature 
 Snow Storm 
 white 
 Zwanenburg Bronze 
 gold with bronze-tinged exterior, miniature 
 Stiped Beauty 
 violet stripes on white 
 Vanguard 
 lilac 
 Yellow Mammoth 
 yellow 
 Tulips 
 Aladdin 
 red and yellow, lily-flowered 
 Apeldoorn red, Darwin 
 hybrid 
 Bellona 
 yellow, single early 
 Boule de Neige 
 white, double early 
 Cape Cod 
 apricot edged yellow, botanical 
 China Pink 
 pale pink, lily-flowered 
 Dante 
 vivid blood-red, double early 
 Golden Apeldoorn yellow, Darwin 
 hybrid 
 Gordon Cooper salmon pink turning to scarlet, Darwin 
 hybrid 
 Guiseppe Verdi 
 carmine striped yellow, botanical 
 Keizerskroon 
 yellow/red, single early 
 Murillo 
 white flushed pink, double early 
 Orange Nassau 
 blood-red, double early 
 Pandour 
 yellow/carmine, mottled leaves, botanical 
 Peach Blossom 
 pink/white, double early 
 Pink Beauty 
 rose flushed white, single early 
 Red Emperor 
 scarlet, botanical 
 Shakespeare 
 red, mottled leaves, botanical 
 Van der Hoeff 
 yellow, double, early 
 Van der Neer 
 violet, single, early 
 Water Lily 
 ivory white with gold base, carmine tinged, botanical 
 West Point 
 yellow, lily-flowered 
 Yellow Empress 
 yellow, botanical 
 Growing Christmas hyacinths 
 1 
 In late September plant healthy prepared bulbs to half their depth in compost-filled pots with drainage holes. 
 2 
 In the garden, mound peat or peat substitute over the pots. 
 Check from time to time and water if the compost is dry. 
 3 
 In late November, bring the pots into a greenhouse or cool place to acclimatise, ready to be taken indoors. 
 4 
 Plant up arrangements in bulb bowls and planters choosing bulbs which are at the same stage of development. 
 The flowers of Narcissus  &bquo;T&ecirc;te-&agrave;-T&ecirc;te&equo; last particularly well 
 The greigii  hybrid tulips such as &bquo;Cape Cod&equo; are always brightly coloured with striped or mottled leaves 
 Plunge power ensures a blooming good Christmas 
 Growing hyacinth bulbs over glass is a fascinating experience 
 Tazetta narcissi such as &bquo;Scarlet Gem&equo; bear their flowers in clusters 
 Fragrant, silvery Crocus  &bquo;Blue Pearl&equo; has a golden-yellow throat 
 Strong stems support the finely-cut blooms of tulip &bquo;West Point&equo; 
 The marvellous deep indigo colour of hyacinth &bquo;Blue Magic&equo; 
 Colour Creations 
 The Heavy Mob 
 So many plants thrive on sticky clay soil that it's no barrier to a beautiful garden, says Nigel Colborn 
 Which would you rather have in your garden &mdash; sticky clay or thin, hungry sand? 
 Given the choice, and assuming that precious few of us are blessed with the ideal soil type, it is probably better for garden land to err on the heavy side. 
 As song as you look after them, heavy soils will never let you down in a drought, will be naturally fertile and can be made to suit the widest range of plants. 
 Roses, for instance, dote on sticky soil. 
 Perennials, even quite shallow-rooted species, tend to grow more robustly in clay loams than on chalk or sand and, given adequate drainage, almost all shrubs thrive on fairly stiff land. 
 Wetland plants will be in their element, so long as they are given generous mulches to keep the moisture in. 
 Heavy soils vary. 
 The calcareous clays, such as East Anglian boulder clay, are alkaline and therefore will not suit azaleas or rhododendrons. 
 But the acid or neutral clays which are found in many parts of Britain are as good for lime haters are are acid sands. 
 Planting plans 
 Designing a beautiful garden is no more difficult on clay than anywhere else. 
 For a formal theme, neat-growing trees such as the clay-loving acers can be planted at regular intervals along a brick path to create a little avenue. 
 The plants beneath help to ensure the right conditions by covering the soil surface, reducing evaporation and hence keeping it moist and workable. 
 For a low-growing, striking herbaceous colour scheme, try a blue and gold theme with lemon balm, forget-me-nots, creamy violas and the gorgeous ice-blue Veronica gentianoides . 
 In an informal planting, willows, ferns and rhododendrons can be combined to give a series of displays, changing the mood through the season. 
 Ferny foliage will make a soft contrast to the  spikiness of sword-like leaves, either of yuccas, on drier soils, or of Siberian irises in the damp. 
 Plants tend to grow big and lush on heavy soils, a feature worth enhancing by going for vigorous species. 
 Roses, especially ramblers like Rosa filipes  &bquo;Kiftsgate&equo;, need plenty of headroom but are sensational in bloom and in fruit. 
 Old shrub roses, particularly centifolias, enjoy clay, but flower only once a season. 
 Repeat-flowering shrub roses include hybrid musks such as &bquo;Penepole&equo; or &bquo;Buff Beauty&equo;, and any of the rugosas. 
 Look for fragrant &bquo;Roseraie de l'hay&equo; (purple-red) and &bquo;Blanche Double de Coubert&equo; (white). 
 Outstanding perennials, especially for alkaline clay, include the comfreys. 
 The common wild species is a course-growing monster but Symphytum x uplandicum  &bquo;Variegatum&equo; has surpassing beauty in the cream zoning of its leaves. 
 Hostas love moist clay but suffer very badly from slugs which are always more abundant than on lighter soils. 
 Other good perennials include cranesbills, particularly Geranium   malviflorum , monardas such as &bquo;Cambridge Scarlet&equo; or purple &bquo;Prairie Night&equo; and any of the violets, Viola labradorica , as pretty for its purple foliage as for its violet spring flowers, looks absolutely superb in a mauve colour scheme. 
 Grasses will help to build up the feeling of luxuriance and they add their own special grace when they sway about in the breeze. 
 Exceptional grasses for heavy soils include the 6ft-high Miscanthus sinensis  and the smaller Molinia caerulea , whose dead winter stems turn parchment yellow. 
 The dreaded gardeners' garters, of Phalaris arundinacea  &bquo;Picta&equo; manages to creep all over the place but is far too lovely a plant to write off just for that reason. 
 Plants for acid clay 
 With acid clay, you can enjoy a number of extra-special plants that are harder to maintain elsewhere. 
 For example, the gorgeous blue poppies, though by no means lime-haters, will always colour better in acid conditions and need soil which has been enriched with leaf mould and retains its moisture. 
 Azaleas and rhododendrons will cope well with heavy soil, provided the drainage is adequate. 
 Slow-growing Kalmia latifolia , a North American member of the rhododendron tribe, loves moist soil. 
 This plant's exquisite pink and white blooms look much like sugar icing cake decorations. 
 The riot of summer vegetation is wonderfully dramatic on heavy soils, but there is a down side: things can go very flat in winter unless you plan carefully. 
 For year-round interest, firs like Abies lasiocarpa  appreciate heavy, moist soil, although A. koreana  is my personal favourite because it produces cones at an early age. 
 Willows like to wallow 
 Willows love the wet. 
 From a vast range in many shapes and sizes, you could select the dwarf Salix lanata  for foliage, the larger S. fargesii  for winter twigs, and another small willow, S. hastata , for its silver catkins. 
 Autumn colour is easy to achieve with such shrubs as Rhus hirta  (often listed as R. typhina ). 
 Try the cut leaved form &bquo;Laciniata&equo; and the related smoke bushes, Cotinus coggygria  and Cotinus  &bquo;Grace&equo;. 
 Ornamental cabbages may be bit bizarre, but they love heavy soil and will make a brilliant late display. 
 If you feel like going completely over the top, why not grow some rhubarb chard near your gaudy cabbages? 
 If you don't like the results, you can always eat them! 
 Coming towards winter, birds have usually scoffed the berries of Viburnum opulus  by late autumn, but the big, bottle-shaped hips of Rosa moyesii  last until Christmas and holly berries should persist well into the New Year. 
 At ground level, bergenias, hellebores and, of course, snowdrops all love heavy soil. 
 Spring can return with tulips, most of which enjoy a well  drained, heavy soil. 
 They may be joined by the gorgeous lime-green flowers of Smyrnium perfoliatum , a plant which is either a satisfactory spreader or an invasive pest, depending on your point of view. 
 Cultural tips 
 Drainage is one of the most important features of your soil. 
 You can improve soil structure and drainage by incorporating organic material such as compost, and make soil more porous by digging in grit or bonfire ash. 
 Cracking in dry weather can be prevented by mulching and ensuring there is a good ground cover. 
 However, if cracks do appear, you should try brushing a mixture of peat or compost and coarse sand into them. 
 Cautions 
 The higher the clay content, the more sticky the soil and the more care you must take. 
 Never be tempted to dig so deep that you bring up raw clay, but work assiduously on the top few inches only, gradually improving the soil deeper each year. 
 And don't try walking on your borders, particularly when they are wet, or you risk causing compaction and damage. 
 Making clay work for you 
 &bull; 
 Heavy clay is made up chiefly of tiny soil particles which bind together tightly and cling to the water around them, making the clay sticky and difficult to work. 
 &bull; 
 The poor drainage that results can be helped significantly by digging in shovelfuls of sharp, pea-sized fruit, together with plenty of well-rotted organic manure or compost. 
 &bull; 
 Preparing the soil in this way means that you are less likely to suffer from too many plant deaths where the roots of young plants have found it impossible to penetrate the soil. 
 &bull; 
 Once the planting has been done, cover the soil with a thick mulch of crushed bark, peat or leaf mould, which will gradually break down into the soil and help to improve its texture. 
 &bull; 
 Mulching has the added benefit of keeping moisture in the soil during dry weather, when clay is liable to dry out and crack. 
 It will also prevent the surface from forming a hard, impenetrable cap. 
 &bull; 
 Clay soils can be neutral, acidic of limey, according to regional geology. 
 Test your soil's acidity before buying plants that are pH sensitive. 
 &bull; 
 Avoid working clay soil in wet weather, as standing on it will cause compaction. 
 A buyer's guide to clay lovers 
 Most of the plants mentioned are widely available, but some may prove more difficult to find.  
 Topical tip 
 Ornamental cabbages can make a lovely late display, and they adore heavy soil. 
 Rhubarb chard grown nearby will make the scene even more spectacular. 
 Both can of course eventually be eaten.  
 Shrub roses such as &bquo;Roseraie de l'Ha&yuml;&equo; really thrive on clay soils 
 The choice of trees for clay includes conifers, acers and birches 
 Soft surrounding planting sets off spiky, yellow-bloomed bog irises 
 Primulas and Berberis darwinii  make attractive companions for springtime colour on clay 
 An avenue of acers creates vertical interest in a formal plan, but potentially large varieties will need to be pruned back in later years. 
 Wildlife Garden 
 Out of the woods 
 Trees in the wild are home, larder and playground to a host of living creatures. 
 With careful selection you can recreate your own wildlife haven. 
 Standing under an ancient oak I am intensely aware of the sheer concentration of life in the leafy canopy overhead. 
 Flecks of sunshine dappling fissured bark are a reminder of summers past during the tree's slow progress to maturity. 
 In the garden some of the natural beauty of country copse and woodland can be recreated. 
 However, the available space may dictate some modifications, among which choice of tree is necessarily paramount. 
 Building a plant community 
 Few gardens are large enough to accommodate a full-grown oak or beech. 
 There are compact, slow-growing forms of nearly all our native trees, but though these are always my first option I consider it a mistake to limit planting choice to our indigenous flora. 
 There are many imported tree species that are equally suitable, filling all the wildlife gardener's requirements as to ultimate height and spread, usefulness in habitat terms and, above all, beauty of leaf, flower and berry. 
 Once planted, and whether 10 or 50ft high, a tree becomes a focal point around which to build a complete plant community. 
 Under natural conditions a tree growing in a hedgerow, copse or forest progresses through various stages of settlement to a climatic climax which, once attained, remains the same year after year with only minor variations. 
 Contrived planting plan 
 This process, which can take several decades in open country, may be contrived in only a few years in a garden by reversing the natural scheme of things. 
 First plant the tree or trees, followed by shrubs carefully selected for their usefulness in supporting a diverse wildlife community. 
 Then reinforce the whole with ground cover made up of herbaceous plants, flowering bulbs  and, of course, the infinitely various and valuable annuals. 
 What I find extraordinary is how each tree seems almost to suggest its own companion planting. 
 On reflection, however, this may not be quite true, since anyone who sets out to plant a wildlife garden instinctively takes a much keener interest in, and is influenced by, natural plant associations and communities. 
 In my own garden the twisted hazel, Corylus avellana  &bquo;Contorta&equo;, is underplanted with primroses, bluebells and wood anemones, for that is how I remember them growing, as they still do, along the banks of the rive Greta. 
 It forms a composition both nostalgically satisfying and harmoniously beautiful. 
 I grow so many of my plants, including trees and shrubs, from seed. 
 This means that any of those experiments in plant association which prove to be unsuccessful can be scrapped without too many regrets. 
 That they have cost me no more than my time makes such decisions much easier than if I had paid for them in gold. 
 My silver birch, a fine form of Betula pendula , is now the tallest tree in the garden at 25ft, yet 16 years ago it was a seed gathered from a moss-covered stump on Birk Crag. 
 As is my usual practice, I pruned the first year's growth back hard to produce several stems instead of just one, and I have been well rewarded for my efforts. 
 The ground-planting around it includes Eranthis hyemalis  (winter aconite), native daffodils and cowslips. 
 Autumn's golden accolade 
 The silver birch is so elegantly beautiful, from spring's pale green bud-burst until the final golden accolade of autumn, that it plays a part in all the seasons, not least because it is especially favoured by long-tailed tits as a food source in winter. 
 Betula pendula  &bquo;Youngii&equo;, with weeping branches, is a neatly  compact form which should fit neatly into a confined space without becoming an embarrassment. 
 The canopy is light enough to encourage underplanting too, making Young's weeping birch a good choice for the smaller plot. 
 Also eminently suitable for the smaller garden is Sorbus aucuparia  &bquo;Fastigiata&equo;, a slow-growing form of our native rowan which will eventually reach 15ft in height. 
 That sorbus berries when red and ripe turn blackbirds, starlings and other fruit eaters into the most shameless gluttons merely serves to underline this tree's usefulness. 
 There is some confusion over the parentage of S. &bquo;Fastigiata&equo;. 
 My only contribution to the debate is to affirm that the colony of twenty or more specimens growing along the lane above my house breeds true. 
 The seedlings, upright as bishops, are as free-fruiting and close-branched as you could wish for. 
 The common holly, Ilex aquifolium , shares an almost symbiotic relationship with rowan, providing an extra amenity as a secure nesting and roosting place, and supplying ample berries in bleak mid-winter for both fieldfares and redwings to feed on. 
 A well defined form 
 According to my dictionary, a tree can be any perennial plant having a self-supporting woody main stem. 
 In a small garden two excellent weeping ornamental and habitat shrubs, the Kilmarnock willow, Salix caprea pendula , and Cotoneaster  &bquo;Hybridus Pendulus&equo;, make ideal trees up to 10ft high. 
 In spring the willow, with its arching branches, embroidered with silver female catkins, is truly a thing of beauty. 
 The caterpillars  so far unidentified, which feed on its leaves provide an abundant source of protein for the many young birds. 
 Birds are bowled over 
 Cotoneaster  &bquo;Hybridus Pendulus&equo; is, in wildlife terms, what Ian Botham is to cricket &mdash; in the allrounder class for usefulness. 
 I have this neatly weeping tree in my own garden, its serried mass of pink flowers in spring followed in autumn by a profusion of dark red berries, and the avian population has expressed its approval. 
 This year a robin has nested in the closely interlacing branches; last summer there was a wren. 
 There are a number of cherries which will interest the wildlife-oriented gardener. 
 Prunus avium  makes a broad canopied tree, the clusters of white flowers in spring followed by small succulent fruit in August. 
 Prunus padus  is well named the bird cherry, for its black fruits are high on the animal and bird menu of gastronomic delights. 
 It grows into a small-too-medium-sized tree which will tolerate fairly hard pruning, but can nevertheless persist in being rather unshapely. 
 However, it has its compensations. 
 Watching badgers graze on bird cherries and elderberries in Gyhll Beck wood is certainly high on my list of happier wildlife experiences. 
 Crab apples and wild cherry grow in company with blackthorn, hawthorn, elder, and wild rose along a verge near my own garden, forming what must be the best natural autumn bird larder for miles around. 
 Too big for their beaks 
 Crab apples are easily grown from seed, and most of the seedlings are well worth their place in the garden. 
 Certainly each of the six crab apples planted in my garden earn their keep in wildlife and ornamental terms. 
 Watching blackbirds trying to give themselves hernias by swallowing cherry-sized crab apples whole is now a firm fixture in my programme of autumn entertainments. 
 Wildlife profile 
 Rowan 
 Some native trees have an attractive robustness and the rowan ( Sorbus aucuparia ), particularly in the upright growing forms, is one. 
 Few sorbus can compare with our native rowan for ease of cultivation or the liberal manner with which it unfailingly produces an abundant crop of insect-pollinated flowers each May, followed in late August by densely packed bunches of bright orange-red fruits. 
 When the leaves turn colour and the berry clusters are ripe, the rowan is a princely sight. 
 The witches' bane 
 S. aucuparia  forms a tree 35&ndash;45ft tall. 
 The compound leaves, orange scarlet in autumn, are unpaired pinnate, made up of nine to 15 leaflets. 
 Rowans will grow in alkaline soils, but prefer heavier acid loams. 
 A valley I know has rowan trees growing with oak, birch and holly. 
 In winter it's a wildlife haven; even in the harshest weather it affords a rarely failing food source. 
 Since ancient times, the rowan tree has been considered a scourge to witches. 
 Cattle wore collars of rowan wood to protect them from spells and curses. 
 In many rural areas the tree was deemed sacred and thus is widely planted in churchyards. 
 Topical tip 
 If you, your relations or friends bring children into the wildlife garden, remember that many berries are poisonous. 
 Keep an eye on youngsters, and teach them to recognise danger too. 
 Turn left at Gib! 
 This is a time of abundance when bird, beast and insect gather to share the cornucopia. 
 Hedgehogs appear as twilight deepens and robins become pugnaciously territorial. 
 Young martins and swallows form chattering groups on eaves and telephone wires. 
 No doubt they are being told by their elders, as a friend informed his grand-daughter, to turn left at Gibraltar!  
 Corylus avellana  &bquo;Contorta&equo;, aptly known as the corkscrew hazel 
 This berry-laden holly bough will be a welcome winter sight to birds 
 Delicate blossoms of Primus avium  &bquo;Plena&equo; are a delight to behold 
 A hungry waxwing pauses, berry in mouth, to contemplate the bounty of nature's larder 
 A berry-laden cotoneaster overhung by the elegant Betula pendula  
 The characteristic spreading canopy of Betula pendula  &bquo;Youngii&equo; allows some sunlight to filter through 
 Ornamental Salix caprea  &bquo;Pendula&equo; makes a well-proportioned tree 
 Hedgehogs are the most welcome of garden pest controllers 
 Specialist Spotlight 
 Apple appeal 
 Growing apples is as easy as apple pie, if you are Joan Greenway of Highfield Nurseries. 
 Graham Rice finds out her recipe for success 
 While I was visiting Joan Greenway of Highfield Nurseries, the fruit specialists, she described to me her recipe for trouble-free apple growing: disease-resistant varieties, the right rootstock for your preferred size of tree, a simple summer and winter prune plus a crab apple to take care of your pollination needs. 
 She made it all sound temptingly and realistically easy. 
 The new varieties and modern techniques that she and other growers use have certainly taken the anxiety out of apple growing, a subject wreathed in mystery, according to traditional literature. 
 Just how small can apple trees get? 
 Small enough to step over, as Highfield's step-over trees testify. 
 The nursery has revived this old and useful idea, whereby instead of growing upwards the tree grows horizontally. 
 Each tree consists of just two branches, 2&ndash;3ft long, running along about a foot off the ground. 
 You can plant step-overs along a path or as an edging to a bed and pick 20 or 30 apples from each one. 
 At around the 5ft height there are two options, bushes or cordons. 
 A bush tree is exactly what you would expect it to be (bushy), but at the right height for picking and pruning comfortably. 
 A cordon is no more than a single stem which fruits all the way along. 
 A row of cordons must be the easiest possible way to grow apples. 
 Trained espaliers 
 Next size up are espaliers and larger bush trees. 
 Espaliers are trained flat against a fence or wall, or freestanding along wires. 
 Each has a vertical central stem and horizontal tiers of branches trained out on either side. 
 A three-tiered espalier stands at  about 4ft; five tiers will reach around 7ft. 
 After that they become too tall to manage easily, although dealing with a tall espalier growing flat on a wall is a breeze compared to pruning a bush tree of the same height. 
 Finally, there are large bush trees and trees of orchard size which are really too big for most gardeners to manage. 
 Choosing rootstocks 
 Apple trees are made up of two parts, the fruiting variety and the rootstock. 
 You'll find the join about a foot above the ground where there's a slight kink in the stem. 
 The rootstocks were developed at government research stations and are still known by their reference numbers. 
 &bquo;The rootstock controls the vigour of the tree and how early it crops,&equo; explains Joan. 
 &bquo;If you simply take cuttings from an apple tree they will grow vigorously but take years and years to fruit. 
 The important thing is to choose the right rootstock for the size of tree you eventually want.&equo; 
 Joan is a firm supporter of new varieties; they are much more likely to stay in good health as they're bred with inbuilt resistance to canker and other diseases. 
 Some of the new apples solve other problems associated with traditional varieties. 
 For example, &bquo;Bramley&equo; is very difficult to keep small or grow as a cordon as it needs quite different pruning. 
 To make matter worse it's also a triploid, so you need an extra pollinator. 
 The answer is to choose the new &bquo;Bountiful&equo;, similar if a touch sweeter, instead. 
 From the 350 different apples listed in various catalogues, Joan Greenway has some favourites and recommendations for the first-time grower. 
 &bquo;Lord Lambourne&equo;, for instance, is a very reliable early-flowering variety with green, red-flushed skin and crisp, juicy flesh. 
 Fleshy favourites 
 Flowering mid-season &bquo;James Grieve&equo; is almost guaranteed to give a good crop of very juicy fruit with fine, slightly acid flavour, lovely both for cooking and for eating. 
 Also flowering mid-season, &bquo;Bountiful&equo; is the first new cooker for 55 years. 
 With good colour, sweet flavour and generous crops, it makes an ideal replacement for the difficult to grow &bquo;Bramley&equo;, and another advantage is its mildew resistance. 
 Another newer variety rapidly replacing the more difficult to grow &bquo;Cox's Orange Pippin&equo;, &bquo;Fiesta&equo; looks similar, has the same flavour, flowers mid-season, produces larger fruits, crops  twice as heavily and even produces a fair crop with no pollinator. 
 Too good to be true! 
 &bquo;Jupiter&equo; is a triploid, so you'll need an extra pollinator for its mid-season flowers. 
 But it's well worth it: sweet and juicy with a lovely flavour and large fruits, three or even two to a pound. 
 Picking a little later, in October, is &bquo;Elstar&equo;, bright red in colour with juicy, very crisp flesh and a fine flavour. 
 Fruitful Ballerinas 
 A lot has been said recently about the Ballerina series of trees. 
 These grow naturally as a single, vertical stem and need absolutely no pruning. 
 They're ideal for small gardens and crop heavily. 
 One problem is that although they stay slim they grow very tall, up to 11ft in six years. 
 If you cut them back when they reach a manageable height they'll retain their shape but will sprout a forest of shoots at the top. 
 This looks a little strange so they're best removed every year. 
 The Ballerina series comprises three eating apples, all derived from &bquo;Golden Delicious&equo; which maybe accounts for their unremarkable flavour, and a very attractive crab called &bquo;Maypole&equo; which can be left to grow as tall as you like if you don't want to pick the fruits. 
 For a free copy of the Highfield Nurseries catalogue, write to Highfield Nurseries, Whitminster, Gloucester, GL2 7PL. 
 Pollination 
 Pollination can seem a daunting subject. 
 In theory, you have to ensure that you have at least two trees in flower at the same time so that they can pollinate each other, otherwise you may get no fruit at all. 
 Different varieties flower at different times; you will find them described as early, mid-season or late flowering in catalogues and on the labels on most garden centres. 
 Fortunately, the flowering of successive groups usually overlaps, and as most of the best varieties are in the mid-season group, just one from that group will pollinate most other varieties. 
 The small group of apple varieties know as triploids present more of a challenge. 
 Although triploids can be pollinated by any other variety flowering at the same time, they don't produce any pollen of their own. 
 So the tree that pollinates the triploid won't produce any fruit unless you plant a third variety flowering at the same time. 
 Simple solution 
 But if you simply don't have room for two or more bushes or trees, all may not be lost. 
 As Joan points out, bees love apple blossom and will range far and wide &mdash; up to three miles &mdash; to find it. 
 So if you're in an area where there are other apple trees, you should have no problem. 
 However, according to Joan, there is an even better, risk-free option. 
 Some ornamental crab apples flower for so long that they will pollinate your fruiting apples whatever their flowering season. 
 Plant a &bquo;John Downie&equo; or a &bquo;Golden Hornet&equo; as a garden tree, and your pollination worries will be banished forever. 
 Apple tree care 
 The secret of efficient and easy pruning is to take control when you first get your tree. 
 Always shorten all branches by one third when planting and never leave any tree unpruned. 
 Thereafter, prune when you see long growths taking the goodness out of the tree; in late summer cut back all whippy shoots to 4in, then in February or March cut back again to two buds. 
 Any pruning is better than no pruning. 
 The most essential thing is to prune once a year, and if you miss the summer, prune in winter. 
 Apples suffer from pests and diseases like other plants, but like many growers, Joan Greenway is no great fan of chemical sprays. 
 She believes in growing the trees well by mulching every September and feeding in March and July. 
 Dress with 4oz of sulphate of potash per cordon tree or per sq yd around bush trees. 
 Her solutions to the most common pest and disease problems are ICI Benlate for mildew, grease bands for the leaf-eating loopers (winter moth caterpillars), tar oil winter wash to deal with woolly aphids and pbi Malathion Greenfly Killer for other aphids. 
 Rootstocks 
 &bull; 
 M27 is the most dwarfing stock; trees reach only 5&ndash;6ft at maturity. 
 They fruit very early but root growth is limited, so they need good soil. 
 Choose it for step-overs, tubs, small bush trees and cordons on rich soil. 
 &bull; 
 M9 is slightly more vigorous; trees will reach about 8ft, and need good soil. 
 This also produces a very small root system, so trees need permanent staking. 
 Choose M9 for most cordons and dwarf bush trees. 
 M26 is quite similar to M9, but a little more vigorous. 
 It is mid-way in vigour between M9 and MM106. 
 &bull; 
 Trees on the semi-dwarfing MM106 are much more vigorous than either M27 or M9, and achieve a height of around 15ft. 
 Choose for espaliers, fans, larger bushes and cordons on poor soil. 
 &bull; 
 Trees grown on MM111 rootstock will reach a robust 18&ndash;20ft in height, but won't crop for the first six years. 
 It is well suited to poor soil and ideal if you want to plant a traditional orchard. 
 Juicy &bquo;Lord Lambourne&equo; is ideal for novice growers 
 Bees will scour the countryside for the scent of apple blossom 
 Angst-free apple growing: Joan Greenway shows Graham Rice how 
 A 5ft espalier is just the right height for pruning 
 A &bquo;John Downie&equo; crab not only looks good, it's a sure-fire pollinator 
 &bquo;Bountiful&equo; is a sweeter, easier alternative to the traditional favourite &bquo;Bramley&equo; 
 Cordons give trouble-free growing 
 Greeny-yellow &bquo;Greensleeves&equo; are delicious for dessert 
 Looks good, tastes good: a fan-trained apple tree enlivens a dull wall 
 &bquo;Ballerina&equo; has been called &bquo;the world's most compact apple tree&equo; 
 Highfield's step-over trees can each produce 20 or 30 apples 
 Kitchen Garden 
 Kitchen Garden 
 As summer draws to a close, some plants are still cropping, others need winter preparation and, suggests Joy Larkcom, a green manure will do your soil a power of good 
 Time to repay your debt to the soil 
 The time has come to think about putting something back into the soil. 
 After all, we have been reaping rewards from the vegetable garden for months: the soil can't go on and on providing if its own storehouse is not replenished. 
 Late summer and early autumn are good times to sow hardy green manures, which stay in the ground through the winter and rot down, or are dug in, in the spring. 
 A green manure is a crop grown mainly to improve soil fertility. 
 While not a complete substitute for manure or compost, it is of particular use to those who find bulky animal manure hard to come by. 
 Autumn-sown green manures improve the soil in a variety of ways, depending on the plants used. 
 They conserve nutrients, especially nitrogen, by taking them up in autumn and releasing them in spring. 
 This prevents nitrates being washed out of the soil in winter. 
 When the manures rot down they add organic matter to the soil, which turns into humus. 
 This is not only a source of plant foods, but also encourages earthworm activity. 
 The two together make poor, dry soil more moisture-retentive, and improve the drainage in heavy soils. 
 Plants with a fibrous root system, creating plenty of organic matter, do most to improve the soil structure. 
 In addition they help conserve the existing soil structure by protecting the surface from the destructive force of winter rain. 
 By blanketing the soil they also help to control weeds. 
 Leguminous green manures, such as clover and beans, fix atmospheric nitrogen in the soil by means of their root nodules, so making it available to plants later in the growing season. 
 Including the planting of a green manure into a garden plan can seem difficult. 
 The easiest way to start is to sow small patches when clearing crops in autumn. 
 Of course, if for any reason you have to leave your garden for several months, the best thing you can do is to sow a suitable green manure. 
 Most green manures can be sown broadcast or in rows. 
 They should always be turned in when they are lush and green, before they flower or become woody. 
 The following hardy green manures are among those most suitable for autumn sowing. 
 Winter field beans ( Vicia faba ) 
 These look like broad beans, and will grow 2&ndash;3ft high. 
 Sow from September to November, spacing seeds about 5in apart each way, or 4in apart in rows 6in apart. 
 Cut the leaves back in spring, then allow them to re-grow before digging in the plants. 
 They  provide humus and fix nitrogen, are excellent in heavy soils but don't grow well in dry conditions. 
 Winter tares ( Vicia sativa , common vetch) 
 Fast, low-growing legumes, tares are excellent for suppressing weeds. 
 Sow the seeds, which look like sweet peas, at the rate of about 1/2oz-sq yd. 
 Tares fix nitrogen and have a good fibrous root system which helps to improve heavy clay soils, preferring these to light or very acid soils. 
 Fodder radish ( Raphanus sativus ) 
 This develops into a large bulky plant 2ft high, which collapses after heavy frost, blanketing the ground and breaking down into a mass of fibre. 
 Sow in August or early September. 
 You can pick off a few young leaves for salads or cooking. 
 In mild winters it may be necessary to chop down the leaves and dig in the roots in spring. 
 Don't grow in clubroot-infected soil. 
 Winter grazing rye grass ( Secale cereale ) 
 This develops a wonderful fibrous root system, but is not very dense, so doesn't suppress weeds well. 
 Birds love the seed, so you may need to net it. 
 Sow it from August to November at the rate of 1oz/sq yd. 
 Dig in when you can feel flower heads starting to form at the base. 
 Don't leave it any longer or it becomes hard to control. 
 Or, you can cover it with black plastic so that it rots down. 
 Give your sprouts sturdy supports 
 If your garden is at all exposed to wind you must make sure that any top-heavy brassicas, such as Brussels sprouts and purple sprouting broccoli, are supported by really stout stakes. 
 Put them in now, before autumn gales and winter blasts make the plants rock at their roots, and frost loosens up the soil to compound the damage. 
 And when I say stout supports, I mean stout. 
 The photo here was taken in friend Jane Allen's garden &mdash; a very practical potter and organic gardener. 
 That same winter my sprouts were &bquo;supported&equo; by flimsy canes. 
 While Janet's plants stayed strong and proud throughout the bad weather, mine were almost horizontal by spring. 
 Dry off the beans 
 One of the best varieties of old-fashioned drying beans is the khaki-coloured &bquo;Dutch Brown&equo;. 
 This year I am also trying &bquo;Chinese Yellow&equo;, claimed to be very resistant to poor weather. 
 These and other varieties are available from the Dutch seed firm Bakker. 
 To dry beans, leave the mature pods on the plants as long as possible, then pull them up by the roots and hang them in the sun to complete drying. 
 In wet weather hand them inside to deter mould. 
 Plum crazy 
 In September's issue of Good Food  magazine you'll find lots of delicious recipes for this season's crop of plums. 
 The cover recipe for a German plum cake is from Glynn Christian, who is celebrating the opening of trade barriers in Europe in 1992. 
 Try his menus from Germany, Portugal, Ireland and an English menu which celebrates King Henry VIII's birthday. 
 You can see him on BBC1's Garden Party, Mondays 12pm. 
 And if you've been watching BBC's Masterchef series, the winning recipes are also in Good Food , on sale August 8.  
 Clover and rye grass should be dug in before flowering 
 Clover is a traditional ley crop 
 Vetch shares with peas and beans the ability to &bquo;fix&equo; nitrogen 
 Green manures, sown in autumn, are turned in when spring comes 
 Sweet corn &bquo;Earliest of All&equo;, ready to be harvested 
 It may look excessive, but this stout staking really pays off 
 Beans drying in the sun give the garden a rustic air 
 60 minute vegetable plot 
 Roy Lacey confronts the weeds, and ponders the lessons of his first season with the labour-saving plot 
 Summer holidays arrive at just the wrong time for gardeners. 
 Everything is growing apace, especially the weeds; there are plants to be watered and crops to be gathered. 
 There's too much to be done in the garden to leave it for a week or more. 
 But, of course, we do. 
 Returning from a break in Wales, we found annual nettles, chickweed and seedling thistles had made a major takeover bid for the plot; a bit of a blow, but not entirely unexpected. 
 Weedy horrors 
 Weeds are opportunists, quick to stake a claim for any vacant patch of ground they find. 
 Some, like chickweed and poppies, have seeds that lie dormant in the soil for long periods until the right conditions trigger them to life. 
 Up until the trip to Gwent, any weeds had been kept in check well within my 60 minutes a week. 
 But it took all of a week's ration of time to restore the plot to its pre-holiday weed-free state. 
 Happily, there hasn't been any problem with the pernicious perennial weeds I find elsewhere in the garden, such as the deep-rooting bindweed and ground elder. 
 Ground elder is said to have been brought to Britain by the Romans as a remedy for gout and has plagued us ever since. 
 Thorough preparation of the plot before sowing also say off those other perennial horrors, couch and horsetail, both of which can go down 6ft or more and spread in all directions. 
 Horsetail is the oldest species of plant still surviving. 
 Its wiry black roots go very deep and break readily, so it is difficult to eradicate. 
 So, too, is couch, or twitch, whose sharp spear-like underground stems pierce potatoes and other root crops. 
 Cleavers, or goosegrass, the weed whose sticky stems and seeds cling to clothing, appeared among the pea vines in June, but was quickly and easily dealt with. 
 So, too, was the odd dandelion seedling that germinated after an airborne invasion of seeds from a patch of wasteland a quarter of mile away. 
 Chickweed, fat hen, groundsel and shepher's purse are the commonest annual weeds in any garden and because of their leaf pattern are easily confused, when young, with the seedlings of cultivated plants. 
 As well as taking up good growing space, they compete with the other plants for light, moisture and nutrients. 
 My various crops have competed not only with weeds but also with each other, a major factor in the profit and loss account for the plot. 
 Pea problem 
 Readers have suggested that it might have been more profitable to give more space to fewer sorts of vegetable, but that would have  been something of a soft option. 
 However, another year I shall not grow even a low line of peas along the south border. 
 Although their rooting system didn't interfere with the other crops, the 18in-tall vines cast too heavy a shadow on the plants below. 
 Their place has been taken by a row of &bquo;Argenta&equo; leeks raised in the seed bed and dibbled into 6in holes spaced about a foot apart. 
 The single row of &bquo;Scarlet Emperor&equo; runner beans along the north border presents no such problem. 
 The beans have now reached the top of their 6ft canes and I'm praying that any autumn gales will be delayed until the beans are all safely harvested. 
 In spring and summer last year, pollination of the runner beans was generally poor. 
 Experts were divided on the cause, with some blaming the hordes of pollen beetles that descended from fields of oil seed rape on to garden crops, other believing the hot, dry weather caused a change in the development of the reproductive system of the plants. 
 But the eventual consensus was that runner beans, which of course rely on insects for pollination, simply weren't getting enough attention from them. 
 In anticipation that the same problem might recur this summer I tried sowing some sweet peas with the runner beans. 
 The result has been both attractive and functional, and there has certainly been no shortage of bees on the beans. 
 The plot pays off 
 The &bquo;Topper&equo; shallots are now in store, hung in our cool cellar in an onion get begged from the greengrocer. 
 When the tops became straw-coloured the clumps were eased from the ground and the bulbs were dried off until the skins were yellow and brittle. 
 As I said earlier this year, there will not be enough of any one crop to give self-sufficiency, but the contribution this small plot has made to the good budget has ten times repaid the outlay on seeds and materials. 
 And after all, what price can you put on the immense satisfaction of taking dew-fresh vegetables to the kitchen within minutes of harvesting them? 
 As for the time investment, planning the layout, preparing the plot by digging and manuring, sowing the seeds and watering those crops that needed extra moisture were all carried out well within the weekly ration of 60 minutes. 
 However, there's no doubt the blitz on the weeds on our return from holiday took a disproportionately long spell. 
 My inclination is to reconsider this summer holiday ritual. 
 It's a critical time to be abandoning the plot. 
 Your 60-minute action checklist 
 &bull; 
 Thin out the parsley sown in July. 
 In hard winter areas it will need protection with cloches to continue cropping all through the winter. 
 &bull; 
 Transplant the sowing of spring cabbages made in July into the patch that grew the shallots. 
 But don't add any fertiliser; these plants will have to stand through the winter, so it's not a good idea to encourage too much soft growth. 
 &bull; 
 Make a final sowing of an early carrot, such as &bquo;Amsterdam Forcing&equo;, &bquo;Early Nantes&equo;, &bquo;Almoro&equo; or &bquo;Bertop&equo;, for pulling as baby carrots at around Christmas time. 
 Cover with Agryl P17 before the first frosts. 
 &bull; 
 Towards the end of the month lift carrots and beetroot and store in boxes of peat, peat substitute or sand. 
 &bull; 
 Check the underside of the Brussels sprout plants for whitefly. 
 Spray with a soap-based insecticide twice weekly until clear. 
 Savona, Sebon, Nature's Answer and Bio Friendly's Pest Pistol are all suitable alternative controls to conventional agrochemicals. 
 Vegetable grow guide  Sweet Peppers 
 Varieties to choose 
 Nearly 30 capsicum varieties are listed in seed catalogues. 
 Colours range from green and yellow to deep red. 
 Some of the best are the dwarf Redskin, Gypsy, Clio, Luteus (yellow), Bellboy, Canape (red), and New Ace. 
 Sowing and growing 
 &bull; 
 From March-April sow seed 1/2in deep in pots. 
 Place in a heated propagator. 
 &bull; 
 When seedlings have 3 leaves prick out into 2&ndash;3in pots. 
 &bull; 
 Keep watered and in good light and warmth. 
 Continue to pot on as required into larger pots. 
 &bull; 
 Wait until first flowers have set fruit before planting out the peppers. 
 &bull; 
 Capsicums are frost tender. 
 Plant outside under cloches when all fear of frost has passed (late May/mid June). 
 &bull; 
 Harden off greenhouse raised plants before planting out, warming the soil first by covering with cloches. 
 &bull; 
 Pinch out the tip of the main shoot when 8&ndash;12in tall to promote the formation of side shoots. 
 Site &amp; soil Sweet peppers crop well in growing bags, planting 3 per bag, or can be grown singly in 9in pots of potting compost. 
 Alternatively, grow outside in full sun. 
 Soil should be rich and moisture retentive, but free-draining. 
 Pest problems 
 Greenhouse crops are susceptible to greenfly, whitefly and red spider mite which all feed on the leaves. 
 Inspect plants regularly and spray at the first signs of attack. 
 Spray with a suitable insecticide or use biological control. 
 Aftercare 
 &bull; 
 Vigorous plants need staking and regular tying in. 
 &bull; 
 Water regularly, ensuring the compost/soil never dries out. 
 &bull; 
 Mist plants each day to prevent red spider mite attack. 
 &bull; 
 Once fruits have set, feed weekly with a high potash liquid tomato fertiliser when watering. 
 &bull; 
 Harvest fruits when plump and full sized. 
 Leave to mature and ripen on the plant for fruits to change colour as required. 
  Grow guide by Adam Pasco   
 Weeding after a week away took the entire 60-minute ration of time 
 Groundsel flourishes rapidly, soon occupying good growing space 
 The end of September is the time to lift and store carrots and beetroot. 
 Pack them carefully in boxes of peat, peat substitute or sand 
 Common chickweed, another familiar annual nuisance 
 On some varieties green fruits ripen to a deep glowing red 
 &bquo;Gypsy&equo; produces early, heavy crops, especially under glass 
 The Victorian kitchen garden 
 Jennifer Davies finds out how Victorian gardeners did battle with the bugs 
 A peewit in the greenhouse is a friend. 
 Well, that was the view of a gardener writing in February 1858 to the journal The Cottage Gardener . 
 His peewit, he said, would manifest its friendship by its exemplary conduct, eating insects of all shapes and sizes but never pecking or injuring the plants. 
 The same writer recommended giving glasshouse room to a few hedgehogs, ideal for keeping down woodlice. 
 Toad sentinel 
 When he first came to Chilton, Harry Dodson recalls that the pest controller in the glasshouses was a large old toad. 
 It took a bit of getting used to. 
 It was, Harry says, something of a shock to life a flowerpot and be confronted by the toad's baleful stare. 
 It also didn't help that the toad's colouring blended perfectly with the surroundings for, Harry remembers, you never knew from where it might jump. 
 One day a young journeyman white-washing the inside of the houses ran his brush over the toad's back. 
 From that time on it was easier to spot. 
 The ritual of the whitewashing (or limewashing, as Harry calls it) the houses was in itself a method of pest control. 
 The lime was mixed with flowers of sulphur so that the walls would give off sulphurous fumes when they got warm. 
 Limewashing began in October and all the houses had to be finished by the end of February, as many would then have the heat turned up to set their inmates into growth. 
 It was also during the winter months that vines were taken down from their wires and their ends tied (often to the water pipes) so that they formed a large bow shape. 
 This checked the sap and induced even growth. 
 The vines were tied back up when the new growth was 4&ndash;6in long. 
 Bug beaters 
 When the rods (stems) were first taken down they were scraped and painted with sulphur mixed with paraffin and soft soap. 
 The crevices where the spurs were cut back each year were particularly attractive hiding places for mealy bugs. 
 However, like the newly decorated glasshouse toad, the mealy bugs, being white, found it difficult to remain unseen. 
 Harry says that a drop of methylated spirit dotted onto their backs from a camel hair brush caused them to turn pink and expire immediately. 
 Years ago, before it was made illegal, pure nicotine was used for fumigating glasshouses. 
 A little would be sprinkled into a small metal dish placed on top of a metal cylinder. 
 Inside was a lighted wick; as the metal dish warmed up, the nicotine began to sizzle and give off fumes lethal to red spider mite and aphids. 
 Almost all garden glasshouses were treated in this way. 
 Harry recalls. 
 But it was not without its problems. 
 You had, he says, to be careful not to fumigate on a foggy night when the air was too heavy to let the fumes drift away. 
 If that happened, when the sun came out the lingering nicotine would burn yellow marks around the edges of young foliage. 
 Soot solution 
 In those days, a bag of soot purchased from the local chimney sweep was a valuable aid to bug control. 
 The bag was dropped into a tank of water and swilled round occasionally like a giant tea bag. 
 The fresher the soot, the longer it needed to percolate through the hessian, but within three or four days the water would be nicely laced. 
 Regular spraying with this soot solution kept leaf miners off chrysanthemums standing outside in pots. 
 Harry also remembers that when he was a journeyman at Stanstead Park, the liquid was used to deter red spider mite from violet cuttings planted out in cool spots in the grounds. 
 Compared to today's remedies it was an effective and extremely economical solution: one bag of soot lasted all summer! 
 Harry's hints 
 &bull; 
 Lure wasps to sticky deaths in narrow-necked jam-jars. 
 Quarter fill the jars with old beer and rotten fruit and hang them out on fruit trees 
 &bull; 
 Trap earwigs as they advance up your peach trees by tying small lengths of hollow broad bean sticks to the branches. 
 The offending insects can be blown out each morning into a jar of water. 
 &bull; 
 For earwigs bend on molesting your chrysanthemums, wood-wool or hay stuffed into a small flowerpot hung upside down at the top of a cane offers a similarly unsafe and temporary lodging. 
 &bull; 
 Poke a carrot into beds containing old meadow loam. 
 The carrot will attract any wireworm around, which can be lifted out as they munch on it (Harry says he finds this particularly useful for melon beds). 
 &bull; 
 Half a grapefruit or orange scraped out and put down forms a trap for slugs attacking young lettuce or rockery plants. 
 The slugs obligingly congregate beneath the citrus dome and can be gathered for disposal. 
 Earwigs are only too ready to picnic on a peach 
 Chilton's baleful toad repelled pests and staff alike 
 Tebb's fearsome-looking &bquo;Universal Fumigator&equo; 
 Spider mite comfy on cucumber 
 Gardens by design 
 The straight &amp; narrow 
 Narrow garden design project: part one 
 If you take a train ride into any of our major cities you will see thousands of long narrow gardens in serried ranks on either side of the track. 
 In all probability you will also see how not to lay them out. 
 That is, with a path slap down the middle, a flanking washing line and four narrow borders around the edge. 
 The effect is similar to dressing a tall man in a pinstripe suit &mdash; it simply accentuates the length! 
 In fact, gardens that are long and narrow are among the more simple to design because they can be broken down very easily into separate garden areas or &bquo;rooms&equo;, each of them having a different function or theme. 
 This philosophy, though on a far grander scale, can be observed in practice in such great gardens as Sissinghurst in Kent and Hidcote Manor in Gloucestershire, where similar plants and colour combinations have been placed in walled or hedged parts of the larger garden. 
 Long narrow plots often adjoin older properties and this can give you the opportunity of working existing trees and shrubs into the new design. 
 When you carry out the initial survey to check just what you have got and what you want, don't discard anything that might make a positive contribution to the garden later on. 
 In older gardens, particularly those that date back to Edwardian or Victorian times, you might be lucky enough to inherit paths laid in old blue paving bricks, or some of those delightful &bquo;rope&equo; edging tiles that cost a small fortune to buy today. 
 If you do, you must lift them very carefully and stack them ready to use again. 
 The garden we show is typical, measuring approximately 25ft (8m) wide and 112ft (35m) long. 
 It faces south-west and slopes gently away from the house. 
 Amply proportioned patio 
 As in most gardens a sitting, dining, and entertaining area is an absolute must. 
 This means that a patio of ample size will be needed, which could use a combination of pre-cast slabs and new brick paving, or, of you are lucky, some old bricks that may have been in the garden already. 
 Here, these have been laid in a bold panel close to the house and have also been used in strips and courses so that they tie the raised pool into  the overall design of the terrace. 
 The pool forms a real focal point from both the house and patio, while the sound of water, falling from a mask set in the wall, will be delightful on a hot summer's day. 
 Of course, if you have a young family and feel water might be a hazard, the feature could become a raised sandpit or planter, which naturally gives you the opportunity of converting it at a later stage. 
 On the other side of the terrace a raised bed provides visual balance and accommodates a specimen juniper and winter flowering heathers. 
 Moving away from the terrace, broad steps drop down past a rose and herb bed edged with low growing box to the first lawn level, which would make an ideal play area. 
 The path flanking the lawn leads first down and then across the garden to help create a feeling of greater space. 
 This zig-zagging technique is particularly effective in visually widening the area, since it passes between the two wings of planting that divide this second &bquo;room&equo; from the next. 
 A final change of level takes us under the archway into the next small grassed and planted area, an altogether quieter space. 
 The path leads down and around to a brick-paved seating area situated beneath a climber-covered arbour looking back towards the house. 
 The final garden section has been screened off neatly with espalier fruit and given over to salad crops and utility elements such as a shed, a compost area and an incinerator (essential ingredients in most compositions). 
 Softening the pattern 
 It is an interesting thought that this whole design has been built up from a series of interlocking rectangles. 
 People often avoid using too many straight lines in a garden as they fear that the end result will look clinical. 
 In fact, selective planting will help to soften the overall pattern and, if the shapes are carefully worked out and planted well, the final result will be a functional and fascinating living lesson in geometry that will serve you and your family well. 
 Archways and arbours need the stout timber treatment 
 Important parts of the overall design are the archway, halfway down the garden, and the arbour at the bottom. 
 Too often these features are made from flimsy, untreated timbers, too week to last long. 
 They look like it, too. 
 I would also avoid all those bent wire contraptions: they may look attractive in a well photographed catalogue but do little for the design of your garden. 
 Remember that any such feature is simply a vehicle for the plants to be grown over it, and in a few years the structure becomes incidental to the glory of the climber that smothers it. 
 It's best to use a simple design and stout timbers, well treated with a non-toxic preservative &mdash; don't use creosote, sure death to plants. 
 Topical tip 
 Using a zig-zagging technique with your garden path will create a felling of greater space and, if it is placed between the plantings, will enhance the &bquo;separate room&equo; effect.  
 An arch creates a feeling of spaciousness, giving the garden an &bquo;extra room&equo; 
 The arbour will play host to Vitis coignetiae , the crimson glory vine 
 Hibiscus syriacus  &bquo;Woodbridge&equo; will add colour to the borders 
 TV Special 
 Cope with a slope 
 A sloping garden needn't be an uphill struggle, as Pippa Greenwood discovered when she lent a hand to the Lloyds on camera 
 When I first met Chris and Pauline Lloyd to discuss their garden and take a look at its one-in-three slope, I was filled with a mixture of admiration for them, and horror at the task ahead. 
 But they have proved that with a good plan, persistence and a lot of hard work even a very steep slope can be transformed into a tremendous garden. 
 If you're going to tackle a project like this yourself there are a few golden rules. 
 &bull; 
 Start with a good plan. 
 You could do it yourself or get expert help. 
 We were lucky to have at our service the skilled pen of Dick Allen of the Millbrook Garden Centre in Sussex. 
 &bull; 
 Break up the slope by creating different levels. 
 We created an attractive and useful patio area paved with wooden decking and surrounded by planting towards the lower end of the garden. 
 This provided a totally separate area to the levelled lawn in front of the house. 
 &bull; 
 If possible increase the size of any vaguely level area already there, as we did with the lawn. 
 A sturdy retaining wall will hold everything in place and you can use soil taken from other areas to fill in gaps. 
 Remember to keep all the topsoil you remove; you're bound to find a use for it later! 
 &bull; 
 A winding, levelled path at a gentle gradient is much easier to walk down. 
 Stepping stones, laid level, can give access to other areas. 
 &bull; 
 As you build up and level out areas of the garden, keep the soil in place using retaining walls. 
 We used Forest palisade poles, which are pressure-treated with preservative and guaranteed to last for at least fifteen years. 
 Inadequately treated wood is not worth bothering with: the retaining walls are too fundamental to the design and structure to take any risks. 
 The poles must be set vertically (use a spirit level). 
 Concrete mixed dry (5 parts ballast to 1 cement) will make the job easier. 
 We widened the steps slightly to make them a secure and comfortable width to walk and wheel a barrow down. 
 &bull; 
 The path's risers here are Forest sleepers, flattened top and bottom. 
 As they lie smoothly  on top of one another, they were also used for the principal retaining walk around the lawn. 
 &bull; 
 Create some privacy. 
 One of the problems with a sloping garden is that it may be overlooked by many other houses. 
 We used Chelsea trellis and a pergola to shield the upper area. 
 When planning screens make sure that all areas will still be readily accessible, not only so you can enjoy the whole garden but also to make planting and maintenance easier. 
 &bull; 
 There are a wide range of plants which will be perfect for planting on sloped beds. 
 Ground cover is particularly valuable, as it will keep the soil in situ. 
 I recommend Vinca major, Vinca minor, Brachyglottis  (or Senecio ) greyi, Potentilla  &bquo;Tangerine&equo;, Spiraea  &bquo;Goldflame&equo;, Lamium maculatum  &bquo;Beacon Silver&equo;, Rosa  &bquo;Paulii&equo;, Rosa  &bquo;Essex&equo;, Stephanandra incisa  &bquo;Crispa&equo;, Juniperus  &bquo;Blue Carpet&equo;, Geranium  &bquo;Johnson's Blue&equo;, Pachysandra terminalis  and the lowgrowing helianthemums. 
 &bull; 
 Finally, and very importantly, make the features of the gradient work for, not against you. 
 You can successfully use plants in all situations, allowing them to grow down and up the slope and trail over pergolas, trellis and fences. 
 We constructed a multi-level pool with a cascading waterfall. 
 Combine this with a seat at the water's edge and you have a lovely place to sit and admire the distant views and your new-look garden. 
 From their first-floor sitting room the Lloyds have a new perspective on the garden, the pool and the top of their pergola! 
 If you would like more information on how we coped with the Lloyds' slope and how you could do the same with yours, write enclosing a stamped addressed envelope to The Horticultural Trades Association, PO Box 56, Reading, Berkshire RG7 5JJ. 
 Dick Allen's design 
 1 
 Paved area 
 2 
 Brick paving/path 
 3 
 Gravel path 
 4 
 Lawn 
 5 
 Brick edging 
 6 
 Low retaining wall ( Forest border timbers) 
 7 
 Steps (Forest mini-sleeper risers with gravel treads) 
 8 
 Compost bin (screened from top lawn area) 
 9 
 Chelsea trellis 
 10 
 Retaining wall (Forest minisleepers laid horizontally) 
 11 
 Seat 
 12 
 Pond (with butyl liner) 
 13 
 Pergola 
 14 
 Retaining wall (Forest palisades set vertically) 
 15 
 Stepping stones 
 16 
 Sitting area (floored in Forest checkerboard decking) 
 17 
 Leyland cypress hedge 
 Forest British timber products are a renewable source 
 Stakes set in cut-out notches hold the steps firmly 
 Pippa gives Chris a hand in the 1:3 sloping garden 
 Using wood throughout ties the design together 
 Planting will give the patio area at the base of the garden more privacy 
 Gardeners' Manual 
 The essential reference book 
 Start collecting our superb free Gardeners' Manual and month by month it will build into a reference book you will turn to time and time again. 
 Compiled exclusively for BBC Gardeners' World Magazine  by Andi Clevely, the Gardeners' Manual provides detailed advice, explains techniques and gives practical information on choosing and using plants. 
 Packed with gardening know-how, its structured style and easy-to-follow, well-illustrated format will appeal to every gardener, from novice to enthusiast. 
 The Gardeners' Manual has been designed to pull out and collect, so you can always keep it close at hand with your other gardening reference books. 
 Coming next month in part 8 
 &bull; 
 A practical guide to rock gardens and alpine plants, including sink gardens 
 &bull; 
 Choosing and using a cold frame through the year 
 &bull; 
 Heating your greenhouse 
 &bull; 
 Successful outdoor ferns and non-flowering plants 
 &bull; 
 Growing fruit under glass 
 &bull; 
 We show you how to spot and combat diseases, with advice on various control methods 
 Part 7 
 Remainder of insert captured after page 85 of main magazine 
 Portrait gallery 
 Rays of Sunshine 
 Always bright and cheerful, daisies never fail to lift Roy Lancaster's spirits 
 If there is in flower which above all others triggers memories of childhood days it is the humble daisy. 
 There can be few of us who cannot make a daisy chain with our eyes closed &mdash; and who could forget the daisy-spangled downs and pastures where we loved to picnic? 
 Life would not have been the same without them, nor would it be now, considering the lasting impression they made in our minds. 
 Maybe part of the daisy's popularity lies in its shape, a yellow disk fringed with white petals (correctly ray-florets), a simple arrangement which reminds us of the sun. 
 Look at any toddler's drawing of the two and you will see what I mean. 
 Chain reaction 
 Happily (and daisy flowers always make me feel happy) the same arrangement and connotations may be reproduced again and again in the garden by planting a selection of daisy relatives and look-alikes. 
 Given the variety available there are enough to fill most of our summer and early autumn days with colour, bold foliage and, let's not forget, happy memories. 
 Leucanthemella serotina  is what I was brought up to call Chrysanthemum ulginosum , the so-called moon daisy of Hungary, where it is often found growing in damp places. 
 It does not demand such a situation in  cultivation but there is no doubt that it thrives best in deep soils that do not dry out in summer. 
 A hardy herbaceous perennial, it develops a bold clump of erect leafy stems as much as 6ft tall, crowned in autumn with loose sprays of green-eyed, white rayed daisies 2in across. 
 Sun-seeking flowers 
 Curiously enough, these charming blooms turn to face and follow the sun as it progresses across the sky, a phenomenon you will find frustrating if you have planted it in a north-facing border, since they will invariably turn their backs on you. 
 Given its height and vigour, L. serotina  is probably best accommodated at the back of a herbaceous border or in the wild garden if you are lucky enough to have such a place. 
 Do not, however, plant it in shade or flowering will be less than satisfactory. 
 Silphium laciniatum , from the prairies of the central and southeastern states of America, is another six-footer, sometimes more, whose large, deeply divided foliage is far more ornamental than the yellow daisies it produces in late summer. 
 Interestingly, the leaves, which are stiff and bristly, turn their faces to avoid the full heat of the sun. 
 They are poised with their edges on a north-south axis, hence its American name, the compass plant. 
 Just as fascinating is the related S perfoliatum , another giant in which the upper pair of leaves unite at their base to form a cup-shaped depression where, after rain, a little pool of water collects. 
 Both these plants are hardy and although not in the front rank of ornamentals, are worth growing in a large border or even on the bank of a stream or lake provided they are kept away from the wet margin. 
 Inula magnifica  also grows and looks well by water, but is equally happy in the deep rich soil of a border or bed. 
 Its great clumps of rough, hairy stems can grow up to 6ft tall. 
 Its equally hairy large leaves will dominate any border or waterside planting and when the large imposing deep yellow daisies appear in late summer all traffic stops. 
 The daisies can be as much as 5 or 6in across and are carried in terminal branched heads, a truly remarkable sight. 
 A Georgian giant 
 In common with several other well-known giants such as the giant hogweed, I. magnifica  is native to the Caucasus mountains of the Russian republic of Georgia, where it is commonly seen in damp meadows and by streams, often on the margins of woodland or in glades. 
 In cultivation it is quite hardy and suited  to all but dry or exposed places. 
 Telekia speciosa , from southeastern Europe and western Asia, is a perennial noted for its bold pile of large, long-stalked, heart-shaped leaves and its suitability for waterside planting although, like Inula magnifica , it is satisfactory in most deep rich soils. 
 It has another virtue too in shade tolerance, providing the soil beneath is deep and cool. 
 Spectacular spread 
 The broad branching heads of large, ragged yellow daisies appear over a long period during summer; a large patch is a magnificent spectacle. 
 Given its spreading tendencies, telekia is not a plant for small gardens unless steps can be taken to contain its roots. 
 It is excellent for naturalising in &bquo;wild&equo; gardens. 
 All those who grow Aster x frikartii&equo; &bquo;M&ouml;nch&equo;  agree that it is one of the finest herbaceous perennials ever raised. 
 It is one of three seedlings of a hybrid raised in Switzerland around 1920 and consequently named after Swiss mountains. 
 Its parents are the European Aster amellus , of which many varieties are grown in gardens, and the Himalayan A. thomsonii , usually represented in British gardens by the dwarf form &bquo;Nanus&equo;. 
 For weeks on end through late  summer and autumn the large lavender-blue, gold-eyed daisies are displayed on branching stems up to 3ft tall. 
 It is suitable for even the smallest gardens, and if you can only accommodate one daisy-flowered perennial it should be this. 
 Give it a rich soil in full sun and it will pay for its keep a thousandfold. 
 A delicate daisy 
 Senecio pulcher  is a plant for the adventurous gardener. 
 For a start, it is not the hardiest of perennials; not surprisingly considering that it hails from Uruguay. 
 Added to this, it is regarded as a special treat by snails and slugs who will soon polish it off given the opportunity. 
 So why, you may well ask, try to grow it then? 
 You will understand when you see its handsome dark green leathery leaves and startling gold-eyed daisies, their cerise-magenta ray florets in branched heads 1&ndash;1/2ft above the ground. 
 The combination is dramatic and somehow unexpected in a senecio, especially as it takes place in autumn when most other border perennials have flowered and then faded. 
 A moist but well-drained fertile soil in a warm sheltered corner will give it the best chance, and even then only in the mildest areas &mdash; and do not forget the slugs! 
 If you're looking for another daisy-flowered perennial to form the perfect contrast with Aster x frikartii  &bquo;M&ouml;nch&equo; I could recommend no better plant than Rudbeckia fulgida deamii . 
 Its rough, hairy, much-branched stems rise to 2ft and will reward you in late summer and early autumn with numerous vivid yellow daisies with blackish central cones, well earning this plant the name black-eyed Susan. 
 It is hardy and easy to cultivate in most soils, even dry ones, but thrives best in soil which retains some moisture in the summer. 
 Give it a sunny position and it will be your pal for life. 
 Echinacea purpurea , also native to the American prairies, was at one time included with the rudbeckias as R. purpurea , differing most obviously in having purplish-red ray-florets. 
 It is a rather stiff-stemmed perennial up to 3ft tall with dark green leathery leaves which are rough to the touch. 
 Backswept blooms 
 The few-branched stems are topped by large single daises, the petals reflexed (turned back) and the bold central boss orange-brown, rounded and prickly to the touch. 
 Even better is &bquo;Robert Bloom&equo; with larger, mire richly-coloured flowers. 
 Contrasting with these are &bquo;White Lustre&equo; ans &bquo;White Swan&equo;, both with white-rayed daisies. 
 All forms of E. purpurea  enjoy a rich, deep, well-drained soil in sun and are best propagated by root cuttings. 
 Their flowers appear over several weeks in summer and are at all times most striking and handsome. 
 Gallery guide 
 Aster x frikartii &bquo;M&ouml;nch&equo; 
 Hailing from the Swiss Alps it prefers rich soil and full sun. 
 Large blue daisies make a wonderful display through late summer and autumn. 
 Echinacea purpurea 
 A rather stiff-stemmed perennial whose few branches are each topped by a large daisy with reflexed petals. 
 Prefers rich well-drained soil in the sun. 
 Propagate from root cuttings. 
 Inula magnifica 
 Imposing six-footer with large hairy leaves and spectacular deep yellow daisies. 
 Hails from the Caucasus mountains and is well suited to all but dry or exposed sites. 
 Leucanthemella serotina 
 The so-called &bquo;moon daisy&equo; of Hungary thrives in deep, moist soils. 
 Grows to 6ft, crowned with green-eyed white daisies two inches in diameter. 
 Silphium laciniatum/perfoliatum 
 Both good in large borders or near water, growing up to 6ft, with highly ornamental bristly foliage and less spectacular yellow daisies. 
 Native to the US prairies. 
 Telekia speciosa 
 Noted for its long-stalked heart-shaped leaves, shade tolerance and suitability for waterside planting. 
 Bears ragged yellow daisies for much of the summer. 
 Senecio pulcher 
 Delicate Uraguayan perennial beloved of slugs! 
 Dramatic foliage and flowers make it a worthwhile challenge for the adventurous. 
 Rudbeckia fulgida deamii 
 With yellow petals and dark cones, black-eyed Susan tolerates most conditions, but prefers moisture and sunshine. 
 Tune in to&hellip; 
 Join Roy Lancaster in the new series of Channel 4's practical ideas show Garden Club, broadcast on Fridays at 9.30pm (repeated on Mondays at 2pm). 
 The series begins on August 23  
 Rudbeckia fulgida deamii  is better known as black-eyed Susan 
 Leucanthamella serotina  has classic sunburst blooms 
 Aster x frikarti  &bquo;M&ouml;nch&equo;, one of the finest perennial plants 
 Senecio pulcher  needs good soil and a sunny, sheltered corner 
 Inula magnifica  will thrive best in deep, rich soils, even in shade 
 Echinacea purpurea comes from the American prairies 
 Green Gardening 
 Waging war on weeds 
 Work with nature and you can make nature work for you, advises Geoff Hamilton from his organic garden 
 Earlier in the year, wherever you looked, whatever you read, gardeners were complaining of the constant battle against weeds. 
 Gardening columns in the Sunday newspapers were full of it, magazines and television programmes gave advice and encouragement and the garden centres made a killing on weedkiller sales. 
 The problem was the unusual one of a warmish (well, for the plants anyway), wet spring. 
 Ideal conditions, in fact, for the growth of all plants and especially the natives. 
 Weeds? 
 What weeds? 
 At the risk of sounding smug, my ornamental kitchen garden gave me no such problems. 
 Weeds? 
 What weeds? 
 The reason, of course, is that my garden is so packed with plants that the weeds simply don't stand a chance. 
 In the middle of the borders, where I can't reach without treading on the soil, I grow shrubs and perennials that need hardly any attention during the year. 
 They're planted quite closely together to deny any weeds a chance of seeing the sunshine. 
 The interlopers soon give up the unequal contest. 
 In the front of the borders where I can reach, I grow my vegetables, annuals and low-growing perennials in patches rather than in rows. 
 Here, of course, weeds do have more space to grow, but they're discouraged by constant cultivation. 
 As soon as one patch of vegetables is cleared, the soil is revitalised with compost and a handful of organic fertiliser and lightly pricked over before replanting. 
 When I do have to evict an intruder, I've discovered that it's far better to pull the weeds out rather than hoe them. 
 The reason is that physically removing a weed, especially a perennial, is quite final, while one hoed out and simply left on the surface can easily root in again, especially in wet weather. 
 So when I go round the garden, I carry two containers: a bucket for compostable weeds, and a plastic bag for those perennials  with tough tools that might survive. 
 So any docks, dandelions and creeping buttercup go straight to the tip and good riddance to them too. 
 Swings and roundabouts 
 But I have to confess that what I save on the weedless swings, I lose on the rampant roundabouts. 
 Because my plants are packed in so tightly I spend a great deal of time trimming and tying. 
 And, of course, closely packed plants compete not only with the weeds but with each other. 
 So in this type of garden you'll need to be doubly vigilant, first ensuring that you keep the soil well fed and watered, then keeping a constant umpiring eye open to make sure that one plant is not starting to take unfair advantage of another.  
 Weeds don't stand a chance in the closely-planted beds at Barnsdale 
 Weeds sprouting in the path can be left or very easily dealt with 
 Hand-weeding prevents perennial weeds from gaining a foothold 
 Pooled resources bring benefits to all 
 For an organic garden a pool is essential. 
 A place for all kinds of wildlife to stop off and drink, it will attract them like a magnet. 
 That's good news for pest control, and even better for gardeners whose interest spreads to birds, butterflies, bees and other creatures. 
 I've spent hours crouching behind plants watching birds and insects, hedgehogs, often frogs and toads and on one memorable occasion a young fox. 
 Somehow, I'm sure that wild animals have a sixth sense that tells them they're safe, even in the presence of their arch-enemy, man. 
 How could it be otherwise, when I have an almost tame squirrel that happily hops about the borders when I'm feeding or digging? 
 He seems completely secure in the knowledge that I'm far too soppy to do him any harm. 
 A balanced regime 
 But pools need regular maintenance too. 
 I try to maintain a regime that keeps wildlife happy. 
 And that means regular work. 
 Tadpoles and young frogs love a pool chock-full of oxygenating weed in the spring and early summer. 
 It gives them plenty of cover and also somewhere to rest with their heads out of the water but their bodies submerged. 
 But if the pool is simply left like this, it will become choked and unattractive. 
 And, after all, though wildlife is important, I deserve my fun too. 
 I like a bit of clear water and the chance to grow attractive aquatics like lilies. 
 Fortunately my own fancies and those of the wildlife can be accommodated. 
 I leave the weed in the pool untouched until the frogs have departed. 
 Then I pull some of it out to clear a bit of space. 
 The difficulty is that every handful of weed that's pulled out is likely to contain its fair share of aquatic creatures too. 
 However insignificant, they still don't deserve to be thrown out with the bathwater, or rather the pond water. 
 So, I pull handfuls of weed and leave it near the water's edge, giving at least some of the creatures the chance to nip back into the water again. 
 The next day I swish the weed around in a bucket of pondwater, throw the water back in and the weed away. 
 It's still hard to know whether I've saved them all, but at least I know I've done my best.  
 Removing weed once young frogs have departed, a compromise between man and wildlife 
 Frogs love to bask on the surface of dense aquatic vegetation 
 A pool needs tending to remain this lovely 
 Wonderful worm factories 
 There could, I have to admit, be something dramatically wrong with me. 
 While other chaps sing the praises of Meryl Streep, Joely Richardson or Gabriela Sabatini, I'm much more likely to be found getting worked up over worms. 
 Star soil performers 
 I don't care what you say, they really are marvellous creatures and one of the few animals in God's world that do absolutely nothing but good. 
 In the soil they aerate, they cultivate and they fertilise and in captivity they'll turn your rubbish into gold dust. 
 I bet Meryl can't manage that! 
 Worm casts make excellent additives to composts, not only improving the structure of the medium but adding nutrients and growth-promoting hormones too. 
 And you can manufacture bucketfuls of this marvellous stuff from nothing more than kitchen waste. 
 You'd have to be daft not to want to give it a go. 
 My own worm factory is made from a plastic dustbin and it works well, but I welcome the advent of a new, custom-made job at what I think is a pretty reasonable price. 
 It consists of a plastic bin with a lockable lid that will keep out flies, children and so on. 
 Inside is a plastic platform which is perforated to allow liquids to seep through to the tank in the bottom. 
 This keeps the material inside reasonably dry and sweet and also provides a liquid fertiliser that can be drawn off regularly via a tap at the bottom. 
 The kit arrives complete with worms, a pack of starter compost to get the process going, calcified seaweed to keep the compost sweet and non-acidic; there's even a ready-torn supply of strips of newspaper to go in the bottom. 
 All you do is put in the starter compost and the newspaper, add the worms and put some kitchen waste on top. 
 This is gently mixed up with the compost and the worms get to work. 
 At they munch their way through, you progressively add waste until the bin's full. 
 Then you remove the top layer, which will contain all the worms. 
 This is set on one side to start again after emptying out your reward, the valuable compost. 
 Warm worms up in winter 
 The bin is completely portable, so it can be brought into the warmth in winter so that the worms will continue to work. 
 And the lid's so well-fitting, you could even have it in your sitting room. 
 Oh well, perhaps not. 
 The wormery is available from: Original Organics Ltd, Organic House, PO Box 6, Tiverton, Devon EX16 7SL and costs &pound;38.45 inclusive. 
 Flocking to amazing &bquo;Grace&equo; 
 The decorative smoke tree Cotinus coggygria  gives terrific value in the garden. 
 The hybrid variety &bquo;Grace&equo; is even better, with huge deep red leaves throughout the spring and summer that turn fiery red in autumn. 
 What I didn't discover until recently was that it provides a bonus for organic gardeners. 
 I've had this shrub for a few years now but it has been a bit reluctant to bloom. 
 But this year, it has finally decided to flower profusely, forming brownish clouds which drift hazily over the bush. 
 And those flowers are literally buzzing with honey-making, pollinating bees and greenfly-eating hoverflies. 
 Just let anyone come near it with a sprayer! 
 Tune in to&hellip; 
 BBC Gardeners' World, on Fridays at 8.30pm (repeated on Tuesday, 5.30pm) where Geoff Hamilton passes on more organic gardening advice from Barnsdale every week  
 Geoff's Barnsdale buddies make short work of kitchen waste 
 Wildlife will grace your garden more often with this cotinus 
 Organic advice 
 From Pauline Pears and Sue Strickland of the National Centre for Organic Gardening 
 Save it for the birds 
 Don't chop off all the deadheads in your border the moment the flowers fade. 
 Leave some for the birds. 
 Their antics as they tease out the ripe seeds in autumn are a delight. 
 You will quickly spot which plants produce their favourite seeds. 
 In general, simple cottage garden type flowers are the best; highly bred double varieties and hybrids are less likely to give a good seed crop. 
 Yarrow, cranesbill, goldenrod, globe thistle, rose campion and Michaelmas daisies are usually in the birds' top ten of herbaceous plants. 
 Herbs are popular too, particularly umbellifers such as angelica, lovage and fennel. 
 As a special treat for finches, plant a few giant sunflowers next year. 
 Strawberry strategy 
 An early start for strawberries ensures a full crop the following season, so you should plant out your runners now. 
 October plantings make small plants which do not crop well until the second year. 
 Strawberry plants deteriorate after three years of cropping and need re-siting. 
 They aren't heavy eaters so do not need constant feeding, but they do prefer well-drained, humus-rich soil. 
 To prepare, fork compost into the top 6in of soil, a barrowful to every 4sq yd. 
 Add a barrow of rotted manure for every 120sq yd. 
 If you can't plant them out at once, pot up the runners and plant out later. 
 Keeping slugs off your spuds 
 Ever dug up a bed of apparently flourishing potatoes, only to find the tubers riddles with holes where the slugs have been at them? 
 The major culprit is the keeled slug, dark grey or black with a distinct ridge down its back, which lives mostly in the soil. 
 Slugs turn to the potato crop in late summer, when other food sources are disappearing. 
 Once started, there is little you can to to stop them, and the damage increases greatly in September. 
 A good solution is to harvest the crop early in September, storing the tubers out of harms way. 
 Chilling news 
 September is one of the best times for sowing wildflower seeds, particularly the many mixtures now available. 
 Some wildflower seeds need a period of cold before they will germinate. 
 You could put them in the fridge, but many like a fluctuating temperature which would be extremely hard to simulate! 
 Wild seeds needing chilling before germination include poppies, primroses and umbellifers like wild carrot and angelica. 
 Topical tip 
 To obtain a free catalogue from the National Centre for Organic Gardening, please send a large stamped (32p) addressed envelope to the HDRA, Ryton-on-Dunsmore, Coventry CV8 3LG 
 Know your friends 
 The earwig is not immediately recognisable as a gardener's friend, and has been known to damage fruit. 
 So we were surprised when a local entomologist advised us to put sacking around our fruit trees or straw round their bases to encourage the insect. 
 Earwigs are redeemed by an appetite for the eggs of moths and sawflies, including gooseberry sawfly, and winter, tortrix and codling moth.  
 Flower garden 
 Little wonders 
 Bulbs bring welcome colour to the New Year, says Anne Swithinbank, and even the smallest garden can house a stunning display of miniature varieties 
 The main bulb planting season is upon us once again. 
 Shops and garden centres are fully stocked with row upon row of tempting treasures to add to our gardens. 
 Spring-flowering bulbs are difficult for any kind of gardener to resist since, unless they are asked to grow in appalling soil conditions, success if usually guaranteed. 
 As well as the more familiar tall-growing daffodils and tulips, there are many dwarf-growing bulbs to choose from. 
 Their diminutive size makes them suitable for even the smallest, most overcrowded garden. 
 Early spring colour 
 My favourites have definitely got to be those which flower early in January and February. 
 They will brighten the garden, produce leaf and die down again often before other plants have come into growth. 
 Early flowering crocus species and certain varieties of Crocus chrysanthus  are particularly lovely and extremely reliable. 
 We've planted several different kinds in drifts under a beech hedge. 
 Planning striking displays 
 The first to open is &bquo;Zwanenburg Bronze&equo;, whose bronze-streaked yellow flowers open up wide in the low shafts of February sunshine. 
 Delicate creamy-yellow &bquo;E P Bowles&equo; stays open just long enough to contrast beautifully with the pale mauve flowers and bright orange stamens of Crocus tommasinianus . 
 Next is &bquo;Prins Claus&equo;, in purple and white. 
 By the time the beech hedge begins to grow and shade the border, the leaves will have refuelled their corms and died down. 
 There is nothing more annoying than unintentionally digging up groups of bulbs when they are dormant. 
 One way of avoiding this is to plant them, not in spaces towards the front of borders, but around the stems of trees and shrubs. 
 Hardy cyclamen and the winter aconite, Eranthis hyemalis , positively thrive in the dry soil ground around the base of mature trees. 
 For a striking display in March plant Scilla mischtschenkoana  (formerly Scilla tubergeniana )  around Japanese quince and camellia. 
 The pale blue flowers stand out like jewels against dark, bare soil. 
 Scilla siberica alba, Puschkinia scilloides  and Chionodoxa forbesii  &bquo;Pink Giant&equo; look similarly marvellous. 
 Creating border space 
 Where space is at a premium, bulbs which are given a prominent position can be lifted while still in leaf, labelled and planted elsewhere in the garden. 
 This releases the space they formerly occupied for bedding plants and other summer flowerers. 
 The smaller kinds of daffodils and tulips are ideally suited to the rock garden or dry bed. 
 Many of the exquisite, tiny species narcissi will thrive in the well-drained soil. 
 A top dressing of grit, though not essential, will show them off and avoid soil splashes on their delicate petals. 
 At only 3in high, Narcissus asturiensis  is a perfect miniature. 
 An alternative is N. bulbocodium , growing between 3 and 6in tall. 
 With its skirt-shaped cups and narrow petals, this narcissus is known as the hoop petticoat daffodil. 
 Small-scale options 
 Similar, yet perhaps even more beautiful, is delicate N. romieuzii , whose cups, the fresh colour of pale lemon sorbet, have undulating edges. 
 Sturdier looking and about 5in high, miniature daffodils &bquo;Little Beauty&equo; (white and yellow) and &bquo;Little Gem&equo; (yellow) are like scaled-down versions of their full-sized cousins. 
 Ideas for rock gardens or for more exposed borders, where taller daffodils are likely to be felled by the wind, the reliable range of cyclamineus  type daffodils varies from 8 to 10in high. 
 &bquo;Peeping Tom&equo; is well known for its cheerful yellow flowers. 
 &bquo;T&ecirc;te-&agrave;-T&ecirc;te&equo; and closely related &bquo;Jumblie&equo;, differing only in its backswept petals, are multi-headed varieties. 
 &bquo;Jack Snipe&equo; has white petals which contrast handsomely with their dark lemon-yellow cups, while for sheer daintiness &bquo;Hawera&equo; is hard to beat. 
 A Narcissus triandrus  about 8in high, it has a short creamy cup and backwards-slanting yellow petals. 
 Dwarf tulips are largely represented by the kaufmanniana  types. 
 Mostly 8 to 10in high, they are distinguished by brilliantly coloured flowers. 
 Greigii  tulips also tend to be short, in particular varieties like &bquo;Sweet Lady&equo;, peach pink, and the impressive &bquo;Queen Ingrid&equo;, producing rich red petals with a striking yellow edge. 
 In addition their mottled leaves significantly extend  the season of interest, so be quite sure to allow enough space for them to reach their full potential glory. 
 Out of the increasingly popular species tulips, my favourite is Tulipa tarda , originally from Central Asia. 
 Long-lasting flowers appear in spring, their green-tinged, white petals gradually shading th bright yellow towards the centre. 
 On dull days the flowers remain closed, revealing their full beauty only in the sunshine. 
 Yellow Iris danfordiae  and varieties of reticulated iris appreciate a well-drained soil. 
 They will reward care over choosing their position with a gorgeous display of early flower on plants rarely more than 4in high. 
 My firm favourite is the lovely I.  &bquo;Katharine Hodgkin&equo;, blessed with flowers the unusual pale blue/green of a clear sea. 
 The falls of the flowers are a delicate yellowish green veined with slate blue. 
 Plant with care 
 Bulbs of any kind look best when planted informally in groups. 
 While most, for example narcissi and scillas, should be planted as soon as they are bought, tulips should not go in to the garden until November. 
 Each kind of bulb has its own particular planting depth, which should be explained on the packaging or in the catalogue. 
 Carry out those instructions even if they sound extreme. 
 Topical tip 
 Planted into well-scrubbed clay pots topped with gravel, miniature spring bulbs make unusual Christmas presents which can be transferred to the recipient's garden after reflowering 
 Container and basket planting 
 Many gardeners plant up colourful tubs, window boxes and baskets for the summer, but few arrange for a similarly splendid winter and spring display. 
 A mixture of evergreen shrubs, dwarf conifers, winter-flowering heathers and ivies with bulbs, pansies and polyanthus will enrich any garden. 
 Dwarf bulbs are particularly suitable. 
 My winter hanging basket looks stunning when Narcissus  &bquo;T&ecirc;te-&agrave;-T&ecirc;te&equo; pops up among Ophiopogon planiscapus nigrescens  and Erica  &bquo;Springwood Pink&equo;. 
 Hyacinths and grape hyacinths make colourful window-box displays.  
 Delicate Crocus sieberi  &bquo;Bowles' White&equo; 
 Harbingers of spring, scillas are perfect plants for the rock garden 
 Scilla peruviana  forms large, conican racemes of flowers if shallowly planted in a hot, sunny spot 
 Pale mauve Crocus tommasinianus  partners crisp white snowdrops 
 Flowering in early to mid-spring, Narcissus cyclamineus , with its reflexed petals, makes a cheerful display 
 Tulipa praestans  &bquo;Fusilier&equo; bears several flowers on each stem 
 Cyclamen hederifolium  forms a bright spring carpet 
 The festively stiped blooms of Tulipa kaufmanniana  &bquo;Stresa&equo; 
 Springtime exuberance packed into a tub 
 The dwarf iris &bquo;Katharine Hodgkin&equo; is an excellent rockery plant 
 Grape hyacinths are natural subjects for creating drifts under trees 
 Houseplants 
 Living with houseplants 
 Colour co-ordinated plant arrangements and an easy way to propagate begonias are among the bright ideas suggested by Carol Kurrein this month 
 Six co-ordinating companions 
 Just as you might decide to colour co-ordinate your curtains and cushions, why not try arranging your houseplants into effective colour schemes? 
 Here are six plants which will give you a delightful blend of pink, purple and rich cream. 
 Purple passions 
 Setcreasea purpurea  (purple heart) is an easy-to-grow trailing tradescantia, with long, elegant deep purple leaves, shown to best effect in good light. 
 It is also known as Tradescantia pallida . 
 The New Guinea impatiens is a compact, bushy plant producing richly coloured foliage which provides a superb foil to its abundant pink to rosy-red busy Lizzie blooms. 
 This plant much prefers to be kept out of direct sunlight. 
 Cordyline terminalis  &bquo;Tricolor&equo;, a cabbage palm, has lance-shaped leaves impressively streaked with creamy white, pink and red. 
 It likes bright light. 
 Hypoestes sanguinolenta , the polka dot plant, has neat, tightly-packed foliage covered in pink speckles on a creamy ground. 
 The new improved varieties have virtually no green in the leaf colour at all. 
 Keep in good light to maintain colour. 
 Candy-striped creations 
 Cryptanthus  &bquo;Pink Starlight&equo;, a widely available bromeliad, has boldly arching dark green strap-like leaves, striped deep pink and yellowy-green. 
 Occasional tubular white flowers appear from the central rosette in summer. 
 It needs free-draining compost and a slightly shaded position. 
 Spathiphyllum wallisii , the peace lily, is a most elegant houseplant, with glossy green lance-shaped leaves and fragrant arum lily-like flowers of the purest white, turning to cream then to the palest green with age. 
 Seasonal tips 
 As the days get shorter and light levels start to fade, September is the time to begin the process of easing your houseplants into their winter rest period. 
 &bull; 
 Over the next six weeks or so, gradually reduce feeding to the recommended winter rate, and water less frequently, according to each plant's needs. 
 Remove any dust and grime so that your plants benefit from all the available light. 
 A spongedown with tepid water works well on smooth-leaved plants, or try one of the proprietary leaf shine wipes. 
 Furry-leaved houseplants can be cleaned with a soft brush. 
 &bull; 
 Some plants may need to be moved to more suitable winter quarters. 
 Those on windowsills could be too cold at night, for example, while plants which spend the summer in darker corners might prefer a bright spot near to the window. 
 Gently wipe down shiny-leaved plants such as philodendrons 
 The elegant, elongated purple leaves of Setcreasea purpurea  make a good display 
 New Guinea impatiens, a striking combination of burnished foliage and rosy blooms 
 The art of selective shopping 
 When you are out buying houseplants, it's always worth taking some time to shop around. 
 Although it can be very tempting to splash out on the first splendid specimen that catches your eye, you might be surprised at what you can find once you really start looking. 
 Dare to be different 
 Many garden centres offer a great deal more than the stock range of houseplants, I have seen unusual specimens like daturas laden with superbly scented flowers, anthuriums (aptly named the flamingo flower), streptocarpus, the new pot gerberas (huge flowers in fabulous colours) and the much improved New Guinea hybrid impatiens. 
 Some plants seem a little intimidating simply because they are unusual. 
 But, after all, experimentation is half of the fun. 
 Temperamental stars of the East 
 Those who relish the challenge of something different should seek out the striking Egyptian star ( Pentas lanceolata ) or its temperamental relative, flame of the woods ( Ixora coccinea ). 
 Both of these members of the Rubiaceae  family are finding their way into good houseplant departments. 
 The ones I've seen have had startling cluster heads of tiny pink-red flowers, star-shaped on pentas and tubular on ixoras, amid bold, leafy foliage. 
 The leaves of pentas are bright green and slightly hairy, while those of ixoras are dark, rich and glossy. 
 Egyptian star should be positioned in bright light, ideally with some direct sun, and kept at 55&deg;F minimum. 
 You should keep compost moist but allow the surface to dry out between waterings. 
 Allow the plant to rest with no food and little water for about six weeks after flowering has finished. 
 Key to good care 
 Provide good light for flame of the woods, but keep it out of direct sun at a temperature of 60&deg;-70&deg;F. 
 Keep compost evenly moist at all times and mist daily to maintain high humidity. 
 Take care not to move the plant when in flower, as the buds will drop. 
 Bringing up begonias 
 Propagating the popular trailing tuberous Begonia sutherlandi  is easy. 
 Simply wait until autumn, when small tubers will appear along the stem, tucked into the leaf axils. 
 Just pinch them off and plant in seed compost, which should be kept barely moist in a bright, warm place. 
 Come next spring, you should have lots of new young plants &mdash; and all for free! 
 Topical tip 
 Check any impatiens and begonias that you intend to over-winter indoors. 
 Trim them back, dead-head regularly and bring in before the first frosts and you should have flowers for months to come  
 Datura meteloides  &bquo;Zurich&equo; bears an abundance of fragrant blooms 
 Ixora coccinea  &bquo;Peter Rapsley&equo;, the so-called flame of the woods 
 Tips and Ideas 
 Readers' original gardening tips 
 Share your gardening tips with other readers and you could win the holiday of a lifetime 
 Everyone has their own favourite gardening wheeze, and if yours is original enough to print on this page we'll send you a &pound;50 cash prize. 
 What's more, at the end of the year we'll be choosing the best tip of all, and the gardening genius who dreamt it up will win a fantastic holiday for two &mdash; with spending money &mdash; in exotic Thailand. 
 Drain Brain 
 Offcuts of plastic drainpipe or pipes of larger diameters can be cut as shown to make plant pot hangers for the fence or trellis, or even to maximise space in the greenhouse or conservatory. 
 A hacksaw is all you need to cut the pipe. 
 Drill a small hole at the top to screw the potholder firmly into position. 
  Mr R Codling, Hartlepool  
 Make a net profit 
 To make these adjustable plant supports, all you need is a piece of semi-rigid green netting and a few canes. 
 It takes only a minute or two to wrap a band of netting supported by three or four canes around the plant, threading one cane through generously overlapping ends to keep the band in place. 
 As the plant grows the band can be slid up the canes or, as the plant grows wider, both canes and band removed and repositioned. 
  Derek Ogden, Cambridgeshire  
 Scary videos A worn-out tape makes an excellent bird scarer. 
 To protect the young, tender leaves of seedlings such as brassicas and lettuce, stretch the old tape between canes about 18in from the ground, where it will flutter in the breeze and glitter in the sunshine. 
 The tape can also be draped on the branches of apple trees, or among bush fruit such as raspberry canes. 
  H Cullett, Sunderland  
 Auto-Waterer 
 Take the guesswork out of watering growbags by raising the bags off the ground and providing a reservoir beneath them. 
 Make simple wooden frame to support the bag. 
 Push two wicks of capillary matting through slits in the bottom of the bag. 
 Put a bowl of water under the frame. 
 Place the growbag on the frame, feeding the wicks into the water. 
 The bottom of the bag and the surface of the water should be as close as possible. 
 Five the bag an initial soaking, keep the bowl topped up, and the bag will water itself. 
  A Gill, Mid-Glamorgan  
 Do-it-yourself trickle hose 
 When hose-pipe bans are on, an easy and efficient way to water rows of beans is to cut a length of hosepipe about 3ft longer than your row and make holes along its length, leaving the surplus length at one end hole-free. 
 Lead this up a stout stake at one end of the row, tying in position, and put a funnel in the open end. 
 Stop up the other end, and bury the hose-pipe alongside the beans. 
 Water poured in the funnel will go directly to the roots. 
  Mrs C Jenkins, Farnborough  
 Win a holiday to exotic Thailand 
 At the end of a year our judges will choose the best tip of all, and the winner will receive a holiday for two in Thailand, plus &pound;500 spending money. 
 All thanks to BBC Gardeners' World Magazine  and Guinness Original. 
 How to enter 
 Just jot down your tips and ideas, including drawings if appropriate, and send them to us. 
 Photos would also be useful. 
 Then open a chilled bottle of Guinness Original and pour it slowly into a glass. 
 Study the rich oatmeal head and the dark velvet body. 
 Then enjoy its distinctive bitter taste as you slowly drink it. 
 What better way to reward yourself for your original gardening idea. 
 Send your entries (being sure to include your name and address) to Readers' Original Gardening Tips, BBC Gardeners' World Magazine , 20&ndash;26 Brunswick Place, London N1 6DJ. 
 All entrants will receive a 50p voucher redeemable against any future purchase of Guinness Original, so everyone can enjoy the distinctive and satisfying taste of this special beer. 
 Competition rules 
 Entrants to the competition agree to abide by the rules which appeared in our March issue and are available on request, if you enclose a stamped addressed envelope.  
 Guinness Original Gardeners' World 
 BBC Scotland 
 The Beechgrove garden 
 Up in cooler Scottish climes it's time to start planning for winter and laying good foundations for next year's displays, says Sid Robertson 
 Our mountains can be very cold in late September. 
 Even in the first week of June, when potatoes were a foot high and oilseed rape was in glower, snow fell on high ground, and this makes a difference to what you can grow successfully. 
 Last September I visited a garden which was nearly a thousand feet up, and I could see that the gladioli, planted as dormant corms in early May, weren't going to flower. 
 What a contrast to the beautiful gladioli grown by Carole in pots. 
 We planted the corms on the programme on May 24. 
 Pot-growing and planting in good soil near sea level made all the difference. 
 Preparing for frost 
 Even on low ground, the risk of frost is certainly with us from September onwards, and preparations must be made to take in half-hardy plants. 
 At Beechgrove we have a well-established standard fuchsia, &bquo;Dollar Princess&equo;, with cerise sepals and a deep purple corolla, but Bill has done well in training a few new standards this summer and intends to give them early protection this year. 
 A gentleman from Peebles called our phone-in to ask for help with whitefly on his fuchsias, and Carole was able to offer some advice. 
 Not only must you spray regularly, but it's a good idea to vary the brand of spray that you use; the nasty wee beasties soon develop resistance if you use the same one over and over again, and that's something worth taking the time to avoid. 
 Burgeoning biennials 
 Seeds of biennials were sown on the programme in June, and many have made fine plants to fill borders, windowboxes and containers, which will grace our first programmes come next spring. 
 All biennials are best placed in their final quarters by the end of the month, and firm planting is extremely important. 
 Your plants will need time to become really well established to give them a better chance of surviving a harsh winter. 
 We've very great expectations of a brand new pansy, an F1 hybrid called &bquo;Imperial Gold Princess&equo; with enormous scarlet blotches over deep yellow petals. 
 It flowers early but continues on through the summer. 
 &bquo;Baby Franjo&equo; is smaller, at only 4in high. 
 It sports small yellow flowers en masse, sometimes showing as many as 30 at a time. 
 It should make a lovely display against &bquo;Black Beauty&equo;, another very distinctive pansy. 
 Double daisies are often overlooked, but we're planning for a really fresh new look from mixed &bquo;Bellis habenera&equo;. 
 Its flowers have needle-thin petals in differing degrees of white, rose, pink and carmine. 
 Wallflowers, particularly blood-red or the salmon-red of &bquo;Eastern Queen&equo;, are favourites in the north. 
 We always tell folk to watch out for clubroot, because the wallflower is actually a member of the cabbage family. 
 Thinking of Christmas 
 Although the programme finishes at the end of the month, head gardener Carole is still thinking ahead and planning for future displays. 
 This month we will be installing prepared hyacinths in bowls of bulb fibre. 
 They must go in right away if they are to bloom for Christmas. 
 In the mild south, gardeners can get away with plunging them in their containers buried in peat in the garden, but up here they'll need to be kept safe from hard frost in a cold frame. 
 They will remain there for up to ten weeks, before being brought into a warm greenhouse so we can force them into flower. 
 Bulb planting, outdoors can also start in September, and continue successfully into October. 
 Our lawns always need attention in autumn. 
 As well as scarifying to clear out thatch, we aerate to let air into the turf and release surface water. 
 We use a proprietary autumn fertiliser to encourage strong roots and stiffer growth, which is beneficial for the winter conditions ahead. 
 As final mowing draws near, be sure to raise the level of the blades to leave an inch of grass showing.  
 Blood-red wallflowers are a favourite of the Beechgrove team 
 If you have whitefly on your fuchsias or other flowers, vary the pesticides that you use 
 Using a hollow-tines aerator will revive and condition your lawn 
 Standard fuchsia &bquo;Dollar Princess&equo; is well established at Beechgrove&equo; 
 Practical Project 
 Planting by numbers 
 Creating a border to see out the summer 
 By following our guidelines and shopping list, you can create a border like this one, ending the season with a cracking display of firework colours 
 This month's plan is for a wide, rectangular border which receives lots of sunshine every day. 
 Although it is mostly made up of perennial plants which will come up fresh in spring, there are one or two evergreen shrubs added for structure: an upright rosemary and a couple of spiky yuccas. 
 The border will provide plenty of interest and colour from midsummer onwards, particularly at summer's end, when many other plants have long since finished flowering. 
 Some of the key plants are described in more detail below. 
 If you have trouble in finding exactly the same varieties, you local nursery should be able to suggest some good alternatives. 
 The suggested list will fill an area roughly 15ft x 5ft. 
 Increase or reduce numbers of plants for larger or smaller areas. 
 Nemerocallis &bquo;Stafford&equo; 
 Striking, dark red flowers with yellow throat, mid to late summer. 
 Height 2ft 6in; spread 2ft. 
 Sedum &bquo;Autumn Joy&equo; 
 Attractive flat heads of flowers, pink at first, turning dark wine red as the season progresses. 
 Height and spread: 2ft. 
 Dahlia &bquo;Shandy&equo; 
 Spiky blooms of apricot-salmon. 
 Height: 3ft 6in. 
 Alternatives to try: &bquo;Shirley Alliance&equo; or &bquo;Majestic Kerkade&equo;. 
 Phlox paniculata 
 Choose mauve cultivars like &bquo;Excelsior&equo;, &bquo;Franz Schubert&equo; or &bquo;Prospero&equo;. 
 Height: 3ft. 
 Penstemon &bquo;Garnet&equo; 
 Tubular flowers of deep crimson/wine from midsummer to autumn. 
 Height 2ft 6in; spread 2ft. 
 Helenium &bquo;Moerheim Beauty&equo; 
 Deep, rusty-orange flowers with attractively reflexed petals. 
 An excellent autumn border plant. 
 Height 3ft; spread 2ft. 
 Aster amellus &bquo;Nocturne&equo; 
 Reliable, lavender-flowered Michaelmas daisy for the front. 
 Height and spread: 20in. 
 &bquo;Brilliant&equo; and &bquo;Pink Zenith&equo; are good pinks. 
 Planting and care 
 1 
 Prepare the new border by clearing away all weeds, and digging in plenty of well-rotted manure, leaf-mould or compost. 
 2 
 Set out the plants in informal drifts as shown. 
 Add spring bulbs for early colour. 
 3 
 Many of the plants can be put in at any time of year, except for the dahlias. 
 These should go in after frosts have finished in late spring/early summer, and will need to be lifted and stored before winter. 
 4 
 Treat pests if necessary, particularly if mildew attacks asters. 
 Look out too for earwigs, which love dahlias. 
 &bquo;Prospero&equo; is a handsome for of Phlox paniculata  with mauve-washed flowers 
 Spiky dahlias lend their vibrant colours to the scheme 
 The end-of-summer border blends a warm mixture of sunset colours 
 Planting plan and shopping list 
 1 
 3 x Hemerocallis &bquo;Stafford&equo; 
 2 
 2x Foeniculum vulgare &bquo;Purpureum&equo; (fennel) 
 3 
 2 x Sedum &bquo;Autumn Joy&equo; 
 4 
 3 x Rudbeckia &bquo;Goldsturm&equo; 
 5 
 2 x Dahlis &bquo;Shandy&equo; 
 6 
 1 x Dahlia &bquo;Apache&equo; 
 7 
 3 x Penstemon &bquo;Garnet&equo; 
 8 
 2 x Phlox paniculate &bquo;Prospero&equo; 
 9 
 1 x Yucca flaccida 
 10 
 3 x Helenium &bquo;Moerheim Beauty&equo; 
 11 
 2 x Dahlia &bquo;Judith&equo; 
 12 
 1 x Rosemary &bquo;Miss Jessup&equo; 
 13 
 2 x Dahlia &bquo;Shandy&equo; 
 14 
 2 x Phlox paniculata &bquo;Prospero&equo; 
 15 
 1 x Yucca flacida 
 16 
 3 x Penstemon &bquo;Firebird&equo; 
 17 
 3 x Helenium &bquo;Moerheim Beauty&equo; 
 18 
 2 x Sedum &bquo;Autumn Joy&equo; 
 19 
 3 x Aster amellus &bquo;Nocturne&equo; 
 20 
 3 x Penstemon &bquo;Garnet&equo; 
 21 
 2 x Aster amellus &bquo;Brilliant&equo; 
 Helenium  &bquo;Moerheim Beauty&equo;: warm russet tints for summer's end 
 Gardening in tomorrow's world 
 A glimpse of the future from Dr Phil Gates, lecturer in botany at Durham University 
 Confusing climates 
 The trend towards milder winters is beginning to concern horticulturists. many trees need lengthy cold spells if they are to open their buds at the right time in spring, and research on the Continent confirms that apple trees will be confused by the changing climate. 
 In mild winters apples buds began to break soon after Christmas, leaving them vulnerable to frost damage. 
 Although bud break is early, leaf development is delayed and very variable. 
 If current cultivars do not adapt, breeders may need to look for new varieties which cope better with milder winters. 
 Lilies like it hot 
 If your amaryllis has produced seed pods, you may fancy raising seedlings. 
 The experience of researchers in Florida should help. 
 The key to their success was to cover the seeds with a fine layer of compost and germinate at a constant 77&deg;F (25&deg;C). 
 As fluctuating temperatures reduced germination, a thermostatically-controlled propagator would be ideal. 
 Friendly fungus 
 Trichoderma is a microscopic fungus with a miraculous effect on plant growth. 
 Professor Jim Lynch at Horticultural Research International has found that lettuce yields can double when pots are inoculated with trichoderma, while petunias and marigolds develop extra-large early flowers. 
 Professor Lynch is uncertain how the fungal growth enhancer works; a likely possibility is that it helps combat natural toxins that develop in seed and potting composts. 
 Perfect peaches 
 Anyone who has ever tried to grow peaches outdoors will be familiar with &bquo;Taphrina deformans&equo;, the fungus which causes peach leaf curl disease. 
 Spores overwinter in buds and on twigs then, especially in cold, damp springs, they infect leaves. 
 These become wrinkled and red, dropping prematurely. 
 Until now the only sure solution has been to grow peaches under glass, but help may be at hand. 
 Indian scientists have identified varieties with a modified leaf structure which confers some resistance to taphrina. 
 Hoe, hoe, hoe! 
 Regular weeding is a tiresome but essential job. 
 Evidence is mounting that weeds do more than just compete with crops for light and nutrients. 
 Several produce subtle chemical secretions which actually interfere with crop growth. 
 Polish scientists have discovered that compounds in the roots and foliage of creeping thistle can prevent seed germination and inhibit root growth in other plants. 
 Heard on the grapevine 
 &bull; 
 Raising decorative and useful herbs in pots is becoming popular, and Danish horticulturists have been busy selecting non-flowering varieties of sage with ornamental foliage for container growing. 
 They report that rooted cuttings, pinched out twice during growth, make very attractive and of course functional houseplants. 
 &bull; 
 Dutch growers have successfully experimented with growing winter crops of cauliflowers in buckets under glass. 
 By planting two seedlings of the variety &bquo;Dok Elgon&equo; per 5-litre bucket of peat in August, they have harvested good-quality curds in time for Christmas. 
 &bull; 
 Research at the University of New Hampshire in the United States shows that the single most effective method of controlling apple scab is to collect and burn all fallen leaves from infected trees in autumn. 
 It's a tedious job, but well worth the effort for blemish-free fruits. 
 &bull; 
 Growers in Holland have added two more popular plants to the list of species which can cause allergies in gardeners. 
 They report cases of contact dermatitis after handling hydrangeas and alstroemerias. 
 The problem seems to affect people sensitive to primulas. 
 Concerted effort in autumn can reduce the risk of apple scab 
 Help at Hand 
 Question Time 
 Puzzling pines and poorly potatoes are just a couple of the problems to be solved by our team of BBC experts this month 
 Colborn induces violet longings 
  Please can you tell me where I may purchase some dog's tooth violets. 
 I have been following with interest the Gardeners' World programmes where Nigel Colborn had been designing a new garden, especially when he had been using plants for the shady corner. 
 He mentions dog's tooth violets and despite an intensive search, I have been unable to find any. 
  Erythroniums are commonly known as dog's tooth violets because their bulbs are curiously shaped and pointed, rather like canine teeth. 
 Erythronium dens-canis , the common dog's tooth violet, has attractively blotched and marbled leaves. 
 Its flowers come in several forms varying in colour from white to deep pinky-purple. 
 Some other erythronium hybrids include &bquo;Pagoda&equo; and &bquo;Kondo&equo; (yellow) and &bquo;White Beauty&equo;. 
 You can buy them mail order from Van Tubergen UK Ltd, Bressingham, Diss, Norfolk IP22 3AA. 
 Tel: 0379&ndash;888282. 
 Helping hand for a budding plantsman 
  Could you suggest some helpful books for a keen amateur gardener who would like to know more about plants? 
  These books are extremely useful: Encyclopaedia of Garden Plants and Flowers  (Reader's Digest &pound;24.95), RHS Gardeners' Encyclopaedia of Plants and Flowers  (Dorling Kindersley &pound;27.50), Perennial Garden Plants  by Graham Stuart Thomas (Dent &pound;19). 
 Ace of spades for back back sufferers 
  Ages ago I saw on television someone using a special space with a lever action behind it, to help people with bad backs to be able to dig the garden. 
 Do you know what it is, and where I can get one? 
  We suspect you had seen the Terrex Autospade, which is made by Wolf Tools. 
 It is quite a hefty spade, with bicycle-type handlebars and a sprung lever at the rear, which you step on to activate it. 
 Used correctly, you shouldn't have to bend your back during general digging, although it won't lift out the soil and put in a barrow if you need to move it! 
 If gardening tends to give you backache, remember to take plenty of rest periods during the day, and never try to lift more than you can easily cope with. 
 The raised bed, no-dig method of growing vegetables is also better for back sufferers. 
 The Terrex Autospade is available from Wolf Tools, Ross-on-Wye, Herefordshire. 
 Tel: 0989&ndash;767600. 
 Looking after the tender abutilon 
  I have been given a beautiful abutilon plant, and I wonder if you could advise me on how to look after it. 
 At the moment it is in my garden, but I don't think it is hardy enough to stay there. 
  Many abutilons are ideal for growing in the greenhouse or conservatory, being frost-tender. 
 They are also frequently put outside during summer as bedding, particularly the ones with variegated foliage. 
 Water and feed your plant regularly over the summer and check regularly for aphid pests. 
 In warm and sheltered gardens Abutilon megaponticum  and A. vitifolium  can remain outside. 
 Readers' questions 
 We are unable to provide a personal query answering service to readers by post. 
 However, a selection of your questions will be answered on these pages each month. 
 Tune in to your BBC local radio gardening experts for advice. 
 Details are in our Television and Radio Guide, starting on p95, including their phone-in numbers.  
 Abutilons make exotic subjects ideal for conservatory planting 
 A drift of the exquisite yellow dog's tooth violet, Erythronium  &bquo;Pagoda&equo; 
 The Wolf Terrex Autospade has been designed to make digging a little easier 
 Dovecote discovery for would-be buyer 
  In your July issue there was a white bird house in the David Stevens feature &bquo;Making Wood Work&equo;. 
 Having looked unsuccessfully for such a bird house, I would like to find the name of a stockist. 
  We haven't been able to locate anyone who makes exactly that bird house (it may even have been especially made). 
 However, we know of two firms who make similar dovecotes together with other garden ornaments: Roseney Farm Designs, Lanlivery, Bodmin, Cornwall (Tel: 0208 872664) and Forsham Dovecotes, Goreside Farm, Great Chart, Ashford, Kent (Tel: 0233&ndash;820 229). 
 I can't do a thing with my carrots 
  I have a Caryopteris x clandonensis  about six years old. 
 It has a mass of flowers in August but has got very straggly. 
 I have not been able to find any reference to pruning it, although I have cut out any dead wood found in the spring. 
 Please can you advise me? 
  You have been doing the right thing by cutting out the dead wood you found in spring, but these plants do get very straggly, and to get the best out of it you will need to be a bit more ruthless. 
 The plant flowers in late summer and early autumn on wood produced earlier in the same year. 
 By cutting the stems back hard, you will encourage it to produce new shoots from low down. 
 These will be much stronger and have better flowers than the numerous spindly bits at the ends would produce, if left unpruned. 
 Prune all the stems back to within about 4in of the ground in mid to late March when the sap is rising. 
 By leaving pruning until after the winter you allow the plant some extra frost protection. 
 A conifer for your conservatory 
  While on holiday in Portugal I saw a conifer that looked so magnificent I just had to photograph it. 
 The trouble is that I can't identify it and can't find it in my gardening books or in any of the books at my local library. 
 I would be so grateful if you could tell me the name of it, because it looks so unusual. 
  Your picture shows a splendid specimen of the Norfolk Island pine, Araucaria heterophylla . 
 It is often planted as an ornamental tree in warmer climates such as the Mediterranean, where it is valued for being very tolerant of salt-laden winds. 
 Over here you will sometimes see juvenile trees grown in conservatories. 
 Lazy daisies love to bask in the sun 
  I wonder if you could give me any information on osteospermums. 
 I was given a cutting a few years ago by my sister and have subsequently passed on cuttings but have never known the proper name of it or much about it. 
  Osteospermums, also known as Cape marigolds or African daisies, come from South Africa, as the popular names indicate. 
 They belong to the huge daisy family ( Compositae ), and are sometimes still listed under the dreadfully tongue-twisting name of Dimorphotheca . 
 Although they are generally regarded as being tender, many gardeners in cold northern areas have reported these plants to have survived several recent winters without harm. 
 However, to be on the safe side, it is better to take cuttings in August to overwinter under glass. 
 Put out new plants in May or June in a warm, sunny position in well-drained soil. 
 They also make excellent container plants for summer. 
 The flowers only open during bright weather. 
 Good varieties include &bquo;Buttermilk&equo; (pale yellow), &bquo;Tresco Purple&equo; (mauve) and &bquo;Silver Sparkler&equo; (white). 
 A thorny problem for our team to solve 
  On p57 of the June issue the picture on the right has some tall pink and white flowers at the back of the picture. 
 What are they called? 
 I saw a whole border of them in Germany, but they were the only plants without a name tag! 
 They have quite sharp thorns on the back of the leaves. 
  The plants you spotted are Cleome spinosa , the spider flower, and you're quite right, there are thorns under the leaves, as its name implies. 
 It is a half-hardy annual, and is available from most seed companies. 
 Sow the seeds in a propagator at 64&deg;F (19&deg;C) in Feb/March, and set out young plants in the garden in late May, or after the last likely frosts in your area.  
 An attractive dovecote can make an excellent focal point 
 Sun-lovers from South Africa, osteospermums are gaining in popularity 
 The Norfolk Island pine is a familiar sight on Mediterranean holidays 
 The spidery blooms of Cleome spinosa  are unusual and attractive 
 Making the most of roses 
  I have a lovely plant of Rosa glauca  which is often admired by my friends. 
 Can I grow some more plants from cuttings? 
  Take cuttings of this and other shrub roses in September. 
 Choose ripe shoots from this year's growth of roughly a pencil's thickness. 
 Cutting should be about 9in long, cut just below a leaf joint at the bottom, and just above a leaf joint at the top. 
 Remove the lower leaves and thorns and place about 6in deep and 6in apart in a trench, poking them into a layer of sharp sand. 
 Refill with soil and firm it down. 
 Water well and keep watered in summer. 
 They should root well by the following November. 
 Charmed by a snake-bark 
  Could you tell me the name of the maple that has interesting white-striped branches and trunk, and where I might be able to purchase one? 
  There are several trees known as the snake-bark maples that have this effect. 
 One of the best is Acer pensylvanicum , which has beautifully striped stems in white and pale grey-green. 
 Others include Acer davidii, A. capillipes  and A. grosseri . 
 You should be able to obtain snake-barks from Hillier nurseries (Winchester) Ltd, Ampfield House, Ampfield, Nr Romsey, Hants SO51 9PA. 
 Tel: 0794&ndash;68733. 
 On the trail of nepeta advice 
  Can you help me with my trailing variegated nepeta? 
 Despite reference to seed catalogues and gardening books, I have been unable to find any information on its propagation, either from seed or from cuttings. 
  Trailing variegated nepetas are often sold with the bedding plants during summer at garden centres as they make admirable subjects for hanging baskets and window boxes. 
 You should be able to find it in gardening books listed as Glechoma hederacea  &bquo;Variegate&equo;, or Nepeta hederacea  &bquo;Variegata&equo;. 
 It is a hardy herbaceous perennial, although you will often see it sold with greenhouse plants. 
 To propagate it, lift and divide up the plants in spring and repot them. 
 Alternatively, peg down the trailing stems in the soil, and they will form roots, then individual new plants you can detach from the parent. 
 They're making mischief in my mulch 
  I use forest bark and cocoa shell mulch on two flower beds to help control weeds. 
 However, both are constantly being disturbed by blackbirds. 
 How can I deter the birds from molesting my mulches? 
 I have tried a product called &bquo;Hoppit&equo; but to no effect. 
  Organic mulches increase worm and insect activity, so it's not surprising and, we fear, inevitable that blackbirds and others sometimes plunder these mulches in search of food. 
 Console yourself with the knowledge that the birds are also picking out many a garden pest. 
 Caterpillars breakfast on eggplants 
  I haven't been very successful with my aubergines the last couple of years, as they keep being eaten by caterpillars. 
 Is there any way of dealing with them without using chemicals? 
  Vigilant and regular inspection of your plants is the best way of avoiding such pests. 
 As soon as you spot caterpillars, their eggs or signs of caterpillar damage such as ragged holes in leaves and the tell-tale small faeces, search them out and squash them. 
 If you have a lot of plants and don't want to use any of the usual chemicals, try a biological insecticide. 
 Bacillus thuringiensis  is sold as DiPel and comes as powder which you dilute to spray. 
 It is effective against all caterpillars, including those of harmless butterflies, so don't spray indiscriminately outside. 
 You can buy packets of it by mail order from HDRA Sales Ltd Tel: 0203&ndash;303517  
 Treat caterpillars before they treat themselves to your fruit and vegetables 
 Rosa glauca  has handsome foliage, pretty single flowers and good red hips 
 Striped like a python, the snakebark maple Acer pensylvanicum  
 Occasionally birds disturb mulches while looking for food 
 Spot the mineral deficiency 
  The older leaves on my potato plants are distinctly yellowing, with brown spots and marking too. 
 Do you know what this could be? 
  It looks like magnesium deficiency, which is very common on sandy and light soils, where the nutrient is quickly leached away. 
 This happens most readily when the season has been particularly rainy. 
 This deficiency shouldn't affect the yield and tends to look more serious than it actually is. 
 When liming the soil choose magnesian limestone to correct the problem. 
 This will take care of any probable calcium deficiency too. 
 Traditional edging can be elusive 
  On p9 in your July edition one of the photographs shows a brown glazed edging to a path. 
 I have often seen this in gardens of older house. 
 Is it possible still to buy this kind of edging, and if so, can you please supply details of the manufacturer or stocklist? 
  Those old, glazed rope-twist tiles seem to be hard to find nowadays, and the ones in the picture will have been in the garden for many years. 
 Try your local architectural salvage merchants, who collect artefacts from old house and gardens. 
 Many garden centres also now sell unglazed terracotta versions of rope-twist tiles, and your local centre should be able to order some for you. 
 Be harsh with your mallow 
  Our Lavatera  &bquo;Barnsley&equo;, now in its second year, is about 5ft tall and ready to flower. 
 How should I prune it and take cuttings? 
  This lavatera (shrubby mallow) flowers on wood made in the same season, so cut last year's branches hard back in spring. 
 Take semi-hardwood cuttings in late summer, choosing material that is woody at the base, but soft at the tips. 
 Dip the base in hormone rooting powder and insert in very free-draining rooting compost, or equal parts peat and sand, four or five cuttings round the edge of a 5in pot. 
 Overwinter in a cool greenhouse, keeping the compost slightly moist to help roots form. 
 Flaming Katy need a drenching 
  I have suddenly noticed that my kalanchoe is badly attacked by greenfly. 
 What should I use to get rid of them? 
  If your kalanchoe is in the house, the most economical and easy way to deal with them is by using a proprietary spray, such as Fisons Insect Spray for Houseplants. 
 If aphids are a big problem outside too, buy some ICI Rapid to get rid of the lot. 
 Pink hydrangea is giving me the blues 
  Last year I was given a beautiful blue pot hydrangea which I planted in the garden when it finished flowering. 
 This year its flowers are different, being a mauvey-pink instead. 
 What went wrong? 
  You can buy forced hydrangeas from florists and garden centres almost any time of year these days, and sometimes in the most tempting, vibrant blues. 
 Although they will grow on successfully when put out into the garden in spring or summer, the flowers you get in future years may well turn pink if you are not on an acid soil. 
 Garden centres stock sachets of blueing powder for hydrangeas, but the most reliable way is to continue growing them in pots.   
 Potatoes growing on light soils often show magnesium deficiency 
 Glazed rope-twist tiles make a traditional edging 
 Lavatera  &bquo;Barnsley&equo; needs regular pruning to maintain its shape 
 Colonies of aphids can build up quickly on plants such as kalanchoe 
 Blue in the pot, the florist's hydrangea may change its colours 
 Following material from an insert 
 Gardeners' Manual 
 Guide to hedges 
 Hedges are valuable features whether your garden is exposed to wind or view. 
 We show you how to create a hedge that will be both effective and attractive. 
 Hedge selection 
 More than 30 prospective hedges to choose from in our comprehensive and detailed selector table. 
 Pest prevention and control 
 Prevention is better than chemical cures; natural pest control relies on recognising and understanding not only your enemies but the gardeners friends in the animal kingdom. 
 Using colour 
 Skilful use of colour compositions is the key to creating spectacular and subtle displays all year round. 
 Harvesting and storing 
 Our simple tips on handling and storage at harvest time, the most satisfying season for the kitchen gardener. 
 Plants for shade 
 Lots of clever ideas to banish gloom and turn that difficult shady spot into an elegant and eye-catching planting feature. 
 All you need to know about hedges, p98 
 Get to know your pests with our complete guide, p102 
 Harvesting and storing made easy on p108 
 Choosing colourful combinations, p106 
 Guide to hedges 
 Hedges create living walls for shelter and privacy in the garden 
 As a means of enclosing your garden and defining its boundaries, a hedge is a durable, less expensive and often more aesthetically satisfying alternative to fencing. 
 It will, however, occupy more space and, depending on the species, may take several years to establish. 
 It will also need clipping or pruning to shape at least once a year, especially in the case of formal hedges. 
 Within the garden, hedges are valuable for marking off special areas, providing shelter for delicate plants and hiding utility areas or eyesores. 
 Dwarf hedges are a traditional means of edging beds, especially in herb and kitchen gardens. 
 As a design element, hedges can lead or intervene as well as define, diverting attention from an obvious path or keeping secret areas from immediate view. 
 Hedges can also provide effective weather protection. 
 Exposure to winds is a problem in many gardens, resulting in scorched and damaged young foliage, collapsed stems, uneven growth and rapid drying of soil and leaves. 
 Strategically sited wind-breaks reduce the impact of strong winds and provide more vulnerable plants with essential shelter for a distance many times the height of the wind-break. 
 The main wind-break should protect the side of the garden most exposed to prevailing winds, with individual or grouped shrubs positioned to limit the impact of other seasonal winds and create sheltered corners for delicate plants. 
 Planning a hedge 
 The type of hedging plant you choose depends partly on the amount of annual maintenance you are prepared to undertake. 
 If left to reach their natural dimensions, many species will eventually take over a wide area of ground and should be avoided in small gardens. 
 Fortunately, most popular hedging plants tolerate frequent close clipping to control them, and a hedge made from species such as beech, hornbeam or box can be as little as 15in wide. 
 Identify the main functions of a hedge before deciding its composition. 
 Thorny plants such as hawthorn and pyracantha will develop into impenetrable barriers where security is important, while the dense foliage of yew and Lawson's cypress suppresses noise. 
 Evergreen species of all kinds are ideal for wind-breaks. 
 Choose plants that should reach the desired height without becoming bare or ragged at the base (this can be a problem with berberis). 
 Make sure hedging plants blend with the rest of the garden. 
 A deciduous or sombre evergreen hedge in a prominent position may look bleak in winter, although in summer they often enhance the brilliance of adjacent flowers. 
 Also consider the cost, since hedges comprise large numbers of plants. 
 As a rule of thumb, tall, vigorous species are spaced 18&ndash;24in apart, those of medium height (2&ndash;4ft) about 15&ndash;18in, and dwarf typed 9&ndash;15in apart. 
 Single lines of plants are preferable to double staggered rows for ease of weeding and hoeing. 
 Garden centres are not the best places to buy hedging plants in large numbers: specimens are usually larger than is ideal (large plants take longer to establish) and more expensive than small plants bought by the dozen or hundred from specialist nurseries. 
 Preparation and planting 
 The least expensive method is to root your own cuttings from one or two stock plants, inserting groups of three cuttings at each planting position through a black polythene mulch. 
 Aucuba, berberis, griselinia, privet, laurel, rugosa roses and many ornamentals will root and develop quickly. 
 Before planting, you should cultivate the site thoroughly. 
 Prepare a strip 3&ndash;4ft wide, extending a little beyond the ends of the hedge. 
 Dig to two spade-lengths if possible, adding at least a bucketful of  organic matter per square yard. 
 Clear out all perennial weeds. 
 Plant in the same way as for trees and shrubs, mulching the prepared ground with black plastic or strips of old carpet. 
 Stake large specimens and protect the young plants from cold winds until growing steadily. 
 Clipping and pruning 
 Hedging plants are usually cut back to half their height after planting to encourage bushiness, but some conifers are best left unpruned until they reach the desired height. 
 Water freely in dry weather during the first two seasons, and feed plants each year with a general fertiliser (2oz/sq yd), starting immediately after their first clipping. 
 This should be done annually to ensure dense sides, removing up to half the season's new growth at a time. 
 Once established, hedges need routine clipping according to species and the level of precision required. 
 Flowering, fruiting and informal hedges can be clipped once annually, but for crisp outlines more frequent trimming is needed. 
 Use a string as a guide to accurate shaping at the beginning of the season, thereafter working by eye. 
 Where possible, shape the hedge so that is narrower at the top, admitting light to growth near the base. 
 Clear away and burn all trimmings, and keep tools sharp and free from sap. 
 Many neglected hedge species respond to hard pruning at the right time of year, and will quickly produce a thicket of new growth. 
 Conifers other than yew usually resent harsh treatment, however, and are difficult to rejuvenate, Deciduous species are best pruned hard back in late winter, evergreens in late spring &mdash; cutting one side a year back to a foot within the intended final width to allow room for regrowth. 
 Always feed generously after hard pruning. 
 Bare patches at the hedge base are the result of excessive height, uncontrolled weed growth or a hedge profile which obstructs light from filtering down. 
 Reducing the height might help, but otherwise it's best to simple disguise the damage by planting decorative shrubs beside the hedge. 
 Dead wood should be cut out, allowing adjacent healthy growth to fill the gap. 
 Hedge companions 
 A hedge will compete with nearby plants for water and nutrients, and the roots of some species can be very invasive. 
 Cutting along the side of the hedge with a spade helps check lateral roots, but it's wiser to grow adjacent plants that tolerate poor, dry soil or shade. 
 This will suit most bulbs, and annual or late-flowering perennial climbers that use the hedge for support. 
 But check whether companion plants prefer the sunny or shady side.  
 A hydrangea hedge, pretty and practical 
 An eye-catching mix of Berberis x stenophylla  and Mahonia japonica  
 Pruning a beech hedge the easy way 
 Trimming with secateurs avoids chopping up attractive leaves 
 Privet and yew combine in an effective two-tone design 
 Hedge selection 
 A hedge can be a dense, glossy barrier, an informal background to herbaceous plants or, with flowers and bright fruits, a colourful feature in its own right. 
 There's something for all tastes in our table 
 Name Artemisia abrotanum Common name Southernwood In leaf: deciduous Ideal height 3ft Clip in March Features Aromatic grey bushy foliage; yellow flowers 
 Name Aucuba japonica &bquo;Variegata&equo; Common name Spotted laurel In leaf evergreen Ideal height 6&ndash;10ft Clip in April Features Dense and glossy; gold-speckled leaves 
 Name Berberis x stenophylla &bquo;Irwinii&equo; Common name Barberry In leaf evergreen Ideal height 2ft Clip in June Features Spiny, arching stems; orange spring flowers 
 &bquo;Castlewellan Gold&equo;, a Leyland cypress type 
 Dwarf box makes traditional edging 
 Flowering quince will add colour 
 Griswlinia will tolerate salt-laden winds 
 Yew foliage and fruits are attractive, but poisonous 
 Gold speckling on variegated aucuba 
 Crataegus , or hawthorn, makes a dense hedge which lends itself well to severe formal trimming 
 Beech gives a spectacular display of changing colours in autumn 
 Glossy laurel is fully hardy and evergreen 
 Pest control 
 Healthy plants and a vigilant conscientious gardener are the two most valuable weapons against pests 
 Like every other organism in a thriving garden, pests have a role to play. 
 They provide food for predators whose presence reduces the likelihood of any one pest developing into epidemic proportions, and they eliminate weak and sickly plants. 
 Destroying one pest leaves a vacuum that will be filled by something else. 
 Although major types of plant pest are surprisingly few, it is easy to become over-sensitive, not to say paranoid, and assume that everything that moves is a potential threat. 
 Friends and foes 
 A garden is a balanced community of plants, creatures and micro-organisms, many of them beneficial. 
 Realistic gardeners encourage this diversity while remaining alert to early symptoms of disturbance. 
 The most practical approach is to accept a permanent low incidence of various plant pests, and prevent serious problems from arising by growing healthy plants that tolerate normal pest populations. 
 Any sudden increase in the number of a particular pest, however, need immediate action. 
 The first priority is to consult a good reference book to identify the pest and choose the most effective control. 
 It is important to distinguish between allies and enemies: large numbers of aphids, for example, are often accompanied by ladybird or lacewing larvae which feed voraciously on them and are liable to be killed by many insecticides. 
 Nuisance or threat? 
 Decide whether the pest is a serious threat or merely a nuisance. 
 Some, such as froghoppers (&bquo;cuckoo spit&equo;) and flea beetles, cause little more than cosmetic damage and will be tolerated by healthy plants. 
 On the other hand, aphids can infect raspberries with incurable virus diseases, and blackcurrant reversion is spread by big-bud mites. 
 As well as selecting a suitable  remedy where appropriate, you should also try to discover the cause of the problem, because this could help prevent future repetitions. 
 Unseasonal weather can encourage a dramatic rise in pest numbers before their natural predators have multiplied in response, but very often an outbreak is the result of poor management, leaving plants susceptible to attack. 
 Plants under stress from drought, disease or nutrient deficiency are the most likely to attract insect pests. 
 Good soil husbandry can help prevent many of the conditions favourable to pests by ensuring steady growth, hence the importance of improving poor drainage and fertility. 
 Too much manure or fertiliser, however, can result in soft lush growth which is equally vulnerable, and you should aim for balance between the various essential nutrients. 
 Test the soil with a pH kit to see if its acidity needs adjusting. 
 Weather watch 
 Guard against the harmful effects of extreme weather by watering plants before drought becomes critical, and making sure excessive rainfall can drain away freely. 
 Site is as important as soil, for plants that prefer full sun, shade or shelter may not thrive if planted in the wrong place, and are then more likely to succumb. 
 A regular walk around the garden to make sure everything is growing healthily is the simplest precaution of all, often revealing preliminary signs of trouble. 
 In addition to maintaining positive plant health, there are several ways to avoid the probability of serious pest attacks, or at least lessen their impact, which in turn will cut down on the need to apply pesticides. 
 Although no single measure is usually sufficient on its own, a combination of deterrents can be remarkably effective. 
 A fundamental precaution against both pest and disease problems is keeping the garden clean and tidy. 
 Whether you grow vegetables, summer bedding or an informal patch of wildflowers, you should compost  or destroy dead leaves, exhausted plants, vegetable stumps and thinnings, for all these are favourite haunts of many harmful insects. 
 Make life difficult 
 Frequent cultivation disturbs and exposes soil pests for birds to clear up. 
 Some pests live temporarily on alternative host plants &mdash; carrot fly on cow parsley and certain aphid species on chickweed, for example &mdash; and controlling these interrupts the pest's life cycle. 
 Growing pest-resistant varieties of fruit and vegetables is a sensible precaution. 
 This promising approach to pest control is in its infancy, but varieties that are less attractive to certain pests are constantly being developed and tested. 
 Work out a sound crop rotation for vegetables to deny pests a continuous supply of particular host plants. 
 Avoid monoculture: growing large areas of the same crop which then becomes an easy target. 
 Inter-cropping and dispersal among other unrelated plants can also reduce the effects of an attack. 
 In cases where vegetables can be sheltered from a common pest by physical barriers, it's worth gathering sowings together in one easily protected site. 
 Brassicas, for example, can then be netted against pigeons, or carrots surrounded by a low fence of plastic sheeting to repel root fly. 
 Provide solitary plants with individual defences, such as snail-proof rings of soot or grit, or brassica collars to foil cabbage root fly. 
 Floating mulches of spun fibre both encourage early crops and shield them from pests. 
 Most insects have fairly predictable behaviour and you can often adjust sowing dates to avoid peak periods of egg-laying or migration, and deny colonising pests a favoured habitat by, for example, pinching out the soft tips of broad beans or applying a protective insecticide. 
 Some pests can be trapped, then collected and destroyed. 
 Slugs will shelter under inverted halves of grapefruit peel, inverted pots of straw on canes will lure earwigs and hanging sticky yellow cards in a greenhouse will catch flying pests. 
 Many fruit pests can be trapped in winter and spring on grease bands. 
 Encourage your allies 
 Learn to recognise and welcome your allies. 
 Plant pests are herbivores, eating foliage or sucking the sap, while predators are carnivorous and live by feeding on plants pests, directly or by laying their eggs among colonies so that their larvae have a ready supply of food. 
 The commonest predators are ladybirds, hoverflies, lacewings, ground beetles, centipedes and insectivorous birds, together with frogs, toads and hedgehogs. 
 Attract birds to the garden by feeding them when their natural sources of food are scarce; grow plants favoured by insect predators (like limnanthes, cornflowers, eschscholzia, asters,  chrysanthemums, robinia, philadelphus and spiraea), and respect the habitats of retiring predators such as beetles, frogs and bats. 
 Treatment 
 A major infestation is almost certain to occur at some time or other, and you must then decide how to control or eradicate it. 
 Some pests are large enough to be gathered and destroyed by hand: caterpillars can be picked off at any time, while slugs and snails around vulnerable plants are easily collected by torchlight on moist evenings. 
 Leaf miner grubs are usually found at the end of their meandering tunnels in leaves and can be squeezed between your thumbnails. 
 Crushing batches of eggs on stems or leaves is quicker and more efficient than spraying. 
 Small numbers of aphids and other soft-bodied insects can be quickly rubbed off plants, while a forcible spray from a hose-pipe will disperse larger colonies, few of the insects surviving to climb back up the plant. 
 Spraying with water is particularly effective for discouraging red spider mite, which flourishes in dry conditions. 
 This can also be treated biologically in a greenhouse by deliberately introducing a predator mite, Phytoseiulus persimilis , which feeds on red spider mite. 
 Other examples of biological control, as it is known, are the use of encarsia parasites to eradicate glasshouse whitefly, and Bacillus thuringiensis , a natural bacteria that kills cabbage caterpillars. 
 Both parasites and predators are affected by insecticides, however, so it is important not to combine biological control with chemical sprays. 
 Chemicals 
 If used strictly according to recommendations, chemical treatments have their place, if only as a last resort for serious threats. 
 Asparagus beetles, for example, can dramatically reduce crop yields and, although often controlled naturally by ground beetles, need to be sprayed if they get out of hand. 
 If you decide to use an insecticide, choose the most appropriate one for the affected plant and the pest concerned to avoid injuring beneficial insects. 
 A guide from the British Agrochemicals Association, Garden chemicals: a guide to their safe and effective use , is available for &pound;1.50. 
 Write to the association, at 4 Lincoln Court, Lincoln Road, Peterborough PE1 2RP, or telephone: (0733) 349225. 
 Larger pests 
 Where birds and mammals are concerned some gardeners are squeamish about killing them. 
 Nevertheless, to protect your crops they must at least be deterred. 
 Smaller birds that prey on insect pests also raid fruit crops, which must be netted. 
 Either keep pigeons off brassicas with nets and various kinds of bird scarer, or intercrop brassicas where they are partly hidden by other plants. 
 Moles are difficult to deter. 
 The latest bright idea is to bury the device from one of those irritating musical greetings cards in their run, which should drive them out (or mad). 
 Traps should wither kill them instantly or confine them for release elsewhere. 
 Mice, too, are best caught in traps tucked beneath slates or inside lengths of pipe to avoid injuring birds. 
 Wire netting is the best defence against rabbits and squirrels, which will chew through plastic netting to plunder fruit crops. 
 Pesticides: handle with care 
 Although biological methods of pest control such as Bacillus thuringiensis  (for caterpillars) are now available to committed organic gardeners, there are few of us who never  need to resort to the use of chemicals. 
 Pesticides are either selective (affecting specific insects only) or non-selective. 
 Some kill on contact and are then rendered ineffective, whereas systemic (translocated) chemicals are absorbed into the plant's system and remain active for much longer, which could delay the harvest of fruit and vegetables. 
 Many gardeners prefer to apply systemic chemicals to ornamentals, restricting edible plants to spot treatment with contract pesticides. 
 Check that the chemical will in fact control the pest and can be used on the affected plant. 
 Use the most appropriate formulation, too. 
 Concentrated liquid pesticides applied as diluted sprays are perhaps the most versatile against pests of top growth, whereas soil pests are often treated with granules or dusts, the latter also used as seed dressings. 
 Aerosols are expensive but useful for emergencies, especially indoors. 
 Fumigants are generally used for non-selective treatment of confined areas such as greenhouses. 
 Simple solutions to small pests 
 Aphids 
 Green and blackfly (but not whitefly), root aphids and the grey-coloured mealy cabbage aphid; sap-feeding insects that multiply rapidly into dense colonies. 
 Their numerous wingless progeny weaken and distort young plant growth as they feed, spread virus diseases and produce sticky honeydew which disfigures leaves and encourages sooty mould. 
 Preventative sprays of systemic insecticides, and winter washes to kill aphid eggs, are often preferable to spraying establishing colonies which might contain predators. 
 Slugs and snails 
 Soft-bodied, voracious molluscs that often shelter by day beneath leaves and plant debris, and feed at night. 
 Catch on damp evenings; under grapefruit skins or large leaves; deter by ringing vulnerable plants with grit or soot. 
 Metaldehyde or methiocarb pellets can harm pets or wildlife; organic gardeners should poison with selective aluminium sulphate preparations. 
 Millipedes 
 Long and segmented, moving slowly and coiling up tightly when disturbed. 
 Two pairs of legs per segment, compared with one for centipedes, the gardener's allies. 
 Millipedes eat seeds, seedlings, roots and bulbs. 
 Disturb with frequent cultivation, and treat with a soil insecticide. 
 Control other soil pests, such as cutworms, leatherjackets and wireworms, in the same way. 
 Caterpillars 
 The larvae of moths, butterflies and sawflies. 
 Most plants are affected by one or more species, their presence betrayed by ragged leaves, buds or shoots, accumulations of dark green grass (excreta), and sometimes silky webs or rolled leaves. 
 Large numbers can strip a plant beyond recovery. 
 Crush eggs and caterpillars when seen: trap fruit species with grease bands; spray with a contact insecticide, or a systemic one if you suspect them to be feeding out of sight.  
 A seven-spot ladybird bears down on a group of hapless aphids 
 Plant bright, open flowers to attract the beneficent hoverfly 
 Wed-spinning red spider mite can wreak havoc in the greenhouse 
 Moles, cute but catastrophic 
 Wood mice make short work of fruit crops 
 Though it may snack on a strawberry, the ground beetle is an ally 
 Biological warfare with Bacillus thuringiensis  
 The frothy den of the froghopper, unaesthetic but harmless 
 No fate is too cruel for voracious snails, here devouring Iris foetida  
 This leopard slug, like all slugs, loves soils rich in organic matter 
 Greenfly can literally suck a plant dry 
 Cabbage white caterpillars hatch en masse 
 Using colour 
 Cool or warm, vivacious or romantic, a garden design depends on the colour mix 
 The chemistry of colour pigmentation helps gardeners to understand the behaviour and health of their plants, but garden design depends much more on visual impact and appreciation. 
 Colour is intimately linked with light, so it is hardly surprising that changing light alters colours, enhancing the brilliance of some while causing other to fade almost into invisibility. 
 Red roses that look vivid at midday seem to vanish as dusk falls, just when white flowers are at their most luminous. 
 Life-giving green 
 The way you arrange and exploit colours in your garden is ultimately a matter of personal preference. 
 A painful clash for one gardener may be gloriously stimulating to another. 
 However, a few basic guidelines are generally valid. 
 Green is the most essential colour in the garden, because without it other colours would be diminished. 
 Most dwellers in the temperate zones would agree, since centuries of conditioning by our surroundings have led us to see green as the fresh, life-giving backdrop to everything we perceive. 
 Cool and refreshing on its own, green is a matrix in which to set other colours like gems. 
 Thus a gold or purple-leaved shrub is best used not as an alternative to green foliage, but as a specimen highlight whose beauty depends on the contrast with its green neighbours. 
 All colours create moods and illusions. 
 Whereas greens and blues are cool and make flowers seem to recede, reds and yellows are warm colours that attract attention and stand forward from paler flowers. 
 White illuminates dark corners and en masse provides a still  breathing space among more lively shades. 
 Pastel colours are gentle and romantic, helping to restrain exuberant reds and yellows from overwhelming the senses. 
 Save intensely blue, purple and crimson flowers for dramatic flourishes within a paler context, otherwise they will lose their impact and seem too heavy or lifeless. 
 Set in front of a light background, these more dominating colours are not only vibrant, but suggest space and distance behind. 
 Harmony and contrast 
 Planning colour schemes involves choosing and balancing colours which will contrast or harmonise in a pleasing way. 
 Combine the stronger shades with care, keeping arrangements simple, except in mixed bedding where a lively tumult of colour is de rigueur . 
 However, while effective in small beds, such polychromatic mixtures can be uncomfortably dazzling unless framed by an outline of a single cool colour. 
 Or you could plant blocks of distinct colours, divided by a neutral foliage plant. 
 Two contrasting colours such a blue and yellow can look effective when freely mingled, each intensifying the impact of the other. 
 Limiting a bed or an area of a border to all the various shades of a single colour produces a sophisticated effect, although on a larger scale it may appear monotonous unless relieved by a subtle use of green or variegated foliage. 
 Colour all year round 
 From April, when spring bulbs, shrubs and herbaceous plants start flowering in earnest, until the summer bedding is dismantled in late September, there should be no problem keeping the garden filled with colour. 
 The majority of perennials flower during this period, along with hardy and half-hardy annuals. 
 A short flowering season can be extended by regular dead-heading. 
 However, fewer species flower out of doors between October and the end of February, and you'll need to plan carefully to devise a sequence of colour during these months, especially as weather conditions may spoil or interrupt normal flowering. 
 Evergreen shrubs with variegated foliage are a valuable insurance, although a great number of hardy plants usually succeed in blooming even in the severest season. 
 Bright ideas 
 The brief selection of flowering plants listed here should help brighten the darker months. 
 Several will remain in bloom for more than one month. 
 October 
 Anemone japonica, Arbutus unedo, asters, autumn crocus, chrysanthemums, helenium, rudbeckia, schizostylis. 
 November 
 Chimonanthus fragrans, gentians, Prunus subhirtella &bquo;Autumnalis&equo;, Sternbergea lutea. 
 December 
 Colchicums, Erica carnea, Hamamelis mollis, Lonicera fragrantissima, Mahonia japonica, Viburnum x bodnantense. 
 January 
 Adonis amurensis, brodiaea, Chimonanthus praecox, crocus, Iris unguicularis, winter aconites. 
 February 
 Anemones, Cornusmas, Daphne odora, doronicum narcissi, primulas, Prunus incisa &bquo;Praecox&equo;, P. mume, saxifrages, scillas. 
 Purple foliage sets off these clematis blooms 
 A bright, dramatic red instantly draws the eye 
 Rich yellows and reds need a green setting for maximum effect 
 A bold mix of sedum, aster and rudbeckia creates a lively border 
 Green, purple and gold in harmony 
 Glowing Schizostylis coccinea  
 Harvesting and storing 
 The prudent gardener takes as much care with his produce once picked as when growing, and saves seed in order to obtain plants for free 
 Throughout the main growing season vegetables, fruit and flowers are gathered or cut according to need, often before they are fully ripe. 
 Gooseberries, for example, can be picked for cooking or processing when they are still hard and green, flowers are often cut while still in bud and many roots or salad crops are at their most palatable when young and tender. 
 A great deal in store 
 Some garden produce, however, is deliberately grown for storage, and crops can be preserved for use during the winter months must be fully ripened if they are to last without rapid deterioration. 
 To recognise when a crop is ripe is an acquired art. 
 The critical moment for harvest varies from year to year and from one plant to the next. 
 Many fruits change colour as they reach maturity and this can be a useful indicator, although not in every case: apples will often colour up early if occupied by a burrowing pest, some pear varieties only change colour once in store and marrows are past their best when they turn yellow. 
 Friendly persuasion 
 A more reliable test is whether a fruit comes away from the plant without much persuasion. 
 Root crops for storage are best left in the ground for as long as possible, provided they are dug up before severe frosts set in. 
 Only unblemished, healthy produce will keep for long, and it is important to handle crops gently. 
 Punctured skins and broken stems might admit spores and cause the fruit or vegetable to rot, often spreading to adjacent specimens. 
 Since a firm intact skin is essential, both to exclude infections and prevent the contents from drying out, it is usual to leave roots on the soil surface for a few hours to harden their skins. 
 For the same reason, fruit that ripens in a dry sunny autumn will often keep longest, whereas a wet season may shorten their storage life. 
 Waste not, want not 
 Although many crops are processed for freezing or bottling, there are wasteful methods with roots and top fruits that can be preserved intact. 
 Storage methods vary considerably, as do the most suitable conditions (&bquo;Grenadier&equo; apples store best several degrees cooler than &bquo;Blenheim Orange&equo;, or example), but as a general rule the place of storage should be dry and cool. 
 A cellar, well-ventilated attic or frost-free shed is ideal, whereas inhabited rooms are usually too  warm and encourage early dessication. 
 Never lay crops directly on the floor where it is possible they could suffer from the effects of damp and poor air circulation, and arrange produce according to its preference: the roots nearer to the cool floor, and onions and marrows close to the ceiling where it is slightly warmer. 
 Spud space 
 Once dug and left to dry, potatoes can be sorted and stored in teachests, thick paper sacks or shallow boxes covered with sacking to keep the light from turning them green. 
 While parsnips, maincrop carrots, turnips and swedes are often left in the ground, covered with straw or leaves and dug as needed, they are better stored in boxes under cover if the soil is heavy and wet, or if you have a high soil pest population. 
 Use any damaged roots immediately and leave the rest to dry. 
 Trim off their leaves, and then spread the roots between layers of moist sand or dry sawdust, placing the largest roots at the bottom as these keep longest. 
 Beetroot is always better stored in this way after its leaves have been twisted off. 
 You should never wash roots before storing, but always gently rub off any loose soil. 
 Apples should be picked carefully and graded so that the smallest and largest are used first, and medium-sized fruit is saved for storage. 
 Lay the fruit stem uppermost on shelves or in shallow boxes so that they do not touch each other. 
 Wrap the finest dessert specimens individually, in some newspaper. 
 Alternatively, store them in perforated polythene bags. 
 Leave a window or door open for a week after storing to let the fruit sweat, and then keep cool, checking them occasionally for signs of decay. 
 Pears are treated in much the same way, but are never wrapped. 
 Most continue ripening in store until ready for the table, but a few varieties must be brought into the warm for a few days before they are ready to eat. 
 Saving seeds 
 Many gardeners collect and store seeds from their garden plants, which is an economical practice, especially in the case of outstanding vegetables, flowering plants and sports or other unusual forms. 
 It is not really worth saving seeds from F1 hybrids or from most fruit varieties as these rarely reproduce true to type. 
 Variegated varieties will often produce green plants from seed, and seedlings from a flower mixture may not represent the full range of colours. 
 You should gather seeds from the best plants only, if possible selecting and marking them early on and removing all but one or two of the first, fattest seed-heads to conserve as much energy as possible. 
 A plant left to fully ripen all its seeds will probably stop flowering or cropping before its neighbours. 
 Off with their heads 
 Wait until the seed-heads are fully ripe. 
 Colour may be an indication of maturity, but some seeds will probably remain green and it is better to gently shake or tap seed-heads to see if the contents are dropping. 
 At this stage cut off the complete head and invert it in a paper bag, hanging these in an airy place for a few days until the seeds are quite dry. 
 Sort and clean the seeds, removing stems, casings and chaff manually, by sieving or blowing away the debris. 
 Seal the seeds in envelopes marked with name, date, place where gathered and other date. 
 Store the envelopes in an airtight container, and include a sachet of silica gel to absorb moisture (if the gel turns pink, dry gently in the oven until it turns blue again). 
 Keep them in a cool dry place until the appropriate sowing time.  
 Choose unblemished, healthy fruit for storing 
 Polythene bags should be perforated if used 
 Store potatoes in tea-chests, paper sacks or shallow boxes 
 Keep carrots, parsnips, swedes and turnips in boxes under cover 
 Make sure the seed heads are fully ripe before you cut them away 
 Honesty ( Lunaria annua ) produces silvery, moon-like seed-heads 
 Plants for shade 
 With the right choice of shrubs and plants, you can brighten up the shadiest of corners 
 Light in some form is absolutely essential for the healthy development of green plants. 
 All the complex chemical changes that take place within every leaf are fuelled by the energy in light, and regulated by the intensity and duration of the light available. 
 But some plants actually prefer varying degrees of shade, which is fortunate for gardeners choosing plants for gloomy corners or the dappled shade beneath trees. 
 Gardeners occasionally regard shade as an evil to be avoided at all costs. 
 It can certainly cause problems with a wide range of plants, but there are many others that suffer from high intensity of sunlight. 
 Too much sun, for example helps trigger the premature bolting to seed of some crops in summer, which is one reason why later sowings of radishes, salads or spinach are much better situated in a cool, shady bed. 
 Other factors affecting growth explain why not all plants welcome unlimited light. 
 For plants to photosynthesise and produce sugars in their leaf cells, they need to absorb large amounts of carbon dioxide. 
 How much they can take in depends partially on the structure of their leaves. 
 Some absorb the gas quickly, whereas others circulate it slowly and cannot respond to floods of bright light. 
 These plants, with their slow metabolism, can be found in the wild growing happily in woodland floors where sunlight is filtered. 
 Plants that manufacture food slowly will respond to full sunshine by wilting as they become hotter and lose water. 
 Bright sunlight destroys chlorophyll which they are unable to replace fast enough, and so they suffer while other, more adaptable plants flourish. 
 Striving for the light 
 Plants that do need sunlight may survive in shade for a while, directing their energies to growing rapidly towards the light essential for their flowering and seed production. 
 Their elongated stems with few small leaves strive upwards until they find sufficient light, and this can be seen when sun-loving species are planted in shady parts of the garden. 
 Similarly, congested seedlings will become thin and drawn, with soft, weak stems that eventually collapse from being forced. 
 And where the source of light comes mostly from one side, as when plants are growing under a hedge, stems often bend and stretch in that direction. 
 The tendency to move or grow towards light is called phototropism. 
 For these reasons, when tackling the problem of gardening in the shade it is important to choose plants proficient at extracting energy from limited sunlight. 
 Mere tolerance of shade is not enough. 
 Some species may be receiving sufficient light to grow plenty of  healthy foliage, but will always lack that little extra needed to produce flowering shoots. 
 Variegated plants will start to make more chlorophyll in their leaves in response to restricted sunlight, and so tend to turn green in the shade. 
 Others need precise daily rations of sunlight that change with the seasons if they are to start flowering at a particular time. 
 Those that need a long day-length to complete their life-cycle often refuse to bloom in the shade. 
 Coping with shade 
 Understanding the preferences of particular plants will help you avoid making mistakes in shaded areas of the garden. 
 Watch to see how long the shade persists; if sunlight reaches the area for at least  half the day, plants listed as tolerating partial shade will thrive there. 
 Depth of shade is also important, since a number of species, while enjoying the limited sunlight filtered through trees with an open branch system, are unable to cope with the dense shade cast by evergreens. 
 Many plants native to natural mixed woodland flower and produce their leaves early in the year, before deciduous trees have developed a full canopy, and welcome the shade in summer that protects them from scorching in full sun. 
 Feed under your trees 
 Favourable soil conditions affect a plant's chances of survival beneath trees. 
 Very often the soil is dry and hungry (deficient in nutrients), especially near evergreens and vigorously rooting hedge species such as privet. 
 Working quantities of organic material into the top few inches will markedly improve some plants' performance. 
 Massed conifers cast dense shadows and their fallen needles can upset the acid/alkaline balance of the soil. 
 Some thinning may be necessary to admit enough light for plants such as rhododendrons, pieris and hostas to thrive. 
 Unless very dense, the shady conditions produced by most garden trees can be turned to advantage by creating a miniature woodland that will suit shade-loving plants and offer a cool oasis in a hot summer. 
 Even branches from a neighbour's tree overhanging your garden can be exploited in this way. 
 With a little unobtrusive thinning, you can regulate the amount of dappled shade and filtered sunlight to suit the kind of plants you would like to grow. 
 The same approach can be used where the shade is cast by a wall, fence or building. 
 Capitalise on this change of environment: train leafy creepers (ivies, honeysuckle, small-flowered clematis) on the vertical surfaces, lay an appropriate style of path through the area and then plant with shade-loving species according to soil type and aspect. 
 No place for nigella 
 Always avoid species where flowers close up at night or when the sun goes in; variegated varieties, whose rich colours will fade and leaves gradually green over in persistent shade, and &bquo;long-day&equo; flowers such as iris, rudbeckia and nigella whose flowering depends absolutely on prolonged sunlight. 
 Arrange one or two suitable shrubs that grow with a relaxed, arching habit, and then fill between them with large patches or drifts of herbaceous plants en masse. 
 Single specimens, even if very brightly coloured, tend to disappear in the shadows, whereas they will be more conspicuous planted in a block especially if supported by masses of healthy green foliage: ferns for a splash of colour. 
 On dry soils, mulch annually around the plants to retain what moisture there is, and remember to water regularly if they are overhung by a tree, fence or wall and hence miss out on rainfall. 
 Plants for a variety of shades 
 Flowers for damp shade 
 Astilbe; cimicifuga; dicentra; Iris sibirica; mimulus; primula (candelabras); rodgersia; smilacina; trollius; viola. 
 Flowers for dry shade 
 Aquilegia; astrantia; campanula; corydalis; epimedium; geranium; helleborus; heuchera; lamium; Lunaria; Meconopsis cambrica; pulmonaria; viola. 
 Shrubs for light shade 
 Amelancher; azaleas (deciduous); cornus; corylus; hamamelis; philadelphus; rose species; Spiraea x arguta; Viburnum x bodnantense. 
 Shrubs for heavy shade 
 Camellia japonica; elaeagnus; Euonymus fortunei; Fatsia japonica; Mahonia aquifolium; Prunus laurocerasus; rhododendron hybrids; sarcococa; skimmia. 
 Woodland flowers &amp; wildflowers 
 Allium ursinum (wild garlic) 
 Anemone nemorosa 
 Arum maculatum 
 Convallaria (lily-of-the-valley) 
 Cyclamen 
 Digitalis purpurea (foxglove) 
 Eranthis hyemalis (winter aconite) 
 Erythroniums 
 Fritillaries 
 Galanthus (snowdrops) 
 Galium odoratum (sweet woodruff) 
 Hyacinthoides non-scriptus (bluebells) 
 Lamiastrum galeobdolon 
 Muscari (grape hyacinths) 
 Myosotis sylvatica (wood forget-me-not) 
 Ornithogalum 
 Primula vulgaris (primrose) 
 Silene dioica (red campion) 
 In light shade, rogersias bring flower plumes and foliar interest 
 Graceful polystichums are the key to this deliciously cool tableau 
 Hamamelis (witch hazel) flowers in winter 
 Many spiraeas will be happy in partial shade, brightening it with their dense white blooms 
 Deciduous azaleas bring subtly contrasting colour in autumn 
 Create a natural woodland look with a carpet of hardy cyclamen 
 Candelabra primulas enjoy dappled sunlight 
 Snowdrops are shady favourites for the dark days of late winter 
 Avoiding gliding accidents 
 Gliding safety depends on good training and on instructors encouraging novices to develop safety-conscious habits. 
 Most accidents occur because the pilot is unaware of, or chooses to ignore, possible hazards. 
 Safety must be everyone's concern &mdash; the majority of accidents could be avoided if every pilot is aware of the common hazards. 
 Reading or hearing of other pilots' experiences emphasises how easy it is for even seasoned pilots to make mistakes. 
 Instructors and senior pilots have a big responsibility to pass on their experience and knowledge and to look out for poor airmanship and flying techniques in others which could lead to mishaps in the future. 
 In section 1, I have chosen various gliding areas which involve special hazards for the unwary, and have suggested how to prevent accidents by being conscious of potentially difficult situations.    
 How glider accidents happen 
 Considering that so many gliders are flown across country on every possible soaring day, the accident rate for gliding is extremely low. 
 However, it must always be remembered that, like the sea, the air is an environment which is potentially dangerous to the unwary. 
 There are, of course, always a number of minor incidents and accidents during training. 
 The result of every accident, however minor, is a rise in the cost of insurance, the loss of the aircraft while it is replaced or repaired and, sometimes, injuries to the pilot and other people involved. 
 Most glider pilots have never experienced anything more hazardous than a bad landing, so reading and talking about other people's mistakes is almost the only way of becoming aware of the kind of situations which lead to broken gliders. 
 few pilots realise how much even minor damage can cost to repair. 
 Just slipping and dropping a wing while loading it into the trailer will cause hundreds of pounds' worth of damage, and although most gliders are insured, every accident eventually results in higher premiums and higher costs for gliding enthusiasts. 
 It is quite rare to have an accident directly caused by some kind of technical failure. 
 The main cause is almost always something to do with the pilot's flying skills or judgements. 
 99% of all gliding accidents happen when the aircraft hits something. 
 A few pilots manage to stall and spin in; some fly into the ground during their final turn; many make such bad landings that they damage their glider; and, finally, far too many run into other gliders or obstructions during take-offs and landings. 
 This indicates that instruction is failing to get across the vital aspects which could reduce the risk of accidents. 
 Are you fit to fly? 
 When an emergency situation arises the pilot needs all his wits about him. 
 A surprising number of accidents and incidents happen because pilots are in some way not 100% fit on the day in question. 
 Obviously, if you have a heavy cold, a headache, are suffering from lack of sleep or are jet lagged, you should not be flying. 
 But the decision about whether or not to fly is left to you, the pilot. 
 You alone have to make that judgement. 
 It is best to make a firm rule not to fly if you are feeling unwell or unenthusiastic. 
 If you have spent a long day on the airfield, it will be difficult to refuse your turn to fly, even if you are tired. 
 However, if you are going to fly solo, refusing is the only sensible thing to do. 
 Flying demands all your concentration and it is not wise to risk flying if you have business worries or some other mental stress on your mind. 
 Even a violent argument will leave you mentally high and quite unfit to fly. 
 You can also become unfit in the air through lack of food and drink. 
 Both these factors can cause lack of concentration and apathy. 
 In warm weather,  dehydration is a serious problem, and sufficient liquid must be taken during the flight even if this has its disadvantages afterwards! 
 Keeping in practice 
 It is probably true to say that the first few solo flights are the safest that a student pilot ever makes. 
 This is because he has recently practised safety procedures for almost every conceivable emergency, and they are therefore fresh in his mind. 
 Also, the pilot will be in very good flying form and his instructor will have made sure that he has not been getting into bad habits. 
 It is important to try and keep in practice in order to reinforce all the things which have been learned during the pre-solo training. 
 Most gliding clubs have a system of re-checking pilots during the first few hours of solo flying, but then pilots are left very much to their own devices to improve their soaring techniques. 
 They may go several years without a cable break on the winch launching, and so they will scarcely give the possibility any thought. 
 An annual briefing on cable break procedures and other emergencies would be very valuable for everyone who flies gliders, and particularly those who stop flying for long periods over the winter months and so get badly out of practice. 
 Many pilots select the days on which they fly so that the weather is near ideal and not too windy. 
 It is easy to forget exactly how much allowance should be made for the wind and other factors on a rough day. 
 Pilots who have only flown in light winds will be dangerously incompetent in rough weather, particularly if they are also out of current flying practice. 
 If they do attempt to fly on a windy day, then a check flight should be made to ensure that they remember the hazards and how to avoid them. 
 When pilots from a big, flat site visit a hill site, they are at risk and often make absolute fools of themselves unless they get a very thorough briefing and listen to what local pilots and instructors have to say. 
 It is always wise to have a dual flight before flying solo at an unfamiliar site. 
 There is always something to be learned from a knowledgeable local instructor, and a flight is far more valuable than just a site briefing. 
 Being in practice is also important for a first flight in a new and unfamiliar type of aircraft. 
 Always avoid doing too many new things in one flight; i.e. do not fly a new type of aircraft on an unfamiliar airfield. 
 Try and get a dual flight on the airfield so that at least you know something about the airfield and its surrounds. 
 Wire launches 
 A large proportion of gliding accidents and incidents result from launch failures. 
 Too many pilots seem to believe that they can cope with these failures and then are proved wrong. 
 Most accidents happen when a cable break occurs close to the ground. 
 Here a failure calls for immediate action if you are to level out into normal flight and so prevent a stall. 
 Always ensure that the initial climbing angles on a winch or car launch will allow time for a safe recovery into  the glide if the cable breaks. 
 Too many pilots allow their glider to zoom up too steeply as they leave the ground. 
 This is always dangerous because at that moment the glider has insufficient speed to allow for safe recovery and landing. 
 If pilots continue to do this, sooner or later they will get hurt. 
 Far too often with a low cable break, the pilot goes for the airbrakes when there is a mile of field ahead and no hurry whatsoever. 
 The actual speed at the time is usually far too slow to allow for any use of the airbrakes, but there is plenty of room ahead for a safe landing. 
 If the failure occurs higher on the launch, again a snap decision can be fatal. 
 Lower the nose and check the actual airspeed before doing anything else. 
 The most common cause of serious accidents on wire launches is making a snap decision to turn off for a 360&deg; turn without ensuring that there is enough speed. 
 Even though the nose has been lowered well below the horizon, a glider takes time to regain speed, and any attempt to turn off immediately results in a potential stall and spin accident. 
 The first question you ask yourself is &bquo;can I get down straight ahead?&equo; 
 If the answer is no, then check the speed before starting to turn. 
 Reacting too slowly and taking too long to make a decision can also be hazardous. 
 If you obviously cannot get down ahead or if you have doubts about it, then you have no alternative but to turn off, but check your speed first! 
 How to avoid problems with wire launches 
 1 
 Go over the launch failure procedures after any long lay-off from flying. 
 2 
 Try and think systematically about your actions in the event of a launch failure. 
 3 
 Always assess the special considerations and conditions for the day (e.g cross winds, turbulence etc.). 
 4 
 At an unfamiliar site, talk to the locals and discuss the best course of action for launch failures. 
 5 
 Before you take off, ask yourself the following questions. 
 Is the glider ready? 
 What about the weather conditions? 
 Are you ready for a launch failure? 
 Is it safe to go now? 
 6 
 Always expect and be ready for a launch failure in the first 500 feet on every launch. 
 Soaring 
 Inexperienced pilots get into difficulties when they are soaring. 
 They often get lost because they have not kept the airfield in sight and within easy gliding range. 
 It is important for these pilots to develop the habit of checking the position of the gliding site immediately after releasing the tow and to re-check it regularly every few circles. 
 It is also important to be aware of the wind direction and the amount of drift, and to avoid drifting down wind whenever possible. 
 Beginners often continue to struggle with weak lift without realising  that they are, in fact, losing height and drifting further away. 
 If the variometer is fluctuating and reading up on one side of the circle and down a little on the other, the probability is that the glider is not climbing at all but is just drifting further down wind. 
 If the glider is down wind of the site, the decision to return must be taken before the glider gets to less than an angle of about 20&deg; to the field in light winds, and 30&ndash;40&deg; in windy weather. 
 Allowance must always be made for wind strength and the possibility of strong sink, since it can never be known beforehand whether there will be lift or sink on the way back. 
 A common mistake is to try to use lift on the way back instead of gliding on through it at a sensible speed. 
 This nearly always results in drifting further back without much gain of height and ending up in a worse situation than before. 
 If it begins to look doubtful that the site can be reached and the glider is down to 1,000 feet, it is time to select the best possible field within easy reach and to make a safe landing in it. 
 If you glide back any lower, the choice of landing area becomes very limited, until finally there is no choice at all. 
 Be decisive. 
 If you are uncertain about whether or not you can get back with a reasonable margin of safety, make a safe landing while you can; a planned approach into a poor field is better than an out-of-wind crash into a good field! 
 For inexperienced pilots flying in light winds, a good general rule is to allow a maximum of 3 miles' glide per 1,000 feet with nothing for the last 1,000 feet. 
 However, an extra allowance must be made for any head wind, and in poor visibility inexperienced pilots should make sure that they are close enough to keep the field in sight all the time. 
 Almost all accidents start with a simple error on the part of the pilot that leads to a chain of events, each of which makes the situation worse and an accident more and more difficult to avoid. 
 The art of safe piloting is to learn to avoid the initial error whenever possible. 
 But, if an error of judgement or a bad decision has been made, the vital thing is to recognise that, admit it and take immediate action to break the chain of events while a safe course of action is still possible. 
 forget the error or the cause of the problem and get on with correcting it and avoiding a worse situation. 
 A similar situation occurs when soaring cross-country. 
 Although you may get ridiculously low because of pressing on too hard, when, a few minutes later, you are back in the good conditions several thousand feet up, you must forget the wasted time and concentrate on flying normally.  
 Ground handling damage 
 Nothing is more heartbreaking than to see a beautiful glider damaged by incompetent handling on the ground. 
 For every incident which causes damage to a glider while it is being flown, there must be many more that happen because of careless or thoughtless ground handling. 
 Sometimes these accidents are caused by laziness, but more often they are the result of someone not realising the significance of doing things the right way. 
 All of them are avoidable and cost time and money. 
 Student pilots need very thorough briefing about the hazards of ground handling in a strong wind and, since most flying is restricted to light winds, this must be reinforced whenever the conditions make extra care necessary. 
 Towing 
 The danger involved when towing the glider into a strong wind cannot be stressed too much. 
 This is when there is the greatest risk of the glider being lifted off the ground by the first strong gust. 
 With no one in the cockpit and the tail on the ground, most gliders will develop enough lift to leave the ground at well under 30 knots. 
 To prevent this happening, the nose of the glider should be held down (or the tail held up) to reduce the wing incidence, as this in turn reduces the lift significantly. 
 Usually, the weight of a person on the extreme nose will prevent the glider lifting off the ground, but to be safe it is best to put a person in the cockpit. 
 Anyone sitting in a glider must always be properly strapped in. 
 If a glider was blown over with someone sitting inside it unstrapped, that person could be killed. 
 The airbrakes should always be opened (tying them open with a harness strap, if necessary) as this reduces the lift and increases the &bquo;lift-off&equo; speed by several knots. 
 A student at Lashan Gliding Centre was badly hurt once when the glider lifted off the ground and came down on top of him as he walked by the nose. 
 This was caused by a combination of a very strong gust and the fact that no one was keeping the nose down while the glider was being towed into wind. 
 The wind that day had been increasing with the approach of bad weather and the instructor, who had decided that it was time to stop, was towing the glider to the hangar. 
 In such situations, it is always worth considering whether it is safer to have another launch and fly the glider to the hangar. 
 Flying is often safer than towing into a really strong and gusty wind. 
 Obviously, the slower the tow is into wind, the less airflow there is over the wings, and thus the safer it is. 
 On a windy day, more care is usually taken, but even then a few moments' inattention, or the wrong drill, can result in the glider being blown over and written off. 
 When a glider is being moved around the airfield, one person should take charge of the whole operation and be responsible for the safety of the aircraft. 
 This is normally either the pilot or the instructor. 
 This person must brief the  helpers if they are inexperienced. 
 He should insist that the correct wing is held, and direct the car or tractor driver so that they take a safe route which is clear of any hazard from dropping winch cables. 
 It is his responsibility to decide whether the glider should be manned at the nose or tail, and whether someone is needed in the cockpit. 
 In a strong wind he must refuse to move until sufficient additional crew arrive to handle the glider safely. 
 Many accidents happen through impatience. 
 If you cannot be sure of handling the glider safely, turn it out of the wind, hold the wing down and wait for help. 
 Ground handling 
 Wing-tips 
 It is generally agreed that only one wing-tip should be held while the glider is being moved about. 
 This is because if there is a person on both wing-tips, neither may have a good grip. 
 Furthermore, it is all too easy for both people to decide to let go at the same moment, so that no one is left holding a wing-tip. 
 Traditionally, it was usual to take the upwind wing-tip and to hold it slightly below the horizontal. 
 This was because with the older gliders like the T21 or T31, the wings were very high and they could not be held securely except by keeping one wing low. 
 However, when towing in a cross wind, the glider will tend to weathercock into wind, and the person on the upwind wing will have difficulty in pushing forward enough to prevent this happening. 
 With a modern glider which has a lower wing and the wheel well ahead of the c.g., this weathercocking will be even more pronounced, so it is better to hold the down wind tip. 
 (Just as with the cross wind take-off, the down wind wing should be held so that any slight pull will not help the weathercocking into wind.)  
 Groundhandling an ASK13 
 Light winds 
 It is a great temptation to tow a single-seater back with only the pilot on the wing-tip. 
 This may be reasonably safe with a very long tow rope, but if there is only a shorter length of rope available the glider may overrun and smash into the back of the car, causing hundreds of pounds' worth of damage to the glider. 
 If towing is permitted with only a wing-tip man, it is vital that the pilots all recognise that this is only safe if the ground is more or less level and the wind is very light. 
 Strong wind conditions 
 In windy weather every effort should be made to avoid having to move the glider upwind; it is far safer and easier to land well into the field and then to move the glider back down wind. 
 It is safe to push backwards, moving down wind with the nose into wind, provided that the airbrakes are open and weight is applied down on the nose. 
 The effective wind-speed is reduced by the movement down wind and, as long as the tail is not held down, this is safer and easier than turning the glider right round. 
 (Always put a knowledgeable and reliable person at the tail, and remind them only to hold the tail down if that is necessary to move the glider easily.) 
 Towing forwards going down wind means that there is no possibility of being blown over, but the controls must be held or locked otherwise the control hinges may be damaged by the surfaces slamming across against the stops. 
 In very strong winds the critical place for ground handling is at the tail. 
 Always make sure that the person on the tail is briefed to hold it up until someone has their weight on the nose. 
 After coming to a stop with the glider facing into wind, holding the tail down is the worst possible thing, and even leaving the nose unattended for a few moments is dangerous. 
 It is always safer to transfer the person on the tail to the nose, where his extra weight can be more effective. 
 Many modern machines do not have hand holds at the tail and are very tail-heavy on the ground. 
 Weight on the nose or in the cockpit will be sufficient to prevent the glider lifting. 
 There is always a tendency for pilots to relax as the launch point is reached. 
 Unless the glider is going to be launched without delay, it should be turned out of wind and held with the into-wind wing down until it is needed. 
 Tail and wing-tip trolleys 
 Britain must be one of the only countries in the world where the club members manhandle the two-seater gliders all the way out to the launch point. 
 Most private owners discovered the use of a tail and wing-tip dolly a long time ago, making it possible to tow out with a car single-handedly on most days. 
 It is a harsh punishment to have to walk the glider all the way back, particularly after a cable break where the glider lands in the middle of the airfield. 
 I am always surprised that clubs will happily buy an expensive tractor to pull gliders back, but will not provide aids to make it all less strenuous and time-consuming. 
 The proper equipment makes the whole operation far easier and safer, and encourages instructors to practise those exercises which can so often result in a long walk back to the launch point. 
 However, it is essential to recognise that  towing aids are only really safe for use in normal flying conditions, and caution is needed if they are used in windy weather. 
 Parking 
 If the wind can be trusted to stay in much the same direction, safe parking is an easy matter. 
 With the lighter machines, the into-wind wing should be picketed or weighted with tyres or weights, and the tail-skid or wheel should be blocked to prevent the glider moving round into wind. 
 The front skid or main wheel will also need to be chocked, and an easy, effective way of doing this is to run the main wheel into a rut in the ground. 
 Parking with the airbrakes open is very little trouble and is helpful if the wind does swing. 
 The canopy should always be locked down. 
 Gliders are often left for short periods with tyres on the wing-tip only. 
 If this is done, the tyres should be right on the tip and not half on the ground, otherwise if the glider does move, the tip will slide out from under the tyre and be freed. 
 This can be disastrous and may easily occur if there is no wind in the early morning when the gliders are parked outside the hangar with a single tyre on the wing-tip. 
 Later, when the wind has picked up, the gliders weathercock round and can be free to tip over so that the into-wind wing is upwards. 
 Another hazard is the wind swinging and increasing during the day so that the glider ends up parked facing directly into the wind. 
 If the glider is facing across the wind with the into-wind wing held down, the wind will be blowing on to its top surface, producing an extra down-load. 
 However, in a strong wind several tyres are required to stop the into-wind wing lifting up. 
 The upper tip will be high in the air where the wind is stronger, while the lower wing will be close to the ground where the wind is much lighter. 
 The glider is not secure with only one light tyre on the wing-tip. 
 Blow-overs 
 If the glider is facing more or less directly into the wind, and there is a pilot in the cockpit, it is just as safe as it would be after a normal landing. 
 Some people think that holding the wing down or putting a tyre on the wing will stop the glider blowing over. 
 However, facing into the wind while waiting for a launch, a tyre on the wing-tip is just a convenient way of preventing the wing from lifting off the ground. 
 When conditions are very squally it is better to have the wings held level, with as much weight on the nose as possible. 
 Having one wing down may result in a light glider being blown over if the wind changes direction and gets underneath the raised wing. 
 Then, all the weight in the world on the wing-tip would not stop it going over. 
 When a blow-over does occur, you will always hear the people concerned state, quite truthfully: &bquo;Up to that time the wind had been quite acceptable and then there was this bad gust&hellip; 
 &bquo;. Of course, had the wind been very gusty before, they would already have stopped flying, or they would have taken extra precautions to make sure that there were enough people to prevent an incident. 
 The moral is clear: when gustiness is getting near to the limit for safe  flying, assume that at any time it could suddenly increase. 
 Stop flying before it becomes too windy to move or fly the glider. 
 Blow-overs were a common occurrence in the early days with lighter gliders and they sometimes even happened on almost windless summer days. 
 Although the gliders were left facing at right angles to the wind and were weighted down with tyres in the approved manner, when the first strong thermal went off nearby the wind would become gusty and change direction completely. 
 This meant that the gliders were then parked the wrong way and, being light, they often blew over. 
 This kind of blow-over can only be avoided by manning the glider all the time or by tying it down with pickets, preferably with the wings level and all its control surfaces locked to prevent them flapping against their stops. 
 This is standard practice in more tropical countries where there are &bquo;dust devils&equo; or &bquo;willy willies&equo; which can produce a 40-knot wind in almost any direction with little or no warning. 
 Even the towplanes are taxied to a nearby picketing point and tied down properly between each flight. 
 Now that modern gliders are so much heavier and have their wings closer to the ground, it is fairly usual for private owners to park 90&deg; out of wind with the into-wind wing up. 
 Although perhaps vulnerable to strong winds in this position, in lighter winds it is stable enough to ensure that no tyres are needed. 
 The result is that many glider pilots are becoming complacent about parking and on a really windy day it is not unusual to see gliders at risk, just waiting for the first really big gust of wind to blow them over. 
 The whys and wherefores of these procedures need to be explained to students, otherwise they might conclude that proper parking is not really important and that it is alright to leave a glider with either wing down. 
 Line squalls and thunderstorms 
 The worst situation for accidents is a good soaring day with a risk of thundery showers. 
 This means that a large number of gliders will be rigged and brought out on the airfield. 
 Then, when the first big shower starts, rather than stand under the wings in the rain everyone will desert the launch point for a cup of tea, leaving the gliders apparently well parked and weighted with tyres but, in fact, vulnerable to a change in the wind direction. 
 Often, even after insisting that everyone goes back to the launch point, there will be barely enough people to hold all the gliders down, turn them around and re-park them if the wind changes. 
 This is an easy way to have a number of gliders wrecked by the wind, but luckily it does not occur very often. 
 The only safe solution is to get the gliders into the hangar before the squalls arrive, or to make sure that there are at least two people close to each glider all the time, ready to swing them round when necessary. 
 Everyone gets very wet but it is worth while getting soaked if it saves even one glider from serious damage. 
 Finally, remember that if a cold front is due in the summer-time, it may be preceded by some hours by a line of unpredicted severe squalls and storms.  
 Overnight or long-term parking 
 In dry and settled weather conditions it is quite safe to leave gliders out overnight. 
 However, permanent parking outside in all weathers has been shown to cause rapid deterioration to the finish of all non-metal gliders. 
 Never risk parking out overnight without checking the weather forecast for a strong wind warning or the approach of a cold front. 
 Provided that all the controls can be locked to prevent them getting damaged by slamming against the stops, parking the aircraft facing down wind will be safest, because then the wing is meeting the airflow at a negative angle. 
 In lighter winds they can be picketed out, facing into wind with the wings level. 
 For long-term picketing out, the main wheel can be run into a hollow or trench in the ground to reduce the wing incidence and to lower the wings still further. 
 Wing covers will also help to reduce the lifting qualities, but they can damage the finish if they are allowed to thrash about in the wind. 
 Protecting the instruments 
 It is always worth while covering both the  pitot  and static vents to prevent rain entering the systems. 
 However, it is unwise to seal them off completely with tape as a large change in atmospheric pressure may cause damage to some instruments. 
 I usually make a tape hood over the static vents to allow them to breathe without letting water droplets get into the tubes. 
 If this does happen, the only solution seems to be to disconnect the instruments and to pump air through the system to blow out the water and dry the tubing. 
 Never blow down the vents or the total energy and pitot heads because this can destroy the instruments. 
 The venturi-tube type of total energy system can be dried out by venting it to cockpit static to allow the venturi to suck out the water in flight. 
 This leaves you with a working variometer but without total energy. 
 Always take precautions against rain. 
 You never find out about the water in the instrument systems until you are airborne and it will ruin that flight, if not the entire flying for that day. 
 It takes at least an hour to get the system clear and dry again, and is a very frustrating problem, particularly if it occurs in a competition. 
 Rigging and de-rigging 
 With the help of good rigging aids such as trestles and a stand for the fuselage, it is often just possible to rig with two people. 
 However, it is always a little risky, especially if the ground is slippery or uneven. 
 One slip may mean that the wingtip is dropped, causing some very expensive damage to the wing or the fuselage structure and fittings. 
 It is rarely an impossibility to find a third person, and in gusty weather this must make sense. 
 Think how often you see two people struggling to rig or de-rig because they are too embarrassed or independent to ask someone to help. 
 In the early days of gliding, trestles were not considered essential as an aid to rigging; I remember the very first ASW17 to arrive in the UK being rigged without them. 
 Like most new machines, everything was a tight fit and by the  time we had the glider rigged, we had worn out several people with the sheer weight of the wings. 
 Trestles make it all so much easier and safer, and it is worth while having a second one so that everyone can relax for a few minutes if it is proving difficult to align both wings to get the main pins in place. 
 Trestles are also very useful for holding the wings level if the glider is being picketed overnight. 
 The routine for rigging and de-rigging is usually passed on by word of mouth, or is self-taught. 
 As a result it is not unusual to see people doing things which increase the risk of serious damage if things go wrong. 
 I have often seen pilots fitting the tailplane on before the wings. 
 This ensures some very expensive damage in the event of the fuselage falling over, whereas without the tailplane very little or no damage is likely. 
 If you put your tailplane on first, you might say, quite rightly, that this will not happen with your equipment. 
 However, someone seeing you may do the same thing using a crude &bquo;dead man&equo; to hold the fuselage upright. 
 If it falls over it will certainly be weeks before he flies again. 
 Make sure that the fuselage is secure and is not liable to move. 
 In windy weather there will be a definite tendency for the fuselage to weathercock round into wind unless the tail-wheel or skid is chocked. 
 Anything which makes rigging and de-rigging more difficult increases the risk of someone getting tired of holding up a wing-tip and so letting it droop or even drop. 
 The most common cause of damage when getting the glider out of the trailer and putting it back at the end of the day's flying is impatience, and the only answer is never to rig without an adequate number of people. 
 If in doubt, get help, and don't rig until enough help is available. 
 Hangar rash 
 It is often said that more damage is done inside the hangar than out! 
 This is often the result of inexperienced people trying to give a helping hand to get the gliders out. 
 Usually the problem is that no one is really taking charge and telling the others exactly what to do. 
 A quick but careful briefing would, in most cases, prevent incidents such as someone lifting a wing without first checking that the other wing will not come down on to another glider's canopy. 
 Moving through a confined space, for example if the glider is too large to go through the door, it is always wise to go nose first, swinging the glider right round and out with its nose close to one door. 
 (Leading edges are much stronger than trailing edges or tailplanes and rudders.) 
 Don't try to go out backwards unless there is ample space for the glider to go straight through. 
 Some hangars have doors at each end and these make a good wind tunnel if both ends are opened at the same time. 
 Even in light winds there can be a venturi effect sufficient to blow the gliders about. 
 Unless the wing-tips are weighted down with a tyre, one wing lifting off the ground means that the other will come down on to another glider with expensive results. 
 Always close the doors at one end before opening them at the other, unless the wind is very light, and never leave both ends open in case a wind springs up later in the day.  
 Trailer towing 
 Unfortunately, most people learn about towing trailers by trial and error, which can prove to be a very expensive way of doing things. 
 Every year a number of trailers are rolled over on our roads and trailer accidents account for a great deal of glider repairs. 
 Snaking 
 Glider trailers can be stable or unstable, depending on the car and the trailer combination. 
 If a trailer begins to &bquo;snake&equo;, the swinging often develops so quickly that within seconds there is no way of stopping it and avoiding going right off the road. 
 Even a fairly stable trailer will start to swing if it overtakes or is overtaken by a large truck. 
 The pressure wave from an overtaking truck strikes the rear of the trailer first, setting up a swing. 
 In addition, the venturi effect between the two vehicles assists this swing and tends to suck the two vehicles together. 
 This is particularly common on motorways where trucks are overtaking at quite high speeds. 
 It is vital to have good side mirrors on the car in order to be aware of traffic which is behind or overtaking. 
 Judging by the number of trailer accidents on the motorways, it may be wiser to keep off them whenever possible. 
 Factors which influence the stability of the combination include the softness of the car and the trailer's suspension, plus the balance of the trailer. 
 It is a good idea to add an extra 5 or 10 p.s.i. 
 to the pressure in the car tyres and to keep the trailer tyres at a higher pressure than might at first seem necessary. 
 If you are building a trailer, fit a suspension rated for a trailer heavier than the actual weight. 
 The balance and dynamic stability of the trailer, loaded or unloaded, is affected by heavy items like spare wheels, which should be up front when possible. 
 The ideal seems to be to have a down load on the tow bar of 10&ndash;15 kg (20&ndash;301b). 
 Anti-snake devices have been proved to be worth while. 
 They work by stiffening the coupling between the trailer and car. 
 Many swinging and jack-knife accidents seem to start on slight downhill gradients, and particularly if the road surface changes or is uneven. 
 Once the swinging has started, there is very little even a skilled driver can do. 
 Slowing down does not help, and generally the driver is not brave enough or quick enough to try accelerating. 
 I learned about trailer driving the hard way during a competition retrieve, when an enthusiastic crew member took us off the road with an Eagle two-seater in the trailer. 
 Both the car and the trailer were badly damaged, but because the glider was securely held in by the fittings, it survived the trailer going over on to its side without damage. 
 As a result of this incident, I am very cautious and rarely drive above 80 k.p.h. (50 m.p.h.) with a loaded trailer. 
 It is a frightening experience, and I have never heard of anyone doing it a second time. 
 With a trailer that you have not towed before, your first priority should be to explore its stability carefully. 
 You can do this by driving on a quiet, wide road with no traffic about, gradually increasing your speed and moving the steering slightly to produce a very slight weave. 
 As the speed is increased, the damping  becomes less and you will be able to decide on a reasonable limit to keep to for the first half hour. 
 By then you will have become tuned in to the driving and will be better able to judge if it is safe to go a little faster. 
 Remember to reduce speed on downhill stretches and to watch in the mirror for traffic which may be about to overtake, and which could therefore set up a swing. 
 Gears must be used more frequently with the extra weight of the loaded trailer, and it is important to change down in plenty of time to prevent having to brake fiercely. 
 The major effects of this will be poor acceleration and a reduction in effective braking. 
 Allow for greater braking distances with a loaded trailer and always use the lower gears going down steep hills. 
 Many trailers are dangerous much above 80 k.p.h. (50 m.p.h.) and it is just not worth taking any chances going much faster. 
 A flat or burst tyre can mean no flying for months! 
 Parking the trailer 
 Simply parking the trailer with the stands firmly down will not prevent really strong winds from doing irreparable damage. 
 Trailers are usually safer if they are parked close together so that they protect each other. 
 However, never park your trailer near one which has poor stands and is liable to swing in a wind. 
 Ideally, every trailer should be anchored by the ball hitch on to a ball mounted in the ground. 
 Alternatively, they need tying down securely at both ends. 
 This should prevent incidents where trailers are blown for hundreds of yards and wrecked. 
 It is worth while designing trailer fittings so that the glider is held firmly in place even if the trailer rolls over. 
 Often, the only cause of damage to the glider is if the wings or fuselage break loose. 
 It is also a good idea to make covers of some kind for the trailer tyres. 
 These tend to rot in the sun and though the treads might be as good as new, they will have to be changed because of the cracks in the walls. 
 Conclusion 
 The main thing to realise with trailer driving is that it only takes one mistake to wreck the trailer and a nice glider, as well as possibly writing off a new car. 
 Clearly, it is important to consider each of the ways in which you can safeguard your equipment because it is no use avoiding all the flying hazards if you are going to write off your glider on the ground. 
 Repairs take time and money to carry out, and if they can be avoided gliding will be less expensive in the future.  
 Cockpit checks 
 There was a time when many gliding instructors scorned the use of a rigid drill, and taught their students instead to check everything logically by going round the cockpit from left to right. 
 The disadvantage of this method is easily demonstrated by asking the students as they finish if they are sure that they have not forgotten something. 
 They will then start all over again and go round the cockpit a second or even a third time. 
 This can easily be avoided if a simple, systematic check is followed. 
 Thus if you go through a drill of vital actions, or check-list each time, you will ensure that you do not forget any item. 
 You can then take off with complete confidence, knowing that you have checked all the really vital things for the flight. 
 However, this confidence is only justified when the check is done systematically and correctly. 
 For example, checking the items in the wrong order is totally unacceptable because it can so easily lead to missing something out altogether. 
 A re-check should never be necessary, since this only implies the acceptance of a half-hearted check in the first place. 
 The idea of having the person attaching the cable ask if the airbrakes are closed and locked has been introduced in some clubs to try and prevent incidents where pilots take off with their airbrakes unlocked. 
 However, if you are going to re-check the airbrakes, it would seem logical to check all the items in the check-list as well. 
 Many instructors are not careful, or thoughtful enough about either their initial teaching or their subsequent monitoring of their students as they do their own cockpit checks. 
 In the UK the pre-take off checks are standardised and remembered by the mnemonic CBSIFTCB. 
 Each letter represents a vital item to be checked, i.e. 
 C-Controls 
 F-Flaps 
 B-Ballast 
 T-Trim 
 S-Straps 
 C-Canopy 
 I-Instruments 
 B-Brakes. 
 Long before going solo the student should have learned the mnemonic by heart. 
 It is a good idea to say the key words aloud every time as you check each item so that it becomes a habit. 
 If you do this when you are solo, you will be less likely to skip an item or become careless about the checks when you are more experienced. 
 It is important for every student to understand the philosophy behind having a rigid drill and the reasons for precise actions such as checking and locking the airbrakes. 
 Without a convincing explanation and an insistence that the checks must be done properly, many students will become careless and slap dash when they are on their own and away from close supervision. 
 All aspects of flying require this combination of understanding and self-discipline, and the vital actions make a good starting point.  
 It is also important to differentiate here between the first flight of the day and subsequent flights. 
 A careless daily inspection after rigging may easily leave the glider with one aileron or the elevator disconnected. 
 The control check is often better done initially before  the vital actions, perhaps even before getting into the cockpit, when the control surfaces can be seen more easily. 
 On the other hand, the check for full and free movement must be done after  strapping in, because it is possible in some aircraft to jam the controls by tightening the straps round a cable or control rod. 
 The importance of the vital actions drill may even be undermined in the eyes of the student if the instructor insists on a complete check of each control movement for every flight (stick to the left, left aileron up, right aileron down, stick to the right, etc.), since it is clear that things like this cannot change between flights, and the majority of experienced pilots only do that check on the first flight of the day. 
 I think that the instructor should treat the first flight on a particular glider as if it was the first flight of the day, and on subsequent flights he should just check for full and free movement and that the surfaces are moving fully. 
 At the same time he should check that he can reach the full rudder and stick movements without undue stretching, and that cushions or other objects are not limiting the movements of the controls. 
 The canopy 
 An incomplete or sloppy check carried out on the canopy can be lethal, because if it comes off it is a matter of luck whether it hits or misses the tail. 
 In addition to checking the canopy lock for security, it is essential to push up on the perspex itself to confirm that the hinges or pins are secure. 
 It has been known for the hinges on a canopy to fail or for poorly designed and faulty catches to fail in flight, resulting in a lost canopy. 
 Most of these expensive incidents might have been avoided by this drill. 
 The airbrakes 
 The method of checking that the airbrakes are correctly locked is all-important. 
 Since the majority of modern machines have airbrakes which are held closed by a geometric lock, it is essential that the method of checking them must be foolproof for this kind of system. 
 First open the brakes or spoilers fully, checking them visually whenever this is possible. 
 Then close them with a firm push on the lever in order to establish the habit. 
 The pilot should be able to feel the geometric lock operating just after the airbrakes are flush with the wing surface. 
 In some cases there is a gate for the lever to go into once the brakes are correctly locked. 
 This operation needs to be explained and demonstrated to every student. 
 It must be understood that unless the geometric lock is felt, either the brakes are not locked, in which case a harder push is needed on the lever, or the locks themselves need adjusting. 
 If it is the latter, the aircraft is unserviceable and must not be flown until the brakes have been re-adjusted. 
 If the basic training is being done on a Falke, or on any other type of glider  fitted with simple spoilers or airbrakes which do not have a lock, the differences must be explained. 
 However, the method of checking should be just the same in order to establish the right habit. 
 The cause of almost every incident where the airbrakes open during the launch is that the pilot has failed to lock them correctly. 
 The amount of force needed to lock them will vary considerably from aircraft to aircraft and even perhaps from day to day. 
 Merely pushing the lever forwards as far as it will go is not enough because the lock may be very stiff. 
 Modern gliders usually have spring-loaded caps which are pulled down firmly to prevent air leaking into or out of the wing. 
 This makes the lock much stiffer to operate than on the earlier types of glider. 
 A geometric lock which requires no force to lock is seriously out of adjustment. 
 It may allow the airbrakes to open during a launch if the lever is knocked or if one side is unlocking a little before the other. 
 However, despite careful instruction, there will still be incidents in which the airbrakes open during a launch. 
 On a wire launch the best hope is for the car or winch driver to build up extra speed to get the glider as high as possible. 
 This gives the glider pilot more time to find out why his glider is semi-stalled and is sinking like a brick. 
 With an aerotow, if the towplane pilot realises that the airbrakes are open, he can signal to the glider pilot by rapid rudder-waggling. 
 In both cases this is a real emergency, because in the event of a cable break the pilot does not have time to realise what is wrong, and he may well stall and spin if he flies by attitude and tries to turn without checking the actual speed. 
 Taking your time 
 Pilots sometimes complain about being rushed through their cockpit drills. 
 Ideally, you need a few minutes to settle comfortably before setting off, but if you have to rush you can usually blame yourself for not getting in before he cable or towplane arrives. 
 Whatever happens, don't rush those vital actions. 
 They take less than 30 seconds to do and they should be left until the last moment before the cable or rope is attached.  
 Swinging and ground looping accidents 
 The pilot's responsibility 
 During the last few years there has been an increase in swinging and ground looping accidents and these must be analysed to see if there are new lessons to be learned. 
 In one instance, a young pilot started a launch with another glider standing only a few yards to the side and just ahead of the take-off point. 
 With a normal take-off the glider would have cleared the obstruction. 
 However, it should have been obvious to the pilot, and to everyone at the launch point, that with either a swing or a wing-drop there would almost certainly be a collision. 
 Unfortunately, the glider did start to take-off, it did drop a wing and swing, and there was a collision. 
 Where there is a slight risk in the event of a swing, a pilot may be said to have made a simple error of judgement or taken an unnecessary risk. 
 However, in the aforementioned case I think we must look further for the factors influencing the pilot. 
 When students are learning to glide, the instructor is not only teaching them the technique of flying a glider, but also how to make decisions and judgements in the air. 
 The final stages of training amount to the handing over of all the responsibility for safety to the student. 
 Ideally, the student should be making all the decisions and choosing actions in the interests of safety and efficiency. 
 By setting the student problems during the final flights before going solo, the instructor can test his ability to think logically and to deal with situations as they arise. 
 An experienced instructor will stop helping the student at this stage and will refuse to comment until after each flight. 
 In this way, the student can gain confidence by knowing that he made the decisions and that they were sensible ones. 
 As he reaches the first solo stage, therefore, the pupil must either achieve a standard of flying which does not leave room for criticism, or he must learn to accept the particular instructor's comments as fair and helpful. 
 In the air, decisions are relatively easy and concern only the student and the instructor. 
 On the ground, however, the situation is not so simple. 
 Even with ground handling someone must take charge, but it may not be the pilot. 
 A young and inexperienced pilot may not feel able to take command of the situation and so prevent a stupid accident or an unnecessary risk being taken. 
 Nevertheless, he should try and take control and tell the other handlers what to do. 
 Inhibiting situations 
 Whereas in the air pilots may make good decisions and behave responsibly, on the ground they may feel that each move is being watched and criticised by the  other members. 
 This will make them less decisive and may inhibit them from giving orders or taking charge of the situation. 
 Since it is quite unusual to need to stop a launch, a shy person would certainly hesitate about shouting out. 
 Many incident and accidents of this nature would be prevented by expert supervision on every flight. 
 However, 100% supervision, even of early solo flying, is impractical for 365 days in the year as there are bound to be moments when the instructor's attention is diverted. 
 The real solution is to train pilots to accept responsibility, whether they are sitting in the aircraft or are merely bystanders at the launch point. 
 The more timid personalities must be encouraged to take charge and to give orders. 
 When there is an opportunity during training for the pilot to decide whether or not a situation is safe, they must be taught to assume that the worst will happen, and then to assess whether there is a risk or not. 
 The rather shy students must be encouraged to shout the launching orders clearly and loudly, so that if they need to shout &bquo;stop&equo;, they do not hesitate because they are reluctant to raise their voice. 
 Normally, the instructor is inclined to emphasise the &bquo;All clear above and behind&equo;, without making the student think consciously about the area ahead. 
 Too often the instructor may allow a take-off when there is an object to one side. 
 This would certainly be hazard in a cross wind and, to an inexperienced pilot, in any wind direction. 
 In these cases the student probably relies on the instructor to make the decision and knows that he is there and can save the situation if things go wrong. 
 It is important to make the student aware of the subtle difference between being safe at all times and being safe in particular conditions. 
 Above all it is vital for every pilot to have the old adage &bquo;safety first&equo; indelibly imprinted on their mind. 
 In other words, if in doubt, don't take a chance. 
 The mature glider pilot would never hesitate to make a fool of himself in the interests of safety. 
 However, it is not just beginners who make mistakes and get caught out. 
 On one occasion a very experienced pilot in a Nimbus 2 was starting on a car launch when it swung off the runway into a K8 which was some distance ahead. 
 There was a very light cross wind from the right which caused a swing in that direction, and as the Nimbus has only a tail-skid, it swung as it started its take-off run. 
 The pilot released the cable but could not keep the glider straight, or stop in time to prevent the collision. 
 The Nimbus was undamaged but the K8 had one wing severed at about half-span as well as other serious damage. 
 Realising that the take-off would involve an element of risk, the Nimbus pilot had, in fact, refused to go at first, and had asked for the K8 to be moved. 
 After it had been moved a short distance away, the pilot was persuaded that the situation was all right and he accepted this, rather than face being unpopular for causing further delay. 
 The accident caused considerable consternation and it became clear, talking to the members present at the launch point, that many pilots did not really understand all the factors which caused the accident. 
 Obviously, the Nimbus pilot was at fault for allowing the other people at the launch point to influence his judgement. 
 Perhaps the most important point is that, regardless of who may be at the launch point, the pilot alone bears the responsibility for accepting or rejecting the launch in the light of the situation as he sees it from the cockpit. 
 If he has the slightest doubt about his ability to launch safely, bearing in mind  such hazards as swinging to one side or a cable break at any stage, then he must refuse the launch. 
 Moreover, if a pilot decides not to launch in a situation like this, he must never be overruled or criticised for playing it safe. 
 Accidents due to swinging on take-off and landing are so common that it is worth studying the causes in detail. 
 The behaviour of some modern gliders during take-offs and landings is very different to most of the training gliders, and it is vital to understand why they are more prone to swinging. 
 Cross wind effects 
 The two main effects of a cross wind on the ground run are well known. 
 The first is that the wind tends to lift the upwind wing-tip and the second is that the glider tends to weathercock into the wind. 
 This applies to every type of aircraft and not just to gliders. 
 Light cross winds, and in particular those with a slight down wind component, create by far the most treacherous conditions for both take-offs and landings. 
 If there is a cross wind, there will be a tendency for the glider to start to swing, while if there is a down wind component on take-off, it will take the glider longer to gain enough speed for the controls to become effective. 
 Prevention is always better than cure. 
 The person holding the wing-tip should always run the down wind wing-tip so that any pull that he may exert is against the weathercocking swing into the wind. 
 He should hold the down wind wing-tip a little above the horizontal and be prepared to run with it, not just balance it and let go. 
 Once again it is up to the pilot to insist that this wing is held and not to accept someone on the upwind wing-tip. 
 The pilot himself can help anticipate the swing into wind by applying full out-of-wind rudder before he starts to roll. 
 As the controls become effective, the amount of rudder will have to be reduced long before full flying speed is reached. 
 A bad swing can easily lead to a serious ground loop or even to cart-wheeling and a broken glider. 
 This can only be avoided by releasing the tow promptly before the situation develops. 
 Always keep your left hand close to the release toggle until you are sure that the glider is stabilised, i.e. in a modern machine until the tail has come up. 
 Strong cross winds 
 Unless the wind is more than about 45&deg; to the direction of take-off, a strong cross wind seldom creates problems. 
 This is because good control is reached at a much lower ground speed. 
 Provided that there is normal acceleration on take-off, the pilot should have good aileron control and be able to stop any swing into the wind by means of the rudder. 
 Of course, there is a definite limit to the strength of cross wind that can be accepted by some machines, particularly those fitted with tail-skids rather than tail-wheels. 
 The main precaution is always to leave plenty of room on both sides of the take-off path to allow for a possible swing. 
 Room must be left on the upwind side in case there is a cable break or premature release, and on the down wind side in case the wing touches and causes a swing that way. 
 If the  wing-tip touches long grass or rough ground, there will certainly be a bad swing and the launch will have to be abandoned. 
 The most serious swings and cart-wheels usually occur when the wind gets under the wing-tip so that the down wind tip scrapes along the ground. 
 A few seconds later, as the glider gains speed, the full aileron suddenly takes effect. 
 If this happens at the same time as the inevitable swing into wind, it can result in a very rapid rolling over on to the into-wind wing-tip. 
 By then the glider may be airborne and a cart-wheel will be unavoidable. 
 This situation can be prevented by being prepared to release immediately if things start to go wrong, or by being ready to stop the wing coming up suddenly. 
 Tow-rope loads 
 On a car or winch launch, the pull of the rope or launching cable exerts very little stabilising effect, but the rapid acceleration usually ensures that enough speed is gained to have good control. 
 A nose hook provides more stability for aerotowing, and it is a slight advantage to start the take-off a little on the upwind side of the towplane. 
 This ensures that there is a sideways pull on the nose, helping to prevent both the glider and the towplane from weathercocking into wind. 
 The poor acceleration of an aerotow makes a swing or a wing-drop more likely. 
 Directional stability 
 In flight 
 In flight, the directional or weathercock stability is maintained by the fin and rudder, which provide extra side area behind the c.g. 
 Thus with the aileron and rudder held in a central position, a glider will always weathercock into line with the relative airflow, just as the wind vane on a church steeple will always swing into the wind. 
 When rudder is applied, the nose of the glider yaws to the side until the force produced by the rudder is balanced by the tendency for the aircraft to swing back into line with the airflow. 
 (In the air this is nothing to do with the actual wind. 
 The aircraft is flying in a mass of air which may be stationary or moving.) 
 If an aircraft is very directionally stable because of a large fin, then the rudder will be less able to produce a large angle of yaw before this balance of forces occurs. 
 With a smaller fin, the directional stability will be weaker, the rudder will be more effective and the angle of yaw will be far greater. 
 On the ground 
 This particular accident, like so many others, would never have happened if just one of the dozen or so people at the launch point had recognised the danger and shouted &bquo;stop&equo;. 
 To say that it was not their business to stop the launch is not good enough. 
 Safety is everybody's business. 
 When a glider is on the ground it does not pivot around its c.g. as it does in  flight. 
 Instead it pivots around the main wheel. 
 If the main wheel is further forward, the glider will have a stronger tendency to weathercock than in the air, and the rudder will be even less effective at preventing this. 
 Conversely, if the main wheel is behind the c.g., the directional stability will be less and the rudder more effective. 
 Most modern gliders have their main wheel well ahead of the c.g. and sit with their tail-skid or tail-wheel firmly on the ground. 
 This wheel position affects the behaviour of the glider once a swing has started. 
 Any swing will be increased by the inertia of the glider because the mass is behind the wheel, trying to move on in a steady direction. 
 In light winds, when the ground speed is much higher, this inertia effect is stronger, and therefore control is relatively poor, making ground looping more likely. 
 This is why the worst risk of swinging and ground looping is always in calm or light wind conditions. 
 In a strong cross wind, the glider will tend to swing into wind, but will then be directionally stable and stop swinging. 
 In lighter winds it will be far easier for the glider to continue the swing, accentuated by the inertia effects. 
 Swings often start by touching down with drift in a cross wind and it is worth remembering that, from the point of view of avoiding a bad swing into wind, it is better to overdo the drift correction. 
 This tends to induce a slight swing out of wind on touchdown, which is useful. 
 Tail-wheels and tail-skids 
 Glider designers sometimes choose to fit a tail-skid rather than a wheel for simplicity and cheapness, saying quite rightly that they offer a little less drag. 
 In addition, they can be made to break off under a large side load and in so doing, perhaps prevent further damage being done to the fuselage. 
 However, a tail-wheel is more convenient for ground handling, particularly as with these types of glider the tail is extremely heavy and awkward to lift when the glider needs turning around on the ground. 
 A swing can only occur if the tail is sliding sideways over the ground. 
 A tail-wheel with a rubber tyre will resist skidding sideways over tarmac, but it will not grip quite so well when it is bouncing over rough grass. 
 On the other hand, a tail-skid will not grip at all on tarmac, but is better on the grass or earth, particularly if it is soft. 
 Any extra load on the tail will help to increase its resistance to moving sideways and so help prevent a serious swing. 
 Some people think that it is useful to hold the stick back during the early part of the ground run, until sufficient speed has been reached to ensure good rudder control. 
 However, it is doubtful whether this really has much effect, because in the tail-down position at such low speeds, the tail cannot develop much, if any, down-load. 
 It may be better just to concentrate on keeping straight, holding the wings level and getting the tail up as soon as possible, to reduce the wing's angle of attack and so improve the aileron power. 
 (See use of flap on take-off on pages 93 and 94.) 
 After landing, the stick should be moved slowly right back to increase the tail load, unless there is good reason to deliberately steer the glider to one side. 
 This helps to prevent the glider from bouncing on any rough ground. 
 With strong winds, the tendency to swing into the wind is far more  pronounced, and after landing the swing cannot always be controlled by full rudder. 
 In very high winds it is usually better to deliberately let the glider swing into wind so that it comes to a stop facing directly into wind. 
 Otherwise, if the wind is squally it may end up with the wrong wing down in a fierce cross wind. 
 Steering on the ground 
 It is vital for every pilot to learn to steer on the ground because it is a completely different technique to turning in the air. 
 Students should be given experience of steering the glider off to one side so that they learn how to use the controls independently instead of co-ordinating them. 
 Otherwise, they will try to stop a swing with the stick and rudder together thus putting the wing-tip onto the ground. 
 Sooner or later students will need to swing, or stop a swing, to avoid a collision on the ground. 
 However, as a matter of principle and good airmanship, at least one full wing-span of clearance should always be left to allow for inadvertent drifting or swinging during landings. 
 This is the absolute minimum, and whenever possible much more room should be left, or an alternative landing area should be chosen. 
 Winch and car launching 
 With winch or car launches, it is essential to consider whether a cable break could result in a part of the cable falling on or near to a glider or anything else in mid-field. 
 Whereas a glider on the upwind side of the launch line may be out of danger, it is not safe to launch until any glider on the down wind side of the cable run has been moved. 
 If such a risk is accepted, sooner or later the cable will break at the wrong moment and an accident will occur. 
 The pilot who takes a chance is always to blame if he creates an unnecessary hazard. 
 Use of the wheel brake 
 Many violent swings and ground loops occur because of heavy braking after landing. 
 If the wheel brake is powerful, the effect of any rapid deceleration increases the inertia effect of the mass being behind the main wheel, and so accentuates any swinging tendency. 
 It also reduces the load on the tail-skid or wheel and makes it slip sideways more easily. 
 Thus hard braking should be avoided,  particularly  if the glider has started to swing. 
 If the glider is running straight, the wheel brake can be applied safely. 
 However, it is best to avoid continuous harsh braking which may just result in locking the wheel and skidding. 
 Intermittent braking is often more effective because it allows the wheel to re-grip between skids. 
 As the glider slows down the braking should be reduced to avoid lifting the tail. 
 Inexperienced pilots sometimes find it difficult to remember, or to work out quickly, the control movements needed to keep straight. 
 But once the wind direction is known, it is easy. 
 The into-wind wing must always be kept down by moving the stick across a little into wind, and it is always necessary to rudder  out of the wind. 
 This applies during any cross wind take-off. 
 It also applies during the landing itself and the ground run, whether the wing-down or crabbing method is being used. 
 As with all flying, anticipation prevents difficulties arising. 
 At the start of the cross wind take-off apply full rudder in anticipation of the swing into wind, and then reduce it as soon as it becomes effective. 
 Get the wing-tip holder to keep the down wind wing-tip high and apply a little aileron to prevent it falling during the first part of the take-off run. 
 Always leave ample room on both sides for swinging or ground looping. 
 Do not land behind or close to another glider or obstruction. 
 If the glider is tipped by a gust it may be difficult, or even impossible, to stop it drifting to one side. 
 Make sure that you correct the drift before touch down and then be prepared to prevent the swing into wind. 
 Remember that if the glider is drifting towards an obstruction this can only be stopped by banking away from it and not by just applying the rudder. 
 Inspections 
 It is almost impossible to judge what loads have gone into the structure during a bad landing, swing or ground loop. 
 Never assume that the glider is undamaged. 
 Get an expert to inspect the whole glider carefully, paying particular attention to the wing-root and fuselage fittings, and the tail and rear fuselage. 
 It is wise to remove the wings and tailplane to inspect the attachment points carefully, and to pay particular attention to the rear fuselage and base of the fin. 
 In a ground loop there are very high inertia forces on the fin and it takes expert knowledge to detect quite serious damage in these areas, particularly with T-tailed types.  
 Winch and car launches 
 Provided that the pilot keeps to the correct procedures, winch and car launches can be very safe. 
 However, they mean that the pilot has to be prepared for a possible launch failure or cable break on every flight. 
 Launch failures account for a very high proportion of gliding accidents, making cable break practice a very important aspect of glider training. 
 Most students have very little difficulty in learning how to make satisfactory launches. 
 However, the critical few moments at the start of the launch are not always fully understood, and often there is an element of luck in getting it right. 
 Instructors can be mistaken about their students' ability to control the initial part properly if one or two launches go well. 
 The critical phase is from the time the glider leaves the ground until it reaches a height of about 400 feet. 
 If there is a problem up to that height, failing to lower the nose and abandon the launch promptly can leave the aircraft in a critical position, semi-stalled and with very little time or height to make a full recovery and a safe landing. 
 Above that height an  abbreviated  circuit should always be possible, although it may not be necessary or desirable in very windy and turbulent conditions. 
 Pilots will tend to try to blame the winch or car driver, or the state of the cable if they have an accident following a cable break. 
 This is quite unreasonable as the pilot should always be in a position to recover and make a normal landing. 
 Cable breaks are a nuisance because they almost always result in having to retrieve the glider from mid-field. 
 However they should not be a worry for a pilot who is well trained, and who keeps in practice and thinks about the conditions before each flight. 
 Cables and wires 
 Single-strand, steel piano wire is often used for car and winch launching. 
 Multi-strand, flexible, steel cable is particularly suited to winching because it does not kink so easily. 
 It is normal practice to use a drogue or parachute to keep the cable under tension after it has been released from the glider. 
 One problem with normal car launching in light winds is that any poor steering on the part of the pilot results in the parachute dropping outside the normal dropping zone. 
 This is largely eliminated with reverse-pulley car launching and winching, where the parachute is pulled in as it drops. 
 Although ropes and &bquo;parafil&equo; (a sheathed form of nylon line) can be used for car launching, they are not generally suitable for winching. 
 The advantage of rope and parafil for car launching is that a drogue or parachute are not absolutely necessary. 
 Whereas the parachute keeps the cable under tension as it drops, if there is a cross wind it tends to drift much more than a rope with no chute. 
 The disadvantage of rope or parafil is that it cannot be retrieved at high speed without the friction overheating and burning the material. 
 Piano wire is less expensive than cable but requires careful handling. 
 If a  break does occur the wire tends to coil up, and it is easy to make the mistake of just tying the broken ends together and towing it straight back to the launch point for the next launch. 
 If a loop in the cable is overlooked, it becomes a small kink and it will fail on the very next launch. 
 Moreover, the strength of the kink is so low that it will often fail when the glider is only just off the ground. 
 With the low acceleration of a car launch, unless the pilot recognises that the cable has broken and lowers the nose very quickly, the glider will stall and land heavily. 
 Special care must always be taken during the climb away if single-strand wire is being used, because there is no sudden jerk or noise if a kink breaks early on the launch. 
 (Stranded cable is expensive and wears quickly when dragged over runways or any other abrasive surface, making it uneconomical to use for car launching.) 
 Weak links 
 Cable which has a large reserve of strength is mostly used so that a weak-link device of some kind safeguards the structure on a fast launch in gusty conditions. 
 It is now common practice to use a series of different strength weak links, and to select one suited to the strength and weight of the glider. 
 For many years all British clubs used 1,000 lb weak links which failed on any two-seater launch where the pilot tried to get the maximum height. 
 Breaking the weak link proved a bigger hazard than actual cable breaks or power failures. 
 With the weak-link strength recommended by the glider manufacturer, breaking the weak link is now comparatively rare and the risks of error have been reduced. 
 However, with fewer breaks pilots tend to take it for granted that they will not get a cable break, and this makes them more vulnerable when one does occur. 
 Launching speeds 
 To prevent overstressing the glider during a launch, the weak link should break if the climb is made too steeply at speeds above the maximum shown on the placard. 
 Below that speed it is impossible to generate sufficient lift to overload the weak link. 
 Nevertheless, above the placard speed a severe gust can raise the loads on the wings and cause damage before the weak link has had time to break and relieve the situation. 
 This means that in rough air it is only safe to pull up hard if the speed is below the maximum launch speed. 
 At other times the exact speed is not critical and the pilot can always reduce the load on the glider by relaxing the backward pressure on the stick. 
 The loads on the structure are lower during the first half of the launch and it is not unusual to exceed the placard speed for a few seconds during the initial steepening of the climb. 
 This is not critical because at this point the winch driver is adjusting the power. 
 Failure to get up into the full climb is the usual cause of serious overspeeding during the first third of the launch. 
 The &bquo;too fast&equo; signal should not be given until the glider is well up into the climb and putting a load onto the cable. 
 Of course, there is a small increase in speed as the climb gets steeper, both because the glider is starting to ascend the  arc of a circle and also because of the effects of the wind gradient. 
 This can be allowed for by the winch or car driver reducing the power slightly. 
 However, this increase in speed must not be relied on if the launch is too slow and the pilot wants more speed, because the cause of a slow launch may be the beginning of a power failure, in which case steepening up in the hope of creating more speed would be dangerous. 
 During a winch launch the potential load on the glider is at a maximum near the top of the launch, when the pull of the cable adds directly to the weight of the glider. 
 Excessive speed at this time can be dangerous in rough air if the pilot is pulling back hard. 
 The take-off 
 If the glider leaves the ground in a very tail-low attitude, with the tail-skid or wheel on the ground, it has the minimum of flying speed. 
 Worse still, if the stick is being held back the aircraft may bounce off the ground into an even more nose-high attitude and at an even lower speed. 
 A loss of power or cable break in these situations leaves the pilot helpless, and a very heavy, stalled landing will be inevitable. 
 In spite of this very real hazard, however, it is not uncommon to see quite experienced pilots leaving the ground with the elevator up, which results in the glider zooming up into a dangerously steep initial climb. 
 To avoid these situations it is important for pilots to be taught the right technique for the take-off run. 
 This involves getting the aircraft into an attitude with the tail-wheel or skid just off the ground. 
 In this position it will not leave the ground until a little more speed is gained. 
 The control movements needed to achieve this vary according to the configuration of the undercarriage. 
 Thus the pilots who are flying several different types of glider, or a glider which is unfamiliar to them, must ask themselves before each flight, &bquo;Do I need the stick forward to lift the tail, or back a little to lift the nose?&equo; 
 With gliders which have a front wheel or main skid, a main wheel just behind the c.g. and a tail-wheel or skid like the K13, Grob 103, ASK21, Puchazc, Schweitzer 233 and most of the older single seaters, it may be necessary to ease back a little during the take-off run to raise the front wheel or skid. 
 A few seconds later as the aircraft gains more speed, it will need more forward movement to prevent it from unsticking with the tail-wheel or skid touching the ground, and climbing away too steeply. 
 When the main wheel is ahead of the c.g. so that the glider is sitting tail-down, a forward movement is needed to raise the tail a little for take-off. 
 The exact movements required will vary depending on the amount of acceleration. 
 A rapid winch launch will tend to pitch the glider back on to the tail, making a larger forward movement necessary to get the tail off the ground and so ensure a margin of speed when the aircraft takes off. 
 With all types of glider, it is wise to hold the stick right forward for the initial part of the ground run, so that there is no possibility of the glider zooming off the ground and into a steep climb if the winch driver applies full power too quickly. 
 However, as soon as it begins to accelerate smoothly, that movement is no longer necessary, and the control should be moved to get the glider balanced nicely on to the main wheel. 
 Care must be taken not to keep the stick  forward for too long, as too much forward movement during the take-off run will prevent the glider from leaving the ground until a much higher speed is reached. 
 It is also undesirable because, if the glider is bounced off by bumpy ground, it will fly back into the ground heavily a few moments later. 
 In very light cross winds there is always the possibility of dropping a wing on to the ground and swinging badly. 
 In these conditions it is vital for the pilot to have a hand close to the release, ready to pull it if the need arises. 
 If the grass is long, touching a wing-tip may result in a serious ground loop. 
 But worse still, if the pilot is able to pick up the dropped wing after the initial swing, because of the acceleration the controls suddenly become effective, and this often results in the other wing touching just as the aircraft becomes airborne. 
 This can cause a cart-wheel and major damage or even injury. 
 Always be ready to release during the take-off run and if in doubt, abandon the take-off. 
 Many gliding clubs use multi-drum winches so that several cables are pulled out at the same time. 
 Unless the cables are well spaced, or the truck driver keeps absolutely straight, there is a risk of two or more cables becoming tangled. 
 Thus when the glider is launched it takes a second cable and parachute up with it. 
 This may cause an abnormally slow launch and the winch driver, seeing the other parachute, may cut the power. 
 However, this should not lead to any particular problem, and it can be dealt with as a normal cable break. 
 Another possibility is the glider swinging and catching the tail-skid under another cable. 
 This is particularly dangerous because the weight and drag of the second cable may make it difficult to get the nose down. 
 Therefore prevention is better than cure. 
 Cables are dangerous, and where there is more than one cable it is important to keep the glider straight and well clear of any other cable. 
 Always be particularly careful to avoid swinging across another cable in a strong cross wind. 
 Initial climb 
 The ideal is to leave the ground balanced on the main wheel, and to hold a constant attitude for the first few feet of the launch while the aircraft gains height and speed. 
 The glider should not be steepened up or levelled out immediately after leaving the ground. 
 After a few seconds the attitude should be allowed to steepen up gradually and smoothly until the full climbing angle is reached. 
 The rate at which the angle is changed must depend on the speed at the time, and this has to be judged because there is insufficient time to check the ASI. 
 If the acceleration is healthy, the change into the climb can be made normally; if the acceleration is slower than normal, then of course the climb must be restricted. 
 At all times the angle of climb and the combination of speed and height must be such that a safe recovery can be made if the launch fails. 
 When the change in angle is made smoothly, the glider will be climbing at a safe angle and will be able to recover if there is a launch failure at any point. 
 Students used to be told that it was dangerous to steepen the climb below 100 feet. 
 This made them hold the glider down and often caused overspeeding or even overrunning of the cable or parachute. 
 Pulling up suddenly at that height puts a sudden, uncontrolled load on the cable and often results in a cable    break. 
 Obviously, it does not suddenly become safe to steepen the climb at a certain height, and it is now recognised that the angle should be progressively steepened. 
 ASK13 on a winch launch 
 With a low-powered winch or tow car, the acceleration is far slower and there is plenty of time to get the glider nicely balanced on the wheel so that it leaves the ground with a safe margin of speed. 
 Again, if the acceleration is poor the climb must not be steepened quickly or it will be impossible to recover in time if the launch fails. 
 The climbing angles for winch or car tow can be similar once the initial climb is over. 
 Controlling the speed 
 There are two completely different systems of speed control on wire launches. 
 Most operations depend entirely on the winch or car driver judging the speeds from the bow in the cable and the way in which the glider is gaining height. 
 Unless the winch or car is very under-powered, pulling up steeper on a fast launch has little or no effect on launching speed. 
 All the pilot can do is to signal if the launch is too fast or abandon the launch if it is to slow. 
 The other system requires a device to measure the load in the cable or to control the maximum pull that the vehicle will provide. 
 In this system the speed is largely controlled by the glider pilot. 
 If the launch is too fast the pilot simply pulls up into a steeper climb. 
 When the driver sees that the load is getting too high, he reduces the power slightly. 
 If the speed is too low, the pilot reduces the climbing angle and the driver, seeing the reduction in load, applies more power. 
 Similarly with the power-limiting device the pilot can control the speed once the optimum power for the type of glider has been set. 
 Obviously, the pilot has to understand which system is being used. 
 Also, there may be confusion if winches and cars fitted with the power-limiting device become common, and launch heights will suffer until both pilots and drivers are familiar with the new system. 
 Healing with a launch failure 
 A failure very close to the ground frequently results in damage. 
 The cause is always one of the following: failing to recognise the loss of power in time; over-reacting and flying into the ground; opening the airbrakes instead of landing ahead with no airbrake. 
 If a cable break occurs just after the glider has left the ground, care must be taken not to overdo the lowering of the nose and fly into the ground. 
 Instead, you should simply level out and land ahead. 
 On no account use the airbrakes unless there is time and height to check the actual speed: usually, you will be flying very slowly, and a heavy landing will occur if the airbrakes are used. 
 With no airbrake the glider will float some distance even at low speed, and it must still be held off for a proper touchdown. 
 Opening the airbrakes at that moment will prevent the glider leaving the ground again. 
 With a cable break close to the ground there is always plenty of room ahead for the landing. 
 If it is a slow launch, any wind gradient will make the situation even more  critical. 
 The speed will then be dangerously low by the time that the nose has been lowered, and even more speed will be lost during the descent through the wind gradient. 
 As a pilot becomes more experienced, there is a real danger of the control movements becoming &bquo;programmed&equo;. 
 If this happens he will change the angle of climb automatically as the glider starts to gain height, and he will continue to pull it higher for a few seconds even if a power failure has occurred. 
 The pilot should always be prepared for an unexpected power failure during this critical stage of the launch. 
 The normal reaction to a launch failure or cable break is to lower the nose and regain speed, and then to pull the release twice, hard, to get rid of any remaining cable. 
 Higher on the launch 
 Higher up on the launch the drill should be: lower the nose into the approach attitude; release the cable; assess if a landing ahead is practical. 
 If the latter is the case the speed should be checked by the ASI and, provided that it is adequate, the airbrakes can be used for a normal approach and landing. 
 Unless the failure has occurred below 50 feet or so, once the speed has been regained it is always best to apply full airbrake first to use up any excess height quickly. 
 The airbrake can then be reduced if necessary for the round-out and landing, provided that there is still plenty of room to do so. 
 This is far better than opening a little airbrake, then some more, and then finally having to use full airbrake for the landing in order to avoid overshooting into the far boundary. 
 It is important to realise that if the glider stops just within the boundary, another few feet of height could have meant a serious overshoot and perhaps a damaged aircraft. 
 Insufficient room to go straight ahead 
 After the initial reaction of lowering the nose and checking the speed, a quick assessment of the situation is necessary. 
 If it is obvious that there is plenty of room to land ahead, that is always the first and best choice. 
 In light winds the situation is far more critical than in windy weather, when it may be possible to land ahead from 500 feet or more, even on a relatively small site. 
 Students and instructors often fail to realise that it is not the amount of height that matters but how much room there is ahead. 
 If there is not enough room to get down straight ahead, obviously a turn has to be made regardless of the height; there is no point in flying on into wind and losing valuable height and space ahead. 
 However, it is vital to check that the speed is adequate before making this turn. 
 A snap decision to turn has been the cause of many serious stalling and spinning accidents, often when, in fact, there was ample room for a landing ahead. 
 During the turn-off, there is time for a reassessment of the height remaining relative to trees and buildings, and a decision has to be made either to continue turning to make a low circuit, or to turn back into wind after using up a little more height (this is known as an S-turn). 
 If, by then, it is  obvious that there is plenty of room to turn back into wind and land, this is the sensible thing to do. 
 If the decision is made to continue with a circuit, use a well-banked turn and monitor the airspeed every few seconds. 
 If there is plenty of height, it may be wise to straighten up and fly down wind a little to allow more room for the landing. 
 Do not try to get all the way back to the launch point unless you have ample height. 
 Remember, if the height is marginal it may be safer to land across the field a little out of wind, rather than try and complete the turn with insufficient height. 
 The direction of the turn 
 On a small site it is important to think about the conditions and to consider what is the best way of turning to make use of a longer run on the airfield, or to avoid having to dodge obstructions. 
 In a cross wind it almost always pays to turn off to the down wind side first. 
 However, if you are correcting for drift with one wing well down, and then the cable breaks, you may find that you have already turned quite a long way, and that it is easier to keep that turn going if you cannot get down ahead. 
 It is seldom possible to land down wind or in the opposite direction to the take-off. 
 This would normally result in overshooting and flying out of the field altogether. 
 Slow launches 
 The optimum speed for a launch depends on both the type of glider and the wind strength. 
 A minimum safe speed for most gliders is the minimum cruising speed, but this is only safe at height, where there is time for recovery if a stall occurs. 
 In windy conditions, the glider will climb higher if the launching speeds are on the slow side, whereas on a calm day the best speed is closer to the limit shown on the placard. 
 Special care is needed if the wings are wet when extra speed is necessary, because the stalling speed is raised. 
 Often, on a small field the most critical situation will be a &bquo;stop-go&equo; launch. 
 This is a slow launch which picks up speed and fades several times, and it is usually caused by a shortage of fuel or mechanical trouble on the winch or car. 
 It is tempting to hang on to the launch, thinking that it will pick up speed, but if you do you may arrive almost over the end of the field with very little height or speed &mdash; an awkward situation. 
 It is best to abandon any really slow launch while there is still plenty of room for a landing ahead. 
 If the glider stalls on the launch it will probably drop a wing and may spin. 
 If the launch seems slow, check the speed every few seconds. 
 Reducing the climbing angle slightly will help the driver to recognise the need for more speed. 
 However, levelling out too much will cause a large amount of slack in the cable and a further loss of speed, often leaving the aircraft in a dangerously nose-high attitude with no pull from the cable to maintain the speed. 
 With a slow launch the pilot must decide if the speed is sufficient to continue climbing. 
 If it is, he should hold the present attitude and stand by to lower the  nose if the speed drops any further. 
 If the launch is much too slow, the nose must be lowered and the launch abandoned immediately. 
 Whereas it is obvious that the launch must be abandoned anywhere near the ground, halfway up the launch it is reasonable to hold on for a few seconds to see if the speed picks up again. 
 A further complication may be that any sideslipping to correct for drift may cause the ASI to under-read so that the speed may have to be judged. 
 If the ASI is reading 20 knots there is an obvious slip error, because that is well below the stalling speed of the glider. 
 Any symptoms of the beginning of a stall, such as buffeting or poor control response, must be dealt with by immediately releasing and lowering the nose. 
 Fast launches 
 Most modern machines have maximum launching speeds of 70 knots or so, making it relatively difficult and unusual for the launch to overspeed. 
 The &bquo;too fast&equo; signal is made by yawing from side to side. 
 If the glider is in a very steep climb this should be reduced slightly before yawing. 
 A common fault is to level out too much, which results in a completely slack cable and makes the winch driver's job of judging the correction quite impossible. 
 In turbulent air the launch should be abandoned if the launching speed becomes really excessive. 
 (Usually this is the pilot's fault for holding the glider down too much during the initial climb, or failing to get right up into the normal angle of climb.) 
 If a decision is made to abandon the launch at height, it is safer to release first and then to lower the nose, as this prevents the risk of the cable parachute opening and flying up over the aircraft. 
 Should the latter ever happen, it is best to land ahead regardless rather than attempt a circuit. 
 The drag of the cable over one wing can make the aircraft uncontrollable in a turn, making a serious crash almost inevitable. 
 Hang-ups 
 Situations where the cable or tow rope cannot be released are now very rare. 
 They are most likely to occur because of a jerk in the cable causing an overrun, with the rope becoming tangled in the main wheel of the glider. 
 The launch should always be stopped if an overrun occurs, and if the launch continues in spite of pulling the release the pilot should make every effort to prevent the glider from leaving the ground by keeping the stick right forward. 
 Because of the automatic override system used on all the winch tow release hooks, this is now an extremely rare cause of accidents. 
 Suggestions on how to deal with a hang-up are covered in my other book Derek Piggott on Gliding  (A &amp; C Black). 
 Pilots are most vulnerable to all of these problems when they are out of practice or when they become blas&eacute; and do not think about the procedures regularly. 
 If pilots are apprehensive about cable breaks it probably means that they are uncertain about what they should do in all situations, and whether they can manage. 
 This is a sure sign that they need more practice. 
 Many pilots quite unwittingly take off with the stick right back, not realising  that if the launch fails when they have just left the ground, an accident will be inevitable. 
 Good supervision can prevent pilots developing careless habits, and students can learn by watching and listening to the instructor's comments about good and bad launches.   
 Gliders lining up for a competition launch 
 Stall and spin-related accidents 
 Although the majority of gliders have extremely docile stalling characteristics and are very reluctant to enter a full spin, most of the more serious accidents in the sport are caused initially by stalling. 
 If the stall occurs above about 500 feet, the accident can be put down to lack of awareness and poor stall and spin recovery training. 
 Where it occurs much lower down a recovery is unlikely, and the accident should be put down either to the failure to maintain a safe airspeed at low altitudes, or to bad planning leading to a situation from which a crash is almost unavoidable. 
 Stalling at low altitudes 
 If the glider is very low and there is not a clear area immediately ahead and below, a stalling type of crash will be inevitable. 
 Even if the pilot is fully aware of being close to the stall, he will instinctively hold off until the glider stalls down the last few feet rather than fly into obstructions at speed. 
 It is easy to realise that in gusty conditions, if the glider is being flown slowly, the stall may occur high enough for a wing to drop and for an incipient spin to develop with even more serious results. 
 Obviously it is very important to train every pilot to recognise when his planning is leading to a disastrous situation, and to take action in time to avoid it. 
 Usually these situations arise from running out of height on the circuit, but they can also arise from arriving back far too high and by badly planned manoeuvring in an attempt to correct that kind of position. 
 Student pilots need plenty of practice at dealing with both these kinds of situation during their basic training if they are to learn to be able to spot them developing. 
 If they can do this, a change of plan at an early stage can usually prevent the situation from developing and leading to an accident. 
 Very often during training, a student will be rather short of height but will just have sufficient for a normal approach. 
 The instructor may have been wondering if the height was going to be sufficient for a normal approach even though the student had already cut out the base leg to make a 180&deg; turn on to finals. 
 The question in this situation is, would the pilot have recognised that this would not have been possible if the aircraft had been 50 feet lower? 
 Would he, in fact, have turned in earlier, or would it have been another near miss or accident in the making? 
 In many training organisations all over the world, student pilots get no training at all with this kind of problem. 
 It is therefore not surprising that incidents and accidents happen when this kind of situation occurs, especially if it is during an early off-field landing when the pilot is under pressure.  
 Undershoots 
 Most undershoot accidents occur because the pilot has not recognised that the glider is critically short of height until it is desperately low. 
 In very open country, the judgement of heights, even down below 200 or 300 feet, is surprisingly difficult. 
 Where there are trees or buildings nearby a direct comparison can be made, and this is a good way of eliminating serious misjudgements. 
 This is an important lesson for every student. 
 Most pilots do not instinctively look across and compare their height with the trees unless they have been taught to do so, and more often than not a pilot will try to judge by angles and positioning alone. 
 Often, the pilot does not even consider what he will do if the glider hits some sink and loses some extra height. 
 This possibility should always be in the mind of the pilot and some reserve of height must be carried all the time. 
 However, too much height often leads to situations where even full airbrake cannot prevent a drastic overshoot. 
 When the glider is desperately low the pilot's handling often goes to pieces, and he may over-rudder in an effort to get round a final turn without touching a wing-tip or turning any steeper. 
 Over-ruddering causes extra drag and an extra loss of height or speed, and it often leads to stalling in the turn. 
 Anticipation 
 The solution to these problems is anticipation, that is preventing them from developing by thinking ahead and taking action early. 
 Many situations where the glider is very low and flying slowly are insoluble quite a time before the accident actually happens. 
 More stalling and spin training will not help to stop this type of accident. 
 Such incidents can only be avoided if the pilot has a more open mind about where he is going to land. 
 For example, if the glider is too low to land conventionally in the normal landing area directly into the wind, it may well be possible to land across wind and behind the normal launching point, so that the low turn can be completed safely. 
 All too often the pilot has a plan in his mind and sticks to it even when it should have become obvious that the situation has changed and his plan is no longer feasible. 
 It is sometimes quite hard for a person to do the unconventional, but that may be the only safe option. 
 However, if the pilot is thinking ahead, that option could have already been considered and he could have had the plan ready for use if more height was lost. 
 Trying to do the normal thing can be the cause of accidents with cable breaks and winch failures on smaller gliding sites. 
 Sometimes the only safe thing to do is to land out of the site altogether in a nearby field. 
 By not considering this as a possibility, the pilot gives himself little or no hope of a safe landing, especially if the alternative is a very low 360&deg; turn and he is already flying rather slowly. 
 Stalling on the actual approach is usually caused by failing to monitor the airspeed regularly, or by failing to react to its indications. 
 There is no point in reading the ASI and knowing that you are too slow unless you lower the nose to correct it. 
 Stalling can also be due to trying to stretch the glide instead of  closing the airbrakes, or stretching the glide after getting into a desperate undershoot position. 
 This is more easily done when landing in an unfamiliar place, particularly if it is in a hilly area and means landing on an uphill slope. 
 If a bad undershoot seems inevitable, again prompt action is needed rather than waiting to see what happens and how far you get. 
 If there is a possible area for a safe landing, use the brakes and get down into it. 
 Remember that it is far better to get down and then to run into obstruction than to stall on to it at flying speed. 
 In a case like this it is often a matter of assessing quickly &bquo;Am I sure that I can reach the field, or if I get more sink will I fail to get there?&equo; 
 If there is any doubt about getting there in the worst circumstances, it is better to get down short in any open space ahead and risk rolling into the hedge. 
 On a windy day with a strong wind gradient, you are quite likely to lose some extra height and speed and low approaches are always very risky. 
 Unintentional stalls at height 
 It is obviously very important for the student pilot to learn to recognise all the symptoms of the stall and to become familiar with them. 
 If they are recognised, there is almost always plenty of time to prevent a stall occurring. 
 However, many inexperienced pilots get so thoroughly engrossed in the thermalling or what is going on elsewhere that they are temporarily &bquo;switched off&equo; to how they are flying. 
 Perhaps the work-load is high at the time, looking at the map and the ground for possible clues as to where they are, looking for signs of possible lift to climb in, together with all the other little worries involved in a field landing. 
 It is often at these times that the glider becomes stalled without the pilot noticing, and then his instincts are bound to be automatic as the nose and wing drops. 
 If you stall accidentally it is almost always because you are not aware of the low speed, etc. and therefore all the training in the world will not prevent you from responding instinctively because you are not at that moment aware that you are stalled. 
 (If you were aware, you would have prevented the stall!) 
 In this situation you are bound to pull back and apply the aileron and rudder to stop the nose and wing from dropping. 
 Hopefully, a few seconds later you will have recognised the situation, taken heed of your training and moved forwards on the stick. 
 Occasionally the stall is recognised by the pilot so that a preventative movement can be made before any serious wing-drop has had time to develop. 
 Accidental stalls seldom happen when the glider is being flown straight, and most result in one wing stalling before the other, causing a wing-drop. 
 Incipient spins 
 Any time that a wing begins to drop at a stall it is the beginning of a possible spin, but the spin can only develop if the wing is kept stalled and the glider is allowed to continue to yaw. 
 In the UK there has been much discussion about teaching stall recoveries with a view to making it all easier for the beginner to understand and  remember. 
 It has been suggested that &bquo;incipient&equo; is an unfamiliar word, that associating the stall with a spin might get the student worried, and that to simplify things we should only talk about stalls and spins. 
 Although it is obviously accurate to call an incipient spin a stall with a wing-drop, I think that this is trying to avoid the issue, which is that it is really the beginning of a spin and at least a potential spin. 
 Recommended recovery 
 The recovery action now being recommended for any stall is to move forwards on the stick to unstall the wings by reducing the angle of attack. 
 A few seconds later the glider is unstalled and can be brought level and back to normal flight with the normal use of the controls. 
 This has the advantage that it does not require the pilot to remember any special movement of the controls other than the movement forward to unstall. 
 Perhaps in an effort to justify this simplification, some instructors have been warning against the use of the rudder to stop the yaw if a wing drops at the stall. 
 They have been inferring that applying the opposite rudder has been the cause of reversing the spin, whereas the real cause of this happening must be the failure to unstall the wings. 
 Use of the rudder 
 Additional yawing caused by the excess use of the rudder in a turn will make the wing-drop much sharper. 
 At the instant of applying the excess rudder, it speeds up the outer wing-tip, creating more lift there, and gives the inner wing &bquo;sweep back&equo; in relation to the airflow, thus increasing the tendency to tip stall on that wing while reducing it on the other. 
 Additional yaw will also occur if the ailerons are used to try to stop the dropping wing because of the extra aileron drag. 
 However, the aileron may well still be effective, and in most gliders applying the aileron to stop the wing dropping at the stall, while not recommended, does not have any noticeable tendency to cause further stalling at the tip. 
 How far the glider rolls over into the beginning of the spin depends to a large extent on the amount of yaw present. 
 Applying the opposite rudder will tend to reduce the yaw and so help even out the stalling of the wings. 
 In fact, the rudder power of most gliders is very poor in relation to the huge inertia of the heavy, long-span wings, and there may not be any visible effect when opposite rudder is applied in an incipient spin. 
 However, it is not true to say that it is dangerous to apply the opposite rudder in an incipient spin. 
 Applying the opposite rudder cannot possibly cause the spin to reverse as is sometimes stated, unless the pilot is keeping the stick right back. 
 The only reason for an incipient or full spin changing direction is if the stick is held right back so that the glider is either kept stalled, or is re-stalled as the rotation stops. 
 If the incipient spin has progressed for more than about half a turn because the pilot has kept the stick back, applying the full opposite rudder must be a good thing because it helps to stop the rotation and to even up the stalling of the  wings. 
 Probably the most effective way of dealing with an incipient spin in practice is to move forwards on the stick, apply the opposite rudder to check the yaw and then to use all the controls normally to bring the aircraft level. 
 This method has been taught for many years and I do not think that pilots who have learned to do it this way need bother to change. 
 New pilots will be taught just to unstall the wings and then to get the wings level using the normal coordination. 
 Of course, unless the pilot is aware that the glider is stalled, he is bound to respond instinctively at first, applying full aileron and rudder to try to stop the rapid wing-drop and pulling right back to try to stop the nose dropping. 
 If the pilot is aware that the glider is stalled, applying the opposite rudder at the same time as moving forwards on the stick should result in some reduction in the yawing movement towards the dropping wing, and therefore must be a good thing. 
 In my experience, the only occasions when I have stalled unexpectedly and known what was happening at the time, have been in very fierce stubble fires and dust devils. 
 In these violent thermals it is possible to be flying with a good margin of speed at one moment and to be falling with virtually no speed the next. 
 In such cases it is easy to make a correct recovery because it is so obvious that the glider is stalled. 
 Unexpected stalls 
 Most unintentional stalls occur, by definition, unexpectedly and usually the first obvious sign of what has happened is that the pilot is banging the stick on the rear stop with the nose still dropping &mdash; a frightening feeling. 
 However, provided that a movement forwards is made to unstall, the possibility of a full spin will have been avoided. 
 The order of movements is relatively unimportant compared to the necessity of making an immediate forward movement to reduce the angle of attack of the wing so that it unstalls. 
 If you imagine suddenly and unexpectedly finding yourself in an almost vertical dive facing the ground, it is easy to understand why so many pilots fail to make a movement forward on the stick to help the glider unstall itself. 
 Below a certain height it may be a hopeless situation, but even where there is enough height for a recovery, you can imagine how hard it is to make that movement forward unless you have practised stalls and incipient spins until the movements are well drilled. 
 Most types of glider are reluctant to enter a full spin unless they are being flown with the c.g. on or very close to the aft limit, that is by light pilots. 
 However, whether it is a full spin or just an incipient one is academic if the glider stalls a few hundred feet up. 
 Problems arise because many pilots do not understand much about spinning. 
 They are often told that gross over-ruddering is needed to spin, but this is not the case. 
 It is possible to spin with the rudder centralised if the glider is one which will spin fully. 
 For example in a 232, Puchacz, or the older Bocian and Eagle, it is usual to be able to get a full spin of several turns without using any rudder. 
 In this case the necessary yawing movement is caused by the high drag of the badly stalled wing. 
 Usually after one or two turns these gliders will unstall themselves and build up speed rapidly in a spiralling dive. 
 Recovery is  simply a matter of relaxing the backward pressure on the stick and using the controls quite normally to bring the wings level and to ease out of the dive. 
 With any recovery from a steep dive, &bquo;ease&equo; is the operative word. 
 If the glider is trimmed for a normal cruising speed, because of the longitudinal stability it will require a forward movement and pressure on the stick to keep it diving at a higher speed. 
 This means that in most cases it is more likely to be a matter of relaxing the forward pressure to allow the aircraft to level out rather than pulling it out with a positive backward pressure on the stick. 
 The stick position 
 The position of the stick in steady flight is a very clear indication of the angle of attack, and having the stick back near the rearmost stop should warn the pilot that he is close to the stalling angle for the wing. 
 If the nose is dropping in spite of pulling back and hitting the back stop, this is a clear indication that the glider is stalled, and a forward movement is needed for a few seconds to let the wing unstall. 
 In most unintentional stalls, the stick position on the back stop will be the first symptom to be recognised. 
 However, although the stick position and the total lack of response to the elevator are by far the most important symptoms of the actual stall, many instructors hardly mention it. 
 By this stage of a stall, very often the noise of the airflow will have increased because of the yawing movement, and most of the other symptoms will either be absent or will go unnoticed in the moments of panic. 
 The fact that the glider is not responding normally must cause alarm to any pilot until the cause is identified. 
 If the glider is stalled and enters a spin at height, the inability to recover must be due a lack of spin recovery training. 
 With insufficient experience, the pilot is likely to be slow to recognise the spin and slow to react. 
 Moreover, because it occurs unexpectedly it may well cause a temporary panic. 
 Clearly while we do have gliders that spin, it is vital to give pilots enough experience to recognise what is happening and to make the right moves instead of panicking and doing nothing. 
 The effects of rain on the stall 
 Many pilots are unaware of the significance of dirty wing surfaces and of rain or drizzle on both the performance and the stalling characteristics of gliders. 
 Tests show that on most high performance machines, a spread of splattered flies on the leading edges can account for up to a quarter of the glider's performance, reducing a glide ratio of 40:1 to less than 35:1 and making a mockery of glide calculations. 
 This is so serious that for world championship flying, many gliders are now fitted with a means of cleaning off the leading edges of the wings in flight. 
 In light rain I have measured an increase of about 8 knots in the speed for the pre-stall buffet and stall of a K13, although the stall itself did not seem to have changed in character. 
 However, some gliders do have a definite change in both speed and characteristics. 
 For example, with wet wings the Falke motor  gliders, the Bergfalke and the Spatz all become viscous at the stall and will flick over if they are stalled during turns. 
 A pilot taking off in rain on a winch or car launch is at risk with any type of glider unless the launch is faster than normal. 
 It is not unknown for gliders to stall and drop a wing badly on a slow launch, and the behaviour of most gliders in the rain may be far worse than in normal flight. 
 The combination of the poor visibility, together with the misting up of the canopy and the effects of the rain on the stall, make launching in rain foolhardy and almost always pointless from the point of view of achieving a soaring flight. 
 However, it is not unusual to see pilots take off towards a heavy rain shower on a good soaring day instead of waiting until it has passed. 
 Usually this is because they got ready before the rain started falling and are unable to see that they are not going to stay up unless they wait until the shower has passed. 
 Inevitably they come straight down in a few minutes looking rather sheepish! 
 It is as though they are unable to change their minds and this is a very dangerous trait in a glider pilot. 
 Really heavy rain can be disastrous. 
 Even in a car the wipers do not clear the windscreen in torrential rain. 
 Snow looks less  innocuous  but is even worse than rain because it blots out visibility more. 
 Flying in even light snow is like being in a fog, and unless you are up high and can manage to fly clear on instruments, you are liable to have real trouble. 
 More about spin recovery 
 The standard method of recovery must be taught because it has been proven to be effective during testing. 
 It involves applying full opposite rudder and then, with the ailerons central, moving the stick steadily or progressively forwards until the spin stops. 
 Finally, the pilot centralises the rudder and eases out of the dive. 
 (To reduce the risk of over-speeding with modern machines, the airbrakes can be opened fully at any time during the spin or the recovery.) 
 If every type of glider required a different recovery there would be the risk of a pilot using the wrong method for the type of aircraft. 
 All gliders and light aircraft have to recover satisfactorily with the standard method. 
 This is not to say that other methods would not work, but it is unwise to use non-standard methods for recovery from a fully developed spin, even if they appear to work better. 
 In the standard recovery, the full opposite rudder is always applied first, and if it does slow down the rotation, the nose of the glider will automatically drop, helping to unstall the wings. 
 In this way the rudder is a very powerful influence on the spin recovery because it helps the pitching movement and also slows the rotation. 
 (The full opposite rudder must never be taken off if the aircraft is reluctant to recover, because any additional yaw would further flatten the spin.) 
 Blanketing 
 Before the days of T-tails, there was a possibility of the downward movement  of the elevator causing some blanketing of the rudder and reducing its effectiveness. 
 This is another reason for standardising the rudder movement first, but it is not relevant to gliders with T-tails where no rudder blanketing can occur. 
 Modes of spinning 
 A more important reason not to experiment is to avoid the possibility of getting the glider into an untested mode of spin from which it might be difficult or impossible to recover. 
 It is possible for an aircraft to have several different modes of spinning, and all of them may not have been discovered during the testing. 
 Using the ailerons during the recovery, for example, may be the means of entering one of these other modes of spin. 
 It is not always realised how little spinning is carried out during the test flying of a new type of glider. 
 Entries are made with every different kind of control input: full in-spin aileron, full out-spin aileron, airbrakes in and out, c.g. forward and c.g. aft, etc., using the standard method of recovery to stop the spin. 
 Finally, to check the recovery from the stabilised spin, the glider is held in the spin for a full five turns if that is possible. 
 The authorities do not require other methods of recovery to be tested, and it is therefore not always possible to be sure whether using the aileron, for instance, will flatten the spin and make it more difficult to stop. 
 In the past there have been a number of problems with spin recoveries with light aircraft. 
 Some have been due to the aircraft getting into a new mode of spin, but others have been due to poor recovery techniques. 
 Often the instructor or pilot knows the correct recovery and thinks that he is using it, but because of the unusual forces on the controls, he is failing to apply the full recovery action. 
 This used to happen on both the Chipmunk and the Tomahawk where the elevator control loads become much heavier during the spin and where a half-hearted movement forward on the stick may be insufficient to stop the spin. 
 The position of the c.g. 
 With any type of aircraft the characteristics of a spin vary according to the loading, so that the spin becomes flatter as the c.g. is moved back. 
 This will also affect how far the stick has to be moved forwards to effect a recovery. 
 This depends mainly on how deeply the wing is stalled. 
 It is therefore important to teach and always to think of the stick movement as being a progressive forward movement made until the spin stops. 
 The effect of the rudder 
 In many gliders the spin may stop as soon as the full opposite rudder is applied. 
 In others the stick will have to move quite a long way forwards before the wing unstalls and the spin stops. 
 Where this is the case, the full opposite rudder may  not even appear to change the spin, and the spin will continue until the movement forward is sufficient. 
 Because each spin may be slightly different, it is important not to try to guess how far to move forwards. 
 Always make a progressive, steady movement forwards until the spin stops. 
 If the spin is unexpected, it may even be difficult to tell in which direction it is going. 
 If you have spun out of cloud, the turn needle always shows the direction of the spin. 
 Usually, but not always, the ball of the slip indicator is out the other way. 
 Control loads 
 In most gliders the rudder will have overbalanced and moved hard over in the direction of the spin. 
 So if you are in doubt about the direction of the spin, push against the overbalancing load and reverse the rudder. 
 One very deceptive thing about the control loads is the effect of the airflow at very large angles of attack and with the yawing and rolling movements during a spin. 
 The rudder will certainly be overbalanced and it will require far more force to apply the full opposite rudder than at any other time in flight. 
 The airflow over the ailerons often tends to move the stick towards the direction of the spin and they should be centralised for the recovery. 
 In addition, the elevator may overbalance so that the force needed to move forwards on the stick is abnormally high. 
 Do not mistake stick pressures for stick movement. 
 The stick must be moved forwards to make the recovery. 
 Training problems 
 In many training gliders it is difficult to demonstrate spinning and the spin may stop when the full opposite rudder is applied. 
 If this happens, it is important to move the stick forwards sufficiently to ensure that the glider does not re-stall. 
 When a glider recovers so easily, a rapid movement forward on the stick often results in a very steep recovery and a high speed dive. 
 After doing this several times in a two-seater during training, the student may find both that applying full opposite rudder will stop the spin and that the glider does not in fact re-stall again even if the stick is kept back. 
 (Sometimes a little of the pre-stall buffet can be felt but the glider levels out all right.) 
 If this is allowed to go unnoticed because the glider stops spinning each time, it will encourage the habit of keeping the stick back. 
 This will, in turn, guarantee a delayed recovery, or no recovery at all, on a glider which requires a more positive recovery action. 
 If the spin stops when the full opposite rudder is applied, the stick must  be moved forwards to allow normal flight. 
 Failure to do this is the only reason for a reversal of the spin from one direction to another. 
 Incidentally, if an aircraft is very difficult to get into a spin, it also may be very difficult to recover. 
 It is not unknown for so-called &bquo;unspinnable&equo; aircraft to come to grief by getting into a stable spin.  
 Light stick forces 
 It is very important to watch for any tendency to use a jerky forward movement on the stick during the full recovery. 
 This is often a sign of nervousness and usually means that more spin training is needed. 
 The following incident with an experienced pilot on a K6E drew attention to the importance of making smooth stick movements. 
 This particular pilot was an instructor who was in good practice in a K13 two-seater but out of practice in his K6E. 
 The E-model, unlike the K6CR, has an all-moving stabiliser with no tabs to provide feel. 
 Without the spring trimming there would be no pressure required to change speeds or to pull out of dives, and the controls would be very light indeed. 
 Since the force exerted by the spring is the same at both low and high speeds, this makes it feel rather twitchy, and it is not difficult to overstress the aircraft at high speeds. 
 In this case the spin itself was quite normal, and after a few turns the pilot initiated the recovery by applying the full opposite rudder and then moving the stick forwards. 
 However, with the negligible stick forces of the K6E, he must have rather overdone forward movement. 
 He stopped the spin but pitched the nose down rather violently. 
 At this point, his head hit the canopy and dislodged his glasses. 
 What occurred next is somewhat uncertain. 
 He was unaware of any high &bquo;g&equo; or, indeed, of anything at all, until he found himself regaining consciousness in a near vertical climb, about to tail slide. 
 After landing, the aircraft was found to have split fabric and extensive minor damage to the wings, which could only be attributed to overstressing at high speed. 
 He was lucky not to lose the wings altogether! 
 Avoid abrupt movements 
 Subsequent checks with this K6E pilot showed that during spin recoveries in the K13 his elevator movements were rather abrupt and uncontrolled. 
 In fact he found it very difficult not to jerk the stick forwards for recoveries. 
 Since most of these control movements are semi-automatic and largely preprogrammed, it is almost certain that this was the initial cause of his reaching such a high speed. 
 Instructors should therefore insist that the movements of the stick must be a controlled, progressive movement rather than a rapid, uncontrolled push or jerk. 
 They should also use the term &bquo;ease&equo; the glider out of the dive rather than &bquo;pull&equo; it out. 
 There have been several cases of two-seaters being overstressed by pilots pulling back hard to recover from steep dives after spin recoveries. 
 Piecing together the evidence from the incident with the K6E pilot, it seems almost certain that the pilot blacked out during the recovery. 
 Susceptibility to high &bquo;g&equo; is greatly affected by the duration of the loading, and whereas most people can cope with 3 to 4 g for a few seconds, a sustained loading of that amount may cause loss of vision. 
 In this case the pilot had possibly pulled about 5 g for 4 or 5 seconds. 
 Much also depends on the seating positions and whether the pilot is expecting the extra &bquo;g&equo; and prepares for it by tensing himself up. 
 For example, when sitting relaxed in a T21b, I have been nearly blacked out by a student during a tight loop. 
 The details are unimportant but the lessons are clear. 
 Extreme care is always  needed when flying at high speeds with gliders fitted with an all-moving stabiliser and spring trimming, particularly when recovering from extreme attitudes. 
 The elevator loads remain almost constant at all speeds and are so low that any jerky movement may result in very high &bquo;g&equo; loadings. 
 Fortunately, glider designers seem to have given up all-moving stabilisers in favour of a fixed tailplane and normal elevator. 
 As a result, most of the new breed of gliders are more pleasant and safer to fly. 
 Interesting demonstrations to try 
 The following are several interesting demonstrations and experiments to try out on your own gliders, or to show to students. 
 The effects of slight slip or skid on stalls in turns 
 If a student has a habit of over-ruddering in turns, it is often worth showing him the effect on the stall of using even a slight amount of extra rudder in a gentle turn. 
 Most pilots have been shown the effect of gross over-ruddering during their basic training. 
 The following demonstration compares a stall with a little too much rudder to a stall in a slightly slipping turn, and shows how even slightly too much rudder has a significant effect at the stall. 
 Start to circle in a normal turn with about 20&deg; of bank, keeping the yaw string exactly  in the middle while you reduce speed very gradually. 
 (On most types of training glider it will be possible to get down to the pre-stall buffet and continue with either a slight rocking of the wings or a very gentle inner wingdrop.) 
 Keep the rudder where it is and allow the speed to increase a few knots so that both you and the student can observe the exact position of the rudder pedals. 
 Most types of glider should be showing a very small amount of rudder being held on into the turn. 
 Next, watching the rudder pedals, increase the amount of rudder by a movement of about one inch forward on the rudder pedal and try again to reduce the speed. 
 Note how this time the glider has a very pronounced inner wing-drop at the stall and tries to spin. 
 After getting back into the accurate turn as before, apply a very small amount of opposite rudder to create a slightly slipping turn and try the stall again. 
 This time the glider will be totally innocuous. 
 This demonstration shows how even very small amounts of extra rudder in a turn cause a bad wing drop, whereas using too little is a safer fault because it inhibits the stalling characteristics. 
 The ideal, of course, is the accurate turn with the yaw string central or, as some pilots say, showing a very slight slipping movement (because the cockpit is ahead of the c.g.). 
 To emphasise the stick forward movement 
 This demonstration is intended to counteract the tendency for pilots trained on very docile gliders to remember the full opposite rudder but to forget the stick movement. 
 In this case the instructor brings the aircraft to a stall and applies full rudder  as if he is going to spin. 
 As the wing drops and the spin starts, he move forwards on the stick, leaving the rudder applied. 
 The wing unstalls immediately and prevents the spin from developing. 
 (After a few seconds the rudder must be recentralised to avoid getting to high speeds with full rudder applied.) 
 This shows conclusively that any movement forward will prevent a spin developing even if the rudder is forgotten altogether. 
 The stall is approached once again but this time in a very slight turn and, if necessary, with a very small amount of extra rudder &mdash; just enough to make the wing drop. 
 Keeping the rudder still and pulling right back on the stick sharply as the stall occurs, should make the wing drop. 
 This time the stick is held firmly back with the aileron central, and the wing will (usually) continue dropping so that the glider spins for a turn or so. 
 A normal recovery is then made. 
 If height permits, I then like to make a series of stalls using large amounts of rudder and handing over control for a quick recovery, moving the stick forward and using normal stick and rudder together to bring the wings level. 
 The point about these last two demonstrations is that they emphasise that spinning depends on stalling and keeping the aircraft stalled. 
 Any forward movement will prevent a spin from developing, whereas failure to move forwards can result either in the spin continuing or, if the opposite rudder has been applied, in the direction of the spin suddenly reversing. 
 These demonstrations serve to emphasise the importance of moving forwards every time the glider is stalled. 
 But although they work well in the older types of glider, they are not practical with the modern machines which have a very docile stall and which will not drop a wing at the stall without gross over-ruddering. 
 Most of the other simulations of accidental stalling involve almost unrealistic handling of the aircraft, and are therefore not very convincing, although they may result in a rather more violent wing-drop. 
 Conclusion 
 There is no doubt that many of the serious stall/spin accidents are caused by poor planning which leads to situations involving difficult manoeuvring near the ground, putting the pilots under stress so that they make mistakes or fly badly enough to stall and spin in. 
 Careful instruction and constant practice is needed if the stall and spin accidents are to be prevented altogether. 
 It is important to be able to recognise all the symptoms of the approach of a stall in order to be able to prevent it. 
 It must be emphasised that to prevent or to stop a spin the wings must be unstalled by means of a forward movement. 
 Unstalling the wings takes away the cause of the autorotation and then the wings can be brought level using the stick and rudder normally. 
 In most cases with either incipient or full spins, any movement forward, or even just relaxing the backward movement of the stick, would prevent or stop the spin immediately. 
 The most important thing to emphasise is that, regardless of the attitude of the glider, if it is not responding to moving back on the stick or if the stick is hitting the back stop, a forward movement must be made to allow the glider to unstall.  
 Advice on making field landings 
 Flying cross-country 
 With all the airspace restrictions in operation it is most important to keep track of your location so that the glider does not inadvertently stray into controlled airspace or other restricted areas. 
 This is particularly true for early attempts at flying cross-country, where it is vital to use a priority system for concentrating on the important aspects of the flying. 
 Flying above 1,500 or 2,000 feet on a reasonable day, you should concentrate mainly on climbing efficiently, selecting the next good clouds, and checking and confirming your position and progress on the map between  thermals . 
 Below 1,500 feet, the maps should be ignored and priority should be given to checking for suitable fields below while also searching for lift, re-checking on the local wind direction and moving towards a better area of fields if necessary. 
 At about 1,000 feet you should put away the maps, select a good field and check it for slopes and surface etc. 
 Use any area of lift but do not drift away from the chosen field. 
 Keep re-checking the field and reselect if a better one becomes apparent. 
 Move away to avoid flying directly over the field, but keep it within easy reach all the time. 
 At about 800 feet AGL, re-check your position to the side of the field, recheck for obstructions, choose the &bquo;turn in&equo; position and prepare for landing. 
 Consider the effects of the wind. 
 Will there be bad turbulence from obstructions upwind of the field? 
 Is it an uphill slope and how much extra speed is necessary? 
 At this point it is a good idea to say out loud to yourself, &bquo;Now I am going to land&equo;, and from then on not to change your mind. 
 Many field landing accidents occur because the initial decision to choose a field is left far too late. 
 Often the pilot is lost and has been worrying for the past half an hour about where he is. 
 Then he gets low and is already in a state of anxiety which tends to make him make poor judgements. 
 If you are getting low, you should forget all your other problems and concentrate on selecting a good field first. 
 Then try to use any lift nearby, keeping within easy reach of the field and in a position from which it is easy to drop on to the circuit. 
 The lower the choice of field is made, the fewer fields are within reach and the less time there is to decide which one is best. 
 By the time that the glider is down to 500 feet or so, an inexperienced pilot often will have forgotten the wind direction, and if he realises this it will increase his anxiety. 
 Finally, below a few hundred feet, if no definite field has been chosen there can be little or no choice, and an accident is almost certain to happen. 
 Often the pilot is in such a state of panic that the flying becomes dangerously inaccurate. 
 This kind of accident is relatively common with inexperienced pilots, especially when they are flying in competitions. 
 The final glide back to the base airfield at the end of the day is a particularly stressful time. 
 Usually it is at the end of a long day's racing, with a number of stressful periods all adding to the   pilot's fatigue. 
 Perhaps the glider is theoretically just within range for a straight glide home, but has very little extra height in hand and not much prospect of getting another climb. 
 At 1,000 feet the pilot may be some distance from his base when some extra height is lost because of strong sink. 
 He badly wants to complete the task and continues hoping to pick up more lift on the way. 
 More sink puts him well below the intended glide path, but instead of making the decision to choose a field and look around near it for more lift, he glides on. 
 Eventually he finds himself at 500 feet, unable to see a good field ahead, unable to remember the wind direction, and trying to select a field with very little choice. 
 Bergfalke 11 landing at Ein Shemer, Israel 
 Even worse off is the pilot who still believes he will make it and takes no action until he arrives on the ground or in a hedge. 
 When you are tired out and upset with yourself for not having taken that extra piece of lift some miles back, there can be a tendency to become apathetic and not even try to prevent an accident. 
 It is as though you are drugged and have ceased to care. 
 This is one of the effects of lack of oxygen, but also of dehydration at the end of a long day's excitement. 
 It can be overcome if you recognise that you are tired and getting complacent, but the onset is very gradual and often you do not recognise that anything is wrong. 
 If you give yourself a shake, change your seating position slightly, open the clear vision panel for some fresh air, change hands on the stick for a few moments and have a sweet or drink, you can snap out of it and start to work normally again.  
 Think about the problems 
 A surprising number of inexperienced pilots haven't really thought about how they would tackle having to land in a field. 
 Since they don't have problems landing on their gliding site, they don't see why there should be any particular problem landing elsewhere. 
 They can be the quiet, but unthinking types who are simply unaware of their lack of knowledge. 
 They probably have never even considered that they could have an accident and damage the glider. 
 So, the idea that they need some training to do it safely just doesn't occur to them. 
 With many aspects of flying, we need to have reached a certain stage or standard to be able to appreciate the problems, or to understand and take in the facts. 
 There is often a tendency for pilots to think that, because they are solo and have managed a few soaring flights and their Bronze C, they should be allowed to go cross-country. 
 What is seldom realised, until a first cross-country, is the vast increase in mental workload involved when soaring, map reading, field landings and flying have to be thought of, instead of just how to stay up. 
 Many incidents and accidents are caused by lack of experience and the pilot unwittingly putting himself into situations beyond his capabilities. 
 For example, it is important for an inexperienced solo pilot to avoid a field landing until he has had some training in how to tackle one. 
 Hundreds of landings on one particular airfield or gliding site do not provide good training for landing in fields. 
 Unfortunately, being familiar with an approach takes away much of the need for real judgement. 
 Pilots, and even instructors, often believe that they have good judgement and can land accurately anywhere because they can manage on their own site. 
 However, even if it is a small field, all they have really learned is to position themselves by habit, using the local landmarks to help. 
 The really valuable experience comes from landing in many different, unfamiliar places, whether they are fields or large aerodromes. 
 Unintentional out landings 
 Throughout the training, landing out is usually treated as such a serious  misdemeanour  that the inexperienced pilot is often influenced into trying desperately hard to get back if he either inadvertently drifts away from the site or gets lost during a local soaring flight. 
 On an early solo some pilots do get rather far from the field, which causes their instructors to become apprehensive for their safety. 
 The inexperienced pilots often try to soar in unusable lift, and they concentrate so hard that they don't recognise that they are drifting away and are not going to get back to the field. 
 Then they may fail to make any choice of field or plan of action until it is too late. 
 If the fields below happen to be large, they may get down safely, but a safe landing is often due to luck rather than to good judgement. 
 After the pilot's personal safety, the safety of the aircraft must be the next most important consideration; it is always safer to land out than to risk trying to get back with marginal height. 
 Forget about embarrassment: a landing out  has to be made if there is any doubt about getting back. 
 If an inexperienced pilot finds himself in a situation where a field landing seems necessary, he should make the decision to choose a field and plan the landing properly, while there is height and time to spare. 
 This is not the time to be thinking about what the chief instructor is going to think or say. 
 Worrying about people's comments instead of keeping calm and concentrating on the flying and on getting down safely is often the root cause of a bad landing. 
 There is really very little excuse for the student wandering out of reach of the field if he has been taught well in the first place. 
 However, during training, decisions such as when to leave the lift and start to get back to the field are too often taken by the instructor. 
 If this happens, the student may not form the habit of checking the situation after every turn and of making his own decision about when to turn back. 
 Hints on choosing fields 
 Obviously if you are flying over a bad area, with very few good sized fields, it is necessary to divert towards the best area within range and to start looking seriously for a field at several thousand feet. 
 Where the countryside is more hospitable, this can be left to a thousand feet or so. 
 Of course, turning downwind will increase the range and the choice of the fields, and it also makes joining a regular circuit very much easier. 
 Choosing a field some distance upwind on the other hand, is not such a good idea. 
 By the time that you have battled against the wind to get there, you may find that it has some hazard that you could not see from a distance, and then there may be no other good field within reach. 
 Do not waste valuable height trying to fathom out how to get down in an unsuitable field. 
 Discard it if it has awkward wires or some other hazard on the approach, and choose another field. 
 Time spent puzzling how to avoid these problems is time wasted which you could use for looking around more. 
 If you cannot see a suitable field, don't be afraid to make a well banked circle to look right round the whole area. 
 Looking further out you will probably be able to see dozens of fields and also the lie of the land and the main slopes. 
 Disregard any fields which would entail landing on a downhill slope. 
 Landing down wind is a silly thing to do. 
 Unless you do it every day at your particular gliding site, you are certain to misjudge such a landing, besides having the hazards of the higher touchdown speeds and loss of control during the ground run to contend with. 
 Don't look at the fields immediately below, because the slopes cannot be seen from directly above. 
 You can only see three of four fields and if they all look bad your morale will suffer. 
 Positioning 
 Once you have selected a possible field, move towards it, checking its size, slope and colour, and look out for possible wires on the approach. 
 Don't fly over it unless you have more than enough height to allow you to reposition yourself well to the side again. 
 Being directly overhead, the field is one of the  worst positions from which to extricate yourself because you have to fly blind, away from the field, for quite a long time to get out to the side for a reasonable base leg. 
 Try putting yourself at five or six hundred feet directly over the landing area of your gliding site and see for yourself how difficult it is to plan and make a spot landing. 
 Be careful that you do not continue to reject fields at the same time as getting lower and lower until it is too late either to have any selection or to achieve a good approach. 
 If there really are no suitable fields within range, then you have left the choice far too late and you must choose the best you can. 
 It will be a matter of making a good landing directly into wind, if that is possible, and of hoping for a minimum of damage to the glider. 
 Formal circuits 
 You do not need a complete conventional circuit with a long downwind leg, although this will obviously give you more time in which to have a better look at the field. 
 But whatever happens, you must get into a good position for the start of the base leg. 
 Unless you have a great deal of spare height, do not try to fly right round the field. 
 Experience shows that people often run themselves short of height on the way right round. 
 Instead, they could have stayed on the side they were flying and made a right, instead of a left circuit, with height to spare. 
 The positioning is made easier by imagining your field to be the normal landing area on your home site and by using the same angle for the positioning. 
 Since it is usual in training to make circuit patterns from 800 feet or so, inexperienced pilots are often seriously put out if they find themselves unable to do this on a field landing. 
 Instead of accepting that their normal circuit is not possible and organising an alternative, they may try to make their formal pattern and so run themselves into an even more difficult situation. 
 Alternatively, they may continue to worry about their initial error of judgement instead of making a revised plan of action to get into a good position for the base leg and approach. 
 Positioning the final turn 
 It is surprisingly easy to make the circuit and base leg far too close to the field, particularly if the surrounding countryside is rough and unlandable. 
 After you have selected the field, it is a good policy to choose the approximate position to complete the final turn and to start the approach. 
 With average British fields, this needs to be at least one field length back from the boundary. 
 This is slightly more than the distance that most pilots would like for a spot landing at the gliding site because you need a little more time for the approach in a strange place. 
 Obviously, if the fields are small, two lengths might be needed. 
 Then, provided you are not running short of height, the final turn must not be any closer than your chosen point. 
 This system helps to prevent you from getting too close for a normal approach. 
 Only come closer if you are anxious, because the base leg is going to be rather low.  
 The base leg 
 The secret is to have sufficient height and to get the angle to the field about right before turning onto the base leg. 
 If the angle is too steep, and you arrive too close, it will mean having a very short base leg and no time for adjustments by moving in or out and using the airbrakes. 
 By the time that you turn onto the base leg you need your chosen speed and the airbrakes unlocked ready for use. 
 Unless you are in the habit of using the airbrakes on the base leg, you will tend to hesitate about using them and will end up too high. 
 With every approach, try to get into the habit of thinking ahead about the height of he final turn and to become familiar with the idea of using the airbrakes to bring you down so that the final turn is not too high. 
 Experience shows that even after doing this, pilots tend to overshoot through being rather too high. 
 This is because it is much more difficult to recognise being too high than being a little on the low side. 
 For this reason I always emphasise that if, as you complete the final turn, you are happy that you have got the field &bquo;made&equo;, you should always open full airbrake for a few moments to check that you would undershoot with that setting. 
 The airbrakes can then be reduced once it is clear that the glider will not overshoot with full airbrake. 
 If full airbrakes are needed for more than a few seconds, and it looks as though they should be kept on, sideslipping should be used to get rid of the excess height so that for the last part of the approach less than full airbrake approach is required. 
 A full airbrake approach is a potential overshoot if the glider flies through any lift. 
 S-turns 
 If it becomes obvious during the base leg or final turn that you are far too high to be able to get down in the chosen field, it is often possible to make an S-turn to use up some of the height. 
 However, effective S-turns are not easy to do, and they need to be practised if they are not to end up in dangerously steep turns or in bringing the final turn too close to the field. 
 Often they cannot be practised on the home site because they are not acceptable on a busy airfield. 
 However, they can be demonstrated and tried at height to get the idea and to see the problems which can arise if they are not neatly executed. 
 They are a sign of poor planning and of not thinking sufficiently far ahead, but they can be useful as an option, just as sideslipping is an extra skill which can prevent a serious overshoot and a broken glider. 
 Beware of &bquo;suckers&equo; gaps 
 Be very cautious about approaching through a gap in a row of trees. 
 If trees are alongside a road they are likely to conceal telephone or power wires, making it dangerous to go between them. 
 Look carefully for single wires leading off the main lines and running across the fields to individual cottages. 
 Unless you can spot all the poles, single wires will be very difficult to see. 
 In Australia single wires are called SWER (Single Wire, Earth Return) lines. 
  They comprise a single wire strung across from the main power wires to the farms or homesteads. 
 They are often hung between trees or old posts a long way apart, and they are extremely difficult to see. 
 The only real clue to spotting them is that every homestead has electricity and if you see the buildings, you must find the wires going to them before making an approach. 
 I was amazed to discover that pilots sometimes forget the large wing-span of their glider and risk touching a wing-tip on one side when flying through a gap. 
 It seems as though the pilot is only worrying about his cockpit getting through and forgets the wings. 
 Experience in many hundreds of practise field selections and approaches in a motor glider show the most common faults to be: leaving the choice of field far too late, and poor planning and judgement of the circuit and approach. 
 Practising in a motor glider with a knowledgeable and competent cross-country pilot is the best way to gain experience quickly at both selecting and field landing procedures. 
 There is no substitute for this kind of training. 
 Summary 
 The following are some of the most common errors, together with suggestions on how a pilot can avoid them and what an instructor can do to help. 
 Failure to accept that a field landing is necessary 
 Be realistic about the chances of finding lift low down. 
 Ask yourself, &bquo;How often can I &bquo;&equo; get away'&equo; from below 800 feet when the soaring conditions have already deteriorated'. 
 Always say to yourself, &bquo;I will select a field just in case I don't find lift.&equo; 
 Failure to keep wind direction in mind and to orientate 
 This is largely a matter of forming the habit of noting the wind from smoke or some other indication and of orientating yourself relative to the sun or an obvious feature such as a coast line, i.e. remember something along the lines of &bquo;Into wind is into sun&equo;, or say to yourself, &bquo;I must land with the sun over my left shoulder&equo;, etc. 
 If you are scratching in weak lift, you may be able to see which way you have drifted after a few circles. 
 Near the coast, watch for large wind changes due to sea breezes. 
 Flying through the sea breeze front without realising it is a common cause of inadvertently landing downwind and ending up in a hedge. 
 Late choice of field 
 Don't keep putting off the choice. 
 Few fields are perfect and all you need is a good sized field with a level or uphill gradient and a good surface. 
 You know that it is extremely risky to leave the choice late and that, at the very latest, you must be organised in time to have a good look at the proposed field and to get into a good position for a proper base leg. 
 Poor selection 
 Practice is the only solution. 
 During local soaring, select good-looking fields, and then go and have a look at them after the flight to see what they are really  like. 
 Travelling by road or train, try to make a quick choice and evaluation of the nearby fields. 
 In the air, look right round as you make a quick circle. 
 This way, you will view a large number of fields. 
 Don't look immediately below because you won't be able to see the slopes. 
 If all four of the fields below are poor, it is very demoralising. 
 Discard difficult fields straight away. 
 Think systematically for size, slope, surface, colour and obstructions. 
 Failure to recognise slopes until committed to landing 
 Make a point of looking for the lay of the surrounding countryside. 
 River valleys and railway lines are usually fairly level, with the ground sloping down to the rivers. 
 Usually one side of the river will present all uphill into-wind slopes, while the other side can be dismissed as being unsuitable except when landing parallel to the river. 
 Keep well away so that you can see slopes properly and, when possible, view the field from at least two sides. 
 By choosing an uphill slope, at least you know that it will not be a downhill one! 
 Slopes which are visible from a thousand feet looking straight down from above are far too steep for an easy or safe landing. 
 Flat fields need to be larger as they may turn out to have slight downhill slopes. 
 Bad planning; failure to plan at all 
 This is one of the most dangerous faults and requires extra training to combat it. 
 More experience is needed at problem circuits and joining from different unconventional positions, such as starting directly overhead, or just downwind of the site. 
 Keeping far too close to the field 
 Re-learn to judge the 20-to-30&deg; angles for circuit planning. 
 Never get within 45&amp;degree of the field unless you are running out of height. 
 Choose a ground mark for the position of the final turn about an average field length back. 
 Failure to fly accurately when under pressure 
 More flying experience, together with more situations training, is needed. 
 Lack of flying experience leads to overloading and panic when under extra pressure. 
 This can result in dangerously inaccurate flying. 
 Failure to try to recognise if the height is excessive at the start of the base leg 
 This is caused by poor basic training and not thinking ahead. 
 Many inexperienced pilots do not even consider what the situation is going to be and only think about what is happening at that moment. 
 Think ahead! 
 Do more circuit planning flights with the last five hundred feet of the altimeter covered and try to guess ahead of time what the height and position will be (not in feet, but in terms of very high, about right, or rather low). 
 Failure to use airbrakes or to move back further when necessary during the base leg 
 Many pilots consider, quite wrongly, that it shows lack or judgement to use  airbrakes on the base leg. 
 If you have been thinking this way, practise having height in hand and using the airbrakes on the base leg. 
 The instructor should encourage the pilot to talk through his thoughts aloud to find out whether not using the airbrakes is caused by failing to realise the glider is too high or by not being quick enough to decide and act. 
 Serious misjudgement of heights during the circuit 
 Blank off the last 500 feet on the altimeter and practise guessing heights below 600 feet. 
 Height judgement above that height is not essential and is largely guesswork. 
 Instructors should encourage the use of comparison for judging low heights so that the pilot is more confident about recognising when he is low. 
 Lack of confidence often results in the pilot playing it safe with extra height, instead of making an effort to rely on his own judgement. 
 Failure to recognise when too high after the final turn 
 Introduce opening full airbrakes after the final turn to check the situation (unless obviously low). 
 Pilots should be encouraged to make an assessment during the final turn of how much airbrake they will need as they start to straighten up for the final approach, instead of waiting until the turn is completed at which point it is already too late. 
 The use of the airbrakes during the final turn should be discussed and pilots should be encouraged to try it if they are too high. 
 It should be emphasised that there is no reason to discourage any but the most inexperienced solo pilots from opening the airbrakes in the final turn, provided the glider is not already low (or slow). 
 Inability to sideslip effectively with full airbrake on the final approach 
 Sideslipping takes skill and practice. 
 Plenty of dual instruction is needed to be safe, and then it requires constant practice on high approaches to be able to sideslip effectively. 
 Failure to recognise undershooting and to close airbrakes in time to prevent an undershoot 
 Instructors should demonstrate correct procedure again and pilots should practise aiming point technique. 
 Flying dual, practise landings just beyond an obvious mark on the ground by manipulating airbrakes. 
 Self-criticism is needed if any landing is even a yard short of the chosen spot. 
 Failure to allow sufficient speed for uphill slope 
 Ideally, have dual landing practice on uphill slopes. 
 Otherwise, re-brief or think over all the aspects of misjudgements on slopes and the reasons for needing extra speed. 
 Failure to make a good hold off and landing because of eagerness to get down 
 Although often not practical, try to get dual experience at sorting out the landing after low final turns or upset approaches. 
 It is important to be able to recover composure after stress, to forget the low turn, and to get on with making a good landing. 
 Practise opening more airbrake during the hold off as a  means of getting the glider down fully held off, but without such a long float. 
 Being able to land safely in fields should be one of the ultimate aims in glider pilot training and it should not be left to the pilot to decide for himself when he is competent to fly across country.  
 Some thoughts on aerotowing accidents 
 Aerotow problems usually arise because the pilot ignores the possibility of something going wrong and is caught by surprise. 
 Crossing the boundary, I always check the airspeed because I know that above 60 knots, if necessary, I can make a well banked turn of up to 180&deg;, with virtually no loss of height and return for a downwind landing. 
 This possibility is worth suggesting to more experienced pilots, but, of course, is not suitable for a beginner. 
 At lower speeds, unless there is plenty of height, a landing must be made somewhere ahead. 
 Certainly during the first five hundred feet or so the pilot should be aware of possible fields ahead. 
 After a launch failure of any kind above two or three hundred feet, once the speed has been checked, it is best to turn off 90&deg; or so in order to avoid going further from the field. 
 In this position, the glider is on a base leg for any available field upwind and it is easy to look back and decide whether returning to the field is practical. 
 On a normal tow, except for very low performance machines, the climbing angle of the towplane and glider is much steeper than the glider's gliding angle when flying downwind. 
 So, in theory, the glider should be within easy reach of the gliding site. 
 However, in turbulent and windy conditions it is always better to play safe and land into wind in another field, rather than to make a downwind landing. 
 Downwind landings 
 Every glider pilot should make at least one downwind landing during training in order to realise that there is no particular problem in making a safe landing as long as the wind is not very strong. 
 In some circumstances it may be the best thing to do. 
 I once witnessed an incident that could so easily have been avoided if the pilot had considered a downwind landing as a possible option. 
 He had never done one and always thought it a dangerous manoeuvre to execute. 
 On this day he was gliding home to our airfield and only just made it back with less than a hundred feet as he arrived flying downwind over the  boundary . 
 Instead of carrying on and making the downwind landing without incident, he flew on to give himself room to land and then tried to turn around into wind for the landing. 
 He was so low that a wing-tip touched the ground, causing a ground loop. 
 He could so easily have hurt himself or irreparably damaged the glider but, in fact, he was very lucky and did surprisingly little damage. 
 It is important to realise that there is no particular danger in downwind landings on an airfield, apart from the possibility of floating too far and overshooting into the far boundary. 
 This makes it important to use the airbrakes to ensure that you cross the upwind boundary very low as though you were attempting to land in the first part of the field. 
 The other essential is to  land well clear of any obstructions, because a wing can so easily go down and cause a bad swing as you slow down after landing. 
 The main point to remember on the tow is to hold position accurately. 
 This means concentrating on the tow and only taking your eyes off the towplane for a brief moment. 
 Rope breaks usually occur through inattention and getting badly out of position. 
 They are probably almost as rare as engine failures, but there is one important difference. 
 With a rope break, the climb out is at the normal towing speed when the rope breaks, whereas when engine problems occur the tow is usually slow and the climb is far worse than normal. 
 If the rope breaks, the take off field should be within easy reach for a downwind landing, whereas a problem with the towplane's engine usually means a field landing is almost inevitable. 
 Towplane upsets 
 Over the years there have been a number of fatal towplane accidents caused by gliders getting too high and jerking the towplane into a steep dive. 
 Although considerable effort has been made to develop an automatic release for the towplane, the problems are not as simple as they might at first seem and so far no really satisfactory technical answer has been found. 
 Unfortunately, these accidents still occur from time to time. 
 Low tow position 
 The risk can be reduced by flying in the low tow position below the wake, but it still has some disadvantages and towing in this position has not been generally adopted in Europe or elsewhere. 
 However, it is frequently used for long distance tows, because there is less of a tendency to get a slack rope during level flight in the low tow position. 
 In Australia, all launching is done this way, and for a time it was common in the U.S.A. The disadvantages, however, of the low tow position are as follows. 
 The glider must be flown through the wake in the turbulent air near the ground. 
 (Some people think that this might be dangerous for inexperienced students, but it does not seem to cause any particular problems in Australia.) 
 It is impossible to watch the towplane and the ground ahead during the climb out so that in the event of a launch failure the glider pilot has to look for a field, whereas in the normal tow position he has a good view of the fields ahead all the time. 
 There is also the additional hazard that if the rope breaks at the towplane end, it may fall over the glider, causing damage. 
 Normal low position 
 Of course, there are also disadvantages in using the normal, high tow position and it is a matter of opinion which is best or easiest. 
 Losing sight of the tow plane for even a second can be lethal and the glider pilot must always release immediately if this happens. 
 In one accident I witnessed, the take off was being made towards the glare of the sun. 
 The glider pilot was dazzled for a moment and lost sight of the tug. 
 He  failed to release in time to prevent the towplane from being tipped over into the ground. 
 There are various contributory factors which can lead to a towplane &bquo;upset&equo; when towing in the normal (high) tow position. 
 Many modern machines are not fitted with a nose release hook for aerotowing, but with one designed to be suitable for both wire and aerotow launches. 
 With these, any jerk or sudden gust tends to result in a nose-up pitching movement, similar to the start of a winch launch. 
 Unless this is quickly controlled, in a few seconds the glider can be far too high above the towplane. 
 The effect is accentuated if the c.g. is near the aft limit and, in some cases, it is doubtful whether there is sufficient elevator authority to stop the pitching once it has gone beyond the early stages. 
 The only safeguard is to maintain the correct position carefully and to release at once if the glider is beginning to get too high in relation to the towplane. 
 A number of accidents and incidents have occurred with gliders such as the Olympia 463, K6 and K18, flown by relatively inexperienced pilots. 
 These machines have lower stick forces than most training two-seaters and are not generally fitted with a nose hook for aerotowing. 
 They have a marked tendency to zoom up into a steep climbing attitude if they are allowed to do so. 
 Moreover, they are often flown by early solo pilots who do not have much experience of flying them or of solo aerotowing. 
 In an effort to prevent this kind of accident (which is almost always fatal for the tow pilot), the emphasis has been for pilots to keep their glider very low just after leaving the ground. 
 It is possible that this has contributed to the risk of the glider zooming too high just after take off. 
 In windy weather, the effects of the wind gradient near the ground accentuate any movement up or down of the towplane and glider. 
 If the towplane gains speed by flying close to the ground, when it noses up to start climbing, the effect of the wind gradient accentuates the climb so that the glider may easily be left flying close to the ground, in or near the wake and below the tug. 
 Then, when the glider pilot recognises he is far too low, any quick movement to regain position takes the glider up through the same wind gradient, causing a sudden surge of speed and producing an unexpected and possibly uncontrollable gain of height. 
 At the same time, the extra load in the tow rope accentuates the nose-up pitching movement on the glider (as in a winch launch). 
 This slows down the towplane, leaving it at low speed below the glider and having its tail pulled up out of control. 
 Although it is vital not to get too high, there is no advantage trying to fly very close to the ground, except perhaps when taking off from a very short field. 
 It is much safer to fly at five or even ten feet until the towplane leaves the ground. 
 This makes it much easier to avoid pitching oscillations. 
 It also makes it possible to watch the towplane instead of the ground and, as on a landing, looking well ahead reduces the tendency to over-control. 
 It is the speed with which the situation develops that causes the problem. 
 Usually the tow pilot receives no warning of the danger. 
 One moment the tow is quite normal and the next, his aircraft is diving vertically into the ground. 
 So he has little or no time to release the glider, or to recover from the dive unless the upset occurs above about 500 feet, and then only if the rope breaks or the glider releases.  
 How can we help to prevent this kind of accident? 
 For a start, novice pilots should have some experience of aerotowing in single-seaters before converting to types which are not fitted with a nose hook, and gliders intended for inexperienced pilots should always be manufactured with a nose hook for aerotowing. 
 It is wise for inexperienced pilots to carry additional ballast to bring the c.g. well forward, making the glider more stable and increasing the stick forces. 
 The nose heaviness will also provide additional down elevator power to help control any nose-up pitching tendencies. 
 The pilot must be vigilant on every aerotow and must realise the importance of being prepared to release at any point on the climb out should his glider get badly out of position. 
 The pilot's left hand should certainly be near the release toggle all the time until the glider is at least 500 or 600 feet up. 
 Pilots should also be briefed about the dangers of raising the undercarriage, closing the canopy window or fiddling with anything in the cockpit in case they are momentarily distracted or jerk the stick unintentionally during the initial climb out. 
 From the start, the need to release immediately if for any reason they lose sight of the towplane must be impressed on the students. 
 The tow pilot can help by allowing his aircraft to climb away, gaining speed rather than holding it down close to the ground. 
 Gradual changes of attitude make it easier for the glider pilot to follow in position behind the tow plane. 
 But it is the glider pilot who literally has the life of the tow pilot in his hands. 
 Remember, do not hold the glider down too close to the ground, 5 to 10 feet is safer. 
 Be ready to ease up to stay in position as the tug starts to climb. 
 If you get out of position and if you find yourself too low, move up slowly in small steps, checking the movement every few feet. 
 Don't try to move to the correct position too quickly. 
 It is only rapid movements up that become uncontrollable. 
 Release immediately if the towplane goes out of sight, or you become very badly out of position. 
 just concentrate on flying the tow smoothly and accurately and don't let yourself be distracted for a moment.  
 Low &bquo;g&equo; sensitivity 
 Everyone is aware of the sensation experienced in a lift as it starts to descend, and in a car when it goes over a humped-back bridge. 
 On the ground the feeling only lasts a fraction of a second, but it can be more severe and prolonged during flight. 
 Since we live at 1g for virtually all of our lives, the feeling of even slightly reduced &bquo;g&equo; is unusual and, for many people, alarming (it can be associated with nightmare dreams of falling). 
 These are the sensations of reduced gravity or low &bquo;g&equo;. 
 Acclimatisation 
 The majority of students become acclimatised to these sensations after a few flights, but every instructor is aware that some students are particularly sensitive to these feelings and can develop a total abhorrence of stalling and pitching manoeuvres. 
 Many give up flying altogether because of this. 
 Others persuade their instructors to do the very minimum necessary and state categorically that they hate stalls. 
 I often wonder whether these pilots would react safely and effectively if they suddenly got their aircraft into a stalling situation. 
 Most experienced pilots and instructors don't remember their own early flights and don't realise that sensations which cause discomfort on a first flight will not even be noticed by the hardened pilot or instructor. 
 At first, almost everyone dislikes the sensation of reduced &bquo;g&equo;. 
 It is normal for this sensitivity to remain for a few flights and then gradually to disappear. 
 After a little more flying experience, beginners' eyes interpret what is happening to the aircraft and the alarm signal is no longer sent on to the brain. 
 For example, as the stick is moved forwards a little, the eyes see the nose of the glider moving down, and the brain expects the sensation and understands what is happening. 
 As there is no cause for alarm, the brain suppresses the sensation at source. 
 This is another reason to start off any flying training by emphasising visual references instead of the instruments. 
 If the reduced &bquo;g&equo; occurs because the air is turbulent, there is no visual sign of what is causing the sensation. 
 This makes it more alarming for the beginner who gets no warning, just a horrible sinking feeling. 
 After more flying the beginner will learn to recognise and accept that he need not worry about the effects of these bumps. 
 It is obviously helpful to make the first flights in smooth weather, with a clear horizon. 
 Because of the connection between vision and sensations, the latter are greatly amplified when visibility is poor, or when the pilot is looking in the cockpit, has no visual reference and is unaware of the exact movements of the aircraft. 
 This is very noticeable with experienced pilots flying into cloud without the help of the instruments. 
 After a very short time their sensations are heightened and they become worried. 
 For this reason, in gliders it is important to avoid watching the instruments during nose-down pitching manoeuvres  such as stall recoveries and when recovering into normal flight following a cable break during a steep winch launch. 
 Instinctive reactions to low &bquo;g' 
 Some pilots are completely incapacitated by even gentle nose-down pitching movements. 
 Less affected people will move their head back and push forwards on the stick. 
 This response of putting the hands out and throwing the head back is certainly not a reaction learned during flying training. 
 It is a very natural and fundamental protective instinct; babies respond in this manner if they are allowed to fall. 
 In the same way, if an adult slips and is going to fall, his hands go out to stop himself hitting his face. 
 I have noticed the same response with sensitive people on their very first flight when they are trying out the elevator. 
 As they move the stick forwards a small amount, causing only the slightest reduction in &bquo;g&equo;, their response to the resulting sensation is almost always to move even further forwards, making the sensation worse. 
 This is, of course, totally irrational. 
 If doing one thing with a control gives you an unpleasant feeling, the normal reaction would be to stop doing it, or to move the control back in the other direction. 
 One possible theory about why some people are much more affected than others is that they may have had traumatic experiences of falling as a baby or a young child, and that this has further re-inforced their instinctive behaviour. 
 Why are the effects of these responses so much less noticeable in powered machines? 
 Probably because of the very much greater stick forces and lower rates of pitch occurring in most light aircraft. 
 These make it far less likely that they will dive vertically for hundreds of feet if the pilot pushes forwards on the stick. 
 Gliders have very low stick forces and the lower flying speeds give them a very high rate of pitch. 
 Associating low &bquo;g&equo; with stalling 
 My experience with glider pilots has made me aware of many aspects of low &bquo;g&equo; sensitivity. 
 Some survivors from &bquo;dive-in&equo; accidents have confirmed that they knew it was useless to try to pull out of the dive while they could &bquo;feel&equo; the glider was still stalled. 
 This led me to think that some students may equate the feeling of low &bquo;g&equo; with the glider being stalled. 
 If this happens, a pilot may mistake pitching or sinking rapidly in turbulence as an indication that the aircraft has stalled. 
 In executing what would be a normal stall recovery, any movement forwards will, or course, increase the pitching, thereby making the sensation more vivid and encouraging the pilot to think that the aircraft is not recovering. 
 This is a sure recipe for panic and will be fatal unless there is plenty of height. 
 I was once with a student who responded with a stall recovery when the glider hit some turbulence on the final approach. 
 The glider dived almost vertically and I was just in time to pull back on the stick so that we hit the ground in a level attitude without any damage. 
 At least one double fatality has been caused in this way. 
 It is obviously crucial that all instructors are aware of any student who has this problem, since  it is so easy to be caught out, like I was. 
 Since then, my instruction on stalls and recoveries has been modified to emphasise from the start that there is no sensation, only symptoms, of stalling. 
 Immediately after the first introduction to gentle straight stalls I demonstrate that in normal flight even a small movement forward results in the same sensation, the feeling of reduced &bquo;g&equo;. 
 I take good care to emphasise that the sensation as we stall and recover is not a symptom and that it can occur in normal flight and in some cases when the aircraft flies through turbulence. 
 Hypersensitivity 
 Perhaps most interesting, but most dangerous, are the very small minority of students who are really chronically affected by this sensation. 
 (At Lasham I estimated about 1 in 400 people making their first glider flights were very sensitive to low &bquo;g&equo;.) 
 Fortunately, most of them try one flight and dislike it so much that they avoid flying again. 
 To a few, overcoming their fears of flying becomes a  challenge . 
 I have flown with a number of people who, with the slightest lowering of the nose or the gentlest stall, look as though they are having an epileptic fit. 
 They become quite unconscious of what they are doing for a few seconds, and yet insist that they want to carry on and learn to fly. 
 With very gradual familiarisation training spread over many months of flying, some of these students have been completely cured. 
 But if they are not spotted early in their training, they can be a real menace to themselves and to their instructors. 
 These are the students who really do freeze on the controls and, with the stick held firmly forward, the instructor has to be quick and strong to prevent an accident. 
 The &bquo;cure&equo; is largely a matter of acclimatisation and a simple but thorough explanation of why the aircraft stalls and what causes the sensation. 
 From then on the stall training must be continued, with a little done on every flight. 
 The student must understand that nobody likes the reduced &bquo;g&equo; sensation at first, but that individuals differ in their reactions to it. 
 Some are scarcely affected, whereas others need longer training to overcome their natural reactions. 
 Young and old people may be affected and there seems to be no way of knowing who will have this kind of problem. 
 Experience has shown, however, that often it is the young and able students who are most likely to go undetected and have a low &bquo;g&equo; accident. 
 I believe that this is because they do everything so well that they do not get excessive pitching movements in their training stall recoveries. 
 As a result, they seldom experience much, if any, reduction in &bquo;g&equo;. 
 Because they appear reasonably proficient, the instructors tend to give less practice to them than to the other students. 
 It may be some months or even years later when, for the first time they over-correct from a practice stall, they experience a substantial reduction in &bquo;g&equo; loading. 
 Then, if they have learned to associate the feeling with stalling, they will move forwards on the stick, making what they remember to be a normal stall recovery. 
 This makes the sensation much worse and, believing the aircraft is still stalled in spite of their recovery action, they are liable to panic and become unable to think or act in time to avoid diving into the ground.  
 &bquo;g'-related landing accidents 
 There are other situations involving reduced &bquo;g&equo; which can be incapacitating. 
 Reports about light aircraft landing accidents often say that the aircraft bounced or ballooned, pitched nose-down and then flew into the runway in a series of worsening crashes, smashing the nose gear and engine. 
 Certainly, a low &bquo;g&equo; sensitive person is liable to become completely incapable of further thought once the aircraft pitches nose-down the first time. 
 These pilots invariably demonstrate the basic response of pushing forwards on the stick and keeping it there. 
 The same kind of accident used to be common with gliders, and the pilots could never remember anything after the first bounce. 
 They have become less common since the fully held-off landings have been taught. 
 It is now likely that a student will experience ballooning a number of times while learning and will have learned to avoid moving forwards on the stick automatically. 
 In the past, many students were so petrified about stalling that they could not be persuaded to hold off properly for the landing. 
 They would try to avoid a stalled situation near the ground by pushing forwards if the aircraft bounced. 
 A person who is scared of ballooning will nearly always fly the aircraft onto the ground instead of making well held-off landings. 
 This problem is accentuated by pilots being very tense and mis-timing the stick movements. 
 It is not unknown for quite experienced power pilots to be very sensitive to low &bquo;g&equo;. 
 I remember an American pilot with about 200 hours, a twin-engine Commercial and full Instrument Rating who visited us some years ago. 
 On his site check our instructor found he was severely affected by reduced &bquo;g&equo;, although he had about 60 hours' solo gliding. 
 When he was asked to do a stall, he became panic-stricken as the glider stalled, and it was obviously unsafe to allow him to go solo. 
 He stayed the week and was given lots of extra training, but he was still unsafe when he returned to the USA. 
 Although it may not have been related, within a month he had crashed on a bad weather approach, killing himself and his friend. 
 Certainly, just a little low &bquo;g&equo; on the approach would have made things very difficult for him and I often wonder exactly what happened. 
 Surprisingly, there is usually less reduction in &bquo;g&equo; during an incipient spin or full spin than in a straight stall and, apart from the initial apprehension, these manoeuvres affect sensitive people less than normal stall recoveries. 
 Pilots who are frightened or apprehensive about stalling have not been properly trained and could be a risk to themselves and their passengers if they obtain their licence without overcoming their problem. 
 So, every instructor has a special responsibility towards such people. 
 Pilots learning to fly the very docile 3-axis control microlight aircraft are also at risk. 
 These all fly at similar speeds and have rather light stick forces like a glider. 
 On the weight shift types it is difficult to give the student experience at low &bquo;g&equo; manoeuvres and the pilots may be badly affected without it becoming obvious. 
 Fortunately, with weight shift, moving forwards causes a nose-up rather than a nose-down effect so that at least it does not accentuate the pitching movement and make the sensation worse. 
 I find it a little horrifying to think that some Commercial pilots flying large numbers of passengers may have had very little exposure to reduced &bquo;g&equo;. 
 Few  have gone through aerobatic training, and the modern tendency is to be happy with a few hours of stall avoidance training and little, if any, spinning. 
 It is even possible that some might be low &bquo;g&equo; sensitive and be at risk if a low &bquo;g&equo; situation suddenly occurs. 
 What could happen if, for example, another pilot raised the leading edge flaps of a large aircraft by mistake? 
 This would result in a sudden high rate of sink, with no obvious visual cause. 
 A sensitive pilot could then be so confused that he would be unable to respond logically to the situation, particularly if it happened at night or in cloud. 
 Pre-solo testing 
 Most gliding instructors are aware of these  problems  and watch out for them in their students. 
 Instructors should test every student before allowing them to go solo to make quite sure that they are not seriously affected by reduced &bquo;g&equo;. 
 This does not mean pitching violently to get weightlessness or negative &bquo;g&equo;. 
 The student can be asked to pitch nose-down gently from level flight and from diving and climbing attitudes. 
 Most pilots who are sensitive find themselves incapable of doing this exercise and their reactions are obvious. 
 In such instances they would need more training until an unexpected sensation does not cause a bad reaction. 
 Perhaps this test should be used for all pilots, regardless of what aircraft they are learning on? 
 This is not the whole story about accidents associated with low &bquo;g&equo; sensations. 
 Because I became aware of the problems when I first came into gliding, I wrote a booklet on the subject, called Sub-Gravity Sensations and  Gliding Accidents  (available from the BGA in the UK and SSA in the USA). 
 Surprising though it may seem, although it is now well established that this is a serious problem with gliding, it is almost unknown in power flying circles or in the Air Force and it is taking many years to convince authorities. 
 It is still probably one of the main causes of fatal gliding accidents all over the world.  
 Cloud flying 
 Fools rush in where Angels fear to tread 
 It is alarming to hear how many relatively inexperienced pilots seem completely unaware of the risks they take when pitting their skills against the forces of nature. 
 They often think that if their flying is good enough, it is safe for them to press on in any weather conditions. 
 The performance of modern gliders makes it much easier and more likely for a pilot to fly himself into a potential death trap unless he uses his imagination or has already learned to have a healthy respect for the elements. 
 The result has been a noticeable increase in the number of pilots who suddenly find themselves faced with a situation far beyond their control, usually a situation that they had not even considered at the start of the flight. 
 In most respects, using wave lift is far safer than cloud flying for attempts at Gold and Diamond heights. 
 However, wave flying has its own problems which a pilot must understand and recognise if such flights are to be made safely. 
 Similarly, if you are going to fly in a cloud, it is important to understand the possible hazards in order to avoid them. 
 Cloud flying, particularly in shower clouds, can be quite a dangerous pastime and on many days it would be totally irresponsible to risk losing a club glider by attempting to climb a large cloud. 
 Competence 
 The first essentials for any cloud flying in large cumulus are that the glider must be properly equipped for serious flying, and the pilot must be competent and experienced enough at instrument flying to be able to regain control from any attitude without having to use the airbrakes. 
 Because of the risk of a failure of the battery-operated Artificial Horizons, I always insist that pilots are competent to fly on the Turn and Slip Indicator before even trying a Horizon. 
 Many pilots find that they manage safely on their first few short cloud climbs but that they soon get tired and lose their concentration. 
 It is after they have lost control for the second or third time that the real difficulties appear. 
 One or two short climbs in cloud do not prove the ability of a pilot to cope with the required longer periods of concentration and more varied conditions in larger clouds. 
 However, there are a number of risks to be considered by even the most competent pilot, and these are outside the pilot's control once the cloud climb has been started.  
 Getting lost 
 It is impossible for any glider pilot to make a high cloud climb and to be sure of his position. 
 For this reason it is not acceptable to make climbs where the glider could possibly drift into Controlled Airspace. 
 Unless frequent pin points can be obtained during the descent, errors in position of 20 miles or more can easily occur, and this factor alone limits cloud flying to days on which large clouds are isolated so that there are clear areas between them. 
 Icing 
 If the glider gets wet before taking off for a high climb, the airbrakes may freeze up and become unusable. 
 This makes it vital for the pilot to be able to manage any loss of control due to stalling or spiralling without using them. 
 Severe icing seems rare, but even slight jamming of the controls should be treated as a serious warning to leave the cloud immediately before all control is lost. 
 Modern machines are blessed with a minimum of tail area and even a small coating on the leading edge of the tailplane may cause uncontrollable stability problems. 
 Probably for this reason most of the glass fibre gliders are not cleared by the manufacturers for cloud flying. 
 Hail 
 Flying into hail or very heavy rain deliberately in search of lift is also an unjustifiable risk. 
 Even in England, half-inch diameter hail stones are not unknown, and these will smash canopies and ruin the surfaces, causing very expensive damage and making it a matter of luck to get out of the area and down safely. 
 Lightning 
 In the past it was thought that the chance of having a glider struck by lightning in cloud was negligible. 
 However, there is now ample evidence to show that this was an over-optimistic view. 
 With gliders which climbed above 15,000 feet in cloud in the early 1960s, there was approximately one serious strike or electrical damage for every ten flights. 
 In those days quite a number of Diamond heights were attempted in large shower clouds and cumulo nimbus, whereas very few are flown today because of the unacceptable risks involved. 
 After an accident in which a pilot was killed by a strike, the remains of the aircraft showed the true potential power of nature. 
 The main spars were burnt where the control cables had been melted away. 
 It was obvious from this that in going into storms we were quite literally playing with fire. 
 The effects of electrical discharges on glass fibre and carbon fibre structures are uncertain, but it is clear that any moisture in the material would be turned to steam by a flash and would certainly cause delamination and very expensive damage. 
 Clearly, therefore, we should take heed of these warnings and never enter clouds which are actively electric.  
 Hypoxia 
 The only safe policy is to have oxygen equipment available and to insist on its use for any attempts at Gold or Diamond Heights. 
 At 15,000 feet, no enthusiastic pilot who is already suffering from the effects of lack of oxygen will be able to make the sensible decision to leave strong lift. 
 Furthermore, people vary in their tolerance from day to day, and it is not safe to assume that because you have been to 15,000 feet or so without oxygen before, you will be able to do it again. 
 The doctors tell us that elderly pilots and pilots who smoke should be aware that their tolerance to a shortage of oxygen is lower than younger people's or that of non-smokers. 
 So, to be safe it would be wise to use it at any time flying above 10,000 feet. 
 There is a very real risk that even at 15,000 feet the pilot may become unconscious, or at least incapable, from the combination of cold and lack of oxygen. 
 If the flight gets really &bquo;exciting&equo;, there is also the possibility the pilot will become so frightened that he will begin to hyperventilate, and this can bring on hypoxia and unconsciousness very quickly. 
 Landing 
 In ideal weather conditions a field landing should present no difficulties and even in poor visibility, with a known wind direction, the risks are acceptable. 
 But landing safely in torrential rain, with a squally and unpredictable wind, can only be a matter of luck for the most skilled pilot. 
 If the cloud base is low, there is bound to be a risk of coming out under the cloud and being unable to reach an area where it is not raining. 
 For a good chance of a safe landing, the ground must be seen from at least a thousand feet so that there is time to select a field and assess the wind. 
 In sinking air even this would not be enough to allow for much choice and, of course, it assumes that the descent will be made over open countryside and not amongst hills or moorland. 
 When the weather is showery, there is always a grave risk of the cloud base lowering to only a few hundred feet, and this can happen within minutes of the rain starting to fall. 
 Beware of snow showers, because they can reduce visibility to a few yards, making a safe landing impossible. 
 Common sense rules for cloud flying 
 1 
 Pilots should have experience at flying on the Turn and Slip indicator before using an Artificial Horizon, so that they can manage if the Horizon topples or becomes unusable. 
 2 
 These instruments should be switched on and checked before reaching cloud base. 
 3 
 Never enter cloud unless you are sure of your present position and are certain that there is no risk of drifting into Controlled Airspace. 
 4 
 The pilot's left hand should be on the airbrake lever during any climb in  cloud, ready to pull and open the airbrakes if the speed increases by more than 15 knots or so above normal. 
 5 
 Inexperienced pilots should only try cloud flying on days when there is no risk of large clouds developing, i.e. when there is an inversion preventing large vertical development. 
 Attempts at Gold Height (3000 metres gain of height) 
 1 
 The clouds must be sufficiently isolated to ensure that clear air can be found by flying out of the lift. 
 2 
 Check the forecast for risk of storms and do not enter large clouds if the freezing level is below 10,000 feet. 
 A high freezing level greatly reduces the risk of shower developing. 
 3 
 The main cloud base should be at least 2000 feet above the highest ground in the region, the freezing level must be high and the visibility should be good. 
 4 
 If you are trying to go high, get on to oxygen and check it is flowing correctly before you need it. 
 5 
 If the glider does not have oxygen equipment, make a move to leave the cloud well below oxygen height. 
 Moving on to other types of glider 
 One of the greatest hazards to a pilot can be his lack of current flying practice. 
 In this section are described ways of getting back into practice and of improving flying skills by making better use of the time in the air. 
 Flying a new type of glider is always fun, but it worries many inexperienced pilots: there is always an extra element of risk if an unexpected situation occurs on the first flight in an unfamiliar machine. 
 I have included help for those pilots trying out different gliders, and have suggested how to explore the handling of a new machine and how to minimise risks. 
 Flaps are described in detail for the many pilots who do not fully understand how to make the best use of them, and who may be nervous about their first flights in a flapped machine. 
 Another common cause of accidents is the inexperienced pilot who buys a glider which is not suited to his skill and experience. 
 There are notes for pilots considering becoming private owners and on the types of glass fibre gliders which are suitable for early solo pilots.    
 Polishing your flying 
 During training, your instructor makes you practise and insists that you try to fly more accurately and efficiently all the time. 
 But when you are a solo pilot, it is surprisingly easy to fly without any particular aim in mind, apart from trying to stay up! 
 You need to make a point of setting yourself tasks to do in order to keep on top line and to improve your flying. 
 Here are some suggestions on things to practise and to try out whenever you have some height and time to spare, rather than just flying up, round and down as so many pilots usually do. 
 Getting back into practice 
 Whereas the inexperienced glider pilot needs to fly at least once a month to be safe, more experienced pilots can go much longer without always becoming badly out of practice. 
 However, there is no doubt that we all fly better if we fly regularly and it is a good policy to fly whenever you have the opportunity. 
 In some countries if you miss a chance to fly it may be weeks before the weather allows you another opportunity. 
 Every year at the start of the soaring weather we have what is sometimes known as the &bquo;silly season&equo;. 
 This is when the pilots who have been hibernating during the winter months get their gliders out and start flying again. 
 The gliding is often spectacular: poor landings, low final turns and generally sloppy flying. 
 At many clubs it is compulsory for everyone to have at least one dual flight at the beginning of the season before flying solo again. 
 Certainly, an emergency on the first flight after a long lay off provides the potential for an incident. 
 If you are out of practice, why not take a ride or two with an instructor and ask him to criticise your flying? 
 This is a very quick way to get your hand in and learn what you need to practise. 
 Landings 
 You get a practice landing on every flight, but do you learn anything from it? 
 If it is the first flight of the day for you, then it should always be the aim to make it an accurate spot landing. 
 The first flight you make on any day is really the only one where your judgement is put to the test. 
 On the following flights you position the final turn and approach relative to where you made the last one, i.e. if you kept too close and landed rather far into the field on the first landing, you will move back more on the next, remembering the positioning of the previous flight. 
 Of course, with field landings, every landing is a &bquo;first time&equo; and needs to be exactly right. 
 You always hope that you will be able to select a large, easy field,  but that may not be possible. 
 Your very first field landing could even turn out to be the most difficult field of your whole gliding career. 
 Much depends on the wind strength as to how accurately it is possible to land. 
 But even in the least conducive conditions, with no wind, you should be able make a properly held-off touch down within about two fuselage lengths of your chosen spot. 
 After the first landing, the things to practise are more variations in the approaches and landings, trying some steep and some shallow, but attempting to touch down accurately on the chosen spot. 
 Always analyse how you could have improved your approach and landing and why you did not manage to touch down nearer to the spot. 
 With students and inexperienced pilots, it is usual to discourage them from making adjustments on the airbrakes during the hold off, apart from reducing the amount of airbrake if it is necessary to float to land further up the field. 
 This helps stress the need to get the whole approach right if the landings are to be reasonably accurate. 
 However, as pilots become more confident about their landings, it is very important for them to develop the skills needed to co-ordinate the stick and airbrake during the final hold off, so that an even more accurate touch down can be made. 
 Many pilots undershoot or overshoot their chosen spot by large margins. 
 Often they will comment that they did it deliberately, for some poor reason or other, or say that they could, of course, have touched down earlier if they had really tried. 
 Usually they really believe this and do not accept that they have made a mistake. 
 This is a dangerous way of thinking. 
 You need to know how consistently and how accurately you can land; be honest with yourself and accept your limitations. 
 Whereas there is a definite minimum speed for rounding out with full airbrake, once the glider is in level flight close to the ground, with the right technique the airbrakes can be opened fully at much lower speeds. 
 When the airbrakes are opened, some lift is lost so that the glider sinks a few feet very rapidly. 
 In addition, the drag of the airbrakes causes a more rapid deceleration. 
 To prevent a heavy landing as the airbrakes are opened, a backward movement is needed on the stick to increase the wing's angle of attack to maintain the same amount of lift as before. 
 When this is done, the combination of the lift loss and the extra drag result in the glider sinking gently and touching down almost immediately. 
 This makes landing accurately on the spot just a matter of timing the opening of the airbrakes and co-ordinating the elevator movement. 
 To land on a spot consistently by this method, the round out and early part of the float must be made without too much excess speed and with less than full airbrake. 
 Additional airbrake should be available to make the glider stop floating at the right moment. 
 It is undesirable to finish the approach with very little airbrake, although even this situation, from the point of view of an accurate touch down, is better than full airbrake and too much speed causing the glider to overshoot the point. 
 Unless the wind is very strong, if it is obvious that you can reach the field, it is useful to open full airbrake for a few seconds immediately after the final turn to check that you can undershoot. 
 It is  surprisingly  difficult to recognise an  overshooting situation until often it is too late to get down without sideslipping and using full airbrake. 
 Obviously if you have any worries about undershooting you should not do this. 
 But you must get the final stages of every approach within the range of the airbrakes so that you have some control to prevent either under or overshooting. 
 In a field landing it often happens that on the final approach or even during the hold off you realise that the first part of the field is not as smooth as it is further along. 
 Here you will need to reduce the airbrake to continue the float and then, as you get to the better ground, to re-open them to make the landing. 
 It is not satisfactory or acceptable, especially in a modern glider, to fly onto the ground by easing forwards on the stick. 
 This will cause a bad bounce and balloon if the ground is rough and, combined with the much higher touch down speed, may result in a broken glider. 
 Every landing should be made fully held off to ensure a low touch down speed. 
 I always think that it is criminal to undershoot the spot with some airbrake still on. 
 It is equivalent to landing on the hedge because you did not close the airbrake, even though you knew that you were likely to hit it. 
 It is important to practise adjusting the airbrakes during the float and to &bquo;kick&equo; yourself hard if you ever land short of your point with brake still applied. 
 It simply means that you have &bquo;frozen&equo; on the airbrake lever and have undershot when you could have saved the situation. 
 This is the same as &bquo;throttle arm paralysis&equo; on a powered aircraft when the pilot undershoots and crashes his aircraft. 
 He could have pushed the throttle forwards and avoided the accident by using the engine. 
 It is also worthwhile attempting the occasional no airbrake touch down to get a better idea of how far your glider will float. 
 Be ready to open the airbrakes fully as it touches down to stop any bouncing or a gust lifting the glider into the air again. 
 Whenever possible, and especially if you are out of practice, choose a completely clear area on the landing ground and remember to prevent the glider weathercocking into wind at the end of the landing run. 
 Landing with obstructions on the upwind side is particularly dangerous and is just the sort of error people tend to make when they haven't flown for a while. 
 If you are in good practice, it is fun to discover just how accurate you can be with a crosswind landing. 
 Choose a line feature along the landing area, with a mark or line across for the touch down point. 
 With a runway it is often possible to use the centre line and a selected spot. 
 See how close to the spot you can get for a fully held off, no drift landing. 
 Honing your skills like this is very enjoyable and will give you confidence if you ever have to land along a very narrow line such as a pathway. 
 I used to do this with my more experienced pilots using the Falke motor glider on the runway at Lasham. 
 We took it in turns to see how close we could get. 
 Most of the pilots were unconcerned if they were five feet or more to the side on their first attempts. 
 Then, when I really insisted that they keep right on the centre line, they found they could do it if they tried hard. 
 To achieve crosswind landing exactly on the spot without using the engine and in a strange machine offers a strong challenge even to the most experienced pilot.  
 Practise side-slipping 
 Every cross-country pilot should be competent at side-slipping. 
 It is often the only sensible way of getting rid of extra height quickly if you are still tending to overshoot with full airbrake. 
 In fact, it is unlikely that you would ever need to side-slip without full airbrake unless the airbrakes became frozen or jammed. 
 It is an important skill because even experienced pilots do occasionally make approaches which are far too high and which can be redeemed if they can side-slip quickly and accurately. 
 Being able to side-slip, therefore, is a useful safety valve and has prevented many a nasty accident. 
 However, it cannot be denied that incompetent side-slipping and sideslipping close to the ground can cause accidents. 
 It is a skilled exercise which needs careful instruction and supervision before attempting it on the approach with full airbrake. 
 Most beginners will find it difficult to apply the opposite rudder, because of their ingrained habit of using the stick and the rudder in co-ordination. 
 It is also surprisingly difficult to hold accurate heading during a full airbrake sideslipping approach. 
 You need to be familiar with the type of glider you are flying because each needs slightly different angles of bank and behaves differently when side-slipping. 
 Many types have a &bquo;pot&equo; pitot in the nose and the ASI indicates a false reading during side-slip. 
 On some, the rudder overbalances badly and there is a bad trim change. 
 Most only need a small angle of bank, as the rudders on gliders are not very powerful. 
 Normally you will want to use full side-slip for a few seconds rather than a small amount of slip for a much longer time. 
 Provided that the need of slipping is spotted straight away, it should never be necessary to side-slip close to the ground. 
 The slip is used just to get rid of the excess height so that less than full airbrake is required for the rest of the approach. 
 With most gliders, the easiest way to enter a side-slip and to hold the heading is to freeze the rudder central while applying the bank. 
 Provided the approach path was correct beforehand, the adverse yaw as the aileron is applied swings the nose off to just about the right point to keep the glider on the correct path. 
 The opposite rudder is then applied to hold that nose direction and to prevent the glider from turning. 
 Most beginners apply the opposite rudder too harshly and this makes it difficult to hold the bank constant. 
 It is easiest at first to limit the rudder movement to half or three quarters of the full deflection and to start by applying the banking movement just before applying the rudder. 
 By all means practise side-slipping at height, but don't assume that because you can do it at height you will be able to do it accurately on an approach. 
 In most cases when it really matters, the glider will already be on the final approach with full airbrake when it becomes apparent that an overshoot is likely. 
 So, this is the situation you must practise and be able to cope with. 
 It is much harder than going into the side-slip from the final turn where it is easy to apply the opposite rudder and straighten up correctly. 
 Practise by coming round the circuit several hundred feet higher than normal, making the final turn well back but very high. 
 When you are quite certain you will overshoot, even with full airbrake, apply full airbrake and start  the final approach, keeping straight. 
 Then, and only then, begin the side-slip and use up sufficient height to be sure that full airbrake will be more than adequate to get down for a spot landing. 
 With most gliders the attitude for the nose during the slip needs to be no higher than required to maintain the chosen approach speed. 
 You may require a small backward movement in many machines to stop the nose from dropping. 
 The critical moment is just after the recovery from the side-slip. 
 Most gliders are very reluctant to stall in the slip (try it some time), but if the recovery is made at a low speed, or the pilot forgets to ease forwards to prevent the nose rising during the recovery, there is a very real danger of stalling or of flying rather slowly as the glider encounters the wind gradient. 
 It is vital to check the actual flying speed the instant the side-slip is over and the ASI is back in normal operation. 
 Usually, if the speed is low, you only have a few seconds either to lower the nose or to reduce the amount of airbrake to avoid a bad landing. 
 In a field landing, or whenever you are trying for a spot landing (which, of course, should be on every landing), the moment you find that you are having to keep full airbrake on continuously, you should start to side-slip and use up the excess height. 
 Otherwise, any puff of lift on the approach will result in an unredeemable overshoot. 
 On every local flight that I make in a single-seater glider, I do some sideslipping on the approach to keep in practice. 
 Usually it will be only for a few seconds, but it is the ability to do it instantly on demand that is so important. 
 You need to know about side-slipping in the aircraft that you fly. 
 It is fun to do and needs to be practised regularly. 
 However, do ask an instructor or a pilot experienced on your type of glider for advice or any adverse behaviour to look out for. 
 Cross winds 
 If you are out of practice, make a particular point of watching for cross wind effects on take-off and landing. 
 Always be alert for a bad swing or a wing-tip touching the ground on take off and have your hand near the release, ready. 
 Make a point of trying to keep absolutely straight rather than just correcting a swing when it happens. 
 In this way you will improve your skills and prevent trouble on take off. 
 Explore the handling in steep turns 
 Time is always well spent when practising steep turns: not the classroom type where you pick up more speed and then go into the turn, but the sort you might use for thermalling. 
 If you are going to fly your glider efficiently while turning steeply in thermals with other gliders, you need to know how it will behave at the stall. 
 You will never get the best out of it if you are worrying all the time about stalling. 
 You need to be able to get into the turn quickly and accurately, and to be  flying within a few knots of the pre-stall buffet. 
 On most gliders that will mean less than 50 knots, which you may think rather slow for a steep turn. 
 However, don't look at the speed; try to go by feel and tighten the turn until you feel or hear the airflow start to break away around the wing-root. 
 Try pulling back harder until you reach the back stop on the stick and see what happens. 
 Does the glider stall or just wallow about buffeting? 
 Attempt this in a gentle turn as well, and in a gentle turn with a little too much rudder. 
 This time it will almost certainly drop a wing, but just easing forwards a little will make a recovery. 
 Try some very steep turns and then some with about 40&deg; of bank; try reversing the turn quickly, and making little centring moves. 
 Of course, if there are thermals about, do all this in the lift, provided there are no other gliders sharing your thermal! 
 You should be able to go into turns and make centring movements without having to refer to the slip ball, yaw string, or ASI. 
 Different types of glider behave slightly differently, so explore all the gliders you fly and adapt your flying accordingly. 
 Aerobatics 
 Aerobatics are an excellent way of improving your co-ordination and confidence, particularly if you aim to make them accurate and smooth-flowing. 
 Practising aerobatics and spinning will help to overcome any misgivings you may have about flying in steep turns at low speeds. 
 It is all a matter of acclimatisation... and practice. 
 It is fun to practise pulling up into a climb and trying to establish an accurate, low-speed, steep turn. 
 This can be put to good use in soaring conditions as a means of getting into the lift when cruising at a high speed. 
 Thermalling 
 Rapid progress across country is largely a matter of finding and using effectively only the very strongest of thermals. 
 You must develop the ability to find the centre of an area of lift quickly instead of losing it, and you cannot have too much practice and experience. 
 To do well, you need to become sensitive both to surges of lift and to the feeling of flying out of it into the sink. 
 Detecting the sink is particularly useful, because it enables quicker centring to be made. 
 Why this is so and hints on how to centre quickly are given in the newest edition of Gliding  (A &amp; C Black). 
 The aim should be to out-climb every other glider nearby and not to be satisfied with just staying up, unless the conditions are very poor. 
 This is a matter of constantly exploring out a few yards on almost every circle to try to find the best possible area of lift. 
 Frequently this involves turning steeply at low speed to keep the radius of turn to a minimum and to make use of the narrow cores of lift. 
 Remember, thermal soaring is more about staying in the strongest area of lift than flying at an &bquo;efficient&equo; angle of bank; it usually pays to turn  steeply, as the small turning circle enables you to keep in the narrow cores of strong lift. 
 If flying across country is not practical and you are local soaring, it is better to practise moving from cloud to cloud or thermal to thermal without taking the climbs to any great height. 
 For example, on a day with a 3000 foot cloud base, climb to 2500 feet on the first climb, then fly off leaving that thermal, using the airbrakes if necessary to come down to try to find another one at 2000 feet. 
 If you are aiming to go back for a landing, only stay long enough in that thermal to get properly centred before moving off again down to 1500 feet and starting to look for the next bit of lift. 
 Bring each search a little lower. 
 In this way you will spend more time on the important part, i.e. finding the lift and getting centred quickly. 
 Remember, too, that the thermals are smaller nearer to the ground, reinforcing the need for minimum speed, well-banked turns. 
 Even this only becomes valuable when you are below 1000 feet, by which time, of course, you will have moved closer to the gliding site or nearer to a suitable field if you are flying across country. 
 At this height, if you do not make efficient use of any lift you find, you will be down. 
 Many pilots give up at 1000 feet when there is still a fair chance of finding something and getting away safely. 
 At low altitudes, it is necessary not only to use the height most effectively to search, but also to retreat gradually to your position, off to one side of the landing area for a good base leg and an easy landing. 
 This is all valuable experience. 
 If you do run into lift, you must assess the situation on each turn, being ready to break off for a normal base leg and approach. 
 Of course, this is impractical on a site with a lot of power traffic or where a rigid circuit procedure is in force. 
 But where it is possible, it is valuable to learn brinkmanship, because you also learn to reduce your feelings of stress under pressure and to make better use of thermals lower down where they are often smaller and more difficult to centre. 
 At these heights, the first turn or so generally dictates whether you go up and get a climb, or go down for a landing. 
 It is in these situations that centring skills are most useful. 
 When giving instruction in thermal soaring, I try to insist that students go on attempting to find lift until about 5&ndash;600 feet, and I very often explain my own thoughts and precautions as they do the flying. 
 All the time during each turn it is essential to have a plan for the worst contingency and to know exactly what you would do if you suddenly lost 200 feet. 
 In this way it is possible to use the lift low down with safety, provided that the thermals are not too turbulent. 
 Then it is necessary to give up much higher. 
 Checking the compass 
 As you gain experience and begin to think about a first cross-country, local soaring provides a golden opportunity to check the compass for large errors and to get some practice at turning on to definite headings. 
 You will find that the normal aircraft compass is quite useless unless you are flying straight and at a steady speed. 
 Experiment with the various compass errors. 
 Heading north or south, try a little banking movement to see what happens to the reading. 
 Then do the same  on an easterly or westerly heading. 
 Also try changing speeds. 
 You will discover large errors flying near north or south with even small amounts of bank, and large errors on east and west if you vary the speed. 
 Compass errors are an awful nuisance and it is well worth finding out a little about them. 
 You also need to become accustomed to thinking and using degrees, and deciding whether you need to turn left or right to change the heading. 
 The easy way to remember it is that for a &bquo;lesser&equo; number of degrees, you turn &bquo;left&equo;, e.g. turning from 350&deg; to 320&deg; is turning to a lesser number and therefore you turn left. 
 Turning point photography 
 If you are aspiring to fly competitions or to get your Gold and Diamond Badges, it is essential to take good turning point photographs. 
 Like most things in gliding this takes practice and experience if you are going to avoid losing a thousand feet or more trying to take the picture of your turning point. 
 First perhaps, try taking the photograph with a hand-held camera. 
 You will soon realise the difficulties and will not need much persuading to make yourself a fixed camera mount. 
 A simple mount is invaluable, and it is best to set it up to get the wing-tip in the top corner of the frame. 
 Then it is only a matter of banking the glider over until the feature is just below the wing-tip, steadying the glider and pressing the shutter. 
 But you must be in the correct quadrant. 
 Until you are consistently getting the photos you want from inside the photographic sector, you will need to fly some distance beyond the turning point so that you do not have to be in a very steep turn or exactly positioned. 
 This is an ideal exercise to practise, using the camera without film. 
 Select a local landmark on a 250,000 scale map and draw in the correct quadrant. 
 It takes quite a bit of practice to orientate and get the right position for the shot, and this is something worthwhile perfecting during the winter or when you are just flying locally. 
 Many badge flights are invalidated by poor photography or by good photographs being taken outside the correct photographic zone. 
 The majority of rejected photographic claims are due to impatience &mdash; the photograph is taken before entering the zone. 
 So, take your time!  
 First flights in new types of glider 
 One of the most critical times in any inexperienced pilot's flying career is the first flight in a new type of single-seater glider. 
 If you get a poor launch or something unexpected happens, you are at a great disadvantage and are likely to have a problem. 
 Therefore, make sure that you are in current flying practice and that you choose a straightforward day without a high wind, severe turbulence or a cross-wind component. 
 Wait for another day if you are not feeling absolutely on top line. 
 You need to be &bquo;with it&equo;, because you can never guarantee that you won't have a launch failure or end up in a field instead of back where you started. 
 You might need to draw on all your skills to manage safely in a strange machine. 
 Normally, you will have an opportunity to look over the machine and to sit in the cockpit beforehand to think about all the knobs and levers. 
 The &bquo;Maker's Handbook&equo;, although sometimes written in somewhat basic English, will give you an idea of the flying characteristics and flight limitations. 
 It is also useful to watch how other pilots handle the glider. 
 If possible, get someone else to fly it before you to make quite sure that the ASI is working correctly. 
 Obtain the approximate stalling speed, the normal thermalling speed and a sensible approach speed for the glider type from the   pilot. 
 Also try to receive a thorough briefing from an experienced instructor or pilot who has flown the type in question. 
 Cockpit layout of a Grob Acro 111 
 Make a particular note of anything which is different from the aircraft you normally fly. 
 The modern tendency to put the airbrake lever, flap lever, trim and undercarriage all on the left side of the cockpit can easily result in you pulling the wrong lever. 
 A surprising number of gliders have been wrecked by pilots pulling the undercarriage lever or even the release knob instead of the airbrakes on the approach, usually on their first flight on type. 
 Even on the ground you can do expensive damage by moving the undercarriage lever in mistake for the flaps or airbrakes. 
 If you do this during a landing, there will not be time to realise your error. 
 If the glider has an unfamiliar type of airbrake or flap, it is vital to check their operation and to understand the system involved in locking them. 
 Over the years there have been innumerable accidents and incidents caused by the airbrakes opening in flight. 
 Although many gliders have a spring or bungee in the circuit to reduce the snatching loads at higher speeds on the approach, this is seldom powerful enough to prevent them sucking open if they are unlocked. 
 Most of the Glass ships have spring-loaded airbrake caps. 
 These contrive to make the locking very stiff. 
 The main point to realise is that if you cannot feel a positive lock, you are either not pushing hard enough or the lock is completely out of adjustment and too light to be effective. 
 Don't be deluded into thinking that they are locked because they are flush with the wing surface. 
 All airbrakes close fully before they lock. 
 Another potential disaster area is the canopy locking and jettison arrangements. 
 These can be quite complicated and it is important that you understand both systems. 
 It is possible that someone may have half pulled the jettison knob. 
 So, with an unfamiliar type make quite sure that the locks are positive and always double check by trying to push the canopy up after locking it. 
 Some emergency systems require operation of both the normal canopy catch and the jettison lever, and even then need a strong push up to get rid of the canopy. 
 Check the operation of the wheel brake. 
 Even your first flight could end up with a field landing and, if the wheel brake lever is not in the usual position for you, your habits will catch you out as you claw for the non-existent lever in panic. 
 Also, if the wheel brake is of the type that is applied automatically with full airbrake, remember that you should avoid touching down with full airbrake. 
 Unfortunately, a great deal of our flying is done by habit and this can lead to serious problems if anything goes wrong on the first flight in a strange machine. 
 If you are in current practice with aerotowing, a high launch is worthwhile for the first flight. 
 Carry extra ballast in the cockpit unless you are well above the minimum cockpit load, as this increases the stability and makes the elevator less &bquo;twitchy&equo;. 
 Think carefully before take-off. 
 Does the glider have the main wheel well ahead of the c.g.? 
 If so, remember it will require a forward movement on the stick to get the tail off the ground, unlike most of the two-seaters. 
 Also, it will need to be kept straight on take-off (see Swings and Roundabouts). 
 Certainly, for your first few flights, your left hand should be close to the release knob, so that you can release immediately if you get into a bad swing or a wing-tip goes onto the ground.  
 One of the biggest hazards is overcontrolling just after you have left the ground. 
 Remember, don't try to fly too close to the ground: 5 to 10 feet is quite all right and will make it much easier to smooth out any pitching which occurs before you have had time to get used to the light controls. 
 Once clear of the ground, most gliders are very similar to each other and you should have no problems. 
 After releasing, slow right down, retrim the glider, and then raise the main wheel. 
 If they are fitted, set the flaps for cruising. 
 Try circling at low speed and reversing the turn to get the feel of the ailerons. 
 Then check it is clear below and attempt a straight stall, followed by a few stalls in very gentle turns. 
 This will tell you if the glider has an obvious stall buffet and if it is likely to drop a wing during a stall when thermalling. 
 Before you go down into the circuit area, increase the speed to 60&ndash;70 knots and try the airbrakes to see how badly they snatch and how effective they are. 
 Also try side-slipping at the approach speed to see if the rudder overbalances badly or the side-slipping is unusual in any way. 
 This could be serious if you had to make a side-slip to get down into field on an early flight. 
 Rejoin the circuit with plenty of height, remembering to lower the main wheel if it is retractable. 
 Look down and check that you are handling the right lever before moving it to the DOWN position. 
 (Some undercarriage levers are forward for up, and others are forward for DOWN!) 
 Finally, check the airspeed carefully and approach with an adequate amount of height and speed. 
 Try to avoid an approach which ends up with a very small amount of airbrake. 
 It is always easier to land with at least half airbrake provided that the speed is not too low. 
 Don't try to judge the landing attitude; just make sure that you are close to the ground and keep holding off until the glider lands itself. 
 Make quite sure that you hold off fully. 
 Gliders only bounce if they are allowed to touch down prematurely with excess speed. 
 If you do inadvertently end up with very little airbrake, or with excess speed, don't be afraid to hold off slightly higher than normal while you get rid of some of the speed. 
 Try to get a small amount of airbrake on and keep the glider off the ground as long as you can, even if it floats a long way into the airfield. 
 Be ready to open the airbrakes fully the moment the wheel touches the ground and then keep it straight and keep the wings level. 
 Modern gliders are more prone to swinging than older aircraft and it is a little more difficult to keep the wings level, so don't relax until the glider has come to rest. 
 Ideally, take another flight straight away so that you can master any difficulties you may have experienced on the first flight. 
 It will also help you to become more familiar with the glider. 
 Remember: modern gliders are more difficult than older gliders to operate in no-wind conditions. 
 For your first flight, choose a day with some wind to make it easier to keep the wings level and to keep the glider straight. 
 In the air, you will find all the modern machines very easy to fly but most are lighter on the controls.  
 Cycling  FOR HEALTH 
 Produced in association with The Great British Bike Ride &copy; 
 Along with jogging and swimming, cycling is one of the best all-round forms of exercise. 
 It can help to build up your strength, boost your body's suppleness and flexibility and, most important of all, give you staying power by boosting your stamina. 
 AEROBICS ON A SADDLE 
 Having stamina, the ability to keep the body going, means having efficient muscles, good circulation and a strong heart. 
 Exercises which are good for building stamina involve moving your arms or legs rhythmically. 
 This creates a demand for oxygen, so the heart works a little harder, and the lungs are fully used. 
 They pump oxygen into the bloodstream, so that it passes through the heart and reaches the working muscles. 
 Sometimes this is called aerobic exercise, and cycling is an excellent form of aerobics. 
 THE WEIGHT OFF YOUR FEET 
 Stamina-building is not the only advantage of cycling. 
 Because you're not carrying the weight of your body on your feet, it's a good form of exercise for people with painful feet, bad backs, or arthritis. 
 And, of course, cycling can save money and provide pleasure. 
 More and more people are taking to their bikes as an alternative to driving or using public transport. 
 Whether you're shopping, going to work or travelling for pleasure, it's a lot cheaper and much healthier! 
 You don't have to pay for parking or petrol and it's much quicker than walking. 
 Cycling is something that all the family can enjoy. 
 GETTING STARTED 
 With all forms of exercise, it's important to start slowly and build up gently. 
 Doing too much too quickly can be a strain on muscles and joints that aren't used to work. 
 If you have any doubts on health grounds about taking up cycling, talk to your doctor and ask his advice. 
 Choosing the right bike for you depends on what you want to use it for. 
 But having gears does help to make life easier on the hills. 
 If your bike is second-hand, or hasn't been used for a while, then it's important to check that it's safe to ride. 
 SAFETY FIRST 
 &bull; 
 Always make sure you can be seen easily at night. 
 Keep your front and rear lights in good working order and don't forget to switch them on. 
 Wear light-coloured clothing or, better still, a reflective jacket. 
 &bull; 
 Beware of careless traffic, especially in towns. 
 Drivers tend to have a nasty habit of cutting corners without a thought for the cyclist on the inside. 
 &bull; 
 Don't change lanes unexpectedly or weave in and out of slow-moving traffic. 
 Take great care turning right. 
 &bull; 
 Always give clear hand signals. 
 Learn the Highway Code before you start. 
 TAKING THE ROAD 
 Once all your preparations are complete, try starting off by doing a number of short rides, say between three and six miles. 
 Ideally, you should be cycling at least two or three times a week. 
 For the exercise to be doing you good, you should get a little out of breath. 
 If you find it too much, or your are in pain, stop and take a rest. 
 As you get fitter, you'll find that you can manage longer journeys in surprisingly short times. 
 Family outings on bikes are a good way to make the best of summer days. 
 If you get really keen, you might like to join your local cycling club. 
 These clubs often run tours and other events to take part in. 
 This leaflet is produced by the Health Education Council in conjunction with the organisers of The Great British Bike Ride, an annual sponsored bike ride from Land's End to John o' Groats organised by Bike Events and sponsored this year, once again, for Friends of the Earth. 
 There are 200 places open to people of all ages and abilities who can achieve a unique ambition by participating in this unusual event. 
 The riders are supported by a complete package of services provided by Bike Events. 
 Friends of the Earth 
 Britain's leading environmental pressure group promoting policies to protect the environment, with campaigns on cycling, transport, wildlife and countryside, safe energy and pollution. 
 Bike Events 
 The country's leading organisers of mass cycling extravaganzas and cycling holidays including The Great British Bike Ride, and The London to Brighton Ride. 
 Other useful organisations: 
 INTRAUTERINE DEVICES 
 the coil:  
 FACTS ABOUT THE IUD 
 What is an intrauterine device? 
 An intrauterine device also known as an IUD, IUCD, loop or coil is a small, flexible object between two and four centimetres in length, made of plastic or plastic wound with copper. 
 It can be inserted into a woman's womb quite easily by a doctor, in order to prevent pregnancy. 
 Intrauterine means inside the uterus or womb. 
 The IUD works partly by preventing the egg from settling in the womb. 
 It is a very reliable reversible type of non-hormonal contraceptive. 
 Of 100 women using an IUD between two and four will become pregnant each year. 
 What types of IUD are there? 
 Various kinds of IUD are used in Britain. 
 Most are wound with copper: eg the Copper-7, Copper-T, Novagard, Nova-T and Multi-load Copper 250; one is simply plastic; eg the Lippes Loop. 
 It is sensible to know which type you have. 
 The devices wound with copper are usually replaced every two-to-five years, depending on which type you have. 
 The Lippes Loop can be left in place longer. 
 When are IUDs fitted? 
 Some doctors prefer to fit an IUD during a period. 
 If not during a period, then adequate contraceptive measures must have been taken since the last period, such as the pill, or sheath, or cap with spermicide, used on every occasion. 
 How soon can an IUD be fitted after childbirth? 
 Some doctors like to fit an IUD soon after delivery; others prefer to wait until six or eight weeks after the baby has been born. 
 In the meantime it is essential not to risk a further pregnancy and other contraceptive measures must be taken see above. 
 Breastfeeding does not always prevent pregnancy. 
 How soon do they make sexual intercourse safe? 
 Straight away. 
 Moreover the IUD does not interfere in any way. 
 Do they suit all women? 
 IUDs are especially useful for women who have had children. 
 For women who have had no children at all, they are not a first-choice method of contraception, but can be used. 
 Discuss this with your doctor. 
 For a few women &mdash; particularly those who have rather heavy periods or any history of pelvic infection &mdash; IUDs are not satisfactory. 
 Can I use internal tampons? 
 Yes. 
 What side-effects are there? 
 After an IUD has been fitted you may feel the sort of cramp-like pain that sometimes comes with a period. 
 Usually this is mild and won't last long. 
 You may find that pain-relieving tablets help. 
 The regularity of your periods should not be affected, but some bleeding may occur after the fitting or between periods, especially at first. 
 Often the periods are heavier than usual. 
 If you miss a period you must consult your doctor as soon as possible. 
 Sometimes the IUD comes out this is called expulsion. 
 Occasionally the woman may not realise that this has happened, and so may become pregnant. 
 Expulsion is most likely to happen soon after insertion. 
 Some women learn to feel the threads tails of the IUD in the vagina. 
 If you cannot feel them, take other precautions, eg the sheath, and see your doctor as soon as possible. 
 You should attend for routine follow-up visits as instructed, probably at least once a year. 
 Supposing I get pregnant? 
 There is a greater chance of miscarriage than in a normal pregnancy, and most doctors advise that the IUD should be removed. 
 So go and see your doctor at once if your period is over 14 days late. 
 A pregnancy with an IUD in place could be ectopic outside the womb. 
 This is an uncommon but dangerous situation, that can also occur in women who do not have IUDs. 
 So any abdominal pain occurring after a delayed, light or missed period must be reported to a doctor at once. 
 Are there likely to be other complications? 
 Pelvic infection  It is particularly important to tell your doctor about any pelvic infections, &bquo;salpingitis&equo; or sexually transmitted disease you have had in the past, as this may affect the choice of contraceptive method for you. 
 You should report any vaginal discharge, pain after intercourse or abdominal pain, especially if accompanied by fever, as these symptoms may be due to pelvic infection which requires prompt treatment. 
 The chances of getting infection are greater, the younger you are, and if you have more than one sexual partner.  
 Pelvic infection is more likely to occur in women using an IUD than in those using other contraceptive methods. 
 In Britain the risk in IUD users is approximately twice that of pill users. 
 For this reason women who have no children may prefer to use another method of contraception.  
 Perforation of the womb  is very rare. 
 It may cause pain but often there are no symptoms. 
 The problem is usually discovered only when the threads of the device cannot be detected in the vagina. 
 The device may have to be removed by a small operation. 
 Suppose I want a baby or want my IUD removed? 
 If you want a baby, ask your doctor to remove the IUD you must never try to remove it yourself. 
 If you do not want a baby, but want your IUD removed, this is best done during a period, and you should immediately start using another method of contraception. 
 If your IUD is removed between periods, you could get pregnant. 
 To avoid this, start your new method of contraception at least a week before the IUD is removed. 
 HOW TO GET ADVICE 
 Where can I get the device fitted? 
 IUDs are usually fitted at hospitals or family planning clinics, by doctors with special training. 
 Some general practitioners will also fit IUDs. 
 Your own doctor or nearest family planning clinic will be able to give you up-to-date information on this. 
 Do I have to pay? 
 All family planning services and supplies on prescription are provided free on the National Health Service if you are ordinarily resident in the UK. 
 The services are available from hospitals, clinics and family doctors who have agreed to provide family planning advice. 
 If for any reason you prefer not to discuss birth control with your own GP, you are entitled to go to another GP for this service. 
 Some clinics have special youth advisory sessions. 
 How do I find my local clinic? 
 There are NHS family planning clinics all over the country. 
 You can get the address and times of your nearest clinic from your 
 &bull; 
 Health Centre 
 &bull; 
 Midwife 
 &bull; 
 Hospital 
 &bull; 
 Health Visitor 
 &bull; 
 Telephone directory or Yellow Pages under &bquo;family planning&equo; 
 There are a few fee-paying clinics too. 
 If you wish you can 'phone or write for details of NHS or fee-paying clinics to the Family Planning Information Service . 
 Or contact Family Planning Association offices in Bedford, Belfast, Birmingham, Brighton, Cardiff, Exeter, Glasgow, Liverpool, London, Norwich or Sheffield . 
 A final word 
 The information provided in this leaflet is not intended to be exhaustive, but tells you the basic facts about the IUD on the basis of evidence available at the time of publication. 
 DON'T FORGET &mdash; ring or visit the clinic or your doctor if you are worried or unsure about anything.   
 Artist's diagram showing a Lippes Loop in the womb 
 Insertion of an IUD. 
 The device in this case a Copper-7 is gently inserted into the womb through a narrow tube or &bquo;introducer&equo;. 
 The introducer is then removed and the IUD opens to its correct shape in the womb. 
 WAKE UP. 
 GET A SMOKE ALARM. 
 CHOOSING SMOKE ALARM PROTECTION 
 Always look for smoke alarms which conform to the British Standard, whatever make or type you choose. 
 It should meet BS 5446 Part 1 or it should have the Kitemark on it. 
 If possible read the manufacturer's information and instructions before you buy a smoke alarm. 
 There are two basic types of smoke alarm. 
 Some use ionization detectors, which tend to react a little faster to flaming fires. 
 Others use optical detectors, which seem to respond more quickly to smoke from smouldering fires such as those involving upholstered furniture. 
 But there is little to choose between the two in terms of overall performance. 
 LOOKING AFTER SMOKE ALARMS 
 Smoke alarms need very little maintenance, but they do need to be tested regularly to make sure they are in good working order. 
 Most smoke alarms have a test button which sets off the alarm when pressed. 
 So when you fit them, make sure they can be reached easily. 
 The batteries should be changed once a year. 
 Some alarms warn you when the batteries need changing by giving a special signal. 
 700 DIE IN FIRES AT HOME EACH YEAR 
 A lot of these deaths might have been prevented if people had been able to get out in time. 
 But well over half of those killed were young children or elderly people who were quickly overcome by smoke and fumes while they slept at night. 
 Remember, even a small fire can fill your home with dense and poisonous smoke in a couple of minutes. 
 WHAT ARE SMOKE ALARMS? 
 Smoke alarms are small plastic devices which can be fitted by most people in their homes. 
 They cost around &pound;10&ndash;&pound;15 each for the battery-operated models. 
 Smoke alarms can detect smoke from fires in their earliest stages and sound a loud warning alarm. 
 Of course, you will need to go on taking basic fire safety precautions even when smoke alarms are fitted in your home. 
 But if, in spite of your precautions, a fire breaks out, a smoke alarm can give those precious few minutes of warning which increase the chances of you and your family getting out safely. 
 FITTING SMOKE ALARM PROTECTION 
 &bull; 
 You should fix the smoke alarm on the ceiling in the centre if possible, but at least 30cm 12 inches from any wall or light fitting. 
 &bull; 
 Smoke alarms need to be close to where a fire is most likely to break out, but also in a position where an alarm can be heard throughout your home especially when you're asleep. 
 &bull; 
 Don't fit smoke alarms: 
 &mdash; 
 in bathrooms or kitchens, where steam or cooking fumes could set them off. 
 &mdash; 
 above heaters, air-conditioning ducts or heating vents, or in very hot or cold rooms, such as a boiler room, or an unheated outhouse. 
 &mdash; 
 in a garage, where exhaust fumes could set off the alarm. 
 &bull; 
 If you live in a bungalow or in a mobile home, you should fix an alarm in a corridor between the living and sleeping areas. 
 &bull; 
 If you live in a conventional two-storey house, the best place for a single alarm is above the bottom of the staircase. 
 HOW MANY SMOKE ALARMS DO YOU NEED? 
 One smoke alarm may be enough if you live in a mobile home or a small bungalow. 
 If you live in a house, one alarm fitted above the bottom of the staircase will give you some protection, but you can be better protected by fixing another alarm on the upstairs landing. 
 You and your family will be best protected by fixing extra smoke alarms in rooms where a fire is most likely to break out, eg the living room, bedrooms where there are electric fires, electric blankets, or where the occupant is a smoker. 
 Smoking a cigarette will not normally set off a smoke alarm. 
 Some smoke alarms can be linked together so that if one of them senses smoke, all of them will sound an alarm. 
 This can give you the earliest possible warning, especially important if you live in a big house. 
 IF THE ALARM GOES OFF&hellip; 
 &bull; 
 get everyone out quickly by the safest route. 
 If you have to go through a smoke-filled area, crawl with your head low 
 &bull; 
 if it's safe, shut doors to delay the spread of fire and smoke 
 &bull; 
 feel each door before opening it. 
 If it's warm or it smoke is coming through, don't open it, the fire is on the other side 
 &bull; 
 call the fire brigade as soon as possible by dialling 999 from a neighbour's house or a phone box. 
 Don't go back inside your house to use the phone. 
 Give the full address of the fire 
 &bull; 
 stay out of your home until the fire brigade tells you it's safe. 
 Possessions are replaceable &mdash; your family isn't. 
 Get out. 
 Get the Fire Brigade out. 
 Stay out. 
 More information is available from your local fire brigade.  
 Fire kills. 
 Think about it. 
 ENTER THE FLU protected  ZONE 
 YOU SHOULD CONSIDER A VACCINATION 
 What is flu? 
 Flu is a viral infection which can make even the fittest person feel quite ill. 
 The symptoms of flu may last several days, usually starting with a high temperature often with a headache. 
 Your limbs can ache and your muscles can feel weak. 
 You may also have a dry irritating cough, a sore throat and a runny, itchy nose. 
 Who can catch flu? 
 Flu can spread very rapidly, so it is easy to catch and to pass on to others. 
 Flu is most likely to affect you in the autumn and winter, e.g. from October to March. 
 In other words, anyone! 
 However some people are more at risk than others. 
 If you are elderly, have a heart, lung or kidney disorder or have diabetes, you should take particular care not to catch flu. 
 How can I protect myself and my family against flu? 
 If you are one of those patients who are at greater risk from flu, you should try to avoid catching it. 
 A flu vaccination can help to protect you from flu. 
 One simple injection, normally given in the autumn, can help to protect you right through the cold months when flu is most prevalent. 
 Who can give me a flu vaccination? 
 Your doctor will normally be able to vaccinate you with a flu vaccine. 
 Only one quick injection is necessary to help give you the protection you may need from flu. 
 Who can help if I do get flu? 
 It may be advisable to speak to your local pharmacist who is professionally qualified to offer advice on how to cope with the symptoms of flu. 
 The pharmacist can also suggest medicines to help reduce your symptoms. 
 If your symptoms persist for more than a few days, then contact your doctor for advice.  
 ONE SIMPLE VACCINATION CAN HELP PREVENT YOU CATCHING INFLUENZA 
 ASK YOUR DOCTOR OR NURSE FOR ADVICE. 
 What to do if you have flu 
 1 
 Go to bed. 
 2 
 Drink plenty of liquids to avoid fluid loss caused by sweating. 
 3 
 Ask your local pharmacist for advice on medications to help relieve symptoms. 
 4 
 Use a hot water bottle if you feel shivery. 
 5 
 Call your doctor for advice if symptoms persist for more than a few days. 
 6 
 A dose of flu means you could be off work for at least a week. 
 You will need a self certification note for your employer available from your doctor's surgery. 
 Why risk catching flu? 
 If you are a person at greater risk from flu, consider having a flu vaccine this autumn.  
 Servier VACCINATION PRODUCTS 
 Supplied as a service by Servier Laboratories Ltd. 
 So you want to be a childminder&hellip; 
 What is a childminder? 
 A childminder is anybody who looks after children under 5 in her own home, usually while their parents are at work. 
 Do I have to register with the authorities? 
 If you receive payment for looking after one or more children who are not related to you, for 2 hours or more per day, then you should, by law, register with your local Social Services Department. 
 What does registration involve? 
 Social Services Departments vary in the way they register childminders, but you will probably be visited in your home and be given some forms to complete. 
 What will they want to know about my home? 
 They will want to know that you have a safe, warm place for children to play, and that your kitchen and toilet facilities are adequate. 
 What will they want to know about me? 
 They will want to be sure that you are prepared to give your time to care for the children, that you will provide for all their needs and take them out regularly, and that you really do like  small children! 
 What will they want to know about my health? 
 You will probably be asked some questions about your health, and you will need to have a routine chest X-ray if you haven't had one lately. 
 Is there anything else I will have to do? 
 You and also anyone else aged over 16 in your house will be asked to sign a statement about previous child care. 
 How many children will be I allowed to mind? 
 Again, local authorities vary, but probably not more than 3 or 4, including any under-5's of your own. 
 What help will I get from my Social Services Department? 
 You will probably be visited from time to time, and in some areas you will get practical help such as toy kits, toy libraries, first aid kits and safety equipment on loan. 
 You may also have the opportunity to attend a course. 
 Ask the person who comes to see you. 
 How can I find children who need looking after? 
 You may find that Social Services will put your name on their vacancy list, and once you are registered you can advertise. 
 What should I charge for minding children? 
 This is a private arrangement between you and the parents, though you may find that childminders in your area have agreed a uniform rate. 
 The N.C.M.A. thinks that a minimum of &pound;17 a week per child for full-time care is reasonable, but you could charge more depending on the parents' earnings and the number of meals provided etc. 
 What does &bquo;full-time&equo; mean? 
 This will depend on the parents' working hours, but it can be a long day, possibly 8.00 a.m. to 6.00 p.mm., or even longer. 
 What do I need to discuss with the parents when taking on a child? 
 You should make sure you know where the parents can be contacted, and that they have given you all the information you are likely to need about the child. 
 Settle things like hours, holidays, pay day etc. right at the beginning if possible. 
 The N.C.M.A. has a contract form which is helpful for this. 
 Will I have to look after children if they are ill? 
 No, a childminder cannot normally take care of a sick child &mdash; it's not fair on the other children in her care. 
 Will I have to take children to the Clinic? 
 Discuss this with the parents, but you will find the Health Visitors helpful and pleased to see you. 
 Is there anything else I will have to do? 
 You should keep a register of when the child comes to you together with basic information like his date of birth, doctor's name and phone number. 
 The N.C.M.A. has another useful form for this. 
 Will I be able to meet other childminders? 
 Some Social Services Departments arrange group meetings for childminders, and in some areas there are self-help groups and associations run by the childminders. 
 You can join the N.C.M.A. as an individual member if you like. 
 Are there any benefits of being registered? 
 How much support and practical help you will get from your local Social Services Department varies from area to area, but everyone is at least entitled to one third of a pint of free milk each day for each child you mind. 
 What is childminding like as a job? 
 Looking after other people's children can be very rewarding indeed, but it is also hard work and a big responsibility and is not quite the same as bringing up your own children. 
 It's important for you and the child's parents to work together as much as possible. 
 You will certainly play a very important part in the life of the young child and provide a valuable service for his family.  
 There are 8 methods of birth control 
 This isn't  a method of birth control! 
 Top-level list labels not repeated in source. 
 repeated here for clarity. 
 METHOD 
 THE COMBINED PILL 
 Oral contraceptive 
 Triphasic and biphasic pills 
 Everyday/ED pill 
 Almost 100% effective 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 Contains two hormones &mdash; oestrogen and progestogen. 
 Taken regularly it stops ovulation the release of a woman's egg each month. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 Easy and convenient to use. 
 Gives regular monthly cycle, often with reduced amount of bleeding, period pain and premenstrual tension. 
 Does not interfere with lovemaking. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 Some women have minor side-effects which normally pass in a few months. 
 Not suitable for women over 45 and smokers over 35. 
 Unsuitable for those with a personal of family history of strokes, heart attacks or raised blood pressure, and some diabetics. 
 Serious side-effects are rare. 
 COMMENTS 
 Does not work if taken over 12 hours late, or if there is sickness or diarrhoea, when extra precautions must be used. 
 some drugs may stop the pill working &mdash; a doctor will advise. 
 The pill is prescribed by a doctor. 
 Pill users should try not to smoke. 
 METHOD 
 MINI-PILL 
 Progestogen-only pill 
 98% effective 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 The hormone progestogen taken regularly every day at the same time causes changes making it difficult for sperm to enter the womb or for the womb to accept a fertilised egg. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 Useful for older women, as there is less risk of blood pressure and blood clotting problems. 
 Easy and convenient to use. 
 Suitable for use while breastfeeding. 
 Does not interfere with lovemaking. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 Monthly cycle may be irregular, with breakthrough bleeding or &bquo;spotting&equo;. 
 Minor side-effects usually last for only two to three months. 
 Sometimes periods are missed. 
 COMMENTS 
 Must be taken at the same time daily or no more than three hours late. 
 Sickness, diarrhoea and some drugs may stop it working, and extra precautions must be used. 
 The pill is prescribed by a doctor. 
 Pill users should try not to smoke. 
 METHOD 
 INJECTABLE CONTRACEPTIVE 
 Depo-Provera 
 The jab 
 Almost 100% effective 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 Acts in a similar way to the mini-pill and also stops ovulation. 
 A hormone, progestogen, is injected into a muscle, and is released very slowly into the body. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 One injection gives protection against pregnancy for three months. 
 Does not interfere with lovemaking. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 Periods usually become irregular. 
 Return of regular periods and fertility may be delayed for eight to ten months. 
 COMMENTS 
 Should only be offered to women for whom other methods are unsuitable. 
 Opinion differs about its value. 
 Prescribed by a doctor. 
 METHOD 
 INTRAUTERINE DEVICE 
 IUD, IUCD 
 Coil 
 96&mdash;98% effective 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 A small device &mdash; usually plastic with copper &mdash; which is inserted into the womb by a doctor. 
 It works partly by preventing an egg from settling in the womb. 
 effective for two to five years copper IUDs, depending on type, or longer plastic IUDs. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 Is effective immediately after fitting. 
 Particularly suitable for a woman who is spacing her pregnancies or who has completed her family, and for older women. 
 Does not interfere with lovemaking. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 Periods may be heavier at first. 
 Sometimes the IUD may come out. 
 Some women develop a pelvic infection &mdash; more likely in younger women who have several sexual partners. 
 There are other extremely rare complications. 
 Not ideal for a woman who has never been pregnant. 
 COMMENTS 
 Inserted by a specially-trained doctor. 
 Copper devices should be replaced every two to five years, depending on type. 
 Women can check the device is in place by feeling for the IUD threads high in the vagina. 
 Tampons may be used. 
 METHOD 
 DIAPHRAGM OR CAP + SPERMICIDE 
 97% effective, with careful use 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 A soft rubber device, put into the vagina before intercourse, to cover the cervix entrance to the womb, and form a barrier which prevents sperm from meeting the egg. 
 Must be used with a spermicide and left in place for six hours after intercourse. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 The diaphragm and spermicide can be put in at any convenient time up to three hours before making love so it needn't interfere at all with intercourse. 
 It may protect against cancer of the cervix. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 Need to plan ahead so that diaphragm/spermicide are in place before intercourse. 
 Must check every six months that cap is the right size, also after childbirth, or weight gain or loss of more than three kilograms seven lbs as size of the vagina may change. 
 COMMENTS 
 A spermicidal cream, jelly, pessary or foam must be used with the diaphragm. 
 Caps &mdash; cervical, vault or vimule &mdash; which are smaller devices that only cover the cervix, are also available. 
 METHOD 
 SPERMICIDES for use with diaphragm and cap 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 Spermicides inactivate sperm. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 Must be used with caps. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 Not an effective method on its own. 
 COMMENTS 
 Essential for use with diaphragm or cap. 
 METHOD 
 CONDOM 
 Sheath 
 Protective Rubber 
 Johnny 
 97% effective, with careful use 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 Made of thin rubber and worn over the erect penis, a condom prevents sperm from entering the woman. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 Easy to obtain and use. 
 Man can take the responsibility for birth control. 
 Can protect both partners against some sexually transmitted diseases and may protect the woman against cancer of the cervix. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 May slip off. 
 Men may find some sensitivity loss during intercourse. 
 Can interrupt lovemaking, although putting condom on could be enjoyed as part of loveplay. 
 Needs care to ensure that no sperm are spilt after ejaculation coming. 
 COMMENTS 
 Must be put on using a anew one each time before the penis touches any part of the woman's vaginal area, and must be held in place when the penis is withdrawn. 
 Approved condoms carry a British Standards Institution &bquo;Kitemark&equo;. 
 METHOD 
 NATURAL METHODS 
 &equo; Safe period&equo; 
 Rhythm method 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 Aims to predict ovulation &mdash; when a woman is most fertile. 
 Intercourse is avoided at this time. 
 The sympto-thermal method involves daily recording of body temperature, noting changes in vaginal mucus and other signs of ovulation. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 No serious physical side-effects. 
 Couples share responsibility for family planning and may become more aware of how their bodies work. 
 Some couples feel they enjoy intercourse more after abstaining during the fertile time. 
 No mechanical devices or hormones are used. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 Much care and restraint necessary from both partners to ensure intercourse does not take place around ovulation. 
 Careful record keeping needed. 
 More difficult to practice for women with irregular cycles, after childbirth and at the change of life. 
 COMMENTS 
 Method must be learnt from a specially-trained teacher. 
 Suitable for couples with religious objections to other methods. 
 The sympto-thermal double check method is the most reliable &bquo;safe period&equo; method. 
 Opinion differs widely on value of these methods. 
 METHOD 
 FEMALE STERILISATION 
 Occasional failures occur 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 A permanent method of birth control in which the fallopian tubes are closed so that the egg cannot travel down them to meet the sperm. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 Is effective immediately after the operation. 
 A once-and-for-all method for couples who are absolutely sure they have completed their family. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 Very occasionally, the tubes rejoin and fertility returns. 
 A few women notice heavier periods. 
 COMMENTS 
 This is a permanent method. 
 It should never be undertaken if in any doubt. 
 Counselling is important. 
  New surgical techniques mean a hospital stay of less than 48 hours. 
 Day-care operation if possible. 
 METHOD 
 MALE STERILISATION 
 Vasectomy 
 Occasional failures occur 
 HOW IT WORKS 
 A permanent method of birth control. 
 The tubes through which sperm travel from the testes to the penis are cut or blocked so that sperm can no longer enter the semen that is ejaculated when the man &bquo;comes&equo;. 
 MAIN ADVANTAGES 
 A once-and-for-all method for couples who are absolutely sure they have completed their family. 
 MAIN DISADVANTAGES 
 It can take many ejaculations to clear sperm already in tube. 
 Another method of birth control must be used for a few months until two consecutive tests show there are no sperm left. 
 Very occasionally, the tubes rejoin and fertility returns. 
 COMMENTS 
 Can be carried out under local anaesthetic at a clinic or surgery. 
 Operation only takes 10&ndash;15 minutes. 
 NB: Withdrawal (&bquo;being careful&equo;) is NOT a reliable method of birth control. 
 These are the birth control methods to choose from: 
 &bull; 
 combined pill/mini-pill 
 &bull; 
 injectable 
 &bull; 
 intrauterine device IUD 
 &bull; 
 diaphragm or cap + spermicide 
 &bull; 
 condom 
 &bull; 
 natural methods 
 &bull; 
 female sterilisation 
 &bull; 
 male sterilisation vasectomy 
 You can fine some information a bout each of these methods on pages 2&ndash;6 of this leaflet. 
 More detailed information is available free on request. 
 WHY USE BIRTH CONTROL? 
 The attraction between a man and a woman can be one of the most powerful emotions known. 
 Not all people who make love want to have a baby. 
 However unless birth control methods are used, sooner or later the woman is likely to get pregnant. 
 Today's methods of birth control make it possible for a couple to choose whether or not to have a child. 
 Advice and supplies are free. 
 It's worth knowing about! 
 There are several birth control methods to choose from. 
 By making sure that you or your partner are using an effective method of contraception, you will be able to relax and enjoy sex much more. 
 And if you do decide to plan a family, you will know that the baby will be wanted and loved. 
 THE BASIC FACTS 
 A woman can become pregnant if, after making love, a sperm released when the man &bquo;comes&equo;, joins with her egg and the egg then settles in her womb. 
 A man and woman who do not want to have a baby can still enjoy lovemaking if they make sure the egg and sperm never meet, or if the egg is prevented from settling in the womb. 
 There are several ways of doing this, but any method chosen must be used properly . 
 No birth control method will work unless it is used regularly &mdash; the one time you take a chance could be the time pregnancy occurs! 
 Different contraceptive methods suit different people at different times, so ask the advice of your family doctor or your family planning clinic. 
 If necessary, try out one or more methods until you find the one that suits you and your partner best. 
 You are far more likely to use a method regularly and properly if you feel it is the right one for you. 
 This leaflet outlines the methods that are available to choose from see pages 2&ndash;6:  pills and injectable  IUDs  barrier methods  natural methods and  sterilisation. 
 If you don't want a child &mdash; don't trust to luck. 
 Use a reliable method of contraception. 
 LET'S GET IT STRAIGHT 
 You sill hear a lot of foolish tales about contraception which are simply not true. 
 So whatever you've heard, these are the true facts : 
 &bull; 
 Breastfeeding does not  prevent pregnancy. 
 &bull; 
 Pregnancy can  occur even if the woman does not  &bquo;come&equo; have an orgasm. 
 &bull; 
 Intercourse in any  position can result in pregnancy. 
 &bull; 
 Pregnancy can  follow first intercourse, and can  even occur without  male penetration. 
 &bull; 
 Pregnancy sometimes occurs when intercourse takes place during  a period. 
 &bull; 
 Douching, however soon after intercourse, will never  prevent pregnancy. 
 &bull; 
 Withdrawal, &bquo;being careful&equo;, can  result in pregnancy. 
 &bquo;MORNING AFTER&equo; CONTRACEPTION 
 If you are unlucky and your contraceptive lets you d own, some doctors and clinics provide &bquo;morning-after&equo; or post-coital advice. 
 This may mean taking a special dose of the combined pill or insertion of an IUD. 
 It is a method only to be used in a real emergency under medical supervision. 
 So don't risk pregnancy &mdash; use a reliable method of birth control every time you make love. 
 It should be available from GPs and family planning clinics. 
 CONTRACEPTION FOR THE OLDER WOMAN 
 As a woman gets older, she may notice changes in the pattern of her periods. 
 When periods finally stop, she has reached the change of life menopause. 
 Contraceptive precautions should be continued until a woman has a period or any bleeding for two years if ages 45&ndash;50, and for one year if over 50. 
 A family doctor or family planning clinic will be able to advise on suitable birth control until then. 
 FREE INFORMATION SERVICE 
 For more details on the contraceptive methods mentioned in this leaflet, write in or 'phone for further information and a leaflet order form to the Family Planning Information Service FPIS, . 
 See page 10 for address and telephone number of your local information centre. 
 Ask for copies of the following free leaflets in print or braille: 
 &bull; 
 The pill 
 &bull; 
 Intrauterine devices 
 &bull; 
 Barrier methods of birth control 
 &bull; 
 Male and female sterilisation 
 &bull; 
 Family planning using the &bquo;safe period&equo; 
 As well as leaflets on family planning, information is also available on women's health care, sexually transmitted diseases and sex education. 
 The Family Planning Association and the Health Education Council provide a free Family Planning Information Service FPIS to help people to know about and use the free National Health Service facilities. 
 HOW TO GET ADVICE 
 You can find out more about contraception  by visiting your family doctor or your nearest family planning clinic. 
 Anyone, married or single, male or female, young or not-so-young can go to a family planning clinic. 
 Your partner is also welcome, so why not go along together to discuss the different methods of birth control? 
 The service is free. 
 All family planning services and supplies on prescription are provided free on the National Health Service if you are ordinarily resident in the UK. 
 The services are available from hospitals, clinics and most family doctors. 
 GPs cannot prescribe condoms. 
 If for any reason you prefer not to discuss birth control with your own family doctor, you are entitled to go to another family doctor for this service. 
 Some clinics have special youth advisory sessions. 
 How to find your local clinic. 
 There are NHS family planning clinics all over the country. 
 You can get the address and times of your nearest clinic from your: 
  Health Centre  Hospital  Midwife  Health Visitor  Telephone directory or Yellow Pages under &bquo;family planning&equo; 
 There are a few fee-paying clinics too. 
 If you wish you can 'phone or write for details of NHS or fee-paying clinics to the Family Planning Information Service . 
 Or contact Family Planning Association offices in Bedford , Belfast, Birmingham, Brighton, Cardiff, Exeter, Glasgow, Liverpool, London, Norwich or Sheffield. 
 This information leaflet replaces those previously issued and those under the title Modern methods of birth control.    
 WHERE THE METHODS WORK Female  
 Mini-pill effect mainly on womb 
 IUD works in womb 
 Combined pill no egg produced 
 Injectable effect mainly on womb 
 Natural methods find &bquo;safest&equo; days to avoid pregnancy 
 Sterilisation stops egg reaching womb 
 Diaphragm or cap + spermicide sperm can't reach egg 
 Spermicide used with diaphragm and cap inactivates sperm 
 Turn to pages 2&ndash;6 to see how these methods work. 
 A note about effectiveness rates: where we say, for example, that a method is 98% effective &mdash; this means that each year, out of every 100 women using the method, 2 will become pregnant. 
 WHERE THE METHODS WORK Male  
 Condom holds back sperm 
 Vasectomy stops sperm release 
 ARE YOU DYING TO GET A SUNTAN? 
 Soaking up the sun is great &mdash; but too much, too quickly and you're risking skin cancer. 
 Protecting yourself and your family is easy&hellip;  
 HEALTH EDUCATION AUTHORITY  In support of Europe Against Cancer Year 
 WHAT YOU CAN DO 
 USE A SUNCREAM OR LOTION WITH THE CORRECT SUN PROTECTION FACTOR SPF. 
 These preparations absorb or block out the sun's harmful ultra-violet rays. 
 You need to find the right one for your skin type. 
 Most have a Sun Protection Factor number, according to the level of protection they give. 
 Unfortunately, different products use different systems of numbering. 
 As a rule, the higher the number, the greater the protection. 
 &bull; 
 If your skin is sensitive and burns easily, or has a tendency to burn &mdash; use a Sun Protection Factor greater than 10 
 &bull; 
 If your skin tans easily, but sometimes burns &mdash; use a Sun Protection Factor greater than 8 
 &bull; 
 If your skin tans easily &mdash; use a Sun Protection Factor greater than 6. 
 You can use a lower factor sun product when you've developed a tan, say, after 2 to 4 days. 
 ASK YOUR PHARMACIST IF YOU NEED MORE ADVICE. 
 REMEMBER: 
 &bull; 
 Put lots on and reapply at least every two hours, as sweat, water, wind and towel friction will wear it away. 
 &bull; 
 Use a sunscreen that protects against both UVA and UVB look on the tube or bottle. 
 &bull; 
 Watch out for sensitive areas like lips, eyelids, nose, cheeks, upper chest, shoulders, nipples, and the soles of your feet. 
 &bull; 
 Don't forget to use a sunscreen on overcast days &mdash; clouds or a breeze can fool you into thinking the sun is weaker than it really is. 
 You can burn just as easily on a cloudy day as on a bright one. 
 If you develop an allergic reaction to your sunscreen, change it. 
 YOUR PHARMACIST WILL BE ABLE TO ADVISE YOU. 
 BABIES AND YOUNG CHILDREN. 
 Keep small babies out of the sun. 
 Use a sunscreen with a SPF greater than 10 from 6 months onwards, and then only let them stay in the sun for short periods. 
 COVER UP 
 Wear loose fitting clothing to protect your shoulders, arms and legs when you're walking around in the sun. 
 A wide-brimmed hat will shade your face and help protect your nose, ears and lips. 
 Get the best sunglasses that you can afford. 
 TAN GRADUALLY 
 Don't rush it. 
 It usually takes three or four days for the pigment which gives you your tan to develop. 
 Build up the time you spend in the sun slowly &mdash; start with 10 minutes and increase gradually. 
 Never stay in the sun until your skin goes red &mdash; the damage has already been done. 
 Don't sunbathe for long periods in the same position. 
 AVOID MIDDAY SUNBATHING 
 Build up exposure in early mornings and late afternoons, when the sun is weaker. 
 WATER AND SAND 
 The sun's rays are reflected off water and sand. 
 So even if you are under an umbrella, for example, you could still get sunburnt. 
 TRY TO AVOID EVEN A SINGLE DOSE OF BAD SUNBURN 
 Remember, sun bathe , not sun bake . 
 You don't have to go red to go brown. 
 THE RISKS 
 The sun is the main cause of skin cancer, the second most common cancer in the UK. 
 Most skin cancers are completely curable, but some can be fatal. 
 One type of skin cancer is malignant melanoma. 
 It can be caused when skin that isn't used to the sun is exposed to short bursts of strong sunlight. 
 Just what happens when you're on holiday! 
 Other types of skin cancer are associated with continued exposure to the sun over a long period. 
 People who work outdoors all the time are more at risk here. 
 ARE YOU AT RISK? 
 EVERYONE should take care in the sun, but you should be especially careful if you have: 
 &bull; 
 fair or freckled skin that doesn't tan or burns before it tans 
 &bull; 
 red or fair hair and light complexioned eyes 
 Even if you've got a darker complexion, or tan easily, you still need to be careful in the sun. 
 YOUNG CHILDREN are extremely vulnerable. 
 The sun can easily damage a child's delicate skin. 
 FOR MORE INFORMATION 
 Most skin cancers are completely curable, especially if detected in the early stages. 
 Malignant melanoma can show itself by a change in the look of a skin mole. 
 A leaflet has been produced by the Cancer Research Campaign which gives information about these changes. 
 Write to them at 2 Carlton House Terrace, London SW1Y 5AR.  
 PROTECT YOURSELF AGAINST SKIN CANCER. 
 MAKING A NEW START. 
 A simple guide to keeping your heart young and enjoying it. 
 A NEW START TODAY, A NEW YOU TOMORROW. 
 A fatal heart attack happens in Britain every three minutes. 
 Heart disease is now our biggest killer. 
 And sadly, many of the people it kills are in their middle years. 
 So much for the bad news. 
 The good news is that you can take steps to prevent heart attacks happening to you and your family. 
 That's what making a new start is all about. 
 It doesn't mean turning your whole way of life upside down. 
 It simply means thinking a little about your diet and daily routine, and improving it a bit at a time. 
 In the long term, your heart will stay healthier. 
 But you'll start feeling better quite soon; a more balanced diet, a little more activity, and a positive attitude are all things that give you a sense of well being and vitality. 
 CUTTING DOWN ON FAT IS EASY. 
 Too much fat in the diet increases the risk of heart disease. 
 Yet it's easy to cut down on fat without changing your diet completely or giving up all your favourite foods. 
 Here are three key points to remember: 
 1. 
 Cut the visible fat off meat before you cook it. 
 Take the skin off chicken before cooking. 
 2. 
 Grill rather than fry. 
 3. 
 Join the move to skimmed or semi-skimmed milk, and low-fat products. 
 This table shows you just how effective simple measures can be.  
 HOW TO SPOT HIDDEN FATS. 
 It's easy to see the fat on a lamb chop &mdash; and easy to cut it off. 
 It's impossible to see the fat that's in a crisp, or biscuit, or chocolate bar. 
 But it is usually there, in surprisingly high quantities. 
 This is what nutritionists call &bquo;hidden fat&equo;. 
 So next time you buy snacks like these, check the labels carefully to see if they're loaded with fat. 
 If they are, choose something different. 
 Why not fresh fruit, or a sandwich? 
 TEN TASTY THINGS YOU CAN EAT MORE OF 
  Jacket potatoes  Beans on toast  Chicken  Pasta  Fish or fish fingers  Vegetables  Fruit  Rice  Bread  Liver 
 YOU DON'T HAVE TO GIVE UP YOUR TIPPLE 
 Perhaps you don't drink alcohol. 
 That's fine. 
 Perhaps you do. 
 That's fine too, as long as you bear in mind that moderation is the key to staying healthy. 
 Think of a pint of beer, or two glasses of wine, as the maximum for one day, rather than the minimum. 
 Drink more than this and you run the risk of developing high blood pressure, which in turn can lead to heart attack or stroke. 
 It's a good idea to ask your doctor to check your blood pressure each visit. 
 WALK AWAY FROM HEART DISEASE. 
 A little exercise helps keep the heart strong. 
 But it doesn't have to be exercise with a capital E. Think of it more as activity. 
 Don't fancy jogging? 
 Embarrassed to go swimming? 
 Many people are. 
 Never mind, walking is good exercise too. 
 A brisk walk, say 20 minutes or half an hour, 3 times a week will do wonders for your circulation. 
 And if you walk in pleasant surroundings, you'll find it a good way to let go of stress, too. 
 NOW FOR THE HARDER PART. 
 Smoking is a cause of 1 in every 5 fatal heart attacks. 
 The only sensible advice here is to stop. 
 No one pretends that giving up smoking is easy. 
 On the other hand, you'll never know if you can do it till you try. 
 To date, 10 million smokers have succeeded in kicking the habit. 
 For most, the first few days were the worst. 
 After that, the compensations make it all worth while; you can taste food again, you have more vitality, you smell better, you feel like a winner which is what you are. 
 If that's not a new start to a better life, what is? 
 FOR MORE INFORMATION: 
 For free booklets on smoking, eating, drinking and exercise, write to:  
 If you want to know more about being healthy, join a local Look after yourself! class. 
 To find out the address of your local office, contact: Look after yourself! 
 Project centre   
 AT LAST 
 Look after your  HEART! 
 SAY WHEN WHEN!  
 I CAN'T FIND MY CAR KEYS  'COS YOU CAN'T SEE OVER YOUR PAUNCH 
 A campaign to promote healthier lifestyles, supported by the Health Education Authority and the Department of Health. 
 AIDS&hellip; 
 Talking with your Children 
 WHY? 
 AIDS is an everyday topic in the papers and on television; there is every chance that your children have become interested, even at a young age, but they may have misunderstood things and have some strange ideas. 
 It is important for you to talk with them about AIDS, to explain the important facts and to answer any questions they may have. 
 HOW? 
 How you discuss AIDS will depend a good deal on the way you operate in your family. 
 Some families talk easily about anything &mdash; others are much more private. 
 If you are someone who finds talking about sex or AIDS difficult or embarrassing, you may find yourself concentrating on the facts, rather than on feelings. 
 But take courage, and try and encourage your children to talk about their feelings too. 
 WHAT? 
 Teaching children should always be taken at the child's pace, answering questions as truthfully and accurately as possible, rather than trying to tell the whole story. 
 Release information in limited quantities so that it can be absorbed and understood. 
 If you don't know the answer, don't be afraid to say so. 
 There is no shame in saying, &bquo;I don't know but I'll try to find out&equo;, provided that you do &bquo;try and find out&equo; and report back. 
 WHEN? 
 Inevitably there are times and places when it is not possible to have a proper discussion on AIDS. 
 Be calm and firm &mdash; promise to talk another time &mdash; and do it soon! 
 THE FACTS 
 AIDS is a life-threatening medical condition caused by a virus known as HIV. 
 There is no way of telling if someone is infected by looking at them, but a special blood test declares a person negative or positive. 
 To be HIV+ does not mean that a person has AIDS. 
 AIDS may develop, or may not, but the person is still capable of passing the virus on to others. 
 The HIV virus is present in the blood and sexual fluids. 
 It is very fragile and dies quickly outside the body. 
 The chief risks of infection are: 
 &bull; 
 Penetrative sexual intercourse, both vaginal and anal, with an infected person. 
 &bull; 
 Blood to blood contact, e.g. from infected blood in needles shared for drugs use. 
 &bull; 
 From a mother, who has HIV, to her child during pregnancy. 
 WHAT ABOUT SCHOOL? 
 If there is a child at school with HIV or AIDS, perhaps born with it or caused from infected blood transfusions, your child is not at risk from everyday contact. 
 Colds and measles may be passed on easily at school, but NOT HIV. 
 You can assure your child that kissing and hugging are not dangerous. 
 Nor are sharing cutlery, sitting at the next desk, going swimming or communal toilets. 
 IT'S MORE THAN AIDS&hellip; 
 Education about AIDS can be useful to reinforce good general health education. 
 We can use such discussions to remind our children of the importance of personal hygiene &mdash; washing hands after using the lavatory, before meals, especially after handling animals. 
 Remember, HIV is not a risk in these situations, but there are other nasty germs around. 
 HOW CAN I TALK ABOUT SEX? 
 Words like &bquo;condom&equo; are now used freely in conversation. 
 Try talking about them when you talk to your child about growing up, relationships and sex. 
 There are several good straightforward books available to help you see book list. 
 Your child's school will value your support in teaching your child about how to make good relationships. 
 We must realise that other children's values may be different, and that our children are affected by the pressure of their peers and others with whom they come in contact. 
 Sex is often a central and vital element of a committed relationship, founded on love, caring respect, honesty and faithfulness. 
 We can remind our children that faithfulness, chastity and married love are not just old-fashioned negative values that inhibit freedom; they are positive life-enhancing virtues. 
 Our children need to be aware that the more sexual partners a person has, the more likely they are to have sex with someone who is HIV+, although the risks of infection are greatly reduced if they practise Safer Sex. 
 You can reassure your children that there are ways to make love which are safe, and there are many ways of showing love other than sex. 
 They also need to be aware of the prevalence and dangers of injecting drugs, and how to reduce the risks. 
 It is naive and dangerous to imagine that our children or their schools couldn't possibly be involved. 
 OUR CHILDREN'S FUTURE 
 Sadly, many more people are going to develop AIDS, some from recent infection, some from infection with the virus years before the risks were known. 
 We can remind ourselves of, and help our children to realise, the need at all times for compassion. 
 It is not for us to judge. 
 People with AIDS have enough to bear. 
 What they &mdash; and their loved ones &mdash; need is our understanding, love, prayers and support. 
 What our children need from us is reassurance, so that they can live safely, knowing the real risks and knowing where they can go if they are worried.  
 WHAT EVERY PARENT SHOULD KNOW ABOUT DRUGS 
 Basic facts for all families with children 
 WHAT ARE DRUGS? 
 Drugs include a whole range of things. 
 Some we all use occasionally, like medicine prescribed by a doctor or bought from a chemist. 
 Others we don't usually think of as drugs at all, like alcohol and cigarettes. 
 But here the word means drugs which are used illegally, such as heroin, cocaine, LSD, amphetamines, barbiturates or cannabis. 
 The effect of any drug depends on the drug itself, how it is used and the person using it. 
 But any of them can cause problems when misused. 
 And all  parents need to know something about them in order to help protect their children from danger, now or in the future. 
 Why does anyone take drugs? 
 There is no single reason. 
 Most youngsters probably start simply from curiosity, or because their friends are doing it. 
 Others like taking risks, particularly if they know their parents or other adults would disapprove. 
 Some may take drugs because they are bored. 
 Some because they don't get along with their parents. 
 Others because they are depressed, worried or resentful about family, school or work problems. 
 Or as a &bquo;cry for help&equo; to attract attention. 
 Depending on how they feel the first time, they may carry on if they enjoy it or if it seems to block out other worries and problems. 
 And if they have enough pocket money or other cash &mdash; say &pound;5 &mdash; to buy whatever is available locally. 
 But it's important to remember that most young people do not  take drugs. 
 And of those that do, few will try them more than once or twice. 
 Even fewer will become addicts. 
 What are the signs of drug-taking? 
 It's difficult to tell when someone is using drugs only occasionally &mdash; unless they are caught in the act, or when intoxicated like being drunk. 
 But here are some of the things you may notice: 
 &mdash; 
 Sudden changes of mood from cheerful and alert to sullen and moody 
 &mdash; 
 Unexpected irritability or aggression 
 &mdash; 
 Lost appetite 
 &mdash; 
 Losing interest in hobbies, sport, schoolwork or friends 
 &mdash; 
 Bouts of drowsiness or sleepiness 
 &mdash; 
 Telling lies or acting furtively 
 &mdash; 
 Money or belongings disappearing 
 &mdash; 
 Unusual smells, stains or marks on the body or clothes, or around the house 
 &mdash; 
 Unusual powders, tablets, capsules, scorched tinfoil or more rarely nowadays needles or syringes. 
 Of course, many of these are just signs of normal growing pains &mdash; particularly those higher up the list. 
 So don't jump to conclusions. 
 What if drugs are taken? 
 &mdash; 
 Don't over-react and take it out on your son or daughter before you know all the facts &mdash; or you could make a small problem bigger 
 &mdash; 
 First, take time to talk to your husband or wife, or perhaps your family doctor, other parents or teachers 
 &mdash; 
 Try to find out if your youngster has any other worries or problems. 
 Above all, show them that you care and will give them all the support and help you can &mdash; even if they are in trouble with the law 
 &mdash; 
 If you want help, or need more information, look at the back page of this leaflet. 
 What are the dangers? 
 The main dangers are: 
 &mdash; 
 Having an accident while intoxicated 
 &mdash; 
 Accidental overdose, leading to unconsciousness or even death 
 &mdash; 
 Dependence or addiction, particularly if drugs are used regularly. 
 In addition, all drugs can have nasty side effects. 
 For example: 
 &mdash; 
 Confusion and frightening hallucinations 
 &mdash; 
 Unbalanced emotions or more serious mental disorders 
 &mdash; 
 First-time heroin users may be sick. 
 Regular users can become constipated and girls can miss their periods. 
 More serious mental and physical deterioration may follow 
 &mdash; 
 Injecting can cause infection leading to sores, abscesses, jaundice and blood poisoning. 
 In an emergency 
 If your youngster overdoses and you find them drowsy or unconscious, here's what to do: 
 &mdash; 
 Make sure they get fresh air 
 &mdash; 
 Turn them on their side and try not to leave them unattended in case they inhale vomit 
 &mdash; 
 Ring for a doctor straightaway, or dial 999 and ask for an ambulance 
 &mdash; 
 Collect any powders, tablets or anything you think may have been used to take the drug. 
 Take them to the hospital with you for the doctor to examine. 
 Afterwards, give your child the chance to talk it over with you. 
 Now may be the time they are willing to tell you what has been going on. 
 Try to encourage them to accept help. 
 Dos and don'ts 
 Prevention is better than cure, so here are some guidelines for avoiding future problems: 
 Do work out your own  attitude to all drugs. 
 Remember, it's more likely that youngsters may turn to drugs if they come from a home where the adults appear to be dependent on legal drugs like tobacco or alcohol. 
 Do remember the same is true for legally prescribed drugs like sedatives and tranquillisers. 
 If you are using these, keep them where they can't be tampered with. 
 Tell your children why they are necessary and explain how the dose is carefully worked out. 
 Do be prepared. 
 Talk with your husband or wife about how you would react if you found one of your children was using drugs. 
 Discuss it with other parents or schoolteachers if there seems to be a problem locally. 
 Do, above all, make time to talk to your son or daughter &mdash; particularly if they want to sound you out on the subject. 
 Get to know their hopes and fears. 
 Give them the confidence that comes from knowing that you care, and will help if they have problems of any sort. 
 All this is important, because young people who have good relationships with their parents are less likely to feel the need to try drugs. 
 Do decide whether it's a good idea to bring up the subject of drugs yourself. 
 This depends entirely on you and your children and there is no simple answer. 
 You must avoid making drug-taking seem acceptable without making the subject a &bquo;no-go&equo; area. 
 Don't dwell only on the horrors and dreadful effects of drugs. 
 However convinced you  are, you will not convince someone who has tried drugs and enjoyed them, or knows someone who has. 
 In fact, it will make anything else you say less believable. 
 Don't be over-suspicious of your children. 
 This could be quite unfair. 
 And it could push them into drug-taking, instead of away from it. 
 If you want to know more&hellip; 
 About drugs 
 Two other leaflets are available from Dept. 
 DM, DHSS Leaflets Unit, PO Box 21, Stanmore, Middlesex HA7 1AY: 
 &mdash; 
 Drugs: What parents can do  DM.2 16 pages of guidance for parents worried that their teenage children are &mdash; or may be &mdash; using drugs. 
 &mdash; 
 Drug misuse: A basic briefing  DM.3 A more detailed guide for anyone who needs to know more about drugs from alcohol and tobacco to solvents and opiates. 
 About glue sniffing 
 This leaflet is available from your local Health Education Unit see in telephone book under Health Authority or in cases of difficulty from:  
  What to do about glue-sniffing  6 pages of advice for parents on the misuse of glue and other solvents. 
 How to get help locally 
 Ask your family doctor or talk to a teacher, social worker, probation officer or Citizens Advice Bureau. 
 They may be able to put you in touch with a drug counselling agency or other local help. 
 If not, contact SCODA  Standing Conference on Drug Abuse at  They have a full list of local services throughout the country. 
 About getting in touch with other parents 
 A chain of self-help groups has already been set up throughout the country by concerned parents. 
 To find out whether there is one in your area contact Families Anonymous  at   
 Shingles 
 will it happen to me? 
 Are you likely to get shingles? 
 &bull; 
 You only get shingles if you have had chickenpox. 
 &bull; 
 The older you are the greater the chance of you having shingles. 
 &bull; 
 1 in 2 people will have had shingles by the age of eighty-five. 
 &bull; 
 Shingles occurs when your body feels &bquo;run-down&equo; due to stress, illness, shock or sometimes medical treatment. 
 How long does shingles last? 
  Shingles usually lasts for 2&ndash;3 weeks. 
 However, some patients may experience pain at the site of the rash for six months or even longer. 
 What are the signs and symptoms of shingles? 
 Shingles is a rash of blisters on the skin accompanied by a severe stinging pain. 
 &bull; 
 To start with you may feel slightly feverish and your skin may feel painful and &bquo;prickly&equo; over the area where the rash will appear. 
 &bull; 
 After 2 or 3 days blisters will appear and form a narrow band on one side of the body or face. 
 &bull; 
 For about a week new blisters will appear. 
 The blisters will itch and then start to dry up forming crusts or scabs which will then disappear. 
 &bull; 
 It's possible to have shingles anywhere on the body. 
 The rash most commonly appears on the chest, stomach and back. 
 Are there any complications with shingles? 
 &bull; 
 Most cases of shingles will clear-up within one month. 
 In some cases however, complications may arise. 
 &bull; 
 The most common complication is a prolonged and often uncomfortable pain which can last for weeks or even months. 
 The chances of getting this pain are greater the older you are. 
 &bull; 
 In those patients with shingles on the face, there is a chance of the infection spreading to the eye. 
 &bull; 
 Less common complications with shingles may include muscle weakness, or infection of the brain encephalitis. 
 What causes shingles? 
 &bull; 
 Shingles is caused by the virus that causes chickenpox: the varicella zoster virus. 
 &bull; 
 Following the initial chickenpox infection, usually during childhood, the chickenpox virus remains inactive in the body. 
 &bull; 
 Shingles arises when some &bquo;trigger factor&equo; reactivates the virus. 
 &bull; 
 Most people only have shingles once in a lifetime but it is possible to have it several times. 
 If I think I have shingles what can I do? 
 &bull; 
 If you suspect that you have shingles see a doctor immediately. 
 &bull; 
 It is important not to touch the rash. 
 It could become infected and take longer to heal. 
 &bull; 
 The blisters in shingles may contain active virus. 
 To stop the spread of the virus avoid close contact with other people. 
 &bull; 
 Wear loose fitting clothes to ease pressure or rubbing on the rash. 
 &bull; 
 Resting ice cubes in a flannel against the rash or bathing in cool water may help. 
 A soothing lotion like calamine can also bring relief. 
 &bull; 
 It is important to slow down, rest properly and to eat sensibly. 
 Pregnancy. 
 What you need to know. 
 The way you look after yourself when you are pregnant is very important, both for you and your baby. 
 This booklet tells you what you need to know and do for a healthy pregnancy, and the delivery of a healthy baby. 
 first things first. 
 As soon as you think you may be pregnant, and certainly by the time you've missed two periods, go to your doctor for confirmation. 
 He may arrange for you to have a pregnancy test. 
 He'll tell you how to collect the sample of urine that is needed for the test. 
 The doctor will work out the date when your baby is due. 
 This is easier if you've kept a note of the date of the first day of your last period. 
 The doctor will also give you a thorough health check, and talk to you about where to have your baby, and how to look after yourself until the birth. 
 Where to have your baby. 
 Most doctors will tell you it's best to have your baby in hospital, especially if it's your first child. 
 Every facility can be provided in hospital, and this is particularly important if special care should be needed. 
 Antenatal care. 
 Your doctor and the hospital will arrange for you to make regular visits for antenatal care. 
 You will either go to an antenatal clinic at the hospital, or to your doctor's surgery or health centre, or you may attend at both places under a &bquo;Shared Care&equo; scheme. 
 It is important for you and your baby's health that you are regularly examined throughout your pregnancy, so make the effort to keep your appointments. 
 Let the clinic or your doctor know if you cannot keep an appointment and be sure to arrange for another. 
 During your pregnancy you will get to know the doctors, midwives and also the health visitor. 
 They will be as concerned as you that you are healthy and happy during pregnancy, and that you should get the best out of the services they offer. 
 So don't hesitate to ask them about anything that may be worrying or puzzling you. 
 Take advantage of the preparation for parenthood classes run in your area. 
 The midwife or health visitor will be able to tell you about these. 
 You will learn about what happens at the birth, and how to look after your baby. 
 And you can meet other mothers-to-be. 
 Looking after yourself&hellip; what to eat. 
 A good diet is essential for everyone but it's extra important when you are pregnant. 
 A healthy diet includes: 
 &bull; 
 meat, fish, eggs, cheese, peas, beans or lentils &mdash; for protein 
 &bull; 
 fresh fruit and vegetables &mdash; for vitamins and minerals 
 &bull; 
 wholemeal bread or high-fibre cereal such as breakfast cereal containing bran &mdash; for roughage, to help avoid constipation 
 &bull; 
 about a pint of milk a day 
 Your doctor may also prescribe extra vitamins or iron tablets for you. 
 If he does, make sure you take them as instructed. 
 You don't have to &bquo;eat for two&equo;; nor should you eat less than normal when you're pregnant. 
 Just eat in quantities that satisfy you, and avoid putting on unnecessary weight by cutting down on sweet things like cakes, biscuits and sweet drinks. 
 Later in your pregnancy you may feel more comfortable eating smaller meals more often instead of large, heavy ones. 
 But still try to keep meal times reasonably regular. 
 The clinic will check your weight gain regularly. 
 It is usually about 9 to 11 kg 20 to 25 lbs by the time your baby is due. 
 If you are seriously over or underweight when you first visit your doctor, he will advise you about your diet. 
 Or you may be referred to a dietitian. 
 Looking after yourself&hellip; exercise and rest. 
 To keep yourself in good health through your pregnancy you need exercise, rest and plenty of sound sleep. 
 How much you take of each depends on you, for no two people are the same. 
 But guard against getting overtired on the one hand, and on the other against become sluggish from too little exercise. 
 You can usually carry on with a sport you enjoy so long as you feel comfortable. 
 But ask your doctor or midwife if you are unsure. 
 Looking after yourself&hellip; visiting the dentist. 
 A visit to the dentist in the early months of pregnancy is a good idea. 
 It is part of making sure your whole body is fit. 
 Besides, dental treatment is free during your pregnancy and until your baby is one year old, so take advantage of this! 
 No smoking 
 Smoking is dangerous, for you and your baby. 
 Babies of mothers who smoke in pregnancy are often small, weaker and slower to develop than other babies. 
 So if you are a smoker, it's very important you give up, at least while you are pregnant, and preferably for good. 
 &hellip; and not too much alcohol. 
 Try to keep drinking to a minimum when you are pregnant, for the sake of your own health and your baby's. 
 Remember, alcohol is a drug. 
 Just as food reaches your baby, so does alcohol. 
 Pills and medicines. 
 Do not accept pills or medicines from anyone but your own doctor or the doctor at the clinic. 
 He knows you well and has your records to consult. 
 Don't listen to the well-meaning friend who says &bquo;two of these will get rid of that headache&equo; or &bquo;a dose of this will cure your constipation&equo;. 
 Taking unprescribed pills or medicines, especially during the first three months of pregnancy, could harm your baby. 
 Problems such as constipation, headaches and indigestion are fairly common in pregnancy. 
 If you are worried about them, talk to your doctor, midwife or health visitor. 
 They can advise you on how to cope with any difficulties. 
 Pregnancy and work. 
 If you've got a job outside the home, it's a good ideas to talk to your doctor and to your employer about the best time for you to stop work. 
 The date you choose can be important if you want to go back to your job after your baby's born. 
 For more information, pick up leaflet Number 4, &bquo;Employment rights for the expectant mother&equo;, at your local unemployment benefit office. 
 If you've worked for one employer for two years or more before leaving to have your baby, you may be entitled to maternity pay. 
 Talk to your employer about this, or look at the leaflet &bquo;Employment rights&equo; mentioned above. 
 Preparing for breast feeding. 
 Breast feeding will be best for your baby. 
 It gives a balanced diet, and protects against infections. 
 It also helps your baby feel loved and secure. 
 Early in your pregnancy, talk to your doctor, midwife or health visitor about how to prepare for breast feeding. 
 They can also advise you about bottle feeding your baby if this is what you prefer. 
 The father's place. 
 Often so much fuss is made of the mother-to-be that the father-to-be feels left out. 
 Yet it's important that he shares your pregnancy in every way he can. 
 Visiting the doctor, attending parentcraft classes, asking questions, reading books and leaflets from the clinic are all things you can do together. 
 Giving up smoking together too is much more likely to be successful than if you have to struggle alone. 
 If you both want the father to be present at the birth, ask about arrangements for this at the hospital as early as you can. 
 Sex in pregnancy. 
 Usually it's fine to go on making love during your pregnancy. 
 You may find that some positions for intercourse become uncomfortable. 
 If so, try to find a different position to suit you both. 
 For a few women, such as those who have had repeated miscarriages, intercourse may have to be limited. 
 Your doctor will tell you if this is necessary. 
 Planning ahead. 
 After the birth, intercourse can begin again as soon as you feel ready and so long as you don't feel any discomfort. 
 Although your chances of becoming pregnant again may be lessened if you are breast feeding your baby, this is not a reliable method of birth control. 
 So talk to your doctor, midwife or health visitor, or your family planning clinic, about contraception. 
 Remember, family planning is free under the National Health Service and you can choose whether to go to a family planning clinic or a GP. 
 Further information on family planning is available free of charge from The Family Planning Information Service  
 Benefits. 
 &bull; 
 While you are pregnant, and for a year after your baby is born, you can get free prescriptions for your medicines. 
 &bull; 
 You can get free dental treatment for the same length of time. 
 &bull; 
 You may be able to get free milk and vitamins if your income is low. 
 If you want to know more about these benefits and how to claim them, pick up leaflet MV.11 at your social security office or most post offices. 
 &bull; 
 You may also be able to get a cash maternity allowance or grant. 
 Pick up leaflet N1.17A, and claim form BM.4, at your social security office. 
 &bull; 
 You can claim child benefit for your baby regardless of your income. 
 Pick up leaflet CH.1 at your social security office. 
 &bull; 
 If you are going to be bringing up your baby on your own, you may be able to get more money every week on top of your child benefit. 
 Pick up leaflet CH.11 at your social security office. 
 There will be someone on the staff at your antenatal clinic who can explain what benefits you can claim.  
 All these leaflets are available free of charge from the Health Education Service of your local Health Authority, or from the Supplies Department of the Health Education Council. 
 Drinking and Pregnancy 
 A guide for pregnant women 
 British Medical Association Professional Division 
 Should you drink if you're pregnant? 
 The best advice if you are pregnant or planning a pregnancy is that you should stop drinking alcohol until after your baby is born. 
 Tobacco, pills and medicines, and alcohol can all harm your baby before it is born. 
 So while you are pregnant, give up smoking, only take pills and medicines with your doctor's advice and stop drinking alcohol. 
 This is especially important during the first few weeks of pregnancy when you might not even know you are pregnant. 
 During this time the baby develops very quickly, so if you are planning to have a baby you should start thinking about your health a couple of months before hand. 
 Look after yourself by eating a balanced and varied diet of protein, dairy products and fresh fruit and vegetables, getting enough rest and cutting out the things that can harm your baby. 
 That way it will have the best possible start in life. 
 The effects of alcohol on an unborn baby 
 When a pregnant woman drinks, the alcohol that enters her bloodstream passes into her baby's bloodstream as well. 
 This happens however much she drinks. 
 For a long time it has been known that heavy drinking during pregnancy can badly affect a baby's development so that when it is born, its face and head are deformed and it is mentally backward. 
 How much alcohol is needed to damage your baby? 
 A woman who takes five or more alcoholic drinks a day two or three times a week while she is pregnant is at a very high risk of harming her baby. 
 A woman who drinks smaller amounts is at less risk, but is still more likely to have a miscarriage than a non-drinker. 
 It is very important not to drink early in the pregnancy, but even if you give up drinking later it will give your baby a better chance. 
 How to avoid harming your baby 
 If you are pregnant or planning a pregnancy, stop drinking alcohol until after your baby is born. 
 If you find it difficult to stop drinking altogether, try to cut down as much as possible. 
 Cutting down on your drinking, even during the last few months of your pregnancy, will help your baby to be healthy at birth. 
 But the best advice is to stay off alcohol altogether until after your baby is born.  
 What to do about Head Lice 
 The Health Education Council 
 What are head lice? 
 Head lice are tiny insects which live in the hair and feed by biting the scalp and sucking blood. 
 They are sometimes greyish in colour, sometimes a dull red or brown. 
 The female head louse lays shiny yellow eggs and glues them one by one to individual hairs, close to the scalp. 
 These eggs, or nits, hatch out, start feeding and soon begin to lay more eggs. 
 As the hair grows, the eggs are carried further away from the scalp and become white or grey in colour, because they have hatched out. 
 Can anyone catch head lice? 
 Yes, although children pick them up much more often than adults do. 
 They catch them just by coming into close contact with someone who is infected. 
 When heads touch, the lice simply walk from one head to the other. 
 How do I know if my child has head lice? 
 The way head lice feed causes itching and irritation. 
 So scratching the scalp is usually the first sign that a child has head lice. 
 By this time, though, the lice have probably been in the hair for several weeks. 
 So don't wait for the scratching to start. 
 Check your child's hair regularly.  
 Look carefully for the eggs, or nits, particularly behind the ears, at the back of the head, on the neck, crown and under fringes. 
 You can't mistake nits for dandruff. 
 Dandruff irritates too, but it is dull, flaky, and loose enough to fall out. 
 The nits are shiny and firmly attached to the hair. 
 That's why it's so difficult to get rid of them. 
 How can I get rid of head lice? 
 It's very important to get treatment for lice and nits as soon as you find them. 
 People who have head lice for some time begin to feel unwell &mdash; in fact, they feel &bquo;lousy&equo;. 
 And head lice can cause other, more serious infections if they are left untreated. 
 So the moment you think one of the family is infected, ask your health visitor, school nurse, local health clinic, doctor or chemist for a suitable treatment. 
 Follow their advice and instructions carefully. 
 Check that no-one else is infected, not just in the family but other possible contacts too, such as your children's friends. 
 What's the treatment for head lice? 
 Treatment is usually a lotion which kills the lice and nits in a few easy applications. 
 It is rubbed into the hair and scalp and then left to dry naturally, because using a hair dryer can destroy its effectiveness. 
 Then, after waiting for a specified length of time, the hair can be shampooed in the usual way. 
 What can I do to avoid catching head lice? 
 Unfortunately, it's always possible to catch head lice, however clean your hair. 
 But there are two important things you should do: 
 &bull; 
 Comb hair regularly. 
 Combing can help to keep lice away. 
 &bull; 
 Check hair carefully and regularly &mdash; every time the hair is washed, for example. 
 If you find lice, get treatment straight away. 
 If you need more advice, ask your health visitor, school nurse or doctor.  
 WHAT TO DO ABOUT GLUE-SNIFFING 
 Advice for parents about glue-sniffing and the abuse of other solvents 
 What is glue-sniffing? 
 Glue-sniffing means breathing in the vapours given off by certain types of glue in order to get intoxicated or &bquo;high&equo;, rather like getting drunk on alcohol. 
 The ingredient that causes this effect is the solvent contained in many brands of glue as well as many other household and industrial products. 
 Why do young people sniff glue? 
 The reasons young people sniff glue vary with each individual. 
 Usually it's out of curiosity. 
 Some do it because they want to belong to a group where sniffing happens to be part of the group's activities. 
 Sniffing is also a cheap and easy substitute for alcohol and can be a pleasurable experience. 
 So young people, who may be unhappy for a number of reasons, might try sniffing to seek attention or to escape from their problems. 
 For most young people it is a passing phase which they will grow out of, but for some it can become a habit. 
 Glue-sniffing and the law 
 It isn't an offence in itself to sniff glue, but the effect on young people can result in possible conviction for public order offences such as threatening behaviour or breach of the peace. 
 It is an offence for a shopkeeper to sell solvent based products to anyone under the age of 18, if they know, or have reasonable cause to believe, that the products are to be abused, and not used for their normal purpose. 
 What are the dangers? 
 By inhaling poisonous vapours, young people put themselves at risk of: 
 &bull; 
 Accidents, which can happen more easily when intoxicated. 
 &bull; 
 Suffocation or unconsciousness. 
 &bull; 
 Hallucinations. 
 Some young people have died as a direct or indirect result of sniffing glue or other solvents. 
 What are the signs? 
 The most obvious signs that someone might be sniffing are: 
 &bull; 
 A chemical smell on the breath or unexplained traces of glue or other solvents found either on the body or on clothes. 
 &bull; 
 Empty containers, such as aerosols or tins. 
 A combination of these signs and the following could also be an indication of sniffing: 
 &bull; 
 Unusual soreness or redness around the mouth, nose or eyes. 
 &bull; 
 Persistent, irritable cough. 
 &bull; 
 Loss of weight/not eating. 
 &bull; 
 Slurred speech. 
 The following can be normal signs of growing up, but if combined with the above may mean there's a problem: 
 &bull; 
 Sudden irritable or moody behaviour combined perhaps with secrecy about movements. 
 &bull; 
 A sudden and uncharacteristic decline in school performance possibly combined with the start of truancy. 
 What you can do 
 Young people are often curious and like to experiment with the latest craze. 
 If you feel that your child may be mixing with youngsters who sniff glue, you could talk to your child and warn him or her of the possible risks and dangers involved. 
 Your interest and support are important to your child. 
 Encourage them to talk to you about any worries or problems they may have. 
 Sometimes young people take to glue-sniffing out of boredom. 
 Encourage your child to get involved in activities at school or in the area. 
 If you think your child may be abusing solvents, think carefully about how you are going to handle the situation. 
 Talk to someone you know. 
 If you react angrily or aggressively, your child may do the same. 
 Don't be over suspicious and try not to over react &mdash; this could be unfair on your child. 
 Teach your child to use household products only for their proper purposes. 
 Teach them to follow any labelling instructions about safety. 
 There are, on average, 30 &bquo;abusable&equo; solvent based products in every house. 
 Keep them in a specific place and discard ones you don't use. 
 In an emergency 
 Don't panic. 
 It's important that you remain calm. 
 Remove any glue or solvents and make sure that your child gets plenty of fresh air. 
 If your child is drowsy or unconscious, lie the child on his or her side. 
 Make sure someone stays near so that if your child is sick, he or she can be prevented from inhaling vomit. 
 When your child wakes up, be reassuring; he or she is likely to be upset. 
 If your child is unconscious dial 999 and ask for an ambulance. 
 After the emergency, give your child the opportunity to talk about the incident and about any other worries he or she may have. 
 If you need further help or information you can contact your doctor, health visitor or child's school. 
 There are organisations in most parts of the country that can help. 
 To find out how to contact an organisation in your area contact your local health education unit in the phone book under the name of your local health authority. 
 The National Campaign Against Solvent Abuse provides leaflets for parents, abusers and professionals. 
 For information write to:   
 AN IMPORTANT MESSAGE for women of childbearing age 
 GERMAN MEASLES is not so harmless as you think 
 This leaflet is about German Measles or, as the doctors call it, Rubella. 
 It explains why it is important that you are protected against it. 
 German Measles is a very infectious disease, but usually very mild. 
 You may not even know you have had it. 
 The usual symptoms are a faint pink rash with a slight fever, perhaps swollen glands or aching joints and a general feeling of being off-colour. 
 It sounds harmless enough, doesn't it? 
 But German Measles can damage your unborn child. 
 If a woman catches German Measles when she is pregnant, it can seriously harm her baby. 
 It can damage the baby's brain, sight, hearing or heart. 
 Some babies affected like this die in the first year of their life, those who do not die can face a lifetime of handicap. 
 This need not happen. 
 Vaccination can protect you against German Measles. 
 What to do? 
 Even if you have no intention of becoming pregnant, don't take a chance. 
 If you have not been vaccinated already, see your doctor now and ask him to check whether you are immune to German Measles. 
 This is done by a quick and simple blood test. 
 If you are already immune, the test will make it clear. 
 Ask for a blood test even if you think you have had German Measles. 
 It can be such a mild disease, and so like other childhood illnesses, you can never be absolutely sure you have had it. 
 So don't rely on your memory. 
 Have the test done. 
 Some family planning clinics will also arrange for you to be given a blood test. 
 Ask at your next appointment. 
 One simple injection gives protection. 
 If the blood test shows you are not immune, one injection will give you the protection you need. 
 It's free and easily arranged. 
 Ask your doctor or at the family planning clinic. 
 Side effects. 
 Side effects from the injection are uncommon. 
 You may perhaps have some mild symptoms of the disease itself. 
 But you won't be infectious and most people are able to carry on just as normal. 
 People especially at risk. 
 Remember, if you are often in contact with young children, either at home or in your job, you run a higher risk of catching German Measles. 
 So it is particularly important for you to be protected against it. 
 Precautions 
 Vaccination should be delayed if: 
 &bull; 
 you are unwell with a fever 
 &bull; 
 you are or think you may be pregnant 
 &bull; 
 you have had certain other vaccinations within the last three weeks &mdash; you can check these with your doctor. 
 You should not have the vaccine if: 
 &bull; 
 you suffer from cancer or an immunity disease 
 &bull; 
 you are on steroids, or on any other drug or medical treatment affecting immunity. 
 You must tell your doctor if you're allergic to certain antibiotics not penicillin, or to rabbits. 
 If you are already pregnant you must not be given German Measles vaccine. 
 But you can ask the staff at the antenatal clinic for the results of your Rubella blood test. 
 If they tell you that you're not immune, you should be vaccinated soon after your baby is born. 
 After the birth, make sure you get your German Measles vaccination so you can be certain you're protected for the future. 
 It is very important that you don't become pregnant for at least three months after you have had the vaccination. 
 If you would like advice on contraception, talk to your doctor or local family planning clinic. 
 REMEMBER. 
 When you protect yourself against German Measles, you're protecting your unborn children.  
 YOUR HEALTH 
 A Guide to Services for Women 
 In general, women are healthier and live longer than ever before, indeed on average they can expect to live 5 years longer than men. 
 But although anyone can catch a cold or break their leg only women have babies or get cancer of the cervix, and, and some health problems, like osteoporosis and cystitis, mostly  affect women. 
 In recent years, a lot of work has gone into improving the quality of care that patients receive from the health service. 
 Particular emphasis has been placed on women's health. 
 Many women have a special, influential role in family health, such as in making decisions about the family's diet and in educating children by their example. 
 This booklet, however, concentrates on women as individuals and outlines the help and services available. 
 It is not a comprehensive guide to symptoms and services, but it should point you in the right direction and show you where to go for help.  
 AT YOUR SERVICE 
 Good health is not just about providing efficient, high quality medical services. 
 In many ways it is also a partnership. 
 There is much that each of us can do to help ourselves &mdash; by not smoking, by eating sensibly, by taking regular exercise, and by not drinking too much. 
 There is also a wealth of support and expertise throughout the health service to turn to when you need help. 
 Your Doctor 
 It is likely that your first point of contact for most medical services will be your Family Doctor or General Practitioner. 
 The GP and the health team which may include a practice nurse will know about the health resources in your area and can arrange specialist help when you need it. 
 Your GP will also keep your details for the systematic screening programmes for breast and cervical cancer. 
 It is essential you are registered with a GP, who needs to have your latest address. 
 GPs are not simply there to give help to people when they are ill. 
 They promote health and help prevent illness in the first place. 
 All will offer general health checks, write prescriptions and immunise against disease. 
 Other services which they and their health team may provide include: 
 &bull; 
 Well Woman Clinics 
 &bull; 
 Family Planning 
 &bull; 
 Health Promotion Clinics which cover aspects of health such as diet, alcohol control, giving up smoking and coping with stress. 
 Different doctors offer different services. 
 All provide a leaflet telling you about the range of services on offer. 
 Before choosing a GP, think about your needs and the  services that a particular surgery offers. 
 The sort of questions you might like to ask the receptionist are: 
 &bull; 
 Is a health visitor or nurse attached to the practice? 
 &bull; 
 Is a woman doctor available? 
 &bull; 
 Are there family planning services? 
 &bull; 
 Are there arrangements for surgeries or clinics out of working hours? 
 &bull; 
 Does the practice work with or employ a midwife? 
 &bull; 
 Are there facilities for young children e.g. play area? 
 &bull; 
 Are there accessible toilet facilities? 
 &bull; 
 Is there a disabled access? 
 If a service or facility you would like is not available, ask about it. 
 The practice might not know that a need exists and may be able to help. 
 Making the most of your doctor 
 Your GP is an expert in health care &mdash; but only you will know exactly what and how you feel. 
 The more openly you and your doctor can talk together, the better the service he or she will be able to give you. 
 Questions you might ask about any problem could be: 
 &bull; 
 what caused it? 
 &bull; 
 how is it treated? 
 &bull; 
 what can I do about it? 
 &bull; 
 are there any long term effects? 
 &bull; 
 how can I prevent it happening again? 
 To make sure everything is covered you could write your questions down before you go. 
 It might also help to make a note of your doctor's answers as a reminder of what is said, for example about any medicines you should take. 
 Sometimes it's not easy to talk about intimate things like sex or your body. 
 Remember it's likely your problem will be common to many other women who attend the same surgery. 
 You might find it helps to bring a friend or relative with you. 
 Service and Choice 
 Everyone has a right to first-rate care and everyone has the right to complain if they're not satisfied. 
 If you aren't happy with the service you're getting from your GP, dentist or optician, then discuss it with them first. 
 They are there to help you and will want to clear away any misunderstanding. 
 If you are still unhappy you can change to another practice. 
 A full list of GPs in your area is obtainable from the library or from your local Family Health Services Authority FHSA address in your local telephone book and you don't have to tell your doctor your reasons for changing. 
 You just ask the doctor of your choice whether you can be taken onto their list.  
 ETHNIC MINORITIES 
 To take account of differences in language and culture a number of services are available for women from ethnic minority communities. 
 Link workers 
 Some health authorities and general practitioners employ link workers. 
 They work in many clinics, health centres and surgeries where there are large ethnic minority communities. 
 The link worker can help overcome language and cultural barriers between the doctor or nurse and the patient. 
 If you wish they can stay with you during a consultation. 
 If you think a link worker might be helpful ask the doctor or nurse if one is available. 
 Advice 
 There are booklets, videos and audio tapes available in ethnic minority languages to advise you on particular health issues. 
 You can ask the Health Promotion Unit of your local health authority address in phone book what material is available and how you can get it. 
 Enquiries 
 Your doctor or the local Family Health Services Authority can tell you about the services available.  
 COMMON HEALTH CONCERNS 
 There are several complaints that may affect women at some time in their lives from period pains and pre-menstrual tension to thrush and cystitis. 
 Often these problems are merely irritating, but for some women the problem can be so severe that the way they live their life can be affected. 
 There is a range of information available on how to cope. 
 Cystitis 
 This usually takes the form of a burning pain when you pass water and the feeling you want to go to the toilet more often than usual. 
 It is very common &mdash; more than half the women in this country suffer from cystitis at some point in their lives. 
 Drinking several pints of water should help to relieve the symptoms in the short term, but, if they persist, you should see your GP as soon as possible. 
 This condition generally responds rapidly to simple treatment. 
 For more information:&hellip; 
 Cystitis &amp; What To Do About It  
 Available from:&hellip; 
 The Health Education Authority  
 Continence 
 Many women suffer from incontinence. 
 If you have a problem, do mention it to your doctor, health visitor or midwife. 
 They will be able to advise you and may recommend exercises to strengthen your pelvic floor muscles or other treatment.  
 Thrush 
 Thrush is caused by a yeast infection. 
 Common symptoms include an intense itching in the vagina and possibly a whitish discharge. 
 If it is recurrent your sexual partner may also need treatment. 
 To soothe the discomfort, if the thrush is severe, your doctor might give you pessaries &mdash; pills you put directly in the vagina &mdash; or cream. 
 For more information:&hellip; 
 A Self-help Guide to Thrush  
 Available from:&hellip; 
 The Health Education Authority 
 Pre-menstrual tension 
 Pre-menstrual tension covers a range of emotional or physical problems that many women suffer before a period. 
 These can include swelling and breast discomfort as well as tension, depression or irritability. 
 If you suffer badly from these symptoms, go and see your doctor who should be able to help. 
 Period Pains 
 Period pains can be severe and disruptive. 
 Sometimes, a mild painkiller is enough to ease the pain but, if it's more of a problem, your doctor will be able to prescribe medicines or give you other advice. 
 For more information:&hellip; 
 Premenstrual Syndrome &amp; Period Pains  
 Available from:&hellip; 
 Women's Health Concern   
 Depression &amp; Stress 
 Events in a woman's life like childbirth see page 23, a break-up in a marriage or partnership, or bereavement, can lead to depression. 
 In some cases this can be painful, distressing and can affect your family and work. 
 If you are depressed, see your doctor, who will be able to discuss your difficulties with you and offer advice. 
 This may involve putting you in contact with specialist help or one of the voluntary organisations that are expert in this field. 
 For help with problems in a relationship see &bquo;Relationships&equo; on page 32. 
 For additional support contact:  
 Sometimes depression is caused by circumstances. 
 In this sort of situation the local Social Services Department may be able to help you with many practical problems, such as caring for a dependent relative.  
 VIOLENCE 
 Physical and sexual assaults against women occur both inside and outside the family. 
 Violence in the home is as much a crime as violence from a stranger, so do not put up with it. 
 You are entitled to legal protection and reporting assaults to the police makes it less likely that they will recur. 
 You can get help from your GP or from your local Social Services Department and you could contact a local rape crisis centre or women's refuge. 
 If you are experiencing domestic violence you can ring the Women's Aid National Helpline on 0272 633542.   
 BREAST AND CERVICAL SCREENING 
 Each year, more than 15,000 women in Britain die from breast cancer and about 2,000 from cancer of the cervix. 
 Many of these deaths could have been prevented if the disease had been discovered earlier. 
 To reduce these figures, two major national screening programmes have been introduced &mdash; the first of their kind in the European Community. 
 Women in the age groups described below are now entitled to free and regular screening. 
 If you are on your GP's books, then you'll be picked up by the schemes. 
 Make sure you take advantage of the service. 
 Cervical Cancer 
 The cervix is the neck of the womb. 
 In certain cases its cells undergo changes, which in time can lead to cancer. 
 But these changes in the cells mean that cervical cancer can be prevented before it starts. 
 By carrying out a smear test, doctors can detect the abnormal cells that might become cancerous in time and then treat them easily and simply. 
 The national screening programme will enable all women between the ages of 20 and 64 to be tested at least every five years you should have received your invitation for screening by 1993. 
 The smear test takes less than five minutes and normally only causes slight discomfort. 
 The great majority of women won't have any abnormalities. 
 If your smear isn't normal it doesn't always mean you need treatment. 
 Sometimes all that is needed is for the  smear to be repeated in 6 months or a year. 
 If treatment is  needed the success rate is very high. 
 Major surgery is rarely necessary. 
 You generally won't have to stay overnight in hospital. 
 The early treatment of abnormal cells will not affect your drive or fertility. 
 For more information:&hellip; 
 The Cervical Smear Test &mdash; Why You Need It   
 Breast Cancer 
 Breast cancer kills more women than any other form of cancer. 
 It is more common in older women but, if the small changes are discovered early, there is a better chance of a successful recovery &mdash; and less likelihood of serious surgery. 
 The national breast screening programme is free and offers mammography breast X-rays every three years to all women between the ages of 50 and 64. 
 Older women can also be screened every three years on request. 
 The service is provided by nearly 80 special screening centres throughout England &mdash; at hospitals, clinics or mobile units. 
 If you are in the relevant age-group, and have registered your address with your GP, then you should automatically get an invitation by the end of 1993.  
 Women below 50 will not be invited routinely. 
 Mammography is less accurate at detecting cancers in younger women. 
 This can lead to unnecessary investigations. 
 Also it is not advisable to have X-rays more often than is really needed. 
 For more information:&hellip; 
 NHS Breast Screening &mdash; The Facts   
 Although routine screening is available for certain groups of women it is still important for your to maintain an awareness of your own health. 
 You should know what is normal for you and consult your GP if any changes occur which concern you. 
 All women should register with a GP and ensure that they notify the practice of any change of address. 
 This will ensure that you are invited for screening as appropriate. 
 Some may find it inconvenient to take the time off work to be screened. 
 Your GP may be able to offer out-of-work-hours cervical screening and you should ask your employer about workplace screening or getting the necessary time off to have it done.  
 Help and counselling about breast and cervical cancer are available from:   
 FAMILY PLANNING 
 Free family planning advice and services are available under the NHS from most family doctors and family planning clinics. 
 In some areas there may be special clinics for particular groups such as young people, or services provided by voluntary organisations to complement NHS facilities. 
 Women are free to choose where they want to go for advice and treatment. 
 Forms of contraception 
 There are many different types of contraception available. 
 You can discuss with your doctor or family planning clinic which is most suitable for you. 
 They include: 
 &bull; 
 the oral contraceptive pill 
 &bull; 
 the intra-uterine device IUD or coil 
 &bull; 
 the diaphragm or cap 
 &bull; 
 the condom 
 &bull; 
 the sponge 
 &bull; 
 injectable contraceptives 
 &bull; 
 sterilisation for you or your partner. 
 This is a permanent method of contraception and is only recommended for those who are absolutely sure that they do not want any more children. 
 Most forms of contraception are available from family planning clinics but GPs are not able to prescribe condoms on the NHS, although some may have agreements with local Health Authorities to supply them to their patients. 
 You can, however, buy some forms of contraceptives like the condom or sponge from chemists or other retailers. 
 GPs and family planning clinics can also provide advice to those who wish to use natural methods of seeking to avoid pregnancy.  
 Contact your local Family Health Services Authority or District Health Authority for information on the availability of local services the address will be in the phone book. 
 Information can also be obtained from:   
 In case of emergency 
 Emergency contraception sometimes called &bquo;the morning after pill&equo; may protect you against pregnancy if you have had sexual intercourse without contraception or if you think that the method you have used may not have worked &mdash; but it should never be used as a regular method of family planning. 
 There are two methods of emergency contraception &mdash; a pill that can be used up to 72 hours after intercourse and an IUD method that may be fitted within five days. 
 GPs or local family planning clinics will be able to advise you on these. 
 Safer Sex 
 Sex is a natural way of expressing human feelings but sometimes there are risks, including the possibility of catching a sexually transmitted disease &mdash; for example gonorrhoea, syphilis or chlamydia. 
 Most sexually transmitted diseases are curable. 
 Now there is the risk of infection with HIV, the Human Immuno Deficiency Virus which causes AIDS. 
 There is as yet no vaccine against HIV infection and no cure for AIDS. 
 You can get confidential help from your GP or local Genito-Urinary Medicine clinic.  
 Remember that, although in this country the impact of HIV and AIDS has up until now been mainly confined to homosexual men and injecting drug users, the infection can also be transmitted between men and women by unprotected sexual intercourse. 
 This is the most common cause of transmission worldwide. 
 Also, remember that many people with HIV infection may remain perfectly well for some years, and it is not possible to tell who is infected just by looking at them. 
 So if you have any doubts at all&hellip; use a condom. 
 Used properly they act as a contraceptive and  can protect you from HIV and other sexually transmitted diseases. 
 Contraceptives, such as the pill, do not  provide protection against these. 
 For free, confidential advice and help you can ring the National AIDS Helpline on 0800 567123, any time, any day. 
 the Helpline will also give you details of the telephone advice services available in various ethnic minority languages. 
 For more information:&hellip; 
 Women and AIDS  Your Guide to Safer Sex and the Condom    
 PREPARING FOR PREGNANCY 
 It helps to plan for your pregnancy before  you become pregnant and above all to concentrate on your health. 
 The healthier you are when pregnant, the healthier your baby is likely to be. 
 Get immunised 
 For adults, catching German Measles Rubella won't do you much harm. 
 But if you do catch it when you are pregnant, your unborn child could be seriously affected and born deaf, blind or brain damaged. 
 Your GP will be able to immunise you free of charge if you need it. 
 After immunisation you must wait at least 1 month before becoming pregnant. 
 Eat properly 
 Eating well before and during pregnancy is very important. 
 It keeps you fit and helps you to have a healthy baby. 
 You don't need a special diet and &bquo;eating for two&equo; could mean you put on too much weight. 
 Enjoying a variety of foods gives you all the nourishment you need. 
 There are certain precautions women should take during pregnancy, for instance, avoiding certain foods and being careful about contact with animals. 
 Your doctor, midwife or health visitor will tell you about these. 
 For general advice on diet, see page 27&ndash;28.  
 Stop smoking 
 If you smoke when you're pregnant, it is not just your own health you are damaging. 
 Smoking can affect the developing baby by holding back its growth. 
 There is a higher risk that your baby will be underweight at birth and you run a greater risk of complications when your baby is born. 
 For further information and &bquo;Smoker's Quit Line&equo; number see page 29. 
 For more information:&hellip; 
 So You Want to Stop Smoking   
 Cut down on alcohol 
 It is probably best to cut out alcohol altogether when pregnant. 
 Never drink heavily during pregnancy. 
 See page 29&ndash;30 for more information and contact addresses. 
 Medicines 
 Some medicines, whether prescribed or bought from the chemist, can damage your baby very early in a pregnancy. 
 If you take any form of medicine or tablet, check with your doctor first. 
 Drugs Misuse 
 Misusing drugs in pregnancy can seriously harm your baby and even lead to the birth of a baby dependent on drugs. 
 If you are involved in any form of drug misuse consult your doctor.  
 Infertility Services 
 It takes different people different lengths of time to conceive. 
 Indeed, one in ten couples find it takes them over a year, while for others it is much quicker. 
 But if you're worried, go to your doctor for advice. 
 Some cases of infertility are easy to treat, although others require complex treatment which may, in any case, not be successful. 
 For further help contact:  
 Maternity Services 
 There's a wide range of services offered by the NHS to help you through every stage of your pregnancy, including regular antenatal classes, designed to keep you well and to prepare you and your partner for the birth and for looking after your child. 
 All services are free. 
 Make sure you go to see your doctor as soon as you suspect you are pregnant. 
 Free Prescriptions and special help 
 If you're pregnant, you can get free prescriptions and free dental treatment. 
 And if you're on income support, you'll be entitled to 7 pints of milk a week and free vitamins. 
 Just show your social security office the certificate of pregnancy which you can get from your doctor or midwife.  
 Screening 
 When you are pregnant, it is possible your GP will suggest a number of tests &mdash; an ultrasound scan for example &mdash; to check that both you and your baby are in good health. 
 Such tests are normally safe. 
 Make sure you understand what you are being offered and why, and also the possible effects they may have. 
 For further information:  
 Abortion 
 Sometimes, because of the circumstances, termination of a pregnancy may need to be considered. 
 A GP is generally in the best position to advise, but advice can also be obtained from a pregnancy advice bureau registered by the Department of Health or one or more of the voluntary bodies which may include religious organisations which offer help to pregnant women. 
 Details of these can be found in your local telephone directory: look under &bquo; pregnancy test services &equo; in the Yellow Pages.  
 The loss of a baby 
 Unfortunately, some pregnancies result in miscarriage or stillbirth; or a baby does not survive beyond the early stages of life. 
 Professional staff, including your GP, hospital consultant or midwife, will be able to provide you and your partner with immediate support and advice. 
 The following organisations can also provide help.   
 BIRTH AND BEYOND 
 Your midwife or GP will be able to tell you about the types of care available which may include: a hospital maternity unit, a GP maternity unit, or a home birth. 
 Soon after the birth, you and your baby will be visited by a health visitor who will tell you about health checks for the baby either from your GP or from your local child health clinic. 
 Breastfeeding 
 There is no doubt that breastfeeding is best for your baby and you. 
 It's natural, promotes your child's growth and helps to protect against allergy and infection. 
 It's also convenient and free. 
 For mothers who choose not to breastfeed, bottlefeeding provides a safe alternative. 
 Depression 
 It's not unusual for many women to feel depressed a few days after giving birth. 
 For most it's a temporary phase, caused by a variety of factors &mdash; not least tiredness. 
 But if the feeling persists then see your doctor or health visitor and let them know just what you're feeling and for how long you've felt it. 
 Immunisation 
 You should get your child immunised as soon as possible against Diphtheria, Tetanus, Whooping Cough, Polio, Measles, Mumps and Rubella. 
 Your GP or health visitor will make the necessary arrangements at the correct time.  
 GROWING OLDER 
 As you get older, the pressures of work, home and family can make it very easy to forget your own health. 
 Events like bereavement or retirement can increase the pressure. 
 The Menopause 
 The menopause is a natural event in every woman's life. 
 It marks the end of her periods and her capacity to bear children. 
 At the same time, for many women it can also mark a new beginning. 
 The average age for the menopause to occur is 50 &mdash; in some women it can start as early as 35 and in others as late as 60. 
 But just as adolescence brings about major changes in your body, most women experience some physical and emotional change during the menopause. 
 Sometimes this can be very unsettling. 
 Common symptoms include hot flushes and dryness of the skin and vagina. 
 Some women also go through varying emotions, including depression and irritability. 
 If your everyday life is affected by menopausal symptoms see your doctor. 
 If it is suitable for you, your doctor might suggest Hormone Replacement Therapy HRT to relieve the symptoms. 
 If further bleeding occurs a year or more after your periods have stopped, you should always consult your doctor.  
 Osteoporosis Brittle Bones 
 Osteoporosis is a condition that mainly affects women after the menopause. 
 Their bones may become fragile and break more easily leading to fractures of wrists, hips and bones in the spine. 
 There may be back pain and loss of height. 
 A healthy lifestyle, including taking exercise and avoiding smoking and heavy drinking see page 27&ndash;30 will reduce the possibility of developing osteoporosis. 
 Your doctor will advise you whether any other action is necessary. 
 If you have already developed osteoporosis, they may be able to treat it or refer you to a specialist. 
 For help and information:  
 Elderly People 
 Getting older does not necessarily mean losing independence. 
 Though people expect illness to become more frequent in old age, you should not assume that nothing can be done, but should consult your doctor if you think you have a health problem. 
 You should continue to lead a healthy life, such as eating a balanced diet, taking  exercise and keeping warm. 
 GPs must offer an annual health check to all their patients aged 75 and over. 
 You do not have to accept this offer, but it makes sense to do so. 
 It is free of charge and can help to detect early signs of health problems and prevent them developing. 
 When necessary, the health and social services can offer help to people to keep their independence with a range of special services including domestic help, delivery of cooked meals, sitters-in and night attendants. 
 For more information:   
 LOOKING AFTER YOURSELF 
 Being healthy is more than a question of not being ill. 
 Although the health services outlined in this book can give you vital help and treatment, you need to help yourself as well, by taking care of what you do and eat. 
 Exercise 
 Taking regular exercise is one of the healthiest things that women can do. 
 Not only can it help control your weight and prevent heart disease, it will make you look and feel better. 
 And exercise is not just a matter of jogging or sport &mdash; it can mean other enjoyable activities like dancing, swimming and walking. 
 If you can exercise just two or three times a week, for about half an hour at a time, you will keep your body in shape. 
 For more information&hellip; 
 Exercise. 
 Why Bother?   
 Healthy Eating 
 Eating regular nourishing meals is important to keep yourself fit and well. 
 Make sure you eat a wide variety of the foods you enjoy. 
 Go easy on fatty foods and avoid adding extra sugar but include plenty of fruit, vegetables and cereal foods in your diet. 
 You also need to be aware of certain precautions that should be taken in the handling, preparing and storing of food.   
 For your health's sake, it is important not to let yourself get overweight. 
 See where you are on this chart.  
 Smoking 
 There is not doubt at all that smoking can seriously damage your health. 
 Not only are you much more likely to die from lung cancer or heart disease, but other illnesses highlighted in this booklet, including cervical cancer, are associated with smoking. 
 You should not smoke if you are pregnant see page 19. 
 Giving up is not easy, but many women manage it. 
 You could too. 
 For further information, help and advice contact:  
 Alcohol 
 Alcohol in moderation is fine &mdash; but if you over-indulge, then you can do yourself serious harm. 
 In the long term, too much drink can cause high blood pressure and stomach disorders. 
 It can cause severe problems at home or at work for you, your family and others. 
 Alcohol affects women and men differently because of the way their bodies are made, so remember that for women the sensible drinking limits are lower. 
 See page 19 for alcohol and pregnancy.0   
 For advice, information and access to over 40 local centres around the country contact:  
 If you've got family or friends with a problem:   
 Drugs Misuse 
 It is dangerous to misuse drugs in any way. 
 You can get treatment for drug dependence, mostly as an outpatient. 
 The voluntary sector also provides advice, counselling and rehabilitation services. 
 Tranquilliser Dependence 
 Many local drug treatment centres provide services to meet the particular needs of people dependent on drugs such as tranquillisers. 
 Your GP can also advise you.   
 OTHER HELP AVAILABLE 
 Social Services for Women and Their Families 
 A wide range of services is available from your local Social Services Department address and telephone number under the local authority or council  in your phone book. 
 These services are not just for women, but you may find them useful. 
 They include services for: families with children; elderly people; mentally ill people; physically handicapped people including those with poor sight or hearing; and people with learning difficulties. 
 Help may also be available for those who care for others, for example if you are looking after a disabled person or an elderly relation. 
 Ask your local Social Services Department for advice and for detailed information about the services they provide. 
 They will also be able to give information about local voluntary agencies which may be able to offer you advice or support, and also about local services for people with special difficulties such as problems with alcohol, drugs or gambling. 
 Relationships 
 Every area will have a Relate office for advice on marriage and partnerships. 
 Counsellors are available to talk to and advise individuals and couples about marital or partnership problems, preparing for marriage and parenthood. 
 For information contact your local Relate office address and telephone number in your local phone book. 
 Other Difficulties 
 Many problems can cause stress or personal difficulty, which in turn can affect your health. 
 You can get advice on a wide variety of subjects including money or debt, legal difficulties and housing from the Citizens Advice Bureaux. 
 See the local telephone book for the address and telephone of the nearest branch. 
 The services provided by the NHS are there to be used. 
 You are not wasting your doctor's time by asking about something which worries you. 
 Your doctor wants to help you. 
 If you are concerned about the provision of any part of the health services in your area you can contact your local Community Health Council. 
 The address can be found in the library, post office or the GP's surgery. 
 This booklet covers some of the many services available and more importantly how to make use of them. 
 The leaflets and organisations mentioned are just some of the sources of information and advice. 
 Your local library, Citizens Advice Bureau, or the Social Services Department of your local authority will be able to give details of help available in your area or tell you where detailed advice can be sought. 
 The Health Education Authority gives people the information they need to look after themselves. 
 For more information on looking after your own health, or the health of family and friends, contact:   
 There is a wealth of useful information about pregnancy and birth, available from organisations like the Health Education Authority. 
 The Pregnancy Book is given free through the NHS to all first-time expectant mothers. 
 Your height in feet and inches 1 foot = approx 0.3 metres 
 Your weight in stones 1 pound = approx 0.45 kilograms 
 Underweight. 
 Maybe you need to eat a bit more. 
 If you are very underweight, see your doctor. 
 O.K. This is the desirable weight range for your health. 
 Overweight. 
 Your health could suffer &mdash; don't get any fatter! 
 Fat. 
 It's important for you to lose weight. 
 Very fat. 
 This is severe and treatment is urgently required. 
 One unit of alcohol equals 1 single measure of spirits = 1 small glass of sherry = 1 single measure of aperitifs = 1 small glass of wine = &frac12; pint of ordinary strength beer lager or cider 
 Estimate your weekly total 
 Adapting Your Home 
 OXFORDSHIRE COUNTY COUNCIL Social Services  CARING COUNTYWIDE  
 Contents 
 Preface  
 Introduction 
 Financial Help with Adaptations 
 Plans, Building Regulations and Building Approvals 
 Flow Chart 
 Installing a Stairlift 
 Through Floor Lifts 
 What Other Grants are available? 
 Specialist Equipment 
 Accessibility for the people of Ealing 
 Further Information 
 Useful Addresses 
 The Motability Scheme 
 PREFACE 
 Being able to stay in your own home or setting up a home of your own is something that most people value greatly. 
 It is an important feature of being independent and a vital ingredient of providing care in the community to people with all kinds of disabilities. 
 This booklet has been prepared to give general information about adapting your homes and about other options that may help you establish and maintain independence. 
 I hope that you will find it useful. 
 In order that as many people as possible may benefit from the information please take a copy if you know of someone else who would find the booklet helpful. 
  Jon Winter  Director of Social Services   
 INTRODUCTION 
 At first, making adaptations to your home may seem a very complicated process, because of the information you need to gather together, and the number of people who have to be involved. 
 There are several people who will probably need to help you with various parts of the work from the very beginning to completion; Environmental Health Officers, Builders, Architects or Surveyors, Building Control Officers and Occupational Therapists. 
 For most people one of the first questions to answer is &bquo;How am I going to pay for it?&equo;  
 What financial help is available? 
 Since July 1st 1990 the major source of financial help is through the Environmental Health Department Borough or City Council. 
 Disabled Facilities Grants are available to people who are disabled, for works which improve their access to essential facilities and which are supported by Social Services Department as being &bquo;necessary and appropriate&equo;. 
 The address of your local EHO Department is at the end of this book. 
 What will the grant fund? 
 The adaptation work should help to overcome or remove any obstacles that prevent you from enjoying the use of your present facilities. 
 Such as: 
 1. 
 getting into the house of flat&hellip; you may have steps that need ramping, or doors that need widening, 
 2. 
 being able to get into a living room, or main family room, 
 3. 
 being able to get into a room that can be used as a bedroom, either upstairs or downstairs, 
 4. 
 being able to get to a room where there is a bath/shower, toilet and wash basin and be able to use them, 
 5. 
 being able to prepare a meal or snack, if this is suitable for yourself, 
 6. 
 being able to control heating, lighting and power. 
 Other works may be eligible, but grants for these will be offered at the discretion of the Environmental Health Department. 
 Your house should also be in reasonable repair to obtain a grant, but if it isn't, help may be available through Renovation Grants &mdash; seek advice from your local council.  
 Is there a limit to the grant and will I have to pay anything? 
 There is no limit to the amount of grant available, but it will be offered for &bquo;reasonable&equo; costs only. 
 If additional work, or special items such as gold taps are requested by you, then you will be expected to pay for these. 
 It is important to agree on, and understand the limit of the works that are being done before work starts. 
 The Environmental Health Officer will however carry out a Financial Test of resources to determine how much, if anything, you are expected to pay towards the &bquo;reasonable&equo; costs. 
 He/she will tell you how much this is at the beginning so you know at the start how much you have to pay. 
 You will then need to gather together the necessary things to make an application.  
 How do I raise the money I am to pay? 
 The amount that you are assessed to pay is based on what you should be able to afford to take out as a loan. 
 It may be that you choose to obtain a mortgage, second mortgage or a loan from a bank. 
 If you feel that you will be unable to take out a loan in this way or that it will cause you financial hardship, you can apply to the Social Services Department for help. 
 They will ask you further information about your finances and/or your situation and may then in certain circumstances by able to offer you a loan. 
 You should tell your Social Services Occupational Therapist that you wish to apply to Social Services for financial help as soon as you know to prevent delay. 
 Remember if you are on an income related benefit it is likely that you will receive a grant for all the &bquo;reasonable&equo; costs. 
 Starting to plan what I need &mdash; who helps with this? 
 The Social Services Occupational Therapist will visit you to discuss the type of adaptation that Social Services would be prepared to support. 
 He/she will work with you and your family to plan what is needed, using knowledge about what is available, what works well and your own experience. 
 It is important that you a shared involvement in this process. 
 The Occupational Therapist is there to try and help you find a solution to your problem. 
 Once you have some ideas of what would suit you, you will need help to take these ideas forward. 
 You can contact your Social Services Occupational Therapist at your local Social Services Office &mdash; Address at the end of the Book.  
 Help with plans. 
 Who do I ask? 
 It will be necessary for you to seek help and advice from someone who knows about building and plans. 
 You may already know someone. 
 You should seek advice from an Architect, Building Surveyor or Builder. 
 These people will help you prepare plans, obtain building regulation approval, planning permission if needed find and supervise a builder. 
 Fees for this can be included as part of the &bquo;reasonable&equo; cost of the work and grant given. 
 Preliminary plans will show what the adaptation will look like &mdash; make sure that these are explained to you. 
 The Environmental Health Officer and Occupational Therapist will also want to comment on these plans, to give advice on whether the planned work is suitable and acceptable. 
 Some Environmental Health Departments may have agencies who can deal with this part for you &mdash; Ask them &mdash; Social Services also may have help available &mdash; Ask your Occupational Therapist.  
 Site Visits 
 Sometimes it is necessary for all the people involved in your adaptation to meet together with you at your home. 
 This is to enable everyone to advise you on the possibilities you may choose to explore. 
 Often during a site visit measurements will be taken and checks made on supply of gas, electricity and position of drains. 
 SEE FLOW CHART PAGE 27 
 If it is only a small job, will I need Building Regulation Approval or Planning Permission? 
 Most new work needs approval from building control, to ensure that the work meets necessary standards. 
 Planning Permission depends on the size of the work and whether it affects other priorities. 
 Both applications are dealt with by your District Borough or City Council Planning and Building Control Section. 
 If you have an architect, surveyor or agent working for you they will do this for you. 
 Once I have plans and all the building approvals, what happens next? 
 If a builder has already worked with you to obtain the above, he will also give you an estimate for the work. 
 If not you will need to choose a builder an agent, architect or surveyor will help you with this, to give you an estimate. 
 It is important to obtain detailed estimates. 
 The Environmental Health Officer will advise you of how many estimates you need to send with your application. 
 Choose a builder carefully &mdash; your Environmental Health Department may have a list to help you.  
 How do I make the application? 
 Have I got all the things I need to do this? 
 To make the formal application you will need to complete the forms given to you by your Environmental Health Officer. 
 He/she will help you to complete these if you have any problems. 
 You will also need to supply documentation about the ownership of your home. 
 Your Occupational Therapist will have written to the Environmental Health Officer to support your application and you will have had an initial test of resources. 
 The application forms should be submitted together with copies of the plans, building and planning approval and copies of the estimate. 
 You should also by now know how you are going to find your part of the cost. 
 When can work start? 
 When you receive the Grant Approval Notice from the District Borough or City Council, you can contact your builder to arrange a starting date or your advisor, architect, surveyor will do this for you. 
 DO NOT START ANY WORK UNTIL YOU HAVE RECEIVED THIS APPROVAL. 
 If you have applied to the Social Services to help with funding you must be sure that you have their written approval too before work starts.  
 What happens when the work starts? 
 You will be asked to let the Environmental Health Officer and the Occupational Therapist know when the work starts. 
 They may wish to visit during the building stages. 
 You must also let them know when the work is complete. 
 If the builder encounters some unforeseen work don't panic, but you must advise the Environmental Health Officer immediately; they should be able to assist with additional finance if they are giving you a grant. 
 When will the money be paid? 
 When the work is finished the Environmental Health Officer and the Occupational Therapist will inspect the work. 
 When you and they are satisfied with the work, the grant will be released to you and you can then pay the builder. 
 It may be possible to have money paid stage by stage during the building process. 
 Ask your Environmental Health Officer.  
 Applications for people who live in council property 
 For some types of work your District Council may expect you to apply for a grant as a tenant. 
 If they support the work they may provide financial help towards the cost. 
 The District Council may offer to rehouse you if this is more suitable for you, and it is an option that you might want to consider. 
 If you are living in council property you must discuss adapting your house with the housing department. 
 The Social Services Occupational Therapist will help you with this. 
 Applications for people living in privately rented property 
 You may apply as a tenant for a grant, or your landlord may apply on your behalf. 
 You must have the approval of your landlord if you are making the application. 
 Applications for people living in Housing Association Property 
 You may apply as a tenant for a grant, or the Housing Association may apply on your behalf. 
 In some cases the Housing Association will fund the work. 
 You will need the support of the Social Services Occupational Therapist for the work.    
 The Flow Chart may help to clarify the procedure. 
 &equo; Making adaptations to your home may seem a very complicated process&hellip; &bquo; 
 &equo; There is no limit to the grant available&hellip; but.&equo; 
 &equo; Seek help from someone who knows something about building and plans.&equo; 
 &equo; Do not start any work until you have received written approval.&equo; 
 &equo; If the builder encounters some unforeseen work&hellip; 
 DON'T PANIC!&equo; 
 INSTALLING A STAIRLIFT 
 In some instances a lift will be the solution to your problem of access. 
 If so you will want to know&hellip; 
 What types of lift are available? 
 There are two main types of lifts &mdash; Stairlifts and Through Floor Lifts. 
 Stairlifts 
 These lifts fit on the staircase. 
 There are several sorts to suit various needs. 
 They can have a seat on which you can travel facing sideways, or facing to the front; a platform on which you can stand, or a platform on which a wheelchair will travel. 
 Stairlifts normally have a weight limit of 20 stone. 
 What if I have a curved staircase or a platform landing? 
 Some companies make lifts that fit on to curved stairways or have automatic platforms that bridge the difference between the two steps at a platform landing. 
 Ask the advice of the Occupational Therapist; Social Services will also arrange for someone to give further advice. 
 Will a stairlift obstruct the stairs? 
 It will take up room on the stairs, so remember that the space left for other people using the stairs will be less. 
 It is not suitable to put a lift on a very narrow stairway. 
 Normally 33&ins; is the minimum required.  
 Will I need room at the top and bottom of the stairs? 
 The answer to this is Yes. 
 The chair has to come to rest at the bottom of the stairs and you need room to get on and off at both ends. 
 Some lifts have rails that can fold up at the bottom if space is tight or if a doorway is going to obstructed. 
 Some have swivel seats to make getting on and off easier. 
 Are they safe? 
 All lifts are fitted with Key Switches that can turn them off to prevent children playing with them. 
 Lifts also should have a micro sensitive pad at the bottom which means the lift will cut out and stop the moment it touches or lands on anything. 
 The British Standards Institute have issued standards to cover lifts. 
 Make sure the lift you are having installed meets with these standards. 
 B.S. 5776 &mdash; Powered Stairlifts 
 B.S. 5900 &mdash; Powered Homelifts. 
 Are grants available for stairlifts? 
 You may apply for a Disabled Facilities Grant towards the installation of a lift. 
 Remember the work will need to be supported by the Social Services Occupational Therapist and you will have a test of resources. 
 The lift must not be installed before you have grant approval. 
 The Social Services Department may be able to help with a maintenance scheme &mdash; contact the Social Services Occupational Therapist for further information. 
 If you are putting the lift in and paying for it yourself it is wise to take out a maintenance agreement and add the lift to your Home Contents Insurance.  
 Through Floor Lifts 
 These lifts go up through the ceiling into the room above. 
 There are several types&hellip; some suitable for use by a wheelchair user and others simply for people to stand or use a seat. 
 The lift needs space available in the ground floor and upstairs room for manoeuvring in and out. 
 How is the lift fixed? 
 The tracks are usually fixed to the wall with special types of fixings. 
 The wall should be a load-bearing wall preferably an outside wall. 
 There are various ways to fix models in different sites. 
 The manufacturer and your architect or surveyor will be able to advise you.  
 How is the lift installed? 
 The manufacturer will be able to provide you with a plan, an estimate and details of building and electrical work required. 
 A builder will need to give an estimate for the building work. 
 The building work and electrical work will need to be completed ready for the installation, and some making good is needed afterwards. 
 Can I get a grant for this work? 
 You can apply for a grant for the building and electrical work under the normal grant conditions &mdash; Ask your Environmental Health Officer.  
 &equo; THROUGH FLOOR LIFTS&hellip; 
 There are several types&hellip;!&equo; 
 WHAT OTHER GRANTS ARE AVAILABLE? 
 If you are elderly and need minor works done to assist you to stay in your home, or to live with a relative, the Environmental Health Department have grants for Assistance with Minor Works to Dwellings. 
 The two main adaptation ones are: 
 Staying Put 
 For repairs, improvements or adaptations to properties owned or tenanted by an elderly person over 60. 
 Elderly Resident Adaptation 
 For adaptations to a property to enable an elderly person over 60) who is not the owner or tenant, but who intends to live in the property to be cared for by a friend or relative. 
 The householder makes the application and he/she must also be elderly. 
 There is no financial test of resources for these grants, but the person applying, or their spouse or person they live with, must be in receipt of one of the following benefits: Housing Benefit, Community Charge Benefit, Income Support or Family Credit. 
 Any one application must not exceed &pound;1,000 and a maximum of three applications in three years can be made. 
 These grants however are discretionary &mdash; that means they do not have to be given so there will be variations from one district to another. 
 ASK YOUR LOCAL ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH DEPARTMENT FOR DETAILS. 
 Grants may also be available for thermal insulation, or repairs to properties in clearance areas. 
 ASK YOUR LOCAL ENVIRONMENTAL HEALTH DEPARTMENT.  
 I would like a home of my own but I have special requirements. 
 Can I apply for a house/flat? 
 Adaptations can usually be done to a property to suit it to your needs. 
 Both local housing authorities and housing associations will try to be helpful in finding somewhere suitable to adapt for you. 
 It may take them a little while, but it is important that you contact them to make a housing application and let them know of your needs. 
 Putting your name on their housing list also enables them to plan new buildings suitable for disabled people.  
 SPECIALIST EQUIPMENT 
 Before starting adaptations to your home, there may be some problems that can be solved by using various pieces of equipment available on the market at the moment. 
 It is advisable to look at some of the types available and try them first. 
 Quite a common problem is not being able to get in and out of the bath. 
 There are many aids that can be tried. 
 The equipment can be very simple, but very effective. 
 Both boards and bath seats assist many people in being able to continue using their baths. 
 Some people may find they need more complicated items such as hoists or units that fit into the bath to raise and lower the bather using air or water pressure. 
 Many types of small aids are available and can help overcome a wide range of problems relating to eating, drinking, toileting, dressing, mobility and others. 
 These may be available through local outlets. 
 Several of the larger equipment companies have a mail order service, which is useful if you are unable to get out to the shops. 
 The Mail Order service offers a range of most widely used items that are not too expensive. 
 The correct equipment is equally important when you are adapting your property, make sure that the bath or shaver, and w.c. that you install are suitable for you to use. 
 This is particularly relevant if you have limited movement in your hips, shoulders or problems with your hands. 
 A simple grab rail placed in the correct place can make a considerable difference to how you cope, especially with the bath or toilet. 
 Remember rails in bathrooms could be plastic coated or bonded to prevent conduction. 
 If you are replacing existing fitments to redecorate or improve your bathroom it is advisable to consider  what equipment suits you best, particularly if you are less mobile, have a disability or are elderly. 
 Can you really use it? 
 If not don't buy it. 
 The same applies to changing your chairs or perhaps your kitchen fitments. 
 If you are considering purchasing a piece of equipment remember many aids can be tried out first at Disabled Living Centres and at &bquo;Dialability&equo; in Oxford. 
 Here you may be able to try things, and get advice on several makes, try many makes and styles in one place. 
 CONTACT DIALABILITY FOR FURTHER INFORMATION. 
 Many companies allow you to try equipment and will demonstrate equipment to you in your own home. 
 It is advisable to ask if this service is available and to TRY FIRST whenever you can. 
 The Social Services department has a variety of equipment which can be on free loan to you if you are assessed to need it. 
 CONTACT YOUR LOCAL OCCUPATIONAL THERAPIST.  
 ACCESSIBILITY FOR THE PEOPLE OF EALING 
 Internally 3 lifts suitable for wheelchair uses were installed, each double ended so that all levels and half levels are served by a lift. 
 All steps in corridors were replaced by ramps so that now wheelchair users can  gain access to any part of the Town Hall. 
 This is proving useful to them as well as to mothers with push-chairs, who are perhaps more frequent users. 
 In 1987 Maguire and Murray were appointed by the London Borough of Ealing to design the major refurbishment of the Ealing Town Hall. 
 This Victorian Stone building, initially constructed in 1886 and extended extensively in 1913 and 1934 had floors on  no less than 17 different levels and half levels. 
 One of the main priorities therefore was to make the whole building accessible to disabled people. 
 The steps at the front entrance were demolished and a ramp was constructed together with new steps. 
 This used existing stone pillars, together with new replicas so that the whole design is very much in keeping with the original architecture. 
 Giving the Town hall back to the people of Ealing was achieved by re-locating administrative staff in an adjacent building, and using the space thus created for lettable function rooms.  
 One such room was especially adapted for partially sighted people and the hard of hearing, so that special interest groups with immobility or other disabilities could make use of the function room. 
 This room was equipped with an induction loop to transmit sound to people with suitably receptive hearing aids. 
 Also, in association with the Partially Sighted Society, special adaptations were made. 
 These were to install illuminations up to 1000 Lux, but all indirectly to avoid sparkle and glare in the abnormally thick spectacles of partially sighted people. 
 A deep black dado below the white walls surrounds the room in order to provide an enhanced sense of perspective to those who see only a blur and have to find their way using very little visual data. 
 Doors are outlined in a black architrave for the same reason. 
 The effect of a black and white room in stunningly attractive. 
 It is surprising what can be achieved in an old and complex building to provide for disabled people and also how much the internal and external architecture can benefit from the refurbishment that the opportunities of converting a building for disabled access can provide. 
  Jeremy Bell, Maguire &amp; Co  
 Maguire &amp; Co was started as the successor firm to Maguire &amp; Murray in 1988. 
 The firm has two offices, at Richmond, Surrey and Thame, Oxon.  
 A disabled ramp serves wheel chair users and mothers with pushchairs. 
 It can enhance a building if done sensitively. 
 A modern lift can be elegantly installed in an old building. 
 A black and white room and indirect lighting helps the visual perspective for the partially sighted. 
 FURTHER INFORMATION AVAILABLE 
 Further information on services is available throughout Oxfordshire on OXCIS a visual display scheme. 
 There are screens in many libraries and other sites. 
 The Oxford Disability Information Network. 
 The Oxford Disability Information Network is a group of information providers both statutory and voluntary together with the users of services, who come together to discuss ways of improving information provision across the country. 
 Oxfordshire Council of Disabled People. 
 The above Council within Oxfordshire exists to promote the views, needs, interests and image of disabled people. 
 It is supported by Oxfordshire Social Services, and makes representation to several departments within the County Council. 
 If you would like to know more about O.C.D.P. they have a development co-ordinator who would be pleased for you to make contact. 
 John Hodgeon available at Rivermead. 
 Oxford 792226. 
 Other Publications 
 The Department of the Environment have a new booklet titled &bquo;House Renovation Grants&equo;. 
 It includes information on Disabled Facilities Grants and the Test of Resources. 
 A copy can be obtained from your local Environmental Health Department.   
 THE MOTABILITY SCHEME 
 Motability was set up with government backing in 1977 with the aim of helping disabled people to use their mobility allowances to achieve greater value for money. 
 Motability has arranged special schemes with motor manufacturers, wheelchair manufacturers, insurance brokers, and other so that today a variety of schemes can be offered which not only help disabled people become mobile but also give them a chance to be truly independent. 
 Under Mobility's hire scheme, it is possible to choose from a wide range of vehicles from most major manufacturers. 
 It is usual to hire a new vehicle on a fully maintained basis for a period of about three years. 
 In these cases, there are no servicing costs, and often insurance is also included. 
 In certain circumstances, the vehicle will also be exempt from Vehicle Excise Duty Road Tax. 
 Models in all price ranges are available under the scheme. 
 For the more expensive models, a downpayment is required at the start of the scheme, but it is still possible to obtain a car with little or no downpayment with the hire charges being met entirely by the mobility allowance. 
 The scheme operates very simply with Motability arranging for the DSS to use part or all of the Mobility Allowance to pay the necessary instalments or rentals. 
 For those who wish to buy their cars, Motability offers a finance scheme under which both new or used cars can be purchased in exchange for part of the mobility allowance. 
 Motability has also negotiated good discounts on new cars on behalf of purchasers.  
 Cars supplied for hire or purchase can be adapted to suit the needs of the individual, but the types of adaptation that can be made to hire cars is more restricted because they have to be returned to the general market at the end of the hire period. 
 Motability can provide the names of professional organisations who can assess the needs of the disabled person and advise them whether or not they are capable of driving and what sort of car and adaptations they might need. 
 Providing the disabled person is entitled to receive mobility allowance, it need not necessarily be the disabled person who has to be the driver of the vehicle. 
 Often vehicles are provided for the use of children or other non-drivers. 
 In addition to providing help for the hiring and buying of cars, Motability also has a wheelchair hire scheme covering both manual and powered models. 
 Motability is a registered charity and if a person cannot meet the full cost of putting a car on the road, including any adaptations, Motability may be able to provide some financial help from special funds. 
 If you would like further details of the scheme, contact your local Motability motor dealer. 
 They will have all the facts and will be able to explain what the costs would be in your particular case. 
 Participant Observation of Police Practice  
 AN ARM OF EXECUTIVE POWER 
 For over a century the control of certain aspects of British social life has rested in the hands of the police forces of England and Wales. 
 However, these increasingly centralized and expensive units only enforce control over a very narrow range of public or &bquo;street visible&equo; acts of social disorder. 
 This system of power and control has primarily been directed towards the protection of property and to prevent assaults on the individual, but only in very specific situations. 
 These aims have gained a high symbolic place in the public imagination and the institution has set out to prevent and detect acts which are usually subsumed under a generic (but simplistic) classification of &bquo;crime&equo;. 
 To a less immediately visible extent the institution of policing is also set up to control those who would publicly demonstrate against the state and its executive powers. 
 It is in relation to this area of activity that recent moves towards systematic amalgamation, centralization, and mutual aid seem to have been made. 
 Cohen (1973) describes how, at specific times, certain public crimes generate &bquo;moral panics&equo; directed at &bquo;folk devils&equo; or scapegoat groups. 
 Pearson (1983) further showed that the identification of these groups as &bquo;the dangerous classes&equo; manifests itself as a continuous historical phenomenon. 
 Tracing this back to the seventeenth century, he points out that in such times, it is &bquo;always those crimes that are associated with the materially disadvantaged underclass which have provided the continuing thread within this history of respectable fears&hellip; 
 &equo;. Prior to the establishment of the modern police system, the control of this underclass was the responsibility of the army working for the monarch or government. 
 Foucault (1980) details the move away from the army, to control  by the civil police; describing how the judicial control and surveillance systems emerged. 
 He suggests the army could no longer be used to drain off the unemployable proletariat by conscription, nor could the newly independent colonies be used to dump the troublesome of society (see also Hughes 1987). 
 In consequence, the burgeoning nineteenth-century penal and criminal justice system was aimed at these socially &bquo;dangerous classes&equo; simply because of their potential for contesting the power of the state and those in control. 
 Foucault (1980: 17) suggests: 
 the bourgeoisie erected an ideological barrier around those who went to prison&hellip; &lsqb;an ideology&rsqb; about crime, criminals, theft, the mob, degenerates, &bquo;animals&equo;&hellip; which was in part linked with racialism&hellip; 
 The Army can't play the same role as it used to. 
 As a result we have a reinforcement of the police and an overloading of the penal system&hellip; 
 He goes on to argue that the bourgeoisie have always used sections from within the &bquo;dangerous classes&equo; to control those who are overtly troublesome, perhaps following the maxim that &bquo;it takes a thief to catch a thief&equo;, when he argues: &bquo;for one and a half centuries the bourgeoisie offered the following choices: you can go to prison or join the Army; you can go to prison or go to the colonies; you can go to prison or you can join the police&equo; (ibid. 23). 
 This somewhat idiosyncratic interpretation is no doubt coloured by the specificities of French history, yet there is little doubt that the British police system is also a political construction of the nineteenth century, created to contain the potential in the newly urbanized working classes for mob disorder, which the excesses of the military had seemed likely to exacerbate rather than disperse. 
 Furthermore, a fear of revolution on the lines of that which had occurred in France still loomed large in the minds of the new English bourgeoisie, underpinning the demand for an organized police system geared to the protection of the life and property of the ruling classes (Reiner 1985). 
 This fear of the mob has continued to haunt the executive, who saw that control could best be determined by the installation of a professional police organization formulated on strict hierarchic, semi-militaristic lines, and possessed of discipline, obedience, and loyalty. 
 Today, police forces pursue the control of the &bquo;dangerous classes&equo; by employing a crucially important range of ritual metaphors of negation. 
 The police world is one of preventing, detaining; arresting, stopping, containing, denying, and rebutting; it is a world of diffused and hidden versions of reality where deflection is a prominent tool of the trade. 
 Moreover, it has a culture which is built on a history of defensive skirmishes and has generated a metaphorical language of warfare which looms large in all of its structures of significance. 
 In addition, it often seems that police culture possesses a dramaturgical or melodramatic inflexion, as the increasingly autocratic operational style is brought to bear in contests with new generations of dissenting workers, political radicals, and the largely dispossessed criminal underclass. 
 Police methodologies of controlling the dangerous classes may well reflect that we are in a period which Foucault (1980) has described as the &bquo;end of an historical epoch&equo;. 
 This, he suggests, is a time when we have witnessed the ending of the construct of what he calls, &bquo;the homogeneity of man&equo; which was a product of a special political climate that has now passed. 
 Leach (1982: 57) has suggested that if Foucault's assertion is correct, then this demise will undoubtedly enhance the separation of man by man into categories of &bquo;inhuman&equo;, &bquo;subhuman&equo;, and &bquo;animal&equo;. 
 Such classificatory techniques and use of social binaries seem all too obvious in police practice and undoubtedly enhance ideological barriers and present further opportunities for the powerful to encourage their agents in the police to pursue bigotry and authoritarian measures in their contests with the dispossessed. 
 If the philosophical discontinuity Foucault describes is truly occurring, then an inside or reflexive exploration of police practice should reveal the strength of these divisive classificatory techniques, for any binary separation of man by his contemporaries into the non-human categories suggested by Leach (1982) is the very stuff of anthropology. 
 And if such a classificatory system is a major feature of the way the police control their fellow citizens, then it seems essential it should be identified, assessed, and described. 
 Foucault (1980), like Thompson (1980), asserts that the criminal justice system is increasingly becoming an arm of the state apparatus, with the institution of policing beginning to wield expanding socio-political power. 
 In a liberal democracy this needs to be scrutinized constantly, and herein lies the first problem for the researcher. 
 For how can one really study a system of state control without acknowledging that such an activity itself is antithetical to  the direction of power? 
 Indeed it reverses the direction, as we shall see. 
 If the British system of policing is a social construction geared to the maintenance of &eacute;litist power and is primarily concerned to keep control over a materially disadvantaged underclass, then these same &bquo;dangerous classes&equo; seem to have willingly entered into this game of power-relations with their masters; and by doing so they have deflected attention away from their own lack of privilege and power. 
 Never having shown the same propensity as the French for violent revolution, the dispossessed have entered into a complex ritual of action within the processes of the criminal justice system, and in doing so have encouraged those tasked with their containment to consider them as being less than human and therefore needing further control and discipline. 
 As Wilson (1981), Reiner (1985), and others have clearly identified, policing is basically a socio-political tool of the state and government. 
 It is sustained by an intimate knowledge of its &bquo;enemy&equo; &mdash; the underclass of society &mdash; and exemplary use is made of this knowledge to produce the technological and structural means for the continuity of this system of power. 
 As we shall see, there is now a specifically created police culture of the dramatic, which incorporates illusion, praxis, and imagery as part of a well-directed social production. 
 It rejoices in an enhanced belief in Manichaean and mythological archetypes of good and evil which are made manifest in exaggerated games of &bquo;cops&equo; and &bquo;robbers&equo;. 
 Series of interlinking metaphors of chaos and inhumanity are generated to maintain this dramatic mode and ensure that the agenda for control remains firmly with the system, and already I have used such metaphorical terms as &bquo;animals&equo; and &bquo;enemies&equo; to indicate some of the ways in which those in power make use of the rich imagination contained in everyday language. 
 As Lakoff and Johnson (1980: 157) remind us: &bquo;whether in national politics or in everyday interaction, people in power get to impose their metaphors&equo;. 
 So when the police declare (as they do) that they are non-political institution, this can only be a partial truth. 
 For a co-ordinated system of mutual police aid is now one  of the primary tools for repressing expressions of political discontent, as the miners discovered during their disputes with government policy in the mid-1980s; and the chief constables of the forty-three forces in England and Wales now form a powerful cabal for co-ordinated action against any political or moral dissent. 
 In the main, however, policing continues to be publicly concerned to prevent and detect individual attempts to steal the property of the citizen and it suits the police's purpose for their community role to be well broadcast, for on those rare occasions when they have expanded their controls to include the activities of the middle classes, they have found themselves on less certain ground. 
 These groups, like all &eacute;lites, have no previous perception of themselves as belonging to the troublesome classes, and it does not do for the police to remind them that the application of control can be redirected depending on who is defining the &bquo;illegalities&equo;. 
 If the police are to continue to exercise control over an increasingly pluralist society, which is better educated and less willing simply to accept any version of events handed out by the powerful, then it seems essential they should avoid scrutiny yet suggest they are totally accountable to the democratic ideal. 
 In order to achieve this they seem certain to continue to deny close analysis of their practices, for exposure could well generate the potential to contest the system by releasing knowledge to those the system was set up to control. 
 It is really one of the foundations of any executive power group that it maintains secrecy about its activities and avoids the possibility for its antagonists to subsume that power. 
 As Arendt (1958) indicated, the more public a group, the less power it is likely to have. 
 Real power, she clearly demonstrates, begins where secrecy exists. 
 It should come as no surprise, therefore, to find that detailed ethnography of police social practice is antithetical to the philosophies of control by which they operate. 
 Yet in a liberal democracy, such a declaration cannot easily be made; indeed the opposite must be proclaimed. 
 To carry out participant observation into the minutiae of police practice might be theoretically approved in any statement made for general consumption, but in the cold light of institutional reality it will most likely be thwarted or subverted even as it is being agreed. 
 In the remainder of this chapter I will explore some of the ambiguities and problems which face those who set out to  research the police and assess some of the fears of the academic incursion into police society. 
 They illustrate some of the problems the policeman/anthropologist faces when he sets out to describe and interpret police culture, for he must &mdash; if the ethnography is to count &mdash; reveal hidden aspects of the relationships of power which are an integral aspect of this institution of state. 
 THE POLICE OFFICER AS ETHNOGRAPHER: ANTHROPOLOGY AT HOME 
 Traditionally in anthropology, the ethnographer has studied a social system or culture through a period of intensive participant observation in the field. 
 This has generated considerable concern about the ethnographic experience itself, and specifically about the subjective nature of the process. 
 Unlike the natural sciences, where discussion often starts with the results and ignores the methodology of the research, the social sciences &mdash; and increasingly anthropology &mdash; have developed an elaborate argument about the practices of doing research. 
 The interpretation of culture and even the ability to understand what is happening in the society under scrutiny as well as the need to grapple with political or ethical questions are all endless and fundamental problems of the moment (Phillips 1973: 78). 
 Mere observation and reporting is inadequate, given the limited scope of things which can be truly observed (Holy 1984: 25). 
 Rather an alternative and extra dimension to the observation is required if the deep structures and meaning inherent in any arbitrarily constructed social world are to be understood. 
 Analysis of any construction of meaning from which social practice is derived has to be part of the participant ethnographer's cognitive processes, replacing the notion of simple observation as the main data-yielding technique. 
 This role as observing participant reverses the emphasis of traditional fieldwork, so that the researcher is required to participate actively in the social life studied and thus consciously eliminate the distinction between the observer and the observed phenomena (ibid. 29). 
 This can create something of a dilemma for the anthropologist  and for the discipline itself, for one of the tenets of social research is that it requires detachment. 
 However, even at the same time as this controversy continues the discipline has not only come to recognize the influence of the self, but has urged that we use it as a scientific construction (Okely 1975a). 
 Analytic detachment is an elusive construct of the intellect. 
 As Cohen (1984: 227) points out: &bquo;by detachment I do not mean we have to distance ourselves emotionally; that I think would be perverse. 
 But we do have to attempt to maintain some intellectual detachment&equo;. 
 In consequence it is becoming increasingly accepted that not only does the anthropologist have his own social history and subjective stance, but more importantly, that those accounts which ignore this seem to lose something in the telling. 
 For my contemporaries in the postgraduate school at Durham in the early 1980s, the inclusion of the scientism of the self (to use Okely's phrase) became part of &bquo;doing the business&equo; (to move to the jargon of my contemporaries in the detective departments). 
 The ethnography we pursued and the seminar papers we created all tended to include the subjective &bquo;I&equo; as part of the discourse, and we were encouraged to explore the effects of our history, our social, political, sexual, and economic influences and include our vision of what we had experienced during the fieldwork situation. 
 For as Crick (1982: 16) has suggested, doing anthropology is inherently autobiographical. 
 It is by making use of this complexity of an extended observing participation  I believe anthropology can edge beyond its contemporaries in the other social sciences, so that the &bquo;thick description&equo; which Geertz (1975) urged us to use, takes on the &bquo;finer grain and detail&equo; necessary for an anthropology at home (MacDonald 1987: 120) where access to the social group or community studied is readily available to any demand for analytic reassessment. 
 Furthermore, the political implication of becoming an observing participant in an institution such as the police is immense, both for the group studied and for the ethnographer. 
 To a unit of executive power, any analysis of how that power is maintained  and used must be uncomfortable; while the &bquo;insider&equo; had no means of retreating across some geographic boundary or vanishing like the traditional anthropologist, back into academia. 
 The researcher who is really at home as one of the natives must seek inside himself to create his &bquo;remote areas&equo; (E. Ardener 1987). 
 He must, as Ardener demonstrates, seek to sow &bquo;semantic grain and grow theoretical crystals&equo; which he may well appreciate no one is asking for. 
 His ethnographic boundaries cannot be described as being geographically to the north of anywhere, for they are around him and within. 
 The insider who studies his own  society is really the &bquo;anthropologist at home&equo; and he cannot move away. 
 Much of the recent writings on anthropology at home remain largely concerned with temporary visits by the academic to what is still the &bquo;exotic&equo; world of &bquo;out there&equo;. 
 Usually the field trip is still an episodic visit to somewhere else, geographically to another culture from which the analyst can take leave or bring visitors too. 
 Returning to academia he can recall the spatial remove as being &bquo;out there in the field&equo;; so that much of the current anthropology at home may still only be practising in its own backyard, pursuing an exploration of &bquo;exotic cultures at home&equo; rather than looking into its own front room (Cheater 1987: 166). 
 Sarsby, (1984: 130&ndash;1) echoing Cheater, points out that &bquo;anthropologists have tended to study people whose values and life-styles are different, even in their own society&hellip; &lsqb;seeking&rsqb; the unfamiliar at home as well as abroad&equo;. 
 An assumption remains inherent in the literature that anthropology is academically based, funded by some research organization, presented in seminar, taught to students, and then written up and published. 
 It exists largely as a product of the institutions of higher education (Sarsby 1984: 132) and has only recently begun to surface in policy and practice. 
 As Okely (1987: 67) observes, the urge to create publications is not always as crucial to others as it is to the academic. 
 Indeed for those insiders living in Cheater's metaphorical front room &mdash; such as in the police &mdash; the need to obscure and seek a degree of anonymity from the analytic gaze can be described as a major principle in the preservation of power, ranking highly in the structures of significance. 
 Yet there are those of us who, although firmly based inside such an institution, have undertaken anthropological training and have  subsequently developed the academic wish to be discursive. 
 Our interpretation of the field situation therefore becomes a specific and unusual type of &bquo;anthropology at home&equo;, for it is not out there in the exotic or even in the backyard. 
 It is neither here nor there, but is everywhere. 
 It is all around, all of the time, and not even an interpretation of another but similar society, &bquo;at home&equo; in what Hastrup (1987) has called a &bquo;parallel culture&equo;. 
 This research at home is primarily about the society of the self and the self in that society. 
 It encompasses an internal exploration of a personal history within a culture and inevitably differs in scale from much of the &bquo;anthropology at home&equo; which has become one of the  genres of the 1980s. 
 Inevitably it has qualitative differences and is not easily written or smoothly integrated into the &bquo;isms&equo; or historical categories of the discipline. 
 Material obtained in such circumstances inevitably contains the seeds of a special inside knowledge, avoiding problems described by Liebow (1967: 232&ndash;56), who was still separated by cognitive barriers while pursuing research in what was ostensibly his own society, and who found an insider's language, education, and &bquo;social membership&equo; all helped to retain boundaries he was unable to penetrate. 
 The semantic ability of the insider to translate the hidden and the unspoken aspects of the cultural agenda which occur in any society should be especially productive in any analysis of the police, where a massive visibility at one level is matched by a secretive, hidden side to institutional practice. 
 Furthermore the ethnography must contain a recognition that the anthropologist within is stepping outside himself to describe how and why he performs within his own culture. 
 This requires a detached intellectual process to illuminate how the culture is constructed and how modes of thought are translated into organized beliefs and action. 
 He must understand how these are taught to the neophyte and inculcated into the consciousness to be transmitted across time. 
 It requires a conscious act of experiencing a reflection of yourself and of how you have become what you are! 
 It can be quite painful, for the insider is studying his own social navel, with the potential always present that he will recognize this to be only one of a number of arbitrary possibilities and perhaps also find that many practices are built on the flimsiest of moral precepts. 
 Such special knowledge holds further difficulties, for it highlights the specifically political nature of any ethnographic account  of such an institution, bringing to the forefront those expectations of loyalty which the executive demands of any individual who has hold of the account. 
 Ethical problems will surface, for no power-based organization likes to have its idiosyncrasies made public, and the anthropologist who is a member of the family and not merely a temporary visitor to the &bquo;backyard&equo; exotica can find that writing anything at all becomes crucially problematic. 
 Expectations of confidentiality and silence prevent many accounts from reaching fruition, for as the revelations of Spycatcher  (Wright and Greenglass 1986) revealed, it is not necessarily what is written which causes the pain; rather it is the breach of the convention which requires members in various arms of the executive to say nothing about their practices. 
 This returns us to Arendt's observation that secrecy is a prerequisite of totalitarianism, for those involved in the executive use of power know that to reveal is antagonistic to its maintenance. 
 The insider/anthropologist is therefore somewhat schizophrenic, something of a Jekyll and Hyde, for he knows that publication and explication might be career-suicidal but are necessary intellectual tasks. 
 One result of this constant paradox is that while the police make statements welcoming research and applaud intellectual debate, they strive to impose rigid control over a system of preferred rules and regulations to negate open enquiry, so that systems are quietly but firmly deployed to deny the critical approach &mdash; as we shall see. 
 The observing participant insider is consequently torn between self and scientism, for he knows the strengths of an inculcated approval for quality of restraint which sustains the police mind. 
 It should come as no surprise, therefore, to find that most insider participant observation of policing is almost always confined to discussion on management techniques and to the implementation of new systems. 
 Philosophical reflexivity is not high on the agenda and in an organization which makes much of the concept of loyalty but really means subservience, the insider can find it hard to bite the hand that feeds and reveal any unhealthy aspect in the agenda. 
 When the research is carried out by academics from outside, critical analysis creates enormous tensions. 
 Barrie Irving, director of the Police Foundation, indicated this antipathy in his title to a paper given to the British Psychological Society,  &bquo;Research into Policy won't go&equo; (1983). 
 He told his audience that &bquo;C.I.D. 
 officers use deception, trickery and psychologically oriented persuasive tactics amounting to threats and inducements, in order to obtain confessions; and this process is potentiated by the custodial environment&equo;. 
 Of course, insiders are well aware of the drama which surrounds interrogation and do not need to be reminded or really welcome such information being made public, for as a detective colleague pointed out after reading Irving's paper, &bquo;if we don't use fear, force, fraud or the promise, how do they think we are going to clear up the crime and get the coughs the system needs to survive?&equo; 
 Irving had studied the 1984 Police and Criminal Evidence Act proposals to legislate for interrogation and prisoner control. 
 He concluded the bill was a legislator's attempt to &bquo;assume institutions work on the kind of rational and ordered basis which they outwardly pretend&equo;. 
 In this he recognizes the same problem which faces the insider/ethnographer, for he clearly understands that pretence, deception, and bizarre social drama play a large part in police culture and accepts this will be difficult to research. 
 However, he is optimistic (as any professional researcher must remain!), for he cites Sir Kenneth Newman's efforts as the new commissioner of the Metropolitan Police to &bquo;make police ethics a major issue, so that performance assessment, promotion criteria etc., will take integrity and professional conduct more and more into account&equo;. 
 With hindsight it seems that the prevailing structures of police practice will remain as powerful as ever, for at a conference on policing at Bristol University (1988), the newly retired Sir Kenneth admitted that police culture had defeated many of his attempts to bring a new ethic to the managerial style during his reign as commissioner of the metropolis. 
 ANTHROPOLOGY FOR THE POLICE 
 It seems relevant that anthropology be used at this time to contribute to the debate on policing, for since the 1964 Police Act and the preceding Royal Commission which was generated through concern over police practice, the organization has held an increasingly central place in the public imagination. 
 Policing issues are never long out of the headlines (Chibnall 1977), and this media obsession has been transmitted into a  wealth of analyses of policing &mdash; which have mostly been carried out by outside observers. 
 Indeed insider accounts have largely consisted of bland reminiscences in the style of &bquo;my greatest arrests and cases&equo; and it has been left to investigative journalism to redress some unacceptable police activity, by calling attention to the limits and abuses of police authority, power, and accountability. 
 Concern also continues to be expressed in some quarters over the increasingly authoritarian attitudes and methodology which surrounds some police practices and there is a commensurate fear about the growth in policing and the exercise of their extensive powers, which look set to become increasingly centralized and wieldy. 
 Thompson (1980) has warned of the potential danger of a strong police autocracy, conscious, no doubt, of the slim line which exists between the democratic use of power and its subversion by a more centralized totalitarianism. 
 And the forty-three forces in England and Wales now contain some formidable units, amalgamated out of the small borough, city, and county forces of the pre-1960s, many of which were prone to the whims of corrupt local politicians (Simey 1988). 
 Some of the forty-three police units now have visibly autocratic chief officers who consistently spell out their public accountability yet pursue very personal perceptions of what they consider to be disorderly and what needs to be controlled, and such constructions of reality generate systems which enforce power differently from force to force. 
 For example, James Anderton, the chief  constable of Greater Manchester, pursued a drive against pornography in the early 1980s which was not imitated by other chief officers. 
 Pornography &mdash; like homosexuality, which he has similarly crusaded against &mdash; is an ambiguous activity and creates very marginal offences in any standard police hierarchy of crimes. 
 Thus, the use of anthropological ideas of social marginality and the construction of gender and masculinity are of primary use in the analysis of such actions, revealing the depth of concern with bodily form which structures considerable areas of police thinking. 
 For a fear of pollution and impurity in the body physical is constantly and easily transposed to create controls in the body social. 
 Disquiet over deaths in police cells, to take one further example, is another area in which anthropology seems well placed to make some comment. 
 Statistically these deaths largely occur as a result of the inhalation of vomit and alcoholic poisoning, and it therefore seems somewhat bizarre for the police to be in charge of those suffering in such a way. 
 More often than not the victims have serious medical problems, show a long history of social inadequacy, or are clearly suffering from mental illness. 
 At the 1987 annual ACPO conference, chief officers complained they were still having to deal with this illness and asked why do people still need to die in cells from inhalation of vomit? 
 In Chapter 3 I will describe in detail the culture created to deal with these &bquo;street-visible&equo; offenders in a cell-block situation, but suggest the inertia surrounding the whole problem is more easily understood when we consider the social history of such illness (Foucault 1967), and see how the executive has always allocated the control of such &bquo;drunken dossers&equo; to the police. 
 As &bquo;social dirt&equo; they become an affront to purity and possess the danger of the contagious and impure (Douglas 1966), requiring their removal from the public vision. 
 As yet there is no other body to undertake this task, and even tentative moves to remove the problem from the cell block and into the detoxification centre foundered in the entrepreneurial 1980s; for there is little immediate profit to be made from reclamation of this kind of scrap material (although the long-term value of a humanitarian return might be thought to be well worth pursuing in a civilized society!). 
 The argument is therefore not about police control or a utopia without controls, but to explore why some cultural behaviour has  a history of police action and to discover where that behaviour fits into police ideology. 
 Its status or (as importantly) its lack of value creates complex systems of meaning which are rarely articulated; for the police world has similar strictures to that which Benedict (1967) described in her attempts to understand the rigidities of Japanese culture: 
 men who have accepted a system of values by which to live, cannot without courting in-efficiency and chaos keep for long a fenced-off portion of their lives where they think and behave according to a contrary set of values. 
 Anthropological modes of enquiry are therefore programmed to steer us through the assumptions of police society, so that contradictions no longer remain incomprehensible. 
 The cultural baggage which any social group, tribe, or institution such as the police acquires over time can thus be translated to reveal just what sustains it, and furthermore reveal what the society itself may not even have understood. 
 Where there does exist a genuine public expression of concern about the way the police operate this cannot just be dismissed as a matter of misunderstanding or be written off as the foolish ramblings of that police &bquo;folk devil&equo; the &bquo;loony left&equo;, who would dismantle the system for their own political ends. 
 Such a mood of concern has existed now for more than a decade and seems to mirror uncertainties of role occurring elsewhere in society. 
 For example, it can be argued the expansion into amalgamated police units has enlarged the organization to a point where it is no longer accessible to the man in the street; alternatively, it may be that the use of a centralized computer and complex technical aids has alienated the public even at the same time they are increasingly fed a diet of violent news snippets which reinforce a fear of crime and generate another &bquo;folk devil&equo; of criminal menace, which demands the impossible: a policeman on every corner. 
 In nightly theatrical TV rituals of social order and chaos, a stream of hero-policemen stand at the symbolic crossroads between peace and mayhem, and the detective and the chief officer now operate at the point where once the church and its priests declaimed on categories of good and evil and the resulting binary codes they produce. 
 Inevitably, as a secular interpretation of morality has superseded that of established religion, so the  activities of the social controller have become increasingly important in the drama. 
 It can be no accident that the opinion of the police officer is now sought on matters which once would have remained the province of the archbishop and his clergy. 
 The immediate result is that alongside a few major clerics such as Runcie and Jenkins, we find that Stalker, Sampson, Anderton, Alderson, Newman, Imbert, Dear, Oxford, and Hermon are national personalities, while a second division of chief officers regularly proclaim on a range of subjects which at other times would lie outside the province of the police. 
 Yet Robert Reiner (1989), writing on the collective culture of chief constables, is the first to explore their extraordinary place in modern society, simply because as an &eacute;lite among the powerful in society they have had little need to reveal how they operate, link together, or reveal what structures of significance guide their actions. 
 Across the history of policing their need has always been for the light of research to illuminate the activities of the underprivileged and the powerless, rather than focus upon the &eacute;lite themselves! 
 Analysis of police culture is therefore particularly suited to the anthropological method, for it requires an extended field study to reveal much about the unspoken agenda which determines many aspects of police practice. 
 These are governed by an often unwritten series of transformations, creating homologies which reaffirm operational practice and which are determined by a definitive, but rarely acknowledged rationale. 
 For, as Benedict (1967: 12) implied, reflexivity in any dogmatic culture always presents the possibility that the whole scheme of things will simply fall to pieces. 
 In consequence, there is always a careful code of practice, elaborated in Force Orders to suit the legalistic need to define. 
 In addition the system also has a range of unwritten rules about such aspects as loyalty and the way activities should be handled in practice. 
 These are taught to the initiate to show him the accepted response to the vagaries of order, disorder, ambiguity, and ambivalence which lies in the complexities of social behaviour. 
 As Crick (1976: 123) has argued, &bquo;criminology (like anthropology), is largely concerned with systems of classification&equo;. 
 In consequence, police modes of thought build up into classifiable systems of praxis which are the product of dealing with the extremes of social experience. 
 These in turn become massively  overdetermined, regenerative and self-justifying, creating an institutional mind which, although allegedly acting on behalf of society and the majority population, comes to regard that same group as outsiders and potential antagonists who are never to be accorded easy access to the processes of the organization. 
 Such a world view is the product of a perception conceptualized to contend dramatically with the instant experience of dealing with highly emotive, personal conflicts at street level, or the tensions of ritual &bquo;battles with criminals&equo;. 
 Inevitably in such circumstances, the detail of practice suffers a reduction to enable these charged and emotional situations to be handled more easily and to allow the complexities of social events to be reduced to the simplicities of narrative necessary for the file of evidence. 
 In such a situation, action becomes more easily defined if it runs along well-known lines, following precepts which have status and acceptability. 
 Such compression into a carefully managed logic allows policemen to deal quickly with what are intensely charged and often dangerous situations, best resolved with the minimum of introspection or self-analysis. 
 Not unnaturally one consequence of this reductionism is that action and pragmatism take on an extra dimension in the police mind, holding a special place in the institutional imagination. 
 While any analytic appraisal or reflexivity on this rationale is never given much credibility in the structures of significance. 
 Anthropological analysis of these beliefs, I believe, should add a crucial semantic dimension to compliment the many non-qualitative enquiries into policing now in progress. 
 For example, the Police Foundation is only one of the bodies publishing indices of current research on the police. 
 Their 1986/7 register of police research (Bird 1987) contains over 200 pages of police-related projects, yet only one item in the index specifically relates to police culture. 
 This is being conducted by Simon Holdaway, an ex-police officer turned academic, with whom I discussed the anthropological potential for police studies at a 1988 conference we both attended. 
 He agreed there was little in an anthropological vein and deplored the current lack of funding available for cultural or qualitative research into the semantics of policing. 
 Much of the work which is being undertaken is dependent on government funding and, of necessity, is required to provide material which fits current political philosophy. 
 As a result, the bulk  of research listed in the Police Foundation Register, or outlined in a Home Office Research and Planning Unit 1987/8 &bquo;Research Programme&equo; document, is concerned with managerial effectiveness, workload assessments, resource deployment measurements; evaluation of neighbourhood watch or victim support schemes, or the analysis of the effectiveness of enforcement programmes. 
 All are described pragmatically (ibid. 21) as measures &bquo;to aid decisions as to how police manpower can most usefully be deployed&equo;. 
 In their own research departments the police continuously attempt to measure aspects of their activity, largely to demonstrate cost effectiveness in line with criteria imposed by the limits on public spending (HO Circular 114/83) and the prevalent socio-economic world view of society. 
 This has meant that many studies tend to concentrate on the objective assessment of a fiscally quantifiable reality. 
 For example, the Audit Commission (an arm of the treasury) spent some time in 1987/8 with myself and others in a police research department assessing an OSU (Operational Support Unit) administrative system which they claimed had &bquo;revolutionized police decision making&equo; and released manpower for patrol equal to &pound;6.358 million. 
 However, a colleague looking at these OSUs in relation to their cultural impact, saw there were many aspects of a qualitative nature which could not easily be expressed in fiscal terms (Adams 1988: 11): 
 direct submission of reports to the 0. 
 S.U. was to be encouraged, eliminating chains of assessment and decision making which had lain within the purview of the superintendent. 
 A central decision making process involving Inspectors and civilian decision makers was established and developed&hellip;. 
 Its early implementation met with a degree of resistance, &lsqb;for&rsqb; the new system fundamentally dislocates the well established and cultural preferences of the service. 
 Inspectors can no longer &bquo;hide behind a paper managing a desk&equo; (quote from a Chief Superintendent). 
 Then again for reasons of established cultural preference we had to go back to the Audit Commission and ask them to translate &pound;6.358 million into &bquo;real men&equo;, for we had difficulty in trying to sell such an alien concept to the police mind. 
 In effect their fiscal mandate meant their version of reality failed to synchronize with the police world view. 
 Constantly the symbolic or qualitative nature of police culture  slips through the grasp of the researcher or the audit analysis, simply because of its ephemeral potential for statistical assessment. 
 At a 1988 Police Foundation Conference &bquo;Coming to Terms with Policing&equo; (ed. 
 Morgan and Smith 1989), where I had had the discussion with Simon Holdaway mentioned above, the symbolic nature of police culture consistently surfaced to confound the economic assessment of good practice which the Home Secretary had set in his opening address to the participants. 
 All too often the outside researcher pursues lines of enquiry which the prevailing culture manages to encompass and nullify. 
 For example, Christine Horton (1989) told the conference she regretted that many aspects of policing had a symbolic role which were not conducive to quantitative measures and were difficult to present with absolute objectivity. 
 Others described problems in dealing with the influences of culture and the ingrained systems of status attributed to &bquo;real police work&equo;. 
 Shapland and Hobbs (1989) consider many low status activities are effectively invisible, while Chatterton and Rogers (1989) acknowledge many cultural inhibitors, ranging from a lack of trust between the ranks to a &bquo;number of deeply rooted myths about the existing police systems which protected it from criticism and disguised its deficiencies&equo;. 
 Chatterton told the conference: &bquo;regretfully there is a considerable amount of material which is unrecorded and unavailable to the researcher locked away in the constable's heads&equo;. 
 This troublesome invisibility in the material record is often inversely related to its semantic value, and activity which may well have a central place in the police model of reality can well remain beyond the grasp of the outsider. 
 Often a priority given to some activity in this police hierarchy of meaning has been laid down from a constable's first days as a probationer and now lies beneath the immediate consciousness, so that any calls for a change in direction of police response may well be defeated by an unspoken semantic value which the institution gives to that activity. 
 For example the considerable criticism of the police response to domestic disputes &bquo;mainly related to their failure to take effective action by arresting men who assault their wives and girl friends&equo; (Shapland and Hobbs 1989) is largely determined by wider social factors pertaining to the historical role and place of women in society. 
 Systems will simply not change as easily as Shapland and Hobbs seem to hope; for police society is extremely conservative and  masculine in outlook, and has long reflected the low esteem women are given in wider society, as I will describe in more detail in Chapter 4. 
 In consequence the wealth of research contained in the bibliographies I have mentioned often fails to follow through the deep structures of police culture or establish the ways in which the culture is self-sustaining even in the face of calls for social change. 
 As long ago now as 1974, Michael Maguire argued a need for a semantic ethnography of police systems and the criminals they pursue; and there has been a subsequent trickle of attempts to carry out participant observation inside the world of &bquo;cops and robbers&equo;. 
 Ditton (1979) was said to have carried out &bquo;a unique  situational ethnography in a bakery&equo;, when he set out to assess fiddling; while Holdaway (1979, 1982, 1983) has pursued aspects of police culture, using his previous insider's knowledge to peel away some of the layers of obfuscation. 
 Dick Hobbs (1988) lived with thieves and detectives as they set out to &bquo;do the business&equo;, and perhaps one of the most effective pieces of participant observation in recent times has been the four-volume Policy Studies Institute work on the police in London (1983). 
 Robert Lustig (1983), writing in the Observer  (20 November 1983) called it: 
 the most detailed examination of the relationships between police and public ever conducted. 
 Every statement is based on observation; every conclusion is supported by evidence; every judgement is carefully weighed. 
 Two of the institute's researchers spent the best part of two years observing. 
 Its analysis of police culture was certainly incisive and accurate, as can be judged by its wholesale condemnation. 
 Sir Kenneth Newman, to whom the report was presented, candidly admitted he would not have commissioned it in the first place (it was commissioned by his predecessor, Sir David McNee), while the official Police Federation magazine (Police , December 1983) concluded in an editorial: 
 the report is certainly not a definitive and unchallengeable portrait of the Metropolitan police. 
 In later, calmer moments, those conclusions which are not based on published research material need to be contested. 
 There is a world of difference between research findings based on safe academic principles and methodology, and those produced with graphic literary phrases, but based upon anecdotal heresay, recorded by listeners blessed with total recall. 
 This attack was repeated again in 1987 in the Federation magazine, for the report had obviously hit a very raw nerve. 
 Its frenzied rejection was very different to that of the many projects listed in the Police Foundation or Home Office Registers of Research mentioned above, most of which are simply ignored and never ever receive any review. 
 I believe the denial of the PSI report and the furore it caused occurred precisely because it managed to get beneath the surface of police culture to explore the deep structures of belief and to comment adversely about their influence on police activities. 
 The invisibility in the written record, which Shapland and Hobbs (1989) observed, and the unrecorded information which Chatterton told the conference remained hidden in the heads of the constables are the result of cultural values, which are then brought to bear to deny validity to these agendas. 
 It is worth noting the language in the Federation rebuttal of the PSI report, for it illustrates how the culture is programmed to sneer at the &bquo;graphic literary phrase&equo; and dismiss the use of &bquo;anecdotal material&equo; as unscientific: while participant observation is considered to be a world away from &bquo;research based on safe  academic principles&equo; (my emphasis). 
 Police culture is omnipotent is structuring such views of critical research. 
 Historically it has homed in on sociology as the generic symbol of reformatory zealousness, regarding its practitioners almost as &bquo;folk devils&equo; or bogeymen. 
 Such a view of &bquo;sociology&equo; sets up another binary derived from the police preference for a Manichaean world created on homologies of &bquo;good &mdash; evil&equo;, and further reflects the ferocious resistance to and fear of change which permeates the organization (see for example Weatheritt 1986, Butler 1984, and Adams 1988). 
 Certainly the social sciences are seen to be the arbiters of revolutionary change which might somehow dismantle the police institution and its processes, and this has led it to negate the reforming social scientists, keeping them as outsiders beyond the system. 
 A further example from the Police Foundation Oxford Conference gives some indication of the different perspectives which exist for the analytic researcher and the practical policeman: 
 Barrie Irving, the Police Foundation director has presented a paper today outlining research into the Police and Criminal Evidence Act (PACE). 
  Having some 1979 data on custody practices and prisoner interviews he sought to replicate the study in 1986/7 to assess the influence of the legislation on police practice. 
 Claiming significant differences in post-PACE activities he suggested these showed the need for legal measures to impact upon police practice and influence change. 
 His observational sample of prisoner interviews, although small, had found the PACE codes of practice were followed to the letter and he argued this showed that it required the sanction of the law to effect changes in interview and interrogation techniques. 
 A detective inspector shrugged this off, arguing from &bquo;practical mastery&equo; and &bquo;insider's&equo; knowledge, that the practices of &bquo;doing the business&equo; remained undisturbed outside of the PACE interview. 
 He accepted there was no question that the PACE interviews Irving had witnessed would have been carried out with exactitude, but was certain that the negotiation of justice could easily continue outside of the world of the written custody record or file of evidence. 
 The fact that a sociologist was witnessing the interviews make it all the more certain they would be conducted with scrupulous care, but there was no way he would be given access to the extra-legal deals which may well have gone on outside the interview room or later during a prison visit for &bquo;write-offs&equo;. 
 As the detective cryptically pointed out: 
 I could make up the detections that his presence lost me in a matter of days, and if he thinks he is going to see any wheeling and dealing when he is sitting in, well he's naive! 
 As a working detective, it would take six months of living with a mate to trust him and know that when it came to the Crown Court appearance he would know exactly what to say. 
 (From fieldnotes.) 
 This distrust of the social scientist is so deeply ingrained that when I was reading anthropology as an undergraduate and I was asked by my colleagues what subject I was reading, I knew that I would have to prevaricate or face problems. 
 Usually I was challenged as to why I was not reading law, which was always quoted as the &bquo;proper&equo; subject for a police officer. 
 I eventually described the discipline of anthropology to certain colleagues as &bquo;the study of old bones, prehistory, and human evolution you know; David Attenborough and all that&equo;. 
 I had taken two classes in physical anthropology and felt less guilty because of this and they were satisfied; although they would have preferred I had chosen to read law. 
 But as one said, &bquo;so long as you're not reading that bloody sociology&equo;. 
 In 1987 I worked with a chief inspector who had just returned from university having read for a Bramshill scholarship in what he called &bquo;black letter law&equo;. 
 He described the  study of precedent and case law as being &bquo;real academic activity&equo; for police officers, thus supporting my contention that research into the philosophy of control is &bquo;unreal&equo; or polluting. 
 He spoke revealingly about the problems he had had with jurisprudence, bemoaning the fact that it was ambivalent and undefined, concerned primarily with the ambiguity which sustains the anthropologist by revealing the centralities of a system: &bquo;it was all grey areas; no black and white certainties or decisions; no precedent or case law giving the definitive interpretation&equo;. 
 At the Police Staff College shortly before I was offered the scholarship to university, I had listened as lists of degrees obtained by previous scholars were read out. 
 The majority were for law and were greeted by applause in an assembly of the staff and students. 
 Later on, however, the names of those who had graduated in the social sciences and especially sociology were greeted with hissing disparagement and barely concealed denigration. 
 Greenhill (1981), then a lecturer at the college, discussed this history of police/sociology antagonism in detail, arguing a tendency in each side to discredit the other; resulting in a situation where &bquo;the number of published British texts and research studies on the sociology of the police may be numbered on the fingers of both hands&equo;. 
 I suspect Greenhill was referring specifically to a dearth in the cultural analysis of policing, while his use of the duality of &bquo;sides&equo; reveals another parallel binary to that of &bquo;cops and robbers&equo;, with the police and sociology arraigned against each other in yet another of the wars which the police wage against those who defile the sanctity of their definition of the concept of order. 
 Constant separations between the two categories are promoted, producing a dichotomized vision of left-wing, radical reformists, antagonistic to the &bquo;right-minded&equo; &bquo;boys in blue&equo; and includes a wealth of negative imagery of sociology which is lodged deep in the collective consciousness of the police mind. 
 The sociologist, as I shall illustrate, is the despised, hairy, intellectual subversive, who is set against the &bquo;clean and ordered British bobby&equo;. 
 To reinforce a belief in their own omnipotence and popularity, the police have made increasing use of market research to show they are well liked; especially by that important category &bquo;the silent majority&equo;. 
 The findings have tended to support the view that the police are held in relatively high esteem, although those  polled have invariably had little or no contact with the police in any capacity. 
 Although such findings are not in dispute, and of course are rarely undertaken in areas where public antagonism to the institution is known to run high, there is continual pressure to replicate them and repeat the consoling message. 
 For such results show the police to be &bquo;on the side of righteousness&equo;, arraigned with the numerically superior forces of goodness and order in their fight against darkness and the void. 
 This tendency to dichotomize policemen against the social reformer even led the ex-police liberal John Alderson uncharacteristically to describe the historian E. P. Thompson as being &bquo;an unfair critic of the police&equo; (Public Office , Granada TV, 20 June 1980); and this at a time when Thompson (1980) had just pointed out that most policemen are &bquo;ordinary blokes, and no society could do without them in dealing with many of its sordid realities&equo;. 
 And sordid behaviour does exist, for even without the labelling techniques beloved of deviance theorists and favoured by the police, there remains the grim fact that such activities would not cease to occur (Maguire 1974). 
 Thompson (1980) has further suggested that many of these analyses are designed to present some utopian vision of a police-free world, but often include &bquo;the soppy notion that all crime is some kind of displaced revolutionary activity&equo;. 
 This perspective, he contends, is a particularly sociological construct, implying criminal activity is some kind of pure or moralistic behaviour. 
 If Thompson is correct, then such presentations are as simplistic as many of the police images which imply that society is consistently under attack from rampaging and ubiquitous criminal enemies, and which (it follows) only they can fight off and defeat. 
 In the light of these partial versions of reality, I suggest there is a need to look beyond the surface presentation, whether handed out in the form of a press release or in the crime statistics which senior officers consistently use as an indication of social mayhem. 
 It is essential to look beyond the public utterance dressed up in  these metaphors of battle, and seek the structural forms which determine the ideological base. 
 It is here that an anthropological observing participation comes into its own, for in living with the semantics of the system the analyst has the potential to undertake a rarely used method of social research. 
 This contains the experience and depth of the insider's knowledge, which Holdaway (1979) recognizes is unlikely to become readily available, simply because &bquo;there is a lack of impetus within contemporary sociology to spend lengthy periods of observation in what may be uncomfortable research situations &lsqb;with the police&rsqb;&equo;. 
 And here the problem really begins, for the ethnographer must explore beyond the public presentation of self, to seek the underlying discourses of police reality. 
 Inevitably this takes the researcher beyond the press release, the statistical return, or the &bquo;folk explanation&equo; and into an interpretive framework, perhaps to seek how these presentations are used (often unconsciously) as part of a well-constructed formula to replicate positions of power and support the ideology and practices of the institution. 
 Immediately the police officer/anthropologist sets out to undertake research or record fieldnotes he is forced to confront a moral dilemma. 
 This exists simply because he must necessarily reveal aspects of a closed and somewhat secretive society to the outside if he is to pursue any ethnography at all. 
 Furthermore, he will know that his contemporaries are not really too keen on its revelation: indeed they may well argue that the police have research facilities of their own which are geared up to the internal needs and interests of the institution (Benyon 1988: 21). 
 He becomes crucially aware that they have little need of any critical analysis, for as Benyon (ibid. 23) goes on to point out, 
 historically, the powerful have encouraged hagiography, not critical investigation&hellip;. 
 And they have been in a position to determine the way they are investigated and the manner of their public exposure. 
 They have also, when confronted with &lsqb;any&rsqb; critical research findings, been quick to use this power to neutralize the critical impact&hellip; 
 Yet in such circumstances the insider's account has a potential to combine &bquo;action anthropology&equo;, &bquo;applied anthropology&equo;, and &bquo;pure anthropology&equo;, to create a fully semantic analysis; and this raises the question of whether it will then be possible to publish and be damned? 
 For such special knowledge holds the potential for an  ethnographic interpretation of police culture which incorporates aspects of &bquo;practical mastery&equo; (Bourdieu 1977) and to enlarge on what Kuper (1973: 238) has somewhat critically dismissed as &bquo;the prissy sterility of much of the methodological or reformist sociology&equo;. 
 Such an insider's account will therefore hopefully achieve the &bquo;finer grain and detail&equo; MacDonald (1987) demanded of postmodern &bquo;anthropology at home&equo;, while &bquo;practical mastery&equo; of the ethnographic field should reduce the problems faced by McCabe and Sutcliffe (1978), who set out to pursue participant observation on the police and found that &bquo;it would be necessary for anyone wishing to fully understand the process of policing to take into account the difficulties in gaining access and an understanding of just what was going on&equo;. 
 Seeking to unravel police decision-making in relation to the classification of crimes, McCabe and Sutcliffe (ibid.) admitted that as outsiders they were usually not quick enough to grasp the nuances of what was taking place before them. 
 They went on to suggest that where complex insider activities are being carried out in a sub-language designed to exclude the uninformed, the best ethnography would probably be carried out by the insider/ethnographer. 
 That this will require some radical reflexivity on the part of the insider is obvious, for it is almost inevitable that his revelations will not only create some discomfort for himself, but will almost certainly be unwelcome. 
 Even the research listed by the &bquo;independent&equo; Police Foundation or undertaken at the University Centres for Criminological Research (and largely dependent on government grants and funding by such bodies as the Economic and Social Research Council) often comes up against the anti &mdash; intellectual bias which permeates all levels in police thinking (Lewis 1976). 
 This facet of the culture is perhaps the reason why the British administrative and academic &eacute;lites have obliquely indicated to the police that they do not consider them fit to be allowed to take charge of police research. 
 It may also be the reason why, in its forty-year history, the Police Staff College has never achieved any real academic status; for, as Lewis (ibid. 183) also points out: 
 there is a deep feeling that academic training gets between a policeman and his knowing and getting the respect of the crude masses of a very crude, very egalitarian and anti-intellectual European race&hellip; the police  have indeed a general belief that they know more psychology than academics. 
 Always the demand is for &bquo;practical&equo; skills, while academic analysis remains a despised pastime, so that even the Superintendents' Association (the equivalent of the Police Federation for the lower ranks) has similarly denied any place for intellectualism for its members. 
 At their 1974 conference they decided: &bquo;It is time to end the service's love affair with education&equo;. 
 Although this conference comment is now well over fifteen years old it still holds good. 
 In 1987 when I attended the Intermediate Command Course at the Police Staff College with some thirty-five other superintendents from around Britain, I found that my Ph.D. 
 was the source of extreme curiosity and even some apprehension, and I watched (and recorded fieldnotes) as my new colleagues sparred warily with the &bquo;Doctor&equo; in their midst. 
 I realized I would need to convince them at the first opportunity that I was primarily a practical policeman and not an academic; and I also noted that while the college was keen to list the academic qualifications of those on the course, the participants quickly justified Lewis's assertions by playing them down to emphasize their history of praxis and practical mastery. 
 AN ANTHROPOLOGY OF THE SELF: PARTICIPANT OBSERVATION OR ESPIONAGE 
 Any insider who sets out to pursue a reflexive anthropology of policing eventually has to face difficulties which arise when he reaches an objective and analytic understanding of his society and its own specific versions of reality. 
 He must come to terms with living with this consciousness and with the inherent problems he will face in revealing this knowledge to the outside in an ethnographic account. 
 Moreover, he must come to terms with a new awareness of what he has previously accepted, perhaps without thinking, which under the intense microscope of social enquiry may well seem to verge on the ludicrous or to be morally indefensible. 
 And having long been supported by the institution he will be crucially aware that it expects a degree of loyalty verging on deference or acquiescence. 
 In such an archetypal world, where &bquo;good&equo; is constantly and insecurely balanced in an eternal struggle against &bquo;evil&equo;, the  objective explication of the rituals and symbols which surround and mystify police work can seem tantamount to a treasonable act. 
 In 1979, James Anderton, the Christian moralist chief constable of Greater Manchester, described the greatest threat to law and order as stemming from &bquo;seditionist&hellip; interested groups who do not have the well-being of this country at heart and who mean to undermine democracy&equo; (Thompson 1979: 380). 
 In the light of such a polemic stand, it begs the question whether the revelation of how crime figures are manipulated by the police to sustain institutional beliefs (see Chapter 5) could be said to undermine democracy or be classified as sedition. 
 For Anderton vehemently rejects the idea of any internal evaluation which might explore the moralities or philosophies of policing: &bquo;there is simply no room in the management and organization of police operations for vague, academic dissertations&equo; (Police Review ; 90, 19 November 1982: 4684). 
 In his 1977 annual report, Sir David McNee, then commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, urged that &bquo;the libertarian should beware&equo;. 
 In due course, his successor, Sir Kenneth Newman, echoed this anti-intellectual stance, when he warned insiders that &bquo;policemen must remember that they are practitioners, not crusaders; theirs is to do, not to righteously philosophise&equo; (Police Journal  56, No. 1 (1983)). 
 Such pronouncements implicitly acknowledge police structures to be a logic upon which rationalizations, justifications, and systems of protection are built up. 
 To reveal these is to peel back a curtain and show this version of institutional order is only one social possibility, and furthermore is a continually manipulated experience. 
 For the insider such an exploration of the secular rituals and social constructs which govern police practice will hold what Myerhoff and Moore (1977: 18) have described as &bquo;the possibility that we will encounter ourselves making up conceptions of the world, society, our very selves. 
 We may slip into that fatal perspective of recognising culture as our construct, arbitrary, conventional, invented by mortals&equo;. 
 Inevitably this perspective will create problems for the insider as he now comes to recognize the arbitrarily constructed nature of his universe. 
 For over a decade I lived with this new knowledge and with the ethical dilemma surrounding my own pursuit of insider research. 
 During the creation of a doctoral thesis and preparation of papers for seminars, I had to face the conscious problem of writing about a system which I know  prefers silence and links such reticence to ideas of &bquo;respect&equo;, &bquo;order&equo;, and &bquo;discipline&equo; in an all-encompassing paternalism. 
 And of course I knew that this hierarchical organization offers the possibility of reward and incorporation into the highest ranks to those who conform to such dictates. 
 The dilemma followed me through the publication of a few accounts of my researches. 
 This loyalty to the family (or force) is another lived quality which is imbued at every turn by practice and example. 
 Although rarely defined, it is often on the lips of the members, so that the phrase, &bquo;I don't want to seem disloyal, but&hellip;&equo; will often preface even the mildest internal criticism of any of the systems of policing. 
 This total reverence to the group binds ideas of silence, loyalty, and reticence together to create a positive category for belief and action and, in turn, links silence to other concepts of respect for the order of the institution. 
 In consequence, even the publication of an academic seminar paper carried out without formal approval could form a breach in the regulated structures of police existence and be subject to disciplinary control. 
 In such a world, the easy resolution of the ethical dilemma remains problematic, for as Anne Akeroyd (1984: 134) recognizes &bquo;there is not, nor ever likely to be any definitive agreement about the nature of either the problems or solutions &lsqb;facing the social scientist and the question of ethics&rsqb;&equo;. 
 I have never completely resolved my own dilemma, for I do not think it has a simple resolution. 
 Unlike the natural sciences, which deal largely in results, the social sciences are rightly concerned for practice, perhaps because results are rarely possible in an exact mathematical sense. 
 Consequently, this ethnography will continually raise such matters simply to illustrate the dilemma as it arises, for I have consistently had to contend with the nature of an insider's breach of social boundaries. 
 Asked to comment on the publication potential of my Ph.D. 
 thesis (Young 1986), Mike Chatterton (1988) rightly homed in on this question of ethics, saying: &bquo;there is reference here to the moral dilemma(s) posed by &bquo;insiders&equo; using their access to do ethnography and what that entails regarding betraying confidences etc&hellip;. 
 The way the writer resolved them is not adequately addressed&hellip; the issues are raised, but no explanation &lsqb;is given&rsqb; of  how they were resolved in practice.&equo; 
 Of course there is no perfect solution. 
 I had the easy choice of remaining silent, or the more difficult one of addressing the problem at some length in various publications; which is how I resolved the practical difficulties. 
 This ethnography is therefore an attempt to meet the dilemma, for the problem of revelation and betrayal continues to surface and can only be resolved, at best, by overcoming these subjective feelings and pursuing compromises (Barnes 1981: 2). 
 Indeed, I believe, along with Akeroyd (1984: 154) that: 
 In a pluralist world and an increasingly pluralist discipline, consensus about ethical behaviour and research practices is unattainable and compromise seems inevitable&hellip; 
 The social researcher must make compromises&hellip; between roles as scientist and citizen; between commitment and impartiality; between openness and secrecy, honesty and deception; and between the public right to know and the citizen's right to privacy and protection&hellip; the onus for making decisions in practice rests with the individual researcher. 
 In the light of these points and Benyon's claims mentioned above, it seems inevitable that any insider analysis of policing seems destined to alarm. 
 To suggest from within the institution that these influential and powerful units of control are essentially ephemeral and arbitrary constructs, involved in very limited and narrow areas of practice, will almost certainly lead to a rejection of the account; and the findings are more than likely to be attributed the same metaphorical rejection as the activities of the villains and criminals, as was illustrated in the response to the study undertaken by the Policy Studies Institute outlined above. 
 For in a similar vein to the criminal &bquo;enemy&equo;, the researcher's activities are across the bounds, a challenge to be taken on, attacked, and, destroyed or at least to be denied. 
 As Chatterton (1973: 107) has written: 
 on more than one occasion&hellip; senior ranking officers have made no bones about the fact that they attribute many of the problems of contemporary police work to the pernicious influence of the media and sociology! 
 Such people are radically opposed to the idea of sociologists conducting research on the police and long for a return to a &bquo;golden age&equo; when the proverbial veil of secrecy surrounded police work. 
 When the research is experiential, carried out by an insider, the publications can prove emotive and will almost certainly be career-problematic for the author. 
 Usually policemen know  the limits allowed by the organization and play safe. 
 Harry Templeton (1980), a police officer in North Wales, suggested: 
 when you read in Police Review that an officer has been awarded an M.A. after post-graduate study, it will probably be in a &bquo;safe&equo; subject such as business management. 
 Few officers who continue their academic studies ever consider sociological study of their own job. 
 Serving officers who attempt constructive criticism of the police, risk being labelled traitors and put their promotion prospects in jeopardy. 
 If internal criticism is unwelcome, the views of outsiders are even more likely to be seen as hostile and derogatory. 
 This risk to promotion chances is well understood and can be clearly illustrated. 
 In his Durham Business School M.Phil. 
 thesis, &bquo;Communications in a Disciplined Society&equo;, a sergeant (Wilson 1978: 6) explained why he had chosen the Royal Navy in preference to the police in which to carry out his research: &bquo;&lsqb;I&rsqb; considered incompatible a progressive career within the police force, and the implications of carrying out research within that organization&equo;. 
 In other words, Sergeant Wilson (who has since left the force) agreed to compromise to enhance his career opportunities rather than present any challenge to the system. 
 Obviously concerned that his analysis of the negative influence of discipline on the efficiency of systems of communication might offend or incite displeasure, he avoided confrontation; but he need not have worried. 
 For it received the neglect that a great deal of insider research achieves and was channelled (unopened) to me, accompanied by a two-line memo from a senior officer which suggested, &bquo;I understand you are doing some research; you may find this useful&equo;. 
 In the following three years the thesis remained on my desk, unrequested by anyone else. 
 Any suggestions for improvements in communications or any critical findings it may have contained were negated by institutional neglect and the &bquo;silence&equo; which Arendt (1958) argues is a primary tool of authority operated to effect! 
 The police, of course, can never really be geared easily to incorporate structural challenge to their existing concepts of order and control, for they are set up to maintain the symbols and practice which has sustained the status quo. 
 It would be paradoxical for them to be in the vanguard of social change, for as Templeton (1980) points out, they are &bquo;there to preserve the structure; to uphold the state of play&equo;. 
 But there are a few who are  questioning the  state of play, and who agree with Ben Whitaker (1979: 312) when he urged &bquo;that police thinking would profit if it more often came out of its shell and concerned itself with wider questions about the role of the police and human relations&equo;. 
 However, this is not always easy to achieve, as I found out when I first returned to work in 1977 after my degree course. 
 In order to continue postgraduate studies I had applied for some financial assistance for part-time fees, under a scheme created by the Home Office and set up specifically in recognition of a lack of higher educational qualifications in the police service (HO Circular 29/74). 
 This directive encourages officers to research and study in their own time and lists suitable subjects, which include &bquo;public administration, management studies, economics, law, criminology, social sciences, youth work, English language and literature and relevant modern languages&equo;. 
 The circular goes on to point out that the list is not exhaustive and suggests other courses may be appropriate. 
 I had applied to continue full-time research following my degree course, but this had been turned down by my chief officers; however, I had been told that assistance for part-time study would almost certainly be approved in view of the national policy of encouraging officers to extend their educational qualifications. 
 I then found my application for financial assistance for part-time study had been rejected &bquo;because anthropology is not on the approved list of subjects (in the Circular)&equo; (Memo from HQ 1977). 
 Eventually I was able to convince my senior officers that anthropology was  one of the social sciences, perhaps only because I somewhat sardonically returned a memo which asked &bquo;why, if anthropology is not approved, have I just been allowed to read the subject on a Bramshill Scholarship, on full pay and allowances?&equo; 
 Just over a year later, at a &bquo;Career Appraisal Interview&equo; with the chief constable, I was asked: &bquo;tell me, how did you find the law course at the polytechnic?&equo; 
 I pointed out that I had not been to the polytechnic, but had been to Durham University on a scholarship &mdash; only the second the force had been awarded. 
 I was then  asked: &bquo;what's the difference between a law course at polytechnic and at the university?&equo; 
 This assumption that policemen study law becomes axiomatic. 
 As Smith (ibid.) indicates, the cost of one scholarship (when he was writing in 1978) was about &pound;30,000 and by the late 1980s this had risen to well over &pound;100,000. 
 Yet some twelve months after I had graduated, I was now having my first interview with my chief constable who had no idea what I had studied or what result I had achieved. 
 This tendency to ignore those on scholarships is mentioned by Smith (ibid. 154): 
 with one exception, all &lsqb;scholars&rsqb; contacted have expressed strongly that the service did not appear to see the practical relevance of university training, did not know how to exploit the benefits gained by the individual and in many cases showed noticeable coolness to those who were part of it. 
 This &bquo;coolness&equo; is something other scholars have experienced. 
 An inspector reading humanities at Oxford, told me: &bquo;I felt cut off, with no contact back at work. 
 No one wished to know me, I was away and forgotten.&equo; 
 Another inspector from Merseyside, reading social studies at Liverpool, said: &bquo;I felt isolated, not just ignored, but socially dead&equo; (personal communication). 
 Smith (ibid. 157) also touches on the crucial feeling of potentiality which the university experience can produce in the individual, but which the police are generally unable to incorporate. 
 Yet another inspector returning to Leicester with a degree in psychology was set to work in the force vehicle store counting tyres. 
 Like many graduates stimulated by their experiences, he discovered that although he had been of sufficient calibre to acquire the offer of the scholarship in the first place, he now faced the inevitable service obsession with a rejection of academic prowess in preference for &bquo;practical skills in the real world&equo; (ibid. 157): 
 the greatest problem with the current working of the scheme appears to relate to &bquo;re-entry&equo; into the Service&hellip; 
 The impact upon the personality expectations and the way of life of a mature scholar by the University experience is not appreciated by many of the police&hellip; 
 It is therefore difficult for him to appreciate the general view of the Service, that, on his return&hellip; he must re-establish his professional standing, even though a few years earlier the Service had sent him to University because he had proved himself to be a good, practical policeman. 
 For those who go on to read postgraduate studies, there is the further problem of publishing any research findings. 
 A police graduate I met at a seminar on &bquo;Research into the Police&equo;, which we had both attended in a private capacity and without force blessing or financial assistance, later wrote to me: 
 there are always strong moves to keep studies under wraps. 
 There is a tendency for senior officers to suppress research findings and to advise those who see it as useful and important, to desist. 
 Usually career coercion will suffice to ensure that any troublesome thesis stays unpublished and out of the public eye. 
 In the late 1970s another insider academic experienced this autocratic preference for silence when he was served a notice under the Official Secrets Act. 
 He had proposed to publish his Ph.D. 
 thesis, and although apparently not very controversial, it invoked such extreme measures simply to ensure it remained under wraps. 
 It would, of course, have revealed some aspects of the variable world of police culture to the outside and this was unacceptable. 
 Another writer on the police met similar problems when he wished to write and publish. 
 I had discussed the problems of insider analysis with him at a 1988 Police Conference, where he described how, on return to his force after his undergraduate degree, he had asked for permission to publish research material. 
 His request was refused in a written memo from HQ, but no reason was given. 
 Unwilling to accept this constraint, he went on to ask &bquo;why not?&equo; (again in written report) and was informed reasons were never given; the official line was simply to refuse all such requests. 
 Not unexpectedly, this officer left the police and moved into academic life. 
 Even the simple article sent to the magazine Police Review  can be subject to vetting and many Force Orders demand this privilege. 
 Another inspector I know had problems with an innocuous piece written in a mildly conversational style. 
 This was put up for vetting to a nominated superintendent whose instinctive response was to deny its submission, suggesting it &bquo;looked as if it would be editorially unsuitable&equo;. 
 He had come up against sterner stuff, however, and an assistant chief constable was called in to mediate and eventually agreed to send it on after the author urged that the editor of the magazine be allowed to decide (fieldnotes 1988).  
 Even a letter to the Police Review  can be regarded as a form of indiscipline: 
 Writing to the Police Review 
 In a duty report to my chief constable I mentioned I had written to Police Review . 
 He sent me a memorandum directing me to inform him in future before I write to any newspaper periodical on matters appertaining to the force. 
 Do you consider that I may have committed a disciplinary offence? 
 Answer 
 A chief constable is perfectly entitled to insist on being informed when a member of his force writes to the press on matters appertaining to his force. 
 The Disciplinary Code in Schedule 1 to the Police (Discipline) Regulations 1985 contains an offence of &bquo;improper disclosure of information&equo;, which is committed where a member of a police force without proper authority communicates to any person, any information which he has in his possession as a member of a police force. 
 This does not apply to matters of general interest, although some senior officers appear to have strange interpretations of their own. 
 (Police Review  26 August 1988: 1797) 
 Of course, the desire to obtain control of the written word has always been one indication of the autocratic mind. 
 This fear of open debate continues even when the publication is by a retired officer and when control is less easy for the chief officer to enforce: 
 Sir Peter Imbert, the Met Commissioner, has written to Met officers warning that he would take proceedings under the Official Secrets Act against police who break an internal discipline code which prohibits &bquo;improper disclosure of information&equo;. 
 The step follows the newspaper serialisation of former D/Chief Supt. Drummond Marvin's account of sensational cases he handled as deputy head of the force's Serious Crime Squad. 
 (Police Review  26 June 1988: 1779) 
 There are shades of Peter Wright and Spycatcher  here, with the warning to stay silent extending to ex-members of the &bquo;family&equo;. 
 It is a salutary lesson on the stability of this precept to see Sir Peter following the precedent set by his predecessors in Sir David McNee and Sir Kenneth Newman, both of whom, as I have indicated above, rejected the internal desire to philosophize or be discursive. 
 In West Mercia, there have been regular reissues of Force  Orders to remind members to be circumspect in their dissertations and essays prepared for part-time diplomas in Management Services or the NEBS qualification which is now an integral part of inspector training. 
 The fear is always that the outside will be presented with the chance to gain knowledge and power at the expense of the institution; although this is often only obliquely implied: 
 Persons Undertaking Outside Study: Disclosure of Information 
 From time to time, and particularly in connection with external courses, police officers and civilian employees may have cause to write articles, dissertations, essays, etc., which require them to research information of a privileged nature. 
 It may not be&hellip; prudent for such information to be then read by other than police personnel. 
 Such information may not necessarily carry any security classification within the Service, but may simply reveal dispositions, working arrangements etc. 
 When such information is submitted to tutors or course directors etc., there is no guarantee of its circulation or copying. 
 All personnel who undertake external study or produce articles should be mindful of the dangers of revealing privileged information and should: 
 a) Use their own discretion on the use or reproduction of such information. 
 b) If in any doubt, seek the advice of a senior officer of the rank of Superintendent or above. 
 c) If it is considered imperative that such privileged information should be included on the paper and which &lsqb; sic &rsqb; falls within the terms of the concern expressed above, then the whole should be submitted for approval by a Chief Officer&hellip; who will give a ruling as to its use and circulation. 
 Nothing in this order changes the already existing practices exercised in connection with courses or papers overseen by the Regional Inspector Training Unit or Police College. 
 In these cases a Senior Police Officer has &bquo;first read&equo; of any papers and all other personnel involved have been required to enter into an undertaking to respect the security of the information. 
 (Force Order w/e 28 November 1987). 
 In effect, such an order intends that all dissertations and papers will be submitted for vetting. 
 Any criteria for defining &bquo;privileged information&equo;, or what the &bquo;dangers&equo; are in revealing such matters as dispositions (of manpower) are so vaguely incorporated as to  ensure that few will risk submitting an essay without approval, which might later be assessed as an &bquo;improper disclosure&equo;. 
 The creation of this order at the time a new Official Secrets Bill was being pushed through Parliament by an increasingly interventionist government is significant, and the idea of a senior officer's having &bquo;first read&equo; of any essay to maintain the integrity of the institution manifests the importance of the legalized surveillance of allegedly dangerous material and enhances the separation of the world of control from that academic enquiry; although its implementation is only randomly applied. 
 Just as Sgt Wilson's thesis was channelled to me because I was known to be interested in research, so many police research departments now get allocated the task of reading the essays submitted by sergeants and inspectors for NEBS or DMS qualifications. 
 In 1988 a visiting colleague from the Royal Ulster Constabulary asked if it was part of my role in Systems Development Department to comment on such essays. 
 He told of his own difficulties in finding time to read all the variable essays submitted and knew of many that were never sent in at all. 
 For although Force Orders inevitably direct that such material will be submitted for assessment, it is typical that in a task-orientated institution which gives low priority or credence to the academic tome, the systems to ensure submission of the essays, or the ability to make much use of any useful ideas they contain, often remains sketchy. 
 As the director of the Police Foundation, Barrie Irving (1984: 4) commented, &bquo;Unlike their American counterparts, the British police community, together with their administrators, do not devour large quantities of written material &lsqb;and&rsqb; if a research project does not produce results which can be acted upon&hellip; no amount of careful editing and dissemination will make an impact.&equo; 
 Research in the police, Irving further asserts, is a matter of pragmatics, eliminating philosophical enquiry into systems of belief, or how the knowledge of an ideology is transformed into action. 
 In the end, only the action is viable, so that all these essays tend to match the inside ethnography and are nullified by neglect or have any contentious matter treated as &bquo;privileged information&equo;, for as Templeton (1980: 904) argues &bquo;the police fear that if you have a better understanding of society, you are in a better position to change it &mdash; the very exercise &lsqb;they&rsqb; are reluctant to engage in&equo;. 
 Those who do go public are disloyal and there are thinly veiled  attempts to dismiss the value of any revelation they make, for they are expected to remain silent and uncritical. 
 When Ronald Gregory, the ex-chief constable of West Yorkshire, said little or nothing new about the &bquo;Yorkshire Ripper case&equo; in a series of newspaper articles, he was castigated in Police Review  (1 July 1983) and they republished a 1979 photograph of him when &bquo;his loyalty was unquestioned&equo;. 
 John Alderson, the ex-chief constable of Devon and Cornwall has suffered even more from his subsequent public persona, because of a move into academia, some critical publications, and a flirtation with the political life. 
 Police Review  (18 February 1983) has an article on him by a superintendent, which is full of graphic metaphors clearly illustrating this idea of &bquo;traitors to the service&equo;. 
 Alderson is revealingly described: &bquo;poor old John Alderson &lsqb;has&rsqb; gone careering off the rails, &lsqb;and is&rsqb; now shacked up with the liberal party&hellip; an intellectual liberal reformer with radical ideas &lsqb;whose&rsqb; philosophical mumbo jumbo, often incomprehensible, and not very original, did nothing to impress&equo;. 
 Furthermore, &bquo;there have been questions about his loyalty&equo;, for Alderson has had the temerity to caution the service about an apparent drift towards paramilitarism. 
 Needless to say the revelations made by John Stalker (1988) were also less than welcome to the service, and all around I heard my contemporaries condemn the fact that he had gone public. 
 Inevitably, I noted these criticisms were rarely in relation to what he had said (few had actually read the book), but rather were expressions of shocked outrage that he had failed to keep silent and say nothing at all. 
 Indeed, the fact that he had apparently used an editor from a Manchester newspaper for some of his purposes was latched onto and quoted as a sign that he was &bquo;suspect&equo; and &bquo;disloyal&equo;. 
 One consequence of these modes of thought is that the service has to live out a continuous and enormous paradox. 
 Even at the same time as it publicly commends higher education, seeking out the graduate entrant, spending large sums on publicity to this  end, and funding access to degree courses on scholarships, it also holds to a central ethic of distrust of the academic. 
 Whitaker (1979: 229) clearly understands the way this rejection of training and education operates within the service: 
 at present good recruits often have to be chased to Bramshill &lsqb;on the lengthy command courses&rsqb;, because chief constables are not anxious to spare able men, and officers themselves are reluctant to be separated from their families and homes, as well as having a fear that they might lose from being &bquo;out of sight, out of mind&equo; for promotion. 
 And although always implied rather than broadcast, this rejection of intellectualism is so well understood throughout the service that it has even affected those to whom Bramshill scholarships to University have been offered, and many turn them down. 
 I know several inspectors who have refused a college scholarship, arguing that the time spent away from the force was time spent in structural limbo, and it has become almost a common adage that time away is time lost in &bquo;the promotion stakes&equo;. 
 All that is required, they feel, is the offer of a scholarship from the Police College, for it serves the same purpose on the c.v. 
 and reduces the need to spend time in limbo or the need on re-entry to reestablish oneself. 
 Furthermore, it reduces the risk of being labelled with the derogatory term of &bquo;academic&equo;. 
 This marginality of academics continually comes to the fore and my fieldnotes are full of examples. 
 In 1987 at one of the regular meetings of superintendents, I listened as the deputy chief constable talked his way through a potential problem for the increasing numbers of graduates in the service, who &bquo;obviously cannot all make it to the top&equo;. 
 Of course this has always been the case for all entrants, for there are only forty-three chief constables and the same number of deputies, so few have a chief officer's truncheon in their knapsack (to paraphrase an old army chestnut). 
 The inference in this was not really about the career chances of the still tiny percentage of graduates (who are obviously well aware that their chances of reaching the highest echelons are constrained by the limitations in the numbers of top posts), rather it was a reassertion  that those with a degree are almost a different species and remain a threat to the stability of the institution. 
 It is not uncommon for the police magazines to feature this antipathy to the academic, and especially the social science researcher: 
 When you take away all the sociological clap trap  which is fashionable in some circles, policing is all about dealing with folk. 
 At the end of the day we must concern ourselves with the practicalities and not philosophies of dealing with everyday problems. 
 (Police Review , 18 May 1983) 
 now &bquo;body language&equo; has to be dressed up with a lot of sociological clap trap  and paraded as some marvellous new technique, aimed at revolutionising police relations with the public. 
 If you believe that not only will you believe anything, you'll probably end up as a Doctor of Philosophy. 
 (Police  magazine, May 1981; my emphases) 
 Inevitably those few insiders who do undertake postgraduate research in the social sciences are aware that they are involved in the creation of &bquo;clap trap&equo;, and must know that this denigration stems from the implicit threat they pose to the structures of pedagogy and institutional power. 
 Those who pursue explication can expect to be seen as suspicious, for they embody the marginality of the anthropologist, described by L&eacute;vi-Strauss (1973: 67) as being someone who is &bquo;psychologically speaking maimed, an amputee&equo;. 
 This maimed psyche, according to Francis Huxley (1970: 62), creates a specific concept of the self and makes the inside anthropologist &bquo;a mutilated man&hellip; in curious revolt against his own society&equo;. 
 In such a world many graduates learn to play down their qualifications, for they know the hostility which exists towards academia and realize the significance of &bquo;practical ability&equo; gained in &bquo;the university of real life&equo;. 
 Furthermore the graduate recruits can judge the derisory attitude to academics for themselves, simply by picking up most editions of Police  magazine. 
 One example (September 1980) headed &bquo;University Challenge&equo; exemplifies this antipathy, with a full page of cartoons on graduate candidates illustrating a range of negative symbols. 
 These graduate applicants are shaggy, long haired, and bearded, reflecting a direct binary to the approved short back and sides. 
 Their need for thick-lensed &bquo;John Lennon&equo; spectacles implies they are physically imperfect as they slouch or lean against props; for these lazy, untidy creatures have techniques of the body which reveal major structuring  principles of police thinking. 
 Their clothes are bedraggled in a clear symbolic indication of bodily order and its antithesis, and illustrate a microcosmic representation of police values. 
 Bourdieu (1977: 94&ndash;5) describes these as a means by which 
 all totalitarian institutions (in Goffman's phrase) embody their principles in an inexplicit way, beyond the grasp of consciousness and exhort the essential by an implicit pedagogy, capable of instilling a whole cosmology, an ethic, a political philosophy through injunctions as insignificant as &bquo;stand up straight&equo;. 
 It is little wonder then that social research is equated with &bquo;clap trap&equo; in police magazines, for they aim to support the beliefs of those who have taken on this unconscious cosmology, and for whom as Bourdieu (ibid.) indicates, such challenges would defy &bquo;the most natural manifestations of submission to the established order &lsqb;and abolish&rsqb; lateral possibilities&equo;. 
 In consequence of this acquired system of generative schemes, an imbued belief is implanted in the institutional mind which verges on &bquo;the natural&equo;, while Huxley's &bquo;mutilated man&equo; pursuing his insider's reflexivity seeks out the lateral possibility, and makes gestures against the principles of the organization. 
 In doing this the anthropologist &bquo;at home&equo; quickly comes to understand why he must always stand on the margins of structure. 
 For it is one of the dictums of the discipline of anthropology that it will reveal unwelcome truths: 
 the anthropologist is committed not simply to description, but to analysing and questioning the definitions and assumptions on which social groups base their existence and predicate their activities, and to unveiling that which may be concealed or unrecognised. 
 This makes the anthropologist at the least an uncomfortable associate, at the worst seem &bquo;dirty&equo;, &bquo;dangerous&equo; or even &bquo;subversive&equo;. 
 (Akeroyd 1980: 6) 
 Anthropology has been prominent in showing how the marginal in any society tends to pose problems for state institutions and governments; and the insider must anticipate that his conclusions might well be 
 frequently uncomfortable &lsqb;and&rsqb; may well challenge the assumptions of the institution. 
 Anthropological knowledge can seem, and often is, dangerous and subversive &mdash; not because we are good at digging up dirt (we  are), nor simply because we document what &bquo;actually happens&equo; rather than what is supposed to happen, but because our ways of defining situations and problems often raise questions in our minds about the fundamental assumptions on which any institution bases its own definitions, and indeed the assumptions on which it rests as an institution. 
 They get far more than they bargain for. 
 (Grillo 1980: 3) 
 In effect, the insider who reveals the structural formations of a system of power inverts that power and the revelation creates a situation where elements of &bquo;anti-structure&equo; (Turner 1969, 1974) now present a version of how things might be constituted; and what has been seen as solid reality begins to be identified as only one social possibility. 
 In this observing participation, the &bquo;thick description&equo; which Geertz (1975) argued for comes hurtling at the ethnographer, so that the classic use of an &bquo;anthropological informant&equo; is hardly necessary. 
 Rather it will be a case of the researcher finding a means of recording and sorting the mass of detail which continuously bombards him and presents him with the lateral possibilities which make the discipline potentially dangerous. 
 He will have little opportunity to stand back and examine the data in the cool light of the academic &bquo;ivory tower&equo;. 
 Nor will he be able to take a sabbatical to formulate the complex structures of meaning lodged deep in the empirical material, which L&eacute;vi-Strauss (1976: 80) has argued are capable of linking together symbolic and metaphoric programmes to &bquo;reveal properties not immediately accessible to the (empirical) observation&equo;. 
 To coin another military metaphor, he must &bquo;soldier on&equo; knowing that all of this activity might well smack of sedition. 
 Even the fact that someone inside is writing fieldnotes will produce unease, as I have experienced; and their collation can almost certainly be tantamount to something akin to espionage; for as Sean Conlin (1980) observed: &bquo;often our work can seem &bquo;political&equo; rather than scientific&equo;. 
 WRITING THE &bquo;ESPIONAGE&equo; 
 Because of this insider's knowledge, I chose to record my fieldnotes surreptitiously and with much burning of the midnight oil. 
 My practical mastery had made me acutely aware of the boundaries which separate those inside the institution from those  excluded from the specialist knowledge of &bquo;doing the business&equo; and I was more than ever aware of the suspicions which would have been aroused if I had introduced questions of an academic nature, or had distributed questionnaires. 
 Like Powdermaker (1967), who recorded fieldnotes in Mississippi only when she was away from her field data, I found I only took notes at the time if I was willing to risk begin interrogated about what I was going to do with the information I was recording. 
 Webb et al . 
 (1966: 72) recognized such unobtrusive measures have found favour in field-work and I discovered at an early stage that the problem remains one of revealing the structural warts of the system while somehow indicating that this need not be seditious; and indeed might even be of some value. 
 As it is, when I showed close colleagues my first working paper (Young 1979a) on experiences in a police bridewell (see Chapters 2 and 3), they were alarmed. 
 I was told on more than one occasion, that I should not really let outsiders see this sort of thing, even though it was agreed that what I had written was an accurate analysis of events. 
 In some respects, I think it was the detail of the ethnographic &bquo;thick description&equo; which most alarmed them; for as almost all of them wistfully pointed out: &bquo;it shows exactly how we do the business&equo;. 
 In effect the insider who questions the gross systems of classification which define police practice seems set to join those deviants or criminals who contest the system of law and order by breaking its rules and regulations. 
 Any challenge to what is an almost xenophobic and dichotomous world of &bquo;order&equo; and &bquo;disorder&equo; casts the social analyst and the critical criminologist onto the dark side of the binary. 
 To some extent these academic outsiders are &bquo;the enemy&equo; of police society, whose training and class aspirations makes them supporters of the status quo and resentful of liberal ideas or academic intrusion (Reiner 1978a). 
 When Sarah McCabe (1980) queried the logic of why just one police system should be entrusted with the control of crime, law, order, and social assistance, pointing out, &bquo;there is some disagreement about the use of the criminal law &mdash; unease about control of the streets&hellip; &lsqb;which poses the question&rsqb; who will be controlled and &lsqb;who will be&rsqb; assisted&equo;, she found the tenor of her &bquo;thoughtful and moderate examination of the police role&hellip; was too much for the senior officers to whom it was presented, and they set out to discredit it with a will&equo; (Greenhill 1981: 98).  
 It seems most likely then, that the increasing police budgets (up from &pound;3.35 billion in 1988/9 to &pound;4.1 billion in 1989/90), which have risen by over 50 per cent in real terms since 1979, will be used to maintain, defend, and expand on this hegemonic style. 
 For who within the service is seeking or is willing to dismantle these units whose power and autonomy has been growing in strides since the Royal Commission of 1960 and the subsequent Police Act of 1964 first created the amalgamated giants? 
 Today, in the early 1990s there seems to be every possibility their taste for autocracy and power might persuade the police that secrecy should take on a new dimension, so that sedition could acquire new status as a deviance, while even the &bquo;espionage&equo; of ethnography could well become actionable. 
 In this situation, research into the police could well become increasingly difficult and even less welcome than it was a decade ago. 
 At that time, Punch (1979) pointed out (in a comparison of facilities in Britain and Holland) that research into the police in Britain is not easy and 
 I think it would be more difficult to gain access and get co-operation &lsqb;from a British Force&rsqb;. 
 Also there is more hostility towards academics than in Holland where their status is higher. 
 In the U.K. academics tend to be denigrated&hellip; 
 In practice some areas of police work are unresearchable, but in principle they shouldn't be. 
 If research can be done in Holland and the USA, I don't see why it shouldn't be done in Britain, except I suspect that some British police forces are just hostile to outsiders. 
 I think this is probably true of the Metropolitan Police; they have never really allowed any fundamental research on any sensitive issue. 
 You get people like Belson who was allowed to do a survey research of public opinion. 
 Few people have been allowed to do any extensive fieldwork. 
 Since this condemnation of research opportunity, few studies have penetrated deeply beneath the sensitive skin of &bquo;police culture&equo;, and even though Chatterton in his notes to my thesis argued there has been a considerable amount of &bquo;participant police research&equo;, I would question whether many of these inquiries achieved the finer grain and detail' of the insider's account, for they can never really know or tell if they have been excluded from the inner workings of police practice or prevented from gaining access to the hidden realities &bquo;contained inside the heads of the constables&equo;. 
 Because of the &eacute;litism which such an organization of control wields, it is not surprising there is difficulty in incorporating the outside researcher, or in accepting his critical findings. 
 And  certainly that other main arm of executive control &mdash; the army &mdash; seems little better at this than the police, for the number of participant accounts of their deep structures remains negligible, supporting McCabe's (1980) contention that we should be asking of all of these costly institutions, &bquo;who is to be controlled by whom and for what reasons?&equo; 
 Meanwhile, as Reiner (1985) suggests, the politicization of the police has proceeded at a pace, and can be illustrated by their growing willingness to respond to political dissent as a form of &bquo;crime&equo; or deviancy. 
 This trend is further displayed in their growing tendency to agree to be used as a pseudo-military arm of government in its socio-economic and industrial/political disputes with whole sections of society. 
 In 1985, Cressida Dick, a probationary constable, wrote a prize-winning essay which clearly showed an awareness of this politicization, and asked the sort of questions which few senior officers seemed to be thinking or voicing. 
 In her essay &bquo;Implications of the Miners' Strike&equo;, she pointed out that: 
 the Government's seeming indifference to the effect of the dispute on police public relations, &lsqb;should entitle the police&rsqb; to wonder whether it is being used to preserve law and order or to implement government policy. 
 This view of the use of the police as agents of government economic policy was shared, frequently with concern, by much of the public&hellip; 
 The miners' strike marks a set-back for those who argue that police and politics don't mix&hellip; for the discussions generated will serve to accelerate the politicisation of the police&hellip; &lsqb;and&rsqb; has highlighted the presence of ACPO and the NRC &lsqb;the co-ordinating National Reporting Centre&rsqb;, as bodies, set up without the authority of Parliament, of apparently unquantified and unaccountable power. 
 Such expansions of police power were forecast by E. P. Thompson (1980), who considered this to be a period which has no equal. 
 He argued, historically, that he knew &bquo;of no period in which the police have had such a loud and didactic public presence,&hellip; &lsqb;or&rsqb; when they have offered themselves as a distinct interest as one of the great &bquo;institutions&equo; and perhaps the first in the realm&equo;. 
 In such a climate it seems even more suitable to pursue the creation of a radical, insider ethnography and in the not too distant past this even seemed to have official support. 
 Writing in a more liberal decade, the commandant of the Police Staff College (Lamford undated &mdash; but probably in the late 1960s) suggested:  
 it would seem desirable to encourage individual police officers to come &lsqb;to the college&rsqb; to do research on their own account. 
 The Staff College should be a place where serving officers have the opportunity to contemplate society as a whole and in particular to study and consider those liberal and humane values which are central to our society. 
 The college should have as its prime concern the nurture of ethics and integrity; they are the core of any professions. 
 Such a proposal is now of another era, however, and I was present when an ex-Dean of Academic Studies at the college presented a paper (Stead 1980) attacking the trend to expensive, amalgamated police units which had grown up in the previous two decades. 
 The appetite for power these immense forces display worried Stead, and he argued their style could only lead to an autocratic national system with a minister of central government at the apex. 
 His fears seem to be well founded, for a move towards regionalization is now occurring, with a proposal that the forty-three forces disappear into perhaps eight or nine giant regional units. 
 Stead argues that only constant inquiry (for which I could substitute &bquo;inside ethnography&equo;) can prevent such an unacceptable trend, and it is some comfort to see a probationary policewoman, such as Cressida Dick (1985), pointing out the political compromises such autocracy can produce, but which few of the chief officers seem willing to admit or even acknowledge. 
 However, I am not hopeful that her example will force the institution to reassess its attitude to the critical account, for even the fears of someone like Stead, which came from a central location of police power at the Staff College at Bramshill, seem to have largely fallen on stony ground. 
 In the main, the college has produced little radical comment or research of note during the four decades of its existence, for the various chief officers have jealously ensured that any consolidation of ideological excellence at this location has been neutered, and under Home Office direction its senior courses have primarily been used to provide a stream of suitably acquiescent candidates for the ACPO ranks, who readily take on the symbols and metaphors of dominance which feed the appetite for power Stead warns against. 
 In 1987 I spent the summer at the college on the Intermediate Command Course and found it depressing to see just how little research was being sponsored or carried out there. 
 The vast  library on police matters was clearly under-used and there is obviously a need for a critical ethnography of the college itself, for it takes in numbers of senior and middle police managers each year, maintains a considerable staff of academics and visiting lecturers, but has singularly failed to provide an academically stimulating &bquo;university of policing&equo;. 
 Even the civilian academics at the college seem to be nullified by the overriding police desire for circumspection in the written account and the preference for academic silence. 
 It could be anticipated that the college would have seen the creation of a continuous stream of books and papers generated by the rich source of material which pours through its gates, but this has hardly been the case. 
 Two books in the recent past (Pope and Weiner 1981 and Thackrah 1985) both contain veiled indications of the problems these civil service academics encounter when they write about the police. 
 In a forward to Modern Policing  (Pope and Weiner ibid.), 
 Sir Kenneth Newman &mdash; then commandant &mdash; suggests that the book's claim to attention is that its contents are contributed by insiders; while in their introduction, the authors claim it goes some way to challenging Holdaway's claim (1979) that &bquo;research from the Police Staff College has not resulted in a major project on the police&equo;. 
 However, an anonymous reviewer of the Pope and Weiner edition (Police Journal  1982), seems to disagree with their claims: 
 there is a consistent air of frustration in the writings of some of the social scientist contributors&hellip; it is almost as though they wish they were in closer touch with the operational side of the service. 
 Certainly the absence of contact is noticeable. 
 Furthermore, as these college-based insiders stress, their essays do not represent police college views or those of the Home Office; and both Thackrah (1985) and his publisher, James Tindall, take pains to ensure from the outset that we are aware than any views expressed in the book are &bquo;those of individual contributors, and not those of the college, the Home Office, or &lsqb;even&rsqb; the police service&equo;. 
 One might suggest then that the &bquo;major project&equo; Holdaway recognized was missing from the college inventory is still to come! 
 Indeed the anonymous reviewer of the Pope and Weiner edition went on to propose that &bquo;if the police staff college is to fulfil its task &lsqb;of producing a major project&rsqb; with any credibility, it must  encourage its academic staff to go out into the field to study policing at first hand&equo;. 
 Other challenges to social researchers to pursue a form of participant observation are to be occasionally found in the journals: 
 questions were being raised about what the police were doing, what they ought to be doing and how they ought to be organised and accountable. 
 The fact that these questions are being raised has significance for the authority of the police&hellip; and it is the single most important determinant of the style of policing. 
 Thus we need to explore in more concrete terms the operational aspects of the questions and the dilemmas they produce. 
 (Manning and Butler 1982: 338) 
 But if attempts to produce this concrete research are doomed to neglect or derision or to be defined as &bquo;espionage&equo;, then what can be achieved? 
 The answer must be &bquo;not a great deal&equo;; for none of the portents of success are immediately apparent. 
 WPC Dick's salutary essay (1985) changed little and generated few ripples on the ACPO pond, while one of the most powerfully critical books on policing in recent years (Jones 1980) seems to have had little effect on the structures of the organization, except, perhaps, to help draw its author &mdash; then a chief inspector &mdash; into the ACPO ranks. 
 Mervyn Jones (ibid.), in this book on organizational  behaviors , presented some glaringly uncomfortable findings. 
 Critical of the way that status is attributed by the institution, his thesis was that even as the service proclaims &bquo;beat patrol work&equo; to be the basis of all good policework, it penalizes and stigmatizes those who remain there. 
 The young officer, he concluded, must escape at the first opportunity or risk being classified as an unambitious &bquo;no hoper&equo; at an early career stage. 
 A keenly stated desire to move into some area of specialization is a necessity, and, as a result, uniform patrol work becomes synonymous with failure and punishment. 
 Men get sent back  from specialist posts to uniform duties as a punishment and the strength of this metaphorical move downwards or backwards (you can never move &bquo;up&equo; or &bquo;forwards&equo; into uniform) is not lost on young officers. 
 Few prior to Jones had cared to admit this seditious point except in the columns of the Police Review , where disgruntled beat officers (often anonymously) indicate the paradox of being the revered and reviled base on which all the hierarchy is built.  
 Jones's book remained untouched on the shelves of Northumbria's modest library in its first two years, even though it had good reviews; and the influence of his research has been all but negligible. 
 For even though some attempt to give status to the &bquo;community or home beat officer&equo; has been made following Lord Scarman's (1981) report on the Brixton riots which gave something of a &bquo;slap on the wrist&equo; to the service, the deference accorded to specialist posting or to detective work remains untouched. 
 In effect Jones's book revealed an unwelcome truth which no one really wanted to hear and which the service was able easily to diffuse and ignore. 
 Indeed when I was at the police college in 1987 and Jones was on the Senior Command Course prior to taking up a position as assistant chief constable, I took a straw poll among my immediate colleagues to see what influence such books achieve. 
 None had read the book or knew its detail, although one or two knew he had written something. 
 The real problem is that such research reveals modes of thought and practice which are well known and constituted, but which are necessarily concealed. 
 For who inside the system needs to be told what is well understood? 
 Silence continues to sustain the hegemony, and social change only occurs when irresistible and more powerful forces are brought to bear from outside (see Adams 1988). 
 Furthermore, such pressures are limited, thus creating a situation where 
 there has been hardly any research on the police compared with the large output of critical scholarship on industry, commerce, the civil service, the health service and education&hellip; what little direct research there has been on the police has scarcely begun to ask such fundamental questions as what is the police force and what is it doing. 
 This point (Wojtas 1982) occurs in a description of a new research centre for Police Studies at Strathclyde University, which is &bquo;to ask whether anyone is doing research on the police, what degree of co-operation they have met&hellip; and to encourage research by the police themselves&equo;. 
 Once again, however, defensiveness won the day and when the Strathclyde Centre circulated forces asking them to co-operate in the venture, a decision was taken to withhold co-operation and a circular went round to this effect, suggesting the existing Home Office funded PRSU (Police Research Services  Unit) and the Home Office Research and Planning Unit were adequate for the needs of the service. 
 This latter unit (formerly the HO Research Unit) does provide some research material for those who seek it out and its bulletin is a reference source to recent government funded research, which is largely concerned with operational systems and the tools of policing. 
 However, I have never seen a copy of this circulated at the subdivision level at any location I have worked; and outside force HQ the availability of any research or analytic literature on policing falls off dramatically. 
 HO Circular (194/78) describing British and American research literature on policing is another typically apologetic, anti-intellectual document, for within its first few paragraphs it admits: 
 the implication of attempting to establish a central research information centre to give advice to chief officers about research findings, &lsqb;or&rsqb; collect, collate and distribute research of interest to the police service, and maintain an up-to-date index of research would be very considerable. 
 There are no plans to establish such a centre. 
 No one seems to have asked whether the Staff College could have taken on this job, but then again such anti-intellectualism is apparent even in the Bramshill Scholars' Association. 
 In 1985, they proposed to extend their role beyond that of an annual dining club for officers who had taken a degree through the police college scheme. 
 It was mooted the association 
 could offer a unique police view of current problems. 
 We could host University seminars to which speakers of note could be invited to attend. 
 In this way the Association could counter the Left Wing Type Seminars &lsqb;sic&rsqb; which were often very one sided and misrepresentative of current Police views&hellip; 
 The Chairman also suggested that the membership could publish papers. 
 This narrow academic proposal for a one-sided, right-wing debating group was circulated in August 1986, with options for the future of the association. 
 These were to be considered at the AGM on 20 September 1986 when the association would seek to create &bquo;a blend of social and professional academic pursuit&equo;. 
 The options never reached a vote, however, as the meeting was cancelled for lack of support! 
 Perhaps in the light of the somewhat narrow academic bias outlined by this cream of police studentship, it is just as well the college was not allocated the task of collating and circulating research to chief officers!  
 In the early 1980s, many forces had reduced secondments to universities or polytechnics, for these had been somewhat unprogrammatic. 
 By 1987, the Home Office Research and Planning Unit Programme was indicating, &bquo;now that resources are more constrained, more stringent criteria of relevance must be applied to the funding of research for the Home Office&equo;. 
 Four years previous, Northumbria decided to reduce the numbers allowed a secondment. 
 An assistant chief constable told a conference of senior officers: &bquo;with future recruitment, the number of graduates will increase&equo;. 
 The conference was also told that as an alternative to the expense of sending officers to university, it was proposed to &bquo; direct  officers to research a particular problem&hellip; and give them a short period to carry out intensive research&equo;. 
 The emphasis on &bquo;directed&equo; research is mine and indicates the reduced potential for any ethnographic sedition, for which force would seek to direct officers to the critical analysis of its subcultural idiosyncrasies? 
 Furthermore, such short periods of &bquo;directed&equo; research can be shown favourably as a saving over any extended degree course in the budgets. 
 The emphasis of this &bquo;directed&equo; (or controlled?) research, it was announced, &bquo;is to be on pragmatic, problem-solving enquiries&equo; (i.e. policy-orientated research), which, it was explained, &bquo;would be of cost-effective advantage to the force&equo;. 
 There seems to be little chance of any philosophical, unprogrammatic enquiry here which might be critical of the system; and no &bquo;espionage&equo; from within! 
 This cost-effective nature of a scholarship was a matter I had been asked to justify when I first asked my new assistant chief constable about the potential of postgraduate research as an &bquo;observing participator&equo;. 
 I had mentioned the unquantifiable public relationships which could be generated during a secondment and argued for the intangible value of the many hundreds of contacts I had made which could not easily be costed in purely fiscal terms. 
 He dismissed this as irrelevant and his use of metaphor, in what  turned out to be an eighty-minute interview, was most revealing. 
 I later recorded he invariably used the idea of an &bquo;escape from real work&equo; to describe any research secondment; in doing so he embodied the common institutional fear of uncontrolled social movement across a divide or boundary into another society such as academia. 
 This is part of the ideological pedagogy which the institution uses to create and maintain defensive boundaries against the outsider or those who might produce a critical analysis of its systems; it is one major strength of the organization. 
 Again, as I recorded in a fieldnote, this assistant chief exhibited aspects of what I could only then describe as &bquo;institutional paranoia&equo;, when he went on to deride an unnamed social scientist who had been allowed research facilities inside a police force (unspecified). 
 He dismissively described how this man had &bquo;come in, taken the material provided, and then had written a childish and critical book on the police, out of which he got a Ph.D.&equo; 
 Again a metaphorical breach of a sacred boundary has occurred and an &bquo;enemy&equo; made a gain at the expense of the integrity of the inside! 
 It is this logic of practice which effectively negates most research and is perhaps the main reason that between 1979 and 1988, only one of the research papers I have compiled has been looked at by senior officers. 
 Neglectful silence is, of course, the most perfect means of maintaining the powerful integrity of the institutional boundaries against any criticisms. 
 During this period I have given readings and seminar papers at various academic centres, including the universities of Oxford, Durham, Edinburgh, Essex, Manchester, Lancaster, Newcastle, Sussex, and East Anglia, and have written a number of unpublished papers which I have given in seminars at other similar establishments. 
 On more than one occasion, I have included a bibliography when submitting a c.v. 
 to my senior command and in 1986 I informed my chief officers of the acceptance of my Ph.D. 
 thesis, in accordance with the directive laid down by Force Orders. 
 No one, of course, has asked to read it, for &mdash; if my argument is correct &mdash; the service has no need of any reminder of how  the ideology works or how to implement the paradigms which support their cultural norms. 
 Nor do they need their daily practice to be exposed to the analytic eye of anthropological &bquo;thick description&equo;, for in their task-driven world there is little to be gained by reflecting on what they already live and understand. 
 Any need to analyse the ways in which the multi-variant police world forms a coherent and self-sustaining whole is material for the social scientist and not the practitioners, for they already live the system as a matter of course. 
 The police, therefore, have little to gain in promoting any exploration of their modes of thought, for analysis can only hold the possibility that the whole intricate system, to paraphrase L&eacute;vi-Strauss (1967), will be revealed &bquo;as an immense disorder &lsqb;which&rsqb; is organised in the form of a grammar&equo;. 
 In consequence, police ethnography remains largely unwritten simply because it is unlikely the organization will be keen to reveal the ways this &bquo;immense disorder&equo; is constructed, for it is not in their nature to allow other individuals to create their classifications for them. 
 Indeed, institutional ideology sets out to &bquo;strait-jacket minds and bodies and overcome individual thought&equo; (Foucault 1970). 
 Mary Douglas (1987: 92), in her analysis of How Institutions Think , pursues Foucault's argument a stage further to show that: 
 Institutions systematically direct and channel our perceptions into forms compatible with the relations they authorize. 
 They fix processes that are essentially dynamic, they hide their influence&hellip; 
 Add to all this that they endow themselves with rightness and send their mutual corroboration cascading through all levels of our information systems. 
 No wonder they easily recruit us into joining their narcissistic self-contemplation. 
 Any problems we try to think about are automatically transformed into their own organizational problems. 
 The solutions they proffer only come from the limited range of their own experience. 
 If the institution&hellip; is one that depends on participation, it will reply to our frantic questions: &bquo;more participation!&equo; 
 If it is one that depends on authority, it will only reply: &bquo;More authority!&equo; 
 Institutions have the pathetic megalomania of the computer whose whole vision of the world is its own programme. 
 This extremely perceptive analysis of the institutional mind fits the police world like a glove, and recent elaborations in policing, along with its growth in the mainstream of the daily social process, supports Douglas's contention (ibid.) that an institution which is dependent upon authority can only demand more of the  same. 
 In such ontological circumstances this allegedly public service must be singularly unsuited to objective assessment of any external demands for a reduction in its power or to encompassing any critical analysis which might cause loss of prestige. 
 Given this premise, we should not be surprised to find the police are in the forefront of support for proposals such as the introduction of identity cards; it was not surprising to find the 1988 Superintendents' Association conference not only supporting this motion, but arguing for the creation of twenty-four hour armed patrols throughout the country and making a plea for a national motorway squad. 
 Always the call will be for more power to the organization, so that the 1989 cry of alarm from the Police Federation conference about private security firms is based more on a fear that areas of influence are being taken from the institution than on beliefs that such groups are incompetent. 
 In a similar fashion, all the representative bodies of the police &mdash; ACPO, the Superintendents' Association, and the Police Federation &mdash; were outraged at the creation of the Crown Prosecution Service in the Prosecution of Offences Act in the mid-1980s; for one area of police power in the courts had been removed at one fell swoop and given to another arm of the executive. 
 So although in a liberal democracy it would seem practical and even suitable for the police to have a say in the way order is defined and maintained, as Foucault (1970) and Douglas (1987) have shown, this will inevitably take on an expansionist line; for anything other than bland support of the proposals of the institution will present a challenge or pose a threat. 
 This dilemma generates the paradox I have outlined above, where intellectualism and graduate recruitment become prized commodities and are publicly sought after as the organization seeks to elaborate its professionalism, but are simultaneously denigrated. 
 In such a world the very idea of research and academic prowess becomes charged with structural ambiguity simply because it creates the potential for outsiders to bring challenging concepts across boundaries which, at other times, are sacrosanct. 
 So what then is the position of the police practitioner who becomes an anthropologist? 
 He is unable to &bquo;switch off&equo; his analytic mind, for he becomes possessed of something which can best be described as &bquo;special knowledge&equo;. 
 On the one hand he can support his understanding of the institutional expectations by simply  repeating those inculcated practices he has learned as a neophyte from the &bquo;stories of the great days of policing&equo;, which are interminably repeated &bquo;at the charge room desk&equo; or &bquo;taken on at Nellie's knee&equo;. 
 Alternatively he can use his understanding of the way the metaphors and structures of significance are used to sustain the institution, and thus reveal the system to be the product of a specific mode of thought, which is only one possibility among many. 
 He must be aware, however, that any antagonistic or critical assessment will not only be unwelcome, but coming from an insider will smell of blasphemy. 
 Anything other than an uncritical acceptance is a direct challenge to the idea of the rule of law which has sustained the police since their inception and which argues that the replication of a known system of order is the best means of containing those who need to be controlled. 
 Alternative readings or critical analysis of this entrenched reverence for a rule of law (which at times may well be out of step with a wider interpretation of ambiguous social behaviour) smacks of subversion simply because it denies the primacy of the institutional framework. 
 And surely, it can be argued, the understanding of what is to be ordered and who is to be disciplined has long been defined and subject to the practical mastery of the controllers. 
 In consequence, even when the insider retires and ostensibly leaves the family, he will be expected to maintain his silence, and although bland hagiographic biography has been acceptable in the past, there has been no place for the espionage of critical ethnography. 
 And even as the unlamented Official Secrets Act of 1911 groaned in its death throes in the late 1980s (to be replaced by an even more constraining measure), officers about to retire in West Mercia were presented with an official force form and asked to sign a &bquo;Declaration&equo; under the Act. 
 This reiterates the whole catch-all section 2 of the Official Secrets Act of 1911, as well as the scale of punishments laid down by the Official Secrets Act of 1920 for those who 
 possess any secret official code word, or password, or sketch, plan, model, article, note, document or information which relates to or is used in a prohibited place or anything in such a place, or which has been made or obtained in contravention of this Act, or which has been entrusted in confidence to him by any person holding office under Her Majesty or which  he has obtained or to which he has had access owing to his position as a person who is or has been employed under a person who holds or has held such an office or contract &mdash; &lsqb;and who&rsqb; (a) communicates the code word, pass word, sketch, plan, model, article, note, document, or information to any person other than a person to whom he is authorised to communicate it, or a person to whom it is in the interest of the State his duty to communicate it, or (aa) uses the information in his possession for the benefit of any foreign power or in any other manner prejudicial to the safety or interests of the State, or (b) retains the sketch, plan, model, article, note, or document in his possession or control when he has no right to retain it or when it is contrary to his duty to retain it, or fails to comply with all directions issued by lawful authority with regard to the return or disposal thereof, or&hellip; 
 The form continues, listing other sections of the Act. 
 It makes it abundantly clear that even the possession  and academic presentation of information necessary for an ethnography could be actionable. 
 For a considerable amount of inconsequential information owned by the institution is classed as confidential, even though its release could only be considered prejudicial to the safety and interests of the state by the most bigoted autocrat. 
 The need to get the retiring member to sign such a document indicates the institutional fear of the outside lying behind the threats which Sir Peter Imbert issued to those who would write controversial memoirs (Police Review , 26 August 1988); for the &bquo;family&equo; demands silence unto death from its members! 
 And even if an uncommissioned but critical ethnography is not considered to be in breach of the Official Secrets Act, it will most likely be construed as structural espionage and lie in breach of the Police Discipline Code as set out in Police Regulations. 
 Any internal disciplinary measure to contain such an account is much less likely to become of public concern in the way that the Clive Ponting or the Cathy Massiter prosecutions became notorious causes c&eacute;l&egrave;bres . 
 As a result of this all pervading desire for reticence it is possible to suggest that the presentation of research papers in seminars, the creation of an undirected thesis, not to mention the production of a book, could easily have placed me in breach of Regulation 6, which outlines the disciplinary offence of  
 Improper disclosure of information, which offence is committed where a member of a police force (a) without proper authority communicates to any person, any information which he has in his possession as a member of a police force&hellip; 
 That I avoided such a course of action is because of my own understanding of what the institution would allow before it swung into action. 
 In effect, I kept a suitable silence and avoided direct confrontation, for I was well aware that the ultimate punishment under the regulations is expulsion or dismissal from the force, forfeiture of a considerable salary and pension, and, of course, the resulting immediate acquisition of true outsiderhood!  
 A Police Career Explored  
 Introduction 
 In this chapter I propose to link the idea of subjective knowledge to an exploration of the insider's personal history. 
 I have mentioned aspects of the debate on the inclusion of the subjective self into an ethnography; now I hope to weave aspects of this subjective self into a scientific construct, revealing something of police culture along the way as I briefly explore some of my own early career moves. 
 &bquo;SPECIAL KNOWLEDGE&equo;: THE SUBJECTIVE FACTOR 
 In a seminal article, Pocock (1973) set out parameters for a personal anthropology. 
 He suggested personal meanings, cultural roots, and the historical equation inevitably means that any true translation of the field experience cannot avoid including a personal interpretation. 
 Inevitably this leads to the question of injecting matters of a subjective nature into the account. 
 Okely (1975) suggests: 
 the participant observer does have a problem of subjectivity. 
 This cannot be resolved by distancing, repression and short cuts&hellip; the specificity and individuality of the observer are ever present and must therefore be acknowledged, explored and put to creative use  (my emphasis&rsqb;. 
 In the accounts of &bquo;anthropology at home&equo; currently being produced, the potential to include the personal is unlike that which exists here, for only rarely does the research material contain an account in which the analyst is the subject as well as the researcher. 
 Most fieldwork is simply episodic, made by an outsider moving in for a period to assess observed social behaviour. 
 In this case, however, I have been unable to make the separation and the  fieldwork is both empirical and continuous; it is diachronic and retrospective, taking in the historical with the contemporary. 
 And as Mary Douglas (1973: 15) had pointed out, &bquo;if we cannot bring the argument back from tribal ethnography to ourselves, then there is little point in starting it at all&equo;. 
 Like Douglas, I see no point in setting up a false theoretical dichotomy between &bquo;us&equo;, and &bquo;them&equo;, creating separate realms and polarities of modern and archaic thought, for I anticipate my inclusion of the concept of self can help link the tribalism which haunts the police defensiveness to an understanding of their &bquo;modern&equo; beliefs, modes of thought, and action. 
 Hopefully this will allow the ethnography to extend on the interpretive analysis which Kuper (1973) termed &bquo;neostructural&equo; and which has since combined aspects of a feminist, semantic, and symbolic framework to generate what may well be a short-lived disciplinary &bquo;ism&equo; of &bquo;post-modern&equo; anthropology (Young 1989). 
 As an inside exploration of culture this might also be considered to be a &bquo;liminal&equo; or &bquo;liminoid&equo; phenomenon (V. Turner 1974, 1977), for as it delves beneath the surface phenomena, the subjective analysis can reveal unconscious categories and transformational operations which lie between the dual poles and such exclusively preferred categories as &bquo;cops and robbers&equo;. 
 It should then contain a generative formulation which cannot easily be suppressed or denied (T. Turner 1977), for such domains of power lying between functional systems of control and disorder are, as Victor Turner (1977: 45) reminds us, &bquo;not merely reversive, they are often subversive, representing radical critiques of the central structures &lsqb;of a system&rsqb;&equo;. 
 Inside analysis incorporating a subjective &bquo;special knowledge&equo; should therefore inevitably encompass aspects of the &bquo;liminoid&equo; and present a radical critique simply by revealing hidden structures to the outside. 
 The effect of living with this knowledge and using this skill raises the consciousness of the insider, perhaps giving him his most effective methodological tool. 
 For as a member of the institution, the insider/anthropologist is uniquely situated to move across the interfaces of his society. 
 He is qualified to think the unthinkable and to pose those questions which in normal circumstances would go unasked. 
 Because of his understanding of practice, he is able not only to show how police ideology is maintained, but even propose alternative models by merely writing down and presenting his knowledge. 
 For, as Gramsci pointed out in respect of those  institutions of the establishment, &bquo;hegemony&hellip; is not universal and &bquo;given&equo; to the continuing rule of a particular class. 
 It has to be won, reproduced and sustained&equo; (taken from Hebdidge 1979: 16). 
 The way the police sustain this ideology of action to maintain their hegemony becomes clearly apparent to the researcher, and he in turn stands revealed. 
 To have advanced within the job and achieved rank means he is likely to have followed and supported institutional precedents without question, and to have unwittingly accepted and been involved in the reproduction of the narrow modes of thought and practice demanded by the culture. 
 It is this special knowledge, or gnosis, which hopefully can make the inside ethnography so different and illuminating. 
 Burridge (1969) has written most persuasively about the effects which fieldwork can have on the anthropologist, describing the prophetic experience this can produce. 
 He links this to the act of consciousness raising, which I consider presents the greatest problem for the insider who cannot leave the field or return to academia. 
 The insider/ethnographer can turn his understanding of an interpretive methodology to an assessment of his own actions, and see connections as if scales had been removed from his eyes. 
 However, he cannot always escape the results, or move away; and may not be able to use this newly acquired knowledge to amend much within the institution. 
 Yet I believe this new understanding must be included in the account, for as Blacking (1977: vii) pointed out in his preface to the Anthropology of the Body : 
 one solution&hellip; is to use subjectivity rather than try to push it aside&hellip; and &lsqb;so&rsqb; it might well be included in analyses and used consciously as a research tool. 
 If I understood him correctly, this is an aspect of what David Parkin described at the 1973 Association of Social Anthropologists Conference as Personal Anthropology. 
 By consciously using subjectivity as a research tool, the insider is peculiarly placed to generate what Geertz (1976) described as &bquo;an inward conceptual rhythm&equo;, moving between the particular and the general. 
 Hopefully, he can use the creativity which exists between the experiential inside view and observational outside view of a cultural system to formulate an ethnography which incorporates &bquo;a continuous dialectical, tacking between the most local of detail and the most global of global structures in such a  way as to bring them into simultaneous view&equo; (Geertz ibid. 235). 
 But it is not just how the new consciousness is to be used which produces problems in handling this new-found wisdom; it is the very acquisition of knowledge itself which makes the concept of self so dynamic. 
 This structural awareness can be as hard to handle as any decision to try to publish the account, for what has happened in the past and what is expected now from the insider is tied up with an understanding of how the institution of policing prefers to present a restricted image for outside consumption, as I have described above. 
 It all becomes uncomfortably apparent and that which had been lived and accepted is opened up in a revelatory manner, so that the vice of being caught up within the hegemonies of such a system designed to control a powerless underclass can become overbearing. 
 In such a situation, the necessary intellectual detachment often becomes difficult to sustain. 
 In extreme cases anthropologists have found such a role impossible to live with, for the field situation was beyond their previous imaginations. 
 Castenada (1970), for example, found he was dealing with new events and totally new ways of understanding. 
 As a result, he necessarily developed a new self-image, and took on a new social personality in the process. 
 In Castenada's case, he &bquo;enters a world so different that he comes to accept reality itself as nothing but a social construct, with effects so devastating&hellip; that ethnography becomes mysticism&equo; (Goward 1984: 90). 
 For Jeanne Favret-Saada (1980), who set out to study witchcraft in the French Bocage, the only means of moving in on the discourse she hoped to understand was to become part of it. 
 Her involvement in the process of witching and un-witching was the single path to obtaining any information on the subject, for she found she was unable to operate &bquo;in the standard situation in which information is exchanged and where the ethnographer may hope to have neutral knowledge&hellip; about beliefs and practices&equo; (ibid. 11). 
 In some ways I feel her peculiar dilemma parallels my own for she described her stance as one which distanced her from the classical anthropological mode, creating a &bquo;memorable adventure&equo;, which she claims, &bquo;has marked me for life&equo; (ibid. 22). 
 Favret-Saada's unique analysis (ibid. 1&ndash;28) of the bizarre subjective position she found herself in is a masterful assessment of the difficulties which arise when the ethnographer seeks to gain  knowledge of a social group which depends for its existence on &bquo;misknowledge&equo; or silence: 
 For anyone who wants to understand the meaning of &lsqb;such a&rsqb; discourse, there is no other solution but to practise it oneself, to become one's own informant&hellip; and to try and make explicit what one finds unstatable in oneself. 
 for it is difficult to see how the native could have any interest in the project of unveiling what can go on existing only if it remains veiled. 
 (ibid. 22) 
 In succumbing to &bquo;the temptation of subjectivism&equo; (ibid. 23), she recognizes that it becomes impossible to put any distance between oneself and the &bquo;native&equo;, or more importantly between oneself and oneself in such a situation. 
 In the world of an inside ethnography as Favret-Saada identifies, &bquo;one is never able to choose between subjectivism and the objective method as it was taught&equo; (ibid. 23), so long as one wishes to find out answers which, in traditional ethnography, are often missing from the finite corpus of empirical observation. 
 This transformational stance, she goes on to argue, allows the ethnographer to have a personal discourse on aspects which are outside the usual limits of the body or corpus of collected material. 
 In my own case I had been taught by Okely to avoid the split between subjectivism and an objective reality, but I had no preparation to contend with the changes which the field experience created in me. 
 That which had been so familiar to me and accepted almost without thinking now took on a new and almost bizzare aspect. 
 My own &bquo;tribe&equo; became as foreign as those isolated, &bquo;primitive&equo; pre-industrial societies which the traditional anthropologists sought out. 
 Once the semantics of police experience were revealed, I had to live with the problems experienced by both Castenada and Favret-Saada, although I demur from casting myself into their intellectual companionship. 
 Reality itself then became a construct of knowing and being known, and of living with the alternative possibility. 
 For personal transitions made across physical and psychic boundaries during the subjectivity of the field situation can produce disjunction; indeed they can paralyse. 
 In such a situation it is therefore all the more necessary to recognize the unique place the ethnographer holds and to capitalize on it. 
 During this time of subjective observing participation,  the policeman/insider moves to the margins, to a point where analysis negates automatic approval or predisposition for a world of known categories and classifications. 
 His inquiries and interpretations will inevitably draw polluting and contaminating ideas to the surface, for they are a result of his place as an &bquo;institutional shaman&equo; and mirror his position as a liminal mover in the organization. 
 By  defining  this insider fieldwork (and the university experience which generated it) as a liminal situation, I am extending the Turnerian concept (1969, 1974) in which the individual moves temporarily into an unstructured and somewhat ambiguous state, during the initial process of passing through a rite de passage  before returning to structure. 
 Here the marginality is less transitory and occurs in the post-tribal situation where the concept of liminality is less familiar to the discipline, even though transitions across spatial and temporal boundaries still create epistemological changes of the kind Turner describes. 
 In my own case, the model of transition through liminality might still produce a recognizable replication of the move through a rite de passage : 
 policeman &rarr; student &rarr; new policeman 
 But there seems more to it than that! 
 It is the total change in perspective and new semantic outlook which ensures that the subjective nature of the liminal journey can be used as an essential part of the analysis; for it can produce a dynamic simply because it incorporates aspects of a newly created ideological disjunction, as some classic accounts have shown. 
 So that now, with the dubious benefit of hindsight and a keen awareness that memory and retrospective versions of reality are often skewed, I feel the subjective account must of necessity become part of the ethnography  in which I play all of the parts. 
 I am the institutional member as well as the marginally moving player. 
 I am the anthropologist and the field of study. 
 Burridge (1979) writes of fieldwork: 
 every anthropologist has experienced &bquo;culture shock&equo;; a temporary inability to grasp and act and think in the terms of the assumptions upon which the newly entered culture is based. 
 Not only is this shock experienced in fieldwork, while one learns the ways of a new culture, but it is experienced even more disconcertingly when one returns to one's own culture&hellip; two different worlds have met in the same person. 
 One alternative is insanity. 
 Another is to comprehend one world in terms of the other&hellip; 
 In this restricted sense, every anthropologist has some share in the experience of the prophet. 
 To weld the subjective with the objective, my personal anthropology includes material culled from various observational and ranked positions within the institution of policing and from across the years. 
 I have woven into the account experiences ranging from a reflection on uniform patrol work, to CID and specialist squad work; from the marginal world of a &bquo;punishment posting&equo; in a bridewell or prison, to the centrality of knowledge gained by spells in the centrality of headquarters postings. 
 The analysis spans a period when technology and communication techniques transformed the outward face of policing. 
 Hopefully the resulting ethnography will generate a new and clearer understanding of the nuances and specificities of police reality, incorporating what Bourdieu (1977) has called &bquo;a practical mastery built upon objectivist knowledge&equo;. 
 A subjective element in the account provides a better potential to unravel the semantic patterns which structure the maintenance of this executive unit of power. 
 It introduces knowledge of the cultural metaphors and the symbolic capital by which the constantly changing gradations of disorder, order, crime, and social sin are determined and acted upon, or are ignored. 
 IN THE PAST: THE PERSONAL EXPERIENCE 
 During the period 1955 to 1978 I moved across classificatory police boundaries on more than one occasion. 
 After three years as  a cadet carrying out basic police tasks around the station, I was sworn in as a constable. 
 I joined the uniform branch on foot patrol in the city centre division of Newcastle upon Tyne City Police. 
 Immediately I was instructed that I had had the good fortune to be posted to &bquo;the division where real polising is done&hellip;&equo; 
 There were only three divisions in the city &mdash; east, west, and central &mdash; and each of us in our own division knew we were the &eacute;lite; for just as the men in the west were certain they were best, so the men from the east remained convinced of their own superiority. 
 And together we were emphatically co-operative that neighbouring forces were populated by lesser mortals. 
 The predominance these spatial constructs have for the ordinary constable is essential to an understanding of the police mind. 
 Ideas of centrality and marginality of place link to the status of activities and tie in with perceptions of derogatory and despised areas of operation. 
 As a result, actual and symbolic transitions across spatial boundaries continue to create a crucial means of analysing the way police reality deals with the changes in power politics at all levels within the institution, and of describing the way status can be won or lost. 
 The structural load which exists within seemingly minor career moves or internal transfers around the force is enormous. 
 Everyone inside knows or speculates endlessly on the politics of power implicit in the most minute gradations of change. 
 The weekly Force Orders which every force publishes for internal circulation have a section listing the latest transfers in departments, specialist units, and divisions. 
 &bquo;Out on the ground&equo; these moves are seized on and discussed avidly. 
 The internal phone system springs into life and the moves are analysed or colleagues contacted to speculate on who has &bquo;blotted his copy book&equo;, or who seems to be on his  way up the hierarchical tree in the mad scramble for position and preference. 
 From 1958 to 1963 I went through various initiation rites, learned the values of the institution, and underwent the training all new constables were then required to follow. 
 As a uniform constable, my boundaries were very clearly demarcated and my peers in the city centre division set out the parameters of my social reality. 
 I quickly became aware of what a &bquo;real polis&equo; was and more importantly what boundaries one had to cross to cease being real and in effect become unreal, inauspicious, and inhuman. 
 The derogatory phrase &bquo;he's not a real polis; he'll never be a polis as long as he's got a hole in his arse&equo; quickly set out markers to define who was one of us and who was not. 
 We were thief takers, while others outside were excluded, perhaps to be dismissively described as &bquo;mere uniform carriers&equo;. 
 Douglas (1966: 1973) has described how the boundaries which lie between the structures of holiness and the anti-structure of pollution are potential power bases and always the source of emotive reaction. 
 Such relative positions were clearly set out for me in chains of metaphoric relevance, with &bquo;real polises&equo; largely symbolized by the use of the body and its social and physical space. 
 Each link in the chain expressed a perceived correct place and tied this into an all-encompassing behavioural ideology which in turn determined our action. 
 In the symbolic construction of this community (Cohen 1985) boundary images of inside and outside were elaborated to an intensity, making us crucially aware and &bquo;conscious&hellip; of dirt that has ambiguously got onto the wrong side of the frontier&equo; (Leach 1976: 61). 
 In the police this desire for a clearly defined world of order derives from an implicit understanding that control of social behaviour is always surrounded by the dirt of structural ambivalence. 
 For &bquo;real polises&equo; there is a rarely articulated awareness that this ambiguity can always turn in on itself and be used for good or evil, or even as an instrument of oppression or release. 
 For even the least reflexive or philosophical seem to be aware of the potential for reversal inherent in this system of power, where the sacred and the profane have the possibility of turning upon each other at every conjunction. 
 During my early career, for instance, when one of the shift was caught and sentenced for a string of burglaries, the others skirted around their implicit knowledge that &bquo;there but for the  grace of God goes everyone&equo;, and comforted themselves by recalling (with the aid of the hindsight-ometer) that he had &bquo;never been a real polis&hellip; always been a bit of a loner, something of an outsider&hellip;&equo; 
 A knowledge of police systems therefore requires an analysis of both sides of the coin, to explore how anti-structure defines structure and in turn redefines and motivates other anti-structural elements in the system, for anti-structural activity has the potential to make bearable some of the constraints inherent in such a closed world as the police. 
 However in such an institution, the elements of anti-structure are often suppressed, denied, or concealed in an attempt to maintain the idealogical purity of the group. 
 Jung (1964) has described these hidden facets as being creatively generative, but possessed of danger in any confrontation and difficult if not impossible to harness; for they are in effect alternative domains of power. 
 In my early career, I set out to meet the demands of my peers and fulfil the necessary qualifications for assessment as a &bquo;real polis&equo;; although there were few opportunities to flirt with any real forms of marginality! 
 I was in a numbered uniform of massive symbolic importance with nuances of style which clearly defined our social identity. 
 This uniform of dark serge symbolized our insider status and separated us completely from the &bquo;civvies&equo; out there in the rest of the world. 
 This use of uniform as a symbol of separation had not changed in 1977 on my return from university. 
 I found the same classificatory system in use with the same unconscious linguistic divisions being applied as I had learned in the mid-1950s. 
 Indeed, there was now more of an emphasis on the separation, with an enhanced denigration of civilians. 
 This elaboration indicates the process of social change, for it reveals an increasing separation between &bquo;real polises&equo; and a public who are much less likely now to accept police versions of reality; while increasing &bquo;civilianization&equo; within the forces presents another perceived challenge to the defensive integrity and introspection of the institution. 
 Chaos now seemed poised to threaten the system from inside and without, and it is almost inevitable that the term &bquo;civvy&equo; should have become a derogatory reference. 
 As John Stalker (1988) pointed out when he retired from the service, he had made the transition and  had joined that group of persons pejoratively known to the police as &bquo;civilians&equo;. 
 The structural invisibility enjoyed by the uniform wearer is a strange matter to experience. 
 You become a symbol with no personal identity beyond the small, specific numeral on the shoulder. 
 &bquo;Civilians&equo; you know well can walk past in the street without recognition, for although the uniform itself is apparent it is a forceful barrier, expressing a demonstrative separation between the culture of control and the individuality of the controlled. 
 Like other symbolic non-verbal devices, the multi-vocal nuances of our uniform were used in a variety of other ways as boundary markers to maintain our cultural identity and define our institutional specificities. 
 Just as the white-coated doctors in hospitals symbolize the clean and purifying nature of the healer, so the dark uniform of the police symbolizes not just the force identity, but also the presence of the avenger, who purifies through retribution rather than by cure. 
 It is the marker of &bquo;force&equo; and hence continues to sustain the continuing paradox of &bquo;police force &mdash; police service&equo; which remains unresolved, on which I will say more later in relation to the role of women police officers. 
 The dark uniform we wore had a military cap with polished brim, and in our fashioned tunics of soft serge and shiny boots we presented an avenging image, clothed in the symbolic colour of death and darkness. 
 Black is a light absorbent, non-reflective colour and most suitable for controllers who operate with a degree of social anonymity, upholding the rule of law and the abstractions of the legal system. 
 In such a world, individuality is never a prized characteristic, and an attempt in the early 1980s to remove the one remaining individualizing feature &mdash; the shoulder numeral or &bquo;collar number&equo; &mdash; was correctly rejected by civilians as a structural move towards an even greater anonymity. 
 As Reiner (1980) suggested, the riot gear in which the police are increasingly seen, with shields, visored helmets, knee-length boots, and flame-proof overalls, enhances their avenging appearance. 
 I suspect it is no  accident the politics of the times seems to parallel the growing toughness of the police image, or that the police have taken on an increasing resemblance to the black-clothed enemies of goodness who sprinkle the popular science fantasy films such as Star Wars, Superman , and the like. 
 In these mass cultural replays of the eternal dichotomy between good and evil, the use of highly symbolic black uniforms as an indicator of anonymous evil predominates. 
 Within the separate police forces, the nuances of uniform difference were always embroidered by &bquo;real polises&equo; to produce symbolic boundaries from which to assess other uniform wearers. 
 Thus our contacts with firemen, St John Ambulance men, special constables, and the like were all used to define them as being somewhat &bquo;unreal&equo; and therefore slightly less than human. 
 Such groups were said to be like the foreigners in the adjacent forces, for it was constantly repeated that many wanted to join us but failed because of some inadequacy. 
 This was especially true of the Fire Service, our immediate neighbours, and it applied equally to those in the adjacent Gateshead Borough Police and Northumberland Constabulary, who were always talked of as being a lesser breed of mortals. 
 This characteristic supports Peter Evans (1977), then The Times's  Home Affairs correspondent, who described the police as being &bquo;peculiarly tribal by nature&equo;. 
 In the small forces of the late 1950s these separations were made much of, with those in the adjacent forces essentially seen as belonging to another tribe. 
 Even today, in the amalgamated forces, this structuring principle holds good; and many old hands still refer to the &bquo;real police forces&equo; as those small units they joined in the late 1960s and early 1970s. 
 Quite often the divisional boundaries in the amalgamated force mirror the old, small force boundaries and men define themselves  in relation to their early experience with perhaps an inner city ethic, a large-town police style, or in the framework of a more rural situation. 
 In each case they inevitably begin to denigrate their opposite numbers for not doing &bquo;real police work&equo;. 
 Tribalism in the pre-amalgamated forces produced a very constricted vision of the world, so that spatial concepts and a narrow geographical containment held a paramount place in determining police reality. 
 Today these are still of immense import, with men deriding those in another division or section, bragging that their villains are the toughest or their section tasks more numerous and arduous. 
 An expressed desire for rigidly determined geographical units separated from a despised neighbour occurs again and again in my fieldnotes, and is clearly illustrated in a note made in 1981, when a superintendent in a somewhat remote subdivision laughingly told me: 
 one of my sections in the subdivision is thinking of declaring UDI &lsqb;unilateral declaration of independence&rsqb; from the Divisional Headquarters&hellip; as for Headquarters and the Force organizational structure, well that's just a joke as far as these men are concerned. 
 This rejection of a distant headquarters and enhancement of their own special identity occurred some seven years after the last amalgamation. 
 In that same year I was posted to South Shields on the south bank of the River Tyne and quickly became aware that I had an enormous burden to carry, simply because I had spent all of my previous service on &bquo;the other side of the river&equo;. 
 At one point a uniform sergeant listening to me discuss some tactic, gloomily pointed out that my style was not theirs; but then, he rationalized, &bquo;how could it be, you're from the north  side of the river&equo;. 
 The emphatic denigration contained in this locational insult had to be heard to be understood, and in many ways it paralleled the dismissive tone used to deride the &bquo;civvy&equo;, for nuances of speech and tone have immense meaning to insiders. 
 Figure 1 shows the existing Northumbria Police area where most of the ethnographic data was collected. 
 This force is an amalgam of nine smaller units (Figure 2), some of which went into the melting pot in 1969. 
 The remainder were taken up in the amalgamations of 1974, which coincided with the creation of the Metropolitan Councils, and today's amalgamated forces often seem to owe as much to local and national political opportunity     than to any operational logic; and even two decades after the first melding together of the small forces, attempts to standardize uniform and systems of operation has consistently failed to dislodge many localized, small-scale beliefs and practices. 
 In 1958 then, I was a member of what we knew was the  premier force in the area with the external boundaries of the adjacent forces as our immediate threshold to what Douglas (1966: 137) had called &bquo;new status&equo;. 
 Minor nuances of detail in our respective uniforms were built upon to form a taxonomy of meaning and used to maintain our in-group (or tribal) knowledge of ourselves. 
 Not unnaturally a police world values uniformity, for as the language infers it embodies the essentials of a system obsessed with physical and ideological concepts of order and discipline. 
 Massively symbolized by the uniform itself, as Douglas (1973: 16) indicates, this obsession tends to focus on the body, for &bquo;the more value people set on social constraints, the more value they set on symbols of bodily control&equo;. 
 Helmets exemplified this &bquo;new status&equo; for &bquo;real polises&equo;, for they were not  worn in the city force, but were  part of the apparel of the surrounding Northumberland County force, whose immediate boundary was only some three miles north of our divisional centre. 
 They policed Northumberland with its rural areas, small towns, country villages, and tracts of moorland and hills. 
 It was an alien place to us city-dwellers, and both their uniform style and their culture was despised. 
 &bquo;County&equo; men were transferred around at short intervals, while we were static in the city, never moving more than a mile or so between the three divisions to undertake real  &bquo;city work&equo;. 
 We had to be 5&ft; 10&ins; at least and most were 6&ft; 0&ins; or over. 
 They were &bquo;dwarfs&equo; at 5&ft; 8&ins; and were disparagingly said to &bquo;need a helmet to help them appear big enough&equo;. 
 Other differences of practice were exaggerated to suggest they were &bquo;the foreigners&equo; and we were &bquo;real&equo;. 
 We could purchase our own houses while they lived in police colonies, denied the privilege of house purchase until they had fifteen years' service; this classified them as &bquo;peasants, serfs, living in the feudal world of tithed cottages&equo;. 
 After an eight-hour shift we went home &mdash; off duty &mdash; free men, while they in contrast went to their police houses and were available for &bquo;discretional duty&equo;, at the call of the system twenty-four hours a day; proving we were independent free men and they were slaves! 
 All of these social differences were em-  bodied in the symbol of uniform. 
 Our expensive, good-quality tunics were well cut and belted, while our &bquo;guard&equo; style cap, set up at the front to emulate the officer class, made us different. 
 Helmets and unbelted tunics were for the despised &bquo;county men&equo;, &bquo;those sheep-dippers up the road in the sticks&equo; whom we continually used to reassert our own status by looking on them as &bquo;hicksville country cousins&equo; and definitely not &bquo;real polises&equo;. 
 To the south across the Rive Tyne lay Gateshead Borough Police, a small force with less manpower and fewer resources than our unit in the city. 
 They also wore the helmet, like the similarly attired British Transport Police at the main railway station (who are also despised as police marginals). 
 Like the county &bquo;sheepdippers&equo; and the borough men, both the specials and the British Transport Police were used to sustain a view of our own preeminence. 
 To my contemporaries then at this time, a helmet was possessed of immense symbolic importance. 
 We saw this one item almost as a totemic object, tabooed for our clan, and filled with a spirit of otherness. 
 Later, when I was a city detective in the early 1960s, we again used clothing to mark off our separation and dirty, ragged tramps shuffling off to shelter in rubble-filled dens under the Tyne Bridge would become a referent to our despised neighbours: &bquo;look &lsqb;we would point&rsqb; there's a Gateshead detective hurrying off on the scent&hellip; 
 &equo;. Again Douglas (1966: 138) has suggested there is a liaison which exists between the physical body and its use as an expression of the social, so that one becomes a paradigm for the other: &bquo;the &lsqb;human&rsqb; body is a model which can stand for any bounded system&hellip; 
 &equo;. It should come as no surprise, therefore, to find that a well-disciplined human body with clearly defined parameters of correctness will provide a symbolic mirror of the  preferred police social formation in which the human condition can be enacted. 
 We can also expect to find that any discrepancy in this preferred social formation will be reflected and transferred to the physical body as a metaphor of chaos. 
 These adjacent police forces were physically aberrant in nuance of bodily style and were therefore deemed to be socially incorrect. 
 In their metaphorical indiscipline they had gained &bquo;new status&equo; and slipped across a boundary into marginality, for as Foucault (1977: 25) has suggested, the idea of discipline revolves around control of the physical body and &bquo;proceeds from the distribution of individuals in space&hellip; it is always the body that is at issue &mdash; the body and its forces, their utility and their docility, their distribution and their punishment&equo;. 
 This disposition of the body reflects an institutional ideal of the social distribution of individuals in spatial purity, and is a major structuring principle for police organization; examples of this will emerge throughout the ethnography. 
 As &bquo;real polises&equo; we were correctly distributed in space and our bodies were properly turned out with the symbols of order. 
 These modes of thought are so deeply embedded in the collective conscious that ten years after the amalgamations, when the chief constable (from the south) replaced the flat cap with helmets, a number of ex-city men could not discuss the impending change without exhibiting distress and described this event as being something of an Armageddon, even though the expensive guard-style cap of the pre-amalgamation days had long since given way to what was always derided as &bquo;a cheap and nasty alternative&equo;. 
 Some continued to make a stance and in 1982 I worked with a sergeant who lovingly took out his old city cap each nightshift and wore it as a symbol of everything which had been lost in 1969, when, as the station graffiti had then affirmed, &bquo;T.J.F.&equo; and a fall from Eden had occurred.  
 Conversely, many of those in the amalgamated force who had previously worn helmets in their earlier life and had been moved into flat caps in 1969 welcomed the return to &bquo;natural&equo; apparel and their own version of a correct bodily disposition which had been prescribed in a 1958 edition of the Northumberland County Police Standing Orders. 
 This was set out in a section headed &bquo;Dress and Deportment&equo;, and illustrates Foucault's point (ibid.) that in such situations the body is &bquo;docile&equo; to authoritative orders from above. 
 Nothing is left to chance. 
 Even the angle of the helmet is defined; and the order ends with the instruction: &bquo;the strap will be worn under the point of the chin, but during the summer months the strap maybe tucked inside the helmet&equo;. 
 I recall summer commenced on 1 May in Newcastle for our &bquo;shirt sleeve order&equo;; meanwhile at the other end of the Northumbrian body, para. 32 of the order commands that &bquo;trousers will be worn with the bottoms of the trouser legs, at the front, just touching the instep&equo;. 
 Twenty-five years later in West Mercia, as a newly promoted superintendent, I listened at my first conference as my peers discussed a chief constable's agreement which allowed officers to discard ties in hot weather and wear open-necked shirts. 
 For over an hour the meeting wrestled with an undefined problem in the order. 
 No one had thought to specify how many shirt buttons could be undone and fear was now patently manifest that some uncontrollable disorder would be let loose should more than one button be opened to reveal &bquo;chest hair, or even a medallion&equo;. 
 Underlying the disquiet was a strong current of belief that the act of going tieless was tantamount to social chaos! 
 Four years later, as I mentioned above, I was party to the same fear at Bramshill, in relation to the use of the Nato sweater. 
 One of my colleagues, no doubt swayed by the heat of the discussion, turned on me sitting in my short-sleeved uniform shirt, and rebuked me with the warning that &bquo;in my force, you'd be disciplined for mutilating police property&hellip; 
 &equo;. Initially I was puzzled, until I realized he thought I had cut off my shirt sleeves, for in his force (noted for its disciplined enforcement of a correct uniform presentation), all uniform shirts had long sleeves. 
 These few examples show the constancy of a principle which defines police reality across time and space. 
 Ideas of identity and insider integrity in the late 1980s are sustained by the same symbols of status and denigration which have existed since at least  the mid-1950s. 
 And of course, all of the &bquo;stories of the great days of policing&equo;, told &bquo;at the charge room desk&equo; were passed on to me by a series of venerable &bquo;real polises&equo;, who, in turn, had learned these structures of significance in their own formative years, often before the Second World War. 
 The rigidity of such concepts and their retention in the institutional psyche enables the organization to deflect the aberrant ideas of any new social order, simply because of the strength of these dispositions. 
 Such generative practices structured my early experience, and built a constructed hierarchy of &bquo;us&equo; and &bquo;them&equo; which was set up and passed on to all initiates. 
 For analytic purposes, these can be cast into a binary model, suggesting positive and negative polarities of:  
 Such spatial and temporal fixations are also deliberately elaborated in other institutions of control, such as the armed forces. 
 There we find similar bodily constructs built up as series of organizing principles, so that the other regiment or unit is perceived to operate in some kind of polluted time and space, and its aberrant nuances of uniform styling used as a marker of significant difference. 
 The police also use concepts of a disciplined body in their dealings to effect the &bquo;capture&equo; of the local villains (or &bquo;prigs&equo;). 
 In any public confrontation a quick assessment and early resolution is the order of the day, for on the streets pragmatism always rules and &bquo;real polises&equo; set out immediately to &bquo;fix&equo; their adversaries by using deeply imbued constructs relating to time and space. 
 Always the disorderly acts of the &bquo;prig&equo; must be stopped, curtailed, arrested, disciplined, and contained; and in pursuit of a &bquo;docile body&equo; the law inevitably seeks to negate, constrain, prevent, and deny movement. 
 For the legal process demands that incidents and occurrences be ideally fixed in time and space. 
 Because the  &bquo;prig&equo; has to be nailed, it comes as no surprise to find that electronic tagging seems set to join the introduction of ID cards as a means of controlling the &bquo;dangerous classes&equo;, for as many anthropologists have shown, the concept of movement itself is possessed of dangerous ambiguity and prevents easy classification. 
 it is essentially a nomadic principle, remaining deeply resented and problematic to most dominant, sedentary political systems and their law enforcers. 
 Concepts of social movement are therefore synonymous with problems of social change, for they are antagonistic to conservative beliefs; and this gives a further insight into why the idea of social research is antithetical to police thought and has seditious connotations for an institution in which metaphors of stasis are of paramount importance. 
 It also reveals why movement becomes problematic for &bquo;real polises&equo;, for it defeats a belief in a fixed and bounded world. 
 Yet movement is the very essence of being human and of the human condition which policing sets out to nullify. 
 It therefore creates something of a paradox which ensures that those who make a marginal move are inevitably referred back &bquo;to the centre&equo;, as being the realm of &bquo;real policing&equo;. 
 I have many examples in my fieldnotes which show this mode of thought to be so ingrained, that even when the possibility of making such a journey &bquo;back&equo; to basic police work has long since evaporated, the supremacy of the belief still remains: 
 I am in Corporate Planning at HQ, as part of a department which incorporates Research, Computer Development and Communications. 
 The Chief Superintendent is being posted to division after heading the department for some 2 years. 
 He has a &bquo;track record&equo; in uniform, CID, Fraud Squad, and Complaints and Discipline. 
 He talks enthusiastically about &bquo;getting back to some real police work&equo; in &bquo;the real world&equo;, even though his responsibilities as Divisional Commander will be mainly administrative and give him little or no contact with the &bquo;dangerous classes&equo;. 
 We take the piss out of him, because of this idea that he will be doing &bquo;real police work&equo;, but we all know that divisional work has higher status for a Chief Supt. than Research, and this is the cause for celebration. 
 Within 3 days of his successor's arrival, we have a Dept. meeting where our new Chief Superintendent outlines his plans. 
 In a run down on the style of deference he anticipates (which I note will stifle any critical point from &bquo;below decks&equo;), he talks about his length of tenure and how long it will be before he can &bquo;escape back into the real world&equo;. 
 The research  manager (a civvy) who is aware of my research interests grins across the room as this desire to &bquo;escape&equo; back into &bquo;real work&equo; is reinforced by yet another Chief Supt. (From fieldnotes, 1988) 
 The inherent dilemma caused by movement is encapsulated in this fieldnote. 
 Senior officers applaud a world of &bquo;real work&equo;, to which they can never return, and implicitly deny the world of managerial power to which they now belong. 
 Their proclaimed wish to &bquo;return to real work&equo; is a contradiction, for it denies their own political scramblings to move out of the grinding realities of shift work. 
 No wonder the &bquo;troops on the ground&equo; are cynical, for they know &bquo;real work&equo; is for young officers and is something to leave behind at the first opportunity! 
 RIGHTS OF SEPARATION: THE MARGINS OF THE CID 
 Van Gennep's ideas on &bquo;rites of separation&equo; (1960) are a useful means of interpreting the social and spatial movements undertaken by the ethnographer as policeman, as he moves out from the early uniformed position of centrality described above. 
 Each separation contains symbolic significance, incorporating transitional stages of liminality. 
 At times it is even possible to lay out for examination the intense post-liminal rites and ceremonies of reincorporation required by the police institution as it seeks to draw the marginal mover back into the fold. 
 Usually, however, the social move is merely in the form of a transfer within well-developed sections of police society where the new experience is structured by the same ideology and beliefs which have gone before. 
 Occasionally, however, the insider is moved across a new boundary severe enough to create a rite of separation and provide the scope for an introspective analysis to generate something akin to a new vision. 
 In this situation, the marginal mover acquires the power to reinterpret the way his institutional structure governs a desire for a rigidified world of immobility, and to understand why, for example, those few policemen who move into other areas, such as probation work or the legal profession, become totally suspect. 
 Transition to the outside destroys the manufactured reality of one &bquo;real world&equo; and two ex-police probation officers I knew became  the equivalent of potential &bquo;prigs&equo;. 
 Again it is this incomprehension of social mobility which seems to have caused my ACC to describe an officer who took a degree and then left to become a solicitor as &bquo;a bad experience for the force&equo; (and not a gain for society). 
 And it is the same logic which attributes those few out of the 120,000 officers who pursue schemes designed to accelerate promotion with the derisory and metaphorically ephemeral classification of &bquo;high-flyers&equo; or &bquo;butterfly boys&equo;. 
 I now see that between 1958 and 1977 I was involved in what might well be described as a social drama of movement, often crossing boundaries into very marginal areas of policing, where the institutional ideal of ordered definition fails simply because the &bquo;use of power and exercise of authority are based in ambiguity and particular interpretations of &lsqb;what is often&rsqb; poorly framed legislation&equo; (Burton 1980). 
 In 1963 I became a CID aide or trainee detective, engaged in run-of-the-mill work dealing with a flow of petty crime. 
 My only training and instruction for the job was given by a detective chief inspector, who told us to &bquo;get out there and lock up thieves&equo;. 
 I was relatively successful and after three or four months moved into the Criminal Investigation Department, as a detective constable, pursuing local villains for the thefts, shopbreakings, burglaries, and petty frauds which were our bread and butter. 
 I had joined a group who are still fixated on a classification of &bquo;disorder&equo; which homes in on those who attack property,; and since the amassing of property has been a primary aim of capitalist society, it should come as no surprise to find that to prevent the dispossessed from simply taking from the &eacute;lite has been the primary structuring principle of policing. 
 Once again, however, the declared aim and the reality are not actually coterminous, and prevention as such has always had lower status than the task of catching those who do the taking. 
 Crime prevention is despised work for detectives for it holds no place for the drama of the chase and no opportunity for the symbolic warfare which exists in the battles between &bquo;polises&equo; and &bquo;prigs&equo;. 
 The result is that the &bquo;war against crime&equo; fought by detectives becomes a symbolic re-enactment of conflicts in the economic world at large, between those who have material property and power and those who labour and are dispossessed. 
 Whether there is any social morality or justice in such a system is not a matter which the detectives are given to question; nor do  they spend much time in reflecting on why some dubious property acquisition is outside their terms of reference, or what the relationship is of such practices to the maintenance of position and power. 
 In the main, they are instilled with the pragmatic games of pursuit they play with the local petty thief; and if asked to consider the wider nature of their role, they tend to fall back on protestations of political neutrality. 
 This is another skewed reality, of course, for in their pursuit of the &bquo;prig&equo; they are merely following a version of justice which depends on blind acquiescence to establishment values of honesty. 
 Leach (1977) has shown the ephemerality which lies in any attempt to classify deviance on a global scale; for what is criminal in one society or at one point in time is relative to that time and place and to who holds the discourse on power. 
 The private delicts of one group may well be public crimes in another society, or acceptable social behaviour in a third, especially when the abhorrence of certain social behaviour wanes over time. 
 In such inversions of social regard we can again see how movement will tend to confound the police preference for and reliance on a rigidly maintained classificatory world. 
 The changing values attributed to our own private delicts such as divorce, slander, adultery, debt, libel, blasphemy, obedience to church, and the like, have turned some earlier &bquo;crimes&equo; into matters now governed by other social mores. 
 With the public appropriation of certain categories of property, however, the police have been on more certain ground, for the status attributed to the &bquo;capture of the thief&equo; has remained fairly constant, at least since the police were created as a public body. 
 The detective therefore has a legitimate target in the thief (again the metaphor is based in militarism); and this is currently reinforced by the politics of materialism. 
 The statistical expansion of recorded crimes and a success largely determined by detection rates support the inevitable institutional contention that more control is a necessity, and has been a corner-stone in police ideology for the whole of my service. 
 Always the quantitative element is emphasized by the CID at the expense of any qualitative aspect of social order or harmony. 
 I will expand further on this dichotomy between quality and quantity of &bquo;crime&equo; in Chapter 5, but would argue that the chase for numerical detections in which detectives everywhere are immersed moves them across another conceptual boundary and takes them into a  statistical world away from their previous world as &bquo;real polises&equo; where the central classifier of conflict with the &bquo;prig&equo; remains, as ever, in a power struggle over the body (Foucault 1977). 
 There is no doubt the uniform policemen see their one-time associates in the CID as having crossed a divide, while the detectives know they have joined a closed and somewhat &eacute;lite family group, whose strengths include the inside support of other members of that society. 
 In many cases becoming a detective relies on a quiet system of patronage; of being invited in by those already inside with power. 
 Having watched and assessed the track record of some young officer, the middle-ranking detectives will perhaps put him forward as a candidate, and I have watched as potential members were admitted only after a series of phone calls had ensured their acceptability to the department. 
 I have also seen written applications for the CID ridiculed by those inside, and listened to the expressions of disbelief that these na&iuml;ve applicants were &bquo;so short of shillings that they didn't realise that admission was by invitation only&equo;. 
 I have also had to tell others they are unlikely to get in and then try to explain the politics of the department to them and watch their dismay when they realize that, perhaps regardless of merit, they do not fit in. 
 Once inside, the new detective will quickly meld into the department's style, pursuing its rituals to form a new link in the tradition of the CID. 
 In my own case I was given a section &mdash; a small area in the central division &mdash; with just over 300 crimes per year. 
 Most of these were undetectable in that there were few enquiries I could pursue after the event; for example, the purse stolen by an unknown thief an hour or two prior to the report and perhaps with the exact time and location of the theft unknown left little chance for skilled investigation. 
 We were well aware of our limitations long before David Steer (1980) pointed out that &bquo;the great majority of crime detections involve little of what the public would perceive as real detective ability&equo;. 
 In a number of ways, both vocal and non-vocal, the uniform branch disparagingly refer to this separation which occurs between themselves and their detective colleagues. 
 They home in on what they see as the uncontrolled nature of CID work, and sneer and begrudge the detective his apparent freedom of movement. 
 They are also well aware of the limited ability of detectives simply to go out and detect crime and know but cannot easily articulate that the symbolic import of  the detection rate is a manipulation (see Chapter 5). 
 All of this creates the fractured rivalry which has existed during the whole of my service and which has survived attempts by management to &bquo;weld the uniform and C.I.D. 
 into a more cohesive unit on Division&equo; (taken from a Divisional Order). 
 Inevitably such attempts are going to fail, simply because the two units have different perceptions of police reality and their own structures of significance to maintain. 
 As a result of the primacy of the statistical world we now inhabit, the quantity of detections obtained by each detective through the &bquo;write-off&equo;, &bquo;the NFA detection&equo;, or &bquo;the TIC&equo; becomes all important. 
 The quality of &bquo;capture&equo; which is often said to be the major aim of the department becomes another &bquo;lip service&equo; to the outside world, although once again the symbolic content of this truth is multi-vocal. 
 A better version of reality is that although the quality of &bquo;capture&equo; has tremendous semantic significance for both uniform policeman and detective, it rarely leads to large numbers of detections for the monthly, quarterly, or annual reports. 
 Indeed the quality &bquo;capture&equo; often means a lot of work with perhaps only one detection &mdash; if that &mdash; at the end of the day. 
 During my relatively short period as a city detective, I was implicitly aware that quality had to be sacrificed to quantity, for the &bquo;arrest list&equo; was checked monthly and the numerical totals counted. 
 However this did not stop us making lists of those quality &bquo;prigs&equo; we would have liked to eliminate. 
 In a game similar to that devised for the radio show Desert Island Discs , we listed those who would get one bullet from a six-gun, and placed them in order of preference, much in the way the FBI listed the top wanted men in the USA. 
 Our lists contained the names of the family &bquo;prigs&equo; we knew were professional thieves and burglars; and of whom I was advised on my arrival in the department by an old detective: &bquo;you only get one chance a year to nail these bastards if you are lucky, so when you do, its got to be watertight&equo;. 
 Again the &eacute;litism in the department is largely symbolic, for although  detectives talk continuously of their special knowledge of the world of &bquo;prigs&equo;, and despise the uniform branch as &bquo;wollies&equo;, often it is the uniform &bquo;polis&equo; who responds to a call and effects the &bquo;capture&equo;, after which the detective moves in to &bquo;squeeze him dry&equo;. 
 The detective has therefore moved away from the centrally important activity of seizing the villains into a manipulated world where the paper exercise of statistical detections is used to assuage politicians, the media, and a public obsessed with the moral panic of increasing crime rates. 
 Furthermore, the detectives are no longer in that basic symbol of police identity &mdash; the uniform. 
 They are less constrained and have more individuality in their &bquo;civvy&equo; clothes, although there are strict, but unwritten rules about what is acceptable dress (sombre suits and ties) and what is disordered and undisciplined (jeans, T-shirts, training shoes, and the like). 
 In the late 1950s this order of dress was even more carefully observed and I saw a detective sergeant ordered home to change from Harris tweed jacket and flannels into &bquo;proper clothing&equo;. 
 By 1965 things had eased, but my detective inspector still railed against my three-quarter length corduroy car-coat with its red lining. 
 He moaned about &bquo;declining standards&equo; and fondly recalled his own early days when each detective had to wear a dark striped, three-piece suit, an Anthony Eden homburg, and a watch chain at the correct angle. 
 Today, the detectives on the shoplifting squads, the burglary teams, and the crime squads are casual, but are still clean and orderly (&bquo;prigs&equo; assert they can still spot &bquo;a horney&equo; because of his tidy style and his shoes). 
 However, it is at the CID social functions which are sprinkled throughout the year (especially at Christmas and any departmental promotion) that you can clearly observe the CID style. 
 To walk into a pub function room as I have often done during the ten years I was collecting fieldnotes and see two or three hundred detectives in their &bquo;uniform&equo; of modern suit and tie, neat haircut, and the fashionable moustache of the times, is to be visibly reminded that there is a narrow symbolic range of bodily correctness within which all policemen can properly operate. 
 And even in this conformity the detectives are moving away from the uniform policeman's concept of correct  dress, for they are wearing &bquo;civvy&equo; clothing like those despised outsiders they have learned to keep at a distance. 
 Furthermore they can move without the constraining presence of the very noticeable uniform and its &bquo;big hat&equo;. 
 Inflation of the theatricality of the social drama leads detectives to lay emphasis on &bquo;the big job&equo; and the arrest of the professional &bquo;prig&equo; who commits the big burglary or pulls off a daring robbery. 
 The cold truth is that such captures are all too rare and it is a daily influx of petty offenders and successfully detected trivia that makes up the major part of the detective's world. 
 The uniform &bquo;polis&equo;, by contrast, feels that regardless of the offence or its value, he is primarily dealing &bquo;at first hand&equo; with &bquo;prigs&equo; and is thus fulfilling another metaphorically prized position as &bquo;a good collar feeler&equo;. 
 His &bquo;real work&equo; always lies in the bodily activity of physically capturing the &bquo;prig&equo;, often to have this dangerous business transformed by a detective who then negotiates justice with the adversary, in the essential CID cause of returning a good detection rate. 
 As a result, the uniform &bquo;polises&equo; often complain that &bquo;the quality of prig has been forsaken to be replaced by quantity&equo;. 
 This qualitative/quantitative dilemma produces a further schism between uniformed policeman and detectives, for CID systems of maximizing and negotiating both the crimes recorded and their eventual classification can drive a wedge between the two units. 
 Once again the result is disjunction, for it is quality and not quantitative measures in the work experience which produce self-esteem for the individual. 
 As Pirsig (1979: 277) correctly observes, qualitative value 
 is the predecessor of structure. 
 It is the pre-intellectual awareness that gives rise to it. 
 Our structural reality is pre-selected on the basis of value and really to understand structured reality requires an understanding of the value source from which it is derived. 
 One further consequence of attributing pre-eminence to quantity in relation to detection rates means that the &bquo;prig&equo; who &bquo;clears his slate&equo; (admits to lots of crimes, no matter how trivial) becomes a prized catch, simply because he helps the figures. 
 His arrest, as I have suggested, will often be made by a uniform &bquo;polis&equo; whose  physical handling of &bquo;the body&equo; (the person apprehended) will be tempered by an acute awareness of the need to maintain physical domination. 
 The immediacy of this world of conflict demands that regardless of his proximity to the metaphorical dirt he is controlling, he needs to erect and maintain social and psychological barriers and separate himself conceptually from the &bquo;prig&equo;. 
 The detective on the other hand, immediately sets out to reduce these culturally created separations, for he needs to negotiate a statistical reality with the &bquo;dirty prig opposition&equo;. 
 The &bquo;real polis&equo; is programmed to maintain a conceptual purity by maintaining structural distance, while the detective, of necessity, is forced to reduce this to carry out his deal with &bquo;the dirt&equo;. 
 By reducing the social space between the dichotomies of ordered law enforcers and uncontrolled &bquo;prigs&equo;, the detective necessarily returns a degree of humanity to the &bquo;prig&equo; which the uniform &bquo;collar feeler&equo; is always structured to deny. 
 The lowly &bquo;polis&equo;, with little or no power in the system, deplores this situation and complains of its escalation, while the detectives moan about the incompetence of the uniform &bquo;wollies&equo; who never get close enough to their prisoners to extract their own &bquo;coughs&equo; or admissions and who fail to understand that the system largely depends on the ability of the department to manipulate a statistical norm in detected crimes. 
 Stead (1980: 305), like Mervyn Jones (1980), has also pointed out how police organization attributes low status to beat work, and asks the service to reconsider the value of the patrol officer: 
 I would enter a plea that I have often made that the street officer's authority&hellip; and discretion should be given better recognition. 
 It has always seemed to me rather sad that almost any move from beat duty is regarded as a promotion. 
 Such a plea, although laudable, has little chance of becoming reality in the present organizational set-up, for it ignores the semantic difference in the uniformed &bquo;polis's&equo; role and that of the 10&ndash;15 per cent of the institution who form the &eacute;lite in the CID. 
 For the uniformed &bquo;wollies&equo; at the bottom of the hierarchical pile, any move  into detective work can have parallels with a marginal movement. 
 It becomes a rite of separation into an area where the detective's need to &bquo;juggle with statistics and detection rates&equo; is diametrically opposed to the constantly voiced uniform preference for action which is simply programmed to &bquo;nail the prig down&equo;. 
 Once again the language is vital to the analysis, for the term &bquo;juggling&equo; is widely used in relation to detection rates and carries with it an understanding that what is happening belongs to a world where movement conceals as often as it reveals. 
 In contrast &bquo;nailing the prig down&equo; is a quintessential statement about the value to uniform &bquo;polises&equo; of stasis, containment, and spatial control. 
 Such vivid, metaphoric language epitomizes and illustrates the ultimate truths and values of the police world. 
 In effect, even those who move across the margins into CID work have produced the first structural crack in the preferred coherent model of uniformed and unitary policing. 
 FURTHER INTO LIMBO 
 In 1966 I moved from the world of &bquo;real polising&equo; into areas of operational marginality which were further to confound the preference for the clearly delineated police world I had been brought up in. 
 Although still nominally under the CID organizational structure, and still holding the title of detective, I was detailed to deal with the new and very ambiguous &bquo;prig&equo; &mdash; the drug user. 
 As half of the first full-time two man drug squad in the North-East of England, I was tasked with defining and dealing with the new social aberration of &bquo;flower power&equo;, &bquo;the counter culture&equo;, and the &bquo;psychedelic trip&equo;. 
 This was an era when phrases such as &bquo;turning on&equo;, &bquo;dropping out&equo;, and &bquo;scoring shit&equo; moved into the language; and when our newly discovered deviants caused an incredible moral panic as wreathed in clouds of incense or cannabis smoke and symbolically clutching well thumbed copies of iconic tomes such as the I Ching , they joined the &bquo;hippie trail to Katmandu&equo;.  
 Victor Turner (1969, 1974) has explored facets of the anti-structure, liminality, and communitas  which are contained in such periods, developing these from Van Gennep's earlier work on rites de passage  (1960). 
 However, he also suggested he would prefer to restrict the use of the concept of &bquo;liminality&equo; to those ritual periods in small-scale societies which all  must pass through, and use the term &bquo;liminoid&equo; for those anti-structural periods personified by the &bquo;counter-culture&equo; of the 1960s (1978: 287). 
 Whether you prefer to follow Turner, and use the idea of a &bquo;liminoid&equo; period for those times and situations when only some  members of a society pass through the rite of separation, is a matter of personal choice. 
 However, I find Turner's work on the results of such movement into the liminal state to be a very useful way of interpreting what an insider experiences when he moves to the margins of his own domain, and I suspect that many such transformations across fiercely defended boundaries of cultural experience lend the individual the chance to stand aside and reflect on his subjective place in the order of things. 
 Whether or not the opportunity is taken up is another matter! 
 In many ways these reflexive moments are invaluable in helping to explain the specificities of what Evans-Pritchard (1951) suggested we might consider as an &bquo;anthropological history&equo;, especially as these alternative periods and the movement through the liminal phase create points in a social process when aspects of structure seem to be made more clearly apparent to the analyst. 
 Turner has also stressed the subversive character of the betwixt and between state of liminality which helps to explain the drives, inversions, and paradigms of the counter-cultural form, and which enhances the potential for the liminal journey to illuminate the postures and pedantic reactions of the dominant ideology to such periods of social upheaval. 
 In this instance, established authority and its police were set to oppose the threat posed by this new anti-structure, for the counter-culture renounced power and society feared their challenge, as it has feared the unworldly in every age. 
 In this liminoid phase, which extended almost across a decade, as Turner (1969: 155&ndash;6) points out, 
 one often finds a simplification, even elimination of social structure in the British sense, and an amplification of structure in L&eacute;vi-Strauss' sense. 
  We find social relationships simplified, while myth and ritual are elaborated&hellip; if liminality is regarded as a time and place of withdrawal from normal modes of social action, it can be seen as potentially a period of scrutinization of the central values and axioms of the culture in which it occurs. 
 Movement from the centralities of &bquo;real polising&equo; in uniform, via the CID, into the marginal fringes of an extended period of drug squad work, had a profound influence on the absolute tenets of policing I had absorbed over the previous decade. 
 In effect this was a period of withdrawal from a rigidly structured police world to a world turned upside down; where, in a &bquo;counter-cultural&equo; way, we were to find that the strict terms of reference we had carefully built up over the years no longer seemed to have relevance. 
 My own &bquo;anthropological history&equo; in this liminoid phase became extended over eight years, until 1974, and not only gave me time to reflect on many of the controls we were required to impose, but also to consider the nature of the social harm these unworldly folk devils and &bquo;drug fiends&equo; were actually causing; for established society has never really known how to handle the unworldly easily. 
 My own marginality with its reflexive potential in some ways mirrored their experience, for some members of the counter-culture stood apart, in a position which allowed them to renounce, ridicule, or reject society's cherished structures of significance. 
 As Turner (ibid. 99&ndash;100) records, this is a time in social history, when 
 the values of communitas are strikingly present in the literature and behaviour of what came to be known as the &bquo;beat generation&equo;, who were succeeded by the &bquo;hippies&equo;&hellip; &lsqb;and who&rsqb; opt out of the status-bound social order and acquire the stigmata of the lowly&hellip; 
 An emphasis on spontaneity, immediacy and the &bquo;existence&equo; throws into relief one of the senses in which communitas contrasts with structure. 
 Communitas is of the now; structure is rooted in the past and extends into the future through language, law and custom. 
 Another binary is created here, for we became separated in our communitas  of spontaneity from the rigid belief systems and certainties of a police structure rooted in language, law, and custom. 
 Indeed there were many policemen who were totally unable to comprehend, never mind live in the haphazard world of  marginality which we now inhabited. 
 Yet there were those who moved easily around the margins, and I am certain the profound effects of this liminal time extended to more than a few of us who made this transition into structural limbo. 
 We had moved to the edges of our previously closed system of thought and action, both physically and philosophically, and almost implicitly came to recognize that the &bquo;foundation metaphors&equo; which Turner identifies as being crucial to transformational experience of liminality were making paradigmatic statements about our own cultural format; although I know we would have been unable to articulate this. 
 In effect, the alternatives presented to the &bquo;counter-culture&equo; by the liminal experience were also available to some of us in our marginal police world, and we were forced to see that those concepts of order and disorder we had once taken almost as the natural way of things were in fact only one model for society; a single framework for social action! 
 Social organization, we learned, was conventional and man-made and there were often realistic alternatives. 
 In our marginal universe, we pursued offences which were then not even classified as crimes in the Home Office Standard list, and were pitched into a new philosophical world structured by a number of alternative social constructs. 
 These were amplified by a variety of non-verbal sign-systems such as gesture, posture, music, clothing, gender relationships, as well as other aspects of the hippie life related to an alternative political and social belief which were alien to our experience. 
 These inevitably came to influence our own structures of significance and were made apparent by changes in our own subculture of style. 
 Our modes of dress and consequent loss of deference to the rigidities of rank and other previously respected apparatus of the hierarchical system were all influenced. 
 Deference to concepts of order based on such signifiers as exact time keeping, definitive shift systems, spatial purity, clearly demarcated terms of address, and other measures designed to maintain the systems of control were irrevocably loosened. 
 In addition, we became experts in a new and complex world where everything from the intricacies of a changing semantic of underground language to the knowledge that tetrahydrocannabinol (THE) was the active ingredient of cannabis separated us from our previous associations and took us into a world where few in  the organization could begin to operate with comfort. 
 Inevitably, over such a long period, I became less institutionalized, more able to function as an individual in relation to belief and action and not merely accept the organization's definition of things; and this is a profoundly un-police like state of affairs! 
 There was no predetermined police model to follow in dealing with our &bquo;counter-cultural&equo; clients, no previous police experience to allow us easily to slot hippie behaviour into any comfortable niche. 
 Unlike the skin-heads and punks of a later generation, or the teddy boys who preceded this era, many &bquo;flower children&equo; were non-violent and in their communitas  even exhibited something of a constructive element. 
 The philosophy which they never tired of expounding to us included visions of a new world, which although sketchy and inevitably idealistic often showed an artistic and positively creative side to their existence. 
 It was often difficult to dislike the gentle, painted hippies, even though they subscribed to a strange new communal, non-hierarchic lifestyle incorporating the unlawful use of &bquo;dope&equo;. 
 This undermined any pre-ordained police logic we might have employed to define them, so that pressures to produce a unidimensional model of &bquo;polis &mdash; prig&equo; were simply unable to be maintained, although we did home in on such facets as their long hair and frequently unwashed state to polarize them as binary &bquo;animals&equo;, in contrast to our human status. 
 And so although they were still the opposition, they could rarely be classified as &bquo;real prigs&equo;. 
 We therefore became aberrant policemen simply because what we were now living was not programmed by previous organizational knowledge and habit. 
 The squad I ran became what can only be described as more &bquo;disordered&equo; and &bquo;polluted&equo; than had been the accepted norm, and we exhibited many verbal and nonverbal signals of this divergent nature. 
 Our clothing became less sombre and much more casual and varied. 
 Our hair became longer and &mdash; in police terms &mdash; almost verged on the wild, confirming Hallpike, (1969: 260), who argued: &bquo;the hypothesis I wish to advance in this article &lsqb;is&rsqb; that long hair is associated with being outside society and that the cutting of hair symbolizes re-entering society, or living under a particularly disciplinary regime within society&hellip;. 
 I would formulate the theory as &bquo;cutting the hair equals social control&equo;&hellip; 
 &equo;. The police obsession with hair returns again and again in my fieldnotes. 
 Its use as a means of defining  order or to set against those outside creates a subcultural style, which is reinforced continually. 
 In a 1978 fieldnote I recorded: 
 a young probationary constable is recommended to shave off his fashionable mandarin moustache before his first appraisal with the Divisional commander (who himself has a 1940s style bush under his nose). 
 There is no reason, and he declines the verbal advice he has been given by his Inspector, so this has now become an &bquo;order&equo;. 
 It is a disciplinary offence to defy an order from a senior officer, so he can only carry on if he is prepared to take on his immediate boss. 
 In a similar vein, a cartoon in Police  magazine (January 1981) repeats an old joke but puts it into the mouth of a totally bald senior officer. 
 He pulls the hair of a young uniformed constable, shouting at him, &bquo;If God had intended policemen to have hair he wouldn't have created barbers&equo;. 
 This use of hair as a symbol of social disorder reflects Benthall's contention (1976) that an obsessive interest in the body was a result of people turning to its use as a medium of expression, because of their individual inability to shape modern technological and bureaucratic society. 
 He argues that the body is an ideal vehicle for representing and symbolizing coherent models of experience and, at times, presents an intense framework for cultural expression. 
 And at this point when a range of established values were under scrutiny, the body was made to carry a new symbolic load which reflected the change from the social conformity of the previous decades. 
 Anthropology has played a significant part in illustrating ways in which symbolic use is made of the body to make statements about the condition of society itself (Mauss 1935, Douglas 1973, Blacking 1977, etc.), and hair became an apposite symbolic indicator of the problems the forces of control were faced with at this time. 
 Disordered hair is constantly used to reflect social chaos by the police and is a prime signifier of everything that is offensive to the world of &bquo;real polising&equo;. 
 Its role in defining the structural marginality of &bquo;Community Policing&equo; departments, for example, can be illustrated by another item taken from Police Review  (11 July 1980: 1449). 
 There, an Inspector Fusco pleads for men to be returned to beat patrol from community projects, for these he realizes are &bquo;an admirable aspiration, until one starts to notice that community involvement officers come to work to spend much of their time in track suits or jeans and tee shirts, and some grow  longer hair and beards and mix with the locals&equo;. 
 There is no irony in this; indeed this is firmly in line with many similar statements collected in fieldnotes, which consider it to be totally inappropriate for policemen to mirror the style of the locals if they wear track suits or jeans or sport longer hair and beards. 
 For although it is constantly argued that the police represent and are drawn from the community they serve, the cultural style required in the body of the police officer inevitably sets him slightly apart from the &bquo;civvies&equo; outside the institution, especially where such symbolic use of clothing and beards or hair is the province of the youthful innovator. 
 Always the police prefer to exhibit bodily constraint in their styles, for restraint and decorum have a symbolic history as an indication of subcultural insider purity, a comfort with a vanishing status quo, and a rejection of the changing outside world. 
 This restraint expected in police hair was clearly illustrated in a large poster exhibited in the Northumbria police training department in the early 1980s, which ordered: &bquo;male hair will be clear of the collar&hellip; &lsqb;and&rsqb; sideburns will not extend below the centre of the ear&hellip;&equo;. 
 Faris (1968), exploring the way such symbols come to represent complex conceptual domains, coined the phrase &bquo;symbols of high meaning capacity&equo;, which exactly fits the structural significance hair has for police ideology. 
 In effect it becomes a reflection of an almost puritanical social containment of the individual, with metaphoric import as a statement of correctness for the society outside. 
 Furthermore, it is also used to denote a belief in the uncontrollable and wildly sensual nature of women. 
 Joseph Wambaugh (1976: 6&ndash;7), in his picaresque novel The Choirboys , uses the symbolic load contained in the control of hair to illustrate the dysfunction between &bquo;real&equo; Los Angeles cops and their incompetent, corrupt, and inept hierarchies. 
 Wambaugh, himself an ex-cop, describes the ways in which wildly autocratic and psychotic bosses set out to undermine their own &bquo;front line troops on the streets&equo; and describes a manual which mirrors the poster in the Northumbria police training department described above:  
 Lieutenant Treadwell a figure of fun and contempt to the real cops after his hair started falling out in tufts, earned his way back into Commander Moss' good graces by authoring that portion of the Los Angeles Police Department manual which reads 
 Sideburns 
 Sideburns shall not extend below the bottom of the outer ear opening (the top of the earlobe) and shall end in a clean-shaven horizontal line. 
 The flare (terminal portion of the sideburn) shall not exceed the width of the main portion of the sideburn by more than one-fourth on the unflared width. 
 Moustaches 
 A short neatly trimmed moustache of natural colour may be worn. 
 Moustaches shall not extend below the vermilion border of the upper lip or the corners of the mouth and may not extend to the side more than one-quarter inch beyond the corners of the mouth&hellip; 
 This symbolic import of bodily hair in a novel about Los Angeles policemen is mirrored in the Force Orders of most British police forces and is part of an overarching use of bodily order and control as a marker of police purity. 
 I will expand on this dichotomy between the clean and the polluted in the next chapter when I detail the ethnography of being a &bquo;real polis&equo;; however, these few examples indicate the cultural preference and the conceptual challenge which our appearance must have presented as we embraced aspects of the bodily style of our &bquo;counter-cultural&equo; antagonists. 
 Our lengthening hair and use of vibrant colour contrasted markedly with the accepted plain-clothes form of the detectives, so that the drug-squad style became a marker of cultural anomaly. 
 Photographs of the squad taken in the early 1970s still evoke surprise in police circles, simply because they display such strong imagery of an unacceptable style, and at the time were made much of in the media, who saw the newsworthy potential of policemen in a disorderly form. 
 In effect we were becoming structurally and visibly undisciplined, in a world where discipline has its import spelled out  on every occasion. 
 For example, Section 5, para. 14 of the West Mercia Force Standing Orders is entitled the &bquo;Maintenance of Discipline&equo;, and contends: 
 Discipline is the foundation of the Force and means not only the performance of specific orders but implies a willing and prompt obedience, proper respect to senior officers and loyalty to the service. 
 Over the years I watched as senior officers struggled to come to terms with our bizarre presence, which overcame any respect they might have had for our practical mastery of dealing with a world they were wary of. 
 Of course, our bodily forms and somewhat disorganized working systems were in contradiction to their understanding of the correct codes of policing. 
 We must have often seemed to deny them the obedience and &bquo;proper respect&equo; demanded by the institution, for we obviously did not emulate their style and in effect were a vision of impurity existing right inside the body of the organization. 
 On more than one occasion I caught senior management using our symbolic disorder to dress down  young constables. 
 One superintendent, keen to control the length of hair of his men, used to shout angrily at his probationers and young officers: &bquo;are you trying to get a bloody transfer to join those long-haired yobs in the drug squad?&equo; 
 On another occasion when I was involved in the tense process of bringing prisoners into the charge room in the central bridewell in Newcastle, a very precise ex-detective colleague (by then a neat, uniformed chief inspector) stopped me to exclaim on my appearance. 
 I had been up most of the night on surveillance and, dressed in &bquo;raggies&equo; in a seedy dockside pub outside my own police area, had posed as a &bquo;driver&equo; for a drug-dealer. 
 I was somewhat dishevelled and unshaven: &bquo;Look at the state of you &lsqb;he exclaimed&rsqb;. 
 What a mess! 
 I never thought I'd live to see the day when a detective inspector would look like this.&equo; 
 I was too involved in the capture and too tired to do other than make light of his comment. 
 In the same way I was unable to do much else but grin and bear it when my then assistant chief constable (crime), Ken Oxford (later to be the chief constable of Merseyside) implicitly restated police concepts of correct bodily order, when he jokingly told a group of visiting journalists who had come to do a story on this wayward group of detectives, &bquo;we pay him a plain clothes allowance you know&equo;. 
 There were few terms of  reference for our operations and no previous squad activity to base our actions on. 
 In effect we defined our own &bquo;real work&equo; and those activities we felt should have credence were given priority, so the role we pursued simply evolved. 
 Initially we had to start from scratch to find out about drug use and drug users, for we were not even one-eyed kings in this land of the blind; and we quickly found we were delving into a new and complex social world. 
 Many of our clients were from sections of society which had few previous dealings or contacts with the police. 
 Some were embarrassingly naive about the rules of engagement and readily admitted their drug use even when we had little or no evidence to prove the point; a most &bquo;un-prig&equo; like quality! 
 A good proportion of our work concerned our availability to act as an unacknowledged arm of the social welfare service to drug users in crisis situations, providing a front-line service for the &bquo;speed freaks who's OD'd on the results of a bent script&equo;, or the &bquo;acid heads having a bad trip&equo;, for we were in the streets, the pubs, the clubs, the crash pads, and communal houses frequented by the new &bquo;alternative society&equo;. 
 Much of our daily work was ten years in advance of the official police community involvement programmes and yet our actions were only an extension of those social welfare activities the police have been heavily involved in for generations, but which are never given status as &bquo;real police work&equo; simply because of the institutional emphasis placed upon summons lists, numbers of arrests, crime detections, and other statistical returns. 
 Many of our new &bquo;counter-cultural&equo; deviants were articulate and presented very cogent arguments relating to their allegedly victimless &bquo;crimes&equo;. 
 For example, they would link their cannabis use and an alternative ideology or religious vision to challenge our somewhat static version of social reality. 
 Many of the &bquo;underground&equo; at this period in social history were consciously making a journey towards a new spiritual growth; and this, as Furlong (1973: 106) suggests, 
 resulted in the controllers making&hellip; a puritan attack directed at the drug taking of the (underground) movement; and since the drug-scene is complex and confused, and we have little time in which to develop a reliable folk-lore about drugs and how to take them (as we have long ago done about alcohol), they have been particularly successful in fostering anxiety among teachers, parents and establishment figures. 
 Our part in this &bquo;controlling puritan attack&equo; consisted of making the occasional arrest, while pursuing the unquantifiable social role which filled most of our time. 
 Furlong is correct, however, in suggesting that anxiety was rife, and because of this and establishment obsessions with a belief in a statistical truth we were constantly being asked to give numerical estimates of how many there were &bquo;out there&equo; who were &bquo;fixing&equo;, &bquo;using the weed&equo;, or &bquo;dropping acid&equo;. 
 During the first three years of full-time drug squad work (1966&ndash;8) arrests totalled some sixty-four persons &mdash; or less than two per month. 
 In this same period I saw many hundreds of users who never featured in the arrest tables and took many to hospital. 
 I acted as unofficial welfare officer for others and spent untold hours merely listening as the unworldly struggled to achieve the alternative vision of a new heaven on earth. 
 Our sixty-four arrests included a few for the traditional crimes of burglary (but now at chemist's shops), forgery (but of NHS prescriptions, not bank notes), as well as the new offences of unlawful possession of amphetamine or LSD. 
 Court cases and the resulting media responses given to these new &bquo;drug fiends&equo; (to use the phrase coined by Stanley Cohen (1973)) verged almost on the hysterical (see Young 1977), and moral entrepreneurs began to press for more controls and increased action. 
 Questions were raised in the House of Commons about a group of local hippies arrested early in 1967, and local MPs vied with each other to be in the vanguard of efforts to control the &bquo;army of secret drug takers in the area&hellip; (who need to be) brought back from the brink of madness&equo; (Newcastle Evening Chronicle : 27 February 1967). 
 Much of this fervour, as Furlong suggests (1973), occurred because of social confusion about this new activity. 
 There was no existing model to use as a comparison of events and so the moral majority focused on clearly visible symbols such as disordered hair, clothing, and lifestyle, to articulate their fear of the &bquo;alternative society&equo; and its drug fiends.  
 One result of this moral panic was that, even as the anxiety mentioned by Furlong (ibid.) forced us to react to these public demands with some arrests, we insiders with &bquo;special knowledge&equo;, who were working face to face with the counter-culture, knew there was a different social reality abroad which we could never adequately explain to the entrepreneur or encapsulate for the media headline. 
 In effect this was a time when new worlds and new social structures were being forged; and in many ways we were closer to the world of the underground than that of the moral majority, for we were walking the same ground and like many in the alternative society were (somewhat unsystematically) following an essential and perennial theme of history &mdash; that of man's journey as &bquo;hero&equo;. 
 In this search for a new spiritual awareness, they &mdash; like us &mdash; were finding new possibilities to achieve a revived sense of what it is to be truly human in the transformational experience. 
 This is basically the same anthropological journey pursued by L&eacute;vi-Strauss (1973) in Tristes Tropiques , which remains a suitable precursor for most of the current reflexive ethnography. 
 In this account, L&eacute;vi-Strauss uses the &bquo;hero's journey&equo; to self-analysis in the field as a means of achieving or engendering knowledge (see also Caplan 1988); emphasizing that it is the journey to self-awareness itself, and not the arrival, which is the most important aspect of the rite de passage . 
 The forces produced in the individual on such occasions, in what Jung (1964) calls a &bquo;journey to individuation&equo;, manifest themselves in a number of very persuasive ways and in this case led to some radical reassessments of the existing moral, philosophic, political, and aesthetic order. 
 These influences have also  been likened to the forces effected by a millenarian journey to a new faith (Jacobi 1967), for they are compelled by an integration of the ego and the unconscious into a vision which demands more from society than the &bquo;acceptable satisfactions&equo;. 
 Indeed many of the counter-cultural ideas had troublesome millenarian or semi-religious elements which owed little to the existing moralities or acceptable satisfactions. 
 One notable effect the alternative social format contained lay in the assault upon the senses which occurred at a pragmatic level. 
 No one who was around in the late 1960s can have avoided the flood of changes which swept through the dress, sexual codes, language, food styles, cinema, literature, music, and other generative aspects of the new counter-culture. 
 Many of these have since been taken on by the wider society and are to be found in all its corners influencing even those who would now deny them any real significance and tend to look back on the decade as only times of silliness and self-indulgence. 
 At the heart of the counter-culture there also lay a vision that was politically troublesome. 
 As Turner (1974: 245) has shown in his essay Passages, Margins and Poverty , this philosophy epitomized the concept of movement as a rite of passage into liminality. 
 It possessed a sense of communitas  that was essentially perceived as being dangerous to structure: 
 there is no doubt that from the perspective of incumbents in positions of command or maintenance in structure, communitas &mdash; even when it becomes normative &mdash; represents a real danger, and indeed for all those, including even political leaders who spend much of their lives in structural role playing, it represents a temptation. 
 Of course not all policemen are in absolute positions of command even though they represent the maintenance of structure in more than a symbolic way; and few can move into communitas  to experience the temptations described above. 
 Once again Turner (ibid. 241) outlines the constraints of structure and the potentiality of standing outside: 
 men who are heavily involved in jural-political, overt and conscious structure are not free to meditate and speculate on the combinations and oppositions of thought; they are themselves too crucially involved in the combinations and oppositions of social and political structure and  stratification. 
 They are in the heat of battle, in the &bquo;arena&equo;, competing for office, participating in feuds, factions and coalitions. 
 This involvement entails such affects as anxiety, aggression, envy, fear, exultation, an emotional flooding which does not encourage either rational or wise reflection. 
 But in ritual liminality they are placed, so to speak outside the total system&hellip; transiently, they become men apart. 
 Like Furlong (1973) Turner defines the effects of the juropolitical role as being possessed of anxiety and denying the reflexive possibility. 
 While for those thrust into a position of &bquo;ritual liminality&equo; there is the possibility of becoming &bquo;men apart&equo;, of standing aside and though not necessarily following political alternatives posed by any counter-culture, undertaking the hero's journey merely by seeking to comment on the social condition they now see with new eyes. 
 The resulting path to individuation means the conscious and the unconscious polarities within the individual become joined, so that the anthropological journeyman hero experiences a kind of crisis; for as Jacobi (1967: 22) points out: 
 to look such truths in the eye is a test of courage. 
 It demands insight into the necessity of growing old, and the courage to renounce what is no longer compatible with it. 
 For only when one is able to discriminate between what must be discarded and what still remains as valuable for the future will one also be able to decide whether one is ready to strike out in the new direction consciously and positively. 
 With benefit of the &bquo;hindsight-ometer&equo;, it can be argued that my own movement into a structural limbo contained aspects of the unconscious journey towards a new self-knowledge, when the old values were able to be adjusted if not discarded; so that it was possible to break through the constraints imposed by the inculcated patterns of police culture, albeit in something of an unprogrammatic and fragmented manner. 
 Through the daily use of our special knowledge of the counter-culture, we were forced to acknowledge and come to grips with many of the complex social factors surrounding some drug use, which a legal framework could never adequately encompass. 
 We now had to grapple with problems of ethics, with questions of morality and of personal philosophy, as we tried to draw a simple police code of practice  together to frame those new deviancies created in the 1960s by the Acts of Parliament relating to drug use. 
 Furthermore, the reading I did for the lectures I was called to give as a &bquo;drugs expert&equo; generated queries about such ambiguous areas as victimless crimes and interference in private acts, and altogether raised more questions than were solved. 
 This acquisition of special knowledge meant that when I was called to give evidence to the Advisory Council on Drug Abuse (chaired by Baroness Wooton) on the use of cannabis, I was perhaps more inclined to dwell on the symbolic dangers attributed to its use than on any alleged physical harm, simply because I was now aware that any reality in relation to cannabis use was more complex than could be contained in some easy binary of social value &mdash; medical debilitation. 
 Such awareness provided another means for the obsessive anxieties of the establishment to be counterbalanced from within, and as Jacobi (1967: 22) suggests, created the potential ability to look truths in the eye and &bquo;the courage to renounce what is no longer compatible&equo;. 
 This, however, produces a further paradox, for this reflexive style, welding the practical mastery and special knowledge of the subjective insider to an objective interpretation of events is not one the institution of policing is  geared up to handle. 
 We were now floating between a world of the street-wise, the gentle hippie, the communal &bquo;crash pad&equo;, the lecture hall, the courts, the addiction unit or hospital casualty department, and the front page. 
 Our peers included our recent colleagues of yesterday in uniform and in the CID, but also took in the professor of psychiatry, the Home Office Drugs Branch official, the NHS executive, the sociologist, and the media hack. 
 Ours was now a multiple reality and our structural ambivalence can be illustrated by one example when one of the squad created a blazer badge in heraldic style (although we could never have been seen in a blazer at this time when faded denim was the order of the day). 
 This badge had crossed hypodermic syringes and a Latin motto which when translated, read: &bquo;Bodies in the cells, names in the papers&equo;. 
 The blazer badge reinforced the &bquo;capture of bodies&equo; philosophy which had sustained our earlier lives, but was created at the same time that I was compiling a paper for presentation at the national BMA police surgeons' conference. 
 I believe they came to hear jolly conference stories about &bquo;drug fiends&equo; and &bquo;acid heads&equo;, but the paper concluded: 
 it would seem that the economics of the socially approved tobacco and alcohol industries means that we have to accept 42,000 deaths annually from cigarettes, and the cost to society of 50,000 alcoholics. 
 These drug casualties are the price of minimal control and an accepted licence to use some drugs. 
 It seems that we must similarly accept the quoted 3,000 poisoning deaths and 100,000 hospitalizations per year from barbiturate overdose, because the industry contributes &pound;168 million each year in exports&hellip; 
 Meanwhile, we the wise, to quote Erving Goffman (1963) are allowed increasing manpower to pursue the cannabis/hallucinogenic using folk devil and to present the incompetent and the inept from the hippie element to the courts and the public for their solace; and to assure them that drug taking is being stamped out. 
 Such material clearly illustrates the new modes of thought we were developing. 
 Our new semantic understanding was therefore linked to the changing epiphenomena of dress, hair, clothing, and the other symbols of the body I have mentioned; but it was also manifest in an irrepressible need to reinterpret and question the social condition, for I had journeyed beyond the norms of the police system, where action to control is preferably a simple  matter of enforcing the rules and regulations as they stand. 
 Yet this move into anti-structure was merely beginning. 
 The unconventional, questioning form I had begun to pursue was rewarded by an invitation in 1972 to attend United Nations European Social Affairs Division in Geneva. 
 &bquo;Experts&equo; from a variety of European agencies were brought together to discuss and report on the various cross-cultural attitudes to drug-taking among young people. 
 In this setting the qualitative was constantly under evaluation at the expense of the quantitative measure, for the &bquo;wise&equo; amongst us who were present knew that the statistical return often gives a skewed version of complex social events, although it speaks volumes about the way our systems of control are generated and maintained. 
 In this even more marginal world of cross-cultural perception and social contrast, the statistical truths I was consistently having to produce for local politicians, senior officers, the press, and the public in Newcastle were of little value, especially when discussion on the structures surrounding approval or illegality of some drug use was a matter which might encompass problems of economic, geographical, cultural, or even religious boundaries, or more likely the changing political whim or opportunity of the moment. 
 FROM LIMBO TO THE OUTSIDE WORLD 
 Shortly after the United Nations experience, I attended a middle management course at the national Police Staff College at Bramshill in Hampshire. 
 This was known as &bquo;the Inspectors&equo; Course, and is now referred to as the &bquo;Junior Command Course&equo;. 
 Of the 500-plus inspectors who attended the college each year on the course, a handful were awarded what is known as a Home Office Bramshill Scholarship. 
 This took the form of a recommendation to a university willing to take on an inspector, who often had none of the usual qualifications. 
 Two weeks after my course finished and I was back in the &bquo;real world&equo; on a murder enquiry, I received notification I had been awarded the second scholarship in the force. 
 My predecessor had read law and obtained a first, but I chose to read social anthropology simply because of a pleasure in the subject. 
 As I have shown above, there is a strong tendency in the  organization to dismiss the social sciences, and it therefore seems fair to suggest that any police officer who elects to read for a degree in that discipline is knowingly placing himself into a position of outsider. 
 My inclination to reject law as a possible course was incomprehensible to many, and while I was waiting to go to university I was constantly challenged about this. 
 If I had failed to get a place in a law school and had been forced to take something else as a second choice then this would have been acceptable. 
 But to avoid law and list anthropology as a first choice was inexplicable: 
 &hellip; why study &mdash; what's it called &mdash; anthropology? 
 What's wrong with law? 
 Surely as a policeman it would be more useful for you to take a law degree&hellip; 
 I would have thought it was your duty  to take law&hellip; 
 (From fieldnotes: detective sgt., 10 years' service) 
 Thus the move into academia and the world of the social sciences was a move across a further conceptual boundary, another movement across time and space, encompassing another rite de passage . 
 It can be likened to becoming &bquo;them&equo; or no longer being &bquo;us&equo;, for I had further increased my distance from the working lives of the &bquo;real polises&equo; and had moved out of their known world to become an outsider, a liminal mover. 
 At university I chanced to meet a detective sergeant who had been in the Durham drug squad outside the Sociology building in New Elvet, Durham city. 
 He was now in the CID in the city and somewhat tentatively asked what subject I was reading. 
 He seemed relieved when I told him I was reading anthropology and, looking somewhat apprehensively over his shoulder at the sociology building, he muttered &bquo;well thank goodness you're not taking bloody sociology, with all those left wing bastards who hate the polis&equo;. 
 An inspector who came to Durham at the same time as myself to read Law and the Sociology of Law, found the latter course  required a move to concepts outside normal police experience. 
 Coming from a police family and married to a police officer, her inculcated beliefs were such that the alternative concepts which the sociology of law posed were beyond acceptability. 
 From a perspective in anthropology where social systems were all equally valid, I teased her about cultural police rigidities which caused this rejection of the alternative views she was being asked to examine, to the point where she refused to lunch with me in the Students' Union, because, &bquo;you're one of those bloody communists I have to listen to&equo;. 
 Few former colleagues had much idea of what anthropology was and many seemed never to even have heard the word. 
 For they live in a world of practice, where the idea of the rule of law forms an ideology or religion, replacing the waning moral power of the church (Hughes 1987: 29). 
 Its practitioners operate in a world constrained by a belief in the immediate implementation of the legal precept, in which it becomes axiomatic that even the academic/criminologist will remain outside the world of praxis. 
 For criminologists surely &bquo;can never be successfully involved at the sharp end, or pointy end, dealing with angry men on the cold, hard streets&equo; (from fieldnotes). 
 Typically stereotyped as being &bquo;absent-minded&equo; cartoon types, intellectuals and academics are considered to inhabit ivory towers and need protection in their na&iuml;vety. 
 Mythological stories about them suggest they are necessarily seen in this simplistic way to reaffirm to &bquo;real polises&equo; that it is they who are the true inhabitants of the pragmatic world of conflict and action. 
 One story of how a local university academic had come into the police station to report his car missing, because he had forgotten where he had parked it, was repeated with relish; while another which I told on my return from university satisfied these deeply held views of the &bquo;intellectual's&equo; practical ineptitude: 
 I tell a small group about a noted professor who was spotted at a tutorial wearing one red and one green sock. 
 He was described by one of his students as being &bquo;a brilliant man but so practically inept that he needed help to cross the road safely&equo;. 
 A detective listening to this story nodded gravely, for it confirmed his beliefs, and as he said, &bquo;these academics cannot operate in the cut and thrust of the real world, can they?&equo; 
 When policemen label one of their colleagues with the term &bquo;academic&equo; it is always a derogatory term of reference, while &bquo;college  man&equo; is another derisory phrase used to define that tiny percentage who gain accelerated promotion through one of the special course or graduate entry schemes generated through the police staff college. 
 Whitaker (1979: 229) records how these &bquo;college men&equo; are described sardonically at police station level, as &bquo;plastic men &mdash; who know all about how to hold a knife and fork, but nothing about how to catch villains&equo;. 
 During a sojourn in Northumbria one of these &bquo;academic high-flyers&equo; remained implacably &bquo;not one of us&equo;, and I heard him summed up in the following terms: 
 &hellip; bloody man is in the fast-lane; comes off at junction 7 for a year or so here, and then he'll be off and away at junction 8, on to his chief's job somewhere else&hellip; and look at him! 
 He's one of them educated bastards who wouldn't know his arse from his elbow on a Friday night in the Bigg Market&hellip; 
 (From fieldnotes) 
 This &bquo;high-flyer&equo; was then in his early thirties. 
 When he did leave for his next promotion, the &bquo;real polises&equo; reading his c.v. 
 in the local press joked that if he had done all the write-up said then he must have joined the police when he, was about 7! 
 One officer who had worked with him during his short stay in the force laughingly told colleagues that this &bquo;college man&equo; definitely had one arrest &mdash; because he would willingly recall details of his big moment for anyone who was prepared to listen. 
 &bquo;College men&equo; or &bquo;academics&equo; are considered to be potentially dangerous and polluting because of their limited understanding of the &bquo;polis's&equo; real world; for they never stay long enough to experience the depth and complexities of the activities which lend him his &bquo;special knowledge&equo;. 
 Consequently they are said to be only suitable for the rarified world of HQ where men with no &bquo;bottle&equo; and the non-combatants have fled. 
 This retreat into the safety of headquarters with its separation from reality is the route for these &bquo;bastards with no teeth&equo;; it is the rightful place for those &bquo;nine-til-five administrators who turn up when real polises have been up and at it for hours, and then ask their daft questions because of their lack of practical experience&equo;. 
 It is the world of &bquo;ESSO&equo; men (Every Saturday and Sunday Off), and the &bquo;real polis's&equo; scorn is reflected in some of the language of definition which I have outlined here. 
 Now, as a consequence of my eight marginal years on a drug  squad, visits to the United Nations, and the three years at university reading a subject which few knew anything about, but would be willing to dismiss along with all of the social sciences, I was in danger of being irrevocably cast into the mould of being a &bquo;college man&equo; or academic. 
 I was close to being &bquo;one of them&equo; and definitely &bquo;not one of us&equo; because of an acquired list of significant differences. 
 Given that the police are essentially an organization constrained by an ingrained respect for the pragmatism of action &mdash; regardless of the lip-service paid to the police college, the &bquo;special course&equo;, or the university scholarship &mdash; it was inevitable that the hierarchy would follow the dictates of institutional philosophy and pull the marginal mover in from the periphery; for there is a boundary beyond which the pilgrim cannot be allowed to stray. 
 In all the legends or tales of the journey to individuation and knowledge, the liminal mover always returns to the centre and is reconstituted into structure. 
 With hindsight, it was inevitable my application to continue full-time study would be refused, for in their eyes I had wandered long enough in the margins and so my hierarchy now ordered that I return to the basics of uniform police duties.  
 CHAPTER ONE 
 When I was one and twenty, 
 I heard a wise man say, 
 &bquo;Give crowns and pounds and guineas 
 But not your heart away&hellip;&equo; 
 Mid-thirties and Jay was given to Falling in Love. 
 She joked that it was her favourite occupation. 
 Usually her passion was an explosion of ecstasy, at a face, a voice, a mannerism; usually she did nothing about it beyond engineering to spend time in The Presence. 
 Doing anything more led to agony, sleepless nights, months of drinking and moping and boring her closest friends to death. 
 Once bitten twice brashly armoured? 
 Not Jay. 
 &bquo;I have been savaged  by love,&equo; she would declaim, when she'd had a few. 
 &bquo;But many years ago, a wise old man said fall in love and you may fall flat on your face, but pick yourself up and rush towards the next one, knees bleeding, face bruised, arms open, heart on fire.&equo; 
 Dear Walter the art teacher, old-fashioned gallant, shouting &bquo;bugger&equo; in class, casting lofty pearls to the in-group of disaffected teenagers. 
 She'd taken him  literally, although now she questioned whether that had been wise. 
 Hollywood stars were safe to fall in love with, dead or a million dollars away. 
 Tennis stars. 
 People at bus stops. 
 And Jay would bathe in a glow of wonder that another human being could move her so. 
 After the first few devastating out-of-loves, she was warily certain that there would always be another goddess; the old idol became a fond memory, like a photo of a dear friend long absent. 
 Once in love, always loving. 
 Never letting go of that feeling, even when the flash-fire gut-lurch of In Love seemed distant, ludicrous, incredible. 
 In Love again, the new beloved was perfect and miraculous; Jay swept away what she had learned in pain about feet of clay and natural caution. 
 Her heart went into a cartoon clinch: Nothing Else Matters ! 
 Lucy was different. 
 Jay had felt fleeting sexual desire when they first met in the corridor where she worked, a tumbledown rats' nest in East London. 
 A pleasant surprise so early in the day: Lucy had style, from well-cut red-gold hair down through the subtly tailored suit, to the jaunty tap-tap of grey suede sub-stilettoes. 
 A designer dyke! 
 She expected Lucy to head for their office: no one else was ever in before noon on the top floor. 
 But Lucy smiled distractedly, passed her, leaving a scent of honeysuckle and spice. 
 She unlocked the next room which had stood empty for months. 
 &bquo;We have neighbours,&equo; she told Francis, her coworker. 
 &bquo;Nice?&equo; he drawled. 
 &bquo;Any trade?&equo; 
 &bquo;A very respectable looking lady, dear,&equo; she said, &bquo;wearing a million dollar perfume.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that all? 
 Mm. 
 Better make her coffee, darling,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You never know.&equo; 
 Somehow among the chaos of coffee cups and a snowstorm of phonecalls and paper, she and Francis  and a cheerfully unreliable string of volunteers threw together every month a gay arts magazine. 
 A lot of women put her down for working with a man, especially one like Francis, camp as Christmas in Tangiers, a slow fuse of lasciviousness smouldered in every phrase. 
 But he made her laugh and worked like hell for peanuts. 
 His favourite topics were sex and sex and he hadn't repeated himself once in three years. 
 Jay giggled along with him, they cried on each other's shoulders and, every week or so over cocktails, swore to marry each other. 
 She made coffee, flicked a V sign at Francis's suggestive tongue and knocked on Lucy's door. 
 The room was bare and filthy, an unfurnished twin to theirs. 
 Raddled nets trailed at grey window-panes, flakes of plaster flecked the bare boards, newsprint, piss-yellow with age, scrunched at her feet. 
 Lucy looked very small and determined and was making a list. 
 &bquo;Thought you'd like some coffee,&equo; Jay said. 
 &bquo;This place is so bleak. 
 I'm Jay. 
 We're next door.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's kind. 
 I'm Lucy,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;In fact, do come and have a seat,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I think I will,&equo; said Lucy, &bquo;I didn't realise quite how bad it would be.&equo; 
 &bquo;Francis, this is Lucy,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Lovely to meet you, darling. 
 Toss aside those masterpieces of illiteracy and have a chair,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Welcome to pervert posers anonymous. 
 What do you  do?&equo; 
 &bquo;We're an ecology magazine,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I edit. 
 Can't write, can spell.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, good!&equo; said Francis from the heart. 
 &bquo;I'm ever so dyslexic, aren't I, dear? 
 But I do have other talents. 
 And I must pop out and get some milk. 
 Want anything? 
 No?&equo; 
 He unfolded his incredibly long legs, arranged a white scarf at his throat and checked the mirror.  
 &bquo;I must re-do these highlights! 
 Ta ta. 
 Back soon unless I meet something divine !&equo; 
 Be made an exit worthy of Noel Coward. 
 &bquo;What do you do?&equo; said Lucy, guardedly, snapping a flame to the tip of a cigarette. 
 &bquo;Oh, Francis always says we're pervert posers&equo; anonymous &mdash; we do an arts magazine, Pink I Do Like , gay and lesbian stuff. 
 Have a look.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; said Lucy, clearly surprised to see glossy sophistication issue from such a down-market maelstrom. 
 &bquo;It's a good-looking product. 
 My son's a painter.&equo; 
 But not gay, thought Jay as Lucy blushed slightly. 
 A son probably meant straight and married. 
 The gold-ringed finger on her left hand confirmed it. 
 A pinstriped husband in the city patronisingly fond of the little woman and her projects. 
 And so on. 
 Bad luck, Jay! 
 She didn't feel up to a zealous dyke conversion. 
 When in her twenties, nothing could stop her and she was proud to remember marriages faltering and once even, Astrid's, biting the dust. 
 Over the months Jay found she liked being around Lucy, enjoyed desiring her and doing nothing about it. 
 It suited her easy-going semi-idleness. 
 Lucy had the decency and zest of a boarding school prefect, the kind the Lower Third would swoon over. 
 Jay was amused by her go-getting energy, especially when Lucy had done battle with yet another charitable trust or foundation. 
 This verve, this ambition and Jay's laid-back curl of desire threw up a picture of Lucy as a B-movie dominatrix &mdash; but very, very civilised. 
 Jay would nod and reply, make coffee, light cigarettes and smile at her silk stocking fantasy. 
 Lucy's clothes were impeccably respectable, the cut and cloth murmuring I know I cost money, but there's no need to stare . 
 Good careful jewellery &mdash; usually she sported a gold looped cameo at her throat, very  conventional, but with the cream wisped relief of a voluptuous woman naked against the nipple-pink shell. 
 Over coffee in the office, in the middle of a serious conversation, Lucy would edge her shoes off, stretch her feet and say: 
 &bquo;Bloody tart-trotters. 
 Still, it impresses the grant-givers, without whom&hellip;&equo; 
 Each business meeting put a spark of challenge in her green eyes. 
 She led with the chin and got her own way most of the time. 
 Francis would snort with laughter when she and her natty briefcase had left in White Rabbit haste. 
 &bquo;Lovely legs, darling, aren't you tempted? 
 And the heaven-sent heaven scent!&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm settling into comfortable middle age, Francis. 
 Me and a few short stories. 
 I've done my running around.&equo; 
 She and Lucy would have a drink after work on Fridays, sometimes an early supper, a few hours to unwind: a pattern pleasing to both. 
 Over the years, over coffee, lunch, drinks now and then, she found out more: yes to straight, yes to married, but divorced for some fifteen years. 
 Lucy's son was the apple of her eye, work her raison d'&ecirc;tre. 
 She had a passion for fine music and fine art. 
 She was much more fun after a few drinks, gently mocking her dedication to saving this planet. 
 Around the third glass of wine, she would become vehement, a soft rose rising to her cheeks from the ivory-silk of her blouse. 
 Then she sparkled, took a ritzy walk to the bar and could be delightfully and surprisingly coarse. 
 She worked from eight till late, even in winter. 
 And she got things done: two days after she moved in, the place was &bquo;positively sanforised, dear,&equo; said Francis, wall-to-wall carpeting, curtains from Heals', furniture in place, phones installed and busy. 
 Lucy. 
 Jay's fleeting lust metamorphosed &mdash; practically &mdash;  into interest and friendship; sometimes on the way home, lyrically drunk and alone, she would fantasise about kissing Lucy, stroking the fine lines etched around her eyes and on her brow, nuzzling into her throat and shoulders&hellip;. 
 She had to smile when the busy reality met her the following day. 
 CHAPTER TWO 
 Lucy worried about her son and drugs, her son and girls, her son and money. 
 My son, my son. 
 Her eyes plunged to a russet flecked deep green when she talked about him. 
 Gradually she confided in Jay who was happy to listen and soothe. 
 Flattered, even, that someone so utterly different and reserved had opened up to her, late-thirties dyke pottering around to nowhere. 
 &bquo;Time for a drink?&equo; 
 Lucy, airily around their door. 
 Jay always had time for a drink. 
 &bquo;Are you coming, Francis?&equo; 
 &bquo;I think it's girls&equo; talk,&equo; said he, archly. 
 &bquo;Oh, piss off, you silly old queen. 
 R's more like Claire Rayner!&equo; 
 &bquo;But you love it, darling!&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right,&equo; said Jay, grinning absurdly. 
 It was pleasant to feel needed by an attractive older woman, it amused her when Lucy pecked her goodbye. 
 Always brisk, always on the cheek. 
 Food for fantasy. 
 It was springtime when she fell in love with Lucy. 
 On St Patrick's Day, at 7.48 in the evening, just like that. 
 She clutched at these landmarks as her heart soared like a kite, time day and place an anchor to the swooping light of love.  
 Lucy had asked her to supper in her West London flat. 
 She wanted to co-ordinate an article about trees and pollution and Jay and Francis had discovered a photographer who only did trees and did them brilliantly. 
 Jay was knocked out by his work, Francis ecstatic over his tight torn jeans, and Lucy's eyes lit up when she saw the portfolio. 
 &bquo;Oh, you can have all the blight and disease, dear,&equo; Francis told her, &bquo;we'll stick with the sunshine and thrusting buds. 
 All things bright and beautiful,&equo; he trilled. 
 &bquo;Sorry, couldn't resist!&equo; 
 Lucy wanted Jay to help her write the article. 
 Jay was delighted with the compliment and intrigued to see inside Lucy's flat. 
 Oh horseshit, Jay! 
 When Lucy asked her, her fantasy took a careful half-step forwards. 
 Dinner was not lunch, and an evening was the prelude to night. 
 Thank you , she said, I'd love to . 
 She ignored Francis's frankly suggestive eyebrows &mdash; damn him for knowing her! 
 &bquo;Well, dear!&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You've got a date. 
 Bit serious tho&equo;. 
 And you! 
 Miss Never-do-a-minute-of-overtime! 
 A working date!&equo; 
 &bquo;Life is not all lust,&equo; said Jay, swatting him. 
 &bquo;Mind my rollers, dear! 
 No, you have to sleep sometime,&equo; he said. 
 The day before the date, Jay went into Lucy's office and saw her crying, silky red head on the desk, fists clenched. 
 Wanted to put her arm around her, hug her, what the hell had super-brat been up to now? 
 She tiptoed out unnoticed. 
 Later Lucy borrowed coffee, a picture of composure. 
 Jay was intrigued, but knew better than to ask the question direct. 
 Vinegar on a clam, that. 
 And Lucy said: 
 &bquo;Got to get back early this evening. 
 Can't stop for a drink. 
 But I'm seeing you tomorrow, anyway, aren't I? 
 Seven-thirty? 
 Bye.&equo;  
 Oui, mon capitaine!&equo; giggled Francis. 
 &bquo;You've got your orders. 
 Come and have a Slow Comfortable Screw Against the Wall with an ageing deviant. 
 It's a cocktail, dear.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know what a slow comfortable screw is, Francis,&equo; said Jay in her best Mae West, &bquo;but I ain't never done it against a wall.&equo; 
 &bquo;Very wise,&equo; said he. 
 That night Jay dreamed in glorious technicolour with full Dolby stereo. 
 Lucy was weeping as she had been that afternoon. 
 But Jay did not tiptoe away. 
 Late afternoon sun spilled white shafts across the desk to light her hair with a jewelled sheen the colour of pomegranates. 
 Jay drifted through the dazzle to hold her, kissed her agonisingly soft hair, breathed her perfume, kissed her closed wet eyes with a tenderness that stabbed through her with a sword of fire. 
 And then she was driving through a heliotrope dusk, a summer evening in deep country lanes, green trunks leopard shadowed, a billion emerald leaves overhead greying as she drove. 
 Lucy was beside her, smiling and weary. 
 No words. 
 But all the sweet and strange scents of evening, the chill of night. 
 And the Pergolese largo enhancing the enchanted dusk with sparse fluidity, unearthly serenity, When I behold the body &hellip; 
 And Lucy. 
 Now holding her hand like a shy and trusting child. 
 They were in the foyer of a country hotel. 
 Signing a book. 
 And walking together on thick-carpeted stairs, hand trailing a blackened balustrade, beams in the ceiling. 
 Their room. 
 White ceiling, white curtains shifting in a breeze, a huge bed neither would admit they had seen and what it meant. 
 And so the dining room. 
 A real log fire. 
 Jay drank a smoky oak ruby wine. 
 Lucy filled her glass with the  palest gold, firelight making a star in the bowl, the label on the wine was olive-green and gold and Lucy's eyes were spring leaves dancing in the light of dawn. 
 They had come to the hotel to make love. 
 Lucy was shy as hell, and Jay was sure and easy. 
 O my beloved! 
 They talked about everything but, mouths moving and laughing with no sound: Jay saw them now as if on film, now from inside her thrilling flesh, looking at Lucy, making her laugh, feeling the thick cream linen napkin, the solid edge of the table. 
 And Lucy knew they were there to be lovers, Jay knew like her heartbeat that they would make love. 
 In their room the lights were honey-pale, and Lucy turned away to undress. 
 But Jay sat on the bed, she had brought brandy liqueur and crystal glasses. 
 My love, my dove, my life, I love you! 
 Oh, the mandarin old gold. 
 Lucy's lips tasted of brandy, their first kiss. 
 No words, just the blissful caress of cool cotton sheets as they slid into bed, Jay's body glowing with desire. 
 And Lucy's silky warm skin all along her, arms wrapped round each other, so close that nothing could come between. 
 So close that Jay didn't know where she ended and Lucy began. 
 She cupped her hands round Lucy's sweet fine chin and drew her lips against her own, tongue trembling into the wet hotness of Lucy's mouth, exploring behind her lips, Lucy's tongue tentative then sure. 
 She lay safe, held warm, and Jay drew adoring fingertips along her throat, learning her ear lobes by heart, Lucy's breast was so soft and smooth, Jay dipped her head and sucked her nipple, in ecstasy, in prayer, fingers tracing mystery. 
 A baby had been here, this close&hellip; 
 Her hand moved ahead of her lips, ablaze when she brushed the fine wiry hair between Lucy's thighs, all at once a mapless explorer in a rich forest. 
 And her blind fingertips sought the sweet elusive bud of ecstasy, her mouth followed blindly, lips meeting  their own dizzy baptism. 
 Above her, below her, inside her, her being welded to Lucy, Lucy. 
 Lucy all around. 
 Lucy's body shuddered, oceans of sweat bound them, tide-tossed, tempest-tossed, redeemed. 
 Like all new lovers they made love all night, laughed, stopped for a cigarette whose smoke tantalised in the lazy glow of the room. 
 They slept in the first grey twitterings of dawn, Jay tore herself away to hang the prosaic Do Not Disturb sign on the door. 
 Nothing could disturb this love. 
 Then back to the exhausted heat of Lucy, and sleep. 
 Sleep. 
 Sun through the curtains, she woke with Lucy in her arms. 
 Sleep, my darling. 
 She woke Lucy with coffee, and more loving, sure and slow. 
 Now she knew how to tease and tantalise her, hold her on the brim of honeydew euphoria then flood her wordless yearning with a Niagara of delirium. 
 Driving home, dropping Lucy a block from her life, her house, her son. 
 And knowing this was just a beginning. 
 Jay woke early, and turned to hold Lucy. 
 Jesus! 
 The dream drifted away, and for once she had pen and paper, made a cigarette and wrote until the alarm went off. 
 It was a story, it flowed. 
 It was a love letter, it was what she wanted and would she have the nerve to deliver it? 
 Could she? 
 Could she not? 
 CHAPTER THREE 
 Jay had not fallen in love very often. 
 Well, apart from that camp every other day thrill&hellip; 
 But seldom with  anything approaching seriousness. 
 Flirting and charming, usually home alone and no regrets next day. 
 She had worked like hell at getting people to like her, believing herself gross and hideous as a child. 
 &bquo;Sarah's pretty,&equo; said her mother, awarding first prize to her sister. 
 &bquo;You've got personality.&equo; 
 Jay's mother managed to slide a moral judgement or evaluation into every statement. 
 Pretty meant vacuous, personality meant show-off, having fun was shopgirl mentality. 
 She had ill-equipped both daughters for life, disapproving of fashion and make-up, deaf to music both classical and popular. 
 In fact what the hell had she enjoyed? 
 Her garden and going to church? 
 Jay couldn't think of anything else. 
 Her mother had both children late in life, and was wonderful for the first six years of Jay's life. 
 Jay remembered the sun in the garden, the paddling pool, her mother meeting her after school, face lighting up with love and joy as her little girl pelted out of school like a tornado, seized her mother's hand and dragged her home down the street, read to her, played with her, woke her with a kiss, read her a bedtime story. 
 Happy days! 
 But it had all soured later. 
 When she was ten? 
 Eleven? 
 Her mother's moodswings began to terrify her, and she would slow to a careful frozen walk as she turned into their street. 
 If there was a car outside the house, she relaxed and speeded up: a car meant visitors and her mother charming, not mad and spiteful. 
 She was a teenager in the sixties. 
 Too young and protected to go to festivals, she grew her hair long like John Lennon and loved John Lennon after Yoko because he too wore glasses but didn't care. 
 Also her parents hated John and Yoko, switching off Top of the Pops , saying they were sacrilegious: Christ, you know it ain't easy ! became her silent song. 
 Her sister listened to  The Moody Blues, Jay listened to Bob Dylan, Joan Baez, The Kinks: she despised the early, clean-cut Beatles and mods. 
 In the town there were mods and rockers, leather-clad and terrifyingly male, or smart, self-assured and terrifyingly male. 
 She adored greasers, saw a motorbike as a symbol of freedom:just climb on and go. 
 Go. 
 Go. 
 Go to Woodstock, the sea, the top of a mountain, a river, go forever from the flat respectability of home and market town. 
 Jay tie-dyed shirts purple with white star bursts, stopped wearing shoes, wore fringed waistcoats, Indian head-bands, bought incense and cultivated a dead-pan expression. 
 She didn't look like she was there; she knew she didn't want to be there. 
 She thought she was ugly and monstrously fat, and was always surprised and cynical when boys/men talked to her. 
 One of the going-steady girly types at her school told her boys thought she was cool and superior. 
 This made her cry desperately. 
 She was sure they didn't really like her, it hadn't occurred to her that she might be off-putting. 
 The first time a boy kissed her, she thought he was being charitable and told him he didn't have to. 
 Could not believe he really wanted to. 
 But Woodstock and the sunshine hippies broke through the clouds of small-town standards, and Jay scoured the Oxfam shop for silk and satin and velvet. 
 She hung around in their sub-hippy world, camouflaged, but never feeling she belonged. 
 There were exceptions. 
 John for example. 
 John van Loon. 
 John van Loon had been sent home from work for wearing a kaftan and he laughed about it. 
 He told her she had a lovely body and when she went to bed with him, she said (he'd find out about it anyway and drop her): 
 &bquo;I have a confession to make.&equo; 
 He held her close.  
 &bquo;I have spots on my back. 
 It's embarrassing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh dear,&equo; he said, kissing her. 
 &bquo;Well, I have something to tell you, too.&equo; 
 God! he hadn't thrown her out. 
 &bquo;My little man goes red when I'm excited.&equo; 
 Someone else bothered by their body? 
 A man? 
 News to Jay. 
 She fucked him with enthusiasm, they laughed, they did it again and again &mdash; on and off for years. 
 She liked him, never thought of him as a boyfriend, he was too comfortable. 
 Actually, she could probably have married him and had a few nice babies with his laughing blue eyes, his loony hippy fluffy hair, and maybe her eyebrows. 
 Jay liked her eyebrows, straight and black but with a decided curve at the end. 
 That was the one part of her body she liked, and with her glasses they were masked. 
 She was blind as an owl in daylight without glasses: therefore nothing to look at. 
 Three wishes would have brought her perfect sight, a million pounds and an ape-hanger motorbike. 
 So. 
 The ten commandments of her teenage. 
 All you need is love. 
 (I am unlovable.) 
 The old order is rapidly changing. 
 (I live in a town which has stayed the same for a thousand years beyond skirt-lengths and cars.) 
 You're beautiful, a child of the Universe. 
 (I'm hideous, and a bad bad girl.) 
 You may not be here tomorrow. 
 Do it today. 
 (He comes like a Thief in the night, Christ, that is, and woe betide you if he finds you wanting.) 
 Thou shalt do everything that the church says thou shalt not. 
 (But if it's true, said Jay's demons and nightmares, what if it's true? 
 There's no hell, but I'm going there anyway&hellip;) 
 If it feels good, do it. 
 (Nothing feels particularly good. 
 Calm down, cheer up, control your  temper, wipe that make-up off, you look like a tart, look at the way you walk, don't wear those trousers, put a dress on, men can't control themselves, it's up to you to take control, love bites are a sign of a man out of control, your sister's a tart, if you lose your name no one will have you, who do you think you are, listen to her &mdash; social life? 
 While you're at school, my girl? 
 You're getting some very odd ideas.) 
 Property is theft. 
 (I should be saving, says my father.) 
 You must please men and be good in bed. 
 (A decent man wants to marry a virgin.) 
 Men never make passes at girls who wear glasses. 
 (I am blind as a bat without and contact lenses are too expensive and who do you think you are, you should be studying.) 
 Believe in yourself. 
 (We should have had boys!) 
 We may not be here tomorrow screamed the rock-fuck bands. 
 (Sufficient unto each day the evil thereof.) 
 Sins of the flesh? 
 She was raped at thirteen and had an orgasm, her first. 
 So she'd enjoyed it? 
 Probably provoked it. 
 Probably had VD. 
 She masturbated. 
 A lot. 
 Didn't want to pass on what she'd got. 
 And there was no one to tell. 
 When she finally screamed it out at her mother four years later, her mother said: 
 &bquo;Don't go round telling everyone. 
 It's nothing to be proud of it. 
 It won't make you look important.&equo;  
 CHAPTER FOUR 
 The office was empty when Jay got in, and she slid her dream onto her desk with a work folder to hide it from Francis's camp curiosity. 
 With her mind wide open to this new enticing prospect, a desire so unexpected and untested, she wanted no audience. 
 It was wonderful to feel again, to let herself go with it, to water-ski blindfold, to jump out of a plane and take a chance on the ripcord. 
 Way to go! 
 And Francis would know something was happening: he would not leave it be until he'd extracted every detail, he never did. 
 But he rang at 10.30, hung over and apologetic. 
 He would not be in at all if she could stand it. 
 Jay grinned ear to ear, commiserated and ordered him back to bed. 
 The day was hers. 
 She cleared her desk onto the floor, made coffee and switched on the typewriter. 
 All the time was hers to work through her story/ fantasy (?) /love letter. 
 After all these years of knowing Lucy, too! 
 Her whole body felt starry-eyed and jubilant. 
 She snapped Satie into the cassette and re-read what the night had brought her. 
 Christ, it was explicit! 
 Explicit? she mocked herself, yeah and why ever not? 
 But a remnant of caution urged that she tone it down, after all, Lucy&hellip; 
 She began. 
 I first met you&hellip; 
 Four pages later she lit a cigarette. 
 Hmm. 
 Hedging. 
 She hadn't even touched the dream. 
 Then she decided to leave it. 
 You don't mess with El Dorado. 
 The four pages were an introduction, a portrait. 
 And she typed  the dream exactly as it had come to her. 
 No way she could show this to Lucy! 
 She felt a thrill in her gut. 
 She did routine office stuff for the rest of the day, and only re-read it at five. 
 She swaggered out of the door like a Mississippi gambler. 
 Maybe. 
 Home, a bath, a mere-smear of slap and fresh clothes. 
 She put her bag with the story on the passenger seat and drove as if it were a newborn baby. 
 At traffic lights she gave it a wary smile, slid into gear and played Nina Simone's &bquo;I need a Little Sugar in My Bowl&equo;. 
 She had decided this was the theme, exactly what Lucy needed, locked in work and the vagaries of her maverick genius boy-child. 
 The car flew up onto the Westway. 
 She pictured Lucy. 
 Would she dare to challenge that tight-jawed efficiency with a declaration of passion? 
 Dedicated to the one I love? 
 Drive, you ridiculous bitch! 
 Jay adored the Westway, swooping over a London bright as Woolworth's jewellery counter, streetlight brilliants and flyover neon like topaz on a chain; red and green and amber a flashing diamond&hellip; 
 It was the flight path the one man she'd ever been In Love with had taken her for the first time, after a late film at the Paris Pullman, Kensington to Hampstead at two a.m. 
 She'd never let go of him, either, even when their affair was over, and he was tramping the globe looking for Nirvana. 
 Every six months, she'd ring him and listen to the ravings of his latest guru. 
 Then he'd inherited and blown the lot, only alcoholism and smack-addiction to show for it after eighteen months. 
 She'd seen him many times then, everyone else had dropped him, and only moneyed privilege had kept him out of the gutter. 
 It had made her feel like a dutiful grown-up daughter, visiting a hypochondriac distant relative once a week. 
  Finally his double-barrelled family had stepped in and bought the prodigal a mega-mineral cure and a penthouse flat. 
 At which point she unlocked her ball and chain. 
 She hadn't seen him in seven years and didn't really want to. 
 Now she was near the Lucy exit. 
 And the lights were green. 
 Jay took such things as an omen. 
 If there was cherry blossom in Lucy's street, she'd show her treasure! 
 At least that was a decision. 
 She stopped at an off-licence and recklessly bought pink champagne. 
 If her love-letter was the Titanic, let it go down glorious, awash with roses, evening dress and a decadent late-night piano playing &bquo;Them There Eyes&equo;. 
 Ha! 
 She drove down the wide west London avenue. 
 On the street where Lucy lived, cherry trees were bursting with pink and white like fairground popcorn. 
 She parked, suddenly chill, picked up her bag as if it held eggshells. 
 Well, well&hellip; 
 Her fantasy hit the earth as Lucy in the flesh opened the door. 
 She had changed since work, to black tailored trousers and a cashmere sweater of black and Irish green. 
 &bquo;Brought some wine,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Self-indulgence. 
 Pink champagne, my favourite. 
 Hope you like it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've never had pink champagne,&equo; said Lucy. 
 What? 
 Jay raged against the divorced husband and all the lovers Lucy was sure to have had in between. 
 Why, this woman should have bathed in pink champagne. 
 Already, Jay's Hollywood imagination was building her beds of rose-petals under crystal minarets. 
 Steady, she told herself, we are here to work. 
 Lucy's self-contained sophistication sipped at the ultimately silly drink. 
 Champagne had brought Ninotchka to her feet, declaiming, I vant to make a speech ! 
 Garbo laughs! 
 Jay sipped and etched Lucy's face and gestures on her mind, in the rose-pink glow of having seen her weeping  and helpless, thinking she was alone. 
 But I am here with you! 
 Jay made a reckless pledge, feeling ianthine waves lap her limbs into a sure promise of ecstasy. 
 Lucy cooked pasta, Jay could hardly eat, and lit a cigarette as soon as decently possible. 
 Smoke curled, wine flowed, and Lucy put her fabulous legs on a chair, smoking too, the most relaxed thing Jay had ever seen her do. 
 &bquo;You write,&equo; said Lucy. 
 Jay blushed, the story in her bag radio-active fluorescence. 
 Yeah, lady, I write. 
 I also want to rip your clothes off and appreciate you like you've never known. 
 &bquo;I've never been able to,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I can foster talent: look at my son, Jeremy.&equo; 
 The walls were hung with competent oils. 
 Clever, even. 
 &bquo;He's good,&equo; Jay allowed. 
 &bquo;I've brought you a story.&equo; 
 Aw, shit, momma! she protested, you've done it now. 
 &bquo;I'd love to read it,&equo; said Lucy, good child that she was. 
 &bquo;Um, it's a bit personal,&equo; said Jay, stalling, suddenly fascinated by the floor tiles. 
 Lucy laughed: Jay thought of medieval tapestries and silver hunting horns. 
 She mammoth walked to her bag and removed the offending sheets. 
 Its now or never , thrummed her jukebox memory, unbidden. 
 She selected the first three pages &mdash; Lucy as she'd been allowed to see her, and handed them over. 
 Lucy read, and between her sudden fascination for the floor tiles, edge of the table cloth, light thru' the wine glasses, Jay shot glances at Lucy, delirious at how small her hands were, how the rings she wore seemed to hold those tiny fingers together, how she longed to touch, kiss and suck those hands, nuzzle the inside of Lucy's wrists. 
 Lucy looked up when she had finished reading. 
 &bquo;And?&equo; 
 Jay said, her eyes questing.  
 She poured more champagne and noticed her hands were shaking. 
 She drew on her cigarette. 
 &bquo;And,&equo; she said drily, casting the purple passages over the table like a deck of cards. 
 Eat your heart out, Diamond Jim Brady! 
 What the hell. 
 She focused on the rim of her wine glass as phrases from the story danced mockingly across her memory. 
 You've done it now , she thought, numbing herself against Lucy's inevitable knowing look and dismissive laugh. 
 But Lucy did not laugh. 
 Was shaking, in fact, as she put the pages on the table between them. 
 A silence. 
 &bquo;God,&equo; she said, not looking at her. 
 &bquo;You do know how to make love.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorry dear,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Just couldn't resist. 
 Look, laugh it off, forget it, sorry.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd never laugh at this,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I don't know what to say.&equo; 
 This Jay had not expected. 
 A fling, a flingette, a sophisticated snigger. 
 But Lucy pale and unable to meet her eyes? 
 Jay floundered. 
 &bquo;How does it feel to have a dyke fancy you rotten?&equo; she managed. 
 &bquo;Strange,&equo; said Lucy, &bquo;very strange. 
 I really don't know what to say.&equo; 
 &bquo;I must go to the loo,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Jay &mdash; what do you want ?&equo; said Lucy as Jay dived upstairs on the tide of a blush. 
 &bquo;YOU!&equo; 
 Jay called, slamming the loo door. 
 Her heart pounded as she peed. 
 Whatever next? 
 She zipped her jeans and sauntered back downstairs to the other side of the table from Lucy. 
 Cool it, she ordered her imminent coronary, cool it. 
 But Lucy had moved to an easy chair and sat, chin cupped by an exquisite palm. 
 Jay penned her in, one hand on each arm rest and kissed her neck. 
 So bold! 
 She sat in the opposite chair while Lucy put a record on; she flung one leg across the  other knee, rolled a cigarette and contained the volcano surging from her clitoris to tight silent lips. 
 &bquo;We should do some work,&equo; said Lucy. 
 But Jay's spine became electric as Pergolese's Stabat Mater  came through the speakers sure as it had filled the dusk of her dream. 
 The only logical conclusion was that they should go to bed. 
 Lucy arranged the contents of a folder on the table and set up a typewriter. 
 Jay wrenched herself into the present. 
 They sat side by side. 
 &bquo;You type,&equo; said Lucy. 
 Ideas flew from Lucy's lips, Jay worked them into the right phrase, the right analogy. 
 And all at once, it was midnight. 
 &bquo;I'm shattered,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Tough shit,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Let's get the damn thing finished.&equo; 
 &bquo;Now?&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Yeah, now,&equo; said Jay, grinning. 
 &bquo;You didn't know how hard I can work, did you? 
 But only when I really want to. 
 Like writing. 
 Like making love.&equo; 
 Right on time! 
 Enter the beloved son. 
 Tall, lazily handsome, and boy did he know it! 
 Jay resented him immediately, and immediately told herself not to be stupid. 
 But he had just slid his key into the lock, simply strolled in and shattered their precious time. 
 He smiled and yawned. 
 Lucy leapt up at once. 
 Hello, darling ! 
 All her time and mind alert for him. 
 &bquo;Hi, mum. 
 Oh, you're Jay? 
 Hi. 
 I'm Jem.&equo; 
 You would be, snarled Jay, smiling back and lighting a cigarette. 
 Lucy stretched up to peck his cheek, and he patted her as if conferring an honour. 
 &bquo;Have you eaten?&equo; said Lucy, half-way to the table. 
 &bquo;Too tired, mum. 
 Don't fuss. 
 I'm dead! 
 Goodnight!&equo; 
 He loped upstairs two steps at a time. 
 A door closed, taps ran, the loo flushed. 
 Another door closed, then  silence. 
 He lived here all right. 
 He took it all for granted, and would never have a clue just how blessed he was. 
 Jay rushed through the rest of the article. 
 They moved across to easy chairs. 
 Lucy poured brandy. 
 It felt to Jay like her time was very nearly up. 
 And shouldn't Lucy say something  about her story, the subtle and extravagant passes Jay had been making at her all evening? 
 Something should happen ! 
 Suddenly there was silence. 
 Cool it, Jay! she told herself, this is all very new. 
 And Lucy was perfectly capable of saying do stay the night . 
 She didn't. 
 There was a shy tense hug and lip brush of a kiss at the door. 
 Enough to have Jay fly home on the wings of Peter Pan and sleep like an angel. 
 Now she knew where Lucy lived and Lucy knew how she felt. 
 Just in case there was any doubt about it, she decided the woman needed flowers every day, and she would be the one to send them. 
 Lucy was not at work the next day, Francis was writhing in voyeuristic anticipation, Jay was mute, and Access and Interflora were making easy money. 
 Lucy rang her in the evening. 
 &bquo;Thank you for the flowers,&equo; she said, with blackbird song precision. 
 &bquo;There was really no need &mdash; I realised I had a sweet and cheeses, you must have been starving.&equo; 
 Do I need a sweet and cheeses when I can feed on your face ? thought Jay. 
 She said: 
 &bquo;I was fine, fine. 
 Said a lot of things I've been meaning to for a long time.&equo; 
 A pause. 
 The lines humming, Jay wordless. 
 Chit-chat, chit-chat, and see you tomorrow. 
 Night and a bottle of hot-blooded Spanish wine brought a poem to Jay, the first one for years. 
 She  looked at it and could see no fault; she thought of Lucy and didn't care. 
 My heart, my life. 
 I love you! 
 Lucy was her immaculate self at work in the morning; they had a drink in the pub, and it was as if that evening, the story, the kiss, the flowers, had not been. 
 But late night Jay tore into the poem, words flowing like wine from an oak cask, and &mdash; what the hell? &mdash; redeemed by the dawn spring of Lucy's eyes, she put the poem in an envelope, avoided Francis's deep meaningful questions: this love had no confidantes, not even one as well known and sweet as he. 
 CHAPTER FIVE 
 Lucy did not refer to that evening or to the story. 
 But there was something in the air like hummingbirds poised over exotic blooms or velvet sheened butterflies. 
 Jay found Lucy's eyes on her sometimes when she looked up, but there was little enough time to meet. 
 A plan occurred to her; she and Lucy would go away for a weekend to the heart of the country, roses round the door, and find out how they would be lovers. 
 If&hellip; 
 Her dreams were so vivid while the poem shimmered on her desk &mdash; signed, sealed, undelivered &mdash; that she had to catch herself from grabbing Lucy's hands, kissing her right out in the street, holding her close at the end of each day, saying, come home, darling; grabbing her and flinging her to the floor, ripping her clothes off, sinking into her breasts, fucking her like a sheet of flame. 
 There was time enough for that&hellip; later. 
 And then she decided, one Lucyless evening of Marvin Gaye and Millie Jackson, Come Live With Me  Angel, I wanna kiss you all over  &mdash; she decided to send the poem. 
 This was year one, everything was a world premiere. 
 &bquo;Voil&agrave;,&equo; she thought, tossing the letter into the postbox, &bquo;Ma vie est faite.&equo; 
 It was near midnight. 
 The first post went at 7.30 a.m. 
 The poem would arrive in two days' time. 
 She checked her diary. 
 What? 
 The day after tomorrow she was actually going to be with Lucy at a conference on ecology and the arts. 
 They'd arranged it months ago. 
 Francis had raised an eyebrow at her enthusiasm. 
 Jay never went to conferences, but as she accepted a lift with Lucy, he smiled with open pleasure. 
 &bquo;You outrageous dyke, you're just oozing with lust!&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I love that.&equo; 
 &bquo;So do I,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Just hope she does.&equo; 
 &bquo;How can she not?&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;Have fun, darling.&equo; 
 Well, it wasn't an oak-beamed house in the hills, but it was some way out of the city. 
 Jay's mind and body looped their loop. 
 Lucy drove, deft competent hands guiding them through the suburbs, Jay lit cigarettes for them both, a secret kiss at the tip of each one; houses blurred past beyond Lucy's profile. 
 And soon it was trees, and then they parked. 
 Paused. 
 &bquo;Did you get your poem?&equo; said Jay biting her tongue. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Lucy, awkwardly. 
 &bquo;You are my inspiration,&equo; said Jay smiling, feeling easy, wanting Lucy to feel easy. 
 &bquo;Well it's a strange feeling to be someone's inspiration,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I'm glad if it helps.&equo; 
 &bquo;I love you,&equo; said Jay, very softly. 
 Lucy smiled a small tight-fisted smile. 
 They registered at the desk. 
 Fool, clumsy fool! 
 Why can't you wait? 
 Can't you ever WAIT? 
 Why do you always demand? 
 She decided to do  nothing else by way of wooing Lucy until there was real time, time for them to be alone. 
 Together. 
 She set her things round the monastic student bedroom. 
 CHAPTER SIX 
 One of Jay's drawled phrases, as she pubbed and clubbed and waded through hung-over mornings of coffee and endless cigarettes, was &bquo; I'm a night-owl, honey .&equo; 
 Any conference she'd been to, everyone wound up in her room long after midnight, playing poker and spouting Bacardi bullshit, wine-bottle wisdom. 
 But this weekend, her sure-fire heartbeat demanded that she spend every moment possible with Lucy. 
 And the first evening in the bar, Lucy said she liked to rise early and walk, it was so rare and precious to be in the green and open air. 
 &bquo;Well, let's go for a walk,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Tomorrow morning?&equo; 
 &bquo;Seven o'clock?&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;It means we can skip breakfast. 
 I always eat too much at conferences.&equo; 
 Is  there a seven o'clock in the morning? 
 Curiouser and curiouser, Jay relished the idea: a new day in this new galaxy. 
 And so she rose at six and bathed, tapped on Lucy's door at seven, to a clear ringing &bquo;Come in!&equo; 
 Lucy was as lovely first thing as always. 
 You'd be so nice to wake up with &hellip; 
 She rubbed on face cream, grimaced at her adorable lines and so together through the fields in the morning-o! 
 It was the first blush after dawn, a fledgling day&hellip; 
 Of course, Lucy was a runner, Jay a moocher, drinking in the mist and the birds and the rising chill. 
 They left the conference building  behind them. 
 She had this absurd desire to swing Lucy round like a child and walk holding her hand. 
 Instead she smiled with pioneer delight. 
 Maybe, maybe, maybe! 
 Over the fields of the university campus, and a sudden low redbrick wall, a precisely colonnaded rose garden. 
 Lucy spoke of her life, Jay wanted to hold her and hug the hurt away. 
 Dew sat prettily on the roses, and they walked more slowly, Lucy looking at roses, Jay wishing she had a camera, knowing that, whatever else, now she was happy. 
 There was a conservatory too, a solid Victorian steam-palace of dark leaves and shaggy trunks towering like film scenery above them. 
 They parted, and Jay watched Lucy through the fronds, utterly thrilled. 
 Hey presto! a magic mauve flower at her feet, a reason to go to Lucy, touch her arm, say come here I want to show you something. 
 Lucy came &mdash; Jay's fingertips blazoned with the feel of her warm flesh &mdash; and crouched to see. 
 Her dear sweet silky head was a breath from Jay's lips, but Jay sensed in her a wild creature that scares easily, and held her tongue, her lips, her sanctified body, in check. 
 Not now. 
 Back at the building, they parted. 
 Jay lay on her bed, sipping coffee and touching her own face with the tenderness she felt for Lucy, closed her eyes with the dizzy perfection of that moment in the conservatory when they had touched, when she had touched Lucy, and Lucy had walked beside her, seen what she saw; when her eyes had met Jay's, dancing with the glory of it all.  
 CHAPTER SEVEN 
 A laser of moonrise stirred on Jay's pillow. 
 She turned half-asleep in her big warm bed to curl an arm and herself round Lucy's hot soft body. 
 Then woke to the empty pillow beside hers; body stretched in delicious ecstasy, as if her sweet saint had just that second ghosted away. 
 Three-twenty, hours and hours to sleep and dream. 
 She folded her arms round the pillow and murmured it and herself to sleep. 
 Dawn brought her a poem about starlight, Lucy's eyes. 
 A poem for Lucy was a message in a bottle hurled into a turquoise ocean. 
 Lucy had made it clear, if only by silence, that talk of love panicked her. 
 Better to write, keep up a warm gentle insistent flow of words and wonderful cards. 
 Jay would not be shut out and from what she could tell, Lucy didn't want to shut her out. 
 Just keep the door on the latch. 
 A tantalising maybe. 
 Jay felt she had been too long alone on her pure-white sandy desert island. 
 She said she was no good at relationships &mdash; too hot, too cool, too frantic, too laid back, too jealous, too free. 
 She'd given up and love had not visited her lonely shore in years. 
 Her island was peopled with plumed parrots, preening dodos, psychedelic land crabs. 
 Jay sought glitter, brassy jazz orchids of sensation, spectacle. 
 Her island had a twenty-foot movie screen, a pantomime parade, carnival. 
 Her friends came to visit in garish canoes, landed and partied and paddled home in the purple sunrise. 
 Jay loved her friends.  
 But Lucy was a white-sailed trim-rigged yacht whose clean lines cut the waves straight to Jay's heart. 
 And what a rich cargo she bore! 
 A treasure-trove of forty something years of elegant piracy &mdash; Mexican silver, abalone, crystal, Schubert. 
 There was a moon-glow about her, from her searching green eyes flickering with bronze to soft red-gold hair; her soul was elusive thistledown drifting in a moonbeam. 
 She is a unicorn, thought Jay, contriving ways to have their paths cross. 
 A hermit crab sticks sand and weed on its shell, and all Jay's glitz was camouflage. 
 She began to shed the brilliant borrowed chameleon plumage, she wanted to let Lucy in. 
 She started on her flesh. 
 Jay was a solid woman, dressed in dark loose comfortable clothes that hid a multitude of sins. 
 All at once she had to notch her belt tighter, found she had hipbones, cheekbones, found her breasts were round and firm. 
 She bought scarlet jeans and loud shirts, shoes with rainbows on the toe. 
 Love lit her from within and the light dancing from Lucy's radiant being brought her dancing to life. 
 She was so sure that time would change Lucy's fear of loving her that every unanswered poem spurred her on to something finer. 
 Those were the good days. 
 Bad days she reached for the neck of the nearest bottle, never quite drunk, never quite sober, maundering on to Francis about the impossibility of love. 
 Francis, who knew Lucy, said little; Francis, who cared about Jay, kept brandy in the office. 
 He kept clear when Lucy called in, kept his mouth shut unless Jay demanded his wisdom, advice that she would never take. 
 &bquo;Darling, you're spending a bloody fortune over this one. 
 All for the privilege of a little pussybumping! 
 You wish to insert your tongue into her vagina, and why not,  you're both lovely. 
 But this is turning into grand opera, dear, rehearsals at La Scala for G&ouml;tterd&auml;mmerung &hellip; 
 I hope she's worth it.&equo; 
 &bquo;She is,&equo; said Jay boring Francis sick with a detailed analysis of the last conversation she'd had with Lucy. 
 &bquo;Well, you are looking pretty good. 
 If I were you I'd schlepp down to the disco and get yourself some trade, dear, otherwise you'll burst!&equo; 
 Jay felt like an athlete in training: Lucy's perfection &mdash; and so her need for Jay's perfection to love her? &mdash; was her racetrack. 
 This tingling alive alive-o ! &mdash; Love &mdash; was her rigorous coach. 
 Time with Lucy was simply not enough. 
 Jay had never been promiscuous after the fuck'em and leave 'em college years, and now, after five years of no sex except occasional pleasant nights with ex-lovers, her newly spare body thrilled with anticipation. 
 So a handclasp burned along her nerves and home again with just herself and music, she burned through sonnets sober as never before and high as a condor. 
 Maybe they had time alone once a week. 
 And that time might just be a drink or a coffee &mdash; as always. 
 But now, in her need. 
 she noticed every moment with Lucy, pictured her, listened to the memory of her voice. 
 The time they shared became special now, where before they had been free and easy. 
 Love added uncertainty, love lavished all her extravagant colours and textures. 
 The day before Jay's birthday, Lucy said, &bquo;Let's go somewhere different &mdash; Islington. 
 Follow me.&equo; 
 Jay's car was twenty years old and useless for long journeys. 
 But nose to bumper she followed Lucy's city runabout and it was fine. 
 She followed, and Lucy waved at her in the mirror at every light. 
 Goddam, baby, you are something else! 
 Jay was Bogart, Dietrich, even Anne Bancroft as her heart tugged along in Lucy's  wake. 
 They parked on adjacent meters. 
 Both broken, alleluia! 
 Jay walked in the frictionless sphere of one whom the gods have chosen. 
 But the caf&eacute;, Lucy's chosen place, was crowded and they had to share a table with the two cream blondes of the ski-tan variety, orange lipsticked, clad in cashmere. 
 &bquo;You know Peter?&equo; said one. 
 &bquo;God, yah, Peter! 
 Hard work!&equo; said the other intensely. 
 Then their blonde heads met over a whisper, followed by twin ricochets of studied laughter. 
 &bquo;No!&equo; 
 &bquo;Darling, I promise you!&equo; 
 &bquo;My husband used to bring me here,&equo; said Lucy quietly. 
 Jay wanted to know more of this husband, wonder boy's father, Lucy's one-time lover. 
 His name was Martin and what had happened that he had let Lucy go? 
 She never probed Lucy, fearful that she might withdraw. 
 But a casual um or oh? a discreet sloshing of more wine would bring pink to Lucy's cheeks and untie her tongue. 
 And at these times, she could hold Lucy's hand, and would melt when the pressure was returned. 
 &bquo;Oh?&equo; said Jay, like who-gives-a-damn. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 If we'd had a row. 
 To calm us down, get us out of the house. 
 Rooms jangle after rows and no one could argue like me and Martin! 
 Then suddenly we'd have to laugh, you know? 
 There we would be, pistols at dawn and I'd laugh or he'd laugh and it would all be over. 
 So we'd make our peace here.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you come here a lot?&equo; said Jay, neutrally. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 We argued a lot. 
 That table's free.&equo; 
 They moved to relative privacy. 
 &bquo;So it's your birthday tomorrow,&equo; said Lucy. 
 Jay had asked her over to show her off to her four oldest friends.  
 &bquo;Yeah,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;One year nearer the big four O.&equo; 
 &bquo;I remember it well,&equo; said Lucy, grinning, &bquo;OK, what do you want? 
 For your birthday.&equo; 
 For once, Jay was utterly rehearsed. 
 She knew damn well what she wanted &mdash; Lucy stark naked and randy as hell. 
 Hm. 
 Lucy knew that too. 
 &bquo;I want a photo of you,&equo; she said wolfishly, leaning back and smiling straight into Lucy's eyes. 
 &bquo;Oh no,&equo; said Lucy quickly and definitely, convent education bringing roses to her cheeks, &bquo;I hate photos of me. 
 &bquo;That, my dear Lucy, is vanity,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;And why not? 
 You're totally beautiful.&equo; 
 &bquo;Vanity?&equo; 
 Lucy was intrigued. 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 Have you noticed, with group photos, everyone goes Bleeaggh!, 
 I look terrible! 
 You think you look better than any photo. 
 And of course a photo never catches the way a face moves. 
 I'd love to photo you. 
 I'd have to take a few hundred and we might get one we both agree on. 
 It is vanity. 
 You have this picture of yourself &mdash; people fall in love with people who look like their idealised self, usually Narcissism. 
 And in your case, why not? 
 You're stunning,&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose. 
 Well, you're not having my photo. 
 I know what I'm giving you,&equo; Lucy smiled on her secret. 
 &bquo;You give me poetry,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Oh, shut up, Jay. 
 It's too much.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can anything be too much?&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I have to go,&equo; said Lucy, as if scolding, eyes sparkling with pleasure, &bquo;I'll see you when you're a year older.&equo; 
 Eye to eye, they kissed &mdash; on the cheek &mdash; and parted.  
 CHAPTER EIGHT 
 Jay had a big thing about birthdays. 
 Her parents had done birthday parties on a grand scale until she was about thirteen. 
 Then stopped. 
 Whether because they had ceased to be pleased about her birthday or simply because they were tired, she did not know. 
 Her sixteenth birthday they had set the dining room table &mdash; her family usually ate in the kitchen &mdash; and her mother had imposed a reign of terror in her preparations. 
 They had meant it to be special, but at the time, it had been dreadful, and when they began to sing Happy Birthday, Jay had burst into tears and run out of the room. 
 Happy? 
 The house was a terrifying tomb. 
 And at sixteen she wished she had never been born. 
 Now, in her  life she had relaxed and wonderful parties all year. 
 But especially on her birthday. 
 She got the food well out of the way mid-afternoon, devised a tongue-teasing cocktail, and asked all the people she loved. 
 Thirty had been a party for fifty, and now had honed it down to a fabulous four. 
 This year there was also Lucy. 
 She always worried that her friends wouldn't like one another. 
 They usually did, but but but but&hellip; 
 And especially she wanted Lucy to like her friends. 
 She had asked Dionne the American ex-pat writer who never stopped talking, Jamie the drag queen who never stopped talking. 
 Francis who stopped talking only sometimes, and Marina the theatre director who listened and had everyone else listening, a perfect example of it's not what you say, it's the way you say it. 
  Marina had that fabulous Gauloise and gin thee-ay-tah voice: which is why Jay had got to know her in the first place. 
 And then Lucy. 
 She concentrated on cooking and wine, cleared all the piles of crap from the living room to the bedroom, agonised about a full spring clean, for what if Lucy stayed? 
 Aw, hell, said the slut in her, it's me she's come to see not a tidy flat. 
 I am what I am. 
 Dionne brought pink champagne and a new Nina Simone album. 
 She darlinged Jay and kissed her mouth, all Chanel Crystalle and black silk shawls. 
 She had come early, knowing the agony of being alone and waiting&hellip; 
 &bquo;So this could be The One, Jay, huh? 
 But not yet?&equo; she murmured, draped along the kitchen door. 
 &bquo;I think so. 
 Hope so. 
 Not for want of me trying. 
 Shit!&equo; 
 Jay swore at saucepans, whirled eight things together. 
 &bquo;I have to change.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't worry, darling! 
 If she doesn't know what a good thing you are, I feel sorry for her. 
 But I shall give her the once over and deliver my inestimable verdict.&equo; 
 Francis drifted in while Jay was changing. 
 &bquo;Sweetheart!&equo; he said, hugging her silk-clad body, butterflying her just-rouged cheek. 
 &bquo;Best of luck! 
 And happy birthday to you! 
 Here's your prezzie. 
 I feel like one of the three wise men, love, enjoy! 
 It's Maui Waui, I got my surfer-ex to send me some. 
 He wraps it in balls if you'll pardon the expression and puts it in M+M packets. 
 Shall I make a joint? 
 I've also brought you some of that queenie hooch you live on.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good idea,&equo; said Jay, kissing him. 
 Jay's friends were very good on pink champagne. 
 Suddenly she wondered if straight Lucy would mind the smoke? 
 Ridiculous! 
 &bquo;You know this smouldering paragon of desire?&equo; said Francis to Dionne.  
 &bquo;Not yet. 
 I'm intrigued. 
 Our Jay has been remarkably un-rampant for years!&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, dear,&equo; said Francis, &bquo;This one's a real puzzle &mdash; no, I'll let you see for yourself.&equo; 
 The bell rang. 
 Shit! 
 But it was only the sensational Jamie, twirling a diamante choker on his index finger. 
 Off-stage, no one would have looked at Jamie twice, standard rips in his faded jeans and political tee-shirt. 
 The only thing he had in common with Cherry Morello, his stage persona, was a mega-mouth of repartee. 
 The boy was born centre stage. 
 He flung one leg round the door post, demanded a Las Vegas introduction and swarmed into the room murmuring good evening, stopping when he saw Jay and looking totally bemused. 
 &bquo;I know your face&hellip;&equo; he said, then bear-hugged her. 
 &bquo;Oh, pull &mdash; ease! 
 I can't hug women. 
 I'm a poof! 
 Business is bad, love,&equo; he said, plonking a flagon of cheap red on the table. 
 &bquo;Just a small token of my undying etceteras. 
 Give me that smoke! 
 I  have arrived!&equo; 
 &bquo;You kiss me before you get to reefer madness,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Fasten it round my neck too, darling Jamie, thank you. 
 &bquo;She's not here yet?&equo; said Francis, raising an eyebrow. 
 &bquo;Should Jamie and I camp along to the pub and keep watch? 
 It's awful to be last, isn't it?&equo; 
 The doorbell rang. 
 Jay opened the door. 
 I Love Lucy. 
 Lucy in white silk Dynasty jacket, butterfly turquoise shirt, skin-tight velvet trousers, silver sandals. 
 Kissed Jay on both cheeks. 
 &bquo;Happy Birthday,&equo; she said; she smelt like spring flowers. 
 Francis and Jamie and Dionne said hi, Marina flew in  &mdash; exhausted, darling! &mdash; and Jay took a bucket of cocktails from the fridge. 
 &bquo;Darling!&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;What is it?&equo; 
 &bquo;You see,&equo; said Jamie, leaning towards Lucy, &bquo;Jay was a cocktail waitress in a previous incarnation &mdash; she has a Gift!&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought she'd had  a cocktail waitress, dear,&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;Dyke's are very creative with exotic fruit,&equo; said Jamie. 
 &bquo;An avocado in every orifice, so they say.&equo; 
 &bquo;Or very ripe figs,&equo; drawled Francis. 
 &bquo;I've seen Jay tongue out figs in the most suggestive manner, and positively drool over the sweet flesh of a mango. 
 I can't imagine why.&equo; 
 &bquo;I hope we're safe with this,&equo; said Jamie, peering into the cocktail jug. 
 &bquo;Oh, she never recycles,&equo; soothed Francis. 
 Thank God the rouge hid the blush, thought Jay, wishing she was a virgin for Lucy. 
 &bquo;And then there's vegetables,&equo; said Jamie, &bquo;A pound of very firm  carrots please, Mr Greengrocer&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, shut UP, you awful queens,&equo; said Dionne. 
 &bquo;What is it, Jay?&equo; 
 Jay poured cocktails for them all. 
 &bquo;Look Out For the Velvet Hammer,&equo; she said, raising her glass. 
 &bquo;Happy Birthday, Jay,&equo; they said, all her favourite friends and Lucy. 
 Then &mdash; &bquo;Wow!&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I just felt the velvet hammer! 
 Here!&equo; 
 She thumped her chest over the heartbeat. 
 Jay smiled, supremely confident. 
 The first taste was fresh and innocuous, then it lit up the throat with a burst of sunshine: it hit the gut with a throb of heat. 
 It had taken her days to invent this one. 
 &bquo;This is your present,&equo; said Marina. 
 She handed over a pink-tissued shape dripping with silver bows and gaudy  ribbons. 
 Marina always wrapped things so you didn't want to spoil them by opening. 
 But inside was a crystal ball, a witch ball, old goldy glass with a fountain of trapped bubbles. 
 &bquo;It's a real crystal ball,&equo; said Marina. 
 Jay loved everything about glass and felt the weight and smoothness. 
 She kissed Marina. 
 &bquo;I'll tell your fortune later,&equo; said Jamie. 
 &bquo;Gets better after a few drinks. 
 You will meet a strange woman &mdash; that's safe, knowing the dives you  frequent.&equo; 
 &bquo;Happy birthday, Jay,&equo; said Lucy. 
 And gave her a square flat parcel. 
 &bquo;It's a baking tray, dear,&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;Baking tray?&equo; exploded Jamie. 
 &bquo;It's a cocaine mirror, oh give me some!&equo; 
 &bquo;Shut up the pair of you,&equo; said Jay, feeling like a kid at Christmas. 
 &bquo;I hope you haven't already got it,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;It&equo; was an LP of Stabat Mater , Pergolesi perfection, and a double of LP of mellifluous Pachelbel, Gluck, Bach et al. 
 &bquo;Thank you,&equo; said Jay who adored all of them, &bquo;I have the Pergolese, but it's totally worn out.&equo; 
 Hardly surprising, since she'd played it non-stop since her Lucy dream, wept to it, soaked it in until it was her heartbeat, floated on the cloud of its beauty all through the Lucyless days. 
 Her eyes met Lucy's and held them. 
 God, she knew all right! 
 No one can look back at you like that unless&hellip; 
 She kissed Lucy and it didn't matter that somehow her lips landed only on her cheek. 
 She put on the other record, save Pergolesi for later when surely they'd be alone. 
 Oh yeah! 
 &bquo;The trouble is they've made most of them into cigar and wallpaper adverts,&equo; said Lucy brightly. 
 &bquo;Or low-fat spreads.&equo; 
 &bquo;Darling, I almost died!&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;They've put  
 Satie over a building society commercial. 
 Two hideous yuppies in tubular stainless steel sipping minimalist  cocktails &mdash; no olives or fruit salad &mdash; God, give my ageing pectorals strength! &mdash; and contemplating how much they can borrow to house their sterile fucking, dear. 
 I mean, they move into a mansion, they'll need both salaries for the next thousand years!&equo; 
 &bquo;I know the one,&equo; said Jamie. 
 &bquo;They'll get an au pair, some poor foreign bitch they can exploit.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's hardly fair. 
 I had an au pair once. 
 She ran off with the silver. 
 Literally,&equo; said Lucy, sparkling into the conversation. 
 Jay smiled. 
 Marina took charge of Lucy, and she relaxed: Marina drawing people out was spectator sport. 
 And that was what Jay loved about her birthdays. 
 Watching the people she loved most simply being together. 
 She drifted from one conversation to another: Jamie and Francis in the Max Miller blue corner, Marina as audience, Dionne and Lucy in the Arts ring. 
 &bquo;Jay is a fabulous cook,&equo; said Francis loudly at one point. 
 &bquo;Not that I'm dropping hints, darling!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, she'll make someone a wonderful wife!&equo; screeched Jamie. 
 And so late into the night. 
 Finally the clock struck three, then four, finally Francis and Jamie lurched down the stairs arguing about how late the late night bars stayed open or had they got the energy to visit the Heath. 
 &bquo;I haven't got my Heath shoes on,&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;Well it's quite dry, dear!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh I hope NOT!&equo; 
 Marina seized a cab immediately, Dionne disappeared to the loo and Lucy stood to leave. 
 Alone at last! 
 &bquo;Give us a kiss,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Three,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Two continental and one on the lips.&equo;  
 And her body went soft in Jay's arms. 
 She almost parted her lips, then drew back. 
 &bquo;Darling!&equo; breathed Jay, drawing her close, searching for her adorable lips again, &bquo;stay with me. 
 You know you want to.&equo; 
 &bquo;I have to go home,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;You will stay sometime? 
 God, I want you so much! 
 Oh, stay now!&equo; 
 &bquo;Jay, you're drunk,&equo; said Lucy, laughing and pushing her away, but gently. 
 &bquo;That was a lovely party. 
 I like your friends. 
 I'll see you on Monday.&equo; 
 Jay followed Lucy as she put her coat on and went into the street. 
 &bquo;I love you, Lucy.&equo; 
 Lucy wound down the window of her car and held her face up. 
 Jay kissed her eyes, her brow, her chin&hellip; 
 &bquo;I've got to go.&equo; 
 She went. 
 &bquo;Angel,&equo; murmured Jay, waving to her along the dark road. 
 She raced upstairs again, paused at the door to touch her face and neck, everywhere Lucy had touched her. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; said Dionne. 
 &bquo;You tell me. 
 Go on, tell me.&equo; 
 Both Jay and Dionne had spent many a dawn listening to each other on the latest One and Only. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; said Dionne, extracting a half-bottle of brandy from her handbag. 
 &bquo;I take it it's too late to be sober or sleep? &mdash; Good. 
 Then I'll begin.&equo; 
 Dionne arranged herself along the couch. 
 Jay poured brandy and sprawled on the floor. 
 Earl Hines hit the turntable and Dionne spoke. 
 &bquo;One: Your Lucy is a stunner. 
 Can you pick'em, girl, or can you pick'em! 
 Two: she's fascinated. 
 Eyes like saucers at those frightful queens we both know and love. 
 Three: she likes you a lot.&equo;  
 &bquo;Oh, I like it,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Now for the bad news?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well. 
 Four: she's straight and a mummy. 
 Had to be responsible all her life. 
 Never had enough fun, thinks there's something endemically wrong with the pleasure principle. 
 By which our kind live. 
 Oh, I did my homework, while you were screaming along with the boys! 
 So, Jay, you've set yourself a wonderful conundrum. 
 What a challenge! 
 But don't be surprised if the answer's no. 
 Have you really fallen head over etcetera, my dear? 
 Of course you have. 
 Does the Pope shit in the woods? 
 I just worry, as usual, that I shall be mopping you up for months to come.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I'm too far in to move back now. 
 Don't care. 
 Do care. 
 God, isn't she wonderful!&equo; 
 &bquo;What's your next move, you rambunctious dyke, you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, dinner, I think, chez moi,&equo; said Jay lightly. 
 &bquo;Leap on her, Jay. 
 Just leap and see what happens.&equo; 
 A bird tweetered in the grey light through the blinds. 
 &bquo;Bed,&equo; said Dionne, &bquo;I'm staying with you, by the way, too broke for a cab. 
 And I'm not too proud to be a surrogate. 
 Make love to me, Jay.&equo; 
 &bquo;You realise we did this on my last birthday? 
 And then on yours?&equo; said Jay as they snuggled close. 
 &bquo;What do you think drew me here?&equo; said Dionne. 
 &bquo;I could get used to this bi-annual orgy, Jay dear. 
 Shame we're not In Love, really. 
 It could be very pleasant.&equo; 
 CHAPTER NINE 
 Jay finished typing an article without any idea what she had typed.  
 Lucy, um, I wondered if you'd like to come over for dinner sometime, like tonight. 
 That was no good. 
 Lucy would be busy. 
 I've got some amazing new music I'd like you to hear. 
 You must come over soon. 
 And then she could say she'd like to borrow it. 
 No. 
 Come over and I'll wine you and dine you and make love with you for the rest of your life. 
 So subtle! 
 &bquo;Have you got a minute, Jay?&equo; 
 Lucy had her serious office-work glasses on and a sheaf of papers. 
 I have a lifetime! 
 &bquo;Sure,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Could you zip through this and see if it's OK? 
 There's something wrong with it, and I just can't see it clearly.&equo; 
 &bquo;Leave it to me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, you are good Thank you.&equo; 
 I'm actually very very evil, thought Jay with a wolfish grin. 
 And sauntered down the corridor a half-hour later. 
 &bquo;Page three,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Cut the second paragraph, it's confusing.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm very grateful,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Do you want to come over for dinner sometime?&equo; said Jay, as if it had just occurred to her. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Lucy, &bquo;That would be nice. 
 Let me get my diary.&equo; 
 They booked a day, an evening. 
 And afterwards, Jay started her own diary, for her eyes only. 
 It was all so unreal, she felt she had to write it down to prove it was happening, to have it and hold it to her heart.  
 Jay's Diary 
 Forty-eight hours to seeing you. 
 Not neurotic, that, just a way of parcelling out the time, and doing everything I need to. 
 All accounted for and two and a half hours to spare. 
 Time to think myself in and out of any last minute panic. 
 Panics. 
 But of course, not neurotic, no! 
 Off to the hairdresser. 
 An hour. 
 Time on the bus to think: what do I wear? 
 Launderette yesterday, everything's clean. 
 Superstition, stop crossing your fingers. 
 Last time I went to the hairdresser's I was so crippled with period pains I drank three instant g &amp; t's on the bus. 
 Not today. 
 No gin for a month already. 
 Have a drink at six-thirty. 
 Not before. 
 Brandy. 
 You like brandy. 
 Is there any hope of getting Greek brandy with its old gold seven stars? 
 Should have thought of that before. 
 Ho hum. 
 Graffiti a heart, slash an arrow. 
 I luv U. Have a cigarette. 
 Another cigarette. 
 Lousy crossword today, clever-clever, too many obvious anagrams. 
 Shall I varnish my nails? 
 Gorgeous camp Sebastian goes to town, goes mad, keeps me laughing, lurid tongue, worldly-wise eyes: 
 you got a date then, darling ? 
 Yeahhrrr I say. 
 Hot stuff, Sebastian. 
 Well, dear, hope she's worth it ! 
 Read the stars in the magazines and the paper: 
 Today is your lucky day. 
 Grey is your lucky colour. 
 You are my lucky star. 
 And give it time ! says Sebastian. 
 Don't wash it for three days! 
 Give it time, I know you, you're so impatient . 
 Yes, Sebastian, no Sebastian, my cup runneth over. 
 Now stop that. 
 Shut up. 
 Whatever happens will. 
 No buts. 
 Just get on.  
 Shop for food. 
 Easy, do it in my sleep. 
 Do it . 
 Shut the hell up. 
 Time's moving on. 
 Off-licence. 
 Only one bottle of pink left &mdash; omen? 
 JESUS! will you stop it? 
 It's all bubbles. 
 Oh, definite omen, Greek brandy, Aegean witchcraft in its classical bottle, lavishly labelled. 
 I can do the Melina Mercouri. 
 Good good good. 
 Dress? 
 Cook? 
 Cook first. 
 Messy cow, bloody garlic all over clothes, not a good idea. 
 Cooked. 
 Clothes? 
 Old, new, borrowed, blue. 
 Shoes, hair, shirt &mdash; oh, yes, borrowed and grey &mdash; stonewashed jeans. 
 Casual, but good with this anarchic riot of hair. 
 Nearest you'll get to Tina Turner, dear ! 
 What a woman! 
 Make-up. 
 Seduction slap. 
 Healthy outdoor look. 
 Easy on the kohl. 
 OK! 
 Sit with the music, blow a little smoke, time enough to snap out of it, sip the brandy. 
 She may not come. 
 Well, all right , you optimistic alter-ego, who rattled your chain? 
 Phone rings. 
 She's not coming. 
 She is. 
 Bloody hell. 
 Your voice&hellip; 
 Thirty minutes. 
 Open the wine, lucky you've got a vacuum cork. 
 Wrestling with corks in front of her? 
 Couldn't handle it. 
 Stick to brandy and Perrier. 
 Hers the first sip of pink champagne. 
 Love her whatever. 
 One of the best. 
 The best. 
 Pretzels and Mozart. 
 Bayberry incense. 
 Now look here, you trembling ridiculous creature, listen to me, nothing may happen and that has to be OK too. 
 Got it? 
 Yizz. 
 I got it. 
 But&hellip; 
 But but but but&hellip; 
 You're HOPELESS! 
 (This from my pseudo-older-and-wiser alter-ego).  
 Yizz Ah Know. 
 Nice, ain't it? 
 Alter-ego sighs and looks wise. 
 So don't talk to me. 
 Take the evening off. 
 Certainly! 
 Exit offended alter-ego with money enough to go to the pictures. 
 Alone at last! 
 Time to recollect, gather myself together, brush my teeth again, roll a&hellip; 
 Shit! 
 You're at the door. 
 How come every time I see you you're even lovelier than I remember. 
 You're breathtaking, sparkling, your lovely hair is swept up to a glossy oriflamme, you're a study in black and white, your merry eyes are wonderful . 
 Talk slow. 
 That way I don't appear as nervous as my skippety-hop heart. 
 Good God, I've known you long enough and why the hell have my knees decided to take their annual vacation at this precise moment? 
 Music. 
 You say Fats Waller. 
 Sit. 
 Come back, knees, all is forgiven. 
 Melina Mercouri just as marvellous as I thought. 
 Glad for the glasses, love lustre. 
 Your eyes. 
 Mouth on careless automatic. 
 Oh, God, your eyes . 
 Pretzels, I say, for God's sake, bring on the pretzels. 
 More jazz &mdash; more jazz. 
 Tapes crash all over my desk. 
 Hysteria. 
 Inanimate objects reflect my mood. 
 Hopeless to try and impress you  with my slender collection of classical music. 
 Stick to jazz, home ground. 
 More Melina Mercouri, hi, knees, glad you could make it, check food, what the hell that's never a problem. 
 Are we going to eat pretzels or are we going to eat? 
 Oh, yeah, food, yeah. 
 More Melina Mercouri. 
 Can't eat much anyway, your eyes, being, presence, hands, mouth, hair, You  marvellous woman , you. 
 Satie, God, if I could write like Satie writes music!  
 If I could just reach out and touch your face&hellip; 
 I love you. 
 Enter alter-ego. 
 Lousy film and what the hell is going on here? 
 Just piss off to a nightclub, dear, come back in the wee small hours. 
 GO! 
 More froth. 
 Perrier too, esses beginning to go. 
 When I fell in love with you, I say, feeling lyrical&hellip; 
 I don't think you are in love with me, you cut in, fixing me with your eyes. 
 My heart double flips. 
 Something in the air. 
 Written you four stories, showed you one. 
 Show you two. 
 You show me an article you've written. 
 It's brilliant, clear, cool, precise and humorous&hellip; 
 I want to touch you. 
 No, you say, all in control, we are not going to sleep together. 
 Honey, who said a word about sleeping? 
 I push you like hell. 
 Maybe I can take, sometime I can take, but I can't take no from you. 
 Yet I am amazed when we do kiss. 
 Your lips are so soft, your hair is silky, your body is warm and so tender. 
 Oh, I don't want to stop. 
 Pushing my luck is my favourite occupation. 
 With you. 
 Love your cheeks, your chin, your ears, your brow, your neck, I love your perfectly beautiful breasts, like holy wine. 
 And then just when we might not stop, oh my love, my virgin forest and me your virgin explorer, it is time, just like that, to stop. 
 We're worth so much more. 
 I don't want to make hasty and furtive love with you. 
 Got to do this with our eyes wide open. 
 You sit beside me in my arms. 
 Jesus! 
 You are lovelier than I dreamed. 
 You say you feel safe with me. 
 You are. 
 I feel sanctified. 
 You say you've never kissed a woman like that before. 
 Of course, I realise, dazed, of course you haven't. 
 How strange! 
 And I  have never kissed a woman like you before, I've never kissed you before. 
 Would you do something for me? 
 Anything, sure, of course, what? 
 I know you're going, my heart fears the worst&hellip; 
 I keep perfectly still. 
 Would you kiss my breasts again? 
 It felt so&hellip; 
 Something for you? 
 Something so indescribably ecstatic for me. 
 You go to undo your shirt, your silk shirt alive with the warmth of your breasts&hellip; 
 I wouldn't dream of allowing it, it's my pleasure, I do it. 
 And you undo your bra, never kissed a woman who wears a bra before. 
 God, I love you. 
 You give me your breasts and hold me close. 
 You are warm in my arms, your body right next to mine. 
 If my lips had words for the wondrous feeling of your breasts and nipples I'd say them. 
 But there are no words good enough for perfection. 
 And I could die and go to heaven when I hear you making wordless muted sounds beside me and feel your lips kiss my brow so gently. 
 I love you so. 
 CHAPTER TEN 
 Jay's diary II 
 I knew L. would take a holiday sometime. 
 What I didn't realise was that her holiday started the day after she'd had dinner with me, she was going to Italy to look at churches with her beloved son. 
 For  fourteen days. 
 I made myself pretty busy: got pissed, went and screamed at Jamie, saw a million movies, realised with horror that that ate up only a week. 
 A repeat performance the next week punctuated by a postcard from L. showing the entire Sistine Chapel ceiling on the front, and missing the word LOVE on the back. 
 Ho hum. 
 Three days before she came back, I cleaned the flat, bought a new jacket and five bright new cotton shirts, stayed sober, worked like hell on the magazine in a way that made Francis &bquo;gasp and stretch his eyes&equo;. 
 &bquo;All this and you haven't even got under the duvet with her yet, dear! 
 God help us when you do!&equo; 
 But I have clammed up about L. Feel superstitious. 
 Maybe if I keep mum and keep my fingers crossed &mdash; what did my father always say when I couldn't have something: &bquo;Them that ask don't get, them that don't ask, don't want.&equo; 
 He thought it was funny and who needs  a Mary Poppins LP, a Beatles poster, a sequinned belt, anyway. 
 Well, I did and didn't get and now I have all these things. 
 She's back tomorrow. 
 Could this be why I'm ironing with a face-pack on? 
 To Aldgate then I came, burning, burning after a Badedas bath, when things happen! 
 Flowers at her door, good God, it's less than nine in the morning&hellip; but she, of course, is already here. 
 Standing at her office door, fool with hearts and flowers. 
 She has positioned herself behind her desk, and will not meet my eyes. 
 &bquo;Hi,&equo; I say, &bquo;welcome back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are these for me?&equo; she says, with (feigned?) surprise, &bquo;That's kind.&equo; 
 &bquo;You have a nice holiday&equo; Or some such bullshit . 
 &bquo;Oh lovely.&equo; 
 Let's keep it civilised . 
 &bquo;Coffee?&equo; 
 I want to kiss you .&equo;  
 &bquo;That would be nice.&equo; 
 Maybe we don't have to talk about it . 
 I make coffee, she phones around, shifts papers, I can't say a word I mean. 
 Think I must be blushing, and maybe she is too or is it her English rose complexion kissed, fuck, there I go, kissed (I should be so lucky!) by sudden Mediterranean sunshine? 
 We drink coffee. 
 I recall that there is a meeting this afternoon to discuss the paper we wrote. 
 I'm being allowed onto her ecologically correct territory, and no one there will know how we kissed and almost, as good as, made love&hellip; but I will and she will. 
 &bquo;Look, Jay,&equo; she says, all bright and brisk, like there was a fascinating bird on the windowsill she just had  to show me, &bquo;we've got to cool it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cool it?&equo; 
 I say, feeling ice cubes drop slowly into this volcano of longing. 
 Should I have grabbed her this morning? 
 Who knows? 
 Not me&hellip; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; she says, rushing through her script, &bquo;we have plans to work together. 
 It's not a good idea.&equo; 
 File this love under N.B.G. I am mute, catatonic. 
 Feel the tears, nod, my ironed clothes crumple to rags. 
 And we have a meeting at six. 
 &bquo;See you,&equo; I say and escape to City Road, where an off-licencee is opening and looks up surprised to see an office yuppie (his definition) among the line of winoes so early in the morning-o! 
 Theirs is cider and Carslberg special and Emva Cream, and mine is a bottle of brandless brandy and lo-cal ginger ale, ever figure conscious as if anyone gave a damn. 
 Francis takes in the scene at ten. 
 I am half-pissed and brilliant, Francis takes me for egg and chips and strong tea and tells me to give it up. 
 I should be so lucky to be able to. 
 But L. knows nothing of this. 
 By five I am sober and handle the meeting with a superb  professionalism borrowed from Mildred Pierce and Mommie Dearest. 
 She hasn't a clue and asks me out for a drink. 
 We chat, and I mentally award myself thirteen Oscars. 
 She relaxes. 
 What was she expecting &mdash; Baby Jane? 
 She feels she has to say something. 
 &bquo;I was very drunk, Jay,&equo; she says in a rush, &bquo;I didn't mean that to happen.&equo; 
 Drunk? 
 &bquo;I know you were. 
 I was too. 
 But I mean it, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll just have to give me time,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;I'm a very slow sort of person usually.&equo; 
 Lights the embers of my fool heart with this maybe. 
 If all she needs is time to say yes, I'll be your lover , then she has all the time in the world. 
 I've waited long enough for love, for her. 
 Does she mean days weeks months years? 
 Not the time to ask. 
 &bquo;I won't stop asking you,&equo; I say, and she looks guarded, pleased, looks like she's trying not to show anything. 
 Home alone to the immaculate discipline of writing sonnets. 
 (Ha!) 
 Feel like Pam Ayres, the rhymes are no problem, but it all comes out doggerel. 
 But my In Love body forgets about food and sleep and produces its own adrenalin to keep me flying through every hour. 
 Francis is knocked out and so am I. I seem to be doing more and more advisory art stuff for Lucy's magazine, positively volunteering, my dear, what is happening? 
 What's happening is that I have a reason for rising, for living, for laughing. 
 Two glasses of wine send me high over the rainbowed moon. 
 And then there are the dreams, more vivid than the live-long day.  
 CHAPTER ELEVEN 
 Jay's Diary III 
 So suppose you turn to me and say yes . 
 The Yes that launches a thousand sky-rockets just as my heart is a catherine-wheel the second I fall in love with you. 
 And has been ever since. 
 Yes  means a time for us to be together, us and only us in a place that is beautiful and special and quiet and doesn't know just how amazing a love is about to transform it into one of those Indian summer memories that make deaf old ladies grin knowingly, when you think they are dead in a deckchair on the sea front. 
 But they are not dead, just dreaming, and you have no idea how passionately their stiff and shaking limbs once burned. 
 The place is off the beaten track, two bumpy miles wrecking the car suspension and who gives a damn? 
 Not you, my dear, with your frankly fabulous soul, and not me, alive alive-o! 
 There is nobody else on this earth who even knows we are here. 
 We are both appalling about food. 
 You forget to eat, and you think it doesn't matter, and I can't eat when you're around. 
 But we are trying to be sensible. 
 So we go through the motions of feeding ourselves. 
 One thing about us , before love and ever since &mdash; B.L. 
 and A.L. 
 &mdash; is we never run out of things to say. 
 Funny how tongue-tied I feel right now, over the table from you, my love, I feel safest pouring wine. 
  We both shake when we're nervous. 
 And go cold. 
 But my arms round you, your arms holding me, and the shivering stops and welds us still and close and still closer. 
 B.L. 
 I had these passionate blouse-ripping fantasies, the sort where you dissolve on a bearskin rug and explode with ecstasy. 
 A.L. 
 I am learning a reality of slow warmth. 
 Slow and sure. 
 Like there is now, holding each other in the middle of nowhere. 
 We shall have music wherever we go. 
 And now in the firelight there is only the best of music to play. 
 Notes that arabesque around the magnificent abundance of trees in the wind, shaking sea-grey, spring-green, ashen-blue. 
 I am lying in the grass dazed by the sun and the busy ants, by the myriad humming galore of a river on a summer afternoon. 
 A dragonfly skims a path through the tips of the rushes. 
 We are on a shore of white sand too hot to stand still for a moment, great breakers surf and trip to swathes of foam as we dart into the solid black and lovely shade. 
 The rose garden at dawn. 
 I watch you freewheeling along a vine-wrapped colonnade, and pause under an archway wrought in stone and lovely with purple flowers ringing in the new light. 
 On this high hill, the wind whips your face chill; the wind drops and your cheeks are burning; you can see the patchwork of seven counties sweeping and dissolving to misty far green at your feet, rising again to heather-blue mountains melting to pure white cloud. 
 Oh, the dawn when shadows skeeter ahead of the sure fluid sunlight, back to their night.  
 We are held, stunned surely under a crescent moon, thrilled by ice-white stars and the scent of magnolia, your dress a sweep of silver through a baroque balcony entwined with dusk-white roses&hellip; 
 Look at you now &mdash; you take my breath. 
 I look at you now, with the flame gold lilting on the fine planes of your face and caressing your fine fingers. 
 In the glow the lazy blue smoke of a cigarette folds in slow waves to vanish in the sepia shadows of the room Everything about us  says come here, you , and our fingertips are first to arc between us and hover on cheeks, lips, chin. 
 We are swimmers in slow motion, we glide together through clear and wordless waves, strokes of pure genius. 
 Mid afternoon gives us a moment when the heart of light in a leaf trembles russet rainbows. 
 Dawn brings a gift of spider webs flashing diamonds on sea-grey gorse. 
 Midday burns the sky azure, bleaches to blind dazzle a field of ripe wheat. 
 Midnight and a silvered road of dreams, a black field shot with a million bursts of white &mdash; the name is glow-worm, the sight is magic. 
 Spring leaves of pure sap green silver-haired as a child's arm. 
 I am in love with you , the feeling drives me, drives me crazy, tumbles me in a drum. 
 To reach you , to touch you 
 CHAPTER TWELVE 
 That spring was magic. 
 A rare sneak preview of  summer in the city, ice-cream regency houses linked with solid tree silhouettes against a sky as blue as blue. 
 Trees in the park misted over with young green, bright spring yellow flowers crowding front gardens; embassy lawns starred with daisies; snowdrop beds, municipal grass studded with crocuses. 
 Jay drove as if inspired, drinking it all in. 
 She made fresh tapes to play in the car, and grinned at the luxury of traffic jams in the company of Louis Prima and Sidney Bechet. 
 She drove as if Lucy was beside her &mdash; usually she cursed every cut-throat city driver &mdash; and sucked the hell out of a row of pre-rolled cigarettes, cigarettes rolled hastily at red lights, slamming in and out of gear. 
 These days of wonder, she felt graciously pleased with her life; keeping her self-promise not to be heavy with Lucy, thinking herself under the skin and into the mind of the woman she loved. 
 It must be strange to be the object of my affection, she thought idly, especially if all you've had is hard-chested men doing their best but never sure. 
 Because when Jay had first kissed a woman, she knew she had come home, it was what she was born for. 
 Extravagant long evenings, she consulted her good fairies. 
 Dionne said: &bquo;Well, if she's had a necking session or two with you, you wicked dyke, she's obviously interested.&equo; 
 Francis said: &bquo;I couldn't have your patience, darling! 
 Could your Lucy be playing a little game &mdash; sorry! 
 I take that back. 
 I am merely a dyke-hag. 
 Stunned  at the privilege, but I shall never understand you. 
 Good luck!&equo; 
 Marina said: &bquo;It's very strange, Jay. 
 I've known you In Love, but never quite like this. 
 I worry that you'll get hurt. 
 You always get hurt.&equo; 
 Jamie said: &bquo;Christ, dear! 
 I'm celibate, don't ask me ! 
 I've probably got AIDS anyway, and I'm hopelessly  jealous. 
 The doctors will tell me if I get ill. 
 I should have been a lesbian! 
 Don't see how you can stand the celibacy when you don't have to. 
 There'll be a fucking explosion one of these days when you do finally Do It. 
 And weren't you the dyke who was extolling the virtues of the single life only months ago? 
 Yes! 
 You were!&equo; 
 Jay said: &bquo;I don't know what I'm doing, it's never been this way before, can't go on anything else, but this time I'm not going to fuck up.&equo; 
 Hm, said her friends, and hmmmm said Jay herself to her self when she was alone. 
 And she had devised a hook for time with Lucy. 
 What a fucking chameleon I am, she mocked herself. 
 The hook was an exhibition they could work on together, a definitive work on pollution and the arts, the environment and how artists respond to it. 
 Lucy had been approached by an international humanist organisation, there was funding, and Lucy was raring to go. 
 But needed some kind of help: she'd spoken about it for months before and was utterly thrilled when Jay drawled an interest. 
 Jay sketched it out as a glass bead game lavishly illustrated; the square squalor of modern conurbations as a desperate attempt to assert human life, defying destruction and repelling nature after wars and disasters. 
 The way &bquo;civilisations&equo; had to make their mark, just in case they might disappear without trace. 
 Lucy bit. 
 Jay realised she was flattered at being asked, realised that Lucy thought of her as somehow daringly on the wrong and the right side of the track all at the same time. 
 And the exhibition would  be important, she told herself, when a flow of desire swept her away at the thought of being with Lucy, time allotted to their togetherness. 
 &bquo;You've got it bad,&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;It'll keep me out of the pub, dear,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I reckon the way to this woman's heart is through her mind.&equo;  
 &bquo;Heart? 
 Mind?&equo; said Francis with a giggle. 
 &bquo;Pardon me being basic, but is it going to be nights over a hot typewriter with champagne and a little heavy breathing on the side?&equo; 
 &bquo;We live in hope,&equo; said Jay. 
 The first exhibition meeting was at Lucy's flat. 
 Where they roughed out the areas they could cover, and possible sources of material. 
 Lucy wanted a pamphlet by way of introduction; Jay said, let's just get all the information together. 
 Lucy had borrowed the office word-processor. 
 The hours burned by on the green screen, and when they finally flopped in Lucy's living room, sipping brandy, a key turned in the lock and in came the charmingly dishevelled one and only son. 
 Like he owned the place. 
 Jay withdrew a little. 
 &bquo;Jem!&equo; said Lucy, switching into mum mode, &bquo;have you eaten? 
 This is Jay &mdash; oh, you met before.&equo; 
 St Patrick's Day. 
 Ho hum. 
 Jeremy smiled with Lucy's elfin charm, stretched, yawned and said: 
 &bquo;Don't fuss, mum. 
 Hi, Jay. 
 I was shattered when I met you last. 
 I gather you're a leading light in the arts &mdash; these are mine for my sins.&equo; 
 He indicated the pictures lining the walls. 
 He knew he was good, and Lucy was blushing slightly. 
 Maternal pride? 
 Or was she confounded by two separate parts of her life coming together? 
 &bquo;I like that one,&equo; said Jay, pointing to a pagan woodland scene. 
 &bquo;But I'm no judge, Jeremy, just a hack.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't work mum too hard!&equo; he said, glancing at his watch. 
 He poured a glass of wine and appeared settled. 
 &bquo;Did you call back the Cartieri Gallery?&equo; said Lucy suddenly. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he said, in a long-suffering tone. 
 &bquo;Well, you must, Jem, they've left three messages.&equo;  
 He loafed to his feet, and put his hands on Lucy's shoulders. 
 &bquo;Worry, worry, worry. 
 I'll call them tomorrow, mum. 
 I'd better sleep. 
 Nice to meet you, Jay.&equo; 
 He loped upstairs. 
 The atmosphere had held a certain smoky glow, he had fragmented it. 
 So sure of himself, so sure of Lucy. 
 &bquo;What's he doing these days?&equo; asked Jay. 
 Not that she gave a damn, but Lucy's mind was obviously on him. 
 &bquo;Portraits,&equo; said Lucy briefly. 
 &bquo;He wants to do mine.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll buy it,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Oh, he'll make me look a hundred and three,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;All these lines!&equo; 
 &bquo;I love your lines,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;They're a map of who you are. 
 You can tell what a person's like from their lines &mdash; you make your face.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, you've done a lot of laughing. 
 And worrying. 
 And crying. 
 But, by God, lady, you've decided to survive.&equo; 
 &bquo;Which line's that?&equo; said Lucy grinning. 
 It was so easy to flatter her, she took it like a sixteen year old wino's never heard it before. 
 &bquo;Oh, that's the chin,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;that chin says don't fuck with me, fella ! 
 Lucy smiled. 
 &bquo;Time to go home,&equo; she said, and kissed Jay gently on the cheek at the door. 
 Jay held her hand and brushed her adorable fingers with her lips. 
 &bquo;I think this exhibition's really going to happen. 
 I knew I couldn't do it alone,&equo; Lucy said. 
 Driving home, she wondered. 
 Jem still lived at home &mdash; was that why Lucy had no lovers? 
 Their next meeting was a month ahead. 
 And that was at Jay's place.  
 CHAPTER THIRTEEN 
 Jay's first task concerned nature forms and architecture, the adaptation of natural societies versus the hard-edged impersonality of modern cities. 
 One of Jay's favourite themes. 
 Nothing but the best for Lucy, and that meant a month of sober evenings honing every flip phrase so that it made a point. 
 Jay was given to grandiloquent rambling, and had to check herself. 
 She spent hours with magazine archives for illustrations, even spent an afternoon in the Royal Horticultural Society library. 
 A deliciously dotty old lady afternoon: the three other researchers there had at least two hundred and fifty years of living between them. 
 Jay had taken her camera to photo the leather-bound treasures of the seventeenth century, where even the language was rounded in sepia sworls, respectful of rhythm, season, nature and wholeness. 
 After three weeks, even she was satisfied. 
 Not a comma out of place. 
 Oh, good child, she teased herself, if only you'd done this at school and art college, you'd have got a first. 
 But she had only ever pulled the stops out for people she loved and respected. 
 One or two teachers and tutors had inspired her. 
 But no one had ever moved her like Lucy. 
 Oh, would she be pleased! 
 Hell, if she wasn't, at least Jay was. 
 A rare feeling. 
 So she hoovered the floor, made a leisurely and politically correct lasagne, whipped egg whites, chilled good wine, luxuriated in the lion-gold tobacco Dionne had brought her from France, wondered about writing to the manufacturers about distribution in England.  
 Only then did she let herself watch the clock to the strains of Beethoven's Apassionata . 
 Oh, to live abroad! 
 But whenever she'd been free to emigrate, she'd fallen in love and put it out of the question. 
 In fact, the day before the I Love Lucy St Patrick's Day, she'd been told of a good job with the British Council in the Gilbert Islands. 
 But why go half-way round the world to find Lady Happiness when She works next door to you? 
 Jay stacked her manuscript and photos, sat with a cigarette and a glass of Pouilly Fum&eacute;, only Lucy needed to complete her freesia-scented scene. 
 Lucy arrived, drained and tight-lipp&eacute;d, Jeremy had been having trouble with his girlfriend, and Lucy had provided the two a.m. shoulder all week. 
 &bquo;Good old mum,&equo; she said, sighing. 
 &bquo;It must be the artistic temperament. 
 His father was &mdash; similar.&equo; 
 Jay rubbed her screaming shoulders. 
 &bquo;Have a drink,&equo; she said. 
 Lucy threw down three glasses in succession like water in the broiling sun. 
 Jay played Satie and waited for when Lucy would stop shaking. 
 She held Lucy's hand still to light her cigarette. 
 &bquo;I shouldn't have come,&equo; said Lucy swiftly. 
 &bquo;I haven't done my bit.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, let's just eat and relax,&equo; said Jay. 
 But while she was setting out plates, a tongue of fury ripped along her spine. 
 So golden boy had flipped &mdash; this week? 
 Lucy had had three weeks before then, and still  done nothing? 
 She tried to think into motherhood, though Jeremy was twenty-five. 
 &bquo;Did you expect this to happen?&equo; she said, as Lucy took small hard bites. 
 She might as well have been eating spam. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Lucy, &bquo;it all blew up last weekend. 
 I thought they were getting on fine.&equo; 
 We had a month, thought Jay, I've worked my ass off  for this exhibition and you've done nothing. 
 Patience, mon vieux, she told herself, the lady's had a hard time. 
 But when she took Lucy's hand and smiled at her, trying to convey some of the warmth she felt, Lucy's lips smiled for a half-second and she took her hand away. 
 Jay's spine spat flame-tipped arrows. 
 &bquo;Show me what you've  done,&equo; said Lucy. 
 Jay shrugged and shoved the pages and photos towards her. 
 &bquo;Listen, we could get going on your bit now,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Couldn't.&equo; 
 Jay wished for telepathy. 
 To her mind, Lucy looked like she could do with a huge warm hug. 
 But had rejected her hand. 
 Was sitting, one knee over her other leg, body language don't touch me . 
 Jay sprawled on the floor, sipped wine, stopped herself grabbing Lucy's grabbable ankles, held herself back. 
 What to do. 
 &bquo;How have you been otherwise?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Oh, busy,&equo; said Lucy. 
 End of subject. 
 &bquo;Is Jeremy still working?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Like a fiend. 
 He said to tell you he'd like to paint you. 
 This will amuse you, he said he liked older women.&equo; 
 &bquo;That gives us something in common,&equo; said Jay. 
 Lucy ignored this. 
 And all too soon the stilted conversation ran out. 
 Jay fell silent, slapped child who doesn't know why. 
 &bquo;It's OK,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;It's just one of those things. 
 It's OK.&equo; 
 You won't touch me, you haven't done a thing for this goddam exhibition you were so all fired up about, and it's OK? 
 Jay became slashingly dykey, rolling one cigarette after another, was unashamedly heterosexist, never raised her voice above a steely drawl, though her throat was screaming with all the things she couldn't say, her body bruised with the feeling of being trivialised. 
 Why  the hell had Lucy come over? 
 What did she want? 
 Did she want to be seduced? 
 Did she want to be loved? 
 She looked so unhappy, Jay didn't know what to do. 
 She knelt in front of Lucy, clasped her hands. 
 &bquo;Lucy, you're with me. 
 It's OK. 
 I love you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know you do. 
 And I must go.&equo; 
 Just that and she was gone. 
 Jay hurled the empty plates at the wall, turned up Millie Jackson on the stereo and stamped back when her neighbours hammered on the ceiling. 
 CHAPTER FOURTEEN 
 Jay borrowed Lucy's pre-occupied indifference for the next little while. 
 As Lucy chatted (work, son) over coffee, a red cloud, just like in the movies and purple fiction, blocked out her sight. 
 Weeks passed. 
 By now, they should have had an outline to present to the sponsors. 
 Which Lucy knew, so why should Jay remind her. 
 &bquo;Darling,&equo; said Francis, &bquo;or should I say Ms. Razorblades, could we attempt lunch?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Only a certain topic is censored, a certain party's name is not to be mentioned.&equo; 
 &bquo;Alleluia!&equo; said Francis, and sparkled like a tinsel waterfall, got Jay laughing and wondering recklessly why she'd ever bothered with the bloody woman. 
 Always she neglected her friends when she was In Love, and regretted it afterwards. 
 But so did they: friends were for fun and solace. 
 Friends were for life. 
 She spent many evenings watching Jamie, whose scathingly political drag show was wowing the entire  circuit. 
 She became taxi driver, purveyor of fine wines, lender of lurex and drag-hag extraordinaire. 
 Alone, she was given to melodramatic sonnet sequences and masturbation. 
 She felt like a fool. 
 Finally, one evening, fighting with the dented lock to her car, she was surprised by Lucy's voice. 
 &bquo;Jay,&equo; she said, with what sounded like pleasure, &bquo;I haven't seen you for ages. 
 What about this exhibition?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, what  about this world-wide exhibition?&equo; said Jay staring Lucy between the eyes. 
 Lucy flushed. 
 &bquo;How angry are you with me?&equo; she said. 
 The right/ wrong question. 
 Shit! 
 Them there eyes! 
 Jay's heart did a Pavlov tattoo. 
 &bquo;I'm angry,&equo; she drawled. 
 &bquo;Don't fuck with me, lady.&equo; 
 &bquo;I deserved that,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry. 
 Let's meet.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah?&equo; said Jay, like who-gives-a-shit. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I am  sorry. 
 I'll come over to you.&equo; 
 As if it was penance. 
 They co-ordinated diaries and Jay congratulated herself on refusing to smile. 
 So Lucy came over. 
 Jay had done wine, and decided, fuck it, there's always a take-away if the bitch is hungry. 
 She did dope all afternoon, spaced out to Nina Simone and Marvin Gaye &mdash; why was there no one better to wank to than Marvin Gaye? &mdash; and decided: OK, LADY, IF WE'RE WORKING, LET'S WORK! 
 The bell rang. 
 Either Lucy was feeling chastened or doing a damn good act that way. 
 She had her introduction for the exhibition and Jay read it like she didn't know who'd written it. 
 It was good, but sparse, abrupt even &mdash; like Lucy? 
 Her lips tightened. 
 &bquo;I have this critical streak,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;If you can stand it,&equo; said Jay and chose her words. 
 &bquo;It's an impersonal thing. 
 You have the substance here but it's too economic. 
 I don't think there's any need to talk  down to people, but you can't assume specialist knowledge.&equo; 
 Lucy looked like a bright little girl, and Jay snapped into the role of brisk helper. 
 She took the bones of Lucy's text, then fleshed them out a little here and there. 
 Flesh. 
 At one point, Lucy's hand brushed hers, and she managed to ignore it. 
 At ten, she made omelettes. 
 The perfect hostess, on her guard. 
 And then it was midnight. 
 Lucy relaxed in an easy chair. 
 Jay poured brandy. 
 &bquo;So that's all done,&equo; murmured Lucy. 
 &bquo;You're very good. 
 I'm sorry about last time. 
 I get scared.&equo; 
 She leaned forward and held Jay's hand. 
 Jay melted, knelt upright and kissed her neck. 
 &bquo;What's killed me,&equo; she breathed, &bquo;is not being able to touch you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've been touching you with my eyes,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Only you wouldn't look at me.&equo; 
 Jay flayed herself for what now appeared gross and hasty: her need for real contact, skin to skin. 
 Because now she was touching Lucy and time stood still. 
 &bquo;I couldn't look at you,&equo; she said, Lucy's fine hands on her shoulders. 
 &bquo;I was so angry. 
 I felt trivialised.&equo; 
 &bquo;Never feel that,&equo; said Lucy, &bquo;Oh, God, I feel like I'm sixteen again. 
 Do you know what I've missed?&equo; 
 Her hands moved over Jay's shoulders. 
 &bquo;I remember holding your breasts,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Last time&hellip;&equo; 
 we stand in the hall, your fabulous eyes searched mine - read my eyes, one last and wonderful caress, shy love, love you are gone into the early morning dark night-rainbows dazzle everywhere you have been 
 &bquo;For God's sake get under my shirt,&equo; said Jay low and urgent, stunned as their lips met, Lucy's tongue shyly exploring her mouth. 
 She ripped her shirt from her  jeans and her hands held Lucy's head like fine porcelain. 
 She eased her shaking hands against the smooth perfection of Lucy's breasts, thumb drawing those soft warm nipples hard and hot. 
 &bquo;But I have to get back,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Jem needs me now.&equo; 
 JEM needs you now? 
 Jem needs you NOW? 
 This boy of yours is twenty-five years old, old enough to father children and break hearts. 
 And just selfish enough to demand that momma bird flies back to the bloody nest &mdash; surely to God not tonight, you can't do this to me, Lucy, I'm going to crack with all this nothing . 
 Jay took a deep breath and nuzzled Lucy's neck. 
 &bquo;You think I don't?&equo; 
 &bquo;I feel safe with you. 
 Give it time,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;It's all so strange. 
 Don't know what's happening. 
 Give me time.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lucy,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;you have all my time.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you,&equo; said Lucy softly, hugged her again and went off into the night. 
 The blessed night, even alone, brought Jay an awareness of her body, as if she were phosphorescent with stars and meteorites. 
 For the first time in all these barren weeks, she wrote poem after poem, cursed that Interflora wasn't a 24-hour service and swore never to doubt again. 
 I love Lucy, she breathed on her eighth orgasm and slept like a loved and wanted baby. 
 CHAPTER FIFTEEN 
 Jay resolved to be a little more eclectic in her renewed passion. 
 This time, no mistakes. 
 She and Lucy would  get out of this one alive, and all in one piece. 
 She spent time with her friends and restricted herself to ten minutes on the perfection of Lucy. 
 Unless she was drunk, when her mouth curled around the delicious pleasure of The Beloved. 
 But she hung on to herself. 
 And since her birthday, she had been seeing more of Dionne than she had for years. 
 It wasn't In Love, they knew each other too well to risk that. 
 But when they met, dinner at home, dinner out, dinner at Dionne's, they had taken to sleeping together, sometimes just that, warmth in Dionne's huge silky bed or hers, and sometimes a deep and wonderful sexual fusion, neither planned nor yearned after. 
 Dionne was between tough young lovers. 
 &bquo;This won't do,&equo; she said to Jay suddenly. 
 &bquo;This is turning into an affaire , darling, and I don't want to. 
 We're both very bad at it and I'm damned if I'm losing my best friend.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought it was OK,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Two old dykes having a little long overdue fun?&equo; 
 &bquo;Jay, honey, no. 
 I've started thinking about you between times. 
 I'm kinda intense, my dear, and I don't want to do that to you. 
 And I've suddenly started to resent those starry eyes of yours and your Lucy. 
 Not seriously, but I know me. 
 Come on, sweetie, what if I started getting it on with one of my baby dykes, what would you feel? 
 We're making a habit of this lovely sex thing, and we're both the type to want more. 
 Pretty damn soon too if we're not careful. 
 Hey?&equo; 
 &bquo;I guess,&equo; said Jay bleakly. 
 Yeah, she'd started to need Dionne, pushed it aside since they were friends, and between friends you could take it for granted, since it was. 
 But surely, she reasoned, where there could be no reason, surely sex doesn't have to bring with it the pain of need, longing, the fear of rejection? 
 Sex for fun? 
 Surely&hellip;?  
 But just as surely, she knew Dionne was right. 
 &bquo;I love touching you,&equo; she said, clinging for a moment. 
 &bquo;Loon, we've always touched. 
 I love fucking with you. 
 Best lover I've ever had and so on. 
 But this isn't &mdash; hell, it isn't in love. 
 And you know it. 
 Against the odds, that's what I want. 
 I want to be In Love. 
 And it isn't you.&equo; 
 And so farewell to that pocket of warmth, thought Jay. 
 It made sense and she didn't like it. 
 While nothing had been expressed it was fine, but words bloody words and a self-conscious constraint was thrust upon them. 
 OK, suppose she was In Love with Dionne. 
 Just suppose. 
 All the movement theorists said you could love more than one person, and had strings of wrecked relationships to prove it. 
 Jay had never known it to work for more than weeks. 
 Then jealousy and anxiety moved in and squatted like diseased vagrants. 
 Conditioning? 
 If it was conditioning it was deep as her bones and marrow. 
 So what was love? 
 Licence to kill? 
 A crime of passion? 
 Licence to allow another person to dictate the rising of the sun, the seasons of the moon? 
 Home, alone, Jay played through the last time Dionne had come over. 
 The last time they'd made love, or would, probably. 
 What would it be like to be In Love with Dionne rather than just loving her? 
 She wrote in her diary, that long-abandoned Chinese embroidered silk book: her unfinished testimony to Lucy. 
 To Lucy? 
 To Dionne? 
 To Love itself.  
 CHAPTER SIXTEEN 
 You come into my room. 
 Oh, pretty woman, walk  my way! 
 More than pretty. 
 Glossy surfers' hair, eyes blue as a robin's egg and a dreamy far-off ocean at dawn. 
 The kind of nose that flirts with the idea of being stroked and kissed and nibbled. 
 Lips holding the promise of an aw-shucks smile, and flirting with every syllable. 
 A chin I could write a prelude about firm and fine over the symphony of your neck. 
 And tho' I know the smooth curve of your naked shoulders, right now, and now it's right, you are wearing a moth-mauve shirt and a chic built-up soap-opera heroine jacket. 
 Memory ignites a garland of fairy lights around the shifting folds of fabric, teases me knowing your nipples' strawberry centre, the soft heat of your naked breasts. 
 You delight my eyes; your voice delights my ears; your being here thrills me. 
 It's a Saturday night, the night that's all right for late and mega-high for Sunday is a day of rest and you've chosen to spend this Saturday night &mdash; let me not presume! &mdash; evening, with me. 
 And a whole lot more besides&hellip; 
 We drink brandy filled with lazy sunshine. 
 You talk to me. 
 I listen and like. 
 Very much. 
 You are the only woman I know &mdash; apart from Lucy &mdash; who wears skirts and dresses and make-up and turns me on more powerful than a monsoon with all the steam and heat&hellip; 
 And tonight, oh my elegant darling, your skirt is a rainbow of shimmering gold and mauve and tan and cerise. 
 Lying across your knees like a maharani's scarf.  
 I conjure an Ethiopian slave to fan you with peacock feathers. 
 Of course you wear black &mdash; stockings? 
 I hope so! &mdash; or maybe tights. 
 Who gives a damn, certainly not me, caressing your lovely legs with my eyes. 
 Which you probably know. 
 Probably like. 
 A lot. 
 I concentrate on your face and say something back to you. 
 But when you talk I stray back to your ankles in a fantasy of exploring there with my tongue. 
 Your feet are a mystery in shoes that look like velvet, look like suede, fit you and enhance you and tantalise my warm mouth with desire every time you move your toes. 
 Your hands are playing with the glass I gave you. 
 Sparkle fine and curving like I remember your breasts in my hands. 
 Well, it would  be kinda fun to suck your fingers and take me a mouth-walk on the planet of your palms&hellip; 
 When I offer you champagne you laugh in a way that only you have, like a stream all at once a delighted cascade into this deep swirling pool of warm humour. 
 &bquo;You are naughty !&equo; you say, spacing your words with a gleam in your wise-sky eyes, &bquo;OK. 
 Let's drink a bottle of champagne&hellip;&equo; 
 Well, I kinda knew you'd say that, but had forgotten the unique thrill of the way only you can say things. 
 I don't know why we drink so much and come up smelling of roses. 
 I don't know why we drink so much. 
 I don't know why we drink. 
 I don't know why we&hellip; the hell I don't! 
 And you are laughing again, shaking your head, it's what's-happening-I-don't-believe-this-honey time again. 
 What amazes me, apart from the instant MGM jungle scenery that leaps out of the walls the minute you walk in, the way the carpet has become an over the rainbow poppy field, only it's rose petals, what amazes me is we don't run out of things to say.  
 Well I guess we have a lot to catch up on, like the whole of our lives seeing as we finally got to say hello to each other only years ago. 
 I have this urge to snow you my childhood stamp collection, just that I don't have one. 
 Time lilts by on the jazz schmaltz I adore, memories, blues and brandy. 
 You start off being coy about drinking brandy. 
 What the hell did I get it for &mdash; to have it sit on the fucking shelf? 
 Much rather see you drink. 
 And much much much much rather feed you brandy with my mouth which hasn't done so much smiling since I was knee-high to a grasshopper and didn't know just how much fun this life could be. 
 BUT Let us not forget Let us not Oh, let's&hellip;? 
 I feel totally new world extravagant around you. 
 You are drunk and so am I and in bed you turn your back to sleep. 
 Do you really imagine that your back is less inspiring than your front? 
 I'd happily joyously ecstatically fuck your eyebrows, darlin'. 
 As it happens. 
 And I can't and won't hold back when you grind your sensational ass against me, a woman is only human. 
 You tell me to seduce you when you're sober, sweetheart, I'll take a chance on now. 
 I want to kiss you like a butterfly on mescaline, all over in a flurry of delirium, I want to bite you to the bones, to be so close to you there materialises a planet called us. 
 I adore fucking you. 
 Feel it's what I was born for. 
 Everything in me shoots high like a hot spring, like the fourth of July when my fingers meet your flowing cunt, my face twisted in an agony of pleasure. 
 Inside you I feel dizzy like a tango, the rose of your breast between my teeth. 
 Inside you, inside you, I can never get enough  of being inside you, makes me break apart, clench my teeth, drag breath so deep my head spins. 
 It's nothing to do with coming, it's everything to do with intoxication, flesh-frenzy, reckless rampant effervescent fever. 
 Coming is easy, roundabouts and swings, and fucking you is a big dipper with no brakes flying out across a midnight ocean under a chandelier of stars. 
 You say it's not OK just to take, darling, angel, siren, demon, goddess, fucking you fucking canonises me. 
 And then you plunge into me, my spine shatters and floats in hyperspace, and I know &mdash; don't know what it is, but it is. 
 I like, too, like very much, like a drowning person likes  the feel of solid ground on their delirious tide-washed body. 
 I LIKE that you tell me about it, your flesh impatient with words, you say: go inside me &mdash; yeah &mdash; yeah &mdash; no &mdash; more &mdash; and your body whiplashes head to toe, the ill-appreciated G spot, baby you got it. 
 In the morning you smoke. 
 I smoke. 
 We have to talk, you say. 
 I just knew this had to be coming. 
 I groan and hide my head in your side. 
 Sure we need to talk, and we also will do pretty fine without. 
 But we do talk and what I know is you are essentially a decent and totally wonderful human being and I'll hang around a long time for you. 
 You dress. 
 It's a crying shame to cover up your body. 
 I want to hold you, want to make love with you, you know and we don't and I still feel OK. 
 Fully dressed, midnight butterfly in this light of day, we hold each other, grind, baby, grind so I could take a chunk out of your neck by way of breakfast. 
 I drive you home. 
 Wish I had a primrose-yellow  
 Hispano-Suiza, with a chauffeur to take you  home. 
 Stop the car. 
 You kiss me, your lips so tender and sensuous I don t want to go. 
 So what else is new? 
 I release my safety belt to hold you, dangerous ground, ground where my feet have wings of flame. 
 Is it OK, you say, are you really pissed off that I have to get home? 
 Well, now, my dear, I hadn't thought of that. 
 Am I pissed off? 
 No, I'm not. 
 Tell you if I was I wouldn't see you. 
 Which is true. 
 Actually true. 
 Goddawmighty! 
 Lady Jay the Impetuous discovers an instinct for a smidgeon of dignity! 
 So I drive back, pig out on a hi-cal breakfast, devour Sunday paper trash, wander home, hug the pillow you lay on, find a blonde hair or two, grin like an idiot, realise my hangover's gone, work like a trooper all afternoon, sip a little brandy come early evening, and raise my glass to your very good health. 
 my dear  Dionne&hellip; 
 CHAPTER SEVENTEEN 
 In fact, there were signs of ending and unease in what she had written. 
 Dumb shit, Jay, always wise after the non-event! 
 And why had she and Dionne never fallen In Love? 
 Perhaps it would have been too easy: they'd made love the first night they met, both involved with women who gave them pain. 
 Then on, they'd got it on from time to happy time, eaten together every week, seen movies, theatre, films, drag, done disco, reggae, boogie&hellip; 
 Why not fall in love with someone you  actually like  and feel easy with? 
 Jay was now In Love with the impossible Lucy, Dionne went for butch crewcut teenagers, and they hugged each other's hurt away and made love like some people offer Kleenex and brandy in times of stress. 
 And after that evening when Dionne said &bquo;it&equo; was over, they had some undoing to go through, so near the edge of agony and ecstasy. 
 They treated each other more carefully than friends usually do, chose each other little gifts, tiny wooden ducks from China, sprays of silk roses, jazz collectors' tapes. 
 One time, Dionne brought Jay a huge bunch of plaited purple garlic from the Breton onion man who hung around in Islington from time to time. 
 Jay brought Dionne honeycomb cell shaped soap and an oil and sand picture with its ever-changing magic. 
 Treasure to the treasured. 
 At least she and Dionne knew how precious they were to each other. 
 &bquo;It's a shame, dear,&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;I hoped you two silly dykes had realised Nirvana, but here you are, alone and palely loitering for the love of your Lucy-o! 
 And Dionne! 
 You've seen the latest? 
 Dear, they were down at the Paradise the other night&hellip; looks serious.&equo; 
 No, Jay had not seen the latest. 
 &bquo;What's she like?&equo; 
 Goddam it, yes, she was jealous. 
 Jealous. 
 Jealous? 
 She wanted Dionne to have the best, oh yeah, Jay, and is that you? 
 Just that she'd seen Dionne so often sad and unsure. 
 And laughing and ecstatic in her arms. 
 And the bloody rest of it. 
 &bquo;Well, dear,&equo; said Francis, considering, &bquo;she must be at least &mdash; twelve? 
 Head to toe black leather, and I believe she has a ring through her nose. 
 Which is considered a sign of beauty in certain parts of the globe. 
 The little mouth was born with a scowl, the brows positively  beetle  over the turned-up be-ringed breathing apparatus. 
 And Dionne is enraptured.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sounds like a clone of Studs,&equo; said Jay. 
 Studs had been Dionne's last Big Romance. 
 She'd moved in on and in with Dionne, spitting scorn at her friends, slurring drunk at parties. 
 Jamie called her Ug the Cavewoman, Francis had tried talking with her on many occasions: 
 &bquo;Only I do find monosyllables wearing, dear!&equo; 
 Dionne went for the outlaw type, or so she said, then mothered and civilised them until they were unrecognisable, and when her dream of civilised and raunchy equality went out the slammed door, there she was alone again, smoking a little more than usual, drinking a little more than necessary and swearing herself to celibacy until the next sulky brow slouched into view and stole her hopeful heart away. 
 And this one Francis named Piggy-wig. 
 Jay visited the new m&eacute;nage. 
 Piggy-wig was in the kitchen, Dionne opened a bottle of white wine and they sat in the elegant grey-blue lounge. 
 Crashes and curses off stage. 
 &bquo;Do join us, Sandy,&equo; called Dionne. 
 &bquo;Can't work your fucking washing machine, can I?&equo; said Piggy-wig, gulping lager in the doorway and strutting out again. 
 &bquo;At least you're not doing her washing,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Cheers!&equo; 
 &bquo;And how's Lucy?&equo; said Dionne. 
 &bquo;Touch&eacute;,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Well, we're meeting next week, hopefully to really get this show on the road. 
 We had lunch the other day. 
 Even held hands over coffee.&equo; 
 &bquo;I feel I'm free-falling, Jay,&equo; said Lucy, her hand light and warm in Jay's. 
 &bquo;I don't know what's happening.&equo; 
 &bquo;You think I do?&equo; said Jay. 
 And their eyes met.  
 Saint Jay re-adjusted her halo as the Queen of Heaven drove away. 
 &bquo;What's this?&equo; said Piggy-wig, straddling a chair with the triumph of one who has mistressed a Zanussi automatic. 
 The finishing touch would have been brylcreem only she was wearing it anyway. 
 &bquo;Jay's In Love with an impossible woman,&equo; said Dionne conversationally. 
 &bquo;Straight?&equo; said Piggy-wig. 
 &bquo;So far,&equo; said Jay. 
 She had no wish to discuss Lucy around this stranger. 
 &bquo;How long have you been in love then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, about three months,&equo; said Jay lightly. 
 Five months, three weeks, four days&hellip; 
 None of your goddam business! 
 &bquo;I couldn't put up with that,&equo; said Piggy-wig. 
 &bquo;Three months! 
 What's her sign?&equo; 
 &bquo;Gemini,&equo; said Jay. 
 Piggy-wig shook her head knowingly. 
 &bquo;You'd better jump on her.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm Gemini, Sandy,&equo; said Dionne. 
 &bquo;That's what I mean, babe.&equo; 
 This time she grinned. 
 Jay suddenly saw: there was a pixie smile in the tough young eyes. 
 Underneath all the leatherado, she was shy as hell and pleased as Punch with Dionne. 
 Sandy. 
 Not Piggy-wig. 
 Friends can never love each other's lovers, but if our friends are happy? 
 So be it. 
 &bquo;I'm off up the pub, babes,&equo; said Sandy, ruffling Dionne's hair. 
 &bquo;Let you two have a good old gossip. 
 Bye.&equo; 
 She bent and kissed Dionne and slammed out of the flat. 
 &bquo;Isn't she sweet?&equo; said Dionne. 
 &bquo;Hard work, Dionne.&equo; 
 &bquo;And Lucy's easy?&equo;  
 CHAPTER EIGHTEEN 
 For Jay, many things in life had been easy, a walk-over,; she had leapt over and through the academic hurdles and hoops of childhood and teenage with a lazy facility that she only realised later. 
 Sailed through college, picked up academic jargon like a duckling gobbles worms. 
 No, Lucy was not easy and so she loved her. 
 Or: she loved Lucy and so she was not easy; she was not at ease. 
 For their next meeting, the enticing mirage of a global exhibition fuelled by their energy, she slowed down and prepared a seduction dinner. 
 Just in case. 
 Glamorous food was a challenge she had set herself and won. 
 Grating ginger, Phoebe Snow on the stereo thank you but I'm just lookin  ', sipping wine, a wry smile damping her forest fire, she thought, at least we'll have a good meal. 
 Good? 
 Jay was into labour-intensive food for The Beloved. 
 Only this beloved never seemed to notice. 
 Jay summed up for herself. 
 Kissing was OK. 
 Usually. 
 Both she and Lucy seemed to have some kind of thing for breasts. 
 Hum. 
 That was all she knew  about Lucy sexually. 
 So far. 
 Oh, to hell and be spontaneous! 
 She concentrated on the culinary. 
 She knew what to do there. 
 First there was Caribbean sea-food, a trip to Brixton,  fresh limes, hand-ground spices, fresh coriander, hot-juiced ginger, a sloosh of Barbados rum. 
 Shoppin' in endless malls, waitin' for phone calls&hellip; 
 She changed Phoebe Snow for Fela Anakupalo Kuti, a dive into Desmond's Hip City&hellip; 
 Then came a salad, forty luscious shades of biting green and purple, roasted sesame seeds, toasted sunflower seeds, walnut oil and red wine vinegar. 
 And hazelnut stuffed aubergines, mozzarella cheese, parmesan, the tiniest button mushrooms she could find. 
 Zombie no go unless you tell im to go 
 The Communards. 
 And then meringues, liqueur whipped cream and crushed raspberries from Andalucia. 
 Pretty damn good, Jay! 
 And she had laid in Greek brandy and pink champagne for old times' sake. 
 Her  fond memories anyway, and what did Lucy think? 
 Would she ever know? 
 Maybe next time you'll wear a pink carnation/ so I can recognise you &mdash; hooo! 
 Said Sarah Jane Morris. 
 Ding-dong, said the bell. 
 Licketty-split, said Jay's feet. 
 Boom-bang-a-bang-booooooom! said Jay's heart. 
 Come on in! said Jay. 
 Lucy's mood had rallied. 
 Her eyes were sparkling, cheeks flushed, body clad in a sea-green that lit the depths of her eyes, her beautiful eyes. 
 And she produced a sheaf of exhibition papers with a flourish; she'd even written some of the wording to go under the photos. 
 Neat and brilliant! 
 And she loved the stills Jay had dug out; her lovely lips tasted the Melina Mercounand she raised her glass to Jay. 
 The air relaxed to Pergolesi, Purcell, Bach. 
 Work raced by like a thrilling dirt-track race, food finished with relish and grace, they sat holding hands,  warmth flowing like the water in a fantastic Escher waterfall. 
 Kissed very gently. 
 Ms Piggy-wig, Sandy the winner, had said jump on her ! 
 Hah! 
 What did she know, rhapsodised Jay into Lucy's neck. 
 Be cool, be natural. 
 But as they sank to the floor, naturally, Jay sensed a tension in Lucy. 
 Easy, she told herself, easy. 
 Lucy sat up abruptly and lit a cigarette. 
 &bquo;Sorry,&equo; she said, 'I just&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Need some time?&equo; said Jay, sure and warm like her heartbeat. 
 &bquo;Mm.&equo; 
 &bquo;Darling,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;if time is what we need, let's take it. 
 Let's do that weekend, Lucy. 
 I want time with you. 
 You know it. 
 I believe you want it too. 
 Get your goddam diary and let's make a date.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't have my diary with me,&equo; said Lucy, sipping wine and suddenly distracted. 
 Jay sighed from her guts. 
 What was it? 
 Did Lucy think of herself as that heterosexually convenient phenomenon, the &bquo;non-orgasmic woman&equo;; had sex been awful for her? 
 Jump on her ! 
 How the hell do you jump on a Lucy, a lady, a Lucy, someone who appears fragile as glass, goes warm and soft like a trusting animal in your arms, then tough as steel with her polished NO &mdash;? 
 &bquo;Do you want  to have a weekend with me? 
 I feel sort of fixed that it would be the best thing&hellip; you know it would.&equo; 
 In a rush, Lucy said: &bquo;I came here tonight hoping you'd got over me.&equo; 
 &bquo;What? 
 Got over you? 
 I can never get over you, Lucy. 
 I love you.&equo; 
 Lucy held her close. 
 Christ, thought Jay. 
 I'm paralysed. 
 But galvanised herself in the heat to tease away Lucy's shirt, work her jeans loose, kneaded her stomach, breathe fire into her breasts.  
 Lucy buried her face in Jay's neck, moaned into her mouth. 
 &bquo;I love you, Jay,&equo; she said, voice breaking on &bquo;you&equo;. 
 &bquo;There you are, I've said it. 
 I love you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm so glad,&equo; whispered Baby Jay, cherub wings fluttering rose-pink ecstasy, &bquo;So glad. 
 Darling. 
 Let's go to bed.&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 I have to go home,&equo; said Lucy, as if torn. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; said Jay wildly. 
 &bquo;Why? 
 Your damn son?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I have to be up early in the morning. 
 &bquo;I don't understand,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I just don't understand.&equo; 
 She pulled away and gave herself some time rolling and lighting a cigarette. 
 Lucy's hand moved through her hair and she clenched her teeth against the tantalising sensation. 
 &bquo;Jay, you're shaking,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Sexual arousal, darling,&equo; said Jay, brittle, agonised. 
 &bquo;And you're a woman,&equo; said Lucy &mdash; wonderingly? 
 &bquo;Yeah, lady. 
 I'm a woman and so are you. 
 Lucy?&equo; 
 It was going to be sheer pain to say it, but acid agony to hold it in. 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 Lucy's hand was shaky against her cheek. 
 &bquo;If I was a man, I believe you'd be having an affair with me. 
 Is that true?&equo; 
 Lucy said nothing. 
 Her hand was still. 
 &bquo;Because if it is, you really should look at that,&equo; said Jay, letting the slow words hold her terror. 
 &bquo;You really should. 
 Give us some time. 
 A weekend &mdash; we both work, there's no time in the week. 
 I don't want to rush this. 
 For chrissake, you said you love me. 
 Say it. 
 What am I supposed to do? 
 Jump on you?&equo; 
 Oh, shit! 
 Lucy was crying. 
 Oh oh oh oh SHIT! 
 &bquo;Darling, Lucy, I'm sorry, darling,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;but I'm this bloody dyke, dear, oh dear Lucy, I don't understand.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just I know you've been busy and enjoying your  friends. 
 I've been really glad about that. 
 Maybe I'm not the one for you.&equo; 
 Distractions, distractions, squirt chilli juice in a wounded elephant's eye&hellip; 
 &bquo;Lucy, for the love of God,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;it's you . 
 You. 
 I want you. 
 I love you. 
 Stay with me. 
 Now, And if you can't right now, then come away with me. 
 Give us a chance. 
 You know you want to.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know what to do,&equo; said Lucy, hiding her face, tears pouring through her clenched fingers. 
 &bquo;You'll have to decide for both of us.&equo; 
 &bquo;OK,&equo; said Jay, wrapping her arms around Lucy, suddenly so tiny, &bquo;I'll tell you. 
 If you have to go home now, and I wish you wouldn't, then call me tomorrow and give me a date. 
 OK?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll call you tomorrow,&equo; said Lucy, then she whispered, &bquo;Only I may not be able to give you a date.&equo; 
 Jay wanted to say then don't bother calling . 
 But she didn't have the nerve. 
 And she drunk herself to sleep. 
 No more thoughts. 
 And Lucy called her in the morning, swept away all doubts with a rush of enthusiasm about the exhibition, and only when they'd hung up did Jay realise that she hadn't given her a date, a time; that she &mdash; they ? &mdash; were just where they'd been five months before. 
 She was richer only by stolen kisses and the rhapsody her tongue had played over Lucy's breasts.  
 CHAPTER NINETEEN 
 &bquo;How were Dionne and Piggy-wig?&equo; said Francis, yawning over the first coffee of the day. 
 &bquo;Her name's Sandy,&equo; said Jay shortly. 
 From time to time she had to pull him up. 
 Because he never meant bitchiness, because he was kind like all good people who've been hurt, he never minded. 
 &bquo;Sorry, darling. 
 I stand corrected. 
 She's got the seal of approval, I take it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Francis, shut up. 
 She's OK. 
 I wouldn't choose her, but then I'm not exactly the legend of taste and discretion.&equo; 
 Sometimes, like now, she wondered if Francis knew what it was be in love. 
 His raptures over pretty strangers and their come-hither designer clothes were as over-the-top as his enthusiasm for a new cocktail. 
 She looked at him. 
 &bquo;OK, Mr Tolerance, sorry yourself. 
 I'm just an old bitch. 
 But, Francis, seriously, have you ever been In Love, like a big one?&equo; 
 &bquo;Darling,&equo; he said, folding one long leg over the other, sweeping his glasses to the desk, &bquo;I have been in love most of my life. 
 As to &bquo;a big one&equo;, dear, what a thing to say to an ageing queen! 
 I suppose you mean an all-consuming I-will-do-anything-for-you passion? 
 Is Lucy giving you more of a hard time? 
 She's terribly good at it, isn't she? 
 Dare I say give it up? 
 That phrase rings in my dyke agony uncle ears constantly. 
 Wasted on you of course.&equo; 
 But Jay wanted more.  
 &bquo;Come on, Francis, you've side-stepped my question with your habitual &eacute;lan, it's confession time. 
 Francis In Love.&equo; 
 Francis lit a cigarette. 
 &bquo;Honey, don't let me commence ! 
 As Saint Truman Capote says &mdash; do you know that story? 
 One of his marvellous women, when anyone asks her anything about herself, she just rolls out that line&hellip; 
 Honey, don't let me commence ! 
 It says it all. 
 I was madly in love once, darling. 
 And for a while, so was he. 
 We were very &agrave; deux, and I was the hoover and windolene queen. 
 I would not let him eat anything canned or frozen, I spoilt him to pieces. 
 I was down the market every day with my shopper, dear, for veg. 
 I can spot a cheap cauli at a hundred paces. 
 Oh, it was heaven.&equo; 
 &bquo;And?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, isn't she a prurient little dyke, pull &mdash; ease!&equo; he said, rolling his eyes. 
 &bquo;Well, it went off. 
 Just that. 
 He wanted an open relationship after a while which meant him bringing bits of trade back and then saying couldn't we be just sisters? 
 I am a jealous, possessive sodden Kleenex style bitch when in love. 
 I did not feel sisterly. 
 He left.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about now? 
 I mean, you should be with someone wonderful.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you so much. 
 Well, darling, I do want to be In Love. 
 Of course I do. 
 What else is there? 
 But I'm not exactly a chicken any more, dear. 
 I am rapidly turning into a ghastly old queen ogling rent boys. 
 The day they expect me to pay for it, I shall retire. 
 In Love, in love, Oh Love! 
 I'm just rather despairing about it happening. 
 I want it to. 
 I live in hope. 
 I'd adore it, but time is fleeting. 
 I refuse to sit at home with my needlepoint, dear. 
 Meanwhile, I take what I can get: safe sex with a bit of clean trade. 
 I'm not proud. 
 Miss Proud left home with my Big Romance. 
 It's better than nothing.&equo;  
 &bquo;Hum,&equo; said Jay, at least that way you don't get your heart broken . 
 &bquo;Well, hmm, Camille?&equo; 
 &bquo;Let's go have a drink,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;It's five to eleven.&equo; 
 In the pub, red plush and genteel fake gas globes, Francis loaded the juke box. 
 &bquo;Since you appear to be doing a thesis on True Romance,&equo; he said, smiling. 
 &bquo;Country and Western, Francis?&equo; 
 &bquo;Get the lyrics, dear!&equo; 
 I done bought her a di'mond ring, 
 An' a purdy rose-trimmed hat, 
 Sat out under th' moonlight, 
 Kissin' an' huggin' an' all or that, 
 An &bquo;yuh know whut she done, 
 Gone an &bquo;ended mah fun &mdash;? 
 She took my heart and squashed the sucker flat. 
 &bquo;There you have it,&equo; said Francis, &bquo;so eloquent. 
 And now let us pass on to Lucy &mdash; we have forty minutes until Happy Hour.&equo; 
 Jay giggled as Patsy Cline went walkin' after midnight, searchin' for yee-ew ! 
 &bquo;Honey, don't let me commence !&equo; she said. 
 CHAPTER TWENTY 
 More days and weeks went by. 
 This year seemed to be full of them. 
 These sun and moon hour and minute and second sections of time. 
 Went by. 
 Went by without Lucy, each dark and light portion of time acquired a date and name only when they met. 
 For example: June 7th, midday, or June 5th, 5.30. 
 To focus still further,  corridor of work and car park. 
 Duration of meaningful contact, two and a half minutes, fifteen minutes. 
 Yo, Jay, have yourself a wallow! 
 Lucy was treating Jay like a delightful new acquaintance she couldn't quite place or fit into her life. 
 Jay cursed that she was so pleased with the crumbs of comfort: coffee, a drink, a phonecall. 
 Almost a month went by before she allowed herself an evening to realise that there was at the very least and latest, an unfinished conversation between them. 
 And Lucy was blithely or otherwise ignoring that fact. 
 Lucy couldn't find time to come over for an evening; the globally significant exhibition was floating on some remote iceberg; Jeremy had an agent, an opening; Lucy's sister was ill and needed her (Jay recalled Lucy's exasperated indifference to her sister); the painters were coming. 
 Busy busy busy. 
 GODDAM IT! 
 If you want to see someone, none of these things stand in the way! 
 Thought Jay. 
 For the first time, she turned Lucy down for lunch. 
 She would not be squeezed in. 
 Or out. 
 When Lucy suggested a quick drink, Jay was cut to the quick and described herself, with sparse and ironic regret, as &bquo;working late&equo;. 
 And was out every night, so much that Lucy actually said: I've called you !, her glorious eyes questioning, troubled green, burning brown. 
 &bquo;Been busy,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;You're still angry with me, Jay. 
 Look, there's lot of things I just can't handle.&equo; 
 Won't. 
 &bquo;Let's talk,&equo; said Lucy. 
 Jay toyed with being busy. 
 Again. 
 Easy enough to fill her empty time, time without love, without Lucy. 
 She looked polite.  
 &bquo;How about next Wednesday,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I'll come over about six. 
 I'll have to go at nine.&equo; 
 How convenient. 
 &bquo;Mm,&equo; she said, wordless at how she couldn't spit out that furious NO! 
 At Art College, she'd had a friend whose catch phrase when asked for a date, was: How about next July, I seem to have a Wednesday free. 
 Oh, to be flip, oh not to care! 
 For that evening &mdash; Yah! three lousy hours ! &mdash; she laid in white wine and gin. 
 Before, during, after. 
 She lived in hope and dread. 
 We have to talk ? 
 Hmmmmmmmmmm. 
 Since Lucy had said it, then let her talk. 
 Jay had poured a million words her way with little response. 
 Let Lucy  articulate, lay herself on whatever uncomfortable line it was that she had elected to draw. 
 Just for once. 
 Enter Lucy, pale, tight-jawed, polite, smile not reaching her eyes. 
 Two glasses of wine. 
 Pouring rain and flat grey sky outside. 
 Did Lucy sense? 
 What did Lucy sense? 
 What was the sense? 
 Jesus, what was this aching nonsense? 
 Well, said Lucy. 
 We &mdash; ell, drawled Jay. 
 We are not going to have an affair , said Lucy, hand shaking a little on her cigarette. 
 She gulped wine and set her glass down firm as a full stop. 
 Period, full stop, as Dionne would say. 
 Jay trembled and clamped her teeth together on a chill sip of wine, the kiss of alcohol meaningless on the tight-lipped blues. 
 She felt cornered, counted out by this cool precision, fighting for something which had given every sign of gracious flowering&hellip; from time to time . 
 She forced herself to admit the words. 
 But no less for that? 
 Surely?  
 &bquo;Look,&equo; she said, unable to meet Lucy's eyes, then unable to look away, &bquo;you kissed me. 
 More than once. 
 Didn't you like  that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, yes,&equo; said Lucy, as if brushing ash from her skirt. 
 &bquo;But that's got nothing to do with it&hellip;&equo; 
 She took a tight breath and stared at her knee. 
 Then said, as if reading from an autocue: 
 &bquo;I am not going to have an affair with you. 
 We're working together now, there's the exhibition and all those projects, Jay. 
 &bquo;Don't you want to?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not going to. 
 It's my decision. 
 It's nothing to do with you.&equo; 
 Oh, God, thought Jay, I can't bear it. 
 Maybe for ten years would be better than no. 
 And she knew  how urgent and fervent their kisses had been, how close Lucy had been to abandoning whatever it was that held her back, made her withhold her beautiful body. 
 I cannot bear it . 
 I will not take no unless I know she really means it, as strongly as she kissed me. 
 &bquo;I really don't want to close this off,&equo; she said, grinding her cigarette to ash and frayed tobacco. 
 &bquo;I've kissed you and more, and none of that lightly, and you know, and I know, that it would be so good &mdash; for Chrissake,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Screw all that work and exhibition shit, I want you .&equo; 
 &bquo;I was afraid you'd say that,&equo; said Lucy, &bquo;Oh, God.&equo; 
 Oh shit, thought Jay. 
 &bquo;But it's true,&equo; she said aloud, forcing her eyes to focus on the middle distance. 
 'I've got a job. 
 In perpetuo, as Francis says, if only because no one else would be fool enough to do it. 
 I'm only doing the other stuff to be with you. 
 A job is a job. 
 You sell your time for money to have a better time in the unsold hours. 
 Lucy, I'm in love with you like I've never been with anyone before. 
 No one  moves me like you. 
 And you&hellip; you're sitting there breaking my fucking heart.&equo; 
 She bit back the unwordable sweet pain of when Lucy had whispered: I love you, I love you, there you are &hellip; 
 And what had she said, stunned by her apocalyptic vision of lovely Lucy, Lucy in love with her? 
 From another life, she heard herself: I'm so glad so glad . 
 She put her head on the table and wept. 
 Jay with no ace in the hole. 
 Death Row. 
 No stay of execution. 
 She heard Lucy's chair scrape and felt her arms round her shoulders. 
 From her ice age, she wrenched herself to turn and wrap both arms round Lucy's waist, her pounding head butting against the soft silk of her blouse. 
 Hold tight , said Lucy, suddenly mummy. 
 Jay gripped, burrowed her head in Lucy's belly: here so safe and wanted inside her beloved Jeremy had grown; her brow nudged Lucy's breasts, where Jeremy had sucked himself full and strong, where she had found a contentment warm as summer wind across white sands; here she had swum easy as a seal, crystal seas halcyon over her head. 
 She trembled at the razor-sharp sleet of misery: losing Lucy. 
 Lucy's firm small hand cupped her chin and drew her face upwards. 
 Those eyes, troubled and wet, those eyes, Lucy's glorious eyes. 
 Jesus, thought Jay, I must look a mess, careful enhancing make-up at the school of Cherry Morello smeared everywhere. 
 And this mess of me is what I want her to love. 
 God, I'm doing this all wrong, I've done all this wrong. 
 Lucy's beautiful face was agonised. 
 She sat down again, poured herself and Jay more wine; it flooded Jay's mouth and throat, cloying, choking like foul water. 
 &bquo;I know you're in love with me,&equo; said Lucy, making a neat mound of cigarette ash, firming her hand against  shaking, &bquo;and I said it before, and I'll say it here and now. 
 I do love you. 
 I'm not in love  with you &mdash; there's a difference.&equo; 
 Yeah, thought Jay, as if wading through cement, let's be semantic, let's forget the way our eyes met, the way our bodies clung so hungrily together. 
 Lucy said: 
 &bquo;I just don't want to mess up your life. 
 I want you to make something of it. 
 I don't want you to drop this exhibition, think what it could do for you. 
 And all these projects &mdash; you could really go places.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I don't give a goddam. 
 I want to be your lover. 
 And I believe you want  that as well. 
 I know you're scared of it, fuck it, you said you felt safe with me. 
 And have I ever pushed you? 
 Have I?&equo; 
 Suddenly she was furious and jabbed out: 
 &bquo;And I'll mess up my own life if I want to, that's not your problem. 
 I didn't ask to fall in love with you, but by God, lady, I have, and I have every reason to believe you want to as well.&equo; 
 &bquo;I am not going to,&equo; said Lucy vehemently. 
 &bquo;Don't you understand? 
 I'm trying to be clear. 
 And this is my decision. 
 For me. 
 I want to be honest. 
 I came here to try and be clear with you. 
 I could have said anything, made an excuse, but I wanted to be straight and it's only making things worse.&equo; 
 Lucy wept, her hand against her face, wiped her eyes as more tears came. 
 Jay so wanted to make it better, but how? 
 With the awfulness of Lucy crying, still she was furious. 
 Goddam it to held lady, you've been straight all your life. 
 I am the only woman you've felt like this about, the only woman you've kissed and caressed this way. 
 And you're forty something and straight and divorced and celibate and a mother and I couldn't have found a more complicated situation to fall in love with. 
 And I bet no  man has ever appreciated the lava flow of sensuality so near your ice-perfect surface. 
 Jay'd had enough men to know they treat a woman's body with anything from contempt and rage to inept uncertainty and fear; once in a blue moon only, with real fascination and tenderness. 
 But there's never the sure intuition that lies between women, welds them together. 
 Like home, like the home you dream of, where people accept you and love you just the way you are. 
 She knew with her first woman, when she was twenty. 
 And Lucy was forty something&hellip; no! 
 She put a clamp on thinking into Lucy's whys and wherefores. 
 Let there be an end to this self-searching monologue. 
 Let Lucy say for herself what was on her mind. 
 &bquo;I'm so sorry,&equo; she said, &bquo;sorry you're crying.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're crying too,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;It's just I see all this pain and shit, and it's all my fault.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bullshit,&equo; said Jay gently, and put her arms round Lucy's shoulders. 
 &bquo;Bullshit. 
 There's two of us here.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm forty-eight,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;So fucking what?&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;You said you felt like a teenager when you kissed me.&equo; 
 &bquo; NO! 
 LISTEN TO ME ! 
 I'm forty-eight. 
 I have a career. 
 I have a highly talented son who, right or wrong, I have committed myself to. 
 It's just not going to work.&equo; 
 You have a lot to lose, thought Jay, rolling a cigarette, and you know damn well you might have to, or at least turn it all upside down if you let yourself fall in love with me. 
 &bquo;I still think you'd be having an affair with me if I was a man,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Jay, you're a very seductive woman,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Not seductive enough, obviously,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;What do you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, why aren't you seduced?&equo;  
 &bquo;Jay, Jay, it's not that. 
 It's not you. 
 It's me. 
 Why don't you find someone else?&equo; 
 &bquo;Who? 
 Who else is there? 
 It's you I want, you turn me on, darling.&equo; 
 Lucy managed a laugh shattered like a dropped mirror. 
 &bquo;Christ,&equo; she said, &bquo;What a pair. 
 At least we can laugh. 
 I don't know why I'm laughing.&equo; 
 Jay laughed too, but unease and bitterness slammed a full stop and left her chill and foolish. 
 &bquo;Desperation, I guess,&equo; she said, &bquo;because I'm only too aware that you're going soon, back to play happy families with Jeremy. 
 There's never any time, Lucy, you've got to give it real time. 
 I don't accept this No, I just don't believe you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, oh God, Jay, you're a hard woman.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; said Jay, irony permitting a hah! of laughter. 
 &bquo;They don't call me bitch for nothing. 
 I've worked for this title. 
 Lucy &mdash; give us  a weekend.&equo; 
 &bquo;I just don't know,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Well, I do,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Marry me, Lucy, eh?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've been married,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;'Samatter with you? 
 You don't do things twice? 
 Marry me.&equo; 
 She knew all at once that the measured time, the false normality of banter, everything led to an end she dreaded. 
 Lucy stood to go. 
 &bquo;I'm aware that I'm leaving you on your own,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Like you said, happy families. 
 What will you do when I'm gone, back to my safe life?&equo; 
 As if she cared! 
 &bquo;Get drunk,&equo; said Jay crudely. 
 &bquo;Who gives a shit.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll make you some tea,&equo; said Lucy. 
 Mother I don't need &mdash; the one who brought me up cost a lot in therapy to get over. 
 &bquo;I won't drink it,&equo; said Jay, tears gushing hot down her  cheeks. 
 &bquo;I'm going to get drunk, to hell, I've been half drunk half my life, who gives a fuck if I'm drunk again? 
 At least that way I can stop thinking, words bloody words.&equo; 
 Lucy made tea. 
 Jay sat back and crossed her arms. 
 &bquo;Drink it yourself,&equo; she said, forcing the words out. 
 &bquo;I said I didn't want it.&equo; 
 She sloshed more wine into her glass. 
 Fucking bottle was empty. 
 She opened the other bottle &mdash; fake champagne and nothing to celebrate. 
 She filled Lucy's glass. 
 Go, bitch, go! 
 She could about stagger to the off-licence and obliterate the rest of the evening. 
 &bquo;I have to leave,&equo; said Lucy, but sat and drank, sat and lit a cigarette, sniffed away more tears. 
 &bquo;Look, Jay,&equo; she said, &bquo;I hate to go and leave you in this state.&equo; 
 &bquo;So stay.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can't.&equo; 
 &bquo;So go.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look. 
 It's all so sudden for me. 
 Just give it time. 
 I need some space and time. 
 Just leave it for a while.&equo; 
 Jay's ears rung with the words. 
 A reprieve! 
 Cool water in the parched circles of hell. 
 God, if it was just time! 
 You can't make love at pistol point&hellip; her being filled with remorse, and she checked herself from flinging her arms round Lucy: steady, Jay, she told herself, we're only seconds away from no, nay, never. 
 &bquo;OK,&equo; she said and they managed a shaky hug at the door. 
 Time. 
 &bquo;&hellip; after all, time is a great healer &hellip;&equo; 
 Camp screen love courtesy of Judy Garland and Clark Gable. 
 And her mind tried to blank out the rest of it. 
 But the Hollywood words rolled on. 
 &bquo;&hellip; and as I speed through the dark night to the abyss  of oblivion, I can only say thanks, thanks for the memory &hellip;&equo; 
 I cried for you. 
 She propped up the champagne blurred photo of Lucy at her birthday. 
 Lucy laughing, smoking, Lucy with Jamie's feather boa round her shoulders, Lucy who had kissed her. 
 Lucy looked straight into the camera with a look she had taken &mdash; and still, against the odds &mdash; with a look Jay thought of as love. 
 CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE 
 Giving it time, Jay thought, is not enough. 
 Not good enough to fret the days away; let her use them, enjoy, let there be something rich about her to love and desire. 
 Having wrested from Lucy an I don't know, you'll have to decide for both of us , having an &bquo;us&equo; acknowledged, she felt there was a purpose to this time of denial. 
 Moments of doubt she magicked away with the spell of Lucy's eyes. 
 Jesus! 
 Were they ever professional, boy, did they ever work hard, well, didn't  they just talk and work as if that melodrama of near separation had never happened. 
 Francis was delighted with Jay's wild renewed enthusiasm for the magazine. 
 &bquo;I really did think you'd gone, dear,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You've been like a YTS trainee for the past millennia. 
 Dragged off the dole queue and hating every minute. 
 But then I realised you had joined the queue of dolour &mdash; I take it from your sparkling eyes that Lucy's dropped her drawers and flung herself into sapphic bliss?&equo;  
 Jay winced. 
 &bquo;Actually, no,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;We &mdash; I stress &bquo;we&equo; &mdash; we're giving it some real space and time.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh no!&equo; said Francis, raising his eyes to the peeling ceiling. 
 &bquo;I do apologise! 
 How gross of me! 
 Well, who is it, darling? 
 Do tell. 
 Who is the lucky dyke putting the roses into your cheeks?&equo; 
 Jay kissed the top of his head. 
 &bquo;It &bquo;s Lucy,&equo; she said, smiling. 
 &bquo;Ad infinitum. 
 I'm nothing if not consistent. 
 But I realised I'd been a bit heavy. 
 She needs time.&equo; 
 &bquo;You treat her far too well, darling. 
 I mean, you've done the prelims, dear, in your own inimitable fashion &mdash; roses, champagne, adoration, necking and fumbling. 
 Forgive me for assuming my role of dyke agony uncle once more, but really, lovey! 
 How much bloody time does she need? 
 Our Titian Lucy isn't exactly virgo intacta. 
 Unless Jem-boy was an immaculate conception&hellip;?&equo; 
 Jay hated the way he came out with things she whisked to the edges of her mind. 
 &bquo;Come on, Francis, what about if you were forty some and straight and never kissed a man before? 
 And suddenly there was a rampant little queen dying to violate everything you've thought of as normal?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sounds like heaven! 
 No, I can't imagine it. 
 But men and women are utterly different. 
 Especially sexually. 
 With a man it's like a rocket: it fires and goes into orbit or it crashes. 
 You know pretty soon. 
 But I've talked, as you know, to so many women, and sex seems to be a wholly other  experience. 
 Would you care to hear my analogy?&equo; 
 &bquo;Go ahead,&equo; said Jay, enjoying this objective discussion where she could focus entirely on the delirium and dilemma of Lucy. 
 &bquo;Right. 
 You know when you go on a swing when  you're a child &mdash; one of those municipal swings. 
 And then you twist round and round? 
 Slowly, because the chain gets heavier and heavier? 
 And then you lift your feet off the ground and rush round and round, faster and faster and the momentum even twists the chain up again the other way?&equo; 
 Jay closed her eyes, Jesus, yeah! 
 &bquo;I know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, your Lucy has got you winding her chain, darling, and she just won't take her feet off the ground and let go &mdash; am I right?&equo; 
 &bquo;I guess.&equo; 
 &bquo;Jay, she might never let go. 
 Those exquisite hand-tailored shoes would not feel that their place is in an airy whirl of orgasmic delight. 
 But no one else has ever even wound up that chain. 
 If she does let go with anyone, it'll be you. 
 But she might never.&equo; 
 Jay's heart knew better, was utterly sure, given the picture of the swing, that Lucy was poised for a recklessly brilliant let go. 
 LET'S GO ! 
 And she recalled her favourite Hans Andersen fairytale, the one that had brought her time and again to tears. 
 The Garden of Paradise . 
 The prince is given the freedom of the garden if only he does not kiss the fairy. 
 The first night he looks into her bower, the second night he bends over her, and the third night he cannot resist kissing her. 
 There is a clap of thunder and the garden disappears. 
 For ever. 
 She had reason to be wary, reason to act cool. 
 She'd almost lost her garden of paradise in heat and haste and desire. 
 She would not make that mistake again.  
 CHAPTER TWENTY-TWO 
 But there came a point when beautiful stories and analogies wore thin. 
 Usually at a sleepless three a.m. 
 Jay had always said you know who you are at three a.m. 
 Because you're always utterly alone then. 
 There may be a lover, a friend, asleep beside you, but who is wide-eyed as a marigold in the trackless dark? 
 Just you and you. 
 And more and more she met herself at this hour, too late to phone anyone, too weary to sleep. 
 At three a.m. she was Jay-in-love-with-Lucy, writing bad poetry or self-indulgent screeds of what daylight sneered at as a journal. 
 Some weeks she would send a dozen poems, sometimes none. 
 All Lucy ever showed was embarrassed appreciation. 
 &bquo;It's beautiful, Jay. 
 You have such talent. 
 Don't waste it all on me.&equo; 
 Waste? 
 Jay couldn't believe her saying that. 
 If she didn't know she was worth it, worth everything, then by God, Jay would leave her in no doubt. 
 And she softened her demanding when  to spending time listening to Lucy, thrilling her with music and words, filled with a need to have Lucy know she was loved unconditionally. 
 That was the feeling. 
 If they'd spent a particularly warm close time together, Jay even wondered if she and Lucy could be unique friends and veer away from this sexual desire which shimmered like an uncrossable burning field for Lucy. 
 She knew she couldn't, didn't want to. 
 But what if &mdash; what if that's all there is? 
 She threw out the uncomfortable question, its pain-filled  answer. 
 Here and now, just be here and now. 
 God, what an old hippy I am, jeered Jay. 
 Lucy basked in the tender warmth lavished her way. 
 She relaxed and told Jay about her life, with the wry humour of a survivor. 
 She had always been a self-sufficient woman, since the married years with Martin. 
 He had bowled her over when she was seventeen and girls got married. 
 She adored him and tied her life up totally with his. 
 The newly-married couple on the up and up. 
 Impromptu suppers for a dozen friends? 
 No problem to Lucy, who kept smiling through, witty and charming, zipping through three courses of creative cuisine into a smart frock and an atomised squirt of Coty L'Amant in the time it took Martin and &bquo;the gang&equo; to get home. 
 But then at two or three after midnight, a stack of dishes in the sink promising her a greasy good morning, Martin would feel drunkenly randy and she fought first her tiredness then her (unreasonable?) anger when the next evening was the same. 
 A million and one impressive ways with left-overs. 
 &bquo;Just a few of the chaps and chapesses, darling,&equo; over the phone in the late afternoon when she had purged wine stains and ashtrays, boxed up the empties, made the kitchen immaculate yet again. 
 &bquo;Do we always have to?&equo; she asked him. 
 &bquo;Why don't we go over to Richard and Jane's one evening? 
 Or John and Siobhan's?&equo; 
 This was 3.30 a.m., Martin nuzzling her exhausted neck. 
 &bquo;Life in the fast lane, sweetheart,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;And you do it so well. 
 Anyway, you're at home all day.&equo; 
 &bquo;And Jane works? 
 Siobhan works ?&equo; 
 Lucy was enraged. 
 &bquo;Lucy, come on,&equo; said Martin, fumbling her breasts. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Lucy, needing a cuddle, to be heard, to sleep.  
 &bquo;Oh, fuck you!&equo; shouted Martin, and stomped off to the spare room. 
 In the morning, Lucy feigned sleep. 
 That evening brought a repentant young husband, flowers and wine, an evening to themselves. 
 Martin even cooked, every pan in the place, &bquo;nothing too good for my  wife!&equo; 
 He was so pleased with himself, so sure she'd forgive the little boy sorry-and-lost-without-her. 
 After a few scotches, he told her he'd buy a dishwasher, throwing in a string of fatuous clich&eacute;s about her delicate hands, sparkling and making her laugh. 
 Around ten, Lucy felt mellow, even tender. 
 Moved towards him. 
 Kissed him. 
 &bquo;Atta girl,&equo; said he, dialling numbers. 
 &bquo;Feeling better? 
 We should just make it to the cabaret &mdash; everyone's there. 
 Some people I have to meet, you'd love them. 
 Sling on something gorgeous!&equo; 
 &bquo;You go,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I'll be fine.&equo; 
 And he went. 
 If she was sure? 
 She was sure. 
 &bquo;He went?&equo; said Jay, incredulous. 
 &bquo;Yup,&equo; said Lucy, nearly thirty years on, lighting a cigarette, tossing away a cloud of smoke with the word. 
 It got worse. 
 Over the months, she found Martin couldn't have sex sober. 
 And then, when she knew she didn't want to have sex with him at all, she was pregnant. 
 A traumatic birth brought wonder boy Jeremy. 
 Martin was so delighted at the idea of fatherhood that he became lovely and loving again, even drank less. 
 Anything for the mother of his son! 
 All this came from Lucy in a rush, as if she was giving the background to someone else's story. 
 &bquo;Don't stop there,&equo; said Jay, pouring wine and beginning to understand why Jeremy was so precious, to be redeemed from his traumas and late-night binges even at the age of twenty-five. 
 &bquo;Well, I decided I wanted a divorce. 
 And I wanted my  son. 
 So I nudged Martin in the direction of a mindless blonde divorcee. 
 The dangerous type. 
 Big tits and lipstick. 
 He thought he was having a secret affair, and everyone thought I didn't know and was terribly sympathetic. 
 Oh, poor Lucy! 
 Poor Lucy? 
 I was getting what I wanted. 
 Very firmly on the pill, Jay. 
 He was heavily into sex with me during his affair, he felt so guilty.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hold on,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I thought he'd reformed to be a daddy. 
 You sound so definite. 
 Did you just fall out of love, or what?&equo; 
 Lucy lit another cigarette, drank her wine, and her voice came out as if she was reading a script. 
 &bquo;He had been very good while I was pregnant. 
 I told him sex could damage the baby. 
 But when Jem was born, there was no reason I could give him why not. 
 I just didn't want to. 
 But we were married, conjugal rights, it was the fifties, Jay, men had to have sex for their health and they couldn't stop once they were turned on. 
 There was  a last straw. 
 Huh. 
 I'd had stitches after Jeremy. 
 Ripped apart and so on. 
 But I sure wasn't pregnant. 
 No baby to damage. 
 So &mdash; after I was home, four days later? a week? he had to have sex.&equo; 
 &bquo;Jesus!&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;On a scar? 
 An unhealed scar?&equo; 
 &bquo;Honey, it hurt,&equo; said Lucy as if she was joking, &bquo;and went septic. 
 Back to hospital and you must restrain yourself, old boy, nudge wink. 
 Bla bla. 
 This is a dreary conversation, Jay.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorry,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;just I want to know everything about you.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're sweet,&equo; said Lucy, stroking her face, holding her hand, &bquo;but it was a long long time ago. 
 I even meet him for dinner from time to time. 
 Have a laugh. 
 Most odd, dinner with your ex-husband. 
 We talk about Jeremy. 
 Oh, Martin's got his fertile pin-up. 
 She's a whizz in the kitchen. 
 Three children they have. 
 Can't be bad in bed either.&equo;  
 Jay held her. 
 Hug the hurt away. 
 &bquo;No, it's all right, Jay,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I've been over it for years. 
 Then why, thought Jay, rubbing her thumb on Lucy's shoulder blades, why does your jaw tighten as you speak, why are your eyes flooded with pain? 
 Oh, darling, she pledged, let me love you, and I will never give you pain! 
 Another time, Lucy talked about Jeremy, his father's wastrel shadow ever in the background. 
 Martin had been one of the post-war most-likely-to-succeed Oxbridge brigade. 
 Feted as a genius at twenty-one, wined and dined for his striking originality, the world his oyster and a nice vivacious wife to boot&hellip; 
 &bquo;Jeremy has his talent plus,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;And the plus is me. 
 Good old mum. 
 I just hope to God it doesn't all go to his head and burn him out. 
 They're sharks in the art world. 
 That's why I like your end of it, OK, no one makes a million, but they keep producing. 
 After I divorced Martin, the big blonde tugged strings and he became consultant designer for a detergent manufacturer. 
 He was one of the first to design TV campaigns: you know, the super-hero voice advising the daffy housewife how she can best clean his clothes? 
 It's a formula now. 
 He could always sell things. 
 He's doing pop videos now and making stars of the pretty, the talentless, the bizarre. 
 It's all so easy for him, perhaps that's why he squandered his talent &mdash; he never had that period of garret starvation that seems to foster genius.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, Jeremy doesn't exactly slum it,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Oh, shut up, Jay, forgive a mother her blind spots. 
 I swear I have a Jewish ancestry! 
 If he lived in squalor, I'd be round there with chicken soup and clean shirts!&equo; 
 &bquo;You're very good at taking care of people,&equo; said Jay. 
 She'd heard Lucy at meetings, fielding worries, steering  the conversation around the reefs and sandbanks of ego and uncertainty. 
 &bquo;No, I'm not!&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Just my son. 
 I'm no one else's mother!&equo; 
 And Jay, who was no one's mother nor wanted to be, found herself mothering Lucy. 
 Another side of love. 
 Making lunch for Lucy and Francis, giving her lifts here and there when her car was off the road, calling her just to see how she was, ordering her home when she looked exhausted, plying her with remedies if she had a cold, rubbing her back if she was tense. 
 Lucy's eyes lit up with warmth when she saw her. 
 Wow, Jay was having fun! 
 She felt beautiful, needed, and alone she dared admit to feeling loved. 
 CHAPTER TWENTY-THREE 
 And just as she was feeling sure and secure, a smile becoming a real part of her as she gloried in the feeling growing between them, Lucy gave her to understand that she was going away for three weeks. 
 Gave her to understand. 
 Gave her the facts to make of what she would; and make of them what she could, Jay did not understand. 
 A cultural tour with the genius son. 
 Murals on Mynos, pots on Paros, icons on Ios. 
 She blanked out the sudden picture of white sands and her and Lucy in a scented olive-grove evening&hellip; her heart panted to slake its thirst with dreaming, but she slammed the scenes of happiness as illusion, mirage. 
 Which they were. 
 Weren't they &mdash; if Lucy could roll out this announcement like she might show a friend a new carpet.  
 All the build up of delight shrivelled and stripped Jay to lonely self-scourging. 
 Fool. 
 Fool. 
 Fool. 
 What was going on? 
 What about this time and space? 
 She felt she'd lived a zillion eternities, crossed endless lifeless galaxies, bearing her solitude, waiting for US, waiting for the fulfilment of all that lay between them. 
 &bquo;Perhaps we could have lunch before you go?&equo; she forced out, as if the idea was merely spur of the moment, merely friendly, merely pleasant. 
 And Lucy would  like that, she described her itinerary over gazpacho, her beach clothes throughout a pasta salad, Jeremy's elaborate packing as she sipped brandy. 
 Jay stuck to white wine and soda, fearing the fragile floodgates on her anger and pain. 
 &bquo;We must do something about this exhibition,&equo; Jay said, with the very English concentration of one commenting on the vagaries of the weather. 
 Who had said: Some countries have a climate, in England we have weather? 
 Thank you, brain, she thought, thanks for that suave little Jay phrase, guaranteed to raise a giggle, calm things down. 
 It mattered as little as it seemed to matter to Lucy that they would have &mdash; yet another &mdash; three weeks apart. 
 Jay walked Lucy to her car. 
 Waited for some kind of sign, a handclasp, a chaste kiss on the cheek, some sign that Lucy knew the meaning of this time and space. 
 Lucy hopped into her car, rolled the window down &mdash; a kiss? &mdash; and said: 
 &bquo;Four weeks today? 
 I'll come over and we'll get this exhibition moving. 
 I've been so busy. 
 Bye.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dinner?&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Oh, don't bother with that,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I'll eat before I come. 
 Jay stood frozen from head to toe and watched the car accelerate down the road. 
 From somewhere, her hands found a diary and wrote Lucy against the date  four weeks away. 
 Date? 
 For the first time, she felt total despair weld her to the spot. 
 Like the Tin-Man in The Wizard of Oz , rigid under the apple trees, she needed oil. 
 Four weeks. 
 CHAPTER TWENTY-FOUR 
 &bquo;I have never known you  be so patient, Miss Jay Goodtime!&equo; declaimed Jamie, gluing centipede eyelashes into unlikely pools of stage make-up. 
 &bquo;Shall I wear the Veronica Lake or the Rita Hayworth?&equo; 
 They were in a windowless hole of a dressing room, backstage of the El Paradiso &mdash; another charity, bring on the bloody drag! 
 Dionne had ordered her to go out and forget the whole thing. 
 This evening, Jamie would wow his rowdies to riot point and make a fast get-away in what Francis called Jay's dyke-mobile. 
 And then to Dionne's for a late night supper. 
 &bquo;I'm not having you sit home swapping the blues with Sister Gin,&equo; Dionne had told Jay. 
 &bquo;Come and bore the ass off your buddies, baby.&equo; 
 Sandy was doing a trash all-nighter at the Scala, and Dionne met them with a cocktail shaker. 
 &bquo;One of those bastards kept my glove this evening,&equo; said Jamie, mock-tragic. 
 &bquo;A keepsake! 
 A fan! 
 Another cheap bloody fan! 
 Fourteen fucking quid fifty a pair and one of them disappears on a charity night!&equo; 
 &bquo;The tribulations of being a megastar!&equo; murmured Francis. 
 Dionne slung on a Dietrich tape and she and Jay escaped to the kitchen, leaving Jamie and Francis  screaming along to a soul-searching Burt Bacharach number. 
 &bquo;A bit of role playing, my dear,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;The men can sit and camp in the lounge and we girls will slave over a hot stove. 
 Now tell me what's frozen that gorgeous face of yours.&equo; 
 Since Dionne's serious no to a casual affair, Jay had found it hard to talk to her. 
 She shrugged. 
 &bquo;Well, she's pissed off with the boy for a cultural break.&equo; 
 &bquo;And?&equo; 
 &bquo;And? 
 What do you mean, &bquo; and &equo;? 
 Imagine Sandy just saying one morning, oh, by the way, babes. 
 I'm going on holiday this afternoon.&equo; 
 &bquo;But we are having an affair. 
 OK, OK, sorry, Jay. 
 You must have been heartbroken.&equo; 
 &bquo;I may not be screwing Lucy,&equo; said Jay coldly. 
 &bquo;But that's not my definition of the quality of love. 
 Shit, I'm trying to talk myself out of it, it's just when I see her&hellip;&equo; 
 She resented Dionne being so damn cool and objective. 
 Had been found lacking by Dionne and it hurt. 
 She slouched back to the living room. 
 &bquo;Come on, Miss Dyke,&equo; said Jamie, &bquo;let's have a ripalong-a-Lucy session and see if we can't shoosh you m-to a better frame of mind. 
 I have met this pinnacle of sexual desire, Jay. 
 Seemed nice enough. 
 But it's been months, dear! 
 And not a lot of fun&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Piss off, Jamie,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I don't mean that. 
 I just don't know what to do.&equo; 
 &bquo;Given that you can't give it up, and you seem unable to scrub round it at present,&equo; said Francis, &bquo;what exactly have you got? 
 Lovely platonic evenings, the odd kiss and fumble? 
 She's a strange one, this Lucy.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've always thought she was interested,&equo; said Marina quietly, &bquo;ever since your birthday. 
 But. 
 Oh, Jay, I'd have  thought she'd have done it by now, if she was going to. 
 Or broken it off.&equo; 
 &bquo;Has she intimated she wants to break it off?&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;Oh, yeah,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;only I wouldn't let her.&equo; 
 &bquo;Stop putting yourself down,&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;If the silly bitch says no and you get her to say maybe, whatever inimitable persuasion you used, she  changed her mind. 
 Unless you were threatening her life? 
 No? 
 Well, you can never tell with dykes.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about if she does say no and sticks to it, finally?&equo; said Dionne. 
 &bquo;I kill myself,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Next?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine,&equo; said Dionne, &bquo;just checking.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I  think, and I use that word in its broadest sense, I think you should jump on her. 
 At least then you'll know!&equo; said Jamie. 
 &bquo;Do you wish to know yes or no, dear Jay?&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;Jesus! 
 I thought &bquo;maybe&equo; was OK,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I know you're right, but I just can't see how I'd handle &bquo;no&equo;.' 
 &bquo;Have a bloody drink,&equo; said Jamie. 
 &bquo;The trouble is, Miss Galahad, this flaming green-eyed redhead has got under your skin, she's growing with you darling, like mistletoe on an oak. 
 It's parasite time! 
 I wish you luck, sweetie!&equo; 
 &bquo;Let's talk about something else,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I've got weeks to mull it over.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let's play,&equo; said Marina. 
 &bquo;The animal game. 
 Come on.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, not that old bloody chestnut!&equo; said Jamie. 
 &bquo;All right. 
 It always comes out different anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;OK,&equo; said Marina, &bquo;this is my version of psychoanalysis. 
 Self-image and so on. 
 Come on, boys and girls, drink up.&equo; 
 They moved into a circle. 
 Downed their drinks, re-filled.  
 &bquo;OK,&equo; said Marina, &bquo;who's going to start?&equo; 
 &bquo;You choose,&equo; said Jamie, &bquo;just don't start on me!&equo; 
 &bquo;Right,&equo; said Marina, &bquo;Dionne, what kind of animal would you be?&equo; 
 Dionne flung her silky blonde head back and laughed. 
 &bquo;I'd be a cat,&equo; she said, &bquo;a platinum-blonde pedigree cat with all the refined desires of Mehitabel. 
 I'd win blue rosettes and gorge on salmon and cream. 
 Then I'd disappear for days and make everyone go crazy with worry while I whooped it up down the nearest alley with some ear-tom tom. 
 No, not a tom. 
 I guess there are lesbian cats?&equo; 
 &bquo;You could start a trend, dear,&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 So that's me. 
 Miss Priss on a silk cushion, yowling my bahoolas off as soon as I could run away.&equo; 
 &bquo;Last time we did this you were a kitten,&equo; said Marina. 
 &bquo;Are you growing up?&equo; 
 &bquo;God forbid!&equo; said Dionne, &bquo;just that I'm living with a delinquent at the moment and it makes me feel mature. 
 &bquo;Fine,&equo; said Marina. 
 &bquo;Jamie?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, last time, last  time, I was a parrot, do you remember? 
 So long as I stuck to squawks and Pretty fucking Polly, I was fine? 
 Well, that TV contract faded to materialise as usual, being a parrot does you fuck all in the way of good! 
 So right now, it's obvious really, I'm a skunk. 
 Utterly repulsive to the rest of the animal kingdom, but totally irresistible to other skunks. 
 Fuck, em all! 
 Some day my stink will come!&equo; 
 &bquo;Yo!&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;And don't ask me yet. 
 Marina, what about you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm still some sort of bird,&equo; said Marina. 
 &bquo;I thought I was a bird of paradise before, but that was in the flow of what never quite materialised &mdash; that new play? 
 Maybe I'm an owl, watching the other owls screech down on helpless little mice, but I won't forsake my  vegetarian principles. 
 I'm a rather inept owl, really, stalking mushrooms and nuts by night.&equo; 
 &bquo;Never mind, said Jay, we all feel a good deal safer around you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Or maybe I'm a fruitarian bat,&equo; said Marina, laughing, &bquo;the one that got turned down for every Drac film because she wouldn't suck blood. 
 Swoop, swoop!&equo; 
 &bquo;Is it that bad?&equo; asked Jamie. 
 &bquo;My end of the theatre is deadly at the moment. 
 Everyone's waiting for what might happen with arts subsidies. 
 Oh, the Government hates the queers, dear. 
 They'll starve us all to death!&equo; 
 &bquo;It's fortunate that skunks and fruitarian bats have meagre appetites,&equo; said Marina wryly. 
 &bquo;Francis?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm tom, dear,&equo; he said, stretching. 
 &bquo;I'm a very domestic nest-building type of creature. 
 Fanatically tidy. 
 Which suggests a rodent of some kind. 
 And that I'm not &mdash; a toothless harvest mouse? 
 Did you know they're making dentures for sheep these days? 
 Really! 
 All the grass grinds their little molars flat. 
 So, something nest-  building. 
 Possibly aligned to water &mdash; a sort of bank by a rushing river. 
 Perhaps something as natty and camp as Ratty in The Wind in the Willows . 
 Dapper, dear, Noel Coward.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can see that,&equo; said Dionne. 
 &bquo;Only you need to be something more lean and long-legged, my dear.&equo; 
 &bquo;A whippet?&equo; 
 Francis raised an eyebrow. 
 &bquo;A whippet endlessly chasing a stuffed rabbit round a track&hellip; a gerbil on a wheel? 
 God! 
 Actually, in all semi-seriousness, knowing my penchant for warm furry places. 
 I'd be a flea. 
 And that would have the added advantage of being able to hop from one creature to another. 
 And career prospects! 
 I could join a circus and see the world!&equo; 
 &bquo;Bravo!&equo; said Marina. 
 &bquo;Jay?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, you, Jay. 
 Lighten our tone, dear,&equo; said Francis. 
 &bquo;What with schizophrenic bats, isolated skunks,  long-legged water rats&hellip; we're all verminous mutations apart from Puss here.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;It's a very determined little animal, whatever it is. 
 Like an agouti: it is going to make its nest on that  spot, come wind or rain, hell or high water! 
 But it's more solid. 
 A pig, perhaps, root root, snort, snuffle, dig in the mud and find a truffle! 
 A rather stupid pig, I think. 
 Rooted so deep it's in danger of the tree falling on its unknowing pig head. 
 Yeah. 
 I stick with a pig.&equo; 
 &bquo;What a menagerie,&equo; said Marina, draining the bottle into their glasses. 
 &bquo;I feel we should open a home for displaced animals.&equo; 
 &bquo;What else is this place?&equo; asked Dionne, &bquo;or any of our places?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, that's it,&equo; said Jamie. 
 &bquo;I think we've all depressed ourselves stupid. 
 And there's no more wine. 
 I'm going to get some beauty sleep, and wake up as a peacock!&equo; 
 &bquo;You can stay if you like,&equo; said Dionne to Jay. 
 &bquo;Sandy's not coming back tonight.&equo; 
 &bquo;You want a surrogate pig?&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Dionne quietly. 
 &bquo;Just mind my pedigree claws.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, we pigs have thick skins, Dionne, don't let the acres of pink fool you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sandy, of course, thinks I'm a bitch,&equo; said Dionne, mouth hardening, &bquo;wants to move in full-time, be a couple. 
 I don't.&equo; 
 &bquo;Want to talk about it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Get your clothes off, Jay. 
 No.&equo; 
 They had sex wordlessly, frantically, furiously. 
 Exhaustion. 
 The thing about sex, thought Jay, apart from everything else, is that for a few, for many, for countless seconds and sometimes glorious minutes, you stop thinking. 
 Entirely.  
 CHAPTER TWENTY-FIVE 
 Usually, Jay was studiously sober at the beginning of an evening with Lucy. 
 Earnest and alert, edgy as hell. 
 This time, she met Jamie in Rital's wine bar at lunchtime. 
 Fun and laughter, a mammoth task she felt equal to. 
 &bquo;I mustn't get too pissed,&equo; she said. 
 Jamie was looking a little fragile and they browsed through coffee and a restrained bottle of house red for the first hour. 
 But Jay didn't want to go home for three, what, four hours to mope over Lucy, alone? 
 And Rital, whose east European eyes had seen been and done it all for more of a century than she chose to admit, merely shrugged and locked the door. 
 &bquo;Houze parrr-dy, dahlink?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Though you look like it could be a wake.&equo; 
 &bquo;Champagne?&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;You do take Access, Rital?&equo; 
 &bquo;Hi take vord Hi can gehd these days!&equo; said Rital. 
 &bquo;Hand ri &mdash; yid now, dear Chay, Jamie dahlink, Hi take a nap. 
 Led yousself out!&equo; 
 Jamie's mega-mouth roller-coastered Jay through side-splitting anecdotes. 
 Jay felt lyrical, delighted. 
 Fuck it, she thought at five, maybe I just won't go home. 
 Do I need this Lucy? 
 Lucy who? 
 She wished she meant it as blithe as it sounded. 
 &bquo;Well, you hideous reprobate,&equo; said Jamie, &bquo;I have to go, plunge my flesh into the asses milk, slather on the Man Tan and hit In Chains. 
 My public calls!&equo; 
 Negotiating her way home, Jay wished she could borrow some of Jamie's crowd-quelling chutzpah to face Lucy. 
 Lucy who didn't know she was going to be  pounced on. 
 Lucy who possibly hadn't given Jay a thought in four weeks; she certainly hadn't woken with Jay's face in her mind, slept with a dream of Jay in her arms. 
 Or had she? 
 Did she even know what Jay felt? 
 Hell with it, what did the bitch know, thought Jay, trying to toughen up. 
 Sober up, too. 
 Jamie called three bottles of wine Betty Ford time, and commiserated on the sexual inequality of male and female livers. 
 &bquo;But you do have clitoral orgasms, Jay!&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Ha! 
 That's  sexual inequality!&equo; 
 She made a huge pot of strong coffee. 
 Pushed books and papers into piles, threw discarded clothes into the bedroom. 
 Suddenly the door bell rang and she blessed that she'd blissed the afternoon away. 
 She'd given more time to thinking about Lucy than anything else for months. 
 At least the lost afternoon guaranteed a certain spontaneity. 
 She opened the first bottle of wine, and went down to the door. 
 &bquo;Hi,&equo; she said and led the way upstairs. 
 Lucy was the sort of redhead who bronzes beautifully. 
 As usual she was stunning, white linen jacket and trousers supremely casual and graceful. 
 For Jay the room was throbbing with desire. 
 Lucy was full of her holiday and an artists' colony where Jeremy might just settle. 
 &bquo;And now, Jay, the exhibition,&equo; she said, smiling. 
 Oh, so now we have time for the exhibition? thought Jay. 
 Thank you SO much, Jeremy, Deo Gratias! 
 &bquo;Jay, what's the matter?&equo; said Lucy. 
 Aside from six months of celibate desire, three bottles of wine with the greatest drag queen in the world, a won't-be-shrugged-off resentment that only now you sound as if you care? 
 &bquo;Nothing,&equo; said Jay, staring at her foot. 
 &bquo;Must change the tape. 
 She selected Goyescas. 
 The music was sure as a  swing in high summer, to and fro, light as racing over a sunny lawn to the blessed shade under the trees. 
 Up the garden path and a frisson of unease: there is no house, but a vista of a majestic lake. 
 Stroll along its shore and find it is a seashore, primly kissed by measured trills of dippy white-capped wavelets. 
 But dip in your toe and all at once, the waves are wild unleashed dangerous passion to sweep you off your feet, drag you around and duck you and go half-way to drown you then toss you above the tide line. 
 Save yourself! 
 Goyescas, where one piano plays as if there were three. 
 She stared at Lucy. 
 I have nothing to lose except self-respect and honey, that went months ago . 
 &bquo;You&hellip; you just talk as if there was nothing between us except this goddam exhibition,&equo; she said dully. 
 &bquo;Well, you do want to do it, don't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;You know fucking well that's not all I want to do. 
 What the hell is going on, Lucy?&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps I should go,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;You're very angry with me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Go!&equo; said Jay, borrowing Baby Jane. 
 &bquo;Go! 
 Just leave me alone again, why not, it's what you always do, just leave me alone with loving you, wanting you, needing you &mdash; why break the habits of a lifetime &mdash; GO!&equo; 
 &bquo;Steady on,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I will not steady on ,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Why the fuck should I? 
 Oh, it's OK for you, let's have an evening of work on the exhibition, your goddam son blew that out of the window once and I was supposed to say, &bquo;Yes Lucy, no Lucy, three bags full, Lucy?&equo; 
 Hah! 
 And now you  want to work on the exhibition you were so all-fired about, I was so inspired by, same deal, huh? 
 It's not the same deal.&equo; 
 &bquo;God, you are angry,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;Oh, had you noticed?&equo; slashed Jay. 
 &bquo;Thank you so much. 
 Recognition at last! 
 Do not let me discommode  you none, Miz Scarlett, I'm sure! 
 Sorry, you're going.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Lucy, &bquo;I haven't been fair to you. 
 Let's try and sort this out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lend a hand and play the game?&equo; 
 Jay screamed. 
 &bquo;You make me sick. 
 Now you want to be reasonable. 
 Why? 
 Make yourself feel better. 
 Well, I don't feel better, Lucy. 
 Fuck you!&equo; 
 Which didn't phase Lucy. 
 Which mode would she switch into next? 
 Understanding parent of semi-alcoholic genius prot&eacute;g&eacute;? 
 Surviving ex-wife or unreasonable alcoholic? 
 Unwilling object of lesbian desire? 
 Jay's brows fixed into furious question marks. 
 &bquo;I deserved that,&equo; said Lucy, looking pale and tired behind the sun-gold glow (beat yourself up, Jay, you've hurt the one you love), but I said it wouldn't work. 
 I said that weeks ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;You said,&equo; said Jay, real B-movie melodrama here, kid ! &bquo;you said I'd have to decide for both of us. 
 You said you couldn't handle it, but you didn't stick with that. 
 I said we needed a weekend, real time, for both of us, and you said give it time. 
 How much bloody time do you want?&equo; 
 &bquo;Jay, it's not going to work. 
 It's not a question of time.&equo; 
 &bquo;Change your tune, why don't you!&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;You call all the bloody shots round here!&equo; 
 Lucy flung herself forward, cheeks flushed, eyes flashing. 
 An emotional response! 
 A hollow Hurrah! 
 (As Jamie would say, compering a truly dreadful act.) 
 It takes fury to rouse her? 
 &bquo;Christ!&equo; she exploded, &bquo;all this bloody drama over a few kisses!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, fine,&equo; said Jay on the unstoppable switchback of Nightmare Alley. 
 &bquo;Thank you! 
 Now we're getting to it! 
 My bloody heart and soul on the line and to you it's a &bquo;few kisses&equo; &mdash; you lousy hypocrite! 
 I'm sorry. 
 I failed to  realise that you kiss so easily. 
 My mistake. 
 Understandable, I think, after the huge deal you made over even that. 
 Fine! 
 Fine! 
 Relegate those few kisses to ridicule, why don't you! 
 Pardon me for thinking they were important, pardon me for feeling beautiful and lyrical, pardon me for loving you. 
 I'll just fuck off and forget it. 
 Time is a great healer.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't mean that,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;You've been lovely to me. 
 It was very important to me, having you there, caring for me. 
 I'm very fond of you, Jay.&equo; 
 Fond, in Jay's book, was what you were of plants, distant and cute nieces and nephews, fond was a rice-pudding emotion: it feeds, but never satisfies. 
 Fond you grow fat and sleepy with, fond and foolish: a grandmotherly emotion, bric-&agrave;-brac, aspidistras and antimacassars. 
 She was repulsed by the dark brown chintzy respectability of fond: as well veil the piano legs and wear a corset! 
 &bquo;Well, I'm not fond  of you,&equo; she drawled. 
 &bquo;I adore you, your body drives me wild with desire, I live for the light in your eyes, my whole being lights up at the thought of you. 
 And you know that. 
 Jesus! 
 I've written you poems better than I ever dreamed I could write&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;And I love your poems!&equo; said Lucy, &bquo;they're wonderful. 
 But Jay, that isn't me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who the hell else is it, excuse my amnesia,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I don't recollect writing poems for anyone else for twenty year.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're impossible!&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I'm not who you think &mdash; I'm not perfect. 
 I'm someone you could do wonderful world-changing things with. 
 Your spark and my organisation&hellip; and I'm a friend.&equo; 
 &bquo;Friend?&equo; said Jay, wearily. 
 &bquo;Friend? 
 Lady, I want to your lover.&equo; 
 &bquo;CHRIST!&equo; said Lucy hurtling to her feet, stalking the floor like Mildred Pierce, &bquo;all your talent and you just  want to be a bloody lover! 
 You could really do something with your life, and that's  what you want!&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;and what's wrong with being a lover? 
 You have some objection to appreciating your body, Lucy? 
 You really think I can do this fucking exhibition, work on all these projects, sit beside you and keep my filthy lesbian hands to myself?&equo; 
 Lucy paced, rampaged, flung out scads of unrequited ire, impassioned as Jay had never seen her. 
 &bquo;I'm fed up, sick, sick, sick to here with people saying I should be some other way! 
 All of you! 
 If only I was this, if I'd only said that, done the other &mdash; why always ME? 
 Why can't you all just leave me be?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know about anyone else,&equo; said Jay, in the eerily calm eye of the storm, &bquo;but you seemed to want me, seemed to be holding back from me and I don't know why. 
 You wanted me sexually, goddammit, Lucy. 
 I was THERE, and suddenly, you've decided no. 
 And I want you so. 
 I'm doing all this the wrong way, I  know. 
 Jesus, all I ever wanted was to love you, you to love me.&equo; 
 Lucy flung herself full length on the floor, curled up and wept. 
 Curled tight like an embryo that doesn't want to be born, like a baby who's had too much pain. 
 Her weeping tore at her slender shoulders, white linen crumpling to folds of despair. 
 What do I do now, thought Jay, we've re-run Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf , and what do I do now? 
 Her body took over, she crossed to Lucy, lay beside her, curling round her, holding her close and Lucy turned, wept into her arms and Jay rocked and sh-sh-ed her, her flights of vituperation spent in the face of this pain. 
 Suddenly Lucy unballed her fists from her face and kissed her, open mouthed, hard. 
 Jay shushed her against her shoulder. 
 What the hell was that kiss about in the middle of all this? 
 Lucy wept. 
 Lucy wept. 
 Jay was weirdly at peace. 
 You'll have to &hellip;  
 &bquo;Come on,&equo; she whispered, &bquo;let's go to bed. 
 You don't even have to take your fucking clothes off, darling, I want to hold all the hurt away. 
 Let's go and lie on my bed, it's a hell of a sight more comfortable, let's just hold each other.&equo; 
 Lucy said yes and Jay led her through to the other room. 
 They lay and held each other. 
 Lucy's sobs stilled a little and she clung to Jay. 
 Kissed her. 
 Jay covered her eyes and brow and cheek with kisses, Lucy's hand shook along her cheek. 
 &bquo;Take your clothes off and get into bed,&equo; said Jay, a wave of calm sweeping over her. 
 &bquo;We don't have to do a thing you don't want. 
 But I know what I want. 
 I think I know what you want. 
 Take your clothes off and let's see.&equo; 
 &bquo;I have to pee,&equo; said Lucy, all at once a child to be coaxed into the treat she wants. 
 &bquo;I'll follow you,&equo; said Jay. 
 And returned to find Lucy in bed, duvet around her neck. 
 She ripped her clothes to the floor. 
 &bquo;Come here, let me hold you,&equo; said Jay. 
 She felt Lucy's heat-soft breasts nudge hers. 
 Felt Lucy's slender arms round her shoulders. 
 Felt her naked legs against Lucy's. 
 She felt like every adagio ever written. 
 &bquo;Well, here I am in bed with a woman,&equo; said Lucy. 
 &bquo;I've never done this before. 
 I might just throw a total number. 
 What am I doing, Jesus Christ, what am I doing?&equo; 
 &bquo;The woman is me and I love you,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Just hold tight, Lucy, Lucy, I love you.&equo; 
 She kissed Lucy's brow, her eyebrows, her ears, her neck, her parted lips. 
 Their tongues entangled. 
 Her hand found Lucy's breast, her thumb found Lucy's nipple, Lucy drew closer as she stroked her belly, and her little finger exploded on the springy turf of Lucy's  hair. 
 So much she wanted to fling back the covers, light incense and candles, worship this adored body. 
 But Lucy gripped her shoulders and Jay explored, dizzy with longing. 
 How to tell, how to be the perfect lover, eight over the eight and exploding with tenderness. 
 Jay's hand played a sonata she'd never seen the score for. 
 Lucy gasped and moved her hand on Jay's shoulders, kissed her with fire, thrust her whole body so close, head to toe. 
 Jay's mind blew. 
 Lucy was used to men, right? 
 What to do, oh, what to do&hellip; her longing fingers moved deep inside Lucy, right to the hard bud of flesh, the flowing cervix. 
 &bquo;Jay, what are you doing?&equo; murmured Lucy, the words broken by hauling breaths inside her. 
 &bquo;I'm loving you,&equo; said Jay to Lucy's breast, &bquo;Is it OK?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mm,&equo; said Lucy, writhing against her. 
 Jay rode that secret muscle for a while, her ears scanning every sigh. 
 Her hand spiralled against Lucy's clitoris, goddamn the useless WORD for the centre of desire. 
 Gentle and insistent, tender and rhythmic until Lucy came. 
 For Jay that was only a start. 
 &bquo;Zzthat OK for you?&equo; she murmured. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Lucy. 
 Jay coaxed around her desire. 
 &bquo;Zzthat really OK for you?&equo; she said, her mouth yearning for more. 
 &bquo;You know it was,&equo; said Lucy, abruptly, then as if making conversation. 
 &bquo;How about you?&equo; 
 While she burned to have Lucy make love to her, that sudden in control precision made her say: 
 &bquo;I'm fine, fine.&equo; 
 Time enough later for Lucy to know the sheer delight of making love to her. 
 And then Lucy had to go. 
 Jay knew it, numbed herself against what it might mean.  
 Lucy wanted coffee, and Jay said sure, but keep your clothes off, took it back when Lucy said fine, no coffee. 
 Came back to bed to find Lucy dressed in bed. 
 &bquo;But I've kept my bra off,&equo; said Lucy. 
 They drank coffee, Jay's brain slurring off some awful truth. 
 She held Lucy's breast. 
 Lucy kissed her. 
 Lucy went. 
 She slept. 
 And woke in the morning knowing it, whatever it was, was over. 
 You do not leave a new lover in the middle of the night. 
 Something was appeased, and something had died. 
 Very neatly and no one could say when, but something had died that night. 
 She dragged on a cigarette and wrote, as if words could change a thing. 
 CHAPTER TWENTY-SIX 
 the day after 
 feeling complete, replete, like a cat sleeping in the sun has all four paws buried under its furred belly, sun too hot to move, tail wrapped over its sleeping nose, I went back to our bed to curl up next to where you had been. 
 Hadn't shifted one crease from the pillows where you sat and smoked and drank coffee, my hand on your warm naked breast. 
 I lay as if you were there and loved the shape your back had made, had a sense of your silky warmth, my body curling round the heat and wonder of you in my arms. 
 One or your down-fine hairs was on the pillow: I picked it up like gold-dust-sweet relic! 
 Another-I knelt delighted and collected your beautiful hair. 
 Fox red, moonbeam silver, I held the precious strands like a  pilgrim sips water from a miraculous spring. 
 I tiptoed to find a sacred vessel to keep your hair in, mouth humming with its knowing:you were here, with me, loving me, kissing me, holding me and could be no closer. 
 Sanctified by your presence, immortal in your beauty, your fire, loving you even more, when I loved you totally before. 
 And wishing, with a sunrise burst of longing to be with you always, to always be gentle as your hair is soft. 
 So you would know&hellip; you know. 
 Oh, wild creature, it's you I've dared to demand in the garden of paradise. 
 Wire-fragile, wind-trembling harebell You are powerful like all creatures, fine-skinned and muscled to the bone, ears alert to every bracken rustle, the cries of the wheeling kites; the wind thrills you with its chill messages of danger and delight. 
 CHAPTER TWENTY-SEVEN 
 &bquo;So how's Lucy?&equo; said Dionne over dinner, sparkling with anticipation. 
 &bquo;Did you pounce?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;I pounced.&equo; 
 &bquo;And? 
 Did she&hellip; oh, come on, puss, TELL me!&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, it was very strange,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;We &mdash; did it &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;She gave in! 
 Wow! 
 I never thought she would! 
 Well done!&equo; 
 Jay had to smile. 
 True, she'd done it. 
 Yes oh yes, she'd got Lucy in bed, made love &mdash; had sex? &mdash; fucked with? &mdash; there wasn't really a phrase to fit how utterly strange the whole thing had made her feel. 
 An eerie shiver as she woke the next morning, suddenly in a cold  landscape for which she had no bearings. 
 There had been less between her and Lucy after the &bquo;act&equo; than ever before. 
 It had been an end, where Jay had yearned to be sure &mdash; had been sure? what a fool believes? &mdash; it would be a beginning. 
 &bquo;So when are you seeing her?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, it's not quite like that. 
 Hell, Dionne, it was so weird. 
 I mean, we had this goddawful evening. 
 She wouldn't have supper for a start. 
 Like, it was work not socialising. 
 But I thought, fuck, NOW you want to work? 
 So we did this whole fury number: I was pissed as a fart, thankyou, Jamie, and I just threw the lot at her. 
 Then she got really mad and started screaming back at me. 
 It was George and Martha OK. 
 Not OK.&equo; 
 &bquo;Some people have to get wildly angry before they let themselves feel anything.&equo; 
 &bquo;I dunno, dunno. 
 Anyway, then she just sprawled on the floor and cried her heart out. 
 I mean, weeping.&equo; 
 &bquo;She's a strange one.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mm. 
 Anyway, I just held her, and it felt like she'd broken, couldn't take any more, then she kissed me. 
 You know, sort of a sexual kiss, only really hard? 
 So we went to bed.&equo; 
 &bquo;Was it OK? 
 I would assume with you it would be.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you, precious. 
 Well, it was. 
 I mean, she seemed to be having a good time. 
 I do aim to please. 
 Only she said something as she was leaving &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;She left ?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 I said something like, well, I was trying to make her feel at ease, oh, something like, we could make a habit of this, and just have fun, Lucy. 
 And she sort of sniffed and said, really shaky, fun? that would be nice . 
 Like it was a foreign language.&equo; 
 &bquo;Stupid woman,&equo; said Dionne, but not unkindly. 
 &bquo;She can't let herself have fun?&equo;  
 &bquo;Either that or she just doesn't fancy me, even I admit that possibility.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't think that's true. 
 Having met her just that once, she was so sparky and ritzy. 
 She couldn't look at you how she did and&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Dionne, very nice and all. 
 I have always relied on the kindness of my friends. 
 But I just felt that's it . 
 Odd how I pinned so much on getting her into bed, and when I did, after we did&hellip; 
 I just knew it was over.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe you just need to give her time.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not that one! 
 If ever I meet a woman who says &bquo;give me time&equo; again, I shall become a Carmalite!&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorry, Jay. 
 So what next? 
 You seem dazed.&equo; 
 &bquo;I feel numb. 
 Last week at work &mdash; she always seems to have someone there when I am. 
 Am I paranoid? 
 Possibly &mdash; she just let drop that they're moving offices.&equo; 
 &bquo;When?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yesterday. 
 She's gone. 
 They've gone. 
 Apparently they're expanding. 
 She's promoted. 
 Hertfordshire.&equo; 
 &bquo;You should call her at home, Jay.&equo; 
 &bquo;I did. 
 She's gone ex-directory.&equo; 
 &bquo;Christ,&equo; said Dionne, &bquo;Christ. 
 Poor you. 
 That's too much of a coincidence.&equo; 
 &bquo;I tell myself she's got my number &mdash; in more ways than one. 
 But she won't call. 
 I even spent every evening last week in, in case. 
 It's a dead one. 
 Get some more wine, Dionne, this bottle hasn't touched me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Baby, I don't know what to say,&equo; said Dionne. 
 &bquo;Baby, get drunk and come and stay with me. 
 You shouldn't be on your own.&equo; 
 &bquo;I am on my own,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;And thanks, but I think I'd just bawl my eyes out all over you. 
 Don't want to. 
 I actually do believe baby requires a little time on her own.&equo;  
 Numb, that was the feeling. 
 Or lack of it. 
 Floating in icy seas. 
 And suddenly a sharp pain as if stabbed in the gut. 
 A monstrous pain crackling along the frozen nerves to leave her dry crying, wordless sobs of abandonment. 
 And when the words came through, pain stabbing through her brain and whipping round her body like barbed wire, words digging into the flesh. 
 It took more and more gin and wine to shut the words up, pick out the barbs. 
 Catatonic. 
 Dully punching Lucy's old number, slamming the phone down on unattainable . 
 Had it been that bad? 
 Was she that lousy a lover? 
 If only it was that simple. 
 I think, said Jay aloud to herself, I do believe I'm going mad. 
 Then so be it. 
 CHAPTER TWENTY-EIGHT 
 Jay at three in the morning &mdash; hello, young lovers, wherever you are ! &mdash; drunk, suddenly had  to see a picture of Lucy. 
 But the contact sheet she'd taken from the office was not in her bag, not in any of the half dozen dead newspapers lying round the floor, not under any of the piles of flung-down clothes, not under the sofa, not in the bin. 
 When you're drunk you check everything eight times, lurching like a pain-maddened rhinoceros. 
 Surely she hadn't chucked it out? 
 Sure enough Jay at ten past three in the morning flits down the stairs of the crumbling house in her  pomegranate kimono, mad woman in search of photo, as if a photo could help her understand. 
 Becomes Ms. Melancholy Moonwailer, is anybody there? 
 On the doorstep of the night-time house, imagining herself locked out by a freak wind slamming the door shut. 
 It doesn't. 
 She isn't. 
 The street is moondark and utterly without sound, the city a smoky neon backdrop. 
 She lugs the most recent bag of trash back up the stairs, unties it, putrid stench, fermenting and ghastly like old fruit skins. 
 Jay gags, this is where love has brought me, rooting through the bins like a vagrant, looking for a sheet of high-gloss photographic paper and a bad profile shot of Lucy smaller than a postage stamp. 
 Oh, well. 
 I've lost it, thought Jay. 
 Congratulations, bitch, what else is new? 
 Thought you were so damn smart getting it in the first place, and drink has blurred you so much you've blown it. 
 Back to bed. 
 On the radio, Peter from Crawley whittering some sort of shit, what? 
 Bisexuals are animals, aren't they, Brian? just bloody animals. 
 Ring Brian again and again for the relief of talking to someone in this Lucyless silent world, engaged, engaged, engaged. 
 Then her rolling eye caught the edge of the contact sheet &mdash; by her bed all the time. 
 Squinted at the dark shot: Lucy smiling, glass and cigarette balanced, somebody talking right to her, Lucy charming, Lucy, Jay rang the Samaritans. 
 She had always thought she was not the type to ring the Samaritans. 
 But before falling in love with Lucy, she was not the type to lie awake, miss meals, weep, miss work, lose weight, have eczema, fall asleep with the light and fire blazing, feel hopeless, feel that everything was more or less meaningless, be unable to cope. 
 All this love had brought her, taught her: the flip side of ecstasy. 
 Boy, thought Jay, am I ever paying my dues.  
 &bquo;It's not like you to be ill,&equo; her mother said. 
 Well, wrong again. 
 Cry me a river? 
 Cry me Niagara, not crying wolf this time: yup, thought Jay tossing Lucy's photo away, away out of sight but never mind, I am Ms. Melancholy Moonwailer, whingeing on to a total stranger at four in the morning. 
 &bquo;Samaritans. 
 Can I help you?&equo; 
 Mummy mummy. 
 &bquo;I'm not suicidal or anything,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I just can't sleep.&equo; 
 CHAPTER TWENTY-NINE 
 It was the in-between of that sludge-grey spring that stopped and started, flowers bursting out then drenched with sleet, blighted by snow; skies grey and thundery, rain mean and seeping, wind a slinking greasy cur that has paddled through filthy city ponds and has nowhere to go. 
 And Jay was pacing her attic, bars tightening and cracking around a heart that would not stop hurting; she could not lay her body down though it screamed for rest and knots of fury made her neck and shoulders a steely hunch like a vulture. 
 Her face in the mirror looked raddled, eyes wild and angry and pained, mouth set. 
 She felt every one of her thirty some years sitting on her face, and stared at this disoriented stranger, her self. 
 You make your face. 
 I do not understand! 
 She fretted against the invisible glass, the cool and unbridged chasm between Lucy and herself, paced the  crumbling edge. 
 So short a time ago they had found and shared a grassy path in a brief Eden of summerblue skies, tapestry green and flowered meadows, every day a delight, the world a beautiful old master cleaned in the zephyr of Lucy's being. 
 And now. 
 London had been grit grey for months, and Jay fought the sunless skies with the blade of keen memory. 
 It was not even as noble and hopeless as tilting at windmills; she was blindfolded by not understanding and whirled towards every sound &mdash; Lucy's voice, laugh, profile, light footfall: all worn by unknowing everyday strangers. 
 She was challenging the shadows of shadows, challenging the shadows of primeval monsters half-glimpsed in nightmare. 
 I am alone on a desolate plain, and I am cold and I am lonely  thought Jay, chanted Jay, she could find no comfort. 
 Finally, she had rung the new office, cursing herself, her need. 
 Lucy would not see her. 
 I feel I have unfinished business with you  said Jay, amazed that she could use such an adult phrase, when alone, her mouth sagged and stretched and gasped with momma, momma , the pain shrieked from her navel, she even sucked her thumb in the hope that do-it-yourself primal therapy would ease something. 
 It did not. 
 Yes, I expect you do , said Lucy, a tiny precise voice in her ear, but I am not the one to help you . 
 Politeness, adulthood, monsters, nonsense. 
 Jay demanded, her voice ugly, feeling so far away she could lose no more, the angrier she grew the further Lucy went; but when she forced herself to be quiet and good, Lucy still kept her distance. 
 FUCK YOU! screamed Jay. 
 It wasn't what she meant. 
 She slammed the phone down, shook and smoked. 
 Then firmed her jaw and imagined the tight lines she  was seeding round her mouth. 
 I shall be a bitter-looking little old lady with no muscle tone, she thought, and re-dialled Lucy. 
 I'm sorry , she lied, beside herself, but I need to talk to you . 
 Come over later and have a cup of tea, said Lucy, each word measured, sounded cold and reasonable, just a cup of tea in front of the fire and no heavies from either of us. 
 OK? 
 What's made you change your mind? said Jay ungraciously, I won't take hand-outs from you ! 
 I've looked at my diary, said Lucy. 
 OK? 
 OK, said Jay, I'm sorry. 
 I'm so sorry. 
 Alone again, and knowing that a cup of tea was what was offered only after screaming and shouting and throwing all her nice toys on the floor. 
 She felt like a bad child, a bad little girl who wouldn't give up. 
 And what was that sorry about? 
 Sorrow itself. 
 my pain is that I knew you 
 and you will only have me as a stranger 
 a dangerous acquaintance 
 an episode you apologise for 
 my sorrow is that we will never kiss again 
 And so to tea. 
 Jay swore she would behave herself, awkward in Lucy's tidy living room, her table between them had a map of the world on it. 
 Jay half smiled. 
 Once more together. 
 Worlds apart. 
 Good God! 
 She couldn't look at Lucy's face. 
 Hopeless laughter curled around her hollowness. 
 All this drama, darling, she thought all this gotta-see-her, and I can't even look at her. 
 She sneaked a glance while Lucy poured tea. 
 Then studied the ceiling as the tears would not be checked. 
 That, my dear, she said, is why you can't look at her. 
 And I do not give you permission to  fling yourself at her feet, grab her hands and weep into her palms. 
 So well-behaved was Jay that Lucy relaxed. 
 Jay couldn't remember why it had been so important to see her. 
 The person across the room was Lucy, Lucy without love. 
 No longer so important. 
 So relaxed was Lucy that she offered Jay wine. 
 I guess I had to see you , drawled Jay, because I was so scared of seeing you. 
 I don't want to be scared of anything . 
 You see, said Lucy, I was never in love with you. 
 I'm very fond of you. 
 Jay looked at the ceiling. 
 I was never in love with you . 
 She'd said it. 
 She'd robbed those stolen kisses of their delight, and if not ever in love, then why, what the hell had she meant? 
 How can her eyes and hands and breasts meet and mingle and Lucy say categorically, like not for one minute or second or fleeting flit of time, never never never had she been in love. 
 Chin up, Jay, she told herself, you needed to hear that. 
 You have to let go or go mad. 
 She let the silence go on, and wondered about just getting up and leaving right then without one word, not one word of the torrent foaming in her guts. 
 I was never in love with you. 
 CHAPTER THIRTY 
 She was coming to the end of months on the barren atoll of Pity Me when she heard the moth rattle against her window, between tacked-up scarlet and black batik fabric and the glass. 
 Jay had a horror of moths flying  into her face and hair; she liked to think of herself as someone who cups her hands for moths and spiders and frees them. 
 But she didn't. 
 She jumped round the room with a newspaper club and splattered them when they settled. 
 She washed spiders down the plughole, and felt guilty as hell about it. 
 Imagined hairy great mutant legs straining against the plug and prying it upwards. 
 So, the moth. 
 It was late one night running into horribly early the next morning. 
 Jay had picked up a pattern of sleeplessness over the last five months. 
 Her sleeve of care was unravelled all right: her life was a basket of woollen shreds, all shades and textures and not one of them long enough to do anything with. 
 As if she'd been wearing a coat of many many colours, and, beached on the desert island shore of Pity Me, had shredded the damn shrunken thing. 
 Without it she was cold, but simply hadn't the energy or inclination to weave it into anything new and warm. 
 Tides and tears had faded and roughened every strand. 
 Her bedroom had become a nest. 
 A crow's nest high above the street, a magpie's nest, phone light fire scads of books juice vitamin pills cold tea tobacco papers matches ashtray diary address book radio all within reach of the heap of pillows and quilts, tangled sheets and herself. 
 Jay had taken up situationist sculpture, and eased herself half upright to look at yesterday evening's achievement. 
 Ah yes! 
 Corduroy Jeans On Upright Hoover &mdash; one of her best. 
 Counterposing this stark image&hellip; 
 Dead Boots Gawping With Limp Sock Tongues. 
 Gee, what a dump. 
 Sleep came, knocked her out some way past four. 
 She woke with the radio and light on. 
 The moth was still fluttering between the pane and pinned scarlet cotton. 
 RoboJay took over in the morning. 
 Put the kettle on,  spooned coffee, rolled a cigarette, sat up in bed again and hoped the horrors had forgotten her address. 
 Jay liked to phone her friends in the morning. 
 A sort of hi I'm here and how are you, have a nice day. 
 She was actually giggling with Francis when the moth swooped into the cave: her light and ever-shaded windows guaranteed a sort of candlelit stalactite effect. 
 Of course the moth went for the light, Jay went under the pillow, and the moth settled on a huge picture she had of a golden African dawn. 
 It was in fact a butterfly, tawny orange like a tiger with a purple and black lace frill to its wings. 
 It shuttled around on the picture. 
 She couldn't kill a butterfly. 
 Even one daft enough to wake up in early February. 
 She had a bath. 
 Her house was falling down, a tree growing out of the chimney, and purple buddleia all summer from the guttering and up over her windowsills. 
 This fool butterfly must have been a chrysallis &mdash; there are a million tortoiseshells pirouetting on the purple flowers all the warm months &mdash; a chrysallis left from last August. 
 Fooled by the fake spring amazing everyone into bright cotton, courtesy of a destroyed ozone layer and a rogue wind from the Sahara. 
 Poor butterfly. 
 There was sweet nothing in the way of nectar and what duped flowers had burst out of the ground were in for a shock when the frosts came. 
 &bquo;Hum,&equo; Jay said to Francis over their caf&eacute; breakfast, &bquo;I have a butterfly in my bedroom.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; said he. 
 &bquo;You'd better buy it some flowers. 
 It must be starving.&equo; 
 &bquo;They only live a day,&equo; said a loony from the next table. 
 &bquo;That's mayflies,&equo; Jay said. 
 She left to do some shopping and forgot the flowers. 
 Poor butterfly. 
 It was nowhere in sight. 
 But the sun tugged her out of bed the next day and  there was the butterfly, still fluttering. 
 Jay unpinned the batik, unscrewed the lock and pushed the window up. 
 Now all Madame Butterfly had to do was climb down a piece of wood twice her height and fly free. 
 Bright little creature &mdash; it took her just three minutes to work this out as her antennae fluttered in the sudden sweet smelling breeze. 
 Jay watched her go, dip down, dip up, over the edge of the guttering. 
 Two weeks later it snowed, Jay thought of the butterfly as the thick white flakes tumbled around. 
 Hoped to God she had found a leaf somewhere. 
 But in a moment, the sun was blazing, the sky blue as cornflowers. 
 CHAPTER THIRTY-ONE 
 Jay's life had not exactly prepared her for falling In Love, still less for I was never in love with you . 
 How to make sense of Lucy and this dizzying all-consuming pain; how to find a meaning for her life which had only acquired meaning with Lucy as its radiant centre. 
 Not just an incomprehensible episode, but a meaningless present. 
 So she ran through those utterly devastating transformations when she had been In Love, desperately seeking patterns, pointers &mdash; digging for something to bring back her joy, her I will survive . 
 First time she was seventeen. 
 And now, nearly twenty years after it was well and truly over, she sometimes still reeled late at night with not understanding. 
 Baby where did our love go, what went wrong, what did I do wrong ?  
 Francis just made a tragi-comic face and said: 
 &bquo;Darling, I don't even understand ME! 
 No one ever understands anyone, dear. 
 I don't know why you bother. 
 Give it up!&equo; 
 And why did she bother? 
 How could she and how could she not give it up? 
 Because it drove her every moment. 
 Her skin was alive with the memory of Lucy's touch; her fingertips alive with Lucy's skin; her lips an agony and ecstasy of kissing Lucy. 
 She read that your life's work is finding who you are and then being it. 
 At thirty-seven she could only say for sure who she was not and she felt that time was running out. 
 Would it have been easier if she hadn't seen Lucy almost every day for four years going into or out of the office next door? 
 Seeing her had become part of her life, first pleasant, then ecstatic, then the whole reason for being. 
 The corridor held memories, the walls recalled shadows, the floor echoed with the sound of her walk. 
 The ecology people were still mailing all sorts of publications to her, and her mouth would set hard with pain when she read Lucy's name in a list of credits or committee members. 
 But she was gone. 
 For Jay absence had only ever made the heart grow fonder. 
 Now, absence paralysed her in sheer aching agony. 
 Jesus, she raged, my life is a string of clich&eacute;s. 
 &bquo;OK,&equo; said Francis, &bquo;I've given you months, darling. 
 Slenderness is one thing, anorexia another; heartbroken agony is one thing, living pain is just not right. 
 You need a holiday. 
 The magazine will just have to lurch along snuggled up to me and my ageing haemorrhoids for a few weeks. 
 Go away. 
 Take care of yourself. 
 Go.&equo; 
 In fact Francis booked the holiday and drove her to the airport. 
 &bquo;Get drunk,&equo; he advised. 
 &bquo;I would recommend a little holiday romance.&equo;  
 &bquo;I don't give myself permission, Francis,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;Imagine inflicting myself on anyone in this state. 
 I'd burst into tears all the time. 
 I've just had open-heart surgery, remember?&equo; 
 &bquo;You must just forget, dear. 
 Scrub round it. 
 Lucy is bad for your psyche. 
 And it's a very nice psyche.&equo; 
 CHAPTER THIRTY-TWO 
 Jay sat on the white balcony, shaded from a Mediterranean sun burning off white walls, sparking off a turquoise sea where the bright sails of a skiff were silk balloons shot with dazzle, sparkles of pure light bursting behind the boat as it skimmed the perfect waters. 
 She had brought detective novels and thrillers and cursed her hectic reading speed: only the second day and she was half-way down the pile. 
 But then she shrugged: every plot was so eminently forgettable, she could start again, once she was through. 
 She watched her bare toe rub against the whitened concrete of the balcony. 
 It was a nice toe, she decided. 
 Here's to you, toe, she said, raising her long clear glass of white wine and mineral water, where the ice cubes had long since melted. 
 That's what holidays were for &mdash; looking at your toes, wandering on the beach, hours of sitting and staring, standing and staring, lying as long as you could bear in the sun with eyes closed. 
 The perfect place to mend a broken heart &mdash; no, she said, stop that &mdash; a jaded  heart and soul. 
 And a certain party's name was not to cross her mind, rather, if it did, she was to wipe it out with a picture of her favourite places, backed by her favourite music. 
 So  far she'd run a mind-movie of Malvern with Elgar, the Outer Hebrides with Mendelssohn, Box Hill with Vivaldi, Santa Cruz with The Beach Boys, Baltimore with Laurie Anderson, and Corfu with Grieg. 
 Well, it was only her second day. 
 The night before she had woken uneasy. 
 Was it the sound of someone crying close at hand? 
 But the dark night was filled with the metallic throbbing of insects, waves on the sand, and she got up and stood naked on the balcony. 
 The moon was a slender crescent, and a few tattered clouds shuffled across the perfect dome of blue-black sky. 
 She watched as night-grey filtered out to recognisable shapes: the beached boats, the shifting edge of the sea, the low houses slung along the road. 
 There was a light in the next window and she drew back into deep shadow. 
 The off-season hotel had been empty when she arrived. 
 They were expecting Club 18&ndash;30, but she would be long gone before that intrusion. 
 Company she did not want. 
 You will find us very quiet, the manager had said, c est la vie. 
 They were eight merciful miles from a holiday mecca. 
 Over on the horizon there was a dark-blue smudge of land to be seen only in first clear light. 
 The hotelier said it was Italy. 
 The ceiling of the Sistine Chapel. 
 Uh oh. 
 She stretched and showered, screamed along with a flashback of Jamie at The Pink Flamingo and There ain't nothin' like a dame ! 
 She sauntered back to the view and Miss Blandish, but swept her sunglasses on with instinctive irritation as she saw a figure on the next balcony. 
 She held a book as if reading and sipped wine. 
 Five yards away a woman sat almost in profile, a white towelling robe easy on her shoulders. 
 She held a book, reached out to a tall glass of pale gold wine, a twin to Jay's. 
 She bent and fiddled with a machine at her feet.  
 God! thought Jay, stiffening, bloody radios! 
 But she relaxed at the sound of Schubert. 
 The sure delicacy of the notes tripped through the air, dancing in the glare of the sun, moving with the light breeze in the parched trees, the uneasy rustle in the blue-green dune grass. 
 Jay smiled. 
 If there must be a neighbour, let her have good taste. 
 And foresight enough to bring her own music. 
 The woman had short very black hair, stylishly cut away from the curve of her jaw; her head was upright, and her firm chin rested on one hand. 
 A tendril of smoke lazed through the air from a cigarette. 
 Her skin was pale, and as Jay watched, she leaned forward and massaged sun-cream into her calves with such concentration and pleasure that Jay was transfixed. 
 Suddenly the woman turned. 
 &bquo;Oh, I'm sorry,&equo; she called, when she saw Jay. 
 &bquo; Mille pardons ! 
 She switched off the music. 
 &bquo;No, no,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;it's OK. 
 Please. 
 I love Schubert. 
 Really.&equo; 
 &bquo;Really?&equo; said the woman anxiously. 
 Jay realised her dark glasses cut off eye contact. 
 She took them off. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; she said, &bquo;I'd love you to play more. 
 Here's to Schubert!&equo; 
 She raised her glass, smiled briefly as the woman raised hers, and looked down at her book. 
 The music continued, and the print flowed past Jay's eyes. 
 At the third corpse there was a faint click, and she looked up as the music stopped. 
 The woman had gone inside. 
 Shame, thought Jay, that was very pleasant. 
 You can tell we're English, she thought that evening as they sat four tables apart in the dining room, books  propped against their separate water jugs. 
 The waiter flurried between them, as busy as if the room were full. 
 A huge local family came in as she was drinking coffee, and suddenly there were voices and laughter as they arranged the stately grandmother at the head of the table, the boisterous children banished to the other end. 
 On an impulse, Jay scribbled a note and beckoned the waiter. 
 The woman turned a page of her book. 
 &bquo; Un Armagnac pour la dame &mdash; l&agrave; &mdash; s'il vous plait ,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo; L'anglaise ?&equo; said the waiter, impassive. 
 &bquo;Oui,&equo; she said, and gave him the folded note. 
 The woman looked up as the waiter made a great show of placing the glass with its golden contents beside her, and nodded his head towards Jay. 
 The woman turned and looked frankly puzzled, unfolding the note. 
 Then she smiled, radiant, but God, she looked weary. 
 The note has said simply: Merci pour Schubert . 
 She raised her glass to Jay, then gathered bag and book and paused at Jay's table. 
 &bquo;I'm glad you like Schubert,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Jay, smiling. 
 &bquo;You do like Armagnac, I hope?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, yes,&equo; said the woman, &bquo;thank you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do join me,&equo; said Jay, &bquo;if you like.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps we could have a drink outside,&equo; said the woman as the French family exploded with bellowed laughter and banging fists. 
 &bquo; Deux Armagnacs, s'il vous pla&icirc;t &equo; said Jay to timmortalshe waiter and they strolled to the table outside the hotel. 
 They sat at the edge of the patio where vines trailed a dusky scent. 
 &bquo;I admire your foresight,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I always forget to bring music.&equo; 
 &bquo;I couldn't be without it,&equo; said the woman. 
 &bquo;Do you like Mozart?&equo;  
 &bquo;Oh, yes,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I shall play some tomorrow,&equo; said the woman, sipping brandy. 
 The light from the window spilled along her cheek and lips, and made a dazzling star in her glass. 
 Jay smiled from her shadow, admitting a lazy, faint and wholly delicious curl of desire. 
 &bquo;Mozart can be anywhere,&equo; she said, &bquo;one of the.&equo; 
 &bquo;Everywhere,&equo; said the woman intensely. 
 &bquo;And to think he was thirty-three when he died.&equo; 
 &bquo;Like Christ,&equo; said Jay. 
 The sea soughed on the shore. 
 They drank another Armagnac. 
 Jay had no inclination to go through the who are you, what do you do, oh really, gosh my brother-in-law used to be in the same field. 
 And the woman showed no signs of starting either. 
 There was something about the firm set of her body that Jay knew instinctively: she was a survivor. 
 Another survivor. 
 She and her music would get through it; just as Jay was forcing herself to thrive on an inimitable diet of white wine and forties Chicago gangland trash. 
 Suddenly, it was chill. 
 &bquo;I think I'll go to bed,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;I'll have a stroll,&equo; said the woman, &bquo;haven't taken any exercise all day.&equo; 
 &bquo; A demain ,&equo; said Jay. 
 It would be nice to see her tomorrow. 
 &bquo;Sweet dreams,&equo; said the woman. 
 She was too far away to speak before Jay realised they hadn't even exchanged names. 
 She strolled upstairs. 
 The air was incredibly hot, and she opened the balcony doors. 
 Caught sight of her neighbour's small grey shape against the blanched sand. 
 She poured herself more brandy and sat on the  balcony, invisible against the dark room. 
 The woman was wandering at random, in loose zigzags it seemed, until Jay's eyes picked out the curling shifting edge of the sea. 
 She was skirting the moving foam, a foot away, and jumped sideways when a wave overreached. 
 After a while, Jay could no longer pick her out against the distant sand, and she lay on the bed, under a sheet, downed the last of her drink, and slept. 
 At three she woke with an uneasy feeling. 
 Someone was crying, from the guts of misery. 
 Jay located the sound: it was the woman next door. 
 But she couldn't lit that self-contained assurance and elegance with this lost and hopeless sobbing. 
 Should she knock? 
 She wanted to: Jay could not bear people suffering. 
 But if she was wrong? 
 She sensed through the darkness, brow creased. 
 The crying stopped, and she breathed easier. 
 She went on to the balcony, pulling on her silk kimono against the cold night. 
 &bquo;Oh, hello,&equo; said the woman on the next balcony. 
 &bquo;Couldn't sleep?&equo; 
 It was a voice which takes charge, organises and copes. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Jay. 
 &bquo;You?&equo; 
 &bquo;Must be the sea air,&equo; said the woman briskly. 
 &bquo;Can't get a wink.&equo; 
 &bquo;Coffee?&equo; said Jay, wondering at herself. 
 &bquo;No, thank you,&equo; said the woman. 
 &bquo;I'd never sleep. 
 But thanks.&equo; 
 Fine, thought Jay, wincing at the way she always overstepped the mark. 
 You're a fucking crusader! had been yelled at her more than once. 
 She lay in bed. 
 Ouch. 
 Now, what about a walk down the River Shannon with a merry fiddle and a melancholy flute? 
 She fell asleep dreaming dragonflies. 
 She rose early, determined to walk the day away, give the  woman her space. 
 They had both clearly come here to be alone. 
 Let it be so, she decided, as she went into the empty dining room. 
 CHAPTER THIRTY-THREE 
 A mile or so along the sand, she sat on a rock, looking at the grey/indigo streak of Italian coastline. 
 The sun coaxed her body to stretch idly as a cat; she tanned easily, adored white heat and turquoise sea. 
 Always wondered what brought her back to the miseries of soggy grey England, the endless winters. 
 Oh, dear. 
 Here comes that name again. 
 Right. 
 Corfu. 
 Corfu the first time, years ago, the summer of Laurie Anderson and O Superman ; the summer she was in love with a difference. 
 The summer she was loved back. 
 Two weeks on perfect sand in sunshine nine to five; she'd returned with an all-over tan feeling wonderful and hey presto, head over heels in love with Astrid! 
 And she was Astrid's first woman. 
 Astrid was married, kids and mortgage, but the summer had rocketed by in a riot of colours and joy, and autumn found Astrid divorced and coming to the end of being in love with Jay. 
 Some you win, thought Jay, however briefly. 
 She remembered their passion for Louis Prima, Fats Waller, Chris Williamson; wild about holographic badges, earrings, stickers. 
 Turquoise glass beads from Murano against Astrid's tanned arm; she wore pastel turquoise dungarees, a tee-shirt the deep green blue of southern seas in a late afternoon. 
 That's why Jay thought her eyes were blue. 
  She told her how beautiful they were, how there had never been such a blue. 
 I have one thing to say to you , said Astrid laughing, two weeks apart and letters every day later, my eyes are green ! 
 Green eyes. 
 Her eyes were also grey like stones through clear water. 
 Pre-Astrid, Jay had been in a dead job, art workshops with utterly disillusioned teenagers, every morning she coughed she rang in sick, malingering Mondays, rain seeped in the doors of the empty bus every morning, the bus to the High Street for the next bus, hoping to be early enough to miss the screaming leering sneering schoolgirls she had to face all day. 
 She was a washed-out wash-out, Miss, why're you such a div ? 
 After she fell in love with Astrid, she became Dragonfly Moonchild, the world her oyster, and for the first time on the daily journey, she saw an adventure playground over the hoardings by the Elephant and Castle, and all the poles were painted like a carousel. 
 Suddenly, there were trees and they were spring-green. 
 She dragged herself from the smoke and choke and bitch and groan of the staffroom every lunchtime to sit in the rose garden in the park. 
 No children or dogs to spoil the gold-fished lily pond. 
 Old people in lavender and tweed sitting against the neat hedges, and roses tumbling along veined and curled beams, timber drydocked after a lifetime at sea. 
 That week, exam week, all she had to do was invigilate. 
 She wrote letters all day, floated around on a lilac cloud, heart beating scarlet with desire for Astrid and the tingling delight of waiting for when she would return. 
 From the family holiday in Tunisia, to come and stay with Jay &mdash; no question that they would be lovers! 
 Jay's rainbow wings fluttered around a sun-sparkling  river that had become her life, where she had been moping by an old canal full of dead shopping trolleys for years. 
 They had a summer full of sand and sea and gold, Jay was blessed with that summer and the sunshine of Astrid's love. 
 But she, she shed her loves in autumn like the trees, and Jay was gusted away in the chill, too late to chrysallis, too late to fly south, too late. 
 And that was the end of Dragonfly Moonchild. 
 For years afterwards, Jay's heart gave a lurch every time she passed the place where they parked &mdash; Astrid drove the three hundred yards from her house so they could kiss in the car before she went to Timisia. 
 They made love in Jay's co-op basement and wandered in Brick Lane market. 
 They giggled with bagels in a park strewn with dog-shit and broken bottles, and pretended it was New York. 
 They painted Astrid's house and made love all the time. 
 They flirted with everybody especially each other. 
 Only last summer, years after it was all over and Astrid had found her stone cottage with roses round the door, golden/grey in a late summer orchard, she met Jay, and her eyes were green as the flames on ashwood. 
 Firelight, evening light. 
 Ho hum. 
 In love meant all the colours, all the sounds, all the sights, sheer joy. 
 But out of love brought ice-age chill, endless snow wastes where wind tossed smoky columns of snow eighty foot high; from these mists lumbered a gallery of primitive animals, blood lust and need raging like her soul. 
 Their hunger was hers, their battle-scarred pelts ached with the gashes on her heart. 
 The voice, the vacuum of denial screamed from her navel, and oh the cold! 
 After love, it was night in the desert,  handfuls of icy sand stinging her skin and eyes. 
 And then it was mammoth time and nothing she could do about it. 
 Yes, Dragonfly Moonchild she had been and loved the summer-child in her. 
 Jay shivered in the solid sunshine and forced memories of the winter after that summer. 
 It had all crystallised at a party. 
 She should not have gone to that party. 
 She closed her eyes and played it back, as if from a great height. 
 Crew-cut Jay, bristling with rage. 
 Not a pretty sight. 
 CHAPTER THIRTY-FOUR 
 Once again, she was drunk. 
 That whole winter she drank with no pleasure. 
 She and Astrid had lollopped through gin sparkling with fresh limes and tonic; late-night hand-warmed brandy, summer wines lighting each day. 
 She drank automatically when It was over, noticed only when her glass was empty and didn't let it stay that way long. 
 Oh no, I'm drunk again . 
 The comic voice and no one's laughing. 
 The first kiss of alcohol warms and soothes the snarling. 
 They didn't want me at this party, but because I AM, fang and claw I have grapple-hooked their smooth cliffs, and have the right to stalk these wooded cliffs, lap at their abundant streams. 
 And I do. 
 Skulk to the waterhole. 
 One drink and the skulk howls away into the night, lean arrogance holds her upright, one shoulder against the wall. 
 She bares her beautiful fangs and her rough pelt fluffs dry, sleek in  the subtle Habitat lighting. 
 Eyes glitter with a memory of the chill snowfields that once claimed her. 
 Her civilised paw curves round a glass. 
 And they stare, can't stop, they know what is said of the claws, the biting words from her jaws, and a shiver tightens the pores of their hairless flesh. 
 They have seen her in the shadows outside the windows of country cottages, and drawn the blinds, dropped the latch. 
 some mangy wolf 
 its rough rust frame 
 on brittle legs of blasted black 
 &mdash; snarl of a husk of hedgerow 
 ranging the dusk full field&hellip; 
 She lounges through the party rooms, a scent of snow as she passes. 
 The bevelled painted doorframe is a winter tree. 
 A glow behind her shaggy head is moonlight, cloud scarred at the change of seasons. 
 She stakes out her territory. 
 &bquo;Sit down, I'll get you a drink.&equo; 
 Weary muscles and taut sinews soothed, she stretches on the carpet. 
 The room arranges itself around her form. 
 They come with a glass. 
 Wariness in their eyes. 
 Propitiation. 
 The liquid brings blood to her face. 
 The faces around her suppliant, wary &mdash; she is in a benevolent lull, she measures out wit and wisdom. 
 They bring more drink. 
 Soon her tongue unleashes. 
 Behind the words a memory of the pack. 
 Where she learnt savagery. 
 Where she would lie still, huddled close to fur scarred and torn, half dead with cold and hunger. 
 Then jerk away, lope alone from the despised warm pulse of life. 
 Born to the pack, but not of it. 
 In her eyes the madness of a starvation that will be satiated, the tempered  contempt of one who will survive. 
 Alone. 
 &bquo;Oh no, she's off again.&equo; 
 The group hears, leers, regroups away from the warning ripples from her slumped body. 
 At her eye level, well-shod heels, well-heeled shoes, above, her, elegantly tailored backs. 
 She attempts a snarl, lost in the chit-chat. 
 Someone sits beside her, a clutch of coals in the snow. 
 Stay. 
 Be warmed. 
 Rest. 
 Be petted. 
 Stay. 
 But she fears the embers' flicker and the night closing in over chill ash. 
 The heals and backs and murmurs are darkness and call a howl from her cells; she lies, almost out of it. 
 The embers die as she denies their warmth. 
 A final flare in the icy wind, the hand is dashed away and lies helpless. 
 She rises, pushing at the carpet, the wall, the doorframe, unsteadily through the party. 
 Lurch. 
 Sorry. 
 Bump. 
 Sorry. 
 Slop. 
 Sorry. 
 Sorry, sorrysorrysorrysorry. 
 Each sorry a slorry slurred whine. 
 She is wearing her party smile which slashes to a snarling slaver and she makes it to the kitchen where cold steal lies on Dutch tiles. 
 Claw and fang. 
 &bquo;Pissed again?&equo; 
 She manoeuvres to face the voice. 
 It repeats its mocking through the haze. 
 The room is dazzling snow, the moon has risen full and cold. 
 The night the pack turned on her, fury in their lean need. 
 Scars throb, pain brings blood to her head and her great paws close on the knife. 
 &bquo;Who asked you, bastard?&equo; 
 Rasped from her gashed throat. 
 They left her, left her to drag herself bleeding to death&hellip; she did not die. 
 She pitches forward. 
 The knife clatters on quarry tiles. 
 &bquo;Bloody lunatic!&equo; 
 &bquo;The woman's an animal!&equo;  
 &bquo;Oh, shit, do I  have to take her home?&equo; 
 &bquo;She's not staying here.&equo; 
 They bundle the puppet-jointed body into the car. 
 It slumps, jolts as it is driven. 
 Street lamps streak her face, a voice streaks unconscious ears as the driver curses the dark, the hour, the traffic, the bloody liability sprawled on the back seat. 
 Three a.m. and the door knocks in the dark street. 
 &bquo;She's pissed again. 
 God, she's done this once too often. 
 This is&hellip; oh HELL!&equo; 
 The body sags against the door, the heavy arms rest around necks and shoulders. 
 They handle the massive limp d&eacute;bris. 
 Consciousness flickers. 
 Tomorrow, sorry, sorry. 
 Tomorrow bravado. 
 She digs claws deep into their shoulders, arches her spine against them. 
 Still they hold and help and she, she needs needs&hellip; needs to&hellip; 
 She flings her great head at one of them and rests against a skull. 
 Breath drags in. 
 A final effort. 
 Fighting the shadows in the dark air, she bares her teeth and sinks them deep, through hair, through pulsing flesh, to the bone. 
 That winter had been savage, she had been savage that winter. 
 What had redeemed her? 
 Oh, yes, she remembered, inwardly arching her eyebrows! hmm , so you recall, do you, Jay ? 
 Surprise, surprise it had been: Falling in love again. 
 With Dionne. 
 Delight that she could be stirred by another person. 
 They had flirted from the word go, had a lorra lorra fun, in bed and out. 
 Dionne said it wasn't love, but who's counting? 
 The sex had drifted away after a while, and Jay didn't mind; not in that end-of-the-world Astrid way. 
 And Dionne stayed friends; a friend who fucked sometimes. 
 Jay had then sworn off love.  
 Too painful, darling! 
 And then came Lucy. 
 Jay had run out of travelogue and music. 
 Well, not quite, but she felt safer after the memory of other loves, other times when she had been happy. 
 And the beginning of Lucy and her had been lyrically beautiful, the stuff that dreams are made of. 
 Live your dreams! 
 Forget the last six months, admit it's been more like a year, remove yourself from the desperate turns on the rack of rejection&hellip; at least you know how to love . 
 Words bubbled in Jay's mind with an absurdly happy smile. 
 She reached for her notebook and cigarettes and played the words around, wielded their texture and richness to sculpt a poem to her joy. 
 A poem for her  eyes only, a poem she liked. 
 There would be no more In Love redemption, thought Jay, in fact all she knew was that she didn't know what Love was. 
 Some conclusion, Baby Jay! 
 She decided to treat herself as good as she would if she was In Love with Jay. 
 For example, now, she would be gathering shells to show to The Beloved, searching for ways to describe the perfect Disney sky. 
 She felt like a total loony doing these things for herself. 
 Perhaps that was why people who talked to themselves usually had an abstracted smile: they had accepted they were stark raving mad, loony tunes, round the twist. 
 We're all maaa-aaaaaaad, darling ! 
 And walked back to the hotel minus her ball and chain. 
 As May Sarton had said (and Jay thought of May Sarton as a cross between a saint and a guru): The muse is always female . 
 Jay lived best when inspired; for her love had always  been the inspiration; she lived and wrote from passion, passion which led to the abyss. 
 But always out of it again. 
 Rose, Astrid, Dionne (a little), and now the chasm of Lucy. 
 Could she do this one alone? 
 Break a pattern and emerge into the daylight without the hovering angel face of a new In Love ? 
 Did she only feel good because of the unexpected fillip of her highly attractive anonymous new neighbour? 
 Certainly that was a part of it: fear of in love and rejection had sent Jay along the sands away from her, away from the pattern of I-love-her, she-loves-me-not. 
 It wasn't even love. 
 I fancy her, said Jay aloud. 
 I fancy her, and why the hell not? 
 Enjoy, enjoy! 
 Jay stripped her clothes off and plunged into the sea, still smiling! 
 Ha, you demons, she thought with every foam-headed wave cuffing her, there's a dance in the old dame yet! 
 Floating beyond the foam, she closed her eyes against the sin. 
 The problem, she thought, in the hotel room, dressing to delight herself, delighted to be objective, to be smiling still, the problem: how to do all that, how to feel alive and brimming without a love object. 
 But, suddenly, spooning soup, a bitter bubble of self-loathing stopped Jay's throat. 
 From deep inside, a jeer, a sneer. 
 &bquo;Yah! 
 Look at you!&equo; it spat. 
 &bquo;Who are you trying to kid?&equo; 
 She froze her face. 
 Tears again, she felt like the child she had been when her father gave wild stinging slaps to her legs by way of welcome after she'd run away from home. 
 His was the snarling rage, hers the shame as she peed and peed and swore one day to be big enough to beat him, razor his skin, utterly humiliate him, and scorn his cries for mercy. 
 The voice continued: she listened, telling it Damn you! 
 Speak your frowsty worst &mdash; go on !  
 &bquo;Yeah,&equo; it said with relish, &bquo;you think you'll forget about your precious Lucy just because you're a few hundred miles away? 
 Pathetic, that's what you are, futile. 
 You never forget anything, you never let go. 
 Jesus! 
 If she crooked her precious little finger you'd be running. 
 You'll be weeping about Lucy when you're fifty and fat.&equo; 
 Go on , she told the voice with deadpan strength, futile, fat, fifty, is that your worst ? 
 &bquo;You stink,&equo; said the voice, steely cold. 
 &bquo;You never do anything right, you never do anything for the right reasons. 
 You always fuck up.&equo; 
 Useless to list her achievements under this acid rain of self-destruction. 
 &bquo;Gah!&equo; said the filthy creature worming along her bones and veins, &bquo;you thought you'd chat up  that woman, didn't you?&equo; 
 Maybe. 
 &bquo;Maybe?!&equo; the voice raised a shaggy eyebrow. 
 &bquo;She looks a little like your Lucy, had you noticed? 
 Your Lucy? 
 Let's get the facts right. 
 Not your Lucy, never was, never will be. 
 Do you think you can fool me, Armagnac at sunset? 
 Out of love and in again? 
 Do you really believe love can save you from you?&equo; 
 Jay could have slammed her head against the table and wept. 
 The scourging voice always did this, whatever golden kernel of hope she treasured, so scared of losing it, it was almost a secret even to herself&hellip; the voice seized it, shredded it, pissed on it, trampled it. 
 All the time with other people she was acting, confident and charming; backstage alone, the pain in her eyes glared at her from a bright-lit make-up mirror, weeping at the tawdriness of it all, scorning costume and plot and witty script. 
 &bquo;You don't fool me!&equo; 
 The voice surveyed the wasteland it had made and stormed away. 
 Whimper like a  whipped puppy, Jay, have a drink and pick up the pieces. 
 Alcohol and phonecalls, after an attack she would not let herself be too sober or alone. 
 Her dreams at these times were of running headlong down streets and staircases, into cellars where the roof and walls closed in on her. 
 Running as the street collapsed behind her, running as if from Sodom and Gomorrah, from a nuclear blast. 
 She never looked back to see what was chasing her, just woke in a cramped sweat, breathless and in tears. 
 CHAPTER THIRTY-FIVE 
 But she had read that if you turn and f ace the nameless fear, just once, you never have that dream again. 
 OK. 
 You're just an animal! 
 Jay decided to gamble with this thing inside her, deep as her blood and bones. 
 Gambling to lose her demons. 
 She had felt so free and lithe along the beach. 
 The stakes were high. 
 Let's play, then , she said, sitting outside alone. 
 Yeah, said the voice, just a bloody animal, driven by hunger and sex. 
 I am actually a mammoth , said Jay, only I survived all your ice ages. 
 I may even learn to tango ! 
 You're talking shit. 
 You chose animals. 
 Most people opt for the furry friendliness of the cat family. 
 Or the big-eyed cutesy seals. 
 Or the lean-flanked wild and free horse. 
 Or the do-probe-me inaccessibility of a porcupine. 
 Jamie has no demons like you and defies you with being a skunk  Repulsive to humanity and most of the animal kingdom, but irresistible to another skunk! 
 Someday I may meet another mammoth . 
 The voice went silent. 
 But Jay continued. 
 She had been herself, until St Patrick's Day and In Love. 
 More or less fancied herself as a fox, the largest predator in the British Isles, beautiful pelt, amber eyes, full and gorgeous tail; a stink to drive away the timid. 
 Sexy, sexy, sexy. 
 And under the green hypnotic gaze of Lucy, a suspicious wild cat, sheathing its claws and desiring a hearth, a heart. 
 Chameleon, ever eager to fit in? 
 Selling out? 
 Jay would have sold her grandmother (if she'd had one) for Lucy's approval. 
 House cat? 
 Puppy? 
 Anything to have Lucy scoop her up from her scrubbed doorstep. 
 You'll never keep it up! the voice was back with all it could muster as vengeance. 
 Just watch it , said Jay, sipping brandy, breathing fire, I may just stomp you with my hairy great mammoth foot . 
 Just wait till you fall In Love again! 
 Oh, it's threat time, is it ? 
 Jay closed her eyes and concentrated. 
 Fee Fi Fo Fum &mdash; I'm Not In Love With Anyone! 
 And now, she thought in the blessed silence, my dear Jay, what would you  like to do? 
 The woman next door came and sat beside her. 
 Jay descended from the heights of near madness to wish her a warm good evening. 
 Armagnac on the terrace? 
 How charming! 
 I like that! 
 I missed you today , said the woman. 
 I played the Elvira Madigan Mozart, you would have liked it . 
 I do , said Jay. 
 Very much .  
 Well, let's hear it now , said the woman. 
 They went upstairs. 
 The woman's room was bare as Jay's. 
 So Jay drifted next door for her dregs of brandy. 
 And the woman &mdash; whose name, it happened, was Aurora &mdash; whittered on about an infidelity performed against her by a titled husband, an imminent divorce, a Sunday paper scandal. 
 &bquo;Mm,&equo; said Jay, immersed in Mozart. 
 &bquo;None of which has any relevance to you,&equo; said the woman, &bquo;but it's nice and polite of you to listen.&equo; 
 Jay was waiting for the soul-inspired Adagio . 
 Aurora re-filled their glasses, brushed Jay's hand rather unnecessarily as she set her glass down. 
 &bquo;So,&equo; said Aurora, &bquo;what brings you here?&equo; 
 Suddenly, a long-held bubble of laughter hurtled through Jay as the immaculate second movement started. 
 She sipped brandy, held it on her tongue, set herself alight. 
 She knew her animal, all at once, no question: not cutesy, not brave, not magnificent. 
 Just solid and misunderstood. 
 Welcome home, mammoth, home to a real fire. 
 &bquo;What brings you  here?&equo; said Aurora again, breathily, as if it mattered, flicking out the light and sitting again with practised gaucherie. 
 Jay sat back in her chair. 
 She looked at Aurora. 
 &bquo;Honey,&equo; she said, with a real slow smile, &bquo;Honey, don't let me commence !  
 USING THE RULES TO HELP YOU WIN 
 It is surprising how many people take part in competition without knowing the rules, even at &eacute;lite level. 
 This chapter will examine the rules of competition from the competitors' point of view, rather than from the referees'. 
 It will show how a knowledge of the rules can be used to help your tournament training by outlining the following: 
 &bull; 
 the kind of fitness requirements you need 
 &bull; 
 the most often scored techniques, explaining why they scored 
 &bull; 
 why techniques failed to score when you felt they should have 
 &bull; 
 how injuries are dealt with 
 &bull; 
 how to ensure that any complaint you make is correctly dealt with. 
 The competition area 
 In principle this is 8m x 8m (9.5yd x 9.5yd) but in practice it may shrink to only 7m x 7m (8.3yd x 8.3yd) in order to fit enough areas in the available space. 
 Many tournament organisers miscalculate entry levels with the result that adjacent areas are crowded together and the competitors' safety is  imperilled. 
 Often the run-off zone is missing. 
 This is a one metre band marked inside the outer perimeter. 
 It is sometimes highlighted by using different coloured mats and its purpose is to alert you when you approach the mat boundary. 
 Since you can pick up penalties for stepping out, even inadvertently, it makes sense to get used to sparring in a competition-sized square. 
 This is very important because a tactically-minded competitor can crowd an inexperienced opponent out of the area, picking up points without even exchanging a technique. 
 You must always be able to locate your position within an 8-metre square 
 Normal free-sparring in the training hall is limited only by the number of people there, so you can pick up bad competition habits through using space uneconomically. 
 Therefore do all your final training in an 8 m x 8 m (9.5 yd x 9.5 yd) area and get used to knowing exactly where you are in it. 
 Safety 
 Virtually all competition now takes place on mats, since hard floors are known to present a hazard to the falling competitor. 
 However, mats can themselves pose hazards, and it is as well if you are aware of these. 
 Firstly, mat modules can come apart, and if the referee fails to notice this the competitor may be injured when his foot slips into the gap. 
 Broken ankles are not uncommon in competition karate! 
 Secondly, some mats are very &bquo;sticky&equo;, preventing your feet from sliding easily over them. 
 This is important when you throw a roundhouse kick and the supporting foot is prevented from swivelling. 
 Finally, mats are very often spongy, requiring you to lift your foot well clear before stepping. 
 Obviously you cannot know in advance which type of mat will be used at a particular tournament, so you should do your final training on any type of mat, just to get used to the feel, and then try to use any free time you may have on the actual competition areas to get a little practice in beforehand. 
 Some competitions provide a warm-up area matted with the same material as the actual competition area. 
 Check this out and use it if it is available. 
 Get those who are with you on the mat to sit down so that the emergency services have a clear view across the area and can move quickly in the event of accident. 
 Check for any areas of hazard such as pillars, radiators, chairs or competitors' bags near the area &mdash; anything, in fact, that might cause you injury if you ploughed into it at speed. 
 Clothing 
 Ensure that you are well turned out in a clean, white karategi that is free of open tears and rips. 
 Coloured gis, black edging, or stripes are not normally permitted. 
 The sleeves must come at least mid-way down the forearm and they must not be folded, since this can lead to injury. 
 Similarly the trousers must come at least mid-way down the shins and must not have fraying edges which can whip across the opponent's eyes. 
 Check beforehand if you intend to wear a badge because, if the rules are being strictly interpreted, only a single national or association badge will be permitted. 
 You will have to wear an identifying red or white belt either in place of your normal grade belt or in addition to it. 
 The Japanese word for red is aka , and for  white, shiro . 
 Remember which is which by bearing in mind that aka, like red, has three letters while shiro, like white, has five. 
 The colour you are assigned arises from your position in the draw, but this may change from round to round, so don't go to the same position as you went to previously. 
 Make it a rule always to check with the scorekeeper before going on to the area. 
 Many times the wrong name has gone forwards to the next round because competitors confused who was white and who was red. 
 Take off the coloured belt after you leave the area so that you won't have stewards chasing after you for it! 
 Protective equipment 
 You must wear white fist protectors of an approved type. 
 These have only one centimetre of padding and leave the thumb free to fold in safely. 
 Always train with these mitts to get used to the additional range they allow, and to experience what an acceptable impact feels like. 
 Never train with heavily padded mitts or you will come to rely upon the extra cushioning effect which is not there with the competition version. 
 Some competition organisers allow shin/instep protectors. 
 Check early on whether these will be allowed; the information is normally contained in the details which accompany the application form. 
 If the information is missing, when contact the organiser to find out. 
 Then you can tailor your training accordingly. 
 Shin/instep protectors which close with velcro are more heavily padded than the tube variety and so allow a greater leeway in impact. 
 You will soon notice the difference if you make a sudden switch between the two. 
 Although groin guards are mandatory for all male competitors, referees have no way of checking that they are being worn. 
 However, if you receive a groin kick and it is discovered that you are not wearing a guard, then you will automatically be disqualified, regardless of whose fault the low kick was! 
 Do not use the plastic cups that slip inside jock straps. 
 Not only do these shatter on hard impact, but the edges have been known to nip off any parts straying outside when an incoming kick is struck home. 
 Buy a boxing-type groin guard instead. 
 Female contestants are sometimes advised to wear a sanitary towel to protect the perineum from injury, but I have never known such an injury to arise. 
 The breasts take more than their fair share of impacts both during competition and during training. 
 This is because they are close to the most frequently attacked scoring area. 
 If the less frequently attacked male groin must be protected by a guard, then it follows that chest protectors ought to be compulsory for female contestants. 
 These are plastic shields which cover the breasts. 
 However, I am not happy with the protectors I have seen and would advise all female contestants to buy a World Taekwondo Federation (WTF) padded jacket for their sparring practice. 
 This is much more effective at muting impacts than any breast shield and though it is not allowed in competition proper, it removes much of the risk from pre-competition training. 
 I would not advise any female competitor to rely upon a firm bra as a means of protection, because all that does is hold the breasts so that they can't move freely under impact. 
 In my view, such bras are capable of causing more damage by trapping breast tissue between the rib cage and the incoming blow. 
 Choose the protection which you feel best suits you, then train with it so that you become use to any constrictions it causes. 
 Female competitors may also wear a plain white T-shirt beneath their jackets.  
 Spectacles are not allowed, so if you can't see well enough without them but want to compete anyway you should either get a pair of soft contact lenses or see how you manage without glasses. 
 Contact lenses often get lost during competition, so bear this in mind before you spend a hefty sum on them. 
 Since karate competition is all about landing a controlled technique, it follows that shortsighted competitors may pose a danger both to themselves and to their opponents. 
 You will not be allowed to wear a sweatband or jewellery such as earrings, necklaces, bracelets or rings. 
 Smooth rings which cannot be removed may be taped over. 
 If you can't remove an otherwise dangerous ring (in the opinion of the referee, that is), then you will be disbarred from competition. 
 Sikh competitors will, on prior application to the Chief Referee, be allowed to wear modified ritual headgear. 
 Long hair must be held back with an elastic band: clasps and metal grips are not allowed. 
 Ensure that your fingernails and toenails are clean and are cut short so that they don't pose a danger to the opponent. 
 Organization of competitions 
 Sparring competition is divided into the following categories: Men's Senior (over 21 years of age on the day of competition); Women's (over 18 years on the day of competition); Men's junior (over 18 but below 21 years on the day of competition); and Male Cadets (over 16 but below 18 years on the day of competition). 
 Juniors are also allowed to fight in the Senior event. 
 Some karate associations hold competitions for 12 year olds. 
 Coaches are generally asked to give an undertaking that their entries all comply with age ceilings. 
 If this undertaking is subsequently challenged and found wanting, then the entire entry can be disqualified and any titles won, forfeited. 
 International competition requires that you present a passport which has your date of birth. 
 This eliminates ineligible competitors on the grounds of age, and also shows whether that competitor is a citizen of the country he represents. 
 Some &eacute;lite karateka have travelled all the way to an international competition only to be disbarred because they never took out their passports! 
 Team events 
 There are both team and individual events. 
 Women's teams consist of three competitors plus one reserve. 
 Men's teams comprise five competitors plus two reserves. 
 Team sizes can be varied but they are always made up of an odd number of competitors. 
 Fighting order 
 Before each round of a team match the team's representative must hand in a list of competitors to the area scorekeeper, specifying the order in which they will compete. 
 If no list is submitted, then any list submitted in earlier rounds will be deemed still to apply. 
 This is not something to take lightly because if the team does not field competitors in the way described on the list, then that team can be disqualified. 
 Remember, use of a reserve requires a new notice of the fighting order. 
 Reserves can be substituted between rounds at the discretion of the team coach.  
 Generally, it is best to send out a strong opener, that is someone who can be relied upon to go all out for a victory. 
 This lifts the team's morale and encourages the next in line. 
 If any team member is at all suspect, the coach should put them into third position. 
 With two wins already gained and two more strong performers to come, the middle position is ideally suited for the weakest member. 
 The last two competitors may be called upon to save the day, so always ensure that you keep at least one good finisher in hand. 
 Such people should be able to fight well from a lagging position. 
 Each male team must field at least three competitors and each female team, two. 
 In this way, short-handed teams still have a chance to win and the match is therefore meaningful. 
 A successful team may have to go through a number of fights during the course of a day's competition so it is not at all unusual to see teams short-handed through injury in the final stages. 
 Never be tempted to forfeit the last two bouts of a male team match, or the last bout of a female team match if you have already seen your team take the deciding first three/two victories. 
 Although the opposing team has no chance of winning, any attempt to withdraw your remaining team-member(s) may well be rewarded by disqualification of the entire team for bad sportsmanship. 
 Sometimes an event is at first delayed but then things happen fast. 
 Should this occur, a team which is relaxing may find itself out of earshot when their name is called. 
 It is therefore vital that each team nominates an observer to monitor what is happening in the arena. 
 Otherwise, if the team doesn't show up after one or two public announcements, they may well be disbarred. 
 Any team, or part of an entry, which withdraws from the competition at short notice may find the whole of its entry cancelled by the tournament organisers. 
 The day of the competition 
 Ensure your entry arrives at the competition venue in sufficient time to register and weigh-in. 
 Many entries face unexpected travel delays and arrive to find the tournament already progressed beyond their level of entry. 
 Important competitions need proper preparation and adequate rest the night before. 
 Therefore try to arrive at the venue a day early. 
 It is the first duty of any coach arriving at a competition to get hold of a current draw sheet, identify the areas on which his entries will be competing and confirm the timetable. 
 Weight categories 
 Individual competition is fought under the following weight categories: Men Women &mdash; 60 kilos &mdash; 65 kilos &mdash; 70 kilos &mdash; 53 kilos, &mdash; 60 kilos &mdash; 75 kilos &mdash; 80 kilos + 80 kilos +60 kilos Open weight (Male Senior only) (Min. weight is + 43 kilos) 
 Weight categories ensure that individuals are more closely matched than they are in team events. 
 I have seen a &mdash; 65 kilo male face a +90 kilo opponent in  team category and the outcome was not pretty! 
 My advice to all lightweights is only to consider individual categories and to leave team competition to the heavyweights. 
 Although it is a great advantage to be just inside your weight category, some contestants forget that even a glass of water can tip them over. 
 At every competition you will see karateka working hard to sweat off the extra weight in time for a re-weigh. 
 Usually, by the time they have lost enough weight, they are totally fatigued! 
 An even more dangerous practice is to take a diuretic. 
 This can reduce weight but it also constitutes drug-taking, for which you may face a lifetime ban. 
 A few grams can be legitimately shed by stripping to undershorts and T &mdash; shirts. 
 The good coach weighs individual entries on accurate scales and warns any marginals to take care. 
 Normally organisers will allow you to re-weigh on another set of scales if you believe that a particular set is reading heavy. 
 Documentation 
 Finally, ensure that you bring the required documentation with you. 
 For example, many British competitions require you to produce a current Martial Arts Commission licence on the day. 
 I have seen many &eacute;lite faces sidelined by forgetting this requirement, so ensure that you are properly prepared. 
 The good coach always takes a few unissued licences along on the day for those who have forgotten theirs. 
 The contest itself 
 Karate competition is held in single two-minute bouts, though this is extended to three minutes in Senior Male competition. 
 The time taken up by pauses is not counted in bout time. 
 This, then, defines the extent of the stamina which your training programme must develop so that you are capable of maintaining a relentless and powerful onslaught for the whole bout. 
 Aim for a margin of safety by allowing for a further two to three minutes' &bquo;sudden death&equo; extension after that. 
 However, there will always be a pause of at least one minute between successive stages. 
 Bout time 
 The first bell you hear is the 30 seconds' warning. 
 Don't confuse this with the time-up bell, especially when many areas are in close proximity and all are using the same type of bell. 
 Always wait for the referee to stop the bout and never drop your guard on the bell. 
 Also, step back from engagement, never forward; an exciting bout generates a great deal of noise and sometimes the opponent doesn't hear the referee's call to stop the bout. 
 I have seen a disengaging contestant step forwards straight into the path of an incoming technique. 
 Scoring 
 There is a scoring ceiling of three full points in each bout. 
 These can be scored as full points, or as combination of full or half-points which, taken together, make up three points. 
 The bout is over as soon as either contestant achieves that score. 
 A full point score is given for a powerful, skilful technique that lands with  control on a scoring area of the opponent's head or body. 
 Elements such as correct distance, timing and a prompt withdrawal to an effective position are integral to the award of a full point score. 
 Theoretically, most referees are supposed to look for full points in the first instance and half-points afterwards. 
 But in practice they award half-points more often than full points because, I suspect, they want to be seen to have a high standard. 
 The half-point is awarded for techniques which are considered to meet 90% of the requirements for a full point score. 
 A technique which is slightly deficient in those criteria necessary for a full point may nevertheless merit a full point if it is a kick to the head. 
 High kicks are inherently more difficult to use than a simple reverse punch to mid-section, so the referee panel relaxes the standards somewhat. 
 This is not to say, however, that any old kick will do. 
 Half-points will also be upgraded to full points for techniques which catch the opponent as he attacks; for deflecting the opponent and scoring on his undefended back; for techniques which immediately follow a sweep or throw; for an onslaught of continuous and effective attacks, each component of which scored in its own right. 
 The scoring areas 
 The scoring areas of the opponent's body are the face, head, neck, chest, abdomen and back. 
 Attacks to the abdomen must be no lower than the bottom edge of the belt. 
 If you deliver an effective technique at the very moment that the time-up bell sounds, then your score will be accepted. 
 Notice that the bell and not the referee calling a halt is the deciding factor here. 
 Often the referee does not hear the final bell and allows the bout to continue, but even if this does  happen, no points can be scored. 
 If your technique is delivered after the referee called for a halt, then as well as not scoring you may also pick up a penalty. 
 A full point score is given for a powerful, skilful and controlled technique to the opponent's scoring areas 
 You can only score if your centre of gravity is inside the area as your technique makes contact. 
 It does not matter if the opponent steps out as long as your technique strikes home before the referee has time to stop the bout. 
 If you and the opponent land scoring techniques on each other at precisely the same time, then neither score will be given. 
 Actually, this seldom happens and one technique usually lands before the other. 
 Nevertheless, many referees take the easy option and give a simultaneous score decision. 
 This is all the more annoying when one person's attack wasn't valid anyway because it missed the scoring area, or was otherwise unacceptable. 
 Some referees appear to see only one half of a pair of techniques and, while reverse punches are seldom missed, snap punches to the face often are. 
 In such cases, the reverse punch may be given simply because the referee failed to recognise the snap punch. 
 Another important factor is the referee's line of sight. 
 Ordinarily the referee and judge remain on opposite sides of the contestants but sometimes, for example when the latter are circling each other, both end up on the same side. 
 Unfortunately, this may be precisely when your scoring technique thumps home but if the panel can't see it, they can't award a point.  
 Simultaneous scores are disallowed; in this case, one contestant's punch has missed, so it is not really a simultaneous score at all! 
 The technique's impact must be seen in order to be scored. 
 Here it has been delivered on the referee's blind side 
 Decision &mdash; wins and ties 
 Not all bouts conclude with a full three point score and when this happens the decision will be given to the contestant with the most points. 
 Where the points score is equal, a decision can still be given if the panel thinks that one contestant used better techniques, used a greater variety of effective techniques, or made more of the running. 
 Actually, you need to be very much better than your opponent to benefit from a superiority decision; a slight difference will not do. 
 When all else fails, a draw is awarded. 
 Team matches are decided on the number of bouts won by each side. 
 Where these are equal, the number of points scored in total by each team is compared. 
 If this also ties, then each team captain selects a representative to fight a deciding bout. 
 If this bout also ties, then a sudden-death extension is fought. 
 The first to score in a sudden-death extension determines the outcome. 
 If this ties again, then team captains must select another pair of representatives, and so on until the tie is broken. 
 Individual bouts are also decided by sudden-death contests. 
 However, in this case a decision must be made and is often given on the flimsiest of grounds (though that is not the fault of the refereeing panel). 
 Do note that the extension is not a new bout, and any penalties incurred in the original bout are carried forwards into it. 
 Sometimes this means that a single prohibited action or technique is enough to lose you the match even though no scoring technique has been made. 
 Prohibited techniques 
 Certain techniques are, by their nature, prohibited. 
 For example, any technique aimed at the throat, or applied to the joints, groin, or instep, will merit a penalty. 
 Note that while the neck is a scoring area, the throat is not. 
 The throat is classed as that area running down the front of the neck and bounded vertically by the angles of the lower jaw. 
 Many contestants apply a foot sweep in such a way as to strike the side of the opponent's knee. 
 Though a foul is not intended, the referee will nevertheless regard the technique as an attack on the opponent's joint and the competitor may face a penalty.  
 The throat is not a scoring area, though the neck is 
 A high foot sweep will be regarded as illegal, because it attacks the joint 
 Obvious attacks on the eyes are prohibited, though the odd mis-directed punch is not interpreted as such. 
 Nevertheless, if it does damage the opponent's eye, you will be penalised. 
 Compare this with the rather more obvious open-hand attack to the face. 
 This is clearly capable of causing eye injury and so is always penalised. 
 The referee looks for open hands fluttering about in the opponent's face, because they all too often &bquo;accidentally&equo; catch the opponent's eyes. 
 Such &bquo;accidents&equo; are always severely dealt with. 
 Take care when you throw the opponent and always allow them to land safely. 
 Throws which drop the opponent on to their head or shoulders will be penalised. 
 Any uncontrolled technique is not allowed. 
 There are some people who claim to be able to control an axe kick to the top of the opponent's head, but I have never seen this done effectively enough to score. 
 There are also people who are unable to control such a simple technique as a front kick. 
 In both cases it is the application of the technique and not the technique itself which is dangerous. 
 You should use only those techniques that you are confident of being able to control. 
 Level of contact 
 The most contentious area of karate competition concerns the level of contact. 
 This must always be controlled and if injury is caused &mdash; other than perhaps a slight reddening &mdash; a penalty rather than a score will result. 
 In general terms, heavier impacts may be made on the body because of the muscular &bquo;padding&equo; available. 
 Provided the blow does not cause actual injury (and winding someone does not count as injury) then it is likely to score. 
 Indeed, a full point score is likely to be awarded if someone is floored by a strong mid-section attack. 
 Facial attacks 
 Face contact should, in theory at least, be no more than &bquo;glove touch&equo;. 
 The face is defined as that area below the eyebrows and extending down to the chin. 
 Do not confuse it with the head, for the latter can be struck harder and still score. 
 A face attack may cause a slight reddening but that is all. 
 It is often said that  penalties automatically follow when blood appears following a facial attack, but this is an over-simplification. 
 In most cases the face attack will not score, but there are instances where the opponent moves into the attack and thus makes its impact worse. 
 Here the referee will often be more lenient in applying the rules of contact. 
 Similarly, roundhouse kicks to the face may land with a slightly heavier impact because they are inherently more difficult to control and yet are to be encouraged. 
 However, most roundhouse kicks make contact with the side of the head and not the face. 
 Face contact is limited to &bquo;glove touch&equo; only, though high kicks are given a little more leeway 
 It used to be the case that contestants who were struck lightly in the face could exaggerate injury in order to have the opponent's score disallowed. 
 Fortunately, referees are often able to tell when this has happened, and instead of disallowing the score they may impose a serious penalty for feigning injury! 
 Referees seem incapable of deciding whether a fast, controlled snap punch to the face has scored or not, and they generally disallow them. 
 This causes the contestant to try and get even closer to the opponent's face with subsequent jabs, in order to pick up that elusive score. 
 Of course, a punch inevitably strikes home and, instead of winning a point, a penalty is incurred. 
 The moral is, restrict your straight punches to the mid-section and land with a fair old thump in order to maximise your chance of scoring. 
 Stepping out of the competition area 
 Always try to remain within the boundary of the competition area. 
 The first time you step out, whether by accident or on purpose, a warning is imposed. 
 The next time you step out in the same bout, a half-point penalty is incurred. 
 The third time you step out, you face a full point penalty. 
 You will be disqualified if you step out a fourth time.  
 Only the lightest contact is allowed to the face 
 Remember that penalties imposed during the main bout carry forwards into the extension, so if you have had a warning in the bout proper for stepping out, and then immediately incur a half-point penalty during the sudden-death, your opponent wins. 
 There are two exceptions to this rule. 
 The first is if you are physically pushed or thrown out of the area. 
 The second is when you score and then step out. 
 In this case, the referee will stop the bout as soon as you score, so your step-out will occur out of time. 
 Hard luck if your score isn't awarded! 
 Penalties 
 The ascending scale of penalties described above is also used for all other prohibited techniques and actions. 
 However, it is important to note two things. 
 The first is that there is no need to follow slavishly the whole procedure for each offence. 
 A heavy contact to the opponent's face may not merit just a verbal warning; after consultation with the other members of the panel, the referee can go directly to a full point penalty or even a disqualification. 
 In some cases the disqualification is not only from a particular event within a tournament, but from the whole tournament. 
 The second thing to note is that each offence carries its own scale of penalties, and penalties for one offence are not added on to penalties imposed for a different offence. 
 Thus if I incur a verbal warning for stepping out of the area, I don't then expect to receive a half-point penalty for a slight contravention of another rule.  
 You will not be penalised if you are propelled from the area! 
 Prohibited actions and behaviour 
 You may seize hold of your opponent as long as this is immediately followed by a scoring technique. 
 Any other attempt to grasp the opponent is prohibited. 
 Also prohibited is any refusal to engage meaningfully with the opponent. 
 This is particularly important when one contestant is ahead on points as time-up approaches. 
 Such a person may well earn a penalty if they continue to back-pedal. 
 Another prohibited act is to fail to make reasonable measures for your own safety. 
 By this I mean flinging yourself forward on to the opponent's fist with your unguarded face. 
 Although this sounds silly, it happens quite often that contestants act with no regard at all for their own safety. 
 Good referees are quick to pick up on this and impose penalties for persistent offenders. 
 A less obvious example of this failure to take protective measures occurs when a contestant believes that a scoring technique has been delivered, and so  disengages and dances around the area waving a fist in the air. 
 Since one of the requirements for a score is that the contestant retains an effective defensive posture, the potential score is wiped out and a penalty imposed in its place. 
 Any contestant who, in the referee's opinion, becomes so over-excited that he loses self control may be disqualified from the entire tournament. 
 You are expected to take adequate steps to protect yourself. 
 In this example, the opponent has thrown himself forwards, with no thought of a face guard 
 It goes almost without saying that karate competitions must be held in an atmosphere of respect, for the self, for the opponent and for the members of the refereeing panel. 
 Where this is missing, the penalties can be severe in the extreme. 
 Not only must the contestants behave, but their team-mates are also obliged to conduct themselves properly, even when not fighting. 
 In practice a contestant is held responsible for the behaviour of team-members and the coach, and he may face a severe penalty if they misbehave. 
 Injury 
 A contestant may withdraw, or be withdrawn from a competition through injury. 
 This is known as &bquo;renunciation&equo;, and it gives victory to the opponent. 
 The referee examines any injury resulting during the bout and, if necessary, a doctor is summoned. 
 The doctor advises the referee of the injury caused but it is the referee who decides whether the bout should continue. 
 If both contestants are injured through no fault of either, then the bout goes to the one with the higher score. 
 If the scores are tied, then the referee panel will award the victory on the basis of their appraisal of both contestants' performances up to the point where injury occurred. 
 Winning by disqualification 
 A contestant who wins because his opponent is disqualified may fight again in the competition. 
 If he wins a subsequent bout also by disqualification, then he must be withdrawn for his own safety, since it is obvious that, in this tournament at least, he is not protecting himself adequately. 
 Well run tournaments use individual record cards which are scrutinised at the beginning of each bout. 
 Less well run events rely upon the memories of the refereeing panel to screen out those who have won by two disqualifications. 
 Protests 
 It is possible to register a protest if the rules of the competition have been infringed by the refereeing panel. 
 It is not, however, possible to complain about whether such and such a point should or should not have been awarded. 
 protests cannot be made by the contestant involved. 
 They are made by the official team representative and take the form of a written deposition to the Chief Referee of the day. 
 The latter examines the complaint and, if it is justified, calls the refereeing panel together to make them aware of what has gone wrong. 
 This can result in a decision being overturned. 
 However, the protest must be made promptly before the next round of an elimination match is fought. 
 If this happens, it is then impossible to redress the situation. 
 The only situation in which a verbal protest is acceptable is when the wrong contestants have been called, or when an administrative error has clearly been made. 
 In such cases, the official acting on behalf of the contestant may approach the arbitrator directly.  
 Referees' signals 
 Referees use various signals and japanese phrases to express their judgement. 
 Make sure that you know what these are and what they mean. 
 Briefly, if the referee points his fingers this indicates that someone had done something wrong. 
 If he extends his arms with the fingers together it is an award. 
 Finally, if the referee brings both fists together in the middle of the chest, this means that both contestants scored at the same time, so no awards will be made. 
 A more detailed list of Japanese expressions appear at the end of this book (p. 109). 
 Refereeing 
 I'm going to conclude this chapter with what I know will be offensive to some referees and judges; yet it is not only my opinion. 
 I refer here to the tendency of refereeing officials to &bquo;expect&equo; a certain person to win a bout. 
 This happens when an &eacute;lite performer draws a newcomer. 
 I have seen the newcomer soundly beat the &eacute;lite performer, yet have none of his techniques acknowledged by the refereeing panel! 
 It is as though the panel has developed a blind spot which does not admit the possibility that the newcomer might win. 
 Before you get the idea that such a bias occurs only in national competitions, I would like to point out that the worse case of this I ever saw was in a world championship. 
 The Women's World Heavyweight Champion had defended her title at three consecutive events, each time soundly beating her opponents. 
 In this case, I saw her caught with classic techniques &mdash; but none of them scored. 
 A senior international referee of my acquaintance was standing nearby and confirmed my opinion. 
 I don't know how the problem can be circumvented, except by being so much better than your opponent that even the most biased referee is forced to acknowledge your scores. 
 This may prove difficult when your opponent is an &eacute;lite performer and so the only practical advice I can offer is to appear in lots of competitions, so you become a known face to many national referees. 
 The referee has to see and correctly interpret extremely fast actions. 
 In my view, accuracy can only be assured over very short periods of time, after which the refereeing panel must receive a proper rest. 
 This never happens, of course, so poor decisions do surface as the day wears on and fatigue levels increase. 
 Yet as the competition's system of elimination proceeds, more and more &eacute;lite performers are brought together, placing greater pressure on the refereeing panel. 
 If they then fail to meet these increased demands, distressing confrontations may result. 
 The point I am trying to make from all this is that to win a karate bout needs two things &mdash; your ability to defeat the opponent and the referee panel's ability to recognise your superior performance. 
 The first requirement is in your hands, the second is not. 
 One can only hope that tournament organisers come to recognise this and ensure that each event is staffed by the requisite number of officials.  
 TRAINING TO WIN 
 As we have seen in previous chapters, a karate bout lasts for two or three minutes. 
 If a tie results, then after a break of up to a minute an extension of two or three minutes is fought. 
 So training must take place with this time period in mind. 
 Aerobic training 
 I will assume that you are not completely unfit and can cope with the demands of normal training. 
 As I have indicated, the requirements for competition are slightly different, but we can use the fitness built up through normal training to provide a platform upon which to establish more specialised requirements. 
 Thus you will already be aerobically fit, that is able to sustain a relatively low work-load over a long period. 
 If this is the case, then your first objective is to raise the level of work you can do before sliding too far into fatigue-producing anaerobic respiration. 
 The longer you stave that off, the less time you will spend building fatigue toxins. 
 Some people would argue that the bout is too short to require any form of aerobic training. 
 This may be the case, but you will spend much of the two or three minutes moving at sub-maximum speed, so the further you can ride on the back of aerobic respiration, the more lies in reserve for explosive onslaughts. 
 Therefore, you should train to lift the level of aerobic endurance by selecting a training routine and working at it until your pulse rate is raised to the top of the aerobic band. 
 This will vary according to age, so use the formula 220 &mdash; (age + 25) 
 This gives an approximate value to work to, so a 20-year-old will aim to generate a pulse rate of 175 beats per minute for a period of 20 minutes or so. 
 This length of time is necessary to ensure that adaptive changes occur to the lungs and heart. 
 However, if you find you can't go the full period at this heart-rate, then lower the work intensity to reduce the pulse rate until you can last out. 
 Count your pulse for 6 seconds and multiply the answer by 10 to get the rate per minute. 
 Always taper your training down at the end of a workout; do not stop suddenly because this can cause fainting or dizziness. 
 Begin increasing training intensity as soon as you can last the 20 minutes. 
 Eventually, you will be able to work higher and higher into the aerobic band, thus staving off reliance on fatigue-producing anaerobic respiration. 
 As you approach the time of competition, begin &bquo;interval training&equo; in your aerobic band by working very hard to raise the pulse rate almost into the anaerobic threshold, then easing up to drop the pulse rate down into the lower third of the band. 
 This is an invaluable part of your preparation. 
 The next question is, what type of training routine do you use to increase pulse rate? 
 Training should be as specific as possible and so for karateka I recommend either shadow boxing against a mirror, or working out on a light  punch bag. 
 just lay into the bag with fast punch and kick sequences, moving around all the time and building up a good sweat. 
 This will build up your aerobic fitness and train you in the right way. 
 Anaerobic training 
 Work on anaerobic endurance at the same time that you are raising your aerobic platform. 
 Two types of training are appropriate here. 
 The first is very short duration, maximum output attacks. 
 Really slam into the punch bag, hitting it with a constant barrage of punches as fast and as hard as you possibly can for no more than 15&ndash;20 seconds. 
 Then reduce the work-load and train lightly on the bag for around two minutes. 
 Switch back into maximum speed (this time using kicks) for a further 15 &mdash; 20 seconds before dropping back to another two minutes of active rest. 
 These rests are important because they allow your muscles to rebuild the depleted energy stores used up during the intense phases. 
 The second type of endurance training uses nearly flat-out effort over a period of up to three minutes. 
 The object here is to train so hard that the muscles work mainly in an anaerobic fashion, and fatigue-producing lactic acid is produced. 
 Continuous hard work-outs train the body to tolerate higher levels of lactic acid without slowing down. 
 Therefore, attack the bag with a mixture of kicks and punches, making sure that your action is continuous over a one minute period. 
 Then slow the pace down for two minutes before hiking it up again. 
 Don't, however, confuse this with the aerobic interval training outlined before. 
 Here your training intensity is such that you are pushed to work for one minute, let alone the 20 required for aerobic training!  
 Shadow boxing is an excellent way of raising your pulse rate into the aerobic training band 
 When you can cope with one minute of hard effort, increase it to two or three minutes. 
 When you can manage this too, then begin cutting down the rest intervals to one minute. 
 Your eventual goal is to be able to work very hard for a full three minutes, followed after a one-minute active break by a second three-minute workout. 
 Any more than this is unnecessary. 
 Training for power 
 The kind of strength you need to develop is that which allows you to move your body or limbs through a short, fast contraction. 
 Thus training must feature fast, explosive movements. 
 A typical example of this type of training is explosive press-ups. 
 For this exercise you bend the elbows until your chin touches the floor, then shoot them out straight so that your upper body flies up and your hands leave the floor. 
 Don't cheat by first allowing your body to droop and then jerking your backside into the air. 
 This defeats the object of the exercise. 
 Another possible exercise is to lie on your back and bench-press a light weight very quickly over, say, ten repetitions. 
 More than this and you will be introducing endurance factors into the training. 
 Rest, then repeat the sequence again. 
 Alternatively, hold a heavy medicine ball in both hands, bend your elbows and thrust it from you. 
 A partner then catches and returns it and the throw is repeated at least ten times. 
 You could also use the medicine ball in a one-armed shot put action, using first one side and then the other. 
 Wrist and ankle weights are useful for power training but make sure they don't modify your technique.  
 Explosive press-ups develop power in the upper body muscles 
 Kick squats work the muscles of the upper leg. 
 Combine them with a high kick on alternate legs each time you straighten up 
 Train the legs for explosive power with a combination of squats and a high front kick. 
 Stand with the feet shoulder-width apart and clench your fists, holding your arms by your sides. 
 Bend your knees to no more than 90&deg; then shoot upwards. 
 Perform a high front kick on alternate legs each time you straighten up. 
 Also try jump squats, or split squats, in which you change legs in mid-air. 
 Try jumping down from a low platform, landing with bent knees. 
 Then spring up on to a bench. 
 Make a circuit in which you alternately jump down and leap up. 
 Use higher platforms as your legs become stronger. 
 Then switch to alternate one-legged bounds as an alternative. 
 You will definitely take the odd blow to the mid-section so your muscles should be strong enough to absorb some impact energy. 
 Train for this with bent-leg sit-ups, changing the angle of the knee from nearly straight to heels tucked in tightly against the buttocks. 
 Aim to curl up with your head and shoulders lifting clear of the mat. 
 Increase the work-load by holding a weight against your chest as you sit up.  
 Exercises such as one-legged bounds train the leg muscles for explosive power delivery 
 Bent leg sit-ups strengthen the abdominals. 
 Change the training effects by varying your knee angles 
 Agility training 
 Train for agility with fast shadow-boxing, or work on the punch bag. 
 Repeatedly switch your stance from leading with the left leg to leading with the right, and strike with either hand as your weight settles. 
 Repeat the exercise but kick with the front or rear leg as soon as the stance switches. 
 Practise fast advances of one or two steps, punching with both hands as you do so. 
 Then immediately back-pedal as quickly as you can whilst throwing punches. 
 Jump diagonally forwards with the front leg and pick the rear foot up for a high roundhouse kick. 
 Jump diagonally back with the rear foot and perform a front foot roundhouse kick. 
 Reaction speed 
 Work on reaction speed with a partner holding a target mitt. 
 First this is held downwards, then it is swung upwards to varying heights so that you have a split second in which to hit it with a suitable technique. 
 It does not always face you, but is sometimes sideways-on, requiring a roundhouse technique. 
 As accuracy and speed increase, the pad is shown for shorter intervals of time. 
 Increase the difficulty by simultaneously working on two pads which are constantly weaving around as your partner moves and forces you to adapt to sudden changes in range. 
 Practise controlled impacts on the pad. 
 Accuracy 
 Use an impact pad to increase accuracy on moving targets. 
 Your partner holds the pad against his chest and suddenly lunges forwards or withdraws. 
 You react immediately and hit the pad with a perfectly timed technique. 
 This is an excellent drill for learning how to &bquo;dig in&equo; under a fierce advance. 
 Stop-punch your partner without hurting your own wrist.  
 Use impact pads to develop reaction speed and accuracy 
 Flexibility training 
 When you have worked through these various drills, finish the session off with flexibility training. 
 Improve suppleness in the hip joint by means of Proprioceptive Neuromuscular Facilitation (PNF) stretching plus ballistic mobility exercises. 
 PNF stretching allows you to gain extra centimetres of movement at your joints. 
 It helps, for example, to improve hip abduction (used in roundhouse kicks when the kicking knee is lifted to the side) by sitting with the soles of your feet together and close in to the body. 
 Your partner kneels in front of you and presses down on your knees. 
 Allow the applied force gradually to separate your knees, driving them down to the mat. 
 A firm, steady pressure should be applied &mdash; avoid jerky movements. 
 When you have separated your knees as wide as possible, squeeze back against the applied pressure, resisting it with all your might. 
 Maintain this resistance for at least ten seconds, then relax once more, allowing your knees to open out. 
 You will find that they open further than they did before. 
 Another version of this exercise uses gravity to work against your splayed legs. 
 Lie on your back and lift both feet together into the air, keeping your knees straight. 
 Next, let your legs separate until they are splayed as wide as you can tolerate. 
 Work at relaxing your muscles, so that the stretch is at a maximum, then hold it there for around 30 seconds. 
 Lift your legs slightly against the force of gravity, holding them for at least ten seconds, then let them relax again. 
 This exercise produces quite startling gains in a short time.  
 Your partner presses down on your knees and you try to relax your muscles 
 Force back against the applied pressure 
 Mobility training 
 Improve mobility by swinging your foot to the front, to the sides and to the back. 
 Never try to exceed the range of movement available but work within it instead. 
 Also train on the punch bag, aiming your kicks as high as you can and reaching as far as possible. 
 Mobility training is not about improving flexibility - it is about ensuring a smooth action throughout the range of movement. 
 Only then can acceleration be maximised. 
 Remember, a flexible joint has a margin of safety which can be useful when you are straining to reach those last few millimetres.  
 Swing your leg but keep the knee straight. 
 This does not increase suppleness, as such, but it loosens the joint 
 I have concentrated on the hip joint in this section because, in my experience, this is the most limiting in terms of technique application. 
 It isn't worth doing any shoulder work unless you have a problem there. 
 However, you should stretch the hamstrings and work on spinal flexibility.  
 Hip mobility is essential if you are to make the maximum use of effective kicking techniques 
 Stretch the hamstrings with progressive, smooth exercises 
 Controlling Stress 
 Perhaps one of the greatest inhibitors of performance is fear or anxiety. 
 A certain amount of mental arousal is necessary but too much causes you to lose confidence in your own abilities. 
 If you find that you worry about the imagined outcome of the bout and fear the worst or if you have a racing pulse, then I would say you are over-aroused and in danger of throwing everything away. 
 The problem is, how do you cope with stress? 
 This depends very much upon the individual, but peer-group support is often invaluable. 
 Train as a unit with your team in order to develop interdependence, from which comes strong support when you are on the mat. 
 It is comforting to hear your team-mates shouting their encouragement during a contest.  
 Sit with your back straight and head erect. 
 Control your breathing and visualise a peaceful scene 
 The coach is also a great help in controlling anxiety, and the right kind of pep talk can work wonders. 
 However, this is only possible when the coach really knows the karateka. 
 The good coach will try to get his students to realise that there is not such a big gap as they imagine between their abilities and the task in hand. 
 This is a key point because you should always feel more or less equal to that which confronts you. 
 If you have done enough of the right type of training, there is no reason why you shouldn't give a good account of yourself. 
 Some karateka can cope with watching the action and measuring up their adversary while others prefer to retire outside the tournament arena to somewhere quiet. 
 Over-anxious competitors may benefit by practising meditation. 
 This involves sitting comfortably with your back and head erect. 
 Look at a particular point on the wall in front of you and try to relax. 
 Breathe slowly and rhythmically, pressing the tip of your tongue against the back of your upper front teeth. 
 Select a relaxing image, such as a sparkling brook or a restless ocean. 
 Try to hear the sound of the water, feel its wetness against your skin and visualise its restless movement. 
 If you concentrate hard enough, your mental activity will slow down. 
 Meditate for at least a minute and longer if you can manage it. 
 Positive thinking 
 Even if you are drawn against an &eacute;lite performer who has a great deal of experience, the fact that you may be younger, hungrier, fitter could be to your advantage. 
 Above all, you have nothing to lose, whereas the &eacute;lite performer has. 
 presumably, as part of your preparation and selection programme, you will already have done well against others. 
 So why assume that you must inevitably lose? 
 The &bquo;good loser syndrome&equo; has to be avoided at all costs. 
 The good loser is recognisable as the competitor who nods with rueful admiration each time the opponent scores. 
 The good loser never makes it to the winner's rostrum of any worthwhile competition. 
 After all, what's the point in taking part in a competitive event if the result is to confirm how ineffectual you are? 
 If you really don't think you stand a chance, then don't even think of competing. 
 &bquo;The opponent block&equo; applies to elite performers who, in the past, have repeatedly drawn and lost to a particular opponent. 
 Elite performers earn that title because they are, by nature, not good losers. 
 Yet they can come to see one opponent as the rock upon which they will undoubtedly founder. 
 This results in dispirited performances, sometimes marred by feigned injuries. 
 The only solution to the &bquo;opponent block&equo; is to pull yourself up by your bootstraps so that you come to believe that you can win.  
 USING THE AREA 
 The ability to move around in the competition area is essential if you are always going to be poised and ready either to attack or to respond. 
 The training environment for this must always be an 8m x 8m (9.5yd x 9.5 yd) area, and you should practise until you are sure of your position within it at any given time. 
 You must never allow yourself to be crowded out, neither must you retreat so far that you overstep the area boundary. 
 To do so is to help the opponent to win without his having to hit you with a single scoring technique. 
 Stance 
 The karate bout has some similarities with a boxing match in so far as both contestants move around the ring exchanging blows. 
 I know of no world champion boxers who stand rooted to the spot. 
 Similarly, the karate competitor must be able to move smoothly and sometimes explosively, so the notion of stance is closely linked to movement. 
 To move freely in any direction your stance must be unpolarised. 
 This means that your centre of gravity must always lie mid-way between both feet. 
 Any bias will slow down movement in one or more directions and produce a tell-tale lurch of the shoulders as the body-weight is shifted.  
 The fighting stance is unpolarised, with weight distributed evenly. 
 Note the low target profile commensurate with weapon's availability 
 To move explosively you must flex the knees slightly, keeping the upper leg muscles under tension. 
 The muscles behave like rubber bands, possessing more potential energy when they are stretched than when they are lax. 
 The length of your stance will therefore vary according to the length of your legs. 
 It must be long enough to give you strength in the face of a direct frontal assault but short enough to allow you to spring back or thrust forwards without warning. 
 Width of stance is important only in determining how much of the body is presented as a square-on target to the opponent. 
 It used to be important because it made it more difficult to score with groin kicks, and it led to narrow stances with the leading foot turned inwards. 
 Though this stance protects the groin, it leaves the front foot susceptible to a front sweep. 
 Groin kicks are not now allowed, so the old requirement of a narrow stance has relaxed somewhat. 
 When deciding how wide to make your stance, look at yourself in a full length mirror to see what kind of a target you present for the opponent. 
 Narrow your stance and pull your rear hip back to try and reduce this profile, but notice also how this makes you gradually more and more susceptible to a foot sweep. 
 &pound;so, your rear hand has to be drawn further and further back from where it should be in order to remain immediately effective. 
 I know of some competitors who fight from a fully sideways-facing straddle stance. 
 This stance has a very small target profile indeed, though it is wide open to the foot sweep and also reduces the competitor's choice of technique to the back fist or the side kick. 
 Don't stand flat-footed. 
 Your weight rests on the balls of your feet, not on the heels, so the calves are under tension. 
 Avoid bouncing up and down because an &eacute;lite performer will simply wait until you are moving upwards before driving in with a strong attack. 
 You will have no weapons beyond a feeble back fist or hammer fist, whereas your opponent can throw a powerful reverse punch that meets all the requirements for an obvious score.   
 Stance width is an important factor which, if ignored, can produce serious stability defects 
 Straddle stance has a low target profile, but body weapons are seriously restricted 
 Your stance must be long enough to dig in under a fierce attack. 
 If it is too high, you will be driven off balance 
 Guard 
 Carry your forward guard well out from the body but do not allow it to cross your own centre-line. 
 If you keep your leading fist slightly to the correct side of the centre-line, then you will be able to use it in a direct thrusting action. 
 Once it crosses the centre-line it can only be used immediately as a back fist. 
 I favour a long-reaching front guard because it has less distance to travel before it strikes the opponent, and it is able to intercept attacks closer to source. 
 While short, fast snap punches delivered by the front fist may work, a tired referee probably will not score them. 
 The rear guard hand must also be carried forwards; allowing it to rest against the rib cage is a hold-over from basic technique which has no place in competition. 
 Carry the hand far enough forwards for immediate use as a reverse punch. 
 As before, the rear guard hand must never cross the body's centre-line. 
 Even during flurries of techniques, both hands remain on their respective sides of the centre-line. 
 Arm movement 
 Economy of arm movement is important since the more you flail them about, the longer it takes to &bquo;cock&equo; them for an effective punch. 
 Move your arms as little as is necessary to achieve your purpose, and always move them together so that if the front hand is knocking down an incoming punch, the rear is executing a counter-punch. 
 You simply do not have the time for the &bquo;one &mdash; pause &mdash; two&equo; sequences so beloved in basic training. 
 Line 
 This is one of two ways to place your opponent at a disadvantage without him even knowing about it. 
 Your opponent takes up a left fighting stance, that is  with the left leg leading. 
 You take up a left stance and line yourself up so that your left foot is in front of the opponent's right, and your right is in front of his left. 
 You are now facing each other in a fully square-on position and each has an equal target profile; furthermore, each has an equal opportunity to use body weapons. 
 Next, move to your right, so that your left leading foot comes to lie in front of the opponent's left foot. 
 Finally, turn your body slightly, so that you face the opponent directly. 
 While you can still hit the opponent with any one of your body weapons he, in effect, has turned away from you and can launch no direct attack without first twisting to face you. 
 Move slightly to the side and turn your body. 
 Notice that the opponent is no longer facing you directly 
 If you step too far to the side, the opponent will see what you are doing and twist to face you. 
 Line, like stance, is therefore a fluid thing; it is a method of positioning and repositioning yourself so that you are always trying to reduce the opponent's opportunities. 
 Although this may sound simple, you should practise with a partner to work out your positioning. 
 Using your centre-line 
 If you don't turn your body to face your opponent directly you will succeed only in placing both of you at a disadvantage. 
 You must always stand so that you face the opponent because this is the position from which you can launch the maximum number of powerful attacks and place your opponent at a disadvantage. 
 For example, consider the scooping block response to the front kick. 
 In the first photograph, the defender has twisted his hips away from the kick and faces 120&deg; to the incoming technique. 
 The purpose of this is to provide a more effective deflection. 
 But notice that in order to respond effectively the defender must now twist all the way back, because sideways-on there is little he can do to score. 
 Compare this with the slide-back scooping block which uses the same technique but does not turn the body away. 
 It is the attacker who is deflected now; your body remains facing forwards and fully effective. 
 Consider also the  scenario where you have been strongly attacked. 
 You turn away from the onslaught and, in so doing, remove all possibility of a strong, scoring counterattack. 
 You can use a side kick still, but if the attack is really effective the opponent will be on top of you before you can launch it. 
 Compare this with the diagonal, twisting advance that takes you directly into the opponent or, if you prefer, the diagonal withdrawal that times your response to coincide with a lull in the attack. 
 In both of these cases you have kept your centre-line turned to face the opponent and so left your options open. 
 Do not turn your centre-line away from the opponent, because this both delays and weakens the follow-up attack 
 Withdraw, but keep your hips forward-facing 
 Line and centre-line together 
 It is now time to put the twin concepts of line and centre-line into practice by having your partner launch attacks. 
 Respond by moving into or away from him, using the diagonals available to you. 
 Keep positioning yourself in the correct line while turning your own centre-line towards the opponent. 
 Disguise your changes in line by &bquo;switch-changing&equo; your stance. 
 (Switch-changing is a fast skipping movement during which one leading foot is exchanged for the other.) 
 Elite performers often launch an attack as soon as the switch-change occurs, suddenly darting forwards with a powerful attack before the opponent has time to re-calculate your distance from him. 
 However, don't make too much of a habit of switch-changing because the opponent may pick up your rhythm and attack just as you are in the middle of a change.  
 Turning away under a strong attack is a sure recipe for defeat 
 There are occasions during which you turn away from the opponent, but these are deliberate and short-lived, leading in to a particular technique. 
 Sudden and abrupt changes in stance and orientation are off-putting for the opponent so work out some routines to achieve this. 
 For example, you could slide the leading foot forwards and outwards and then throw your body-weight forwards, swinging the rear leg in and forwards in a shallow U-shaped movement. 
 This means that you zig-zag from one side to the other, twisting your centre-line as you move. 
 Practise this also in reverse mode, stepping back from the attack and simultaneously moving out of line.  
 (a) Slide your front foot diagonally forwards 
 (b) Bring the rear foot to it 
 (c) Then step out, throwing a punch as you go 
 Practise stepping quickly from one stance into another, always ensuring that at least the width of a fist separates your leading guards. 
 This means that the opponent always has to step forwards in order to make an attack, thus warning you well in advance. 
 If you allow the opponent to come too close, then a step forward may not be necessary but you will have to be very quick with your responses! 
 Disguise 
 Disguise your steps with feints that make the opponent blink, or which divert his attention elsewhere. 
 Fast jabs to the face are ideal for this purpose, because if they look effective they cause the opponent to throw back his head. 
 Circular techniques do not produce the same flinch and are correspondingly less effective at disguising a follow-up. 
 However, even with straight jabs it is important that the technique looks effective. 
 An obvious feint, or a punch that looks easy to avoid, may well encourage attack rather than succeed in diverting it.  
 A straight punch into the face disguises your intent 
 Timing 
 Practise timing, always aiming to deliver your response just as your opponent is beginning his: this is a sure way to turn a half-point score into a full point. 
 The earlier you intercept your opponent's technique, the less power it will have developed, leaving a greater leeway open to you. 
 Alternatively, wait until the opponent's technique has missed and is being withdrawn. 
 This is also a &bquo;dead time&equo; during which you can profitably respond. 
 You can sometimes discover what responses the opponent is likely to make it you make a sudden move towards him. 
 He will either come forwards to meet you, &bquo;dig in&equo; and prepare to punch, or back off. 
 It is useful to know which is the likely response to your committed attack and that is one way of finding out. 
 We will explore this further in the chapter dealing with tactics.  
 Deliver your attack even as the opponent begins his 
 BLOCKS AND DEFLECTIONS 
 In the last chapter I outlined certain similarities between karate competition and boxing. 
 I would now like to pursue the resemblance by claiming that blocks as such (i.e. techniques which are solely performed to deflect attacking techniques), have no more place in karate competition than they have in boxing. 
 This is not to say that you will never deflect the opponent's attack and then counter, because you will. 
 What I mean is that you will find little use for the basic &bquo;one &mdash; pause &mdash; two&equo; sequences of block followed by counter-attack. 
 The speed of &eacute;lite competition means that your countering punch either arrives at the same time as any deflection you make, or very soon after it.  
 Attack the opponent's open side, where there are more targets to aim for 
 Before going on to analyse the kinds of blocking technique one might nevertheless use, I want to briefly explain what I mean by the terms &bquo;open&equo; and &bquo;closed&equo; sides when referring to a stance. 
 picture the opponent standing in front of you with the left leg and fist leading. 
 His closed side lies to your right as you look at him. 
 There is little target to aim at because the leading hand covers the body and the elbow is near to the ribs. 
 The leading shoulder protects the chin from upswinging kicks, forcing them to loop high over it. 
 The opponent's open side is on the left as you view him. 
 Here the right guard hand and shoulder are drawn back, exposing more of the body and head. 
 Stepping towards the opponent's closed side provides fewer targets, though it does succeed in preventing an immediate, effective counter. 
 Stepping to the open side provides more target opportunities, but also gives the opponent opportunities too. 
 Remember that blocks do not score, however well they are executed, and so a follow-up punch, kick or strike is essential. 
 Underline the follow-up by means of a loud shout to show that you have unified mental resolve and physical effort in the technique. 
 This is an important point given that otherwise effective techniques sometimes fail to score because they are delivered without a shout. 
 On the other hand, don't make a habit of shouting every time you do something: this will cause the panel to switch off, and thereby perhaps miss an actual score. 
 Slapping blocks 
 The first of the few blocks that can be used in competition to be considered are the slapping blocks. 
 These use the cupped palm of the hand to slap an incoming punch either down or to one side. 
 The following is a possible scenario where a slapping block might be applied. 
 Your opponent throws a long-ranging reverse punch; you draw back your front foot into a cat stance, withdrawing your body  from danger. 
 Your leading hand slaps down on the punch as you simultaneously punch over the top and into the opponent's face. 
 Being a combination, this is more likely to score than a single face punch which, as I said earlier, is often simply overlooked by the referee. 
 Sometimes the alert referee will award a full point for your combination, though this is rare. 
 Slide back into cat stance and slap the opponent's reverse punch, counter-punching at the same time 
 A few points need to be borne in mind when trying out this sequence. 
 The first is that the opponent's punch need miss only by the smallest amount. 
 Pull back too far and you will find your counter-punch also falling well short. 
 The second point is that many people lean forwards as they slap down the opponent's punch and so you need to remember that there are two fists to worry about here, not one! 
 The third point is that the opponent's fist only needs a slight deflection so you shouldn't need to make your action too pronounced. 
 The slapping block can also knock the incoming punch sideways, but the blocking hand must be retrieved as quickly as possible so that it can act as a guard. 
 Remember to keep your body turned square-on and never be tempted to twist your hips away from the opponent. 
 Rock back into a cat stance and block, then fire off a back fist with your leading hand. 
 Finish with a thrust forwards and a reverse punch. 
 practise these stance changes until they happen smoothly and quickly. 
 In theory (I have never seen this done) you can also slap the incoming punch upwards and then go underneath it with a reverse punch.  
 (a) Rock back into cat stance, slapping the opponent's punch to one side 
 (b) Use the blocking hand to deliver a back-fist 
 (c) Thrust forwards and reverse punch to the opponent's mid-section 
 Scooping block 
 Since we discussed the scooping block in the previous chapter, only a brief recap is necessary here. 
 The opponent throws a front kick and you pull back into a cat stance. 
 Your leading guard hand curls under the opponent's Achilles tendon and draws the trapped foot towards you and to the side. 
 The drawing movement is necessary to take the opponent's centre of gravity too far forwards, thus causing him to fall heavily forwards. 
 The deflection is intended to turn his closed side towards you, so that his immediate counter is restricted to a back fist or suchlike. 
 Do not deflect the opponent so that his open side faces you or you may well find yourself facing a powerful reverse punch fuelled by the fall forward. 
 If you are liable to do this, then keep hold of the opponent's ankle as you thrust forwards, lifting and pushing the trapped leg so that you turn his closed side towards you. 
 Then finish with a reverse punch into the opponent's head. 
 The object is always to keep your centre-line facing the opponent, while also trying to turn his centre-line away from you. 
 Follow the opponent's shape, not his attacking limb, because although an individual technique may have been successfully evaded, the opponent still remains potentially dangerous.  
 Scoop the opponent's front kick, drawing it back and up to break his balance 
 If you are likely to face his open side, then circle your blocking arm so you twist him away 
 A front kick can also be countered effectively by moving back on the diagonal. 
 Face the opponent in opposite stance (i.e. if your opponent's right leg is forward you lead with your left and vice versa). 
 As he kicks, slide the rear foot back and withdraw your leading foot by an equal amount so that your stance does not become too long. 
 Do not turn your hips away from the opponent but use a reverse scooping block with your leading hand to lift and draw him out. 
 It doesn't really matter if you succeed in catching the opponent's foot or not: the main objective is to move out from the opponent's centre-line while turning to face him. 
 This puts you in a strong position to counter-attack.  
 Move diagonally back and catch the opponent's kicking foot with a reverse scooping block 
 Advancing blocks 
 The blocks which we have discussed up to this point have all been coupled with withdrawal actions. 
 But this is not the only way to deal with an attack. 
 Dramatic results are obtained when you go forwards to meet the opponent just as he attacks. 
 If you have a healthy respect for your opponent, you will thrust forwards on a diagonal line that takes you out of his centre-line, before twisting to face him square-on. 
 Thus the advance is made a split second after discerning the opponent's attack. 
 However, those of a more robust spirit will thrust directly into the opponent's attack, staking all on a combination block and counter. 
 Actually, providing your timing is reasonable, this is not too dangerous, because you will be interrupting the attacking technique close to its source, when it is at its weakest. 
 Reverse block 
 For this type of block you slide diagonally forwards so that the angle of your advance takes you clear of the opponent's front kick. 
 Try to scoop the outstretched foot with your rear guard hand. 
 If this succeeds, then lift the trapped foot while also thrusting your leading guard hand into the opponent's opposite shoulder. 
 This corkscrews the opponent backwards over his supporting leg and dumps him on the mat. 
 Finish with a reverse punch.  
 Slide diagonally forwards, catching the opponent's front kick with your rear guard hand. 
 Thrust against the opponent's chest to unbalance him 
 Alternatively, knock his kick to one side and counter-punch 
 If you don't succeed in lifting the foot, then simply knock it outwards with your rear guard hand while punching with the other hand. 
 The third example uses a short but wide diagonal movement of the front foot to take you clear of the opponent's incoming reverse punch. 
 Use a long, thrusting snap punch to the opponent's face and if the chance presents itself, follow up quickly with a reverse punch. 
 If the opponent's attack is a face punch, then hit his extended arm with your forearm, glancing your punch over the top of his and into the target.  
 (a) Step diagonally forwards, catching the opponent's advancing punch with your leading forearm 
 (b) Continue your fist into the opponent's face 
 Blocking Kicks 
 Of all the kicks used in competition the high roundhouse kick is perhaps the easiest to see, though there are ways of disguising this. 
 If your opponent attempts a roundhouse kick to one side of your head, thrust forwards off your rear foot as soon as his foot lifts and the hips begin to rotate. 
 Then turn your hips behind a long reverse punch to hit the opponent square in the chest, just as his knee is rising to its full height. 
 The effect of this is generally to knock the opponent over and earn you a full point. 
 It is also possible to use a barring block and stop punch a front kick, though you must time this right and not leave it too late. 
 Thrust forwards strongly as soon as the opponent's rear foot lifts and the kicking knee moves forward. 
 Bring your leading hand down, barring the rising knee, and simultaneously reverse punch to your opponent's mid-section. 
 There are two main requirements for these last two techniques. 
 The first is that you must be the correct distance from your opponent; that is at his closest kicking range (any closer and he won't kick at all). 
 Conversely, you shouldn't be so far away that you cannot close quickly enough. 
 This may prove difficult if your opponent is much taller than you. 
 The second requirement is that of good timing. 
 Some competitors just aren't quick enough off the mark, or they hold back instead of thrusting in strongly. 
 Either of these faults means that the attacking technique is well developed before you move into it, and so your front barring arm or groin suffer accordingly.  
 Move directly into a high roundhouse kick and stop-punch it 
 Stop a front kick by barring down with your leading guard whilst reverse-punching to the opponent's chest 
 Forearm blocks 
 Although rarely used, there is no reason why modified forearm blocks shouldn't prove effective in competition. 
 I say &bquo;modified&equo; because you have to use them as attacks in themselves. 
 Thus, whereas a basic forearm block simply deflects the opponent's punch, the more advanced version deflects the opponent. 
 To perform this version, change to the opposite stance to the opponent. 
 Then thrust off your rear foot, driving your open hand across the opponent's leading guard. 
 The direction of your forearm block is towards the opponent, not towards his guard hand. 
 This closes the opponent off and presents you with a good opportunity to continue the block into the opponent's face. 
 Do not allow your blocking hand to cross your own centre-line or your punch will be weakened and any follow-ups slowed down. 
 Notice that the blocking hand is not pulled into a fist. 
 Instead it is turned forwards and hooks over the opponent's leading guard hand. 
 This hooking action is important because it interferes with the opponent's attempts to free his arm and keeps him closed off for a longer period. 
 Use any opportunity to force the opponent's front hand across his own centre-line since this always inhibits his immediate responses. 
 provided that you then turn your body directly towards him, you will be able to deliver a powerful scoring punch. 
 It is possible to duck underneath your opponent's powerful head punch as he comes barrelling in, but this requires a fair amount of nerve and good timing.  
 Begin from the opposite stance and advance into the opponent. 
 Thrust your hooked forearm across the opponent's forward guard, closing him off 
 To do this you slide back your rear foot so that the stance lengthens (this makes it more stable in a longitudinal direction) and your centre of gravity drops. 
 If the action is sharp enough your opponent's punch will graze over the top of your head, helped on its way by a fast rising block. 
 As well as dealing with the punch, the rising block travels diagonally up and forwards into the opponent, catching him high on the attacking arm. 
 Do not lean forwards as you block since this will bring your chin close to the opponent's other fist. 
 There is no need to withdraw your blocking arm fully as you reverse punch; you probably won't have enough time to anyway! 
 The main thing is to shift your centre of gravity forwards behind the punch, so that it is delivered with plenty of power. 
 Simply rock forwards on to your leading knee to achieve this. 
 Summary 
 The following are the cardinal rules of blocking: 
 &bull; 
 block on the move 
 &bull; 
 time the block according to the opponent's technique 
 &bull; 
 move out of the opponent's centre-line 
 &bull; 
 keep your own centre-line turned towards the opponent 
 &bull; 
 close the opponent off if you can 
 &bull; 
 counter-attack quickly after the block 
 &bull; 
 shout to underline your score. 
 Drop under the opponent's high punch, blocking high on his arm with rising block whilst reverse-punching strongly with the other 
 MAKING YOUR PUNCH SCORE 
 As we saw in the chapter dealing with rules, it is not enough for your punch to be an effective scoring technique; it must be seen to be so, and this entails making its success obvious. 
 The first way to do this, as I mentioned in the previous chapter, is to underline the punch with a loud shout. 
 However, many people shout from their lungs, with the result that the sound is high pitched and lacks penetration. 
 A correct shout emanates from the diaphragm and is caused by a general muscular contraction accompanying the punch. 
 WUKO Chief Referee Tommy Morris describes it as the sort of sound you make when pushing a really heavy car; the sound explodes out of you, as it were. 
 Use your shouts sparingly, otherwise the refereeing panel will quickly come to see that they generally signify nothing, and will ignore them. 
 The second way to underline your punch's effectiveness is to allow it to strike with a satisfying thud that cannot be mistaken. 
 While not seeking to cave your opponent's ribs in, do strike hard enough to leave the refereeing panel in no doubt at all that contact has been made on the scoring area. 
 Be careful during team matches if you are heavier than your opponent, because what seems like a light tap to you may prove a sledgehammer to him, and may result in a penalty. 
 Having said that, if you weigh only 60 kg (132 lb) and yet still manage to sit your 90 kg (198 lb) opponent down with a solid thump to his mid-section, then the refereeing panel may well applaud your fervour with a full point. 
 Obviously, you cannot rely on a hard landing in the case of face punches, so other means must be employed. 
  The third way to underline effectiveness is to make sure your punching arm travels over a sufficient distance for the refereeing panel to see it. 
 Even in the case of front arm jabs, the distance travelled should be maximised and the action demonstrated as a thrust rather than a snap. 
 Many valid front punches are not scored because they travel such short distances at high speed, and are  snapped back before the panel can react. 
 A thrusting action should accompany all linear punches and kicks, since it is believed to be related to potential power in a way that a snapping action is not. 
 There are exceptions, which we shall come to later. 
 Slide forwards on the front foot and deliver your snap punch with a thrusting action 
 Hip action must be obvious, since the referee panel equate this with powerful technique 
 The refereeing panel will be more likely to score your punch if there is evidence of body involvement. 
 A simple movement of the striking limb is not enough to ensure a score. 
 Therefore, the fourth way to underline effectiveness is to slide forwards slightly on the front foot, drawing the rear foot up an equal distance if there is a danger that otherwise the stance will stretch out. 
 Even if the slide is not feasible, you can still throw your centre of gravity forward, so that weight increases on the leading leg. 
 The fifth attention-grabber is the exaggerated hip action which should accompany every punch. 
 This shows that the punch is not merely an arm movement, but a powerful, co-ordinated body action. 
 The punching hip, be it the leading hip of a front punch or the trailing hip of a reverse punch, must swivel forwards, so that your centre-line directly faces the opponent. 
 You may well decide to twist even further when using the front punch, but beware that your situation is weakened should the opponent immediately counter &mdash; attack. 
 The reverse punch 
 This technique has probably been responsible for scoring more points than any other in the entire history of karate competition. 
 It therefore follows that it is worthy of your closest attention and your most energetic practice. 
 Begin from a fighting stance, perhaps by throwing a light snap punch into the opponent's face from the front hand. 
 You do this for two reasons. 
 The first  reason is that if it is meaningful, it briefly diverts the opponent's attention away from what follows. 
 The second reason is that it draws the punching hip right back and cocks it, without telegraphing this fact to the opponent. 
 Even as you begin to draw back the snap punch, pick up your front foot and set it down diagonally forwards and outwards, using a thrusting action from the rear leg to cover ground. 
 Begin to thrust your punching hip forwards, using the pull-back of your snap punch to power the reverse punch. 
 Move your centre of gravity forward so that the heel of your trailing foot is lifted. 
 This last point is sometimes regarded as a bad fault in basic training, but it is almost inevitable in a long-ranging competition reverse punch.  
 Throw a fast snap punch at the opponent's face. 
 This cocks the hips for a reverse punch 
 Go for maximum range, allowing the rear heel to lift off 
 Lean your body forwards to squeeze the last few centimetres of range out of the punch. 
 However, don't thrust the chin forwards and only pull back the withdrawing hand as far as the side of the face &mdash; not to the ribs or the hip. 
 Withdrawing the hand too far makes it more difficult to launch a fast follow-up technique. 
 Withdraw to a safe engagement distance as soon as the punch strikes or misses, since this is a pre-requisite of any score being awarded. 
 Defensive reverse punch 
 Practise &bquo;digging in&equo; under attack by sliding the rear foot back slightly while cocking the punching hip. 
 Then drop low under the incoming technique and drive your weight forwards into the punch. 
 Keep your front guard hand close to your face where it can give protection. 
 The best way to train for this is to have your partner hold a plastic foam impact pad against his chest. 
 It is actually quite difficult to range on a moving target, and sprained wrists have been caused through lack of skill in this respect.  
 Practise stop-punching the pad as your partner advances into you 
 Advancing reverse punch 
 Practise an advancing competition reverse punch from a fighting stance by holding your guard still as you quickly step forwards. 
 Your leading hand is used to perform a reverse punch, but it doesn't travel as far as a refereeing panel would like. 
 You can make sure that you will score by following with a snap punch. 
 Practise an advancing double reverse punch by throwing the first reverse punch with a slight slide forwards on the front foot. 
 Next, as you withdraw the punch, simultaneously step forward. 
 Time the action so that your withdrawal is completed at the same time as your advancing foot is taking up its new position. 
 Then throw the second reverse punch. 
 Skilled performers use the impetus of the opening punch to throw themselves forwards and into the second punch.   
 (a) Hold your guard still as you run forwards&hellip; 
 (b)&hellip; then reverse-punch 
 (c) Complete the sequence with snap punch 
 (a) Reverse punch and allow the rear leg to begin moving forwards 
 (b) Use the pull-back of the spent punch to power the step through 
 (c) Then complete the step with a second reverse punch 
 The Snap punch 
 The second punch used successfully in competition is the snap punch. 
 This employs a thrusting motion of the leading guard hand accompanied by a twisting movement of the forward hip. 
 Begin from a fighting stance by thrusting forwards with the back foot and sliding a short distance with the front. 
 Let your rear guard hand move forwards slightly as you do this. 
 Even before the slide forward has come to a stop, pull your rear guard hand back slightly in order to augment the snap punch. 
 The hips turn strongly behind the punch and a loud shout should accompany it. 
 It is nearly always possible to throw a reverse punch to mid-section afterwards, capitalising on the draw-back of the snap punching fist. 
 To see how this is done look again at the description of reverse punch.  
 The snap punch (a) Advance your rear guard hand slightly as your front foot skims forwards&hellip; 
 (b)&hellip; then pull it back again and thrust the snap punch out 
 (c) Complete the sequence with a reverse punch 
 Hip-twist snap punch 
 Try sliding diagonally forwards and outwards with the front foot turned slightly inwards. 
 Perform the snap punch exactly as before but turn your hip more than previously. 
 You will have now moved out of line, yet you can still punch strongly into the opponent who, in consequence, is forced to turn towards you.  
 Hip-twist snap punch (a) Turn your leading foot as you slide diagonally forwards 
 (b) Twist your hips strongly as you punch. 
 Notice that the punch is still on target, though the approach is diagonal rather than direct 
 Snap punch stepping forwards 
 Take a fast step forwards, holding your guard hands still as you do so. 
 The length of your step should be tailored according to the distance you are away from your opponent. 
 Throw your body-weight forwards and pull back the leading fist, using this combination action to snap punch into the opponent's face. 
 Time the delivery of the punch to coincide with the cessation of the step forward, and shout loudly at the moment of imagined impact. 
 Some people change their guard hands as they step, but this curtails the punch's potential. 
 Defensive snap punch 
 &bquo;Dig in&equo; and throw a snap punch off the front fist as your opponent Turn your hips and shoulders behind the punch and strike the opponent strongly in the chest. 
 Add a reverse punch to underline your technique. 
 Alternatively, you can rock back into a cat stance knocking the opponent's punch down with a slapping block performed with the rear hand. 
 Then snap punch off the front fist into the opponent's face.  
 Step forwards quickly, holding your guard still as you do so 
 The back fist 
 This punch is not a linear strike like the previous two but a circular one. 
 The back fist unrolls from the shoulder, propelled as much by the body turning away as by the arm action itself. 
 Many karateka get this wrong and make use only of the arm action. 
 A back fist will out-range a reverse punch performed by an opponent of equal height but it is not often scored because many referees do not consider it powerful enough. 
 Nevertheless it remains an excellent opening strike because, even more than the snap punch, it cocks the hips for a powerful reverse punch. 
 However, all the time your shoulder leads, your centre-line is not facing the opponent, so you are vulnerable to a strong counter-attack. 
 Lean in behind the strike in order to get the maximum range, and raise your other hand as a guard. 
 Unfortunately, the cocking action that begins a back fist movement presents an unmistakable cue to the opponent. 
 The punching elbow must be flexed before it can be extended fully, and any attempt to strike with a semi-extended arm is sure to fail because of the obvious weakness of the technique. 
 The question is, how do you disguise the elbow flexion? 
 One answer is to open with a reverse punch to the mid-section. 
 Flex your elbow strongly as the punch thrusts out, then use its subsequent pull-back to help unroll the strike. 
 Your stance will lift as this happens. 
 Then strike into the opponent's face, slide forwards once more and deliver a final reverse punch to the mid-section, to complete a highly effective sequence.     
 Back fist will out-range a reverse punch from an opponent of similar size 
 (a) Begin with a reverse punch to mid-section; use this to disguise the pullback of your non-punching arm 
 (b) Pull back the spent reverse punch, using this action to help unroll the back fist. 
 Notice that the rear foot slides forward 
 (c) Step forwards, drop down and use a final reverse punch 
 COMPETITIVE KICKS 
 Kicks are harder to score with than punches and in recognition of this, a greater latitude in judgement is applied by the refereeing panel. 
 Scoring head kicks, in particular, are likely to merit a full point, even when they are slightly deficient in skill, range, power, control, etc. 
 Before beginning a detailed discussion of kicks, however, I would like to make two important points. 
 The first is, never kick when you are within punching range. 
 A punch travels faster than a kick and you may be stop-punched by an alert opponent. 
 Bear in mind that a sliding reverse punch covers a lot of ground and a slightly taller opponent may still be able to punch you while your own fists are out of range. 
 Therefore, use kicks from a distance; don't stand on one leg when you are close to the opponent! 
 The second important point is, don't kick unless you have a target. 
 Many people seemingly throw a kick in the hope of hitting something. 
 As you might expect, this inevitably leads to bruised insteps, toes and shins. 
 The cocked fist in a reverse punch travels just over a metre to its target. 
 The instep must travel two metres or so to reach the opponent's head. 
 This distance is further increased should you first need to step in order to close range slightly.  
 Use kicks only when you are well outside punching range 
 Front leg kicks travel the shortest distance, though they are regarded generally as too weak to score. 
 However, with a bit of training a step-up roundhouse kick or reverse roundhouse kick will convince the referee that it is worth a full point. 
 As a rule of thumb, always use a rear foot kick after a feint. 
 The following remarks apply particularly to the roundhouse kick and the side kick and only to a lesser extent to the front kick. 
 I have repeatedly stressed the importance of keeping your centre-line turned towards the opponent, yet some kicks require that you turn it away, sometimes by as much as 120&deg;! 
 This must of necessity put you in a very weak defensive position and I would maintain that this is responsible for losing more bouts than any other factor. 
 The kick misses, recovery is slow and the alert opponent has scored before you know what's happened. 
 It therefore makes sense to use kicks judiciously only when there is a clear opening and the opponent is not expecting a kick. 
 Bag work is essential for training competition kicks. 
 Much modern training aims kicks against the air, so the effect of recoil is never experienced. 
 Consequently, you fall over or jack-knife forwards the first time you land heavily. 
 Train for accuracy, range and control by aiming at a target mitt (this is not suitable for front kick practice). 
 The front kick 
 Different styles of karate perform the front kick in different ways but the effective competition front kick is common to them all. 
 First of all, it is a thrusting and not a snapping kick. 
 It digs into the opponent's mid-section and doesn't just tap it. 
 Secondly, it is aimed high and to the side of the opponent's chest, since this makes it more difficult to block.  
 Front kick (a) Throw a long-ranging reverse punch to the opponent's face 
 (b) Draw back the spent punch, using this action to bring the knee forwards and up. 
 Notice that the sole of the foot is parallel with the mat 
 Begin the front kick from a fighting stance and throw a long reverse punch to the opponent's face. 
 This transfers your weight forwards and allows you to lift the rear foot quickly. 
 Bring your foot up but keep the sole parallel to the mat. 
 Some schools spring the heel off first, so that the foot points downwards. 
 This may be faster but it leads to a kicking action that tends to collide with the opponent's leading knee rather than pass over it. 
 The kicking knee rises higher than the target as the guard is held in place. 
 The supporting knee is bent to aid  balance and the foot swivels slightly outwards. 
 Don't twist the foot too far because although this engages the hip, it also turns your centre-line too far away from the opponent. 
 Thrust your lower foot out with an active push, rather than the passive snap used in some styles. 
 Note that the knee drops as the foot drives out, adding to the thrusting action. 
 (c) The knee drops slightly as the foot digs in to the opponent's midsection 
 For a powerful kick you have to move your centre of gravity forwards, and this inevitably forces you to drop the spent kicking foot close to the opponent, where it can then be hooked or swept. 
 If your kick is such that you can pull it back and reassume your original stance, it is too weak to score. 
 This, of course, is a generalisation; you can withdraw a powerful kick where the opponent has impaled himself on it, because in this instance recoil gives you the required stability. 
 You should land ready to fight and watch out for the opponent's foot sweep. 
 Where the opponent does not advance on to your kick, you should generate extra range and power by sliding forwards slightly on the supporting leg as the kicking knee rises. 
 Preferably, you should use the front kick only when you have first moved out of line and the opponent is unable to respond powerfully. 
 Use the opening reverse punch to achieve this by advancing on a diagonal.  
 (d) Turning the hip too much extends the range of the kick, but renders you more vulnerable 
 The roundhouse kick 
 This is the most commonly used competition kick, scoring more full points than all the other kicks put together. 
 The kick uses a turning action which momentarily exposes a large target area to the opponent. 
 The first objective is therefore to shorten this interval. 
 Throw a reverse punch at the opponent's face, so that your weight moves forwards and your rear foot is free to lift. 
 Swivel on your supporting leg and bring your kicking knee full across your body where you can fend off the attacker, if necessary. 
 Your lower leg should be at the same height as the knee as the latter points to the target. 
 Lean away from the flexed knee and keep your guard close to your body, but avoid hunching your shoulders. 
 Power the lower leg into the target, aiming for a light smack if attacking the head, or a more solid thump if going for the ribs.   
 Roundhouse kick (a) Pull back the spent reverse punch, using this action to help bring your kicking knee across the front of your body 
 (b) Lean away and power the kick into the target 
 Here the attacker's foot has dropped to the outside of the opponent's leading leg 
 You are almost certain to land at least partially sideways-on to the opponent, so be wary of a possible foot sweep. 
 However, unlike with the front kick, the fact you have leaned back means that your centre of gravity is not thrust so far forwards, and you can at least land comparatively lightly. 
 Should your foot drop to the outside of the opponent's leading leg, you could try hooking it around his ankle and dragging his foot the way it is pointing. 
 Lean away as you do this to avoid getting hit in the face with a snap punch. 
 If you succeed, twist your hips back and reverse punch the opponent s face. 
 If the hook fails, continue the movement and turn to face the opponent with your guard raised. 
 Diagonal roundhouse kick 
 There is a version of the roundhouse kick which reduces the time spent turned away from the opponent. 
 This uses a diagonal, rising action that is mid-way between a front kick and a roundhouse kick proper. 
 Though this tends to snag on elbows and shoulders, it is nevertheless a powerful and effective technique, and it doesn't place you at as much potential disadvantage as the orthodox roundhouse kick. 
 Pull-back roundhouse kick 
 Correct distance is crucial to the success of a roundhouse kick, and if you are marginally too close you should draw your front foot back before throwing the kick. 
 This means that even if the opponent throws a punch, you will have drawn back and out of range. 
 You can increase your chances of success by raising the kicking foot sufficiently for it to travel horizontally into the target. 
 If you get the knee high enough, you will even be able to attack the opponent's closed side, looping over his shoulder and into his head.   
 He hooks the opponent's ankle, leaning away as he does so 
 The sequence is completed with a reverse punch 
 Left A diagonal roundhouse kick is fast and not easy to detect, though it usually cannons off elbows and shoulders 
 Below Draw your front foot back as you kick and the opponent's reverse punch will fall short 
 Disguised roundhouse kick 
 If you can do it properly, the following version of the roundhouse kick gives you an added advantage. 
 Throw a reverse punch as before and bring the kicking knee forwards without raising the lower leg or turning the hips. 
 This is the cue for a front kick, not a roundhouse kick. 
 However, as you thrust out your lower leg, you suddenly turn your hips to the side and the technique changes to a roundhouse kick. 
 More than once I have seen a hapless opponent reaching down to scoop a front kick that never comes, and getting caught on the undefended side of the head! 
 Though this technique is not as powerful as the orthodox roundhouse kick, its sheer technical brilliance clinches a full point.  
 (a) At this stage, the technique appears to be a front kick 
 (b) The hips then begin to turn and the kicking foot rises to the side 
 (c) The opponent has responded to a front kick that turned out to be a roundhouse kick! 
 Step-up roundhouse kick 
 This kick is useful because it allows you to move out of line before launching the kick. 
 Throw a snap punch from your leading guard hand. 
 Slide diagonally forwards as you do so and twist your hips so that your centre-line faces the opponent. 
 Aim your snap punch into the opponent's face to disguise the movement of your rear foot. 
 Note that the rear foot is turned outwards, so that the heels touch each other. 
 Then lift the kicking leg and power it into the target.  
 Step-up roundhouse kick (a) Use a snap punch to disguise your step-up 
 Reverse roundhouse kick 
 This is another high scoring technique, though its use is fraught with danger. 
 You must turn until your back is nearly towards the opponent, which is not a healthy position to be in. 
 However, the kick enjoys a measure of success because it can literally curl around an otherwise effective guard and thump into the back of the opponent's head. 
 Even if it is stopped by the guard, you can drop the kicking leg quickly to the mat and push the opponent over it. 
 It goes without saying that you must be quick, otherwise the opponent can turn the tables on you.   
 (b) Then kick with the front foot 
 Reverse roundhouse kick has a habit of curling around the opponent's guard! 
 (a) Your failed reverse roundhouse kick falls to the outside of the opponent's leading leg 
 (b) Push the opponent over your flexed knee 
 Step-up reverse roundhouse kick 
 Practise the step-up version of the reverse roundhouse kick, sliding the back foot forwards until the heels brush each other. 
 Then lift the front foot high and hook it back into the opponent's head. 
 If you kick at the limits of effective range, then your nearly straight leg will bring the sole of the foot into the side of the opponent's face. 
 If you are closer, then your foot curls around and strikes with the knee still part-flexed.    
 Step-up reverse roundhouse kick (a) Slide the back foot up until the heels touch 
 (b) Lift the front foot high&hellip; 
 (c)&hellip; and hook it into the opponent's head 
 The side kick 
 This is an extremely powerful kick that leaves no one in any doubt when it thuds home! 
 Also, there are situations in which it could well save the day. 
 However, the angle at which it is applied makes it very risky from the point of view of defending yourself. 
 Practise the kick from a sideways-on stance such as a straddle. 
 Slide your back foot up (this may not be necessary in all cases) and lift the kicking foot until  the heel is pointing directly at the opponent's mid-section. 
 Note that the supporting leg is twisted so that your hips face 120&deg; away from a forward-facing position. 
 Then thrust your kicking foot until it travels in a straight line. 
 Slide in the direction of the kick and you will add body momentum to an already powerful technique. 
 pull the spent kicking foot right back to the body before setting it down. 
 Side kick (a) Lean away and point your heel directly at the opponent's midsection 
 Note that the foot does not travel upwards. 
 It is brought to the correct height and is then thrust out horizontally. 
 This peculiar action is responsible for giving  the kick its unique feature, that is the ability to generate tremendous power from a very short action. 
 Imagine that you have thrown an unsuccessful roundhouse kick to the opponent's head, and dropped into a sideways-on position. 
 The opponent sees the opening and moves forwards to sweep or punch you. 
 You could then lean back and pick up the front foot, thrusting it straight into the opponent's solar plexus. 
 The recoil gives you added stability, but you must take care that it doesn't thrust you backwards and off balance. 
 Bag work is essential to learn how to cope with the often heavy recoil effect produced by this kick. 
 (b) then thrust your foot out in a straight line 
 The side kick delivered from the back foot is comparatively slow and does no more than a good front kick. 
 In fact, it does a great deal less! 
 It contains more moves, needs a higher level of skill and turns your centre-line clean away from the opponent. 
 Therefore, do not substitute a side-thrust kick where a front kick will work. 
 The back kick 
 This kick is not worth covering in detail since it invariably comes in low and catches the opponent in the groin, and thus rarely scores.  
 FOOT SWEEPS AND HOOKS 
 Foot sweeps and hooks are essential techniques in the repertoire of the would-be karate champion. 
 Their application is a matter of skill and timing and this is reflected in the attention they receive from the refereeing panel. 
 Surprisingly, some people think it is possible to score simply by sweeping the opponent, but this is not the case. 
 The sweep is only part of the scoring combination, and an effective punch, strike or kick must immediately follow it. 
 In practice, the follow-up is often too slow, or it misses the scoring areas, so a good opportunity is missed. 
 The follow-up often fails because you are just as surprised at its success as your opponent! 
 Also, the opponent may fall in an unexpected direction, so that you have to spin around and perhaps take a step to reach him. 
 By that time, of course, the element of surprise is lost and his guard is ready and waiting. 
 The remainder of the sequence then degenerates into a m&ecirc;l&eacute;e of pumping arms and legs. 
 The hook 
 At this point it is necessary to distinguish between foot sweeps and hooks. 
 In fact, there isn't a great deal of difference between the two and the one merges into the other. 
 However, we can see a difference when we compare the two extreme forms.  
 The hook (a) Slide back to avoid the opponent's front kick, then hook his foot as it lands 
 Consider the following scenario. 
 The opponent launches a front kick, which you evade by stepping back. 
 The spent kick slaps down near your leading foot and you hook it away with the crook of your ankle. 
 There are four points to take into account here. 
 Firstly, an effective guard is essential for defending against your opponent's wild punches. 
 Secondly, your step back will have taken you slightly out of line so that the opponent's leading foot is now facing slightly  away from you. 
 Thirdly, you should hook the opponent's foot in the direction that it is pointing because this is the line of least resistance. 
 Finally, note that you hook the opponent's foot before his full body-weight has descended on to it. 
 (b) Be ready with a reverse punch 
 The fourth point is the one that requires the greatest skill because it presupposes that you apply the hook at precisely the right time. 
 Once the opponent has landed fully, the hook will require a lot of force to make it work, and a foot sweep may then be the more appropriate technique to apply. 
 If the opponent is much heavier, the hook won't work at all. 
 However, assuming that you have timed your hook correctly, the opponent will find no support for his descending weight, so he will be obliged to twist and fall on to his side. 
 Be prepared for this and ensure that you are close at hand with a reverse punch. 
 The Sweep 
 Compare the previous example with the following. 
 You notice that the opponent is standing in a wide stance, so you throw a powerful reverse punch at his face. 
 The object of doing this is both to disguise your foot movement and to make the opponent shift his weight back slightly. 
 As you throw the punch, swing your back foot around so that the big-toe edge of the foot strikes the inside of the opponent's leading ankle in a scooping action which knocks it outwards. 
 This jars the opponent off balance and brings the head forwards and into range of a following punch. 
 Notice that in this example of the foot sweep,  the opponent's ankle is actually struck with the flat of your foot and is knocked, rather than drawn, to one side. 
 That is the basic difference between the hook and the sweep though, as I said, the two do blur into one. 
 The sweep (a) Throw a long-ranging reverse punch to the opponent's face. 
 Use this to set your hips up 
 (b) Scoop the opponent's foot, knocking it yet wider 
 The rules of competition do not allow direct attacks upon the limbs, so use foot sweeps with care. 
 I have seen many dangerous foot sweeps applied high on the side of the opponent's leading leg, with some even catching the side of the knee. 
 These sweeps nearly always result in at least a warning from the referee. 
 Bear this in mind when using the foot sweep and ensure that it has a good chance of shifting the opponent by forcing him to lift his weight from the ankle to be attacked. 
 This is particularly important when the opponent is heavier than you are.  
 (c) Complete the sequence with reverse punch 
 Faults to avoid 
 Beware of over-committing yourself to the foot sweep. 
 The opponent may be setting you up by turning his leading foot inwards. 
 Then when you swing hard at his foot, he lifts it so that your sweep passes underneath it. 
 The momentum of the swing forces you to turn your back on the opponent, who is waiting to counter-attack at the first opportunity. 
 Nevertheless, a foot sweep does require a lot of power to prevent it from degenerating into no more than a shin attack.  
 Over-committing yourself to a foot sweep may expose you to your opponent's full point counter 
 The trick, then, is to generate sufficient power without over-committing. 
 The best method I have seen for acquiring this skill uses an impact pad. 
 Have your partner sit down on the mat, extending one leg and flexing the other. 
 Your partner holds the pad at the side of the shin of the flexed leg. 
 You then sweep hard into the pad and try to spin your partner without leaning forwards or over-committing yourself.  
 Sweep the pad really hard and try to spin your partner around with the force of impact 
 Reverse foot sweep 
 The following technique is both spectacular and effective when used by someone with good timing and a fair turn of speed. 
 When it is used in competition a score nearly always follows. 
 Your opponent performs a roundhouse kick to the head and you slide forwards and drop your shoulders, throwing your weight forwards to free the rear leg. 
 Next, you spin on your front foot, sweeping the rear leg around in a wide arc that intersects the back of the opponent's supporting leg. 
 Provided that you have reduced the distance between you, your turning hip will jar against the opponent, lifting him on to the ball of his foot. 
 Your swinging leg then completely takes away his support. 
 Follow this with an effective punch. 
 Summary 
 &bull; 
 Do not attempt to sweep or hook a solidly planted opponent. 
 Attack only vulnerable stances that are too wide, too long, have no sidestep, etc. 
 &bull; 
 Wait for the opponent to move, or force him to pull his weight off the front foot before sweeping or hooking it. 
 &bull; 
 Maintain an effective guard and don't over-commit yourself. 
 Drop down and spin around, so your rear foot reaps the opponent's supporting leg. 
 Notice how close you come to the opponent 
 TACTICS 
 Combination techniques 
 These are series of movements following each other smoothly and in a logical fashion. 
 Whereas an opponent may be able to cope with a single technique, it is much more difficult when the attack is continuous, incorporating both linear and circular blows delivered to different, often widely separated targets. 
 The first punch may be to the face, so attention is focused there. 
 The second technique (which follows on without delay) may be a kick to the ribs. 
 Not only has the target now changed but the technique itself has changed from a linear one (the punch) to a circular one. 
 It follows that if you can deliver an effective and continuous attack, your chances of scoring are higher than when you throw a single technique. 
 When putting a combination together, take account of the distance you are from the opponent and whether this will alter as the combination progresses. 
 Thus, if you begin with a kick and land in a forward position, a second kick will be inadvisable unless the opponent has maintained a constant distance from you. 
 Similarly, if you advance with a rapid sequence of punches, there is little point in throwing a kick unless the opponent has back-pedalled faster than you have advanced. 
 You may find that distance closes quickly during a combination sequence and you and your opponent end up facing each other within reverse punch range. 
 Don't wait around when you are that close because the first person to throw the punch is likely to be the one that scores. 
 A brief feint at the opponent's face may be enough to clinch the follow-up. 
 Bear in mind the way each technique sets the body up in a different way. 
 Thus a snap punch from the leading hand brings the hip forwards and disguises the rear foot as it slides up. 
 The front leg then lifts into a roundhouse kick and drops in such a way that the hips are cocked for a powerful reverse punch. 
 Each time one hip thrusts forwards, the other draws back by an equal amount and is thus cocked for the next punch. 
 This is the principle behind fast flurries of powerful punches. 
 Training methods involve repeating these combinations until the juxtaposition of foot, hip and shoulder becomes automatic. 
 Perform combination techniques on the move so that you are able to work effectively in a retreating as well as an advancing mode. 
 Assessing your opponent 
 Apply tactical thinking to the opponent's stance and attitude. 
 What happens when you suddenly make as though to move into him? 
 Does he stand his ground and look as though he is going to punch you as soon as you come into range? 
 Does he withdraw his front foot, indicating his preference to give ground? 
 Or does he come forwards to meet you? 
 Competitors generally adopt an attacking or defensive attitude which governs their usage of technique. 
 Thus the defensive fighter waits for you to  attack and then counters as your technique is concluding. 
 Don't fall for this but draw him out instead by providing openings. 
 Then, just as he responds, pull back out of range, deflecting his technique and countering. 
 The wary fighter backs off from you and so must be encouraged to make all the running. 
 The aggressive fighter comes to you, seeking to stop punch your attack in its tracks. 
 The aggressive fighter is often weak on defence and generally prefers just to smother your attack so that he can proceed with his own. 
 In this case, you should put him on to the defensive by maintaining a series of very strong attacks delivered from the correct distance. 
 The object, therefore, is to force your opponent to fight in unfamiliar or less preferred ways that he finds difficult. 
 However, in order to do this, it follows that you must be versatile and able to assume many different roles. 
 If you are by nature a defensive fighter, then by adding on the abilities of an attacking fighter you will effectively double your capability.  
 Put an aggressive fighter onto the defensive by attacking strongly 
 Perhaps the first step towards achieving this balance of ability is to be able to use both left and right sides with equal effectiveness. 
 Few of us are naturally ambidextrous but in terms of karate technique this can be achieved through training. 
 Be prepared to train twice as hard on your weaker side and each time you feel fed-up through lack of progress, switch to your stronger side to give yourself a boost. 
 Remember that the competitor who can use all his limbs equally well is able to use a complete range of techniques. 
 If you can use some limbs well but not others, the alert opponent will soon ensure that you are always being wrong-footed. 
 What stance is the opponent using at any time? 
 Is it a high stance? 
 If so,  thrust forwards with a committed attack. 
 Is the stance long and low? 
 If this is the case, it is difficult to suddenly change it, so you should switch to a diagonal attack on the closed side. 
 Alternatively, you could hook the front foot and draw it out. 
 Is the stance narrow? 
 If it is, sweep the front foot to either side. 
 Is the stance too wide? 
 If so, make it even wider by sweeping the lead foot outwards. 
 Is the opponent bouncing up and down? 
 If he is, attack while he is rising because then he will have little opportunity to launch a powerful counter-attack. 
 Southpaw stance forces the opponent to be very careful when making rear foot kicks 
 Advance strongly into an opponent who is in a high stance 
 Are there openings in the guard? 
 If the front guard hand is too far forward, then you can grab and pull at it. 
 This will provoke a strong pull-back which can draw you towards the opponent Lash out with a back fist the instant this happens. 
 Alternatively, you can close the opponent's guard hand across his body with a slapping block that travels diagonally forwards, and then reverse punch to the opponents face. 
 Is the leading elbow too high? 
 If it is, lift it further with a long-ranging reverse punch and exploit the gap that is made with a following roundhouse kick to the floating ribs. 
 If, however, the opponent doesn't move back, snap punch to his face and follow with a reverse punch to his mid-section. 
 Is the leading hand too low? 
 Begin what seems to be a front kick, then change it at the last moment into a high roundhouse kick. 
 Is the guard comprehensive, so that no immediate openings are visible? 
 If so, provide an opening yourself and as the opponent goes for it, rock back and punch over the top.  
 Snap punch to bring the opponent's attention high&hellip; 
 Maintaining effective pressure 
 If your tactics are effective you will accrue points. 
 If they are unbalanced, that is you attack effectively but lose out on your defence, your opponent also will accrue points. 
 Bear in mind that there is a three point scoring ceiling which is often reached within bout time. 
 It therefore follows that even if you are two points ahead at the 30 seconds' bell, the opponent can still pull these back and take the final point to win. 
 The moral is simple: do not let up until the time-up bell sounds. 
 That is the only time when you can rest on your laurels. 
 Similarly, if you are lagging behind at the 30 seconds' bell, it is not too late for you to win the bout. 
 You have little to lose by attacking with the utmost determination. 
 You may at least force the opponent to back off, since he will have more to lose than you. 
 If he backs off too often, he will stand a good chance of picking up a penalty.  
 &hellip; then reverse-punch into the mid-section 
 SQUAD TRAINING SESSIONS 
 National squads 
 Access to international competition is via the national squads. 
 There are two squads for each male age division and two squads for females. 
 Your karate school is responsible for nominating you to the open &bquo;B&equo; or regional squad sessions which are normally held at least twice a year. 
 (Note that you cannot nominate yourself for a place.) 
 A good performance in the &bquo;B&equo; or regional squads may bring you to the attention of the national coach, and may also result in your promotion to the &eacute;lite squads. 
 Another way of getting yourself noticed is in the national championships organised by your governing body. 
 Some people do well in these but not so well in the squad (and vice versa), presumably because of the different pressures each brings to bear. 
 Though you may pick up some new techniques, the national squads are basically designed to select already gifted karateka rather than teach karate tactics or techniques. 
 Wear a clean white karategi and bring your groin guard/ breast shield, shin/instep protectors and mitts. 
 Some sessions involve a heavy work-out, so a spare, dry karategi might come in handy for the second session. 
 Take your governing body licence along for good measure. 
 The national coach will give you some sequences to practise and these usually illustrate some theme that he wants you to work on. 
 Fairly soon, the group will be divided up into pairs for free sparring. 
 The second session begins with a few limbering-up exercises and then goes immediately to the selection. 
 You will fight in up to three bouts (not consecutively) and your performance will be assessed by the national coach. 
 You may be asked to fight again in cases of drawn bouts, and at the end of the session a list of selectees to the &eacute;lite squads will be read out. 
 Don't expect to be selected on your first session! 
 The &eacute;lite squads work more intensively and aim to produce at least three prospective candidates in each weight division. 
 More techniques are taught and there is ample opportunity to demonstrate your ability. 
 After two or three such sessions, everyone's performance is scrutinised and the leading contenders selected. 
 The selected &bquo;A&equo; squad then works together for the targeted event by means of a series of residential training sessions. 
 During the last session the final entry to the forthcoming tournament is chosen. 
 Most successful governing bodies send their entry away for at least ten days' intensive training prior to a world event. 
 This sharpens everyone up and welds the entry into a cohesive unit. 
 The idea of getting everyone away is to isolate them from mundane worries so that they can concentrate wholeheartedly on the task in hand. 
 Training 
 To conclude this section it is necessary to point out a few things about the squad training sessions. 
 Firstly, karateka are not allowed to bring their own coaches  with them to training sessions because experience has shown that the presence of other coaches breaks up the training atmosphere, and causes people to separate to far corners instead of remaining together. 
 The second point is that you may be asked to take a drug test at any squad session. 
 If you refuse, you will be treated as though you had failed the test, and you will face a lifetime ban. 
 Thirdly, the coach is in the business of picking winners, not his friends, so if you haven't been selected, you have to admit to yourself that perhaps you didn't deserve to be. 
 The final point, which is related to the previous point, is that it is a mystery to some people why, despite the fact they do well in the squad, they still don't get selected. 
 We covered this earlier and it may be because the coach feels that you are not capable of performing well under the pressure of an actual competition.  
 It was hard work &mdash; but it was worth it! 
 DEALING WITH INJURIES 
 Being a combat sport karate carries with it the risk of injury and the more you compete, the more likely you are to suffer injury. 
 Thankfully, the majority of injuries are superficial and, with a little care, heal quickly. 
 The purpose of this chapter is to help you to deal with any injuries which you may pick up, so that they affect your fitness as little as possible. 
 Bruises 
 This class of injury is the most common of all and we all know what a bruise is and how it is caused. 
 Freezing sprays give immediate relief and help reduce swelling. 
 However, they should not be over-used or applied anywhere near the face. 
 You can buy small bags which, when squeezed, mix two otherwise separated chemicals to form a cooling solution. 
 These are excellent at bruise management, but they are quite expensive and are not re-usable. 
 As well as a good first-aid kit, a cool-box is useful for storing cold applications. 
 Bandaging 
 Having administered first aid immediately, the next priority is to minimise further damage. 
 The best method is to swathe the injury in cr&ecirc;pe bandage and secure it with tape, not a pin. 
 Then a shin guard is pulled over the whole thing. 
 However, before competing again you must present yourself to the tournament doctor to have both the injury and your bandaging accepted. 
 Tournament organisers and the refereeing panel expect competitors to come to the tournament in a fit state to compete, not shrouded in bandages! 
 Therefore you may find that a bandage is not allowed if you didn't incur the injury in that day's competition. 
 Severe forearm bruising may be covered with both a cr&ecirc;pe bandage and a shin pad (but not a shin/instep protector). 
 Less severe bruising on the arm should be covered only by a cr&ecirc;pe bandage. 
 Since cr&ecirc;pe bandages are very expensive, you may care to look at cheaper support bandages known as &bquo;lyobands&equo;. 
 These are made from a tough plastic foam and are very light to wear. 
 You should discard your cr&ecirc;pe bandages when they have lost their elasticity. 
 Wrap the bandage around the injured limb, then spiral it up or down for one turn. 
 put the next turn around the limb and spiral the third, and so on. 
 This method of bandaging provides a firm grip that is less likely to slide of and fall in festoons during the ensuing bout. 
 Do not put the bandage on too tight or you may find your fingers or toes going blue through lack of circulation. 
 Remove any bandages after the day's tournament unless you are likely to knock the injury during the course of your normal daily activities. 
 Insteps frequently smash into elbows and need bandaging, but they can be protected by shin or instep pads. 
 Do not bandage too tightly but arrange it so that you can move your ankle sufficiently to use foot techniques. 
 However, I would suggest that you subsequently attack employing the ball of the foot rather than the injured instep. 
 Bruised knuckles can be bandaged and this,  together with the mitt, means that they are cushioned sufficiently to allow punches to be used. 
 Severe bruising to the ribs cannot be satisfactorily dressed or protected within the rules of competition, but female competitors can use breast shields which may extend over the injury site. 
 You must make a value judgement as to whether you can cope with any further hard blows on the injury site. 
 I would suggest that if you sustain your injury during the early rounds, and if the injury really is painful, you should withdraw. 
 If, on the other hand, you have got into the semi-finals, you may consider a placing worth the risk of further pain.  
 Begin by wrapping the cr&ecirc;pe bandage one full turn around the limb 
 Then spiral the bandage, aiming for a 50 per cent overlap 
 Close the spiral with another turn, and so on&hellip; 
 Haematomas 
 A hard impact on an unprotected bone can result in severe bleeding under the skin. 
 This raises a lump which may become as big as a small orange. 
 This is a haematoma and if it is in an area where you are likely to receive further knocks, you should withdraw from the competition. 
 Further impacts on a recently incurred haematoma increase the volume of blood lost, which in turn leads to greater discomfort and delayed healing. 
 Haematomas may need draining by means of a minor procedure carried out in the surgical unit of your local hospital. 
 Fractures 
 Some broken bones have no more than a hairline crack in them, but this is enough to cause your withdrawal from competition, regardless of the stage you are at. 
 Unfortunately, it is virtually impossible to distinguish between a severe bruise and a hairline fracture, so the tournament doctor will sometimes insist on your withdrawal, pending X-ray examination. 
 Whereas it may just be possible to compete with bruised ribs, you will not be able to compete with broken ones. 
 This is a good thing because, even if you could, further impacts might well drive them inwards, skewering your lungs. 
 Joint injuries 
 Joint injuries are also very common and the most frequently encountered are impacted toes and dislocated fingers. 
 Apply your freezing spray to damaged toes and report to the tournament doctor. 
 Provided no fracture is apparent, you. 
 can strap the injured toes together and thereafter avoid kicks which require that the toes be pulled back. 
 One word of advice is relevant here. 
 Clean your feet thoroughly before you apply strapping, otherwise it will come off. 
 Do not apply it too tightly and check the balls of your toes to see whether they turn blue and become cold to the touch. 
 If so, this may mean that you applied the strapping; too tightly. 
 Take it off and reapply it. 
 Though extremely painful, you should try walking normally on the injured foot, lifting the heel as you step forwards. 
 If applied early on, this exercise helps retain mobility in the damaged joints. 
 Ankles suffer a high rate of injury wherever poor mats are used. 
 For example, the foot may slip between mat modules or, because of excessive friction, the foot may not turn as it should, resulting in a twisting stress. 
 As before, apply your freezing spray or a cold preparation and lift the ankle between bouts to help reduce swelling. 
 Have the doctor check the ankle for injury to the bone and, if none is indicated, firmly bandage the foot so that the ankle is supported. 
 You may use strapping as a temporary measure, and while this will inevitably reduce freedom of movement, it is the price you must pay for carrying on. 
 After the competition, you should attend the injury with a lighter bandage and work the joint as much as possible. 
 Begin with a light regime and then gradually increase the work-load as the acute phase (the period when the injury is most painful but the effects have not yet manifested themselves) comes to an end.  
 Knee injuries are the bane of the karate competitor's life. 
 Research seems to indicate that normal karate training may lead to joint injury given that when you kick hard against the empty air, there is nothing to stop the movement of the foot except the limits of the joint. 
 Repeatedly slamming the kick out to its fullest extent eventually leads to inflammation of the knee joint and damage to the supporting ligaments. 
 The final result is a permanently damaged knee joint. 
 Prevention is better than cure, and you should use a lot of deep stances during your basic training. 
 These contract the muscles working through the knee without moving the joint itself, so they are ideal for managing acute knee injury. 
 Chronic knee injury can be managed by means of leg extension exercises on a multigym. 
 This builds up the muscles which locate the knee joint, helping to stop it moving above and grinding up bits of cartilage. 
 If your training routine has played up a chronic injury, then apply a light pressure bandage to the knee before beginning the day's competition. 
 Bandage the knee in a slightly flexed position and allow plenty of turns, especially below the kneecap. 
 If the joint begins to give trouble late in the day and you have a chance of a placing, then consider reapplying the bandage, only this time slightly tighter. 
 If you suffer acute knee injury on the day, you should withdraw. 
 Otherwise you may aggravate something that, with a little rest and good management, could have been no more than a minor injury.  
 Deep stances help to strengthen the muscles which locate and stabilise the knee joint 
 Spinal injury 
 An interesting and persistent form of spinal injury occurs when you try to hold your body upright while performing the roundhouse kick. 
 This stops the hip from moving properly, and twists the pelvis, so that a sudden, sharp strain is placed on the sacroiliac joint at the base of the spine. 
 Though this is called a joint, the sacroiliac isn't really capable of much movement, and when pressure is repeatedly applied the joint surfaces become inflamed. 
 Interestingly, the pain this causes shows itself as what used to be called &bquo;groin strain&equo;. 
 Though  debilitating, this should not prevent you from continuing. 
 Treatment consists of giving anti-inflammatory injections.  
 Straining the sacroiliac joint by holding you body upright as you perform a roundhouse kick can lead to long-term pain and discomfort 
 Shoulder injuries 
 Shoulder injuries occur in competitors who have a history of problems with that joint. 
 It is particularly common amongst ex-judo players, and may be caused by an awkward fall. 
 What happens is that the head of the humerus levers through the already weakened shoulder muscle, causing a severe tissue insult and great pain. 
 The tournament doctor may be able to reduce the dislocation by twisting and pulling on the injured limb, but even if he is successful, that is the end of your day's competition. 
 Reduce the possibility of a recurrence by strengthening the shoulders with isotonic work on a multigym, or by using free weights. 
 Wrist injuries 
 Wrist injuries are best attended to with strapping or bandaging. 
 It is important to prevent the damaged wrist from suddenly flexing, and you can afford to reduce freedom of movement at the joint without losing technical effectiveness. 
 Loosen the support when the competition is over and work the wrist in such a way as to maintain its range of movement. 
 Finger injuries 
 Finger injuries should be dealt with immediately before the damaged tissues start swelling. 
 Unfortunately, dislocations occur frequently when the fingers get in the way of an incoming kick. 
 Get these seen to immediately by the tournament doctor, then strap the injured finger(s) between adjacent uninjured digits. 
 Don't try making a fist with the injured hand! 
 Cuts 
 Cuts are not common in karate competition though, on occasions, a cut eyelid may be caused by the opponent's long toenails. 
 Apply a sterile eyepad and hold it in place with micropore tape. 
 But remember that with one eye out of action, your stereoscopic vision is disabled and that means poor range perception. 
 Clean cuts on other parts of the body with moist gauze and apply a waterproof plaster to exclude dirt. 
 Split lips occur when they are caught between your fitted gumshield and the incoming kick. 
 These are sore and bleed freely, but the haemorrhage soon stops if a pad is held against them. 
 Clean up the area to gauge the extent of the cut and, if necessary, draw the edges together with a steristrip closure (a small strip of tape designed to stick firmly onto skin). 
 Stitches may be necessary to close a gaping cut, and if this is not done a permanent scar may result. 
 Do not fight on if the stitches are in danger of being ruptured.  
 Teeth 
 Dental damage is both painful and disfiguring. 
 If your tooth is chipped you can fight on if you want to. 
 If the tooth is loosened in its socket, modern dental surgery may be able to fix it to adjacent teeth. 
 However, if the tooth is knocked out completely, little additional damage can be done by fighting on. 
 Nose bleeds 
 Immediate first aid for a bleeding nose is to tilt the head back and pinch the nostrils together for as long as it takes. 
 Next, pack the nose with cotton wool or gauze and make sure that you inform the referee in subsequent fights that you sustained this injury. 
 Do not fight in further rounds if your nose is broken &mdash; unless, that is, you don't mind losing your looks! 
 As well as being painful, a further bang on a broken nose can greatly increase disfigurement. 
 Head injuries 
 The final injury I want to talk about is brain damage caused by a hard blow to the head. 
 If you lose consciousness, even for a second, then you have suffered  brain damage and must withdraw from further competition. 
 There is no leeway in this case! 
 If you fight on after sustaining a head injury and then receive a further blow to the head, the damage caused by the initial impact will be multiplied several times over! 
 The problem with head injuries is that you can't see any blood, so you refuse to accept that serious damage has ensued. 
 If you are knocked out for longer than a few seconds, you should report to your doctor as soon as possible after the competition. 
 Allow at least six weeks to recover from a head injury. 
 Maintain your fitness level during this period but cut out sparring. 
 First aid for a bleeding nose is to pinch the nostrils closed whilst tilting the head back 
 Withdrawal 
 It is possible to win two bouts if your opponent is disqualified for injuring you, but after the second win the referee will withdraw you from further competition for your own safety. 
 Drugs 
 There is not doubt that certain classes of drug can increase aggression, sharpen awareness and dull the pain arising from injuries, but they are all banned. 
 Under the governing body's initiative, some karate competitions now include a random drug test. 
 If the result of your test is positive, you can say goodbye to your competitive career. 
 Bear in mind that cold cures and certain drinks contain prohibited substances that show up in a drugs test. 
 Therefore, make sure that you take advice before entering a competition. 
 Also, bear in mind that traces of drugs remain in the system and can be detected for some time after you have stopped taking them. 
 I would therefore advise against taking any kind of drugs, not just because it is unsporting, or because of the threat of severe penalties on discovery, but also because of the adverse effects any drug regime has on the mind and body. 
 It is necessary to know when you have been hurt, if you are to avoid making the injury worse. 
 Furthermore, if your level of aggression is increased by drugs, you may very well prove to be a danger to the opponent and lose anyway! 
 First Aid Kit 
 Every competitor should have his own first aid kit. 
 Also, the coach should have a comprehensive kit on hand and he should be skilled enough to use it properly. 
 A coach's kit consists of a pain-relieving cold spray, a couple of medium width cr&ecirc;pe bandages, a roll of adhesive strapping, a roll of micropore tape (for securing injured fingers and toes), some adhesive tape, a few pieces of gauze, absorbent cotton wool, a package of baby-wipes, a roll of toilet paper or kitchen towel, some steristrip closures, waterproof plasters, an eye-pad, some pain killers and a pair of strong scissors. 
 A pair of tweezers is also useful for pulling out splinters. 
 A coolbox containing cold packs and energy-restoring, sugary drinks is also useful.  
 THE REQUIREMENTS OF A KARATE CHAMPION 
 Skill is one of the most important elements in the champion's make-up, because if he can't perform the right technique at the right time and in the right way, he will never make it to the winner's rostrum. 
 However, while skill is something that can be trained other aspects of success may be pre-determined. 
 Karate competition is biased in favour of long-limbed individuals who have good reach in relation to their weight. 
 The taller you are for your weight, the more range advantage you will accrue. 
 Try to fight in the lightest category you can manage without heavy dieting because, theoretically, the heavier you are within the weight limit, the more power you can pack into techniques. 
 Pare down your weight until you are carrying as little excess as is commensurate with health. 
 Women, in particular, can train off too much fatty tissue, and this sometimes leads to menstrual problems. 
 You must have predominantly fast-twitch, white fibres in your muscles to generate really fast, explosive action. 
 Those of us with mainly slow-twitch, red fibres are physiologically disadvantaged, because there is nothing we can do about our muscle type. 
 The only way to minimise this lack is by yet further skill-acquisition. 
 Yet no matter how far you progress with this, ultimately you will have serious problems with an opponent of equal skill but faster-acting muscles. 
 Finally, it is as well to realise that the title of &bquo;karate champion&equo; can only be legitimately conferred by a national governing body recognised by the Martial Arts Commission. 
 To discover whether you are affiliated to a bona fide school write, enclosing an s.a.e. to: The Martial Arts Commission Broadway House 15 &mdash; 16 Deptford Broadway London SE8 4PE.  
 The News 
 Thin blue smoke poured straight up from the freshly mortared chimney of the McCullochs' house in Weem. 
 It tinged the air with a smell of herbs and whisky. 
 Old Donald had put three more peats on the fire. 
 His daughter Mary said it was all he was good for &mdash; using up fuel that others had cut. 
 She was a scold &mdash; whenever she was near him he felt in the wrong and wondered anxiously what it was he ought to have done. 
 But between them, he told himself, they had made this nest comfortable. 
 He looked up with satisfaction at the panelling of the new box-beds &mdash; comfort and decency for all three of them, while others in the village still slept on the floor like beasts. 
 And the stone seats beside the fire would be replaced with benches, once Cameron brought the rest of the spare timber he had promised from the linen mill he was building for the Flemyngs at Aberfeldy. 
 Cameron made him uneasy with his dark, closed look, the way he stopped and thought silently before he answered you. 
 But he got things done, he was a weighty man to have in the village, no doubt of that. 
 Old Donald touched the peats with his fingers to bring more of the dry brown fibres above the flames. 
 His thick fingers with their horny' nails that stood away from the flesh took no harm from the heat. 
 He wanted to feel warmed through to his spine, to have the comfort steal into him like strong ale. 
 It would soothe away the worries that ached in his head, even on this hazy gold morning of early September, with a fine harvest coming and plenty of work for the young men in the new town. 
 A clack of shoes in the road outside. 
 High-pitched shouts. 
 He looked up startled, his eyes fire-dazzled, trying to focus on the door through the dusty levels of sunlight from the two small windows. 
 It flung open and slammed back against the wall. 
 Mary burst in. 
 She stared at him and seemed not to see him. 
 She sat down on the floor and took great heaving breaths as though she had come up a hill with a burden beyond her strength.  
 &bquo;What is wrong with you?&equo; her father asked. 
 &bquo;The lists,&equo; she said through her big breaths, which were trembling now. 
 &bquo;Robertson &mdash; has made up &mdash; his lists.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lists &mdash; what lists?&equo; 
 The old man was taking refuge in confusion. 
 She glared at him and her impatience at his frailty began to neutralize her fear. 
 &bquo;You know very well what lists &mdash; marking down the young men for the wars.&equo; 
 &bquo;Will Donald be named?&equo; 
 &bquo;He is twenty-one, is he not? 
 And not married?&equo; 
 &bquo;They may not call on them. 
 They surely have enough already.&equo; 
 &bquo;You know nothing.&equo; 
 She stared in anger at the old man's face, at his eyes which goggled anxiously at hers, then roved off when she met his look, his lips which caved in on his gums and mumbled and tightened as though he was always eating. 
 Did she have to shoulder his fears too? had he no strength left at all to feed into their little supply? 
 &bquo;If his name is there, he is in mortal danger, and if the French war gets worse, they will be taking them all.&equo; 
 &bquo;They may not be sending them abroad &mdash; &bquo;That is what they promised when James enlisted.&equo; 
 Her heart cramped now as she thought of her husband's folly in plumping for the easy money, as it had seemed, after three bad harvests &mdash; his airy promise to come home soon &mdash; his failure to return after his regiment had been disbanded in Madras and left to make its own way back round half the world. 
 &bquo;That is what they promised Morag Mackintosh and big Mary, and Sheila Stewart, and Flora MacGregor. 
 And they are all widows now. 
 James was a fool, but Donald will be a pressed man and a slave. 
 And so will a hundred others from hereabouts. 
 No no no!&equo; 
 She rose on to her knees and looked as though she was praying, but her eyes were fully open and the clenched look on her remarkably white face with its mannish black eyebrows suddenly reminded him of her dead mother. 
 &bquo;We will not lie down under this.&equo; 
 She said it with an almost questioning tone, as though listening to the sound of her own defiance to gauge how real it was. 
 But her hands were gripping into fists. 
 &bquo;What will you do?&equo; 
 He looked scared and she pitied him. 
 &bquo;Och &mdash; give them a dose of Archibald Menzies's medicine. 
 A bit of a ride down the road and a chance to change their minds.&equo; 
 She giggled unexpectedly. 
 &bquo;There will be a good crowd at church tomorrow, that is for sure. 
 Where is Donald?&equo;  
 &bquo;Gone after rabbits, up the hill.&equo; 
 &bquo;He would be better doing a day at the mill.&equo; 
 Her return to mere domestic grievances was a relief after the nightmare about the army. 
 He felt hungry, and went through to the cool room at the back for a bowl of sheep's milk and some bits of potato. 
 When he came back, she had gone. 
 From the front door he could see her walking along the road past the graveyard with three of her friends, their heavy skirts swinging. 
 As he sat by the fire softening potatoes between his gums, he felt pleased with himself. 
 If they took a whirl at the minister, he would have a fine sight of the fun. 
 Two days ago when they had carted out Menzies the minister and Fleming the young teacher from along the road at Dull and danced round them like children at a Halloween fire and stuck them up on horses, facing backwards, and paraded them past the door and down the road to Aberfeldy, he had flung a soft carrot himself and caught the man on the side of his face. 
 He had deserved all he got &mdash; was that what ministers and teachers were paid for? to draw up the militia lists and condemn the young men to the barracks and the camps, to swamp fever in the Indies and their legs and arms blown off? 
 Young Donald &mdash; his eyes were clear black-brown, like a lochan stained with peat, his hair was curly like a bull's poll, and he had been a lovely lad until his father went away, clever with his hands, whittling pieces of wood and glueing them to make little windmills and watermills. 
 The wheel he had mounted on a bit of rod from Stewart's smithy still turned freely in the burn at the side of the kail-yard. 
 If he was taken for the army, the light in their house would be damped out forever. 
 Who would reap the corn and the flax, or milk the ewes? 
 Mary would work like a slave, but a woman could not take the animals to market, though he knew of widows living alone, soldiers' wives mostly, who farmed on in a rough way by themselves, their cattle straying and mixing with the herds of others, their oats still standing in November&hellip; 
 Old Donald chuckled in himself as the scene in the road came over him again. 
 The horse had stopped, held its tail out stiffly, and dunged a yard beneath the minster's gaping face. 
 A young lad had called out, &bquo;See what the beasts think of the Act!&equo; 
 And another had capped that: &bquo;Aye &mdash; send a dollop of it down to London!&equo; 
 They had spirit enough for anything. 
 They would need it, to match the military. 
 Down in Tranent, which was somewhere near Edinburgh, and anything could have happened there &mdash; but old Donald had had this from Cameron  himself, and he got newspapers by the carrier's cart from Dunkeld &mdash; some miners had sworn not to serve, even if the King called on them, and the Volunteers had chased them into the cornfields and played havoc with their sabres&hellip; 
 That was a bad dream &mdash; like the &bquo;Forty-five again. 
 He had brooded himself into a black dwam, and when the door opened again he started violently and spilled the last of the milk on his legs. 
 Young Donald was grinning at him with his new look of mockery. 
 &bquo;Where have you been?&equo; 
 The old man was trying to imitate his daughter's sharpness. 
 &bquo;Your mother was after you. 
 The hay you left lying last night will spoil when the rain comes.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rain? 
 The sky is clear as glass. 
 Grand weather to be after the girls or the rabbits.&equo; 
 Young Donald leaned his long-barrelled small-shot gun in the corner by the door and then his face darkened over. 
 &bquo;What did she want?&equo; 
 &bquo;She thought you would be working. 
 There is the timber to pay &mdash; &bquo;There is nobody working from here to Killin. 
 Do you know what they have done there? 
 They have taken Fergusson the teacher, while he was nailing up the lists, and stripped him and tarred him &mdash; &bquo;Donald &mdash; you would not do that! 
 They will put them in the gaol for that!&equo; 
 Young Donald coolly considered his grandfather's staring look of fright and answered him deliberately: &bquo;No &mdash; I would not dirty my&equo; hands on a bit of a teacher. 
 But they will never get the Killin lads. 
 They are off into the hills and they will hide there as outlaws till the Act is lifted.&equo; 
 &bquo;Would you do that, Donald? 
 Would you hide if you had to?&equo; 
 The lad looked suspicious. 
 &bquo;Have you been hatching something up with her  &mdash; to stow me away?&equo; 
 &bquo;She only wants you safe &mdash; &bquo;She wants me safe from Jean. 
 Well &mdash; if she had taken kindlier to her a year ago, we might have been wed by now, and I would have escaped the list.&equo; 
 He glowered at old Donald, as though to brand the accusation on to him too. 
 Then he looked suddenly sulky like a child. 
 &bquo;Tell her, if she comes back bothering about the hay, she can turn it herself. 
 Unless she's too busy flinging mud at ministers.&equo;  
 The Conversation 
 Angus Cameron looked incredulous, permanently. 
 His friend James Menzies the wine merchant, in whose house he lodged, had said once, infuriated after a two-hour argument, &bquo;Angus &mdash; do you believe nothing  completely?&equo; 
 After thinking about it, Cameron replied, &bquo;James, I was told a good thing once, by the sawyer at Bunarkaig. 
 I used to help there as a boy. 
 &bquo;Angus,&equo; he said, &bquo;if anybody ever says anything to you, think to yourself, How can I disagree with that? 
 And if you cannot, well then you might believe it.&equo; 
 And that is the best thing I ever heard.&equo; 
 They sat in the parlour, on the evening of Saturday, September 2nd, waiting for Menzies' man Allan Stewart to come back with the news from Blair Atoll. 
 They were disputing strategies for the resistance and drinking red wine from France &mdash; sour claret, which had proved hard to sell. 
 The room had the look of a tattered nest &mdash; piles of newspapers were stacked against the walls, empty stone bottles stood about with dust on their shoulders like soldiers after a battle. 
 The hearth was drifted up with cinders that had been left uncleared when today's fire was lit. 
 Mrs Menzies had died five years before, killed by malaria and stomach trouble from their time in Bengal. 
 Menzies himself had a yellow face with a stained-looking flush on each cheekbone, and when he felt a bout of fever coming on, he drank to drown the symptoms. 
 Now he looked over at Cameron, taking stock of the quizzical lift of his right eyebrow when he looked out below his black fringe, the down-turn of his mouth under his long curved nose, and began to recapitulate his argument with care, uncomfortably aware that Angus might think he was trying not to sound drunk. 
 &bquo;Consider, Angus,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They have seized the Session Books at Auchtergaven, and Kirkmichael, and Logierait, and &mdash; and many another place. 
 So the lists cannot be drawn up. 
 So the Act cannot be applied. 
 That strikes to the root.&equo;  
 &bquo;The root? 
 We wheedled the book ourselves out of that gullible weakling Fleming over at Dull. 
 But Menzies had had copies made already. 
 They are crafty. 
 We must be craftier.&equo; 
 &bquo;Och, craft&hellip; they need frightening. 
 The Auchtergaven men broke in at night with their faces blacked and knives in their hands. 
 Old MacCormack wet himself &mdash;&equo; James laughed and spilled wine. 
 &bquo;He must have been terrified.&equo; 
 &bquo;Terror is all very well, but it breeds revenge. 
 I say, discredit them. 
 Menzies and Fleming will never forget that two hours riding backwards, with every soul from Dull to Aberfeldy having a good look at their humiliation.&equo; 
 &bquo;So they'll want vengeance too.&equo; 
 &bquo;But nobody will join them in it, because nobody respects them. 
 They are butts now. 
 But old MacCormack is a victim. 
 Blackfaced men with knives! 
 They sound like pirates, or ruffians. 
 A few wild men playing a violent game. 
 And when the big men, the Lord Lieutenants and the Colonels of Volunteers, when they get violent back, how do we resist? 
 We are many, but we are unarmed. 
 Like the Tranent folk.&equo; 
 &bquo;We can soon change that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well&hellip; 
 There are fifty muskets in the Duke's armoury at Blair Castle. 
 How do we get them? 
 Only by going there in thousands, outnumbering his tenants, talking to them , until they feel their power, and disarm their masters. 
 And how do we muster thousands? 
 Our people will never come out unless they understand the reasons for all this stir. 
 But once they know &hellip; 
 You can keep a people ignorant but you cannot make them ignorant &mdash; &bquo;Tom Paine?&equo; 
 &bquo;Who else? 
 Do you think I could rise to such wisdom?&equo; 
 This sounded ironical but James could not fathom which way its edge was turned &mdash; was Angus actually mocking Paine, his chosen prophet, or merely depreciating himself? 
 Angus was too deep &mdash; you never knew&hellip; 
 Ruffled, and pent-up in his urge to plump for some outright and decisive plan, he grabbed the poker and hit the smouldering coals. 
 A red one jumped out on to the floorboards and they began to smoke. 
 Menzies threw his wine onto the coal, it fizzed, and a reek of bonfires filled the room. 
 Cameron was shaking with laughter, looking on and making no move to help. 
 Steps clicked on the stones outside and Allan Stewart came in, out of breath, his red hair darkened and sticking to his forehead. 
 James at once poured him wine from a fresh jug and  refilled his own glass and Cameron's. 
 &bquo;You're early,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I hardly expected you before midnight.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Faskally boatman brought me across the foot of the loch and I came straight over the hill to the Brig of Grandtully.&equo; 
 &bquo;So he is friendly?&equo; 
 &bquo;They are all friendly on that side.&equo; 
 Stewart's eyes were alight and he was drinking the claret down like water. 
 &bquo;It is like Hallow-fair from Ballinluig up to Blair. 
 I went for a sup to Widow Duff's howff, of course &mdash;, &bquo;Of course.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, where else would you go to meet up with the Duke and his followers?&equo; 
 (The &bquo;Duke of Lennox&equo; was John McLaggan, a horse dealer from Grandtully.) 
 &bquo;And was the Duke on his feet or his back?&equo; 
 &bquo;I think his head was clear enough, for all it was going round. 
 You know he is known to everybody &mdash; &bquo;As a rogue.&equo; 
 &bquo;And a singer, and a clown with plenty of good stories to tell folk while he wheedles out their money. 
 His sons have been to every place and farm along the Tummel. 
 Every family with a young man knows they may lose him to the war, and they are as furious about it as a swarm of bees. 
 Or Alex and Donald say they are, and I believe them. 
 They are all outside their houses, staring along the roads, waiting for something.&equo; 
 He stopped talking, still breathing hard, and held his glass out frankly for a fill of wine, like a child asking for milk. 
 James poured, then held the spout of the jug over Cameron's glass. 
 Why was he saying nothing? asking no questions? 
 Surely this was the news they had most wanted to hear. 
 &bquo;Angus?&equo; he said, but Cameron was looking past him at Allan Stewart, sceptical and intent. 
 He said at last, &bquo;So what plan has come out of all this buzzing and swarming?&equo; 
 &bquo;It will suit you, Angus,&equo; Stewart said, laughing and unabashed. 
 &bquo;They have done their homework too &mdash; they have it down on paper. 
 A letter for the Duke of Atholl.&equo; 
 &bquo;Saying what?&equo; 
 &bquo;I would have brought a copy away but they wanted them all. 
 They ask the Duke to do away with the Act, because it will turn the Atholl Highlanders into slaves, and if he will not, they will fight to the last drop of their blood.&equo;  
 &bquo;With targe and claymore? and a roar and a rush downhill?&equo; 
 Cameron's voice dried up their excitement like a dose of paregoric. 
 &bquo;Does MacLaggan want them to charge against the muskets, and make a Culloden in Strath Tummel? 
 Does he know what has happened in Tranent?, 
 &bquo;Come on, Angus, he said no such thing.&equo; 
 Menzies was querulous, an ache in the head was interfering with his thoughts. 
 &bquo;They will confront the Duke &mdash; &bquo;Will he let them up the drive? 
 If more than forty-nine go up there, he will read the Riot Act.&equo; 
 Allan Stewart had flushed with discomfiture at the defusing of his story. 
 &bquo;He will have no option but to meet them, man. 
 You should see them &mdash; they were ringing the Castle round when I came away, and making themselves fires for the night on Cnoc na Lude across the Tilt. 
 If the Duke looks out from his eastern windows, he will see crowds of flames dancing among the tree trunks, a hundred fires and a dozen folk round every fire.&equo; 
 Cameron looked steadily at him for a while until Stewart turned his head with a little toss and swallowed down his wine. 
 Cameron got up and went over to the back window. 
 In the north their own wooded hill rose up. 
 It showed as a black absence of stars in the lower sky. 
 No fires here yet. 
 Above it the Plough was tilted and he followed the line of the two stars at its end until he found the Pole Star. 
 His thoughts were running north and west, up into Lochaber, the oakwoods and pinewoods at the foot of Loch Arkaig which had cradled him in his boyhood. 
 It would be peaceful there. 
 But the Act threatened his people too&hellip; 
 James looked at his back for a full minute, then asked, &bquo;Are you wishing it was like that here &mdash; fires on the hill?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, it is not,&equo; Cameron said without turning. 
 &bquo;But it could be?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh aye &mdash; all sorts of things could be. 
 Fair rents. 
 Fair leases. 
 No king, no throne for him to sit on &mdash; &bquo;Now you are the dreamer.&equo; 
 It has happened in France, Cameron felt like saying, and then the thought of the gulf between France and Scotland came over him so dauntingly that he suffered a backwash of despair. 
 Lochaber&hellip; 
 He thought of the autumn day fourteen years before when his father had taken him through the hills towards Morar. 
 He had been pestering him for a while for stories about the grandparents he had never known. 
  At last big Angus said, &bquo;Very well &mdash; let us go and see the old place &mdash; if we can find it.&equo; 
 They had walked by Murlaggan at the head of the loch and up Glen Pean. 
 Midges drawn by the smell of their sweat swarmed round their heads and young Angus began to regret his curiosity, but his father's face was set and dark in a way that froze out complaints, or chatter of any kind. 
 Long before they had passed the watershed and were looking over into the jaws of the mountains at the head of Loch Morar, young Angus felt he had strayed into a foreign country. 
 The black mouths of the peat haggs reminded him of stories about ghosts and murders. 
 Suppose they lost the solid path between these pools? 
 The ground quaked as they walked on it. 
 He looked back. 
 All landmarks that he knew had long since sunk out of sight beyond the rise. 
 And they had all that way to travel back&hellip; 
 But now his father was slackening the pace and looking round him. 
 &bquo;Is this it?&equo; 
 The moor looked empty. 
 Big Angus stared at him as though he was not there. 
 It was along ago, young Angus thought. 
 Maybe he has forgotten. 
 They trudged on again, their feet following a vein of beaten earth under the thickness of the heather. 
 Ahead, a low cairn of granite boulders rose clear of the moor. 
 And another. 
 They were shaped &mdash; they were the shells of cottages, each one reduced to its ground plan, one course of massive stones, roughly masoned, with rounded ones at the four corners. 
 Big Angus was pointing along a stretch of turf between the shells. 
 &bquo;There is the street. 
 And there &mdash;&equo; He stopped and seemed to struggle. 
 His hands rose into the air and clenched, as though he was wrestling a bullock by its horns. 
 &bquo;That is my father's house.&equo; 
 He pointed. 
 &bquo;My mother was born there.&equo; 
 He pointed at a shell on the far side of the street. 
 &bquo;They fired the thatch &mdash;&equo; His hands gripped and whitened. 
 &bquo;They fired every house and they ran the men down like deer. 
 The women and children had gone off to the caves &mdash;, &bquo;Did you not fight?&equo; 
 Young Angus felt hot with rage and wrong. 
 His father was more than six foot and could toss the caber further than any man in Bunarkaig. 
 He could have laid in wait for the soldiers and split their heads and &mdash; &bquo;Fight? 
 Some of us knew what that meant by then. 
 The bold spirits stood and made a show until the muskets cut them down or sent them fleeing. 
 The rest of us crouched under the bank of the river.&equo; 
 He pointed across a meadow overgrown with rushes. 
 &bquo;When we put our heads up, we saw the fires, and the swords slicing away. 
 When they had killed three sheep and roasted them in the middle of the street  and ridden off with the rest of the flock, and the cattle and the horses and the hens, we buried the dead &mdash; we were at it for most of a day &mdash; and then we went off east into Arkaig. 
 And now I am sorry I came back. 
 But you had to know.&equo; 
 Young Angus thought, You were a coward &mdash; no you were not &mdash; what else could you have done? 
 He grew up that day, and never again saw his father as a being who could do anything and was never at a loss. 
 His mother looked nervously at them as they came in long after dark &mdash; she was obdurately against the recalling of &bquo;the bad old times&equo; and she would neither ask them what they had seen nor let them tell her. 
 It had been his first and only history lesson, and throughout their hungry and needy years in Bunarkaig he never lost the sense that they lived under threat, that government was pitiless, and that some day they would have to fight again for the right to live at peace in their own place. 
 He surfaced from his thoughts and turned back to the room. 
 James was slouched back in his chair with his mouth a little open. 
 Allan Stewart was starting to clear away the mess of jugs and pots with a deliberate clatter. 
 Sensing the need to gather the loose strands of the evening into one firm fabric, Cameron said, &bquo;Tomorrow then &mdash; we go to hear Archibald Menzies preach at Dull., James was staggered. 
 &bquo;We have taken care of him already. 
 We had better torment our own man next.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Cameron, wishing that James would think harder and spoil less for a mere sporting occasion. 
 &bquo;James MacDiarmid will be expecting us, so we will let him stew a bit. 
 Allan here can keep an eye on this place, and handle ambitious little Robertson if he tries to nail up his damned lists. 
 I think we should cover Dull, and see whether the man there has had his wits cleared by the smell of fresh shite under his nose.&equo;  
 The Sermon 
 The Reverend Archibald Menzies, minister to the stony and muddy village of Dull, was not exactly the pride of his parishioners &mdash; he had little chance of being that, since he had been chosen by the laird, not elected by the people. 
 But they took some wicked pleasure in his fame as the most extraordinary vocal artiste in the whole Synod of Dunkeld. 
 He used the complete gamut of his voice, from a growl like a dog warning its master that it has a sore foot to a high, exalted monotone which he kept for perorations; and when he was using the words of an Old Testament lament, Isaiah or Zephaniah, to make a piteous effect, he had been known to put his head back and yowl like a tom-cat. 
 The congregation usually watched him with a perverse relish which he mistook for devout attention, but this Sunday afternoon there was palpably an added curiosity to see how well he managed to live down the shaming comedy he had enacted on horseback a few days before. 
 As he made his way down the path from the manse between the round-shouldered granite gravestones, his face looked pink, as though he had recently shaved in scalding water. 
 Some people at the church door caught his eye and smiled and bowed respectfully but others looked away and exchanged glances with grinning friends. 
 As he put his foot on the doorstep, a young man seemed to jostle him &mdash; it was young McCulloch from Weem, the sulky handsome lad with the curly head &mdash; why had he come hanging about here instead of hearing his own man preach in Weem? 
 To stir up mischief, no doubt, and to eye Jean Bruce, the blacksmith's daughter &mdash; they had been seen strolling about in the gloaming more than once, laughing quietly together and holding hands. 
 But there were other interesting visitors from down the strath &mdash; Cameron the builder, who came late, and sat in a pew near the back beside Donald Stewart, the blacksmith from Grandtully. 
 Soon the door was closed, leaving outside, among the gravestones and round the Cross, a small and growing crowd who lingered on with a sense that the entertainment might not be over.  
 A psalm droned and swelled. 
 The minister read a lesson from Job, chapter 2. 
 When he came to the words, &bquo;Then said his wife unto him, Dost thou still retain thy integrity?&equo;, 
 Cameron began to wonder if Mr Menzies was identifying himself with Job, and when he ended ringingly on &bquo;Shall we receive good at the hand of God, and shall we not receive evil?&equo;, the suspicion was confirmed. 
 Clear yellow sunlight shone through the window-panes, making a pattern of diamonds on the plasterwork. 
 Children in the congregation watched the diamonds slowly grow squarer, less elongated, as the sun moved down the sky. 
 Another psalm. 
 The shuffling and rustling of bodies settling again into the pews. 
 A resigned silence congealed over the rows of people and the Reverend Archibald Menzies gripped the edges of the lectern, closed his eyes and raised his face to the ceiling, then looked down at the serried faces and spoke. 
 &bquo;I will speak to you today on a text from that book, the Book of Exodus, which is so replete with wisdom concerning the leader and the led. 
 The Book of Exodus, chapter 16, at verse 6.&equo; 
 He paused to let the devout look up the passage in their Bibles. 
 &bquo;And Moses and Aaron said unto all the children of Israel, At even, then ye shall know that the Lord  hath brought you out from the land of Egypt: And in the morning, then ye shall see the glory of the Lord ; for that he heareth your murmurings against the Lord : and what are we, that ye murmur against us? 
 And Moses said, This shall be, when the Lord  shall give you in the evening flesh to eat, and in the morning bread to the full; for that the Lord  heareth your murmurings, which ye murmur against him: and what are we? your murmurings are not against us, but against the Lord .&equo; 
 Mr Menzies' exposition was fluent. 
 It swelled, diminished, and swelled again like an oratorio. 
 At times his voice went through its paces almost independently of the sense. 
 When he repeated the text (which he did frequently), &bquo;And in the morning&equo; would boom suddenly and dozy members of the congregation twitched, wondering if they had missed something. 
 What they had missed was an elegant argument in which Mr Menzies cast himself as Moses, the much-wronged and sorely-tried shepherd to the Israelites, and his session clerk and schoolmaster James Robertson as the faithful lieutenant Aaron. 
 &bquo;For Moses and Aaron knew, they knew full well,&equo; said Mr Menzies  in a sorrowful coo, &bquo;that their lot was a thankless one. 
 But equally,&equo; his voice surged, &bquo;they knew that the Lord would provide. 
 And they were not mistaken, for He did provide, and provide abundantly: quails and bread, &bquo;and he that gathered much had nothing over, and he that gathered little had no lack; they gathered every man according to his eating.&equo; 
 But were they satisfied? 
 I fear not, for indeed &bquo;they hearkened not unto Moses&equo;, they murmured against him, and against Aaron, which is to say, they murmured against the Lord, for was it not the Lord Himself, speaking and working in  Moses, who had brought them out from the land of Egypt?&equo; 
 And so the words turned back on themselves, phrases reappeared, seeming to confirm other phrases, merely repeating themselves, clicking into place with a semblance of logic which nicely disguised the truth that all these words were nothing but a glittering fabric which hovered above the ground, unwinding endlessly, slipping between the fingers, beguiling like a mirage, taking on whatever shape the conjuror wanted, and leading nowhere. 
 Cameron now expected a glancing reference to Exodus 32 and a figuring of Aaron the idolator as the rebel and troublemaker who seduced the honest Israelites with the golden calf of dangerous principles. 
 But if Mr Menzies had thought of this he must have been keeping it for another Sunday. 
 Evidently he had decided to finish on a note of grave and reproachful dignity. 
 &bquo;For those were troublous times,&equo; he said on a downward-curving cadence, &bquo;and such times have come again, but take heart: for &bquo;when Joshua heard the noise of the people as they shouted, he said unto Moses, There is a noise of war in the camp. 
 And he said, It is not the voice of them that shout for mastery, neither is it the voice of them that cry for being overcome: but the noise of them that sing do I hear&equo;.&equo; 
 He finished, face raised and eyes closed, and at once gave out the final psalm. 
 Mr Menzies had enunciated &bquo;them that sing&equo; with noticeable pleasure in the resonant properties of the words. 
 Looking at his glistening face, his cheeks and forehead like apple-skins, Cameron wondered what fired him most at this moment &mdash; self-satisfaction? or a true pleasure in poetic language? 
 Whichever it was, he did live well. 
 He was entirely suited to enjoy the hospitality at the Castle, to relish Sir John's venison and cranberry sauce and compliment him on the beauty of his larches. 
 I am envying him, thought Cameron sardonically. 
 Outside, single shouts sounded &mdash; a threatening growl from several voices together &mdash; hens squawking. 
 Startled faces turned as they sang, then turned back and looked at the pulpit. 
 Mr Menzies said the benediction,  it seemed at a deliberately dragging pace. 
 Everyone filed out, pushing a little, finding it hard to maintain their Sunday solemnity. 
 The graveyard was packed with people, more were arriving down the farm lanes and along the main road from east and west. 
 On the boulder that lay against the rough stone stump of the Cross two men were standing, waving torn papers and conducting the crowd in a chorus of jeers. 
 Cameron caught sight of young McCulloch from Weem, standing beside Jean Bruce with his arm round her waist. 
 He shouldered towards them and asked, &bquo;What is going on?&equo; 
 Donald McCulloch was jubilant. 
 &bquo;Oh, three of the Duke's boobies from Blair Castle came riding up with bits of paper &mdash; some rubbish about the Act. 
 So the lads here knocked them from their horses, and stripped off their breeches&equo; &mdash; Jean Bruce giggled and he paused to cuddle her and kiss her cheek &mdash; &bquo;and sent them back to Atholl. 
 Their horses are in the park &mdash; three good ones, too.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do these papers say?&equo; 
 &bquo;Who can tell? 
 They are in English,&equo; Donald said contemptuously. 
 Beside the Cross one of the men had torn a paper into little bits and scattered them, to a groaning catcall from the crowd. 
 The other man shook his head, held up his paper, and shouted out, &bquo;Can anybody read this?&equo; 
 &bquo;Give me a look at it,&equo; Cameron shouted back. 
 Faces turned, bodies gave way a little, and he went up to the Cross and took the crumpled sheet. 
 He scanned it &mdash; it was little more than a text of the Act. 
 He reminded himself of the details and exulted as he saw what he could do with it. 
 &bquo;Here is a polite letter from the Duke of Atholl,&equo; he said loudly, waving the paper. 
 &bquo;And you know he rarely bothers to address us. 
 But now he wants our young men, so he is gracious. 
 They want six thousand,&equo; he paused, &bquo;not more, a mere six thousand. 
 They are to serve as long as the war lasts, and a month on top of that, they are to serve in Scotland only&equo; &mdash; someone cheered &mdash; &bquo;or so it says, and you can ask Widow McCulloch, or Widow McGregor, if they have heard that anywhere before. 
 The parish schoolmasters are to make up the lists, and I am sure they will oblige. 
 Every man from nineteen to twenty-three is liable, except for married men with two or more children, and sailors, and apprentices &mdash; whoever heard of apprentices as old as that?&equo; he jeered, and the crowd jeered with him. 
 &bquo;And except for ministers, of course &mdash; we cannot do without them ; or schoolmasters &mdash; the Lord Lieutenants will need them  to draw up more lists and sign  away more lives when the six thousand have bled and died in France, or Spain, or India.&equo; 
 A hoarse, angry noise came from the crowd and faces turned to look at Fleming the teacher, who was standing near the manse under a yew tree. 
 &bquo;Objections to be heard by the Deputy Lieutenants &mdash; all honourable men, I am sure, and well above military age. 
 They have sons, no doubt, but most of them  will be in the Volunteers already, and I see that they too are exempt. 
 Each district to be balloted to produce its squad for the six thousand, and if the ballot brings up your name,&equo; he paused again and saw the hundreds of eyes fixed on his, &bquo;then you must go off to the Army, or else pay &pound;10 to hire a substitute. 
 So there is the Duke's special message for the people of Strathtay. 
 It will have to be answered, so we had better talk about it in the shelter of our homes, and in the morning we can send and tell him what we think.&equo; 
 There was silence at that, an air of waiting for more. 
 But presently the crowd loosened into smaller groups and a good many people went off into the village or set off for outlying farms. 
 Fleming the teacher had gone into the manse as soon as Cameron finished. 
 Cameron found Donald Stewart and set off beside him towards Weem, which lay among its woodlands in a light blue haze of evening smoke. 
 &bquo;Will we meet in the morning, then? 
 And had the Grandtully folk best come up the glen and join on at Dull?&equo; 
 Stewart was thirsting for action, his colour high. 
 But Cameron felt spent with the effort of the past hour and would say only, &bquo;Let us see if anything went on at Weem.&equo; 
 And it had: James Menzies and Allan Stewart were full of it. 
 An unprecedented crowd, with quite a few strange faces, had gathered round the church door before the afternoon service. 
 John Robertson the schoolmaster had come &bquo;trotting along from the manse, looking full of himself and with not a word to say to anyone&equo;. 
 He had brought out his lists, four sheets, and had got them half fixed to the door when Allan knocked him aside and tore them down and then spent an hour, with James's help, going down the names and telling the young men to their faces whether or not they were listed. 
 A great anger had heated up, one of Robertson's new windows had been shattered by a stone, and the womenfolk had made a move to drag the teacher out and throw him in the river. 
 But by then he had taken refuge in the church, and the service must have been little more than a conversation between him and old MacDiarmid, because not another soul had dared to run the gauntlet and go inside when the clock struck three.  
 The Signing 
 The conference in James Menzies' house that night was brief. 
 Camerun would not drink, feeling his head hum already with the gathering pressure in the village and with his compulsive second thoughts about his speech. 
 He knew he had simplified the matter when he said the six thousand would be sent abroad to the War &mdash; simplified it and coloured it blood-red. 
 To make an effect? 
 Like Menzies the preacher? 
 Was he himself as calculating and vain as that? 
 But surely it was right to warn the people, to make them feel their plight. 
 It was a time for fierce tactics, not for scruples. 
 But the scruples would spawn in his head, giving a cynical taint to his image of himself. 
 He sighed tiredly, as though he had been working for a full day with stone and timber, and tried to listen to James Menzies, who was well away, drinking whisky with Allan and simmering with the news from the west, where the lists had been torn down from the church doors at Fortingall and Kenmore, and from Blair Atholl: the Duke's factor had had to meet a crowd of more than a thousand and the Duke had signed a paper swearing not to impose the Act. 
 James seemed in a fever. 
 He was stoking the fire unnecessarily until the flames raced up the chimney. 
 &bquo;So &mdash; should we beard Sir John at once, and serve him our ultimatum? 
 Come on, man &mdash; the folk are ripe and ready.&equo; 
 &bquo;I would wait a day or two,&equo; Cameron answered reluctantly. 
 &bquo;But they will not ask me.&equo; 
 They did ask him, however, and they came in hundreds for the purpose. 
 He felt he had scarcely fallen asleep, he was dreaming of a black river, with no banks, yet there was something there, a source of light that he wanted to reach, which he could not reach against the cold drive of the current&hellip; 
 He woke in a sweat &mdash; voices &mdash; a dog barking. 
 Someone entered the room and he recognized Allan Stewart's voice. 
 &bquo;There is a crowd here, asking for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;What time is it?&equo;  
 &bquo;Not sunrise yet. 
 But near it.&equo; 
 Cameron got out of bed and dressed, feeling unreal. 
 He expected a few dozen people. 
 But the ranks and clusters of them stretched uncountably into the darkness. 
 He turned to James in amazement and saw that he was enjoying his surprise, as though it confirmed one of his arguments. 
 Keen wafts of pine resin sharpened the air. 
 Torches were bubbling out flames and streaming smoke. 
 A man coughed and Mary McCulloch's voice said, &bquo;Snuff it well in, Dugald. 
 It will clear your chest.&equo; 
 The few people who were visible looked like a crew of spectres as the shadowed hollows in their faces shifted with the wavering of the flames. 
 Instinctively the two men were looking for faces that they knew &mdash; Mary McCulloch and her friends, big Mary as tall as a man, red-haired Flora. 
 Cameron recognized several of his workment from Aberfeldy and warmed to their comradeship &mdash; he had talked little politics with them (in the aftermath of the big treason trials, caution had seemed advisable) but he had passed on his newspapers and one of the men came from Lochaber like himself. 
 People were stamping their feet and putting their hands in their armpits against the chill of an open, starry night. 
 One person looked at another, grinning or expressionless. 
 Few were talking. 
 The current of force in them was eddying slowly round &mdash; it had reached a level stretch after whatever rush had carried them here. 
 No weapons were to be seen but a good many shepherds' crooks and plenty of rough sticks cut from birch or alder. 
 Cameron felt called upon to act. 
 But why him? 
 He wanted the choices and decisions to be clear. 
 But in this new raw situation that was flooding up round them, nothing could be clear, not yet. 
 He turned to Menzies and said, &bquo;Who all is here? 
 Aberfeldy and Weem, but who else?&equo; 
 &bquo;They say they have gathered in all who would come out from the north side down to Pitnacree, and the south side as far up as Kenmore., &bquo;The Grandtully crowd? 
 The &bquo;Duke's&equo; army? 
 We will need them. 
 We will need everybody.&equo; 
 &bquo;The word has gone up every road and track. 
 Look &mdash; they are still flocking in.&equo; 
 A ripple of new arrivals was making the front row press forwards. 
 Cameron and Menzies were squeezed back nearly into the house, and big Mary, finding herself hard up against Menzies, took his arm, cleared a space with a sideways butt of her hip, and twirled once round with him. 
 &bquo;Come away, James!&equo; she said loudly. 
 &bquo;This is better  than a ceilidh.&equo; 
 He twirled her again, hands clapped a rhythm, and faces glowed briefly as pipes were lit. 
 Cameron turned back into the house for his cloak and tried to order his thoughts as the last fogginess of sleep evaporated in his head. 
 If James was right and they could count on contingents from every part of the strath, they would be a force indeed &mdash; a mass big enough to frighten the most assured gentleman. 
 Would the others make for Castle Menzies? 
 Where else? 
 You had to trust folk. 
 They knew their business, more or less. 
 They knew the owners, the well-to-do, the grandees back from Jamaica and Bengal who sat here now behind tall walls and drew their rents. 
 Down beyond the fork where the Taly joined the Tummel another world began &mdash; the world of government. 
 The axis that joined Edinburgh to London &mdash; that was the lightning-rod of power. 
 Sir John Menzies was part of that, by his marriage to Atholl's daughter, and Atholl dined and intrigued with the Lord Advocate when he went to Edinburgh for the season. 
 Each of these men occupied a bastion. 
 Well, they had penetrated Atholl's bastion and he had had to meet &bquo;his&equo; people man to man, and man to woman, on a level, with no intermediary. 
 Menzies the old bon vivant had not a fraction of Atholl's strength, he would not dare to turn them away, and if he did they would go in there with sticks and clubs and &mdash; As Cameron felt his anger rising, he swallowed it, took up his own cherrywood stick from the corner, and went hack outside. 
 A pale yellow lustre was growing low down in the east, making feathery silhouettes out of the black stands of trees along the bends in the river. 
 Faces turned as he came out and sleepy people started to get up from the low walls and boulders it the side of the road. 
 James nodded to him as though for confirmation and then said loudly, &bquo;Let us go to the Castle &mdash;&equo; He became aware that the further reaches of the crowd were out of hearing and shouted at the top of his voice, &bquo;Let us go &mdash; along to the Castle &mdash; and let us see &mdash; what John Menzies &mdash; will do about the Act!&equo; 
 Scattered cheers answered him, big Mary gave a &bquo;Heeuggh!&equo; like a dancer, and the whole throng began to move along the road westwards, past the dark silent fa&ccedil;ade of the inn, the equally silent church and manse, towards the gates of Castle Menzies. 
 Sir John Menzies had a recurrent dream, especially on the nights when his young wife would not have him in the bed beside her, or he had been drinking late, and he slept in the side bedroom, which  was tall and narrow with two pistols perched on nails in the wall. 
 He dreamed, each time, of his plantation in Jamaica &mdash; banana palms leafed like green fountains, bright orange papaws clustered at the top of their naked stems, a noise of surf quickened the air with its rustling freshness. 
 All the animals were dying. 
 A cat lay outside the front door, one of its eyes protruding in a grotesque bubble with the iris leering darkly from its rim. 
 Butterflies as big as birds fell down from the branches, wings flopping limply. 
 A golden oriole lay on its side in the twilight of a banana grove; a column of ants was passing to and from the bedraggled corpse. 
 A thud of chopping &mdash; movement between the tree trunks &mdash; a labourer was coming towards him, one of the consignment of convicts he had ordered through a merchant in Bideford, he had his machete in his hand, he was not menacing, he held out his spare hand in a strange appeal, lifting his face, which was crossed by deep scars, wounds across his eyes had puckered them right in so that he moved like a blind sleeper, closer and closer &mdash; Sir John woke up sweating, surprised to find himself alone, and then remembered: he had been drinking with his cousin Alexander Menzies of Bolfracks, the last bottle must have sent him under. 
 His head was swinging and throbbing like a bell, The bell was  ringing &mdash; absurd! 
 Was there a wind to swing the great plantation bell which he had brought home and hung on the oak beside the east gate? 
 He got up in his night-shirt and looked incredulously out at the twigs of the stately chestnut tree in front of the castle. 
 They were motionless. 
 Someone at the bell &mdash; why did his factor and nephew Robert not go out and stop them? 
 What could be happening? 
 In a spasm of irritation he pulled a cloak over his nightshirt, took down a pistol from the wall, and went downstairs into the chilly, stone-smelling darkness of the ground floor, looking for servants. 
 As big Mary pulled heartily at the pleated rope of the bell, a loud murmur of voices and footsteps sounded along the road west. 
 The dawn light showed a crowd of men and women with a pack of dogs running beside them. 
 Cameron and James recognized none of the faces. 
 The men wore short kilts of grey homespun, their hair was flowing or knotted at the back, most were bearded: the uplanders had arrived from the Glen of Keltney. 
 Now, surely, the whole of Strathtay was going to turn out. 
 Looking down from a small window in the lodge house, the factor Robert Menzies was terrified to see the throngs  of people, like herds of cattle milling at a tryst. 
 Amongst them he saw, with a further pang, Joseph Stewart, the laird of Foss beside Loch Tummel. 
 What on earth &mdash;? 
 As he watched, a young lad suddenly stooped behind Stewart and made a piggy-back, another lad shouldered him, and over he went, falling heavily while people nearest roared and laughed. 
 He was a prisoner, then? 
 Thunderous knocks hit the door downstairs, the bell clanged and clanged. 
 &bquo;Lock the door behind me!&equo; he said to his wife. 
 He went out on to the landing, opened a window, and called out to the crowd: &bquo;What do you want? who are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;We want you, dearie!&equo; a woman shouted. 
 Above the laughter a man's voice carried and Robert Menzies recognized the wine-merchant from Weem. 
 &bquo;We have business with the laird,&equo; James Menzies shouted above the bell. 
 &bquo;So get him down here.&equo; 
 &bquo;I do the laird's business. 
 But not before the sun is up. 
 Come back at nine o'clock.&equo; 
 A roar greeted his effort at authority and dirt spattered him, making him blink and cower. 
 If he could see the culprits! 
 But it was hard to pick out faces that he knew in the swaying mass of heads. 
 &bquo;Put on your breeches and get your master. 
 Our business is personal with him and if you get between us &mdash;&equo; The factor waited for the threat but a tall cloaked figure standing beside Menzies had pulled his arm to forestall him. 
 &bquo;Take off your nightshirt and come down like a man!&equo; &mdash; a catcall from the body of the crowd. 
 Hooves sounded. 
 To his left, along the drive, he saw the grey-haired minister from Weem arriving at a gallop. 
 The gatekeeper opened half the gate to let him through. 
 Before he could close it the crowd swarmed past him in their hundreds and set off towards the castle at a trot. 
 James Robertson, teacher at Weem and Session Clerk to the Reverend James MacDiarmid, was wakened by the minister in the dim bluish light of dawn. 
 He slept on a straw pallet in the low attic space at the Widow MacIntosh's and these days he hated to wake up. 
 Sleeping was no better &mdash; fleabites tormented him, fears plagued him like bad dreams. 
 His colleague Fleming's humiliation on horseback had made him dread the same thing for himself. 
 And the ordeal of putting up the lists &mdash; he could still feel the brute weight of Allan Stewart's shoulder  jolting him aside, the smell of whisky on his breath, and then the twilit hours lying low beside the minister in the church, waiting for the hubbub outside to die away. 
 He shuddered awake. 
 Mr MacDiarmid's long yellow face and white hair were close above him. 
 &bquo;Robertson! 
 Robertson! 
 Are you not awake, man? 
 Half the parish has been roaring past your door.&equo; 
 &bquo;You will wake Widow MacIntosh &mdash; &bquo;She is not here, you fool &mdash; she has gone off with the mob.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where? 
 What &mdash; &bquo;They are off to the Castle, where else? 
 They will be mobbing Sir John by now. 
 I will ride there and maybe pass them among the trees. 
 You follow as fast as you can.&equo; 
 &bquo;Me? 
 What &mdash; &bquo;You know the business.&equo; 
 The minister's wintry face looked acid with disapproval. 
 &bquo;These people are all mad to escape the Act. 
 Well, we have a duty to draw up the lists, and manage the ballot, and by God we will carry it out and support Sir John, or else there will be madness and misrule here for evermore. 
 Now &mdash; dress yourself and come.&equo; 
 He went out and Robertson heard the hooves of his garron clopping on the road. 
 He got up and dressed as though in a trance, and set off for the Castle with the hangdog look of a condemned man. 
 In the smithy house at Dull, Jean Bruce hail lain silently under the covers until her four little sisters and brothers had stopped fidgeting in the oppressive atmosphere and her parents had started to snore. 
 When she heard the shrill call, like an owl but human, she slipped out and joined her lover in the little barn beside the byre. 
 She and Donald had started to take risks &mdash; they wanted each other so much that the reality of other people had dimmed for them, half the time they felt cloaked in invisibility. 
 And now that Donald's name was on the militia list, the thought of being parted obsessed them and they made love as though each time was the last time. 
 Just now they had been utterly careless about the noise they made in the hay. 
 The open night sky had not yet cooled the air, they were sweating, yet they still lay close together and the soft milk-and-blood smell of her breasts soothed his nostrils. 
 But the worry surfaced again. 
 &bquo;If you go for a soldier&equo; &mdash; she had said it fifty times &mdash; it will stop us getting wed. 
 And if you go to England &mdash; &bquo;  
 &bquo;There are other things could stop us marrying.&equo; 
 He was disinclined to disturb the well-being of the moment. 
 &bquo;Only because I am very young. 
 And father likes you. 
 And they  married young enough &mdash; mother was sixteen when she had me. 
 But you do not sound bothered&hellip; 
 &equo; Anxiety was making her touchy, unsure even of him. 
 &bquo;Not bothered!&equo; 
 He was stung to speech. 
 &bquo;Who will have to march and bleed, and live on filth? 
 Who will lose his legs &mdash; &bquo;And sleep without his girl &mdash; &bquo;&bquo;My family have been through all this already. 
 Where is my father? 
 Rotting in India, or Africa? 
 Where is he?&equo; 
 &bquo;He should never have gone.&equo; 
 At that he turned his face round and glared at her. 
 &bquo;If there is an army, men will go off to it, if they are poor.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know &mdash; I know.&equo; 
 She cuddled close to him again, to soothe away the friction of disagreement. 
 &bquo;But they will never take you, Don &mdash; I will hide you here &mdash; no, I will hide you up at the old shieling hut &mdash; or we could run away west into Rannoch &mdash; &bquo;There are forts everywhere. 
 But the islands might be safe&hellip; 
 &equo; So they romanced for a time, whispering on the edge of sleep, until a noise of footsteps, first a few and then large numbers, came from the road outside. 
 &bquo;What is that?&equo; 
 Jean startled awake. 
 He was listening. 
 &bquo;The Keltney people? 
 Making for the Castle? 
 Look &mdash; the sky is lightening. 
 We had better join them.&equo; 
 She shook his hand. 
 &bquo;Donald &mdash; if you go straight there, folk will know where you have been.&equo; 
 He laughed. 
 &bquo;I will say I was catching a stray.&equo; 
 He put his arm round her waist and kissed her hard. 
 &bquo;Jeannie &mdash; if you come, I will meet you among the crowd. 
 Otherwise &mdash; tonight, and I will give the call. 
 Jeannie &mdash;&equo; They kissed again and then he was gone, running after the uplanders to catch them at Camserney mill. 
 It was like a drovers' camp in front of Castle Menzies. 
 The light of the risen sun was glittering now on the tall glazed windows of the central part and glowing like honey on the yellow walls. 
 Perfection, thought Cameron &mdash; dominance and wealth most perfectly crystallized in dressed stone, sleek plasterwork, trees planted in a picturesque frame. 
 It looked as though nothing would ever shake it. 
 Behind some  of the panes pale blurs of faces could be seen watching &mdash; womenfolk and servants. 
 When people in the crowd pointed and called, the blurs disappeared. 
 Down on the grass and on the bare earth under the chestnut tree, dozens of people now squatted at their ease among the sheep and their droppings, drinking from skin water-bottles and smaller stone ones of ale or whisky. 
 Most people had stayed on their feet, expectant and alert, and frankly curious to size up the laird's domestic arrangements while they had the chance. 
 Women were remarking on the window hangings &mdash; &bquo;You could hang my whole downstairs with one of those red curtains,&equo; said Mary McCulloch, &bquo;and have a length left over for the beds.&equo; 
 A good many boys and girls had joined the crowd now and shouts of laughter broke out as a few of them came out from the gate in the kitchen-garden wall, their hands full of ripe peaches, their chins dripping with juice. 
 On the edge of the gravel near the front door, Cameron and James Menzies conferred with Allan, Donald Stewart the blacksmith, and John Stewart the pedlar from Newbigging, who seemed to have been everywhere in the past twenty-four hours. 
 The factor had gone into the castle, &bquo;to get his orders from his master,&equo; as Cameron put it. 
 The men were hotching for action, but what response could be dragged out of those granite walls and that oak door? 
 Cameron was resolved on one thing. 
 &bquo;We will not waste our time chopping logic with that underling. 
 We talk to the laird only.&equo; 
 &bquo;The old man will never come out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Last week he might not have. 
 But now that Atholl has given way and condescended to meet the people &mdash; &bquo;He is a diplomat,&equo; said John Stewart. 
 &bquo;But this man here has a temper.&equo; 
 &bquo;His factor will be feeling it now, for letting us through the gates.&equo; 
 James Menzies laughed. 
 &bquo;I would like to have seen him holding us back with an old sword in his hand.&equo; 
 &bquo;Pistols, more likely,&equo; said Allan, &bquo;and a musket or two. 
 Remember the old man is a sportsman &mdash; good at killing, and at chasing slaves. 
 He is cornered now &mdash; maybe he will come out red-eyed like a bear.&equo; 
 &bquo;So long as we get him out&equo; &mdash; Cameron was still cagey. 
 &bquo;We talk to him only &mdash; do you agree? 
 And we keep him prisoner here till he signs. 
 Have you the paper?&equo; 
 Menzies felt in his pocket. 
 &bquo;Yes, it's safe., The low thick door had swung open. 
 As the factor came out, it shut behind him and they heard the bars and chains go on. 
 Robert  Menzies was nervous, his eyes flickered everywhere, but he had his message pat. 
 &bquo;Sir John will meet a spokesman this afternoon &mdash; if you have anything particular to say. 
 But now you are to leave his land peaceably &mdash; &bquo;A murmur rose in a crescendo and drowned him out. 
 The people at the front were shouting at him, the news of his message was running through the crowd like a grass fire. 
 Somewhere a bagpipe skirled. 
 &bquo;Tell the laird,&equo; James Menzies began, then raised his voice so that he could be heard as well by the crowd as by the factor. 
 &bquo;Tell the laird,&equo; he shouted out, &bquo;that we will have him out here, to hear us for himself &mdash; that is what we came for and we will stand here till we see him. 
 We need his name, in his own hand, on a paper against the Act. 
 And if he stays behind that door&equo; &mdash; the mounting gale of voices behind him was lifting him as he spoke, he wanted to jump on the factor, grab his hair and swing him against the door like a battering ram &mdash; &bquo;we will fire the roof! and smoke him out!&equo; 
 A pulse of pressure from behind threw them against the factor, he turned and jumped for the door, beat on it, it opened abruptly, and he fell inside. 
 Cameron turned and rose on tiptoe &mdash; the Grandtully crowd had arrived in force, the &bquo;Duke of Lennox&equo; in the lead, he was striding across the grass with an oak-tree branch slanting across his chest like a sceptre, its green sprays nodding on his shoulder. 
 A piper marched beside him, the patched black bag of his pipes under his arm, the chanter blowing a reel. 
 The Duke was revelling in the occasion, his toothless mouth curved up in a great leer like the mask of comedy. 
 When the boys saw him, they ran towards him, calling out shrilly &bquo;Up the Duke!&equo; he swung his sceptre at them and they ducked, shrieking. 
 Shoals of people were coming up the drive from the west gate &mdash; Cameron recognized faces that he knew from the sawmill at Kenmore. 
 Amongst them walked a gentleman in an expensive greatcoat, his arms firmly held &mdash; another hostage. 
 Good tactics, whether planned or not &mdash; the more gentry were pinned down here, the fewer were left to muster the Volunteers or ride off with news to the Deputies at Blairgowrie. 
 Dust hung in the air now, making it yellow and the sun orange. 
 People coughed. 
 Someone had fainted and a woman was loosening his shirt and running water over his head. 
 Up in the chestnut branches girls and boys were clambering about, hitting at the spiked green conkers and knocking them down on to the heads below. 
 Somewhere behind the east wing of the castle glass shattered. 
 Menzies had better  come out soon. 
 As Cameron surveyed the crowd, trying to make a rough count, he saw some women cracking stone bottles against their cudgels, stripping off their stockings, and packing them with shards and handfuls of gravel from the forecourt. 
 In the hall of the castle Sir John was reasoning with a group of servants while Lady Charlotte had hysterics under the portrait of a clan chief of the sixteenth century &mdash; an armoured and bearded warrior who looked down with an imperious black stare. 
 At one side the Reverend James MacDiarmid was standing in his dark clothes with the conspicuously expressionless demeanour of an undertaker's mute. 
 The servants wanted to flee, by a back door. 
 &bquo;McDougal, calm them down!&equo; 
 Menzies barked fiercely at his butler. 
 &bquo;This is a castle, not a cottage, we could sit here in safety for a year.&equo; 
 Glass cracked and splintered in the passage through to the kitchens. 
 A maid jumped and began to scream shrilly on the same note as her mistress. 
 &bquo;Robert&equo; &mdash; he turned on his factor &mdash; &bquo;you should have made it plain &mdash; &bquo;Nothing is plain out there, I tell you. 
 It is like hanging day in the Grassmarket. 
 You should see their eyes.&equo; 
 &bquo;I will not parley with a rabble.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bring Menzies of Weem in here, then. 
 What else can we do?&equo; 
 &bquo;You said he was obdurate. 
 Who else is there? 
 Are they all cottars and tinkers?&equo; 
 &bquo;There is that tall sharp fellow from the new factory &mdash; Cameron. 
 They say he made a speech at Dull.&equo; 
 &bquo;A speech! 
 A farrago of treason. 
 We will have no speeches here. 
 Come on &mdash; let us beard this lot and send them packing. 
 The half of them are on my rent-roll anyway.&equo; 
 He looked with displeasure at the frantic figure of his wife and said tersely to the housekeeper, &bquo;Mrs McDougal, have you no smelling salts? 
 Or you might try brandy &mdash; it cures most fits. 
 Come, MacDiarmid. 
 Robert, open the door.&equo; 
 A funeral silence had come over the gathering. 
 Hundreds of eyes stared fixedly as the laird stepped out onto the gravel and stood for a moment with his chin jutting and his mouth pulled down, like a general reviewing his troops. 
 Behind him the minister stood as straight and shadowy as a cypress tree. 
 Two servants came out, labouring  under the weight of a kitchen table. 
 The factor showed them with fussy gestures where to set it. 
 They went back for chairs and then the laird, the factor, and the minister sat down weightily, like judges. 
 Cameron could sense James Menzies fidgeting and breathing beside him and he wondered if he had had a dram. 
 Then James spoke up. 
 &bquo;Good morning, Sir John. 
 Mr MacDiarmid &mdash; it is Monday now, you know. 
 Are you here to bless us?&equo; 
 &bquo;I am here in duty bound to assist Sir John.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, he will need that. 
 But where is little Robertson, to do your writing for you?&equo; 
 &bquo;The Session Clerk has been informed. 
 He should be here by now.&equo; 
 And he was &mdash; a small figure in a drab coat, lurking at the side of the crowd, speaking to nobody. 
 MacDiarmid waved him forward with a commanding sweep of his arm and he came and sat at the end of the table. 
 There was a pause while everyone present wondered how to proceed. 
 Abruptly the laird smiled, looking from face to face along the front row, and said, &bquo;Well, well &mdash; it is a fine morning for it. 
 Shall we &mdash; &bquo;But James had mentally worded his speech a dozen times and would not be forestalled. 
 &bquo;You cannot pretend not to know our purpose,&equo; he began, so loudly that the laird's head went back. 
 &bquo;We are all here as free men &mdash; not tenants, and not plaintiffs or slaves but free people who are determined to remain so. 
 Now this Act will bind six thousand of us &mdash; I am not speaking in my own interest, I am well past the age &mdash; but this Act will empty the glens of the young active men &mdash; and how can they marry if they are in barracks and camps in England, or in France if you send them there &mdash; you say you will not&hellip; 
 &equo; He was wandering now, his voice had dropped as he struggled to keep his thread and a restlessness at the back of the gathering broke out in shouts of &bquo;Speak up! 
 What did he say?&equo; and then &bquo;Where is Cameron? 
 Tell Cameron to put the case.&equo; 
 Angus looked at his friend. 
 James's face had reddened with confusion but he managed to give him a nod which said &bquo;Go on.&equo; 
 Cameron half-turned, to speak as much to the crowd as to the table, put his head back, and spoke slowly, pausing between his sentences. 
 &bquo;Sir John Menzies, and Mr MacDiarmid, represent the important people of this place. 
 They have the power to send the rest of us into the ranks of the army, if they like, or into prison or the colonies. 
 But if we are free citizens&equo; &mdash; he paused on the word, feeling it alien but unable to think of another &mdash; &bquo;if we are not slaves, we must have liberty  to say &bquo;No, we have no dispute with France &mdash; we have business here at home which matters more than anything else on earth &mdash; we will not learn to play with swords, or blow out brains with bullets.&equo; 
 Now, we cannot speak to the government, but we can speak to you.&equo; 
 He turned and let his eyes lock with the laird's, the minister's, and the factor's, each one in turn, while they stared back and tried to look perfectly blank. 
 &bquo;You are sitting here because you have the power, and if that is true, then you can use it as well for us as against us. 
 I hope you do not approve of this Act &mdash; if you do, there is not another man or woman in all this country who does. 
 And you must know that, because we are all here. 
 Count us.&equo; 
 He paused again. 
 &bquo;Now, we are asking  you&equo; &mdash; he stressed the word with some irony &mdash; &bquo;we are asking  you to join with us in a petition to the government for relief from the Act. 
 What do you say?&equo; 
 The laird had been studying Cameron with unwavering attention. 
 Now he looked down at the table top, then sideways at his colleagues and back at Cameron. 
 &bquo;I have listened to you, Mr Cameron,&equo; he said finally, &bquo;and you have spoken for the people of Tayside. 
 I believe, however, you come from somewhere else?&equo; 
 Cameron smiled at that, a tight smile with his mouth closed. 
 &bquo;Yes, I come from Lochaber, and the Lochaber people, if they were here, would be at one with the people of Breadalbane. 
 I can say that because I now belong to them both. 
 Now, can we do business?&equo; 
 The last word came out fiercely and the force of it set off a slow noise from the crowd, like surf on a beach. 
 Menzies half turned as though to consult the minister, then said abruptly: &bquo;You may petition if you like.&equo; 
 &bquo;But will you join us? 
 And will you?&equo; 
 Cameron leaned towards the minister, who straightened his back still more but said nothing. 
 Sir John was sitting perfectly still, his hands pressed between his knees, his forehead red under his wig. 
 &bquo;A petition can be proper enough,&equo; he said very deliberately. 
 &bquo;But what will it say &mdash; have you thought of that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes,&equo; said Cameron, &bquo;there has been plenty of thinking. 
 We will have words for you in a minute,&equo; and he turned round to the crowd. 
 &bquo;Have we leave to write down what you are all agreed upon?&equo; he shouted in his loudest voice. 
 &bquo;Can we do that?&equo; 
 There was a roar of assent and the gathering began to stir and kindle into easier feelings &mdash; neighbours muttered to each other and laughter came from the Grandtully part of the crowd. 
 Cameron was speaking to the people  nearest him, gathering suggestions, prompting, trying to draw in James Menzies, who looked sullen after his poor showing. 
 Finally Cameron turned back to the table and said, &bquo;We have agreed on a text. 
 Will you hear it?&equo; 
 The laird nodded and Cameron said curtly to Robertson the teacher, &bquo;Take this down.&equo; 
 &bquo;What will I write with? or on?&equo; 
 The man was bridling at being treated like a minion. 
 I have paper here &mdash; properly stamped. 
 I suppose there are pens in the castle.&equo; 
 They were brought and Cameron dictated slowly, cheers punctuating his sentences. 
 &bquo;We, the country people of Tayside in Perth, living between Fortingall in the west, Foss on Tummel in the north, and Logierait in the east, do solemnly petition your Worship to exempt us from the Militia Act passed in July this year, 1797, for it would submit us to hardship and bondage, which we believe to be no duty of ours.&equo; 
 He paused, and this was taken as a signal for a round of cheers and shouts. 
 &bquo;Is that enough?&equo; he asked the front ranks of the crowd. 
 &bquo;Go on &mdash; make him sign,&equo; a young man shouted back and Cameron recognized young McCulloch from Weem. 
 Robertson had caught up with the words and passed the manuscript, still wet, to the laird. 
 &bquo;Give me the pen,&equo; said Menzies. 
 Silently he corrected a word, silently he endorsed it. 
 He stood up, stony-faced, and was turning to the door when James Menzies held up his hand and said, &bquo;Wait &mdash; wait &mdash; that is only half the business.&equo; 
 The laird frowned. 
 &bquo;You have your petition &mdash; &bquo;We have that, but we need our safety and liberty as well. 
 You must commit yourself, and so must all the gentry, to take no vengeance for today's work. 
 You must keep the soldiers out of here.&equo; 
 There was a loud cheer at that. 
 The laird waited for it to finish and said scornfully, &bquo;How can I do that? 
 That is in the hands of the government.&equo; 
 Cameron was demurring too. 
 &bquo;Wait, James &mdash; what is the use of making him pretend to powers?&equo; 
 &bquo;Whose side are you on?&equo; 
 Menzies snapped back. 
 &bquo;We need security.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course we do, but it must be plausible. 
 If it looks forced, it will count for nothing., Angus and John Stewart were restive now and young McCulloch was jeering openly. 
 But Cameron would not budge. 
 &bquo;There is only one way to decide,&equo; he said, and jumped up on the table, making  Robertson flinch. 
 &bquo;Here is the issue,&equo; he shouted out. 
 &bquo;Do we ask Sir John to restrain the soldiers &mdash; which he cannot do &mdash; or do we bind him  not to pursue or hound us for this action? 
 If you are for the latter, shout out Aye. 
 What do you say? 
 Do you say Aye?&equo; 
 There was a great shout of Aye. 
 &bquo;Or do you say No?&equo; 
 A few calls answered him. 
 &bquo;The Ayes have it.&equo; 
 He jumped down and began again to dictate. 
 &bquo;We hereby solemnly declare that we shall use no forcible means to apprehend, confine, or imprison any person assistant whatever who has appeared at Castle Menzies or elsewhere, or in any part of Perth on prior days. 
 Further that we shall petition government tor an abolition and nullifying of the foresaid Act from the records of British parliament; that the members of parliament for this county shall present this petition, or any annexed thereto, to the two Houses of Parliament, and to the Privy Council, during the prorogation of parliament &mdash; &bquo;Menzies was seething and he broke in on the last words. 
 &bquo;This goes much too far.&equo; 
 He stood up as he spoke. 
 &bquo;They will never believe this &mdash; they will know it was extorted.&equo; 
 &bquo;Very well &mdash;&equo; Cameron trumped him instantly. 
 &bquo;Add this: &bquo;and this we shall do of our own free will and accord&equo;.&equo; 
 He smiled straight into Menzies' smouldering look and said, &bquo;Will you swear to this?&equo; 
 &bquo;Swear? 
 Swear? 
 And how am I to swear?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sir John&equo; &mdash; Cameron sounded appalled &mdash; &bquo;is there any God but one? 
 Swear as you usually do. 
 Now, Robertson, add this: &bquo;of our own free will and accord &mdash; as we shall answer to God.&equo; 
 That is very fine. 
 I think we have it now. 
 Robertson &mdash; fresh ink, and we will round it off in style. 
 Sir John &mdash; your name first &mdash; you are the leader here. 
 Where is Joseph Stewart of Foss?&equo; 
 The young man was passed through the crowd, looking haggard, and he signed without a word. 
 &bquo;And who is that?&equo; 
 Cameron pointed at the hostage among the Kenmore crowd. 
 He in his turn signed: &bquo;William Stewart of Garth&equo;. 
 Cameron turned back to the table. 
 &bquo;Mr MacDiarmid &mdash; you have had a heavy responsibility for the Act &mdash; we had better have your name too.&equo; 
 Donald McCulloch was grinning to his friends. 
 &bquo;It is a poor thing,&equo; he called out, &bquo;when ministers turn recruiting sergeants!&equo; 
 MacDiarmid took the quill and signed, his face like a paper mask. 
 The Grandtully piper, sensing the climax of the gathering, had filled his bag and set. 
 off on a steady marching tune. 
 The Duke held up his branch like a banner and began to lead the way along to the east gate, but a large part of the crowd stayed in a half-circle round the group at the table, as though waiting for the victor's crow in the cockfight.  
 &bquo;Clear the grounds!&equo; the factor was shouting. 
 &bquo;Clear the grounds!&equo; 
 Young McCulloch raised his cudgel and lunged at him. 
 The factor jumped back. 
 McCulloch laughed and turned away. 
 Cameron folded the paper and gave it to James Menzies. 
 &bquo;Let us meet outside the gates,&equo; he said, &bquo;and draw up the day's work.&equo; 
 &bquo;And take a vote on it?&equo; 
 Cameron seemed to ignore the dig. 
 &bquo;There is enough to do,&equo; he said, and let out a long breath. 
 &bquo;We had better get some horses.&equo;  
 The Reel 
 Before the crowd could drift off, Cameron got up on the massive stone gate-post and called on them to swear an oath. 
 The words drew on his memory of a secret meeting he had gone to at the end of his first year in Glasgow. 
 It had looked like a melodrama &mdash; a little group in a candle-lit attic, holding up their arms with fists clenched and swearing to do or die. 
 But they had meant it, and he was eager now to bring everybody together in a fine, hard point of resolve, in case zeal slackened and died away in the holiday atmosphere of this soft, comfortable afternoon. 
 The hills themselves looked asleep, the heather glowed dust-blue in the hazy light, and the people, after a night of little sleep and hours of walking and standing, now looked stunned as they sat on the grassy banks, leaned on dykes, or lay on their backs in the hayfields, munching oatcakes and drinking the last of their water. 
 Some little groups were going off to west and east, but most hung on with a sense that the next thing now demanded to be done. 
 Cameron raised his right hand, clenched his fist, and spoke in a relaxed voice. 
 &bquo;Very good. 
 We have seen to one of them. 
 But there are plenty more. 
 There is Alexander Menzies of Bolfracks.&equo; 
 He pointed across the river at a squat grey house on the far bank with a stand of trees behind it. 
 &bquo;And further down there is Hope Steuart of Ballechin &mdash; a hard man to crack, no doubt. 
 And Alexander McGlashan of Eastertyre &mdash; you know them all, and they know you, and by now they will be expecting us. 
 Well &mdash; will we disappoint them? 
 Will we? 
 People kindled a little. 
 Some shouted, &bquo;No, no,&equo; and a woman called out, &bquo;Come on then, Angus &mdash; let us go and have our dinners at Bolfracks!&equo; 
 &bquo;I am hungry too,&equo; he answered her. 
 &bquo;Maybe some of these nice gentlemen will offer us meat. 
 But first things first. 
 Are we all resolved to finish this day's work?&equo; 
 He looked from one tired face to another. 
 A few had turned on their sides in the hay and cradled their heads on their arms. 
 &bquo;All right. 
 We have started well. 
 But if you are truly  resolved, then pledge it now, swear an oath &mdash; come on &mdash; let us see all hands raised &mdash; come on now &mdash; every hand high&hellip; 
 &equo; The little army was stirring to its feet, movement ran from front to back of the broad crowd like hackles rising. 
 &bquo;Let me see your hands.&equo; 
 Hundreds of arms were standing up stiffly now like bristling branches. 
 &bquo;Let us bind ourselves now by this oath &mdash; say it with me. 
 We do swear &mdash;&equo; He paused, and a murmur followed him with some clearer, harsher voices audible amongst it: &bquo;We do swear &mdash;&equo; He went on: &bquo;Never to swerve,&equo; and they said it together, &bquo;Never to swerve &mdash; from our present path &mdash; till we have cleansed the country &mdash; or this oppressive Act. 
 And we do swear &mdash; never to betray &mdash; the name of any friend.&equo; 
 The collective voice rumbled to a close. 
 Cameron jumped down from the granite post and walked over to his little committee. 
 They were looking at him with an air that mingled irony and respect. 
 He felt like justifying himself, at least to James. 
 But other things mattered more. 
 Another castle to be stormed. 
 For the sake of a scrap of paper. 
 His sudden lapse of morale took him by surprise, like a qualm in his stomach. 
 No food since broth and bread last night. 
 It was mad to charge on like this. 
 But momentum was the thing &mdash; self-doubt came sneaking in as soon as they let up. 
 Why wait for horses? 
 There would not be a horse for everybody. 
 &bquo;James,&equo; he decided, &bquo;station yourself here &mdash; let five hundred folk come past, then come yourself. 
 Allan &mdash; the same, then follow after James. 
 We can wade the river at the shallows. 
 Gather on the terrace under the house. 
 Donald &mdash; take the tail of the crowd.&equo; 
 And the swarm of people flowed down the path, stumbling on stones where a burn ran in winter or after thunderstorms, between the silvery wands of rowans with their clusters of blood-drops and the quivering tapestry of the alders, down into the Tay which ran from the west like molten iron, too flashing bright to look at, and over the Tay, wet to the waist; the girls and boys who had not gone home were prancing and shrieking when they fell full length. 
 But one grey-haired uplander disappeared into a hole below a boulder and was pulled out by the hair and carried back towards Keltney on a stretcher of cut branches. 
 Up the slope, at the top of his semi-circular steps, Alexander Menzies was waiting for them in his best silk coat like a dandy at a ball, with a straightfaced young man standing by his side. 
 James bowed ironically and offered them the document; Alexander Menzies pretended to think about it for a full five minutes and signed it with  extraordinary flourishes that made the pen splutter and seemed to say, &bquo;Very well, I will humour your ridiculous ritual.&equo; 
 James was remembering the young man now, William, the laird's son, a surgeon in the Army; here was trouble. 
 The young man scanned the paper, held it out, and as James's fingers reached for it, dropped it, eyed him, and said in a carrying voice, &bquo;I see you are mad, but does even a lunatic suppose that one of His Majesty's officers would bind himself to oppose the law and refrain from arresting criminals?&equo; 
 They went for him then, Alexander and Donald McLaggan, the Duke's two sons, dragged him from his father's side so that his head bounced on the steps, lifted him bleeding, like foresters keeping a dying deer clear of the hounds, and started to carry him down to the river &bquo;just to cool him off&equo; but Cameron ran and gripped Donald's shoulder and shouted, &bquo;If you injure an officer it is treason on top of sedition,&equo; so they carried him back and laid him carefully at his father's feet. 
 Cameron was thinking ahead now. 
 In an hour we will be at Aberfeldy, at the Flemyngs' house at Moness, how can I besiege my employers? 
 Why put my head into the bear's jaws before I have to? 
 So he divided the people, half to scour the right bank of the river down the forested links and narrows as far as the meadows above Logierait and force a signature from every proprietor, half to come with him to the north side; they would all meet at Haugh of Ballechin after the sun had set and plan for tomorrow. 
 The McLaggans had put grass halters round the necks of a few of Menzies' horses; Cameron rode on one; from the back in his dark coat he looked like a preacher leading away the faithful to a field communion. 
 James Menzies and the McLaggans, riding on horses, led the rest away on the long climb of the hill to Dunskiag, a gaunt treeless place where the owner lived without a woman and three great staghounds with long coarse hair slavered to get at them, wrenching their chains. 
 They did not waste time there but headed downhill, taking the shepherds' road that slanted luminous green between clusters of birches, their shadows stretching ahead like gawky giants so that the children jigged to make the shadows jump and curved their fingers from their heads to give the giants silhouettes like devils. 
 The Flemyngs would be away, no doubt, &bquo;at a banquet in Perth&equo;, and they were; a butler spoke to them from an upper window and asked them would they kindly leave a message so they marked the house with dirt and rotten potatoes while the servants rushed to bar the shutters over the windows.  
 The last of the sunlight was diffusing through the trellis of oaks and evergreens in a yellow sparkle; single rays pierced through like stings; in the gloaming. 
 Aberfeldy was a ghost town. 
 The laddering and scaffolding round the half-built mill reared up emptily like the skeleton of a forest. 
 All their energies had run low now. 
 James was wondering, were they pirates doomed to plunge forever after another quarry? 
 His head throbbed with drink and sunsmite and the bony bouncing of his horse &mdash; time to rest and replenish. 
 He led his army round by Anderson's howff. 
 Anderson seemed to be the only person at home; he sold them jugs of ale, small beer for the children; James's credit was good for a stone jar of whisky and one of the Duke's men was detailed to carry it on his back in a wicker frame. 
 They might have become becalmed there as their heads ballooned with the drink but the Duke told his piper to rouse their feet with a steady march, &bquo;Murdo Mackenzie of Torridon&equo;, and they headed off downstream towards Grandtully past the standing stone, the quiet watcher, while damp black shadow massed in the river-channel as though the night came from there. 
 on the far bank Cameron had outstripped them, his army moving steadily down the strath, winning signatures at the house of Cluny, at Clochfoldich and Pitnacree, by the solid slow avalanche of their numbers, massing quietly round each house, hammering three times on each door. 
 By this time every gentleman knew what was expected of him: Cameron never dismounted, he leaned from the saddle and passed the paper down to the angry, helpless proprietor and took it back signed. 
 The west windows of Hope Steuart's place at Ballechin flared with sunset, as though fires blazed inside it. 
 Cameron passed it by, the man could stew in his choler for a while, and when the dark came on and his servants and womenfolk grued at every owl-call or salmon-splash from the river, his defiance would burn lower and he would give his name. 
 While most of the people rested in the river meadow, shivering as the layers of fog brimmed round them, Cameron and a few strong runners made for the Tummel above the confluence, crossed it, and found the people of Atholl and Tulliemet overflowing the howff at Widow Duff's, supping broth, chewing mutton, throwing ribs to the dogs. 
 They had made sure of the few proprietors between there and Dunkeld; the Duke of Atholl's authority was weaker here; tomorrow would be the hard day when they made a drive up to Moulin and  Faskally: perhaps they should go and terrify them now while darkness made them lonely? 
 That took care of Strathtummel; Atholl would get Up in the morning to find half his country crumbling under his feet. 
 Cameron turned back up the Tay, glad that the harvest of names was nearly home. 
 The darkness ahead was flickering, shapes of trees appeared and vanished, cheering surged like surf &mdash; here was their other army &mdash; James and the Duke were standing on a rock conducting the dancers, who were reeling in eights, linking and whirling between the bonfires. 
 The two young McLaggans were taunting and prodding at a trio of hostages, Thomson the constable, Bisset the minister, and the old soldier Major Alexander McGlashan of Eastertyre; they stood in a huddle with their eyes staring, while young McCulloch staggered up to them and shoved stalks of bracken into their hair. 
 Cameron went and spoke to James angrily, in a quiet voice, What were they doing, holding a ceilidh? 
 Or making their people safe against the Act? 
 James laughed, &bquo;Look at them, Angus, look at the people, they are rampant now, this is better than &bquo;Forty-five, nobody is dying, no royal fop is leading us into the bog. 
 Give us a word, Angus &mdash; go on &mdash; make these &bquo;gentlemen&equo; swear the oath! 
 They will never forget it! 
 Neither will we! 
 For once they are dancing to our music.&equo; 
 So Angus got up on to the rock and held his fist high and told young McCulloch to stand the hostages on a knoll where everyone could see them and called out the oath above the drone of the pipe: &bquo;We do swear &mdash; never to swerve &mdash; from our present path &mdash; till we have cleansed the country &mdash; of this oppressive Act. 
 And we do swear &mdash; never to betray &mdash; the name of any friend.&equo; 
 The Major and the minister and the constable repeated it after him in low voices, the crowd gave them a round of applause, the reel was over. 
 They tramped along to Ballechin among the ferns and sheltering oaks, smelling the cheesey smell of cows among the mist. 
 Hope Steuart had felled a tree across the track, two men with cudgels were standing sentry behind it, they dropped the clubs and ran when the whole wood came at them, the darkness between the trees turned into people, people everywhere, herds and thickets of them surrounding the low tower-house. 
 Hope Steuart had leaned two loaded muskets against the doorjambs; he turned to pick one up but the Duke's two sons were on him, twisting his arms behind him. 
 He struggled and roared out, &bquo;I see you, James Menzies, I charge you with sedition,&equo; and the Duke roared back, &bquo;We charge you  with tyranny, trail him round the house,  lads, show his servants who is the master now.&equo; 
 They carted him like a scarecrow, his heels scoring the gravel, but he was as stubborn as a pig in a cart, he would never squeal without a hard prod; Donald Stewart the blacksmith had to grip his wrist to make him sign the paper.  
 The Building 
 Donald McCulloch came back from &bquo;the reel of Ballechin' long after his mother, and when he got up at last next morning, the cold porridge had been thrown out to the hens. 
 He pretended not to mind. 
 His mother and grandfather were eyeing him as he emerged from the bed and felt the nag of their expectation that he would go off at once to earn a day's wage at Aberfeldy. 
 He pulled on his boots in silence. 
 Bits of mud fell on the floor. 
 &bquo;Where were you, then?&equo; his mother snapped at once. 
 &bquo;Along at Dull till all hours?&equo; 
 Her ill-humour was nothing but a habit. 
 &bquo;You have a habit of ill-humour&equo; &mdash; his thoughts spoke themselves before he could stop them. 
 But she probed on undeterred. 
 &bquo;I saw you both at the Castle, then I lost you.&equo; 
 He hated her way of alluding to Jean but never saying her name. 
 &bquo;I sent Jean  home before we crossed the river. 
 The McLaggans were spoiling for a fight and I thought the lairds might have the mettle to retaliate.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, he takes care of her then,&equo; old Donald jeered to Mary, trying to side with her. 
 But she wanted no allies. 
 she could think of nothing but her son. 
 She was consumed with gauging his mood, foreseeing every move he made, hag-ridden by the spectres of all the troubles he could bring down on himself and them. 
 Donald felt the pressure from her and stared from one to the other, letting them feel his defiance and distaste. 
 &bquo;What am I doing here,&equo; he said at last, &bquo;between two old scolds?&equo; 
 She easily matched him. 
 &bquo;Go away to the army, then &mdash; you will be your own man there.&equo; 
 She had said too much. 
 Old Donald looked at her, shocked and her son straightened as though lashed and flung out of the house. 
 Across the bridge in Aberfeldy more people than usual were standing about on the dried mud of the half-built streets. 
 Beside the stone  shell of the Flemyngs' new mill, at the back of a piece of ground it now shared with a new carpet factory, long-haired cattle were browsing desultorily among mudded grass and stacks of timber. 
 Drovers had pastured their herds here for many years but their customary right had vanished when Flemyng bought the ground and it was a daily vexation of Cameron's to move the animals out from among his materials and even from inside the unfinished walls. 
 &bquo;Come on now, mind my beasts,&equo; a drover would say, standing up among the Golds of the plaid in which he had spent the night and putting on a practised tone of wheedling grievance. 
 &bquo;Look there, they are startling and snorting now &mdash; you have frightened them and they will not eat before the journey. 
 No no, they will never make a price in Perth now you have terrified them,&equo; and Cameron would have to spend a good few shillings to make the drove move on. 
 Now the grey dew had gone from the grass, pats of dung steamed where the cattle had been standing, and Cameron, in his shirt-sleeves with a cloth tying back his long black hair, was supervising the winching up of timbers for the roof. 
 He had an audience: perhaps twenty people had gathered round the site, idly expectant, smoking and calling out. 
 As the men at the windlass rope heaved and a long timber started to rise up and swing, the wheel on the pulley squealed like an injured dog and the man stationed at the top of the wall took a stickful of thick grease from a pot, leaned out, and worked it into the axle. 
 Cameron pretended not to see young Donald till he was close beside him, then turned in mock surprise and said to him, &bquo;Well well, Donald &mdash; we had given you up. 
 Now, suppose I have taken enough men on already &mdash; &bquo;Donald laughed. 
 &bquo;If there is no room here, there is plenty up on the hill, and where do you think I would like to be?&equo; 
 But he took off his jacket and went round the back to work with the sawyers who were cutting joists to a length. 
 The work hummed on for a while. 
 After an hour James Menzies came across the bridge from Weem, aggrieved at Cameron for leaving him to sleep late. 
 &bquo;And where was Allan Stewart?&equo; asked Cameron innocently. 
 &bquo;Ach, where was anyone last night?&equo; 
 James retorted, and he went over to unlock his warehouse and take delivery of a cartload of barrels from Dunkeld. 
 As Cameron turned back to the mill, he saw a small coach coming along the Grandtully road with a pair of deerhounds loping at its wheels and a man on horseback behind it dressed in an expensive tweed cloak. 
 The Flemyng entourage, he said to himself,  now what will he find fault with today, and what news will he have heard? 
 The coach trundled briskly past, browning everyone with dust; the deerhounds checked and growled thunderously at the town dogs until James Flemyng called them loudly to heel. 
 He reined in his horse beside Cameron. 
 &bquo;Mr Cameron &mdash;&equo; he began. 
 &bquo;Good morning, Mr Flemyng.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good morning. 
 The work goes on again, I see, now that the &mdash; holiday &mdash; is over. 
 I trust the &bquo;holiday&equo; is over?&equo; 
 He was looking past Cameron at the mill, eyeing each workman in turn as though to memorize his face, then looking back at Cameron. 
 &bquo;We are ahead of ourselves, Mr Flemyng, as you know. 
 The mortar is set before the frosts, and the roof will be on well before the snow.&equo; 
 &bquo;It must be, Mr Cameron., &bquo;It will be, Mr Flemyng.&equo; 
 Their gazes locked for a second and then Flemyng followed his wife up the road towards their disfigured house among the birch trees. 
 McCulloch had watched the comedy with his most provocative look. 
 &bquo;Well, Angus, how do you think they will like the new decorations to their house?&equo; 
 Cameron was unamused. 
 &bquo;Let us hope his butler was too drunk to remember faces,&equo; he said shortly, and turned back to the work. 
 By noon eighteen joists had been nailed into position against the roof-tree but they were short of nails and little Willie McGlashan had been sent off to Grandtully to order a load from Donald Stewart's smithy. 
 They all took a break then, to eat their oatcakes and drink jugs of beer from Anderson's. 
 Sandy McGlashan, the windlass man, climbed down the ladder and came to sit beside Cameron. 
 He was small and agile, bow-legged and with a rubbery face that squirmed in on to his toothless gums as he chewed. 
 &bquo;Bolfracks had a rough time, then?&equo; 
 He was eyeing Cameron sideways. 
 &bquo;Oh, he knuckled under, but the young man made a great show of being a soldier and the McLaggans went to cool him down.&equo; 
 McGlashan was sniggering. 
 &bquo;I heard that too. 
 Oh aye, it was a bad day for the house of Bolfracks &mdash; no doubt about it &mdash; very bad &mdash; oh aye. 
 High time they had a fall, eh?&equo; 
 &bquo;No doubt it is., &bquo;Oh aye, high time and past time. 
 Menzies of Bolfracks is a stony devil, so was his father. 
 I know that &mdash; none better &mdash; I do.&equo; 
 The man  was hotching with his story and Cameron had no need to prompt him. 
 &bquo;Now &mdash; if we are going to roast the lairds, and get some rights at last, do you think we can win our lease back from old Menzies &mdash; do you think so, Angus?&equo; 
 &bquo;Your lease, Sandy? 
 I thought you were a townser., &bquo;A townser? 
 We have only perched in Weem, and now here. 
 My grandfather was born at Farrochil, on Bolfracks Hill &mdash; we would still be there &mdash; but was my father to slave at carting stones from the Menzies's quarry for old Wade to build his damned bridge? 
 He was a farmer, not a labourer &mdash; why should he put his plough-team between Menzies&equo; shafts to drag his damned stones for him? 
 Well &mdash; he would not, and the laird turned him out for it &mdash; he turned him out and sent him off and we have had no land since and he put nobody else into Upper Farrochil &mdash; he only wanted it for himself. 
 He was a magnate, Angus. 
 Like his son today. 
 They coin money at Bolfracks. 
 But we will have them out now, eh? 
 They will never stop us now.&equo; 
 As his excitement steadied, he focused on Cameron again and waited, simmering, for his opinion. 
 &bquo;Sixty-five years ago, Sandy.&equo; 
 Cameron's voice came slowly. 
 &bquo;A long time for a claim to run.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I have a long memory. 
 Especially for a grudge. 
 Will I take your jug to the howff, Angus?&equo; 
 &bquo;No no, I have no head for it today.&equo; 
 Cameron wanted time to think; he was in a turmoil of emotions; he felt for Sandy's grievance even while he was blenching at the man's mad certainty that a day of reckoning was near. 
 And underneath these feelings he felt some hot, dark stirrings in himself. 
 What were they? 
 A desire to retaliate &mdash; against whom? 
 Against landowners whose own fathers had had to flee from the Crown's killers in &bquo;Forty-six? 
 Yet here, on the verge of the Lowlands, most of the gentry had hedged their bets; some had even entertained the Butcher as he progressed triumphally from one massacre to the next and had then bought over the gutted glens and stocked them with the great sheep. 
 He looked round the littered site, at its dried browns and darkened greens, and considered the men who were sitting round quietly talking and blowing smoke at the swarming flies. 
 He did not know of one who had anything to thank the Flemyngs for, or old Menzies at the Castle. 
 Since the busy fencings and ditchings of the previous thirty years, the men who farmed the best land had flourished all the more; they could afford the rents for the greater acreage under the plough. 
 But the families in the little awkward places,  at the heads of the small glens, on boggy ground that would not drain &mdash; they were nearly helpless, they trembled on the threshold of destitution, impaled on the horn of the one-year lease, uncertain whether it was worth going into debt to improve the ground and knowing that, even if they did, they could still be turned out next term day and their place annexed to the holding of a better-off neighbour. 
 Not one of these men here came from a lower-lying farm (except Donald McCulloch, and their place was only a slip of ground between the steep hill and the road). 
 When the mill was finished, a few of them might get work in it (but the Flemyngs wanted girls for it because they would work more days). 
 The rest would have to go off as wage-labourers to the Lowlands. 
 Or to the regiments. 
 The deathly regiments. 
 He stood up and stretched, yawning to squeeze the bad thoughts out of his head. 
 Sandy McGlashan was not yet back from Anderson's. 
 He walked over to the timber stack along with a sawyer called Iain Logan whom he knew well &mdash; they were both friends of Donald Gillies at Camserney mill. 
 As Cameron started to pick out wood to finish the forward half of the roof, Iain said to him quietly, &bquo;Sandy McGlashan is not the only man with troubles. 
 You know my brother's sawmill at the waterfall above Moness? 
 The Flemyngs would close it if they could. 
 James Flemyng has been at my father, complaining about dirt in the water and the noise of the saws and axes. 
 It is not that at all. 
 He wants the place. 
 And it is only a patch! 
 With a damp, rotten house on it!&equo; 
 &bquo;Is the water dirty?&equo; 
 Logan looked at him almost scornfully. 
 &bquo;You could drink from it, except after a spate. 
 The Flemyngs can think of nothing but fences, and these fancy trees&equo; (he meant Sir John's larches). 
 &bquo;I would have put a torch to their damned house yesterday, if I had had some tinder. 
 He sends his factor up to terrify my father &mdash; after dark &mdash; when I have gone over to Camserney with Alastair. 
 I tell you, one night, if we knew he was coming, we would wait for him round the back and pitch him down the falls!&equo; 
 &bquo;And hang for it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Angus&equo; &mdash; he dropped the timber he was lifting, letting it clank off the others, and turned to look at him with widened eyes and squared mouth, like the face of someone taking a great strain. 
 &bquo;Is there no thing, no thing at all, which you  would swing for? 
 If it came to it? 
 You know that Alastair split and cut these planks on our own saw-bed. 
 If Flemyng forces us out, then we will have nothing left but our hands.&equo;  
 &bquo;They might get you anyway. 
 Is Alastair not listed?&equo; 
 &bquo;Aye &mdash; he is just twenty-one. 
 My little brother!&equo; 
 &bquo;So we had better choke this Act &mdash; &bquo;All right. 
 But that is just the start.&equo; 
 They carried timber together for a while after that, one at each end of the planks, eyeing each other with set little smiles. 
 The mood seemed similar at many places on the site &mdash; less whistling and singing than usual, more talking. 
 People who had been out together at Castle Menzies, then on down to the Reel of Ballechin, conversed steadily, opening up their private problems to each other with a freedom well beyond the usual. 
 Two masons who were chiselling at the finials which Flemyng had ordered for the gables would stop their clinking from time to time to confirm something that one or other had said. 
 Both were landless men who depended on being allowed to pasture their milk-cows on the water-meadows down at Ballechin, and as Cameron caught the drift of their intent talk and occasional sardonic laughter, he wondered again how many names had been put to faces during yesterday's hurly-burly. 
 The shadows had grown long by the time Sandy McGlashan came back from Anderson's howff. 
 &bquo;What do I see?&equo; he exclaimed. 
 &bquo;Work, work, work, like Noah's sons at the Ark. 
 And here was I, thinking you could not be building a roof without nails. 
 Well, well, well&hellip; 
 &bquo;He put his foot between the two bottom rungs of the ladder and then caught at the upright to save himself from staggering. 
 Carefully he tried again but Cameron took his arm and told him not to hurry unduly, the joists had only been pinned in place and they were still waiting for the long nails from Grandtully. 
 Work slowed to a halt until Donald Steuart clattered up on his cart and began to lift down hefty canvas bags from the tailboard. 
 &bquo;Sorry, Angus,&equo; he was saying, &bquo;my lad from Ballinluig never turned up, I had to get my father to blow the bellows &mdash; ouch! some of them are still hot &mdash; that bag has charred, spread them out to cool, or keep them for tomorrow. 
 Unless you want to burn down Flemyng's mill before it is up.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aye, why not?&equo; said Iain Logan. 
 &bquo;It would keep us working.&equo; 
 &bquo;What a week!&equo; 
 Donald Stewart was talking and working in a steady frenzy. 
 &bquo;And it is not over yet &mdash; you know we have Mary to marry off to Alex McLaggan this Friday coming. 
 Will you be there, Angus? 
 We want you there. 
 And Iain &mdash; and Alastair, of course, and your father, if he will come so far., &bquo;I will come so far,&equo; Sandy McGlashan proclaimed from six rungs  up the ladder, &bquo;and I willing them a song of William Ross's to send them on their away. 
 &bquo;I went to woo a young girl&equo;, he trolled out, 
 &bquo;As fair as a swan, 
 But I turned for home 
 Like a bald old man. 
 On a misty Sunday &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;All right, Sandy, keep it for the wedding. 
 Young Donald &mdash; will you bring your Jean? 
 She had better see what is in store for her.&equo; 
 Donald McCulloch grinned with pleasure and then turned it into a look of complicity for the younger men. 
 James Menzies had locked up his warehouse for the day and come over in time to be included in the lengthening list. 
 &bquo;Mind now, Donald,&equo; he put in, &bquo;or Angus will be telling you to keep it down to forty-nine. 
 A fine thing for a wedding if the laird came in and read the Riot Act.&equo; 
 Donald pretended to grow grave at this. 
 &bquo;There is a lot in that. 
 Supposing they came down on us with Thomson the constable from Pitnacree &mdash; they could arrest us all, and behead the movement!, 
 &bquo;No no, you have it wrong, Donald,&equo; James Menzies objected. 
 &bquo;There are no leaders here &mdash; we are all on a level. 
 What do you say, Angus?&equo; 
 Cameron was taking off his head-band and shaking out his hair. 
 &bquo;I say we are all leaders. 
 Sandy can lead the singing. 
 And Donald can lead the cart. 
 And James can lead the toasts. 
 And even old MacDiarmid can had a prayer. 
 As for the laird &mdash;&equo; he looked round with a quick black glint, &bquo;he can lead us by the nose.&equo; 
 A rising sound between a crow and a cheer came up from the men. 
 Along at Moness House James Flemyng and his wife looked at each other apprehensively and wondered if it was time to bar the shutters. 
 Next day and the day after that Mr Flemyng rode his horse along the slope south of the town, as though to exercise his dogs, and looked down at the site through an opera-glass, trying to make out whether the workmen were forming a mob. 
 He had no idea that little Willie McGlashan was posted in the trees just below Moness. 
 As soon as the gentleman came round from the stables on his horse, the lad pelted down town and across the building sites to alert the men. 
 By this time they were starting to review the situation steadily, forecasting the Duke of Atholl's likely moves, wording formal requests for warrants  to meet in larger groups, arguing furiously over the likelihood of being able to get weapons from the armouries at Atholl or Taymouth Castle. 
 When Willie came running, they at once dispersed around the site. 
 Through his glass James Flemyng observed a fine exhibition of model workmen sawing and hammering industriously at his great new masterwork.  
 The Wedding 
 On the night of Thursday Cameron slept badly, for no reason that he knew of. 
 The river dream came to him again, he was wading deep into the current, its coldness griped him by the crutch, shocking him, he must reach that bluish hovering light on the far bank &mdash; trees towering above &mdash; a house, a tall bulky building towering above him&hellip; 
 He half-woke, and saw the window-square glimmering with the pallor of sunrise&hellip; 
 The river again, the far bank was nearer but here was a black smooth stretch, he half knew that he was dreaming, he wanted to stop the dream and he wanted to get across, if only he could raise his mouth and nostrils above the swell of the water&hellip; 
 He made himself wake finally and lay under the covers feeling weak and hot, as though he had been spending energy incessantly all night. 
 Outside the day was fine enough, too clear perhaps; each roughness on the skyline was sharply visible, as though it might rain later. 
 Just now the autumnal coolth was tonic and he breathed it in like drinking draughts of fresh milk, then took dippersful of water from the butt at the side of the house and sluiced his head into activity. 
 In other parts of the house James Menzies and Allan Stewart were stirring with a clumping of boots. 
 In an hour they were all ready and stood in the parlour looking humorously at each other in their best shirts of white linen and clean breeches. 
 James's had a brown mark on the leg the shape of an iron. 
 When Allan grinned knowingly at it, he said, &bquo;Oh aye &mdash; this house needs a woman., &bquo;Maybe we will find a willing girl at the wedding,&equo; Allan suggested. 
 &bquo;Donald's other daughters are like their father &mdash; too hefty in the arm. 
 No man will ever cow them.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did I say a Stewart? 
 The Duke will bring a fine tail with him &mdash; &bquo;The McLaggan women &mdash; do not mention them, they would eat you alive!&equo; 
 You are hard to please, James &mdash; I wonder you ever married,&equo; said Cameron, then regretted he had spoken.  
 &bquo;Kirsty was a gem &mdash; there is nobody else like that.&equo; 
 James's eyes filled suddenly with tears, he wiped it them and looked disbelievingly at the wet on his fingers. 
 &bquo;Ach, come on, you would think I had been at the whisky already. 
 Let us get on the road.&equo; 
 They stepped out briskly in the chill of evaporating rime and dew. 
 By the time they came to the sharp bend at Borlick they had caught up with the McCulloch family, old Donald limping and muttering to himself, Donald hand in hand with Jean, Mary and her friend big Mary striding on ahead, their arms pulled down by heavy baskets of pies and eggs. 
 &bquo;Where so old Iain Logan?&equo; said old Donald irritably as they came abreast. 
 &bquo;They will have gone down by the other side,&equo; said Allan Stewart, &bquo;it is their quickest way.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ach &mdash; I was sure he would be with you &mdash; we could have taken our own time then. 
 &bquo;Take it now, Father,&equo; said Mary, putting down her baskets and easing her shoulders. 
 &bquo;What is the use of dying on the way to a wedding?&equo; 
 They all moved off together down the tawny dust of the road, close beside the shingle banks and black deeps of the river. 
 Here it ran between quiet green glades, the remnant of an oak wood which had been stripped to build ships for the navy and then, in a last plundering, to make charcoal for the insatiable furnaces and foundries down at Carron forge. 
 But here a thin frieze of very old trees had been preserved for the delectation of the lairds who looked out from their houses on the slopes &mdash; Cluny, Grandtully, Clochfoldich, Pitcastle. 
 At two of the gates on the roads up to thy houses dogs had been stationed, chained to posts newly hammered in. 
 The animals barked themselves hoarse as the little party tramped past and they were amused to see men watching them, one from behind a ruined byre, another behind a thick tree-trunk. 
 &bquo;What can the lairds be frightened of?&equo; asked Menzies innocently. 
 He waved and the man dodged further behind the tree. 
 &bquo;Once they are frightened of their own servants, then we will know we are doing well,&equo; said Cameron. 
 Donald McCulloch was humming to get a tune going. 
 After a little he remembered it and sang out loud, 
 &bquo;George of Hanover, 
 When you came to London  
 You piped a feeble tune 
 To charm yourself a kingdom&hellip; &bquo; 
 The others took it up, humming or singing, and walked in time to it until old Donald got breathless and they had to saunter for a while. 
 jean had her arm round Donald's waist now and from time to time she skipped, roused by the fighting spirits of the menfolk. 
 Well before noon, beside a small church whose roof sagged under clumps of grass and willow-herb, they came to the bridge over to Grandtully and looked across at the dense little settlement, lumpish houses made of undressed river boulders with brown smoke streaming through their heather thatch, hovels of branches littered through the trees, a few solid cottages with level roof-trees. 
 It was a place of moss and mud and standing pools, myriads of flies twirled in the sun-rays, and dogs and children ran out to greet the newcomers in a raucous chorus. 
 Behind a one-storey inn the Duke and his tribe of brothers and uncles lived in a cluster of rough stone houses, one built onto the end of the next as the family grew. 
 Their sheep-fanks and cattle-pounds spread away, across land rented from the inn-keeper, in a close mesh of stone dykes. 
 Droves of grey and brown horses grazed on the haugh beyond, milling round the still point of a tall grey monolith which thrust up through the turf like a stone sword. 
 Little clusters of guests were standing about on the cobblestones between the houses, looking at a loss. 
 Mary McCulloch and big Mary went straight along to the Duke's house with their loads of food and as they went in the Duke came out, dressed in a long plaid of turquoise blue, and had a quick low word with them. 
 &bquo;Now what is going on?&equo; 
 James Menzies asked the others. 
 &bquo;I have seen livelier funerals.&equo; 
 But the Duke was coming over with his usual smile, broad and toothless, mantled with crazy mirth. 
 He saw their questioning looks and said, &bquo;No bother, no bother at all. 
 Donald came down two hours ago, and would you believe it, Bisset will not come to marry them.&equo; 
 &bquo;He will not marry &mdash; &bquo;He will not marry them. 
 And why? 
 Not because we made a fool of him at the Reel on Monday, no no, not at all. 
 He says that the church is dangerous &mdash; &bquo;not fit for a man of God to officiate at a most solemn sacrament&equo;.&equo; 
 The Duke intoned the words in a hollow boom like a ghost in a graveyard. 
 James Menzies burst out laughing. 
 &bquo;It is as well he is not a Papist,  then, or the Pope would take off his frock., &bquo;He what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Take off his frock. 
 That is what they do to wicked priests.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that so, now? 
 At least our ministers wear trousers &mdash; though you would wonder, if Bisset is frightened to come here among the desperate sinners of Grandtully.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have you tried at another manse?&equo; asked Cameron. 
 &bquo;It is not worth shoe-leather. 
 After this past week they will all be thinking the same.&equo; 
 &bquo;What will you do, then?&equo; 
 That is up to you. 
 The Duke gave him a squint grin. 
 &bquo;To me?&equo; 
 The Duke leered more than ever. 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; Donald asked me to ask you &mdash; would you do the honours?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ach, come on, man, what does he mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just that. 
 We need a little ceremony&equo; &mdash; he dropped his voice &mdash; &bquo;it will keep the women happy. 
 What do you say? 
 The marriage is the man and the woman wedding each other, that is the common law we all believe in. 
 What does the minister do but add the mumbo-jumbo and the bit of paper?&equo; 
 &bquo;That is right, of course it is. 
 But why pick on me? 
 I have no &mdash; &bquo;You have a black coat and a long tongue, Angus &mdash; they can hear you from the back of the crowd.&equo; 
 &bquo;I should have stayed at home,&equo; said Cameron. 
 &bquo;Not at all,&equo; said James Menzies. 
 &bquo;Think of it &mdash; if Flemyng sacks you, you can get a job as a preacher.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good man, Angus,&equo; said the Duke, clapping Cameron's shoulder. 
 &bquo;Will you go along and tell them, now? 
 And say we are coming in no time at all.&equo; 
 The families of guests were drifting along the river bank towards Donald Steuart's a quarter of a mile upstream. 
 They looked like thy camp followers of an army, with their bundles of food, but they were carrying their best shoes in their hands. 
 One or two looked questioningly at Cameron but he was absorbed in thinking up phrases. 
 What could he say? 
 Declare them man and wife? 
 Not declare &mdash; pronounce. 
 The one was as pompous as the other. 
 He would ask young Alex for the ring, and see that it was put well on Mary's finger, he would wish them to be happy and fruitful and true to one another and that nothing would ever part them. 
 And that was what he said, at one o'clock in the afternoon, in the smithy yard at Ballinluig. 
 The house  was much too small; people made a deep ring round the couple and Cameron, standing on the cobbles among piles of bar and rod iron, the children perched on tree-stumps and on the lower branches of the very old yew tree which made a dark thicket with its multiple trunks. 
 Donald's wife Aileen looked upset and redeyed, without a minister the occasion seemed rough and ready, no better than a ceilidh, unlawful even, and her misgivings about the McLaggans had all revived. 
 She glanced repeatedly at her daughter in the long white linen gown which had been her own wedding dress. 
 But Mary was delighting quietly in the atmosphere of freedom. 
 The ordeal she had expected had turned into fun. 
 Her father stood behind her, sweating and beaming, and behind the bridegroom stood the Duke, tall and shaggy, holding a long pine branch covered with fresh green cones. 
 The clusters of needles spread above the young couple's heads like a canopy. 
 Angus Cameron stood up on the oak stump which Donald used as a chopping-block, held out his hand to each part of the crowd as though drawing them into the circuit of the ceremony, and said, at first quietly, then gaining volume as he felt the truth of his words: &bquo;Alexander McLaggan, Mary Stewart &mdash; you love each other, and must wed each other, and that is right and good. 
 We all of us feel your happiness and we have come to celebrate it with you, and with your families. 
 Alex &mdash; have you the ring?&equo; 
 The young man passed it up, the little circlet of gold glistening between the tips of his thick hard fingers. 
 &bquo;All right, Alex, but that is for you to do, I have only to make sure you do it right.&equo; 
 Laughter rustled quietly through the crowd. 
 &bquo;Now, Mary &mdash; will you accept this ring from Alexander McLaggan?&equo; 
 The girl tried to say &bquo;Yes&equo; but her mouth had dried and she had to swallow before the word would come. 
 &bquo;Now Alexander, do you give her the ring.&equo; 
 Alex put it on her finger with a sure movement, took her by both hands, and kissed her closely on the mouth. 
 The Duke held his branch still higher, waving it slowly from side to side, and the piper started a long, echoing note on his drone. 
 &bquo;Now,&equo; said Cameron, letting his voice peal round the yard, &bquo;we wish you happiness and health, Alexander and Mary McLaggan. 
 We wish you will be fruitful, and true to one another. 
 And we wish and trust that no ill will of man or woman, and no act of government, will ever come between you.&equo; 
 The piper was moving into the ring of people. 
 When everyone expected him to break into a nimble tune, he played a slow air that sounded Irish in the long luxuriant unfolding of each phrase. 
 People  listened entranced, laced together by the tendrils of the melody. 
 It finished, he tapped his foot, one two three four, and then he did launch into a jig, springy and violent. 
 Young Donald McCulloch whooped and two of the McLaggan girls whooped with him. 
 Donald Steuart had his arms round his daughter and son-in-law. 
 He squeezed them and kissed them and went off into the house. 
 Bumping noises came and he reappeared carrying a door. 
 His wife was bringing out heavy ashets piled with pies, her daughters brought out clothsful of new loaves, still steaming. 
 Now Donald was bracing himself to take the weight of the heavier outer door and Donald McLaggan was helping him, easing it up off its hinges. 
 The guests were crowding slowly past the wedded couple, kissing them, shaking their hands. 
 Sandy McGlashan had arrived late, his hair plastered down with sweat; he was spluttering over the tale, to whoever would listen, of how he had &bquo;come up flemyng and Menzies of Bolfracks, in the street at Aberfeldy, they had their heads together and were plotting something wicked, no doubt about it, if only he could have heard what they were saying&equo;. 
 Young Donald listened sceptically for a moment. 
 Jean was pulling him by the hand towards the dance. 
 &bquo;Ah well,&equo; he said finally, &bquo;if he tried to get his own back for his son's trouble, we will have to crack his head too,&equo; and he swept off into the dance. 
 Jean's black curly hair Hew out as they swung round and her cheeks, always so ripe that they looked as though they would bleed at the touch of a straw, reddened more richly than ever. 
 At one end of the heavier door, now held up on trestles, Donald had hefted a stone jar of whisky into position and Donald McLaggan was drawing off cupsful and handing them out. 
 People were blowing on their bowls of broth and mingling its savours of onions and mutton with the harsh fire of the whisky. 
 Aileen Stewart had placed an eighteen-inch pie in the very centre of the board; its summit gleamed yellow with a basting of egg. 
 Donald held up their biggest knife, kissed its blade, and cleft the crust. 
 Steam puffed out and people cheered. 
 &bquo;Where is Angus Cameron?&equo; 
 Donald shouted out. 
 &bquo;Come on, Angus, you have earned your meat!&equo; 
 He heaped a plate for him and Cameron took it thankfully. 
 Still caught in a clench of emotion after the effort of the ceremony, he had accepted a spilling cup of whisky from Donald McLaggan and drained it as though it was milk to quench a thirst. 
 Now he felt his brain slowly expanding, the noise and sunshine seemed  to have entered his skull, and he badly wanted some food to settle the turbid churning of his feelings. 
 At the far end of the yard the Duke had planted his branch in the ground and was sitting under it like a potentate. 
 Now he beckoned Cameron over and shook him formally by the hand. 
 &bquo;I heard the bit of politics in your address. 
 And that was good. 
 That was right. 
 We are deep into it now, and there is no avoiding it. 
 Did you hear the news from Atholl?&equo; 
 &bquo;No &mdash; nothing for a day or two.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Society teacher at Fincastle &mdash; Forbes. 
 A few folk went to his place before sunrise yesterday, just to let him know he had better have no hand in the lists. 
 Well, he fired a pistol and someone went for him with the blade of a scythe.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fincastle? 
 Where is that?&equo; 
 Cameron was trying to concentrate. 
 &bquo;Not two miles from Atholl Castle &mdash; across the ford and over the hill. 
 The damned Duke will make the worst of it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is the man dead?&equo; 
 &bquo;Dead enough. 
 They took him away on a cart, soaked with blood from head to foot.&equo; 
 &bquo;Like a soldier&hellip; 
 I know, I know &mdash; we want no battles here. 
 But they hate the Act so bitterly, not everybody will hold back their hands forever. 
 Are you trying to stop your people carrying blades of any kind?&equo; 
 &bquo;They will do what they like.&equo; 
 The Duke gave him a quick, keen look. 
 &bquo;What about your folk?&equo; 
 &bquo;They had none at Castle Menzies, as you know. 
 And I saw none at Ballechin. 
 Some women had stockingsful of stones that would have felled a bullock. 
 I would not stop that. 
 We have to show our mettle.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I did not expect that from you.&equo; 
 The Duke laughed with pleasure. 
 &bquo;Let us drink to that.&equo; 
 He held up his cup, clinked it on Cameron's, and gave him a deliberate nod. 
 The audience was over. 
 But Cameron could hardly move away &mdash; the dancers filled the yard, flying toes and heels banged against the shins of the onlooking elders as the dancers twirled. 
 Donald McLaggan had gone too far with Flora Stewart, swinging so wildly that the girl flung against the smaller table and fell onto it with her hair in the great bowl of broth. 
 For a moment she looked furiously at Donald, her teeth bared like a cat's, then she shook her hair out, spattering Donald with bree and barley, and hauled him back into the dance. 
 Sandy McGlashan had taken out a little yellow fiddle and was adding a frenzied strum of strings to the piper's  notes. 
 As the dancers changed partners, set to each other, backed away, then set again and spun with crossed arms, Donald McCulloch became masterful, gripping the girls' hands strongly, spinning so hard that the balls of their feet ached on the cobbles, and passing them on with an almost lordly flourish of his arm. 
 Jean felt belittled; for as long as the dance lasted she seemed no more to him than any girl there, but then he came round to her again and clasped her closely as they stepped it down the aisle between the lines of dancers. 
 Sandy McGlashan was wild now with the sound of his own music. 
 When the dance ended and everyone was standing in clusters, sweating and smiling and breathing heavily, he sang out in a high voice with a laugh in it &mdash; 
 &bquo;When I reached her window, 
 The watch-dog heard. 
 He started barking, 
 She never said a word. 
 There was nothing for it 
 But to cower and hide 
 Like one who lacked the courage 
 To give a girl a ride. 
 I cannot sleep a wink now, 
 Bed I cannot abide 
 For my merry member 
 Rising by my side.&equo; 
 There were ooh's and aah's when he finished, and some unbridled laughter. 
 Aileen was looking dubiously at her husband but he was in no mood to disapprove. 
 He winked at the Duke and called across to him, &bquo;What a grand thing, your Honour, to have a wedding without a minister!&equo; 
 The Duke did his stately bow at that and then Donald was calling for another song. 
 Some of the veterans were on the point of giving tongue but young Donald McCulloch was on his feet and moving into the middle of the ring, he was full of himself, sparkling with mischief but with an undertow of ardour. 
 &bquo;Duncan Ban MacIntyre wrote a song for his wife Mary. 
 I do not know if Alex used it to court his Mary &mdash; he must have used something &mdash; &bquo;The joke was unconscious but crowing laughter came from the young  men beside the whisky jar. 
 Donald silenced them as he sang the first line, rather solemnly, in a rich baritone: 
 &bquo;I went into the thickets 
 To cut a wand of love 
 And searched among the saplings 
 That clustered close above. 
 One branch was all blossom, 
 I gently curved it down, 
 No-one else must cut it, 
 I claimed it for my own.&equo; 
 His tribute was meant for Alex and Mary McLaggan, but as he sang he half turned towards Jean, he could not keep his look away from her, and as the words enveloped her she felt herself choking in a warm cocoon, her cheeks burned unbearably, he should not be doing this, it was too much in front of so many friends and strangers. 
 &bquo;My net was in clear water, 
 I hauled strongly in 
 And landed me a sea-trout 
 As lustrous as a swan. 
 The share I won has made me 
 Content in heart and head &mdash; 
 Star of my early mornings, 
 Dear partner of my bed.&equo; 
 It was too much but she loved him for it and let him kiss her when he came and stood beside her again. 
 There were cries of applause and as they died down Donald Stewart turned to Cameron and said, &bquo;Now, Angus, let us hear from you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Och &mdash; I have said my say already.&equo; 
 Cameron realized he was having to form his words carefully. 
 He felt a brimful of yearning &mdash; of some mixture of emotions that were hardly expressible, that must pour outwards. 
 &bquo;Come on, Angus,&equo; Donald persisted, &bquo;let us hear a song from over the mountains. 
 Come on, now &mdash;&equo; He had no need to say more because Cameron had risen to his feet in the greying light and a song was coming from him in a steady flow of sound and a hard gravelly voice that resonated like a pipe.  
 &bquo;I grieve for the white bodies 
 Scattered over the hills 
 Without shroud or coffin 
 Or burial in holes. 
 Those who survived the battle 
 Lie in the hulks in chains. 
 We are called &bquo;rebels&equo; 
 And the Whig reigns&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;John Roy Stewart,&equo; he said, sitting down heavily. 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; if he hated the massacre, he should not have been at the battle.&equo; 
 Iain Logan had been listening to him as though fascinated by the stress of experience which had lengthened Cameron's face and closed his black brows over his eyes. 
 &bquo;You are right, Angus,&equo; he said excitably. 
 &bquo;Hired murderers &mdash; in it for the blood money. 
 Flemyng of Moness is no better, you know, no better at all. 
 You know where his father got his money? 
 Canada &mdash; trading rubbish for furs. 
 And why was he there at all? 
 Army quarter-master &mdash; selling off the soldiers&equo; rations to the traders in Quebec. 
 And why were the soldiers &mdash; the soldiers &mdash; why were they&hellip; 
 ' He had lost his thread and Cameron's head was too ravelled to think much about it anyway. 
 In the gloaming the Weem folk made their way home along the dark gorge of the road. 
 Above their heads bats flickered almost invisibly between the treetops. 
 Donald and Jean had disappeared and Mary was in a black mood, striding along and making old Donald gasp. 
 Behind them the nests of little lights at Ballinluig and Grandtully had dimmed to orange sparks in the fine drizzle. 
 &bquo;That was a sad song for a wedding, Angus,&equo; said James Menzies after a time. 
 &bquo;It would be a sad thing,&equo; Angus answered at once, &bquo;if Alex was taken away from his Mary into the army when they were not a year married.&equo; 
 Or if my Donald was taken, married or not, Mary McCulloch was thinking. 
 But she kept the thought to herself. 
 For a mile or two nothing more was said. 
 They knew when they were opposite Pitcaple, and then Cluny, by the barking of the dogs and the rattle of their chains.  
 &bquo;They would have our throats out if they could get at us.&equo; 
 Allan Stewart's voice sounded tiredly out of the darkness. 
 Cameron had not the energy to reply, but he was thinking, So would their masters. 
 Dogs would do it to us with their teeth but they  have laws and guns instead. 
 They had passed through the blackest part of the valley now and it was a relief to see a light or two at Weem, and across the invisible river at Aberfeldy. 
 The McCullochs turned into their cottage with a brief good-night and Cameron, James, and Allan let themselves into the tall, silent house along the road. 
 It smelled of wine dregs, damp soot, and whitewash. 
 A day's work still to do before the Sabbath and they would have sore heads in the morning. 
 But at least their wits would have cleared again in time for Sunday's meetings and the next milestone in the struggle.  
 The Speech 
 If they managed to exact a sworn and written abrogation of the Act from every single proprietor in the strath (and over into Tummel and down past Dunkeld), at least they would have built a paper wall round themselves. 
 More than that? 
 How keep the gentry to it? 
 How reach through and past them to the axis of power? 
 It felt like hauling on a rope that ran half round the world. 
 You strained till thy blood came &mdash; still no movement at the far end. 
 They would never get the Act repealed. 
 Make it unworkable &mdash; yes, do that. 
 How? 
 The Tranent folk had had a notion (but look whit happened to them) &mdash; say to the government, &bquo; You cannot trust us  if ever you make us fight.&equo; 
 The young men must resolve to be mutinous. 
 How could they stick to it, though, once they were under a sergeant-major, a trained bully, lashed to a gun carriage and flogged to pieces? 
 They must not go at all. 
 They must lie low here, amongst their own folk, where they know the ground, where they can be fed. 
 But. 
 But the government troops are devils in the thoroughness of their searching and destroying &mdash; would it be like &bquo;Forty-six again? 
 Houses burnt &mdash; gardens and orchards uprooted &mdash; herds and flocks driven off wholesale &mdash; sparing nobody, even when there was no proof to likelihood that the family was harbouring a wanted man&hellip; 
 No &mdash; the government will find it hard to sustain that again, when there has been no army in the field against them &mdash; no pitched battles &mdash; no weapons, even. 
 Maybe our weakness is our strength, thought Cameron &mdash; we are seen to be democrats , nothing like the Prince's bands of warriors. 
 But they hate the very word &bquo;democrat&equo;! 
 To Atholl's friends in Edinburgh, the Dundases, the Abercrombies, a &bquo;democrat&equo; is the  worst thing, a wrecker, a traitor. 
 And our own people here have never heard the word at all&hellip; 
 Is that it? 
 To disappear the young men into their own terrain, make use of every cave and wood (and send them over the water if need be)? 
 Not till after the harvest. 
 People would never put up with it before then. 
 If we can afford to wait that long. 
 To organize it will demand utter  secrecy &mdash; utter. 
 Anything less and we might as well not do it at all. 
 There must be several hundred quiet, individual meetings with individual families. 
 If  the broad plan is agreed. 
 How to discuss it secretly? 
 Probably there are government spies amongst us already (but who? which friend at the wedding? 
 Which fellow-workman?). 
 We must do two things together (Cameron found his thoughts concentrating to a point at last). 
 We must keep up the pressure on the lairds, the stream of meetings, so that we are all welded together, we feel our accumulated powers, day in day out. 
 And the lairds believe that that is all. 
 Under the cover of the hubbub we must organize the families, until each listed man knows where he will go, and who will feed him, when the platoon comes to march him off. 
 Cameron's brain reeled slightly under the weight of all these alternatives. 
 He had better try them out to James. 
 They were walking steadily up the strath, past Castle Menzies, looking unreal in its composed beauty under early Sunday sunshine, past the close-built cottages and huts of Dull which looked like scree left by a spate, heaped-up boulders, shaggy heather thatch, dykes built recently with field stones and already falling down. 
 Now they could see the broad glitter or Loch Tay, and in the foreground their destination, the gable or Kenmore church perched on its knoll at the loch-end. 
 Down every track and path and road the knots and files of people were converging. 
 If the minister had been looking out from his manse windows, he would have thought that his prophecy had found honour in its own country at last. 
 In fact the service would be nearly over, if Cameron and Menzies had timed it right. 
 They felt they had done well enough already to endure the service at Dull, and that there was no need to martyr themselves yet again (the Reverend William MacIvor's sermons were notoriously long and repetitious). 
 Cameron looked at Menzies and said, &bquo;James &mdash; what will come of today's work?&equo; 
 &bquo;What we said,, James answered, mildly surprised. 
 &bquo;Petitions against the Act from all the villages. 
 Signatures in forty-nines to escape the Riot Act. 
 Undertakings to be won from the lairds binding themselves to undertake nothing punitive against tenants seen at meetings.&equo; 
 Cameron let him finish. 
 &bquo;Do you think it is enough?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing is enough, so long as we have no hand in government.&equo; 
 &bquo;We are putting paper chains on their arms; they can break them with a gesture.&equo; 
 They stopped and looked at each other and James laughed. 
 &bquo;We  are talking ourselves into a fine slough! 
 It must be the Sabbath getting into our bones., &bquo;It is as well to take a full look at the worst.&equo; 
 Cameron would not let him go. 
 &bquo;You know well enough, James &mdash; you must have thought &mdash; once the government is resolved, and we have talked ourselves hoarse and there is no ink left in the country &mdash; then the dragoons will come in and cart the young men away as though we have done nothing. 
 We might as well be praying !&equo; 
 &bquo;The young men should take to the hills.&equo; 
 Cameron looked at him to make sure he was in earnest. 
 &bquo;I was thinking just that myself.&equo; 
 &bquo;But if they do, we should go with them. 
 If you were Atholl, who would you come for first? 
 Why, Cameron king of the rebels and Menzies his henchman.&equo; 
 &bquo;Leave us aside. 
 I will never  go to prison. 
 But leave us out of it just now. 
 There is enough to do, if all the listed men are to be visited and spoken to.&equo; 
 &bquo;A few have gone off already. 
 From Killin, and Rannoch of course &mdash; they like this kind of thing up there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh aye, in this easy weather. 
 But how will they live through the winter?&equo; 
 By now they were in among thickening crowds of people, nodding to acquaintances and looking out for their own key men from down the valley. 
 There were the Logan brothers from Moness, watchful, keeping to themselves. 
 There was Sandy McGlashan, carrying his fiddle in a bag. 
 There was Donald from the smithy, joking with young McLaggan from Grandtully and two of his own daughters &mdash; they had brought parcels of food and bottles of drink and looked ready for a good day's outing. 
 Young McCulloch was on his own &mdash; where was Jean? 
 Clusters of dark clothes marked out contingents from up Keltney and beyond. 
 A solid snake of people still wound back along the north shore of the loch. 
 A waft of singing sounded from the church, like a great collective musical groan, with an overtone of keening &mdash; the final psalm. 
 People presently came flowing out of the door and spread between the gravestones. 
 A few went home. 
 Most stayed, under the shadowy evergreens, among the tall sycamores and beeches on the bluff above the water. 
 Cameron waited for the minister to finish his ritual of nodding and handshaking with the congregation. 
 He then passed quickly through the crowd, eyes studiously on the ground, black gown folded round  him like a rook's wings. 
 The crowd was still thickening, filling back down the high street, but it looked like time to start. 
 As Cameron opened with his usual explanation of the Act, he did not know that the Reverend William McIvor, a tall whiskery man with coarse orange hair and very pale blue eyes, had stayed outside his manse, in the cover of a thick yew tree, and was listening hard with a hand cupped round his ear. 
 &bquo;This Act will enslave you,&equo; he heard Cameron saying, &bquo;and not only the young men among you but every family with a son who is in his prime. 
 For how are we to bring in the corn harvest with all those strong hands and strong arms gone? 
 You will manage  &mdash; oh yes &mdash; although you  have no servants to feed your animals or cook your meat for you &mdash; you will manage , although you are a year married with a wee child learning to walk, and no wet-nurse to mind it for you while you milk the beasts &mdash; and no young husband to thatch your house above your head. 
 The lords in parliament, and in the courthouse and the castle, they do not know how we live &mdash; they know nothing about us, except that we will die for them, to protect their forts in India and in Scotland &equo; &mdash; his voice sharpened suddenly, his arm swung round and pointed north and a gust of response rose out of the crowd &mdash; &bquo;we have always been good at that, their demands can never be satisfied, regiments for the colonies, indentured servants and labourers for the plantations, they have scoured Scotland like a killing wind and the men have been whirled away in the blast of it. 
 When the Philadelphia  &mdash; now remember this name &mdash; when the Philadelphia  put into Stornoway in Lewis, and gleaned young boys from the beach, and stowed them in the hold like trade-goods, what constable or what factor raised his arm or his stick to stop the slavers? 
 When seven slave-ships &mdash; now this is true &mdash; when seven slave-ships were cruising in the sound between Taransay and Harris, did Lord MacDonald's men protect Lord MacDonald's tenants? 
 Not at all &mdash; the price  was too good &mdash; MacDonald's factor was far too busy agreeing a price  for the young folk that he sold  to the Carolina merchants. 
 When the pressgang came to Aberdeen last year&equo; (had it been last year? 
 Near enough), &bquo;did the baillies and the constables protect the citizens from the bully-boys with their clubs and handcuffs? 
 Oh no &mdash; never &mdash; the bribe was far too great to refuse &mdash; they ran a cordon  round the Green and delivered over their own folk to the men-of-war. 
 Where will it end,&equo; he cried out, &bquo;where will it end?&equo; (feeling the helplessness in his own depths, knowing that to the crowd it came as an incitement to great anger). 
 The  feeling was soughing through them, every face was turned fully towards him, features naked, eyes widened (they were too expectant, too dependent on the next sally, their wills must be gathered up and channelled towards an irresistible action). 
 &bquo;It will  never end until we feel our powers, until we see how few and weak they are&equo; (this was the merest wishfulness), &bquo;and how strong they are, for consider what they have now, and in what sort of a country we are living. 
 The forts and barracks have gone up, an iron chain along the Great Glen, an iron ring round the coasts &mdash; you  have built it for them, you have clamped these fetters on your own wrists, and I do not excuse myself &mdash; my first work was mending the roof of the arsenal at Fort Augustus in 1784. 
 I should have known better, but we are learning now. 
 We are not free people under this Constitution &mdash; not any longer, if we ever were. 
 There is a Bastille in every glen and firth, and this Act is the final fetter&equo; (but it would not be, there would be plenty more). 
 &bquo;Let them put it on you and you are done for at last &mdash; food for the cannons, and the swamp-fever, and the hulks. 
 But remember&equo; &mdash; he had lifted an arm now and was prodding with his forefinger as though pointing to the furthest corners of the country (he was feeling the attention of the crowd and letting it recharge his energy), &bquo;the people are mightier than a lord.&equo; 
 He paused, letting the crowd dwell on the proverb (hearing the rooks caw above his head). 
 &bquo;The people are mightier than a lord, and if we know that, we &mdash; can &mdash; not &mdash; be &mdash; put &mdash; down.&equo; 
 Each of the words came out separately with the force of an oak peg hammered into a hole. 
 A roar of arousal sounded out at once and he spoke above it, formal and explanatory now (letting the standard phrases quell his own misgivings). 
 &bquo;It is very clear what we must do. 
 We petition against the Act, a petition to go from every parish. 
 We must all join in this &mdash; there is no room for anyone to hang back. 
 We have paper and ink here &mdash; make a start now if you have not already. 
 No more than forty-nine names on a paper, or the Deputy-Lieutenants will infer a gathering of illegal size and bring in the soldiers under the Riot Act. 
 Do not fail &equo; &mdash; he was having to shout now above the stir (was everything clear? or had he only thrown water on a fire?) &mdash; &bquo;do not fail to put in a clause calling on the proprietors to undertake nothing punitive against tenants seen at meetings. 
 We are within the Constitution as it stands, nothing illegal is going on and we claim the right to be treated as democratic citizens assembling as we are free to do. 
 We carry no weapons, the guns are all in Taymouth Castle, but if they threaten us or fire on us&equo;  (behind the yew the minister listened harder than ever), &bquo;then we will reply in kind . 
 &bquo;Now, can everybody see a paper? 
 James &mdash; Alastair &mdash; Iain &mdash; Donald &mdash; Angus &mdash; hold them up. 
 There  are our arguments &mdash; I believe we can muster sixteen thousand names &mdash; they must listen to that. 
 So sign your names, friends, or make a mark if need be. 
 We must have one great voice in this, and it must come from every quarter, up to Rannoch, along the loch to Glen Ogle and Loch Earn. 
 We will meet at Fortingall tomorrow, and let us make it the biggest meeting of all &mdash; the Glen Lyon folk will join us there, and once Breadalbane joins with Atholl, then they will know that the whole people is on thy move. 
 I know there is hay to cut and turn, but it is the harvest that will suffer if we let the Act stand. 
 So come to Fortingall, to the Green, at noon. 
 Now &mdash; can everybody reach a paper?&equo; 
 In the midst of the crowd a huddle of men and women were using a flat-topped gravestone as a table. 
 The point of the quill broke through the paper where it lay over an incised letter and a woman in the group pushed the man with the pen and crowed out, &bquo;Donal, you great fool &mdash; the King will never read that now!&equo; 
 People were flocking round each paper, jostling and craning to see what it said and who had signed so far. 
 The fringes of the crowd loosened and eddied is people slipped away and stragglers arrived. 
 Over at the manse the Reverend William McIvor, in a drab overcoat, let himself out by the back door and rode off to the north-east by a back path through the woods near Taymouth Castle, keeping his grey garron on a tight rein and stepping slowly so that the hoof-beats were nearly soundless. 
 Hemmed in by bicks and shoulders, besieged by people wanting to shake his hand, put questions, or merely to remind him of past meetings, Cameron was struggling to respond and make each person feel attended to.He still felt naked and drained after the speech, yet now was the time to be weaving more individuals firmly into thy spreading fabric. 
 We only have the year's agreement on our place &mdash; will the laird turn us out if Kenneth signs the paper?&equo; a nervous yellow-haired woman was asking him. 
 Her face was only a foot from his. 
 &bquo;Who is the owner?&equo; he started to ask. 
 A surge in the crowd behind him jolted him forwards and he saved himself, and the woman, by setting his feet wide and holding onto her shoulders. 
 He smelt smoke in her hair, felt her flesh soft under her shawl, and then a further quake in the crowd parted them. 
 He rose up on tiptoe, looking round for James, Allan, and the rest. 
 The crowd was gradually thinning. 
 The papers, covered with crosses  and signatures, were passing back to the organizers. 
 Within an hour Allan, Donald the smith, and the Logan brothers had set off down the strath to Weem with the petitions in a leather wallet, to add to the already thick bunch in James's strong-box, and Cameron and James had got horses from a sympathizer in the village and rode off towards the narrow glen of Keltney. 
 Among its tortuous water-courses, its hidden back-glens and caves and dark deformed woods choked with fallen trees knee-deep in moss, there might be refuges for a hundred listed men, if the worst happened. 
 And word of the meeting at Fortingall must be spread. 
 The sawyers at the government mill at Kinlochrannoch were good friends of Cameron's, and might try to bring out their neighbours, although they themselves were still felt to be incomers. 
 If the people from the hill farms around the loch foot could be mobilized, they would add a fierce thrust to the movement. 
 If they kept to themselves, the whole northern end of the area might as well be written off.  
 The Sawmill 
 An eagle planed over miles of country without a single flapping of its wings, curving and rising on the air currents generated by the warmed mass of Schiehallion. 
 In eleven miles Cameron and Menzies had passed three houses &mdash; all the fewer people to betray the refugees, they told each other. 
 The fewer also to provide food. 
 How to balance out these factors? 
 Their eyes followed thy bird as its image shrank and lost itself in space. 
 All around them the shoulders of the hills were browned by the fading of the heather, dulled by the weakening sunshine, their expanses turned dusty-blank as though a great grinding had sifted down on them, decades of labour and hardship, and left them blinded. 
 A desert, Menzies thought, a wilderness where you might just manage to survive for forty days and forty nights, especially if there was an angel at hand to minister to you. 
 He thought of trying this fancy on Cameron but his face looked so closed and dark, eyes narrowed and mouth-corners turned right down, that it forbade pleasantry. 
 Cameron was thinking: Those upland folk who were at Kenmore this morning &mdash; they nearly all kept on towards Tummel when we forked north-west for Rannoch. 
 So: up there they are with us, some of them; but here we might as well be among foreigners. 
 Are we stretching our lines too far? 
 The whole campaign dragged on him with a dead weight at this moment. 
 &bquo;The people are mightier than a lord&equo; &mdash; it was easily said. 
 But they were so scattered, their power diffused through a thousand little steadings &mdash; not concentrated into arsenals and parliaments and prisons. 
 You had to tell yourself, again and again, that there were links between all the little homes, filaments that tensed and hummed with power when the time came. 
 Look how readily the thousand had turned out to besiege the laird at Castle Menzies! 
 Yet all that feeling, all that energy, discharged itself into the void so long as it did not flow down one of the channels that made the great wheels turn &mdash; in Edinburgh, in London and Paris. 
 Our  people should be there. 
 How can a belted knight speak for us? 
 It is  in his interest to speak against  us, to force up rents, not fix them fairly, to give his friends a charter to chop down our forests. 
 Our trees, he thought, as the moss-green heads and bronze trunks of the pines round Dunalastair came into sight &mdash; our meadows in the low lands round the lochs. 
 How could it have come about, he marvelled afresh, that they had parcelled it out and tied it up with strings of law? 
 He knew full well: by Acts of Parliament, voted by landlords to benefit their like. 
 In France they had loosed the strings. 
 Paine was across there now, it was said, helping to write new laws. 
 If he came back, to spread the word, no doubt they would hang him like a felon. 
 But he had written his book &mdash; the people in Glasgow and Paisley knew it by heart, nearly &mdash; now it was up to themselves. 
 They trotted west straight into the broad golden glare of the sun and came among the scattered settlements of the Rannoch people. 
 The houses were huts &mdash; branches and small tree-trunks caulked with turf. 
 Plumes of shining pink and amber grass flourished on the thatch of their roofs. 
 As the horses trotted past, kicking up gravel from the rough road, women in dark-brown shawls picked up their babies and shouted at their children to come inside &mdash; as though strangers from the east were liable to spell trouble. 
 &bquo;It must have been like this in Arkaig when my father first went there,&equo; Cameron said to Menzies. 
 &bquo;How did he ever settle?&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps he was as savage as they,&equo; Menzies replied. 
 &bquo;Och yes, that is true &mdash; not like your fine slave-traders and moneylenders down at Perth.&equo; 
 Cameron turned off down a churned, peaty track towards the wooden roofs and palings of the sawmill. 
 Among orange mounds of dust and evil black pools the sawyers squatted, self-reliant Lowlanders who perched here like colonists and were tolerated because the sub-tenants and cottagers on the poorest land could get a few days felling trees when they were desperate. 
 A man was sitting on the ground outside his house. 
 He looked up at the horses, shading his eyes against a sting of sun from the west. 
 He was tall, sun-reddened, with a big lower jaw and a nose like a wedge. 
 He was smoking a clay pipe and his hair was speckled with sawdust. 
 &bquo;Angus Cameron!&equo; he said and got to his feet. 
 The two shook hands and Cameron introduced Menzies. 
 &bquo;James Menzies &mdash; my partner. 
 Kenneth Byers.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that in business, now, or in politics?&equo; asked Byers. 
 &bquo;Business! 
 What do you take me for?&equo; 
 Cameron pretended to be affronted.  
 &bquo;Ach well &mdash; I thought you were all in the money down there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Gunsmiths are doing well,&equo; said Menzies. 
 &bquo;And chainmakers, and bankers., &bquo;And lawyers and spies,&equo; said Cameron. 
 Byers regarded them quizzically. 
 &bquo;You should move up here, then. 
 If you want to starve in peace. 
 Come on inside &mdash; the midges will devour you if you don't smoke.&equo; 
 The hut had a muddy wooden floor, patched at the edges where the planks had rotted. 
 A partition of rough studding hung with ragged cloths divided the room into two. 
 In the public end a fire flamed in a stone hearth. 
 Black pots stood steaming on a pair of hobs. 
 On a bench a young woman with red hair had been suckling her baby. 
 Now she tidied herself up, arranged her shawl on her forehead, and soothed the baby, who was still nuzzling for her breast. 
 &bquo;Ella &mdash; here is Angus Cameron. 
 And he has brought his partner, Mr Menzies. 
 You're in luck &mdash; we found a fowl this morning, and it didn't look too well, so we had to put it out of its misery.&equo; 
 &bquo;No wonder they look darkly at you hereabouts, if you steal their fowls.&equo; 
 &bquo;What? 
 I wouldn't take an egg from the village folk. 
 No no, this fat old bird was round the back of Bunrannoch House, when I took wee Alex for a walk. 
 They've plenty to spare, and they're always in among other folk's corn. 
 The laird robs his tenants and his hens steal the harvest. 
 Sit down &mdash; will you take a dram?&equo; 
 They all, except Ella, took a pull at a stone bottle of fierce whisky. 
 &bquo;How is wee Alex?&equo; asked Cameron. 
 &bquo;Is he five yet?&equo; 
 &bquo;Five past Easter. 
 When were you here last?&equo; 
 &bquo;The end of March, when the drifts cleared from the road past Keltney falls.&equo; 
 &bquo;You came about the timber for the mill at Aberfeldy.&equo; 
 &bquo;I did. 
 We are still at it. 
 But it is not easy to keep working just at present.&equo; 
 &bquo;Does James Flemyng keep you up to the mark?&equo; 
 &bquo;Och, he comes snapping about, with his dogs and his &bquo;man&equo;. 
 He calls McHarg the factor &bquo;his man&equo;. 
 &bquo;I heard you were busy at other things. 
 Ella &mdash; where was I hearing the news?&equo; 
 &bquo;Down at Atholl, when you went for the new blades,&equo; his wife answered from beside the fireplace. 
 The baby was lying in a cradle of osiers, crooning to itself like a wood-pigeon.  
 &bquo;It s all a stramash of gossip down there, Angus,&equo; said Byers, giving his visitors a look. 
 &bquo;How your mob have murdered a teacher, and thrashed the Duke's servants nearly to death. 
 Well &mdash; I believed the half of it.&equo; 
 &bquo;That might be a bit too much.&equo; 
 Cameron was moved to deny the atrocities &mdash; he could see the doubts twingeing across Byers's forehead. 
 But there were other things to find out. 
 &bquo;What else did you hear? 
 Any word of the petitions?&equo; 
 &bquo;Petitions? 
 They said there was a wild night or it somewhere down about Ballinluig. 
 They called you &bquo;King Cameron&equo;. 
 I thought to myself', that doesn't sound like Angus. 
 But I said nothing.&equo; 
 Cameron and Menzies were looking seriously at each other. 
 Where to start? 
 How to convey the gist? 
 &bquo;Seventeen lairds have sworn to oppose the Militia Act,&equo; said Menzies flatly. 
 &bquo;And six thousand people have come out to the meetings.&equo; 
 &bquo;I heard there were great crowds about. 
 What's next, then?&equo; 
 Cameron did not want to be asked this. 
 Byers was offering him the bottle. 
 He drank and let the burn of the whisky pass slowly down his gullet. 
 &bquo;We are meeting again tomorrow, at Fortingall. 
 Drawing in the Glenlyon folk, and your neighbours here, we hope. 
 Once all this country is solid against the Act, and all across the Lowlands, then the government must think again.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do governments do that? 
 And anyway &mdash; suppose the war hots up, and they're desperate for men?&equo; 
 &bquo;Our people are steeling themselves, Kenneth,&equo; James Menzies said at once, talking excitedly. 
 &bquo;They mean business. 
 They will never follow a drum now. 
 March when a laird's son gives an order? 
 They know the lairds are straw men now!&equo; 
 Cameron watched for the effect or this on the sawyer's face. 
 Byers heard Menzies out, looked over at Cameron as though wondering whether he believed this too, and then stood up and stretched. 
 He knocked his pipe out on the stone above the fire. 
 &bquo;I wonder if they will take orders once they have red coats on,&equo; he said at last. 
 &bquo;I believe the Breadalbane men were up in arms against their commanders down at Glasgow a few years back. 
 But now there's a war on, and everybody's frightened at the French&hellip; 
 &equo; He let his words trail off. 
 They all went over to the fire for plates of meat and bread. 
 In his mind Cameron continued the argument throughout the meal. 
 He found in Byers a bracing scepticism like his own. 
 Yet speculation was actually fruitless now. 
 They were no longer debating the  rights of man at a Club for Equality and Reform. 
 They had committed themselves to a movement and had no option but to drive it through to its end. 
 What he wanted from Byers above all was an offer &mdash; a plausible offer &mdash; to bring two hundred people down to Fortingall. 
 And this was what Byers could not make. 
 They sat on arguing for three hours while Ella went into the other end of the house and sang quietly to the baby and wee Alex came home filthy from playing and sat drowsily beside the fire, chewing at the bones of the fowl. 
 The hut was sweltering with smoke and steam and everybody scratched as vermin crept and bit under their clothes. 
 But it was no better outside: midges boiled in clouds out of the sodden peat around the saw-bed and the timber stacks. 
 Byers felt the pressure on him to offer something and was restive under it like a dog on a tether. 
 &bquo;You know my position,&equo; he broke out at last. 
 &bquo;I work here but I don't belong here.&equo; 
 Am I any different, Cameron was wondering to himself, and Byers, sensing the thought, grew more heated. 
 &bquo;Do you know what it's like when people turn away before you've finished speaking? 
 Or refuse you milk or an egg when you have an ailing wean? 
 The government put this here after &bquo;Forty-six because they wanted one spot of safety in a wilderness of hatred, and because they thought they might as well get some good of this country once they'd ruined it. 
 Well &mdash; it might have happened yesterday, for the Rannoch folk. 
 They can bear a grudge forever, like a fire in a mine. 
 Don't you know that, Angus? 
 You speak their language, man!&equo; 
 His eyes were wide with stress, his face glared with fire-heat and whisky. 
 Menzies tried to intervene. 
 &bquo;Surely, then, Kenneth, this great grudge of theirs will bring them out against the enlistment?&equo; 
 Byers turned on him as Ella came through to ask them to hush their voices. 
 For a moment he looked from Menzies to Cameron and back again, then he nodded his head towards the doorway. 
 Once they were outside, he pointed across the level land towards the loch. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; he said. 
 Perfectly calm water mirrored a sky which shaded from smoky orange through turquoise to night blue, reflecting nothing but the sheerness of space, unlit by stars. 
 Smoke wisped up from huts invisible among the bunched darkness of trees and spread in faint blue webs. 
 Silhouetted against the gleam of the water human figures moved about. 
 Cameron and Menzies recognized the swaying shoulders of men leaning as they scythed, the reach and drag of women raking and turning the cut hay. 
 &bquo;Those are the folk you want to walk fifteen miles to your meeting,&equo;  Byers said in a low voice. 
 &bquo;In the middle of the hay harvest. 
 With the weather holding.&equo; 
 &bquo;There will be fewer to bring it in next year, when the listed men have gone.&equo; 
 Menzies brought out the familiar argument. 
 &bquo;They will settle for the devil they know. 
 Who doesn't? 
 They get mad here after the last wisp of hay &mdash; I've seen old women down on their knees, gleaning it with their fingers.&equo; 
 Byers's voice had tightened with compassion and distaste. 
 Menzies started to answer but Cameron put his hand on his arm, shook his head slightly, and said to Byers, &bquo;I see the trouble. 
 It is softer down our way and there is hay enough. 
 But, Kenneth &mdash; there is a war now &mdash; it is between the government and us. 
 They are going to draw the young men out of the country like pith out of a rush. 
 We cannot let that happen &mdash; can we?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Byers's voice was low, even sulky. 
 &bquo;No &mdash; we can't.&equo; 
 &bquo;So we need all help, all resources, everybody, if we are to win, and save ourselves.&equo; 
 Cameron was speaking in a low-pitched, pressing whisper. 
 &bquo;And there is a thing that this wild part is very good for. 
 A refuge, Kenneth &mdash; a haven. 
 Will they harbour some listed men here, if it comes to it? 
 Would they do that, do you think?&equo; 
 &bquo;The redcoats will go through the houses like a fire! 
 Remember &bquo;Forty-six &mdash; &bquo;Not in the houses. 
 They must lie up in the caves, if we do send refugees here, and in the pinewoods and the tall juniper &mdash; they will do even in the winter. 
 So long as your people will take them food. 
 And so long as they pass them through Rannoch to the west if need be. 
 Are there no families who would do that?&equo; 
 &bquo;The sawyers would do it &mdash; that makes fourteen houses. 
 And a good many are obliged to us for the work they get here. 
 Anyway, they would never give a man away to the soldiers&hellip; &bquo; 
 Before Cameron and Menzies left they had written down lists of safe houses, sources of milk and meal, and secure points further west. 
 A frail safety-net had started to take shape. 
 They rode east and south under a moonless sky alive with stars, the lustre of the Milky Way making a faint track across the zenith. 
 Their heads seethed with possibilities, worries, further problems. 
 As the deep black shadow in Glen Keltney closed over them, they moved slowly nearer home in a trance of fatigue.  
 The Hayfields 
 At two in the morning Cameron and Menzies were still sleepwalking between the ragged dykes of Dull, swaying and nodding in the saddle, letting the horses pick the way. 
 Blenching at the last few miles, shivering as sweat and dew ran down their backs, they turned into Donald Gillies's yard at Camserney sawmill. 
 The house door was locked. 
 They stabled their horses round the back and bedded amongst dry hay with their cloaks wrapped round them. 
 Noises of chopping reached them as they lay there in the morning, feeling stiff and foul. 
 They went indoors to find Donald splitting wood to start the fire. 
 He pretended to be unsurprised. 
 &bquo;We knew you were there. 
 The dog was whining and wanting out at you.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you could not have known it was us.&equo; 
 Cameron enjoyed teasing him. 
 &bquo;That dog has powers,&equo; Gillies insisted. 
 &bquo;One time, a tinker put in a day here, mending pans, and at night off he went, with my best tools hidden in his bundle. 
 Well &mdash; at Dunkeld fair that autumn, Roy here bites a man in the calf of his leg &mdash; it was the tinker!&equo; 
 &bquo;Would he bite a recruiting sergeant?&equo; asked Menzies. 
 &bquo;Or a teacher, for the matter of that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that why you are here?&equo; 
 Gillies turned back to the fire and spoke to them over his shoulder. 
 &bquo;Still drumming up followers for your meetings.&equo; 
 &bquo;We were benighted after a long day's ride to Rannoch, ordering floor timber for the mill.&equo; 
 Cameron covered up without thinking it out. 
 Donald Gillies was a friend. 
 But he had kept well clear of the struggle against the Act &mdash; why? 
 &bquo;Will we see you today at Fortingall, Donald?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fortingall? 
 That is a fair step. 
 I am not &mdash;&equo; He stopped and looked round, almost in alarm, at a noise outside the door. 
 His wife Aileen came in with pails of milk, scolding at two little girls for clinging onto her skirt and making her spill.  
 &bquo;Early visitors,&equo; she said with a keen look. 
 &bquo;And I have no water boiled yet for the porridge.&equo; 
 &bquo;We must get on the road at once,&equo; said Cameron, still diplomatic, while Menzies longed for a hot drink. 
 &bquo;Take a bite of cheese with you.&equo; 
 Aileen Gillies was all brisk agreement as she wrapped up some food in a cloth and gave it to them while her husband busied himself with laying the fire. 
 He saw them to the door but when they rode past a minute later, it was already shut. 
 &bquo;Well,, said Cameron, after a silent mile, &bquo;he was a friend before. 
 Or anyway he sold me timber.&equo; 
 &bquo;I blame the woman.&equo; 
 Menzies trotted out his hobby-horse right away. 
 &bquo;Keeping her man under her eye and calling it looking after him.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Weem women have not been behind-hand &mdash; they would have stormed Castle Menzies on their own., &bquo;There is a bit more spirit down our way &mdash; more spirit and more cash.&equo; 
 They remembered this two hours later as they stood on the meadow in front of the big house at Fortingall, waiting for a crowd to gather. 
 Heavy mists mantled the forested slopes behind the village, parted silently to show the crests of trees like seaweed under a tide, then closed again. 
 A few dark tracks criss-crossed the grey dew. 
 Black cattle snuffed and chewed. 
 Little knots of people stood about eyeing each other with an air of wondering why they had come at all. 
 When a larger group came tramping in behind a piper, Cameron and Menzies recognized some stalwarts from Foss on Tummel. 
 They went over to greet them and gather details of the events on Sunday when they were said to have ringed the churchyard and exacted an oath against the Act from all the gentlemen in the congregation. 
 But the latest news was discouraging &mdash; they had met few supporters on the road down Keltney, a handful from the far side of Tummel, not a soul from Rannoch. 
 &bquo;Wait till they come down from Glen Lyon.&equo; 
 Menzies was determinedly positive. 
 But they waited, and the roads north and west remained quiet. 
 The grey rocks on the hillsides wore shut faces. 
 The barking of two ravens sounded like syllables in a foreign language. 
 A traveller or two, pedlars and shepherds, were persuaded to join the few hundred who were there by the weight of glowering disapproval from dozens of faces when they showed signs of passing by. 
 But no massed contingents from up Glen Lyon and none from along Loch Tay.  
 &bquo;Has Breadalbane cowed you all with his recruiting and his threats?&equo; 
 Menzies asked a grey-haired man who stood bundled up in his plaid, tall and erect as though he was ready to take root. 
 &bquo;Och well, a terrible lot have gone to the colours, that is true. 
 They get the shilling, and a golden promise, and they think they will come back alive one day.&equo; 
 &bquo;Those who do come back should tell the young men what to expect.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can tell a young man nothing. 
 Thirteen went to the wars in Canada from my village, four came back. 
 And they have had little enough to say. 
 I think they are ashamed.&equo; 
 The mist was shearing from the hillsides like a fleece, the air lightening and warming. 
 A good drying day. 
 People were moving slowly off to east and west. 
 Cameron and Menzies looked at each other, searching for signs of belief that something could still be made of the occasion. 
 The men from Foss were restive. 
 One of them called across, &bquo;Give us a word, then. 
 Tell them what is in the Act, and what to do.&equo; 
 With a great qualm mining at him inwardly, Cameron got up on a tree stump and said his piece. 
 The scattered crowd drew closer together and listened quietly, but when he gave his warning about the Riot Act, glances were exchanged, a few grinned openly, and a wit called out, &bquo;They must know the law here &mdash; that is why they have all stayed at home.&equo; 
 There was nothing else to be done. 
 The threads of connection binding the people into a fabric seemed to have thinned to invisibility, the little steadings turned in on themselves like snails in a drought. 
 Cameron and Menzies collected a few names for their lists of contacts &mdash; the tall old man, who came from Camusvachan in Glen Lyon, the red-haired MacLennan brothers from Foss. 
 They arranged to come that way again next Sunday and then turned their horses eastwards for the long ride home. 
 Each man was struggling to fill the hollow that had opened inside him, to bridge it over with some kind of reasonable structure while saying nothing about it as though afraid it might crumble if it was exposed to the light. 
 &bquo;Maybe we stretched too far beyond our own place,&equo; Menzies hazarded at last. 
 This was uncomfortably like Cameron's thought of yesterday and he shrank from admitting it. 
 In any case it was much further up to Tummelside. 
 But the Foss men were famously militant, they had been ever since a young minister with lordly tastes and little scholarship had been foisted on them by the laird twelve years before and  they had first boycotted him, then run him down the road on a cart. 
 Cameron sensed Menzies waiting for some words &mdash; any words. 
 He roused himself to say, &bquo;Maybe. 
 Yet Atholl is as far, and we have good ties with them. 
 There will be many causes, James &mdash; let us not be speculating, and frightening ourselves. 
 Everybody in Strathtay is awake now &mdash; they know . 
 And that is the first thing. 
 Now we have to convert all this commitment into real results and save the listed men. 
 The rest is just froth if we fail in that.&equo; 
 He had reined his horse to a stop and was searching Menzies' eyes for complete agreement &mdash; for more, for energy to carry it out. 
 &bquo;James &mdash; when we have rested and supped, we will make a start &mdash; do you agree? 
 Near home, in our own place. 
 Will you go to Moness and see the Logans and sound them out about hiding? 
 Get them to think of their own best refuge. 
 And I will see the McCullochs.&equo; 
 &bquo;Two families&hellip; 
 &equo; Menzies was wilting under the enormity of the work. 
 &bquo;The army will have them all in barracks before we have saved the first ten men!&equo; 
 &bquo;Wait a bit. 
 Some others &mdash; the best ones &mdash; Donald the smith, and maybe Iain Logan, the real sterling men &mdash; they can join in once we have their agreement. 
 Then our net will grow. 
 Your Allan, too, of course., &bquo;Allan? 
 He talks like a mill-wheel. 
 We had better tell him nothing., It was the second cover-up of the day. 
 Cameron felt the dirtiness of conspiracy seeping into his being. 
 &bquo;He will not become sounder by being mistrusted,&equo; he said sharply. 
 &bquo;Ach, James &mdash; he is in your household. 
 You must decide.&equo; 
 They had built up the fabric in their minds again and could even feel some weary well-being as they neared Weem and saw it sheltering between the steep hills and the flood plain of the Tay. 
 The low lands were patched with hayfields at every stage of readiness, from bleached yellow to ferny green, and across the coloured surfaces people moved as though they were stitching and knitting at its texture, arms pulling on rakes, backs stooped under burdens on their way to the steadings. 
 Far up on the left, above the inn and the cottage row, two other figures moved, blue and white, not haymakers &mdash; Jean Bruce and young Donald, walking hand in hand amongst the bents of a neglected field at the furthest point of the McCullochs' holding. 
 For years it had not been worked. 
 A grey building with a sagging roof stood inside a stone enclosure with a wind-blown rowan tree beside it. 
 Its berries glistened red under the burnish of the breeze, which came in uneasy gusts  from the south and east. 
 Below them the strath spread its pattern like a map. 
 &bquo;I feel like a bird,&equo; said Jean. 
 She held out her arms and spread her fingers gracefully, pleasuring herself in Donald's admiration. 
 As he looked at her, his face closed over with a faintly embarrassed incredulity. 
 &bquo;A bird?&equo; he chaffed her. 
 &bquo;Are you a hen, then? 
 Or a duck?&equo; 
 &bquo;Donald McCulloch! 
 I am a wild-flying pigeon.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, you are a pigeon.&equo; 
 He stopped and turned her towards him and tried to kiss her on the mouth. 
 Over his shoulder she was looking at the derelict house. 
 Should she mention it now? 
 She let him kiss her, his tongue on hers, and then she eased him on across the field, her arm curved closely round his waist. 
 &bquo;Who lived here, Don?&equo; she asked him. 
 They parted a way through the tough bracken that choked the enclosure and their feet found the path to the front door. 
 &bquo;Old Donald's uncle Murdo was here for a while. 
 He was never bothered to marry, or to do anything else very much, they say. 
 He just let the place go. 
 And there is enough easier land for us down-by.&equo; 
 They bent their heads under the lintel and stepped inside. 
 Dusky light came from the two small front windows between the toothed leaves of nettles. 
 A rent in the old thatch let in a piercing beam of sunlight. 
 Jean held up her hand to it and when it made a bright white spot on her palm, she closed her fingers over it and pretended to give it into Donald's hand, like a delicacy. 
 He laughed and turned away to the hearth. 
 An old kettle with a hole burnt in its bottom lay on its side in a drift of twigs and old mortar. 
 The small earthenware cup of an oil lamp stood in a neuk in the wall with the stub of a candle beside it, stuck in a mess of wax. 
 &bquo;You can think of it with a fire going and a light burning,, Jean said. 
 &bquo;It would be cosy enough.&equo; 
 &bquo;There are plenty peats in the hill behind,&equo; Donald answered. 
 &bquo;father brought me up here on his back in the spring one year, and I sat in the moor while he and old Donald were digging peats. 
 I fell in the brown water and fouled my frock, and the men never heeded, of course, but there was the devil to pay when we got home at night.&equo; 
 &bquo;Would it take much work to make it sound and tight again?&equo; she asked in a carefully ordinary voice. 
 &bquo;This place? 
 The walls are straight enough. 
 But och, who would  want to live here, out of it all, and with a weary hill to climb&hellip; 
 &bquo;Young folk with a bit of spirit.&equo; 
 He turned, beginning to see her meaning. 
 She took him by the hands and said eagerly, &bquo;Don &mdash; we  could live here &mdash; it is right for us &mdash; would you like that, Don?&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 He laughed incredulously. 
 &bquo;We will live with mother and old Donald &mdash; you know that.&equo; 
 Her whole face drooped and she blushed with chagrin. 
 &bquo;I think you want that, living under their feet, and their scolding and groaning. 
 Why do you not want our own place?&equo; 
 &bquo;Because we have a good house already, with the new beds and windows. 
 There is a year of my work in it.&equo; 
 He looked mulish now, with his hard-eyed expression that she dreaded, that seemed to treat her as nothing. 
 &bquo;It is not ours, Donald. 
 This could be ours. 
 Think of it with the garden cleared and new fruit-trees put in &mdash; &bquo;They would never take up here. 
 Look at the lean of the rowan.&equo; 
 &bquo;Och well, berry bushes will grow well enough behind the wall. 
 And stock will graze down that tough grass and sweeten it again.&equo; 
 She brought out her trump card: &bquo;If we bring this into use, it will raise the value of your holding, and that will please your mother.&equo; 
 &bquo;And if we raise its value, then Robert Menzies will raise our rent.&equo; 
 They looked squarely and intently at each other for a full minute, as blankly as strangers, trying each other for traces of concession or agreement or affection, even. 
 Outside at the back a curlew piped, a lonely single sound, and among the weeds of the garden sparrows cheeped and quarrelled in shrill bursts of noise. 
 Cameron stepped between the stunted apple-trees and knocked on the McCulloch' new front door. 
 No sound from inside. 
 He stood for a minute, appraising the close-fitted timbers and sleek varnish, then knocked again. 
 &bquo;Who is there?&equo; 
 Mary's voice. 
 It had a frantic note. 
 &bquo;Angus Cameron.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh &mdash;&equo; Her voice seemed to choke. 
 He went in doubtingly. 
 Mary was kneeling with her head and shoulders inside the dark cave of a box-bed. 
 She turned and Cameron saw, under her arm, old Donald's face, eyes staring fixedly, his mouth drooping at one side, a shine of saliva on his chin. 
 &bquo;Mary &mdash; what is ado?&equo;  
 &bquo;Father has &mdash; Father has &mdash; oh, he is very ill, it took him yesterday.&equo; 
 She drew in a great sharp breath which shook her shoulders, then wiped the old man's chin with a cloth. 
 &bquo;Has Donald gone for a doctor?&equo; 
 &bquo;I sent him yesterday. 
 The man from Dunkeld will come today or tomorrow &mdash; if he thinks it is worth his trouble.&equo; 
 &bquo;I missed Donald at Fortingall. 
 Is it a fit?&equo; 
 &bquo;A fit of some kind. 
 His right side has gone. 
 Oh Angus &mdash; has the trouble turned his brain?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, why? 
 There is nothing desperate going on. 
 It would be worse if the army &mdash;&equo; But it was no time to be arguing. 
 Was it right even to burden the family with his plan? 
 To do nothing might be worse &mdash; Allan had greeted them at the house with the news (fresh from the great oven of rumour, the widow Duff's at Ballinluig) that a file of English soldiers had ridden out from Perth. 
 &bquo;Mary,&equo; he said carefully, &bquo;you have your own troubles now. 
 I just wanted a wee word with Donald. 
 Is he out at the back?&equo; 
 &bquo;I sent him into the hay. 
 We must bring it in whatever else.&equo; 
 Her voice sounded mechanical as though she were drawing a shutter across her pains and fears. 
 &bquo;Go on through and see him if you must. 
 She turned back into the bed as a sound came from old Donald's mouth. 
 In the narrow field that sloped upwards at the back between scrubby thickets Donald's rake lay with its teeth in a swathe. 
 Most of the field was still quilted with cut hay. 
 It had been so dry that two days under the warm sun had been enough without letting it stand in stooks or draping it on the hedges. 
 Now it could go straight to the byre. 
 Cameron looked round the neighbouring fields, some shorn close and yellow, some still fledged with feathery grass and sparkling with daisies and buttercups. 
 It was close here &mdash; midges crawled on his forehead under his fringe &mdash; abstractedly he took the handle of the rake and rumpled it lightly across the nearest hay, turning it over. 
 The green of it was bleached through and through. 
 Perhaps he should stay till Donald reappeared, help him clear the field and talk as they worked? 
 Up at the old house, Donald kicked the kettle in a spasm of impatience and said angrily to Jean, &bquo;Why are you putting me in a vice? 
 You know that I have to work the land down there. 
 The old man will never be good for much now.&equo;  
 &bquo;You could work it and live here, Don &mdash; why are you angry?&equo; 
 &bquo;You know why &mdash; I am the man of that house since my father&hellip; 
 Why should we not live there?&equo; 
 &bquo;Under your mother's eye?&equo; 
 Jean was suddenly shrill with frustration. 
 &bquo;And her thumb. 
 Alex McLaggan and Mary have their own roof at Grandtully, even if it is next door to his father. 
 I want to live with you , Donald, not with your old folk. 
 What do you  want-me or them?&equo; 
 &bquo;That is a trap.&equo; 
 Donald had his brow lowered now like a bullock and his eyes were hot. 
 &bquo;Why am I here at all? 
 I would be better off in Canada, free of all these tethers.&equo; 
 He flung out of the door, crushed through the bracken, and strode down the hill at his fastest pace. 
 She ran after him, calling his name. 
 Cameron raked on for half an hour, making loose heaps up the middle of the field. 
 Once a dark toad clambered away towards the little burn at the side of the field. 
 It must have been lucky to escape the sickles, he mused, as he watched its clumsy struggling across the cut stalks. 
 Invisible grasshoppers were churring like little birds. 
 When Mary came out, she found him standing still with his back to the sun, looking down the river towards the shady woodlands round Grandtully. 
 He had started out to make a rough count of the houses to be visited and then let his thoughts drift into a reverie of his own old home, the far tropical look of the mountain skyline beyond Loch Arkaig on the rare hot days. 
 &bquo;Where is the boy gone?&equo; her voice broke in sharply. 
 &bquo;His rake was here &mdash; no other sign of him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Gone after his girl. 
 Look at that queer sky. 
 If a thunder-plump comes, we will lose this good grass.&equo; 
 He gave her the rake and she went vigorously at the hay while he plaited a grass rope to put round a burden and heft it down to the byre. 
 &bquo;Once the harvest is in, Mary&equo; &mdash; he put his question abruptly &mdash; &bquo;could you manage here in spite of old Donald's ailment &mdash; I mean, if Donald was away?&equo; 
 &bquo;Away? 
 The soldiers will get nobody from here. 
 We will be meeting them with a hail of stones if they show their faces.&equo; 
 &bquo;Stones against guns, Mary? 
 It is all supposition; the gentry may have swung the government against the Act by now. 
 But just suppose &mdash; if they do send in dragoons with guns to take the men away &mdash; we are helpless, then, you know we are. 
 So let us think of that.&equo; 
 He  paused. 
 &bquo;If a deadly beast was coming for you, what would you do? 
 Fight or hide?&equo; 
 &bquo;Hide.&equo; 
 She was looking at him questioningly but he could see she had caught his drift. 
 &bquo;You believe the listed lads should hide?&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps we should try it.&equo; 
 Now it was out, it seemed hare-brained. 
 &bquo;Do you think we could feed them if they were in refuges in the woods and the back glens?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course we could. 
 We know the country, and there is a lot of it.&equo; 
 &bquo;But the redcoats are good hunters. 
 In &bquo;Forty-six they spared nothing.&equo; 
 &bquo;There is a war on now. 
 If we do it right, we can engage more soldiers than they would gain if they caught the lot.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mary &mdash; you should have been in the government.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh aye. 
 And I would not have made the war in the first place.&equo; 
 Feet sounded on the slope above the field and Donald came into sight, Jean close behind him, her face fiery. 
 Donald grabbed the rake from his mother and began to ply it hard, bouncing its teeth on the parched ground under the stalks. 
 Mary said hullo to Jean and then gave her son a shrewd look. 
 Feeling out of place, Cameron laid his rope on the ground, bundled a mass of hay onto it, and began to make a slip-knot round it. 
 Dry herb smells filled his nostrils. 
 Now the whole family was here, he must broach the scheme and work out the details of at least one refuge. 
 Was young Donald sound enough to be sent to contact other families? 
 &bquo;Donald and Jean,&equo; he said, and waited till he had their attention. 
 &bquo;Here is a secret matter, and it is a mortal secret. 
 We are thinking that the listed men must each have a refuge ready, if this Act is not withdrawn. 
 Where they can lie low. 
 Donald &mdash; it is your decision. 
 What do you say?&equo; 
 &bquo;A refuge?&equo; 
 His voice was barbed with irony. 
 &bquo;A cave? 
 A desert island?&equo; 
 Cameron deflected the jeer. 
 &bquo;A cave can be a trap. 
 But there are other kinds of shelter. 
 Would you lie low, if it came to it?&equo; 
 &bquo;And skulk like a fox? 
 Until I starved? 
 We never reckoned with this when we went and trounced the lairds!&equo; 
 &bquo;We have to think ahead now,&equo; Cameron began, but Donald was staring at him like an enemy. 
 Then he threw his rake down, took two paces across the field, and spoke into his mother's face. 
 &bquo;I suppose you agree with this? 
 To keep me on a string? 
 I will never do it. 
 There is more freedom in Canada and that is where I will go. 
 Jean agrees.&equo;  
 &bquo;I never &mdash;&equo; the girl started to say. 
 Mary's fury forestalled her. 
 &bquo;You say that &mdash; with your grandfather drooling in his bed! 
 And your friends threatened with the press-gang! 
 And your father &mdash; &bquo;My father? 
 He got out of here, though it was to the colours. 
 Maybe the place is too narrow, that we all want to leave it.&equo; 
 Jean was clinging onto his arm, as though to stop him inflicting more hurt. 
 As Mary looked at the couple, the fire seemed to die in her. 
 She turned to Cameron in a little movement of appeal. 
 &bquo;They will do what they like,&equo; she said to him. 
 &bquo;The soldiers will come for him and they will be sitting here, dreaming about Ontario.&equo;  
 The Ride 
 The thunder broke not long after sunset, as Cameron and Menzies sat with a jug of wine, reckoning up the day's gains and setbacks. 
 Iain and Alastair Logan had agreed at once that Alastair must go into hiding. 
 At first they assumed that he could find a place among the steep woods behind Camserney and be supplied by their good friends Donald and Aileen Gillies at the mill. 
 Menzies squashed this with his news of how cool the Gillieses had been in the morning. 
 &bquo;Sheep and goats now, eh?&equo; said Iain in his tight-lipped way. 
 &bquo;All right, then &mdash; Alastair can go up through the Glen of the Birks and use the old byre below Urlar. 
 The Urlar folk will neither help nor hinder &mdash; you know how close they are.&equo; 
 After that Menzies had walked along the hill to Duntaylor and Dunacree (leaving out the lonely man at Dunskiag with his terrifying dogs). 
 Both these families had sons of about twenty, both had been in the crowd that won the signature from Menzies of Bolfracks. 
 They saw the sense of the plan and agreed to find refuges for the boys in the thick forest between Bolfracks and Kenmore. 
 &bquo;It was dry work,&equo; Menzies summed up, &bquo;so I came back then for some refreshment. 
 It must be like this for a minister paying his visits. 
 No wonder they like a dram at every house.&equo; 
 Outside the thunder grumbled; it sounded pent up, unable to discharge itself. 
 Cameron found himself saddened and frustrated by the episode at the McCullochs' &mdash; it brought the dilemma of the movement to a point. 
 The real, mortal urgency of the situation could erode and trickle away like powder under the crush of people's domestic troubles. 
 Which they were used to. 
 Which were always there and would outlast even the war. 
 But so many would not come back from the war. 
 They seemed to realize that always too late &mdash; when it had happened. 
 He had a vision of the people of the country, walking and walking in endless droves, like pilgrims, across a battlefield shaken by the explosions of guns; and as the smoke blew into their eyes, the  people turned, desperate to see their homes again, but behind them a great dark channel had opened, with torn precipitous sides, and there was no way back&hellip; 
 The thunder thumped from some nearer point, the glass vibrated in the window, and Cameron came out of his doze to find Menzies grinning quizzically at him and offering him some more claret. 
 He shook his head. 
 &bquo;I will sleep without that tonight. 
 Today went on forever. 
 Like yesterday. 
 Will we plan tomorrow's work in the morning?&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought you would have to go to the mill?&equo; 
 &bquo;Aye, but with luck we will do little there. 
 No planks for the flooring yet, and if it is raining we cannot be on the roof. 
 Maybe we can talk quietly to a few of the men &mdash; one of the masons from Ballechin has a son who must be twenty.&equo; 
 Cameron slept instantly, and woke and dreamed and woke and dreamed for hours &mdash; the river, the cold shock of the water between his legs, the glimmer of light on the far shore, the current filling his mouth, he swam against it, it helped him, he struck out as smoothly as a seal, skimming effortlessly, he could power onwards forever, the water buoying him, his hand stroking it easily backwards without a splash&hellip; 
 I have never swum in my life, he thought, is he lay wakefully at dawn. 
 Rain dripped outside, drummed heavily, then slackened again. 
 He went over the Tay to Aberfeldy more to keep Flemyng quiet than with any hope of working. 
 The masons were busy with their mallets and chisels inside a makeshift hut on the site and it was easy to talk to them privately. 
 They had worked together for several years and the elder of them readily agreed to help supply the other's son if he went into hiding in the woods above Eastertyre. 
 Both men were dubious about how long someone would be able to endure in the winter, equally they could think of no alternative. 
 &bquo;Do you think,&equo; the elder man wondered, his face as grey as his hair with stone-dust, &bquo;that the generals really want to go into the war with an army of pressed men?&equo; 
 &bquo;It is hard to put yourself in the mind of a general,, Cameron answered. 
 &bquo;But they seem to trust in the power of the nine-tailed whip, and they will continue in that until a regiment breaks out of its barracks and makes its own way home.&equo; 
 The masons smiled at his fancy and went on with their work. 
 The day passed. 
 Few men turned up for work &mdash; no Sandy McGlashan,  and no Donald McCulloch of course. 
 Cameron wondered if it would be possible to raise the matter with him again, and bring him into a more realistic frame of mind, before the soldiers came. 
 If they came. 
 During the afternoon, while he sat idly chatting to a few men in the masons' lean-to, James Menzies arrived, his brown horse soaked black. 
 He looked full of himself but Cameron steered him across the street into the privacy of his store before he would let him talk. 
 &bquo;Why bother to be secret?&equo; 
 Menzies asked. 
 &bquo;There is that much talk about hiding and plotting down Grandtully anyway &mdash; &bquo;What! 
 Has that mad Duke been blethering? 
 I said to be chary of the McLaggans &mdash; &bquo;No no, there is no harm really. 
 Only I went to Donald Stewart's smithy and Mary was there, chatting to her mother, so by the time I had fixed things up with Donald and went along to Grandtully to explain the plan to Alex, Mary had already gone back and told him. 
 Ah, young love &mdash; she was sitting with her arm round him, crying silently. 
 She looked like Kirsty when I first went off to Bengal &mdash; &bquo;Menzies stopped, his own eyes watering, while Cameron let his temper sink back to normal after the gratuitous alarm. 
 &bquo;What does the Duke say, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, he was not at home. 
 He is off on a stravaig past Atholl, looking for cheap horses. 
 Alex will tell him tonight. 
 No&equo; &mdash; he forestalled Cameron's objection &mdash; &bquo;you know as well as I do, Angus, the Duke is daft but he is clever, and he has an entry to every house from Atholl to Dunkeld. 
 We cannot do without his cunning, or his tinker friends. 
 And if his own son has to take to the hills &mdash; &bquo;Yes, well &mdash; is Alex sound, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;He is, he sees the sense in hiding. 
 But he scarcely thinks it will come to that.&equo; 
 &bquo;He means he wants to stay in bed with Mary.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course he does, but he knows the score. 
 He and his brother are going to organize the soundest folk among their cousins and get the word to the boys on the other side from Pitnacree up to Cluny. 
 It is good work, this, Angus, it is bringing the thing home to plenty folk who have only been in it for the furore so far, for the chance to squeeze their girls in the crowd and all that kind of thing. 
 Even if they do not have to hide, they will be like lieutenants to us now &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;So long as we are not like generals to them.&equo; 
 Cameron shuddered inwardly, remembering his vision of the evening before and his exchange with the masons just now.  
 &bquo;Well, sometimes a lead is necessary. 
 Think of these last few days. 
 Who else has been planning anything, or thinking ahead at all? 
 A few at Foss &mdash; one or two at Kenmore. 
 We cannot be like Red Indians, sitting in a circle and acting as one man., &bquo;Do you think we have lost that forever?&equo; 
 Menzies looked at him in astonishment, then took his flask from his hip pocket and offered him a dram. 
 &bquo;You will be saying next that that is what they are doing in France. 
 Easy on the whisky &mdash; there is not much left after the great crack we had at the McLaggans&equo;. 
 Typical James, thought Cameron, as he handed back the flask and looked at his friend's flushed face: we are plotting to save our lives and he turns it into a holiday. 
 He looked round the cool gloom of the store, rows of small barrels and big jars clad in wicker, standing on shelves and on the floor, inside thick windowless walls. 
 Like some fantastic prison, where you could drink so deeply and so long that you forgot your bondage. 
 They went home at the end of the afternoon, just is the cloud slid back like a shutter and let clear yellow light stream along the valley from the west. 
 The evening was spent uncomfortably, biting back remarks that might have let the hiding plan slip out prematurely to Allan Stewart. 
 James Menzies woke abruptly. 
 Still dark. 
 A scratching at the window. 
 Like a claw. 
 A rose-tree branch? 
 Too regular. 
 He got up into the chilly darkness and went to look. 
 A spectre with a shock of wild black hair &mdash; the pedlar, John Stewart the pedlar. 
 He had not been seen since Castle Menzies. 
 They had missed his flute at the wedding. 
 He mouthed and gesticulated &mdash; what did he mean? 
 Menzies gestured towards the front door and went through to draw the bolt. 
 Stewart came in sweating and gasping, almost too desperate to form words. 
 &bquo;Soldiers &mdash; on the road from Tummel &mdash; at Keltney, nearly &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;How many?&equo; 
 &bquo;Eighteen. 
 An officer. 
 And a bigwig, a stranger.&equo; 
 &bquo;Riding?&equo; 
 &bquo;All of them.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who are they?&equo; 
 &bquo;Who? 
 Blur coats &mdash; black helmets. 
 I will go and &mdash; &bquo;Wait, John. 
 We must know their weapons and &mdash; &bquo;There are other folk to tell!&equo; 
 Stewart was suddenly violent, he backed away from Menzies, came up against the door, turned, and was gone. 
 A pony's hooves rattled on the road outside. 
 Twenty mounted men! 
 With swords? 
 How many guns? 
 They might   turn west along the strath and not&hellip; 
 Menzies struggled to stop the racing of his mind and sort out the options coolly. 
 The damp wind blowing in at the open door made him shiver and he went to wake the others. 
 In a minute the three of them were huddled in cloaks, by the light of two candles and the last glow of the embers, trying to think quickly. 
 &bquo;They may be making for Kenmore.&equo; 
 Menzies was staving off their fears. 
 &bquo;Why come that way?&equo; 
 Cameron objected. 
 &bquo;Soldiers from Stirling would have come by Crieff and Amulree, or if it is the Perth lot, then by Dunkeld and the lower strath.&equo; 
 &bquo;To avoid the strath &mdash; they must know it is all ours., &bquo;Then who is the big-wig? 
 Did John Stewart not name him?&equo; 
 &bquo;He ran off before I asked.&equo; 
 &bquo;You should have &mdash; Well, he is gone now&hellip; 
 Some law agent? 
 James &mdash; they are coming for us.&equo; 
 &bquo;I said they would &mdash; I said we should find our own refuge!&equo; 
 &bquo;And skimp the other work? 
 Allan &mdash; how long do you give them?&equo; 
 Allan Stewart had been itching to speak. 
 &bquo;How long? 
 Oh &mdash; five miles &mdash; half an hour if they mean business&hellip; 
 Come on, let us load and prime the fowling guns.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why, Allan?&equo; 
 Cameron asked soberly. 
 &bquo;To keep them off &mdash; to defend ourselves!&equo; 
 His blue eyes had fired up with excitement. 
 &bquo;Allan!&equo; 
 Cameron was sincerely amused &mdash; he found himself weirdly untroubled, as though he was watching a fantasy unfolding in which he was barely implicated. 
 &bquo;They would break in in a trice, while you were putting fresh shot in your fowling gun, and cut us into mincemeat. 
 If we have half an hour, the first thing is to burn the lists. 
 And the petitions.&equo; 
 &bquo;And destroy the work?&equo; 
 Allan Stewart was appalled. 
 &bquo;The work is destroyed already &mdash; if they are coming for us.&equo; 
 &bquo;But there is no offence in the petitions.&equo; 
 &bquo;We have committed no offence! 
 But still they are after us! 
 What do the petitions do but name many thousands of folk? 
 The government could pick up anyone they wanted and prosecute at their leisure, if we made them a present of all those names. 
 James &mdash; do you agree?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ach, burn the lot &mdash; burn the house.&equo; 
 Menzies had slumped suddenly. 
 He was looking into vacancy with dull eyes. 
 &bquo;James!, 
 Cameron wanted to bring him round. 
 But there was time  now for nothing but actions. 
 Without another word the three of them dressed and then, by the small yellow light of the candles, they opened the strong-box and fed the many leaves of paper one by one into the embers. 
 Flames lit up, for a moment, the soot-flowers trembling in the flue. 
 Black layers curled and then collapsed. 
 Cameron and Menzies looked at each other, their eyes gutted of all expression. 
 Allan Stewart went to the door. 
 &bquo;I will get horses now.&equo; 
 He was looking at them as though they were ill or crazed. 
 &bquo;To run off? 
 Why?&equo; 
 &bquo;Angus!&equo; 
 Stewart strode over and seized Cameron by the front of his cloak. 
 &bquo;You have only minutes now!&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 You go if you like &mdash; you should go.&equo; 
 &bquo;Come on, Angus!&equo; 
 The man had scarcely heard him. 
 Cameron turned to face Menzies. 
 &bquo;James &mdash; I am for staying here &mdash; do you agree?&equo; 
 &bquo;Let Allan get the horses.&equo; 
 Menzies' voice was low and automatic. 
 &bquo;James &mdash; I say we stay. 
 Flight is guilty. 
 If we stay, we can defend ourselves.&equo; 
 &bquo;With the guns?&equo; 
 &bquo;With arguments.&equo; 
 Cameron felt the frailty of the position as he spoke. 
 &bquo;We could not incriminate the others &mdash; well, at least their names are safe now. 
 But we will speak up for ourselves.&equo; 
 &bquo;Och, we are doomed now.&equo; 
 A thudding outside, which they felt with their feet before they heard it. 
 A flurry of bangs hit the door and before Allan Stewart could shoot back the bolt gun-butts had burst through the timbers, the bolt and its socket tore the jamb away, and soldiers in blue coats and white breeches were stepping in across the wreckage. 
 More bangs from the rear of the house, the door through to the kitchen slammed back against the wall, the room filled with soldiers, and in the wrecked doorway a tall, slim officer was making a small ceremony of ushering in a man with long grey hair and a black coat. 
 &bquo;Sheriff Chalmers,&equo; said the officer in a clear London voice, &bquo;your men, I believe.&equo; 
 &bquo;Angus Cameron?&equo; asked the sheriff. 
 He took a folded document from his pocket and looked at it. 
 &bquo;Is this James Menzies?&equo; 
 He looked at Allan Stewart. 
 &bquo;Or &mdash;?&equo; 
 Menzies stood up very straight and arranged his clothes. 
 &bquo;I am James Menzies, owner of this place, and I demand to know your business.&equo;  
 Sheriff Chalmers eyed him sourly. 
 &bquo;I think you know the &bquo;business&equo;. 
 I am to arrest you, and Mr Cameron, on charges arising from the mobbing and sundry other disturbances in this district. 
 You will be examined in Perth, with a view to preferring formal charges. 
 Captain Colberg &mdash; will you proceed with the prisoners, while I search these premises for evidence? 
 I will follow on presently, with Constable Thomson from Pitnacree.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wish you would remain under the protection of my men. 
 But I must be guided by you, sir.&equo; 
 His voice changed abruptly. 
 &bquo;By twos &mdash; right about &mdash; march !&equo; 
 Cameron and Menzies found themselves moving out of the door in a file of soldiers whose feet were already walking in step. 
 Allan Stewart's mouth was open, his eyes big with accusation. 
 In the darkness horses loomed. 
 A squeak and trundle of wheels &mdash; the post-chaise from the inn. 
 Cameron and Menzies felt themselves half-lifted inside by the arms. 
 Then they were rocking past the shut faces of the village houses towards the black thickets down the river. 
 In the gloaming before sunrise they saw each other's features as pale apparitions. 
 They clasped hands and held them clasped for a time. 
 Tension choked them: they could feel it rising up their throats, threatening to swamp their brains. 
 They wanted to pass it off through words &mdash; none would come. 
 Outside, shapes began to materialize &mdash; heads, implements &mdash; they wanted to recognize friends but they could see nothing but shawls, cloaks, silhouettes. 
 The muzzle of a gun poked up &mdash; would they be caught in crossfire? 
 The tines of a fork rattled to the glass of the little window, a face stared in just inches away, they recognized Donald McCulloch before he whisked backwards out of sight. 
 The panel splintered above Cameron's head, the tip of a scythe-blade broke through, shone for a moment, disappeared. 
 Nightmare was rising round them. 
 They heard Angus's name shouted out &mdash; &bquo;Cameron! 
 Cameron! 
 Fight for Cameron!&equo; 
 Normality flowed into them again, their neighbourhood was out there, friends and fellows, the animals grazing in the fields, the hens roosting in their houses, chimneys and hearths and beds, from all the steadings the people were coming now and would save them. 
 The glossy black haunch of a horse rubbed against the window. 
 Colberg's voice: &bquo;Cameron! 
 Menzies! 
 You have brought this on your own heads. 
 My troopers may not manage to hold back from firing now. 
 Tell these people to go home !&equo; 
 Cameron and Menzies looked at each other &mdash; &bquo;tell these people&equo;! 
  Cameron shot down the little casement of the window and roared out in his own language, with the whole strength of his voice, &bquo;We are here, friends! 
 Stay with us now! 
 Get word to the McLaggans!&equo; 
 Colberg was still there, fuming. 
 &bquo;Send them home ! 
 We shall not fire first. 
 But if your men attack we shall mow them down. 
 There are women here, you know.&equo; 
 Mary McCulloch, Cameron thought, and big Mary and Aileen Stewart and her Mary, and the McLaggan girls &mdash; they are all with us. 
 The sun must have cleared the hill beyond Grandtully, its light showed them weapons bristling above a river of faces, small boys with cudgels, women with stockingsful of stones and shards, men with shot-guns and blades set in poles. 
 A horse-rider towered amongst them, forcing against them like a rock in a torrent. 
 Cameron recognized Hope Steuart of Ballechin. 
 &bquo;Captain Colberg!&equo; 
 He was shouting in English. 
 &bquo;A thousand people have blocked Grandtully bridge. 
 They say they will have the prisoners or they'll cut you down.&equo; 
 &bquo;I shall fire if I have to&equo; &mdash; the captain's carrying voice. 
 &bquo;Cameron! 
 Menzies!&equo; 
 Hope Steuart's voice. 
 &bquo;You must tell your people &mdash; tell them you are going voluntarily &mdash; there is bloodshed threatening here.&equo; 
 &bquo;We will not say that!&equo; 
 Cameron's voice shouted back. 
 &bquo;We are arrested for resisting government &mdash; our people know &mdash; &bquo;Your people will be cut down&hellip; 
 &equo; Steuart's voice diminished as the mass of people blocked his way and the coach forged ahead. 
 Colberg's voice: &bquo;Load your pistols. 
 No shots until ordered. 
 Coachman &mdash; halt. 
 Sergeant Collier &mdash; rein in here. 
 Stand with the men. 
 I shall speak to the people at the bridgehead.&equo; 
 Against the broad yellow light Cameron and Menzies could see the officer in silhouette, walking his horse forwards to meet a crowd in the road where it levelled out after the sharp rise from the bridge across to Grandtully. 
 People flowed round him, shouting. 
 A hush &mdash; he was talking &mdash; Cameron and Menzies strained to hear but caught only his tone, several notes lower than his sharp pitch of command. 
 He laughed. 
 He leaned down from the saddle, took off his glove, held out his hand to the spokesman nearest him &mdash; Alex McLaggan (where was the Duke?). 
 And Alex was accepting the hand-clasp &mdash; Cameron and Menzies were rising from the bench to shout a warning, a plea &mdash; the coach jerked under them, flinging them backwards, their heads banged on the panelling, they were pounding down the hill towards  the crowd, Colberg's voice yelling &bquo;At them! at them!&equo;, people reeling away on both sides, jumping onto the parapet, a woman screaming, a red wound slashed along her brow. 
 The coach tore onwards, lurching and jumping. 
 They were jounced mercilessly on the narrow fitted bench. 
 Brilliant light dazzled in at the left-hand window as they swept past Balnaguard, Balmacneil, Kinnaird. 
 Low thatched houses crouched between hill and riverbank. 
 Their minds reeled, sickness churned as they struggled to save themselves from injury. 
 We should have run for it. 
 We should have run for it. 
 We should have run for it. 
 The words dinned in Cameron's head. 
 They taunted him like a rope dangling just out of reach. 
 We should have run for it. 
 To undo this moment &mdash; to force time backwards &mdash; to be again at the moment of choice back at the house&hellip; 
 Futile. 
 Defeat entered him like a heart attack, stunning the centre of his system. 
 He looked at James, wanting to speak and hear &mdash; nothing would come. 
 Menzies was crouching back on the bench, his legs braced, like a cornered hare frozen in a last effort to baffle the enemy. 
 Now they were rattling between the massive oaks of Glenvinean. 
 Across the river the tiled roofs of Dunkeld looked warm and homely, like a picture from another world. 
 &bquo;Steady now&equo; &mdash; Colberg's voice. 
 &bquo;We shall bait at Inver inn and I shall cross the ferry for fresh horses. 
 Sergeant Collier &mdash; the prisoners may refresh themselves., The party was drawing up with a jingle and a grinding of hooves on a cobbled forecourt. 
 Three sides of a square surrounded them with high walls and rows of windows. 
 Cameron and Menzies stepped down, staggered, and were supported into the inn. 
 In a brown-panelled room smelling of tobacco they sat on opposite sides of a cold hearth full of cinders, swallowing hot wine and water under the blue eyes of Sergeant Collier, who was looking at them with intent curiosity like a man staring at a two-headed dog in a freak show. 
 &bquo;If only they had saved us. 
 They should have held solid at the bridge.&equo; 
 &bquo;If they had, the troopers would have had their heads off.&equo; 
 &bquo;But they  were armed! 
 Donald Stewart owns three guns&equo; &mdash; Menzies spoke in a pressing whisper &mdash; &bquo;there were spears there, and pikes &mdash; &bquo;Who wins a battle &mdash; professionals or enthusiasts?&equo; 
 &bquo;A thousand of us could have swamped them.&equo; 
 &bquo;At a cost.&equo; 
 &bquo;There is always a cost.&equo; 
 Shouts came in a chorus from outside. 
 Four troopers had them by  the arms and were hustling them out into the coach. 
 A horse whinnied and reared; the troop trotted quickly out of the inn yard towards the high road; Colberg rode up as hundreds of people &mdash; women, children, men &mdash; ran out of the woods along the riverbank upstream. 
 A sharp shout of command &mdash; twelve troopers ranged themselves across the road. 
 The people had stopped in their tracks, women were making their children stand behind them. 
 Three men stepped forward to meet Colberg: Donald Stewart, a gun across his arm, Donald McLaggan, holding a shaft with a curved blade at its end, and someone unknown to Cameron and Menzies, also with a gun. 
 Colberg drew his sabre slowly and held it sloped on his shoulder. 
 He looked elegant, as though presenting arms in some courtly ritual. 
 &bquo;Hand over Cameron!&equo; 
 Donald McLaggan was speaking in a loud high voice, for their own benefit, they guessed. 
 &bquo;Hand over Angus Cameron and James Menzies! 
 You have seized them for no crime at all. 
 Or if you keep them, there are four hundred of us here and two thousand on their way, and we will cut you down to a man.&equo; 
 Again Colberg used his casual voice. 
 &bquo;Come, sir, my charges have only to give bail against their appearance at the Assize Court. 
 They'll be with you again in a day or two, if you don't hold us up. 
 Come now, be reasonable.&equo; 
 McLaggan shouted louder than before. 
 &bquo;Surrender Cameron and Menzies or the whole country will be fired!&equo; 
 Donald Stewart was speaking to Colberg: &bquo;What is the charge? 
 You have taken away innocent men. 
 We must know the charge.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's a legal matter, it will all arrange itself presently,&equo; Colberg answered on a light note of reassurance. 
 His voice rose suddenly: &bquo;By twos &mdash; to the right about &mdash; march !&equo; 
 The Grandtully men were looking thunderstruck. 
 Cameron saw Donald half turn to the crowd, then swing back round and raise his gun. 
 The coach wrenched forwards, the spurred boot of the trooper next them stabbed at his horse's side, blood spurted and red drops hit the window. 
 The gables and chimneys of Dunkeld slewed out of sight, a hill bristling with trees reared steeply above them, sunlight glanced from rapids in the river. 
 Then they were plunging into shadow between the woods of Birnam, hauled along like a leaf on a mill-race, and the hedges and trees never ceased to rock backwards past their staring eyes or the horses to gallop onwards with shoulders working and manes streaming until they were in sight of Perth. 
 By then Cameron's mind was rousing itself from shock, there were many things he wanted to say to James, but the  moment they stepped down under the massive archway of the prison they were hustled in opposite directions. 
 There was a stench of urine, like a foul byre. 
 The last Menzies saw of him was his head turning, his mouth uttering inaudible words, as a heavy door ground backwards and then slammed shut.  
 The Prison 
 The gaoler who usually dealt with Cameron was called Jamie &mdash; he called himself Jamie, like a little boy who has not long learned to speak. 
 One of his eyes squinted outwards, he looked massively strong, he always edged in sideways, moving the heavy door with his right shoulder. 
 He seemed friendly: one day he sat down on Cameron's pallet bed, looking sheepish. 
 A choking smell of pig-offal and old sweat came from him. 
 He hugged Cameron and said, &bquo;Mister Campsie, Mister Campsie&equo; &mdash; his voice cooed on a high note, not his at all, as though he was possessed by the spirit of a woman who had nursed him once. 
 Slaver ran down from a corner of his mouth. 
 He seemed to fall asleep, leaning heavily onto Cameron. 
 He could hardly ease himself free from the great stinking weight. 
 The day after, Jamie came in with the wooden dish of porridge, held it out to Cameron, then twitched it away when he reached for it and turned it upside down. 
 The grey mass fell onto the flagstones. 
 Jamie backed away, laughing, and slammed the door shut behind him. 
 The mess lay there for two days. 
 Luckily the flies had gone by now. 
 At night there was frost. 
 In the morning white rime coated the sill of the barred window-space. 
 It would be better, it might even be bearable, if only he knew what had become of James. 
 Had they left him in Perth, to keep the two of them well separate? 
 Yet Edinburgh was presumably safer, if the government was still worried about the turbulence of the Strath Tay people. 
 (Was it, though? 
 Perhaps by now they had been totally cowed.) 
 One morning Jamie conducted him down two flights of stairs and into a long high apartment, like a baronial hall. 
 Shabby men were walking about, in ones and twos. 
 At once Cameron was looking in every face, craving familiar features. 
 There were none. 
 After a time  he nerved himself to say to a couple of youngish men, &bquo;Have you heard at all about a man called Menzies? 
 James Menzies?, 
 They looked derisive. 
 &bquo;Haff you heard at aal apout a maan caald Menzies?&equo; one asked the other in a broad parody of the Gaelic accent. 
 &bquo;Ach, they're all called Menzies in here,&equo; his friend replied. 
 &bquo;Aye, that's it,&equo; said the other. 
 &bquo;A bad lot, the Menzieses.&equo; 
 The men laughed in Cameron's face and they both turned away. 
 At an early stage he worked out that the cell faced west. 
 Direct light came onto the sill and jambs of the embrasure at about the time when the noises of wheels and voices from the street were at their loudest. 
 As they quietened, the sun-colours on the stone yellowed, oranged, reddened. 
 After dark, drunken shouts, merry and angry, echoed up from the street. 
 Once a man sang with a little laugh in his voice, 
 &bquo;She pit aff her petticoat 
 An&equo; I pit aff my sark 
 An' we sweatit at the yokie 
 As we pleughed the muckle park.&equo; 
 The refrain tailed off down the street: 
 &bquo;Hi-dum-do, tum-a-hi dum-day, 
 Hi-dum-do&hellip; &bquo; 
 He hated the dirt; he wanted to touch nothing; he lay on his side, trying not to let his ribs come against the inside of his shirt or his hand touch the blanket. 
 He breathed through his mouth to try and not smell the fungus smell from his crutch. 
 Fiery itches tormented him &mdash; in his arse, below his armpits and inside his thighs where the fleas had bitten most. 
 A big-wig came to examine him. 
 &bquo;Cameron &mdash; you are required below to give evidence before the Lord Advocate's officers.&equo; 
 He lay and stared at the wall. 
 &bquo;Cameron! 
 You are to come now., He concentrated on positioning his shoulder so that it was in a cave formed by a fold of the stiff, harsh blanket, untouched by it. 
 &bquo;It is an offence, Cameron, to withhold information required in a due process of law.&equo; 
 He addressed the wall. 
 &bquo;I will speak to you again when I am clean.&equo; 
 Shoes scuffed the flagstones. 
 The door clunked shut. 
 He focused  again on the patterns made by damp and mould on a patch of distempered mortar level with his eyes &mdash; a piece of coastline seen from a hill, headlands enclosing a bay with a wide curve. 
 As the light failed, it came to look like the mysterious seas on the moon. 
 He dreamed that he was amongst dark waters, on a mudbank just above the surface. 
 Faces appeared, water streaming from their eye-sockets. 
 He forced them back and down and in, his fingers slipping on their cheeks and brows; they turned into mud, shiny and viscous. 
 He knew he must have betrayed someone. 
 But what had he done? 
 Or left undone? 
 The petitions and lists &mdash; there was the weakness! 
 They had not crushed the ashes in the hearth, the ink would still show up the names, if that sheriff had thought to look! 
 And the strongbox! 
 Could he be sure they had emptied it of its last sheet? 
 He tried to visualize its brown wooden bottom &mdash; he could not &mdash; there must still have been at least one sheet there. 
 Would he ever know which friends and fellows he had delivered over to the government in that one fatally careless moment? 
 Jamie began to let him out daily, down three flights of stairs to a yard where buckets of water stood beside a drain. 
 He could sluice himself, shuddering, take off his clothes and scrub them on a stone kerb, then hang them one by one out of the window. 
 They dried slowly. 
 No doubt this &bquo;concession&equo; was to soften him up for the next examination. 
 Unnerved by his betrayal nightmare, he wanted more desperately than ever to escape and flee. 
 One moment of confusion and he might give someone away, or incriminate himself. 
 After bringing in the evening meal one night (some ribs of mutton with a jacket potato &mdash; they were softening him up), Jamie left the door unlocked. 
 Cameron chewed slowly. 
 His gums were aching. 
 He eyed the door, expecting the handle to turn or a key to rattle in the lock. 
 It was perfectly quiet (no sounds ever reached him from the rest of the Tolbooth; it was hard to believe that it existed, the street below was more real). 
 He put the platter on the floor and got up stiffly. 
 He put on his cloak and padded over to the door. 
 Tried the handle delicately. 
 It turned. 
 He pulled. 
 The door opened. 
 He looked out. 
 The corridor dusky. 
 Empty. 
 He padded past the other cell doors and reached the door at the end of the corridor &mdash; massive, clenched together  with square-headed nails. 
 He grasped its iron ring-handle and pulled confidently. 
 The door did not budge. 
 He wrenched in a spasm of desperation and tore a fingernail. 
 The door was as rooted in the wall as a pine-tree in the ground. 
 Heartburn rose in his throat, tears in his eyes. 
 He turned back down the corridor, which was now as dark as a catacomb. 
 Were the other cells unlocked? 
 He tried a door. 
 It gave. 
 The cell inside was empty. 
 So was the next one. 
 And the next. 
 Hollow cubes drained of all life, movement, noise. 
 They might have been like this for three centuries, and could be for three centuries more. 
 Sucking his torn finger-end, he went into the cell next his own and sat on the floor, his back against the wall, looking at the scraps of scratched lettering on the distemper opposite him. 
 LAT THAIM SAY &mdash; what did that mean? 
 ALEX R  FRASER. 
 1746. 
 JN OGILVY 1694 &mdash; he would not write ANGUS CAMERON in his cell, it would be like leaving a vital part of himself here forever. 
 Lower down the wall, an unfinished sentence: PRINCE WAS. 
 Lower still a woman's name, with green mould edging up to cover it: ANN &mdash; BELOVED. 
 Perhaps his worst betrayal had been nothing to do with unburnt papers, it had been whatever he had conceded, or let slip, or left ambiguous, at the second long examination after arriving in Edinburgh. 
 Three big-wigs; two clerks at one side, scratching continuously with their pens. 
 Yes, he was aware of the provisions of the Riot Act. 
 No, he had never &bquo;flouted&equo; it; on the contrary, he had repeatedly counselled meeting in forty-nines at the most. 
 No, they had not &bquo;intimidated&equo; the proprietors, they had urged them to sign documents pledging themselves to appeal to government to rescind the Act. 
 &bquo;Urged&equo;? 
 Yes, urged. 
 By a show of force? 
 By reasoned arguments concerning the hardship it would bring upon the district if some hundreds of the most able-bodied young men had to go. 
 &bquo;Mr Cameron, are you suggesting that your repeated speeches &mdash; and mind, we have abundant eye-witness testimony concerning them &mdash; contained no word about the driving out  of proprietors? 
 Or of ministers and teachers? 
 Or the desirability of a republican form of government?, 
 &bquo;Not at all &mdash; I was concerned with one thing only, this Act and the difficulties and sufferings it entails, that kind of thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Kind of thing&equo;? 
 Be exact.&equo;  
 &bquo;The numbers of men who might be taken. 
 The likelihood of their serving at home or oversea &mdash; &bquo;Were you not aware of the government's express assurance on the latter point?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh &mdash; a crisis, a set-back in the war, could surely force the government to send more men to France or elsewhere.&equo; 
 &bquo;Given the known sympathies of yourself and your associates with the &bquo;republic&equo; in France, you would clearly be eager to counsel young men against warring with that country &mdash; &bquo;&bquo;Associates&equo;? 
 I have friends &mdash; &bquo;You are fencing. 
 We know very well that during your time in Glasgow you became familiar with the secret and unlawful society styling itself the &bquo;United Scotsmen&equo;. 
 It would be convenient to know the extent of its following in Perth.&equo; 
 Pause. 
 &bquo;And Mr Cameron &mdash; it might be convenient for you as well., &bquo;If I could tell you&hellip; 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 &bquo;I would not tell you if I could. 
 I will never name any &bquo;associate&equo; &mdash; any friend or fellow of mine.&equo; 
 &bquo;We are not asking for names, Mr Cameron. 
 Did I ask for names? 
 General evidence of the activities of that society would be quite sufficient for the time being.&equo; 
 Pause. 
 &bquo;The present charges against you are not immutable. 
 If you are reasonable, we shall be too.&equo; 
 Had he struck a bargain, or seemed to have? 
 He spent many hours of darkness, sweating lightly in spite or the autumn and early winter cold, wishing some of his replies unsaid, and wishing above all that he had said anything at all  after the examiner's last remark. 
 His silence must have seemed like complicity. 
 Now they expected information from him. 
 When he turned out to have nothing to give, how would they punish him? 
 As for their hint of a concession, he hated the thought of that loophole being closed. 
 And hated himself for depending on it. 
 The conflicting thoughts gnawed at his mind like wasps at a timber. 
 In the meantime the meat continued in the evenings. 
 Who, if anyone, had been the spies? 
 On the very day after his arrival in the Tolbooth, the Lord Advocate's officers already knew the name, the trade, and the movements of several people (the Duke, Iain Logan, young Donald McCulloch). 
 To think of a traitor amongst their own  people lacerated him as much as the thought of Iain or Donald lying in some cell. 
 But someone must have been slipping amongst them like a stoat, noting, memorizing, carrying word stealthily to the Duke of Atholl. 
 James had said that John Stewart the pedlar had seemed frantic that night &mdash; more so than the emergency warranted? 
 It was true he was footloose, and unmarried. 
 And he had not been seen for some days. 
 But surely, if he had been spying, he would have had to continue coming to all the meetings? 
 There was no end to such supposings &mdash; he shook his head like a dog with a bad ear, trying to rid himself of these crawling thoughts. 
 Sandy McGlashan &mdash; why had he been off work that Tuesday? 
 He was notoriously avid for every shilling he could earn. 
 And he had seemed almost to be currying favour when he was tumbling out the story of his family's lost lease, trying to get Cameron to agree that the lairds were done for now. 
 Cameron thought of the wee man's rubbery face, his busy scurrying movements &mdash; his compulsive drinking. 
 He must have needed money badly for that&hellip; 
 No &mdash; stop &mdash; this was a cancer of mistrust, spreading through him, eating him. 
 They  implant this. 
 They  keep us poor, till we are desperate for bribes. 
 But why is one man open to a bribe, while another is utterly staunch? 
 His neck and shoulders gradually became so stiff that he had to turn in one piece from the waist up. 
 When he got up in the morning, his ankles felt ricketty. 
 But he made himself walk to and fro a hundred times, slowly at first, then more briskly, to keep up some sense of health. 
 One morning big dry snowflakes starred the rime on the sill. 
 The sky never seemed to wake up and about the middle of the day it darkened. 
 More flakes sifted down like meal, sifted and sifted, drifting in at the embrasure and lying on the flagstones, unmelting. 
 When Jamie came in with the food at gloaming, Cameron asked him for another blanket. 
 &bquo;Naaa,&equo; Jamie said on a coyly taunting note, &bquo;naaa, I winna.&equo; 
 He went out, slamming the door. 
 Later that night he brought a ragged brown blanket. 
 It smelled of horses. 
 Time was rolling over him like a huge millstone, a broad grey abrasive surface turning and turning just above him, crushing him smaller, wearing him away. 
 He reached out for something outside his prison and found The Rights of Man , he concentrated on passages he  knew well and summoned them up word for word. 
 &bquo;Rank talks about its fine blue ribbon like a girl, and&hellip; 
 &equo; What was next? 
 Its garter &mdash; &bquo;It shows its garter like a child. 
 It &mdash; it-&equo; It was no good, they were going from him. 
 He sweated coldly, shut his eyes, and forced the words to come: &bquo;It is from the elevated mind of France that the folly of titles has fallen. 
 It has outgrown the baby-clothes of Count and Duke and breeched itself in manhood, it has put down the dwarf and set up the man.&equo; 
 A tune was sounding in his head &mdash; something from a magazine a friend had sent from Glasgow. 
 For a' that and' that&hellip; 
 He focused his mind still more sharply and some lines came out clear: 
 For a' that and a' that, 
 His ribband, star, and a' that, 
 The man of independent mind 
 He looks and laughs at a' that. 
 A prince can mak a belted knight, 
 A marquis, duke, and a' that, 
 But an honest man's aboon his might, 
 Gude faith he mauna fa' that&hellip; 
 The lowland poet, Burns. 
 Had he read Paine, then? 
 Cameron laughed aloud. 
 It was a nice thought, the lovers of liberty lighting their beacons there, and there, and there. 
 They burned and burned, driving back the darkness. 
 When would Paine be able to come back? and live again in his own country? 
 He knew that to face their defeat in Strath Tay (he assumed defeat now) would be too wounding, too dispiriting: it would bring him near despair. 
 If he was still himself, he should  be able to face it. 
 It began to be a test &mdash; the test &mdash; of whether he could still live with himself once the months (but probably it would be years) of imprisonment were over. 
 Why had they failed? 
 He found that his feet had cramped in a clench of anguish. 
 He pulled his toes backwards, hard, to ease the cramp. 
 No, he was not ready yet to face the defeat. 
 Perhaps after the hot food in the evening? 
 Yesterday's meat and vegetables had been high &mdash; soft and sweet with badness &mdash; he had made himself swallow it and then in the night the shite had poured out of him until he was too weak to stand. 
 He must wait till the poison had all gone. 
 Then he  could think back over the rising and understand and admit its weaknesses and set himself to imagine a better future&hellip; 
 This small piece of reasoning was as frail as wormwood &mdash; memories welled and streamed in his head, washing away all effort at steady thinking. 
 Colberg galled him most &mdash; the officer's gentlemanly aplomb helping him to swim like an eel under and between the weapons of a thousand angry people. 
 Colberg was confident . 
 They themselves had not been so. 
 They had at Castle Menzies &mdash; at the sunrise of the movement, striding from house to house, irresistible. 
 They should have kept that up &mdash; the Castle, Bolfracks, Ballechin, Kenmore, Fortingall&hellip; 
 The gentle mists draped over their moment of failure, when impetus ran down, as though they had no goal ahead of them. 
 They had not. 
 To save six thousand men, that was goal enough? 
 But they had merely asked for it &mdash; petitioned &mdash; begged &mdash; like &bquo;humble servants&equo; &mdash; if your Grace would graciously grant&hellip; 
 How to exact  this &bquo;favour&equo;, that was what had never been thrashed out (except for some loose talk of getting weapons from castle armouries). 
 He and James should have broached it early on, devised sanctions (the withholding of rents; the blocking of highways and sieging of the big houses), called for practical suggestions from among the crowds &mdash; all that tradesmen's and farmers' skill and nous and energy, coalesced for a moment into a great ball of force, then left to collapse under its own weight, to crumble again into its thousands of separated grains&hellip; 
 We have not the gift of combining, he thought bitterly. 
 The clans are gone and we stray about, waifs in our own homeland, letting government suck us in and swallow us and spew us out on foreign shores. 
 They  can combine. 
 Behind Colberg, the sheriff. 
 Behind the sheriff, the duke. 
 Behind him the king. 
 What an irony &mdash; the republican ideas they had accused him of propagating were exactly what he had left unsaid, and should have said. 
 No good to say that Strathtay was not ready for them. 
 If they had said this about the Paris workmen, Louis would still be on the throne&hellip; 
 Through all the turnings of his thoughts one image dogged him &mdash; Colberg's face, so sharply carved, his eyes a wee bit slanting at the corners, his nostrils cut on a long shallow curve, his forehead not rounded but angled above the glossy black hairs at the outside ends of his eyebrows. 
 A professional cavalier, who enjoyed excelling at the game of soldiering, who gave his orders with the perfect authority of a corps whose drills have been tempered by a score of successful wars, a hundred victories, a million unsung deaths. 
  They prepared Cameron for his appearance in the High Court of Justiciary by one final interview, a dry recapitulation of what had been said before, with the slightest of hints that it would go well for him if he divulged something about the United Scotsmen, who evidently still preyed on their minds. 
 The days had lengthened slightly, measured by the breadth of the pale sunlight on the sill. 
 He was stupefied with cold. 
 When the officer said, &bquo;You will be charged with sedition, over and above the mobbing, but in certain circumstances that might not be pressed,&equo; Cameron distressed himself by making a small, indefinite sound which could well have been taken for agreement. 
 A quick, bewildering passage through cold air, strange faces turning to look, a flapping of black gowns topped by frosty wigs. 
 Dark corridors smelling of snuff and dead flowers. 
 The court-room, high, with ceiling timbers like branches in a forest. 
 At the far end, a judge in a high-backed chair, looking at him once over little gold-rimmed spectacles, then disregarding him. 
 Charges were read (in a strong Lowland accent) by a tall stooped grey figure, like a heron. 
 Black figures stirred and poked their heads at each other like rooks in a rookery. 
 Sedition, mobbing, rioting (so &bquo;sedition&equo; had not been dropped). 
 A constable had him by the arm and was turning him about &mdash; was that all? no arguments? 
 The musty corridors again &mdash; dazzle of sunshine. 
 As he was handed back into the Tolbooth, there was a bustle at another door &mdash; a man's face, focusing suddenly into familiarity: James, a patch of high colour on each cheekbone, red on white, his hair more grizzled than Cameron remembered, looking ahead of him with wide eyes. 
 No time to shout out &mdash; the door clunked behind him. 
 Hot liquid of tears brimmed in his head. 
 He felt as abject as a convalescent child and had to be helped up the three stone flights to his cell. 
 It seemed filled with people &mdash; officers, clerks, a constable. 
 &bquo;Mr Cameron&equo; &mdash; a bigwig with painfully slow and clear articulation, his back to the window, his features invisible &mdash; &bquo;now that the charges have been preferred, you would be well advised to apply for bail.&equo; 
 He gaped stupidly. 
 (Where was James? 
 In court? 
 Would he come back here tonight?) 
 &bquo;Bail?&equo; 
 &bquo;Your trial will of course commence tomorrow. 
 However, a short stay may well be granted against bail, to enable you to order your affairs, and in particular to find guarantors.&equo; 
 &bquo;I would like to see my friend, James Menzies.&equo; 
 A pause. 
 No sound of movement in the cell. 
 The clear, harsh voice  again: &bquo;There is reason to believe that an application for bail would be allowed.&equo; 
 The cell was emptying. 
 Cameron was staring at the shut door. 
 It felt like the underside of his coffin-lid. 
 Confinement, which had gradually become accustomed and endurable, now chafed like chains. 
 He wanted to roar out James's name, his own name, to scream for help, he tried to pull up on the sill but his fingers scrabbled uselessly and he dropped back. 
 He fell onto his pallet, breathing hard. 
 Slowly the offer of bail was seeping into his understanding. 
 It was a nasty joke. 
 It was a trick. 
 If he was freed tomorrow, they would follow him (to the underground den of the United Scotsmen, no doubt). 
 But no deep thought was needed: he would accept their offer and see what happened. 
 The law-machine was clanking and clattering to its own weird rhythm. 
 Let it carry him along for a bit longer. 
 Where was James? 
 He would ask Jamie in the evening. 
 But Jamie was replaced that night by a tall, white-faced man who said nothing when he handed in the plate of food. 
 When Cameron spoke to him, he pointed to his ears and shook his head. 
 In the morning Cameron felt exhausted. 
 His dreams had come back after many nights which had seemed as empty as death, dreams of walking between high hedges, it was daylight on the other side of them but gloaming where he was and thick earth rose up to his knees, to his waist, stopping him, he tried to open his mouth but his jaw-bones jammed, he was choking&hellip; 
 Again the movement through fresh air and corridors (the smell was not old flowers but cloth and mildew, like church). 
 The judge looked at him as though along an oval tunnel lined with gowns and faces. 
 &bquo;Accordingly,&equo; he was saying, &bquo;I grant bail for the sum of &pound;500 against your appearance in this court tomorrow, when trial will duly commence.&equo; 
 &pound;500! 
 A vile joke &mdash; he could as well sprout wings and fly straight up to the sun as find that sum! 
 In the Tolbooth they stayed in a panelled room on the ground floor. 
 The officer with the harsh voice was advising him that the money would be &bquo;charged to the Lord Advocate's account&equo; if he himself could not &bquo;procure the funds&equo;. 
 A quarter of an hour later he stood alone at the edge of the High Street with as little notion of his next steps as a soldier discharged in Madras with the whole of India, Arabia, and Africa lying between him and his homeland.  
 THE MAKING OF A WORDSMITH 
 &bquo;Children show scars like medals. 
 Lovers use them as secrets to reveal. 
 A scar is what happens when the word is made flesh.&equo; 
 LEONARD COHEN 
 &bquo;If I do not utter a word, I am its master; once I utter it, I am its slave.&equo; 
 IAN GABRIOL 
 &bquo;All my work is the evidence of a life, and not the life itself.&equo; 
 LEONARD COHEN 
 THE MAN IN QUESTION 
 Some people impress by what they do, others by what they say, yet others by what they are. 
 The last is always the more interesting type; not infrequently he or she is an impressive doer, sometimes an eloquent speaker; some, very few, are both. 
 Leonard Cohen is one, but in his own inimitable way. 
 We first met him at an elegant hotel in the &bquo;uptown&equo; district of Manhattan, New York, overlooking Central park, a watering place well known to artists (Joe Cocker also happened to be in residence at the time). 
 We had travelled over 12,000 miles to see him &mdash; from Greece to New York via Edinburgh, thence to Los Angeles via Nashville and back to New York via Salt Lake City and Chicago. 
 It was worth every mile, and somehow the travelling was particularly appropriate, for he is himself a travelling man, at home everywhere and nowhere. 
 He is one of nature's gentlemen. 
 Aware of the distances we had covered, aware too of the reason for our travels &mdash; this book and our interest in his deeper self &mdash; though far from eager, indeed, &bquo;alarmed&equo; by it, he nevertheless agreed to meet &mdash; a moment of dual appraisal. 
 Several cups of coffee later, and many cigarettes (not to speak of his midday repast , a small bowl of Rice Crispies &mdash; a suitable delicacy, given his previous late night explorative jazz session with Sonny Rollins and the group Was Not Was) later, he kindly consented to our task: the victim was ours. 
 He left town the next morning, for Montreal where he feels most at home. 
 Our plan was to meet there in a few days' time, once our researches in New York were concluded. 
 These were now more eagerly undertaken, and soon completed; thanks not least to the good offices of his very able assistant, Kelley Lynch, and his unofficial archivist, Robert Bower.  
 A few days later, after we had established ourselves in Montreal, we called him. 
 &bquo;Mr Cohen?&equo; we asked in response to the &bquo;Hello&equo; at the other end of the telephone. 
 &bquo;Yes&equo; came the unmistakable, deep-voiced reply. 
 We reintroduced ourselves. 
 As before, he was concerned to hear that we had enjoyed a good flight to his native city, had found a good hotel and that we were managing to survive the bitter cold, the snow and the ice of a Canadian winter. 
 One could never have guessed from his enquiries that the matter was somewhat uncongenial to him. 
 It was an ambition come true. 
 We were now face to face with this man of diverse talent &mdash; poet, novelist, song-writer, performer &mdash; after following his career for nearly two decades, reading his books, playing his records, watching him sing, reading of him through the eyes of his critics &mdash; no easy feat when one is not inhibited by astigmatism! 
 There is no &bquo;side&equo; to him. 
 He who had performed for royalty, dined with national presidents, rubbed shoulders with the greatest names in the world of art and theatre, film and music, became a delightful companion and &mdash; it was never absent &mdash; a solicitous host. 
 The 60 or so hours he put at our disposal fled by. 
 Our questions ranged far and wide and his courtesy and patience turned them into an intriguing trail of discovery which was endlessly fascinating and richly rewarding, for he is also a natural raconteur. 
 When he commits himself to an assignment &mdash; be it a poem, a book, a song, or merely aiding a fellow-scribbler's itch, he does it with gusto &mdash; con brio , as he might annotate one of his scores. 
 Our second meeting, once the regulative caf&eacute; au lait  had been taken and a strenuous five  hours  of talk had been put behind us, was concluded by a guided tour of his beloved Montreal, whose night-time allurements were enthusiastically described in a car hired for the occasion, and concluded by a celebratory meal at one of his favourite Indian restaurants, toasting each other's health and futures in an excellent Chablis. 
 Leonard Cohen is a man of medium height, five-feet, eight-inches (173 cm); lean, with a rugged, world-weary face. 
 He looks like a man who should be heavier than he is, and one soon realises that an iron discipline keeps it that way. 
 He enjoys his food and wine, but disallows its enjoyment to distort the image which is important chiefly to himself, and then to his public. 
 He is frequently described as &bquo;having the stoop of an ageing crop-picker and the face of a curious little boy&equo; &mdash; which may have been true 30 years ago, but now belongs to the discard-tray with other caricatures: caricatures, as Oscar Wilde observed, are compliments that mediocrity pays to genius. 
 Greying a little at the temples, Leonard unconsciously confirms why he is labelled one of Canada's sexiest men, a handsome and elegant man with dark eyes (they are said to be green, but that never showed in the light of Montreal, nor in its wintry sunshine). 
 His skin is somewhat winter-pallid, thickening  a little, but nevertheless disguising his 54 years. 
 His hands are slim and well manicured, as becomes an artist-musician, somehow they seem especially sensitive &mdash; strong and caring hands! 
 He is always well-dressed, usually in smart suits and casual shirts, though in deference to the Jewish tradition which he discreetly adorns, he rarely wears a tie. 
 Occasionally he appeared in a bomber jacket and he frequently wore a hat &mdash; when we were there it was an engaging and stylish grey and white cap, though sometimes an American baseball hat in honour of Stevie Ray Vaughan. 
 What was entirely missing was any sense of flamboyance, in clothing or lifestyle. 
 His clothing was always dark, usually black, with few concessions to colours of the brighter hue. 
 As was his general demeanour. 
 He speaks softly and very reflectively, with few flights of passion. 
 He is content for everyone else to have their say first, though his everyday associates and friends respect his views too much to let him get away with that too often. 
 They wait and are seldom disappointed. 
 A word, an insight, a jeu d'esprit , is offered. 
 The conversation moves on, all the better for the comment, not infrequently the gayer for it. 
 His is not a dour presence, still less a melancholic one. 
 His humour constantly breaks through in asides and anecdotes, as does a delightful and mastering smile that transforms his face like Aegean sunlight on a frowning sea. 
 The first impression is of a quiet, reflective, determined man of the world, of affairs. 
 But the eyes give him away: sometimes they are all-seeing, giving the impression that he is quietly dissecting one's soul. 
 Sometimes they are especially tired, as if sleeping had been difficult. 
 (We almost always met in the late mornings at his favourite caf&eacute;, always starting the day with a reviving bowl of caf&eacute; au lait , followed by another &mdash; and not infrequently another!) 
 Sometimes they were misty and abstract, especially when one talked intimately of the past, of subjects he had long forgotten &mdash; or wanted to forget &mdash; awakening memories &mdash; nightmares? &mdash; from deep within. 
 Sometimes they were a little lifeless, not with lethargy or simple weariness (they could be that, but then his whole body-language &bquo;drooped&equo; accordingly), but with a specific withdrawn quality which, when taken with a certain passivity of the face, can be hard and unyielding: betokening a concern &mdash; even a resentment &mdash; in being examined in that particular way. 
 It is this which some journalists, using a phrase made popular by A.M. Klein, have referred to as his &bquo;stony, Semitic stare.&equo; 
 It can be very disconcerting. 
 But he never succumbs to what Max Scheler termed ressentiment  &mdash; that mixture of resentment and anger and injured pride that destroys so many, even if it were present in earlier years. 
 If one trespasses beyond the limits, he quietly corrects the fault in a plea, never a paroxysm. 
 His general attitude is one of an untiring and immense courtesy and helpfulness. 
 He knows the routine, he appreciates the need, if  without relishing it, he is too much the practised professional to show more than the briefest irritation. 
 And he is a man of enormous good humour, with a highly developed sense of fun and laughter which many second-hand commentators have failed to understand, or preferred to ignore. 
 When he laughs, it is different from the smile spoken of above. 
 His face is transformed into one of rapturous pleasure over which suffuses a boyish sense of fun. 
 It is a contagious thing that laugh, and healing too. 
 The Talmud says, &bquo;Happy is he who knows his place and stands in his own place,&equo; and Leonard Cohen is such a man today. 
 &bquo;Seriousness&equo;, a key word in his vocabulary, and perhaps the most important trait of his character, is ever ready to break down into self-mockery, ever willing to enjoy the jeux d'esprit  with which his work and art are replete. 
 He is a man of balance and careful equilibrium, a man with something to say by his life as well as by his words. 
 Indeed, a man whose life is his word: a word made flesh. 
 His house, into which he welcomes his visitors with open hospitality, is a charming, three-storeyed Victorian building attached to a smaller unit which acts as the atelier  for his lifelong friend, the sculptor Morton Rosengarten, and his charming painter-wife, Violet. 
 It backs on to another property owned by a professional photographer-friend, Hazel. 
 It overlooks a pretty communal park which, though much smaller, reminds one of Gordon Square, London: base of the famous Bloomsbury Group. 
 The artistic emphasis of the locality (there are other writers and musicians nearby, all in close contact with Leonard) is symbolic of his life. 
 He now lives alone, but his entourage is extremely friendly if wary of interlopers and proud of their friend, their mentor and sometime benefactor. 
 His house is sparsely, rather than modestly, furnished. 
 There is just enough d&eacute;cor and furniture to prevent it from looking empty, but space and simplicity are the most powerful impressions made on the visitor &mdash; what Leonard called in a different context &bquo;the voluptuousness of austerity.&equo; 
 The environment suggests a particular character. 
 In an unselfconscious way, it makes a profound statement about him and his place in the world. 
 It is kept very warm &mdash; a real relief from the biting cold outside &mdash; and suffuses a strong feeling of tranquillity. 
 There are no easy chairs, save for a single wooden rocking chair; no cushions, save for three ornamental ones in a corner. 
 The essential projection is of simple wooden furniture, plain walls, some carpeting on the polished floorboards. 
 For a man given to painting there is a surprising lack of colour, of objets d'art . 
 Everywhere is white. 
 A single figurine sits in the kitchen, significantly representing Catherine Tekakwitha, and a sculpted head of his friend, the poet Irving Layton, adorns his study. 
 An old twenties or earlier photograph of Jewish emigrants to Palestine adorns the top of a bookcase. 
 Everything is very clean, neat and tidy, dusted  and polished &mdash; but plain, like the man himself. 
 He is reluctant to preach, but if his lifestyle conveys anything, it is an emphatic witness to the importance of the things of the spirit; a disclaimer of the acquisitive society. 
 While provision for his guests is more than adequate, his bedroom consists of a single bed with a small television at its foot, remotely controlled. 
 One suspects that it is his concession to a profound loneliness, a loneliness which he dare breach only at great cost to his true self, his equilibrium as thinker/artist. 
 To that extent it is a harsh existence, quite unlike that of the artists, musicians and writers with whom he normally mixes. 
 Seymour Siegal wrote &bquo;In everyone's heart stirs a great homesickness,&equo; Leonard Cohen's home is itself a symbol of such homesickness; not a gesture, but an emblem of man's existential isolation and alienation, which he represents discreetly, without ever advertising it. 
 (&bquo;Lonely&equo; or &bquo;loneliness&equo; occurs a dozen times in his songs. 
 &bquo;Solitude&equo; and its cognates &mdash; a much more positive expression of the reality &mdash; but seven times, a not insignificant indication to which we must return.) 
 We should note, however, that loneliness is itself a feature of many Canadian writers, fruit of that belittling vastness of country in which they are placed. 
 As Professor Desmond Pacey emphasises in his brilliant survey, Creative Writing In Canada , in the words of Duncan Campbell Scott: 
 &bquo;So lone is the land that in this lonely room  Never before has breached a human being &hellip;&equo; 
 Pacey also argues that terror is another of its features: 
 &bquo; Terror of the wilderness, of storm and flood, of savages and of the  intense extremes of cold and heat .&equo; 
 Significantly he adds: 
 &bquo;But there is also exultation, the fascination as well as the fear of great strength.&equo; 
 In such comments we find ourselves in the precise atmosphere of Rudolf Otto's &bquo; numinous &equo;, the &bquo; mysterium tremendum et fascinans &equo; &mdash; the mystery that creates wonderment as well as terror &mdash; which surely accounts at least in part for the high level of religious feeling in Canadian folklore and literature; not least in Leonard's expression of it. 
 It also accounts for poetry being a more natural instrument of its literary expression than fiction or drama.  
 His frugality extends to his two work-places. 
 The plural is required for this multi-talented worker: his ground-floor music-room included a chair, a not over-expensive hi-fi unit with a modest collection of cassette tapes and a synthesiser; in the corner stands one of his guitars. 
 His writing-room on the first floor contains an unprepossessing table and a sideboard, on which sit his word-processor and printer. 
 A small chair and bookcase completes the picture. 
 The books &mdash; almost as much a symbol of Jewishness as the Mogen  David itself &mdash; are by and large well thumbed, though fewer than one would expect. 
 They offer a microcosm of his mental world in their range: Zen Buddhism, poetry, English and French literature, mysticism and spirituality (not least that of Simone Weil), music, a few general books. 
 He speaks of them with enthusiasm, and he lends them with abandon. 
 In another room adjacent to one of his two bathrooms lies some weight-lifting equipment: the needs of the mind are counterbalanced by those of the body. 
 But the spirit is never forgotten. 
 In an age mesmerised by quantitative values &mdash; &bquo;big is beautiful&equo;, &bquo;small is beautiful&equo; &mdash; he projects another, and immensely more important aspect: kind is beautiful. 
 It is his principle ethic. 
 Here then is a man, a large measure of a man: your man! 
 A PRESTIGIOUS FAMILY 
 Leonard Norman Cohen was born on September 21, 1934, to Nathan B. Cohen and his wife Masha, citizens of Montreal, Quebec. 
 The times, to say the least, were not propitious. 
 The New York stock-market had collapsed but five years previously, ushering in a period of need and anguish not only across America and Canada (New York is but 400 miles from Montreal), but throughout Europe, too. 
 In Canada it came to be known as &bquo;The 10 Lost Years&equo;, which were devastating for those on the prairies and very difficult for those in the cities. 
 To the scourge of this Depression dark voices were being added, and the shadows of armed conflict were beginning to impinge &mdash; a most unwelcome, even unbelievable thought to those who had, within the last 20 years, already risked their lives for King and country in &bquo;The War To End All Wars.&equo; 
 Nathan Cohen was one of them, and he had just cause to fear the upturn of the events, as did his younger brother, Horace. 
 (A third brother, Lawrence, was too young to enlist). 
 They had both served in the armed forces, and Nathan had been disabled as a result. 
 They knew what was threatening. 
 Masha Cohen also knew of such things, not in the same way, but from her own very different experiences as a young girl whose family had been harassed and hounded in the anti-semitic agitations that rent Poland. 
 She had seen her country overrun by both the German and the Russian armies; she knew at first-hand the madness of war and the fear it transmits to the civilian population. 
 Her memories and her character had been indelibly scarred by the suffering engraved in mind and flesh. 
 If Nathan Cohen &mdash; some years older than his wife &mdash; had known the dangers of battle as a young lieutenant in the army, then Masha Cohen had known its civilian equivalent, what it was  like to have been humiliated, to have lost everything, and to have been forced to flee from one's country and kindred. 
 Masha had, in fact, learned the terrible lesson as the despicable pogroms developed into a policy of national hatred and persecution, later to be transformed into actual genocide and thence into the horrors of the Holocaust. 
 If Nathan conveyed confidence and buoyancy to his progeny, Masha brought distrust and fear and the recollection of terrible suffering. 
 But with it all, an indomitable hope of the finest calibre. 
 Nathan Cohen himself was the eldest son of Lyon Cohen, one of the really influential men of early Canadian consolidation over five decades, not least among his own Jewish people. 
 His father, Lazarus Cohen (known as Reb Leizer), was formerly a bochur  (teacher) in the rabbinical college of Wolozhin, near Wilkovislak in Lithuania. 
 Born in 1844 to a family noted for its piety and scholarship, Lazarus had decided to emigrate to Canada in 1869, having heard reports of the young country's potential: its federation was then but two  years  old. 
 The writing was already on the wall for those willing to read it in his own country. 
 Within two years he had so firmly established himself that he was able to bring to Canada his wife and young son, Lyon, where they settled happily, first at Maberly, Ontario, then in Montreal, a home with more than a touch of aristocratic manners and style. 
 (Lazarus's brother, Hirsch, was a man of similar energy and stature, who became the Chief Rabbi of Canada. 
 He was of a more literary bent, and wrote a biography of King Louis, as well as a book on ethics and business titled Put Money In My Purse ). 
 Lazarus's business ambitions soon elevated him from storeman to lumber merchant, thence to a partnership in the coal industry which became his sole business &mdash; L. Cohen and Son &mdash; after a few years, and hence to a high-profile dredging company which could boast that it had kept every one of the lifelines of the young nation &mdash; the St. Lawrence tributaries between Lake Ontario and Quebec &mdash; open. 
 Lyon soon emulated his father's zestful example. 
 By the time he was 16, The Montreal Herald  was reporting the great success of his four-act play Esther , which he had written and produced (and played a leading part in) &mdash; shades here of his precocious grandson! 
 This so impressed the then president of the Canadian branch of the Anglo Jewish Association that he invited the young man, scarcely more than a boy, to be its secretary; the start of a highly successful and very wide range of business and charitable interests. 
 Quite apart from his business acumen (by the end of his commercial life he was the head of the largest clothing manufacturers &mdash; which his father had acquired earlier, originally named Freedmans &mdash; in the British dominions, as well as chairman or president of the most  important trade bodies related to that industry) he held very senior positions in such organisations as the Baron de Hirsch Institute, the Montreal Reform Club, the Montefiore Club, the Montreal Insurance Co, the Jewish Public Library, the Hebrew Educational Institute, the Canadian Jewish Committee for the Relief of War Sufferers in Europe, the Executive of the Canadian Jewish Congress, the Canadian Colonisation Committee, the Zion Athletic Club, the Zionist Organisation of Canada, and many, many more. 
 From 16 to 70 he worked assiduously and well, justifying the proverb that &bquo;Work is easy &mdash; for those who like to work.&equo; 
 The rewards, financial and social, were commensurate with this, to the great benefit of family and community alike. 
 In all this he found time to address meetings for these and many other bodies, hold weekly classes for teaching the youth of his synagogue post-biblical history and related subjects, write articles for the Jewish press (he founded an Anglo Jewish Journal called The Jewish Times  later to be absorbed into the Canadian Jewish Chronicle ). 
 By the age of 35 he had become the youngest president of the largest and most prominent synagogue in Canada; brilliantly engineered the merging of all the philanthropic societies of Montreal (&bquo;With a view to obtaining the greatest efficiency with the least possible expense and labour,&equo; &mdash; surely his own life-principle next to his religious and familial devotions); and placed himself in the forefront of the social and economic battles of the period. 
 This paved the way for leadership in an even greater battle &mdash; world war. 
 He led the war-effort locally by encouraging volunteers to enlist, saying, &bquo;I would not consider my son fit for recognition in civil society if he would not fight for his land, his flag, and his king.&equo; 
 Not only one but both his elder sons did so, and thereby became the first Jewish officers to be commissioned. 
 In time he was to meet and correspond with the most prominent political leaders of his nation, and become a trusted adviser to them. 
 Indeed, on September 12, 1924, he journeyed to Italy to meet the Pope on behalf of his people; which some commentators viewed as &bquo;historic&equo;. 
 His home was ever open, a centre of wisdom and influence for decades; admired even by cabinet ministers from Britain. 
 Among many high-level tasks, he drafted an Appeal to the League of Nations on minority rights, and made many approaches to various government authorities through a wide range of memoranda, petitions and similar appeals. 
 He was asked to stand for parliament, but declined, having no particular relish for party-politics; he was too large-hearted a man for that. 
 For all his organisational and business efficiency, he was a man of immense personal charm and dignity: &bquo;Well-dressed, aristocratic, calm, and with a ready and reassuring smile,&equo; it was said. 
 Moreover he was a man of great devotion, who upheld the high ideals of the synagogue's  pulpit, the beauty of its services, as well as the splendour of the building itself. 
 He was elected President of the Congregation in 1934, the year of Leonard's birth, which helped to cement even further that deep family loyalty to the institution. 
 He once said that his ambition was to make of it &bquo;the Cathedral Synagogue of Canada,&equo; and that is exactly what happened. 
 Years later, in a moment of youthful self-disclosure, his grandson commented through one of his fictional characters, &bquo;It didn't matter to him how he faced the congregation: his grandfather had built the synagogue.&equo; 
 One of Lyon's responsibilities was to ensure that the cantor, who led the singing on behalf of the congregation, was fit for the job. 
 He could not abide those who went in for exhibitionism, considering such to be irreligious. 
 On engaging a new cantor he would say (in Yiddish), &bquo;You must be able to sing; but don't you dare!&equo; 
 A view which undoubtedly reached down through his family, as we shall see. 
 For all his communal effort, he was a strong family man, head of a &bquo;truly aristocratic home,&equo; according to Albert Cohen, no relation, but the Hebrew teacher who privately taught Lyon's children on Rosemount Avenue. 
 He loved to speak Yiddish, and every Sabbath would find family and guests, rabbis and friends, some of them world-famous, discussing the sermon, the latest books (of which he had a very fine collection), Jewish history and literature &mdash; in Yiddish, Hebrew and English. 
 Curiously, he had a pronounced Scottish accent, in an area whose street names reflected the provenance of the early settlers at Westmount: Douglas, Montrose, Ramsay, Aberdeen, Argyll and so on. 
 His son, Nathaniel Bernard (shortened to Nathan, as was the custom), Leonard's father, exited from his war service disabled. 
 Whether it was through actual injury or through falling foul of one of the debilitating illnesses (such as trench fever), we do not know. 
 But he was to spend the next dozen or so years of his life as a partial invalid. 
 To be sure, he still upheld the standards of his father; he played a full role in the family business on the manufacturing side, but the crown went to his younger brother, Horace, who had not only secured field-promotion to Captain, but went on to bring the family business &mdash; and his industry &mdash; to new heights, for which he was awarded the OBE several years later. 
 (Lawrence managed the brass-works.) 
 It was through such ascendancy that &bquo;the power of the uncles,&equo; from which Leonard appears to have suffered somewhat in adolescence, obtruded itself on the maturing boy. 
 They were a close family, who gathered at Lyon's and his wife Rachel's home each week, cementing the family solidarity by such meetings sabbath by sabbath. 
 Because of his father's incapacity, Leonard grew up with all the advantages of family prestige, and few of its responsibilities. 
 His home, a very well disposed, if modest, semi-detached residence in the affluent part of Montreal known as Westmount, backed on to a park  overlooking the city and the mighty St. Lawrence River and port. 
 Despite the Depression, the family were well provided for, and spared the rigours that many others endured. 
 Mrs Cohen was &bquo;queen&equo; of her domain and, aided by a maid (suitably attired), a nurse for the children (Leonard had an elder sister, Esther), and a chauffeur-gardener (a coloured man named Kerry), they were particularly fortunate. 
 When Mr Cohen was well, they lived the life of any well-to-do family of the time, in the Edwardian style of the period. 
 Indeed, Leonard's main recollection of his father lies in that style, rather than more personal attributes or memories, and he is wont to describe him with his top hat and gloves, his cane and spats, and miniature service medals. 
 Breavman, the main character of his autobiographical novel The Favourite Came  recollected his father singing the old soldiers' song &bquo;K-K-K-Katy&hellip;&equo;! 
 When ill, which was often, Mrs Cohen acted as his nurse, and thus their children were largely left free to do as they liked, or at least as much as their &bquo;nanny&equo; allowed them. 
 Curiously, she was of Irish descent, a Roman Catholic, and so they grew up influenced by her form of Christianity, which is the dominant religious influence in Montreal. 
 It is this which partially explains Leonard's openness to, and understanding of, Catholicism which we find in his poems, books and songs. 
 from the earliest years he was enveloped in a clash of &bquo;mythologies&equo;, to use his word, and grew up aware of their contributive, as well as their competitive, differences. 
 Nathan Cohen was necessarily a quiet and reflective man, 19 years older than his wife. 
 He had inherited his family's respect for learning, and though not a savant  himself, he nevertheless brought his children up with a healthy respect for books and the independence they instil. 
 One of Leonard's great joys in his teenage years was a full set of the English poets, bound in leather, which had been given to his father for his Bar Mitzvah . 
 Already drawn to poetic vision and utterance, Leonard discovered this world for himself, cutting the virgin edges of the books which his father had left uncut for 40-plus years. 
 It was true self-education, and accounts for the enjoyment he still shares in the works of poets now regarded as pass&eacute; . 
 But there were many other joys for the family, and they led a privileged and enjoyable lifestyle, despite Nathan's indispositions. 
 The day-to-day running of the house was in Mrs Cohen's hands. 
 She was herself the daughter of a rabbi, whose father and grandfather before him had upheld the light of Jewish learning in their part of Poland. 
 Her own father, Solomon Klinitsky-Klein (sometimes Kline, who was born at Vilkaviki; the other side of the family come from Vilna), was hugely influential there; through his books, notably his Lexicon Of Hebrew Homonyms  which received excellent reviews in North America, Great Britain and Israel when published, became very well  known in his adopted land. 
 Another of his famous works was the Otsar Taamei Chazel , or The Treasury Of Rabbinic Interpretations , a thesaurus of views and definitions which was hailed as brilliant, indeed, unique in the sacred literature of his people. 
 Rabbi Klinitsky-Klein and his family had escaped to Canada through the good offices of a Jewish agency in 1923 &mdash; the sort movingly described by Norman Glimotsky in his My Life, My Destiny . 
 Up to that time their lives had been appallingly difficult, given the savage treatment their fellow-Poles meted out to them. 
 Insecurity, hunger, constant vilification and injustice were their lot, and it was as exhausted escapees that they made their way from Europe via Liverpool to Halifax (then the most important port on the Atlantic coast), before finally settling in Montreal. 
 &bquo;A stab in the heart leaves a hole,&equo; says the proverb of a people Leonard refers to as &bquo;professionals&equo; when it comes to suffering and loss; this trauma was one in which Leonard and his sister grew up. 
 Not that Masha was unable to enjoy herself &mdash; she had a fine sense of humour and loved to sing, which she could do well, serenading the songs of her homeland &mdash; lullabies and airs which still resonate in her son's head to this day. 
 As do the stories she told him. 
 But she would never forget the very different lifestyle of her early years &mdash; she was 20 when they emigrated; the veneration of her father and her father's father, the gross insecurity under which they lived; the ever-present threat of injury and loss, and the belittling malice; experiences which moulded and coloured her whole existence, as did her knowledge of Polish, Russian and Yiddish. 
 It was natural for such a leading Talmudic authority as her father to earn the respect and friendship of one such as Lyon Cohen, the prestigious future president of the synagogue and nephew of the Chief Rabbi; he had corresponded with Lyon prior to settling in Montreal. 
 It was natural, too, for his unattached son to be smitten by the courage and buoyancy of Masha Klinitsky-Klein &mdash; whose name in Yiddish, appropriately, means &bquo;brave&equo;. 
 Self-pity was absent from her make-up; she had that indomitable strength of acceptance and total commitment. 
 Following her arrival, she obtained a temporary job as a nurse in the Hospital of Hope, and this situation was destined to be of great use, not least to her future husband. 
 It was not long before the two families were joined with ties other than zeal for their faith and a deep devotion to its outworking. 
 Thus came together two very divergent streams of highly talented, family tradition, representing very different experiences: the one blessed with order, security, great success and prestige; the other reflecting a similar piety which had been tested and purged in the fires of persecution and suffering. 
 Of Birth and Bereavement 
 The Montreal into which Leonard was born was deeply segmented, as is Canada itself in its famous &bquo;two solitudes&equo;, the legacy of its Franco-British history; a difficult dimension for those outside its rivalries to understand. 
 It is not merely a question of its vastness (it is the second largest country in the world, measuring 9.2 million square kilometres), but its breathtaking grandeur:  God's own country, as the Canadians delight to call it. 
 There is, indeed, a divine magnitude to this demi-continent of nearly four million square miles, almost half of which constitutes the backbone of the country &mdash; the famous Canadian Shield, a range of ancient rocklands (the world's oldest) which arcs from Labrador in the east, through Quebec far into southern Ontario, thence piercing north for 2000 miles into the Arctic itself. 
 This natural phenomenon has forced human occupation, by all races since Canada was first inhabited, not just her French colonisation in the 16th century, into its disparate parts and localities, a situation further exacerbated by the Appalachians to the east and the Cordilleras to the west. 
 In the smallest yet most intensely populated of the two main lowland regions, the St. Lawrence, lies the city of Montreal, an island in the St. Lawrence River itself. 
 By no means the first place to be discovered, it soon established itself as a maritime port of central importance to Canada's growing economy; though it commenced as a Jesuit mission-place, which explains its ethereal qualities. 
 At one time a fifth of the town was occupied by religious houses or mission centres. 
 That &bquo;colonisation&equo; has now gone. 
 In its place is a charming, modern city, bursting with French culture and sensibilities and gaiety. 
 The city is divided geographically from mainland Canada. 
 But the geographical differences pale when they are compared to the deep  threefold divisions which rend the city itself: of language  (four-fifths of the population speak French, only one fifth English and the smaller languages); of culture  (the French-speaking part naturally looks to France and French literature for its mores, while the English-speaking part relies on the attachment to the Commonwealth and its close neighbour, the United States of America); and of religion  (for the gulfs here are wider than the Atlantic as the former protestant cross-sectioning of Episcopalianism/Presbyterianism meets the Roman Catholicism of the French, and both meet the surging secularism and agnosticism of our day). 
 To all this is added (and it must be emphasised that Catholicism has always been in the ascendancy), a healthy input from the Jewish fraternity whose civic and educational emphasis greatly increases the town's well-being, albeit from a proportionately tiny community. 
 (Professor Dudek has demonstrated that from a base of only 1.7 per cent of the population, the input in terms of literature and art amounts to a staggering 25 per cent.) 
 Montreal is an unusual city, made up of 50 villages which have grown and merged together over the years to form the modern conurbation: about 100 square kilometres in size (60 square miles), encircled by the St. Lawrence River. 
 The various groups keep a fairly sharp difference between them, centering their activities, not least through the exigencies of the two languages, in their own areas: essentially in the East (French) and West (English &mdash; which includes the large Scottish and &bquo;other&equo; cultural elements). 
 So it was that the Cohens' life was very largely circumscribed by the Montreal riding, which had as its most prestigious centre Westmount, where they lived. 
 Here this very affluent neighbourhood spreads out southwards and westwards from the Mont Royale, after which the city is named. 
 The Cohens were situated a little below the halfway mark, just below the grand boulevard that cuts through the neighbourhood. 
 By the late twenties, they were no longer a single-family unit centered on Rosemount Avenue, where Lyon's prestigious and influential residence (bedecked with a Star of David, in bold honour of the family's commitments) was situated. 
 All three brothers had settled themselves in the area, Nathan's being a pleasant semi-detached residence of three storeys. 
 It was ample for a small family of four of modest intent, yet large enough for a maid and a nurse to be employed. 
 (The maid was called Mary; the nurse simply &bquo;Nursie&equo;. 
 She stayed with the Cohens for the first seven or eight years of Leonard's life.) 
 There was never any sense of deprivation, but &bquo;frugality&equo; (Leonard's word) was definitely part of the family's style. 
 Years later he said in &bquo;The Telephone&equo;:  
 Did we ever use those battered pots, I wondered once while rummaging in the basement. 
 We must have been poor or deliberately austere, but I was not told&hellip; 
 Leonard's main recollection was one of orderliness, not extravagance. 
 &bquo;My father ran a pretty tidy ship,&equo; he recalled, in wistful recollection. 
 While its gardens were small, it had the inestimable good fortune to back on to a park with splendid views across the city and one arm of the river. 
 For a family with particular needs for quiet it was ideal, and when Mr Cohen was well a short walk took them into this repose of diverting potential. 
 Moreover, it was but a few  minutes  walk from the Junior School (Roslyn), and only a little further from the senior school (Westmount High) to which Esther and Leonard were duly sent. 
 Of particular importance to the family was the proximity of the synagogue itself, a mere few  minutes  walk through the park. 
 The Shaare Hashomayim Synagogue, &bquo;the cathedral synagogue in all Canada,&equo; stands in sovereign splendour at the heart of the community. 
 It was their synagogue not only by religious right, as members of the local community, but because the Cohen family had, very largely, been the driving force behind its foundation and continued expansions through the years. 
 There were other families whose contributions were also very important, but the leadership qualities of the Cohens &mdash; Lyon's in particular &mdash; had been unmatched. 
 These were acknowledged publicly by no less a figure than a former Prime Minister, W.L. MacKenzie King, at the communal celebrations of Lyon's 60th birthday and his 35th anniversary of engagement in social interests, as well as those of his friend of many years (to whom Lyon Cohen had diverted the honour of being invited to be the Member of Parliament several years before), Sir Samuel W. Jacobs, KC: &bquo;Our friend finds himself today,&equo;, commented Jacobs, &bquo;the acknowledged leader of Jewry in Canada, a position acquired by years of self-denying effort&hellip; respected by his own, and also by the larger community in which we dwell.&equo; 
 Just words indeed, and of more general application than that of Canadian Jewry only. 
 For his abilities and interests had been felt throughout the land, and had touched Palestine itself; the day would not be far distant when a woodland would be dedicated to him, the Lyon Cohen Memorial Grove, at Kadesh Naftali, south of Jerusalem. 
 What we know of the family shows that it enjoyed its privileges to the full, and shared a positive and happy lifestyle, without hardship, yet without vaunted excess &mdash; a balanced lifestyle, despite his indispositions. 
 Their life was founded on love and mutual respect: father for mother, and parents for children, to which other members of the family were regularly invited. 
 Nathan's illness apart, theirs was a home  life of high-minded living, fun and goodness; one which rang with Masha's high spirits, an acceptable foil for her husband's Edwardian style and manner, a real baleboste . 
 One of Leonard's few memories of his father (in addition to his monocle, his spats and his hair smelling of Vitalis) is that of his reading, both privately and aloud, to him and his sister &mdash; precious moments that fired the young boy's imagination and set him, although no one realised it at the time, in the direction of his life's work. 
 (One of his father's particular delights was found in the Reader's Digest , perhaps an indication of his limited energies.) 
 Leonard's overriding impression was of a stout man, reticent and somewhat withdrawn, at least introspective, who enjoyed a good laugh; a proud member of the Royal Canadian Legion and its military traditions. 
 From time to time other members would appear &mdash; the grandparents, the uncles, the cousins, business contacts and friends, a community within the community, and one of great internal strength. 
 We know very little of these early years, beyond that it was a family of privilege, untouched by the economic scourge that surrounded it, though Nathan Cohen must frequently have feared it might touch them, too &mdash; not least when he was blessed with a much hoped-for son, whom he named Leonard Norman. 
 The first name was aimed at keeping the initial &bquo;L&equo; in line with family tradition; the second was much more significant, relating to the family's Jewish ethos and hopes, as we shall see. 
 &bquo;Norman&equo; is the anglicised form of Nehemiah, who stands in the history of his people as the master-builder, rebuilder more accurately, prior to the People's return from Babylonian captivity. 
 The name actually means &bquo;God is comfort&equo;, or &bquo;comfort of God&equo; &mdash; a word which will be found to have high and particular meaning for Leonard, and for those touched by his perceptions. 
 In the 17th century one Nehemiah Cohen made himself particularly famous by opposing &bquo;the false prophet of Smyrna,&equo; Sabbatai Zevi, who sought to lead his people back into the Holy Land. 
 We have no knowledge of this being in his parents' minds, but it is interesting to note that this Cohen was a Cabalist, in which tradition Leonard was deeply immersed. 
 We should not minimise this naming, nor its effect on Leonard's early life. 
 Coming as it did from such a family &mdash; not only from Lazarus' and Lyon's own strenuous devotions to their faith, in which names are of the greatest significance, but also from that of Solomon Klinitsky-Klein, his maternal grandfather and his very similar tradition. 
 His names projected an above-average sensitivity and commitment, which was to haunt Leonard throughout his life. 
 Names, like words, in Hebrew are things ; they are not merely descriptive labellings, but possess a dynamic of their own which can be communicated to those touched by them. 
 It is as if, with the name, an extra dimension of personality is  added &mdash; not merely as a pious recollection of the great, but as a stimulus (at times a goad) to the one so named. 
 The naming of a child is a rite of the greatest importance in Judaism. 
 In addition to the secular names, there is an additional one by which the person is known in the synagogue, by which he is &bquo;called to the Torah&equo;. 
 That is given to the child at the all-important ceremony of circumcision, which re-enacts the covenant between God and Abraham &bquo;the father&equo; of the Jewish people, and admits the child into the family of Israel. 
 So Leonard was given his secular names (Leonard Norman) at the Sabbath on which his mother first attended synagogue, and his Hebrew name, Elieser (&bquo;God is my help&equo;) at the circumcision-ceremony itself. 
 And what more propitious names for the devout and hopeful parents than those of the chief servant of the father of the People and the great rebuilder of Jerusalem! 
 But what more daunting burden for a young man, in addition to the prestigious and ancient name of Cohen itself. 
 We can be very sure that the story-telling with which Leonard grew up &mdash; from grandparents, parents and Hebrew teachers &mdash; never failed to emphasise this aspect of his heritage; never failed to add to his sense of duty and destiny. 
 Leonard's circumcision took place, in accordance with Jewish law, on the morning of the eighth day after his birth; several prayers of blessings being recited before the actual ceremony, at which Nathan his father offered the solemn prayer: 
 &bquo;Blessed art Thou, O Lord our God, King of the Universe, who hast sanctified us with Thy commandments, and hast commanded us to make our sons enter into the covenant of Abraham our Father.&equo; 
 In deference to custom, there was a party in the child's honour, central to which was a dish of peas, which symbolises the lessening of grief to those who have been in sorrow &mdash; never far from the Jewish consciousness, and of particular relevance to this family; a copy of the scriptures was placed in the child's hands, along with a pen &mdash; how especially appropriate for this child! &mdash; which will have been followed by the usual Talmudic discussions in which, no doubt, Lyon and Solomon will have capped each other's comments. 
 Whether the parents planted a cedar tree in honour of the occasion, as another custom dictated (girls only got a pine tree!) we do not know, but we can rest assured that the salutation-prayer was made with particular relish for this first son of a first son: &bquo;A boy is born into the world; a blessing has come into the world.&equo; 
 There was another aspect of all this which will have heightened his sense of duty and commitment: in Judaism there is a law of redemption which must be applied to the first-born of any family. 
 It goes back to, and celebrates, the deliverance of the Israelites from Egypt's bondage under Moses. 
 Originally, all first-born sons were  dedicated to God, but monetary gifts later took their place, which were given to the priests. 
 But in the case of the Kohanim this was waived. 
 It was not necessary for the priests to fulfil the tradition, for their sons were automatically dedicated to the service of God and their fellows. 
 No redemption-money was needed, the child itself was the actual embodiment of the prayer-gift. 
 With the disappearance of temple-worship as such, this fell into misuse, but a new significance took its place, which would have had particular significance for Leonard's parents and grandparents. 
 At this time the father dedicates his son to the study of the Torah or to the rabbinate. 
 There can be no doubt that something of this sort took place at this time in Montreal, and that it forms one of the subconscious inputs in the growing boy's development, along with the high family traditions and the significance of his names. 
 Moreover, the covenant with Israel signified by circumcision was offered to make of the nation &bquo;A kingdom of priests and a holy nation.&equo;, 
 The whole people were theoretically &bquo;a kingdom of priests&equo; by virtue of their privileged relationship with God. 
 But it was from the first emphasised that a priesthood of succession should be established through Aaron, Moses' brother. 
 Thus the priests were known in Hebrew as the Kohanim &mdash; the Cohens &mdash; and it is this name (which Leonard later signified in his poetry by references to his &bquo;blood&equo;), which exerted most influence on Leonard, primarily in his formative years, but throughout his career &mdash; consciously and otherwise. 
 There was imposed upon him, which he reaffirmed at his Bar Mitzvah  at 12 years of age, a double mark: not only the circumcision by which all Jewish males are placed under the covenantal blessings and duties, but also the onus of priesthood. 
 From that time he was dedicated, a marked man. 
 We need to take good note of this, for it is an aspect of Leonard's life, little stressed to be sure, at times perhaps deliberately down-played, that is of immense significance to him. 
 And to us if we are to understand him in anything more than a superficial way. 
 The priest in Israel was not merely a temple functionary, a master and manipulator of sacred ritual by which the people's offerings and worship were duly performed. 
 He was also a spokesman for God, even as Aaron was Moses' spokesman. 
 (Moses, the great founder and lawgiver of the nation, had a speech impediment which necessitated this. 
 Aaron the priest was thus the spokesman, even though the authority was that of Moses.) 
 The temple ritual turned out to be of passing significance to Judaism. 
 In the history of the nation, the temple &mdash; and its associated ritualism &mdash; rose and fell, as oppression and persecution (not to speak of the Israelites' hot-and-cold religious attitudes) promoted or denied its expression. 
 By AD 70, that fateful year of Roman conquest and  banishment, the temple had fallen for good, and the classic priestly ritual was no more. 
 Never again, except in the nostalgic hopefulness of a few &mdash; would the ceremonies be performed; gone were the offerings, the blood-shedding, the fire and incense, the gorgeous (and the plain) robes, and the rest of the sacred imagery which &bquo;fenced-off&equo; God's otherness from the people &mdash; and brought them close to him in awe and penitence. 
 But the priestly role was not finished, and their equally sacred duty of reading and explaining the law remained. 
 No person is more important in the history of the people since Moses, than &bquo;Ezra the priest&equo;. 
 Ezra ha-kohen not only played the  leading role in reordering the nation's religious establishment (re-establishment), but was almost certainly responsible for a great deal of the safeguarding and consolidation by which the scriptures have come down to us today. 
 Accordingly, in all the synagogues since the destruction of the temple, the Kohanim (the word Kohen in Hebrew actually means &bquo;one who officiates&equo;) have pride of place. 
 They are the ones first called to read the scriptures, and offer the priestly blessings whereby the people are blessed of God &mdash; another key aspect of their office and work. 
 So, despite the loss of the temple, and its intricate system of worship and sacrifice, the hereditary priesthood had a role &mdash; a role which expanded, in fact, as the People themselves were thrust out into the world. 
 Enter into the world, therefore, the newest member of this exalted family: Leonard &bquo;the priest&equo;, whose early years were shadowed &mdash; albeit not too solemnly &mdash; with a high sense of Tradition, and of the divine plan and ordering, even divine mission. 
 There is a fascinating folk-tale about a child's pre-birth experience which adds weight to this, though it is not reserved to the Kohanim. 
 It is said that prior to birth the angels instruct the child in full knowledge of life and the universe. 
 At the time of birth, however, an angel strikes its upper lip, so causing it to forget everything that it has seen and learned. 
 The physical mark of this is to be seen in the indentation between the upper lip and the nose. 
 (In Leonard's case this is well marked, sign no doubt of superior knowledge!) 
 Another superstition relates to the day on which a person is born. 
 Those born on a Friday are said to be marked out for special piety, which does not mean that they will be pious necessarily; only that their natures are imbued with that proclivity. 
 According to Jewish calculation, the year of Leonard's birth was 5694, in the month of Tishri (the biblical name is Ethanim), which is the first month of the religious year with several of the most important religious festivals in it: New Year's Day itself; the 10 Days of Penitence prior to Yom Kippur  (the Day of Atonement); and the pilgrimage festival known as Succoth, also known as the Feast of Booths (or Tabernacles or Ingathering) which is a harvest festival, an especially colourful and joyous one traditionally, in which  the priestly activities in the Temple climaxed. 
 Leonard was thus especially welcome, especially privileged, and especially burdened: on that Friday, September 21, 1934. 
 So the family settled down in its definitive shape: father, mother, daughter and son. 
 It was overshadowed by two problems: one personal; the other national, indeed, international. 
 To Nathan's persistent ill-health, always attentively managed by Masha, was added the growing concern about their fellow jews in Europe. 
 Their own family experience had spelled out the horrors of bigotry and racial hatred; to these general and now somewhat distant things came the chilling reality of Adolf Hitler's seizure of power in Germany. 
 By 1935 the infamous Nuremberg laws which deprived Jews of their citizenship had been effected; with them went the boycotting of their businesses, their harassment in public places (such as education and law), and the first signs of ultimate horror &mdash; the moves to be rid of them completely. 
 A daunting background for the growing boy even though his parents wisely sought to cushion him from the realities. 
 Nevertheless, he was touched by it, as references to his people, his blood, military words, rank and weapons all show in his earlier poetry. 
 Jewish education is understood in three phases: primarily in the home, which is regarded as a sort of mini-temple, so strongly are the emphases and traditions posited there; at school, in the normal way, as with all growing children; and at Hebrew school, which is attached to the synagogue under the rabbi or the teachers appointed by him. 
 Leonard's ears, from his earliest moments, were conditioned to hear not only his mother talking but also singing in her lovely, deep alto voice the Yiddish lullabies she had known since her own childhood. 
 By this time she had been away from her native Russia scarcely a dozen years. 
 Little wonder that they were so fresh in her mind; creating a very powerful effect on his mind and unconscious, musically and rhythmically, that would remain with him for life. 
 Later the legends and stories with which she had grown up would be added to them &mdash; stories of astonishing miracles and heroic adventures, by which she and her father, Solomon Klinitsky-Klein &mdash; whose influence on Leonard should not be overlooked &mdash; fired his imagination and stimulated his ideas. 
 (Heroes are an important motif in his work.) 
 It was a childhood rich in the family traditions of Judaism, one that was made to feel all the more in need of protection, thanks to the brutality against them and their people in Europe. 
 Additionally, his father's side of the family were very enthusiastic adherents of the British Empire and in addition to their being (as Leonard preferred to call them) &bquo;gentlemen of Hebrew persuasion,&equo; they were perhaps more British in some respects than the British themselves, recalling what Hugh MacLennan said in his superb novel of the period, The Two   Solitudes : &bquo;The French are Frencher than France and the English are more British than England ever dared to be.&equo; 
 As soon as Leonard learned to talk he was taught to recite the first words of the Shema , the &bquo;creed&equo; of Judaism which originated on Sinai with Moses and is recited daily: 
 &bquo;O Israel, the Lord our God is One&hellip;&equo; 
 To this, as he matured, more was added, until the whole declaration of faith was perfectly grasped, part of his deepest consciousness: 
 &bquo;And thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy might. 
 And these words, that I command thee this day, shall be upon thy heart; and thou shalt teach them diligently unto thy children, and shalt talk of them when thou sittest in thy house, and when thou walkest by the way, and when thou liest down, and when thou riseth up. 
 And thou shalt bind them for a sign upon thy hand, and shalt be for frontlets between thine eyes. 
 And thou shalt write them upon the door-posts of thy house, and upon thy gates&hellip;&equo; 
 In so doing, from his earliest possible moments, Leonard Cohen became a witness in testifying to the unity of God (his &bquo;oneness&equo;) and his creation. 
 His deeper and more influential education was thereby commenced, based on the key concept of &bquo;oneness&equo;, which would be intensified by the traditional recitations and questionings the eldest son asks of his father at Passover and the other festivals, and by his presence from an early age in the synagogue. 
 (The Cohens' place was very prominent there, in deference to their priestly status and local influence.) 
 Here he was allowed to take part in the processions, kiss the mantle girding the Torah scrolls; and sip the wine of sanctification (the Kiddish ) on Friday evenings. 
 These recitations are of crucial importance, not only religiously (whereby the reciter &bquo;reactivates&equo; the stories, the traditions, the revelation) but socially, in integrating the participants into a unity with them &mdash; as their stories and traditions, from which strength and morale were drawn. 
 The practice is at the back of all Leonard's writing, poetry and especially his songs, as we shall see. 
 Not merely in form, but in the old rhythms and modulations &mdash; the &bquo;sounds&equo; built deeply into his subconscious. 
 Nathan Cohen was, even in those spartan days, an enthusiastic if amateur cameraman. 
 Thanks to his hobby some splendid pictures of his son and daughter's early life were preserved &mdash; on their tricycles, walking through the local park, playing with their cousins, skating and skiing, and some more imposing ones of them with the grown-ups &mdash; getting into the car while Kerry the chauffeur holds the door open; looking very serious with the uncles and aunts, their mother appearing to be taken up with the idea of not being photographed with them! 
  Nevertheless, a close relationship was sustained, each Sunday evening saw the three brothers and their wives and children gathering together at Rachel Cohen's home in highly convivial mood, Leonard's grandmother being especially delighted in her firstborn's firstborn. 
 Nothing exemplifies the spirit of the family more than musar : instruction (as moral training) which is given to Jewish children. 
 It is best expressed in the admonition &bquo;To act nobly, to speak purely, and to think charitably,&equo; and nothing exemplifies Leonard's deepest nature than this triune pattern, then and now. 
 Leonard's recollections of his early childhood are very indistinct. 
 He does remember, puckishly, an incident when he was about three years of age. 
 The doctor, a family friend, had called to see his father, after which Leonard was invited to sit on the good man's lap. 
 Alas! his only response to the friendly gesture was to urinate accidentally on him, which was of consummate embarrassment to his mother, and not quite in the spirit of musar ! 
 His introduction to day-school went more or less unnoticed. 
 Esther had already whetted his appetite, and it was close enough to his parents' home for him to return there for lunch each day. 
 Their parents had a sensible approach to the matter. 
 The children were expected to do well, carefully encouraged, but never laid under strain to do or be the best. 
 In Hebrew School it was a little different; he was a Cohen, after all. 
 There he was expected to be in one of the top three places &mdash; and first is better than third! 
 In keeping with this traditional matter went another, equally traditional: &bquo;Spare the rod and spoil the child,&equo; though in Leonard's case it was not &bquo;the rod&equo; but the dog-lead that reminded him of his responsibilities, accurately wielded by his mother. 
 Necessary, he confessed, in his case, as his independence and &bquo;bohemianism&equo; showed itself early&hellip; 
 Roslyn Junior School is a large, square building less than five  minutes  walk away from his home. 
 It is one of which the neighbourhood, for all its prestige, is proud, with an excellent academic record as well as a vigorous &bquo;Home and School Association&equo; &mdash; the forerunner of Parent-Teacher Associations. 
 At this level there was normally little more than &bquo;The Three R's&equo;: reading, writing and arithmetic. 
 But this was no ordinary school. 
 Thanks to its vigorous and far-seeing headmaster, it also found time for physical recreation, handiwork classes and art. 
 Once it was mooted that there should be a study-period after school, but this was vetoed by the parents' meeting which protested that it would interfere with after-school sports. 
 They were so enthusiastic for these that its pupils regularly walked off with all the trophies on  sports  days. 
 And they paid extra for one Mr Simonds to coach in football and hockey. 
 But they were also difficult days, finances being severely restricted by the government. 
 (Leonard's recollection is different. 
 He  has no memory of any such difficulties, only of how stable society was then. 
 He does, however, remember the yardstick or strap which was then used to facilitate good conduct and discipline by the teachers.) 
 Dr Jessie Scriver made a speech stating that the economies were affecting the health of the mothers, though not that of the children as yet. 
 To offset the problem, the teachers agreed to salary cuts! 
 Nevertheless, they were able to continue the art classes (to Leonard's chagrin, a Saturday morning event) alongside needlework and other crafts, which were exhibited locally from time to time. 
 Jewish tradition said this about the education of the child: &bquo;Scripture at five; Mishnah  (that is, the explanation of the scriptures; mishnah  means &bquo;repetition&equo;) at 10; Bar Mitzvah  at 13.&equo; 
 And so Leonard, from an early age, at home and at Hebrew school, was brought to the source of his faith. 
 Academically, he was a bright pupil, though it would appear he had difficulties in concentrating on the day-to-day routines &mdash; perhaps through boredom, often an indication of the brighter child. 
 One recollection of Leonard's concerns his reciting a prayer at Synagogue, which he got wrong. 
 Instead of the authorised prayer, he recited one for the dead. 
 Nathan was not too troubled by the error: &bquo;He'll have to learn about it soon,&equo; he commented, perhaps even then aware of the grimmer realities behind his words for his family. 
 In an interview with Mark Paytress in 1988 Leonard stated that by the age of six he was already acquainted with rudimentary Judaism and recalled being deeply touched by the stirring language and imagery of the Bible - in English and Hebrew. 
 Each day after school he would wend his way to the synagogue for instruction in the sacred scriptures, the stories and history of his people, which reached its climax in 1946, when Leonard was made &bquo;A son of the law&equo;. 
 &bquo;All hell rules over the man who is angry,&equo; says the Talmud, and by September 1939, when Leonard was beginning to come to terms with the thresholds of life's reality, hell was ruling the world, or at least appeared to be. 
 War had been declared, and the fate of Czechoslovakia, Austria and Poland was sealed, as it would be for several other countries. 
 It would be six years before that anger would begin to subside, six years of unspeakable anguish for those of &bquo;Hebrew persuasion&equo;, when unbelievable monstrosities would be inflicted on them, by the end of which half of the world's Jewry had been murdered. 
 This was carefully shielded from the growing boy, though horror of a personal, more penetrating sort was to obtrude itself soon enough on him. 
 The genteel and pleasant routine of life which he understood, despite the lengthening shadow of his father's illness, was convulsed in 1943, when Nathan Cohen died, and the family was plunged into loss and grief. 
 Masha Cohen had always felt an outsider,  vis-&aacute;-vis her more Westernised sisters-in-law. 
 She did not have the New England style of the others, and was made to feel it strongly. 
 This was now cruelly exacerbated; for she became even more dependent on them, not least financially. 
 As the old Jewish proverb has it, &bquo;from happiness to suffering is a step; from suffering to happiness seems an eternity.&equo; 
 She had taken that step; and now she, at only 36 years of age, had to bring up her children alone, and help them in their turn to make that large and difficult step. 
 The loss was irreplaceable, and the pain was never forgotten, even if stoically shouldered. 
 Leonard was but nine when his father died, and Esther 13. 
 Both were old enough to feel keenly the savage blow, one from which Leonard suffered in particular, albeit outwardly in guarded silence: &bquo;The deeper the sorrow, the less tongue it has,&equo; said the rabbis. 
 His mother sought to protect him from the usual customs such as summoning the relatives to his father's bedside, but the trauma was nevertheless very deeply felt. 
 Leonard recently referred to the memory of his father as &bquo;a dark mass or mountain,&equo; of which, clearly, the details were too painful for the young boy to register or the adult to express. 
 (The image actually appeared in a somewhat different way in The Favourite Game : &bquo;Concerning the bodies Breavman lost&hellip; a man on the mountain,&equo; a reference to the cemetery on Mont Royale probably.) 
 Loss, the most alienating of all experiences; the most unbelievable, and therefore the most easily forgotten (or repressible) thing. 
 There can be no doubt that he was devoted to his father &mdash; his first book, published 13 years later, was dedicated &bquo;To the memory of my father: Nathan B. Cohen&equo; and there are a number of references to him in Leonard's work. 
 There was deception and anger, too. 
 As he said in one of his early poems, &bquo;Rites&equo; ( Let Us Compare Mythologies , p 227): 
 My uncles prophesied wildly 
 promising life like frantic oracles; and they only stopped in the morning, promised 
 after he had died 
 and I had begun to shout. 
 In his autobiographical novel, The Favourite Game , he tells how Breavman &bquo;tried to fight his anger with a softer emotion,&equo; and how &bquo;he tore the books as his father weakened.&equo; 
 He was being cheated. 
 It was all too premature. 
 He had things to ask, things to learn of his father, things to tell him. 
 In a moment of youthful inspiration, the day after the funeral, he took one of his father's bow ties, one reserved for special occasions, and opened up its seams, into which he infiltrated a message &mdash; his first poetic utterance, as he told his Spanish biographer, Alberto Manzano &mdash; long since forgotten (or too painful to remember?). 
 He buried it in the back garden, near the fence, overlooking the park that  overlooks the city of which his father was so proud. 
 It was winter, and something of its icy strains entered the young boy's soul, never to be forgotten. 
 The funeral itself he remembers only for his mother's withdrawn, uncommunicative state; and for the solemnity with which his uncles &mdash; always sober and grave &mdash; conducted themselves on the day. 
 Jewish mourning, as with every other aspect of life, is strictly regimented. 
 By law no attempts may be made to hasten death or prolong the life of the sufferer. 
 By law no preparations are to be made in anticipation of death, apart from allowing the loved ones due access, and the positioning of candles &mdash; symbolic of the flickering life and to chase away the forces of darkness. 
 The funeral arrangements are a sacred duty, a mitzvah , and intense mourning (weeping and wailing) is encouraged. 
 We need have no reservation that such memories, not least the sounds, entered deeply into the young boy's consciousness, as his mother gave vent to her distress in English and her native Yiddish, as well as symbolically rending her clothes and chanting the dirges. 
 Head coverings were normal, as was the removal of one's shoes; (in some quarters the placing of dust or earth on one's head, even flesh-cutting and head-shaving, were tolerated). 
 It is also traditional to burn spices for the deceased; to cover the mirrors (or soap them); and to remove from the house any photographs of the deceased. 
 All in all, apart from the loss itself, a deeply traumatic experience heightened by the rituals. 
 And the day of the funeral, recalled in a quasi-fictionalised form 18 years later, was no less memorable or searing: Breavman's mother had stayed alone in her room leaving &bquo;Nursie&equo; to get the children ready. 
 (Leonard confirmed to us that &bquo;the details in The Favourite Game  were true&equo;): Breavman sat stiffly on his bed. 
 Whispers from the people downstairs floated up to him. 
 He remembered the descent down the stairs, the wintry sun reflecting off his mother's stockings, the lines of cars outside the house. 
 He recalled his uncles, &bquo;tall and solemn,&equo; standing behind them, patting him on the shoulder affectionately; neighbours and friends behind them, and the factory workers taking their own, lowlier places. 
 He remembered seeing his father's face for the last time; the coffin being lowered into its final resting place &mdash; and the hateful wake which followed. 
 Most of all the cheerfulness of it; his uncles' jokes, the traditional fare of eggs and bagels; the pervading sense of loneliness after they had all gone home &mdash; his uncles last of all. 
 And his anger, as well as his mother's night-long laments. 
 An experience that no boy should have; that no boy can forget. 
 As he admitted, &bquo;In real life (as opposed to his novel) there was repression&hellip; 
 I did not discover my feelings until my late thirties&hellip; 
 The psychologists would say something had been repressed&hellip; 
 There was a traumatic effect,  blocked feelings&hellip; 
 It is beyond alienation&hellip; 
 I had to adopt  the aspect of receptivity. 
 I was very receptive to the Bible, authority. 
 I wasn't  interested in argument, philosophy&hellip; 
 I took the simple biblical past&hellip; 
 Having no father I tried to capitalise (on his absence), resolve the Oedipal struggle, (create) good feelings.&equo; 
 Whether there can be a true &bquo;Oedipal struggle&equo; with a very sick, and then absent, father is a mute point. 
 Its centre normally lies in the conflict between father and son (of which Leonard never speaks) and the ensuing guilt (which, likewise, has no explicit reference), though the anger may have eclipsed that.  
 SON OF THE LAW &mdash; AND SON OF LORCA 
 By the time the first sharp feelings of his loss had begun to wear off - it would be very many years before all of it did so, and arguable that it ever did &mdash; other voices were beckoning. 
 As he said in The Favourite Game : &bquo;Seven to 11 is a huge chunk of life, full of dulling and forgetting,&equo; though perhaps some of the &bquo;forgetting&equo; was deliberate. 
 It is clear that a certain possessiveness took over in his mother, always deeply caring and attentive, from which Leonard had to struggle to free himself. 
 The tumult of war had undoubtedly touched Leonard, though his immediate family were spared its direct horrors. 
 Indeed, he seems to have been more influenced by the adventure of war: &bquo; Que la guerre est jolie !&equo; 
 Apollinaire (who coined the word &bquo;surrealism&equo;, to which we must return) had commented. 
 In pensive vein he had published &bquo;an early warning&equo; in The Favourite Game  against those who would follow &bquo;our future leaders, the war babies&equo;; for the simple reason that while the world convulsed in its madness and death-throes, &bquo;we grew up with toy whips,&equo; &bquo;games&equo; played by old and young alike. 
 And as he moved from boyhood to early youth, tales of heroism and daring-do accumulated, luring him by their unreal charms. 
 Military language and imagery entered his consciousness more forcefully at this time too. 
 Though soon to be exposed to Nazi atrocities as returning soldiers and the world's press became free to speak, he enjoyed the feeling of being on the winning side, of seeing his country's troops and their allies making strong progress across Europe. 
 By this time, he was in the second phase of his Jewish formation - that of the Mishnah , and attending his Yeshiva with some diligence, if not zest. 
 The Talmud Torah (&bquo;Study of Torah&equo;), the official name for Hebrew school, was very close to the family's heart, his forebears having put much energy into its foundation and extension. 
 And  Solomon Klinitsky-Klein's rekindled reputation, albeit now based in New York, increased that determination. 
 (Leonard called him, &bquo;a wise man; a world-study teacher,&equo; adding &bquo;I received a great deal from my grandfather.&equo;) 
 His daughter Masha was careful to deposit in the synagogue's library copies of his works as they appeared, to the great appreciation of those who minded such things. 
 But there is cause to suspect that even by this time, a certain boyish scepticism had erupted in Leonard's mind. 
 The anger over losing his father had barely diminished, and the older he grew, despite his uncles' attentiveness to many of his needs (as they saw them), the more the loss was felt. 
 As he said in his first novel, answering one of his early girlfriend's naive questions, &bquo;What was it like to have no father?&equo; he laconically answered, &bquo;It made you more grown-up. 
 You carved the chicken. 
 You sat where he sat.&equo; 
 And that sitting, for a Jew, was particularly meaningful: it was where the head of the household sat; responsibility was encroaching upon him, even then. 
 All this made his instruction in the scriptures and the explanation attached to them more dramatic; not least his studies in the sacred language which he was expected to acquire. 
 Leonard has admitted to a certain indifference to these studies, particularly his grasp of Hebrew with its strange characters and back-to-front writing (with which he grew up). 
 But it should not be taken too literally. 
 When needed, he displays a fine and intimate grasp of the Hebrew scriptures, and its rhythms and images (not least its parallelism &mdash; a form of free verse &mdash; the versets  of the Bible) suffuses his work. 
 Ressentiment  is a more precise word; he may well have been blaming God in these developing years for the loss he felt &mdash; for the anguish it gave not only to himself but also that witnessed by him in his mother and sister. 
 His early need of solitude may also suggest this; more so the story of daring to curse God in his novel, and his refusal to kiss his prayer-book when it was accidentally dropped. 
 Memories of the synagogue are also few, and its uplifting worship ceremonial almost completely absent. 
 The buildings and the scripture-readings he loved, especially its evocative music; but he was never conscious of &bquo;surrendering my heart to worship,&equo; only conscious that therein was &bquo;the tree of life, for all who follow the path.&equo; 
 Nevertheless, advance he did, and so the time came for his Bar Mitzvah , at 13 years of age, by which every Jewish boy technically becomes adult (i.e. morally responsible for his actions), a &bquo;son of the law&equo;. 
 Next to the circumcision ceremony, this is the most important event in a young Jewish boy's life, and invests him with a measure of maturity as well as a commensurate sense of responsibility. 
 It is &bquo;a non-obligatory&equo; ceremony, an unreal description to one of Leonard Cohen's background. 
 Specifically, it obliges the young person to wear the tefillin   (the symbolic &bquo;boxes&equo; of the law worn by the orthodox) when engaged in weekday prayers; to participate in the synagogue services by being &bquo;called to the law&equo; (a particular privilege and responsibility for a Cohen); to be counted as an adult in the community for the purpose of establishing a quorum by which no service (or synagogue, indeed) could be instituted. 
 So his Hebrew schooling thereby climaxed; his public participation galvanising him to accelerated study. 
 But for Leonard and his family there was special sadness at this point, for the traditional &bquo;prayer of release&equo; (from responsibility for his son) by the father was necessarily absent, a pang he could recall 40 years after the occasion. 
 So Leonard was called by name from among the congregation, arose and ascended the steps, stepped on to the special box placed for short candidates like himself, and recited in Hebrew the traditional blessing before the reading of the Torah: 
 &bquo;Praise ye the Lord to whom all praise is due. 
 Praised be the Lord who is to be praised for ever and ever. 
 Praised art Thou, O Lord our God, King of the universe, who hast chosen us from among all peoples, and hast given us Thy Torah&hellip; 
 Blessed art Thou, O Lord, who givest us the Torah.&equo; 
 The lesson itself was then read by the rabbi or cantor; Leonard taking up the concluding part &mdash; the maftir . 
 Following this, he recited the blessing set to follow the reading: 
 &bquo;Blessed art Thou, O Lord our God, King of the universe, who hast given us the Law of truth, and hast planted everlasting life in our midst. 
 Blessed art Thou, O Lord, who givest the Law.&equo; 
 The family celebration, at his grandmother's house where they frequently met, was enjoyable &mdash; to a point, but the loss of his father could only be exacerbated at such a time. 
 His secular school-work proceeded as well as that in Hebrew school; particularly well in English literature where Leonard had an excellent and sympathetic teacher by the name of Waring, &bquo;A fond, kindly man,&equo; in Leonard's phrase. 
 Here he was able to indulge a growing passion for literature, but not poetry, he recollects. 
 That seems to have been inspired by his father's excellent library, as well as the spiritual contact with him that such studying brought. 
 Prized most of all was the collection of classical poetry &mdash; from John Donne to Robert Browning &mdash; which enhanced the Hebraic and Yiddish verse that had been with him from the first. 
 Already a boy given to solitariness and a certain economy of words, he found in poetic diction (thanks, not least to Wordsworth) the most congenial vehicle for comprehension and self-expression. 
 &bquo;In the multitude of words there wants no transgression; therefore let thy words be few,&equo; is but one admonition regularly repeated in scripture and the sayings of the fathers. 
 In poetry it found  its perfect fulfilment; already, his vocation was being felt. 
 As he said to us 42 years later, &bquo;I was interested in some kind of sense, that I descended from Aaron, that I was some kind of high priest. 
 I was creating my own mythology.&equo; 
 He re-emphasised it on another occasion: &bquo;I identify with this notion&hellip; 
 Sometimes my psychic life was touched by this inspiration&hellip; 
 The super-ego was very strong.&equo; 
 And, indeed, he was already beginning to write some poetry. 
 (His mother was not a great reader. 
 Indeed, Leonard can only recall a volume of the Russian writer Gogol on her shelf, by which she presumably kept in touch with her own more distant &mdash; if painful &mdash; affiliations, though influencing Leonard, perhaps, unconsciously, with Gogol's sense of fantasy and comic genius &mdash; as well as his need to travel.) 
 Ironically, it was at this time that Ezra Pound, who had been arrested and imprisoned for treason, was examined by four prominent psychologists and judged to be insane. 
 It had a marked effect on those who read his poetry, and a few  years  later Leonard was to find himself tutored by one of Pound's most sympathetic admirers and directed to the understanding of the American's verse, somewhat to Leonard's concern, as we shall see. 
 We should not, however, think that these years were those of some frustrated novice-monk (not that Judaism has such in any case!) of solitary and sober reading from dawn till nightfall. 
 Leonard was full-blooded, physically and temperamentally, and these teenage years saw him active in a wide range of sporting interests: cycling (one of his favourite pastimes then), skiing, swimming, canoeing, sailing and ice-hockey (in which he made the school team), boxing and wrestling, though he was very little involved in the last two. 
 He did not attend any professional fights nor, unlike his later friend Irving Layton, did he get much involved in fisticuffs. 
 There was, of course, the all-important interest in the opposite sex. 
 Indeed, he has commented that the only sensation that he recalls from his youth (which did not evaporate on his coming of age) was one of persistent desire. 
 This underlines perhaps the damage done to him by his father's death, which appears to have robbed him of the memory of many of the normal sensations. 
 In this regard it is interesting to hear him comment in The Favourite Game  that &bquo;deprivation is the mother of poetry.&equo; 
 The sexual feelings were there, and were overwhelming, as they are to many teenagers. 
 They encroached upon him very early, leading to imaginative experiences very like those wild and rumbustious scenes he describes in his first novel. 
 He, like many others, was to learn the truth of the Talmud that, &bquo;our passions are like travellers: at first they make a brief stay; then they are like guests, who visit often; and then they turn into tyrants, who hold us in their power.&equo;  
 But this should not obscure from us the fact that Judaism resisted stoutly the prudery that stultified sexuality throughout the West, and always retained a high and honoured place for bodily functioning and its pleasures &mdash; as becomes indeed, a gift from God: &bquo;Man and woman are one body and one soul, (oneness reasserted, as ever), and it is this powerful union which it projects and enhances. 
 The Zohar  states that &bquo;The pleasure of cohabitation is a religious one, giving joy to the divine presence.&equo; 
 And Martin Buber (in that same tradition as Leonard's) stated that, &bquo;A husband is united with his wife in holiness, and the Shekhina  rests over them,&equo; &mdash; male and female and the glory of God combining at copulation! 
 Andrew Greeley encapsulates it well in his phrase &bquo;the sacrementality of human sexuality,&equo; to which is allied a concept we shall repeatedly discover in Leonard, of women as the &bquo;sacraments par excellence  of God's attractive love,&equo; to use another of Greeley's telling insights. 
 At a graduation ceremony from the school, on Tuesday, May 31, 1949, Leonard was chosen to offer, in Hebrew, the opening prayer (the fate of his being a Cohen!) and take part in a short presentation entitled, &bquo;What Is Torah?&equo; which went down extremely well. 
 The president was his own uncle, Horace Cohen OBE. 
 Another connection with his family's involvement was the presentation of the Lyon Cohen Memorial Medal (to Mark Bercuvitz), and the Lazarus and Fanny Cohen Memorial Medal (to Lewis Batshaw). 
 Leonard, one of seven graduates that year, was merely awarded the graduation certificate; a sign, he says of his half-hearted application. 
 for several years Leonard had attended various camps held for youngsters whose parents were able to afford to send them. 
 (He met Morton Rosengarten at the Hiawatha Camp.) 
 This year was notable in that Leonard was assessed, among other things, for his leadership potential. 
 The following is the counsellor's report on him, and demonstrates the 14-year-old's all-round interests and abilities: 
 CAMP WABI-KON: CAMPERS' REPORT NAME: Leonard Cohen. 
 Age: 14. 
 Cabin: 22. 
 Unit: 3. 
 Counsellor: Marcy Goldstein. 
 This report about your son's adjustment to group life in camp has been compiled by the members of our staff who have been working with Leonard. 
 We hope it will be of interest as well as help to you. 
 It is not meant as a criticism but as a frank report of how we think your child gets along at camp as an individual and as part of a group. 
 HEALTH: Lenny's health has been excellent all summer. 
 PERSONAL AND HYGIENE HABITS: He is neat and clean. 
 He is careful about his clothes and always appears well dressed.  
 PERSONALITY: Leonard is cheerful, intelligent, and pleasant to everyone. 
 He has a fine sense of humour, and he shows strong leadership qualities. 
 REACTION TO CAMP ROUTINE AND RESPONSIBILITIES: Lenny can be trusted to carry to completion any task given to him. 
 He follows the camp routines well, but at times he becomes disinterested and a little slow in carrying them out. 
 RELATIONSHIP TO OTHER CAMPERS: Lenny is the leader of the cabin and is looked up to by all members of the cabin. 
 He is the most popular boy in the unit and is friendly with everyone. 
 RELATIONSHIP TO CAMP STAFF: He is well liked by the entire staff and they enjoy his company just as he does theirs. 
 INTERESTS AND ABILITIES: Leonard is particularly interested in sailing and is one of the best skippers in the unit. 
 He participates enthusiastically in all the activities and is good in all of them. 
 GENERAL BEHAVIOUR: He is an excellent camper. 
 Lenny responds quickly to requests made of him both by campers and counsellors alike. 
 REMARKS AND RECOMMENDATIONS: Lenny has had an excellent summer. 
 He has had ample opportunity to exercise leadership, which he almost invariably directs along positive channels, and has improved in the various skills. 
 (August 26, 1949) 
 In addition to his leadership potential, it is interesting to note the particular emphasis on character and deportment: excellent self-imaging (in cleanliness and clothing); good social awareness (cheerful and pleasant, friendly to everyone); marked intelligence; a fine sense of humour; tendency to boredom (&bquo;disinterest&equo;); sportive, especially in sailing and skippering, but a good all-rounder; biddable. 
 Such objective reporting offsets his own recollections that he &bquo;never was a teenager,&equo; and recalling only sexual feelings. 
 (Later, he returned to one such camp to work as a counsellor himself. 
 &bquo;Sunshine Camp&equo; was a community camp for disturbed children. 
 It may not have been the origin of his interest in such people but clearly played a formative part in his development. 
 It finds fuller expression in The  Favourite Game in which he describes &bquo;the divine idiot&equo; &mdash; though not to his satisfaction, as we shall see.) 
 Leonard was fortunate in the leaders and counsellors running the camps. 
 At one of them Irving Morton, an early folk-singer and left-wing agitator taught Leonard a number of songs, using The People's Song Book . 
 Alongside him was Alfie Melderman, an official in the union/labour movement. 
 They may not have  enthused him for their particular brand of political idealism, but they certainly sowed seeds of great potential musically. 
 For some time Leonard had been listening to the music of the day, which he shared with his mother and sister. 
 He also recalls his father's love of Sir Harry Lauder's songs and those of Gilbert and Sullivan &mdash; important aspects of an otherwise sombre man. 
 Their Jewish inheritance apart (and no serious understanding of his music interests can afford not to give this a very high place, as we shall see), was formed by such artists as Eddie Fisher, Gordon Jenkins, Vaughan Monroe, Patti Page, Dinah Shore, Frank Sinatra, Tony Bennett and Johnny Ray, who followed in the wake of the big bands. 
 &bquo;Teenage music&equo; had not yet arrived, and what there was was essentially for adults, in the form of country and western and rhythm and blues; jazz was popular, of course, in some circles, but for the rest it was this or classical music, which Leonard also enjoyed, and waltzes. 
 For the opening years of the sixth decade &bquo;R&amp;B was King&equo; &mdash; thanks, not least, to the popularity it had enjoyed among the troops. 
 This soon gave rise to such names as Hank Ballard And The Midnighters, Georgie Gibbs, The Clovers, Ruth Brown, Joe Hill and, not least, Leonard's idol of many years, Ray Charles. 
 Leonard himself was enthused to make his own music, an inspiration which developed from being induced to learn the piano as a young boy with Miss McDougall, in which he said that neither he nor his sister made any headway. 
 He had, however, a natural ability with a penny-whistle, of which he had a great number, one of which he always carried in his pocket. 
 Much as poetry was becoming a part of him, his most natural form of self-expression, and the one that reached him first, was music; side-by-side they were to advance with him throughout his developing days and early professional life. 
 One of his particular enjoyments at camp was the log-fire singing, whose ebullience and rhythms remain with him even today, many of them drawn from The People's Song Book . 
 By this time the guitar had made its popular impact, and in just five  years  time it would be considered virtually the  instrument of musical expression. 
 On one of his walks through Murray Park (now King George VI Park) he encountered a young Hispanic who was playing the guitar to himself. 
 Leonard talked him into giving him a lesson. 
 It went well, as did the second and the third lessons. 
 Leonard quickly and enthusiastically learned the rudiments of the instrument, those first chords basic to its mastery. 
 On the appointed time for his fourth, however, his young instructor failed to turn up. 
 More concerned that this reflected on his own abilities than his tutor's zest, Leonard telephoned his residence at Bowdy House, in the poorer district of Montreal. 
 To his horror he found that the young boy had hanged  himself in a moment of despair. 
 For the second time in his life the icy fingers of death pierced his innermost self. 
 Life was teaching him its grim realities &mdash; the hard and close way. 
 Yet there were bright moments, and the overall feelings in his life were those of contentment and growing confidence. 
 One of these showed itself in his prowess as a teenage hypnotist. 
 &bquo;I could get anyone under the spell,&equo; he says, adding that he had hypnotised their maid (as Breavman had in The Favourite Game ) and feared that he had driven her insane by it! 
 Another was that he had been elected to the Students' Council at his school, Westmount High, and to its Board of Publishers. 
 His literary prowess was now enforcing itself upon him with the urgency of a destiny, as with all true writers, &bquo;born, not made&equo;. 
 It had been given particular poetic stimulation a few months earlier when, at 15, and musing in a second-hand bookshop in the city, he had come across a book of poetry by the Spanish poet, Federico Gar&ccedil;ia Lorca, a book he has carried with him ever since, as Manzano records. 
 Leonard was to say later, &bquo;Lorca ruined my life!&equo; 
 The part which caught his eye so dramatically that day was in the Spaniard's great work &bquo;Divan del Tamarit&equo; (1936, quoted from The Selected Poems of Federico Gar&ccedil;ia Lorca , Ed. 
 Francisco Garcia Lorca, New Directions publishing Corporation, pp 169): 
 Through the arch of Elvira (the wife of Don Juan) 
 I'm going to see you pass, 
 to feel your thighs 
 and begin weeping. 
 Brought up, as Leonard was, to admire the Romantics and their charming, reliable, amiable world-view, their delight in nature, not least man's own nature which had an organic relationship with the world by which sensibility and feeling &mdash; frequently emphasised as a pleasure-principle, paved the way for his being catapulted into the &bquo;surreal&equo; world of the Spanish writer. 
 Not that we should over-emphasise Lorca's surrealism. 
 He was as Romantic as any man of his time, and more so than most; one ideally suited to Leonard's own deeply Romantic (and romantic) strains &mdash; imagists both, rather than surrealists. 
 If the hallmark of the Romantics was &bquo;imagination&equo;, that of the Imagists was &bquo;verbal concentration generating energy&equo;; they shared both, and were to demonstrate both tirelessly. 
 Lorca's attempts at surrealism issued in response to his friend Salvador Dali's savage criticisms of his lack of modernity in his Gypsy Ballads  (&equo; Bound hand and feet to the old poetry,&equo; as Dali commented). 
 They never quite came off. 
 They merited John Ash's epithet &bquo;old-fashioned modernism,&equo; and most of all Jaim Manrique's judgement, that the secret of Lorca's appeal  is nostalgia : &bquo;His art does not deepen as we grow older!&equo; he said, another trait the Canadian shared with the Spaniard. 
 His brother, Francisco Gar&ccedil;ia Lorca, has very finely defined the canciones , one of the most notable poetic forms used by Lorca, as a lyric in which: the poet checks his first flights in order to achieve greater purification&hellip; 
 The atmosphere of transcendental romantic sensibility gives way to fleeting states of mind, momentary sensations, or a disinterested humour, often imbued with a note of elegiac melancholy. 
 Moreover, Lorca influenced Leonard's world-view too; his &bquo;transcendental and far-reaching&equo; ideas about life touched him: &bquo;Lorca changed my way of being and thinking radically,&equo; he told a Spanish journalist. 
 &bquo;His books taught me that poetry can be pure and profound, and at the same time popular.&equo; 
 This emphasis on people &mdash; the populace &mdash; has the ring of truth about it. 
 It was part of &bquo;the patrician Jew's&equo; mental furniture (without compromising his special status, to be sure). 
 It has an immensely old lineage, not merely in Alcuin's famous vox populi, vox dei  (&bquo;the voice of the people is the voice of God&equo;), but in Jewish societal awareness going back beyond Moses to Hammurabi. 
 It touched Lorca to the point that he reduced his poetry to a secondary status, concentrating on theatrical communication as a better means of getting his message over. 
 (He even ran a government-sponsored travelling company, serving mainly the peasants in outlying areas.) 
 We shall see Leonard likewise being &bquo;diverted&equo; from pure poetic concentration in order to achieve maximum hearing. 
 Another aspect may well be Lorca's rejection of industrialisation &mdash; a Romantic hangover, no doubt! &mdash; which appears in Leonard's oscillation in his late teens between commerce and art. 
 Yet another is Lorca's love of the city, a curious contradiction of his anti-industrialism, which only comes out explicitly in Leonard's devotion to Montreal, though he soon became snared by New York, London, Paris, Athens and Los Angeles, to name but a few of his favourite cities. 
 All this is of great significance for exploring Leonard's characteristics, for what was natural to Leonard's incipient viewpoint and versification now found stimulating and corroborative encouragement. 
 The fact that Leonard was influenced so deeply by Divan del Tamarir  is very suggestive, for it is one of the types of poems known as gacela  (the other is casida ), a short-rhymed fixed verse-form in Arabic poetry. 
 It naturally shares much with its literary cousin, Hebrew poetry, on which Leonard had been raised from his earliest days. 
 Another aspect, quite apart from this shared verse-form and linguistic usage, is the natural hyperbole endemic to it, which is but a step away from the &bquo;surrealist&equo; usage of language that Lorca essayed. 
 Further, his Catholicism also deeply influenced, if subconsciously, Leonard's own awareness of it in  Catholic Montreal. 
 As he said of it much later, &bquo;We who belong to the city have never left the Church. 
 The Jews are in The Church as they are in the snow&hellip; 
 Every style in Montreal is the style of The Church&hellip;&equo; 
 Further, Lorca, a gifted painter and pianist, had little time for the academic qua academe . 
 Although educated at the universities of Granada and Madrid, he distrusted purely intellectual emphases, and poured scorn on the idea of the Muses &mdash; albeit the most lovable and influential of creatures! 
 Lorca stood for something else &mdash; for life and the day-today dynamic of men and women. 
 He had returned from a sojourn in New York to aid his oppressed people in the Spanish civil war, in which he lost his life just over one year after Leonard was born. 
 (Others have said that his death was due to his homosexuality. 
 Interestingly, Lorca was much more influenced by Walt Whitman, also a homosexual, than T.S. 
 Eliot, though he knew The Waste Land  well.) 
 In seeking to grasp this dynamic, and portray it, he had become enthused with the duende , the spirit unleashed by the flamenco &mdash; music and dance &mdash; which he believed to be the dynamic of true art and artistic expression: &bquo;Repel the angel, kick out the muse,&equo;, he was wont to exclaim; arguing that artists must work &bquo;from the gut,&equo; with the conviction and intensity that the expression exudes; allowing the life-force it releases to flow &mdash; torrentially, vividly, dramatically; as in the flamenco  itself. 
 It was precisely this spirit-this agitation against the staid and the genteel &mdash; which Leonard had perceived in the guitar-playing of his late youthful instructor, whose demise had the intensity of surreal life. 
 It was to hound and hasten Leonard's waking thoughts, eliminate any residual interest he may have possessed in mere intellectual commitment, and open to him the stark reality of life downtown. 
 from now on he was an enthusiastic convert; a propagandist, indeed. 
 WORD AS DISCOVERY 
 Poetry is images wrapped up in rhythm. 
 Sir Stephen Spender 
 The poem is the place where occasions are exhausted, where opportunities are used up. 
 Richard Howard 
 &bquo;I didn't kill myself when things went wrong 
 I didn't turn 
 to drugs or teaching 
 I tried to sleep 
 but when I couldn't sleep 
 I learned to write 
 I learned to write 
 what might be read 
 on nights like this 
 by one like me.&equo; 
 Leonard Cohen    
 The Emergence of a Poet 
 September 21, 1951 was a propitious day in Leonard's life. 
 It was his 17th birthday, when family affection towards him was especially warm and confident and feelings of young manhood were rife. 
 It was also registration day at McGill University, which marked a particular and new phase in his early life &mdash; in one sense, a new independence. 
 So it was that a bold, if boyish, hand completed the form; but not over carefully! 
 He omitted, as he was wont to do, his middle name, Norman; he put the present year down for his date of birth, not 1934; and instead of entering &bquo;Canadian&equo; for his parents' and his own nationality, he entered &bquo;Jewish&equo;. 
 (This was done by those Jews who wished to make a Zionistic point, but it was not so shared by Leonard or his family.) 
 Other aspects of his answers are equally interesting: he admits to not having won any prizes or scholarships, having apparently settled for doing what was required &mdash; that, and no more! 
 He mentions his presidency of the Student Council, and his chairmanship of &bquo;Student Productions&equo;; as well as an interest in debating &bquo;current events&equo;. 
 He declined to add anything in the column for &bquo;Other personal information&equo;. 
 He also gave his mother's new name, as she had recently remarried. 
 (To both Leonard's and his mother's regret, sadly; another of those alienating-reconciling events which seem to have been characteristic of this family.) 
 As named relatives or friends, he listed his ever-caring grandmother, Mrs Lyon Cohen, resident at the prestigious Haddon Hall, on Sherbrooke Street, and his uncles Norman Friedman and Horace Cohen. 
 Thus completed, he signed the form &bquo;accepting and submitting himself to the statutes, rules, regulations and ordinances of McGill University and of the Faculty or Faculties in which I am registered, and to any amendments thereto which may be made while I am a student of the university and I promise to observe the same.&equo;  
 It was a momentous step for him in the awesome institution, which had received its Royal Charter from George IV exactly 130 years previously, thus antedating the federation. 
 The land, formerly the Burnside place estate, and a monetary gift of &pound;10,000, had been bequeathed to the city by one James McGill, a fur-trader and noted merchant. 
 It took a further eight years before classes got under way, and then only in medicine, and it was not till well into the 1850s that it became really established. 
 It prospered and expanded under the principalship of Sir William Dawson; by the time he had completed 38 years as Principal (1855&ndash;1893) the student body had risen from 100 to over 1000, and Dawson had had the satisfaction of seeing great strides made in both the building programme and the various curricula &mdash; not least in his own scientific fields. 
 As well as academic achievements, McGill was noted for originating two major sports: ice hockey, in 1875, largely from the rules written by J.G.A. Creighton; and a species of rugby which was played by the citizens and soldiers (for Montreal had remained a garrison town) as well as the students. 
 A McGill team introduced it to Harvard University in 1874, which marked the formal birth of &bquo;football&equo;. 
 Montrealers are not inclined to overlook their influence on Harvard! 
 To this broadly-based academic institute &mdash; arts and science; intellectual and physical prowess &mdash; Leonard now set his hand. 
 His entrance examination, three months earlier, had shown a student of above-average ability, whose overall marks averaged 74.1 per cent, tantamount to a Second Class Honours, called Distinction at McGill. 
 Curiously, his lowest mark was in English Literature (a mere 57 per cent), though in Composition he achieved 69 per cent. 
 His performance was better in French, where he obtained 71 per cent and 75 per cent in the grammatical and oral examinations respectively. 
 Physics realised 67 per cent; History a promising 77 per cent; and Mathematics was strongest of all, with an average of 77 per cent over three subjects: algebra I and II at 72 per cent and 80 per cent, geometry at 86 per cent and trigonometry at 70 per cent; (he admitted to us that he had opted for the latter at school, because it enabled him to evade Latin!). 
 In Chemistry he obtained a splendid 84 per cent. 
 Had vocation advisors been around they would doubtless have recommended a commercial future on the scientific side. 
 Certainly he came under such guidance from within his family which clashed with his own predilections, for his varsity life seems to have been plagued by vocational uncertainty and more than a touch of its weakening indifference. 
 At any rate, they are the best marks that were to appear on his performance schedule over the next four years, when his average ran at 56.4 per cent. 
 In his own beloved English, it was always higher, averaging 71.3 per cent in the three years he offered the  subject; French, which was only offered in his first year produced a convincing 75 per cent; and Economics, offered in two years, 62 per cent. 
 Philosophy, at 70 per cent, was significant; but he barely squeezed by in Latin, taking a refusal at his second attempt and attaining a mere &bquo;pass&equo; at the repeat stage (thanks, no doubt, to his past opting out, which necessitated his taking Latin from scratch at university). 
 Zoology, the joker in his pack, offered in his final year, also achieved 62 per cent. 
 Perhaps the choice was his way of declaring his consuming interest in life , not learning, which was becoming an obsession. 
 Readers of The  Favourite Game will remember Breavman dissecting a frog, which arose out of such early experiences; they will also remember his tearing up an economics textbook outside a bank on Sherbrooke Street &mdash; another reaction to the struggles and disinterest he later recalled. 
 The choices he made, and the way his achievements oscillated, show a decided lack of conviction, or perhaps of direction, in his thinking. 
 That the ability was there is beyond question. 
 And his third year First Class results (known at McGill as &bquo;Great Distinction&equo;) in English demonstrate where his heart truly lay, as did his obtaining the coveted Chester Macnaughton Prize for &bquo;Creative Writing&equo; in 1955; as well as the Peterson Memorial Prize in literature. 
 He recalled that Ian Duthie, a graduate of Edinburgh University, -was one of his tutors in &bquo;English 101&equo; (a compulsory subject), who provided interesting connections with his father's accent and the general Scottishness of Westmount. 
 Behind the indecision lay a youth torn in one direction by the family business, not least perhaps his father's shadow hanging over him; and the preferences of his mind and ever prolific imagination in the other. 
 Accordingly, he read arts in his first year; commerce (which included accounting, commercial law, political science and a couple of doses of mathematics) in his second; arts (though strangely retaining political science) for his third and fourth years, to which was added zoology. 
 The choices are both a reflection of his inner confusion, and a statement of his determination to let his curiosity run wherever it would - and that long before &bquo;mixed&equo; courses were popular. 
 The results confirm that he could have done very much better, but his mind was partly elsewhere, ever active, ever engaged, ever busy. 
 But not in his set books! 
 Still less at lectures which, Rosengarten recalled they avoided on a regular basis. 
 He was not single-minded in the manner preferred by academe ; scholarship per se  was not going to be his m&eacute;tier. 
 In fact, if truth be told, he despised the breed. 
 His attitude reminds one of Southey's dictum, &bquo;Your true lover of literature is never fastidious.&equo; 
 There is a point here of immense importance for the understanding of Leonard which he shares with Layton (who preferred to be regarded as a poet-prophet in the Hebrew tradition). 
 It lay along the  lines of Layton's understanding of the poetic function  &bquo;which exists somewhere between fact and imagination,&equo; as Eli Mandel said of him. 
 Not pure fact, not meretricious research, which observes and &bquo;tames&equo; the insightful-prophetic thrust; not &bquo;mere&equo; imagination or mental excitement &mdash; but the fruitful intercourse between the two, in an artistic equilibrium. 
 Leonard could be fastidious to the nth degree in completing his own work &mdash; he has always said that he works &bquo;one word at a time,&equo; and can spend months, even years, in adding finesse to it; he is nevertheless dismissive of anything approaching scholarly exactitude, still more so pedantry. 
 It is not clear where this comes from. 
 There is certainly an element which highly values the proprieties of artistic freedom: a work of art must be a work of free spirit, untrammelled by rules and regulations, wherein absolute consistency &mdash; or conformity of any sort &mdash; is out of place. 
 But there also seems to be a more personal element, too. 
 In The  Favourite Game he turns on those who produce such work in a wholly negative way. 
 Of Breavman (his alter ego) he states, &bquo;He didn't know why he hated the careful diagrams and coloured plates. 
 We do. 
 It was to scorn the world of detail, information, precision, all the false knowledge which cannot intrude on decay.&equo; 
 Whether this is the result of oppressive criticism by his school-teachers or family, or whether it comes from a reaction to the finer-than-fine scholarship visible in some branches of Judaism (which counts letters and finds significance in the smallest linguistic minutiae), is not certain. 
 But it is there, and grew with the passage of time. 
 (The &bquo;on decay&equo; aspect is significant, encapsulating a cynical view of life, not least in the shattered security resulting from his father's death.) 
 Nevertheless, he did not go to university unwillingly. 
 He was keen for success and learning on his own terms, and to that he now set his face. 
 Two names in the English department stood out especially: Professors Hugh MacLennan and Louis Dudek. 
 The former was known, albeit chiefly in Canada, as a novelist of distinction, whose The  Two Solitudes won for its author fame and comment throughout the land. 
 It is a brilliant, evocative and inspiring story of the clash of the two founding cultures of modern Canada &mdash; the two solitudes &mdash; and was to have a telling significance educationally and politically. 
 (When Leonard came to write his second novel, he paid MacLennan the finest compliment of all &mdash; and the riskiest &mdash; by imitating his theme, as we shall see.) 
 Professor Dudek's name was familiar to Leonard beyond the academic sphere, in the (to him) much more important and fascinating area of poetry, in which Leonard was now inextricably enmeshed. 
 Determined to follow his own star, he was drawn to his classes in Canadian Literature (which Dudek did hand-in-hand with MacLennan); and the Great Writers of Europe (from 1850 till the present); as well as  Poetry of the 20th Century (in particular that of W.B. Yeats, T.S. 
 Eliot, Robert Frost, Ezra Pound, W.H. Auden and Dylan Thomas). 
 He also took courses in Continental, European and American Drama (from Ibsen to the present day); and English Prose from Francis Bacon to the Present (which included both fiction and non-fiction). 
 He brought these to a fitting conclusion by doing the Advanced Course in Creative Writing, which was open only to students selected on merit. 
 Significantly, Leonard did not enter for the &bquo;Art Of Poetry&equo; course, a study of its forms and techniques under Professor Dudek. 
 That for a practising poet, as Leonard had now become, was unnecessary! 
 The period between 1939 to 1949 has been called the most productive and significant period in Canadian letters to date, which matches the &bquo;10 Lost Years&equo; of the post-Depression period exactly. 
 Leonard was fortunate to come to it when he did, for he was able to enter into the fruits and the confidence born of it, as well as classical English literature. 
 If, under Hugh MacLennan, he was able to form his judgment and turn his phrases under the eye of a skilful novelist, in Louis Dudek's adroit hands he was able to fashion and test his poetic acumen to the full; both were to be of absorbing interest to him. 
 Moreover, Dudek's scholarship was of a more penetrating kind than anything under which Leonard had yet sat, or was to sit, as became that of a Doctor of Letters from Columbia University. 
 He was a highly reputable and incisive critic of art and culture as well as literature; a bilinguist of note, and &mdash; more important than all those! &mdash; a poet of rare accomplishment; a poet's poet. 
 He was also a disciple of Ezra Pound, more (one suspects) because Pound was &bquo;the most controversial, dynamic and stimulating figure in modern literature,&equo; than for personal rapport  between the two men. 
 Pound was a bohemian figure, despite his Quaker origins, who espoused an anti-credit economic philosophy which thrust him into anti-Semitism. 
 Leonard found this hard to stomach, and frequently expressed himself vehemently against his professor's defences of the founder of Imagism (which advocated free rhythm as well as concreteness of expression in poetry); and against his disdainful, if teasing, comments of those who came from Westmount. 
 Nevertheless, Leonard was to learn much from the Pennsylvanian, who helped to inspire his interest in Eastern thought, not least through his translations of the Chinese poet Li Po. 
 &bquo;I love Pound,&equo; Leonard said to us late one afternoon. 
 &bquo;There are still lines that resound in my mind. 
 You cannot overlook his craft. 
 But he is hard to understand!&equo; 
 The reading-list to which Leonard's mind was directed was broad and enticing. 
 It is worth looking at, for from it sprang his fund of knowledge along with the all-important Jewish scriptures and his family's experiences with them in eastern Europe. 
 The formidable  recommended reading-list adds a proviso: &bquo;There is no list of minimum readings. 
 You are responsible for a field. 
 This list and its two supplements, far from setting limits, offers suggestions.&equo; 
 Here is that list printed as given. 
 Scant consideration was given to getting the authors' names or initials, or even their book titles, correct!):    
 This is a formidable range, containing no less than 143 titled works; the poems, stories, prefaces and essays of 29 authors; and 41 works of criticism or related literature. 
 Moreover, in his third year, in which he read modern, European and American drama, there were a further 44 works from 20 authors not included in the above list; some in French! 
 Omitting his radical change of direction (i.e. of subject) in his second year, it represents a demand of surrealist proportions, especially when one considers that alongside these he was reading French, Latin, Mathematics, Philosophy and History. 
 His task, one of unending and heady excitement, was now well and truly under way! 
 Little wonder that he sometimes gave the impression of inattentiveness in class; he was inebriated in a world of letters, engulfed by an avalanche of ideas and images, forms and metres, essays and critiques: a fast-changing, provocative kaleidoscope which took his already well-stocked and fertile mind to fresh heights. 
 Paradise it was not; but at least it resembled something like its antechamber. 
 He plunged himself into all this and more, avidly reading everything that came his way; especially poetry, and not least Spanish, Chinese and Japanese poets in translation, but chiefly that of Federico Gar&ccedil;ia Lorca and W.B. Yeats, of whom he mused, &bquo;I loved Yeats; his connections (such an important code-word with Leonard!) his rhythms.&equo; 
 A single prose piece, written early in his course, has survived the fates of time. 
 It represents one of his assignations. 
 More importantly, it reflects his laconic style, and what was going on under the surface: 
 X died last Sunday. 
 The event had absolutely no emotional or intellectual effect on me. 
 In fact I don't give a damn. 
 Neither do you. 
 Neither do the 30 odd thousand people who read the Gazette on March 11. 
 His family probably cares (no one to support them) but very few others. 
 Here was a fellow human, Canadian, and Montrealer who went to the same movies and read the same papers as you or I. 1.) 
 He rode beside you in the street car and complained about the traffic and the weather with you. 
 The eyes of his beloved wife, are tear-reddened (sic) and she has come to the awful realisation of a gap in her waning life which will never be filled. 
 She had always sworn to herself that she would never impose on her daughter's marriage 2.) but she knows now that she cannot possibly decline an invitation to spend the rest of her days at her son-in-law's house. 
 It sounds like a soap opera but so does any  tradgedy  (!) that happens to real people. 
 Death is a  tradgedy  (!) and whether it strikes at an eight-year-old  youngster 3.) or a senile old man, a scar is always left on one 4.) of the survivors &mdash; a scar that does not heal quickly. 
 We still don't give a damn that X died last Sunday. 
 I listen to the World Federalists and the Communists talk about One World and The Brotherhood of Man and how much they are doing to bring them about. 
 They uphold the feasibility (!) of two billion people, diverse in language, colour, nationality and religion, living together in harmony. 
 And yet, none of them, who have so much in common with X, who have so much regard for their fellow man, was at the funeral this afternoon. 
 Neither was I. 
 It is curious that he should select such a subject for his essay, drawn from a newspaper announcement of a man's death. 
 We also have the comments of his tutor, Ian Duthie, on the piece, which shows that he found it curious, too. 
 Across the top he has written, &bquo;This verges on being in poor taste, but makes a twist and escapes.&equo; 
 He drew attention to the three spelling mistakes Leonard manages to include in so short a piece, marked by (!), and at the points we enumerate offers the following marginal comments: 1.) 
 &bquo;Be concrete&equo;. 
 2.) 
 No &bquo;comment&equo; here actually. 
 Merely a questioning underline, presumably to emphasise the looseness of the phrase. 
 3.) 
 &bquo;Boy&equo; is suggested in place of &bquo;youngster&equo;. 
 4.) 
 &bquo;Why necessarily one?&equo; 
 Why this preoccupation with death (if such a word is allowable on the evidence of but one piece)? 
 There must have been several dozen possible suggestions for an essay from that paper &mdash; political, industrial, military (the Korean war was still ongoing), in sport or arts, etc. etc. 
 He chooses death and bereavement! 
 On which he makes two statements: first, that we are unmoved by it; second, that it is a tragedy, especially to the eight-year-old  son. 
 (Where did he get that information from?) 
 But the second is surely contradicted by the first; especially if one adds to it the sympathetic view he evinces of the widow's plight. 
 It is difficult to avoid the feeling that this, one of his first university essays, is purely subjective. 
 He is  that eight-year-old boy. 
 He knows how it feels to lose a father at a tender age. 
 Moreover, &bquo;a scar is always left on one  of the survivors.&equo; 
 The others, to his way of thinking, got away more lightly. 
 He suffers still, even if the widow's life is said to be &bquo;waning&equo;, her eyes &bquo;tear-reddened&equo;, her freedom blighted &mdash; along with her happiness. 
 The daughter, apparently, had no feelings; she did not come into the picture, as elder sisters frequently do not. 
 The real situation was between the widow and the youngster who was effectively older than a boy, in feeling and reaction at least. 
 It was &bquo;a scar that does not heal  quickly.&equo; 
 He knows; his own &mdash; now of eight or nine years, was still fresh, still hurting. 
 The piece is essentially about that. 
 It proclaims that he does care. 
 Moreover, he is angry that the rest of us &mdash; including the so-called caring brotherhood of World Federalists and Communists &mdash; do not. 
 He was not there, at X's funeral. 
 But could he have been? 
 Would it not have been too painful, not least having to watch another youngster take his first steps into the fatherless state? 
 X died in March, but it was close enough for the connection that Eliot wrote of in The Waste Land : 
 April is the cruelest month, breeding 
 Lilacs out of the dead land, mixing 
 Memory and desire, stirring 
 Dull roots with spring rain. 
 Things were stirring, all right, at his roots not least. 
 Stirring at these roots in a different way was his friend of eight or nine years, Morton Rosengarten. 
 One year older than Leonard, he went through the varying experiences of adolescence with him, sharing not least Leonard's musical interest (Morton played both the banjo and the trombone), as well as a variety of pastimes and a healthy interest in the fairer sex. 
 Unlike Leonard, he had very little interest in the synagogue and broke from its traditions much more decisively, finding Leonard's continuance somewhat irritating. 
 (&bquo;Krantz&equo; is modelled on Rosengarten in The Favourite Game , though highly fictionalised.) 
 He was always impressed with Leonard's room, which he found to resemble more a study than a youth's bedroom &mdash; already the style was evident. 
 In particular he remembers the very smart set of poetry classics, and noted his friend's compulsive reading of them. 
 Indifferent student Leonard might have been formally, he was nevertheless already showing those precocious marks of the litt&eacute;rateur , &bquo;always an ideas man,&equo; as Rosengarten commented. 
 Leonard also had a little room in the basement in which a piano was kept, where they spent much time together. 
 But he had become &bquo;addicted&equo; to the guitar, which drove Morton &bquo;crazy&equo; &mdash; for it went everywhere with them, and was played incessantly. 
 Neither of them had pure academic interests. 
 At school they shared truancy escapades, which developed a more interesting potential once they had matriculated. 
 Rosengarten's forte  lay in the fine arts, painting and sculpture in particular, to which he committed himself at McGill ahead of Leonard. 
 Part of his spare time was taken up with the marching band of the university, but much of it was given to boisterous evenings drinking and singing with his companion &mdash; always with a view to winning the girls' eyes and hearts. 
 Some of these escapades upset Mrs Cohen, who was given to &bquo;flying off the handle,&equo; in Rosengarten's phrase. 
 And she would stay  off it for days on end. 
 Young as he was, he could see the conflict she evidenced as an &bquo;off-the-boat Russian&equo; with the rest of Leonard's &bquo;classy&equo; family. 
 Their adventures made life no easier for her. 
 But Leonard himself was smitten, he says, by his family's past, by its name and meaning. 
 He used to drive his cousins &bquo;crazy&equo; with its &bquo;mythology&equo;. 
 Like his mother, Leonard was even then subject to alternating highs and lows, which added spice to their friendship. 
 Morton saw that Leonard and Mrs Cohen were very close, and nothing emphasised this more than her willingness to take them and their friends out for meals, especially to a favourite Greek restaurant where she would be the life of the party, not least in singing, and encouraged by good wine which the restaurateur would ply them with in order to get the mood of the evening going. 
 At other times she would refuse to let Rosengarten in the house, especially if Leonard had had a late night out. 
 And woe betide both of them if Leonard failed to phone her if he decided to stay out and thereby wasted the food! 
 These were the high days of &bquo;square-dancing&equo;. 
 Chief of the musicians in that genre were Burl Ives and The Weavers. 
 In &bquo;Goodnight Irene&equo;, the latter had an outstanding hit, a key point in the development from traditional folk to modern in 1950. 
 The musicians' ability to involve their listeners &mdash; they worked mainly in sub-concert settings (campuses, churches, libraries and union halls) matched their left-wing accents, a major aspect of the peoples' song movement. 
 (Their Peoples'  Song Books were released in two volumes. 
 They even published pamphlets of a political nature.) 
 Many of the songs, perforce, had to deal with injustice and exploitation, and it was their effective and social melancholia that inspired Rosengarten and Leonard. 
 They still have good memories of The Weavers playing together in concert &mdash; before Pete Seeger quit in the wake of Decca's dropping them for their politicking &mdash; a symptom of McCarthyism, then gathering pace. 
 Happily, they were contracted by Folkways Records, with which Leonard himself became involved later. 
 But perhaps the biggest thing in popular music took place in 1948 when the LP was introduced; an innovation of immense importance for the industry and public alike, and not least for Leonard who set about acquiring an enviable collection. 
 Rosengarten was at McGill for Leonard's first two years or so, and they ran the Fraternity together. 
 There is an &bquo;&eacute;litist thread&equo; in such places, and joining was by oligarchic selection and specific invitation, followed by a suitably off-beat initiation. 
 Their natural rebelliousness achieved its heights now, not least in their violation of the traditional rules, their attempts to undermine the institution by radical policies, their attempts to breach the system. 
 They invited people whose backgrounds were very different to join this &bquo;high class Jewish  fraternity,&equo; and tried to run it as a continuous party. 
 They even instituted a rule of drinking in front of the Fraternity House, for which Leonard was impeached! 
 And he conducted its meetings to the sound of his guitar, singing to his fellow-students suitable &mdash; and unsuitable! &mdash; songs and ditties. 
 (One of them was &bquo;Sunshine 1950 Will Be Nifty&equo;; another was &bquo;Racing With The Moon&equo;.) 
 Once a girl was smuggled into the proceedings in her boyfriend's overcoat. 
 Removing the coat revealed her to be completely naked, which finally put the cat among the pigeons: they were banished! 
 All this coincided with the start of the coffee-shop movement, and many opened in Montreal. 
 The Caf&eacute; Andr&eacute;  was one such place, near to the Students' Union building. 
 They called it The Shrine &mdash; even then secular sanctity was in vogue! 
 It was situated in an old house, a three-storey building which the students and others had the run of, more or less. 
 One of its rooms was given over to chess-playing, a pastime enjoyed by Rosengarten and Leonard. 
 After the second or third week of starting his course, Leonard asked to speak to Professor Dudek, and showed him some of his own poetry. 
 He was aware that the professor was deeply involved in the burgeoning poetry movement of Canada, chiefly in the form of &bquo;the little books and magazines&equo; which were in the van of the movement. 
 Dudek was surprised at the request; it was not a course designed to deal with such matters. 
 He consented to talk and to look at Leonard's work. 
 It moved him not at all. 
 It was merely interesting, somewhat pedestrian; not a promising start. 
 Two weeks later the same thing happened. 
 Dudek flicked over the pages, found them to be a little better, but still somewhat hum-drum. 
 Then his eye chanced on a sheet headed &bquo;The Sparrows&equo;. 
 The first lines gripped him; as did the next verse; and then the whole poem. 
 This was the real thing! 
 This was poetry ! 
 A discovery had been made. 
 By this time they had left the classroom and were walking down one of the long, high-ceilinged corridors of the Faculty building. 
 &bquo;Kneel down,&equo; commanded the professor. 
 Startled, his young student did so. 
 Using his rolled-up manuscript, Dudek dubbed Leonard. 
 &bquo;Arise,&equo; he commanded. 
 &bquo;You are a poet. 
 I have knighted you. 
 Now you are one of us.&equo; 
 There was no turning-back after such an experience. 
 The poet was commissioned. 
 Here is what Leonard wrote, which set the shape of his life (later published in Let Us Compare Mythologies , pp 26): 
 The Sparrows 
 &bquo;Catching winter in their carved nostrils the traitor birds have deserted us, leaving only the dullest brown sparrows for spring negotiations.  
 I told you we were fools 
 to have them in our games, 
 but you replied: 
 They are only wind-up birds 
 who strut on scarlet feet 
 so hopelessly far 
 from our curled fingers. 
 I had moved to warn you, 
 but you only adjusted your hair 
 and ventured: 
 Their wings are made of glass and gold and we are fortunate 
 not to hear them splintering 
 against the sun. 
 Now the hollow nests 
 sit like tumors or petrified blossoms between the wire branches 
 and you, an innocent scientist, 
 question me on these brown sparrows: 
 whether we should plant our yards with breadcrumbs 
 or mark them with the black, persistent crows 
 whom we hate and stone. 
 But what shall I tell you of migrations? 
 When in this empty say 
 the precise ghosts of departed summer birds 
 still trace old signs; 
 or of desperate flights? 
 when the dimmest flutter of a coloured wing 
 excites all our favourite streets 
 to delight the imaginary spring. 
 Another influence &mdash; arguably of even greater influence &mdash; burst upon him at this time, in the form of Irving Layton, the enfant terrible  of Canadian poetry then a local school-teacher, who was invited to participate in a poetry workshop on the campus, and did so with great &eacute;lan. 
 In those early days Layton had much in common with Dudek, not least their ability to poke fun at the richer districts of Montreal Jewry &mdash; including Westmount, which greatly irritated Leonard. 
 Ironically, they both live there now; and Leonard does not, having opted for their former, downtown, districts! 
 Leonard was aware of Layton before this, of course. 
 He had published his first book of poetry, Here And Now , in 1946; his second, Now Is The Place , in 1948 &mdash; shortly before Leonard chanced on Lorca's poetry. 
 Leonard had even met him briefly in 1949, but this meeting at McGill was the one which quickly developed into a strong and mutual respect, a lifelong friendship. 
  Irving Layton is not one to be lost in a crowd. 
 Though short, he stands head and shoulders above most. 
 He is one of those characters whose personality is somehow several sizes too large. 
 He comes across in large, energetic, engulfing, captivating waves, at once friendly and disturbing. 
 Poetry in motion. 
 And what poetry! 
 It is larger than life, more real than truth, dramatic and daring, perceptive and flowing, and, significantly, full of paradox and ambiguity. 
 Above all &mdash; like the duende  itself &mdash; he works &bquo;from the gut&equo; and to the gut. 
 Perhaps more than any other man in Canada, he has put poetry on the map &mdash; at the centre, indeed; and fought and argued and worked demoniacally to preserve it there. 
 His poetry &mdash; there are now 50 books of it, no less &mdash; comes in all shapes and sizes, all colours and sounds, except the muted. 
 Leonard later wrote of him: 
 &hellip; you finally came in, 
 more furious than any Canadian poet&hellip; 
 He has been so occupied since before his first book was published; in season and out of season, through thick and thin, and always with the certitude that his views, his perceptions, would prevail: a catalyst and an agitator of the first order. 
 Born in Romania (and thus sharing part of Leonard's eastern European background), transferred by his parents to Canada in the harsh years of the early century, he represents, perhaps more than any other, not the genteel &bquo;English&equo; background common to many of his fellow-workers, but a rough, raw Canadian view that is intensely patriotic, proletarian, passionate and pure. 
 If some (such as F.R. Scott, A.M. Klein or P.K. Page) represent the priestly caste, Layton represents the prophetic &mdash; in language and manner, in word and symbol. 
 And as with all true prophets, he respects no man, nor spares any. 
 One of Layton's traits, as Leonard was at pains to emphasise, was to distinguish between priest and prophet; and Layton is not slow to emphasise the historic conflict between both offices. 
 In poetry, as in life, Layton is held captive to his own Muse, no subject being too sacred nor too delicate especially the previously &bquo;taboo&equo; ones of violence, cruelty, politics and sex. 
 All have been exposed to his scarifying eye and his audacious judgments; he has projected on all his volatile wit and a searching wisdom. 
 He is totally dedicated to his calling, his art, and spares no expense to fulfil it. 
 He is merciless to other poets whom he considers to have sold the pass: 
 Since Auden set the fashion 
 Our poets grow tame; 
 They are quite without passion, 
 They live without blame. 
 Indeed, he is at his most virulent when attacking his fellow-poets, so caught up is he in the seriousness of the poetic task. 
 If Soren Kierkegaard vitiated the easy-going philosophical idealism of his day with his heavily personalised challenges to it; if von Rochau brought in the concept of Realpolitik  to Bismarck's Germany; and if Karl Barth ushered in &bquo;Crisis Theology&equo; in Switzerland; it is at least arguable that Irving Layton fathered &bquo;Crisis Poetry&equo; in Canada: poetry that demanded a decision, a response; that cut through the emollient patter and posed a rough demand on the reader or hearer. 
 In order to get that response he was prepared to dispense with the niceties of convention and the formulae of polite language: &bquo;from the gut, to the gut.&equo; 
 It was exactly what Leonard expected of a poet, and he and Layton have remained firm friends ever since. 
 (Moreover, he was, like Lorca, another &bquo;L&equo; &mdash; and that could not be merely coincidental!) 
 Indeed, the relationship has been more than mere friendship, but one of familial depth. 
 Leonard has described his youth as being &bquo;free from adult figures,&equo; but Layton overturned that. 
 Here was not an authority-figure, of school or university or civic discipline; still less a relation who could &bquo;pull rank&equo; by virtue of family influence or purse string manipulation. 
 He was a man, a friend, a fellow-rebel, a poet , with whom one could simply be oneself; and write knowing that it was understood, respected. 
 A father-figure in the deepest sense of the word. 
 Significantly, when Esther, Leonard's sister, introduced Jennifer Warnes to him, she commented that Layton had been &bquo;like a father to Leonard.&equo; 
 There was much truth in it, despite their respect for each other's freedom and independence. 
 There are major differences of personality and style, as well as background, but these complement each other rather than antagonise. 
 Layton appreciates in Leonard the patrician Jew aspects that he finds so ridiculous in others; Leonard, the anti-establishment (and anti-everything else!) that he finds in the older man. 
 Layton described the four things which stand out in Leonard, which give him the confidence to work as he does, and promote his work: The strong tradition of learning; the business entrepreneurship of his family; the broad philanthropy/charity which hall-marked it; and, lastly, the self-awareness that comes from being a Cohen &mdash; not understood as class-distinction, but from the high symbolism of &bquo;the priest and his role.&equo; 
 This latter is particularly interesting. 
 It was raised by Dudek in somewhat different form when he said that Leonard &bquo;always had an image of himself as a rabbi.&equo; 
 We are talking of two very perceptive men &mdash; whose m&eacute;tier is perception; and their recollection of Leonard at this young age, his late teenage years. 
 Layton put it somewhat differently when he added that &bquo;the two great qualities a young writer has are his arrogance and inexperience,&equo; and on another occasion he picked out the twin characteristics of &bquo;precocity and  independence.&equo; 
 Leonard was never arrogant, but he was &mdash; as Pierre Berton once remarked on Canadian television, &bquo;a very confident young man.&equo; 
 By the time they met, Leonard was indeed pushing hard at the doors of his own individuality &mdash; in one sense he had been doing that for years. 
 But university life, not least his ability to rent a flat with Morton Rosengarten in Lower Stanley Street (for some time unbeknown to his mother), now allowed him to do this actually. 
 (When she was told, she was surprisingly sympathetic, and tolerant of this need for independence. 
 &bquo;Just follow your little heart,&equo; she commented; as she ever did in matters of important self-expression.) 
 Irving Layton was exactly the sort of man to further that: enthusiastic and bold, erudite and observant, worldly and street-wise, compassionate and cavalier; he could throw all caution to the wind and sing and drink and dance the night away. 
 Not merely poetry in motion, but surrealist poetry! 
 As with the Hebrew prophets, there were no greys, no subtle shades. 
 Though he is meticulous in his choice of words and turns of phrase; his attitude, his demands, are for black and white: take it or leave it; but at least recognise that you have been offered it.  
 SELF HOOD, POETRY AND MUSIC 
 In the year in which they met, 1954, Layton had two books of poetry published &mdash; he does nothing by halves! &mdash; and Leonard was clearly dazzled by the man's prolific genius. 
 When it mattered, Leonard was a learner; he could sit at a man's feet and absorb completely. 
 In Layton he saw the splendour, and the viability, of the poetic destiny. 
 A life in art began to make real sense. 
 Unlike his rabbinic forebears who were not allowed &bquo;to use the Torah as an axe,&equo; to earn their keep from its knowledge and application, this was a m&eacute;tier which both claimed him and offered a fulfilling vocation. 
 His questions flared fast and furious. 
 As Layton emphasised, theirs was the Jewish tradition of the Lehrer : the teacher/learner relationship. 
 In amiable mood one day Leonard remarked of his friend, &bquo;I taught him how to dress; he taught me how to live forever.&equo; 
 And so began this friendship of 35 years, between the older and the younger man (Layton is 20 years senior to Leonard); between the master and the apprentice. 
 Whenever Layton had a promotional tour or appearance, a poetry reading or a workshop (poetry-reading in Canada predated Ginsberg's sensation with Howl that set in motion the &bquo;beat-poetry&equo; style, despite Scobie arguing it as an influence on Leonard's background), he would take Leonard along, acquaint him with the nuts and bolts of the business and get him to read some of his own poetry. 
 And they had such fun together! 
 On one occasion they were so preoccupied with their discussion, driving from Montreal to Toronto, that they failed to notice how low in petrol they had become. 
 Too late! 
 They ran out of petrol some miles from their destination, fortunately near to some houses whose occupants came to their rescue. 
 Two years later, incredibly, the very same thing happened, at the very same spot. 
 Only the discussion had changed!  
 Nothing captures this profound relationship like Leonard's poem, &bquo;Last Dance At The Four Penny&equo; ( The Spice-Box Of Earth , pp 73), which perfectly catches the way they could cock a snook at the establishment, scholarly and religious: 
 Layton, when we dance our Freilach 
 Under the ghostly handkerchief, 
 the miracle rabbis of Prague and Vilna 
 resume their sawdust thrones, 
 and angels and men, asleep so long 
 in the cold palaces of disbelief, 
 gather in sausage-hung kitchens 
 to quarrel deliciously and debate 
 the sounds of the Ineffable Name. 
 Layton, my friend Lazarovitch, 
 no Jew was ever lost 
 while we two dance joyously 
 in this French province&hellip; 
 Reb Israel Lazarovitch, 
 you no-good Romanian, you're right 
 Who cares whether or not 
 the Messiah is a Litvak? 
 Let them step with us or not 
 in their logical shrouds. 
 We've raised a bright, white flag&hellip; 
 In this poem we see their shared Jewishness, and the &bquo;irreverence&equo; (as some would see it) they each had for the Tradition &mdash; at least for that view of it which some espoused; we also see a shared disdain for rabbinic (and priestly) logic, to them both a form of mental death. 
 As Leonard commented in Police Gazette , &bquo;I'd rather sleep with ashes than with priestly wisdom,&equo; which has even more point when we understand that the ashes referred to are those of the victims of the Holocaust. 
 Professor Pacey referred to Layton as &bquo;a poet of revolutionary individualism,&equo; and there can be no doubt that that individualism was a common tie, and not merely religiously but in every way. 
 Not least in the sexual, for both projected a red-blooded response to their manhood which goes beyond the merely sexual or corporeal, claiming &mdash; demanding ! &mdash; the full world of nature and manhood as their proper spheres: nothing was to be too sacred, for all is sacred &mdash; a Blakeian conception which predates Blake in its patent Jewishness by millennia, not centuries. 
 Said Leonard to us over a bottle of Sabbath wine, &bquo;I did not have a scholar's bent; at that time I spent many evenings with Layton and we  would &bquo;crack&equo; poetry together &mdash; discover the poet's meaning. 
 (That is) training at its best: serious, dedicated&hellip; 
 (Ours was) an ad hoc  group. 
 We lived for it, in between homes and restaurants.&equo; 
 Significantly, he adduced the work of the American poet Wallace Stevens at this point, a man torn between the profession of law and the poetic muse, whose view of lost faith and a &bquo;disconnected&equo; tradition imbued his poetry with a wistfulness and a challenge that was taken very seriously by Leonard and Layton; or, perhaps, viewed by them as a satisfactory replacement. 
 As Layton asked in his poem &bquo;To The Roaring Wind&equo; (or was it to the Spirit-behind-the wind?): 
 What syllable are you seeking, 
 Vocalissimus, 
 In the distances of sleep? 
 Speak it. 
 This was the year in which Leonard was elected president of McGill's Debating Society. 
 He was, as we have seen, already President of his fraternity. 
 The following is his acceptance speech as President and, while betraying a certain youthfulness, it demonstrates the cast &mdash; the humour and the audacity &mdash; of his mind at that time: 
 Mr Chairman, Ladies and Gentlemen. 
 The foreigners in  Ottawa constitute an ominous threat to the integrity and autonomy of our province. 
 The Communists in the CBC have tried to poison our minds with bolshevism and the capitalists of Ontario have tried to poison our bodies with margarine. 
 Twice in the last half century they have plunged us into British wars and twice have they taken our finest youth from under our beds and from behind our hams. 
 We are incompatible with them because they cannot understand us or comprehend our heritage. 
 In our Church they see bigotry; in our homespun cloth they see provincialism; in our wooden ploughs they see something primitive; in our fallen bridges they see corruption. 
 And, ladies and gentlemen, how long before they interfere with the very guardians of our existence and prevent the provincial police from shooting down vicious unarmed textile strikers? 
 These are the things we believe in &mdash; the things they are trying to take away. 
 There is open to us only one course of action: we must  quit the Confederation, consolidate and centralise our own power. 
 But who is qualified to lead us on this Crusade? 
 The answer is as obvious as the sign on a streetcar &mdash; it is a business man. 
 In this day governments handle astronomical sums and a multitude of people. 
 In effect, a government today is big business. 
 Who then more logical to head our new government but a business  man? 
 There is nothing so admirable as a man who applies his knowledge with forceful direction and from his efficiency reaps a profit. 
 To be a good business man is the epitome of development and these learned people secretly aspire to that goal. 
 For what are their professions and avocations per se without the business sense? 
 The lawyer is a deceptive sophist half smothered in ipso factos. 
 The artsman is an antique fossil and at best will make a fine filing clerk. 
 And would we trust the doctor to rule? 
 I am reminded of a short verse written in Roman times when even then they a new the nature of doctors. 
 It goes: 
 &bquo;But when the wit began to wheeze 
 And wine had warmed the politician 
 Cured yesterday of my disease, 
 I died last night of my physician.&equo; 
 And the engineer &mdash; or scientist &mdash; an automaton, his imagination chained to a drawing board by a formula and a slide rule. 
 Will he be our new leader? 
 Quebec was the last province to give the vote to women. 
 Under the new r&eacute;gime we would be the first province to disenfranchise them. 
 For as Ambrose Bierce said, &bquo;Here's to woman. 
 Would that we could fall into her arms without falling into her hands.&equo; 
 And frankly, ladies and gentlemen, what is a theological student but a sebastomaniac? 
 But don't despair, my friends. 
 Even for the engineer there is still hope. 
 Charles E. Wilson, the newly appointed Secretary of Defence, graduated as an engineer but soon realised there were better things in life and he took a course in commerce and went into business and is now engaged in the most complicated of businesses &mdash; that of running a country. 
 But perhaps I should not encourage you. 
 The business man can use you all in the new r&eacute;gime. 
 But you must all acknowledge his obvious superiority. 
 To close, I should like to quote from a source that especially some of us find more authoritative than a business man. 
 It is the Holy Bible and if you will turn to Proverbs 22:29 the following quotation will be found: &bquo;Seest thou a man diligent in his business? 
 He shall stand before kings. 
 A keen and powerful debater, he was not amused at the dreariness of the Executive's meetings, the small talk and the administration (never his strong point). 
 So he refused to call the Executive at all! 
 It led to a major fracas, in which some tried to get him &bquo;unelected&equo;, but failed. 
 The rebel was sharpening his teeth!  
 Such behaviour did not recommended itself to another, more discreet, influence on Leonard during those undergraduate years: Professor F.R. Scott, later Dean of the Faculty of Law, presently, while Leonard swithered and swayed as to whether he should commit himself to the arts or commerce, his lecturer in law. 
 (An influence on Leonard equal to that of A. M. Klein, also a lawyer, but more importantly a poet-novelist of considerable skill, whose familiarity with literature equalled his Jewish erudition and commitment unlike Leonard he was a &bquo;ghetto&equo; Jew of Montreal). 
 Leonard dedicated a poem to him &bquo;Song For Abrabam Klein&equo;, in which poetry and song find their first and significant expression. 
 Steinberg, introducing Klein's brilliant novel The Second  Scroll, draws attention to, &bquo;The obsessive theme of the discovered poetry (of New Israel) is the miraculous, and the key image necessary to explain the remarkable vitality, the rebirth evidenced in every aspect of life, is the miracle.&equo; 
 A theme and an image which will be apparent &mdash; and crucial for Leonard's own novel Beautiful Losers. 
 It is doubtful if Leonard learned much law from Scott. 
 Even when in lectures, which was not often, his mind was elsewhere. 
 But there was a degree of comprehension, if not agreement, from the professor. 
 Scott was in fact a poet of considerable skill himself a founding father, no less, of Canada's emerging poetry movement, and the doyen  of poetry in Montreal, which has produced so many excellent poets. 
 An odd diversion, perhaps, from one of the country's leading constitutional lawyers, but he was seized of the gift, and so the poetry became assertive. 
 His presence had a telling, if quieter, effect on Leonard than that of Dudek or Layton, but it was nevertheless very important. 
 Scott made no secret of Leonard's ambiguities regarding law, and he sought to ease him into a position nearer to his own, of both lawyer and poet. 
 But Leonard is not of that cloth; his nature is obsessive; what he does, he must do with abandon; he has to work in total conviction, and dedication. 
 As he said himself of this time, &bquo;I yearned to live a semi-bohemian lifestyle, an unstructured life; but a consecrated  one; some kind of calling.&equo; 
 It was this that fostered an even more radical bid for his independence. 
 Being adequately provided for, he was able to book himself into a downtown hotel which cost him three dollars per night, though he often failed to make it back to the hotel, finding the cosmopolitan and nocturnal life of the town there entirely to his liking: consecration dismantled! 
 Leonard was fortunate in being welcomed &mdash; virtually as an equal - into the regular company of such as these older poets. 
 Not merely welcomed among them, but escorted around the country by them to various literary and poetry events, and often presented to their confr&egrave;res as their prot&eacute;g&eacute;.  
 It was during this time that he was invited to the discussions of the CIV/n group, a gathering of poets of the more serious sort &mdash; and to some extent inspired by Ezra Pound's revitalising energies, even as its name was culled from his writings &mdash; who had just launched a new poetry magazine of that name. 
 It included such as Wanda Staniszewska, Jackie Gallagher, Buddy Rozynski (cousin of Louis Dudek) and Aileen Collins (later to be Mrs L. Dudek), Robert A. Currie, Yaffa Lerner, Anna Azzulo, Betty Sutherland (later Mrs Sutherland Layton), and Dudek himself. 
 Between April 1953 and March 1954 they produced the first five issues, meeting in Layton's home, occasionally at Rosengarten's, to discuss The Things That Matter &mdash; their latest poetry and material offered by others, not infrequently being led in song by Leonard on his ever-present guitar. 
 Despite the fun and gaiety, it was a very serious concern &mdash; the concern of poetry itself. 
 It was also revolutionary, an emphasis that attracted Leonard particularly. 
 Commented Aileen Collins retrospectively, &bquo;&hellip; our study of literature in no way reflected what we knew was happening in the world&hellip; (we aspired) to let in new voices, and essentially to jolt Canadians from their lethargy and narrow-mindedness. 
 We were set against (the Canadian Authors' Association) poetry and maple syrup!&equo; 
 The magazine was set to be &bquo;a new force in writing and criticism in Canada&equo;; based on Pound's comment: &bquo;CIV/n (civilisation) &mdash; not a one-man job.&equo; 
 And not always ironical, either, as Layton commented: &bquo;The discussion would be lively, boisterous, and prolonged; no fistfights, but plenty of abuse and insult&hellip; 
 What really stands out in my mind was the homage that was instantly paid to a good poem and the individual who had written it.&equo; 
 Some years later he and Dudek parted company; the former being too much the evangelist-propagandist for the &bquo;pure&equo; scholar. 
 As Pacey said of Dudek &mdash; he could never say it of Layton! &mdash; &bquo;(his strength) lies in his serious attempt to give as purely as possible the experience which is pure and isolated in his own mind,&equo; a view which is offended by the notion of &bquo;popular culture&equo; and the torch-carrying it requires. 
 Into that group came Leonard. 
 He grew mentally and spiritually, and his art increased accordingly, in depth and dexterity. 
 As became poetry of a new civilisation, it was socially conscious as well as spiritual, incisive as well as whimsical; as the following demonstrates ( Let Us Compare Mythologies , pp69): 
 Les Vieux 
 North-eastern Lunch 
 with rotting noses and tweed caps, 
 huddling in thick coats  
 and mumbling confidential songs 
 to ancient friends &mdash; 
 the public men of Montreal: 
 and in parks 
 with strange children 
 who listen to sad lies 
 in exchange for whistles 
 carved from wet maple branches; 
 in Phillips Square, 
 on newspaper covered benches, 
 unaware of Ste Catherine Street 
 or grey or green pigeons 
 inquiring between their boots &mdash; 
 public men, 
 spitting blood in crumpled handkerchiefs, 
 twisting fingers against brittle years. 
 But rising as his star was, there was one aspect to Leonard's poetry which was encouraged by Layton and discouraged by Dudek. 
 What the former valued as a proper earthiness and sensuality, the latter condemned as mere vulgarity. 
 To Leonard, who long had felt the masterful power of passion &mdash; when the guests become tyrants &mdash; Layton's honesty was as refreshing as his candour was liberating. 
 Dudek, no prude, had already delivered his concern at this, finding the &bquo;adolescent sexuality&equo; an offence against the higher standards of art. 
 In Layton's company Leonard could be himself, recognise his own nature, and celebrate its pleasing to the full. 
 No Talmudic saying was nearer to him than that at the end of the Kiddushin : &bquo;When a man faces his Maker, he will have to account for those (God-given) pleasures of life which he failed to enjoy,&equo; and the Mezeritzer Rabbi commented, albeit a little more warily, &bquo;You may reach a compromise between evil and good by enjoying legitimate bodily pleasure and serving God at the same time.&equo; 
 The &bquo;Dionysiac&equo; qualities of life were an essential part of Layton's view; they were so in Leonard's, too. 
 So these beginning years focused on reality &mdash; the underbelly of creation as well as its brightness &mdash; which was of immense importance to the making of the man and his mind. 
 In them opposing forces sought to violate his commitment: the physical versus the spiritual; the free versus the regimented; the religious versus the secular; and so on. 
 He repeatedly found himself asking the question Who? &mdash; and What? &mdash; was he? 
 Believer or agnostic? 
 Saint or Sinner? 
 Writer or Businessman? 
 Musician or poet? 
 His emotions, the Tradition, pulled one way; art and the imaginative impulse, another. 
 The earlier call of music, now happily developing into &bquo;teenage&equo; forms and addressing their concerns for freedom and individuality,  as well as evoking a certain resentment at the growing post-war materialism, was sweeping many along in its wake. 
 And Leonard's interests in it were moving from the amateur to the professional. 
 He was to be frequently found at various &bquo;gigs&equo; with his Buckskin Boys &mdash; a square-dance group of three, of which he was the leader. 
 They played mainly country tunes, at high-school and church-based venues most weekends. 
 Terry played bucket-base, Mike played the harmonica, and Leonard played the rhythm-guitar. 
 Two of the numbers they played were &bquo;Red River Valley&equo; and &bquo;Turkey In The Straw&equo; (the former finding expression in 1989, when it was included in the video Songs from The Life Of Leonard Cohen !) 
 His guitar was his companion, its music his soul-mate, not only at such professional expressions as these but everywhere. 
 Rosengarten recalls an afternoon when Leonard, sitting on the Faculty steps with his guitar, started to sing. 
 Other students joined in and before long, quite spontaneously, a crowd of some 200 or so was found to be singing lustily, with Leonard as the ecstatic, unselfconscious conductor. 
 The music by which he frequently composed his poetry (a natural continuance of a centuries-old tradition) was asserting itself as an independent expression. 
 But recent reality had also taken its toll: his father's lamented death, his guitar teacher's suicide, and that of a cousin; the presence of his grandfather Klinitsky-Klein, now reduced unhappily to senility in his mother's house (at which he would surprise Leonard by encountering him suddenly, in odd moments of clarity, saying, &bquo;Oh, yes, you're the writer, aren't you?&equo;) created other pressures. 
 And then his grandfather died, and Leonard was faced with other traumas: his mother's remarriage and its unhappy dissolution. 
 Another related to his canine companion, Tovaritch. 
 (Leonard also kept white rats and mice &mdash; even as late as his thirties, when on the Greek island of Hydra.) 
 The dog, named before the pact between Stalin and Hitler, as Leonard was wont to emphasise in certain quarters, was a Scottish terrier of above-average sentiment and intelligence. 
 It fell ill, unknown to the family, and as it was mid-winter it crawled under a neighbour's balcony to escape from the cold, where it expired. 
 Leonard spent hours walking and cycling around the neighbourhood looking for it. 
 When it was eventually found it was almost summer, and another sharp lesson on the ephemerality of life and relationships had been learned. 
 Twenty years later he could still recall the event: &bquo;I can think about my loyal dog buried in the snow,&equo; ( Death Of A Lady's Man ). 
 No one brought up in the Jewish faith with his sort of European connections could fail to be unaware, or convulsed, by the nightmare we call the Holocaust. 
 Nightmares and night-time anxiety, are a regular feature of Leonard's work, though he did remark to us, &bquo;I don't think  that I was scarred by anything.&equo; 
 For someone whose life has been lived in search of the word, who perceived that &bquo;a scar is what happens when the word is made flesh,&equo; who owned that his education began on hearing of the Holocaust, it is not a convincing comment. 
 It may well be that his nocturnal anxieties began on hearing the nightly ministrations by which his father was nursed &mdash; to a young boy, eerie and mysterious, doubtless at times frenetic; no doubt they were exacerbated after his death, as sorrow and loss impinged. 
 &bquo;Night&equo; itself occurs several times in his early books of poetry, as it was bound to do, and its references are of an intimidating sort: &bquo;the night never ending&equo; (in &bquo;Letter&equo;), and &bquo;the clinic of your thighs against the night&equo; (in Let Us Compare Mythologies ; the latter intimating that other experience of the night which such high thinkers as Bertrand Russell found laden with sexual feelings). 
 In The Spice-Box Of Earth  he has a particularly pointed reference to it: &bquo;Night, my old night&hellip; 
 The black, the loss of sun; it will always frighten me&hellip; always leave me to experiment.&equo; 
 His songs have an even greater preoccupation with it, no fewer than 52 references to date, in fact. 
 Dreams similarly occupy him, the first occurring in &bquo;Letter&equo; which was quoted above: &bquo;your dreams of crumbling cities and galloping horses&hellip;&equo; 
 In &bquo;It Swings, Jocko&equo; he says, &bquo;I want my dreams to be of deprivation&hellip;&equo; (which is, after all, the mother of poetry). 
 He wrote candidly of Breavman in The Favourite  Game being &bquo;an insomniac with visions of vastness,&equo; by which a more positive element is projected. 
 But by the time Parasites Of Heaven  was written an intensely negative aspect is unveiled: &bquo;The nightmares do not suddenly develop happy endings, I merely step out of them.&equo; 
 Whatever we may make of this, it is interesting to observe that Professor Hartman of New York has established a link between those who suffer from this nocturnal disposition and a high level of creativity. 
 (Hartman has shown that the average person has one or less nightmares a year; and only one person in 500 has them on a weekly basis.) 
 Moreover, he assesses such people (in his book The Nightmare , 1985) as being &bquo;markedly open and defenceless, not having developed the psychological protection most people have&hellip; they have thin boundaries (between conscious and unconscious states) and let things through.&equo; 
 Professor Andrew Greeley extended this by drawing attention to the special sensitivity of the sufferers, by which they are easily hurt, which he found often resulted from an unhappy childhood. 
 For, in addition to any &bquo;genetic inheritance&equo;, he noted that such individuals frequently suffered from an interlude in which motherly care was unavailable. 
 It is always dangerous to draw individual implications from social and psychological survey-work such as this, but it does fit:  Leonard's admission of insomnia, of disturbing dreams and nightmares, his high sensitivity, his creative abilities; not least his father's demise and his mother's need to attend to him during his frequent bouts of sickness before it. 
 The horrors of the Holocaust started to burst around Leonard's ears when he was 11. 
 He actually called it elsewhere &bquo;a central psychic event&equo; in his life. 
 The word itself is derived from two Greek words: holos  and kaustos ; the former, &bquo;wholeness&equo;, has a tragically ironic edge to it in the light of Leonard's concerns for &bquo;oneness&equo;. 
 Whatever we may make of its influences, Leonard is clear that he &bquo;never recovered&equo; from its d&eacute;nouements ; its &bquo;illumination of human behaviour&equo;; its horror (which he termed &bquo;metaphorical&equo;). 
 But he was honest enough to say that he was &bquo;fascinated&equo; by it too; as he was by all forms of physical violence. 
 It raised immense questions of fundamental reality; as was translated (badly!) of Joseph in his experience of suffering: &bquo;the iron entered his soul.&equo; 
 Leonard was not so much brutalised by the experience, as anaesthetised: hence the recollection of only desire throughout his youth. 
 His poetry tells a different story: there was wide and profound sentience &mdash; of man and nature, of beauty and the beast, of times and seasons, of perception and tactility, of hearing and tasting, and smelling; at the bottom of which remains an unresolved questing, a whole gamut of unanswered questions which drove at the very heart of what he most wished to believe. 
 His own faith did not have the answers to this, any more than it had the power to prevent the catastrophe, which exacerbated Leonard's growing disaffection from it, or, should we say, his endless self-questioning of it. 
 He said, &bquo;There was a lack of teachers in my own tradition. 
 There were great rabbis in the cities, but I was not part of that. 
 No preparation was given (me) for the religious vision. 
 That was not the emphasis; rather, it was a preparation for Canadian citizenship&hellip; 
 My grandfather was dividing himself&hellip;&equo; 
 (The latter, of Lyon Cohen, a signal appraisement which finds similar expression in his uncle's behaviour, as we shall presently see.) 
 Looking around at the suffocating power of the Roman Catholic Church and the less humane churches of Protestantism, he found that he had nowhere else to go; they had no answers for this situation either. 
 He wondered sometimes if they even understood the questions. 
 Little wonder, then, that Professor Dudek viewed him as &bquo;always a troubled young man.&equo; 
 He took himself, his name and his calling seriously. 
 But did anyone else? 
 What was it all about, and where did he fit in? 
 There is a passage of great beauty and relevance to this in The Favourite Game  (pp116), in which Breavman reflects on his family, its prominent position, and its meaning:  
 &bquo;He thought that his tall uncles in the dark clothes were princes of an &eacute;lite brotherhood. 
 He had thought that the synagogue was their house of purification. 
 He had thought that their businesses were realms of feudal benevolence. 
 But he had grown to understand that none of them could even pretend to these things. 
 They were proud of their financial and communal success. 
 They liked to be first, to be respected, to sit close to the altar, to be called up to lift the scrolls. 
 They weren't pledged to any other idea. 
 They did not believe their blood was consecrated.&equo; 
 There is an authentic ring about such passages. 
 They reflect the sense of disquietude, of alienation even, that broke into his consciousness, wrenching him from contentment and popularity and success into a feeling of grave unrest; as they have continued to do, exacerbated by his own failures and guilt. 
 Hence the prominence of such words as &bquo;comfort&equo; in his writings; not of their plush armchairs or velvet drapes, but the comfort of a quiet mind and a balanced equilibrium in life. 
 We see the struggle asserting itself in the preface to his poem &bquo;The Glass Dog&equo; ( Flowers for Hitler ): 
 Let me renew myself 
 in the midst of all the things of the world 
 which cannot be connected. 
 He, like his uncles, was a Cohen, with a rank and a calling. 
 But, for all their excellence, he did not like, he could not agree with, what he saw. 
 His self-image and his idealism were being threatened at the anvil of reality. 
 He continued: 
 &bquo;No, his uncles were not grave enough. 
 They were strict, not grave. 
 They did not seem to realise how fragile the ceremony was. 
 They participated in it blindly, as if it would last for ever. 
 They did not seem to realise how important they were; not self-important, but important to the incantation , the altar, the ritual. 
 They were ignorant of the craft of devotion. 
 They were merely devoted. 
 They never thought how close the ceremony was to chaos. 
 Their nobility was insecure because it rested on inheritance and not moment-to-moment creation in the face of annihilation.&equo; 
 (Our italics, see below.) 
 He found them wanting. 
 The annihilation had all but occurred in far-off Europe, but that with which he wrestled was of even deeper concern &mdash; the cessation of the faith from within. 
 So he continued: 
 &bquo;&hellip; 
 Breavman knew the whole procedure could revert in a second to desolation. 
 The cantor, the rabbi, the chosen laymen stood before the open Ark, cradling the Torah scrolls, which looked like stiff-necked royal children, and returned them one by one to their golden stall. 
 The beautiful melody  which soared proclaimed that the Law was a tree of life and a path of peace. 
 Couldn't they see how it had to be  nourished? 
 All these men who bowed, who performed the customary motions, they were unaware that other men had written the sacred tune , other men had developed the seemingly eternal gestures out of clumsy confusion. 
 They took for granted what was dying in their hands .&equo; 
 (Our italics.) 
 The observer had become a diagnostician; he was fast becoming a prophet. 
 And, true to the tradition of prophets, he rebelled: 
 &bquo;But why should he care? 
 He wasn't Isaiah, and the people claimed nothing. 
 He didn't even like the people or the god of their cult. 
 He had no rights in the matter&hellip; 
 He didn't want to blame anyone. 
 Why should he feel that they had bred him  to disappointment? 
 He was bitter  because he couldn't inherit the glory they unwittingly advertised. 
 He couldn't be part of their brotherhood but he wanted to be among them. 
 A nostalgia for solidarity. 
 Why was his father's pain involved ?&equo; 
 (Our italics.) 
 Rebellion was one thing; severance or denial was something else. 
 The responsibility was going to haunt him for years to come. 
 The die had been cast. 
 He had perceived. 
 But to the &bquo;rebellion&equo; (which may have given rise to something far deeper, as we shall see) we must add two further emphases which we have italicised. 
 One, the unforgettable &bquo;incantation&equo;, the &bquo;melody&equo; and &bquo;tune&equo; of the services &mdash; things which were deeply rooted in his soul, and would reappear with striking force through his music and songs; and two, his distancing himself from its strictly religious aspects. 
 Moreover his stark question, &bquo;Why was his father's pain involved?&equo; raises a very different note. 
 In what ways did he feel it, his father's pain? 
 How did he allow himself to feel it? 
 And how often? 
 &bquo;The mills of God grind exceedingly small&hellip;&equo; &mdash; even if &bquo;the god of their cult&equo; was disliked. 
 As with so much in Leonard's writing, the passages may be read at different levels. 
 Unquestionably, the loss of his father was felt as a grievous blow for many years after the event. 
 Ironically, Judaism's splendid emphasis on the father-son relationship, the most sacred there is next to that between the Creator and the created, exacerbates this loss; hence Judaism's very humane laws to do with &bquo;the fatherless&equo; &mdash; far ahead of its and any other time. 
 So the consideration of his uncles' place in both the community and the synagogue calls to mind the fact that his father, as the first born son, should have had that pre-eminence. 
 Leonard has been doubly cheated: of his father's presence and his rightful position. 
 Hence his &bquo;disappointment&equo;, and even his &bquo;bitterness&equo;. 
 (It reached its zenith in Beautiful Losers  when he referred to &bquo;my factory&equo;, his metaphor for Judaism as, &bquo;a pile of rags and labels, a distraction, an insult to my spirit.&equo;) 
 For all this he has ever been grateful for his uncles, careful considerations &mdash; as his father's executors &mdash; of his family, and especially of their kindness towards him personally. 
 Lawrence,  in particular, was extremely concerned, and sought to influence his nephew's development advantageously. 
 (It was Lawrence who &bquo;blew my cover,&equo; he said, on finding that Leonard was failing to attend Law School lectures, which was all the more concerning as he had no scholarship to go there, only his family's financial backing.) 
 It is this which suggests the secondary level. 
 Was the pain, in fact, actually his father's as well as his own? 
 In other words, was there not a feeling that, first through illness and then through his premature demise, he had been supplanted  in his rights (through &bquo;natural&equo; causation, we emphasise), much as Jacob supplanted Esau's rights so many centuries ago (through devious schemes). 
 Was Leonard aware, even at such a tender age, of the sense of grief his father had, not only in his life being shortened but with it his usefulness? 
 Or if not then perhaps later as his mother &mdash; always self-conscious as to the difference between herself and her more Westernised sisters-in-law gave vent to the feelings of inadequacy they unconsciously inspired? 
 (But we should understand that &bquo;complaint&equo; is part of the Tradition, and should not be interpreted as merely personal affront: it is a valid and recommended part of Jewish expression.) 
 Such evidence that we have suggests that his father was more introspective than his brothers. 
 If that is the case, then it is possible that he also thought that the synagogue ritual, as well as the direction of their commercial life and benefactions should have been handled differently. 
 Nathan Cohen would have been &bquo;pledged&equo; to another idea; his &bquo;blood&equo; would have been consecrated; he would have been &bquo;grave&equo; &mdash; though perhaps not &bquo;strict&equo;; he would better have protected the fragile ceremony; owning the importance of his proper role in it. 
 It would, perforce, have been a &bquo;devoted&equo; service therein rendered; and adequately &bquo;nourished&equo;. 
 Leonard has admitted to a general feeling in the family that Horace was somewhat &bquo;arrogant&equo;, this son that now wore the mantle: &bquo;My father was the eldest but his health and nature (an interesting, significant addition) prevented him taking over.&equo; 
 It was this &bquo;nature&equo; that caused Nathan to act as the factory supervisor &mdash; &bquo;a good guy&equo; so far as the workers were concerned; and allowed Horace the seniority, as &bquo;a front-office man.&equo; 
 But this throws into high relief Leonard's (or at least Breavman's!) denial of spiritual responsibility: if the onus had passed to his uncles, and thereby to his cousins, why should he care? 
 If no one was now &bquo;claiming&equo; anything from him; if he had been marginalised, then &bquo;he had no rights in the matter&equo; any longer. 
 Supplanted, perhaps; cheated (by fate) probably; but now self-absolved from its responsibility, though to bear for ever in his mind the trauma of a calling from which he had somehow been disinherited. 
 It would indeed hound him for ever, and inspire the many references in dialogue to his father which we  shall encounter, and his ambiguous sense of direction and self-fulfilment. 
 When the priest cannot function as a priest, is he bound to become a prophet? 
 HIS MYTHOLOGICAL PHASE 
 It is not possible, in a family such as Leonard's, to refuse the subtle (and the not-so-subtle) constraints. 
 The business was in need of new blood, he had a widowed mother to consider, and his lineage through Nathan, Lyon and Lazarus claimed priestly &mdash; not to say professional &mdash; satisfaction. 
 Leonard, sensitive to such pressures, was in deep doubt. 
 Such time as he had spent on commercial subjects (in vacations, etc) had produced a profound dislike for them. 
 This was not life! 
 He could not see himself chained to these realities for the next 40 or 50 years. 
 The time spent at his summer jobs &mdash; perhaps not least that spent in his uncle Lawrence's brass foundry reinforced this view. 
 Nevertheless, he felt bound to accept the challenge of post-graduate work at Columbia University in New York, albeit with deepening reservations. 
 Moreover, Dudek had taken his doctorate at Columbia, and Federico Gar&ccedil;ia Lorca had studied there a few years before Leonard was born. 
 Almost immediately on arrival, surrounded by the cosmopolitan excitement of New York, its immense anonymity, the total lack of personal interest shown towards him after having been the centre of warmth and appreciation in Montreal, he knew that it was not for him. 
 Columbia University's Law School had no charms, no personal comfort (like the surrounding high-rise buildings); there must be another way. 
 Paul Robeson &mdash; himself a belatedly famed son of the Law School &mdash; might embody law and song, and F.R. Scott might embody law and poetry, but even he recognised the more profound call of the muse: &bquo;poetry first,&equo; he had said &bquo;and the poetic element all the way through,&equo; which in the hurly-burly of the clothing industry, was even less possible. 
 And, in any case such dual commitment Leonard could not  share, commitment for him had to be the expression of what drove  him; he was obsessive about his poetry and his life in art. 
 Having registered, he set about ordering his life as he saw it developing, by giving himself over to the muse, by associating with those whose lives found proper space for literary reflection and endeavour, by getting close to that bohemian existence which he loved and from which all modern art seemed to spring. 
 Most of all, by writing poetry and seeking to enhance his skills at it. 
 The &bquo;Quiet Revolution&equo; which was beginning to take place in Canada was now seizing Leonard himself; he would be a poet-writer, and be would find a place for his music alongside it. 
 And there was much encouragement around him to do so. 
 Layton's ebullience was on a par with Ezra Pound's &bquo;showmanship&equo;, and Leonard now found himself not so very far from where the great revolutionary poet (of Imagism, Vortism etc.) was actually incarcerated. 
 What he was now unable to do, the &bquo;Beat&equo; poets fulfilled, in their own bohemian street-style in New York. 
 Ginsberg's Howl actually came out while Leonard was there, doing for the fifties and sixties generation what Eliot's The Waste Land  did for the twenties and thirties, and not least Ginsberg's &bquo;A Supermarket In California&equo;, in which he questioned Lorca's lonely habits; as did Lawrence Ferlinghetti's Picture Of The Gone World . 
 Others of a similar ilk were Gregory Corso, Gary Snyder and William Burroughs. 
 Their whole emphasis was against conventionalism &mdash; in every form, not least the sexual, the religious and the artistic. 
 It is almost certain that Leonard's interest in Zen Buddhism was sown at this time, and his &bquo;anti-intellectualism&equo; confirmed. 
 It was the start of a serious counter-culture which achieved its apogee  in the poetry and antics of Bob Dylan, The Beatles, The Rolling Stones et al . 
 Not so quiet was a parallel revolution that was reshaping the music scene, with which Leonard had an ongoing affair. 
 Like any form of art, music has an intrinsic ability to revitalise itself; but when this is stimulated by &bquo;external&equo; factors, for example, those that become operative in the wake of the industrial revolution, the Darwinian ferment and the resurgence of nationalism in the 19th century, not least a species of war-mongering, then wholly new genres may emerge. 
 Such had happened in Scotland and Ireland in its employment of folk-themes for late 19th century &bquo;classical music&equo;. 
 And in England &mdash; in the shape of Cecil Sharp and company &mdash; it too began to assert its own folk-music (over Continental, largely Teutonic forms) in the opening decades of the present century. 
 Many of these had found their way across America and Canada with the early settlers, along with psalm versions and hymnody. 
 The wave of interest in the rediscovery of Celtic music is particularly important, and not merely because of the Celtic-Scottish influence on Leonard's family (an aspect that the  Montreal Gazette  highlighted regarding Lyon Cohen's Gaelic accent recently) and American eclecticism &mdash; often little more than a slavish following of European forms &mdash; which found itself in the development of &bquo;pop&equo; music, notably of ragtime around 1900 and jazz around 1918. 
 The ignoramuses who deplored pop music in the fifties failed to understand how these new forms, far from being &bquo;a return to the jungle,&equo; were actually heightening genuine musical development by incorporating their rhythmic vitality and percussive effects into them, as Stravinsky had done. 
 Gershwin and Gruenberg, in Rhapsody In Blue  and Daniel Jazz , were to extend the process still further. 
 The First World War had caused massive sociological repercussions. 
 In one sense civilisation as we know it had become unhinged. 
 Angst  took over from utopian ideas of man's upward march, quickly followed by despair on the one hand and pure silliness on the other. 
 The &bquo;twittering twenties&equo; was one of its results, a concentrated version of the &bquo;naughty nineties&equo; papering over the fissures, which were undermining society at its heart &mdash; and mind. 
 The influence of its music was greatly enhanced by the technological advances which then took place: first in gramophones; then in public broadcasting systems. 
 The ballad-type songs of the day sung by such as Tony Bennett, Rosemary Clooney, Doris Day, Debbie Reynolds and Frank Sinatra, plus the great classical music she had heard from her youth, facilitated Masha Cohen's overcoming of her personal nightmares, and had become &mdash; along with the very important Yiddish music &mdash; the natural background to Leonard's life, too. 
 (Apart from these Yiddish songs, Judaism did not really have any modern music of its own, its practitioners &mdash; Mendelssohn, Meyerbeer, Rubinstein, Schonberg, for example &mdash; all incorporated the best as they saw it from the past. 
 It was not until Ernest Bloch launched himself on the scene, with Three Jewish Poems  in 1913 that &bquo;Jewish music&equo; per se  arrived; even then it was only half-oriental, half-western in style and colouration. 
 But even he, in his rhapsody America , in 1926, was not fully committed to its exclusive individuality. 
 It did, however, have the &bquo;incantations&equo; referred to above, which were immensely old, very musical in their own way , and a powerful social force &mdash; cohesively, and as an instrument of struggle &mdash; as the intifada  have found in modern Israel in our own day.) 
 During the forties and early fifties these, plus the romantic songs evoked by wartime partings, loss and refindings, found a worthy competitor in the more recent folk-songs of America, which were borne out of economic collapse (on the white hand), and subservience and racialism (on the black). 
 What had hitherto been regional versions of folk and country music now joined with the former &bquo;racist&equo; music of the coloured population, creating through cross-fertilisation modern,  i.e. &bquo;pop&equo;, music. 
 (An interesting confluence also took place between the development of classical music, which by now had moved away from tonality by vastly enlarging its range, and the coloured musicians' microtonality.) 
 This livelier music, at hitherto unimagined cheapness, combined with the postwar boom and the natural assertiveness of youth. 
 Indeed, it depended on its buying-power for sustenance, for by 1949 the life of a &bquo;hit&equo; record was about three months, with a market profile of a third under 21-years-old and a further 45 per cent between 21 and 35; leaving only one-fifth of purchasers over 35 (many of whom bought for the younger generation in any case). 
 Leonard was a very close observer, and collector, of this scene; always keeping his hand in with his guitar, writing much of his early poetry to the sound of its music: the emerging Nashville sound, Muddy Waters, Chuck Berry, Big Joe Turner, The Drifters, The Clovers, Guitar Slim and, most of all, Ray Charles, whose first hit, &bquo;Baby Let Me Hold Your Hand&equo; in 1951, marked the onset of an astonishing career. 
 These, and many more, were easily accessible, thanks to the jukebox revolution. 
 Even if the observation was not consciously made, Leonard recognised the great similarities which were taking place between music and poetry (and in art and sculpture, too), which went under the name of neo-classicism in the former and modernism in the latter. 
 In them there is an avoidance of subjective emotion, an abhorrence of rhetoric, an emphasis on simplicity, with terseness and economy of expression (the first &mdash; subjectivism &mdash; not shared by Leonard, of course). 
 And so the months passed quickly, filled with the sights, sounds, smells and tastes &mdash; all of them clamorous and variegated and, not least, the girls with which he filled his mind and his hours. 
 Even as Breavman's lectures in The Favourite Game  &bquo;didn't count&equo;, so the academic exercises dwindled &mdash; and faded away. 
 His distaste for such work may be seen from the fact that Breavman refers to the (infrequently visited) lecture rooms of Columbia by saying to Krantz: &bquo;Nothing smells more like a slaughterhouse than a graduate seminar. 
 People sitting around tables in small classrooms, their hands bloody with commas&hellip;&equo; 
 Leonard stayed like Breavman at the International Student's House, from whose lofty heights he could see across New York &bquo;relieved that it wasn't his city,&equo; in the day wandering all over New York &bquo;to stare and taste at will.&equo; 
 All of it grist to the mill of this young poet-in-the-making. 
 Said his friend-cum-mentor, Irving Layton, in looking back over the period, &bquo;I had a very sharp feeling in the early fifties that poetry in Canada had come in from the cold and was starting to gain momentum.&equo; 
 Professor Pacey had epitomised the forties as one of &bquo;vacillation and disillusionment,&equo; but the tide had indeed commenced to turn, a new  era was opening up. 
 What was true on the wider front was also true at a personal level: Layton was about to go into his most prolific period of writing, and the whole literary scene was being galvanised into a productivity never before realised in Canada. 
 In the century which Canadians believed belonged to them, poetry had come of age. 
 Leonard, too, was coming of age &mdash; precociously so. 
 Between 1949 and 1954 much of his spare time had been given to poetic scribbling; and he was also giving voice to a measure of vacillation and disillusionment, which we shall encounter in his poetry from time to time. 
 Dudek's &bquo;knighting&equo; him, and Layton and Scott's friendship, had set the seal on his gift; his two prizes (the Macnaughton and the Peterson) had confirmed it. 
 For the former award he had offered his work under the title &bquo;The Sparrows: Thoughts Of A Landsman&equo;, which was divided into four parts: 
 1. 
 A Statement: &bquo;For W(ilf) and his house&equo; 
 2. 
 A Criticism: &bquo;Ste Catherine Street&equo; 
 3. 
 A Criticism: &bquo;Lord On Peel Street&equo; 
 4. 
 An Alternative: &bquo;The Song Of The Hellenist&equo; 
 Plus &bquo;The Sparrows&equo; that we encountered earlier. 
 He was also publishing some poetry in the &bquo;little magazines&equo;, such as &bquo;Had We Nothing To Prove&equo;, &bquo;The Fly&equo;, &bquo;To Be Mentioned At Funerals&equo;, and &bquo;Just The Worst Time&equo;. 
 Professor Dudek, as we saw, had been in the van of promoting the post-war interests of poetry in a variety of forms and outlets. 
 Contact , which he edited with Souster, now closed. 
 So he conceived the excellent idea of producing a new series designed to catch the emerging poets at their earliest publishable point, to be called the &bquo;McGill Poetry Series&equo;. 
 The university authorities liked it, and readily consented to the use of its name. 
 Leonard was a natural choice for the first of the new series, both in bearing and background he represented, not merely McGill, but Canada itself; he was accordingly approached. 
 A manuscript of poems was assembled by him for the Professor to view; the intention being (and Dudek was very well experienced in this sort of work) for him to take the matter over and see it through to publication. 
 But Leonard bad different ideas. 
 He had seen beyond the excitement of being approached for his first book; he already visualised it on the bookshelves! 
 Following the professor's agreement to the material, Leonard now set his own hand to the matter entirely, learning at 21 the art of negotiation with typesetters, printers, binders and designers. 
 (There had been no plan to illustrate the book, but Leonard talked his friend and fellow-student Freda Guttman into it, and so the book appeared with five designs from her hand). 
 Professor Dudek had envisaged the series coming out in paper covers (the format that was just becoming the  way  to the mass market); Leonard ensured that it went into hard; Dudek had not meant the books to be prestigious in format but vehicles of introduction; Leonard saw to it that his book could stand alongside the best that there were from both sides of the Atlantic. 
 And he himself covered the entire costs (of &dollar;300), and did most of the distribution and selling (on the campus, in the local caf&eacute;s, in bookstores and so on, aided by a mini-advertising campaign in the McGill paper). 
 In fact, within a month it had sold out &mdash; a unique feat for such a volume. 
 He had clearly learned a thing or two from his family's entrepreneurship, and was not willing to be confined to any form of anonymity such as overtook some would-be poets. 
 The book appeared in the Spring of 1956, and was significantly dedicated to the memory of his father: the memory of whose dying he could not assuage: 
 Bearing gifts of flowers and sweet nuts 
 the family came to watch the eldest son, 
 my father; and stood about his bed 
 while he lay on a blood-sopped pillow, 
 his heart half-rotted 
 and his throat dry with regret. 
 And it seemed so obvious, the smell so present, 
 quiet so necessary, 
 but my uncles prophesied wildly, 
 promising life like frantic oracles; 
 and they only stopped in the morning, 
 after he had died 
 and I had begun to shout. 
 ( &bquo;Rites&equo;, Let Us Compare Mythologies , pp22) 
 He could scarcely help himself in choosing this physical format. 
 The dedication was a gesture of pained sorrow at his father's death as much as an act of filial piety, and the natural way to do it was to reproduce the style and character of his essentially Edwardian father. 
 The first copy he inscribed &bquo;To my dearest grandmother, with love and gratitude.&equo; 
 It was not merely a debt repaid, but a duty fulfilled. 
 He had done it with consummate aplomb. 
 Let Us Compare Mythologies , the title of the book, placed Leonard at the forefront of the young poets of Canada. 
 As well as launching the series, he had launched himself; he had moved from the ranks of a contributor to the little poetry magazines into the mainstream; his apprenticeship days were over. 
 The title is indicative of a movement generally in Canada away from the &bquo;social environment towards the more permanent world of archetypal forms and myths,&equo; (as Desmond Pacey reviewed it); but it  represented much more the interests uppermost in Leonard's own mind: the juxtaposing and conflicting &bquo;mythologies&equo; of his youth in cosmopolitan Montreal. 
 Not that he found them conflicting, still less was he offering a comparative mythology. 
 The word is used by him in a somewhat extenuated sense; not the classical definition of a sacred narrative-cum-worldview of Levi-Strauss and the anthropologists, but the more ordinary sense of metaphor, image or symbol, &bquo;rites&equo; even, and especially &bquo;mythologies within mythology&equo; as Milton Wilson perceived. 
 (&bquo;Platonic myth&equo; might be more accurate, if we detach from poetry does &bquo;narrate&equo; in a Joycean sense.) 
 This enabled him to bring together the Judaism of his upbringing and the Roman Catholicism and Anglo-Saxon Protestantism in which it was set in Montreal; the former dominating of course. 
 It also allowed him to include a wide range of &bquo;non-sacred&equo; ideas and images which colour our lives from the cradle to the grave, not least those of loving and sexuality. 
 Understood thus it avoids the questions (and therefore the problems), which Leonard nowhere addresses: such as the historicity, canonicity and the like of the world-faiths &mdash; to his mind a species of academic involvement with which he was not interested and of which he was even disdainful. 
 It is for this reason that Professor Desmond Pacey correctly posits Leonard in his second category of Canadian poets, the socialist-realist group, of which Layton is &bquo;the chief prophet&equo;; not the first, the mythopoetic group of Frye, Reaney and Macpherson. 
 In this sense Leonard's critic, Stephen Scobie, could not be more wrong. 
 Indeed, his treatment of this first book (and we shall see that it is not very dissimilar from the others) is a blatant piece of eisogesis  &mdash; reading into (as opposed to exegesis , out of) the text what he wishes to see, or rather plant. 
 Taking the word &bquo;mythologies&equo; in its usual &bquo;technical&equo; sense, Scobie comments: 
 The opening poem, &bquo;Elegy&equo; (13), announces the main themes with a firmness of tone and richness of texture that reverberate through to the culmination of Beautiful Losers . 
 It takes either great pretentiousness or great brilliance (or an outrageous combination of the two) for a young poet to proclaim himself as Orpheus in the first poem of his first book. 
 We have no quarrel with his perception of the poem's tone or texture, which is correct, but no such &bquo;proclamation&equo; was made, or intended. 
 Leonard may have acted audaciously in determining his book's format and presentation (as he became wont to do with his later works), but his response to Professor Dudek's invitation was level-headed, indeed humbly &mdash; if enthusiastically! &mdash; grateful.  
 No such claim as Scobie posits was made, and grounds for it do not exist empirically. 
 A better case can be made out for its subject being Salmo salar : the Atlantic salmon, than for Orpheus! 
 In any case, even within technical, i.e. classical mythology, Orpheus was a singer, not a fish. 
 In one form of the myth he was killed and dismembered, but then his head floated . 
 The image, as with the subject itself, is far more ethereal, and meaningful. 
 (One of America's leading Jungian psychologists, Dr Joseph L. Henderson, in Man And His Symbols , edited by Carl Jung, has made the connection &mdash; without reference to Leonard's work, to be sure. 
 But while he argues for general connections between the rites, incidentally ignoring the many repudiations of Gnosticism that were made of it by early Christian leaders, his viewpoint is much more balanced than Scobie's.) 
 Scobie appears to borrow the connection from an article by Sandra Djwa &mdash; &bquo;Leonard Cohen: Black Romantic&equo; which first appeared in 1967, where it is more skilfully and roundly argued: &bquo;Cohen's dominant theme (is),&equo; she says, &bquo;the relationship between experience and art, and more specifically the suggestion that the value of experience is to be found in the art of &bquo;beauty&equo; distilled from it&hellip;&equo; 
 The central point of the book is a reflection of a non-technical &bquo;wider ecumenism&equo;, &bquo;a juxtapositioning of mental shapes or ideas through which the poet had learned to look at life, his own and that reflected by others.&equo; 
 Pacey grasps the matter more perceptively when he says, categorically, &bquo;he does not take refuge in the ambiguity of myths, but expresses with engaging candour and simplicity his own personal response to experience.&equo; 
 But Djwa rightly perceives that &bquo;reading through Cohen's work we become aware of an unsatisfied search for an absolute.&equo; 
 The indefinite article may be suggested by the broad &bquo;mythological&equo; framework; he still disliked &bquo;the god of their cult&equo;! 
 It is not justified by viewing his work comprehensively, even to 1967; still less so to 1978 when Scobie wrote. 
 (Another eisogetic blatancy occurs in Scobie's reading into the poem &bquo;Exodus&equo; a reference to the Suez war. 
 Let Us Compare Mythologies  was published in May 1956; the war took place later that summer!) 
 Djwa is precise in saying that his &bquo;dominant theme&equo; is &bquo;the relationship between experience and art,&equo; though it avoids the nature of the experience &mdash; &bquo;art for art's sake&equo; or art for truth's sake: the reality behind the mythology &mdash; whatever it is. 
 The book is prefaced by a quotation from William Faulkner's The Bear , in which McCaslin says (in response to uncertainty as to what the poem they were discussing meant), &bquo;He had to talk about something.&equo; 
 Leonard likewise. 
 He was impelled to say something: it was in his blood, his whole being drove him on. 
 But what? 
 The only thing that &bquo;rang bells&equo; for him was his own  consciousness &mdash; Djwa's &bquo;experience&equo; &mdash; and most of all the inner experiences which had always dominated his vision &mdash; his &bquo;inner landscape&equo;. 
 (From which point we must not fail to understand the high importance of crypto-amnesiac inputs, as we shall see). 
 He commented specifically on this and his use of the Faulkner quotation by saying, &bquo;When the writer has some urgency to speak, the subject matter becomes almost irrelevant.&equo; 
 Somehow his feelings became detached from the critical procedures (not that he does not handle and assess his own work critically, which he does). 
 He feels something; is inspired by it; his mind takes off; his periods flow &mdash; and afterwards he has difficulty in recalling their point of origination, even their exact meaning (like Browning, see below). 
 His experience is transmuted into art. 
 Understanding &bquo;mythologies&equo; thus, we might paraphrase his title: &bquo;Symbols Of Life&equo;, which has the additional benefit of thrusting forward his debt to the &bquo;surrealist&equo; poet Lorca, a natural child of the symbolist movement, whose &bquo;super-realisms&equo; had infatuated Leonard from his teenage years. 
 (The symbolists' position was best declared by Mallarm who, in a famous phrase, said, &bquo; Peindre, non pas la chose, mais l'effet qu'elle produit .&equo; 
 &bquo;Painting is not what matters, but the effect it produces.&equo; 
 It is this which produces Leonard's startling use of juxtaposition, which goes on to become a disavowal technique.) 
 Whilst owing his debt to Lorca, it has to be said that this volume is markedly conservative. 
 The language apart, Leonard also seems to have been drawn towards the scandal-provoking propensities of the social catalysts as well as their revolutionary emphases; drawn towards them, at times suggesting some involvement with them, but always as an outsider to their cause; never a fully committed revolutionary himself. 
 It is another pointer to that ambiguity which is so much a characteristic of his life and work, in which the essential orderliness and formal morality of his upbringing clash with his more libertarian &mdash; and sometimes libertine &mdash; impulses and imagination. 
 He could &mdash; and would - visit a revolution, be it political and national, or merely student; he would reflect on it, but he would never get &bquo;involved&equo; in it, be it Cuban, Ethiopian, Greek or Polish. 
 (Priestly &eacute;litism undermining the prophetic?) 
 The book highlights such subjects as animism, Jewish, Christian and Hellenistic &bquo;mythologies&equo;; the realities of health, sickness and death; of nature &mdash; its seasons (notably Spring and Winter) and its glories, as well as its decadence (we find no evidence for Djwa's contention that &bquo;the book moves through cycles of winter death followed by spring rebirth,&equo; any more than for her &bquo;structural myth&equo; or &bquo;controlling Orpheus myth&equo; which form the foundation for her critique of the book); of  rationality and madness; loneliness and intimacy; of truth and treachery, prayer and protest; of prophet and priest, doctors and teachers, angels and devils; freedom and slavery, sainthood and sinning, wonder and despair, war and peace, love and loss, beauty and brutality; regret and humour; sensuality and discipline, joy and sadness; of the greatness of God and his creation, and the pitiful smallness and incompetency of man; the city and the breadth of nature itself: sea and air, rivers and countryside; savagery and urbanity; loss and its disappointing pangs. 
 In a word he offers a cornucopia of man's hopes and experiences, his successes and his frustrations, set in Canada, but energised by a trans-historical and global outlook of classical mythology and biblical settings. 
 (Memphis is the only city which gets a mention outside this range; appropriately, considering its high profile in the mythology of music!) 
 It fits perfectly the charm and naivety of the early to mid-fifties; it has little to do with the self conscious posturings of the later period that Scobie wishes to impute to it; most of all that of the &bquo;Beat generation&equo;, for most of the book had been written before Howl howled and junkie commenced the near-universal junketings. 
 It was this work, along with the subsequent brilliance of his public performances, that created his reputation as &bquo;Canada's leading young poet&equo;: &bquo;His virtues are his own, and they are considerable&hellip; at his best he expresses himself, sometimes whimsically, sometimes passionately, in speech which is beyond the capacity of mere formula to produce,&equo; commented Allan Donaldson at the time. 
 &bquo;Mr Cohen knows how to turn a phrase, his poems at their best have a clean, uncluttered line, and he writes about something, &equo; said Milton Wilson. 
 &bquo;Easily the most promising,&equo; judged Pacey, in 1961; and George Woodcock added that Leonard was one &bquo;who could write lines which are no longer good imitation Yeats; they are lines which only Yeats could have imitated.&equo; 
 &bquo;A fresh and exciting talent&hellip; a brilliant beginning,&equo; commented the anonymous reviewer in the Queen's Quarterly . 
 All of this he offered in a variety of poetic forms, from the traditional quatrain to the more controversial prose-poem &bquo;Friends&equo;. 
 Stephen Scobie has called attention to the sheer excess  with which Leonard adorns his pages. 
 It is natural that the surrealist should deal in super-abundance, quite apart from it being a reflection of his youth. 
 Leonard was but 21 when it was first published, though the poems were culled from his output from 15 to 20 years of age, according to an interview he gave to Andrew Tyler of Disc  in 1972. 
 It was not, however, the luxuriance of his style or language which his former mentor, Louis Dudek, focused on in 1958, but &bquo;the total negation,&equo; &bquo;the high condition.&equo; 
 Professor Dudek, who had begun to express criticism rather than encouragement for the young poet, went on to speak of &bquo;an intellectual disorder (not only in politics, but in  morality and religion) which leads to a primitive mythological effort to organise chaos&hellip; (it) proceeds from a state of mind fundamentally disturbed, and bordering on the deeply neurotic or worse.&equo; 
 Mythological or not, it has to be emphasised that he was speaking here of a group of poets &mdash; Ellenborgen, Hine, Mandel, Purdy, Macpherson, Layton and Cohen &mdash; not just Leonard himself. 
 But he clearly places Leonard within this group which, he held, &bquo;grasps at a confusion of symbolic images, often a ragbag of classical mythology, in the effort to organise a chaos too large for them to deal with in the light of reason,&equo; which in turn causes them to express &bquo;a sardonic bitterness in their social criticism, a realism without any utopian idealism to support it.&equo; 
 Not only sardonic bitterness, we must add but delicate irony, too. 
 Leonard's mind was such that he always had several ironies in his fire at any one time, even when he was seeking to demythologise some of them! 
 This, so far as it concerns Leonard, simply goes too far. 
 He was not trying to organise anything! 
 He was speaking from a mind full of ideas and images, which all offered insight in varying ways, which he sought to reflect on over several years. 
 It is placing an artificial, not to say architectonic, view on the whole work so to argue; it is to take his &bquo;mythology&equo; too seriously, too literally; to fail to see that the &bquo;excess&equo; was part of the message. 
 It is unfortunate that the influential Dudek could only illustrate Leonard's work by quoting from the admittedly despondent poem &bquo;Rededication&equo;, without a reference to the many other elements of positive delight that the book &mdash; and Leonard's work elsewhere at that time &mdash; demonstrates. 
 Regrettably, he makes the same point in his brilliant collection of causeries In Defence Of Art , gathered together by his wife Aileen, in 1988, when he links Susan Musgrave's &bquo;inner nightmares&equo; to Leonard's &bquo;early poetry&equo;. 
 It is a pity; for it was commentators of his stature, followed by journalists of no stature, who promoted an excessive negative emphasis on Leonard which was out of balance with his work as a whole. 
 And who, moreover, failed to differentiate between the artist and his art. 
 This is not to say that such comment is wholly wrong; merely to say that it lacks precision, finesse. 
 Leonard could be depressive along with many other poets (the psycho-endocrinological critique of poetry has yet to be written!); he could also be uplifting and assertive; he could, indeed, write &bquo;about something&equo; to use Faulkner's phrase from The Bear , and did so to the advantage of large numbers of people who gladly read, and asked for more. 
 We must remember that this collection was put together in late 1955, when most Jewish thinkers' minds were somewhere between the atrocities of the Holocaust and the fearfully questionable use of the Bomb. 
 Further, Israel was now a reality &mdash; &bquo;next year in Jerusalem&equo; for millions had been fulfilled; but the reaction of the Arab world was very  hostile &mdash; Suez was but months away, and glimmerings of its possibility (and worse) were evident. 
 Moreover, the Cold War was not thawing; Eisenhower was firm, if complacent; Khruschev was, well, Khrushchevian; stamping round the world belligerently, rattling his bombs and adding reality to the nascent CND warnings. 
 Young people were afraid, wondering if they would have time to have their children, and became agitated at the racheting-up of international tensions in East and West. 
 They were not sure that they would see 30; millions had not, scarcely a decade ago. 
 Little wonder there was &bquo;intellectual disorder&equo; &mdash; if that is the correct word for daily thought stymied by explicit threats of destruction; &bquo;a state of mind fundamentally disturbed&equo; &mdash; if they are the mots justes  for those who doubt whether they will be able to put their professional training into practice; &bquo;bordering on the neurotic&equo; &mdash; if that is an accurate description for lives lived under the fear of total extinction in the mushroom cloud. 
 Many did so think, and fear; and saw nothing in the religious experience &mdash; or that to which it pointed &mdash; of the last decade and a half to cause them to think otherwise. 
 The days were truly apocalyptic; sadly, many of the commentators and reviewers, the would-be art leaders, were merely apoplectic; not least in fastening on to his overt sexuality, their criticisms of him shielding their own neuroses. 
 The rabbis had a saying: &bquo;Where there is too much, there is something missing.&equo; 
 The excess to which some have pointed may well disclose the absence of something crucial, but for that we must defer judgment. 
 In the meantime we may note that, right or wrong, balanced or not, Leonard spoke from the heart &mdash; as did the prophets of old; the sell-out qualities of the book demonstrated the need, as well as his astuteness in compiling his selection. 
 He was proving himself to be not only an accurate witness to the times, but a respected one, too. 
 There was one particular aspect to which all commentators drew their readers' attention: his sensuality, referred to above. 
 For those raised in the prudery of puritanism or the celibacy-conscious preoccupations of Catholicism this ran against the grain. 
 They could not see how one so patently spiritual in his emphases, so biblical in his references (to both &bquo;Old&equo; and &bquo;New&equo; Testaments), could be so frank about his appreciation of female beauty and his corporeal appetites. 
 But this is part of the witness he bears; celebrating  love and sex and intimacy. 
 He speaks characteristically of his &bquo;greed&equo; as well as his need; of his &bquo;longing&equo; as well as his belonging (the latter more often by default &mdash; itself a mechanism of his alienation); of passion as well as affection; of fleshly appetites as well as the spiritual. 
 He was only too well aware of the Talmudic dictum that a handful does not satisfy a lion, but he was neither apologetic nor guilty  over it. 
 He prized too highly the Judaic emphasis of the wholeness of man's nature &mdash; oneness &mdash; his enjoyment of the gift of sexuality; and he criticised &mdash; at least e silencio  &mdash; the false views that dichotomised and castrated man. 
 We should not forget that it was not that long since Samuel Butler had published (in 1878) his famous poem &bquo;A Psalm Of Montreal&equo; which was evoked by finding that Canadian &bquo;philistinism&equo;, had removed a Greek statue of Discobolus to a side-room in the Natural History Museum, presently used by a taxidermist, because of its &bquo;vulgarity&equo;. 
 On being asked what constituted such vulgarity, it was explained that it was because it had &bquo;neither vest nor pants to cover his lower limbs!&equo; 
 Lazarus Cohen would have laughed at that; Butler simply vented his spleen &bquo;psalmically&equo;, whose chorus was, starkly, &bquo;O God! 
 O Montreal!&equo; 
 What the young Queen Victoria had to say about this, from her youthful posture on Sherbrooke Street, we shall never know. 
 Such prudery was simply offensive foolishness; an attack on God's gifts and creation, against which Leonard set himself solidly. 
 He was to be, as he called himself later, &bquo;the poet of the two great intimacies&equo;: together, in balance, and genuinely.  
 &bquo;POET OF THE TWO GREAT INTIMACIES&equo; 
 The success of Let Us Compare Mythologies  confirmed Leonard in his decision to be a poet-writer, even if it did not relieve Masha of her concern for his future well being. 
 Six Montreal Poets , a short film made by CBC &mdash; which gained considerable American exposure through Folkways Records &mdash; re-emphasised that decision. 
 (The other participants were A.J. Smith, L. Dudek, I. Layton, F.R. Scott and A.M. Klein, whose ages ranged from 40 to 60; Leonard was just 23.) 
 In this film Leonard recorded eight poems from his recent book (&bquo;For Wilf And His House&equo;, &bquo;Beside The Shepherd&equo;, &bquo;Poem&equo;, &bquo;Lovers&equo;, &bquo;The Sparrows&equo;, &bquo;Warning&equo;, &bquo;Les Vieux&equo; and &bquo;Elegy&equo;); the sleeve was careful to emphasise that he also wrote songs for a local group called The Stormy Clovers, by no means his first such work. 
 And he was now frequently called to other public performances; his first &bquo;professional&equo; poetry recital was at Dunn's Jazz Parlour in Montreal, where he recited &bquo;Gift&equo; to piano accompaniment, in honour of the ancient traditions of poetry. 
 Another event took place at Birdland, a jazz-club in the centre of Montreal, where Leonard gave poetry readings after midnight, frequently to the accompaniment of his own guitar on which he improvised appropriate backings, though often in company with more experienced jazz musicians. 
 His early involvement in this so-called jazz-poetry &mdash; which achieved such popularity in the sixties &mdash; shows that Leonard, not for the first time, and certainly not the last, was &bquo;where it was all happening&equo; before it actually happened. 
 Similarly, he performed at various locations in the States, reading his poetry to the accompaniment of Maury Kay, a well known jazz musician of the time. 
 But poetry and music were not the only things that he wrote at this time. 
 His prose-poetry had tumbled into full prose, and he was now engaged on his first novel, under the title of Beauty At Close Quarters . 
  Sadly, for it was a lively, largely autobiographical piece, it would never see the light of day. 
 It went through several mutations, but he failed to convince his publisher of its commercial viability. 
 He was also keeping notebooks Coleridge-like and in the time-honoured fashion these fed his later work, notably his novels and Death Of A Lady's Man  in particular. 
 Poetry still continued to claim much of his time, and several pieces were penned or started such as &bquo;Snow Is Falling&equo;, written to the music of Ray Charles, Edith Piaf and Nina Simone, among others. 
 His domestic arrangements were somewhat bitter-sweet. 
 He needed solitude to write, as well as a place of his own for entertaining his girlfriends, which he found on Mountain Street. 
 But his mother was concerned, and lonely. 
 Concerned as to whether he was adequately looking after himself, but especially concerned as to his future as a writer. 
 She was only too well aware of the fragility of the undertaking, and had little confidence in his making it. 
 She exhorted him to &bquo;follow your little heart&equo;; it was much more difficult for her to do so, and it showed. 
 He still saw Irving Layton, and they decided to put their hands to playwriting; which reinforced his mother's concern! 
 (It will be remembered that he had studied drama at McGill, and the plays of Britain's &bquo;angry young men&equo; had made waves in Canada.) 
 They settled on a series of four or five plays which are notable for anticipating subjects destined to become central issues in the sixties: student revolt, the hippie movement, violence and so on. 
 A recollection of their work was given by Layton in an interview for the Canadian Theatre Revue  in 1977, in the wake of A Man Was Killed , the first play to be written by them, but tardily presented. 
 Layton used to go to Leonard's flat each morning where they would work for three hours or so, though sometimes letting the work run on through the afternoons. 
 They spurred each other on, allowing the action and the words to flow naturally. 
 As Layton said, &bquo;He'd get off some line, and then I would take the part of a character and so on. 
 We found ourselves working very beautifully together, and we finished this play&hellip; 
 We had a good deal of fun doing it.&equo; 
 Leonard recalled his own practice of that time, an &bquo;instinctive&equo; use of &bquo;primitive meditation&equo;: &bquo;I sat with my hands on my lap, like a cataleptic&hellip; like Ezekiel! 
 My head was bowed down. 
 I was just a kid looking for the &bquo;juice&equo;&equo;. 
 Their optimism was confounded by CBC's impervious disinterest. 
 And they got the usual terse rejection-slip to that effect. 
 It has to be said that the plays are somewhat thin in material, and the characterisation weak, but they were both offended by the offhand refusal and the Corporation's unwillingness to offer even the slightest guidance for the betterment of the projects. 
 It was not all going to be wine and roses;  and Leonard again felt the sharp problem of the Canadian writer at that time &mdash; having a small home market, not wishing to become artistically part of the &bquo;53rd State&equo; of America, and yet having nowhere else to go. 
 As Layton said, &bquo;I still regret that we got no encouragement from the CBC, because I think that we would have gone on to write plays.&equo; 
 So it was that they went on to do other things, but separately; a &bquo;beautiful&equo; working relationship was thereby broken up, and two highly creative thinkers had their play-writing ambitions stillborn. 
 (This was not, in fact, the end of Leonard's ambitions in that regard. 
 In Flowers for Hitler , pp 110ff, he published his &bquo;The New Step&equo;: a ballet-drama in one act; and an involvement in film-making would help to sublimate it, as we shall see.) 
 Leonard did, however, manage to get a grant from the Canadian Arts Council. 
 Having found both America and Canada limiting &mdash; for different reasons &mdash; he took the only other course open to him, he went east: to Europe which then meant London. 
 Now London in the late fifties was very different from that of the &bquo;seething sixties&equo;. 
 Harold MacMillan, Prime Minister, might still be saying to the electorate that they had never had it so good &mdash; which was true in terms of the change-round from post-war reconstruction, wartime destruction, and the days of depression; but to someone of Leonard's background, from Canada, the place was a bore. 
 The scenery was grim, the food was unappetising, fashion was all but non-existent (he did buy a Burberry raincoat &mdash; his &bquo;famous blue raincoat&equo; &mdash; which he adorned till someone relieved him of it in New York 20 years later), the arts were struggling, almost moribund, despite the explosive qualities of Kingsley Amis, John Osborne, Colin Wilson, and Alan Sillitoe; and the weather was atrocious. 
 His friend Morton, who had recently been studying art and sculpture in London, mentioned his parents' old friends, the Pullmans, who had a place in Hampstead. 
 To this Leonard went, and there he stayed for several months, playing his part in the Pullman household under the terse agreement: &bquo;If you stay, you'll pull your weight, like the rest of us&equo;; ensconced in a lively family atmosphere for the first time in years. 
 Apart from organising his domestic life, Stella Pullman was a disciplinarian in the old British landlady tradition (her husband was a former RAF pilot who now flew for BOAC). 
 She organised his professional life: she demanded to know his daily quota of work (three pages a day) and ensured he kept to it &mdash; on pain of leaving should he fail! 
 That sort of failure does not belong to Leonard Cohen, he is by nature an industrious and self-conscious worker, if restless; and so he stayed. 
 He got plenty of work done there; he made friends; he felt liberated and enjoyed himself. 
 He even found English girls desirable, a girl called Elizabeth in particular. 
 But he could not come to terms with the climate. 
  It lacked &bquo;comfort&equo; and that spiritual stimulation he needed for his work. 
 On one of his afternoon strolls (mornings were for work, once he had completed his domestic chores laid down by Stella), he chanced on Bank Street, in the East End. 
 His attention was caught by the National Bank of Greece &mdash; not an inappropriate interest for one who had composed &bquo;The Song Of The Hellenist&equo;, and was drawn to Judaism's most persistent &bquo;enemy&equo; through it. 
 He went in to speak to one of the tellers. 
 Struck by the young man's suntan, he asked where he had acquired it, and when. 
 It settled his mind. 
 To Greece he must go! 
 And without more ado he booked his one-way ticket. 
 A new and dramatic phase was opening up. 
 Another factor was undoubtedly Layton's own involvement with Greece, which went back to 1951, about which he had written many poems. 
 By 1974 he was able to publish his 75 Greek Poems: 1951&ndash;1974 . 
 It was the capital of Greece, Athens, that first captivated his mind; a very different place from the Decapolis of which he had written in &bquo;The Song Of The Hellenist&equo;, and light years away from the London from which he had fled. 
 Here was the Acropolis, which had dominated the city since the second millennium BC, and older than Judaic Jerusalem (King David's city) by 500 years; the Agora, the civic centre, formerly situated between the Acropolis and the main gate to the city; both being crowned by the remains of the Parthenon, that geometric and architectural treasure widely copied &mdash; from Birmingham, England, to Nashville, Tennessee. 
 Here the streets were alive with the chatter of tongues from all over Europe and the Middle East &mdash; the central meeting place of cultures, philosophies and religions, in which many found their roots. 
 This was a city to get lost in, to come alive in, a city of immense contrasts, warmth and vitality. 
 &bquo;Athens, my chiefest joy,&equo; he had written several years before he got there in vivid anticipation; now he experienced its individual dynamic. 
 There was very little of his own faith to be seen in the city, even if he had wished to become involved. 
 By this time the Jewish community in Greece had dwindled to something like 6,000 (from the 11,000 which remained after the Nazi occupation; 75,000 having been liquidated). 
 His mind was elsewhere, exploring, recording, storing up scenes and experiences that would serve his work, even as the travel served his restless needs. 
 But it was the Greek islands on which his attention was finally fastened, notably Hydra (Ydra) in the Saronic Gulf, which had had an artistic community on it for some years. 
 (Missolonghi, on the mainland opposite, had been Lord Byron's pied-&aacute;-terre , where he died in 1824, with whom Leonard shared much, romantically and in the fuller Romantic sense.) 
 Here, on a small island of some 2,000 or so souls,  pocketed by the encircling hills around its charming port, was the ideal place for him to gather his thoughts and address himself more seriously than he had been able to do in busy Montreal, grim London or frenetic New York. 
 It was a place of solitude, of plodding donkeys (even today no cars are allowed on the island; nor would they get very far if they were); cold water and kerosene lamps. 
 In such primitive surroundings, amid the stunning beauties of the island and the glories of the Aegean, where fishermen still wrested a living from the sea and farmers scrabbled one from the land, Leonard found his peace; his &bquo;sitting-down time,&equo; as he called it, where he could &mdash; as all poets must &mdash; recollect in tranquillity. 
 Here he could live in virtually complete seclusion, at a fraction of the cost it would take in northern Europe or Canada; where the people were unconcerned as to who you were or what you did; and where breathtaking vistas opened up for the seeing &mdash; both external and internal. 
 Here Leonard discovered the Greek way of life &mdash; its alternating rhythms of work and leisure, both on the seasonal and the daily basis, which are so conducive to creative thought and achievement. 
 Here he was able to stand back from the onrush of western man and ask himself the real questions of life and meaning; get his young life, full and successful as it had been, into perspective. 
 Here he began to crystallise the wisdom of some of his best poetry, writing and songs; for it was here that he was reborn, where he truly began to find himself; where, not least, the music of Greece entered his soul, evoking earlier memories and melodies, combining with them to suggest a new style, a new mystique. 
 (&bquo;Filled with wonder at the sound of the bazouki,&equo; as Jacques Vassal commented; also emphasising Leonard's appreciation of Theodorakis's then emerging art.) 
 Perhaps the words of his &bquo;Old Dialogue&equo; ( Flowers for Hitler , p128) come from this time, overshadowed as they are with other meanings and claims: 
 Has this new life deepened your perceptions. 
 I suppose so. 
 Then you are being trained correctly. 
 for what? 
 If you knew we could not train you. 
 And it was here that he met Marianne, a young woman of great beauty, high intelligence, deep sympathy, and fun. 
 The gods had drawn them together, and together for 10 years or so they would make music, exploring the world and themselves, unharried by outside pressures, responding only to the more meaningful pressures of life and love. 
 Leonard had tried to get Elizabeth, his London girlfriend, to take the bold step of departure to Greece, but she had refused. 
 (She had not liked  his &bquo;famous blue raincoat&equo; either!) 
 On arriving he missed that female intimacy which had been so important a part of his life for many years. 
 He knew that &bquo;it was not good for man to dwell alone&equo;; and he sharply felt his loneliness. 
 He admired, and we may guess coveted, the warmth of relationships he saw around him. 
 One in particular caught his attention: a blonde couple by the name of Jensen, Norwegians, who had sailed to the island on their 16&mdash;foot boat along with their young son, Axel. 
 Like Leonard, they were given to the literary life. 
 Leonard was actually looking in a shop window when he first saw them, noticing Marianne &mdash; naturally &mdash; first! 
 She took his breath away, as she did most men's. 
 He never realised, on that eventful day, that she would &bquo;come into my arms&equo; (as he put it) and stay there for so many years, adding in no small degree to the legends of love which keep the world sane and hopeful. 
 There was serious work, however, at hand for Leonard. 
 His writing, prose and poetry demanded rigorous attention, and received it with the same daily routine that he had established earlier: three pages a day, writing and rewriting, creative and self-critical. 
 Moreover, he had added to his possessions a piece of luggage of inestimable value for now - and for the next 30 or so years: his Olivetti 22 portable typewriter, which he had bought in London for &pound;40, no small investment for those days. 
 There were also the calls from home with which, throughout this period and always, he was to keep in close contact. 
 He had built, or at least started to build, a public (in the Kierkegaardian sense: &bquo;a gigantic something, an abstract and deserted void which is everything and nothing&equo;) and he was determined to stay true to it; recognising that publicity is the lifeblood of an author. 
 As ever, his world was split into two contradictory rhythms: solitude and company, his own tough self-criticism and the adulation of those around him: ambiguities converging, and testing. 
 In November 1959 he found himself back in Montreal, &bquo;to renew his neurotic affiliations&equo; as he was to repeat endlessly to journalists; meeting his friends and family, sometimes bumping into his uncles who would take him for expensive meals at top restaurants &mdash; such as the Ritz &mdash; and hotels; and generally awakening and reawakening those impulses and memories which would fire his imagination and energise his mind for months to come. 
 He was due to join up with his old friend Irving Layton again, and former professor F.R. Scott at New York's prestigious YM/YWCA centre on 92nd Street. 
 Here they gave poetry readings in the 800-seat auditorium; a measure of the man he was becoming and of the distinguished company he kept. 
 It was serious stuff, this poetry, Leonard's now suntanned complexion adding to the prophetic tones as he came, Elijah-like, out of his own wilderness experience. 
 (Scobie  correctly urges this background in prefacing his comments on Leonard's work, but fails to mention, alongside Canada's vastness, the particular Jewish motif by which all prophets found their calling; similarly he omits reference to Leonard's own &bquo;wilderness experience&equo;, on Hydra.) 
 Distanced from the day-to-day world of his youthful and not-so-youthful listeners, he could speak with all the more understanding, all the more authority, to their needs. 
 He was already on the way to establishing his role as a leading spokesman for the &bquo;sixties generation&equo; &mdash; a generation that was forced to handle change as never before, as Bernard Levin commented, in &bquo; The Pendulum Years &equo;: 
 fashions changed and changed again, changed faster and still faster: fashion in politics, in political style, in causes, music, in pop-culture, in myth, in education, in beauty, in heroes and idols, in attitudes, in responses, in work, in love and friendships, in food, in newspapers, in entertainment&hellip; 
 What had once lasted a generation now lasted a year, what had lasted a year now lasted a month, a week, a day. 
 There was a restlessness in the time that communicated itself everywhere and to everyone, that communicated itself to the very sounds in Britain's air, the stones beneath Britain's feet. 
 And not just in Britain either, though it was now setting the pace - or at least contributing its own in all these fields. 
 Though not in poetry, whose influence now chiefly came from America and Canada. 
 At such meetings he kept himself in touch with the constantly changing scene of poetry, the new faces which appeared, the old names which disappeared. 
 And it was fast changing. 
 Between 1959 and 1969 poetry production was to triple, thanks to the industrious imagination of such as Phyllis Webb, Eli Mandel, Daryl Hine and not least that battery-hen of poets, Irving Layton, to name but a few. 
 Comparisons were now being made between it and that of Britain and the USA in the thirties, when names such as T.S. 
 Eliot, W.H. Auden, Ezra Pound, Stephen Spender, Louis MacNeice, Barker, Karl Shapiro and Randal Jarrell were exerting a telling influence. 
 Moreover, Canada itself was changing &mdash; in the great building programmes in and around Montreal (not least at McGill itself, one of whose schemes resulted in the superb McLennan Library) and, more ominously, in the growth of separatism that was about to rock, in Pierre Trudeau's words, &bquo;the smug complacency&equo; of English-Canada, the Canada of the WASPS (&bquo;White, Anglo-Saxon and Protestant&equo;) and of the Roman Catholic Church, a party to the &bquo;Quiet Revolution&equo;. 
 Leonard was keen to assert his own lead in that movement, for it was during this time that he was compiling his second book (five years after the first) The Spice-Box Of Earth , which was published in 1961 to great critical acclaim. 
 If Let Us Compare Mythologies  is a young man's book, this is one (though still of a young man, at 26) that offers poetic  maturity, whose lyrics are charged with that mellow wistfulness, that trembling of angst , that vibration of incipient guilt and the plunging sensuality of a knowing, searching man; a book whose range &mdash; for all that &mdash; is narrower than Let Us Compare Mythologies . 
 As Professor Pacey then judged him, &bquo;easily the most promising in this group of young poets.&equo; 
 The spice-box itself is one of the most suggestive symbols in Judaism; one which forcefully elucidates the Sabbath festivities, or at least their completion. 
 Whatever we may make of Leonard's Judaism, he is a man seized by its traditions, its scriptures and their imagery. 
 His mind is replete with it, and no real understanding of it, as expressed in poetry or song, should omit it. 
 In the simple Sabbath ceremonies, much of Judaism's genius finds expressive recollection. 
 It is a wonderful experience to sit with him in the quiet peacefulness of his home, the table cleared (in addition to having had the house duly cleaned by his &bquo;daily&equo;) to make room for the Sabbath candles, its bread and wine. 
 Most of all to listen to that deep reflective voice reciting the blessings, in Hebrew; a service which touches the very soul of the traditions, as well as the souls of those who are privileged to share them with him. 
 &bquo;The Sabbath is made for man,&equo; and with its unpretentious yet pregnant ceremony a special grace overcomes those present. 
 The incense-burner of old Israel, the besamin , is no longer; the violent fury of man against the Chosen People has done its work and eliminated many of the ceremonies and practices. 
 Replacing them at a familial level, the spice-box has taken its place, sometimes simple, sometimes ornate; a witness to the fragrance of that Sabbath grace that lingers still. 
 Whether Leonard shares the old belief that the spice-box also honours Adam, who was supposed to have been bestowed with a &bquo;higher soul&equo; on the Sabbath, we cannot say. 
 But it is certain that he, like the Jews of old, knows that, &bquo;we are the Adam of our souls&equo;; each has its own opportunities, each its own triumphs, failures and guilts. 
 He bears witness to this, and to the whole man (as ever), with particular distinction in this new book. 
 Scobie is surely right when, with regard to Let Us Compare Mythologies  he says that the title &bquo;seems to indicate that Cohen himself regarded the religious sense as the primary one&equo; &mdash; which in The Spice-Box Of Earth  becomes completely explicit and even urgent. 
 The ceremony of the havdalah , the bidding adieu to the Sabbath, centres on the spice-box and the candle. 
 The blessing itself is made over a cup of wine in honour of the day (&bquo;Blessed art Thou, O Lord our God, King of the universe, who createst divers kinds of spices&equo;) which adds to the light of the Sabbath, symbolised by the candle, offering a fragrance and a beauty all its own. 
 Leonard extends this sense here in this book &mdash; to those who will read and ponder. 
 The book was offered with a sharp recollection of his own family, not only regarding his  father's absence of many years (whose duty it was, formally, to say the prayer), but in the dedication of the book, another link with the past broken, another mainstay, albeit distant, removed: &bquo;This book is dedicated to the memory of my grandmother Mrs Lyon Cohen, and to the memory of my grandfather Rabbi Solomon Klinitsky.&equo; 
 The familial links are not wanting in the poetry either. 
 Beautiful is the one titled &bquo;Priests 1957&equo; (in honour of the family name, as well as its traditions and responsibilities; The Spice-Box Of Earth , p78): 
 Beside the brassworks my uncle grows sad, 
 discharging men to meet the various crises. 
 He is disturbed by greatness 
 and may write a book. 
 My father died among old sewing machines, 
 echo of bridges and water in his hand. 
 I have his leather books now 
 and startle at each uncut page. 
 Cousins in the factory are unhappy. 
 Adjustment is difficult, they are told. 
 One is consoled with a new Pontiac, 
 one escapes with Bach and the folk-singers. 
 Must we find all work prosaic 
 because our grandfather built an early synagogue? 
 His tone is one of sadness, of a great day now passed, of his uncles' and cousins' deep sense of loss &mdash; which he shared &mdash; of the death of his father (again), and of the disenchantment with their present, pedestrian lives in the light of the splendid triumphs of the past. 
 (The reference to one escaping with &bquo;Bach and the folk-singers&equo; is to himself.) 
 It haunted, it tyrannised  their lives, not least his own. 
 As he said (through the journal of his grandfather) &bquo;I will never be free from this old tyranny: I believe with a perfect faith&hellip;&equo; (which is how the statement of faith called the 13 creeds begins). 
 But we should also note (as the critics largely did not) the positive values he inculcates in such reflections, with which he concludes his piece: &bquo;Must we find all work prosaic&hellip;?&equo; 
 It is typical of him to assert, as Judaism does roundly, that all work is honourable; and deny that the reliance on special work and destiny (&bquo;God's work&equo;) elevates a man per se . 
 Not so! asserts our poet &mdash; there is no  difference between the sacred and the secular, prayer or work (which have the same root in Hebrew); &bquo;oneness&equo; will out! 
 If Let Us Compare Mytholoqies  marks the awakening of his poetic consciousness when the city of Montreal (and all that was in it, not excluding its female charms) &bquo;began to jump at me,&equo; The Spice-Box Of Earth  marks the heightening of his Jewish consciousness which he  encountered in young adulthood, as a free agent abroad in the world, having to establish his own identity at a time when his own Tradition, and his position in it, began likewise to jump at him. 
 Noteworthy is a second dedication in this regard, of a single poem to Marc Chagall (also a Russian Jew of hasidic extraction) whose rich symbolism entranced Leonard. 
 (Nearly 30 years after writing it Leonard was enthusiastically recommending our attendance at a Chagall exposition on Sherbrooke Street.) 
 Aniela Jaff has spoken of &bquo;the mysterious and lonely poetry,&equo; which she finds in Chagall's art, a &bquo;ghostly aspect of things that only rare individuals may see,&equo; which very much encapsulates Leonard's work, too. 
 Commented Chagall himself, &bquo;Everything may change in our demoralised world except the heart, man's love, and his striving to know the divine. 
 Painting, like all poetry, has its part in the divine&hellip;&equo; 
 Leonard's poem, &bquo;Out Of The Land Of Heaven&equo; majestically captures that noble spirit, as it does the depth and beauty of human love and the song to which it gives birth. 
 It was a consciousness of joy and pain, of celebration and concern, of thinking and feeling, of hope and despair. 
 Through it all the words dance like butterflies and dart like wasps. 
 Sandra Djwa argues that &bquo;its lost ideals&equo; are reworked as a Neo-Hasidic myth, and comments that &bquo;the poet as priest is forced beyond Genesis&equo; (sic); elsewhere she adds a description of Leonard as &bquo;the exiled poet priest of The Spice-Box Of Earth .&equo; 
 Commented Al Purdy, &bquo;with (this book) Cohen brought to near perfection the techniques and rhythms of his first book&equo;; Eli Mandel &mdash; one of Canada's most astute critics &mdash; speaks of it as &bquo;a kind of gloss&equo; to the Sabbath service, noting its rich diversity in subject and tone, and emphasising that it is &bquo;not a random collection of lyrics. 
 It is unified, powerfully, by recurrent patterns and an informing theme.&equo; 
 But he is wrong to say that it is a gloss &mdash; especially as a rabbinic scholium ! &mdash; on the Sabbath service only, and to hang (as he does) all his review from it. 
 Leonard makes his own point powerfully enough by placing that very reflective ode to freedom, &bquo;A Kite Is A Victim&equo;, first in the collection. 
 That is the emphatic point; the tone of the book, its whole direction, is thereby established. 
 Mandel is right about its being &bquo;unified powerfully&equo;, but the principle of unity centres on &bquo;freedom&equo;, not the Sabbath ceremonies (intrinsic, as they are, to Leonard's conception of freedom); which merely protects  (when allowed to do so) that freedom. 
 The kite is the representative image of freedom, of which Scobie commented, &bquo;it is one of Cohen's most successful and most richly complex images&equo;; which Ondaatje highlights as &bquo;symbolic of our ego and our ambition, of all that is original and free in us.&equo; 
 To a child of the thirties and forties there was no better symbol. 
 The kite is &bquo;a contract of glory&equo;, a signing between heaven and earth, which needs  both parties for  its sustaining. 
 Though apparently  free, it needs its controller; but the controller must release it to the natural powers, the wind and the air-thermals, if he wants to enjoy its flights. 
 It is a picture of interdependency, not mere independence; it is a freedom of restraint, not unconstrained licence. 
 As T.S. 
 Eliot remarked in another regard, &bquo;No association is free for the man who wants to do a good job,&equo; for the &bquo;religious&equo; man not least, and for a Cohen most of all. 
 The second poem, &bquo;After The Sabbath Prayers&equo; is placed second in deference to this, directing and interpreting the symbolism of the kite. 
 Wholly in the spirit of that imagery is his vision of the Baal Shem's butterfly &mdash; so much like a kite! &mdash; which followed him down the hill. 
 A more powerful figure it would not be possible to evoke from one of Leonard's background, for it captures a significance which the kite could not: that man is only one of many free creatures, subject with them all to a higher power and influence. 
 The name &bquo;Baal Shem&equo; means &bquo;Lord (or Master) of (God's) Name&equo;. 
 Though applied to others of a given authority or holiness, it refers principally to one of the most influential personages in Ashkenazi (eastern European) Judaism, who followed the Palestinian traditions (as opposed to the Babylonian ones represented in its version of the Talmud): Israel ben Eliezer (Leonard's spiritual forebear, after whom he was named) &mdash; an 18th century Pole, the founder of the Hasidic movement; one whose religious awareness was very close to that which inspired Leonard, his mother and his grandfather Klinitsky-Klein. 
 (This represents another divergence between Masha Cohen and her sisters-in-law. 
 They, as became self-conscious representatives of the Cohen tradition &mdash; austere, genteel, &bquo;polished&equo; &mdash; were not taken to the spontaneous expressions of liveliness which Masha's Judaism exhibited. 
 Indeed, they could be offended by it. 
 Masha merely felt put down by the hauteur  she felt, even if not intended.) 
 And we may see another reason for the ambiguity in Leonard: Ashkenazi Jews expressed themselves in Yiddish, which was not merely their language (resting on 16th-century Middle High German and many Slavic loan-words) but in a particular sense a reflection of their world, their universe. 
 Sephardic Jews, who are descended from Western Europe (Spain and Portugal; but also the Middle East and North Africa), expressed themselves through their own languages, but were always more &bquo;intellectual&equo;, more philosophical &mdash; in the Aristotelian sense - more scientific and commercial, and more open to syncretism (e.g. with Islamic and Christian modes of thought) than their Eastern brethren. 
 But it was that cultural milieu , as expressed through the left-wing Federico Gar&ccedil;ia Lorca, that Leonard reacted to and espoused in his youth! 
 In it collided two incompatible forces, mental and emotional,  alienating him from his own tradition &mdash; to which he was deeply fettered. 
 The BeSHT &mdash; ben Eliezer is known by that acronym &mdash; produced a shock-wave of such proportions in Judaism that it has still not recovered from him. 
 It is said that his influence came through his extraordinary power, both learned and &bquo;uncanny&equo;, to rearrange suggestively the letters of the divine Name (the Tetragrammaton: YHWH), which are so sacrosanct that they are considered to be unpronounceable. 
 &bquo;The Name&equo; has been the Holy of Holies to all Jews since it was given to Moses as a special revelation of the divine essence; all other holinesses merely subserve it. 
 We find allusive reference to it from time to time in Leonard's writings and songs &mdash; always with a frisson  of awe. 
 Ben Eliezer was able to channel some of that power, by which Jewry worldwide was hugely influenced. 
 He was by profession a melamed , a Hebrew school-teacher, not even of rabbinic standing. 
 But so seized was he by the divine knowledge, so &bquo;evangelistically&equo; fixed with its potency, that his exploits on its behalf quickly created his legend. 
 In essence his message was very simple, as the products of such geniuses tend to be. 
 It was, &bquo;Love God, love the Law, love mankind.&equo; 
 It gave rise not only to a new religious movement of tremendous vitality, but also to tales of miracles and wonders. 
 Moreover, he was a warm-blooded man, who respected and enjoyed his humanity, and sought to encourage his followers to do so too. 
 Judaism, as we have seen, has always emphasised the wholeness of man's nature and sought to sustain it. 
 The BeSHT did more; he promoted it to a higher level of importance; he confirmed and extended the principle of enjoyment, bringing it much more centrally in to the people's worship as a sense of divine gladness. 
 With his teachings and observances they could sing and dance, laugh and exult before God &mdash; as David did of old, as other psalmists did, as Miriam the prophetess and Moses himself did in his own Victory Song over the Egyptians. 
 The everyday things of life were the greatest gifts to ben Eliezer; even as the human heart was the most appropriate place of worship. 
 Two Hasidic sayings exemplify this particularly: &bquo;The best synagogue is the human heart,&equo; and &bquo;The heart is half prophet.&equo; 
 Jonathan Eibeschutz, a Polish authority on the Cabala, similarly commented when he said, &bquo;Man's heart is the holy of holies.&equo; 
 It adds significantly to Masha Cohen's constant advice to her son throughout his life: &bquo;follow your little heart.&equo; 
 Prayer itself therefore had to be personal, spontaneous and joyous. 
 The felicity of God was not a piece of theological reasoning, but an essential part &mdash; a large and essential part &mdash; of God's being and the world's essence. 
 So The Spice-Box Of Earth  teems with this joyous response; it fills one's nostrils with its fragrance; it delights one's palate with its savouriness. 
 Even as the BeSHT delighted his listeners  with his pearls of wisdom, his stunning turns-of-phrase, his aphoristic acuity, so Leonard was learning his own, parallel metier; the butterfly was following him down the hill. 
 The negative side of all this was ben Eliezer's polemics against straight-faced, over-serious rabbinism; against those whose understanding of God's nature was austere and unfatherly; those who, while seeking to elevate the Most High, merely put him out of touch with his own children; debarred them from his welcoming presence by a system or learning that became &bquo;frivolous&equo; in its intensity: not that its perpetrators could be frivolous: black was their colour, even as severity was their posture &mdash; as becomes the frozen-in-soul. 
 For such, God only frowns on the world, and stirs it to judgment; the butterfly cannot break loose into flight; it merely expires, as Leonard expressed it, ending &bquo;its life in three flag-swept days.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was hard for Satan alone to mislead the whole world,&equo; declared the grandson of the BeSHT, Nachman of Bratislava, in one of his more caustic diatribes, &bquo;so he appointed rabbis in different locations.&equo; 
 And not only rabbis, one might add, but priests and nuns, monks, ministers and bishops! 
 The BeSHT became so influential that the leaders of the people, the power-manipulators and self-appointed guardians of the Law, had no alternative but to do what their like has always done to those who broke loose, butterfly-like: They excommunicated him; marginalised his usefulness; neutered his religious potency: &bquo;A prophet is not without honour&hellip;&equo; 
 Now one of the interesting cameos of God's providence, prominently found in the Talmud and among the Hasidim, is the idea that in every generation are 36 tsadihim , pious or righteous men, who (though unknown) keep the world going. 
 The Hasidim idealised them, regarded them as intermediaries between God and his world. 
 They are the Saints (the Lamed-vov tsadihim , the 36 saints) who perpetuate the principles of compassion and kindness which sustain life. 
 This pity, compassion or mercy, is quintessentially Jewish hasidic; to such God is essentially the God of Mercy and Compassion. 
 As against that central epithet of the rabbis, the justice of God, they posited the creative, life-giving and life-nurturing aspect of mercy . 
 Sainthood and mercy are entities of the most considerable sort in Leonard Cohen's work, as we shall see. 
 Stephen Scobie, in emphasising the motif of sainthood in Leonard's writing, completely omits reference to this key Jewish emphasis, which would have prevented him from some of his more questionable comments, such as the reference to them as &bquo;social outcasts&equo;. 
 Whether that is so in other societies, which is highly questionable, is irrelevant. 
 Their rejection did not make of them &bquo;social outcasts&equo; (save to the unseeing) but raised their mark intensely: they were closest to God. 
 In Judaism they were venerated  &mdash; which is the position they obtain in Leonard's writing.  
 It is difficult to comprehend to what extent Leonard felt the sense of this over-arching, life-elevating principle. 
 But it is very clear that it is present, though at times its influence waxed and waned. 
 It is surely part of the ambiguity of his person, as well as of his work, whether &bquo;priestly&equo; or &bquo;prophetic&equo;. 
 What, after all, is the difference between a priest acting in the highest sense of his vocation, or a prophet compelled into declamation, or such a saint (even unknowing), opening himself up to the mercies of God, becoming a channel for them to the world? 
 One thing is certain, that those of them &mdash; priests, prophets or saints &mdash; who did so respond, were usually rejected. 
 Not made &bquo;outsiders&equo; as Scobie argues, but marginalised, neutered: precisely because they were too near the centre of things; dangerous catalysts. 
 &bquo;It is better that one man should die&hellip;&equo; was not infrequently their lot. 
 Said Leonard, at the point of disclosure (&bquo;After The Sabbath Prayers&equo;, The Spice-Box Of Earth , p10): 
 And how truly great 
 A miracle this is, that I, 
 Who this morning saw the Baal Shem's butterfly 
 Doing its glory in the sun, 
 Should spend this night in darkness, 
 Hands pocketed against the flies and cold. 
 It was never different. 
 It is difficult to react adequately to George Woodcock's silly comment that in Leonard's first two books of poetry &bquo;the thirties urge to relate the imagery of poetry to the world we live in, as the world we dream, might never have existed.&equo; 
 Spender's and Auden's world for example, as well as their views of it, were broken on the anvil of history; that ideology was bankrupted &mdash; and they themselves acknowledged it and moved on. 
 Poets do not necessarily  have to be commentators on the historic present; there is a world within as well as a world without. 
 Leonard believed that they interconnected more than he is given credit for; he chose to speak of that one within, though not absolutely. 
 The generation that rediscovered the existential  was precisely the one best fitted to look and think &bquo;within&equo;, which is not unrealism, but a different form of realism &mdash; and one unavoidable to such as Leonard, given the horrors inflicted on his own people by the most &bquo;culturally advanced&equo; nation of the day. 
 A.M. Klein, a Jewish Montreal poet of considerable skill understood the matter, as Woodcock could not: 
 Not sole was I born, but entire genesis: 
 for to the father that begat me, this 
 Body is residence. 
 Corpuscular, 
 They dwell in my veins&hellip; 
 (&bquo; A Psalm Touching Genealogy &equo;)  
 If Leonard appeared in his first book to invite comparisons, now he made statements, claims, and most of all, confessions. 
 Ondaatje perceived this and described the book as being &bquo;far nastier and more frightening&equo; than Flowers For Hitler ; but the choice of words is unjust: there is nothing nasty or frightening about honest observation. 
 Such value-judgments surely arise out of the critics' disappointment at finding negative aspects in an otherwise positive projection, an all-  to  -human aspiration for avoiding reality which Leonard refuses to do, to his great cost. 
 Manzano has drawn attention to a real difference when he says (of both these first books), &bquo;In general Cohen is lyrical in his writings when he refers to himself, and anarchistic when he confronts the outside world,&equo; a comment which becomes more fully justified as time goes by, though Leonard's anarchism remained personal and mainly verbal. 
 He is wont to talk of the new vision that Lorca's poetry gave to him; &bquo;here is my landscape,&equo; he exclaimed repeatedly. 
 But that other &bquo;landscape&equo;, quieter perhaps, but like an underground stream, unconscious and very persistent, never failed to obtrude itself on him: &bquo;It is strange that even now prayer is my natural language,&equo; he said, in &bquo;Lines From My Grandfather's Journal&equo; (The Spice-Box Of Earth, p10) which powerfully reflect his own self-questionings; the &bquo;tyranny&equo; was asserting itself. 
 He went on to speak of it thus: 
 My journal is filled with combinations. 
 I adjust prayer like the beads of an abacus&hellip; 
 Thou&hellip; 
 The language in which I was trained: spoken in despair of priestliness  (our italics)&hellip; 
 In my work I meant to love you, but my voice dissipated&hellip; 
 I played with the idea that I was Messiah&hellip;&equo; 
 And yet he speaks with painful recollection of the sense of alienation he felt at times, &bquo;&hellip; 
 I stood outside my community, like the man who took many steps on Sabbath&equo;; (concluding) &bquo;I will never be free from this tyranny.&equo; 
 But it is not a conclusion: &bquo;All my family were priests, from Aaron to my father,&equo; suggesting that on the family's spice-box should be inscribed (as was the old custom): 
 Lead your priest 
 from grave to vineyard. 
 Lay him down 
 where earth is sweet. 
 Even in death he is willing to work at the vine (the biblical symbol of the Chosen People), suggesting in &bquo;Credo&equo; that the work, however unlikely it appears, is going on; &bquo;the holy promised land&equo; is being peopled: &bquo;the feet of fierce or humble priests trample out the green&equo;; he among them, despite putative evidence to the contrary. 
 We should note that it is the spice-box of earth . 
 Among the exquisitely pungent thoughts of self, of responsibility and tradition,  stands the one who was powerfully driven by his sensual nature, by his personal loneliness, by the intense need to be one not only with the One, but also with the many in human completion. 
 Indeed, as we shall presently see, the two great intimacies &mdash; as ever &mdash; sharply reacted with each other, strengthening the conflict, heightening the ambiguity, posing in ever more painful interjections the question, &bquo;Who am I?&equo; 
 One cannot write of &bquo;the real world&equo; till such a question has been answered. 
 It is this question which is the ultimate one; the others are a screen to hide modern man from his real self, as T.S. 
 Eliot found. 
 Yet there is a deeper, yet more exultant sense of the delights of love, of its mellifluous sensuality, in this second book than in the first; though Scobie overstates his case when he claims it as &bquo;nothing more than a joyous celebration (of love) richly seasoned.&equo; 
 (His view of sex seems to suffer from the same &bquo;Pharisaical&equo;, constraints that ben Eliezer fought against, when he condemns &bquo;Celebration&equo; as &bquo;a failure of tone,&equo; &bquo;portentous&hellip; imagery and the reality of the blow-job.&equo; 
 It is, as is so often the case in criticism of Leonard's work, a travesty of Pope's high standards, a supra-imposing of the critic's personal standards not dispassionate appraisal.) 
 There are fine expressions of true sensuality in this book, and great gratitude to those he left behind: Anne (in &bquo;For Anne&equo;); Annie (in &bquo;Now Of Sleeping&equo;); Betty (in &bquo;The Boy's Beauty&equo;: for Betty , his italics); and beyond those unnamed lovers of yesteryear, not a few who responded to his charm and wit. 
 Longing was the key: &bquo;I long to hold some lady,&equo; a longing that was inexhaustible, tumultuous and yet ardently romantic. 
 It finds full expression in &bquo;When I Uncover Your Body&equo; ( The Spice-Box Of Earth , p39):  
 When I uncovered your body 
 I thought shadows fell deceptively, 
 urging memories of perfect rhyme. 
 I thought I could bestow beauty 
 like a benediction and that your half-dark flesh 
 would answer to the prayer. 
 I thought I understood your face 
 because I had seen it painted twice 
 or a hundred times, or kissed it 
 when it was carved in stone. 
 With only a breath, a vague turning, 
 you uncovered shadows 
 more deftly than I had flesh, 
 and the real and violent proportions of your body 
 made obsolete old treaties of excellence, 
 measures and poems,  
 and clamoured with a single challenge of personal beauty, 
 which cannot be interpreted or praised: 
 it must be met. 
 Lineation guessed at in following poem 
 In its fulfilment Leonard found solace from the angst  which gnawed at his soul, a sublime escape from the rigorous demands imposed upon him. 
 He is the poet par excellence  (and later, the singer/ songwriter par excellence ) of the two great intimacies &mdash; woman and God - because he found refuge from the One in the other; when accidie  impinged, Cupid intervened. 
 Eros is, after all, not so far from Agape in the pantheon of the heart. 
 Another expression of this psychic force is found in the cynicism and bitterness he displayed from time to time when he grumbles about the dark, the flies and the cold; but other references are very much stronger, e.g. &bquo;The Cuckold's Song&equo; etc). 
 This is not new to Canadian poetry, as Desmond Pacey declares, not least of A.J. M. Smith's poetry. 
 &bquo;Smith's chief themes are loneliness, and death, fear and renunciation&hellip; nowhere in modern poetry can one find such concentrated agony.&equo; 
 An aspect omitted by Dudek in his description of Smith's work. 
 In a later book ( Book Of Mercy , 1984) Leonard speaks of &bquo;the two shields of bitterness and hope,&equo; once again contradictions emerging, complementaries offered, by which the psychological and spiritual mechanisms of &bquo;balance&equo; and &bquo;equilibrium&equo; are secured. 
 The reason for the exultation, the explanation of how this sense of craving had been mollified and a sense of sexual peace bestowed on the lyrics was simple: Marianne had come into his arms; that golden apparition of loveliness, that lithe, sensuous, intelligent being of intuition and sympathy; a gift of the gods to rank &mdash; and outrank &mdash; anything so far told in the surrounding mythology of his adopted Greek homeland! 
 He has memorialised their encounter and its temporary effect upon his deeper self, the depths of feeling he had for her, in his significantly titled poem &bquo;Destiny&equo; ( Flowers for Hitler ): 
 Destiny has fled and I settle for you 
 who found me staring at you in a store 
 one afternoon four years ago 
 and slept with me every night since. 
 How do you find my sailor eyes after all this time? 
 Am I what you expected? 
 Are we together too much? 
 Did Destiny shy at the double Turkish towel, 
 our knowledge of each other's skin, 
 our love which is a proverb on the block, 
 our agreement that in matters spiritual 
 I should be the Man of Destiny  
 and you should be the Woman of the House? 
 Perhaps nowhere else is the mood and tone of love more beautifully expressed than in his poem &bquo;Beneath My Hands&equo; ( The Spice-Box Of Earth ): 
 Beneath my hands 
 your small breasts 
 are the upturned bellies 
 of breathing fallen sparrows. 
 Whenever you move 
 I hear the sounds of closing wings 
 of falling wings. 
 I am speechless 
 because you have fallen beside me 
 because your eyelashes 
 are the spines of tiny fragile animals. 
 The sense of delight, of gentle wonder, the startled realisation of his sense of her bodily perfection and spiritual grace is consummated not merely in their mutual passion but more enduringly in that oneness which is beyond time and space, which understands the fragility of love as well as its strengths, its ethereal qualities as well as its physical needs. 
 To the musician in Leonard she was a melody, to the poet a lyric, to the singer a song: poetry in motion and melodiously sweet. 
 It is not surprising that he found in addition to writing about her, he had to sing about her, too. 
 Irving Layton found it too much, this eximious union of contrasts. 
 Even his extraordinarily fecund language struggled to reassert the recollection: &bquo;the ideal couple,&equo; &bquo;the beautiful inspiration,&equo; &bquo;illusion and reality,&equo; (by which he meant that it was simply too good to be true; too perfect to last &mdash; a forbidding afterthought). 
 For her intelligence, beauty and charm he had the highest admiration; it evoked a poem &bquo;Party At Hydra: For Marianne &equo;. 
 She was the sort of woman to evoke poems, from Leonard not least, and lastingly. 
 The spice-box is delectable in its fragrance, Chagallian in its rich mixture of images and responses. 
 As Leonard expressed it in the poem which &mdash; in title and texture counterbalances the title of the book: 
 Out of the land of heaven Down comes the warm Sabbath sun. 
 As in Jacob's dream of old the movement is from earth to heaven. 
 The words he uses leap and tumble over each other to catch the exultant mood: &bquo;dancing&equo;, &bquo;brandishing&equo;, &bquo;chanting&equo;, &bquo;leaping&equo; and &mdash; most important of all &mdash; &bquo;gathering&equo;. 
 The questor was beginning to find,  the traveller beginning to arrive, the searcher beginning to secure. 
 Or was he? 
 Nudists May Be Encountered 
 What went with what? 
 Who was she today? 
 And why? 
 Naked, Julia stretched under the sheet, stretched so hard she pulled her stomach muscles to their full length. 
 With each day she spent in the sun these crucial questions mattered less. 
 Each evening, arriving at a new hotel, she carried from the car one suitcase, one shoulder bag, a striped beach bag and a Guernsey knotted round her shoulders. 
 Each morning she opened all her luggage, looked at the shirts and dresses and pairs of trousers, felt a moment's regret for a favourite red silk blouse, before choosing either the cotton shorts and the yellow tee shirt or the denim shorts and the pink top. 
 Sometimes she walked miles along the clifftops, taking no notice of the scenery. 
 Sometimes she stopped for hours to gaze across the sea, to peer between rocks, to watch an osprey ride the thermals. 
 Sometimes she ran &mdash; through the rare rain or to feel the wind on her face. 
 It was a just over a week since she had first set foot on the Dorset coast path. 
 Each night she spoke to a waiter to order a meal; each morning she asked for boiled rather than scrambled eggs for breakfast. 
 Otherwise she could not remember when she had last spoken to anyone. 
 There  was only the sun, the seaweed, the feel of pebbles, sand or shingle under her feet and a night asleep in a hotel room. 
 So it was a shock this morning, after miles of deserted sands, to come into a small crowded bay: to see buckets and spades and sandcastles, a parade of shops with fishing nets and beach balls and to return to a world of people. 
 She picked her way between them, treading with care so as not to shower things with sand. 
 A woman she passed was telling her husband to put on his shirt or he would bum. 
 She watched a wet swimsuit twisted from the body of a screaming toddler, and a beach towel making freakish shapes as the woman under it changed. 
 Julia turned away from the sea, stepped from sand onto concrete and settled herself at a terrace table outside a caf&eacute;. 
 She ordered a pot of tea for one. 
 She put on her sunglasses to decrease her visibility, but she could still see something of herself; brown knees, frayed cut-offs. 
 What kind of statement did she think she made? 
 It was certainly not one of the many studied effects which Paul had variously condemned as &bquo;ludicrous&equo;, &bquo;over the top&equo;, &bquo;outrageous&equo;, &bquo;dingy&equo;, or &mdash; most damaging of all &mdash; &bquo;silly&equo;. 
 How often had this meant an edgy evening, when she had been unable to concentrate on what people were saying because of an ill-placed fabric rose or an over-embroidered antique shawl? 
 Sometimes she was so brought down by one of his pronouncements that she had to change completely. 
 And then, because her first effort had been wrong, it was hard to know, now, if or when she was ready. 
 &bquo;Paul, what do you think of this? 
 Is it all right?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course it is. 
 How much longer are you going to be? 
 Anyway, no one will notice.&equo; 
 That always made her reach, in agitation, for something else, so that when they finally set off she was already exhausted and Paul was angry and full of contempt.  
 &bquo;You know how it is,&equo; he would say to their hosts, on the pretext of apologising for arriving late, &bquo;She couldn't find a thing to wear. 
 You should see the state of the bedroom. 
 It took her two hours to come up with that.&equo; 
 &bquo;You look lovely whatever you wear, Julia,&equo; someone would say. 
 It turned out Paul had been wrong. 
 The fact was that she had achieved something. 
 Won a national competition &mdash; well a competition in a national magazine &mdash; by imagining how to put together three exceptional outfits for three occasions: a job interview, meeting a partner's parents for the first time, and addressing a conference. 
 The competition set a fairly tight budget so Julia decided to mix second-hand clothes with new ones. 
 For the interview she opted for a cream silk shirt, and a tailored black skirt. 
 That would show she could fit in neatly anywhere. 
 She added something for the panel to remember her by &mdash; sheer seamed black tights with black and grey checked flat shoes and, on the lapel of her jacket, a blue glass antique brooch. 
 Her bag was also a surprise &mdash; a black purse sewn over with tiny blue beads and a thin, black shoulder strap. 
 The brooch and the bag would make it clear she had originality although, taken in the context of the rest of the outfit, not too much. 
 On a first visit to a partner's parents, she decided, she would want to make it clear that her relationship was primarily with him, not them. 
 The ensemble should, of course, not be too sexy, but polite, though not conciliatory &mdash; nothing that could suggest an inclination to join his mother in the kitchen to whip up a batch of fairy cakes. 
 It should be slightly, but only very slightly, bizarre and unmistakably modern. 
 That meant trousers. 
 She hit upon a pair of corduroy breeches which would fit snugly at the waist but balloon over the hips, with highly-polished brown leather boots for a touch of chic, a maroon Italian  sweater, which at 15p at a jumble sale had been a real snip, and a jaunty maroon beret. 
 The conference was easier. 
 She didn't have to worry what happened from the waist down as this would be hidden by the table holding her notes. 
 Other than that, it was important that she should look interesting so that even if what she said was dull the audience would not be bored; that the outfit should take account of the long range view &mdash; jewellery or other small items were irrelevant &mdash; and that it should draw attention to her face. 
 She defined the waist with a wide black leather belt, studded with silver. 
 The lines of the top must be simple, but eye-catching; she chose an emerald, short-sleeved sweater. 
 Over it, for dramatic effect, an old school blazer into which she would sew shoulder pads to make the silhouette wider. 
 No need for a hat, but the hair must be pulled off the face to minimise distraction and caught at the nape in a black band into which she would stick a single green feather. 
 That way, every time she turned her head to address one section of the audience, the rest of them would have something to be surprised about. 
 Julia tried it all out in the bedroom mirror. 
 She put a table in front of her to see how she would look from the lecture hall. 
 It was unfortunate that Paul came home just then. 
 His reaction might have been enough to make her call a halt to the whole thing. 
 He was particularly scathing about the feather, which she immediately agreed to be a mistake. 
 But she could do nothing about it. 
 She had been &bquo;carried away&equo; as Paul had put it. 
 She had already posted the entry. 
 &bquo;You were wrong,&equo; she said to Paul, when her prize of two hundred pounds arrived. 
 &bquo;I suppose you're going to spend it on even more clothes.&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 I'm going away. 
 For two weeks I think.&equo;  
 She packed a selection of outfits and drove south because it was the quickest way out. 
 Once clear of London she stopped, consulted the AA Handbook  and wondered, where next? 
 &bquo;Dorset,&equo; someone had said at a recent dinner. 
 &bquo;Wonderful place for a short break. 
 Absolutely unspoilt. 
 Spectacular scenery.&equo; 
 So here she was. 
 She had been lucky with the weather. 
 It was taking a risk, when she thought about it, to go to the seaside in September. 
 She stretched her legs under the table, feeling the same satisfaction that she felt when she woke that morning. 
 What went with what no longer mattered. 
 She wanted instead to wear fewer and fewer clothes, to have next to nothing left between her and the sun: to take off her shorts and let the sun's rays reach the tops of her thighs. 
 She jerked out of the caf&eacute; chair, paid for the tea and strode away from the crowd. 
 In pursuit of pleasure, not effect. 
 She settled on a slab of rock with her shorts rolled into a pillow. 
 That was better. 
 But her breast felt shifty under the pink top. 
 She sat up and looked around. 
 Further away the cliffs were higher, the strip of rocks narrower. 
 She hurried to the far end of the bay where the sun gazed from above the cliff with hot, friendly passion. 
 No one else was around. 
 Turning her back on the distant crowd, she sat and unbuttoned her top. 
 She tipped her face up to the sun. 
 But she was soon uncomfortable. 
 She could not turn round or lie down. 
 Someone might see and this was not Brighton and there were families about. 
 She buttoned up, put on her shorts, slung her bag over her shoulder and walked to the edge of the sea, then back again. 
 She walked past the crowded beach and the caf&eacute;. 
 She walked on and on, imagining herself utterly alone wearing nothing at all. 
 When she next looked inland, the terrain had changed to soft, silvery sand and rustling, bumpy dunes. 
 Half-way  between the dunes and the water stood a green sign, a foot high, no more. 
 She squatted down to read it, balancing on the balls of her feet. 
 On this part of the beach, she read, &bquo;Nudists May Be Encountered.&equo; 
 Nudists. 
 People with no clothes on. 
 She could lie in the sun; the wind could blow all over her, even, with careful positioning, the neglected places under her arms. 
 She found, as she walked on, that this place, like any other, had its etiquette. 
 People in swimsuits or shorts and tops strolled at liberty on the wide sands. 
 The unclothed, except when swimming, stayed in the background, secluded in the lee of a dune. 
 Finally she found an unoccupied hollow. 
 She dropped to her knees. 
 Tumbled out of her clothes. 
 She lay, as she had envisaged, on her back. 
 Heat sank unopposed through her skin. 
 A kaleidoscope of colour shifted behind her closed eyelids. 
 Perhaps she was asleep. 
 Or perhaps she was awake? 
 She made no effort to turn over, although she thought about it, imagined how it might be to lean on one elbow, to twist her body in a single movement. 
 Instead she opened her eyes and watched a small cloud move across the sky. 
 When it had gone she turned to watch the white waves roll up the beach then roll back. 
 Closer, there were her outstretched fingers to study as they burrowed through the sand. 
 Her cheeks, her stomach, her arms and her lower legs felt heavy, pressed under the weight of the sun, then light and drifting in its warmth. 
 Hours could have passed. 
 She sat up. 
 Others around her were standing, stretching, trying the water, strolling through the dunes. 
 Apart from one plump couple, they were all men. 
 Nude but not naked. 
 They wore things. 
 Things which left their genitals exposed. 
 One man had a rucksack, another a white cotton hat, a third an unbuttoned shirt, a fourth,  sandshoes. 
 It was, she supposed, a reduction of clothes to pure function &mdash; to protect one's head, back or feet from summer's elements. 
 Her own body was nearly ready again for clothes. 
 She felt tired, even exhausted from the powerful attentions of the sun. 
 And it was time to find a hotel. 
 &bquo;Would you talk to me for a few minutes?&equo; 
 A red nude man with black hair. 
 A bag, no other accessories. 
 &bquo;I was about to go.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just for a few minutes. 
 It'd make my day.&equo; 
 She glanced at her watch. 
 &bquo;All right.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you a naturist?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't mind me being like this?&equo; 
 He waved his hand in the direction of his lower half. 
 &bquo;Not at all.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mean you are  a naturist?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 I like taking my clothes off in the sun.&equo; 
 &bquo;May I sit down?&equo; 
 He did so. 
 There was a moment's pause. 
 &bquo;Your skin hasn't a single blemish,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;This is like Paradise. 
 I never imagined this would happen. 
 To sit like this with such a beautiful woman. 
 What more could any man ask?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know.&equo; 
 People with clothes on strolled by. 
 &bquo;Paradise.&equo; 
 he said again. 
 &bquo;So many people misunderstand what naturism is about.&equo; 
 &bquo;I expect so.&equo; 
 &bquo;The innocence. 
 You've no idea what this means to me. 
 You and I. Here. 
 Like Adam and Eve.&equo; 
 He extracted a small, oddly-shaped, yellow and white stone from the bag at his feet and offered it to her. 
 &bquo;Unusual, isn't it? 
 I found it further down the beach. 
 Feel how smooth it 
 &bquo;It looks it.&equo;  
 She took out her Ambre Solaire and rubbed a small amount on her nose. 
 &bquo;Could I borrow some?&equo; 
 He turned sideways, lying full length. 
 &bquo;My stern,&equo; tapping his buttocks, &bquo;can't take too much sun.&equo; 
 She handed him the tube, being fairly and correctly sure he would not ask her outright to rub it in for him. 
 They were sitting on opposite sides of the small hollow. 
 She gazing at the sea, he at her. 
 &bquo;Would you sit closer?&equo; he asked, smoothing the sand. 
 &bquo;We could talk better.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's all right. 
 I can hear what you say.&equo; 
 &bquo;I come to the beach every week. 
 Every Saturday at this time. 
 I could be here tomorrow too.&equo; 
 &bquo;This is a short holiday for me. 
 I'll be going soon.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let me show you something. 
 We'll have to stand.&equo; 
 He rose, flung his arms wide, took a deep inhalation of sea air and climbed the few paces to the top of the dune where he would be visible to the clothed. 
 &bquo;Come and see,&equo; he said. 
 She joined him. 
 &bquo;For two miles across the dunes,&equo; he waved his hand at the lumpy landscape, &bquo;there are walks for naturists. 
 Lovely places. 
 Really lovely. 
 Would you, I wonder, would you walk with me? 
 Just a short way? 
 We would be quite alone. 
 As though we were the first man and woman ever, walking in the Garden of Eden. 
 It would make the afternoon so beautiful.&equo; 
 Julia shook her head. 
 &bquo;I really do have to be going now,&equo; she said. 
 She began to dress. 
 &bquo;I could walk along the beach with you. 
 I'll put on my shorts if you like.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no. 
 You stay here. 
 There's at least an hour or so of sunshine left. 
 You enjoy yourself.&equo; 
 Julia walked the length of the beach to her car. 
 She did not look for a hotel. 
 She drove straight back to London where her wardrobe would be waiting.  
 LANGUAGE 
 Unlike many people, Rita did not write to The Times  deploring modern standards of English. 
 She preferred to make corrections on the spot. 
 Sometimes she did this by offering an incentive. 
 This afternoon in the market she negotiated the amendment of &bquo;Brokkoli&equo; on a hand-written sign by agreeing to buy two pounds of the vegetable &mdash; or to be precise, flower used as a vegetable. 
 Tom would resent having broccoli for dinner again, she knew. 
 But unfortunately it was misspelt far more often than peas or spring greens or even aubergine, although that, too, was a difficult word. 
 On other occasions Rita found, as she did with the children, that a certain sharp authority was more effective. 
 Today she decided that &bquo;house clearences&equo; lettered on a junk shop window was intolerable. 
 She went into the shop. 
 For a moment she stood in the doorway, allowing her eyes to adjust to the gloomy interior. 
 On either side furniture was piled in high, precarious heaps. 
 She could distinguish desks, tom chairs, filing cabinets and Beautility tables. 
 Further away, in the dim recesses of the shop, the individual items merged together, with just a leg discernible here, an upholstered arm protruding  there. 
 She stepped forward and discovered, sitting at a desk which stood the right way up, a small dark man. 
 &bquo;Your business cannot hope to succeed,&equo; she announced, her voice booming in the narrow space. 
 &bquo;First impressions count. 
 The impression your shop gives will deter potential customers.&equo; 
 She pointed her finger at the lettering on the window. 
 &bquo;The &bquo;E&equo; should be an &bquo;A&equo;.' 
 Later that afternoon, when she had finished her shopping and passed the shop a second time, she found the E had been changed to an A. Just as, when she informed her class of noisy fourteen-year-olds that there was to be &bquo;no more of that&equo;, there was no more. 
 When she arrived at the bus station she saw on the wall behind her bold, splashy writing in foreign characters, Arabic maybe or Urdu, and small, disordered scribbles around the glass faces of the timetables, which, although an irritation, caused Rita no real pain. 
 &bquo;Fred was here&equo;, &bquo;Mandy loves Greg&equo;, &bquo;Joey sucks&equo; were inane, but neither the grammar nor the spelling could be faulted. 
 On the bus home she passed, as usual, the new industrial estate. 
 Someone had painted an &bquo;I&equo; between the words &bquo;TO&equo; and &bquo;LET&equo; on the boarded up windows. 
 She left the bus, walked down the main road to the comer, turned into her own road and saw scrawled in black beneath her feet &bquo;cunt&equo;. 
 The word had not been there when she left that morning. 
 &bquo;Shit&equo; was painted on the next flagstone. 
 She scuffed at it with the tip of one brown brogue but it did not even smudge. 
 &bquo;Balls&equo; was the next word she came across, a few yards further on. 
 She accepted this was the kind of thing children wrote on the pavement nowadays. 
 But what had happened to hopscotch? 
 She remembered drawing with white chalk the six squares for hopping and, at the far end, a semicircle which she labelled &bquo;BED&equo;.  
 The words on the pavement were common currency nowadays; although Rita's mother would have found them deeply offensive. 
 &bquo;Language!&equo; her mother would cry when Rita or her brother Bob said even &bquo;crikey&equo; or &bquo;blimey&equo;. 
 Her mother's voice would fill with outrage. 
 Their grandmother, she said, would have washed out their mouths that instant with carbolic soap. 
 The threat was enough to stop Rita and Bob going as far as their friends with real rude words. 
 Instead they went in for archaic exclamations such as &bquo;Botheration!&equo; or made up their own: &bquo;Slitherkins!&equo; 
 &bquo;Pistoops!&equo; and the somehow more daring &bquo;Oh zags!&equo;. 
 Rita wheeled her tartan shopping trolley past &bquo;cock&equo; and &bquo;tit&equo;. 
 Remarkable, she thought, how many of these terms were familiar to quite young children. 
 Certainly, in her classroom, sex was the topic on which she knew their vocabulary to be widest, in spite of the fact that it didn't receive the level of attention she insisted they devote to the subjects on the curriculum. 
 She wheeled on. 
 &bquo;Brest&equo; stared up at her from the pavement. 
 She wheeled on again. 
 She reached her house. 
 Rita let herself into the house with the Yale. 
 The kitchen was already dark. 
 She looked through the french windows. 
 The back garden was a small square of lawn bordered by rhododendrons which, in turn, were surrounded by a high wattle fence. 
 Neither Rita nor Tom used the garden for anything apart from mowing and weeding. 
 She drew the curtains. 
 She went into the living room where she settled down at the dining table to mark compositions. 
 Why did so many of the children put the &bquo;e&equo; and the &bquo;i&equo; the wrong way round again in &bquo;their&equo;? 
 She circled &bquo;unnecessary&equo; in one effort, wrote in the margin of another &bquo;participal phrase must refer to grammatical subject&equo;. 
 Tom arrived at twenty to eight &mdash; on schedule for his daily journey from London. 
 He awarded Rita the  customary homecoming kiss. 
 It was a brief kiss but Rita no longer felt aggrieved by that. 
 &bquo;Had a good day? 
 What's for dinner?&equo; he asked. 
 She told him. 
 &bquo;Broccoli again,&equo; he said with little real enthusiasm. 
 He went upstairs. 
 There he would remove his jacket, his waistcoat and his tie, roll up his sleeves and wash his hands. 
 Possibly he also washed his face, she did not know, never having asked him. 
 Until bedtime, no further kiss would be offered in which, had it been, she might, or might not, have detected the scent of soap. 
 &bquo;How about your day?&equo; she asked, over dinner. 
 &bquo;Trouble with the trains again. 
 All very well them claiming these improvements to commuter lines. 
 No seven fifty-three this morning. 
 No eight o two. 
 I'd have taken my overcoat if I'd known. 
 You know how damp it was this morning. 
 I think I might have caught a cold.&equo; 
 &bquo;For them to claim&equo; would not have jarred the ear in the same way, she thought, but did not say. 
 After dinner he leaned back on the sofa, she sat upright across the room in a matching easy chair. 
 They watched News at Ten . 
 A junior Defence Minister attempted to explain that a bomb might easily be planted in a barracks: &bquo;Anyone could walk in as long as they were carrying a package which did not look suspicious.&equo; 
 &bquo;He means,&equo; said Rita, slowly, in her loud classroom voice, &bquo;anyone could walk in as long as he or she were not carrying a package that did look suspicious.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wanted to hear what else he had to say,&equo; complained Tom. 
 &bquo;An early night for me,&equo; was the next thing from him, while she stayed as always, to complete the Guardian  crossword. 
 &bquo;You go on up,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;There's some Lem Sip in the medicine cabinet.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about you?&equo;  
 &bquo;I'll just finish up in the kitchen.&equo; 
 For once her motive for staying downstairs was not to avoid the bedroom routine &mdash; his request and her reluctant compliance. 
 Tonight, her craving to correct had the sharp tingle of sherbert. 
 Silence upstairs. 
 Tom had settled down swiftly. 
 He might read for a while but he would not come downstairs, would not hear anything if she were quiet. 
 She found black paint in one of the kitchen cupboards, left over from the time Tom had painted the front door, and a brush. 
 She levered the lid off the pot with a screwdriver, stirred the contents, replaced the top lightly and loaded the lot, along with a small torch, into a shopping bag. 
 Less than half an hour later she cleaned the brush in white spirit and pressed the lid of the tin noiselessly down. 
 She went upstairs and completed the usual preparations for bed. 
 In the bathroom she slid dental floss in and out between her teeth. 
 She washed her face and smoothed cream over her skin. 
 In the bedroom she took off her blouse and skirt and hung them carefully in the wardrobe. 
 She folded her slip and draped it over a chair. 
 She added her underwear to Tom's Y-fronts in the laundry basket. 
 She slipped into her nightie and slid into bed beside Tom, who was asleep and breathing through his mouth. 
 She would not wake him or touch him or even lie close enough to feel his warmth. 
 In the beginning, more than fifteen years ago, when she was much slimmer and wore flared trousers, she seemed to enter a magnetic field whenever she came close to Tom. 
 Once within range, parts of her body could not be prevented from touching parts of his. 
 If she sat beside him her head would loll onto his shoulder and stay there for long moments. 
 If they were both standing, perhaps having drinks with friends, she would lean towards him and her glass would tilt and spill. 
 Her hands also behaved unexpectedly. 
 The heel of one of  them might massage his arm or the rough texture of his cheek. 
 Some of these incidents occurred, regrettably, in public. 
 Even after marriage, even in the bed in which she was now trying to lie disturbingly still, Tom was embarrassed by the caresses that brought Rita such pleasure. 
 With effort, vast at first, diminishing by slow degrees, she suppressed her body's compulsions. 
 And bit by bit their lovemaking turned into a dry ritual which caused Rita no actual pain, only a lingering, grey regret. 
 Eventually she found other things to do when, in his view, it was time to do that. 
 In the morning Tom said he had a cold. 
 Not bad enough, he judged, for him to stay in bed but bad enough to keep him at home. 
 Rita made sure that he had a supply of Kleenex and Lem Sip and left for school, approving on the way the neatness with which she had changed &bquo;brest&equo; to &bquo;breast&equo;. 
 Though to be really professional she should make corrections in red as she did in the children's books. 
 On the way back that afternoon she bought a can of red spray paint in a car accessories shop. 
 At home she found Tom looking better, though serious. 
 He blew his nose and said: &bquo;I don't have a cold. 
 I stayed home so we'd have time this evening. 
 I want to talk to you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can it wait till I've started dinner? 
 And corrected 4b's grammar?&equo; 
 &bquo;Can't you ever think about anything but correcting grammar?&equo; 
 &bquo;The compositions are always so bad I can only face them if I do so right away.&equo; 
 &bquo;This is important.&equo; 
 &bquo;4b's are the worst of all.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm seeing someone else.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why do none of the children distinguish between &bquo;it's&equo; and &bquo;its&equo;? 
 I've told them often enough.&equo;  
 &bquo;I've fallen in love with someone.&equo; 
 &bquo;They sprinkle commas around for absolutely no reason.&equo; 
 &bquo;She wants me to move in with her. 
 I told her I'd tell you today.&equo; 
 &bquo;Restrictive clauses, for instance. 
 There is just no justification.&equo; 
 &bquo;She wants to have children and you never did.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nominative not objective pronoun in a comparison where the verb is understood.&equo; 
 &bquo;I want to marry her. 
 I want a divorce.&equo; 
 &bquo;Imagine putting two &bquo;ts&equo; in writing.&equo; 
 &bquo;We can still be friends. 
 You know you've not been interested in sex for years.&equo; 
 She picked up the bag that held the can of red spray paint and left the living room in silence. 
 She stepped out of the front door and closed it behind her. 
 She stood on the pavement and pointed the spray can at the low brick wall of their front garden. 
 &bquo;Unclean&equo; she sprayed in bold script and below that &bquo;adulterer&equo;. 
 She moved to the neighbours' wall and sprayed &bquo;fornicator&equo; and &bquo;debauchee&equo;. 
 Next door but one came in for &bquo;concupiscence&equo; and &bquo;whoremonger&equo;. 
 By the third house she completed &bquo;lecher&equo;, &bquo;libertine&equo; and &bquo;licentious&equo; before she heard Tom mutter: &bquo;Rita, please. 
 People are looking.&equo; 
 She turned the spray and stained the white front of his shirt blood red, then turned back and slowly wrote &bquo;carnal knowledge&equo;, &bquo;impudicity&equo;. 
 Had she looked she would indeed have seen many faces peeking from behind twitched curtains, but she was too busy with &bquo;copulation&equo;, &bquo;coition&equo;, &bquo;clitoris&equo;, &bquo;testicles&equo; and &bquo;fuck&equo;. 
 By the time someone called the police the street boasted red descriptions of every aspect of straight sex along with some more arcane terms such as &bquo;fellatio&equo;, &bquo;cunnilingus&equo; and &bquo;onanism&equo;.  
 &bquo;It's quite all right,&equo; she said to the young, pink faced WPC. 
 &bquo;The can is, in any case, almost empty.&equo; 
 Rita sat in the back of the police car as she was told to do. 
 A broad shouldered constable sat beside her. 
 The young WPC drove. 
 At the police station Rita sat on a wooden bench and answered questions. 
 The policeman typed his version of what she said on an old manual Remington. 
 He finished typing, took the paper from the machine and gave it to her. 
 She examined the statement. 
 &bquo;Too many passive verbs,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Very common nowadays and makes for flabby, colourless prose. 
 I said I was &bquo;loath&equo; not &bquo;loathe&equo;. 
 Occurrence with an &bquo;e&equo; not an &bquo;a&equo;. 
 When a quotation is followed by an attributive phrase, the comma is placed within the quotation marks. 
 In all other respects I agree it is an entirely accurate record of the event.&equo;  
 THE RIGHT TO WORK 
 I haven't had a job for a year now. 
 I don't mean I'm unemployed, God forbid. 
 I go to work each day. 
 I have an office to myself. 
 I send minutes laid out in the proper style. 
 I even have a job title &mdash; Special Projects Officer &mdash; but I have no work. 
 Not since they abolished my real job. 
 They couldn't sack me, though. 
 I'd done nothing wrong. 
 At first it was a bit of a blow. 
 Having your real job abolished must mean there was no real job in the first place. 
 Or they didn't think there was. 
 Also it was hard to know what to say to Anne &mdash; that's my wife &mdash; when she asked each evening &bquo;How was your day?&equo; 
 It wasn't enough for her, after spending the day on her own, hoovering, shopping and running the washing machine, so she said, for me to retell a couple of jokes from the Telegraph  diary. 
 The problem was that there were no special projects. 
 I drew this to the attention of Mellowes, my line manager, at an early stage and he had made vague noises about something being in the pipeline. 
 I'm a civil servant; not very senior, but I get by. 
 And even though I have no real job, I believe that life is what you make of it. 
 Besides, it would be a criminal waste of taxpayers' money if I did nothing. 
 We're not all as bad as we're painted.  
 So I spent my first month as Special Projects Officer looking for work. 
 I read all through the papers dropped into my in-tray marked &bquo;for information only&equo;. 
 I spotted a critical piece about my department in the Economist  and drafted a letter to the editor for Mellowes to send but he didn't use it. 
 One morning I received a report on the terms of reference for the Service-wide performance review and wrote a minute to its author stressing the need to define the concept of work. 
 When I told Anne this she said, somewhat tartly, &bquo;if I redefined the concept of dirt I could stop hoovering the place.&equo; 
 She doesn't have a job, of course, so she doesn't understand that things are different when you do them for a living. 
 Next, I studied the staff handbook. 
 I read about the duties of and constraints on employees. 
 I read summaries of the Health and Safety at Work etc . 
 Act and went on to other employment and trade union legislation. 
 I absorbed chapter and verse of nationally-negotiated settlements. 
 Then I began on custom and practice &mdash; a fascinating subject, because so much depends on precedent rather than formal agreements. 
 Put simply, if it becomes the custom or the practice  of a group of workers to do a job in a certain way and management makes no objection, then that method of working can be cited as a precedent in disputes. 
 I've never been a trade union man myself, never saw the point, but in terms of research and analysis I found the field a fascinating one. 
 I looked up the name of my shop steward &mdash; Chris Pike &mdash; in a recent union bulletin, wrote to him for further information and he invited me up to the Branch Office. 
 I was pleasantly surprised at his general attitude. 
 No chip on his shoulder. 
 A genuine man, I would say, a man of principle. 
 He introduced me to the Branch Secretary, Forbes, who I found less congenial,  more prone to rhetoric, though at his level I daresay it was expected of him. 
 It was Pike who put me onto the Department's Legal Section. 
 I went along there one afternoon and stuck my head round the door; saw two men in the sort of office you'd expect of solicitors &mdash; box files in neat rows and shelf upon shelf of law reports. 
 I announced myself. 
 &bquo;Illingsworth,&equo; I said, &bquo;Special Projects. 
 Looking into custom and practice. 
 Thought you might be able to help with a few snippets of case law.&equo; 
 &bquo;Harrington,&equo; said the smaller, dark one. 
 'Give us an idea where you want to begin.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lewis,&equo; the other one rose to his feet and extended his hand. 
 &bquo;Pre- or post-Fulton?&equo; 
 We spent a most agreeable couple of hours, the three of us. 
 Harrington and Lewis both said they found it a pleasant change from their usual routine. 
 &bquo;Drop in any time,&equo; said Lewis as I rose to go. 
 I looked in on them fairly frequently after that. 
 Between whiles I worked hard. 
 I read and made notes. 
 As an exercise and to test my familiarity with the material, I drafted a summary of disputes procedures, both national and local, confining myself to a single sheet of A4. 
 Most succinct. 
 When I finished I took the lift down to the typing pool. 
 &bquo;Mrs Carter,&equo; I said to the supervisor, &bquo;by tomorrow, please. 
 Double-spaced, with side heads in caps,&equo; then took the lift up again. 
 Next morning I checked the typing for errors and sent it back for correction. 
 After lunch I reread and filed the summary. 
 I did not plan to submit it to anyone. 
 The pursuit of excellence was sufficient unto itself. 
 But mid-way through the afternoon the door opened. 
 Pike came in. 
 &bquo;Can you spare a moment?&equo; 
 I nodded. 
 He sat in the chair in front of my desk. 
 &bquo;Any idea where I could lay my hands on an idiot's guide to disputes?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;It's for the new stewards&equo; training day.&equo; 
 So I gave him a copy of my summary.  
 After he left it occurred to me that Harrington and Lewis might also find my effort useful, so I took them a copy. 
 Within days my summary was in demand throughout the Department. 
 I wrote a similar piece entitled &bquo;The Grievance Procedure, Step by Step&equo; which also went down well. 
 I read more widely and, as news of my expertise spread, people began to seek me out for a ruling on a specific industrial relations issue or for an historical precedent. 
 It was all at my fingertips and I was only too pleased to be of some assistance, from whatever quarter the request came. 
 I was straight with all of them, mind you, made it quite clear I had no axe to grind. 
 Then I branched out into a new area. 
 Once again it was Pike's idea. 
 I set out to clarify my own circumstances vis-&agrave;-vis employment rights. 
 I examined my contract and pointed out a minor discrepancy in it to Personnel. 
 They were most amenable and forwarded a corrected contract without delay. 
 By now they too knew they could call on me. 
 I checked my job description. 
 It was vague in the extreme. 
 &bquo;To undertake Special Projects,&equo; it read. 
 Quite a come-down from the two-page list of duties required of me when I had a real job. 
 A thought struck me. 
 I checked with Pike and found I was correct: according to custom and practice my job description formed a part of my contract. 
 Had I known that the previous year, I could have made a good case to contest the abolition of my old job. 
 Each evening I reported to Anne, keeping it light for the most part. 
 &bquo;But are you actually getting anywhere?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;What about promotion? 
 It sounds such a dead end job.&equo; 
 It was a little irritating of her. 
 And unjust. 
 I did, after all, earn a decent living. 
 I planned to tell her so, but  left it for tonight. 
 In any case, she was absorbed in her patchwork. 
 She has rather a thing about patchwork. 
 She borrows books on it from the local library and copies out old patterns. 
 While I cannot see the attraction, at least it keeps her busy in the evenings. 
 Next morning I found a note on my desk. 
 &bquo;See me. 
 9.30. 
 Mellowes,&equo; I read. 
 Bit of a shock after all this time, to be summoned to my line manager's office. 
 When I went in he was sitting at his desk with a file open in front of him. 
 He waited for me to take a chair. 
 &bquo;Well, Frank,&equo; he said. 
 He always uses my first name, although he is several years my junior. 
 He looked at the file. 
 &bquo;You joined us from Central Records, I see. 
 Another victim of the cuts.&equo; 
 I didn't reply. 
 It was all in the file. 
 &bquo;Well, Frank,&equo; he said again. 
 &bquo;You've been with us, now, 
 near on a year.&equo; 
 &bquo;Almost to the day.&equo; 
 &bquo;Right. 
 Well. 
 I won't beat about the bush. 
 There's been a complaint.&equo; 
 &bquo;Complaint? 
 About what?&equo; 
 He looked straight at me. 
 &bquo;I assume you know the state of play in the admin assistants&equo; dispute?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; I said with interest. 
 And surprise. 
 The admin assistants reported to Personnel, not to Mellowes. 
 &bquo;Deadlock. 
 Complete stalemate.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's unfortunate. 
 I'd heard on the grapevine it was nearly settled.&equo; 
 &bquo;Frank, I'll come to the point. 
 Did you let the management negotiating team know they could use bonus payments as a bargaining tool?&equo; 
 &bquo;I did indeed. 
 They were most grateful.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you tell the trade union side about an obscure precedent which would allow for their claim to the bonus?&equo;  
 I thought for a moment. 
 There was no point in denying the truth. 
 &bquo;Correct again,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Did you then suggest to the management team that, although the administrative assistants were arguing for party with the statistical clerks, reference should be made to similar groups in the private sector?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right.&equo; 
 &bquo;And point out to the union that the comparable grade in local government already had higher pay and a thirty-five hour week?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;It has to stop. 
 You've had ample time to get your feet under the table by now and one or two things have come up which I'd like you to pursue. 
 Urgent stuff.&equo; 
 He pushed two thick buff folders across his desk. 
 &bquo;Cast your eyes over these. 
 Get through as much as you can this afternoon. 
 By five p.m. 
 I'll expect results.&equo; 
 I took the folders to my office. 
 I was more than a little put out. 
 I had planned to spend the day analysing the knock-on effects for the statistical clerks of a three per cent increase in the admin assistants' salaries. 
 I sighed, opened the first folder and flipped through it. 
 It contained instructions on different sheets of paper in different handwriting. 
 &bquo;Check on remaining supplies of Form NLZ/897246 with Regional Offices and issue replacement Form NLZ/897247 as appropriate,&equo; read the first one. 
 &bquo;Send standard acknowledgment to enclosed letters,&equo; read the second. 
 I slammed the file shut and got on the blower right away. 
 &bquo;Pike,&equo; I said to my shop steward, &bquo;I'd like your advice,&equo; and explained what had happened. 
 He was over like a shot. 
 He opened the file. 
 &bquo;It's the admin assistants&equo; work all right,&equo; he announced. 
 &bquo;Held up on account of their work to rule. 
 If you were to go ahead it would be strikebreaking. 
 Don't touch it with a bargepole.&equo;  
 I returned the folders to Mellowes during the lunch hour with a note explaining that union instructions prevented my undertaking the work. 
 A good thing I was free of it, as both sides in the dispute applied to me for further information in the course of the afternoon. 
 As Mellowes said, negotiations had reached a tricky stage. 
 The management rep told me he'd even heard whispers of sympathetic action among the statistical clerks. 
 Next morning when I arrived there were two new buff folders on my desk. 
 I took a look inside: computer printouts of columns of figures. 
 I dialled the Branch Office extension. 
 Pike, as I expected, confirmed that this was work which was normally done by the statistical clerks. 
 It stood to reason that it must be someone's job; anything that Mellowes gave me was bound to be. 
 During the next two days I advised on industrial relations problems in catering, computers and property services and sent back three more folders of work to my line manager. 
 On the Friday pike dropped in to see me. 
 &bquo;Mellowes is gunning for you&equo; he said as he sat down. 
 &bquo;Hope you won't take this the wrong way. 
 I've asked Forbes to issue you a formal warning of expulsion from the union if you touch work which is in anyone else's job description. 
 It's for your protection, so that you have the union behind you if Mellowes kicks up a stink. 
 Oh, and we're backdating the warning to cover the stuff you returned to him last week.&equo; 
 My weekend began very pleasantly. 
 I did a few odds and ends in the garden on Saturday, played a round of golf on Sunday morning. 
 But Anne was late serving Sunday lunch. 
 She apologised of course; I gathered she'd been talking quilts with a fellow enthusiast and had forgotten the time. 
 The fact remained that the beef was overcooked and some of the potatoes were burned. 
 I  didn't say anything, just put the bits I couldn't eat on the side of my plate. 
 Then, in the afternoon, I came in from the garden and found her in an armchair, engrossed in a thick, glossy-looking book. 
 &bquo;Something new from the library?&equo; 
 I asked, taking an interest. 
 When she didn't reply I crossed the room, stood with one hand on the back of her chair and watched her turn pages of colour plates of patchwork quilts. 
 &bquo;That library does you proud,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Ordering special books.&equo; 
 She turned and looked at me. 
 &bquo;It's not from the library. 
 I bought it.&equo; 
 I really felt she had gone too far; the book must have cost a small fortune. 
 &bquo;How much did you pay for it? 
 As a matter of interest.&equo; 
 &bquo;I bought it with my own money.&equo; 
 She always does this &mdash; assumes that the money is hers when she saves something out of the housekeeping. 
 I earned it in the first place, so strictly speaking it's still mine; but you learn not to say some things in marriage. 
 Monday morning. 
 As usual we had breakfast in the conservatory. 
 I cast my eye over the front page of the Telegraph  while Anne poured the coffee. 
 I looked at my watch; &bquo;Is there more toast?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;I've time for another slice.&equo; 
 But Anne said &bquo;Frank, there's something about you in the paper. 
 Oh dear.&equo; 
 &bquo;About me?&equo; 
 I took her Daily Mail . 
 &bquo;A Year's Pay for Nothing,&equo; read the headline. 
 There must have been a leak. 
 I read the rest of the story; the gist of it was I had idled away a year on full pay and what was the Government going to do about it? 
 There was also a quote from Forbes; he praised the stand I had taken in the face of management victimisation and stressed my right to real work. 
 I put down the Mail , opened the Telegraph  and found the same tale, though told in less lurid terms.  
 I folded the paper and looked at Anne. 
 &bquo;Well!&equo; 
 I said, &bquo;that should ruffle a few feathers,&equo; but she didn't seem the least impressed. 
 &bquo;How did you get yourself into this mess?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Can't you just do the work you're paid for?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's the nub. 
 I am the Special Projects Officer. 
 Mellowes has assigned me to the duties of the administrative assistants, then to those of the statistical clerks. 
 It's iniquitous. 
 And divisive. 
 I wasn't expecting the press to get hold of it, mind you; but it may be no bad thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;I would have thought your work was whatever Mellowes told you to do.&equo; 
 As I've said, she doesn't understand these things. 
 I received rather more satisfactory reactions at work. 
 I walked in the front door of the Department and the receptionist said &bquo;Good morning, Mr Illingsworth,&equo; which she never normally did. 
 In the lift a man I hadn't come across before spoke to me. 
 &bquo;Illingsworth, isn't it?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;You've certainly caused a stir.&equo; 
 I hurried out of the lift, along the corridor and opened the door to my office. 
 No buff folders on the desk today. 
 Instead there was a solitary red one. 
 I crossed the room and picked it up, still wearing my coat. 
 The folder was marked &bquo;priority&equo;. 
 I opened it. 
 An opposition MP had tabled a question in parliament. 
 About me. 
 I took off my coat quickly and tossed it on the chair in front of my desk. 
 I sat down and read further. 
 The Minister was to answer the question this afternoon. 
 Mellowes had drafted a reply for him to read out. 
 A note from Mellowes instructed me to cast my eye over the draft, pronto, for inaccuracies. 
 This, being in the nature of a special project, I did. 
 It would have been an education to have been in the House when the Minister spoke. 
 But I received another note from Mellowes; it said I was not to leave the office; I was not to answer the phone; above all I was not to speak to the press.  
 I drafted a statement for the trade union, detailing the nature of their support for me and hinting at a readiness to take further action were the matter not resolved in days. 
 I called Pike and read it to him. 
 He was delighted, said he would mark it for immediate release to the newspapers under the Branch Secretary's name. 
 I then drafted a statement for the management side and sent it by hand to Mellowes who was sufficiently impressed by this initiative to pop his head around the door an hour later with a look of something less than mistrust. 
 I reviewed the position. 
 I was employed by the civil service to carry out special projects. 
 Hitherto management had identified no special projects. 
 On the other hand no one else did the work I had been doing over the past year. 
 Therefore it could be classified as a special project &mdash; one for which there was constant demand. 
 My records were frequently consulted, my opinion often sought. 
 I was indispensable. 
 After these reflections I formulated my demands. 
 My bottom line was to retain the status quo. 
 So often the parties to disputes make the mistake of not being crystal-clear about the bottom line. 
 I scratched my head. 
 I checked a couple of precedents in my files. 
 I thought for a while. 
 I added a number of subsidiary claims. 
 I varied the audacity of these to ensure the change of pace and tone so essential to a good negotiating table. 
 I imagined the scene: Mellowes at one end of the table, Forbes at the other. 
 I would send in a note addressed to Mellowes. 
 He would read it, nod and announce that he was ready to make a concession. 
 Forbes would request an adjournment. 
 I would be waiting for him outside the room and would suggest that he too withdraw a minor claim; then add a new demand. 
 The final settlement, as with the various disputes to which the Department  seemed ever more prone, would be in my gift and mine alone. 
 I finished my list of demands and took it to the Branch Office, where I received something of a hero's welcome. 
 Pike shook my hand; Forbes slapped me on the back. 
 He would fight my case to the bitter end, he vowed. 
 Over dinner that evening I told Anne everything that had happened. 
 Told it rather well, I thought. 
 &bquo;So you see,&equo; I concluded, &bquo;I'm sure I can put the wind up Mellowes.&equo; 
 She looked at me across the dining table, frowned and said, &bquo;I don't see the point.&equo; 
 I sighed. 
 I explained again: about my job description, custom and practice and my right to do the work for which I was employed. 
 She said, &bquo;I still don't see the point. 
 By the way I'm taking on homeworkers.&equo; 
 This rather threw me. 
 I put down my knife and fork and said, &bquo;You keep the place beautifully.&equo; 
 &bquo;Homeworkers. 
 Not somebody to clean. 
 People who work at home. 
 For me.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mean someone to take in the ironing? 
 Or the laundry? 
 Is that the cheapest way?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd be employing women for sewing. 
 Quilting to my designs.&equo; 
 &bquo;Quilting? 
 Whatever for? 
 The house is full of your little efforts.&equo; 
 &bquo;So I'll have more time for designing. 
 For marketing.&equo; 
 &bquo;What on earth are you talking about Anne? 
 I haven't been in the least difficult about your doing all that sewing. 
 Even though it does seem to have taken over the house a bit.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've been selling patchwork for some time now,&equo; she went on. 
 &bquo;I thought I'd wait until I made a go of it before I told you. 
 Now I've more orders than I can handle. 
 I'm ready to expand.&equo; 
 &bquo;Orders? 
 Expand? 
 But you don't need to work. 
 Not for a living.&equo;  
 &bquo;Well I am.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;It's tough out there in the real world. 
 Competition. 
 Cut and thrust. 
 Take my situation; you'd never be able to handle that, would you? 
 You ought to think again.&equo; 
 But she said, &bquo;If you've finished your cottage pie, I'll fetch the pudding,&equo; and rose to her feet. 
 I sat there with my elbows on the table. 
 Fancy hitting me with this. 
 After the day I'd had at work. 
 You'd almost think she did it on purpose.  
 DISPLACEMENT ACTIVITY 
 Don had backaches and headaches. 
 He suffered from bouts of indigestion. 
 He could no longer keep his eyes open to watch any one of the Thrill-a-Minute videos which, until quite recently, would have kept him on the edge of his seat. 
 Tonight he had been immersed in scenes of Mafia violence and found himself the next moment slumped in the Chesterfield staring at silver snow on the screen. 
 The film was over. 
 He rubbed his eyes, rose slowly and went into the bedroom. 
 He undressed, but could not bother to do so in the proper order, to remove his socks before stepping out of trousers and boxer shorts. 
 Anyway Amanda was dead to the world. 
 He slipped in beside her and crunched on the dusty taste of a Rennie. 
 He lay on his back for a few moments as he always did, then turned onto his right side, arranging himself as if for sleep. 
 ft was too much to hope for. 
 His short doze in the living room had been long enough to keep him awake now. 
 With weary patience he watched the room's familiar objects assume slow, grey shapes. 
 Amanda rolled over taking most of the duvet with her; it was easier to let her have more than her fair share. 
 He sighed, closed his eyes and drifted finally into uneasy sleep.  
 In the morning he woke to find Amanda already up and well on the way with preparations for her day, to judge by the clattering coming from the kitchen. 
 The bedroom door opened and she rushed in. 
 &bquo;Want anything ironed?&equo; she asked and dumped a mug on the bedside table with such vigour that steaming coffee splashed in Don's direction. 
 She flung the wardrobe open, riffled the line of clothes, selected a blouse, waved it at him, added, &bquo;&hellip; while I'm doing this,&equo; and rushed out again. 
 Don sat up and sipped his coffee. 
 Amanda filled the flat with so much energy it hurt: humming, calling out snatches of news from the radio, crunching toast at a painful volume. 
 He pushed the duvet aside and rose to his feet. 
 In the bathroom he peered in the mirror at the creases on his forehead; surely they were deeper than they had been yesterday. 
 He probed the puffy white bags under his eyes with a tentative finger. 
 Oh well. 
 Better make a start on shaving. 
 &bquo;You nearly ready yet?&equo; called Amanda. 
 Did she have to shout at him? 
 By the time he finished in the bathroom she was fully dressed in a bright yellow suit with padded shoulders. 
 Her hair was a blonde cloud. 
 She smiled cheerily. 
 To look at her made Don want to go back to bed. 
 &bquo;Tell me the truth,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Do you think my eyes are sinking?&equo; 
 That evening Don arrived at Amanda's flat just before eight. 
 &bquo;Hi,&equo; she said as she let him in. 
 &bquo;I'm only just back myself. 
 Had a rush job on.&equo; 
 He didn't reply, but made straight for the Chesterfield. 
 She stood in the living room doorway and frowned at him. 
 &bquo;You should have had an early night,&equo; she commented. 
 &bquo;You don't have to come round if you're not up to it. 
 Did you pick up the video?&equo; 
 &bquo;I would have. 
 I was whacked.&equo; 
 She shrugged. 
 &bquo;I'm going to change,&equo; and went into the  bedroom; so he didn't find out what she was wearing underneath. 
 What Amanda was wearing underneath had once been a matter of passionate interest to Don. 
 After a moment he rose slowly, poured himself a whisky, returned to the Chesterfield and took a dismal sip. 
 Amanda came back wearing a tee-shirt and black leggings, made herself a large gin and tonic, sat down and drank. 
 They used to share a bottle of wine, Don reflected. 
 Quite good wine, which he used to select carefully on the way to her place. 
 &bquo;You could have tried,&equo; she grumbled. 
 &bquo;The reviews say Wall Street  's well worth watching.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't know I was going to feel so knocked out. 
 Perhaps I ought to see a doctor.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you want to do now? 
 It's too late to get anything else.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing. 
 Watch television. 
 I had a hard day. 
 And I didn't get a lot of sleep last night.&equo; 
 &bquo;You only come here to crash out.&equo; 
 Amanda inspected her drink. 
 To do this she unwrapped her legs from each other, bent her right knee briefly and peered into the empty glass. 
 In one movement she was on her feet and en route for the drinks table. 
 She paused at the mantelpiece to move a small cactus a couple of inches to the left. 
 &bquo;I'm tired. 
 I've a headache. 
 Do you think I have M.E?&equo; asked Don. 
 Amanda filled her glass and spun round to face him. 
 &bquo;Displacement activity,&equo; she said and headed back to the mantelpiece where she swapped a silver-framed photograph for a white porcelain horse. 
 &bquo;That's what your tiredness is,&equo; she pronounced over her shoulder. 
 &bquo;And your headaches. 
 And your indigestion. 
 No one can be tired all the time. 
 You must really want to be doing something else but you won't let yourself admit it.&equo; 
 She turned to the mantelpiece. 
 'They look better like that don't they?&equo;  
 Don, knowing he should say something, managed &bquo;The horse is crooked.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that better?&equo; 
 Amanda bounced to attend to it. 
 &bquo;Like this? 
 This? 
 Or should I put them back where they were?&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you think you could sit down? 
 There was something I wanted to say.&equo; 
 His eyelids were beginning to droop. 
 &bquo;It's too much.&equo; 
 &bquo;You could have another drink.&equo; 
 Amanda returned to her chair. 
 &bquo;You could try to guess what I'm wearing.&equo; 
 &bquo;You said you had an early start tomorrow. 
 And my first meeting is at eight thirty.&equo; 
 Amanda stood up again, crossed the room, took a blue bowl of chrysanths from the coffee table and carried them across the room to the dresser. 
 &bquo;It's all this toing and froing,&equo; said Don. 
 &bquo;It takes it out of me. 
 And I worry in case someone needs to ring me.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've put this number on your answerphone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Amanda,&equo; said Don, making a last ditch attempt. 
 &bquo;This stuff about your place or mine is all very well. 
 But it's been going on for two years.&equo; 
 &bquo;No one's forcing you. 
 And I do come to your place.&equo; 
 Amanda looked at a picture on the wall. 
 &bquo;One of us must have knocked that. 
 It's not straight.&equo; 
 &bquo;I just think we should live together.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not at yours. 
 Your cooker's electric.&equo; 
 &bquo;Buy a place. 
 Something we both like.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't you like this flat? 
 You said you did.&equo; 
 &bquo;You know I do. 
 But it's not big enough.&equo; 
 &bquo;You stay over often enough.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's different. 
 There's nowhere for my clothes. 
 We're always on top of each other.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you say so.&equo; 
 Amanda uncoiled her legs again and stood up. 
 &bquo;Do you think the speakers would give a better quality of sound if I moved them further apart?&equo;  
 It was Don who made the effort; he bought the local paper and looked at ads for houses; he phoned estate agents and asked for lists of properties. 
 &bquo;Highgate,&equo; he said to Amanda. 
 'What do you reckon? 
 It's almost like being in the country. 
 Lots of trees. 
 And the schools are good.&equo; 
 &bquo;Schools,&equo; Amanda said to Don, &bquo;are places to send children. 
 I do not have any children.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's only what they all said. 
 Shows it's a good area.&equo; 
 Don even gave up his Saturday. 
 He set out at ten; he viewed as many houses as possible, trudged across miles of fitted carpet and sanded floors, exchanged weary smiles with anxious vendors. 
 By the time he arrived at Amanda's he was ready to drop. 
 &bquo;Oh, good,&equo; she said, when she saw him. 
 &bquo;You're just in time to give me a hand.&equo; 
 He stopped in the living room doorway and looked, appalled, at the room. 
 The Chesterfield, onto which he was ready to drop, was no longer at its usual, comfortable angle to the television. 
 It stood in the middle of the room, apparently on its way somewhere. 
 The television was unplugged. 
 The drinks were heaped in Amanda's chair. 
 &bquo;What on earth have you been doing?&equo; he demanded. 
 &bquo;There's nowhere to sit.&equo; 
 &bquo;The least you could do is take the other end of the Chesterfield,&equo; Amanda said crossly. 
 He did. 
 &bquo;It's going over there, I think,&equo; she went on. 
 &bquo;Where the drinks table is. 
 The table is coming out of the alcove and the armchair is going in. 
 Then there's the television.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't move the television!&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right. 
 I bought an extension lead for the aerial point. 
 We could even watch it in bed.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; asked Don, stopping to draw breath. 
 &bquo;Why are you doing this? 
 We'll only have to go through it all again when we move.&equo; 
 The thought filled him with exhaustion. 
 &bquo;I forgot,&equo; said Amanda, perching on the arm of the stranded chair. 
 &bquo;You don't know about this. 
 Look.&equo; 
 She  pointed to a huge mirror with an ornate surround which was leaning against the wall. 
 &bquo;I picked it up at Camden Lock.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't have. 
 It must weigh a ton.&equo; 
 &bquo;If I managed to get it home with the help of a cabbie we must be able to move it between the two of us. 
 Mind the plasterwork, though.&equo; 
 Amanda took one end of the mirror. 
 &bquo;Where?&equo; asked Don. 
 &bquo;Over the fireplace. 
 So I can see if it looks okay. 
 Then I'll put in rawlplugs and hang it properly.&equo; 
 &bquo;It'll be a fixture with rawlplugs. 
 What's the point when you won't be here?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've bought it,&equo; said Amanda, &bquo;and I want to see it up.&equo; 
 The following Saturday she agreed, at least, to go with him but then all she did was pick holes: &bquo;Carpet's frayed,&equo; she said, after inspecting an apparently immaculate place in Muswell Hill; &bquo;Too far from the shops,&equo; of a modern luxury development on the prestigious fringes of Hampstead Heath; and of the one he'd had real hopes for, a newly-converted maisonette over towards Crouch End &mdash; &bquo;original features all been taken out. 
 Pity. 
 And look at those trees. 
 I'm sure they're the sort that drop sticky stuff on the top of the car.&equo; 
 Their last port of call was a large, unmodernised house. 
 Amanda's face brightened as soon as they were inside. 
 &bquo;Potential,&equo; she said, &bquo;definite potential. 
 Nice high ceilings. 
 Where's that damp coming from?&equo; 
 Don raised his head while his heart sank. 
 They could have it done professionally, he supposed, wearily imagining a pile of builders' estimates. 
 The house was full of little flights of steps where he least expected them. 
 There were many dark, stained rooms. 
 &bquo;I would have had it done,&equo; said the owner, a small, pale woman, &bquo;but I'm selling up to go and live with my sister and it didn't seem worth it.&equo;  
 &bquo;Much better not.&equo; 
 Amanda confronted, with relish, the unrenovated kitchen. 
 &bquo;They do such awful things.&equo; 
 Outside the kitchen were brambles and thistles as far as the eye could see. 
 &bquo;Hundred foot garden,&equo; said the woman and Amanda set off to verify this while Don and the woman waited. 
 If Amanda would only get it over with, thought Don. 
 It was late in the evening when Don and Amanda returned to Amanda's flat. 
 Don lowered himself onto the Chesterfield. 
 Amanda went into the kitchen and returned with two packets of crisps. 
 &bquo;Catch,&equo; she challenged and tossed one of them in his direction. 
 She dumped herself on the Chesterfield beside him and ripped open her own packet, noisily. 
 &bquo;That was quite a place,&equo; she enthused. 
 &bquo;Imagine the huge room at the front painted a sort of duck-egg blue. 
 A golden sunshine yellow would suit the bathroom. 
 We'll need to put in a new suite.&equo; 
 She twisted her legs up under her, crunched a crisp, ran a hand through her hair and turned towards him. 
 &bquo;The back faces south, so it will be in full sun,&equo; she went on. 
 &bquo;We could build on a garden room.&equo; 
 She paused. 
 &bquo;Did you see the varnish in the kitchen though? 
 And layers of gloss on those lovely shutters. 
 It'll take us forever to strip them right down. 
 What shall we do tonight? 
 Shall we go out?&equo; 
 Don said, &bquo;I'm exhausted. 
 You know crisps give me indigestion. 
 And why can't you leave things the way they are?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be silly. 
 We couldn't live there with it in that state.&equo; 
 &bquo;That seems to be exactly what you are planning to do.&equo; 
 &bquo;Only till we get it straight.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's crazy. 
 When we could have the maisonette for the same price. 
 Amanda I'm not twenty years old. 
 I'm not even thirty and nor are you. 
 Why can't you settle down?&equo;  
 &bquo;You know what?&equo; said Amanda. 
 &bquo;I think this room was better the way it was before. 
 Don't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;Even with the mirror? 
 Could you give me a hand?&equo; 
 &bquo;For God's sake, Amanda. 
 We'll be up half the night.&equo; 
 &bquo;So what? 
 It's Sunday tomorrow. 
 You can have a nice lie in.&equo; 
 &bquo;Amanda, I haven't been sleeping well.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't come here to go to sleep. 
 You didn't used to.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's no good talking when you're like this. 
 I'm going to bed.&equo; 
 &bquo;No you're not.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who's stopping me?&equo; 
 &bquo;I am. 
 I don't want you to go to bed. 
 It's my bed. 
 And I'm sick and tired of it.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mean you don't want me to stay? 
 You want me to go? 
 You don't want me to sleep here?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't want anyone to go to sleep. 
 Anywhere. 
 It's half-past nine on a Saturday evening for Christ's sake. 
 If I had any children to send to those good schools in Highgate, even they wouldn't be asleep by now.&equo; 
 &bquo;If that's how you feel, I'll go to my own flat.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine by me. 
 The last thing I want to do is to share a place with a couch potato. 
 You're getting a paunch, did you know that?&equo; 
 Don's flat, after all those nights at Amanda's, was not the most welcoming place in the world. 
 He shivered; he put the central heating on &bquo;constant&equo;; he went round the corner for a bottle of whisky. 
 He returned and sat on his cold, leather sofa flicking channels. 
 He did not call Amanda for a week. 
 When he did her answerphone answered. 
 Don did not have backache that night. 
 He did not have a headache although he listened to his old albums at full volume. 
 He did not have indigestion although he ate ready salted crisps with his whisky. 
 Nor was he in the least tired until well after midnight.  
 The next night he remembered to pick up a video on the way back from work. 
 He sat upright on the sofa and watched the whole film. 
 Then, the following night, half-way through a political thriller, he became so restless that he rewound the tape and took it back to the shop; but the shop was closed. 
 The third night he went straight from work to a wine bar. 
 In the wine bar he bought drinks for two young women. 
 He chatted to them all evening, then went home and fell asleep. 
 The following evening he went to a different wine bar and bought drinks for two different young women. 
 Most nights, at some point, he thought about phoning Amanda but he always managed, at the last moment, to replace the receiver before her answerphone answered. 
 He managed to do other things too; on Saturdays he went to the gym to lift weights. 
 On Sunday he played squash and on weekday mornings he jogged for twenty minutes before work. 
 No time for insomnia, backaches, headaches, indigestion or general lethargy. 
 He felt a lot better. 
 On the evidence of his bathroom mirror, he looked better too. 
 So much better, in fact, that he could no longer resist the urge to go and see Amanda. 
 He rang the bell to her flat. 
 The door opened and there she stood. 
 She was wearing a huge orange tee shirt and black leggings and looked exactly as she always looked. 
 But the door, he realised, as the light from inside fell on it, was not black as before, but bright pink. 
 &bquo;Come in,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You're just in time to give me a hand.&equo; 
 He followed her, but stopped in the living room doorway and looked at the room. 
 The fitted carpet was gone. 
 The floorboards were sanded. 
 The walls were no longer white, but pale green. 
 The ornate mirror was firmly fixed on the wall opposite the fireplace. 
 There were new shelves in the alcove where the drinks table once stood. 
 The porcelain horse, the cactus, the blue bowl  and the drinks were on the shelves. 
 The television was on the drinks table. 
 The armchair in which Amanda used to sit had turned green too. 
 And the Chesterfield, which stood, as Don had last seen it, in the middle of the room, waiting to go somewhere, was now plumply buttoned in the most florid of Sanderson prints. 
 &bquo;You didn't call,&equo; said Amanda. 
 &bquo;I thought you didn't want to see me. 
 I had to have something to do.&equo; 
 &bquo;Displacement activity,&equo; said Don. 
 &bquo;You said you didn't want to sleep with me.&equo; 
 He paused. 
 &bquo;Would you like to go out for a drink?&equo; 
 &bquo;I can't leave the Chesterfield like this&equo; Amanda complained. 
 &bquo;I've brought some wine,&equo; said Don. 
 &bquo;The Chesterfield seems fine where it is. 
 We could listen to music instead. 
 What are you wearing under that?&equo;  
 EXPOSED 
 &bquo;You're different from the women I've met so far,&equo; said Ray. 
 &bquo;You have something special about you.&equo; 
 Gillian looked at his round pink cheeks, then into his little blue eyes. 
 &bquo;Really?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;What exactly?&equo; 
 &bquo;That wasn't a line.&equo; 
 He reached across the table and took her hand, which was a nuisance; he would notice if she tried to look at her watch. 
 &bquo;Anybody coming anywhere near you would feel it. 
 I did immediately.&equo; 
 She toyed with her empty glass. 
 He paused, said, &bquo;You're ready for another drink,&equo; and clicked thumb and fingers of his free hand at a waiter, who showed no sign of feeling anything untoward when he approached Gillian. 
 His hands, transferring glasses from tray to table, did not tremble. 
 He did not even smile at her. 
 Gillian offered Ray a pack of Marlboro Lights; he released her hand, took one and lit her cigarette, then his. 
 She checked her watch quickly. 
 Nine-fifty. 
 She could make a move in about twenty minutes. 
 In the meantime she was stiff from sitting still; she crossed one knee over the other. 
 &bquo;You have beautiful legs,&equo; Ray tried, but one of the other men had already told her that.  
 She leant her elbows on the table, clasped her hands lightly and rested her chin on them. 
 She knew this pose showed her slim fingers to advantage. 
 Ray reclaimed her left hand and said, &bquo;What star sign are you? 
 No, let me guess.&equo; 
 He tilted his head to one side, then straightened it again. 
 &bquo;Libra,&equo; he said firmly. 
 &bquo;Artistically inclined, outgoing, a lover of beautiful things.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sagittarius,&equo; Gillian corrected. 
 &bquo;Of course. 
 The Archer. 
 Friendly. 
 Easygoing.&equo; 
 He smiled. 
 &bquo;You like animals. 
 Enjoy the outdoor life. 
 And sports.&equo; 
 He launched into details of the sporting activities in which he thought she took part. 
 She understood that he was imagining her in a swimsuit with sleek hair at the local pool or in a short, white dress on a tennis court. 
 &bquo;I should be going,&equo; she said, hoping that the time was a convincing one by now. 
 &bquo;You said you lived near Vauxhall, didn't you? 
 Victoria line. 
 I'm on the Northern.&equo; 
 Her trick was to establish during the early part of the evening roughly where the man lived; then to announce a destination for herself to which he could not suggest accompanying her without seeming over keen. 
 Only with the first man had she got this wrong. 
 What was his name again? 
 Checked shirt, windcheater with a black zip, brown hair, thinning slightly. 
 Freelance science writer. 
 Had a Hornby 00-gauge railway in his attic. 
 Dennis, that was it. 
 With Dennis she made the mistake of saying where she lived before he did. 
 &bquo;It'll be no trouble at all to see you to your door,&equo; he had lied. 
 To avoid the trouble she had been obliged to invent a friend, a suicidal woman friend with whom she was staying that night. 
 The friend lived at the end of the Piccadilly Line so Dennis had insisted on escorting Gillian to Covent Garden when Leicester Square would have been easier for her.  
 Tonight she had no problem with Ray. 
 They parted at the corner of St Martin's Lane and Gillian made her way home on her own. 
 She left the Tube at Chalk Farm and walked &mdash; it was only a few hundred yards. 
 Several paces from her flat she took her keys from her jacket pocket; she kept her keys in her pocket rather than her bag in case of mugging. 
 She unlocked the Chubb. 
 Also the Yale. 
 There were locks on all the windows of the flat too. 
 Gillian had long ago learned to look after herself. 
 Inside, in the warm living room, with a glass of chilled dry wine to drink and Mozart to listen to on the CD, she was far from the tiredness she had claimed earlier. 
 She was never tired till past midnight. 
 She played back the messages on her answerphone and jotted down the numbers and names of the men who had called: Tony, Ali, Geoff, and Junior. 
 This time of the night was the best. 
 She relaxed, as satisfied as if she had chaired a difficult meeting through to its triumphant conclusion or been acclaimed at Board level for the fresh approach of her latest report. 
 She had, after all, done her homework as thoroughly &mdash; if anything more thoroughly &mdash; than she would have in order to realise either of those goals. 
 Her preparations had taken six weeks. 
 Before she began them she prepared a timetable. 
 ft read: 
 Week One: Join health club. 
 Begin exercises to increase general fitness, start gentle swimming. 
 Twenty minutes on sun bed (repeat each week). 
 Walk up escalator on way to work. 
 Book course of cosmetic dentistry. 
 Week Two: Appointment with hairdresser for new style (query highlights). 
 Tackle programme of hair care. 
 Seek advice from health club on exercise routine (to concentrate on stomach and hips). 
 Swim ten lengths twice a week. 
 Walk for fifteen minutes each lunch hour.  
 Week Three: Facial. 
 Select new skin-care products. 
 Continue exercise programme, increasing swimming to twenty lengths, walking to twenty minutes. 
 Week Four: Visit image consultant for advice on colours and colour co-ordination. 
 Two-hour workout with weights. 
 Place ad in New Statesman . 
 Week Five: Manicure. 
 Select new make-up and experiment with it. 
 Step up exercise routine (possibly include brisk country walk?). 
 Choose and join executive dating agency. 
 Week Six: Buy new clothes &mdash; to fit new figure &mdash; and accessories to transform office clothes into outfit suitable for evening &mdash; e.g. scarves, belts, bracelets, chokers. 
 Then she followed the timetable. 
 Everything went according to plan. 
 So many men answered her ad she hadn't replied to all of them yet; and the dating agency supplied a steady stream of potential partners. 
 Gillian arranged to meet her first date in Leicester Square. 
 She felt conspicuous standing on her own; crowds of young people drifted past. 
 A man in rags asked her for the price of a cup of tea. 
 She wondered whether she would find enough to discuss with a stranger to fill the evening. 
 The clock on the Swiss Centre began to whirr and clang. 
 Surely the man &mdash; Dennis &mdash; wouldn't turn up late? 
 She needn't have wondered. 
 Dennis arrived just before the clock chimed the hour. 
 And she hardly had to say a word the whole evening. 
 Not on that date, nor on the ones that followed. 
 Gillian took a sip of wine, put the glass down on the table in front of her on top of the brochure from the dating agency, slipped off her shoes and curled her feet up under her on the sofa. 
 Her preparations had paid off. 
 Each man took time to compliment her hair, her face,  her clothes, her figure; he told her a great deal about herself. 
 When he finished he told her about himself. 
 She thought about the men she had met. 
 Martin, tall with a roll-necked sweater under a grey suit, played war games; John, slightly paunchy with a beard, was into steam trains &mdash; he took photos of them; Julian, fair, well-dressed, with crooked teeth, divorced, spent Saturdays with his children and would expect her to do so too if they suited each other; Lewis, in three-piece suit and striped shirt, supported the reintroduction of corporal punishment in schools; Gerald, a mild, bushy-haired man, described with passionate precision the arrangement of the plants in his garden. 
 Only one thing these men had in common &mdash; they were sure they wanted to see Gillian again. 
 Her efforts were, therefore, a success, though not, she had to admit, of the kind promised by the dating agency. 
 She moved her glass, picked up the brochure and leafed through it, studying pictures of happy couples. 
 They came in all shapes and sizes; and all of them claimed to have become permanent partners. 
 But did such relationships really exist, Gillian wondered. 
 If they did, did she want to be part of one? 
 And if the answer was yes, would such a thing happen? 
 She shook her head and looked at her watch. 
 Twelve midnight. 
 She switched off the CD player, went into the bedroom, checked that her black dress, red jacket and red shoes were spotless for the morning: tucked a red and gold scarf and a couple of gilt bracelets into her bag to wear in the evening and went to bed. 
 She arrived at work at a quarter to nine and went straight to the studio. 
 &bquo;Your roughs look really good, Charles,&equo; she told the graphic designer. 
 &bquo;The layout you came up with worked out beautifully. 
 Just one small thing. 
 The company name could have a little more prominence. 
 Perhaps a different type face? 
 More white space around it? 
 You'll be the best judge of that. 
 Could you carry the  idea through on the headed notepaper? 
 And the business cards? 
 The point-of-sale material? 
 The presentation to Purdy and Roy is at three so you'll need to get cracking.&equo; 
 Next she went to David's office. 
 &bquo;You've done splendidly,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Nice, crisp, clean copy. 
 Purdy and Roy should be pleased with your draft for their Annual Report. 
 I particularly like your ideas for the sub-heads.&equo; 
 A pleased smile spread across David's face. 
 &bquo;One or two minor points,&equo; Gillian went on. 
 &bquo;You could cut this paragraph without losing any of the impact. 
 perhaps make more of the one before. 
 The section at the back &mdash; these three pages &mdash; could go here, right after the statement from the Chairman. 
 And in the point-of-sale material just a headline as opposed to the two sentences you have now? 
 I'll leave you to liaise with Charles on that. 
 Can you make sure you both have something to show me by lunchtime? 
 So I can run through it before the presentation.&equo; 
 Gillian retired to her own office where she prepared her flip charts. 
 At eleven she asked Janice, her PA, to set up the flip charts in the conference room. 
 At twelve she asked her to fetch a salad from the local wholefood bar. 
 At one she ran through her presentation. 
 At two she called Charles and David, went over their revised efforts and made one or two last-minute amendments. 
 By two forty-five her confidence was complete; nothing could stop her now. 
 The phone on her desk buzzed; Gillian picked it up. 
 &bquo;Mr Purdy and Mr Roy are in reception,&equo; said Janice. 
 Gillian replied, &bquo;Show them into the conference room.&equo; 
 Gillian and her team reached the conference room at the same time as the clients. 
 &bquo;Mr Purdy. 
 Mr Roy,&equo; Gillian shook hands briskly. 
 &bquo;Coffee? 
 Tea? 
 Do have a seat.&equo; 
 Janice took their orders while Gillian studied the two men. 
 Purdy, she judged, would try to rile her. 
 But she suspected he was all front. 
 Roy looked much more solid &mdash; the kind of man who would sit silently through what she  had to say, listen to Purdy's probing, then corner her with a single, well-informed comment. 
 So she must be flashy for Purdy, devastatingly accurate for Roy. 
 She smiled. 
 &bquo;We'll press on, shall we?&equo; 
 For Purdy's benefit she dropped the names of her most prestigious clients. 
 For Roy's she gave a hard-nosed, step-by-step account of the campaign she proposed &mdash; market research, target audience, lead-in times, media mix, follow-up. 
 At the end of it, at five o'clock, they all shook hands. 
 &bquo;I must say,&equo; said Roy. 
 &bquo;I am most impressed. 
 None of the competitors have the same level of professional expertise.&equo; 
 Purdy added, &bquo;Touch of showmanship about your presentation, too. 
 I like to see that.&equo; 
 Roy concluded, &bquo;Need to have it ratified by the Board. 
 But you can take it as read that you have the contract.&equo; 
 Gillian returned to her office on a high. 
 This evening, she decided, she would tell the man she met a thing or two. 
 At seven p.m. she entered the wine bar where she had arranged to rendezvous. 
 She recognised Peter because he was carrying a rolled-up copy of the Standard  and because his eyes lit with appreciation as she walked in. 
 She tossed the end of her red scarf over her shoulder, flung back her head and strode over to him. 
 He jumped to his feet. 
 &bquo;Gillian, you must be Gillian. 
 I wasn't expecting anyone at all like you.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean? 
 Is there something wrong? 
 I told you what I'd be wearing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course not.&equo; 
 He frowned doubtfully. 
 &bquo;You look marvellous. 
 Spot on. 
 Can I get you a drink?&equo; 
 Gillian sat down. 
 &bquo;Dry white wine,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Frascati if they have it.&equo; 
 Peter returned with a bottle and two glasses. 
 &bquo;White Lambrusco,&equo; he told her. 
 &bquo;It's slightly sparkling so I  thought you'd prefer it.&equo; 
 He poured the wine and lit a cigarette for himself. 
 &bquo;I won't offer you one. 
 I'm sure you don't smoke. 
 You look so fit.&equo; 
 &bquo;I am fit. 
 I swim thirty lengths twice a week. 
 I work out with weights for two hours on Saturdays. 
 I walk up all the escalators I come across. 
 Plus I have an extremely high-powered job; I have just signed a contract with a major new client. 
 And I'm Sagittarius but I've never played tennis in my life.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can imagine you in a tennis dress. 
 You have such long legs.&equo; 
 &bquo;My knees are knobbly,&equo; she said firmly. 
 &bquo;Have been since I was a kid.&equo; 
 Peter said, &bquo;We could have a meal later. 
 I'm sure you like Chinese food.&equo; 
 &bquo;Shall I tell you how much the contract is worth?&equo; asked Gillian. 
 &bquo;Or are you going to tell me what you think of my hair? 
 This isn't my natural colour by the way.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a lovely colour.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thirty thousand in round figures. 
 See my hands?&equo; 
 She offered him one. 
 &bquo;I used to bite my nails.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't do now. 
 They're perfect.&equo; 
 &bquo;Plus a generous amount for expenses. 
 Be honest. 
 You prefer shorter women.&equo; 
 &bquo;You said on the phone you didn't mind me being four foot eight.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course, it's taken me years to get where I am. 
 I did tell you how old I am, didn't I?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 You don't look it.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about my nose?&equo; 
 Gillian persisted. 
 &bquo;It's too big, isn't it? 
 I should have had it altered. 
 But I can't afford it. 
 Not even on my salary.&equo; 
 He looked at her warily. 
 &bquo;It isn't too big. 
 What's wrong? 
 Why do you keep asking me about yourself?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing. 
 Nothing's wrong. 
 Could I have one of your cigarettes?&equo;  
 Unlike the other men, Peter did not suggest they meet again. 
 But Gillian did not let this faze her. 
 She woke next morning &mdash; Saturday &mdash; with renewed determination. 
 She combed her hair, applied her make-up and set off for the Post Office. 
 She bought six first-class stamps, took a pound coin from her purse and went into the automatic photo booth. 
 She posed carefully for each exposure. 
 The snaps these machines took never portrayed her at her best, but they would give the general impression. 
 After waiting a few minutes she collected the pictures from the slot outside the booth, put them in her bag without looking at them and hurried home. 
 In her living room she took the bundle of replies to her ad in the New Statesman , settled at her desk and wrote to Michael who was an architect and described himself as outgoing. 
 In her letter she told him about her job, her salary and the contract she had won yesterday. 
 She signed the letter and took the snaps from her bag 
 She stared at them. 
 Had she picked up someone else's by mistake? 
 Huge pools of eyes stared back at her from the dead white planes of the face. 
 The nose was large and lumpen; the hair was stringy and unkempt. 
 Dark shadows disfigured the character's chin. 
 It was a photo of a corpse &mdash; but it was Gillian's corpse, she had to admit. 
 She looked at the second photo: the person in this one seemed to be dead too. 
 But a shifty, rather criminal smirk, lingered in her eyes. 
 She dropped the photos, rushed into the bathroom and looked in the mirror. 
 She looked the same as before. 
 She rushed back to the living room and picked up the snaps. 
 The phone was ringing. 
 It was a man, a new one called Oliver. 
 He began to tell her about himself. 
 &bquo;I'm just over six foot, dark-haired, with a beard, medium build,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;What do you look like?&equo;  
 Gillian snorted. 
 &bquo;I've got a dead white face, staring black eyes, stringy hair and I need a shave,&equo; she announced in a rush, put the phone down and collapsed into gales of laughter. 
 After a while, when the gales dwindled to chortles, Gillian wrote three more letters. 
 In them, she again described the work she did and the success she had achieved; she gave details of her height, weight and false hair colour; she even made a comment or two - as some of the men had in their letters &mdash; on her sexual preferences. 
 From time to time she stopped to laugh. 
 Finally, still shaking, she cut the photos apart and clipped one to each letter. 
 These men would know how she really looked.  
 FRIDAY NIGHT, WATCHING TV 
 &bquo;Hello, who's that?&equo; said Alan's voice at the other end of the line. 
 &bquo;It's Geraldine.&equo; 
 Geraldine said into the phone. 
 &bquo;Thought I'd ring. 
 Just to see how you're doing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, hello. 
 I'm okay actually. 
 How are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine. 
 You're all right then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 How did you know I was here?&equo; 
 &bquo;There was a number on the early news.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did they have a lot about the thing this afternoon?&equo; 
 &bquo;A bit. 
 So you're okay?&equo; 
 &bquo;Will be. 
 Broken my arm. 
 A few cuts. 
 What are you doing this evening?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not a lot. 
 Watching television as usual. 
 You know how I am on Fridays. 
 Have you had people to see you?&equo; 
 &bquo;No need. 
 I'll be out in a day or so. 
 I would have rung if this hadn't happened. 
 Come over to your place perhaps.&equo; 
 &bquo;I could have a couple of hours free tomorrow. 
 If you tell me what to bring.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't really want people to see you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; Geraldine paused. 
 &bquo;Right.&equo; 
 &bquo;I could give you a call next Friday. 
 Meet up as usual? 
 Though I think my arm will be in plaster. 
 If that's okay?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course. 
 That's fine. 
 See you then.&equo; 
 Geraldine hung up and went into her living room. 
 She looked at her watch. 
 Nearly seven o'clock. 
 The news would be starting on Channel Four. 
 She switched on the television. 
 Alan was on the screen; there were streaks of blood on his face, his arm was strapped up and he wore a blanket round his shoulders. 
 He said, &bquo;One hell of a crash, that's all. 
 Then people rolling around all over the place. 
 No, I couldn't see what caused it. 
 Yes, my left arm was trapped. 
 No, I don't know how long. 
 The Fire Brigade were superb. 
 And I was luckier than some.&equo; 
 Geraldine had seen this shot earlier. 
 She watched the next scene; nurses running towards a hospital, their unbuttoned navy-blue coats flapping over pale uniforms. 
 A reporter explained, &bquo;NHS staff throughout the south of the city have been recalled to deal with the emergency.&equo; 
 The camera returned to the scene of the disaster, lingered over piles of debris strewn on the railway embankment and focused on firemen cutting through the tangled remains of the trains. 
 Then it showed two of the coaches of the second train sprawled across the track. 
 &bquo;The death toll currently stands at twenty-one, with fifty-four survivors receiving hospital treatment,&equo; said the reporter. 
 Geraldine hoovered the living room and watered her plants. 
 She picked off the dead leaves one by one. 
 She went into the kitchen, scrambled three eggs and returned to the living room to eat them. 
 It was still only a quarter to eight &mdash; exactly the time when, last Friday, Alan turned up. 
 &bquo;Hi,&equo; he said when she opened the front door. 
 &bquo;Good week?&equo; he asked as he followed her into the living room. 
 &bquo;So, so.&equo; 
 Geraldine switched on the television. 
 &bquo;You?&equo; 
 &bquo;About the same.&equo; 
 They sat on the sofa and watched The Two Ronnies , laughing at the same jokes. 
 This Friday Geraldine returned to the kitchen, washed her plate, wiped all the worktops, mopped the floor and cleaned out two cupboards. 
 She unplugged the fridge and  opened the door intending to let the fridge defrost. 
 There were two cans of beer inside; she took one. 
 On the nine o'clock news she watched Alan sitting in bed, wearing striped pyjamas. 
 Geraldine had not seen him in pyjamas before. 
 The next sequence &mdash; from an amateur video taken soon after the crash &mdash; showed him being cut out of a wrecked coach. 
 He was wearing a leather jacket with one sleeve torn off. 
 Then Geraldine learned: 
 lumps of concrete had been found on the line in front of the first train 
 Alan had been in the third coach of the second train and was therefore luckier than the people in the first and second coaches, several of whom were dead 
 British Rail had introduced new safety measures over the last few months, but they could not legislate against criminal vandalism 
 most injuries were to the head or the chest, so Alan's were unusual. 
 Last week Alan was not in bed at nine o'clock; he was watching the news with Geraldine. 
 When the news finished they bent over the Guardian  TV page, deciding what to see next. 
 &bquo;It's all rather heavy,&equo; Alan complained. 
 &bquo;Who on earth wants to watch a documentary about heroin addicts in Hong Kong on a Friday night? 
 Or another of those dramas about the Second World War?&equo; 
 &bquo;The Golden Girls  is on later.&equo; 
 Geraldine did not watch the Golden Girls  tonight because it clashed with News at Ten . 
 On News at Ten  Alan was cut from the wrecked coach, then he wore a blanket and said, &bquo;One hell of a crash, that's all,&equo; and then he sat in bed in pyjamas. 
 After that Geraldine learned: 
 inspectors from the Department of Transport were at the scene  
 two survivors had died in hospital 
 the London Fire Brigade was continuing to work on 
 the wreckage but did not expect to find anyone else alive. 
 Last Friday Geraldine and Alan went to bed after the Golden Girls . 
 Geraldine was still thinking about who would want to watch dramas about the Second World War on a Friday night. 
 &bquo;What would you do if there was a war?&equo; she asked Alan as they undressed. 
 &bquo;And you had to fight?&equo; 
 &bquo;Hide.&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;That's cheating. 
 They'd find you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not if I hid well enough.&equo; 
 He paused and stepped out of his trousers. 
 &bquo;Or I could pretend to be someone else.&equo; 
 &bquo;Should I pretend that too?&equo; 
 &bquo;If it turns you on.&equo; 
 Geraldine sat on the bed and thought for a moment. 
 &bquo;I don't think it does,&equo; she said slowly. 
 &bquo;But maybe that's because you haven't told me who you're planning to be.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mickey Rourke? 
 Charles Dance?&equo; 
 Mickey Rourke was a possibility because his eyes were similar to Alan's. 
 Whereas Charles Dance did not resemble him in any way. 
 &bquo;I'll think it over,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'll let you know,&equo; and got into bed. 
 This Friday Geraldine settled down to wait for Newsnight . 
 She decided to sleep on the sofa so as not to miss anything. 
 No one had mentioned how fast the trains were going: nor the precise time of impact, not down to the minute. 
 She wanted to hear interviews with other survivors and to know what the emergency services had to say &mdash; the fire fighters who rushed to the scene, the doctors who performed the operations. 
 She wanted to see reconstructions of the accident, diagrams of how it might have come about.  
 After Newsnight  there was snooker and a film on BBC2. 
 She switched to London Weekend because it went on all night and watched another film, then a comedy about a Los Angeles police precinct. 
 The set was so tacky she expected it to collapse each time one of the characters came through the door. 
 She fell asleep. 
 When she woke her neck was stiff. 
 American football was on the screen. 
 Ads. 
 The five a.m. news. 
 There was only one development. 
 &bquo;Already last night,&equo; said a reporter, &bquo;commuters were laying flowers beside the track where the crash took place.&equo; 
 People always did that, Geraldine reflected. 
 Strange. 
 Why not give the flowers to the survivors? 
 She imagined herself turning up at Alan's bedside with an armful of freesias and went hot all over. 
 Too hot to go back to sleep. 
 She picked a bunch of flowers for Alan once. 
 On his birthday. 
 From her garden. 
 Daffodils. 
 It was late March. 
 The air was raw and threatened rain but was tinged with the warmth of spring. 
 The sky was a murky, pinkish grey; clouds swirled across it exposing higher, greyer banks of cloud. 
 She snipped crisp green stalks with a pair of scissors. 
 Milky liquid oozed from the stalks. 
 She had so many daffs in her garden; she could pick loads. 
 On the bus to Alan's flat she held the flowers carefully in her lap, then lifted them to sniff their faint fragrance. 
 &bquo;What an enormous bunch,&equo; said the woman next to her. 
 &bquo;For your Mum are they?&equo; 
 &bquo;What? 
 Oh yes. 
 Of course,&equo; Geraldine replied and left the bus a stop early. 
 The woman was right. 
 The bunch was too big. 
 Geraldine checked no one was looking, took one daffodil and dropped it over a wall into a garden. 
 Did the same again. 
 And again. 
 Until the bunch was not too big. 
 It was too small; it was pathetic. 
 Better to turn up with a single flower. 
 She threw all of them away except one, then realised how silly and significant it would be to arrive on his doorstep with one daffodil; she tucked it  into the contents of an overflowing litter bin and arrived at Alan's empty-handed. 
 They had a good evening together, all the same. 
 She remembered the evening because his parents had given him an awful sweater for his birthday and between comedy programmes on the television she and Alan thought up alternative uses for an awful sweater. 
 The best one was as a skirt, modelled by Geraldine, with the sleeves twisted into a waistband. 
 At six, TV am started and there was a news round-up every fifteen minutes. 
 Geraldine hardly had time to boil the kettle, to make a cup of coffee, to toast a slice of bread between shots of Alan being rescued, wearing a blanket and sitting up in bed in pyjamas. 
 She was used to seeing him in pyjamas by now; also, by now, she quite understood why he wouldn't really want people to see him. 
 She wouldn't either, if she were him.  
 THE BALANCE OF TRADE 
 &bquo;In favour of the motion to increase the subsidy on Uridian marioc by sixteen per cent, 522 votes,&equo; announced Neputa Tharm, Leader of the Council of the Galaxy. 
 &bquo;Against the motion, one vote.&equo; 
 The World stood alone. 
 &bquo;How do I feel?&equo; 
 The President of the World turned quickly to Susan. 
 &bquo;Am I shocked by this decision? 
 Am I taken aback?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; she replied. 
 &bquo;First you are outraged. 
 Thump your fist on the table. 
 Then you are saddened on behalf of the citizens, not just of the World, but of the Galaxy. 
 Shake your head slowly at that point. 
 The sequence of feelings is: anger, dismay, regret, then strong determination.&equo; 
 The President spoke and spoke well, then sat down. 
 It was rare for the Leader of the Council to make a proposal; he did so now. 
 &bquo;The Council must of course proceed on the basis of the vote,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;But the President of the World can have left none of us unmoved by the depth of his feeling. 
 It is within the power of the Council to make a one-off grant to the World for golden hellos to attract a higher calibre of research workers. 
 I believe we would be wrong to do less.&equo; 
 The Council moved to the vote once more. 
 The proposal was agreed. 
 Neputa Tharm brought the proceedings to an  end. 
 The Heads of State rose to their feet. 
 &bquo;A good piece of work, Susan,&equo; said the President of the World. 
 &bquo;Yes, President. 
 It was your delivery. 
 Particularly your timing, switching from regret to determination.&equo; 
 &bquo;Even while I was speaking I realised I could well turn the tables with that. 
 The dinner will be child's play by comparison.&equo; 
 As always after a plenary session of the Council, the dinner was a formal affair. 
 The medals and chains of office of the Heads of State glittered in the white light from cubic fittings suspended over the tables in the banqueting hall. 
 Waiters in the silver national costume of Luctia bowed stiffly as they placed dish after lavish dish in front of the delegates. 
 Susan wore a high-shouldered gold tube of a dress with a tall collar which restricted the movement of her neck. 
 She sat beside the President. 
 The Emperor of Trame leant forward from the opposite side of the table. 
 &bquo;A pleasant surprise for you, I imagine, President,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You cannot have expected such a satisfactory development for the World at such a late stage in the debate.&equo; 
 &bquo;You are not at all satisfied,&equo; Susan said softly into the President's ear. 
 &bquo;Nor are you pleased. 
 You are surprised that the Council could not do more for the World. 
 But you are cautiously optimistic because of the constructive atmosphere in which the talks took place. 
 You are hopeful of better results at future meetings.&equo; 
 After the dinner, each of the Heads of State was to be presented with a small Luctian art form. 
 Susan had read of the ceremony in the factual brief for the President (Michael's brief, but she did not allow herself to think of Michael). 
 She had read, &bquo;Art forms are made by the people of Luctia from the preserved arms and legs of the  people of Vascar. 
 They are exported in large quantities to Coria.&equo; 
 The President accepted his scrap of twisted limb with a gracious smile and said, on Susan's advice, &bquo;I am delighted to receive this gift which I see as a symbol of the cultural and commercial interdependence of the planets. 
 I am confident that we shall move forward from this Council to greater co-operation between the planets and thus to mutual gain.&equo; 
 A nurse switched on the television in the lounge. 
 A voice announced, &bquo;The News, read by Derek Carlisle.&equo; 
 Some of the people sitting at the big table did not even raise their eyes. 
 A woman with long white hair wearing a loose, black dress went on plaiting bright strands of silk; a young, dark man in a sleeveless jerkin continued to bend over the sketch book in which he was drawing. 
 On the screen Derek Carlisle said, &bquo;Our foreign affairs correspondent, Trevor Newsom, is now in the studio on Luctia, ready to explain to us the background to today's decisions by the Council of the Galaxy.&equo; 
 Trevor Newsom's face appeared to one side of Derek's. 
 A small boy in pyjamas put down the basket he was weaving and looked at the face for a second or two, then turned back to his basket. 
 &bquo;Now, Trevor,&equo; Derek Carlisle confronted his colleague, &bquo;we know that the President of the World faced a demand for higher salaries from our research workers; that unless he came up with some incentive we would lose the best of those workers; and that the increased contribution towards marioc manufacture would compete directly for Exchequer funds. 
 But why the need for the increase in the marioc subsidy in the first place?&equo; 
 A small, fair woman came into the lounge, picked up an embroidery frame from the table, turned a chair away from the television, sat on the chair and began to sew.  
 &bquo;Put simply, Derek,&equo; Trevor replied, &bquo;the production costs of marioc have risen in excess of the price the Martians can afford. 
 The Uridian economy depends on income from marioc sales and the Martian economy would collapse without regular supplies of the drug.&equo; 
 &bquo;But there are other markets for marioc. 
 The World, for instance?&equo; 
 &bquo;Tiny by comparison. 
 In the World, marioc is a luxury enjoyed by the few. 
 But the Martian Government has signed a contract guaranteeing weekly delivery to the Furus &mdash; the native tribes of Mars &mdash; in return for which the Furus work the red iron mines. 
 This is to the benefit of both parties. 
 The Furus are addicted to marioc and cannot survive without a regular supply. 
 But conditions in the mines are so appalling that if the Furus were not under the influence of the drug they would undoubtedly refuse outright to go below ground.&equo; 
 &bquo;And red iron? 
 How important is that to the balance of trade?&equo; 
 The dark man stopped drawing. 
 He lift ed his picture, held it at arm's length, considered it, replaced it on the table, rubbed out a couple of lines and carried on drawing. 
 &bquo;Essential.&equo; 
 A shot of a factory. 
 Red iron ore poured continuously from a chute into a labyrinthine machine. 
 Several people wearing masks connected by tubes to cylinders strapped to their backs pulled levers and inspected moving parts of the machine. 
 &bquo;Library footage,&equo; said Trevor, &bquo;of a refinery on Trame. 
 Refined red iron is pumped into the breathing apparatus that each inhabitant of Trame wears at all times. 
 With the help of the red iron a Tramen is able to inhale the atmosphere of the planet &mdash; which would otherwise be deadly to him &mdash; and to exhale gas for export to Vascar. 
 The Vascars have, of course, become headless through repeated exposure to Tramen-exhalation. 
 But the gas also causes them to grow  extra arms and legs (at a rate for the average adult male Vascar of one limb every two months, slightly longer for women and children).&equo; 
 The elderly woman pulled at her silks and a skein fell from her lap. 
 The young, dark man looked at it lying on the floor. 
 He rose, walked round the table and picked up the skein. 
 He touched the woman on her arm and she turned and smiled up at him. 
 He smiled back, dropped the silk in front of her and returned to his drawing. 
 Trevor went on talking to Derek: &bquo;The Luctians preserve Vascar limbs,&equo; he said. 
 A twisted sculpture appeared on the screen. 
 &bquo;&hellip; and carve them into art forms which the Coriads purchase and contemplate to stimulate their lateral thinking.&equo; 
 &bquo;And the World buys the lateral thinking, of course,&equo; said Derek, &bquo;and we transform it in our research establishments into practical schemes for export to Uridia.&equo; 
 &bquo;Exactly, Derek. 
 Uridia, as a developing planet, is much in need of practical schemes but it could no longer pay for them without today's increase in the subsidy. 
 And without the new grant for golden hellos the World would have lost its research workers. 
 So today's decision on the golden hellos is something of a coup for the President of the World.&equo; 
 The small fair woman snipped her blue thread with a pair of scissors. 
 She opened a wicker sewing box, looked inside, shook her head and closed the box again. 
 The elderly woman separated a skein of red silk from the bundle in her lap and gave it to her. 
 A second nurse came into the lounge and switched off the news. 
 It was late, very late. 
 Susan was alone in the double sleeping-space which had been allotted to Michael and her for the night. 
 She took off her shoes. 
 She slipped out of her dress. 
 She went into the adjoining bathroom  and soaked in warm, scented water. 
 She smoothed her skin with oil and chose a short, ice-green robe in which to welcome him. 
 She sat down on the bed. 
 It was a long time since she had last seen Michael: it was seven months, two weeks and three days, four if she counted today. 
 She tried to think about Michael. 
 She was always careful not to think about him during their estrangements but now, with him so near in time, there was a permissible pleasure in doing so. 
 Or perhaps there was a heightened distress? 
 What did she think? 
 That he was tall and broad-shouldered, that his hair was fair and thick, his eyes blue. 
 But what did she feel? 
 To come up with the right emotions for the President of the World, though hard work, was still so much easier than identifying her own. 
 If only she and Michael had more time together, time for her feelings to rise close enough to the surface for her to be sure of what they were. 
 Michael burst into the sleeping-space. 
 &bquo;Darling,&equo; he boomed, &bquo;you've no idea how much I've missed you.&equo; 
 He kissed her. 
 He removed the green robe. 
 He fucked her. 
 He fell asleep. 
 It didn't matter, thought Susan. 
 Breakfast was bound to arrive early enough for them to have time to talk afterwards. 
 Sure enough, in the morning, a small round table holding an appetising array of titbits rose from the floor a minute or two before Susan and Michael had finished their exercise routine. 
 It nearly knocked Susan off her balance. 
 They sat at the table. 
 Michael talked eagerly between mouthfuls. 
 &bquo;So, tell me how you've been, what you've been doing. 
 Before here, I mean. 
 I know all about the marioc debate. 
 I wrote the President's factual brief, did you realise that?&equo; 
 &bquo;I saw your name on the front page.&equo; 
 She wondered whether to say that she had missed him. 
 &bquo;What was it like on the galactic tour of state?&equo; he went  on. 
 &bquo;What did you make of Pollux? 
 Are conditions there as primitive as everyone says?&equo; 
 &bquo;Pretty much,&equo; she said instead. 
 &bquo;How about you? 
 How have you been?&equo; 
 &bquo;Hectic, as ever. 
 I managed to hammer out the brief for the marioc debate in the nick of time. 
 The final information turned up late and we were at it till the small hours. 
 Still, glad to hear that it pulled the President through.&equo; 
 &bquo;Tell you something else,&equo; he said. 
 Susan watched him take a large bite of a Luctian yeast cake. 
 She watched him drain his cup and thump it onto the table. 
 &bquo;You'll never believe who I came across during the talks on Zork.&equo; 
 How did Michael feel, Susan wondered. 
 How did he feel about being here with her? 
 Michael leaned towards her. 
 &bquo;Go on. 
 Guess.&equo; 
 He felt cheerful, she decided. 
 Perhaps he even felt happy. 
 &bquo;I don't know.&equo; 
 &bquo;James. 
 James Cardiff. 
 You remember him. 
 Chap with red hair. 
 Same year as us in college. 
 Quite an old flame of yours.&equo; 
 &bquo;James? 
 He was the first man I ever thought of partnering.&equo; 
 She watched as Michael frowned and leant back. 
 &bquo;Never seriously, of course,&equo; she added quickly. 
 &bquo;Is he stationed on Zork?&equo; 
 &bquo;Far from it. 
 He was taking advantage of one of the training schemes. 
 Said it got him out of the rut for a while. 
 He hasn't worn too well, to be honest. 
 And he's still living in the World. 
 Sorting out the boundary dispute between Russia and the United States.&equo; 
 &bquo;James? 
 In local government? 
 How did he feel about that?&equo; 
 &bquo;No idea. 
 I always said I'd make you a better partner, didn't I? 
 Think where you'd be if you'd chosen him.&equo;  
 Susan made an effort to imagine what it would be like to live a settled life with a partner she saw every day. 
 She could not imagine it. 
 &bquo;We've come a long way, you and I,&equo; Michael went on. 
 &bquo;What's more, we're still going places.&equo; 
 Susan said, &bquo;I'm leaving for Trame tomorrow for the bilaterals. 
 Just for two weeks before we have our home leave together.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ana,&equo; said Michael. 
 &bquo;I've some news too. 
 I've been saving it. 
 I'm in for promotion again. 
 Second Comptroller on Gibor. 
 The President told me in person last night. 
 That's why I was so late.&equo; 
 He paused and frowned again. 
 &bquo;Don't I deserve any congratulations?&equo; 
 &bquo;Michael of course you do. 
 It's wonderful. 
 You must be, you must be&hellip; pleased. 
 You must be delighted: and excited: you must be looking forward to it. 
 When do you start?&equo; 
 &bquo;Right away. 
 It means our not having our leave together. 
 But you don't mind, do you? 
 After all, it's for us.&equo; 
 He looked at his watch. 
 &bquo;I must dash. 
 I want to catch one of the Uridian delegates before he leaves.&equo; 
 He tightened his tie, put on his jacket, picked up his case. 
 &bquo;Onwards and upwards,&equo; he said, bending to kiss her. 
 &bquo;I'll write as usual as soon as I arrive.&equo; 
 In the lounge of the residential home the white-haired woman was moulding a lump of clay. 
 Around her head she wore, Furu-fashion, the bright band she had woven from the silks. 
 The boy sat on the floor beside her, carving a piece of balsa wood. 
 The dark man was also on the floor, kneeling. 
 He stirred a pot of paint, dipped a brush in the paint, bent forward and applied it in slow strokes to the sheet of card in front of him. 
 The boy turned and pointed to the woman's headband. 
 She unwound it and gave it to him. 
 He smoothed it with his fingers. 
 She took it and  tied it round his brow. 
 He lifted the object he was carving, lifted it with both hands to show to her. 
 It was a boat. 
 As before, the news was on. 
 &bquo;We are now going live to Luctia,&equo; said Derek Carlisle. 
 A vast auditorium appeared on the screen; every seat was filled; at the far end was a platform. 
 &bquo;&hellip; where the formal press conference to mark the end of the Council of the Galaxy is about to begin.&equo; 
 The picture changed to a close-up shot of the platform. 
 The table on it held a thicket of microphones, a glass and a jug of water. 
 Behind the table sat the President of the World. 
 Beside the President sat Susan. 
 &bquo;You have already been given a full briefing on the facts,&equo; said the President. 
 &bquo;Now is your opportunity to put to me any questions you have on the detailed implications for the people of the World of the Council's decisions.&equo; 
 &bquo;Could you tell us, President,&equo; Trevor Newsom asked the question, &bquo;how you would describe your feelings when the marioc vote went against you?&equo; 
 The President turned to Susan. 
 There was a pause; the President dipped his head and spoke into the microphones. 
 &bquo;Lonely,&equo; said the President. 
 He frowned and turned back to Susan. 
 She nodded and he went on, &bquo;I was lonely. 
 I was not satisfied. 
 I was not pleased. 
 I was surprised that the Council could not do more for the World. 
 But I am cautiously optimistic about the atmosphere in which the talks were conducted. 
 I am hopeful for better results at future councils. 
 I am lonely yes, but my loneliness is the price I pay in order that the people of the World may look ahead to peace and freedom and to a decent standard of living for their children.&equo; 
 Susan said, loudly enough for her words to be clearly audible, &bquo;That is not what I said President. 
 I said that I am lonely.&equo;  
 Two nurses wheeled a trolley into the lounge, blocking the television screen from the view of the people in the room. 
 &bquo;Time for tea everybody,&equo; said one of the nurses brightly. 
 &bquo;I still don't understand how you could do such a thing,&equo; Michael complained. 
 &bquo;With your emotional experience. 
 Especially as my promotion could go by the board.&equo; 
 Susan did not answer. 
 She looked away from him, out of the car window, seeing nothing. 
 Tears filled her eyes; they rolled down her cheeks and dropped from her chin. 
 She cried silently, but made no effort to stop, although Michael would not like to see her cry. 
 &bquo;I shouldn't have said that,&equo; he went on. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, darling. 
 It's not your fault. 
 A few weeks back here in the World won't do my career serious harm. 
 It's your health that matters. 
 I'll find another post as soon as you're better.&equo; 
 He drove on. 
 &bquo;Can you tell me where to take a left?&equo; he asked after a while. 
 &bquo;It should be somewhere near here.&equo; 
 He turned his head towards her. 
 'You're crying. 
 Why are you crying?&equo; 
 But Susan could not say. 
 &bquo;It's a good thing we've booked you into this place,&equo; Michael continued. 
 &bquo;You know you need professional help. 
 And it's supposed to be the best in the World. 
 We've the President to thank for that. 
 He thinks very highly of you, you know. 
 He wouldn't pick up the tab for anyone else. 
 It's not just the medical attention that's first class either; there's a gym, so you won't give up your exercise routine will you, darling? 
 And a swimming pool. 
 An, this must be it.&equo; 
 There were several people in the room, Susan saw. 
 Maybe as many as ten. 
 One of them was making a basket;  another was drawing; they were all doing something. 
 None of them looked up when she and Michael entered. 
 There was a television in one corner of the room. 
 Its screen was blank. 
 Susan sat on a chair close to the screen. 
 She saw some shadows on its surface, smears of cleaning fluid perhaps. 
 The smears made the shape of a winged lizard, only it had no proper nose. 
 Susan tilted her head. 
 Looked at from this new angle, the smears were only smears. 
 She counted them; she lost count. 
 There were either five smears or six. 
 She counted them again, then realised that Michael was saying goodbye. 
 &bquo;Hate to leave you with this bunch of weirdos. 
 That old woman looks like a witch. 
 Something decidedly peculiar about the boy with the whatsit round his head. 
 And there's a grown man sitting on the floor over there. 
 Look on the bright side, though. 
 At least you have a private room. 
 And you'll soon be out of here in any case. 
 Back at the President's side where you belong. 
 I'll be in to see you tomorrow, darling.&equo; 
 &bquo;It&equo; s a lovely morning.&equo; 
 The nurse pulled back the curtains. 
 &bquo;We'll have everyone out and about today. 
 You could take a stroll in the grounds. 
 Or have a swim. 
 It's up to you.&equo; 
 Susan walked in a small, formal garden. 
 She paced the garden; she found it was an exact square. 
 She stopped and looked at the garden; inside the square was a circle of flower beds. 
 Low clipped hedges enclosed the beds. 
 The circle was divided into four equal segments by two straight paths; she took one of the paths. 
 At the intersection of the paths she came to a fountain. 
 Near the fountain several people sat on canvas chairs, sewing. 
 One of them nodded a greeting to Susan. 
 Susan nodded back. 
 At the end of the garden she reached a summerhouse. 
 Inside the summerhouse she saw an old woman and a boy. 
 The boy held out something to Susan. 
 It was a boat, a wooden boat  for miniature Vikings, with a curved prow and a square sail of bright, woven silk. 
 The old woman was making a clay animal; the animal was a little like a lion, but it was not a lion. 
 It was a gryphon, Susan decided. 
 She walked on. 
 Behind the summerhouse, on a stretch of grass, sat a man, cross-legged. 
 His back was towards her. 
 She walked round him. 
 He was painting a picture. 
 She walked round him again. 
 He did not look up. 
 She returned to the formal garden and paced its perimeter several times, counting her steps to see if the number would be the same on each circuit; but it wasn't. 
 She went indoors to her room, lay on the bed and looked at the ceiling until a nurse brought lunch. 
 In the afternoon Susan sat alone in the lounge. 
 The smears on the television had gone so she gazed at the reflection of the sunlight on the blank screen instead. 
 The door of the room opened. 
 A nurse said, &bquo;Time for you to see the doctor.&equo; 
 Susan followed her along the corridor. 
 A plump man in a three-piece suit shook Susan's hand. 
 &bquo;How are you feeling?&equo; he asked, but she did not answer. 
 &bquo;How are you feeling?&equo; asked Michael afterwards. 
 He was waiting for her in the lounge. 
 On the television in front of them the President of the World said abruptly, &bquo;It's not a question of how I feel. 
 The fact is that we have no option but to raise salaries. 
 The one-off grant was not enough to retain our researchers. 
 We will therefore be unable to pay our contribution to the marioc subsidy. 
 The Council of the Galaxy must make some concession. 
 It's as simple as that.&equo; 
 A close-up of Neputa Tharm followed. 
 &bquo;The President of the World,&equo; he said, &bquo;spoke with great feeling at the last meeting of the Council. 
 But it is clear from the tone of his recent statements that the issue no longer concerns him deeply. 
 We will give no further grant.&equo; 
 &bquo;The President's not the same without you,&equo; said Michael. 
 &bquo;He's losing his touch.&equo;  
 Susan's days fell into a pattern. 
 In the mornings she walked in the formal garden. 
 When the group of people were sewing by the fountain they nodded to her and she nodded back. 
 When the old woman and the boy were in the summerhouse they looked up and smiled and showed her what they were making. 
 Then Susan walked past the summerhouse to watch the dark man paint. 
 She stood for hours behind him, seeing him sketch, then stop and change what he had drawn. 
 She walked round him, but he never raised his head. 
 In the afternoons she sat in the lounge, sometimes on her own, sometimes with the others; but if the others were there she did not look at them, only at the television screen. 
 Nor did she nod to them or smile or turn to see whether the dark man was there and whether he was painting. 
 Michael might come to visit her at any time. 
 &bquo;Don't try to talk,&equo; he said when he came. 
 &bquo;You're not up to it. 
 I'll tell you what's happening outside. 
 The marioc shortage &mdash; that's the main thing these days. 
 The authorities have set a limit of one twist per customer per week, which is no way to handle the problem. 
 They'll end up with panic buying and stockpiling and blackmarket trading. 
 You know we only imported a small amount but all the same there was always enough to meet demand. 
 Makes me glad I never touched the stuff.&equo; 
 He had always put two pinches of it on his food, hadn't he? thought Susan but she wasn't sure and Michael was talking again. 
 &bquo;I blame the emotional advisers. 
 I gather one of them told the President he should be downcast during his negotiations with Uridia. 
 Even I can see that he should have been implacable.&equo; 
 On the screen there were scenes of rioting and looting. 
 Wild-eyed Furus, bright scarves knotted round their brows, hurled chunks of red iron ore through the plate-glass windows of Government House. 
 &bquo;Bit of crisis on Mars, isn't there?&equo; asked Michael. 
 &bquo;Now the Uridians can't  afford to produce enough marioc for the government there to keep the Furus sweet.&equo; 
 Next day, behind the summerhouse, the dark man began to colour in his picture &mdash; he used two colours only, yellow and blue. 
 The picture was of a terraced garden. 
 There were steps from one terrace to another but Susan could not yet see where they would lead in the end. 
 Perhaps to the distant yellow castle? 
 In the foreground, blue water tumbled beside the steps into rectangular pools. 
 Still the man did not look up. 
 Susan wondered how she would feel if he did; or if she touched him or let him know in some other way that she was there? 
 &bquo;It's really time you snapped out of it, whatever it is,&equo; said Michael in the lounge later. 
 &bquo;I've even had a letter from the President's office asking for your date of return. 
 And look what's going on.&equo; 
 He waved his hand towards the TV. 
 &bquo;Martial law has been declared on Mars,&equo; announced Derek Carlisle. 
 &bquo;All mining of red iron has ceased. 
 We are going over to Trame to see what effect this is having.&equo; 
 Tramens lay in the streets, in offices, in their homes, gasping, choking, clutching their throats, fighting for air. 
 &bquo;As yet there have been no fatalities,&equo; said Trevor Newsom, stepping in front of a group of writhing Tramens. 
 &bquo;But without the resumption of a regular supply of red iron, it can only be a matter of time before these tragic people die.&equo; 
 How did Susan feel about that? she wondered. 
 &bquo;It's all such a mess,&equo; said Michael. 
 &bquo;If you could only get over it. 
 Though I'm worried about you first and foremost, of course.&equo; 
 She looked at him. 
 His eyes were bright, his smile false. 
 Perhaps he had found a new temporary partner by now. 
 &bquo;If relations between the planets don't improve the Council may break up altogether,&equo; he went on. 
 &bquo;I could be out of a job. 
 So could you.&equo;  
 Next day, on the stretch of grass behind the summerhouse, Susan touched the dark man's shoulder. 
 The fabric of his jerkin was rough and stiff. 
 He turned towards her. 
 He raised his eyes and smiled. 
 He stretched out his right hand. 
 Susan saw a smear of yellow paint across his knuckles. 
 She watched his hand approach her face, felt it touch her cheek. 
 His hand was warm; he pulled her face to his face with his warm hand. 
 His lips touched Susan's. 
 They were warm too. 
 The sun was bright; Susan closed her eyes and was in darkness. 
 She opened them and was in the light. 
 She lay on the grass, beside him, and looked up at the blue sky. 
 She watched him move between her and the sky. 
 She lay in the sun on the grass with the dark man. 
 &bquo;I can't stay in the World indefinitely,&equo; said Michael the next day. 
 &bquo;I have my future to think about.&equo; 
 He said this so loudly Susan jumped. 
 &bquo;You did hear me then. 
 Why don't you say anything? 
 You haven't spoken a word to me since you came here.&equo; 
 He looked at his watch. 
 &bquo;The news will be on. 
 Will these people notice if I turn up the sound?&equo; 
 &bquo;Details are just reaching us of a major breakthrough in the Martian revolution,&equo; Derek Carlisle announced. 
 &bquo;In return for a cessation of violence, amnesties have been granted to the Furs and a number of them are to be co-opted onto the Government. 
 The Furus have agreed to return to work &mdash; for wages instead of marioc &mdash; on condition that it is not in the red iron mines. 
 The red iron mines are therefore to close. 
 The Furus, after the recent prolonged disruption of their marioc supply, have lost their craving for the drug. 
 The total collapse of the Martian market for marioc is expected to have a major effect on the economy of Uridia.&equo; 
 Loud music flooded the room; on the screen people were dancing, as far as the eye could see. 
 &bquo;I am standing in what until very recently was one of the largest Uridian  marioc manufacturing centres,&equo; Trevor Newson poked his microphone in front of the nearest dancer. 
 &bquo;How do you feel about the loss of Uridia's main market for marioc?&equo; he shouted above the music. 
 &bquo;Terrific. 
 All the more for us. 
 Join the party,&equo; the dancer replied. 
 The picture changed once more. 
 &bquo;Yes, a remarkable discovery,&equo; said the Emperor of Trame. 
 &bquo;If we breathe through our pores instead of the apparatus we have no problem at all. 
 And we all feel so much better.&equo; 
 In the morning Susan watched as the dark man made the steps in the picture higher and steeper. 
 The steps were in flights, with platforms at intervals which would allow her to stop and rest. 
 She would be panting, longing to reach the top. 
 What would she see when she arrived? 
 She touched his shoulder as she had the day before. 
 He looked up at her and smiled and she lay down with him on the grass in the sun. 
 Michael did not visit the next day, nor the day after. 
 On the third day Susan received a letter from him in which he explained that he was in a clinic for marioc addicts, &bquo;Not that I could be called an addict,&equo; he wrote, &bquo;and this place is more of a health farm, really.&equo; 
 That afternoon Susan sat in the lounge with the other people. 
 She looked at them one by one; she nodded to the people she had seen sewing by the fountain; she smiled at the old woman and the boy. 
 She rose, crossed the room and sat with the dark man on the floor. 
 On the TV screen was a crowded room; smartly-dressed people sipped cocktails; they talked with animation. 
 &bquo;As a Vascar,&equo; said Trevor Newsom to a woman in a purple, off-the-shoulder frock, &bquo;you must surely regret that you can no longer grow the extra arms and legs on which your livelihood depends?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not a bit of it,&equo; The woman laughed. 
 &bquo;As you can see, now that we have stopped exposing ourselves to Tramen-exhalation we have developed heads and can talk to  each other for the first time. 
 We're all discovering conversation. 
 No market for it of course, but what the Hell? 
 Now, who can I introduce you to?&equo; 
 &bquo;There are changes on Luctia, too.&equo; 
 The television showed two children chasing each other round a car, shrieking. 
 A woman and a man were packing a hamper, blankets and Wellingtons into the car. 
 &bquo;Trevor Newsom,&equo; said Derek Carlisle, &bquo;is now on Luctia, having just arrived from Vasca where he earlier recorded the interview we have just seen.&equo; 
 An exhausted-looking Trevor walked into the picture. 
 He approached the man. 
 &bquo;Today is Tuesday,&equo; he said, &bquo;a working day. 
 Could you tell us why you are not at work?&equo; 
 The man replied. 
 &bquo;Nothing to preserve now the Vascars have no limbs to sell to us. 
 May as well live in the present, that's what I say. 
 You ought to have a day off yourself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where are you going?&equo; 
 &bquo;To the mountains.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; cried the children. 
 &bquo;Let's go to the sea.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, let's,&equo; said the woman. 
 The man said. 
 &bquo;Quickly, then. 
 Run and fetch your swimsuits. 
 Before the sun goes in.&equo; 
 After that two giggling Coriads appeared. 
 They had their arms around each other. 
 &bquo;Fuck lateral thinking,&equo; said one of them. 
 &bquo;We're going to have a shot at making love sideways instead.&equo; 
 Finally, a press conference. 
 &bquo;A question for the President of the World.&equo; 
 (Trevor Newsom is speaking to the President by satellite from Luctia, interposed Derek Carlisle.) 'How do you feel about the collapse of interplanetary trade?&equo; asked Trevor. 
 &bquo;Are you weary of the endless round of new developments? 
 Are you exhausted by the continuing, surprising sequence of events? 
 Are you burned out? 
 Are you finished?&equo; 
 And the President replied, &bquo;No. 
 I am disappointed. 
 I am resolute. 
 No. 
 I am implacable. 
 I am outraged. 
 Angry. 
 Optimistic. 
 Yes, I am  optimistic. 
 And confident. 
 And taken aback.&equo; 
 A nurse came into the room and switched off the news. 
 Susan looked at the dark man's picture. 
 The yellow steps rose in steep flights but now it was clear that when she reached the top she would also be at the bottom, starting out. 
 The blue water which tumbled down formal cascades fell through several levels but the lowest level fed into the highest. 
 Susan did not know how she felt about this until she saw that he had painted himself and herself half-way up or half-way down, looking up or down at their reflections in the water. 
 She felt that she would like to take up life drawing. 
 Either that or sculpture.  
 AVOIDING GATWICK 
 Saturday morning and Sara was packing. 
 Books first &mdash; the new Fay Weldon, an Alan Coren paperback collection and a weighty Zo&euml; Oldenburg. 
 Then a pack of cards, and backgammon, Trivial Pursuit and Monopoly because she was sure the cottage would have only Snakes and Ladders and jigsaws with several pieces missing. 
 For the daytimes she would need swimsuit, snorkel and flippers; oilskin, so rain could not stop her going out; Hunter boots and crash cap because she was bound to find a riding stable; tennis racquet &mdash; on the offchance, as Rodney didn't play; a frisbee; a lilo; shorts, walking boots, a pedometer, a compass, a small knapsack and a thermos. 
 Oh, and she would take the folding bike. 
 She went downstairs to the kitchen where Rodney was packing food and cookery equipment into cartons. 
 &bquo;Surely you won't need the fish kettle?&equo; she queried. 
 She opened the cutlery drawer. 
 &bquo;What have you done with the spanners? 
 I put one in here yesterday.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's not where they belong. 
 Why do you want a spanner?&equo; 
 &bquo;For the bike. 
 If I fold it up it'll fit in the back of the car.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't. 
 We won't be able to take the second case of wine.&equo;  
 Sara sighed. 
 She said, &bquo;(a) it hardly takes up any room once it's folded. 
 (b) if you take the aubergines, artichokes and courgettes out of those boxes and put them in the glove compartment, on the back shelf, wedge them between other things on the floor, there will be loads of space. 
 Presumably the tool kit does still live in the cupboard under the stairs?&equo; 
 He nodded. 
 At least they wouldn't be bored this year, Sara reflected as she rummaged in the kit. 
 Holidays could be difficult. 
 She sometimes thought that if they went somewhere hot and beachy as most people did &mdash; the Seychelles, the Maldives, the Caribbean &mdash; they would spend the whole day swimming or sunbathing. 
 But they had long since agreed that there was nowhere to touch the English countryside. 
 Plus none of that awful hassle at Gatwick. 
 She found a spanner and set to work on the bike. 
 But this year, she thought with satisfaction, she was well-prepared; and Rodney had found a much larger place than usual and invited all and sundry to join them. 
 She returned to the kitchen and replaced the spanner in the cutlery drawer. 
 &bquo;On second thoughts,&equo; she said, taking it out again. 
 &bquo;I'll need it for the bike when we arrive. 
 Incidentally, I'm ready. 
 We did agree we'd start before twelve.&equo; 
 Late afternoon. 
 Rodney was not in the best of tempers because (he kept saying) he couldn't see out of the rear window with that damned bicycle in the way. 
 Sara was not in the best of tempers because (she kept saying) she had nowhere to put her feet between the aubergines and the case of wine on the floor. 
 But they were nearly there. 
 They turned off the main road and caught sight of the cottage. 
 It was a glorious cottage. 
 Its walls were of pinkwashed cob, its roof was thatched and it stood on its own. 
 Behind were purple moors; in front were the cliffs and the sea. 
 Rodney pulled up outside the cottage. 
 Sara jumped out of the car, ran through the garden and opened the  front door. 
 &bquo;Exposed beams,&equo; she called excitedly over her shoulder. 
 &bquo;A huge fireplace. 
 And chintz curtains.&equo; 
 She opened another door and found a proper farmhouse kitchen, large and homely, with quarry tiled floor, scrubbed table and four chairs. 
 Rodney joined her. 
 As usual he made small disappointing discoveries in the kitchen drawers. 
 &bquo;Only three saucepans and the frying pan is too thin for stir-fry. 
 No salad bowl. 
 Good job I remembered the garlic press. 
 But roughing it a bit is part of the fun.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm going to look upstairs,&equo; said Sara, &bquo;and choose our room.&equo; 
 &bquo;Make it the one with the hardest bed,&equo; he responded. 
 &bquo;Otherwise it's up to you.&equo; 
 Sara inspected each of the three bedrooms. 
 The first was scarcely large enough to qualify as a room. 
 Its ceiling sloped and it held a narrow bed with a small table beside it; no space for anything else. 
 The second had a double bed but was at the back of the cottage and overlooked an overgrown vegetable patch. 
 The third was big and light, contained a cupboard, a chest of drawers and twin beds which Sara did not try. 
 She looked out of the window;, the view was of the sea. 
 &bquo;We're sleeping in the front. 
 Are you ready to explore?&equo; she called to Rodney, joyously, as she ran down the narrow stairs. 
 But Rodney replied that he wanted to work out which utensils he could improvise with and make a start on the boeuf bourguignon. 
 Sara stood in the road and inhaled warm, clean country air in which she could distinguish the smell of the sea from a hint of the gorse on the hills. 
 She set off, passing a field of cows on her left, until she reached a gate to a grassy track. 
 Walks across the moors she thought, beginning to plan her activities for the week. 
 For now she stuck to the road which took her to the right, towards the sea. 
 She walked almost to the edge of the cliff, where the road made a sharp left. 
 Ahead lay a steep, narrow valley and a village, diminutive at this distance, its buildings clustered round a harbour. 
 Below,  uneven steps carved out of the cliff led down to a small sandy cove. 
 Sara was pleased with the cove. 
 It was close enough to the cottage for her to take an early morning dip or a quick swim before dinner. 
 At the far end a rocky promontory extended into deep water &mdash; a promising place for snorkelling. 
 She turned to walk back, then decided to jog. 
 A second car was parked outside the cottage. 
 In the kitchen she found Rodney stirring the contents of two saucepans and Veronica, John and a young man she did not know sitting at the table drinking wine. 
 &bquo;Hello all,&equo; Sara said. 
 &bquo;Where did you get to?&equo; 
 Rodney looked up crossly. 
 &bquo;I could have done with a hand.&equo; 
 &bquo;This is Peter,&equo; Veronica announced. 
 &bquo;Lovely to see you, Sara.&equo; 
 &bquo;And you. 
 I was exploring, Rodney. 
 Do I get a drink? 
 Hello, Peter,&equo; but Peter didn't reply. 
 John poured her a glass of wine. 
 &bquo;Peter's just split up with his partner. 
 Have to bear with him. 
 Great place this. 
 You look as though it's done you good already.&equo; 
 &bquo;There are a few drawbacks.&equo; 
 Rodney began to serve rice. 
 &bquo;No tablespoons, for a start,&equo; brandishing the dessertspoon he was using. 
 &bquo;And I found a list of rules pinned to the larder door. 
 It says no smoking in the house; if we break anything we have to pay for it; if we make any calls there's a money box beside the phone; no dogs in the lounge, though that won't affect us; the tables in the living room mark easily so use a coaster if you take your drink in there. 
 And we can't light a fire, the chimney hasn't been swept.&equo; 
 He dipped a spoon into the boeuf bourguignon. 
 &bquo;Sara, how about being useful? 
 Making the salad?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll do it.&equo; 
 Veronica rose from her chair. 
 She washed a Cos lettuce, leaf by leaf, then patted each of them carefully with a tea towel. 
 &bquo;That's the way, &bquo;Rodney approved. 
 &bquo;Sara always forgets  to dry them separately.&equo; 
 &bquo;But it's essential! 
 Otherwise the dressing won't adhere.&equo; 
 After dinner they agreed that Rodney should not wash up. 
 Peter produced a bottle of Bacardi, poured himself a large measure, added some coca cola, looked in the fridge, commented gloomily, &bquo;No ice,&equo; and followed Rodney into the living room. 
 John issued instructions. 
 &bquo;I'll wash, Sara, you dry.&equo; 
 Veronica added that she'd put away later and went to join the others. 
 John and Sara sang Buddy Holly songs while they worked: &bquo;Words of Love&equo; and &bquo;Peggy Sue&equo; and &bquo;Peggy Sue Got Married.&equo; 
 By the time they started &bquo;I Guess it Doesn't Matter Anymore&equo; they were onto the last saucepan and the table was covered with clean, dry things. 
 &bquo;Do you remember, baby, last September how you held me ti-ight each and every ni-ight?&equo;, they sang as the back door opened and Nick came in, a bottle of wine in each hand. 
 &bquo;We-ell whoops a daisy, how you drove me crazy,&equo; sang Nick, pirouetting and waving the bottles in the air, &bquo;but I guess it doesn't matter anymore.&equo; 
 And he dumped the wine on the table with a crash. 
 A clean glass fell onto its side, rolled off the table onto the quarry tiles and shattered. 
 &bquo;What on earth's going on?&equo; 
 Rodney appeared in the living room doorway. 
 &bquo;Oh hello, Nick. 
 Glad you made it. 
 We'll have to pay for that. 
 Where's Carla?&equo; 
 She followed Nick into the room and held out a bunch of sweet peas, wrapped in paper. 
 &bquo;We brought you these, Sara. 
 Stopped specially at a stall by the side of the road. 
 Aren't they lovely?&equo; 
 A few overblown petals drift ed to the floor. 
 &bquo;My fault,&equo; said Nick as a big, yellow dog bounced through the door. 
 &bquo;You've met The Hound before, haven't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mind his paws on the glass,&equo; Carla warned. 
 Nick pushed the dog into the living room and shut the door behind it. 
 He gestured at the bottles. 
 &bquo;Shall I open these? 
 To restore the peace.&equo; 
 He began to do so. 
 &bquo;If not the pieces.&equo; 
 Then  everyone went into the living room, leaving Sara to sweep up. 
 When she joined them Rodney was making another announcement. 
 &bquo;There's one double room to spare, one single and the floor in here. 
 Sara and I are in the front bedroom. 
 Apart from that I leave you to make your own sleeping arrangements. 
 Nick, the dog isn't allowed in here.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was only because of the glass. 
 I'll put a mat in the kitchen for him later. 
 Would anyone prefer whisky?&equo; 
 Next morning Sara woke to find Rodney asleep and early sunshine seeping between the curtains. 
 Downstairs she stepped past two sleeping bodies in the living room and closed the front door quietly behind her. 
 One of the cows mooed as she passed their field. 
 She reached the cliff and scrambled down the steps to the beach. 
 The sea was so cold she had to force herself to take the plunge. 
 She swam, as strongly as she could, twice across the cove. 
 It was the perfect start &mdash; the real start &mdash; to the week. 
 She returned to the cottage. 
 The smell of fresh coffee and frying bacon filled the kitchen. 
 Rodney was standing at the cooker. 
 The others were sitting at the table. 
 Veronica lit a cigarette. 
 &bquo;No smoking,&equo; he turned, spatula in hand. 
 &bquo;One of the rules of the house.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nonsense,&equo; Veronica replied, &bquo;we can give the place a good airing before we go.&equo; 
 Sara began to look for a cup. 
 &bquo;In that case I'll have one too,&equo; Nick took a pack of Silk Cut from his pocket. 
 Sara found a dirty mug on the draining board and washed it. 
 &bquo;If you must smoke you could at least go in the living room while I'm cooking,&equo; said Rodney. 
 &bquo;Who asked for two eggs and a sausage?' 
 &bquo;I did,&equo; said John. 
 The smokers left. 
 Sara poured coffee and sat down. 
 &bquo;Did you sleep well, John?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Not too bad. 
 Bed was a bit hard.&equo; 
 Rodney cracked two eggs into the frying pan. 
 &bquo;I'm not doing this every morning,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;With so many of us  we ought to set a rota for cooking. 
 And for chores. 
 Before we even decide what to do today.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fit me in where you need,&equo; said Sara. 
 &bquo;I'm taking the bike to the village.&equo; 
 In the event she cycled much further, because she was given directions in the village to a riding stable. 
 By the time she found it, booked a ride for the next day and searched &mdash; without success &mdash; for tennis courts, and pushed the bike up the steep hill which led to the cottage, it was mid-afternoon. 
 She stopped to catch her breath, heard voices, crossed the strip of grass and looked over the cliff. 
 The others &mdash; Rodney and Veronica in the lead &mdash; were straggling up the steps from the cove. 
 She waited for them and told Rodney, &bquo;I booked a horse for tomorrow afternoon.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good for you,&equo; he said, and turned to Veronica. 
 &bquo;You must tell me what you think of the terrine. 
 We'll have it as the first course this evening.&equo; 
 Sara mounted her bicycle and rode back to the cottage. 
 She changed into her swimsuit and returned to the cove for a quick dip. 
 She was back again, wriggling out of her wet swimsuit in the bedroom when Rodney came in. 
 He said, &bquo;You're down to lay the table in a few minutes.&equo; 
 Sara fastened her bra and pulled on her shirt. 
 Rodney sat on the bed. 
 &bquo;And,&equo; he added, &bquo;you're part of the shopping expedition tomorrow morning.&equo; 
 Sara went to bed immediately after dinner. 
 She set the alarm. 
 After all that exercise she might sleep too long. 
 She didn't, but in the morning as she snapped off the alarm, anxious not to wake Rodney, she saw that the man in the next bed was not Rodney, nor was he asleep. 
 &bquo;It's no big deal.&equo; 
 Peter rolled onto his side and shrugged the covers over his shoulder. 
 &bquo;Besides I'm gay.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where's Rodney?&equo; 
 &bquo;Playing Monopoly last time I saw him. 
 Only he and Veronica left in the game. 
 Must have been two o'clock in the morning. 
 We gave up on them.&equo;  
 Sara dressed in the bathroom. 
 She took a long time to dress. 
 She wanted to bike along the road for a swim but after she finished dressing she simply sat on the edge of the bath and looked out of the window. 
 It was gone eight before there was a knock on the door. 
 &bquo;Anybody in there?&equo; 
 John's voice called. 
 She opened the door. 
 'You look fresh as a daisy which is more than can be said for the rest of us.&equo; said John. 
 &bquo;Is everyone up?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Far as I know, yes. 
 Veronica's started breakfast.&equo; 
 In the kitchen she found Veronica cooking and Rodney sitting at the table writing a list. 
 &bquo;You're in charge of this, Sara. 
 Make sure you don't miss anything.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aren't you coming?&equo; 
 &bquo;Veronica and I are going to look for mushrooms.&equo; 
 After breakfast John wanted to explore, so Nick drove Sara, Carla and peter into the nearest town. 
 They parked in a &bquo;Pay and Display&equo;. 
 Nick and Peter went in search of an off-licence. 
 Carla went to find craft shops and Sara went to buy Rodney's provisions on her own. 
 It wasn't easy. 
 Many of the items were unobtainable. 
 She couldn't find coriander, only English parsley. 
 No Chinese leaves, only Iceberg lettuce. 
 Back at the cottage she found Rodney and Veronica in the kitchen picking over a pile of fungi. 
 Rodney looked up as Sara and the others trooped in. 
 &bquo;We've got quite a haul. 
 Mainly horse mushrooms, but a handful of parasols too.&equo; 
 Sara asked, &bquo;Where did you get to last night?&equo; 
 &bquo;One or two of these mushrooms are deliquescing already,&equo; Rodney picked out a couple and put them in a plastic bag. 
 &bquo;We decided to have a rota for the beds as well,&equo; he went on, still inspecting the mushrooms. 
 &bquo;Otherwise the same two people have to sleep on the floor all week. 
 I thought of making soup with these, but we'd lose the delicacy of the flavour.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mean there'll be someone different in the bed next to me tonight?&equo;  &bquo;'Fraid not. 
 You're down for the floor. 
 It's perfectly comfortable if you use the cushions from the armchairs. 
 I could bake them &mdash; what do you think, Veronica? 
 Maybe with twists of bacon. 
 How does that sound for lunch?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't have time for lunch,&equo; said Sara. 
 &bquo;I'm due for my ride.&equo; 
 Sara's legs were trembling with exhaustion by the time she reached the stables. 
 A girl in breeches led out a grey horse and said, &bquo;I'm Fay. 
 This is Pepper. 
 If you like to get on I'll fetch my horse.&equo; 
 Fay and Sara rode up a steep track. 
 As they climbed higher the air became cooler and a light breeze rustled the gorse beside the track. 
 Pepper lift ed his head, snorted and jogged. 
 They reached the open moors. 
 Fay asked, &bquo;Okay to canter?&equo; and they were off. 
 The horses took clumps of gorse and two stone walls in their stride; they ripped through a copse. 
 Sara ducked her head to dodge low branches; brambles tore at her legs. 
 They came to the edge of the moors and turned down a steep track towards the beach. 
 Stones spurted from the horses' hooves and then they were on a wide stretch of sand, galloping full speed, flying in the face of the wind; the sea, the sky, the cliffs streamed past Sara's stinging cheeks. 
 &bquo;Nice ride?&equo; 
 Rodney asked later as Sara came into the living room of the cottage. 
 &bquo;I've been telling Veronica about the week we had in Scotland. 
 Remember the fresh salmon?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes thanks. 
 Yes I remember. 
 I'm exhausted.&equo; 
 &bquo;You look wonderful,&equo; said John, &bquo;glowing with health. 
 Shall I pour you a cup of tea? 
 It's just made.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thanks.&equo; 
 Sara dumped herself on the sofa. 
 &bquo;Been swimming?&equo; she asked Carla who was curled in an armchair, wrapped in a purple towel. 
 &bquo;How was the water?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've just had a bath.&equo; 
 &bquo;You could do with one yourself, Sara,&equo; commented  Rodney. 
 &bquo;I can smell horse from the other side of the room. 
 You sitting on the sofa is as bad as letting the dog on it.&equo; 
 Sara felt better after a cup of tea. 
 She went upstairs, changed into her swimsuit and set off, on foot, for the cove. 
 She plunged into the sea, grateful for the buoyancy of the salt water, then decided to push herself, swam the width of the cove six times and stumbled out onto the sand, shivering. 
 Back in the cottage she found everyone in the kitchen. 
 Rodney was standing at one end of the table, a turquoise can in his hand. 
 &bquo;Who on earth bought this?&equo; he asked. 
 Sara said, &bquo;It said beans. 
 On the list.&equo; 
 He turned to look at her. 
 &bquo;I might have known it was you. 
 It said pinto beans. 
 I was going to make baked beans for tomorrow lunch.&equo; 
 &bquo;Those are baked beans. 
 I often have them when you're not back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Real beans. 
 Home-made baked beans. 
 They take eighteen hours all told, including the overnight soaking. 
 You know that perfectly well. 
 And another thing. 
 Somebody bought honey instead of molasses.&equo; 
 &bquo;They're both natural sweeteners. 
 I was in a hurry.&equo; 
 &bquo;A hurry? 
 This is a holiday, or hadn't you noticed? 
 And have you forgotten you're down to cook tonight?&equo; 
 &bquo;So am I.&equo; It was John who spoke. 
 &bquo;We haven't even started. 
 How about going out for a meal instead?&equo; 
 &bquo;We go out on the last night,&equo; said Rodney. 
 &bquo;We can do that too. 
 Live dangerously. 
 I'll find a place in the phone book and book a table.&equo; 
 &bquo;You won't need the phone book. 
 I brought the Good Food Guide . 
 Don't forget to put 10p in the box.&equo; 
 They went in Nick's car and Rodney and Sara's car. 
 In Rodney and Sara's car were Rodney, Sara, Veronica and John. 
 Rodney drove, Veronica sat in the front. 
 &bquo;What's  this on the floor?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;It's probably an aubergine,&equo; Sara replied. 
 At the restaurant they were ushered into a small, extremely hot cocktail lounge. 
 Sara looked at her watch. 
 It was eight thirty-five. 
 &bquo;I thought you booked for eight-thirty, John.&equo; 
 &bquo;I did. 
 They're always behind in this sort of place. 
 What would you like to drink?&equo; 
 She chose a dry martini because it would have an olive she could eat. 
 She sat in a corner on an antique settle as far away as possible from the blazing open fire. 
 John sat beside her. 
 Rodney opened a large, red menu. 
 &bquo;I'd steer clear of the fruit soup,&equo; he advised Veronica. 
 &bquo;No reason I can see not to try the goulash.&equo; 
 Nick studied the wine list. 
 &bquo;They've a Bulgarian red. 
 That should go with most things.&equo; 
 They all ordered. 
 John talked to Sara but she didn't listen, just nodded from time to time. 
 When at last a waiter said &bquo;Your table is ready,&equo; Sara looked at her watch again and found that it was nine-fifteen. 
 Ages later, Rodney leant across Veronica. 
 &bquo;Sara, do this with your Access.&equo; 
 Sara did. 
 They would all chip in later, of course, but she was too shattered right now, they must all be too shattered right now, to start doing sums, working out who had eaten what and how much it had cost. 
 Not too shattered when they arrived at the cottage to propose a round of Trivial Pursuit. 
 Nick poured glasses of whisky. 
 He had forgotten the coasters, Sara noticed. 
 But Rodney had not noticed, he was so deep in conversation with Veronica. 
 Also the dog was sitting on the carpet on Carla's bare feet. 
 Sara longed to sleep. 
 Unfortunate that it was her turn for the floor. 
 In the end she found a couple of blankets and the alarm clock and curled up regardless. 
 Voices continued for hours, snapping her to occasional attention. 
 &bquo;A googly,&equo; said one. 
 &bquo;The Daily Mirror ,&equo; said another. 
 &bquo;Ypres,&equo; &bquo;Michaelangelo,&equo; &bquo;Morse Code,&equo; &bquo;Tar-macadam.&equo;  
 In the night Sara woke to find Rodney's arms round her. 
 &bquo;Not now,&equo; she protested groggily, &bquo;I need my sleep.&equo; 
 But he kissed her just the same. 
 He was not Rodney. 
 She stumbled to her feet, crossed the dark room and switched on the light. 
 John was sitting on the floor in a tangle of blankets. 
 &bquo;You should have said earlier,&equo; he complained. 
 &bquo;You were much more agreeable in the restaurant.&equo; 
 She picked up the alarm clock, three large cushions and a blanket, went into the kitchen and closed the door firmly behind her. 
 She arranged her cushions on the floor with the alarm clock beside them, switched out the light and slipped under the blanket. 
 The Hound snuggled down next to her. 
 It was just after seven-thirty when Sara woke. 
 The Hound was lying on her arm. 
 She pushed it off, rose and went to look out of the window to see what the weather was like. 
 It was raining; by the look of the heavy, grey sky it would rain all day. 
 She filled the kettle and switched it on. 
 She opened the door to the living room; John was fast asleep. 
 She climbed the stairs and peered into the room she had chosen for Rodney and herself. 
 Nick was in one bed, Carla in the other. 
 She tiptoed past them to the chest of drawers, took out a pair of shorts and a sweatshirt and slipped back downstairs to the kitchen. 
 She splashed her face with cold water at the sink; she dressed, made a sandwich, filled her thermos with coffee, packed a compass and a map into her knapsack, laced her walking boots and fixed her pedometer to her belt. 
 She took her oilskin from the hook on the back door, buttoned herself into it and stepped out, still undetected. 
 She strode past the field of cows and turned up the grassy track. 
 Soon she was in the moors. 
 The rain fell steadily; wet bracken brushed her bare legs. 
 She stopped in the shelter of a stone wall, drank a cup of coffee, consulted the map and decided to aim for a twenty-five  mile circuit which would bring her out, eventually, at the foot of the steep hill near the village. 
 She rose to her feet and walked on; every so often she checked her pedometer, as she clocked up five, ten, fifteen miles. 
 It was still raining hours later when Sara returned to the cottage. 
 She was cold and tired; the oilskin had kept her shoulders dry but her socks were drenched and the turn-ups of her shorts flapped wetly against her knees. 
 She found the kitchen empty. 
 She hung her oilskin on the hook, left her muddy boots on a piece of newspaper and went into the living room. 
 Peter and Nick were sitting on the sofa sharing a bottle of whisky with Sara's backgammon board between them. 
 Carla was cross-legged on the floor next to the coffee table on which she was playing Patience with Sara's cards. 
 Rodney was in an easy chair; Veronica perched on its arm. 
 He was reading aloud from Sara's Alan Coren collection. 
 He stopped reading when he saw her. 
 &bquo;You look as though you got wet.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm going to have a bath.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't.&equo; 
 Nick looked up from the backgammon board. 
 &bquo;John is.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're still down to cook,&equo; said Rodney. 
 &bquo;And no tinned baked beans please.&equo; 
 Sara went upstairs to the front bedroom, dumped her knapsack on the floor, took off her socks and shorts and sat on one of the beds. 
 She remembered the sandwich she had packed, but not eaten. 
 She took it out of the knapsack, poured coffee from the thermos and ate and drank. 
 She would lie on the bed &mdash; just for a moment, she thought &mdash; before starting dinner. 
 She lay down. 
 She fell into deep sleep. 
 When Sara woke it was light, the bright light of late morning. 
 The bed next to her was empty. 
 She padded across to the window, drew back the curtains and looked out. 
 Veronica lay in a bikini on Sara's lilo on the  lawn; Rodney was rubbing sun tan lotion on her back. 
 Peter and John were playing French cricket with Sara's tennis racquet. 
 Carla and Nick were sitting on the grass, languidly tossing Sara's frisbee to and fro. 
 The Hound was chewing one of Sara's flippers. 
 She looked at her watch. 
 It was after ten o'clock. 
 She dressed hurriedly, made herself a snack, took the bike and wheeled it round the corner of the cottage into the front garden. 
 &bquo;Well, look who's here,&equo; said Nick. 
 &bquo;The original sleeping beauty,&equo; said John, &bquo;only she didn't have a prince to wake her.&equo; 
 Rodney said, &bquo;We've put you down for dinner, seeing as you chickened out again last night.&equo; 
 Sara said nothing. 
 She mounted the bike and set off. 
 She freewheeled into the village, pedalled doggedly through it, then tackled the hill on the other side. 
 The sun was hot. 
 Sweat dripped into her eyes. 
 She turned up a lane which was even steeper than the road she had just left. 
 She pressed on, walking when she was forced to until &mdash; she checked her watch &mdash; it was one o'clock. 
 The morning was over. 
 She stopped and sat on the grass verge. 
 Far below, the sea sparkled under a shimmering haze of heat. 
 Tiny boats bobbed in the harbour. 
 She stretched her aching legs. 
 What should she do now? 
 She climbed onto the bike and set off in the direction from which she had come, gathering speed as she descended. 
 She went faster and faster, swinging round corners, bumping over uneven patches in the lane. 
 At the junction with the road she braked just long enough to see that nothing was coming then turned right and careered wildly down the long hill into the village. 
 She decided to take a look at the harbour. 
 She pushed the bike along the quay, sniffing the tarry, fishy air. 
 The tide was in; water lapped against the harbour wall. 
 She came to a blackboard on which she read, &bquo;Sea fishing. 
 Two p.m. 
 Ten pounds.&equo; 
 Sea fishing! 
 That's what she  would do next. 
 She groped in the pocket of her shorts. 
 She had just enough money. 
 There were two other passengers in the boat. 
 Sara ignored them as the boat chugged out to sea; soon the harbour and the cliffs were a long way away. 
 The boat stopped and its owner announced, &bquo;We'll try here. 
 Take a rod each.&equo; 
 Sara dropped her line into the water and let it unravel. 
 Time drift ed past. 
 Suddenly her line tightened, so suddenly she squeaked with surprise. 
 &bquo;You've caught one,&equo; said the boat owner, &bquo;reel in your line.&equo; 
 Sara reeled. 
 The pull of the invisible creature grew stronger. 
 Now she could see shapes beneath the water; now there were three, no here came another one &mdash; four &mdash; silvery fish dancing in mid-air on her line. 
 Icy drops of water fell from them onto her sun-warmed arms. 
 The mackerel landed slithering on the deck. 
 The boat owner seized them, twisted the hooks from their mouths and tossed the fish, tails still flapping, into a bucket. 
 &bquo;Quick, reel your line out again,&equo; he said, as one of the other two people squealed, &bquo;I've caught one.&equo; 
 Soon all three of them were reeling out and reeling in, pouncing on the fish as soon as they could reach them and pulling the hooks from their mouths. 
 The air was filled with wriggling fish and bright drops of water. 
 Sara's arms ached from the weight of the rod and the reel. 
 The bucket seethed with dying fish. 
 Blood from their mouths stained the deck. 
 &bquo;Time to stop and turn back,&equo; said the boat owner. 
 She carried her haul up the hill to the cottage where she found the kitchen empty once again, although she could hear people talking in the living room. 
 She tipped the fish into the sink and began to clean them. 
 She planned to grill them until their skins were brown and crackly. 
 She would eat hers with mustard, a green salad and French bread. 
 Fresh fruit afterwards with cheese. 
 Simple, quick, delicious. 
 She could hardly wait.  
 The door to the living room opened and Rodney came in. 
 &bquo;What's that wonderful smell?&equo; 
 He pulled out the grill. 
 &bquo;Mackerel! 
 Terrific idea. 
 I'll bet they're really fresh. 
 Probably caught last night.&equo; 
 He pushed them back under the heat. 
 &bquo;I caught them. 
 This afternoon.&equo; 
 &bquo;You what? 
 You caught them? 
 How?&equo; 
 &bquo;I went in a boat. 
 Miles out to sea. 
 It cost ten pounds.&equo; 
 He strode back to the living room doorway. 
 &bquo;Hey, everyone,&equo; he announced, &bquo;you'll never believe what Sara's done, the trouble she's taken over dinner.&equo; 
 He turned back to her. 
 &bquo;What are we having with them?&equo; 
 She told him. 
 &bquo;Not bad. 
 Not bad at all,&equo; he judged. 
 &bquo;Mind you, if you'd said in advance I would have done gooseberry sauce. 
 And new potatoes. 
 That would have lifted the meal into the gourmet class.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're not on the rota for cooking.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll check who is.&equo; 
 He crossed the room and consulted the list on the wall. 
 &bquo;John,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Incidentally, according to this we're both down for beds tonight. 
 We can have the room you chose at the beginning of the week.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't need any help with the food. 
 John can lay the table.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll tell him to get his skates on. 
 And I'll ask Nick and Peter about which wine.&equo; 
 The kitchen became a hive of activity. 
 Nick and Peter were standing in front of the fridge arguing over whether a Muscadet or a white Burgundy would best bring out the flavour of the fish. 
 Rodney was discussing with Veronica whether people should be given the choice of English or French mustard. 
 John was setting out knives and forks. 
 Carla was arranging a posy of wild flowers for the centre of the table. 
 And The Hound was rushing about sniffing and getting under everyone's feet. 
 In just over ten minutes they all sat down. 
 And oh, they were impressed! 
 Between mouthfuls they exclaimed at  Sara's cleverness and at the tastiness of the fish. 
 Sara did not reply; she was too hungry to spare any attention from her food. 
 As soon as they finished the first course Rodney raised his wine glass. 
 &bquo;A toast to Sara,&equo; he proposed, &bquo;for the best meal yet.&equo; 
 &bquo;To Sara,&equo; echoed the others, &bquo;for the best meal.&equo; 
 There was a pause. 
 &bquo;You're supposed to respond,&equo; Rodney prompted. 
 Sara placed her knife and fork neatly on her plate and turned to Peter. 
 &bquo;Peter,&equo; she said, &bquo;you and John. 
 This morning you were playing French cricket with my tennis racquet which I have just had restrung.&equo; 
 &bquo;Carla,&equo; she looked at Carla. 
 &bquo;You used my cards yesterday and now the three of hearts is missing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nick,&equo; she faced him. 
 &bquo;You were playing with my frisbee. 
 And your dog has chewed one of my flippers.&equo; 
 &bquo;Veronica,&equo; she went on. 
 &bquo;You were lying on my lilo this morning. 
 While Rodney was oiling your back.&equo; 
 There was another pause. 
 &bquo;We thought you wouldn't mind,&equo; said Rodney. 
 John said quickly, &bquo;What would people like to play after dinner? 
 There's this game I wanted to teach everyone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let Sara choose.&equo; 
 Rodney picked up a not-quite empty bottle of Muscadet. 
 &bquo;There's a drop left in here.&equo; 
 He leaned towards her. 
 She placed the flat of her hand over her glass as he tried to pour. 
 &bquo;Of course I don't mind.&equo; 
 She smiled, turning her head first to one side, then to the other so that they could all see the smile. 
 &bquo;You are very welcome to use my things. 
 Don't feel you have to ask. 
 Just go ahead. 
 Assume it's okay,&equo; and she rose from the table and went upstairs. 
 She did not go to the room with the twin beds but to the single room with the sloping ceiling. 
 She undressed and climbed stiffly into bed. 
 Only two days left, she thought, as she lay in the dark. 
 Tomorrow she would book another ride; she would fit in a swim before breakfast, possibly before dinner as well; and  the day after that she would walk &mdash; thirty miles would be a reasonable target this time. 
 She fell asleep. 
 It was Saturday and Sara and Rodney had finished packing. 
 The others had left. 
 The cottage was locked up. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; said Rodney as he opened the car door. 
 &bquo;Terrific idea of mine inviting people, wasn't it? 
 Everyone loved the ratatouille. 
 And the stuffed artichoke hearts. 
 Pity I didn't have time to make bouillabaisse. 
 Still, it was the best week yet. 
 In my book anyway.&equo; 
 Sara said, &bquo;The riding was something else. 
 And I couldn't have done without the bike. 
 Only trouble was I had so much to do; I never even had a chance to snorkel. 
 Or to start the Zo&euml; Oldenburg. 
 I didn't have a moment to spare.&equo; 
 &bquo;Me neither. 
 Roll on next year.&equo;  
 THE PERFECT MAN 
 Maggie spent the early part of the evening putting together her persona &mdash; scarlet lipstick and nail varnish, pale face, sheer black tights, a brief black dress with a bustier top, a black cloche hat, flat lace-up boots, long green earrings and finally a huge, spiky, green cat brooch pinned to her belt. 
 The result was all she intended &mdash; glamorous, enticing, unusual. 
 She would do her hosts credit. 
 Yet when she arrived, when she knocked at the door and waited outside, bits of the outfit threatened to dissociate, to turn ugly and risible. 
 The cat brooch stuck out; the bustier was precarious; worse, she could see the tips of her toes so her shoulders must have rounded, her head drooped. 
 &bquo;Maggie!&equo; 
 Roger exclaimed when he opened the door. 
 &bquo;You look great. 
 That cat is magic. 
 How do you find these things?&equo; 
 Everything she was wearing shot into line. 
 &bquo;Come and have a drink,&equo; he added. 
 He led her through the crowded flat to the kitchen and poured her a glass of wine. 
 &bquo;You have to meet Tony,&equo; he said. 
 He propelled her into the living room towards a fair man. 
 &bquo;Tony, I don't think you know Maggie,&equo; he said to the man. 
 &bquo;She lives next door.&equo; 
 Maggie looked at Tony. 
 &bquo;Means I don't have to drive  home at any rate,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Did you come by car?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Brought a couple of other people.&equo; 
 Conversation was easy after that; she questioned Tony on the make, model and year of his car. 
 She progressed to a range of general likes and dislikes, favourite foods, politics and leisure pursuits. 
 But it was not so easy to brush him off afterwards. 
 She managed to escape to the kitchen on the pretext of having seen an old friend heading in that direction. 
 &bquo;Any joy?&equo; 
 Caroline, Roger's partner, came into the kitchen to refill a couple of glasses. 
 &bquo;Afraid not, sorry. 
 His ears are huge. 
 He smokes a pipe. 
 He drives a Mini Metro.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have to try again later,&equo; said Caroline, leaving to answer the front door. 
 &bquo;Shouldn't a familiar sit on the shoulder rather than the waist?&equo; suggested a new voice behind Maggie. 
 She turned and was relieved to see someone who bore absolutely no resemblance to the man she had described to Roger and Caroline. 
 She had specified fair hair, slim build, regular features, smooth skin. 
 Nothing like the man who had spoken about her cat brooch. 
 She had no idea who he was. 
 She didn't ask his name she preferred to guess. 
 Not Jeremy or Simon &mdash; too Channel Four. 
 Not Chris &mdash; too lightweight. 
 Fred was too mundane. 
 Something a bit primitive perhaps &mdash; mythical or Biblical. 
 Jason? 
 Matthew? 
 No, Luke was the one. 
 &bquo;I'm wondering what to eat first,&equo; Maggie said. 
 &bquo;Is it safe?&equo; 
 His blue eyes widened with the question. 
 &bquo;Safe? 
 What on earth do you mean? 
 Caroline and Roger make absolutely everything themselves. 
 Even the bread.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can I be sure you won't slip a charm or something worse into the humous. 
 I think I'll just watch.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh Lord, there's Godfrey,&equo; she said.  
 Godfrey always complained about her though they split up a year ago. 
 He was doing it again. 
 &bquo;I mean,&equo; he was saying to Caroline, 'she'd bring something to the table and I'd have to ask what it was. 
 I'd never seen anything like it before. 
 She'd claim it was quite ordinary &mdash; fish cake s, only they went wrong &mdash; that sort of thing. 
 She even made pound cake &mdash; you know, a pound of butter, a pound of flour, a pound of eggs &mdash; without weighing anything.&equo; 
 Maggie approached Godfrey and said over his shoulder, &bquo;I made it by the pound cake method. 
 You cream the butter first, add the egg yolks, then the whites whipped separately, then the flour.&equo; 
 Luke had disappeared while she was talking to Godfrey. 
 Roger arrived at her elbow with more wine and a further introduction. 
 This man looked promising. 
 Crisp hair curling on his collar, Levi 501s and a taupe cotton shirt. 
 By the look of him he might well have left a genuine World War Two leather bomber jacket in the bedroom. 
 But did he like hats? she decided to ask. 
 &bquo;Forties cloches like yours, yes. 
 I can't abide those Afghan caps everyone is wearing now.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about shoes?&equo; 
 &bquo;I like your little pointed boots.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hardly little at six and a half, or whatever that is in metric. 
 I still can't convert in my head.&equo; 
 &bquo;Second nature to me. 
 I spend a great deal of my time in the Community; Brussels and Luxembourg for the most part. 
 To my mind the yard, foot and inch are as antiquated as the rod, pole and perch.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, there's Laura in the other room&equo; Maggie waved cheerily to a woman she did not know. 
 &bquo;I must say hello. 
 Catch you later.&equo; 
 She threaded her way purposefully between people. 
 Caroline turned from a conversation as Maggie passed and said in a conspiratorial whisper. 
 &bquo;What's the verdict on Jeremy?&equo;  
 &bquo;He has no respect for the foot. 
 And he talks like a translation.&equo; 
 Roger, who was always in charge of the music, bad decided the party was ready for nostalgia &mdash; the 60s by the sound of it &mdash; someone, Maggie couldn't remember who, was singing a song called &bquo;Hats off to Larry&equo;. 
 Luke reappeared. 
 &bquo;Do you like hats?&equo; 
 Maggie asked him. 
 &bquo;Is yours an attempt at disguise?&equo; 
 His face creased into a smile. 
 &bquo;Shall we try to reach the food again?&equo; 
 &bquo;As long as I don't have to go past Godfrey.&equo; 
 They headed back to the kitchen. 
 Roger approached her with another tall, fair man. 
 I'll come back later,&equo; Maggie smiled at him. 
 Luke and Maggie found plenty of food. 
 Salads, quiches, baked potatoes, cheese and bread covered the table; bowls of taramosalata, smoked mackerel p&acirc;t&eacute; and humous stood on the worktops; a casserole simmered on the stove. 
 Maggie crossed the room, lifted the lid of the pot and sniffed at the contents. 
 &bquo;What do you think this is?&equo; she asked Luke. 
 But the voice that replied was Godfrey's. 
 Was he following her? 
 &bquo;Caroline told me it was cassoulet,&equo; he announced. 
 &bquo;If you'd made it you'd presumably insist it was Irish stew. 
 Or Lancashire hot pot.&equo; 
 He shrugged and made for the door. 
 &bquo;Oh dear,&equo; Maggie turned to Luke. 
 &bquo;He makes me feel as though I ought to go and write &bquo;I must always measure my ingredients&equo; five hundred times.&equo; 
 Luke didn't say anything. 
 But Roger, coming into the kitchen as Godfrey left, said, &bquo;Might get it out of your system.&equo; 
 He picked up a corkscrew and began to open a bottle of wine. 
 &bquo;You know, you were quite different when you were with Godfrey.&equo; 
 Caroline arrived. 
 &bquo;Could you open another one, Roger?&equo; she asked, &bquo;I'm doing the rounds.&equo; 
 Maggie said to Roger. 
 &bquo;Godfrey didn't like it if I talked  too much. 
 And he said the things I said were silly. 
 Though when we were on our own he found some of them quite funny.&equo; 
 &bquo;We all know Godfrey wasn't right for you.&equo; 
 That was Caroline's opinion. 
 &bquo;You deserve someone much better. 
 Stop lurking in the kitchen and come and meet people.&equo; 
 Maggie was about to protest that talking to Roger and Luke did not qualify as lurking, but Roger made off with a bottle in each hand and Luke had vanished again. 
 Caroline led Maggie back into the living room where she introduced Colin. 
 &bquo;I find it hard to know what to say to people,&equo; Colin said straightaway. 
 Maggie knew that if she felt like that she'd never say so. 
 Men did though, even men who professed to be shy. 
 Colin suggested they go into the next room to dance; she agreed. 
 &bquo;I'm not crackers,&equo; she thought she heard him say next, through high-volume Madonna. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've got crackers. 
 In the bedroom. 
 I wasn't sure about them once I arrived. 
 Is it the right sort of party?&equo; 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 Among the coats in the bedroom was a leather bomber jacket which did look as though it could be genuine World War Two. 
 Colin dug out a huge carrier bag. 
 Not only crackers in it, but party hats and balloons. 
 Maggie blew up two balloons and handed them to Colin. 
 &bquo;Give these to the first person you come across, introduce yourself and see what happens,&equo; she advised him, then set off on her own to the kitchen. 
 She inspected the food again; the baked potatoes were all gone; so was the cassoulet. 
 &bquo;I've brought your hat.&equo; 
 It was Luke. 
 He was carrying a witch's hat. 
 It must have come from Colin's collection. 
 &bquo;Did you come by car?&equo; she asked Luke. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;Car. 
 What car do you drive?&equo;  
 &bquo;I don't have a car.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't have a car.&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 Why do you keep rushing from room to room?&equo; 
 He was smiling again, so there could be no harm in telling him. 
 &bquo;As long as you don't tell Roger or Caroline,&equo; she warned. 
 &bquo;Not much choice, have I? 
 If I tried I suspect I'd find I couldn't articulate the words. 
 Or I might contract warts. 
 Bubonic plague if you were really put out.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm escaping from them. 
 They keep producing men.&equo; 
 She looked at Luke. 
 He was leaning against the sink and listening to what she said. 
 It wasn't the way party dialogues were supposed to go. 
 &bquo;I'm to blame,&equo; she went on. 
 &bquo;After I split up with Godfrey they went on and on about how I should find someone else. 
 In the end, to put them off, I told them I was quite clear about the type who attracted me and that there was no point in introducing me to anyone who didn't match up. 
 Then I made the description so precise I would always find some reason to reject each and every candidate. 
 I mean, really precise. 
 Not just appearance, but habits, hobbies, lifestyle &mdash; the lot. 
 Even the kind of car he drove. 
 Now they complain I'm too fussy. 
 But at least they believe I'm looking. 
 And I am, honestly.&equo; 
 &bquo;To keep Roger and Caroline happy? 
 There must be easier ways.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not without upsetting them.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're the one with the power.&equo; 
 Maggie was about to tell him not to talk nonsense when Caroline arrived, clasping a man's elbow in her right hand. 
 &bquo;Simon has been asking to meet you all evening,&equo; she told Maggie. 
 Maggie looked at the man. 
 And oh dear! 
 On the surface this one fitted the bill exactly. 
 The features, colouring and build were correct. 
 The hair was exceptional, lightly-gelled with one designer curl sculpted on the brow. 
 And  the style was impeccable &mdash; Next trousers, a white shirt under a Fair Isle sweater. 
 She turned in search of Luke but he must have taken off at Caroline's approach. 
 &bquo;Maggie's our next-door neighbour,&equo; Caroline told Simon and left the two of them together. 
 &bquo;I love your boots,&equo; Simon said. 
 Maggie's brooch, her dress, her cloche, came in for similar praise. 
 She began to ask Simon her usual questions and found that he drove a Merc, preferred cacti to ferns and voted Labour but only because there was no alternative. 
 Purcell, Vivaldi and Telemann were among his favourite classical composers. 
 William Morris prints, pre-Raphaelite paintings and Romantic poets left him cold, although Keats, especially in &bquo;The Eve of St Agnes&equo;, had some good moments. 
 Of contemporary writers Anthony Burgess was dazzling, Iris Murdoch dispassionate, Peter De Vries came close but John Updike hit the exact note. 
 Maggie felt symptoms of panic: prickling facial heat, intermittent interference with her hearing. 
 Why on earth had she been so precise in depicting her supposed ideal man to Caroline and Roger? 
 She heard that his flat, to which she foresaw she would soon be invited, was a mixture of Victorian (the furniture) and deco (the mirrors, the glass). 
 He hated all soaps, especially Neighbours . 
 He did a great deal of walking. 
 He played tennis. 
 He didn't jog. 
 He rarely ate red meat. 
 This was terrible; he was exactly as she had envisaged. 
 What could she do? 
 Caroline returned, &bquo;Everything all right?&equo; and offered them both more wine. 
 Maggie looked desperately around the room. 
 She was small and cold. 
 She ought to have worn high heels. 
 And a jacket. 
 Could she feel sick. 
 Or hungry, which she was. 
 Could she make an excuse and run? 
 She felt a tap on her shoulder. 
 &bquo;I assume this is yours.&equo; 
 Luke handed her a broom. 
 &bquo;I found it in the kitchen cupboard. 
 You'll need it if you're going to take off.&equo;  
 Simon said &bquo;I haven't eaten yet. 
 Have you?&equo; 
 Maggie leant the broom against the wall. 
 She didn't like to leave it there; someone might fall over it. 
 But she had no choice. 
 She would look odd carrying it around. 
 &bquo;No, I haven't Simon,&equo; she replied. 
 &bquo;But I'm just going to the loo. 
 I won't be a moment.&equo; 
 Once there, in a temporary safe place, she sat down, took a pen from her bag and wrote in a page of her diary &bquo;Means of Escape&equo;. 
 Writing things down always clarified her thoughts. 
 She wrote a list. 
 1. 
 I have flu symptoms. 
 2. 
 I feel sick. 
 3. 
 I've left the iron/oven/electric fire on. 
 4. 
 I have to get up at 5.30 tomorrow to fly to Manchester to interview a woman who collects bassoons. 5. 
 I do volunteer work for a victim support scheme. 
 My telephone duty starts in ten minutes. 
 Someone tried the door. 
 &bquo;Out in a minute,&equo; she said in a bright, encouraging tone. 
 6. 
 I work nights &mdash; in a news bureau, as a croupier in a nightclub, as a waitress. 
 The door shook. 
 Maggie stood up, shot the bolt and let herself out. 
 &bquo;Sorry,&equo; she muttered. 
 A pity Simon hadn't stayed in the kitchen. 
 He was lying in wait in the hallway, where he was impossible to overlook, forking salad into his well-shaped mouth. 
 A frond of endive approached his lips, hovered, was gripped firmly by admirably white teeth. 
 He bit through the frond; half of it fell onto the floor. 
 Too late she regretted that her blueprint contained no clause on messy eating.  
 He said, &bquo;Oh there you are. 
 Good.&equo; 
 Roger appeared, paused, said quietly to Maggie, &bquo;So glad to see you two have got together,&equo; and then took off again. 
 &bquo;I brought you the best of what was left,&equo; Simon went on. 
 He turned, took a plate of food from the hall table and offered it, making sure his hand just grazed hers in the passing. 
 She saw splinters of bright, sharp, angry light. 
 She looked from the plate up at Simon and a spark struck his eyes. 
 Another landed on his cheek where it sizzled and went out. 
 She looked back down at her hand holding the plate. 
 Her nails had grown longer, dangerous. 
 She heard a hissing sound. 
 She looked up again and saw Simon's eyes were shrinking, his gaze shifting, avoiding hers. 
 His cheeks grew puffy. 
 &bquo;If you're free next week, we could perhaps see the new Cher film,&equo; he suggested, as if unaware. 
 Of course she was free. 
 He was no ideal man now. 
 &bquo;About time,&equo; the voice was Luke's. 
 &bquo;What about the others?&equo; 
 Maggie said, &bquo;See you later, Simon. 
 See you later, Luke,&equo; and set off. 
 No problem to find the World War Two hero &mdash; owner of the bomber jacket &mdash; and to change the colour of his trousers to turquoise at a glance. 
 She found large-eared Tony and made his ears larger. 
 She roamed the room. 
 Tall, fair men gazed into her eyes and were transformed. 
 She adjusted a nose here, a thigh there, she shifted the alignment of a particularly alluring set of eyebrows, unzipped flies to inspect their contents, was disappointed and failed to put them back properly, so they peeked, pinkly, from between metal teeth. 
 Time to make enquiries. 
 She found Roger. 
 &bquo;Have you seen Luke anywhere?&equo; 
 &bquo;Luke who?&equo;  
 &bquo;Guy with black hair and blue eyes. 
 Don't know his last name. 
 He brought me a broomstick. 
 It's leaning against the wall.&equo; 
 &bquo;How much have you had to drink, Maggie?&equo; 
 &bquo;You must know him,&equo; she persisted. 
 &bquo;Lots of lines on his face. 
 Wearing a black sweater and rather old black jeans.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hand on heart, no.&equo; 
 &bquo;You saw him with me earlier. 
 We were in the kitchen together when Caroline said I should meet Colin.&equo; 
 Roger looked at her oddly. 
 &bquo;You weren't with anyone in the kitchen. 
 That's why Caroline wanted you to go and meet people. 
 Look, why don't you have a chat with Philip? 
 He's just your type. 
 And he's another one who's been admiring you from afar.&equo; 
 Roger started to propel her in the direction of yet another tall, fair man. 
 &bquo;Thanks, Roger, but I have to look for someone.&equo; 
 The broom was no longer against the wall, though that was not conclusive. 
 Someone could have put it away or be using it to sweep up a broken wine glass. 
 But when she went into the kitchen there was no sign of the witch's hat. 
 She went over the sequence of events in her mind. 
 Luke had come into the kitchen with the hat. 
 He had offered it to her. 
 She had not taken it. 
 He had put it on the draining board. 
 So where was it now? 
 Caroline entered the room, followed by Godfrey. 
 &bquo;Caroline, thank goodness you've turned up,&equo; said Maggie. 
 &bquo;Roger says he didn't see me with anyone in the kitchen earlier. 
 Before you introduced me to Colin. 
 I was with someone, wasn't I? 
 Dark man with blue eyes. 
 Holding a witch's hat.&equo; 
 &bquo;A man in a witch's hat! 
 She's gone over the top. 
 I knew it would happen. 
 Drunk as a newt,&equo; said Godfrey. 
 &bquo;You were on your own, Maggie,&equo; said Caroline. 
 &bquo;Looking at the food.&equo;  
 &bquo;No you weren't&equo; said Luke. 
 She looked round, but Caroline was right. 
 There was no one there. 
 She ought to have guessed. 
 &bquo;Of course I was. 
 Yes. 
 Sorry,&equo; she said quickly. 
 &bquo;It was only a joke.&equo; 
 Godfrey didn't laugh and Caroline said. 
 &bquo;I don't see how it was meant to be funny. 
 What happened to Simon?&equo; 
 &bquo;We didn't get on.&equo; 
 &bquo;What a pity. 
 How about Chris? 
 Over there.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Maggie. 
 She poured more wine and took a sip. 
 &bquo;The person I want to meet is&hellip; 
 &equo; She looked about the kitchen, walked to the doorway, looked around the living room and turned back to Caroline. 
 &bquo;That man by the window. 
 The one with the slouch hat. 
 Looks like Lou Grant.&equo; 
 &bquo;But he's fat!&equo; said Caroline. 
 &bquo;And short. 
 He wears the hat because he's bald!&equo; 
 &bquo;That's nothing to do with anything. 
 He looks interesting.&equo; 
 Maggie paused. 
 &bquo;On second thoughts,&equo; she said, &bquo;I'll introduce myself,&equo; and set off across the room. 
 Before she left the party, she must look for the witch's hat.  
 PESTS 
 How that princess ever managed to kiss a frog is beyond me. 
 For a start, frogs and toads, they both jump. 
 If you were to approach one, ever so cautious, lips pursed for the coming osculation, it would leap, trailing warty legs. 
 It might jump away from you or &mdash; horror &mdash; towards you. 
 In principle, in any case, the story of the princess and the frog is unacceptable. 
 Not that I have anything against ugliness. 
 Some of the most attractive men are ugly. 
 No; it is the idea that if you force yourself to offer sexual favours to an abhorrent creature you will be rewarded by its transformation into a beautiful prince. 
 I have always found frogs and toads abhorrent. 
 I made no secret of this when me and my ex were on good terms. 
 I insisted that toads, in particular, were malicious. 
 I knew it by the way their eyes glowed green and yellow in the dark and because they always hopped in my direction in spite of how much I hated them. 
 Proof of their evil intentions came the day the dog caught one. 
 The dog played with it, as dogs will, nose to the ground between his paws, retreating to full height with a sharp bark, rolling the toad over to expose its horrible pale underside. 
 For other prey, a rat for instance, death would be next. 
 But the dog, toad between teeth,  jaws primed to gnash, began to foam, in spurts, like a washing machine, and dropped the beast on its uneven back leaving me to confront the hideous creature putting itself to rights. 
 The dog is long since gone, though not, so far as I know, as a result of its encounter with the toad. 
 My ex is now my ex. 
 I live alone with my garden, a patch of London land which I have reclaimed from waist-high thistles, elderberries, brambles and rose thorns to a restrained wilderness of my own design. 
 My garden is all the more attractive because the gardens on either side are so rampant and untended: places where moss covers the paths, the grass is yellow and long and the stalks of sycamore seedlings have red, fungoid lumps. 
 By attractive, I me an my garden attracts everything. 
 The first year after I moved in I found snails, morning after morning, an infantry of them, silvering across the damp lawn. 
 A host of them slid onto my lupins, waving their horns and munching. 
 The lupins died. 
 I dissolved the snails with slug pellets. 
 Soon, empty shells lay everywhere. 
 During the second summer, the ants came. 
 They nested under my lawn and the nest made a bulge in the smooth green turf. 
 I studied my gardening books. 
 Following the instructions, I filled my saucepans and kettle with water and set them all to boil. 
 I went into the garden where I made an H-shaped cut through to the nest with a spade. 
 It took courage to do this as I was fearful the ants might swarm over the spade and run all the way up the handle to my hands. 
 After I made the cut I folded back the turf (still using the spade) and saw the nest. 
 Thousands and thousands of ants seethed in it. 
 I quickly poured the kettle full of water over them, then the contents of all four saucepans. 
 It wasn't enough. 
 I ran to and fro from the kitchen for some time with saucepans and kettles of boiling water. 
 Even when all sign of life had gone I kept on feeling itchy. 
 I replaced the portion of turf, reseeded  its damaged edges with ryegrass mix and within weeks the site of the ants' nest was again as smooth and green as the rest of the lawn. 
 I can't remember all the other pests in my garden, there have been so many. 
 At one time there were silver-winged ants. 
 Then wasps; a cloud of them hovered around my Virginia creeper where I suspected they had a nest. 
 I called the local council who told me the wasps were best left until the end of the season when they would follow their queen and find somewhere else to live. 
 The third summer I came across greenflies which I easily killed with  malathion . 
 The black fly were more tenacious, clinging beneath the elderberry leaves and disfiguring the stalks of the nicotania; but I killed them too eventually &mdash; regular doses of poison dust did the trick. 
 The garden became orderly. 
 A smooth green carpet lay at its centre. 
 In the shady spots flourished hostas, and in the full sun, nasturtiums, clarkias, stocks and geraniums bloomed. 
 Tomatoes leaned on stakes, runner beans twined round a wigwam of canes and rambling roses rambled over their appointed places. 
 Last year the pests were replaced by harmless, pretty creatures who loved my city oasis of colour and scent. 
 Bees &mdash; the bumble and the honey &mdash; and butterflies &mdash; red admirals and small, delicate blue ones whose name I did not know &mdash; tilted at each other in the warm summer air. 
 Fat grey pigeons and speckled thrushes bent the branches of the elderberries in the autumn, pecked at the fruit and flapped into the sky when frightened by my cat. 
 My cat is a large tabby tom. 
 He works for me, although the work is self-imposed. 
 He works as an odd-job man or possibly, given the nature of the work, as a husband. 
 He brings things home. 
 Sometimes something relatively innocent such as a chewed sausage or a chicken bone, or a scrap of toast with a little fish paste sticking to it. 
  Sometimes something more offensive. 
 An almost-dead thrush in the living room, feathers scattered, entrails on show, wings still twitching: and a severed claw in the hall. 
 A stiff rat in the passage, over which he meows his triumph. 
 When I go on holiday he slaughters a whole nestful of starlings to celebrate my return, spreads embryos and eggs all over the carpet, across the sofa and under the bed. 
 Then he vomits among his trophies. 
 Of course I hate cleaning all this up, but he means well. 
 And many of the objects my ex used to bring home were equally unwelcome and led to as much mess. 
 Other women, for instance. 
 This summer I went to Spain: on my own as usual. 
 The holiday was a hot interlude beneath a blue sky beside a blue pool. 
 I chose a spot well away from the wasp-infested rubbish bins and kept my eyes on my book when the shadow of a man cast over it. 
 I had cool water to splash in, a cool shower in the evening and enough crisp, cotton clothes to change in and out of without once washing a thing. 
 When I returned to my flat the cat meowed a welcome and rubbed himself against my legs. 
 In the living room I found the usual debris. 
 I took off my jacket and set about clearing up dead birds. 
 I carried the mess, in the dustpan, into the garden. 
 While I was away it must have rained. 
 Everything was lush; the lawn needed mowing; the geraniums needed dead-heading; the runner beans needed picking. 
 Also 1 spotted traces of snails. 
 I approached the compost heap and saw a small cloud of whiteflies rise from it. 
 Tomorrow I would find chemical solutions to these new problems. 
 I tipped the remains of the birds into the compost. 
 Something moved against my sandalled foot. 
 I looked down. 
 I thought it was a brown leaf, but it moved again, and I saw the object of my greatest dread, a toad. 
 I dropped the dustpan and ran indoors.  
 The next day, although I sprayed the pests, as I knew I must, I stood at arm's length from the compost heap and wore jeans and high-rise trainers. 
 Afterwards I skirted that comer of the garden and let the weeds grow. 
 It was my offering. 
 I hoped to placate the toad. 
 My ex and I still met every six months or so, I don't know why. 
 These occasions, so far as I could tell, brought neither of us any pleasure. 
 But we both tried hard. 
 Before the summer faded it was time, once more, for us to get together. 
 It was his turn to visit me. 
 I took him into my garden. 
 We always showed each other what we achieved. 
 He looked at the springy, sharp-edged lawn, the borders of stocks and pansies backed by honeysuckle and late roses, the baskets of purple trailing lobelias, red geraniums and white alyssum hanging on the walls. 
 We walked past the beans and the tomatoes. 
 I turned to go back. 
 &bquo;What's that bit?&equo; he asked, pointing to the small area I had left to the toad. 
 I explained. 
 &bquo;You know I've always hated toads.&equo; 
 &bquo;There can't have been a toad. 
 You imagined it,&equo; he said. 
 That night I dreamed of the toad I had imagined. 
 He invaded the bedroom and hopped, scabrous, all over me while I lay there, unable to move. 
 He became vast and covered me, covered my face, his hideous throat working. 
 I woke to find myself screaming and the cat standing on my chest. 
 On other nights I dreamed of other pests. 
 Of spiders which squatted on the floor, then criss-crossed my face, hairily, of mice which scampered in the wardrobe and of lizards, steely blue and green. 
 In the daytimes I made the flat secure against all creatures. 
 I replaced each plug &mdash; in the wash basin, the bath, the sink. 
 I poured bleach down the loo. 
 I nailed airtight  strips around doors and windows. 
 I glued up the cat flap. 
 1 sprayed the letter box with insect repellent. 
 I abandoned the garden, which harboured the non-existent toad. 
 In the bathroom I saw silverfish. 
 In the kitchen I scoured the cupboards, and poured disinfectant over small black creatures like woodlice. 
 The creatures died on their backs in viscous green pools. 
 I went shopping and filled an entire cupboard with the sprays and powders and liquids of chemical death. 
 I couldn't find anything in any of the shops to kill toads but reasoned that there was no way now for a toad to enter the flat. 
 Besides, there was no toad. 
 I still could not relax. 
 I called in the experts. 
 &bquo;And what is it this time?&equo; said the man from the council. 
 It was his third visit. 
 The first was because I was sure the wasps had returned. 
 The second was when I had mistaken a stag beetle for a cockroach. 
 &bquo;Rats,&equo; I told him, but he opened the cover on the drain outside my back door and showed me the trap to stop rats climbing up. 
 Did that mean they were lurking, massed behind the trap, below the surface, in angry, diseased hordes? 
 I didn't dare ask. 
 Every week, for one reason or another, there was a man about the place, looking for some creature I'd seen, or thought I'd seen. 
 They were all men. 
 It was dick-work, routing out pests, for which I paid a fair price. 
 After these visits, I slept the whole night. 
 Slept the whole night several nights. 
 Became confident and prised the cat flap open again. 
 That night the dream returned. 
 Things crept across the room, then hovered above me, pale and threatening to suffocate me. 
 Small creatures poured into the room, from under the door, screaming. 
 I woke. 
 I realised slowly that the screams were coming from the kitchen. 
 I switched on the light in the bedroom. 
 I switched on the light in the hall. 
 I stepped forward and switched on  the light in the kitchen. 
 I saw the cat; the cat was crouched over some creature. 
 I switched off the light and closed the kitchen door quickly, thankful for the seal I had fixed under it. 
 And although I could still hear the screams and although they were real and terrible I slept well and late. 
 In the morning I opened the kitchen door an inch or two and peered inside. 
 The cat rushed past me into the hallway. 
 Then I spotted something small, black and misshapen at the other end of the kitchen. 
 I looked at it. 
 It lay still. 
 It was dead. 
 I took a step forward. 
 It heaved. 
 I slammed the kitchen door, kicked the cat with my bare foot, rushed into the bedroom and flung open the window to let him run out. 
 I peered into the kitchen again. 
 The creature did not heave. 
 But it was in a different place! 
 I slammed the door again. 
 I called &bquo;Quick Kill&equo; because this was no job for the council; it was an emergency. 
 The woman I spoke to on the phone realised this immediately and within the hour a man in a boiler suit arrived. 
 &bquo;In there,&equo; I said, pointing to the closed kitchen door. 
 He opened it; I stood in the doorway while he approached the creature. 
 &bquo;It's a frog,&equo; he said, bending over it. 
 But I knew it was the toad. 
 &bquo;It's dead.&equo; 
 He picked it up by one long back leg. 
 He carried the dead toad into the overgrown garden. 
 I directed him to the corner where I knew the compost heap was. 
 I could not see the heap; it was hidden by brambles nowadays. 
 He deposited the toad and we returned indoors. 
 &bquo;Thank you for coming so quickly,&equo; I said to the man as I wrote a cheque. 
 &bquo;Any time,&equo; he responded. 
 &bquo;Next time you have a problem, just ring the office and ask for George. 
 I work weekends too.&equo;  
 The cat did not return until late afternoon. 
 He curled his tail round my legs, rubbing his body against me. 
 I loved him too, with reservations. 
 While he was out I had rewritten my will so that I left nothing to my ex. 
 I had decided to leave everything in trust to the cat. 
 Tomorrow I would take my new will to my solicitor. 
 Not that I planned on dying. 
 I would kill them all first.  
 Alcohol in the Workplace 
 A guide for employers 
 EMPLOYMENT DEPARTMENT 
 Alcohol in the Workplace 
 Why you need a policy to deal with it 
 Introduction 
 No one knows for certain how much the misuse of alcohol costs society, but it's a great deal. 
 One estimate puts the cost in terms of sickness absence alone at over &pound;700 million a year. 
 The effects of alcohol misuse spill over from private life into the workplace, causing inefficiency and accidents as well as absenteeism. 
 This booklet gives you guidance on how to deal with the problem in the workplace. 
 If you tackle it along the lines suggested in this booklet, you will have taken a step towards reducing the appalling costs the problem imposes on all of us. 
 You may not think that you have a problem, but in a company of even modest size it is statistically likely that some employees will have a drink problem. 
 Whether or not you do have a problem, you need a policy. 
 If you are not ready to deal with the problem of alcohol misuse if and when it occurs, one day you could be faced with a crisis. 
 The results could be disastrous for your business and the people it employs. 
 This booklet isn't a blueprint for a policy, but a guide. 
 You know your company's needs and situation. 
 But whatever the size of your company and whatever business you are in, I believe it will be to your benefit to read this booklet and act upon its recommendations. 
  Patrick Nicholls, MP Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Employment   
 How bad is the problem? 
 Getting reliable figures to show how much alcohol misuse costs us, or how many people are affected, isn't easy. 
 What is clear is that the financial cost of alcohol misuse to society as a whole runs into hundreds of millions of pounds each year. 
 There's a good chance that someone affected by alcoholism works for you. 
 The problem isn't just with the person who has become dependent on alcohol. 
 Any level of drinking that adversely affects someone's work performance is likely to damage your business. 
 Lunchtime drinking that leads to reduced or poor quality work in the afternoons is one example. 
 If alcohol misuse affects your business, it could mean that you aren't as competitive as you might be.  
 How does it affect you? 
 Let's assume one of your employees drinks too much both at work and at home. 
 Have you stopped to consider how much he or she costs you? 
 What about: 
 &bull; 
 days off sick, probably because of a hangover? 
 &bull; 
 lateness and long hours spent in the pub at lunchtime? 
 &bull; 
 business opportunities lost because of impaired judgement? 
 &bull; 
 strained relationships with other staff who resent having to provide cover? 
 &bull; 
 damage, lost production and suffering resulting from avoidable accidents? 
 How much does all this cost you in lost production, lost business opportunities, inefficiency? 
 Unless you do something about it you will be losing money &mdash; money you could have invested in new equipment, or better marketing, or taking on more employees. 
 Money you could have used to make your future, and that of all your employees, more secure and more prosperous. 
 The causes 
 There are many factors that can contribute to alcohol misuse. 
 Both the workplace environment and domestic circumstances can cause a build-up of stress which can drive people to rely on drink. 
 Some of the commonest factors at work are: 
 &bull; 
 too much or too little work 
 &bull; 
 irregular or long hours 
 &bull; 
 pressure from colleagues 
 &bull; 
 working alone or without supervision 
 &bull; 
 monotony 
 &bull; 
 under- or over-promotion 
 &bull; 
 occupations involving access to alcohol. 
 And in someone's home or social life the most common factors are: 
 &bull; 
 marital or family problems 
 &bull; 
 family illness or bereavement 
 &bull; 
 financial difficulties 
 &bull; 
 social habit. 
 The alcohol policy 
 You need to have a policy on the use of alcohol. 
 It should cover: 
 &bull; 
 prevention 
 &bull; 
 recognition 
 &bull; 
 help for individuals 
 &bull; 
 implementation 
 &bull; 
 monitoring. 
 There are some circumstances where for health and safety reasons alcohol cannot be allowed at all. 
 In some occupations &mdash; bus and train drivers and airline pilots, for example &mdash; employees are not allowed any alcoholic drink during the working day. 
 Your policy should draw a clear distinction between this sort of rule and a supportive policy to help someone with a drink problem. 
 Prevention 
 Even if you decide you don't have a problem now, it makes sense to do all you can to prevent it happening in the future. 
 Prevention is always more sensible and less costly than cure. 
 Look at the workplace environment: 
 &bull; 
 workloads, flexibility 
 &bull; 
 management styles 
 &bull; 
 availability at work of low alcohol and non-alcoholic drinks 
 Consider: 
 &bull; 
 setting an example yourself and making sure your managers do too 
 &bull; 
 posters and health education booklets 
 &bull; 
 courses and seminars. 
 Recognition 
 You should have a system for monitoring people's work performance. 
 Possible signs of alcohol misuse affecting someone's work are: 
 &bull; 
 lateness and absenteeism 
 &bull; 
 poor work and output 
 &bull; 
 unreliability 
 &bull; 
 bad relations with colleagues 
 &bull; 
 impaired concentration, memory and judgement 
 &bull; 
 accidents. 
 These could all be due to a number of different factors but they may be signs that someone is drinking too much. 
 Don't automatically assume that someone displaying one or more of them is misusing alcohol, but if the problem persists, you should certainly investigate whether alcohol is the cause. 
 Help for individuals 
 If you have employees who misuse alcohol, what should you do about it? 
 Turning a blind eye could cost you a great deal of money in lost orders and lost production, and it certainly won't help them or their colleagues who have to work with them. 
 Dismissal may look like the easiest, quickest solution. 
 but how much is it going to cost you to recruit and train a replacement? 
 And again dismissal certainly will not help them overcome their alcohol problem. 
 Of course, if alcohol is banned for safety reasons, dismissal may be the only option, when the circumstances have been fully investigated. 
 In the great majority of cases, however, you should encourage any of your employees who have an alcohol problem to seek help and treatment. 
 You should have a clear policy on confidentiality, on job security, on sickness benefits, on time off for treatment and on pension rights. 
 If time off is needed for counselling or treatment, you should do everything you can to grant it.  
 You should: 
 &bull; 
 encourage employees to seek help voluntarily 
 &bull; 
 provide advice and any other type of help needed 
 &bull; 
 offer an opportunity for help where work has deteriorated 
 &bull; 
 give the same protection and employment rights that you would to other employees who have problems related to other forms of ill-health 
 &bull; 
 treat employees sympathetically if they relapse and give them another chance if they take advice and undergo treatment 
 But what if an employee refuses help, or drops out of a recovery programme? 
 In itself, this shouldn't be grounds for disciplinary action. 
 But unacceptable behaviour (and that includes bad timekeeping and too much sick leave) and poor work standards should be dealt with through your usual disciplinary procedures.  
 Implementation 
 Once you've worked out your policy, you should make it clear it applies to all staff, at all levels, and you should be prepared to use it fairly and consistently. 
 &bull; 
 Designate yourself or a senior manager in your organisation to be responsible for seeing that the policy is applied reasonably and fairly. 
 &bull; 
 Make sure managers and supervisors are familiar with the policy and procedures, and make sure too that they set a good example to the staff they supervise. 
 &bull; 
 Make sure staff know what is expected of them &mdash; a responsible attitude towards drinking, standards of work performance and so on. 
 &bull; 
 Make sure that your employees' representatives are involved all along the line. 
 That way the policy has a much greater chance of success. 
 &bull; 
 Remember that there are many agencies who can provide advice training for key staff, assessment and counselling. 
 You'll find some listed under &bquo;Useful addresses&equo;. 
 Monitoring 
 Once you have decided your policy and put it in place, keep an eye on how well it's working. 
 Have regular reviews. 
 Ask the staff if the policy has had any effect on their attitudes to drinking, or on their awareness of their drinking habits. 
 Is it having the effect you want? 
 If not, how can you change it?  
 Next steps 
 The list of addresses and publications at the end of this booklet includes sources of advice on how to draw up a policy to suit your own particular circumstances.  
 Useful addresses 
 Alcohol Concern 
 Can put you in touch with local services. 
 The Workplace Advisory Service advises on alcohol policies and provides education and training 
 Alcoholics Anonymous 
 Branches throughout the country  
 Health Education Authority 
 Policy advice 
 Education and training materials 
 The Industrial Society 
 Courses/seminars 
 Advice on alcohol policies 
 Institute of Alcohol Studies 
 Information. 
 Also courses/seminars. 
 Advice on alcohol policies.      
 JUDGEMENT AND EFFICIENCY SEND THEIR APOLOGIES 
 YOU DON'T HAVE TO BE SOBER TO WORK HERE BUT IT HELPS 
 The Flight From Mind 
 Howard Robinson 
 There is an account of the mind-body problem which could, with some oversimplification, be described as the currently fashionable one. 
 According to this account, the mind-body distinction as we know it was invented by Descartes. 
 He it was who conceived the idea of identifying mind with consciousness and of claiming that consciousness and its contents are radically different sods of things from bodies and their properties. 
 The mind is a sort of arena in which private objects are viewed: all our experience is, ultimately, confined to this arena. 
 Descartes, so the story goes, reached this conception because, unlike his predecessors, the Aristotelians, he was obsessed by epistemological questions &mdash; that is, questions about what we can know and how we can know it. 
 He thought that the only things of which we could be really certain were things of which we were directly aware, that is, things in our own minds. 
 The empiricists, although they may not have taken up Descartes' idea that the mind is an immaterial substance, followed him in treating the contents of mind as objects private and internal to the individual and different from physical objects. 
 This conception of the mind is now almost universally regarded as disastrously wrong, for two reasons: first, because it creates a dualism of mind and body and second, because it is held to create insuperable sceptical problems. 
 The dualism is deemed disastrous because it prevents us from having a unified conception of the world built around the natural sciences, and because it leaves the relationship between the mental and the physical an insoluble mystery. 
 The scepticism follows because if we are confined in experience to the contents of our own minds alone, it would seem to be impossible that we should ever come to know anything about &mdash; or even come intelligibly to think about &mdash; things outside our own minds. 
 The programme of many modern philosophers, therefore, has been to develop a conception of man and his mind which either disposes of or downgrades the inner, private arena, making the function of mind essentially a part of the public and physical world. 
 Once this is achieved &mdash; and this, it is held, can be done by some sort of physicalist theory of mind with strong behaviourist elements &mdash; then most of the insoluble problems of early modern philosophy disappear. 
 I want to defend a radically different picture, which takes a much  broader historical perspective. 
 This alternative picture involves denying that there is a coherent materialist alternative to the Cartesian &bquo;private theatre&equo; view of the mind; but it also involves placing the attack on the Cartesian picture in a wider context. 
 From the point of view of those who have a high doctrine of the mind, the Cartesian developments of the seventeenth century were ambiguous. 
 The concentration on the subjective nature of experience made clear the logical privacy, and hence non-physicality, of sense experience in a way in which it was never made clear within the classical and scholastic traditions. 
 The earlier traditions had focused not on experience as the key element in mind, but on intellect and thought; it was this that made mind special and different from anything physical. 
 As I shall explain in the next section, this earlier privileging of intellect was intimately connected with resistance to nominalism, and, in the seventeenth century nominalism triumphed. 
 The emphasis on the mentality and immateriality of sense experience was associated with the denial that there was anything special about intellect. 
 Even whilst developing the modern immaterialist notion of consciousness, the eighteenth-century empiricists and others were attacking the dignity of intellect and assimilating it to sensory activity by treating thoughts as mere images. 
 As well as being a defence of mind, therefore, the early modern philosophy, through its nominalism, was also an attack on it. 
 And, in certain important respects, the general form of this attack is preserved in contemporary physicalist theories. 
 Like the physicalist attacks on the privacy of subjective experience, these attacks on intellect are self-defeating, in that they end up denying the very realities they are trying to explain. 
 What I hope to show is that the attacks on the reality and irreducibility of both subjective experience and thought leave one with no contentful conception of the world. 
 The flight from mind in respect either of its intellectual or sensational aspects would be disastrous, but the currently fashionable flight from both leaves us with no world at all. 
 In the Phaedo , Socrates praises Anaxagoras for saying that the world must be explained by reference to mind, and then criticizes him for not acting on the principle that he recommends. 
 Most pre-Socratic philosophy had been a form of primitive natural science, explaining everything in terms of the physical elements. 
 By contrast, the metaphysical question of what the preconditions are for the world's being accessible to thought was uppermost for Plato and Aristotle. 
 This is explained via the role of form  in the world. 
 The important thing about form, in either the Platonic or  Aristotelian senses, is that forms are the sort of things that can be thought, or apprehended intellectually. 
 There is, in common sense, something close to a paradox which generates the problem of universals. 
 This problem dominated philosophy from Plato until the seventeenth century. 
 On the one hand, it is natural to think of the world outside mind as consisting solely of particulars: the only things that could be general would be ideas. 
 But if ideas are to fit the world there must be something which answers to that generality. 
 According to Plato, that generality is found in a pure way in the Forms, and derivatively in particular physical objects because they participate imperfectly in the Forms. 
 For Aristotle, forms are in objects and are themselves particular, though they are by their nature potentially universal, becoming actually so when they are apprehended by the intellect. 
 The disturbing thought that motivates both theories is that, if the world is to be intelligible, it must be mind-like, in the sense that generality &mdash; the feature of thought, concepts and meanings &mdash; must in some way, run through the world itself. 
 A world that was, per impossibile , purely particular, in the sense of not allowing forms or universals to be an essential component or determinant of it, would have nothing which intellect could grasp. 
 The reason for this is straightforward. 
 Human thought is something essentially expressible in language, and language is possible only if there are predicates as well as names. 
 But predicates are essentially general. 
 Consider the sentence &bquo;John is tall&equo;. 
 For this sentence to express something, &bquo;John&equo; must refer to a unique individual, but &bquo;tall&equo; must express a feature that is general, that is, that many different things might possess. 
 If this were not so, and all statements simply joined names that referred to individuals, nothing would be said about  those individuals. 
 But if a statement such as &bquo;John is tall&equo; is to be true, then the predicate &bquo;is tall&equo; must latch on to the world, just as &bquo;John&equo; does. 
 So there has to be something in the world answering to the general predicate, just as there is something answering to the name. 
 This thought casts the world in a profoundly different light from common sense in its materialistic moment; and much of metaphysics can be seen as a response to it. 
 Aristotle was the first to try to naturalize the veins of generality that must structure any intelligible world, by saying that forms in things were individuals, not universals. 
 The controversy surrounding the interpretation of Aristotle's conception of form is unending, but, on all interpretations, his objective is to give forms as great an affinity with particulars as is possible, consistent with their retaining a sort of generality which is, so to speak, released in the intellect when they are thought. 
 Something that was not form, but was only matter, could not become general in this way and could not answer to the generality of  the concepts with which we think. 
 The naturalistic instinct has been to claim that mind somehow creates generality in a sense stronger than that which Aristotle allows; it does not merely release generality from its potential state in matter, but fabricates it. 
 The mind puts together certain things and deems them to be of the same kind. 
 The medium in which the mind fabricates generality is language. 
 This vision lies behind nominalism, which claims that it is the mind's capacity for creating general words  that creates the illusion of generality in the world itself. 
 But the problem of generality has two locations. 
 The first, about which I have mainly been talking so far, is the generality, or potential for generality, of things in the world. 
 The reductive instinct is to explain this by reference to the generalizing capacity of the mind. 
 This leaves generality as a real capacity of the mind. 
 Philosophers have often been content to assign to the mind features that they are unwilling to ascribe to the physical world. 
 Most empiricists, for example, have been prepared to do this with secondary qualities, such as colours, sounds and smells, which, they believe, science could not allow to the external world. 
 In so doing, they claim that it is not just secondary qualities that are confined to the mind, but, with them, the whole vivid force of the world-as-we-perceive-it, - what some philosophers call the manifest image  of the world &mdash; which is intrinsically bound up with the secondary qualities. 
 David Hume went further, transferring causal power from the world of objects to the mind, making of it a tendency of the mind to pass from the thing we call &bquo;the cause&equo; to the one we call &bquo;the effect&equo;. 
 But someone committed to a thorough-going naturalism is no more prepared to allow to the mind mysterious properties than he is prepared to allow them to matter: for the thorough-going naturalist, after all, mind is no more than a manifestation of matter. 
 The nominalist impulse, therefore, which originates from the attempt to make generality in the world a creation of mind &mdash; thus allowing the extra-mental world to consist only of particulars &mdash; eventually leads to trying to explain the powers of the mind entirely in terms of the work of particulars. 
 This move from nominalism about the extra-mental to nominalism about mental acts can be seen in the development from Descartes to Locke and Berkeley, or, perhaps, in the contrast between such continental rationalists as Descartes, Malebranche and Leibnitz on the one hand, and British philosophers from Bacon and Hobbes on the other. 
 Descartes believed firmly that universals were formed in the mind and that ideas possessed &bquo;objective&equo; and &bquo;formal&equo; reality; that is, that it was an irreducible feature of ideas that they were able to be about  a class of objects. 
  Descartes is true to his radical dualism: everything that is a mark of mind is withdrawn into the mind, leaving the external world in atomistic darkness. 
 But mind remains truly special. 
 The materialist Hobbes, by contrast, denies that universality is really found even in the mind: 
 This word universal  is never the name of anything existent in nature, nor of any idea or phantasm found in the mind  &lsqb;my italics&rsqb;, but always the name of some word or name; so that when a living creature, a stone, a spirit , or any other thing, is said to be universal , it is not to be understood that any man, stone etc., ever was or can be universal, but only that the words, living creature, stone, etc., are universal names , that is, names common to many things; and the conceptions answering them in the mind are the images and phantasms of several living creatures or other things.  
 (Concerning Body , Molesworth's English Works of Thomas Hobbes , vol. 1, p. 74; my italics) 
 But, by a tragic irony, it is not a materialist who most influentially encapsulated nominalism about the mind; it was the idealist Bishop Berkeley. 
 Hume described Berkeley's attack on abstract ideas as &bquo;the most important development of late in the republic of letters&equo;. 
 The purport of that attack was to prove that generality could never be an intrinsic property of a mental content. 
 Berkeley's reason for thinking this was that he believed mental contents to be mental images, and there cannot be a general image. 
 It never seemed to occur to him that a general idea might be an entirely different sort of thing from an image. 
 Ideas, according to Berkeley, are particulars whose significance is explained by saying that they stand for  the things they represent. 
 This naturally prompts the question what it is for one purely particular object to stand for  another. 
 Specifiedly general objects, such as forms and universals, by their very nature stand for the many things which are instances of them: a single particular may be in a variety of relations &mdash; most obviously causal, spatial or temporal - to others, but the nature of a &bquo;standing for&equo; relation is obscure. 
 At first sight this might not seem to be a serious problem; one thing stands for others if it is used  or taken as representing  them. 
 But this only restates the problem. 
 Using  or taking as representing  is a mental act, and it presupposes that the mind has the power of seeing generality in things, by seeing the class (or form) in the particular. 
 It is exactly this power that the nominalist is trying to analyse and explain. 
 If one is to avoid this simple circularity, then  one must explain standing for  in terms of some natural relation between particulars. 
 Berkeley's theory gave rise to the development of modern externalist  theories of mental content. 
 By &bquo;externalist&equo; in this context I mean any theory which denies that a mental episode has any meaning-content intrinsically, and affirms that its content consists in some external relation to other things. 
 The first expression of this was associationist psychology. 
 At its simplest, associationism is the theory that a mental content has the meaning it does because of the things that tend to follow, or precede, it into the mind. 
 So the word &bquo;red&equo; means red because thought of the word tends to be succeeded by a mental image of the colour, or vice versa . 
 This can be expressed in Hume's terms of the tendency of the mind to pass  from one to the other, but one must be careful how one interprets such a tendency. 
 It is tempting to think of it as a felt  tendency, so that one is somehow aware of where the mind is going. 
 This will not do, for it is no different from saying that when one experiences &bquo;red&equo; one thinks or conceives of the colour, whereas the point of the theory was to explain what such thinking, or conceiving, is. 
 It is similarly tempting to think of the colour image as hovering in the background, somehow anticipated by the mind; but this is a metaphor, for the image either is or is not in consciousness. 
 And, contrary to Hume's contention, being very dimly  in consciousness is not the same as being thought of. 
 The tendency of the mind to move from one thing to another has to consist in the straightforward fact that one thing usually follows, or is caused by, the other; the tendency or association cannot be thought of as some experienced  feature of the situation without reviving the original situation of having an unanalysed conception of the mind's ability to reach out and apprehend things. 
 So the meaning of a sign consists in the bare fact that it stands in an external causal relation to that which we say it signifies. 
 From the point of view of the experiencing subject, the meaningfulness is not something of which he is conscious; all he experiences is, first the word &bquo;red&equo;, then a mental image: there is nothing that could count as his internally and introspectably associating them which does not reintroduce the mysterious generality of thought. 
 It does not help the associationist to press the concept of resemblance to his aid. 
 It might seem that it would, because it might seem very natural to think that one red thing or image might be taken as standing for red things in general because of its natural resemblance to the other members of the class, this constituting the most fundamental sort of association. 
 But resemblance cannot explain how a thinker could experience one object as standing for another; for how could the fact that a particular  datum is similar to other things mean anything to a thinker unless he experienced it as  being like many others &mdash; that is, unless he grasped it, not just as a particular but as  an instance of a kind? 
 But this is the very ability for which we are trying to account. 
 If we are to abide by a pure nominalism or particularism, we are forced into externalism, and this is vicious. 
 It is vicious because, as I have just argued, the external relation that constitutes the meaning of the mental content is not something that the subject himself can apprehend: it can only be constructed from a third-person perspective. 
 The reality of meaning therefore, would only be accessible to some idealized third person who was able to observe the relation between the particulars. 
 But there never could be such an observer &mdash; at least not if his thought-processes were to be analysed in the same way as ours &mdash; because his thoughts about the relations of the particulars would themselves be just a succession of particulars whose relations, which give them meaning, were not directly accessible to him. 
 Associationism is long dead as a theory of thought, but externalism remains as a feature of most of its naturalistic successors, because, by virtue of their naturalism, they can find no space for intrinsic generality of mental contents. 
 The problem for the associationalist is exactly mirrored in those theories of thought and mind inspired by computers and artificial intelligence. 
 The human mind &mdash; which, from this viewpoint, is the brain &mdash; is said to work on the same plan as a computer, with operations being carried out on physical symbols. 
 The question is, &bquo;what gives these symbols meaning?&equo; 
 The answer is that, as with associationism, their meaning comes from their relations to things external to themselves. 
 Their relations to one another determine the syntax (that is, the grammar) of the language they constitute, and their causal relations to the external world determine their semantics (that is, what they are about or refer to). 
 These causal relations are essential to what they mean: without semantics a language is an uninterpreted formal language. 
 But if we think of the conscious subject as located within, or identical to, the brain, then external relations are beyond his gaze. 
 John Searle has compared the computational view of mind to an Englishman who has no understanding of Chinese processing Chinese symbols according to rules which correspond to the grammar of Chinese: what he deals with may be meaningful Chinese sentences, but he is none the wiser. 
 Only an idealized observer could see both the inner processing and  the causal relations of the symbols to outside objects that give them meaning: no one could actually be that idealized observer, because each observer is confined to operating on the symbols that are within  his computational machinery, and this excludes their external causal relations. 
 There is a tendency of protagonists of the computational theory of mind to boast that they are restoring the Aristotelian emphasis on cognition and thought, and unseating Descartes' modernist emphasis on consciousness. 
 One such protagonist has recently gone so far as to claim that Aristotle's Phantasmata  &mdash; the mental images that are involved in most or all mental activities &mdash; are identical with the symbols on which computational procedures are carried out. 
 This approach sees classical and ultra-modern theories as constituting a sound tradition from which the Cartesian emphasis on consciousness constitutes an unfortunate aberration. 
 I have tried to sketch in outline why I think this to be wrong. 
 Far from being of a piece with classical theories, computational theories share with early modern ones the nominalism that made them oblivious of what was important in the classical tradition: namely the irreducibility of thought and universals. 
 The problem that consciousness sets for the materialist is well known. 
 Imagine a scientist in the distant future who knows everything about the mechanism and neurology of vision, but who is blind from birth. 
 That there is something he does not know is shown by the fact that if he were to gain his sight, he would come to know something that he previously had not known. 
 This might be characterized as &bquo;what it is like to see&equo; or &bquo;what things look like&equo; or, most especially, &bquo;what colours are like&equo; (that is, what they look like &mdash; there is no difference in their case). 
 No amount of unsighted knowledge of neuronal activity or light wave-lengths could amount to this. 
 The same point can be made in a slightly different way. 
 Call our blind super-scientist &bquo;BS&equo; and an ordinary sighted subject &bquo;V&equo;. 
 BS is supposed to have complete scientific knowledge of V and his physical environment when V sees: yet BS does not know what it is like for V to see, what colours look like, etcetera. 
 As BS knows everything relevant about the physical state of affairs, the things that he does not know about are not physical states of affairs. 
 Since these states of affairs are of the essence of human perceptual consciousness and, therefore, of the human mind, it must follow that there are non-physical states of affairs essential to the human mind. 
 So a materialist theory of the mind is false. 
 The most primitive physicalist response to this argument is to  deny the claim that there is anything about the mind that BS does not know. 
 All that BS lacks is an ability to respond directly to stimuli of certain sorts: V knows no more than BS, he can simply do something BS cannot. 
 BS is like a man who knows all about swimming, even to the point of being able to train the Olympic team, but who cannot swim himself, and V is the man with the normal talent for swimming. 
 I think that it would be true to say that, nowadays, most materialists want to avoid theories that are as nakedly behaviouristic as this, and want to accommodate the common-sense intuition that something inner and introspectible is missing in the blind or deaf, for example, in addition to their lost capacity to respond. 
 On the other hand, materialists seem to be prevented by their materialism from allowing that there is any relevant fact that BS does not know. 
 The way that most materialists try to reconcile their flight from behaviourism with their materialist world picture is to say that when V sees something, and BS observes V's brain, BS knows everything about V's mental states that V himself knows, but that he knows about it in a different way . 
 It is this difference of way  which constitutes the difference of &bquo;feel&equo; in their experience. 
 This reply sounds very plausible, until one reflects on it; and then a serious difficulty emerges. 
 For a physicalist, a mode of access is just a physical process, so any mode of access V enjoys should, if physicalism be true, be available to BS. 
 Differentiating modes of access seems relevant only because of the covert assumption that different ways of knowing feel  different &mdash; that is, what it is like to have those experiences is different. 
 But this brings us back to the initial problem, which was precisely to explain how materialism could accommodate such a &bquo;feel&equo;. 
 We cannot, therefore, leave it as an irreducible fact about different physical processes that they &bquo;feel&equo; different. 
 In fact, the &bquo;mode of access&equo; argument is ambiguous. 
 It might be interpreted as saying that V has a mode of access to his own brain different from any modes of access to V's brain available to BS; or that V has a different mode of access to the external world, and that this constitutes the difference between him and BS. 
 It is impossible to deny that V has a different mode of access to the external world from BS, for V can see and BS cannot. 
 But the question is how this constitutes a subjective difference. 
 One can then choose to say either that it constitutes the difference by virtue of  having a particular internal &bquo;feel&equo; associated with it, or that it is itself the difference, simpliciter . 
 The former simply reinstates the problem of the inner &bquo;feel&equo;. 
 Within the &bquo;mode of knowledge&equo; framework, the &bquo;feel&equo; will be explained by the special mode of access to one's own  brain. 
 That this will not do is what I have just argued. 
 The second response, that the difference consists solely and simply in a mode of knowledge of the external world, without invoking any internal and introspectible &bquo;feel&equo;, requires one to explain perceptual experiences with different modes of access without reference to a subjective component. 
 As far as I can see, the only way to do this is to adopt a behaviouristic approach to this knowledge and characterize it as an ability to discriminate visual objects. 
 To take this road is to resort to what I earlier described as the &bquo;most primitive physicalist response&equo; to the problem, which involves denying that there is anything about the nature of experience that BS does not know. 
 Michael Tye, in his recent book The Metaphysics of Mind  (Cambridge, 1989), has a way of dealing with the difficulty which, if it worked, would solve the materialist's problem. 
 He combines the view that what it is like to see, for example colour  is something BS would come to know on gaining his sight, with the view that what it is like to see, for example, colour  is not a further fact  in addition to the physical facts about the brain (p. 146f). 
 So it is something further, without being a further fact . 
 At first sight this looks like an uninteresting stipulation about how to use the word &bquo;fact&equo; &mdash; uninteresting because the anti-materialist could as well state his case using some such term as &bquo;feature&equo; or &bquo;aspect&equo;, and it is difficult to see how, once having allowed that there is something called &bquo;what it is like to see&equo; which one only learns by seeing, one could refuse to describe this as a feature or aspect of mental life. 
 (Tye does compare this learning to learning to balance a pencil on your nose, but if that comparison is made to do any work, Tye's theory will simply be a behaviouristic one, and he usually seems to want it to be more than this.) 
 Tye, however, does have an argument for his conclusion that what is extra is not &bquo;really&equo; something extra. 
 I think the argument is that if we call the nature of the experience &bquo;R&equo;, and if we concede the materialist claim that R is a brain state, then in knowing the brain state the blind scientist knows R, though not what R is like. 
 Because BS knows all the facts about the brain state, and the experience just is  the brain state, then what the experience is like  must be something other than a fact about the experience. 
 The argument transposes, however. 
 Since merely knowing the brain state does not reveal what the experience is like, and since what the experience is like , if it is a reality at all (which Tye does not dispute), must be a fact about the experience (or a feature or aspect of the experience, which will do just as well), it follows that the experience is not a brain state. 
 There is one well-known materialist account of different modes of knowledge that might seem to be useful here in preserving the  &bquo;mode of knowledge&equo; approach against the need for the more drastic behaviouristic alternative. 
 Physicalists of the 1950s and 1960s were worried by the following problem. 
 Experiences, they argued, are identical with brain states; but when someone is conscious of his experiences he is not conscious of his brain as such: it takes modern science to tell us that consciousness is a state of the brain. 
 They therefore concluded that in consciousness itself we are aware of the brain topic-neutrally ; that is, not as  the brain, but in some way that is neutral about the nature of the object of our consciousness. 
 Thus, one might characterize one's grasp on the experience of seeming to see a red object as something is going on in me (I don't know what it is) which is like what goes on when a red object is acting on my eyes ; or&hellip; like what goes on in me to make me behave in a red-object-appropriate way . 
 It takes science to come along and tell us that what is going on  under these circumstances is a brain process, let alone to tell us which brain process it is. 
 All consciousness does in its own right is to tell us that it is something  internal which fulfils a certain role. 
 But even if treating our awareness of our own mental states as topic-neutral plausibly explains why we are not aware of our brains as such when we are aware of our mental states, it does not explain why knowing fully about the brain does not include knowledge of the nature of experience. 
 Topic-neutral knowledge is weaker than, and hence is entailed by, full knowledge, though it does not entail it. 
 So, if the blind scientist BS knows that V is in brain state B and that B is the state usually brought about by experience of a red object, then he knows that V is in some state or other  of the sort usually brought about by red objects. 
 So, if he abstracts from his knowledge of what the brain state actually is, he can form the same conception of experience as that had by the subject of the experience. 
 In brief, topic neutrality was invoked to explain why, within the materialist scheme, consciousness of our mental states is not sufficient for knowledge of them as  brain states: what it cannot do is explain why knowledge of brain states is not sufficient for knowledge of their nature as conscious states. 
 A rather similar, and equally mistaken, line of thought which might appeal is as follows. 
 It might be thought that the subject's apprehension of his own brain is more immediate  and more holistic  than any external knowledge, however complete, and that this explains the experiential difference between the two kinds of knowledge. 
 The scientist has essentially separate pieces of information, whereas the subject has a sort of Gestalt . 
 Once again, this explanation shows a failure to grasp the radicalness of the physicalist perspective. 
 A Gestalt  is a mode of perception of a  group of objects &mdash; say of the dots in a printed picture &mdash; so that they are seen as one thing. 
 It would make no sense to say that the dots in the picture had a Gestalt  of themselves, but to apply this model to the brain and experience would be just like that; for, if the experience just is  a state of the brain, then there is no way in which the character of the experience can be explained as the result of some perspective on  the brain. 
 Nor, more abstractedly, could it be the result of a perspective on the informational content of the brain; for, in either case, the perspective would have to be the occurrence of some further brain or informational state and to both of these the scientist has complete access, and the problem reoccurs. 
 If what I said above is correct, failure of the &bquo;mode of access&equo; argument forces the materialist to deny that BS lacks any knowledge and to adopt a behaviourist theory. 
 When a behaviourist approach is employed, it is not applied only to perception, but to all cognitive states. 
 Remembering that philosophers of the seventeenth and eighteenth century had already assimilated thought to perception, this is not surprising. 
 But this historical reason is not the only one, for, if the project is to develop a materialist theory of the mind in general, thought requires a materialist analysis as much as perception. 
 It is in its form as a general theory of cognition that the behaviouristic approach is most clearly refutable, but from the general refutation we can refute its application to perception. 
 The behaviourist theory of knowledge says that for someone, S, to know or believe that some proposition p is true is for S to be disposed to behave  in some way which is supposed to be appropriate to the world's being as p says. 
 The problem with any general behaviouristic account of knowledge is that it is impossible to make sense of any behavioural description without being able to make sense independently of statements about how the world is. 
 So, for example, it is impossible to make sense of a statement that S is disposed to behave in a certain way unless one already understands the concepts required to understand the content of the relevant behaviour. 
 As this content will involve the movement of bodies through space and time in relation to other bodies, an understanding of &bquo;behaviour&equo; presupposes a general grasp on the layout and nature of the physical world. 
 The experimental context in which the behavioural understanding of cognition developed involved such a presupposition: we understand the rat's or the pigeon's behavioural repertoire because we see it in the context of a physical layout that we take as given. 
 If I had no grasp on the shape of the maze, that is, at least its basic spatial properties, I could  not understand any ascription of behaviour to the rat. 
 This leads to problems when I try to conceive of my own knowing, believing or thinking in behaviourist terms. 
 I cannot think of my own knowledge of the physical world in terms of my dispositions to behave, but only as my dispositions, construed as operating in the world of which  
 I conceive without reference to my dispositions. 
 I cannot understand my conception of the world in terms of, or reduce it to, some account of my dispositions, as it seems plausible one might for the rat's (or any third person's) conception of the world and its dispositions. 
 In my case at least, therefore, thought, belief or knowledge concerning the world cannot be analysed simply in terms of dispositions to behave. 
 There are two responses that defenders of the behavioural approach might make to this argument. 
 First, an objector might try to press the fashionable distaste for the first-person perspective and say that the fact that I cannot apply the theory to myself shows nothing except that one should not approach the philosophy of mind via the first person. 
 A philosophical theory is essentially a reflection on a practice, and the first-person perspective expresses engagement in the practice: to apply the theory first-personally is to confuse levels. 
 This is a spurious argument. 
 A philosophical account gives the necessary and sufficient conditions (at least in outline form) for the application of a concept, and it should, therefore, apply in principle to anything that is a case of that concept. 
 If it really is the case that all I am doing when I have beliefs about the world is to have dispositions to behave, then it ought to make sense for me to think of my believing in those terms. 
 But no such general reduction can be carried out. 
 There cannot be a genuine perspective from which a true analysis does not apply. 
 The behaviourist's second line of defence is to distinguish between knowing and what is known, and say that the behavioural reduction applies only to the former. 
 So when S knows that p, it is his knowing  that is his disposition, not what he knows . 
 This line of defence is no better than the first. 
 The dispositional analysis is meant to cover the whole of the relevant mental state, not just part of it, and that mental state must include its content, otherwise what is thought  will not be the content of the psychological act of my thinking. 
 There is no way that the content of my thought can both be something that the subject really thinks, apprehends or is conscious of, and yet fall outside the scope of an analysis of the act of thinking. 
 All behaviouristic theories of cognition are viciously third-personal, where that expression signifies, first, that they cannot be applied to the first-person perspective and, second that our ability to apply them to the third person really rests on our bringing to bear  first-person knowledge: as with rats in mazes, where my  plain and unreduced apprehension of the rat's environment enables me to see its  grasp of that environment in terms of its behaviour within it. 
 Our general topic of discussion is perceptual consciousness and the problem that it constitutes for physicalism. 
 In showing that cognition as a whole cannot be treated behaviouristically, I have not thereby shown that a behaviouristic treatment of sense-experience is false. 
 So perhaps my overkill misses the target: perhaps the behaviourist analysis of perception is sound, even though a general behaviourism is not, and what BS lacks is not knowledge of the nature of certain mental states, but only the ability to respond spontaneously to visual stimuli, that is, to respond as a result of actually seeing them. 
 Reflection on the nature of the argument against behaviourism in general, however, reveals that the argument refutes the behaviourist treatment of perception in particular. 
 That argument showed that knowledge of the external world cannot be reduced to behavioural dispositions, for the very idea of a disposition functions only in the context of an unreduced grasp on the physical world. 
 But there is nowhere else that we might get our conception of the physical world from, other than perception. 
 It is the content specifically of sense-perception that must be taken non-reductively, if the contrast required by our concept of disposition is to be maintained. 
 Some philosophers might suspect that I have not considered the behaviouristic theories in their most sophisticated form. 
 Would it not make a difference if one identified experience, not with some disposition to overt behaviour, but with the &bquo;behaviour&equo; of the brain as it &bquo;discriminates&equo; the various sorts of stimuli within the nervous system? 
 This is a version of the supposedly post  -behaviourist theory called &bquo;functionalism&equo;, which treats mental states as responding to other internal and mental states as well as to external stimuli. 
 The first thing to notice about functionalism is that it does not fare any better than behaviourism in providing an account of what it is that V knows and BS does not, for BS could know all about V's functional or covertly behavioural states; so there is no lack of knowledge that his deficit could consist in. 
 It can reside only in his inability to do certain things spontaneously. 
 The situation would be different from this only if the internal discriminations carried with them some experiential &bquo;feel&equo; that was not to be identified with some physical process of which BS could know. 
 But this is just what the physicalist cannot allow. 
 The second and more important point is that the general argument against behaviouristic theories does take in functionalism and is not merely directed against traditional behaviourism: it works against any theory  that analyses one's conception of the world simply in terms of the way one functions  &mdash; that is, behaves  &mdash; in the world. 
 The addition of internal discriminations within the nervous system adds nothing relevant to this, unless the internal discriminations really possessed semantic properties, so that they somehow contained in themselves a real description of the world. 
 But it is accepted by physicalists of all kinds that the meaning  or semantic value  of internal states must be analysed in terms of their causal relations to stimulus and response, just as it is for the behaviourist's dispositions, and is not something they possess in their own right, or of themselves. 
 I have considered the flight from mind in two major aspects: first in the flight from the generality of form and universality, both in the world and thought; second, in the flight from consciousness. 
 There has not been space to say much about the flight from generality in the world outside mind, but I have tried to show how the attempts to flee generality within the mind and to abandon or reduce consciousness must both fail. 
 I promised at the outset, however, to show that reductive treatment of these features of the mind leads to an incoherent conception of the world, quite independently of the inadequacies of the reductions themselves: that is, even if the reduction of consciousness and thought were not independently flawed, the picture of the world that emerges is incoherent. 
 The physicist's picture of the world is extremely formal. 
 I mean by this not merely that it can be represented mathematically, but that, such is its concern with the  quantitative   aspects of reality that it consigns all the qualitative content  in our conception of the world to the realm of conscious experience. 
 Science tells us about the structural and relational properties of objects, while consciousness tells us what they are qualitatively like . 
 This qualitativeness &mdash; the &bquo;manifest image of the world&equo; &mdash; is irreducibly connected with what experience is subjectively like, and it is part of what is lost if consciousness is analysed away or otherwise abandoned. 
 It is not surprising, therefore, to observe a tendency amongst materialists to treat all  properties as if they were purely relational. 
 The historical progression that has led to this can, at the price of great oversimplification, be seen as follows. 
 Aristotelian physics was not essentially mathematical. 
 The physical world is composed of the elements, earth, fire, air and water which are characterized by the  qualities hotness, coldness, dryness and wetness. 
 These qualities are perceptible but the nature of their interactions is never talked of as if they could be quantified. 
 In contrast, the atomistic physics which was revived in the seventeenth century concentrated on quantifiable properties. 
 Secondary qualities, such as colour and hardness, were confined to the senses, and were marginalized. 
 When this picture was fully developed, even space was represented not as being qualitatively the way it is in vision, but as a structural isomorph of visual and tactile space. 
 By this point, every knowable quality was confined to the mind. 
 But the modern behaviourist and functionalist analyses of mind treat mental states as mere powers to produce behaviour: that is, they abolish the intrinsic qualitative content of mental states, replacing it by causal, hence relational, properties. 
 We have then reached the absurd position that nothing in the world possesses a knowable intrinsic or qualitative nature, for all properties are essentially relational. 
 This predicament arises out of the demise of consciousness, when only consciousness, understood in a traditional way, can bring us face to face with, and hence give us any grasp on, the qualitative, as opposed to relational, properties. 
 So the flight from consciousness is the flight from any grasp on the intrinsic nature of any properties &mdash; not merely, as with Russell, of properties in the external world, but also of the features in our experience. 
 This is not merely a very bare conception of the world, but argument supports intuition in pronouncing it an incoherent one. 
 It reduces language to an uninterpreted formal system. 
 All we know about As, for example, is that they have relation to R to Bs, relation R' to Cs, relation R'' to Ds, etc; and similarly for our understanding of Bs, Cs and Ds, and the variety of Rs. 
 What any of these things is like in itself, even the qualitative nature of the spatial medium of the relations, remains unknown. 
 It is not surprising that reductive treatment of consciousness should have this effect. 
 In consciousness alone is it possible to confront at least some empirical properties and apprehend them directly, and if consciousness is analysed in terms of some purely non-mental notion this grasp is lost; just as, in the analysis of thought, if the irreducible generality of thought is analysed away, our ability to think and refer is wished away with it. 
 If, as I have argued, thought and consciousness irreducibly escape the net of physicalist interpretation, and if, as I have suggested, the  external world must possess the mind-like property of generality if it is to be conceivable, then we can see that Socrates' assertion in the Phaedo , that the world must be explained by reference to mind, was essentially correct. 
 In metaphysics, the understanding of everything begins with mind, not with natural science, and modern philosophy's flight from mind is a flight from reality. 
 Bibliography 
 Berkeley's attack on abstract ideas is to be found in the introduction to his Principles of Human Knowledge , of which there are many editions. 
 The best discussion of the problem of universals is D. A. Armstrong, A Theory of Universals, vol.  
 I  (Cambridge University Press, 1978). 
 The best statement of materialism is also by Armstrong, A Materialist Theory of the Mind  (London: Routledge &amp; Kegan Paul, 1968). 
 A lucid introduction to contemporary theories of mind - mainly materialist &mdash; is P. M. Churchland, Matter and Consciousness  (Cambridge University Press, 2nd edn, 1988). 
 There is an attack on a variety of materialist positions in Howard Robinson, Matter and Sense  (Cambridge University Press, 1982).  
 &bquo;In the Beginning Was the Dead&equo;; Mental Development and the Philosophy of Mind 
 James Russell 
 'TIS wit, &bquo;In the beginning was the Word.&equo; 
 I pause, to wonder what is here inferred. 
 The Word I cannot set supremely high: 
 A new translation I will try. 
 I read, if by the spirit I am taught, 
 This sense.: &bquo;In the beginning was the Thought.&equo; 
 This opening I need to weigh again, 
 Or sense may suffer from a hasty pen. 
 Does Thought create, and work, and rule the hour? 
 'TWERE best: &bquo;In the beginning was the Power.&equo; 
 Yet, while the pen is urged with willing fingers, 
 I sense of doubt and hesitancy lingers. 
 The spirit comes to guide me in my need, 
 I write, &bquo;In the beginning was the Deed.&equo; 
 Goethe, Faust  I, 1224&ndash;37 (tr. 
 Philip Wayne) 
 It would seem that, for the foreseeable future at least, we are stuck with the &bquo;mind-body problem&equo;. 
 How anything physical &mdash; a brain - should be able to support a mental life is beyond the reach not only of our science but of our imagination. 
 There is, of course, a school of thought which says that a bit of straight thinking, a kind of conceptual analysis-cum-psychotherapy, will sweep this puzzlement away. 
 I do not take this view, but I do think that there are certain deep assumptions about how the mind-body problem should be addressed which increase its difficulty. 
 These two assumptions are: that our main questions should be about how individual  mental states relate to individual  neural events; and that we should view the mind primarily as something which represents  reality. 
 I want to look at the consequences of replacing these assumptions by two others: that we should concentrate on how mind might develop  out of matter; and  that we should view the mind primarily as something which enables action . 
 My first task will be to say why the focus upon mental representation has muddied the waters. 
 This will lead on to a discussion of an action-based theory of mentality, the theory developed by the Swiss developmental psychologist and philosopher Jean Piaget, and then to some discussion of mental development itself. 
 By the end of it all the mind-body problem will loom large &mdash; but this may  be because we are now a little closer to it. 
 Thinking and representing: the representational theory of mind 
 It would seem to be a truism that the mind is a representing device. 
 What else could  it be? 
 Evolution must surely have seen to it that a good proportion of our thoughts are true of the world, and so in some simple sense the mind must perform computations which record the world and direct our behaviour appropriately. 
 This does not mean that the mind just responds to information in the way in which a thermostat, for instance, transduces information about temperature and performs switching operations. 
 We act upon reality as we represent it to ourselves, not as it physically is. 
 Thus, Oedipus married Jocasta and knew he did; he also married his mother and did not know he did. 
 His representation of Jocasta was, as are all representations, incomplete; and his behaviour was driven by this representation of the woman not by some physical fact about the world. 
 This is one of the things that philosophers mean when they say that our mental representations are &bquo;opaque&equo;: thoughts are (necessarily partial) representations of reality and therefore we can have one thought about a referent without having any access to another (&bquo;lover&equo; / &bquo;mother&equo;). 
 Considerations such as these would seem to lead inevitably towards what is often called a &bquo;representational theory of the mind&equo;. 
 So what can we say about these &bquo;representations&equo;? 
 Doesn't the term suggest something like &bquo;mental pictures&equo;? 
 Much of our thinking would seem to have a more-or-less pictorial character, after all. 
 There are, though, a host of reasons for resisting any kind of equation between mental representations and mental pictures; and all of these derive from one fundamental reason. 
 Any mental picture will require interpretation, and this interpretation will be another mental operation, which, on the view that thinking is having mental pictures, will be another picture, which itself will require interpretation, and so on and so on. 
 This may look like an easy knock-down argument  against a silly theory which nobody has ever seriously held: but what is true of mental pictures would seem to be true of any  kind of mental representing process which encodes sensations in some determinate form. 
 In other words, the argument works equally against the view that we think in a kind of mental language, that mental sentences rather than mental pictures are the stuff of thought. 
 Sentences and words also require interpretation &mdash; indeed they would seem to require this more obviously than pictures &mdash; and so we're back on the circle of infinite regress. 
 This was the kind of dilemma which the American philosopher Jerry Fodor faced up to in his important book The Language of Thought . 
 Very roughly, Fodor argued that this kind of blanket objection to representational theories of mind does not work against the mental-sentence kind of theory for the simple reason that we know just what it would be like for a system to work on the mental-sentence principle. 
 Digital computers work on this principle. 
 Computers have a machine-code into which instructions on the program are translated, a code which is a kind of computational &bquo;bottom line&equo; &mdash; a language that does not require a further interpretive step because it comes complete with its own interpretation. 
 It drives the machine; with the &bquo;interpretation&equo; being the action, or output, of the machine. 
 We can have, then, an analogy between the natural languages that we think in (English, Swahili&hellip;) and the programming language, on the one hand, and the machine code and our &bquo;language of thought&equo;, on the other hand. 
 So long as we adopt a broadly &bquo;functionalist&equo; philosophy of mind &mdash; in which mental states are defined in terms of their causal relations to sensory inputs, motor outputs and to one another &mdash; this &bquo;computational theory of the mind&equo; is a very satisfying general account of the mind-body relationship. 
 It implies, of course, that as long as they have the right kind of causal relations, other machines, apart from brains, can possess mentality; and it also implies that the study of artificial intelligence and computational modelling is the royal road to understanding mentality. 
 The Language of Thought , is, for my money, the major text of the &bquo;cognitive science&equo; movement. 
 I would say that there are two major problems with the mental-sentence thesis which both lead &mdash; one ultimately, the other directly &mdash; to the kind of developmental questions I shall be raising shortly. 
 The first problem arises once we admit that in order for a &bquo;system&equo; (I shall use this neutral term) to think, its thoughts must have reference : that is to say, they must refer to things regarded by the system as existing and enduring independently of itself. 
 In short, thinking implies something that we can call &bquo;a theory of the  external world&equo;. 
 Now the machine-code analogy works well only so long as we forget that all a computer program has to do is run . 
 The machine does not need to know anything: it has to perform a task. 
 (For the functionalist, I should interject, knowledge is decomposable into tasks.) 
 Robot arms driven by digital computers can carry out instructions to, say, &bquo;put a pyramid on the big block&equo; even if successful completion of the instructions means first removing a small block from the big one. 
 This is a very sophisticated procedure, but only in the most metaphorical sense would we want to say that the computer has a theory of the external world. 
 (John Searle, the Reith Lecturer in 1984, built up a critique of computational psychology around considerations such as these.) 
 Well how do I know  that this computer does not have a theory of the external world? 
 I have no argument, an objector would say, just a prejudice. 
 Well, I think that there is an argument of sorts for saying that a computer of the kind described does not have a theory of the external world, does not have mental states which refer, and does not therefore have thoughts in any significant sense. 
 There is representation in a language but no knowledge, and therefore no thought in the human sense. 
 We should attend to the fact that knowledge of the external world means representing a lot of facts at once, so many facts that we lose hold of the idea of &bquo;representation&equo;. 
 The computer which can move blocks around to instructions represents, in contrast, a few facts and does what it can with them. 
 I will try to illustrate this by example. 
 I am thinking about my spectacles lying on the desk before me as I write. 
 Maybe the thought is &bquo;They need cleaning&equo;. 
 In fact, it doesn't matter what the thought is, what predicate I ascribe to them, just that they are the object of some kind of thought. 
 To put it simply: I can never have just one  thought about the spectacles, and if it could be truly said that I was only able to entertain, say, two or ten thoughts about them &mdash; if my thinking consisted of discrete, countable thoughts &mdash; then they would not be thoughts at all. 
 For example, the thought &bquo;They are on my left&equo; does not &bquo;succeed&equo; as a thought unless I can also have other thoughts such as &bquo;If I move to my left they will move to my right&equo;, &bquo;They are substantial&equo; (that is, not a chimera), &bquo;They are reachable/not reachable&equo;, &bquo;They are supported by something&equo;, &bquo;A large opaque object coming between me and them would render them invisible to me&equo;&hellip; 
 Any of us could fill this chapter with similar thoughts. 
 And these are just thoughts about the spectacles qua  physical objects of a certain size and weight. 
 If we also consider thoughts about them qua spectacles , then we would say that I have not succeeded in thinking about them unless I am thinking  about artefacts, thinking about items that can be worn on the nose, that aid vision, that are more-or-less breakable, that did not exist a thousand years ago, that this pair existed yesterday but did not exist in 1983, and so on. 
 Moreover, these potential thoughts do not just lie there like strands of spaghetti on a plate: each must have a certain kind of relation to the others. 
 Thoughts about how the spectacles would appear to me if I moved towards them leftwards must be related in the correct way to thoughts about how they would look if I moved above them to the right; thoughts about their being artefacts must be related to thoughts about their not existing before a certain time or not coming into existence in the kitchen as the kettle boils. 
 The phrase &bquo; the holism of the mental &equo; is used in a number of ways; but I hope the reader now understands what I intend by it. 
 One thought succeeds only because of the relations that it has to innumerable other potential thoughts. 
 But isn't there something artificial in my references to bunches of individual thoughts? 
 Certainly, the idea that when I look at my spectacles and think &bquo;So that's where I put them&equo; I am having thousands of other little thoughts at the same time is a silly idea, and some would say that the doctrine of the holism of the mental is  just a silly idea. 
 But this silliness does not derive from what I claimed about what it means to have successful thoughts: it derives from our habit of regarding individual thoughts as if they were like sentences. 
 It looks silly from the perspective of our so-called &bquo;folk psychology&equo; of thinking. 
 For, paradoxically enough, it is the &bquo;language of thought&equo; thesis which is closer to the layman's intuitions about thinking. 
 We have a way of talking, and thus a way of thinking, about thoughts as if they were sentences in the head; and it is worth noting that Fodor (for example in Psychosemantics ) regards folk psychology as providing a rough but reliable account of mental life and behaviour. 
 The doctrine of holism, by contrast, challenges our folk psychology of thought (see Note 1). 
 How, then, might a supporter of the mental sentence view try to deal with the holism of the mental? 
 Well, he might say that one mental sentence is, as it were, &bquo;upfront&equo; (for example &bquo;The spectacles are broken!&equo;), but that this sentence has a network of connections to other sentences in the mental architecture (&bquo;They are made of glass,&equo; &bquo;They were purchased&equo;, &bquo;They are not unique&equo;). 
 This kind of view is, in fact, quite a familiar one in artificial intelligence-influenced cognitive modelling. 
 But really it is just a reductio ad absurdum  of the mental sentence view. 
 Each of the &bquo;sentences&equo; in the network only has meaning in terms of its relations to other sentences, and each of these sentences only has meaning in relation to others, and so on. 
 In  which case they have no independent meaning or function at all. 
 To put the point another way: proponents of the mental-sentence view &mdash; being functionalists &mdash; typically see the meaning of mental sentences (or mental &bquo;states&equo;) in terms of their causal role vis-&agrave;-vis  other such sentences. 
 But how can a sentence have a causal role in relation to other sentences if the second sentence's causal role is defined in terms of its relation to the first sentence? 
 Where does the meaning come in? 
 It can only come in as some kind of &bquo;emergent property&equo; of all these causal interactions. 
 Well if that is the case, then this is just another way of expressing the holism of the mental. 
 Now for the second difficulty with the mental-sentence view, taking this view, remember, as the most sophisticated expression to date of the representational theory of the mind. 
 It is about the possibility of learning . 
 I don't mean learning facts like &bquo;Lemur is the capital of Peru&equo; or that &bquo;St Tracy is the patron saint of the dormer window&equo; (we can learn things that are false: learning is not mere information pick-up), but acquiring concepts such as what is to count as a &bquo;chair&equo;, that weight is conserved through transformations of shape, that the earth is a heavenly body circling a larger heavenly body. 
 It is self-evident that learning something entails a prior capacity to learn it. 
 How are we going to understand this &bquo;prior capacity&equo; on the mental-sentence view? 
 There is only one way: in terms of symbolic representations of the predicates, as in &bquo;X is a chair and only if it is a portable seat for one person&equo;. 
 This means that a child acquiring language who does not yet know what chair  means but will acquire the knowledge must already have represented in his &bquo;language of thought&equo; a predicate of the kind &bquo;is a portable seat for one&equo;. 
 Or to put it another way: on the representational theory of mind, all learning is the testing of hypotheses which are already represented in the mind in some form (for instance as sentences). 
 This means, in turn, that the initial state of the learner must be as a possessor of vast battalions of hypotheses which are selected out as the child bumps up against the physical world and the human conceptual system. 
 This is a way of thinking derived from Chomsky (and ultimately from Plato), and it is one with which Fodor is quite happy. 
 He writes &mdash; perhaps pour &eacute;pater les empiricistes &mdash;  that &bquo;all concepts are innate&equo;. 
 But this is a fairly repugnant conclusion to most of us. 
 Do we really want to say that all we ever learn we knew before &mdash; even if we are  saying this in some technical &bquo;computational&equo; sense? 
 How about a more modest version of the argument which says that only certain &bquo;primitive&equo; concepts are innate (about three-dimensionality, causal relations, etcetera), and that the more sophisticated concepts develop  out of these through the time-honoured processes of differentiating  finer concepts from global ones and integrating  the results into complex, structured concepts. 
 This is not much help because (a) later-developing concepts must still on the representational theory of the mind  be present in these primitive concepts (there are no merely potential competences  such as my potential but non-existing competence to know Portuguese); and (b) how and where do we draw the line between the primitive concepts and the developed ones? 
 Predictably, perhaps, I regard this argument not as a demonstration that the acquisition of new concepts is impossible, but as another reductio ad absurdum  of the representational theory of the mind. 
 The holism of the mental should make us suspicious, I have argued, of the mental-sentence view. 
 Well, if a thesis that it is difficult to make sense of allows a conclusion that is repugnant, then the rational course would seem to be to take this as another reason for distrusting the thesis: not as a reason for admitting the repugnant conclusion. 
 Methodological dualism 
 The reader cannot have failed to notice that J. A. Fodor is fast emerging here as the b&ecirc;te noire , in that he both presents the strongest case for the representational theory of the mind and champions the conclusion which flows from it about the impossibility of concept-learning. 
 Well, now I want to introduce another of Fodor's theses which, for my money, is as correct as the other two are false. 
 Fodor has written in The Modularity of Mind  that the consequence of accepting the representational theory of mind in cognitive psychology is a kind of &bquo;methodological solipsism&equo; (that is, we deal with representations, not the with relations between organisms and real objects out there). 
 I like to think of this next Fodorian thesis as a kind of &bquo;methodological dualism &equo;. 
 Recall that at the beginning of this piece I briefly discussed what the representational theory of the mind has got right: that thoughts are not simple responses, reactions or reverberations to environmental stimulation &mdash; contrasting this with the case of the thermostat which automatically switches on and off at pre-set temperatures. 
 Thinking involves taking perspectives on reality, rather as drawing does. 
 Let us now consider the class of mental processes which are not perspective-takings of this kind, which are , in some sense, directly caused by proximal stimuli. 
 A reflex would be the paradigm case here. 
 To take Fodor's nice example, imagine that you are chatting to an old friend. 
 That this person should harbour aggressive feelings  towards you is unimaginable, but then suddenly, she goes to poke you in the eye &mdash; and you blink . 
 The blinking was a reflex which could equally well have been set off by a puff of wind or a flash of light. 
 The causal chain between stimulus and response had a kind of inevitability, an independence from processes which we would normally regard as mental: it by-passed our knowledge of the friend's personality, history, and basic assumptions about human motivation, the orderliness of conduct, and so forth. 
 Now if the reflexive processes were not  autonomous in just this way, if they were determined &bquo;top down&equo; by our thoughts then we would not  have blinked. 
 This much is not controversial. 
 But Fodor goes on to argue that much of what can be said about reflexes can also be said about processes which we would normally regard as &bquo;cognitive&equo; rather than &bquo;neurological&equo; or &bquo;behavioural&equo;: the parsing of heard sentences, for example. 
 There is something reflexive rather than rational, automatic rather than deliberative, circumscribed and autonomous rather than holistic about parsing a sentence such as &bquo;She met John before Mary arrived at the airport&equo; in the way we do (with the pronoun she  not referring to Mary but to some other female). 
 We have, as it were, no choice  but to parse sentences in a particular way. 
 Believing  sentences and slotting the information that they convey into our knowledge base (for instance, what we used to think about the referent of she ) is another story. 
 That is, it is open to us to deliberate  about the light that this fact throws on the person's character; but deliberation is not open to us when it comes to parsing the sentence. 
 From facts such as this, Fodor argues that the parsing mechanism constitutes one independent cognitive module  among others, which can be studied in terms of representations that are built from the raw input of the speech stream &bquo;bottom up&equo;. 
 We can ignore the influence of higher-level systems. 
 There are a large number of psycholinguists who would say that Fodor is overstating his case here and that parsing is indeed canalized by so-called &bquo;real world knowledge&equo;. 
 However even these workers opt for something that they call &bquo;interactionism&equo;, in which there is a clearly modular, autonomous element which can be studied in isolation from the knowledge systems. 
 Vision is a better example of a modular processing system. 
 Not only does seeing a chair as a three-dimensional object have this character, but so does seeing one line as longer in the Mulier-Lyer illusion (in which two lines of equal length look unequal when differently slanting lines are drawn at the tips) despite our knowing that the two lines are really the same length. 
 Visual illusions are an excellent illustration, in fact, of the division between a  specialized and autonomous mechanism for seeing and the cognitive system which determines whether we should believe what we see, as Helmholtz pointed out over a century ago. 
 We can disbelieve the evidences of our senses, we can suspend disbelief, as well as believing the world is such-and-such with no sensory evidence at all. 
 So, to introduce Fodor's terminology, the mechanisms for delivering up packaged information about the world (a parsed sentence, a representation of a three-dimensional object&hellip;) he calls the input systems . 
 What I have been referring to vaguely as the knowledge system, Fodor calls the central systems . 
 Unsurprisingly, Fodor characterizes the central systems as holistic &mdash; though he prefers the term &bquo;global&equo;. 
 But somewhat surprisingly (given that the representational theory of the mind is supposed to be a theory of thinking, not of how we handle inputs) he concludes that a psychology of the central systems is beyond our reach: the more global a mental process is the less we are likely to understand about it. 
 This  is what I mean, then, by &bquo;methodological dualism&equo;. 
 I think we should see this pessimism as a direct result of adopting the representational theory of the mind. 
 The last  thing that a representational theorist really wants to have to explain is the global nature of thinking; and I suppose we can regard Fodor's pessimism as an implicit kind of owning up to this. 
 But when we turn to the input systems there would seem to be no choice but  to use the language of &bquo;representations&equo;. 
 Psychologists of vision, for example, have to think in terms of levels of representation that the nervous system computes and not to do so would be to render unintelligible the processes that occur between the transducing of light-rays into electrical impulses at the retina and the cortex recording the object as (say) a rigid cylinder rotating at such and such a distance from the viewing point. 
 The alternatives would be to theorize exclusively in terms of neuronal processes (impossibly fine-grained) or in terms of drawing inferences from &bquo;cues&equo; (inappropriately rational). 
 In the first case we need a level &bquo;above&equo; physiology and in the second we need a level &bquo;below&equo; reasoning. 
 Much the same can be said about sentence parsing. 
 Although, as I mentioned before, rival groups of psycholinguists dispute the question of whether, when, and how the central systems exert a top-down influence upon the parsing processes, contemporary psycholinguistics proceeds on the assumption that levels of linguistic representation (phoneme, morpheme, noun phrase, clause, etcetera) are &bquo;psychologically real&equo; in the sense of referring to processes in the nervous system which take a certain time, which happen in a particular order, and which have determinate causal relations  to similar processes. 
 Why? 
 Because these representations refer to computational achievements within systems which are by definition  (Fodor's definition) not holistic . 
 The same kind of representational language could be used to refer to the working of a television set or indeed a thermostat. 
 In short, a representational theory of the input systems would seem to be a necessity, whereas a representational theory of the central systems would seem to be a non-starter. 
 This is not just a point I am making in passing. 
 The input/central distinction is something on which I shall be heavily reliant when I come to my positive thesis. 
 This is now due. 
 Constructivism and development 
 The constructivist theory of mind regards thinking on an analogy with action; just as the representation theory takes an analogy with drawing and writing. 
 Moreover, to the same extent that the representational theory is non-developmental (recall the Fodor's argument against learning), the constructivist theory is developmental. 
 I would not say that the developmental view is a consequence of the thoughtaction analogy exactly, because there could be constructivist theories that do not mention development. 
 It is certain, though, that the constructivism that has received the most attention in psychology and philosophy has been the developmental theory of Jean Piaget. 
 Although, as I say, constructivism and the developmental view are separable, constructivism invites a developmental perspective on thinking in the following sense. 
 On the representational theory nothing can be prior to a mental representation &mdash; the bedrock of thought is representational. 
 On the constructivist view, by contrast, actions exist before central systems exist &mdash; before thoughts, beliefs, hypotheses, justifications, notions of truth. 
 Obviously enough, action is not all that is required for thought. 
 We need input systems. 
 In other words, the representations which exist before cognitive &bquo;representations&equo; (in the &bquo;representational theory of mind&equo; sense) are of the input system variety. 
 That is to say, the infant must convert stimulation from light rays, sound waves, from the speech stream into the appropriate representational grist if it is to get the kind of information that it requires from the world; but this gleaning of information does not constitute thought. 
 The next claim which constructivism makes is that centralsystem thinking emerges out of the organism's interaction with the environment, an interaction that is initially a literal inter- action  but which is later carried out internally, at least in the  human case. 
 Thoughts are &mdash; as the slogan has it &mdash; &bquo;internalized actions&equo;. 
 Before passing on, I will introduce a piece of terminology of my own and call central-system thinking &bquo;cognisance&equo;, a term chosen so as to give the flavour of knowledge, rationality, and accessibility to consciousness. 
 Thoughts will be referred to as &bquo;cognisant acts&equo;. 
 The simplest and most fundamental aspect of cognisance (fundamental philosophically and developmentally) is what is usually referred to as &bquo;self-world dualism&equo;: the knowledge that there is a physical world out there of which I am an experiencer and that is distinct from me. 
 Mental development, on the constructivist view, consists in the elaboration of this knowledge; so that if there is one central difference between the mental processes of the baby, the child, and of the adult it is in terms of how self-world dualism is manifest in (and to) the subject. 
 The representational theory of mind treats the explanation of mental life as a kind of engineering problem; it starts from the inside , from the representational state, and asks how mental states interact with one another to produce something that we would call &bquo;knowledge&equo;; the representational theorist proceeds like a sceptical philosopher who thinks that what figures in our mental life is not reality but our mental representations of it (recall my saying the Fodor described his position as &bquo;methodological solipsism&equo;). 
 The constructivist starting-point could not be more different, and might be said to be &bquo;biological&equo; where the representational theory is &bquo;engineering&equo; &mdash; or &bquo;machinological&equo;. 
 Constructivists do not admit such scepticism: the existence of an external world is one of the factors which make cognisance possible. 
 With its existence thus assumed it is knowledge  of the external world which has to be explained. 
 In constructivism we view the organism-environment dyad from the outside  and ask how it might be possible that an organism which has input systems and which is active could ever come to know that the environment exists. 
 Consider then, an organism in a world of inanimate objects. 
 (There is a lot to be said about the role of other persons too, but I am leaving that out for the time being.) 
 There are three crucial differences between the organism and the objects. 
 (1) It can move itself and has biological needs (not just for food and warmth and the like, but the need to use its faculties &mdash; Functionlust  as it was once called by a German psychologist). 
 (2) It has input systems. 
 (3) It is designed so that the interaction between (1) and (2) and other objects in the world will result in cognisance. 
 To put it epigramatically, the bridge between information pick-up and knowledge is action. 
 And  this means that the task of a constructivist developmental psychology of cognisance is to describe how this bridge comes to be built. 
 When introducing the notion of mental holism earlier, I said that thoughts must have reference  and I implied that only holistic systems could achieve this reference. 
 Constructivism is designed to deal with reference and holism. 
 First, we assume that the neonate's input systems deliver up more-or-less true information about the external world, telling a six-week-old, say, that although the &bquo;retinal&equo; image of a square piece of cardboard changes to a trapezium when it or the baby moves sideways, the shape really remains square, and enabling it to discriminate between changes in angle and changes in orientation. 
 These systems also enable neonates to discriminate between different facial expressions of emotion (for example, smiling versus frowning) and, sometimes, to imitate these expressions as well as non-emotional ones (for example, mouth-widening, tongue protrusion). 
 The reader only has to glance at a good modern textbook of infant development (say, Bremner's Infancy ) to get the main message: very young humans are prodigiously skilled at picking up geometric and social information, and this can be seen both informally (a neonate turning to a voice) and in the laboratory. 
 None of this implies of course that babies know  anything about the external world at all. 
 It is a matter of their input systems being tuned to the contours of this physical and this social reality. 
 Now it is frequently said that the development of skilled movement &bquo;lags&equo; a long way behind that of skilled perception, and in one sense this is certainly true: young babies have excellent visual acuity as revealed by their behavioural discrimination of, and neural responsivity, to gratings and chequerboards &mdash; but we don't see them playing darts! 
 The presence  of movement is one of our main criteria for being alive, and yet infant movements appear at least to be random, reflexive and undirected. 
 Moreover, we know that people who are born with severe motor impairments develop normal and sometimes supra-normal intelligence. 
 They may indeed, as in the case of Christy Nolan, win the Whitbread Prize for literature. 
 So why not say, then, that in development perception &bquo;teaches&equo; action, that as the information delivered up by the input systems becomes progressively &bquo;richer&equo; the infant becomes better able to direct his own movements, rather than saying that cognisance develops out of action? 
 My answer to this point will be more philosophical than empirical. 
 It will rely upon an argument from Kant. 
 In the Critique of Pure Reason , Kant's aim was to show how objective experience is possible, to set out the conditions necessary for this; whilst Piaget's aim was to show, given certain Kantian assumptions, how objective experience  actually develops. 
 One of the conditions for ascribing to oneself experiences of a mind-independent reality, Kant argued, was that we should be capable of distinguishing between those sequences of perceptions (if you like, &bquo;representations delivered up by the input systems&equo;) which are determined by the movement of objects and those which are determined by our own movements. 
 In the former category we have, to take Kant's example, watching a ship sailing upstream: here an object moves against a more-or-less stable background from (say) left to right. 
 We have no option but to see it as movement from left to right. 
 To describe self-governed perceptual sequences, Kant gave the example of scanning the front elevation of a building; in doing which we  determine what we see and the order in which we see it &mdash; roof, front-door, top-left-hand window, and so forth. 
 Obviously, each kind of experience necessarily contains elements of the other. 
 Thus, there is some degree of selfdetermination in the ship case because we are free to shut our eyes, to cross the river and see it move from right to left, free to jump into the water and watch it coming towards us, free to determine the speed with which it passes across our visual field by moving our eyes with or against its movement. 
 In the house example, we can choose the order in which we see the parts of the building but we surely cannot see occluded portions, and we surely cannot look up to see a thatched roof &mdash; because that's the kind of roof we want to see &mdash; when the roof is tiled. 
 In fact, in every microsecond of perceptual experience there is a tension between the real as refractory, as something we cannot choose or will, and the subjective as chosen and willed. 
 This may sound a somewhat highfalutin' way of making an obvious point; but the obvious points are often the important ones: in this tension we find the limits  of experience, beyond which we locate an objective universe and within which we locate subjectivity. 
 (One caveat: I am not saying that this is the only  necessary experiential condition for objectivity: it is, though, the one which highlights the importance of action most clearly in differentiating the objective from the subjective within the stream of experience.) 
 Without the possibility, then, of altering one's perceptual inputs at will it is difficult to see how the information provided by the input systems could ever be centered upon a self, a self that is not just a repository of information, but something which addresses itself to reality and for whom reality is centred upon itself. 
 I will give just one reason for this. 
 If there were no refractoriness (no failures  to experience X when trying to have an X-experience) there could be no basis on which to draw a distinction between appearance and reality, and without this distinction there can be no possibility  of thinking about reality. 
 There would be no distinction between the thinker and the reality he was thinking about. 
 You may say, against this, that there can surely be some form of appearance/reality distinction so long as the input systems can deliver up information about such objective facts as occlusion . 
 In this case, the reality of (say) of an orange being behind the breadboard is different from the appearance &mdash; which is that of a breadboard leaning against the kitchen wall. 
 And what of the unseen portions of the wall behind the board? 
 The &bquo;appearance&equo; is of the wall stopping just as it reaches the board; but do not the input systems deliver up the information that the wall continues behind the occluder? 
 Indeed, as I mentioned above, there is  plenty of evidence from research with the very young infants that their input systems allow them to make appearancereality distinctions (for example, apparent versus real shape) at so young an age that the possibility that they have to rely upon records of their actions to do this is just not worth considering. 
 I think that this kind of objection rests upon a false way of thinking about the information that the input system provides. 
 I shall have more to say about occlusion a little later, but for now: grasping the fact of occlusion in the sense of grasping the fact that if something were removed then something behind it would be perceived because the something behind was there all along  is an achievement of the central systems. 
 It means that we can think about things that are not present. 
 Sure enough, we would expect the input systems to ensure that the right kinds of distinctions are drawn &mdash; between contour changes that define occlusion and those which define disappearance, for example &mdash; but this surely does not mean that the possessor of these input systems is capable of thinking about unperceived entities. 
 What this adds up to, then, is the claim that if there existed an organism which either could not act or whose actions made no difference to its perceptions then not only would that organism not be cognisant, it could never become cognisant. 
 (It is not clear to me whether this is some kind of philosophical claim or an hypothesis. 
 You may say that it is refutable  and so it is empirical; but then &mdash; see below &mdash; our criteria for cognisance are so much bound up with what the subject can do that it is difficult to see how we could assess the cognisance of a totally passive creature.) 
 Perhaps the reader is now in a position to understand what Piaget intended when he said that infants &bquo;construct&equo; reality through action. 
 They surely do not &bquo;construct&equo; it in the sense of making it up! 
 They construct it in the sense of developing a conception of the real as being the refractory limit of their own actions. 
 But does this not leave  babies with an awful lot to do for themselves ? 
 And does it not have the ludicrous implication that a two-month-old only knows more than the two-week-old because he is more active? 
 What is more, we still have to answer the objection that intellectual development can be normal in people with very severe motor impairments. 
 If we find cognisance flourishing where there is a set of actions as restricted as those of Christy Nolan's, then how can reality be something that we posit as the limits of action: in this case a poor actor should have a correspondingly poor grasp of the real. 
 The answer is that by &bquo;action&equo; the constructivist intends something much broader than &bquo;motor behaviour&equo;. 
 The term is supposed to encompass any intentional change in the perceptual input . 
 There need be no movement. 
 Thus, attention  &mdash; listening to one voice rather than another for example &mdash; is non-overt action. 
 Obviously, if the infant were deaf, blind, without tactile sensations, and totally immobile then the prospects for cognisance would not be very rosy; but in this case the input systems would fail to function as well, so both constructivists and nativists (those who believe in innate mental structures) would predict failure. 
 (Even the radical nativist has to admit that information has to impinge upon the organism.) 
 Indeed action would seem to be necessary for the input systems to function properly: the role of eye-movements in vision being the most obvious case. 
 So far we have been discussing the role of activity in the development of referential thinking, the development of the knowledge that &bquo;there is a world out there&equo;. 
 What of the claim that I made earlier that no such conception could ever exist without the mental system being holistic? 
 How does the necessity for action relate to the necessity for mental holism? 
 According to the kind of constructivism that I am espousing, the holism of the mental is logically and developmentally dependent upon the holism of directed action. 
 That is to say, a system could not be cognisant unless it appreciated how intentional changes in its perceptions were constrained by reality. 
 Among other things, this means that we should look for the origins of cognisance, as did Piaget, in infancy (babyhood). 
 Initially, the infant perceives and the infant acts, but nothing suggests that the infant understands the relation between these perceptions and these actions. 
 Take the example of following an object by eye-movements (so-called &bquo;tracking&equo;). 
 As Piaget observed, very young infants will do this, but that if the object (mother, say) leaves the visual field it will not be followed. 
 Why not? 
 Because there exists no distinction between causing the experience by acting and the maintenance of the experience requiring action,  and so no conception of acting in order to experience a something  in the external world. 
 How could infants develop towards such a conception? 
 Not, the constructivist argues, by the enrichment of perceptual input (in any case the evidence tells us that this is already rich): only through action itself. 
 Specifically, in Piaget's theory the infant's central systems develop by &bquo;assimilating&equo; perceptual data (data implying &bquo;graspable&equo; / &bquo;suckable&equo; / &bquo;trackable&equo; /whatever) to actions whilst &bquo;accommodating&equo; (that is changing in a goal-driven way) the actions taken in terms of the outcome (changing the grasp, the suck, or the head movement in terms of the size, contour, or the trajectory of the datum). 
 So the basic assumption is that the developmental process is failure-driven: actions are continually failing to fulfil the assimilatory intention (recall the term Functionlust  that I used earlier) and must therefore be modified. 
 The infant's brain records the results of this modification and gradually &bquo;constructs&equo; a model of reality on that basis. 
 It must be said, however, that despite the beautiful detail of Piaget's behavioural descriptions, his picture of the mental reorganizations underlying behavioural change was painted with a very broad brush (by present-day standards); and indeed the assimilation-accommodation model is little more than a description of what has to be explained, awaiting, what we now call, a &bquo;computational model&equo;. 
 My own view is that connectionism (see Chapter 7) is well placed to provide such a computational account of sensorimotor development; but that is not the issue here. 
 Here is Piaget's most well-known demonstration of the infant's failure to relate actions to experiences. 
 At about seven months of age the average baby is quite skilled at removing obstacles to prehension; is well able, for example, to pull a cushion away to reach a rattle behind it. 
 However, if the rattle slips down so far that it is no longer visible, the infant will at once lose interest and behave as if the rattle had also slipped out of existence. 
 By about eight months of age most infants are capable of retrieving completely hidden objects; but between eight and twelve months they show another intriguing pattern of errors. 
 There are now two occluders, A and B, side-by-side before the infant. 
 The infant retrieves, or witnesses the retrieval of an object from behind A (say) three times, after which he watches as the experimenter moves it to place B. On seeing it vanish at B he will go straight back to A. Although the back-to-A error is more likely to be made the longer the delay between hiding at B and allowing search, this is not a memory problem in any simple sense because the infant will return to A even if the object remains visible  at B. We find a particularly clear demonstration of this kind  of &bquo;perseveration&equo; in an experiment by Paul Harris in which there were two transparent, lockable boxes as the A and the B location. 
 After the object (a toy car) had been put at B, the boxes were locked; with the result that most of the infants went straight to B, could not get in, and returned to A and tried to gain entry to a box which they could see (whatever &bquo;see&equo; means here exactly) was empty. 
 A minority of them never went to B at all, but went straight to A and searched, like the others, at a visibly empty space. 
 Until about eighteen months or so they will typically be unable to search for objects which have been displaced invisibly (by transposing containers, for example). 
 We need fine-grain theories of why the performance breaks down, theories about memory development (a sophisticated memory-failure account is still in the running), about the ability to inhibit actions, about the development of the frontal cortex. 
 But from the perspective of constructivism &mdash; which is a general theory of how cognisance is possible and how it develops &mdash; the immediate &bquo;information-processing&equo; shortcomings that lead to the failure to relate one's actions to objects is not relevant. 
 That  infants fail to search in these situations &mdash; although they clearly have the motor skills to do so &mdash; is one of the empirical bolsters to the view that what develops  is the ability to relate actions to experiences &bquo;of&equo; them (again: whatever &bquo;of&equo; means in this context!). 
 As Piaget said himself when reporting his original data, it is just not possible to explain the seven-month-old's failure to search in terms of memory failure (that is the baby knows that objects exist unperceived but keeps forgetting that this object went behind there) because if an organism had a memory this bad  it would ipso facto  lack object permanence. 
 Moreover, we know that infant memory is remarkably good in other contexts. 
 In fact, cognitive psychologists are nowadays more sympathetic to the Piagetian view that memory is the result  of cognitive activity, not a passive receptacle in the mind which grows, rather as the body grows. 
 (Note how in-house debates in experimental psychology criss-cross with epistemological issues in this area.) 
 Before passing on I want to raise a problem with all this. 
 It may have occurred to some readers already. 
 Isn't there something suspicious about making the performance of intentional actions the acid test of objective knowledge when it is quite possible that young babies have a very rich knowledge about the unseen existence of objects but that they lack the capacity to co-ordinate this knowledge with their motor skills at object removal? 
 Constructivism seems to make this a logical impossibility, which of course means that no data could ever disprove the constructivist claims about what develops in  infancy: any evidence that object knowledge (the &bquo;object concept&equo; or &bquo;object permanence&equo;) exists without reaching behaviour will not be judged to be evidence for object permanence &mdash; as a point of logic. 
 I will say two things about this issue. 
 First, we have evidence from Ren&eacute;e Baillargeon (see the Bremner volume referred to above) that babies as young as three or four months are able to &bquo;represent&equo;, in some  sense, the continuing existence of an invisible object behind a screen because they show &bquo;surprise&equo; when this out-of-sight object does not  resist the backwards movement of the screen. 
 They do not show surprise when the fall of the screen is  resisted by the out-of-sight object. 
 Now such infants are too young even to organize a so-called visually-guided reach (that is, reaching for what they can see). 
 The constructivist answer might be that this is behaviour guided by the input systems, with the added assumption that the behavioural expectation of resistance does not entail knowledge of continuing existence &mdash; of a continuing object of thought. 
 Second point: is  the constructivist's fundamental assumption not justified if knowledge  is our subject of study rather than successful behaviour? 
 What sense does it make to say that somebody knows  that there is, for example, a beer in the fridge, wants  a beer, is able  to open the fridge door but doesn't  open it? 
 Something has got to give: all these italicized attributions cannot be true of the same person at once. 
 In our &bquo;folk psychology&equo; of knowledge, the relation between action and knowledge is that secure. 
 Surprise (in the sense studied in Baillargeon's experiment &mdash; passive capture of visual attention) is not an action so it cannot tell us about central system function. 
 (Recall Fodor's example of blinking when a good friend goes to poke us in the eye.) 
 If surprise were a central system function then we would not , indeed, blink because the blink would be controlled by our knowledge of a friend's good nature. 
 Thus: surprise cannot tell us about the development of the central systems. 
 Needless to say, this is not going to be the last word in the debate between the constructivists and the nativists. 
 Cognisance after infancy 
 Piaget's claim that thinking is a kind of internalized action, exemplified in the assimilation-accommodation theory of infant learning mentioned above, is really a global assumption in search of some refined, detailed and testable expression. 
 One way of stating this global assumption is this: what the child has to acquire is the  ability to direct, inhibit, and co-ordinate his thoughts, as he earlier had to direct, inhibit and co-ordinate his actions . 
 This is, I would argue, a powerful idea which makes the phenomena of mental development more intelligible to us. 
 What I shall do now is try to back up this last statement by sketching some of the characteristics of childish thought, showing how they can be explained in constructivist terms. 
 They all concern, in different ways, the appearance-reality distinction, because cognisance must be understood in terms of our drawing this distinction in every area of our mental life. 
 An infant at eight months who retrieves a completely-occluded object has made a major advance in understanding the appearance-reality distinction, at least on the plane of action, because he now knows that, although the perceptual input at one time tells him that there is no rattle in his reachable space, really there is. 
 This also means that the infant can now understand a kind of ambiguity: the rattle is both &bquo;absent&equo; and &bquo;present&equo; at the same time. 
 Piaget's claim is that the cognitive difficulties which infants come to resolve &bquo;on the plane of action&equo; in infancy reappear, in childhood, &bquo;on the plane of &lsqb;verbal&rsqb; concepts&equo; and have to receive the same kind of solution &mdash; by way of the direction, inhibition and co-ordination of cognitive acts. 
 John Flavell (see Cognitive Development ) did the following experiment with pre-school children. 
 In one condition he showed them a series of objects which had been bought from a joke shop: a piece of rubber cheese, a chicken's egg made of stone, and so forth. 
 Even the youngest children, who were three years old, were well aware of the fact  that appearance and reality were conflicting, but how did this knowledge reveal itself in their judgements  about the distinction? 
 To put it another way: how did they think they could share their thoughts about the trick objects with another person? 
 When they were asked what the (say) &bquo;egg&equo; was &bquo; really, really &equo; the three-year-olds answered correctly that it was a stone, but when asked what the object &bquo; looks like to your eyes &equo; they also said &bquo;stone&equo;. 
 (There are a number of control questions that I am omitting here.) 
 This tendency to give a realist answer when we request a phenomenalist (appearance-based) answer - which Piaget called &bquo;intellectual realism&equo; &mdash; is also very easy to see in children's drawings. 
 That is to say, young children frequently draw not how a scene looks from their point of view but a good, revealing representation of it &mdash; something which further experiments have shown is not  explicable by simple graphic incompetence. 
 This does not mean, however, that young children are realists &bquo;across the board&equo;. 
 Consider another of Flavell's conditions. 
 He also showed the children other kinds of illusion in which object's  perceptual properties were altered: a white index card behind a blue light-filter for example. 
 When three-year-olds were asked what colour the card was really they typically said &bquo;blue&equo;. 
 Flavell accounts for this paradox in terms of, what he calls, cognitive salience , which amounts to the claim that the thought of the three-year-old is determined by whatever is &bquo;up front in consciousness&equo; at any given moment. 
 So when they see an apparent egg that is really a stone, the fact of its being a stone  (not that they have found a stone on the beach, say, which happens to look just like an egg) swamps their judgement; similarly when they see a white card changing colour &mdash; the blueness is salient not the fact that it started white. 
 And so one may say, in more directly Piagetian terms, that the child's thinking fails, by our lights, in so far as one thought is not balanced (&bquo;in equilibrium with&equo; in Piaget's jargon) by another. 
 The child's cognisant acts have the character of perceptions: if an act is done it cannot be undone (&bquo;reversed&equo; in the jargon) and so there is no going back and taking another perspective on the question or practical problem. 
 So children are not little realists or little phenomenalists, nor does it really make sense to say that they &bquo;waver&equo; between the two. 
 We should say that their thoughts are captured by salient information where they should be centrally directed, inhibited and co-ordinated. 
 In a somewhat more subtle form, these tendencies continue into later childhood. 
 Martin Braine found that if children between five and six years of age are shown a standard visual illusion &mdash; such as a stick in water appearing to be broken, by light refraction &mdash; they will distinguish correctly between &bquo;looks?&equo; and &bquo;really?&equo; questions, but that if they are asked the neutral question &bquo;Is the stick straight or broken?&equo; they will say that it is broken. 
 The neutral question is interpreted phenomenally, where an older child (around seven years) interprets it in a realist fashion. 
 Maybe the reader's first thought an experiment of my own showed that this is not misinterpretation in any simple sense. 
 We tested children in pairs so that each child in the pair observed visual illusions from different angles such that one child saw one kind of illusory view and the partner saw an opposite but equally conflicting view. 
 For example both children knew that bricks A and B were the same size, but, when viewed through portholes in a box, A looked bigger to one child and B looked bigger to the partner. 
 They were free to look over the top of the box to see what size the bricks really were, and they were quite aware that their own view was distorted because one of the portholes contained a magnifying lens. 
 The instructions were to agree one answer to this question &bquo;Are these two bricks the same size, or is one of them bigger  than the other?&equo; 
 We also gave them colour, length, and brightness illusions. 
 In another experiment one of the pair had a non-illusory view; for example he or she had portholes of plane glass. 
 In control conditions children worked alone, either seeing one view only or walking round the table with the experimenter to see both. 
 The point of the experiments was this: strong social pressure  was being put on these children to agree to a realist answer (they were not allowed out of the room until they had an answer!) and if their usual tendency to interpret questions phenomenally is a trivial and weak effect then this social pressure should obliterate it. 
 The result was that the social pressure had no effect at all. 
 In children between four and eight years of age there was absolutely no difference between the number of realist answers produced by the pairs and by the control, solo children. 
 They knew the realist option but did not take it as a way out of a social impasse, because, I would argue, the phenomenalist tendency of thought is too strong. 
 What dominated their judgements was the salience of the illusion &mdash; that  was &bquo;most up front in consciousness&equo;. 
 Many readers who know nothing else about Piaget's work will know of his experiments on &bquo;conservation&equo;. 
 These simple but extremely robust observations concern children's knowledge that although a substance or display is changed perceptually &mdash; in other words, that the appearance of an object may change &mdash; properties such as length, area, volume, weight, number do not change. 
 Here is perhaps the simplest and most dramatic example: the non-conservation of length by children below about seven years of age. 
 We give the child two pencils of equal length side-by-side, and he correctly judges them to be the &bquo;same size&equo;. 
 We then move one of the pencils upwards on the table, by about an inch or so, and ask again about the relative length of the pencils. 
 It's safe to say that every child in every culture will go through a period of saying that the pencil which has been moved up is now longer or bigger or big now. 
 Why is it longer: &bquo;because it's higher up&equo;. 
 It is pretty certain that, in term of what adults mean by &bquo;longer&equo; the children do not really  think that the pencil is longer; but why do they say this? 
 They are, in one sense, interpreting the question differently from the way we do; but why do they do it? 
 As Piaget said when he reported the original finding, trying to explain the children's behaviour away by saying that they &bquo;misinterpret the question&equo; is circular: of course  they are misinterpreting the question and the next question is about cognitive determinants of this misinterpretation &mdash; this &bquo;non-conservation&equo;. 
 Although it is tempting to do so, non-conservation cannot be assimilated to the phenomenalist tendency shown up in Martin  Braine's experiment. 
 For a start, the higher pencil does not look  longer. 
 Moreover, we showed, in a small study, that non-conservers of length will say that a one-inch and a ten-inch stick are the same length so long as their tips are on a level. 
 Clearly, they do not look the same length; and clearly the child's thought is focused on the tips (&bquo;centrated on&equo; in the jargon). 
 Viewed in constructivist terms, the non-conserver is failing to exert central control (lack of &bquo;direction, inhibition, and co-ordination&equo;) over his cognisant acts. 
 The tips of the pencils are &bquo;cognitively salient&equo;, and what is seen of their relation determines the child's communicated beliefs about length. 
 What if we simply draw their attention to the trailing ends? 
 I have tested literally hundreds of children on conservation tasks over a period of twenty years and have confirmed (to my own satisfaction at least) that fundamentally &mdash; in terms of the central systems &mdash; one does not succeed in drawing their attention to non-salient features. 
 The child sees them and talks about them; but this does not affect his beliefs. 
 The judgement of basic physical and geometric phenomena have then &mdash; descending still further into metaphor &mdash; a perceptually-determined, evoked character, rather like the actions of younger infants. 
 I will turn finally to experiments on what is now called the &bquo;child's developing theory of mind&equo; (see Astington, Harris and Olson, 1988). 
 By this is meant young children's explicit knowledge that they and others have mental states which are only &bquo;in the running for truth&equo;, that beliefs held by people can be false and yet these false beliefs can determine their thought and behaviour. 
 The phenomena studied in theory-of-mind research, I will argue, fill out the Piaget-Flavell picture of the child as a victim of cognitive salience. 
 Here is one of the standard procedures that is used to test whether a child has an adult-like appreciation of false belief. 
 John and Mary (the two experimenters) show a child of three years of age a red box and a blue box and a pound coin. 
 John gives Mary the coin, she hides it in the red box for safe-keeping and departs. 
 Meanwhile John tells the child that he is going to play a trick on Mary and transfers the coin into the blue box. 
 Where will Mary look for the coin when she comes back in? 
 And once Mary has returned, where will she &bquo;think&equo; the coin is? 
 Typically, three-year-olds, but not four-year-olds, say that Mary will look for the coin where it really is &mdash; in the blue box. 
 Does the child regard mind and reality as existing in a state of perfect correspondence? 
 That's surely putting it too high. 
 But there is a salience problem here. 
 Recall that it was three-year-olds who had difficulty with Flavell's appearance-versus-reality problems; and indeed further experiments have shown that there is a strong  statistical correlation between performance on the appearance-reality and on the false belief task. 
 Where is the salience effect? 
 I would say that the child is capable &mdash; more or less &mdash; of recognizing that other people have mental states different to his own. 
 Indeed it would be difficult to imagine how children were able to use language to communicate if no  such conception were present. 
 Moreover in other kinds of false belief experiment (by Henry Wellman) where three-year-olds watch a puppet make a mistake in searching, the children are quite capable of explaining the failure in terms of what the puppet is wrongly thinking. 
 But competing with the conception of the other person's thoughts is the child's own  knowledge of the location of the coin. 
 This is &bquo;up front in consciousness&equo; and it is this which determines his answer, in the absence of central control. 
 We recently did a simple experiment which happens to illustrate how children's knowledge of where an object is determines their behaviour. 
 It shows quite dramatically how difficult young children find the inhibition of reference to a salient object. 
 Children played a game against a second experimenter for chocolate. 
 For fifteen trials, two closed boxes were placed between child and experimenter. 
 We told the child that there was a chocolate in one of the boxes and that he had to point to one of them &mdash; guessing of course &mdash; to tell the experimenter where to look for the chocolate. 
 If the experimenter found it then he kept it, and if he did not find it the child got the chocolate. 
 In this way the child learnt that it was in his own interest for the experimenter to go to the empty box. 
 Then the boxes were changed. 
 This time there were windows facing the child (invisible to the competitor) so the child could see where the chocolate was on each trial. 
 Where will the child now point? 
 If he points to the empty box then it is probably fair to regard this as deliberate misinforming, as the &bquo;implanting&equo; of a false belief in another's mind. 
 In fact we did find a clear difference between the three- and the four-year-olds: the younger ones typically pointed to the box with the chocolate and the older children to the empty box. 
 But what was striking about the three-year-old's behaviour here was that they did this for twenty trials . 
 They could see that the competitor's pile of chocolate growing ever higher and that they were winning nothing, and yet they were powerless to do anything about it! 
 If we told them to point to the empty box they would do so; but would revert to pointing to the baited box again on the next trial. 
 I did not mention before that theory-of-mind tasks are also typically failed by autistic children who are otherwise quite able. 
 That is to say, they behave like three-year-olds on false belief tasks even if their mental ages are, by other criteria, well above three years. 
 This is not  the case in non-  autistic mentally handicapped children, who do well on false belief tasks so long as their mental age, by other criteria, is above three years. 
 We also tested a sample of autistic children in the chocolate-finding task and found that they were again behaving just like the three-year-olds: going to the baited box for twenty trials, despite wanting to win chocolates and occasionally trying to filch them from the experimenter's bag. 
 This suggests the hypothesis that one of the features of autism is a lack of central control of thinking similar to that found in very young normal children. 
 Their input systems function adequately, but their thinking lacks the full, holistic character of normal thought. 
 Uta Frith, in her recent book Autism , argues something similar. 
 (Non-autistic mentally-retarded children would appear to have a different kind of problem.) 
 Autism is a very profound cognitive deficit indeed, and everything that I have said up to now entails that a person whose thinking significantly lacks an holistic character, and lacks the related qualities of directedness, inhibition and co-ordination, will be profoundly affected. 
 Coda 
 We have covered a lot of ground, and maybe the path through the undergrowth of arguments and data is not a very straight or a very clear one. 
 I certainly would not want to attempt a summary of the route we have taken all the way from the mind-body problem to children trying to win chocolates; but I do need to make some concluding comments to justify the bold claim in the first paragraph that constructivism makes the mind-body problem less intractable. 
 I argued that the representational theory of mind, with its assumption that thinking is the possession of determinate &bquo;mental states&equo; which are in some sense encodings (pictorial, syntactic) of actual or possible states of affairs, contributes to the difficulty of the mind-body problem. 
 We have mainly been concerned with the modern &bquo;computational&equo; version of the representational theory of mind; but, as I shall mention again later, the more traditional views of mental life are no less representational &mdash; phenomenology, for example, is a representational theory of mind. 
 I How might such states be both mental and physical at the same time? 
 We do not want to say that one kind of state causes the other kind, but neither does it make much sense to say that they are &bquo;parallel&equo; or &bquo;identical&equo;. 
 There are arguments for all possible positions, but none of them convinces us for long (see chapters 1 and 5). 
 Recall that constructivism refers only to mental representations at  the level of the input systems, as entities which can be translated, more or less directly, into the language of neuropsychology. 
 (It refuses to take seriously the claim that central-system processes - thinking &mdash; are explicable in terms of the causal interplay of representations.) 
 Thinking &mdash; cognisance &mdash; is, however, not a matter of being in one mental state or another, or of flashing through a sequence of mental states: it is having conception of oneself as an experiencer of an external world, an experiencer who has the freedom to perform cognisant acts. 
 Thinking is a capacity to refer at will, whose nature is made more mysterious if we try to chop it up into mental episodes with particular epistemic content or causal power. 
 Inadequate thinking, as I hope to have shown in my section on mental development, can be regarded as the inadequate control of mental attention, and, like inadequate action, fails through misdirection, disinhibition, and unco-ordination. 
 An adequate thought is an achievement made possible through the co-operation of the whole cognitive system: it's not a well-formed encoding of something else. 
 As I said, it is not only the modern, computational form of representational theory which is, from the point of view of constructivism, mistaken. 
 Throughout the philosophy of mind and certainly amongst both lay and professional psychologists there is the view that basically two kinds of fact exist: physical facts about the brain and the external world, on the one hand, and facts &bquo;about how it is with us&equo;, on the other. 
 This may seem harmless enough, but problems arise once we try to describe the latter kind of fact. 
 When trying to describe these facts, we find ourselves being sucked into the language of phenomenology with its core assumption that our experience consists of shifting mosaics of raw experiential data - colours, feelings of pain, desires, glimpsed movements&hellip; 
 These experiences are at once ineffable and a psychological bedrock beneath which we cannot penetrate. 
 And this conception leads inexorably to the view that experience is like a kind of screen, something which could perhaps be painted if only we had the skill and reflective capacity, or something which could be captured by language or music. 
 Or we might talk in terms of an &bquo;inner world&equo;, the world of mental tableaux accessible only to ourselves. 
 How could this phenomenal screen or these phenomenal tableaux also be  brain activity? 
 A constructivist would deny the existence of anything that corresponds to this conception of a phenomenal screen. 
 To think there is such an entity is to confuse two kinds of process, processes that correspond roughly to the input and the central systems. 
 (I admit  I am suggesting that we replace one kind of dualism with another!) 
 In accordance with this latter kind of dualism, we have on the one hand our computational successes in recording (the psychologist James Gibson used the useful phrase &bquo;resonating to&hellip;&equo;) information in the external world. 
 On the other hand, we have mental activity which enables us, second-by-second, to conceive of ourselves as mental entities. 
 Without cognisant acts there can be no beliefs about phenomenology: no phenomenology without self-ascription, and no self-ascription without mental actions. 
 Does this conception make the mind-body problem easier for us? 
 Perhaps it does in the following modest sense. 
 At the first, input-process level, we do not encounter philosophical problems in the classic sense: these are problems of mental engineering, of &bquo;cognitive science&equo; &mdash; in the current jargon. 
 However, the problem at the cognisance level is to describe how a history of activity (that is, intentional changes in informational content) results in the conceptions which we have about our mental life. 
 It hardly needs saying that how this story is told will depend upon philosophical argument. 
 But surely, you may say, consciousness does  consist of determinate mental episodes. 
 I think of eating an omelette or walking by the sea and these thoughts have a determinate &bquo;qualitative&equo; or &bquo;phenomenal&equo; content. 
 And is not the thought of, say, blue different from the thought of green in some way which we may one day be in a position to describe, just as we are now able to describe the causal conditions for the experience  green which is different from the experience of blue? 
 Why do we have to say that these thoughts are like mental actions? 
 Surely the determinate content of thoughts is not captured by constructivism. 
 At best constructivism is a developmental theory about what kinds of organism-environment interaction are necessary for certain kind of understanding. 
 That is quite a lot; but why be more ambitious and say that it makes the place of mind in Nature more intelligible to us? 
 Answer: nobody is denying that thoughts have qualitative content. 
 (And why shouldn't the kind of holism that I am espousing not help  to make processes such as mental imagery more intelligible to us &mdash; Piaget published a number of experiments on the development of imagery.) 
 What is being attacked by constructivism is the assumption that these mental contents are , in some way, &bquo;consciousness&equo;, &bquo;mental life&equo; - whatever term we wish to use. 
 It was primarily David Hume who highlighted the problem of understanding how a coherent, ego-based mental life could emerge from bundles of &bquo;impressions&equo; and &bquo;ideas&equo;. 
 It cannot, and that is the reason, above all others, that classical &bquo;associationism&equo; failed. 
 Paradoxically, associationism is anathema  to representational theorists like Fodor; and Fodor criticizes connectionism (see Chapter 7) for inheriting all the problems of associationism. 
 But a picture of the mind as consisting of atomic mental states causally interacting is not a million miles from the Humean view &mdash; a view of which Hume himself was the most insightful critic. 
 On a more phenomenological level, if we wanted some visual analogue to the associationist view of mental life we could not do much better than think of one of those &bquo;psychedelic&equo; slide-shows popular in the late 1960s, in which lights were projected through oil, producing coloured globs which met, merged and repelled in a series of kaleidoscopic patterns. 
 Every emerging pattern was explicable in terms of principles of local association. 
 From the standpoint of constructivism, the reason why associationist-representational theories so spectacularly fail to capture the essence of thought is that they ignore the fact that every thought, like every action, has, at some level, a purpose. 
 The fact that we often feel that our thoughts come unheralded by &bquo;intentions&equo;, that the content of our mental life is unwilled, just demonstrates how thin is the layer of consciousness. 
 This is a familiar point to those who know anything of Freudian theory. 
 But there is, perhaps, one crucial objection to the constructivist's claim that moving the focus away from mental representations and towards mental actions will make the mind-body problem appear to us as less of a problem. 
 It is this: saying that the character of &bquo;mental representations&equo; (beliefs and imaginings, for example) can be understood only in terms of a history of activity, or that it is the subject's conception of himself as active in relation to the world which gives these &bquo;representations&equo; their &bquo;content&equo; or &bquo;semantics&equo; (I hope to have shown something like this) is simply irrelevant  to the mind-body problem. 
 This is the problem of how mentality &mdash; call it &bquo;mental representations&equo; or &bquo;cognisant acts&equo; &mdash; relates to its physical realization in the brain. 
 The constructivist thesis, it is argued, is not relevant because mental representations have not been defined away and replaced by talk of actions: we still have to say how mental life as we know it to be, with the representational character that we naturally give to it, relates to neuronal life. 
 The only interesting claim that the constructivist can  make here, the objection runs, is that there is  a prospect of translating all representational language into action language &mdash; with a host of adverbs, perhaps? 
 If that  is what is intended, the objector would say, then constructivism is nothing more than a kind of behaviourism (another attempt to replace the mental by the behavioural); or perhaps we might lump it together with Marxist attempts to &bquo;resolve&equo; the mind-body problem in terms of  &bquo;praxis&equo;. 
 That is hardly a solution: it merely changes the subject from the mental/physical relationship to the behavioural/physical relationship. 
 What can I say in answer to this charge of irrelevance? 
 I will take the example of an experience about whose veridicality a subject is undecided. 
 I do this simply to bracket off questions about how experiences relate to the world and thus to concentrate on the question of subjectivity. 
 Here is the example. 
 Having just been reading a bright-red leaflet we glance up to a plain, white wall &mdash; at which instant we see a green patch. 
 For a second or so we are undecided about whether the patch is an after-image or a spot of mildew on the wall. 
 What we do know, however, is that we are seeing a green patch, and our experience has a particular, qualitative &mdash; indeed paintable &mdash; character. 
 How is a &bquo;cognisant episode&equo; such as this going to be analysed away into the language of activity? 
 Well clearly it is not  going to yield to any such analysis, and to believe that it will is to deny the reality of subjective life and to side with the behaviourists. 
 What I can say, however, is that the constructivist position allows a distinctive analysis of the &bquo;mental&equo; when we speak of a &bquo; mental  representation of a green patch&equo;: it helps us to understand the difference between mental representations and the non-mental variety (a photograph for example). 
 At the time of looking up we ascribe an experience of greenness to ourselves; we consider the experience as something being undergone by us before any decision is taken about its veridicality. 
 Such an ascription is a cognisant act involving, at the very least, a conception of a one's self, a conception of experience, and a conception of veridicality. 
 As I argued, given the holism of the mental, we are not going to succeed in analysing these conceptions in terms of some complex causal interplay between determinate representations. 
 We can, however, make some attempt at understanding the cognisant act on the model of a physical act. 
 And that is &mdash; I am afraid - as far as it goes. 
 The constructivist says that we should regard the problem of how it is possible to act at will as the best philosophical and psychological road to the problem of mentality. 
 This problem is difficult enough; but starting from the nature of mental representations, considered as entities poised somewhere between subject and object, guarantees failure. 
 I admit that this constructivist way of thinking hardly &bquo;solves&equo; the mind-body problem. 
 But I doubt that it is irrelevant to it.   
 Notes 
 1. 
 Stephen Stich (1983) presents a case for a syntactic theory of mind which is more radical than Fodor's. 
 He argues that the language of folk psychology (talk about &bquo;beliefs&equo;, &bquo;desires&equo; and the like) may float free of the kind of mental states that actually do the computational work: these are defined solely by their syntax and causal role, not by their reference. 
 He spends a lot of time saying why this way of regarding syntactic mental states does not  encounter the problem of the holism of the mental. 
 2. 
 This means the process of assigning syntactic roles to elements of a sentence: noun phrase, prepositional phrase, adverb, etc. 
 In the dedication of his book, Fodor says that the following remark by the psycholinguist Merrill Garrett had a strong influence on his thesis:  &bquo; 
 What you have to remember about parsing is that basically it's a reflex&equo;. 
 3. 
 The more precise terms that he uses are &bquo;isotropic&equo; and &bquo;Quinean&equo; (after the philosopher W. V. O. Quine). 
 The former means that anything in the domain of belief is potentially relevant to what is being considered; the latter means that the falsification or verification of propositions is done relative to their status in a scientific theory (and, by extension, in a belief system). 
 4. 
 The main influence on thinking in this area is the work of the late David Marr (e.g. in Vision ). 
 He described three levels of representation in the process of vision and three levels of explanation. 
 5. 
 Perhaps the best place to begin reading Piaget in the original is Piaget and Inhelder, The Psychology of the Child . 
 Piaget's The Child's Construction of Reality  (1955) is probably the best source of the constructivist thesis. 
 Boden has written an excellent shod introduction to the theory. 
 Piaget is not the only constructivist. 
 The philosopher Mark Johnson has recently produced what can only be called a constructivist account of linguistic meaning and reasoning. 
 6. 
 This presents the problem for the constructivist of how to regard beliefs . 
 To be consistent with holism the constructivist has to say that individual &bquo;beliefs&equo; &mdash; mental states that are only in the running for truth &mdash; do not correspond to anything in the mind. 
 This is then, in Fodor's (1987) terms, not a &bquo;realist&equo; theory of belief. 
 Paradoxically, constructivism would side with Stich (see note 1) about the unreality of belief. 
 7. 
 The principal technique for testing babies' perceptual and cognitive capacities is the &bquo;habituation-dishabituation&equo; technique. 
 (This does not, unlike the Piagetian methods, rely on the baby doing anything intentionally &mdash; such as reaching. 
 It allows the psychologist to determine whether the subject has detected a change in a stimulus or can discriminate between two stimuli.) 
 Initially the subject will attend to a new stimulus but will then gradually lose interest and start to look away (habituation); if the stimulus is then changed in some way and if this causes a re-awakening of interest (dishabituation) then we can assume that the baby has detected the change. 
 Another technique is &bquo;preferential looking&equo;. 
 If the subject prefers to look at one stimulus rather than another we can assume that he has detected a difference between them. 
 8. 
 This idea had a great influence upon the thinking of Schopenhauer who followed up its implications more thoroughly than did Kant. 9. 
 The term &bquo;refractory&equo; is taken from the theorist James Mark Baldwin. 
 He had a considerable influence upon the thinking of  Piaget. 
 See Russell, The Acquisition of knowledge , for a comparison of the two. 
 10. 
 Baillargeon used the habituation-dishabituation technique &mdash; see note 7. 11. 
 Phenomenology is the method of enquiry developed by the philosophers Brentano and, later, Husserl. 
 In this, all assumptions about external reality are suspended (&bquo;bracketed&equo;) and the theorist focuses entirely upon his field of immediate experience. 
 It is not a million miles away from Fodor's &bquo;methodological solipsism&equo; &mdash; though phenomenologists have little interest in the causal interplay between the mental states thus identified.  
 The Mind in the Laboratory 
 Richard Latto 
 We have the technology 
 The increasing power and sophistication of computers is advancing the brain sciences in two ways. 
 It has improved our ability to model cognitive processes, both as a spin-off from the computations necessary to create artificial intelligences and through the computing metaphors used in cognitive psychology. 
 (See the discussions of these developments elsewhere in this book, particularly Chapters 4 and 7.) 
 And it has led to the introduction of new technologies for the direct investigation of the relationships between brain, behaviour and external events, the subject of the present chapter. 
 Most current procedures for recording the electrical activity of the brain, or producing radiographic images of the living human brain, or investigating the accuracy and timing of behaviour are dependent on computing capacity which was not available twenty years ago. 
 But many of the techniques which computers are enabling us to exploit are not new. 
 By 1875, the Liverpool physiologist Richard Caton had detected tiny fluctuations in voltages present on the surface of the brains or scalps of monkeys, cats and rabbits. 
 More significantly, he also realized that this electrical activity was affected by external stimuli falling on the sense organs. 
 Fifty-five years later, Hans Berger, a psychiatrist working in Jena, reported similar fluctuations in humans and discovered that, in a resting subject, this electroencephalogram (EEG) oscillated at a regular eight cycles a second, a pattern he called the alpha rhythm. 
 This disappeared if the subject was alerted by a noise or touch. 
 Edgar Adrian, in Cambridge, subsequently demonstrated the importance of the visual cortex at the back of the brain in generating alpha waves and the particular effectiveness of visual stimuli in blocking them. 
 In one especially striking experiment, the alpha waves disappeared when the subject imagined  a visual scene. 
 It began to seem a possibility that an external observer would be able to predict whether or not an apparently relaxed subject was forming visual images. 
 Another exciting window on the mind seemed to open up in Chicago in the 1950s when Nathaniel Kleitman and Bill Dement  began using the techniques of electroencephalography to investigate sleep. 
 Sleep could be divided into a number of different phases which recurred at regular intervals throughout the night. 
 One of these phases was known as paradoxical or rapid eye-movement (REM) sleep. 
 It was paradoxical because although the subject was very deeply asleep, being completely relaxed and more difficult to wake than at any other time during the night, the EEG pattern was that of alert wakefulness. 
 At the same time there were bursts of rapid eye-movements and muscular twitches in other parts of the body. 
 Dement's discovery was that when subjects were woken during REM sleep they nearly always reported that they were dreaming. 
 Later research has shown that dreaming is not unique to this phase of sleep, but REM dreams are typically much more colourful and rich in imagery than non-REM dreams. 
 So again, laboratory techniques were affording scientists a glimpse of their subjects' mental lives. 
 The brain is not only an electrical machine, it also has a physical and chemical structure and these too are now being monitored in the living brain. 
 By using computers to integrate the information from a large number of different viewpoints round the skull, it is possible to visualize the appearance of a slice through the brain and build up a full three-dimensional image. 
 The viewing medium can be X-rays, as in computerized tomographic (CT) scans; magnetic resonance of atomic nuclei, as in nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) scans; or emission from radioactively labelled substances incorporated into the structure of nerve cells as in positron emission tomographic (PET) scans. 
 These obviously have considerable clinical value for localizing and identifying areas of brain abnormality, but they also enable areas of activity in the normally functioning brain to be pictured. 
 The resolution of these pictures is still relatively coarse and they produce only a stationary image at a single moment in time. 
 Nevertheless, they have demonstrated activity in the visual areas during an imaging task, in the language areas during a verbal task and even, on one - occasion, in the higher visual areas of a schizophrenic patient who subsequently reported that he had been hallucinating. 
 Remarkable as these observations are, they are currently only confirming what was known already about localization within the brain. 
 All these EEG and scanning techniques are, so far, giving us only very rough correlations between brain structure and function and mental processes. 
 More important, the mental processes being studied are still only crudely defined. 
 A different and apparently much more specific line of research, however, developed from another of Adrian's electrophysiological experiments. 
 While studying the relationship between visual stimuli and the EEG, Adrian found  that if a regular series of bright flashes was presented to the subject's eyes there was an equally regular series of blips in the EEG recorded from electrodes on the scalp over the visual areas at the back of the skull. 
 These little potential shifts, known as either evoked potentials (EPs) or event related potentials (ERPs), are normally buried in the random background activity of the EEG. 
 They can be reliably dug out again only by averaging over many presentations so that the random background fluctuations cancel each other out, leaving just the potential shifts that are linked in time to the triggering event. 
 Averaging of this kind was first done at the National Hospital in London in the 1940s by George Dawson, initially using a technique of photographic superimposition and then later a system of addition using banks of condensers, but it was the electronic processing and computing power of the 1960s and 1970s which made the accurate timing of these averaged potentials possible, resulting in a rapid expansion in ERP research. 
 Since then, correlations have been reported between potential shifts and a wide variety of different events, ranging from simple and complex sensory stimuli to whole sequences of behaviour or even internally generated mental events. 
 It is now being claimed that the ERP allows the objective monitoring of well specified mental activities. 
 As Fergus Campbell has suggested, if the ERP can tell us whether or not the subject has seen a light, it takes the psycho out of psychophysics. 
 It enables the scientist to say something about the internal experiences of others without the tedium of having to ask the subjects themselves. 
 The central consideration of this chapter is the validity of these claims and their significance for our understanding of the mind-body relationship. 
 We know what you're thinking 
 Are you ready? 
 Benjamin Libet of the University of California at San Francisco has been responsible for two sets of experiments which are often cited as crucial evidence in the debate about the relationship between brain and mind. 
 In 1979 he published a paper showing that the perception evoked by stimulating the skin or the neural pathway between the skin and the cortex was reported  by the subject as occurring a few hundred milliseconds before the cortical ERP was sufficiently complete to generate that perception. 
 In earlier work, he and others had established that the cortical-evoked potential, and also direct cortical stimulation, had to persist for several hundred milliseconds  before subjects reported feeling anything. 
 Then in the 1979 paper he found that subjects placed the time of occurrence of this sensation only a few milliseconds after the peripheral stimulus which evoked it. 
 So although the ERP had to persist for several hundred milliseconds before the subject felt anything, they nevertheless reported  that the sensation had occurred at the moment when the ERP was beginning. 
 Libet concluded from this that the subjective experience was occurring before the neural events which bought it about. 
 This apparently backward causality, if true, would cause problems for identity theories of mind and has been used by dualists like John Eccles to support their position, with the backward step in time made by a non-physical mind. 
 Libet's second set of experiments, described in 1985, is even more striking. 
 About a second before a subject moves a part of his body, a slow negative shift in the electrical potential generated by the brain begins. 
 This effect, which is strongest over the frontal lobes, was first observed in 1964 by Grey Walter, who called it the Contingent Negative Variation. 
 More recently, and perhaps begging the question of its mental significance, it has come to be known as the Readiness Potential (RP). 
 In Libet's experiment, subjects were asked to move their hands at random times of their own choosing. 
 Averaging the EEG over forty such self-initiated movements, Libet found that there was indeed a time-locked negative shift beginning about 550 msec before the movement. 
 Whatever the particular significance of these RPs in terms of information processing, it is reasonable to conclude with Libet that 550 msec is the minimum interval by which neural activity precedes a self-initiated, and therefore presumably voluntary, movement. 
 At the same time, Libet set up a procedure for allowing subjects to report the time at which they first experienced the conscious intention to act. 
 This was done by asking them to report the position of a dot moving round an oscilloscope screen at the moment of the experience. 
 Knowing the time the dot was in any particular position, Libet was able to calculate that on average the experience of the conscious intention to act was reported as beginning about 200 msec before the movement began. 
 Subtracting these 200 msec from the 550 msec by which the RP preceded the movement, Libet concluded that the neural activity associated with an apparently voluntary act began some 350 msec before  the first moment at which the subject was aware of his intention to act. 
 So, he argued, the &bquo;cerebral initiation of a spontaneous voluntary act begins unconsciously&equo; (Libet, 1985). 
 If accepted, this somewhat paradoxical suggestion leaves the problem of finding a role for consciousness in voluntary acts. 
 Libet speculates that it may &bquo;function in a permissive  fashion, either to permit or prevent the motor implementation of the intention to act that arises unconsciously.&equo; 
 The marginalization of consciousness in this way would certainly make life simpler for those attempting to understand our cognitive processes, but unfortunately Libet's conclusions do not follow from his data. 
 The problem with the conclusions in both sets of experiments is that they are based on the assumption that we can infer when an experience occurs from a subject's verbal report. 
 In each case, the subject was reporting which other event a particular experience was synchronous with. 
 But, and this is Libet's error, what the subject was actually comparing was the time at which two experiences  were occurring. 
 We have no way of knowing exactly when these experiences took place. 
 All we can reasonably conclude is that they happened at the same time. 
 A much more likely explanation of Libet's findings is simply that all experiences are delayed relative to the stimulus causing them, so that synchronous external events produce synchronous experiences. 
 (Another useful illusion is that of the instantaneity of experience. 
 We have to view a stimulus for a finite time before it generates a perception, but that perception appears to us to occur instantaneously rather than fading into view like the Cheshire cat.) 
 But there is no way we can test for this hypothetical delay. 
 Subjects are always limited to making judgements about experiences; experimenters are stuck with observing physical events like evoked potentials, verbal reports and button presses. 
 There is no way in which the time of occurrence of an experience can be related to the time of occurrence of a physical event without assuming answers to the questions Libet is asking. 
 (One, untestable, assumption which most reductionists would make is that conscious experiences cannot precede the neural events underlying them.) 
 So Libet's experiments tell us something interesting about the information processing going on in the subject's brain but they tell us nothing about the temporal relationship between physical events &mdash; either inside or outside the brain &mdash; and conscious experiences. 
 There is another, apparently much more fundamental although philosophically less interesting, criticism of Libet's work. 
 Perhaps the particular potentials he is recording are not causally linked with the conscious experiences he is investigating? 
 Given that there are good correlations between the two, this would imply that they are both being caused by a third, unidentified event. 
 This event would presumably precede the potentials being recorded and it could provide an explanation for the apparent referral back in time in the first set of experiments, although it does seem electrophysiologically unlikely that there could be a neural change  happening sufficiently early after the triggering stimulus. 
 But in the second set of experiments, a neural event preceding the RP would only serve to make the effect Libet is claiming even more striking and alternative explanations still need to be sought. 
 Get set 
 Libet was investigating the processes underlying a decision to move; that is, the ERP that precedes a movement. 
 But most human electrophysiological work has been concerned with the processing of incoming events, that is the ERP that follows the presentation of a stimulus. 
 When, for example, a subject fitted with scalp electrodes over the auditory cortex is played a series of brief clicks through headphones and the EEG following each click is averaged so that random fluctuations cancel each other out, what is left is a systematic but complex pattern of electrical waves which is caused by the click in the same way that the waves on the surface of a pond are caused by dropping a pebble into it. 
 The first fifty or so milliseconds of these waves are the most consistent for any particular stimulus and it is thought that they are almost entirely generated by the incoming stimulus, irrespective of any mental activity on the part of the subject. 
 These early components of the ERP are therefore usually called exogenous. 
 After fifty milliseconds the waves are more labile. 
 Some of them are still exogenous and can be modified only by varying the stimulus, but some of them now seem to depend mainly on the way the subject is processing the stimulus. 
 It is these internally generated or endogenous components, lasting sometimes as long as a second after the triggering stimulus, which offer the most potential for investigating mental activities. 
 ERPs are very slippery customers. 
 Even those who most strongly advocate their use as research tools would admit that we do not know exactly what neural processes generate them and that any particular fluctuation will be the result of a multiplicity of different kinds of changes occurring in several different and possibly independent systems. 
 Some of these changes will be related to neural processes that have little psychological relevance. 
 Nor is there any reason to suppose that the peaks and valleys of the fluctuations have greater neural or psychological significance than any other intermediate point. 
 So sorting out what is going on in an ERP is like untangling a complex bundle of many different strands of similar wool with one hand tied behind the back. 
 Given this, the progress that has been made is remarkable, particularly in relating components of the ERP to attentional processes. 
 Whether or not we perceive an event in the world around us  depends on three things. 
 First, it has to fall within our viewing window: we have to have the right apparatus to receive and process the information signalling the event. 
 Thus, we can perceive the sound emitted by a piccolo but not that from a dog whistle. 
 Second, we have to be sufficiently alert: the apparatus has to be switched on. 
 If we are drowsy we may not hear either the piccolo or the dog whistle. 
 Third, in certain circumstances, we have to be attending to the stimulus: the apparatus has to be tuned in correctly. 
 In a complex orchestral passage, we shall probably not be aware of the piccolo unless we are specifically listening out for it. 
 This facility for selective attention increases the processing power of our brains enormously by enabling us to direct our limited processing capacity where it is most needed. 
 It is clearly under voluntary control: we can decide who to listen to in a crowded room and who to shut out. 
 And it is extremely sophisticated: we can pick out our chosen voice from an overlapping background of very similar sounds. 
 From William James at the end of the last century to the present day, psychologists have speculated and experimented to discover how this is done. 
 A stimulus will generate an ERP only if it falls within our sensory window and the size and form of that ERP will vary according to our general state of alertness, of which alpha blocking is one important indicator. 
 Even more strikingly, the ERP will vary according to whether or not we are selectively attending to it. 
 As early as 1957, Michel Jouvet in Lyons had reported that the size of the ERP generated by a visual stimulus from the occipital cortex at the back of the brain, a primarily visual area, decreased when the subject was asked to attend to an auditory stimulus. 
 Working with Ra&uacute;l Hem&aacute;ndez-Pe&oacute;n, he also showed that the auditory ERPs generated in the neurons in the cat's ear almost disappeared when a salient visual stimulus, for example a mouse, was brought into the cat's field of view. 
 So this damping down of the sensory input when attention moves elsewhere can occur very early in the pathway from the sense organ to the brain. 
 These early experiments were sometimes difficult to interpret, but the general finding that the form of the ERP is affected by shifts in attention has proved very reliable. 
 Recent experiments on the psychophysiology of selective attention by, for example, Steven Hillyard at San Diego and Emanuel Donchin at Illinois have successfully related different endogenous components in the ERP to different stages in the process of selective attention. 
 Suppose a subject is listening to different sequences of sounds played independently to each ear through a pair of headphones in order to pick out and respond to a particular target sound. 
 If the subject is instructed to attend to one ear and ignore the sounds coming into  the other ear, all the sounds in the attended ear will produce an enhanced N100 component in the ERP. 
 (The name N100 indicates a systematically occurring negative shift in the ERP which peaks about 100 msec after the stimulus.) 
 This enhancement is thought to be associated with the extraction of additional information about the stimuli in the attended ear. 
 A more subtle distinction affects a later component, the P300 (a positive shift peaking 300 msec after the stimulus). 
 For while all stimuli in the attended ear give an enhanced N 100, only those sounds which the subject, correctly or incorrectly, identifies as the target stimulus will result in an enhanced P300. 
 So the P300 is thought to be associated with the completion of stimulus identification and classification in preparation for a cognitive or motor response. 
 Late waves like the P300 and the more recently identified N400 are by far the most cognitively interesting of the ERP components. 
 The P300 was first described in 1965 by Sutton. 
 It is generally elicited only by stimuli that are both infrequent (or improbable) and significant in the sense that they require some kind of response by the subject. 
 Its purely endogenous nature is well illustrated by the facts that it can be evoked by the absence  of a stimulus such as a gap in a long sequence of evenly spaced tones and that the actual probability and significance of the stimulus is less important in determining whether or not the P300 will occur than the subject's perception of its probability and significance. 
 The most cognitively complex association with an ERP was found in 1980 by Kutas and Hillyard for the N400 wave. 
 This is elicited, after the very long delay of 400 msec, by the visual presentation of a semantically improbable word (for example, the word &bquo;socks&equo; in &bquo;He spread the warm bread with socks&equo;). 
 Meaning seems to be the crucial factor, since the presentation of a grammatically inappropriate word or an appropriate word in a new and unexpected typeface does not evoke an N400 wave. 
 And the finding that it takes 400 msec to generate the electrical activity associated with the meaning of visually presented words suggests that this is one of the most complex activities our perceptual systems are asked to perform. 
 These experiments tell us a great deal about certain aspects of cognitive processes, particularly their relative timing or sequencing. 
 They also provide circumstantial evidence for a close relationship between mind and brain. 
 They have shown that mental processes can be correlated with specific neural changes. 
 This is a necessary condition for a reductionist view of the mind but, particularly given the absence of any effective demonstration of a causal connection between the mental and the neural, it is certainly not a  sufficient condition. 
 (The many demonstrations, in neuropsychological experiments of the kind discussed in Chapter 4, of the loss of mental processes caused by the loss of neural processes are more powerful here.) 
 But the electrophysiological examples I have described go some way to countering Wittgenstein's negative assertion: &bquo;No supposition seems to me more natural than that there is no process in the brain correlated with associating or with thinking; so that it would be impossible to read off thought-processes from brain-processes&equo; (Zettel, paragraph 608, Anscombe's translation, 1967). 
 There may of course be some mental processes for which no neural activity exists, but such an awe-inspiring negative could not be proved until we knew the place and function of every least sub-atomic particle in the human brain. 
 And the more links that are discovered between mental and neural processes, the smaller the dualist gap becomes. 
 What have we found? 
 It is an act of faith of most brain scientists, including, as must be obvious by now, this one, that an understanding of the brain will lead to an understanding of behaviour and of the processes that control and underpin behaviour, some of which are conscious and some unconscious, but which taken together correspond to the folk-psychological term &bquo;mind&equo;. 
 Indeed brain-mind identity is more than a belief, it is a hypothesis which seems to be the simplest explanation of the mind-brain problem, if it is a problem, and therefore one which parsimony requires us to accept. 
 Further, although this hypothesis has not yet resulted in an account incorporating consciousness, it has been remarkably successful in explaining many other mental phenomena which earlier generations saw as necessarily mysterious and as evidence for some kind of duality. 
 Joan of Arc's hallucinations were not so much the voice of God as the voice of some aberrant neurons in her temporal lobes. 
 Electrophysiology allows us to correlate one set of observable physical events (electrical activity in the brain) with another (the behaviour, including the behaviour of reporting experiences, of the subject being recorded from). 
 It is important to remember that the linguistic utterances of others are just as much externally observed behaviour as walking down stairs or pressing a button in a psychophysics laboratory although, because of the high information content of linguistic behaviour, we are prone to endow it with some mystical quality which opens a special window on to the mind of the person generating it. 
 We must approach observations of linguistic  behaviour with the same careful attitude as we approach other kinds of behaviour or indeed as we approach our electrophysiological observations. 
 It is also worth noting that correlations between ERPs and behaviour are never perfect, perhaps because of masking of some of the ERPs by random fluctuations of the background EEG. 
 An individual event which normally gives a particular ERP may sometimes yield nothing and the ERP may sometimes occur in the absence of the evoking event. 
 It is always the case that averaging over tens of trials is necessary to give consistent results, particularly with endogenous ERPs. 
 So it is not yet possible to say with absolute certainty, using evoked potentials that are correlated with reports of conscious mental events, whether or not an individual external event has resulted in a particular mental event. 
 Further, the need for averaging obviously favours repetitive responses to repetitive stimuli and neural events that do not correlate in a consistent time-locked way with external stimuli will necessarily be overlooked. 
 This weakness must become more severe as we move from investigating relatively simple sensory and motor processes to the study of high level cognitive processes. 
 All of these observations of correlations between ERPs and different kinds of behaviour, including phenomenological reports, may tell us something about mental representations and the cognitive processes generating them, but they can tell us nothing about whether these representations and processes are conscious or unconscious. 
 It is the essential but usually overlooked fact that in any psychophysical experiment when, for example, subjects are asked whether or not they perceive a stimulus, their responses, verbal or otherwise, cannot be relied on as accurate accounts of their conscious experiences. 
 So, in a near-threshold task the subject may be accurately identifying the presence of a stimulus which tells the experimenter that there is some kind of mental representation of the stimulus, but there is no way the experimenter can decide whether or not the subject is consciously aware of the stimulus. 
 Indeed, it is a common observation in experiments of this kind that subjects themselves often express confusion about what they are conscious of. 
 The problem arises whenever we try to use conscious awareness as a dependent variable: for example, when we want to decide whether or not a particular external event leads to a phenomenal event. 
 This is an area of some controversy at the moment in psychology, where one of the holy grails is the attempt to provide empirical evidence for the intuitively reasonable idea that there can be a dissociation of behaviour from consciousness. 
 This is a phenomenon which most  of us experience from time to time, particularly when performing a highly practised task like driving a car or using a keyboard, and which the clinician often feels presents in exaggerated form in certain neurological conditions. 
 The term &bquo;blindsight&equo; was coined by Larry Weiskrantz at Oxford to describe perhaps the best known example of this dissociation, in which patients with damage to the visual areas of the cortex deny being able to see a visual stimulus while behaving in some respects as if they are processing it, for instance by moving their eyes in its direction. 
 The difficulty here is the same as the one already encountered with the attempt to relate evoked potentials to conscious events. 
 We only have the subjects' external behavioural indicators (verbal or non-verbal) of their experiences and we have no way of validating these indicators. 
 So we end up dissociating one piece of behaviour from another: in &bquo;blindsight&equo;, the verbal response &bquo;No, I did not see the light&equo; is dissociated from the ability to move the eyes towards the light. 
 This, I would argue, though not all would agree, may tell us something interesting about the way the brain compartmentalizes different aspects of visual processing and it may tell us that subjects are more conservative about admitting to seeing a very degraded image than about trying to move their eyes to it, but it sheds little light on the actual experiences the patients are having when we show them a light. 
 There is an elegant circularity in trying to prove that behaviour can be dissociated from conscious awareness by using behaviour to indicate the absence of awareness. 
 I am not suggesting that we should be completely sceptical about the value of introspection. 
 There are some circumstances in which accounts of conscious experiences may be very useful in suggesting hypotheses about the nature of cognitive processes. 
 The still influential contribution of K&ouml;hler and the other Gestalt  psychologists to elucidating the rules underlying pattern perception is a major example. 
 But when we talk about our conscious experiences we are providing our listener with only a very crude approximation to the actual phenomenal content of experience. 
 (Interestingly, one of the functions of art is the attempt to refine this process of communicating mental states and the accounts of the artist can sometimes be a more useful guide to the nature of cognitive processes than na&iuml;ve introspection.) 
 What I am suggesting is that introspective reports, while often providing helpful qualitative information, can never be reliable enough to use as quantitative data defining the presence or absence of conscious awareness. 
 Returning to the central theme of the present chapter, electrical activity can be correlated with behaviour and this helps us towards an understanding of the neural mechanisms and cognitive processes  underlying behaviour. 
 It does not enable us to say anything directly about the nature of consciousness. 
 But then an understanding of consciousness, for all its fascination, is not necessary to the production of an adequate model of cognitive behaviour. 
 While consciousness may be central to an understanding of one's self, it is marginal to an understanding of other people. 
 Consciousness in other people is a hypothesis for which there is circumstantial evidence in their verbal reports which match, by-and-large, our verbal reports of our own experiences. 
 (This implies of course that consciousness in animals is a hypothesis for which there can be no evidence at all unless we resort to anthropomorphism, which we usually do.) 
 Most psychologists accept that cognitive processes, and therefore &bquo;mind&equo; &mdash; although this is a term not widely used in the brain sciences - encompass both conscious and unconscious activities. 
 Clearly, conscious processes are central to an individual's own experience, but most of us remain neutral as to whether they are central to cognitive processes given that many, if not most, of these are not conscious. 
 It also follows from this that understanding consciousness would not be sufficient for understanding mental processes. 
 So current cognitive models of language, memory, perception and so forth are also basically neutral to the question of consciousness. 
 They discuss how information is processed to achieve a particular end (storage and retrieval in memory, for example), but they say nothing about the borderline to be drawn between the conscious and unconscious parts of these procedures. 
 What remains uncertain is whether consciousness is a separate phenomenon which needs  explaining, like language or vision, or whether it is simply an attribute of certain neural processes in the same way as high reflectance is an attribute of the piece of paper you are looking at while you read this, something which is simply part of the physical characteristics of the brain or the paper. 
 Indeed, the evidence we have from cognitive psychology of the overwhelming predominance of the unconscious over the conscious parts of mental processes suggests that consciousness may be as peripheral to the central information processing activities of the brain as the whiteness of this paper is marginal to the semantic content of the words printed on it, which are telling you what I think about the mind.    
 Cognitive Neuropsychology and the Philosophy of Mind 
 J. Richard Hanley 
 Introduction 
 Clinical neuropsychology involves the study of the effects of brain injury on human behaviour. 
 What neuropsychologists are trying to do is to come to some understanding of the way in which damage to the brain impairs abilities such as memory, perception and the use of language. 
 Within the last two decades, a new approach to this subject has assumed great influence. 
 This new approach is known as cognitive neuropsychology , and it attempts to explain the impairments which neuropsychological patients unfortunately experience within the vocabulary of cognitive psychology. 
 One of my main goals in this chapter is to describe the nature of cognitive neuropsychology, and to account for its pre-eminence. 
 However, this is a book about the philosophy of mind  rather than experimental psychology, and the main point that I want to make is rather more philosophical than psychological. 
 Consequently, I am going to start off by outlining some of the philosophical beliefs about the nature of mind which underpin contemporary research in the cognitive sciences, including cognitive neuropsychology. 
 This will involve a brief discussion of the approach known in contemporary philosophy as functionalism . 
 The basic theme of this chapter will be that the success of cognitive neuropsychology provides strong grounds for believing that functionalism, or something very close to it, is actually true. 
 Functionalism as a Philosophy of Mind 
 The functionalist approach to the study of mind characterizes much of the work currently being done in cognitive psychology, artificial intelligence and linguistics. 
 Unlike classical behaviourists, functionalists believe that is not possible to explain intelligent behaviour unless we make reference to processes that are taking place inside a person's head. 
 Now, of course, nobody denies that  certain processes (blood flow, neural transmission etcetera) occur in the brain and that behaviour would be impossible without them. 
 What is controversial about functionalism is its claim that we are going to be able to make significant generalizations about behaviour only if we think about what is going on in the brain at a particular level of description. 
 If we confine ourselves to explanations couched in the vocabulary of physics or neurochemistry, then we are going to lose, or fail to formulate, a vitally important set of generalizations about human behaviour, and science will never be able to explain or predict behaviour in a satisfactory way. 
 According to functionalism, it turns out that the appropriate level of description is the same as that which characterizes folk psychology , the psychological theory that ordinary people use when predicting and explaining the behaviour of their fellow human beings in the course of their everyday lives. 
 Functionalists, therefore, attempt to explain behaviour in terms of mental concepts such as beliefs, thoughts, desires and memories. 
 Behaviour comes about as a result of the interaction of these mental processes with each other and with the environmental stimuli that are constantly impinging upon our sensory systems. 
 This is not to say that folk psychology already has adequate theories of perception, language, memory or any other cognitive process. 
 Indeed, the data from patients with brain injury that I will be discussing in the final two sections are very puzzling indeed from the standpoint of folk psychology. 
 The point is simply that the account of mental processes which folk psychology provides, constitutes an explanation at an appropriate level of abstraction  for the purposes of explaining behaviour scientifically. 
 It should be emphasized that this level of explanation does not commit the functionalist to a belief in any non-physical substances or processes. 
 Most, perhaps all, functionalists are thorough-going materialists who believe that mental phenomena are genuine physical  phenomena seen at a particular level of abstraction. 
 This commitment to materialism means that a couple of standard dualist objections must be faced. 
 First, there is the dualist's argument that mental processes cannot be physical processes because physical entities &mdash; such as neurons - lack certain qualities &mdash; such as intentionality or consciousness &mdash; that characterize the mental. 
 The response to this is that intentionality and consciousness are emergent properties  of physical systems. 
 Neurons do not individually have the property of consciousness, consciousness emerges when a large number of neurons are interacting in the right kind of way; just as speed  is a property not of any single component of a car, but an emergent property of the whole system  when it is operating in an appropriate way. 
 Of course, nobody as yet knows how intentionality &mdash; the property that mental phenomena have of being about  something other than themselves &mdash; or consciousness emerge from the operations of the brain. 
 From the perspective of functionalism (and from the perspective of other materialist theories also), however, this is a question for science rather than an imponderable problem of metaphysics. 
 Searle (1984, pp. 18&ndash;21) strongly supports the view that intentionality and consciousness are emergent properties, but there is at least one important difference between Searle's account of emergent properties and the one I am advocating here. 
 I have no quarrel with Searle's claim that &bquo;mental phenomena are caused by processes going on in the brain&equo;. 
 When he states subsequently that &bquo;mental phenomena just are features of the brain&equo;, thus tying mental phenomena very rigidly to the brain itself, then I dissent. 
 The functionalist view I advocate is that mental phenomena emerge as a result of the way that the neurons etcetera are functionally organized  in the brain, not as a result of the physical properties of neurons per se . 
 As Churchland (1988, p. 37) has put it, &bquo;what is important for mentality is not the matter of which the creature is made, but the structure of the internal activities which that matter contains&equo;. 
 Consequently, mental phenomena could emerge from a physical system which does not contain neurons at all, if its physical components were arranged together in a particular way. 
 Most important, there may be no interesting similarity whatsoever that could be formulated in the vocabulary of physics between such a system and the brain. 
 This might even include the nature of the emergence of the mental from the physical itself. 
 Only at the functional level would the two types of system be equivalent. 
 The second question which an opponent of dualism such as a functionalist must face, concerns the alleged privacy  of the mental. 
 It is true that we cannot observe or measure directly mental processes taking place in the brain in the way that we can measure, say, blood flow via a brain scanner. 
 This does not mean however that mental processes are in some way divorced from the physical world, nor does it mean that they should be excluded from the subject matter of natural science. 
 From a functionalist perspective, mental processes are inferred processes &mdash; they gain their status in our theoretical base not as a result of being directly observed or experienced, but from the way in which they enable us to understand and explain human behaviour. 
 They exist, theorists believe, because they help us to see the world as it really is. 
 Their ontological status is therefore every bit as secure as the status of unobserved  theoretical entities in other sciences (for example quarks in subatomic physics). 
 What this means, of course, is that functionalists do not see consciousness as a defining feature of the mental. 
 Since the time of Freud, it has been acceptable to many theorists that the way in which we behave may be powerfully influenced by mental processes to which we have no conscious access. 
 This is not to say that functionalists would be in sympathy with Freud's belief that certain unconscious mental processes are so anxiety-provoking that they must not be allowed to enter awareness. 
 They simply share the belief that it is not going to be possible to explain behaviour adequately if mental processes are identified with the contents of conscious awareness. 
 Let me emphasize here that functionalists are happy to accept that many of our mental states are  associated with conscious awareness. 
 They are also happy to accept that it is only because we have these mental states that we behave as we do. 
 Behaviour is genuinely caused by the interaction of such mental states. 
 Such views are very different from those that would be associated with behaviourism or epiphenomenalism, neither of which allows mental states any causal role in the production of behaviour. 
 Furthermore, the work of Young and his colleagues, which I shall be discussing later in the chapter, shows that being aware of the operations of, say, one's face processing system has vitally important functional consequences. 
 However, the functionalist view is that it would be quite misguided to attempt to explain behaviour by making direct reference to the subjective  or phenomenal  qualities (technically known as qualia ) of these mental states. 
 If it is really necessary to think of mental states as having qualitative content (and see Dennett, 1988, for some powerful arguments that it is not), then it follows from functionalism that such qualia do not have causal interactions with other mental states or behaviour and are mere epiphenomena. 
 Successful Science 
 The sceptic might, at this point, complain that while I may have sketched out the functionalist position, I have not provided any convincing arguments as to why one should believe it. 
 What I now want to suggest is that there is a lot of very successful science currently being conducted which literally depends on functionalism being true. 
 If functionalism is false, then the success of the cognitive sciences is a massive scientific fluke. 
 My argument for functionalism  is therefore critically dependent on whether or not I can convince you that progress in one of these areas &mdash; cognitive neuropsychology &mdash; is unlikely to be simply an illusion. 
 In this section, I will set out what I believe to be the basic characteristics of a flourishing, as well as an unsuccessful, approach to science. 
 I will then attempt to evaluate cognitive neuropsychology in terms of these criteria. 
 Science exists so that we can improve our understanding of naturally occurring phenomena. 
 Understanding in this sense means being able to perceive structure amongst a set of observations that were at first sight perplexing and confusing. 
 When we identify such a structure, then it means that we can successfully explain our observations in terms of concepts that we genuinely understand already. 
 What are the signs that tell us whether or not we are making genuine progress in a particular area of study? 
 First, we should be able to explain a relatively large set of observations in terms of a much smaller set of more general theoretical principles. 
 Second, these principles should then lead us on a successful search for phenomena that we had not observed previously. 
 Then, as we encounter fewer phenomena that genuinely puzzle us, so our faith in the explanatory adequacy of our theoretical base increases. 
 Why might an attempt to explain a particular set of phenomena flounder? 
 Perhaps the most obvious cause of failure is an inability to perceive the pattern that exists in nature. 
 There would appear to be at least two different reasons why this might be so. 
 First, it may be that no one (as yet) has made the critical observations which would allow the pattern to become evident. 
 In this situation, &bquo;further research is necessary&equo; and, when controversy arises, it is likely to occur between those who actually share a large number of fundamental theoretical assumptions. 
 Secondly, a failure to perceive the pattern may also occur because we lack within our theoretical base the conceptual framework that would enable us to grasp the structure that is potentially available, given the observations that we have made already. 
 For example, we apparently only came to some understanding of how the heart  worked when we had within our conceptual framework the notion of a pump . 
 In such a situation, further collection of data may be pointless in the absence of any fresh conceptual insight. 
 There is, however, a more fundamental reason why an attempt to perceive a structure within a given set of phenomena may fail; it may be that there actually is no structure there to be perceived in the first place. 
 Plato said that we should attempt &bquo;to carve nature at its joints&equo;. 
 The implication, contrary to relativism, is that certain things (referred to in the contemporary literature as &bquo;natural kinds&equo;)  simply belong together. 
 If we attempt to put the wrong type of things together, or attempt separate explanations of things which are part of the same natural kind, then we are going to struggle to produce successful science. 
 We won't produce any interesting generalizations, we won't succeed in predicting new phenomena, and the world will remain every bit as confusing as it was previously. 
 Cognitive Neuropsychology 
 Case Studies and Group Studies 
 Cognitive neuropsychology is the attempt to draw parallels between models of cognitive function and the patterns of performance observed in patients who have suffered Brain injury. 
 There are two basic questions. 
 First, can we explain the impaired performance that these patients produce in terms of our functional models? 
 Second, can we learn anything new about the nature of the underlying cognitive processes from studying these unfortunate individuals? 
 Cognitive neuropsychology is largely a European rather than a North American phenomenon. 
 The vast bulk of the neuropsychological work performed in the United States to investigate cognitive processes uses group studies as in, for example, the investigation of human amnesia (severe loss of long-term memory function as a result of brain damage). 
 A set of amnesics is first assembled on the basis of their low scores on a clinical memory test. 
 Their performance on some task is then evaluated by comparing their average score with the average score of a group of matched control subjects. 
 The purpose is to test an hypothesis about what the &bquo;cause&equo; of amnesia might be. 
 This approach to amnesia has had some success. 
 In particular there is the intriguing finding that some amnesics can learn certain new skills as quickly as normal subjects, even though they are often unable to remember the circumstances in which they learnt them. 
 Unfortunately, though, we are not very much closer to a genuine explanation of amnesia in functional terms that we were twenty years ago. 
 The problem is that it is highly improbable that a group of patients with brain injury constitute a natural kind, even when they display similar symptoms on some test or other. 
 This is because no two patients are likely to have identical injuries, and large groups of patients are even less likely to be homogenous. 
 In fact, if you probe deeper, vitally important functional differences between patients will emerge. 
 In amnesia, as in many other  so called neuropsychological syndromes (developmental dyslexia, schizophrenia, Wemicke's aphasia etcetera) there is probably no uniform pattern in nature waiting to reveal itself. 
 What you have are groups of people who display superficially similar symptoms for a variety of different reasons. 
 Where cognitive neuropsychology has had its greatest success is in areas where a detailed model of cognitive function is used to explain the pattern of performance produced by individual  patients. 
 Let me illustrate this via an examination of the cognitive neuropsychology of reading. 
 Models of Reading 
 According to one influential cognitive model (Coltheart, 1985; see Figure 1), there are two distinct reading routes that might come into operation when one is reading aloud. 
 Following the terminology of Patterson (1982), these two systems are said to involve either &bquo;assembled&equo; or &bquo;addressed&equo; phonology. 
 A pronunciation of a word is said to be assembled when it is built up piecemeal from its component letters. 
 The letters are first &bquo;parsed&equo; into their appropriate graphemic units. 
 A grapheme is here defined as the way in which a phoneme is represented in print. 
 Graphemic parsing is necessary because a phoneme is often represented in English by more than one letter (for example, PH represents one phoneme in &bquo;graph&equo;, OO represents one phoneme in &bquo;boot&equo;). 
 Each grapheme is then translated into a corresponding phonemic representation on the basis of pre-established conversion rules (each grapheme would become associated with a particular phoneme as one's reading skills develop). 
 Finally, the phonemes are blended together to produce the spoken response. 
 The alternative pronunciation route, which involves &bquo;addressed&equo; phonology, employs the lexical system. 
 Initially, an entry in a reading lexicon which matches the sequence of letters that one has detected is located. 
 The reading lexicon (or &bquo;visual input lexicon&equo; as it is sometimes known) contains our knowledge of written English word forms. 
 It is built up as a result of encountering these words in print as one is learning to read, though of course new word forms will be added throughout adult life as they are encountered. 
 This whole-word visual representation is then used to address and so locate its associated pronunciation in a lexicon of spoken word forms known as the speech output lexicon. 
 It is known as a speech output  system because there is evidence that a quite separate lexicon is involved in speech perception. 
 A pronunciation is addressed either with or without the mediation of the semantic system &mdash; our store of word meanings. 
 The fundamental difference between the two  routes, then, is that a pronunciation is either built up from sublexical components (&bquo;assembled&equo; phonology) or looked up as a whole (&bquo;addressed&equo; phonology). 
 This model has been extremely successful in enabling us to understand acquired dyslexia. 
 Acquired dyslexia involves a loss of reading ability as a result of brain injury. 
 This contrasts with developmental dyslexia which is an impairment, possibly congenital, in learning to read in the first place. 
 The model can explain a pattern of acquired dyslexia known as surface dyslexia  which is   characterized by poor reading of irregularly spelled words such as &bquo;yacht&equo; or &bquo;colonel&equo;. 
 These words tend to be read as if they were regular. 
 So &bquo;colonel&equo; might be read COLL-OH-NELL. 
 In one memorable instance, a patient pronounced &bquo;LISTEN&equo; as &bquo;LISTON&equo; and responded &bquo;that's the famous boxer&equo; (Marshall and Newcombe, 1973). 
 Despite their problems with irregular words, however, these patients can produce a plausible pronunciation of unfamiliar non-words (&bquo;blasp&equo;, for example). 
 What might be responsible for such an unusual pattern of performance? 
 This impairment can be explained in a straightforward manner if one assumes that damage has occurred to the part of the reading system that involves addressed  phonology. 
 This would mean that the patient is heavily reliant on assembled phonology . 
 This allows them to generate a plausible pronunciation for a non-word like &bquo;blasp&equo;, but means that they cannot pronounce many irregular words correctly. 
 Consequently, words like &bquo;colonel&equo; or &bquo;yacht&equo; are pronounced as if they were non-words. 
 The success of the model does not end there. 
 Following the discovery of surface dyslexia, it became clear that there should also exist another form of acquired dyslexia in which the ability to use assembled phonology was lost, while the ability to read a word via addressed phonology was intact. 
 This pattern had never been noticed before, but as soon as researchers started looking for it, several case studies of what is now known as phonological dyslexia  were reported in rapid succession in the early 1980s. 
 In cases of phonological dyslexia, the patient finds it almost impossible to read any word with which he or she was unfamiliar prior to brain injury. 
 However they can still read a very high percentage of pre-morbidly familiar words accurately, regardless of their spelling. 
 This pattern of performance suggests that these patients find it difficult to assemble a pronunciation, but they can continue to read familiar words because the lexical system, utilizing addressed phonology, is still working effectively. 
 This means that they are able to retrieve the appropriate pronunciation of a word as a whole from the speech output lexicon. 
 The dual-route model of reading is thus able not only to explain an existing set of data within a simple theoretical model, it also successfully pinpointed the existence of an entirely new type of acquired dyslexia. 
 Moreover, a closer look at individual patients provides support for what was said about the heterogeneity of groups at the start of this section. 
 So, the more that surface dyslexics are studied, the more it becomes obvious that the condition fractionates; there are important differences between individual surface dyslexics. 
 These differences can also be accommodated by the dual route model.  
 For example, one surface dyslexic can accurately define the irregular words that he regularizes in pronunciation tasks (for instance, pronouncing &bquo;colonel&equo; as &bquo;COL-OH-NELL&equo;). 
 His problem is therefore at the level of the speech output lexicon. 
 Another, who has problems in understanding speech as well as problems in understanding print, has an impairment at the semantic level. 
 Yet another patient's problems are at the level of the visual input lexicon itself. 
 A different patient correctly reads irregular words aloud but fails to retrieve their meaning, responding for example to a word on a card with: &bquo;HYENA, what the heck is that?&equo; 
 (Schwartz, Saffran and Marin, 1980). 
 This patient has lost the semantic representations for many words (the brain's store of meanings), but retains the link between the visual input and speech output lexicons. 
 In addition, Coltheart (1985) argues that other patients have impairments to the assembled phonology system. 
 One patient pronounces every letter in a word separately, which suggests a problem of graphemic parsing. 
 Another patient could name letters but could not sound them out, suggesting a problem at the level of grapheme to phoneme assignment. 
 I have gone into such detail about individual patients to try to convince you first, that it can be misleading to categorize patients too narrowly into groups, and second, that the dual-route model I described can accommodate a wide variety of data from different individual cases. 
 There is an equally important additional point that I want to make. 
 Since brain damage can produce these very precise differences between patients, it is difficult to avoid the conclusion that there is one part of the brain that has the precise function of carrying out each piece of information processing that is specified within the cognitive model. 
 It seems to me to be perverse in the extreme to attempt to resist the claim that the brain is literally carrying out these functions. 
 Cognitive neuropsychology thus provides powerful evidence that the level of analysis which functionalists use to describe brain processes is the correct one. 
 Models of face processing 
 Finally, I want to move from cognitive models of word recognition to cognitive models of face recognition. 
 This is because I believe that one of the basic assumptions of functionalism can be successfully illustrated, and alternatives to functionalism can be successfully confronted, by a careful examination of the effects of brain injury on face processing tasks. 
 According to functionalism, it is useful to categorize environmental stimuli on the basis of what they mean to a subject rather than on the  basis of their gross physical characteristics. 
 In other words, when it comes to an attempt to understand how someone is likely to respond to a stimulus, a description of the stimulus in terms of its simple physical dimensions is not going to be of any value. 
 No laws of behaviour are going to be formulated which are in any way dependent on the basic physical characteristics of a stimulus. 
 One might think that radical behaviourists such as Skinner would advocate the classification of stimuli along purely physical dimensions. 
 However Skinner (1957) writes of verbal behaviour as being &bquo;under the control of extremely subtle properties&equo; of a stimulus, but never clarifies what this might mean. 
 This is one of the reasons why Chomsky (1959) was able to launch such a devastating attack on radical behaviourism. 
 The inadequacy of conceptualizing stimuli in purely physical terms is neatly illustrated in a study by Campbell, Landis and Regard (1986). 
 They compared the performance of two patients on a lip-reading task and on a task which required analysis of facial expression. 
 One of the patients could not categorize the expression on faces that she was shown in photographs in terms of whether the expression was one of happiness, anger, surprise and so on. 
 However, she was  able to judge the sounds that were being mouthed by faces in photographs, and showed other evidence of normal lip-reading abilities. 
 By contrast, the other patient (known as &bquo;T&equo;), was able to judge facial expression normally but had lost the ability to lip-read. 
 At first sight, the reader might doubt whether even people without  brain injury usually possess significant lip-reading skills. 
 In fact, though, McGurk and MacDonald (1976) have shown the extent to which we use information about the position of a speaker's lips to help us recognise spoken words. 
 They showed, for instance, that if you look at someone saying &bquo;ga&equo; on a piece of film with the sound being removed and replaced by the sound &bquo;ba&equo;, then subjects will actually report hearing the sound &bquo;da&equo;. 
 Patient &bquo;T&equo; was not susceptible to the McGurk effect. 
 It is important to remember just how similar the physical features are that one must respond to in facial speech and facial expression judgements. 
 In both cases it is the position of the lips that conveys much of the vital information. 
 If it is the simple physical characteristics of a stimulus that play the key role in generalizations about behaviour, then we might expect to find patients who have lost the ability to lip-read and lost the ability to judge expression, but not patients who have lost only one of these two abilities while retaining the other. 
 According to the functionalist, of course, facial expression and lip-reading are likely to be dealt with by distinct parts of the information-processing system because the nature of  the information that they convey is so different. 
 Therefore the dissociation which Campbell and her colleagues have demonstrated between lip-reading and expression analysis makes perfect sense from a functionalist perspective. 
 Phenomenology 
 I now turn to a consideration of some implications of the cognitive neuropsychology of face recognition for phenomenology &mdash; an approach to the mind and mental phenomena that gives prominence to introspectible &bquo;phenomena&equo; understood as acts of consciousness and their immediate objects. 
 Phenomenologists such as Dreyfus (1972) argue that the level of explanation utilized in cognitive science does not truly exist. 
 The physical brain and the world of introspectible phenomenal experience are all that there really is: &bquo;no cognitive psychologist has succeeded in defining another sort of input between these two which would provide the ultimate bits of information to which rules are applied&equo; (p. 199). 
 My favourite phenomenological quote, however, comes from Jennings (1986): 
 &hellip; social psychologists spent years conducting experiments to specify the exact parameters of a hypothetical motivational state called &bquo;cognitive dissonance&equo;&hellip; 
 Certainly, an enormous amount of unproductive work could have been saved if phenomenological analyses were first performed to &bquo;see&equo; if this supposed psychological state actually existed&hellip; (p. 1236). 
 One of the most remarkable findings to have emerged from contemporary cognitive neuropsychology is the demonstration that patients can show evidence of covert recognition of faces that were known pre-morbidly, in the absence of any conscious awareness that the face is familiar. 
 For instance, the patient PH (Young and De Haan, 1988) shows no overt recognition of faces. 
 When he is shown a pair of faces and has to decide which of the two is a celebrity, he performs at chance level, even though he performs almost as well as normal subjects on this task when the faces are replaced by their names. 
 In other situations, however, PH's pattern of responding makes it clear that he is recognizing familiar faces at an unconscious level. 
 The clearest example of this is PH's performance in priming tasks (Young, Hellawell and De Haan, 1988). 
 Associative priming is a well known phenomenon in cognitive psychology. 
 If one has to identify a stimulus &mdash; for instance a word - then one can accomplish this more quickly if presentation of the word is immediately preceded by an associated word or picture. 
 For instance , when subjects have to decide whether certain names are familiar or not (say, Oliver Hardy) they respond more quickly if they are shown, a few tenths of seconds earlier, a picture of a person who is associated with the target name (Stan Laurel). 
 Now, the remarkable finding is that PH shows exactly the same pattern. 
 He can identify a familiar name more quickly if it is preceded by an associated face, even though he does not report finding any face familiar. 
 What is more, he shows every bit as much priming from these unrecognized faces as he does from names (which, of course, he can  recognize overtly). 
 These data are of great theoretical significance within cognitive neuropsychology. 
 For instance the strength of the priming effect suggests that covert recognition reflects the otherwise intact operation of the normal face recognition system when it is cut off from some centre of consciousness (Young and De Haan, 1988) rather than the operation of a separate, subsidiary face recognition system. 
 This in turn opens up some fascinating questions about the role of consciousness itself in memory and perception. 
 What I want to emphasize here is the impact of these findings for a phenomenologist. 
 If all that exists in reality are low-level physical processes in the brain on the one hand, and the high-level products of phenomenological awareness on the other, then how is PH's covert recognition of faces to be conceptualized? 
 You could ask PH to introspect into the contents of his phenomenological awareness when he is looking at faces for as long as you liked, but there would be no insight that any recognition is occurring. 
 That PH is genuinely recognizing faces, however, cannot be seriously questioned. 
 This pattern of findings would appear to be impossible to accommodate from the viewpoint of phenomenology. 
 As Bauer put it in a recent BBC television discussion of covert recognition, &bquo;Our normal experience of perception, of seeing objects or faces as an all or none process, is a trick that the brain plays on us&equo;. 
 It is a trick that should no longer fool anyone except phenomenologists. 
 Finally, as in the discussion of reading, I could point to other patients who have a wide variety of different face processing problems. 
 For example, some have difficulties in retrieving semantic information about people (for example their occupation), some have difficulties specific to the retrieval of people's names, and some can remember old faces but cannot learn new ones. 
 The problems which these and other patients suffer can mostly be explained in terms of detailed functional models of face processing such as that proposed by Bruce and Young (1986), in the same way that patients' different reading problems could be explained by Coltheart (1985).  
 Bearing all this in mind, what are we to make of Searle's (1984) claim that the brain does not identify faces via information processing of the kind described in cognitive models and that, as far as the cognitive sciences are concerned, there may simply be no story to tell? 
 His suggestion is that &bquo;facial recognition may be as simple and as automatic as making footprints in the sand&equo;. 
 If this were true, then it is hard to see how impairments in face processing could be explained so economically in terms of the cognitive modules that functional models contain. 
 If these information-processing modules exist only in the minds of cognitive scientists, rather than in the minds of the subjects they study, then breakdowns in face recognition or word recognition should either be all-or-none, or else they should be extremely difficult to conceptualize within the vocabulary of cognitive psychology. 
 In fact, the striking dissociations that one can observe in neuropsychological patients show us instead that skills which seem so simple and automatic in the course of everyday life are in fact comprised of a large number of functional sub-components, any of which may be impaired by brain injury. 
 Work such as that of Young et al (1988) has even shown us how something that was traditionally assumed to be as intangible and subjective as the nature of conscious awareness itself can be disrupted by physical damage to the brain and can be successfully studied by the observational techniques of cognitive psychology. 
 The fact is that cognitive neuropsychologists have significantly increased our understanding of the effects of brain injury on behaviour by conceptualizing mental processes in purely functional terms without regard to their subjective qualities or to physiology. 
 This seems to me to represent good grounds for believing that functionalism itself may well be true. 
 It is time for certain philosophers to come and take a hard look at the data which we have collected before they dismiss our models and our philosophical assumptions so glibly. 
 Suggested Reading 
 Although neither have been cited directly in the text, the philosophical ideas in this chapter have been heavily influenced by the work of Jerry Fodor and Zenon Pylyshyn. 
 Fodor (1981) provides a very clear description of functionalism, and his book The Modularity of Mind  discusses some of the philosophical issues surrounding cognitive neuropsychology. 
 Pylyshyn (1984)  contains an important account of the relationship between cognitive psychology and artificial intelligence, and Pylyshyn (1973) contains an interesting discussion of the differences between cognitive science and phenomenology. 
 A very clear introduction to current work in cognitive neuropsychology is provided by Ellis and Young (1988). 
 Churchland's Matter and Consciousness  is an equally lucid introduction to the philosophy of mind.    
 A Critique of Neuromythology 
 Raymond Tallis 
 Introduction 
 One of man's great intellectual adventures &mdash; the exploration and understanding of his own nervous system &mdash; is progressing at a rate undreamed of only a few decades ago. 
 There are many reasons for this. 
 First of all, there have been important advances in experimental methods: single cell recordings with exquisitely fine electrodes; novel methods of imaging the internal structure of neurons and the connections between them; cell culture techniques permitting the growth and development of nervous systems to be studied in great detail; and sophisticated computational and statistical analysis of data permitting better mathematical modelling of large and small scale events in the nervous system and its functional connections. 
 Secondly, there have been important conceptual advances. 
 Since Hubel and Wiesel began publishing their work in the late 1950s, there has been an increasing appreciation of the way in which nervous systems are so structured as to ensure that certain events of special importance to the organism have an increased likelihood of triggering activity in the relevant places. 
 Alongside this, there has been growing awareness of the plasticity of the nervous system and of the extent to which the &bquo;hard-wiring&equo; of the wetware of the brain is itself modulated by the brain's own experience. 
 At a microscopic level, the range of factors and substances behaved to influence the interactions between neurones has been greatly widened. 
 And there has been a remarkable interchange of ideas between computational theorists and neuroscientists, in which attempts to create computer models of neural function have not only generated powerful new tools for the interpreting of the brain but have also fed back into computer theory and practice. 
 At every level &mdash; from the simple oligosynaptic circuits involved in the tropisms of primitive organisms to the complex neural activity implicit in human perception &mdash; computational models dominate scientific thought. 
 The converging conceptual worlds of computational theory and neuroscience are expressed in the huge and powerful &bquo;neural nets&equo; of parallel distributed processors and in the emergent science of cognitive neurobiology in which the brain  is approached as an immensely complex information processor (see Chapter 7). 
 A third reason for the accelerating rate of advance in neuroscience is that there are simply larger numbers of better funded people engaged in research in this field today than ever before. 
 And they come from diverse backgrounds: not only physiologists but also physicists, molecular biologists and mathematicians are attracted into neuroscience which threatens to displace physics and even molecular biology as the queen of the sciences. 
 It would be perverse, then, to deny that very exciting things have been happening and it is no business of this chapter to disparage these remarkable advances in understanding of the brain. 
 My concern here is with the mythology that has accompanied these advances; the metaphysical claims implicit &mdash; and not infrequently explicit &mdash; in the way they have been described. 
 I am concerned, that is to say, with neuromythology. 
 The founding myth of neuromythology is that our more detailed knowledge of the nervous system has resulted &mdash; or very soon will result &mdash; in an increased understanding of the mind, indeed of the very nature of understanding itself. 
 If we do not yet have the solution to the problem of consciousness, we are at least working towards it within the right framework. 
 Any delay in arriving at a solution will be due not to our being on the wrong track but simply to the enormous complexity of the problem. 
 (We are frequently reminded that the brain has many millions of neurones and that these have many billions of connections). 
 When we have a complete account of the brain, we are assured, consciousness will be intellectually transparent and the mind will assume its rightful place as just another part of (physical) nature, obedient to the laws that hold sway elsewhere in the material universe. 
 This is the myth that I want to examine here. 
 Although the majority of scientists tend to be a little coy about metaphysical matters in their professional publications, they are often less so outside when writing elsewhere, being prone to describe the framework of presuppositions about perception within which they conduct their investigations as if it were a discovery in its own right and that &bquo;discovery&equo; an explanation of perception. 
 And although the majority of materialist philosophers base their belief in the neurophysiological theory of perception on arguments rather than observations, they are, nevertheless, greatly influenced by the apparent successes of neurophysiology. 
 The Materialist Theory of Perception 
 We may think of consciousness as having two components: sensation and perception on the one hand and willing or agency on the other; or input and output. 
 For the purposes of the present discussion I  am going to confine myself to sensation and perception and ignore behaviour. 
 I do this not only because the issues are easier to grasp in the case of perception than in the case of voluntary movement, but also because neurophysiologists of movement are less prone to wild claims than neurophysiologists of perception: most of the former would admit that we do not yet have the faintest idea how voluntary activity is able to utilize or over-ride reflex pathways; how we mobilize so-called &bquo;motor programmes&equo; when we need them; or even where in the nervous system voluntary movement is initiated. 
 The metaphysical framework for the neurophysiology of perception is provided by the Causal Theory of Perception  (henceforth referred to as the CTP). 
 This goes back at least as far as Aristotle. 
 According to Aristotle, perceiving an object is the result of being acted upon by it: objects of perception, acting via a medium of perception, causally affect the perceiver's sensory apparatus. 
 As a result, the apparatus &bquo;receives the form of the object without its matter&equo;; the change in the apparatus is  perception. 
 The CTP is susceptible of a materialist interpretation and this, in its neurophysiological version, is what I am going to focus on. 
 This explicitly materialist framework of contemporary neurophysiology originated much later than Aristotle. 
 One of its earliest expressions is to be found in Thomas Hobbes's Leviathan , published in 1651: 
 The cause of sense is the external body, or object, which presseth the organ proper to each sense, either immediately, as in taste or touch; or, mediately, as in seeing, hearing or smelling. 
 The external object 
 worketh on the eyes, ears and other parts of a man's body; and by diversity of working produceth diversity of experience. 
 We experience the world in virtue of the fact that the contents of the world impinge  on us. 
 Our bodies and the world bump into one another and there is an exchange of energy between them. 
 This exchange of energy explains how we perceive the world. 
 This is now so widely accepted that it seems less like a theory, or even a theoretical framework, than a piece of common sense; and in one form or another it encompasses the views of the majority of Anglo-American philosophers and neuroscientists about the basis of consciousness or, at the very least, of perception. 
 Although some philosophers and psychologists would emphasize the role of action in controlling perception (see chapter 2) and some talk of &bquo;top down&equo;  constraints on the interpretation of the perceived, the causal role of incident energy remains fundamental and the materialist version of the CTP essentially unchallenged. 
 The neurophysiological  version of the CTP, with which we are concerned here, holds that perception is the result of the constant interaction between the material world and the nervous system. 
 In particular, perceptual awareness, and so consciousness itself, is identified with certain events taking place in the higher reaches of the central nervous system where a chain of events, collectively described as sensory processing, and originating from the object that is perceived, reaches a terminus. 
 For example, I perceive this flower in front of me because light which has been reflected from it impinges on my retina and causes trains of nerve impulses to travel along the visual pathways to the visual cortex. 
 The events in the visual cortex correspond in some way (see later) to perception of the flower. 
 It is out of such events that the visual field, indeed the visual world, is composed. 
 And these, along with other cortical events relating to other sensory pathways, are the basis of consciousness and of our state of being &bquo;worlded&equo;. 
 In other words, according to the neurophysiological CTP, sensation, perception, experience, consciousness, are intimately related to, or even boil down to, large numbers of trains or patterns of nerve impulses. 
 We perceive what is &bquo;out there&equo; or what is &bquo;around us&equo; as a result of the transfer of energy from objects or events to specialized parts of the body known collectively as &bquo;the sensory system&equo;. 
 I shall argue that this framework is explanatorily inadequate and that the inadequacy is inherited by theories developed within it. 
 Such theories contribute nothing to explaining the mystery of perception. 
 At best they re-describe perception in a manner that actually generates more problems than it solves. 
 Neuroscience, which depends upon a materialist CTP for the explanatory force of its explanations of the mind, cannot, therefore, sustain any claim to be explaining or advancing our understanding of the basis of perception, or of the mind. 
 The Neurophysiology of Perception: Exposition 
 The main task of sensory neurophysiology has been to establish in more precise detail how &bquo;the diversity of working produceth diversity of experience&equo; &mdash; the modern term for which is &bquo;coding of sensory information&equo;. 
 The framework for the investigation of &bquo;sensory coding&equo; was established in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, when  the business of explaining perception was transformed into the more specific project of correlating the physical properties of perceived objects and events with patterns of activity in the nervous system and the latter with the subjective properties of the experience:  
 It was early appreciated that, apart from, say, minor variations in the speed of conduction, the impulses in all nerve fibres have essentially identical characteristics. 
 This was explicitly recognized by the early twentieth century physiologists who saw their fundamental task as that of discovering how the infinite variety of the perceived world could be reflected in, or reconstructed in, the rather monotonous nervous system. 
 With the advent of digital computers and the development of information theory in the 1940s and 1950s, this job was interpreted as being that of finding out how the nervous system &bquo;encoded&equo; reality in a digital form. 
 The task of the nervous system was seen to be a computational one. 
 It would not be appropriate here to attempt the impossible task of summarizing modern sensory physiology but it is necessary to discuss a few basic principles and laws. 
 We can think of experience as being differentiated both qualitatively  and quantitatively . 
 For neurophysiologists and neuropsychologists, the way forward in understanding perception has been to correlate these dimensions of experience with, firstly, the material properties of the experienced object or event (usually regarded as the &bquo;stimulus&equo;) and, secondly, the patterns of discharges in the sensory system. 
 Qualitative Aspects of Experience 
 The quality  &mdash; or modality  &mdash; of the experience depends less upon the quality of energy reaching the nervous system than upon which parts of the sensory system are activated: stimulation of the retinal receptors causes an experience of light; stimulation of the receptors in the inner ear gives rise to the experience of sound; and so on. 
 Muller's nineteenth-century &bquo; doctrine of specific energies &equo; formalized the ordinary observation that different sense organs are sensitive to different physical properties of the world and that when they are stimulated, sensations specific to those organs are experienced. 
 It was proposed that there are endings (or receptors) within the nervous system which are attuned to specific types of energy, For example, retinal receptors in the eye respond to light energy, cochlear endings in the ear to vibrations in the air, and so on. 
 Of course, high  energy stimulation even of the wrong kind may stimulate a sensory ending; for example, excessive pressure on the eyeball will produce a sensation of light. 
 Contrariwise, over-intense stimulation of the appropriate kind will evoke pain. 
 These are, however, abnormal situations; for ordinary perception, the doctrine of specific energies holds. 
 This early framework for sensory physiology &mdash; of a piece with the Hobbesian idea of &bquo;the organ proper to each sense&equo; &mdash; has undergone a good deal of refinement. 
 Within the cochlea, for example, it has been shown that there are endings that respond preferentially to sounds of high rather than low pitch. 
 More centrally, in the cerebral cortex the afferent fibres from groups of receptors are &bquo;wired together&equo; so that more complexly patterned stimuli &mdash; such as edges or lines of a certain inclination &mdash; may preferentially elicit neural activity and the corresponding subjective experience. 
 The work of Hubel and Wiesel, in particular, put the conception of neurones as &bquo;feature detectors&equo;, rather than simply energy detectors, on the map, supporting the idea that for each cell in the cortex there was a specific pattern of excitation that would reliably excite it. 
 Each cell had its own stimulus requirements and when it became active this said something about the nature of the event or object in its own part of the visual field. 
 It would not be too great a distortion of the facts to say that the main thrust of twentieth century sensory physiology has been to move the application of the doctrine of specific energies inwards from the sensory ending towards and into the cortex. 
 Quantitative Aspects of Experience 
 There are three fundamental dimensions of quantity  in experience: (a) intensity; (b) (spatial) extensity; and (c) duration. 
 At a neurophysiological level, the intensity of an experience is typically reflected in the number of neurones activated (the phenomenon of &bquo;recruitment&equo;) and, more specifically, in the firing frequency of the relevant neurones. 
 Extensity (for example the size of a patch of light) usually correlates with the number and spatial distribution of receptors activated. 
 Finally, duration is correlated with the period of time for which the relevant neurones are active. 
 (I am leaving aside phenomena such as accommodation, whereby a constant stimulus when sustained may activate the nervous system progressively less intensively, with a corresponding reduction in the perceived intensity of the stimulus. 
 These, and other features of &bquo;adaptation&equo;, do not invalidate the underlying conceptual framework.) 
 The earliest psychophysical observations demonstrated a correlation between the intensity of the physical stimulus and  subjective reports of the intensity of the resultant experience. 
 These were eventually formalized in the Weber-Fechner law which reported a quantitative relationship between stimulus and subjective experience, the sensation increasing in proportion to the logarithm of the magnitude of the physical stimulus. 
 A quantitative correlation between the objective intensity of stimulus and the pattern of neural activity was subsequently demonstrated by physiologists recording from individual fibres. 
 Since the work of S. S. Stevens in the 1930s and later, it has been recognized that, although the Weber-Fechner Law holds for many sorts of sensory experience, the exponent varies widely; nevertheless, the principle of a quantitative correlation between external stimulus, neural activity and experienced sensation remains intact and now appears to be well-established. 
 So much for the basic laws. 
 The repeated confirmation of the correlation between the physical characteristics of the stimulus and the characteristics of the neural activity it triggers, and between the characteristics of the stimulus and that of the subjective sensation, has encouraged the belief that our sensations are in some sense to be understood in terms of a set of stimulation levels (spiking frequencies) in the appropriate sensory pathways. 
 And it would seem that physiologists &mdash; working within the common-sense assumptions that we experience the world because it impinges upon our bodies and that what we experience is what, directly or indirectly, impinges on our bodies in the form of transferred energy &mdash; have made considerable progress in explaining how &bquo;the diversity of working produceth the diversity of experience&equo;. 
 Or have they? 
 In the discussion that follows, I shall question whether: 
 (a) scientific, and in particular physiological, observations have provided any additional, independent evidence in support of the impingement theory of perception/experience; 
 (b) the impingement theory, with its physiological embellishments, goes any way towards explaining perception. 
 One might expect, a priori, that no empirical  (that is perception-based) observations could provide evidence in support of a metaphysical theory of perception; that perceptions would not enable us to get to the root of perception. 
 By unmasking the circularity of physiological explanations of perception that have been developed within the framework of the idea of the &bquo;impingement&equo;, I shall show that the a priori  principle is upheld.  
 The Neurophysiology of Perception: Critique 
 The Psychophysical Laws 
 According to the Muller doctrine, sensory endings are particularly sensitive to certain types of energy &mdash; light energy in the case of retinal endings, sound energy in the case of cochlear endings, and so on - and that when they, or their central connections, are stimulated a specific modality of sensation is experienced. 
 According to the Weber-Fechner law, there is a correlation between the intensity of the energy incident on the sense ending and the magnitude of the corresponding subjective experience. 
 These laws seem a) to provide empirical support for the neurophysiological account of perception and b) to contribute to its explanatory force. 
 I will argue, however, that a) and b) are apparent rather than real.  
 a) Do the laws provide empirical support for the neurophysiological account of perception? 
 Both laws are derived from observations and there can be no doubt about their empirical credentials. 
 Are those empirical credentials sufficient, however, to sustain the metaphysical implications it is thought that the laws have? 
 Empirical observations may generate laws that correlate one type of experience with another; but can they take us &bquo;beneath&equo; experience to its basis? 
 It seems unlikely that experience can take us outside of the closed circle of experience to reveal that upon which experience &mdash; experience in general, rather than particular experience &mdash; is based. 
 Yet some writers seem to think that the laws do just that; and that the quantitative observations encompassed in the laws take us beyond (subjective) experience because they are based upon objective measures of physical energy, utilizing scientific instruments. 
 The objectivity of the psychophysical laws &mdash; and the escape from the closed circle of experience &mdash; is more apparent than real. 
 For the scales on the &bquo;objective&equo; measuring devices used to derive the data upon which the laws are founded are not validated independently of subjective experience. 
 In the final analysis, the scientific estimate of the intensity of light, for example, is rooted in subjective experience of brightness. 
 Our objective measures of light intensity would be discarded if they universally  gave answers that contradicted our subjective experiences. 
 Scientific measurements may &bquo;correct&equo;, &bquo;reform&equo; or at least question individual unaided observations but there cannot be a systematic, universal discrepancy. 
 The cash value of scientific observations in this context must therefore be based upon subjective experience and cannot be greater than the cash value of the  latter; for it is subjective experience that, ultimately, validates our objective scales of energy intensity. 
 We may use physical methods of measuring light intensity that are apparently independent of our subjective experience &mdash; for instance photosensitive cells &mdash; but these are accepted because they correlate to a greater or lesser degree, under normal circumstances, with subjective experiences of brightness. 
 If there were simply no correlation whatsoever between the electrical output of a photo-electric cell and some other measure of light intensity directly or indirectly related to experience, it would not have been accepted as a way of measuring light intensity. 
 However indirectly related to sensory experience a laboratory quantification of a particular form of energy may be, in the end the rate of exchange between one form of energy and another &mdash; the way in which we compare the quantity of one with the quantity of another - reposes upon the gold standard of subjectivity. 
 The observation that a sensory system has a relatively low threshold for the form of energy which it transforms into experience is not only a pre-scientific empirical observation but also one that science could not reform &mdash; if reform were necessary &mdash; nor independently validate. 
 It would seem therefore that the contingent or empirical links uncovered by experimental science between the nature of the stimulus and the intensity and distribution of neural activity on the one hand and between the properties of the stimulus and those of the evoked sensation on the other are not based on discoveries that go beyond, or arise outside of, ordinary experience. 
 Ultimately, the two variables of impinging stimulus and evoked sensation are internally rather than externally related; for our estimate of the properties of the impinging stimulus &mdash; and the decision as to whether or not those properties &bquo;justify&equo; the sensation they give rise to &mdash; is based upon the norms of, necessarily subjective, experience. 
 The psychophysical laws relate sets of experiences, rather than relating experiences to something external to experience. 
 Interestingly, the psychophysical laws may be even more entrained in subjectivity than I have suggested. 
 Recent work has confined that it is not possible to measure intensity of subjective sensation in a way that is distinct from and independent of measurement of the physical stimulus from which it is derived; that Fechner's logarithmic transform exists only as a mathematical construction to link reports of sensations with measurements of stimuli; and an experimental subject's conformity to Stevens' power law depends on his getting the experiment &bquo;right&equo;. 
 Even if the laws of psychophysics are empirical laws in the sense of correlating one type of observation or experience with another,  they are not  laws about the relationship between experience and that which lies outside of experience and is its trigger or basis &mdash; &bquo;pure&equo;, objective, material energy. 
 Psychophysical laws, in other words, provide no independent evidence for a physical basis of perception. 
 To assert this is merely to reiterate a point that should be obvious: that science, however sophisticated its instrumentation, cannot generate observations that somehow enable us to look at the relationship between experience and the world as it were from outside of experience.  
 (b) The lack of explanatory force of the laws 
 The lack of explanatory force of neurophysiological and psychophysical observations is explicitly admitted by some scientists. 
 It has been well expressed by the biologist Richard Dawkins: 
 The sensation of seeing is for us very different from the sensation of hearing, but this cannot be directly due to the physical differences between light and sound. 
 Both light and sound are, after all, translated&hellip; by the respective sense organs into the same kind of nerve impulse. 
 It is impossible to tell, from the physical attributes of a nerve impulse, whether it is conveying information about light, about sound or about smell. 
 A similar point was made by the seventeenth-century philosopher John Locke, who saw it as an insoluble mystery. 
 Dawkins, however, feels he has an answer. 
 He asserts, rather cryptically, that 
 It is because we internally use  our visual information and our sound information in different ways and for different purposes that the sensations of seeing and hearing are so different. 
 It is not directly because of the physical differences between light and sound 
 This is not a very convincing escape from the circularity of the psychophysical laws. 
 On the contrary, it exposes the explanatory weakness of the Muller Doctrine, if it is offered as an advance in our understanding of the origin of different modalities of sensation, of why the world feels as it does; and, even more, if it is offered as an account of our being able to feel the world at all. 
 The Doctrine is at best a circular re-statement of the obvious: Why did I experience those vibrations in the air as sounds? 
 Because they stimulated my auditory, rather than my visual, system. 
 But why do those particular nerve endings count as part of the auditory  system? 
 Because they are connected with the area of the cortex that  is designated the auditory cortex. 
 But why is that particular area of the cortex designated the auditory  cortex? 
 Because it is concerned with the reception of sound. 
 But what evidence is there that this bit of the cortex is  concerned with the reception of sound? 
 Well, there is the fact that it is connected to sensory endings that are designed specifically to respond to vibrations in the air. 
 And so we are back to the beginning&hellip; 
 The circularity is obvious: the destination of the particular sensory pathway defines/explains the starting point, the starting point defines/explains the destination. 
 Metaphysical Problems 
 We are now close to the fundamental inadequacies of the neurophysiological explanation of perception. 
 Consider the physiologist's intuition that an increased neuronal firing frequency explains  increased intensity of experience. 
 This depends for its prima facie  plausibility upon the assumption that there can, should or must be a correlation between the quantity of energy incident on nervous tissue and the intensity of experience. 
 But to begin  with this assumption is to by-pass, rather than explain, the mystery of perception as it presents itself to us if we assume that perception occurs because the perceived object impinges directly or indirectly upon the nervous system. 
 The mystery that it by-passes is that of how energy is transformed into sensation, experience, information  or whatever. 
 Only when that  has been explained might the Weber-Fechner Law and the Muller doctrine &mdash; connecting the quantity and modality of energy with the quantity and modality of sensation &mdash; have any explanatory value. 
 The specific observations of neurophysiologists, correlating stimulus properties, neural activities and the characteristics of subjective reports of sensation, contribute to explaining how &bquo;the diversity of working produceth a diversity of experience&equo; only if we have already explained how &bquo;working&equo; produceth &bquo;experience&equo; at all . 
 Or how energy impinging on the nervous system is transformed into information in, or addressed to, the nervous system. 
 I would argue that physiologists of perception, working within the framework created by the Muller Doctrine and the Weber-Fechner Law are in a position of dotting the i's and crossing the t's in a text that has not yet been written. 
 This is only the beginning of the neurophysiologist's metaphysical problems. 
 For the materialist version of the CTP is beset with many difficulties that ultimately make its claim to have explanatory force somewhat vacuous. 
 I should like to deal briefly with the most important of these.   
 a) How do the neural events in the brain actually relate to perceptions? 
 There are several rival accounts of this, some of them not compatible with materialism. 
 For example, substance  and bundle  (or event ) dualism assert that the neural events cause  the perceptual events. 
 In other words, the perception is a mental effect  that is at one step in the causal chain beyond the physical events. 
 Since the causal chain passes through perception and on to the rest of the nervous system, perhaps triggering action, it must become physical again. 
 So one is left with the impossible task of explaining why a perfectly respectable causal chain should &bquo;go mental&equo; for a while and then, recovering its non-senses, should return to being purely physical. 
 Substance and bundle dualism for this and other reasons are rather unpopular. 
 Property  dualism holds that the perception and the neural events which are its physical basis are simply different aspects, properties or attributes of the same (physical) events: what the physiologist observes on examining the brain and what the owner of the examined brain feels are two aspects of the same event. 
 This interpretation in no way diminishes the enigma of the relationship between electrochemical events in the nervous system and conscious experiences. 
 For the idea of an object or an event with two metaphysically different aspects &mdash; with, as it were, an unextended mental front end and an extended physical rear end - is deeply puzzling. 
 Moreover, rather as substance dualism tends to do, it seems to undermine the causal role of consciousness in, for example, bringing about or influencing actions. 
 For the causal relations of events would be just the same irrespective of whether or not the causal chain temporarily took on a mental aspect (as in property dualism) or (as in substance dualism) &bquo;went mental&equo; for a while. 
 A further telling argument against the dual aspect theory - and one that has been rarely noticed &mdash; is that &bquo;aspects&equo; are relative to viewpoints; in other words, they emerge posterior to perceptions. 
 They cannot, therefore, be invoked to explain perceptions, even less the manner in which perception is related to matter. 
 Most scientists implicitly, and the many philosophers explicitly, prefer identity  theories. 
 These assert that perceptions are strictly  identical with certain events in the nervous system. 
 Such theories have to face the obvious objection that brain processes and mental phenomena seem utterly unalike. 
 For example, one can say of a brain process that it occupies a particular point in space or that it can be displayed on an oscilloscope screen; whereas neither of these things could be said of, for example, the subjective sensation of the colour blue or of the thought that I hate Monday mornings. 
 It is difficult  to comprehend an object that is utterly unlike itself. 
 This, in fact insuperable, difficulty is said to be overcome by proposing that mental phenomena and brain processes are the same stuff viewed within different theoretical frameworks. 
 But this apparent escape is only another version of the dual aspect theory and inherits the latter's problems.  
 b) How/why does the causal chain linking object and perception have a beginning and an end? 
 The materialist versions of the CTP assume that there is a causal chain that begins with the perceived object and ends with the perception. 
 The perception then &bquo;reaches back&equo; to the perceived object. 
 Since this causal chain is but part of a boundless nexus of causal chains that originate before and outside the perceived object and end beyond the perceiving body, it is not very clear why the former should count as an &bquo;origin&equo;. 
 Why, in other words, should perception be of the perceived object rather than any other object in the causal chain further back in the causal chain; why every perception should not be of the Big Bang that started off the Universe. 
 Nor is it clear why the events in the cerebral cortex should count as a terminus; why they &mdash; rather than other events up- or down-stream &mdash; should constitute the perception. 
 The CTP proclaims that the link between the perceived object and the perception is just an ordinary bit of the great causal nexus of nature (it needs to believe this, as we shall see presently) and yet it is prepared to accept that this segment of the chain has a rather privileged status; at the very least, that it has a beginning and an end.  
 c) How does the nervous system construct stable objects out of transient events? 
 The neurophysiological CTP asserts that perception consists of neural events triggered by events in the perceived object. 
 The perceived world, however, seems to consist of stable objects as well as events occurring in them. 
 The CTP requires, therefore, that transient events triggering transient events should give rise the idea of (permanent) objects as well as that of transient events within them. 
 There is as yet no way of explaining how objects are constructed out of events; even less how the contrast between objects and events &mdash; one of the most pervasive features of everyday experience &mdash; is perceived.   
 d) The monotonous nervous system and the infinitely varied perceived world 
 As Dawkins pointed out in the passage quoted earlier, nerve impulses look pretty much the same whatever &bquo;information&equo; they are carrying. 
 There is a sharp contrast between the monotony and similarity of the event in the nervous system and the variety of the perceived world. 
 The perceived world is infinitely various, within and across modalities of sensation. 
 Moreover, there is a clear distinction between present and past perception (memory); between memory and thought; between passive and active states of mind (daydreaming versus active recall, association of ideas versus directed meditation); and between the content and the level of consciousness. 
 For causal theorists there are only nerve impulses, all of which are essentially the same. 
 Perception, that is to say, boils down to the passage of sodium, potassium and other ions across semi-permeable membranes. 
 It is legitimate, therefore, to ask what it is that is special about flea-bitten membranes that they should open up one object (the body) to all others, to a world. 
 That they should make of one body a site where the variousness of all other bodies is in some way received. 
 There are several responses to this puzzle. 
 They all involve the use of terms, or an appeal to concepts, that are illegitimate within the physicalist terms of reference of the neurophysiological CTP. 
 Yes, it will be conceded, there is  an apparent discrepancy between the rather simple nerve impulses nervous system and the complex representations of the world they afford us. 
 This discrepancy, however, disappears when we recognize that it is not in individual nerve impulses that we must seek our representations of the world, but in their patterns . 
 We must think of the nervous system encoding the perceived world; and in trying to understand this process we should consider not individual spikes but their potentially infinite combinations. 
 The monotony of the individual neurones is irrelevant; what matters is the infinite variety of their combinations, of their patterns, which will become evident when we look at the nervous system at the right level. 
 I shall deal with the language of neurophysiological description shortly. 
 However, it is necessary to say a word or two here to refute this seemingly compelling argument. 
 We are so used to hearing talk about the nervous system &bquo;encoding&equo; the outside world that it is easy to forget that this is a metaphor and it is one that has no place in serious philosophical discussion of the mind-body problem or the philosophy of perception. 
 The reason the coding metaphor has such currency in contemporary talk about perception is that it seems to suggest a way in which very simple and apparently homogenous  elements such as nerve impulses can generate the richness and variety of consciousness. 
 Consider morse code. 
 Using this very simple code, constructed out of dots and dashes, it is possible to encode a text of any degree of richness &mdash; even, for example, the works of Shakespeare. 
 We may imagine therefore that neural dots and dashes &mdash; trains of impulses &mdash; can encode the variousness of experience. 
 The analogy is attractive, but illegitimate. 
 For the richness of morse code is a borrowed richness. 
 First, it is parasitic, as all codes are, upon a primary, natural language. 
 The meanings of morse are borrowed from the meanings of, say, English and messages encoded in it are meaningful only when they are interpreted, that is, decoded. 
 Where is the decoder in the nervous system? 
 In so far as it &bquo;translates&equo; at all, the nervous system &bquo;translates&equo; only from nerve impulses into nerve impulses, from sodium fluxes into sodium fluxes. 
 This would not count as decoding unless muscular activity and other outputs were regarded as translations out of &bquo;impulses&equo; into an interpreted language. 
 But to interpret decoding in this way would be to espouse behaviourism and to by-pass consciousness altogether. 
 There is a second, yet more damaging, objection to the coding metaphor. 
 Even translation from morse into natural language does not take us all the way to consciousness; for, in the absence of consciousness, language is merely variegated sound, rather than the rich varieties of meaning that are embodied in, for example, Shakespeare's texts. 
 No one outside of the wilder sects of the artificial intelligence fraternity would suggest that a device that translated morse into natural language characters on the screen of a computer was releasing the consciousness implicit in morse. 
 Natural languages such as English in turn owe their meanings to the conscious experiences of language users. 
 Codes, in short, owe their meanings - and the variety that is constructed out of their monotonous elements - to consciousness. 
 If the nervous system, therefore, owes the richness of the experiences which its activity embodies to the complexity of its codes, it must, ultimately owe its consciousness &mdash; to consciousness; for this will be required ultimately to turn its codes into complex experienced meanings, into experiences.  
 e) The unities of consciousness 
 Neurophysiological accounts of consciousness fail to address the problem of the unities of human consciousness. 
 These unities are evident at different levels. 
 There is the unity of the moment: different tactile and proprioceptive sensations amount to a coherent body image; different visual sensations cohere to a visual field; and  sensations from different modalities converge to a general sensory field, an organized moment-by-moment presence of a world, so that the feeling in my hand as I hold a stone, the sight of the sea and the sound of the seagull behind me are all not merely present but co-present. 
 Beyond this, current sensations converge with knowledge and memory and desire to make sense of the experience of the present: I not only experience this object but I recognize it &mdash; as something of a certain kind; as yours, as mine, as something I have seen before; and it means something to me in terms of my appetites and needs and ambitions. 
 Beyond the unities of the present moment, there are unities over time. 
 There is a self that coheres over time, so that a person p 2  at time t 2  is in some sense identical to the person p 1  at time t 1 . 
 This identity operates at a much higher level than mere identity of the body or continuity of habits. 
 It is an explicit sense of continuing self which includes a sense of responsibility over time (&bquo;1 did that&equo;) and, beneath this, a deep sense of psychological continuity (&bquo;I remember having that experience&equo;, &bquo;I was there then&equo;). 
 Sensations and memories converge to create a continuing, if interrupted, sense of a coherent self. 
 This sense of self is quite robust: when we wake up, we not only remember what we know, but also who we are. 
 We are able to resume ourselves after sleep, after an alcoholic stupor, after an epileptic fit, after prolonged coma. 
 In the light of these unities, it seems necessary to postulate a systematic set of relationships between the patterns of memory and the sense of &bquo;1&equo;, the qualitative interior of mental experience. 
 The basis of these unities does not seem to lie within the nervous system as it is currently conceived. 
 Since Sherrington's classic The Integrative Action of the Nervous System , there has been much talk of &bquo;the integrative activity of the nervous system&equo;, based upon the convergence of nervous pathways. 
 But the scattered activity of different parts of the nervous system seems to converge only at the cost of merging, and so losing, the components that come together in the process of convergence, rather in the manner of snowflakes joining a drift. 
 There is no neurophysiological model of the kind of convergence that would seem to be necessary for the many different sensations of the moment to be brought into synthetic unity, without loss of their individual distinctiveness and specificity, into the instantaneous sense of &bquo;being here&equo;; or of the manner in which experience of many different moments can be synthesized into a sense of continuing self without those moments losing their separateness in memory. 
 As for the recovery of consciousness, or wakefulness, there is no imaginable physiology of this &bquo;light dawning over the whole&equo;. 
 Neural activity, triggered by a thousand  scattered occasions, temporally and spatially dispersed, has nothing within itself to create the basis of these fundamental unities of consciousness.  
 f) Intentionality 
 The final and the greatest problem of the neurophysiological version of the CTP (or, indeed, any version of the CTP), is that it cannot explain the intentionality or &bquo;aboutness&equo;  that connects the neural events with the object they are supposed to be perceptions of. 
 The causal theory of perception relates the object and contents of perception in two directions: there is an afferent limb connecting the object with the nervous system in which perception is generated; and an efferent limb in virtue of which the neural events &bquo;reach out to&equo; or &bquo;are about or of&equo; the object. 
 The efferent limb carries the intentionality or aboutness that is fundamental to perception:  
 It is clear that the inwardly-directed causal, connection does not explain the outwardly-directed intentional relation. 
 Intentionality is usually overlooked by causal theorists who tend to see their job as being to sort out the afferent limb. 
 It is therefore especially ironical that the neurophysiological CTP, which locates the basis of perception literally in the head, at a particular place away from the perceived object, actually sharpens the mystery of intentionality. 
 For nature, after all, offers no other examples of causal chains in which events causally downstream refer back to the objects that are involved in producing their causal ancestors. 
 The intentionality of perceptions &mdash; and indeed of other mental phenomena &mdash; makes them non-analogous to material phenomena outside of the nervous system. 
 And nothing that takes place within the nervous system can explain why this property of intentionality should emerge there.  
 The Attractions of the Materialist Causal Theory of Perception 
 If, as I have argued, neurophysiological explanations of mind explain nothing and if physiological observations give us no purchase on the essentially metaphysical question of the nature of mind, how has the myth become so powerful that many people within and outside the scientific community do believe that neurophysiology has advanced (or will advance) our understanding of mind and the mind-body relationship? 
 The CTP itself is attractive for many reasons. 
 For a start, it promises to biologize consciousness; to make it part of the natural world. 
 This, in turn, opens up the possibility of a unified account of the world that encompasses not only physical but also mental events. 
 The causal thread that reaches from the perceived object to the perception and on from that to the overt activity of the perceiver symbolizes the ontological homogeneity of the world. 
 The CTP, or something like it, is thus crucial to the over-riding scientific project of describing the whole of reality in terms of a single set of (physical) mechanisms. 
 Secondly, the neurophysiological CTP is consistent with scientific and everyday observations about the interdependence of mind and brain. 
 Ordinary experience seems to indicate that brain position determines experience content: where my head is (in space and in time) is the most important determinant of the content of my consciousness. 
 Moreover, the state of my sense endings &mdash; whether they are covered or uncovered, damaged or undamaged, pointed in one direction or another &mdash; also influences experience content. 
 Changes in electrical activity of the brain are associated with changes in the level and content of consciousness: you can tell whether someone is asleep or awake by looking at his electro-encephalogram. 
 And we have already discussed the correlations described by the Weber-Fechner law between impinging energy and sensation. 
 The most striking demonstration of the interdependency of brain and mind are observations, ranging from the most crude to the most refined, that brain dysfunction leads to abnormalities of or absence of perception. 
 Decapitation, with associated brain removal, leads to a perceptible decline in I.Q. in most instances. 
 Indeed, brain removal leads to mind removal. 
 Brain injury, due for example to trauma or to stroke, or to experimental lesions, seriously interferes with perception and may remove perception completely, either temporarily or permanently. 
 There are rough correlations between the kinds of brain injury and the kinds of deficits observed in consciousness, as are described in a vast neuropsychological literature. 
 Brain dysfunction - due to uncontrolled electrical discharges as in epilepsy or due to  the effects of drugs or toxins damping down electrical activity &mdash; will lead to disturbance or loss of consciousness. 
 Contrariwise, pseudoperceptions, ranging from crude, unformed noises and flashes of light through to complex scenes with accompanying meanings and emotions, can be generated by spontaneous discharges of the brain or in the laboratory by stimulating electrodes. 
 All of these observations seem to fit with, and to give support to, the idea that perception is the result of the impact of the perceived objects on an appropriately tuned nervous system. 
 It would be perverse to deny this. 
 But it has to be reiterated that the CTP does not explain  these observations: it does not explain how the impinging events give rise to awareness of those events. 
 At best, the CTP is a vacuous summary of these observations, a framework within which they can be gathered together. 
 Conformity with observations about the interdependence between mind function and brain function does not support the claim of the neurophysiological CTP to explain mind or point the way to such an explanation. 
 A parallel attraction of the theory is that it seems to constrain perception to be true  &mdash; to be only about things that impinge on the nervous system; that are, in other words, &bquo;really there&equo;. 
 This is important for the biologizing of consciousness: consciousness will evolve only if it improves the survival chances of creatures endowed with it; and it will have survival value only if it accurately reports what is actually &bquo;there&equo;. 
 If perception has to be triggered off by what is actually there, then it is constrained to be true. 
 False perception can arise only if the nervous system has spontaneous activity independently of any causative external object. 
 Unfortunately this evolutionary attraction of the causal theory is also illusory, for reasons that similar to those that established the circular nature of the Weber-Fechner and other psychophysical laws. 
 The constraint that we shall perceive only that which is &bquo;really there&equo; is a true constraint only if &bquo;really there&equo; can be defined independently of the usual constraints of perception. 
 Unfortunately, as I have demonstrated elsewhere (see Chapter 3 of my Explicit Animal ), it cannot. 
 So the constraint boils down to: we can perceive only that which we usually perceive. 
 This, of course, is no real constraint at all. 
 Moreover, what we perceive far exceeds what actually interacts with our nervous system; for what interacts with our nervous systems is occurrent energy and what we perceive are continuant objects (see earlier, p. 98). 
 Since the CTP is so flawed as an explanation of the mind and since its apparent attractions are apparent rather than real, how does the claim of that science to advance our understanding of the mind  command such a following? 
 To answer this question, we need to understand the language of neuromythology.  
 WHY ME? 
 Leena Dhingra 
 I couldn't possibly do that. 
 And why me anyway? 
 I wouldn't know where to start. 
 Well yes, I suppose I could give it a try but I don't want to promise anything. 
 It's just that&hellip; well, I need to feel touched by a topic, connected. 
 I put the phone down with a frown, grabbed my books, bag and coat, raced through the door and down the street and reached the bus stop breathless. 
 I looked at my watch automatically, and then again more carefully. 
 Could it have stopped? 
 The second hand was going round, but&hellip; 
 I asked someone, who smiled at my look of incredulity. 
 I had arrived at the bus stop two hours early. 
 I carried my bewilderment into the coffee shop and tried to drown it along with the froth of my cappuccino. 
 Why did I rush out like that? 
 I was still frowning and my throat felt constricted. 
 I had literally run away &mdash; from Englishness! 
 Well, I just won't do it. 
 I'll ring up and say that it's not for me. 
 I started to sip my coffee. 
 In any case, I don't have to do it if I don't want to. 
 Who are you trying to fool! 
 Ha! 
 I asked myself and returned to folding the froth into the coffee. 
 What was it you said on the phone about needing to feel connected,  affected, moved? 
 And can you honestly say you are unaffected? 
 Obviously there is some problem which I shall attempt to diagnose. 
 Location, Sensation, Modalities, Concomitants I repeated, having decided to walk to my class in town. 
 Location, Sensation, Modalities, Concomitants, That's what one needs for diagnosis! 
 I remembered my homeopathy seminars&hellip; 
 Playing as a child on the Paris pavements, my ten-year-old companion asked me, &bquo;Why do you speak in English? 
 You're not English and you've never even been to England.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know, but I just do. 
 It's spoken around me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well I don't like English.&equo; 
 &bquo;But why, you've never been there either.&equo; 
 &bquo;And I never will! 
 They killed Joan of Arc! &Ccedil;a me suffit !&equo; 
 &bquo;But that was ages ago!&equo; 
 &bquo;And so?&equo; 
 Back at home I asked my mother why we spoke in English. 
 She shook her head, &bquo;I know it's very bad. 
 I am ashamed,&equo; and immediately started to talk in Hindi, in the manner of an elementary language lesson, as though to jog my memory of my long forgotten mother tongue. 
 In any case she didn't answer my question. 
 Location, Sensation, Modalities, Concominants I muttered looking around me, trying to imprint some image of elusive Englishness. 
 The location of Englishness is clear. 
 It's here. 
 All around. 
 This is it. 
 Of course, what it is, I don't know. 
 But this is where it's supposed to be. 
 So the first point is: Englishness Eludes. 
 Sensation: What does it feel like? 
 To me, it's a constriction in the throat. 
 A closed club. 
 No admittance. 
 You either are or you're not. 
 Englishness Excludes. 
 Modality. 
 The procedure to find out. 
 I could just try and ask people. 
 See then about concomitants.  
 I met a friend at the college library and we went out for a coffee. 
 &bquo;What is Englishness? 
 What about the &bquo;habit of command&equo;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Isn't that a bit clich&eacute; or at any rate, pass&eacute;?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, yes and no, You know the saying: &bquo;The fish is gone but the smell remains.&equo; 
 The empire too may be long gone, but you'd never think it listening to the cricket commentators. 
 For them the Imperial Sun shines on  undiminished ! 
 That's Englishness! 
 You could write about that.&equo; 
 &bquo;What cricket and all that? 
 I wouldn't know what to say.&equo; 
 My friend laughed. 
 &bquo;And you want to write abut Englishness!&equo; 
 &bquo;No I don't want to write about Englishness. 
 I've been asked to write about it and I said I'd give it a think.&equo; 
 My tone was defensive and I could feel the tenseness returning. 
 &bquo;Well it's nothing to get upset about. 
 Just say that you don't want to do it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, I think I will. 
 And I'm not upset, it's something else&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Could it be fear?&equo; 
 &bquo;But of what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fear of exposure, maybe?&equo; 
 &bquo;Exposure!&equo; 
 I stirred my coffee. 
 This time there was no froth to fold into it. 
 &bquo;Yes, maybe. 
 I'm certainly affected by the whole idea in the strangest manner, quite paranoid. 
 In fact I even found myself trying to diagnose it like an illness, analysing it in terms of location, sensation, modalities, concomitants.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;To find the correct homeopathic remedy for any condition, the symptoms are diagnosed in those terms, and the Materia Medica places them under those headings: location, sensation etc.&equo; 
 My friend laughed. 
 &bquo;Well some people might agree  with you that Englishness was a condition of a kind. 
 A sort of  dis-ease .&equo; 
 Be stiffened himself to illustrate his point. 
 &bquo;It's highly contagious as well. 
 I think you've caught it. 
 In fact, I think that we all get affected by it through prolonged exposure. 
 It rubs off. 
 You could approach your writing from that angle. 
 No?&equo; 
 I laughed. 
 &bquo;It's an interesting idea. 
 But how exactly?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 Something about Englishness and its effect on you? 
 Couldn't you distance yourself from it somehow?&equo; 
 &bquo;I could. 
 I could write as if it was someone else&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes that's right, a character from a play or a novel. 
 You might discover something.&equo; 
 &bquo;You never know. 
 I might. 
 But I'll give it a try. 
 Thanks.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let me know how you get along.&equo; 
 I liked the idea. 
 I got some paper and wrote: Englishness  and its effect on&hellip; 
 I stopped to find her a name. 
 I decided on an anagram, Neela. 
 Neela is a woman in her 4Os, living in London. 
 She left India, the land of her birth when she was a small child. 
 India was partitioned and her home lost. 
 She was brought up between India, Europe, and England. 
 Of course today, England is a part of Europe, but when Neela was growing up, England never saw itself as a part of Europe. 
 If it ever did, it was always as a part which was apart, separate, a &bquo;precious stone set in the silver sea. 
 A sceptered Isle!&equo; 
 Neela was aware of this difference. 
 But what did this difference mean to Neela? 
 Or rather how did it feel? 
 Europe appeared to accept her difference and individuality, whereas England demanded that she should somehow conform, assimilate, and yet at the same time, there was no way in which it was possible to really &bquo;assimilate&equo;. 
 In fact it wasn't even allowed. 
 In any case,  assimilation never meant any real acceptance or belonging. 
 Basically it grew out of the idea that what the West represented, and the English middle class best of all, was something to emulate, look up to, admire &mdash; all the rest was just a bit rude and best if it politely disappeared. 
 This then was the paradox Neela grew up with and had to learn to grow out of. 
 So, in England a whole part of her personality remained buried. 
 And she had so perfected this technique of politely disappearing, that she had to live almost half her life before she came to realize that she had almost disappeared to her own self! 
 That self now needed to be discovered &mdash; but where? 
 And how? 
 She picked up a pen, and started to write, in English. 
 &bquo;So she became a writer in English, but without Englishness presumably?&equo; asked my friend when we met again. 
 &bquo;I wasn't just trapped in the tower, I also had the key to the door. 
 Do you see?&equo; 
 &bquo;I see that you're a hell of a lot more cheerful.&equo; 
 &bquo;And do you know what I'd like to do?&equo; 
 &bquo;Go out for a coffee.&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 Crumpets and tea.&equo;  
 THE GHOST IN THE WOOD 
 Judith Kazantzis 
 She is staying with Harriet. 
 Just one wary night, before she goes to America, at Harriet's weekend cottage in Norfolk. 
 There is a little wood to one side of the lawn, and a large stubble field to the other. 
 Mist is rising, a bat flies round Jen's head and then away over the thatch. 
 An owl hoots. 
 &bquo;Is it always so stunning?&equo; 
 &bquo;In the winter I visit Mummy in Norwich instead. 
 I brought her out here last weekend.&equo; 
 Her sister Harriet has had the cottage for two years. 
 Harriet knows how to get a cheap mortgage. 
 Such a place is as beyond Jen as Xanadu. 
 Jen's two years older. 
 She has been teaching in North Kensington. 
 Harriet's a property consultant in Mayfair. 
 They don't quarrel. 
 Suppertime and deep blue dusk. 
 Harriet is barbecuing pork kebabs, which w ill be as exotic as her long hair swinging blonde white over the glowing charcoal. 
 Jen's hair is coppery/gingery and short. 
 Jeff loves it; he strokes his hand over her head as if she were a child. 
 But when she gets to America she's vowed it will be longer and lighter. 
 &bquo;It's so like Lacings.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm a country gal at heart. 
 Though I'm off to Singapore on Wednesday. 
 Big deal &mdash; big development. 
 Cheers.&equo;  
 They toast her &bquo;engagement&equo; and Harriet's deal in red wine out of tall crystal goblets. 
 Harriet charmingly apologizes: &bquo;I forgot! 
 Jeff rang before you arrived. 
 He'll ring again. 
 I love the Deep South honey in his voice.&equo; 
 &bquo;Didn't I tell you he's a New Yorker?&equo; she smiles back. 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 What was it like being proposed to by a New York City Planner with a voice to melt molasses by?&equo; 
 &bquo;Lovely.&equo; 
 She's not going to confide immediately. 
 &bquo;Could do without Mommy though. 
 We paid her my first big visit in Brooklyn, she hadn't met me except on the phone. 
 And all she could do,&equo; Harriet, she says silently, what a betrayer you make me, immediately, &bquo;all she could do was ask about the Royals, was Diana as beautiful as in Newsweek.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, I suppose that would have irritated a Socialist Republican Feminist like you.&equo; 
 They drink. 
 It's a warm good wine; it hits some little sore spot. 
 Jennifer, she scolds herself, be warm too, more affectionate. 
 Harriet has laid on a midsummer's night farewell, just the two of us, sisters. 
 Didn't we share a bath when we were little, ride ponies together when we were bigger? 
 Just us, fair and dark, peas in a pod, little and large (well, I exaggerate here, she's smaller, more slender; but then Jeff, he's given me new trust in my ass). 
 &bquo;Won't you miss old England?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll miss the kids. 
 But I'll be teaching again over there.&equo; 
 Just before the bell on her last day, Sharon and Maria dumped a huge card on her desk: of the Statue of Liberty togged out as Batperson, all welcoming Batcape. 
 &bquo;Oood luck and tons of love from 2.3.&equo; 
 X's everywhere. 
 They were all, her included, madly laughing. 
 Michael Morrissey looked at her with his white face. 
 Afterwards she visited the Head. 
 He was short and tended to get jostled crossing the playground. 
 &bquo;Off to the land of opportunity, are you?&equo; he said jovially and reproachfully. 
 He was more concerned to get her last report on  Michael Morrissey who, now he told her, had a grown brother in the IRA and so, as the Head put it, the family had been made unwelcome in Northern Ireland. 
 &bquo;I'm really sorry to leave,&equo; she said sincerely. 
 &bquo;I hope to teach in public schools in New York, I mean New York public schools.&equo; 
 &bquo;Keep up the good work,&equo; he waved her farewell, &bquo;tell the next child to come in.&equo; 
 On the tube home she felt like crying, not because she had left, but for Sharon and Maria, not to say Michael. 
 For herself she was relieved she didn't have to struggle to harness their zippy, anarchic minds any more to a future of filing and fast food shoppers &mdash; till for Christ's sake let's get married and turn on the telly and have some peace. 
 Maybe in another neck of the woods, with Jeff's kind of cheerful, simple yet not stupid, certainty, she would make good&hellip; 
 For, she thinks, if privileged spoiled people like her can't get off their backsides and put their money where their mouth is&hellip; 
 &bquo;I love teaching. 
 It's just that the powers that be treat us teachers like dirt. 
 And now with opting out&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I tend to think,&equo; says Harriet, &bquo;teachers in state schools get paid pretty well. 
 What d'you think of my wine?&equo; 
 &bquo;You know I wouldn't know. 
 But, great.&equo; 
 &bquo;I got given a crate of this, it's Ch&acirc;teau Margaux, by the small, fat and lecherous owner of one third of Singapore. 
 Chin chin. 
 Actually he was a Jap.&equo; 
 Jeff, she calls. 
 I'm homesick for you. 
 Just a yearning only, no lust. 
 And call, you snake &mdash; Manhattan &mdash; Norfolk. 
 Now a tiny red salamander of lust does pierce me. 
 I've seen salamanders in green woods north of New York, with Jeff. 
 Call soon, you snake. 
 &bquo;The kebabs are brilliant.&equo; 
 She'd forgotten Harriet was a great cook. 
 Harriet, fair-plaited, a tea-towel round her middle, another round her front as wide as the nuns still wore their dicky fronts at school. 
 Helping Mummy stir the cake mixture. 
 &bquo;Go 'way. 
 You can't have any. 
 I helped, you were just reading.&equo; 
  &bquo;&hellip; I'll do it for the Young Farmers sometime.&equo; 
 &bquo;Young Farmers?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not your thing. 
 They're all scientists really, plus businessmen. 
 I'll marry one when I've made my first million, and we'll run an enormous model farm. 
 No hedges, and peas as high as an elephant's eye.&equo; 
 &bquo;Pouring nitrates into the dykes to poison the villagers, sort of thing?&equo; 
 Harriet sits calmly in her flowery chintz deckchair. 
 She is calm too, of course. 
 &bquo;You really shouldn't believe those funny Green men, love, it's all a scare to queer water privatization. 
 Just because the Government's doing so fabulously well.&equo; 
 &bquo;Harriet&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;You do-gooders are always so serious&hellip; 
 Listen.&equo; 
 it's just about dark and Harriet's hair flies out and glimmers as she moves her head. 
 &bquo;I think I heard Maggie just then. 
 She flies around her wood all night. 
 Like the Holy Ghost, ascending and descending on the foreheads of the Apostles, only in Maggie's case it's voles and fieldmice.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maggie is?&equo; 
 &bquo;My barn owl. 
 Isn't England wonderful, Jen&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;But now I want to ask you something, seriously,&equo; Harriet's voice softens. 
 Now they can't see each other's face, just Harriet's hair glimmering. 
 Jen feels sad. 
 Whatever it is, now the moment's here that she came for, that she half foresaw, she won't tell. 
 A long train ride to an owl called Maggie. 
 She drinks up. 
 &bquo;I've been wondering, now it seems, well, you're leaving, why did  you turn Socialist? 
 Was it the nuns at school? 
 Or Daddy, with all his William Morris-type talk. 
 We turned out so different &mdash; I'm curious.&equo; 
 Curious? 
 Curious way to ask, she thinks. 
 Very funny way, she muses. 
 Daddy dead and Lacings gone. 
 Why ask? 
 Mummy in her Norwich fiat now. 
 No more tawny owls in the tall Scotch pines. 
 No more croquet lawn; Daddy, longlegged in shorts and a big blue T shirt,  coaching us girls to play. 
 Harriet and I as teenagers bashing each other into the lavender bushes. 
 &bquo;So competitive,&equo; he would mock groan. 
 Of course. 
 Tall man, booming out laughter and orders, watching us, adoring us. 
 Harriet more: the prettier; bumptious, cheeky. 
 But it was she the older, the larger and clumsier, who listened to him over supper. 
 He told them This Island Story  from Wat Tyler's point of view. 
 He voted Labour even, amazingly; like no one they knew. 
 Down from his stocked shelves he took Shirley and The Ragged Trousered Philanthropists . 
 &bquo;Jen, try this one. 
 You'll see how&hellip; 
 &equo; She lay on her bed for hours leading righteous riots of millhands against languid tophatted fops or hardfaced bowlerhatted men of iron and steel. 
 Harriet, she regrets softly, I've no answer for you. 
 &bquo;Harriet, your cornfield's the spit image of the one at home.&equo; 
 She remembers the way the sun would sink down as the combine sliced out the last ranks of the wheat. 
 Rabbits would dash out of their losing darkness, and the village boys would chase them with sticks and yells, careful not to get in front of the two who had the guns. 
 That year, she was fourteen? 
 She scrambled over the garden fence and joined them, shy, thrilled. 
 A rabbit dodged between her feet and made it to the hedgerow. 
 A groan from Paul, standing on her right. 
 &bquo;Good old Jen.&equo; 
 He worked at the local riding stable cum farm. 
 She went there for her weekly ecstasy, her Sunday ride. 
 Paul was longlegged, in stained breeches. 
 His yellow hair flopped into his blue eyes as he did up her girths for her. 
 The Sunday before she had asked him to come to tea. 
 &bquo;Would you like to come to tea?&equo; 
 In a mumble downwards. 
 Paul didn't appear to notice. 
 Also then, they had a cousin, Nigel, to stay. 
 More spots than manly growth. 
 He did have a red MG. 
 Harriet polished the fenders furiously but then she stopped. 
 Nigel had fallen for Jill, the punky purple-haired girl at the garage. 
 Their mother used to click her  lips surreptitiously as Jill filled the car up. 
 &bquo;Heard the latest?&equo; said Harriet in the kitchen where they were lounging and doing nothing as usual. 
 &bquo;Paul the Ape Brown is going out with El Tarty Queen of El Garage. 
 Isn't it just too, too, darlings?&equo; 
 Eyeing her and Nigel and speaking to the air. 
 Harriet read film and gossip column mags voraciously. 
 She couldn't summon up a whacky death-dealing reply and went into their mother's beautiful garden to cry. 
 Nigel meanwhile went for the beer. 
 &bquo;So you're a fucking Commie,&equo; he said to her on her return. 
 &bquo;No, I don't think so,&equo; she said, &bquo;I think I'm pretty much in the English Christian Socialist tradition, you know.&equo; 
 Nigel's spots became crimson. 
 &bquo;When Margaret Thatcher gets in you and your bloody unions better watch out.&equo; 
 That was it. 
 She was a Peculiar Young Person locally, a Socialist. 
 She despised them all: dupes, hackettes, lackeys. 
 Harriet played in tennis doubles and her public school boyfriends crowded in to eat her jam tarts. 
 Meanwhile she thought about bosses and masses. 
 She never imagined her little sister, exasperating as she was, would join the bosses. 
 Harriet. 
 She sees her, the little sister. 
 Earlier memories again. 
 Shelling peas on the sunny lawn with Janey, their help, and Janey getting red with annoyance as she and Harriet ate them up, all but seven. 
 The two of them tickling staid Janey, one on each side until she couldn't help laughing, and the seven peas rolled away. 
 And her saying, &bquo;Harriet, you're so greedy!&equo; 
 And Harriet opening her mouth but then both of them giggling wildly. 
 But then, Harriet with her fair-haired plaits and smooth round forehead jiggling off to help Mummy do the shopping. 
 They'd come back chatting merrily. 
 Then they made jam tarts. 
 &bquo;My Princess Harriet,&equo; said Daddy, yes he did, as they paraded in with the silver tea things and the three dead-at-birth jam tarts. 
 She sees: Mummy and Harriet together. 
 Oh well, let them get on with it. 
 It was a long time ago. 
 Later still again, she was doing her A's, there was Daddy talking  to them over the shepherd's pie about Keir Hardie, and her saying, &bquo;Oh gosh I see, yes &mdash;!&equo; and Mummy laughing, &bquo;Can we all eat and not so much learned talk. 
 Janey's waiting for the washing up and then she's off.&equo; 
 And Daddy, &bquo;Of course, dear. 
 Just one thing, Jennifer&hellip; 
 &equo; But those years he would go into his study afterwards with the coffee her mother made, to smoke his pipe and look over a case, and he shut the door. 
 Then he took them all to Mexico. 
 Mexico! 
 Her balding country solicitor Daddy. 
 It must have cost the earth, package and all. 
 Did he know he would die a few years later? 
 It was hot, hot. 
 They saw the temple of the sun and the temple of the moon, driving out of the huge city past a tangle of ravines and yellow clifftops hung with shacks of corrugated iron and this and that. 
 Fowl, pigs and human kids played among yellow and white plastic rubbish &mdash; water containers, Exxon oil bottles. 
 In the heart of the vast city, Daddy again, his brown eyes bright, you could see his sparse hair growing down by the minute into the Hippie pigtail he'd been too young or too old and always too respectable to wear&hellip; 
 Well, he showed them his real find, the Rivera murals, the white-clothed indigenos  who were being liberated, the obese bosses with their cigars tumbling, the beautiful Mayan prostitute cheeking the bourgeois couple in Almeida Park. 
 &bquo;The Latin races know how to make a revolution,&equo; he said waving his specs in the empty gallery. 
 &bquo;Now this is a truly Socialist country. 
 Even its skeletons dance for joy, for love.&equo; 
 Poor Daddy. 
 Poor Daddy, she cries. 
 It wasn't the nuns, Harriet, who gave me my guilt, my conscience (do you have a conscience, Harriet?). 
 The day I went up to university I left you all, country gentry all&hellip; country where my father was stifling. 
 She sees that Harriet is quietly gazing at her in the red firelight. 
 The trouble is, Harriet is beautiful and her sister. 
 She feels soothed in the familiar Norfolk  darkness&hellip; 
 What can she please her with? 
 Murdoch 
 &bquo;Have I told you about Niall?&equo; she asks. 
 &bquo;No&hellip; 
 Quick, have some more Oriental plonk.&equo; 
 &bquo;Niall was Mr First. 
 At Oxford. 
 I met him at the Labour Club. 
 I was totally petrified &mdash; so I went with another girl, my first feminist incidentally.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was your first feminist!&equo; 
 &bquo;No, you were a crypto-Post-feminist; now you're a fully fledged Post-feminist.&equo; 
 Fair enough. 
 Harriet had gone straight into property after her A's and left home, funnily enough, before she did. 
 It had bemused her, hearing. 
 It was the time of the Miners Strike; just afterwards. 
 She had instructed herself to forget Harriet. 
 Harriet lights a cigarette. 
 &bquo;So Niall? 
 Was he incredibly handsome?&equo; 
 &bquo;King of the Irish, greeny eyes, Irish eyebrows, Irish lashes. 
 He spoke brilliantly on secondary picketing and the police. 
 Afterwards in the pub someone told me he would probably be sent down. 
 He'd been beaten up once and arrested once.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh God, the dreaded Scargill.&equo; 
 &bquo;Harriet&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;No, go on. 
 Did he ask you out?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not till the second meeting. 
 I spent the time before it boning up on things like Troops Out . 
 So I jumped in, eloquently I thought, to second Niall's resolution, to be released to the press if agreed: that the Labour Party should make annual contributions to the IRA &mdash; Yes I did - I was in a wonderful whirl, you see, the whole ant-heap had suddenly become vivid, and, um, deconstructable; I forgot Wat Tyler and Keir Hardie, and saw rich and poor as it all is today, internationally struggling, the classes &mdash; well, you couldn't understand&hellip; 
 &equo; &bquo;I've always admired your conviction,&equo; Harriet says unexpectedly; but then: &bquo;I'm sorry, he sounds dire. 
 Possibly dangerous. 
 You mean he was your First?&equo; 
 &bquo;He was James Connolly to me, anti-Imperialist,  
 Socialist. 
 Everything right. 
 You ought to listen and learn, Harriet,&equo; she says earnestly. 
 &bquo;D'you want me to go on?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wouldn't miss it,&equo; Harriet says. 
 &bquo;Look &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Look, isn't it possible to tease each other about our politics &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Look, I simply don't connect with that,&equo; she answers sincerely, &bquo;We should respect each other, just because. 
 Let's talk about something more sisterly. 
 How're your roses?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine, thanks.&equo; 
 Harriet sloshes her some more wine. 
 In the trees a little wind dies away. 
 &bquo;And so what happened?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, someone got up and said I couldn't propose throwing redcoats out of Belfast because there weren't any nowadays. 
 I said I was a historian. 
 And Niall got up and said, music to my ears, that Erin's soil wasn't green either but we all knew what it meant&hellip; 
 Then he went on, to amplify what he called my brave intervention. 
 After that&hellip;&equo; 
 She falls silent. 
 Sometimes still, those greeny eyes. 
 She's glad Jeff's are brown. 
 An impression only of Niall's black hair flying, awkward jumble on her hearthrug of arms and legs. 
 She cried out. 
 It was her nail scissors that she'd been searching for days, lost under the hearthrug and pressing into her hip; and the cry was also her virginity, small and bewildered and gone. 
 Afterwards somehow an argument started. 
 Were they both unhappy? 
 Niall sending her up in his lilting Belfast voice for claiming Irish blood. 
 &bquo;I've an uncle farming in the Sou &mdash; the twenty-six counties.&equo; 
 &bquo;He a Prod, Jenny?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's not the same thing down there. 
 W.B. Yeats was a Protestant you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;I did know,&equo; he said; then putting on the style, &bquo;Your uncle's grandaddy's granddaddy, came over with that murthering bugger Cromwell, did he, English Jenny?&equo; 
 &bquo;Niall, I'm terribly pro  Troops Out&hellip; 
 &equo; &bquo;Shame on ye, ye plump English trollope,&equo; he giggled suddenly and rolled onto her again. 
 She got the scissors out just in time. 
 Now she thinks, not his cock but his tongue, I should have cut his tongue out with them, his slow quicksilver tongue; for he partly took me backwards out of my joy, into an old timidity that's there still; and it's made a meal of me sometimes teaching, when the sharper ones have had me squirming for my lazy luck. 
 Going back to a big house and long lawns, Jen? said Michael Morrissey's eyes last week. 
 No, she answers their stare, it's not true any more. 
 If Niall turns up in the dock for blowing up redcoats, I'll feel guilty. 
 And defiant, against Harriet and her lords. 
 And defiant, against Niall and his. 
 And sad, because I wanted to join him. 
 I wanted him to approve of me. 
 Oh Jeff, ring, you soft-drawling American snake. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; says Harriet in the darkness. 
 &bquo;Aren't you going to spill the beans? 
 Here, you haven't been drinking.&equo; 
 Her voice is flat, not bright like five minutes ago. 
 They've been sitting during this meditation on her short useless history as a Socialist, they've been sitting in the dark and now the moon rises, full and amber against a bar of cloud and Harriet's face is bowed; a drink at one hand; and a cigarette droops glowing from the other. 
 &bquo;It was a washout actually,&equo; she answers. 
 &bquo;I lay on my nail scissors by mistake &mdash; they were under the rug &mdash; and just at the  moment, well, to be graphic, an awful pain from outside  was all I could feel.&equo; 
 Pause. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Harriet murmurs, &bquo;you always were untidy.&equo; 
 Has she drunk too much? 
 Jen thinks: I don't think I'm very tipsy at all. 
 This evening seems to be going up the spout. 
 &bquo;Er, how about opening another bottle?&equo; 
 Docilely Harriet pads off and comes back and they gurgle out what she knows is the sweated labour of  Singapore. 
 Harriet lights up and recrosses her legs. 
 How slim and white they seem in the moonlight. 
 Harriet comments, &bquo;When I come to your wedding in the slums of Brooklyn you can do me the honours.&equo; 
 &bquo;We're only going to the old registry office,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't get married at all except I need to work over there. 
 Jeff thinks the same way.&equo; 
 &bquo;You really are going? 
 You won't miss us?&equo; 
 In the other voice she hears a softness and immediately, softly then, she hears herself answering &bquo;I'll miss you. 
 And Mummy. 
 Visit me, Harriet, promise?&equo; 
 Harriet is smoking again. 
 She thinks, I wish she wouldn't. 
 But the smoke is fragrant, it curls up into the perfume of jasmine or climbing roses somewhere behind by the cottage door. 
 Which of the two? 
 Oh Lord, she has forgotten the country. 
 &bquo;I don't think you should go, not yet&hellip; 
 &equo; Harriet says softly. 
 &bquo;Harriet love.&equo; 
 Her heart melts. 
 &bquo;I'm going to be away increasingly in the next few years. 
 With work getting heavier. 
 And so.&equo; 
 Go carefully, she warns. 
 I'm listening, she pleads: I know we're chalk and cheese but. 
 We took each other, body and soul, for granted when we were little, Harriet, we don't quarrel, we don't. 
 &bquo;Mummy's arthritis can only get worse. 
 Have you thought about what your emigration means to her? 
 Who, to come to my point, is to shoulder the responsibility?&equo; 
 &bquo;I&hellip; you brought me all the way up here&hellip; moonlight and dinner, to tell me this?&equo; 
 She laughs angrily. 
 &bquo;Harriet, you shouldn't have.&equo; 
 Shushing herself:: calm down Jennifer&hellip; 
 It's true, I haven't given much thought to Mummy. 
 She seemed thrilled when I told her. 
 I'm not irresponsible, thirty twelve-year-olds over a year&hellip; 
 &bquo;Calm down,&equo; Harriet says out of moonlight, coldly. 
 &bquo;You think I'm being selfish. 
 That's weird; coming from you.&equo; 
 Woa, Jennifer. 
 We're sisters, I'm a feminist,  all we've got. 
 We work to be friends. 
 We respect each other. 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; Harriet drinks delicately, the moon blanches her hair even paler, even whiter, &bquo;what d'you mean by that?&equo; 
 Springing up she feels not more powerful but even clumsier, so she sits down again. 
 &bquo;This perfect life of yours, you really just grab grab grab it from others. 
 This was a farm labourer's cottage obviously &mdash;&equo; she recalls Niall, this time with some pleasure: &bquo;Why've you  got it?&equo; 
 She throws out her right hand. 
 &bquo;You wreck the countryside, you wreck the towns, now not content with England you're off to wreck Singapore.&equo; 
 &bquo;You know fuck-all, Jen,&equo; Harriet bursts out laughing. 
 &bquo;Didn't teach you much at Oxford, did they? 
 Who's &bquo;you&equo; for example?&equo; 
 Cow, she implodes. 
 I've better things to do than make a fool of myself with you. 
 O.K. get what you want. 
 &bquo;Thatcherism, the developers,, the City, the multi-nationals, the Pentagon, the international arms industry,&equo; big breath, &bquo;the whole military industrial complex!&equo; she yells. 
 She jumps up. 
 So does Harriet. 
 They're eyeballing each other. 
 The cornfield, the wood, whose side are they on? 
 Goddess, she calls happily, I've wanted to shout these things at her for years. 
 The great naming curses flutter into the bland night. 
 And this about their mother. 
 Anyway she's Harriet's guest. 
 W ill Harriet turn her out? 
 Shall she sleep in wood or cornfield? 
 &bquo;Sorry.&equo; 
 She sits. 
 &bquo;Oh do go on,&equo; Harriet hovers above, laughing, &bquo;it's not as if we didn't all know how virtuous you feel.&equo; 
 To hell with guest, she thinks. 
 &bquo;Come off it,&equo; Harriet carries on with a sudden jerk. 
 &bquo;You're all so smug you repel me. 
 You think if I hadn't bought it and done it up at enormous personal cost this cottage would still be standing?&equo; 
 Her voice changes notes. 
 &bquo;While you've been sitting on your intellectual arses alternately pitying yourselves and the so-called workers, it's my hard work, my money that's been  keeping this country &mdash;&equo; Stalking off indoors; the door shuts. 
 &bquo;Harriet!&equo; 
 Oh to hell with it. 
 &bquo;I don't want to quarrel. 
 It's your patch. 
 Shall I leave?&equo; 
 &bquo;You're jealous.&equo; 
 Tittering from inside. 
 Blonde hair shining, visible, in the shadow, through the mullioned hall window. 
 &bquo;Jealous? 
 When d'you meet any real people apart from those limousine sharks and cordless telephone freaks who never met an ordinary person, don't know any ordinary people: how they live, we live, nor how we die, I mean how they die.&equo; 
 Mexicans in the moonlight, surging towards her over the stubble, old wrinkled women, kids with the bulbous stomachs, things to be honest she didn't see because they drove past too quickly on the motorway. 
 But, she defies her, I do know, you stupid woman. 
 How about life in the Westway high rises. 
 The two Bangladeshi boys I had for remedial English all this year. 
 White-shirted beyond belief, incredibly anxious to please, to do the English thing. 
 Of course. 
 They're the lucky ones. 
 The door unbolts. 
 Harriet comes out with a bottle. 
 &bquo;You are,&equo; she says comfortably. 
 &bquo;You're not the only teacher in state schools I know. 
 Friend of mine's just quit. 
 Awful loutish children, cynical staff. 
 And she went into it out of real idealism, not just as an ego trip to prove oneself to one's dead father &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Fuck you. 
 I'm going.&equo; 
 &bquo;Feel free, martyr.&equo; 
 Harriet sits down, begins to hum the Marseillaise. 
 The cork pops up. 
 Jen sits down. 
 They sit silently. 
 She wants to cry. 
 Why? 
 Then she has some wine. 
 Harriet stretches out her hand and tops her up. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry. 
 Oh Christ. 
 Jen?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll have to wait for Jeff to phone, that's all.&equo; 
 After another pause. 
 &bquo;Is it Jeff, Harriet?&equo; 
 &bquo;You're getting out,&equo; Harriet whispers, &bquo;admit you're getting out.&equo; 
 Hardening again: &bquo;Isn't Jeff a way of getting out; as well&hellip; 
 Why are you so hypocritical?&equo;  
 It pierces her. 
 My Jeff? 
 &bquo;Damn you. 
 No.&equo; 
 Salamander, I love you. 
 Rescue me. 
 I'm incredibly lazy but I do think I've found the right way or at least a better way than hers to live. 
 No cottage, thanks. 
 &bquo;Harriet, if I got what you get a year, I'd invest it to&hellip; support the Sandinistas in Nicaragua or something. 
 I wouldn't just use it to grab grab grab with. 
 Or,&equo; she leans forward but only the beautiful hair shines, &bquo;I might just buy a bomb after all &mdash;&equo; 
 Harriet comes out of darkness to pour only herself some more. 
 Jen grabs for the bottle and it drops down on the grass and rolls away, glug, gurgle. 
 They beth splutter with anger and burst into silly giggles, wrestling. 
 Harriet makes for her wine cellar. 
 &bquo;Hey, what about my bomb?&equo; she shouts after her. 
 &bquo;Prig, you old prig, even terrorism a virtue. 
 Daddy wouldn't have liked that.&equo; 
 Two filled crystal goblets later (perhaps she won't go after all), &bquo;Hypocrites, both of you,&equo; Harriet continues. 
 &bquo;You screwing the IRA and Daddy boring Mummy and me over the roast beef with what a socialist champion you were, daughter after his own heart.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cheers.&equo; 
 She waggles her goblet. 
 &bquo;Never knew that, promise. 
 Always felt&hellip; you were the one, really&hellip; 
 He didn't much like you being a property shark, I suppose?&equo; 
 &bquo;Property management consultant. 
 Don't try to rile me again, Jennifer, you are my guest.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorry, no offence meant&hellip; 
 Just to be clear, what's this &bquo;prig&equo;, &bquo;hypocrite&equo;. 
 Not sure if I can stay the night yet. 
 Bitterness not good for our souls, Harriet.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, prig. 
 You are. 
 You're such a killjoy, misery. 
 I invite you up here and all you think is whether the dyke is full of nitrates poisoning the villagers.&equo; 
 &bquo;Didn't.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did.&equo; 
 &bquo;I said &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Guilty. 
 That's what you want to make me. 
 Nuns' stuff. 
 Guilty. 
 Oh I'm not. 
 I'm incredibly proud of what  I've achieved. 
 Of Where I Am Today, just like Maggie, however scornful you get. 
 And wimps like Daddy. 
 Always trying to pass along their failure.&equo; 
 Harriet's voice drops but she's not listening. 
 Harriet's explaining that she gives a service, something about helping people realize their dreams. 
 &bquo;He wasn't a failure.&equo; 
 She's dizzy, she's a long way off. 
 There's more light, Harriet has switched on the kitchen light. 
 Now leaning forward from out of the flowery deckchair: &bquo;You know he died in debt. 
 No, you didn't, did you, darling. 
 So we lost Lacings. 
 But that's no surprise. 
 The question is, for the last three years, who's been helping to look after Mummy? 
 Who, darling? 
 St. Jennifer, Big Sister, Robin Hood of the workers &mdash; Who's been looking after Mummy, d'you imagine?&equo; 
 &bquo;You, she, never told me, never.&equo; 
 The kitchen light skids across the lawn. 
 &bquo;Mummy pleaded with me not. 
 I was beginning to make some money. 
 You were doing your finals. 
 It went on from there.&equo; 
 A fiat, furious voice. 
 &bquo;If it wasn't for the drink, I mightn't have told you. 
 Mummy will be upset. 
 You know, Jen, she's rather in awe of you.&equo; 
 The harsh voice. 
 It twists in her guts. 
 &bquo;I'll help of course, now&hellip;&equo; she mutters. 
 &bquo;It's not the money&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh. 
 Then. 
 You think I'm terrible, unforgivable to go?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't mind, really, what you are or aren't. 
 It's being here, Jennifer, being here. 
 Someone to be around. 
 Like a daughter? 
 Well, you see, that's how I think.&equo; 
 Harriet, she begins to talk, feeling the wine in her head, and talking faster, you are telling me how you bought this pretty scenery for Mummy's sake, partly. 
 I understand. 
 Mummy visits from Norwich. 
 Janey can visit too, from where she's retired to. 
 It's all brilliant. 
 I didn't even ask. 
 Janey sends me Christmas cards. 
 I think I w ill wander in round the lawn, out of the light. 
 I send her cards. 
 Last Christmas she sent me a bluetit  and I sent her a robin redbreast, a bloody great Robin Redbreast. 
 I raise my arm, my finger traces a bird on the shape of the moon over the trees in front of me. 
 So, Jennifer, Ms. hypocrite, how d'you feel? 
 Well, nothing. 
 I feel, nothing. 
 To break away, to London, a bedsit, a rather cozy bedsit, laughter and plonk, moaning in the staffroom, and laughter, and exhaustion, and nothing, nothing achieved, not for the kids, not by me. 
 I&hellip; 
 I&hellip; 
 I&hellip; 
 People like Niall, like Michael Morrissey, who do know what it is like to be poor and shat on, the bottom of the whole U.K. heap, they know I'm nothing when they set eyes on me. 
 Nothing. 
 Like my stupid father. 
 What did he ever do? 
 A few cases on legal aid, a sub to the Fabians, maybe a sub to the Nicaragua Solidarity Campaign. 
 It's Harriet who's the something, a good little capitalist something looking after her family plus not to forget the old Babushka. 
 Yes, smiles Harriet, tossing her hair, tearing down hovels and putting up Far Eastern hotels, I'm making the world safer for my family &mdash; Bam, punch in the nose for Salim and Sharon and Michael&hellip; 
 I've seen them after all (she's talking still faster)&hellip; for Harriet they're just future factory fodder. 
 All right, less cant&hellip; 
 No, I guess I might not want to spend my life teaching. 
 But, to do something relevant! 
 It'll be better, more straightforward with Jeff and away from home. 
 Bigger country, not one tight little prejudiced clapped out topheavy society, less breathing down one's neck. 
 As for Harriet who supports the family and stays, she doesn't like rough kids, she just plays in a rough ballgame. 
 Come midnight: the two of us sisters bashing each other into the lavender bushes. 
 Who shall be higher in the eyes of Heaven. 
 She potters over, &bquo;I'm going for a walk, so if I feel sick I won't puke all over your lawn.&equo; 
 &bquo;Running away again, you hypocrite,&equo; Harriet says drowsily, leaning over to slop some wine into her glass as she meanders past.  
 Hypocrite, she weeps to herself. 
 Blundering into Harriet's treetrunks. 
 The glimpsed lawn seems all of a sudden to have shrunk, to shine like a tiny stage set, Harriet's slumped figure centre stage and the consoling bulk of the cottage thatch as backdrop. 
 She puts her arms gingerly and tenderly round an inscrutable black trunk. 
 Is it oak, ash or thorn? 
 How do I get to own a tree? she cries up. 
 I want a tree. 
 I want the tall high beechtrees round my bedroom window, I want the night rustle of the wind round the house, in moonlight or the beginning of rain or storms&hellip; 
 I want the clouds sweeping over the stubble when I creep and stand on the front steps after reading all night, and our owls hoot, and everyone's sleeping upstairs, sleeping sound, in quiet bedrooms. 
 And all the time I'm taking further steps away. 
 First, here in my own country, a few baby steps, and now, other people, other places, other lands. 
 &bquo;I'll be your home,&equo; said Jeff with loving arrogance when she grew panicky. 
 But one man, one person, can't be home, she has to keep from panicking, trust she's doing right, that's all. 
 She sees: not Harriet&hellip; but her mother. 
 &hellip; She was crouching over some flower bed, I see her, always, extracting some weed or other. 
 How hunky dory she kept it all. 
 The flowers I loved were hers. 
 She with, it's true, Janey's help, cooked, served, washed up, cleaned, drove us here, there and everywhere, the doctor, school, the dentist, up to London for nerve-racking bouts of clothes shopping, she had the Nigels to stay, and laughed at the J ills at the garage and I'd've died if she'd found out about Paul. 
 She gave us parties and disapproved of me teaching: Jennifer darling, surely you can get a job in a nice private girls' school But when I was 14 and had awful tonsillitis she brought me lemon and honey and sat on the edge of the pillow holding my damp hand. 
 High boned face, blue-eyed, faded permed lock of fair hair flopping over her eyes. 
  She pushed it back, and wiped the same hand on the Beatrix Potter apron Harriet had made her for her birthday. 
 &bquo;Did I ever tell you about when Daddy and I went to Greece on our honeymoon. 
 I was so pleased,&equo; she looked at me shyly or was it a little slyly, &bquo;I could understand from knowing my Classics what the old peasants were saying. 
 They talked so beautifully to us, they had names like Agamemnon or Thetis. 
 I could understand them but Daddy couldn't. 
 I couldn't help feeling pleased though I was ashamed of myself&hellip; 
 Go to sleep now, darling.&equo; 
 Why did she belong to Harriet then? 
 Why? 
 Why does Harriet get everything? 
 Trees, home&hellip; 
 Her tears are wetting the treetrunk. 
 She pats it apologetically. 
 Perhaps it will tell her why. 
 Birds of a feather flock together &mdash; Her head is rustling minutely, the back of her skull. 
 She turns round and a white sheet flaps, a white sail sails, a white wraith passes silently in front of her eyes. 
 Then it's gone into the dark, into the wood further. 
 DTs? 
 No, she's not that far gone. 
 From the insides of the wood comes a piercing screech. 
 Her neck prickles, this must be her hair going up on end. 
 She flounders and leaps towards the kindly light, towards her Princess Harriet asleep on her lawn. 
 Suddenly it's all thorns, she comes to a full stop, caught and blind in a thicket of thorns like Abraham's sacrificial ram. 
 &bquo;Jen? 
 I've got a torch.&equo; 
 Harriet, hiccuping, stands with the beam shining at her feet, waving it unsteadily up into her eyes. 
 &bquo;Stop cursing. 
 You're nearly out.&equo; 
 The edge of the lawn, it seems, is two feet further. 
 &bquo;Now, now, good feminists don't use words like that.&equo; 
 Harriet's doubled up laughing, the beam is shaking on seas of brambles. 
 &bquo;When you lot seize the land back again make sure you know about ban owls first,&equo; she's choking, &bquo;you're so keen on wild life. 
 Ha ha. 
 Teach you to take Maggie's  name in vain. 
 Oh. 
 Oh!&equo; 
 Harriet's sobbing and she herself is st ill cursing and her head's spinning and spinning and they lurch into each other, and Harriet isn't Princess H any more, cool and cocky, she's sad too, mysteriously, unglamorously, and she hugs her and feels how slight she is and it seems she's luckier than Harriet, well, just now. 
 Inside the cottage the telephone is ringing. 
 &bquo;Come on, Harriet, it's Jeff. 
 Hey, you're gonna have a brother. 
 How about that! 
 C'mon.&equo; 
 Dancing and swaying and sniffing past jasmine and roses, out of the moonlight, and Jeff says, at last, &bquo;Hi, honey, is that my beautiful English princess?&equo; 
 And Harriet, clasping the receiver, says nothing and, pale and fragile, hands it over. 
 And she says, &bquo;Come off it, my man, who d'you think you're talking to, a mere jumped up commoner princess.&equo; 
 So Harriet gives a half giggle half sob. 
 And Jeff says: &bquo;Honey, I've got an urgent message from my mother. 
 She says to tell you she's seen Princess Di's wedding dress in a Coney Island store front and should she check it out for you?&equo; 
 And she says, &bquo;Piss off, you great hairy Yank, d'you know, actually I love you ever so much.&equo; 
 Harriet puts her head on Jen's shoulder, her long straight strange hair fanning across Jen's breast as if it were her own hair, and her own short, coppery/gingery hair stops standing on end at the ghost in the wood and begins to flow loose. 
 And Jen thinks: I'll never go back home, never.  
 A KIND OF DESIRED VISION 
 Kate Pullinger 
 Starting with the Belgian chocolates, desire seemed a potent and dynamic force, like a nuclear engine, high-powered and probably lethal. 
 The chocolates made her melt, sticky, gooey, and desire made her harden, glass blown by fire. 
 She flexed her muscles and felt strong and American, like an airforce base in a foreign country. 
 Strength, however, was not part of the problem-He, of course, was a married man, a married Englishman, like Trevor Howard or James Mason in an early role. 
 Beneath his pale and archetypally reserved exterior something burned and melted, hardened then softened. 
 She could tell this by looking at his back as he stood at the bar ordering more drinks. 
 His long neck was tinged a bright pink as though reflecting some internal glow. 
 He had just given her the chocolates and she had kissed him. 
 After their lips parted, he sank into the tatty, beer-stained seat, then suddenly stood, knocking his knees on the edge of the table. 
 She felt she had shocked him and his response was to wing slightly out of control. 
 The colour of his neck faded as he returned to the table with the drinks. 
 They were colleagues at the university. 
 She was not married. 
 She was new to the country and did not have many friends. 
 It was not like her to flirt  with married Englishmen. 
 Her sexual habits had changed with the times and, besides, in England all the signifiers seemed different. 
 Here the semiotics of sexuality were not her own. 
 Like celibacy, chocolates seemed an old-fashioned gesture, from another time although perfectly appropriate now. 
 Perhaps romance had snuck back into vogue, she thought, along with the new sexual caution. 
 Chocolates, especially European ones, were decadent and luxurious, like love-letters and long kisses: something one's parents had before they married. 
 Soft-centred milk chocolates that came as one bit them seemed almost as exciting as dancing with someone you knew you were about to sleep with used to be. 
 His marriage to another woman, an immutable fact, posed even greater restrictions on their fledgling nuclear romance. 
 Infidelity had become freshly dangerous, potentially much more lethal to a marriage than adultery had been previously. 
 Restraint carried with it nobility, safety, a new kind of self-respect. 
 &bquo;Would you like another chocolate?&equo; she said leaning against his shoulder. 
 His leather jacket smelt raw, his jeans felt soft and worn. 
 He was dressed like an American, it was she who looked English in her patched tweed jacket and jodhpurs. 
 She looked horsey as well as strong, like a kind of repellent Country Living  housewife. 
 But her clothes were not literal, as clothes rarely are; she was as much a bloodsportswoman as he was a baseball fan. 
 Still, he was married, even if he didn't look it. 
 What do married people look like? 
 &bquo;Let's go away for the weekend,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;What about your wife?&equo; 
 &bquo;She can stay home. 
 I'll say it's work.&equo; 
 &bquo;She won't believe you. 
 It's such a clich&eacute;.&equo; 
 They paused and poured alcohol into their systems. 
 &bquo;Anyway, what would we do? 
 Play chess?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 We'd go for long walks and eat hot meals and watch the sunset. 
 We'd kiss with the wind in our faces. 
  I'd hold you close and feel your heartbeat.&equo; 
 He placed a chocolate under his tongue and waited for it to melt down. 
 She looked at him longingly, Wondering if he really did want to have an affair with her. 
 She had a theory that English men enjoyed sex even less than her male compatriots. 
 She was still allowed to like it, wasn't she? 
 Maybe this new restraint appealed to most people, perhaps everyone felt more comfortable with prudishness. 
 &bquo;I want to look at you without any clothes on,&equo; she said suddenly as she watched him suck his chocolate. 
 His neck began to glow again. 
 He moaned softly. 
 &bquo;I want to see you naked.&equo; 
 The people at the next table moved their chairs forward imperceptibly. 
 He closed his eyes and leaned back. 
 &bquo;I want to run my hands down the length of your legs. 
 Both of them. 
 One at a time.&equo; 
 He moaned more loudly and the people at the next table held their drinks in mid-air. 
 She leaned back against the seat, her hands pressed between her own legs. 
 The lights in the pub flickered like a fluttering heart, a clenching and rumbling nervous gut. 
 After a while he stopped shaking and bit into another chocolate. 
 Its softness covered his teeth, coating his tongue. 
 In a voice thick with sugar and lust he said, &bquo;You are driving me wild. 
 I don't understand you.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You are so foreign and yet so familiar. 
 Like sex itself, I guess, a kind of desired invasion.&equo; 
 They fucked like chickens, their feathers ruffled, pecking and scratching at nothing, everything. 
 She grappled with him as he pressed against her, pushing him away and urging him on. 
 He tried to be controlled, even a bit leisurely, but as he pulled back he could not help but rush forward again. 
 He felt the condom tear inside her. 
 It was all he could do to stop. 
 &bquo;It broke,&equo; he said.  
 &bquo;Shit.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is there another?&equo; 
 &bquo;Over here somewhere.&equo; 
 She crawled away and scrabbled over the junk on the bedside table, returning with the foil-wrapped encumbrance. 
 &bquo;Let's try again.&equo; 
 They had been fucking like this for a few months, slyly, without letting on to the outside world. 
 They would meet in her flat &mdash; the weekend away was still talked about although not realized. 
 He would arrive at her door and they would begin right away, sometimes before he took his coat off. 
 They did not talk much, what was there to say? 
 She saw more than enough in the guilt and pleasure on his face to make questions redundant. 
 It would not go anywhere; there was nowhere for it to go. 
 She could not take him back to America with her, he could not take her home. 
 They had sex protected from each other, the little slip of rubber a true barrier made of caution and sensibility. 
 Because of it they simply could not plunder on ahead without thinking. 
 They always had to pause and reflect. 
 &bquo;In my country,&equo; she began like a student from abroad, &bquo;the English are often thought of as fey.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hmph. 
 In my country,&equo; he mocked her slightly, &bquo;Americans are often thought of as vulgar.&equo; 
 &bquo;How fey.&equo; 
 He pushed harder today, knowing he would not hurt her. 
 She wrapped herself around him like a clam in formation, her body one big muscle, straining. 
 When he came he had to pull away quickly so as not to spill a drop of his bodily fluids, like the instructions on the box of condoms said. 
 She reminded him of somebody from a movie, maybe it was Kathleen Turner in Body Heat , sometimes Kim Basinger in 9&frac12; Weeks . 
 Not an old movie star but someone new and less defined, whose character melted into a dozen different actresses. 
 Like her, he relied on clich&eacute;s for guidance, for cross-cultural understanding. 
 He thought he would like to be more like her; when she  spoke people listened. 
 It was the twang in her vowels that commanded attention, people thought to themselves &bquo;here's someone from a Woody Allen movie.&equo; 
 And she capitalized on this, she saw where it could be to her advantage to be perceived as a celluloid creation. 
 Some afternoons they talked at cross purposes; it was not just their vocabulary that differed. 
 He would appear cold and withdrawn, tormented with guilt over his wife. 
 She would become overly effusive in response, feeling hopelessly alone. 
 &bquo;Are you mad?&equo; she would ask, meaning &bquo;Are you angry?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he would reply shortly, thinking she was implying he was mad &mdash; insane &mdash; with desire for her (which, in a way, he was). 
 Then they would thrash out their anxieties in bed, moaning and coming to false understandings. 
 Two cultures rarely understand each other, especially when one is waxing dominant. 
 The weaker often needs to copy the stronger &mdash; for every one of her foreign bombing campaigns conducted with supreme arrogance and ruthless certainty he had his own dirty little war on distant barren islands, his own vicious murders on the Rock. 
 Were they playing out these scenarios in sex? 
 Did he want to be dominated? 
 One night he put a Belgian chocolate inside her and as it melted he licked away the cream. 
 &bquo;Do they have Marmite in America yet?&equo; he asked. 
 She broke off mid-moan to reply. 
 &bquo;We'll never have Marmite over there. 
 It's you who will get peanut butter over here. 
 That's the way Imperialism works.&equo; 
 She was coated with chocolate as he pushed inside her. 
 His marriage seemed like the Atlantic Ocean to her, something vast and unknowable which she could not attempt to bridge but only fly over at a terrible speed. 
 It kept them apart, kept them foreign to each other, him unhaveable, her unhad. 
 After a year his wife still appeared not to have noticed  the smell of another woman on her husband's face. 
 He was always careful to wash his chiselled visage, of course, but in a year of passion one would think some small scent would have escaped, a tracking odour that would put her senses on alert. 
 It was time for the Other Woman to go back to America. 
 Her academic job had run its course. 
 She had found England a cold place. 
 The rooms where she lived were damp, even while the brief summer had passed. 
 Her career beckoned, the Atlantic Ocean dimmed and became crossable. 
 Still, there was the problem of her married Englishman. 
 Would she simply leave him behind? 
 Would she just move away and forget? 
 One afternoon in bed in her flat she said, &bquo;I will be leaving soon, you know.&equo; 
 He sat up, surprised. 
 &bquo;I thought you had the afternoon free.&equo; 
 &bquo;I do. 
 It's the rest of the time I'm talking about. 
 I have to go home.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought you liked it here, I thought you thought it was fun living in England and sleeping with me.&equo; 
 &bquo;I do. 
 But I can't be a tourist forever.&equo; 
 They argued about it for the rest of the afternoon, he becoming sullen and sorry, she remaining dispassionate, untouched-She was impressed by his sudden remorse. 
 She had always felt insulated from pain with him, as if the condoms served to forever prevent them from getting unhealthily close. 
 Now he was filling their relationship with a seriousness she had always assumed it could not possibly contain. 
 &bquo;Don't you think,&equo; he began to plead, &bquo;that sleeping together automatically provides us with a kind of contract?&equo; 
 &bquo;A legal document? 
 Fucking gives us certain rights over each other? 
 I fuck you therefore I owe you?&equo; 
 &bquo;You can be so crude sometimes,&equo; he said as though wounded. 
 &bquo;It's in my blood,&equo; she replied.  
 &bquo;I think your blood runs a bit cold,&equo; he said, helping himself to a bit of cruelty. 
 &bquo;You are the one who is married,&equo; she said, &bquo;not me. 
 I know what that means. 
 I know what married people look like.&equo; 
 &bquo;Huh?&equo; he said, like an American. 
 &bquo;What do married people look like?&equo; 
 She paused and then smiled and said, &bquo;They wear rings around their fingers and have ties around their hearts.&equo;  
 AWAY GAMES 
 Moya Roddy 
 Olive parked badly and swore. 
 slamming the car door she trotted rather than walked &mdash; towards the flat-roofed building dominating the quiet cul-de-sac. 
 As she rounded the gates of the school she saw him sitting on a low wall, his little legs dangling, swinging backwards and forwards. 
 &bquo;Colm!&equo; she yelled. 
 His head jerked up in her direction then went back to studying the ground. 
 Something was wrong &mdash; she sensed it. 
 He kept his face averted while she drew nearer but when she was nearly beside him he turned it to her almost defiantly. 
 She gasped at the sight of the blood beginning to cake under his nose. 
 &bquo;Darling!&equo; 
 Quickly she folded her arms round him then just as quickly pulled back to inspect his swollen nose and mouth. 
 &bquo;What happened? 
 Were ye in a fight?&equo; 
 Colm didn't answer. 
 He began to swing his legs again, vigorously. 
 He studied them, blocking her out. 
 &bquo;Will ye not tell me what it was ye were fighting over?&equo; 
 Olive stroked his arm gently, coaxing. 
 He didn't exactly push her away. 
 Instead he stuck his chin in his hand, so removing his arm from her touch. 
 Olive gave up.  
 &bquo;It's all right, you can tell mammy when we get home. 
 There's a good boy.&equo; 
 But Colm wouldn't budge. 
 The grim look on his young face as she washed off the dried blood frightened her. 
 When she'd finished he sat at the kitchen table, watching her getting his tea ready, brooding. 
 Thank God it's Friday, she thought, Steve and her could have a relaxing evening, open a bottle&hellip; 
 As she cleared the table the headline of the Evening Standard  caught her eye: ENGLAND MUST WIN! 
 Fuck, she'd forgotten the World Cup was on. 
 He'd want to watch it. 
 When she put the fish fingers and oven chips in front of Colm &mdash; his favourites, he almost smiled at her. 
 &bquo;Will ye not tell mammy?&equo; she ran a hand through his soft hair. 
 Slowly he finished what was in his mouth, his eyes roaming the plate. 
 Then he raised them and met hers. 
 &bquo;Mammy am I Irish?&equo; 
 Olive had been expecting so many horrors that hearing the question she almost laughed with relief. 
 &bquo;Well of course you're Irish. 
 Haven't we been home loads to times to where Granny and all your cousins&hellip; 
 &equo; A thought suddenly struck her and she stopped. 
 &bquo;Why, has someone been saying you're not?&equo; 
 Olive felt her temper rise. 
 The school he went to had a fair number of second and third generation Irish &mdash; these days even first generation &mdash; and she was glad of that. 
 She wanted him to have contact with other Irish kids and families, as a sort of bulwark against the swamp of English culture. 
 Was some bastard getting at Colm because his father was English? 
 &bquo;Is that what ye were fighting over? 
 My poor baby&hellip;&equo; 
 She put her arm round him but he pushed her away. 
 &bquo;But I was born in England wasn't I?&equo; 
 &bquo;That doesn't matter. 
 It's not important where you're born.&equo; 
 She stopped. 
 Even she didn't believe that. 
 How could she? 
 Quickly she sorted out her thoughts and began again.  
 &bquo;I mean it's important but it's not the only important thing. 
 I'm Irish and you're my child, so you're Irish. 
 You'd have been born in Ireland if things, history and all had been different.&equo; 
 She was on firmer ground again. 
 She hurried on. 
 &bquo;It's like a feeling, you know you're Irish even if you're born here.&equo; 
 She stopped again. 
 Could a seven-year-old understand that? 
 &bquo;But daddy's English and I was born here. 
 That's two things, that makes me English.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what I'm trying to explain. 
 It doesn't. 
 You mustn't mind what kids say. 
 You're Irish and you're proud of it.&equo; 
 He shoved the half-empty plate away and jumped up from the table. 
 At the door he turned, his face ashen. 
 &bquo;I'm not, I'm not. 
 That's what they were saying and I fought them.&equo; 
 His eyes blazed. 
 &bquo;I'm English.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thanks.&equo; 
 Olive took the glass of wine, sniffed at it and downed half in one go. 
 She settled back on the pillow. 
 &bquo;I needed that.&equo; 
 Steve pulled the duvet over the two of them and began fiddling with the remote control. 
 &bquo;D'you know because so many people switch off their TVs by remote control instead of pulling out the plug, they go on using electricity, the same in one night that would power Leicester for one day. 
 Or is it Hull?&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that what you learned at school today?&equo; 
 Steve teased her. 
 &bquo;Well teacher&equo; &mdash; he stopped and upped the volume. 
 &bquo;It's starting. 
 This is the life. 
 Are you sure you want to watch it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Have I any choice?&equo; 
 &bquo;You could wash the dishes.&equo; 
 He put his arm round her. 
 &bquo;Maybe seeing England getting thrashed will cheer you up.&equo; 
 He paused. 
 &bquo;The kick-off isn't for ten minutes. 
 Would you like me to speak to Colm?&equo;  
 &bquo;Not unless he brings it up. 
 D'ye know Steve, I've been thinking. 
 Remember I thought of having him in Ireland - I wish I had. 
 But I suppose I thought it was, like I was trying to tell him today, a gut feeling, being Irish. 
 It's probably a phase he's going through&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Thanks very much. 
 Some of us are stuck with it.&equo; 
 Sorry was on the tip of her tongue when a thought struck her with such force she lay back to fathom its meaning. 
 She stared hard at the black curly hairs on the neck of the man she'd married nine years before. 
 She followed the contours of his hairline to the almost kiss curl that hung over one of his eyes, the eye she could see now staring intelligently at a group of men &mdash; Englishmen like himself &mdash; discussing the prospects of the English team. 
 She heard the various accents and identified them without thinking, Cockney, West Country, and a thick nasal Mancunian. 
 Then she blurted the thought out: &bquo;D'you know I've never thought of you as really English. 
 I know you are but&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;That's probably a compliment.&equo; 
 He looked her straight in the face. 
 &bquo;Colm has a point. 
 He's half and half, in fact a little bit more English if you weigh it up.&equo; 
 Not quite quickly enough Olive tried to shut out a second thought: that she would never, could never, have married an Englishman. 
 Jesus what did that mean? 
 Whatever it meant she wasn't going to think about it. 
 Not now. 
 Besides it was Colm they were talking about. 
 &bquo;That's not true, I've brought him up Irish.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right, I'm only pulling your leg.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can afford to.&equo; 
 &bquo;I have my own problems. 
 You mightn't think it but it would be nice to feel proud of where you come from. 
 That's something you have. 
 Anyway if you're feeling like this maybe we shouldn't watch the match &mdash; you might start attacking me.&equo; 
 But Olive needed to watch the match, needed a diversion from the thoughts spinning round her head. 
  She punched him playfully. 
 &bquo;We'll watch it, I want to see England beaten by Morocco. 
 I bet they think they can waltz home.&equo; 
 He squeezed her. 
 &bquo;I didn't know you were a secret football fan. 
 Here, it's starting.&equo; 
 &bquo;It would be hard not to be. 
 Tim and Richard talk about nothing else in the staff room. 
 I could give you a blow-by-blow account of how England lost to Portugal the other night. 
 Sorry, how Portugal &bquo;stole&equo; the match. 
 England never loses&hellip;&equo; 
 Steve held up a hand interrupting her. 
 &bquo;I hope you're not going to talk all the way through it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fuck off.&equo; 
 But she shut up and lay back forcing her eyes to focus on the two groups of men in their different coloured shirts battling for the ball. 
 She tried joining her mind to the millions of people everywhere glued to screens for this all important match but all she could see was Colm's pudgy little legs swinging backwards and forwards and the grim look on his face as she washed away the crusted blood. 
 It was strange &mdash; hard &mdash; to think about something she took for granted. 
 Being Irish for her was synonymous with being. 
 Mind you when she went home she noticed her accent was getting worse and worse and she was picking up a sort of English reticence or so they enjoyed telling her. 
 Here she was &bquo;so Irish&equo;, a kind of veiled racism or compliment: it depended on her mood or the person saying it how she took it. 
 And now Colm&hellip; 
 She laughed to herself. 
 Maybe there should be a rule if Irish and English people had children they should be brought up Irish &mdash; the way the Catholic Church used to insist on the children of Catholics and Protestants being brought up Catholic. 
 But just as quickly she remembered herself, barely thirteen, standing up in class and saying she didn't think the Catholic Church was fair and the nun, red in the face, asking who did she think she was to question the Pope's teaching. 
 Steve's roar filled the room. 
 &bquo;A goal?&equo;  
 Steve sighed despondently. 
 &bquo;The English are playing so they won't lose. 
 No one's taking any chances. 
 Look!&equo; 
 He glared at the screen scornfully. 
 &bquo;That crossball was pathetic. 
 They should sack the bloody manager. 
 Y'know when England had men like Bobby Charlton, they knew what to do if they got the ball. 
 This shower just do what they're told.&equo; 
 Olive loved it when Steve got excited like this, somehow it always reminded her of her father. 
 &bquo;Look there's Hoddle &mdash; he's good when he's playing for Tottenham but look at him now.&equo; 
 Names like Danny Blanchflower and Christy Ring, shouts of &bquo;Up Down&equo; and &bquo;C'mon the Dube&equo; crowded into her mind from the dinner tables of her childhood. 
 The voice of Michael O'Heiner on the radio&hellip; 
 &bquo;Daddy who's playing?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ssshh &mdash; go and play, there's a good girl.&equo; 
 Steve slumped deflated. 
 &bquo;It's a real example of Thatcher's Britain. 
 Do what the boss says even if it means annihilating yourself.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm glad. 
 I want them to lose. 
 C'mon Morocco!&equo; she cheered but it was half-hearted. 
 She snuggled closer into Steve's body searching assurance. 
 &bquo;I thought you wanted them to lose too.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well at least Morocco are trying to score,&equo; was all he replied. 
 &bquo;If you've just joined us,&equo; the commentator's voice droned, &bquo;there's no score in this all important match but England can be admired for holding their own, down to ten men and against a Moroccan team that's used to the sort of heat&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you hear that Steve, they wouldn't say the opposite if it was raining.&equo; 
 She stuck her tongue out at the television. 
 As she did one of the English players danced across the screen and up the sideline, outwitting several of the Moroccan side who tackled him from all directions. 
 Olive grabbed Steve's arm.  
 &bquo;That's Hoddle isn't it? 
 C'mon Hoddle, waddle, dawdle, kick it!&equo; 
 &bquo;You're getting very excited.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can't bear them being such idiots&hellip; eigits,&equo; she corrected herself quickly using the Irish word. 
 &bquo;Cheer Morocco then.&equo; 
 Olive wasn't going to admit it but she was finding it hard to identify with the Moroccans. 
 &bquo;Oh no,&equo; Steve groaned, &bquo;they're bringing on Steven. 
 They should put Barnes in.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who's he?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's brilliant. 
 Got the best goal ever scored against Brazil. 
 Steven is a bloody midfielder.&equo; 
 &bquo;What does&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Sshh&hellip; 
 Hoddle's got it&hellip; he's going to try.&equo; 
 Steve's voice was at breaking point. 
 &bquo;C'mon. 
 C'mon&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Score England, score&equo; Olive screamed. 
 She grabbed Steve's sleeve, their eyes in unison watched the ball sail through the air and high over the net. 
 They both sagged. 
 After a moment Steve looked at her. 
 &bquo;You cheered England.&equo; 
 Olive stared back at him. 
 She felt flushed and drained, angry and ashamed all at the same time. 
 &bquo;I can't bear seeing them throwing it away, that's all. 
 You were cheering them to.&equo; 
 But Steve had gone back to the match, his face rigid with anticipation. 
 &bquo;There's only a few minutes left, they'll never&hellip; wait wait, Steven has it, he's come from nowhere and yes, he's going for a shot!&hellip;&equo; 
 Olive closed her eyes. 
 &bquo;I'm not watching. 
 I hope they lose.&equo; 
 It was ridiculous getting so excited over a game. 
 How would she explain that sort of behaviour to Colm? 
 Oh, she knew well enough there were thousands of Irish who followed English clubs but there were thousands who would choke before they'd cheer an English team and she was one of them. 
 She'd got carried away on Steve's excitement, that was all. 
 That's not true, she  told herself. 
 Admit it, you wanted England to win. 
 She stiffened. 
 C'mon, secretly just between you and me the voice persisted in her head, it would be hard not to. 
 They're your team really. 
 You're half English now anyway, you live in England, you're married to an Englishman, Colm&hellip; 
 The commentator shrieked into her reverie. 
 She opened her eyes and not trusting her tongue any longer simply looked at Steve. 
 &bquo;It's over. 
 No score.&equo; 
 She turned over and buried her head in the pillow. 
 She felt sick. 
 She wished she hadn't watched the match. 
 She wished she could turn back the clock. 
 But to when? a voice asked. 
 To earlier when they'd turned on the TV? 
 To when she collected Colm from school? 
 Or right back to the day she married Steve, or took the boat to England? 
 Or maybe even further than that: to those warm sunny days when she sat watching her Daddy and asking him questions and he told her like he always did - &bquo;Go and play, there's a good girl.&equo;  
 THE CROSS IS GONE 
 Ben Okri 
 It was a day of fairs 
 Yellow music on the wind, feathers 
 Of dead birds whirling beyond 
 The green trees. 
 We walked up into the Heath 
 Passed a man riding a baby's bicycle 
 And the paths confused us. 
 It had rained, the earth was soggy 
 Beneath the deceptive grass. 
 We strayed past trees that bore 
 The features of dying men. 
 All around us the trees were heaving. 
 Their comrades had fallen 
 The great spirits trapped in their monstrous 
 Trunks sang in the cold air 
 Songs of white mermaids 
 Corrupted beyond their time. 
 Their comrades had fallen 
 They who had witnessed the sordidness 
 And the miracles of three hundred years 
 Felled in an instant of nightspace 
 By the karmic hurricanes 
 Of an unconfronted history.  
 Like old elephants, their trunks inscrutable, 
 Breathing lamentations on the unforgiving earth 
 Into which they will not be reborn, 
 The trees sang to us of a darkening age 
 With mysteries dying 
 And yellow spirits in the wind. 
 We passed their hulks 
 On the graveyard of the Heath 
 We said nothing about them 
 We talked about a single voice 
 From oppressed spaces 
 That could bring down thunder on corrupt lands 
 And about tyranny unleashing wounds on itself 
 That bleeds through us, the innocent journeyers 
 Into forbidden zones of dying gods. 
 We passed them quickly 
 Noting the character and psychology 
 Of each surviving tree &mdash; 
 Then, from the valley, we looked up high 
 And saw three kites, 
 One red, another of blue, 
 The third of gold, invisibly attached 
 To a black cross, 
 Bold against the sky. 
 We climbed Parliament H ill 
 Our spirits heaving, our breaths 
 Quickening, the earth slipping beneath our feet. 
 The sky quivered with silent birds. 
 With our ascent we noticed a gathered crowd,  
 An old woman with a yellow scarf 
 A black man with a red beret on his bald head 
 Children playing with strings 
 A nun with frozen hands 
 An Irish priest wearing metal-framed glasses 
 An enormous bible under his arm 
 A wand in one hand, the string of the red 
 Kite in the other. 
 We approached them, holding 
 Fast to our invisible trail, breathing 
 Heavily the rarified air: 
 And when we gained the hill top 
 The Cross shivered 
 A strong wind, smelling of incense and radiation, 
 And disease and French perfume and hidden wars, 
 Blew over from the distant Thames. 
 We saw all the world laid out 
 Before us in the air 
 A city perceived in a moment's enchantment 
 Whose history, weighed down with guilt and machines, 
 Laughed all around us like ghosts 
 Who do not believe the existence 
 Of men. 
 We saw the city and marvelled. 
 We dream the city better 
 Than it dreams itself. 
 The air and distance weave such burning 
 Miracles from the houses and church spires 
 The towers and glass offices of multinationals. 
 We dream the housing estates, built on  marshes; 
 The woods, sad and defiant; 
 The chaos of buildings, the threaded streets, 
 Where madmen wander alone, 
 Where men dream of impossible women, 
 And women of non-existent men, 
 With each pursuing instant fulfilment 
 Orgasm without end 
 Love without responsibility 
 Miracle without pain 
 Transformation without knowledge 
 Difficult dreams, doomed to abortions 
 And sick births 
 Blind births, one-eyed births. 
 In the phantasm of the city 
 Glacial vision prevails 
 While voices from the marshes vainly cried out 
 That they are the victims and hostages 
 Of the history their parents accepted 
 In silence. 
 The world lay before us 
 And the wind stayed still. 
 We wandered round the Irish priest 
 Not daring to approach 
 How would we be received? 
 And then a bitter wind blew the kites 
 And one got stuck, blue on green, against 
 The branches of a fallen tree &mdash; 
 We wandered round the crowd 
 And gazed at the cross 
 Upon which was written, on that wintry day, 
 Summery with the blessedness of its naming &mdash; 
 For it was Easter Sunday &mdash; 
 The words, clear as glass: 
 Christ is dead  
 Christ is risen 
 Christ will come again &mdash; 
 And our spirits soared, mixing with the clouds 
 Of deep colour &mdash; 
 A child's cry of delight 
 Sent the golden kite upwards. 
 The priest's cassock lifted and was whipped 
 By the winds of four directions. 
 Voices became sweet on the air. 
 In the distance below, the three lakes 
 Shimmered &mdash; the wind carved its many names 
 On the face of the waters. 
 We went down and dwelled 
 In the solitude of swans. 
 We talked of painting, love, and adventures. 
 My friend's face was reddened by her red coat. 
 We heard the fair and followed the jangling music 
 Through the wet trails 
 And came upon cacophony. 
 We dwelled in the fair, listened to the conflicting 
 Noises, watched the faces of ticket sellers, 
 And the machines like windmills sending 
 The children into the air 
 Of artificial stimulation 
 And the gadgets and games and bumper cars 
 That once filled our adolescence with longing 
 But which left us hungry and empty now. 
 We left the fair followed by the smell 
 Of mass-cooked sausages, by dogs  
 Dragging hamburgers between their teeth &mdash; 
 We left the day behind us, with the view 
 From Parliament Hill 
 Forever bright in our vision. 
 We went back to our lives of ordinary miracles 
 With the joy of that day lost in us 
 Till three days later when she returned 
 From a long walk &mdash; 
 She didn't look sad, or disappointed: 
 But in that tone of voice we reserve 
 For events that should be underlined 
 Except we don't know why, or how, or with what accentuation 
 To underline them 
 Make them speak 
 Make them significant &mdash; 
 And with a disturbed, imperceptible tossing 
 Of her head 
 A movement of her shoulders 
 A hand launching itself into the air 
 But holding back 
 She said, simply, without mystery: 
 &bquo;The cross &mdash; That cross &mdash; is gone.&equo; 
 I SWEEP THE SUN OFF ROOFTOPS 
 Hanan Al-Shayakh 
 Like a thirsty horse making for water, I lunged. 
 But I wasn't thirsty. 
 I was on fire. 
 I threw the water over the English boy and his friend, and the fire blazed in my head and heart and between my legs. 
 Images kept on coming at me which, like a crazy horse, I tried to resist, defiantly tossing my head high, but each new picture flashing into my mind enraged me more and more and I shook my head frantically from side to side. 
 Seeing Saad laid out on the floor, dumb and silent. 
 Saad, whose mighty voice had welled up from his entrails. 
 Now his wife seemed to have snatched his voice to lament for him, joined by her daughters, by his aunts and sisters, all beating their faces and rubbing ash and black soot on to their cheeks. 
 The English pigeon devouring the remains of the couscous, without a pause, immersing its whole beak and head in the grains while I smiled at it, saying: &bquo;You seem to like couscous from a packet. 
 I suppose it's because you're an English pigeon. 
 You're used to things out of packets.&equo; 
 Aisha's insistent words in the grain store, as she shook her gold earrings and the bangles on her wrist, urging me to stay at home, but I could only gaze at her  shoes and marvel at how exactly they matched her handbag. 
 Then I am standing in Aisha's house with its Moroccan furniture and Moroccan smell, hardly able to believe that I'm in London, having braved the customs official who turned my passport over and over in his hands. 
 The letter with my name in English on the envelope, a Moroccan stamp, and a list of requests from my family for a white bridal veil to go with my sister's wedding dress, surgical stockings for my brother and a china dish for my mother. 
 Offering the blond English boy &mdash; the one I was throwing water at now &mdash; half my lunch, and sitting there full of gratitude because he smiled, because he liked the taste of the piece of chicken dipped in cumin and saffron and he had smiled at me for the first time. 
 I wanted his approval because he was English. 
 I wanted the approval of everyone from the bus conductor to the Pakistani shopkeeper, because he owned a shop and spoke English. 
 Being lost in the underground, tears running down my cheeks. 
 Learning to decipher the names of the stations. 
 Learning them by heart as if they were magic signs. 
 I was throwing water at the English boy and his friend and they were yelling, &bquo;She's crazy. 
 Jesus Christ, she's completely crazy!&equo; 
 I was transformed into a raging bull, and everything turned red. 
 He started up at my scream and I saw the dark blood on him and on me. 
 Then he'd jumped to his feet as if he'd been bitten by a snake, shouting, &bquo;You're a virgin! 
 You're still a virgin! 
 I don't understand you.&equo; 
 I didn't chew my nails with regret at giving him my virginity, furious at my weakness in lying down for him, and taking this boy in my arms just because he was English, a citizen of that great nation which had once ruled half the globe: nor did I blame myself for clinging on to an idea even though it meant severing my  links with my country, and travelling to London alone without any member of my family. 
 Instead of striking my face and grieving aloud because my hymen was no longer intact, I wondered, &bquo;Is it because he's an Englishman that he doesn't feel proud he's taken my virginity, or is he frightened that now I'll try to force him to marry me?&equo; 
 I tried to tell him that I didn't blame him for deflowering me but he wasn't listening. 
 He just went on saying in a shocked way, as if he had lost his mind, &bquo;You're twenty-five, thirty years old? 
 And you're still a virgin? 
 Jesus Christ, I don't understand you. 
 I just don't understand at all.&equo; 
 He didn't go to the bathroom to wash, he stayed in the room. 
 Out of the corner of my eye I watched him wipe himself with Kleenex tissues and drop them on the floor, indifferent to the smears of blood on them. 
 He pulled on his trousers and went quickly over to turn up the music, moving his head from side to side in time to the beat. 
 He lay face down beside me, not knowing that I was now painfully aware that the threads which bound me to home and the inevitable marriage had snapped once and for all. 
 I could see myself on the roof of our house, as, for the last time, I spread the couscous out to dry on a sheet in the sun before my journey to London: I could see the village below me: the tops of the trees, the minaret, the ancient wall which ran round my village. 
 I could think of nothing except going to London and finding my way among its tall buildings studded with lights. 
 I remembered the friend of Aisha's who'd helped me escape from her house in London, carrying one of Aisha's children, while I took my suitcase and dragged the other child along with me. 
 I could see her English neighbour shutting her front door in our faces, and yet all the same we left the two children there, rushing away after I'd pinched their cheeks to make them cry so that she'd have to come out to them.  
 I walked in the cold of London without tights, without an overcoat, without a jumper. 
 In Marks and Spencer's there were hundreds of dresses and jumpers and beautiful nightdresses. 
 I paid the woman at the cash desk and smiled at her. 
 She smiled back and said the coat I'd chosen was really pretty. 
 I was overjoyed. 
 She approved of my taste and I'd given her the right amount of money for the red coat which I st ill haven't worn. 
 Eagerly I was bending over the vacuum cleaner. 
 It was a magic broom to transport me to another world, from poverty to riches. 
 The implements available here for cleaning were as many and as varied in colour and smell as the places which I had to clean. 
 Aisha's gold chain which I'd carried away from her house hidden among my clothes was in my hands one moment and the next on the counter in the Oxford Street goldsmith's. 
 The red of my anger bubbled up like the rosy orange juice squeezed by the vendors' machines in the main street in our village. 
 It ran down between my eyes and made me see everything blood-red, even though seconds before my mind had conjured up a pleasing vision: the English boy's sister. 
 She was polite, she gave me a small box of chocolates with a thank-you card and kissed me and shook my hand when she came for a meal on Sunday. 
 She had been different from her brother and from his friends who used to visit, make themselves at home in my clean room, on the clean bed, delighted to find a video and a cassette recorder and cassettes, who ate my nice food and listened to loud music and swallowed the drink they brought with them. 
 They all said they wanted to visit my country and I nodded my head, promising it wouldn't cost them a penny, thinking how the people in the village would crowd around them, look at their coloured hair, some of it short and some long. 
 I smiled at them, heaped more food on to their plates, poured more mint tea or coffee into their cups. 
 I wanted their approval, even if they did smell so terrible,  the reek of their hair in its stiff, bright tufts mixing with the fumes of alcohol. 
 I began to alter my standards of hospitality, offering them my pale, cold face when their music grew louder, when they began laughing among themselves and didn't take the trouble to explain their jokes to me as they had before, or repeat their words until I understood what they were saying. 
 The English boy showed the others all the implements and products I had collected for cleaning and disinfecting, telling them I had a mania for cleanliness, and I'd once decided to wash all his clothes and he'd had to stay indoors the whole day. 
 I felt revolted by them and began to sleep in the hall, dragging a pillow and a wool blanket off the bed and leaving the room to them, in the hope that they would understand my anger, that they would no longer stay till the early hours of the morning, stepping over me as I lay asleep, leaving overflowing ashtrays and empty glasses and cans and bottles strewn about the floor. 
 Sometimes they were so drunk they fell asleep where they were and lay without pillows or covers until I returned from work, and then I would rage at them in Arabic, telling them that thanks to them my room was no better than the Italian's pigsty at home; we used to spit on the ground whenever we went near it, children and grownups alike, shouting exclamations of disgust, even though all we could see of it was the outer fence. 
 Why was I doing this? 
 Pouring water over them while they yelled back at me? 
 Perhaps this is what happened in the neighbouring rooms, which were occupied by all different people. 
 Their noise had stopped me sleeping: shouting, shattering glass, the word &bquo;police&equo; echoing here and there. 
 How glad I'd been in those first nights with him. 
 I'd believed the English boy would protect me from these sounds. 
 Now they were happening right inside my own room. 
 I tried to shout like the two of them, but my cry came out strangled and distorted; I just couldn't express  my anger in English. 
 So I reverted to the role of crazy horse, raging bull: wheeling, rearing, plunging, now attacking, now drawing back. 
 Were they shouting? 
 No, they were laughing. 
 Actually laughing. 
 It was the music that had brought me in from the hall where I had been lying. 
 A single note repeated over and over again, throbbing in my head, making my chest tighten. 
 I had to be rid of them, I decided. 
 I had to be rid of the English boy. 
 I'd give him a choice: he could either stay on his own or leave. 
 I knew he had no home, but that wasn't my problem. 
 I had to go in there immediately. 
 I had to pull the tape out of the machine, interrupt the music right in the middle of the song. 
 It had been on loud all evening, and now it was the early hours of the morning. 
 They had no sensitivity, no conscience. 
 I charged in like a bull. 
 When I saw no one in the middle of the room, which had been full of music and smoke and pungent with the smell of hashish, I thought he might have forgotten to turn off the music before he went to sleep. 
 I found myself thinking affectionately that I ought to be straightforward with him; the English liked that. 
 Perhaps he didn't understand why I'd become so angry and distant. 
 Suddenly I stopped and stood still, staring in amazement. 
 A man was lying by his side. 
 They were both naked. 
 They were lying in each other's arms. 
 I saw their uncircumcised members as clear as day and shuddered. 
 That was the first time I'd seen a man's penis so clearly and my mouth and throat went dry. 
 I went dry between my legs for several seconds, then I charged again. 
 Shocked, they started up, but they made no attempt to cover their nakedness. 
 Then, as if they'd recovered from the surprise, they began to laugh, snorting and giggling in delight at the water being thrown at them, like two children playing a game. 
 I had to be dreaming. 
 What I was seeing was surely the opposite of what was actually happening. 
 In reality  they should have been dumbfounded and embarrassed, wishing the floor would open up and swallow them. 
 Or hiding themselves from me, resorting to a whole range of lies and excuses. 
 How could the English boy go on living now that he'd been found out? 
 They continued to call on Jesus Christ, trying to dry themselves off, then laughing again. 
 The English boy pointed to my face, unable to control his mirth. 
 I must have looked like the mad ape that wandered the streets of our village with its gypsy owner. 
 Their laughter so infuriated me that I began to have thoughts of revenge. 
 But how, when he had nothing that I could take by force, steal, hide, break in front of him, tear up or trample underfoot, to vent my rage and spite? 
 All he owned were the clothes on his back and a few cassettes which I'd partly paid for anyway. 
 I looked wildly about me a hundred times, unable to think what to do; then I threw my coat on over my nightdress, pulled woollen socks over the wool trousers I wore to protect me from the cold, and ran to the door, without listening to what his friend was trying to say to me. 
 I went out and slammed the door behind me, turning the key in the lock as if I wanted to safeguard the proof of the crime and its only witnesses, repeating the same English phrase, over and over again, &bquo;Just you wait and see.&equo; 
 Then I went on in Arabic: &bquo;You'll be sorry. 
 Everybody's going to know. 
 I should have noticed. 
 You've been with me for a whole week now and you might just as well have been a girl, or a boy without balls. 
 What was I doing admiring you for being so well-behaved, sitting there for hours content to have your arm round me? 
 I even said to myself, &bquo;He's English and yet he understands.&equo;&equo; 
 St ill I wanted you to go all the way with me. 
 London's very far&hellip; and I'll never go back home. 
 I'll always live here now. 
 I should have been on my guard. 
 How was I to know? 
 If you'd had a big fat bottom I might have guessed. 
 But you're all scrawny. 
 Your bum's hardly bigger than a fist. 
 I'm crazy. 
 I let your  white flesh and your skinny body and your blond hair blot out things that would have made me shudder at home. 
 I rang his sister from a public phone box. 
 When she heard my voice, she asked drily, &bquo;What do you want?&equo; 
 &bquo;Your brother&hellip; 
 &equo; I began. 
 She cut in. 
 &bquo;Are you getting me out of bed at this hour to talk to me about my brother?&equo; she demanded. 
 &bquo;It's urgent,&equo; I replied. 
 At this she changed her tone, and asked quickly, &bquo;Is he all right?&equo; 
 Why did I bother to tell her, only to have her shout at me, accuse me of being crazy to wake her up for that and tell me to keep my nose out of her brother's business, especially since it was nothing to do with me. 
 As her parting shot she told me never to phone her at this time of the night again. 
 but then her anger seemed to have woken her and she continued, &bquo;I know you went to a lot of trouble over the meal, but my brother's sexual proclivities aren't any of your business, or mine either.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bitch,&equo; I screamed down the phone at her then, remembering how much they like dogs here, I shouted in English, &bquo;Whore! 
 Whore!&equo; 
 I walked along, trembling with anger and misery, not through the London of beautiful houses and clean streets that I'd dreamed of, where people wore only elegant, expensive clothes, nor between buildings that soared into the clouds, but in the darkness past trees planted at infrequent intervals and council houses with their unlit windows, all alike; I passed people asleep, protected from the cold in cardboard boxes, and rubbish in untidy heaps or neatly tied up in black plastic bags and empty milk bottles with traces of sour milk lingering in them, and I marvelled once again that the dairies were trusting enough to leave them lying about. 
 A voice rose from a heap of clothes on the pavement, accompanied by the stench of alcohol-laden breath, a voice begging for a drink or money to buy a drink. 
 I used  to smile at the people who stopped me in the street, not knowing what they wanted at first, until I discovered that there were actually beggars in London. 
 I gave them money, full of pride that I was richer than at least one English person, even if he was a beggar. 
 I walked along with something boring a hole between my legs. 
 Now I was conscious of Aisha's words when we stood together in the storeroom and she tried to dissuade me from going to London: &bquo;Go alone to London without an aunt or a husband or your mother and they'll say you've sold your soul. 
 You'll be known as a bad girl even if you're as pure as the Prophet's daughter.&equo; 
 &bquo;What are you talking about?&equo; 
 I'd said to her nervously. 
 &bquo;I'll be staying with you!&equo; 
 Aisha's annual visits home had sown the seed of travel in my spirit and this seed had grown and opened out and reached my eyes and tongue. 
 On her last visit I'd been unable to take my eyes off her gold earrings and her bangles. 
 I'd dragged her into the storeroom and begged her to take me to London, saying my family wouldn't allow me to go without her. 
 It was not only her matching handbag and high-heeled shoes which fired my enthusiasm. 
 The smell of couscous and other grain which filled the air constantly reminded me of my own situation. 
 All I wanted to smell from now on was the fragrance of England which Aisha exuded. 
 I urged her to listen to me and to feel what I was feeling. 
 Then I took off my little gold earrings and felt in the folds of my dress for all the money I'd saved or stolen from my brother's pockets over the years, and placed both the money and earrings in the palm of her hand, forcing her fingers shut around them. 
 As I gave her an exaggerated account of my clashes with different members of my family, she continued to discourage me, saying that the work in London was hard and that exile was no easy way of life. 
 I thought she must not like the idea of my going on the plane with her, then coming home every year laden with presents. 
 How could she compare the  task of dusting and polishing the magnificent English furniture to the drudgery of cleaning our house, where there were only tom rags, a broom and a pail of water, and you had to go down on your knees to scrub the floor and do the endless piles of washing by hand? 
 The man at the British customs was much sterner than the magistrate who came from the capital to investigate crimes committed in our village. 
 This man would forget the purpose of his visit, at least for a brief spell, and the fact that he was on official business, and drink tea and eat a good meal in the prosecutor's house, crack jokes and make amiable conversation, and sleep through the heat of the day. 
 The British official behind his high desk asked me numerous questions which I didn't understand. 
 When all I could reply were the two forlorn words, &bquo;No English,&equo; he asked me if I knew French. 
 I nodded my head to find I had opened Ali Baba's cave merely by answering all his questions with the one French word, &bquo;oui&equo;. 
 His features relaxed and he stamped my passport. 
 Without realizing it he had let me know that using French words, however few and halting, has a bewitching effect upon everything in London, animate and inanimate alike. 
 I'd woken up the next morning at Aisha's place, not convinced that I was really in London: her flat was like any flat at home with the same smell, the same coloured ottomans and rugs, the same pictures on the walls, the brass tray in the middle of the room, and the loud shrieks and wails of her two children puncturing the air. 
 However, this sensation evaporated as soon as I looked out of the window, when I realized how imprisoned I was by my ignorance, which Aisha seized upon, exploiting the fact that I didn't know how to flush the toilet, work the shower, turn on the oven or boil the electric kettle to make tea, and that I couldn't understand what her older child or her next-door neighbour said. 
 I couldn't even answer the phone. 
 Inventing farfetched excuses, she left me trapped in her flat and  made no attempt to help me look for work. 
 From the window I saw the flats opposite, their even lines making them look like children's drawings. 
 Noisy voices floated through their windows. 
 I let my gaze wander to the open grassy strip at the side of the block, which was almost completely empty of life, and then on to the red buses and cars hurrying along the main road. 
 Fixing my eyes on them, I couldn't help cursing Aisha, wishing she was dead, swearing by the Prophet Muhammad that I would have my revenge because it was she who was stopping me walking those streets and riding in those red buses to find work and a flat or a room of my own. 
 When Aisha returned from work, coming through the door weighed down with plastic carrier bags, her coat smelling of perfume mixed with cigarette smoke, I gave a shiver of anger: I wanted to carry shopping bags like that and wear a coat like hers! 
 Since everything seemed out of my reach I was reduced to making friends with the pigeons who were everywhere, and whose gentle murmurings I'd grown accustomed to hearing. 
 I put the remains of our dinner on the window ledge to attract them, and when one of them alighted near me I called to it, &bquo;Taste this couscous, steamed and mixed with oil, English pigeon, and tell me if it's nice.&equo; 
 I'd been amazed that in London you could buy ready-made couscous in packets, and that the English used it in their cooking. 
 I'd imagined that they would eat food fit for pigs, and look upon our food with distaste. 
 I left Aisha's prison in the following way: one day a woman from the same village as Aisha and I came to pick up her sewing machine. 
 She asked me if I was happy here and I sighed. 
 She responded with an even deeper sigh. 
 I found myself lying to her, although my lies seemed to me to represent the truth as soon as I was out of Aisha's house. 
 I told her how Aisha kept a close watch on what I ate and drank and how I had to take care of the house and children to pay for my board and  lodging. 
 The woman nodded her head in agreement and remarked, &bquo;Yes. 
 Everybody says Aisha's become like an Englishwoman. 
 She must have saved herself about thirty pounds a week having you there, because she used to pay her neighbour to look after the two children for her while she was out at work.&equo; 
 Immediately we joined forces against Aisha, criticizing her and insulting her. 
 The visitor told me things about her which I didn't believe, but still I nodded my head as if to confirm what she had said. 
 For my part, I told her that I was sure Aisha had a lover and we began searching for proof. 
 We broke into the single, locked cupboard, and although we only found some new clothes and shoes with jewellery stuffed up inside the toes we assured each other that Aisha received money from her lover and liked leaving me in the house with the children because it made it easier to cheat on her husband. 
 Only the walls heard this delirious talk, but I was suddenly seized by a guilty fear, and became convinced that the two children were taking it in and that it was ringing in Aisha's ears at work, and I rushed to pack my suitcase before she came back. 
 The visitor left, forgetting to take her sewing machine, and I left with her, knowing full well that I would never see Aisha again and that news of my forcing the lock on her cupboard would reach my family and the whole village well amplified, so that I'd end up accused of stealing all of Aisha's possessions. 
 I took the woman's advice and looked for work paid by the hour. 
 I discovered that time was money and threw myself into cleaning offices, restaurants and hospitals. 
 Picturing the pounds mounting up in my handbag, I pushed myself harder, indifferent to the veins aching with fatigue and the bits of my body which cried out with exhaustion and craved for sleep. 
 I only stopped working frenziedly hour after hour after I met the English boy I'd just thrown water over moments before.  
 I left the woman's house as soon as I found work and a room to rent. 
 When I was told that I'd have to share a kitchen and bathroom with strangers I couldn't help thinking how this would astound the people at home, how they would snort with laughter at the idea that this could really happen in England, mother of civilization. 
 The English boy used to work in the hospital for a day at a time, and then be off for several days. 
 At tea breaks and lunchtime I never saw him eat more than a bar of chocolate or a biscuit. 
 I never saw him talk to anybody. 
 He would just put headphones on and close his eyes. 
 He had blond hair, light eyes and a thin face. 
 I suppose I fancied him although I told myself that it was just that I felt sorry for him. 
 I decided to offer him some food. 
 When I approached and held a piece of chicken out to him he opened his eyes in surprise and at first refused to take it. 
 I insisted and he put out his hand, asking me if I was sure. 
 I smiled. 
 I no longer took what the English said seriously. 
 &bquo;Are you sure?&equo; they ask without fail, regardless of whether you are offering help or an invitation to lunch, giving them a cup of tea or paying their bus fare. 
 After eating the piece of chicken dipped in cumin and saffron which he must have liked, he asked me where I came from. 
 I told him and it was as if I'd opened Heaven's door. 
 His face softened, his pupils grew bigger, and his irises went deep green like olive oil. 
 Enthusiastically he told me that he'd always wanted to visit Morocco, live there even, and that our hashish was the best of all. 
 Was it true, he inquired anxiously, was it really cheap there? 
 I answered him with lies, happy that he was so interested after I'd been certain that he'd never say a word to me: I told him that I grew it myself, my family grew it, and it was everywhere like green grass and empty milk bottles in London; it was really amazing hashish. wherever I threw its seeds it sprang up like flames leaping into the air. 
 Dreaming of the hashish and the sunshine he said,  &bquo;You left all that sun for the sake of these grey clouds and this miserable country?&equo; 
 &bquo;What can I do with the sun?&equo; 
 I answered. 
 &bquo;Sweep it off the rooftops?&equo; 
 In my imagination I could feel the monotony of the days in my country, the poverty and the nothingness. 
 I remembered the threatening looks of the men of the family, the attentive stares from the ones in the street, my mother's harsh way of talking: and I repeated it to myself. 
 &bquo;What can I do with the sun? 
 Sweep it off the rooftops?&equo; 
 I was happy in London, free, mistress of my self and my pocket. 
 Here it was impossible not to be happy. 
 At home I was thought ugly. 
 In one week I listened to the English boy singing the praises of my dark colouring and frizzy hair, felt him kiss me on the cheek with obvious pleasure whenever I cooked a meal and when I came in from work, or when we sat watching television together, and found him waiting for me at the end of the road when I was late back for some reason. 
 I encouraged the English boy to move in one evening after he had taken me to a pub, and I felt this urge to have a hold on all the different sides there were to London. 
 Even though I didn't say a word in the uproar and drank only water, I was standing there like them in the crowds and smoke, proud and glad and sure of myself. 
 As soon as he entered my room that night, he declared provocatively that I must be rich to have such a bed and quilt, as well as cassettes and a television and a video. 
 He'd expected it, he added, since he noticed that I had my own plate and cup at work, and bought tea for whoever was sitting with me. 
 I smiled, nodding my head, not unhappy that he'd jumped to the wrong conclusions, but surprised that he didn't know the secret of paying by instalments. 
 He flung himself down on my bed, trying it out in different positions. 
 &bquo;How clean it is!&equo; he exclaimed. 
 &bquo;How comfortable! 
 I've never  slept in a bed like this before.&equo; 
 Was I hearing him right or had I missed the point as so often happened? 
 When we talked it was like two people playing with a ball: sometimes it went into the goal, sometimes it grazed the post, but most of the time it went high in the air and missed completely. 
 He hadn't slept in a bed like that before, yet there were all those advertisements for them on television, and they were on display in shop windows and in almost all the big stores in London so that I'd imagined them in all the houses I could see from the bus. 
 Quite at home in my bed, he fell fast asleep until dawn. 
 In the little streets and neighbourhoods where I wandered, London did not sleep. 
 And when it did, the hoardings stayed wide awake. 
 Hoardings about films, pop concerts, milk, drugs and AIDS&hellip; 
 AIDS? 
 My thoughts suddenly became alert: he was going to die of AIDS. 
 I should tell him, extending my finger in a threatening manner: &bquo;You'll die of AIDS.&equo; 
 Then I found myself shouting, inside my head, &bquo; I'll die of AIDS. 
 O, my God !&equo; 
 Then partly reassured, I thought, &bquo;He entered me twice, but he came outside me.&equo; 
 Then again I cried out in terror, wordlessly, &bquo;Who knows? 
 Maybe a germ slipped out of his prick and landed on me. 
 &equo;  
 And with an involuntary movement I raised my eyes to the sky &mdash; where God was &mdash; beseeching Him, wanting Him to see my fear and my contrition. 
 But I couldn't see the moon or the stars, only the gloomy sky. 
 I lowered my head quickly, as if to acknowledge the truth spoken by the old woman Khadija when she heard of my decision to travel to London. 
 &bquo;Foreigners have no God,&equo; she claimed, as if she wanted to weaken my resolve and then, correcting herself and asking God's pardon, she changed this to &bquo;Our God, the God of Islam, is different from theirs in the West.&equo; 
 Then, again asking God's forgiveness, she said that  there was no God but God, and the trouble was that Westerners didn't fellow His instructions or live by His law. 
 At this she rose, washed her mouth ten times to make amends and performed twenty prostrations for her scepticism. 
 I had to go back to the room, as if I needed to tell the place where I lived of my feeling. 
 As I accelerated my pace I asked myself what I was doing here, and I didn't know the answer. 
 Why didn't I go home to my own country taking with me the sheet which bore the stains of my virginity. 
 I had purposely left it unwashed, stuffing it in a suitcase because I might need to spread it out on my bridegroom's bed in the dark of night. 
 Bridegroom? 
 I would save some money and then I would find a man to marry me, especially if I promised to bring him to London. 
 But why was I here? 
 Was it because I was out of reach of the prying eyes of the men in my family and their questions about my comings and goings, and far from my mother's interrogations about why I slept on my stomach, or why I took so long in the bathroom? 
 The God of my far-off country must remember that I used to pray four times a day and still love me. 
 Now I had to be on my guard against AIDS and the Devil. 
 I opened the front door and heard the voice of Warda Al-Jazairiyya flooding through the door of my room. 
 Pushing the door open, I was confronted by a tall, blonde, green-eyed version of myself, the Englishman's friend dressed up in my clothes, with my kohl on his eyes, wearing a pair of my earrings. 
 He was swaying his head in time to the Arab song. 
 I stood before my blonde other self, wondering at my calmness, contemplating my clothes on the English boy's friend. 
 After the long conversation with my brown self out in the street and being confronted now by a blond self, the haze lifted and all the images became clear. 
 I no longer had to push away the picture of Saad laid out on the floor, or banish from my imagination the  sound of his huge voice, louder than the roaring of the wind, dumb for ever. 
 The women of the family struck their faces and smeared them with soot. 
 Saad had taken his own life the night the news had gone round that he'd been caught sleeping with a travelling shepherd. 
 He could speak no longer: he'd swallowed his voice, choking on the words, while his wife's voice, which had always been weak and incoherent before, rose high into the air, followed by those of his daughters and his sisters. 
 When Saad's note proclaiming his innocence was discovered there was an outcry in the village. 
 Saad's family rushed to try and have their revenge on the witness who had announced the news like someone possessed, and who cared less about Saad's death than about convincing the whole community of what he had seen in the hut that burning noonday. 
 The village was divided between those who wanted Saad's name cleared and those who wanted the accusation against him proven even after his death. 
 His soul would have no repose and would hover over the place, flying through the night. 
 As I remembered I laughed. 
 My blonde self laughed at the people of my village. 
 I imagined Saad lying down with the English boy and the two of them flirting and giggling together. 
 The boy came over and put his arm round me, as if he could not quite believe my laughter and my lack of agitation. 
 I smiled at both of them and told his friend my clothes suited him. 
 He asked if I had a caftan he could borrow. 
 I shook my head regretfully &mdash; I hadn't brought it with me, thinking the English would look down on my caftan with its silver belt &mdash; although I saw garments like it selling here at huge prices. 
 I was st ill laughing. 
 I imagined the beggar from the London streets sitting with the old woman Khadija in my village. 
 I had a mental picture of the conductor on the red London bus talking to Hammouda the village postman, of the English boy's friends playing with Khadija's grandson, especially Margaret, whose hair reminded me of the coloured feather duster Khadija's  grandson had pleaded for everytime he saw it in the market, thinking that it was a toy or a bird. 
 I saw Margaret talking to Saniyya, the daughter of the woman who ran the bathhouse. 
 I saw people springing up from the ground and letting down ropes out of the sky, boarding red buses, jabbering in English. 
 Englishmen climbing the ancient village wall with their bowler hats and black umbrellas. 
 Englishwomen, some pushing their pushchairs along the winding muddy roads, other older ones fanning their faces with trembling hands and still wearing their coloured woolly hats. 
 The television blared, and then I noticed the electricity advertisements: an electric stove, an electric heater, an electric boiler. 
 I'd have to buy an electric boiler to replace the gas one which had been leaking for a week now. 
 The gasman had told us it would blow up and had stuck on a waning sign to remind us. 
 I tuned, intending to ask the English boy why he lived with me, why he liked my company. 
 Once he had said I showed him a concern which he had never met with before, even from his parents, and that he would love to visit my country one day. 
 At the time I didn't believe him because I wasn't used to hearing the truth from people's lips, preferring to believe what I thought rather than what I heard. 
 Instead I found myself thinking &bquo;AIDS&equo;. 
 I looked at the two of them, &bquo;You ought to go and have yourselves examined.&equo; 
 I was thinking I would boil the sheets that evening and ask the chemist for a powerful disinfectant and give myself a vinegar douche to get rid of all the germs inside me. 
 They went into the kitchen and I started to tidy the room, gathering the plates from here and there and scattering the remains of the food on the window ledge. 
 The pigeons flocked around it immediately, though dawn was only just breaking. 
 I knew the neighbours  complained that the pigeons grew used to coming close to the windows, but I didn't care. 
 &bquo;Eat up,&equo; I told the nearest bird. 
 &bquo;You're lucky I'm feeding you, not eating you. 
 Where I come from, if we see a pigeon we throw a stone at it. 
 If it falls we accept our good fortune, kill it and eat it. 
 If it carries on flying we shrug our shoulders and say, &bquo;it's the angels' turn today&equo;. 
 You're not beautiful, you're not white, or even a nice light brown. 
 You're grey and black like a big rat, but I love you because you're English and you wait for me every day.&equo;  
 Translated by Catherine Cobham 
 PLACING OURSELVES 
 Deborah Levy 
 On the tragedy and the hilarity of being in an uncomfortable place: Yasser Arafat jokes that he lives in an aeroplane because being made homeless, he might as well live in the air. 
 In Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses , two Indian men, Farishta and Chamcha, fall out of an aeroplane and hang suspended in the air before landing on the shore of Britain, where they begin to reconstruct their identities. 
 I am nine and-a-half years old and sit in front of the television in England with my brother, watching characters like Meg and Sandy argue in the Cross roads motel, while fat Benny, the tele West Country moron in woolly hat, eats lots of pies. 
 And somewhere through the hotel muzak lurks the sensation that things used to be different, that we (my brother and I) hadn't always been wrapped in jumpers, silent, staring at the screen, that the days used to be hot and long. 
 That we used to walk home from school at one p.m. in the burning sun and play barefoot in grass that was dry and scratched our calves. 
 That we would wait for our mother to come home from work with &bquo;Lucky Packets&equo; full of sherbet, that most of our childhood had been outdoors and here  we were inside, with our dad home again, our dad who we hadn't seen for four years, here we were having crossed the equator with nine suitcases, where flying fish leapt from the sea, to be in this place. 
 Wembley Park, London, no money, no furniture, no nothing, short winter days and starless nights. 
 Here we were on swings in small parks, our hair that had been blonded by the African sun now turning dark, as if another person was emerging, slowly, day by day, and with it our accents changed too, so that we spoke in multiple mangled voices as we moved endlessly, six times, seven times, eight, nine times through different versions of Englishness. 
 Here where class and its rituals, football teams, chips, queues for everything, council estates, three storey houses, pebble dashed suburbia, languages we'd never heard, the tube, children who'd grown up with TV programmes we'd never seen, pubs and warm beer (when we saw COURAGE written on pub hoardings we thought they were left over from the war to give people morale), tea and gasfires and pets, having to make appointments to see people in advance rather than just arriving, suspicious politeness, all of these began to reveal themselves, intricately and ambiguously. 
 We arrived in England in 1968. 
 Tee shirts had the black power fist, Angela Davis and Che Guevara printed on them. 
 I was born in Johannesburg, South Africa in 1959. 
 When I was fourteen months old my mother was arrested. 
 There was a knock on the door in the early hours of the morning, she had curlers in her hair, and my father, thinking it was for him, told her not to panic. 
 But they took her away instead and she was in gaol for a day and a night; they released her because the State of Emergency (1960) which allowed the government to detain political prisoners without charge, had not  yet been legally declared. 
 When I was five years old, my father was arrested. 
 Another knock on the door, he packed a small suitcase while the police dug up the garden for &bquo;subversive&equo; literature. 
 The charge was membership of, and working for, the banned African National Congress. 
 I am six years old and eat pickled herring with my father's mother Miriam Leah, who has changed her name to Mary. 
 She tells me that when she came to South Africa from Lithuania in 1910 and met her husband Abe Moses, she could only speak Yiddish. 
 Together they owned a fish shop called Levy's Provisions and Fisheries. 
 Abe Moses, who was also a poet when he was not gutting fish, died while the children were st ill young, and Miriam Leah, who stunk of fish, decided to go into something more glamorous. 
 &bquo;Chinese Lingerie,&equo; she says, staring at the silver belly of her herring. 
 We all wave goodbye to my father on the stoop as he is taken off in a little red car. 
 I will not see him again until I am nine years old. 
 I am nineteen years old and at college in rural Devon, away from friends and family and the city where I spent ten years of my life. 
 I really feel a foreigner and walk up the drive cursing the mud that has ruined my gold stilettos. 
 I look like a refugee from a Verdi opera, stranded in the damp gentle valleys of South West England, where no one has yet introduced me to wellington boots or the useful strategy of invisibility. 
 But I make three best friends. 
 One is a Nigerian man, one is an Indian woman and the other a Kurdish man. 
 What I have in common with the Kurd is green eyes, the fact that he came to England at the same time as I did &mdash; and that he too looks like a refugee from a Verdi opera. 
 The Nigerian who is six feet four inches tall, tells me about his audition to get into this college. 
 He turned up at the dance studio in a pair of very skimpy tight shorts and observing that everyone else was very white and  wore towelling track suits, and seeing that he was very tall and very naked, got nervous so went for a walk and smoked a joint. 
 Then he came back and did the class. 
 &bquo;How did it go?&equo; 
 &bquo;I danced like Nijinsky.&equo; 
 There is a sort of joy in persuading the English you are the right person for them by dancing like a stoned Russian. 
 The Indian woman was born in Kerala, Southern India, and came to this country when she was six. 
 She tells me how her mum and dad know everything there is to know about fish, and tried to teach her. 
 But as an Indian woman, and the only daughter among seven brothers, she resisted all attempts to teach her how to cook and clean fish and how to prepare spices for sauces. 
 Her brothers could lean for themselves. 
 Now, here in Devon, she suddenly wants to know all about why a fish is oily near the spine and how you cut and salt it. 
 She wants to catch up on everything they can teach her about themselves, because then she can learn about herself. 
 She feels she needs this information to defend herself. 
 The drama students at this college are discussing theatre very seriously and sociologically when the Nigerian comes in late, long and loose limbed. 
 He has pinned a little square of material onto both his knees so that when he drives, the fabric of his best trousers will not rub against the steering wheel. 
 &bquo;Hello wankers.&equo; 
 The very blond student from Birmingham we have nicknamed Madam Mosely goes red with the terrible burden of always being right. 
 &bquo;Why are you late?&equo; 
 &bquo;Extra curricular activities.&equo; 
 Every time one of us dares contribute to the debate, she tells us with thriftiness of spirit and consonants of flint that we have no common sense. 
 And she is absolutely right. 
 We have no sense in common. 
 She feels  imperialized, that everything familiar to her is being disturbed, the peace is being disturbed, and that our ways of telling (form) and what we have to tell (content) are simply not something that should be on an agenda of any kind. 
 Which is interesting because here the three of us are, thinking about what it means to belong somewhere, what it might mean to belong to this idea called &bquo;theatre&equo;. 
 And we are discovering that we are not interested in exploring the finer points of alienation with tea cuppery, but that the theatre can be a bridge of bone between sickness and health &mdash; that our language will somehow always be on the edge of poetry and that image and metaphor are our natural tools &mdash; they best express whole worlds and histories in collision with each other. 
 &bquo;Why don't you just talk straight-&equo; Madam Mosely sucks a mint with vigour. 
 When the Kurd talks to his mother in Teheran from the telephone in the common room, he can hear bullets being shot just outside her front door, and we hear him tell her to take the phone away from the window. 
 This is happening while students play pool and pinball machines, and right next to him, Madam Mosley knits a scarf and talks about making good sensible entertaining shows. 
 Had she known it, there was no peace to be disturbed. 
 A martyr of tolerance, I think she would like not to just purse her thin prim lips. 
 I think she would like to burn our houses down. 
 I am thirteen years old and go to a girls' school, predominantly working class, at the Elephant and Castle, London. 
 I don't know any of the Beatles songs and the girls sing them on top of their desks. 
 A lot of their boyfriends were skinheads who go &bquo;paki bashing&equo;. 
 We all wear mutated versions of the school uniform and platform shoes. 
 Everyone supports Millwall. 
 I am at the bus stop and have dropped my busfare. 
 As I search for it  on the pavement, one of the girls says, &bquo;Look at the yid licking the gutters for pennies.&equo; 
 And then she says, &bquo;You're from South Africa aren't you? 
 My mum and dad go there every year.&equo; 
 &bquo;The English molest their children and love their dogs.&equo; 
 This is the sort of cheap bitter jibe we love to say to each other when we feel wronged by life and attribute it to the lukewarm stew of Englishness. 
 That they're cold and formal and anal. 
 That the principle of pleasure is sacrificed to the principle of endurance and eroticism and sensuality replaced by sudden repressed explosions of rage and abandon. 
 But who are they? 
 My English friend Annie was more or less brought up by her nan in a back-to-back in Manchester. 
 Her nan had lost her hearing working in the textile m ills. 
 Because she had no garden, she improvised a sandpit for the children to play in. 
 She took an old carpet, filled it with soil and put it in the front room, where Annie and her brother spent the day. 
 When it was time for them to go, she rolled up the carpet full of soil and put it in her bedroom. 
 Later on she taught her grand-daughter how to sew, how to make tripe, and she taught her politics. 
 Annie, now in her thirties, talks about what being working class means in terms of self-image and worth. 
 Of how there are no accurate contemporary representations of her life, only this heritage stuff about happy agricultural labourers with straws in their mouths, or chirpy cockneys eating winkles. 
 She says she needs to gather up, in her post-modern skirt, all the creative, affirmative, intellectual parts of her childhood; she needs to know how her folk survived, and when she looks for them in England, on TV, at the theatre, in art galleries, in advertising, they're invisible. 
 Whether it's fish in Southern India or tripe in Northern England, the need to place  ourselves is the same. 
  That put him in his place . 
 The phrase has always interested me. 
 It means something has been said or something has happened that has put the subject of the remark in an uncomfortable place . 
 Is &bquo;Englishness&equo; a comfortable place? 
 If as Marx said, the working class have no country, what does it mean to have a place in a culture anyway? 
 And what language do we use to name that place, or rather whose language? 
 What if your place has been described for you as being a so-called &bquo;minority&equo;, or an &bquo;emerging voice&equo;? 
 What are the multiple repertoires of identity buried in this word Englishness? 
 What does it mean to be &bquo;English&equo; when so many people are disenfranchised in this country? 
 Here where the streets are not paved with gold, but with garbage. 
 Garbage and the people who sleep amongst it. 
 Violet next door to me, who I help sometimes rake over her allotment, is eighty-five years old, and if one was to draw a graph of her life from 0&ndash;85, it would be one of unremitting poverty. 
 She tells me that when she was a nippy (of course I say what's a nippy and she tells me it's a waitress) the worst sin the girls could commit, sackable instantly, was to whirl the pencils which were attached by string to their aprons. 
 &bquo;It was the first thing you wanted to do,&equo; she says. 
 Putting sticks into the ground for her beans, she says, &bquo;Oh the kids will take these. 
 Y'know, kids love a stick.&equo; 
 The kids on the estate have nowhere to play. 
 Similarly, when she catches me watering my plants on the balcony we share, she says, &bquo;Shame you haven't got a patch to muck about in.&equo; 
 Violet has mostly dug up her patch and planted vegetables in it, but she has left a little strip of grass, about three foot long, which she mows with a lawn mower she bought at a jumble sale for two pounds. 
 Annie has a little rug in her bedroom the same size, and every day she hoovers it. 
 I think the real English gardens are not the manicured  lawns of the home counties (usually nurtured by someone &bquo;who comes to do the garden&equo;) but precisely these little pocket handkerchief gardens and allotments; places of little rugs and doormats and tiny bits of land for which rain is prayed, cultivated with beans and tomatoes and cabbages and roses, a respite from the rest of life, where people are autonomous, in control of something they are making. 
 Places to think in, mull things over, escape to. 
 They are full of cats and tools, improvised sheds and extraordinary devices to keep out birds. 
 When the temperature rises to 59&deg;F Violet says there's a heatwave. 
 The man next door has spent the last year making a kennel for his dog. 
 This plywood structure has grown bigger and bigger, and he has even carved gothic spires on its top. 
 The neighbours complained and when he asked if I minded, I said I loved the kennel and hated the dog. 
 He hasn't talked to me since, but Violet tells me she has explained to him that &bquo;some people are funny about dogs&equo;. 
 She has also warned me that the little porcelain giggling buddha I've put in the tomato plant pot outside my front door &bquo;will probably be nicked by the Arab boy who delivers the newspapers.&equo; 
 Apparently, the milkman will not be tempted. 
 I am sixteen years old. 
 I have lived in this country for seven years. 
 People ask, &bquo;Are you English?&equo; 
 And I don't really know what to say. 
 People ask, &bquo;Are you South African?&equo; 
 And I don't really know what to say. 
 I love it in the summer when London is full of tourists. 
 An Englishman with Eton accent and broken NH8 glasses stands unsteadily in a pub in the East End of London. 
 He begins to read, beautifully, lyrically, with heartfelt empathy, a poem by Wole Soyinka in which the poet tried to rent a room in London in the 1950s, and the landladies on the telephone ask him just precisely how black he is. 
 For some reason this inspires the  barman to tell me there were a lot of good boxers in the 1980s because they were hungry. 
 A group of Turkish workers in South London buy lamb and bread and take it on a coach to the striking miners in Wales (1984). 
 The roads are full of snow and the coach is delayed. 
 The Turks are worried that the meat they so painstakingly prepared will not be as tasty as it should be. 
 The Welsh miners and their families and the Turkish workers and their families eat well together, exchange song, dance and poetry, while around them hang banners of solidarity with Chile, the African National Congress, and the women of Greenham Common. 
 The children secretly throw away the rings of raw onions in their kebabs. 
 As peoples shift from one part of the globe to another, from one self to another, in various states of exile, dispossession and displacement, the dominant feature of the late-twentieth century has to be the search for place . 
 It is these people who are uniquely placed to observe the culture and comment on it. 
 They had been hurt by it and have had to seriously think about how to make themselves better. 
 A pinstriped youth in his early twenties, fingernails bitten into a raw and livid mess, drinks a cup of fake cappuccino in a Eurobar. 
 The theatres around the bar play out all the trifles of TV soap life, larger, its little pains domesticated, microwaved and packaged into a popular night out. 
 He stares at the streets near him and hopes the grief he sees there is something that happens to other people. 
 He is standing on his own two feet &mdash; on the face of someone else. 
 In 1989 the tee shirts have ZAP, INSTANT, WOW, HELLO and PALM BEACH written on them. 
 In the last months of 1989 the people of Central and Eastern Europe take it upon themselves to address the future and make it a different place to be in. 
  I am thirty years old and have lived in this country for twenty-one years. 
 Rain pours down the window panes of my London flat and I am reading the letters of black political prisoners in the country I was born in. 
 One man describes reading the biographies of Maya Angelou, popstars on the radio, vegetables they have been allowed to plant and harvest. 
 He talks about news of the education cuts in England, and is aghast when there is such a thirst for education all around him. 
 But most of all he is anxious about the children of friends and comrades. 
 He wants photographs of them, information, he wants them to be well. 
 He wants to know where they are living and what they are thinking. 
 I am eleven-and-a-half years old and have lived in this country for two years. 
 I am on a swing in a small park with my brother. 
 We push ourselves higher and higher into the air and our shoes fall from our feet on to the concrete below us. 
 We watch the train shuffle and rattle across the tracks where we collect blackberries and know, soon, when it gets dark, we will have to come down to collect our shoes.  
 This is dedicated to Simon Levy 
 GOODBYE DUNCAN 
 David Barnes 
 All evening they sat in silence until Catherine brought Duncan his supper. 
 &mdash; Duncan, I want to talk about something, she said. 
 &mdash; Not again, replied Duncan irritably, looking up from the News. 
 &mdash; I want to move to London and get a job. 
 &mdash; I've told you you'll hate it down there. 
 &mdash; I want a job Duncan. 
 &mdash; What d'you need a job for anyway? &mdash; You know I want one. 
 &mdash; It's no' as easy as they say to find work these days, even down there. 
 &mdash; But Sheila moved down to London with Bob and she got a job no bother. 
 Catherine was staring earnestly down at Duncan over her coffee. 
 Duncan buried himself in the paper and with an air of finality he said, &mdash; Well I've got my job here and I'm happy with it. 
 &mdash; But I just hang around the flat all day getting bored. 
 Duncan put down the paper. 
 There was rancour in his eyes. 
 &mdash; In a month you'll be bored with your job. 
 &mdash; Sheila's not bored. 
 There's things to do in London. 
 &mdash; It's all a big con. 
 Look I'm tellin' you&hellip;  &mdash; Duncan, I want to go. 
 &mdash; What am I meant to do with my job then, eh? &mdash; Duncan, I'm leavin'. 
 I'm going to London. 
 There was a pause. 
 Then she added, &mdash; Sheila can put me up until I find a place. 
 Another pause. 
 Duncan looked up and protested. 
 &mdash; But we're just married a couple of months. 
 &mdash; We've been living in this flat over a year Duncan. 
 I wanted a new start. 
 &mdash; You've got to give it a chance. 
 &mdash; How long Duncan? &mdash; It's different now we're married. 
 &mdash; I've always wanted to go to London, I told you before. 
 &mdash; It's crazy. 
 We've just got settled in this place. 
 What the bloody hell did you go an' marry me for if you wanted to go to London? 
 You don't know what the hell you're on about, you've no idea at all. 
 &mdash; I'm sittin' here waitin' for nothing. 
 I'm still young, Duncan, I want the life. 
 Sheila's havin' a good time and she's getting a bit of money too. 
 &mdash; Well bloody go then, but you're mad Catherine, bloody crazy. 
 Catherine moved to Sheila and Bob's, and Duncan was left alone. 
 One Saturday night he'd been drinking in front of the telly when he decided to phone Sheila's place. 
 &mdash; Hullo, is that you Sheila? he asked. 
 &mdash; Aye, came the answer. 
 &mdash; It's Duncan here, is Catherine there? &mdash; Um, no, she's no' in at the moment. 
 &mdash; Will she be in later on d'you know? &mdash; Um, she could be, aye. 
 &mdash; Right, I'll probably call back later then. 
 Y'all keepin' well down there? &mdash; Aye. 
 &mdash; I won't keep you then Sheila, cheerio.  
 Duncan went back to Hill Street Blues  and the scotch. 
 At a quarter to twelve he phoned back. 
 And after a while it was answered. 
 &mdash; Hi&hellip; 
 It's me again, is Catherine there yet? &mdash; This is Catherine, Duncan, she answered coldly. 
 &mdash; Oh&hellip; em, Catherine, how are you? &mdash; Fine, Duncan. 
 &mdash; Did you have a good time tonight then? &mdash; Yes. 
 &mdash; You got a job yet? &mdash; Yes. 
 &mdash; Oh&hellip; &mdash; Duncan, it's five to twelve. 
 There was a space of silence. 
 &mdash; Yes&hellip; well, I'd better be off, hadn't I? &mdash; Yes. 
 &mdash; Well, goodbye then. 
 &mdash; Goodbye Duncan. 
 LEICESTER SQUARE 
 Adam Zameenzad 
 I was sure I was not being followed. 
 I looked behind me just the same. 
 I was being followed by a crowd. 
 A crowd of pink white brown and black people; all blue with unnatural cold, grey from lack of oxygen, and yellow with pent-up bile. 
 All climbing up the stairs in one mad rush trying to get out of the hell-pit of the London Underground tunnels, after having escaped from the claustrophobic strangulating suffocating hold of the London Underground Tubes, marginally cleaner but less picturesque than those of New York. 
 They couldn't all be following me, of course not. 
 Even I knew that. 
 But was there one among them&hellip;? 
 I hesitated for a moment on the stairs, turned round and tried to look at some of them, to see if there was a familiar face, a suspicious or suspecting face, a face I could place, a face that could&hellip; 
 I was nearly knocked down the steps then nearly carried up the steps then nearly trampled upon then nearly asphyxiated then completely ambushed engulfed surrounded then wholly abandoned. 
 All in a flash. 
 Soon all who were following me were leading me so the chances were that they were not following me  though they could still be following me by leading me and then waiting around to ambush etcetera etcetera; but of course not. 
 No, there was no one following me. 
 Another crowd was following me. 
 Another train had arrived. 
 Yes, I was not being followed. 
 Any more. 
 The feeling had gone. 
 But a feeling remained. 
 I tried to shudder it away. 
 But it remained. 
 I was out on Shaftesbury Avenue, facing Eros, the heart of Piccadilly, in the guts of Soho, the cunt of London. 
 Or so I had been told. 
 It was rather a loveless heart, the guts were dagging, and the cunt was the driest coldest and most shrivelled of cunts, if indeed cunt it was and not an asshole in disguise. 
 It certainly made an asshole of visitors. 
 A real let down, especially after all I had heard about it, not to mention all that nudge nudge wink wink from the son of the house in East Ham where I had found a room, and so much eyebrow raising and snorting from the father. 
 I had been quite looking forward to sampling its unsavoury delights. 
 Unsavoury, yes; delights&hellip; you must be joking, to quote a famous British phrase. 
 All promise and no delivery. 
 ft was about as frustrating as trying to masturbate with your hands tied behind your back. 
 Nothing was what it claimed to be. 
 There was none of the so-called obscenity &mdash; real sex shops and real sex films or honest free-trading prostitutes of either sex, or any allied pleasurable activities: the scourge of the righteous. 
 Instead there was true obscenity, the obscenity of deceitfulness and come-on lies. 
 And to cap it all, the bland sleazy boredom of it all. 
 Quite a contrast to equivalent places in European cities, even New York. 
 I rambled aimlessly for about an hour, in and out of dirty narrow streets, their only saving grace being their brevity, in and out of a variety of shops, bought some oranges from the market stalls, the most interesting feature of the wretched place, then went in to see an &bquo;explicit sex&equo; film and was presented with a badly  mutilated and heavily censored version of some third-rate continental film which I left within the first fifteen minutes. 
 By that time I was hopelessly lost and hopelessly bored. 
 Perhaps because this was the first time I was all alone in a big city in a new country. 
 I had always had someone to go round with, while in Europe, or in America; and good company, any company, can make an enormous difference to one's perception of whatever one happens to be perceiving. 
 And London was different. 
 I had got so used to the straight criss-crossing North-South, East-West roads of most American cities that I would have to acquire a taste for the more complex and possibly much more fascinating spread of London lanes. 
 Perhaps I was in the wrong place, the wrong part of the town. 
 Perhaps I was going about it the wrong way. 
 Going to the wrong places. 
 Had the wrong attitude. 
 I could have gone to one of the libraries or museums, art galleries&hellip; 
 Perhaps I had the wrong expectations. 
 Too high. 
 London was, or should have been, the most exciting place in the world. 
 After all, Great-Grandmother swore by the British, or the English, angrez , as she called them. 
 And though she would never admit to it, I was sure there were moments, however fleeting and however infrequent, when she wished she'd been with the Church of England, rather than the Roman Church. 
 For Americans she had scant respect and considered them to be nouveau riche upstarts, not good enough to hold a candle to the real  thing. 
 the true English gentry, the real  ladies and the real  gentlemen. 
 Even Father had all but stood to attention at the very mention of the pucca angrez saab . 
 Loyalty to crown and &bquo;country&equo; sometimes exceeded in the colonies that in the core of the Empire itself, especially among the poor and the powerless. 
 Glory by association was one explanation  for the phenomenon, gullibility and impressionability were two more. 
 and despite my inbuilt irreverence for all sacred stones of all establishment temples, I too had grown up with an aura of awe for the British and all things British, and London was meant to encompass represent and symbolize the best of the best of it all. 
 I came back to my earlier proposition. 
 I was in the wrong place. 
 The wrong part of the town. 
 I picked up the Evening News  from one of the street sellers and looked through its entertainment pages. 
 In times of disorientation, intellectual or otherwise, it is sometimes best to stick to the familiar, cling to the known. 
 I decided to go and see one of the Bond films which was on in a cinema at Leicester Square. 
 I didn't know exactly where Leicester Square was, but 1 did know it wasn't far from Piccadilly, I had seen it in one of those tourist maps I had in my hand a short while ago, didn't know where it went, probably left it in the cinema showing the explicit sex film which wasn't. 
 Even if I might have wandered away from Piccadilly, I couldn't have gone far, and anyway I didn't mind walking. 
 Provided no one was following me. 
 All I had to do was ask for directions. 
 I saw this good-looking redhead with a bust to challenge Shakti's &mdash; a sight which was getting rarer and rarer as women were made to get thinner and thinner for the convenience of the multi-billion dress designing industry, much easier and hence more economical and hence more profitable to clothe a bean pole than an hour glass &mdash; walking my way. 
 Could you please tell me the way to Leicester square, I said, speaking softly, in my best voice and with my toothiest smile. 
 Perhaps I was showing too many teeth which could make me appear roguish and untrustworthy. 
 She sort of froze for a moment, tried to smile and not smile at the same time, looked uncomprehendingly at me, turned ever so slightly towards the farther side of the road from  me and walked away with quick nervous steps. 
 I tried the next time with a very dapper man, all pinstripes and umbrella. 
 He didn't even stop or turn his head to look at me. i don't think he heard me. 
 Perhaps I spoke too softly. 
 Perhaps I was not saying the name of the place correctly. 
 I wasn't. 
 I was uttering three distinct syllables: Lei-ces-ter Square. 
 Not merely that, I was putting my strongest accent on the syllable that wasn't! 
 I ought to have known. 
 After all I did know through my discussions with Pasha regarding the plausibility of King Lear's plot that the Earl of Gloucester was really the Earl of Gloster . 
 But I failed to make the connection. 
 Anyway, since the English language, not unlike its speakers, and the climate in which it was reared, did not necessarily adhere to the principles of predictability, even had the thought of the good Earl occurred to me, I may st ill not have surmised that it gave proof positive one way or the other re the acceptable pronunciation of the Square's Christian name. 
 What's more, were I sure I was mispronouncing, I might not have worried that much. 
 After all, in Paris and Rome, Copenhagen and Amsterdam, I had frequently made a complete mess of whole sentences, much less place names, and had generally been set in the right direction, after a little bit of repetition and a lot of hand waving. 
 Another perhaps occurred to me. 
 Perhaps I had spoken to two of the many tourists that must be coming over to pay their respects to this capital of capitals. 
 At the time it appeared to be the most plausible perhaps. 
 The answer, ask someone who had to be a true native. 
 The man selling the evening papers by the bend of that road yonder. 
 I hastened there without delay or ado. 
 Could you please tell me how to get to Lei-cee-ter Square? please, I asked wide-eyed, eager and hopeful. 
 The man, with a blotchy red skin and wavy brown hair generously mixed with wavy grey hair, looked up  momentarily then looked down again and said, there is no such place, face and voice both utterly expressionless. 
 The faces and voices of the two young men, one about my age, the other hardly fourteen, one standing right behind the newspaper man the other nestling next to him, were by no means devoid of expression. 
 I heard them no sooner I turned to walk away which I did after a brief moment's hesitation when I wrestled with the foolish notion of somehow eliciting a confession out of the florid man that he was lying and that Leicester Square did indeed exist; not realizing then that he was  right, and that there really was no such place as Lei-cester Square. 
 The older of the young ones let out a sniggering laugh which developed into a hiccoughy laugh, the younger one hissed out, fuckin' bloody Paki; a third voice, I couldn't tell whose, said something which I did not quite understand but sounded like, and indeed was, National Front. 
 I felt my face go red, as red as it was physically possible for it to go red, and a surge of hate and rage and fear swept through me from nerve ending to brain cell to nerve ending. 
 But only for one passing second. 
 The hate and rage went almost instantly. 
 A little bit of the redness and a lot of the fear remained. 
 Once the initial involuntary reactions had settled down, the overall feeling was a strange mixture of sensations, memories and impressions, not altogether unpleasant. 
 After all, rejection was nothing new to me. 
 I was born a reject, in the gutter; was bred in the gutter; and had learnt, very early on in life, to walk close to the gutter. 
 And that was in my own country, the land of my birth, and the birth of my father and my mother, and their fathers and their mothers. 
 This was a foreign land, peopled not only by my superiors, for that applied to everyone I'd ever known, from the hole in Mother woman through which I was expelled to the hole in the Mother earth by which I'd be swallowed; but by those  who were superior to my early superiors; probably the most superior peoples in the entire world. 
 At least so Great-Grandmother declared, with the exception of the Jews. 
 Her utterly unquestioning faith in the Bible led her to believe that none could possibly be luckier or greater than those whom the love of God chooses, and if the love of God had chosen to choose the Jews, then their superiority over the rest of mankind could not possibly be doubted. 
 Salvation is through the Jews, she often quoted Father Franklin who baptized her, for through the Jews came the Law, through the Jews came Christ, the Son of God was born a Jew, and the Holy Mother of God was a Jew and married a Jew. 
 If all that was not the ultimate in human proximity to God, way above all ordinary mortals, she couldn't imagine what else could be. 
 I was neither Jew nor English nor white, or even a proper Indian or a proper Pakistani; but my travels through Europe and stay in the USA and my near acceptance there as a living entity capable of suffering pain and enjoying pleasure had temporarily given me a sort of quasi-human status, further aggravated by those willing to be my sexual partners; I had become spoilt and pampered. 
 Obviously I would have to start re-learning my past and re-discovering my appointed place in the world. 
 I almost felt at home, secure. 
 The redness in my face was no longer of anger, but embarrassment, and even warmth. 
 I was back where I belonged. 
 However the feeling was not entirely pleasant either. 
 The fear, though not new, was greater than I remembered, and stronger than it need have been. 
 The determined practical side of my nature soon took over from the lazy brooding one. 
 I had to get to Leicester Square. 
 I had to find where it was. 
 I no longer cared about seeing the film, though it was to be the last with my great hero Sean Connery. 
 I just wanted to get to Leicester Square. 
 The answer came from heaven. 
 In a manner of  speaking. 
 I looked up to the skies for no reason I can now remember, probably a spot of rain or a ray of sunshine. 
 On their way down my eyes spied a policeman on the horizon. 
 Now why hadn't I thought of it before! 
 Could you please tell me how to get to Lei-ces-ter Square? please, I said once again, in my best voice once again. 
 For a flicker of a moment as the policeman looked up at me I thought I had struck a wall again, but then the door opened. 
 The policeman smiled showing large flashy teeth. 
 He was young and fresh with large blue eyes and his skin shone. 
 I would have enjoyed taking his uniform off. 
 He began explaining, straight on, then first right, on to the second set of lights&hellip; etcetera&hellip; etcetera&hellip; it's rather a long walk, sir, he concluded. 
 He called me sir! 
 I was thrilled. 
 An English policeman actually called me sir. 
 Great-Grandmother would have been so proud of me. 
 Mother would have given me a cuddle, and she wasn't given to cuddles. 
 Not where I was concerned. 
 Father's eyes would have lit up. 
 And it takes a lot to light up the eyes of a man dying of tuberculosis. 
 He could tell my mind had wandered off. 
 I'll tell you what, sir, he said. 
 He said &bquo;sir&equo; again. 
 I'll tell you what sir, he said, I'll write it down for&hellip; here his eyes narrowed a bit, he hesitated, you can&hellip; 
 Oh yes, I assured him, answering the unasked question, I can read. 
 he relaxed. 
 Taking out a note pad from his pocket he drew a map, writing down the names of the roads and the turnings to take. 
 I must have wandered off course more than I had thought. 
 But then the streets had led one into another and twisted and turned and escaped into strange territories&hellip; 
 There you will see the sign, a big board&hellip; that's where&hellip; he smiled his big smile again as he tore off the piece of paper and handed it over to me. 
 I started getting confused halfway through, but I was  determined not to ask anyone else I didn't want another negative response to spoil the childlike happiness that the policeman's courtesy had brought to my otherwise unrewarding day. 
 I finally managed to get to where the directions led me. 
 I still wasn't quite sure if I had got it quite right. 
 Looked different from what I had imagined, but then places in real life often are different from what you imagine them to be. 
 There was a large park spreading in front of me. 
 Couldn't see any cinemas around. 
 It was only when I looked up to my right and saw the board that I realized I had  come to the right place. 
 The sign read, LONDON ZOO. 
 The reputation of the famous British sense of humour was well deserved after all. 
 If a policeman could be so well endowed with it, despite the obvious difficulties and frustrations of his profession, the ordinary man or woman would surely be brimming over with a joke or two no matter what the occasion. 
 I could hear the young man's hiccoughy laughter all over again, this time with more telling effect. 
 I couldn't help but joining in. 
 The devil riding my back dug his hard pointy heels into my flesh, but I stayed my ground. 
 I had nowhere I could go. 
 But to Leicester Square. 
 This time I decided I would try a child. 
 For unto such belongs the Kingdom of Heaven. 
 Leicester Square shouldn't be much of a problem. 
 He ran to his mother half way through my sentence. 
 My fault. 
 I hadn't seen her sitting on a bench not far from the spot. 
 I tried an Indian-looking middle-aged man with a pouchy face hidden beneath a large brimmed hat, and a paunchy stomach that seemed to run a perfect little circle round his navel hidden beneath a scruffy fair-isle sweater hidden beneath a wrinkly brown jacket hidden  beneath an overcoat which brushed the homeless autumn leaves strewn despairingly across the lawns. 
 His tie was muddy green with flowers which once must have been yellow. 
 Sorry, no know, new&hellip; sorry&hellip; sorry&hellip; new, no know&hellip; 
 I decided to make one last attempt after which I would start looking for a place from where I could obtain a map of the city. 
 I tried a pink old lady with the future of the universe mapped on her face with linear symbols just waiting to be decoded by anyone who had the wisdom and the patience to want to do so. 
 It took her a while to understand what I wanted and where I wanted to go. 
 Then she walked with me to a bus stop &mdash; I had to take one step every two minutes, and that in slow motion &mdash; waited with me, put me on the right bus and reminded the conductor where to let me out. 
 I was in Leicester Square. 
 What's more. 
 I had learnt that it was really Lester Square. 
 That was not all I learnt that day. 
 I hadn't even begun.  
 ENGLISH TEA 
 Margo Glantz 
 &bquo;Constable? 
 No, I'm not too keen on Constable. 
 Or rather I am, but my favourite English painters are Stanley Spencer and Turner. 
 And Hogarth.&equo; 
 I take a sip of beer, of lager. 
 His is a pint of bitter, mine's a half. 
 He has bought me a drink . 
 How I loathe that expression. 
 At home we say: &bquo;Would you like a beer?&equo; or &bquo;do you fancy a drink?&equo; 
 &bquo;Okay, I'm lying,&equo; I admit. 
 &bquo;There are lots of English painters I really do like.&equo; 
 In any case, it's weird that whenever I say that to Keith, he looks at me with the unmistakably quizzical air of the tall thin intellectual he is, his hair on the blond side of chestnut (now heavily greying); his fair skin with his rosy cheeks reminding one of Victorian youths with perfect complexions (or so the novels of Wilkie Collins and the paintings of the Pre-Raphaelites would have us believe); his eyebrows bushy and deliberately unkempt; his classic tweed suit of the old school, worn with a shamefully Byronic air somewhere between hippy and academic; his accent public school, as befits his education, although he also speaks a passable Spanish, so we can keep switching languages whenever linguistic difficulties develop. 
 Last but not least, Keith is an historian who has frequently visited Mexico and it doesn't faze him that I,  as a Mexican, should come to his country to write about its artists. 
 He's in favour of it, perhaps even likes it, and approves of the Third World rather as some of the English also evince my approval, Malcolm Lowry and Graham Greene among them. 
 And Keith is one of the few Englishmen I know who really likes Spencer, the rest dismiss him as representative of an imperial, conservative, rural English idyll. 
 &bquo;Not so,&equo; I insist, and Keith agrees: &bquo;But I like Spencer too.&equo; 
 He then continues: &bquo;There are only three great English painters this century: Stanley Spencer, Wyndham Lewis and Francis Bacon.&equo; 
 I add Burra. 
 We've just emerged from an exhibition at the Royal Academy, &bquo;British Art of the Twentieth Century.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, I like Hogarth, but Spencer intrigues me. 
 Did you notice they both concerned themselves with the everyday? 
 Spencer has his characters busy washing sheets, making beds, tidying cupboards, and Christ and his apostles appear in Cookham as though attending a summer regatta-&equo; &bquo;Fine,&equo; he says, rising from his chair, &bquo;I couldn't ask for more proof of realism, of everyday life&hellip; 
 &equo; &bquo;But,&equo; I interrupt, &bquo;for English snobs of the upper classes&hellip; 
 &equo; &bquo;Members of the aspiring middle class hankering after nobility,&equo; he continues, &bquo;these paintings offer what they most of all dislike: a celebration of the people.&equo; 
 &bquo;They'll be better off when they're part of Europe,&equo; I rejoin, now in the pub doorway. 
 Keith says goodbye, impatient to be off. 
 I carry on talking with the same chattiness and speed that got Jane Austen's heroines into trouble. 
 He is not to walk out on me before I run out of steam. 
 &bquo;England is an island without sea, or else an island that used to be sea-bound, only so long ago that the sea's now evaporated.&equo; 
 He impatiently plants a swift kiss on my cheek and&hellip; and is already gone. 
 I like &mdash; I'd like &mdash; to smoothe his eyebrows with my tongue and maybe more besides. 
 But it's too late now, I've frittered away the time, as usual. 
  Sunday and it's very cold. 
 I'm waiting at Charing Cross station and I'm wrongly dressed in a black hat and coat, whereas I should have come in jeans and a heavy Shetland jumper. 
 I'm off to Boulogne-sur-Mer with Rosita, Keith, Brian and Sue. 
 Not by plane, we'll catch the train and then the ferry like before, almost nostalgically since when the tunnel is open, there'll be no more frontiers to cross: the sea, I think again, has already ceased to exist for England. 
 Where are those boats beloved of Conrad? 
 Nowadays it's the regular ferries that capsize &bquo;D'you remember last year's Zeebrugge catastrophe?&equo; 
 We're sitting in the train, knocking back gin, and I'm continuing the same line of thought, aloud. 
 &bquo;England has an archaic style; that's why I like Spencer.&equo; 
 I take another slug, and ignore the amused smile of those around me. 
 I talk and talk, they drink and drink. 
 &bquo;And what with the tunnel and the European Market, what'll be left of England? 
 Will the pound sterling be done away with, the last relic of that ancient monetary system of shillings, pennies and guineas?&equo; 
 We carry on with the gin, nobody paying any attention to my sentimental reminiscences, contradictory and literary as they are and unable to express my conflicting desire that England be an island in a timewarp and that the English behaved like Continentals. 
 Nobody listens but instead they stare out at the countryside, the classic English landscape. 
 Then suddenly the white cliffs, a salty tang in the air, a few sheep and a funereal sky. 
 We've arrived in Folkestone, to leave the train and board the ferry. 
 We continue drinking, gazing out at a sea now almost as redundant as five o'clock tea or straw boaters, both commonplace back in the 1950s when the children in Lord of the Flies  became violent in the midst of their paradisical island, at precisely this magical hour of five o'clock, and in the living room, that sweetly British interior, flowering the semi-darkness into a  plethora of chair covers and curtains, sprigged bone china and mums in Liberty-print dresses&hellip; 
 &bquo;The tea itself,&equo; I reflect aloud, &bquo;is transformed by bleaching it with milk, so it no way resembles the complexions of those swarthy people , least of all the inhabitants of a tea-producing Indian subcontinent. 
 &equo;  
 (What of novels of Somerset Maugham, Forster and Conrad? 
 No, consider first and foremost Emily Bront&euml;'s Wuthering Heights , for who was Heathcliff other than a swarthy bastard  who spoke gibberish in preference to the Queen's English.) 
 &bquo;Such people,&equo; I continue aloud, &bquo;who are rendered suspect of nothing more than their swarthiness , are repulsive in their manifestation of a sinister attraction. 
 All the more important, then, to stand protected from the like and ensure that all things &mdash; not excluding alcohol &mdash; conspire to bear visible witness to that ruddy hue sported by the English living in the Tropics.&equo; 
 For some time it seems I've been talking to myself. 
 Nobody's listening but I insist: &bquo;This fairness  of skin obliges them to shield themselves so that if they do catch the sun they avoid the obvious danger of peeling. 
 Shedding their skin puts them in the same position as Jane Austen's heroes, prematurely aged by the treacherous sun of the West Indies.&equo; 
 The wind off the Channel is brisk and fierce and icy. 
 We're now at Boulogne, totally drunk. 
 The others are dozing while I chatter, attempting to cure their somnambulism with my words. 
 A jolt, and a voice booming through loudspeakers to announce our arrival in France. 
 I wake them up and we shamble along towards the Customs. 
 We reach the station at the same moment as an elegant train loaded with ladies preening themselves in their furs and hats, the men all wearing dark suits. 
 The compartments have little curtains in the windows; the lamps are lit; it's eleven a.m. but still winter. 
 Am I dreaming or is this the Orient Express of the inter-war years? 
 Irresistible memories of Agatha  Christie and Hercule Poirot. 
 The customs officer checks our passports, notes the absence of a visa in both the Mexicans'. 
 Having failed to obtain one means I've forgotten my status as a foreigner in Europe, Latin American, undesirable. 
 I need a visa and have failed to obtain one, Rosita likewise, and so they put us behind bars like prisoners. 
 Keith, Sue and Brian have British passports and enter Boulogne without visas. 
 Rosita and I are to be punished, stuck there with long faces, alongside our fellow wrong-doers, representations of swarthy people , black as tea taken without milk. 
 But with a sliver of lemon? 
 &bquo;You should see the care and tenderness Burra bestowed on his portraits of Blacks and Mexicans.&equo; 
 I'm advising Rosita, by the way reminding her of Malcolm Lowry, of whom we're all fans. 
 Rosita glances at me impatiently. 
 &bquo;And so,&equo; I continue, &bquo;the suntan becomes fashionable and it's no longer as necessary as it was &mdash; taking Robinson Crusoe by way of example &mdash; to hide from it under a parasol in order to conserve that fairness of skin  threatened by the desert island climate. 
 So that when he returns to Mother England he's still sporting that delicate shade of complexion so beloved of English males, and above all English females.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you understand the precise meaning of swarthiness ? 
 It's quite difficult to translate: would &bquo;negritude&equo; be the correct term?&equo; 
 Rosita looks at me indignantly, with a furious gleam in her eyes, a look of hatred that exactly transmits the colour of my question. 
 The customs officers run their eyes over us as if we weren't there. 
 Keith, Sue and Brian reappear weighed down with shopping bags, flashing their teeth in wide grins which set off their milky skins. 
 They show us an exquisite quantity of French cured meats, smoked crayfish, mayonnaise, salads, champagne, p&acirc;t&eacute;, patisserie and chocolates.  
 We retrace our steps to the station, wait a while for the ferry to take us back to Folkestone. 
 We settle ourselves down in a First Class cabin, lay our delicacies out on the table, open some wine and champagne, set the crayfish on to plates that don't look paper, and eat, drink and devour vast quantities of p&acirc;t&eacute;, hors d'oeuvre and champagne. 
 We talk, laugh, guffaw, sing in English and Spanish and suddenly, just before we dock I demand: &bquo;And now, all of you, who do you prefer, Spencer or Constable?&equo;  
 translated by Amanda Hopkinson 
 IF ENGLAND WAS WHAT ENGLAND SEEMS 
 Naomi Mitchison 
 Yes, we get some lovely views from the railway, just as you say, but &mdash; oh dear! &mdash; the industrial side and the back streets and the mess! 
 Yes, that was Birmingham. 
 If England was what England seems 
 And not the England of our dreams 
 But only putty, brass and paint, 
 How quick we'd chuck her &mdash; 
 That's what Kipling wrote. 
 He decided that after all England wasn't what she seemed. 
 But now? 
 It looks sadly as though only too much of England &mdash; or shall we say the English populace &mdash; is what it seems. 
 And should be chucked by those who still have some idea of what a good society should be. 
 What is Englishness, then? 
 I remember well, during the air-raids of the forties when I was in London and we waited as darkness came for the first sirens and the deep breath to get one's courage up, that we felt we were part of the will of the capital of England. 
 Knowing that if they break our will, they win. 
 So it must not be. 
 But this was different from Englishness. 
 So what can that be? 
 Looked at from Scotland, it is sadly tied up with Thatcherism, which, we hope, is something that will pass, since it goes against a better, more basic feeling  which is still there. 
 People of my generation were brought up to admire the sacrifice of life and happiness for others, the hope that we can live up to what this means in ordinary, dull practice. 
 We wanted, on the whole, to be good, not just through fear of punishment, but perhaps with an element of pride. 
 You may remember E. Nesbit, the great children's writer and inventer of the family of Wouldbegoods, who were very English, trying to do the right thing but often falling over themselves &mdash; or others &mdash; when it came to practice. 
 This surely is the basic English policy of helping and solidarity, which took us through the last war and into the first Labour Government and the welfare state. 
 Much of it still remains. 
 But the present doctrine of competition is destroying it, and with it the picture of our Englishness. 
 Children are mostly friendly, only accidentally cruel. 
 But soon enough they learn competition, useful at first, but dangerous when it becomes, as it easily does, the only atmosphere. 
 Not &bquo;His need is greater than mine.&equo; 
 Not Grace Darling. 
 You teachers realize well enough what is happening, but teachers have to play the competition game, assessing pupils, pushing them on. 
 One of their problems, of course, is Englishing children from other cultures. 
 Which England should they hold up as a pattern, a reasonably true pattern? 
 Whichever it is, the more it is rubbed in, the more it will fail to click. 
 Yet, haven't we tried to teach and think in non-racial history? 
 That isn't easy. 
 There is so much of it! 
 I would be surprised if it wasn't still possible to go through ten years of education with only the faintest idea of what has been happening in the world, even your own country. 
 In my day and at a good school, it was easy, as you moved up from class to class, to miss out totally on some period of English history &mdash; the only history that was taught. 
 It ended grandly with Queen Victoria's jubilee, having skipped over the Crimea and the Indian Mutiny. 
 But at least we knew a lot of Shakespeare by  heart, especially Agincourt. 
 But you are a teacher yourself! 
 Well now: this decision that all children must learn two languages, forgetting the thousands in many English cities who already have a home language, with a literature of its own. 
 Nowadays it may well be world history, deeply simplified. 
 Does it mean anything to most children? 
 What do they think Englishness is? 
 I suspect that most of them identify it with being white. 
 And because white, superior. 
 So Englishness is corrupted from the beginning. 
 If they think of history, it may be hard not to see it in dressing-up terms from telly watching. 
 Teachers may try to tip the balance about this Englishness. 
 Radio and telly make great efforts &mdash; at least sometimes. 
 But it is a struggle. 
 Good Englishness doesn't dress up, indeed it tends to hide itself. 
 There are parts of Asia and Africa where there are good memories of English people who devoted themselves, sometimes gave their lives, to the practical good of the indigenous population. 
 They were just and merciful. 
 Most of them, perhaps, were doctors, government servants of one degree or another; a few were farmers (I can think of one, still remembered) and some were just friends, as I myself have been for the Bakgatia and, I hope, for the whole new country of Botswana. 
 Up until recently the English have had certain virtues assigned: honesty, loyalty, fair dealing, kindness to animals (and women). 
 But how much is true now? 
 From Scotland we are apt to look at and condemn Thatcher's England, south of Birmingham, the greenbelt-eaters, the yuppies, the Sloanes. 
 That is no doubt wrong and covers our blindness to our own Scottish variety of unpleasantness, but easy to see how it happens. 
 Again, most women have at some time come across specimens of English anti-feminism, though the geography of this unpleasant addiction does not follow national boundaries or even religious ones although  both have their own special effects. 
 In some ways people in London (flower of cities all, as a Scots poet put it long ago), both men and women, have more freedom to live as they want than they have in most other cities. 
 But is that Englishness? 
 So, does dream England always disappear at dawn? 
 Well, there are strange little bits of old-fashioned good Englishness about, dating perhaps from the late forties, when city streets were safe and when people of good will in England were happy and even proud to see the end of Empire. 
 I think that Englishness, for all that we pull it to bits, had a certain important moral structure, which has been eaten away by unchecked competition, an underground civil war breaking our roots. 
 Can it ever come to life again, not as a bait and hook for politicians to use, not as a shouting for soccer fans? 
 The true dyed-in-the-wool, deep down Conservatives may feel uncomfortably that the sacred word has come into the hands of unsuitable people; including the Americans. 
 We, the people of good will, feel this even more strongly. 
 Can Englishness ever become clean again? 
 If so, it must change.  
 BEING ENGLISH 
 Fleur Adcock 
 You can't be it at home: they won't notice; 
 there are too many kinds of it around. 
 But abroad it's what you've suddenly become; 
 and it's cute, if you're in the United States, 
 or threatening, if you're somewhere else, or just 
 puzzling, if you're the only English-speaker 
 they've ever met who's not American. 
 You have to tell them, shyly naming the place 
 you never name at home, where &bquo;in this country&equo; 
 serves to avoid a tricky semantic choice. 
 At least with real &bquo;abroad&equo;, where they're all foreign, 
 you're braced behind passport, phrase-book and 
 hopeful smile. 
 What's more unsettling is when you're in a country 
 where they all speak English, and you understand 
 them, 
 and you ask for something simple &mdash; a return ticket, 
 say, or a pint of milk, or a bag of crisps &mdash; 
 and just for a moment they  don't understand you . 
 (They know about Englishness, but you don't fit 
 into any of its three varieties: 
 EastEnders, Coronation Street, and posh.) 
 You have to repeat your question, mouthing the words 
 like a goldfish: &bquo;No, not two, I said a return.&equo; 
 Or: &bquo;Milk &mdash; you know?&equo; 
 (You could try pronouncing it 
 &bquo;moowk&equo;.) 
 Or: &bquo;What I want is paper with narrow  lines, 
 not no  lines.&equo; 
 (An, they've got it &mdash; the phrase, that is: 
 you'll have to go elsewhere for the actual paper.) 
 And suddenly you've become the thing you are: 
 no longer a Commonwealth citizen, one with them. 
 &bquo;Crisps? 
 Aw, chippies, you mean.&equo; 
 The eyes narrow. 
 &bquo;Whaddarya, mate?&equo; they ask. 
 &bquo;Some kind of Pom?&equo; 
 FISHWANDA 
 Susan Daitch 
 Playing on the third floor of Loew's Thirty-fourth Street Multiplex, in Cineplex 3: Fishwanda . 
 The abbreviation as it travelled around the dot board, sounded as if someone were reading a map accordion-folded between Africa and India. 
 I went on to the next level to see Midnight Run . 
 Robert de Niro chased a mafia accountant from Brooklyn to Las Vegas, and afterwards as we walked down Second Avenue we repeated lines from the movie. 
 Do I know you? 
 Wait a minute, I don't think I know you . 
 We instinctively understood that de Niro was referring to Taxi Driver , even in this much later movie and it's funny. 
 We know the language. 
 We get the joke. 
 Fishwanda , seen briefly in a preview, disappeared, forgotten. 
 On lower Second Avenue we passed the Telephone Bar and Grill whose front was constructed from a series of British telephone boxes. 
 They could be copies, but they look real enough. 
 One red box is actually the entrance to the bar. 
 I continue to be surprised all those little panes of glass haven't been smashed in, but a metal door comes down at night and the neighbourhood is full of tourists anyway.  
 Money was supposed to be wired to her soon from somewhere. 
 As she walked from the post office empty handed, she pretended to be an American tourist, one who could leave in a few days, one for whom the trip would soon be nothing more than a few travel stories and postcards. 
 She wasn't sure she wanted to return, but seemed not to have much choice anymore, and so she stayed. 
 Dedham from Langham , long blues, long brown shore, brush strokes in the clouds; Rockets and Blue Lights (Close at Hand) to Warn Steamboats of Shoal Water , painted light rippled the sand and waves into a vortex and what were those people doing on the shore? 
 Who were they waiting for? 
 Smugglers, escaped convicts, drenched fishermen, or they might have been just watching the storm, voyeuristically curious to see a boat break up in choppy water. 
 Some of the paintings almost reminded her of the Hudson Valley, but she hadn't seen the Hudson River in nearly a year. 
 She stood before Constables and Turners and imagined Algonquin Indians on a western embankment. 
 She imagined tiny villages far to the north of England which had no electricity or telegraphs, which believed in lake monsters and King Arthur, and were not so different from northern towns near Canada. 
 The northern English towns might not know or care that Wall Street had crashed. 
 What does it mean that a market has crashed? 
 Boom, a couple of awnings tumble, a horse runs away, apples roll into the gutter. 
 Tiny American villages might by now have read about Black October and stockbrokers jumping from windows, fortunes utterly lost, but the crash mightn't mean all that much to them either, in northern American towns with names like Chateaugay, Champlain, Swanton, and Saddleback. 
 She hadn't quite determined what it was going to mean to her. 
 Perhaps nothing, but as she waited for money which didn't seem to be coming, it was  fairly certain the crash was going to mean something. 
 American travellers became stranded in Europe and turned into expatriates or exiles in Henry James's novels, shadowy amalgamation of foreign manners with shreds of familiar accents that were up to the narrator to decipher, but it couldn't happen to her, not in 1928, even with a crash. 
 The money to return home would have to come. 
 Mercurial changes in painted light were due to fog, not smoke signals. 
 She tried to remember the Hudson River as she had travelled down it by train, and the weather seemed constant although she knew it wasn't. 
 In memory, when the sun shone over Reinbeck, it would be bright in Reincliff as well and all the way down to New York. 
 In London she lost umbrella after umbrella, as if with each accidental leaving behind lay the idea that she might not need that particular umbrella again. 
 She left the museum and walked to her rooms to save money. 
 When she had arrived from France she was supposed to contact friends of her family, but the bag which had contained their address had been lost or stolen. 
 Weeks passed, but still she didn't bother to try to find them. 
 After travelling around the continent to a constellation of cities linked by who her father knew, it was a relief to cross the Channel alone and to arrive at a place where it was not generally such a struggle to make herself understood. 
 She liked to take walks alone, and occasionally pretended she completely belonged in St James's Park or Kensington and always had. 
 She invented a new history for herself, one of privilege, with distant relatives living in colonies who would send her ivory totems from Nairobi, tea from Ceylon, a three-eyed, many-armed brass Devi with a moon on her head. 
 The reality of a painted postcard of a log cabin and box of arrowheads disappeared. 
 As long as her money held out and she didn't open her mouth, she could almost make the artificial history stick. 
 She rented rooms from a woman whose husband died  in Suez and had left her a small income and a house in Whitcher Place. 
 The widow claimed to be particular about who she let to and told her a great deal about the other lodgers; a musician and a German student, both women, and one man, a writer. 
 His room was closest to hers and she often saw him coming and going. 
 He was simultaneously working on two projects: a glossary of regional expressions and slang terminology, so far mostly from London; and a Gothic novel. 
 He was often broke and was gradually forced to sell off his library. 
 On odd days he would work on the novel. 
 On even days it was the glossary. 
 She could hear him repeating phrases to himself through the thin wall between her room and his. 
 The landlady told her he would drive them all round the twist, he was born to chase a bob without success, and he left queer books lying around. 
 The landlady repeated that she was being very lenient with him but generosity on her part was not without limits, my girl . 
 She pretended to agree, suspecting that her time for trying the landlady's leniency would be next. 
 On even days he whispered about the five different meanings of how's your father  and the etymology of knackered, Bob's your uncles , and taking the piss out of X or Y . 
 On odd days, a young woman who had gone to work as a governess at a remote Scottish house wrote to an employer she never saw about portraits which moved in the middle of the night and which, the governess wrote, appeared to speak monosyllabic expressions of agony. 
 None of her letters were answered. 
 When he stopped his work for tea, the prying landlady being out at the shops, he would try to arrange to meet her, either in the house or at the British Museum if she were going near the West End that day. 
 He could justifiably be at the British Museum if asked. 
 There was always research to be done. 
 They met in the Egyptian wing, at the same place each time, near a fragment of papyrus which was labelled, The Opening of the Mouth  Ceremony. 
 This ritual restored to the mummy all his faculties so that he might enjoy the afterlife to the full. 
 She read all the labels as she waited. 
 He was often ten minutes late, as if the minutes had been timed exactly. 
 She didn't know what to think of these solicitations. 
 He rarely actually touched her, apart from taking her arm. 
 They began to meet in pubs, sometimes in the evening, near the centre of London where it was unlikely they would be noticed. 
 &bquo;Tell me about the funny Dutch houses and Red Indians,&equo; he would ask. 
 &bquo;Describe the historic fort, the table with a colonial's dried blood on it that's never been cleaned. 
 Whose blood do you think it is really? 
 Maybe it's a recent murder after all.&equo; 
 It was a stupid idea but nothing she said seemed to make any difference. 
 She wanted to say screw the colonialist blood but didn't. 
 She kept waiting for him to do something, but he hesitated, as if he were waiting for her. 
 She enjoyed hearing about the governess's letters which would never be received and translations of East End rhyming slang, but didn't think he actually listened to her, he often asked her the same questions. 
 It was as if he were memorizing her life so he could sail to New York, adopt a different accent, and claim to be a long lost relative due a piece of her fortune which hadn't been considerable and might all be gone now. 
 Sometimes she caught him looking at her, but he never really kissed her and the vagueness of his attentions made her anxious and say bitter things she didn't mean. 
 She didn't know what he wanted from her. 
 She thought she might have to move to a cheaper place anyway. 
 At breakfast he grew nervous and left in a hurry. 
 She was disappointed that he hadn't arranged to meet her during the afternoon or even later on. 
 She knew that his Gothic romance and glossary were being turned down by publisher after publisher and he grew despondent as he rewrote and rewrote again. 
 She caught him in the hall as he put on his hat. 
 Later, my dear , and he kissed  her quickly, when the landlady's back was turned. 
 Upstairs, alone, feeling left out of something she couldn't define, she looked through a pile of books left by his door. 
 She picked up London Labour and the London Poor , Henry Mayhew, and began to read. 
 I continued walking the streets for three years, sometimes making a good deal of money, sometimes none, feasting one day and starving the next. 
 the bigger girls could persuade me a do anything they liked with my money. 
 I was never happy all the time, but i could get no character and could not get out of the life. 
 I lodged all this time at a lodging-house in Kent Street. 
 They were all thieves and bad girls. 
 I have known between three and four dozen boys and girls sleep in one room. 
 The beds were horrid filthy and full of vermin. 
 There was very wicked carryings on. 
 I can't go into the particulars but whatever could take place between boys and girls squeedged into one bed, did take place and in the midst of the others. 
 She shut the book and walked out, down Camden High Street, Hampstead Road, past knots of schoolchildren in uniforms, prams, and grocers with horse-drawn carts. 
 She walked and walked, up Shaftesbury Avenue, Holborn Viaduct, she gave nothing to buskers, veterans of the Great War, gassed blind, missing limbs, clinking cups, Cheapside, Threadneedle, Bishopsgate to Spitalfields. 
 She circled back, stopping at Cleopatra's Needle, leaning over, looking at the river. 
 It was growing dark, and she thought of sleeping on a bench or under a tree in a remote part of Regent's Park, but she was afraid that, having spent the night out and returning in a dishevelled state, her landlady might assume the worst and not let her in again. 
 She could make up a story, say she suffered temporary amnesia, or that she was knocked unconscious by thieves and all her money was gone, but she doubted she could make it sound believable. 
 By the time she returned to Whitcher Place it was night. 
 On the first floor, a radio had been left on. 
 Trio Snotta in F , an announcer's voice said. 
 The room was empty. 
  She reached into a cabinet and turned the radio off. 
 The pretence fell apart. 
 As long as she had money, she could pretend she had always been here, but the prospect of destitution tested her false history in a way which made her feel it wasn't her fault. 
 She didn't know the language. 
 On the second stairwell she could see the landlady peering from the doorway of the writer's room, pink with anger. 
 Look, she said, he's left, bolted, owing three months' back rent. 
 She looked in. 
 The room indeed was nearly bare. 
 His books and clothes, all his things were gone, he had even stolen bits of china and a lamp. 
 He had give his name as E. Thomas Reardon and it turned out to be a pseudonym, so cheques left on the mantel were useless, and he must have known that they would be. 
 She had gone right to the bank with them when she'd discovered he'd gone. 
 Why ever did he bother to write them out? the landlady asked, gravely vexed and insulted. 
 She was hungry and sorry she'd turned off the radio. 
 The landlady stared at her in an uncomfortable silence. 
 She felt tired and cold from all her walking, her shoes badly worn, and without thinking she asked the landlady if he had left a note for her. 
 Only afterwards did she realize how foolish her request sounded. 
 Foolish in that it gave a great deal away to the other woman, and she could tell the woman looked at her as someone who could be aggressive and perhaps a bit vulgar, someone who said things which ought never even to have been thought. 
 The landlady looked at her with suspicion as she backed into her room and she resolved again that as long as she stayed in London she wouldn't speak to anyone. 
 She would be as if mute. 
 Eleanor Marx left Liverpool for New York on 31 August 1886. 
 She was thirty-one years old. 
 The first Americans she observed were on the boat and she wrote, &bquo;they  laughed at the poor immigrants lying on the deck in their wretched clothes&hellip; without the least sign of sympathy.&equo; 
 She was seen with a man in a loud checked suit who favoured bright ties. 
 Edward Aveling's interests in the signs of class were not the same as Eleanor's. 
 Nobody is as bad as Aveling looks . 
 Her friends, with the exception of Engels, loathed him. 
 He was the great love of her life. 
 In photographs his face looks pasty and his expression petulant; it would contradict his reputation as a seducer, and of his alluring voice there is no record. 
 Besides women he was pursued by financial scandals. 
 All that remains of his seductiveness are the historical traces of a bad lot. 
 Infamy Disrepute Scheming 
 In a letter posted shortly before departure, Aveling wrote, half ironically, but perhaps also partly believing the possibility existed, that he might make millions of dollars in America. 
 He was to see the beginnings of the great urban slums of New York and Chicago, and he must have had some sense of this if they were going to speak to American working people, but still, there was the mythology, the possibility of millions of dollars waiting to be made. 
 Though not an out-and-out cheapskate, he was thought the kind of man who would try to squeeze a shilling into a pound by whatever means. 
 On board ship he invariably tried to hoodwink other people, even a cabin boy, into paying for his sherry. 
 He was to have one heroic moment in America although the mythological fortune eluded him. 
 He looked over the women in the ship's dining room, just checking, a few glanced his way. 
 There were opportunities to flirt with other passengers, moments when young American women returning from a long  tour left mothers and aunts below deck, and, standing a few feet away from Edward, they stared out at the Atlantic. 
 He could do little more than watch porpoises and gulls with them. 
 He might have listened to complaints of how stifling an aunt could be when one wanted to wander around London alone, or how one got sick in Venice or Paris, but he could only touch an elbow with mock sympathy or pat a sea-sprayed hand. 
 Ten days on the ocean gave him a few chances to visit the cabins of single women, but until they arrived in New York, there were no places to escape once the liaison ended, however passionately, half-heartedly, or ephemerally it had begun. 
 If he needed to give the object of his desire the slip, he would have to hide in steerage or the boiler room. 
 (Even in the cause of evasion, Aveling was not known to have spoken to any workers during the course of his tour.) 
 A boat was not the best place for the kind of romance Aveling preferred. 
 As rumour circulated within its confines, Eleanor would surely discover his infidelities. 
 He leaned over the rail and watched porpoises and gulls. 
 Except for the burial at sea of a woman travelling to meet her husband, it was a dull voyage. 
 Once in New York he couldn't disappear into the city either. 
 If he could have, if he had no responsibilities, he would rent hotel rooms, write plays, and go to auditions. 
 He would meet American women of all kinds whose faces he imagined would reflect mixed nationalities, and he would tell them he was an actor who had performed before the Queen. 
 The American women wouldn't have seen his picture. 
 They wouldn't know that his trip had been sponsored by the Socialist Labor Party of North America and his time, if he stuck to his commitments, was to be all booked up. 
 The Statue of Liberty had just arrived from Paris and was being assembled so it was not in New York harbour when they arrived. 
 Lower Manhattan must have looked confusing to them as several different neighbourhoods met at the end of the island, at Coenties Slip. 
 Already  the new world was not easily reduced to one thing. 
 These contradictory elements drew Eleanor's first image of New York: smokestacks, horse-drawn carts, the steeple of Trinity church, shipchandlers offices, and English spoken in unfamiliar accents. 
 The black metallic S curve of the elevated train shadowed the squalor of the lower east side which had begun to grow under it. 
 They were taken deeper into that neighbourhood and Eleanor wrote to her sister Laura in Paris that she considered New York a &bquo;very dirty, shoddy town&equo;. 
 She stayed in the apartment of Wilhelm Rosenberg at 261 East Tenth Street between First Avenue and Avenue A. It is a street of tenements and railroad apartments and Rosenberg's apartment was one of these. 
 She didn't think to compare the German-speaking neighbourhood to Spitalflelds or the East End. 
 It was dirty and shoddy in a way that was very symbolic of New York: square blocks, square buildings, several storeys higher than English ones, packed full of people, no yards, no gardens, not even mingy ones with soot covered plants. 
 Eleanor and Aveling spoke to 25,000 people at Cooper Union, a school for artists, architects, and engineers. 
 The building is large, brown, a series of Romanesque arches in tiers that span Astor Place and Cooper Square. 
 There is a small triangular park behind it and the crowd may have spilled out from the Great Hall. 
 That night there was one Buddeke present, a Pinkerton agent. 
 Originally the Pinkertons were detectives but they became known for spying on union organizers and breaking strikes by violent means. 
 Buddeke, probably a German immigrant, was actually hired to tail Wilhelm Liebknecht, but on their American tours Liebknecht's and Eleanor's paths intersected. 
 (In a sense they must have worked in tandem since Liebknecht, whose English wasn't very good, addressed primarily German-speaking crowds. 
 Eleanor and Aveling were able to reach non-German-speaking Americans.) 
 When  Eleanor spoke at Cooper Union police entered the crowd and tried to disrupt the meeting. 
 As she saw movement near the doors Eleanor said, &bquo;I have been told that you in America enjoy such freedom that socialism is not needed. 
 Well, all you seem to enjoy is being shot by Pinkertons. 
 I speak not only of what I have seen, but of what I have read in your labour statistics. 
 You have no more freedom than us.&equo; 
 Buddeke wrote bits of her speech into a notebook as he examined those around him and made note of the enthusiastic individuals who happened to be standing nearby, describing dress, attitude, or making little sketches. 
 At the same time he tried to determine the identities of the Americans on the podium. 
 He was kept very busy. 
 When he saw the blue uniforms of the New York police, did Buddeke show them some sort of identification or did he just leave? 
 To flash a badge was to risk someone in the crowd remembering his face and in the future, on another job, he could fingered as the stoolie he truly was. 
 His cover would have been blown. 
 On the other hand, by refraining from identifying himself he risked being bludgeoned or arrested. 
 Photographs of Eleanor Marx survive but Buddeke's image has vanished. 
 His bill for spying on the English Marxists was &dollar;712.10. 
 The attempt of the police to cause a riot was called &bquo;a disgrace for New York&equo; by one paper. 
 Eleanor, Aveling and Liebknecht wrote to another, We have never seen in Europe such wanton interference on the part of the police with the liberty of the subject as we saw today in a country proverbially known as &bquo;the land of the free&equo; . 
 There was no quiet retreat, no time to rest between speeches and meetings. 
 Tenth Street provided no refuge. 
 Rosenberg's railroad apartment, one room following the next, offered little privacy. 
 Tenements were noisy and smelly, and then they left for New England. 
 If a movie were to be made of her American tour, one would see pages fly from calendars, clock  hands spin and headlines slapped one on top of the next. 
 The headlines of the New York Herald , for example, read &bquo;Socialist Pleadings. 
 Cooper Union Crowded. 
 Spurred on by a Woman.&equo; 
 &bquo;In European countries, it took the working class years and years before they fully realized the fact that they formed a distinct and, under existing conditions, a permanent class of modern society; and it took years again until this class-consciousness led them to form themselves into a distinct political party, independent of, and opposed to, all the old political parties formed by the various sections of the ruling classes. 
 On the more favoured soil of America, where no medieval ruins bar the way, where history begins with the elements of modern bourgeois society as evolved in the seventeenth century, the working class passed through these two stages of development within ten months.&equo; 
 Engels also believed in the myth of a new society which could be moulded in a sensible modern way, without &bquo;feudal traditions or appendages.&equo; 
 The Buddekes, however, were to win. 
 Eleanor made notes on the differences between English and American workplaces and unions. 
 Corporations, banks and trusts controlled a great deal and, although machines replaced workers more frequently in America, certain trades, Eleanor wrote, were 50 per cent more labour intensive than in England. 
 American labour politics were complicated and deemed a &bquo;slippery business&equo; by Engels. 
 Workplace observations notwithstanding, for Rosenberg, one judgement echoed: New York, shoddy and dirty. 
 Did she fault the landlords or tenants for shoddiness and dirt? 
 It seems obvious she must have known it was the fermer but he wished she had said so, after all this remained his city. 
 Rosenberg worked hard to raise the money to have them give the American lecture tour, and he was beginning to be  suspicious of Aveling, but Eleanor was devoted to him and deaf to all his antics. 
 In her loneliness Eleanor found no comfort in the geography of New York's lower east side. 
 The nearby Tompkins Square Park was dangerous, and walks by herself, Rosenberg told her, were out of the question. 
 Moments alone were limited to climbing his tenement stairs, smelling different cooking smells on each landing. 
 When she reached the apartment she tried to write, but sounds of crying children and raised voices came through the ceiling and walls. 
 She chain-smoked and stopped eating. 
 Eleanor used to say that she inherited her father's nose and she would one day sue him for damages. 
 She must have seen many similar noses in Rosenberg's neighbourhood, but how she felt about the similarity has not been recorded. 
 They travelled to Chicago by train. 
 Aveling eyeing hats and legs in the dining car, both fascinated and repelled by mid-western accents. 
 He was collecting notes for a book of random observations, a Thackeray-like Sketchbook, called An American Journey . 
 He observed that American women spoke and chewed gum simultaneously and took copious amounts of snuff. 
 Under the pretext of research he spent hours trying to observe a woman &bquo;hiding&equo; snuff. 
 He also observed that Americans wiped their noses on their sleeves, employed spittoons and had poor aim. 
 Coarse, money-grubbing provincials . 
 One of the myths Eleanor would speak against was the idea that socialists wanted to have women in common, and the men who made these accusations, she said, were the owners of the means of production anyway. 
 Chicago was in a state of siege in the aftermath of the Haymarket trial. 
 The Chicago Eight, anarchists unfairly tried and convicted had been sentenced to hang. 
 The Chicago press warned of &bquo;Dr  Aveling and his vitriolic spouse&equo;, in the language of a carnival sideshow. 
 The anarchist paper Freiheit , in opposition to the Marxists, thought Eleanor should have been shot on sight upon arriving. 
 Yet they drew huge crowds and all their meetings seemed a success. 
 Aveling preferred actresses, but they were more difficult to locate once he left New York, and he rather looked down on what passed as theatre in America, although he admired Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show . 
 He made no secret of what he thought of as the poverty of American culture. 
 His disdain was a source of embarrassment to his sponsors, but a greater embarrassment developed as they prepared to return to London. 
 He developed an aphorism, New York is over-eager to get rich . 
 He repeated it constantly, goading Rosenberg. 
 Rosenberg's suspicions of Aveling multiplied as piles of receipts were tuned in. 
 He had demanded exorbitant fees for his speaking engagements and billed the Socialist Labor Party for theatre tickets and corsages which he claimed were for Eleanor. 
 The irony of excessive expenses incurred for Karl Marx's daughter wasn't lost on Rosenberg, but Aveling called his accusations ridiculous, and he was defended from England by Engels who brushed off Aveling's embezzlements as the pranks of a boyish &bquo;noodle&equo;. 
 Rosenberg could sense the counter-accusations ringing across the Atlantic, the worst of them perhaps unspoken: Americans had idealist and somewhat puritan expectations of how Dr Aveling should have behaved, Americans are a simple people, literal-minded and dependent on secondary sources of information. 
 London papers in fact ate up the scandal, writing that the New York socialists would &bquo;nevermore import a professional agitator from the effete monarchies of Europe. 
 The luxury is too expensive.&equo; 
 When questioned about the contradictions between his enormous lecture fees and his supposed interest in the disenfranchised,  Aveling replied, Well, it's English you know, quite English . 
 When Eleanor left, the Statue of Liberty had just been unveiled in New York harbour. 
 Icon for future paperweights, imitation foam tiaras, and torches covered with foam flames, an image to be printed on bumper stickers, T-shirts and sweatpants, some of which, through donations, will find themselves passed out by evangelical missionaries in Central America one hundred years after the unveiling. 
 But in 1886, when Eleanor Marx sailed back to England, the statue was a symbol in its infancy, a giant thing, a gift from France, constructed in parts and shipped across the Atlantic. 
 If you walk east from the Telephone Bar and Grill, you arrive at the block where Eleanor Marx stayed when she came to New York. 
 The buildings are the same as they were one hundred years ago; there has been no development on this block. 
 Crack dealers operate on the west end of the street, near the Good Medicine and Co storefront theatre. 
 The Russian-Turkish baths are directly opposite 261 East Tenth Street and were probably there when Eleanor Marx spoke in New York. 
 They reserve one day for women, and in 1886 there may have been no day reserved for women at all. 
 261 is between a Reggae music store which has T-shirts and records in its window, and the Osgood Fulfillment House, a halfway house for runaway children. 
 Cooper Union is a few blocks west. 
 In front of the building people sell junk either stolen or scavenged from the garbage. 
 They have bundles and shopping carts full of things, old magazines, books, used clothing, shoes. 
 When it rains they huddle against the building, leave the objects on blankets or broken up cardboard boxes, only to return to selling when the rain stops. 
 The park behind the school is fell of homelsss people who have set out their blankets and mattresses near the  statue of Peter Cooper. 
 There is a methadone clinic nearby and on Saturday morning, if it's raining, junkies, too, meet under the Romanesque arches. 
 Lately none of these groups have been present in the park, but as it gets warmer they will return. 
 On a London bus she had heard a driver announce Stoke-Jewington when driving through Islington. 
 She had heard rhyming slang, she knew what four by twos  meant, and she'd once been asked if she could speak with a Jewish accent. 
 The man had come up to her at the entrance to the library where she worked and just asked her. 
 Can you speak with a Jewish accent ? 
 She thought he might have meant a New York accent, but she was from Los Angeles and wouldn't have tried anyway. 
 She'd also been addressed near Notting Hill Gate in Arabic. 
 When she couldn't answer, the man turned to his friend and said in English, she's not one of ours . 
 At work everyone was talking about the television dramatization of the Jack the Ripper story. 
 Michael Caine played a highly emotional, fairly hard-drinking detective who finally uncovered the Queen's physician as the Ripper. 
 &mdash; Did you know he was Jewish, someone asked? &mdash; The Queen's physician? &mdash; No, Michael Caine. 
 The head librarian expressed incredulity. 
 Judy Holliday, Piper Laurie, Laurence Harvey, Cary Grant (half), a woman in the cataloguing department who claimed to be Polish, those he knew about, but Michael Caine? 
 He said he was going to start a Secret Jew of the Week Club. 
 A different one every week but they had to be believable. 
 The Prince of Wales was out, and so on. 
 It was funny for awhile but the novelty soon wore off. 
 It was hard to top Michael Caine, and later the woman confessed she wasn't even sure about that one.  
 In New York in 1882 I met Oscar Wilde. 
 After lectures, theatre openings, at private parties, I would infiltrate his circle, usually posing as a reporter or a photographer, and while he tried to snub me, I pretended to ignore his ignoring me. 
 It was difficult to see him alone, but I did manage a few times. 
 I knew that my presence annoyed him, and if I'd stop to nurse hurt feelings, I'd travel home each night on the el, lonely and defeated, in the way one can be on a train. 
 So I just barged on. 
 I made my way home each night with at least some notion of hope and plans for a new assault on Wilde. 
 With what little money I had I would try to wear unusual suits or hats, learning a combination of subtlety and the unexpected in order to gain attention. 
 After leaving me outside a restaurant in the theatre district while he and his friends dined inside with Oliver Wendell Holmes or P.T. Barnum, I realized it was stupid to pander to his interest in aesthetics. 
 I was neither aspiring poet nor actor and had never been further east than Brooklyn. 
 I wanted to offer him something no one else would. 
 One night as he waited for a young man to find him a cab, I saw my chance. 
 He was alone for just a few minutes and I made my offer. 
 Oscar , I said, let me take you to Coney Island, it's like Brighton, I think, the Brighton of the New World . 
 I really had no idea if this was true. 
 He wasn't interested. 
 Oscar, I tried again, after engaging in a critique of American culture in speech after speech, will you fail to visit the spot where Walt Whitman had been known to read Homer after Shakespeare to the waves ? 
 He became mildly interested. 
 I nearly told him Coney Island was also known as Sodom by the Sea, but thought better of it. 
 Some subjects, I'd learned during the weeks I followed Oscar Wilde, were better left only as implications. 
 We arranged to take the train out on a Saturday. 
 I  knew Oscar would have preferred a quieter, less raucous venture, on a weekday perhaps, but I had to work on certain days and those days came up during his visit. 
 On the train as we rode past the spines of Manhattan to the flat rooftops of Brooklyn, he told me something of his travels in north America, indeed, he had been much further west than Jersey City, even beyond Chicago. 
 He told me how he had been deceived by a young man who claimed to be the son of a banker, and he had lost money in a gambling casino because he believed the con artist. 
 It had been a narrow escape and I was impressed. 
 He had next invested in Kelly's Perpetual Motion Company and lost more money. 
 In one city he had been impersonated by a woman named Helen Potter, and in another a boy of sixteen managed to get into his hotel room. 
 He'd left school and wanted his advice on becoming a writer. 
 I just gave him a piece of fruit , Oscar said, and told him to learn French . 
 Yeah, I'll bet, I thought. 
 I was curious about Kelly's P.M.Company. 
 Was it to do with zoetropes or physical fitness? 
 Afraid to ask seemingly stupid questions, I kept my mouth shut. 
 At about high noon we arrived at Coney Island and approached the boardwalk. 
 People pushed and shoved, stared at his madder lake suit, trousers cut off at the knee. 
 He looked faintly uncomfortable and began to sweat. 
 I pointed to the bathing lockers where we could leave our things and go for a swim. 
 No, he shuddered. 
 Wrong again, I realized, of course Oscar Wilde wouldn't swim with the immigrant masses. 
 I had the sinking feeling of failure. 
 Look, I pointed to the site of the former Coney Island house. 
 Do you know who used to stay there? 
 Melville and Edgar Allan Poe. 
 Together ? he asked. 
 The day, though hot, turned more promising. 
 We took a long walk down the Iron Pier. 
 Oscar took his jacket off and I offered to carry it for him. 
 It would have been easy to nick his wallet at that point. 
 The crowd was full of  pickpockets, as I pointed out to him, and I could have easily said, well, I am sorry Oscar, but you know it is one of the risks here. 
 I bought him a red hot, a sort of sausage on a roll with mustard. 
 He wouldn't eat it, so I did. 
 Later when he was hungry, he ate three of them in a row, washed down with bottles of beer which he said he didn't much care for. 
 American beer, pooh. 
 The Atlantic Ocean splashed against the pier, and he stared out to sea and began quoting Homer. 
 A few people stared. 
 Coney Island is about staring and he seemed to enjoy being a spectacle even for dirty children with candysmeared mouths. 
 He was invisible here, just a man in a strange suit and a funny accent. 
 Some mimed dances and twirled around him, humming popular songs. 
 Little did they know this was the fellow for whom The Flippity Flop Young Man  was written, and I wasn't about to tell them. 
 Would it have made any difference if I had? 
 Did he enjoy being a temporarily anonymous spectacle, or did he believe these seamstresses and pipe fitters knew who he was? 
 I couldn't quite tell, and as a sort of curator of the afternoon, it made me nervous. 
 One woman pointed to his madder lake trousers, said she wouldn't mind a pair like those. 
 Oscar didn't pay any attention to her. 
 By late afternoon we'd stopped in at a number of bars along the pier. 
 I managed to keep boys away from him, but in one alley he disappeared. 
 It was the worst of all Coney Island's dark corners, and I ventured down it, calling his name and looking in dirty windows. 
 It occurred to me that he might well have heard me and decided not to answer. 
 I still had his jacket, but he had taken his wallet out at one of the bars and had that with him. 
 It was growing dark as I walked down the pier alone, his jacket draped over my shoulders, and I wondered if I should really look for Wilde at all. 
 He could find his way back to New York somehow. 
 He could speak English. 
 He could ask directions. 
 I sat on the shore and stared at  all the junk left on the beach: beer bottles, paper wrappers, bits of clothing, shreds of cigarettes. 
 I thought I saw something purple floating in the tide, a pair of trousers, or a skirt, an upsidedown umbrella even. 
 In the twilight and without my glasses, I couldn't really tell. 
 Would I one day show people this jacket and say that it had been a lovely afternoon in Central Park when he gave it to me and, in closing, would I say that as he disappeared into the trees, I never saw Oscar Wilde again? 
 The purplish thing drifted on to the beach, but I felt too lazy to walk over and examine it. 
 The stars were clouded over, the gas lights were dim then grew a bit brighter, and I could hear a tinkly organ out of tune, the sound came from the direction of the Iron Pier. 
 Perhaps he thought I was the impersonator, dressed as a man, hoping to win his confidence and thus learn the kind of mannerisms and opinions he might reveal only in private. 
 Perhaps he thought that, and he'd given me the slip. 
 I brushed sand from my suit and strolled towards the pier, stepping on a rotten orange. 
 I nearly slipped on the convex peel as it made a squishing sound underfoot, doing small damage to my shoe. 
 The Bowery looked ominous but I wasn't afraid. 
 It was time to make some attempt to look for him. 
 Finally we give in and rent the movie we ignored a few months ago when we went to see Midnight Run . 
 As we listen to Kevin Kline run through every possible clich&eacute; about the English, the people who live upstairs begin to fight. 
 The noise gets louder and louder and we wonder if they are beating their children. 
 You think you have balls? 
 Well my balls are bigger than your balls . 
 Father to eleven-year-old son. 
 Sound of slaps. 
 John Cleese tells Jamie Lee Curtis he doesn't like being English all that much. 
 It's a pain being so repressed, he more or less says. 
 I call the police and describe the sounds of the fighting going on above my head. 
 It's Saturday night  and they may not come. 
 Sometimes they do, sometimes not. 
 We could turn up the movie but it doesn't help. 
 Before the end of it, we rewind and just wait. 
 A braindamaged man who lives with his mother near the top of the tenement comes in at eleven o'clock, after sweeping out Seventh Street Pizza. 
 He always repeats certain phrases over and over. 
 Sometimes it's No news is good news. 
 No news is good news. 
 I always say, no news is good news . 
 Tonight it's the story of his uncle and as he stands around in the hall, he talks about his Uncle Rocco who was stationed in Ipswich. 
 His uncle was fend of French fries and he tells the empty corridor for the hundredth time that they are called chips over there and they are eaten with vinegar. 
 Normandy Beach , he repeats as he climbs the stairs. 
 Normandy Beach. 
 Normandy Beach .  
 Win &pound;100,000 with Wilson  
 Federation Cup 1991  A Royal Occasion 
 SUPPORTERS OF BRITISH TENNIS. 
 MIDLAND The Listening Bank  
 Contents 
 MAIN POINT 
 Final countdown by Alastair McIver 
 SPEAKING MY MIND 
 David Wynne-Morgan 
 AROUND THE WORLD 
 What Price the Future by John Parsons (Daily Telegraph) 
 TOURNAMENTS 
 Stella Artois Grass Court Championships 
 Alastair McIver at Queen's 
 Direct Line Grass Court Championships 
 Barry Wood reports from Beckenham 
 Pilkington Glass Ladies' Championships 
 Alastair McIver reports from Eastbourne on a 10th title for Navratilova 
 French Open 
 Peter Blackman (Evening Standard) sees Courier and Seles triumph in Paris 
 Midland Bank Students Tennis &mdash; Sue McCarthy reports from Bristol 
 FEATURES 
 Insight &mdash; the world's best coaches on the game's greatest players. 
 This month, Pancho Segura on Jimmy Connors, by Lailee van Dillen 
 File America &mdash; Jim Martz (Miami Herald), looks at the Florida coaching academies 
 Coaching Commentary &mdash; Olga Morozova on the importance of fitness 
 NEW 
 Tennis workshop Alan Jones with Barry Wood 
 COMPETITIONS 
 WIN &mdash; &pound;100,000 with Wilson: Spot the Ball 
 WIN &mdash; Head Rackets 
 WIN &mdash; Ellesse &bquo;limited edition&equo; framed print 
 PLUS &mdash; Readers Letters, Positively Pilkington, Junior Tennis World, Junior Set by Lotto, Rankings, Results, Off Court 
 Final Countdown 
 Royalty, Read and the Radio One Roadshow&hellip; 
 by Alastair McIver 
 Fed Cup fever will hit Nottingham during the week of 21st July, when HRH, The Princess of Wales attends the Opening Ceremony for the 28th staging of this great women's event. 
 Apart from the large numbers of tennis fans expected on day one of the 1991 Federation Cup, millions more around the country will be witness to the day's proceedings, courtesy of the BBC's Radio I Roadshow. 
 D J Mike Read and guest Cliff Richard will be on hand to capture the excitement of the first day and hopefully set the mood for a week of high quality tennis &mdash; and not a little fun! 
 The Festival Court has a different activity taking place each day, while the Centre and surrounding &bquo;competition&equo; courts will see the best women players from 56 nations competing for what is the premier team prize in women's tennis. 
 As well as world No. 1, Monica Seles, fans will have the opportunity to see the top players, including Steffi Graf, Zina Garrison, Jennifer Capriati, Sanchez-Vicario, not to mention the British contingent of Jo Durie, Monique Javer, Clare Wood and Sam Smith. 
 From Seles down, the list of competitors reads like a who's who of international tennis players. 
 The telephone hotline for remaining tickets is 071&ndash;793 1234. 
 If you haven't got your ticket to the 1991 Federation Cup by NEC, presented by Midland Bank, then call now. 
 Nottingham beckons&hellip;   
 Countdown 
 Ah yes I remember it well&hellip; 
 10 things you didn't know about the Federation Cup 
 &bull; 
 Billie Jean King played in the first five Federation Cup finals. 
 Representing the United States, she played between 1963 and 1967. 
 &bull; 
 Martina Navratilova is the only player, to date, to have represented two countries in Federation Cup competition. 
 She played for her native Czechoslovakia in 3&ndash;0 defeat of Austria in 1975, and then played for the United States in 1982 and 1986. 
 &bull; 
 Prior to the establishment of the Federation Cup by the ILTF (now the ITF) in 1962, the former US player, Margaret du Pont, together with former Australian pro, Thelma Coyne Long and supported by the USTA, had drawn up plans for their own women's international team competition and had even offered to donate a cup for the event. 
 It was all too late for the ILTF, however, which, in 1962, announced that the first Federation Cup would take place at Queen's Club in June 1963. 
 &bull; 
 In 1977, the Federation Cup was contested at Eastbourne and replaced the traditional pre-Wimbledon ladies grass court tournament that year. 
 &bull; 
 Brazil was the first South American country to host the Federation Cup in 1984, some 21 years after the event was founded. 
 &bull; 
 The Federation Cup itself was purchased in 1982 for &pound;300 and it is inscribed in two languages, English and French. 
 &bull; 
  Prizemoney  was awarded for the first time to competing teams in 1976. 
 Colgate Palmolive sponsored the event's  prizemoney  to the tune of &pound;130,000. 
 &bull; 
 Virginia Wade has the best win/loss, singles/doubles record of any player, in Federation Cup competition, either British or foreign. 
 She represented Great Britain for 16 consecutive years, between 1967 and 1983. 
 She won 67 of her 99 singles and doubles matches. 
 &bull; 
 This year's total of 56 participating nations is a record for the Federation Cup. 
 It beats last year's record of 47 (in Atlanta) by 9. 
 &bull; 
 When this year's competition in Nottingham is completed, Great Britain, like Japan, will have hosted it on 3 occasions. 
 The United States and Australia have both hosted it 4 times each, while a total of 10 other countries have hosted the Federation Cup either once or twice. 
 How to get there 
 Nottingham is easily accessible by road, rail and air 
 Weekday departures every hour from St Pancras. 
 Journey time about 100 minutes Phone 071&ndash;387 7070 or contact your local station for details. 
 The City of Nottingham Tennis Centre is situated 3 miles south west of the city centre and a regular bus service stops outside the Centre: Service numbers 13 and 14 from Friar Lane, next to Market Square. 
 Park and Ride facilities will be available from the Victoria Embankment to the Tennis Centre. 
 Look out for signs to Federation Cup Park and Ride at city approaches. 
 Sunday 21st July 10am 
 Preliminary Matches 
 5pm Opening Ceremony (in the presence of HRH, The Princess of Wales) 
 Monday 22nd July 1pm 
 1st round main draw matches 
 International Day &mdash; the first day that local schools begin their support of their adopted nation in the &bquo;Welcome to the World&equo; project. 
 Tuesday 23rd July 1pm 
 1st round main draw matches (cont.) 
 Cliff Richard &bquo;Search for a Star&equo; 
 Children's Day &mdash; all activities on the Festival Court will be geared towards children, tennis and fun. 
 Wednesday 24th July 1pm 
 2nd round main draw matches 
 Year of Sport &mdash; Great Britain is this year celebrating a &bquo;Year of Sport&equo;. 
 Therefore, all activities in the Festival areas will be connected with various sports &mdash; not just tennis. 
 All sports' enthusiasts are invited to take part. 
 Thursday 25th July 1pm 
 Quarter-final matches 
 Ladies Day &mdash; All activities in the Festival area are aimed at encouraging more ladies to take up tennis. 
 Friday 26th July 1pm 
 Quarter-final matches (cont.) 
 Club Players' Day &mdash; All activities in the Festival area are geared to those club players who play tennis on a regular basis. 
 Saturday 27th July 1pm 
 Semi-final matches 
 Family Day &mdash; Families will be encouraged to play tennis together amidst related activities on the Festival Court. 
 Sunday 28th July 1pm 
 Final 
 Closing Ceremony 
 Virginia Wade &mdash; Fed Cup record holder 
 Hana Mandikova &mdash; representing Czechoslovakia in Tokyo 
 Speaking my Mind 
 David Wynne-Morgan 
 Player power is once more causing concern amongst those responsible for administering tennis throughout the world. 
 Even the players themselves are getting concerned although they put it in slightly different terms. 
 Boris Becker recently expressed the view that there was too much money in tennis and that it was ruining the game &mdash; a view of course that it is much easier to make objectively once you have &pound;5m in the bank. 
 It is, of course, money that causes almost all the trouble. 
 It is at the root of almost all the player power problems. 
 One man who would sacrifice all his prize money for the year just to win the Wimbledon Singles Crown that has eluded him is Ivan Lendl, and the tension clearly showed when he lost to the Canadian Grant Connell in windy, dark, and damp conditions in the Stella Artois Championship at Queen's Club. 
 It was no way for the holder to go out. 
 Ivan Lendl has been a great credit to the game which he has played with distinction for so long. 
 His discipline, his dedication, and his pursuit of excellence may not have made him the most charismatic of world class players, but it has made him one of the most respected. 
 He had an uncharacteristic fall from grace in his match against Connell. 
 Clearly, out of sorts with himself in the wet and windy conditions which he hated, he smashed his racquet on the ground on no less than eight occasions. 
 The umpire never said a word. 
 There was no rebuke or caution of any kind. 
 This is the kind of inconsistency that encourages players to take advantage. 
 I wonder whether the umpire's attitude would have been the same if the offender had been his opponent, the comparatively unknown Grant Connell. 
 I am afraid I believe a caution would have come a great deal more quickly. 
 As we go to press, there has been no satisfactory explanation as to the withdrawal of the number one seed Monica Seles from the Wimbledon Women's Singles at the last moment. 
 A fine of &pound;4,000 is certainly not going to act as any kind of deterrent to her future behaviour. 
 Monica has had a very hard year. 
 The stress and strain on muscles and joints is considerable, but why has she not sent the doctor's certificate as a matter of courtesy to the tournament authorities? 
 Monica's number one ranking would have been at stake at Wimbledon. 
 Grass is not her favourite surface and there were many who thought she would have great difficulty holding off the challenges of Steffi Graf, Martina Navratilova or Gabriela Sabatini. 
 I am sure that had nothing to do with her withdrawal but the way she did it raised more questions than it answered. 
 I suspect that the rejection of the &pound;7m offer by the All England Club for the land of the Wimbledon Sports Club opposite is not by any means the end of the story. 
 The Club is almost entirely financed by the proceeds it gets from turning a large part of the Club into a giant car park throughout The Championships. 
 I do not entirely believe the member who said that their traditions were more important than the money. 
 I equally do not believe that the All England Club is going to sign a contract to create a completely new club in Basingstoke tomorrow morning. 
 So tennis fans can, for the moment, pout away their railway timetables. 
 I am afraid I am cynical enough to believe this is just another round of a giant game of poker, where the only thing that will matter in the end will be the size of the cheque. 
 Negotiations have not finished; I am sure they are just beginning. 
 Watch this space&hellip;  
 Tennis World Club &mdash; Prize Draw 
 WIN a Casio Mini TV 
 It's true. 
 We have a Casio TV 470 colour pocket television to give away this month. 
 The TV 470 is the first pocket television in the range to incorporate a new auto tuning system. 
 It features a 2.2&ins; screen with built in aerial, weighs as little as 8oz and comes complete with a protective soft case and batteries. 
 The Casio TV 470 has a retail value of &pound;99.99, which makes it a great prize for our readers. 
 All that you have to do to be included in the draw for this super prize, is to take out a subscription for yourself &mdash; or a friend or relative &mdash; by 25th August, on which day the draw will take place. 
 The winner will be notified immediately and his or her prize will follow within 21 days. 
 If you want to go into the draw, then just complete the form below and send it, with your remittance, to arrive at the editorial offices by 25th August. 
 Tennis World Magazine &mdash; you know it makes sense.   
 Around the World 
 WHAT PRICE THE FUTURE? 
 by John Parsons (Daily Telegraph) 
 Seldom has Philippe Chatrier, a man renowned for his forthright views, especially whenever he has felt the advancement or the image of tennis was at risk, been quite so outspokenly blunt, as in his final Presidential newsletter he issued before ending his 14 year reign in charge (which &amp; referred to in last month's column) at The International Tennis Federation. 
 The focus of what could be seen as a heartfelt cry for commercial sanity to be restored to the sport centred upon one simple but now all-consuming issue &mdash; money! 
 &bquo;Make no mistake,&equo; he warns, &bquo;money is now a cancer in the game. 
 Our game really is in danger of dying from too much of it.&equo; 
 No doubt there will be some who dismiss such utterances as hypocritical, asking how such views can be reconciled with the way Mr Chatrier, as President of the French Tennis Federation, worked so hard to provide Paris, in what was already a crowded autumn calendar, with what at the time was the richest official indoor tournament, other than The Masters, in terms of prize money. 
 The will point to his agreement, however reluctantly, to the introduction of the Compaq Grand Slam Cup last year &mdash; the ITF's official end of the season competition &mdash; which offered &dollar;2m to the winner and &dollar;6m overall, more than double the amount on offer at the ATP Championships and which even some of the players, including Boris Becker and John McEnroe, described as exorbitant. 
 Mr Chatrier's response would be direct and unashamed. 
 In his view, there are times when you have to fight fire with fire, or, as he put it rather more eloquently during his defence of the Grand Slam Cup decision, &bquo;It was a sad reality that we were left with no real option but to protect tradition with the modern deterrent &mdash; money.&equo; 
 Anyone who believes that Mr Chatrier's remarks can be dismissed either as those of someone who has lost touch with reality, are also way off the mark. 
 Few have done more over the years to encourage and inspire the growth and development of tennis by putting it on as professional footing as possible. 
 The rise in the quality of French tennis over the last 20 years, culminating in the emergence of players such as Yannick Noah, Henri Leconte and now Guy Forget, coupled with the transformation of the French Open at Roland Garros into what the majority of players regard as the best organised of the four Grand Slams (even though Wimbledon remains favourite as to the one they most want to win) are due very largely to the leadership he has shown. 
 What clearly frustrates him is that so much of the money now sloshing around in professional tennis, is being spent in damaging &mdash; or at least potentially damaging ways &mdash; rather than for the good of the game, as well as for the good of the individuals who are benefitting. 
 I make no excuse for quoting at some length from the Chatrier newsletter &bquo;I have always said that the biggest problem we face in tennis is that there is too much money around. 
 The main reason is quite simple. 
 Tennis is such a perfect sport for exposure in television.&equo; 
 Cancer 
 Then, after dealing with the Grand Slam Cup and explaining how he only went along with the idea after insisting that the event would also produce &dollar;2m for the development of the game in &bquo;third world tennis countries, he went on: 
 &bquo;Make no mistake, money is now a cancer in the game. 
 Our game really is in danger of dying from too much of it. 
 You cannot blame a brilliant young player who takes, say, the &dollar;200,000 he or she is offered, to play just for one night but it inevitably gives them a  totally false impression of life and what their tennis priorities ought to be. 
 But when you have a situation where youngsters of 12 or 13 &mdash; and in some cases even younger &mdash; who may only have won a couple of matches, are being offered &dollar;500,000 guarantees to sign up with one of the management companies before they are snapped up by one of the rival agents, the potential for long term damage is enormous.&equo; 
 This year, in prize money alone, there is well over &dollar;100m available for professional players round the world, including team events such as The David Cup and The Federation Cup. 
 And that is before you start taking into consideration commercial endorsements and appearance money which, at a conservative guess must add at least another &dollar;30&ndash;40m. 
 Yet all we seem to have heard, either from a few of the more militant leading players or their representatives in recent months, has been the cry &bquo;We want more.&equo; 
 If it is not the Women's Tennis Association, spurred on by the vocal support of Martina Navratilova and Monica Seles demanding equal prize money at Wimbledon and the French, then it is the voices on the men's side who want prize money for the top tier of their tournaments doubled to &dollar;2m. 
 Despair 
 It is not wonder that Mr Chatrier seems ready to throw up his hands in despair. 
 He has only expressed what a lot of other people have been starting to fear for a long time, that unless the commercial manipulators in tennis are careful, they could cook the golden goose. 
 Players need to be aware too. 
 An increasing number of directors of sponsoring companies are beginning to ask &bquo;What did we get for our money?&equo; when they so often see players to whom considerable appearance fees have been paid, losing limply in their first or second round matches and, even worse, then turning round and implying that the only tournaments they really take seriously are the Grand Slams. 
 Real Dangers 
 It's the market place economy, a case of supply and demand. 
 There's nothing you can do about it,&equo; I can hear some of you thinking. 
 May be, but it is also surely the duty of someone like Mr Chatrier, as a leading official of an organisation responsible for the continuing prosperity of tennis worldwide and at all levels, to draw everyone's attention to such dangers. 
 Make no mistake, they are real. 
 As Mr Chatrier put it: &bquo;All I would ask of any successor is that he will always try to put the best interests of the sport before money. 
 If it was not for the Grand Slam tournaments and the unique place they hold in the game, I am sure we would be losing this vital battle.&equo; 
 In his 14 years as president, both tennis in general and the ITF in particular have undergone enormous development and Mr Chatrier can take much of the credit for the changes which have taken place. 
 His foresight has been especially important in transforming the ITF from a largely amateur, mainly non-international organisation, with a staff of just four plus a part-time accountant, into an all-embracing tennis authority, with a staff of 40, capable of coping with increasing demands and responsibilities. 
 Olympics 
 Perhaps, though, his greatest achievement, was in leading tennis back into the Olympic Games for the first time since 1924. 
 As he now wistfully recalls, there were relatively few other supporters for the idea when he and the late David Gray, the ex-correspondent of The Guardian, who became ITF General Secretary, launched their Olympic campaign almost ten years before gold medals were again being presented to tennis players in Seoul in 1988. 
 &bquo;It took us quite a while to persuade other people just how much tennis in general could benefit, especially in those countries where Government grants are dependent on Olympic membership, if tennis was once again a member of the Olympic family. 
 &bquo;Although tennis was formally reinstated as an Olympic sport in 1981, it wasn't until 1987, some four years after David had died, that we finally persuaded the IOC to allow all tennis players, including the professionals, to be eligible to compete,&equo; he recalls. 
 &bquo;I had insisted all along that we could not return until that was the case and that having waited so long, waiting a little longer would not matter. 
 The only proviso, of course, was that in keeping with the Olympic charter, there would be no appearance money or prize money.&equo; 
 The success of the tennis in Seoul was the perfect answer to all those who had doubted either the need or even the  ethicacy  of tennis once more becoming an Olympic sport. 
 It has also contributed greatly to the funding for grass roots tennis in many parts of the world. 
 This was also another issue always close to Mr Chatrier's heart. 
 That was why he promoted the idea of the Grand Slam Trust Fund, an opportunity for the four Grand Slam tournaments, as the pinnacles of the game, to make a major contribution to the grass roots on a global basis, over and above the enormous funding they provide for tennis in their own countries. 
 Wimbledon as usual, led the way, with the first substantial grant. 
 The others soon followed. 
 Integrity 
 Over the years, Mr Chatrier has had his enemies and critics. 
 There must have been many an occasion when agents, in particular, must have wished to see the back of him. 
 Yet no-one could ever have doubted either his sincerity or integrity in fighting for what he always felt was right for the game. 
 In recognition of his enormous contribution to world tennis, fellow ITF members presented him during the World Champions Dinner in the elegant Pavilion Gabriel in Paris, during the French Open, with a specially commissioned bust, complete with that pugnacious chin which perfectly reflects the determined response he has always presented to any potentially damaging challenge. 
 Future 
 Mr Chatrier's involvement, and influence, in tennis is far from finished. 
 As a member of the International Olympic Committee, the sport which has been his life, both before and since his professional career as a journalist, will have a permanent voice in the world's most important sporting forum. 
 Providing his French colleagues agree, which is akin to the BBC agreeing to retain Dan Maskell, he will stand for another four year term as President of the French Federation, which will take him through to early 1997. 
 And as Life Honourary President of the ITF, he will continue his experience, knowledge and opinions, through the corridors of Barons Court&hellip; 
 Men only 
 The women will not, after all, take part in this year's Compaq Grand Slam Cup. 
 &bquo;We've simply run out of time in trying to reach an agreement with all concerned&equo; said tournament director, Alex Meyer-Wolden, who nevertheless remains hopeful that he will be able to stage a mixed event in 1992. 
 Any disappointment he may feel over the delay has been more than compensated for by the news that tickets for this year's event are already selling  fast. 
 The two German players, Boris Becker and Michael Stich (an unseeded semi-finalist at the French Open) have already qualified to take part&hellip; and, even more important, both have indicated that they will play. 
 &bquo;Michael Stich has definitely told us he will play and all the indications are that Boris will do so this time as well&equo; said Mr Meyer-Wolden, who spent several hours on a flight back from Australia earlier in the year, putting Becker in the picture of a wide range of his views, ideas and objectives. 
 Whatever was said, Becker clearly seems to have changed his mind about the credibility and validity of the Grand Slam Cup, judging by a recent interview he gave to Suddeutsche Zeitung, one of Germany's most influential newspapers. 
 Apart from re-iterating his belief, which is gaining support, that there probably should be a completely new major circuit of not more than a dozen tournaments, based round the Grand Slams and culminating in one end-of-season event, Becker said &bquo;We're not machines. 
 For the top five in the ranking list, only the Grand Slams count.&equo; 
 More directly, on the issue of the Grand Slam Cup, he added &bquo;I think it will replace The Masters (the ATP Championships finals). 
 I believe the two events will join together. 
 Both can't survive like this. 
 The ITF has more power than the ATP but the ITF needs the ATP.&equo; 
 Explaining why he now supports the Grand Slam Cup, after refusing to compete a year ago, he said &bquo;I have my word to the ATP that I would do everything I signed to do in my contract with them. 
 I think I am the only one who hasn't had to pay any fines for not missing a tournament. 
 And this of course, included not playing in the Grand Slam Cup because I was defending the idea of the ATP Tour. 
 Afterwards I realised that this idea was wrong. 
 That's why I am now relatively open-minded about the Grand Slam Cup. 
 &bquo;It is also an unbelievable chance for Germany to have the fifth most important tennis tournament in the world&hellip; a certainty also that tennis will continue there when Steffi Graf or I are no longer around.&equo; 
 Super Super Series! 
 Although no formal proposals have yet been announced by anyone, there is no doubt that the idea for a &bquo;Super Super Series&equo;, as I suppose it should be called, is gaining momentum. 
 The problem, of course, would be reaching agreement with all parties concerned, as to which events, other than the four Grand Slams, would be included. 
 One theory is there should be Sydney, a week earlier than at present, leading into the Australian Open, the Stella Artois Championships as the traditional prelude to Wimbledon, plus Cincinnati and Indianapolis on the way into the U.S. Open. 
 Rather more controversial would be deciding which tournament should take pride of place in the European clay court season leading into Paris. 
 Tradition suggests Rome, especially now that it is once more a major tournament in every way, despite suffering from so many lack lustre performances from some of the leading players this year. 
 Somehow, I cannot see either Monte Carlo or Hamburg allowing their status to be lowered without a fight. 
 Also in an ideal calendar, the Grand Slam Cup should be brought forward to the end of October, 4&ndash;5 weeks after the US Open, which would not only give the players a brief chance to relax but then to prepare for the &bquo;tour finale&equo; on an indoor surface. 
 As for the build-up venues for the Grand Slam Cup, providing the surface was the same, the geographical choice need not matter. 
 It could even vary from year to year. 
 The Stockholm Open would have a strong claim, but so too would Tokyo, not least for the enormous amount of Japanese funding there is these days for tennis. 
 Somehow I just knew in the end we would get back to the subject of money! 
 Protection Racket 
 Having realised, I suspect, at least for the time being, that they are not going to get anywhere in their fight for equal prize money at Wimbledon or the French, the Women's Tennis Association have come up with another proposal which I know has support in some areas but which I certainly hope will also bite the dust. 
 What they want in future is 32 seeds in all the Grand Slam tournaments instead of the 16 they have at present. 
 Their argument is that it is good for the tournament, a s well as the players concerned, if as many as possible of the higher ranked competitors survive the early rounds. 
 They also claim that the players have &bquo;earned&equo; this protection by the performances in the rest of the year which have brought about their rankings. 
 In my view, to have 32 seeds, even in the men's singles where there is far greater depth of talent than among the women, cannot possibly be justified. 
 To have 32 seeds in a 128 women's singles draw, would be nothing less than a protection racket. 
 It is difficult enough now to find any first or second round matches of any consequence in the women's singles at almost any tournament, especially the Grand Slams. 
 While the quality of play, and competition, at the top end of the women's game has increased superbly in the last few years, the drop off after the first half dozen or so, is still equally evident. 
 If you do not believe me, then listen to how Steffi Graf and Monica Seles let the cat out of the bag in Paris. 
 First, Steffi admitted &bquo;The women's event doesn't really start before the second week&equo; after most of the top seeds had advanced for no more than the loss of a few games. 
 Then Monica, in apparently wanting the ITF to change the Olympic eligibility rules to suit top players who did not want to qualify by playing in the Federation Cup, said &bquo;without Gabriela, Martina or I in the Olympics, they wouldn't really be the Olympics and Steffi could win the gold medal playing left-handed.&equo; 
 Ouch!  
 (Editor's note: We would be interested to hear readers views on the WTA proposal to increase the numbers of seeds in Grand Slam tournaments) 
 Chatrier's passionate pronouncement &bquo;money is ruining the game&equo; 
 Becker &mdash; Exorbitant prize money 
 Stich &mdash; Cup Qualifier 
 Tournament report 
 156 and Counting 
 Martina Money Machine Rolls on 
 by Alastair McIver 
 Another week, another win. 
 Another day, another dollar&hellip; well, another &dollar;70,000 to be precise. 
 The Martina money machine marches on but at 34, and with career prize money of &dollar;16million plus to her name, the dollars aren't so important these days. 
 It's the titles that matter, and Martina, with 156, has her fair share of them. 
 In fact, by winning the Pilkington Glass Ladies' title in June for the 10th time, she came to within one of Chris Evert's record of 157 career titles. 
 This latest victory at the sunswept and showery Eastbourne was probably one of her most satisfying, not least because she defeated a player in the final who herself, did everything but win. 
 Arantxa Sanchez-Vicario positively demolished her opponents with a ruthlessness reminiscent of Navratilova's great rival of the 1980's, Chris Evert. 
 The 19 year old Spaniard has always had the weapons but, so often in the past, has used them sparingly in her pursuit of greatness. 
 Now, there is an added urgency to her shots and she remains an unlikely threat to both grass court opponents and, (following her victory in the 1990 French Open and her re-appearance in the final again this year), clay court specialists. 
 Sanchez-Vicario gambled on power, played for the lines and left her opponents, particularly the vastly experienced but hopelessly out of sorts Pam Shriver and the Puerto Rican, Gigi Fernandez, floundering. 
 Shriver's recent long term absence from the tour, following shoulder surgery, and her lack of match practice were shown up by an opponent who was playing the women's game of today, powerful and merciless. 
 Shriver, good humoured as she was in her quarter final defeat, played &bquo;yesterday's&equo; tennis. 
 Despite the humour, which was lapped up by an appreciative crowd, it was a sad spectacle and one that must have left her regretting her comments, when asked about her chances at Wimbledon. 
 She said, &bquo;&hellip; 
 I think I would be top of any seed's list of players they would prefer not to have in their section.&equo; 
 As expected, Martina, fresh from victory in the Dow Classic in Birmingham, proceeded unharmed to the final, defeating Amanda Coetzer and Brenda Schulz for the second time in a week, Mary Joe Fernandez, and Heather Ludloff, all in straight sets. 
 She was held up briefly in the final when the in-form Sanchez-Vicario swept to a 4&ndash;1 lead (and deservedly so) and yet Martina, the grass court player supreme, merely drew on her experience, stepped up a gear, kept her nerve and won 5 games in a row to deflate the Spanish challenge. 
 It was all over in 60 minutes, thus confirming what everyone knew anyway &mdash; that Navratilova, at 34, is still probably the best grass court player in the world.  
 Special feature 
 This is live from Eastbourne&hellip; 
 by Alastair McIver 
 It wasn't one of the major soccer matches of the day, indeed, national media attention rarely focused on the fortunes of Bradford City Football Club. 
 And yet, when disaster strikes, it doesn't matter where it is, or what sport is taking place, the spotlight swivels to capture the emotion, the excitement, the sadness of the moment. 
 Such a moment came to pass on one fateful Saturday back in 1985. 
 Local radio sports editor, Tony Delahunty, microphone in hand, was working in the commentary box, which was located in the main stand, offering live reports to regional stations, servicing the needs of local radio. 
 Little did he know that, for the saddest of reasons, he was going to be thrust into the national, even international spotlight. 
 His reports from Bradford were no longer of the sporting kind. 
 This was tragedy. 
 The fire that engulfed the main stand, devouring some 56 lives in the process, was both fast and furious. 
 Delahunty's reports from the burning stand that afternoon won him worldwide acclaim and a number of top international radio and journalistic awards. 
 For Delahunty, though, although it was an horrific afternoon, it was also just another day's reporting. 
 Such is the life of the radio reporter. 
 And so to 1991. 
 Whatever local radio you were listening to during the 3rd week of June, it is likely that you would have heard Delahunty's editorial director, Paul Mace, on the hour, every hour, bringing you those live reports from the Pilkington Glass Ladies' Championships at Eastbourne. 
 The operation is a simple one but an effective one. 
 Based in the international press room along with some 60 or so other reporters from around the world, Mace watches, records and listens, aware that any time, his imminent live report could easily be overtaken by events. 
 For example, a 30 second live report which is due to take place at the same time as Martina Navratilova is about to serve for the match can be both a reporter's dream and a producer's nightmare. 
 Whatever, it keeps Mace on his toes. 
 &bquo;There's a fair amount of to-ing and fro-ing from the courts&equo;, explains Mace, &bquo;and I like to maintain my contact with the live action on court, as well as the monitored information in the press room. 
 It pays to keep in touch with the atmosphere of the match.&equo; 
 Nottinghamshire based Delahunty Associates has always provided a diverse service of sports reporting but now sees its role in tennis, in particular, developing. 
 &bquo;We are established in many other sports, including the Johnnie Walker Ryder Cup, the RAC Rally, the Silk Cut Derby at Hickstead, the Benson and Hedges Snooker Masters at Wembley, the Volvo European PGA Tour and the British Grand Prix&equo;, explains Delahunty, &bquo;and although we have been in tennis since 1985 when Stella Artois first commissioned us, I still look at tennis as a growth area. 
 We maximise sponsor benefits in all media so that they can get their name all over the country. 
 We feel that, by using experienced broadcast and newspaper trained personnel, we know what both the public &mdash; and sponsor &mdash; requires&equo;. 
 It helps, of course, that tennis people in general be they spectators, administrators, media or players, all seem to be accommodating and welcoming of the increased media opportunities which are now available to broadcasters. 
 It's something which Delahunty finds particularly helpful. 
 &bquo;Tennis is one of my favourite sports now because tennis people, in general, are perfect gentlemen and ladies.&equo; 
 Who am I to disagree? 
 (Tony Delahunty Associates can be contacted on 0949 836090) 
 Exclusive competition 
 WIN An Ellesse limited edition &bquo;Couples&equo; print 
 Tennis World has teamed up exclusively with Ellesse UK to offer our readers a fabulous 30 by 40 inches signed and limited edition print. 
 The print, named &bquo;Couples&equo;, was photographed and styled exclusively for Ellesse. 
 The dual colour technique has resulted in a renowned piece of photography which has been translated into quality national press advertising. 
 The print is framed black and gold. 
 To have a chance of winning this superb prize, just answer the three questions below and send your answers in to arrive not later than 28th August. 
 1 
 From which country does the Ellesse brand originate? 
 2 
 Name the American, a former Wimbledon Champion, new retired from competitive play and expecting her first child, who is one of the company's longest serving contract players? 
 3 
 What are the two colours used in the Ellesse half tennis ball logo on its clothes and shoes? 
 Positively Pilkington 
 Nelson Has One Eye on Seniors 
 Pam Nelson may not yet be a household name but if this young American progresses in the same manner as previous Pilkington Glass U.21 Champions Steffi Graf, Arantxa Sanchez, Jana Novotna and Manuela Maleeva, then it will not be long before her name appears in the latter stages of the world's leading tournaments. 
 Pam emerged from a strong field headed by twenty-fifth ranked Sabine Appelmans from Belgium and two of the world's most successful juniors in recent years, Maggie Maleeva and Cristina Tessi. 
 On route to the final, Pam defeated Appelmans 6&ndash;3, 6&ndash;3 and Tessi 6&ndash;2 6&ndash;3. 
 In the final, Pam's aggressive game produced a 6&ndash;4 7&ndash;5 victory over another young American prospect Clare Rubin. 
 Once again, the U.21 event provided invaluable experience for young British players. 
 Mandy Wainwright played exceptionally well in taking the middle set 6&ndash;3 from 142 ranked Nana Miyagi from Japan; whilst Joanne Ward typically made the most of her opportunity by extending Cristina Tessi to 7&ndash;5 6&ndash;1. 
 Indeed Joanne was unlucky not to claim the first set, having served for it at 5&ndash;3. 
 (See Junior Set by Lotto, where Joanne is featured) 
 The supporters at Devonshire Park are looking forward to seeing how Pam handles the transfer from the U.21 event to the senior event. 
 The 1900 U.21 Champion, Arantxa Sanchez certainly made a successful switch this year by reaching the final of the Ladies singles!  
 Anthony Mule, the winner of the Pilkington Glass Save the Children Longest Rally, was presented with two tickets for a tennis coaching holiday at La Manga Club in Spain and flights courtesy of Falcon travel. 
 Pictured with Anthony, &bquo;the 1066 Man&equo;, are Joe Durie, Rose Saliba from La Manga, David Crook &mdash; Marketing Communications Manager at Pilkington Glass, and Anne Noakes &mdash; the coach who actually rallied with Anthony. 
 File America 
 Florida's Dream Machines&hellip; 
 Where today's talent is turned into tomorrow's champion 
 By Jim Martz (Miami Herald) 
 In light of the heat and humidity that permeate Florida much of the year, you could call the tennis academies that dot the state &bquo;Sweat Shops for the Sneaker Set&equo;. 
 But these facilities are much more than that. 
 Some are veritable campuses where students can learn about logarithms as well as lobs, fine arts as well a s fitness training. 
 They attract would-be Boris Beckers and Monica Seleses from Anchorage to Zurich, from London to Lakeland, Fla. 
 And they strain the bank accounts of the students' parents, some academies costing more than &dollar;2,000 per month. 
 Are they worth it? 
 If your goal is a college scholarship, the odds are very high that attending one for a few years will lead to a number of scholarship offers from top-notch college tennis programmes in the United States. 
 If your goal is the professional tour, your  chances can be enhanced because of the superb coaching, training facilities and opportunity to practice with and compete against leading junior players daily. 
 The most publicized US tennis camp is the Nick Bollettieri Tennis Academy at Bradenton, where Andre Agassi, Jim Courier and Seles honed their games. 
 But Florida has two other prominent international junior training centres &mdash; the Rick Macci International Tennis Academy at Grenelefe Resort a few miles from Orlando and Disney World; and Harry Hopman/Saddlebrook Resort in the town of Wesley Chapel near Tampa. 
 Jennifer Capriati, who stormed onto the women's pro tour at the age of 14 last year, is a product of both the Macci and Saddlebrook academies. 
 Capriati spent two and a half years under the tutelage. 
 When she was 13, she moved to Saddlebrook, where the United States Tennis Association operates one of its Player Development Centres. 
 An honour roll student, Capriati attended eighth and ninth grade classes at the Palmer Academy at Saddlebrook. 
 It is a college preparatory school headed by Dr Norman A Palmer. 
 His son, Jared, attended the academy and is now a student at Stanford University in California, where he won the National Australian Collegiate Athletic Association men's singles championship this spring. 
 The tennis camp was started in the 1970s by Hopman, the renowned Australian Davis Cup coach who died in 1985. 
 Dr Jack Groppel, an international recognised expert on fitness training, is director of player development at Harry Hopman/Saddlebrook International Tennis. 
 There were 79 students at Saddlebrook during the 1990&ndash;91 school year, including James Prendiville, Julian Shamsa and Hesham Busefi who is from London. 
 The graduating seniors were accepted to such colleges as UCLA, Stanford, Harvard, Princeton, Yale, Michigan and Florida. 
 There is plenty of individual instruction available at both the Palmer school (25 pros) and at the Hopman tennis academy (30 pros). 
 The cost for room, board, tuition and tennis instruction is &dollar;5,885 per quarter. 
 At Macci's academy, enrolment during the school year is limited to about 40 students &bquo;for control factors and because we want to maximize everybody playing supervised matches on Tuesdays and Thursdays,&equo; Macci said. 
 &bquo;We drill on Monday, Wednesday and Friday.&equo; 
 Former Macci pupils include Tommy Ho, who turned pro three years ago at the age of 15, and Will Bull, the National Boys 18 runner-up in 1990 who is a rookie on the tour. 
 Macci's students include 11 from foreign countries, among them Gerrard Quinland from London. 
 They all attend  nearby public schools. 
 &bquo;We feel it is a healthy situation,&equo; Macci said of students going to public schools. 
 &bquo;They are around kids who don't play tennis. 
 It's as close to normal as it can be.&equo; 
 About 75 percent of the students are nationally ranked in tennis. 
 A year ago, 11 of his students earned scholarships to four-year colleges. 
 On a typical day, Macci's students go to classes from 7.30 am to 1.15 pm (they substitute their physical education classes with tennis). 
 Back at the academy, they eat lunch at 2 and are on the court from 2.30&ndash;6.30. 
 Matches are videotaped and charted to keep track of errors and winners. 
 Macci employs a staff of 11 full-time tennis pros during the school year. 
 There are 18&ndash;20 on the staff in summer when up to 60 boys and girls are at the academy. 
 Cost during the school year (September to June) is &dollar;2,200 per month; in summer it's &dollar;625 per week. 
 &bquo;The summer program is intense tennis,&equo; Macci said. 
 &bquo;It's geared to the more serious player. 
 It's usually 95 degrees and humid, so it's not for the lighthearted.&equo;  
 Macci Training &mdash; It's Tough 
 New Men's Squads 
 cellnet  Cellnet &amp; LBA Initiative 
 A unique joint venture between Cellnet and the Lawn Tennis Association has resulted in the formation of three men's tennis squads, guaranteeing financial support to fourteen of the UK's most promising players. 
 The three new squads will be formed in addition to the Davis Cup squad, and represent the most tangible development of the Cellnet's sponsorship since the country's leading cellular phone network operator announced its six-figure commitment to British men's tennis last autumn. 
 The principal objective of the scheme is to provide each of the fourteen candidates with a 12-month commitment to his appropriate squad. 
 Each player has been set an individual achievement target, and has the security of a year-long period in which to prove himself. 
 As well as appropriate financial support, two of the squads will benefit from the services of a full-time travelling coach. 
 The three Cellnet squads, and their members, are:  
 &bquo;This is a major step forward in British men's tennis &mdash; truly a first,&equo; commented the LTA's Director of National Training, Richard Lewis. 
 &bquo;We have never before been able to run more than one senior men's squad, yet now, thanks to Cellnet's backing, we will have three to back the elite Davis Cup squad. 
 Each offers slightly different and more appropriate benefits to the players, so that the individuals have a secure platform from which we hope they will make serious bids for international success. 
 &bquo;A good example of the sort of player who should be a great beneficiary of this scheme is James Lenton &mdash; a tremendously hard worker who has struggled financially and once even had to quit to resort to coaching,&equo; Lewis added. 
 &bquo;He has been crying out for support for ages, and I am sure that this new opportunity is just what he is looking for.&equo; 
 Nigel Sears will be taking up the role as permanent coach to the Cellnet Challenger Squad, whilst John Paish will be working with the Achiever Squad. 
 &bquo;Cellnet is a business whose success is based on innovation and quality,&equo; stated Marketing Support Manager Paul Leonard. 
 &bquo;It is therefore highly appropriate that we should support this innovative scheme to enhance the quality of British men's tennis.&equo;  
 Bailey Back to fitness with the challenger squad 
  Readers  letters 
 Winning Letter 
 This month's winning letter comes from Donna Davidson who, amidst a big postbag on the subject of Steffi Graf's popularity, offers her support to the German in an honest and fair way. 
 Donna wins for herself a Head Electra Master racket of stiff graphite construction in the head with slightly softer flex in the shaft. 
 The Elektra is designed for the intermediate player and comes complete with racket bag. 
 Genuine Graf 
 I am writing in reply to all the letters you have printed over the past few months about Steffi Graf. 
 Being one of her biggest fans I would like to say I am sick and tired of all the criticism that she receives. 
 There have been people writing in asking for her fans to stop making excuses for her. 
 Everything that has happened to her over the past year has been genuine, from breaking her thumb to the operation, not to mention all the hassle she has had from standing by her father. 
 That alone would make anyone else want to hide away but not Steffi. 
 She fought her way through like a true champion. 
 May be she did not do as well in the major championships as in previous years but in 1990 she still managed to win one Australian, get in to the final of the French and the US Opens, and the semi final of Wimbledon. 
 Now who else managed a record like that? 
 No other person, female or male, managed to do that well in the major tournaments of 1990. 
 So how dare anyone criticise a true champion who has proved herself over and over again. 
 She is to me and many others, the best tennis player in the world today, even if she is No 2 it won't be long before she is back on top where she belongs. 
 Keep up the good work of entertaining your fans on court Steffi; we know you can do it; your fans are behind you all the way. 
  (Steffi's No 1 fan) Donna Davidson N. Ireland  
 Tribute to Graf 
 I am writing to express my views about the Graf/Seles situation. 
 On the whole, your readers seemed very supportive of Steffi Graf but I would like to reply to one letter in particular, that in defence of Seles. 
 It asserted that Steffi Graf made excuses for her losses. 
 This is probably the most untrue statement I have heard in some time. 
 Steffi Graf never makes excuses, never &mdash; its her most famous trademark after her forehand! 
 It would appear otherwise, at times, due to wording of newspaper articles. 
 The press apparently had expected Steffi's invincible reign to last for several years &mdash; when last year Graf had a bad year (by her standards) the men and women of the press understandably searched for reasons for it &mdash; and voiced them. 
 They were mostly sympathising with her loss of form and her problems. 
 This is not to be confused with her own personal feelings. 
 Graf never blamed her upsets on family problems, flu, food poisoning, sinus trouble and a variety of other problems. 
 I challenge any reader to prove otherwise. 
 Steffi Graf is human. 
 I cannot believe so many people have attacked her for petty reasons, like here lack of smiling. 
 Many great players never smiled on court but were great people off the court &mdash; as Steffi is. 
 Monica Seles is an excellent player. 
 She has the best groundstrokes in the women's game and she is still only 17. 
 She has a great future ahead of her and will undoubtedly improve as here serve and volleys do. 
 I am a great fan of Monica Seles but I cannot believe all the letters about these two players. 
 The women's game is much more open today and Gabriela Sabatini has been the best player on the women's tour this year. 
 It has been a long time since the women's game has been so open; hopefully it will continue. 
  Shane McGlynn C. Galway  
 P.S. I am Gabby's biggest fan so I consider myself neutral on the Graf/Seles controversy. 
 In Defence of Steffi 
 In your June 91 issue of Tennis World, was a letter from a reader, unsigned, by a Seles fan, titled &bquo;In defence of Seles&equo;. 
 This made me and I bet a few more Steffi fans very angry indeed. 
 So for all you Seles fans, let's just get this sorted out once and for all. 
 Steffi Graf is the best woman player of all time. 
 Always will be. 
 Never mind what Chrissy or Martina have done, I wouldn't dare take that away from them. 
 But were they World No. 1 for nearly 4 years like Steffi? 
 Well I rest my case on that one. 
 To be No. 1 you have to be the best; fast pace on court, quick thinker, footwork spot on, lob the ball, serve well. 
 All these, Seles cannot do. 
 Yet at 17, Steffi could. 
 Seles admits she can't lob or serve very well to save her life. 
 Yet Monica said &mdash; (quote in a recent interview) &bquo;Nobody is scared to play Steffi anymore, because youngsters are coming through&equo;. 
 Well Miss Seles and the reader who wrote in defence of you, I would like to say this. 
 Steffi has lost at least four times this year to Sabatini. 
 I must admit the matches I have videoed from Sky were brilliant. 
 Gabby played brilliantly. 
 She's a different player now, goes to the net more and so on. 
 I would say that she is more dangerous  than Monica. 
 Anyway, Steffi has beaten Seles twice this year, very comfortably indeed &mdash; no messing. 
 So for Tennis World reader from Glamorgan, leave my Steffi alone; yes she's had problems, what with nasal problems, private ones and a bad 1990. 
 But Steffi fans will like to express their thanks and wish her well. 
 We don't make excuses for her, she's too tough for that, anyway if Seles watched Steffi a bit more she might just be able to learn how to lob a ball and hold a racket properly. 
 Because champions do! 
  One Angry Steffi Fan  
 (name and address not supplied) 
 P.S. I know Steffi reads Tennis World so please make sure this is published. 
 Graf Verdict &mdash; She is Popular! 
 Flicking through your magazine as one is apt to do, I was rather startled by &bquo;Tennis World reader, Glamorgan&equo; who inferred in his letter published in your June edition that you were biased. 
 He claimed that he was sick of this &bquo;Steffi is Great&equo; attitude and he accused you of showing favour towards Steffi. 
 I was surprised because you showed no  defence  to his letter. 
 So I decided to do some investigating of my own. 
 Lo and behold, in the same issue at T.W.R's moaning, I found 3 letters all in praise of Steffi. 
 Going back over previous months' editions, I found the following: 
 Readers' letters praising:  
 Whatever could this mean I wondered? 
 Are the editorial staff sitting around at empty desks saying &bquo;Tut! 
 I'm bored. 
 I know, I'll write some nice letters praising Steffi?&equo; 
 Or is there some Steffi-crazy fan out there inundating the Tennis World office with letters cunningly disguised in a variety of handwriting just to confuse us? 
 Or could it be that, by the merest possible chance, Steffi is in fact&hellip; 
 GASP!&hellip; 
 POPULAR!!! 
 A quick scan of the above mentioned issues shows that Tennis World can be vindicated from all blame. 
 Previous issues from November 1990 to the last edition show that the major features have been on Gabby and Steffi, Zvereva and Martina and Monica, Capriati and Monica, Anke, Jana Novotna and Arantxa respectively, evidence of a fair and even representation of all women players by Tennis World. 
 Dismissing the crazy fan with &bquo;I love Steffi&equo; emblazoned on a fluorescent t-shirt as an outside possibility, my conclusions on this phenomenon rested on one word. 
 This word is &bquo;Readers&equo;, which seems to indicate by my reckoning that 5 out of every 6 letters written on women players are sent to readers who are Steffi Graf fans. 
 So you see, it's the opinion of the majority (and including the crazy fan) that Steffi is great! 
 So there! 
 I suggest to T.W.R. from Glamorgan that if he is sick of hearing about Steffi, he should move to the moon. 
 I hear Steffi hasn't got media coverage there&hellip; yet! 
 A crazy fan who owns a rather fetching &bquo;I love Steffi&equo; fluorescent T-shirt. 
 (Name and address not supplied) 
 Schools not Neglected 
 I was interested to read the prize winning letter from Catherine Haslam in your last edition. 
 Her view that we should encourage schools to take up tennis is one that is very much at the heart of our philosophy. 
 It is, however, easy to say; much more difficult to put into practice. 
 Let me outline a few of the obstacles: 
 1 
 All major sports would like to be the centre of a school's curriculum. 
 It may be obvious to tennis nuts why tennis should be the chosen one, but to the objective outsider, other games have better claims to priority. 
 2 
 In many cases teachers have been indoctrinated with the view that it is not their job to encourage competitive sports. 
 3 
 Teachers without a coaching background feel insecure in attempting what they consider to be a difficult game to learn and so play safe with rounders or athletics. 
 4 
 School courts are crumbling and repair is a very low priority in a head teacher's budget. 
 There are many others. 
 But problems exist to be overcome and the British Schools LTA has made considerable progress in attempting to solve them. 
 There are tangible signs of this. 
 Membership, for example, has doubled in the last five years. 
 In 1990, over 5,000 school teams competed in the various Midland Bank sponsored national schools competitions and figures received so far suggest even more in 1991. 
 The development of a Tennis Teachers Course offers help to the non-coach teacher, and the inauguration of County Schools Tennis Associations (there are now 39) has enabled locally based courses to be set up. 
 We have prepared a wide-ranging study kit for GCSE, which will be available next term, and preparations are in hand for a scheme to construct solid links between schools and their local tennis club. 
 Perhaps most significant of all is the launch of the National Schools Coaching Programme. 
 This is being run as a pilot scheme in three counties this year, and will go nationwide as soon as a sponsor can be found. 
 A number of schools in each county are selected annually, partly by the County Schools Association and partly by the Local Education Authority. 
 They are given equipment and free visits by carefully selected coaches, who give a series of lessons in the school with the class teacher being gradually trained to take a more and more active part. 
 A starter pack of course material and a three-year development programme are part of the package. 
 With limited space, it is unavoidable that I can provide only a summary of the work of a very active Association, but I thought your readers would be interested to know that schools are not being neglected. 
  Jim Coates Executive Director The British Schools LTA  
 The conflicts within British tennis 
 As Wimbledon again approaches, the arguments about why British tennis is so poor still rage on, and are getting even more heated. 
 The June issue of Tennis World was no exception, with letters and articles giving both sides of the picture being published; the only problem is that, in their own way, they are probably both right. 
 The LTA are spending more and more money and whilst the rest of the world gets stronger, our players get lower in the rankings. 
 In fact it could be said that our position in the rankings is declining in direct proportion to the increase in the money spent. 
 The only people who can change the situation are the players themselves. 
 They always have some excuse, but Russia has far worse facilities than we have and how many players have they got in the top fifty; three men and three women? 
 One wonders how often our players play in tournaments for if one looks at the tennis results in the daily newspapers one seldom sees the letters G.B. behind the player's name, and if we do, seldom does it appear past the first round. 
 Perhaps the tennis circuit as we know it today does not suit the British temperament. 
 What about a feature on &bquo;Where are they now&equo; with comments on why they did not continue on the circuit. 
 It may give us some answers. 
 Many a player who had been highly thought of has disappeared from the tennis scene. 
 There were one or two comments made in the June issue which may give an insight to the British problem. 
 Firstly Olga Morozova makes a point about taking the ball early. 
 She finds our girls take the ball about 5 metres behind the baseline. 
 They do this because they are not as quick as the opposition and want to give themselves as much time as possible to play the ball, no matter that they also give the other player more time. 
 Our players are out not to lose, relying on others to make mistakes; very few of our players have winning shots. 
 The other was in the article by Alexandra McAdam Clark, in which she mentioned the number of courts available in France. 
 There are many courts available in England which are not used, schools, private and club. 
 Perhaps there are not enough players available to play on them; perhaps there is no one to unlock them except at peak periods; then there are courts taken out during the winter and one of the major reasons in this country is damage by vandals. 
 No doubt, if you went to France or America, public and club courts would be available from 7 o'clock in the morning until late evening. 
 Undoubtedly, the public interested in tennis has declined. 
 They would rather watch American football on television; at least we import success. 
 Let us hope that the choice of Manchester for the next Davis Cup tie will provide more interest than the last match against France. 
 This begs the question, what happened to the British Tennis Supporters Club? 
  R.S. Barber Dorset  
 Let's hear it for the fans 
 For years now there have been thousands of letters written about tennis players. 
 So for a change I thought someone should write in for the fans. 
 Has there ever been a tennis player that has written in to say &bquo;thank you&equo; to their fans who have stood by them through all their traumas and their losses, who have stood for hours in the rain or slept out in the streets to get a look at their idols? 
 Do they give them a second thought? 
 When they are so wrapped up in themselves and their problems, and, they are so hard done by? 
 Now the women want equal pay. 
 What is this? 
 Will they never be satisfied? 
 On the other hand  they are telling us we are not playing for the money but the love of the sport. 
 This was maybe true years ago, not now. 
 They are paid vast amounts of cash, to wear a little sticky label on their shirts; even getting a hair cut is big money. 
 When they are asked to sign a piece of paper they moan and groan, and get paranoid about people trying to peep at them in their luxury. 
 I saw one player push fans out of the way at the Australian Open this year. 
 Now I know not all players are like this. 
 Steffi Graf, for instance, signs more autographs than any player I have seen and does care for them. 
 She always mentions them in her winner's speech but maybe the players taking part should take a moment to think what makes it possible for them to perform, and maybe say &bquo;thank you&equo; for all the years of loyalty from these people, instead of getting away from them as fast as they can. 
 Maybe one will write in one day. 
 Who knows? 
 Anyway I hope Steffi Graf wins Wimbledon. 
 I think she has a genuine feeling for the fans and for all that's been written about her. 
 She is the most gifted player to ever grace the Centre Court and also best wishes to Chris Evert. 
 I hope she feels better soon. 
 She also cared in the last years of her career. 
  Name Illegible Shrewsbury  
 P.S. I love Tennis World 
 Role Model 
 There are many excellent players in women's tennis, but for me, Miss Sanchez-Vicario is the best. 
 As a young player I look for subtlety and skill, not big top spin shots all the time. 
 Miss Sanchez plays her game with such enthusiasm she is always so entertaining to watch. 
 She is a good role model for young players with her excellent attitude and obvious love of the game. 
  Ann Fitzpatrick Dublin   
 Coaching Commentary 
 Fitness &mdash; an option? 
 by Olga Morozova 
 Today, kids are watching TV, listening to headphones or playing with computers. 
 There is less movement. 
 They are losing the habit. 
 All the body is losing its structure. 
 If you're not using your mind, then finally you're stupid. 
 If you don't read, then eventually you will forget how to read. 
 It's the same with exercise. 
 If you can't exercise then you will lose all your ability to be a healthy person. 
 Our young British players are lacking in fitness, I think. 
 They are less fit than they need to be if they are to become international juniors. 
 I've just come back from France. 
 Youngsters from Yugoslavia, Hungary, Germany and France&hellip; they're huge, big guys because they were doing everything property from 5 years old. 
 Ours now have to catch up. 
 So all the players that I teach have to be very strong. 
 They will have to do a lot of physical fitness training. 
 The players will have to do this work. 
 When they do it, their life on the court becomes much easier. 
 Power-packs 
 Chang and Sanchez-Vicario are great athletes and so fit. 
 Chang is very strong. 
 He has a normal baseline game but he uses his head, and he uses his opportunities to attack every short ball. 
 It is very difficult to produce this type of game but I am asking my players to do it. 
 Sanchez-Vicario also, of course is equally tough and she attacks every ball so well. 
 She has very strong legs. 
 She can stay on court for 6 or 7 hours. 
 She was built strong. 
 She is a little short but she has these other advantages. 
 Her strength i s so important to her game. 
 All Players must have this strength if they are to succeed at the top level.  
 Insight &mdash; The World's Best Coaches on the Game's Greatest Players 
 CONNORS The Ultimate Survivor 
 Jimmy Connors has won many a tight match in his time. 
 Last month, at the age of 38, he won two more before bowing out to Michael Chang in the fifth set of their third round match. 
 What are the secrets of Connors' survival on the circuit? 
 Pancho Segura, one of Jimmy's earliest and longest serving coaches, reveals them to Lailee van Dillen. 
 First of all,&equo; asserts Pancho Segura, &bquo;Jimmy was number one in his mobility on the tennis court. 
 Jimmy could hit both the running shot and the ball on the rise better than anyone. 
 Beyond these two technical talents, it was Jimmy's desire and his innate feeling for the game that helped to achieve his greatness. 
 he never gave up on the court and was respected as a fantastic competitor. 
 &bquo;Winning close matches on a regular basis is a signal that you're watching a champion.&equo; 
 Jimmy Connors' career holds a record of one hundred and nine singles titles and over eight millions dollars won in prize money alone. 
 Connors was a finalist in six Wimbledon's, winning two in his two decade career. 
 &bquo;It was incredible the way Jimmy played at key points in his matches&equo;, recalls Segura. 
 &bquo;At those instances, he threw a hundred percent of effort into his game every time. 
 Although Jimmy did not have the height and size of a Stan Smith, who was a top player at the same time, I saw other strengths in Jimmy's game which I liked as I coached him. 
 Even though his game was not perfect, the look of his game was terrific. 
 Jimmy could have had a better serve. 
 It was his return of serve that was unbelievable. 
 He has great hands.&equo; 
 Mother 
 While Connors became a protege of Segura's at sixteen years old, Jimmy also had had the benefit of coming from a strong tennis family.  
 &bquo;Jimmy Connors inherited a lot to begin with,&equo; Pancho says. 
 &bquo;Jimmy's mother, Gloria, loved tennis. 
 She played the game very well herself. 
 Jimmy credits, rightly, much of his success to her.&equo; 
 Pancho has witnessed players he believed were thwarted in achieving their apogee on the tennis court. 
 Not all parents were as informative as Mrs Connors. 
 &bquo;Parents are okay to an extent in coaching a junior player's developing game. 
 The problem is, some won't let the whole personality of the child blossom. 
 There are juniors who won't even speak without nodding and asking the parents permission. 
 To become a winner, you want a player to have personality, character and private convictions. 
 If parents are too emotionally involved, it's not good. 
 A player should be a man or a woman, make decisions, think. 
 If you allow a player to broaden themselves, it helps. 
 A few players don't even know what is the capital of France when they're in Paris playing the French Open. 
 Yes, they go through school, but don't learn enough. 
 Suddenly, a domineering parent knows everything, also about tennis strategy. 
 How can they compare themselves to a former professional player who has played in front of ten or twenty thousand people?&equo; 
 Pancho is convinced that, &bquo;once the parents and the player have selected a coach, they should believe in him. 
 Permit the coach to handle the growing game. 
 If they want all the glory, it's trouble for the coach.&equo;  
 Destiny 
 In the case of Jimmy Connors, Segura acknowledges the Connors' clan helped Jimmy immensely. 
 &bquo;Jimmy was born to be a tennis player,&equo; Pancho says. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; he adds, &bquo;it was his destiny.&equo; 
 The tennis shots Segura esteemed in Connors related to balance on the court. 
 &bquo;Jimmy was able to shift his weight from left to right. 
 He moved diagonally on the tennis court like a ballet dancer might on the stage. 
 Connors hit a shot on the run, then recovered immediately. 
 He had mobility, balance, plus heart. 
 With his great hands, Jimmy returned the fast serve better than anyone in the history of the game. 
 Strategy 
 After the fundamentals, Segura was eager to focus on strategy with Jimmy. 
 &bquo;We expected players would serve to Jimmy's forehand&equo;, explains Segura &bquo;not his strong two fisted backhand. 
 To compensate, I told him to move to his left on the return of the serve. 
 Allow more time to play that forehand shot.&equo; 
 Time, even a fraction of it, possessed value in producing a better return. 
 More than coaching fundamentals, which Pancho Segura considers a different type of coach than himself, he was a coach for the championship performances. 
 &bquo;I taught Jimmy the sensation of where to expect the serve of an opponent, plus where to plan to return that shot. 
 I saw two shots ahead of the opponent's first shot. 
 Where could that particular player he was about to confront, volley the ball? 
 Where couldn't he volley because of his own weaknesses or patterns. 
 You need to play competitive tennis one shot ahead,&equo; says Pancho. 
 &bquo;Any coach can instruct you to hit the ball waist high. 
 If you want to be a great player, it takes extra effort.&equo; 
 Loyal 
 &bquo;Jimbo took enormous pride in his tennis game,&equo; Pancho says. 
 &bquo;He listened very carefully, believed what I said, and he was loyal to me.&equo; 
 Segura believes that players must have enough pride when they lose to find out why they lost. 
 Did they play the key 30&ndash;30 point correctly? 
 Was concentration lacking? 
 Were they hitting the ball in front in relation to the centre of the court? 
 Did they try to go for passing shots as they stood two feet behind the baseline? 
 So how should a player analyze the game? 
 &bquo;A player should force their opponent to earn the points,&equo; Segura says. 
 &bquo;Play offensively only when you are inside the service line. 
 Tennis is like chess. 
 Hit four or five balls, waiting for that short ball. 
 Then, be at the net. 
 How many points might you hit before then?&equo; 
 Segura asks. 
 &bquo;It could be two hundred shots, if necessary. 
 Hit the ball deep into the court. 
 Like Jimmy did. 
 Establish the reaction for the short ball. 
 Once Jimmy got that short ball, the opponent's ball was dead.&equo; 
 Probably the hardest task to master during match play is concentration. 
 &bquo;Michael Chang has a similar concentration to what Jimmy had. 
 Jimmy was intense under fire. 
 At four or five-all in games, other players lapse their concentration. 
 Quite a few champions lose ten or fifteen points in a row.&equo; 
 Pancho played on the pro circuit and repeatedly saw this trend over the decades. 
 &bquo;Tennis is a cycle of momentum,&equo; Segura says. 
 &bquo;You hit three fantastic shots, then six or seven bad ones in a row. 
 Seldom, do you see two players play well at the same time. 
 You must hustle and struggle on the court. 
 It's not always the stronger player, with the big serve who wins. 
 It's the player with purpose, whose return is going to be where he wants it. 
 The winner is alert as to what to expect next. 
 Generally, when you played Jimmy Connors you understood you were going to stay out on the court for four or five hours, at least.&equo; 
 Connors' best match as Segura recalls, was played against Rod Laver in Las Vegas. 
 &bquo;Jimmy won on competitive ability. 
 Nobody fought harder than Jimmy. 
 Borg was outstanding as a competitor, too. 
 Lendl and Chang have the same competitive attitudes.&equo; 
 Professional 
 The elements of success Connors owned were his pride, his desire to train, working hard on good tennis habits. 
 &bquo;If you stay out late, and think you're going to play the professional game of tennis forever, you're wrong,&equo; Pancho says. 
 &bquo;No one has all the shots to begin with. 
 Champions learn them. 
 That's a real professional, a player who plays all surfaces: grass, clay, hard courts. 
 The ingredient that champions have is that they practice what they need to learn.&equo; 
 If Segura could pick one gift of tennis talent to be born with, he'd choose mobility. 
 &bquo;The ability to move quickly on the court is a great asset. 
 Jimmy had it.&equo;  
 New Instruction Series 
 Practice &mdash; The Neglected Essential 
 by Alan Jones with Barry Wood 
 In this first in a series of extracts from the Tennis Workshop (Crowood Press), Alan Jones, with Barry Wood explain the often neglected area of practice once the lesson is over. 
 A very important factor in the teaching of tennis is the value of practice once the lesson is over. 
 Many players are guilty of having a lesson and almost expecting a magical remedy to their problems. 
 Over the years, most of the players I have taught at all levels have benefitted from sensible practice, that is, well-organised drilling. 
 You will discover, especially with the better players, that particular drills are valuable in ironing out their weaknesses. 
 The best way to go about proper practice is to find yourself a partner of similar standard, who is equally keen to improve, and spend hours sweating and toiling on the practice court. 
 There are many sensible ways for players of all levels to work on their game with a series of drills and exercises. 
 The great thing about drilling is that it can be fun, but remember not to spend too much time on one particular drill, since boredom can easily set in and have a disruptive influence. 
 Quality of practice, rather than quantity, is what really matters. 
 A maximum of 15 minutes on any one drill is therefore ideal, unless, of course, it is being played for points, in which case you should play to the end of that particular session. 
 Rallying 
 Let us start. 
 You are two players who have just started to develop your game, and the simplest of drills is learning to rally. 
 You should think in terms of setting yourselves goals. 
 If you are capable of directing the ball over the net ten times, then, realistically, you should set yourselves a target of twenty. 
 That is the first aim of learning to drill a twenty-stroke rally, chasing and returning the ball on one bounce each time. 
 If you find it difficult to keep a rally going within the confines of the court, chase the ball wherever it goes so that you become accustomed to the habit of pursuing the ball. 
 When the 20-stroke rally has been attained, increase the target to 30, then to 40 and so on, but keep it realistic. 
 Each time you go onto the court to play sets or points, you should first attempt a longer rally. 
 By the time you are achieving 50 and 100-shot rallies, you are at the stage where you can develop your play. 
 (At this time, I would strongly recommend trying to maintain a high quality of shot during the rally.) 
 Targets 
 As you progress, the next facet of rallying is to give yourselves higher-level objectives, which include seeking to hit the ball in a more confined area. 
 For example, you can put down hoops or ball cans in certain areas of the court and use them as targets. 
 The most common drill &mdash; and this is even practised by the better players who may be struggling with their groundstrokes &mdash; is to put targets within 60&ndash;90cm (2&ndash;3ft) of the baseline and inside tramline and think in terms of rallying while aiming at the targeted areas. 
 It is important here to stress that it is not just hitting to the target that is foremost, but at all times moving the feet to take the ball in one bounce. 
 It is also important to keep the rally going. 
 As your playing standard improves and you develop the feeling of the rally, the rally should cease when the ball is out of play (ie, when it has bounced twice, or outside the lines). 
 Obviously, you can try hitting down the lines or cross-court, but keep up the quality of the rallies by maintaining speed and weight of shot. 
 Make sure at all times the boredom does not creep in and that there is a feeling of concentration and application to the task. 
 Playing to a Length 
 As you begin to improve, you will become aware of the importance of being able to direct the ball deep, close to the baseline. 
 An excellent drill is to think in terms of rallying, with targets of 30, 50, 100 or whatever you think you are capable of doing &mdash; and making sure the ball lands between the service line and the baseline. 
 If the ball is short of the service line or over the baseline, then the rally ceases. 
 It is a great exercise to improve your ability to play to length. 
 I have seen some fine players who compete at a high level bring in another line, between the service line and the baseline. 
 They are aware of the need to improve their length so much that they put in the extra line so they are looking at a 1 or 1.5m (4 or 5ft) area. 
 So, you can experiment, adding an extra lane at each end. 
 It is of paramount importance to realise and appreciate the value of deep groundstrokes. 
 Playing to a consistent length is one of the basic requirements to perform to a high level. 
 As we are discussing groundstroke skills, I think it is important to stress that at the beginning, according to the shape of shot that you have &mdash; whether it be topspin, slice or flat &mdash; you can insist on slice only, topspin only, or on hitting your favoured shot. 
 This helps to improve your repertoire of shots and development and understanding of spin. 
 (The Tennis Workshop, Crowood Press, available through our book service, &pound;19.95)  
 Tournament report 
 SMALL TOWN &mdash; BIG HEART 
 Barry Wood reports from Beckenham 
 Something very interesting and very clever had been happening to the Direct Line Insurance tournament at Beckenham lately. 
 Some of the biggest names in tennis have descended, with Stefan Edberg, John McEnroe, Pat Cash, Pam Shriver, as well as two-time champion Ivan Lendl all being recent visitors. 
 The players' marquee has grown larger and more grand, with chandeliers installed this year. 
 The space-age has arrived too, in the shape of ultra-modern satellite TV coverage, and electronic net-cord judges. 
 And yet the changes have taken place without disturbing in the slightest the unique atmosphere that makes the event so special, a credit to the care, attention and financial assistance that Direct Line have devoted to making Beckenham one of the most pleasant stops on the tennis calendar. 
 It truly is a most remarkable week. 
 The field of players, and the facilities they enjoy, are far superior to some tournaments on the world tour offering much more prize money. 
 The atmosphere remains that of a small-town challenger event, relaxed, friendly and informal, the perfect place to escape to after the tension and crowds of the French Open. 
 Jokes pour forth from the PA system, and so do hits from the 50's and 60's. 
 It just isn't like that anywhere else. 
 The tournament has charm, and the evenings especially are a piece of old England, relaxed and comfortable. 
 As the shadows lengthen, the men can be seen standing around with a pint of beer in hand, while mothers keep watchful eyes on the kids and catch up on the latest gossip. 
 There is also a rare chance to watch some of the lesser known British players trying their luck against more famous visitors from overseas, or even challenging their more experienced compatriots. 
 And they can spring some surprises. 
 This year, for instance, Jonathan Haycock, defeated Jeremy Bates, and Sara Gomer was beaten by Virginia Humphreys-Davies in the 1st round. 
 The tournament though, in giving some of our hopefuls the opportunity to assess themselves against quality foreign opposition, delivers some harsh truths. 
 For even at the generally modest level of competition that Beckenham offers, the British are shown to be dismal failures. 
 One example is Shirli-Ann Siddall, who has drawn much praise recently. 
 Last year she won 7 national junior titles, and she won a &dollar;10,000 event at Bracknell in May. 
 But when she came up against Australia's Michelle Jaggard, a more experienced player but by no means a world-beater, she struggled even to get a game. 
 Perhaps the trauma of changing coaches, moving from the Bradnam methods to those at Bisham, have affected her. 
 Whatever the realities of Shirli-Ann's situation, the broader truth is that she is not alone. 
 A total of 39 British players started the week this year, and not a single one got past the 3rd round. 
 That demonstrates just how far behind we have slipped in world terms. 
 It is a little sad to see the innocent eagerness and enthusiasm from so many who have stars in their eyes and really believe they are quite good players. 
 It is soon replaced though, by tears or a brave smile after yet another setback, with family and friends offering support and comforting words of &bquo;Bad luck. 
 You played well.&equo; 
 As rain threatened throughout the week, but failed to actually materialise most of the time, there were fewer disruptions than usual, and another delightful aspect of Beckenham week was able to take place. 
 The mixed doubles is another throwback to a different age, with the men and women now spending most of their careers following separate paths around the world. 
 Grand Slams are virtually the only tournaments to offer the light-hearted social event, but it fits perfectly into the scheme of things at Beckenham. 
 Not surprisingly, some of the best matches of the week were those involving the top players. 
 Cash greatly impressed in defeating 25th ranked David Wheaton, and then by taking Lendl to 7&ndash;6 in the 3rd set in the final. 
 And Shriver's match against the two-time Wimbledon Junior Champion, Andrea Strnadova was also of a very high standard. 
 Strnadova went on to take the title by beating Australia's Rennae Stubbs in the final.  
 Lendl &mdash; winning warm-up 
 Strnadova success 
 Students Pass With Distinction 
 by Sue McCarthy 
 A few surprise upsets occurred during the Midland Bank/LTA Trust British Students Tennis Championships, held at a Bristol University at the end of June. 
 This tournament accepted the top 16 University players, top eight Polytechnic players and the top 4 College players from qualifying tournaments held at Easter. 
 There was an added incentive this year for the students as it was their last opportunity to catch the eye of Sue Rich, captain and selector of the British Team for the World Student Games which take place later this year. 
 Jeff Hunter, currently studying Latin and French at Oxford, and Edinburgh University's Heather Lockhart, emerged as the new singles champions. 
 Despite the absence of two players, Alex Niepel and Ross Matheson, a high standard of tennis was displayed in the windy conditions. 
 In the men's singles, Hunter proceeded to the final without conceding a set and ended wildcard entry. 
 Robert Antoun's good run to the semi-finals after Antoun had disposed of No. 6 seed Andrew Carswell. 
 Foreign students studying in Britain were eligible to compete here, and this year, Midland Bank's tournament attracted Frenchman Pierre Pourquery, currently studying at Exeter University. 
 He not only added a greater dimension through his excellent, exciting tennis, but also through his personality. 
 The flamboyant Frenchman from Bordeaux, who seemed particularly comfortable on a hard court, disposed of No. 2 seed and defending champion Neale Pashley in a close semi-final encounter. 
 Pourquery displayed a variety of touch shots and moved with great athleticism about the court, to defeat his net rushing opponent 6&ndash;4 6&ndash;7 6&ndash;2 and earn himself an intriguing place in the final against Hunter. 
 Unfortunately, the Heavens opened on finals day, ending the good weather and causing disruptions. 
 The men's final began in truly exciting style with an abundance of winning shots on both sides and looked to be a most promising match until play had to be suspended at 3&ndash;2. 
 After the resumption Hunter's sharp service returns, and chip and charge tactics proved effective against the &bquo;hit and miss&equo; style of the Frenchman, with Hunter claiming the title 6&ndash;3 6&ndash;3 with a winning forehand volley. 
 Seeds continued to be upset in the Ladies event and the quarter-finals proved to be the downfall of both the top seed and defending champion Isabelle Wild, and the No. 4 seed Alison Fleming &mdash; both girls who had recently completed their final examinations were beaten by Lockhart and Nina Topper respectively. 
 In the semi-finals Miss Lockhart, very much a hard hitting baseline player, went on to defeat No. 3 seed Lindsay Nimmo in a very close battle, while Nina Topper defeated Maggie Laughton 7&ndash;5 6&ndash;2. 
 The ladies final, somewhat overshadowed by the men's final, was resumed in the evening because of rain. 
 The Edinburgh student appeared too consistent and resilient for Miss Topper who seemed to be struggling with the slippery court, and she triumphed 3&ndash;6 6&ndash;1 6&ndash;3 an impressive achievement for a No. 7 seed. 
 Unfortunately, the ladies doubles final had to be cancelled, but the men's title was taken by Pashley and Carswell. 
 This tournament has filled an important gap in Higher Education tennis thanks to Midland Bank's financial support (which stretches from sponsoring schools tennis right through to the World circuit). 
 As well as the obvious competition this tournament offered, it reunited many former national junior players and was enjoyed by all.  
 Hunter &mdash; passed with distinction 
 Edberg Carries his Bat 
 Alastair McIver reports from Queen's Club 
 They don't play cricket in Sweden. 
 If they did, however, then Stefan Edberg, the world's leading tennis player, would surely be a candidate for opening batsman for the test team. 
 Edberg sees the ball so early, hits it so sweetly and executes his shots so effectively, that one suspects that he could easily defy any West Indian or Australian pace attack. 
 That he got into his stride so quickly at the pre-Wimbledon Queen's Club tournament was evidence of his timing ability, an ability that holds good for both sports. 
 Edberg moves gracefully and speedily over the grass in a way that would surely be the envy of a Torville and Dean. 
 At the Stella Artois Grass Court Championships, he showed once again, that give him grass, a &bquo;bat&equo;,  and he is surely the best striker of a ball in the world. 
 Unfortunately for the Frenchman, Arnold Boetsch, the Australians, Jason Stoltenberg and Pat Cash and the Americans Malivai Washington and David Wheaton, Edberg is not a cricketer and amply demonstrated his tennis talents by winning his first Stella title for the loss of just one set. 
 Edberg's performance was near perfection as the famous Queen's Club pavilion court has seen. 
 It didn't matter that there was an uncomfortable breeze throughout the week, an overcast and threatening sky and a lively court. 
 Edberg was in charge. 
 Tony Pickard, Great Britain's Davis Cup captain and coach to the Swede, predictably understated the performance of his charge when he said &bquo;Let's not get carried away. 
 He hasn't played a Becker yet&hellip;&equo; 
 In fact, the opportunity for Edberg to play (up to the final) one of the 7 other players entered with a top fifty ranking, was denied him when first, Lendl slumped to defeat against Grant Connell in three sets, then Chang and Jarryd lost to Wheaton, while, in the Swede's half of the draw, Rotsagno lost to John Fitzgerald and Woodbridge fell to the unseeded Pat Cash. 
 Edberg defeated Cash in a quality final which many, I suspect, would have preferred to see as the final itself. 
 The surprise package of the tournament was the 224th ranked qualifier, Mark Keil, another young American who defeated US Open Champion, Pete Sampras in straight sets. 
 Another American, Malivai Washington, overcame Keil's resistance in the third round and the stubborn efforts of Fitzgerald in the quarters before bowing out in just 73 minutes in the semi-final to Edberg. 
 That victory set the Swede up for a seemingly difficult task against the 6th seed Wheaton, who had beaten Edberg's former doubles partner Anders Jarryd, in the other semi-final, 6&ndash;3, 6&ndash;4. 
 Difficult, it was not to be, however. 
 Edberg stamped his world class authority on the match, dominating the 90 minute final and setting himself up for the defence of his Wimbledon title. 
 &bquo;This is the best I have played so close to Wimbledon,&equo; confirmed Edberg, and no one was disputing the fact. 
 His bank account benefitted by &pound;38,382, but the benefit to his confidence was surely of greater value.  
 Edberg True to form 
 Cash &bquo;would-be&equo; finalist 
 Mats Wilander &mdash; dumped out in the first round 
 Competition 
 VENTORIS &mdash; INTO THE FUTURE 
 WIN Head products in this easy to enter, free competition 
 Head and Tennis World have teamed up to bring you a competition to win tennis competition used by some of the world's top tennis players. 
 The lucky winners will receive a Ventoris wide bodied racquet, a pair of Ventora tennis shoes and a deluxe tennis thermo holdall, all from the Head 1991 tennis range. 
 The 1991 Head racquet range has been developed from Head's wide bodied racquet, Genesis. 
 The Ventoris features all of the technical systems which made the Genesis such a successful racquet. 
 The Head Nodal technology reduces shock to the arm helping to prevent injury, whilst the double power wedge strengthens the tip of the racquet, increasing power without losing control. 
 The Ventrola tennis shoe is designed for comfort and performance. 
 It supports and stabilizes the foot preventing rollover, whilst absorbing shock from impact. 
 All this specialist equipment needs protection in transit therefore Head have introduced a range of luggage for racquet sports, including holdalls and racquet bags. 
 The deluxe tennis thermo features two lightly padded racquet compartments and a water bottle in a separate pocket. 
 1st prize 
 Head are offering three fantastic first prizes, consisting of a Ventoris tennis racquet, a pair of Ventora tennis shoes and a Head deluxe tennis thermo bag. 
 2nd prize 
 The five second places will each receive a deluxe tennis thermo holdall. 
 Runners up 
 The next ten names out of the hat will each receive a Head t-shirt. 
 To win one of these terrific prizes answer the following three questions and send your answers on a postcard to:  
 1 
 Which of the following two Head players reached the finals of the Italian Open in May this year?  
 2 
 Which two features, first used on Genesis, are part of the winning Head technology incorporated in Ventoris? 
 a 
 tighter strings and new graphics 
 a 
 wooden frame and towel grip 
 c 
 Head Nodal and Head Double Power Wedge systems 
 3 
 In one set of a match, Mr Smith wins by 6&ndash;3. 
 His opponent, Mr Jones wins each of his three games off the first advantage from deuce. 
 Mr Smith wins each of his sex games losing only two points in each to Mr Jones. 
 How many points are played in the entire set?  
 Closing date for entries 29th August 
 Prizes cannot be exchanged for cash. 
 Head's Fair Lady court shoe is an alternative prize for female winners.  
 Off court 
 Tournaments 
 The Nomura Inter Company Tennis Challenge expands to three city event 
 A good response to last year's competition has caused the organisers to expand the 1991 Nomura Inter-Company Tennis Challenge into a three city event. 
 The 1990 winners, Credit Suisse First Boston (Men) and Bank of England (Ladies), both seeded one this year, are joined by new entrants, Sainsburys and Midland Bank, in what is proving to be an even keener contest than last year. 
 Of the 150 companies entered in this singles and doubles company tennis competition, twenty are from Edinburgh and Glasgow. 
 The event began in June, with a Scottish Regional Finals day to be held on September 14th at the Stirling University Indoor Centre, from which one Ladies' and one Men's team will be invited to the National Finals at the Vanderbilt Club, London, on October 5th. 
 In addition to winning the Nomura Challenge Trophies, the Men's and Ladies' champions will win a luxurious weekend break, with guest, at the exclusive Chewton Glen Hotel in the New Forest. 
 Runners-up will win a one night stay at the Chewton Glen or an equivalent Scottish hotel, with additional prizes of rackets, sportswear and accessories for all National finalists. 
 Sanctioned by the Lawn Tennis Association and the Scottish Lawn Tennis Association, the event, now in its second year, is sponsored by Nomura International, one of the world's leading investment banks. 
 Other teams competing in this year's event include Saatchi &amp; Saatchi, Barclays Bank, Prudential Corporation, British Airways, Abbey National, Mercury Communications, ICI and Nikki Securities. 
 Mr Keith Clarke, Executive Director of Nomura, said: &bquo;Now in our second year, we are very pleased to support this event. 
 The idea of mixing social and competitive tennis seems again to have attracted many of the UK's top companies.&equo; 
 For further information and copies of the draw, please contact Pal Hutchins Tennis &amp; Leisure on: 081 946 9374.  
 Coaching 
 Visual Tennis Video-new release 
 T John Yandell, one of America's top coaches, has produced a new 60 minutes teaching video for beginners and those wishing to improve their games. 
 It's called &bquo;Visual Tennis&equo; and offers the viewer a comprehensive approach to learning the game based on visualisation and mental imagery. 
 The video retails for just &pound;14.99 (plus &pound;1.50 p&amp;p) and is available through our video service elsewhere in this magazine. 
 Pros and Celebrities 
 Bueno heads information network 
 Tennis legend Maria Esther Bueno takes on a new challenge as Chairman of Tennis Interlink Limited, a new venture launched to create a unique, membership base, international network for tennis-related information and services. 
 Ms Bueno, who won 20 Grand Slam titles in an on-court career abruptly curtailed through injury in the late sixties, commented today: &bquo;Tennis Interlink is an exciting new concept which will enhance our sport at many levels. 
 I am delighted to be associated with such a far-reaching project that will act as a clearing house for many people's activities across the world through a service dedicated to the needs of an unrestricted membership. 
 Although she lives in Brazil, Ms Bueno remains active in tennis through regular personal appearances in several countries. 
 She has acted as a consultant to both the International Tennis Federation and the South American Tennis Confederation and was instrumental in helping to develop women's tennis throughout Latin America before taking on the role of spokesperson for Tennis Interlink. 
 &bquo;The game's growing popularity increases the need for easily accessible information and services,&equo; explains Ms Bueno. 
 &bquo;Established organisations are often stretched in satisfying these varied needs which Tennis Interlink can help resolve through its London based operation. 
 We will be expanding opportunities by promoting existing tennis resources around the world and improving communications between members so an extensive and thriving network is created.&equo; 
 Tennis Interlink is run on a day to day basis by Barbara Wancke, former ITS Director of Women's Tennis, and Isolda Montero, who serve as Managing Director and Company Secretary respectively. 
 The wealth of experience that these three individuals bring to the operation is extremely broad-based and, combined with further expertise available through an international team of consultants, members' requirements are resolved quickly and effectively. 
 For further details contact 081&ndash;947&ndash;1607. 
 Trade 
 Lacoste look ahead 
 The year was 1927. 
 It all started with a bet&hellip; 
 The stakes were a crocodile briefcase&hellip; 
 The winner was Rene Lacoste + two time winner of Wimbledon &mdash; &bquo;the crocodile&equo; &mdash; the sporting legend was born. 
 Five years later, he created the original cotton pique shirt embroidered with the famous crocodile. 
 Now, the shirt comes in a choice of 30 colours, and is made from 12 miles of pure cotton. 
 Today, the legend lives on throughout the supreme range of sports and leisurewear, available throughout the UK. 
 At this year's Wimbledon, Henri Leconte and Gut Forget gave us a sneak preview of the Autumn &bquo;Roland Garros&equo; ensemble &mdash; a matching tracksuit, short, shirt and jersey in dominant white with a green double stripe running through. 
 Clean and classic with a stylish twist. 
 From their current Spring/Summer range, tracksuits in fashionable shellsuit fabric for men and ladies are popular, worn with shorts and pleated skirts and new cotton/lycra leggings in coordinating colours. 
 The range is accompanied by the choice of accessories &mdash; towels, socks, hats, etc plus something to carry them inn &mdash; multi-size bags in tough, durable fabric, in black, blue, green, white and now in dashing red. 
 High tech ladies 
 Though the trend in tennis today is towards the high-tech, powerful, graphite rackets, often with larger heads, many women find them a little heavy and sometimes even a bit too large. 
 Now Slazenger, which has been linked with the sport for more than 100 years, has produced a new racket design with women, and teenagers in mind. 
 Slightly shorter in length, and with a 90sq in headsize rather than the 95 and 105 which are currently the norm, the Challenge 26 is also lighter and specially balanced to suit female and junior players. 
 It features a highly aerodynamic wide-body graphite frame for easy manoeuvrability and greater power and includes Slazenger's Optimum Mass System at the 3 and 9 o'clock positions on the frame to extend the &bquo;sweet spot&equo; and so improve playability and ball control. 
 Available at most good sports shops, the Challenge 26 retails at around &pound;45.00.  
 Styled to win 
 The first Slazenger clothing collection designed by Coats Viyella is action packed &mdash; both in terms of styling and colour. 
 There is a very clear, clean cut approach to the whole collection with the accent on strong graphics and sports oriented motifs to create renewed interest in the &bquo;contemporary classic&equo; shapes of the shirts, shorts, tops, sweaters, track suits, joggers and shell suits which make up the whole range. 
 The colour combinations are very fresh and new: cornflower blue, guava and lime;; azure, emerald and purple; and navy, mid blue and gold which complement the &bquo;core&equo; shades of white, black, grey and ecru. 
 Racquet sports, and tennis, in particular, are catered for extensively with sporty prints, including a series of graphic figures in action. 
 For the extremely serious tennis player there is even a tennis ball print on a short which teams with a short and a skirt featuring a matching embroidered ball. 
 As well as the traditional cotton pique polo style shirt (which comes in 10 colours), there are cap sleeve blouses for the women; and alongside the classic short, there are culottes, wide box pleated and wrap over skirts. 
 The range also includes good quality fleece jogging suits, shell suits in both matt and shiny fabrics, with attention to details such as zipped pockets, and zips on the legs. 
 All shell suits are cotton lined, except from the knee down where the nylon replaces the cotton for ease when slipping over shoes. 
 On the right track 
 Track suits &mdash; as distinct from shell suits &mdash; will come into their own again from spring '92, according to leading suppliers Slazenger Sportswear. 
 The demand for shell suits in shiny crinkle and trilobal fabrics is waning and there will certainly be less of these versions around by next spring as far as the more fashion conscious wearer is concerned. 
 Designs in French terry jersey and heavy pique with textured finishes will become the best sellers for the sportswear trade in 1992, predicts Slazenger Sportswear. 
 The ubiquitous shellsuit will, however, retain its popularity as a leisure garment, although buyers will be opting for designs in fabrics with a softer handle, such as that achieved by special finishes such as acid, stone or garment washing, which can be applied to both woven and knitted cloths. 
 While bold designs will be in demand, sportswear styles will become more casual and tonal in terms of silhouette and colouration, to tempt customers. 
 Extra small to extra large 
 By popular demand, Mizuno Sports have produced several of their ladies and youngsters shoe ranges in smaller sizes. 
 The award winning Cross Court range now features a Girls Ultra Lo TP and Girls Ultra Cross &frac34; TP in size 1&frac12;, 2 and 2&frac12; &mdash; priced at &pound;37.60 and &pound;33.84 respectively. 
 In trainers, a new Controller Boys is available in sizes 1&frac12; and 2&frac12; priced &pound;40.89. 
 Uni-k-Swiss 
 K-Swiss have launched a ladies version of their Si-18 top of the range tennis shoe. 
 A new colourway for men &mdash; white/burgundy/navy &mdash; has also been introduced. 
 The ladies shoe, like its male counterpart, is specifically designed for the serious club tennis player. 
 All the Si-18 range models feature the exclusive K-Swiss cushion board construction which provides a polyurethane cradle of Silicone Formula 18 shock pad along the midsole. 
 This absorbs shock form impact with the ground, enhancing comfort and helping to prevent injury. 
 The Aosta rubber outsole on the Si-18 is hardwearing and durable. 
 Special flex bars along the ball of the foot allow ease of movement, and abrasive traction zones have been strategically placed to ensure maximum grip. 
 The full grain leather upper moulds to the foot for a good fit, whilst resisting wear and tear. 
 During a tennis match, the movements of the foot can gradually loosen laces. 
 K-Swiss use their five strip lacing system for constant lateral support, combined with a D-ring cinch system to hold the laces firmly in place and so stabilise the foot. 
 The family of Si-18 shoes also features a removable, washable sockliner for extra cushioning and protection. 
 The padded ankle collar and tongue provide an overall comfortable fit. 
 Sponsorship 
 Coca-Cola sign up until 1995 
 The Coca-Cola Company, manufacturer of the world's most popular soft drink, has renewed its backing for the three most important team events in tennis &mdash; the Davis Cup by NEC, the Federation Cup by NEC and the NEC World Youth Cup. 
 The new arrangements for Coca-Cola to be the official soft drink at all three events will cover the years 1993, 1994 and 1995. 
 Coca-Cola has been associated with the Davis Cup since 1982, and with the Federation Cup and World Youth Cup since the mid-1980s. 
 Mike Davies, General Manager of the International Tennis Federation, said: &bquo;There are not many events in the world that can claim to have continuous sponsorship for 14 years as will be the case of Coca-Cola. 
 It is a reflection on the ITF competitions, the television exposure, the prestige of these events, and also on the Marketing Department's commitment to excellence in servicing the needs of our sponsors. 
 We are very proud of our long-term association with Coca-Cola.&equo; 
 A record 86 nations entered the 1991 Davis Cup by NEC. 
 The Federation Cup by NEC, which is to be played in Nottingham, England, from July 21 to 28, has attracted entries from 56 countries, while the NEC World Youth Cup will be contested by 32 national teams at the new Olympic Stadium in Barcelona in September. 
 Sweet Caroline 
 Inter is a name synonymous with functional, practical footwear for the leisure sports market. 
 Their present tennis range is led by Caroline, a lightweight, durable shoe for the casual lady player. 
 The upper is made of leather with a perforated vamp. 
 To support the foot during play there is a lateral support strap which also ensures that the shoe has a close fit. 
 Caroline has a full length EVA midsole to absorb shock during the game. 
 Further cushioning is provided by the padded insole and tongue. 
 It is important to support the heel and for this Inter have constructed Caroline with a stiff leather heel counter. 
 The hardwearing rubber outsole has been designed for hard court play. 
 The protected toe area is designed to reduce wear from toe drag. 
 Caroline is available from branches of Olivers and Freeman Hardy Willis, nationwide. 
 Wilson Hammer competition winners 
 The prize of five Wilson Hammer rackets to be won in the April issue of Tennis World understandably produced a large, imaginative entry. 
 The answers to the questions were:  
 The five lucky winners were:   
  Veterans  tennis 
 British successes in Perth 
 The small party of British players competing in the Veteran's World Championships in Perth at the end of April achieved greater successes overall than in previous years. 
 The Ladies 60 age group brought home the highest honours: both Rita Lauder (Hampshire &amp; Isle of Wight) &mdash; and Ruth Illingworth (Essex) reached the singles'' semi-finals, each losing to top-ranked American players, while Ruth, in a new partnership with Ann Williams (Somerset), beat the numbers 1 and 2 seeded pairs to take the title at their first attempt. 
 Rita was on target to capture the singles title when a recurring leg injury regrettably ended her bid. 
 Don Shears (Avon) moved up to the 55 age group where, seeded number 4 following his unbeaten run in the Dubler Cup, he reached the semi-final to give the ultimate runner-up, Gordon Davis (USA) a tough fight after battling through three exhausting rounds. 
 Then, partnered by Brian Storr (Staffordshire), he went through to the doubles final, to be outdone again by Davis and his partner Ahlers, both from the USA. 
 A new combination of Mike Hayes (Herts) and Derek Howorth (Surrey) defeated the Men's 45 top seeds John Cooper, brother of former Wimbledon champion Ashley, and partners from Australia to proceed also to the semi-final where they lost in straight sets to the new champions, Burns and Weaver, also from Australia. 
 Tony Starling partnered A Swetka of the USA to reach the semi-final of the Men's 70 doubles. 
 In the consolation events, Brigitte Newbury won the Ladies' 50 singles, while Harri Gibbon was runner-up in the Men's 70 singles.   
 Junior Tennis World 
 Brothers Triumph at Doncaster 
 The fifth event on this year's Reebok Grand Prix Circuit at Doncaster turned into a personal triumph for the Ingham family from Heywood, Lancs. 
 Michael, the second of three tennis playing brothers, took the 21 and under title with a powerful 6&ndash;3 6&ndash;3 victory over Graham Hobbs (Dorset): whilst younger brother Craig, fought back from one set down against James Lake (Lincs) to win the 12 and under title 4&ndash;6 6&ndash;2 6&ndash;1. 
 Beating the Ingham family monopoly was Michael Calvert (Yorks) who won the 16's title 7&ndash;6 4&ndash;6 7&ndash;5 against a tiring Richard Stamp (Lincs). 
 In the girls' event, Catherine Wittenberg (Kent), consolidated her position as leader of the Reebok 12 and under Grand Prix table by reaching the final, but missed out on maximum points when she lost to Claire Sewell (York) 6&ndash;4 6&ndash;1. 
 The 16's final was an all Derby affair, in which Tina Crosen defeated Helen Frankland 6&ndash;2 6&ndash;3, whilst the 21 and under title went to Lizzie Jelfs (Oxon) who outfought one of our top student players, Maggie Loughton (Yorks) 7&ndash;6 4&ndash;6 7&ndash;5 with an excellent performance. 
 Tennis World INSTRUCTION 
 HITTING WITH TWO HANDS 
 There are probably three good reasons for playing a stroke with two hands on the racket: 
 1 
 You are just learning and have a very weak wrist. 
 2 
 You are a natural athlete, the stroke feels right to you and you find you can achieve far greater power this way. 
 3 
 You are a natural athlete and find you can disguise your shots easily this way. 
 Notice the emphasis on natural athleticism. 
 This is because, played correctly, the stroke is a demanding one and is not for everybody to use. 
 If you think the stroke is for you, the keys to success are: 
 1 
 Keep both hands close together on the grip throughout the stroke. 
 2 
 Twist your upper body fully through the stroke. 
 Using the arms alone is simply not enough as the swing is now restricted by the additional hand. 
 3. 
 Work on your speed around the court as your reach is restricted by two hands. 
 4 
 Work on your ability to handle low, short balls, together with those struck directly at you, as these can be a problem. 
 You may even find it simpler to revert to a one handed shot on these occasions. 
 Finally, copy good exponents of the shot. 
 It is not easy to find fault with Jimmy Connors' version of the backhand, is it? 
 Reproduced from Tennis by Jeremy Woods (Crowood Press) available from Tennis World Book Service    
 Two handed play 
 Junior set by Lotto 
 The Chemistry is Right 
 The Joanne Ward story by Alastair McIver 
 I spoke with Joanne on the eve of her chemistry GCSE. 
 She wasn't looking forward to it, which is a little surprising for a 16 year old who, just 3 years ago, combined all the elements of her talent to produce the compound which exploded her on to the junior tennis scene! 
 This was no experiment, however. 
 Athletic and committed, Joanne, who once stood on the fringes of junior county badminton, now has a goal to realise. 
 Discovered at one of the LTA's 3 Star Clubs at King George's Comprehensive school, by the father of local professional coach Harvey Slater (who now coaches the youngster), Joanne, who is about to leave school for a year of full time playing, is one of the few British juniors who has the ability to &bquo;kick&equo; and break from the pack. 
 Joanne doesn't come from a wealthy background and yet, by hard work and determination and not a little goodwill from Slater himself (who coaches her free of charge), she is making things happen in her tennis life. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't do it if she wasn't committed&equo; explains Slater. 
 &bquo;I coach her for up to 15 hours per week, usually early in the mornings, before breakfast, and lunchtimes. 
 She's so keen&hellip; so committed.&equo; 
 So how does she compare with her contemporaries? 
 Slater has no doubts. 
 &bquo;She has &bquo;a million miles&equo; better commitment&equo; he says forcefully. 
 &bquo;Other juniors aren't on the same planet as Joanne, when it comes to commitment. 
 She is more like a European or an American youngster.&equo; 
 Perhaps one of the best examples of that, could be found at a recent tournament, where, after suffering considerable pain during a match, she declined the soothing comforts of an ice pack in the clubhouse. 
 Instead, she chose to visit the bleak northeast coastline, where she used the restoring &mdash; but freezing &mdash; waters of the sea to ease her pain! 
 It's all part of the drive that she believes, will take her to the top of her forthcoming profession and to that end, she is not prepared to put a time limit on her arrival. 
 &bquo;I want to be the best&equo; she explains proudly, &bquo;it doesn't matter how long it takes.&equo; 
 Having come so far in just 3 years, the suggestion is that success might come sooner rather than later. 
 That is not to say, of course, that it won't take longer for her to fulfil her potential. 
 A win over British No. 17, Katie Ricket in a ratings tournament at Alfreton in May, confirmed her rapid progress. 
 That victory followed on from success in the Dewhurst International in March, where she came through from being a reserve qualifier to reach the semi-finals. 
 Between the Dewhurst and the Ratings tournament, Joanne won the 16 and under Seat finals. 
 &bquo;She is strong and athletic&equo; says Slater &bquo;and she has a big serve. 
 She can volley, too, which means she is developing into a fine all-court player.&equo; 
 Her exceptional strength and movement are a result of regular fitness work with renowned expert Len Heppel. 
 It was his support which perhaps influenced both Wilson rackets and View From clothing to sponsor her. 
 Joanne's commitment to the next 12 months will leave her little time for the hobbies that she enjoyed before tennis came along. 
 She doesn't play badminton anymore. 
 &bquo;I like swimming,&equo; she confirmed &bquo;which is obviously good for my fitness. 
 I don't like football. 
 My dad took me to watch Newcastle when I was about 10 but I couldn't see because of all the people standing in front of me. 
 My biggest comment on football is that I don't like Sunderland&hellip; or Gazza (Gascoigne). 
 I don't like it when he sings!&equo; 
 Who does, I ask myself? 
 Does she have a favourite singer? 
 &bquo;Prince&equo;. 
 And television? 
 &bquo;Roseanne.&equo; 
 And food? 
 &bquo;Salads.&equo; 
 When it came to revealing her personal likes and dislikes, Joanne was not a girl of many words. 
 One had the feeling that she was happy enough just to let her racket do her talking for her&hellip;  
 Geordie Joanne 
 Joanne with her coach Harvey Slater 
 Tournament report 
 Character Victories 
 Seles and Courier star on the Paris stage 
 by Peter Blackman  Evening Standard 
 When Jim Courier and Andre Agassi roomed together at Nick Bolletieri's tennis academy in Florida, one of them just had to leave the door ajar. 
 First it looked as though Agassi would bolt through as he reached for stardom; then Courier did it. 
 Winning the French Open took him through the door, down the passage, into the street and out into the sunshine Fame. 
 At 20 years old he is a Grand Slam winner and he achieved it against Agassi in a slugging final that in the end had the 17.000 crowd at Roland Garros on their feet. 
 The match was in Paris, but chic it wasn't. 
 This is Courier: a red haired lad from Dade City, Florida. 
 He once called it Hicksville, a small town in which his father works in the orange juice factory. 
 In contrast, Agassi is from Las Vegas, the booming gambling town in the desert. 
 We all know about Agassi and his paintshop clothes, his tinted hair and gold around his neck. 
 Last year Andres Gomez beat him the final; this time it was Courier and everyone remembers things about him. 
 He used to play baseball and he wears a white baseball cap that one day may become as famous as Pat Cash's chequered headbands. 
 He smiles a lot, talks to himself and  uses a tennis court like an officer patrolling it, owning it and thumping around it as if he hasn't a care in the world. 
 But in his 3&ndash;6 6&ndash;4 2&ndash;6 6&ndash;1 6&ndash;4 victory, one had to admit that Courier has character and a burning conviction that he can beat anyone. 
 And no one doubts that he has earned his place among the sport's leading players. 
 When the French began he was ninth in the world. 
 When it was over he was fourth. 
 This was poor old Agassi's third defeat in his third consecutive Grand Slam Final. 
 Yet he should not weep too long because old stone face himself, Ivan Lendl, made five attempts to land a major title. 
 Once he started he could not stop! 
 That could now apply to Monica Seles. 
 The 17 year old Yugoslav retained her French Open title and her world No 1 ranking. 
 To do that she worked through a minefield for two weeks, finally beating the tiny Spanish girl Arantxa Sanchez-Vicario 6&ndash;3 6&ndash;4. 
 Having won the Australian Open and now the French it means that Seles is on a Grand Slam roll, though she swiftly pointed out that Wimbledon's grass might be her downfall. 
 But was she trying to confuse the plot by saying: &bquo;I know that it is impossible for me to win four Grand Slam tournaments this year.&equo; 
 Some burning sun, black clouds, rain and wind were the backdrop to another highly agreeable fortnight in Paris at just about the perfect time of year. 
 But tennis players don't seem to know where they are or what the weather is like. 
 Memories? 
 The men first. 
 John McEnroe's limp first round exit to the Russian Andrei Cherkasov; Ivanisevic's tepid performance that brought deserved defeat against Paul Haarhuis. 
 Then US Open champion Pete Sampras fell at the same hurdle to Thierry Champion. 
 But it was the 38 year old veteran, Jimmy Connors, who made the blood come to the boil. 
 First he downed Todd Witsken, then Ronald Agenor. 
 And then he withdrew after four sets against the former champion Michael Chang. 
 It was a glimpse of the old Connors, fighting and refusing to walk down memory lane. 
 It was superb theatre; Meanwhile, the star turns danced on. 
 Wimbledon champion Edberg lasted until Courier beat him in the quarter finals. 
 Michael Stich romped past Franco Davin at the same stage before falling to Courier who was now well into his war dance. 
 The other end of the draw saw Agassi topple the surprise packet Jakob Hlasek and Boris Becker beat Chang. 
 Then Agassi moved past Becker, the three times Wimbledon champion. 
 That win made Agassi's pulse race, but in the end Courier was his master. 
 Seles was tremendous value for her win. 
 The Brits &mdash; Jo Durie, Sarah Loosemore, Monique Javer, Sara Gomer, Clare Wood and Sam Smith &mdash; predictably vanished after the first round. 
 It was a disastrous collective slump that left British Tennis supremo Richard Lewis scratching his head. 
 Zina Garrison, the beaten Wimbledon finalist last summer, lost in the first round, but not much of consequence occurred until Sanchez-Vicario toppled Mary Joe Fernandez in the quarter finals &mdash; and then came the heavy matches. 
 Seles had no trouble beating Conchita Martinez and Gabriela Sabatini, who was let off the hook in the quarters by Jana Novotna. 
 Steffi Graf sailed through until Sanchez-Vicario whipped the rug from under her feet in the last four. 
 So Seles triumphed alongside Courier. 
 Two young athletes winning on the big stage and managing to enjoy every minute of the experience. 
 No one can deny that professional tennis is going through one of those periods when a sure thing in the betting sense is a short cut to bankruptcy.  
 Big Jim does it 
 Monica &mdash; half way to Grand Slam 
 Sanchez-Vicario &mdash; crushed Graf 
 Connors &mdash; pumped up 
 Agassi &mdash; question marks 
 Tennis World INSTRUCTION 
 SUPPLENESS 
 Suppleness or flexibility is vital to the tennis player who needs the ability to move the various parts of his body through a full range of movements, often at full stretch. 
 Injury is more likely when a joint has become stiff either with age or disuse. 
 Often people realise this almost unconsciously, and immediately on walking onto the court, commence a vigorous bouncing/stretching routine. 
 This is WRONG! 
 All stretches should be gradual and held for a period of 30 seconds before release. 
 The small, bouncing stretch routine is likely to introduce minute tears in muscle fibres and so should be avoided. 
 Also, remember to stretch when you come off court as well. 
 This will reduce soreness and ease the risk of a restiffening up of the joints. 
 Also, remember to stretch when you come off court as well. 
 This will reduce soreness and ease the risk of a re-stiffening up of the joints. 
 1 
 Be aware of your own strengths and weaknesses and maximise your strengths. 
 2 
 Actively seek to minimise your weaknesses and maximise your strengths. 
 3 
 Use the warm-up time to analyse your opponent's strengths and weaknesses. 
 4 
 Be prepared to take time out between competitions in order to work on improving your game. 
 5 
 Practise regularly. 
 Reproduced from Tennis by Jeremy Woods (Crowood Press) available from Tennis World Book Service  
 BALANCE 
 Good balance is the effective control over your centre of gravity, relative to the direction in which you are delivering the ball. 
 If your balance is correct, dramatic passing shots hit on the run become possible, followed by quick recovery while still in a balanced position. 
 It begins with the ready position. 
 Knees should be flexed comfortably, the racquet pointing towards your opponent, weight on the balls of the feet, and the body bent slightly forwards at the waist. 
 You should feel your centre of gravity to be located down through the hips. 
 In the same way, when running for a shot, try to keep your centre of gravity under control. 
 Run in an upright (or, at most, a slightly leaning) position, so that your balance point stays in the hips. 
 Many players make the mistake of leaning from the waist, which limits the stroke you can make, and puts too much strain on your upper body and lower back muscles. 
 Instead, take an extra step nearer the ball if necessary and get down low by using the legs and knees rather than the waist. 
 Reproduced from Tennis by Jeremy Woods (Crowood Press) available from Tennis World Book Service 
 INTRODUCTION &mdash; TRAINING AIMS 
 Training for strength 
 Some individuals are naturally stronger than others. 
 Many people make the mistake of thinking that they can train for speed, strength, size and endurance all at the same time. 
 But this is not possible because it is necessary to approach each of these aspects differently to get the required results. 
 Training for strength involves low repetition work with very heavy weights. 
 The number of repetitions should not exceed 6; even this is high for true strength training. 
 An example of the combination of weight and repetitions would be to use 80% of your maximum lift for 5 reps, followed by 90% of your maximum lift for 3 reps. 
 Whenever all the reps are completed with some strength still in reserve, then the weight should be increased, never the reps. 
 Pyramid training 
 Another method of repetition training for strength is to use the pyramid system. 
 Start with 5 reps at 75% of your maximum lift, then increase the weight but decrease the reps to 4. 
 Do this until 1 lift is performed at 90&ndash;95% of your maximum and then decrease the weight but increase the reps until you are back to 5 reps at 75% again. 
 With this system (see table below) 29 reps will be performed, but it is the way they are split up that promotes the development of greater strength. 
 This type of training is very demanding and rest and food intake are most important. 
 At least 1 or 2 rest days will be required between training sessions. 
 Also, you will need to be particularly careful with your diet if you are not to suffer from fatigue. 
 The amount of protein and carbohydrate in the diet will determine how much repair and development can take place, and also how much energy is available to train with. 
 Training for size 
 Weight training can produce very different results, depending on the type of routine followed. 
 Even if the majority of exercises employed are basically the same, the results will vary according to whether you work hard for short periods or do easier work for a longer stretch. 
 When training for size the number of reps per set ranges between 8 and 12. 
 Any less than 8, while developing some strength, would not stimulate muscle growth, and any more than 12 would lead to increased muscular definition but no growth in size. 
 Everybody responds differently to weight training and you must experiment to find the number of reps between 8 and 12 which will promote maximum growth best. 
 You may discover that some muscle groups respond best to 8 reps whereas others, such as the calves or the forearms, respond best to 12 reps. 
 If you find that you are making no gains in size  whatsoever, do not be tempted to do more exercises or repetitions because this could lead to overtraining. 
 Instead, try cutting down on the number of exercises, increasing the weight and making sure that you perform 3 sets of at least 8 reps. 
 Muscles only actually grow after they have recovered from a hard training session. 
 The physical act of training breaks down part of the muscle exercised, and it is during the next 24&ndash;72 hours that the muscles recover and begin to grow. 
 Your food intake is of prime importance during the rest and recovery stage. 
 It is no use stimulating muscle growth if your protein intake is insufficient. 
 There is no quick and easy way to build muscles, but once you obtain the correct balance between training, rest and recovery, and diet, then your muscles certainly will grow. 
 Training for speed 
 Muscles are made up of fibres which have different mechanical properties, and two of the main groups of fibres are called fast twitch fibres and slow twitch fibres. 
 The fast twitch fibres have a much higher contraction speed and are associated with dynamic bursts of energy. 
 The slow twitch fibres react much more slowly and are more resistant to fatigue, producing greater endurance. 
 Thus it is clear that you need to work on the fast twitch muscles if you want to improve your speed. 
 The ratio of fast twitch to slow twitch fibres varies between individuals and is determined by heredity. 
 However, by applying the correct type of training it is possible to make the maximum use of the twitch fibres present. 
 Training for speed must work repeatedly on the fast twitch fibres on a stop &mdash; go basis. 
 In the gym the weights must be light and movements explosive; for example you could see how many repetitions you can perform in 10 seconds and then try to beat that amount. 
 Other forms of training might include sprint-stop running or speed skipping. 
 Training for speed is very taxing and hence you will need to gear your work towards a particular event. 
 Training after a main event should be much less dynamic and should concentrate on improving technique in preparation for the next competition. 
 BASIC EQUIPMENT 
 Most people incorrectly believe that you must belong to a gym which is equipped with ail the latest equipment in order to make any significant progress in weight training. 
 This is not so. 
 While it is convenient to have lots of equipment at your disposal, it is by no means essential. 
 Excellent gains can be made with the minimum amount of equipment if you are determined. 
 Three basic pieces of equipment will enable you to perform an enormous variety of exercises to improve your physique or figure. 
 These are the dumb bell/barbell kit, the adjustable bench and the abdominal board. 
 Dumb-bell/barbell kit 
 Free weights were used long before machines were invented for weight training, and virtually every exercise can be executed using them. 
 Dumb-bell/barbell kits are inexpensive to buy, and as you become stronger the poundage of the kit can be increased by  purchasing additional discs. 
 This way the size of the kit increases gradually with no large cash outlay. 
 Adjustable bench 
 Many exercises are performed either sitting or lying across a flat bench. 
 When you also have the option of adjusting the angle of the bench the range of exercises is greatly increased, and it is then possible to develop different parts of muscles much more easily. 
 An example of this is the basic flat bench press; by performing the bench press with the bench inclined at an angle of 30&deg;s;, the emphasis of the exercise is placed on the upper pectorals. 
 This would result in muscular development up to the clavicles for a man, preventing a &bquo;droopy&equo; looking chest, while for a woman it would cause a build-up of tissue leading into her cleavage, thus emphasising her bust. 
 If the bench press is done on a decline, the emphasis is placed on the lower pectorals, giving men a strong outline to the lower chest, and women a muscular development which creates the impression of a larger bust. 
 Abdominal board 
 Most people need to work their midsections regularly, and having a proper abdominal board encourages this. 
 Sit-ups, crunches, leg raises and knee tucks are all possible on this simple piece of equipment, and as the stomach muscles become stronger the angle of incline is increased so as to bring gravity into play. 
 Side leg exercises can be done to work the outer thigh area, and a wide variety of scissor-type exercises can be done for the hips and lower stomach areas, (More advanced stomach exercises can be carried out using weights if desired.) 
 The board can also be used for incline/decline work with barbells and dumb-bells, and does not have to be regarded only as a piece of equipment for exercising the stomach. 
 It can now be seen that these pieces of equipment constitute a basic gym around which routines for both beginners and advanced trainers can be structured. 
 Whether your aims are physique development or figure improvement, the vast majority of the exercises you will need to do can be carried out with these very basic pieces of equipment.  
 Fig. 1 Dumb-bells and barbell 
 Abdominal board 
 DIET 
 The amount of calories a person needs each day is determined by the type of work they do, the exercise they take and their metabolic rate. 
 It is very simple to work out the amount of calories needed each day. 
 For 7 days count the calories in every piece of food you eat and every drink you consume. 
 Add these amounts together and then divide the total by 7. 
 This will give you your average daily calorie intake. 
 If your weight remains constant you must be using up all your calories, but if you are gaining weight then some of the calories you consume are being stored as fat. 
 If you are losing weight, then you are not consuming sufficient calories daily. 
 Once you know your daily calorie intake it is easy to adjust it so that you gain or lose weight. 
 When exercise is concentrated on specific areas it will help to tone up the muscles faster and so tighten the skin, giving the impression of increased weight loss in the desired areas. 
 It is the distribution of a person's body-weight that is most important. 
 Since muscle is heavier than fat but not as bulky, a small increase in muscle size compensates for a larger amount of fat loss, resulting in a considerable change in shape but no change in body-weight. 
 Protein 
 Training breaks down muscle tissue and during rest periods the tissue is repaired and growth takes place if sufficient protein is available. 
 So how much protein do you need? 
 The most widely accepted figure is 0.6g (0.02oz) per pound of body-weight. 
 Thus a person weighing 154lb (70kg) would need 154 x 0.6 = 92.4g (3.23oz) per day. 
 This amount would maintain the person's health and keep his weight steady; to promote growth an extra 10&ndash;15g 0.35&ndash;0.5oz) per day would be necessary. 
 Excessive protein intake can be dangerous, putting stress on the kidneys and causing dehydration. 
 The protein content of food varies considerably, and the following are average values for some of the better sources. 
 (Remember that these values will depend upon the size of the egg, the type of milk, the cut of the steak and so on.) 
 Egg (1) 6g (0.2oz) Milk (pint) 12g (0.4oz) Cheese (28g or 1oz) 6g (0.2oz) Chicken (28g or 1oz) 7g (0.24oz) Fish (28g or 1oz) 5g (0.17oz) Steak (28g or 1oz) 5g (0.17oz) 
 It is perfectly possible to obtain all the protein you need from a balanced daily diet. 
 However, the protein must be eaten in amounts not exceeding 20&ndash;25g (0.7&ndash;0.88oz) at a time because the body is unable to digest more than this and any extra will just pass through the body. 
 This is why people who want to build muscle have 4 or 5 smaller meals throughout the day. 
 Since this is not suitable for everyone, protein drinks are a convenient alternative, 
 CARBOHYDRATES 
 There are two types of carbohydrates; simple and complex. 
 The basic difference is that simple carbohydrates are refined complex carbohydrates, so that if you remove the nutrients from the  complex carbohydrates you end up with simple ones. 
 Hence complex carbohydrates are better for bodybuilders and athletes. 
 Complex carbohydrates are found in cereals, fruit and vegetables, while simple carbohydrates are found in white bread, white flour and any food containing white sugar. 
 Sugar is positively detrimental to bodybuilding due to the fact that it causes a rise in insulin levels. 
 Intensive training routines cause the release of growth hormone from the pituitary gland, but insulin can block the release of this hormone and thereby nullify the effects of training. 
 The source of energy for a muscle contraction is Adenosine Triphosphate (A.T.P.) and this occurs in very small amounts in human muscle. 
 Therefore, it needs to be rapidly regenerated if exercise is to continue, and this regeneration is brought about by a substance called Creatine Phosphate (C.P.). 
 The splitting of the A.T.P. and C.P. molecules is the prime source of muscular energy. 
 These processes are anaerobic (without oxygen) and no lactic acid is formed in the muscles. 
 The length of time for these processes to occur is very short (up to 6 seconds). 
 After this the energy is supplied by the breakdown of muscle glycogen into lactic acid. 
 Glycogen is produced from complex carbohydrate, and therefore the energy required for training is ultimately derived from the complex carbohydrates you eat. 
 It is possible to break down fat to use as energy when you are training, but it is essentially glycogen which is the energy source. 
 In order to ensure that enough glycogen is present for training, carbohydrates should make up approximately half of your daily diet. 
 It is also advisable to take a vitamin B supplement to aid in the digestion of the carbohydrate. 
 Once the carbohydrate has been consumed it is stored as glycogen in the muscles and stays there until it is required for energy. 
 This storage of glycogen in the muscles adds to the overall size of the muscles. 
 Once training is underway the glycogen is gradually removed from the muscles to produce energy and is replaced by blood, that is the muscles are &bquo;pumped&equo;. 
 After training has finished the blood supply is reduced and the &bquo;pump&equo; disappears, resulting in the muscle being smaller than before the exercise started. 
 A fresh source of glycogen is then needed to restore the muscles to their original size and to encourage growth of the muscle tissue. 
 Therefore, complex carbohydrates are initially more important after a work-out than protein. 
 Complex carbohydrates are best taken regularly throughout the day so that the glycogen is steadily replaced and built up in the muscles. 
 Lack of complex carbohydrates in the daily diet is very often the cause of sportspeople feeling under par. 
 Iron 
 Iron has a crucial role to play in the efficient working of the human body and is vital to healthy living. 
 The main function of iron is to form the red pigment in the blood called haemoglobin. 
 (Up to 80% of the iron in the body is used daily in this way, with approximately 20% being stored mainly in the liver and the bone marrow.) 
 When not enough iron is available the amount of haemoglobin in the blood is reduced, leading to a decrease in the amount of oxygen which can be transported from the  lungs to the tissues. 
 The effects of this decrease in oxygen transportation are tiredness, lack of stamina, a pale complexion and the inside of the eyelid becoming colourless. 
 if the iron deficiency is not remedied the organs of the body may be affected, and when all of these factors are combined the results can be severe, with the person suffering from headaches, insomnia, dizziness, loss of appetite, shortness of breath and reduced resistance to infection. 
 A well balanced diet will provide enough iron for the average person, but sportspeople may need to supplement their diet with 15&ndash;20g (0.5-O.7oz) of iron per day. 
 You should not exceed this amount because iron can be toxic in certain individuals. 
 One of the best forms of supplement is haemoglobin iron which is derived from beef blood and is completely natural (virtually 100% of it is used by the body compared to very low utilisation by the body of synthetic iron-ferrous salts). 
 Haemoglobin iron can be taken on its own or with desiccated liver. 
 Eggs and ordinary liver are the best sources of iron in food. 
 Desiccated liver 
 This is perhaps one of the most widely used and cheapest of supplements in bodybuilding. 
 It is produced from raw beef liver, and once in its dried form is one of the most concentrated forms of food available. 
 It has all the goodness of liver but with virtually all the moisture, fibre and fat taken out. 
 Desiccated liver is approximately 80% protein and is easily broken down and absorbed by the stomach. 
 It contains all the essential amino acids and all the known B vitamins, but perhaps its most important constituent is haemoglobin iron. 
 If you are only going to take one form of supplement then desiccated liver should be your choice. 
 Basic vitamins &mdash; vitamin B complex and vitamin C 
 When the majority of athletes begin to take vitamin supplements the most basic mistake they make is to take too many without considering which is going to help them most. 
 The type of vitamin taken should depend on the general state of health of the individual and the type of diet he follows. 
 Vitamin B 
 The &bquo;B&equo; vitamins are a very complex group, with each individual &bquo;B&equo; vitamin contributing to a different aspect of fitness. 
 However, a general consideration of the &bquo;B&equo; group is of great importance to both the serious and the casual trainer. 
 The vitamin B complex enables the body to make full use of the food consumed. 
 Part of the group helps in the use of carbohydrate for energy and growth (B1 thiamin), while vitamin B6 (pyridoxine) helps in using protein and fats and also in removing water from the body tissues (diuretic). 
 Niacin aids blood circulation, which means that protein is carried to the muscles more efficiently, and also helps muscle recovery by carrying waste products away more quickly. 
 Pantothenic acid is important in the digestion of protein. 
 Choline and inositol help to break down fat. 
 Vitamin B12 helps to produce red blood cells which carry oxygen, and therefore prevents anaemia and tiredness. 
 Vitamin B15 (pangamic acid) helps  the muscles to retain oxygen, thus combatting fatigue. 
 The &bquo;B&equo; complex can be obtained by taking desiccated liver and yeast tablets, or by taking a special &bquo;B&equo; complex capsule. 
 The result is better utilisation of the food being eaten, accompanied by a feeling of well-being and more drive during training. 
 Vitamin C 
 The body cannot store vitamin C so it is essential to have a fresh supply every day. 
 Since vitamin C is water soluble any excess is excreted and so you don't have to worry about taking too much. 
 Vitamin C helps to combat stress either from worry or from intense physical exercise. 
 Therefore the amount taken needs to be related to the type of job a person has and also the type of training he undertakes. 
 Athletes in combat sports should take large amounts of vitamin C to help combat bruising and soreness. 
 Marathon runners need large amounts to help combat the stresses experienced in the ankles, the knees and the hips. 
 Bodybuilders can obtain relief from vitamin C for the aches and pains they suffer in the shoulders and elbows. 
 Vitamin C is readily available in citrus fruits and green peppers. 
 Alternatively, it can be taken in tablet or capsule form. 
 If the latter option is taken, it is better to spread the intake throughout the day so as to continually top up the body's supply. 
 The recommended amount to take varies, but usually ranges between 1&ndash;6g (0.03&ndash;0.2oz) per day. 
 A person will soon know if he has exceeded his body's tolerance because excess vitamin C produces the &bquo;runs&equo;. 
 FITNESS DETERMINATION ROUTINE 
 This routine is designed to increase a person's pulse rate, and then to monitor its decrease over a set period of time. 
 The rate of decrease of the pulse after vigorous exercise is a good indication of the overall fitness of an individual. 
 The routine should not be attempted by anyone with a heart condition or high blood pressure. 
 if you have any doubts about your present health, you must consult your doctor beforehand. 
 The only equipment you need is a watch or a clock with a second hand or second display. 
 The 3 easiest places to take your pulse are the wrist, the side of the neck and the temples. 
 To take your pulse all you need to do is to count it for 10 seconds and then multiply by 6. 
 This will give your pulse rate per minute. 
 At the start of the routine, when you are in a relaxed state, you take your pulse and note the reading (reading 1). 
  At the end of the very last exercise you immediately take your pulse again and note the reading (reading 2). 
 You then wait, standing still for 1 minute, and take a final pulse reading (reading 3). 
 Subtract the third reading from the second, which will generally give you a value between 0 and 50, This is the value which indicates your fitness. 
 0&ndash;10 poor 10&ndash;20 fair 20&ndash;30 average 30&ndash;40 good 40&ndash;50 very good 50+ excellent 
 Your pulse rate will continue to decrease until it reverts to the first reading. 
 The time taken to revert to the relaxed state is directly related to the fitness of the body. 
 Each exercise only lasts 15 seconds, and in that time you must complete as many repetitions as possible. 
 You then have 15 seconds' rest, during which time you must stand still. 
 As soon as the 15 seconds' rest has elapsed, you must start the next exercise. 
 The total time of the exercises from start to finish is 3 minutes 45 seconds. 
 The exercises are detailed below; it is advisable to practise each exercise individually before attempting the whole routine. 
 Touch toes 
 Start off by standing upright with the arms above your head. 
 Bend from the waist, with your arms still straight, and touch your toes. 
 Return to the start position and repeat. 
 Press-ups 
 Lie face down on the floor with your feet together and your hands shoulder width apart. 
 Keeping the body rigid, press with the hands until the arms are straight. 
 Lower your body to the floor but do not touch it, and repeat. 
 (Anyone having difficulties may leave the hips and legs rest on the floor until strength increases.) 
 Running on the spot 
 The knees must come up as fast as possible to waist height. 
 Sit-ups 
 Lie on your back with your knees bent. 
 Put your hands over your ears and sit up until your elbows touch your knees. 
 Return to the lying position and repeat. 
 (You may hook your toes under a chair if you like, but do not link your fingers behind your head as this puts strain on your neck.) 
 Knees up to chest 
 Stand upright and do high jumps, bringing both knees up to the chest at the same time. 
 Do not crouch to the floor. 
 Squat thrusts 
 Start from a crouched position with your hands touching the floor at either side of your feet. 
 Kick your legs back approximately 0.6m (2ft), supporting your body with straight arms. 
 As soon as your feet touch the floor behind you, spring back to the starting position and repeat. 
 High jumps 
 Start from a crouched position and jump as high into the air as possible with your arms above your head. 
 Repeat.  
 Star jumps 
 Stand upright with your arms by your sides. 
 jump to a position with your legs apart and your arms in a &bquo;ten to two&equo; position. 
 Return to the start and repeat. 
 ADVANCED USE OF THE FITNESS DETERMINATION ROUTINE (FDR) 
 By now you should be completely familiar with the original FDR, and you will already have experienced its benefits. 
 It might already have occurred to you that the routine can be varied to produce different benefits. 
 The object of advanced use of the FDR is to make you aware of its potential. 
 The first and most obvious change is to increase the duration of each exercise, but keeping the rest periods constant, that is 30 seconds' exercise followed by 1 5 seconds' rest. 
 This relatively small increase causes much more work for the heart and lungs, and will result in greater cardio-vascular fitness. 
 Once this increase becomes easier, change to 45 seconds' exercise followed by 15 seconds' rest. 
 Again the results will be dramatic. 
 It should be stressed that these increases should not be attempted unless you are finding the original routine fairly easy. 
 A second possible change is to swap one exercise for another, for example sit-ups for crunches. 
 Once a routine becomes boring it is soon forgotten and its benefits are lost. 
 if you feel the exercises are not hard enough for you, substitute more difficult ones. 
 When doing this, try to keep a balance between upper and lower body exercises. 
 For people who are training for a particular sport such as karate, specific exercises can be inserted in the routine, for example alternate mae-geri or squat/standup/mae-geri. 
 The variations are virtually endless and are only limited by the imagination of the individual. 
 A third change, and probably the most physically demanding, is to introduce weights into the routine. 
 The routine then becomes very specific and is no longer a general fitness method of training. 
 With weights, the routine can be used to greatly increase the muscular endurance of the legs and the stomach muscles. 
 The use of weights coupled with longer exercise periods is very demanding and is only intended for serious athletes. 
 The Fitness Determination Routine must be used to enhance your existing training, not to compete with it. 
 Therefore, if you are in a building-up period as far as weight training is concerned, you should keep the FDR work at a low rate. 
 That way you will not burn off too many calories which might prevent you from increasing muscle size. 
 Conversely, if you are building up to a competition and wish to greatly increase your fitness and endurance, the FDR should be very intense and should make up a large part of your training. 
 This also applies to bodybuilders who need to reduce body fat. 
 The harder and faster they work. 
 the more calories they will burn up and the leaner they will become. 
 Finally, it must be stressed that increases or changes in the rate of work should only be carried out once a person has attained a high standard of physical fitness. 
 If you have not used the FDR regularly over the past six months, do not change it.  
 BASIC EXERCISES (1) 
 The following section deals with the basic exercises you will use during the first 6 months. 
 These exercises will be used on your first 3 routines, and will be incorporated in stages so as to make your training progressive and more demanding. 
 It is necessary to follow the routines exactly to obtain the best results. 
 Style is very important, and it is important to execute the movement slowly and strictly. 
 Refer to the available photographs when reading the exercise description, and practise them on their own first before attempting a whole session. 
 Remember that a full set of weights is not essential for the routines. 
 House bricks can be used instead of dumb-bells and a plank on bricks can be used instead of a bench. 
 Similarly, a wooden bar with a box on either end will serve as a barbell and this can easily be weighted by filling the boxes with soil or sand. 
 Sit-ups 
 (see p.9) 
 Twists 
 Standing upright, hold a stick horizontally at the back of your neck. 
 Twist your body to the left as far as possible, and then round to the right as far as possible. 
 This counts as one movement. 
 Keep your feet and hips still and keep facing forwards. 
 Hold your stomach in during the twists. 
 Knee raise 
 Lie on your back with your hands over your ears and your legs out straight. 
 Raise your left knee as far as possible, and raise your right elbow to meet it, Return to the flat position then raise your right knee as far as possible, and raise your left elbow to meet it. 
 This counts as one movement. 
 Bench press 
 Lie flat on the bench. 
 Grip the bar with the hands shoulder width apart and the arms straight up. 
 Lower the bar slowly to the top of the chest, touching the chest lightly with the bar and pressing until the arms are straight. 
 Do not let the weight drop to the chest and never &bquo;bounce&equo; the bar off the chest. 
 This exercise is best done with a partner to assist. 
 An alternative exercise is wide press-ups with the hands on house bricks (these will allow a greater stretch). 
 Dumb-bell flyes 
 Lie flat on the bench with the dumb-bells held out above your chest. 
 Bend the elbows slightly. 
 Slowly lower the elbows apart until a full stretch is obtained. 
 Pull evenly back to the vertical position, concentrating on the chest muscles all the time. 
 Pull-over 
 Lie across the bench with the dumb-bell overhead and the elbows slightly bent. 
 Slowly lower the dumb-bell as far behind the head as possible, keeping the hips down. 
 Inhale as you stretch. 
 Pull the dumb-bell slowly back to the overhead position, then breathe out. 
 Side-lateral raise 
 Stand upright with the dumb-bells by your sides. 
 Slowly raise your arms out to the sides until they are horizontal. 
 Lower them again slowly.  
 Dumb-bell shoulder press 
 Stand upright with the arms bent and the dumb-bells at shoulder height. 
 Slowly press vertically until the arms are straight. 
 Lower them slowly to shoulder height. 
 Do not twist the dumb-bells during the press. 
 Bent-over lateral raise 
 Bend from the waist until the torso is horizontal, and the arms are hanging straight below. 
 Slowly raise the arms apart until they are horizontal (keep the elbows slightly bent). 
 Lower them slowly to the start position. 
 Squats 
 Stand upright with the feet approximately 46cm (18in) apart and pointing out slightly. 
 Hold the bar across your shoulders at the back of the neck. 
 Bend the knees until the thighs are parallel to the floor, keeping the head up. 
 Do not bend forwards. 
 Push slowly to the upright position. 
 The knees should be pointing at the same angle as the toes. 
 This exercise is best done with a partner For safety and assistance if necessary. 
 An alternative exercise is the  one-legged squat. 
 Stand upright on one leg, keeping the other leg straight out in front. 
 Bend your supporting leg until the thigh is parallel to the floor and then push until the leg is straight again. 
 The other leg must remain straight out all the time, and must not touch the floor. 
 Complete all reps on one leg and then change over. 
 You may hold the wall to help your balance. 
 Dumb-bell shoulder press &mdash; slowly press the dumb-bells vertically until the arms are straight 
 Calf raise 
 The starting position is the same as for the squat. 
 Raise up slowly on to your toes, as high as possible, keeping your body upright. 
 Do not lean forwards. 
 Lower yourself slowly. 
 You may place a 5cm (2in) thick block of wood under the balls of your feet to make the exercise harder. 
 Lunges 
 Hold the bar across the shoulders behind the head. 
 Stand with your right leg about 60cm (2ft) in front of your left one, and slowly lower your body forwards until your right thigh is parallel to the floor. 
 Keep your back straight and vertical. 
 Your left leg should be bent and should nearly touch the floor. 
 Slowly push upwards with your right leg until it is almost straight. 
 Repeat all movements on 1 leg without straightening it. 
 Change to the left leg and repeat.  
 Squats &mdash; bend the knees until the thighs are parallel to the floor 
 Upright rowing 
 Stand upright holding the barbell in front of you, with your arms straight down. 
 palms facing the body and hands approximately 15cm (6in) apart. 
 Slowly pull the barbell upwards, keeping it close to the stomach and chest until it is just underneath the chin and the elbows are pointing upwards. 
 Lower slowly to the start position. 
 Do not bend the back and do not sway. 
 Bent-over rowing 
 Bend from the waist until the torso is horizontal, the arms are hanging out straight below, and you holding the barbell with hands shoulder width apart. 
 Slowly pull up the bar until it touches the chest, and then slowly lower it to arm's length. 
 Stretching and contraction should be felt in the back, but do not rock or jerk. 
 Hyperextensions 
 Lie face down on the floor with your hands touching in the small of the back and your legs straight out and together. 
 Slowly arch the back and lift the chest and head upwards and back. 
 At the same time raise the feet off the floor as  far as possible. 
 Hold this position for 2 seconds, then slowly lower them to the floor. 
 Upright rowing &mdash; slowly pull the barbell upwards until just underneath the chin 
 Bent-over rowing &mdash; slowly pull up the bar until it touches the chest 
 Triceps extension 
 Stand upright with the left hand on the hip. 
 The right hand should hold the dumb-bell straight overhead. 
 Slowly lower the dumb-bell to the back of the head, keeping the upper arm vertical. 
 Press slowly to the vertical position. 
 Triceps kickback 
 Bend from the waist until the torso is horizontal. 
 Hold the dumb-bell in the right hand. 
 Keep the upper arm horizontal, with the forearm and dumb-bell hanging straight down. 
 Slowly straighten the arm by lifting the dumbbell backwards, keeping the upper arm still. 
 The palm of the hand should now be facing the floor. 
 Slowly lower the forearm to the starting position. 
 The left arm can either hold the wall or a knee to assist balance.  
 Triceps extension &mdash; slowly lower the dumb-bell to the back of the head and then press to the vertical position 
 Dumb-bell curls 
 Stand upright, with your arms holding the dumb-bells by your sides and your palms facing inwards. 
 Slowly curl the dumb-bells upwards to shoulder height, twisting them gradually during the full movement until the palms are facing you. 
 Slowly lower the dumb-bells to the start position. 
 Do not arch the back during the exercise, and do not swing the dumb-bells. 
 Barbell curl 
 Stand upright with the arms straight down, holding the barbell with the hands shoulder width apart and the palms facing outwards. 
 Slowly curl the barbell to shoulder height, and then lower it slowly to the starting position. 
 Do not lean backwards or jerk the barbell upwards as this will put great strain on the lower back area and detract from the development of the biceps.  
 Dumb-bell curls &mdash; curl the dumb-bells upwards to shoulder height 
 Wrist curl 
 Sit on the end of a bench, holding the barbell with hands 15cm (6in) apart. 
 Bend forwards and rest your forearms on the bench with your hands hanging over the edge. 
 Slowly let your fingers unfurl and let the barbell roll down to your fingertips. 
 Now slowly curl your fingers upwards, gripping the barbell, and curl your wrists as high as possible without lifting your forearms off the bench. 
 Repeat the exercise. 
 This exercise must be done slowly and carefully so as not to let the barbell drop from your fingertips. 
 BASIC EXERCISES (2) 
 This section deals with the basic exercises that will be incorporated into the more advanced training routines outlined later. 
 They are designed to work the various muscle groups from slightly different angles, and will enable you to vary your routines according to your requirements. 
 Once again the importance of style needs to be stressed, given that the poundage you lift does not matter as much as the way in which you lift it. 
 Crunches 
 Lie on your back, with your hands over your ears, your knees bent and your ankles crossed. 
 Slowly &bquo;crunch&equo; your head and knees together and then lower your head back on to the floor. 
 The knees should only move slightly &mdash; it is the head and upper body movement towards the knees which produces the best results.  
 Barbell curl &mdash; slowly curl the barbell to shoulder height, then lower it to the starting position 
 Leg raises 
 Lie flat with your legs completely off the bench. 
 Keeping the legs straight, raise them until they are almost vertical and then lower them until they are almost touching the floor. 
 Keep your lower back flat against the bench to prevent any strain. 
 This exercise can be done lying flat on the floor, but using a bench stretches the lower abdomen more. 
 Flat dumb-bell press 
 Lie flat on the bench with your arms out straight holding the dumb-bells and your palms facing your feet. 
 Make sure that the dumb-bell bars are lower than the top of your chest. 
 Slowly press out until your arms are straightened again and your palms are facing down as before. 
 Incline dumb-bell flyes 
 Set the bench at an angle of 30&ndash;45&deg;s;. 
 Lie on the bench with arms out straight, almost vertical, and hold the dumb-bells with palms facing each other. 
 Slowly lower the arms, still keeping them slightly bent at the elbows until the dumb-bells are level with the chest. 
 Slowly raise until vertical, breathing  out. 
 This exercise develops the upper chest and the front deltoid. 
 Front dumb-bell raise &mdash; alternately raise each arm outwards in front until horizontal and then slowly lower 
 Front dumb-bell raise 
 Stand upright with the dumb-bells on the front of the thighs and the palms facing the thighs. 
 Alternately raise each arm outwards in front of you until horizontal and then slowly lower, keeping the arms straight at all times. 
 The emphasis here is on developing the front deltoid &mdash; excellent for martial artists. 
 Barbell press 
 Stand upright, holding the bar at shoulder height in front of your chest with your palms facing outwards. 
 Slowly press upwards until your arms are straight overhead, then lower gradually to the top of the chest again. 
 Do not arch the back and do not jerk. 
 Dead lift 
 Squat down with your feet just over shoulder width apart. 
 Hold the bar with an alternate grip, that is one palm facing outwards and one facing inwards. 
 The back must be straight or slightly arched, never rounded. 
 Gradually straighten the legs until you are standing upright, then lower slowly to the floor without jerking. 
 It is advisable to wear a weight-training belt for this exercise because of the strain on the lower back. 
 Do not use this exercise if you have lower back problems.  
 Barbell press &mdash; press upwards until the arms are straight overhead 
 Seated calf raise 
 Sit on the edge of the bench, with the balls of the feet on a 15cm (6in) block of wood. 
 Place the barbell across your knees, holding it in place with your hands. 
 Slowly lower your heels to the floor, gaining full stretch. 
 Next, raise the heels until they are as high as possible without moving the balls of the feet. 
 Hold the contraction for 2 seconds, then lower again. 
 One-arm dumb-bell rowing 
 Place one knee and one hand on the bench for balance. 
 Bend over, holding the heavy dumb-bell below the bench. 
 Slowly raise the dumb-bell vertically as high as possible without jerking or rocking, keeping it close to the body. 
 The elbow should be high. 
 Complete the set on one arm and then change sides.  
 One-arm dumb-bell rowing &mdash; slowly raise the dumb-bell without jerking or rocking, keeping it close to the body 
 Seated calf raise &mdash; raise the heels as high as possible without moving the balls of the feet 
 Stiff-legged dead lift 
 Stand upright, holding the barbell in front of your thighs. 
 Slowly bend from the waist, lowering the bar towards the floor and keeping the legs straight. 
 Lower as far as possible without bending the legs and then gradually stand up straight again. 
 This exercise must be done slowly with no jerking movements. 
 It exercises the lower back and stretches the hamstrings. 
 Triceps dips 
 This exercise can be executed using 2 benches or 2 chairs. 
 Hold on to the edge of 1 bench with your hands behind your back. 
 Put your heels on the other bench with your legs out straight. 
 Slowly bend your arms, lowering the upper body towards the floor and keeping the legs straight until the elbows form right angles, then slowly straighten up. 
 The exercise can be made more difficult by placing a weight across the thighs.  
 Triceps dips &mdash; lower the upper body until the elbows form right angles 
 Close grip bench press 
 Lie flat on the bench, holding the barbell with your hands 15&ndash;23cm (6&ndash;9in) apart. 
 Slowly lower and touch your chest with the bar. 
 Then press upwards until the arms are locked straight out and the triceps are fully contracted. 
 Close hand press-ups also have the same effect. 
 Swing-bell curls 
 A 46cm (18in) centre-loaded bar is used in this exercise. 
 Sit on the edge of the bench with your knees apart. 
 Bend over, holding the ends of the bar at arm's length. 
 Slowly curl until the weights touch your chest, staying bent over the weight all the time. 
 Concentration curls 
 Sit on the edge of the bench with your knees apart. 
 Bend over, holding the dumb-bell at arm's length between your knees, with the back of your elbow pressing against the inside of the thigh. 
 Slowly curl until the dumb-bell touches your shoulder. 
 Do not jerk or swing. 
 Complete a set on 1 arm and then change arms.  
 Close grip bench press &mdash; slowly lower and touch your chest with the bar, then press upwards until the arms are locked straight out 
 Concentration curls &mdash; slowly curl until the dumb-bell touches the shoulder 
 TRAINING ROUTINES 
 The following 6 routines are designed to last 8 weeks each and they become progressively harder. 
 Do not be tempted to start a harder routine at the beginning as this will almost certainly detract from the potential gains. 
 Each training session should begin with 5 minutes' stretching, 5 minutes' skipping and a 15-second circuit of the fitness determination routine (see page 8). 
 This warm-up period will take less than 15 minutes to complete, but will increase cardio-vascular fitness and ensure that the muscles are ready for action. 
 Remember, the majority of muscle strains and pulls are the result of insufficient warming up. 
 All of the routines are designed for complete body training 3 times a week. 
 Always have a day's rest between training; growth only takes place after the muscles have fully recovered from the previous training session, generally after 48 hours. 
 Sets and repetitions 
 Routine 1 1st session 1 set of 10 repetitions for each exercise 
 2nd session 2 sets of 10 repetitions for each exercise 
 3rd session 3 sets of 10 repetitions for each exercise 
 This gradual build-up of reps over the first 3 sessions will reduce the amount of stiffness and soreness experienced in the muscles at the start of the programme. 
 Thereafter 3 sets of 10 repetitions should be used for most exercises in all routines. 
 The exceptions to this include the abdominals, the calves and the forearms. 
 You can increase the abdominal repetitions to any number you like as long as 3 sets are performed. 
 Repetitions for calves and forearms can be increased to sets of 15 because they are composed of denser, more resilient muscle fibres and the need to be worked harder. 
 The weights used should be increased once 3 sets of 10 repetitions have been achieved so as to make the weight training progressive.  
 The routine sheets should be filled in each week or whenever the weight is increased. 
 After a few sessions you will know which weights to use, but you should make sure that the routine is kept up to date. 
 It is good psychologically to look back and see just how much you have improved both in terms of strength and physique. 
 This should provide you with the incentive to train harder and achieve even more. 
 LEG TRAINING 
 All too often leg training is neglected, resulting in a lack of balance between the legs and the upper body. 
 However, the problem is more predominant in men; women tend to spend around two thirds of their training time working on their legs and glutei (buttocks). 
 Well-equipped gyms will have a large selection of leg machines designed to isolate the various muscle groups. 
 But there will never be an exercise as good as squats for working all of the muscles together. 
 Correct squatting works the quadriceps, the leg biceps, the calves and the glutei and also gives the heart and lungs a good work-out. 
 Squatting is an anabolic exercise in that it promotes growth in all other muscle groups as well as specialising on the legs, 
 The front of the thigh is composed of four muscles which are collectively known as the quadriceps. 
 These are responsible for straightening, lifting and rotating the leg. 
 The back of the leg has large muscles known as the leg biceps which bend the leg. 
 The calve muscles at the back of the shin bone make it possible to raise the heel. 
 The gluteus maximus muscle in the buttocks makes it possible to pull the legs back, push the hips forward and stand up straight. 
 Beginners and intermediate trainers rarely need to do more than squats or calf raises to achieve good leg development. 
 If these are done with moderate weights in strict style during the early stages of training, then very good foundations will have been laid for more advanced, specialised exercises. 
 Lunges will place more emphasis on the quadriceps and glutei, and are therefore excellent for women to raise sagging bottoms. 
 Front squats also place more emphasis on the quadriceps. 
 The calves can be trained in isolation by using seated calf raises or standing calf raises. 
 The former works the soleus (lower) muscle more, while the latter works the gastronemius (upper) muscle. 
 Remember that an overdeveloped soleus will give the appearance of a &bquo;thick&equo; ankle, so aim for balance between the two rather than just increased size. 
 The most effective way of isolating the leg biceps is by using a hamstring  machine to perform leg curls. 
 Without this machine the best method is to do dead lifts; the negative part of this exercise (resistance to dropping) really works the leg biceps very hard. 
 Fig. 2 Upper leg muscles 
 The glutei are worked in squats, lunges and dead lifts, but one other very simple exercise is straight leg kicks to the rear. 
 These can be done free standing, with ankle weights or strapped to a pulley machine. 
 ABDOMINAL TRAINING 
 The abdominals are perhaps the most striking and impressive of all the muscle groups. 
 The waistline is usually the first area where fat accumulates, and so the presence of well developed and well defined abdominals is an obvious sign of an excellent physical state. 
 The stomach muscles are made up of several muscle groups, the most important being the rectus abdominis and the external oblique. 
 The rectus abdominis is a large flat muscle which joins the sternum (breast bone) to the pubic bone. 
 This is divided vertically by the linea alba, and horizontally by 3 fibrous bands. 
 These fibrous bands create the impressive &bquo;washboard&equo; look of the abdominals. 
 The external obliques are situated either side of the rectus abdominis, and run diagonally from top to bottom. 
 It is the obliques and abdominals which create the well trained look. 
 Thus because there are stomach muscles which operate vertically, diagonally and horizontally, complex bending and twisting movements are possible, and support for the vital abdominal organs is provided. 
 One of the most popular myths in weight training is that higher reps produce bigger abdominals. 
 However, in order for the abdominals to grow you must treat them like any other muscle group, and work them hard for 8 to 12 reps using 3 to 4 sets. 
 Two of the most basic exercises for increasing abdominal development are weighted sit-ups and weighted leg raises. 
 To do these effectively you need either an abdominal board which can be used on an incline, or a plank with one end raised on bricks and a piece of rope tied to that end to hook your feet underneath. 
 (The angle of the incline board can be made steeper as strength and fitness increases.) 
 For the sit-ups either a dumb-bell or a weight disc is held to the chest, and the back is kept slightly rounded with the chin on the chest. 
 The start and finish positions are such that there is no rest until all the reps have been completed. 
 The sit-ups start with the back off the board, and end before the upper body  reaches the vertical position. 
 When you lower to the start position, do not touch the board; if you do this, or if you sit up past the vertical position, then the abdominals will have a slight rest. 
 Fig. 3 Lower leg muscles 
 The leg raises are done the opposite way round, with the feet at the lower end of the incline bench. 
 Either iron boots or weights are strapped to the ankles and the legs are raised to an almost vertical position. 
 The legs are then lowered to within 15cm (6in) of the bench before being raised again. 
 Try not to arch the back during this exercise. 
 CHEST TRAINING 
 Good chest development is generally accepted as an indication of strength. 
 The link between strength and chest development is probably due to the fact that bench pressing is the prime chest builder and is now one of the most basic of all bodybuilding exercises. 
 The chest muscles are called the pectorals major and pectoralis minor &mdash; &bquo;pecs&equo; for short. 
 The pectoralis minor lies underneath the pectoralis major and in almost all cases any reference to the pecs means the pectoralis major. 
 The pecs respond fairly quickly regular training, especially the bench press. 
 The main function of pecs is to adduct the arms (adduction is a movement towards the centre-line of the body), that is they move the upper arms across the body as in dumb-bell flyes. 
 Other movements brought about by the pecs are shoulder flexion, which draws the arm forwards and upwards, and shoulder extension, which draws the arm down and forwards. 
 By working the pecs from different angles it is possible to direct the work-load to different parts of the muscle. 
 To develop the pecs fully it is necessary to be aware of how much development there is already, and whether that development is well balanced. 
 The most common problem for men is to develop too much lower pectoral muscle, and so end up with a &bquo;droopy&equo; looking chest. 
 Conversely, too much upper pectoral development and too little lower pectoral development gives the impression of a chest that &bquo;fades&equo; away. 
 Both of these common faults can easily be rectified by using the correct exercises. 
 The range of chest exercises is really only limited by the equipment that is available. 
 The flat bench press is very good for building size, and fairly heavy poundages can be used quite quickly. 
 Varying the grip on the barbell alters the range of movement but too wide a grip reduces the range of movement, leading to restricted development. 
 Bench pressing should never be done alone because of the dangers of getting the barbell stuck across the face, neck or chest. 
 There are two variations on the bench press &mdash; the incline bench press and the decline bench press. 
 The incline  bench press puts more emphasis on upper pec development and the decline bench press gives more low pec development. 
 Dumb-bell flyes can be used on a flat, incline or decline bench to vary the emphasis. 
 Fig. 4 Abdominal muscles 
 The dumbbell pull-over is excellent for development of the deep pec line. 
 Dips will also place great emphasis on this line if they are performed very low, that is with the shoulder below the level of the elbows. 
 (Weights can be attached to the waist to make the dips much harder.) 
 The use of cables, if available, is excellent for bringing out the definition at the centre of the chest (origin) due to the fact that they allow movement over the body's centre-line without loss of tension. 
 Pectoral decks emphasise the outer part of the pecs near the insertion into the humerus (upper arm). 
 They also relieve stress on the elbows. 
 If women fully develop the lower pec muscles, the result is that the bust is pushed out by large underlying muscles, thus seeming larger. 
 Thus upper pec work and cable work enhances the cleavage. 
 To conclude, it has to be said that balance is the most important factor in chest development. 
 The pecs are such a dominant muscle group visually that it is very difficult to hide faults in development. 
 Also, all chest exercise must be balanced by back training, otherwise the chest muscles will begin to pull the shoulders round and the weaker, untrained back muscles will be unable to counteract the pull. 
 BACK TRAINING 
 After the legs, the back is the most neglected area in terms of training and development. 
 The reason for this is very simple &mdash; you can't see it. 
 An individual will get far more pleasure working his chest, his abdominals or his arms because he can see the muscles working and developing. 
 Also, it is much harder to train the back muscles and receive a hard pump. 
 The back consists of 3 main sections; the lower, the middle and the upper back. 
 The lower back muscles, the spinal erectors, are neglected by the majority of people, and yet these muscles are perhaps the most important in the back. 
 It is these muscles which make it possible to stand up straight and bend over to lift objects. 
 Most back problems originate in this area, but they could be easily avoided by regular exercise of the spinal erectors. 
 The two easiest and most basic of lower back exercises are hyperextensions and stiff-legged dead lifts. 
 Remember to use light weights and be very cautious when first  exercising the spinal erectors. 
 Fig. 5 Chest muscles 
 The main muscles of the middle back are the latissimus dorsi and the lower trapezius. 
 The latissimus dorsi account for the very impressive &bquo;V&equo; shape of athletes and bodybuilders. 
 These muscles draw the arms to the sides, therefore all rowing exercises, pull-ups or pull-downs are performed by them. 
 Swimmers often have very good &bquo;lat&equo; development due to the fact that the arms are drawn towards the body in most styles of swimming. 
 The lats can be exercised for width or thickness. 
 The best exercises for developing width are wide grip pull-ups to the back of the neck and lat pull-downs. 
 Exercises to develop thickness include seated rowing. 
 bent-over rowing, &bquo;T&equo; bar rowing and single arm rowing. 
 These latter exercises also work the lower trapezius muscles and the rhomboids. 
 The main muscle of the upper back is the upper trapezius. 
 The trapezius muscle group is kite-shaped and basically pulls the head and the shoulders back. 
 The main attachment points of these muscles to the bones are on the shoulders, the base of the skull and the middle of the back. 
 The upper trapezius is best exercised by doing dumb-bell shrugs and upright towing. 
 It can also be exercised by doing shoulder presses either with dumb-bells or with barbells. 
 It is essential to work the trapezius muscles, otherwise a stooped, round-shouldered posture will result; this is a common fault with people who do a lot of chest work but little or no back work. 
 SHOULDER TRAINING 
 Broad shoulders are always associated with strength and are very impressive. 
 The skeletal width of the shoulders is hereditary but an illusion of breadth can be created by fully developing the shoulder muscles. 
 These muscles are called the deltoids and have 3 &bquo;heads&equo;; anterior (front), lateral (side) and posterior (rear). 
 The heads form a cap which covers the shoulder joint, and they are attached at one end to the upper arm and at the other end to 3 points to the front, top and back of the shoulder. 
 The function of the deltoids is to raise the arm to the front, the side and the rear. 
 All 3 of the heads of the deltoids are involved in shoulder movements, but the direction of the arm movement determines which head is being used the most. 
 The most impressive shoulder development shows an equal development of all 3 heads of the deltoids. 
 However, this is not very easy to achieve. 
 In almost all cases the anterior deltoid is the most developed and the posterior the least  developed. 
 The reason for this is very simple; the anterior deltoid is brought into play with nearly all chest exercises and is therefore always being trained more than the other heads. 
 Fig. 6 Back muscles 
 The lateral and posterior heads should always be trained with specific exercises. 
 The best exercise for the lateral deltoid is dumb-bell side-lateral raises (remember to only raise the arms to the horizontal because after this the upper trapezius will be used), The posterior deltoid is the least enjoyable to train, but should never be missed out. 
 This head is worked hard by bent-over dumb-bell laterals or bent-over cable laterals if a cable cross-over machine is available. 
 It is unlikely that you will need to train the anterior deltoid specifically, but if you do then the straight arm dumb-bell raises to the front are excellent. 
 When you start shoulder training it is best to do an exercise which works all 3 heads together and then concentrate on each head individually. 
 The seated press behind the neck with a barbell is one of the best exercises for training the 3 heads together, but seated dumb-bell presses are also good if no barbell is available. 
 It should be said, however, that the press behind the neck exercise works the upper trapezius quite heavily, so if the trapezius muscles are already well developed the exercise should be avoided. 
 Alternate dumb-bell presses, which do not use the trapezius as much, could perhaps be used instead. 
 Correctly balanced shoulder development should be aimed for if you are to avoid spoiling the whole physique. 
 ARM TRAINING 
 The balance between biceps and triceps development is perhaps one of the most difficult to achieve in physique development. 
 The triceps make up 60% of the upper arm while the biceps make up only 40% and yet it is still the case that most people tend to have overdeveloped biceps. 
 There are two reasons for this. 
 Firstly, training the biceps is very enjoyable and the results are easily seen. 
 Secondly, the biceps respond very quickly to training and are relatively easy to develop compared to the triceps. 
 Upper arm training should be in the ratio of 3:2 for triceps to biceps. 
 It is always best to train the triceps first because these are usually the least developed group. 
 There are 3 heads to the triceps; 2 of them have their origins on the humerus and the third originates on the shoulder blade. 
 The group has a single tendon insertion below the elbow into the forearm. 
 The function of the triceps is to straighten the arm, therefore at the end of each exercise the arms should be locked out straight. 
 If this is  not done then the full range of triceps movement has not been achieved and full contraction will not be carried out, thus inhibiting development. 
 To develop more size heavy basic exercises must be done, for example close grip bench presses, reverse grip bench presses, dips, push-downs and lying extensions. 
 It is always advisable to have a training partner to assist when doing lying triceps exercises. 
 Fig. 7 Shoulder muscles 
 The biceps have 2 heads, the points of origin being the coracoid process on the shoulder blade and the glenoid fossa (where the humerus fits into the shallow socket of the shoulder blade). 
 There is a single tendon insertion into the radius bone of the forearm. 
 The function of the biceps is to bend the elbow, supinate the forearm and flex the shoulder. 
 As with the triceps, to develop larger biceps heavy basic exercises such as barbell curls or dumb-bell curls must be performed. 
 Dumb-bell curls should always involve rotation of the dumbbells. 
 This means that the biceps have been worked through their complete range of movement, aiding complete development. 
 Forearm training is frequently omitted because of all the work the forearms do while training other body parts. 
 Higher repetitions must be used because the muscle type is denser and more resilient (like the calves). 
 Wrist rolling is probably one of the best exercises to perform. 
 This involves holding out a bar at arm's length and then rotating it. 
 A weight can be tied to the bar by a piece of rope and then raised and lowered to make the exercise more difficult. 
 One final point to remember is that it is very easy to overtrain the arms. 
 More exercises and more repetitions are not the answer to correcting poor arm development &mdash; it is better to do fewer exercises and repetitions and to take more rest. 
 Stretching 
 The benefits of stretching for people from all sports and of all ages cannot be overemphasised. 
 However, incorrect stretching can cause untold damage and even permanent injuries in extreme cases. 
 It is vital, therefore, that you know how to stretch properly and safely. 
 Some coaches believe that stretching before exercise reduces the chances of injury and helps athletic performance. 
 But others believe that stretching should only be carried out after exercise when the muscles are warm, thus reducing the risk of tearing them. 
 Both stretching before and stretching after exercise have their merits, but it is important to consider the type of stretching involved. 
 There are 2 types of stretching; static and ballistic. 
 Static stretching involves slow, continual movement until the person is at the limit of his stretch. 
 The pressure is then eased off and gradually reapplied to a maximum again. 
 This is the only type of stretching which should be carried out before exercise when the muscles are cold.  
 Fig. 8 Arm muscles 
 Ballistic stretching is more vigorous, as the name suggests, and involves bouncing and jerking movements. 
 This type of stretching can clearly be dangerous if done before exercise when the muscles are cold, and so it should only be used at the end of a training session. 
 Both types of stretching increase flexibility, and as a basic rule you should do static stretching before exercise and both ballistic and static after exercise. 
 The length of time spent stretching depends on the sport you are training for and the degree of flexibility you wish to attain. 
 There are now a number of stretching devices on the market. 
 However, a machine can only stretch in a few directions and is therefore only of limited value. 
 Most people use their own bodyweight as a stretching aid, with the number of different ways to stretch being limited only by the imagination. 
 The most important factor in &bquo;free stretching&equo; is that you know when it hurts and how far you can go, making it possible for you to immediately release the stretch should you need to. 
 Safety is also an important factor when stretching with a partner; he does not know how much pain you are in and he could inadvertently overstretch you. 
 Aerobic activity 
 Aerobic activity is a form of training requiring a constant supply of oxygen to the muscles. 
 Anaerobic activity does not require an oxygen supply to the muscles for a sudden, short burst of activity. 
 Running is obviously an aerobic activity while weightlifting is anaerobic. 
 To reach an aerobic state the heartbeat must be taken above 120 beats per minute and maintained above this level for twenty minutes. 
 The benefits of this type of training for the heart and lungs are enormous, but very few people who train ever reach this level. 
 A class which has a rest every 3 or 4 minutes but trains for an hour would be better off training non-stop for 30 minutes. 
 This would increase the fitness of the class-members, their sense of well-being at the end of the session and also their physical appearance.  
 Stretching 
 An Argus specialist publication August 1991 &pound;1.60 Founded in 1901 
 Carving special Edward Hopkins' Gothic Revival 
 Carving Plans Carving Productions Carving People 
 National Marquetry Exhibition Reviewed  
 Contents August 1991 Vol. 95 No. 8 Woodworker 
 Features 
 798 Electric carving 
 Test of power carving systems 
 802 Mastering marquetry 
 Review of the National Marquetry Exhibition. 
 Nick Gibbs  
 816 Carving through the confusion 
 Market review of carving tools. 
 Nick Bell  
 822 Testing the Cogelow angles 
 Ray Gonzalez  tests the new Henry Taylor tools. 
 826 Workshop creations 
 Results of our Workshop Carving Competition. 
 830 Board games 
 The craft of Cabinetmaking continued. 
 David Savage  
 842 Carving out of his shell 
 Profile of carver, David Morgan. 
 Bertie Somme  
 850 Gibbons' blazing glories 
 Hampton Court Palace restored. 
 Trevor Barnes  
 Projects 
 795 Prize tribute 
 Lee Dickenson's  carved Chindit. 
 806 Guidelines in wood 
 More marquetry advice. 
 Gerald James  
 832 Three dimensions of chair design 
 The opening part of Steve Goulden's  series on chair construction. 
 834 Gothic traces 
 A project for the church. 
 Edward Hopkins  
 854 Sun seeking seats 
 Building a seat around a tree. 
 Dan Solman  
 Regulars 
 778 Face and Edge 
 News and new products 
 736 Letters 
 Correspondence, comment and competitions 
 793 Turning the Page 
 Regular feature for turners 
 846 Bob Wearing's Workshop 
 Making Perspex squares 
 849 Question Box 
 Timber, handles and linseed 
 856 Hands On 
 Eight tips from readers 
 876 Profile 
 The Cheltenham Art Gallery and Museum 
 On this page: George Brownlee's Teddy (p.818) and workshop carving (p.826) 
 On the cover: Gothic table (p.834), David Esterley carving (p.850) and Newman and Redford (p.802) 
 Face &amp; Edge News 
 Woodland competition 
 A new competition, sponsored by John Makepeace, and a display of craft products has been dedicated to wood at an annual agricultural show in the South West. 
 The Melpash Agricultural Show will this year include a marquee for Woodlands and Woodcraft, and will offer woodworkers the opportunity to display their skills on 29 August. 
 The Parnham Trophy will be awarded to the &bquo;best article made from wood&equo;. 
 In sponsoring the competition John Makepiece is hoping to &bquo;encourage and to recognise excellence in design and individual craftsmanship in wood&equo;. 
 The trophy will reflect this objective. 
 The woodland marquee will house exhibitions of tools and timber species, with expert advice for farmers or landowners wanting to plant and manage woodland. 
 There will be a pole lathe on the go, and the Adams Axeman making walking sticks and baskets. 
 The Parnham Trophy is open to both amateurs and professionals: as John Makepeace has said himself, &bquo;the amateur can so often teach the professionals a thing or two!&equo; 
 The competition will be judged by Alan Amey, who was an apprentice at the John Makepeace Workshops in 1976, and then head craftsman until he left last year. 
 Alan will also be making the Parnham Trophy. 
 Entry forms and details are now available from Mrs E. Gale, 23 South Street, Bridport, Dorset, (0308) 23337. 
 Somerset subjects 
 The latest one-day courses at the Somerset Rural Life Museum have been announced, offering another mix of subjects for woodworkers. 
 The first two are demonstrations on pole-lathe bodging with Dick Apps on 10 August, and 17&ndash;18 August. 
 Then Alan Wakefield will be demonstrating walking stick making over that latter weekend, with Les Davis turning on 25&ndash;26 August and John Adams caning seats on 22 September. 
 For more details of these demonstrations contact Mary Gryspeerdt on (0458) 31197. 
 Turning contests 
 Pollards Woodworking Machinery are sponsoring a new turning competition on 3 August, with classes for novices and experienced turners in a selection of categories. 
 The competition will be held at the Old Stores Turnery, Nantwich, Cheshire, with sections for turned boxes, lamps and bowls, and general category for pieces that must include a Goodwoods accessory. 
 For more details of the contest contact Bruce Pollard, 1 Canons Road, Old Wolverton, Milton Keynes (0908) 222272. 
 Annual Conference of tools in docks 
 The annual summer conference of the Tools and Trades History Society will this year feature a visit to Chatham Docks. 
 The weekend event will be centred around Wye College in Ashford, Kent, but the outing to the docks &mdash; including the Historical Society Museum, Joiners Shop and Ropewalk &mdash; should be the highlight. 
 An important part of the weekend will be the auction of tools, books and other objects. 
 It is vital that all members being something along, with proceeds going to the society's special fund. 
 There will also be visits to Wye College's Agricultural Museum and the Museum of Kent Rural Life at Sandling. 
 For details contact The Administrator, 60 Swanley Lane, Swanley, Kent BR8 7JG. 
 One in the eye for maple scientists 
 If you want to know how the bird's eye in maple is formed ask a logger. 
 That is the advice of the Timber Trades Journal , which discovered, from a lumber man in the USA, that the figuring is created by sap pockets exploding in the spring. 
 That logger even believes you can hear it popping as the pockets burst. 
 However, the TTJ  also report that if you want the real cause of bird's eye features, don't ask a scientist. 
 When they put it to an expert they received the bewildering reply: &bquo;Bird's eye figure is formed as a result of local suppressions in divisions of cambial tissue that cause indentation to develop. 
 This retardation effect continues for several growing seasons and produces an indented conical depression.&equo; 
 Toying with the BTG 
 A major restructuring of the British Toymakers Guild has been recommended at their Annual General Meeting. 
 Unfortunately insufficient members turned up to achieve a quorum, but ex-chairman, Robin Brookes, took the opportunity to state that the guild could not continue to be run on a rotation of volunteers. 
 Clive Green has now taken Robin's place in the chair. 
 The aim is now to change the constitution to elect four associate members onto a management committee. 
 The meeting also resulted in a recommendation to allow toy designers to join the BTG.  
 &bquo;The only thing I really want is for Alonzo Kettless to carve me an East Suffolk Policeman's helmet,&equo; said Chief Superintendent Rom Rumsby on his retirement. 
 Alonzo chose mahogany, with the braid separating the bulk of the helmet from the peak. 
 It took him about 150 hours to complete, and won him a City and Guilds senior award for excellence. 
 Spoonerisms: Bertie Somme is planning spooncarving classes in September, teaching techniques for making functional spoons. 
 Cost for the class, on 14 September will be &pound;7. 
 Details from Stella Bellem, Cobtree Museum of Kent Life, Lock Lane, Cobtree Manor Park, Sandling, Maidstone, Kent, (0622) 763936. 
 Gothic twist: just one of the many exhibits at the annual Buckinghamshire College Design Degree Show, which featured craft and manufactured furniture. 
 However students were finding that the normal demand for High Wycombe graduates is waning this year due to the economy. 
 Charity begins at the home bookshelf 
 We all collect books in vast numbers, often leaving them unread for year. 
 Now those unused tomes of practical or technical information can be donated to a worthy cause, offering others the opportunity to gain from our over-filled bookshelves. 
 The Ranfurly Library Service is a charity which helps combat the critical shortage of books in developing countries, by providing carefully selected consignments of books in response to urgent requests from schools, colleges, hospitals and other institutions. 
 They do this by tapping the vast resource of surplus old and new books in the UK. 
 Many of the requests are for practical, technical and vocational literature for all levels, from secondary schooling upwards. 
 Sadly these books are in shortest supply in Britain. 
 If anyone has any unrequired books &mdash; the Ranfurly Library Service particularly needs carpentry books &mdash; they can be contacted at 2 Coldharbour Place, 39/41 Coldharbour Lane, Camberwell, London SE5 9NR, (071) 733 3577. 
 Dust survey shows lack of control 
 Woodworking businesses still have some way to go before they can show that they are controlling the hardwood dust emissions from machinery. 
 The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) are saying that the situation is depressing, with a lack of effective control. 
 These are the results of the HSE's latest survey, which charted the exposure to hardwood dust among employees of 41 companies. 
 In only five of those factories were the levels on all machines below the maximum exposure level (MEL), stipulated by the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health (COSHH) laws. 
 Such was the ineffectiveness of controls that only 13 factories fell within a limit twice that of the MEL. 
 Although 60 per cent of the 363 samples taken were below the MEL, there were plenty of examples of poor control, with nearly two-thirds of all planers producing dust levels above the MEL. 
 The HSE's Woodworking National Interest Group have concluded that lack of control is not the preserve of specific machines, and dust levels are high within factories as a whole. 
 They are urging better &bquo;housekeeping&equo;, and a better understanding of when and how to use respiratory protective equipment (RES). 
 That some factories and many machines showed effective control shows that the MEL standards can be achieved. 
 The group is demanding more effort from those in charge of factories. 
 The latest information sheet (No.11) can be obtained from HSE Woodworking National Interest Group, 14 Cardiff Road, Luton LU1 1PP, (0582) 34121. 
 They have also recently published a catalogue of all the safety standards and levels for woodworkers. 
 This includes sources for information on noise and fire, as well as advice on the law and occupational health. 
 Conserving Matters 
 Steps are at last being taken to create a formal structure for checking the sources of sustainably managed tropical timber. 
 If all the claims of timber merchants and suppliers are to be believed, most tropical timber sold in Britain is already produced on a sustainable basis. 
 However the Worldwide Fund for Nature (WWF) has said that less than one per cent of all tropical timber brought into Britain is managed sustainably. 
 Of course, disparity between the timber industry and environmental groups centres on the definition of sustainability. 
 It is the development of &bquo;clear and practical standards for forest management&equo; that will be the first aim of the new Forest Stewardship Council (FSC). 
 The council sill be an &bquo;umbrella organisation&equo; to provide an infrastructure for other groups to monitor forest management, and the FSC will be promoting the standards through a Forest Stewardship Charter. 
 The FSC is currently in the draft stage, with proposals being presented to conservationists in Britain and the USA. 
 In America the Rainforest Alliance and Green Cross are attempting to monitor sustainable sources but the two organisations have complimentary skills, and will benefit from a coordinating body which will hopefully be able to make more efficient use of the many diverse groups working on rainforest practices. 
 The draft proposals for the FSC are open to further discussions and suggestions of aims and objectives are welcomed through the pages of Woodworker . 
 Workshop manual 
 For anyone setting up a workshop, or in the midst of that eternal task, a new publication may offer some assistance. 
 Woodworkers' Workshop  includes all the information needed to source machines and tools for a workshop, with further advice on insurance, floors, timber storage, and the best way to purchase tools. 
 Expert woodworkers, like Luke Hughes, Ian Norbury and Lucinda Leech provide samples of their experience of organising a workshop, and the magazine includes a pictorial view of some of these idyllic work areas. 
 Woodworkers' Workshop  costs &pound;2.95, from newsagents, or from Argus Specialist Publications, Argus House, Boundary Way, Hemel Hempstead HP2 7ST, (0442) 66551.  
 Ray Gonzalez &mdash; whose Gorilla featured in Woodworker  and the BWA &bquo;Wildlife in Danger&equo; exhibition last year &mdash; is now opening his workshops to students. 
 Ray specialises in ornamental carving, but his range of skills and teaching ability cover figurative work, and other aspects of carving. 
 He already trains apprentices, and now welcomes any potential carving students. 
 Contact Ray at Chardleigh House, Chardleigh Green, Wadeford, Somerset, (0460) 65611. 
 Face &amp; Edge Products 
 Turning accessories 
 Woodturning Supplies are a new company who are producing a range of lathe accessories at competitive prices. 
 Woodturning Supplies have one or two interesting changes from standard thinking. 
 Their pin chucks fit directly on to the headstock spindle, bringing the work closer to the bearings so putting less strain on them. 
 The 5in faceplate is turned rather than cast, so is more accurate. 
 The 3in faceplate and screwchuck, has a central position for use as an ordinary screwchuck with small workpieces, and three holes in the flange for use as a faceplate on larger work. 
 Their outboard turning stand, like all their products, is a robust piece of kit. 
 Originally designed for use with the popular five speed Taiwanese lathes, which are imported by a variety of companies, they can be used with other lathes to increase the capacity for bowl turning. 
 The stand is a machined steel column with telescopic height adjustment, the top is threaded to accept the banjo assembly, and tool rest from the lathe. 
 They make a bowl turning tool rest, and two straight tools rests. 
 The prices are very reasonable, for example, the straight 5in and 10in tool rests are priced &pound;6.00+VAT and &pound;8.50+VAT respectively, the bowl turning rest &pound;8.25+VAT. 
 The outboard turning stand costs &pound;33.00+VAT. 
 Woodturning Supplies are also able to make special sizes of tool rests and faceplate to order. 
 At the moment they are only selling by mail order and at Woodturning Supplies, 7 Parker Close, Elson, Gosport, Hampshire, (0705) 522032. 
 Solvent Free Varnish 
 Sterling Roncraft have launched what they call Ronseal Solvent Free Varnish. 
 All they are giving away about the composition is that it is a water based polymer. 
 The benefits of this finish quoted by the makers are, that it doesn't smell strongly during application and drying, and brushes are cleaned are cleaned up with water when the job is finished. 
 Perhaps a more important advantage of Solvent Free Varnish is that it is touch dry in 20 minutes, and ready for a further coat in two hours. 
 A considerable time advantage over polyurethane finishes, against which it is match. 
 Roncraft are producing a range of clear and coloured versions, but I suspect that the clear gloss and satin finishes will be of most interest. 
 Details from Ronseal Woodcare Advisory Bureau, 15 Churchfield Court, Churchfield, Barnsley S70 2LJ. 
 Wirbel keeping the workshop air clean 
 Wirbel (UK) supply industrial cleaning machines, and have launched two workshop vacuum cleaners which can be used either as ordinary cleaners, or as remotely switched dust extractors. 
 Remote switching means that the extractor is switched on and off by operating the power tool it is connected to. 
 Both new machines can operate two power tools simultaneously. 
 The filters are of non stick nylon and singed polyester, filtering out particles down to 0.4 microns. 
 To help maintain this level of filtration and extend the life of the motors. 
 the exhaust air is not used to cool the motor; a separate stream of air is used for this. 
 The 430E is powered by a 1000 watt motor and has a 20 litre waste capacity, the 820E has a 1500 watt motor, 45 litre waste capacity and is trolley mounted. 
 Both are supplied with full tool kits. 
 Prices are &pound;239.00+VAT for the 430E, and &pound;403.00+VAT for the 820E. 
 Wirbel (UK) Ltd, Millers Close, Fakenham Industrial estate, Fakenham, Norfolk NR21 8NW, (0328) 863333.  
 AEG's new dust extractor, the WV2000, combines two 100watt motors and sub-micron filtration from their familiar WV dust extractors, with the polythene waste bag from the bag filler. 
 This wall mounted unit can also be mounted on a trolley (above), and can be fitted with a remote switching unit. 
 AEG, 217 Bath Road, Slough, Berkshire SL1 4AW, (0753) 872101. 
 The Staysharp, from Markek is a combination sharpening unit, for drills 3&ndash;10mm in diameter. 
 Chisels and plane blades can be sharpened and honed, held at the correct angles by ingenious jigs. 
 Powered by a power drill, knives, scissors, shears and rotary mower blades can also be sharpened. 
 Four grinding stones are provided. 
 Martek Ltd, PO Box 20, Redruth, Cornwall TR15 2UF, (0209) 219911. 
 Albert Purcell (above) at the drop hammer, is producing a range of hand forged and finished turning and carving tools, using methods most of the industry has discarded. 
 Because of these methods of production he is also able to make special tools to order, one such recent order was for hooked turning tools. 
 Endeavour Tools, Unit 1, Derbyshire S41 9BQ (0246) 208962. 
 Letters 
 Manufacturing Resource 
 You may remember that in the December issue of Woodworker  last year I wrote about John Makepeace's new venture, Hooke Park College. 
 At the time the college was specifically teaching and developing the practical skills needed to use thinnings, green and coppice timber in the design and construction of buildings and wooden products. 
 John Makepeace's aim then was to bring the courses a step further with the potential for product manufacture on site. 
 His hope has been that better use of woodlands will give the trees greater value, and so farmers and landowners will have an economic reason for managing their woods. 
 John admitted recently that the economic climate has rarely been worse, and woodland owners have no financial rationale for management of this resource. 
 He is, however, frequently contacted by landowners who want to know how they can make better use of their trees. 
 Now, as a step away from the craftsman entrepreneur that has been John Makepeace's hallmark he has introduced a new course to Hooke Park College for manufacturing businesses that want to make better use of wood. 
 He is attempting to provide training for people who want to create businesses that produce quality products from indigenous timber at source. 
 Like his other courses this one-year programme will comprise a mix of practical and business studies, though the practical side is more likely to look at machining, timber technology and forestry. 
 It is hoped that the first year's crop of students will stay on at Hooke Park to help initiate a production plant there. 
 With the funding John Makepeace has attracted he should have no difficulty finding the students. 
 Again it will be they who will become the cutting edge when it comes to the readiness of woodland owners to offer the use of their woods and premises for other business. 
 The principle will also be dependent on the development of technology to allow people to once again work in the forests, near the resource. 
 Soon the pole-lathe bodgers will be replaced by bodgers powered by compressed air. 
 Doubtless local authorities will want to have their say in the matter, but let's hope that soon we will be finding woodworking workshops and factories in amongst our trees, and making best use of our most readily renewable resource. 
 Nick Gibbs. 
 Hold on, hold-down 
 Regarding the winning Hands On feature in March Woodworker , despite the well-intended editorial footnote, I do feel it was a mistake to include Bill Wiseman's fascinating but appallingly dangerous hold-down device, and to then endorse it in a recommendatory way by awarding it special recognition. 
 At risk of seeming a killjoy, I would urge readers to think through the implications of all home-made safety devices which set out to resolve some well-acknowledged safety problem only to create others of a less obvious by more hazardous nature. 
 Remembering that anything that bodes to threaten concentration in wood-machining is a prime risk, let us consider a router cutter revolving at anything up to 24,000rpm sitting midway between 12 highly unstably-sprung devices whose proper purpose in life is the support of wet laundry on a clothes line. 
 It takes little imagination to foretell the likely consequences of just one peg disintegrating and flinging its spring or its free arm into the cutter gap during a pass; or the possible knock-on effect(s) on the rest of the makeshift assembly and the astonished operator if this should happen. 
 There have been better hold-down devices of a home-made nature in Woodworker  in the past &mdash; the best of them doubtless designed after some careful thoughts about an acceptable specification. 
 Mr Wiseman doesn't only have the safety of his hands to consider: in this case he might stand to lose his sight or sustain laceration from bits of flying clothespegs, blocks and cramps into the bargain. 
 So might those who choose to take up his well-meaning idea. 
 John Bull, Norfolk 
 Woodworking Types 
 Kevin Bevel Edge 
 Matching methods 
 I would like to suggest that John Adler looks to his own laurels before criticising rough carpenters. 
 and the ability of amateur woodworkers to cut an accurate tenon (WW/May 91/p.456) . 
 Take for example his statement that the position of every groove, cut, and hole is relative to the dimension of the timber. 
 What nonsense &mdash; they are relative to the face side/edge, or the reference plane as the author calls it. 
 Later on in the article he repeats this; ie. &bquo;not only does the tenon need to be pretty much where it needs to be relative to the thickness of the wood.&equo; 
 However, a little later he says &bquo;set the tenon gauge the same distance in from the reference plane.&equo; 
 Presumably he means &bquo;mortise&equo; gauge. 
 When talking about edge jointing he advises scribing a line with a knife or gauge. 
 I would suggest that if a gauge was used then any curvature of the edge would be repeated at the line produced. 
 Perhaps he would have been better off with a pencil! 
 On the same subject I would advise the author that hot glue is not a necessity to make a joint without cramps &mdash; it can be made equally as well with a cold glue. 
 When talking about marking off the stretchers he seems to place more importance on the length of the tenon than the distance between the shoulders. 
 At this stage there would be no harm in leaving the tenons slightly long. 
 He advocates marking the stretchers off one at a time instead of squaring cross all four at once. 
 He talks about the accuracy of rulers. 
 If he uses the ruler to transfer a measurement from one piece of his work to another then they are going to be identical; accuracy of the ruler doesn't come into it. 
 The author should also be reminded that &bquo;rulers&equo; are used by children in schools; woodworkers use &bquo;rules&equo;. 
 He cuts the tenon shoulders one at a time, and then lines them up to make a final pass if necessary. 
 Why not cut all four at one go? 
 He then goes on to fit the tenons to the mortise saying &bquo;fit the stretchers to the posts and repeat the exercise on the mullions.&equo; 
 Seems reasonable, except for the fact that he hasn't cut the mortises for the mullions. 
 He did this after he had cut the grooves for the second time in the stretchers. 
 the lid: why cut a rebate the full length of the frame pieces when simple notches would have sufficed? 
 Indeed it would have improved the appearance of the underside of the lid. 
 With regards to the finish. 
 I think the choice of white french (or white shellac as the author calls it) was ill advised on a timber like teak which has a greasy nature. 
 Whilst I stand to be corrected, it may well have been this greasy property which made the finish dry out with a khaki tone. 
 It makes me shudder to read of a timber like teak being stained. 
 In conclusion I should like to ask the author if the chest had a bottom. 
 I also believe that the editorial staff of the magazine are open to criticism in allowing the article to printed as it was. 
 It should have been returned to the author for him to re-write in a clear and concise manner. 
 P. Maynard, Wilts 
 Cutter request 
 Now that I am retired, I find I am spending more and more time on voluntary charity work, for which I am very happy to take part, and I am hoping to make a start on making small wooden articles including picture and plate frames. 
 Recently, I obtained a saw rabbeter (sic)  for my Bridges drill but, unfortunately, was unable to find any of the moulding cutters (STD825-829). 
 May I ask of any of your readers have any of these cutters they do not need and would wish to sell them? 
 James A. Bailey, Lancs 
 Screwdriver to hand 
 I would refer to the winner of &bquo;Hands On&equo; (WW/April 91/p.398)  does this now mean that screwdrivers can now be used for opening tins of paint with raising of eyebrows? 
 T. Ellold, Kent 
 Any old tools? 
 HELP! 
 Dedicated but poor woodworker starting in business will give any old or unwanted tools a kind, loving home. 
 Please contact me through Woodworker . 
 Thanks. 
 Jane Gubb, Bristol  
 On the bleach 
 I would like to correct a serious error made by Noel Johnson Leach in his article &bquo;On the bleach&equo; (WW/May 91/p.466) . 
 He states that it is not necessary to use vinegar or mild acetic acid to neutralise the reaction, as it is a waste of time to apply a mild acid on top of a stronger acid. 
 This comment is correct if the bleaching has been done with oxalic acid. 
 However, most two pack systems, similar to our own Wood Bleach, do not contain any acid and as Mr Leach himself points out the &bquo;A&equo; solution is usually a strong alkaline. 
 The &bquo;A&equo; solution is usually a strong alkaline. 
 The &bquo;A&equo; solution is not applied to act as a de-greaser on the wood, but to make sure that the surface of the wood is alkaline. 
 The second solution, which contains hydrogen peroxide, is stabilised so that it will not liberate oxygen until it comes into contact with an alkali. 
 It is for this reason that any unused &bquo;B&equo; solution must never be returned to the original container, as it would then destabilise the contents which, in a sealed container without a vented cap, could cause the container to burst, and with a vented cap the solution would eventually become ineffective. 
 In Mr Leach's reply to J. Wigg of Halifax (WW/June 91/p.557)  he referred to commercial acrylic water borne lacquers. 
 The caution he gave regarding their use implied that, despite being water based, there could be hazard in their application. 
 We would like to point out that we manufacture a range of acrylic varnishes and acrylic floor coating for domestic and industrial use, which are completely safe to use and are non-hazardous. 
 The varnishes are available in gloss, satin and matt and the floor coating in gloss and satin. 
 Mr Leach also states that &bquo;to date there is no full mirror-gloss available.&equo; 
 Our gloss acrylic coating can be burnished to a mirror-like gloss surpassing that which can be obtained with polyurethane varnishes. 
 Ronald Rustin, Rusins 
 Wrong end of the stick 
 May I, through the medium of Letters page, reply firstly to Jack Hill (WW/April 91/p.352) . 
 If he read what I wrote, I did not imply that the Nortec tools were inferior and needed adjustment. 
 Neither I, nor my friends who borrow them, have any cause for complaint. 
 I merely included the note about adjustment for interest, whoever the maker might be. 
 I know that Jack is a master chairmaker and I admire what he does. 
 He may regard me as an amateur but the fact is that, due to physical difficulties, I cannot pull and twist in a horizontal mode and so I invoked gravity to assist. 
 The derogatory remark that the rounder handles might strike the bench leg is uncalled for. 
 Secondly, to Paul Clarke (WW/May 91/p.452) ; do, please, read Barry Jackson's book. 
 It is an excellent book, as I took care to point out, except for my few niggles. 
 Without tools, when the original Shakers landed, they would have been hard put to it to manage. 
 The Ejner Handberg books are available from Stobart Davis, Priory House, Priory Street, Hertford SG14 1RN &mdash; and they could probably obtain other books on demand. 
 The known facts about Shakers are carefully set out by June Sprigg and I do not believe her work is a romantic history. 
 Why speculate what Mother Anne might have thought about modern glues &mdash; they had none and she spoke to the brothers and sisters in their instant present. 
 Len Dennis, Barnet 
 Handcrafted 
 I would like to follow up your article on the Letters page of April's Woodworker  by asking you to put the following question to your experts or readers. 
 Not all of us like using woodworking machines, and do not mind spending the extra time achieving results which may be less perfect and mechanical-looking. 
 Can you tell me if any woodworking and design courses &mdash; part-time, full-time, short or long &mdash; are available in which the emphasis is largely or completely using hand-tools? 
 Simon Barley, Sheffield 
 Pit your wits 
 Richard Elderton's latest challenge is to work out the layout for a solitaire board he is designing. 
 The winner of this challenge will receive a selection of Trend router cutters courtesy of Trend Machinery and Cutting Tools, Unit N, Penfold Works, Imperial Way, Watford, Herts. 
 WD2 4YF, (0923) 249911. 
 Answers must be sent to Woodworker  at Argus House, Boundary Way, Hemel Hempstead HP2 7ST by 1 September at the latest. 
 Please mark your envelope &bquo;Pit your wits&equo;. 
 Good luck. 
 Solving solitaire centres 
 I have always envied John and Barbara's solitaire board. 
 Last Christmas, having loads of time on my hands over the holidays, I decided to take the plunge and make one at least as nice theirs. 
 I found a piece of quarter-sawn oak in my wood store, which would do perfectly for the job. 
 Solitaire boards are normally circular and have 33 circular depressions or sockets for the playing pieces (marbles) arranged on six lines in a cross configuration. 
 On mine, I cut a groove near the periphery of the board to collect used marbles. 
 My piece of oak allowed a blank of 270mm diameter. 
 Measuring radially from the centre of the board, the annular groove is 8mm from the edge and is 16mm wide. 
 The sockets are 16mm diameter, and the eight outer ones are 8mm from the groove. 
 Each socket is equidistant from its neighbours. 
 The problem 
 Calculate (accurate to two decimal places) the correct centre distanced of each socket from its neighbour so that the specifications given above are satisfied. 
 All working must be shown. 
 While you ponder this month's challenge, I must admit that the first competition, about the Teddy box, has proved a cathartic experience for me. 
 I had worked out three ways of making the box; the volumes different for each. 
 Unfortunately the solution published in the July issue of Woodworker  is not correct. 
 Thank you Christopher Andreae of Bembridge for pointing out my error. 
 To any readers who feel hard done by or annoyed please accept my sincere apologies. 
 Looking on the bright side, I think this corner of the magazine could turn into a piece of gladiatorial entertainment! 
 Even with my mistake, only one person answered all three questions correctly: Alan Hezzlewood of Endon. 
 Congratulations. 
 The correct volume for question one was 0.31026m3, and yes three different volumes were possible for question two, though the answer, 0.34047m3 stands for question three. 
 I hope we can all remain partners, friends and challengers in puzzle working.  
 Ploughing small 
 The June issue of Woodworker  published a letter entitled &bquo;Ploughing small&equo; which was answered by Bob Grant. 
 I had a similar problem when I wanted to rout a decorative edge around small components. 
 I couldn't hold the component in a sash cramp, itself held in the vice, because the bearing at the base of the router fouled the sash cramp. 
 I eventually solved the problem by two small blobs of hot stick glue which temporarily glued the component to a scrap piece of wood, dimensioned so that the component overhung the scrap all around. 
 The scrap was then clamped in the vice, and the routing was easy. 
 The final procedure was to split off the component from the scrap and clean up. 
 It wouldn't work if the component was made from very fibrous wood which might lift with the glue but it works in a lot of circumstances which defy the &bquo;sash cramp&equo; solution. 
 J. Smart, Powys 
 Heat treated copan from the Congo 
 Further to the query by Mr P. Ridgley of Oldham regarding copal varnish (WW/June 91/p.557) , we would inform you that copal varnishes were manufactured from fossilised resins, mainly obtained from the Congo. 
 The copal was heat treated to make it soluble in oils and solvents. 
 A varnish made from copal was known as short, medium or long oil length, depending upon the proportions of copal to oil. 
 The mixture of oil and copal was thinned, usually with white spirit. 
 If Mr Ridgley's varnish is slow drying, he can add a little paint driers. 
 If too thick for easy brushing, then the varnish can be thinned with white spirit. 
 Copal varnishes have now mainly been replaced by polyurethane and alkyd varnishes. 
 Rustins 
 Screwdriver slip for punching head 
 I was surprised to seen that in April's Hands On that you had awarded Zwi Rotem of Israel the winner's prize for his tip on extracting nails with screwdrivers and a washer. 
 What he didn't say and you didn't pick up was how do you get the screwdrivers underneath the nail head without damaging the wood, seeing as nails are usually driven in flush with the face of the timber. 
 I would suggest if anybody has this problem, they drill the heads off as you would a rivet, punch the nail in a little and fill in then with the appropriate filler. 
 G. Wilcox, Liverpool 
 More exchange rates 
 During more than 20 years in the food machinery business, I was a frequent traveller to the USA, and one of the fringe benefits for me was to go along to the tool department of the local Sears Roebuck store. 
 For me it was like an Aladdin's Cave, and one could not help but notice the often ridiculously low prices being asked. 
 Much of this was &bquo;own label&equo; merchandise of course, but occasionally one would come across a familiar branded item, at about half the price of those at home. 
 The difference was compounded even further with the consideration that American pay-rates were two or three times ours. 
 If we cannot beat the system, how can we get it to work for us? 
 I have had some modest success in this regard, and pass on here some tips I have used. 
 Never, ever be tempted to buy mechanical items from overseas, unless you are absolutely sure that the power requirements are available here. 
 Even if all is well in this regard, you may find that the manufacturer's agents in the UK will not honour the guarantee. 
 However, small, non-mechanical parts are fair game and might show considerable savings. 
 These days a credit card has universal application. 
 If you are lucky enough to obtain a Sear's catalogue, or one offered by any number of American suppliers, you can give your card number and order what is required on the order form usually enclosed. 
 Many state that overseas custom is welcomed. 
 One of my best buys was a dovetailer jig costing a little over &pound;100. which represented a saving of &pound;200.00 over the price here. 
 The friendly dispatch clerk had written a personal note with the invoice attached. 
 There was a saucy additional note from British Customs and Excise, who had opened the package upon arrival, to determine any duties payable. 
 The note complimented me on my friend's honesty! 
 I do not know how the customs people work these things out, but I have never paid import duties on these overseas postal purchases. 
 As they have always been properly declared, I have assumed that goods below a certain value must be duty free. 
 Bill Watts, Glos 
 Admiring lathes 
 I have nothing but admiration for those hardy woodturners who have put the clock back a few hundred years and are making furniture with their pole lathes, but it has made me more than ever aware that the wood lathe has changed very little over the years. 
 I have often wondered why it should be such a primitive machine in spite of all its modern gadgets. 
 The turner still has to hold a great juddering chisel in his hands and relies on a good eye and a steady hand to ensure a true cut. 
 I have no doubt that dedicated woodturners everywhere would scoff at the idea of engineers' lathes being used for woodturners, but when I think of the various moulds and patterns I have made over the years with comparative ease but which due to their intricacies could only have been made with extreme difficulty on a wood lathe &mdash; if at all. 
 I then wonder why some enterprising manufacturer hasn't made a cheap engineer's lathe as an alternative to the old-fashioned wood lathe. 
 Is there a masochistic streak in all woodturners that sends them back to the pole lathe? 
 T. Burton, Herts 
 Appalachian dulcimer 
 Having read your article (WW/May 91/p.484)  on the Appalachian dulcimer, I would draw your readers' attention to the following points, which might aid them in producing an effective musical instrument. 
 The original articles (Dec. 1970 and Jan. 1971) included helpful photographs showing stages in the instrument's construction. 
 Anyone unskilled in wood bending would find it helpful to read a more detailed description of the process, which can be found in most books on guitar or violin construction. 
 The thickness would suit a guitar but are unnecessarily heavy for a dulcimer less than half its width. 
 Soundposts are an important feature of bowed instruments but are unsuitable for plucked instruments and will deaden the sound of a dulcimer. 
 Try comparing a plucked note on a violin and on a mandolin and you will certainly notice the difference. 
 If the posts are only intended to curve the back, this can be better achieved by planing a curve on to the struts before they are glued to the back. 
 It is possible to make dulcimers of different sizes and shapes but this does affect the sound produced. 
 The instrument described is traditional in shape, size and stringing. 
 A modern dulcimer is more like the lower one in the photograph, with a double first string. 
 A common modern technique is similar to guitar finger style using a CC-G-C or a similar fifth and octave tuning which gives greater versatility without re-tuning and can be further extended by the introduction of an extra fret between the 6th and 7th. 
 A good tutor book will explain this. 
 If the ribs (sides) are thinner, as suggested (about 1.5mm) hot bending will not be necessary and a better shape can be achieved by the use of a simple jig to hold the ribs while the glue dries. 
 The use of small glue blocks along the inside of the joint is also a good idea. 
 If the instrument is to be resonant the apparently solid finger board needs to be hollowed out from underneath, leaving about 6mm of wood top and sides and openings cut through the soundboard (face) to link this space to the interior of the instrument. 
 If you are using guitar machine heads (far more easily adjusted than pegs, which also require special tools to fit them accurately) it is more convenient to modify the shape of the head and fit them only on the left (if you are right-handed) in the manner of Fender guitars. 
 If you want symmetry make sure you get the right number of left or right-handed machines. 
 A machine fitted on the wrong side will be inefficient and wear out quickly. 
 Alan Margerison, Lancs  
 Moisture meters in wood 
 In the June issue of Woodworker  we invited suggestions for moisture meters, following Colin Mill's article on the subject. 
 We have already received two ideas, which might prove useful in the workshop. 
 A widely used method of temperature control, writes Peter Rowe of Reading, employs two strips of metal of differing coefficient of thermal expansion, which are welded together lengthways. 
 Differential expansion with increasing temperature causes the compound rod to bend and make or break electrical contact. 
 The same principle can be used to make a moisture meter from wooded strips. 
 Glue together lengthways two strips of regular grained hardwood, one with grain running along the length as normal, and the other, cut from the end of a wide board, with grain running across. 
 Dimensions are not critical but strips 6x3/4x1/4in glued on the wider face are suitable. 
 Fix it to a convenient base to stand vertical and attach a pointer at the top to measure deflection. 
 Sensitivity is increased by reducing the sandwich thickness which can be adjusted to suit after gluing, but not too thin or the short grain will crack. 
 Leave the instrument in a greenhouse containing well-watered plants on a sunny day for a few hours to get an idea of maximum deflection. 
 Boring bits in wood 
 May I ask a question of the majority of manufacturers of wood boring bits? 
 Auger bits for use in a brace are made with a screw nose so that they are self feeding. 
 Physical effort is required only for turning and guiding and, as the feed speed is slow, precise depth control is easy. 
 Auger bits for use in power-tools used to have brad points, but they are now very hard to find. 
 As a woodwork teacher for many years I consider this design to be dangerous because power drills run at a much higher speed than a brace and consequently the feed is too fast for accurate control. 
 The user has to judge the exact moment to stop. 
 When used in pillar drill, it is often very difficult to reach the on-off switch with one hand on the lever. 
 The workpiece may even be snatched up. 
 On many occasions I seen students surprised by the unpredictability of these bits, and are unwilling to use them again. 
 Even when used properly, the bit has to be reversed to release the nose screw; mot all machines have this facility. 
 My remedy is, of course, to file off the thread. 
 Why is this not done by the manufacturer? 
 I'd love to know. 
 D. Mann, Essex 
 Router Crafter lathe 
 I am desperately seeking to obtain a Router Crafter lathe. 
 They are used for fluting, reeding and other features on the lathe. 
 Does anyone know of a supplier or second-hand dealer who might have one? 
 I know there was one called a Woodmaster, and Sears made another. 
 G. Russell, Keighley 
 Tilting turners 
 At the most recent target for the Antipodian Don Quixote, who tilts not at windmills but at woodturners, and not wishing to turn a non-existent battle into a war of attrition, I can only wonder who Mike Darlow will focus his attentions on next! 
 Jack Hill, Sussex 
 Rates of exchange 
 At a recent Hugh O'Neill turning demonstration he mentioned in passing how much cheaper woodworking equipment is in the USA. 
 This confirms many readers' views and, since woodworkers keep tool and machinery suppliers in business, it seems to me that somebody on the supply side should justify what appears to be gross profiteering. 
 At a recent show a motorised respirator was retailing at between &pound;280 and &pound;300. 
 In an American publication it was offered at &dollar;279. 
 At the current exchange rates that amounts to a mere &pound;159. 
 It seems daft to have to send to America to buy a British product, but that is what I have done, because I am tired of being ripped off by every Tom, Dick and Harry. 
 Goods even arrive more quickly sometimes. 
 N. Bex, Bournemouth 
 Hezzlewood meter 
 My design of moisture meter, writes A. Hezzlewood of Endon, has been made, tried and tested and works very well. 
 The strip of mahogany has the grain running lengthwise. 
 Since expansion takes place laterally on exposure to moisture, there must be a resulting contraction longitudinally, which manifests itself by rotation of the coil to unwind, with of course, expansion on drying. 
 Coiling the strip was achieved by heating a 3/4in diameter aluminium tube with a blowtorch, and dry heat bending the strip around the tube. 
 I used mahogany, but other woods may be preferable. 
 The knob at the rear is for setting the pointer to any desired position for calibration. 
 Simple planning 
 When planning if the problem is that the vice jaws foul the plane fence, the answer is simple. 
 I don't know about the Stanley No. 45, but I just put my Record Multi-plane upside down in the vice and pass the wood over the &bquo;sharp end&equo;. 
 Some might like a push stick for safety but I've never bothered. 
 At first it might help to retract the iron a little. 
 Certainly liberal use of candle grease is in order. 
 Don't cramp the plane in the vice too tightly. 
 Owners of small block planes or even smoothing planes can make these planes almost as jointers or try-planes. 
 True up a piece of hardwood (one surface/two sides) the same width as the regular plane and put both in the vice, truing up plane case and hardwood with a straight edge. 
 Set the iron plane well down in the vice so as not to obtain the plane cheeks, or else&hellip;! 
 Quite long pieces can be trued this way. 
 Any push-stick could have sandpaper glued on for additional grip. 
 J. Mather, Bedlington 
 Steaming away 
 I am writing to you to ask if it is possible to obtain drawings, designs and or working instructions for making what is known as a Steamer Chair. 
 I have recently started reading Woodworker  magazine and find it most interesting and informative; thank you for an excellent publication. 
 Rex Brier, Rotherham 
 Musical issue 
 I was gratified to see the coverage in May's issue on musical instruments. 
 However, it was a pity that Greg Lewin was interviewed by somebody only knowledgeable about corncrakes; it would have been interesting to know whether Greg has done anything about the diabolical fingering needed on the ancient form of the racket. 
 The one in the photograph seems to lack the bits of tube I have seen in others. 
 The problem of having more holes than fingers is bad enough, but the serpentine bore means that the fingering in unlike that of any other instrument. 
 Probably having keys would bee greeted with horror by some, but it ought to be possible to rationalise the finger holes. 
 Has anyone made a user/friendly racket? 
 If so, could they share the knowledge with us? 
 George Swallow, Dorking  
 Turning the page 
 Many readers wrote in explaining that Terry Porter's mystery object is a hat for Madonna, royalty or even aliens. 
 Its real purpose though &mdash; which the editor guessed (oh yes?) &mdash; is for strengthening ankles, and it is called a wobble board. 
 J. Smart of Powys lived up to his name, and was the only entrant to get it right. 
 Well done. 
 We welcome more mystery objects. 
 This month we are introducing a new competition category to the Woodworker Show competitions. 
 Sponsored by Turn-a-Round of Norwich, we are inviting turners to submit turned toys. 
 The only conditions of this contest are that the piece must be largely turned and must be a toy. 
 Indeed the more imaginative and fun the better. 
 The judges will of course be looking for turning ability, but the most important factor is that children &mdash; or adults &mdash; will find the toy a joy. 
 The winner will be awarded &pound;100 by Turn-a-Round, who offer a full woodturning service from their base at Rockland St Mary, Norwich. 
 The bulk of their business is production turning of the furniture and joinery industries. 
 Turn-a-Round will doubtless take some interest therefore in our continuing production turning competition, which was such a success last year. 
 George Hatfield, who runs the production turning course at Sydney Technical College in Australia, will again be setting the competition, and again we will be asking entrants to submit two pieces. 
 The aim is to achieve two identical representations of George's drawing (available with entry forms), with the judges looking for consistency, finish and use of timber. 
 Last year the judges debated at length how to mark entries that did not follow the drawings to the letter, but showed evidence of good economical production turning techniques. 
 It was finally decided that the drawings must be the guide. 
 The most obvious area of doubt was in the chucking marks, and in this area the drawings must again be followed. 
 There was also some debate about timber choice, with some people questioning the use of some timbers for production turning. 
 The choice of timber is up to the entrant; the only proviso being that the two pieces must be consistent. 
 We are fortunate to announce that this year George Hatfield will be demonstrating on the Woodworker stand, at the Woodworker Show for the Saturday and Sunday (19&ndash;20 October). 
 He will be available for advice and tips about production turning, and will have his selection of home-made tools on display, and is use. 
 Well worth a visit. 
 For details about the show, and entry forms for the competitions, contact Argus Specialist Exhibitions, Argus House, Boundary Way, Hemel Hempstead, HP2 7ST, (0442) 66551. 
 We hope to see you at the show. 
 The Pedigree of Holtzapffel 
 By Warren Greene Ogden Jr. 
 Book review by Jon Sauer, ornamental turner  This book is primarily the history and provenance of Holtzapffel lathes. 
 It has taken Warren Ogden nearly 30 years to compile the information on these machines which began in the mid 1950s. 
 With the help of Frederick Barnes, Warren obtained the Register of Lathes from Guildhall Library of London. 
 The first portion of lists this complete register &mdash; all 2557 lathes manufactured between 1795 and 1928, when the last one was sold. 
 This register lists them by serial number, price, type of lathe, date sold and to whom. 
 Part Two comprises the notes on the history of the Holtzapffel lathes. 
 This is a most comprehensive work which lists the original owners of the lathes and their biography. 
 Subsequent owners are also reviewed up to their current owners. 
 The lathes and the special apparatus are also reviewed, i.e. common lathes, screw mandrel, rose engine lathe, elliptic-eccentric chucks, dome chucks, geometric chuck and various cutting frames which were supplied with these lathes. 
 At the time of publication (1987) it listed almost 300 Holtzapffel lathes still in existence in the world with 20 per cent of them in the United States. 
 Warren Ogden Jr. 
 has done a tremendous amount of meticulous research on these valuable records. 
 The Pedigree of Holtzapffel Lathes  is a valuable reference tool for the ornamental turner with an inclination towards the Holtzapffel lathe. 
 It is not for everyone; I can only recommend this book to those who are serious about the history of turning lathes and ornamental turning. 
 &bull; This review was first published in Turning Points , and the book is available from the Wood Turning Centre, PO Box 25706, Philadelphia, PA 19144, USA; cost &dollar;45. 
 Finger in the wind 
 I was interested to read Hugh O'Neill's article (The Price is Right) in the Turning supplement  to the June issue of Woodworker  writes Geoffrey Heath, which gave a clear account of how the price of a finished article might be established. 
 However, I believe that the vast majority of woodturners in the UK are amateurs like myself, and it is the contrast between our approach to pricing and that of the professional which I wish to discuss. 
 We amateurs find various outlets for our products. 
 At one end of the scale, some of use make things solely for our own use, or to give away to our friends and relations. 
 Then there are those who sell their wares for charity at zero gain to themselves. 
 As we progress up the scale of profit-taking, we find others who sell at small craft fairs and those who find an outlet through local shops, until we come at last to the favoured few who sell at the prestigious crafts fairs which Hugh prefers. 
 But no matter how we dispose of our goods, we are not in woodturning to make a living. 
 Hugh chides us for selling at what he regards as low prices, but he forgets that our hobby not our source of income; it is a way of relaxing during evenings and weekends when the serious business of earning a living is over. 
 We might even feel that any financial loss is a small price to pay for the satisfaction which woodturning brings. 
 This is where we differ from the professionals &mdash; they turn in order to earn; we earn in order to turn. 
 We are striving for perfection in our products, not for making money out of them. 
 However, we do want to get rid of they (otherwise the house soon gets full of unsold turnery!), so we price them by our own standards &mdash; which may well include a look at what the competition is charging and the &bquo;finger in the wind&equo; which Hugh decries. 
 He says that if the wages element is higher than 15 per cent of the selling costs, then he has &bquo;to work out ways of working faster&equo;! 
 But what will happen to the quality of the product? 
 I, for one, couldn't make a 10in bowl in 45 minutes &mdash; at least, not one with which I would be satisfied. 
 Once a craft becomes a business, half the pleasure goes out of the window if one has to worry about making enough money to maintain a reasonable standard of living. 
 How much more enjoyable is turning as a pure hobby! 
 Free from such cares, the craftsman can concentrate on quality rather than quantity. 
 Despite Hugh's remarks about downgrading our skills and devaluing wood, we are as concerned as the professional (possible more so) about &bquo;promoting wood&hellip; as something with its own intrinsic beauty&equo;, since we can put our heart into the work without worrying about whether or not it will sell, let alone whether it will sell at an &bquo;economic&equo; price. 
 And if it ends up in the scrap bin, we simply write it off to experience, and start again. 
 It seems to me that the successful professionals make their money not be selling their wares, but by selling their skills &mdash; by writing books, running courses, making videos, holding seminars and giving demonstrations &mdash; in short, by teaching others how to do it. 
 Nothing wrong with that, of course, but let's not pretend that one can really make a decent living just by turning wood. 
 They being agreed, one may as well go back to the &bquo;finger in the wind&equo;!  
 Prize tribute 
 Lee Dickenson explains how he came to carve the massive &bquo;Chindit&equo; sculpture, which won the Arbortech Woodcarver competition at the 1990 Woodworker Show. 
 Lee used nothing but this disc to carve the piece with an angle grinder, and he describes some of the effects the tool can achieve. 
 The burn marks are most easily achieved when the Woodcarver has lost its edge 
 Every piece of carving on the Chindit, which stands about 3ft high, was done with the Woodcarver 
 As a professional carver I thought it only natural to get my hands on one of those new Arbortech Woodcarvers to add to my compendium of tools last year. 
 I had no specific use at the time, but I thought it would prove a handy addition to the workshop, and was delighted when my grandfather elected to purchase the tool for me. 
 Sadly he died shortly afterwards and for many reasons it was some months before I used the disc. 
 The advent of the Arbortech Carving Competition at the 1990 Woodworker Show gave me the idea of putting the tool to some good use. 
 My grandfather had always taken a keen interest in my work, and I had an equal admiration of the stories of his time spent in Burma during the Second World War. 
 Therefore it seemed fitting that as a tribute to him and his comrades I produce a sculpture with this tool. 
 The strongest image I got from his stories and subsequent research was of the oppressive jungle and heat in which the soldiers fought. 
 They given the colloquial name of &bquo;Chindit&equo;. 
 Particular units who operated for long periods at a time in the jungle became so adept in their surroundings they became known as &bquo;Green Ghosts&equo;. 
 This description gave me the idea of a soldier slipping silently through the jungle. 
 I thought this a viable way to use the Woodcarver, with its circular cutting motion giving a good effect for the hanging, clinging jungle. 
 If the foliage was closely arranged around the figure this would allow for the cutter's inability to carve deeper than the distance between its projecting edge and the body of the angle grinder that powers it. 
 In planning details, I was fortunate that  my family had certain items of grandfather's equipment; a bush hat and a bush knife known as kukri. 
 I still needed extra information on clothing etc&hellip; 
 This was obtained with kind assistance from the Burma Star Association and the National Army Museum. 
 I produced sketches and a clay model for ideas, but these were eventually only used for reference when working on the sculpture. 
 I chose a large irregular lump of spalted walnut and directly drafted my idea on to the timber with a paint brush and some white paint. 
 This was the only medium that showed up well enough against the various colours and patterns of the spalted timber. 
 At later stages a thick crayon and a large felt tip suited particular areas of marking. 
 I set about the lump with the Woodcarver and soon discovered what it could and could not do. 
 Certainly it is essential to use some form of eye protection. 
 Work was carried on around the lump in a fairly ordered pattern helping to keep everything in proportion. 
 It was easy to stand back and view what had been accomplished, decide what had to be done and move straight in again with the view fresh in memory. 
 It became self evident when it was time to stop as the depth of cut ran out, though this was not a problem as I wanted the effect of closely surrounding foliage. 
 The foliage was achieved by allowing the cutter to run up and down in the timber. 
 Being mainly softwood around the outside, with no pressure applied, I allowed the cutter to dictate where I wanted to go. 
 This left any harder wood in place. 
 Where possible I allowed the cutter to go through to meet a similar cut. 
 I found the Woodcarver to be an ideal tool for fast removal of waste as well as useful, with care, as a modelling tool. 
 In the softer areas it worked like a hot knife through butter and large areas could be removed, shaped or modelled in an  astonishingly short time, in comparison with traditional mallet and gouges. 
 I felt that on this particular piece it did struggle through the heartwood at times, especially on the figure's right-hand side as this was extremely hard in places, with dense interlocking grain where a branch or branches had formed. 
 It soon became obvious that I was probably pushing the cutter and grinder too hard and had to adjust my force. 
 Although this slowed progress down and was, it must be admitted, somewhat disappointing, I only had to remind myself what effort would have been needed if using a mallet. 
 The harder parts gave a much more satisfactory finish with clean shiny cutter marks even in the interlocking grain. 
 But it did blunt the tool quite easily and sharpening was needed more often that I had thought likely, though this walnut was extremely hard. 
 However, sharpening is no problem. 
 I found the metal of the cutter easy to work as it seems quite soft in comparison to the tool steel of my gouges. 
 I presume this was a design compromise as an extremely hard and brittle edge could easily shatter on a hard piece of timber, so a softer tempering of the metal is necessary. 
 Even with the edge dulled, the finish on the harder parts was still quite clean but the softer wood tore up quite badly and in places just fell away. 
 It needed a really sharp edge and just a light brushing with the cutter to form some of these parts. 
 On such a large piece it was possible to achieve the facial features and details of the clothing by gentle removal of material by holding the grinder and cutter to the work at many different angles carefully and in a safe manner. 
 Do not hold the grinder back to front, and never remove the guard. 
 To complete, the whole piece was dressed down with as many and as fine cuts as possible again using different angles of attack, all the time experimenting. 
 For more definition in certain areas I allowed the cutter to stay in one place long enough to burn the surface of the timber. 
 This gives lines of shadow under belts, etc&hellip; 
 It was a slight problem though when the cutter was sharp as it would just keep eating away material, never leaving enough time to generate heat through friction, especially on the softer wood. 
 But when the edge had dulled it was no problem and on the harder wood a burn mark could be left in a few seconds if very little pressure was applied with the cutter just spinning on the surface. 
 The applied finish &mdash; several liberal coats of linseed oil &mdash; was allowed to dry, then finally waxed.  
 The burn marks are most easily achieved when the Woodcarver has lost its edge 
 Every piece of carving on the Chindit, which stands about 3ft high, was done with the Woodcarver 
 Fig. 1 An early sketch of a Chindit 
 Lee used the natural lines of the walnut lump to portray the soldier moving in the jungle 
 The Chindit went on to win the Arbortech Carving Award at last year's Woodworker Show, sponsored by M&amp;M Distributors of Bexhill-on-Sea 
 Fig. 2 Special jungle effects with the Woodcarver 
 Tool Test Electric Carving 
 To give more power to the carver's elbow there are now a wide range of electric carving systems, and here we test a selection of machines and tools that may offer more than a saving in time 
 SuperCut carving disc 
 Price: &pound;18-&pound;24 Luna Tools and Machinery Presley Way Crownhill Milton Keynes MK8 0HB (0908) 262262 
 There is an interesting story behind the SuperCut woodcarving disc for angle grinders. 
 It has been launched by Toolbox of Sweden in direct competition to the Arbortech Woodcarver; the principle of both tools being to imitate the action of chainsaw teeth, but in a safer, more versatile manner. 
 Arbortech did so by developing a stamped disc with a tooth shape that differs from the chainsaw, to make sweeping cuts possible. 
 Its inventor Kevin Inkster started with a loose chain on a disc, and it is this formation that Toolbox have chosen. 
 This move has been promoted as a safety measure, permitting slip when the tool bites, but the legalities of patent law were doubtless considered when Toolbox decided to manufacture their version. 
 Kevin Inkster discarded the loose chain when he was dissatisfied with the cut it gave, but it made him realise that he was certainly on the right lines. 
 To that extent the SuperCut is also on the right lines, and has some benefits, but for the serious woodcutter it is limiting. 
 Such is the waste removal power of this sort of tool, that safety for the operator and workpiece must be considered. 
 On a superficial level then, the SuperCut is the safer tool, slipping whenever problems arise, though there is concern about the chain breaking. 
 However, I found that in many instances this slipping action makes the disc useless, as it is unable to cut to any depth before it stops rotating. 
 I had expected it to be best for trenching and shaping in the vertical position, but on all but the softest of timbers it failed to supply a substantial cut. 
 Conversely I discovered that it could cut with the disc flat, or at a slight angle, and I can see it having benefits for very fine work. 
 On the fruitwood I was working it left an interesting rippled effect. 
 However the moment it slips you have to wait for the chain to gain momentum before cutting can recommence, otherwise it bites again. 
 Waiting is a bore, and it is worth noting that the chain continues to rotate after the disc has stopped, so beware fingers. 
 In all, this seems a product created more by necessity than design. 
 I believe that the original Arbortech Woodcarver was one of the most dynamic inventions for woodworkers of recent time, offering fast cutting with a good finish and potential for fine detailing. 
 It was only a matter of time before a competitor sprang on the market. 
 I see that someone terrified of using any woodworking tool involving the slightest of danger may be attracted by the SuperCut, and it might have potential for novices, but then what tool offers complete security? 
 To date I have found both tools perfectly safe, used with care, and though there are rare occasions when I might choose the SuperCut, for the moment I'll be sticking with the real thing, which remains in a class of its own. 
 Easy-Carve Power Chisel 
 MAC659 Price: &pound;92.50 MAC750 Price: &pound;82.50 Pintail Decoy Supplies 20 Sheppenhall Grove Aston Nantwich Cheshire CW5 8DF (0270) 780056 
 When is a chisel not a chisel? 
 When, I suppose, it is a power chisel. 
 The idea is simple, with an electric drill powering a reciprocating blade, via a flexible drive shaft and cam mechanism. 
 Though the drill rotates continuously, the blade only moves when pressed against the workpiece. 
 There are obvious advantages to this method, especially for those inclined to use  no more effort with a mallet than is absolutely necessary, The downside to this is that rhythmic tapping is replaced with the screaming of a drill and the rattle of the reciprocating mechanism. 
 The Easy-Carve is in fact not as noisy as one might imagine, but it is not necessarily a tool I'd want to use for long stretches. 
 It is, however, a lovely feeling to be cutting through timber with the slightest of pressure. 
 With a sharp edge this method of power carving offers a degree of control more difficult to achieve with conventional carving techniques. 
 I used it for areas hard to reach with chisel and mallet, and expect that when carving delicate work it has the advantage of not disturbing the workpiece with sudden strikes. 
 The MAC750 is a smaller unit than the 650 I tested, and is recommended for that more delicate carving. 
 As a novice carver I found the MAC650 very useful for controlled shaping of curved pieces with flowing lines. 
 By raising and lowering the handle it is possible to follow the contours of the shape, and though this can also be said of a normal chisel, I enjoyed being able to concentrate solely on the chisel edge, as if whittling. 
 Changing blades is a simple process, using C-spanners supplied with the tool. 
 A set of fine carving bits is also supplied, including a 3/8in gouge, 3/8in bent gouge, 3/8in V-tool, 5/8in gouge and 1/2in chisel. 
 Of course even the best power carving system is only as good as its edge. 
 These bits are a forged lamination of soft, low carbon steel and high, hard carbon steel, made, seemingly, in Japan. 
 As they are only small they appear to be quite light, but seem to hold an edge and time can only tell how quickly they wear out. 
 There is also a line gouge available, costing &pound;15, for larger stock removal. 
 All round, an interesting tool, that sits comfortably in the hand, is kind to the elbow, and doesn't cost an arm and a leg. 
 Pfingst Power Carver 
 Price: &pound;239 Pintail Decoy Supplies 20 Sheppenhall Grove Aston Heath Nantwich Cheshire CW5 8DF (0270) 780056 
 Now this really is the business. 
 I have recently been making sculpted furniture, using a variety of power carving methods for fast timber removal. 
 I had got to the stage with one particular chair when even a mallet and chisel was being limited by the design. 
 Then along comes this Pfingst Power Carver and my problems were solved. 
 The system incorporated the motor and flexible drive of the sort made famous by Dremel and dentists. 
 Two handpieces are supplied in this package. 
 The 44 has a 1/4in shank, and I found it perfect for the aggressive work I was attempting. 
 It is quiet and vibration free. 
 For finer work the 88 handpiece is available in two versions; the more expensive using a spring connector to hinge it mid-way from the main connector. 
 This gives it the feel of a heavy craft knife or pencil, making fine texturing easier on the elbow. 
 Most of Pintail's customers are carvers of wildfowl, and so this smaller handpiece must be very popular. 
 Both handpieces have a simple snap-on connector to the power driveshaft. 
 When fitting the headpieces it is important to ensure the shaft is fully connected by rotating the collet manually, prior to switching on. 
 The motor is 1/8hp, with a 39in shaft, rotating at 14,000rpm. 
 I found it to be quiet, even when under pressure, and the hooked power pack means that it can be hung conveniently out of the way. 
 The torque is certainly necessary when using some of the really meaty burrs. 
 These come in a variety of shapes and grades, but the silver Karbide Kutzalls are the most powerful, with gold ones offering a finer finish. 
 For what I was doing, on furniture, the silver burrs were extremely effective, retaining their edge. 
 Though the gold ones are good for finishing, they do tend to clog, although that probably depends on the choice of timber and level of finish. 
 The silver cylinder and cone worked wonders, and I'd be interested to try some of the other shapes. 
 Amongst the alternatives are tungsten, diamond and ruby carvers offering a range of benefits from longer life to precise detailing, which is vital for wildfowl carving. 
 There is also a drum sander, nylon brush and a steel mandrel for unmounted discs or defuzzing pads. 
 All these bits are changed quite simply in the 44 with a spanner and locking pin, while the smaller 88 uses a C-spanner and fingers. 
 I found this a little fiddly, with the C-spanner light weight, but the sliding finger guard, which covers the collet on the 88 is excellent for ensuring digits don't get near burrs. 
 As with any form of power carving, safety raises its cautious head, especially when using the silver burrs. 
 It is possible for these to &bquo;run away from you&equo;, and they can do more damage than you'd imagine. 
 This tendency to catch and pull happens most often when approaching the workpiece, but with experience I found this can be avoided easily by working against the rotation. 
 There is also the potential for catching then in jerseys and sleeves, so Pintail Supplies recommend a leather apron &mdash; which they conveniently supply &mdash; and care. 
 David Clews, of Pintail, says that about the only request for spares was due to a shaft breaking when a burr caught in clothing. 
 The risk is minimal, but such is the attraction of this form of carving that it is easy to get carried away, and its effectiveness does make eye and respiratory protection essential.  
 Dupli-Carver T110 and F200 
 Price: from about &pound;340 Rod Naylor 208 Devizes Road Hilperton Trowbridge Wilts. 
 BA14 7QP (0225) 754497 
 The carving machine was first developed in 1845 by T. Jordan. 
 Modern high-speed routers and precision bearing have allowed considerable improvements in speed, accuracy and versatility. 
 They work on the principle of a pantograph which can operate in three dimensions to carve a variety of materials such as marble, plastic and wood. 
 Dupli-Carvers are not suitable for high volume production; for this the German or Italian automatic or semi-automatic machines with pneumatic loading are more efficient. 
 The advantage of the Dupli-Carver is its low cost and efficiency for one off's and medium quantities in simple or very complex shapes. 
 The cutting head is a router with a variable speed control (0&ndash;30,000rpm) which is attached to the same shaft as a stylus. 
 As the stylus is moved over a pattern, the router duplicates the original. 
 Movement can be in any one, or a combination of five different ways, so allowing intricate shaping and undercutting with very little experience. 
 A pattern can be almost any material, even plaster which has had a layer of sealer on it. 
 It is also possible to modify the original by adding or omitting parts, or even combining different patterns into one carving. 
 There are two basic models of Dupli-Carver. 
 The smaller T110, which stands on the workbench and carves pieces up to 18in tall by 10in diameter; low relief panels 10in wide and limitless length; and spindles 36in long by 8in diameter. 
 The larger floor-standing F200 carves up to 40in high by 14in diameter; panels up to 14in wide in lengths restricted only by material lengths or workshop walls; and spindles up to 66in long by 8in diameter. 
 Perhaps the most serious problem with the machines is that during use some of the parts can loosen. 
 Router movement can be solved by changing the holding bolts for longer ones with a fine thread and fitting very thick washers, so enabling the nuts to be fully tightened without the router getting in the way of the spanner. 
 Movement in the stylus was even easier, putting a very thin leather strip between each of the two adjustable parts. 
 Small panels of bold, simple very low relief are perhaps most easily carved by hand, but on other work time savings of over 90 per cent can be achieved; 75 per cent is a reasonable average. 
 A further advantage is that the amateur can also save 20 years practice. 
 Copy carving machines are also available from Micom, 7 Industrial Estate, The Street, Heybridge, Maldon, Essex CM9 7XP, (0621) 856324.  
 Mastering Marquetry 
 In June the National Marquetry Exhibition culminated in the award of prizes to the best marquetarians in the land. 
 Nick Gibbs reviews the exhibition and competitions, and wonders how such masterpieces are achieved on wood     
 Perhaps of all the marquetry skills, the three veneer class brought out the most consistent high levels of artistic interpretation. 
 I found these pictures, Like &bquo;Shadow of War&equo; by B. Freestone from Harrow (left), to be the most vibrant, and the most attractive to view. 
 This piece is a fine example of the use of timber grain and colour to illustrate the depth of movement and texture in the sky and air around the figure 
 R.L. Soale's &bquo;Peace Perfect Peace&equo; (above), is a more typical entry to the marquetry classes, and won the Jack Fletcher Trophy for the best piece in the Secondary category, for marquetarians who have never won an award. 
 There seems to be an attraction amongst marquetarians for depicting Dickensian scenes of cobbled streets populated by pseudo-Dickensian characters. 
 This picture has a more contemporary scenario, and successfully portrays a village at sleep 
 One piece that uses more veneer than most &mdash; in a variety of flavours &mdash; is &bquo;Orpheus&equo;, by P.R.O. 
 Stephens, who won the Jim Jelley prize for the best applied marquetry by a beginner. 
 It is in fact a table, with hinging top, of about 36in diameter. 
 That it was made by a &bquo;beginner&equo; is a statement of the quality of entries at the National Marquetry Exhibition. 
 However the applied section was of a lower standard than other categories, and the winners stood out above the rest 
 The Artistic Merit Cup is annually awarded to the piece of marquetry that, presumably, stands best as a piece of interpretive art. 
 P. Davies' &bquo;Storytime&equo; (below) certainly conveys the moment of its content. 
 The picture forces the viewer to wonder at the subject of the crowd's attention. 
 It failed to strike me immediately, and I questioned the judges' decision &mdash; replacing it with one of the entries to the three veneers class. 
 The piece has grown on me, though I do wonder if there is any prejudice towards marquetry made of many pieces of veneer 
 My favourite piece at the exhibition was E.G. Neale's &bquo;Happy Eater&equo;, which won a second prize in the three veneer category. 
 The cartoon brings to life the humour of these famous characters. 
 The exhibition itself was brilliantly organised by the Harrow branch of the Marquetry Society, with one awe-inspiring collection of competition entries, and those on display only. 
 It is a measure of the current popularity of marquetry that there were 404 entries to the competitions, of which 93 came from the Harrow chapter 
 The miniature class shows a spread of subject matter and techniques. 
 D.R. Walker's stark caricature of the Prime Minister exemplifies those pieces that make use of line rather than grain. 
 &bquo;Polpero&equo; (middle above) by D. Carman, won the advanced class for miniatures and is of the scenic type, while the third miniature is symptomatic of the popular depressed urban portraits 
 The most startling of the three veneer section, to my mind, was &bquo;Caught on the turn&equo; by A. Smith. 
 Fortunately the judges agreed, and awarded it the first prize. 
 A. Smith was the only entrant to win two sections, with his beautiful parquetry box in the advanced, applied class 
 Though many pieces caught my eye at Harrow, space limits my personal choice. 
 Possibly due to my lack of marquetry expertise I was drawn towards the three veneer section, and E.J. Higgs &bquo;Light Music&equo; (left) won third prize in the class. 
 Perhaps it's because you get to see more of the timber. 
 However I was amazed by the quality of the exhibition as a whole, and can see that marquetarians are continuing to produce work of the highest standard. 
 In the long term, I'd only like to see more effort aimed at subject matter, and perhaps, in some cases, less concern with veneer quality 
 E.H. 
 Thorne's &bquo;Sports Page&equo;, which was highly commended at last year's Woodworker Show, uses more line than grain for the cartoon effect. 
 Other effects start with Fig. 1 (top, left-hand column) leaf design with silhouette shapes in the right-hand column 
 Marquetry Guide Lines in wood 
 Gerald James' concluding feature on marquetry methods looks at the use of line to create wooden decoration, and offers advice on choice of veneers, composition, the use of line and grain, and mirror images 
 Perhaps the most important factors in choosing veneers are those of tone and colour; and of these, tone is the more over-riding. 
 For tone and colour are not synonymous, though the two terms are often wrongly interchanged. 
 Tone is the amount of light a surface reflects and so determines how &bquo;light&equo; or &bquo;dark&equo; that surface appears to the viewer. 
 Colour refers to the actual wavelengths of the light rays concerned and determines the &bquo;hue&equo; (redness, blueness, etc&hellip;), which can be bright or dull, muted or full. 
 Most timber colours are of somewhat muted hues and generally very subtle (though not often dull), but can vary enormously from one another in tone value. 
 Much of the judgement used in choosing your veneers is instinctive, based on comparing different samples; it comes from familiarity with woods and an innate colour sense. 
 I suggest two points to bear in mind. 
 The first is to try to achieve a combination in which the tones of the different parts of the design are sufficiently distinct to read clearly one from another but do not display too violent tonal contrasts, unless a particularly dramatic effect is part of your aim! 
 Secondly, in designs where a 3D effect is required, it may in general be more effective to select the higher-toned timbers for background elements (eg distant hills) and keep dark-toned veneers for foreground work. 
 Concerning arrangement there are also, perhaps, two basics to bear in mind. 
 These are the practical considerations of the nature and limitations of wood as a material, on the one hand, and the visual effect one is trying to achieve on the other: the two are sometimes difficult to satisfy simultaneously. 
 In some cases the former dictates the direction in which the grain must run in individual pieces of the pattern (as well as often influencing the actual shapes of parts). 
 If, for instance, a certain portion of a design includes a number of long, narrow, shapes (eg tree branches) then the grain in those components should be arranged to run along, rather than across, the strips; just commonsense, but keep an eye on it. 
 At the same time due consideration must always be given to the visual effect of the grain markings. 
 The illusion of perspective can be enhanced by arranging the grain of one piece to run slightly obliquely to the horizon (fig. 1). 
 Composition 
 Looking back to the opening statement of the first article last month, we must remember that in the main we are thinking  about these designs as decoration rather than as pure picture-making. 
 It follows, then, that in their composition one must pay attention to the actual shape and purpose of the surface they cover. 
 Some designs fit neatly into circles and would be suitable for, say, small turned boxes, coasters or shallow platters. 
 Opportunities sometimes arise, however, for decorating objects with square or rectangular faces, or where certain considerations of function restrict the extent of possible ornament. 
 If decoration is to remain valid it must be subordinate to the over-riding proportions and the requirements of use of the object in question; yet still look good. 
 Using the grain 
 In some types of wood the grain markings are indistinct, while in others they are well-defined. 
 Amongst the former &mdash; plain sycamore, box and horse chestnut, for example &mdash; you can find good variations of tone and hue, but very little marking. 
 In the well-defined types, such as yew, zebrano and walnut, grain is the dominant visual feature and it is in this group that some of the effects most characteristic of good marquetry can be achieved. 
 But you have to develop an eye for spotting possibilities; a kind of &bquo;picture eye&equo; which sees a winter sky in the grain marking on one particular piece of veneer or a rock formation in the figure on another. 
 It is this aspect of the craft that I want to look at first this month. 
 Some wood samples have strong markings; either regular, random or quite wild. 
 Each one, in its way, might suggest some piece of a natural form which could be used in the creation of a marquetry design. 
 Take for instance the example of yew wood. 
 Its very strong and linear grain marking makes excellent leaf veining. 
 If this feature is exploited it makes a very nice leaf spray, and the 3D effect is enhanced if the yew is combined with a darker-toned wood such as sapele. 
 To make up these leaf forms, each motif is prepared by first cutting out two rectangles of suitable size having the grain running obliquely at about 45&deg; which are then edge-jointed and taped together. 
 The leaf tracing is then pasted on to the assembly so that the centre vein coincides with the join. 
 A more complicated type of leaf, such as in an ivy design (fig.3), can be prepared by assembling the parts in stages. 
 Castello is a wood in which the markings are usually very distinct, consisting of stripes of light and dark wood, varying in width and of a wavy character. 
 It can give very good sky or water effects especially when combined with a moon/sun or a cloud formation. 
 Don't forget that the sun will always appear behind  the stripy cloud, never in front of it; clouds can do either but probably look best with the stripes as a background. 
 Certain samples of walnut can be similarly used giving a rather more dramatic and somewhat stormy appearance to a design. 
  There are many stripy veneers available which can be employed to give various effects exploiting the characteristics of stripyness. 
 Olive ash, for instance, makes a good ploughed field, as does yew, especially if you can find a piece with a nice &bquo;crook&equo; grain; zebrano is useful for both water and sky; walnut often yields a rock formation; some of the &bquo;burr&equo; types (eg. walnut, ash and elm) make excellent tree foliage, if the scale is right. 
 One other quality of timber which bears on marquetry, and of which you should always be aware, is that of texture. 
 In this context, texture is the visual equivalent of the &bquo;feel&equo; of a given surface. 
 In wood this is produced by flecking (oak), ripple (mahogany), sheen (satinwood), dappling (lacewood), and even insect attack (masur birch)! 
 The main point, then, about realising an idea, is that of transformation. 
 You should always be on the lookout for the markings which can be transformed to suit your own ends. 
 For this you need to keep an open mind; don't just admire, also seek. 
 If you can spot a possibility and make it work the result can be exciting, and don't be afraid to use your sense of form, colour and originality. 
 Intuition is the name of the game. 
 In another context, Picasso once turned a bicycle saddle and some handlebars into a bull's head; transformation through the eye of a genius! 
 Use of line 
 Designs composed of small masses of veneer forming a readable &bquo;picture&equo;, correspond roughly in looks, if not in colour, to subjects as they actually appear to the eye; they seem to be in 3D even though they are flat, and to a degree they are naturalistic. 
 There is another branch of graphics, however, in which an image is produced by the use of line rather than mass. 
 In its most basic form the technique involves merely an outline, or when it is filled in, a silhouette; but of course it can be much more elaborate than that. 
 Linear representation of solid form has always been a valid artistic technique, especially in drawing (as distinct from painting), and it can be used in marquetry work also provided the nature of the material (ie. wood) is not ignored. 
 You have to remember that wood is really quite a coarse material (compared to fine metals, for instance) and it is also stronger along the grain than across it. 
 This means that with wood veneer you cannot achieve very fine lines in a design but with care and good planning some quite delicate effects can be obtained (fig. 3). 
 To make this design you will need three veneers of quite distinct tonal contrast; call them dark (A), medium (B) and light (C). 
 First, paste a tracing of the complete outline on to &bquo;A&equo; and tape this piece on top of &bquo;C&equo;, then cut out the centre of the motif and edge-glue the portion obtained from &bquo;C&equo; into place. 
 Next, tape &bquo;A&equo; into position on top of &bquo;B&equo; and cut round the profile. 
 The resulting shape is finally inserted into its background and the design mounted and finished as required. 
 A more emphatic outline can be achieved by making a second cut round the outside of the first outline. 
 This involves choosing a further veneer (D), and when you do, keep an eye on maintaining a good contrast between the two linear shapes produced. 
 For making up you will have to first paste the motif on to &bquo;A&equo;, as before, then cut in &bquo;C&equo;. 
 Proceed by taping this assembly on top of &bquo;D&equo; and cutting round the original outline. 
 Finally, after taping &bquo;D&equo;, together with its insert, on to &bquo;C&equo;, saw round a new outline, keeping the cut a millimetre or two outside the original shape. 
 Before we leave this topic, may I repeat the caution with regard to grain direction. 
 When pasting your template on the piece of veneer selected for the outline &mdash; usually a dark wood &mdash; try to arrange for the thinnest parts of the design to run along the grain. 
 The line and infill technique imparts to the work a certain quality not unlike that of a woodcut or sometimes even stained glass and the effect can be most attractive. 
 It can often be enhanced by introducing some of the techniques discussed under &bquo;grain markings&equo; above. 
 Flat patterns 
 In the past, some purists have said that all surface decoration applied to designed objects &mdash; all ornament, in other words &mdash; must be based on motifs which look flat, ie. they must not be drawn with a third dimension: you are allowed to make a pattern out of squares, so to speak, but not cubes. 
 They also insisted that design must be formalised, that is, made symmetrical and rigid rather than natural. 
 Neither of these extreme dogma is applied rigorously today, but it is certainly still accepted that 2-D form makes good pattern. 
 Historically, highly formalised patterns in wood, especially those of a purely geometric kind, fall into the category of parquetry which, though allied to marquetry, is not quite an identical craft, often requiring different techniques. 
 Nevertheless, some flat pattern work can be fairly treated as marquetry, most often based on natural forms. 
 It can vary from single units to repeats and form borders to all-over effects. 
 Though it does not, in general, exemplify, the uniqueness of marquetry (achieved by using the wood grain as the source of the visual effects) it can be intriguing in spite of what I implied earlier about the limitations of the silhouette as a design form. 
 Where problems do arise over cutting out narrow strips &mdash; which we have met before &mdash; it is sometimes best to cut in the background piecemeal, gluing in each subsection of background separately as you go along. 
 For the roundel pattern (fig. 2), a cutting sequence is suggested. 
 First cut in all &bquo;A's&equo;, then edge-glue them in place. 
 Next, tape a further background piece to the back of the assembly and cut out all the &bquo;B's&equo;. 
 Glue them into place also, and so on. 
 It is best to select a fairly dark, fine-grain veneer for the background since it is then less likely overall to read as a number of different pieces. 
 Counter-change patterns &mdash; essentially 2-D in nature &mdash; can be most effective (fig. 2). 
 They can be cut in two separate operations or, if three alternating veneers are taped together, the top one bearing the pattern, both halves of the design can be cut in one operation. 
 The figure produced from &bquo;A&equo; fits into the ground &bquo;B&equo;; the figure from &bquo;B&equo; fits into ground &bquo;C&equo;. 
 One half has then to be turned over before the two halves are trimmed and married up.   
 Roundel and counter-change patterns (fig. 2 left) and line patterns (fig. 3 below) 
 Signed by its maker inside (right), its twin was in the Woodworker Show last year 
 Clockmaking 
 The fortunes of time 
 Bill Watts, whose clocks achieve the highest levels of craftsmanship, was recently commissioned to produce a clock to replace one built in the 1760s. 
 He is now critical of the British clockmaking industry, but hopes that with the help of a German movement, his new clock will survive longer than the original. 
 It was in September 1990 that The Royal London Hospital, Whitechapel, celebrated its 250th anniversary of continuous service to the community. 
 The highlight of the anniversary ceremonies was the visit of H.M. The Queen to bestow the Royal Charter. 
 An early governor of the newly founded hospital was John Ellicott, who became  chairman of the House Committee (the governing body of the hospital), in 1757. 
 The records show that he presented a clock of his own making to the hospital circa 1760, which was in continuous use until the night of 10&ndash;11 January 1978, when it was stolen. 
 Despite a substantial reward being offered, it was never recovered. 
 John Ellicott was born in 1706, the son of a clockmaker, in the parish of All Hallows, London Wall. 
 At the age of 22 he set up shop in Sweeting's Alley, which was near the Royal Exchange. 
 He had a distinguished career as a clockmaker with several original inventions to his credit. 
 one of these was  the compensation pendulum, in which brass and steel are used to move freely and compensate for different co-efficients of expansion. 
 Alas, it was said to have been of not much practical value. 
 He was elected a fellow of the Royal Society in 1738, having been proposed by Sir Hans Sloane and other eminent scientists of the day. 
 He read several papers before the society and his published works include observations on the laws of electricity, the height to which rockets can be fired and the influence which two pendulum clocks, in close proximity, were seen to have on each other. 
 His intellect and range of interests were wide and profound. 
 He died in 1772. 
 The Anniversary Organising Committee had felt that a clock should be commissioned to replace the one which had been stolen, and perhaps because I have for some years specialised in the reproduction of historic clocks, my name was one of those considered. 
 There were some practical considerations to be taken into account before the work could actually commence however. 
 Although several quite good photographs of the original clock existed these were in plan elevation only and there was no indication of the dimensions, particularly the depth. 
 The photographs also indicated that the original had two trains (going and striking) and indeed there were some interesting notes prepared by a Dr Byrom who was an enthusiastic amateur clock repairer, and who overhauled the clock in 1970, but these were couched in very general terms. 
 At about the time the new clock was commissioned, I became seriously ill with a heart condition, and it proved not possible to undertake the extensive research required to faithfully replicate the old clock. 
 Also there were doubts as to whether the panelling in the proposed new location was strong enough to take the weight of the new clock and its &bquo;sculptured&equo; bracket. 
 Accordingly it was agreed that the free-standing clock should be built very similar to the one John Ellicott made in 1740, and featured on p. 288 in the standard reference work by Cescinsky &amp; Webster, English Domestic Clocks . 
 The choice of movement proved a problem. 
 My longcase clocks are entirely handcrafted, with brass and dial work, engraving, silvering, hand piercing and bluing, etc.&hellip; undertaken in association with Steve Kelly, the renowned Exeter clockmaker &mdash; who has been practising for more than 65 years &mdash; and other craft specialists. 
 My bracket clocks however usually incorporate movements from Kieninger of Germany. 
 It was felt that the new clock should have a British movement for the sake of authenticity and because of its historic associations. 
 I can speak with feeling about the frustrations I experienced trying to obtain a suitable movement here. 
 I came to the conclusion that there was quite a bit of room in the psyche of the British clockmaking establishment for a little humility. 
 One manufacturer declined absolutely to supply other than his own complete clocks and another quoted &pound;3000.00 plus extras and VAT, which was about twice the budget for the entire project! 
 It is worth spending a little time to ponder the significance of this. 
 There was a time when British clocks were supreme throughout the world. 
 The motion-work was at the very apogee of clockmaking technology and the case-work enjoyed a world wide reputation for quality of design and good taste, all at very competitive pricing. 
 We really were world leaders in all respects. 
 How things have altered! 
 Thank goodness neither Keininger nor The Londsdale Clock Co. of Swaffham, their agents, were guilty of the luxury of being rude to their customer. 
 The movement cost less than 10 per cent of the price quoted by the British firm and this included all import duties and delivery charges, and VAT. 
 Just in case the specification might considered inferior at this price, it includes as standard an eight day, three train movement with triple chimes, (St Michael, Westminster and Whittington) all on a peal of perfectly-tuned bells. 
 These are automatically silenced at night and may be silenced manually at any time by operating levers which are neatly and unobtrusively located on the hand-crafted dial. 
 I might mention that I have been using these movements since the commencement of my business in 1983, with outstanding performance both as to accuracy and reliability. 
 It is sad to reflect that this arguably more comprehensive specification is simply not available from any UK manufacturer at anywhere remotely near the price, yet there are several rival firms in Germany with this capability. 
 The cherub spandrels are similar to the Cescinsky &amp; Webster classification No.4 and are hand cast by the lost wax process, fettled and polished. 
 The engraving is also by hand on brass, filled with black wax, silvered and shellaced. 
 All the other brass fittings, supplied by Chas. 
 Greville at Farnham Surrey, are to the highest standard. 
 The case is of highly figured solid English walnut, and Macassar ebony. 
 Finish is by french polish applied with a hand rubber and then covered with a protective coating of carnauba wax polish. 
 All the small mouldings were shaped by an overhead router either against a fence or with a pin (for the so-called great arch). 
 Total construction time was about 200 hours including installation of the movement and assembly of the various parts. 
 The clock has been timed to a consistent gain of less than half a minute per week during several months of sustained testing. 
 Special attention has been paid to security. 
 The clock is attached to the table on which it will stand by means of a padlock and plastic covered cable, which is located with the clock and out of sight. 
 Whilst a prospective burglar might fumbling with the clock and wondering why it won't lift, his movement will have activated the pressure pad which controls an audible alarm giving out 85dbs. 
 This alarm may only be de-activated by a key holder, and the noise alone is such that the prospective thief will hopefully abandon his anti-social ideas. 
 It is an interesting thought that had John Ellicott not donated one of his magnificent clocks to mark his benefaction, the greed of a contract thief nearly 250 years later would have never taken place &mdash; and my humble tribute to this great gentleman, philanthropist and scientist, would never have been built. 
 Happily, the work of these &bquo;old timers&equo; still inspires and encourages us to this very day. 
 With our vastly improved materials, adhesives and security technology, perhaps the new clock has an even greater chance of survival? 
 I do hope so. 
 The Woodworker Show this coming October, (17&ndash;20) includes a clock-making competition, and Bill Watts, along with Martin Bulger, will be judging entries. 
 Details of this and all the other competitions at the Woodworker Show, from Argus Specialist Exhibitions, Argus House, Boundary Way, Hemel Hempstead HP2 7ST. 
 &bull; Clock kits, without movements, plans, and mouldings are available from Park Clocks, 13 Oakfield Court, Damory Street, Blandford Forum, Dorset DT11 7HF. 
 &bull; The plans of the bracker clock accompany this article, are reproduced by the kind permission of Charles Greville &amp; Co. 
 Ltd, Willey Mill House, Alton Road, Farnham, Surrey GU10 5EL, from whom plans and movements are available, cost &pound;3.50.  
 Market Review Carving through the confusion 
 Over the centuries carving has built up a range of chisels and gouges, the names of which are as esoteric as the craft itself 
 The full range of carving tools on display at The Woodworks 
 A Cogelow tool (above) and the sweep of shapes to be found in the Ashley Iles catalogue 
 There are over a thousand different shapes of carving chisels and gouges. 
 It is hardly surprising that there is confusion over the names and numbers which describe the shapes. 
 Not only does the cutting edge vary in shape, there are a variety of patterns of shanks; the metal behind the blade. 
 Just to add to the confusion there are also different types of handles. 
 However it is not necessary to own all the available shapes, some have very specific uses which may only needed on rare occasions. 
 When a special tool has been developed, it is usually because nothing else will do the job as well. 
 During the nineteenth century a numbering system was standardised in Britain. 
 The last two digits of a maker's reference number describe the shape of the shank and the cross section, the width is always given separately. 
 The cross section curve of a gouge is known as its sweep. 
 Gouges and chisels can be straight, curved, bent or back bent along the length of the tool shank. 
 Different lengths of tools are made: full length tools for professionals, shorter medium length tools for hobby carving. 
 Lino and block cutting tools, are the smallest style of carving chisels, V-tools and gouges, developed for cutting printing blocks. 
 The blades are about 2in long, the small rounded handles designed to be held in palm of hand. 
 At the other end of the scale are the alongee gouges; large heavy gouges, for removing large amounts of wood on big items such as sculptures. 
 Alongees are now only made by a few manufacturers. 
 There is some controversy over the finish on carving chisels and gouges. 
 The is no doubt that polished tools look better, but some say that the extra expense is unnecessary. 
 The only areas which must be polished being the areas in contact with the wood; the bevels. 
 A smooth surface moves more easily through the fibres. 
 Some manufacturers like to leave the tempering colour on the tools, as an indication that this operation has been carried out properly. 
 The body of the tool being black, the ground areas, the bevels, and gouge channels should be a light straw colour in this case. 
 Carving chisels 
 Carving chisels are similar to ordinary carpentry chisels, in that the edge of the blade is flat and square across the shank. 
 Carvers' chisels differ from carpentry  chisels in the way they are sharpened. 
 Carvers put a bevel on both sides of the edge. 
 Some carvers also like to put curved bevels on their tools. 
 Skew or corner chisels have the edge angled out of square to the shank. 
 Fishtail carving tools, chisels, skew chisels, and gouges, taper from the cutting edge down to a thin shank. 
 They are useful for getting into awkward spaces, avoiding damage to the work around them. 
 Carving gouges 
 Gouges vary in the amount of curve or sweep on the cutting edge and the form of the shank of the tool. 
 The sweep of the cutting edge and the shape is usually defined by a number, which was standardised in Britain in the nineteenth century. 
 Tools from the rest of Europe do not follow the same numbering system. 
 Straight gouges are numbered 3 to 11, a 3 sweep is a very shallow curve, an 11 has a very deep flute. 
 Curved or bent gouges are numbered 12 to 20. 
 The sweep of the straight number 3, is the same as on the curved number 12, the spoon bit number 24, and the back bent spoon bit number 33. 
 Cogelow gouges don't conform to any of the standard shapes or numbering systems. 
 Parting and V-tools 
 V-tools or parting tools are usually available in three angles 45&deg;, 60&deg; and 90&deg;. 
 In sizes between 1.5mm and 15mm. 
 All measurements are taken inside the angle. 
 Suppliers of carving tools 
 An Architectural Woodworkers carver (below) and a host of tools (above right) from R.A. Salman's Dictionary of Woodworking Tools  published by Unwin Hyman 
 Carving Bearing up to reality 
 Teddy Bears may not be the most active models, but their nuances of age make reproduction in wood a challenge, as George Brownlee discovered when he carved this award-winning piece. 
 Eva Schweitzer reports 
 The original Teddy, with the lime and mahogany taking shape 
 Almost every child, I imagine, has at some time owned a much-loved Teddy Bear. 
 Some of these cuddly toys, like the one featured in this project, had arrived in someone's childhood as a gift from Grandma, and been loved to bits by its owner. 
 By the time the owner had children of her own, it had become all too clear that Teddy was not likely to survive the rigours of another nursery. 
 Luckily, her husband found George Brownlee to immortalize the middle-aged bear in wood. 
 This was not the first time that George had attempted a figurative animal sculpture. 
 Once again, his work radiates a sense of fun and natural affinity with the subject and the medium; in this case creamy, beige lime for the Teddy Bear and rich, dark mahogany for the cushion. 
 George carefully positioned the old bear crossed and in a delightfully laid-back, almost human repose. 
 The chose pose proved interesting, and suited the size of the timber, yielding very little waste. 
 George's favourite model, his daughter Samantha, had turned model-maker for this project and fashioned a velvet beanbag to help him achieve a realistic finish and to portray the Teddy as an &bquo;old bear with modern leanings.&equo; 
 Calculations were taken from the original bear to produce drawings, reducing it from three to two dimensions. 
 At the same time, George measured the beanbag model. 
 From the drawings, he sketched various elevations, then cut them out and transferred them on to the blocks of wood to be bandsawn. 
 The beauty of it is that you can easily move them around on the wood. 
 Generally, the grain runs the length of a carving, but in some cases, it may be necessary to slightly alter the angle of the drawing to get the best effect by using the end-grain. 
 Medium-sized gouges were used to start the basic roughing out of the shape, with references made to the life model to get the proportions absolutely right. 
 Any form of measurement to obtain these calculations is helpful; ie. caliphers taken from the original. 
 Even at this early stage, the basic shape began to emerge. 
 Try and resist the temptation to concentrate on one area. 
 You do not want to get trapped by detail. 
 Start general rounding off, and at this stage, some form of modelling could be tackled; working on deep folds, light creases and facial features. 
 Carefully observing the model, George concentrated on the tiny creases in the ears, on arms and legs. 
 the paws; simulating the stitching and seams, merely suggesting the heavy black braid that defines the nose of the original bear. 
 All the details that help breathe life into the little fellow can be marked with a pencil or Biro. 
 Beware of marker pens, as their ink tends to seep deeply into the wood. 
 A tip from George: for darker wood like mahogany and walnut, it pays to use a white Cont&eacute; pencil. 
 Features, like seams and folds, should be marked for visual effects before taking up the chisel, as inaccuracies cannot be corrected once a deep gouge or V-tool has been used. 
 At this particular point, when marking details, it is sometimes a good idea to use a very small U-gouge. 
 That way, the same effect can be achieved without taking it to the full depth. 
 The teddy, judging by the state of one foot, had obviously been excessively loved: his cloth fur had been hugged and stroked away in many places. 
 Therefore, there was no need to apply a tooled finish all over. 
 Instead, George concentrated his efforts on the few remaining furry areas on an otherwise bare bear. 
 He used small gouges to carve little tufts of fur with long, controlled strokes, following the marked lines. 
 George used a small V-tool when it was safe. 
 However, V-tools are very useful for creating the ins and out of a body. 
 The sparseness of fur did have one advantage &mdash; no mass of hairs to obscure the charming pose. 
 The client did not want the teddy to have glass eyes. 
 Therefore, George carved them into the wood in relief. 
 It was possible with only a small selection of gouges to find the appropriate one to fit the circumference of the eyeball, using the gouge on both sides. 
 Remember, eyes are marble-shaped, not flat discs! 
 Aim for a dome shape. 
 Once the width between the eyes had been  determined and marked out, George worked on both eyes; that way, neither eye ends up larger than the other. 
 The completed bear, pressed into the beanbag model, gave a clue to the depth required to be cut from the block of timber for the beanbag. 
 To shape the generous indentation, the wood was taken out gradually with a deep oval gouge. 
 References were frequently made to the original model to faithfully simulate the soft effect of the creases. 
 It is an essential part of the composition and, as George put it: &bquo;You don't want to end up with a cushion that resembles a lump of putty.&equo; 
 For sanding George uses cloth-backed sandpaper, because it is so much stronger. 
 He worked through various grades, finishing with a very fine flour paper. 
 Only the beanbag was stained. 
 One good, strong application of a spirit-based mahogany strain was sufficient. 
 To bring out the natural colour of the teddy and the richness of the mahogany cushion, he heavily burnished boiled linseed oil into the wood with a cloth in combination with a button polish. 
 This achieves a delicate sheen rather than a strong lustre. 
 A day later, a second coat was applied.  
 Such is the wear of a Teddy that a textured finish is unnecessary, and most of it is sanded to look warn 
 Notice how the grain goes up the body of Teddy, and his elbow nestles in the cushion 
 Testing the Cogelow Angle 
 Ray Gonzalez tests the new range of Cogelow carving tools from Henry Taylor, and offers some advice on bevel grinding 
 Though they can be used with a mallet, the Cogelow tools invite slicing and paring, and are especially useful for ornamental work 
 The opportunity to review the Cogelow tools was welcomed for several reasons. 
 Firstly, I have a love off good tools of all types, and a passion for innovations. 
 In addition, I have a particular axe to grind, as I have been a professional woodcarver for 25 years in both ornamental and sculptural disciplines so woodcarving tools hold a special interest. 
 The choice of brands of woodcarving tools is hardly wanting, both in the home market or abroad, but the range offered by each manufacturer tends to be same-ish, though prices and quality vary. 
 I therefore warmly welcome any attempt to expand the scope of existing tools and/or present entirely new concepts. 
 The question is, is the Cogelow skew a new concept? 
 Not entirely. 
 The skew chisel is well known, and though not manufactured in recent times, the skew gouge has been utilised as a modification. 
 The baroque carvers in Germany and France made extensive use of this type of gouge in the drapery of their ecclesiastical figures, enabling them to make difficult pipes and folds against the grain, whilst keeping a smooth flow. 
 Gothic carvers also ground normal gouges to skew shapes in order that they may execute mitres where two deeply curved sections meet. 
 Woodcarvers through the ages have adapted, and even mutilated standard tools to suit their needs. 
 Even the bullnose chisel of the stonecarver found its reflection in the woodcarver's kit, though no manufacturer to my knowledge has ever marketed this variation. 
 An exploration of an old craftman's tool-roll would reveal some strangely shaped tools, probably made for some one-off job. 
 Though many adaptations have obvious applications, there are those only their creators could accurately explain. 
 Sometimes a tool was ground after a breakage or similar accident, and the resulting shape would allow a usage not previously possible, and may even have become a treasured &bquo;special&equo;. 
 In this way I have encountered skews of various angles. 
 The Cogelow kit is a range of 17 skews. 
 Sixteen gouges and one bent skew chisel. 
 The kit comes complete in its cardboard case, which is given a fabric texture and embellished with gold lettering. 
 The tools are kept separate with a card tool rack which is integral to the base. 
 The set that I am working with has the standard black finish, but the all-bright is available. 
 The largest tools are 200mm long, and the smallest are 120mm long. 
 All the handles are turned and are 45mm long, and fitted with brass ferrules. 
 Some manufacturers supply larger handles with larger tools, but I have not found any discomfort with this aspect of the design. 
 According to the manufacturer, the bevels on the Cogelow tools need only honing to be perfect. 
 In my experience, there is only one manufacturer (not British) that produces tools ready for use for professional ornamental carving. 
 Even in this case, some work needs doing to the back of the bevel to bring them to optimum usefulness. 
 The most pointed criticism is that the angle of the bevel is not rounded off or taken back far enough, so producing an elbow that hinders the smooth entry and flow of cut. 
 This is especially pronounced in the front bent versions where this elbow acts as a lever, &bquo;kicking&equo; the cutting edge off the surface, and forcing a more awkward cutting position. 
 Sometimes the bevel elbow is so crucial, it makes certain cuts impossible. 
 With the Cogelow tools, I found it necessary to grind new bevels completely for these tools to be useful for intricate ornament. 
 The primary bevels were ground back and feathered away on the grindstone, taking care not to overheat and destroy the temper. 
 Then the secondary bevel was carefully cut with a fine silicone coated felt wheel. 
 This can also be done on a medium grit oilstone. 
 The final honing was carried out in the usual fashion, using slipstones and strop. 
 The temper of the tools seems good, just soft enough to give a razor-edge, but not too soft that they bend against hard grain. 
 So, no problem with temper. 
 Some carvers prefer the thicker bevels for mallet work, but as these tools lend themselves more to  paring and slicing, the finer edges appear imperative. 
 As for the curves in this selection, the C13 and C14 were not the same, and therefore the work that was possible with one tool could not be repeated on its mirror image with its counterpart. 
 This particular tool I would find little use for. 
 The more open back bends have limited use, but this could be improved. 
 All the front bends have varying uses, and the smaller tools C1, C2, C5, C6, C7 &amp; C8 have good versatility. 
 The bent skew was a pleasant little tool, with wide applications, and a usefulness beyond its humble appearance. 
 It can be used as an incisor; a grounder; skew chisel; it can do some modelling, cleaning corners, curved &bquo;V&equo; cuts that twist and turn, has the tight size and bend to enable good control regardless of grain, and gets the blue ribbon. 
 The biggest advantage of this type of tool lies paradoxically in its strength. 
 Because of the skew, the cuts are certainly more fluent. 
 However, this means that every curve requires two tools, a left and a right, therefore doubling the number of tools necessary. 
 This is why the idea of grinding a good gouge to a skew shape was never very popular. 
 The conventional design, though not as fluent is more versatile. 
 For ornamental carving and small sculpture, there could be a wider range of smaller tools 10mm and under. 
 The back bends could be more versatile if they had flatter carvers, with more radius in the stem. 
 At &pound;211.20 + VAT for the full kit of 17 tools, each tool averages &pound;12.42, and can be purchased individually. 
 Smaller sets of seven and 10 are also available. 
 I would advise the interested enthusiast to purchase the smaller set that includes the skew chisel C17, and try those before going the whole hog. 
 For some professionals price would be a secondary consideration. 
 Personally, I would be prepared to pay much m ore for a tool that would do the job required. 
 There seems to be a dearth of good small tools across the board. 
 The old Herring and Addis tools were made with a finesse and temper that modern tools do not approach, let alone equal. 
 With modern technology, I cannot accept that this standard is out of reach. 
 The answer must be economics. 
 Though we do not form the bulk of the market, I would like to speak for all discerning professionals and ask for a &bquo;top end of the market&equo; service, where quality comes first. 
 Perhaps the will is not there. 
 The market is. 
 &bull; The Cogelow range of chisels were created by the American carver, Fred Cogelow and are now being made in Britain by Henry Taylor Tools at The Forge, Lowther Road, Sheffield S6 2DR, (0742) 336978. 
 The chisels are sold in standard black finish, or all-bright, in sets of seven, 10 and 17.  
 Competition Results 
 Workshop Creations 
 Since introducing our workshop carving competition in February we have waited expectantly to see the carved tools, sent to the competition sponsors &mdash; The Woodworks &mdash; for judging. 
 Now we can announce that Dennis Hurst of Wigan is the winner of the Koch clamping system, with his smoothing plane   
 Philip Wooler's brace and bit won the &pound;139 worth of Koch honing system for second prize. 
 Michael McLaughlin's block plane (middle left) and A. Wright's smoothing plane (near left). 
 For humour there was Ian Ford's rat tool, and below it Lee Dickenson's Kirchen carver 
 Dennis Hurst's smoothing plane wins the Koch carving clamp 
 Winner Dennis Hurst of Wigan Second Philip Wooller of North Allerton Third Alan Toplin of Basingstoke WE WOULD like to thank our sponsors, The Woodworks, for donating the prizes for this competition. 
 Their range of carving and turning products can be found at The Field, Shipley, Heanor, Derby DE7 7JJ, (0773) 719842. 
 Tool extremes: Richard Meighan's gouge and Alan Toplin's Bosch drill which won third prize, and &pound;100 of Kirchen carving tools 
 The craft of cabinetmaking 
 Board Games 
 David Savage explains how to redesign a workshop with cardboard templates, noting the importance of machine table height, and discusses second-hand machinery 
 Well, I have been and gone and done it this time. 
 It's all very well putting in applications for the bank to loan you large sums of money, but it is quite another thing to have them accepted. 
 I am sure some of the guys in my workshop think I am off my trolley. 
 It wasn't but a few months ago that I was telling them how bad everything was, how we had to keep our spending down to new lower budgets because if we didn't the next cuts we would have to make would be human ones. 
 Cuts in either wages or staff. 
 Now I am twittering on about buying a new workshop, equipping it with this or that kind of planer/thicknesser, getting this or that panel saw. 
 It must be confusing and I have no answer to the criticism, except to blame the clearly short-sighted attitude on management. 
 Planning out a new workshop is always fun. 
 I suppose I have had three or four cracks at it now at different times of my life and in different circumstances and every time I have got it wrong. 
 It seems that the Third Law of Aerodynamics is especially at work in this case. 
 (The Third Law of Aerodynamics states quite clearly that what ever you do you are knackered). 
 Incidentally I got that information on the third law from a very reliable source. 
 Frank was a retired boffin I think from British Aerospace. 
 He came here five or six years ago on one of our short courses to learn veneering. 
 In retirement he had set himself the task of making a replica Tomkin long-case clock. 
 The whole thing: movement, hands, face, case and all. 
 He sent me a photograph of it recently. 
 He had managed to complete what was a major undertaking and the thing is, he had made it absolutely superbly. 
 Frank, if you read this, you should share this project with the Woodworker . 
 However, I digress. 
 When you are laying out a new workshop you can play a particularly entertaining board game. 
 First you need a scale floor plan of your workshop drawn out on graph paper marking where all the doors and windows are, and, if they are already fixed, where all the electrical points and outlets are. 
 The next stage is to go to the manufacturers of the machines you thinking of installing and get the plan dimensions of their products. 
 You then make little card templates of each machine in the same scale as your floor plan, then go and look for any other large objects that you might have to install &mdash; your bench area, your timber storage area and a storage area for board material. 
 You measure those up and make little templates to scale to represent them. 
 You are now equipped to play the game: what is the ideal position for each of these machines allowing for you, the craftsman, to work around them and allowing for a board of a chosen dimension to go across that production set-up? 
 The key to it is choosing the problem correctly. 
 Are you handling 8x4ft sheets of MDF or are you handling dirty great 12ft boards of ash or, like our friends the chair-makers in Harland, are your components hardly ever longer than 24in. 
 Given a large enough supply of machine catalogues and enough flexibility of mind to give yourself different problems, an inventive woodworker could spend the entire winter playing this game. 
 Think of it as the woodworker's equivalent to Dungeons and Dragons. 
 There are, of course, several traps. 
 pitfalls and just general cock-ups that you can make. 
 I will tell you about one or two just to get you going but it would be unsporting to warn you about everything.  
 You see, when you are working in plan like this it is difficult to bear in mind that machine table heights can work in your favour and they can also work against you. 
 For example, if you have the situation where you want to put two occasionally-used machines quite close to one another, it may be to your advantage that their heights are exactly the same so the job can run across both tables. 
 The converse of this can apply if your table heights are at different levels. 
 Most bandsaws, for example, have a table considerably above the common machine table height which may enable you to cast long jobs above other machines. 
 Most planer-thicknessers have a thicknessing table below common machine height, so position your thicknesser very carefully. 
 For instance, we know in our workshop if you want to plane and thickness timber for a solid wood dining table that is longer than 10 feet, we have got to do it somewhere else. 
 When it comes to choosing which machine to buy I would suspect that our requirements would be rather different from your own. 
 This a busy commercial workshop. 
 Each machine is probably used by half a dozen different people every day. 
 Some of them may be less careful with it than others so we need machines that can take a battering. 
 Not, I hope, that ny of my staff or students would batter any of my old ladies but my machines have to be very solid and reliable. 
 A workshop with one machinist who carefully adjusts and sets the machine up and leaves it that way at the end of the job is not necessarily going to need the heaviest equipment. 
 I know it is a terribly sexist remark but I do think of the machines in our first workshop as old ladies. 
 Over the years I have had all sorts of lighter weight machines and I have gradually replaced them with either Wadkin or Robinson versions. 
 The golden period of manufacture seems to me to have been in the late 1950s and early 1960s when both manufacturers were making superbly engineered, fully adjustable machines. 
 If properly serviced and looked after they would last certainly one, possibly two, maybe three life-times. 
 My bandsaw is a classic made in about 1960 by Robinsons. 
 It is 36in model with all the trimmings It runs superbly, absolutely no vibration. 
 Like all elderly ladies, however, she needs polite attention. 
 Her guides need to be adjusted regularly, a spot of oil here and there and a spot of grease here and there periodically. 
 Look after her like this and she is a sweet tempered old soul. 
 Apart from Mrs Robinson, the bandsaw, most of my other machines are made by Wadkin. 
 I must admit to liking Wadkin. 
 They are horribly expensive but to my mind they are the best. 
 I will give you an example of why I have come to that conclusion. 
 A few years ago I wanted to invest in a new spindle moulder. 
 My aim was to buy a tool that would last out my working life. 
 I bought a new Wilson FM with a sliding table for tenoning, a reversing switch, roll-on and roll-off tables, all the whistles and bells that would make it a really useful machine. 
 I bought that because I suppose it seemed to offer nearly everything the equivalent Wadkin moulder had to offer but at &pound;2&ndash;300 less. 
 We have had that moulder now for three or four years and it has done a lot of work. 
 Nobody in the workshop has a good to say for that machine. 
 The adjustment to the rise and fall is difficult because it is always sticky, the wood chips tend to collect on the travel of the sliding table making the action very bumpy, the sliding table is always out of adjustment for one reason or another. 
 It is a heavy serviceable machine and I am not really knocking Wilson because in another situation it would probably do a very good job but for us it is just not a very pleasant tool to be with. 
 As a consequence I really wish that I had spent the extra money and bought a slightly better machine. 
 However, I must confess I don't think I will buy new machines again. 
 Not even Wadkin. 
 Where possible I will buy really good quality second-hand machines from a reliable dealer. 
 I have tried buying second-hand machines at auction with some mixed success. 
 We got our Wadkin PK dimension saw from an auction five or six years ago. 
 It was the closure of a good, old style joinery firm and there were some very good machines to be had. 
 I had to go down there for the preview and then go down and bid. 
 I then had to send Malcolm and Neil down with a rented truck to pick the machine up. 
 They had to hassle for the best part of the day to get the machine out of the factory because, like most of these auctions, the auctioneers wanted the place cleared immediately. 
 We then had to drive the machine back and unload the rented van. 
 Now that is no joke because one of these big old saws can weigh the best part of half a ton. 
 So we had to rent a forklift truck from somewhere, then manhandle the saw into the workshop. 
 I don't think anybody enjoyed that day's work. 
 It was then the best part of a week's work on Malcolm's part to get that saw running sweetly. 
 It has gone very sweetly ever since but that was a good deal of production time that was lost that cost me a lost more money than I had anticipated. 
 Certainly if I had been doing all the restoration work myself it wouldn't have cost me so much because I am the cheapest worker in this outfit. 
 So now if I need a &bquo;new&equo; piece of equipment I go to a reputable second-hand wood working machinery dealer. 
 Next month I will take you to meet Brian Stacey of Daltons in Nottingham.  
 Space around a bandsaw is vital 
 Doubtless the door helps for extra length over the planer 
 Unfortunately, for boards over 10ft long, David has to thickness elsewhere 
 Three dimensions of chair design 
 In the first of three articles that follow the progress of a chair making project, Steve Goulden explains how he designs a chair, looking for robustness, comfort and elegance 
 As an everyday piece of furniture, the dining chair is certainly the most frequently used. 
 As a design project it is perhaps the most exploited. 
 But when one considers the requirements of such a piece of furniture, they are really quite simple: it must be robust, comfortable and elegant. 
 Whereas it is simple to make a robust chair, combining these three characteristics and yet producing a chair which has individual character can be a real challenge. 
 I would imagine that most chairs made by craftsmen are of the spindled variety, from the Windsor to the Shaker and many shades in between. 
 Although no one will doubt their possibilities for elegance and robustness, sitting on a solid wood seat can test the limits of comfort after quite a short time and woven seats are little better. 
 In addition, these styles do not fit well with walnut dining room tables and candlelit evenings. 
 When such dinners can last for hours, a well-upholstered seat is essential. 
 My own taste for formal furniture tends to fall between the &bquo;Arts and Crafts&equo; and &bquo;Modern&equo;, rather than &bquo;Repro&equo;, and yet looking at modern designs you see in exhibitions, I doubt their &bquo;long-sit&equo; comfort and, personally, I feel that the limits of acceptable elegance are frequently passed by many, in the cause of being different. 
 The demand for elegance carries with it the requirement to fit in with existing furniture and although talking points can be useful, a table surrounded by a set of such chairs could be a positive eyesore. 
 Talking to professional designer-producers confirms this point: people will stop to admire such designs, but many more &bquo;traditional&equo; products are purchased. 
 So we can put some limits on the project: the chairs must be upholstered; modern in the simplicity of their lines but not &bquo;Cubist&equo; for want of a better term; easy on the eye and bottom; they should fit in with other existing furniture; and naturally should be of strong construction so that they will be heirloom quality. 
 Starting with a blank sheet of paper is perhaps easy for some, but for myself, I can neither draw accurately nor can I imagine  without a picture or actual model to start from. 
 Consequently I find myself spending a lot of time looking at chairs in museums, shops, exhibitions and other peoples' houses. 
 The variety is enormous but many can be ruled out in not satisfying all the requirements. 
 After a long study, I have concluded that I like chairs which have slightly curved rear legs, flairing outwards slightly from the seat both up and down. 
 A straight back, sloping downwards, seems more comfortable than a curved back. 
 Much variety is possible for &bquo;filling&equo; that back; stick backs and ladderbacks cover many possibilities. 
 However, to satisfy the requirements of comfort, the back should curve (in the horizontal plane) to accommodate the back of the rib cage, and there should be no large obstruction to the positioning of the backbone. 
 These two points provide objections to the ladderback design; with sitters of different heights, the cross bars can hit prominent vertebrae. 
 The thought of producing many curved back pieces is a bit off-putting. 
 With the stickback style, however, it is only necessary to curve the top piece; the sticks would then position themselves into a curve, even from a straight base. 
 This base can be the rear seat rail, or another rail fitted above the seat, but if so, no more than 2in above the seat or it would also need to be curved to avoid discomfort. 
 The chair looks better to me if the seat is wider at the front than at the back, but the front of the seat should only be slightly wider than the top of the back. 
 Further on the point of comfort, a seat which slopes down slightly front to back is preferable to a horizontal seat. 
 During a study of the various styles, it became apparent to me that if the back legs are set into the seat rails at an angle, this angle, together with the curvature of the rear legs and backward slope of the chair back can regulate the flair: if the legs are mounted at right angles to the rear seat rail, there would be no flair. 
 Increasing this angle increases the flair very sensitively, up to the maximum deflection of the curve of the rear leg, if it were to be (impractically!) mounted in the plane or the rear seat rail. 
 The requirement for robustness also demands that there be leg braces to create a strong rectangle around the rear seat joint, the point of maximum strain in all chairs. 
 Anyone who has had to reglue chairs will be painfully aware of this fact. 
 A crossmember between these two braces helps; people frequently put their legs back under their chair seats, and a cross brace between the front legs would be in the way. 
 The above design conclusions have profound implications for the construction details of my chair. 
 None of the joints are at right-angles. 
 The requirement for long-term robustness rules out the general use of dowels but the thought of complex, angled mortise and tenon joints is intimidating. 
 This project almost died at that point, as I should not imagine that my skills were good enough to meet the precision requirements and the time factor seemed unacceptable. 
 Fortunately, the contribution by Peter Guyett, (WW/Sept.89/p.803)  of his router jig, saved the project. 
 Considering the tenoning half of his design, I modified it so that it could quickly accommodate a different pair of blocks for each differently angled tenon. 
 The curved backpieces can be roughed out on the bandsaw, then finished on the router table, using a cutter with a bearing following a template. 
 The workpiece is held in place on the template using toggle clamps. 
 At this point, all the head-work has been done. 
 It is now necessary to decide on real angles and heights. 
 I planned to make one chair as a trial piece, and, if it looked right, to do a real run of six, using the trial pieces as &bquo;templates&equo;. 
 This requires a re-examination of such chairs as please my eye and try to come with a starting point. 
 Instead of going into all the details of this stage, which are likely to be inapplicable to other designs, as they are so dependent on personal likes and dislikes, I simply show you the design limits worked out (fig.1) and what I made. 
 In the next article, I will describe the details of the job, and in another the solutions I found to the many problems encountered on the way.  
 Fig. 1 Side and front elevations of nascent chair 
 Fig. 2 Early sketch 
 A variety of chair designs through the ages, culminating in Steve Goulden's chosen shape (below left) 
 Credence Table 
 Gothic Traces 
 For a recent commission Edward Hopkins had to match the Gothic influences of church architecture with a restricted church budget, and produced a table of contemporary simplicity 
 Initially in awe of the craftsmanship of his predecessors Edward Hopkins arrived at this relatively simple design (left and below). 
 The corner braces form the Gothic arch shape as well as keeping the whole structure rigid 
 If you ever think that your woodwork is rather good, to church. 
 Forget exhibitions and museums. 
 Ignore the glossy pages. 
 In almost any parish church there is craftsmanship of quiet excellence. 
 On some you'll find screens and pews and font-covers of such exuberance they'd more at home in a Moorish palace. 
 The carving is of a quality I do not even understand. 
 It is especially clear in figure-work. 
 Statues of saints and martyrs  sometimes just several inches high, carry enormous poise and serenity. 
 Most astounding are their faces, and their eyes. 
 Wisdon and compassion have been captured in the flick of a chisel. 
 So by now you feel your skills are barely born. 
 This is great for the soul but not so hot for business. 
 This time, business was my purpose. 
 Ahead of me was a chancel screen, a filigree of Gothic tracery. 
 To the left was a dinosaur of a stone pulpit, all arched and ornamented. 
 On the right was a gap where the credence table (side table serving an altar) had stood. 
 Beyond the screen, beyond the choir, was another altar and another gap. 
 Two fine oak tables were missing, and the space was for me to fill. 
 The church warden gave me sizes but did not ask for reproduction pieces and anyway, he only had a poor and partial photograph. 
 He wanted a design of 1991 which would sit happily with the past. 
 I sat unhappily in the empty church with two lines of thought. 
 When man's lifestyle is more natural, basic and strenuous, he glories in the ornate. 
 When, as for us, it is luxurious, busy and restless, we are refreshed by simplicity. 
 I wanted therefore to make the tables light and clean and spacious but how could I, amongst this Gothic clutter? 
 Also, the ghosts of the carvers frightened me off. 
 Most complicated jobs can be reduced to a sequence of relatively simple operations to be approached step by step. 
 This applies equally to carving, but that's still not easy and it certainly isn't fast. 
 The tables were on a fixed budget and should take a fortnight. 
 Now, however medieval my proclivities, my bills are bang up to date, so I waved a sheaf of payment slips at the ghosts of the carvers and they vanished. 
 Gothic or thin? 
 Sometimes design is a constructive method, and sometimes a process of elimination. 
 Wishing hard to avoid the carved arches, I invited all manner of alternatives and shot them down one by one as unsuitable. 
 Eventually I struck the compromise. 
 It should be possible to abstract the Gothic elements and represent them. 
 The main themes were decorated pillars, trefoils and roundels. 
 Whatever curves I specified had to be made using a bandsaw, a drum-sander, spokeshave and scraper. 
 Corners must be accessible and easy to clean up. 
 It is at this stage of the hob that the one-man band plays the best music. 
 Knowing the problems and the opportunities that your tools offer, you design maximum effect at minimum effort. 
 Nobody pays you extra to work inefficiently. 
 As part of the design to construction stage I developed the &bquo;Gothic bracket&equo;. 
 These corner braces are curved on either side. 
 The undersides link up to form an arch while the uppersides are cut to appear as pierced circles. 
 With the overall dimensions I had been given, it worked out easily that there could be three arches along the front to one at the side. 
 It is that sort of falling-together that reassures you are on the right lines. 
 The front arches are not repeated on the back because a credence table is a side table and will always be against a wall. 
 It is subordinate to the altar and although it may be decorative, it has direction towards the altar. 
 Another Gothic element is mass. 
 It is heavy and, when overdone, oppressive. 
 My Gothic brackets required legs thicker than usual to correspond to stone pillars. 
 The octagonal section allows easy mortising, and is turned in the middle. 
 Just before the cylinder is a bead. 
 This semi-circular motif is repeated on the tabletop, the top rail and underneath the bottom rail. 
 The top of the bottom rail is scooped as yet another, but much larger echo. 
 The balancing of these main curves is done on the drawing board. 
 I advise anyone to resist preconceptions. 
 Do not, for instance, think ah! yes, a bottom rail here will have to be about 4in deep. 
 Don't think at all. 
 Sketch! 
 See what looks right and then measure it. 
 So too with the curves which happen to look right circular; the centres of these arcs happen to be in obvious places. 
 This is either some magic geometry of which I know nothing or it is a happy coincidence. 
 Either way it makes you feel that you still have your wheels on the track. 
 The octagon 
 The more I work with oak, the more I know why. 
 A job like laminating these legs could hardly be more satisfying. 
 Cut strips say 2&ndash;3/4in wide to finish at 2&ndash;1/2in. 
 Plane them with newly-ground knives and thickness them, reversing them frequently to remove wood equally from both sides. 
 If they come out at just over 13/16in, three will stack up to make 2&ndash;1/2in. 
 Not all mine did, so I left them all as thick as possible and matched the thick with the thin later. 
 To glue them up, arrange your heaviest cramps with blocks and, to save time later, go through a dry run. 
 Separate the laminates (I glued six legs at a time). 
 Size both surfaces of each joint with a mix, one part PVA, one part water, liberally brushed on. 
 Be quick. 
 Then, immediately, brush one surface of each joint with a slightly stiffer mix, line them up and apply the pressure. 
 The danger is in having a film of glue dry prematurely and appear as a line. 
 The pleasure is when it doesn't. 
 The joint between your quartered oak disappear and it becomes one block. 
 Protect these wet joints from the metal of the cramps or they will stain. 
 Once dry, plane up the unfinished sides, thicknessing to a perfect square. 
 Tilt the say and slice away the corners. 
 Leave enough for one careful pass on the planer. 
 The result should be a perfect octagon. 
 The leg-frame of each table is mortise and tenoned; 5/8in on the legs except the little top rail mortise. 
 This could only be 5/8in long so  it is 1/2in wide. 
 This allows the machine-chisel to shuffle back and forth, stepping down to full depth. 
 Joints between the top rail and the bracket are 3/8in. 
 Much of this is straightforward: some of it isn't. 
 It is the brackets, of course, which slow down production. 
 The are structurally brilliant because they triangulate the frame. 
 Each table has 12 which, with six fat legs, could probably hold the roof up but it is this very rigidity that makes the construction hard. 
 There is no room for inaccuracy, no room for movement. 
 Gluing the whole lot up will be interesting enough &mdash; even arranging the cramps requires thought. 
 Persuading recalcitrant joints to co-operate is best left to a bad dream. 
 Make a full-size drawing of at least the bracket. 
 Mark on it the width of plank from which the brackets will be cut. 
 Using the drawing as a template, mark out the brackets on the plank, reversing them head to toe to save timber. 
 Allow a safe margin for sawing, and cut the blanks. 
 The next is the crucial stage of the whole operation; nothing else can correct it. 
 The brackets must end up with their two oblique edges absolutely square, and each bracket must be identical. 
 I was making 24 of these and needed a repetitive method. 
 I'm not sure that a radial-arm saw is accurate enough for this at the best of times, but, at the moment, mine rattles up and down its rails like a train in the sidings, and is definitely not fit for the job. 
 I shot the longer edge down on the planer. 
 If you need to change angle to land on the line, you take two slight passes, the first either stopping with the wood still on the back table, or starting with it already on the front table, depending which way you want to tilt. 
 The second pass will level out between the cut and the uncut points. 
 On a sliding-fence tablesaw you can square off the other edge. 
 Set a stop to ensure uniformity. 
 (You can't work from the feathery point you've just planed, so chop it off. 
 Again, be uniform, so arrange a stop from the planed edge itself).  
 The risk 
 A man with a clipboard told me that the cutting of the tenons is a dangerous practice. 
 I asked how he thought I should do it and he said buy a tenoner. 
 He was, to be fair, smiling. 
 It is dangerous (and forbidden to employees), but is you observe common-sense, stand firmly and hold the wood in same way each time, with all soft pink bits well away from the blade, you will not end up like the man in the story that the same Health and Safety Officer delighted in telling me. 
 A man was sawing and he sawed off his fingers. 
 He rushed to hospital where the doctor said &bquo;I could have sewn them back on. 
 Why didn't you bring them with you?&equo; 
 The man replied &bquo;I couldn't pick them up.&equo; 
 The curves on the brackets are carefully bandsawn and cleaned up before they are bevelled. 
 How will you bevel them? 
 Spokeshave? 
 That might work the underside, but the upperside would require a curved spokeshave, such an awkward bit of kit to use that mine stays permanently sharp. 
 &pound; 
 While the ghosts of the carvers were gently chuckling, I considered the bandsaw, the sander and the router. 
 Each one must be set up with fail-safe guides for a true and even curve. 
 Each one has inherent hazards. 
 I tried to arrange guides on the drum sander but quickly gave up. 
 My bandsaw competes with the radial-arm for clatters and bangs so the big router won with a large chamfer bit. 
 Two strips of waste wood were slowly fed over the revolving cutter and cramped to the table. 
 These pointed fingers were adjusted to be my guide and, apart from the very ends of each cut, were quite reliable. 
 These ends were cleaned up with a spokeshave and then scraped with a twist of the wrist. 
 The last careful cut on the brackets is the point at which they meet. 
 This another critical operation: a gap will be there for good. 
 I fitted the brackets in their pairs to the top rails, grinding away the point on a plate sander. 
 The dress rehearsal 
 You probably can't wait any longer. 
 It's a good enough excuse that you need to check for gaffs, but the real reason for dry-assembly is to see what this hitherto fictitious table looks like. 
 I tried not to watch as I fitted the frame together and balanced the unfinished top on it. 
 It is a delicious moment, walking away and then, with an inevitable hint of apprehension, turning round. 
 Less delicious is having to hit the thing apart again. 
 The perfect joint responds to a couple taps: any stiffer and you can be in seven sorts of trouble. 
 The dry-assembly need not be cramped tight, but the wet one obviously must. 
 Five-foot sash cramps sort out the main frame; the brackets need special treatment. 
 Take the curved pieces of waste, band-sawn off the underside, and notch them; once parallel to the leg and once to the top rail. 
 This will allow you to cramp across and pull the bracket tenons tight. 
 (You can get away with one vertical cramp per arch if you roughly joint in a horizontal bar between the blocks. 
 Another tip: cut the top-rail tenons just short of the rail depth. 
 This will allow you to block and cramp directly over the joint. 
 Put paper beneath the top block or you'll weld it to the rail). 
 Gluing up wrong is like crashing a car. 
 The memory stays with you for ever and you'll always be more careful. 
 You start the clock, paint the glue, fit the pieces, block the cramps. 
 You knock and heave, squeeze and wipe. 
 You switch on the kettle and sit on the stool. 
 Then, with an almost audible stab in the chest, you see one piece upside down or inside out. 
 Flat panic! 
 Idiocy! 
 Fury! 
 This is one more benefit of being self-employed. 
 If you weren't, you'd probably sack yourself on the spot. 
 In future you take preventative measures. 
 Lay out the components in their final formation. 
 Keep them in piles and groups. 
 Mark them (unobtrusively), but most of all, look and check the whole way through. 
 It has always been a problem: the ghosts aren't laughing now. 
 Quite often while restoring antique pieces, I come across filled-in mortises or misplaced detail &mdash; evidence that they too had ruined mornings. 
 The change 
 The top is not what I wanted. 
 My original design featured an ovolo and round moulding adding detail and delicacy to the edge, but this table was to have a tablecloth in use, and there was a fear that anything placed too close to the edge might tumble. 
 I was allowed only a small chamfer. 
 I knew, however, that the top must remain thick. 
 A simple 3/4in board is an anticlimax after all that architecture, and would ask &bquo;Why the fuss?&equo; 
 A double thickness top adds the correct weight and importance. 
 It is not, of course, 1&ndash;1/2in throughout. 
 There is no need for that. 
 Instead, in selecting the finest boards for the top, cut them over-length. 
 After jointing and gluing (be careful where you stop and start your tongues), two pieces can be cut off to finish at four and a half inches each. 
 These are mitred in to an extra front strip. 
 A thinner strip runs between them at the back. 
 This way, all the grain travels in the same direction and you do not store up shrinkage problems. 
 They must all be wide enough to take the buttons which will hold down the top. 
 Mould these pieces and glue them in place. 
 Gluing large surfaces can be difficult because the pieces tend to aquaplane and squidge out of position, so screw them first. 
 Remember to keep these screws well back, to be hidden by the frame, because although the Faithful kneeling at the altar are meant to have their minds on other things, this is professional woodwork and we don't want them peering up the legs of our fixings. 
 The wipe 
 The finish, specified by the church architect, was a mixture of oils and spirits and ammonia, to be followed by beeswax. 
 This, I'm sure, will give a fine finish in time. 
 Matt lacquer is a quicker alternative with the advantage of impermeability. 
 In the (admittedly unlikely) event of consecrated wine soaking into the oiled wood, the credence table must (is my memory of canonical law is correct), be either burnt or eaten. 
 Still; look on the bright side: they'd have to order another one. 
 The pair were delivered on a frozen Monday morning. 
 We lifted them into place, one of them nestling in precisely to the mark on the wall, left by the previous incumbent. 
 I shook hands and exchanged smiles with the vicar and church warden. 
 Then I wandered around for a while, casting wistful glances at my tables. 
 They had occupied three weeks of my life and the whole of my workshop, but here they seemed very small. 
 Surrounding them in vaulted stone and glass, wood and gorgeous cloth, were millions of man-hours of work. 
 I listened for any murmurs from the ghosts but heard none. 
 I wasn't surprised. 
 Their minds were elsewhere. 
 The church again seemed very quiet, but not completely empty. 
 The cleaning lady gave me comfort. 
 With wax and rag in hand, she eyed up her new target. 
 Like a big tabby cat she was ready to pounce 
 Edward Hopkins, The Black Swan, Frome, Somerset BA11 1BB, (0373) 65247.  
 Cutting tenons on a table saw. 
 The guards are removed so great care has to be taken and hands kept well clear of the blade (below left and right). 
 This operation is not to be attempted by novices. 
 Because of their bracing action the joints have to accurate 
 Fig. 1 The Gothic bracket 
 Fig. 2 Credence table plan and elevations 
 Notches and cross-bars in the waste pieces from the curves, create flat clamping surfaces. 
 Waste blocks protect the legs (above) 
 Carving out of his shell 
 Bertie Somme meets carver David Morgan, and looks at some of the endearing pieces David produces in his West Country workshop 
 Pond snail in monteray pine  David Morgan (or Ned) is one of the rate sorts of person who always appears to be happy and cheerful, making him the natural leader of the Devon branch of the British Woodcarvers Association. 
 His degree in zoology from Bristol University has doubtless led to his strong feeling for the natural curves and shapes which are so predominant in his work 
 Slug in ash (above and pond snail in walnut  Ned says he &bquo;loves the infinite variety of wood and feels that woodcarving or sculpture should compliment this&hellip; 
 The pieces that work best are those that are harmonious with the wood's properties of strength and grain, and not battling to impose a feat of engineering that might be better made with some other material. 
 Nature is full of imperfection, and I prefer to avoid following a strict design. 
 This allows carvings to develop as they are being produced.&equo; 
 Fat fish in laburnum (above)  &bquo;I have always made things,&equo; says Ned, &bquo;and while on a boating holiday on the Thames about 15 years ago I found a branch of very dark wood lying on the ground. 
 It joined me for the rest of the holiday, much to the annoyance of my fellow passengers. 
 My first two carvings were produced from this branch: a small whale and an orangutan. 
 I collect and season most of my wood, which I feel gives me a head start over the clinical pieces available at timber yards.&equo; 
 Slug in ash (above) and tortoise in burr elm (right)  Making no bones about methods or means, David is a proud user of mechanical aids, ranging from lathes to the Woodcarver, from drum sanders to a Black &amp; Decker Powerfile. 
 That is not to say that the more traditional tools and methods are not in evidence in his workshop, but, true to form, he feels that the finished work is more important than the means. 
 He is a free spirit, with a long way to go, who should be closely followed 
 Bob Wearing's Workshop 
 Edges of Perspex and similar acrylic sheet plane well, but not with the conventional plane. 
 The thin edged-woodworking cutter blunts very quickly and at times produces a very chipped or chattering surface, so it is modified (fig.1). 
 A very small 45&deg; bevel is ground on the top surface, giving an approach angle to the work of 90&deg; ie, a scraping cut. 
 Although the angle on the blade is quite large when compared with the normal, nevertheless it must be kept well sharpened. 
 The cap iron should be set as far as possible from the cutting edge. 
 If this is not possible, saw off the end of a cap iron. 
 Fine cuts are more effective than heavy ones which tend to break out at the far corner. 
 If this is happening, work from both ends. 
 Pieces of material much longer than the vice jaws should be gripped between two wood strips and held in the vice with the addition of a G-cramp or screw at each end (fig.2). 
 Considerably greater downward pressure is required than for planing wood. 
 A supply of Perspex offcuts can often be obtained from firms  making illuminated signs. 
 Surplus radio and electronics shops are another source. 
 Smoked or tinted material is preferred as the instruments constructed can be more easily seen when set aside. 
 When a more polished edge is required, follow the plane with fine wet and dry paper, used wet, on a wood block. 
 Be sure not to damage the main surfaces by scratching with the paper or when wiping away the slurry. 
 The sharp edge or arris can conveniently be removed using the conventional cabinet scraper sharpened normally or else the proprietary Scarsten scraper. 
 Leave on the protective paper until the last moment to reduce scratching. 
 Transparent Perspex makes ideal T-square blades. 
 Few readers will wish to make wood blades and even fewer to fit an ebony edge. 
 Standard T-squares and the specials for perspective drawing boards (WW/May 83)  can be produced in this way, as can longer straight-edges. 
 There is little point in making the normal 45&deg; and the 30 &deg/60; &deg; set squares. 
 However, a number of specials are worth making. 
 Readers too, may have their own special requirements. 
 Mark out with a sharp scriber and saw out with a bandsaw &mdash; or hacksaw. 
 Plane the edges and bore a finger hole. 
 The latter can be cone very neatly by drilling a small hole then enlarging it with one of the conical sheet metal drills. 
 Bevelling the edges of T- and set-squares is helpful on two accounts. 
 With a bevel on top, a thinner edge presented to the work makes drawing easier. 
 A small bevel underneath prevents smearing when drawing with ink. 
 Quite a small bevel is adequate for this purpose so in cases where a square has to be turned over, such a small bevel on each side is the solution. 
 A simple piece of apparatus (fig.8) is required to work the bevel accurately and with a good finish. 
 Screw together the two strips (it may be desired to alter the overlay in the future). 
 Groove and glue on a stout strip which can be gripped in the vice. 
 Ensure that the modified cutter is sharp and adjust for a fine cut. 
 Cramp the workpiece to the upper board and by means of a wood block ensure that it lines up with the edge of the top board. 
 Using strong down pressure, plane until the desired bevel has been obtained. 
 If desired, a fine finishing cut can be removed using a freshly sharpened cabinet scraper. 
 Wrap the bottom corner with a couple of layers of masking tape to prevent the scraper from cutting the device. 
 Alternatively a Scarsten scraper can be used having first tapped away the cutter from the lower corner to avoid damage. 
 When a less opaque finish is required, tape abrasive paper of grade 500, 800 or 1200 to a wood block and proceed as if planing, keeping the paper well wet with water. 
 Set squares are made in the same way though a little ingenuity may be required to grip the material. 
 This jig allows wooden T-square blades to be made or reconditioned, using a conventional plane.  
 Question Box 
 Your questions 
 Moveable tops 
 Q We constantly read that when making table tops and the like from solid timber, one should not fix finishing pieces across the end-grain because the greater lateral expansion across the grain will break the glue joint eventually. 
 Yet many of the &bquo;custom designed&equo; pieces we see have such end pieces, often an integral part of the design. 
 Are there ways around the problem which are not generally discussed, and is the problem non-existent with some timbers? 
 Steve Goulden, Hereford 
 A The received wisdom indicates that to restrain timber across its width will lead to the fracture of either the glue line of the lateral end piece, or the splitting of the board itself. 
 The effects of movement can be observed in antique pieces from the 17th century onwards, where cleats were put across the ends of structures like writing desk falls in order to gain a flush surface. 
 Frequently, such furniture now displays longitudinal splits in the boards. 
 The earlier and well-known technique of framing up a loose panel appears to have been sacrificed to the whimsy of fashion. 
 In more modern furniture where a composite board of inherent stability, such as plywood, has been used the use of end and side lippings of solid wood is both sage and justifiable in concealing raw edges. 
 But, where as you suggest, &bquo;custom designed&equo; pieces which adopt this practice when using sold wood there is the likelihood of failure whatever the species or moisture content. 
 I can only volunteer that this is done by designers who have an imperfect understanding of the nature and properties of wood, or who are literally prepared to risk it. 
 Bob Grant 
 Fixing handles 
 Q Could you please tell me the best method of fixing turned wooden handles to cutlery blanks? 
 I would also like to know if there is any special relationship between the length of the blank and the length of the handle. 
 Ted Newnham, London 
 A I have found that the best method of fixing cutlery blanks to the handles is by using Special T-Gap Filling Bond (time 50 seconds). 
 The method of preparing the blank before inserting the cutlery blank is simply to drill and clean out the hole in the shaft before fixing, put the Special T on the tang and insert with the handle on top so the Special T does not run down the wood. 
 Any surplus glue can be easily wiped off with a rag and then with solvent. 
 There is actually no hard and fast rule with size of handle to size of cutlery blank, but depends on the design and shape you require &mdash; I often look around shops for ideas and take my tape measure and notebook to jot measurements and ideas down. 
 Obviously you will need a longer and wider piece of wood than the size of the cutlery blank. 
 Jamie Wallwin 
 &bull; Jamie Wallwin is a lecturer of woodturning 
 Howling timber 
 Q I have been asked to make an outside sign in timber for my bowls club. 
 What is the best material, that keeps its shape, lasts in all weathers and takes lettering and varnish? 
 What is the best finishing process? 
 Should it be done before or after lettering, and what is the best form of lettering to use? 
 A sign at our local church is in oak, with gold lettering, but the latter is already fading after three years. 
 A I think that the design considerations of your notice board should be given some careful thought. 
 As you say, plain boards lettered and varnished and exposed to the elements soon lose their fresh effect. 
 Some shielding from sum, wind and rain should be provided even if it is just a capping to the board, and the whole fixed on some sheltered wall. 
 Better still, the whole board should be protected within a framework rather like a picture frame with its face covered with clear polycarbonate sheet. 
 This will not only protect the notice face from the weather but also deter the vandal. 
 The materials used may be selected from the humble waterproof ply-wood suitably painted to clear finished oak. 
 As to the preparation of the material you would so well to consult your signwriter, usually they specify a well sealed surface as flat as possible, with protective coats of clear gloss applied after the lettering process. 
 There remains the possibility of incised carved lettering of course. 
 Bob Grant 
 &bull; Bob Grant is a professional woodcutter and tutor 
 Spinning sources 
 Q I have been, for 70 years, the proud owner of a spinning wheel, stamped with the name &bquo;Foster&equo;. 
 It has been in our family since 1850. 
 I have done certain repairs over the years, but much is still original, and though the marquetry is lifting it remains a beauty. 
 The main parts are of mahogany, but the spindles are lighter wood, possibly ash or yew? 
 Could you tell me anything about Foster; where he lived and the dates he worked? 
 W. Booth, Beds 
 A Very little is known about Foster, but he is believed to have worked with Leppard in Bristol around 1810&ndash;30. 
 The wheel is of Flemish type, typical of the Donegal flax wheel. 
 These wheels in pine or fruitwood were sold in large numbers for around 3/ &mdash; each, to spinners in Co. 
 Donegal. 
 Your wheel appears an upmarket version in mahogany, probably a one-off model. 
 Bone decor was used instead of ivory. 
 These wheels were very good workers and many replicas have been built; some very decorative specimens. 
 A spinning wheel is a working tool so repairs are quite acceptable. 
 The cane distaff is not unusual and would be required for spinning flax. 
 Fine grooves in the quill aperture and flyer hecks (hooks) would confirm the use of the wheel for flax. 
 Wheels are very difficult to date accurately and very detailed examination would be needed to establish its age. 
 Your wheel certainly appears original and of very good quality and I am sure if tuned would spin quite well. 
 The lifting marquetry on the saddle is a problem and I hesitate, without examination, to suggest a cure. 
 The suggestion that the wheel is Welsh I would personally discount as like the Sugar Loaf hat the claims of the Welsh to spinning wheels have very little claim to fact. 
 There is no indigenous Welsh wheel in the Welsh Folk Museum so I would certainly feel that your wheel came from the Bristol builders. 
 It is a very good example and well worth restoration and care, and I feel it should be used to spin again. 
 Roger Sear 
 &bull; Roger Sear is a maker of spinning wheels 
 Linseed canister 
 Q I was recently given a large five gallon tin canister containing linseed oil. 
 I think it is raw. 
 Could you advise me on any good uses in the way of finishes for this oil? 
 I seem to remember a recipe in the Woodworker  using linseed oil. 
 S. thompson, Tyne and Wear 
 A Raw linseed oil is lighter in colour than the boiled variety but they are both used in wood finishing. 
 Oil polishing is a lengthy and strenuous process which brings out the beauty of the wood like no other finish and imparts a most durable, dull sheen. 
 It is particularly suitable for table tops on account of its ability to withstand accidental spillages and does not blister when hot dishes are placed on it. 
 Either raw or boiled oil may be used. 
 Raw linseed may be better on light coloured woods because its darkening effect is less than boiled oil. 
 Whichever oil is used the method of application and polishing is the same. 
 A small quantity of oil is sprinkled on a clean rag and rubbed well into the surface to be polished. 
 Continue rubbing until the surface feels dry and then polish vigorously with a clean soft duster. 
 Because of the amount of hard rubbing needed to achieve a good finish, oil polishing is best confined to plain surfaces. 
 Many applications are required but once a good shine has been built up it can be maintained by oiling every six months or so. 
 A good polish reviver can be made by mixing equal parts of raw linseed oil, substitute turps and vinegar. 
 Shake the bottle well, apply with a clean cloth and polish with a soft duster. 
 The linseed oil helps restore the shine to a dull surface. 
 A mixture of equal quantities of raw linseed oil and substitute turps is often rubbed into pine prior to staining. 
 This gives the pine a more even rate of absorption so that a more uniform colour results when the stain is applied. 
 Charles Cliffe 
 &bull; Charles Cliffe is a tutor of finishing, and contributor to Woodworker  
 Restoration Gibbons' Blazing Glories 
 With the restoration of Hampton Court Palace nearing completion, Trevor Barnes meets an American who has been asked to work on some of the most important recreations of Grinling Gibbons' original carvings 
 David Esterley working on a Gibbons reproduction with the tools &bquo;to which I am more attached than anything.&equo; 
 Fortunately photographs were taken of the original carvings (above) 
 When the World Service broadcast news of the fire which damaged the State Apartments of Hampton Court Palace on Easter Monday 1986 David Esterly was busy at his workbench in up-state New York carving grapes in the manner of his guiding spirit, the 17th century genius woodcarver Grinling Gibbons. 
 As he listened with mounting alarm he began to realise that the flames would almost certainly have reduced some of the world's finest baroque woodcarving to lumps of featureless charcoal. 
 In dismay he put aside his tools and set down his reaction to the disaster on paper. 
 The resulting article, part elegy for the lost carvings, part tribute to the man had transformed the English woodcarving tradition, was later published in  
 The Spectator. 
 With Gibbons, he wrote, oak had given way to limewood and earthbound solidity to feats of impossible lightness. 
 Soaring compositions of fruit and foliage, tangles of leaves and flowers, garlands of nuts and berries had been artfully choreographed into balletic wood sculpture which seemed to mirror nature then refine it. 
 Now, he concluded gloomily, some the best examples of the Gibbons technique were destroyed and where was the expertise today to replace them? 
 Where, that is, if not in a small workroom in up-state New York? 
 The Spectator  article secured him an invitation to Hampton Court and, having offered his specification for the repair work, he was duly hired. 
 Gibbons carving is a small field so his skill was in demand. 
 Of all the styles it is the most laborious and there are few professionals able or willing to continue the tradition. 
 As Esterly puts it, &bquo;I'm the only person crazy enough to make a living out of original limewood foliage work. 
 It's so time-consuming that most professional carvers avoid it like the plague.&equo; 
 Five years after the fire, his work now nearing its end, he is at the centre of a specialist team of restorers replacing the recarving swags and pendants which had adorned the King's Bedchamber and adjoining rooms since the time of Charles II and which now lie boxed or in pieces on shelves and benches at the South East corner of the palace. 
 With infinite delicacy forget-me-nots and rosebuds, croci and oak leaves are chiselled out of native lime (grown in the grounds of the palace itself) and slotted into ancient floral compositions which, but for a discarded cigarette in the grace and favour flats above, could perhaps have remained undisturbed for the next 300 years. 
 For all the damage, though, the fire has  brought unexpected benefits. 
 For one thing it has prompted a full-scale review of all the carving at Hampton Court and given the restorers the opportunity to reverse years of general neglect. 
 Secondly, it has provided young, highly enthusiastic professionals with unprecedented access to some of the jewels of English carving. 
 What lies in pieces around them represents, in effect, a unique private exhibition open to a lucky few who for the first time in generations have had the opportunity for hands-on experience of greatness. 
 Who but Gibbons has been able to reproduce in wood the precise bloom of a ripening peach, the very texture and mass of a bursting apricot, or the exact weight and trajectory of an ear of corn on its stem? 
 His complete mastery of technique and flawless sense of proportion and design have much to teach. 
 The restorers are eager to learn. 
 &bquo;It's exceedingly stimulating,&equo; says David Esterly. 
 &bquo;He's been my guardian spirit for years and it's interesting to be forced to suppress all my own creativity in order to copy him slavishly to the last detail. 
 I'm stealing everything I can!&equo; 
 Tall and elegantly mustachioed, David Esterly is a softly spoken Californian in his mid-forties whose passion for Grinling Gibbons takes him by surprise even today. 
 &bquo;I was walking down Piccadilly in 1973 with the woman who was later to become my wife when she grabbed me by the arm and steered me into St James's church to see the carvings&equo;. 
 What followed dictated the course of his life. 
 &bquo;It was a conversion experience,&equo; he says, &bquo;I had seen his carvings in a vague sort of way already &lsqb;Esterly was then a post-graduate student at Cambridge and surrounded by some of Gibbons' best work&rsqb; but I found myself looking at them there in St James's as if for the first time. 
 The scales fell from my eyes.&equo; 
 He initially mistook his interest for an academic one and outlined plans to write a book. 
 But as time went on he realised he could not convey how the style had evolved without understanding the techniques at first hand. 
 &bquo;So I bought a few chisels and some wood and had a go. 
 Then I lost all interest in writing.&equo; 
 There followed lean years in a cottage in Sussex, &bquo;living on nothing but spaghetti&equo; while he perfected his newly-discovered skill. 
 Self-taught to a high degree of proficiency he is engagingly dismissive of his talent. 
 &bquo;I'm not a fine artist. 
 I'm not a sculptor. 
 I'm a humble carver.&equo; 
 But a humble carver who is essential to English Heritage's programme of restoration. 
 And one who has arguably the toughest brief of all the carvers at the palace. 
 While the others are assigned to carvings which were partially damaged David Esterly has to recreate something which was all but destroyed in the fire. 
 The left-hand foliage pendant which once hung above the west door of the King's Drawing Room bore the brunt of the flames and only two tiny fragments of the original 7ft drop survive; a couple of limewood crocus heads no more than an inch and a half across. 
 He has had to carve a replacement. 
 Like a detective displaying the only clues in a case in which he has become personally involved, he holds out the croci with a shrug of quiet resolve. 
 They are, as they say in the films, all he has had to go on. 
 Well, not quite. 
 The restorers' single most valuable resource came in the form of life-size archive photographs of all the Gibbons' carving at Hampton Court, and David Esterly is the first to admit his debt to the unnamed civil servant who in 1939 seeing war clouds gather, prudently took it upon himself to record the work for future generations. 
 These photographs &mdash; &bquo;my life's blood&equo; &mdash; are pinned to his bench enabling him to check the size and configuration of the newly-carved elements. 
 &bquo;We've adopted a very conservative philosophy of restoration&equo; says Esterly. 
 &bquo;Nothing which is not either documented by photograph or clearly indicated by surviving is replaced. 
 Whereas restorers in the past speculated on some of the missing elements and snapped in a few flowers here and there, we take the view that if it's missing when we took the carving down then it will stay missing when we put it back up again. 
 For the first time we are trying to preserve the historical integrity of the carvings.&equo; 
 The restoration work has brought to light tricks of the Gibbons trade. 
 As they lie on the benches within arm's reach, the foliage compositions initially shock by their scale. 
 Tulips and rushes seem implausible large. 
 But that, says the quiet American, is all part of the art. 
 &bquo;The first impression is that the flora is vastly over-modelled. 
 But that's because we're looking at it at close quarters. 
 Remember that it was designed to be seen from 20ft below and back. 
 If it had been carved to life all the detail would have disappeared in a dense and unreadable thicket of vegetation. 
 That's his genius.&equo; 
 Twenty years after the conversion experience in St James's the book may yet materialise (as, also, might a planned Gibbons exhibition &mdash; the first). 
 In the meantime David Esterly is content to pursue a humble carver's life. 
 &bquo;An honourable profession where cheating shows and virtue has its own reward.&equo; 
 and one which, as he has noticed while walking through the great houses of the world, &bquo;has given many an anonymous carver a little power over the grave.&equo; 
 An exhibition charting the history of Hampton Court, and the restoration of fire damaged apartments is now open to the public. 
 The Fire Exhibition displays some of the discoveries that were made during the repairs. 
 For instance under the floorboards were tons of sea shells used for insulation, and behind the wooden panels were mock painted versions, obviously applied as an experiment. 
 The exhibition, in the King's Guard chamber is open from 9.30am-6.00pm, daily, at Hampton Court Palace.  
 The designs are carefully drawn out (below) before David can attempt any of the oversized carving on a block of lime (below right) 
 Garden furniture 
 Sun Seeking seats 
 David Solman builds a special garden bench, inspired by a sunnier summer than 1991, and makes a simple dowelling jig 
 Having spent much of the glorious summer last year sitting in the shade of the apple tree I decided that if such summers were to continue it would be a good idea to build a permanent seat around the tree. 
 The ideal should be a circular seat but I felt it would take a considerable amount of timber with a lot of waster so I opted for an hexagonal shape. 
 The tree was 360mm in diameter and to enable me to get the correct clearance around the tree and the seat width I drew a rough development on the patio with chalk. 
 Once satisfied, I got a large cardboard carton and broke it open so that the development could be accurately drawn. 
 This was all important to enable me to get the correct shape of the legs and the lengths of the rails. 
 The shape of the legs was formed to make sure that each face that had a rail joint was at right angles to the rail which reduces the time and effort needed for angled joints. 
 Development 
 Draw a semi-circle to a radius of 255mm, then on the same centre draw another semi-circle of 665mm radius, and divide the larger semi-circle into three equal parts. 
 Draw radial lines from these divisions to the centre point, now join with straight lines where these radial lines cross the semi-circles. 
 From this you can develop the shape of the legs, and calculate the lengths of the different rails. 
 These dimensions give a seat width of 350mm. 
 The four legs and four rails that will make up the seat-jointing section are cut oversize so that they can be cut in half. 
 Pin the angled offcuts from the legs on to a scrap piece of wood to make an excellent cradle for planing and also for clamping blocks. 
 As there were 68 joints to be made, and I do not own a mortising machine, I decided on dowels. 
 I used 8mm dowels for all joints except on the thinner rails where I used 6mm. 
 Use waterproof glue for all joints. 
 I made a simple drilling jig from a piece of 25x25x3mm angle iron which covered all the correct distances and spaces. 
 This also made the drilling of all component quick and accurate. 
 Assembly 
 Careful thought had to be given to assembly and I found that the easiest way was to join all the inner to the outer legs first, making eight rectangular frames. 
 With the clamping blocks, join the leg frames with the other rails forming two half hexagons. 
 Make the top from six slats of 19x44mm material, mitred to fit. 
 Chamfer the top corners and nail on with 1&ndash;1/2in ovals, punched in and filled. 
 The two halves are screwed together with brass screws, three on each side, two on the outer legs and one on the inner legs. 
 This enables it to be easily removed for winter storage or recoating with a wood preservative.  
 Hands on 
 Shimming up 
 During last year I came into possession of a large quantity of 1/4in router bits. 
 A lot of my work includes routing grooves for 5/8in and 3/4in boards, and it takes some time achieving the right width of groove even with the appropriate cutter. 
 Then I saw a friend using parallel rulers on a map, and I realised that by using a similar technique I could put all those 1/4in cutter into use. 
 I made two ruler from Tufnol (24x1&ndash;1/2x1/2in), then joined them with two brass strips, allowing about 1 in of play between the rulers. 
 Clamping one of these rulers to the board and keeping both rulers together, I cut the first groove, and then widen the groove by putting a shim between the rulers. 
 I have even used paper shims for more accuracy. 
 F. Ensor, Sutton Coldfield 
 Kitchen cabinets 
 Fixing kitchen units to walls always poses problems for the &bquo;one-man&equo; DIYer, but it can be simplified. 
 By making a stand it is possible to hold the unit in position at a constant height above the worktop, while marking and drilling the holes, and then fixing the unit in place. 
 It can always be returned to the same position. 
 W. Wilson, Ayrshire 
 &bull; It should be noted that this method does require some help, even if it is of the most menial nature. 
 For those without any assistance, a similar stand could be made which ensures the unit does not have the tendency to tip forward. 
 RE 
 Extra vacuum capacity 
 Turning, planing, routing and so on generate vast quantities of shaving, and I have found that I have to empty my 17 litre wet and dry vacuum cleaner at frequent intervals. 
 Then I retrieved a 251 metal container, with a good-fitting lid, from a skip. 
 I cut two holes int he lid and fitted a couple of turned spigots, using plastic pipe to keep the bore as large as possible. 
 Then I sealed the lid with hot melt glue. 
 The large shavings and heavy stuff drop out in the container while the finer dust goes through to the cleaner. 
 My particular cleaner came with two sizes of suction tube, and experiment has shown that for maximum suck the large diameter pipe must go from the cleaner to the container. 
 The smaller diameter tube tended to choke with shavings, but I found it cheap and well worthwhile to buy another large section suction tube. 
 Andrew Lawton, Lancs 
 Webbing blocks 
 I find the webbing straps and lever locks used to hold my boat to its trailer make excellent cramps. 
 It is important though to have corner blocks, and these I make in the time it takes for my tea to go cold. 
 Take 4in cubes of timber and cut one corner out. 
 Cut this waste in half and cramp it to the opposite corner of the block, and drill a 1&ndash;1/4in diameter hole where the pieces meet. 
 Then fit a 1 in dowel, 4in long into that recess, secured with some wire. 
 This dowel can rotate freely, which helps in positioning the blocks. 
 Richard Smith, Kent 
 Pencil irritation 
 Irate with frustration through constantly having to pick up my pencils after bending over, I really thought I'd cracked it when I bought a &bquo;posh&equo; mechanical pencil, with a clip. 
 Imagine my rage when I leaned too hard against a workpiece and bent the pencil. 
 What I needed was a solid holder that wouldn't let pencils bend or break, and a retainer that would expand and contract a million times. 
 The solution is two 5/8in-thick pieces of hardwood to fit in a breast pocket; mine is 4x4in. 
 Clamp them together, making sure they are vertical. 
 Drill four 5/16in holes in each to take the pencils, turn them 90&deg; and drill a 1/2in hole 1 in from one end and along the joint; this forms a half hole in each block, and hence the reason for making two holders. 
 Cut a 5/8in wide band of bicycle inner tube. 
 Stretch this around the holder over the half hole, to form a gripper, and press drawing pins through the rubber into the material between the holes to maintain tension. 
 A drawing pin through the pocket ensures the holder does not fall out; comfort, security and peace at last. 
 David Cox, Notts  
 Creating a vortex 
 For waste collection in my workshop I use a Hoover Wet/Dry Powervac Super, fitted with a pleated paper drum filter and connected to my tools and machines with flexible hoses. 
 I also use the vac in the garden, collecting leaves, grass and hedge clippings. 
 But by using an auxiliary collecting tank I am able to increase the capacity by more than eight time, thereby avoiding having the empty the vac so frequently. 
 I acquired a 1301 plastic tank (the kind with a removable lid which is retained in position with a ring clamp) and installed inlet and outlet hose sockets in the sides close to the top at diagonally opposite points. 
 The hose sockets were the genuine parts supplied with the Powervac. 
 These required a little modification to get a better fit around the radius of the tank, sealing with a glue gun. 
 If ordinary drainage fittings are used it is vital that the inner parts of both inlet and outlet are passed through a 90&deg; elbow to create a vortex. 
 The tank's lid is so good that the suction is enough to seal it, with the ring clamp. 
 J. Brooks, Leeds 
 Making tamper-proof nameplate mounts 
 To make invisibly mounted brass nameplates cut a brass disc of the appropriate diameter and thickness; I use 1 mm sheet, and 1 mm diameter. 
 The disc should correspond with the diameter of your winged boring bits. 
 Take a brass screw (i/2in or 3/4in No.8) and solder it to the back of the disc. 
 Polish the face of the plate and bevel the edge, before burnishing. 
 Bore a shallow recess with the winged bit and, using the central pilot hole as a guide, drill the workpiece to take a steel screw that matches the one on the back of the nameplate. 
 Screw this in, and remove it to create the thread. 
 If the orientation of the writing on the disc is unimportant (in the centre of a bowl, for instance) you can engrave it now, before fitting. 
 For cabinet work, however, you will need to fit it first, and engrave it in situ. 
 Put a smear of wax on the screw thread, and screw the plate into position. 
 Extra twist can be achieved by the wearing of an old rubber glove on the required thumb. 
 Do practise your engraving first on some scrap metal, and lacquer if desired. 
 The additional shine will make the nameplate that much easier for your grandchildren to recognise when they see the piece on Antiques Roadshow in a hundred years or so! 
 Peter Sztencel, Wakefield  
 Handson in association with Stanley Stanley Tools are offering &pound;100 worth of Stanley and Rabone tools as shown below for the winner of Hands On competition for readers' tips. 
 We hope that woodworkers of all types will send in their wheezes, as readers are always asking for more tips. 
 We also award a Stanley tool worth &pound;15 to runners-up who have their ideas published. 
 To enter type (if you can) your tip and send it with clearly annotated drawings, and name, address and telephone number to: Hands On, Woodworker, Argus House, Boundary Way, Hemel Hempstead HP2 7ST. 
 This selection of winning tools includes an English/metric folding steel rule from Stanley's famous Rabone range for every runner-up. 
 Rabone rustless steel rules are precision made for all kinds of measuring and marking-out tasks, combining a high degree of accuracy with durability in use. 
 The 57R pattern shown above folds out to 24in in length. 
 On one side it is subdivided in inches and 16ths. 
 The special anti-glare finish on all Rabone precision steel provides a marked contrast to the clear, durable black graduations and figures. 
 Manufactured to conform to British Standards, the 57R can be relied upon to meet stringent accuracy tolerances. 
 Numerous other lengths in both metric and English graduations are available. 
 Winner Centre Ejector To avoid the necessity of using a drift to eject the revolving centre from a tailstock, fit a bush of hardwood or metal between the body of the tailstock and the back of the revolving centre. 
 The bore of the bush should be a snug fit over the moving slide. 
 The length of the bush should be 1/8in longer than the distance between the back of the centre and the front face of the tailstock casting, when fully retarded. 
 Then, when the slide is wound back fully, the bush will eject the centre, Jacobs chuck or whatever Morse taper device is fitted. 
 C. Souter, Rotherham 
 Next month September on sale 19th August 
 Classic Cabinets 
 For woodworkers inspired by furniture and cabinetmaking, the September issue of Woodworker  will be filled with potential projects, ideas and techniques. 
 Michael Burley charts the progression of his collector's cabinet, explaining how to make the piece with veneers, MDF and solid timber. 
 Adrian Jones, who studied for a number of years at Parnham House, has made a similar cabinet, and in the September issue he displays that piece and talks bout his work as a successful furniture-maker. 
 Any readers attempting to furnish a home should find ample material in the September issue. 
 Ralph Sinnott makes a desk and chair, while Hazel Rogers moves from the box she wrote about in the April issue, to a nest of tables. 
 Brian Cook shows how to make a coffee table, and Steve Goulden will be moving to the second part of his feature on chair design and construction. 
 Meanwhile David Savage has moving on his mind, with his decision to extend his workshop facilities coming to fruition in his ongoing series, The Craft of Cabinetmaking. 
 Masters of the Craft 
 From Australia, former Woodworker  editor, Peter Collenette sends a report on the Tasmanian furniture-maker, Alan Livermore, who is one of the few designer-makers to have his designs made in factories and in his own workshop. 
 In Britain, Bill Watts meets John Pizey, whose finishing skills are devoured by the variety of &bquo;students&equo; he teaches, and gains vital advice on those final touches, and how to rejuvenate antique furniture. 
 We also take a look at William and Mary furniture, and on a contemporary level visit some of the woodworking colleges. 
 Technical Treatise 
 Most woodworkers now own a router, so for those who wish they also had a biscuit jointer, Roy Cannon explains how to use the router for biscuits. 
 John Revell discusses the best sources for reclaimed timber. 
 For those more concerned with the professional aspects of woodworking, Loretta Radeschi offers advice on the best ways to find publicity through local papers and magazines. 
 Then, of course, there'll be the regular pages of advice, news, tests, correspondence and competitions that make &bquo;Woodworker&equo; Britain's quality woodwork magazine. 
 Order your copy now. 
 &bull; We at Woodworker  aim to publish in the September issue all the features we've mentioned here. 
 This may not be possible, so we apologise if any are missing, and guarantee, they will follow shortly. 
 We hope those articles not mentioned here, but present next month, will be some consolation.  
 A student on one of John Pizey's finishing courses (left) and a technique for marking angled shoulders (below) with hands removed for clarity. 
 Robert Ellwood's furniture will be featuring on next month's cover (bottom) 
 Arranging a Funeral 
 December 1990 
 This factsheet is designed to help those people who have to organise someone's funeral and/or those people who want to plan ahead for their own funeral. 
 Contents 
 1. 
 What happens when someone dies. 
 a) 
 Death at home 
 b) 
 Death in hospital 
 c) 
 Sudden death 
 d) 
 Procedure at the Registar's office 
 2. 
 Arranging a funeral. 
 a) 
 The funeral director 
 b) 
 Burial 
 c) 
 Cremation 
 d) 
 The service 
 3. 
 Arranging a funeral without the help of a funeral director. 
 4. 
 Financial help from the Social Fund. 
 5. 
 The duty of local and health authorities to pay for certain funerals 
 a) 
 Duty of Local authorities 
 b) 
 Duty of a Health authority 
 6. 
 Planning and paying for a funeral in advance. 
 a) 
 Planning 
 b) 
 Cost 
 c) 
 Planning &amp; Cost 
 7. 
 Bequeathing a body for research 
 8. 
 Donating organs for transplantation 
 9. 
 Important organisations 
 10. 
 Useful publications 
 As Scottish law differs from English law, Scottish readers should contact Age Concern Scotland at 54A Fountainbridge, Edinburgh, EH3 9PT, for a copy of their factsheet, available free on receipt of a sae.   
 1. 
 WHAT HAPPENS WHEN SOMEONE DIES 
 Even if the person or family have had little contact with a religious organisation a minister may be willing to visit while the person is dying. 
 What follows is a short account of the legal procedure &mdash; 
 a) 
 Death at home 
 If the person dies at home the family doctor and nearest relative should be informed. 
 The family doctor who has attended the person must complete a certificate giving the cause of death. 
 This is issued free. 
 If the body is to be cremated, two doctors must sign a certificate &mdash; but the first doctor will instruct the second doctor who can see the body in the chapel of rest or at the mortuary. 
 The doctor's certificate must be taken to the Registrar of Births and Deaths in the registration sub-district where the death occurred, normally within five days. 
 The doctor may provide a leaflet explaining how to register the death and should be able to advise where to do so. 
 Otherwise funeral directors keep detailed lists, or offices are listed in the phone book, or the Citizens Advice Bureau can advise. 
 A check should be made that it is the correct registration office and for opening times. 
 Sometimes a doctor will send the certificate direct to the Registrar, but it is always necessary for whoever is arranging the funeral to attend at the Registrar's office, this is usually a close family member but does not have to be. 
 b) 
 Death in hospital 
 If someone dies in hospital the health authority may give the certificate to the registrar who attends the hospital but, again, someone must attend the registration office. 
 This will be the district office which covers the hospital which may not be the same office as for the place of residence. 
 Sometimes the hospital will want to carry out a post mortem, and the hospital will need consent from the nearest relative. 
 c) 
 Sudden death 
 If there is doubt about the cause of death &mdash; if, for example, the death was sudden and the doctor had not seen the person within fourteen days of death, or if they had no general practitioner, the coroner must be informed, and will decide whether it is necessary to hold a post mortem. 
 If the death is then considered to be from natural causes, the coroner will issue a notification that he does not consider it necessary to hold an inquest, and this may be given to the relative to take to the registrar or sent to the registrar direct. 
 It will always be necessary for someone to attend the registrar's office in person.  
 The coroner may also order an inquest to establish the circumstances of the death. 
 An informant is not required to register a death which is the subject of a coroner's inquest, but the coroner's officer may inform the relatives when the coroner has issued his inquest certificate to the registrar so that the relatives can obtain any death certificates from the registrar. 
 The coroner will also issue an order for burial, or a certificate for cremation free of charge. 
 d) 
 Procedure at the Registrar's office 
 The relative or person who has been given the medical certificate by the doctor must see the Registrar of Births and Deaths for the district where the death occurred, in order that the death may be registered. 
 The information required will be &mdash; the full names of the ceased person, and any other names that they have been known by, including the maiden surname of a woman who has been married; their date and place of birth; their recent occupation, and their husband's full name and occupation, if the person who has died was a married woman. 
 It will also be necessary to confirm the date and place of death. 
 This is the essential information which must be included in the death register. 
 Other questions will be asked about date of birth of surviving spouse, and information about the state pensions and allowances that the person was receiving, including war pensions. 
 The National Health Service insurance number will be requested, and the deceased's medical card should be surrendered to the registrar if it is available. 
 However, if this number is not known and the medical card is not available, there is no need to worry. 
 Once the death is registered, a white certificate is issued free of charge, which contains a social security form to claim any arrears of benefits due to the estate of the deceased person and to ensure that the correct benefits are paid to the widow (if applicable); and a green certificate for burial or cremation (see Section 2). 
 Copies of the death certificate can be purchased. 
 A standard version will be necessary for a grant of probate or letters of administration costing &pound;2.00 per copy. 
 These are documents which are often necessary to obtain access to a deceased person's assets &mdash; further information may be obtained from the Principal Registry, Family Division of the High Court, 5th Floor, Golden Cross House, Duncannon Street, London, WC2N. 
 Copies ordered at a later date may cost &pound;5.00 depending upon the time lapse between the registration of death and the date of the order. 
 Different special certificates can be obtained (at a price of &pound;1.50) to show banks, social security and building societies, for claiming from friendly societies, and for claiming insurance taken out on the life of the person.  
 2. 
 ARRANGING A FUNERAL 
 When there is insufficient money in the estate of the deceased person to pay for the funeral and if the person arranging the funeral is likely to have a problem meeting the cost then sections 4 and 5 of this factsheet should be read before making any arrangements. 
 It should be noted that help from the Social Fund for funeral expenses is only available where there is insufficient money in the estate, and where the person making the arrangements is in receipt of income support, housing benefit or community charge benefit, or is the partner of someone receiving these benefits. 
 The person who makes the arrangements with the funeral director may be considered to have entered into a binding contract, and become responsible for the cost, even if they are not related to the deceased. 
 a) 
 The funeral director 
 When someone dies at home and the person is to be buried, the funeral director can be called to take the body to a chapel of rest as soon as a doctor has certified the death. 
 If someone dies in hospital, they may rest in the hospital mortuary, or the funeral director will arrange for the body to be taken to the chapel of rest. 
 Sometimes this can be a considerable expense if the person died some way from where the family wish them to be buried. 
 Before the funeral can take place the funeral director must have the burial or cremation certificates. 
 It is important to check whether the dead person left any instructions with the Will about the funeral, or wished the body to be given for medical research (see Section 7), or organs to be donated for transplantation (see Section 8). 
 If there is a Will, the executor has the right to decide whether it will be a burial or a cremation, whether the Will expresses a particular wish or not. 
 If there is no Will, the next of kin should decide. 
 It is important to check whether the deceased has already made arrangements for their own funeral, or carried funeral insurance (see Section 6). 
 Funeral directors accept that relatives will seek quotations before they decide which company to use &mdash; information can be found in Yellow Pages Directories under the heading &bquo;funeral directors&equo;. 
 If relatives cannot afford to pay for the funeral they should seek assistance from the Department of Social Security (DSS) (see Section 4).  
 The National Association of Funeral Directors (618 Warwick Road, Solihull, West Midlands B91 1AA. 
 Tel (021) 711 1343) has a code of practice for funeral directors which it encourages its members to display. 
 It can be seen at Citizens Advice Bureaux, or at funeral directors who are members of the Association. 
 The Association also operates a complaints procedure. 
 Members of the Association offer a basic funeral which can be requested. 
 This consists of a fitted and lined coffin, conveyance for the dead person, or delivery of a coffin (at least ten running miles allowed), laying out of the person, which normally includes embalming, use of the chapel of rest, provision of a hearse, and one following car to the nearest local cemetery or crematorium, and necessary conductors and bearers. 
 They will also attend to all necessary arrangements and papers. 
 If not all these services are required, the bill should be reduced. 
 Work done outside normal hours means extra costs. 
 The funeral director will discuss varying costs of a funeral and cremation, including additional costs of burial, and should have a price list with all types of coffin, casket and services provided. 
 A written itemised estimate of costs will be given. 
 Additional costs of flowers, crematorium and cemetery fees, doctors and clergy, often exceed the actual costs of the funeral, and the funeral director will also advise on these. 
 The funeral director will usually offer to pay costs to the hospital, crematorium, or burial ground, and minister of religion, but these can be handled direct. 
 Many funeral directors will submit the bill, and offer a discount for payment within a certain time. 
 Where the dead person had a bank account, the bill can be submitted to the bank. 
 The Department of National Savings (form SB4 obtainable at Post Offices) and building societies will pay out amounts up to &pound;5,000 on the evidence of the death certificate, although they are not bound to until the grant of probate or letters of administration have been issued. 
 The funeral director will understand if the bill cannot be paid until then, but the circumstances should be explained when planning the funeral. 
 b) 
 Burial 
 Everyone has a right to be buried in the churchyard of the parish in which they die &mdash; assuming that one exists, and that there is space left. 
 If the dead person has paid for a grave space in the churchyard, there will be a document called a &bquo;faculty&equo; in existence, and you will need to produce this.  
 With a family grave, there will be a fee for opening it up, for moving headstones, and for additional inscriptions on an existing headstone. 
 If the dead person wanted to be buried outside the parish where they lived, the permission of the local clergy must be sought, and can be refused, unless there is space in an existing grave that the family intended for the dead person. 
 The charge is likely to be higher than that for a parishioner. 
 A Parochial Fees Order lays down the fees payable to the Church of England for funeral services and burials in Church of England churches, the churchyards and consecrated parts of cemeteries. 
 The fee for burial does not include charges for grave-digging, which may be carried out by a parochial officer (in which case the vicar sets the charge), or by a grave-digger hired by the funeral director. 
 If a monument is required, the consent of the minister must be sought. 
 The fees for monuments vary according to the type. 
 There are restrictions covering the types of monuments and inscriptions that are permitted in a churchyard. 
 An alternative is to be buried in a cemetery. 
 These are mostly run by local authorities, but some are privately owned and/or denominational. 
 They too will charge for a plot. 
 Fees are set by the owners under Acts of Parliament, and vary widely. 
 Information about the scale of fees and cemetery rules can be obtained by writing for brochures. 
 Grave plots vary in cost depending on whether they are common or private. 
 Fees will also be levied for the erection of monuments and borders. 
 Private &bquo;lawn&equo; graves can also be bought, which are cheaper, because they are on grass, and only a simple headstone can be erected. 
 In consecrated parts of cemeteries, if the burial takes place immediately after a church service, there is no Church of England fee for the burial service. 
 If the burial service follows a church service on a separate occasion, a fee will be charged. 
 The clergy's travelling expenses are chargeable as extras. 
 If a member of the clergy officiates at a service in an unconsecrated part of a cemetery, or at a crematorium, the charge usually reflects the parochial fee for a similar service. 
 &bquo;A guide to Church of England fees&equo; is available free from the Pastoral Department (General Section), Church Commissioners, 1 Millbank, London SW1P 3JZ, on receipt of an s.a.e. 
 Local authorities often charge a different fee to their own residents and ratepayers than to outsiders, although there may be concessions to former residents and community charge payers. 
 Burial outside the area of residence will be more expensive because of the additional transport costs.  
 c) 
 Cremation 
 In order to prevent anybody being cremated where there is possible doubt about the cause of death, there are very strict rules about certification, which can increase the cost of cremation. 
 Before a cremation can take place three statutory forms have to be completed, one by next of kin, the others by two different doctors. 
 Each of the doctors is entitled to a fee &pound;25.75 recommended by the BMA in 1990). 
 One will be the doctor who has attended the person in their last illness who must see the body before completing the form, and another doctor who must also see the body. 
 Only the doctor who attended the last illness is required to certify when someone dies in the hospital and a post mortem has been carried out and the results known to the doctor. 
 When a coroner has issued a certificate for cremation, no other doctors are required to certify, and the coroner's certificate is free. 
 A final document is signed by another doctor, who is the medical referee to the crematorium. 
 He must receive the above certificates the day before the cremation is due to take place. 
 The fee for this usually comes as part of the crematorium fee. 
 The majority of crematoria are run by local authorities. 
 Some will charge higher rates to non-residents. 
 Brochures can be obtained about charges and conditions from the owners of the crematorium. 
 Fees include the medical referees' form, and the use of the chapel and, usually, recorded music (which can be selected in advance), or an organ. 
 Many crematoria include scattering or burying the ashes in a garden of remembrance in their fee. 
 If a relative wants to collect the ashes they can be collected or sent, but they will only be kept free for a time (usually about a month) &mdash; a charge will be made after that time. 
 Some churches are happy to scatter the ashes in the graveyard or bury them according to the family's wishes. 
 If the minister of religion is required to conduct a service, the family or funeral director arrange this. 
 The crematoria will have a duty list of ministers. 
 The Cremation Society of Great Britain (Brecon House, 2nd Floor, 16 Albion Place, Maidstone, Kent, ME14 5DZ. 
 Tel. (0622 688292) offers free advice and help on any aspects of cremation and publishes a leaflet, What you should know about cremations , which explains what happens at the crematorium on the day of the funeral. 
 After the cremation the crematorium will send details of memorials and their cost. 
 Memorials vary from books and stones of remembrance to planted bushes (often roses).  
 d) 
 The service 
 Everyone has the right to a church funeral, and for the body to be taken to the church, but it is not necessary to have a service at a funeral whether it is a burial or a cremation. 
 A few words can be said by a relative or friend, or, if there is no wish for a religious ceremony, a non-religious one can be planned. 
 Societies such as the British Humanist Association (14 Lamb's Conduit Passage, London, WC1R 4RH. 
 Tel. 071 430 0908), or the National Secular Society (702 Holloway Road, London, N19 3NL. 
 Tel. 071&ndash;272 1266) may be able to arrange for someone to conduct a non-religious ceremony, or can send a form of words that could be used (leaflets are available from these organisations on receipt of an sae). 
 3. 
 ARRANGING A FUNERAL WITHOUT THE HELP OF A FUNERAL DIRECTOR 
 A few people wish to arrange a burial without the help of a funeral director. 
 Sections 1 and 2 have explained the procedure that must be followed, this section explains the additional tasks that the family may have to perform. 
 If the person dies at home, the district nurse could be asked to complete last offices, or the family may wish to do so. 
 This must be done fairly soon after the death. 
 The body is laid out on the back with hands at the side, the eyes are closed (coins or cotton wool on the eyelids will help) the jaw supported by a pillow, and all the natural outlets of the body plugged with cotton wool. 
 After the doctor has certified the cause of death, the body can be washed, dressed in whatever clothes are desired and hair brushed. 
 If the body is to remain at home it is advisable for the room to remain cool. 
 If the person dies in hospital the family will need to collect the body from the mortuary. 
 It may be possible for the arrangements for the funeral to be made direct with the crematorium or cemetery and minister of religion if desired. 
 A coffin can be purchased from the undertaker or made. 
 A large estate car or van will be needed to transport the coffin, and four to six people to carry it. 
 Some funeral directors will assist in do-it-yourself funerals by supplying a simple coffin and dealing with the documentation. 
 4. 
 FINANCIAL HELP FROM THE SOCIAL FUND 
 The Social Fund, which is a new part of social security, can give grants for those arranging a funeral who do not have sufficient money to cover the cost. 
 The person who applies for the grant must be receiving income support, housing benefit or community charge benefit or be the partner of someone receiving those benefits. 
 The person applying must have taken responsibility for arranging the funeral. 
 Claim form SF200 is obtainable from the local DSS office.  
 The person who dies must normally have been resident in the United Kingdom, and the funeral has to take place in the UK. 
 Before anyone applies for a grant from the Social Fund they should check what money is in the estate of the person who has died, such as in bank or building society accounts; whether there will be any money from insurance policies or charities, friends or relatives (either of the person claiming the grant or the person who has died); and any savings that the person claiming has over &pound;500. 
 (The capital limit is &pound;1000 for people aged 60 and over). 
 The savings may be in their name or the name of their husband or wife. 
 They will only get help if they cannot easily realise savings of the person who died to pay for the bill, or if paying for the bill brought their own family savings below &pound;500. 
 (The capital limit is &pound;1000 for people aged 60 and over). 
 The funeral payment will cover: - 
 bringing the body home if the person died away from home but in the United Kingdom 
 travel to arrange the funeral, or to go to the funeral (one return journey only) 
 necessary death certificates 
 an ordinary coffin 
 transport for the coffin and bearers and the cost of one additional car 
 &bquo;reasonable&equo; cost of flowers from the claimant 
 funeral directors fees 
 clergy and organist 
 additional expenses up to &pound;75, which arise from a requirement of the dead person's religious faith. 
 It cannot cover newspaper announcements, private burial plots or memorials. 
 It is advisable for the claimant to take along one written estimate for the funeral before the arrangements are made, in order to ensure that the cost will be met by the DSS, but a bill can be taken after the funeral to the DSS for help. 
 The time limit for making claims is three months (or twelve months if there is good reason for the delay). 
 If a grant is made and there is money or other assets in the estate of the person who has died, this will have to be used to pay the money back to the Social Fund. 
 If there is insufficient money to pay the whole cost, what is available will be put towards the cost. 
 If the person claiming is not looking after the estate, the Social Fund Officer will write to the person who is, at the same time as a payment is made.  
 Regulations governing this grant are contained in The Social Fund Maternity and Funeral Expenses (General) Regulations 1987 (Statutory Instrument 1987 No. 481), the Social Security (Claims and Payments) Amendment Regulations 1988 (Statutory Instrument 1988 No. 522), the Social Fund Maternity and Funeral Expenses (General) Amendment Regulations 1989 SI 1989/379 and the Social Fund Manual Page 12. 
 If the grant cannot meet the whole bill some funeral directors may accept weekly payments. 
 It is difficult to get help from charities towards funeral costs. 
 If an attempt is to be made it would be wise to approach those organisations with whom the dead person, or their spouse, had some link, eg. Royal British Legion, 48 Pall Mall, London, SW1Y 5JY, Tel. 071&ndash;930 8131; or the Soldiers, Sailors and Airmens Families Association, 19 Queen Elizabeth Street, London, SE1 2LP, Tel. 071&ndash;403 8783/071&ndash;962 9696 if they were in the services. 
 The local Citizens Advice Bureau, or Age Concern group, may be able to advise. 
 The Death grant was abolished under the Social Security Act 1986. 
 5. 
 THE DUTY OF LOCAL AND HEALTH AUTHORITIES TO PAY FOR CERTAIN FUNERALS 
 In certain circumstances local and health authorities have a duty to organise and pay for funerals. 
 These circumstances arise where the person who has died has no relatives or friends who would undertake the organisation, and has not made advance arrangements. 
 Many people who know that they may die in such circumstances wish to discuss the procedure beforehand, and it is possible that the authorities concerned may be prepared to do this. 
 a) 
 The duty of local authorities 
 Local authorities have a duty under Section 46 of the Public Health (Control of Diseases) Act 1984, to arrange the burial or cremation of any person who has died in their area where it appears that no suitable arrangements can be made other than by the local authority. 
 However, local authorities have no powers to reimburse burial costs where a third party has already arranged a funeral (but see (b) below in relation to deaths occurring in hospitals). 
 The authorities concerned would be in the cities &mdash; London Boroughs or Metropolitan Borough Councils &mdash; and, in the rest of the country, District Councils. 
 In the boroughs it is normally the Social Services, or the Environmental Health Department who would handle the arrangements. 
 In the rest of the country it is likely to be the Environmental Health Officer, unless someone dies in a council residential home, in which case the County Social Services Department will organise the funeral.  
 The local authority will make enquiries to see if the funeral can be paid for by a relative. 
 Also, if the deceased person leaves any estate, the local authority will claim its expenses from the legal personal representative. 
 The ways in which individual councils arrange matters vary greatly, but normally a council has an agreement with a local firm of funeral directors for a funeral service. 
 This usually consists of a simple coffin, no car, no flowers, no organ, but with a minister of religion present. 
 It is likely that the funeral will be at times when the cemeteries or crematoria are not busy, such as early in the morning. 
 If there are relatives and friends, arrangements will often be made to suit them so that they can attend. 
 b 
 Duty of a health authority 
 When anyone dies in hospital, and there are no relatives or friends to arrange and meet the cost of the funeral, the Secretary of State for Social Services has agreed that the Health Authority will do so (Hospital Memorandum 1972/41 and Health Notice 1985/31). 
 Like local authorities, hospitals have arrangements with funeral directors to provide a simple funeral. 
 Questions about the arrangements should be made to the Hospital Social Worker. 
 Although technically the health authority bears responsibility, in practice the funeral arrangements are made by the staff of the hospital where the patient died. 
 6. 
 PLANNING AND PAYING FOR A FUNERAL IN ADVANCE 
 Many people wish to plan their funerals in advance, and to know that they have set aside the money to pay for them: 
 a) 
 Planning 
 A letter can be left with the Will specifying the arrangements for the next of kin to follow. 
 It is also possible to discuss arrangements with the funeral directors in advance &mdash; requests will be lodged with the company. 
 This can be an advisable move if there are no immediate relatives who will be available to make arrangements. 
 The name of the funeral director can then be kept in a safe place with other important documents, such as the Will, so that whoever is left to deal with the situation can contact the funeral director. 
 b) 
 Cost 
 If savings have been set aside for a funeral, and would now pay for one at current prices, that money, invested at the best rate of interest, may be enough to pay for the funeral when it occurs. 
 It is also possible to pay a lump sum  premium to an insurance company which will pay out to the amount insured.  
 Some insurance companies offer small sum policies, with monthly or annual premiums, which may pay for the funeral when someone dies, however much has been put into the scheme. 
 There may be difficulty obtaining a policy over the age of 75. 
 Such schemes are advertised in the press, and policies can often be bought without a visit from an agent, or a medical assessment. 
 Abbey Life Assurance, Direct Mailing Dept., 80 Holdenhurst Road, Bournemouth, BH8 8AL or telephone free of charge on (0800) 262422 (maximum age 70) is one of the companies offering this type of policy. 
 A few companies still arrange house to house collection of the premiums, including: - 
 Prudential Assurance Co. 
 Ltd., 142 Holborn Bars London, EC1 N 2NH Tel. 071&ndash;405 9222 (maximum age 75 next birthday) A medical may be necessary Premiums collected every 4 weeks 
 Refuge Assurance PLC, Refuge House, Alderley Road, Wilmslow, Cheshire SK9 1PF Tel. (0625) 535959 (maximum age 75) 
 The Association of British Insurers, Aldermary House, 10&ndash;15 Queen Street, London, EC4N 1TT, Tel. 071&ndash;248 4477, is a trade Association for insurance companies which can provide information about its members. 
 c) 
 Planning and cost 
 Some organisations will combine planning a funeral and the cost. 
 Some funeral directors are prepared to allow payment in advance. 
 The National Association of Funeral Directors, may shortly have a scheme which will cover funeral costs. 
 Look for an undertaker who is a member of the NAFD and ask for information. 
 Chosen Heritage Ltd. has a scheme whereby a firm instruction can be given for a guaranteed price funeral which can be paid for at today's prices. 
 There are three plans available to cater for individual preferences. 
 Chosen Heritage nominates a local funeral director. 
 Details can be obtained by writing to Freepost, Chosen Heritage, East Grinstead, West Sussex, RH19 1ZA, or telephone free of charge on (0800) 525555. 
 Further information is available from your local Age Concern group or from the Marketing Department of Age Concern England.  
 Dignity in Destiny, a joint operation between the charity, Help the Aged and P F G Hodgson Kenyon International plc, offers prearranged funeral plans with guaranteed services and prices. 
 There are four plans available to cater for individual preferences. 
 Payment at today's price may be by a single lump sum or by instalments. 
 Details from Dignity in Destiny Ltd., Freepost, Manchester M1 8DJ or telephone, free of charge on (0800) 269318. 
 A Funeral Bond may be purchased from the Co-operative Wholesale Society through its Co-operative Funeral Services on payment by cash, credit card, or by instalments. 
 This scheme does not offer set funerals but customers decide on the details of a specific funeral paying in advance at current local prices. 
 Further information may be obtained from the Co-operative Funeral and Memorial Service, 2 Commonwealth Buildings, Woolwich Church Street, SE18 5NW, Tel 081 317 7317. 
 Most co-operative societies have some form of funeral prepayment plan which may involve vouchers for goods in their stores. 
 As schemes differ it would be essential to enquire at a local branch. 
 The Independent Order of Odd Fellows &mdash; Manchester Unity Friendly Society, 40 Fountain Street, Manchester M2 2AB, Tel: 061&ndash;832 9361 offer assurance to people up to age 85 next birthday. 
 7. 
 BEQUEATHING A BODY FOR RESEARCH 
 Instructions can be left by those who wish to donate their bodies for research, although these do not have to be followed by the executors. 
 On the other hand executors can decide to donate the body. 
 Contact should be made with the nearest medical school of H.M. Inspector of Anatomy whose address may be obtained from London Anatomy Office, P.O. Box 915, London W6 8RP (South East England), or the H.M. Inspector of Anatomy at the Department of Health and Social Security, Eileen House, 80&ndash;94 Newington Causeway, London, SE1 6EF (for the rest of England and Wales). 
 The address for Scotland is the Scottish Home and Health Department, St. Andrews House, Edinburgh, EH1 3DG. 
 The body may not always be accepted, but swift action must be taken on death to inform the authorities. 
 Eventually the medical school will arrange the funeral, and the family can participate if they wish. 
 8. 
 DONATING ORGANS FOR TRANSPLANTATION 
 The transplantation of organs such as heart, liver and kidneys can save people's lives, and the transplantation of corneas can save people's sight. 
 Transplant programmes are being held back because of a shortage of donor organs, and more are urgently needed. 
 The removal of organs for transplantation is permitted either if the deceased person has previously indicated in writing his willingness to be a donor, for example by signing an organ donor card, or if, when enquiries are made of the surviving relatives, no objections are raised. 
 Not all patients who die are suitable as organ donors, and the decision on whether to remove the organs is made by the doctors concerned. 
 Removal has to happen very soon after death &mdash; afterwards the body is returned to the relatives for burial or cremation. 
 The hospital does not contribute towards funeral costs. 
 Organ donor cards are available from most hospitals, general practice surgeries, dispensing pharmacists, and social security offices.  
 9. 
 IMPORTANT ORGANISATIONS 
 Organisations involved in the practical aspects of funerals have been mentioned in the text. 
 The following organisations may offer counselling and support through their groups. 
 There may be other local groups who can be contacted through lists kept at public libraries, or Citizen Advice Bureaux. 
 Age Concern England , Astral House, 1268 London Road, London SW16 4ER Tel. 081&ndash;679 8000, has over 1000 groups who provide services for elderly people. 
 Some groups offer bereavement counselling. 
 There are also Age Concern groups in Northern Ireland (6 Lower Crescent, Belfast, Northern Ireland, Tel. (0232) 245729); Scotland (54A Fountainbridge, Edinburgh, EH3 9PT, Tel. (031) 228 5656); and Wales (4th Floor, 1 Cathedral Road, Cardiff, Wales, Tel. (0222) 371821). 
 CRUSE &mdash; Bereavement Care , Cruse House, 126 Sheen Road, Richmond, Surrey, TW9 1UR, Tel. 081&ndash;940 4818, offers a counselling service and practical advice after a bereavement. 
 There are over 170 groups in the country. 
 National Association of Widows  54&mdash;57 Allison Street, Digbeth, Birmingham, B5 5TH, Tel. (021) -643 8348. 
 Their local branches provide support and help and social opportunities for widows. 
 They also offer a free advice service. 
 Gay Bereavement Project , Unitarian Rooms, Hoop Lane, London, NW11 8BS. 
 A telephone help and support service for people bereaved by the death of a same-sex life-partner. 
 Can help find suitable clergy and secular officiants for funerals. 
 For the number of someone to talk to telephone 081&ndash;455 8894 (recorded message). 
 London Lesbian and Gay Switchboard  offer a telephone counselling service. 
 Tel. 071&ndash;837 7324. 
 10. 
 USEFUL PUBLICATIONS 
 What to do after a death  DSS leaflet D49 &mdash; October 1990. 
 Provides detailed information and advice on everything that needs to be done following the death of a relative or friend.  
 This leaflet is available free from DSS offices, post offices, or from the DHSS Leaflets Unit, P.O. Box 21, Stanmore, Middx, HA7 1AY, quoting reference number. 
 Survey of Funeral Costs  &mdash; The 1990 Odd Fellows Survey. 
 Available free of charge from the Order of Odd Fellows, Manchester Unity Friendly Society, Odd Fellows House, 40 Fountain Street, Manchester, M2 2AB (tel. 061&ndash;832 9361). 
 What to do when someone dies . 
 Published by Consumers' Association. 
 Available from most libraries or bookshops, or by post from Consumers' Association, Castlemead, Gasgoyne Way, Hertford, SG14 1LH. 
 Funerals without God &mdash; a practical guide to non-religious funerals . 
 Price &pound;3 including postage. 
 Available from the British Humanist Association, 14 Lamb's Conduit Passage, London WC1R 4RH. 
 Instructions for my next of kin and executors upon my death . 
 Published by Age Concern England. 
 Price 25p. 
 Available from the Marketing Department. 
 This document is not intended to replace a Will. 
 It is a form on which a person can record their wishes concerning funeral arrangements; names of friends and relatives to contact; names and addresses of banks, clubs, life assurance companies, insurance brokers, where to find keys, certificates, receipts, etc. 
 Making Your Will  &mdash; Age Concern England factsheet no. 7. 
 Available free on receipt of an sae (9&ins; &times; 6&ins;) from the Information and Policy Department. 
 Make Your Will : A practical guide to making your own will (England and Wales) &mdash; Available from bookshops or by post from Consumers' Association, Castlemead, Gasgoyne Way, Hertford, SG14 1LH. 
 PLEASE NOTE THAT WHILE THE AGENCIES OR PUBLICATIONS MENTIONED HERE ARE KNOWN TO AGE CONCERN ENGLAND, INCLUSION IN THIS FACTSHEET DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A RECOMMENDATION BY AGE CONCERN ENGLAND FOR ANY PARTICULAR AGENCY OR PUBLICATION. 
 All rights reserved. 
 This publication may be reproduced in whole or in part in unaltered form by Age Concern groups with due acknowledgement to Age Concern England. 
 No other reproduction in any form is permitted without written permission from Age Concern England  
 Help with Heating 
 July 1991 
 The aim of this factsheet is to provide advice and information to elderly people on the help that is available to assist with heating costs and other fuel problems. 
 1. 
 Heating costs, Income Support and the Social Fund 
 2. 
 Housing Benefit and Heating Charges 
 3. 
 Grants for Insulation and Draught-proofing 
 4. 
 Easy Ways to Save Energy 
 5. 
 Gas and Electricity Codes of Practice 
 6. 
 Payment Schemes for Gas and Electricity 
 7. 
 Disconnection 
 8. 
 Services provided by the Fuel Industries* and assistance from Social Services 
 9. 
 Where to go for further help 
 *In this factsheet references to &bquo;the fuel industries&equo; or &bquo;fuel suppliers&equo; means gas regions and electricity companies.   
 HEATING COSTS, INCOME SUPPORT AND THE SOCIAL FUND 
 Income Support 
 Income support replaced supplementary pension in April 1988. 
 It is intended to provide a regular weekly income if you do not have enough money to live on. 
 Like supplementary pension it tops up your income to the amount the government says you need to live on. 
 As with supplementary pension you are supposed to pay for heating out of weekly income. 
 There are no longer any weekly heating additions to help pay for extra heating expenses, but extra weekly amounts called premiums may be paid on top of income support to people with special needs. 
 The Social Fund 
 The social fund is a scheme which makes loans and grants mainly to people getting income support. 
 It replaces the system of grants to people who were getting supplementary benefit before April 1988. 
 Applications for social fund payments should be made to your local DSS office. 
 The social fund is different from the grant system because it is discretionary. 
 If you are turned down for a grant or loan or you are unhappy with the amount given, there is no right of appeal to an independent tribunal as there used to be. 
 However, you can ask for a review of the decision, and if you are still not satisfied you can ask for your situation to be referred to a social fund inspector. 
 There is a limited amount of money available for these payments, so social fund officers have to look at the needs of all those who apply for help and decide which needs can be met. 
 There are three types of payments under the Social fund: 
 Budgeting Loans  are for people getting income support. 
 They are to help pay for something you need but cannot afford at the time you need it. 
 You must have been receiving or entitled to income support or supplementary benefit for a continuous period of 26 weeks (but one break of 14 days or less will not matter). 
 Savings over &pound;1000 will make a difference to the amount you can get as will your ability to repay the loan. 
 Budgeting loans are not available for gas and electricity bills. 
 If you have a large bill which you cannot pay you may be able to go on the fuel direct scheme and deductions will be made from your benefit each week to pay for your current fuel consumption and any arrears. 
 (For further details about fuel direct  see Page 8). 
 However loans can be available to meet the costs of fuel which are not on mains supply, such as coal, oil, paraffin, or bottled (LPG) gas. 
 Loans will also be available for the cost of installing a prepayment meter if you find it easier to pay for fuel as you use it. 
 You can also get a loan for the cost of reconnection of fuel supply after a debt has been paid, and for essential household equipment such as a cooker or heating appliance. 
 Social fund officers are expected to give high priority to requests for loans for the above purposes. 
 Budgeting loans are paid back by weekly deductions from benefit.  
 Crisis loans  are to help pay for things needed urgently because of an emergency or disaster. 
 You do not need to be on income support to get a crisis loan but you must be able to show that it is the only means of preventing serious risk to you or your partner's health and safety. 
 You also have no money, savings or other resources which you can use. 
 Crisis loans are repaid by weekly deductions from benefit. 
 Community Care Grants  are to enable people to establish or maintain themselves in the community rather than having to be in hospitals, nursing homes and residential care homes etc. 
 You must be on income support or be expected to get income support when you move into the community. 
 Grants may be made for items such as the installation of a prepayment meter, reconnection charges and essential household equipment such as cookers and heaters. 
 Community care grants do not have to be repaid. 
 Cold Weather Payments  are also made from the social fund. 
 They are grants intended to help you meet the cost of extra fuel used in very cold weather. 
 They do not have to be paid back. 
 If you are on income support and aged 60 or over you will automatically receive &pound;6 for any consecutive period of seven days when the average temperature is 0 degrees celsius or below. 
 Further details about income support and the social fund are explained in factsheet No. 25, Income Support &mdash; Regular Weekly Income  available free from Age Concern England on receipt of a large s.a.e. 
 HOUSING BENEFIT AND HEATING CHARGES 
 Some people pay a fixed amount for their (heating, hot water, cooking and lighting) fuel bills in their rent. 
 Normally you will have to pay this fixed amount, even if you get a full rent rebate. 
 Example: &mdash; If your rent is &pound;20, which includes &pound;5 for fuel, the maximum help you can get is &pound;15. (&pound;20-pound; 5 = &pound;15). 
 If you are getting income support and you have high fuel charges at a fixed rate, you will not have to pay more than a maximum fixed amount. 
 For further information on this contact your local housing benefit office.  
 GRANTS FOR INSULATION AND DRAUGHT-PROOFING 
 If you receive income support, housing benefit, community charge benefit or family credit, and if you are an owneroccupier, private tenant or housing association tenant, you may be able to get a minor works grant from the council. 
 This can cover the whole cost of draught-proofing, getting your loft insulated, having your pipes and tanks lagged, and possibly wall insulation and secondary glazing. 
 Unfortunately minor works grants are only &bquo;discretionary&equo;, ie it is up to the council whether or not you receive help. 
 To apply, get an application form from the improvement grants section of your council. 
 Do not buy any materials until you have been told you can have a grant by the council, and once you have, keep any receipts. 
 Home Energy Efficiency Scheme 
 From 1 January 1991, if you receive income support, housing benefit, family credit or community charge benefit, you can get a grant under the Home Energy Efficiency Scheme  (HEES). 
 These grants are available for loft, pipe, and hot and cold water tank insulation, draught-proofing and basic energy advice. 
 You can get a grant for loft insulation up to 150mm if you have less than 50mm. 
 You can do the work yourself, use a &bquo;network installer&equo;, or get the work carried out by a contractor. 
 The size of the grant will depend on the work you have done, and who does it. 
 The maximum grant is &pound;270, and you will have to pay a fixed contribution towards the cost, up to a maximum of &pound;15. 
 For details of grants available and how to claim them, contact the Energy Action Grants Agency, Newcastle-upon-Tyne NE1 1JL. 
 Who can do the work 
 The Energy Action Grants Agency has appointed approved network installers to work in all areas of the country. 
 Because network installers have to satisfy certain standards of workmanship and quality, you can be confident that any work will be done efficiently and well. 
 In addition the network installer will be able to advise you on the most efficient energy use for your home. 
 For details of your local network installer ring: &mdash; Freephone 0800 181 667 . 
 If you prefer to have a private contractor do the work make sure they are a member of the following relevant trade associations:  
 Loft Insulation 
 National Association of Loft Insulation Contractors, PO Box 12, Haslemere, Surrey GU27 3AN. 
 Cavity Wall Insulation 
 National Cavity Insulation Association, PO Box 12, Haslemere, Surrey GU27 3AN. 
 Cavity Foam Bureau, PO Box 79, Oldbury, Warley, West Midlands B69 4BW. 
 EASY WAYS TO SAVE ENERGY 
 Although insulation and draught-proofing are the best ways to save money on heating bills, there are many other things you can do which, when combined, can make substantial savings. 
 If you have central heating: 
 let the room thermostat control the temperature, DON'T  use it as a switch 
 turning the room thermostat up WON'T  heat the room up faster. 
 A higher boiler  temperature will  heat the house faster, but will use more fuel. 
 don't open windows to cool rooms &mdash; lower thermostat setting or turn down individual radiators if overheating is a problem. 
 have the boiler serviced annually, because like a car it will become less efficient at using fuel after prolonged use. 
 stick kitchen foil &mdash; shiny side facing into the room &mdash; behind radiators on outside walls. 
 don't block radiators or air vents with furniture. 
 don't have curtains in front of radiators. 
 fit small shelves above radiators; they will deflect the rising warm air towards the centre of the room. 
 individual thermostatic radiator valves can be used to control the temperature of each radiator individually. 
 If you don't have them, use manual valves to adjust the radiators or turn them off in rooms not in use. 
 OTHER TIPS 
 Save washing-up for a once-a-day blitz. 
 Rinse dishes in cold water. 
 Don't wash under a running tap. 
 Repair dripping hot taps. 
 Use the right size pan to cover the burner or ring. 
 Don't over-fill kettles &mdash; heat just enough water for your needs. 
 GAS AND ELECTRICITY CODE OF PRACTICE 
 British Gas, and the local electricity companies (from the end of 1990), each have a number of codes of practice, setting out their terms of supply, how you can pay your bill, and the services that they offer. 
 You should be able to get copies of these codes of practice by telephoning your local British Gas office or electricity company, or by calling in at the nearest showroom. 
 PAYMENT SCHEMES FOR GAS AND ELECTRICITY 
 If you are worried about being unable to pay your next bill, it may help to pay through one of the payment schemes operated by the fuel industries. 
 There may be variations in the schemes operated locally, so it is best to check with your local gas or electricity showroom. 
 The main schemes are listed below. 
 1. 
 Prepayment or &bquo;Slot&equo; Meter 
 Both the local gas region and the electricity company can offer you a prepayment meter where it is safe and practical to put one in, although some local fuel boards have been reluctant to offer pre-payment meters to people who are not in debt. 
 (A slot meter may not be practical, for example, with a gas central heating boiler which goes out every time the money runs out and needs to be re-lit when more money is put in the meter. 
 Modern gas appliances with electric ignitions are suitable for use with a slot-meter). 
 Having a slot meter means that you pay for your fuel as you use it and do not have to worry about large quarterly bills. 
 However, the price of gas and electricity for slot meters is generally higher than for quarterly billing . 
 If you are worried about your slot meter being broken into, you can insure the contents under Age Concern England's &bquo;Meter Insurance Scheme&equo; (for the address see WHERE TO GO FOR FURTHER HELP  Pages 10&ndash;11). 
 Some electricity companies may be able to offer you a token meter, operated by a token or rechargeable key depending on the type available. 
 Purchases of tokens (&pound;1 or sometimes &pound;5 minimum) can be made at electricity showrooms or offices. 
 Token meters are also available from most gas regions. 
 If you have a disability which makes it difficult to use your slot meter, electricity companies will usually move it free of charge. 
 British Gas will move a coin, token or credit meter up to a meter from its present position free of charge if you find it difficult to use (see Page  no number stated  for information on adaptations for meters and appliances). 
 2. 
 Monthly Budget Scheme 
 This scheme means that instead of paying quarterly bills you pay the same amount into your electricity or gas account each month. 
 Your yearly consumption is estimated, and the cost of the fuel spread out evenly throughout the year. 
 Payment can be made automatically through a bank or building society. 
 Alternatively, vouchers are supplied and payment may be made by cash or cheque at banks and showrooms. 
 Some electricity companies and gas regions offer weekly budget schemes. 
 A disadvantage of budget schemes is that if your fuel consumption is underestimated, you may have a large sum to pay out at the end of the year. 
 Also it may mean that you have to pay in advance. 
 3. 
 Saving Stamps 
 You can buy stamps, usually worth &pound;1.00 from local showrooms and use them to pay all or part of the quarterly bill. 
 You can use gas stamps to pay your electricity bill and electricity stamps to pay for your gas bill. 
 However, you cannot exchange your stamps for cash. 
 You can also buy savings stamps from some sub-post offices. 
 4. 
 Flexible Payments 
 Most gas regions and electricity companies will make arrangements for you to pay what you like when you like towards your next  bill. 
 Again, a possible disadvantage is that you must pay in advance. 
 If you are unsure about any of these schemes, or want further advice, please see WHERE TO GO FOR FURTHER HELP  (Pages 10&ndash;11). 
 DISCONNECTION 
 If you are threatened with disconnection or are already disconnected, it is useful to know the protection given under the Gas and Electricity Codes of Practice to consumers in &bquo;hardship&equo;. 
 If you require advice on the protection offered by the Codes, contact your local Citizens Advice Bureau, Age Concern group or Neighbourhood Advice Centre, see WHERE TO GO FOR FURTHER HELP  (Pages 10&ndash;11). 
 Be sure to contact the supplier as soon as possible. 
 1. 
 If all the people living in your house who have incomes are over pensionable age (60 years for women and 65 years for men), you will not be disconnected between October 1 and March 31 unless it is clear that you have sufficient money to pay. 
 2. 
 If you are over retirement age, disabled, or sick, disconnection can be delayed for 14 days or more (21 days in the case of gas) if you inform the fuel boards that you are contacting the Department of Social Security (D.S.S.) or Social Services for help. 
 For details of the help available from these agencies, see HEATING COSTS, INCOME SUPPORT AND THE SOCIAL FUND  (Pages 2&ndash;3) and SERVICES PROVIDED BY THE FUEL INDUSTRIES AND ASSISTANCE FROM SOCIAL SERVICES  (Pages 8&ndash;9). 
 3. 
 You can avoid disconnection or be reconnected by entering into a payment arrangement that is reasonable in all the circumstances. 
 Such an arrangement might be: 
 a) 
 The installation of a slot meter : (See PAYMENT SCHEMES FOR GAS AND ELECTRICITY  Page 6). 
 The industries &bquo;calibrate&equo; the meter to collect any debt you may owe, so you would be paying above the going rate in order to pay your bill. 
 This calibration should always take into account how much you can afford to pay. 
 If you are going to pay off a debt through a prepayment meter, you should get advice from a Citizen's Advice Bureau who will be able to negotiate with the supplier to &bquo;calibrate&equo; the meter to pay  of  any debt at a rate you can afford. 
 In most cases, the industries will not charge for installing a slot meter if you are in &bquo;hardship&equo;. 
 In other cases, if you receive Income Support you may be able to get a loan from the social fund to meet the cost of installing a prepayment meter. 
 For more information see HEATING COSTS, INCOME SUPPORT AND THE SOCIAL FUND  (Page 2). 
 b) 
 The Fuel Direct  scheme. 
 This is only possible for those receiving Income Support. 
 It means that money to pay for your current fuel consumption, and towards the arrears you owe, is taken from your benefit each week and paid direct to your fuel account. 
 For further advice about this, see WHERE TO GO FOR FURTHER HELP  (Pages 10&ndash;11). 
 If you decide to go on the scheme you must enquire at your local Social Security Office to see if you are eligible. 
 Tell the fuel supplier as well.  
 c) 
 An agreement to pay a regular amount each week . 
 You can make an arrangement to pay off the bill and your current consumption, by regular payments to the fuel supplier. 
 But you are only protected as long as you keep your side of the arrangement. 
 However, if your circumstances change, and you cannot keep to an arrangement, tell the fuel supplier, who should not cut you off without offering you another arrangement or a pre-payment meter. 
 Again you should get advice from your local Citizen's Advice Bureau, to negotiate a level of debt repayment you can afford. 
 (For the address and other sources of help see WHERE TO GO FOR FURTHER HELP  (Pages 10&ndash;11). 
 You cannot be disconnected for a Hire Purchase debt, a Credit Sale Agreement, or a debt for anything other than supply of gas and or electricity. 
 Nor should you be disconnected for a debt owed by a previously registered consumer, but you must have made proper arrangements with the fuel boards to take over the supply. 
 5. 
 If your fuel bill debt is in the name of your landlord, and you pay him for your electricity or gas, you should let your fuel supplier and local council know this is the case. 
 The fuel supplier will also tell the council. 
 Your supply will not be cut off for at least fourteen days (21 in the case of gas) to give the council time to help. 
 SERVICES PROVIDED BY THE FUEL INDUSTRIES AND ASSISTANCE FROM SOCIAL SERVICES 
 You can get advice from your local electricity company or gas region on various aspects of heating. 
 1. 
 Both give general advice on the best way to use appliances, and on how the effectiveness of your heating system could be improved. 
 Both Gas regions and electricity companies can advise on adaptations available for disabled people, e.g. for slot meters or appliances, which can often be fitted free of charge. 
 You can arrange for a visit from a Home Service Adviser (gas regions) or Energy Marketing Team (electricity companies) by contacting your local showroom. 
 2. 
 You can get a free safety check on gas appliances and installations from British Gas if:  your  are over 60 years of age and you live alone or with someone who also qualifies; you are a registered disabled person of any age and you live alone, or with someone who also qualifies; or you receive a state disability benefit and you live alone or with someone who also qualifies. 
 This check will show whether your gas appliances and installations are safe to use. 
 The check consists of a basic examination and includes any necessary adjustments, and materials up to a cost of &pound;2.50 plus VAT. 
 One free gas check is available in any period of 12 months. 
 This check is not  a substitute for servicing.  
 If your appliance is dangerous, the engineer has to disconnect it by law. 
 If this happens, he will give you written information about what has been done, and where you can get advice or assistance. 
 Also ask him for the telephone number of the Home Service Adviser for your area, in case you need further advice. 
 You can also contact your local Social Services Department, who may be able to help in a number of ways. 
 a) 
 If you are disconnected, they may be able to lend you heating, cooking and lighting appliances (such as Calor Gas fires and cookers). 
 b) 
 They may arrange for you to have short stay daytime, or full time care at a day centre or residential home if you are without heat and light at home. 
 c) 
 If you are disabled, the Social Services Department can give you gadgets to enable you to operate various appliances. 
 There is normally no charge for these. 
 3. 
 Some electricity companies do free visual wiring checks for elderly or disabled people. 
 They may also agree to re-site appliances for disabled people at reduced cost. 
 It is best to check with your local company for information about the services they offer. 
 WHERE TO GO FOR FURTHER HELP 
 Enquiries about the social fund, (Page 2) income support (Page 2) and fuel direct (Page 8) should be made at the local office of the Department of Social Security . 
 The address is in the telephone book under &bquo;Social Security&equo;. 
 You can get advice on general heating problems by calling at your local Citizens Advice Bureau  (look in the telephone book under &bquo;C&equo;) or Neighbourhood Advice Centre . 
 They may help to negotiate with the fuel suppliers on your behalf where disputes arise. 
 Your local Age Concern  group may be able to inform you of the help available in the area to assist you with your fuel or heating problem. 
 Details of local Age Concern groups can be found in the telephone book under &bquo;Age Concern&equo; or &bquo;Old People's Welfare Council&equo;. 
 If you cannot find an address of the local group, ask your local Citizens Advice Bureau, local library, or write to Age Concern England, Astral House, 1268 London Road, London SW16 4ER, Tel: (081) 679 8000. 
 For details of Age Concern England's meter insurance scheme contact your local Age Concern group or write to Alexander Stenhouse (UK) Ltd, Grosvenor House, 65&ndash;71 London Road, Redhill, Surrey, RH1 1YN, Tel: (0737) 774177.  
 The addresses of local Energy Projects  who may be able to help with draught-proofing and insulation, can be obtained from local advice agencies, or by writing to Neighbourhood Energy Action at 2/4, Bigg Market, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, NE1 1UW. 
 If you require the help of your local Social Services Department  they can be contacted through your local Town Hall. 
 For further details of the services that the fuel industries can provide, contact your local electricity or gas showrooms. 
 The address will be in the telephone book under &bquo;Electricity&equo; or &bquo;Gas&equo;. 
 In case of disputes, you can contact your local Gas Consumers Council , who may refer your complaint to OFGAS  (the Office of Gas Supply); OFGAS can be contacted at Southside, 105 Victoria Street, London SW1E 6QT. 
 OFFER (the Office of Electricity Regulation) can be contacted at Hagley House, Hagley Road, Birmingham B16 8QG. 
 The addresses of your local Consumer and Consultative Councils is on the back of your fuel bill. 
 A Winter Warmthline  &mdash; run by Age Concern, Help the Aged and Neighbourhood Energy Action provides information on heating and can be contacted on Freephone 0800 289404.  
 Finding Help at Home 
 September 1991 
 Age Concern England receives many requests for information about finding help at home. 
 You may be an older person living on your own or in someone else's home, or a relative or friend helping to look after an elderly person. 
 You may be looking for light domestic help one or two hours per week, or 24-hour a day care. 
 Or you may be a carer looking for help to enable you to take a break, either for regular short spells, or to go on holiday or in an emergency. 
 In this factsheet we suggest possible sources of help for services or improvements to you home; suggest ways of finding companions or live-in help; and list some benefits which may assist you in paying for help. 
 Organisations mentioned in the factsheet are listed in the final section. 
 To obtain Age Concern England factsheets mentioned here, send a 9&ins; &times; 6&ins; sae to the Information and Policy Department, Age Concern England, Astral House, 1268 London Road, London SW16 4ER, stating which factsheet(s) you would like to receive. 
 Please note : As Scottish law and service provision differ from those in England and Wales, Scottish readers should contact Age Concern Scotland at 54A Fountainbridge, Edinburgh EH3 9PT (Tel: 031&ndash;228 5656). 
 CONTENTS 
 1. 
 PERSONAL SOCIAL SERVICES AND HEALTH 
 Social Services Department 
 Family doctor &amp; community health services 
 Local Age Concern groups 
 Hospital discharge schemes 
 Bereavement 
 2. 
 HELP WITH HOUSING 
 3. 
 PAYING FOR CARE 
 4. 
 A COMPANION AT HOME 
 5. 
 EMPLOYMENT OR NURSING AGENCIES 
 6. 
 FURTHER HELP OR ADVICE &mdash; NATIONAL ORGANISATIONS  
 PERSONAL SOCIAL SERVICES AND HEALTH 
 If you are having a problem coping at home, you should first get in touch with your local social services department, or your family doctor, to see if they can give you some advice or support. 
 Social Services Department 
 Your local social services department  should be able to advise you about help which it may provide or know about. 
 The main types of services likely to be offered are described below. 
 There may be charges for some or all of these services, depending on your income, but it is certainly worth asking about what may be available. 
 To contact the social services about what may be available. 
 To contact the social services department, look in your local telephone directory under the name of your local council (county or metropolitan borough), or ask at the library, town hall or Citizens Advice Bureau. 
 Under the terms of the 1986 Disabled Persons Act, the social services department must assess the needs for day services and services at home of people who are disabled. 
 The person or someone on their behalf can ask for the assessment. 
 The social services department should also tell you about services provided by itself or other services known to it which could be of use to you. 
 What can the social services department do to help? 
 All local authority social services departments offer different kinds of help and support. 
 Each authority has its own ways of deciding how much, if anything, you will have to pay. 
 This factsheet can only suggest some of the ways in which they may help you. 
 Many areas have special schemes which fit in with the particular needs of individual people at home. 
 Make sure that you talk to a number of people to find out whether what you need is available. 
 Talk to your local councillor as well, if you feel there is a need which is not being met. 
 Here are some of the most commonly known services. 
 Also listed are some other places where these services may be provided, or where you can get more information. 
 aids and adaptations: 
 &bquo;Aids&equo; to living are gadgets or equipment which may help you if you have a problem in managing certain tasks. 
 They include for example special taps for people who have difficulty with normal ones. 
 There are special amplifiers for telephones and televisions, for people with hearing problems. 
 Magnifiers are available for partially sighted people. 
 &bquo;Aids&equo; are available to help people pull themselves out of bed, or to put on stockings. 
 There are many more, including wheelchairs, sticks, commodes, special non-slip trays, and bath seats.  
 An occupational therapist from the social services department may be able to tell you about aids which could help you. 
 Some aids may be available on loan from the Red Cross, Age Concern groups, the WRVS or other organisations. 
 &bquo;Adaptations&equo; are changes to your home to help you to get about or to manage better. 
 They include stair or grab rails; handles in the toilet or bathroom; or a ramp to the front or back door. 
 They may include more major alterations, such as widening a door for a wheelchair. 
 An occupational therapist may also advise you about these. 
 Further information : Carers National Association Fact Sheet 1, &bquo;How to find out about gadgets and equipment to daily living&equo;. 
 Available free on receipt of sae from the Carers National Association. 
 Disabled Living Foundation or Disabled Living Centres. 
 Royal Association for Disability and Rehabilitation; Royal National Institute for the Blind; Royal National Institute for the Deaf. 
 (See also p7 for information about home improvements, including alterations) 
 alarm systems: 
 Some older people who live alone or who cannot get out appreciate the security of knowing that they can contact someone in an emergency. 
 Many different kinds of alarm schemes are available. 
 Some are provided by council housing or social services departments. 
 Others are offered by private firms. 
 Further information : &bquo;Alarms for Elderly People: a folder of information&equo;. 
 Price &pound;1.50. 
 Available from Research Institute for Consumer Affairs, 2 Marylebone Road, London NW1 4DX. 
 Help the Aged Community Alarms Department offers advice on alarms. 
 In certain circumstances, they can consider helping with the cost. 
 Contact: Help the Aged (Community Alarms Department). 
 day care: 
 There are many different kinds of day care outside a person's home. 
 Some offer a chance to meet other people and share activities and a meal; others offer specialist care, for instance to people with dementia. 
 Some areas have day care available at weekends, or for long days so that a carer can go out to work. 
 In rural areas, day care may be provided in mobile centres. 
 Ask what is available in your area. 
 If you feel that there is a need for a particular kind of care, ask whether it might be arranged.  
 Further information : local Age Concern group (many Age Concern groups provide day care); local Alzheimer's Disease Society group; local stroke group; local carers group; social services department. 
 home help, or home care assistant: 
 Home helps have traditionally provided help with household tasks, shopping, and other practical help. 
 Some local authorities no longer offer the traditional &bquo;cleaning&equo; service. 
 Instead, many social services departments are now introducing a new type of service, offering more &bquo;care&equo; to people who need a lot of help and assistance. 
 Some Age Concern groups are setting up schemes for home care, in cooperation with the local authority. 
 There may be a Crossroads Care Attendant scheme in your area, which can provide regular help to give relief to carers. 
 In some areas, private agencies offer help at home (see p10). 
 Further information : local Age Concern group; social services department; Association of Crossroads Care Attendant Schemes. 
 laundry: 
 Some social service departments provide a laundry service for people with incontinence, or who cannot manage their laundry for other reasons. 
 Ask if such a service is available in your area. 
 meals on wheels: 
 There are many different kinds of meals on wheels services. 
 Some are run by Age Concern or WRVS groups for the council. 
 Many offer meals for special diets. 
 Some provide a freezer for people at home, and then deliver frozen meals so that people can heat their own, when they wish. 
 Meals on wheels may be offered any number of days per week. 
 What is available to you will depend on your needs and on the policy of the local authority. 
 Further information : social services department; local Age Concern group; WRVS. 
 respite care: 
 Respite means taking a break. 
 Respite care is often available to give the carer and the person cared for a break from each other. 
 It could be for a night, or a day, or longer &mdash; for example, a week or two weeks. 
 It may be possible to arrange respite care in the person's own home, or in a residential care or nursing home or hospital. 
 Ask for further information.  
 Further information : local Age Concern group; local Alzheimer's Disease Society group; local carers group, general practitioner, social services department. 
 &bquo;Taking a Break: a guide for people caring at home&equo;. 
 This is a booklet providing information on all types of breaks, both at home and away from home. 
 Price: free to carers, 60p to others. 
 Bulk orders: 10 copies &pound;4; 100 copies &pound;30. 
 Available from Department KFP, Bailey Distribution Ltd., Learoyd Road, Mountfield Industrial Estate, New Romney, Kent TN28 8XU. 
 Cheques to be made payable to Bailey Distribution Ltd. 
 See Age Concern England Factsheet 4, Holidays for Older People . 
 sitting schemes: 
 There is a number of &bquo;sitting&equo; schemes run by social services departments or others which may help a carer to take a break. 
 Arrangements are made for a person to &bquo;sit in&equo; in the older person's home. 
 This could be on a regular basis, for example once a week, or could be available in an emergency. 
 Ask whether there is a scheme in your area. 
 Further information : local Age Concern group; local Alzheimer's Disease Society group; local carers group; social services department. 
 telephones: 
 If you need help with the cost of installing a telephone, you may be able to get help from the social services department. 
 Some charities also provide help. 
 If you have difficulty using standard telephone equipment, British Telecom can provide information and advice on adaptations and equipment. 
 Further information : British Telecom; Disabled Living Foundation. 
 See also: Age Concern England Factsheet 28, Help with Telephones . 
 Family doctor and community health services 
 Your family doctor  should be able to put you in touch with community health services. 
 If necessary, arrangements can usually be made for you to be seen at home. 
 The kinds of people who may help or services which may be available include:  
 district nurse or health visitor 
 chiropodist 
 continence advisor 
 physiotherapist 
 community psychiatric nurse 
 hospice at home or Macmillan nurse 
 Further information : Your local community health council is an organisation which helps people who may need more information about local health services. 
 You can find their address at the local Citizens Advice Bureau, or in the telephone directory under &bquo;community health council&equo;. 
 Specialist nursing or care at home for people with a terminal illness may be available through Macmillan nurses, provided by Cancer Relief, and Marie Curie Foundation nurses, or from a local hospice. 
 Ask your doctor if there is local support of this kind. 
 See also: Age Concern Factsheet 23, Help with Incontinence , and Factsheet 5, Dental Care in Retirement . 
 Local Age Concern groups 
 The local Age Concern group or Old People's Welfare Council group  may be able to tell you about special services in your area, which they or other groups run. 
 There may be support groups, for example for stroke sufferers, or carers. 
 They may also know of people seeking work for a few hours or days per week, perhaps to help out with the garden, or heavier household tasks, or shopping. 
 They may arrange transport, or visiting services. 
 They may provide day care. 
 The address and telephone number of your local group should be listed in the telephone directory or is available from Age Concern England. 
 Hospital discharge schemes 
 Many older people need help in the period after being discharged from hospital. 
 Some Age Concern groups, social services departments and other organisations run a variety of hospital discharge schemes which can help people over the first few days or weeks after a stay in hospital. 
 Ask if such a scheme is available in your area. 
 Further information : local Age Concern group; social services department; community health council; hospital social worker. 
 Bereavement 
 You or someone you look after may have suffered a recent bereavement. 
 This is understandably a very difficult time which may be helped by support or counselling. 
 Some people show signs of confusion because of the shock of bereavement. 
 Others feel that they can't carry on by themselves. 
 Help at this time may help you or the person you look after to remain at home as confidence is slowly regained in managing in a new situation.  
 Further information : local Age Concern group; social services department; family doctor; hospital social worker. 
 Cruse &mdash; Bereavement Care is a national charity which runs a counselling service for all bereaved people throughout the UK, offering understanding, advice and information. 
 HELP WITH HOUSING 
 Repairs or improvements 
 Agency services  such as &bquo;Staying Put&equo; or &bquo;Care and Repair&equo; give advice and practical assistance to older home owners who need to repair or improve their home. 
 They may also be able to tell you about local organisations which give practical help with gardening or decorating. 
 Further information : local Age Concern group; the local council's renovation grants section (the borough or district council, not  the county council). 
 If you are a private tenant  and you are having problems getting the landlord to carry out repairs, seek advice from : a Citizens Advice Bureau, housing advice centre, or the environmental health department of your borough or district council. 
 Grants for repairs or improvements 
 The local council can give grants to home owners to cover all or part of the cost of getting repair and improvement work done. 
 The size of the grant you get depends on your income. 
 Some work, such as putting in an inside toilet or repairing dangerous electric wiring, qualifies for a mandatory  grant, which means that the council has to give a grant if you qualify on income grounds. 
 Other types of work may qualify for a discretionary  grant, which means it is up to the council whether you get a grant. 
 Minor works grants  of up to &pound;1,000 are available to home owners or private tenants over the age of 60 who are in receipt of Income Support, Community Charge Benefit, or Housing Benefit. 
 Disabled facilities grants  cover all or part of the cost of adaptation work, such as putting in a downstairs toilet. 
 Some types of work attract mandatory grants. 
 The renovation grants section must consult the local social services department, and will normally arrange for an occupational therapist to visit you to assess your needs. 
 The size of the grant you get depends on your income.  
 Social services departments may also be able to help you pay for work not covered by disabled facilities grants, and can also provide additional facilities to make the property safer, more comfortable and more convenient. 
 Further information : Royal Association for Disability and Rehabilitation (RADAR). 
 See also: Age Concern England Factsheet 13, Older Home Owners &mdash; Financial Help with Repairs . 
 PAYING FOR CARE 
 There are some social security benefits which may help you to pay for care. 
 These are briefly described here. 
 Attendance Allowance 
 People who require help with their personal needs or bodily functions, or to avoid danger to themselves or others, may be eligible for Attendance Allowance, which is paid regardless of age or income, and is tax free. 
 Attendance Allowance is paid at a lower rate to people who require personal care or attention by day or  night, and at a higher rate to those requiring care by day and  night. 
 It can be paid to individuals who live alone, but who still require a high level of personal care. 
 Further information  and an application form in leaflet DS2, available from local offices of the Department of Social Security (DSS). 
 See also: Counsel and Care, Factsheet 11, Attendance Allowance for People over Pensionable Age . 
 Free on receipt of 9&ins; &times; 6&ins; sae. 
 In April 1992, for people disabled before the age of 65 Attendance Allowance will be replaced by a new benefit &mdash; the &bquo;Disability Living Allowance&equo;. 
 People disabled after the age of 65 will still be able to claim Attendance Allowance. 
 Contact Age Concern England for further details. 
 Invalid Care Allowance 
 A benefit paid to people under 65 who spend 35 hours or more per week looking after someone who receives Attendance Allowance. 
 You may not receive any extra money if you or your spouse already receive a state benefit, and your taxable earnings should not be more than &pound;30 per week after the deduction of reasonable expenses. 
 Further information : Leaflet DS700 from local offices of the DSS.  
 See also: Carers National Association, Leaflet 5: Invalid Care Allowance. 
 The rules explained . 
 Available free. 
 Income support 
 If you have a low income and no more than &pound;8,000 savings, you may qualify for Income Support, which is paid weekly and tops up any Income you have to a level set by the Government. 
 If you are looking for respite care for short periods, or convalescent care, you may qualify for some help through Income Support if you have less than &pound;8,000 in savings. 
 Further information : Age Concern Factsheet 25, Income Support and the Social Fund , and Factsheet 11, Income Support for Residential and Nursing Homes . 
 Local DSS office; local Citizens Advice Bureau or Age Concern group. 
 Independent Living Fund 
 If you are very severely disabled, you may be able to get a grant from the Independent Living Fund. 
 This is a discretionary trust fund which was set up to give financial help to people who need to pay for personal care or domestic assistance in order to remain living independently in their own homes. 
 Whether you can get help or not will depend on your needs and your income and savings, and whether there is anybody else who can provide the help that you need. 
 People aged over 16 and receiving higher Attendance Allowance are eligible to apply. 
 Information and application forms available from The Independent Living Fund, PO Box 183, Nottingham NG8 3RD. 
 Further information about financial help: 
 Counsel and Care  factsheets Help at Home  and Which Charity  describe the above listed benefits and other sources of help. 
 The Association of Charity Officers  may be able to give advice about grants or statutory benefits. 
 See also: Age Concern England's annual publication, Your Rights: a guide to money benefits for older people . 
 Price &pound;2.15. 
 Available from the Marketing Department, Age Concern England. 
 A Guide to Grants for Individuals in Need  edited by Mike and Nikki Eastwood. 1990 edition. 
 Price &pound;12.95. 
 Available from Directory of Social Change, Radius Works, Back Lane, London NW3 1HL. 
 This may be available in your local library.  
 Disability Rights Handbook . 
 Price &pound;4.50. 
 Available from the Disability Alliance ERA, 25 Denmark Street, London WC2H 8NJ. 
 Benefit Enquiry Line . 
 This free DSS telephone line can provide information about benefits to disabled people and their family or carers. 
 Tel: 0800 882 200. 
 A COMPANION AT HOME 
 Some older people feel that they could manage at home if there were someone else living in their home, perhaps helping with light care tasks, or just &bquo;keeping a watchful eye&equo;. 
 Some people feel their home is too big for one or two, but do not wish to move. 
 It is sometimes possible to find a companion, or &bquo;living-in help&equo;. 
 Some local agencies may be able to help you, or you might consider advertising in local newspapers, magazines or church journals. 
 The following national publications may prove useful: 
 The Lady 39&ndash;40 Bedford Street London WC2E 9ER Tel: 071&ndash;379 4717 Published weekly; classified ads not accepted by telephone 
 Choice Magazine Apex House Oundle Road Peterborough PE2 9NP Tel: (0733) 555123 Published monthly 
 Daily Telegraph South Quay 181 Marsh Wall London E14 9SR Tel: 071&ndash;538 5000 Published Mon&ndash;Sat 
 If you do advertise for a companion it is advisable to use a box number and also to take up references. 
 You should carefully consider the duties you require of a companion and write a &bquo;job description&equo; so that there is no misunderstanding by either party as to what is expected. 
 You may wish to seek legal advice on whether a contract could be drawn up. 
 Further information: Recruiting and employing a personal care worker  by M Dunne. 
 Price &pound;2.25. 
 Available from Disablement Income Group, Millmead Business Centre, Millmead Road, London N17 9QU. 
 EMPLOYMENT OR NURSING AGENCIES 
 There is a number of private agencies which will recruit and place living-in companions and daily or longer-term nurses or care workers. 
 Some helpers will not undertake more than light household duties, and heavy washing, ironing and cleaning will have to be done by someone else. 
 In order to provide &bquo;permanent&equo; help, many agencies operate a rota system with the carers working for a period of one or two weeks or a month, and then changing over in a planned way with another carer. 
 This ensures continuity with more than one worker, where it may be difficult to find one person to live in permanently. 
 Each agency has its own system for placing staff, and charges and style of service vary considerably. 
 Agencies may charge an agency or booking fee, and staff may be self-employed and responsible for their own tax and national insurance contributions.  
 Further information: Local agencies  will be listed in the Yellow Pages of the telephone directory under &bquo;Employment Agencies and Consultants&equo; or &bquo;Nurses and Nursing&equo;. 
 Or contact: The United Kingdom Home Care Association. 
 FURTHER HELP OR ADVICE 
 You may not be able to find the help you would like in your area. 
 We list here some other places where you may be able to obtain help or advice. 
 We are not able to list all the available sources of help in this factsheet, but we hope that these suggestions will help you to find the help that you need. 
 Alzheimer's Disease Society , 158&ndash;160 Balham High Road, London SW12 9BN. 
 (Tel: 081&ndash;675 6557/8/9/0) Supports families, provides information about all forms of dementia, runs local groups for patients and their relatives. 
 Arthritis Care , 5 Grosvenor Crescent, London SW1 X 7ER. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;235 0902) Advice and information, and over 510 branches, for people with arthritis and their families. 
 Arthritis Care Wyeth Helpline, a freephone advice service, is available on weekdays 1&ndash;5 p.m., on 0800 289 170. 
 Association of Crossroads Care Attendant Schemes , 10 Regent Place, Rugby, Warwickshire CV21 2PN. 
 (Tel: (0788) 573653) About 190 schemes in the UK which aim to relieve carers. 
 To find out if there is a scheme in your area, contact the national organisation. 
 British Diabetic Association , 10 Queen Anne Street, London W1M OBD. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;323 1531) Help for all diabetics and their families; branches across the UK. 
 British Red Cross Society , 9 Grosvenor Crescent, London SW1 7EJ. 
 (Tel: 071 235 5454) Services mainly provided by volunteers and available from local centres: home nursing, transport, holidays, equipment loan for frail elderly people and others with disabilities. 
 British Telecom . 
 Dial 150, ask for Freephone Telecom Sales, and ask for the Action for Disabled Customers Liaison Officer. 
 Carers National Association  (or &bquo;Carers&equo;), 29 Chilworth Mews, London W2 3RG. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;724 7776) General help and advice for all carers.  
 Chest, Heart and Stroke Association , CHSA House, Whitecross Street, London EC1Y 8JJ. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;490 7999) Helps sufferers of asthma, bronchitis, emphysema, tuberculosis, angina, coronary thrombosis, hypertension and stroke illness. 
 Counselling and welfare services. 
 Lists available of stroke and cardiac support and rehabilitation groups. 
 Cruse &mdash; Bereavement Care , Cruse House, 126 Sheen Road, Richmond, Surrey TW9 1UR. 
 (Tel: 081&ndash;940 4818) A counselling service for bereaved people throughout the UK. 
 Counsel &amp; Care , Twyman House, 16 Bonny Street, London NW1 9LR. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;485 1566, weekdays 10.30&ndash;4.00) A general advice agency for elderly people. 
 Case workers may be able to advise on grants or local agencies which may be able to provide help. 
 Covers England mainly, but also Scotland and Wales. 
 Disabled Living Centres  (see Disabled Living Foundation) 
 Disabled Living Foundation , 380&ndash;384 Harrow Road, London W9 2HU. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;289 6111) Information service about equipment for daily living. 
 Specialist advisory service on clothing. 
 Incontinence Advisory Service (see below). 
 Information about Disabled Living Centres in the UK. 
 Help the Aged  (Community Alarms Scheme), 16/18 St James's Walk, London EC1R 0BE. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;253 0253) Information about personal alarm systems. 
 The Holiday Care Service , 2 Old Bank Chambers, Station Road, Horley, Surrey, RH6 9HW. 
 (Tel: (0293) 774535) Free information and support on holidays for people who are old or disabled, or on a low income. 
 Please enclose large sae if writing for information. 
 Hospice Information Service , St Christopher's Hospice, 51&ndash;59 Lawrie Park Road, Sydenham, London SE26 6DZ. 
 (Tel: 081&ndash;778 9252) Information on hospices in UK (including home care teams). 
 Incontinence Advisory Service , 380&ndash;384 Harrow Road, London W9 2HU. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;289 6111 Mon&ndash;Thurs) Information and advice for those affected by incontinence and their carers. 
 MENCAP (Royal Society for Mentally Handicapped Children and Adults) , 123 Golden Lane, London EC1Y 0RT. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;454 0454) Support for mentally handicapped people and their families, through local branches.  
 MIND (National Association for Mental Health) , 22 Harley Street, London W1N 2ED. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;637 0741. 
 Advice lines 2&ndash;4.30 pm weekdays) Information Unit offers support for people in mental distress and their families. 
 Local groups. 
 Patients Association , 18 Victoria Park Square, Bethnal Green, London E2 9PF. 
 (Tel: 081&ndash;981 5676) Advice to patients and carers on patients' rights, complaints procedures and access to health services or appropriate self-help groups. 
 Royal Association for Disability and Rehabilitation (RADAR) , 25 Mortimer Street, London W1N 8AB. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;637 5400) Advice and information on access, housing, holidays, mobility and welfare. 
 Royal National Institute for the Blind (RNIB) , 224 Great Portland Street, London W1N 6AA. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;388 1266) Many services for people with visual handicaps. 
 Royal National Institute for the Deaf , 105 Gower Street, London WC1E 6AH. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;387 8033) Advice, information and a wide range of services. 
 United Kingdom Home Care Association , 206 Worple Road, London SW20 8PN. 
 (Tel: 081&ndash;946 8202) An association of providers of care at home, with a code of practice. 
 Lists available of member agencies and others in the UK. 
 Women's Royal Voluntary Service (WRVS) , 234&ndash;244 Stockwell Road, London SW9 9SP. 
 (Tel: 071&ndash;733 3388) A nationwide network of community services. 
 PLEASE NOTE THAT WHILE THE AGENCIES OR PUBLICATIONS MENTIONED HERE ARE KNOWN TO AGE CONCERN ENGLAND, INCLUSION IN THIS FACT SHEET DOES NOT CONSTITUTE A RECOMMENDATION BY AGE CONCERN ENGLAND FOR ANY PARTICULAR AGENCY OR PUBLICATION. 
 All rights reserved. 
 This publication may be reproduced in whole or in part in unaltered form by Age Concern groups with due acknowledgement to Age Concern England. 
 No other reproduction in any form is permitted without written permission from Age Concern England .  
 The Community Charge (Poll Tax) and Older People 
 April 1991 
 The community charge (often called the poll tax) is the system of payment towards local government services in England, Scotland and Wales, while in Northern Ireland the rates are still in place. 
 In March 1991 the Government announced that the community charge will be replaced by a new system of local tax. 
 It is planned that this will start in the year 1993&ndash;94. 
 Until then the community charge will continue. 
 Further information about recently announced changes is given on page 2. 
 This factsheet gives general information about the community charge system including details of the help available to reduce bills. 
 CONTENTS 
 Changes to the community charge system 
 What kind of community charge should you pay? 
 The personal community charge The standard community charge The collective community charge 
 Who does not have to pay the community charge? 
 How the community charge works Registration If your circumstances change Paying the community charge Penalties for non-registration and non-payment 
 The community charge reduction scheme Do you need to claim? 
 Reductions and community charge benefit How the reductions are worked out Extra help for former non-ratepayers 
 Community charge benefit (rebate) Who can get benefit? 
 How to work out if you qualify for benefit Maximum and minimum benefit Your savings Your income What you need to live on Calculating your benefit Examples How to claim benefit 
 Further information from Age Concern 
 CHANGES TO THE COMMUNITY CHARGE SYSTEM 
 On 23 April 1991 the Government announced that they intend to replace the community charge with a new &bquo;council tax&equo;. 
 Properties will be allocated to one of seven bands based on their value. 
 The tax for a property in the highest band will be about two and a half times that for one in the lowest band. 
 Where only one person lives in a property there will be a 25 per cent reduction. 
 There will still be a system of rebates for people on low incomes but there will no longer be a minimum contribution &mdash; so some people will be entitled to 100 per cent rebates. 
 There is to be a period of consultation lasting until the middle of June 1991 when individuals and organisations can put forward their views. 
 It is expected that the new system could be in place in the year 1993&ndash;94. 
 However until then the community charge will remain. 
 Details of the &bquo;community charge reduction scheme&equo; were produced in January 1991 and then modified in March 1991. 
 Like transitional relief which it has replaced, the reduction scheme is intended to help people who have faced high increases in charges because of the introduction of the community charge. 
 This scheme is explained in more detail later in this factsheet. 
 In the budget on 19 March 1991 the Chancellor announced that there would be extra Government grant to enable the community charge bills originally set by councils to be reduced by &pound;140 for every individual (or in the case of Wandsworth to reduce the bill to &pound;0). 
 People do not have to pay any of their charge until they receive this revised bill. 
 In addition to the &pound;140 reduction, some people will also qualify for a &bquo;community charge reduction&equo; and/or &bquo;community charge benefit&equo; as explained later. 
 The &pound;140 lowering of bills will be made before any community charge reduction or benefit. 
 Example 
 Mr Smith receives income support so he pays 20% of the community charge. 
 At the beginning of March his council announced that they had set the charge at &pound;400. 
 Mr Smith would have had to pay 20% of this &mdash; &pound;80 and would have received a rebate for &pound;320. 
 After the Government announcement the charge was reduced by &pound;140 to &pound;260. 
 Mr Smith now has to pay 20% of &pound;260 which is &pound;52 and he will receive &pound;208 benefit.  
 WHAT KIND OF COMMUNITY CHARGE SHOULD YOU PAY? 
 There are three types of community charge, and nearly everyone aged 18 or over will have to pay at least one of them. 
 The Personal Community Charge 
 This is the community charge which most people have to pay in the area where they live. 
 The level of charge will depend on how much the local council spends on services and the income received from central government and business rates. 
 A couple will each get a personal community charge bill. 
 If a couple is married or living together as man and wife, then they are married or living together as man and wife, then they are liable for their partner's community charge if it is not paid. 
 The Standard Community Charge 
 If you own or lease property where no-one is living you may have to pay a standard community charge in that area in addition to the personal charge in the area you live. 
 The standard charge is set by the local council, and can be zero, one half, equal to, one and a half or twice the cost of the personal community charge in the area. 
 Owners of holiday caravans will not normally have to pay a standard community charge. 
 People who own holiday homes available for rent at least 140 days a year will not have to pay a standard charge but they will be liable to pay business rates. 
 You cannot get a rebate on the standard community charge. 
 For certain classes of property the Government has laid down rules about the level of standard charge. 
 The charge will be 0 for the first 6 months that a property is empty. 
 In the situations below the charge will be 0 for an unlimited time: 
 your previous home is empty because you are permanently living in a hospital, residential or nursing home. 
 your previous home is empty because you have gone to live with someone else to provide personal care because they are elderly, ill or disabled 
 your previous home is empty because you have gone to live with someone else in order to receive personal care due to your age, illness or disability. 
 There are other classes of property not covered here. 
 Your council can also choose to extend these periods of time or set new classes of property other than the one laid down by the Government. 
 The Collective Community Charge 
 The collective community charge is paid by landlords of some properties where people normally only stay for short periods. 
 These might include some bed and breakfast hotels, lodging houses or certain types of hostel. 
 The residents will pay contributions to the landlord who will pay these to the council. 
 The local registration officer will decide when a collective community charge should be paid. 
 The collective charge has been introduced because it would be difficult to register and collect a personal charge from some people who move about very frequently.  
 In the rest of this factsheet, the community charge referred to is the personal community charge unless stated otherwise. 
 If you need more information on the other types of charge contact your council or local advice agency. 
 WHO DOES NOT HAVE TO PAY THE COMMUNITY CHARGE? 
 Although most people will have to pay the community charge, certain groups will be exempt from paying the personal or collective charge. 
 To apply for an exemption you should contact your council's Community Charge Registration Officer. 
 These are the main groups of people who will not have to pay the charge: 
 1. 
 People whose only or main residence is in hospital, or in a residential care home, nursing home or a hostel which provides a high level of care or treatment. 
 2. 
 People who are &bquo;severely mentally impaired&equo;. 
 Someone will be exempt if they have a certificate from a doctor stating that they are severely mentally impaired and are also receiving one or more of certain social security benefits including attendance allowance, severe disablement allowance, or invalidity benefit. 
 The cause of the mental impairment is not important &mdash; it could be due to a handicap from birth or due to a condition such as Alzheimer's Disease. 
 People will not be exempt because they have a physical disability. 
 3. 
 People who are members of religious communities who do not have any income of their own, and who depend upon their religious community for their livelihood. 
 4. 
 People staying in some short-stay hostels or night shelters. 
 5. 
 Homeless people with &bquo;no fixed abode&equo;. 
 6. 
 Prisoners (unless they are imprisoned because of failing to pay their community charge). 
 7. 
 People aged up to 20 but still at school or in further education, who have no independent income of their own. 
 8. 
 Care Workers who are volunteers working for, or introduced to the person they care for, by a charity, and who fulfil certain conditions. 
 These will usually be young people, belonging to an organisation such as Community Service Volunteers, who receive no more than &pound;25 a week, work at least 24 hours a week and have accommodation provided on the premises. 
 HOW THE COMMUNITY CHARGE WORKS 
 Registration 
 You must register for the community charge in the area where you live. 
 The information collected is used to compile the &bquo;community charge register&equo; &mdash; a list of people liable to pay the community charge. 
 The electoral roll, local authority records, and other sources of information may also be used to complete the community charge register. 
 A simplified version of the register is available to the public, and contains the address, surname, and initials of people registered. 
 If you are worried about your name appearing on the public register you should contact your local council's Community Charge Registration Officer. 
 If Your Circumstances Change 
 If your circumstances change you should inform your local council. 
 If you move to a new address, you should inform the council in the area you have left and in the area you have moved to, of your change in address. 
 Paying The Community Charge 
 Under the community charge rules, the normal payment plan will be for the charge to be paid in 10 monthly instalments. 
 If you have problems in meeting the instalment plan which the council gives you, you should ask if it can be changed. 
 The council can choose not to accept instalments of less than &pound;5. 
 Penalties for non-registration and non-payment 
 If you do not provide the information requested for registration, this could lead to a fine of &pound;50 in the first instance, and then &pound;200 if you still do not comply. 
 If people do not pay the community charge they will receive a reminder. 
 If they still do not pay, the council can apply to the magistrates court for a summons to be served. 
 There are different ways of enforcing payments such as a direct deduction from wages or income support, or by seizing a person's possessions. 
 In extreme cases people can be imprisoned for non-payment (this does not apply in Scotland). 
 THE COMMUNITY CHARGE REDUCTION SCHEME 
 This scheme has replaced transitional relief which operated in the year 1990&ndash;91. 
 Like transitional relief, community charge reductions will provide payments to some people who face high increases because of the changeover from rates to community charge. 
 Community charge reductions are worked out after the bills originally set by councils have been reduced by &pound;140 as explained on page 2. 
 Because bills are now lower, fewer people face large increases, so the number of people entitled to a reduction will be less than originally expected.  
 The rules are more generous than those for transitional relief and some of the basic points are: 
 Community charge reductions are only available to people who have not moved since 31st March 1991. 
 Reductions will be available to people whose charge in 1991&ndash;92 is more than &pound;52 (&pound;1 a week) over the 1989&ndash;90 rates bill for the property where they now live. 
 The help is based on the actual community charge set in your area in 1991&ndash;92. 
 Reductions take into account all the chargepayers in a property whereas previously transitional relief was based on a maximum of two charges. 
 Your income and savings are not taken into account for the reduction scheme. 
 Do you need to claim? 
 The reductions will normally be worked out automatically before you receive your bill and you will not need to make a claim, but some people who did not previously pay rates, and who are pensioners or disabled people, can apply to the council for extra help as explained below. 
 Reductions and community charge benefit 
 The reductions scheme is not based on your savings and income and is separate from the community charge benefit system. 
 You may receive a reduction or benefit or both. 
 Any reduction is made before the benefit is calculated. 
 Ask at your council or local advice group if you are unsure what you can claim. 
 How the reductions are worked out 
 Community charge reductions are available to people who have not moved since 31 March 1991. 
 They will normally be worked out automatically but see also &bquo;Extra help for former non-ratepayers' below. 
 The reductions are worked out by comparing people's rates in 1989&ndash;90 with their community charge for 1991&ndash;92. 
 In most cases the &bquo;rates&equo; used in the calculation will be the same amount as the actual bill you received in 1989&ndash;90. 
 &bquo;However this will not be the case if you no longer live in the property where you previously paid rates because it is the 1989&ndash;90 rates of the property where you now live which is used to calculate any reduction. 
 If you move on or after the 1st April 1991 you will normally lose the reduction although there are certain circumstances when this is not the case.&equo; 
 Where there is one chargepayer  in the property a community charge reduction will be given if the 1991&ndash;92 community charge in your area is higher than your 1989&ndash;90 rates plus &pound;52. 
 You should not normally have to pay more than your rates bill plus &pound;52. 
 Where there are two people in the property  the reduction will be given if two community charges are higher than the rates bill plus &pound;52. 
 If there are more than 2 people , the threshold for help is increased by &pound;52 for each extra person. 
 So, for example, &pound;104 is added to the rates bill for a three person household and &pound;156 for a four person household.  
 Example 
 Mr and Mrs Forest's bills are as follows: 
 1989&ndash;90 rates &pound;350 
 1991&ndash;92 community charge after &pound;140 taken off &pound;260 each 
 2 &times; community charge of &pound;260 &pound;520 
 &pound;350 (rates) plus &pound;52 (threshold for reductions) &pound;402 
 Community charge reduction = &pound;520 - &pound;402 = &pound;118 (&pound;59 each) 
 Mr and Mrs Forest's bills will be reduced by &pound;59 each so they will have to pay &pound;201 each in 1991&ndash;92. 
 Extra help for former non-ratepayers 
 There may be extra help for some people who were not ratepayers, or the partner of a ratepayer, immediately before the community charge system started in April 1990 and who have not moved since then. 
 This is available to former non-ratepayers who, by 1 April 1991, were pensioners (women aged 60 and men aged 65 or over) or disabled. 
 To be considered &bquo;disabled&equo; for this purpose you will normally need to be receiving a benefit such as Attendance Allowance, Mobility Allowance, Invalidity Benefit or be registered blind. 
 If someone else was paying rates on your behalf then you may still be counted as a ratepayer so check with your council if you are unsure whether you qualify. 
 This extra help will apply to people such as elderly people who live with family and friends. 
 For those who qualify for this extra help the reduction will be equal to the community charge minus &pound;52. 
 This means that normally people in this position will receive a bill for just &pound;52. 
 To receive this help you will need to make an application to the council. 
 Applications will be accepted as long as they are made by 1st October 1991 but your council can  chose  to set a later date. 
 However if you were receiving the extra transitional relief in 1990&ndash;91 then you should not need to apply again. 
 Contact the council if this does not happen. 
 In Scotland  the community charge reduction scheme is basically the same taking into account that the community charge was introduced was year earlier. 
 In Wales  the scheme is different so contact your council for further information. 
 COMMUNITY CHARGE BENEFIT 
 This section gives details about community charge benefit (rebate) and how to apply. 
 If you are not sure whether you will be entitled to benefit, remember that you have nothing to lose by applying. 
 More information about benefits is available in other Age Concern factsheets (see page 11).  
 Who Can Get Benefit? 
 People who are liable to pay the community charge may qualify for benefit if they have a low income and no more than &pound;16,000 in savings. 
 You can claim if you own your home, you are a tenant or you live with family or friends. 
 The maximum benefit is 80% of the charge. 
 If you are entitled to a community charge reduction as explained earlier this is taken off your bill first before your benefit is worked out. 
 A couple will each receive a community charge bill, but their income and savings will be added together when their benefit is worked out. 
 Only one partner needs to apply for the rebate which will be divided equally. 
 How To Work Out If You Qualify For Benefit 
 To work out whether you can get benefit you need to follow the steps below, which are then explained. 
 1. 
 Work out the maximum benefit you could get. 
 2. 
 Add up your savings. 
 3. 
 Add up your income. 
 4. 
 Work out the amount that the Government says you need to live on, (this is called your applicable amount). 
 5. 
 Calculate the benefit you are entitled to. 
 Maximum And Minimum Benefit 
 The maximum rebate you can receive is 80% of your community charge, since everyone who is not exempt will have to pay at least 20% of the community charge. 
 In 1990&ndash;91 the minimum benefit someone could receive was 50p, however from April 1991 benefit will be paid even if it is less than 50p a week. 
 The calculations below are all based on weekly amounts so you must first work out how much your community charge is per week. 
 Your Savings 
 You cannot receive community charge benefit if you have over &pound;16,000 savings. 
 Savings of between &pound;3,000 and &pound;16,000 will reduce your rebate. 
 For every &pound;250 (or part of &pound;250) over &pound;3,000 you will be assumed to have an extra &pound;1.00 per week income. 
 For example, if you have &pound;4,200 savings you will be assumed to have an extra &pound;5.00 per week income, even if you are not actually receiving any interest from your savings. 
 If the council thinks that you have given away or used up savings in order to qualify for, or increase the amount of your benefit they can treat you as still having those savings. 
 This might happen if you give money away to members of your family or if you buy expensive items in order to reduce your savings.  
 Savings include cash, money in bank and building society accounts, national savings certificates and accounts, premium bonds and shares. 
 The value of your home if you own it, does not affect your rebate. 
 For more information see factsheet 16. 
 Your Income 
 Most income is counted in full when your entitlement to a rebate is calculated. 
 This includes the state pension, any occupational or personal pension and invalidity benefit. 
 Some income is ignored, such as Attendance Allowance, Mobility Allowance, payments from the Social Fund, or any actual income you receive from your savings. 
 There are other sources of income which are partly or fully ignored. 
 For more information see factsheet 16. 
 What You Need To Live On (Your Applicable Amount) 
 To work out any benefit due, you need to know the weekly amount the Government says you need for basic weekly living expenses (not including rent). 
 This is called your &bquo;applicable amount&equo; and depends on your age and whether you are disabled or not. 
 If your income is higher than this amount you may still receive some help as explained below. 
 The main weekly applicable amounts are: Single person 
 aged 60&ndash;74 &pound;53.40 
 aged 75&ndash;79 &pound;55.20 
 aged 80+ or 60+ and disabled* &pound;58.10 
 Couple 
 aged 60&ndash;74 &pound;83.15 
 aged 75&ndash;79 &pound;85.60 
 aged 80+ or 60+ and disabled* &pound;88.45 
 If one of a couple is disabled or older than the other, the couple will qualify for the higher amount. 
 The amount may be higher in certain circumstances &mdash; for example if you are a carer entitled to invalid care allowance or if you are disabled, live on your own, get Attendance Allowance, and have no one receiving invalid care allowance for looking after you. 
 (See factsheet 17 for more information). 
 * You will be classed as disabled if you are registered blind, or receiving Mobility Allowance, Attendance Allowance, Severe Disablement Allowance or Invalidity Benefit. 
 Calculating Your Benefit 
 Once you have worked out your &bquo;applicable amount&equo;, compare this with your income. 
 If your income is the same as or less than your applicable amount, you will receive maximum community charge benefit of 80%. 
 If your income is more than your &bquo;applicable amount&equo; the maximum benefit you could get is reduced by 15% (15p in every &pound;1) of the difference between the applicable amount and the income. 
 For example, if a person's income exceeds their applicable amount by &pound;10.00 per week, their maximum rebate will be reduced by &pound;1.50p (15% of &pound;10).  
 Examples 
 A. 
 Mr. &amp; Mrs. Seymour are aged 84 and 77. 
 The community charge in their area is &pound;5 per week each, (&pound;10 per week for both of them). 
 They receive the basic state pension of &pound;83.25 and an occupational pension of &pound;45.20 per week. 
 They have &pound;500 savings. 
 1. 
 Their maximum weekly benefit is 80% of &pound;10 = &pound;8.00 for them both (&pound;4.00 each). 
 2. 
 They have less than &pound;3,000 savings so this will not affect their rebate. 
 3. 
 Their income is: state pension &pound;83.25 occupational pension &pound;45.20 Total &pound;128.45. 
 4. 
 The &bquo;applicable amount&equo; for a couple where one is aged 80 or more is  is  &pound;88.45. 
 5. 
 Their income is higher than their applicable amount. 
 The difference is &pound;40.00 (&pound;128.45 - &pound;88.45 = &pound;40.00) 15% of this difference = &pound;6.00 
 Community Charge benefit = &pound;8.00 (80% of charge) &mdash; &pound;6.00 (15% of difference) = &pound;2.00 = &pound;1.00 each 
 Mr. &amp; Mrs. Seymour each receive a rebate of &pound;1.00 a week so they will have to pay the remaining &pound;4.00. 
 B) 
 Mr. Patel is 67, and lives with his son and daughter in law. 
 The community charge in their area is &pound;4 per week. 
 Mr. Patel receives a state pension (including additional pension) of &pound;54.40 per week, and has savings of &pound;5,100. 
 1. 
 His maximum weekly benefit is 80% of &pound;4.00 = &pound;3.20. 
 2. 
 His &pound;5,100 savings will be counted as &pound;9.00 per week assumed income as explained in &bquo;Your savings&equo; on page 8. 
 3. 
 His income is: state pension &pound;54.40 assumed income from savings &pound;9.00 Total &pound;63.40 
 4. 
 The applicable amount for a single person aged 60 to 74 is: &pound;53.40. 
 5. 
 His income is higher than his &bquo;applicable amount&equo;. 
 The difference is &pound;10.00 (&pound;63.40 - &pound;53.40) 15% of this difference = &pound;1.50 Community charge benefit = &pound;3.20 - &pound;1.50 (15% of difference) = &pound;1.70 (80% of the charge) 
 Mr. Patel will receive a rebate of &pound;1.70 per week and will have to pay the remaining &pound;2.30 a week. 
 How to claim benefit 
 If you claim income support from your local Department of Social Security office you will also be given a form to claim community charge benefit and (for tenants) housing benefit. 
 Otherwise you should contact your local council and ask for a claim form for community charge benefit. 
 If a member of your family may be entitled to a rebate, but is unable to manage their affairs you may be able to claim on their behalf and you should contact your council about this. 
 Normally benefit is not backdated unless you have &bquo;good cause&equo; for a late claim. 
 However this year (April 1991&ndash;92) community charge benefit will be backdated to 1st April as long as you make a claim within 56 days of receiving your bill which takes into account the &pound;140 reduction. 
 If your circumstances change you should let the council know. 
 FURTHER INFORMATION FROM AGE CONCERN 
 This is one of a series of free factsheets produced by Age Concern England. 
 The ones listed below give more detailed information about social security benefits. 
 No. 16 
 &bquo;Income related benefits: income and capital&equo; 
 No. 17 
 &bquo;Housing Benefit and Community Charge Benefit&equo; 
 No. 25 
 &bquo;Income Support and the Social Fund&equo; 
 If you would like copies of any of these or a list of the other factsheets produced send a stamped addressed envelope (9&ins; by 6&ins;) to Age Concern England . 
 All rights reserved.  
 This publication may be reproduced in whole or in part in unaltered form by Age Concern groups with due acknowledgement to Age Concern England.  
 No other reproduction in any form is permitted without written permission from Age Concern England.   
 NEWS IN FOCUS 
 Published by Age Concern England, Astral House, 1268 London Road, London SW16 4ER Tel 081 679 8000 
 Editor: Elspeth Rodwell October 1991 Issue 72 
 This month in the News in Focus series we include News in Focus, News for Chairmen, Training News and Publishing News. 
 We have reviewed our corporate design over the past few months and as from November we will be presenting a new design for this newsletter series. 
 It will be in A4 format but similar to the banner for News for Local Groups. 
 So, look out for the &bquo;New Look&equo; not to miss out on what is happening in Age Concern each month. 
 This month will see the launch of the Coldwatch campaign and details can be found in this newsletter together with the pack. 
 The first of the new style Age Concern Forums, proposed by the Chairman's Working Party, will be held on 30th October and is open to all Governing Body members to attend. 
 Several regions are holding pre-meetings open to Chief Officers and Chairs. 
 The &bquo;Services for You&equo; Guide &mdash; a new directory to Age Concern England services to Age Concern organisations is due for publication later this month. 
 A basic grants pack is also in preparation and will form part of this series. 
 We also hope to update the Directory and Who's Who at ACE into a similar format. 
 Various marketing opportunities have been set up recently by ACE including Christmas Cards and a holiday scheme. 
 We will continue to look for joint initiatives from which AC groups can also derive financial benefit and will keep you informed as they happen. 
 We would like to welcome our Ethnic Minorities Development Officer &mdash; Meena Patel &mdash; and our new Field Officer for Greater Manchester &mdash; Maggie Clay &mdash; both of whom have started with ACE this month. 
 Meena will be based with the Fieldwork Services Unit in Astral House. 
 CONTENTS 
 ACE Briefing Papers 
 ACE Training Fund 
 Age Concern Directory Amendments 
 Age Concern England Books 
 Age Concern Events 
 Age Concern Organisation Accounts 
 Age Concern Security Card 
 Basic Facts Card 
 Breathe Easy: British Lung Foundation Club 
 Coldwatch 1991 
 Cold Mailings 
 Community Care Changes 
 Conservative Political Centre Programme 
 Golden Years Appeal Update 
 Grandparents Day TM : media coverage 
 Job Advert: Age Concern Coventry 
 Local Authority Influenced Companies 
 National Survey of Age Concern services 
 Newscuttings Service 
 Parliamentary Unit News 
 Press Releases 
 Primetime Programme 
 We Care &mdash; With a Chair 
 Welfare Benefits Advice 
 ENCLOSURES 
 Press Releases 
 Cold Watch Pack 
 Cold Mailing Letter 
 Briefing Paper 
 Booklist 
 &bquo;Looking Good, Feeling Good&equo; book 
 Basic Factcard 
 Security Card 
 ACSIN Questionnaire 
 Newscuttings subscription form and sample 
 Age Concern Directory &mdash; new pages 
 AGE Concern  
 COLDWATCH 1991  
 Your 1991 Coldwatch pack is enclosed. 
 Please note that the campaign, and the Icebreaker Award, will now be launched on 30th October , rather than 28th October. 
 A sample of the leaflet &bquo;How To Cut the Cost of Keeping Warm&equo;, with an entry form for the Icebreaker Award, is included in the pack, as is a sample poster advertising the Icebreaker Award. 
 NB.  
 Last year's leaflet is out of date, please order copies of the new one from Distribution Services . 
 Your allocation of leaflets is 250 , and of Icebreaker posters is 20 . 
 Thanks to those who responded to our request for information last month &mdash; we would still be very interested to receive any information about your own Coldwatch activities and your use of the Coldwatch pack and leaflet. 
 Please contact Jane Titley, PR Promotions with details. 
 LOCAL AUTHORITY INFLUENCED COMPANIES under the Local Government and Housing Act 1989 &mdash;  
 Implications for Age Concern Groups  
 There is apparently interest on this topic throughout the movement, so the legal unit has been checking the position. 
 A voluntary group which is a company  may be regarded as &bquo;influenced&equo; by the local authority where both  20% or more of its voting members or board of directors are associated with the local authority and  50% or more of its business. 
 Such influenced companies may be subject to controls on borrowing, party political activity, conditions in contracts and other matters yet to be decided. 
 ** However, Age Concern Groups should not need to worry about these provisions at all . 
 This is because 
 1) 
 groups which are not companies are not covered by the Act at all. 
 2) 
 various &bquo;exempt networks&equo;  have been proposed, including an Age Concern network. 
 Regulations giving the detail of both the exemptions and the controls have not yet been finalised, so the relevant parts of the Act are not effective. 
 When they are, (probably not before April 1992) Age Concern Groups will almost certainly come under the network exemption, provided that they are recognised as groups by Age Concern England, or by the relevant major group. 
 The legal unit will keep groups informed as necessary, but we expect that no action will need to be taken by existing recognised groups in any case. 
 COLD MAILINGS  
 As winter approaches, the Fundraising department will be undertaking the usual large-scale programme of cold mailings. 
 The aim is to recruit new donors to support the work of the Age Concern Movement. 
 The letters are clearly labelled as coming from Age Concern England. 
 If anyone receives any enquiries or complaints, please refer these to the Fundraising department (Bob Hough or Helen North), if at all possible. 
 The mailing will be sent to a small segment in late October, the bulk in early November and to another segment at the end of January. 
 The majority will receive the &bquo;Operation Enterprise&equo; pack which has been used for a number of years and is known to the movement. 
 If anyone has not seen this before and would like a copy, please contact us. 
 We will also be testing new  material, in the hope of improving response. 
 This will only go to the small segment mailed in October. 
 It is an entirely new pack, based on the Christmas theme. 
 The text is enclosed here for information, in case local organisations are approached about it. 
 If successful the new letter will be used in larger quantities next year. 
 The text has of course been approved by our Chairman and is enclosed for your information. 
 &bquo;BASIC FACTS&equo; CARD  
 This card produced by ACE with facts and statistics about older people in the UK was recently updated and a copy is enclosed with this newsletter. 
 Further copies are available on request from the Distribution Department, ACE.   
 COMMUNITY CARE CHANGES: IMPLICATIONS FOR AGE CONCERN ORGANISATIONS  
 The changes now being introduced in the field of community care will have major implications for Age Concern's work for older people. 
 To assist understanding of what is involved, ACE is producing a series of booklets on Complaints, Inspection, Community Care Plans, Purchasing &amp; Contracting and Assessment. 
 All will have a common question-and-answer format, designed to be &bquo;user friendly&equo;, and all will reflect the emphasis upon user involvement which runs throughout the community care proposals. 
 Copies of the first in the series, on Complaints, should reach Age Concern organisations by early December; the next two (Community Care Plans and Contracting) should follow in the early part of 1992. 
 The series should ensure that Age Concern (and its service users) are well placed to participate in the new systems of community care. 
 ACE TRAINING FUND  
 New arrangements for the Training Fund have been devised and are now in operation. 
 The Training Fund will be divided between the Fieldwork Department and the Training Division. 
 The monies allocated to the Training Division will be used to subsidise the cost to Age Concern organisations of courses, training needs analysis and other training services provided by the Age Concern Training Division. 
 Enclosed with Training News are details of the services available and where they can be obtained from. 
 An application form for Training Division courses is also included. 
 Also please note that any Training Fund applications submitted within the last four weeks for courses organised by the Training Division have already been forwarded to them for attention. 
 Contact: Maxine Fawcett Training Administrator Age Concern England Training Division PO Box B96 Hammonds Yard King Street HUDDERSFIELD HD1 1WT Tel: (0484) 510740 
 The Fieldwork Department will retain the responsibility for applications for grants to cover the costs of courses and training initiatives provided by the Age Concern England Management Development Unit, and all other training providers. 
 The existing conditions continue to apply and applications should be sent to the Grants Officer at Astral House. 
 Field Officers will continue to comment upon all  applications so you should discuss all plants for training with them.  
 ACE BRIEFING PAPERS  
 The latest in our series of Briefing Papers produced by Age Concern England is entitled &bquo;Pensioner Organisations in England.&equo; 
 A complimentary copy is enclosed for your information and use. 
 The Age Concern England Executive Committee requested at its last meeting that a copy of the Briefing Paper on Council Tax be circulated to Chairs of Age Concern organisations and this will be included with News for Chairmen this month. 
 AGE CONCERN ENGLAND BOOKS  
 Enclosed is a copy of the new ACE Booklist 1991&ndash;2, which lists all our consumer titles and intended for distribution to members of the public. 
 Please dispose  of all copies of the current booklist. 
 Further copies of the new list are available from Gill Cronin, Publishing Department, ACE. 
 Also enclosed with this newsletter is your group's complimentary copy of &bquo;Looking Good, Feeling Good&equo; due for publication at the end of this month. 
 An order form is enclosed with Publishing News. 
 AGE CONCERN SECURITY CARD  
 As part of our mailing activity we have produced a security card designed to help elderly people check on callers. 
 The front has space for the older person to put details of gas, electricity, telephone, water, local council and police station numbers. 
 The back highlights the importance of using caution and suggests how to use the card. 
 A sample is enclosed and a limited further supply is obtainable free of charge from the Distribution department, ACE. 
 If there is a demand for these we will look into providing further supplies which we could provide to groups at cost price. 
 Please contact the PR department if you are interested in purchasing large quantities. 
 WE CARE &mdash; WITH A CHAIR  
 Margot Knowles, the originator and co-ordinator of the We Care &mdash; With a Chair campaign, has written to many chief officers this summer to enlist your support in the campaign. 
 Should would like to thank those who have replied, and would be very pleased to hear from anybody else interested in taking part. 
 Please write to her care of PR Promotions at ACE. 
 The stickers and leaflets which are the main tools of this campaign (to persuade managers of shops to care for their older and disabled customers by providing a chair) are distributed from PR Promotions. 
 Unfortunately there have been some problems and delay in getting them reprinted, and we have now decided with Margot to re-launch the campaign with a new logo, new stickers and leaflets. 
 We very much hope to have the new materials ready before the end of 1991 &mdash; watch this space! 
 PRESS RELEASES  
 The following press releases are enclosed in this mailing: 
 Grandparent of the Year Award Presented by Derek Jameson 
 Grandparents Day &mdash; A day For All Older People 
 Age Concern Fringe Meeting At Labour Conference 
 Ageing Today &amp; Tomorrow: Age Concern Reception At Conservative Party Conference 
 &bquo;Looking Good, Feeling Good&equo; &mdash; new publication 
 GRANDPARENTS DAY&trade; MEDIA COVERAGE  
 The Media Unit would like to thank everyone who carried out radio and press interviews about Grandparents Day. 
 Although representatives of Age Concern England were interviewed by a number of local radio interviewers the stations are always far more interested in a local angle and it is very helpful when we can refer enquiries to a local group. 
 Overall coverage and publicity of the day was excellent, with very little adverse publicity. 
 Particularly strong was local radio and newspaper coverage; again thanks to all who participated. 
 If anyone would like further details about Grandparents Day media coverage please contact Sarah McHugh at the Media Unit.  
 PRIMETIME PROGRAMME  
 A new series of &bquo;Primetime&equo; begins on BBC1 at 3.05pm on Wednesday October 30th 1991. 
 The third series will feature new slots such as &bquo;Sexy At Sixty&equo;, where viewers will have the chance to nominate their choice of who is sexy at sixty; the major political parties will be quizzed on their policies of older people and there will be regular films of &bquo;remarkable people doing remarkable things&equo;. 
 If you have a story or issue you would like to see covered or if you have any enquiries about the programme please write to: 
 Primetime BBC Television Room 4308 White City Building 201 Wood Lane London W12 7TS 
 BREATHE EASY  &mdash; THE BRITISH LUNG FOUNDATION'S CLUB FOR PEOPLE LIVING WITH LONG-TERM LUNG PROBLEMS 
 Over one million people in the UK have chronic bronchitis, emphysema, sarcoidosis and other long-term lung diseases. 
 The majority of these people are over 60, many are housebound or have mobility problems, and some use oxygen 24 hours a day. 
 Struggling for breath can be exhausting and frightening. 
 And people often feel isolated and depressed when normal daily activities become difficult. 
 The British Lung Foundation has set up the &bquo;Breathe Easy Club&equo; for people living with lung problems, their families and friends. 
 Breathe Easy is sponsored by DeVilbiss Health Care UK. 
 The club is free to join and provides a club newsletter three times a year as well as a range of information leaflets on lung disease. 
 Those who join are able to share experiences and keep up to date with the latest information on lung conditions, treatments and the services available. 
 Since its launch in April, the Breathe Easy club has received thousands of letters and calls from people with lung problems. 
 Already over 2,500 people have joined. 
 But there are many more thousands who could benefit from the club. 
 If you could help to publicise Breathe Easy by displaying for distribution posters and leaflets please contact: Julie Roberts, Breathe Easy, British Lung Foundation, 8 Peterborough Mews, London SE6 3BL. 
 Tel: (071) 371 7704. 
 PARLIAMENTARY UNIT NEWS  
 The next stage of our election preparations will be a leaflet to be used during the election campaign itself, entitled &bquo;Your Vote Counts!&equo; 
 The leaflet will highlight issues which can be raised with parliamentary candidates when they  coming  knocking on doors, and will suggest some questions to ask. 
 We hope to ensure that every candidate will have given some consideration to the issues which affect older people. 
 The leaflet can be used by Age Concern local organisations or by older people themselves. 
 We will be including a sample copy and an order slip with the November mailing. 
 Following a request from an Age Concern organisation, we will also be producing short guidelines on why older people should vote in the first place. 
 These will be included with the November mailing. 
 CONSERVATIVE POLITICAL CENTRE DISCUSSION PROGRAMME  
 The Conservative Political Centre (CPC) is currently undertaking a consultation exercise on &bquo;The Contribution of Elderly People To Society&equo;. 
 This will continue until 8 November. 
 The Conservative Political Centre is part of Conservative Central Office. 
 The briefing note which the CPC has sent to local Conservative associations gives Age Concern England as a contact point for further information. 
 A number of local Conservative Associations have contacted their local Age Concern organisations requesting a meeting or a speaker to attend Association meetings. 
 Copies of the CPC briefing are available from Jane Clarkson in the Parliamentary Unit. 
 Jane would also be happy to talk to any Chief Officer who is contacted by a local Conservative Association and would like further information. 
 AGE CONCERN ORGANISATION ACCOUNTS  
 The last ACE Executive Committee meeting in September recommended circulation to Age Concern organisations of the &bquo;Statement of Recommended Procedure on Charity Accounting&equo;. 
 These are now on order and will be circulated when available.  
 GOLDEN YEARS APPEAL UPDATE October 1991  
 Launch  
 With the election now off until sometime next year media attention continues to be absorbed by party conferences and international activity. 
 As many of you will have seen the Macmillan Nurse Appeal has also been launched as has the Help The Aged Home Security Appeal, and appeals by Oxfam and Guide Dogs for the Blind, so it appears we have made the right decision to delay until January. 
 Work on the launch and the focus of the appeal is close to completion and we are benefitting from the good offices of our advertising industry contacts. 
 The Appeal Video is also close to completion. 
 Once the right focus has been identified this will be applied to a range of Appeal materials from posters to T-Shirts. 
 National Appeal  
 As before we continue to receive a good flow of donations from the work of the Presidents Committee and their approaches to company contacts. 
 Employee fundraising appears to be an increasingly popular option and whilst it involves a lot more work than a straight donation it has the ability to generate longer term grass roots support amongst employees. 
 Unigate and Allied Lyons have now joined Tarmac and Cadbury's in this respect. 
 We are looking at ways to develop this as well as ways to ensure that groups are kept informed of any activity in their area. 
 Regional  
 Good progress has been made recently towards the establishment of chairmen and regional fundraising committees. 
 Both direct approaches and efforts to set up regional recruitment events are yielding positive results in four of the regions and we are still awaiting response to the other four. 
 Media  
 We continue, through the Presidents Committee, to develop contacts with the broadcast media. 
 Strongest connections are with commercial stations but progress has been slowed due to the continuing uncertainty over franchises. 
 Once this issue has been resolved we will increase our efforts in the regions. 
 In the meantime we have been able to develop relationships with companies in the South East who have been very keen to schedule programmes on age issues through their social action programming units. 
 This augurs well for the regions. 
 Inevitably, these negotiations take time but we are currently contacting various radio and television companies and will keep you involved in the identification of key issues for coverage in your area. 
 Project Shopping Lists  
 All regions have now drawn up at least a first round of projects for inclusion on the shopping lists. 
 These will all be presented to interested donors in a common summarised format that will provide them with the information they are looking for to make their decisions.  
 WELFARE BENEFITS ADVICE  
 The Lisson Grove Computerised Package 
 A few months ago we mentioned that a computerised welfare benefits package was available from a medical school research and development team in London. 
 This is called the Lisson Grove package. 
 It is designed to help guide experienced benefits advisers through the maize of allowances and exceptions, and users are sent updates whenever the procedures and allowances change. 
 Until October of this year, the package was free to all who required it. 
 Now that the project funding has expired, the team have to charge to cover costs. 
 They have developed a sliding scale charge so that organisations can get together to take advantage of bulk ordering and so save them some of the administration expenses. 
 If a single user was to buy the package, it would cost &pound;60.00 + VAT for the year (including updates and documentation). 
 To take advantage of the lower charges, Age Concern England agreed to act as an agent for the movement. 
 Groups order through us, we place a &bquo;bulk&equo; order and pass on the saving when we send out the disks. 
 Only a few groups responded to our earlier notice, and one or two sent an order directly to Lisson Grove (at the highest price). 
 This is a last call. 
 If you wish to be included in our order and have not already told us, do so in writing WITHOUT DELAY. 
 We estimate that the TOTAL COST to each group ordering through us will be &pound;50.00 &mdash; a saving of &pound;20.00. 
 Send a WRITTEN request please to: Nick Pizey, Age Concern England, Astral House, 1268 London Road, LONDON, SW16 4ER. 
 The last date for orders is 25 October 1991. 
 VOLUNTEER DRIVERS EXPENSES  
 We are aware of changes being introduced by the Inland Revenue from 6.10.91 and our Field Officer, Hilary Bath, is looking into the implications for Age Concern volunteers. 
 If you run any schemes with voluntary car drivers who do more than 4000 miles a year and feel this may effect your volunteers please contact Hilary on (0604) 670092. 
 REQUEST FOR INFORMATION  
 NATIONAL SURVEY OF AGE CONCERN SERVICES  
 The Services Development Unit at ACE has as part of its primary mission the development of a centralised database concerning the services and activities provided for, and of particular interest to older people, their relatives and carers. 
 This is an important initiative for the movement as a whole. 
 It will enable ACE to give accurate and up-to-date information about a whole range of services. 
 People who contact ACE for information about services &mdash; older people, relatives, carers, potential volunteers, students, researchers, reporters, Age Concern groups, other organisations, and many more &mdash; will be given much more accurate and appropriate details. 
 Until now, we have had to rely on casual contacts with groups, annual reports and occasional documents, in order to tell us what Age Concern groups are doing. 
 This survey is an attempt to capture much more detailed and precise data. 
 The questions it asks (directly or indirectly) are based on the regular enquiries received by various personnel at ACE from the wide variety of people who contact us, as suggested above. 
 In building up this database we are initially asking major groups to complete a questionnaire that informs us about what services they provide. 
 After a period of time we will then ask local groups to provide this information. 
 The questionnaire form is enclosed with this edition of News In Focus, together with some notes about the form and how to complete it. 
 PLEASE COMPLETE THE QUESTIONNAIRE FORM(s) AND RETURN AS QUICKLY AS POSSIBLE AND NOT LATER THAN 15 NOVEMBER 1991.  
 NEWSCUTTINGS SERVICE  
 A draft newscuttings list for the month of June is enclosed. 
 You will see that there are two parts to it &mdash; one in which the items have been sorted according to the geographical location (ie by county name, alphabetically); the other by service category. 
 Some weeks ago we sent a draft of a similar digest to a few Age Concern groups in order that we gain an appreciation of such a service and whether we should develop it further. 
 The majority of the responses indicated that they would like to receive these digests on a quarterly basis. 
 In November the first of these digests for the months July, August and September, will be available. 
 An order form is enclosed to be completed if you wish to subscribe to this service indicating the regularity with which you would wish to receive it. 
 AGE CONCERN EVENTS  
 October 
 25th 
 Sally Greengross to speak at Carnegie Inquiry into Third Age 
 30th 
 AC Organisations Forum, London &bquo;Looking Good, Feeling Good&equo; book launch Coldwatch Campaign launch, London 
 November 
 1st 
 SG to speak at National Council of Domiciliary Care Services study day &bquo;A Matter of Choice&equo;, London 
 7/8th 
 Four Nations meeting 
 9th 
 SG Guest speaker at 10th Annual Dinner of Rural Pharmacists Assoc, Stratford-upon-Avon 
 12th 
 SG at Law and Vulnerable Elderly People workshop at Notts Poly 
 13th 
 SG to speak at conference in conjunction with NAHAT on Demographic changes. 
 &bquo;Health Care and the NHS &mdash; is time running out?&equo; 
 Queen Elizabeth II Hall, London 
 AGE CONCERN DIRECTORY AMENDMENTS  
 Page 17 
 AGE CONCERN HARINGEY Correction to new address: The Campsbourne Centre 1&ndash;3 The Campsbourne LONDON N8 7PN 
 Page 30 
 ACE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE East Midlands Delete L. Jones and A E Ball Insert: Mr A Clark, AC Leicester Tel.: (0532) 704112 Ann Smith, AC Northampton Tel.: (0327) 78060 
 Page 39 
 FUNDRAISING PROMOTIONS Insert: Special Events Fundraiser Jane Marsh CORPORATE FUNDRAISING Corporate Campaign Asst Insert: Norah Shortland 
 Page 41 
 COMMUNICATIONS DIVISION Insert: Age Well Unit Age Well Officer: John Towers Age Well Asst: Shirley Theniger 
 Page 44 
 FIELDWORK SOUTHERN GROUP Field Officer (Mid South) Insert: Jean Jeffrey (1.11.91) Address to be notified. 
 Page 45 
 FIELDWORK NORTHERN TEAM Field Officer (Greater Manchester) Margaret Clay 68 Church Street Bollington, CHESHIRE SK10 5QD Tel.: (0625) 576920 
 The re-distribution of Field Officer areas in the North West will be confirmed in November's News in Focus. 
 Page 49&ndash;53 
 TRAINING DIVISION Insert new pages 
 Age Concern Briefings 
 Age Concern England national Council on Ageing 
 Needs of Older People  
 There are more than ten million pensioners in the United Kingdom today. 
 In 1990, 18.27% of the population of the UK (10,490,000 people), were over pensionable age. 
 People often refer to &bquo;the elderly&equo; as if they were a single group of people, but their needs are as varied as those of any other group in our population. 
 This briefing aims to provide an introduction for anyone interested in what some of the needs might be. 
 It is difficult to say that such a vast group of people has special needs, and indeed many older people may prefer not to be separated out from the rest of the adult population. 
 But &bquo;old age&equo; may bring disadvantages and less favourable social and economic circumstances. 
 Like most people, older people want to have enough income for their needs and to live in homes which they can manage and keep warm. 
 Most older people cope with the ups and downs of their daily lives. 
 But, as with others in society, there are times when extra help or advice is needed. 
 Age Concern England receives thousands of enquiries a year about many of the problems which older people face and the changes which they may have to cope with. 
 Many of the enquiries focus on income; housing; heating; getting about; health and community services; or leisure opportunities. 
 INCOME  
 Many people believe that pensioners are becoming increasingly well off financially. 
 People retiring now are likely to have an occupational pension on top of their state pension and the average income of pensioners rose by 31% more than the rate of inflation between 1979 and 1987. 
 However, average figures can be misleading. 
 While some pensioners have sufficient money to take long holidays and enjoy a comfortable retirement, many find it difficult to manage on their weekly income. 
 The weekly basic state pension from April 1991 to April 1992 is &pound;52.00 for a single person and &pound;83.25 for a married couple. 
 This is equal to 20% and 32% respectively of average adult earnings. 
 To qualify for the full basic pension, someone would need to have paid national insurance contributions for most of their working life (usually 44 years for a man). 
 The state pension is paid to men aged 65 and women of 60 &mdash; Age Concern believes that the law should be changed to make pension age the same for both sexes.  
 In addition to the state pension, people may receive a graduated pension based on earnings between 1961 and 1975 and/or an additional state earnings related pension (SERPS) if they have worked after 1978. 
 In 1989, 70% of pensioners received a graduated pension, with the average amount being &pound;1.38. 
 26% received an additional pension and the average amount was &pound;6.86. 
 In 1987, 52% of pensioners received an occupational pension. 
 The average weekly amount was &pound;44.80. 
 However, when these figures are broken down, it can be seen that certain groups, such as single women over 75, are less likely to have an occupational pension, and, if they do, the average amount is less. 
 It is only a limited number of pensioners who at present enjoy substantial occupational pensions. 
 Nearly 60% of pensioners receive at least 75% of their income from state benefits, particularly the basic pension. 
 For many older people, income is so low that they have to claim additional means-tested benefits such as income support, housing benefit and community charge (poll tax) benefit. 
 Income support makes a person's income up to a level set by the Government. 
 For example, a 70 year old person living alone would have their income made up to &pound;53.40 a week. 
 Housing benefit would then pay their rent and 80% of their community charge. 
 Out of this &pound;53.40, the older person must pay for their water rates, 20% of their community charge, heating, food, clothing and all other essential spending. 
 This clearly does not leave much money for other items such as a television licence and rental, or holidays. 
 It is also difficult to save for an emergency such as house repairs or other expenses like a new winter coat. 
 1,607,000 pensions (single people or couples) in Great Britain were receiving income support at the time of the last available figures (May 1989). 
 Many thousands more who do not get income support receive some help towards their rent and/or community charge. 
 However, it has been estimated that around one in five of pensioners entitled to these benefits do not actually claim them. 
 There are many reasons why people do not claim. 
 It may be because people are not aware that these benefits exist; they do not wish to ask for help while they can manage on what they have; or they may be too proud to claim, thinking that it is like asking for charity. 
 Others may be put off by the complicated forms. 
 Although working people are now more likely to be contributing to an occupational or personal pension, even in future years not all people will have been able to accumulate sufficient provision to support themselves in retirement &mdash; for example those people who have not worked for many years because they were unemployed or disabled or caring for relatives. 
 Those in low-paid work will also find providing for retirement difficult. 
 Age Concern believes that the basic state pension should be equal to one third average earnings for a single pension and one half for a couple. 
 This would ensure that most pensioners would not need to rely on means-tested benefits.  
 HOME  
 In households in Great Britain in 1988 where the head of the household was aged 65 or over, 47.5% were owner occupiers without a mortgage and 4.5% with a mortgage, 40% were renting from a council or housing association and 8.5% were renting from private landlords. 
 Only a minority of people move in retirement &mdash; most stay where they have always lived. 
 The comfort of their home can be especially important if they spend a lot of time there. 
 Yet older people tend to occupy the oldest, poorest housing and are more likely to be private tenants than other groups. 
 The 1986 English House Condition Survey found that 62% of dwellings lacking one or more basic facilities were occupied by people aged 60 and over. 
 Almost 40% of unfit properties, and 35% of properties in poor repair, were occupied by people aged 60 and over. 
 Some older people may want to move to obtain more suitable housing or to be nearer their children or brothers or sisters. 
 Increased frailty may suddenly make a house or flat, lived in for years, totally unsuitable &mdash; the garden is too big to manage, upstairs bedrooms become inaccessible, or getting to the shops and other local services presents difficulties. 
 Apart from the lack of suitable housing, there can be problems of access to the alternatives that do exist. 
 It may be difficult to move areas since many local authorities and some housing associations operate strict residence restrictions. 
 Owner-occupiers are often given no priority on local authority waiting lists, or have no access at all. 
 The National Mobility Scheme and Tenants Exchange Scheme do, however, enable a small number of older people to move. 
 For those who wish to stay at home, or who cannot obtain a move, Age Concern believes that there is an urgent need to improve housing conditions. 
 Tenants need help decorating their homes when they can no longer do it themselves, and owner occupiers on low incomes need both financial and practical help to adapt, repair and improve their homes to suit their needs, or just to make them habitable. 
 There are around 180 repair schemes to help older people obtain grants or loans for repair and improvement work. 
 These are often called &bquo;Staying Put&equo; or &bquo;Care and Repair&equo; schemes. 
 However, most older people still have no such help in their area and far more schemes are needed. 
 Age Concern believes that there is also a need for more provision of smaller accommodation, particularly in the public sector. 
 There is a widespread need, too, for part-ownership options for older people who do not have enough capital to make a full purchase. 
 Some older people are keen to live in sheltered accommodation where they hope for a combination of independence and security. 
 Sheltered housing is accommodation in a group of self-contained flats (or sometimes bungalows) with a resident warden, alarm system and some shared facilities such as a residents' lounge, guest room and laundry. 
 Around 5% of older people now live in sheltered housing provided by local authorities, housing associations, and, increasingly, by private developers.  
 KEEPING WARM  
 A warm home is essential to the wellbeing of older people. 
 It is not known exactly how many people die from hypothermia (ie die &bquo;from cold&equo;, because their inner body temperature has become dangerously low), but thousands of older people do die each winter from cold-related conditions. 
 The death rate in winter for those aged 60&ndash;69 is on average 12% higher than in summer; this increases to 17% for those in their seventies and 26% for those aged 80 and over. 
 It has been estimated that there are 8,000 &bquo;excess deaths&equo; for every degree celsius that the winter is colder than average. 
 Older people are more likely to experience the circumstances that cause &bquo;fuel poverty&equo; &mdash; low income; poor quality housing with little or no insulation; and reliance on expensive and inefficient heating systems. 
 They are also likely to have greater need for heating than other groups, because they spend more time at home. 
 The Family Expenditure Survey 1989 found that over 36% of single pensioner households do not have central heating. 
 Even people with adequate heating may not use it because of the cost. 
 Poorer pensioners spend much more of their weekly income on fuel than other households. 
 In 1986, they spent 14.4% of total expenditure on fuel, compared with 7.4% for non-pensioner households. 
 Rises in fuel prices have been relatively stable in recent years, although this restraint may be ending, with the possible introduction of a &bquo;carbon tax&equo; on fossil fuels to combat global pollution, and the running down of the cheapest supplies of natural gas. 
 Age Concern believes that a national energy strategy is required to improve standards of insulation and energy conservation and to reduce the high costs of heating which deter poorer consumers from keeping themselves warm. 
 GETTING ABOUT  
 Maximum mobility is important for people of all ages. 
 The mobility of older people, which affects their access to the facilities that they need to use, may decrease with age. 
 Slowing down means that roads have to be crossed with more care and that bad road and pavement conditions are greater hazards. 
 The mobility needs of older people therefore should be taken fully into account in transport and land-use planning. 
 The need to be able to get about is essential for daily life, and also to take advantage of increased leisure time. 
 The National Travel Survey 1985&ndash;86 found that, overall, older people make 50% fewer journeys per week than the population as a whole. 
 They also make significantly fewer social and recreational trips than the overall population. 
 Both public and private services, such as hospitals and shopping centres, are increasingly concentrated in large, sometimes inaccessible sites. 
 This has further increased the importance of mobility.  
 In 1989, only 7.8% of pensioners who were mainly dependent on state pensions and living alone had a car. 
 The combination of lack of access to a car, difficulty in using public transport because of the increased likelihood of disability, and inaccessible location of necessary services, means that older people are both more likely to have difficulty walking and yet more likely to depend on walking as means of getting about. 
 Access to public transport depends upon the cost and availability of services, particularly in rural areas. 
 There is little consistency in the travel concessions available to older people. 
 British Rail and some coach companies offer reduced fares to older people. 
 Locally, however, there are big variations in the concessions that are provided. 
 A transport survey in 1988 showed that only 19 local authorities gave free travel to older people, 265 made a charge or issued limited value tokens, and 30 made no concessions at all. 
 Community transport schemes organised by voluntary schemes can make a valuable contribution, particularly in areas where appropriate public transport is not easily available. 
 Mobility Allowance is paid to people who become unable to walk or virtually unable to walk before the age of 65. 
 At present, the allowance is only paid to people under the age of 80. 
 Age Concern believes that Mobility Allowance should be extended to those who become disabled after 65 and that payment should continue regardless of age. 
 HEALTH AND COMMUNITY SERVICES  
 The idea of &bquo;care in the community&equo; has developed over the past 20 years to encourage the development of services to help older people in need of care to remain in their own homes for as long as they wish, and for as long as is practical. 
 &bquo;Old age&equo; is not a disease in itself, and it is not helpful to think of the problems which face older people as being caused &bquo;by their age&equo;. 
 Older people are not necessarily ill or frail &mdash; most are fit and active. 
 As people grow older, however, they may be more likely to develop illnesses or conditions which make it more difficult for them to cope without some help or support. 
 This is particularly true for some people over the age of 85. 
 For example, one in five people over the age of 80 are likely to develop Alzheimer's Disease, a form of senile dementia. 
 One in three women over the age of 80 at some time have a fracture of the hip. 
 It is specific conditions like these, and others such as arthritis, diabetes, blindness or deafness, which lead some older people to need extra help. 
 Most of the help that older people receive is provided by their family, neighbours and friends. 
 The idea that families do not &bquo;look after their own&equo; is not found to be true in practice. 
 Many &bquo;carers&equo; are husbands and wives, but there are also children who look after their parents &mdash; these are mainly women, many of whom have work or other family commitments of their own. 
 In recent years, attention has increasingly  focussed  on the needs of these carers, who may very much want to care but who may need practical help and advice as well as emotional support. 
 In 1985, 26% of carers who devoted over 20 hours a week to caring were over 65 themselves. 
 However, many older people are not married and do not have children &mdash; and a small number outlive their children. 
 In 1988, only 23% of women aged 75 and over were married. 
 For these people, some extra help may be needed. 
 During the course of a year, most older people will visit their general practitioner. 
 They may have a medical problem which the doctor can help with, but the doctor can also help them to find help at home. 
 He or she may recommend chiropody, or visits from a district nurse; or physiotherapy may be required to help regain mobility after an operation. 
 The help of an occupational therapist may be needed to recommend aids and adaptations to help the older person. 
 The doctor can refer the person to the social services department for a home help, or meals on wheels, or a place at a day centre. 
 The availability of such services for older people and their carers varies considerably in different areas. 
 The General Household Survey found that in one month in 1985, out of people aged 65 and over, 34% had seen their doctor; 5% had seen a nurse; 1% had seen a health visitor; 11% had seen a chiropodist (footcare): 9% had seen a home help; 2% had received meals on wheels; and 5% had been to a day centre. 
 Only a small proportion of older people live in institutions (residential homes, nursing homes or long-stay hospitals). 
 About 250,000 people live in residential homes, which are run by local authorities, charities or private companies. 
 These numbers have increased considerably over the past few years, partly because income support is available to help cover the fees of residential and nursing home care, and money to pay for care at home is not easily available. 
 At the time of writing, the Government's plans are to change this system from April 1993. 
 Local authority social services departments will become responsible for assessing and arranging packages of care for people who need help. 
 Such people will, in most cases, be assessed for their ability to pay for services at home or in residential or nursing homes. 
 For older people at home, voluntary organisations such as Age Concern may provide a wide range of services and activities, both to help look after older people with care needs, and to provide day centres, for example, where people may meet others with similar needs or interests. 
 Support groups for people with particular needs or conditions also play a vital part in helping some older people and their families to adapt to changes in their lives. 
 These groups include the Alzheimer's Disease Society, the Parkinson's Disease Society, the Chest, Heart and Stroke Association, and the Carers National Association. 
 The expectations of older people, their families, and people who work with them, may significantly affect the way that they cope with illness or disability. 
 People who &bquo;expect&equo; older people to have worsening health or to &bquo;decline&equo; in their faculties, may not have a positive approach to various ways of coping with physical and mental changes. 
 This may lead some health workers, families and older people themselves to believe that there is little to be done to improve the circumstances of people with care needs. 
 Yet new approaches to treatment of incontinence, for example, mean that many people can learn to cope with the problem; learning about how to communicate with deaf people can reduce the isolation of someone who has withdrawn from social contact because of hearing loss; and modern drugs and careful monitoring by a general practitioner can reduce the effects of Parkinson's Disease. 
 LEISURE  
 Retirement is a time of great change and should also be a time for development. 
 Either from choice or because they cannot find employment, people are retiring earlier. 
 In Great Britain in 1989, only 54.6% of men aged 60&ndash;64 and 54.3% of women aged 55&ndash;59 were working. 
 Yet despite the trend towards early retirement, there is only very limited pre-retirement education available. 
 Most people will welcome advice and guidance before and after retirement. 
 Libraries, adult education and leisure centres and other local agencies are beginning to respond to the needs of older people in the leisure field. 
 There is also a growth in the number of commercial organisations offering information, services and activities. 
 Increased leisure time is a challenge for older people and most will welcome the challenge. 
 Leisure activities offer opportunities for older people to meet others who share similar interests. 
 There may be time for hobbies or interests, either life-long ones where skills can be renewed and activities expanded, or new ones where opportunities to learn can lead to great personal satisfaction. 
 There may be time available for voluntary work. 
 Many organisations rely heavily on older volunteers. 
 The 1987 General Household Survey found that 22% of people aged 60&ndash;69, and 13% of those of 70 or older, were participating in voluntary work. 
 Age Concern believes that older people need a wide variety of educational and leisure opportunities, to suit their broad range of backgrounds and abilities. 
 The barriers to greater participation include finance, mobility, and sometimes lack of knowledge about what is available. 
 Older people are now becoming involved in an increasingly wide range of activities. 
 These may include activities with organisations that are concerned with the quality of their lives (eg pressure groups), intergenerational activities and those which promote individual development. 
 As each generation reaches retirement age, their expectations may cause them to be more active in all of these areas and make greater demands on service providers. 
 Age Concern believes that the participation of older people in all activities which put their skills and enthusiasms to good use should be encouraged. 
 The Age Resource project, which Age Concern England co-ordinates, seeks to promote such schemes.  
 In this briefing paper we can only illustrate some of the needs which older people may have. 
 Needs vary, as do expectations and demands made of available opportunities and services. 
 However, as for everyone in society, the most common needs are, broadly speaking, a sufficient income, good physical and mental health, suitable accommodation, and social opportunities. 
 Where these opportunities are not as good as possible, we have tried to show some of the many ways in which older people can be helped. 
 FURTHER READING:  
 BOND, J and COLEMAN, P (eds.). 
 AGEING IN SOCIETY: AN INTRODUCTION TO SOCIAL GERONTOLOGY  (Sage, 1990). 
 DARNBROUGH, A and KINRADE, D. DIRECTORY FOR OLDER PEOPLE  (Woodhead-Faulkner, 1989). 
 FENNELL, G et al. 
 THE SOCIOLOGY OF OLD AGE  (Open University, 1988). 
 GARRETT, G. OLDER PEOPLE: THEIR SUPPORT AND CARE  (Macmillan, 1990). 
 LODGE, K. (ed.). 
 DIRECTORY OF SERVICES FOR ELDERLY PEOPLE IN THE UK  (Longman, 1990). 
 NORTON, D. THE AGE OF OLD AGE  (Scutari Press, 1990). 
 (Historical account of care provision for older people). 
 TINKER, A. THE ELDERLY IN MODERN SOCIETY  2nd edition. 
 (Longman, 1984). 
 You should be able to buy these books at a bookshop or borrow them from a library. 
 A longer reading list is available from Age Concern England's Information and Policy Department if you send in a stamped addressed envelope. 
 For further statistics, you may like to look in your library at recent editions of SOCIAL TRENDS, the GENERAL HOUSEHOLD SURVEY, SOCIAL SECURITY STATISTICS and the FAMILY EXPENDITURE SURVEY. 
 Compiled by staff of the Information and Policy Department, Age Concern England. 
 August 1991. 
 (LC/SD) 
 Age Concern Information Circular 
 OCTOBER 1991  
 CONTENTS 
 Arts &mdash; therapy 
 Carers &mdash; literary contest 
 Christian Council on Ageing 
 Community care &mdash; Mental Illness Specific Grant 
 Consumer Complaints &mdash; MORI survey 
 Council tax &mdash; Audit Commission's response 
 Counsel and Care 
 Disabled people &mdash; Orange Badge scheme 
 Energy efficiency &mdash; House of Lords Committee report 
 Eurolink Age 
 Home equity &mdash; investment bond income schemes 
 Housing &mdash; effectiveness of current leasehold legislation 
 Housing &mdash; elderly persons' housing and the Right to Buy 
 Housing &mdash; Government allocations to local authorities 
 Housing &mdash; regulation of estate agents 
 Imperial War Museum &mdash; items for use in reminiscence work 
 Mental health &mdash; Age Concern response to Law Commission report 
 Methodist Homes for the Aged &mdash; change of address 
 NHS &mdash; access to medical records 
 NHS &mdash; continuing care: ACE letter 
 NHS &mdash; continuing care: selected reports of the Health Service Commissioner 
 NHS outpatient services 
 NHS Trusts &mdash; third wave 
 NHS waiting lists 
 Older people and HIV 
 Optician home visits 
 Pensioner organisations in England &mdash; ACE briefing 
 Probate &mdash; new ACE factsheet 
 Residential care &mdash; local authority homes 
 Residential care &mdash; local authority supported residents 
 Social security &mdash; ACE letter on upratings 
 Social security &mdash; changes to rules on benefit backpayment 
 Social security &mdash; consumer views on Attendance Allowance medical examinations 
 Social security &mdash; extension of carer premium, definition of remunerative work and other changes 
 Social security &mdash; Housing Benefit: guidance on the treatment of income 
 Social security &mdash; Housing Benefit reviews 
 Social security &mdash; Invalid Care Allowance study 
 Social security &mdash; Social Fund 
 Social security &mdash; support for low income families 
 Statistics about older people 
 Telephones &mdash; ACE letter on BT price rises 
 Telephones &mdash; braille bills 
 Telephones &mdash; BT security deposits 
 PERIODICAL ARTICLES 
 NEW PUBLICATIONS 
 COURSES AND CONFERENCES  
 The Information Circular reports developments of interest to people who work with and for older people. 
 Mention in the Circular does not imply support or recommendation by Age Concern England. 
 The subscription rate for the Information Circular is &pound;15.00 per annum for twelve issues. 
 EDITED BY LYNETTE CAWTHRA 
 Assistant Editor 
 : Audrey King. 
 Housing 
 : David Bookbinder. 
 Health and Personal Social Services 
 : Barbara Meredith and Jane Whelan. 
 Income Maintenance 
 : Sally West. 
 Consumer Affairs 
 : Robin Versteeg. 
 Press 
 : Margaret McLellan. 
 Parliamentary 
 : Jane Clarkson. 
 Editorial Secretary 
 : Nimal Dharmasena. 
 Education &amp; Leisure 
 : Dianne Norton. 
 Additional contributions by 
 : Evelyn McEwen and Kate Callen. 
 Distribution 
 : Brian Reed. 
 Subscriptions 
 : Linda Simmons. 
 Printed by 
 : Age Concern England Print Unit. 
 COUNSEL AND CARE 
 Until further notice Counsel and Care will not be able to consider new applications for financial help with home fees, the cost of care at home or single need payments. 
 This is due to increased demand on funds. 
 This decision will be reviewed shortly and it is hoped that the grants programme will be started again if there is a sufficient improvement in finances. 
 The charity's free and confidential advice service on all aspects of residential and nursing home care will continue. 
 Further information from Alison Birch, Information and Policy Officer, Counsel and Care, Twyman House, 16 Bonny Street, London NW1 9PG. 
 Tel: 071&ndash;485 1566. 
 OLDER PEOPLE AND HIV 
 The Red Admiral Project, a counselling centre for people affected by HIV or AIDS, is considering setting up a group for older people. 
 This would include partners as well as people diagnosed as HIV positive. 
 Further information from John Shine, Project Director and Senior Nurse Counsellor, Red Admiral Project, 51a Philbeach Gardens, London SW5 9EB. 
 Tel: 071&ndash;835 1495. 
 Confidentiality is assured. 
 PENSIONER ORGANISATIONS IN ENGLAND &mdash; ACE BRIEFING 
 Age Concern England's briefing paper, Pensioner organisations in England , has just been revised. 
 It lists over 40 bodies, from public service and trade union pensioners organisations to ones run by employers, as well as national general groups. 
 There is a description of the aims and activities of each body, plus a contact name and address. 
 Pensioner organisations in England . 
 Available free on receipt of (9&ins; &times; 6&ins;) sae from Donna Pearce, Services Division, Age Concern England. 
 METHODIST HOMES FOR THE AGED &mdash; change of address 
 Methodist Homes for the Aged moved in December 1990 to the following address: Epworth House, Stuart Street, Derby DE1 2EQ. 
 Tel: (0332) 296200. 
 Fax: (0332) 296925.  
 CHRISTIAN COUNCIL ON AGEING 
 The Christian Council on Ageing (CCoA) is a national voluntary and inter-denominational organisation, inaugurated in 1982, which believes that churches should give greater attention to the particular needs &mdash; and potential &mdash; of older people. 
 It sees the practical development of its work as taking place mainly at local level, and to this end encourages the formation of autonomous local groups which can respond to needs in their own area. 
 The CCoA produces a quarterly journal, Plus ; publishes occasional papers; runs courses; and promotes in-service training on ageing and pastoral care for clergy and pastoral workers. 
 It is also currently developing devotional material for use in residential homes. 
 Further information from CCoA Membership Secretary, 20 West Way, Rickmansworth, Hertfordshire, WD3 2EN. 
 STATISTICS ABOUT OLDER PEOPLE &mdash; ACE FACTCARD 
 Age Concern England has updated its factcard which gives basic statistical information about older people in the UK, covering areas such as population structure, income, housing, mobility, and health. 
 Older people in the United Kingdom: some basic facts . 
 Available free on receipt of (9&ins; &times; 6&ins;) sae from Distribution Department, Age Concern England. 
 Charges for multiple copies will be given on request. 
 EUROLINK AGE 
 Eurolink Age, a European network concerned with older people and issues of ageing, has produced a new leaflet in French and English outlining its work and objectives. 
 Available on receipt of (9&ins; &times; 4&ins;) sae from Eurolink Age, c/o Age Concern England. 
 RESIDENTIAL CARE &mdash; LOCAL AUTHORITY HOMES 
 Local Authority Circular LAC(91)112 was issued in August. 
 It contains guidance on arrangements to transfer local authority residential care homes to independent control; it also gives Directions from the Secretary of State for Health about local authorities' continuing responsibility for residents in transferred homes whose care was arranged by the local authority under Section 21(1) of the National Assistance Act 1948 (as amended by paragraph 2(1), Schedule 23 to the Local Government Act 1972) and under paragraph 2, Schedule 8 to the National Health Service Act 1977.  
 The Circular also contains appendices and annexes which discuss related issues, and which report the statements by the Secretary of State for Social Security on eligibility for Income Support of residents of transferred homes. 
 Under objectives stated in the White Paper, Caring for people , local authorities are required to take all reasonable steps to ensure a diversity of provision in their area. 
 However, the Circular states that they will also be expected to &bquo;retain the ability to act as direct service providers, if other forms of service provision are unforthcoming or unsuitable. 
 This is likely to be particularly important in services for people with high levels of dependency, or particularly challenging patterns of behaviour, whose care it is essential to safeguard&equo; (paragraph 3). 
 &bquo;It is the view of the Department that Section 42 of the National Health Service and Community Care Act 1990, which is to be implemented in April 1993, will require authorities to make some direct provision for residential care under Section 21 of the 1948 Act&equo; (paragraph 5). 
 In moving homes to other management, local authorities &bquo;must have full regard, particularly at the transitional stage of ownership change, to the welfare and wishes of the residents in any homes to be transferred&equo; (paragraph 4). 
 The Directions to local authorities contained in this Circular, and the Income Support Amendment Regulations (SI 1991 no 1656 &mdash; see Information Circular, August 1991) came into effect on 12 August 1991. 
 They are not retrospective. 
 An Appendix to the Circular discusses a number of related issues, and relevant legislation. 
 Subjects covered include: assistance for privately let housing; disposal of land; assistance to voluntary organisations under Section 65 of the Health Service and Public Health Act 1968; transfer of staff of homes; local authority capital finance; promotion of bodies to acquire homes; controls on local authority companies; compulsory competitive tendering; and restrictive trade practices. 
 Community care: review of residential homes provision and transfers . 
 Local Authority Circular LAC(91)12. 
 Available from Health Publications Unit, No 2 Site, Manchester Road, Heywood, Lancashire, OL10 2PZ. 
 RESIDENTIAL CARE &mdash; LOCAL AUTHORITY SUPPORTED RESIDENTS 
 Statistics have been published showing numbers of residents supported by local authorities in England in their own homes, and in private and voluntary establishments, for the year ending 31 March 1990. 
 The figures show that in 1990, there were 90,843 people over the age of 65 supported by local authorities in all types of accommodation (of whom 87,652 were in their own or other authorities' homes). 
 Equivalent figures for 1980 were 118,813 and 102,890; and for 1985, 110,169 and 101,526. 
 Between 1985 and 1990, however, the number of people aged over 85 supported in residential care by local authorities has declined at a slower rate than that for all people aged 65+. 
 The proportion of those aged 85+ has increased from 38.7% to 44.2% during this period.  
 Figures are given for each local authority, showing numbers and proportions of residents aged under 65, and 65+, supported in each type of accommodation. 
 Some local authorities only support elderly residents in their own homes, whereas two authorities have no directly provided provision. 
 One authority supports elderly residents solely in voluntary establishments, whereas the other uses a combination of private and voluntary provision. 
 Residential accommodation for elderly and for younger physically handicapped people: local authority supported residents: year ending 31 March 1990: England . 
 Department of Health, Personal Social Services, Local Authority Statistics RA/90/1. 
 97pp. 
 Available from DoH, Room 821, Hannibal House, Elephant and Castle, London SE1 6TE. 
 COMMUNITY CARE &mdash; MENTAL ILLNESS SPECIFIC GRANT 
 A report has been published which looks at the operation of the new Mental Illness Specific Grant in the first few months after its introduction in April this year. 
 The report summarises the types of schemes which have been launched under the grant, noting that many schemes so funded are not &bquo;new&equo;, but are continuations or expansions of existing provision. 
 The report discusses the implications of the short time local authorities had to plan for use of the grant, in particular the difficulties within the time scale of consulting users, carers and others in planning for and providing new services. 
 The adequacy of the capital and revenue parts of the grant are discussed. 
 The Mental Illness Specific Grant: the early days  by Gary Hogman and Jerry Westall. 
 40pp. 
 Price &pound;5. 
 Available from National Schizophrenia Fellowship, 28 Castle Street, Kingston-upon-Thames, Surrey, KT1 1SS. 
 CARERS &mdash; LITERARY CONTEST 
 Crossroads Care is organising a literary contest for carers. 
 Entries, which must not exceed 2,000 words, can be on any subject, fact or fiction and there is a separate section for poetry. 
 Cash prices will be awarded to three winners in the general category and one in the poetry section. 
 The closing date for entries is 28 October. 
 Further information and entry forms available on receipt of sae from Crossroads Care Literary Contest, 5 Hillside Court, 409 Finchley Road, London NW3 6HQ.  
 NHS &mdash; CONTINUING CARE: SELECTED REPORTS OF THE HEALTH SERVICE COMMISSIONER 
 The Health Service Commissioner (the &bquo;Ombudsman&equo;) has published a report of selected investigations completed between October 1990 and March 1991. 
 Three of these decisions relate to, among other things, health authority provision of long-term care. 
 In making a decision on the first of the three cases cited, the Commissioner communicated with the Chief Executive of the National Health Service Management Executive, asking him about a health authority's duty to provide continuing nursing care which is assessed as being needed, and which is not otherwise available. 
 In the particular case in question, the complainant's father had not been offered a bed by the health authority, although he was assessed as needing nursing care. 
 He entered a nursing home, and subsequently his resources ran down and his daughter was threatened with being sued by the nursing home for outstanding fees. 
 The Commissioner referred to the letter to Age Concern England in 1988, from Nicholas Scott (now Minister for Social Security and Disabled People) which stated, &bquo;In the last analysis, where a person in a home can no longer meet his fees but still requires nursing home or residential home care it will fall to the NHS or local authority as appropriate to provide that care if it is not otherwise available to the person&equo;. 
 The Commissioner states in his report: &bquo;Because it seemed to me that the Minister's letter implied that the NHS had an absolute duty to provide care for the complainant's father once it became clear that he could no longer meet the nursing home fees, I asked the DoH for clarification of the legal position and invited their general views.&equo; 
 The Chief Executive replied that the health authority had a duty to provide care without charge if: 
 &bquo;in a doctor's professional judgement a patient needs NHS care&hellip; 
 In the case of a patient such as you describe, this can be done by providing community nursing care to the patient's own home, by providing in-patient care or by a contractual arrangement with an independent sector home (ie paid for in full by the health authority). 
 The level of service provided overall is a matter for individual health authorities in the light of local circumstances and priorities&equo;. 
 The Chief Executive expanded on this: 
 &bquo;there is no general duty on a health authority to provide inpatient medical or nursing care to every person who needs it. 
 Legal precedents have established that the Secretary of State's duty under Section 3 of the Act is qualified by an understanding that he should do so &bquo;within the resources available&hellip;&equo;. 
 The three cases described by the Health Service Commissioner differed in detail, and in each the Commissioner came to slightly different conclusions. 
 The issues raised in his report relate directly to Age Concern's ongoing work on NHS continuing care and hospital discharge.  
 A discussion note will be prepared on the implications of the Health Service Commissioner's decisions, and should be available by the end of October free on receipt of (9&ins; &times; 4&ins;) sae from Francis d'Costa, Information and Policy Department, Age Concern England. 
 Health Service Commissioner second report for session 1990&ndash;91: selected investigations completed October 1990 &mdash; March 1991 . 
 (HC 482). 
 119pp. 
 Price &pound;12.60. 
 Available from HMSO. 
 NHS &mdash; CONTINUING CARE: ACE LETTER 
 Sally Greengross, Director of Age Concern England has written to William Waldegrave, Secretary of State for Health, about Age Concern's recent report, Discontinuing care  (see Information Circular, July 1991). 
 The letter links the findings of Dis-continuing care  with Age Concern's recent work on hospital discharge and other issues, and refers also to the recent decisions of the Health Service Commissioner on health authority responsibilities for provision of long-term care. 
 The letter reiterates questions raised earlier this year by Age Concern about &bquo;bottom-line&equo; responsibilities of health and local authorities. 
 Age Concern England has urged the Government to monitor more closely the provision by health authorities of continuing care, and has made a number of recommendations about how this might be done. 
 Continuing care for elderly people in the National Health Service . 
 Letter from Sally Greengross to William Waldegrave, 19 August 1991. 
 Available free on receipt of (9&ins; &times; 4&ins;) sae from Francis d'Costa, Information and Policy Department, Age Concern England. 
 NHS &mdash; ACCESS TO MEDICAL RECORDS 
 From 1 November 1991, under the Access to Health Records Act 1990, individual patients will have the right of access, subject to certain exceptions, to all health information recorded about them. 
 The Act imposes a duty on all holders of health records, usually a hospital or GP, to disclose information on application by a patient. 
 The Act applies only to records produced from November onwards . 
 A DoH press release states that &bquo;access to records will be free except when they have not been added to in the previous 40 days. 
 When this is the case, a fee of up to &pound;10&hellip; may be charged&equo;. 
 DoH Press Release H91/403, 27 August 1991.  
 NHS TRUSTS &mdash; THIRD WAVE 
 Health Service Managers have been invited to express interest in joining the third wave of NHS Trusts, scheduled to come into operation on 1 April 1993. 
 The deadline for expressions of interest was 16 September 1991. 
 A DoH Press Release reported that a total of 113 applications to join the second wave of Trusts had been received. 
 This second wave will come into operation on 1 April 1992. 
 DoH Press Release H91/369, 5 August 1991. 
 NHS WAITING LISTS 
 The NHS Management Executive has issued to health authorities a report containing examples of good practice guidelines on Managing waiting lists for in-patients and day cases . 
 The report, drawn up following a study commissioned by the Department of Health in 1989, contains guidelines on how best to manage and organise waiting lists. 
 Recommendations cover: 
 keeping records accurately and scrupulously maintained; 
 regularly validating lists to ensure that they do not contain the names of patients no longer requiring treatment; 
 keeping patients fully informed; 
 dealing with cases where patients do not respond to offers of admission. 
 Managing waiting lists for in-patients and day cases  by Ken Churchill, John Howard and Bob Jayes. 
 70pp. 
 Individual copies available free from Qa Business Services Ltd, Techno House, 226 High Street, Harborne, Birmingham B17 9PX. 
 Tel: 021&ndash;426 1050. 
 NHS OUTPATIENT SERVICES 
 The House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts has published its report on NHS outpatient services. 
 The report states amongst its main conclusions: 
 &bquo;We are profoundly concerned about the length of some waiting times first non-urgent outpatient appointments which in some cases have increased since the National Audit Office examination&equo;.  
 The Committee recommends that the NHS Management Executive should ensure that all English Regional Health Authorities set broad standards for waiting times for such appointments, and that the Management Executive should require District Health Authorities and Family Health Services Authorities to take urgent action to reduce waiting times for first appointments. 
 NHS outpatient services . 
 House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts thirty-fifth report, Session 1990&ndash;91 (HC 270). 
 31pp. 
 Price &pound;10.30. 
 Available from HMSO. 
 OPTICIAN HOME VISITS 
 Virginia Bottomley, Minister for Health, has announced that some people on low incomes who also find it difficult to visit their local opticians will be able to get help from the NHS to pay for the optician to visit them at home. 
 From 1 November 1991, people who hold a partial help certificate (AG3) under the NHS Low Income Scheme will be able to put their patient contribution towards the cost of a private home visit by their optician. 
 Previously the contribution could only be spent on sight tests and buying glasses. 
 DoH Press Release H91/401, 22 August 1991. 
 DISABLED PEOPLE &mdash; ORANGE BADGE SCHEME 
 The Minister for Roads and Traffic, Christopher Chope, has announced changes to the Orange Badge Scheme which provides parking concessions for people for disabilities. 
 The main changes are: 
 automatic entitlement to an Orange Badge for those getting Mobility Allowance and War Pensioners' Mobility Supplement; 
 eligibility for people with very severe upper limb disabilities who regularly drive a vehicle; 
 introduction of a passport-style badge; 
 provision in the Road Traffic Bill to tackle abuse; 
 increase from two to three hours in the limit on yellow line waiting. 
 The Minister intends to bring forward amending regulations in the autumn. 
 Department of Transport Press Notice 227, 24 July 1991.  
 MENTAL HEALTH &mdash; AGE CONCERN RESPONSE TO LAW COMMISSION REPORT 
 Age Concern England has replied to the Law Commission's consultation paper, Mentally incapacitated adults and decision-making  (see Information Circular, June 1991). 
 In this response Age Concern England welcomes the wide-ranging review of the law and the account taken of so many of the issues highlighted in 1986 in its publication The law and vulnerable elderly people . 
 The response recognises the need for substantial reform in this area of the law, including clarification and guidelines in regard to tests of capacity. 
 Age Concern would welcome an attempt to introduce a single unified system and favours an element of formality and monitoring with a local and &bquo;user-friendly&equo; face. 
 Age Concern considers that an individual should be able to make statements about their future life circumstances, health care and the like in addition to financial aspects, and would therefore wish to see Enduring Powers of Attorney extended to cover other areas. 
 The view is also expressed that personal care and welfare aspects cannot be divorced from financial and property matters, while it is recognised that proper safeguards are vital. 
 Age Concern wishes to see safeguards against abuse, exploitation and neglect of duty for those who can  take decisions plus procedures for those who cannot  do so. 
 Expansion of the work of the Court of Protection is favoured but if this is not thought appropriate then some form of locally accessible tribunal or court to exercise supervision, possibly supplemented by some form of guardianship, is considered desirable. 
 Available free on receipt of (9&ins; &times; 6&ins;) sae from Legal Unit, Age Concern England. 
 IMPERIAL WAR MUSEUM &mdash; ITEMS FOR USE IN REMINISCENCE WORK 
 Amongst items produced by the Imperial War Museum are some suitable for use during reminiscence sessions. 
 They include 35mm slide packs on subjects such as the home front and women at war, photographs of wartime London and the Battle of Britain, and postcard sets on such topics as fashion in the 1940s, wartime posters and World War I cartoons. 
 Further information from Chris Lewis-Ashley, Business Development Officer, Imperial War Museum, Lambeth Road, London SE1 6HZ.  
 ARTS &mdash; THERAPY 
 The Sesame Institute UK offers training for people working in therapeutic situations. 
 It uses movement and drama to develop the clients' sense of self and to broaden their interests. 
 Since 1964 it has been working with people of all ages and varying needs. 
 The method works on the principle that the art form is a healing agent but that time must be allowed for the work to be effective. 
 Short, long and advanced courses are available. 
 Further information from Administrative Secretary, Sesame Institute UK, Christchurch, 27 Blackfriars Road, London SE1 8NY. 
 Tel: 071&ndash;633 9690. 
 ENERGY EFFICIENCY &mdash; HOUSE OF LORDS COMMITTEE REPORT 
 The House of Lords Select Committee on the European Communities' report, Energy and the environment , says that without &bquo;enormous political will and commitment&equo; the Government's promise to stabilise carbon dioxide emissions at 1990 levels &bquo;will never be met&equo;. 
 The key recommendation is that a workforce should be recruited and trained to bring five million energy-inefficient homes to current building standards at a cost of &pound;2&ndash;3,000 each or a total of &pound;40&ndash;45 billion. 
 Such a programme could, says the report, save 10% of the total energy consumed in the UK, or &pound;4.5 billion a year. 
 Energy and the environment . 
 House of Lords Select Committee on the European Communities thirteenth report, Session 1990&ndash;91 (HL62). 
 29pp. 
 Price &pound;7.95. 
 Available from HMSO. 
 CONSUMER COMPLAINTS &mdash; MORI SURVEY 
 A National Consumer Council report of a MORI survey of 2,005 consumers in March finds that almost a third of the population is unhappy with local authority services. 
 Road maintenance was the biggest source of complaint, with 54% dissatisfied. 
 Refuse collection was seen as the best service, pleasing 85%. 
 Street lighting and libraries also received high ratings. 
 32% were dissatisfied with district councils, whilst almost a quarter were unhappy with county councils.  
 Council tenants were generally satisfied but were concerned about quality and speed of repairs, with 49% finding them too slow. 
 Two-thirds of the respondents were satisfied with local bus services, while coach services won 85% approval. 
 Half of those questioned were happy with British Rail's service, with 31% dissatisfied. 
 Local electricity, gas, telephone and post office counter services all satisfied more than 70% of their customers, with the electricity board coming out on top with an 85% approval rating. 
 Consumer concerns 1990: a consumer view of public and local authority services . 
 58pp. 
 Price &pound;5. 
 Available from National Consumer Council, 20 Grosvenor Gardens, London SW1W 0DH. 
 TELEPHONES &mdash; ACE LETTER ON BT PRICE RISES 
 Sally Greengross, Director of Age Concern England, has written to British Telecom (BT) expressing concern about the likely effects on older people of the price rises announced on 1 August (see Information Circular, September 1991). 
 In her letter of 21 August, Ms Greengross referred to the 1989 Family Expenditure Survey which found that 25% of retired people living alone mainly dependent on the state pension do not have a telephone and linked this &bquo;poor level of penetration among people who need a telephone most&hellip; to the policy of increasing rental and connection charges to the maximum permitted by the retail price index (RPI) + 2% price cap, while targeting businesses and heavy residential users for international call rate reductions and volume discounts&equo;. 
 The letter continues: &bquo;Any increase in connection and rental charges above the RPI will act as a disincentive to pensioners &mdash; since the state pension is uprated only in line with the RPI. 
 Inevitably, the &pound;10 increase in the connection charge will only serve to put telephone ownership out of the reach of more elderly people. 
 &bquo;A commitment to freeze connection and rental charges at current levels for state pensioners and exemption from deposit demands should be the essential prerequisites to improving penetration levels&equo;. 
 Available free on receipt of (9&ins; &times; 4&ins;) sae from Pam Zeida, Information and Policy Department, Age Concern England.  
 TELEPHONES &mdash; BT SECURITY DEPOSITS 
 The maximum security deposit that British Telecom (BT) can ask of new residential customers is now &pound;150 compared to amounts of up to &pound;700 previously. 
 In addition, customers asked for a deposit may now appeal against the decision by BT to charge a deposit. 
 The changes, announced on 15 August, come after an investigation into BT's deposits policy by the Office of Telecommunications (OFTEL). 
 OFTEL had expressed the concern that the level of the deposit had amounted to &bquo;an effective denial of service to some customers&equo;. 
 BT is also revising its credit procedures to reflect the credit-worthiness of potential customers more accurately and will allow appeals against unfair ratings. 
 BT will no longer make deposit decisions based on a customer's address &mdash; the major criterion used to determine the level of deposit under the old policy. 
 OFTEL Press Notice 19/91, 15 August 1991. 
 TELEPHONES &mdash; BRAILLE BILLS 
 British Telecom (BT) can now produce bills in braille and in large print for the partially sighted, free of charge. 
 The new bills have already had successful trials in the East Midlands. 
 The braille bills are produced for BT by the Royal National Institute for the Blind (RNIB). 
 Mr John Wall, chairman of RNIB commented: &bquo;RNIB urges other companies to follow the example of BT and to give visually impaired people the right to privacy&equo;. 
 BT News Release NR64, 12 August 1991. 
 PROBATE &mdash; NEW ACE FACTSHEET 
 A new title has been added to Age Concern England's information factsheet series. 
 Probate &mdash; dealing with someone's estate  (Factsheet no 14) explains ways in which money may be collected, debts paid, and the balance distributed to those who are entitled to receive a share in the estate. 
 Other areas covered are: how to apply for a grant; who may apply for a grant; inheritance tax; settling the estate; intestacy; and other sources of information.  
 Fact no 11, Income Support for residential and nursing homes , has been updated. 
 Single copies of factsheets available free on receipt of a (9&ins; &times; 6&ins;) sae from Distribution Department, Age Concern England. 
 An updated list of factsheets, and details of subscriptions to the factsheet folder service and the cost of bulk orders, are available from Audrey King, Information &amp; Policy Department. 
 HOUSING &mdash; GOVERNMENT ALLOCATIONS TO LOCAL AUTHORITIES 
 The Government has announced plans for local housing authorities to compete against each other for part of the money they need to renovate their stock. 
 Michael Heseltine, Secretary of State for the Environment, stated that from April 1992, 60% rather than the current 50% of Government housing finance will be allocated on a discretionary basis following civil servants' assessment of councils' performance. 
 The proportion allocated according to a need formula will drop to 40%. 
 Amongst the performance criteria to be taken into account when deciding allocations will be councils' willingness to involve the private sector in the management and maintenance of its housing stock, and the extent of tenant participation in the management of estates. 
 Daily Telegraph  1 August 1991. 
 Guardian , 2 August 1991. 
 HOUSING &mdash; EFFECTIVENESS OF CURRENT LEASEHOLD LEGISLATION 
 The Department of the Environment has published the results of a study investigating the impact of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 on resolving problems faced by leaseholders in flats. 
 The survey, carried out by Social and Community Planning Research, interviewed leaseholders, landlords (ie freeholders), managing agents, housing advisers and solicitors. 
 Leaseholders were found to have experienced a variety of problems with the management of their block, including failure on the landlord's part to carry out repairs, too little or excessive refurbishment, estimates &bquo;rigged&equo; by landlords or managing agents, failure to consult leaseholders and difficulty in obtaining information about accounts and insurance. 
 Areas where the legislation was felt to be insufficiently strong included many rights which were considered to be beneficial in theory but ineffectual in practice. 
 In particular, the process of consultation, and the provision within the Act to challenge service charges, were felt to be very difficult to enforce. 
 The Act was often said by advisers to be powerless to deal with problems of insufficient, inadequate or poor quality management services.  
 Respondents identified a number of procedural deficiencies in the Act which was said to lack sufficient powers to enforce compliance. 
  These  was felt to be an excessive use in the Act of phrases such as &bquo;consult&equo;, &bquo;challenge&equo;, &bquo;take note of&equo; and &bquo;reasonable&equo;, which were thought by many to be vague and open to interpretation. 
 Furthermore, landlords and managing agents were said to use a range of &bquo;sharp practices&equo; to circumvent the law or to stop or reduce the likelihood of tenants taking legal action. 
  Coincidently , the report was published not long after the Government's announcement of its intention to introduce commonhold legislation (see Information Circular, August 1991), which is aimed at strengthening the rights of existing leaseholders. 
 The Landlord and Tenant Act 1987: awareness, experience and impact . 
 114pp. 
 Price &pound;9. 
 Available from HMSO. 
 HOUSING &mdash; REGULATION OF ESTATE AGENTS 
 Edward Leigh, Parliamentary Under-Secretary of State for Industry and Consumer Affairs, has announced the introduction of improved protection for consumers from unscrupulous estate agents. 
 The new regulations came into force on 29 July 1991. 
 Individuals can now be banned from estate agency work if they have engaged in &bquo;undesirable&equo; practices such as failing to inform the vendor about services being provided to prospective purchasers, discriminatory conduct against purchasers who are not accepting services from the agent, misrepresenting the existence or status of a prospective purchaser and failing to send written details of offers made by prospective purchasers. 
 Estate agents will now have to give consumers more information, with specific requirements to write to clients informing them of services they intend to offer to prospective purchasers, and to explain in writing terms such as &bquo;sole agency&equo;, &bquo;ready, willing and able&equo;, and &bquo;sole selling rights&equo;. 
 Department of Trade and Industry Press Notice P/91/414, 29 July 1991. 
 HOUSING &mdash; ELDERLY PERSONS' HOUSING AND THE RIGHT TO BUY 
 An internal survey by the Association of District Councils (ADC), reported in the journal Housing , has found that many local authorities are having great difficulty in exempting from the Right to Buy those properties they consider to be especially suitable for older people. 
 The Local Government and Housing Act 1989 gave back to the Secretary of State for the Environment the power to make determinations excluding certain elderly persons' dwellings from the Right to Buy. 
 The ADC found that all of the 83 district councils responding to the survey expressed concern with the way in which the Secretary of State was implementing the legislation.  
 According to the ADC, in the cases quoted by councils the properties by and large fulfilled all the principal criteria set down by the Government for a property suitable for occupation by older people, ie that it was let to persons over pensionable age; access was relatively easy; the accommodation was on level ground; the dwelling had no more than two bedrooms; the heating arrangements were adequate; the property was reasonably conveniently located. 
 Examples of reasons given by the Secretary of State for not allowing a property to be exempted include: 
 the accommodation was located on a busy road which generated excessive noise. 
 The ADC felt that this was ironic, given that a property has to be close to amenities if it is to be excluded from the Right to Buy; 
 the accommodation had an &bquo;exceptionally large garden&equo;, was located on a &bquo;hazardous road&equo; and was a &bquo;good distance&equo; from local shops. 
 According to the council, the garden was indeed large but much of it was paved; the property was in an urban area where the speed limit was 30mph; the shops were located 700 yards from the property; 
 the accommodation was located in an area where younger households lived. 
 In this case the council argued that the property was set within a block in which all but one of the tenants were over pensionable age. 
 This flat had to be sold by the council, and the ADC states that by allowing tenants to purchase such dwellings, the Government will ensure that over time younger households will buy up accommodation formerly occupied by older people; 
 the accommodation was let to a couple in which the man was just under 65. 
 The council argued that it had adopted a sex equality policy to enable both men and women over 60 to rent elderly persons' dwellings, but that they would now have to review these &bquo;progressive&equo; policies. 
 Selling by the back door  by Roger Jarman. 
 Housing , August 1991. 
 (See Periodical Articles section). 
 HOME EQUITY &mdash; INVESTMENT BOND INCOME SCHEMES 
 Some of those caught up in investment bond income schemes (see Information Circular, June 1991) have the right to go to FIMBRA's Consumer Arbitration Scheme, where any award against the broker is legally binding. 
 At the end of August the first arbitration case was decided upon. 
 The arbitrator stated that the elderly couple in question had been sold an unsuitable product and had not been given adequate risk warnings.  
 However, in making his award, the arbitrator subtracted those moneys (plus interest) already received by the couple, who were awarded &pound;9,000 against their current building society debt of &pound;18,000. 
 At the time of writing it appears that the broker in this case has gone into liquidation without making the required payment, and the couple must now turn to the Investors' Compensation Scheme, which can pay compensation in cases where (a) the broker has gone into liquidation, and (b) the original investment was taken up about 28 August 1988. 
 A number of the 150 people who have contacted Age Concern England about the debt they face took up their scheme before this date and will not be able to obtain compensation even if they are granted an award through arbitration or private legal action. 
 Sally Greengross, Director of Age Concern England, has written to the Chartered Institute of Arbitrators urging that awards made by arbitrators should enable investors to escape their debt completely, ie to pay off the whole of their outstanding loan, which will otherwise &bquo;roll up&equo; on a daily basis, in some cases leading to repossession. 
 SOCIAL SECURITY &mdash; SUPPORT FOR LOW INCOME FAMILIES 
 This report looks at the effect of the introduction of Income Support and Family Credit in terms of the standard of service, the impact on low income families and the staffing needed. 
 Amongst its conclusions, the report welcomes the emphasis being placed by the DSS and Social Security Benefits Agency (SSAB) on &bquo;customer care&equo;, and the recognition that much remains to be done to be sure that an adequate service is given. 
 They note that relocation and reorganisation programmes are expected to improve the service and also that it is the intention to provide training and advice to staff on dealing properly with customers. 
 A system of assessing &bquo;tolerable&equo; and &bquo;desirable&equo; standards at offices is being used based on 13 different factors such as accuracy and time for applications to be processed. 
 In giving evidence, Michael Bichard, Chief Executive of the SSAB, listed the 14 offices (out of around 470) that failed to reach tolerable standards. 
 These are: Birmingham Ladywood, Birmingham Ravenhurst, Leicester Burleigh's Way, Ealing, Oxford, Neasden, Paddington, Aldershot, Battersea, Brixton, Lewisham, Streatham, Woking and Chelsea. 
 Support for low income families . 
 House of Commons Committee of Public Accounts twenty-sixth report, Session 1990&ndash;91. 
 (HC216). 
 21pp. 
 Price &pound;7.95. 
 Available from HMSO. 
 SOCIAL SECURITY &mdash; CHANGES TO RULES ON BENEFIT BACKPAYMENT 
 The Government has now introduced changes to the rules for the backpayment of social security benefits (see Information Circular, May 1991). 
 It was originally proposed that Supplementary Benefit and National Assistance would be removed from the provisions of Regulation 72 of the Social Security (Adjudication) Regulations. 
 (Under Regulation 72, unlimited backdating can be made in cases of official error). 
 However a DSS Press Release states that the Government has accepted the recommendation of the Social Security Advisory Committee to adopt an alternative approach whereby the circumstances under which unlimited arrears can apply is more explicitly defined. 
 The circumstances are: where the adjudications authority failed to take into account specific evidence before it relating to a claim; where a member of staff did not submit or record relevant evidence; or where an adjudication officer overlooked and misconstrued a provision in legislation or case law. 
 The regulations originally were intended to come into effect on 11 September 1991, but the commencement date was brought forward to 31 August. 
 Nicholas Scott, Minister for Social Security and Disabled People, said that this was &bquo;to prevent widespread abuse of the system&equo;. 
 DSS Press Release 120/91, 21 August 1991. 
 DSS Press Release 91/123, 30 August 1991. 
 SOCIAL SECURITY &mdash; AGE LETTER ON UPRATINGS 
 Age Concern England has written to Tony Newton, Secretary of State for Social Security, prior to his announcement on social security upratings which is expected at the end of October. 
 The letter asks him to consider the needs of older people dependent on state benefits. 
 The issues covered include: the level of the state pension, the position of older people with incomes just above Income Support level, the minimum Community Charge Benefit, Income Support for residential and nursing home fees, the assessment of capital for income-related benefits, the Social Fund budget and disability benefits. 
 Available free on receipt of a (9&ins; &times; 4&ins;) sae from Cathy Bennett, Information and Policy Department. 
 SOCIAL SECURITY &mdash; EXTENSION OF CARER PREMIUM, DEFINITION OF REMUNERATIVE WORK AND OTHER CHANGES 
 Two sets of regulations have been laid before Parliament which make a number of changes to Income Support, Housing Benefit and Community Charge Benefit. 
 These include: 
 the extension of the care premium for eight weeks after the claimant ceases to be entitled to Invalid Care Allowance. 
 For Income Support the claimant will not be required to be available for employment during that eight-week period. 
 This will come into effect on 7 October 1991; that the value of the right to receive a personal pension will be disregarded as a person's capital from 7 October 1991; 
 that the hours of work required for a person to be treated as in &bquo;remunerative work&equo; will be reduced from not fewer than 24 to not fewer than 16 hours a week from April 1992. 
 This will mean that a person working 16 hours a week or more will not be able to claim income support. 
 The Housing Benefit and Community Charge Benefits (miscellaneous) amendment regulation 1991 . 
 Statutory Instrument 1991 no 1599. 
 10pp. 
 Price &pound;2.20. 
 The Income Support (general) amendment no 4 regulations 1991 . 
 Statutory Instrument 1991 no 1559. 
 10pp. 
 Price &pound;2.20. 
 Both available from HMSO. 
 SOCIAL SECURITY &mdash; SOCIAL FUND 
 On 8 August 1991, Nicholas Scott, Minister for Social Security and Disabled People, announced increases in the Social Fund budget for 1991&ndash;92. 
 The budget for grants has been increased by &pound;10 million and for loans by &pound;30 million, increasing the total amount from &pound;228 million to &pound;268 million. 
 All districts will receive increases taking into account &bquo;pressure of local unemployment patterns and of the importance of focusing extra help on those most in need&equo;. 
 DSS Press Release 91/118, 8 August 1991. 
 The Social Fund annual report for 1990&ndash;91 has been published. 
 More than 1.3 million discretionary payments were made in the year in question. 
 Of the total &pound;68.1 million allocation for community care grants, &pound;67.4 million was spent. 
 For loans the total allocation was &pound;160.4 million of which &pound;27.8 million was awarded for crisis loans and &pound;128.4 million for budgeting loans. 
 For all client groups 40% of decisions on community care grants resulted in awards. 
 20.4% of the grants made and 3.6% of loans were awarded to pensioners. 
 The report also gives details of the reasons for refusals. 
 For older people just over half the refusals for grants are reported to be because the basic criteria are not satisfied. 
 Annual report by the Secretary of State for Social Security on the Social Fund 1990&ndash;91 . 
 42pp. 
 Price &pound;7.35. 
 Available from HMSO. 
 A report by the Social Security Research Consortium calls for the discretionary Social Fund to be abandoned because it is failing to help those who most need it. 
 The report starts by reviewing the pattern of spending in the first two years of the fund. 
 It then looks at the impact on users of social services and social work departments. 
 Monitoring revealed widespread financial need that the Social Fund could not meet. 
 Loans were felt only to provide a short-term solution while grants were inadequate or not available to those in need. 
 Social workers in the study had &bquo;grave reservations&equo; about the fund and a few felt it was quicker and easier to apply to charities for help.  
 A second report on the same research study gives further information about clients' use of the fund. 
 Information was obtained about 1,200 people approaching local authority departments with financial needs not met by their weekly benefits, and about 1,084 people approaching Citizens' Advice Bureaux (CABs). 
 The characteristics of the clients are described, as are the circumstances leading to their requests for help. 
 Around half of those approaching social services, and 60% of those calling at a CAB, already had debts or direct deductions from their benefits. 
 Often the need for help arose from a specific pressure such as damaged or lost equipment or from a life event like moving house or the birth of a child. 
 The report then looks at how the fund was used, the outcomes obtained and the options for those refused help. 
 Half the people in the study received nothing from a formal agency and the authors conclude that the Social Fund &bquo;is largely irrelevant to most real-life situations within which the poorest people find themselves&equo;. 
 Cash limited: limited cash  by the Social Security Research Consortium. 
 47pp. 
 Price &pound;7. 
 Relieving poverty: use of the Social Fund by social work clients and other agencies  by Gill Stewart and John Stewart. 
 53pp. 
 Price &pound;12. 
 Both available from Association of Metropolitan Authorities, 35 Great Smith Street, London SW1P 3BJ. 
 The annual report of the Social Fund Commissioner for 1990&ndash;91 on the standards of reviews has also been published. 
 9,775 applications for review were received, an increase of 24% on 1989&ndash;90. 
 The aim to clear applications within six weeks was achieved from August to December 1990 but the backlog then rose to eight weeks as applications increased. 
 Twenty-five per cent of decisions reviewed were changed, 57% were referred back to the local office and in 18% of cases the original decision was confirmed. 
 The Commissioner considers the quality of decisions by Social Fund Inspectors to be high with around 90% reaching the &bquo;high quality standard required&equo;. 
 Annual Report of the Social Fund Commissioner for 1990&ndash;91 on the standards of reviews by Social Fund Inspectors . 
 49pp. 
 Price &pound;6.85. 
 Available from HMSO. 
 SOCIAL SECURITY &mdash; HOUSING BENEFIT: GUIDANCE ON THE TREATMENT OF INCOME 
 A recent DSS Housing Benefit/Community Charge Benefit circular has given guidance about the treatment of income which is paid at intervals other than one week. 
 Where income such as an occupational pension or Retirement Pension is paid into a bank or building society account on, for example, a monthly or four-weekly basis, in some cases this has been treated as capital resulting in a possible reduction of benefit. 
 In effect it appears that the pension has been assessed both as income and capital. 
 The circular states that income to cover a certain period should be ignored as capital for that period. 
 For example if a person who has &pound;3,000 capital receives a monthly pension of &pound;200 paid into their bank account, this should not be assessed as an increase in savings unless it remains unspent at the time the next payment is due.  
 DSS Circular HB/CCB (91) 15, 30 July 1991. 
 SOCIAL SECURITY &mdash; HOUSING BENEFIT REVIEWS 
 This study looks at the Housing Benefit review system, drawing on data collected from a number of sources. 
 This includes information from local authority staff and records, a postal questionnaire of councillors on Review Board panels, and fieldwork in six areas which included interviews with claimants, housing benefit officers and advice workers. 
 In the present system claimants can ask for an internal review and if they are still dissatisfied, take their case to Review Board of local councillors. 
 Among the findings were: 
 claimants' knowledge of their rights of review and the procedures was limited, and most authorities give little information and publicity about this; 
 the way reviews are carried out reflects the size and type of authority and the attitude of senior officers and councillors; 
 some local authorities have institutionalised unlawful practices such as having a second internal review before the case has a chance to go to a Review Board; 
 claimants did not generally feel Review Boards to be independent. 
 Although local authority staff and councillors accepted that Review Boards could not be truly independent, members feel that in practice they did act  independently; 
 few Review Board hearings took place within the statutory six weeks; 
 decisions are sometimes influenced by factors such as the local authority's policies, political views of Board members and the character of the appellant. 
 In some cases decisions in favour of claimants went beyond the powers given in regulations. 
 The report considers options for changes to the system. 
 It argues for a one-stage system with challenges to decisions being thought of as &bquo;appeals&equo; rather than &bquo;reviews&equo;. 
 Although the authors see some advantages in a system within the local authority, they conclude that claimants would be better served by independent tribunals and feel Social Security Tribunals are well placed to take on the task. 
 Housing Benefit reviews . 
 DSS Research Report no 3 by Roy Sainsbury and Tony Eardley. 
 136pp. 
 Price &pound;16.50. 
 Available from HMSO.  
 SOCIAL SECURITY &mdash; INVALID CARE ALLOWANCE STUDY 
 This report looks at the role of Invalid Care Allowance (ICA) through secondary analysis of available statistics and a survey of 60 ICA claimants. 
 The survey included people receiving ICA, some who had stopped receiving ICA three to twelve months previously, and others who had been refused the allowance. 
 Although around one million people were estimated to be caring for at least 35 hours a week, only 109,000 received ICA in December 1989. 
 Few carers in the study were in employment, reflecting the earnings limit which was only &pound;12 at the time. 
 However low levels of employment were also found among ex-carers particularly those in their fifties and sixties. 
 Data from the General Household Survey and Family Expenditure Survey showed that carers and carer households have substantially lower incomes than average. 
 Usually ICA claimants had particularly low average household incomes. 
 In addition carers often reported further expenditure related to disability and caring which had resulted in using savings and cutting down on normal expenditure. 
 Around a third of people in the study reported being affected by the overlapping benefit rules, and this aroused strong feeling of  unjustice . 
 Despite negative comments about the level of the allowance and overlapping benefit rules, ICA is seen as a valuable addition to the resources of carers. 
 The report also looks at ways in which the effectiveness and targeting of ICA could be improved &mdash; for example by increasing the level, raising the earnings rule and by improving the take-up of Attendance Allowance. 
 Social security and community care: the case of the Invalid Care Allowance . 
 DSS Research Report no 4 by Eithne McLaughlin. 
 67pp. 
 Price &pound;9.70. 
 Available from HMSO. 
 SOCIAL SECURITY &mdash; CONSUMER VIEWS ON ATTENDANCE ALLOWANCE MEDICAL EXAMINATIONS 
 This is a research report after a study looking at Attendance Allowance claimants' views of the medical examination they underwent. 
 Data was collected using a postal questionnaire sent to just over 3,000 people in two regions &mdash; Bristol and Manchester. 
 This produced about 2,500 completed questionnaires. 
 Overall the results show high levels of satisfaction in the aspects covered by the questionnaire. 
 Seventy-five per cent said they had received at least 3 days notice of the visit and 94% were happy with the amount of notice. 
 Ninety-one per cent of people asked to demonstrate certain movements or activities were content with or indifferent about this aspect while 5% were not happy. 
 Of claimants who had a clinical examination, 90% were satisfied while 7% were dissatisfied &mdash; mainly due to a perceived lack of thoroughness. 
 The manner of the examining doctor was described as pleasant by 85% and as unpleasant by 2%. 
 Older people were more likely to express satisfaction. 
 Other factors related to satisfaction level included the outcome of the claim (where this was known) and the way examinations were carried out.  
 In discussing the findings the author concludes that while a number of people do have cause to complain about their medical examination, these results indicate that only a small percentage have problems. 
 The Attendance Allowance medical examination.  
 DSS Research Report no 5 by Julia Chilvers. 
 37pp. 
 Price &pound;5.50. 
 Available from HMSO. 
 COUNCIL TAX &mdash; AUDIT COMMISSION'S RESPONSE 
 The Audit Commission's response to Government proposals for the council tax focuses mainly on administrative implications. 
 The Commission concludes that the community charge will become harder to collect and that every effort should be made to introduce the new tax in April 1993. 
 However, the timetable for the council tax is tight and will only be achievable if lessons are learnt from the introduction of the community charge. 
 The Commission believes that the abolition of the 20% minimum contribution will ease the administrative burden, but notes that the consultation paper is vague on a number of administrative details. 
 The paper also comments on the low proportion of expenditure to be raised through local taxation and the high &bquo;gearing&equo; on tax rises. 
 &bquo;Gearing&equo; refers to the increase in bills caused by authorities raising spending above their Standard Spending Assessments (SSAs). 
 In some areas a 1% increase in spending will result in a 7 or 8% increase in bills. 
 The Commission concludes that the Government should consider options to enhance the local tax base and should make efforts to increase the understanding and acceptability of SSAs. 
 A response to the Government's consultation paper: A new tax for local government  by the Audit Commission. 
 14pp. 
 Limited number of copies available from the Audit Commission Library. 
 Tel: (0272) 236757. 
 PERIODICAL ARTICLES 
 An evaluation of an alternative to long-stay hospital care for frail elderly patients: 1.  
 The model of care: 2.  
 Costs and effectiveness  by David Challis and others. 
 Age and Ageing 20 , 1991, pp 236&ndash;244, 245&ndash;254. 
 Describes a project where case managers employed by social services, with devolved budgets, were located in a geriatric multi-disciplinary team. 
 Concludes that older people receiving community-based care had a higher quality of life than those in hospital, and that there was no evidence of greater stress upon carers. 
 Issues in physician-elderly patient interaction  by Ronald Adelman, Michele G. Greene and Rita Charon. 
 Ageing and Society 11 , 1991, pp 127&ndash;148 
 Considers barriers to communication such as sensory or cognitive impairment, and reviews studies of doctor-patient relationships. 
 Talks to elders: social structure, attitudes and forms of address  by Linda A. Wood and Ellen Bouchard Ryani. 
 Ageing and Society 11 , 1991, pp 167&ndash;187. 
 Reviews research on attitudes and talk to older people, with particular reference to the concepts of status and solidarity. 
 The Children Act  by Katja Faber. 
 Choice , September 1991, pp 41&ndash;43. 
 Describes the rights this new legislation will afford to grandparents and other non-parents. 
 The dark incontinent  by Maureen Cleave. 
 Daily Telegraph , 20 August 1991. 
 Short overview of the subject of incontinence. 
 Elderly people and energy efficiency  by Ann Salvage. 
 Energy Action , August 1991, pp 8&ndash;9. 
 Includes discussion of lack of awareness amongst older people of means to help save energy. 
 New face of ageism  by Anne Karpf. 
 Guardian , 3 August 1991. 
 Critique of what is claimed to be a new, over- positive  stereotype of ageing which denies its problems. 
 Selling by the back door  by Roger Jarman. 
 Housing , August 1991, pp 18&ndash;19, 21. 
 Claims that the legislation designed to protect council-owned elderly persons dwellings from Right to Buy is being undermined &mdash; see elsewhere in this Circular. 
 The law and house adaptations for people with disabilities  by Derek McConnell. 
 Housing , August 1991, pp 26&ndash;27. 
 Discusses the provisions of the Local Government and Housing Act 1989 and other legislation. 
 A two-faced society  by Sheila Green. 
 Nursing Times , 14 August 1991, pp 26&ndash;29. 
 The author disguised herself as an eighty-year old and reports considerable discrimination in shops and on public transport which disappeared when she returned to the same situations in her normal persona. 
 Legal lessons  by Neil Bateman. 
 Social Work Today , 1 August 1991, pp 15&ndash;17. 
 Discussion of advocacy. 
 New age problem  by Mary Ann Hildrew. 
 Social Work Today,  22 August 1991, pp 15&ndash;17. 
 Report on local authority guidelines on elder abuse.  
 Hidden grief  by Emma Small. 
 Social Work Today , 29 August 1991, p 21. 
 Report on the work of the Gay Bereavement Project. 
 Single copies of any of the above periodical articles can be supplied by the ACE library. 
 We are required by the Copyright Act to have a written request before we can supply the copy, for which the law demands that we make a charge. 
 Forms are available for this purpose from the Librarian. 
 NEW PUBLICATIONS 
 Supporting Black Voluntary Action 
 This report is written primarily for funders, such as local authorities, Government, trusts and businesses, and describes the importance of Black and Ethnic Minority Local Development Agencies in developing black voluntary action. 
 Drawing on the experience of the Local Development Agencies Development Fund, the report gives guidelines on grant-aid procedures, labelling, and effective ways to support management committees of Black Local Development Agencies. 
 Supporting black voluntary action  by Audrey West. 
 37pp. 
 Price &pound;5. 
 Available from National Council for Voluntary Organisations, 26 Bedford Square, London WC1B 3HU. 
 Researching Voluntary and Community Action 
 This publication is the final report of a seminar organised by the Association of Researchers in Voluntary Action and Community Involvement (ARVAC) and hosted by the Voluntary Services Unit at the Home Office in November 1990. 
 This report contains three keynote speeches on commissioning, carrying out and disseminating research. 
 Also included are summaries which discuss particular experiences from many areas of the voluntary sector. 
 Researching voluntary and community action: questions of policy and practice  edited by Peter Lloyd, Pat Marsden and Duncan Scott. 
 152pp. 
 Price &pound;9.75 (plus &pound;1.25 postage and packing). 
 Available from ARVAC, Unit 29, Wivenhoe Business Centre, Brook Street, Wivenhoe, Essex, CO7 9DP.  
 Lifetimes of Commitment 
 Lifetimes of commitment  explores the ways in which political belief is developed and sustained throughout the course of a lifetime. 
 Through extensive interviews, it focuses on the lives of 15 British men and women, aged between 70 and 90, who have dedicated half a century or longer to working for social change and justice. 
 Lifetimes of commitment:  aging , politics, psychology  by Molly Andrews. 
 229pp. 
 Price &pound;30 (hardback), &pound;10.95 (paperback). 
 Available from Cambridge University Press, Edinburgh Building, Shaftesbury Road, Cambridge, CB2 2RV. 
 Medical Advice for Residential Homes 
 This guide contains information about specific medical conditions which may affect older people in residential and nursing homes and other places where they may be cared for &mdash; such as hotels and guest houses. 
 The book briefly describes the regulations relevant to setting up and running care homes; looks at general issues to do with medical care in homes &mdash; such as relationships with general practitioners, prescribing and use of drugs, and admission to hospital; and then summarises the implications of a range of clinical conditions which may affect older people in care homes. 
 Medical advice for residential homes  by Graham Hunter. 
 104pp. 
 Price &pound;12.95. 
 Published by Longman in association with the Social Care Association. 
 Available from Longman Group UK Ltd, Longman House, Burnt Mill, Harlow, Essex, CM20 2YE. 
 Residential Care Training Video 
 An hour-long video from the Centre for Applied Gerontology, Training to care the video way , discusses physical handling, incontinence and communication. 
 It is aimed at new staff in residential care homes. 
 Training to care the video way . 
 Price &pound;55.81 plus &pound;2.35 postage and packing (cheques payable to University of Birmingham). 
 Available from Centre for Applied Gerontology, University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham B15 2TT. 
 Community Care Planning 
 The changes in provision of community care services initiated by the white paper, Caring for people , have major implications for local authority social services departments. 
 A report from the Joseph Rowntree Foundation discusses many of the themes raised in the white paper, including joint working, assessment procedures, and quality control. 
 The discussion is illustrated by the results of interviews with ten directors of social services, and draws on illustrative material from authorities which are already tackling aspects of the community care reforms. 
 The study particularly notes the difficulties which may arise in defining the split between &bquo;health&equo; and &bquo;social&equo; care. 
 Concern is also voiced about the adequacy of resources for implementation of the new policies. 
 From providing to enabling: local authorities and community care planning  by Nirmala Rao. 
 78pp. 
 Price &pound;5.50. 
 Available from Joseph Rowntree Foundation, The Homestead, 40 Water End, York, YO3 6LP. 
 Markets in Social Care Services 
 A resource pack has been produced by the School for Advanced Urban Studies at the University of Bristol. 
 The pack is designed to help local authorities and independent service providers address the practical and conceptual issues around markets and contracts in community care services. 
 The pack includes a discussion paper and seminar report on issues related to markets in social care; plus additional materials, including journal articles and specimen contracts and service agreements. 
 Markets in social care services resource pack  by Lesley Hoyes. 
 Price &pound;14.50. 
 Available from School for Advanced Urban Studies, University of Bristol, Rodney Lodge, Grange Road, Bristol BS8 4EA. 
 Support for Carers of Afro-Caribbean Elderly People 
 The King's Fund Centre Carers Unit has developed a project looking specifically at the needs of Afro-Caribbean carers. 
 The project has produced a booklet based on research in selected London boroughs and other areas of the country. 
 The project consulted carers themselves about their needs, and also worked with voluntary and statutory agencies dealing with Afro-Caribbean elderly people. 
 The booklet describes services which might be available to Afro-Caribbean carers, and includes quotations from interviews and examples of experiences of carers. 
 There is advice about benefits, legal help, housing, health and social services. 
 There is also a list of the Afro-Caribbean organisations contacted during the project's work. 
 The support you need: information for carers of Afro-Caribbean elderly people  by Lynda Eribo. 
 70pp. 
 Single copies price &pound;2 (plus 50p postage and packing); bulk orders of over 100 copies price &pound;1.50 each including postage and packing. 
 Published by the King's Fund Centre. 
 Available from Dept KFP, Bailey Distribution Ltd, Learoyd Road, Mountfield Industrial Estate, New Romney, Kent, TN28 XU.  
 Carers' Local Groups 
 Carers National Association has recently produced a publication, Branching out , aimed at carers' groups, about the work of its 85 local branches which provide support and information to carers in their area, and endeavour to raise awareness of carers' needs. 
 It briefly outlines activities such as helplines, respite care services and consultation on community care proposals. 
 Branching out: the voice of carers at local level  edited by Margaret Unwin. 
 20pp. 
 Available free from Carers National Association, 29 Chilworth Mews, London W2 3RG. 
 Informal Carers Training Pack 
 A booklet and set of cards form a training exercise which aims to stimulate discussion about the needs of informal carers, and to confront some assumptions on which services are based. 
 The package is designed to be used with staff from health, social services, housing, voluntary and private agencies. 
 The three stages of the exercise are: examination of personal values of the participants; evaluation of existing services in the light of values expressed; and a focus on ways of changing services so that carers can have access to &bquo;valued lifestyles for themselves, as well as for the people they care for&equo;. 
 New lifestyles for carers: a training exercise for staff and carers based on the principle of normalisation  by Hilary Brown and Thurstine Bassett. 
 26pp plus two overhead projector transparencies and one set of New Lifestyles cards (sufficient material for two groups of up to twenty-four people in total). 
 Price &pound;29.75 plus 10% postage and packing. 
 Available from Pavilion Publishing (Brighton) Ltd, 42 Lansdowne Place, Hove, East Sussex, BN3 1HH. 
 NHS Handbook 
 The 1991 edition of the NHS handbook  has been published by the National Association of Health Authorities and Trusts (NAHAT). 
 The handbook is intended to be a readable guide to the NHS for all those interested, whether health authority members, staff or members of the public. 
 This latest edition incorporates the changes introduced by the NHS reforms, and aims to provide a comprehensive description of the new organisation and structure of the NHS. 
 The guide includes information on the role of health authorities and Trusts; the new roles of members of health authorities, Family Health Services Authorities and Trusts; complaints, quality assurance and planning in the NHS; assessing the healthcare needs of local populations; Care in the Community; and services for elderly people.  
 The NHS handbook 1991 . 
 7th edition, edited by Barbara Connah and Ruth Pearson. 
 267pp. 
 Price &pound;18.95 plus postage and packing. 
 Available from Macmillan Education, Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hants. 
 RG21 2XF. 
 National Targets for Health 
 The Faculty of Public Health Medicine has published the first report of a working party set up to investigate available indicators of the nation's health. 
 The report, UK levels of health , discusses the need for a common, strategic approach to improving the health of the nation. 
 It aims to present the available evidence on selected topics of concern, and to highlight areas for future improvement. 
 The report details the targets which the Working Party developed for five main areas of public health concern, and the associated needs for improved information and data sources. 
 One of the five fields dealt with is disability in the elderly. 
 UK levels of health: first report, June 1991 . 
 61pp. 
 Price &pound;5.90. 
 Available from Faculty of Public Health Medicine, Royal College of Physicians, 4 St Andrew's Place, London NW1 4LB. 
 District Health Authorities and Assessing Local Populations' Health Needs 
 The Centre for Health Economics at the University of York has published a discussion paper on District Health Authority assessment of local populations' need for health services, and of priority setting. 
 This paper considers the usefulness of existing sources of data for health needs assessment. 
 Future role of the District Health Authority: assessing needs for services and setting priorities  by Brian Ferguson and Steve Ryder. 
 58pp. 
 Price &pound;5. 
 Available from Publications Secretary, Centre of Health Economics, University of York, York YO1 5DD. 
 Primary Care 
 The King's Fund Institute and the Nuffield Provincial Hospitals Trust have published a report called Developing primary care: opportunities for the 1990s . 
 The report draws on the experience of the first 14 Primary Care Development Fund Projects, which were established in 1989. 
 It attempts to identify key primary care questions to be resolved in Britain in the 1990s. 
 Topics discussed include discharge from hospital and supporting individuals with chronic conditions. 
 Developing primary care: opportunities for the 1990s  by David Taylor. 
 (Research Report No 10). 
 48pp. 
 Price &pound;5 plus 50p postage and packing. 
 Available from Department D/KFP, Bailey Distribution Ltd, Learoyd Road, Mountfield Industrial Estate, New Romney, Kent, TN28 8XU.  
 Nurses' Guide to Activities Programmes 
 This book is a practical guide for nurses who wish to develop activities programmes for their older clients. 
 The book describes ways of going about setting up a variety of programmes with different purposes. 
 It contains practical suggestions for different activities, and includes a set of worksheets which can be photocopied to help with planning and record keeping. 
 The overall aim of the book is to help with developing activities which meet the needs and wishes of individual older people. 
 Develop an activities programme: a practical guide for nurses working with older people  by Theresa Briscoe. 
 83pp. 
 Price &pound;9.95. 
 Available from Winslow Press, Telford Road, Bicester, Oxon, OX6 0TS. 
 Health Visiting and Elderly People 
 The second edition of Health visiting and elderly people: a health promotion challenge  has been published. 
 It is primarily intended for health visitors, plus public health nurses, health promotion workers and other staff. 
 The book includes consideration of health promotion in later life; the relationship of World Health Organisation targets to the care of older adults; and the specific needs of ethnic minority older people and of frail, vulnerable older people. 
 Health visiting and elderly people: a health promotion challenge . 
 2nd edition, by Mary McClymont, Silvea Thomas and Michael J Denham. 
 334pp. 
 Price &pound;16.50. 
 Published by Churchill Livingstone, Robert Stevenson House, 1&ndash;3 Baxter's Place, Leith Walk, Edinburgh EH1 3AF. 
 FHSAs and Dental Services 
 The Department of Health and the Welsh Office have published the report of a working group on the future role of Family Health Services Authorities (FHSAs) in relation to general dental services, and the Community Dental Service. 
 The report assesses the current role of FHSAs, Regional Health Authorities (RHAs) and District Health Authorities (DHAs) in the management of primary dental services, and makes various recommendations, such as that FHSAs should become the focus of responsibility for co-ordinating primary dental care, including in the long term the treatment role of the Community Dental Service. 
 The role of Family Health Services Authorities in primary dental care . 
 37pp. 
 Available free from FHS2A, Department of Health, Room 526, Portland Court, 160 Great Portland Street, London W1N 5DT.  
 Know Your Medicines 
 The second edition of this guide to medicines for older people and those who help care for them has been published by Age Concern England. 
 It explains how the body works and how it is affected by drugs. 
 Know your medicines  is divided into three sections: section 1 gives general information on using medicines, and advice on questions to ask a doctor, nurse or pharmacist; section 2 covers the actions of medicines on the body system; section 3 is an index of medicines to enable users to check what each is for and what effects they can have. 
 The side-effects of medicines are also listed. 
 This edition additionally incorporates information for those working in residential homes. 
 Know your medicines . 
 2nd edition, by Pat Blair. 
 144pp. 
 Price &pound;6.95. 
 Available from Publications Department, Age Concern England. 
 Disability and Health &mdash; Older People's Perceptions 
 A sample of older people was derived from age/sex registers of five general practices in Kent. 
 Two hundred of these were interviewed with the aim of finding out how they felt about their health and physical disabilities, and comparisons were made with findings from a range of objective measures included in the interviews. 
 Most of the older people interviewed perceived that they were in good health. 
 Their measure of their health status was related to what they could do, rather than to the presence of current disease or conditions. 
 Their views of appropriate actions for resolving problems of disability related to their own value systems; the authors of the study conclude that a standard service, which does not take individual values into account, will conflict with the view of some people it is trying to help. 
 They suggest that clinical psychologists, with an understanding of psychological aspects of disability, may have a role to play in the development of services for older people with disabilities, and in training other health service professionals in how to respond to problems of disability in older people. 
 Disability and health services: perceptions, beliefs and experiences of elderly people  by C J Partridge, M Johnston and L Morris. 
 24pp. 
 Price &pound;3. 
 Available from Centre for Physiotherapy Research, Kings College London, Strand, London WC2R 2LS.  
 Ideas for Alzheimer's Carers 
 The Alzheimer's Disease Society has published a book called Exchanging ideas . 
 It is primarily intended for carers, and draws together practical hints and ideas sent in by carers of people with Alzheimer's Disease, on subjects including household tasks, exercise, using transport, music, games and gardening. 
 Exchanging ideas: ideas, suggestions and helpful hints from carers of Alzheimer's Disease sufferers  compiled by Ann Blofield. 
 56pp. 
 Price &pound;3.50. 
 Available from Alzheimer's Disease Society, 158&ndash;160 Balham High Road, London SW12 9BN. 
 Meanings of Death 
 This book shows something of what has emerged out of religious interpretations of death, not as a history of death but as an indication of what lies at the root of the major religious traditions, lending to each its characteristic style. 
 It includes sections on death and the origins of religion, and religions and the origins of death, from various religious perspectives &mdash; those of Judaism, Christianity, Hinduism and Buddhism. 
 The conclusion suggests how religious and secular attitudes to death might be unified in a manner that could support pastoral involvement in hospice and hospital work. 
 The meanings of death  by John Bowker. 
 243pp. 
 Price &pound;16.95 (plus &pound;1.85 postage and packing). 
 Available from Cambridge University Press, Edinburgh Building, Cambridge CB2 2RU. 
 Reminiscence &mdash; West Indian Stories 
 Age Concern Thamesdown's Caribbean Lunch Club has produced a book of reminiscences and recipes. 
 The idea grew out of their weekly meetings and from the desire to inform younger West Indians about their heritage. 
 The book  consist  of 12 stories, a number of recipes and some Ring Play Rhymes. 
 &bquo;We just came for five years&hellip;&equo;: writings about young life in Jamaica and adult life in England . 
 46pp. 
 Price &pound;3. 
 Available from Age Concern Thamesdown, 14 Milton Road, Swindon SN1 5JE.  
 Multicultural Healthcare and Rehabilitation for Older People 
 Demographic changes in Britain are resulting in a varied ethnic minority population. 
 Age Concern England and Edward Arnold have jointly produced a book which brings together various authors experienced in addressing the particular needs of elders from ethnic minorities. 
 Health needs and beliefs, special circumstances, cultural requirements and the history of immigration are amongst the subjects discussed with reference to individual minority groups. 
 There is also a section on future planning of services for multicultural elders. 
 Multicultural healthcare and rehabilitation of older people  edited by Amanda J Squires. 
 206pp. 
 Price &pound;9.95. 
 Available from Publications Department, Age Concern England. 
 Arts Provision for Older People 
 Partnerships , a quarterly newspaper highlighting issues in the fields of arts and disabilities in the West Midlands, has produced a special issue looking at arts provision for older people. 
 Partnerships , summer 1991. 
 8pp. 
 Limited number of copies available free from Art Link, The Garage Arts &amp; Media Centre, 1 Hatherton Street, Walsall WS1 1YB. 
 Using Informal Education 
 This book looks at the development of informal education, its theory and practice, in a variety of settings including residential care and community. 
 It includes the uses of informal education for carers. 
 Using informal education  edited by Tony Jeffs and Mark Smith. 
 176pp. 
 Price &pound;30 hardback, &pound;10.99 paperback. 
 Available from Open University Press, Celtic Court, 22 Ballmoor, Buckingham MK18 1XW. 
 Educational Guidance Services 
 The National Educational Guidance Initiative has published its comprehensive listing of educational information and advice services for adults. 
 All the services listed offer free guidance to anyone over the age of 19 who has been away from education for a significant period. 
 Information is available on all kinds of education and training opportunities, full and part-time, vocational and non-vocational. 
 Entries include information on facilities such as disabled access and interpretation services. 
 Educational guidance services for adults: UK Directory 1991&ndash;92 . 
 110pp. 
 Price &pound;5. 
 Available from NIACE, Publication Sales Department, 19B DeMontfort Street, Leicester LE1 7GE.  
 Housing &mdash; Social Landlords and Housing Complaints Procedures 
 A National Consumer Council report suggests that only 31% of council and housing associations tenants were satisfied with the way in which their complaints were handled, and that one in six tenants dissatisfied with the service provided by their landlord had not made a complaint at all. 
 The report is based on a University of Salford research project entitled Voicing grievances and getting redress , which is a comparative study of tenants of different types of public sector landlord. 
 It looks at the reasons for dissatisfaction at the ways in which complaints are handled, highlighting an example of an elderly couple who had waited two years for someone to come round with a colour chart, prior to decorating the outside of their house. 
 The report looks at the reasons for having a complaints procedure and discusses the principles of good practice for complaints and appeals procedures. 
 Considerable stress is laid on the accessibility and approachability of the landlord organisations, especially given that most tenants stated a preference to speak rather than write to housing staff about their problems. 
 Housing complaints procedures: principles of good practice for social landlords . 
 60pp. 
 Available free from National Consumer Council, 20 Grosvenor Gardens, London SW1W 0DH. 
 The State and Social Welfare 
 This book aims to present a reappraisal of the objectives and achievements of the welfare state. 
 After an overview of issues, questions of principle are raised with chapters reflecting different viewpoints. 
 The third section covers the practical implementation of policy including a chapter on the British state pension. 
 The book also looks at European policies, and considers the implementation of policy changes within a political and institutional context. 
 The state and social welfare  edited by Thomas and Dorothy Wilson. 
 305pp. 
 Price &pound;16.50. 
 Available from Longman Group UK Ltd, Longman House, Burnt Mill, Harlow, Essex, CM20 2YE. 
 Training for Older People 
 Training for older people  is an International Labour Office handbook written for trainers and training institutions of all kinds dealing with the training of older workers or older people in general. 
 This handbook emphasises the design of training programmes directed towards placing older people in the labour market.  
 It provides information on methods to improve the efficiency and effectiveness of training programmes for older workers, including helping older workers to find productive employment. 
 Training for older people: a handbook  by Peter C Plett and Brenda T Lester. 
 200pp. 
 Price &pound;11. 
 Available from International Labour Office, Vincent House, Vincent Square, London SW1P 2NB.   
 All rights reserved. 
 This publication may be reproduced in whole or in part in unaltered form by Age Concern groups with due acknowledgement to Age Concern England. 
 No other reproduction in any form is permitted without written permission from Age Concern England. 
 AGE Concern 
 WORKING FOR PATIENTS 
 A DISCUSSION PAPER ON THE NHS REVIEW 
 INTRODUCTION 
 The Government has published its review of the National Health Service and has subsequently released 8 working papers. 
 The review  focusses  on management structures, budgets and monitoring their use, securing value for money, and directing money to those hospitals which treat most patients. 
 The working papers develop some of the organisational and management implications of proposals in the Review. 
 Age Concern has prepared a Briefing Paper which summarises the White-Paper and the working papers, and which is available from the Information and Policy Department. 
 This discussion paper considers points made in the Review and in the working papers. 
 It is difficult to relate the proposals in the review to prospects for services for elderly people, as although it is entitled &bquo;Working for Patients&equo;, the Review makes little mention of health care for individuals or particular client groups. 
 Nor does it make any statements about the costs of administrative and managerial change, or of the considerable developments in information technology which will be required to carry out some of its proposals. 
 The points raised in this discussion paper are based on existing Age Concern policies. 
 COMMUNITY CARE 
 The review scarcely mentions health authority services related to community care. 
 It thus appears to neglect a significant part of care under the National Health Service which is of crucial importance to elderly people and their carers. 
 Age Concern's response to Sir Roy Griffiths' review of community care emphasised the importance of community health services in care and rehabilitation of elderly people at home. 
 The report just released by the Royal College of Physicians on Care of Elderly People shows just how far there is to go in improving services for mentally ill elderly people and their carers. 
 Age Concern believes that there is an urgent need for the Government to clarify the role of the health service in providing community care. 
 Community care also depends crucially on cooperation between different professional workers, and between different service providing agencies. 
 The White Paper and working papers do not discuss how the new organisational and managerial arrangements will improve links in development of community care. 
 Age Concern believes that these issues should be explicitly considered when discussions take place about responsibilities of health authorities, family practitioner committees and self-governing hospitals. 
 MAINTENANCE OF CORE SERVICES. 
 The White Paper and Working Paper 2 refer to &bquo;core services&equo; which must be maintained by the District Health Authority. 
 But the working papers state that the list in the White Paper is not definitive, and that DHAs will be able to decide what core services are appropriate for them to maintain.  
 Working Paper 2 states: &bquo;&hellip; even where a service is regarded as one which must be provided locally, it does not follow that every patient must have that treatment locally, it does not follow that every patient must have that treatment locally, if the patient and the GP or DHA as purchaser believe it to be better for them to be treated elsewhere&equo;. 
 This appears to make the concept of locally-available core services a rather uncertain one. 
 As time goes on, the Government envisages more and more hospitals becoming NHS Trusts, with powers to negotiate what services they will provide. 
 Working Paper 1 states that many core services &bquo;are currently provided by hospitals likely to seek self-governing status, and the Secretary of State, in first establishing an NHS Hospital Trust, will approve the arrangements for providing core services. 
 Thereafter Trusts will be expected to continue to provide such services subject to review at the request of either party to the contract and, in the event of disagreement, the approval of the Secretary of State.&equo; 
 The imprecision in definition of core services will make it difficult to ensure that people will have access to appropriate, locally-based services, regardless of where they live. 
 WAITING LISTS. 
 A main aim of the White Paper is to improve services, and the document refers repeatedly to the need to reduce waiting lists. 
 The major means for doing this is to encourage doctors and health authorities to seek care where it can mostly cheaply and efficiently be provided. 
 One ingredient of the proposed contracts is a stipulation about waiting times. 
 Waiting lists are known to be an inaccurate indicator of need, as many doctors do not refer patients if they know the wait will be long (this is as true for instance for hearing aids as it is for hip replacements). 
 The reasons for waiting list length are complex, and may be as related to shortages of aftercare facilities and ancillary staff as to the availability of surgical facilities. 
 The White Paper implies that waiting lists will be reduced by increased efficiency &mdash; often meaning more operations and shorter periods of time spent in hospital by patients. 
 The White Paper does not deal with the implications of this increased activity for, say, community physiotherapists, and rehabilitation facilities. 
 Reduction of waiting lists is not necessarily an indicator of improved &bquo;quality&equo; of care for elderly people, whose needs may go beyond a brief period of surgery and recovery. 
 The White Paper offers no reassurance that resources will be made available to provide appropriate support facilities. 
 For elderly people, there must also be concern that emphasis on reducing waiting times by contracting for services non-locally will impose serious hardship on those unable or unwilling to travel. 
 It is also difficult to see how such a policy will ensure continuity of specialist care, for instance through outpatients, after a distantly-resident elderly person has been discharged from hospital. 
 There will also be considerable implications for hospital transport services, as well as financial implications for the individuals involved, which are not acknowledged by the White Paper. 
 CONVALESCENT CARE. 
 Age Concern believes that convalescent facilities must be available to all elderly patients who require them. 
 The White Paper gives no indication of how such care will be planned and budgeted for, and there is an urgent need to consider this aspect of health service provision. 
 Age Concern believes that the Department of Health should develop a policy and issue national guidelines on the provision of such care. 
 Each health authority should assess the need for this care and make provision accordingly, perhaps requiring the opening of convalescent homes or contractual arrangements with private and voluntary sector providers. 
 If budget allocations for regions and districts are made on the basis of continuing existing spending patterns, this need will be overlooked, as most authorities do not have adequate provision for post-hospital care for elderly people. 
 HOSPITAL DISCHARGE. 
 Hospital discharge procedures for elderly people often include a trial visit home and multidisciplinary conferences with community workers and hospital workers. 
 They must take fully into account the availability of and needs of informal carers, and the adequacy and accessibility of the home environment. 
 It is often recommended that such work is coordinated by a &bquo;key worker&equo;. 
 How can this be done if the patient is 50 miles or so from home? 
 How can health and local authorities develop cooperative procedures if care is spread across many health districts? 
 The need for proper assessment and cooperation at the time of hospital discharge is an essential preventive measure to ensure that elderly people are not discharged to inappropriate care settings. 
 A booklet on hospital discharge procedures is now imminent from the Department of Health. 
 It is imperative that provision for suitable hospital discharge procedures is an integral part of contracts negotiated by district health authorities and GP budget holders, and is also included in requirements to be made of self-governing hospitals. 
 IMPROVEMENT OF CHOICE. 
 General practitioners . 
 Age Concern welcomes the Government's proposals to remove administrative barriers to people who wish to change general practitioners. 
 Age Concern also believes that general practitioners should be able to provide information about their services, and that there should be increased health promotion and preventive screening provided by general practices. 
 7.1.2 The proposals of the White Paper and Working Papers 3 and 8 do not appear to offer disincentives to general practices to work with elderly people, and to welcome them to their lists. 
 However, there is nothing in the White Paper to act as a positive incentive for such work, and Age Concern is worried by the proposal in Working Paper 3 that once allocations are made to practices holding their own budgets, they will be free to shift expenditure within the year between the individual components of the budget. 
 The granting of a higher capitation allowance for elderly people will not necessarily mean that this money is spent on services for elderly people. 
 7.1.3 Age Concern receives reports from elderly people of difficulties in registering with general practitioners. 
 Age Concern would like to see this issue specifically addressed, so that elderly people will be assured of being able to register with a practice near their home.  
 7.1.4 There may be special problems in areas with large numbers of residential and nursing homes. 
 Residents of these homes should have the same rights to choice of general practitioner and to NHS care as any other person. 
 Choice of place of treatment . 
 A major change for the National Health Service will be the introduction of contracts for the provision of hospital services. 
 GPs with their own budgets and District Health Authorities will be expected to place either block contracts for a defined range of services, or cost and volume contracts, for a certain number of cases, for most services. 
 Allowance will be made for contingencies, but these are to be the exception rather than the rule. 
 7.2.1 At present, general practitioners are free to refer to the hospital and consultant of their choice, although in practice this freedom has been restricted in recent years, partly because of health authorities' reluctance to accept cross-boundary patients. 
 The new contracts may improve accounting procedures, but do not appear to offer more choice to either doctors or consumers, who will be bound by contractual arrangements, which the government recommends should be on a three-year rolling basis. 
 7.2.2 The White Paper comments that some GPs may have to be &bquo;re-educated&equo; in their referral practices, if the DHA arranged a contract with a hospital other than that which the GP has used by choice. 
 Even within a GP practice, it is likely that doctors will wish to use different hospitals and consultants, but may now be constrained from doing so. 
 7.2.3 For elderly people, the proposals appear to overlook the difficulties which they may face if, for instance, the contract for cataracts or hip replacements is placed at a hospital some distance away. 
 This may well be more economic in &bquo;costs&equo; to the GP budget or DHA involved, but could well create considerable extra cost for the person and his or her family, both in terms of travelling to and from hospital and in loss of support from friends and relatives who may not be able to visit. 
 USE OF CONTRACTS. 
 DHAs and GP budget holders will be free to negotiate contracts with private or NHS providers. 
 Age Concern expressed reservations in its response to the Griffiths Review of Community Care that contracts for certain services might prove unprofitable to private sector providers after a few years, by which time District Health Authorities would have divested themselves of the resources to provide similar services. 
 What protection will there be for potentially unprofitable, yet necessary services to continue to be available under the NHS? 
 Certain types of contracts will be negotiated on a &bquo;cost per case&equo; basis. 
 If the cost exceeds the budget, the hospital will pay, but conversely, if the actual cost is cheaper, the hospital profits. 
 There is evidence from America that costing by &bquo;Diagnosis Related Group&equo; may provide a disincentive to offering support and aftercare to elderly people, as average figures for &bquo;cost per case&equo; may not take into account the higher costs incurred by some elderly people who need longer recovery times or more aftercare.  
 TAX RELIEF ON PRIVATE HEALTH INSURANCE. 
 Private health insurance may help some elderly people to gain access to hospital treatment more quickly than would otherwise be the case, although there seems little justification for a National Health Service which cannot cater for the needs of people in acute pain or discomfort as and when necessary. 
 The limitations of private  haalth  insurance mean that many elderly people may not be comprehensively covered under its terms. 
 Even where relatives or friends purchase a policy on behalf of an elderly person, the insurance companies reserve the right, for instance, to re-negotiate a policy held through a company when the person reaches retirement age. 
 At this time, certain pre-existing conditions may be excluded, as will happen if a new policy is negotiated for an older person. 
 Private health insurance provides for acute treatment and related care. 
 Many policies specifically exclude rehabilitative or convalescent care. 
 Such policies also pay only for hospital-related treatment, and many exclude treatment which does not include invasive techniques. 
 Thus, therapy for a particular ailment may specifically be excluded from a policy, whilst surgery would be covered. 
 The choice of treatment may be skewed towards that which can be paid for, rather than that which may be in the best interests of or preferred by the patient. 
 DRUGS BUDGETS. 
 Age Concern believes that GPs should be encouraged to make rational, efficient, effective and economic use of resources in relation to prescribing, and that the use of drugs for elderly people should be closely monitored. 
 Cash-limited budgets may not necessarily mean that prescribing practice improves. 
 Working Paper 4 states that new patients on a list or changed clinical conditions of existing patients will bring corresponding adjustments to the drugs budget, but it is not clear whether these adjustments will have to be made within the overall regional allocation to the FPC, or whether new funds can be made available during a year in recognition of patient migration. 
 This point will be particularly important in areas which have net inflow of elderly patients, and in areas where there is extensive new building of residential or nursing homes. 
 LONG-STAY CARE OF ELDERLY PEOPLE 
 There is no clear indication about expectations for long-stay care. 
 In its response to the Griffiths review of community care, Age Concern commented on the continued need for long-stay facilities to be available for some elderly people. 
 Age Concern receives frequent reports about health authorities closing long-stay beds, without ensuring that appropriate alternative provision is available. 
 Age Concern believes that this issue needs urgent consideration in the context of the NHS Review, and that the statutory responsibilities of health authorities in this respect should be clarified. 
 Hospital Trusts appear to have the freedom to choose what they provide, and as they increase in number and DHA provision declines, it is possible that long-stay care will become a residual service, separated from profit-making, &bquo;attractive&equo; services.  
 GERIATRIC AND PSYCHOGERIATRIC SERVICES 
 Similar concern might be expressed for the continuation or development of geriatric and psychogeriatric services. 
 Recent developments have seen the growth of such services closely linked with other locally-based care, although in many areas services are not adequate to need. 
 The devolution of responsibility to hospitals, DHAs and FPCs may prevent the broadly-based planning which is necessary to ensure that such services continue to grow and prosper. 
 STAFF. 
 If Hospital Trusts attract more staff and can determine their own pay rates, there must be concern about shortfall in other services. 
 In addition, the Government states that expansion of the private sector will benefit the community by reducing demand on the NHS. 
 If the private sector expands, staff already in short supply may be further stretched. 
 More &bquo;attractive&equo; services will be likely to attract trained, qualified staff, as the White Paper suggests. 
 This may mean that planning for care of so-called &bquo;priority&equo; groups will become increasingly difficult as provision and accountability are fragmented, unless there is a commitment to increase resources specifically for these groups. 
 There is an urgent need for the NHS Review to focus on the development of training at all levels to ensure that properly qualified, trained staff are available to provide not only hospital care, but support and rehabilitative care for increased numbers of patients. 
 MANAGEMENT OF HEALTH AUTHORITIES 
 The reduction in size of District Health Authorities, and their restructuring on managerial lines, may reduce the involvement of local bodies such as voluntary agencies in health service provision. 
 Community Health Councils will remain as the link between authorities and the consumer, and the working papers mention consulting consumers in audit of services. 
 Age Concern believes that the work of community health councils should be expanded and better funded, and that membership of voluntary organisations on CHCs should be increased, with the interests of elderly people represented. 
 These developments should be an integral part of change in the NHS. 
 CONCLUSION 
 Age Concern welcomes the attention drawn by the White Paper to the necessity for an efficient and effective National Health Service freely accessible to all. 
 However, it is not entirely clear how the White Paper's proposals will affect services for individual patients, particularly those with complex or chronic conditions. 
 A considerable injection of resources will be required to provide the managerial and technological expertise called for in the White Paper. 
 Age Concern would like to see similar attention paid to the extra resources required to ensure provision of adequate staff and facilities to enable high quality health care to be provided for elderly people, both at home and in hospital. 
  BM/2.3.89  
 THE AGE OF THE TRAIN 
 THREE-quarters of the track including half the through lines, the semaphore signals, the last vestiges of freight facilities and the last of the men who used proudly to work for the old railway company have gone, yet the long-distance service is faster, more frequent and above all better used than at any time in railway history, and the number of passengers passing through probably at an all time high. 
 The comment happens to be about the writer's home station, but much of it might equally apply to numerous others. 
 One thing is for certain. 
 The eighties was not the decade in which people abandoned railways, not anyway in Britain. 
 Virtually everywhere from the Highlands to London's suburbs, main line and local, passenger trains were steadily busier, the total number carried exceeding that of pre-Beeching days when the system was much larger. 
 Indeed, the vast majority of lines remaining carried record numbers of passengers for peacetime on ordinary working days, the great holiday and excursion tidal waves of traffic of course being history. 
 The statement is truer of lines than individual stations since average journey lengths are much longer, and continued to increase during the eighties. 
 And while BR gave up carrying more categories of goods and our daily newspapers overnight, the overall freight picture again improved to a greater extent than most people forecast. 
 If newspaper trains ceased to cause nocturnal activity over much of the system, the number of travelling Post Offices actually increased. 
 The eighties was a decade of paradoxes, great and small. 
 As the government squeezed the finances ever harder, British Rail became more efficient, and while even InterCity began by pruning 10 per cent of its mileage, at the end most of the sectors were more concerned about how to handle their increasing traffic. 
 As financial results improved and there was increasing reason to believe the slogan on everyone's lips at the decade's start, &bquo;This is the age of the train', morale deteriorated further. 
 While much was achieved in improving safety standards, towards the decade's end there was a series of accidents that perhaps shocked the public more than anything since Harrow &amp; Wealdstone in the very early days of nationalisation. 
 And while the eighties saw fewer closures and many more reopenings than anyone could reasonably have hoped, it ended with thunder clouds of uncertainty about management style, privatisation, how to solve overcrowding, the Channel Tunnel. 
 Then there was the paradox that the erstwhile Premier Line out of Euston steadily slipped down the speed and performance league as the High Speed Trains out of King's Cross, St Pancras and Paddington proved (for all the    undoubted technical troubles) that they could sustain their role as InterCity's workaday tool. 
 Catering that had been so under threat in the later seventies suddenly attracted new importance; indeed, the single Manchester Pullman that looked almost certain to be a casualty of further standardisation in the eighties was joined by a bevy of Pullmans if only Pullman service on HSTs and Mark 3s. 
 But it became clear that the passenger was not automatically right: only when he paid up! 
 Thus while first-class patronage was encouraged, and more businessmen complained bitterly that they had to go first-class in order to enjoy their British breakfast, more humble individuals who merely wanted to enjoy the view from the train were not so generously treated. 
 It was perhaps the miracle of the decade that BR was allowed to invest so heavily in a new generation of multiple units. 
 Enthusiasts were less surprised that much of that investment went sour through design faults and technical failures, and grieved that so little thought was given to the simple, old fashioned matter of looking out, the deprivation of forward and backward view that had encouraged so much travel on the first generation of multiple units allegedly being due to the unions not liking the public seeing their men at work. 
 Not that the working man's point of view has been generally well heard. 
   Management-union relations were of course at the heart of many developments. 
 Once private enterprise was excluded in passionate principle. 
 If Travellers Fare did not wish to provide a service on a train, there should be none; if they closed a refreshment room, it had to lie idle for a year before a private operator was allowed to take over. 
 The eighties brought commercial pragmatism, with for example many refreshment-trolley services run by private firms that employees of any organisation as large as BR would almost certainly have found impractical. 
 In all kinds of ways many bad old practices disappeared, while at last the central administrative overhead came under control. 
 Generally, and one says it graciously, sectorisation has worked, the eighties seeing it flowering and bringing both improvements and cost savings. 
 InterCity has its own clear identity, though the greatest achievements have perhaps been with Network SouthEast, where the tide has really turned, and in Provincial with its own increasing network of imaginative expresses often resulting from stringing several services together. 
 Suddenly many stations have through services to many more destinations. 
 The need to emphasise that God would not maintain the system indefinitely   no matter what restrictive practices and losses could hardly have been greater. 
 Yet this writer's abiding impression of the eighties is that management along with the government did not know when to stop. 
 Yes, there has been more consistency, a following of the capitalist competitive dream, which has paid good dividends. 
 But the pressure for productivity has sometimes been remorseless. 
 Generally the culture has lacked colour and personality, certainly fun and pride on the job. 
 Improving ratios might have satisfied officials at headquarters but have only produced harder work and often more complaints from the public for the railwayman out on the system. 
 To a large extent this is perhaps inevitably a criticism of the chairman from September 1983, Robert Reid. 
 But then another paradox is that he was successful in persuading the government to allow increased investment, especially in rolling stock. 
 Sir Peter Parker who he replaced will always be remembered as an enthusiastic chairman with a human touch. 
 The &bquo;This is the age of the train' slogan thoroughly suited him. 
 He will not however go down in financial history as a great achiever, and it has to be said (as recorded later in these pages) that even under his leadership labour relations were far from perfect. 
 That Sir Robert Reid has been more effective is one of the headlines of the eighties. 
 He proved himself to be thoroughly professional as a railwayman and ruthless as a manager. 
 But the pips squeaked and still the remorseless pressure was on&hellip; and on, in a cool, impersonal style. 
 Any joyous note there was came very occasionally from the sector managers, but they were seen as too much under corporate control to exercise real individuality of style. 
 The Clapham accident of December 1988, the first for half a century in Britain due to the failure of the signalling, appalled the public in demonstrating how poor morale and discipline were in a vital part of the service at a key point. 
 The industrial labour dispute of early summer 1989 had virtually the whole public ridiculing BR's labour relations and calling for a change of style. 
 It was a sad but inevitable outcome of not maintaining a proper balance between productivity and personality. 
 Those who used large parts of the system regularly saw from daily observation that many staff enjoyed ever less satisfaction. 
 Everyone has his own story of being ignored when requesting information and of being left uncertain what to do when things have gone wrong, such as connections lost. 
 Management decidedly cannot rely on having its spokesmen on the spot in the shape of co-operative station staff. 
 Which is not to say that much fine work is not achieved. 
 Driving standards on the whole improved during the eighties and certainly average speeds increased, in some cases dramatically. 
 The overnight maintenance work on HSTs in particular deserves the award of many medals. 
 Though frequently finding some initial reason to put you, the customer, down, restaurant-car stewards then generally look after you well, and enjoying good food at speed remains one of the joys of railway travel. 
 It is just that it could have been more meaningful and less unpleasant had it felt a touch more like a pilgrimage than a harsh, faceless drive for productivity. 
 Even the lack of a catchy slogan  at the decade's end (&bquo;The age of the train's&equo; replacement &bquo;We're getting there&equo; only lasted briefly) contributes to this lack of social purpose. 
 What will the enthusiast's main memories be of the eighties? 
 Not, to be sure, the rapid changes in administrative structure, much though the results of sectorisation have been felt actually on the track. 
 One memory will certainly be of the running of far more steam trains than seemed possible in the seventies, not all of them successful&hellip; 
 The GWR 150 specials, the Blackmore Vales, Cambrian Coasts, Cumbrian Mountains and regulars for some seasons into Scarborough and over the West Highland. 
 While ordinary motive power generally became more standardised, and again as told later in these pages the difference between locomotive-hauled and multiple-unit stock less marked, the variety still remains impressive and just as many notebooks and cameras record the passage of trains at the end as at the beginning of the eighties. 
 Liveries have of course proliferated; not since pre-1923 days have so many different colour schemes been seen, the only snag being that often    two or more liveries are included in the same train where for example the PTE's dedicated stock gets diverted. 
 Most of the semaphores of 1980 have gone, virtually no large gantries remaining in total use. 
 But multiple-aspect signalling has not been (nor ever will be) universal. 
 Radio signalling made more than a debut, helping toward the achievement of one of the decade's miracles, not only the survival but with greater expectation of long life of much of the Highland lines and many more. 
 Indeed, no major routes closed in the eighties. 
 Survivals include the Cambrian Coast, radio signalled in 1988, where Barmouth viaduct was after all repaired, the Central Wales where a decision was taken to rebuild the bridge which collapsed while a train was crossing it in high flood, and the Settle &amp; Carlisle where the government perhaps surprisingly refused closure. 
 Another memory must surely be of the improvement to many stations, some of the London termini becoming shopping meccas, albeit the reduction in size of key ones such as Crewe and the general simplification of track layouts. 
 The wartime hunt for German spies was not carried out with greater enthusiasm than the campaign to eliminate diamond crossings! 
 Station improvements, and most of the reopenings, of course resulted from that new pragmatic combination of railway, municipal and industrial sponsorship. 
 Repainting schemes in particular have been more imaginative, and for example one can proudly take overseas visitors interested in railways around our great cathedrals of the steam age now doing record business in a whole variety of ways&hellip; more trains and passengers, more refreshment facilities, many more shopping complexes. 
 What you cannot turn to with such pride is BR's printed timetable, which changed format several times during the eighties and ended as a poor thing, well below continental standards. 
 Throughout the eighties some officials displayed a tendency to overdo the latest idea, often itself not particularly sound. 
 Thus we were told that, since the timetable was only used &bquo;by enthusiasts and the travel trade&equo;, it was pointless to indicate which trains had meal service, and while vital to show which services were operated by Sprinters nobody was interested in which were HSTs. 
 Then long-term account holders were told that when they reached sixty they could no longer use BR's own rail warrants but had to switch to credit cards on which a commission is payable. 
 BR's own credit card experiment at the decade's start failed through sheer ineptitude. 
 It is not hard to portray the BR of the eighties Monty Python style with such stupidities as creating a semi-autonomous Cornish Railways with great enthusiasm one year only to abandon them the next as though that were equally great progress. 
 Happily achievements do take place alongside such nonsense. 
 And the abiding memory of the eighties must be of the greatest achievement, the enormous increase in passenger traffic. 
 BR indeed continued to change the country's very geography, Gatwick suddenly becoming much closer to London with its Express every fifteen minutes, places like Peterborough and Swindon now almost as accessible as suburbs only fifteen miles away from Piccadilly. 
 In the decade's final timetable, there is an express     every 15 minutes (plus one extra) between Swindon and Paddington over a two-and-a-half-hour period in the morning rush. 
 Though the policy has been to raise the price of long-distance season tickets well above the average, for thousands there is still standing room only on the high-speed commute. 
 Despite the cost, many measure their distance from London in time, and corridors along the main lines north and west out of the capital compete very favourably with traditional Metroland and Southern electrified territory. 
 Not that Network SouthEast's more everyday trains are short of patronage. 
 The experts got their calculations wrong and the daily influx into London is vastly greater at the end than the start of the eighties, or any prediction forecast. 
 Nor is it only an influx into London. 
 More commuters actually go from London to Reading to work than vice versa. 
 Swindon and Peterborough probably have more commuters going to them than their total everyday passenger traffic in the steam age. 
 Many of the northern and Scottish cities also experience sharply enhanced rush hours. 
 It is again the age of going to work by train. 
 The buoyant economy at the end of the eighties of course helped in part by increasing road congestion, forcing many to take the train who would have preferred to drive. 
 This happens even in rural areas, such as between Exmouth and Exeter. 
 Bus competition has been hampered not only by road congestion but upheaval in the road-passenger industry. 
 Who a decade ago would have thought it possible that the chief benefactor of bus deregulation would be BR? 
 That it is results from the chaotic competition and lack of liaison, hundreds of thousands of would-be passengers turning to the railway with its reliable timetable for want of proper information about road services. 
 That planning has been poor is more the fault of the economy than BR,  the high interest rates at the end of 1989 being seen as likely to repeat the recession of 1981 out of which we climbed so painfully. 
 Yet every year one questions the quality of many BR decisions. 
 In 1989 we were assured there was no, absolutely no, case for electrifying between Edinburgh and Glasgow:. 
 a short trunk route between two major conurbations, electrification already in place at either end, that would seem to be the absolute classic next stage. 
 But there never has been anything as sensible as a planned, rolling programme of electrification. 
 The achievement of the eighties was that at least something was achieved out of the stops and goes. 
 And on the whole achieved at less cost than earlier schemes &mdash; with less disruption, too, especially on the East Coast main line. 
 So Bedford, Leeds, Norwich, Hastings, Weymouth, are added to the places from which you travel electric to London, perhaps not so bad a score for the decade. 
 Even Paddington's platform ends were given supports for overhead electrification when the Lawn was extended to accommodate a shopping centre, leaving Marylebone as the only other London terminus yet to see electric activity. 
 But even Marylebone sees a revitalised Chiltern service. 
 (Amazing how quickly BR abandoned its scheme to close Marylebone when a scheme popped up to turn it into a kind of Victoria Coach Station for northern routes!) 
 Personal memories: of the larger knots of passengers at reopened Templecombe than at most other stations between Exeter and Salisbury, a route far busier and better served than ten years ago; but of travelling from Southampton to Newton Abbot via Westbury having dinner with a traveller from London to Crewkerne, the common Westbury-Taunton section way north of both passengers' direct line being attractive because of the faster pace of HSTs. 
 Of the scandalous way in which the railway hotels were sold off and nine-tenths have deteriorated rapidly since. 
 Of the way that stations such as Inverness still remarkably reflect their region's economy. 
 Of the Persil soap powder offers that enabled two passengers to travel for the fare of one and of the utter complexity of offers and restrictions that taxed the ingenuity of many booking clerks and ticket collectors until the Blue (cheaper) and White (all Fridays and occasional other days) Savers were standardised as BR's on the whole highly successful marketing tool against coach competition. 
 Of ancient multiple units that keep going well beyond their years, the bane of commuters but still offering forward views of stunning coastal and moorland scenery. 
 Of quadrupled track being reduced to double, double to single, more blade ends and diamonds taken out, yet a highly complex system still remaining on a truly national scale. 
 Of more money-making opportunities taken such as Settle &amp; Carlisle regular trains hauled specially by freight locomotives and carrying more passengers than any service train probably since the war. 
 Of splendidly smooth rides out of King's Cross and Paddington, sporty ones out of St Pancras on the HSTs, and nerve-racking, noisy ones with hunting bogies on ordinary stock out of Euston. 
 Of days one was proud to be associated with railways and too many (still only a sprinkling but so devastatingly disrupting) that one swore always to take the car next time.    
 This book aims to serve several purposes. 
 It should provide quick reference on the important events and trends, including motive power, traffic, vehicles and safety, in the eighties. 
 With its pictures as well as text contributed by a team of experts, it portrays a colourful decade in which hope was more rekindled than lost. 
 Our wish is that it will enable you better to recall and enjoy your own memories. 
 Might we indeed suggest adding a personal looseleaf comment and photograph or two within your copy for posterity? 
 Finally, a few guideline wishes for the 1990s: undoubtedly, first, that the Channel Tunnel will be completed without undue delay and that a new highspeed route will rapidly follow through Kent; that under their new chairman, Robert Reid the second, from Shell, due to take his post in October 1990, BR will somehow regain a touch of personality, warmth, humanity, without losing their commercial edge; that the policy of providing new and cheaperto-operate stock for secondary routes rather than handing down yesterday's worn-out express trains pays real dividends and prevents too much discussion of &bquo;bustitution&equo;; and that defensive theory will give way to common-sense pragmatism over matters such as the quality of the printed timetable and what really benefits the customer.  
 Class 50 No 50021  Rodney leaves Newton Abbot with the 10.30 Liverpool to Penzance train on 10 March 1987 a few weeks before the removal of the semaphore signals . 
 The 1980s certainly proved to be the age of the train, but not the age of the ATP as this entrance barrier at Glasgow Central proclaims in May 1983. 
 manchester Pullman. 
 No 86244  The Royal British Legion (named 2 November 1981) gets away from Crewe with the 16.00 ex-Euston on 16 August 1988. 
 The rake is mostly Mk 3A and Mk B (1985 Pullman) coaches. 
 The last BR all-Pullman service, to Manchester, ceased in May 1985 . 
 Class 31 No 31486 and Class 47 No 47010 receive attention in the maintenance area of Crewe diesel depot on 22 June 1988. 
 A pair Class 20s, Nos 20007 and 20053, struggle up the steep incline out of Coalbrookdale with an empty MGR train on 3 November 1988. 
 This freight line has seen a limited summer weekend passenger service to a temporary station at Coalbrookdale for the Ironbridge museum since 1987. 
 No 37669 in early Railfreight grey livery brings down English China Clays train, consisting newly introduced CDA wagons, into Lostwithiel station on 6 May 1988. 
 No 87028  Lord President displays its InterCity livery while pausing at Carlisle with a southbound express on 27 August 1988. 
 It does not carry the swallow symbol . 
 Jubilee Class 4-6-0 No 5593  Kolhapur rounds the curve into Rotherham Masborough station (now closed) en route from Birmingham to Carnforth via York and Leeds on 4 June 1988 . 
 The crisp Highland air makes for a fine display of steam form K1 No 2005 as it hauls the Royal Scotsman along the shore of Loch Eil on the Fort William to Mallaig line in 1988. 
 Two veteran campaigners. 
 Class 40 No 40160 tows a failed Class 108 dmu near Seascale on a Barrow-Carlisle service. 
 Both designs first appeared in 1958 and by the 1980s were showing signs of their age. 
 This photograph is dated 15 June 1984; No 40160 was withdrawn in November. 
 The skyline of Brignorth, dominated by Telford's church tower, provides a backdrop for this view of Class 59 No 59001  Yeoman endeavour leaving the Severn Valley terminus with a train for Kidderminster on the SVR diesel weekend in May 1988 . 
 Parcels sector locomotive No 47567  Red Star leaves Carlisle with the Hadrian special on the return journey to King's Cross via Settle &amp; Carlisle line in June 1988 . 
 Class 37 hauled freight. 
 Nos 37077  British Steel Shelton and 37077 double head the 10.50 Lackenby to Corby &bquo;steel&ndash;liner&equo; train through Cargo Fleet, Middlesborough on 9 December 1986 . 
 With the advent of 110 mph running on the West Coast main line a number of Mk1 gangwayed full brakes (fitted with B4 bogies) coded NHA were specially maintained for high&ndash;speed running. 
 No 92032 is seen here at Crewe in September 1989. 
 Alexander/Barclay Class 143 dmu No 143022 in Tyne and Wear PTE colours crosses the High Level bridge into Gateshead with 14.17 Newcastle to Middlesborough service on 7 November 1986. 
 The original narrow&ndash;bodied Leyland/BREL Class 141 dmu consisting of Nos 55503/55523 approaches Heaton Lodge Junction, Mirfield with the 14.51 Leeds to Marsden train on 21 March 1987. 
 The set sports West Yorkshire PTE colours. 
 No 47475 rounds the curve at King Edward Bridge Junction, Gateshead with the 10.23 Newcastle&ndash;Liverpool Lime Street on 16 May 1989. 
 Both locomotive and train are in the Provincial colours. 
 The leading vehicles are Mk1 gangwayed full brake carried on B4 bogies and Mk2 corridor first. 
 Note the metro bridge in the background. 
 Class 58 locomotives Nos 58016, 58017 and 58018 under construction inside Doncaster works on 28 July 1984. 
 They were taken into BR stock in October 1984 and allocated to Toton depot. 
 Railfreight&ndash;liveried Class 37 (coal sub&ndash;sector) No 37235  The Coal Merchants Association of Scotland on display at the Coalville depot open day on 11 June 1989 . 
 Eastfield&ndash;allocated Class 37 No 37413 hauls the 09.50 Glasgow Queen St to Fort William near Achallader, approaching Rannoch Moor, on 29 September 1987. 
 The rake is made up of early Mk2 and Mk1 coaches. 
 The leading vehicle is open brake second (micro buffet) No 9107, one of eight converted from Mk2 BSOs during the 1980s. 
 One of the troublesome Leyland Class 155 units No 155302 forms a Provincial sprinter service, the 15.10 Portsmouth&ndash;Cardiff in July 1988. 
 It is climbing the 1 in 75 of Ashley Hill Bank Bristol. 
 There is still much evidence of the traditional railway environment in this view of Whitby on 18 August 1982. 
 A Metro&ndash;Cammel three&ndash;car dmu passes Bog Hill signalbox with semaphore signalling, redundant engine and goods sheds and a rather derelict goods yard (with full coal staiths) on leaving the station with the 09.15 Whitby&ndash;Darlington service. 
 ATP&ndash;P unit No 370001 passes Lambrigg, north of Oxenhlome, at 10.52 on 19 March 1986 with a high&ndash;speed test run between Crewe and Carlisle. 
 Scrapping of the ATP vehicles commenced a few moths later. 
 Peppercorn K1 2&ndash;6&ndash;0 No 2005 reflects the morning sun as it passes Bolden Colliery with the Northumbrian Mountain Pullman on 22 January 1983. 
 This was a North Eastern Locomotive Preservation Group special (No 2005's owners) which included the SLOA Pullman rake. 
 No 86427  The Industrial Society and 87005  City of London head south through the Lune Gorge with a Mossend&ndash;severn Tunnel Junction steel coil train on 23 February 1988 . 
 Birmingham RC&amp;W Co Class 104 unit No 104325, in the bizarre ScotRail &bquo;mexican bean&equo; livery, works the 09.55 Oban to Crianlarich service near Tyndrum Lower on 29 September 1987. 
 Note the high&ndash;intensity headlamp fitted above the destination blind. 
 A version of LNER apple green was applied to No 47522  Doncaster Enterprise during the 1980s. 
 The locomotive is seen here passing Stonebridge, Durham working the 17.29 Heaton carriage sidings in York, with the stock for the York&ndash;Cardiff postal service, on 10 June 1988 . 
 GWR&ndash;liveried Class 50 No 50007  Sir Edward Elgar originally  Hercules, renamed in 1984) hauls a NSE service, near Pirbright Junction on 29 July 1989 . 
 The 14.20 King's Cross&ndash;Leeds InterCity service pulls away from Wakefield Westgate on 25 April 1989 powered by a Class 91 No 91008 Note the difference in profile between the Mk3 stock and the Mk4&ndash;styled locomotive. 
 MEMORIES OF THE 1950s 
 CHAIRMAN Sir Peter Parker was doing his best, but the 1980s opened with much the same worries of insecurity over government policy, lack of investment, and working practices which harked back to the old company rules. 
 Although the new chairman Sir Robert Reid had his critics, at the decade's end it was clear that his method of management had produced decisive changes. 
 A slimmer BR was more confident, easier to contemplate privatising. 
 There was no longer just the promise of investment, but much of it in place. 
 With a backbone of electrification, traffic rising and the prospect of the Channel Tunnel, everyone was talking about the railways. 
 1980. 
 At first, it seemed that the antics of marine woodworms in the piling of Barmouth's 115 span timber bridge would rob the Cambrian coast of its railway, but BR surprisingly stumped up &pound;500,000 for short-term repairs, and, after a seven-month closure, the line was back in business. 
 With hyper-inflation, BR started the year with a 20 per cent fares increase &mdash; despite furious cost-cutting. 
 There were increasing signs that the APT project was foundering. 
 The introduction of the three pre-production prototypes into timetabled service was abandoned through &bquo;a series of technical difficulties&equo;. 
 The submission for sixty production trains was postponed. 
 The Liverpool &amp; Manchester's 150th was celebrated by a cavalcade of locomotives through Rainhill. 
 Unlike the Shildon display five years earlier, diesels and electrics were included. 
 BR spoke of replacing Ribblehead viaduct on the Settle &amp; Carlisle with a new earth embankment to reduce maintenance, not that the stone structure was unsafe. 
 1981. 
 &bquo;Deltic Mania&equo; is not too strong a label to attach to the last full year of the locomotive flagships of the East Coast main line. 
 Undoubtedly the most powerful, distinctive and popular design of the post-steam era, their final months on secondary workings produced a near manic enthusiasm that happily led to six of the fleet of twenty-two heading for preservation. 
 It may have been heralded as a strategic disaster, but the Manchester-Sheffield electric route via Woodhead tunnel slipped quietly into oblivion, due ceremony avoided because of the public puzzlement that a heavy freight route should be axed only twenty-five years after complete modernisation. 
 The post-mortems continue but the truth is, that from an operational     viewpoint, the 1,500V DC Woodhead line is not missed for a moment. 
 Unprintable were many of the comments when BR and Leyland collaborated on the ultimate basic DMU, slotting standard bus bodies on to coach frames, with an underbody power unit, and a flimsy cab bolted to each end. 
 The seats were simple and uncomfortable, the noise intolerable, but it still shaped a disastrous decade of short-term economy stock building that is now being regretted. 
 1982. 
 Millions of pounds of investment meant nothing to Bedford-St Pancras commuters when their long-awaited new electric trains were laid up in the sidings while BR and the rail unions hammered each other over one-man operation. 
 It eventually saved a year's tyre wear on the Class 317s, and meant a lot more string and sticky tape on the clapped-out DMUs. 
 Britain as a whole experienced thirty-four days of strikes. 
 We all feared the worst when BR withdrew InterCity services from the Settle &amp; Carlisle. 
 Stories started about the unsafe state of Ribblehead viaduct; it was another case of closure by stealth. 
 Enter the campaigners. 
 The visit of Pope john Paul II over the Spring Bank Holiday returned people to the railways in numbers not seen since the 1950s. 
 It was an enthusiast's delight as BR moved rolling stock from anywhere and everywhere to convey Papal followers to masses at Canterbury, York, Wembley, Coventry, Liverpool, Manchester, Glasgow, Edinburgh and Cardiff. 
 That meant twelve-car DMU rakes, Sunday services on non-Sunday routes, and hosts of locomotive-hauled &bquo;Popex&equo; specials. 
 As for his Holiness himself, he was treated to a ride from Gatwick to Victoria behind the Royal loco No 73142 Broadlands  bearing the special Southern headcode &bquo;HF&equo; (Holy Father). 
 The adoption of the name ScotRail by the Scottish Region was far more than a marketing ploy. 
 The new regular-interval timetable was actually understandable by the common man, the first real hint of a corporate localised identity, and the first appearance centre stage of one of the new breed of managers &mdash; Chris Green. 
 How unfortunate that the long-awaited arrival of comfortable Mark 3 sleeping coaches coincided with a downturn in the national economy. 
 While the sleepers ran empty, BR picked up the hard-pressed nocturnal travellers with a new cheapo &bquo;Nightrider&equo; using spare first-class coaches with fluorescent lighting encased in soothing blue plastic. 
 It became possible to change trains again at the Welsh mining town of Blaenau Ffestiniog. 
 Yes, the twenty-eight-year effort by the Ffestiniog to restore service to Blaenau Ffestiniog was finally completed, resulting in increased business on BR's branch from Llandudno junction. 
 1983. 
 They were building new railways across the world, but there had to be an extraordinary reason to do that in Britain. 
 The fourteen miles of new mainline railway on the East Coast main line, bypassing Selby at a cost of &pound;60 million, resulted from threat of coalmining subsidence under the old formation.  
 Class 50 locomotive No 50041 Bulwark  arrived at Paddington station on its side! 
 It had been derailed at the entrance while approaching at speed with a sleeper service from Penzance; miraculously there were no serious injuries, though much of the track at the station throat had to be relaid. 
 As for Bulwark , it was severely damaged, but valuable enough to be repaired. 
 Orange and black meant Strathclyde, green and cream West Yorkshire, and yellow and white Tyne &amp; Wear, as passenger transport executives provided public proof of their interest (and subsidy) of metropolitan rail services by applying their own liveries. 
 As for the West Midlands, it tried various shades of red, white, blue, and grey and even canary yellow but by the end of 1989 had still not got its formula worked out. 
 The latest economy drive saw the introduction of a prototype bus-bodied hauled passenger coach, quickly labelled by journalists as &bquo;third class&equo;. 
 They were right. 
 The arrival of the new Saturday l25mph High Speed Train service from Swansea to Pembroke provided a new job for the train guard: he had to leap out at Manorbier to open the crossing gates, wait for the train to clear the crossing, close them, and then walk seven coach lengths to give the driver the right away. 
 LNER Flying Scotsman  became an old age pensioner in style with a series of runs over its old haunts from Peterborough to York. 
 A pity so many kamikaze spectators chose to stand in the four foot to watch it go by. 
 Whoever would have thought it possible? 
 Almost unnoticed, the standard vacuum-braked 12 ton freight van was eliminated. 
 They were so ubiquitous that grounded bodies used as sheds will be a feature of Britain's farmyards for decades to come. 
 Surprise, surprise, the year ended with the news that BR wanted to close the Settle &amp; Carlisle. 
 The rescue machine was poised for action, and the rest is now history. 
 1984. 
 Great news &mdash; the &pound;306million electrification of the East Coast main line was approved in one go on 27 July. 
 A veritable flood of new locomotive liveries, some smart, some misguided and dreadful, transformed the station scene from a mass of standard blue and grey to an unpredictable display of sector showing off. 
 The Western Region won the prizes however for its nostalgic application of lined GWR steam-style livery to five of its top-link diesels. 
 Sir Edward Elgar would have been delighted. 
 The economist's Utopian dream of a rural railway without station staff, platelayers and expensive signalling staff came closer with the introduction of radio signalling over the Far North lines from Inverness. 
 As BR discovered however, it is essential to give maintenance crews skiing lessons to cope with mountaintop transmitters in winter, and placate Irish TV viewers whose screens suddenly go fuzzy. 
 The Gatwick Express was a good demonstration of how to create maximum impact with the minimum of resources, simply recycled Mark 2 coaches, a  rebuilt driving trailer from a scrap EMU, a spare Class 73 locomotive converted to push-pull, and a generous helping of new paint. 
 The result: millions of contented passengers, and millions of extra revenue. 
 The late 1980s will be remembered by many for their tragic rail accidents, but 1984 witnessed the deliberate, spectacular and entertaining wrecking of Class 46 locomotive No 46009 to demonstrate that a nuclear flask is safe even when struck by a 100mph train. 
 The &pound;1.5million show by the CEGB also showed that Mark 1 coaches are remarkably resilient to high-speed impacts. 
 However, eighteen people were killed during the year. 
 Major incidents were at Wembley, Eccles, and Morpeth.  
 Goodbye LNER, farewell soon LMS. 
 The replacement of the old electric units on the Manchester-Hadfield line and most of the Merseyrail network with second-hand BR sliding-door stock removed the last pre-Nationalisation trains. 
 Happily, preservation groups stepped in to save some stock for posterity. 
 Despite all the publicity to the contrary, Trans-Pennine services moved through another Cinderella phase when the travelling public quickly rumbled that the &bquo;new&equo; locomotive-hauled services used rolling stock actually older than the DMUs they replaced. 
 However, at least a new generation of diesel unit was in mind.  
 Steam made its last gasps in BR passenger trains, through the heating pipes of passenger coaches. 
 There were enough new coaches at last to enable the steam-heat-only Mark 1 vehicles to be discarded, and enact new operating practices with newly converted electric heat, air-braked diesel locomotives. 
 Even in Scotland. 
 Gresley &bquo;A4&equo; Pacifics were big news. 
 No 4468 Mallard  was being prepared for a return to steam for the 50th anniversary of its 1938 world record speed run. 
 There were also delightful rumours that the heavy overhaul on sister No 4498 Sir Nigel Gresley  would see it repainted green as No 60007. 
 Wishful thinking. 
 It reappeared in garter blue. 
 1985. 
 The 150th anniversary of the founding of the Great Western was marked in style but to many it will be remembered for the decision to shut down Swindon Works. 
 Union leader Arthur Scargill's dream of political victory crumbled with the collapse of the national miners' strike. 
 But it decimated BR's annual accounts, and ultimately the freight network, as the government then approved a severe pruning of unremunerative collieries. 
 British Coal had its own Dr Beeching. 
 The West Country's joy at being able to combine quality and tradition in the shape of brand-new brown-and-cream-liveried bus-based four-wheeled diesel units for local branch services turned to dismay when their long wheelbase caused ear-splitting squeals on tight curves, and they had to be rapidly replaced by the thirty-year-old DMUs they had supplanted, fortunately not yet scrapped. 
 Publicity machine called the units &bquo;Skippers&equo;. 
 Locals called them &bquo;Slippers&equo;. 
 It was goodbye to the Class 40s. 
 Fashions change, and the hulk-like diesels that were so unwelcome as steam replacements twenty-five years previously were given a massive send-off from the new generation of enthusiasts. 
 On cold january nights, they camped out on platforms for the last experiences of &bquo;Whistler&equo; haulage, as the class of two hundred was whittled down to just one, the rebuilt, pioneer D200. 
 What was described as &bquo;modular catering&equo; or &bquo;Cuisine 2000&equo; was introduced on expresses out of Euston. 
 The exotic land-prepared dishes did not go down well. 
 Technology has not managed to replace the smell, taste and enjoyment of freshly cooked food, but some traditional cooking on board did survive. 
 1986. 
 The thirty-year rundown of the Great Central Railway terminus at Marylebone (a prelude to seemingly inevitable total closure), was dramatically slammed into reverse gear on 30 April when BR admitted blossoming Chiltern Line services could not possibly be handled by Paddington, Euston, or even handed over to London Transport. 
 The answer, was, investment and modernisation. 
 A new film Give My Regards to Broad Street  achieved extra significance on 30 September when all pleas for a reprieve were rejected, and the North London mausoleum closed its doors to passengers and awaited total demolition. 
 It was bad enough having to admit that the APT train project was a dead  duck, but BR shot itself in the foot and provided the cynical national media with a field day by selling off some of the vehicles to a Sheffield scrapyard. 
 The strict rules of disposing of redundant vehicles by public tender was forgotten for the rest of the stock, dismantled very much behind closed doors at Derby Works. 
 By 1989 InterCity director Dr john Prideaux was reassuring his customers that it was wrong to regard the APT as a failure; it had indeed been a great design success! 
 Unfavourable train reliability statistics are easily shrugged off until one of your passengers is a VIP. 
 Eyebrows were raised in high places in February when Class 47 locomotive No 47457 failed near Cambridge in charge of the Royal Train. 
 Inside was none other than the Queen. 
 After his success in rebuilding morale in Scotland, Chris Green went for the big one &mdash; London. 
 As the director of the new Network SouthEast, he never shied away from the divisive problems of pre-Grouping company loyalty and post-war neglect, and as a media lover soon became a star. 
 To the commuter, the new red, white and blue house colours just had to represent a commitment to strive for quality. 
 It did sound convincing. 
 The Yanks are coming! 
 The entire railway freight business took note of Foster Yeoman's radical decision to buy its own fleet of locomotives off the shelf from an American builder. 
 An unshackled BR first seemed keen to follow suit, but then took the safer political option of ordering its own replacement machines from a domestic supplier.  
 1987. 
 It was a big year for electrification. 
 Norwich and Cambridge were reached; Clydeside's &pound;85million showpiece was completed with the linking up of Largs and Ardrossan Harbour to the main Ayrshire system; and the Great Northern system was extended north to Huntingdon and Peterborough. 
 Royston-Cambridge and Watford-St Albans fill-in schemes were also approved. 
 But the government proved it was no pushover when ruling that the Far North line from Inverness to Wick/Thurso could not share the new road bridge over the Dornoch Firth. 
 All pleas fell on deaf ears. 
 BR meanwhile accelerated its elimination of older locomotive types redundant through a reduction of trip workings and arrival of new designs. 
 The net effect was the end of the Class 25 and 27, and a remarkable stack of over thirty asbestos-contaminated loco bodies piled high in Vic Berry's Leicester scrapyard as he struggled to cope with the influx. 
 The great &bquo;volte face&equo; came on 7 October when BR's chairman Sir Robert Reid officially opened (or re-opened?) 
 Birmingham's Snow Hill station closed after the LMR took over the old Great Western's lines. 
 The tape was broken at the tunnel's exit by Isambard Kingdom Brunel  in green with GWR-type plates and name. 
 Old Moor Street station closed and all trains previously running there now use the new station. 
 Work started almost immediately in planning the replacement of tracks northwards to Smethwick and the line to Stourbridge, Worcester and Hereford. 
 A new Act was prepared for placing before Parliament the inter-urban tramway link to Wolverhampton. 
 The organisers of the Basingstoke Open Day succeeded in assembling the largest collection of motive power types ever seen on BR. 
 Present were (deep breath), Classes 20,24,25,27, 31,33, 35,40,44,45,46,47,50, 52, 55,56, 58, 73, 77 and 86.    
 The year ended in tragedy. 
 The night of 16 October saw some of the worst storms across the south of England for hundreds of years. 
 Trees fell across tracks like dominoes, and barely had services begun to return three days later when a Central Wales line bridge collapsed while being traversed by a DMU. 
 Four lost their lives. 
 The end of year deadline for eradication of asbestos-contaminated rolling stock, agreed many years ago between BR and the unions, was quietly and mutually forgotten when it was realised it was a long way from being achieved unless services were decimated. 
 Not BR, to be sure, but the showpiece Docklands Railway opened with its driverless trains. 
 1988. 
 The year started with five regions, and ended with six. 
 The newcomer was Anglia, to manage the area east of the GN main line which has the fastestgrowing population in the UK. 
 It was there for all to see &mdash; BR became less of a corporate business, more an overlord for the sectors who were expected to find their own feet with or without government subsidy. 
 Privatisation was now daily conversation. 
 London's rail system was transformed with the opening of the Snow Hill tunnel, providing a through link from Bedford to Brighton via King's Cross Midland and Blackfriars. 
 What a difference! 
 January saw the inauguration of the Bournemouth-Weymouth electrification and three months later &pound;16.4million was promised to convert the Portsmouth-Southampton route. 
 Enter the Class 91, the new breed of East Coast main-line electric locomotive. 
 The prototype series of ten appeared from BREL Crewe Works with a collection of teething troubles, but were in regular passenger traffic to   Leeds by the end of the year. 
 What happened to their Electra branding, by the way? 
 Exit the Class 45 &bquo;Peaks&equo;, the last surviving locomotives built at Derby Works &mdash; and Flying Scotsman  to Australia for a year's tour. 
 The Sprinter DMU, the saviour of Provincial, proved both a success and a disaster. 
 The success was the Metro-Cammell Class 156, which helped create a new-style hourly Anglia-North West service and transform domestic Scottish and Welsh services. 
 The headache was the Leyland Class 155, withdrawn after only a few months with doors that jammed open. 
 The bustle at London termini to load newspaper trains ended in july when BR terminated the contracts remaining after the previous year's transfer to road by News International and the Mirror Group. 
 For sale: a complete railway. 
 BR issued a prospectus for the handing over of the entire Settle &amp; Carlisle line to private enterprise. 
 But there were no serious takers. 
 Cornwall became more of a standardised railway with the demise of the timber-bodied clay hood. 
 In their place arrived 125 new BR-sponsored airbraked CDA hoppers. 
 Steam really did come to an end on BR when the state-owned narrow-gauge Vale of Rheidol was sold, not without tears, to the Brecon Mountain Railway. 
 In the deal were three steam locomotives and a new interloper in the shape of a diesel. 
 The biggest, and most tragic, news event of the year was the 12 December Clapham disaster, discussed in detail elsewhere. 
 1989. 
 With Clapham still in people's minds, public confidence in BR was shattered again on 4 March when two Saturday afternoon trains collided at Purley, killing six and injuring over eighty more. 
 This time, it was driver error. 
 Still with disaster, swirling flood waters felled the River Ness bridge at Inverness, isolating the Kyle and Far North lines. 
 Good news was the decision to build a replacement. 
 Not in my back yard! 
 While the citizens of Amiens demonstrated in favour of the High Speed Line from Paris to the Channel Tunnel serving their city, the rural stockbrokers of Kent revolted against the idea of an equivalent new railway from the tunnel to London. 
 The Settle &amp; Carlisle was reprieved in a shock statement issued on 11 April, a triumph for pressure groups and local authorities. 
 BR made an immediate start on the backlog of maintenance, including repairs to Ribblehead viaduct. 
 Recognition that London's traffic problems are reaching seizure point came when BR announced schemes for two new cross-city links costing &pound;2,000 million &mdash; links between Paddington and Liverpool Street, and from King's Cross/Euston to Victoria; plus a tube line from Hainault to Wimbledon via Chelsea and Hackney. 
 (But the new tube was less sure of itself, and revised versions of it during the next few months whiplashed over the map of south London like a demented snake.) 
 BR disposed of its BREL engineering business to its management.  
 The rail unions staged a series of strikes over poor pay and BR insistence on an end to collective bargaining, and were somewhat surprised to find themselves with public sympathy despite many complete network shutdowns. 
 To their dismay, however Britain did not seize up without trains. 
 Railfreight's new locomotive design made its debut. 
 The British-built Brush Class 60 will number at least a hundred examples, all with evocative names. 
 We learned for the second time that old London Underground trains never die: they are sold for another quarter-century's work on the Isle of Wight. 
 Like the 1920s stock before them, 1938-design vehicles were shipped over to the island to provide a moderately more comfortable service between Ryde and Shanklin. 
 It was good fortune for BR to be able to pick up the 1938 survivors &mdash; only retained into the 1980s to bail out the Northern Line from a vast increase in traffic.    
 West Coast up to date. 
 Willesden&ndash;based Class 90 No 90006 (new 9 September 1988) climbs Shap at Greenholme with the 14.30 Euston&ndash;Glasgow service on 10 May 1989. 
 Later Intercity examples received &bquo;Mainline&equo; livery. 
 Double&ndash;headed Class 37s Nos 37501  Teeside Steelmaster and 37502  British Steel Teeside haul the 10.47 British Steel Lackenby to Corby coil train through Cargo Fleet, Middlesborough on 15 November 1988. 
 Both locomotives were named at Thornaby in march 1987 37501 also received its &bquo;British Steel&equo; blue livery . 
 Wessex Electric. 
 A five&ndash;car Class 442 unit forms the 09.46 Poole and Bournemouth to Waterloo service passing through Pirbright, Surrey on 20 February 1989. 
 The Basingstoke Canal runs parallel with the railway in the background. 
 Recently modified Class 4718 (with extended&ndash;range fuel tanks) No 47818 heads to Holyhead to Carlisle charter train, Victoria Travel's Settle&ndash;Carlisle Express, through Baron wood on 6 May 1989. 
 East Coast contrasts. 
 Class 40 No 40124 hauling a Tyne Yard&ndash;Dringhouses, York vacuum&ndash;braked freight is overtaken by HST set No 254004 at Ouston Junction, Chester&ndash;le&ndash;Street on 16 May 1980. 
 The HST rake includes two catering vehicles (TRSB and TRUK) and is made up to nine cars by the addition of a Trailer Second. 
 End of an era. 
 No 55015  Tulyar having returned light engined from Edinburgh to York on 2 january 1982 became the last Deltic to be switched off by BR. 
 The locomotive was subsequently acquired by the Deltic Preservation Society . 
 The 14.20 King's Cross to Edinburgh parcels train is stabled overnight at Newcastle Central station on New Year's Eve 1981. 
 Motive power is provided by No 40092. 
 The 1 in 117 climb to Woodhead tunnel, past the empty Torside reservoir, is tackled by Class 76 locomotives Nos 76031 and 76033 with a train of MGR empties from Fiddles Ferry to Wath on 7 September 1980. 
 One of reasons for the survival of the S&amp;C into the 1980s had been its ability to handle diverted WCML trains; this continued despite withdrawal of Intercity services in the winter 1982&ndash;3 timetable. 
 No 47472 approaches Garsdale with the rerouted 08.30 Glasgow&ndash;Euston on 18 April 1982. 
 Note the turntable (minus stockade), now installed on the Keithley &amp; Worth Valley Railway. 
 One of the ubiquitous Metro&ndash;Cammell built&ndash;dmus (No 101339) leaves the fuelling point at Glasgow's Eastfield TMD on 29 May 1982. a quarter of the decade passed with little visible sign of change. 
 Electrification continued apace during the decade with the major investment on the East Coast main line and in East Anglia. 
 No 31246 heads an overhead mast foundation train between Haughley Junction and Stowmarket on 18 June 1984. 
 Preparations started in 1984 to return No 4468  Mallard to full working order for the fiftieth anniversary of its record&ndash;breaking run in 1988. 1986 saw the locomotive's return to steam in original streamlined condition. 
 It is seen here, in an now historic view of York station, waiting to depart with the Scarborough Spa Express on 9 July 1986 . 
 The introduction of Intercity's Nightrider service seems to have caused some difficulty in the publicity department. 
 late nights? 
 The spelling of Milton Keynes and stopping would suggest so. 
 REGIONS, SECTORS AND PTEs 
 Regions. 
 At the start of the 1980s the British Railways business was still run by five regions: the Eastern, Western, Southern, London Midland, and Scottish. 
 The whole of Great Britain was divided between them on a strictly geographical basis, and &mdash; subject to the general supervision of the British Railways Board and its chief officers in London &mdash; each region was completely responsible for the planning, working, and selling of all rail services in its area (except in the seven provincial centres where PTEs had been established). 
 In other words, the regions were both production and marketing organisations. 
 True, certain services for which duplication of provision would have been especially absurd (such as the Legal Department) were centrally provided. 
 True also that property questions had already been separated off from the main business, to be handled by the British Rail Property Board (also on a regional basis, but with somewhat different geographical areas from those used by the operating regions). 
 Nevertheless, essentially the regions ran the show. 
 This regional structure came about by accident rather than design. 
 Even before the 1923 Grouping some companies were strongly territorial, and several had working arrangements with one another within one geographical area. 
 The grouping formalised the situation by creating four essentially geographically based companies, even though they did stray into one another's territories. 
 Nationalisation saw the basic pattern retained, although the Scottish elements of the London Midland &amp; Scottish and the London &amp; North Eastern Railways were hived off to form a Scottish Region, and the North East based on York also became a separate region. 
 Changes in the 1950s and early 1960s brought rationalised boundaries to create tighter geographical regions and eradicate penetrating lines and competition. 
 So the Southern lost its lines west of Salisbury to the Western, the Western gave up its lines in the West Midlands to the London Midland, the Eastern surrendered its access to Manchester, and the London Midland gave up to the Eastern and North Eastern its Yorkshire lines. 
 Massive structures remained, many attitudes and management at the beginning of the decade were very similar to those of long ago. 
 The regional general manager remained effectively the managing director of a large company. 
 His chief officers formed a board which had a very considerable measure of authority to determine its own ways (witness, for example, the Western Region's adventure with diesel-hydraulic locomotives when the remainder of British Railways was following the diesel-electric path, or  the Eastern Region's policy of civil engineering for speed). 
 An innovation in organisation sectorisation resulted in the regions losing their business roles and becoming purely the providers of services and facilities. 
 Within the regions there have also been big changes, notably first the creation of area management, then the abolition of the divisions. 
 The area manager is responsible for all aspects of the working railway in his patch, including operations, and his role in liaison with the sectors, which have only a limited presence away from headquarters, is crucial. 
 There must now be a real question-mark over the continuing existence of the regions. 
 They have been downgraded in areas like Tyneside and Manchester by the creation of the PTEs. 
 With sectorisation they have lost most of their planning, commercial, and marketing activities. 
 Their function now is to make a good job of delivering the railway services that the PTEs and sectors want to buy from them. 
 Is there any need in the future for an intermediate level between headquarters and the greatly enlarged areas? 
 Is there indeed a case for some form of national track authority in place of six regions? 
 Yet, long after the North East had lost its separate region, on 4 April 1988 East Anglia was given independence. 
 Anglia controls East Anglia lines of Network SouthEast serving the London commuter area more locally than they were being controlled by the Eastern at York. 
 Management where the job is actually being done may show the way forward in other ways, though the granting of extra power to Cornish Railways was a short-lived experiment. 
 One thing is certain: further changes in the 1990s will reflect the role of the railway as a business out there in a hard, competitive world. 
 The 1980s have been a period of considerable and long-overdue change. 
 PTEs. 
 All the present PTEs were already firmly established by the start of the 1980s, and they have survived the 1986 abolition of the metropolitan councils. 
 Their creation limited the powers of the Scottish, Eastern, and London Midland Regions in a number of major conurbations outside London. 
 The Western and Southern Regions have no PTEs in their areas. 
 The principal change in the 1980s has come with the creation of the sectors, in that the PTEs primarily talk business to the sectors these days, the region then delivering the agreed product. 
 The PTE decides on frequency, and it can even specify &mdash; within reason &mdash; the timings of the trains it wants. 
 It considers whether it wishes to invest further in rail, simply keep the rail services it has, replace rail with bus, or seek other solutions to local transport problems. 
 It sets fare levels. 
 (All the PTEs have done a great deal of work on the integration and simplification of fare-structures and the provision of interchangeable tickets.) 
 It can even buy rolling stock, and several PTEs have made extensive purchases of the new 1980s multiple-units. 
 Strathclyde and West Yorkshire, for example, both have their own Super Sprinters. 
 All have sponsored rail investment in one form or another and are continuing to do so. 
 Tyneside has its Metro, Liverpool its underground lines, Strathclyde a lavish electric system. 
 Manchester at first lost out very badly on rail investment, but now it has some compensation in the Windsor Link and is  going ahead with an advanced tram system that will take over a number of heavy rail routes. 
 Birmingham and Sheffield are making similar plans. 
 West Yorkshire, having presided over a massive expansion of rail traffic in recent years, is pushing for more electrification in the wake of the successful completion of InterCity's electrification to Leeds. 
 With the abolition of the metropolitan councils in 1986, responsibility for the supervision of the PTEs has passed to joint boards of delegates from each of the metropolitan boroughs. 
 Since they have lost their buses through bus deregulation they have become essentially planning and co-ordinating bodies for both rail and road modes. 
 So far, many of the improvements they brought about have survived, and the fragmented bus industry has not yet led to a breakdown of the integrated ticketing that marked such a step forward in British practice. 
 Sectors. 
 Sectors are of course the most significant creation of the 1980s. 
 In   the mid 1970s there was an abortive attempt to develop a new way of managing the industry in the Territories Plan (which would have given a structure very similar to that developed in Germany in much earlier years and still in use both on DB and DR), but this failed largely on account of union opposition. 
 Each territory would have been a complete business organisation in its own area, but because no territory would have been large enough to run a complete main line a great deal more co-operation would have been necessary than existed between the regions, and on a much more formal basis. 
 The basis for a different type of approach already existed. 
 Dr Beeching had drawn attention to the shortcomings of the railway's accounting practices. 
 Slowly better systems were introduced, making it possible to look more analytically at what was happening. 
 This made it possible to group together different types of service (InterCity's identity was first established on this basis) and look at their costs and revenues in a sensible manner. 
 The whole process was greatly helped by the much more widespread availability of computers. 
 And the remit of the railways was changed. 
 Government decided  that the whole of the railway freight business should pay its way. 
 Then a policy directive in 1977 reinforced by the new government in 1979, also insisted that InterCity should run commercially even if other parts of the passenger business were to receive grant-aid under the 1968 Act. 
 Under the chairmanship of Sir Peter Parker the concept of the commercial railway and the social railway was developed at the end of the 1970s and the start of the 1980s. 
 The first was to be run on strictly business lines, while the second needed financial support. 
 This emphasised not only the importance of the distinct types of business but the difference between the businesses and the operations. 
 So on 4 January 1982 the railway's commercial undertaking was divided into its separate elements. 
 Freight and parcels had always been seen as distinct entities, and these naturally formed two of the new sectors. 
 On the passenger side InterCity was taken out first; then all the London-commuter-belt services were grouped to form London &amp; South East (later renamed Network SouthEast); finally, everything left over formed Other Provincial Services (later renamed Provincial). 
 The last two were the social railway, requiring continuing support in grant-aid for the provision of socially essential services  in the capital, in the great conurbations, and in rural areas. 
 British Rail's accounts have charted financial progress. 
 InterCity turned in its first profit in 1988&ndash;9, only a year after transitional support was withdrawn. 
 Network SouthEast has improved its performance beyond what anyone could have dreamed might be possible. 
 And now that Provincial has sorted out its rag-bag inheritance into clear service-groups, it too can show great steps forward in many areas. 
 There is a need for close and on-going liaison with the regions and PTEs, but at the end of the day it is the sector that calls the tune. 
 Each sector director looks at his business on a national level, ignoring regional boundaries, and has the power to deploy all his resources to the best commercial advantage. 
 The best example of this has been the deployment of the HST fleet. 
 This was first bought in the 1970s by the regions, but it has been deployed under sectorisation with singleminded determination to maximise earnings. 
 Yet while InterCity is supposed to be one business, offering consistent standards throughout Britain, many regional differences in what the traveller actually experiences die slowly. 
 It is now the sectors which sponsor investment in track and signalling as well as rolling stock, that must deal with the modernisation of stations, and so on. 
 The decisions are commercial: what will earn the best return on the investment? 
 Questions that should have been asked long ago are now being asked &mdash; and, more importantly, answered. 
 In years to come the commercialisation of BR via sectorisation could well be seen by historians as important as grouping and nationalisation.    
 Scottish Region. 
 The extremely utilitarian front end of the Sprinters is displayed against the massive ironwork of the Forth Bridge by No 150284 as it heads south working the 13.40 Dundee to Edinburgh train on 29 August 1988. 
 Anglian memories. 
 Class 47 No 47580  County of Essex pulls away form the elegant Norwich Thrope station with the 15.20 to Liverpool Street on 22 June 1984 . 
 Invaluable service. 
 Severe winter conditions create much hardship for the isolated Settle&ndash;Carlisle line and the railway provides the only reliable form of transport at such times. 
 No 31410 leaves Blea Morr tunnel with the 08.57 Leeds&ndash;Carlisle train on February 1983. 
 Cardiff&ndash;based single&ndash;car unit No 55032 carrying the dragon and red &bquo;V&equo; of Provincial's Welsh &bquo;Valley Lines&equo; is seen near Porth at the head of a Barry Island to Treherbert train on 15 August 1985. 
 Two&ndash;car diesel parcels unit (No 55972 and 55982) passes the fine North Staffordshire &bquo;Jacobean&equo; gables of Stone station en route to Birmingham. 
 The Class 127 units were modified (for Parcels sector use) after their eventual replacement by emus on the St Pancras&ndash;Bedford route. 
 EXPRESSES EVER FASTER 
 THE 1980s will be remembered as the decade in which far-reaching changes were initiated on Britain's InterCity network. 
 But at its start there were two great threats: the economic recession and the Thatcher Government's attitude to nationalised industry spending limits and investment criteria. 
 Despite the immediate success of the new fleet of 125mph trains which brought new standards of safety and on-board comfort firstly on the Western Region services out of London (Paddington) and then on the East Coast main line from London (King's Cross), so much of what had been gained in the late 1970s was lost as the economic recession started to bite. 
 The impact was twofold. 
 The sharp decline in business activity severely reduced the volume of full-fare first-class ticket sales while the increase in unemployment and interest rates curtailed to a drastic degree levels of disposable income available for leisure purposes such as optional standard-class rail journeys. 
 This loss of optional travel was also exacerbated by the intensified competition from longdistance coaches following the liberalisation of route licensing in the 1980 Transport Act. 
 Given the choice in such circumstances, many of InterCity's customers on low or fixed incomes &mdash; in particular students and senior citizens &mdash; preferred the cheaper but slower coach option. 
 Faced with such a quick and potentially damaging erosion of its business base, BR tackled the situation on two fronts &mdash; reduction of costs and a headon response to the coach operators with bargain fare offers. 
 A 10 per cent cut in loaded train miles was phased between June 1981 and October 1982. 
 Skilfully applied, these cuts were made in such a way as to protect the sectors' long-term business-base stability. 
 With relatively little loss of traffic or even complaints, InterCity was able to phase out many of its old life-expired Mk 1 coaches. 
 Meeting the coach competition necessitated a more risky strategy: head-on confrontation at the low-price end of the market. 
 By introducing bargain-level fares &mdash; &bquo;Savers&equo; &mdash; BR's aim was to generate sufficient extra passengers to achieve a net revenue gain. 
 The tactics succeeded and the erosion of optional business was stopped. 
 Train loadings were increased and unit costs reduced. 
 It was the creation of the bargain-priced Saver which paved the way for an airline-style market segmentation which has subsequently played such an important part in InterCity's move into profit which was achieved towards the end of the decade. 
 The first indications of the new 1979 Conservative Government's attitude to investment became apparent when BR sought approval to build an  additional seven HST sets to cope with the first flush of growth following the launch of 125mph services on the East Coast main line the previous year. 
 After much haggling, approval was only obtained for those four out of the seven sets which could meet the much higher rate of return which would henceforth be applied to BR investment. 
 If BR could not make a case for seven trains for one of its most profitable routes, it was clear that plans for a second tranche of HSTs for the Cross Country group of services would not satisfy the new criteria. 
 These were the circumstances which led BR to terminate HST building with a fleet of ninety-five operational trains. 
 It is a matter of history that as the 1980s drew to a close, a few extra HSTs to cope with the unprecedented levels of business by now on offer would have been very welcome. 
 Running a national business as complicated as a railway network is in all circumstances a daunting task, but the challenge is even more difficult when the government of the day can effectively veto any major decision. 
 For the past forty or so years since the railways passed into public ownership, the issue of social support &mdash; that is the extent to which unremunerative routes should be directly subsidised by the taxpayer &mdash; has never been entirely clear. 
 For example  , in 1976 a White Paper on transport policy issued by the then Labour Government, stated that inter-urban passenger transport in Britain should not be subsidised. 
 Unequivocal though that statement was, it was not until the 
 1979 Conservative Government got into its stride that this tenet was raised from aspirational status to a specific directive that InterCity must operate as a self-financing business. 
 How to cope with the separate issues of the economic recession, the need for major investment such as the electrification of the East Coast main line and identification of those parts of the network or services which needed direct government subsidy, was the overriding concern of the BR Board at that was the problem. 
 It was more a matter of how BR's organisation should be adapted to cope with a much tighter (but more specific) set of government directives. 
 The story of how the traditional management through the regions has been transformed into a marketing one based on the sectors is told elsewhere. 
 So Far as InterCity is concerned sector management has brought two major benefits: overall responsibility for deployment of its rolling stock fleet, and the building of a national range of express train products. 
 The first example of equipment redeployment came in 1982 when the then director (Cyril Bleasdale), faced with a serious downturn on Great Western sub-sector services out of Paddington, decided to move ten HSTs to the Midland main line so that a badly needed improvement could be implemented on this potentially profitable and much neglected route. 
 Under the previous organisation it would have taken months of internal wrangling to resolve the conflicting aspirations of regionally based management. 
 Transfer of all Anglo-Scottish sleeping car services from the East to the West Coast main line from May 1988 was a similar decision based on a corporate rather than a regional viewpoint. 
 An important feature of the 1980s which has contributed to InterCity's financial turnround is market segmentation and pricing &mdash; or the shaping of products to meet the needs of customer groupings. 
 Essentially this concept is not new &mdash; from the early days our railways were providing first-, secondand even third-class accommodation and the excursion ticket was quickly used to sell spare capacity. 
 What is new is the much greater degree of sophistication which is now necessary to produce the maximum revenue yield from each and every InterCity journey. 
 Today's equipment &mdash; trains and track &mdash; is very expensive to provide and maintain; to cover its basic costs it has to be in service providing revenue for up to say sixteen hours per day. 
 But, as we know, demand for seats is not evenly spread. 
 Monday-to-Friday peak-hour trains &mdash; the 07.25 from Manchester to Euston and the 16.30 back to Manchester are cases in point &mdash; will always load well, but the stock providing these two services will also make two midday trips for which custom may be sparse. 
 Market segmentation and pricing has provided the answer. 
 InterCity now has a range of offers &mdash; first class, standard and the Saver ticket &mdash; the purpose of which is, by offering varying fares to channel demand   so that it can spread the load over existing capacity. 
 To many it has complicated the process of selling InterCity travel, but &mdash; like the airlines who face similar problems &mdash; it is a necessary tool to maximise the earning potential of high-cost equipment. 
 By the second half of the 1980s InterCity was well on its way towards selfsufficiency and genuine operating profits. 
 A greatly reduced fleet of locomotives and coaches along with better overall control and increased patronage (especially in long-distance commuting) resulted in a sharp recovery. 
 In 1984&ndash;5 the sector returned a loss of &pound;157million; in one of the most dramatic business turnrounds in recent years this has become a &pound;24million profit in 1988&ndash;9. 
 From such an unpromising start in 1980, BR has become the first railway in the world to provide a long-distance passengerrailway service without subsidy. 
 West Coast Main Line. 
 One of the ironies of the 1980s is that while the East Coast main line started to take delivery of its second-generation 125mph equipment, the maximum speed of West Coast trains had only moved from 100 to 110mph. 
 This sorry state of affairs follows from the failure of the Advanced Passenger Train (APT) prototype to achieve sufficient reliability to justify the ordering of an operational fleet which could exploit the &bquo;tilting&equo; train concept on BR's long-haul routes. 
 Space precludes a full account of the APT saga, but briefly stated the purpose of the tilting train is to run through speed-restricted curves in complete safety and without loss of passenger comfort at much higher speeds than can be achieved with conventional rolling stock, enabling journey times to be reduced without recourse to realigning and upgrading existing tracks at prohibitive cost. 
 As BR looked towards the 1970s and into the 1980s, it was realised that if InterCity was to survive the growing threat posed by the airlines and the rapid extension of motorways, train speeds would have to be lifted beyond the prevailing norm of 80mph start-to-stop between main business centres. 
 While a good proportion of the West Coast route could be raised from 100 to l25mph at reasonable cost, there are many locations where it is necessary to impose speed restrictions because of curvature and track geometry. 
 As the APT was so ideally suited to the needs of the West Coast main line and offered the possibility of major train service improvements, BR &mdash; regrettably as matters transpired &mdash; became wedded to the project to the extent that no other traction possibility was considered. 
 It is now a matter of history that &mdash; notwithstanding an outlay of &pound;150million at current prices on research and development and prototype trains &mdash; the technical potential of the train was never achieved and in 1983 the entire project was abandoned. 
 Had BR had more time and more funding, had the government been more sympathetic towards the railway investment and had there been no recession, the APT might have eventually been successful &mdash; but that is another story. 
 (By 1988 the Italian Railways had produced a tilting train &mdash; the Pendolino &mdash; which  appears to be successful.) 
 Not only was the non-fulfilment of the APT an enormous financial loss but since its rapid adoption in &bquo;squadron service&equo; had been presumed there were no alternative plans for either trains or track. 
 As the depression began to affect West Coast loadings it soon became clear that it was no longer possible to sustain the level of service provided in the 1974 Glasgow electric timetable. 
 The hourly off-peak service from Euston to Liverpool and Manchester was an early casualty when the service was cut back to a ninety-minute headway, but the most far-reaching change concerned the Anglo-Scottish services between Euston and Glasgow. 
 Historically, Scotland was always perceived as the premier West Coast market on which the case for electrification from Weaver Junction to Glasgow (Motherwell) was made. 
 But by 1985 the sad reality had to be faced that &mdash; so far as InterCity was concerned &mdash; the market had changed, probably for ever. 
 Business people &mdash; no longer prepared to spend five hours or more on a daytime Euston-Glasgow journey &mdash; had switched to air, while leisure travellers had been lured away by the bargain-priced coaches. 
 To offset the loss of Glasgow business, extra stops were added to the daytime service which was revamped to serve towns such as Warrington, Wigan, Lancaster, Oxenholme and Penrith which offered greater business prospects. 
 Only the Royal Scot  remained as a viable Euston-Glasgow train but with a schedule fifteen minutes slower than the five-hour norm established in the 1974 timetable. 
 At one stage the average time of the five daytime trains between Euston and Glasgow was over five and a half hours. 
 However the long-term decline of the West Coast main line was not a prospect that InterCity was prepared to accept. 
 As a first stage towards  reviving the route's viability plans were made to accelerate certain key Glasgow services by raising the line speeds from 100 to 110mph; the second stage was to prepare an investment case for new equipment to fill the gap which would otherwise have been covered by APT. 
 Raising the maximum speed from 100 to 110mph was relatively easy. 
 While the fleet of Class 87 locomotives and Mk 3 stock was capable of 110mph, the only guards' vans on the route were old Mk 1 cars restricted to 100mph. 
 An agreement was obtained to run a small dedicated number of these at the higher speed. 
 Broadly speaking the curvature and signalling on most of the l00mph sections were also fit for 110mph. 
 The only added cost was the need for a second driver when running in excess of 100mph, but this was subsequently rescinded to 110mph. 
 Two 110mph trains in each direction were introduced from May 1984 and the entire service was upgraded in the following year. 
 Subsequently, while the total number of 110mph trains was retained some were withdrawn from the Glasgow service in favour of key Manchester and Liverpool business trains. 
 In some respects the long-awaited authority for new West Coast locomotives proved to be something of a disappointment. 
 Instead of the 125mph Class 89 prototype, an order was placed in January 1986 for twenty-nine Class 90 locomotives but they only have a potential of 110mph. 
 To go with the new Class 90s an order was placed for twenty-nine Driving Van Trailers (DVTs) to replace the old Mk 1 guards' van. 
 By the close of the 1980s the West Coast had started to regain some of its old vitality and was emerging as the most utilised and profitable part of the  InterCity network. 
 Although no plans exist at present for 125mph train speeds, a more general extension of 110mph services is likely to start in 1990. 
 East Coast Main Line. 
 Probably because it started the 1980s with a fleet of new 125mph HSTs which had made a major impact on its market, the East Coast main line was far better placed to withstand the rigours of the recession than its West Coast neighbour. 
 While train mileage cuts were implemented in 1980/1, these were mainly marginal services covered by 100mph dieselhauled trains the loss of which was of little long-term consequence. 
 Indeed, for a time it enabled the service to become an all HST operation so that some places actually had a better service. 
 There were four major East Coast developments in the 1980s: the significant increase in HST productivity so that sets could be more extensively deployed to provide service to Inverness, Glasgow Queen Street, Hull and Cleethorpes; electrification of the route from Hitchin to Leeds with only minor interference to train services; introduction of a new track-maintenance strategy and transfer of overnight Anglo-Scottish sleeping-car services to the West Coast main line. 
 Although the original HST plans provided for two daily return journeys between King's Cross and Aberdeen, by judicious programming of the sets (plus some extra sets transferred from the Western region) it was possible to add on some extra trips to existing rosters. 
 This enabled InterCity to introduce additional HSTs to Aberdeen, a pair of business services to Hull and Cleethorpes and an entirely new service The Highland Chieftain  between King's Cross and Inverness with a journey time of seven hours. 
 Because of the need to refuel the two power cars, the practical operating range of an HST set is about 1,100 miles after which the unit must visit the depot to replenish its tanks. 
 Needless to say such a constraint does not apply with electric locomotives. 
 For several years BR had been trying to persuade the government to authorise the East Coast main line electrification; after considerable discussion this was eventually agreed in July 1984. 
 The cost is &pound;302million. 
 The project entailed wiring from Hitchin to Leeds, Newcastle and Edinburgh, a total of 400 route miles. 
 To work the new service a fleet of thirty-one Class 91 140mph locomotives and matching set of Mk 4 stock have been ordered. 
 Intensive road testing of the first ten Class 91s started in the spring of 1988 and the first public services with the new Mk 4 stock started between King's Cross and Leeds in October 1989. 
 Electric service at Edinburgh will start in May 1991. 
 The fastest time between King's Cross and Edinburgh by HST in the 1980s was 4 hours and 23 minutes, with one stop at Newcastle; this will be cut to 4 hours from May 1991. 
 In mainland Europe the spacing between tracks and reversible signalling enables engineers to work on one track in complete safety while traffic continues to pass on the other. 
 Here the engineers have to carry out most of their work on Sundays when traffic is light, but this often entails diversions and extended journey times followed by temporary speed restrictions for a few further days at the beginning of each week. 
 To compensate for these  temporary speed restrictions additional &bquo;recovery&equo; time is added to daytime schedules. 
 Following studies by Eastern Region's engineers, a new tracklaying strategy was introduced in 1987 whereby &mdash; with the use of a new machine called the Dynamic Track Stabiliser &mdash; tracks could be handed back by 06.00 on Monday morning at the full 125mph line speed, eliminating the need for a temporary speed restriction and associated recovery time allowance. 
 Removal of these recovery allowances made possible a general acceleration of East Coast 125mph services from May 1987. 
 Overnight services for sleeping cars are a long-standing feature of BR's Anglo-Scottish routes, but this market has also changed. 
 With a much smaller baseload of night traffic it was no longer viable to retain separate services to Scotland on both the East and West Coast routes. 
 With the exception of the Newcastle service which was withdrawn, all East Coast Anglo-Scottish overnight services were transferred to the West Coast route from May 1988, making substantial economies. 
 Great Western. 
 As was the case with the West Coast main line, the Great Western sub-sector was also badly affected by recession, but the decline at the start of the decade was matched by a spectacular recovery which started from the second half of the 1980s. 
 The strength of the recovery was such that the Great Western was the first part of InterCity to move into profit. 
 It was the service between Paddington, Bristol and South Wales which felt the full impact of the recession. 
 Things were made tougher by the completion of the M4 paralleling Brunel's main line to the Bristol area and across the Severn Bridge to Newport and Cardiff. 
 It was perfect for low-fare express coach services. 
 Loss of passengers led to dramatic train service cuts, enabling the sub-sector to release seven HSTs for the Midland main line. 
 Fortunately not only did growth return but on a scale far exceeding expectations. 
 This was partly due to the economy's revival, but a major factor was the growth of long-distance commuting. 
 With 125mph trains it was now possible to travel from places like Swindon, where house prices were lower, to London in less than an hour. 
 Between 1985&ndash;6 journeys from Swindon to Paddington increased by 16 per cent, from Bath to Paddington by 12 per cent and from Bristol to Paddington by 20 per cent. 
 By 1988 the morning-peak load was such as to necessitate a fifteen-minute clockface interval service from Swindon to Paddington between 06.30 and 09.00; additionally two services passed through Swindon without stopping. 
 To cope with its new level of business the Great Western has a fleet of thirty-one supplemented by some sets of locomotive-hauled stock. 
 In 1988/9 unit availability had risen by 87 per cent and the average daily miles per operational set was 844. 
 Originally the Great Western HST fleet consisted of 2 + 7 (two power cars with seven trailers) but in 1983 ten sets were given an additional trailer to work on the West of England line and to cover the prime business services. 
 By May 1990 &mdash; after delivery of the first ten sets of the new Mk 4 stock for the East Coast main line &mdash; the Great Western will receive an additional HST set and sufficient trailers to make all HST formations 2 + 8.  
 Midland Main Line. 
 Despite its importance as a trunk route linking London with Leicester, Nottingham, Derby, Chesterfield and Sheffield, until 1982 the Midland had Cinderella status. 
 While it had received some decent Mk 2 air-conditioned stock, the maximum speed of its fleet of diesel locomotives was 90/95mph; average city-to-city speeds compared unfavourably with other parts of the InterCity network, and initially BR replied to local pleas that HSTs could not provide the answer, implying stagnation until perhaps the route was electrified and received APTs that could take the curvatures in their stride. 
 However, when some of the Great Western HST sets became surplus to requirements an obvious option for redeployment was the Midland. 
 Although the curvature and track geometry precludes speeds much in excess of 100mph (except by upgrading at unacceptable costs) the power: weight ratio, acceleration and braking of the HSTs immediately demonstrated their worth and have made it possible to introduce some very useful cuts in journey times. 
 A package of accelerations, improved peak-hour services and upgrading of the Master Cutler  to Pullman status has generated new business. 
 To provide some much-needed improvement the InterCity director decided to transfer ten HSTs to the Midland &mdash; five from the Great Western, two from the East Coast main line plus three which were part of the build for the Cross Country (North East-South West) routes. 
 A completely new Midland timetable was introduced in two stages in October 1982 and May 1983. 
 By the end of the decade, the Midland's outlook had been transformed. 
 In 1990 it is planned to introduce a new Pullman service from Nottingham, an hourly off-peak service to both Nottingham and Sheffield and, by upgrading certain sections of the route for 110mph, a further general acceleration of all trains &mdash; unthinkable at the decade's start. 
 While the Midland main line is now a fully fledged HST route, it does not have its own depot. 
 Its HSTs are provided from a combined pool of trains based at Neville Hill Depot (Leeds) used for both the Midland and East Coast main line services. 
 Cross Country. 
 Comprising originally the North East/North West to South West/South East network of trains which were routed to run through Birmingham New Street (where they made a series of interchanges) the Cross Country InterCity sub-sector is now responsible for all services which do not use a London terminus. 
 At one stage the Birmingham New Street interchange was an integral part of the West Coast electrified service and was based on an hourly sequence of arrivals/departures from the LMR electrified area and to the North East via Sheffield. 
 As well as the series of long-distance trains which still run through Birmingham, the sub-sector now includes those few trains from the North West to Dover which run through Kensington Olympia in London, and the service between Manchester and Scotland via Preston and the West Coast main line. 
 In the late 1970s plans were prepared for a fleet of HSTs to operate the North East-South West (Newcastle/Leeds-Cardiff/Plymouth) route and these were introduced from 1982. 
 As already mentioned, many plans had to be  changed in the light of the recession and these included reduction of the number of Cross Country HSTs. 
 Plans to upgrade parts of Cross Country routes for higher speeds were also deferred. 
 However, although the Cross Country route has not emerged as a high-speed line per se, it now features a number of useful long-distance trains mainly aimed at the leisure market. 
 They make some of the longest journeys on the BR network. 
 Examples include the Wessex Scot  (Glasgow/Edinburgh-Poole), the Devon Scot  (Aberdeen/Glasgow-Plymouth) and the Sussex Scot  (Glasgow/Edinburgh-Brighton) and there is also &mdash; an entirely new innovation &mdash; an overnight sleeping-car service between Poole and Glasgow, linking with the Plymouth-Edinburgh/Glasgow sleeper at Birmingham. 
 All of these services are electrically hauled between Glasgow (Carstairs in the case of the Edinburgh trains) and Birmingham New Street where diesel locomotives take over. 
 One of the innovations of the decade, introduced in 1987, is the series of cross-country trains from the North West to the South Coast via Kensington Olympia. 
 Not particularly successful, their number has been reduced. 
 In 1989 came the opening of the Windsor Link connection in the Manchester area. 
 This short section of the new railway has enabled through running from Preston and Bolton to Manchester Oxford Road and the through platforms at Manchester Piccadilly. 
 Four daily InterCity services in each direction now take this route. 
 Anglia. 
 After many years of indecision, in December 1981 BR obtained approval for the electrification of the main line from Colchester to Ipswich and Norwich and also the Harwich branch. 
 The project was completed in May 1987, bringing new life both to the railway and the region it serves. 
 There has been a particularly sharp increase in long-distance commuting. 
 The Anglia services are worked by Class 86 locomotives and long rakes of Mk 2 air-conditioned stock. 
 Gatwick. 
 Finally, the Gatwick Express service between London (Victoria) and Gatwick Airport was launched by InterCity in May 1984 and has been a great success. 
 Introduction of the project followed a major upgrading of the tracks in the Croydon area and new signalling permitting 90mph speeds. 
 The trains, running non stop every fifteen minutes, were formed from Mk 2 airconditioned coaches made available following the changeover to HST operations on the Midland main line; the locomotives are Class 73s. 
 The superior quality of the trains as well as their speed has both created new commuter business and extracted some traffic from the EMU service.   
 Mk4 DVT No 82203 with Mk4 stock and No 91009 providing rear power race through Potters Bar on 4 November 1989 on a proving run prior to entering service. 
 Beginning of the decade on WCML. 
 No 86247 (named  Abraham Darby in 1981) speeds through the Lune Gorge with an up &bquo;Electric scot&equo; service on 22 March 1980. 
 The train make&ndash;up is typical of the time with air&ndash;conditioned Mk2 stock supported by Mk1 braking coaches . 
 Discontinued ECML sleeper service. 
 The Night Scotsman, 23.40 King's Cross to Edinburgh, is hauled north at Bournmouth behind No 47525 on 23 July 1983. 
 The train was running approximately two hours late due to a broken rail at Northallerton. 
 Note the Motor Rail vans at the rear. 
 The corporate identity image has been slow to disappear, with the old standard liveries lingering even on Intercity services. 
 Here No 50034  Furious, which has subsequently been painted in NSE livery, heads the 13.40 Paddington to Penzance train under Taunton's west signal gantry on 11 April 1986. 
 The GWR semaphores were replaced a weeks after this, losing the character of a much older &bquo;corporate identity &equo;. 
 An aerial view of the approaches to Liverpool St station on 4 February 1989. 
 Passing Class 86/2s Nos 86242  James Kennedy and 86221  BBC Look East, which are stabled prior to hauling one of the hourly InterCity services to Norwich, is Class 315 emu No 315850 forming the 11.42 form Southend Victoria . 
 The May 1986 timetable saw the introduction of a new cross&ndash;London service from North West England to the South East. 
 On the second day of the new service, 13 May 1986, No 47446 arrives at Kensington Olympia with the 17.45 Dover to Manchester train. 
 The trains to Brighton over this route brought echoes of the old Sunny South Express. 
 Class 73 Electro&ndash;diesel No 73120 leaves Gatwick propelling the 15.50 Express service to Victoria on 22 September 1986. 
 Horely station is in the background. 
 SPECIAL AND CHARTER TRAINS 
 IN the glass-enclosed rear section of the elegantly furnished 1892 Caledonian Railway observation car, the guests on the Royal Scotsman  gathered to sip pre-dinner cocktails, nibble fresh foie gras canap&Eacute;s, and engage in polite rapport about their day's visit to Achnacarry Castle, the stately home of Sir Donald and Lady Cameron of Lochiel. 
 In the growing queue for the buffet on the Cheshire Cheese , the passengers moved one place nearer the long-awaited ham and tomato sandwich in stony silence. 
 If anyone spoke, it was usually only to voice condemnation of British Rail for the time it took to get served. 
 These were the opposite ends of the British special-train scene of the 1980s,    on either side of a conscious divide where the key words were price and profit. 
 Six days of luxury on the Royal Scotsman  (which included some steam haulage and as many glasses of Domaine des Berthiers as the liver would stand) at the end of the decade meant writing a cheque for &pound;2,880. 
 For the afternoon round trip from Crewe via Chester and Shrewsbury on the steam-hauled Cheshire Cheese  (buy your own coffee), fifteen pounds was seeing you home and dry. 
 The illustration shows how the special-train business developed in these ten years. 
 In 1980, luxury trains like the Royal Scotsman  and the Venice Simplon Orient Express  did not exist. 
 In 1989 they accounted for more than a quarter of BR's total charter-train revenue &mdash; and the trend is ever upwards. 
 In the 1970s the word was excursion, even then hardly fashionable, conveying an image of day trips to Blackpool and kiss-me-quick hats, of FA Cup tie specials (when football supporters swung rattles instead of knives), and of the classical BR Sunday Mystery Tour, when for ten and sixpence, you could be pretty certain of finishing up at Barry Island (again). 
 The age of the bucket-and-spade seaside special was all but dead by 1980, so what filled the void? 
 In the absence of any corporate direction, BR's excursion trains then were not much more than a mishmash of bright and not so bright ideas by divisional and area managers, which lost as much money as they made. 
 Pied Piper and Merrymaker outings, locally organised specials, and a profusion of enthusiast-orientated railtours were run with little or no coordination between the regions, with the result that there was remarkable disparity in standards and even the level of fares. 
 It was not until sectorisation in 1983 and the creation by the then InterCity director Cyril Bleasdale of a special department to co-ordinate and develop charter-train operation, that BR began to get its act together. 
 The man Bleasdale picked to head up its new Charter Train Unit was David Ward, who since 1976 had been responsible for co-ordinating main-line steam operations in conjunction with the Steam Locomotive Owners Association (SLOA). 
 One of the unit's first initiatives was to commission the London Business School to undertake detailed research into BR's existing excursion business. 
 The LBS report was uncompromising; it showed that even with full trains, there was little or no money at the bottom end of the market, whereas with first-class and full-dining trains, there was considerable profit potential. 
 So the man on the street ceased to be the prime target of charter-train salesmen. 
 Specials organised by InterCity became geared towards smaller numbers of passengers paying premium fares for VIP treatment in Pullman standard coaches with catering of comparable quality. 
 Under the old regional arrangements, the entrepreneurial independent tour organisers had been able to profit handsomely; especially those who catered for the insatiable demand by railway enthusiasts to travel &bquo;new&equo; lines behind favourite or unusual diesel types. 
 Now there were hard times. 
 Only operators able to fill their trains could expect to make a reasonable profit. 
 Traditionally operators with insufficient passengers simply cancelled; BR now insisted that 10 per cent of the train hire charge &mdash; in some cases as much as &pound;500 &mdash; be paid as a non-returnable deposit. 
  Since previously only about one in three advertised charter trains actually ran (there were indeed up to a hundred independent rail tour operators), the new regime immediately brought a crop of casualties, including in 1985 the Rail Tour Operators Association, the very organisation which had been established at Ward's insistence to negotiate train hire on behalf of all independents. 
 (It must be said that the RTOA also contributed to its own downfall, by failing to get a grip on in-fighting among its own members.) 
 Another development during the first half of the 1980s hastened the decline in ordinary charter-train operation: the wholesale withdrawal of ageing steamheated 90mph Mk 1 coaching stock from which such trains were usually formed. 
 The victims were not just the established railway enthusiast tour operators (all but a handful of which had already been squeezed out) but organisations such as the women's institutes and working men's clubs, whose annual train trips had been a tradition. 
 Now they were told &bquo;Sorry &mdash; no spare vehicles&equo;. 
 The only beneficiaries of the stock withdrawals were Britain's independent steam lines, who eagerly snapped up ready-to-run coaches from around &pound;1,000 a time.  
 At an early stage in the proceedings, SLOA recognised that, with the phasing out of Mk 1 stock, main-line steam operation (successfully revived in 1971) was in jeopardy. 
 Steam's incompatibility with modern, air-braked, electrically heated Mk 2 and Mk 3 stock, was absolute. 
 Thoughts of acquiring a complete rake of steam-compatible Mk 1s from BR were aired for the first time in 1977. 
 The announcement in April 1981 that SLOA had bought a rake of eight Pullman cars, mounted on 100mph Commonwealth bogies and fitted with dual steam/electric heating, seemed to be the answer to a prayer. 
 They came complete with David Ward's recommendation, and an assurance that the price, though never publicly disclosed, was &bquo;generous&equo;. 
 The set was to be maintained by BR at Carlisle Upperby depot under contract. 
 It had a total seating capacity of 378. 
 In BR's blue-and-grey standard coach livery, later to be repainted in classic Pullman umber and cream, the Pullmans made their SLOA debut behind &bquo;Back Five&equo; No 5407 on the Carlisle-Hellifield Cumbrian Mountain Pullman  on 2 May 1981. 
 Yet even before that special had run, SLOA secretary Bernard Staite was announcing that the Pullmans would form the basis of a new series of special charter trains, operating during the summer months with diesel and electric haulage, under the title Pullman Scenic Land Cruises. 
 This was the first time the phrase Scenic Land Cruise had been used by a train operator &mdash; but it certainly was not the last. 
 If the move up-market started anywhere, it was on Saturday 4 July 1981, when SLOA ran the first PSLC over the Settle &amp; Carlisle and down the Appleby-Warcop branch, for what now seems a very modest fare of &pound;15 first class, &pound;12  second class from London (Euston), together with a tray meal at &pound;2! 
 By 1983 the SLOA Pullman Scenic Land Cruise had become a series of oneand two-day charter trains with overnight hotel accommodation, embracing a variety of destinations &mdash; but most significantly, the Scottish rail routes to Mallaig, Oban, Inverness and Kyle of Lochalsh. 
 Despite what was then described as the worst financial recession for fifty years, the Mallaig train sold out in just nine days, there being no shortage of takers for seats which by now were creeping up towards the &pound;40 mark, and beyond the pockets of the traditional excursion-train traveller. 
 As a special train, the Land Cruise was a cut above its immediate predecessors, and in the ensuing years its profile and format have been further refined into a series of repeat itinerary three-day tours which, although still plying the scenic Scottish routes, now do so as part of InterCity's charter operation utilising specially refurbished first-class stock and Mk 3 sleepers in lieu of the Pullmans. 
 But in terms of luxury, elegance and sophistication, the Land Cruise was (and is) poles apart from the Venice Simplon Orient Express  unleashed on an unsuspecting world in May 1982. 
 Back came all the romance of train travel that had not been seen for fifty years. 
 Reviving the classical grandeur of the railway carriage of Edwardian days, with all its silver-plated, lacetableclothed dining-car finery and mahogany-panelled parlour-car ambience, on the long-established route from London to Paris and Venice, the Orient Express  was the brainchild of James Sherwood, head of the Sea Containers Group. 
 Sherwood's idea was to start his all-Pullman train from London's Victoria station, and run to Folkestone where passengers would disembark, make the cross-Channel sailing to Boulogne, and continue their journey by rail to Venice via Paris and Milan. 
 That the classical wooden-bodied Pullman cars of earlier days had long since been split up and sold or scrapped was no deterrent. 
 Where others would have dismissed the idea as impractical, Sherwood set about locating those vehicles which had survived intact. 
 Nine Pullmans were restored to their former splendour (but with modern air braking) at Carnforth in a remarkable &pound;3 million project. 
 Late in 1989 a tenth Pullman was undergoing &bquo;the treatment&equo; at an expected cost of &pound;400,000. 
 Across the Channel, Sherwood had indulged in a similar restoration exercise with a variety of former Wagons-Lits coaches, arranging the professional refurbishment of the sleeping cars, diners, day cars and staff vehicles by the Wagon-Lits shops at Ostende, and the Bremer Waggonbau company at Bremen. 
 In eight years of operation, the VSOE charter train has not strayed far from its original concept. 
 The departures from London on Thursdays and Sundays between the end of February and mid-November (the return leg departs Venice on Wednesdays and Saturdays) have become well established in the BR timetable. 
 A natural target for tourists &mdash; Americans and Japanese are especially evident during the high season &mdash; the popularity of the VSOE has been spread by tourism agencies, word of mouth, and occasional advertising  in the up-market Sunday colour supplements &mdash; a clear indication of where VSOE Ltd sees its main market. 
 In 1989 passengers undertaking the full journey from London to Venice paid a one-way fare of &pound;745 each for a double cabin with all meals included but drinks extra. 
 Combined train and air options have proved popular. 
 Anyone minded just to sample VSOE Pullman luxury on &bquo;the British bit&equo; &mdash; and many do &mdash; could travel Victoria-Folkestone return, with champagne, lunch, a half-bottle of wine and afternoon cream tea thrown in, for &pound;125. 
 Increased usage of the VSOE Pullman train for repeat itinerary charter work on days when it is not required for the Folkestone run, has given prospective passengers some further options. 
 In 1989 a luncheon-train round trip of the Kent coast from Victoria via Canterbury and Ashford at &pound;110, alternated on Fridays with a &bquo;day out to Salisbury&equo; charter special for the cathedral. 
 Similarly, VSOE deployed the Pullmans on Wednesdays, their destination alternating between Bristol/Bath and Goodwood House/Arundel Castle. 
 Also in demand for private and company charter hire such as conference and product launches, the one-time roadside diner and spring company board room accumulated some 400,000 miles in the eight years of operation since their &bquo;second coming&equo; in 1982. 
 Yet the title of &bquo;the world's most luxurious train' was snatched away in 1985 by a still more exclusive charter operation introduced to British metals by a company which owned none of its own locomotives or coaching stock. 
 The six-day Royal Scotsman  promoted by the L &amp; R Leisure Group under the trading name The Great Scottish &amp; Western Railway Company, was either a remarkable piece of opportunism, or a very shrewd example of business judgement. 
 Or both. 
 The nine-coach train carrying just twenty-eight passengers each paying around &pound;2,600 a time, was billed as &bquo;the highest point yet reached in luxury train travel&equo;, its on-train cuisine described as &bquo;simply the best on any train anywhere in the world&equo;. 
 Originating at Edinburgh Waverley the Royal Scotsman  set out to make stately progress through the mountains and glens of the Scottish Highlands, with a package of sightseeing visits to ancient castles and gardens, country houses and distilleries in store for its well-heeled patrons. 
 Despite its somewhat unmatched look, the stock formation included some pearls of the Victorian railway era, such as an 1891 ex-LNWR dining saloon, and a Caledonian observation car originally built in 1892, together with a varnished teak Great Northern family saloon of 1912. 
 Sleeping cars with en-suite bathroom, shower and toilet were barely recognisable as the BR Mk 1 vehicles from which they had been skilfully converted. 
 This is truly a &bquo;cruise train' with all facilities on board as on a luxury liner. 
 The whole train, attired in the plum-and-spilt-milk livery of the LNWR and Caledonian Railways, had been assembled together by Rick Edmondson, then chairman of Rotherham diesel locomotive manufacturers Thomas Hill, and leased to the Great Scottish &amp; Western Railway Company, under a fiveyear agreement. 
 One of the principal highlights of the Royal Scotsman  was steam haulage over the superbly scenic forty-one-mile section between Fort  William and Mallaig &mdash; the romantic &bquo;Road to the Isles&equo; &mdash; using one of the two locomotives stabled at Fort William for BR's own summer excursion trains; and from 1986 over the independent Strathspey Railway's five-mile line between Aviemore and Boat of Garten as well. 
 The durability of the Royal Scotsman  over five long seasons of operation, with the top tour price now only a short step away from &pound;3,000 was proven by 1989, but even as this book was being prepared for press, there were changes in the wind which may prove to be a sterner test of the depth of the elitist train-tour market. 
 Both the Great Scottish &amp; Western Railway Co and independently of each other in 1990! 
 Taking British Rail itself into the VIP train market was an altogether different matter. 
 There was no easy route. 
 In 1984, when the InterCity Charter Unit was first set up, it had at its disposal some twenty sets of Mk 1 stock &mdash; principally second-class tourist open vehicles &mdash; but nothing which  could credibly be described as suitable for the VIP trains it was seeking to introduce. 
 Progressively reducing the twenty Mk 1 sets by half, and acquiring from regular service stock a fleet of Mk 1 first open coaches, Ward put in hand a programme of vehicle refurbishment involving re-upholstering, recarpeting and curtain replacement and the fitting of individual table lamps, with the aim of restoring a level of respectability to coaches which had seen better days. 
 During the second half of the eighties, InterCity could at last boast five complete ten-coach VIP train sets all based and serviced at London's Bounds Green depot. 
 They comprised four Mk 1 FO sets, each made up of seven FO saloons, two kitchen cars and a BFK brake vehicle, plus the former Manchester Pullman  set of seven parlour cars, two parlour  kitchen cars and a parlour brake. 
 All were outshopped in standard InterCity &bquo;raspberry ripple&equo; coach livery but distinguished from ordinary service stock by having white-painted roofs. 
 For up-market small-party charter hire, InterCity also procured the former London Midland Region general manager's saloon No 6320 &mdash; something of a hybrid, comprising a special body on a Mk 1 underframe and B4 bogies, which had been converted for dual braking and electric train heating. 
 In addition, there is a single HST Mk 3 saloon, which, since special refitting to include a lounge and dining area, has seen use by both the Queen and the Prime Minister. 
 The Charter Unit's second-class sets, or more correctly standard class sets as BR now prefers to describe them, also underwent refurbishment during the tail end of the 1980s with twenty-four of the Mk 1 TSOs being smartened up and fitted for air braking during 1988, and a further twelve earmarked for the same treatment during the early part of 1990. 
 Because BR is reluctant to talk about profits, it is difficult to gauge accurately how successful InterCity's forage into the top end of the charter-train market has been, or how much the total earnings from charter traffic contribute to the sector's overall profitability. 
 But there is little doubt that charter-train profit can be read in seven-figure sums rather than six and that as a business venture, InterCity has not done badly at all. 
 Nevertheless InterCity cheerfully reveals that the VIP/first-class/full-dining trains contribute by far the largest share of the special-trains earnings &mdash; 50 per cent &mdash; compared with the 23 per cent from private charters, 18 per cent by standardclass charters, and 5 per cent by the steam market. 
 Exhibition-train revenue makes up the final 4 per cent. 
 The aces in the pack are undoubtedly high quality business charters and the three-day Scenic Land Cruise trains. 
 The latter became InterCity property in 1986, following a long and complicated sequence of events which began near the end of 1983 with the enforced withdrawal of the SLOA Pullman set, following the discovery that the potentially dangerous blue asbestos coach body insulation had become exposed. 
 Unable to meet the huge cost of the highly specialised asbestos de-contamination work then demanded of the entire Pullman set, SLOA agreed to sell the Pullmans to industrialist Sir William McAlpine (better known to railway enthusiasts as the owner of Flying Scotsman)  and to hire them back for steam-charter use once the asbestos stripping work was complete. 
 Under McAlpine's &bquo;Pullman Rail&equo; banner, the Pullmans returned to railtour duties in September 1984 &mdash; but by now Pullman Rail, with former SLOA secretary Bernard Staite as managing director, had also acquired from BR a second full rake of coaches &mdash; Mk 1 first opens, ostensibly for steam railtour work. 
 The Pullmans, it was announced, would be kept more or less exclusively for Pullman Rail's newly created non-steamcharter haul business. 
 After four months back in traffic however, the discovery of further traces of blue asbestos on parts of the Pullman underframes, caused the set to be impounded again&hellip; at which point InterCity took the initiative to run its own refurbished VIP stock on the Scenic Land Cruise trains, albeit with Pullman Rail contracted to continue  booking the trains. 
 In January 1988, the name Pullman Rail was dropped by McAlpine, in favour of &bquo;Flying Scotsman Services,. 
 As the 1980s were drawing to their close, The West Highlander  &mdash; not to be confused with the BR-promoted summer steam service of the same name running between Fort William and Mallaig &mdash; emerged as the Charter Unit's most successful train, achieving an average load factor of 87 per cent. 
 With 156 passengers representing a full trainload, and high-season tickets (end of May &mdash; end of July) selling at &pound;320, one does not have to be a brilliant mathematician to get a grasp of the kind of revenue being earned. 
 The inclusion in the Land Cruise trainset of seven first-class sleeping cars, coupled to InterCity's insistence that every passenger should have a window seat, stretched the West Highlander  formation to sixteen vehicles &mdash; too long for the platforms at King's Cross which could cope with only fourteen &mdash; so by default the Friday evening departure was written down to St Pancras, picking up at St Albans and Derby. 
 By way of example, the highlights of the 1989 train itinerary looked something like this: 
 Friday: Depart St Pancras. 
 Dinner served on train. 
 Overnight berth at Stirling. 
 Saturday: Depart Stirling for Oban. 
 Passenger ferry to Craignure on the Isle of Mull for a tour not only of Mull but a visit to Iona. 
 Overnight hotel at Fort William. 
 Sunday: Depart Fort William for Mallaig, with a cruise on Loch Nevis followed by a stop for Glenfinnan Monument visit. 
 Depart Fort William for overnight berth at Stirling. 
 Monday: Depart Stirling for Edinburgh. 
 Three-hour visit for shopping. 
 Lunch served on train to include Haggis and Neeps, Cock-a-Leekie soup, Noisettes of Lamb or Poached Scotch Salmon, Pineapple Pavlova. 
 Arrive St Pancras. 
 A far cry from the &pound;2 tray meal handed out on the first of the Scenic Land Cruise trains eight years earlier, in a decade of special-train running where sophistication got its chance &mdash; and left behind many ordinary folk for whom the railway &bquo;excursion&equo; is now but a fading memory.   
 Black Five duo. 
 No 4767  George Stephenson and No 5407 double head the mountain Express over the S&amp;C viaduct at Smardale, near Kirby Stephen in April 1981 . 
 Maunsell N15 4&ndash;6&ndash;0 No 777  Sir Lamiel pounds up to Harbury tunnel with the up Shakespeare Limited for Marylebone in July 1986. 
 This is one of BR's regular steam hauled Sunday dining trains . 
 SLOA special the West Highlander is caught near Crianlarich on 1 June 1985. 
 Motive power for the King's Cross to Mallaig train is provided by Nos 37081  Loch Long and 37111  Loch Eil Outward Bound over the West Highland section. 
 The train is now run by BR and originates from St Pancras . 
 N 47487 hauls a King's Cross to Chester&ndash;le&ndash;Street charter near Stonebridge, Durham on 27 June 1985. 
 The stock is mostly refurbished InterCity Mk1 vehicles. 
 Traditional roast dinner is served in one of InterCity's refurbished Mk1 open coaches. 
 Note the table lamps. 
 NETWORK SOUTHEAST 
 NOWHERE did the 1980s have a greater impact than on the services which at sectorisation became Network SouthEast (NSE). 
 At the decade's start everything was gloom and doom, cutbacks the order of the day since in 1979 the number of commuters going into London dropped for the tenth successive year. 
 By 1989 the problems were of growth and too buoyant demand stretching the resources though those had been considerably augmented. 
 Not merely was the transformation great in itself but, of course, on the largest commuter network under single ownership in the world &mdash; equating to the complete Dutch or Belgian railways, carrying two million passengers daily and accounting for 41 per cent of all commuters into central London. 
 When reading this chapter, remember that not merely is NSE the largest of BR's  businesses but in 1989 ranked as the 106th largest business of every kind in Britain. 
 Briefly to record the miserable 1970s, London's rail commuters faced fare increases of 40 per cent between June 1974 and May 1975. 
 BR could not avoid passing its dramatically increased costs following the oil crisis on to its customers, especially London commuters, and as they reduced in number (demand falling at 1 per cent a year) services, stock and facilities were reduced to &bquo;match demand&equo;, inevitably causing poor morale. 
 Even the ever-ebullient Sir Peter Parker saw parts of the commuter system &bquo;rattling into decline&equo;, and nobody was surprised when in 1979 the government referred the services to the Monopolies &amp; Mergers Commission. 
 The Commission's report was perhaps the turning point, for while it paid respect to the management it found &bquo;to be totally dedicated to the railway with a high degree of pride in the service which came before financial reward in importance&equo;, it made thought-provoking recommendations about management style and the need to set clearer financial objectives. 
 In particular BR were advised to create a new senior post at headquarters with special responsibility for London and the South East. 
 How did the transformation come about? 
 Like Caesar's Gaul, it can be described in three parts: continuing decline 1980&ndash;2; the London &amp; South Eastern phase under David Kirby 1982&ndash;5; and the reign of Chris Green and the birth of Network SouthEast commencing with his appointment on 6 January 1986. 
 Just how great the change has been is perhaps best illustrated  by reference to the number of daily commuters into London. 
 The decline was finally arrested in 1984; in the next four years the losses of the previous fourteen were made good! 
 Let us look at it year by year. 
 1980, the year of Continuing Decline. 
 BR could claim that even before the Monopoly Commission report's comments on the need for a new rolling-stock policy it was moving towards the development of stock for use on all regions, having introduced Class 313 25kV AC/750V DC (dual voltage) inner-suburban stock in 1976 for the Great Northern electrification scheme followed in 1978 by Class 507 750V DC third-rail stock for Merseyrail (Midland Region); and Class 314 25kV AC stock in Scotland. 
 From 7 January 1980, Class 508 750V DC stock commenced all-day operation on the south-western division of Southern Region and later in the year Class 315 units were introduced on Great Eastern line services from Liverpool Street. 
 Albeit with differing electrical systems, these units were of similar external appearance and brought to the Southern Region for the first time (other than on the Waterloo &amp; City line and the experimental PEP unit) sliding-door stock which might ultimately be suitable for one-person operation. 
 Elsewhere on Southern Region (where main-line passengers could see no prospect of new stock) 1980 saw the introduction of the first refurbished 4-CEP (Class 411) unit No 411506. 
 These main-line electric multiple units had been built between 1959 and 1963 for the Kent Coast electrification with a design life of approximately twenty-five years. 
 To all intents and purposes, the body shells of the old units were rebuilt above the solebar at Swindon Works and new (and considered by many less comfortable) seats with removable cushion covers, fluorescent lighting, double-glazed windows and a public address system were installed to extend their working lives into the twentyfirst century! 
 With their infamous riding qualities, the units compared ill with the air-conditioned delights of Mark 3 and HST stock being introduced on other regions. 
 But despite the still-falling demand, 1980 was not all gloom and doom. 
 It saw the signing of a contract worth &pound;15.5million with Westinghouse Brake &amp; Signal Company for the construction of a new power signalbox at Three Bridges as part of a &pound;45million scheme for resignalling the whole of the Brighton main line. 
 The new box was to replace thirty-three existing signalboxes and to control the line between Norwood Junction and Brighton, including Gatwick Airport which, from May 1980, was to be the terminus of a new semi-fast cross-country service from Reading (via Guildford and Redhill). 
 11 June saw the reopening of a station closed thirty-five years previously and the opening of the first new inner-London station for very many years: Hackney Central and Hackney Wick on the &bquo;Cross Town Link Line&equo; between North Woolwich and Camden Road, a promise of greater things to come. 
 1981. 
 Quiet Consolidation. 
 Only one station was reopened, Kentish Town West on the North London line, on 5 October by Ken Livingstone, leader  of the GLC which had entirely funded the &pound;400,000 rebuilding costs. 
 But on the Southern Region, &frac34; mile Laverstock loop (last used in 1859) was reinstated at Salisbury linking the Basingstoke and Romsey lines as part of the &pound;2million Salisbury resignalling scheme. 
 This scheme was relatively modest in comparison with many others such as the &pound;7million scheme, for which contracts were this year placed to resignal fifty-six route miles from Cambridge to Royston, Bishop's Stortford, Fulbourne (on the line to Newmarket) and to a point just south of Ely. 
 But even more important for travellers in East Anglia was the announcement, just before Christmas, of the approval of part of the Anglian electrification scheme (to Norwich and Harwich). 
 On 12 January the Midland electrification between Luton and Bedford went live in preparation for driver-only training. 
 1982. 
 The Year of Dispute and Sectorisation. 
 That training (and the service that should have started with the Class 317 units at the beginning of the 1982 timetable) was stopped by an industrial dispute about bonus payments for driver-only operation. 
 It became entwined with the separate dispute with ASLEF over flexible rostering, which the board had announced would be introduced from July with or without agreement. 
 ASLEF called out its members on a strike, described by Sir Peter Parker as &bquo;deplorable and shameful&equo;, from 3 July. 
 With government imposing pressure by withdrawing its PSO grant of &pound;15.5million per week, and a mixed response from ASLEF members that enabled the board to run approximately 1,500 passenger trains and 150 freight trains each weekday, a peace formula was worked out and normal services were resumed on 19 July. 
 The disruption contributed to the still-declining commuter business. 
 But some positive things happened in 1982 like the opening of Milton Keynes Central at a cost of &pound;4.5million; Watton-at-Stone between Stevenage and Hertford North; and of Watford Stadium on the Watford Junction-Croxley Green branch on 4 December. 
 And it was in 1982 that David Kirby was appointed director of the new London &amp; South East sector. 
 But he remained general manager of the Southern Region, almost as it were being his own superior. 
 He was (in retrospect) surprisingly luke warm about the potential of cross-London links &mdash; &bquo;show me the market&equo; &mdash; although he was no doubt pleased to accept in this first year in office an offer from the GLC to fund the third-rail electrification over 8&frac12; miles between Dalston and North Woolwich. 
 1983. 
 Turning the Corner. 
 The economy was improving, and evidence of increased confidence within L&amp;SE can be found in 1983 in the eventual introduction of electric one-person-operated trains between Moorgate, St Pancras and Bedford; the opening of no less than four new stations; and government approval for the long awaited electrification of the Tonbridge-Hastings line. 
 After its well publicised trials and tribulations, limited electric working from St Pancras commenced on 28 March and the electric service was officially inaugurated by the Secretary of State, Tom King, on 15 July. 
 A full service was introduced in the following year after various problems with  the new units had been resolved. 
 New stations opened during 1983 included Pinhoe (Devon) on the very edge of the L&amp;SE boundary, Templecombe, and Dalston Kingsland on the Camden Road-North Woolwich Cross Town Link line. 
 The latter, built on the site of a station closed as long ago as 1865, was wholly funded by the GLC and the Department of Environment's urban programme grant. 
 There were also closures such as the short section of electrified line between Elmers End and Sanderstead (near Croydon), Coulsdon North to enable Brighton line resignalling works to proceed, and Broad Street as a prerequisite of the redevelopment of Liverpool Street. 
 Evidence that David Kirby was keen to show that L&amp;SE was no longer a region-based organisation is to be found in the launch of Awayday, entitling an adult, if accompanied by at least one child, to purchase up to four additional tickets for adults or children at a flat fare of &pound;1 each for use anywhere within the sector area. 
 1984. 
 Take-off and Gatwick Express. 
 For the first time in fourteen years the peak-hour commuter figures show growth (a modest half per cent) but an  interview with David Kirby indicated that L&amp;SE had no inkling of what was to come. 
 Indeed, David Kirby stressed how the L&amp;SE call on the PSO grant would be limited by a continued reduction in fleet size (from 7,465 vehicles to 7,050 vehicles within two years) and by running fewer and shorter trains to adapt to &bquo;reduced demand&equo;. 
 The only opportunity for a large increase in revenue was thought to lie in the Gatwick Express  non-stop service introduced in May, featuring air-conditioned stock on the half-hour journey from Victoria to Gatwick every fifteen minutes (and powered on a push-pull basis by Class 73 electro-diesels). 
 One of the locomotives (No 73123) was named Gatwick Express  and turned out in a new livery to match the refurbished Mark 2 stock. 
 (The successful service was transferred to InterCity in 1985.) 
 In July the Southern's south-east, central and south-west divisions were abolished, new passenger business manager posts created and a reduced number of area manager posts (but each with increased responsibility) set up. 
 This was part of a new drive, following criticism in the Serpell Report that the railway was too &bquo;production led&equo; to become more businesslike. 
 The joint BR/LRT Capitalcard for the following year was announced, along with plans to electrify from Bishop's Stortford to Cambridge, on the East Coast main line to Huntingdon, and between Romford and Upminster. 
 1985. 
 To Thameslink and Beyond. 
 In the light of its subsequent success, the most important event was the authorisation of a &pound;54million scheme to link  the Midland and Southern electrified systems by reinstating the half-mile-long disused tunnel between Farringdon and Blackfriars. 
 Reopening of the tunnel, which had last seen regular passenger services in 1916 and goods traffic in 1969, had been considered in the London Rail Study in 1974 but rejected because the cost (including a new interchange station at West Hampstead) had been estimated at &pound;30million. 
 A more realistic and simple proposal was investigated by the GLC who concluded that it might be possible to reopen the link for as little as &pound;1million. 
 The &pound;54million package now authorised included the cost of forty six four-car dual-voltage electric units, the introduction of which would enable a greater number of existing units to be withdrawn because of more efficient use. 
 Within months it became obvious that increased demand on the Midland electrified lines (at last free from industrial problems and stock defects) would make additional units necessary. 
 Fourteen additional units were authorised in May 1986, by which time traffic on the Midland electrified lines had increased by 50 per cent since electrification. 
 Electrification was announced over the eighteen-mile stretch between Sanderstead and East Grinstead (but excluding the Uckfield branch). 
 This scheme was justified by the withdrawal of asbestos-bearing diesel multiple units and by the more efficient use of the existing EMU fleet; the withdrawal of asbestos-bearing stock was also one of the grounds for the Bournemouth-Weymouth electrification scheme submitted during the year. 
 From 13 May electric operation actually commenced between Dalston and North Woolwich, and a new &pound;440,000 station jointly funded by the GLC and the Department of the Environment opened at Homerton (between Hackney Wick and Hackney Central) on the site of a station closed in 1944. 
 In contrast, 5 July saw the end of the already very limited service between Stratford and Tottenham Hale via Lea Bridge, a line which may now return to passenger use following electrification at 25kV in 1989. 
 The image of LSE was enhanced by David Kirby's decision to introduce a new livery unique to LSE. 
 It was revealed when &bquo;Essex Express&equo; unit No 309605 was handed over on completion of refurbishment at Wolverton Works under a &pound;17.5million contract in March. 
 The refurbished unit enjoyed a 26 per cent increase in seating capacity and was finished in a two-tone brown livery embellished with an orange band at waist level. 
 This &bquo;Jaffa cake&equo; scheme was soon also to be adopted for main-line Class 411 stock by the south-east sub-sector of Southern Region. 
 1986. 
 Network SouthEast. 
 There was suitable razzamatazz at Waterloo on 10 June when the blue/white/red/grey livery was shown to the press on two Class 455 units and a Class 50 Howe  hauling a short rake of Mark 2 coaches. 
 L&amp;SE went out with a bang rather than a whimper. 12 May was marked by the introduction of no less than four new electric services; on the Eastern Region branch lines between Wickford and Southminster and between  Romford and Upminster; on the Great Eastern main line between Manningtree and Harwich; and (at last) over the thirty-two miles between Tonbridge and Hastings. 
 The Hastings &pound;20m scheme was celebrated by a successful &bquo;Gala Day&equo; on 27 April when unlimited travel over the line for only &pound;1 was available and more formally on 6 May when the Queen Mother (Lord Warden of the Cinque Ports) travelled over the line in the Royal Train. 
 In preparation for electrification, sufficient Class 411 units had been repainted in &bquo;Jaffa cake&equo; livery and branded the &bquo;1066 Electrics&equo; to give added impact. 
 Also on 12 May, and with financial assistance from Berkshire County Council and the developer of an adjoining industrial estate, a new station opened at Winnersh Triangle on the Southern Region line on the outskirts of Reading. 
 Another new station opened on 29 September at Welham Green (between Hatfield and Brookmans Park). 
 During David Kirby's period as head of L&amp;SE, the sector's call on the public service obligation grant had fallen by 36 per cent during three years, and Chris Green's task was to reduce (if not ultimately obviate the need for) the grant. 
 NSE's name, and livery, was chosen to give a new character and significance to the rail system in the south east, and to emphasise its unity as a system, no longer a series of independent lines owning loyalty not to London as a whole but to long-abolished independent railway companies. 
 He aimed to increase off-peak travel in particular by enhancing the quality of travel and station environment by &bquo;Operation Pride&equo;, a name coined to launch the quality improvement drive, and by new and imaginative marketing exercises, one of the first of which was a &bquo;Network Day&equo; on 21 June when over 200,000 people took advantage of the special &pound;3 ticket enabling them to travel all day anywhere. 
 So successful was the exercise, in both revenue and public relation terms, that a further &bquo;Network Day&equo; was held on 13 September. 
 The same 10 June also saw the launch of the one-day Capitalcard giving (after the morning peak) unlimited travel on BR, London Underground, London Buses and (in due course) Docklands Light Railway. 
 Within twelve months it had exceeded expectations and become a &pound;40million growth product. 
 Further growth in leisure travel (which represents 29 per cent of NSE income) was planned to follow the introduction of the &bquo;Network Card&equo; on 29 September providing one-third discounts on off-peak travel. 
 Chris Green announced that NSE had a commitment to quality improvements on all fronts, but with full-blooded business direction aimed at maximising the high profile of the sector, to which his famous red lamp posts gave an immediate impact. 
 Longer term financial and quality improvements were to follow major station redevelopment schemes, including profitproducing office and retail elements, of which the redevelopment of Liverpool Street and for which new plans were announced in 1986 is a good example. 
 The redevelopment of Liverpool Street involved the closure of the much decayed ex-North London Railway terminus at Broad Street, and the diversion from 30 June of the remaining North London Line services to the City via the newly constructed Graham Road curve into Liverpool Street using dual-voltage Class 313 units. 
  In retrospect the most important event of 1986 may have been the conception of the new Networker train, filling a vital gap price and quality wise, at long last making it possible for NSE to plan systematic replacement of old EMUs. 
 1987. 
 The Year of Electrification. 
 On 19 January electric trains began operation between Bishop's Stortford and Cambridge, and within three months authority was received to electrify the nearby ten-mile gap from Royston to Shepreth Branch Junction (near Cambridge), the anticipated &pound;2.5million costs being justified by savings in the use of rolling stock and lower maintenance costs. 
 Next month, full electric services commenced between Cambridge and Liverpool Street; between Norwich and Liverpool Street (partly sponsored by InterCity) and between Peterborough and King's Cross. 
 To celebrate its joining the electric network, Cambridge was visited on 23 March by the Minister of Transport (David Mitchell) on a recordbreaking (48 minute) trip from Liverpool Street. 
 The May timetable also saw the reintroduction of a limited and experimental passenger service between Oxford and Bicester Town (previously Bicester London Road before closure in January 1968), sponsored by Oxford City and County Councils, Cherwell District and Bicester Town Councils as a possible partial solution to traffic congestion in Oxford. 
 Subsequently, the Bicester service, although still indicated as experimental in the public timetable, has been enhanced and an intermediate station opened at Islip. 
 A month earlier, another experimental service reopened between Kettering and  Corby with as many as seventeen trains daily. 
 On the former GWR line to Bicester North a new station opened in October at Haddenham &amp; Thame Parkway &mdash; the 150th new station opened by BR since the Beeching cuts of the 1960s. 
 A new station at Lake (near Shanklin) on the Isle of Wight showed NSE's commitment to retaining the railway on the island. 
 More passengers have of course benefitted from the electrification of the Oxted and East Grinstead lines, although railway euphoria was possibly dampened by the Minister of Transport who on 30 September took the opportunity of rejecting further recommendations by the Monopoly Commission that increased investment was necessary to provide a satisfactory quality of service on NSE. 
 The East Grinstead scheme had only been authorised because of the need to replace asbestos-infected elderly diesel multiple units and by demonstrating that no new rolling stock would be required. 
 New stock was of course required for the proposed Thameslink service, and Chris Green formally accepted the first Class 319 dual-voltage unit at BREL York on 2 September. 
 Also welcome was the Royal Assent to the Bill authorising the construction of spurs from the Liverpool Street-Cambridge line to serve Stansted Airport on which work is now substantially advanced. 
 1988. 
 Thameslink and Wessex Electrics. 
 The pace quickened, this year seeing the long-awaited introduction of the Thameslink service, the extension of electrification from Bournemouth to Weymouth and the delivery (albeit late) of Class 442 &bquo;Wessex Electrics&equo; units to give air-conditioned comfort to NSE passengers. 
 But 1988 ended with the disaster at Clapham discussed in the signalling chapter. 
 Given its success after only eighteen months, and the current plans to extend the Thameslink network, it now seems hard to believe that passengers have enjoyed the ability to cross London by regular electric BR services for  such a short time. 
 Success has been despite the somewhat confusing route plan initially imposed on the service south of the Thames by the necessity of incorporating the new service into an existing timetable without increasing mileage. 
 Thameslink was formally inaugurated by HRH The Princess Royal on 25 April, when she combined its formal launch with that of Save the Children Week and travelled with a number of children on unit 319036 to Crystal Palace. 
 The everyday Thameslink service commenced on 16 May. 
 The initial order for sixty Class 319 units was soon increased to eighty-six. 
 Later in 1988 these units began to be joined north of the Thames by similar (but AC current only) units of Class 321 for use on Cambridge and Northampton services for which sixty-eight units were authorised, together with a further five similar Class 322 units for the Stansted Airport link. 
 The Class 321 units (of which the first was delivered in September 1988), were an immediate success, but the same cannot be said of the Class 442 &bquo;Wessex Electrics&equo; of which twenty-four five-car units should have been delivered in time for the May 1988 timetable. 
 In fact, only four units were available in May. 
 Southern Region general manager Gordon Pettitt took a calculated gamble when he authorised a charity high-speed run to Weymouth on 14 April, when the special train completed the 142&frac12; mile trip to Weymouth in seconds within two hours with a maximum speed of 109mph. 
 On the London Midland Region, electric trains of Class 313 commenced running, a year earlier than anticipated, between Watford Junction and St Albans Abbey on 11 July, on which line a further new station &mdash; How Wood &mdash; opened later in the year. 
 Class 313 units are also used on the suburban service between Euston and Watford Junction, to which service fell the honour of being the first line to be given a NSE total route refurbishment programme and branded &bquo;Harlequin'. 
 The programme included station and train refurbishment, new train information systems and full resignalling. 
 Experience on this line, as earlier on the Midland Suburban line and subsequently on the North London, has demonstrated the marketing advantages and associated traffic growth that follow such schemes. 
 It may well have contributed to the 1989 decision to introduce a policy of &bquo;Power to the Routes&equo; for the current decade. 
 Fifteen separate routes have been made the responsibility of managers whose chief aim is to satisfy their customers. 
 In the words of Chris Green: &bquo;Every problem will at last have an owner.&equo; 
 The lot of the Great Northern manager was eased in November by the reopening of an additional suburban platform (No 11) at King's Cross. 
 The Minister of Transport initiated electrification of twenty-eight route miles in Hampshire between Portsmouth and Southampton and Eastleigh, to be finished in 1990. 
 To the east, management within NSE was assisted by the creation on 29 April of a new Anglia Region covering lines serving Liverpool Street and Fenchurch Street stations. 
 1989. 
 Looking to the Future. 
 Hot on the Clapham accident, five passengers were killed in a collision at Purley (south of Croydon), again involving two Southern Region electric multiple units.  
 Save for the opening of a further station, at Islip on the Oxford-Bicester Town line, it was a year of consolidation and planning. 
 Class 321 units continued to be delivered at the rate of two a week, and on the Isle of Wight &bquo;new&equo; 1938-built former London Underground trains began to be introduced to replace coaches dating from 1923. 
 Authority was obtained for the modernisation of the Chiltern line between Marylebone and Banbury via Bicester including resignalling and the provision of seventy-seven Class 165 Networker coaches, and in August the then new Minister of Transport, Cecil Parkinson, authorised the first hundred Networker four-car trains for the North Kent lines. 
 The decade could hardly have ended on a more optimistic note. 
 While it has to be obvious that current success has been built on foundations that were perhaps sounder than people generally thought ten years ago, the combination of a livelier economy and greater commercial drive (leading above all to more commonsense, usually more local management) has produced results far above the most rosy forecasts. 
 The pride taken not only by many staff but passengers in their more clearly identified &bquo;Lines&equo; is paying handsome dividends. 
 But four main factors are singled out by Chris Green for the currently greatly improved outlook: the record investment currently being made, at the end of 1989 amounting to an astonishing million pounds a day; the success of the Networker train whose carriages in 1989 were being delivered at the rate of one a day; the enormous level of London station development both enhancing the environment (who at the start of the 1980s would have thought of treating a terminus as a shopping precinct?) and producing revenue on the grand scale; and the steady introduction of Integrated Electronic Control Centres (discussed in detail in the signalling chapter). 
 As mentioned at the start of this chapter, forecasts made at the end of the 1970s now seem horribly pessimistic. 
 It is hard to envisage the total 1990s story, but the decade starts with greater confidence in the railways serving London and the South East than, perhaps since Victorian times.   
 Refurbished 4&ndash;Cep unit No 1585 in London an South East Express two&ndash;tone brown (jaffa cake) livery comes under the impressive signal&ndash;box at Canterbury West working as the 12.03 Margate to Charing Cross via Ashford on 23 September 1986. 
 The 11.20 &bquo;Bedpan&equo; service from St Pancras to Bedford departs the london terminus on 26 September 1986 formed of Class 317/0 emu No 317315. 
 No 5029  Renown approaches Exeter Central station with the 09.15 Waterloo to Exeter St David's on 17 August 1989. 
 The whole train is in NSE colours and includes Mk2A and B vehicles . 
 A unique view of Holborn Viaduct photographed from a well placed office window on 18 august 1989. 
 Class 319 No 319041 forms the 15.56 Luton&ndash;Brighton &bquo;Thameslink&equo; service emerging from Snow Hill tunnel while above Class 413/2 4&ndash;CAPS Nos 3206 (heading the 16.54 to Kent House) and 3207 (leading the 16.47 to Canterbury East) await their respective departure times. 
 The 11.02 Dartford&ndash;Charing Cross with 4&ndash;EPB No 5335 leading passes the new Eltham station under construction on 17 August 1984. 
 This station replaced Eltham Well Hall and Eltham Park. 
 Class 321 emu No 321307 takes the Cambridge line through the Bethnal Green station platforms on 10 January 1989 forming the 13.05 Liverpool Street&ndash;Cambridge train while, on the right, the 11.37 Harwich Town&ndash;Liverpool Street service is formed of Class 312/1 emus Nos 312793/784. 
 looking to the future! 
 Breaking the banner at Ryde Pier head to inaugurate the first run of the Eastleigh&ndash;refurbished ex&ndash;LT 1938 stock from Ryde Pier Head to Brading on 13 July 1989, Class 483 unit No 001 looks particularly smart in a neater version of NSE livery. 
 PROVINCIAL 
 WHO would have thought, back in 1980, that we would now be reading in the popular railway magazines a number of reports that British Rail's Provincial sector possesses some routes which are promising to become profitable? 
 Who indeed could have forecast that the Provincial sector would be announcing such an improvement in their financial situation resulting from rapid but targeted investment in new trains, with the prime objective of cost reduction? 
 Certainly, only eight years ago, when the other sectors were given clearly defined briefs, the lumping of unprofitable passenger services into a somewhat negatively titled &bquo;Other Provincial Services&equo; produced a kind of dustbin sector. 
 Provincial inherited a very wide range of types of route, train make-up, and service level. 
 It had very few jewels in its crown. 
 Possibly the Edinburgh-Glasgow push-pull trains represented the sector's highest quality product, being formed of Mark 3 stock and powered by smart and newly overhauled Class 47/7 locomotives. 
 Other internal Scottish Region expresses to Aberdeen and Inverness also became part of the Provincial empire, even though their carriages were still branded &bquo;InterCity&equo; for many years after sectorisation. 
 There was also the Liverpool-Newcastle service, which in other countries would have been given &bquo;InterCity&equo; status, and which shared tracks north of Leeds with InterCity trains, but which ran here with older stock, Mark 1 or early Mark 2, hauled by the heavy and increasingly unreliable 1Co-Col locomotives of Classes 40 or 46. 
 If those trains represented the top quality of Provincial's empire, there was much less to be excited about elsewhere. 
 Outside the large conurbations, which were the province of the locally financed Passenger Transport Executives, Provincial inherited a disparate collection of routes linking various centres or branching to less populous places. 
 Many routes could not be said to form a coherent network, other than as InterCity connections to whom they did not now belong, and a few (surprisingly few) were in the mould of the traditional country branch line. 
 Most of the secondary routes that survive are relatively long, run through sparsely populated land, and have no hope of making money. 
 In this category one can group the West Highland and Kyle lines, the Central Wales, the Cambrian and Cumbrian coast, and possibly the Suffolk coast line. 
 The rest are mainly either inter-urban routes like Portsmouth-Bristol, quite busy branch lines like the Cornish branches or the South Wales branches; or  they are former main lines from which InterCity has progressively withdrawn &mdash; like the Settle &amp; Carlisle, the former Glasgow &amp; South Western Glasgow route, Newport-Crewe, the trans-Pennine lines and some cross-country routes crossing England from east to west. 
 There are local stopping services which run on InterCity routes, such as the Birmingham-Rugby-Northampton electric trains, the Manchester-Blackpool trains, Edinburgh-Dunbar locals and stopping trains on the North Wales route. 
 The description of these services as &bquo;disparate&equo; surely applies also to the traction and rolling stock inherited by Provincial, the assets most responsible for the sector's cost base. 
 The only modern-design vehicles, apart from the Scottish air-conditioned stock, were possibly the Class 310 electric multiple units radiating from Rugby, and even these dated from the mid 1960s. 
 Everything else was either original or refurbished diesel multiple unit, or the popular but cost-ineffective combination of diesel locomotives and cast-off main line carriages. 
 For many lifetimes railway practice had been for locomotives and rolling stock to be downgraded or &bquo;cascaded&equo; from front line to secondary services. 
 No one expected otherwise than to get second- or third-hand stock on a train running between Weymouth and Bristol, or between Manchester Victoria and Leeds, or from Glasgow to Stranraer. 
 The same happened to stations. 
 The owning Regions had their priorities to maintain to reasonable standards the stations on main lines and which were the calling points for InterCity trains. 
 In the 1970s money just was not available to smarten up more than a handful of Provincial stations. 
 Those fortunate to be in the areas covered by the PTEs were another story. 
 Money or the lack of it is what had modelled the railwayman's thinking in the formative years of BR. 
 From Dr Beeching onwards, managers were trained in the science of work study, in the discipline of financial restraint, and in being able to manage on less, to cut out or just delay expenditure. 
 In a sector where the income from sales of tickets represented less than a quarter of total expenditure, there was little else one could expect. 
 Thus as the recession of the early 1980s drew to its close &bquo;condition of track&equo; speed restrictions of some severity were imposed: for example stretches of 35 to 50mph between Selby and Hull on the straightest railway in Britain. 
 How, then, do we now celebrate Provincial's success as the 1990s begin? 
 It is a fascinating story of a turnaround, of the value of sectorisation and of the quality of the managers who took up the challenge of &bquo;Other Provincial Services,. 
 As a loss maker, Provincial received the bulk of its income from grants from the PTEs, and from the government in the form of the Public Service Obligation (PSO). 
 Not surprisingly, the Department of Transport, and in consequence the British Railways Board, maintained a policy of aiming to reduce the PSO so as to reduce the demands on the taxpayer. 
 Nationalised industries were first set annual cash limits under a Labour administration, but the concept was in line with Conservative Government policy to cut direct  taxation and release cash so that people (voters) had a greater choice with what to do with their money. 
 John Welsby was appointed as the first Director, Provincial, and he set about evaluating the sources of the sector's costs. 
 Quite clearly, as costs were four times direct revenue, 10 per cent (for example) saving in costs had much more effect on the balance than did a potential 20 per cent increase in revenue, so energy was at first concentrated on the cost base. 
 A significant feature was the realisation that BR's policy to refurbish and life-extend the ageing fleet of diesel multiple units involved an enormous additional expense in the sudden requirement to extract all their blue and white asbestos. 
 (The asbestos had been built into the carriages to act as sound and heat insulation, but had of course later been found to be a health hazard.) 
 The same work was also required in a large number of the early Mark 2 locomotive-hauled carriages, and in many long-life electric multiple units. 
 It emerged that across the very varied fleets the cost of asbestos removal would be &pound;25,000 per vehicle, an investment producing no financial return. 
 The question had to be asked: could the purchase of new trains produce savings sufficient to cover the cost of servicing their capital costs as well as reducing the burden on the PSO?  
 In the 1970s there were only two types of potential replacement DMU being considered by BR's passenger marketing people and the engineers. 
 The Class 210 diesel-electric design of three-car or four-car unit had actually been produced to a business specification developed in conjunction with the board's passenger commercial managers. 
 It was intended as a high-performance set which could inherit the reliability associated with previous BR (SR) DEMUs, thus beating the older, inherently unreliable diesel-mechanical multiple units hands down. 
 Its problem, when analysed by the new Provincial sector was its price: it would cost too much to enable a financial case to be made for the 210 breed to replace existing DMUs even taking asbestos removal into account. 
 The other design in the offing was the two-axle railbus which had started life as a Research Division project aimed at combining high-speed freightvehicle technology with that of the standard Leyland road bus in order to produce a low cost diesel train. 
 This was certainly a cheap option, and there were some short- or medium-distance routes where such a basic vehicle was considered acceptable. 
 In particular the PTEs in West Yorkshire and Greater Manchester were interested in the railbus as a replacement for their ageing DMUs. 
 Experience with these trains, delivered as Classes 141 (West Yorkshire) and 142 (Greater Manchester and elsewhere) was encouraging. 
 Their promised availability and utilisation was such that one new vehicle was expected to replace two old ones, and thus considerable cost savings were  ensured. 
 More units (Classes 143 and 144) were delivered for services in Tyneside and West Yorkshire. 
 The problems with the gearboxes of the 141s, 142s and 143s were well publicised as the 1980s drew into their second half. 
 The supplying company could not keep up delivery of repaired gearboxes to match the rate at which they failed, and with low availability of their new fleet Provincial had to retain the DMUs it was supposed to replace for a couple or so more years. 
 It also turned out that the 142s in Cornwall, and indeed those in Manchester to a lesser extent, suffered high wheel wear. 
 This necessitated their removal from the West Country branches while those units working in the Northern conurbations needed their wheel treads reprofiling more frequently, causing another temporary source of low availability for there was a shortage of replacement wheels. 
 But the new two-axle units were actually responsible for part of the upsurge in traffic on their routes and were certainly no worse than the buses with which they were successfully competing. 
 Meanwhile, however, it had become clear that there had to be a replacement DMU which was placed midway in size and cost between the railbuses and the 210 units. 
 But, if underfloor engines and transmissions were to be used, they had to be in a different league of reliability and performance from the DMUs which BR had been running since the 1950s. 
 Fortunately, some experience had been building up on the European continent, in Holland in particular, with DMUs which had very reliable and  cost-effective engines and transmissions. 
 The Nederlands Railways 3100 and 3200 Class units employ Cummins diesel engines with Voith hydraulic transmission driving through permanently engaged final drives on the axles. 
 This combination was tried among others on four prototype three-car DMUs on BR, two from BREL being Class 150 and two from Metro-Cammell being eventually known as Class 152. 
 Thus was born the hardware of the BR Sprinter units, but their business environment needs discussing in depth because of the fundamental re-thinking which resulted from the need to maximise the potential of those trains. 
 When the first orders were placed the numbers of two-car units in the fleet were set by means of a number of calculations. 
 Availability was targeted at 85 per cent, a quantum leap from the 70&ndash;75 per cent being achieved at most BR DMU depots up until then, and typical of the radical thinking which accompanied Provincial's second director, John Edmonds. 
 High-density seating with many rows fixed in face-to-back mode, together with much more standing room, enabled trains which had previously been formed of three old DMU vehicles to be scheduled for two Sprinter vehicles. 
 Large tanks permitted the Sprinters to run longer (up to 1,000 miles) between the need to refuel, and maintenance visits to home depots were reduced from the two or three times weekly of older DMUs to fortnightly. 
 Thus was it possible for one new Sprinter vehicle to replace at least two old DMU coaches. 
 In service the targets were beaten from day one. 
 90 per cent availability is now the norm, and there have been weeks when the 150/ 2 series, arguably the most reliable diesel trains ever to have run in Britain, have attained 100 per cent availability during the daytime. 
 For not only is maintenance now much less frequent, all scheduled depot attention is given at night or at weekends or between peak diagrams. 
 Thus, Sprinter units working out of Derby depot, covering as they did stopping services on routes spread out as far as Leeds, Manchester, Cambridge, Aberystwyth, Pwllheli, Holyhead, Scarborough, Skegness and Cleethorpes, actually achieved annual mileages in excess of 100,000 miles per year, practically double that achieved by the older DMUs. 
 Through the late 1980s another force was at work which turned the Provincial sector's fortunes further round. 
 Increasing prosperity in the United Kingdom meant that people had more spare cash, and much of this was spent on an increase in personal travel. 
 The new trains on the Provincial routes therefore had a market with a degree of positive elasticity not previously enjoyed. 
 Inevitably the services which had been planned on the basis of high seat-load factors quickly became overcrowded. 
 Provincial had been bitten by its own success. 
 Rediagramming of units, and the retention of old DMUs for many years longer than originally planned in order to keep up the fleet size to meet this new demand, have enabled the worst of the overcrowding to be contained, though there are at the time of writing (1989) stili several tight spots to be dealt with in certain areas at peak times. 
 And at the very end of the decade, after this chapter had been written, Provincial announced that such was the     cost of retaining ageing DMUs that in 1990 some services would be temporarily reduced until more Sprinters come on stream. 
 If that all sounds like success, there is another, more amazing story which Provincial can now tell. 
 And another one is just round the corner as this book is published. 
 Following the success of the early Sprinters, which were basically of suburban body design and layout, later builds of Sprinter have been up-market, aimed at the longer-distance traveller. 
 The Classes 155 (Leyland, Workington) and 156 (Metro-Cammell) employ longer, 23m bodies with end doors so that the central passenger saloon in each vehicle has the maximum possible space in which to arrange the medium-density seats. 
 The  the units have an ambience of comfort which is well matched by the refreshment-trolley service which is becoming the norm on the services on which these Super-Sprinters run. 
 What is really amazing however is the routes which have been dreamed up for the Super-Sprinters, and which have taken off with growth factors unbelieved when first disclosed. 
 The process has evolved over the decade with the linking up of what used to be short runs into long, cross-country routes. 
 Norwich-Birmingham had already been tried, with locomotive-hauled stock, but putting together the services which previously had separately linked  Liverpool, Warrington Central, Manchester; Blackpool and Manchester; Sheffield via the Hope Valley line; Nottingham, Grantham, Peterborough, Ely and Ipswich/Norwich and Harwich Parkeston Quay, was a bold move from which has developed a popular route on which much new business is emerging. 
 Other new routes coming into fruition have included the welding together of the trans-Pennine services between Leeds and Manchester with those starting back at Newcastle, Scarborough, Hull and the main line to Liverpool, with connections to Chester and North Wales. 
 There is also a route from Newcastle through Carlisle to Stranraer and/or Glasgow via Kilmarnock, which results from the combination of previously separate services. 
 Most Super-Sprinter services are based on hourly or two-hourly clock-face timings, and a feature of their operation has been their reliability, much in the face of opposition from traditional railway operators who originally rejected out of hand the idea that end-on services could be linked up without transferring delays from one part of the system to another. 
 The next phase in the growth of the Provincial sector's services is the introduction of the new Class 158 units on the Sprinter Express routes. 
 The 158 is a 90mph, fully air-conditioned DMU of high quality customer ambience specification. 
 It is the nearest thing to a modern InterCity train, and yet has the flexibility and economy of the DMU. 
 The quality is good enough to enable the 158s to replace the Mark 3 push-pull trains in Scotland as well as the Mark 2s. 
 The 158s will revolutionise the trans-Pennine routes when they push the 156s away on to other lines. 
 The annual mileages to be run by the new units will be well in excess of 150,000! 
 Indeed, there is now a distinct possibility that the Provincial sector will create some profitable railway routes in its quest for efficiency and quality. 
 The Provincial story is still proceeding. 
 Its present director is Sidney Newey, a successful career railwayman who sees almost endless possibilities for new routes. 
 We shall have to wait until each is announced, but the possibility of reopening new routes &mdash; a far cry from bus substitution &mdash; raises a new image for the sector which ten years ago had been written off by some people as a collection of unremunerative passenger railways. 
 The key evidence of success is the financial results. 
 From a frightening ratio of expenditure to fares revenue of four to one, the ratio has improved to better than two and a half to one and it is stili improving.   
 The 1980s saw the extensive refurbishment of the aging Class 31 fleet and a need for the more eth fitted Class 31/4s. 
 Here two examples are seen at Gilberdyke. 
 No 31466 halts at the platform with 13.39 Lancaster to Hull service while No 31439 passes non&ndash;stop with the 15.50 Hull to Lancaster on 16 August 1985. 
 This section of line is now double track and the station platforms have been altered to serve the middle roads on this picture. 
 During the late 1980s the line to Doncaster was severed when the swing&ndash;bridge over the River Ouse are Goole was damaged by a Swedish freighter on 23 November 1988. 
 Expensive prototype. 
 The three&ndash;car version of the Class 210 dmu, set No 210002 departs form West Ealing with the 11.05 Paddington&ndash;slough service on 22 February 1984. 
 Note the main and relief lines ladder junction. 
 Climbing the Pennines. 
 Sprinter units Nos 150242 and 150230 pass the distant signal for Greenfield as they work the 10.03 Liverpool to Scarborough service on 31 August 1987. 
 Swindon Style. 
 Still carrying its Trans&ndash;Pennine branding, four&ndash;car Class 124 dmu forms the 12.00 Leeds&ndash;Morecambe service near Clapham on 22 May 1982. 
 These distinctive units were finally withdrawn in 1984. 
 Sprinter No 150279 &mdash; one of the 150/2 series built with gangwayed ends &mdash; in the Nantgarw Gap nearing Radyr on the Taff Vale main line. 
 Castle Coch, a folly built on the site of a 13th century ruin by the Marquess of Bute, rises out of the wooded background. 
 31 March 1988. 
 Class 45 1Co&ndash;Col No 45110 (withdrawn July 1988) shirts the Irish Sea near Penmaenmawr with an eight&ndash;coach Bangor&ndash;Newcastle train in august 196. 
 These services were brought in with the May 1983 timetable to improve the range the Trans&ndash;Pennine trains on offer. 
 First&ndash;class accommodation is provided by an air&ndash;conditioned Mk2 coach, the most modern vehicle in the rake, second from the rear. 
 The leading coach is a down&ndash;graded open first. 
 Note the rockslide shelter (above the locomotive) protection from the granite quarries on the headland. 
 The European at ow Gill on its long journey south to Harwich Parkeston Quay. 
 The motive power is provided by No 85013 as far as Preston, from where diesel traction will take over. 
 The date is 9 August 1983, the service had commenced on the introduction of the summer timetable. 
 ScotRail push&ndash;pull Class 47/7 No 47716  Duke of Edinburgh's Award ( named July 1985) leaves Edinburgh Waverley with a shuttle service to Haymarket TMD for the ScotRail festival on 24 August 1985 . 
 CATERING 
 THE 1980s opened with British Transport Hotels (BTH) still running around thirty traditional railway hotels; with its Travellers-Fare wing sprucing up its portfolio of dull, old-fashioned refreshment rooms, and restaurant cars continuing to suffer declining patronage as journey times shortened and eating habits changed. 
 The HSTs had effected one major positive change: an increase in hot snacks in the age of the microwave. 
 The decade ended with the railway hotels not merely privatised but in many cases under second and third owners, generally poorer in standard and distinctly without the nation  having benefited (since they ran at a profit anyway), with Travellers-Fare privatised and healthier (both profitwise and in what they served), and with InterCity rethinking the role of the restaurant car and with many chefs still preparing meals on board. 
 It was in station catering, so long the Cinderella, that the changed order of the 1980s made its first mark. 
 The fast-food revolution arrived in style in October 1980 with the opening of the first Casey Jones restaurant at Waterloo. 
 Casey Jones, with its colourful, upbeat presentation, its production-line methods and its computer-controlled cooking, was light years away from anything seen before on British stations. 
 Passengers and passers-by alike found its wide, illuminated photographs of mouth-watering meals irresistible &mdash; though at a cost (in 1980) of nearly &pound;&frac12;million, Casey Jones was obviously going to pay for himself only at the busiest venues. 
 Over the next five years the CJ chain grew to fourteen, including provincial cities such as Birmingham, Liverpool and Glasgow (Central and Queen Street), spawning meanwhile a revolution in approach throughout the business. 
 The staff had been recruited and trained with a new professionalism; and the new methods now began spreading into the rest of station catering, bringing to the name Travellers-Fare a new credibility and respect. 
 Marketing too underwent a revolution; old names &mdash; the &bquo;Tournament&equo; at Paddington, the &bquo;Golden Frame&equo; at Sheffield &mdash; were out, while in came the snappy new &bquo;Quicksnack&equo; or &bquo;Station Tavern&equo; that proudly proclaimed a new image nationwide. 
 Everywhere, too, customers were finding much nicer things to eat. 
 Sandwiches &mdash; nearly 7 million sold on stations in 1985 &mdash; lost their &bquo;curly&equo; image; the new order was Tuna &amp; Cucumber, Salami &amp; Coleslaw, or BLT &mdash;  bacon, lettuce and tomato. 
 The immediate success of these fillings, and the brown bread they came in, reflected John Bull's broadening palate. 
 As the 1980s progressed, seasoned travellers observed that the offerings of railway stations, airports and motorway service areas were growing more and more alike. 
 All three are &mdash; or, in the case of railways, have become &mdash; essentially light catering markets; and in such markets profitability, the watchword of the times, calls for selling made-up products like plate meals or filled rolls, rather than retail lines like chocolate bars where the scope for mark-up is obviously small. 
 It means, too, devoting as much space as possible to selling rather than seating. 
 All this had a dramatic effect on station catering's turnover, up from &pound;33.1 million in 1978 to &pound;62.8million seven years later. 
 This was as well; for from 1980, the BR Property Board began charging Travellers-Fare a percentage of turnover, as rental; and if another retailer, caterer or not, could offer a better return, Travellers-Fare might find itself out. 
 One of the new-look business's greatest successes proved to be its Food Courts, where up to five takeaway counters open on to a central, supervised seating area. 
 Euston, the first to open in July 1986, included &bquo;Le Croissant Shop&equo;, a franchise business that at once complements and rivals Travellers-Fare. 
 Its &bquo;running powers&equo; over TF territory reflected the rising political pressure to dilute, and ultimately privatise, all public sector businesses. 
 Under this nostrum, the more successful station catering became, the more saleable it was; and in May 1986, the threat of sell-off moved dramatically closer, when British Rail split Travellers-Fare into its train and station counterparts, train catering becoming an integral part of InterCity, with station catering, continuing under the name Travellers-Fare, as a totally selfstanding business. 
 Travellers-Fare had first been split out of BTH from 1 January 1982 as a preliminary to privatising the hotels. 
 This further split between train and station catering was rigidly enforced and led to some extremes of rivalry. 
 One keen young steward on the Cannon Street-Hastings trains drummed up afternoon beer trade by operating his trolley on the platforms at Cannon Street. 
 While trains are exempt from the licensing laws, stations are not. 
 This was before the 1988 Licensing Act which brought all-day opening. 
 A quick telephone call from the station's duty catering manager resulted in the young unfortunate being escorted for questioning by the heavy hand of the police. 
 In 1988 BR decided to sell station catering outright. 
 That December, the Secretary of State for Transport announced the identity of the successful bidders: Travellers-Fare's own management. 
 There was widespread pleasure at this, justice had been done. 
 It had been a very different story with the earlier sell-off of the hotels where the managers' interest had not been shown proper respect. 
 No such satisfactory denouement came the way of the beleaguered train catering business. 
 Political hotheads were demanding a sell-off; but no wouldbe purchaser dared tangle with the horrendous staff rostering costs, the problems of management control, the antiquated working conditions, the  railway operating hazards that frustrate a crew's best efforts while landing them with the blame and, not least, the ever-lurking cynicism of the media. 
 Unlocking all these problems needed several different keys. 
 One of them was the mini-buffet, first introduced in 1980 on the Waterloo-Exeter run. 
 Designed as a low-cost replacement for the fleet of &bquo;miniature&equo; buffet cars, then twenty years old, these trolleys were (and are) pre-loaded, operating on board from behind a small fixed counter in an open saloon coach. 
 At any station en route the steward can speedily remove or exchange his trolley, or switch to another train. 
 This highly flexible system quickly spread to longdistance commuter runs, such as Liverpool Street to Cambridge or Clacton; and in turn gave fresh impetus to the old dream of establishing corridor trolley services throughout the length of trains. 
 The new, spacious Mk 3 rolling stock, with its luggage stowage space and automatic vestibule doors, was at last making these a practicality; and, despite some unofficial rearguard action, in 1984 the NUR ended opposition. 
 The resulting at-seat light refreshment services provided an ideal foothold for the private operators whose involvement in railway catering the government was urging. 
 The first of these now widespread services began, in the summer of 1984, between Chester and  Newport, run by Gylee Enterprises (whose &bquo;operating manager&equo; was a former Travellers-Fare station catering manageress). 
 The mini-buffets underlined anew the truism that if all food could somehow be prepared on terra firma, familiar restaurant-car hazards such as unreliable equipment and minuscule space would no longer matter. 
 And technology was now offering a key to this problem also. 
 Modern cook-chill processes, using liquid nitrogen, chill partly cooked food very rapidly to just above freezing point at which temperature it will keep perfectly for several days. 
 Heating in a simple convection oven is all that remains to do on board; and this system, coupled with a range of basically similar (&bquo;modular&equo;) trolleys formed the basis of &bquo;Cuisine 2000&equo; begun experimentally between Euston and Manchester in August 1985. 
 Modular catering cars retained an orthodox grill for that perennial favourite, the Great British Breakfast, which in 1987 accounted for 630,000 out of the total of 1.1 million main meals served. 
 Preparation of the food &bquo;on shore&equo; now offered private contractors a foothold in the core of the business, and this in turn led in 1987 to the highly symbolic step of privatising the railway sandwich. 
 Once the butt of musichall comics, the quality and range was further improved &mdash; and was an immediate success. 
 Soon InterCity were claiming that sales had doubled to 5 million a year. 
 Part of this somewhat free accounting was undoubtedly due to much better control: no longer could staff pass off a &bquo;do-it-yourself sandwich and pocket the proceeds; but much of the increase was real and deserved. 
 Cuisine 2000 itself, meanwhile, was enjoying a somewhat mixed reception. 
 Freed from railborne restrictions, the new menus could offer much greater sophistication. 
 Passengers now encountered &bquo;Duckling in Ginger and Shallot Sauce: an irresistible combination of seasoned roasted duck, off the bone, served with a sauce of shallots, ginger, honey and white wine.&equo; 
 But such pretentious billing set up Cuisine 2000 for instant mockery whenever problems arose &mdash; as surely they did. 
 Private contractors, appointed both to supply the food and to staff and run the &bquo;shore&equo; depots, seriously underestimated problems such as the relentless, unforgiving intensity of the railway timetable &mdash; very different from their airline experience where there are far more carpets under which to sweep catering delays. 
 There were many complaints of altered menus, minuscule portions, and too often, of no food at all. 
 The running of Cuisine 2000 furthermore quickly proved very costly. 
 Expensive bought-in food and increased depot costs were largely to blame. 
 The forecast upsurge in takings did not happen. 
 The cost of train catering to its parent BR Sector, InterCity, almost doubled between 1983 and 1988. 
 A review completed in spring 1989 confirmed once again the truths of the business: that catering is an essential and integral part of InterCity travel; that (trolleys excepted) most train catering, modular or otherwise, will ever be a net cost; and that therefore, the catering budget can only emerge after the extent and level of services have been specified. 
 Setting a cost limit first, and then trying to tailor services to fit, causes only conflict and demoralisation. 
 So InterCity declared a policy for the 1990s of offering catering in some  form, on all their services. 
 Modular catering (though not necessarily Cuisine 2000) is expanding on to the Liverpool Street-Norwich run (using former West Coast vehicles), the East Coast main line (with Mk4 stock), and the Western Region, when the ex-ECML cars can be cascaded in 1991. 
 Food will be bought-in at various stages of pre-preparation; but the operation of shorebases by contractors is at an end. 
 Meal style and availability will vary, more than hitherto, with the journey length and passenger profile of each individual train. 
 Meantime BR's two other passenger sectors, Provincial and Network SouthEast, were left under the 1986 reorganisation without their own catering. 
 Subsidies are out; if no one can operate their on-train catering profitably, then no catering there will be. 
 Unlike at InterCity, little ticket revenue is considered at risk from taking this stance. 
 Proper buffet cars are economic on only a small handful of their routes, notably Waterloo-Bournemouth. 
 On many other routes, trolleys have provided an ideal lowcost solution and today's timetable shows a good variety of trains, including many of Provincial's Sprinter expresses.     
 Station Breakthrough: the first Casey Jones fast food restaurant, at Waterloo, seen here soon after its opening in October 1980. 
 &bquo;Welcome Buffet&equo; was a marketing attempt to jazz up the merchandising in the old Mk1 buffet cars, patently unsuited to the 1980s. 
 Its success &mdash; unlike the public cynicism it generated &mdash; proved hard to identify. 
 The new dawn: Cuisine 2000 in its first month of service, August 1985, on to Euston&ndash;Manchester run. 
 Among the first private trolley operators on BR were Rightline Caterers of Rhyl, seen here working 17.40 chester&ndash;Rhyl service on a very cold 25 February 1986, when the well&ndash;known instant coffee, common to both private and public sectors, was extremely welcome. 
 Hot favourite: through the 1980s the Great British Breakfast took a larger and larger share of total main meals served. 
 Mk2 first&ndash;class open vehicles, like that shown here, gave way to the Mk3 build, and glass jars of Cooper's Oxford Marmalade to plastic portion-sized containers. 
 FREIGHT, EVER MORE SPECIALIST 
 AT the beginning of the 1980s BR's freight business retained many facets of the inefficient, labour-intensive system of yesteryear. 
 True, the &bquo;Beeching era&equo; of the 1960s had brought revolution in the form of Freightliner and unit trains, the latter represented above all by the highly successful &bquo;merry-goround&equo; concept. 
 But such innovations were only applied to certain traffic flows, and the old order of vacuum-braked or unfitted wagons, sprawling marshalling yards and generally lavish siding provision was allowed to linger on. 
 It was only during the 1980s that it was finally laid to rest, enabling BR to run a fully modernised and streamlined freight system. 
 The most telling indicator of Railfreight's success in the 1980s was the unprecedented turnround in its financial performance. 
 From a massive deficit of &pound;281mi1lion in 1984&ndash;5, the year of the miners' strike, the sector was able to recover quickly to break-even point and then achieve a handsome surplus of &pound;69million in 1988&ndash;9. 
 In so doing Railfreight chalked up an achievement which would scarcely be considered feasible by any other European railway administration: only in Britain is the freight-carrying railway required to function without government subsidy. 
 Sectors and sub-sectors. 
 Sectorisation had especially far-reaching consequences for Railfreight. 
 Nothing has been allowed to stand in the way of the sector's progress towards profitability. 
 It is free from many of the constraints of timetabling, shared usage of stations and so on which limit the extent of true independence amongst the passenger and parcels sectors. 
 It has been able to shed its loss-making operations without the need for lengthy legal procedures such as those which normally accompany the proposal to close a branch passenger service. 
 The further division of Railfreight into five subsectors, namely Coal, Construction, Petroleum, Metals and Distribution, has exposed the strengths and weaknesses of individual traffic flows and kept the degree of cross-subsidy within the sector to a minimum. 
 All the way through Railfreight's emergence as a viable, forward-looking concern, the emphasis was on improving the service to the customer. 
 A bad reputation had resulted from years of unwieldy and sometimes inefficient management, coupled with the inherent un-reliability of the old wagonload system. 
 Under sectorisation individual managers have much more clearly defined responsibility, and the need to keep the customer informed about the whereabouts of his goods, for example, is now recognised as paramount. 
 An outward sign of Railfreight's resurgence was the brightly coloured livery  which made its debut in October 1987. 
 For locomotives there was now a livelier three-tone grey colour scheme with sub-sector logos and depot badges. 
 Other Railfreight assets from office buildings to headed notepaper also received the appropriate embellishments. 
 The Railfreight Infrastructure. 
 Railfreight is the sole user of numerous yards, sidings and terminals. 
 Most running lines used by Railfreight are shared with at least one other sector, though there is a not insignificant mileage which exists purely for the benefit of freight. 
 It is not surprising, then, that considerable rationalisation of yards, sidings, terminals and lines has taken place. 
 To say that every inch of siding space must earn its keep by virtue of the traffic it carries is not so very far from the truth. 
 A striking example of rationalisation was the wholesale closure of the Severn Tunnel Junction marshalling yard complex in November 1987. 
 The yard was a product of piecemeal development over many years and found an important role in the air-braked wagonload network (Speedlink) from the 1970s onwards. 
 It was a convenient gathering point for all non-trainload traffic to and from South Wales, and also became the gateway to south-west England with feeder services to Bristol, Exeter, Plymouth and so on. 
 Moreover it was not an under-used white elephant in the manner of Kingmoor yard in Carlisle; traffic levels remained comparatively healthy right up to the  end. 
 In their quest to reduce costs, however, the Railfreight managers were keen to explore every way of streamlining their operations, and in the case of Severn Tunnel Junction it was found that total closure would bring substantial savings for relatively little inconvenience. 
 Most of the work previously carried out at Severn Tunnel Junction was transferred to Gloucester, Cardiff Tidal and East Usk (Newport) yards, with Stoke Gifford (Bristol) playing a minor role. 
 Though in the early days there were capacity problems at Gloucester, by and large the new arrangements have worked well. 
 Many other yards throughout the BR network saw reductions in activity as a result of the continued trend towards unit or &bquo;block&equo; train working. 
 Toton was a pivotal Speedlink yard in 1980 but its status had been reduced to that of staging and storage sidings, plus a small amount of household coal shunting, by the end of the decade. 
 The importance of Healey Mills yard (West Yorkshire) has declined in a similar way, with most of its shunting duties transferred to Tinsley (Sheffield) and Doncaster. 
 But two entirely new yards were opened towards the end of the decade, showing that BR envisages at least some need for shunting for the foreseeable future! 
 These yards are both in South Wales, at Margam and Ebbw Vale. 
 Both were sponsored by  the Metals sub-sector for specific categories of traffic, rather than by Railfreight Distribution for general Speedlink work. 
 So far as terminals are concerned, the trend of the 1980s has been overwhelmingly towards the setting up of private distribution depots, so running down BR's own facilities. 
 The traditional railway goods depot, with its acres of sidings and its own cranage and cartage facilities, has declined almost to the point of extinction. 
 Some towns and cities are now devoid of any kind of public freight terminal, or even a suitable siding which could be used for a one-off consignment. 
 Where private enterprise has stepped in, the results have been variable. 
 Among the more successful privately owned terminals have been the Glaswegian trio of Deanside, Mossend and Law junction, all of which (but especially the first two) have attracted healthy quantities of regular traffic. 
 More specialised terminals, such as those handling chemicals or coal, have thrived in relation to the industry they serve, though the tendency has been to close lesser used depots whenever investment in new track or pointwork has become necessary. 
 Most of the new terminals commissioned during the 1980s were funded partly by the government by means of a &bquo;Section 8 Grant&equo;, giving up to 60 per cent of the total cost. 
 As for running lines, the axe fell principally on two categories of &bquo;freight only&equo; railway: through lines where an adequate diversionary route existed; and branch lines which carried only small quantities of wagonload traffic. 
 Casualties in the first category included Walsall-Brownhilis, the Woodhead route, Northampton-Market Harborough, Warrington-Skelton, Bottesford-Newark and Airdrie-Bathgate. 
 Examples of the second category are Wymondham-Dereham/Ryburgh, Barnstaple-Torrington/Meeth, Grimsby-Louth, Perth-Forfar and Kinnaber-Brechin. 
 Where a rural freight branch has survived, this is only because of the presence of a major user, such as Blue Circle Cement at Eastgate, Associated Octel at Amlwch and Esso at Fawley. 
 Such branch lines are of course vulnerable to changes in output level or distribution policy of their users. 
 The Staffordshire branches to Caldon Low and Oakamoor were each carrying several trainloads of aggregates a week in the mid 1980s but their traffic was lost to road transport in 1988 and 1989 respectively. 
 Sometimes the closure of a through &bquo;freight only&equo; route and the consequent diversion of traffic fails to bring the desired results. 
 While the costs of maintaining the closed route will be saved, these may be offset by the need to deploy additional resources because of the extra time required to send trains via the diversionary route. 
 This phenomenon occurred twice in the 1980s: Dee Marsh-Mickle Trafford was closed in 1984 but reopened mainly for steel coil traffic in 1986, and Annbank-Mauchline closed in 1985 but came back into use as a Railfreight Coal asset in 1988. 
 In the case of Annbank-Mauchline, the reopening allowed an enhanced schedule of Knockshinnoch-Ayr coal trains to be covered by one pair of locomotives instead of two. 
 Bulk Traffic. 
 Four out of the five Railfreight sub-sectors deal mainly with bulk traffic which travels by the trainload rather than by the individual  wagonload. 
 Few would deny that the railway is admirably suited to carrying this type of traffic. 
 So as the 1980s drew to a close, the sub-sectors dubbed Coal, Construction, Petroleum and Metals were all in fine shape, and their outlook for the 1990s is promising. 
 Not that the eighties were without their problems: quite apart from the industrial recession of the early years, which affected all Railfreight's bulk traffics to some degree or other, there was the historic miners' strike of 1984&ndash;5, taking heavy toll of steel as well as coal carryings. 
 Happily the coal traffic was revived to the point where pre-strike tonnages were exceeded, although the number of individual collieries served was vastly reduced. 
 The &bquo;merry-go-round&equo; system which allows loading and discharge to take place while an entire train remains in motion has continued to form the mainstay of Railfreight Coal's operations, and it is difficult to imagine a more efficient alternative. 
 Railborne steel traffic suffered in proportion to the cutbacks in the steel industry itself, with complete withdrawal from one or two locations such as Consett in County Durham. 
 Interestingly, though, Railfreight also derived some benefit from the contraction of British Steel's steel-making activities. 
 The concentration of blast furnaces at a smaller number of plants meant that the rolling mills at Corby and Shotton, for example, would henceforth receive their raw steel from other parts of the country. 
 This provided Railfreight with valuable contracts for long-distance bulk coil traffic, traffic which would not have materialised if the steel industry had survived the 1980s unscathed. 
 Another area of growth within the Metals sub-sector has been finished &bquo;bright steel&equo; or cold reduced coil. 
 Almost non-existent at the beginning of the 1980s, rail carryings of this commodity had assumed significant proportions by the end of the decade, showing Railfreight both eager and able to adapt to new opportunities. 
 The Petroleum sub-sector began the decade in the doldrums, having lost much of its traffic due to reduced demand and surrendered further flows to long-distance pipelines. 
 An upturn in tonnages was recorded in the latter part of the decade, however, and the threat of at least one further pipeline receded when Total Oil renewed a major contract with BR in 1988. 
 As for Railfreight Construction, the transporting of bulk aggregates from quarries such as Merehead and Whatley has thrived unabated, particularly to London and the South East where the construction industry's appetite could no longer be satisfied from local sources. 
 A record quantity of 14 million tonnes was carried in 1987&ndash;8, of which over three-quarters were destined for the South East. 
 Twenty years previously this traffic had amounted to just two million tonnes per annum. 
 Also worthy of mention for the Construction sub-sector is the growth in domestic waste traffic. 
 By the late 1980s regular trainloads were being dispatched from purpose-built transfer terminals in Greater London, Manchester and Avon, and these would soon be joined by a new flow from Edinburgh. 
 The Distribution Problem. 
 Railfreight's success in the 1980s was clouded by one area of uncertainty. 
 That was the non-bulk wagonload operation, later  marketed as Railfreight Distribution. 
 The basic problem remained, as always, the cost of providing a service to a large number of individual freight terminals, many receiving only a handful of wagons each week. 
 On the positive side, a milestone was reached in 1984 when the old vacuum-braked wagonload network was finally abandoned and all worthwhile traffic transferred to the air-braked Speedlink system. 
 The principle of Speedlink is that train sections are exchanged at specified groups of sidings on the network, rather than individual wagons sorted at full-scale marshalling yards. 
 On certain routes Speedlink has served BR and its customers well, with many trunk trains running to capacity; but the economics of running three- or fourwagon feeder services at the periphery of the network have remained questionable. 
 Some worthwhile traffic gains were made during the 1980s, such as timber from the Scottish Highlands and drinks from several locations in the South West. 
 But equally notable were the losses, such as the once substantial Rowntrees traffic from York. 
 Nor was the Distribution balance sheet improved by the abstraction of most coal and steel traffic from Speedlink services, in 1986&ndash;7 and 1989 respectively, to form dedicated networks for these commodities. 
 Towards the end of the decade Railfreight Distribution was increasingly  setting its sights on traffic between Britain and mainland Europe as a major source of revenue. 
 Until 1987 there were two separate train ferry operations for through freight traffic between Britain and the continent, Dover-Dunkerque and Harwich-Zeebrugge. 
 This arrangement was, however, in many ways inefficient, and in January 1987 the Harwich-Zeebrugge service was withdrawn and all train ferry traffic routed via Dover. 
 In the short term this did result in a reduction in capacity, leading many observers to criticise BR for short-sightedness in view of the need to attract new traffic in readiness for the opening of the Channel Tunnel, but during 1988 the Dover-Dunkerque service received a boost when Railfreight Distribution commissioned a new high-capacity ferry, the Nord &mdash; Pas de Calais , to cater both for individual wagonload consignments and for trainload traffic on this route. 
 This enables Railfreight to cater for a modest increase in international traffic in the years leading up to the opening of the Channel Tunnel. 
 Another change which took place with the anticipated increase in continental traffic in mind was the merger of Railfreight Distribution with the former BRB subsidiary Freightliners Ltd in 1988. 
 This allowed BR to concentrate all its non-bulk freight activities under one organisation, and eliminated the counter-productive competition which might otherwise occur between Freightliner and the conventional wagonload (ie Speedlink) network. 
 By 1989 there was only one regular instance of Speedlink and Freightliner traffic sharing the same train, this being a service between Bristol and Coatbridge, but the organisation had already begun marketing its two products as complementary rather than competing systems, itself an important step forward in the history of Railfreight. 
 Traction Developments. 
 Now that all three passenger sectors prefer unit trains to the traditional combination of locomotive and coaches, the Railfreight sector is left as the prime user of diesel locomotives. 
 Mixed-traffic types such as the Brush Class 47 have fallen from favour since they inevitably entail a compromise between a high maximum speed for passenger working and a high tractive effort for freight haulage. 
 The only orders for new diesel locomotives placed during the 1970s and 1980s, were for locomotives designed specifically to haul freight. 
 First came the Class 56, superficially similar to the Class 47 but with a maximum speed of 80mph and no facility for train heating. 
 A fleet of 135 Class 56 locomotives was introduced between 1977 and 1984. 
 Next came the Class 58, functionally similar to the Class 56 but with a number of radical design features such as external walkways along the sides of each locomotive; a fleet of fifty entered service between 1984 and 1987. 
 And as the 1980s drew to a close, the first locomotives of Class 60 were rolling out of the Brush works at Loughborough, destined to become the standard Railfreight traction unit well into the early years of the twenty-first century. 
 Perhaps the most exciting new build of the 1980s, however, was the small fleet of Class 59 locomotives built for Foster Yeoman of Merehead in Somerset. 
 Not only were these the first privately owned diesels to regularly haul freight trains over BR main lines,   but they were also remarkable in having originated at La Grange, Illinois. 
 So successful was the Class 59, perhaps embarrassingly so from the viewpoint of British manufacturers, that the initial order for four machines was followed up by orders for five more, comprising one for additional Foster Yeoman traffic and four for the neighbouring but rival firm ARC. 
 Existing traction resources were trimmed severely as the new, more efficient types entered service. 
 Less favoured designs such as Classes 25, 40 and 45 were withdrawn completely, and the Railfreight sector relinquished its claim on the costly Class 50. 
 A major life-extension programme was carried out on nearly half the Class 37 fleet, with a number of variants designed specifically for freight haulage and expected to survive into the next century. 
 Some important changes were made to maintenance arrangements, whereby locomotives became attached first and foremost to specific traffic flows rather than to a defined geographical area. 
 Many diesel depots ceased to carry out maintenance for the Railfreight sector, with some facing the axe such as Gateshead and others concentrating on work for other sectors such as Bristol Bath Road. 
 Out of the thirteen which still had a formal Railfreight allocation in 1989, many had become specialised bases for traction belonging to a particular sub-sector. 
 Toton and Tinsley are good examples of depots with specific sub-sector allegiances and covering a wide geographical area. 
 Toton took over responsibility for all Railfreight Coal traction used in the Midlands, North West, Yorkshire and North East districts, comprising some 250 locomotives of Classes 20, 56 and 58. 
 Tinsley became the base for over  150 locomotives used on Speedlink services throughout the BR network, comprising members of Classes 31, 37 and 47. 
 At the other end of the scale, Plymouth Laira gained a small fleet of Class 37s which rarely ventured away from the West Country china clay empire, although a new trainload working was introduced in 1989 which would take them twice a week up to Irvine in South West Scotland. 
 At some maintenance depots the establishment of specific sub-sector pools led to significant improvements to reliability, even though in many cases the locomotives concerned were travelling further from home than ever before. 
 The only Railfreight traction to retain common-user status was the AC electric fleet on the West Coast main line. 
 Wagons. 
 The number of wagons used on BR continued to shrink dramatically during the 1980s. 
 In 1979 there were over 150,000 vehicles authorised for main-line running, but by 1989 the total had fallen to around 40,000. 
 Over the same period BR's annual freight tonnage fell only marginally, from 169 million tonnes to 149 million tonnes, so the reduction in size of the wagon  fleet was a remarkable achievement. 
 The main casualties were railway-owned vehicles fitted with vacuum brakes or with no automatic brake at all. 
 Many such wagons spent long periods hidden away in marshalling yards or being used as storage containers on customers' premises, practices which the business-led Railfreight sector was understandably keen to eradicate. 
 The new vehicles built as replacements during the 1980s were generally of higher capacity, privately owned and fitted with air brakes. 
 Where a customer did not wish to purchase his own fleet of wagons, he was usually encouraged to hire or lease from firms such as Procor or Tiphook in preference to using railway-owned vehicles. 
 In the Construction sub-sector, for example, the use of railway-owned vehicles on aggregates traffic ceased altogether in 1989, following the withdrawal of a pool of 16.5 tonne opens based in the Peak District. 
 Almost half of the serviceable BR-owned wagon fleet in 1989 comprised &bquo;merry-go-round&equo; coal hoppers, with the remainder consisting largely of steel carriers, some vans and opens for general merchandise traffic,  and &mdash; rather surprisingly and after much argument with the industry &mdash; the fleet of china clay carriers built to replace the venerable &bquo;clay hoods&equo; in 1988. 
 Towards the end of the 1980s attention was being focussed on some interesting developments in wagon design. 
 The MiniLink and MaxiLink container systems, both of which appeared in 1987, incorporated some novel design features which enabled road-rail transfer without the need for separate lifting equipment. 
 An even more exciting development was TrailerTrain, comprising a specially profiled road trailer which could be loaded on to railway bogies, again without the need for fixed equipment at the transfer location. 
 Finally, one of the best kept secrets of the decade until its unveiling in 1988 was the Redland self-discharge aggregates train, a permanently coupled set of hopper wagons with a conveyor belt running underneath and a special unloading vehicle at one end.     
 Railfreight Petroleum's new image. 
 Refurbished Class 37/7 No 37888  Petrolea passes Stratford with the 09.22 Micheldever&ndash;Ripple Lane empty tank train on 3 November 1988. 
 The high&ndash;capacity wagons would be worked to one of the refineries at Thames Haven. 
 The North Thameside petroleum traffic was among the first to have its own train crew and dedicated fleet of locomotives . 
 Laira&ndash;based Class 37s. 
 No 37672  Freight Transport Association ( in old Railfreight livery) and No 37673 (in two&ndash;tone grey) pass Cockwood Harbour, near Exeter, with the 15.45 St Blazy to Gloucester freight on 17 august 1989 . 
 Old style wagonload marshalling. 
 The down sorting sidings at Tees Yard are pictured from the hump control tower on 12 September 1980, with Class 08 pilot No 08770 in attendance. 
 The yard looks busy, but close examination reveals that very few wagons were carrying traffic. 
 The hump was closed in 1985 and all shunting carried out from the east end. 
 Railfreight's greatest success &mdash; Coal by merry&ndash;go&ndash;round. 
 Class 58 No 58026 approaches Moira West Junction on the freight&ndash;only Burton&ndash;Leicester line, with a rake of empty HAAs from Drakelow power station on 30 October 1986, bound for Bagworth opencast loading point. 
 The importance of the Leicestershire coalfield declined during the 1980s as seams gradually became worked out, but new opencast sites continued to provide useful revenue for BR. 
 Bulk freight in Wensleydale. 
 The twenty&ndash;three&ndash;mile branch line from Northallerton has survived only because of the Tarmac quarry terminal located at Redmire, supplying limestone for use as flux in the steel&ndash;making process. 
 class 47 No 47302 passes Ainderby with the 10.12 up train on 8 August 1896, hauling 900 tonnes of limestone in privately owned PGA wagons. 
 It is common practice nowadays to introduce guard&ndash;operated level crossings on rural freight&ndash;only lines. 
 Foster yeoman's 126 tonne Co&ndash;co Class 59 No 59004  Yeoman challenger passing West Ealing with the 10.05 Acton Yard to Merehead empty stone hoppers on 13 August 1988 . 
 Coal in the valleys. 
 The number of rail&ndash;served collieries in South Wales declined dramatically in the 1980s. 
 Class 37 No 37234 pulls forward through the disused station at Tondu on 15 April 1982, having just run round its train of MDVs carrying coal from Garw to Ogmore. 
 By 1989 the branches from Tondu to Garw and Ogmore had both closed, leaving only Maesteg as a source of traffic in this once thriving part of the Welsh coalfield. 
 No 37109 brings a freight off the Dundee line through platform No 1 at Perth station on 8 September 1987. 
 Pick&ndash;up goods on the Midland main line. 
 Class 25 No 25303 draws to a halt at Finedon Road, Wellingborough, with an up local trip working on 1 July 1981. 
 At this time BR's wagon fleet comprised an awkward mixture of vacuum&ndash;braked and air&ndash;braked vehicles, making the brake van an essential feature of many wagonload services. 
 The train has a vacuum&ndash;braked fitted head, one VVV van and two HTV hoppers, but the air&ndash;braked OBA wagons at the rear are running with their automatic brakes inoperative. 
 No 37011, with Ethel heating unit No 97251, hauls the overnight sleeper from London (Euston) near Torlundy on the last stage of its journey to Fort William. 
 The photograph is dated 24 April 1984 and shows the development of BR stock up o that date in the make&ndash;up of the rake. 
 The leading vehicle is a Mk1 open brake second fitted with a micro buffet area (B1 bogies) followed by Mk2 vehicles, bot early and later air&ndash;conditioned examples carried on B4 bogies, finally two Mk3A sleeping cars built in the early 1980s with BT10 bogies. 
 COACHES 
 AT the beginning of the 1980s passengers experienced great variances of comfort and style on InterCity and cross-country trains mainly according to whether they were travelling in one of the three basic designs that made up most of the fleet, one each from the fifties, sixties and seventies. 
 Features dating from before World War I were still commonly encountered, along with luxury wall-to-wall carpeting even in what today we call standard class. 
 Side corridors and composite vehicles (for example first and standard or first and guard's van) were still common. 
 They were the days when many passengers were afraid to enter a secondclass compartment believing (because of its quality) it must be a first, of a mixture of vacuum and air-braked stock, steam and electric heating, and continual development and changes with the design of bogies. 
 The Mark 2 coaches inaugurated in 1966 had generally set a new standard of comfort with for example better heating and ventilation but there were no Mark 2 catering or sleeping cars. 
 So a familiar sight of the early 1980s was a standard formation of Mark 2 vehicles with an obviously inferior Mark 1 catering vehicle squeezed in. 
 The production of Mark 3 vehicles, at first for the High Speed  Trains, began in 1975, but the proportion of even top-grade express trains composed of them in the early 1980s was stili small. 
 The HSTs were important from several points of view, not least because they marked the beginning of the end of the once strict division between locomotive-hauled and self-propelled stock. 
 The story of the HSTs powerwise does not belong here but from the point of view of passenger comfort we should note that while much was conventional there was also much that was new&hellip; 
 Though not so revolutionary as to require years of testing and modification (and run the risk of ultimate rejection as in the case of the Advanced Passenger Train). 
 The integral construction of bodies, new air-sprung bogies, air conditioning, excellent sound and heat insulation, and a high standard of luxury furnishing and decor for both second and first class, and above ali strength to resist compression and buckling forces in an accident to an extent never seen before, brought a new era to BR coach design and made the HSTs deservedly popular. 
 Even their automatically operated doors at their ends were widely appreciated. 
 A variation known as Mark 3A was produced for locomotive haulage, differing only in having side buffers available when necessary, and centre buck-eye couplers instead of the special couplers on the 125 sets, and electric wiring to suit the different needs of locomotive haulage. 
 The remarkable feature of the Mark 3 is the fact that only one basic bodyshell was produced so that standard-class coaches have exactly the same external dimensions, window spacing and appearance as the first class. 
 There is, though, one large disadvantage that became much discussed in the eighties: standard-class seats do not match the window spacing. 
 For every four windows on a Mark 3 standard-class coach there are four and a h&ndash;f bays of seats, only the end bays matching the windows and succeeding bays being more tightly spaced so that some passengers are seated against a blank wall. 
 But in riding, quietness, and general environment, Mark 3 coaches gliding through the countryside at speed owe little to even a decade ago. 
 Wall-to-wall carpeting, luggage racks running lengthways above the windows, supplemented by space for cases and bags between the seats, provide an uncluttered spaciousness to give a relaxed atmosphere on the longest of journeys. 
 At least that is what it should be like. 
 The upsurge in traffic in the 1980s has alas meant that passengers have often had to stand in the centre aisles, in the lobbies, and around the door vestibules. 
 With floor sensors operating the automatic sliding doors between the end vestibules and the passengers' saloons perpetually energised by standing passengers, travel in an overcrowded Mark 3 coach seems little better than its predecessors. 
 At the upper end of luxury the first-class Mark 3s have much more room with one-plus-two seating, like their earlier Mark 1 and 2 counterparts but all in open saloon accommodation, since the side-corridor coach was deemed to be a thing of the past. 
 Even Mrs Thatcher levelled criticism at the lack of compartment privacy, but the policy against compartments was now firmly established. 
 The 1980s ended very differently from their beginning. 
 For a start, each   of the sectors has its distinctive livery, though much of the old corporate blueand-grey still survived into 1990. 
 InterCity of course has its light and dark grey with a red band under the windows, while Scotrail established its own blue band instead of red. 
 Network South East has its patriotic red, white, and blue bands with grey thrown in for good measure. 
 The PTEs sport their own colour schemes on a variety of multiple units. 
 As for Provincial, if you were visiting an area in which you were not quite sure what to expect, you might find Mark 1 or 2 (the latter air conditioned or otherwise) locomotive-hauled rakes of various lengths and compositions, first-generation multiple units (anything from one to nine cars, riding roughly but still with forward and rear vision), or the latest Sprinters, plain, super or express, many with privately run buffet-trolley service on long cross-country journeys. 
 On the main line, the remorseless reduction in fleet sizes resulted in Mark 3 vehicles steadily being more predominant. 
 But at the end of 1989 Mark 2s were still well in evidence (particularly the air-conditioned types) and Mark 1 coaches will still be found on occasional reliefs or specials as well as some daily Network SouthEast locomotive-hauled services (especially out of Paddington) for some time to come. 
 During the decade new Mark 3 pattern sleeping cars were evolved at long last to replace the Mark ls. 
 They incorporated all the Mark 3 features of air conditioning, insulation and good riding. 
 But they were just at the design stage when early on a July morning in 1978 twelve passengers died in a fire on Mark 1 sleeping cars of the Penzance to Paddington overnight train. 
 As a  result the design was modified to include much greater fire resistance, adding &pound;50,000 per car to the basic cost of &pound;200,000 of the initial design. 
 So far it has not been put to the test in service. 
 But Mark 3 stock in its conventional form has been involved in accidents, and has been found to stand up with little crushing and buckling in potentially horrific situations where in older stock casualties might have been high. 
 Probably the most outstanding demonstration of their strength was in the 100mph Colwich collision in 1986 when despite coaches &mdash; some of them Mark 2s but largely Mark 3s &mdash; being piled on top of each other, or spreadeagled across the track, not a single passenger was killed. 
 Safe as the Mark 3 coaches have been, however, their designers have been responsible for actually causing one or two accidents because straps and fixings holding underfloor equipment were inadequate and worked loose, allowing major items to fall off. 
 The worst case was in July 1989 when an alternator set fell off at around 100mph at Harrow on the main line into Euston and caused a major derailment, fortunately with no more than a few injuries. 
 As the decade concluded the Mark 4 coach arrived (at first on the East Coast newly electrified service to Leeds). 
 A development of the Mark 3, it contains some APT features including a curved narrowing body profile which would allow the body to tilt like the APT but which feature is now unlikely to be used. 
 Like the Mark 3s, the Mark 4s have a lightweight steel body (but there is simpler framing for ease of construction). 
 The bogies are new: the BT4l evolved in Switzerland, to give good riding at the 140mph (225 km/hr) speeds for which these coaches have been designed. 
 From the passenger's viewpoint the first things that are different are the plug-type sliding doors, improved welcoming entrance vestibules and a seating layout with some facing pairs of seats in the standard class at tables for four, with others in twos having a face-to-back arrangement. 
 Like the Mark 3s with an identical window spacing for standard- and first-class coaches this gets over much, but not all, of the criticisms of seats alongside blank panels between windows. 
 The doors between end vestibules and saloons are now controlled by push buttons instead of floor sensors, but how do you press the button if both hands are carrying luggage or a tray meal from the buffet? 
 Decor and furnishing are for the 1990s styles, insulation is even better than the Mark 3s and passengers with special needs are catered for as, for example, mother and baby facilities and disabled toilets. 
 The first-class saloon is visually broken in two, less tube-like, the gangway's position changing half way through. 
 Plans evolved for new trains for the 1990s Channel Tunnel workings between British provincial centres and Paris, Brussels, and beyond being formed into eighteen coach trains with a power car at each end like an extended electric version of the InterCity 125 diesels, but with the capability to split into nine-coach trains push-pull style with a single power car, perhaps they are all things to all men. 
 Maybe the purely locomotive-hauled coach could be obsolete or at least an enthusiast's treasure by the end of the nineties.     
 Mk2a open second No E5259 as built at Derby in 1967. 
 The Mk2As featured integral construction and were fitted with air brake and dual heating facilities (steam now isolated). 
 The internal layout is similar to the Mk1 with two lavatories at the same end of the vehicle. 
 Mk3A (loco hauled) tourist open second No M1 2004 carried on BT10 bogies. 
 This coach received Provincial ScotRail livery during the 1980s and worked in Push&ndash;pull rakes from Edinburgh Craigentinny depot. 
 The standard Mk3 open second as built with tables for four apart from the twin face&ndash;to&ndash;back seats at the centre partition. 
 Because the second&ndash;class coaches use a common bodyshell with first&ndash;class coaches, seats do not always align with the windows. 
 Delivery of the Mk4s from Metro&ndash;Cammell commenced in 1989. 
 Initially for the East Coast route they include disabled and mother&ndash;and&ndash;baby facilities. 
 Marginally longer than the Mk3s at 23m over the body, the bodysides incline inwards slightly to allow for tilting on curves, a feature not fitted, but noticeable in this view of a standard&ndash;class interior. 
 CLOSURES AND OPENINGS 
 SUCH has been the scale of reopenings (not to mention survivals) of lines and stations in the 1980s that to put matters in perspective it is necessary to go back a bit in history. 
 Closures of railway lines had been taking place for many years, accelerated by the growing availability of cars in the 1950s. 
 The upsurgence of the motor car was forcibly rammed home when the cross-country holiday route, the Midland &amp; Great Northern Joint line from Peterborough across Norfolk to Great Yarmouth Beach station was shut on 28 February 1959. 
 Dr Beeching's famous report of January 1963 then opened the floodgates  to closure proposals, battles by campaigners and, invariably, consent by the Conservative Government which, after all, was the architect behind Dr Beeching's appointment as Chairman charged with reducing losses. 
 Throughout the 1960s and 1970s, line after line closed. 
 Many were main or arterial routes. 
 Some were duplicated by other routes, a legacy of the pre-Grouping days (1923) when companies competed for business. 
 (If ever there was a lesson to be learnt in today's world, competition definitely did not work!) 
 Giants like the Great Central Railway &mdash; in latter days known by its despairing appreciators as the Gone Completely Railway &mdash; and the Leeds Northern main line north of Harrogate, through Ripon, were two such casualties. 
 Scores of branch lines closed despite the economies of diesel traction. 
 Even the introduction of four-wheeled railbuses in the early 1960s failed to stem the closures. 
 By the time 1970 dawned, the closures were beginning to slow down. 
 Public opinion was becoming more concentrated. 
 Closure battles were more embittered and MPs had to take notice. 
 Closures had practically ceased by 1980 but a far greater force had by then begun to take effect. 
 The formation of the Metropolitan County Councils and their respective Passenger Transport Authorities would begin to have a far reaching effect on the future of many lines and stations. 
 With a background of socialism, these PTAs were not averse to spending public money on promoting public transport. 
 Rail began to benefit. 
 At first, it appeared an anachronism for BR to go to a council and say, &bquo;please give us some money to build a new station&equo; or, &bquo;we need a subsidy to keep this service going&equo;. 
 Many councils were sceptical. 
 Some are to this day. 
 Many took the plunge and the great rail revival had started. 
 The seven PTAs &mdash; Sir Peter Parker called them &bquo;The Magnificent Seven&equo; &mdash; have been the driving force behind scores of new initiatives to improve rail services by building new stations &mdash; often replacing ones closed by Dr Beeching &mdash; restoring passenger services to freight-only lines and, incredibly, in the case of the West Yorkshire PTA actually purchasing their own trains! 
 Yet at the end of the eighties the only government money paid to BR was the rapidly dwindling subsidy paid to Provincial and Network SouthEast sectors to support loss-making services and talk continued of &bquo;bustitution&equo;, however ridiculed it was by professional transport executives. 
 The broader view based on cost benefit analysis (taking all costs and benefits into account) was still unacceptable to a government insisting on an 8 per cent direct investment return. 
 Thus, unless some sympathetic council contributes to a station or reopened line, improvements will not happen. 
 The classic example of the inequality faced by BR was at Dornoch on the line between Inverness and Wick/Thurso. 
 The new road bridge spanning the Dornoch Firth was suggested as having a dual role &mdash; carrying both road and rail, the rail section to be a new piece of line which would cut out a long detour and dramatically reduce the journey time to the Far North. 
 The cost of the rail link was a paltry &pound;12million and all but three million pounds had been found elsewhere. 
 The Scottish Office  still refused to pay this &pound;3million despite the astronomic sums spent on the parallel A9 road. 
 One area which saw a great revival in rail fortunes is South Wales where local and county councils invested public money &mdash; and reaped the rewards. 
 At the end of 1988, BR's Provincial sector announced that the Valley Lines had doubled their revenue in five years, the only Provincial services to do so! 
 The ultimate achievement, notwithstanding the numerous new stations opened in the area during the last five years, was the reopening to passenger traffic of the Cynon Valley line to Aberdare (closed in March 1964) with no less than eight new stations. 
 The new service started on 3 October 1988 and was immediately so successful that Mid Glamorgan County Council applied to the Secretary of State for Wales for a &pound;600,000 grant to purchase a Sprinter unit to provide an hourly service. 
 The grant was blocked. 
 BR itself came to the rescue and offered to provide an additional DMU, albeit a first-generation unit, to provide a better service. 
 Even in South Wales, it is not ali enlightenment since while Mid and South Glamorgan are positively pro-rail neighbouring Gwent turns its back on rail projects, preferring to invest in roads. 
 Indeed the overall score of the 1980s has been very uneven. 
 For example, the early years of the decade saw numerous freight-only branches close  because in most cases only a handful of wagonload traffic was being conveyed &mdash; uneconomically. 
 The Lancashire branch to Rawtenstall closed on 4 December 1980, with the Wallingford branch from Cholsey following on 31 May 1981. 
 The same month saw the end of the Brechin line while in 1982 the Forfar service ceased in June. 
 A major closure took place on 27 November 1982 when the GN&amp;GE Joint line closed between March and Spalding, together with the avoiding lines at Sleaford and Lincoln. 
 Residual traffic was routed via Peterborough and this closure reflected the vastly changing freight scene as vacuum-braked freights gave way to air-braked company or block trains, precluding the necessity to marshal en route. 
 Much of the huge yard at Whitemoor, March, closed. 
 1983 witnessed the last rites on perhaps the most famous freight line in the country &mdash; to Consett. 
 The cessation of the steel plants sealed the fate of the line on which herculean battles took place daily in the haulage of loads of iron ore imported at Tyne Dock up the ferocious gradients to Consett. 
 Another historical line saw its last BR train on 26 September 1983 when the Cornish Wenford Bridge line was officially closed, its latter role being entirely devoted to the china clay traffic. 
 Meanwhile, on the passenger front, the four-mile Sanderstead-Elmers End line witnessed funereal acts on 13 May 1983. 
 Another Southern Region service  axed was that between Tunbridge Wells Central and Eridge which finished on 6 July 1985. 
 One day earlier, the Stratford to Tottenham Hale service in the east end of London bade farewell to passengers. 
 One closure &mdash; the Clayton West branch service which ran from Huddersfield &mdash; finally succumbed on 22 January 1983, because the West Yorkshire PTA declined to provide the subsidy. 
 A similar casualty was the Kilmacolm branch which ended on 8 January 1983, because the Strathclyde PTA would support it no longer. 
 The irony is that within five years, investigations started with a view to relaying part of the canal route to Kilmacolm as far as Paisley for a new passenger service! 
 Building on the trackbed precludes a new service from serving the whole of the former route. 
 1983 witnessed the opening on 16 May of the first stretch of new main line built for over half a century &mdash; the 23.5km Selby Diversion line, replacing the former main line via Selby which closed completely between York Chaloner's Whin Junction and Selby North Junction. 
 Since the introduction of the business sectors of BR, Railfreight has not been slow to totally eliminate certain freight-only routes where an alternative existed, albeit, invariably longer. 
 The Walsall-Lichfield, Manchester South Loop line and the Skelton-Arpley lines are cases in point. 
 With the drastic decline in the coalmining industry, numerous branches to mines have closed, some of them quite lengthy, such as the Cynheidre and Maerdy branches in South Wales. 
 Two 1989 closures were the Oakamoor and Caldon Low branches in the Stoke area which yielded their sand and stone traffic to road competition. 
 However, even in the world of freight, revival is taking place. 
 The Annbank-Mauchline line which closed in 1984 was never lifted but merely mothballed. 
 This prudent act paid off, for it reopened in 1988 to provide a shorter route for the coal traffic from Knockshinnoch to Ayr. 
 Likewise, the Mickle Trafford to Dee Marsh line reopened for business on 1 September 1986. 
 It originally closed to freight traffic on 14 May 1984. 
 One worrying aspect concerning the reopening of freight lines to passengers is that invariably where such revivals have taken place, BR has badly underestimated the level of business. 
 The line to Bathgate, reopened to passengers on 24 March 1986 (including two new stations at Uphall and Livingston) at a cost of &pound;1.5million shared by six public bodies expected to see a top figure of 400,000 passengers annually. 
 This figure was rapidly exceeded and by 1989 was carrying one million passengers annually, necessitating lengthening platforms at several stations along its route at a cost of &pound;60,000. 
 Worthy of mention in this review of closures and revivals is the widely applauded reprieve by Chris Green, director of Network SouthEast, of London's Marylebone station on 30 April 1986. 
 BR had proposed closure of this famous station, but the growth of the commuter traffic meant that London Underground would not be able to cope. 
 This station and line is now the subject of a multi-million pound investment scheme. 
 Mr Green was also behind the move to relay the track on the abandoned freight-only link  between Blackfriars and Faringdon, thereby linking the electric systems north and south of the Thames. 
 The new &bquo;Thameslink&equo; service started in May, 1987 and presently carries 20,000 passengers daily. 
 One famous London station did close. 
 We gave our regards to Broad Street on 27 June 1986 when the last train pulled out, the site required for redevelopment. 
 The 1980s cause c&eacute;l&egrave;bre was of course the battle of the Settle &amp; Carlisle. 
 If ever there was proof needed that public opinion works, this is it. 
 This famous line's deliberate run-down, closure proposals (three in total), the unbelievable fight by the public, culminating in 35,000 objectors during the five-year fight, was an object lesson to BR and the government. 
 It was the latter who, unable to find a private buyer, announced on 11 April 1989 that BR must continue to operate the 72 mile route, a triumph for the three coordinating bodies &mdash; Transport 2000, The Settle &amp; Carlisle Action Committee and the Friends of the Settle &amp; Carlisle. 
 This mammoth battle vividly demonstrated how inextricably railways are tied to politics. 
 The reprieve of the S&amp;C, besides marking the rightful conclusion to a tale of deceit and neglect, was also the first closure proposal vetoed by the Conservative Government under Mrs Thatcher. 
 The ever-changing railway saw several large marshalling yards close. 
 Severn Tunnel yard went in October 1987, and Margam Hump yard closed on 31 October 1988, being replaced by the new 18 road Knuckle yard to cater for the huge growth in steel business, most of which travels in block trams. 
 It was the same story which brought about the downfall of another huge yard &mdash; Tyne &mdash; in October 1989. 
 The virtual cessation of the local trip workings, coupled with the growth in company trains (affecting the payloads of Speedlink services) meant that the reduction of actual Speedlink services could not justify the retention of a separate yard at Tyne (opened in 1961) &mdash; much of which handled Railfreight's Metals sub-sector business. 
 Thus the healthy growth of a particular commodity &mdash; in this case steel &mdash; actually caused a closure. 
 The passenger scenario is more interesting. 
 There seems to be no let-up with the continuing rise in patronage, even in the Network SouthEast area where the August 1989 approval to spend &pound;257million on Networker units will inevitably attract more passengers when they are introduced. 
 On the passenger side, interest in the 1990s will centre on Provincial's split between the highly successful Sprinter Express routes and the also-rans. 
 How do you privatise a business of numerous loss-makers? 
 With the roadorientated Department of Transport constantly pressurising British Rail to examine all its options on loss-making services, the spectre of &bquo;bustitution&equo; is never far away. 
 A test case was the proposed closure of the Gainsborough Central-Wrawby Junction, Barnetby, section of line used by Sheffield-Cleethorpes trains. 
 The separate announcement by BR in 1989 that it was proposing closure of the Doncaster-Gainsborough line was a surprise for there are many lines which lose more money than this with its nine daily trains. 
 No sooner   had the announcement been made than it was withdrawn, pending deliberations by Lincolnshire County Council as to whether subsidisation could be considered as a way of continuance. 
 Some sceptics have been quick to see that this could well be a familiar pointer to the future &mdash; suggest a service for closure in the hope that the relevant council will come up with the money to reprieve it. 
 This transfers the onus from government subsidy to the local people who, should the council refuse, will themselves be &bquo;blamed&equo; for the service closure. 
 In total one can only marvel at the numerous stations opened in the 1980s and it is pleasing to note that many more are in the pipeline. 
 The growth of BR stations in recent years is heartwarming for pro-rail supporters and the figures speak for themselves, 1986 = 2,526, 1987 = 2,530, 1988 = 2,554, 1989 = 2,561. 
 A list of specific openings follows. 
 Some ironically have been brought about by road congestion caused by the railway's erstwhile competitor, the private car. 
 Many of the reopenings were under the &bquo;Speller&equo; rule: Tony Speller's 1981 Bill made it possible for services to reopen experimentally without the need to go through the formal closure procedures in the event of failure. 
 Some were the direct result of campaigning by the Railway Development Society and the list is almost a tribute to it. 
 It should be added that though this book is about BR, the 1980s also saw the opening of the last section of the Tyne &amp; Wear Metro in March 1984 and the launch of the stillexpanding Docklands Light Railway in July 1987. 
 Both produced passenger levels far greater than forecast and have encouraged more planning of urban light railways.     
 Closure and Opening. 
 Six&ndash;car Metro&ndash;Cammell dmu arrives at South Shields with a service from Newcastle in April 190. 
 The statio was closed to BR trains when it became part of Tyne &amp; Wear Metro system. 
 the 8.00 Blackpool North&ndash;Euston train passes Milton Keynes Central station at speed on 6 October 1984 powered by Class 87/0 No 87010  King Arthur. 
 Hardly looking like a suburban station in the densely populated Croydon area of south London is Coombe road which closed at the end of the 1982/3 timetable with the ending of services on the Elmers End&ndash;Sanderstead line. 
 2&ndash;Epb unit No 5723 halts at the station while working the 17.30 Elmers End to Sanderstead on 15 april 1983. 
 Cardiff Cathays. 
 One of the many new stations opened with the help of local government finance. 
 This view, taken during the first month of operation, shows three&ndash;car unit No C312 entering the station working the 11.35 (sundays) Treherbert to Barry service on 30 October 1983. 
 Deltic No 55003  Meld leaves the now closed and lifted section of the East Coast main line via Selby at Chaloners Whin Junction while working the 14.05 King's Cross&ndash;york on 18 my 1980. 
 The diversion opened in 1983 . 
 the line between Eridge and Tunbridge Wells Central closed in July 1985. 
 Here a month before closure Class 207 dmu No 1306 leaves Eridge with the 14.35 from Uckfield, to Victoria, to be followed by unit No 1310 (in platform 1 on the right) forming the 14.59 to tonbridge via Tunbridge Wells. 
 A REVOLUTION IN MOTIVE POWER 
 BR's motive-power policy was rapidly turned on its head with the abandonment of two sacred principles: sectorisation saw the end of the common-user policy for locomotives and passenger multiple units: and no longer was it accepted that life-expired main-line cast-offs should spend their last days propping up secondary services. 
 The locomotive fleet may have become slimmer and generally older, but it still ended the decade in better overall shape thanks to this revised policy; new maintenance procedures, and heavy expenditure on refurbishment of key types, also helped. 
 The multiple-unit fleet was transformed virtually beyond recognition. 
 It was goodbye to the last vestiges of pre-war LMS and LNER designs, and even the slam-door concept that the Southern Railway bequeathed to its nationalised successor was displaced from many important commuter routes. 
 To the enthusiast, the loss of no less than fourteen locomotive designs was countered by the application of highly distinctive sector liveries, all the more interesting because of the number of attempts made before the final choices were made. 
 The apparent &bquo;if it moves, renumber it&equo; policy was also a major source of interest. 
 InterCity saw its future in push-pull electric traction, modernised High Speed Trains on non-electrified routes, and only a handful of diesellocomotive-hauled services on feeder and cross-country routes. 
 Provincial resisted InterCity's relatively modern but redundant 1960s coaching stock, and nailed its colours firmly to the mast of the Sprinter DMU. 
 The two-car diesel unit provided ultimate flexibility and low operating costs, plus the chance to attract new business with smart new stock operating on faster schedules. 
 The government accepted the argument, and approved the investment. 
 Network SouthEast, struggling to cope with its massive upsurge in business, proceeded with complete refurbishment of serviceable 1960s stock and started massive investment in new trains, notably its Networker. 
 Parcels was happy to operate with a small fleet of locomotives and hauled stock, plus a fleet of 1950s passenger DMUs converted for load carrying. 
 Railfreight is now by far the biggest user of locomotives. 
 The restructure of the coal, aggregates, Speedlink, petroleum and metals businesses made it relatively easy to identify and organise separate sub-sector fleets, increasingly recognised by the new grey livery decorated with esoteric fleet symbols and depot badges. 
  Finally, the departmental, engineering side also laid claim to its own clearly defined fleet of engines, which could be profitably loaned to the sectors at times of peak demand. 
 New Classes. 
 New locomotive classes of the eighties were just five, all highpower main liners. 
 After nearly thirty years, the first AC electric Co-Co locomotive arrived in 1986 in the shape of the prototype 5,850hp, 125mph Class 89, built under contract by BREL Crewe with electrical gear by Brush Traction. 
 After trials, it pioneered locomotive-hauled electric trains over the northern extension of East Coast main line electrification to Peterborough in 1988. 
 The Class 89 was notable for its lack of teething troubles, sadly not experienced by the two other new electric designs. 
 The first BREL/GEC Class 90, an updated version of the Class 87 Bo-Bo, emerged from Crewe in mid-1988, but it was many months before the state of the art electronics were mastered. 
 Delivery of the final members of the class was still taking place at the end of the decade, but the early members had by then settled into their routine of West Coast InterCity push-pull passenger duties with similarlooking new driving van trailers at the opposite end, plus freights from the North to the East Coast ports via the newly electrified North London link.  
 However, the new build highlight of the 1980s was undoubtedly the 6,000hp-plus, 140mph Class 91 intended for the full King's Cross-Leeds/ Edinburgh electrification in 1991. 
 GEC supplied the equipment for assembly at BREL Crewe, and although software problems delayed entry into service until the early part of 1989, the prototype batch of ten (another twenty-one are on order) were a regular sight on King's Cross-Peterborough commuter and some Leeds service by the end of the year. 
 The traction combination with an HST power car converted to a driving trailer and only seven HST coaches made mincemeat of conventional timings. 
 The heavy freight diesel replacement policy was a muddle from beginning to end. 
 First, BR curtailed the production line of the obsolete overcomplicated Class 56 Co-Cos in 1984 when the 135th example emerged from BREL Crewe. 
 This overlapped the appearance of the first modular construction Class 58 from Doncaster, mechanically similar but theoretically cheaper to maintain. 
 This so-called new standard machine found itself overtaken by new technology and failed to attract hoped-for export orders, only running to fifty examples. 
 Although they were all allocated to coal traffic in the East Midlands, their arrival coincided with the miners' strike, and in truth BR only tolerated the construction of so many because the components were already on order. 
 General Motors of America believed they had made a major breakthrough into the British market in 1985 when they persuaded Foster Yeoman to buy four specially constructed 3,300hp locomotives to haul heavy stone traffic  from their Merehead quarry to locations in the South East. 
 Rules were relaxed to allow the first privately owned locomotives unlimited access to the national rail network. 
 By now urgently needing at least 100 replacements for its geriatric locomotive fleet, Railfreight initially appeared to show deep interest in its own General Motors stud, but in the event the order went to Brush Traction of Loughborough. 
 The arrival of the first Class 60 Co-Cos in the autumn of 1989 would spell the wholesale demise of many thirty-year-old Class 20s, 31s, 33s and 47s. 
 Farewell. 
 Fourteen locomotive types were eliminated during the 1980s, although examples of all but five have been secured for preservation. 
 The most sadly missed type is undoubtedly the twenty-two English Electric Class 55 Deltics from the East Coast main line. 
 Their 1st runs at the end of 1981 were witnessed by scenes not seen since the end of steam when literally thousands either embarked on farewell trips or crowded platform ends for a last glimpse of the 3,300hp machines that were as popular as the LNER Gresley steam Pacifics they replaced. 
 Displaced by High Speed Trains, much of their final year was remarkably spent on new territory including York-Liverpool runs. 
 No less than six survive in preservation. 
 Almost equal euphoria was attracted by the English Electric Class 40s, the first large-volume design introduced after the 1955 Modernisation Plan. 
 Underpowered, overweight and outdated, the once 200 strong fleet, affectionately known as &bquo;Whistlers&equo; was in decline from the mid-1970s, and when major overhauls ceased at BREL Crewe in 1981 it was only a question of time before they disappeared first from top link Eastern Region duties, and finally in 1985 freight workings originating from the North West. 
 BR's own acknowledgement of the Class 40s' popularity, and therefore revenue potential, was the renovation of the 1958 pioneer locomotive D200 to working order, and original livery, for use on special trains for a full three years after the rest of the class had been retired. 
 It is now in the National Railway Museum, and another five were purchased privately. 
 Less fuss was created by the no less significant demise of two important products from the Derby Locomotive Works. 
 The &bquo;Peaks&equo; once numbered 193 of three similar types with twelve-cylinder Sulzer power units in heavy bodyshell on four-axle plate-frame bogies. 
 Withdrawal of the prototype Class 44 series of ten was completed in 1981, and a start was then made on the production Class 45 and 46 fleets. 
 Displaced first from the North East/South West corridor and East Coast services, they had largely disappeared from their traditional Midland main line haunts by the mid-1980s, and the arrival of Class 156 Sprinter DMUs displaced the last survivors from Trans-Pennine workings in the summer of 1988. 
 Although a handful have been preserved, BR's attempt to emulate the success of the D200 project was short-lived when the selected example suffered a terminal breakdown. 
 It is hard to imagine that there were once almost 600 Sulzer-engined Bo-Bo locomotives in the 1,160&ndash;1,250hp range, because a mere thirty-two  survived at the end of 1989. 
 The entire BR fleet of Classes 24 and 25 had gone by the beginning of 1978. 
 The Birmingham RC&amp;W-built Class 27s disappeared soon afterwards (despite expensive overhauls only months before), leaving only the 1958/9 Birmingham-built Class 26 surviving on specialist duties in Southern Scotland. 
 The closure of the Manchester-Sheffield/Wath 1,500V DC freight route via Woodhead tunnel in 1982 spelt the inevitable end of the LNER-design Class 76 Bo-Bos, which although far from life-expired could not work anywhere else. 
 The London Midland Region also gave up with its older AC electric locomotives, first its troublesome contractor-built Classes 82, 83 and 84, and then with new designs coming along, Classes 81 and 85 were into their last days. 
 Almost unnoticed was the exit of the last 0-4-0 locomotive, latterly represented by the 204hp Andrew Barclay Class 06 dock shunter in Scotland (and departmental service in England), and the three curious Class 13 700hp hump shunters formed of two Class 08s in permanent formations. 
 Modifications. 
 Large-scale modifications were made to the BR locomotive fleet to both keep them running, and create a stop-gap before the arrival of new motive power for both passenger and freight use. 
 Two long-running conversion programmes reached their conclusion at last. 
 Barring a handful for specialist duties, every locomotive was equipped with air brakes. 
 This involved a massive conversion programme on Classes 08, 20, 26, 27, 31 and 37, often outside normal overhaul schedules. 
 Steam-heated hauled stock was also eradicated, and the response was the reclassification of more Class 31/4s and 47/4s, plus the first Class 37/4s. 
 Longer-term planning forced BR to embark upon life-extension programmes for several locomotive types expected to be needed until well into the 1990s, although they were halted in 1989 before being completed. 
 English Electric Class 37s in particular were subjected to near-total rebuilds, involving replacement of the main generator with an alternator, regeared CP7 bogies, and in some cases Ruston or Mirrlees power unit, electric-heat generator, or ballast weights added to provide extra adhesion for particular freight work. 
 Thus, one standard locomotive design evolved into six specialist types. 
 Many Brush-built Class 31s were equipped with ETH generators and given a major body overhaul, while some Class 47s were similarly treated. 
 The Class 50 refurbishment programme was completed, although they are destined for a short life, while limited work was also carried out on Class 20s, 26s and 33s to see them through to the arrival of new designs. 
 On reflection, costly mistakes were made with both the Class 27s and 45s, whose short careers could not possibly have justified the lavish life-extension work carried out on them. 
 High Speed Trains. 
 The eight-year High Speed Train power car production line came to an end at BREL Crewe works in August 1982 with the delivery  of the 198th and final example, although strengthening of the fixed coach rakes meant the final augmentation trailer did not appear until the spring of 1985. 
 Healthy business, and integration of the Midland main line into the HST network, saw most of the fixed rakes expanded to eight vehicles. 
 Opponents of the two locomotives for each train concept were vindicated by a series of stress defects and overheating of the Paxman Valenta 2,250hp power units, and it was agreed to re-engine four Western Region examples with Mirrlees units. 
 (It is the long-term plan to re-engine 140 more.) 
 Trailer-wise, complaints from guards about excessive noise in the guard's compartment at the rear of the power car saw an order for 101 second-class trailers hurriedly modified to include a small compartment for them. 
 Pullman units were created for prestige services to Newcastle, Leeds, Sheffield, Cardiff and the West of England, while most other trailer kitchen firsts (TKFs) were converted to hauled stock. 
 The original concept of separate kitchen/restaurants and buffets for HSTs was too ambitious given shorter journey times and changing eating habits. 
 Mid-life refurbishment with new first- and second-class seating has justifiably continued the HST's popularity. 
 Externally, the repainting from blue and grey to the new InterCity house style was practically complete as  1989 drew to a close. 
 As for embellishments, the people organising naming ceremonies seemed to be outnumbered by other policymakers whose desire was to see them progressively removed. 
 No one was really sure why. 
 Diesel Units. 
 The Sprinter DMU was one of BR's greatest success stories of the 1980s &mdash; though there were severe setbacks from late deliveries, unreliability of one design, and a near-disastrous flirtation with cheap-to-build railbuses. 
 The decision to press ahead with new builds on a large scale was based on Provincial's conviction that it could reduce its losses if given the freedom to operate cost-effective diesel-mechanical rolling stock, allowing shorter but more frequent trains, than having to take on InterCity's weary cast-off locos and hauled stock. 
 Added to that was the desire to eradicate all vehicles with asbestos insulation by 1988, a target not in fact achieved. 
 The truism that you get what you pay for was ably demonstrated by the decision in 1981 to replace ageing first-generation DMU fleets on non-  electrified outer suburban lines and remote branches with low-cost bus-type bodies on four-wheeled underframes. 
 The prototype Leyland two-car Class 140 unit appeared in 1981, and other fleets quickly appeared from Leyland, BREL and Andrew Barclay as Classes 141, 142, 143 and 144. 
 By 1987, the honeymoon was over. 
 Large numbers were laid up with a multiplicity of gearbox, transmission, body and wheelset problems. 
 Old-generation units were patched up even further beyond their expected life span. 
 In one curious case, Cornish services inherited the units delivered there thirty years previously! 
 The Sprinter DMUs, conventionally engineered units built by BREL, Leyland and Metro-Cammell, Classes 150, 151, 154, 155, 156 and 158, were considerably more successful and by the end of the decade in charge of the mainstay of Provincial services literally from Wick to Penzance. 
 Although the first units were somewhat spartan, the later builds were well equipped and responsible for a sizeable upturn in passenger business on some routes. 
 Again, there was a slight hiccup when the entire Leyland Class 155 fleet were  withdrawn for almost a year with door troubles; they opened while the train was running. 
 It was goodbye therefore, albeit slower than planned, to large numbers of vintage units. 
 The asbestos-contaminated Cravens Class 105s, Gloucester Class 100s and Park Royal Class 103s were completely wiped out, while the advancing army of Sprinters began to make heavy inroads into the enormous numbers of Metro-Cammell and BR-built units. 
 The Southern Region's small domestic fleet of diesel-electric units was trimmed back thanks to the completion of the Tonbridge-Hastings and East Grinstead electrification. 
 By the end of the decade, new electrification projects meant the writing was on the wall for the surviving English Electric-engined Class 205 and 207 units. 
 AC Electric Units. 
 Commuting became fashionable again in the 1980s, and BR responded with new suburban electrification schemes, over a thousand new electric passenger vehicles and (when replacement finance was not available) 1950s units given the asbestos-removal treatment and a mid-life facelift. 
 By contrast to the erratic and often wasteful locomotive policy, BR seemed determined to extract maximum mileage out of its EMU fleet, sometimes moving entire fleets from one line to another. 
 Standardisation has reached such a level that there are now only five main types of AC unit, the pre-1960 Southern Region-inspired slam-door units (Classes 302&ndash;8), express (Class  309), modern slam-door (Classes 310/312), Scotland/Manchester suburban sliding door (Classes 303/31 1), inner suburban sliding door (Classes 313&ndash;315), and modern outer-suburban based on the Mark 3 coach bodyshell (Classes 317&ndash;21). 
 Only one class of AC unit, the pre-war design LNER Class 306 disappeared completely. 
 Network SouthEast provided its four showpiece routes north of London with new rolling stock, Bedford-St Pancras, King's Cross-Cambridge/ Peterborough, Liverpool Street-Cambridge, and Euston-Northampton. 
 First was the newly energised Bedford-St Pancras route which was the first home of forty-eight four-car Class 317s. 
 They entered traffic in 1982 after a series of teething troubles, and union resistance to one-man operation. 
 Their stay was brief however. 
 The integration of the Bed-Pan service with Thameslink operation from 1988 onwards, allowed dual voltage use of the similar, brand-new Class 319 units, dispatch of the 317s to the Great Northern and London Midland, and closure of the recently modernised Cricklewood maintenance depot into the bargain. 
 King's Cross-Cambridge/Peterborough outer suburban services, a bodged combination of electric units to Hitchin and Royston, and DMUs and HSTs over the non-electric gap, was brought together at the end of the decade, courtesy of two collections of four-car 317s, a purpose-built second batch of twenty-five units, and thirteen of the earlier series. 
 Class 313s continued to look after the inner suburban system, and the now non-standard 1977-series Class 312s were packed off to the Colchester line. 
 As GN business continued to grow, the solution was simply to obtain more slightly soiled Class 317s from somewhere or other. 
 Cambridge-line passengers, celebrating the establishment of an electric link to Bishop's Stortford and Liverpool Street, felt short-changed when the only trains BR could offer were facelifted 1960 built Class 305 slam-door stock, actually older than the hauled stock it replaced. 
 After a brief spell with ex-GN Class 312s, relief came in 1988 with brand-new Class 321s, sporting a smart exterior, but in truth little more than a Class 319 Thameslink unit without the end gangway connection. 
 Apart from seeing the replacement of LNER-design inner-suburban Class 306s, Colchester, Southend, Bishop's Stortford, Hertford and Chingford-line travellers will have to wait until the 1990s for their new stock. 
 In the meantime, most of the original Classes 302, 304, 305, 307, 308 have been turned into open saloons and given new seating and gangways. 
 The gap left by the withdrawal of the worst examples has been filled with Class 312s, and ex-London Midland 310s. 
 Now almost thirty years old, and arguably BR's best-ever buys, the Mark 1 based Class 309 &bquo;Clacton&equo; units, continued their relentless treks across the Essex countryside, now with new seating, a new livery, and with the extension of wires to Ipswich and Norwich, the chance to break out of their traditional operational straitjacket. 
 Euston-Northampton services, now recognised in their own right, jumped the queue in 1989 to receive new Class 321s with first-class facility. 
 It also       became clear that the 319/321 design would be built for some time yet. 
 Scotland's only new acquisitions during the decade were twenty-one Class 318s, three-car versions of the Class 317, to service the newly electrified Glasgow-Ayr/Largs routes, although 1989 also witnessed the first withdrawals proper (apart from accident victims or asbestos units) of the original Pressed Steel 1959 &bquo;Blue Train' Class 303s, whose unrefurbished examples are due for early replacement by 100mph Class 321-type Class 320s. 
 Greater Manchester, unable to finance its own units, was content to take up twelve redundant ex-Scottish Class 303s, at the same time reducing its fleet of equally geriatric slam-door Class 304s from four to three cars. 
 DC electric units. 
 Apart from an influx of long-awaited sliding-door stock for inner suburban units and a small batch of unpopular Weymouth-Waterloo stocks, the headlines for the Southern Region's vast DC electric fleet were disappointingly dull. 
 It was a long tale of low-cost facelifts, make do and mend, and cover up the cracks in a coat of Network SouthEast red, white and blue paint. 
 This was no more evident than on the Isle of Wight at the end of 1989, which seemed to be going backwards despite getting new stock. 
 The replacement units, renovated life-expired 1938 ex-Underground vehicles, were fifty-one years old to begin with. 
 It replaced 1923 stock, which was incidentally only forty-four years old at the time it was moved to the island! 
 South London commuters who have travelled practically all their working lives on dreary Bulleid-influenced 4-SUB and EPB units would have celebrated the arrival from York in 1981 of the first Class 455 four-car units, which, in three batches, eventually ran to 137. 
 Elsewhere, it was very much the same. 
 Eastleigh and Horwich shared a rebuilding programme for ninety-seven four-car units of 195 1 EPB stock, and two-car units followed before the scheme was halted in the face of more orders for new stock. 
 Kent Coast travellers saw their Mark 1 based Class 41 1 4-CEPS taken to BREL Swindon (the last major coach contract before the works closed) for a thorough facelift that also included new windows and double glazing. 
 The similar Class 421 4-CIGS, and unpopular Class 423 4-VEPS were also processed, but at lower cost. 
 Apart from the 4-SUBS, traffic levels meant there was little chance for stock to fall out of the bottom of the cascade. 
 This was reserved for those with asbestos, including most of the two-car express-geared but still unpleasantly cramped 4-HAPS. 
 The extension of electrification from Bournemouth to Weymouth, completed in 1988, saw the arrival of the new streamlined 100mph Class W2, fivecar buffet units with power-operated sliding doors, air conditioning, and the return of compartments for first-class travellers. 
 The traditional Southernwaste not, want not policy was perpetuated in the reuse of traction equipment from the Class 432 4-REPS they replaced. 
 InterCity's dedicated Victoria-Gatwick Express push-pull service launched in 1984 made little difference to domestic services, employing ex-LMR Mark 2f coaches formed into trailer sets with a 1959-type 2-HAP driving trailer  converted to a driving van at one end, and a Class 73 locomotive at the other. 
 More thorough stock control completed the changed Southern scene as virtually all EMU units were renumbered to allow the first two digits to match their fleet status. 
 The London Midland Region, the only operator of wholly DC units, cut its varieties to just three. 
 Conversion of the Manchester-Hadfield stub of the old Woodhead route from 1,500V DC operation to standard 25kV kissed goodbye to the eight 1954 Class 506s, ninety-two of which were used on Great Eastern services until 1982. 
 LMS influence disappeared from Merseyside's Southport and Wirral electric routes with the demise of the pre-war three-car sliding-door stock of Classes 502 and 503. 
 In their place came standard aluminium-bodied BR units, Class 507s brand new, and Class 508s second hand from the Southern. 
 In decline almost since they were built, the North London line's BR-design Class 501s peacefully passed into oblivion, replaced by Class 313 dual-voltage units borrowed from the Great Northern. 
 So, very little pre-nationalisation influence is left on our increasingly standardised system. 
 For the enthusiast there are two tiny pockets worth exploring however&hellip; 
 London's Waterloo &amp; City tube line, where the 1940 vintage cars sport NSE livery on the outside and Southern Railway ventilator grilles on the inside, and the individualistic Manchester-Bury line, where Lancashire &amp; Yorkshire influence still shines through with battered 1959 BR stock rattling up and down the short, but unique 1,200V DC side contact third rail complete with semaphore signals. 
 But not for much longer.      
 The 09.02 for Liverpool Lime Street leaves Euston on 10 July 1989 powered by Class 90 No 9000  Royal Show. 
 O the left, Class 87/0 No 87010  King Arthur awaits departure time with the 09.45 to Carlisle. 
 It is interesting to note that bullhead rail is still in evidence some forty years after the infant British Railways adopted flat-bottom rail as standard . 
 Propelling the 10.10 Leeds-King's Cross Intercity service, Class 91 No 91007 passes under the Wood Green flyover on the approaches to Alexandra park station on 23 September 1989. 
 Romanian-built Brush Class 56 No 56015 at Coalville on 11 June 1989. 
 It carries Railfreight coal sub-sector livery and is allocated to Toton(TO) depot. 
 The bodyshells of Class 60 Nos 60005 and 60006 under construction inside toe Procor Works at Horbury on 25 April 1989. 
 Class 60 No 60002  Capability Brown undergoes trials at Derby RTC on 9 October 1989 . 
 At the close of the decade there were only two examples of the Class 03 diesel mechanical shunter remaining in stock, both on the Isle of Wight. 
 Here No 03073 (since withdrawn) stands at Duke Street in Birkinhead Docks on 23 August 1988. 
 Class 26/0 No 26005, in old Railfreight grey, stands at Eastfield depot on 12 June 1988. 
 At the end of the decade all the remaining members of the class were based here. 
 (Opposite above) Given a new lease of life. 
 Rebuilt English electric Class 37 No 37372, now ETH fitted Class 37/4 No 37 4331  Sir Powys/County of Powys stands at Cardiff with 09.50 Swansea to Portsmouth train, 16 February 1988. 
 The Cardiff Catonbased locomotive was modified in 1986 . 
 (Opposite below) The first of the Class 47s &mdash; or Brush Type 4s as they were known when D1500 appeared in 1962 &mdash; still hard at work rom Gateshead depot in 1987. here No 47401, as it is now numbered and carrying the name  North Eastern which it both received and lost during the 1980s, nears Greenfield on a Trans-Pennine service, the 17.03 Liverpool to Newcastle on 19 June 1987. 
 The train is made up of Mk2a and C stock in Provincial &bquo;Trans-Pennine&equo; colours with Mk1 full brake in blue and grey at the rear . 
 HST. 
 Nos 43119+43065 emerging from Calton Hill Tunnel at the start of the journey with the 09.35 Edinburgh-King's Cross service on Sunday 21 June 1987. 
 The leading power car is in the older Inter-city livery and has its number rather than a set number displayed on the front end. 
 This reflects a change in attitude, the power cars are now seen as separate locomotive units. 
 The visible Mk3 trailers are still in blue and grey. 
 Colourful is perhaps a polite way to describe this BRCW three-car dmu set P460 with 51317 the leading car. 
 It is painted in British Telecom yellow livery with blue lettering. 
 The unit is seen here leaving Plymouth working a shuttle service to Laira depot open day on 7 September 1985. 
 Class 142 Pacer diesel multiple unit No 142073 passes the Midland Railway signalbox at Hellifield South Junction while working the 11.33 Leeds to Morecambe service on 2 April 1988. 
 The signalbox controls the junction with the Blackburn line which diverges on the left of the picture. 
 The station is now an unstaffed halt. 
 The first Class 158 Provincial Express vehicle, No 158701, is unveiled at Derby Railway Technical Centre on 9 October 1989. 
 on delivery from BREL York to Ilford, new class 321 emu No 321334 is reflected in the waters of the River Ouse as it passes Offord Cluney, near Huntingdon, on 31 March 1989. 
 BALLETIC MATERIALS 
 Having been inspired to create a ballet by any one of the sources mentioned, choreographers have to decide upon the appropriate materials with which to work. 
 The most important are music and the type of dancer. 
 Music 
 Music must be chosen that will best give the overall and phrase rhythms to the steps, poses and gestures, that will help to create the atmosphere and mood of the whole and that will underline the action. 
 Alternatively, the choreographer may be inspired by a piece of music and wish to bring it to life in dance (see page 41). 
 There are three types of music from which to choose. 
 Specially commissioned music 
 From the first ballets de cour  until the beginning of the twentieth century music was always specially commissioned. 
 Much of the music played by a pianist for ballet lessons is still borrowed from the dance suites of court, opera and other ballets of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, as well as from other dance suites of Bach, Mozart, Beethoven and Brahms. 
 Most items in these suites were designed to contrast one with another by varied time signatures, tempi and phrasing so that they built up to a climax which, in the early days, signalled the entrance of the king or the most important participant. 
 Each dance followed particular rules laid down by the dancing masters, and this idea continued to prevail even after Gluck began to compose operas and ballets which had greater continuity. 
 His ideas of symphonic development were followed by Beethoven ( Prometheus  1801), Adam ( Giselle  1841), Delibes ( Copp&eacute;lia  1870) and Tchaikovsky. 
 Although the scores of The Sleeping Beauty  and The  Nutcracker  followed Petipa's explicit orders that each item consisted of so many bars of one tempo and time signature and as to what it was supposed to represent, Tchaikovsky did demonstrate how ballet music could be developed symphonically by using the leitmotifs. 
 He showed how music could flow through a scene and not be broken up into short numbers which encouraged the audience to applaud each time. 
 Stravinsky composed the first truly modern score for ballet with The Firebird  (see page 61). 
 He understood that there must be an overall rhythm as well as the phrase rhythms of particular leitmotifs and dances if dancers were to understand and feel properly Fokine's choreographic design. 
 Stravinsky confessed that he borrowed the idea from Tchaikovsky and his own example was followed by later composers of specially commissioned scores.  
 Amongst the most important of these carefully plotted works are: de Falla's The  Three-Cornered Hat  (1919) which originally accompanied a mime play and so fascinated Diaghilev that he commissioned the composer to enlarge it for Massine's ballet (see page 59); Vaughan William's Job, commissioned by Diaghilev, was unused until de Valois created her important &bquo;Masque for Dancing&equo; (1931) (this marked the inaugural performance of what has become The Royal Ballet); Arthur Bliss' Checkmate  (1937) was choreographed by de Valois after both composer and choreographer had worked on the plot; Prokofiev's Romeo and Juliet  was composed with the help of a Shakespearean theatre expert and has been used notably by Lavrovsky, Ashton and MacMillan (see page 26); and Ashton provided a roughly outlined plot for Hans Werner Henze's score for Ondine  (1958). 
 But standing out above all are the scores commissioned from Stravinsky by Balanchine, such as Apollo, Orpheus  and Card Game . 
 During the third phase of his enterprise Diaghilev realised the need to keep up with the tastes of his wealthy audiences always anxious to be in fashion and commissioned works from members of the group known as Les Six. 
 These were Milhaud, Poulenc and Auric whose music greatly influenced many later composers such as William Walton and Constant Lambert, many of their works remain in constant use today as witness MacMillan's moving interpretation of Poulenc's Gloria . 
 When choreographers decide to commission music, they should first give the composer an outline of the plot, roughly suggesting the sequence of the action, the likely entrances and exits for the characters and the dances or brief scenes in which they are involved. 
 Secondly, some description should be given of the characters, their moods, emotions and particular role in each part of the action. 
 Thirdly, it may be valuable to indicate the style or quality of the movements to be used. 
 Fourthly, the choreographer should indicate roughly how long each dance or episode should last. 
 It cannot be repeated too often that a dancer requires less time to make a statement than do words or music. 
 No matter how interesting the music and the dance movements, if the passages are too long the dancer rarely has sufficient stamina to sustain the dance to its proper climax. 
 This happened in Benjamin Britten's The Prince of the Pagodas  and, originally, in the Red Knight's dance in Checkmate  (Arthur Bliss later shortened it, giving it much greater strength and significance). 
 Specially arranged music 
 &bquo;Specially Arranged Music&equo; refers to those scores where a musician, in collaboration with a choreographer, selects from the varied works of a particular composer and weaves them into a viable ballet score. 
 After Diaghilev's death composers seemed reluctant to create what Edwin Evans said they called &bquo;accompaniments to dance&equo;, because they &bquo;preferred to create the new for the sake of being new&equo;. 
 Their efforts certainly often lacked the rhythm and phrasing suitable for interpretation by physical and not mechanical means. 
 It was then that choreographers turned their attention to music already available, very often because financial difficulties prevented any approach being made to a living composer. 
 Since 1933, and the development of recording, there has been an immense range of both well- and little-known music on which to build all kinds of ballet (see page 56). 
 But this will be to no avail if the choreographer is attempting to tell a story and does not have expert advice from musicians of the calibre of Edwin Evans, Constant Lambert   and John Lanchbery. 
 All made valuable scores from existing music for de Valois, Ashton and MacMillan. 
 Not all the results were of the same high quality; nevertheless the music they arranged reinforced the choreographer's design by giving the plot atmosphere, local colour, continuity and flow as well as giving the dancing its rhythmic vitality, emotion and mood. 
 In some cases it also helped to underline the main moments in the action by emphasising gestures for greater strength and expression. 
 In other cases they added humour, most notably in Lanchbery's score for La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e , where several witty slants in the orchestration raise laughter, for example the music for the Cock and the Hens. 
 La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e Ashton's English comic masterpiece The Cock and Hens squawk in their roost (The Royal Ballet) 
 However, music chosen from a composer's total output and specially arranged as a score for a three-act ballet with a story has rarely been completely successful. 
 The composer wrote the song, piano solo, quartet or whatever for a particular purpose and for particular soloists, groups of musicians or an orchestra. 
 He could not anticipate &mdash; that his work would be put to an entirely different use, let alone tell a story. 
 Two contrasting examples of what can happen when music is borrowed are Tomassini's arrangement of Scarlatti's sparkling music for Massine's The Good-Humoured Ladies  and the arrangement of the same composer's music for Cranko's The Taming of the  Shrew  which merely gives overall and rough phrase rhythms as time-keepers for a three-act ballet.  
 On the other hand, Charles Mackerras' wonderful pot-pourri of tunes from the Gilbert and Sullivan operas for Pineapple Poll  displayed how well he has caught not only the humour but also the pathos of The Bum Boat Woman's Story. 
 Choreographers should also study John Lanchbery's sensitive handling of some lesser-known Chopin music for Ashton's A Month in the Country  and his equally successful score for Ashton's film, The Tales of Beatrix Potter . 
 He based the latter on his research into Victorian and Edwardian &bquo;salon&equo; music and showed what can be done by looking into such highways and byways of music when a particular period atmosphere is needed. 
 The same can be said about Constant Lambert's arrangement of Auber's music for Ashton's Les Rendezvous  and Meyerbeer's for Ashton's Les Patineurs . 
 Specially chosen music 
 &bquo;Specially Chosen Music&equo; refers to particular pieces of music that have inspired a choreographer and whose score has been interpreted by the choreographer as it stands, the composer's scheme and continuity unchanged. 
 In 1901, Gorsky was inspired by Glinka's Valse Fantaisie  to create the first abstract ballet. 
 His example was followed by Fokine with Les Sylphides  (music by Chopin) and Le Carnaval  (music by Schumann). 
 It was when Colonel de Basil re-started Diaghilev's Ballets Russes that his major choreographers, Massine, and later, Balanchine, turned their attention to the symphonies, concertos, chamber and other music by composers such as Tchaikovsky (Fifth Symphony for Les Pr&eacute;sages ), Brahms (Fourth Symphony for Choreartium ), Beethoven (Seventh Symphony for Seventh Symphony ), Mozart (music for Mozartiana ) and Bach (Double Violin Concerto for Double Concerto .) 
 Major composers have continued to provide an abundant source of inspiration to more recent choreographers. 
 They have not always been as humble as Balanchine in submitting to the dictates of the score as envisaged by the composer. 
 This can be of particular significance if the chosen music is already combined with words, either sung or spoken. 
 Fine examples of this kind are MacMillan's Song of the Earth  and Ashton's Persephone  and The Wedding Bouquet . 
 In the last example, the words form frivolous comment on the action. 
 But there is no such careful blending of ingredients in Tetley's Dances of Albion  where the singer's words of the traditional &bquo;Lye Wake Dirge&equo; bore no relation to what was being danced on stage. 
 This was offensive to the Scots in the audience as was Tetley's disregard for the purport of the poem by Blake that gave the ballet its title. 
 The music by Benjamin Britten includes some part of the War Requiem which means far more to British audiences than mere decorative patterning. 
 Choreographers have never disdained to use popular music for their everincreasing audiences and they realise that they should reflect popular taste. 
 The score for La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  (1789) reflected the new revolutionary ideas pervading France and contained several folk and popular airs. 
 This example was followed by Gavin Gordon, singer-composer, who borrowed street songs and cries for his score of The Rake's Progress . 
 Audiences today expect choreographers to satisfy current demands. 
 The influence of jazz and Latin American rhythms caught the attention of Les Six, Walton and Lambert and in turn inspired choreographers such as Ashton. 
 He used music by Walton and words by Edith Sitwell for Fa&ccedil;ade . 
 (He was later to commission Richard  Rodney Bennett to provide a score for his Jazz Calendar  based on the old nursery rhyme &bquo;Monday's child&equo;.) 
 Balanchine created a ballet The Seven Deadly Sins  with music by Kurt Weill and words by Berthold Brecht which later inspired MacMillan to stage his version of this parable for the times. 
 Music by Scott Joplin then helped him to create his light-heartedly comic Elite Syncopations . 
 Would-be choreographers have an enormous field from which to seek inspiration. 
 It ranges from the traditional dances of ancient Greece used by David Bintley for his Choros  to the latest pieces of minimal music by John Cage that are used for Robbins' Glass Pieces . 
 Musically inspired ballets 
 Choreographers wishing to interpret music in dance terms are limited in several ways because their choice should not only determine the style of dance used and its phrasing but other factors which are an integral part of the score. 
 Their task is nowhere better summed up than by Ernest Newman, one of the great music critics of his day, who rarely watched ballet until intrigued by the news that Massine was creating ballets to Tchaikovsky's fifth Symphony (Les Pr&eacute;sages , London 1933) and to Brahms' Fourth Symphony ( Choreartium , London 1933). 
 Newman was overwhelmed by the latter and wrote in The Sunday Times:  &bquo;Strictly speaking no art is translatable into another, not even poetry into music. 
 The most we can get is convincing parallelisms between the two and the fact that some parallelisms are much more difficult than others and have hitherto not been attempted is no reason for denying that a choreographic genius like Massine has the right to attempt this. 
 Massine has given a translation into choreographic terms of a hundred musical features of the Symphony. 
 The ballet works itself out consistently as a design, reproducing in the subtlest way the design of the music in the matter of subject, repetitions, balancings, treatment of episodes and so on. 
 In the last resort, the more musical we are and the better we know Brahms, the more pleasure we derive from Choreartium .&equo; 
 Ernest Newman's remarks stress that choreographers creating dance to their own choice of music must study how the composer has structured his score and try to understand what he intended the audience to hear and feel, whether it be played, or played and sung. 
 Choreographers have to create dance movements which make their response to the music visible before the performers can communicate the music. 
 A socalled abstract or dance ballet has to be both thought and felt if the partnership between the often-dead composer and the living interpreters is to make sense. 
 It is perhaps worth recording the remark of an eight-year-old boy on first seeing Ashton's Symphonic Variations  (1947): &bquo;That was lovely, I know all about the music now. 
 The dancers told me.&equo; 
 The remark could only be made because Ashton had given so much thought to how the music could be given shape in dance. 
 There are three aspects which have to be considered in all dance interpretations of music. 
 Firstly, the style used should reflect something of the period and quality of the chosen score; secondly, the dance should reveal something of its technical construction; thirdly, the movements should parallel the composer's treatment and development of the various episodes and the orchestration. 
 Some guidance on how to achieve these aspects of interpretation can be gained by a study of ballets by Ashton, Fokine, MacMillan and others. 
 The examples are not always abstract ballets, because the three aspects described above are applicable to most choreography if music and dance are to be equal partners in a ballet.  
 How Ashton reflects the period and quality of the music 
 A study of five Ashton ballets shows that all are based on classical technique, despite their apparent differences. 
 Each reflects something of the period and quality of the music, the period being of the time when written by the composer or when presented as a ballet and the quality being that inspired in the choreographer by the composer. 
 Symphonic Variations (1947)  
 Sir Neville Cardus, another great music critic writing about the history of music, likened the image of great composers such as Bach, Mozart and Beethoven as, &bquo;Looking at a range of mountains, those names are on the summits then one comes to a plateau &mdash; and there standing out and rising from it is the cathedral of C&eacute;sar Franck.&equo; 
 This statement exactly sums up the quality and feeling of Franck's music. 
 As organist and piano teacher most of it was composed for performance at some ritual, often in church &mdash; it conveys not only the solemnity of the occasion but also the spaciousness of the building and the sound of the organ with its vast range of tonalities. 
 It is without emotion but conveys a sense of reverence for order and serenity. 
 Although Symphonic Variations  was not intended as a ritual, Ashton can be said to have used it as such for six dancers who were practising their art in the spacious simplicity of Sophie Fedorovitch's d&eacute;cor. 
 But it was and is something more. 
 Those first six dancers had come to celebrate the newly awakened school of English classical dance that was establishing itself with the coming of peace. 
 Like Franck's music, Ashton's dance flows onwards in simple lines and phrases, each one is of equal value to the whole, neither pianist, nor orchestra, nor dancers indulge in virtuoso passages which would destroy the solemn serenity of the design. 
  Sc&egrave;nes de Ballet (1945 ) Ashton's Sc&egrave;nes de Ballet  could not be more different from the previous example. 
 Stravinsky was commissioned to provide the score for a New York revue, 1944 (choreography by Anton Dolin). 
 He undoubtedly had in mind the particular patterns and balanced relationship of the various dances (i.e. solos, grands pas, variations , etc.) as laid out in all Petipa ballets and he made the ballerina the focus of all attention. 
 Ashton punctiliously followed the layout. 
 But Stravinsky's music, although classical in form, was far from the tuneful dance idioms of Tchaikovsky, Stravinsky's source of inspiration. 
 Despite strict rhythm and exact phrasing, the music was daringly frivolous in tone and quality because it was meant to entertain a popular audience. 
 In following Stravinsky's guidelines, Ashton found many new, sometimes frivolous, ways of performing class-room steps. 
 The corps de ballet  neglect the turn-out and step forwards sur les pointes , raising the working knee and resting the toe on the calf of the other leg, before moving forwards. 
 They travel forwards instead of en place  in &eacute;chapp&eacute;  relev&eacute;s  after breaking the rule that the arms never cross the centre line of the body and are always (except in arabesque ) rounded. 
 If Ashton's Sc&egrave;nes de Ballet  is compared with Balanchine's Ballet Imperial , it will be seen that Balanchine rarely breaks away from the classical technique as practised in petipa's day when Tchaikovsky wrote the music. 
 Ashton, like Stravinsky, took into account the technical developments which had taken place. 
 Petipa's orders to Tchaikovsky were sacrosanct because the composer knew that if that &bquo;dictator&equo; did not approve the music would have to be changed (as it was for The Nutcracker .) 
 Although studying and admiring Tchaikovsky's methods of composition, Stravinsky felt he could break away from the stereotyped dance forms demanded by nineteenth-century balletmasters, His music was far more economical in melody and orchestral sound but his rhythmic phrasings and marked attention to newer dance forms inspired Ashton to break away from traditional class-room practices. 
 Symphonic Variations Ashton's definition of English classical dance in 1947 (The Royal Ballet) 
 Birthday Offering (1956)  Ashton's third classical ballet Birthday Offering  to music by Glazounov was a celebration of the twenty-fifth birthday of The Royal Ballet and of the seven ballerinas it had now fostered. 
 Ashton resorted to Petipa's way of selecting and phrasing the steps, poses and ports de bras  which would best display the ballerinas' individual qualities. 
 It was a celebration of their talents because, by being confined &mdash; so to speak &mdash; to those steps which they most enjoyed and thus performed best, they positively sparkled. 
 Different dancers have to work hard both technically and as individuals to bring out the particular qualities which Ashton saw in the original performers. 
 Nevertheless, the design comes directly from the traditional vocabulary and, with thought, it can be performed by dancers who possess strong and precise technique and who can enjoy the challenge it sets before them. 
 Monotones I and II (1965)  Erik Satie, like C&eacute;sar franck, was an organist and piano teacher. 
 He composed much liturgical music but he admitted that, in writing his Gymnop&eacute;dies  and Gnossiennes  for the entertainment of his friends, he had been vaguely inspired by the friezes on antique Greek vases. 
 This was the clue upon which Ashton based his fourth classical ballet, Monotones I and II . 
 Each finds a trio of dancers working close together to form    
 Monotones II  Aston's sense of linear design (The Royal Ballet) 
 and re-form beautiful groupings as they weave their patterns over the stage in softly projected shafts of light. 
 There are calm, spaciousness and perfectly balanced pictures within the overall design which from time to time acquire a more athletic quality, particularly in Monotones H  (i.e. two boys and a girl). 
 This forming and re-forming of pictures never loses its serenity. 
 It resembles the pictures of dancers frozen for all time by the potters who made the Greek vases just to display their feats. 
 Ashton's dancers have to weave themselves into and out of such play without losing the flow of both music and movement. 
 Rhapsodie (1982)  Ashton's fifth dance ballet is different again (see also page 54). 
 In it he expressed his own and his dancers' sheer enjoyment of &bquo;just dancing to music which cries out to be danced&equo;. 
 That passionate love of &bquo;music as movement&equo; is what Rachmaninov's Rhapsody on a Theme of Paganini  is all about. 
 To have heard Rachmaninov play hisown or any other Russian music or to listen to his orchestral works is to realise he was a passionate musician, loving his art and giving his all to express the joys and sorrows, the tender and brutal moods and all the emotions to which man is subject. 
 In composing the Rhapsody , Rachmaninov tried to vary the Paganini theme as much as  possible by differentiating the instrumental sections one from another. 
 Whereas Symphonic Variations  flows onwards in simple serenity, Ashton, following Rachmaninov, here uses an enormous variety of steps and constantly changes the choreographic phrasing to reflect the increasing or diminishing sounds and to match the tempi of the melody, in order to give his encha&icirc;nements  light and shade and to indicate the sheer complexity of the orchestration. 
 That he was so successful was not because his dancers were technical experts, but because he made them feel Rachmaninov's passionate love of &bquo;music as movement&equo;. 
 Dance rhythm 
 (see also pages 41 and 68) 
 &bquo;Every dance has its own rhythm.&equo; 
 This is the very first idea to be taken into consideration when a choreographer starts to work with music. 
 He should remember that most ballet music until that of Tchaikovsky was based on the same time signatures, tempi and phrasing as that of fashionable court and, later, social dances i.e. waltzes, polkas, galops, minuets, gavottes, mazurkas and so on. 
 Tchaikovsky was the first to break that mould when he gave the Sapphire Fairy (now one of Florestan's sisters) a solo to a 5/4 time signature. 
 But this was only innovative in so far as classical ballet was concerned as there are many 5/4 Slav folk dances. 
 Ashton makes brilliant use of this in his version of the solo, phrasing the steps so that a jump upwards can last three beats followed by two short steps or two beats followed by a long and then a short step. 
 Taking time in the air makes leaps appear higher and more sustained than is usual. 
 Music should, however, not be used merely as a time-keeper as the above remarks may suggest. 
 Choreographers should understand that counting beats or what is called the measure of the music is not dance rhythm. 
 The time signature is merely a guide to the number of minims, crotchets and quavers there are in a bar. 
 (The first note is usually the longest and marks the beginning.) 
 Dance rhythm means how the varying lengths of notes are grouped together within a phrase. 
 Briefly, it is how the composer, like the author of a sentence or of a line in a poem, groups his &bquo;words&equo; in order of importance so that they make sense. 
 The choreographer can make an overall rhythm fur a long phrase of music and within it shorter phrases. 
 This is well exemplified in Fokine's choreography fur the first Nocturne in Les  Sylphides , where it can be said that the corps de ballet  are marking the overall rhythm lasting sixteen or thirty-two bars, whilst the three soloists represent the shorter rhythmical phrases lasting four to) eight bars. 
 Ashton does something similar in Symphonic Variations  where he makes overall phrase rhythms from pas de burr&eacute;e en  place  accompanied by very distinctive ports de bras . 
 These are marked by three of the dancers whilst another performs a solo to a short phrase. 
 In this case three girls interpret the very rhythmic orchestral accompaniment whilst the male soloist interprets the shorter melodic phrase played by the pianist. 
 In both these examples Fokine and Ashton are following Ivanov's choreography for the beautiful Act II pas de deux  in Swan Lake . 
 In it the corps de ballet  frequently mark the overall rhythmic beat whilst Odette and Siegfried dance to the melody played by solo violin and &bquo;cello. 
 Another equally interesting way of marking the rhythmic beat occurs in Fokine's Carnaval  when Columbine dances to the semi-quavers and Harlequin to the quavers as they enter side by side. 
 A further study of Les Sylphides  reveals Fokine's great understanding of the dance  rhythms which he felt he had to make visible whenever he was using well-recognised dance forms. 
 For example, in the solo waltz the dancer marks the three beats of a waltz in roughly every other bar, usually with her feet, but in the third musical phrase she poses in arabesque  and marks the beat by gradually lowering her hand three times. 
 The accent throughout the dance is lightly marked on the first beat. 
 However, in the two mazurkas, Fokine expected the dancers slightly to accent the second beat of each bar as in any traditional mazurka or polonaise. 
 This is something that Ashton emphasises when Natalia, Kolia, Vera and the Tutor dance to Chopin's Grande Polonaise  and Fantasy on Polish Airs  in A Month in the  Country . 
 It is this careful attention to traditional dance rhythms which is so important to the style of both ballets, although neither can be called a character or national work (see page 28). 
 Choreographers can make subtle differences between dancing to a waltz, mazurka or polonaise and there are contrasting rhythms to be found in a &frac34; time signature. 
 Another way of accenting it is the so-called &agrave; six temps , that is, two bars with six strong beats. 
 This was a favourite rhythm fur male solos used particularly by nineteenth-century balletmasters. 
 Changes can be made in the look of any step not by a change in the tempo but in the time signature: for example, dancing a pas de  basque  to a 2/4 or 6/8 instead of the usual 3/4. 
 The rise and fall of the melody 
 Fokine wanted to make dance rhythm visible by more than just marking the beats. 
 He felt that if he waltzed his dancers round and round as in a ballroom he would not be interpreting Chopin's idealised romantic waltzes for a solo pianist. 
 Such a performance would not be theatrically viable. 
 His design had to reveal the pattern and phrasing of the dream world he wished to conjure up. 
 He followed Ivanov's example in Act II of Swan Lake  in which Odette's movements rise and fall with the melody. 
 Something that Ashton does in most of his ballets. 
 In Requiem , MacMillan goes further. 
 He was using a modern style of movement therefore the rise and fall of his design had far greater dimensions and therefore greater emotional content, His dancers had to parallel the sonorities of Faur&eacute;'s solemn ritual of mourning. 
 From the opening piteous pleas with shaking hands as the dancers sink to the floor in the depths of their sorrow, the choreographic pattern of the overall rhythm is seen to swell in size and intensity as the music does until there comes the gleam of hope, a quiet moment when a child-like figure dances in wonder at the ways in which she can explore not only the space in which she moves, but also the ways in which she shapes each part of her body into an ever flowing design. 
 The dancers and music then swell to fill the stage again, ultimately to depart all sorrow spent with the child-like figure lifted high in the hands of one man and carried away out of sight whilst another dancer kneels low in homage as the music resolves the picture into a great Amen. 
 Further examples of musical interpretation 
 There are other ways in which choreographers can be guided by the musical context other than those already cited. 
 When inspired by Tchaikovsky's Fifth Symphony to create Les Fr&eacute;sages  (1933), Massine took a theme which proposed that Man would win his struggle against fate if he had Action, Love and Frivolity on his side. 
 The moods and emotions of each were expressed in the first three movements. 
 In the fourth, Man,  with the help of the three soloists from the other movements, overcame the bat-like figure representing Fate. 
 Massine took this theme from Tchaikovsky's own letters to his patron in which he described a composer's search for ideas. 
 Similarly Massine interpreted Berlioz's own synopsis for the Symphonie Fantastique . 
 This told how the poet, having taken opium, dreamt backwards through time to seek his love in a ballroom, on his way to a medieval scaffold, at a well in ancient Greece and finally at a Witches&equo; Sabbath, where her kiss ended in death (see page 56). 
 However, Massine's interpretation of Brahms' fourth Symphony (Choreartium , 1933) was very different. 
 It was the ideas behind this design that so interested not only the audience but also the music critics of the time (see page 41). 
 Massine not only paralleled the overall and short phrase rhythms of the music by those of the dancers, but the instruments of the orchestra by related groups of dancers. 
 Each group was led by a soloist representing the leader of a particular orchestral section so that as the themes were taken up by first one and then another section, the various groups of dancers joined in. 
 This is most obvious in the fourth movement, the Passacaglia or set of variations. 
 The musical theme is initially stated by all the instruments playing a series of eight chords. 
 Massine interprets these chords by setting six dancers about the stage and on each chord the six men either singly or together, and in turn, rise into a tour en l&equo; air  finishing in a pose . 
 The tour  is repeated, as are the chords, at the beginning of each variation which features a different orchestral section and its accompanying set of dancers. 
 As these related groups are active throughout, both the musical content and its orchestration are made visible. 
 It is this relationship which led to Ernest Newman's remark that, &bquo;The ballet was living music&equo; (see page 41). 
 The same critic's remark that Massine had captured the essence of Brahms' fourth Symphony by &bquo;repetitions, balancing and treatment of episodes&equo; should be clarified. 
 By repetition, he did not mean that every time a phrase was repeated it had to be the same. 
 On the contrary, he also asserted that it needed variation. 
 For example, the six male dancers do not always appear in the same place nor end in the same pose in the passages mentioned above. 
 No! 
 Massine followed Petipa's example of the solos by Aurora and the Six fairies in The Sleeping Beauty . 
 They may repeat the same step but the ports de bras  or &eacute;paulement  may change at each repeat. 
 Petipa and Massine also met Newman's requirement for the balancing and treatment of episodes. 
 This is perhaps best understood by the way both choreographers frequently show that certain steps can be danced sur les pointes  but can also be jumped, e.g. petits  changements  or sissonnes piqu&eacute;es . 
 Whichever way they are danced they must be set so that the one step grows logically out of the other because the music and the dancer have become excited by their relationship as the dance unfolds. 
 This is what must happen when a ballet ends happily. 
 Three fine examples of this exhilaration can be found in the excited circling of the cast round the hero and heroine in such ballets as Copp&eacute;lia, Pineapple Poll  and Daphnis and Chlo&euml; . 
 Choreographers however should avoid what can be called a purely technical analysis of the music by matching particular patterns of steps to particular musical phrases whenever they appear. 
 This is what Balanchine has frequently done. 
 It was first noted in Ballet Imperial  (1941) when every time a scale-like passage in the second movement of Tchaikovsky's Piano Concerto No. 2 is played, the three soloists link hands to make two arches through which the corps de ballet  &bquo;ran round the houses&equo; (Edwin Evans). 
 This type of device is repeated again and again in other works whose music contains similar passages. 
 Other easily recognised Balanchine signatures    can be seen in passages marked Stretto  where his dancers stab their toes into the floor as they travel across the stage in pos&eacute;s attitudes devant  or &agrave; la seconde . 
 Some choreographers today have adopted the same habit. 
 For example, when the musical phrases get complicated because of the use of many notes, the dancers find themselves using their hands feverishly in order to give every note its value. 
 Occasionally this can be interesting as it is in Bintley's Consort Lessons  (1984). 
 But if it is repeated too often the incessant jigging of hands makes the audience restless, too. 
 A study of Dalcroze Eurythmics from which such ideas emanate is valuable, but the practice must be used with discretion if the resultant ballet is not to resemble an examination of machinery rather than a feeling fur the rhythm and shape of the engine that makes the dancers perform. 
 Daphnis and Chlo&euml;  Aston's Romitic style The Lovers are united (Margot Fonteyn, Christopher Gable and The Royal Ballet) 
 It is often not understood by outsiders that certain types of music immediately suggest to dancers, teachers and choreographers particular kinds of steps. 
 The &bquo;insiders&equo; can walk down the corridors of the National schools in London, Leningrad, Paris, Moscow, Copenhagen, Milan and elsewhere, pause to listen outside a studio door and know instantly what type of step is being practised. 
 For example, it is necessary to hear only a brief phrase of some Grand Waltz by Tchaikovsky, Glinka or Strauss to know that steps of grande &eacute;l&eacute;vation  are the object of the exercise; to hear some slow pavane, minuet or saraband is to realise that an adage  is being practised. 
 Choreographers, like dancers, have long memories and what a student experiences in a class-room can trigger off an idea much later. 
 What develops may and usually does have some similarity to what was danced as a student. 
 Characteristic qualities of a step are likely to be retained because the type of music so decrees, although it will rarely be identical in its performance because it will have been refurbished. 
 Types of Dancer 
 Having chosen the story, theme or music, choreographers must consider the available living material through which they can mould the particular style of dance appropriate to their ideas. 
 It is well known that they always develop their more satisfying choreographic ideas when working with a group of dancers whose abilities they know. 
 It is then easier to select the individuals best suited to the proposed task. 
 This is the case regardless of whether they take an objective, subjective or general view of their work (see page 62). 
 The selection of dancers is also made easier because dancers full roughly into four categories (see page 51) which are determined by individual characteristics and abilities. 
 Training will have made dancers more adept at a certain style of dance and they usually show preference fur a certain type of step: elevation, pointe  work, pirouettes  or whatever. 
 Another characteristic of importance to the choreographer is the nature of a dancer's response to music. 
 As stated earlier, whereas creative artists such as authors commit words to paper, artists paint or carve and composers write scores away from the performers, choreographers create movements directly on the dancers in front of them. 
 Although it is now possible to use a system of notation, choreographers still prefer to create directly on the human material, working on it and relying on the dancers' own memories to repeat what has been designed on and for them. 
 Choreographers should, therefore, remember that dancers possess physical and mental abilities of their own which should be used effectively and expressively. 
 Choreographers must have been  dancers themselves if they are to understand and feel the natural abilities of the body and to allow fur the influence of the techniques in which they have been trained. 
 In addition they have to appreciate that all movement is affected by moods, emotions and actions. 
 Only by such understanding can a ballet be created with style and expression. 
 Despite what some modern choreographers seem to believe, the human body has certain well-defined limitations beyond which it is not possible to go, no matter how hard the choreographers push their intellectual ideas. 
 Dance is a physical manifestation and dancers only become expressive when they can feel the movements both physically and emotionally, and when they are inspired by the choreographer's interpretation and enthusiasm. 
 It is widely recognised that the classical technique can and does prove a stable basis fur all styles of dance. 
 Dancing masters gradually developed the classical technique from European folk dance which they first changed into the elegant steppings of courtiers in the palaces of Italian and Spanish kings and prelates. 
 The technique was further refined by Italian dancing masters employed by the french kings whose courts became the richest in Europe. 
 It was increasingly polished during the reign of Louis XIV when the first professional dancers took over from the courtiers after the founding of the Acad&eacute;mie Royale de Danse within the Acad&eacute;mie Royale de Musique (1672). 
 This early style of classical dance displayed the talents of each particular performer, therefore many rules were laid down in order to achieve perfection of movement. 
 These rules were based on the knowledge of what movements the dancers' bodies were capable. 
 Canon Arbeau in his Orch&eacute;sographie  (1588) recommended the use of four positions from and through which the feet moved, the turn-out to show off the line of the leg and ports de bras  to display one's carriage and courteous behaviour. 
 John Weaver, dancing master of Shrewsbury Grammar School, went further. 
 He wrote the first textbook on the relationship between the natural functions of the bones, ligaments, tendons and muscles, and dance movement. 
 His Anatomical and  Mechanical Lectures on Dancing  (1723) described the four movements &bquo;of which the body is capable&equo;, namely: to bend, to stretch, to rise or raise, to rotate or turn. 
 He also laid down certain rules fur balance, on the need to bend the knees always as a preparation for any kind of step followed by a stretch, on the vital use of the head and on the need fur the co-ordination of all parts if the desired movements were to be precise and elegant. 
 John Weaver designated dancers as the Serious, the Grotesque and, most importantly, the Scenical, &bquo;who practise Stage dancing&equo; which was &bquo;to Explain things conceived in the Mind by the Gestures and Motions of the Body and plainly and intelligently representing Actions, Motions and Passions so that the Spectator might perfectly understand the Performer by these his Motions, although he say no Word&equo;. 
 Weaver was the first to create a ballet d'action  in which the dancers told their own story. 
 His ideas were taken to Paris by Marie Sall&eacute; and the Italian Comedians led by Luigi Riccoboni. 
 From there Weaver's ideas spread throughout Europe. 
 Jean-Georges Noverre in his Letters on Dance  (1760) described the seven movements which give steps their varying qualities, namely: to bend, stretch, rise, jump glide, dart and turn. 
 He also described the four types of professional dancer whom he used in his ballets. 
 Noverre distinguished his dancers by their particular physiques and personalities, whereas Weaver had judged them by their ability to act. 
 Most of Noverre's ballets dealt with heroes and heroines from Greek, Roman and other  epic sources, all of whom had characteristics in common, as do so many modern heroes and heroines. 
 Danseurs nobles  and ballerinas 
 These dancers were placed in the first of Noverre's categories. 
 Their dancing was highly dignified and best suited to aristocratic roles or, as he was to say later (1810), &bquo;those of noble birth, the only appropriate heroes and heroines fur ballets staged at the Paris Opera&equo;. 
 They had to be well-proportioned, elegant and behave as rulers of a kingdom and thus able to command the attention of all. 
 The tempi of their dances were usually slow and grandiloquent, the gestures generous yet precise and performed with conviction. 
 The heroes and heroines of Petipa's ballets are an example of this category. 
 Today such dancers are rare, but others can assume these roles because technique has advanced. 
 Danseurs  and Danseuses classiques  
 Noverre's second category comprised those dancers whom he expected to be technical perfectionists. 
 They were often shorter and plumper than those of the first category, excelling in pirouettes, &eacute;l&eacute;vation  and batterie , because of their natural gift of ballon . 
 They had livelier personalities and danced roles such as Diana, goddess of the hunt, or Mercury, messenger of the gods. 
 Their dances were usually fast and had to display their exciting footwork, e.g. Petipa's Bluebird. 
 Because of the present-day search for virtuosity many dancers can attempt such roles after they have mastered its technique. 
 Demi-caract&eacute;re  dancers 
 Although Noverre did not specifically name them he described these dancers' particular characteristics as having similar physiques and technical expertise as the danseurs classiques  but they were not always so well-proportioned and usually possessed a natural sense of comedy. 
 They were in demand to play fantastic or comic roles such as satyrs or jesters and were used to relieve the solemnity of late eighteenthand ninteenth-century ballets, e.g. the many jesters found in Petipa and Soviet ballets and Puck in Ashton's The Dream . 
 True demi-caract&egrave;re  dancers with a sense of comedy are still rare but they are to be found. 
 They are often most valuable members of a company because of their ability to sink their own personalities in order to play a range of entirely unusual characters such as the comic Alain in La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e , the tragic Bratfisch in Mayerling , Kolia, the son, in A Month in the Country  and the ridiculous short dancer in Elite Syncopations . 
 Character dancers 
 Noverre called his fourth group character dancers, that is those whose physique and movements were not necessarily of the finest but whose abilities when playing some comic or dramatic role such as a Cyclops or Fury were most valuable. 
 Such talent is still most valuable to choreographers wishing to bring reality to the stage by contrasting youth and age, naivety and experience, the peasant and the aristocrat. 
 Such actor-dancers play an important, sometimes vital, part whenever convincing mime and characterisation are predominant features in a production.  
 Examples are Father Thomas in Ashton's La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  and Bottom in The  Dream . 
 In addition there are dancers whose forte is to demonstrate the different national styles when Scottish, Polish, Hungarian and other national dances are included in such ballets as Copp&eacute;lia  and Swan Lake . 
 These four distinct types of dancer are still found in twentieth-century ballet companies. 
 They are, of course, required for the older works in the repertoire and probably in newer story ballets where all ages should be seen if a plot is to have credibility. 
 They are found in such widely differing ballets as MacMillan's Romeo and  Juliet  and The invitation  and as Ashton's Enigma Variations  and A Month in the  Country . 
 This is why the same physical types and personalities are still represented amongst the students of professional schools. 
 However, it must be said that true danseurs nobles  and classiques  are rare. 
 This is because demands fur virtuosity have grown as well as for greater physical flexibility. 
 Choreographers are creating much more complicated and longer encha&icirc;nements , particularly for their pas de deux , and they give their dancers greater freedom to break the strictly conventional rules of class-room technique. 
 Sufficient time is not always given to the study of the basic principles and the proper spacing and placing of the movements. 
 Instead of concentrating on the lines of the dance &mdash; which they will need if they ever dance in Ashton's Symphonic Variations  or Monotones , MacMillan's Requiem  or Bintley's Consort Lessons  &mdash; students spend more time loosening up to meet the demands of modern choreographers. 
 There is often a rush to create something new without enough thought being given to the physical problems they may cause. 
 There remain, however, a few dancers who excel in the purely classical roles, which an audience demands because they are still testing grounds for particular talents. 
 Purely classical ballets are still popular, so there have to be choreographers who understand and mould the technique. 
 They must know how to make use of and when necessary discard the old conventional rules. 
 They must retain the calm spaciousness of movement if they are not to destroy the essence of the classical style. 
 Balanchine, Ashton, MacMillan and now Bintley break many conventions, but they never lose sight of its true qualities in those of their ballets which can be called classical.  
 BALLET-MAKING 
 Kinds of ballet 
 When choreographers have studied all the available sources of inspiration, they should consider what kind of ballet they want to create. 
 There are roughly three kinds all of which can use one or a mixture of dance styles. 
 The story ballet 
 A story ballet demands that the circumstances and events occurring as the plot unfolds will be seen to affect the lives and personalities of the characters involved and that dance and gesture will express moods' emotions and action. 
 Since Fokine broke away from the rigid categories of dance or mime, twentieth-century choreographers, following his example, have usually created a continuous design of expressive movement which interprets the story by means of mimed dance or danced mime (see page 58). 
 The stories can range from the most tragic such as The Rake's Progress , Romeo and Juliet  and Mayerling  to the lyrical fantasy of The Dream  and from the subtle and poignant A Month in the Country  to the happily funny La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  or the rumbustious Pineapple Poll . 
 But no matter whether the ballet lasts one, two or three acts the choreographer must be fully in control of his material so that every detail of the characterisation of the whole cast is appropriate to the general atmosphere and environment within which the plot unfolds. 
 This is particularly important in a three-act ballet where any temptation to display dance &bquo;for its own sake&equo; can lead to the introduction of divertissements  merely to fill in time or show off all the dancers in the company, but is not concerned with the unfolding of the story. 
 Petipa was often accused of doing this, the best example being the dances by characters from other fairy tales who come to Aurora's wedding ( The Sleeping Beauty .) 
 In a short story ballet this intrusion of extra materials is unlikely. 
 Each dance should arise naturally from the context and reveal something about one or another or all the characters in reaction to a series of situations. 
 Particularly valuable examples of the amount of information which can be given about a character in brief solos are those for most of the characters in A Month in the Country  and, dramatically, for those in Mayerling . 
 Ballets with a theme 
 The second kind of ballet describes a theme and this often requires the choreographer closely to observe the behaviour and possibly the customs, ways of moving and moods of a particular group of people. 
 They can come from the world of fantasy as in Les  Sylphides  or reality as in Enigma Variations . 
 The latter is an unusual work because it  is about people who really lived at a particular period and who had particular relationships with each other. 
 No matter whether the theme comes from fantasy or reality every movement should be lightly or firmly drawn into an overall dance design. 
 lt must also delineate the personalities and behaviour of the characters. 
 These designs can reveal people at play during a party as in Les Rendezvous  or on an ice-rink as in Les  Patineurs ; they present the conflicting or subtle moods arising from the tragedy of lost youth and hope during war-time, as in Gloria ; or they show how deep sorrow gradually changes into resignation and on to exaltation as in Requiem . 
 There can be great variety within some themes. 
 For example, Balanchine in his Four Temperaments  (with music by Hindemith) describes the moods of a melancholic, sanguine, phlegmatic and choleric man or woman. 
 Ashton in Fa&ccedil;ade  and MacMillan in Elite  Syncopations  describe how dancing is such fun when influenced by &bquo;show biz&equo; fashions of a particular period by particular kinds of people. 
 ln all the ballets just mentioned not one makes use of the purely classical technique with its severe class-room discipline. 
 Yet this is the firm basis from which the choreographers built their framework of steps, poses and gestures before painting in the personal touches which describe each performer as an individual with a right to speak in a particular way. 
 Ballets about dance and abstract ballets 
 When a choreographer wishes to make a statement about dance that is inspired by a piece of music, he has to answer the question as to what style of dance is appropriate. 
 The answer largely lies in the music chosen, because music is usually, if not always, the source of the inspiration. 
 Dance can be of a fairly severe classical style as in Ashton's Sc&egrave;nes de Ballet  which reflects Stravinsky's own description of his score: &bquo;This music is patterned after the form of classical dance&equo; (see page 43). 
 Alternatively, dance can be in an entirely modern idiom as in Martha Graham's Diversions of Angels  (with music by Dello Joio, 1948) one of her most lyrical works. 
 Whichever style is used in plotless ballets the choreographer should submit to the structure of the music, particularly if the score develops according to the classical techniques of composition. 
 Classical dance is by its very nature soundless, whereas much folk, character and theatre dance use the sound of the dancers' feet, hand-clapping, footstamping and occasional verbal comment to emphasise the rhythmic beat and phrasing of the dance. 
 Any style of classically inspired dance needs to be reinforced rhythmically by music which helps to create the timing of the steps within the phrases and also suggests varying qualities, moods and sometimes even emotions. 
 As the critic Ernest Newman wrote: &bquo;Music can become dance when it is subjected to repetition, multiplication and abstraction using steps, poses and gestures with pattern and expression to appeal to both the eye and the intellect&equo; (see also page 47). 
 The framework of a ballet 
 Having decided on the story, theme or music, choreographers should consider some vital rules of theatre and construct their ballet in the same way that authors and composers work out their books and compositions. 
 In other words, they must take into account another meaning of the word structure (see page 70) in the sense that it  is the basic framework fur the choreographic design. 
 As already stated, ballets can be roughly divided into the three different kinds usually danced by companies with a classical repertoire. 
 Firstly there are those which tell a comic or tragic story, such as La  Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  or Romeo and Juliet . 
 Secondly, there are those which describe a theme, such as Les Patineurs  or Elite Syncopations . 
 Thirdly, there are those which can be called abstract ballets, among which are Symphonic Variations  and Monotones I  and II . 
 Although the ballets mentioned are very different in style, quality and content, they have several things in common because they have to be theatrically viable. 
 Firstly, all ballets need a beginning, a climax and an end. 
 Secondly, they should conform to the unities of time, place and action. 
 That is, a particular action (even if it is only dancing). 
 takes place during a particular period and in a particular environment. 
 These two requirements were first established by Greek playwrights and were later codified by the Acad&eacute;mie Fran&ccedil;aise (1635) when it laid down rules for the composition of any literary work. 
 The rules are still valid and the libretto of any ballet neglecting them often fails to hold the attention of its audience because the content has been weakened by too many irrelevances.   
 Enigma Variations  Ashtons interpretation of Elgar's &bquo;My friends pictured within' (The Royal Ballet) 
 &bquo;A play must have a beginning , a climax and an end&equo; (Aristotle) 
 A choreographer inspired to create any one of the three kinds of ballet described above would be wise to consider Aristotle's dictum. 
 Every ballet must have a beginning because every ballet begins with a dancer or dancers making an entrance or being discovered on stage. 
 It must establish at once what type of character each is to play in the plot and the relationship of each to the environment of a theme or the style of dance being used. 
 Dancers on stage must establish their relationship to each other and to those who enter and also the particular way they are to set the action or dance going by initiating the phrasing, style and expressiveness of the choreographic design to be unfolded. 
 The ballet must have a climax. 
 The relationship of dancers to each other usually leads to a climax of some kind, possibly a confrontation or conflict, perhaps an exciting pas de deux  or a feat of virtuosity. 
 In the case of a ballet interpreting music, strong distinctions can be made between two movements of different tempo. 
 The ballet must have an end. 
 No matter which kind of ballet is being performed, it must be drawn to a proper conclusion. 
 It can be the outcome of a confrontation or conflict, e.g. Giselle  and Romeo and Juliet . 
 It can be a group picture, e.g. Enigma  Variations ; a solitary figure mourning lost love and youth, e.g. A Month in the Country  or enjoying himself, e.g. Les Patineurs ; or, more rarely, the curtain fulling on an empty stage, e.g. Gloria , possibly the most dramatic ending of all. 
 Plotting a story ballet: the unities of time? place and action 
 There are other considerations to be taken into account when the ballet has a story. 
 The same rules apply whether the plot is tragic or comic. 
 The first part introduces the characters and shows how they set the action going because of their relationship or attitude to each other. 
 This leads to conflict between individuals (Giselle ) or groups (Romeo and Juliet .) 
 The conflict develops in the second part where it reaches a climax: in Giselle  a death, in Romeo and Juliet  several deaths. 
 The third part describes the outcome of the conflict and the fate of the protagonists. 
 Some examples of how to plot  
 When Bournonville discussed the construction of a ballet he referred to the librettos and development of plot in La Sylphide  and Giselle . 
 He considered both were good examples for others to follow and deplored the long petipa ballets which lost their meaning through the inclusion of innumerable divertissements  in which: &bquo;Petipa only devised new difficulties fur the dancers.&equo; 
 Although La Sylphide  and Giselle  are two-act ballets with one change of scene, both Taglioni and Perrot (the latter with the help of the writer, Saint-Georges) divided the ballets into three distinct parts. 
 1 
 In the first part the leading characters are introduced in their proper setting before a meeting takes place. 
 In La Sylphide, James  is seen dreaming in his farmhouse before La  Sylphide  awakens and dances with him. 
 Later, apparently unseen by others, she dances through the betrothal party at which he is confronted by Madge, the Witch, who foretells that he will never marry. 
 He throws Madge from the room. 
 In Giselle  Albrecht 
 After persuading her to dance with him, he swears to marry her. 
 The entrance of a hunting party leads to Giselle's meeting with Bathilde, a crucial moment in the plot. 
 2 
 The second part of both ballets can be called the climax. 
 James follows La Sylphide  into the woods, unable to resist her charms, while Madge and her coven are seen stirring a magic brew into which they dip a silken scarf. 
 Giselle discovers Albrecht's deceit when Bathilde confronts her with the fact that the Count Albrecht is her fianc&eacute;. 
 This leads to Giselle's madness and death. 
 3 
 The third scene in both ballets shows what ensues from these climaxes. 
 James captures La Sylphide  with the magic scarf. 
 She loses her wings and dies, leaving him to be cursed by Madge. 
 In the latter, Albrecht comes to pray at Giselle's grave. 
 When the Queen of the Wilis commands Giselle to rise and dance him to his death, so strong is. her love that she helps him to dance until cockcrow when he will survive. 
 As dawn breaks, she returns to her grave leaving him to mourn alone. 
 Most other story ballets can be analysed in much the same way. 
 Those with a theme, or which consist of dance only, have a similar plan. 
 A choreographer who neglects the old rules and any item pertinent to the unfolding of the plot, theme or music is demanding a great deal from an audience. 
 Many plotless or so-called abstract ballets, by choreographers such as Balanchine, have no specific characters or climaxes but they do follow the composer's score very closely. 
 Most composers of specially commissioned music, even those later than Stravinsky, follow the time-honoured rules of thematic continuity and development and above all rhythmic phrasing. 
 Good phrasing is all important: it has to set and keep the dancers going. 
 Balanchine would have been the last person to break or contradict the thematic content and destroy the composer's intentions. 
 The layout of a story ballet 
 The layout of a story ballet or ballet d'action  was first conceived by John Weaver in 1717 when he did away with actors and/or singers to tell the story. 
 In his The Loves of  Mars and Venus  the dancers had to tell their own story in different ways. 
 four main kinds of action were later named by French balletmasters as: 
 Sc&eacute;nes d'action 
 during which some part of the story was told in conventional gesture, e.g. the casting of Carabosse's spell and the Lilac Fairy's response in the first scene of The Sleeping Beauty . 
 Pas d'action 
 such as solos or pas de deux  in which dancers portray the character each represents by depicting mood, emotion and action, e.g. again in The Sleeping Beauty , the Four Princes express their admiration for Aurora and she returns their compliments in the Rose Adage. 
 Variations 
 which display the solo dancing ability of each character and define social status and other traits that are so important to the unfolding of the story, e.g. the Six fairies bring their various gifts to the Christening and Aurora dances happily to acknowledge the compliments of the Princes and all who have come to her birthday ( The Sleeping Beauty .)  
 Divertissements 
 which were and still are a display of dances that may or may not be applicable to the plot. 
 These dances mattered very much to Petipa and all nineteenthcentury balletmasters because they were expected to show off the wealth of talent found in the many imperial, Royal and State theatres, e.g. all the characters from other fairy tales who came to Aurora's wedding and the character dances in Swan Lake . 
 Mimed dance and danced mime  However, the strict division of a ballet into four distinct kinds was eliminated by Fokine when he totally cut the sc&egrave;ne d'action  from his first ballets and never replaced them. 
 Instead, he used what he called mimed dance or danced mime, insisting, when asked fur an explanation, that there was a subtle difference between them, &bquo;only one of degree&equo;. 
 To Fokine, Les Sylphides  was mimed dance because he had incorporated a few conventional gestures into his choreography. 
 Fokine said that every &bquo;phrase of his dance was a gesture&equo;, and explained: &bquo;Undoubtedly an arabesque  has many meanings but only when it appears as an idealised gesture. 
 It is a very apparent gesture (in Les  Sylphides ), a yearning for height, for distance, an inclination of the whole body, a movement of the entire being. 
 If there is not this feeling, if it is only a raising of the leg, the arabesque  becomes intolerable nonsense.&equo; 
 Would-be choreographers should study how Ashton uses this gesture, whether he is telling a story, describing a theme or conveying the feel of the music. 
 They may then realise the truth of Fokine's words.   
 Petrushka  Foline's second Russian ballet The Puppets dance in the market place (The Royal Ballet) 
 On the other hand, Fokine insisted that most of Petrushka  was danced mime, explaining that the dances performed in the fairground were the only real ones: &bquo;These were not my own work as such crowds would have danced like that any way. 
 But even If the movements made by the three puppets inside their rooms might seem like dance to some &mdash; those who perform them must be actors who can dance.&equo; 
 Since Fokine showed that dancers must also be able to act if they are to live out the story or theme, very few choreographers have used the almost static sc&egrave;nes d'action  which stop the flow of dance. 
 Yet, and very often, even a single emphatic conventional gesture performed in a moment of stillness can be tremendously effective and make a strong point in what may otherwise be a continuous flow of dance. 
 Some of the best examples of the single gesture of great significance are to be found in Ashton's A  Month in the Country  and MacMillan's The Invitation . 
 Descriptive and narrative dance  
 Mimed dance or danced mime can also be called descriptive or narrative dance. 
 Descriptive dance applies to those passages, which can be communicated by dance, which portray everything about a role working within a story or theme, i.e. type of character, period, location, etc. 
 Narrative dance applies to those phrases of conversation between individuals or between dancers and public, where the dancer uses explicit gestures. 
 These ideas are no better illustrated than by Massine in his The  Three-Cornered Hat . 
 The success of these two means of communication is largely due to the nature of De Falla's score, which is somewhat like that of Stravinsky fur The  Firebird  and Petrushka . 
 De Falla borrowed elements from Spanish folk song and dance for all the descriptive passages. 
 Narrative dance is used in the conversations between the Miller, his Wife and their canary, and between the Wife and the Corregidor, which are based on flamenco music. 
 This is usually performed extempore, following the whims of the singer, musician and/or dancer. 
 It is therefore slightly erratic in phrase, rhythm and tune. 
 Such irregularity makes these conversations appear spontaneous, an element which Massine was careful to preserve. 
 Thus there are no repetitions of sentences. 
 To a very large extent this is what Ashton does in A Month in the Country  where the non-dancers speak out from time to time in explicit gestures. 
 Most of MacMillan's ballets, particularly Mayerling , contain the same juxtaposition of descriptive and narrative. 
 This is of extreme value and should be used more often by young choreographers. 
 Continuity and the use of the leitmotif 
 Once the basic structure fur a story ballet has been created, the choreographer must find ways of linking the beginning, climax and end so that the plot develops easily from one scene to the next. 
 This can be effected by the use of a leitmotif or phrases of music. 
 Since the first performance of Giselle , certain composers and arrangers have used leitmotifs fur one or several characters and repeat the leitmotifs each time the characters appear. 
 These musical phrases give continuity to the action and are most valuable because they help both performers and audience to understand how moments in the story or theme affect the players. 
 Adolphe Adam, composer of the music for Giselle , initiated this idea which greatly influenced Wagner and later composers. 
 Leitmotifs are a firm point of reference that carries the dancer onwards from the     beginning to the climax and to the end of the story. 
 Adam provided Giselle with five leitmotifs which perrot (the choreographer of her dances) matched with five brief encha&icirc;nements . 
 These change slightly with the music as the plot unfolds and allow Giselle to develop from a simple peasant dancer in love with Albrecht to a tragically distraught maiden and finally to the ethereal Will. 
 The leitmotifs for Giselle created by Adam and Perrot can be said to disclose her emotional development. 
 Prokofiev used several leitmotifs in the same way in his score fur Romeo and Juliet  where they heighten not only the emotional involvement of the hero and heroine but also the conflict between the warring Montagues and Capulets (see page 26). 
 Giselle  The Old Romantic ballet-Perrot's leitmotifs Above: Giselle counts the petals; below: Giselle throws the flowers to Albrecht (Ravenna Tucker, Jay Jolley; Ravenna Tucker) 
 Although Tchaikovsky used leitmotifs to weave magic threads through his ballets, his have a slightly different purpose. 
 He composed &bquo;The Flight of the Swans&equo; (his own title) to herald each arrival of Odette and the Swans. 
 It was not intended as music fur dancing. 
 He similarly composed two leitmotifs to run through The Sleeping Beauty. 
 The Lilac Fairy's music is always heard just before and during all her entrances. 
 It is in contrast to another leitmotif that marks the entrances of Carabosse, the wicked fairy. 
 The two tunes underline the conflict between good and evil. 
 Whereas Adam and Prokofiev's leitmotifs heighten the emotional content of the love theme, Tchaikovsky's are there to create the right atmosphere and to emphasise the conflict. 
 When Stravinsky composed The Firebird  he used leitmotifs in yet another way. 
 He created very distinctive passages of ascending chords to accompany the magic bird's flight through the trees. 
 They accompany her every entrance. 
 In contrast, he provided passages of descending chords for Kostchei. 
 These two themes illustrate the conflict between life and death, love and hate, youth and age &mdash; all three topics being an essential part of any Russian fairy tale. 
 In addition to the two leitmotifs, Stravinsky used traditional songs and dances backed by a mysterious rhythmic sound which helps to heighten the tension. 
 It can be said to be the wind rustling through the trees, when first heard as the Tsarevich climbs over the wall to find his Princess. 
 It keeps the tension going until the Tsarevich breaks the egg and thus signifies the death of Kostchei. 
 Whereupon the music solemnly changes to the traditional Easter hymn of rejoicing, &bquo;At the Gate&equo;, as the Tsarevich and his Bride are crowned king and queen. 
 Stravinsky used similar ideas in his score for Petrushka  and again provided an underlying rhythmic pulse to represent the incessant throb of the engines in the fairground and the general noise of the excited crowd. 
 The throb occasionally rises above all other sounds and helps to make Petrushka's Cry (Stravinsky's original title) so poignant. 
 When petrushka is left alone in his room, his cries dominate the stage both musically and choreographically because the incessant throb is not heard. 
 So when the cry is heard again just before the curtain falls it comes as a final appeal for help. 
 There is always a moment of silence before the audience respond, so strong has been the tension. 
 Prokofiev threaded two leitmotifs through his score for Cinderella  to mark the heroine and her Fairy Godmother. 
 When Ashton staged his version of the ballet he made Cinderella's leitmotif into a major factor fur the development of the plot by creating a matching dance leitmotif. 
 It is first heard and seen when the dancing-master gives the Ugly Sisters a lesson. 
 After they have gone to the ball, Cinderella, with a giggle, picks up her broom and gives it the same lesson, using it as a partner. 
 This introduces several movements seen later in more solemn form when she dances with the prince at the ball. 
 Some of the same movements are repeated yet again in the final pas de deux , when the Prince raises her high above the glistening Stars before leading  her away to the land where &bquo;they lived happily ever after&equo;, where all fairy tales should end. 
 Dance leitmotifs can be found in most of Ashton's ballets and are sometimes marked by his particular use of one step or pose. 
 This was first apparent in The Quest  (1943) where the arabesques  danced in many ways became the movement through which Una (danced by Margot Fonteyn) expressed the emotions aroused when she is assailed by the four false Knights and then her joy when rescued by St. George. 
 Ashton has other ways of creating a leitmotif to link incidents pertinent to the plot throughout a ballet. 
 These are not necessarily created through dance and music. 
 Quite the most enchanting is the leitmotif of pink ribbons being continually tied and untied until Lise and Colas are finally wed in La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e . 
 The ribbons are first seen when Lise ties them to a nail on the wall. 
 Colas sees them there and ties them to his own crook. 
 Lise retrieves them to tie his hands together. 
 This marks their first exchange of vows, which is reiterated when Lise pretends to harness Colas by the ribbons to a trap of which she is the driver. 
 But not for long, for they make another pledge by tying themselves together in a cat's cradle. 
 Ribbons appear again and again, ultimately in the maypole dance, before they disappear in a flutter of rose petals when Mother Simone relents and blesses the happy couple. 
 There is another leitmotif in this funny, happy ballet, the precious red umbrella, Alain's only love &mdash; or so it would seem &mdash; for it is the one thing he clings to and simply has to find when he has lost Lise. 
 The choreographer's viewpoint 
 Generally speaking, choreographers can approach their task in three different ways. 
 An objective view  
 Choreographers wish to express themselves through dance because a story, theme or music has inspired them. 
 Their work will require strict adherence by the dancers to a distinctive style of dance and gesture, which is designed to communicate thoughts, moods, emotions and actions as the plot, theme or dance unfolds. 
 They insist that there must be no deviation from that style and demand such loyalty that their dancers lose their own identity and become absorbed in the world of that particular ballet. 
 Fokine was the first choreographer to distinguish the need for a particular style for each ballet when he created such different ballets as Les Sylphides, Le Carnaval , Prince Igor, The Firebird  and Petrushka . 
 From his innovations have come many developments opening the way for similar independently minded choreographers. 
 They also opened the eyes of the audience to the endless possibilities of expressing meaning through dance. 
 Three particularly objective masters of choreography are de Valois in Job  and The Rake's Progress , Massine with such different ballets as The Good  - Humoured Ladies  and The Three-Cornered Hat  and MacMillan with Mayerling  and Requiem . 
 A subjective view  
 Choreographers can also take a more subjective view of their work. 
 This is equally important and has so proved throughout ballet history. 
 The choreographer seizes on the personality of a particular dancer and creates ballets through which the dancer gradually develops and discloses unique talent and qualities to such a degree that audiences soon recognise a star. 
 The names of four choreographers immediately stand        out. 
 Taglioni recognised his daughter Marie's quality of other worldliness in La  Sylphide ; Perrot discovered Carlotta Grisi's unique qualities as an actress-dancer in Giselle ; Fokine exposed Tamara Karsavina's many-sided brilliance in such works as The Firebird, Le Carnaval  and Petrushka ; Ashton fostered Margot Fonteyn's varied personality. 
 The Firebird  Fokine's first national ballet above: the Firebird sings her lullaby; below: the Coronation &bquo;At the Gate&equo; (Antoinette Sibley; Deanne Bergsma, Anthony Dowell and The Royal Ballet) 
 La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  Ashton's English comic masterpiece Above: Lise and Colas are drawn together by the pink ribbons; below: Alain misses Lise's kiss (Wendy Ellis, Wayne Eagling, Guy Niblett and The Royal Ballet) 
 A fifth choreographer must be added to this list. 
 Kenneth MacMillan is a master of many styles and views but it was he who first revealed Lynn Seymour's dramatic gifts in Romeo and Juliet  and has more recently been doing the same for Darcey Bussell. 
 Perhaps because he is in many ways an absolutely objective choreographer, he successfully exposes his deeply held views on society and its problems, in particular man's inhumanity to man, through dance. 
 His two profoundly moving ballets, Gloria  and Requiem , the one a poem for lost youth and hope through the onset of war and the other a song of mourning and praise for a departed friend, stand and fall by theaudience's response to their message and not to the pre-eminence of a star. 
 Would the ballerinas named above have reached the same eminence without the personal attention of a choreographer of genius? 
 It does not really matter what the answer is. 
 A choreographer's wish to exploit a particularly gifted dancer usually leads that dancer to develop more fully and to have more to give when cast in ballets by more objective choreographers. 
 In such cases, the dancer has to submit to the discipline of style and context dictated and not created for them. 
 This experience generally makes them more versatile artists. 
 No better example can be given than by citing the careers of Tamara Karsavina and Margot Fonteyn, both of whom worked with many different choreographers as well as submitting themselves to the severely classical discipline of the older Petipa repertoire. 
 A general view  
 There is a third type of choreographer who produces ballets which give audiences great pleasure through the sheer variety of their virtuoso designs. 
 Because of the interesting, usually technical, demands made on the performers, their ballets often become testing grounds for future soloists. 
 Variations from such ballets as Petipa's Don Quixote, Raymonda  and La Bayad&egrave;re  and Bournonville's Napoli  are still considered by most classical dancers to be more technically demanding than the more complex twistings and turnings of modern choreographers who mix their styles. 
 This is because a lack of technical expertise in a Petipa variation danced in a &bquo;tutu&equo; is all too obvious, whilst its lack in modern works usually goes unnoticed. 
 In classical technique, the calm spaciousness and perfection of each part of an encha&icirc;nement  flows onwards in line as part of whole sentences in the choreographic design. 
 The contents of a choreographic vocabulary 
 Dance is a language which contains verbs (or steps) that give continuity and lead up to, through and from the nouns to create a design in movement. 
 The nouns are the poses or gestures which, with the semi-colons, commas, colons and full stops, give expression. 
 The choreographer must understand how to form sentences or encha&icirc;nements  which will make sense in the context of the ballet. 
 Because the verbs (steps) are the vital links in any encha&icirc;nement  they must be performed in a manner suitable to the context and the music. 
 To do so, both verbs and nouns need to be  qualified by adjectives and/or adverbs determined by the choreographers during the making of the design. 
 Firstly, they can give them physical shape by referring to Noverre's seven movements of dance, viz. to bend, stretch, rise, jump, glide, dart and turn. 
 Secondly, they should decide in what manner and why they are so performed to give appropriate expression and sustain a style throughout the whole design. 
 Choreographers today also need to understand what can be called a Grammar of Choreography if their work is to emerge as a valid stage presentation. 
 They can no longer concern themselves only with the technical aspect of class-room steps and poses. 
 There are, therefore, other items that should be included in the contents of such a Grammar. 
 Useful definitions are given by the Oxford English Dictionary . 
 Grammar  
 &bquo;The art or science dealing with a language's inflexions and other means of showing the relation between words&equo; 
 This definition raises many questions for the choreographer. 
 Dance movement in every form and style must be correctly parsed and expressed if it is to be clearly understood whether its message is simple, subtle, bold, comic or tragic. 
 Movement makes its proper effect when the choreographer has selected and co-ordinated appropriate movements to make sentences flow from one to another with such style, quality and expression that the design makes sense. 
 This can be achieved only if there is motive. 
 Motive  
 &bquo;Tending to initiate; that which induces a person to act&equo; 
 Every choreographer must have a motive if he or she is to give proper thought, impetus and significance to the movements made by the dancers whether: they are telling a story; describing and/or expressing the thoughts behind a theme; or interpreting music either by expressing personal feelings about the melody and rhythm or by so framing the dance that it parallels the music and reveals its structure. 
 ln all three types of work choreographers must give the dancers reasons for their movements. 
 To do this they will need not only a knowledge of the vocabulary of steps through which dancers communicate, but an ability to explain their design so that dancers can give it depth of feeling (see page 78). 
 Motion  
 &equo; Manner of moving the body as in walking, running, dancing, etc.&equo; 
 If choreographers are to justify their reasons for creating a ballet, they should use or create a style of movement appropriate to and expressive of the characters in the story being told and their moods, emotions and actions. 
 The dancers or players in a theme ballet will need to convey the general atmosphere and any other element pertinent to the situation in which they find themselves, as well as the mood and content of the music chosen to give them phrasing. 
 They will need to do the same if they are interpreting music. 
 Today there are many ballets which are created in the generally accepted styles from which choreographers can borrow: classical, demi-caract&egrave;re , romantic, character and/or national, and modern (see pages 75&ndash;138). 
 However, when necessary,  choreographers can and should create a particular style that is perhaps based on a mixture of the above but that is, in the final analysis, a style suitable for one ballet only. 
 Such choreographers as Ashton, MacMillan and Robbins have produced some ballets which have an exclusive style of their own. 
 The most outstanding are possibly Monotones, Gloria  and Afternoon of a Faun . 
 Although the movements in all three are classically based, they would look out of place in older classical ballets or danced to other music. 
 Impetus  
 &bquo;Force with which a body moves; the impetus to move in dance; impulse to create&equo; 
 For the purpose of a choreographic grammar the word &bquo;impetus&equo; can be interpreted in three ways ali of which are applicable to the design. 
 The first meaning should be understood as the inspiration which has urged the choreographer to create. 
 The sources of inspiration are seemingly endless (see page 17). 
 Many enduring ballets have been inspired by stories from world literature. 
 Others describe a pastime such as skating, concert-going and even a dance party. 
 Other choreographers find disturbing themes of madness, the tragedy of war and man's inhumanity to man. 
 There have even been attempts to stage biographies, one of the first being Loring's Billy the Kid  (see page 30). 
 Choreographers who are inspired to interpret music can do so in many ways, all of which can be successful, but only if they remember that its overall rhythm is not merely a mechanical guide to the timing of the steps within the dance design (see page 68). 
 The second meaning of the word &bquo;impetus&equo; should be applied to the actual performance of any step or pose in the purely technical sense. 
 That is, the choreographer must understand from which part of the body impetus is to be given so that the step achieves its full purpose at the proper moment &mdash; usually in some gesture and its musical emphasis. 
 The moment can be as the dancer pauses momentarily in a pose, as a comma in the middle or as a full stop at the end of a sentence. 
 Or the moment can be an important point in an overall design to fill space, such as the moment in a grand jet&eacute; en avant  when the dancer's two legs are at an equal height from the ground and he or she appears to travel onwards effortlessly through space. 
 It can also be the moment when a dancer moves into a pirouette  and spins before holding a pose. 
 However, more important is the third meaning of impetus which has also to do with physical performance. 
 Impetus is again needed, particularly in a story ballet, when it has to be given to emphasise the significance of a step. 
 This always used to happen in older ballets when the hero would take a step forward with a slight stamp before he &bquo;swore to marry&equo; the heroine. 
 Impetus given from or with any part of the body must coincide with the musical phrasing fur it indicates the performer is to make or is making an important statement. 
 Even in softly flowing ballets such as Monotone II  where no impetus should be seen as deliberate, it must nevertheless be there and firmly controlled lf, for example, the two boys are to turn the girl sur pointe  with her working leg stretched upwards and her head and body bent downwards over her supporting leg. 
 Sometimes it is valuable to emphasise the impetus itself, particularly if a bravura pirouette  is needed to display a dancer's particular expertise or perhaps some exhibitionist trait in the character portrayed. 
 This can be most effective in cases where the dancer takes a slow preparation into a firm but slight demi-pli&eacute;  then suddenly rises  and turns five or six times. 
 This kind of bravura performance is only legitimate if the context and music allow the dancer to &bquo;steal a little time&equo;. 
 Most classical choreographers still use this device when working with nineteenth-century ballet music, which was often written to order by a composer understanding the choreographer's desire to show off a dancer. 
 Since the days of Diaghilev and his commissioning of scores exclusive to one ballet from such composers as Stravinsky, this pandering to technical prowess has rarely happened. 
 The impetus fur any step, pose or gesture should be part of the overall rhythm of the ballet. 
 Rhythm  
 &bquo;Metrical movement determined by the various relations of long and short, or accented and unaccented beats&equo;, e.g. the choreographer's arrangement of steps and poses 
 The above definition does not adequately answer the question: &bquo;What is rhythm?&equo; if the choreographer is to understand how the uses of rhythm must be applied to the creation of a ballet. 
 The late Frank Howes showed an understanding of the problems racing a choreographer when he wrote: &bquo;Every dance has its own rhythm, just as every dancer has an inborn sense of measuring time because each movement must be felt to flow through the whole body as well as the space in which it moves. 
 Without a sense of rhythm our sense of time is devoid of landmarks. 
 It is the particular organisation of movement in time, space and intensity that a choreographer achieves through his grouping of the various types of steps. 
 He can create overall rhythms and within them short phrase rhythms, but the basis of them all is that they exist in groups and by being efficient in action and appropriate to the context give pleasure to both the performer and the onlooker.&equo; 
 (See also page 41.) 
 Rhythm in ballet is not therefore a mere time-keeper as it is in such social ballroom dances as waltzes and fox-trots. 
 A ballet fur the stage must have an overall rhythm which sets the atmosphere, quality, mood and possibly the emotional content of the whole. 
 And ballet must also have short phrase rhythms which will give it variety, dimension, mass, structure, texture and style. 
 Perhaps no ballet has ever made the same impact on dancers and audience as Stravinsky's Rite of Spring . 
 Its urgent overall rhythm commands the choreographer to keep the dancers moving forever onwards with greater intensity to the climax, whilst the shorter phrase rhythms give the Chosen Maiden and smaller groups such ways of moving that they hold the audience's full attention until the fall of the curtain. 
 Variety  
 &bquo;Being various; absence of monotony or uniformity; class of things differing in some common qualities from the rest of a larger class to which they belong&equo; 
 The important point in the above definition is the assertion that things which differ in some common qualities do nevertheless belong to the larger class. 
 In other words, the choreographer should set out to create a particular style for the whole dance design, yet within it be free to vary the way of performing a step without breaking away from or distorting the overall rhythmic quality and phrasing of his encha&icirc;nements . 
 It does not matter on which style of dance a choreographer bases his design. 
 It should be obvious that there are many ways of performing any step, pose or gesture. 
  The usual ways can be seen in any class-room and are based on the four movements dictated by the natural anatomical structure of the body, namely: to bend (contract), stretch (relax), rise (raise), turn (rotate). 
 These can take place anywhere by the correct use of the bones, joints, tendons, ligaments and muscles. 
 The ways in which these four actions can be co-ordinated are extremely varied. 
 Altering the look of a step can involve changing the time signature or tempo to which it is danced, the direction it takes or a change of &eacute;paulement , its quality and expressiveness, to name but a few. 
 The choreographer's problem is to select which of the movements are appropriate, when and how they are to be incorporated and what style and quality they require. 
 Dimension  
 &bquo;Measurable extent of any kind; number of unknown qualities contained as factors in a whole&equo; 
 Dimension immediately suggests that the choreographer must take into account the space in which the dancers move. 
 Although this is of considerable importance, particularly if the ballet is to be presented in a large theatre, too much concentration on certain of the dimensions (height, depth or breadth) may deprive some members of the audience of much of the pattern. 
 for example, too much weaving and rolling of bodies on the floor is hardly visible from the stalls, whilst too much concentration on one side of the stage finds spectators on the same side craning their necks to see what is going on. 
 It was for such reason that most of Petipa's famous pas de deux  take place centre stage, whilst those of Ashton and MacMillan cover the whole area as befits their more flowing lyrical styles, 
 Dimension does not merely mean the space to be filled. 
 It must also refer to the depth of thought behind the design whether the subject deals with a bold tale or a subtle philosophical, psychological or even theological theme. 
 It may even present a comic, frivolous or bawdy joke to arouse laughter or attempt to reveal the workings of a composer's mind. 
 However, choreographers should always remember that whatever story, theme or music is chosen, it must be translated into clear, often simple, dance statements understandable by an audience. 
 It should not be necessary to compile long programme notes, except perhaps in those cases where a poem is being interpreted (see page 28). 
 Choreographers should never assume that all in the audience have sufficient knowledge of the subject, theme and ideas which are possibly understood only by an exclusive coterie of friends. 
 This does not mean that only wellknown or straightforward subjects and themes are to be staged. 
 far from it. 
 Shakespeare's dramas of Hamlet, Romeo and Juliet  and Othello  have many subtle touches of humour and tenderness, as do his lighter works such as A Midsummer  Night's Dream . 
 All have been translated into successful choreographic form. 
 Similarly the delicate and subtle nuances of such ballets as Ashton's A Month in the Country , Robbins' Dances at a Gathering  and MacMillan's Song of the Earth  are successfully conveyed and capture the audience's attention from the moment the curtain rises by the impetus, rhythm, dimension and variety of dance. 
 Dance in all its aspects has proved capable of embracing the whole range of emotions and behaviour that emerge from a proper reading and understanding of the text. 
 Mass  
 &bquo;Coherent body of matter of indefinite shape or dense aggregation of objects, or assembly of people&equo;  
 The above definition may at first seem to have little to do with a choreographer's work. 
 But if the choreographer does not understand all the details which go to make the total presentation of a ballet, it can all too easily fail in some way or other. 
 Merely to count all the details that it is necessary to accumulate from the preparation of a scenario and score through rehearsal to public performance should make it clear that co-operation from other artists as well as from dancers is required. 
 There must be a librettist &mdash; if the choreographer does not plan out the plot &mdash; a composer or arranger of music, a designer for set and costumes and all those associated with sets and props, painting stage-managing, lighting and everything else needed to &bquo;get the curtain up&equo;. 
 An understanding of &bquo;mass&equo; in choreographic terms only means how to organise and manipulate the dancers within that mass of objects. 
 Are they to take pride of place, as they should in ballets worthy of the name? 
 Or is dance going to be overloaded and the choreographic design lost in a mass of stage materials, such as too-heavy costumes, an overdose of stage effects and machinery or over-powerful sets which dwarf the dancers. 
 These are but a few of the hazards that can wreck the look and expression of the choreographic design. 
 An even more important sense of the term &bquo;mass&equo; applies to the choreographer's handling of his cast. 
 1s it small or large and who is to play a general or particular part in the action? 
 Can certain individuals be directed in such a way that they stand out from the mass because they are the tellers of the story, the chief exponents in the drama or theme? 
 Or do they play only a minor role which nevertheless gives a vital clue to the unfolding of the plot? 
 Or must they remain part of the &bquo;mass&equo;, in other words the corps de ballet , because they are needed to create the proper atmosphere, state the location, suggest the mood and very often respond to whatever is taking place? 
 To do this successfully the choreographer must be able to select from the &bquo;aggregation of objects&equo; only those which are appropriate to the ballet in hand. 
 Structure  
 &bquo;Manner in which a building or other complete whole is constructed; supporting framework&equo; 
 This definition is to be construed as the way in which the choreographer designs the layout of the ballet. 
 It is particularly appropriate in the case of a ballet that tells a story where the libretto has to be set out in such a way that the action can be logically developed and each item roughly timed. 
 Such a libretto can then be handed to a composer or arranger of music and a designer so that they can make their contributions to the total production. 
 At first the libretto is only an outline of how the story unfolds and what part each member of the cast is supposed to play. 
 It also needs a brief explanation of how and why they make their entrances and exits. 
 The following questions arise, although not necessarily in this order. 
 1 
 Is the tale to be told in the short space of thirty or forty minutes with a minimal cast? 1f so, then care should be taken to dispense with any dancer or item not essential to the action, e.g. Ashton eliminated several characters in Turgenev's A  Month in the Country. 
 Or  is it to be a full-length ballet with a maximum use of dancers? 
 However long or short the work, care is needed not to overload the tale with variations  and divertissements . 
 It should only include items which increase tension as in Romeo and Juliet  or give rise to more fun and happiness as in La Fille   Mal Gard&eacute;e , or enhance the general mood as in A Month in the Country  where there is romance in the air and also a general feeling of frustration. 
 Moreover no matter the size of part each dancer has to play in the unfolding of the plot or the quality of each dancer's place in the dance design, everything must be mapped in every aspect. 
 2 
 How is the story to be unfolded? ls use to be made of the strictly ordered oldfashioned sc&egrave;nes  and pas d'action, variations  and/or divertissements ? 
 Or is it to be told by mimed dance and/or danced mime? 
 The latter methods are used by every modern choreographer working with classical dance because it is more flexible and expressive and many dancers trained in its technique are capable of acting out the deepest emotions of the characters played, as Ashton and MacMillan have continually shown. 
 Yet even mimed dance and danced mime need to be carefully structured if the story is to be told in all its aspects. 
 There are sc&egrave;nes d'action  in Romeo and Juliet : for example, when Lord and Lady Capulet bring Paris to confront Juliet in her bedroom which merges into apas d'action  as she repulses his advances when he tries to woo her; there is the variation describing the activities of Romeo, Mercutio and Benvolio before they enter the ballroom. 
 A similar description can be given to various parts of A Month in the Country , such as the sc&egrave;ne d'action  where the entire cast tries to find the lost key, the exquisite pas d'action  of Vera and the Tutor, and Kolia's excited variation playing with a ball. 
 3 
 Once an outline of the story and a general layout of the plot have been decided, they should be discussed with the composer or arranger of music whose first task may be to create a proper beginning with the overture. 
 Is it to set the general atmosphere and mood as Stravinsky did for The Firebird  Mysterious sounds of the wind whispering in the trees, the soaring flight of a bird and the heavy tread of an unseen foot are still a wonderful introduction to this magic tale. 
 On the other hand, Prokofiev used his overture to Romeo and Juliet  to introduce the leitmotifs which will help both dancers and audience to follow the unfolding of the plot. 
 He contrasts the love themes of Romeo and Juliet with those which accompany the bitter struggles and fights between Montague and Capulet. 
 Differently again, the overture to A Month in the Country  conveys romantic nostalgia with deeper hints of passion which Lanchbery created when he arranged little-known music by Chopin. 
 This music also firmly sets the location and period of the tale. 
 4 
 The choreographer's next task is to establish the relationship between two or more players and set the action going. 
 ls the opening to generate atmosphere and mood, to establish the location, time of day and/or period which will give an air of reality? 
 This is the most valuable way of working out a first scene and happens in Ronzeo and Juliet . 
 Here is a market place in a certain town, in a certain period, with the inhabitants setting about their daily tasks as the sun rises. 
 Despite the general activities there is menace in the air and it is not long before the rival factions of Montagues and Capulets are fighting and deaths occurring before the lovers even meet. 
 This opening is very different from the quietly charming first scene of A Month in the Country , where the only thing amiss is Natalia's bored behaviour. 
 Even with such examples in mind the choreographer may well decide it is better to delay the confrontation between the chief players because, by creating and stressing the general atmosphere, this raises the audience's expectations before the  meeting of the protagonists, and the sudden onset of passion is what makes the ultimate tragedy so poignant. 
 This happens in Giselle  where Hilarion's suspicions of Albrecht's identity are already aroused before Albrecht meets Giselle. 
 Hilarion's discovery of Albrecht's sword and later his confrontation with Giselle, with the sword in his hands, still does not convince Giselle of Albrecht's duplicity. 
 It is only later when Bathilde confronts her with the news that Albrecht is her fianc&eacute; that Giselle realises the truth and loses her reason. 
 The scenes between Hilarion, Giselle, Albrecht and Bathilde are reminiscent of the scenes that develop Tybalt's hatred of Romeo from the first fight between Montague and Capulet to his discovery of Romeo with Juliet after their first meeting at the ball, and finally to the fight that ends in Tybalt's death. 
 These scenes heighten the tension and suggest that all will end in tragedy. 
 Despite the great differences in style between the above three ballets and despite their different libretti the three choreographers perrot (with Saint-Georges), MacMillan and Ashton give valid reasons why the tragic deaths of Giselle, Romeo and Juliet, and Natalia's lost love are the inevitable result of what has gone before. 
 In other words, what happens at the beginning of the story states why the relationships between two or more characters lead to confrontations which continue onwards to a climax and finally draw the ballet to a suitable conclusion. 
 This last task is possibly the most difficult because the audience must be convinced that the ending chosen is the only possible outcome of everything that has gone before. 
 The ending can also owe a great deal to the composer or arranger of music. 
 Stravinsky ensures a happy yet solemn ending to The Firebird  by using the old Easter hymn &bquo;At the Gate&equo; where the whole congregation rejoices at the renewal of life. 
 Lanchbery uses Chopin's poignant Andante Spinato  to express Natalia's realisation that love has now escaped her. 
 Prokofiev's solemn and doom-laden funeral march finally stamps the tragedy of Romeo and Juliet  because it has already echoed through each stage in the unfolding of the plot. 
 It seems the inevitable and only way to conclude such a passionate story of love and hate. 
 5 
 Similar considerations have to be given to ballets on a theme and to ballets that interpret music where the composer's own structure should inspire the design (see page 41). 
 Texture  
 &bquo;Arrangement of threads; the characteristic feel or look of this arrangement&equo; 
 This definition should be understood as the choreographer's ability to establish a style of movement through which the audience will feel and understand what the performers are communicating through a particular way of dancing. 
 The style must disclose and be expressive of the moods, emotions and actions of the roles played even where few personal feelings are allowed to show, as in such ballets as Ashton's Monotones  where all that is needed is a calm, unhurried and seemingly endless weaving of the dance design in all its dimensions. 
 Nevertheless the three dancers in Monotones  are expressing their close relationship to each other and to the space in which they dance and above all to the flowing lines of the design and of the musical phrases. 
 The composer Satie confessed to his friends that his music was probably inspired by a study of the friezes on ancient Greek vases. 
 It is surely not surprising that  Ashton was similarly inspired. 
 He selected the simplest steps and poses of classical dance with its perfectly balanced form and at the same time gave it straighter, longer lines to draw attention to the more athletic qualities of Greek dance and to the clear, austere sounds of Satie's modern music. 
 In other words, Ashton created a special style for a ballet with its roots in ancient classical art yet entirely modern in outlook (see page 130). 
 Choreographers can derive a particular style from any of the usual forms of dance studied in the established schools of France, Russia, Denmark, Italy, England and America. 
 Each school has its own method dictated by the dancers' response to the way that technique is practised, a way which is coloured by national traits in music, society and culture. 
 All dance is based on the same principles and rules which are dictated by the anatomical capacity for movement found in the human body. 
 There are some five main styles to consider: the purely classical, demi-caract&egrave;re , romantic, character and/ or national, and modern in its various forms. 
 But before describing these categories it is valuable to consider the meaning of style. 
 Style  
 &bquo;The artistic expression or way of presenting characteristics proper to the period and/ or the subject chosen&equo; 
 This definition &bquo;proper to the period&equo; is nowhere better exemplified than in Ashton's five classical ballets. 
 In these he has tried to reflect not only the period in which their music was written but also to devise a particular way of dancing inspired by the structure and tone of the particular piece of music (see page 41). 
 The choreographer must decide what kind of subject has been chosen. 
 For example: is the subject taken from classical literature with its firm structural rules like those which govern Balanchine's Apollo ? 
 Or is it from romantic poetry or music, such as the Massine-Berlioz Symphonie Fantastique  or Balanchine's Double Concerto  based on music by Bach? 
 Or does it re-create a folk tale such as the Fokine-Stravinsky The Firebird  or a national epic such as Bintley's The Swan of Tuoneia ? 
 Choreographers should then go on to decide which style of dance would be most appropriate. 
 Generally speaking, there are certain well-recognised ways of dancing which can serve as a basis. 
 But more often than not these will all need some adjustment and/or extra touches to make the dance design suitable or, even better, unique for a particular ballet. 
 These touches will depend firstly on the type of character to be portrayed; secondly on how their movements will be affected by the unfolding of the plot, theme and/or music; thirdly on what particular steps, poses and gestures within the total design will be needed to communicate meaning.    
 Rhapsodie  Ashton's interpretation of Rachmaninov's belief that&equo; music is movement' (Lesley Collier, Anthony Dowell) 
 STYLES IN BALLET 
 The classical ballet 
 The classical style with its particular look and feeling was first described by Pythagoras (5th century BC): &bquo;It represents the subtle equilibrium of outline and axis, by the perfection of its symmetry of balance within a composition.&equo; 
 De Valois reiterated that thought when she said in a lecture to teachers (1947): &bquo;Classical dance requires an ordered, balanced form in which a calm spaciousness of movement animates the dancers. 
 Any expression it may show arises solely through the inspired personality of a dancer who has mastered its technique.&equo; 
 A classical ballet has a style of dance based on certain accepted principles and rules laid down by french, Russian, Danish, Italian and more recent schools. 
 Its movements are harmonious, perfectly balanced and symmetrical in design. 
 It follows the restrained style associated with classical antiquity. 
 If it has a story or theme the behaviour and actions of the characters are predictable and conform to the old code of courtly behaviour. 
 Nineteenth-century choreographers who adopted this style defined the characters by certain known habits and actions, and told their stories by means of conventional gestures during the sc&egrave;nes  and pas d'action . 
 When Fokine developed his mimed dance and danced mime, the old dualism of dance and mime was largely eliminated, although twentieth-century choreographers still use the strictly academic technique as the firm basis of their design. 
 The best example of the older classical ballet is Petipa's The Sleeping Beauty . 
 In the twentieth century such Ashton ballets as Symphonic Variations  and Monotones , MacMillan's ballets with a theme, Gloria  and Requiem , and Balanchine's many essays about music and, more importantly, his very clear interpretation of a myth, Apollo , are excellent examples of the style. 
 Apollo  was the first ballet to display a fresh way of looking at class-room technique for the communication of an ancient Greek legend. 
 It taught many others how classical style could be adapted and developed. 
 To create such a ballet, choreographers need to understand what type of character they are using and how the type of character will colour the dance movements. 
 Characters in  classical ballet 
 When a choreographer creates a ballet based on ancient Greek or Roman myth and legend, or on medieval legends and the fairy tales derived from them, he can find inspiration for ways of acting out the story or theme by reading the works of authors such as Homer and Plato. 
 These describe the appearance and behaviour of heroes, heroines, villains and other characters. 
 They show what happens when an individual is confronted by fate. 
 Such descriptions give a generalised picture of what such characters are and do. 
 They behave much as do similar characters found in the epics of other nations. 
 On the one side, they are all brave and honourable; if the epic has a  happy ending they surmount every obstacle; if there is a tragic end, they succumb in an unequal fight. 
 On the other side, the villains are truly evil and are equally well described. 
 The scholars of the Renaissance courts studied in depth the philosophy and dictates of classical authors and applied their knowledge to the education of courtiers, so that they would act and behave correctly in the new society. 
 The most important field of study was that of courtly behaviour and manners so that the attention of everyone was focused round the king, prince or prelate. 
 It was equally important to ensure that all would-be courtiers studied music, which in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries included ali the arts and muses. 
 This required a knowledge of the theory of numbers and geometrical design, of singing and playing some musical instrument, of composing poems, of dancing, fencing and sword play, as well as of practising the fashionable sports and pastimes. 
 This study of the Muses in the widest sense was reflected in the work of such balletmasters as Beaujoyeulx, producer of the first ballet de cour  and later by Beauchamps, dancing master to Louis XIV. 
 The same types of generalised character continued and still appeared in Petipa's many ballets, Fokine's Pavillon d'Armide , Ashton's Cinderella  and MacMillan's Romeo and Juliet . 
 There are some glimpses of the same behaviour in MacMillan's Mayerling , although the manners and behaviour have deteriorated. 
 The heroines of such ballets go hunting, practise archery, play lutes or mandolins, dance appropriate period dances and generally behave &bquo;as to the manner born in aristocratic surroundings&equo;. 
 They arrive on stage in strict order of precedence, the noblest usually arriving last so that the lesser characters can look on in suitable admiration, whilst the servants (the corps de ballet ) keep their distance. 
 This acceptance of the usual forms of court etiquette was first developed in a particular social environment, and it is important to comply with it if a proper atmosphere is to be established for the action which is to take place. 
 Rules of behaviour 
 The need for classical dancers to study courtly behaviour is nowhere more important than in all pas de deux . 
 The courtesies to be shown are seen at their best when Aurora dances with her Prince in the last act of The Sleeping Beauty . 
 It is not merely the gracious bow they give each other before they begin, nor the even more gracious one when she submits to the prince, sinking to the ground with head bent low. 
 She then places her hand in his and with his help gradually rises onto pointe  until she poses triumphantly in attitude . 
 The way he proffers his open hand before this difficult feat of balance draws attention to the vital part to be played by all heroes in classical ballet. 
 The danseur  must complement and follow the lines drawn by the ballerina as she poses and dances. 
 It is often the way he extends his hand to take hers and the way she responds that lead to the successful conclusion of a balance, lift or pirouette . 
 It is not always understood that he does not only help her but has frequently to lead her into a movement. 
 He can do this by guiding her with a strongly held forearm or firm hand clasp as she sustains a pose. 
 He can steady her balance by holding his hands sufficiently close but not grasping her waist as she pirouettes , then grasp it firmly at the end of the turn, maybe to twist her into another pose. 
 He must know how to lift or catch her in different ways from a static position or jump without any sign of strain. 
 Nor must he step outside the dimension of the choreographic design both are making.  
 The ballerina has to behave as graciously and confidently as her partner. 
 She must know how to give or take his hand and always to acknowledge his presence as an equal partner in the dance. 
 Admittedly in many of Petipa's pas de deux  he seems merely to be a porter. 
 This is because Petipa was not interested in male dance and often left the danseur  to arrange his own brief solo. 
 But such a situation should not be allowed to occur because any casualness in the ballerina's behaviour destroys any attempt to convey style in the classical manner. 
 Among the best early examples of how hero and heroine should dance pas de deux  are those in Giselle  and La Sylphide  where both have equal rights as dancers. 
 A weak dancer playing Albrecht or James spoils the total effect. 
 A more recent master of pas de deux  is Ashton whose choreographic designs in ballets such as Symphonic  Variations, Cinderella, Sc&egrave;nes de Ballet  and Ondine  reveal many different ways of displaying the spaciousness, dignity and grace of courtly behaviour. 
 It is necessary to preserve this style and he does so despite the modernity of some of the movements. 
 Another important instance of courtly behaviour is when the hero has to lead the heroine into the dance. 
 Is he merely to proffer his hand and lead her into a stately minuet? 
 Is he to stand behind her, to take her right hand in his right and to lift it over her head while their clasped left hands stretch sideways before they move swiftly and diagonally into an allement? 
 Or is he to allow her to rest her left forearm on his right and to guide her round in an elegant mazurka &mdash; leading her, as it were, from the shoulder so that she always moves just in front of him? 
 Such beautiful manners are quite unlike those of the ranch hands and their girls in De Mille's Rodeo  or those in MacMillan's Elite Syncopations . 
 In addition to the courtesy the partners show to each other, there are also the courtesies that must be shown to the bystanders on stage during a pas de deux  so that such reciprocation can help to focus the audience's attention on the context of the dance. 
 The courtesies must also be exchanged between couples in a group dance. 
 This is very important where there is a constant change of partners. 
 There should be an acknowledgement on meeting and a &bquo;thank you&equo; on parting, no matter how brief. 
 The exchange of tiny glances that partners must practise in any pas de deux  is artistically valuable and technically important. 
 It helps them to find their centre of balance when working close together and also to counter-balance their weight when necessary. 
 They must always be seen to have sufficient room in which to manoeuvre if they are to create a spaciousness for the most difficult changes in &eacute;paulement  as pose follows pose. 
 Room is obviously important when the ballerina is wearing a tutu, whose shape should not be distorted by a collision between the partners. 
 It is equally important when she is wearing a soft tunic or one-piece tights and leotard. 
 The lines made by the two dancers together must always have room to breathe and to be seen separately if the whole design is to flow. 
 It is possibly the spaciousness of design that brings audiences again and again to Ashton's Symphonic Variations  and Monotones , whose straighter and continuously moving lines require the dancers to draw them calmly and to fill the stage generously with movement. 
 This could not be more different from the cruel flinging of Mary Vetsera's body by Rudolf in the Mayerling pas de deux  with which MacMillan describes the Count's tragic mental state. 
 Technical characteristics 
 Classical dance in its purest form requires symmetry and balance. 
 Each part of the body must be placed in a true relationship to the others and to the whole as the dance  flows onwards. 
 This requirement has its origins in Greek sculpture. 
 Anyone seeing such works of sculpture for the first time cannot fail to note the harmonious line described through the perfectly proportioned bodies of the men and women portrayed. 
 No matter from which angle they are viewed, these statues reveal that the head and limbs counter-balance each other round a central line running through the body so that each part is one with the whole picture. 
 There is space, dimension and structure. 
 All is open and alive for all to see. 
 If choreographers have had training in classical dance, they already have a large vocabulary of movement on which to call. 
 Petipa divided movement into seven categories which other teachers have analysed further. 
 If these definitions were put through a computer they would list five kinds of jumps, twenty-three pas de bourr&eacute;e , seven glissades  and so on. 
 The technical structure of each step and pose is known and years of practice in hundreds of class-rooms have produced principles of calm and - spacious movement. 
 But technical descriptions only indicate the positions through which the feet and legs should move and at which moment they should co-ordinate with the arms as weight is transferred from one step and pose to the next. 
 There are few, if any, suggestions of how individual movements can be linked together to achieve some expressive or rhythmic quality suitable to the style of dance required by the plot, theme and/or music. 
 if choreographers wish to make their design more interesting they should attempt to give each step and pose some distinctive quality or unusual place in the design, which may or may not break the old conventions. 
 As Fokine said: &bquo;There can never be revolution in dance, only evolution, because the human body remains as it always has been, a living apparatus which can only move in certain well-defined ways.&equo; 
 Choreographers should remember that the descriptions in any dictionary of steps only indicate the beginning, passing through and end of a single item. 
 There is no linkage, no indication of how to amalgamate one step with another and no indication of either rhythm or quality to make the movement come alive. 
 Giving quality to the movements 
 &bquo;Routine is the enemy of art&equo; is the wisest remark fur every artist to digest. 
 Every choreographer should realise that the usual vocabulary of steps is only a beginning. 
 The problem is how to link them so that they become like sentences in a play or poem. 
 They must make physical, musical and, when necessary, dramatic sense. 
 The sentences must have a rise and full, an ability to flow onwards with pauses for breath, like full stops, or a moment's silence for the onlookers to assess what has just been stated and to understand its purpose and place in the design before the dance continues. 
 These choreographic sentences, no matter how short or long, broad or narrow, high or low must make sense within the total pattern or movement traced on the stage. 
 This pattern is made not only by the dancers' feet as they move over the surface but also by the dancers' bodies as they move through space. 
 Their limbs, torsos and heads can make straight, angled or rounded lines, usually at one and the same time, according to the natural structure of the dancers' bones and how they are activated by the muscles. 
 The choreographer must learn the natural functioning of the dancers' bodies in order to combine steps and poses in a way that gives quality to the whole. 
 If the dance design is to have physical, musical and, when necessary, dramatic sense, would-be choreographers should study how and why Petipa divided his steps into seven categories and then study some examples of how other choreographers have used his ideas. 
  The auxiliary or preparatory steps  
 Such steps as glissades, chass&eacute;s, pas de bourr&eacute;e  and so on, form the links between the steps of elevation, pirouettes  and poses. 
 They are the verbs which should initiate the style of movement needed to sustain a ballet. 
 For example: to move from one foot to two in any glissade , it can and should be when first studied a smooth gliding movement as it is when Albrecht gently draws Giselle to sit on the bench before telling her of his love. 
 But it can also be very brisk and neat with a perfect close in 5th position as it is in many Bournonville ballets and Ashton's Birthday Offering . 
 It can also be danced sur les pointes  or become a spacious preparation into some grand assembl&eacute;  or saut de basque en tournant  as in many Petipa solos. 
 If the glissade  is too emphatic then the step of grande &eacute;l&eacute;vation , the highlight of a sentence, will lose its impact. 
 Thus when using glissades  the choreographer must decide whether they are to be darted. and controlled by careful spacing to close in an elegant 5th position, or glided smoothly with a gentle rise and full, or danced in such a way that they give impetus to propel the dancer upwards into the step of elevation. 
 The above remarks presuppose that the choreographer has carefully studied the various ways of using the feet. 
 Do they merely glide on the surface as they do in Les  Patineurs? 
 Do they weigh heavily downwards as in MacMillan's A Distant Drummer , where the pas march&eacute;s  become a military exercise of horrific quality? 
 It is when discussing the many ways in which pas de bourr&eacute;e  can be danced that the uses of the feet are widely exposed. 
 Dancers easily understand how a series of swift pas de bourr&eacute;e courus  (i.e. running on the toes) as danced by the Queen of the Wilis in Giselle , differs from the same step performed piqu&eacute;  (i.e. each foot picked up sharply at each change of weight), as in many of petipa's solos. 
 But it is not always easy to decide which is the more appropriate, nor how the two ways mentioned can lead to other versions. 
 for example, in her solo in Ashton's Cinderella  the Winter Fairy moves across the stage in a series of pas de bourr&eacute;e en tournant&agrave; terre , the feet weaving their in-and-out pattern as the arms flick to and fro sparkling with frost. 
 In Symphonic  Variations , the dancers perform pas de bourr&eacute;e piqu&euml;s sur les pointes  very gently because they are marking the rhythmic beat as the soloist dances to the melodic phrase. 
 This is an excellent example where both the overall and shorter phrase rhythms are explicitly brought to life by the dance design (see page 68). 
 One of the most beautiful uses of pas de bourr&eacute;e courus  is when Ashton places his danseuse  in her partner's arms as she floats over the surface of the floor as if in a dream like ecstasy. 
 It is a movement he has used many times and which is perhaps seen at its best in the pas de deux  to the Meditation  from Thai-s  created for Anthony Dowell and Antoinette Sibley; in A Month in the Country  when Natalia dances with the Tutor to express her emotions; and in Les Deux Pigeons  in the final pas de deux , when the Young Man has returned to The Girl and tenderly dances with her in his arms (see page 83). 
 It was this ability to display a ballerina's apparent weightlessness and sheer joy in dance that was so impressive when the Spirits of the Air danced in Homage to the  Queen , Ashton's exquisite celebration of the 1952 Coronation which was danced by Margot Fonteyn and Michael Somes. 
 Her feet scarcely touched the ground as she rose, descended, turned and floated to be held momentarily in some pose as a gesture of homage. 
  Steps of petite and grande &egrave;l&egrave;vation  
 It is not enough merely to consider how to perform the five jumps as a technical exercise. 
 They must have quality given to them because their varying dimensions can add so much to the design. 
 Certainly in the class-room those from two feet to two feet only go straight up and down in all changements, soubresauts  and entrechats  with both legs fully extended at the height of the jump. 
 But such jumps can also travel some way forwards, backwards or sideways and can become sparklingly light when the knees are sharply bent upwards at the height of the jump. 
 This is required of the Four Fairies, the Fairy Godmother and the Stars in Ashton's Cinderella . 
 However if this way of jumping from two feet to two feet had not been combined with well picked-up pas  de bourr&eacute;e piqu&eacute;s  and relev&eacute;s retir&eacute;s  as well as extremely accurate, quick ports de  bras  with straighter and more angled than rounded arms, they would have seemed out of place. 
 When moving dancers from two feet to one in both open and closed sissonnes , the choreographer can make the movements dart over the floor as Aurora does in her final solo in The Sleeping Beauty . 
 In Les Patineurs  and Les Rendezvous  Ashton makes his dancers travel upwards as well in an effort to show off their abilities to keep up with the music and beat each other to the exit. 
 Grands jet&eacute;s en avant  require a spring onwards from one foot to the other and can take on many forms. 
 Are they to be sharply accented upwards with a hold on the downwards accent as they are in Ashton's version of the Act III pas de quatre  in Swan  Lake? 
 Or  are they to be softly stretched and so angled that they curve upwards and over before descending silently as in Fokine's Les Sylphides? 
 These last jet&eacute;s  would be completely out of place in Lander's Etudes  where a strong &bquo;flick&equo; outwards of the leading foot propels the dancer straight forwards through the air with little or no time to pause in arabesque  on landing because the continuous repetition of this strong movement is intended to cover as much ground in as little time as possible. 
 This gives an impression of speed which is so important in this interpretation of Czerny's finger exercises for the piano, and is quite alien to the soft rise and fall of the Sylphides' jet&eacute;s  danced to Chopin's romantic music in a woodland glade. 
 Grande and Petite batterie  
 Petipa's suggestion that beats can add brilliance to the dance is nowhere better exemplified than in the bris&eacute;s voi&eacute;s  and temps depoisson  of the Bluebird's solo in The  Sleeping Beauty  and other male solos from ballets by Bournonville. 
 But it is not so easy to find good examples of his suggestion that batterie  can lend wit except in the Blue Boy's r&eacute;voltades  in Ashton's Les Patineurs . 
 But their witty performance depends on the soloist's own attitude to the fun. 
 Is he really to appear as if tripping himself up and thus about to fall? 
 Or is he to show how difficult he finds them? 
 Ashton has also found a delicious use for the ordinary class-room petits battements sur le cou depied  when Cinderella parodies the Ugly Sisters' dancing lesson. 
 There are many other instances of Ashton's witty beaten touches that may only become apparent after several viewings and are to be found in Birthday Offering, Sylvia, La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  and elsewhere. 
 Pirouettes  
 In the same way as steps of batterie  and grande &eacute;l&eacute;vation, pirouettes  are usually employed to add excitement. 
 There are so many different ways of turning on one or two feet. 
 Now that the teaching of pirouettes  has become more scientific, dancers can  attempt turning with the working leg held at many different angles, even changing the pose as they spin. 
 Since Legnani first danced the famous thirty-two fouett&euml;s  in Swan Lake , it sometimes seems that choreographers lacking ideas for a spectacular finish to a solo, send the dancer spinning faster and faster round the stage, or set them centre stage and make them turn with increasingly difficult poses. 
 In Les Patineurs  they just spin happily in the snow. 
 The supporting leg can go on spinning on full pointe  with that knee bent, as the working one is held in arabesque  or attitude  and finally sit on the floor. 
 Whether the last two antics are viable depends entirely on the context. 
 Such antics as performed by both girls and boys display how fur technique has developed. 
 Nevertheless they should have no place in pure classical ballets because they are largely acrobatic, and as such have a place only in certain modern works which discard the old conventions in order to display the athleticism and freedom of movement that today's choreographers use as part of their material. 
 Poses  
 As already stated, poses are the nouns in the dance phrases and act as statements (see page 67. 
 It can be that magic moment in such dances as the Rose Adage in The  Sleeping Beauty  when Aurora triumphantly raises her hand from the fourth Prince's grasp and holds the final attitude  for several seconds revealing her complete command over the forces of gravity. 
 There are hundreds of instances of this kind of pose created by many different choreographers. 
 There is the moment in the Act II pas de deux  or Swan Lake  where Odette appears to fly away in an arabesque  before Siegfried seizes her arms and draws her body close to his in an embrace. 
 There are also the exciting poses that come at the end of some of Ashton's pas de deux  as the two characters declare their love, for example, when Oberon cradles Titania in his arms at the end of The Dream  and, even more excitingly, when Colas lifts Lise high on one arm it the end of their dance in Act II of La Fille Mai Gard&eacute;e  as if to crown her queen of the harvest 
 In some modern classical ballets too little attention is paid to the momentary holding of a pose as the focus of a picture to sum up &mdash; as it were &mdash; what has gone before. 
 Similarly, few choreographers make use of a sudden change of &eacute;paulement  to make an emphatic statement. 
 It is not easy to achieve this effect if they do not take into account the dimension and spacing of the steps as well as their particular quality, which must be in tune with the music if it is to make sense. 
 A contradiction in style during this change of &eacute;aulement  or alignment can distort the design. 
 Nevertheless an unusual change of &eacute;aulement  or alignment can add interest and draw attention to a dancer's statement. 
 for example: the swift change from the grand d&eacute;velopp&eacute;  &agrave; la seconde  which Odile makes facing the audience and her sudden turn to arabesque  when she looks straight into the kneeling Siegfried's eyes in the Act II pas de deux of Swan Lake ; it is Odile's triumph for she knows she has won Siegfried's heart. 
 Even more exciting changes of &eacute;aulement  can be found in Ashton's Birthday  Offering  where each soloist dances an old step at a new angle, without breaking the rules or older conventions of nineteenth-century ballet. 
 He then gives an entirely new quality to the class-room exercise on which these encha&icirc;nements  are based. 
 David Bintley, the Royal Ballet's new choreographer, also has a masterly touch when he creates exciting quick changes of &eacute;aulement  in his &bquo;classical&equo; ballets. 
 For example : in Choros  he focuses attention on many ancient Greek dance rituals and accents the playful use of movement whilst at the same time showing that such warlike, athletic courtship and other activities are a wonderful game to be played by the performers. 
 In Consort Lessons  these quick changes of &eacute;aulement  give much greater variety and dimension to the overall design particularly where the solo girl dances with four boys. 
 More recently, in his The Sons of Horus  he has found ways of incorporating the profiled attitudes and poses seen in ancient Egyptian designs with straight turned-in legs, elongated lines and angled arms, all in contrast to the turnedout legs and curving bodies of classical dance. 
 As Ashton and MacMillan in many of their ballets, he has created a style appropriate to one particular ballet. 
 Unless he chooses another ancient Egyptian theme he is unlikely to use the same style again. 
 Ports de bras  
 Petipa's remark that &bquo;without ports de bras  the dancer is dumb&equo; is only one of the wise comments he made when working on his choreographic designs. 
 Fokine echoed this remark when he said &bquo;every step and pose is a gesture&equo; (see page 58). 
 De Valois summed up the ideas of these two great choreographers by saying: &bquo;Only synchronisation of arms and legs will give symmetry to step and pose, strength to the jump, speed to the pirouettes , calm to the adage and spaciousness to the dance.&equo; 
 To ensure that his audience would appreciate each sentence in his dance, petipa usually repeated each at least twice and usually four times. 
 But towards the end of the second or fourth repeat he made some small alteration in the ports de bras  so that the dancer could move easily into the next sentence. 
 He did this without ever losing sight of the contrasts he made between steps of each sequence because these were controlled by the particular rhythm, tempo and quality of the music. 
 This is particularly noticeable in his variations for the Six fairies in The Sleeping Beauty . 
 Petipa clearly reflects in dance the gift that each fairy brings to the Christening. 
 The first Fairy is slow and gracious to denote Beauty; she encircles her face with her hand and displays the line of her arm (the traditional gesture for beauty). 
 The Second Fairy brings Grace and dances slightly faster in such a way that she shows off the lines of her body as it faces forwards and then backwards (the traditional gesture). 
 The Third Fairy dances slowly sur les pointes  and uses conventional hand movements to show she brings the gift of Plenty, just as the godmother at a Russian christening scatters breadcrumbs over the cradle. 
 The Fourth Fairy is a songbird bringing the gift of Language and flutters to and fro as she sings. 
 The Fifth Fairy has fast stabbing movements of feet and arms to bring the gift of Energy. 
 The Lilac Fairy is generously slow and controlled and taps her forehead because she is bringing the gift of Wisdom (the traditional gesture for wise). 
 It is the gesture she uses later to make the Prince think what he must do to wake Aurora. 
 Similar contrasts in the qualities, musical tempi and phrasing within the classical style are found in Ashton's dances for the Four Seasons in Cinderella . 
 Each step can be found in the classical vocabulary. 
 Spring dances lightly and happily with fresh energy in the pale sunlight and soft breezes, with generous ports de bras  to greet the dawn. 
 Summer shows all the languor of a hot, breezeless day as the dancer lazily brushes her hand over her brow. 
 Autumn is blown hither and thither by an ever-changing tempestuous wind. 
 Winter sparkles in the frost (see page 79). 
 The cold air is made even more apparent by the swift footwork when the entire cast jump lightly upwards away from the ground. 
 Admittedly the d&eacute;cor and lighting help to create the illusion of  changing seasons. 
 But if Ashton had not made these very distinctive changes in his ports de bras , the seasonal differences would not have been so notable. 
 The above examples are only a few of those showing how conventional ports de  bras  can be changed. 
 A study of Ashton's ways of using them, or of MacMillan's, reveal how unnecessary it is to keep passing the arms through 1st position. 
 Nor is it necessary always to keep the arms rounded except in arabesque . 
 Examples taken from both choreographers' works describe the particular feelings, moods and emotions of the characters their dancers are portraying. 
 Arms flick to and fro as the Winter Fairy and the Stars of Ashton's Cinderella  give the illusion of twinkling lights in the frosty air. 
 The poignant shaking of the hands above upraised heads followed by the pressing downwards, outwards and then backwards of the arms make an overwhelming plea for pity in MacMillan's Requiem . 
 The fact that the two leading English choreographers create so many unusual ports de bras  as a means of expression is what has made so &mdash; many Royal Ballet dancers so successful in ballets with a story. 
 Coming from a country where the use of the appropriate word is more important than a gesture in daily life, both choreographers have resolved that words must be replaced by gestures within the choreographic design. 
 Nowhere are they more telling than in Ashton's Enigma  Variations  where they explain the sympathy felt by Jaeger (the critic) for Elgar and his Wife or in A Month in the Country  where Ashton communicates the growing feelings of love and frustration of the participants. 
 Other profoundly moving gestures are to be found in MacMillan's The Invitation  and particularly in his Requiem  when he evokes a child's wonder of life in the solo, Pie Jesu  (see page 136). 
 The pointes  The use of pointes  as a delicate finishing touch is not always exploited by today's choreographers, who often use them to display their dancers' ability to &bquo;get up and stay there&equo; &mdash; come what may! 
 The first &bquo;stunt&equo; of this kind in London occurred in a revue at the Hippodrome when the star dancer &bquo;toe-tapped&equo; up and down an escalator. 
 In the next revue the star dancer &bquo;charlestoned&equo; on her pointes . 
 Anyone using steel backs to their shoes can still do this. 
 There is no light and shade and this way of using the pointes  has nothing to do with giving a finishing touch to such dances as those fur Petipa's Aurora and the Six Fairies in The Sleeping Beauty  to make them seem lighter than air. 
 Nor does it resemble the bravura footing of Kitri in the Don Quixote pas de deux  or the passages in Ashton's Ondine  where his ballerina appears to be floating through water. 
 Nor can it be compared with the ballerina's dance in Rhapsodie  where she wafts to and fro as if in a dream before breaking into her solo. 
 The spacing of such steps on pointe  is so minute and so fast that it is not possible to see the change of feet as one succeeds the other. 
 It is this same delicate use of pointes  throughout Ashton's ballets which gives extra finesse to the danseuses'  work. 
 One of the most subtle finishing touches that pointes  give is to Bottom in The Dream  when he is transformed into an ass. 
 Who but Ashton would have thought of giving this country yokel so delicate a movement? 
 Yet how better to characterise his transformation into a &bquo;dear little donkey trotting here and there&equo; with dainty feet? 
 (The words are from an old song.) 
 Pointes  can and do have an enormous part to play in classical ballet because there are so many ways in which they can be used to give character and variety to a role. 
 Some of them are to be found in Checkmate  when the Red Pawns pick their way from square to square, whilst their Queen guides her King to his throne with tender steps. 
  Those movements are in direct contrast to the stronger, vicious and spacious pointes  of the Black Queen and her pawns. 
 The pointes  must not be thought of as a prop on which to balance the body, but as an extra dimension to make dramatic sense of a statement about the character on pointes  and/or to relate in some way to the story or theme. 
 Otherwise they are a mere technicality to be mastered with much patience and practice. 
 Following the rules of classical dance 
 As de Valois said in a lecture to teachers: &bquo;It is better to have a rule to break than no rule at all if chaos is not to reign in the class-room or on the stage.&equo; 
 A choreographer working in the classical style is wise to conform to the traditional principles and rules found valuable through years of experience. 
 They are based on a refinement of the natural movements made by the bones and joints when activated by the muscles, tendons and ligaments found in any human body. 
 The movements were and still are practised because they are designed to display the body as it moves to the best advantage from the audience's point of view. 
 They were and still are designed to give that style of dance spaciousness, calm, balance and grace of form so that the lines drawn during the transition from one step an/or pose to another fills the available space in every dimension. 
 In every encha&icirc;nement  each step an/or pose must be given its appropriate value by way of beginning, climax and end so that its place is justified by its importance to the whole sentence. 
 This does not mean that today's choreographers need follow the conventions laid down by the Renaissance scholars who were more interested in the physical ability and behaviour of courtiers. 
 They were not creative artists but they were and still remain for the most part arbiters of technique and the niceties of perfect performance. 
 The originality of so much of   Ashton's and MacMillan's choreography fur classical ballets lies in the way they follow the basic principles and rules in order to create an infinite variety of encha&icirc;nements  from the traditional vocabulary of steps, and yet discard the conventions. 
 Birthday Offering  Ashton's technical virtuosity (The Royal Ballet) 
 Choreographers who do not adhere strictly to the old conventions of court etiquette realise that their total design will flow more easily because their dancers' behaviour will appear more spontaneous and natural. 
 For example: each soloist need not begin with a formal bow to a king or to the audience, nor end with another bow or considered pose; but such behaviour may be included if the choreographer wishes to locate dance in a particular century and probably a palace in which the story unfolds. 
 Many new members of an audience have been known to object to the applause greeting the last bow. 
 It breaks the continuity of the dance. 
 Other practices that once held up the flow of the dance were the continual closing in 5th position before a new step and the continual moving of the arms through 1st position at every change of weight or during a ports de bras . 
 This last convention is invaluable in early training because it helps to stabilise balance during the transfer from one foot to the other and is also valuable in such ballets as Birthday Offering  as it echoes the period and style of Glazounov's music. 
 But this would get very boring if used too often. 
 Another old rule decreed that dancers never turned their backs on the audience, because all had to face the king, the centre of attention. 
 The turn of a dancer's back can now become part of a beautiful line being made in a total picture. 
 Today's dancers not only dance fur an audience. 
 They also dance for and with each other. 
 And it is their response to each other's movements and their own enjoyment in dance that makes their behaviour appear natural and spontaneous even when they perform difficult technical feats. 
 It is perhaps not surprising that choreographers use the classical style fur most abstract ballets. 
 Even those basing their work on modern techniques seek to create a total picture with all the movements in harmony, as in ancient Greek sculptures. 
 They must, therefore, ensure that the choreographic lines in their design flow through and round the centre of their dancers' bodies and that limbs and heads move in true coordination. 
 They too wish to display their dancers' bodies at their fullest extension, therefore they must give them time, rhythm and space in which to move. 
 Any untoward or awkward transition is immediately noticeable because it destroys the calm dignity that the human body needs if it is to be shown at its best. 
 This does not mean that speed must be avoided, nor that the unexpected need offend the eye. 
 A sudden change of &eacute;aulement , an unusual turn in-out of legs or arms, or quick jumps up and then down to the floor followed by a roll over or even a somersault can accentuate the particular place that unusual movement has in the whole design. 
 Swift changes in the dimensions covered in any linear design are nowhere more obvious than in Ashton's five abstract ballets and his example is now being followed by David Bintley in his Choros  and Consort Lessons . 
 In fact such unusual movements often arouse the audience to gentle laughter as swift changes add a touch of humour as two or more dancers compete to capture the attention of both the audience and their Colleagues. 
 Classical dance patterns 
 In classical ballet the patterns and groupings delineated by the dancers' bodies are usually symmetrical and evenly balanced over the whole stage. 
 This symmetry of design comes with the nature of this style of dance and its historical development. 
 Technically each movement emanates from and is circled round a centre line of  balance. 
 Therefore in daily training it is customary for each exercise to be performed to the left and right, forwards and backwards. 
 But even if a choreographer breaks such regularity when setting a classical ballet he usually balances the pattern made on the floor in one encha&icirc;nement  by another moving in the opposite direction. 
 This balancing of floor patterns is also matched by the rise and fall of the dancers' bodies, heads and arms. 
 It is very noticeable in Petipa's ballets, particularly in all the corps de ballet  work of The Sleeping Beauty . 
 Ashton and MacMillan adopt the same practice in their ballets which can be called classical in the court meaning of the term and whenever the music used is composed according to the formulae for classical composition. 
 They do this even though they may break the conventions from time to time. 
 They do it because they know the audience is watching a constantly evolving picture which is being drawn on, over, across and above a flat stage in front of a background. 
 They know they must fill the empty space with movement, whether there is scenery in the background or where the costumes are at their simplest and the background merely a hint of some venue as, for example, in Symphonic Variations  or Requiem , or even just shafts of light as in Monotones . 
 It is useful for would-be choreographers to study the historical development of classical style so that they may stage a ballet in a traditional way when it has a story firmly linked to a particular time and place. 
 when the members of the newly founded french academies laid down rules for all artists at the court of Louis XIV, they had to conform whether they were painters, sculptors or designers of scenery, props and tapestries. 
 The rules stated that artistic works had to be inspired by the ancient Greek arts, be symmetrical, properly proportioned and balanced round a centre. 
 These edicts were particularly important for all concerned in the opera-ballets in which the king himself frequently appeared at the climax of the action. 
 To prove his importance and so that his entrance was emphasised all entered in order of precedence. 
 He was thus the focus for all performers as well as spectators. 
 His position is now occupied by the ballerina and her partner or a soloist. 
 It should be noted that a similar order of precedence exists in Ashton's Sc&egrave;nes de Ballet  as in Petipa's The Sleeping Beauty  which was supposed to be an evocation of a court ballet at the time of Louis XIV. 
 However, when ballets were performed for the public, professional dancers took the place of courtiers and technical innovations had to be made. 
 The dancers now appeared on a stage before a wide audience and the focus of their attention changed to the whole audience or to the most important performers. 
 They had to adapt their movements to cover a larger space which was like a box with one side only being open to public gaze. 
 They had to pay greater attention to the placing of each step and pose within the new framework. 
 Much time was spent in the formulation of rules to lay down the alignments and &eacute;aulements  which would best display each movement from the audience's point of view. 
 These rules still hold good for choreographers who work in the classical medium and the wise ones never neglect them. 
 If they do, their design loses the calm spaciousness which the style demands, no matter how fast or slow the dance. 
 for example: by making his six dancers appear equally important in Symphonic Variations  Ashton was the first to break away from the convention of making a ballerina the focus of attention. 
 (He repeated this idea for the six dancers in Monotones I and II .) 
 Nevertheless his choreographic plan is so designed that each movement of every dancer, whether as an individual or part of the group, is co-ordinated with the others so that it fits correctly into the overall pattern and within the space allotted by stage,    wings and backcloth which &mdash; in Symphonic Variations  &mdash; delicately echoes the curving lines or the dance. 
 Swan Lake  The classico-romantic ballet of Ivanov and Petipa Right: Odette's arabesque as Swan; below; Odile's arabesque as enchantress (Yvette Chauvir&eacute;, Erik Bruhn; Merle Park, Rudolf Nureyev) 
 The fact that dancers acquired more space within which to move also meant that all 
 terre &agrave; terre  steps could cover more ground. 
 The floor patterns ceased to be confined to the curved, angled or straight lines decreed by the older rules which proposed that certain geometrical figures had great significance. 
 They could only be understood by those educated as courtiers. 
 For example: certain dances had to be composed with two sections only, such as the earliest minuets, which made the shape of a &bquo;Z&equo;, i.e. a diagonally straight line with an acute angle at each end. 
 Later minuets drew the shape of an &bquo;S&equo; as the footwork began to flow more easily. 
 The strictly geometrical pattern of dance is still very important if the musical score retains a traditional structure. 
 Perhaps the best example fur choreographers to study-is Petipa's work for the corps de ballet , particularly in La Bayad&egrave;re  (Scene of the Shades). 
 As the thirty-six girls enter one by one down the ramp at the back of the stage and move into six straight lines across the stage until it is completely filled, there is one continually progressing line of arabesques  and ports de bras . 
 This demonstrates what can be done with two simple movements to hold an audience's attention. 
 Later the mass of dancers merely moves upstage sur les pointes  to a pose and further ports de  bras , then returns downstage to another slowly unfolding set of ports de bras  and arabesques . 
 It is when this mass of dancers divides and moves to the sides that the open space available for dancing is exposed fur the first time. 
 Before this the slowmoving dancers in their wide spreading tutus and veiled arms have hidden it from view. 
 Its exposure prepares the audience for the brilliant solos to follow. 
 When Marie Camargo shortened her skirts and removed the heels from her shoes, jumps and batterie  first entered the vocabulary. 
 These lent brilliance to the footwork which became more intricate and thus more interesting. 
 As music and musical instruments developed and became more flexible, so did the dance. 
 Not only were dancing masters expected to follow their own rules of dance but they also had to conform to the rules of the Acad&eacute;mie Royale de Musique. 
 Later, the introduction of pointes  and the &bquo;ballerina&equo; skirt led to the dominant role of the ballerina at the expense of the male dancer and this brought further changes in the patterns. 
 Many more recent innovations in costume have led to today's all-over leotard and tights which has not only given dancers complete freedom of movement but has given choreographers freedom to design as they will without constricting rules and conventions. 
 But such apparent freedom must be controlled if the dance is to remain  wthin  the limits of the true classical style. 
 Means of expression &mdash; conventional mime 
 An important step in the development of classical ballet for storytelling came with John Weaver's staging of The Loves of Mars and Venus  (London 1717). 
 Be did away with actors and singers to tell the story as had happened hitherto. 
 He insisted that his dancers told their own story by using the many conventional gestures familiar to theatregoers throughout Europe. 
 He explained the gestures in the libretto he prepared for his audience. 
 As a Greek and Latin scholar he had found them described in the works of ancient authors who wrote about the moods, emotions and actions of all the actors involved in their dramas. 
 By 1717 these gestures were accepted practice by actors to reinforce the meaning of the words spoken and particularly by members   of the commedia dell'arte travelling troupes who produced mime plays. 
 In these the expert gestures and extemporised playing of easily recognised characters in certain stock situations were understood by audiences everywhere no matter what the native language because the gestures were so explicit. 
 These gestures were first listed by monks in the tenth century. 
 They described some four hundred used by monks and nuns of certain religious orders during the hours of silence. 
 Some can be seen in religious paintings, particularly those of the Virgin Mary, the Saints and the Angels. 
 some actors today, notably Sir John Gielgud, use them when playing in classical drama and some eighty are still part of a dancer's means of telling a story in classical style. 
 They have become part of the spacious ports de bras  used during the dance. 
 They conform to the same technical rules as ports de bras  and must appear to pass through the centre line of the arm from shoulder to finger-tips and move within the two circles drawn by the elbows and hands. 
 Two of the best examples occur when the Lilac Fairy casts the spell that sends Aurora to sleep in The Sleeping Beauty , (&equo; Until a prince comes, sees her, falls in love and kisses her awake. ') 
 and when Siegfried swears to marry and save Odette after she has told him how the wicked Von Rothbart turned her into a Swan (Swan Lake , Act 11).  
 Sc&egrave;nes de Ballet  Ashton and the older classical style The Ballerina is the focus of attention (Antoinette Sibley, Anthony Dowell and The Royal Ballet) 
 Fokine broke down the artificial practice created by earlier choreographers and his dancers acted as they danced. 
 He felt that to stop the dance and make gestures, no matter how elegantly, destroyed the flow and the ability of the dancers to communicate expressively the meaning of their movements. 
 He began by including some conventional gestures within the ports de bras  of Les Sylphides  and Le Carnaval . 
 He further developed what he called his danced mime or mimed dance in The Firebird  and above all in Petrushka . 
 It is in this field that Ashton and MacMillan have made many innovations in those of their ballets that describe very subtle relationships, feelings and emotions such as A Month in the Country  and Enigma Variations, The  Invitation  and Mayerling . 
 In the last, MacMillan's choreography makes Bratfisch, the prince's coachman, appear as the only sympathetic yet helpless onlooker at the sordid proceedings. 
 Bratfisch attempts to entertain the doomed couple at the last meeting before their death and his sorrow as he comes to the graveside of the murdered. 
 heroine are an object lesson in understatement. 
 So explicit are the tiny gestures and the perfect timing of exits and entrances that the audience is forced to recognise the personal tragedy of a love that spoke no words. 
 Although MacMillan's choreography fur both the above ballets is based on classical technique, it in no way conforms to the old school of dance or conventional mime. 
 To portray specific characters, whether imagined or real (some were known to members of the audience at the first performance of Enigma Variations  and Isadora ), the would-be choreographer can use classical dance as a firm base but must pay more attention to his characters as particular individuals. 
 They live and work in a more varied, often plebeian, environment than that of courtiers in the palace of a prince. 
 The latter, after all, was the stereotype setting fur all classical ballet until 1789, the year of the french Revolution. 
 La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  of 1789 was the first ballet to display the lives and loves of peasants and farmers. 
 Even the popularity of these lesser mortals could not drive aristocrats completely from the stage, particularly in those countries where major theatres continued to be subsidised by Royal Treasuries who largely dictated what choreographers could produce. 
 The style of demi-caract&egrave;re ballet 
 The demi-caract&egrave;re  style has its roots in classical technique, but must be coloured by more clearly defined and individual movements which allow the dancers to show they are playing the part of some character who has some claim to live in the real world and therefore can be recognised as such. 
 In other words they usually, &bquo;dance classically from their feet to the waist and above that are free to express themselves as people of more definite behaviour, work, play and age&equo; (de Valois in a lecture to teachers, 1947). 
 The head, body and arms of the characters portrayed should show the status they have in the society to which they belong whether it is rural, urban or fantastic, as well as their behaviour, customs, work or play. 
 Dauberval's La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;  (1789) was the first ballet in this style. 
 Dauberval's exclusion from the Acad&eacute;mie Royale (later the Paris Opera) was justified by those in charge because they felt his idea of making farmers, peasants and the like the heroes and heroines of his ballets was beneath the dignity of an opera house whose stage had hitherto been occupied with the deeds of noble heroes, heroines and courts. 
 Bournonville coloured his ballets with movements characteristic of many different personalities and nationalities. 
 In his particular style of  demi-caract&egrave;re  dance he used classical footwork for most of the time but, from the waist upwards through the body, arms and head, he tried to convey how his performers worked and played in the environment to which they belonged. 
 for example: in Napoli  they were Italian, in Far from Denmark  they were Danes influenced by the dance of South America. 
 This way of creating more plebeian characters is fully demonstrated in Ashton's comic masterpiece La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e , where this style of dance is shown in two different aspects, the light-hearted yet technically highly expert dancing of Lise and Colas and the comically eccentric work of Alain and the Cock and Hens. 
 Their dance is very different from the work of petipa, whose suggestion of demi-caract&egrave;re  is seen when the Songbird and Bluebird dance in The Sleeping Beauty , where the fluttering of the hands is meant to indicate that birds fly and sing. 
 Ashton's Cock and Hens come straight from the farmyard and not the Imperial Ballet. 
 They squawk and scratch with unturned-out feet in temps lev&eacute;s  and batterie , elbows flapping and heads pecking and poking. 
 Petipa's ideas about birds were followed by Ivanov's Odette in Swan Lake  and later in Fokine's unforgettable The Dying Swan  fur Anna Pavlova. 
 But by the time Fokine produced The Firebird  he had developed his mimed dance much further. 
 It had become the most important part of his choreography. 
 His Firebird flew and still flies in all her glory before being trapped pitifully in the arms of the Tsarevich. 
 Her release sends her soaring in grands jet&eacute;s en avant  through the magic garden. 
 This flight of the magic bird held and stili holds audiences spellbound. 
 Ashton's version of La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  is a perfect twentieth-century example of demi-caract&egrave;re  ballet. 
 So are de Valois' The Rake's Progress , Cranko's Pineapple Poll  and Robbins' The Concert . 
 However despite the great variety of demi-caract&egrave;re  ballets staged since 1789 there appear to be only three main sources of gesture which contribute to a particular style for a particular ballet. 
 These have led to the same stereotyping of characters as happens in classical ballet. 
 The three sources are: 
 Firstly 
 the secular, moral and emotional behaviour of characters found in rural or urban communities; 
 Secondly 
 the traditional dances and customs of a particular country that can give local colour and atmosphere to a plot or theme; 
 Thirdly 
 gestures and behaviour from work activities in rural areas (landowners, farmers and peasants) or in urban areas (merchants, innkeepers and so on) or from the professions (army, navy, medicine, law). 
 Characters in demi-caract&eacute;re  ballets 
 Literally translated demi-caract&egrave;re  means &bquo;half character&equo;, but that gives little understanding of its implications in ballet. 
 It should describe how the characters, usually non-aristocratic or less educated, express moods, emotions and actions as they would in real life. 
 The types of character and the plots in which they play have existed since the Dorian mimes first began to lay the foundations of the theatre. 
 The art of mime was developed by the commedia dell'arte and is still being developed by such artists as Marcel Marceau and the mime theatres of Poland and Czechoslovakia. 
 Actors in travelling companies used to set up their stage in a town or village, mix among the inhabitants, watching and listening to the local news, gossip and scandal. 
  They became adept at portraying well-known types such as the domineering wife, her hen-pecked husband, the poor widow anxious to get a son or daughter wed, the miser, the guardian or the severe nurse and at spotting any odd person or antics. 
 They were also fond of aping the grand manners of servants to aristocratic households and rich farmers. 
 Each player in these groups was engaged for his or her ability to perform one type of role, therefore the playing was predictable because there was a particular way of acting out the various situations. 
 These often required jokes, tricks and special ploys, all of which were performed in dumb show, something at which the great mimes Grock and Charlie Chaplin were expert. 
 Foremost amongst the travelling players were the Serious Lovers who were to become the danseurs nobles  and ballerinas of classical ballet, because they were always noble heroes and heroines. 
 Their two servants, known as the Comic Lovers or, later, Harlequin and Columbine, were to become the danseurs classiques  or dexi-  caract&egrave;re  dancers. 
 In ancient Greek myth Harlequin made his first appearance as Hermes (or Mercury), the messenger of the gods and himself the god of all animals and travellers. 
 This heritage gave and still attributes to him the ability to move fast, avoiding all obstacles, to do his master's bidding. 
 When in trouble he could, like a god, make himself invisible or turn himself into an animal. 
 Shakespeare's Puck, as envisaged by Ashton in The Dream , is a wonderful example of Harlequin's role. 
 It was the aspect of Harlequin as servant that intrigued Massine, who employed it in his own portrayal of the factotums, bar-tenders and servants in several works. 
 Ashton demonstrated Harlequin's technical expertise when he was transformed into Colas, a farmer, dancing with his shepherd's crook. 
 Ashton did the same when Daphnis competed for Chlo&euml;'s attention in his interpretation of Ravel's Daphnis and Chlo&euml; . 
 When the character of Harlequin, the Comic Lover, had become familiar in England he was quickly promoted to lead the pantomimes; nowhere in ballet does he rise to more commanding heights than as Captain Belaye in Cranko, s Pineapple Poll , where he takes on the superior airs and manners of the British Navy and becomes the apple of every girl's eye. 
 Columbine too started life as a servant of the gods and gradually rose in rank from waiting on the aristocracy to conspiring with Harlequin in such ballets as The Good-  Humoured Ladies , where the two of them appear as serving maid and waiter. 
 Columbine became Mother Simone's daughter, Lise, in La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  where she makes butter, churns and helps to spin. 
 She is also there as the inquisitive fun-loving Swanhilda in Copp&eacute;lia  and displays a humble origin in Cranko's Pineapple Poll . 
 She is not, however, always the fun-loving Columbine of Fokine's Carnaval . 
 In de Valois' The Rake's Progress  she confirms her eighteenth-century origin as an innocent serving wench whom the Rake has dallied with and then discarded. 
 Columbine is rarely seen in so tragic a role. 
 That is why she elicits so much sympathy. 
 She is the only decent character among the money-grabbers and hangers-on surrounding the Rake. 
 Her role has the same sobering effect on the atmosphere of the ballet as that of Bratfisch, the Count's valet, in Mayerling . 
 Harlequin, in his earlier embodiment as Hermes, was the god of animals and this idea has been another valuable source of choreographic material. 
 Ashton's design for Pepe, the dog, in The Wedding Bouquet  was bettered when he created the Town and Bad Mice, Pigling Bland and the other animals in the film The Tales of Beatrix Potter . 
 He used all the steps in the classical vocabulary named after Harlequin's early ability as  dancer-acrobat to change himself into an animal. 
 Amongst the steps are sauts de carpe , temps de poisson, pas de cheval  and so on. 
 from the same source come such diverse creatures as Massine's poodles in La Boutique Fantasque , a delicious pair of goats in Ashton's Sylvia  and of course the squawking Cock and Hens in La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e . 
 It was an easy step for Ashton to respond to the sadness attending the closure of the Covent Garden Market in central London. 
 His delicious Pas des L&eacute;gumes  performed at a special performance to mark the market's passing brought to mind the long history not only of the &bquo;fruit and veg&equo;, but also of Harlequin, Columbine and their colleagues of the commedia dell'arte, inhabitants for many years of the Theatre Royal, Drury Lane, and the King's Theatre, Drury Lane, where the first ballets d'action  were staged. 
 Giving quality to the dance through music, patterns and traditions 
 One of the most successful ways of giving a different quality to the steps and poses of classical dance and of transforming them into demi-caract&egrave;re  style is to relate them intimately to appropriate music. 
 Every country has its own way of performing the traditional dances which go hand in hand with certain musical characteristics. 
 Choreographers should note the particular relationships between steps and notes, encha&icirc;nements  and phrases and how strong or weak beats affect the rhythm. 
 They cannot be too strict about this relationship, for the score, whether commissioned or arranged, will only give some flavour of the traditional ways of singing and dancing. 
 This can be easily recognised if Bizet's music for Carmen  is compared with De Falla's fur The Three-Cornered Hat . 
 Yet the former has sufficient Spanish flavour, as does the Minkus score fur Don Quixote , for audiences to believe that characters really would perform in the way they do to the kind of music provided. 
 When Dauberval removed to Bordeaux, the audience, like those elsewhere in france, was largely unaware of the grandeur of aristocratic entertainment. 
 It welcomed the new ideas in La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  because the characters portrayed were familiar and were living in the farms and vineyards. 
 Dauberval is said to have borrowed steps and gestures from such people to give his ballet greater reality. 
 By so doing he originated a style of dance which owed its liveliness to the way such people behaved and danced in real life. 
 Even so, he did not fully dispense with the technique of the classical school. 
 He realised, as did later choreographers, that the steps and patterns of such material had to be properly displayed to the audience, not just danced for themselves. 
 In other words he opened up the circles, squares and longways sets to show what gave rhythm and life to the movements. 
 It is this opening up and exposure of traditional dance that is so important when choreographers attempt to give a realistic atmosphere to the style and expression of their work. 
 They should remember that they are suggesting and not giving the actual location. 
 In real life the onlookers are part of the activity and usually join in. 
 In ballets such as Petrushka  and Rodeo  they are wandering around, watching and occasionally responding to the dancers' efforts. 
 But audiences sitting and watching can only join in the fun in their imagination and if the dancers are sufficiently out-going. 
 Choreographers like Bournonville often borrowed from regional dancing, which he eagerly studied wherever he travelled. 
 It is useful for would-be choreographers to examine his ballets and discover that he mostly set them in countries possessing easily recognised characteristics. 
 If his dances are compared with those derived from similar sources by later choreographers, Bournonville's generalisations of style become evident. 
 The most outstanding are Scottish, Italian and Spanish. 
  Scottish style  The Royal Danish Ballet's production of La Sylphide  is evidence of Bournonville's imaginative use of the Scot's quick light footwork and &bquo;capers&equo; as well as the very distinctive Highland ports de bras , which help the dancer to sustain balance. 
 To these features he added purely classical batterie, grands jet&eacute;s en avant  and en attitude , cabrioles  and quick glissades  into &eacute;chapp&eacute;s &agrave; la seconde  and swift changes of &eacute;aulement . 
 He also took care to make the patterns of his dances as interesting as in Scottish country dance. 
 Another example of this stereotyped Scottish style is danced by Swanhilda in Copp&eacute;iia . 
 Much later, Ashton made a delightful caricature of it in his &bquo;Scottish Rhapsody&equo; in Fa&ccedil;ade . 
 Yet oddly enough when Massine staged his Donald of  the Burthens  with the help of a Scottish expert to guide him through the traditional steps and figures it was not a success, possibly because too much reliance was placed. 
 on authenticity and not enough on the sheer fantasy of the story. 
 In his Scottish dances Bournonville highlighted the Highland characteristic of an upwards lift from the floor on the first beat of a bar whereas in English and French dance the movement is downwards. 
 This makes the Scottish footwork look very light and easy particularly as it is allied to the steps of petit  and grand allegro  he also used. 
 Another important feature is the absolute co-ordination of the arms as they change in the ports de bras , often moving through the 1st position. 
 The change usually occurs on the first beat of a bar or phrase, which eliminates any fussiness when the footwork is intricate. 
 Ashton maintained these formal changes in his frivolous &bquo;Scottish Rhapsody&equo;. 
 Italian style  
 Bournonville's Napoli  is an absolute feast of Italian styled demi-caract&egrave;re  dance which comes to a superb conclusion during the wedding celebration of the hero and heroine. 
 The whole cast muster in the market place before breaking into extravagant variations of the tarantella. 
 Legs fly over tambourines held steady by one or the other partner. 
 Round they spin, arms clasping each other's waists. 
 Boy chases girl and catches her in a fond embrace without pausing as they cover the stage with footwork of a speed rarely seen elsewhere. 
 Bournonville's Flower Festival  is a slower, slightly more classical variation, as was Petipa's Neapolitan Dance in Swan Lake . 
 Massine's quicker more set version of the tarantella in La Boutique Fantasque  shows exactly the same features as those listed above. 
 Most traditional Italian dances are performed to a 3/4 or 6/8 time signature, the tarantella or salterello being recognised everywhere as being the most typical of the country as a whole. 
 These both include many steps with the so-called &bquo;dotted&equo; rhythm i.e. in 3/4 the dancer steps on the first beat, holds on the second and briefly takes weight on the other foot on the third before stepping onwards. 
 If this is danced to 6/8 it leads to the very swift footwork needed fur Massine's tarantella and Ashton's version of the Italian pas de deux  in Swan Lake , a miracle of timing and quick changes of &eacute;auiement . 
 This type of dancing to a &bquo;dotted rhythm&equo; also leads to many steps where the dancers hop continuously on one leg holding the other firmly in attitude devant , retir&eacute;e , or stretched backwards. 
 Like Scottish ports de bras , those of Italy are very simple, the arms changing places after each sequence of dotted steps or hops. 
 As traditional Italian dances are often sung, the performers pose solemnly fur a second or two at the end of each phrase. 
 This was a feature widely used by nineteenth-century Italian balletmasters and by Bournonville. 
 But the latter's pause was often to hold the dancers in perfect 5th positions of both arms and feet. 
  Spanish style  
 The stereotyped Spanish style is possibly seen at its best in Petipa's Don Quixote , most particularly in the famous pas de deux  fur the ballerina and her partner. 
 The tone is set by the continual use of the pose with head held high, back slightly arched, arms in closed 4th or a stretch fully upwards in 5th sur les pointes  for Kitri or on demi-pointes  for Basil. 
 The brilliant bravura variation when Kitri springs lightly forwards sur les  pointes  whilst fanning herself and Basil attempts to make his zapateado (heel-tapping) appear authentic by the slightly crouching pose of his body, add even greater panache to their efforts. 
 Swanhilda strikes similar poses with her mantilla and fan in Copp&eacute;lia  and so do the Spanish dancers in Swan Lake . 
 However Massine in The Three-Cornered  Hat  took an entirely different view. 
 His ballet is not demi-caract&egrave;re . 
 His choreography is firmly based on the authentic folk and flamenco dances he studied in Spain. 
 His work must, therefore, be considered as one of the very few character/national ballets of its time, like the Russian ballets of Fokine. 
 Elsewhere reference has been made to the difference between Spanish style and flamenco style (see page 59) which belongs to the Spanish gipsies from whom has also developed what is known as gipsy character dance. 
 There is however a third style of Spanish dance known as Spanish Court dance. 
 This developed after the French Revolution of 1789 when many french dancing masters fled to Spain to become dancing masters to the aristocratic families. 
 This led to a courtly style of social dance which Petipa studied and taught fur some six years in Madrid before returning to St. Petersburg as balletmaster. 
 His Spanish dance has therefore many authentic features seen through the eyes of a master classical teacher. 
 Amongst the most notable are the poses finishing each musical phrase and the careful relation of the well-marked beats on heels to the beats of the music. 
 The poses come as pauses at the end of each sequence, the dancer then changing position before beginning a new phrase, as if the guitarist were resting his fingers fur a moment. 
 The steps also diminish or broaden as the tunes grow softer or louder. 
 But petipa kept to well-defined limits of courtly behaviour and never fell into an extravagant style, even in the market place scene of Don Quixote . 
 Hungarian style  
 Towards the end of his life Petipa made much more use of demi-caract&egrave;re  elements in his work and strengthened the characteristics of the steps he used. 
 He incorporated many Hungarian features in his production of Raymonda  (last Act). 
 Be showed how intimately the traditional could influence the dances for his corps de ballet . 
 Couples enter high-booted in an elaborate but genuinely traditional promenade. 
 The working leg is thrust outwards on the first beat of a bar, heels click and stamp to accent the appropriate beats. 
 Although the solo danseuses  perform sur les pointes , they still mark the appropriate beats by stabbing their toes into the floor, i.e. they dance a series of retir&eacute;s pass&eacute;s  forwards or backwards without descending and use typical Hungarian ports de bras . 
 These are also strongly accented as the arms straighten into 2nd position before being bent, with hands sometimes clasped behind the head, sometimes placed akimbo on the waist or sometimes with one on the waist and the other behind the large bow at the back of the head-dress. 
 The danseuses  perform some of the traditional steps such as the sideways moving pas de bourr&eacute;e  danced sur les pointes  and the sideways cabrioie  rarely used in classical ballet.  
 The unusual feature of traditional Hungarian style is the strong distinction made between the two parts of most folk dances. 
 They usually start with a promenade kept to a strictly slow tempo (the lassu) and then break into an extremely fast movement of turns, pas de bourr&eacute;e  and very controlled hops (the friss). 
 It is this strong contrast between the two parts which is so important to maintain whether the dances are in demi-caract&egrave;re  or character (authentic) style. 
 This contrast was used by Petipa to great advantage and demands a very musical dancer to display his brilliant choreography in Raymonda . 
 Oriental styles  
 Some of the most fascinating demi-caract&egrave;re  ballets are those where the choreographer has sought inspiration from oriental dance. 
 This can be fairly easy to achieve because a brief study of ancient Egyptian friezes shows exactly how to adapt the movements depicted to the turned-out legs of classical dance. 
 Petipa attempted this in The Daughter of Pharaoh . 
 This type of choreography was taken up by later music-hall acts whose very eccentric soft shoe, sand dances before a background of pyramids and palm trees aroused much laughter. 
 However when Fokine staged A  Night of Egypt  (later Cleopatra ) he went a great deal further and developed a more particular Eastern style inspired by the performance of some Siamese dancers. 
 He started by sketching numerous frescoes and statuettes he found in the Hermitage Museum, Leningrad. 
 From such ideas he formed dances which did away with pointes  but retained much of the classical footwork which he co-ordinated with the less familiar action of the arms and hands. 
 Thus the angular and straight lines drawn by the legs were also drawn simultaneously by the arms and hands, which were allowed to cross the centre line of the body, very often with a twist sideways at the waist. 
 This made the dancers appear as if they were a moving frieze. 
 Something that David Bintley was also to achieve later in his Sons of Horus  (1985). 
 Ashton too has created two oriental styled ballets in which the delicacy of the hands and arms drew attention to the way such subtle movements can take the place of words. 
 His interest in ports de bras  nearly always produces something new to say, whether it is to tell a story, describe the characters and/or create a style exclusive to one work. 
 Japanese  The first of Ashton's ballets in oriental style was Madame Chrysanth&egrave;me , in which he utilised many traditional japanese gestures made more fascinating by emphasis of his dainty ballerina's footwork. 
 Elaine Fifield did not always keep her feet fully pointed nor knees stretched, even when on pointe . 
 At times the supporting leg would bend when on balance, whilst the working one was also bent with the foot turned up at the ankle during certain poses, or when performing a rond de jambe en  dehors  or en dedans  during the pas de deux . 
 MacMillan created a very strong style of Japanese demi-caract&egrave;re  dance in Rituals . 
 In the first scene he showed how men and boys prepared for combat and self-defence. 
 This was followed by a wedding staged as if the Bride and Groom were being manipulated as puppets by a group of servants, a particular japanese theatrical tradition. 
 The final scene was a formal celebration and prayer fur a wife giving birth. 
 The movements were strongly influenced by the stylised Bugako players and were appropriate to each scene, but oddly enough the whole appeared too static, as if a series of japanese prints was being paraded before the audience. 
 At this time a MacMillan ballet was expected to be, above all, about dancing. 
 The apparent ritualistic  posing, although strongly performed and easy to understand, did not appeal in the same way as his Song of the Earth . 
 Nevertheless the extraordinary use MacMillan made of the traditions of the japanese theatre with its warlike ritual drills for selfdefence showed how much more masculine his choreographic design was then becoming. 
 This was no better reflected than in his creation of A Distant Drummer  with its horrific theme of man's inhumanity to man, where ritual warlike movements were applied to the jack-booted soldiers of Nazi Germany. 
 Persian  The second of Ashton's oriental ballets was La F&eacute;ri  (music by Dukas) for 
 Margot Fonteyn and Michael Somes. 
 Here La P&eacute;ri's ports de bras  were flowing and sensual yet almost innocent in order to express the magical vision Askender, the poet, was seeing in his dream. 
 These gestures can be seen in many Persian miniatures, some of them at the British Museum. 
 They are also part of certain styles of Indian dance where gestures are explicit in conveying the beauty of the world, of women and of - love. 
 In such dances physical contact between lovers rarely if ever takes place. 
 Ashton broke this all-but-written law and communicated the exotic atmosphere of the dream but there was little to express the passion of love, which he would later convey in such works as A Month in the Country . 
 Chinese  The most interesting of present-day ballets inspired by oriental sources is 
 MacMillan's Song of the Earth  (music by Mahler). 
 It is an interpretation of and a parallel to the singing of seven Chinese poems about the ever transient phases in the life of Man. 
 MacMillan has chosen to incorporate the delicate sometimes intricate turnings of the arms and hands used by the actor-dancers in the traditional Chinese theatre. 
 But his choreography is no longer like that of earlier demi-caract&egrave;re  styles such as that of the Chinese dance in The Nutcracker . 
 Together with the intricate and expressive ports de bras  he allows his dancers' feet, legs and body to take on different shapes and lines as the design unfolds to interpret the words. 
 The poems speak of Youth, of Beauty', of Love, of Parting and of Death, the last of which is not tragic but full of promise that life will be reborn. 
 The solo man and woman are always accompanied by a masked figure known in China as &bquo;the Eternal One&equo; and in England as &bquo;the Messenger of Death&equo;. 
 The words also speak of the joy and fun of friendship, of looking into a pool of knowledge, of drinking and lastly of a tender farewell. 
 MacMillan has made this last song a welcome to the future as the three protagonists quietly and slowly come forwards, their hands linked, gradually raising their heads as if greeting a new day. 
 few ballets have so fully interpreted the deepest thoughts of a poet. 
 The words speak a philosophy known and believed in China for many centuries. 
 Nautical styles  
 Although few characters from the professions appear to influence demi-caract&egrave;re  dance (their activities are usually confined to character works), the Navy and Army have regularly inspired choreographers. first comes the Navy'. 
 Versions of the traditional hornpipe danced by sailors of many nationalities are featured in many ballets because it is so descriptive of the very particular way in which seamen walk and do the many different jobs that have to be done on any kind of boat. 
 The hornpipe is not exclusive to England, which many seem to think, even though Petipa in his ballet The Daughter of Pharaoh  included a hornpipe to represent the Thames in a spectacular scene where the four greatest rivers of the world met &bquo;under the sea&equo;. 
 Each country with a sailing history has its own version which differs only slightly from that      of others. 
 The difference lies in the rhythm of the pipe tune to which it is danced. 
 But much more can be made out of its well-recognised movements. 
 A particularly fine example is that designed by de Valois for the Sailor in The Rake's Progress . 
 It is easy to understand why he is in the madhouse. 
 He is unsteady through drink and blind in one eye. 
 Song of the Earth  MacMillan's view of modern dance and interpretation of words Left above: the boy's dance; left below: 'of Love'; above: &bquo;The eternal round of man's love, life and death&equo; (Natalia Makarova, David Wall, Anthony Dowell and The Royal Ballet) 
 A brilliant example of variations on a hornpipe theme is to be found in Cranko's Pineapple Poll , which has very strong, even coarse elements when danced by the sailors before it is slightly refined by the gallant Captain Belaye. 
 But when Poll, dressed in her sailor's uniform, proceeds to dance &bquo;ship-shape&equo; sur les pointes , with the Wives similarly equipped, it is easy to recognise the feminine touch that classical technique can give to their attempts at boat drill. 
 Among the steps they perform are the traditional &bquo;hauling up the anchor, paying out the rope, hoisting the flag, going on lookout after climbing the rigging&equo; and, of course, &bquo;taking the salute&equo; &mdash; a little haphazardly. 
 Military style  
 Today very little military demi-caract&egrave;re  style exists in Western ballet except in such American works as Balanchine's Stars and Stripes , but it played a large part during the nineteenth century. 
 It was then taken over by such excellent troupes as the Tiller and Jackson Girls who toured widely over Europe and America and later by the Drum Majorettes, who have also appeared in Balanchine's works. 
 One glimpse of this welldisciplined style can be seen in Lichine's Graduation Ball , where both boys and girls march in formation and make other military manoeuvres. 
 It is this aspect of military style that is well worth studying for the precision with which a battalion of soldiers makes patterns such as can be seen at the British ceremony of &bquo;Trooping the Colour&equo;. 
 Something like this event was once staged at the Alhambra in the famous ballet Soldiers of the Queen  at the height of the Boer War (1900). 
 The scene represented an inspection and Grand March on the Queen's Parade, Aldershot. 
 It was performed by the combined bands, drums and fifes, and some two hundred and fifty soldiers from thirty infantry regiments as well as a corps de ballet  whose dances were arranged by Lucia Cormani. 
 History does not relate what steps she used. 
 Balanchine employed every variety of pas march&eacute;s  at every possible speed in Stars  and Stripes . 
 Every part of the foot was placed first on the flat and then up on pointes , and the working leg was raised to every possible height and angle. 
 It was certainly a spectacular display of what dancers could do with their legs whilst merely marching but the ports de bras  were very limited and merely swung at the sides or sprang to attention. 
 Means of expression &mdash; occupational gesture 
 An English style of demi-caract&euml;re  dance is not always very obvious except in the hornpipe and in Ashton's Harvest, Maypole and Morris Stick Dance in La Fille Mal  Gard&eacute;e , where the last two vary very little from the traditional versions. 
 He rearranged the Stick Dance because of its vital link in the story. 
 fellow peasants carry Colas into Mother Simone's kitchen hidden in sheaves of corn so that he can meet Lise. 
 They intend to carry out Lise and Colas by the same means. 
 The trick does not work, but at least it leads to the hiding of Colas in Lise's bedroom and the awful discovery of the two of them together just as Alain has received the key and goes to claim his bride. 
 Many English stick dances, like those elsewhere, are believed to be ancient rituals in which the performers are enacting some job necessary for the well-being of the    community. 
 Such dances are the source of &bquo;occupational gesture&equo; (mime) and use movements which describe a certain work process. 
 It is probably not realised how English this type of gesture has become and can be seen in many English ballets. 
 It is not formally structured as it is in the ballets of other countries where choreographers are more likely to present the traditional dance itself, slightly adapted for the stage with the footwork more complicated. 
 That is if they are creating a demi-caract&egrave;re  and not a national ballet (see page 120). 
 The Rake's Progress  English National Ballet and de Valois' interpretation of Hogarth's evils of the day Right: the Betrayed Girl; below: the last meeting in Bedlam (Margaret Barbieri; Margaret Barbieri, Desmond Kelly) 
 A wonderful example of an English demi-caract&egrave;re  dance is that of de Valois fur the Betrayed Girl in The Rake's Progress . 
 Here in the front cloth she is seen at her embroidery, sadly waiting and earning her living to pay off the Rake's debts. 
 In and out goes the needle, the body, head and foot follow the direction of the hand as it pulls the thread through the canvas. 
 She sighs, pauses, then in and out goes the needle again and again. 
 The whole dance is controlled in rhythm, gesture and pattern as in all English folk dance. 
 It also conveys the mood and emotions of the Girl, a very rare happening in true folk dance. 
 The participants in folk dance can and certainly do show elation. 
 In La  Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  Mother Simone does this when she triumphantly finishes her Clog Dance on the arms of her more graceful neighbours, just as all the guests but Alain do after the Betrothal and they all dance out, arms linked to celebrate. 
 The gestures of such pastoral characters as Lise and Colas in La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  have already been noted (-see page 100) as well as that of Lise churning and helping her Mother to spin. 
 But the conventional gesture &bquo;to spin' has often been used in ballet. 
 In The Sleeping Beauty  Carabosse shows Aurora what a spindle is for and Aurora later shows how she can use it before she pricks her finger. 
 In Giselle , Giselle shows Bathilde how she works. 
 There are many instances of this use of the single gesture for spinning or threading a needle and making a stitch or two which are easily understood and recognised by an audience. 
 A careful study of the gestures of the characters in The  Rake's Progress  reveal the trades of the tailor, jockey, dancing-master, gambler and others. 
 There are many kinds of occupation from which choreographers can and do borrow. 
 These can roughly be classified as coming from work, hobbies and pastimes. 
 The activity involved may be heavy or light or something with a specialised technique. 
 For example, there is a very great deal of difference between sawing a large log by hand and stitching, or between playing a game of tennis and a game of cards. 
 Embroidery requires a specialised technique, so does ice skating. 
 In deciding to use a particular occupational process in his design a choreographer has four considerations: 
 1 
 He must decide the general outline of the process as he sees it in terms of movement. 
 Traditionally every hornpipe begins as the sailors come on deck and dance figures-of-eight round the bollards before setting to work. 
 Every harvest dance begins with the workers circling the field before moving into a straight line and beginning to reap. 
 2 
 He must select and contrast the strong and weak or tensed and relaxed movements in order to give them tempo, rhythm and expressive quality. 
 The second step of every hornpipe is &bquo;hauling up the anchor&equo;: the sailors stand one behind the other in line, bend down, grasp the rope with both hands, haul it backwards and then relax a moment before repeating the grasp and haul. 
 To sweep a floor the broom must be firmly but lightly used to push the dust forwards, then carefully brought backwards just off the floor before repeating the push. 
 This is  what Lise does in Mother Simone's kitchen in La FilleMal Garde&eacute;  and Cinderella in her kitchen before she dances with the broom. 
 3 
 He must balance the movements one against the other to give proportion and emphasis as well as dimension. 
 Each gesture in a sequence must be carefully timed so that it is of proper value to the whole. 
 Once the sailor has &bquo;climbed the rigging&equo;, which is usually an energetic process, he &bquo;looks out&equo;, remaining stationary except for a slight sway as the boat sails out of harbour. 
 Lise's dance when she sweeps the floor before helping Mother Simone to spin is an excellent example of how the subtle timing of gesture can be and is helped by the appropriate choice of music. 
 4 
 He must include all the necessary details which will suggest the purpose of the gestures. 
 There can be few better examples of how to include all the necessary details than in de Valois' dance for the Betrayed Girl in The Rake's Progress . 
 Not only does it demonstrate the work process but also the mood and emotion of the dancer. 
 This is also true of occupational dances in other ballets, for example in those for the tradespeople in Ashton's Cinderella . 
 To some extent the heroes and heroines of classical ballet also use occupational gesture when they indicate hores riding, hunting, lute-playing and singing. 
 But by and large these are only examples of the gesture as an item on its own, MacMillan is one of   the rare choreographers who has used occupational gesture as an integral part of the dance. 
 For example, in Romeo and Juliet  this aspect of his choreography is seen at its finest in the pas de trois  fur Romeo, Mercutio and Benvolio before they enter the Capulet ball. 
 They ride, fence and parry with swords, and sing a song with a lute. 
 The gestures they make are at one with their interesting footwork. 
 The footwork appears again and again in different encha&icirc;nements  during their other appearances, notably in the short solo for Mercutio when he dances in a more tragic vein just before he dies. 
 Les Patineurs  Ballets with a theme &mdash; Ashton's view of skater's. 
 &bquo;All go together&equo; (The Royal Ballet) 
 Ashton, too, has made vivid use of occupational gesture from time to time as, for example, when his &bquo;Swiss Miss&equo; milks her cow with the help of the three boys in Fa&ccedil;ade . 
 One of his finest examples of occupational gesture as the foundation of a ballet remains Les Patineurs . 
 Here he creates the many happy and not so happy incidents that can occur on a skating rink where even a professional can &bquo;miss a trick&equo;. 
 Jerome Robbins has a knack of using occupational gesture in many of his works and most particularly in The Concert , where the well-observed behaviour of the many different concert-goers arouses much laughter. 
 Those in the audience who have had to suffer such behaviour in a concert hall, whilst trying to listen to a brilliant musician, know that his remarks about certain characters are only too true. 
 Whatever occupational gesture (mime) a choreographer chooses to use in ballet, it must be envisaged in terms of dance without the use of props. 
 Even such mundane tasks as eating or drinking have found a place in some ballets. 
 Because on the stage they acquire importance, they must be seen to have a proper purpose. 
 This is usually to throw light on the character being played or to create the right atmosphere for the location of the action and for the expressive action required for the unfolding of the plot or theme.   
 The Concert  Robbins' view of concert-goers. 
 The Listeners (The Royal Ballet) 
 The romantic style 
 The romantic style is the most poetic of all because its movements must express moods, emotions and actions that are reactions to the circumstances and events which surround and occur to characters during the unfolding of plot, theme or music 
 There are two kinds of romantic ballet. 
 firstly, there are ballets of the older type which depict the struggle between the world of the flesh and the world of the spirit and which were usually inspired by a fairy tale or legend, e.g. La Sylphide  and Giselle . 
 Secondly, there are modern works which are based on tales of passionate love, often frustrated or unrequited, and usually ending in tragedy, e.g. Romeo and Juliet, A  Month in the Country  and The Invitation . 
 The two kinds of romantic ballet 
 A The first kind developed out of the Romantic movement which emerged at a time when artists of all kinds rebelled against being servants in wealthy households, obeying their patrons' orders and being regulated by religious, political and other advisers. 
 They broke away to work independently and become their own masters. 
 Inspired by Dante's Divine Comedy  and the sad tale of his love fur Beatrice and by medieval ballads about a knight saving a damsel in distress, their works told of lovers in search of a beloved, a metaphor for the &bquo;artist in search of his muse&equo;. 
 But the beloved was unattainable either because she belonged to another or because, like his muse, she forever eluded him as she was only a figment of his imagination. 
 Such romantic stories and ballads inspired many nineteenth-century ballets, directly or indirectly, from Petipa's Raymonda , Massine's Symphonie Fantastique  and Lenau's Don Juan  (to the tone poem by Strauss which was later to inspire an Ashton ballet) to La Sonnambula  (Balanchine's ballet based on Bellini's opera which was based on a Walter Scott novel, see page 33). 
 Such plots gave choreographers scope to stage dances in which the world of the flesh could be exemplified by folk style or demi-caract&egrave;re  dances and that of the world of the spirit with the newly developed &bquo;flight sur les pointes&equo;  and softly lyrical ports de  bras  which epitomised the heroine's ethereal being. 
 This style allowed other-worldly figures to express themselves more naturally than in classical ballet where technical precision and command over conventional gesture were necessary. 
 Such romantic libretti required a choreographer to have a greater understanding of the significance of each movement, particularly if the protagonists came from different classes or environments as in La Sylphide  (a farmer and a fairy) or Giselle  (a count and a peasant). 
 Fokine's advice to those wishing to create the romantic style of dance was much as fur demi-caract&egrave;re  when he said: &bquo;The choreographer should base his design on classical technique from the feet to the waist, but above that the dancer's head, body and arms must be free to express the moods, emotions and actions of the character in the story or theme to be communicated.&equo; 
 This style was first created by Taglioni for his daughter Marie. 
 The tale of La Sylphide  gave him an opportunity to exploit her expressive arms and face as well as her ability to dance sur les pointes . 
 Perrot developed the style in his dances fur Carlotta Grisi in Giselle . 
 It was then expanded by Fokine and used in both grave and gay moods in Les Sylphides  and Le Carnaval , where it is particularly expressive of both meaning and music. 
 In both ballets he incorporated several conventional gestures in the ports de bras  but also demanded    greater emotional involvement from the dancers. 
 These changes added to the overall meaning communicated by the dancing. 
 He used to say: &bquo;Listen to the music, let it tell you what to do.&equo; 
 Les Sylphides  Fokine's interpretation of romantic ballet &bquo;Let the music tell you what to do&equo; (The Royal Ballet) 
 The above ballets are classified under the nineteenth-century meaning of the term &bquo;romantic&equo; because they are based in the world of fantasy and deal very subtly with the theme of Man's struggle against fate. 
 When Fokine was asked who was the male figure in Les Sylphides  he replied: &bquo;Perhaps he is Love himself in a romantic, nostalgic mood. 
 I do not know. 
 I made it for a dancer (Nijinsky) who can soar like a spirit, but who has the strength to dance with the Wilis &lsqb;as in Giselle&rsqb;  and live to dance again.&equo; 
 When talking about Le Carnaval , he added: &bquo;Pierrot was the strange tragic clown known all over Europe as the little man &mdash; he who gets slapped. 
 He is the odd man out at the ball, he only wants one kiss, but it always eludes him.&equo; 
 The theme of the &bquo;little man&equo; made and still makes Fokine's Petrushka  so memorable.   
 Petrushka  Fokine's second Russian ballet Petrushka's cry &mdash; &bquo;He who gets slapped&equo; (David Bintley) 
 Ashton's re-working of the old story of Ondine  (with music by Hans Werner Henze) was a perfect modern version of the older type of romantic ballet. 
 He not only used very expressive ports de bras  for his other-worldly characters but changed the usual conception of classical pointe-work. 
 Ondine, the sea nymph (Margot Fonteyn) so used her feet that she appeared always to float through water. 
 This was done by a series of pas march&eacute;s  each of which softly rose and fell through her feet from toe to heel. 
 They were co-ordinated with a soft undulating movement of the arms. 
 Ashton thus created a special style fur a particular character which summed up &mdash; as it were &mdash; her whole being, but which would have been unsuitable for any other ballet. 
 B  Once Fokine had demonstrated that mimed dance and danced mime were the best materials to use in ballets where individual characters had to stand out from the rest of the cast, and particularly when true love did not run smoothly, other choreographers. followed suit. 
 Although in some ways twentieth-century romantic ballets resemble those of the nineteenth century, they more often originate in a drama which supposedly takes place in the world of reality. 
 Moreover they nearly always end in tragedy because the protagonists reach out in some way fur the unattainable. 
 The events and circumstances surrounding such plots are difficult to control and organise because the characters are supposedly living in the real world. 
 So the choreographer cannot make strong contrasts between the style usually used for the other-worldly spirits and that used for the characters living in the particular setting. 
 He can only highlight the atmosphere supporting the plot, especially those circumstances where he has to portray differences between classes and thus general behaviour, idiosyncrasies, etc., for example the contrast that must be made between the dances for all and sundry in the town square and those for the aristocrats in the ballroom of Romeo and Juliet . 
 Nevertheless every choreographer creating this kind of romantic ballet today has to spend much time creating the proper gestures to replace the words, which in such ballets are never spoken but must be understood. 
 If the dancers perform those gestures with feeling and understanding they will express the moods, emotions and actions of the characters they play. 
 This is what happens in MacMillan's Romeo and Juliet  and Ashton's A Month in the Country . 
 It is perhaps appropriate to stress again that where playwrights require pages of dialogue to explain every factor in the development of the plot, to create a changing atmosphere and to show how the actions affect the actors in the play, dancers can communicate whole passages of dialogue in a few expressive gestures woven into encha&icirc;nements . 
 (As played by the Moscow Arts Theatre, Turgenev's A Month in the  Country  takes over two hours, Ashton's ballet roughly half an hour.) 
 Only characters and episodes essential to the plot are retained. 
 All others can be eliminated because they are there to create atmosphere, which in ballet can be supplied by the music, set and appropriate costumes. 
 MacMillan and Ashton understood this and emphasised the main action. 
 Their work should be studied by all would-be choreographers. 
 The development of the individual character 
 Unlike classical or demi-caract&egrave;re  ballets today's romantic ballets have few stereotyped heroes and heroines because they deal with the moods, emotions and actions of one or more individuals in response to their circumstances and the unfolding of the plot. 
 Their movements must, therefore, have literal implications even though  they use the flowing romantic style originated by Taglioni and Perrot in La  Sylphide  and Giselle . 
 What is meant by the term &bquo;literal&equo;? 
 Literal:  &bquo;taking words in their usual and primary sense and applying the ordinary rules of grammar without mysticism, allegory or metaphor&equo; (O.E.D.) 
 A choreographer should translate this definition into dance terms thus: taking the moods, emotions and actions expressed, understood and observed by everyone in general and using natural gestures when applying the rules of choreographic grammar without trying to express them in any other way. 
 Twentieth-century choreographers rarely deal with fairyland; they prefer to depict real characters living in a particular environment who have strong individual traits. 
 They must take a realistic view and look objectively when deciding which movements will best describe individuality. 
 No better example of such objectivity was Ashton's own playing of the Onlooker in Nocturne . 
 He stood silent and still, watching the tragedy of the Poor Girl who was being rejected by the Rich Man. 
 His two tiny gestures said everything and expressed the audience's understanding of the plot. 
 He made one as if he should try and comfort her, but turned away, walked upstage and on the balcony with his back to the audience, raised his arms widely only to drop them helplessly. 
 No one could fail to understand the Onlooker's reaction to the tale just unfolded. 
 To some extent the same idea of an onlooker applies to that of Jaeger, the critic in Enigma Variations . 
 He is there as the only one who fully understands the problems of both Elgar and his Wife, but plays no part in the other activities. 
 And, although Bratfisch in MacMillan's Mayerling  is a dancing role, he, too, is an onlooker who only shows his real self during his final entrance and last gesture as he throws his flower into Mary Vetsera's grave. 
 However hard modern choreographers may try there are bound to be similarities to older ballets because their vocabulary is not limitless. 
 Nor are the dancers' physical abilities. 
 Certain steps, poses and gestures are bound to recur because tradition has demonstrated time and again that technically there are certain sure ways of giving the design dimension, variety and texture. 
 These ways have become so much a part of the fabric of dance that they are used almost unknowingly by teachers and dancers. 
 Ashton and MacMillan do show that changes can be made. 
 To take only one example, their use of the arabesque  as a gesture. 
 Its style of performance and expression change repeatedly throughout each ballet as the dancer changes with the attendant circumstances. 
 The arabesque  as a gesture changes to give some insight into the character's moods, emotions and actions, as well as arising out of the rhythmic and melodic phrasing of the music. 
 There is an obvious contrast in Ashton's Enigma Variations  between the youthful Dorabella's playful and loving arabesques  in front of Elgar and the arabesques  of his Wife, which are calm and tenderly sympathetic when she dances with him. 
 Another vivid contrast can be seen in MacMillan's The Invitation . 
 When the Young Girl first dances with her Cousin her arabesques  are tentative but outward-going. 
 When she meets him after her seduction by the Older Man, they are tragically tense and withdrawn. 
 She is too afraid, even ashamed, to move towards her Cousin even though he is gentle and understanding in his wish to comfort her. 
 He has learnt his lesson through being seduced by the Older Woman.    
 A Month in the Country  Ashton's romantic style Natalia and the Tutor embrace for the first time (Lynn Seymour, Anthony Dowell) 
 The above examples demonstrate what can be done if a ballet is to communicate meaning beyond that of distinguishing between the world of the flesh and that of the spirit. 
 Another firm distinction which both Ashton and MacMillan make clear is between the dances of youth and age or innocence and experience. 
 Dorabella's lively personality with its carefree lack of attention to technical details is in contrast to Mrs Elgar's more disciplined, thoughtful movements. 
 Another side of youthfulness is exploited in Enigma Variations , that of awakening love. 
 The episode of the &bquo;enchanting Isobel Fitton&equo; being swung in her hammock by and then dancing with Richard Arnold. 
 They both display a new awareness of each other and this colours their movements. 
 She is a little playful, first accepting and then rejecting his advances, whilst he suggests there are stronger feelings behind his efforts to steal a kiss. 
 Such feelings are also suggested when the Cousin first meets the Young Girl in The  Invitation . 
 The Young Girl's movements are innocent and child-like unlike those of Isobel and the shock of seduction makes a fur greater impact on her whole being. 
 This is shown vividly when, left finally alone, she strikes a dramatic pose of complete withdrawal from love and happiness. 
 Dorabella's playfulness is similar to that of Natalia's ward, Vera, when she first dances in A Month in the Country, . 
 The carefree quality disappears when she shyly tries to tell the Tutor how fond she has become of him, and when she discovers Natalia and the Tutor in each other's arms, she loses all inhibitions to denounce them. 
 Her shy confession of love is in deep contrast to that of Natalia, who cannot wait to show that her emotions are fully aroused when left alone with the same man. 
 It is in these brief intimate scenes that Ashton exploits the difference between youth fulling in love and experience demanding it, because Natalia is used to getting her own way. 
 It may be asked: &bquo;How does the Tutor react to these situations?&equo; 
 Ashton's choreography follows the style used by the Moscow Arts Theatre production of the play &mdash; he is danced in the ballet in the same way as he is acted in Russia. 
 The Tutor is a student of peasant origin who has taken a job teaching the son of a wealthy merchant whose household is spending the summer in their country dacha. 
 In Ashton's version, as in the Russian staged version, the Tutor's encounter with Katia, the servant girl, allows him momentarily to be back home amongst his master's peasants. 
 So he relaxes and enjoys a brief dance with her after she has fed him with cherries. 
 Later he responds more positively to Vera's shy advances and embraces her gently but respectfully when they are interrupted by Natalia. 
 The latter's vicious slap on the child's face explains more than any other gesture Natalia's selfishness. 
 Yet the Tutor's capitulation to Natalia reveals her power over every man she meets as well as his failure to withstand her wiles. 
 Ashton's careful build-up to this climax makes Vera's discovery of them in each other's arms all the more poignant because she shows a child-like petulance at losing one she so longed to have for her own. 
 It is so unlike Natalia's reaction when finding the Tutor and Vera together. 
 The Tutor remains a sympathetic character fur Vera, s sorrow at his departure is echoed by Kolia, Natalia's son, when he too realises he is losing the only person who has tried to make him happy. 
 If would-be choreographers examine Ashton's The Dream  they will discover the significant development that has been made in the structure of the old kind of romantic ballet. 
 Certainly Ashton makes a clear distinction between the dances of the Fairies and those of the Mechanicals. 
 The dances of the four Lovers belong to both worlds. 
 The fairies giggle at their antics as they do at those of Bottom and their Queen. 
 &bquo;Lord, what fools we mortals be&equo;, are Shakespeare's own words and it is this particular comment that Ashton has used as the keynote to the adventures in the forest. 
 Another aspect of Ashton's design are the strong individual traits shown by all the leading characters. 
 Despite the contrast he makes between the dances of Puck and      
 The Dream  Ashton's interpretation of Shakespeare: Titania &bquo;lighter than air' (Antoinette Sibley)... 
 ... 
 Puck &mdash; &bquo;Lord what fools&equo; (Simon Rice) 
 Bottom, between those of the Lovers in the pas de deux  and those of Titania and Bottom, the movements grow out of a firm technical choreographic design. 
 Ashton looks back to Petipa's more formal style because it is suitable for Mendelssohn's music. 
 Despite Puck's wild leaps, crazy antics and turns, the clumsy attempts by the Mechanicals to &bquo;cut capers&equo; and Bottom's efforts sur les pointes , it is Oberon and Titania's dancing that commands the stage as well as those trapped in the &bquo;magicked&equo; Athenian wood. 
 from their first confrontation, when Titania appears wilfully aloof as Oberon tries to exert his authority, to their final reconciliation, they stand out as a true Fairy King and Queen, who are not beyond suffering the moods and emotions of &bquo;We mortals here&equo;. 
 Technical characteristics 
 If choreographers study the above works of Ashton and MacMillan, they will understand how far the art of choreography has developed since Fokine changed its structure and texture. 
 They will perhaps understand even better if they pay particular attention to the fine details of every movement. 
 It is no longer the case that the romantic style means dancing classically from the feet to the waist and above that allowing the body, arms and head to express themselves to describe the moods, emotions and actions of the characters.  
 It is well known that only a great dancer-artist can suggest the development of the sixteen-year-old Aurora, happy at her birthday, into the dreamy figure the Prince meets in the woodland glade and on to her final entrance as a triumphant princess fully awake to her responsibilities as Queen-to-be. 
 The encha&icirc;nements  she dances  thoughout  the three scenes do not change in style or content. 
 When Diaghilev staged The Sleeping Beauty  in London (1921) two of his Auroras were princesses by marriage and ballerinas assolutas by Imperial decree. 
 They were grand princesses dancing superbly throughout, but never once suggested that they grew from girl to woman by any change of expression or ways of dancing. 
 Yet if the dances of Vera and Natalia in A Month in the Country  and Juliet in Romeo and Juliet  are examined it will be discovered how the technical content is so designed that the steps, poses and gestures show how changing circumstances are affecting the individuals. 
 This is what Perrot first attempted with his five leitmotifs for Giselle  (see page 61). 
 Continual development in the choreographic design is very obvious in the quiver of the raised leg as the Tutor takes Natalia in his arms. 
 It shows her growing emotional involvement and gradually seems to affect her every movement. 
 This same tiny movement also appears when Vera begins to dance with the Tutor, but her movement is not so intense. 
 It does not develop into the passionate circling en l&equo; air  that occurs when the Tutor swings Natalia round as she rests on his knee before they ultimately turn to face each other and embrace. 
 This particularly subtle quiver of the leg to express newly aroused emotion was first noticed in Ashton's The Two Pigeons  when the Young Girl and her friends pretend to strut around like pigeons. 
 But when she repeats the movement in her dance with the Young Man, it appears in a different context, that of awakening love. 
 When he leaves her for the Gipsy and she dances . 
   alone, it becomes a sad reflection of what has been. 
 When the Young Man returns and the movement is again repeated more slowly and deliberately it becomes the signal of a tender reunion. 
 Somewhat similar changes take place in MacMillan's dances for Juliet. 
 His ever-developing design gives the vital clues to Juliet's development from a child playing  with her doll to the shy recipient of Paris' respectful admiration. 
 Juliet then becomes the slightly apprehensive debutante at the Ball where her movements, though tentative, &mdash; are conventionally correct when she dances with Paris. 
 The moment she encounters Romeo and senses somehow that her life has changed her movement becomes more purposeful. 
 From there onwards it becomes stronger and more emotional so that her joyous movements and later abandon in Romeo's arms are in absolute contrast to her later dance with Paris. 
 Her movements then are equally purposeful but they are constricted and withdrawn, so that her father's contemptuous rejection of her pleas and his throwing her to the floor seem the proper outcome of what in his eyes is sheer disobedience. 
 It is her final passionate abandon on discovering Romeo's body that demonstrates how overwhelming sorrow can destroy all sense of discipline over both body and mind.     
 The Two Pigeons Ashton's delicate use of movement: the wanderer returns&hellip; 
 ... the quivering foot (Lynn Seymour, David Wall) 
 Romeo and Juliet  MacMillan's interpretation of Shakespeare left: Romeo and Juliet's first meeting at the hall; above: 'My heart's dear Love' &mdash; Balcony scene (Lesley Collier, Wayne Eagling) 
 Although Mayerling  is not itself a romantic ballet, it is involved with love affairs. 
 In the deterioration of Count Rudolf's manners and behaviour, MacMillan shows more clearly than anywhere else in his works how any mental and physical breakdown must show through and beyond the technicalities of the dance. 
 The portrayal of this tragic figure is possibly one of the most demanding of all male roles because of the sheer complexity of the incidents where Rudolf is always the centre. 
 Everything focuses on the fact that he is always struggling with his desire for love and power as well as for an end to all his problems. 
 In no way is he shown in a sympathetic light. 
 Nor can one feel any sympathy for the various ladies in his life, all of whom conform outwardly to the strict etiquette of the enclosed society of the Austrian court. 
 Yet they are all prepared to intrigue one with another to gain more power over the tragic Count. 
 Even Mary Vetsera has only one wish, to be possessed by him, and is prepared to go to any lengths to achieve that end. 
 It is possible to say that their pas de deux  are completely uninhibited. 
 Here, there is no tenderness, no lyricism, only sheer brutal passion in which technical discipline is seemingly thrown to the winds. 
 Not one of Rudolf's other ladies has been so embraced. 
 Nor has any of them had to respond so intensely to his wishes. 
 Yet the discipline of MacMillan's design in all its variety, dimension and structure requires each dancer to understand and conform to technical discipline. 
 It is this which makes the performance capable of repetition. 
 A comparison of Rudolf's apparently undisciplined emotions with the subtle feelings expressed by Bratfisch, his valet, shows how MacMillan creates some relief even within the decadence and horror. 
 Natural emotional expression 
 Because the characters of A Month in the Country, Enigma Variations, Romeo and  Juliet, The Invitation  and Mayerling  are supposedly living in a real world, the choreographers have no need to make many deliberate contrasts in the style of dance. 
 Certainly there is a difference between classes when, fur example, the Tutor dances first with Katia the servant, and then with Natalia in A Month in the Country  or when townspeople dance in the street and nobles in the ballroom in Romeo and Juliet . 
 Nevertheless much more attention has to be given to the ports de bras  of all types of character in such ballets because these supply the words not spoken in dance. 
 lf the ports de bras  are to be convincing, choreographers need to study Natural Emotional Expression. 
 In the same way as conventional gesture (see page 88), it has its rules which were formulated by John Davies in &bquo;Orchestra, A Poem of Dancing&equo; (1594). 
 In it he discusses &bquo;the Motions seven that are in Nature found&equo; (Stanza 73). 
 These rules give the directions into which the head, body and arms should move when expressing certain moods, emotions and actions. 
 1 Upwards and outwards 
 The head, body and arms rise upwards and outwards in all the happy emotions as can be seen in the final dances of The Sleeping Beauty, La  Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  and Daphnis and Chlo&euml; . 
 If the movement only goes upwards it usually means pride or arrogance. 
 2 Downwards and inwards 
 The head, body and arms move downwards and inwards in all the sad emotions as in the final dance of the Swans in Swan Lake  and the opening dance of Requiem . 
 If the movement is only downwards it usually means disgrace or tiredness.  
 3 Sideways open ( &eacute;cart&eacute;  or effac&eacute; ) 
 The head, body and arms open out boldly in such a way that the performer is seen to be fully revealed to all as an honest, sincere person who has no need to dissemble. 
 The movements are more or less directed sideways, i.e. &eacute;cart&eacute;  or effac&eacute; , as in the dances fur Romeo, Mercutio and Benvolio in Romeo and Juliet  and fur the Tutor in A Month in the Country . 
 4 Sideways closed ( crois&eacute; ) 
 If the character moves sideways with the head, body and arms in some way averted from the front, i.e. crois&eacute; , possibly with a twist of the shoulders, he or she is usually playing some evil or cunning person. 
 One of the finest examples used to be de Valois' dance for the Three Comforters in Job . 
 Their twisted cunning movements were vividly contrasted with those she created for Elihu, the personification of Youth and Truth. 
 The best present-day example of the cunning gestures are those of Rudolf's Four Friends, the conspirators in Mayerling . 
 5 Forwards 
 A dancer coming forwards can convey a variety of meaning: giving a greeting; asking a question, even if it is only an inquisitive movement of the head; saying Yes, or agreeing with a nod or with a particular wave of the hand; giving something with arms circling outwards, e.g. Natalia and the Tutor when they open their arms to each other; or merely proffering a hand at the beginning of a dance, e.g. Paris offering his hand to Juliet. 
 6 Backwards 
 There is a backwards movement in saying No, which can be a slight withdrawal of head and shoulders; a more emphatic shake of the head perhaps accompanied by the hand pushing away an undesirable request or person, e.g. Juliet's rejection of Paris in the Bedroom scene. 
 More importantly, there is always a withdrawal backwards or turn aside in moments of fear. 
 This movement is usually made more apparent because the head sinks into the shoulders and the hands come close to the body to protect it from some blow, curse or frightening event, e.g. Juliet's movement after her father has demanded why she is not conforming to his wishes. 
 7 The turn 
 The seventh direction is a &bquo;Turn around&equo; which John Davies suggests is like a stop in some sentence or dance. 
 The conversation is ended or the speaker has changed his or her mind. 
 There are many uses for this turn, particularly when dancers are conversing in ports de bras . 
 One of the most beautiful is probably that of Odette in the Act II pas de deux  of Swan Lake  when, overcoming her fear at being captured, she turns her head and deliberately looks into Siegfried's eyes. 
 A study of how people react in real life when affected by any kind of emotion and mood soon reveals how the movements of the whole body can change. 
 Sometimes they are perceived only by those in intimate contact, yet sometimes they can make everyone in a large crowd aware of individual feelings. 
 The choreographer's problem is how to make subtle or vigorous gesture visible to those on the other side of the footlights. 
 Success will depend very largely on the dancer's own sense of timing and ability so to perform the gestures created that they convey meaning which makes sense within the context of the ballet. 
 This can be done only if the whole body is seen to be involved in some way or other. 
 It also depends on how the gesture is extended in time and space so that it appears to emanate from the dancer's concentration on the purpose of the gesture. 
 Amongst the greatest dancer-mimes even the slightest wink  becomes obvious. 
 De Valois, Ashton and MacMillan have studied paintings and drawings by English artists and/or the words of such great playwrights as Shakespeare and translated them into gestures for which the dancer's whole body has to play a part. 
 Character and National styles 
 Character and/or National styles of ballet can be linked in some ways to that of demi  - caract&egrave;re . 
 Character dance like demi-caract&egrave;re  dance had its beginnings in La Fille  Mal Gard&eacute;e  when farmers and peasants were first allowed to set foot on the Royal and Imperial stages, which had hitherto been the home of gods and goddesses or noble and well-born heroes and heroines. 
 But as Napoleon's initial conquests and later defeats made European countries aware of their own traditional arts, so choreographers, like. 
 composers, authors, poets and painters, began to strengthen the national features of their work. 
 More typical and traditional folk dance steps and customs were absorbed into demi-caract&egrave;re  dance and were accompanied by idiomatic features from national music. 
 When this happened, however, even the traditional features became more stereotyped because choreographers used only those which the audience could easily recognise and which were commonly seen and heard in a particular country. 
 It was from such traditional dance that Fokine, at the instigation of Diaghilev, devised the first truly national ballets by breaking away from the sterotyped steps. 
 Instead, Fokine based his design (as did the composer Stravinsky and the artist Korovin (later Goncharova)) on the folk tales, customs, traditional dances and music of Russia without in any way conforming to the generally accepted rules of classical technique. 
 The Firebird  set the example fur many nationally styled ballets such as Petrushka, The Rake's Progress  and Rodeo . 
 These are seen to belong to one particular country and are at their best when performed by dancers from that country. 
 Definition of Character and National ballet 
 A Character Ballet  is one in which classical technique is discarded except where it is used to depict particular and usually fantastic characters as for the dolls in Petrushka  and La Boutique Fantasque . 
 Instead, a particular style of dance is used through which the performers play strongly defined characters who express not only social status in a particular community but also moods, emotions and actions, which are alien to the calm spaciousness of classical dance. 
 Such ballets range from The Green Table  (Kurt Jooss 1933) and Fa&ccedil;ade  (Ashton 1931) to Robbins' Fancy Free  (1944). 
 A National Ballet  is one which is based firstly on the traditional stories, dance, music and customs of a particular country and/or secondly on the atmosphere, texture and typical life of a country. 
 Examples of such ballets are Fokine's The Firebird  and Petrushka , de Valois' Job  and The Rake's Progress  and Ashton's La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e , the last of which, despite its French origin, discloses the particular quality of English theatre customs and comedy, as does Cranko's Pineapple Poll . 
 The Americans have such ballets as Loring's Billy the Kid  and De Mille's Rodeo  and Fall River Legend . 
 The Russians have their twelve ballets based on Pushkin's poems such as The Fountain of  Bakhchisarai  and the Czechs have The Gingerbread Heart . 
 In fact most countries have chosen to reflect something of their own heritage. 
 David Bintley's Hobson's Choice  (1989) is in the same category as The Rake's  Progress . 
 Like Hogarth, Harold Brighouse, the author of the play, discussed the  problems and topics current in Salford in the early nineteen twenties such as class barriers, women's rights, temperance, pubs and music-hall jokes. 
 Bintley's rumbustious choreography reflects ali these through a rich mixture of social, clog, stage and traditional dance, which are richly echoed by Paul Reade's evocative score. 
 The cast enter into this Lancashire hot-pot as to the manner born and only a snob will fail to enjoy: &bquo;By gum! 
 What a Ballet&equo; daring to show itself in the Opera House. 
 Nineteenth-century choreographers creating either a character or a national ballet used both occupational and natural emotional gesture in their dance designs. 
 They had to be more specific about the traditionally accepted forms of behaviour, customs, occupations and particular national characteristics. 
 It was the impact of the Polovtsian Warriors and their dances from Prince Igor  (1910) that startled Parisian and other audiences into recognition that even the most barbaric dance had a rightful place in the theatre. 
 The differences between character dance and dances of character 
 A distinction must be made between character dance and dances of character. 
 It was first made by Dauberval when staging La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e . 
 He described the former as derived from traditional sources and given theatrical form which demonstrated how his peasants and farmers would move in everyday life. 
 The latter he created specially to depict Alain, a very particular role which was unlikely to appear in any other ballet. 
 A distinction should also be made between the particular style of character dance known in all the leading schools and the true folk dance performed by the people of a country. 
 The former was derived from traditional sources but stylised by Saint-L&eacute;on, who gave much thought to the theatrical presentation of such material. 
 This development of a character style happened after Napoleon's campaigns which gave birth to the so-called National movements. 
 These led such Russian composers as Glinka and those known as &bquo;The Mighty Little Heap&equo; to create operas and tone poems on traditional stories, and Pushkin and Lermontov to write poems in the language spoken by the Russian people. 
 Later, what is now known as National music was composed by such musicians as the Czechs Smetana and Dvorak, the Hungarian Liszt, the Norwegian Grieg, the Spanish Granados, Albeniz and De Falla, the Polish Chopin and, finally, the English Elgar and Vaughan-Williams. 
 Rules for staging character dance 
 Saint-L&eacute;on laid down certain rules for the staging of character dance based on the traditional folk dance of a particular country. 
 These rules are still of value and are widely followed throughout Europe and Asia. 
 1 
 Steps should be classified under the terms used in the classical vocabulary so that they have a commonly recognised form, e.g. the three changes of weight required by the Russian &bquo;Kolokol&equo; or bell step and the Hungarian &bquo;Harang&equo; make them pas de  bourr&eacute;e , whilst the &bquo;goat's leap&equo; known in several countries becomes the pas de chat . 
 2 
 Emphasis must be placed on certain steps and their qualities which appear to be particular to one country and dances should be limited to those which can be recognised. 
 The movements of Hungarian dance are &bquo;down to the earth&equo; whereas those of Scottish Highland dance are &bquo;away from the earth&equo;.  
 3 
 In order to display particular native features, the traditional circle, chain and couple dance formations must be broken up and opened outwards so that the steps are seen clearly by the audience. 
 This is after all what the first balletmasters did when professionals appeared on stage and were no longer surrounded by the court where all eyes were focused on the king (see page 76). 
 4 
 The very particular relationship of the accenting and phrasing of the steps with the overall and short phrase rhythms and accents of the music must be maintained. 
 It was shortly after Saint-L&eacute;on's arrival in Russia that he instigated the teaching of the so-called character dance at the Imperial St. Petersburg Theatrical Academy. 
 In thoroughly systematised form it now applies throughout the USSR. 
 Much of the syllabus has become part of the training of dancers all over the world. 
 Its features are very much the same as those described earlier in connection with demi-caract&egrave;re  style (see page 93) but with a very strong difference. 
 The steps are always performed in boots or heeled shoes so ali the movements look stronger and often heavier. 
 They require accurate timing and neat footwork of the accents are to be heard and seen. 
 The ports de bras  must be more emphatic and be accurately placed. 
 The partnership between boy and girl must be carefully observed and timed because each country has its own forms for such joint movement. 
 Hungarian 
 The couples frequently face each other looking into each other's faces and appear to crouch over their feet slightly which emphasises the &bquo;down to earth&equo; quality as most steps appear to go down into and not out of the ground. 
 (See page 95 for other characteristics.) 
 Polish 
 The boy's way of appearing to guide his girl just in front of him in all travelling steps affects the  carrige  of both himself and his partner. 
 The constant use of what is called the &bquo;feminine cadence&equo; is a particular rhythmic feature. 
 This is when a phrase finishes on the second (or weak) and not on the first or third beat of a final bar. 
 It is usually accompanied by a firm clipping of the heels together and is noticeable in all mazurkas and polonaises, particularly in the steps that Saint-L&eacute;on called the promenade, cabriole  and pas sissonne  (see page 121). 
 Spanish 
 In all Spanish Theatre dances there must be strict control over the stance taken. 
 Bodies should be fully stretched upwards and curved either slightly forwards or backwards from the waist only. 
 This stance must be accompanied by the wellrecognised ports de bras , which must be accurately co-ordinated with the footwork. 
 The arms usually change after each brief encha&icirc;nement . 
 Their movement also depends upon which foot is in front. 
 If the right foot remains there for several bars, the arms will be held still, but as soon as the left moves in front the arms will change. 
 There is also a tendency to pause in a pose at the end of a phrase and for a deliberate change to be made before further dance. 
 An interesting point to note in real Spanish folk dance is that the boy and girl rarely touch each other. 
 In some older dances they each hold a corner of a handkerchief to form a link and in some areas they link little fingers.  
 Italian 
 There is little to distinguish between the Italian character dance and its demi  - caract&egrave;re  form save only that heeled shoes are worn and thus from time to time take on a slightly Spanish flavour, the only difference perhaps being the more fluid way of phrasing and less rigidly accurate timing of the steps. 
 For all their liveliness of style any of the above national dances seen in one ballet resemble those in another because choreographers such as Petipa, Bournonville and Saint-L&eacute;on utilised the same steps and ports de bras  again and again. 
 Only the music created slight differences and this not markedly because the composers used the best of commonly recognised traditional musical idioms. 
 Possibly the best of commonly recognised character dance styles are found in Copp&eacute;lia, Swan Lake  (Old and Soviet versions) and La Boutique Fantasque . 
 Even Massine's choreographic genius realised that the old stylised forms were the best way to portray the national dolls sold in the shop. 
 It is, however, easy to recognise that the choreography for The Three-Cornered  Hat  has greater authenticity because it is based on the folk and flamenco dance Massine had studied in Spain. 
 He made his design choreographically viable by distinguishing clearly between the two styles he was using. 
 By so differentiating he described both the characteristics of his villagers and the typical gestures which enabled them to tell their tale (see page 59). 
 Massine's brilliant use of descriptive and narrative gestures in The Three-Cornered  Hat  was a proper development of Fokine's mimed dance and danced mime, first seen in The Firebird  and Petrushka . 
 As already noted, the dances Fokine staged for the nursemaids, coachmen and others at the Fair were &bquo;real dances&equo; (see page 59). 
 They created the atmosphere and mood, but the narrative was told by the dolls using specially created movements which could be called dances of character. 
 Characters from the commedia dell'arte 
 When Dauberval defined what he meant by dances of character he undoubtedly had in mind some easily recognised characters of the commedia dell'arte, whose actors regularly played such roles as the absent-minded doctor or scientist, miser, termagant wife or widow and various clowns such as the sad Pierrot or zany clown. 
 He was aware that famous players of those roles had developed their own ways of interpretation and tricks, which were then handed down from generation to generation. 
 Some part of their play still exists. 
 For example: Mother Simone in Pavlova's version of La Fille Mal  Gard&eacute;e  which I saw in Kiev (1954) was played by a man and used such tricks as titivating before meeting Father Thomas and fainting when Lise is discovered in her bedroom with Colas. 
 Alain was played as an idiot who hardly danced at all except to full over his own feet. 
 In fact they were stereotypes, well known in the popular theatre and instantly recognised as are supercilious members of the upper classes, superior servants and prostitutes. 
 This is useful when telling a story, particularly as prostitutes appear in many ballets. 
 One expects and sees silk stockings or nowadays fish-net tights on made-up hussies with split or very short skirts, or brief frilly knickers, low-necked bodices or tight gaudy corsets, elaborate hair-dos or hats, and so on. 
 They are found in ballets by Jooss, Massine, MacMillan and others. 
 Yet in The Rake's Progress  de Valois found something new to say about the ladies of the town when she made their leader kick off her shoes, pull up her long yellow skirt and roll down her red stockings before bursting barefooted into a riotous dance on a great salver. 
 Other ladies of doubtful   virtue take similar liberties when they drop their skirts, as happens in Ashton's Polka in Fa&ccedil;ade . 
 But MacMillan's street dancers and cabaret girls in Mayerling  are stereotypes. 
 The Rake's Progress  English National Ballet and de Valois' interpretation of Hogarth's evils of the day The Prostitute and the Rake (June Highwood, Desmond Kelly) 
 There are very different ways of presenting these old characters even whilst preserving their basic form. 
 From the beginning of his career Ashton frequently used the old stereotypes but created unique dances which can be called a translation of favourite comic play into the language of ballet. 
 Foremost amongst the dances are those for Bottom, in The Dream , when he is transformed into an ass. 
 Here is the clown whose clumsy, na&iuml;ve behaviour is exemplified by his &bquo;tottering sur les pointes &equo;, scratching his back on a bush and performing other antics when he dances with Titania. 
 How moving are his gestures when, once again himself, he muses: &bquo;Methought I was, I know not what methought.&equo; 
 Ashton enlarged this choreographic gem in The  Tales of Beatrix Potter  when Pigling Bland and the Black Berkshire indulge in a delicate pas de deux , both sur les pointes . 
 Ashton's Mother Simone in La Fille Mal  Gard&eacute;e  is rightly played by a man who adopts stereotyped female behaviour, but gone is the non-dancing character of the older versions. 
 This Simone has come directly from playing the Dame of pantomime and maintains that character from her very first entrance when she shakes a tablecloth out of the window and then furiously throws  every vegetable in sight at Colas because she finds him waiting for Lise. 
 But &mdash; of course &mdash; being of a frugal mind, saving the pot before finally flinging the geranium. 
 She later shows her mettle as a clog dancer abetted by four pretty girls, tries to set her cap at Father Thomas, but finally realises she cannot frustrate true love and dances out happily with the rest. 
 This English pantomime tradition Ashton also exploited earlier in his choreography for the Ugly Sisters in Cinderella  where he followed the tradition that one is always a somewhat modest violet bossed about by her dragon of a sister. 
 This double characterisation was made more hilarious at the first performances when the bossy one was danced by Helpmann, and later the taller MacMillan, with wonderfully extended d&eacute;velopp&eacute;s , and the shyer one by Ashton with dainty attempts to be correct at all costs. 
 A similar incongruous matching of the very tall girl with one of the shortest boys in MacMillan's Elite Syncopations  reveals that he, too, understands that old music-hall and pantomime practices are a wonderful source of inspiration if a British audience is to laugh and enjoy the occasion as the dancers do. 
 Another commedia dell'arte character whose play has influenced too few choreographers is that of Harlequin, a maker of mischief, a &bquo;magicker of spells&equo;, an animal impersonator and always a great dancer. 
 Fokine's Harlequin only gives a glimpse of his abilities. 
 Ashton's Puck in The Dream  uses all his &bquo;bag of tricks&equo; as envisaged by Shakespeare. 
 The whole performance is based on the classical vocabulary of steps shorn of every convention so that he can go &bquo;swifter than an arrow from an archer's bow&equo;. 
 Every leap, turn, beat and somersault is perfectly co-ordinated with the phrase and with the music despite the fact that the dance scarcely reflects the period when the music was composed as does Ashton's choreography in other ballets (see page 42). 
 Choreographers should therefore note that it is possible to design movements which may contradict the music that is being played, but not if they contradict the mood and rhythmic qualities of the whole context. 
 Mendelssohn's music is light-hearted. 
 It does not probe the deeper emotions. 
 Nor is it any more than the incidental music to a play that captured the composer's imagination and inspired him to conjure up the &bquo;goings on in the Magicked Athenian wood&equo;. 
 Thus in his own way Ashton has reflected the composer's own imaginative flight of fancy, firstly by following the academic structure of the score and secondly by using his choreographic imagination to bring to life Shakespeare's mortals and immortals for &bquo;of such stuff dreams are made&equo;. 
 Another source for dances of character can be found in the sad clown or &bquo;the man who gets slapped&equo;. 
 They range variously from Fokine's Pierrot in Le Carnaval  who only wants &bquo;one kiss&equo; and his puppet Petrushka  who wants to be free to Ashton's Alain mentioned above and MacMillan's Bratfisch in Mayerling . 
 Such a lonely figure is always pathetic because whatever he wants proves impossible to have. 
 Only in Petrushka  is he seen to be the principal player in the action and even then only the actor-dancer's complete commitment to the whole and complete loyalty to Fokine's design make him dominate the action. 
 As yet there has been no other attempt to describe so vividly in dance the wish of any character, but in this case a puppet, to escape from prison. 
 MacMillan's Bratfisch tries to keep his employer amused and thus to postpone the inevitable tragedy. 
 He only reveals his true feelings when he throws his flower into Mary Vetsera's grave just before the curtain falls. 
 His dance throughout has its base in the classical vocabulary but MacMillan has coloured it by gestures from cabaret and vaudeville dance traditions, which serve to reveal not only class  differences in behaviour but also genuine feelings. 
 This is why Bratfisch is so important. 
 Without him there is no other character with whom the audience can feel sympathy. 
 Ashton's Alain shows yet another aspect of the sad clown or &bquo;little man&equo; and can, when subtly played, gain much sympathy because, while things seem to go right, he is so pleased with life. 
 His delight first makes itself evident during his solo for Lise even though technical mistakes keep on happening. 
 When he pulls himself up or corrects his placing or step he beams on the audience as, for example, when he finishes with his back after a pirouette  and hastily turns to face them. 
 The same happens during the pas de deux  that is supposed to be with Lise. 
 Each time they arrive at a pose, Colas somehow steals the expected kiss or holds Lise in the proper climax as Alain strikes what he believes to be the proper pose. 
 He is always part of the total picture but facing the wrong way. 
 Such a dance requires exact timing from all concerned, just as certain movements do in MacMillan's Elite Syncopations  when the tall girl and the short boy dance to &bquo;Alaskan Rag&equo; or when the giggly couple dance in &bquo;The Golden Hours&equo;. 
 The above examples are all slightly parodied versions of classical dance steps. 
 It is useful to point out that when using such materials choreographers must know their vocabulary very thoroughly and select movements through which they can emphasise the moment when disaster strikes. 
 Such a moment arises when the short boy endeavours to catch the tall girl round the waist as she extends her leg to turn &agrave; la  seconde  but grabs her knee instead and has to creep round underneath. 
 Some may complain that such tricks are too obvious. 
 This is not so. 
 The dance has to be so arranged that the mistake must appear accidental. 
 Both Ashton and MacMillan take the technical aspects of their choreography very seriously. 
 They know that just one small slip can make a joke in dance. 
 Moreover, the dancers involved have to take this type of performance very seriously, even though they must be able to &bquo;toss off&equo; the mistakes with an air of surprised innocence. 
 Characters in National ballet 
 The above approach towards any type of character role is a very typically English trait and has been used in music halls, pantomimes and comedies fur many years. 
 It is this particular way of playing which makes Ashton's La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  what can be called a National Ballet in the same sense that both The Firebird  and Petrushka  can be called Russian National Ballets and Rodeo  and Fall River Legend  American. 
 When choreographers wish to be patriotic by displaying the national origins of a company, school or ballet, they must not only be thoroughly conversant with that country's uniquely traditional folk arts but also be very sensitive to the way that native performers play in the popular theatre. 
 It is not enough to give folk dances theatrical form by opening out their patterns, paying increased attention to the relationship of step to music and developing any unique style of movement. 
 All these should also happen in character dance (see page 120). 
 The collective behaviour of all the inhabitants as well as certain idiosyncrasies and possibly even eccentricities can make some contribution to the overall design. 
 They can also emphasise features which belong exclusively to that one country. 
 Massine's The Three-Cornered Hat  is possibly still the most important national ballet of Spain yet to be produced. 
 Its story, music, d&eacute;cor and costumes were created by the Spaniards Alarc&oacute;n, De Falla and Picasso. 
 Yet the choreography is by a Russian who studied among the Spanish peasants and worked out his design with the help of a   particular peasant, a natural dancer, whose passion for dance was such that his life ended tragically when he found he was not to perform in the ballet. 
 Such was his influence and so intense Massine's study and application of the knowledge gained that other versions of Spanish dance by native choreographers made no such impact. 
 The great dancer Antonio was unable to match Massine's design even though each member of Antonio's company danced as to the manner born. 
 Antonio was a star dancer and he could not take an objective view of the whole. 
 His design focused on his brilliant performance of the various solos but otherwise filled the stage with authentic steps which played little part in making the action unfold. 
 Cinderella  Ashton and English pantomime traditions Shoe fitting (David Bintley, Deryck Rencher, Jonathan Cope) 
 Means of expression 
 While choreographers who wish to create a character and/or national ballet have an immense amount of material upon which to work, they must be very selective if they are to communicate the characteristic and/or purely nationalistic elements which will make a ballet unique. 
 Moreover, as has been noted earlier, all character dance movements must be more strongly marked both physically and musically than the demi-caract&egrave;re  versions of the same steps. 
 Similarly, all the poses and/or gestures performed by each character must be distinctly national, no matter how minor a part is being played.  
 The truly heroic character of Lemminkainen in the great Finnish epic Kalevala  acts, according to the story, very much in the same way as the heroes of the Anglo-Saxon Beowulf  or the French Song of Roland  and many other heroic poems. 
 Nevertheless he is uniquely different because he is not only a hero but also a powerful magician in the tradition of many Slav and Asiatic epics. 
 In some ways, too, he behaves as the type of classical hero who ultimately became the danseur noble  of classical ballet, because he always behaves nobly and truly. 
 If the choreographer thinks he can use the purely classical vocabulary as the basis of his design it will fail to convey the totally different world from which this ancient epic emerged. 
 It will not reflect the beliefs, behaviour, problems, wars and evil forces which give such colour and life to the narrative. 
 Lemminkainen was able to weave and cast spells to win his way through to the end of his journey. 
 He is a barbarian in the same way as the Polovtsian dancers in Prince Igor . 
 If he were to conform to the strict rules of etiquette and combat guiding the danseurs  nobles  of the French opera-ballets, he would not demean himself by seizing the nearest thing at hand, the rudder from his boat, to put his adversary to flight. 
 David Bintley's The Swan of Tuonela  was one of the first attempts to create a ballet from the Finnish epic with music by Sibelius, a truly national composer from Finland. 
 It successfully conveys something of this many faceted tale of daring behaviour. 
 To produce any kind of character and/or national ballet the choreographer should call on the three kinds of mime mentioned earlier, viz. conventional and occupational gesture and natural emotional expression. 
 Conventional gestures are valuable not only because they often appear in the epics themselves, but also because they are universally recognised as a means of communication in real life and have been used on the stage since the earliest days of the theatre. 
 They must be performed and co-ordinated with the dance style and musical rhythms appropriate to the location where the story is being enacted. 
 They must also be performed and co-ordinated with the occupational gestures that belong to the location and that are employed by the particular inhabitants whose story, with its moods, emotions and actions, is being told. 
 This means that natural emotional expression must also be folded into the design. 
 This is probably the most difficult material to handle because the many characters and nationalities involved in the various available libretti must express themselves as distinctively as they do in real life and the choreographer must try and ensure his design has some semblance of reality if it is to communicate meaning. 
 It was in this particular field of difficulty that Balanchine sometimes showed his deep understanding. 
 In his abstract ballets or interpretations of music, he rarely worried about the mood or emotional content of the music. 
 Yet in The Four Temperaments  he revealed very clearly and subtly how four very different types of person react to the mood suggested by Hindemith's music, whilst using his particular style of classical dance (see page 54). 
 If the choreographer is attempting to draw and communicate a moving picture of the individual character and physical attributes which permanently affect the manner of acting, feeling and thinking of their hero, heroine and entire cast, then they must study not only the general outline and background of their chosen story or theme, but also the beliefs, ways of life and traditions which have given life to the people and tales of different countries.  
 Modern style 
 There is a necessary distinction to be made between modern style and modern ballet. 
 In the modern style used by choreographers, they are to an increasing extent trying to do away with all the conventions inherent in the traditional techniques of classical and other styles. 
 This has certainly led to a freeing of the body to give it a greater range of movement. 
 The various schools of modern dance do, however, usually insist on a proper discipline and technique of movement. 
 Without turn-out, tutus and pointe  shoes the dancers' bodies still have the same physical apparatus as before and if bodies are to dance at all they must submit to some form of discipline. 
 Even primitive tribes when dancing submit to the discipline imposed by their leaders. 
 It is worth noting that such important modern choreographers as Kurt Jooss and Martha Graham and the leader of the Dance Theatre of Harlem, George Mitchell, insisted that their dancershave knowledge of some school of classical technique, to which they added other exercises to develop the flexibility of their dancers' bodies, athletic qualities and an ability to explore more thoroughly the space around them in all its dimensions. 
 The additional exercises certainly led to a greater use of patterns made by the dancers rolling or posturing over and on the floor. 
 This gave greater depth to most of the patterns, but often made the dancers appear earthbound. 
 It also led to closer contacts between the dancers as they moved from picture to picture within the design. 
 From time to time this can be very beautiful but because there is a lack of continuity in the dance movement from one picture to the next, the resultant work often appears static. 
 Alternatively, it may appear too acrobatic or athletic because the choreographer has been so concerned with the turning of the pages of a picture book that there is no explanation why one picture follows another and leads to another and yet another until the curtain falls. 
 Modern ballet 
 If the choreographer has &bquo;subordinated tradition to harmonise with modern thought or modern terms of expression&equo; (see page 12) then in a literal sense, the ballet is modern. 
 Since the publishers of Radcliffe Hall's The Well of Loneliness  and Lawrence's Lady  Chatterley's Lover  were charged before the courts for contravening the laws of obscenity and both cases were lost by the Crown, any subject can be discussed in public. 
 Novels, plays, films and documentaries, both serious and frivolous, have presented taboo subjects in English ballet. 
 MacMillan's The Invitation  was only one to have been staged by the Royal Ballet companies. 
 A brief list shows how much ground he has covered since the strict rules of British censorship have been lifted. 
 rape and frustration 
 The Invitation; Las Hermanas 
 decadence and schizophrenia 
 Mayerling; Manon 
 madness 
 The Playground 
 incest 
 My Brothers, My Sisters 
 &bquo;Man's inhumanity to Man&equo; 
 The Burrow; A Distant Drummer 
 It is important to note that these ballets were created by MacMillan whose aim has been to convince audiences that dance in ballet belongs to the reality of life and to show how life can be manipulated. 
 He first described this in Noctambules  which  showed how the characters portrayed were manipulated by the Hypnotist. 
 Manipulation was shown more dramatically in A Distant Drummer . 
 The enormities of the Hitler regime and the Holocaust opened up many fields of research into the workings of minds not only of fanatics but also of the mentally disoriented or diseased. 
 Such influences seriously affect all movement and behaviour, most noticeably in the works listed against &bquo;Man's inhumanity to Man&equo;, where the &bquo;little man&equo; is manipulated by others. 
 To communicate the meaning of any story or theme based on real life, choreographers must take into account all the facets of modern thought and behaviour. 
 They must then develop a style of movement which will convey the life of all their characters no matter how minor their roles in the unfolding of the action or theme. 
 In other words, they must develop a style which will reveal not only the physical attributes of the characters but also their mental attitudes. 
 Thus the choreographic design will describe not only personal moods, emotions and actions but also their effect on inter-personal relationships. 
 It is the conflict between the players in any drama which heightens or when necessary relaxes the tension necessary for a climax to the plot. 
 However hard one may try to place a new ballet in any of the style categories already mentioned, it is noticeable that the basic style of dance used in any ballet is usually merged with another. 
 This is because the choreographer has amalgamated the steps, poses and gestures to make a particular statement about the story, theme or music inspiring the work. 
 For example: Enigma Variations  could be called a character ballet because it describes &bquo;the persons empictured within' by Elgar himself. 
 Yet Ashton found ways of so moulding classical dance that the ladies even danced sur les pointes  in so Edwardian a setting. 
 The ballet could have been entered under the title of demi-  caract&egrave;re , but those people were not figments of the imagination. 
 They really lived, were visualised by the composer, then the choreographer and recognised by old friends in the audience. 
 Robbins&equo; Dances at a Gathering  could be called a romantic ballet because it uses classical technique coloured by natural emotional expression. 
 It communicates the moods, sentiments and behaviour of young people meeting to enjoy each other's company as young people always do though not usually to Chopin's romantic music. 
 In essence their behaviour is little different from that in Fancy Free . 
 Yet this work was absolutely contemporary when produced. 
 The three boys come directly from a battleship when they pick up three girls from the street. 
 The dancing reflects the wartime atmosphere when shore leave was a cherished moment. 
 Even though the boys and girls are figments of Robbins' imagination, their brief encounter is based in reality even to the introduction of popular dance steps and stylistic elements current during the 1939&ndash;45 war. 
 Both the above-mentioned works show that ballets based on the life of real people require that choreographers closely observe the characteristics and idiosyncrasies of all types of person and that they make them recognisable in order that they convey meaning. 
 Yet the above ballets are different again from de Valois' The Rake's Progress , which was based on the reality of Hogarth's pictures. 
 When these pictures were issued they were indeed contemporary because they were based on the evils of the day. 
 Today's audiences find them old-fashioned: yet many modern ballets deal with similar evils such as present-day problems with drugs, AIDS, mental handicap, racism, imprisonment and so on, in which the balletic interpretation makes the same impression if the choreographer has really studied the themes outlined in his subject.  
 These choreographers must create movements which display each protagonist's particular behaviour and reactions. 
 Too often their movements are insufficiently defined because too much effort is made to shock, unlike the tightly controlled movements of characters in The Rake's Progress  and A Distant Drummer . 
 In each of the three ballets discussed movements are not merely coloured by natural emotional expression but often by conventional and occupational gesture, which appear to spring from each dancer's physical and mental reactions to each situation as it arises. 
 A comparison of such different ballets as Enigma Variations, Fancy Free  and The  Rake's Progress  emphasises how important it is for young choreographers to remember that ballet is an art of the general as well as of the particular. 
 This arises from the fact that no one really dances through life, though doing so once the curtain has risen. 
 Enigma Variations  is a unique ballet about particular people at a particular time &mdash; and in a particular environment &mdash; the characters were even recognised by old friends (see page 53). 
 Yet Mayerling , although based on what little facts are known of the life of Rudolf of Austria, barely suggests reality. 
 In an attempt to show the decadence and revolutionary ideas endemic in the court life of the Emperor Francis Joseph, MacMillan overloaded his plot with incident. 
 He thus turned what could have been a tragedy into a melodrama, i.e. &bquo;a sensational dramatic piece with crude appeals to the emotions&equo; (O.E.D.). 
 Even so, it was the first successful attempt in this genre because it gave its performers an opportunity to reveal their talents as actor-dancers. 
 Although they were playing stereotyped conspirators, innocents, prostitutes, courtiers and lackeys each role had a personality of its own and thus a semblance of reality. 
 This had not happened on such a scale before and encouraged MacMillan to stage another biographical work, Isadora , which followed the pattern of his earlier Anastasia . 
 Neither was very successful because the characters were not fully defined and the plots were confused by too much use of stage effects. 
 MacMillan's The Burrow , based on the real diary of Anne Frank, was possibly the most explicit and moving of all his efforts to depict reality in terms of dance (see page 30). 
 The classification of today's ballets becomes more difficult as their stories, themes and music get more complicated. 
 Very occasionally, the opposite happens, e.g. in Robbins' Glass Pieces  to John Cage's &bquo;minimal music&equo;, the constant repetition of musical phrases paralleled by dance phrases lost the interest of an audience bored with too much meaningless to-ing and fro-ing. 
 Modern style 
 After studying the above ballets it may well be asked what is modern style? 
 Before attempting a new definition (see page 12) it would be better to consider two important factors, namely the art of the general and the art of the particular. 
 The art of the general  
 General  &bquo;completely or almost universal including or affecting nearly all parts&equo; 
 (O.E.D.) 
 The art of the general in dance means that the choreographer must understand the working of a dancer's body and its ability to respond physically to any demand for movement. 
 Dance technique is more embracing than that for any other physical activity such as sports, gymnastics, athletics and so on. 
 As explained elsewhere  classical technique is the most demanding. 
 It has evolved from the simplest folk through the mannered court and finally to the expert classical dance. 
 It is designed to display both dancer and dance to the best advantage from the audience's point of view. 
 It is a strict discipline upon which to build. 
 Its exponents are trained to feel how to move with each part of their bodies and to know how their movements must be coordinated to produce one or another step or pose. 
 Each movement is complete in itself but must flow into the next and become part of the total choreographic design. 
 Correctly practised such movements ensure that each dancer can perform in many different ways the four vital movements of which the body is capable (the legs may be turned in or out), viz. to bend, stretch, rise and rotate. 
 These active steps (or verbs) can also be interpreted as meaning to relax, contract, raise, lift or jump, turn or twist (see pages 50 and 69). 
 The muscles must be trained to counter-balance each otherappropriately if the dancer is to defy the laws of gravity whatever the style of dance. 
 Even if it seems inappropriately mentioned, any fall used as part of the design has to be carefully worked out. 
 Every movement on stage has to be a conscious effort on the dancer's part if it is to make its proper impact. 
 When performing any movement in the classical vocabulary dancers are drawing straight, angled or rounded lines which affect one or all parts of the body. 
 They can fill the space in which they move by the amalgamation of steps, poses and gestures, which can travel in any direction and dimension (see page 69). 
 The encha&icirc;nements  can be danced to any time signature, phrasing or tempo. 
 Although some modern dancers do without music in the accepted sense of that term, they rarely do without rhythmic phrasing. 
 If they do they have forgotten that, like them, every member of their audience &bquo;has an inborn sense of measuring time... 
 Without a sense of rhythm, our sense of time is devoid of landmarks&equo; and, as Frank Howes added later, &bquo;and sense&equo; (see page 68). 
 The art of the particular  
 Particular  &bquo;the relation to one as distinguished from another&equo; (O.E.D.) The question now to be asked is where does the art of the particular begin in the creation of style? 
 It has already been noted that the movements in Ashton's five abstract ballets have been coloured by the music, its period and sometimes by the composer's own thoughts (see page 42). 
 Each of those ballets can also be said to have dimension and linear patterns which can be roughly described as follows: Symphonic Variations  Lines are widely structured, flowing and straight rather than rounded, with no hard edges. 
 Sc&egrave;nes de Ballet  The lines are straighter and more angled than usual in classical dance. 
 They are precise in detail yet from time to time break away from the formal patterns of Petipa's well-ordered conventions. 
 Birthday Offering  Precise and accurately placed encha&icirc;nements  and &eacute;aulement  give a clear definition to each step and pose as it takes its place in a perfectly balanced design. 
 Rhapsodie  The patterns fill the stage in all its dimensions whilst remaining within the more conventional patterns of older ballets. 
 Because the patterns are forever changing shape, the lines are more lightly etched and give greater fluidity and excitement to the dance.  
 Similar remarks could be made about the abstract ballets by Balanchine, MacMillan and others. 
 Since choreographers discarded the conventions which kept &bquo;ballet dancing&equo; in a straight jacket (after Fokine taught that it was &bquo;the whole body that dances&equo;, not merely the legs), the classical vocabulary has provided ideal material on which to build for those who understand its technique. 
 It was and stili is the extraordinary pictorial value of the linear patterns and forms created by Nijinska for Les Noces  which emphasises more clearly than any other ballet the need for every choreographer to keep strict control over the mass of material needed to make a single work. 
 At the time of its production, Diaghilev was convinced that another truly Russian ballet was needed, traditional in essence but reflecting the revolutionary ideas of contemporary artists working in Russia as well as Paris. 
 Stravinsky had started composing Les Noces  before 1913 and often played it toDiaghilev, gradually simplifying his ideas until it became the present cantata for voices, four pianos and percussion. 
 Similarly the artist Goncharova's original gorgeously coloured designs for traditional Russian wedding costumes were made austere in keeping with Nijinska's demands for simplicity even though Les Noces  was to be danced sur les pointes . 
 She felt that their use &bquo;would elongate the dancers' silhouettes and thus resemble the figures of Byzantine Saints&equo;. 
 Anyone acquainted with ancient ikons will recognise how acutely she has captured their essence. 
 The ballet is also based on the traditional Russian wedding rites which prepare both Bride and Groom for the ceremony before the wedding feast. 
 Yet Les Noces  was also of its own time, 1923. 
 It was strongly influenced by the contemporary art movement known as Constructivism, which was being energetically pursued. 
 It has been defined as: &bquo;The minimal requirements needed to fill a picture surface meaningfully, whilst combining various materials into forms that usually do not depict anything&equo; (O.E.D.). 
 The forms depicted by Nijinska are far from meaningless. 
 Not only do they reflect the significance of each part of the ancient ritual, but also the solemn chant of the singers during the ceremonies and later the raucous shouts of the guests at the feast. 
 She displays how to build living structures of pictorial importance by weaving individual dancers or groups deliberately and solemnly so that they frequently pause in a meaningful picture of distinctive shape. 
 These are the full stops to a paragraph that give the audience an opportunity to sum up &mdash; as it were &mdash; how the Bride's hair is cut; why the men convey the Groom to the Bride's house; how the Bride and Groom are blessed by their parents; and so on. 
 By so phrasing each paragraph and bringing each incident to a proper conclusion, Nijinska gives both dancers and audience time to consider what has been done and what is yet to happen. 
 The nature of the formal shapes made by the dancers' bodies and limbs as they move into and hold a picture must be evaluated. 
 Nijinska insisted on the use of the pointes  in order to emphasise the elongated portraits of the Byzantine Saints, thus the dancers' bodies mostly face the audience but their arms and legs turn inwards and are seen mostly in profile. 
 The angles made at the elbows, shoulders, knees and ankle joints are clearly visible. 
 Those of the arms are particularly interesting because the fists are either clenched or the fingers flattened thus the lines and shapes made only appear slightly rounded by the folds in the sleeves. 
 The dancers drawing these straight, angled and very slightly rounded lines have to work accurately and be correctly aligned with their neighbours in each temporary grouping. 
 Each grouping has to be correctly aligned with the other whether it precedes, balances or follows another. 
 Yet each must be within the whole framework. 
 This is particularly so in the last dance, when the  Bride and Groom are watched by all as they solemnly walk together through the doorway into their room. 
 This moment is the proper conclusion that sums up what has now been accomplished. 
 Few, if any other choreographers, have consistently controlled the very personal and strongly motivated style for a single ballet. 
 It is starkly simple and exactly states its purpose demonstrating that even the most primitive of beliefs and traditional practices are valid materials on which to build not only the style but the dramatic content of a ballet. 
 It emphasises, too, man's primitive belief that if his real life task is to be successful, then it must first be enacted in the magic made by dance (see page 15). 
 Les Noces  practises the art of the general and the art of the particular at one and the same time. 
 This should be the important factor of every ballet. 
 Nijinska's design. 
 reveals the group personality of peasants attending a traditional Russian wedding. 
 They already know the part they have to play to ensure its success. 
 Not even the Bride and Groom stand out. 
 They are dressed like everyone else. 
 In fact they scarcely dance at all. 
 Yet because of their passive acceptance of the ministrations of their neighbours they become the focus of attention. 
 The group activities ensure that each phase of the ceremony is performed according to tradition. 
 The design emphasises the importance of creating a style which will define not only the time, place and action, but also the characters portrayed. 
 The technical or general style creates the structure and atmosphere of the whole. 
 In other words, the particular becomes the general. 
 A similar analysis could be made of MacMillan's Requiem . 
 The general structure is drawn from specific rules of movement. 
 It comprises elements from both modern and     classical techniques ensuring that the lines and patterns made by the dancers' bodies are more expressively stretched and angled and less rounded than usual, because so much is danced with tense emotion. 
 These shapes are built into moving pictures which are inspired by those drawn by Blake to illustrate stories from the Bible. 
 Because the dancers' gestures register despair, anger, appeals for help and then resignation, the emotional content of the whole is overwhelming. 
 No one stands out, although some emerge from the group in brief solos to express their personal sense of loss. 
 But these soloists are the links between one group or grouping and another. 
 Everyone is part of the whole design. 
 Yet when the stage is empty of mourners, there emerges a solitary dancer and the entire mood changes. 
 She is a child-like figure who dances innocently to Faur&eacute;'s Pie Jesu . 
 As she explores the vast cathedral-like space with her movements, she marvels at the shapes and lines every part of her body can make to fill the space. 
 She is supremely happy merely to dance in such a setting and to such music. 
 She represents hope and it is the purity of MacMillan's design which shows how &bquo;the whole body dances&equo;. 
 When the mourners return, all passion spent, recognising the eventuality of death and now resigned to their loss, the child-like figure can be raised on high in the final Amen (see page 46). 
 Requiem  MacMillan's modern classicism and use of Blake's drawings: the Mourners (The Royal Ballet led by Bryony Brind)... 
 ... 
 Pie Jesu (Lesley Collier) 
 Technical characteristics 
 It is the very particular choreographic style that MacMillan created for the child-like figure in Requiem  that emphasises more strongly than any other of today's ballets the need for choreographers to explore dance itself. 
 Only when they have examined what hands, arms, legs and feet, body and above all the head can do in isolation and then in harmony with the story, theme or music, can they set out and create a style which will be general in structure and particular in texture, with the right quality, mood, emotion, action and character. 
 The structure will determine the lines and shapes needed to fill the dimensions and, when needed, help to create the atmosphere and mood of the whole. 
 Choreographers must then decide how many and which details they need to add to disclose the particular features of the story, theme and/or music that they wish to communicate. 
 The exploration of what each part of the body can express in isolation and then in co-ordination with the rest is possibly the most important aspect of a choreographer's work if it seeks to be modern in spirit and technique. 
 Different fields of research have disclosed the many different factors that can affect both physical and mental behaviour. 
 All such studies have influenced every form of art in some way. 
 Dance seems to have been affected most by psychological studies initiated by Freud and others and first exploited by Rudolf von Laban and Mary Wigman. 
 Such theories have helped to free dancers from the strict conventions of classical technique and to develop what can be called body language. 
 Such theories also opened up other fields in which to search for inspiration. 
 The danger is that too much reliance can be placed on intellectual exercises with resulting works only comprehensible to those studying the same theories. 
 Nevertheless it is worth citing some instances where the continual use of one or a very few gestures can fully describe the feelings of some characters and convey their reactions to the circumstances of the plot or theme. 
 Hands 
 Ashton described the innocence, piety and wonder of the Bride at the event to be when he created the exquisitely detailed hand movements in The Wise Virgins , as he did for La P&eacute;ri  and Madame Chrysanth&egrave;me . 
 Also there was his own final gesture  of hopelessness in Nocturne  (see page 109). 
 MacMillan created a strange gesture for Rudolf in Mayerling ; he frequently clasps his hand against the side of his head and ear as if to ease the pain of his deteriorating brain in order to shut out the rumours surrounding his every activity. 
 This gesture becomes more strongly evident and unpredictable as more and more events crowd in until both hands are used to shut out thoughts of the suicide he feels is inevitable. 
 Legs 
 In Ashton's The Two Pigeons  and A Month in the Country  there is the ecstatic quiver of the leg which continues upwards through the body until the Young Girl or Natalia and Vera can rest their head on their lover's shoulder as they embrace. 
 The ecstasy of love being felt to rise through the body &bquo;from the tips of the toes, to the tips of the fingers and from the heart to the head&equo; was said by Anna Pavlova to be the essence of dance. 
 And it is in so many of Ashton's pas de deux  where the truth of those words is always evident. 
 There is a particularly fine example in the last pas de deux  of La Fille Mal Gard&eacute;e  where Lise and Colas weave themselves into an embrace which is so tender, gentle and loving that it arrives at the end of a phrase as the most natural thing in the world. 
 There are other delicious gestures drawing attention to the feet in La Fille Mal  Gard&eacute;e  such as Mother Simone gently tapping her clogs as if thanking them for   allowing her to show off her particular style of dance. 
 It emphasises that she is not the awful old termagant she has so far seemed to be. 
 A similar tiny gesture takes on the same value when Alain rubs one foot up and down the other leg when the girls tickle him. 
 This not only allows him to indulge in more of those awkward movements, which make his first solo such a wonderful parody of classical dance, but shows him as the pathetic clown, always the butt of everyone's laughter. 
 Mayerling MacMillan's use of specific gesture  Mary Vetsera gives her willing body to the tormented Rudolf (Fiona Chadwick, Wayne Eagling ) 
 Heads 
 However some of the most expressive movements are made by the head because the way in which it is used can draw attention to the look on the face. 
 As John Weaver said (1708): &bquo;The face is the mirror of the soul&equo;, and in dance &bquo;must speak through the eyes&equo;. 
 The mere fact of lowering the head in suffering and despair or raising it in anger or appeals for help as the dancers do in MacMillan's Requiem  vividly conveys the tragedy and sorrow that has befallen these mourners. 
 Yet it is the head movements of the young girl as she dances to Pie Jesu  that are so telling. 
 She actively watches the lines made by her arms and legs as they form varying shapes. 
 She marvels that they flow so easily to fill the vast space in which she moves. 
 She raises her eyes to the wonder of its beauty, sometimes tilting her head as if listening to the music echoing round her. 
 In Gloria  every movement seems tense even when characters are looking tenderly at those they love for they are always aware of the next leave-taking. 
 This is particularly poignant towards the end when both girls and boys, the youth of their generation, disappear forever in the tragedy of war 
 Choreographers today choose to interpret a vast range of subjects through what can be termed the purely physical movements of the body, sometimes coloured by moods ranging from the tragic to the comic and even the ridiculous. 
 They sometimes create what can be called highly intellectual concepts such as the case-history of a mental patient, which require a distinctive style. 
 Unfortunately these histories are not always clear owing to the limitations of the human body and its inability verbally to state the problems. 
 Dance is a language of silence. 
 Everything has to be expressed by movement alone, coloured by expression. 
 It is impossible exactly to define what is modern dance because the body is the same that has danced for hundreds of years. 
 Choreographers cannot in any way change the ways in which their dancers move. 
 The audience recognise physical movement for itself alone whereas those who theorise and attempt to define what they mean by such terms as post or neo-modern, contemporary, avant-garde, etc. base their works on intellectual concepts which need to be discussed in words. 
 Thus the audience fail to understand everything that is offered. 
 Dance is firstly a physical activity and if it is obscured by complicated costumes, props, machinery, lighting and stage effects, it ceases to be relevant to anything but the cleverness of the producer. 
 In a letter Ashton once answered such bewilderment by quoting: 
 &bquo;If we shadows have offended 
 Think but this and all is mended 
 That you have but slumbered here 
 Whilst we shadows did appear.&equo; 
 AS NEW MEMBERS FLOCK TO JOIN A SPECIAL SPREAD CHARTS THE HISTORY AND AIMS OF CAMRA 
 Four men and a shoebox start a beer revolution 
 THE idea for a beer drinkers' protection movement came to four young men holidaying in Ireland in 1971. 
 They were rejoicing in the splendid Irish Guinness they drank and bemoaned the sad state of beer back in Britain. 
 In those days the major brewers were busily promoting keg beer, a chilled, filtered and pasteurised apology for traditional draught beer. 
 Keg was given massive promotion and the success of such brands as Double Diamond and Worthington E was forcing independent brewers to switch to keg production too. 
 There was a real fear that cask ale, Britain's unique contribution to the world of beer, could be drowned in a rising tide of cold, fizzy keg. 
 Michael Hardman, Graham Lees, Bill Mellor and Jim Makin decided to launch CAMRA, which stood at first for the Campaign for the Revitalisation of Ale. 
 Hardman, Lees and Mellor were professional journalists. 
 They were able to drum up a great deal of press and radio material on the sorry plight of British beer. 
 When the first CAMRA annual meeting was held in 1972 the event was given wide media coverage and thousands flocked to join the new organisation. 
 At first CAMRA was run on a purely voluntary basis, controlled by an elected national executive. 
 Graham Lees was the honorary secretary and kept the national records in an old shoe box. 
 Michael Hardman edited a monthly newsletter called What's Brewing, produced on a typewriter and edited and pasted on a kitchen table. 
 But the demands of a growing membership were outstripping the voluntary nature of the Campaign. 
 An office was rented in St Albans and a small staff was appointed, with Michael Hardman as the first editor of publications, responsible for both What's Brewing and the new and immediately successful Good Beer Guide, which listed all the known outlets for real ale. 
 By the late 1970s CAMRA, now known as the Campaign for Real Ale, had more than 28,000 members. 
 Its presence had at first been derided by the national brewers but its campaigning zeal attracted continual media attention and many independent brewers had been encouraged to return to cask beer production with enthusiasm. 
 By the time CAMRA celebrated its first ten years it could pride itself on a large national membership and a series of hardhitting reports that had exposed the market domination of the big brewers and the shoddy beers they produced. 
 The drinking public was now aware they were being taken for a ride by the brewing barons. 
 They were being overcharged for third-rate beer, much of it brewed from cheap and inferior ingredients. 
 It was beer that was forced on the public as a result of expensive advertising. 
 In many parts of the country there was little choice for drinkers as the big brewers owned most of the pubs as a result of the takeover and closure of scores of independent brewers. 
 There was still much to do to ensure greater choice and better quality for drinkers. 
 But beer lovers now had a national movement that was dedicated to fighting on their behalf. 
 CAMRA? 
 It's a piece of cake&hellip; 
 Jim Makin, Bill Mellor, Michael Hardman and Graham Lees celebrate the first 10 years. 
 The first edition in 1972. 
 Saving our pub heritage 
 YOU can't enjoy good beer if the pubs that serve them are badly run or have been modernised in a vulgar and insensitive fashion. 
 CAMRA's Pubs Group involves planners and architects in its work to preserve the quality of British pubs. 
 It is not against modernisation but believes that pubs should cater for all tastes. 
 The group organises the annual pub awards given to brewers or free traders who have built or refurbished houses to a high standard. 
 Keg&hellip; the quick and the dead 
 There is a major difference between real ale and keg beer. 
 Keg, which includes lager, is known in the industry as &bquo;brewery conditioned beer&equo;. 
 Instead of a secondary fermentation in the cask to add a full, mature palate, keg beers are killed off in the brewery by filtration, chilling and pasteurisation. 
 The aim is to produce beers that are sterile, have a long shelf life and are highly profitable. 
 In the case of keg milds and bitters when fermentation is complete they are conditioned for a short period under gas pressure and are then filtered to remove yeast solids and pasteurised. 
 As the beer cannot generate its own carbon dioxide it would be flat and lifeless so it is racked not into casks but into pressurised containers known as kegs. 
 In the pub cellar the kegs are connected to gas cylinders and the gas pushes the chilled beer to the bar. 
 Lager is Britain's insipid apology for the fine beers perfected by master brewers in such great brewing countries as Germany and Czechoslovakia. 
 Such beers as a Czech Pilsner or a German Munchener are rich and complex beers brewed with pale malts, special hop varieties and a bottom-fermenting yeast strain which works at much lower temperatures than ale yeast. 
 British lager is weak (the Whitbread version of Heineken is 12&deg; weaker than the original Dutch version), gassy and served ice-cold to mask its lack of flavour. 
 British lagers are rarely stored (from the German word &bquo;lagered&equo;) for the period needed to develop taste. 
 CAMRA is concerned that inferior beers like keg bitter and lager are foisted on a public unaware of the inferior ingredients used in their production. 
 The brewers of these beers want to produce them as fast as possible and use chemical additives to speed up fermentation, cut down on yeast head to get more liquid into the fermenters and to produce a beer with a thick head of foam. 
 These beers are also made with substantial levels of adjuncts to the malt mash: maize, rice, triticale, wheat flour and potato starch. 
 British brewers do not have to declare the ingredients they use but when American consumers ran a check of Miller Lite they found it contained corn syrup, propylene glycol alginate, papain enzymes and potassium metabisulphite. 
 New readers start here 
 Cask ale &mdash; unique beer of the world 
 Real ale &mdash; or cask-conditioned beer, to give it the correct technical name &mdash; is the champagne of the beer world, a beer that reaches maturity inside its container in the pub cellar. 
 It is that conditioning in the cask that marks it out from the rest of the world's beers. 
 The rest of the world drinks mainly lager beers and even in countries such as Belgium where ale-type beers are produced they come to fruition in the bottle rather than in the cask. 
 The British drink most of their beer in draught rather than bottled form. 
 A cask ale is brewed from the finest malting barley, produced in the main in East Anglia, with the addition of English hop varieties. 
 Before barley can be used in a brewery it must be turned into malt. 
 This requires great skill in encouraging the barley to germinate, producing the natural starches that will provide sugar for fermentation. 
 In a maltings the grain is allowed to germinate, with roots breaking through the husk of the barley, and is then heated in a kiln to produce a pale or darker malt according to the brewer's needs. 
 In the brewery the malt is ground into a coarse powder called grist. 
 It is thoroughly mixed in a large vessel called a mash tun with hot pure water. 
 The sugars dissolve into the water and the sweet liquid, called wort, is pumped to a copper. 
 The flowers of the hop plant add bitterness to beer and the oils in the plant also guard against any infections during the brewing process. 
 As the wort is boiled in the copper with the hops many brewers also add sugars, such as glucose or cereal syrup, to encourage a strong fermentation. 
 CAMRA would prefer beer to be brewed solely from barley malt but the use of sugar dates back to the 19th century and many renowned beers, such as Marston's Pedigree, have recipes that include 10 per cent or more brewing sugars. 
 When the hopped wort has been cooled it is run to fermenting vessels where it meets its destiny with yeast. 
 The type of yeast strain used for ale is known as &bquo;top fermenting&equo;. 
 It works at a warm temperature and vigorously turns the sugars in the wort into alcohol and carbon dioxide, producing at the same time ripe fruity aromas that add to the pleasure of ale drinking. 
 The great head of yeast created during fermentation is cropped off and after a week the remaining yeast is overcome by the alcohol it has produced and sinks to the bottom of the fermenter. 
 The liquid is now officially called beer but it needs a few days further conditioning in the brewery, to purge some of the rough alcohols, before it is ready to leave for the pub. 
 The beer is run into casks. 
 Brewers may add sugar to encourage a strong secondary fermentation and also additional hops to give the finished beer a pleasant hoppy aroma. 
 Finings, a glutinous liquid made from the swim bladder of the sturgeon, is also added: this slowly clears the beer of its yeasty deposits. 
 It is in the pub cellar that the beers  reaches  maturity. 
 The remaining yeast in the casks turns the residual sugars into alcohol while the natural gas produced escapes through a soft porous wooden peg knocked into the shive hole on top of the cask. 
 When a vigorous secondary fermentation begins to die down the soft peg is replaced with a hard one to keep the gas inside the cask, which gives the beer a natural sparkle in the glass. 
 Two days after reaching the pub the beer is ready to be served. 
 Plastic tubes or &bquo;lines&equo; are connected to the tap in the cask and a pump &mdash; known as a beer engine &mdash; or an electric pump draws beer from the cask to the bar. 
 As the beer has been vented and is open to the atmosphere, each cask must be sold within three or four days to stop the beer becoming oxidised. 
 A vented cask. 
 Turn off the gas &mdash; good beer needs no blanket 
 Real ale is a natural product that should be served by the natural methods described above. 
 It can be spoilt if publicans serve it by unnatural methods. 
 In order to prolong the life of a cask, some publicans connect a cylinder of carbon dioxide to the shive hole and cover the beer with a blanket of gas. 
 In extreme cases the gas pressure is used to force the beer to the bar. 
 The end result is an immature beer that has not been allowed to breathe and condition in the cask and which tastes flat and gassy in the glass. 
 In some pubs fake hand pumps serve gassy beer. 
 In recent years some brewers have started to use a cask breather, a simple demand valve connected to a cask and a CO2 cylinder which maintains the gas pressure inside the cask as the beer is drawn off. 
 It is a system opposed by CAMRA as it interferes with the natural processes of beer maturation. 
 Pressurised cask. 
 CAMRA has produced a series of fact sheets on the Campaign, how beer is brewed and other aspects of the modern brewing industry. 
 They are free to members in receipt of a large stamped and addressed envelope. 
 The Brewing Process. 
 The MILL grinds the malt to grist. 
 Grist goes through the MASHING MACHINE mixed with hot water into the MASH TUN. 
 Malt sugar solution (wort) is run off from the MASH TUN through the UNDERBACK to the COPPER. 
 Hops are added and the mixture is boiled. 
 Spent hops are filtered from the HOP BACK. 
 The liquid then passes through the COOLER. 
 From the COOLER the liquid passes into the FERMENTING VESSEL where yeast is added and fermentation takes place. 
 Dry hops and finings are added to cask conditioned beer. 
 Cold storage and filtration for keg and bottled beers. 
 Courtesy of Eldridge Pope. 
 Top ales that haven't lost their bottle&hellip; 
 A handful of beers brewed in Britain still mature in the bottle as draught beer does in the cask. 
 They have to be poured with caution and skill to keep the slight yeast sediment out of the glass and the publican has to rotate his stock carefully to make sure the beer is served when it is in the peak of condition. 
 The most widely available bottled-conditioned beer is Worthington White Shield, brewed by Bass in Sheffield. 
 It is the original India Pale Ale that made Burton the brewing centre of Britain. 
 The version of Guinness sold in crown corked bottles in pubs in England and Wales is naturally conditioned. 
 Courage's Imperial Russian Stout has a powerful gravity of 1108&deg;. 
 The name stems from the fact that it was once exported to imperial Russia where it was popular with the Czarist court. 
 Thomas Hardy's Ale, brewed by Eldridge Pope, has an OG of 1126&deg; and each nip bottle has to be laid down for several years before it is ready to drink. 
 Gales of Horndean brew a Prize Old Ale (1095&deg;) which comes in a cork-stoppered bottle. 
 Among the micro brewers, Burton Bridge produce a bottle-conditioned porter. 
 Knowing the body count 
 The strength of beer is shown in two ways: the original gravity and the alcohol by volume rating. 
 Original gravity (OG) is not strictly an indication of strength but is the measurement taken by excise officers at the start of the fermentation process to see how much sugar is present in the brew. 
 Brewers pay tax &mdash; excise duty &mdash; on the gravity. 
 Water has a gravity of 1000 degrees. 
 If 36 parts of &bquo;fermentable material&equo; are added to water, a beer will be said to have an OG of 1036&deg;. 
 Mild beers usually have OGs of 1030&ndash;1036&deg;, bitters 1034&ndash;1039&deg;, special bitters 1040&ndash;1048&deg; and strong ales anything from 1050 to 1100&deg;. 
 Stouts usually have gravities in the middle 1040s. 
 Brewers are now introducing the Alcohol by Volume rating system. 
 The ABV of a beer may be similar to its OG &mdash; for example 3.6% ABV and 1036%degree; OG but the ABV can be higher or lower than the OG according to the amount of sugar left in the finished beer. 
 It is likely that the present system of paying duty on the OG will be phased out and Britain will adopt the European method of paying tax when the beer leaves the brewery. 
 Tackling the power of the barons of beer 
 There are fewer breweries operating in Britain today than when CAMRA began. 
 It is equally true that there would be even fewer breweries left if the Campaign had not opposed takeovers and mergers vociferously. 
 The history of the past 30 years in brewing has been dominated by the emergence of a handful of giant national companies &mdash; Bass, Allied, Whitbread, GrandMet/Watney, Courage, and Scottish &amp; Newcastle &mdash; driven by a need to maximise profit rather than concentrating on high quality products that also generate a good return. 
 The nationals control the bulk of production. 
 They supply most of the pubs and they distort the market as a result of their sheer size and advertising wealth. 
 The national brewers' leverage has been intensified as a result of the rise of lager. 
 The growth has been fuelled by massive promotions, with the brewers spending some 70 per cent of their promotional budgets on the fake Euro brands. 
 Many smaller brewers do not have the capital to invest in lager production lines and buy their lagers from the nationals, including Guinness's Harp subsidiary. 
 The national brewers account for more than 90 per cent of total lager production. 
 An investigation by the Monopolies and Mergers Commission on the supply of beer appeared in 1989 and in the main agreed with CAMRA that a monopoly existed as a result of the complex vertical and horizontal grip of the nationals. 
 They brew around 75 per cent of all beer, control a majority of tied pubs and dominate the &bquo;free trade&equo; through cheap loans and other backhanders. 
 The MMC's radical proposals included a demand that the nationals should collectively sell off 22,000 pubs, loan ties should be banned and all tenants should be free to buy beers free of the tie. 
 After much huffing and puffing, the government backed down from implementing most of these proposals. 
 The only small crumb of comfort is that, since May 1990, tenants (but not managers) of national brewers' pubs can buy guest cask ales free of the tie &mdash; but the nationals have been quick to dominate this new market niche by organising their own lists of &bquo;guest beers&equo;, many of them brewed by their own subsidiaries. 
 By 1992, brewers with more than 2,000 pubs will have to turn half of them above the 2,000 ceiling into quasi free houses. 
 But they can still be loan-tied, which means the nationals will still effectively control these outlets. 
 Nevertheless, S&amp;N has sold pubs to bring the group below the 2,000 ceiling and Grand Met has sold its breweries. 
 Another disturbing trend is the drift of large regional companies out of brewing. 
 Boddingtons and Greenall Whitley have both sold their breweries. 
 Their beers are now brewed by Whitbread and Allied, intensifying the grip of the nationals. 
 On the positive side CAMRA can point to the success of the independent brewers, many of whom would not exist today but for the interest in cask ale generated by the Campaign. 
 They have been joined by a host of small &bquo;micro brewers&equo; producing a limited barrelage but adding variety and choice in the genuine free trade. 
 With little promotional support, cask ale sales are rising and now account for 20 per cent of the total beer market. 
 There is still a great deal for CAMRA to do to ensure that a wide-ranging and diversified brewing industry survives into the 20th century. 
 But we can take heart from the fact that, apart from Germany, Britain enjoys the greatest choice and variety of beers in Europe. 
 Lager distorts market.  
 Grassroots key to success  
 The Campaign's policy-making forum and driving force is the annual general meeting. 
 It votes on policies for the ensuing year and elects a National Executive, which is also a board of directors, for CAMRA is a company limited by guarantee. 
 The Campaign has branches throughout the country, which organise regular meetings, social activities and brewery trips and also monitor any changes in local breweries and their beers. 
 Branches produce newsletters, local beer and pubs guides and run beer festivals. 
 The branches are organised into regions. 
 Each region has a director and all the regional directors meet together as the Branches Committee. 
 This looks after the day-to-day running of the Campaign, leaving the executive to consider major policy initiatives. 
 The executive has a number of committees and policy groups that take on special responsibilities. 
 The Finance Committee takes detailed control of the Campaign's income and expenditure and organised the buying of the Campaign's head office in St Albans. 
 The Economics and Industry Group has a watching brief on the state of the brewing industry. 
 Over the years it has produced a wide-ranging series of reports on abuses of power by the national brewers, many of which have led to action by central government. 
 The EIG was at the centre of CAMRA's response to the Monopolies and Mergers Commission. 
 The Strategies and Promotions Group takes the policy decisions of the AGM and organises their implementation. 
 It uses the best talents available to produce promotional materials to recruit new members. 
 It also controls the publication of national Campaign books and pamphlets. 
 The Technical Committee looks at all aspects of brewing and serving beer. 
 It monitors new developments in brewing and serving beer. 
 It monitors new developments in brewing and reports on such matters as ingredients and methods of storing beer. 
 All the committees are linked into brewery liaison officers who regularly visit all breweries and report on their state of health and brewing practices. 
 The National Executive and the Beer Festival Working Party organise the influential annual Great British Beer Festival, the biggest festival in the world with the widest choice. 
 The strength of CAMRA lies in the voluntary nature of the organisation and the commitment of the members. 
 But 30,000 members need full-time professional support, too. 
 The St Albans head office has a full-time staff including a chief executive, in day-to-day charge of the running of the Campaign, a Campaigns Manager and a Senior Research Manager, and membership and products managers. 
 The work of head office now has a European dimension as the Open Market of 1993 approaches and CAMRA is a founding member of the Beer Consumers Union which seeks to support traditional beer styles in many countries and ward off greater concentration of ownership. 
 What's Brewing and the Good Beer Guide are produced from head office which is also the home of Alma Books, the Campaign's publishing company that produces such successful guides as Good Pub Food, the Good Cider Guide and Pubs for Families. 
 Apple is a CAMRA subsidiary that campaigns for real cider and perry. 
 It tackles the power of the Big Three cider makers and organises regular cider festivals. 
 KEEP THIS SPREAD FOR FUTURE REFERENCE OR PASS IT TO A DRINKING FRIEND 
 CAMRA CAMPAIGN FOR REAL ALE 
 If you don't care what or where you're drinking&hellip; 
 DON'T READ THIS 
 APPLICATION FOR MEMBERSHIP 
 Do you&hellip; 
 &hellip; enjoy a pint of traditional ale? 
 &hellip; like the relaxed atmosphere of a good pub? 
 &hellip; believe that beer drinkers deserve a better deal? 
 If so, then read on &mdash; you're not alone! 
 Traditional beer and pubs have been under threat for decades &mdash; and remain so today. 
 CAMRA &mdash; the Campaign for Real Ale &mdash; exists to combat these threats. 
 It has been called &bquo;Europe's most successful consumer movement&equo;. 
 CAMRA saved traditional British beer, which the brewers wanted to do away with. 
 It has saved some breweries from takeover, and encouraged new ones to open. 
 It has persuaded pubs to open during the afternoon, and provide an additional beer from a different brewery, through successful lobbying of Parliament. 
 CAMRA is campaigning to save traditional Cider and Perry from extinction. 
 BUT the drinker's struggle is far from over&hellip; 
 &mdash; why is beer 30p a pint cheaper in Manchester than in London? 
 do you know what goes into your pint? 
 Why can we not be told? 
 &mdash; why are we losing the heritage of so many traditional pubs? 
 Brewery takeovers and closures are gathering momentum: 
 &mdash; WATNEYS: 
 Norwich (closed 1985); Wilsons of Manchester (closed 1986); Drybroughs of Edinburgh (closed 1987); Ruddles (taken over 1986); Trumans, London (closed 1989). 
 WHITBREAD: 
 Wethered of Marlow (closed 1988); Boddington, Manchester (taken over 1989); Chesters, Manchester (closed 1988); Higson, Liverpool (closed 1990); Fremlins, Kent (closed 1990). 
 SCOTTISH &amp; NEWCASTLE: 
 Holyrood (closed 1986); Home Ales of Nottingham (taken over 1986); Matthew Brown, Blackburn (taken over 1987), future uncertain. 
 GREENALL WHITLEY, 
 having closed their subsidiary in Wem, taken over and closed Simpkiss (West Midlands) and Davenports in Birmingham, have now decided to opt out of brewing altogether. 
 Brewing at Warrington (Greenalls) and Nottingham (Shipstones) is scheduled to cease in 1991. 
 We name but a few &mdash; will your local brewery be next? 
 &hellip; 
 CAMRA is needed today more than ever 
 &mdash; 
 the increasing stranglehold of the big brewers has led to high prices, poor choice and pub closures; and many new small breweries have been driven out of business. 
 &mdash; 
 multi-million pound advertising promotions for weak but highly-priced &bquo;lagers&equo; constantly mislead drinkers. 
 &mdash; 
 classic traditional inns continue to be destroyed in favour of theme-pub concepts. 
 A growing number of pubs, particularly in rural areas, have been closed, often depriving a whole community of their local social centre. 
 What do you get as a CAMRA member? 
 &mdash; 
 What's Brewing, the independent monthly newspaper for the beer drinker 
 &mdash; 
 an information-packed Member's Handbook 
 &mdash; 
 discounts on many products, including CAMRA's best-selling, annual Good Beer Guide  
 &mdash; 
 up-to-date information about new beers and breweries, takeovers, closures and campaigns 
 &mdash; 
 advance notice of beer festivals around the country, and discounted admission 
 What can you do as a CAMRA member? 
 &mdash; 
 you can join in CAMRA's local and national campaigns 
 &mdash; 
 you can participate in branch activities such as socials, beer festivals and brewery visits &mdash; there is a branch near you! 
 &mdash; 
 you can play a part in CAMRA's Great British Beer Festival, the country's biggest beer extravaganza 
 CAMRA &mdash; THE PUBGOERS' CHAMPION 
 APPLICATION FOR CAMRA MEMBERSHIP  
 I/We wish to join the Campaign for Real Ale Limited, and agree to abide by the Memorandum and Articles of Association of the Campaign. 
 NAME(S) 
 DATE 
 ADDRESS 
 SIGNATURE 
 TELEPHONE NUMBER(S) 
 POSTCODE 
 I/We enclose remittance for individual/joint membership for one year: 
 U.K. 
 &pound;10 
 Overseas 
 &pound;14 
 Joint membership 
 &pound;12 
 Joint membership 
 &pound;16 
 I/We would like to receive further information about CAMRA Knowledge of the average age of our members would be helpful. 
 The information need only be given if you wish. 
 AGE: 
 18&ndash;25 
 26&ndash;35 
 36&ndash;45 
 46&ndash;55 
 56&ndash;65 
 Over 65 
 Please send your remittance (payable to CAMRA Limited) with this application form to: 
 THE MEMBERSHIP SECRETARY, CAMRA LTD., 34 ALMA ROAD, ST. 
 ALBANS, HERTS. 
 AL1 3BW 
 OR WHY NOT TAKE ADVANTAGE OF DIRECT DEBIT? 
 INSTRUCTION TO YOUR BANK TO PAY DIRECT DEBITS 
 Please complete parts 1 to 4 to instruct your bank to make payments directly from your account. 
 Then return the form to Campaign for Real Ale Limited, 34 Alma Road, St. Albans, Herts, AL1 3BW. 
 To the Manager Bank 
 1 
 Please write the full postal address of your bank branch in the box. 
 2 
 Name(s) of account-holder(s) Address Post Code: 
 3 
 Account number 
 4 
 Your instruction to the bank, and signature. 
 I instruct you to pay direct debits from my account at the request of Campaign for Real Ale Limited. 
 The amounts are variable and are to be debited annually. 
 I understand the Campaign for Real Ale Limited may change the amount only after giving me prior notice. 
 PLEASE CANCEL ALL PREVIOUS STANDING ORDER INSTRUCTIONS IN FAVOUR OF CAMPAIGN FOR REAL ALE LIMITED. 
 I will inform the bank in writing if I wish to cancel this Instruction. 
 I understand that if any direct debit is paid which breaks the terms of this instruction, the bank will make a refund. 
 Signature(s) Date 
 Banks may refuse to accept instructions to pay direct debits from some types of account. 
 Direct Debit instructions should only be addressed to Banks in the United Kingdom. 
 CAMRA Computer Membership No. (for office use only) 
 Originators identification No. 
 What's  BREWING 
 NEWSPAPER OF THE CAMPAIGN FOR REAL ALE 
 OCTOBER 1991 
 Bass dodges the draught 
 GIANT brewers Bass have sold 372 pubs to Enterprise Inns, a new pub-owning company based in Solihull, and have artfully dodged the government's &bquo;guest beer&equo; rule. 
 It is the biggest sale of pubs to a single company since the 1989 Monopolies Commission report on the brewing industry. 
 The new company's tied estate is centred on the West Midlands, but stretches from Sheffield to Worcester, and from Leicester to Telford. 
 Further acquisitions are planned once the company is fully established. 
 Enterprise Inns have signed a five year supply deal with Bass and all their pubs will continue to stock Bass beers. 
 This sparked immediate criticism that the MMC regulations requiring Bass to free pubs from the tie or sell them had been by-passed. 
 The Guardian commented that these sorts of deals &bquo;would simply prompt further government investigations into the industry, unless the pub owning company was seen to be genuinely independent of the brewer&equo;. 
 Those publicans stocking a guest beer will lose their rights to do so, since Enterprise Inns is not considered to be part of Bass. 
 Even the Bass list of &bquo;in-house&equo; guest beers will not be available to Enterprise tenants. 
 Enterprise's managing director Ted Tuppen defended the supply deal, saying that it had not been a condition of the sale that Enterprise take its beers from Bass. 
 The group had considered all other brewers supplying their trading area before making a final decision, he added. 
 The supply deal could be terminated at three months' notice. 
 It was also non-exclusive, so Enterprise could take beers from other brewers if they chose. 
 &bquo;We did a lot of research,&equo; Tuppen said. 
 &bquo;Most tenants were very happy with their existing range, and their biggest fear was that we would stop supplying them with Bass beers. 
 &bquo;There was very very strong brand loyalty.&equo; 
 Only a small minority of tenants were taking guest beers and few of them were worried about losing them, Tuppen claimed. 
 Enterprise intends to make free supplies of Highgate Mild and M&amp;B Mild available so that pubs could try out a new Bass beer for their range. 
 Tenants would be consulted about Enterprise's list of approved beer suppliers. 
 Pubs will be placed on 21 year leases and they will be free of the tie on amusement machines and non-beer drinks. 
 &bquo;Our biggest asset is the licensees,&equo; Tuppen said. 
 Enterprise Inns may be a new company but its board is predominantly from the industry. 
 The chairman is Michael Cottrell, former managing director of Courage and presently chairman of Taunton Cider. 
 Also on the board are David George, formerly of Manns &amp; Norwich, and former Watney Truman tied trade director Chris Pitt. 
 Ted Tuppen, with a finance background, is the only &bquo;outsider&equo; on the board.  
 Giant's pub deal robs tenants of guest beer rights Report by Stephen Cox 
 Meet Jim, CAMRAman 30,000 
 CAMRA reached its highest ever membership last month when Jim Jordon became number 30,000 at the Ipswich Beer Festival. 
 Jim is an Ipswich resident of 15 years' standing. 
 He says: &bquo;I do like real beers, but I can't stand keg. 
 &bquo;I can see what CAMRA has done from the local pubs. 
 It would be nice if there were pressure groups for other things that were as effective.&equo; 
 CAMRA's membership has grown from under 20,000 to 30,000 in less than three years. 
 The Campaign now has more paid-up members than it did at the height of the 1970s real ale revival. 
 National Chairman John Cryne was at the festival to give Jim Jordon, on the left in the picture, an engraved tankard. 
 &bquo;We set ourselves the 30,000 target for our 21st birthday &mdash; March 1992,&equo; John said. 
 &bquo;Now we intend to carry on recruiting, towards 40,000 members, and beyond. 
 &bquo;Real ale sales are growing, and there is increased interest in Britain's brewing heritage, but the threat to traditional pubs remains as severe as ever. 
 &bquo;More than ever before the beer drinker and pubgoer needs a watchdog to protect their interests.&equo;  
 Membership reaches all-time high 
 GBG heralds &bquo;key of the door&equo; birthday by Jeff Evans 
 Hot on the heels of the 1991 sell-out, the 1992 edition of the Good Beer Guide goes on sale at the end of this month as a prelude to CAMRA's 21st birthday year. 
 The Guide has long been seen as CAMRA's flagship, mixing solid campaigning points with entertaining features, the latest information from the brewing world and Britain's best pub guide. 
 This year's edition, once again generously sponsored by British Coal, is no exception. 
 The breweries section continues to expand, such is the growth in demand for real ale, and there are many new brews to whet the appetite. 
 More historical information on the breweries has been added and the tasting panels have once more been out and about finalising their tasting notes. 
 If you're a survivor of the Red Revolution &mdash; or was it a failed coup? &mdash; one feature you'll want to read is Brian Glover's nostalgic glance back at those dreadful keg beers. 
 Do you remember who claimed &bquo;It's what your right arm's for&equo;? 
 On the other hand, if you fancy a night in, take a closer look at TV pubs with top critic Hilary Kingsley, while following Barrie Pepper's advice on what to drink at home. 
 Roger Protz welcomes with open arms the rebirth of stout and porter, and Michael Jackson chaperons drinkers who want ale, not lager, when abroad. 
 Campaigning points remain at the forefront: new long-leases for tenants, inter-brewery supply deals and the latest wave of brewery closures are all put under the spotlight. 
 And, of course, the Pub Section points the way to nearly 5,000 pubs that serve top-notch cask beer &mdash; there are more than 1,500 new entries from last year.  
 NEWS AND DIARY CAMRA joins election fray with manifesto 
 CAMRA has launched its own manifesto for the next General Election with policies to be presented to candidates of all parties for action in the next parliament. 
 Election fever rises and falls with the opinion polls but CAMRA is determined that issues affecting the pub and drinkers will be fully debated during the election, whenever it comes. 
 Two-thirds of adults use pubs, and one million people work in the drinks industry or licensed trade. 
 &bquo;CAMRA's aim is that future generations should enjoy a variety of good beers, in a healthy and diverse mix of pubs,&equo; said Campaigns Manager Stephen Cox. 
 &bquo;As a non-political organisation, we believe politicians of all parties will listen to our views.&equo; 
 The manifesto defends the right to enjoy drinking in the British public house. 
 It says that health and social policies should accept that responsible drinking in pubs is a benefit to society. 
 CAMRA rejects tax policies seeking to make beer more expensive in real terms. 
 Britain already has one of the highest beer tax rates in Europe. 
 The Campaign attacks the carve-up of the brewing industry by vested interests, and the way that large companies are getting around legislation following the 1989 MMC Report. 
 CAMRA believes that many &bquo;independent&equo; retailers are in effect tied to brewers. 
 The manifesto calls for a ban on takeovers, greater controls over supply deals between brewers and pub owning chains, the extension of the guest beer to managed houses, and action on local monopolies. 
 CAMRA restates its support for the principle of the tied house. 
 It warns that unless the brewing industry gets its act together, the European Commission will impose sweeping changes on the industry. 
 On licensing issues CAMRA wants the right for pubs to open on Sunday afternoons and for children to be allowed into suitable pubs, reforms already introduced in Scotland. 
 CAMRA wants the right of licensing authorities to refuse new pub licences much more carefully defined. 
 The Campaign wants a major new right for pub customers: to be consulted over refurbishments to their locals. 
 Proposals should have to be advertised locally, the manifesto says, and customers should be given a right of audience before the licensing authorities to oppose unwelcome changes. 
 CAMRA supports tenants evicted so that pubs can be run by managers or who refuse to sign new leases on unfair terms. 
 CAMRA wants a sliding scale of excise duty, to promote competition by encouraging the retention of specialist breweries owned by larger concerns. 
 Finally, the Campaign seeks a ban on TV advertising of alcohol and laws requiring the listing of alcoholic drinks ingredients. 
 P. A. Newton 
 Ex-pat Scouse is top Twit 
 OUR chums at Twitbread once again wins the wooden spoon for naff PR. 
 The &bquo;brewing&equo; (sic) group's might organ, Twitbread News, informs me that Twitters have made a special award to Paul McCartney as &bquo;Scouse Personality of the Year&equo;. 
 Scouse? 
 Surely this term should be used to describe someone who lives and works &mdash; or draws the dole &mdash; in Scouserpool? 
 When last sighted, McCartney was living in the soft south, several hundred miles from his natal city. 
 He did, however, make a brief appearance in Scouseland this summer for the premiere, and so far only, performance of his &bquo;Oratorio&equo; in the Anglican cathedral, his first serious musical work since Rupert and the Frog Song. 
 Twitbread News further regales me with the information that McCartney was voted Scouseperson of the Year by &bquo;the people of his home city&equo;. 
 Unlike serious pollsters, the brewer's flaccid organ fails to report the size of the sample of Scousers interviewed but it is believed to be adjacent to the number of fans at a Tranmere Rovers away match. 
 Personally, I would have voted for the lads at Cain's Brewery but Twitters may have got the jitters if the revamped Higson's had made the headlines. 
 But at least the Cain's mob would have made the lunch where the awards were announced. 
 McCartney sent his apologies. 
 Well, it's a long drive from Essex&hellip; 
 Canvas bagman 
 FEELING sorry for poor old George &bquo;Punchy&equo; Walker, so brutally deprived of his role as chairman and chief exec of Brent Walker by the rest of the board? 
 Re-programme your feelings, in that case. 
 The annual BW accounts, published last month, reveal that Gorgeous George voted himself a 17 per cent pay rise last year just as his company was plunging to the canvas with debts of &pound;350 million. 
 The former boxer and founder of the Spud-U-Hate fast-food chain saw his salary rise from &pound;515,000 a year to &pound;606,000. 
 This is thought to be a mite higher than the brewery workers in Hartlepool will draw on the dole even if the management buyout of Cameron's Brewery is successful. 
 Commenting on the Bent (sorry, this is a printing error)  Walker figures, accountants Peat Marwidk McLintock &amp; Leigh Carr said: &bquo;We are unable to form an opinion as to whether the financial statements give a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the company&hellip;&equo; 
 Methinks a few thousand Hartlepudlians could form an opinion, especially where George &bquo;In the Red Corner&equo; Walker's salary rise is concerned. 
 Meanwhile, the Frivolous Crime Squad continues to investigate the company's accounts. 
 Upchuck Downunder 
 I AM indebted to the worthy journal Australian Hotelier for this nauseous account of a court case involving the major Oz brewers, Tooheys. 
 Appearing before Mr Justice Beaumount in the New South Wales Federal Court, Tooheys had to answer a charge of misleading the public and of deceptive advertising. 
 The group had claimed that drinkers would have to consume a &bquo;not insignificant amount&equo; of their 2.2 light beer before reaching the .05 blood alcohol limit set for drivers in NSW. 
 No less than 66 people &mdash; mugs in Australian parlance &mdash; volunteered to drink up to eight &bquo;middies&equo; (285ml) of the kangaroo's by-product in an hour. 
 The end result was that Tooheys won the day, with most of the drinkers still under the limit after an hour's soaking. 
 But the case left a few unfortunates in its wake. 
 Two of the volunteers ran up the white flag and couldn't stay the court. 
 Four more drinkers produced violent  Technicolored  Yawns long before reaching the eighth glass. 
 As M'lud Beaumont intoned, drinking that amount of 2.2 is an &bquo;uncomfortable process&equo;. 
 Pass the sick bag, Alice Springs. 
 Crouch v. crutches 
 I AM pleased to bring the glad tidings that the British Guild of Beer Writers cricket team have at last won a match. 
 Thrashed mercilessly two years running by the Crouch Vale Brewery Ensemble in Essex, the BGBW geriatrics got their revenge last month by trouncing the brewers by eight wickets. 
 It would have been nine wickets, but Lewis Eckett, editor of Club Horror, was Absent Without Leave. 
 The age of the BGBW tyros, who included Chris Hutt, Iain Dobson and R. &bquo;Stumper&equo; Protz, did cause some concern. 
 At one stage the scorer called out: &bquo;What is the name of the grey-haired player?&equo; 
 Back came the riposte: &bquo;Which one?&equo; 
 Weeny one 
 ONCE again baseless charges of lewdness and indecency in this column make it impossible for me to report the following headline in the newsletter of Wolverhampton and Dudley Breweries: &bquo;What's Five Inches Long &mdash; and Worth &pound;200?&equo; 
 I didn't know you could get it insured. 
  Chin, chin!  
 Tankard awards 
 THE closing date for entries in the 1991 Tankard Awards competition organised by the British Guild of Beer Writers and sponsored by Bass is 1 November. 
 Entries &mdash; from part-time writers as well as professionals &mdash; should be sent to Mike Ripley, Brewers' Society, 42 Portman Square, London W1H 0BB. 
 New bed guide 
 A NEW edition of Beer, Bed and Breakfast, CAMRA's guide to pub accommodation, will be published in spring 1992. 
 Members with suggestions for new entries should send them without delay to Roger Protz at CAMRA HQ.  
 NEWS Wonderful summer for Wood's 
 THE summer was a scorcher for Wood's, the family-owned Shropshire brewery. 
 While many brewers are bemoaning over-capacity and falling sales, Wood's are trading 33 per cent up on last year's summer figures on their Parish, Special and Wonderful brews. 
 Reaction to their two recently-rescued Sam Powell ales, formerly brewed by the Sam Powell Brewery in Newtown, Powys, is also very encouraging, with repeat orders coming in at a good rate. 
 The brewery at Wistanstow, Craven Arms, is nearing brewing capacity and Wood's are bringing forward plans to extend their premises and work should start this Autumn. 
 And the business boom has been matched by accolades awarded to Wood's Wonderful, at 1050&deg;OG the most heady of their five regular beers. 
 The brew has been listed as one of the UK's top 100 by a multimillion circulation national magazine. 
 It has won its way into CAMRA's Heart of England Beer Festival finals. 
 And Wood's Wonderful beer mats have taken second place in the British Beermat Collectors' Society annual popularity poll. 
 * Winners of the Beermat Collectors awards were: set of mats &mdash; Burton Bridge (1), Guernsey Brewery (2) and Cotleigh Brewery (3). 
 Individual mats &mdash; Jolly Roger (1), Wood's (2) and Otter Brewery (3). 
 Jolly Roger backs both sides in war re-run 
 A VITAL battle in the English Civil War was re-enacted in Worcester last month &mdash; with help from the city's Jolly Roger Brewery. 
 The brewery was asked by the Civil War Centre to sponsor two of the key events in the pageant &mdash; the entry of King Charles and his Scottish army into Worcester in 1651 and his escape from the city when Cromwell's forces routed his troops. 
 When the Royalist army arrived at Worcester's oldest pub, the Cardinal's Hat, they were refreshed with pints of a special 1042&deg; gravity beer, &bquo;His Majesty's Royal Celebration Ale&equo;, brewed by Jolly Roger. 
 When the Cromwell forces arrived, the pumpclips in the Cardinal's Hat were rapidly changed to read &bquo;Parliamentarians Premium Ale&equo;. 
 The Jolly Roger Quaffers raised more than &pound;400 for charity, which will be used to take a party of under-privileged children to Drayton Manor park and zoo. 
 The Worcester Evening News picture shows troops outside the Cardinal's Hat. 
 S&amp;N come clean on Brown clips 
 SCOTTISH &amp; Newcastle will relabel all Matthew Brown beers. 
 S&amp;N closed the Matthew Brown brewery in April and transferred brewing to Home in Nottingham. 
 But point of sale material, in particular fonts, referred to Matthew Brown as a &bquo;brewer of fine Lancashire ales&equo;. 
 Paul Riley, CAMRA's liaison officer with Matthew Brown, commented: &bquo;Brown isn't a brewer of anything. 
 And Nottingham isn't in Lancashire.&equo; 
 CAMRA complained to the local trading standards officers, who have agreed that the fonts were misleading. 
 Victory as Tories give in on labels by Iain Loe 
 AFTER years of lobbying, it looks as if the Government will bring in legislation to force brewers to list the ingredients in their beers. 
 The Food Advisory Committee's latest review of labelling legislation has recommended that all alcoholic drinks should be subject to the same legislation that governs all other foodstuffs. 
 The Government is believed to be willing to accept the recommendation. 
 If you go into a pub today and buy a pint of beer, a coke, a low alcohol lager and a packet of crisps, you have a right to know what is in all those products except the beer. 
 &bquo;That is nonsense,&equo; says CAMRA's Campaigns Manager Stephen Cox. 
 &bquo;A more health conscious consumer wants to know what he is drinking.&equo; 
 Now, at long last, the brewers will have to step in line. 
 It is not surprising, since it is almost certain that the European Commission will shortly propose that labelling of ingredients for alcoholic drinks should become law throughout the community. 
 Recently, thanks to legislation from the EC, all drinkers have to state their alcoholic strength by volume (ABV). 
 CAMRA, in conjunction with fellow beer consumer organisations in the European Beer Consumers Union, have produced a &bquo;Euro-Beer Label&equo; setting out exactly what beer drinkers would like to see declared. 
 The demands include ingredients, place of brewing, date of bottling or racking, and whether or not it is cask or brewery conditioned, bottle conditioned or pasteurised. 
 * Just to show the brewers how it should be done, CAMRA is producing a bottle-conditioned beer to celebrate 21 years of the Campaign. 
 The beer will have labels giving all the information it is felt the beer consumer needs. 
 The bottled beer will be available early in 1992. 
 Oxon brewer cuts prices 
 OXFORD independent Morrells has announced small price cuts for some of their beers. 
 The brewery is reducing wholesale prices of Morrells Bitter and lager by about one pence a pint. 
 This follows six years where wholesale prices have risen less than inflation, according to the brewery. 
 Morrells hopes to hold the price of cask mild for a further 12 months. 
 Other price rises will be less than the rate of inflation. 
 Managing Director Charles Eld sees this as part of a package to preserve traditional local pubs. 
 &bquo;We want our tenants to be able to offer good beers at the right price,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We're leaving big managed pubs to other companies.&equo; 
 PUB OPINION 
 Guest Beer Writer Dave Goodwin 
 As the leaves fall where can I take my kids? 
 &bquo;MANY as are the virtues of the Moon under Water I think that the garden is the best feature, because it allows whole families to go there instead of Mum having to stay at home and mind baby while Dad goes out alone. 
 &bquo;And though, strictly speaking, they are only allowed in the garden, the children tend to seep into the pub and even to fetch drinks for their parents. 
 This, I believe, is against the law, but it is a law that deserves to be broken, for it is the puritanical nonsense of excluding children &mdash; and therefore to some extent, women &mdash; from pubs that has turned these places into mere boozing-shops instead of the family gathering-places that they ought to be.&equo; 
 (George Orwell, London Evening Standard, February 1946). 
 THINGS haven't changed much in 45 years. 
 As autumn approaches, those of us with children have to leave the relaxed, informal and often cold and damp atmosphere of the pub garden in search of those few pubs which admit children somewhere within their four walls. 
 The present laws, except in Scotland, prevent the under-14s being admitted to bars or licensed premises. 
 I understand the definition of a bar is somewhere used principally for the consumption of alcoholic beverages. 
 Strictly a child could be excluded from a pub garden if it is used principally as a drinking area. 
 Even the &bquo;family room&equo; may not be strictly legal. 
 Everything is open to interpretation, usually by the police, and the poor, hard-pressed licensee and his customers are so confused that the usual solution is to avoid the problem and not let children into the pub at all. 
 While we must support family rooms in those pubs which have the space and can provide suitable amusement for the little angels, this cannot remain the only answer to the problem. 
 Family rooms are useful to let the less well-behaved and noisier children run riot but they are frequently cold and characterless and, no matter how good the facilities may be, you often feel excluded from the main atmosphere of the pub. 
 I WOULD rather take my children into the main bar or lounge of a pub and expect them to sit sensibly and reasonably quietly so that we can all relax, drink, talk and eat in a proper pub atmosphere. 
 What is needed is a relaxation of the law as it now stands to allow the controlled admission of children to certain pubs at certain times of day. 
 I am not proposing a free-for-all, but the admission of children to certain pubs on the application of the licensee and the approval of the local licensing bench. 
 Assuming licensees and magistrates act sensibly in seeking and granting approval, I cannot see any strong objection to this. 
 The attitude of many who object to children in pubs is not dissimilar to those who objected to women in men-only bars and pubs in the early 1970s. 
 &bquo;I work with women all day and I go to the pub to get away from them&equo;&hellip; 
 &bquo;I go to the pub to get away from the wife&equo;&hellip; 
 &bquo;The pub is a place for men, not women&equo;&hellip; 
 &bquo;It's not a suitable place for women&equo;. 
 For women or wife substitute children. 
 Just who are we trying to protect with these archaic attitudes? 
 The pub as an institution is struggling to survive. 
 Pubs  needs  all the custom they can get. 
 If we continued to exclude children, we are effectively excluding many women, we are excluding families and in many ways the men as well. 
 Everyone then gets out of the habit of going to the pub and goes to the ever-increasing competition such as McDonald's or other fast food establishments. 
 There is also a great benefit in allowing children into pubs from an early age. 
 If young people get used to the idea of the pub being a centre of the community, a place for sensible conversation and for sensible drinking, they are less likely to abuse the pub and its facilities when they become young adults. 
 And for those who say that some pubs are unsuitable for children because they might have some evil influence, then isn't it about time those pubs were cleaned up? 
 What is needed is an active campaign to change the law to allow children, accompanied by a responsible adult, into a public house, or certain specified rooms within that public house, at specified times of the day, the rooms and times being agreed by the licensing justices following application from the licensee. 
 The way things are moving, my daughters will be grown up with families of their own before any change occurs. 
 And who knows how many years will then have passed since George Orwell wrote about his ideal pub? 
 Dave Goodwin, CAMRA's Finance Director, is married with two daughters.   
 COMMENT 
 Leases are threat to pub heritage 
 THE treatment of pub tenants by the national brewers is a disgrace. 
 The headlong rush by the brewers to switch tenants to long leases is creating misery and hardship. 
 The brewers are moving over to leases not to improve the running of their pubs or to offer better service to customers but simply to avoid new government legislation aimed at giving tenants greater protection. 
 One of the few recommendations of the Monopolies and Mergers Commission report of 1989 into the supply of beer that was adopted by the government was to bring tenants under the protection of the Landlord and Tenant Act. 
 The national brewers, whose attitude to staff and tenants would bring a blush to the face of the average Victorian mill owner, object to new legislation that would deprive them of the right to evict tenants and their families at a moment's notice. 
 And so the long lease was dreamt up by Grand Metropolitan and taken up with enthusiasm by the rest of the national pub owners and brewers. 
 In some cases, the leases include absurd barrelage targets that leaseholders find impossible to meet and have to pay heavy fines as a result. 
 Tenants who refuse to accept leases are given notice to quit and find themselves on the streets after years of loyal service. 
 As we show on page 10, brewers are refusing to pay for urgent repairs to their tenanted pubs which they have earmarked for conversion to leases because new leaseholders will have to carry that burden when they take over. 
 The outlook is grim for tenants and consumers. 
 A new breed of publican is being created who has no long-term interest in the pub trade but who sees the lease as the quick route to a fast profit. 
 Logic and experience suggest that, on the contrary, leases in the hands of the inexperienced and short-sighted will lead to bankruptcies and wholesale closure of pubs. 
 As the present government, despite its &bquo;hands off, free market&equo; attitudes, is involving itself in the workings of the pub trade, then it must shoulder the responsibility for the present state of affairs and insist that arbitration on rents must be genuinely independent and not loaded in favour of the brewers. 
 And Secretary of State Peter Lilley should also demand that the brewers pay adequate compensation to tenants who refuse to take leases. 
 If Bass &amp; Co had to fork out &pound;20,000 per tenant their enthusiasm for leases would swiftly fade. 
 NEWS Ryburn bounces back with mild brew 
 THE re-opened Ryburn Brewery in Halifax has started brewing a new mild, Ambleton. 
 The new beer is being brewed for the Stanley Arms in Stockport. 
 The brewery had to shut down between March and June due to problems with its boilers. 
 The beer is flowing again, thanks to help from Clark's Brewery, Wakefield. 
 &bquo;The head brewer at Clark's has helped out a lot,&equo; said Ryburn's owner, Harold Coburn. 
 &bquo;Although small brewers are competitors there's a lot of camaraderie.&equo; 
 Harold started Ryburn in July 1990 after being made redundant. 
 He used his pay-off money to buy the five barrel capacity plant. 
 &bquo;I used to do a lot of home brewing and going round beer festivals gave me the idea of doing it for a living. 
 It's been a hard struggle but we're getting through,&equo; he said. 
 Although he has had a good response from his three other beers, production is still only two barrels a week. 
 The other beers are the hoppy Best Bitter, the more malty Rydale and the powerful and fruity Stabbers. 
 All the beers are full mash. 
 The new mild (1033&deg;OG, 3.2 per cent ABV) is made without caramel from mild malt, chocolate malt and roasted barley. 
 Suffolk's Tolly puts some pride back in Ipswich by Andrew Sangster 
 SUFFOLK brewers Tolly Cobbold celebrated the first anniversary of their &bquo;rebirth&equo; by launching Ipswich Pride on draught at the town's beer festival. 
 The brewery was closed by Brent Walker in 1989 but a management team bought the site and restarted brewing a year later. 
 The team, led by Brian Cowie and Bob Wales, were able to buy the brewery from their employers, Brent Walker, after Ipswich council had slapped a planning order on the brewery site, stopping BW's redevelopment plans. 
 CAMRA were at the forefront of the fight to rescue the brewery. 
 A Tolly Cobbold Action Group collected more than 3,000 signatures against the closure and picketed Brent Walker's London offices. 
 Brian Cowie said: &bquo;It was the Ipswich branch of CAMRA which mounted a publicity campaign to save the brewery and so it seemed appropriate that the launch of Pride should be at the festival.&equo; 
 The new beer was launched in a bottled version last January. 
 It was the first of a range of &bquo;year beers&equo;. 
 The beer (1048&deg; OG, 4.6 per cent ABV) will be available on draught initially for only two weeks. 
 Prices driving away pub trade 
 PRICE rises are keeping customers away from pubs, according to a report by City analysts SG Warburg. 
 Drinkers are resorting to off-licences and clubs instead, it claims. 
 Further damage was caused by the way price rises were introduced, the report says. 
 Big brewers traditionally stagger rises, introducing increases in certain trading areas and certain types of pubs first, such as their tenanted estate before managed pubs. 
 The authors of the report, John Spicer and Philip Morrisey, say the result is that customers perceive beer prices as rising continuously, Beer is no longer considered good value for money. 
 The price freezes introduced by many regional brewers further damaged the reputation of the big brewers, they add. 
 &bquo;Tesco's, with its recent price promotion, has highlighted the price difference between home consumption and that in a pub,&equo; state the report. 
 It also warns that the legislation that followed the Monopolies and Mergers Commission report in 1989 has been a flop. 
 There is now no more choice, competition or lower prices. 
 The likelihood of further government investigation when the beer orders are reviewed in 1983/4 is reckoned to be &bquo;very high&equo;. 
 * Beer prices were raised by two big companies in Wales and East Anglia last month. 
 Leaders of pub tenants and local CAMRA activists condemned the increases. 
 Allied subsidiary Ansells put up prices by six to eight pence in Wales. 
 GrandMet raised the cost of a pint in their managed houses by eight pence in East Anglia. 
 Curfew slapped on Tyne beer fest 
 TYNEMOUTH beer festival had a curfew imposed on it last month by local magistrates. 
 Residents near the Tynemouth Metro station venue had originally lobbied for it to be cancelled. 
 The festival organisers, the local CAMRA branch and Tynemouth Round Table, planned to open from 11am to 10.30pm on Friday and Saturday in the first week of September but were forced to close at 9pm instead. 
 North Shields magistrates clipped 90 minutes off the hours after hearing complaints that Tynemouth already suffered enough from drunkenness. 
 After the hearing in the court Alison Draper, who lives near the station, said: &bquo;Nearly all the people here are against the festival because of the trouble we had to put up with last year. 
 &bquo;There were people throwing glasses around and men urinating in our gardens. 
 CAMRA promised us there would be security men but there were none to be seen.&equo; 
 Anne Whittaker of CAMRA's Tyneside and Northumberland branch denied there was any problem last year. 
 She also pointed out that a considerable sum is raised for charity by the festival. 
 &bquo;We had a very successful festival last year in the same place and many local people came and enjoyed themselves. 
 &bquo;People pay a &pound;2 deposit for their glass and are unlikely to throw it away,&equo; she said. 
 Top barley in decline 
 MARIS OTTER, once the most popular of malting barleys, continues to decline according to a survey. 
 The Home-Grown Cereals Authority Planting Survey shows that the variety contributes only 2.5 per cent of total area of Barley under cultivation in the Eastern Counties (down from 6 per cent in 1990), 0.5 per cent in the South and South West (down from 0.8 per cent) and 0.5 per cent in the Midlands down from 1.4 per cent. 
 Maris Otter was first listed as an approved variety by the Barley Committee of the Institute of Brewing 26 years ago and is still used by brewers such as Youngs, Brakspear and Eldridge Pope. 
 In Scotland, the long time spring barley favourite, Golden Promise, has been delisted by the Committee after more than two decades.  
 GERMANY'S WHEAT BEERS Bavaria's best advice is &mdash; try the Weiss 
 ANYONE who appreciates a good ale is enjoying a fruity complexity of flavours. 
 This derives not so much from the basic raw material &mdash; barley that has been malted &mdash; or the seasoning of hop flowers, as it does from the top-fermenting yeasts used in the making of ales (as opposed to the bottom type employed in lagers). 
 If, though, the barley is augmented, with wheat, that raw material will impart a fruitiness right from the start. 
 Wheat beers also use top-fermenting yeasts (they are not lagers, contrary to widespread belief), and this renders them doubly fruity. 
 Some taste apple-like, and others are reminiscent of plums, or even bananas. 
 There may be more complexities, too. 
 There is a distinct style to the wheat beers made in South Germany, especially the state of Bavaria, and notably the region to the east of Munich. 
 The combination of malted wheat and the type of yeasts used by this region's brewers can sometimes make for a spicy, clove-like character. 
 In Bavaria I have been served the paler, lighter type of wheat beer as a refreshingly tart, acidic, Champagne-like summer refresher, or even as a dessert beer, with elderberry fritters (how about apple pie with cinnamon and cloves?), but there are also darker and stronger versions more suited to autumn and winter. 
 I have been banging on about South German wheat beers for years, and I am delighted to see that they are becoming more easily available in Britain. 
 The most visible examples are perhaps those from the Erdinger Weissbr&auml;u brewery. 
 Erding is an attractive country town near Munich. 
 The town was originally a ducal seat. 
 It was founded in the late 700s, but most of its present buildings (pastel-coloured and timbered, and punctuated with onion-dome towers) date from the reconstruction in the late 1600s and 1700s, after the 30 years war. 
 The easiest way to make the journey, of just over 20 miles from Munich, is by the suburban railway (S-Bahn), one of whose lines ends at Erding. 
 I went this year, during the town's autumn festival, which always starts on the last Friday of August and lasts for 10 days. 
 The festival is held on parkland conveniently next to the railway station. 
 Behind the fairground attractions stands the customary tent, capable of holding 3,500 people, served by waitresses capable of holding ten litre-sized steins of Erdinger Weissbr&auml;u's Festbier. 
 (For the brewery's other wheat beers, it is necessary to walk into the town). 
 Weisse , meaning &bquo;white&equo;, is one designation often applied to wheat beers. 
 In the days when most types of beer were dark, wheat brews were seen as being relatively pale and often cloudy. 
 The term Weissbier  may be used. 
 Or, in the Munich area, the colloquialism Weises . 
 Or the label may bear the similarsounding word Weizen , meaning &bquo;wheat&equo;. 
 The same brewer may use both terms: sometimes Weissbier on his pale, or cloudy (unfiltered) version and Weizen on the darker interpretation, but the terms are interchangeable. 
 &bquo;Dark white beer&equo; sounds contradictory but some brewers, including Erdinger, use that form. 
 Some brewers feel that Weissbier sounds more traditional, because it is an older term; others argue that Weizenbier is more precise. 
 A Munich brewer told me derisively that Weissbier was a local term from Swabia (to the west). 
 Another said Weizenbier was a term used by ignorant Franconians (to the north). 
 I have also heard it argued that the term Weizenbier offers a better guarantee that the beer was made according to the convention that specifies a minimum of 50 per cent wheat. 
 It is necessary to use some barley both for its natural enzymes and its husks, which form a filter in the mash tun. 
 Erdinger says it uses more than 50 per cent wheat, but declines to be more specific. 
 I will guess 50&ndash;60 per cent. 
 The brewery was founded in 1853, started to make wheat beers in the 1890s, and has produced nothing else since it came into its present ownership, the Brombach family, in 1935. 
 At the time, it was making 3,500 hectolitres a year. 
 WHEN I first encountered South German wheat beers, in the early to mid 1960s, they were regarded as an old-fashioned, rustic style, favoured by old ladies with large hats. 
 The beer was at that time customarily garnished with a slice of lemon. 
 People have told me the lemon was to mask the taste of the uneven products made at that time by unscientific country brewers; I do not believe that. 
 Some of the wilder wheat beers might taste odd to the uninitiated, but not to people who grew up with them. 
 I have also heard it said that the lemon reduced the foam to manageable proportions, but why would anyone want to flatten a naturally sparkling drink? 
 I believe the lemon accentuated the tart, refreshing character of the beer, and I am sorry that it is so rarely seen in Germany today. 
 Apparently the green movement is worried that the rind may carry pesticides; a new generation of beer purists dislike the lemon; and it does not go so well with the heavily sedimented style currently favoured. 
 In the early 1960s, wheat beers had only 1 or 2 per  ent  of the Bavarian market, or at most 2 or 3, reckons Erdinger's second generation owner, Werner Brombach. 
 At the time, his brewery was making 20,000 hectolitres a year. 
 In the late 1960s, the cloudy, rustic version began to be replaced by the filtered type, sometimes identified as Kristall . 
 This &bquo;Champagne&equo; image helped it recover. 
 then, in the 1970s, the pendulum of style swung back to the cloudy, sedimented type, which is seen as a more natural product by today's young audience. 
 If the cloudy type is made in the traditional way, as Erdinger is, the sediment is yeast left during a secondary fermentation in the bottle. 
 Some examples from non-specialist brewers are simply sedimented with the residual protein that would normally be removed after brewing. 
 The latest trend has been towards the darker types, still usually sedimented, and today wheat beer has a good 25 per cent of the Bavarian market. 
 Brombach confesses he gulped when he found it necessary in 1983 to invest 45 million marks to make a quantum leap to a capacity of a million hectolitres, at a new brewery on the edge of town. 
 The brewhouse he installed then is now being replicated in mirror image to double that capacity. 
 Both are spectacular &bquo;show&equo; brewhouses, in matt stainless steel, with vessels of traditional shapes though in more singular, stylised renditions. 
 Erdinger is by far the biggest wheat-beer producer in Germany (about twice the size of the other famous specialist, Schneider Weisse). 
 Erdinger contracts with local farmers to grow some of its barley and all of its wheat, and provides them with seed. 
 All the barley is of two-row, summer varieties. 
 Two varieties of wheat are used. 
 A double decoration mash is employed. 
 There are three hop additions, using Perle, Hallertau and Tetnanger, with the accent on aroma. 
 (Hop bitterness does not sit well with the wheat beers' particular style of fruitiness. 
 A top-fermenting yeast is used in primary fermentation. 
 The brewery has only horizontal tanks, in which the fermenting wort is a mere 2.8 metres high. 
 &bquo;People in Bavaria say it is crazy not  to  have tall cylindro-conicals in a wholly ultra-modern brewery,&equo; says Brombach, &bquo;but I think that kind of vessel sets up a convection that makes for dirty beer.&equo; 
 CLEAN beer is something of an obsession at Erdinger, which works to tolerances of a tenth of a degree of temperature, from mashing to fermentation, and is coy about revealing the details of either. 
 The filtered beer is tank conditioned, but the greater part of output has a secondary fermentation in the bottle. 
 For this purpose, it is primed with wort, and pre-yeasted with a bottom culture. 
 This beer then spends from two to four weeks of warm conditioning at temperatures of up to 15&deg;C. 
 I was shown a conditioning warehouse that can hold 15 million bottles and in which pallets are moved by &bquo;robot&equo; lifts  than  run on tracks. 
 It was the most advanced warehousing I have ever seen, even in Japan. 
 The popularity of Erdinger's products is no doubt partly due to their clean, easy, drinkability &mdash; and to a slight residual sweetness that is an intentional house characteristic. 
 For a systematic tasting, I went back to Erdinger Weissbr&auml;u's original premises, a 1537 house that is still the brewery tap, at Number One on the &bquo;High Street&equo;, Lange Zeile. 
 First, there were two bottled beers at around 1050&deg;: the filtered Erdinger Kristall, sweetish, with a hint of vanilla; and the sedimented Erdinger Mit Hefe (&bquo;with yeast&equo;), which has a fruitier (apple-like) character. 
 The Erdinger Weissbier Dunkel (&bquo;dark&equo;), at 1050&ndash;52&deg;, had a spicier character. 
 This is a style of wheat beer that I especially enjoy, with its teasing counterpoint of tartness and chocolate-malt sweetness. 
 Finally, the strong version of the dark: Pinkantus Weizenbock, at 1070&deg;, smooth and liquorice-tasting. 
 THERE was also the Festbier in the tent: just a marginally fuller version of the regular brew. 
 Erdinger Weissbr&auml;u also has a recent stake in the town's other, much smaller, brewery. 
 This is called Erdinger Stiftungs (the second word means foundation). 
 At the risk of seeming ungracious to my hosts, I must record that I found the Stiftungs beer more complex in character and traditional in style. 
 From an extensive range at the Stiftungs brewery tap (built in 1698, reconstructed in 1816, at the corner of Haager and Munchen streets), I greatly enjoyed the Weisse (good clove character); the Dunkelweizen (dates? anise? 
 Victory V tablets?); and the Bavarian Weizenbock (warming, soothing, linctus-like). 
 There was also a delicious Helles (&bquo;pale&equo;) lager in the malty Bavarian style, a toffeeish Dunkles (&bquo;dark&equo;) lager and a wonderfully mouth-coating Bock. 
 I earnestly hope that Erdinger Weissbr&auml;u does nothing to interfere with the Stiftungs products, by either culling the wheat beers or &bquo;cleaning up&equo; their palates. 
 When Weissbr&auml;u has finally mopped up the market for popular, easily-drinkable wheat beers, it will be glad to have such tasty, characterful brews as a specialist line. 
 * Bottled versions of Erdinger's wheat beers are available from specialist beer shops in Britain.   
 The Beer Hunter Michael Jackson 
 THE Belgian &bquo;Beer Year Book&equo; I mentioned last month is available from CAMRA member Richard Larkin complete with an English-language glossary (the book itself is in Flemish). 
 If you already have the book, and want the glossary, send two firstclass stamps to Richard, at 42 Mansfield Road, London NW3 2HT. 
 Black beer from east 
 BITBURGER, one of Germany's biggest brewers, has bought a second brewery in East Germany and may sell its jet-black beer in Britain in 1992. 
 The brewery in Bad K&ouml;stritz in the Th&uuml;ringen region brews two Pils-type beers but it is the speciality Schwarzbier &mdash; Black Beer &mdash; that caught Bitburger's attention. 
 The K&ouml;stritz beer is 3.5 per cent alcohol by volume. 
 At present the beer is bottom-fermenting in the lager style but Bitburger are considering turning it into a top-fermenting beer.  
 LONDON'S FORGOTTEN BREWERIES How East Enders lost their pig's ear* 
 THERE never was a Joe Bloggs &mdash; there's no such surname. 
 But there was a Bill Blogg, brewer of Bansbury. 
 Blogg's brewery was making ales in Roman Road, Barnsbury, in the East End of London around the turn of the century. 
 Perhaps it was seeing signs advertising &bquo;Blogg's Beer&equo; that led East Enders to immortalise the name Bloggs as the Cockney equivalent of Mr Everyman. 
 William Blogg, whose brewery disappeared just before the First World War, is one of a whole host of East End brewers whose names live on, even if they no longer brew. 
 The East End once boasted the biggest brewery in the world, and it gave birth to some of the most famous names in British brewing history. 
 Indeed East Enders can claim to have invented two of the bestknown English styles of beer. 
 Everybody knows that porter was first brewed, according to legend, by Ralph Harwood of the Bell brewhouse in Shoreditch in 1722. 
 The East End was also the place where India Pale Ale was invented. 
 Docklands historians say it was first shipped out to thirsty expats in the Far East from Hodgson's brewery in Bow in 1734. 
 Hodgson's brewery, whose tap room in the Bow Road bore the name Bombay Grab, remained pre-eminent in the India beer trade until at least the 1820s. 
 But the Hodgsons seem to have over-extended themselves and lost their monopoly on exporting beer to India, which was subsequently picked up by such upstarts as Bass. 
 The brewery itself eventually became, some time around 1847, Smith Garrett and Company. 
 This merged in 1927 with fellow East End brewers Taylor Walker of Limehouse. 
 Taylor Walker's Thameside Barley Mow brewery was one of the landmarks of the river east of Tower Bridge. 
 It started out in Stepney as Salmon and Hare in 1730, with Taylor joining the firm in 1796 and Walker in 1816. 
 As the brewery expanded it was rebuilt, taking in first of all, in 1889, the old Lambeth Workhouse, and later the old Lambeth Town Hall. 
 The Barley Mow brewery was among the very last to still brew draught London porter, which it made until the late 1930s, and even in the 1950s it was famous for another dark beer, its Main Line mild. 
 The company made at least one take-over of another East End brewery before the First World War, John Furze and Co's St George brewery, Church Lane, Whitechapel, in 1901. 
 IT GREW rapidly in the 1920s and 1930s, its most famous acquisitions being the Cannon Brewery company in Clerkenwell, EC1 in 1930 (which itself had acquired Holt's Marine brewery in Ratcliffe Road, E7). 
 This proved invaluable in March 1941 when the Barley Mow brewery was knocked out of action by German bombers and the Cannon brewery had to fill in production for 18 months. 
 Eventually, however, Taylor Walker fell victim of Ind Coope in 1959, closing two years later. 
 The name was later revived by Allied Breweries for its London operation, but using the Cannon Brewery trademark. 
 The oldest-established of the Thames-side breweries was Hoare and Company's Red Lion brewery. 
 This traced itself back to John Merchant, a Fleming given a permit almost 100 years earlier, in 1492, to export 50 tuns of &bquo;ale called berre&equo; to the Low Countries. 
 The brewery passed through several hands in the next few centuries, becoming one of several East End specialists in the production of porter. 
 Oliver Goldsmith praised one owner, Sir John Parsons, as the brewer of &bquo;Parsons' black champagne&equo;. 
 The Hoares, a banking family, bought into the concern in 1802. 
 As competition for tied houses became hotter from 1905, with licensing magistrates actively closing down pubs and beerhouses, Hoare's began grabbing up other brewery firms where they could. 
 Around 14 or 15 different concerns were taken over up to 1930, from Tottenham to Brighton. 
 Those in the East End included a half-share in Chandler's Wiltshire Brewery in the Hackney Road, Bethnal Green (via the Lion brewery, Lambeth, the brewery that gave us the South Bank lion); some of the pubs belonging to the Commercial Brewery Co in Commercial Road, Stepney, in 1927 (the rest went to Hammerton's brewery, Stockwell); and West and Co, of the Three Crowns brewery, Hackney Road, Bethnal Green, with 60 pubs, in 1929. 
 Then in 1933 Hoare's &mdash; and its Toby jug trademark &mdash; was itself taken over by an East End brewer, Charrington and Co of the Anchor brewery, Mile End Road. 
 The Anchor brewery had been built in 1757 by a couple of brewers from Bethnal Green called Wastfield and Moss, at a time when the district was so quiet and un-built-up you could still see ships passing on the Thames from the brewery windows. 
 John Charrington, the son of a Hertfordshire vicar, bought a third share in the brewery in 1766, and by 1783 the Charrington family was in sole control. 
 Theirs was one of the few ale-only breweries in London at this time, most of the others producing huge amounts of porter for a voraciously thirsty market. 
 Not until 1833, when the Anchor brewery took over Steward and Head's brewery in neighbouring Stratford, did Charrington's start brewing porter and stout. 
 This was just about the time when pale ales from Burton were starting to grow in popularity. 
 In 1871 Charrington's bought the Abbey brewery in Burton-on-Trent to brew Burton pale ales for itself. 
 The company which sold the Abbey brewery to Charrington's was the London and Burton Brewery Co of Stepney, which carried on brewing in Stepney until its own takeover by Watney's in 1929. 
 BEFORE the acquisition of Hoare's, Charrington's had bought several other East End brewers; the other half of the Wiltshire brewery in Bethnal Green; Savill Brothers' Stratford Brewery, Maryland Point in 1925, the year it closed its Burton brewery; and two years later Tilney's Alma brewery, Spelman Street, Whitechapel, founded in 1854. 
 All the same, the takeover of Hoare's doubled the size of the Anchor brewery's tied estate, and gave Charrington's one-third of all the pubs in the City of London and a fair proportion of those in the East End. 
 This was to prove unfortunate when the Second World War came &mdash; Charrington's suffered more than any other brewery from the effects of bomb damage on its tied estate, with one-eighth of all its houses destroyed or damaged. 
 After a rush of taker-overs in the 1950s and 1960s, from Yeovil to Walsall, Charrington merged with the northern-based United Breweries. 
 In 1967 it merged with Bass in the Midlands to form Bass Charrington. 
 This bought another East End brewery into the family tree, the Wenlock Brewery, in Wenlock Road, Shoreditch, just off the City Road, which had been taken over by Bass in 1961 and closed the following year.  
 Charrington's kept going for longer, but in 1975, after 218 years, brewing ceased at the Anchor brewery. 
 Just a short distance away, where the Whitechapel Road has turned into the Mild End Road, was another East End concern whose name had become part of a company with national interests &mdash; Mann Crossman and Paulin of the Albion brewery. 
 This was started next to the Blind Beggar pub in 1808, and by 1809 it was being leased to a man called John Hoffman. 
 After 10 years, however, Hoffman was bankrupt, and the brewery was bought for just &pound;2,420 by Philip Betts Blake and James Mann, partners in a brewery in Lambeth. 
 The two soon concentrated their business at the Albion brewery. 
 Eventually, in 1826, Blake left the business, which continued under James Mann and his sons until 1846, when James Mann died. 
 Richard Crossman, manager of the Border brewery, Berwick, joined Mann's as a partner, being joined a few months later by a friend from Berwick, Thomas Paulin. 
 Mann's best-selling brew was its &bquo;entire&equo;, or porter, but like other East End brewers it was facing growing competition from Burton-brewed pale ales. 
 In 1875 Mann Crossman and Paulin opened its own purpose-built pale ale brewery in Burton-on-Trent, costing &pound;77,000, to beat brewers such as Bass and Allsopp at their own brew. 
 Eventually, however, in 1896, Mann's sold its Burton brewery. 
 Mann's remained famous for stouts and brown ales, and many other brewers sold its bottled brown ale, first introduced in 1899. 
 The brewery used horse-drawn drays for beer deliveries in and around the East End, and during the Second World War it was hit hard when a German land mine damaged the brewery stables, killing and injuring many of the horses. 
 BUT even in 1963 the brewery still had 25 heavy horses delivering beer in London. 
 Before that, however, in 1958, the year the Albion brewery celebrated its 150th anniversary, Mann Crossman and Paulin had been taken over by Watney's. 
 The Red Barrell company was losing its own Stag brewery, near Victoria Station, to redevelopment, and decided it was easier to buy another London brewery than build one. 
 It did keep the Albion brewery open for another 20 years, but brewing finally stopped in Mild End in 1978. 
 There was still one more big brewery left in the East End, however, the biggest the East End ever saw &mdash; Truman Hanbury and Buxton of Brick Lane. 
 Joseph Truman, &bquo;based on papers now lost&equo;, is said to have set up business as a brewer in 1666, the year of the Great Fire of London. 
 However, he is not definitely found as a brewer in any records that survive today until 1683, when he appears in the register of St Dunstan's, Stepney, as a &bquo;brewer of Brick Lane&equo;. 
 One of Joseph Truman's nine children, Benjamin, born about 1700, became a partner in the brewery in 1722. 
 By the end of the 1730s Truman's Brewery had getting on for 300 publicans on the books, though less than a tenth were tied houses actually owned by the brewery. 
 It seems highly likely that most if not all the beer produced in Brick Lane by now was porter. 
 Benjamin Truman, who was knighted in 1761, died in 1780, and the brewery passed to his grandsons, William and Henry Truman Read. 
 However the brewery, which by 1786 was the second-biggest in London, was run by Sir Benjamin's old head clerk, James Grant. 
 When Grant died in 1789 his share in the brewery was bought by Sampson Hanbury, aged 30, a member of a family of Quaker bankers. 
 He was joined in 1808 by his nephew, another Quaker, 25-yearold Thomas Fowell Buxton. 
 Two more Quakers, the Pryor brothers, Thomas and Robert, who had been leasing Proctor's brewery, joined the concern in 1816. 
 For the next 138 years the Brick Lane brewery was to be run exclusively by members of these three families, the Hanburys, Buxtons and Pryors. 
 By the late 1850s the Brick Lane brewery was selling 400,000 barrels of beer a year, a quarter of it now ale rather than porter. 
 The whole operation covered nearly six acres. 
 Black Eagle Street had been swallowed completely, surviving only as the dray walk, where casks were loaded. 
 The brewery employed 65 coopers, used 130 horses to move the beer out to publicans, and consumed 500,000 barrels of water a year from its own artesian wells. 
 It even had its own Thamesside wharf, Black Eagle Wharf, near St Katherine's Dock. 
 Even though by 1873 it was proclaimed the biggest brewing company in the world, Truman's too found itself under pressure from the growing popularity of Burton ales. 
 That year Truman's bought the Phillips brewery in Burton. 
 Unlike its East End rivals, however, Truman's never stopped brewing at Burton, and its Black Eagle brewery there only finally closed in 1970. 
 For this reason many old Truman's pubs still say &bquo;brewers of London and Burton&equo; on the front. 
 By the mid-1960s Truman's had 1,300 pubs, concentrated mainly in the South-East. 
 By 1971 it was down to 980 tied houses. 
 But profits were low, and predators were around. 
 On July 1 that year Maxwell Joseph's Grand Metropolitan Hotels chain, which also owned the Berni Inns and Chef and Brewer setups, made a surprise offer of &pound;34 million for Truman's. 
 It was certainly a surprise to Watney's, which for the previous four months had been planning its own takeover bid for Truman's, so that it could close the high-cost Mann's site. 
 Watney's came in with its own offer a week after Joseph and &pound;4 million higher than his. 
 Joseph replied with a renewed bid, this time of &pound;43 million, Watney's came back again with &pound;47 million, and so the battle swayed from one side to the other for eight weeks. 
 Eventually Watney's waved the white flag, and Maxwell Joseph had acquired the brewery he wanted. 
 The last big East End brewery had lost its independence. 
 A short while later Joseph had his revenge on Watney's. 
 In March 1972 he made a &pound;360 million offer for the Red Barrel brewer, winning control three months later. 
 EVEN after GrandMet brought its two breweries together in 1973 as Watney Mann and Truman Holdings, the Brick Lane brewery's pubs still kept their own identity and beers. 
 But as the 1980s progressed, the Brick Lane site was becoming more valuable as a potential development area than as a brewery. 
 In January 1989 it was finally announced that the Brick Lane brewery was to close. 
 The last of the old East End brewers was gone. 
 * Martyn Cornell is a member of the Brewery History Society.   
 As the Docklands beer festival fades from view, Martyn Cornell  looks back at the sad demise of brewing in the Cockney heartland 
 Grand Met drop a Brick 
 THE HOPFIELDS REPORT It's &bquo;perfick&equo; ale with Larkin's hops 
 I CAUGHT Bob Dockerty on the hop last month. 
 He was brewing beer and getting the harvest in as well as organising the picking of his Goldings. 
 Larkins Farm at Chiddingstone in Kent is up a narrow, highhedged lane and over two bridges from the Tonbridge road. 
 The brewery, surprisingly spacious, is in a converted cow shed. 
 Across the road there are two handsome oast houses, those familiar symbols of the hop fields with their wonky, cowled roofs. 
 But, in keeping with the decline of the Kentish hop industry, they have been turned into weekend retreats for green-wellied Londoners driving trendy 4&times;4 jeeps. 
 Larkin's own oast house is not so good to look at. 
 It lost much of its roof during the great storm of 1987 which devastated large parts of Kent and turned Sevenoaks into Oneoak. 
 It is still used for its original purpose. 
 As I arrived a tractor pulled up with sacks of freshly-picked hops that would be carried up to the main floor of the building to be dried. 
 Larkins started life in 1986 on the site of the old Royal Tunbridge Wells Brewery. 
 Bob, a keen home brewer, took over from his parents when the plant moved to the farm in 1989. 
 Bob brews 25 barrels a week of Traditional Bitter (1035&deg; gravity), Sovereign (1040&deg;) and Best Bitter (1045&deg;). 
 But the 10-barrel John Hickey plant can knock out more when the occasion demands. 
 &bquo;July was very good,&equo; Bob said. 
 &bquo;And this week &lsqb;early September&rsqb; I'm brewing 40 barrels. 
 That takes three days and I'm also getting the combining done.&equo; 
 Trade has increased because of the general revival of cask ale and the pickings to be made from the &bquo;guest beer&equo; policy. 
 In a region dominated by Whitbread (aka Fremlins) and Allied (aka Friary Meux), who both prefer to supply their own guest beers to tenants, getting into the pubs is no easy matter for a micro. 
 Bob, who hides a sparky humour, behind a grizzled exterior, said tenants who were taking his beers were doing it on a &bquo;belligerent, sod-the-brewer basis&equo;. 
 Pride 
 The brewhouse has an eight-barrel mash tun, a second and larger tun bought from Peter Austin, founder of the Ringwood Brewery in Hampshire, which is used for Bob's main seller, the 1035&deg; bitter, and two fermenters. 
 His pride and joy is the splendid wood-lined copper which he bought from Brendan Dobbin at the West Coast Brewery in Manchester. 
 &bquo;I installed a hop-back in the copper,&equo; Bob said. 
 &bquo;Brendan designed it for hop pellets but I only use whole hops.&equo; 
 The copper is fired at the base by roaring gas flames. 
 Bob tips in a portion of hops at the start of the boil and adds more at the end for aroma. 
 When the boil is over, the spent hops settle on the floor of the hop back, acting as a strainer for the wort. 
 &bquo;I don't use any copper finings,&equo; Bob said. 
 &bquo;I like to build up a good bed of hops. 
 You mustn't take too much protein out of the wort or there'll be no head on the finished beer.&equo; 
 He is careful, too, not to remove all the amino acids from the hops: &bquo;The yeast thrives on it.&equo; 
 If he bought compressed pellet hops he would have to use only half the amount compared to whole hops. 
 But Bob is a great believer in using the plant as nature intended. 
 Know 
 &bquo;With whole hops you know the year,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You can see if there's any disease from browning of the plant and you can see how well they've been dried &mdash; they mustn't be crusty round the edges. 
 &bquo;If you see anything wrong, then take 'em out and don't use 'em. 
 &bquo;You have to rub the hops to get the nose or aroma. 
 Once a hop's lost its &bquo;rub&equo; then it's no use for brewing &mdash; it must have an oily stickiness.&equo; 
 The Dockerty family have been growing hops since Tudor times and know a thing or two about them. 
 They now grow Whitbread Goldings Variety, developed to be more resistant to wilt than the traditional East Kent type. 
 After years of knockabout abuse in this paper, lets give two muted cheers for Whitbread and their hops. 
 Bob uses hops in the classic British bitter fashion: Fuggles for bitterness and Goldings, added late in the boil, for aroma. 
 He gets his Fuggles from a leading grower named Tony Redsell at the splendidly-named Mockbeggar Farm near Faversham. 
 Bob has a further good reason for preferring whole hops: pesticides. 
 &bquo;It's the stalks and the leaves of the hops that carry the sprays, not the cones,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If they all go through the pelleting machines, the residues will remain.&equo; 
 Bob is not keen on the hop oils and essences now being used by some national and regional brewers. 
 &bquo;CO&amp;sub2; extract hops are expensive but they do give a good hop nose when they're added in the conditioning tank. 
 &bquo;But we'd never do that at Larkins. 
 You can tell when you're drinking if beers have been &bquo;spammed up&equo;. 
 &bquo;My beers are certainly bitter but you can drink several pints &mdash; and you can't say that for many big brewers' beers.&equo; 
 Bob is certainly generous with his hops. 
 He puts 3.3 kilos in at the start of the copper boil for Best Bitter and an additional 1.5 kilos at the end. 
 He doesn't find it necessary to &bquo;dry hop&equo; the beer &mdash; that is adding hops to each finished cask. 
 All his beers have a tempting hop resin aroma, balanced by pale and crystal malts, with a tiny proportion of chocolate malt. 
 The yeast, which gives the beers a rich fruitiness, is a strain developed by Ridleys of Chelmsford and further cultured by Crouch Vale in Essex. 
 By European standards the beers are extremely bitter, rating 40 EBUs (European Bitterness Units) for traditional bitter, 36 for Sovereign, 45 for Best Bitter and 60 for a Porter Bob brews in the winter months. 
 Across the yard in the oast house, hops fresh from this year's harvest are placed in a kiln for 12 to 14 hours and heated by electric fans at temperatures starting at 90 degrees F and rising to 140&deg;. 
 From the kiln they are laid out and raked on the pressing floor and packed into the tall sacks with Mickey Mouse ears known in the trade as pockets. 
 Rates 
 Bob rates other beers by their hop character. 
 His favourite is Bass's bottle-conditioned Worthington White Shield as a result of its fine hoppiness. 
 As the sells his beers to the free trade and to national brewers' pubs he has noticed both the  swingeing  price increases imposed by the brewing giants and the reaction among their tenants. 
 &bquo;I can sell my 1040&deg; bitter cheaper than a 1035&deg; bitter from a national brewery,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They're only putting prices up in tenanted pubs because they want to frighten tenants out.&equo; 
 He fears the impact on the traditional character of pubs if the brewers have their way and turn many of them over the leaseholders. 
 But he witnesses a growing determination among some tenants to fight back against their landlords' dubious practices. 
 &bquo;There's a lot of uncertainty in the trade but some tenants are getting Bolshie. 
 They won't take beers from their breweries. 
 &bquo;Others take my beers even if they're warned not to &mdash; they sometimes put them on the bar without pump clips.&equo; 
 From the oast house we wandered back to the brewhouse where the copper boil was progressing satisfactorily and the previous days' brews were frothing cheerfully away in their tall, cylindrical fermenters. 
 In the temperature controlled sample room, where Bob keeps his hops as well as batches of ale, we savoured examples of Sovereign and Best Bitter. 
 &bquo;I haven't got any Traditional Bitter &mdash; I've sold it all,&equo; Bob said. 
 So we just had to pop down to the Castle in Chiddingstone for a pint or two. 
 The sacrifices you have to make in this job&hellip;  
 As the cask beer revival brings life back to English hops What's Brewing writers survey ancient and modern trends 
 Cones, pellets or essence&hellip; 
 MANY years ago a renowned brewer claimed that his brews outshone others because he squeezed his hops &bquo;until the oil ran dry&equo;. 
 Similar confidence in hops extraction is currently running high in today's brewing industry as the range of hop products and their application increases. 
 Fondlers of fresh hops will be acquainted with the sticky oils and resins released from the lipulin glands on hand rubbing. 
 The typical character of fresh hops is pungently rich in floral, spicy and citrus aromas. 
 During normal brewing with leaf hops these flavours are released rapidly into the hot wort and are often appreciated in the vicinity of the brewery during boiling. 
 In addition hops provide bitterness as well as flavour. 
 Bitterness is contributed by chemicals called iso- a  acids. 
 These do not exist in the hops and must be converted from precursor a  acids which are present by an extended period of boiling. 
 Hops thus contain both flavour and bittering components making them valuable ingredients in brewing. 
 Unfortunately releasing these into the wort requires mutually  incompatable  conditions. 
 Flavours rapidly evaporate from hot wort while bitterness requires up to an hour to fully develop. 
 Brewers have been aware of this issue for centuries and have developed the practice of adding &bquo;copper&equo; hops early in the boil to provide bitterness and &bquo;aroma&equo; or &bquo;late&equo; hops towards the end of the boil for flavour. 
 While whole hops are repeatedly claimed to produce the best hop character in a beer, problems may be encountered. 
 First is the liability of hops to deterioration by oxygen in the air. 
 As might be expected this is accelerated by heat, making cold storage essential. 
 Oxidation of hops causes a loss and alteration of flavours. 
 Catty and stale aromas may develop and taint the beer. 
 In addition a  acids oxidise and the bitter character is altered. 
 A second major problem is the loss of bitterness due to precipitation in boiling and in fermentation. 
 This loss in boiling and fermentation occurs because the a  acids absorb to yeast and to trub deposits. 
 Up to 75 per cent of hop bitterness may be lost during standard brewing. 
 Such losses can be overcome by using a larger charge of hops. 
 In spite of accounting for only 0.2 per cent of a beer's cost, this is naturally felt to be wasteful and undesirable. 
 A greater difficulty of using whole hops is the effect on consistency. 
 Loss of bitterness depends on the boiling conditions, on the degree, type and time of trub formation and on the yeast action in fermentation. 
 All of these may vary from brew to brew, leading to beers with variable bitterness. 
 This may not worry a small brewer unduly since other effects offer greater potential for variability but it is anathema to bulk production which must couple closely to marketing and customer perception. 
 To overcome such effects brews are increasingly turning to preprepared hop extracts of one form or another. 
 A range of these exist from simple compressed hop pellets to Pre-Isomerised Kettle Extracts, more affectionately known as PIKE. 
 Compressed hops have a number of advantages, including reduced liability for oxidation, reduced storage volume and ease of handling. 
 An extension to simple compression is to crush the hops and pelletise the powder produced. 
 The resulting pellets are termed Type 90 reflecting the high percentage of hop material present compared to water and foreign matters. 
 Enriched hop powder pellets are also possible by sieving the powder at &mdash; 35&deg;C to remove coarser non a  acid material and by blending with liquid extracts to further enhance the a  acid content. 
 Pellets may also be &bquo;stabilised&equo; by the inclusion of vitamin C (ascorbic acid) to reduce oxidation. 
 Calcium and magnesium salts may then be added to partly catalyse conversion of a  acids so pre-empting the boiling reactions. 
 Losses of a  acid may be reduced from 75 per cent to 50 per cent by these means. 
 Even greater efficiency of a  acid utilisation is obtained using chemical extracts of hops. 
 Many years ago it was found that a variety of solvents extracted a  acids and refinements have continued to perfect the process. 
 Early solvents included ethanol, hexane and methylene chloride. 
 More recently liquid CO&amp;sub2; has been used and found to achieve a better extract with no risk of solvent contamination. 
 Moreover the extraction leaves undesirable chemicals such as pesticides behind. 
 Carbon dioxide also offers the flexibility to separate the hop components into bitter and flavour fractions. 
 This advantage is considerable since the bitter fraction may then be chemically manipulated to produce bitter iso a  acids from the a  acids and so provide a PIKE product which may be added towards the end of the boil or even afterwards. 
 Near 100 per cent utilisation of the hop a  acid is possible by this process. 
 Flavours may also be separated in the hop extract and can be fractionated. 
 Chemical analysis has indicated which compounds are associated with different hop flavours. 
 Copper hop, late hop and dry hop extracts are available, each emphasising the flavour associated with that particular procedure. 
 Brewers may thus formulate a character and emphasis it in the beer. 
 Dry hop flavour is an interesting application since the use of a liquid extract allows a more accurate and consistent flavour to be produced. 
 Moreover whole hops used for dry hopping take seven to 10 days for the character to be extracted and then slowly decline. 
 Dry hop extract provides immediate character which lasts longer and reduces the possibility of infection being added from whole hops or, more likely, from a dirty hand. 
 Because of the degree of processing involved, hop extracts are not necessarily cheaper than using whole hops. 
 Per unit of bitterness they are roughly as costly. 
 Instead their attraction lies in their flexibility to ensure greater consistency in both bitterness and flavour, in avoiding the effects of oxidation and in being easier to handle and more suitable for bulk brewing procedures. 
 A major question is, of course, whether such products provide a better, or at least no worse, hop character than whole hops. 
 If beers brewed with hop oils are compared to beers brewed with stale, out of season hops of unknown history then hop oils will be superior. 
 A comparison of new season whole hops to hop oils, is, however, less clear cut. 
 The criticism that extracts are leading the brewers into the same realms of flavouring technology as the food industry is to some degree unfair since the extracts are modifications of existing ingredients. 
 However, promoting extracts for efficiency and ease of use is not guaranteed to preserve the subtlety of whole hop flavour which reflects the many hundreds of compounds and derivatives present. 
 Traditional producers proudly maintain their commitment to traditional methods and whole hops. 
 The continued success of their beers justifies such an approach but it will be of considerable interest to chart the viability of other beers as the drinking public reacts unconsciously to the character of extracts. 
 Keith Thomas 
 THE HOPFIELDS REPORT Liberated growers wage war on the randy male 
 IT'S NOT just in Eastern Europe that major upheavals are taking place. 
 There has been a political revolution in Paddock Wood in Kent, though it has got marginally less press coverage than the fall of the Berlin Wall or the failed Russian coup. 
 For 50 years the Hops Marketing Board was a governmentregulated body that laid down the price of hops and how many each grower should produce on an annual basis. 
 It also acted as a central store and clearing house for hops, organising the supply to the brewers. 
 Even those in the Britain of the 1980s who would have liked to privatise the last municipal loo weren't too bothered about the Hops Marketing Board. 
 But it ran foul of the European Community. 
 From Brussels and Strasbourg came the stern warning: &bquo;This constitutes a monopoly &mdash; get rid of it!&equo; 
 And so the Hops Marketing Board, like free school milk and NHS orange juice, disappeared into the black hole of British social history. 
 In fact its name still adorns the large office block in Paddock Wood &mdash; they're waiting for the Friends of Felix Dhjerzinsky to come and remove it &mdash; but below is enscribed the new and politically squeaky-clean name of &bquo;English Hops&equo;. 
 &bquo;We're now a growers' co-operative,&equo; David Gardner explained. 
 &bquo;Because of contracts and forward planning, there had to be an orderly change from government monopoly to co-op.&equo; 
 The problem with the old board was that it did not innovate and did not concern itself with exporting English hops. 
 &bquo;There is a direct parallel with the command economies of Eastern Europe,&equo; David Gardner said. 
 &bquo;Market forces did not operate. 
 &bquo;Lagers brewed under franchise in Britain needed special hops, often German varieties. 
 Within eight to nine years production of hops had halved in the UK.&equo; 
 All brewers use the female hop but lager brewers want seedless ones while ale producers need fertilised varieties with their more robust and earthy bitterness. 
 English Hops is now busily developing the export trade and is helping growers to produce seedless varieties &mdash; which means waging war on the hapless and horny male hop. 
 &bquo;YOU'VE got to get rid of the males,&equo; David Gardner said with such fierce determination that he conjured up an image of concentration camps for male hops in remote parts of Kent. 
 &bquo;It's no good one neighbour trying to grow seedless if next door his neighbour has seeded hops blowing pollen over the fence.&equo; 
 But before you rush to form the Male Hop Liberation Front, the little devil is still much in demand. 
 The revival of cask ale has created a growing need for traditional English hop varieties and, thanks to a good summer &mdash; wet at first and then hot and sunny &mdash; there will be a bumper harvest this year. 
 There is even a small but important market for English seeded hops in Belgium, and the United States with its burgeoning microbrewing industry. 
 English Hops works closely with the hop research centre at Wye Valley and with the British Brewing Foundation in Surrey to develop new varieties of hops and to test them in brewing conditions. 
 Our old chums, the Fuggle and the Golding, are remarkably prone to attack by pests and disease, which is why varieties such as Challenger and Target &mdash; more resistant to aphids and wilt but less subtle in aroma and flavour &mdash; have been developed. 
 It is when you get on to the more high tech aspects of English Hops' work that small and muted alarm bells begin to ring. 
 The co-operative sells more cone and pellet hops than any other form. 
 But 20 per cent of its hops are now in the form of oils and essences and it is a growing sector. 
 It may well be there is nothing wrong with hops in this form except that I find that brewers who use them, such as Whitbread and Charles Wells, produce beers with a bitterness that is a shade too harsh for my liking. 
 And David Gardner's defence of processed hops does remind the listener powerfully of the arguments advanced by the brewers in the 1960s when they were replacing cask ale with keg beer. 
 &bquo;In the 1950s and 60s there were superb beers &mdash; if you caught them on the right day. 
 But they could be vinegar the next day,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The new mega brewers introduced new techniques and they were conscious of the raw materials handled in the brewery. 
 &bquo;And the supermarkets, when they moved into beer, demanded reliability. 
 The brewers had to match their customers' demands.&equo; 
 With whole hops, he added, there is a vast decline in aroma volatiles over two years. 
 There is no such decline with extracts. 
 &bquo;Within 30 years the brewing industry has gone from a cottage industry to high tech.&equo; 
 English Hops began their development of hop oils by looking at the &bquo;dry hopping&equo; end of the brewing process, when a handful of whole or pellet hops are added to casks of beer. 
 &bquo;There can be problems of infection at this stage,&equo; David Gardner said. 
 &bquo;With hop oils you can get the best from the hops, the essential oils and essences that can replicate the aroma and bitterness of two such disparate varieties as a Fuggle and a Golding. 
 &bquo;In the early days alcohol, methanol, even benzine were used to extract hops oils,&equo; David Gardner said. 
 &bquo;But since 1980 we have used liquid carbon dioxide. 
 &bquo;The essential components &mdash; alpha acids for bitterness and the volatile oils &mdash; are both soluble in liquid CO&amp;sub2;.&equo; 
 HE admits that the end product has been improved at the expense of character but quotes the co-op's slogan: &bquo;Consistently better, consistently bitter&equo;. 
 &bquo;We're removing the variables. 
 Processed hope aren't cheaper but brewers are more concerned with quality than shaving the price of a pint.&equo; 
 If a slight loss of quality and taste is the downside of English Hop's work, the upside is that oils and essences have opened new markets for growers. 
 &bquo;They're more transportable and sustainable,&equo; David Gardner said. 
 &bquo;A large brewery in Nigeria can't use coned hops &mdash; they need hops that will last and won't be too costly to transport.&equo; 
 English Hops now use merchants throughout the world to sell their products. 
 When David Gardner speaks of his oils and essences having &bquo;a longer shelf life&equo; he raises the spectre of Worthington E, Double Diamond and Watney's Red. 
 But hop oils from Paddock Wood are, at present, made mainly for export. 
 The whole cone and the pellet, fertilised by that raunchy green devil of a male, are still the preferred versions at home. 
 And, as the bumper harvest comes in, there are in David Gardner's words &bquo;No longer long faces among English hop growers.&equo; 
 Roger Protz   
 THE PUB CHAINS Snooty ale houses that want to keep the! *? * out 
 KEEPING prices high keeps the shite out,&equo; says Tony Willis, the new director of Allied's up-market Nicholson's pub chain in London. 
 The remark popped out at the end of an extended tour of Nicholson's pubs. 
 It was made more in jest than seriousness but it does convey the nature of the Nicholson's operation. 
 Nicholson's are emphatically not backstreet boozers populated by men in cloth caps talking about their ferrets. 
 The 35 pubs in the chain are split between the West End and the City. 
 Pubs around the City have a booming lunchtime and early evening trade but usually close around eight or nine at night. 
 The clientele are bankers, brokers and lawyers. 
 Without a pinstripe, you'd be underdressed. 
 Of what interest to CAMRA members, I hear you cry, are pubs that cater for G&amp;T swilling executives? 
 Has CAMRA somewhat belatedly decided to join the yuppie set? 
 Maybe the mobile phones at the Docklands beer festival were no mere accident. 
 The answer is that the City gents are surprisingly fond of their beer. 
 Jim Stevens, licensee of the Red Lion in Lombard Court, EC3, reckons to sell 25 kilderkins (18 gallon casks) of real ale a week. 
 This is despite a tiny cellar which means deliveries are made up to five times a week. 
 There is a double stillage with casks marked with the time as well as the date. 
 &bquo;Our punters, although very much the suit and tie brigade, do like a good pint. 
 Many of them live out in the provinces so we keep a good range of beers that include some from their part of the world,&equo; explained Jim. 
 &bquo;We stock six different beers at any one time from a list that includes Arkells, Adnams, Marston's, Greene King, Youngs and Bass.&equo; 
 Since Nicholson's is an Allied operation it is not surprising that Tetley's is a fixture in its pubs and Burton Ale can usually be found. 
 There is even the exclusive Nicholson's Bitter, the chain's own session beer which was launched earlier this year. 
 The 1035&deg; gravity, 3.5 per cent ABV beer, is brewed at Burton. 
 The beer was soon selling well. 
 At the Red Lion, for example, Jim Stevens says that two barrels a week are pulled through his handpumps. 
 The popularity is put down to a good flavour &mdash; with its tight creamy head it's similar to Tetley's &mdash; the lack of any other light bitters in Nicholson's range that compete with it and a slight price advantage of around five pence. 
 I disputed the latter with Tony who conceded that the differential existed more because it was &bquo;expected&equo; by customers than in any attempt to persuade them to buy the beer in preference to another. 
 Nicholson's customers are not price sensitive explains Tony, although he stresses that this is different to not expecting value for money. 
 He said: &bquo;Our strengths are the freehouse image, the quality of our property and the standards set by our managers. 
 If we get these areas right then price is not particularly relevant.&equo; 
 People will pay a premium price for a premium product, he feels. 
 Pub customers do not just buy their beer. 
 The ambience of the pub is equally important. 
 In part this is created by the building and decor of the pub. 
 Nicholson's are blessed with a range of pubs that are magnificent buildings. 
 They include the Black Friar, opposite the railway station of the same name, which is a favourite for tourists. 
 Built in 1903 it has bronze and marble panels in an Art Nouveau style depicting the friars from the monastery that used to be on the site. 
 Although much of Nicholson's business is centred on the Square Mile, around half of their pubs fall outside this range. 
 The trade here is of a more usual nature with the pubs open to 11 at night. 
 The pubs themselves are no less impressive, however. 
 For example the Barley Mow in Dorset Street, W1, is an expawnbrokers. 
 The wooden booths where people would bring in their items to pawn for cash, or more likely beer, still exist. 
 What all Nicholson's pubs share is a commitment to quality service, achieved through careful recruitment and training of staff. 
 Tony Willis said: &bquo;If I was going to leave a message it would be &bquo;people management&equo;. 
 Our properties were here 30 years ago, the impact we have now comes from our staff.&equo; 
 He was speaking in the Punch Tavern, the only pub to have a national magazine named after it. 
 I asked him to explain his pricing policy. 
 He pointed across the road to another pub. 
 &bquo;By raising our prices slightly we get a certain sort of customer. 
 They are prepared to pay a little more for a better quality of service. 
 &bquo;Prices are used as a barrier so that the sort of people we don't want go over the road,&equo; he said. 
 The price charged in any one particular Nicholson's pub is unimportant, considers Tony. 
 A base price is set according to the area. 
 The size of barrier needed is set against the need to maintain volumes. 
 This pricing philosophy owes little to that sacred cow, free market economics. 
 Tony admits that the price is calculated according to what the market will bear, not, as Adam Smith and his fan club would like, by examining his costs and fixing a price which allowed a modest profit. 
 He denies there is any profiteering. 
 He claims: &bquo;If we charged less, we'd be unable to maintain the same standards. 
 &bquo;The price reflects what else is available in the pub. 
 The food operation, for example, is not viable on its own.&equo; 
 Nicholson's customers certainly don't complain about prices. 
 The recession has led only to a &bquo;period of consolidation&equo; &mdash; in Tony's words &mdash; but expansion is not too far away. 
 There will be no move out of the core business in the City or West End, simply a push for greater market share. 
 In the long term there may even be Nicholson's pubs appearing in the business centres of other cities. 
 The hardest part about expanding will be finding pub stock up to the Nicholson's standards. 
 They have won more awards in CAMRA's pub design competition than any other company, most notably for their careful refurbishments. 
 There will be no hasty purchases, as Tony is determined to keep a focus on the chain's niche market, which he describes as the top end of the traditional ale market. 
 &bquo;Nicholson's is known for its high standards. 
 We charge a little more but our customers receive the highest quality service, excellent food and a wide choice of quality beers,&equo; Tony said. 
 If you're in London, take a look for yourself. 
 But take a tie and plenty of cash. 
 Old inn under threat 
 THE New Inn at Coln St Aldwyns, Gloucestershire, is under threat again. 
 The pub, built around 1600, was bought by a developer in 1988, who wanted to turn it into housing. 
 The Coln St Aldwyns Society was formed to fight the closure. 
 The developer was eventually defeated through the planning system, where it was decided that the pub amounted to an important social amenity. 
 The pub was then sold as a going concern and refurbished. 
 Now new owner Chris Knight is reported to be in financial difficulties. 
 He is looking for a partner to retain the pub as a viable business. 
 But creditors are threatening to wind up the business unless six figure debts are paid. 
 &bquo;I am making every effort to avoid the inn being sold,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I would be a very unwilling seller, that is the last resort as far as I am concerned.&equo; 
 The Coln St Aldwyns Society still want the pub retained as a village inn and would support any buyer willing to keep it open.  
 PUB NEWS Giant brewers agree to talk on rents 
 BASS, Allied and Whitbread have agreed to independent arbitration of rents when introducing new leases. 
 If tenants and brewers cannot agree terms then some form of outside arbitration will occur. 
 This has been a major demand by the National Licensed Victuallers Association, who hailed the decision as a victory for their campaign. 
 Secretary of State Peter Lilley MP has met representatives of the national brewers. 
 Their main concern was that independent arbitration would drag out negotiations and prevent them complying with the MMC proposals to free pubs from the tie by the deadline of November 1992. 
 Peter Lilley told the brewers that no action would be taken in the particular instance where a pub had not yet been freed because independent arbitration of rents was still taking place. 
 Some scepticism has been expressed by tenants as to whether independently judged rents will be significantly lower than those asked by brewers. 
 Grant Metropolitan's Inntrepreneur lease already provides for independent arbitration but rents are still considered excessive by many tenant leaders. 
 In other commercial sectors, rents are being slashed to find leaseholders, with the first five years of many office leases offered rent free. 
 The contrast with the brewing industry is striking. 
 A sad tenant quits his pub as Benskins demand lease 
 JOHN WELLS, the longest-serving publican in St Albans, Herts, said a sad farewell to his pub last month. 
 A tenant for 16 years, John refused the offer of a lease from Allied Breweries, and, with his wife Maureen, he packed his bags and left. 
 He is not bitter. 
 He says Benskins, Allied's Watford-based subsidiary, have not been unpleasant. 
 But he feels let-down and disappointed that all his years of effort in building trade in the Harrow, a city-centre pub, count for nothing. 
 &bquo;The company has changed in the last four to five years,&equo; John said. 
 &bquo;They must have known that leases were in the pipeline but no one said anything to me.&equo; 
 Vital repairs have not been carried out. 
 At present they are the responsibility of  thr  brewery but a future leaseholder will have to look after them. 
 &bquo;The roof has leaked for a year,&equo; John said, &bquo;and I had to cover over the electrics to protect them from the rain. 
 &bquo;The swinging signboard fell down and was left in the garden for 14 months. 
 &bquo;The saloon bar door is rotten and the hallway is soaked when it rains. 
 But Benskins said that none of these things was important.&equo; 
 Benskins increased his rent by &pound;6,000 last year and John is convinced they must have known then that leases policy. 
 This year Benskins came back with a demand for a &pound;5,000 a year increase that would have taken John's annual rent to &pound;23,000 plus &pound;100 a week for the business rate. 
 &bquo;I decided it was time to say goodbye, but before I could give notice Sam Hall, the Benskin's area manager, phoned me to say the company was going to turn the Harrow into a managed house. 
 &bquo;I said it would never work &mdash; there are too many sports teams that use the pub and they need the contact of a regular tenant. 
 I also told Sam that I didn't think the main Benskin's board would approve the switch to management.&equo; 
 John and Maureen took their first-ever fortnight's holiday in their 16 years in the Harrow and returned to be told the Benskin's board had rejected the plan to turn the pub over to management. 
 &bquo;Sam Hall told me they wanted me to stay on &mdash; but I would have to accept a lease,&equo; John said. 
 &bquo;It would be a 10-year lease, index-linked to inflation for the first five years and I would have to do all the repairs the brewery hadn't done.&equo; 
 On top of those repairs, John faced a bill for &pound;18,000 to replace all the doors and windows in the pub and a further charge of &pound;5,000 to improve the kitchen. 
 &bquo;I was not prepared to use my own savings to pay for that,&equo; John said. 
 &bquo;It would have been a different story if the brewery had done the earlier repairs.&equo; 
 John and Maureen decided to call it a day. 
 John admits they are in a better position than most tenants, for they have their own house to move in to and are not dependent on the pub's accommodation. 
 He fears for the future of the pub if leases become widespread. 
 &bquo;They are the quickest route to bankruptcy. 
 &bquo;People used to queue up to get a pub but that's all stopped now. 
 The only people who will go for a pub will be those who have been made redundant from their jobs and will consider taking leases. 
 &bquo;But they will have no experience of running pubs and I know from talking to the local bench that licensing magistrates are concerned at the standard of new licensees.&equo; 
 John thinks the character of pubs will change. 
 &bquo;Leaseholders won't hang around for 16 years in a pub, because leases can be sold on. 
 &bquo;And they will forget the bread and butter customer who drinks three to four pints a day, seven days a week.&equo; 
 Leaving the Harrow was a moving experience in many ways for John and Maureen. 
 On their last day they were overwhelmed by farewell messages and gifts. 
 &bquo;I'm a pretty tough sort of bloke &mdash; you have to be to run a pub,&equo; John said, &bquo;but I've had tears in my eyes today.&equo; 
 Roger Protz 
 Black Country inn faces axe from bureaucrats 
 WOLVERHAMPTON'S famous Great Western pub is under threat from a compulsory purchase order. 
 The Black Country Development Corporation has begun proceedings to buy the pub but it has made no public statement giving its reasons. 
 Regulars and local councillors fear the Great Western will be demolished to allow better access for lorries in the area. 
 The Great Western was CAMRA's West Midlands Pub of the Year in 1989. 
 Owners Holdens oppose the purchase. 
 The pub is sited by Wolverhampton's Low Level Station, scene of local CAMRA festivals, and is a regular Good Beer Guide entry. 
 Regulars at the Great Western have launched a petition to save the pub. 
 The purchase order is vigorously opposed by the Wolverhampton branch of CAMRA. 
 Jim Laws, Wolverhampton Pub Preservation Officer, says the intentions of the corporation are surrounded by mystery. 
 &bquo;What do they want the pub for?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;What do they intend to do with it?&equo; 
 All the corporation has suggested so far is a vague road and landscaping scheme that would affect only part of the pub garden and car park. 
 The local council also opposes the compulsory purchase order. 
 Councillor Gill Walton called the thriving pub &bquo;a great asset to the town.&equo; 
 The Black Country Development Corporation is appointed by the Secretary of State and is not accountable to local opinion. 
 Letters of protest should be sent to Sir William Francis, Chairman, Black Country Development Corporation, Black County House, Rounds Green Rd, Oldbury B69 2DG. 
 Wedding ale 
 A SPECIAL brew was produced by Moorhouse's of Burnley last month for the wedding of the company's sales manager Carolynne Brammer to Barrie Pepper chairman of the British Guild of Beer Writers. 
 Pepper's Wedding Ale is a hoppy premium bitter with a gravity of 1041&deg;. 
 It will be available for a limited period in a number of pubs including the City of Mabgate and the Grove Inn in Leeds, the Marine Hall in Fleetwood, Cooky's Devonshire Arms in Bradford. 
 Sack for tenants as Marstons switches Hants pubs 
 MARSTONS of Burton-on-Trent is taking six of its tenanted pubs in Winchester back into management. 
 Four of these are Good Beer Guide listed. 
 The tenants have been given a year's notice to quit and they face the loss of their livelihood and homes. 
 The local CAMRA branch have condemned the move. 
 They say it is unjust for the publicans and bad for the pubs. 
 &bquo;Marstons must realise that it is the skills and enterprise of the licensees that have made these pubs so popular,&equo; said branch spokesman Robert Whatley. 
 &bquo;To treat them in this way is disgraceful.&equo; 
 He has written to Marstons managing director Michael Hurdle, asking for a meeting to express the branch's concern. 
 The local Licensed Victuallers Association have pointed out that all six pubs have gardens and car parks, suggesting that they will be converted to plastic &bquo;eating houses&equo;. 
 The LVA claim that pubs converted to management in Winchester in the past have seen a rapid turnover of staff and a substantial decline in trade. 
 Clubs and societies, such as darts and crib teams, have been wound up in pubs converted to management. 
 Robert Whatley agrees. 
 &bquo;Good tenants are an asset for the brewery,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Marstons seem to be doing its best to get rid of them.&equo; 
 GBG Deadline 
 Survey formrs for the 1993 Good beer Guide will be dispatched to branches in late October. 
 They must be returned by branches to regional Directors no later than Friday march 13, 199.  
 FOOD AND ALE TRAIL Going green with down town Berko's bard of beer 
 Chimay Red puts me to bed 
 It's like a friendly aunt 
 Have a jar, you won't get far 
 The reason is you can't. 
 The Trappist monks 
 Don't leave their bunks 
 When supping these fine brews. 
 Chimay boasts four splendid ales 
 Isn't that good news! 
 JUST a little ditty penned by beer poet laureate Rex Tyler, a prolific rhymster with an entire anthology of odes for all the 70 bottled beers sold in his extraordinary store. 
 &bquo;I've been to something like two dozen breweries in Belgium. 
 I'm as keen a beer hunter as Michael Jackson &mdash; only he's famous and I'm not,&equo; says Rex. 
 He does indeed go to great lengths to check the credentials of everything on sale at his deli-cum-restaurant-cum off-licence in Berkhamsted, Herts, (&bquo;Berko&equo; to the locals) celebrating its 10th anniversary this month. 
 There are 80 organic wines on his list (&bquo;no chemicals so less chance of a hangover&equo;) and he's been to loads of vineyards to make sure production is as natural as possible without actually treading the grapes. 
 They are mainly from France, Germany and Italy but do include a couple from Down Under. 
 &bquo;I've visited Australia's one and only organic wine producer at Mudgee where he's been growing organically for 30 years. 
 He's got various types of grapes and environments; for instance, some he grows using green manures and he's experimenting all the time. 
 &bquo;I can't say it was a particularly pleasant experience &mdash; it's a bit hairy wandering through waist high vines that could be full of black and brown snakes!&equo; 
 From there comes a wine with hairs on its chest, a Shiraz from the 1985 vintage described by Rex as &bquo;a big, strong red, 14 to 15 per cent alcohol.&equo; 
 He has sold organic wines for the past five years, ever since he got a licence. 
 But beers are his real passion and around two years ago he began filling his shelves with an ever-increasing selection. 
 For a store which is totally uncompromising in the wholefood and vegan pedigree of all products and meals on sale, where Rex waxes eloquently about macrobiotics and the ying and yang of food, it's comforting to note that genuine beers fulfill his criteria quite easily. 
 &bquo;I like the concept of people who produce beer using the natural hops and malts and even, in some cases, wild yeast,&equo; he says. 
 BEERS in bottles all shapes and sizes &mdash; some look at least two pints &mdash; now fill a whole corner of the store, their colourful labels firing your tastebuds. 
 &bquo;Try this Jade,&equo; says Rex hospitably, pouring from a bottle with a wire-secured cork, &bquo;it's a pleasant, light summer drink.&equo; 
 Its label tells you in French that it is guaranteed unpasteurised and made using malt &bquo;d'orge de culture biologique&equo;. 
 Of these six dozen beers 10 are organic as well as being naturally conditioned. 
 In Rex's terms that means the malt and hops are organic and finings have not been used in the production; not that finings affect the organic status of the brew, but Rex objects on vegetarian grounds. 
 Most of his organic beers are brewed in the UK including Scottish Golden Promise from Edinburgh's Caledonian Brewery, Clifton Dark Ale, Hartcliffe Bitter and Saxon Ale flavoured with borage and honey from Ross in Bristol, and Bottle Green Organic Porter. 
 &bquo;I'd like to help the small beer producers of Britain more, I've made a start with cider &mdash; I'm stocking Dunkerton's cider from Herefordshire; Ivor really is a man after my own heart, full organic status from the Soil Association.&equo; 
 But the bulk of his beers come from Belgium, where some of Rex's happiest moments have been passed in breweries, sometimes following in the footsteps of Michael Jackson, who has graced the Cook's Delight annual beer tasting. 
 &bquo;De Dolle Brewery in Essen is one of my favourites. 
 They have a similar principle to me &mdash; they only brew on Saturdays and Sundays! 
 &bquo;And it's absolutely spotless, you could eat your meals off the floor. 
 Their laboratory is tiny and that's always the mark of a good brewery.&equo; 
 From there comes Oer, which Rex describes as a primitive beer; a dry-hopped Ara; Boscuen which means rabbit of the forest, a dry beer and one he particularly enjoys. 
 For some time Rex has been conducting a correspondence with one of the brewers entirely in verse. 
 He corresponds frequently in rhyming couplets. 
 An anniversary poem went to the Queen, and many MPs have been recipients of his comments couched in rhyme on subjects from food irradiation (he's an opponent) to saving the Antarctic. 
 Neil Kinnock has been sent three Tyler missives and responded, albeit in plain prose. 
 Rex is a man of strong opinions unflaggingly put into practice. 
 &bquo;It has been really hard. 
 When we stopped serving white meat and seafood to become totally vegetarian there is no doubt we lost a lot of customers but you have to stick to your guns. 
 &bquo;If you believe that what you are doing is right then you can't compromise.&equo; 
 It was really Rex's wife who launched the business, initially with her brother in-law, in a little shop in a Victorian terrace on the edge of Berkhamsted. 
 KHAI Eng is from Malaysia and an architect by profession but loved cooking and was often asked to create dinner parties for her clients. 
 Their enterprise began as a wholefood store &mdash; &bquo;we had very little stock but all those years ago we did manage to get organic Basmati rice&equo; &mdash; with a little tearoom at the back and a Malaysian feast once a week. 
 &bquo;I don't know of any Chinese girl who can't cook, and Malaysian girls inherit a cocktail of cultures which leads to some fantastic recipes,&equo; Rex said. 
 &bquo;We have moved along so we are not simply cooking Malaysian food but using the best possible organic vegetables, proteins and grains to create various meals.&equo; 
 It is difficult to see how anyone could notice the absence of white meat or fish with such an unending variety of tastes set before them. 
 Rex was employed as a toy importer but had also been in wine importation before he joined Khai Eng full-time towards the end of the first year. 
 They took over the wool shop next door to expand their stock and the surprisingly large upstairs restaurant, now spread over both stores, has attracted well-known food critics to this outof-the-way location. 
 &bquo;We are famous for our soups, and we don't use any oil in them, vegetable or otherwise. 
 Nor do we use any stocks. 
 They are simply made on the day from fresh organic vegetables.&equo; 
 They include pumpkin, lentil, onion, parsnip, beetroot, pea, fennel and the redoubtable Buddhist Monk of mung beans with cashew nuts and coconut added towards the end; &bquo;a tropical soup,&equo; says Rex. 
 The restaurant opens four times a week for pre-booked dinners only. 
 On Thursday and Friday nights and Sunday lunchtimes you can enjoy Malaysian or Indonesian curries, perhaps a Cambodian-style casserole of sweet potatoes, pumpkins and yams with fresh coriander, or the very popular macrobiotic platter, an assortment of tastes sometimes including arame, one of 10 different sea vegetables they prepare. 
 Ingredients such as wheat, barley, lentils, seitan, daikon, miso, quinoa and tempeh are all used with so many different fresh herbs and spices that an astonishing kaleidoscope of tastes is achieved. 
 On Saturday nights around 30 people sit down to a four-course SE Asian banquet. 
 &bquo;These are dishes we have adapted over the years to be vegan but are also the authentic tastes of, chiefly, Malaysia but Vietnam, Cambodia and Singapore as well,&equo; Rex said. 
 All the diners eat the same feast which takes Khai Eng and Rex a day and a half to prepare. 
 They get the ingredients ready but don't cook until the last minute, preparing the second course while the first is being eaten. 
 And here is a place where nice need not mean too naughty &mdash; the creamless syllabub is made with Tofu, the dandelion coffee mousse contains agar agar, and the all-time favourite is a gravity defying lemon meringue pie. 
 &bquo;I think professional cooks have a responsibility to their customers. 
 If people want to kill themselves, that's their affair, but when they come here I want to give them food which will do them food rather than harm. 
 &bquo;There is a doctor near here specialising in candida sufferers who sends his patients to eat here,&equo; said Rex. 
 And if all that sounds a bit pious, I've created the wrong impression. 
 The food certainly does not wear a hair shirt, and nor does Rex, ebullient and gregarious, ensuring a meal at his place is a sort of crazy party with himself as the slightly eccentric host. 
 &bquo;IT really is a friendly and fun restaurant; not a place for a t&ecirc;te &agrave; t&ecirc;te. 
 If it's your birthday then I write a song or an ode and you share it with the whole restaurant &mdash; everyone joins in.&equo; 
 And as Rex and Khai Eng, still thriving in an area which has seen plenty of other vegetarian establishments come and go, get ready to enter their second decade, perhaps we'll leave the last word to Rex: 
 The highland fling is not a Scotsman standing on a 
 rock 
 Tossing piping haggis from a great height in a loch 
 No, it is the sale Scots make for all the girls and boys 
 Of Belgium who appreciate it's one of life's great joys. 
 An old man, sporran dragging along the dusty ground 
 Spoke to me of &bquo;Nessie&equo; his theory did expound 
 A glass of Gordons and the sword dance seemed an easy task 
 It kind of built his confidence with each successive flask 
 &hellip; 
 * Cook's Delight, 360&ndash;364 High Street, Berkhamsted, Herts. (0442 863584).  
 READER'S LETTERS 
 Geordie's brew is the best pint 
 I HAVE been a free trader for eight years, with no brewery ties whatsoever. 
 During this time my Theakston's Best Bitter has been brewed in Carlisle, Workington and Newcastle upon Tyne. 
 I have tried the Theakston's brewed at the Masham brewery in recent weeks, and can only comment that I prefer the Gallowgate product. 
 The only significant difference that I have observed in the Best Bitter from Newcastle is that it has a much higher level of secondary fermentation in the cellar. 
 In other words it is more of a true &bquo;real ale&equo; than that from other sources. 
 I also sell vast amounts of Draught Bass, which sometimes comes from Burton-on-Trent and at other times from Tadcaster. 
 Either way the taste is the same&hellip; excellent! 
 Perhaps S&amp;N should advertise their Theakston's ales as being brewed &bquo;from an original Yorkshire recipe&equo;. 
 At the end of the day, the best Theakston's ever brewed is made by Geordies! 
 And the upswing in Theakston's sales is proof of the pudding. 
 &mdash; HUGH PRICE, Tynemouth Lodge Hotel, Tynemouth.  
 Honest policy 
 AS CAMRA's Brewery Liaison Officer for Newcastle Breweries I have followed the discussions in these columns concerning the origin of Theakston's beers with interest. 
 This is not a new issue and I have spoken to the Tyne Brewery and its counterpart at Masham on several occasions in the past and tried to argue that &bquo;brewed in Newcastle and Masham&equo; would indeed be a more honest alternative to their current advertising policy. 
 Unless forced to do so by law, I can see no way that S&amp;N will change their practices. 
 CAMRA's attitude must be: 
 1. 
 That no beer can be replicated and brewed miles from its original home without altering the character of the brew and 
 2. 
 That in the interests of consumer awareness, advertisers should not be allowed to imply that beers are brewed at locations other than true point of origin. 
 Without this attitude, and given the inventiveness of many beer advertisements, we can forget about our greatest asset, the local and traditional character of British brewing. 
 S&amp;N argue they have kept Theakstons open and, presumably, would not have been so keen to do so if they couldn't use the name and local appeal of the brand to advertise their Tyne Brewery beers. 
 There is validity in this point. 
 They could have filled the cellars of Masham with McEwans 80/ and Youngers No. 3 from Edinburgh or with the new Theakstons-on-Tyne which the locals declare is a far inferior brew. 
 They could have turned Theakstons of Masham into a museum alive or dead. 
 S&amp;N did not buy a beer, they bought a name and the price of Masham's survival has been the marketing of this name. 
 Masham can never supply the whole S&amp;N estate so extra capacity in Newcastle is used for this purpose. 
 The more traditional local is used on the advertising. 
 It is not a practice we can condone but it is preferable to brewery closure. 
 Yes, I would like to see this specious form of brewery advertising eradicated for all breweries by legislation but I would also like to see as much of our present brewing heritage as possible preserved intact. 
 In an ideal world I would also like to see the Campaign I support and represent cease to accept cash inducements from the institutions it attacks while paying lip service to valid campaigning issues. 
 &mdash; NICK WHITAKER, Tyneside &amp; Northumberland Branch.  
 Destroyed 
 I LIVE in Deptford, south London, I work in Woolwich. 
 Both of these places are within walking distance of Docklands but I did not go to the Great British Beer Festival. 
 I did go to the beer festivals in Camden, Battersea, Greenwich, Stratford (and the Cider and Perry Exhibition) and many others. 
 One of my favourite festivals is the small winter ale festival in Exeter. 
 In fact, if I can time my travel to be in a place when a beer festival is on, I attend it. 
 But I did not go to the Great British Beer Festival. 
 I don't know how many breweries or pubs were knocked down during the redevelopment of Docklands. 
 My only knowledge is the pubs that still remain but are boarded up. 
 As you come out of the Blackwall Tunnel, right by the new Financial Times building, there are at least two shut and boarded up pubs. 
 They are not alone. 
 The redevelopment of Docklands ignored the local culture and destroyed the local pubs. 
 For CAMRA to hold its biggest beer festival there is a disgrace. 
 &mdash; CHRIS WHEAL, London SE8.  
 Belly ache 
 I ATTENDED four of the evening sessions of this year's Great British Beer Festival and had a great time &mdash; my thanks to all those who worked so hard to make it such a success. 
 However, on three occasions I was witness to CAMRA members complaining loudly that they should not have to queue as long as non-members to get in, or that only CAMRA members should be allowed to attend. 
 As a long time drinker of real ale, who has only joined CAMRA in the last year, I found this belly-aching very annoying. 
 As a professional campaigner I found its elitism deeply disturbing. 
 &mdash; PHIL RIMMER, London E13.  
 Half, please 
 AT LEAST Mrs Donaldson (September) doesn't have to ensure the bearded drinker's frequent first encounter on the glasses front, which is to find the barman reaching for a pint glass before a word's been said. 
 Does no one nowadays keep up the old precaution of when in a strange pub always starting with a half? &mdash; KEN REED, Sutton,  Surrey  . 
 Hots Czeched out 
 CZECH government official Mrs. Jana Halova checks out a pint of Holts Entire at a visit to the company's Station Road brewery in Oldbury. 
 Watched by landlord of the Holts Brewery Inn, Tony Stanton, she was joined on her visit by other representatives from  Czechoslavkia  and councillors and officials from Sandwell Borough Council. 
 Give us back our fizzy keg! 
 I RECENTLY spoke to one of your employees on the telephone about the Watney's Party Seven. 
 He informed me that CAMRA would not be part of any campaign to re-introduce the Party Seven, as the beer was &bquo;nasty&equo; and not real ale. 
 I would like to state that CAMRA has done a great deal for beer drinkers throughout the country. 
 However I know for a fact that  is  has done much more than just promote real draught ale. 
 Foreign lagers are welcomed by CAMRA, despite the fact that many of these are not real. 
 The Party Seven is a great British institution and its downfall merely a product of marketing mismanagement. 
 It is recognised universally as a free invitation to any party, and as a postmodern display of pop art in its most popular and utilitarian form. 
 Fizzy keg beer it may be, but that is no reason to dismiss it out of hand without considering its appeal as a true classic beer. 
 With the strength of CAMRA as a consumer movement, I welcome the return of the Party Seven into the off-sales world, which is one of the largest sections of the industry, as the large breweries are forcing the &pound;2 pint upon tenant landlords and others, and people turn elsewhere to seek their alcoholic enjoyment. 
 &mdash; BEN BYRAM-WIGFIELD, Free the Watney's Party Seven, Campaign HQ, The Steps, Foley Terrace, Great Malvern, Worcs. 
 One small problem: Watneys don't brew any more!  
 Cool look at warm beer 
 KEITH Thomas's article on warm beer (September) highlights the main reason why I so rarely attend beer festivals these days. 
 The days are long gone when drinkers should put up with warm and often out-of-condition beer. 
 The beer awards given at GBBF must be moved to a cooler part of the year if they are to have any credibility. 
 I would hope that the vast majority of beer festival organisers take heed of Keith Thomas's article and try to ensure that quality comes before quantity at beer festivals, then I might be tempted to visit more beer festivals again. 
 &mdash; RICHARD SANDERS, Loughborough.  
 P.A. Newton fan club 
 As a recently joined member of CAMRA, I must say how appalled I was to read of the new rules for the Champion Beer of Britain Competition for 1992. 
 I seriously considered cancelling my subscription. 
 It was only when friends accused me of being a pompous, humourless prat that I realised it was meant as a joke. 
 Be that as it may, I don't think such frivolity helps CAMRA's cause. 
 Let's concentrate on the important, serious issues and spend less time worrying about such matters as the quality of the beer. 
 Mrs Donaldson, in last month's letters page, certainly seems to have the right idea. 
 I have adopted her splendid suggestion and now drink my excellent pint of Flowers IPA from only British made, top-quality tankards. 
 CAMRA needs more people like her. 
 It is surely no coincidence that while Mrs Donaldson proudly signs her own name, P A Newton sees fit to resort to the utterly immature tactic of hiding behind a transparently obvious alias. 
 &mdash; TONY SOPER, Highbridge, Somerset.  
 WHY have you stopped giving details of local real ale guides in What's Brewing? 
 Despite a vague assurance to the contrary last year, this useful list has not appeared since February. 
 Perhaps What's Brewing could feature an up-to-date list of local beer guides every other month, alternating with the painfully unfunny P.A. Newton column? &mdash; DAVE WHITE, Wigan.  
 FOLLOWING P.A. Newton's revelation that Scottish &amp; Newcastle Breweries supplied quantities of Newcastle Brown and Tartan Keg to a pub adjacent to the Russian Parliament during the recent failed coup, I understand that the Morning Star, daily organ of British Communists, has started a campaign for Old Peculier to be supplied for the next coup attempt. 
 Shameful. &mdash; KEITH FLETT, London N17.      
 Letters for publication must be written on one side of the paper only. 
 If typed or word-processed, use double spacing. 
 If handwritten, write clearly and print your name. 
 Send to What's Brewing, CAMRA, 34 Alma Road, St Albans, Herts, AL1 3BW to arrive not later than the 15th of the month. 
 The editor reserves the right to shorten contributions. 
 BUSINESS NEWS The Loe Down 
 Iain Loe 
 Walker on the ropes as bankers lose patience 
 ARE we now into the final scene of the long-running Brent Walker City Saga? 
 By the time this column is read the curtain may have fallen on the empire created by George Walker, finally defeated by a &pound;1.5bn debt burden. 
 The late appearance of Lonrho's Tony Rowland in the guide of Fairy Godmother &mdash; or is it the Wicked Witch? &mdash; offering to wave the magic wand and change the bulk of the debt into convertible preference shares could have offered a reprieve. 
 But Rowland's offer has been dismissed out of hand by Brent Walker and unless the bond holders, owed &pound;102m in all, agree to the restructuring plan involving BW's 47 bankers it would appear that the directors will have no other alternative but to put the company into receivership. 
 If that happens Lonrho may be gambling on picking up the betting shop part of the operation for the proverbial song. 
 Meanwhile still waiting in the wings are the Cameron's management buy-out team and Sunderland brewers Vaux. 
 Both are more interested in the brewing side of the company. 
 While the banks and bond holders battle it out, the reorganisation of the company into two divisions, betting and pub retailing, goes on apace. 
 The tenanted side of the Pubmaster pub retailing division is to be called Threshold Inns and not Legend Inns as I reported last month. 
 One can only hope for all concerned with the pub estate that Threshold Inns are allowed the chance to prove themselves and become a legend in pub retailing. 
 Bruce may bid 
 HAVING disposed of their pubs and disco estate in Scotland to Scottish &amp; Newcastle Breweries, Stakis are now looking to sell off the 14-strong Firkin pub chain bought from European Leisure only a year ago. 
 Among the expected bidders is David Bruce himself, founder of the Firkin concept and currently running two Hedgehog and Hogshead pubs in Hove and Southampton. 
 But David may find he has competition. 
 Allied Breweries' Taylor Walker subsidiary may consider the chain is just what they are looking for to increase their estate. 
 Although Allied have been working steadily to free or sell their required quota of pubs under government rules, few of the disposals have come from the 700-plus London estate of Taylor Walker. 
 In spite of recession and spiralling prices, trade at Taylor Walker's Central London pubs, and in particular their Nicholson's houses, have held up well. 
 With the economy predicted to be on the upturn it is perhaps the right time for Allied to invest in the Firkin chain and cash in early on the next consumer boom. 
 David Bruce and partner Paul Adams may find themselves once again deprived of the opportunity to regain control of their old company just as they were when Stakis paid European Leisure &pound;9.7m last year. 
 I think the price this time might be lower but competition between rival bidders might mean that Stakis can get a sum close to &pound;9m. 
 Bass off-loads 
 BASS, the UK's biggest brewer and pub owner, are now well on their way to meeting the November 1992 deadline for disposing or freeing half their pubs over the 2,000 limit. 
 They have found an &bquo;enterprising&equo; way of off-loading 372 of their Midlands-based pubs. 
 Just under &pound;60m in cash is believed to have changed hands in the deal where the pub owning company Enterprise Inns, headed by Taunton Cider chairman Michael Cottrell, acquired the Bass outlets. 
 But the five year supply deal signed by Enterprise, by which Bass continue to provide the beers, must raise questions as to whether the letter, if not the spirit, of the Supply of Beer Orders are being broken. 
 Enterprise also plan to expand their estate by acquiring more pubs, aiming to double in size by 1996. 
 The deal is believed to have been financed with debt and equity funding arranged by ANZ Banking Group and County NatWest Ventures. 
 Bass have now disposed or freed more than 1,400 of their pubs and another 400 are in the pipeline, according to Bass Inns and Taverns boss Charles Darby. 
 A total of 2,680 houses have to be sold free of the tie by next November. 
 Going east 
 NEWS and rumours of Western brewers interested in acquiring stakes in Eastern plants continue apace. 
 Belgium giants Interbrew &mdash; Stella Artois to you and me &mdash; are negotiating in Czechoslovakia, Poland and Hungary and all the other normal suspects are also reported to be continuing talks east of the former iron curtain. 
 A little bird tells me that Scottish &amp; Newcastle's private jet has been spotted in the neighbourhood of Pilsen. 
 It is unlikely, however, that any Western company will get more than a minority stake in Pilsner Urquell. 
 Cider wars 
 I'M still awaiting news about the eventual buyer of Showerings, the cider company put on the market by owner Allied. 
 Hereford cider producers Bulmers had been rumoured to be considering a bid but in the end have apparently not tendered an offer, fearing a referral by the Office of Fair Trading to the Monopolies Commission. 
 We should shortly know who the new owners of Showerings are and what plans they have for the company. 
 With the resurgence in the popularity of cider we could well see increased competition between the Big Three: Bulmers, Showerings and Taunton, the last named now under its new management buy-out ownership. 
 This time last year Bulmers shares were at 170p, today they are near to 260p. 
 With a good harvest in prospect and cider sales expected to stay steady the Hereford firm looks set fair to face any new challenges from Taunton and Showerings. 
 Hoskins gloom 
 LEICESTER brewers Hoskins held their annual general meeting last month and reported a &pound;167,000 loss for the year to March. 
 The shares are currently at only a third of the 120p high they once reached. 
 The company's coffee shops have been identified as being one of the main causes for the poor performance and are to be sold. 
 Hoskin's chairman, Barry Hoar, is putting on a brave face and has told shareholders that &bquo;your directors view the future with confidence.&equo; 
 Barry and brother and fellow co-director Robert will need all the confidence they can get because there could be troubled times ahead. 
 The company has promised much in the past but to date failed to perform up to the market's expectations. 
 The failure finally to secure 18 pubs from Bass, which would have boosted Hoskin's estate to 29, must have dented market confidence, a confidence that needs to be regained if they are not to be swallowed by one of the many new thrusting pub retailers actively seeking new acquisitions. 
 Up the kriek 
 THE guest beer market is not only a target for UK companies. 
 Belgium brewer Liefmans are making a big push with their draught kriek &mdash; cherry flavoured beer &mdash; the sales of which have increased by 45 per cent over recent months. 
 The company was acquired last year by the regional brewer Riva, best known for its Dentergens wheat beer. 
 Liefmans plan to impress potential customers with their products at this month's Innovate 91 exhibition in London where they will have a stand in the &bquo;Real Ale Village&equo;. 
 Riva's move into the UK could well be just the vanguard of a friendly invasion of quality draught continental beers which may soon be competing on the bars of UK pubs with our own traditional ales.  
 Beer sales up 
 BEER production for July 1991 was 3,179,380 barrels, an increase of 3 per cent on the same month last year. 
 Adjusted production (production plus imports minus exports) was 3,364453 barrels, also an increase of 3 per cent on July 1990.   
 NEWS Top hall for '92 beer fest 
 by Christine Cryne 
 FOLLOWING this year's success at the London Arena, Docklands, the Great British Beer Festival will move to West London in 1992, taking over Olympia, Britain's most prestigious exhibition hall. 
 The festival, a key part of CAMRA's 21st birthday celebrations, will be held in Olympia's Grand Hall. 
 The hall was commissioned in 1884 by the National Agricultural Hall Company to provide an arena suitable for both agricultural shows and military pageants. 
 Current events include the annual Horse of the Year Show. 
 Not since Alexandra Palace in North London has the Great British Beer Festival been at a site with so much style and heritage. 
 It is also the biggest venue to date, with more than 150,000 square feet of space. 
 The vast arched glass ceiling adds to the sense of space and grandure. 
 The designer, Henry E. Coe, allowed for natural ventilation by arranging for the roof to part in the centre by the use of pulleys. 
 All being well, the skies will part once or twice during the festival &mdash; only the second time the event has been out in the open air. 
 Transport links are good. 
 The hall has its own station, Olympia, with Underground trains running every 15 minutes. 
 There are four other stations within 10&ndash;15 minutes walk &mdash; High Street Kensington, West Kensington, Barons Court and Hammersmith &mdash; as well as plenty of buses running along the road outside. 
 This is likely to be the biggest Great British Beer Festival for more than 10 years. 
 The dates are August 4&ndash;8. 
 Make a note in your new Letts/CAMRA diary and come and help celebrate our 21st birthday. 
 Lilley denies concession to giant brewers 
 TRADE Secretary Peter Lilley has not relaxed the deadline for compliance with the Beer Orders, a spokeswoman from the Department of Trade and Industry claimed last month. 
 It had been announced earlier that Lilley would not take action against the national brewers if they still controlled a few pubs in excess of the number allowed under the Beer Orders legislation. 
 The DTI statement was made after the brewers had agreed to arbitration for their tenants &mdash; see page 11 &mdash; and some commentators claimed that there had been a trade-off. 
 But the spokeswoman said the concession in no way gave the allclear for the brewers to delay action. 
 &bquo;The Secretary of State made it quite clear earlier in the year that he would not extend the deadline,&equo; she said. 
 The current arrangement was announced in a letter sent to all MPs in mid-September. 
 It has been made after repeated lobbying by the big brewers for an extension to the deadline by which they must free from the tie half of their pubs above a ceiling of 2,000. 
 The brewers had met Lilley and Corporate Affairs Minister John Redwood in the summer. 
 Thousands of pub landlords had been given notices to quit and offered lease agreements with rents widely regarded as excessive. 
 It was thought at the time that the talks would result in some extension of the deadline. 
 The brewers argued that introducing arbitration would inevitably slow down the process of negotiating agreements. 
 Vaux join fight for Cameron's 
 by Andrew Sangster 
 THE fight for Cameron's brewery has taken another twist with the announcement by the Sunderland Vaux Group that they are prepared to buy the Hartlepool brewery. 
 Faux, who also own Ward's in Sheffield, told Cameron's owners, Brent Walker, of their interest in early September. 
 The proposed purchase would involve the Cameron's brewery, 300-plus pubs and associated assets and brands. 
 &bquo;We strongly believe that a North-east merger of Vaux's and Brent Walker's northern brewing and pub operations would be in the best interests of all,&equo; said Vaux chairman Paul Nicholson. 
 But he warned that &bquo;some rationalisation&equo; would be necessary. 
 A merger, Nicholson added, is a more viable alternative to keeping the brewery open than the planned management buy-out. 
 The MBO team, heavily supported by CAMRA, is still negotiating a similar deal. 
 Although Brent Walker says the MBO is the preferred option, negotiations are complicated by Brent Walker's precarious financial position. 
 A restructuring plan, put forward by the 47 banks owed &pound;1.5 billion by Brent Walker, needed the approval of 75 per cent of the company's bondholders. 
 Meanwhile the Serious Fraud Squad is continuing its investigations into the company's affairs. 
 Stout fellow feels the strain 
 PETER Mauldon (right), winner of the Champion Beer of Britain award, admitted when he received his plaque last month from CAMRA chairman John Cryne that his Suffolk brewery was &bquo;bulging at the seams&equo; as a result of demand for his Black Adder Stout. 
 &bquo;We'll either be here next year &mdash; or we'll have gone under,&equo; he quipped at the awards ceremony in London on September 23. 
 All the winning breweries were represented at the ceremony held in Doggets Coat and Badge, Blackfriars. 
 Brians Dark won the Best Mild award, Cains Bitter the bitter category, Bathams Best Bitter won its class, Fuller's ESB came top in the Strong Bitter section and Theakston's Old Peculier the Old Ale and Barley Wine class. 
 Mauldon's Black Adder came top in the Stout and Porter category and Worthington White Shield was voted top bottle-conditioned beer. 
 Plug pulled on Bass pub loo plans 
 THE Good Beer Guide &mdash; listed Star Inn in Bath has been saved from the developers. 
 The pub has been largely unchanged for 100 years but owners Bass took advantage of development planned in the next door antiques market to announce a drastic redevelopment. 
 The brewers wanted to convert the landlord's accommodation into offices and turn the lounge into a toilet. 
 But, following complaints from locals and CAMRA branches, Bass have dropped the plans. 
 Landlord Allen Perrett says he is &bquo;over the moon&equo; and thanked all his regulars. 
 Cash crisis could close Hartlepool 
 THE financial crisis at Brent Walker now threatens the continued operation of Cameron's brewery and the Brent Walker tied estate. 
 Income from the pubs and brewery is being swallowed by the debt-ridden parent group, who are not paying the brewery's bills. 
 Suppliers are not being paid by Brent Walker head office and as a consequence are threatening to withhold their services. 
 The situation has been poor for some months, but press speculation about receivership has worried suppliers and customers of the brewery. 
 Brewery staff are concerned that brewing will not be able to continue once basic supplies such as malt are cut off. 
 Even the brewery social club has been threatened with closure. 
 Bills had not been paid, despite the fact that the club had already given money to Brent Walker to pay them. 
 Some smaller breweries are understood to have stopped supplying the Famous Firkin wholesale division, as they cannot afford the risk should it cease trading. 
 Staff at the brewery are bitter that a profitable business can be reduced to penury by the financial crisis in its parent group. 
 If the situation is not resolved within months, the rescue plan might cease to be viable. 
 See Loe Down, page 15.  
 Allied: takeover fever mounts 
 ALLIED-LYONS, Britain's third biggest brewer, was the subject of intense takeover rumours at the end of September. 
 Shares in the food and drinks conglomerate surged by 8 per cent in a week as speculation about a bid gathered momentum. 
 Three companies have been mentioned as possible bidders: Philip Morris, the US-based food and tobacco concern and owners of Miller Brewing, Anheuser Busch of the US, the world's number one brewer, and Hanson, the acquisitive UK company that once owned Courage. 
 Analysts were divided on the likelihood of any takeover. 
 Many reckon the enormous cost, estimated to be as much as &pound;10 billion, is too great for most of the players in the current economic climate. 
 But the 15 per cent fall in Allied's pre-tax profits, mostly a result of disastrous dabbling in foreign exchange markets which lost &pound;150 million, leaves the company vulnerable. 
 The company was forced to replace both its chairman and its chief executive after the losses were announced. 
 AGM '91 
 NOTICE is hereby given to all members of the Campaign for Real Ale Limited that the 1992 Annual General Meeting will be held at Bristol University, on Saturday April 11 and Sunday April 12, 1992. 
 Business  
 1. 
 To receive and adopt the accounts for the year to December 31, 1991 and the reports of the Directors and Auditors. 
 2. 
 To elect members to the National Executive (Board of Directors). 
 3. 
 To re-appoint the Auditors and to authorise the Directors to fix their remuneration. 
 4. 
 To receive reports of campaigning activity during 1991. 
 5. 
 To consider and, if thought fit, to pass Special Resolutions and to debate motions. 
 Members, branches, action groups, etc who intend to propose motions for debate, are asked to make sure that these are received at HQ in St Albans by first post on FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 7, 1992. 
 Nominations  
 Candidates for election to the National Executive should note that nominations should also be received at HQ by FRIDAY, FEBRUARY 7, 1992. 
 Each nomination must be proposed and seconded by two members of the Campaign and be accompanied by a signed declaration from the candidate that he or she is willing to stand. 
 Iain W. Dobson Company Secretary  
 Climber &amp; Hill Walker August 1991 &pound;1.60 Gimmer Crack A quality climb French limestone A guide for middle graders Mountain walking In Africa and the Yorkshire Dales  Volume XXX No.8 August 1991 
 CONTENTS 
 FEATURES 
 8 
 Quality climbs &mdash; Gimmer Crack on the Lakes, By Bill Birkett 
 12 
 Castaway Climbs &mdash; Bob Reid visits the small island of Cara off the west coast of Scotland 
 16 
 Monarch Of The Dales &mdash; Ingleborough tops them all, says Jerry Rawson 
 20 
 Hooked On The Fish &mdash; Roger Everett uses old fashioned cunning on the Dolomites 
 26 
 On The Rock &mdash; Jim Perrin pays tribute to botanist and climber Evan Roberts 
 30 
 Kenya's Other Mountains &mdash; There's much more than just Mount Kenya, as David Else discovers 
 34 
 French Without Tears &mdash; You don't need E-grades to enjoy Verdon, says David Pickup 
 38 
 Europe's Icy Crown &mdash; Kev Reynolds tests glasnost on Mount Elbrus 
 NEWS 
 4 
 Compass &mdash; News from all corners of the climbing world 
 46 
 Reports &mdash; Our correspondents in Scotland, the Lakes, the Peak and Wales 
 COMMENT 
 2 
 Rescue! 
 &mdash; Climber editor Peter Evans joins the growing roll of wounded writers 
 REGULARS 
 10 
 Off Belay &mdash; Ed Douglas explores the Environment Myth 
 50 
 Books &mdash; Nepal, Rockgear, Lakes pioneers and much more 
 52 
 Mail &mdash; Season tickets on sandstone? 
 &mdash; no thanks! 
 64 
 Back Page &mdash; Pete Livesey feels some guidebooks are sinking towards Zero Credibility 
 EQUIPMENT 
 42 
 Backpacks &mdash; We test four big packs in the 60-litre plus range 
 Climbline Weather Forecasting Service 
 Climbline offer up to the minute weather and hill conditions for the major mountain areas of Britain. 
 In addition it offers the latest avalanche conditions in Scotland as supplied by the Scottish Mountain Safety Group, and winter climbing conditions in the major Scottish centres. 
 Calls cost 34p/minute cheap rate and 45p/minute all other times. 
 East Highlands 0898 654 668 
 West Highlands 0898 654 669 
 Lake District 0898 654 691 
 Snowdonia 0898 654 692 
 War memorial in Mt Elbrus on the Caucasus (see page 38). 
 Photo by Kev Reynolds 
 Cover shot Ben Nevis and the Mamores from Aonack Dubh, Glencoe, by Robert Lees. 
 Comment 
 It's open season for broken feet: our own Jim Perrin and Pat Littlejohn to name but two. 
 &bquo;Climber&equo; editor Peter Evans decided he couldn't be left out&hellip; 
 Mid afternoon and I was climbing on the Ben. 
 By midnight I was in an operating theatre in Inverness having an ankle fixed. 
 I pondered on these things and felt that it was not good&hellip; 
 &hellip; 
 The right hand pulling on a not very positive lay-off and the left gripping a tenuous pinch, I moved up, expecting friction on the slab above to take me to a small shelf. 
 Two good pieces of gear had encouraged me to make the move, but once started there was nothing for 15 feet. 
 Chalk on the lay-off indicated this was probably the right line, though it looked tricky for HVS. 
 Once on the slab my boots failed to bite. 
 Maybe I was on some damp lichen. 
 Shifting my weight left on the layoff to get a better grip I pulled again. 
 Still no purchase and it was beginning to look like all or nothing. 
 Desperate now, I pulled a third time, and a third time the boots slipped. 
 The inevitable happened and I was off, dangling upside down on the end of the rope seconds later, 30 feet below, parallel to my climbing companions. 
 The Serendipity Variation on Minus One Direct had claimed a victim. 
 The gear had held and I hung there for a moment, taking stock. 
 Blood was spouting from cuts on my right hand, and my left foot ached a bit and felt strange &mdash; no more. 
 I righted myself and pain shot up my right leg as I put weight on it. 
 The cuts in the hand were superficial and there seemed to be nothing else wrong. 
 We took stock. 
 With four of us, climbing the route in two parties of two, and four 50 metre ropes to play with, retreat would be relatively straightforward to the snow at the foot of the route. 
 My descent could be protected by a safety rope. 
 Two hopping abseils later &mdash; I'm an expert at them now &mdash; and I was on the snow. 
 Necessity being the mother of invention (and ingenuity), the foam mat from the back of my rucksack served as a seat for sliding down the snow, protected from behind by a rope and with an ice-axe to help control. 
 One member of the party went to summon the rescue team and the helicopter appeared as we neared the CIC hut. 
 We had reached level ground so winching was relatively easy. 
 A few minutes later and I was getting into the rescue ambulance for a short ride to the Belford Hospital in Fort William. 
 A tall Irish doctor in shirt, tie and shorts greeted me. 
 His size belied the touch of a new born babe and he gently coaxed the life back into the cold toes on my injured foot as a nurse cleaned up the cut hand. 
 The X-ray showed clean breaks on both sides of my ankle, as if someone had miraculously scythed the pieces of bone off with a knife. 
 &bquo;It'll mean an operation to pin them back into place,&equo; came the lilting Irishman's prognosis. 
 His voice was reassuring, but I was worried. 
 This meant the knife; bones were broken: what about my prospects of finally climbing Minus One Direct? 
 Ambulance to Raigmore Hospital, Inverness and a few hours later I was talking to the consultant. 
 He would do the operation that night. 
 Full mobility would return to the foot eventually and I'd be climbing again. 
 And so to sleep &mdash; perchance not to dream at all. 
 Pain, boredom and badgering of some very kind nurses bring me to a steam-age typewriter in the hospital's occupational therapy department. 
 There really is life outside the ward, and I'm going home tomorrow, complete with crutches and instructions from a zealous physio on how to use them. 
 Progress over the next two months or so should take me back to climbing. 
 But here's a toast to all those who played a part in this fall of a climbing journalist: my climbing friends, the helicopter rescue team, the doctors and nurses and our superb National Health Service (coming from Ebbw Vale I knew one day I'd have cause to be thankful to Aneurin Bevan). 
 My grateful thanks to you all for your kindness and consideration. 
 Now &mdash; how the hell do you get up the Serendipity Variation?  
 Compass 
 Compiled by David Rose, Peter Beaumont &amp; Ed Douglas 
 Bouldering competitors pose dilemma for BMC 
 The British Mountaineering Council face a difficult decision over what action to take against those who participated in June's bouldering competition held at Crookrise in Yorkshire. 
 The event was won by Ben Moon, and despite attempts by the organisers to keep details of those participating secret, the BMC quickly learnt of Moon's involvement. 
 While the majority view among climbers and many of those within the BMC is that the competition, organised by Jerry Peel and Mick Johnstone, was a largely social affair, the BMC will find it difficult to overlook the matter. 
 The principal reason the council became involved in competitions in 1988 was to control them and to prevent events taking place outdoors. 
 The BMC have sought clarification from the organisers and from Ben Moon; as we went to press no reply had been received. 
 The matter was due to be reviewed at meetings of the Competition Committee and the Management Committee, where any ban would be ratified. 
 BMC General Secretary Derek Walker would not speculate on the outcome of these meetings, adding: &bquo;It would be wrong for me to pre-empt any decision of the Management Committee. 
 There will be one group within the BMC and climbing that will say it wasn't really a competition and that the rule was invented for television spectaculars. 
 The other view is that we've got a rule and we've got to stick to it.&equo; 
 Yet the BMC will feel uncomfortable whichever option they follow. 
 They will not wish to devalue their authority by failing to apply a ban, but they will also wish to avoid alienating competition climbers. 
 Sources suggest that if Moon, who is currently considering his position, were to indicate to the BMC that he had not fully understood the consequences of taking part, then a compromise could be worked out. 
 However, with further events of a similar nature planned for this year, such a compromise would be difficult to arrange. 
 And with one of the country's top competition climbers banned by his own governing body, the situation could deteriorate. 
 Heseltine urged to buy Mar Lodge for nation 
 The British Mountaineering Council have written to Environment Secretary Michael Heseltine urging him to consider buying Mar Lodge Estate in the Cairngorms as a matter of &bquo;necessity&equo;. 
 The BMC move comes as part of a wider campaign to persuade the Government to intervene and secure the estate, described as one of Europe's most important conservation and winter mountaineering areas, for the nation. 
 Other groups that have written in support of the Save the Cairngorms-led initiative include the Mountaineering Council for Scotland, the Ramblers' Association, North East Mountain Trust, Friends of the Earth, RSPB and the World Wide Fund for Nature. 
 The move follows the offer by a coalition of larger conservation groups, led by the World Wide Fund for Nature, to raise &pound;5 million for the estate, for which its billionaire American owner, John Kluge, is asking &pound;10 million. 
 The groups are urging both the Scottish Office and Department of the Environment to match their offer. 
 The future of Mar Lodge, which includes three of Britain's five highest mountains, was also raised in an adjournment debate in the House of Commons by Labour MP Tam Dalyell. 
 In the debate, Mr Dalyell compared the estate with Brazil's rainforest, a comparison that was echoed by Kenny Taylor, chairman of the Save the Cairngorms Campaign. 
 He said: &bquo;It is a priceless national asset and like the rainforest, faces imminent destruction. 
 Allowing it to become an executive toy of yet another millionaire would drive the final nail in the coffin of the Government's green credentials &mdash; both at home and abroad.&equo; 
 However, prospects of a change in the Government's attitude over Mar Lodge seem unlikely after Scottish Office Minister Lord James Douglas-Hamilton said during the adjournment debate that the existing system would be adequate to safeguard the estate. 
 The latest moves followed the collapse of Prince Charles's initiative to persuade the Crown Estate to purchase Mar Lodge. 
 The bid failed because the estate's value was considered to be less than the &bquo;knockdown price&equo; of &pound;10 million at which the Prince had persuaded Mr Kluge to offer it to the nation, with some assessments valuing the estate at between &pound;2 and &pound;7 million. 
 Problems over parking 
 The farmers who own the land around Pot Scar are getting increasingly agitated over the way climbers using the crag are parking their cars. 
 The BMC is therefore asking people to park their cars at Feizor Hamlet and walk &mdash; please! 
 Access problems are also emerging at Heptonstall Quarry where the bowling and social club have complained about climbers using their car park. 
 While this was the parking area recommended in the new Yorkshire Gritstone guidebook, the BMC are now asking climbers to ignore it, park in the village and walk the extra quarter of a mile.  
 Estcourt Award goes to Hispar team 
 The annual Nick Estcourt Award of &pound;1000, granted to small expeditions in pursuit of challenging mountain objectives, goes this year to the British Makrong Chhish expedition which will attempt the first ascent of the mountain. 
 Makrong Chhish (6808m) dominates the south side of the Hispar glacier in the Karakoram and has not been previously attempted. 
 Expedition members Steve Hillen (24), Dave Tyson (23), Dave Lister (23) and Mike Penlington all have extensive climbing experience in Britain and the Alps. 
 Two members of the team have trekked widely in the Hispar area and Hillen, Tyson and Lister had six months high-altitude mountaineering experience in the Andes during two successful expeditions in 1989. 
 The trustees of the award, which is aimed at young and relatively unknown mountaineers, are anxious to encourage more applications, so get weaving. 
 Details are available from: The Secretary, Nick Estcourt Award, 24 Grange Road, Bowdon, Altrincham, WA14 3EE. 
 Forms should be returned by November 30. 
 Drummond's dream of a climb for the world 
 Poet and visionary climber Edwin Drummond is about to achieve his ambition of a United Nations Climb for the World, now sponsored by the Sheffield firm Fretwell-Downing Datasystems. 
 The big event is scheduled for 21&ndash;22 September, its object the raising of funds for environmental projects worldwide. 
 The main climb by several parties on the North Face, West Flank, Mittellegi Ridge and South Ridge of the Eiger will see the meeting of an international team on the summit, televised live. 
 Participants, who will carry symbolic lanterns and a &bquo;flag of flags,&equo; include a blind person, a Czech grandmother, a black South African archaeologist, a Siberian and an Argentinian model. 
 The Eiger, Drummond hopes, having been claimed by Hitler after the Nordwand climb of 1936, will thus become a world mountain. 
 Supporters across the globe will take part in fundraising support climbs on their local hills, and their money will go to provide fresh water for the village of Askole on the way to K2, where infant mortality is 50%, and other schemes on every continent. 
 The list of supporters is most impressive, among them Vaclav Havel, Neil Kinnock, the Aga Khan, UN secretary-general Perez de Cuellar and BBC TV's Blue Peter. 
 Those who want to organise local support climbs should contact the project's office at Brincliffe House, 861 Eccleshall Rd, Sheffield S11 7AE, tel 0742 663869.  
 Anger at outdoor centre's &bquo;vandalism&equo; of Gritstone Crag 
 The BMC's ability to negotiate access agreements for the whole climbing community and to enforce their controversial bolting policy has been thrown into stark relief over a small and obscure gritstone crag in the Derbyshire Peak. 
 They said it could never happen, but in an act many will regard as nothing short of vandalism, an outdoor centre has negotiated privately with the owners of Brock Holes quarry in the Peak to place up to 50 bolts to secure a rope handrail across the rock. 
 The quarry, which rises to around 80 feet in height, has 18 routes ranging in difficulty from Severe to E3, with a starred E3 and the two-star route Rock Around the Brock &mdash; mostly concentrated on the left hand side of the crag. 
 The bolts have been placed on the broken right wall of the crag to furnish a zigzagging handrail across about 100 feet of rock. 
 The placement of the bolts by the Crowden Outdoor Centre, which is based just below the quarry, follows private negotiations between the landowner, North West Water, and Crowden Outdoor Centre, which is run by Peter Noble. 
 This action is, of course, in direct contravention of the BMC's much vaunted policy on where and how bolts may be placed, which places an absolute ban on bolting on any gritstone crag. 
 While many of the bolts were placed prior to the issue of the BMC policy document, they still break the tradition against placing bolts or pegs on grit for any reason. 
 In this case it appears that the bolts have been placed, not for the purpose of protection, but to create an artificial gangway. 
 Equally worrying to the BMC is that the centre negotiated its own private access agreement without consulting or even informing the council or its access officer Bill Wright. 
 The BMC's management committee, faced with what appears to be a fait accompli, must now decide what action, if any, can be taken. 
 They will be writing to the centre to demand an explanation and if possible an undertaking to remove the bolts, although this seems unlikely. 
 Bill Wright said: &bquo;We are dealing with two issues here. 
 The bolting is clearly against the BMC's policy and I think it is extremely unlikely that the BMC's committee of management will accept any kind of amendment to that policy. 
 &bquo;We are also concerned about arrangements made by individuals or organisations like outdoor centres negotiating their own arrangements for their own benefit. 
 The BMC have a whole range of policy considerations for the negotiation of agreements. 
 Individual negotiations are inevitably led by the benefits that they give an individual.&equo; 
 Amongst those who have been appalled by the bolting is local activist Malcolm Baxter. 
 &bquo;It is a good little crag with one or two modern routes, and it's in the centre of a nature reserve. 
 At the very least this bolting goes against the spirit of the bolting and access agreements. 
 It looks as though this may be the price for privatising the water companies that everyone feared.&equo; 
 Peter Noble is unmoved by the row that is blowing up around him. 
 &bquo;The quarry is really a grotty little place with little to interest climbers. 
 We asked North West Water, more as a matter of courtesy than a private arrangement, whether we could place the bolts and I don't see that our arrangement undermines BMC policy.&equo; 
 Joss's charity challenge 
 Last year, at the age of 54, the great fell-runner Joss Naylor ran from Pooley Bridge to Wasdale, only setting foot on tarmac as he crossed Kirkstone Pass and Dunmail Raise &mdash; a total distance of 47 miles with 16,200ft of ascent. 
 He was accompanied by son-in-law Colin Dulson and was raising money for Age Concern. 
 Joss is now offering inscribed and signed pewter tankards to the first twenty over-50s who complete the route. 
 Over-50s have a time allowance of 12 hours, over-60s have 18 hours and over-65s have 24 hours. 
 They must, however, raise at least &pound;100 for their chosen charity. 
 The full route is described below. 
 All you have to do is send a signed statement from your pacer(s) together with a receipt from the charity, and Joss will send you a tankard. 
 Those under 50, and over-50s who complete the traverse after the tankards have been won, will get a signed certificate. 
 Naylor's Lakeland Challenge &mdash; The Route: 
 Section One: Pooley Bridge, Barton Fell, Arthur Pike, Loadpot Hill, Wether Hill, Red Crag, Raven Howe, High Raise, Kidsty Pike just off the ridge , Rampsgill Head, High Street, Thornthwaite Beacon, Stoney Cove Pike, Pike How, Kirkstone Pass. 
 Section Two: Red Screes, Hart Crag, Fairfield, Seat Sandal, Dunmail Raise. 
 Section Three: Steel Fell, High Raise, Rossett Pike, Bowfell, Esk Pike, Great End, Great Gable, Kirkfell, Pillar, Scoat Fell, Steeple, Haycock, Seatallan, Middle Fell, finishing at the bridge at Greendale (GR 143056). 
 Joss covered the route in 11 hours 30 minutes on a day of heavy rain and strong SW winds. 
 Successful challengers should contact Joss Naylor MBE, Bowdendale, Wasdale, Seascale, Cumbria CA20 1ES. 
 Crumbling climbs 
 The following limestone routes have been listed missing in despatches, so don't come crying to us if you can't find them. 
 In Mother Carey's Kitchen in Pembroke, a large rockfall has demolished the top pitches of Wraith, Nimrod and Necrepolis. 
 Wraith can now be finished by way of a new arete at a grade of E2 5c courtesy of Andy Blakeley and Sue Logan, unless anyone knows to the contrary. 
 Andy reports that the top of the area above Necrepolis now features some loose rock &mdash; so beware. 
 At Symond's Yat in the Wye Valley, part of the Longstone Pinnacle is reported to have parted company, although which routes have been affected is not clear. 
 Meanwhile, at Exmonsworthy on the North Devon Coast, the Catburglar area has plummeted precipitously downwards, leaving plenty of scope for new routebaggers with a penchant for the crumbly bits left behind.  
 Cooking with gas on the Ben 
 Climbers should have no problems keeping warm on the Ben &mdash; for the next couple of years, anyway. 
 British Gas have supplied and installed a new cast-iron Jotul stove in the CIC Hut, and have provided enough bottled gas for two years into the bargain. 
 The stove was installed in June by climbing gas-fitter Kevin Wilson, whose ascents include the Eiger and Ama Dablam. 
 The highest stove in Britain will no doubt see plenty of use in the months ahead. 
 Forbidden treats 
 Climbing from London can be a frustrating and time-consuming business. 
 Dedicated souls have, in the last few years, congregated at the Mile End wall in east London &mdash; a trip that takes your correspondent half an hour; a length of time that sees most Sheffielders halfway to their first route at Stanage. 
 And so news of a new addition to the facilities at the Sobell wall in Holloway caused much excitement. 
 The Bendcrete competition structure used at the British Open at Olympia last year had been set up in all its over-hanging glory next to the existing facilities. 
 However, the capitals' sports-climbers were dismayed to discover that because of an agreement between Bendcrete and the Sobell to share profits from any organised competitions, a special sports licence was required for insurance purposes: a licence which the sports centre lacked. 
 The opening ceremony, set for last May, was cancelled, and local activists had to remain on the original walls while gazing up in wonder at the spectacular treat they were being denied. 
 The irony being, of course, that climbing on the new wall would be considerably safer than soloing on the existing facilities. 
 Dateline Ultar 
 Aficionados of the prose of Victor Saunders, who won the Boardman-Tasker award for his book Elusive Summits , will be able to follow the further adventures of Slipper Vic, Fowler &mdash; the climbing tax collector &mdash; and friends on their expedition to climb Ultar, the highest unclimbed peak in the Karakoram. 
 Saunders has been commissioned to file reports on the expedition's progress which will appear in The Observer  throughout August. 
 Herts Wall 
 A new bid DR wall has been opened in Hertfordshire, as the Phasels Wood scout camp, open 10 am to 10 pm, admission &pound;2. 
 It boasts a height of 11 metres, a 36 metre traverse, a competition style overhanging section, aretes, chimneys and a slab. 
 In fact, as the press release says, &bquo;almost every rock climbing feature you could expect to find in the mountain environment.&equo; 
 &bquo;This obviously bogus claim should be hotly contested. 
 But it does open up a vista for the future. 
 Coming soon: the super duper version with a glacier, loose rock, sudden electric storms and sheep with bells round their necks.  
 Quality climbs 
 by Bill Birkett 
 Gimmer crack 
 Known historically as The Crack, the distinctive corner rift up the north-west face of Gimmer was one of the most remarkable first ascents of the 1920s. 
 George Bower first examined its possibilities and lowered from the top to a distinctive ledge beneath the steepest section. 
 He was top-roped out to report that the difficulties were considerable. 
 His exposed starting point for the ascent was the strategically positioned rock ledge now named the Bower. 
 Reynolds attempted it next and reached the Bower climbing from the bottom &mdash; alas only to be benighted and top-rope rescued. 
 Undaunted, he returned a week later and made the first clean ascent. 
 In fact The Crack is a much more interesting climb than the name would suggest. 
 At least a third of the route takes the steep open wall to the left of the corner and the climb as a whole demands a wide range of climbing technique. 
 Even the first pitch, escaping left from the steep corner, demands positive commitment and the ability to confidently tackle technical wall climbing. 
 The next pitch, stepping from the exposed top of the pinnacle block, is again a bold exercise, one immediately followed by a forced mantleshelf move to gain a horizontal weakness in the smooth wall. 
 Above, a steep rib requires a ridiculously long reach before an easy traverse leads back into the corner. 
 The moves up to gain the famous Bower ledge are nothing less than brutal with the corner crack first expanding to chimney-like proportions then closing again to slim finger-crack holds. 
 During the first ascent a precariously jammed flake provided a valuable aid to progress. 
 Unfortunately this fell out on the third ascent. 
 It was noted that it bounced only once before exploding in the gully below! 
 Once reached, the Bower forms a solid haven from which to tackle the final, most demanding, section of the crack. 
 Impressively placed and considerably exposed, it hangs on the vertical right wall of the corner with a straight drop to North-West Gully, an uninterrupted 150ft (45m) below. 
 I remember my father giving me specific advice on just how he climbed the crux section of the corner crack above; &bquo;When you get to the steep bit &mdash; you'll know it when you get there &mdash; just face right and use the square cut holds on the edge. 
 Like little dominoes they're small but quite positive. 
 An amazing lead for the &bquo;20s. 
 Whatever method is employed to make height at the overlap, some 40ft (12m) up the final corner, there is still a long reach to be made to find the hold in the crack above. 
 Fortunately, it's a tremendously generous jug, enabling a secure launch to be made over the bulge into the easier crack above. 
 Tradition, line, length, fine climbing, difficulty; The Crack must surely be The Classic of the classics.  
 Information 
 Gimmer Crack: 
 240ft (73m), Very Severe (4c). 
 First Ascent: 
 A.B. 
 Reynolds, G.G. Macphee, 5th May 1928. 
 Location: 
 North-west face, Gimmer Crag, Great Langdale. 
 Guidebooks: 
 Rock Climbing in the Lake District by Birkett, Cram, Eilbeck and Roper. 
 Great Langdale (FRCC Guide) by M.G. Mortimer. 
 Classic Rock Climbs in the Lake District by Bill Birkett. 
 Rock and Protection: 
 Rough mountain rhyolite. 
 The climb will take a full rack from small to large Rocks and Friends; a large tape sling is also useful. 
 Access: 
 From either the New or Old Dungeon Ghyll Hotels. 
 New: Take the path leftwards to cross Dungeon Ghyll and follow the steeply rising, zigzagging path until it levels off. 
 Continue until just after it starts to take up the steep fellside again, where a small path branches off left. 
 This leads to the south-east face of Gimmer (1 hour). 
 Old: Take the steep path leading up through a re-plantation scheme until it is possible to exit from its left-hand top corner to gain steep scree. 
 Trudge up this to find a well-defined narrow path which eventually leads to the south-east face of the crag. 
 Alternatively, ascend Middlefell Buttress and continue directly up the hillside above to intercept the level path that originates from the New Dungeon Ghyll Hotel (1 hour). 
 On reaching the face drop down to the toe of the rocks then climb steeply back up the other side until North West Gully is reached (15 minutes). 
 Observations: 
 The reddish-grey rock of Gimmer is outstandingly clean, hard and compact. 
 This and its position, perched on steep ground yet effectively sheltered by the hillside behind, make it one of Lakeland's finest climbing crags. 
 It dries quickly and the north-west face gets the afternoon and evening sunshine. 
 Descent: 
 Into North Gully via Junipall Gully &mdash; an awkward, steep descent, or to the south-east face via South-East Gully &mdash; easier but still steep. 
 Gimmer Crag forms a head separated from the steep hillside by these two obvious gullies, which both start at the same point. 
 South-East Gully can be entered from a lower point, so dispensing with a few feet of scrambling above the climbs. 
 Finding the point is not easy, and the gully walls are vertical elsewhere, so if in doubt continue up and back to the source of the gullies. 
 The Route: 
 Soon after the path scrambles up North-West Gully a prominent corner crack can be found. 
 Start beneath this. 
 1. 
 85ft (26m), (4b). 
 Enter the steepening corner crack and climb it until it is possible to move delicately left out across the wall. 
 A groove is gained and followed to a ledge and large pinnacle block below. 
 2. 
 85ft (26m), (4b). 
 From the top of the pinnacle step onto the wall and, using the thin cracks, effect a mantleshelf move into the horizontal break. 
 Move across, up and left to a rock ledge. 
 Climb the steep rib, a long reach being a distinct advantage, until a traverse leads right back into the corner crack. 
 A few feet of awkward ascent lead to an open rock ledge &mdash; the Bower. 
 3. 
 70ft (21m), (4c). 
 Continue directly up the crack to the small overhang. 
 It is arguably best to face right to make height to surmount it. 
 Keep in the corner crack, passing a ledge, all the way to the top. 
 Off belay 
 The environment myth 
 As an environmental issue, bolting pales into insignificance beside other activities which are a far greater threat, argues Ed Douglas 
 I catch the eye of a knifeblade. 
 Mine is glittering and blue and rather fearful; the pin's is brown and disinterested. 
 One hundred feet below the English Channel plucks forcefully at the base of the crag. 
 If I shift in my harness and lean nervously backwards I can see my partner creeping nearer on a wall of loosely compacted rubble, brushing and blowing the sand from the holds as he swings upwards. 
 But then I return to the knifeblade, flexing gently under my weight as I try to shift my centre of gravity as far as possible over my feet to protect the belay. 
 There is other gear: another pin, from which I pick out chunky flakes with my little finger, a zero Flexible Friend behind an expanding flake which, when I leave this stance an hour later, I will rip from its placement, and a wire which rattles uselessly in a flared crack. 
 And so I am pasted to this leaning morass, observing the simplest of equations. 
 If that pin comes out, both I and my partner, who is now commenting on how all his holds are loose, will be in deep doodoo. 
 I mention all this because it's been in my mind a lot recently. 
 The incident made a considerable impression. 
 The route in question was at Swanage and not at all difficult &mdash; getting its HVS grade for the seriousness of the climbing and not its difficulty and I've certainly done harder in the last month. 
 But the demands it made upon my timid psyche gave it a quality and significance its components: loose rock, repetitive moves and so forth, wouldn't immediately suggest. 
 Climbing is really about levels of safety. 
 Once each of us has progressed beyond the initial terror that being on a vertical plane high above the ground induces, once we feel comfortable above the ground, then a new awareness develops. 
 We learn that climbing is about tenuous niches in the horizontal rather than scaling a &bquo;sheer cliff&equo;, as the journalese has it. 
 It's about oases of control where there should be none. 
 It should come as no surprise then, that some of those who see bolting as fundamentally reducing the experience I've outlined above, and which is our common heritage, should cast around for some solid arguments to counter its spread. 
 Hence the great cry has gone up: &bquo;Leave the environment alone!&equo; 
 What are a few bolts beside the environmental devastation caused by a large quarry? 
 People opposed to bolts have, variously, cited planning controls and conservation designations and by implication, or overtly, have accused those who drill placements as being somehow anti-environment and those opposed to their activities as being defenders of a wholesome tradition. 
 These regular outbursts have inevitably had an effect beyond that intended. 
 If you start writing to councillors and start complaining that Sites of Special Scientific Interest are being damaged then broader interests are going to become involved. 
 Controversy and argument attract notoriety. 
 In the spring a story appeared in The Observer  under the headline &bquo;Power-drill rock climbers accused of vandalism&equo;, of how a minority were threatening the relationship between landowners and climbers as a whole. 
 The strapline above the story included the phrase &bquo;mountaineering's image on slide&equo;. 
 The story enshrined the belief that has developed in recent years that people who place bolts are villains who have no place on British soil. 
 I am never fond of watching people blast away with both barrels at their feet, but when climbing is engaged in such a destructive pastime, it becomes doubly worrying. 
 Over the next decade and beyond land use and access will become an even more central issue than it is now. 
 And with the numbers of climbers increasing by a significant margin each year our relevance within the broader public sphere will also increase. 
 So a swift injection of logic might just save us embarrassing ourselves any more. 
 Take, for instance, the issue of protecting SSSIs. 
 The Government's infamous &pound;12 billion road-building programme will, if it goes ahead (and it may not following the intervention of the European Commission), gobble up SSSIs. 
 Agriculture accounts for 50% of the long-term damage inflicted on these areas. 
 The Council for the Protection of Rural England have warned that if current destruction rates continue then by the year 2025, 50% of the 5000 SSSIs will be irrevocably damaged. 
 Recreational damage is cited by the CPRE as being short-term and minimal. 
 Chunks of the Peak District are being gobbled up and we're worried about the environmental implication of drilling a few tiny holes. 
 And as for damage to an historic monument, to wit Dumbarton Rock, and the subject of the piece in The Observer , the photograph that appeared alongside it gives the lie to this self-generated argument. 
 The climber is centre-frame, his offending bolts invisible, but in one corner and easily legible is a mess of graffiti! 
 Think about this scenario for a moment. 
 A climber jumps in his car, burns precious fossil fuels on a stretch of tarmac that has eaten acres of countryside to arrive at an undeveloped crag. 
 He raps down his prospective lines using webbing and rope made from non-renewable resources and starts stripping vegetation from the cracks and ledges on the route. 
 He doesn't know what species of flora are being removed, isn't sure that there are no birds being disturbed. 
 Perhaps he even drops a Kit-Kat wrapper. 
 He then drives home and writes to a climbing magazine detailing his new routes. 
 The monstrous irony is that as long as he doesn't place bolts nobody will bother accusing him of environmental vandalism. 
 There are enough access difficulties already in existence for us to worry us. 
 The Peak Park's restrictions to moorland in the last three years have caused far more disruption to climbing than bolts ever have, and these were bans imposed by people who are sympathetic to our cause. 
 Access problems caused by bolting will be the products of our own paranoia and not because landowners are ethically minded. 
 There are plenty of reasons why they should ban us. 
 The levels of litter we leave behind for example &mdash; or the aggressive treatment we hand out to sensitive individuals as occurred at Craig-y-Forwyn. 
 These really are environmental concerns worth bothering about. 
 It is a curious thing but those who are most vociferous in their criticism of bolting are often those who have gardened crags heavily. 
 This whiff of hypocrisy can only cause resentment. 
 If there had been a bolt on my belay at Swanage it would not have been an environmental disaster. 
 It would just have altered my level of safety and I would have forgotten the route completely by now. 
 Bolting is a purely ethical consideration, no more, no less. 
 It is simply a question of what sort of world we wish to inhabit &mdash; one of predictability, or one where the outcome is unknown to us and thus includes an element of self-exploration.  
 Castaway climbs 
 The islands of Scotland hold unimagined potential for new routes. 
 Bob Reid hired a boat and went exploring on Cara, off the west coast of Kintyre 
 Harry leant against the boathouse and puffed on his pipe. 
 In his blue Guernsey sweater he looked every bit an old sea dog. 
 His Gemini was ready, outboard fuelled, and Graham and I bundled our bags on board. 
 One was exceptionally heavy, laden as it was with all manner of climbing ironmongery, wire brushes and ropes. 
 I hoped it would be put to use, though there was a chance it might be just ballast for the journey. 
 The October sun dipped into the Atlantic, silhouetting the Paps of Jura as we shoved off into the sound toward Harry's Island. 
 He twisted the throttle, 20 knots or more, skimming across the waves, while I clung tightly to the gunwhale, and Graham sheltered his daughter, Abigail, from the spray. 
 You could hardly ask for a more exhilarating way to kick off the week's traces. 
 The rocker switch on the side of my head clicked&hellip; work off, weekend on&hellip; stress off, mellow on&hellip; and sea air crackled static through my stale brain. 
 A &bquo;Brownie&equo; or friendly spirit haunts the island, and his consent to land is normally sought. 
 I scoffed at such nonsense, and leapt up the beach, lanyard in hand, only to fall flat in the surf, as the waves turned sand from firm to quick. 
 &bquo;Okay, okay. 
 Permission to come ashore?&equo; 
 The others hooted with laughter. 
 Evening drew in while we carried the weekend's provisions ashore. 
 There is a discernible, almost romantic frisson about a sea crossing, no matter how short. 
 We seemed to have left the world behind. 
 Harry had rebuilt the tackman's house. 
 The very house that had sheltered the entire community during the great storm in 1756, when waves spumed right across the island and lightning struck the Mull, causing a massive rockfall, and the steep cliffs. 
 &bquo;Of course, there was a whole community living here then,&equo; Harry told us, &bquo;but I suppose I'm all that's left.&equo; 
 He lifted another log onto the fire as we mused about climbing possibilities, and poured another round of rather large drinks. 
 &bquo;Malt whisky!&equo; our Bacchanalian host proclaimed. 
 Harry had designed a malt whiskey distillery in his final year as a student of architecture. 
 &bquo;Nobody south of Perth had heard of malt whisky in those days,&equo; he said, &bquo;so I took a bottle and six glasses into my final crit. 
 Glenlivet, of course. 
 Twelve year old. 
 All my classmates and tutors said I'd never get away with it. 
 The examiners finished the bottle and I got a distinction.&equo; 
 In the morning, after an early breakfast of freshly picked mushrooms, Graham, myself and our hangovers ventured to the south side of the Mull. 
 A hint of hatching on an early map, and the mysterious name of &bquo;Brownie's Chair&equo; were enough to suggest possibilities. 
 And even from the mainland there appeared to be a distinctly vertiginous southern edge to the island. 
 There, to our delight were the most beautiful cliffs, set above a grassy platform, above the sea. 
 Not more than one pitch, but all untouched. 
 &bquo;Just look at that crack,&equo; Graham plotted. 
 &bquo;Aye, but that ramp to its right,&equo; I schemed. 
 Ambitions soon melted under an unseasonally hot sun. 
 Graham led a lovely rib, slabby and clean, though it didn't test our mettle too severely. 
 Indeed the heat and glare were taking a heavier toll, and my head was buzzing. 
 We inspected several more lines, but they looked hard and in need of a clean. 
 So Harry's cliffs had a couple of their lines manicured. 
 Bits of unkempt Atlantic debris were removed, and lichenous excesses trimmed. 
 The abseils hung free though, and only deflated our drive even further. 
 Everything seemed to overhang. 
 We retreated to the house, with confessions of lost-bottle and do-better vows for the morrow. 
 Saturday night and a more mellow sort  of relaxation was in order. 
 Work was now a day's climbing, as well as a sea crossing away and all but forgotten. 
 Adventures past, or planned filled the fireside chatter as Harry kept the fire roaring with bellows made from a converted siren, whose reed had fortunately been removed. 
 He cranked the handle and breathy rush of air made strange coloured flames leap from sea marinated flotsam. 
 &bquo;I'll listen to Alastair Cook and join you later,&equo; Harry told us in the morning, obviously intent on his Sunday ritual. 
 Graham and I had risen early, thinking to creep out and leave our host in peace, but he was a difficult man to steal a march on. 
 He'd been up since six trying to fix his motorbike. 
 It was cooler and grey, and a brisk sou'wester spiked with a salty drizzle met us at the crag. 
 Graham stormed up the corner he had cleaned. 
 It reminded me of Cenotaph, except the right wall overhung. 
 &bquo;This is a bit worrying,&equo; I thought as I followed, huffing and puffing. 
 The sharp miniature flakes that covered the rock like fish scales cut into my finger tips and felt as though they would break as soon as I placed a toe on them. 
 A manic grin leered down at me as I struggled to bridge the crux. 
 My belayer has a leg span at least 18 inches wider than mine, so I was forced to cling to the merely vertical left wall. 
 Honours weren't even and though time was getting on, I needed to climb a route. 
 That's why we'd come, after all. 
 The line I had designs upon looked unlikely. 
 Obvious cracks soared to the left and right, reminiscent of Fairhead in Antrim, but I craved subtlety after the brutal corner we'd just climbed. 
 &bquo;Watch me, Graham,&equo; I insisted, as I tried the move for the third time. 
 He laughed, because I was still to get off the ground. 
 But then the crag was undercut, and my first move was a leftwards traverse above a 20 foot drop. 
 &bquo;Help, this is one way&hellip; irreversible&hellip; layaways&hellip; finger tips&hellip; wrong way,&equo; I shuffled and chalked, &bquo;bloody hell that foothold's too far away, way, way&hellip; done it.&equo; 
 My arched body had moved gingerly toward the only hold, and once there I stood upright and whooped knowing that nothing would stop me now. 
 I had the Brownie's wings. 
 I had doubted whether the traverse, my tiger traverse, would go. 
 But now I was euphoric. 
 &bquo;That was hard,&equo; I told Graham, forgetting that he'd probably just step across using his stilt-like limbs. 
 The climb kept unfolding in front of me, the weirdest sequence of moves, each one different, each one technical, and each one etched forever in my brain, like the steps of a dance. 
 A beautiful, once in a lifetime waltz, choreographed by the rock. 
 Later, we shuddered back across the waves toward a weary homeward haul. 
 The sea crossing served only to emphasise the idyll we left behind. 
 Harry invited us back though, and told us, &bquo;The crack was good,&equo; and Graham just smiled. 
 Graham Little taking advantage of the sunshine by soloing Rubha Rib, photos by Bob Reid. 
 Bob Reid following Cara Corner, E2 5b, photo Harry Teggin 
 Above: The impressive crack and corner lines on the main face of Carraig Mhor. 
 Below: Graham Little nearing the top of Rubha Rib, VS 4c. 
 Monarch of the dales 
 Jerry Rawson revisits the dramatic limestone landscape around Ingleborough 
 Ingleborough &mdash; the &bquo;Monarch of the Dales&equo; &mdash; is a noble hill, especially when seen from Whernside's Twistleton Scars across the deep trench of Chapel-le-Dale to the west, with its features etched against a clear, blue sky; then it looks as fine a peak as any in the country. 
 From the surrounding dales, Ingleborough's finer parts are often hidden by the billowing folds of its foothills, but from a distance the stepped profile is easily recognisable, and dominates the countryside of West Craven. 
 Its steep sides and contrasting summit plateau high above the surrounding moors combine to make Ingleborough one of the most distinctive and popular peaks in the Pennines. 
 However, Ingleborough has much more than just an impressive outline; geologically it is a fascinating place. 
 Layers of impervious shales and grits on a pedestal of Great Scar Limestone, which in turn rests upon impervious Silurian rocks, have created a varied landscape of crags, gorges with fine waterfalls, limestone pavements, streams vanishing and resurfacing and a array of caves second to none in Britain. 
 In Gaping Gill Ingleborough has the deepest shaft, biggest cave and the highest waterfall in Britain &mdash; some pedigree! 
 Ingleborough's many tops, pavements and moors occupy a large complex area which takes many visits to really get to know. 
 Whatever the season, Ingleborough has something to offer the keen fell walker. 
 There is a web of exhilarating approaches &mdash; from Ribblehead; Crummackdale; Ingleton via Crina Bottom House and Hill Inn in Chapel-le-Dale; but a particular favourite is a circular route that starts from the charming hamlet of Clapham and visits the most fascinating parts of the area. 
 It had been some time since I had visited Ingleborough, so last summer I went back with a couple of friends to rediscover some of its hidden treasures. 
 It was a calm, windless and hazy morning as we left Clapham and headed up through two dark tunnels along the old Drove Road of Thwaite Lane, a continuation of the medieval monastic highway that crossed the Dales, linking the lands of Fountains Abbey. 
 After about a mile we quit the lane for pastureland below Robin Proctor's Scar, beyond which lies the famous Norber Erratics field &mdash; a geologist's paradise. 
 Here are scattered numerous slate boulders which have been carried by glacier action and dumped on a limestone shelf. 
 Many of the dark rocks stand on limestone pedestals, the surrounding rocks having been eroded away. 
 Once through the boulder field, a grassy sward high above picturesque Crummack Dale led steadily up to a broad plateau near Long Scar, from where we had our first view of the distant and brooding Ingleborough rising from a vast array of moor and limestone pavements, shimmering in the summer heat like a huge field of cotton grass. 
 These pavements, the bare bones of the Dales, stripped of soil during the last Ice Age, seemed to stretch for miles, their surface fretted by grikes and clints and scoured and bleached by rain and winds that sweep these fells. 
 We couldn't drag Phil away. 
 A keen botanist, he was in his element identifying the ferns, plants and shrubs which inhabit the miniature ecosystems in the cracks and fissures, adding a welcome touch of colour to this primeval landscape. 
 A few stunted rowan trees reinforced the feeling of desolation. 
 This is a confusing area, and in mist and rain, navigation can often be awkward as you slip and slide your way across the greasy limestone. 
 In winter, the pavements become miniature glaciers with hidden crevasses! 
 Today they had become a real sun-trap and it was a relief to swop the white, rocky desert for the subdued greens and browns of heather and grass which sweep across The Allotment up towards Simon Fell, its flanks scarred by the pale slash of Ingleborough's eastern approach track. 
 Before continuing we slaked thirsts with warm water from our own bottles &mdash; we couldn't find any streams. 
 In fact there is little natural water hereabouts; what there is usually disappears down cracks and fissures, tumbling down sunless waterfalls and on through subterranean channels to reappear some distance lower down in the valleys. 
 In the heat of the midday sun we reached Ingleborough's companion top of Simon Fell, deserted except for a few inquisitive Swaledale sheep. 
 By contrast there were lots of walkers on our next top which beckoned beyond the shallow, peaty col that separates the two hills. 
 The final sweaty pull up the eroded rocky path to the summit plateau of Ingleborough was warm work and it was a relief to lie back on the dry grass, rucksack for a pillow. 
 The huge, gently tilting summit plateau is vast and it is easy to believe that locals held horse races here last century. 
 The splendid open aspect in all directions probably accounts for the building of Britain's highest Iron Age hill fort whose ramparts encircled the plateau. 
 Outlines of hut circles, still visible, suggest there was a permanent Brigante settlement here, supposedly one of the last strongholds against the Romans. 
 The summit itself is crowned by a trig pillar, a huge cairn, and a walled shelter along with the remains of a celebratory tower built in 1838 to commemorate Victoria's Coronation, but wrecked by revelling locals after the opening &mdash; there were problems with vandals even in those days! 
 Ingleborough's steep sides always manage to give the impression that the top of the hill has been sliced off; when it's cloaked in a mist cap, you can almost imagine a cone-shaped summit. 
 Maybe it was wishful thinking that made Thomas Jeffrey show the hill on his 18th Century map with a height of 5,280 feet &mdash; the second highest mountain in Britain, its neighbour Whernside supposedly being highest. 
 At least he got the order right! 
 We tried to identify distant hills, but in the dense heat haze that now hung about us, we could only just see Whernside and Penyghent. 
 If you do pick a clear day, tops from Scafell to Pendle Hill can be picked out and, beyond the glint of Morecambe Bay, Snaefell on the Isle of Man is sometimes visible more than 80 miles away. 
 Leaving the summit sun-bathers, we  scrambled down crags and loose stones to join the track for the long descent to Little Ingleborough. 
 Obvious efforts are being made here to reduce the damage, which was much worse than I remembered it from a previous visit. 
 Other walkers were struggling up the dusty track, sweating and wheezing their way to the high plateau. 
 &bquo;Is it far to the top?&equo; 
 harassed father of one group enquired. 
 &bquo;About another 20 minutes,&equo; I responded, trying to sound encouraging. 
 The smile disappeared, his head fell and, as he set off to catch up with his children and dog who were racing ahead. 
 A track leads down the open fellside to join Fell Beck, whose peaty waters eventually tumble into the fern-hung swallow hole of Gaping Gill. 
 The first thing I noticed as we arrived at the famous pot was a fixed caving rope leading down into the dark abyss, and I couldn't resist scrambling across to peer in. 
 Despite the small entrance hole I could sense the presence of the huge chamber below, up which faint voices were drifting. 
 From the vibration on the rope it felt like somebody was jumaring up the 300 tiring feet back into sunshine &mdash; some prussik! 
 Fortunately there was only a trickle of water entering the opening. 
 A much easier alternative is to come here on a summer bank holiday weekend, join the queue and be winched down in a bosun's chair courtesy of various caving clubs. 
 A Frenchman, E.A. Martel, made the first descent of Gaping Gill nearly a hundred years ago in 23 minutes using caving ladders; the petrol-driven winch drops visitors in less than 90 seconds! 
 For non-troglodytes, with a penchant for the unusual, the trip can provide a memorable experience. 
 From Gaping Gill a path leads through a grassy dry valley which soon narrows at the boulderchoked entrance to Trow Gill, a small but imposing limestone gorge &mdash; possibly caused by a collapsed cave &mdash; through which Clapham Beck once tumbled before being swallowed up by Gaping Gill. 
 Its overhanging walls provide a number of hard rock climbs. 
 Once through the gorge you are into the valley of Clapdale with its tourist trappings of grottoes, nature trails and Ingleborough Cave which Walter White, in his 1858 book, A Month in Yorkshire , referred to as a &bquo;Glittering Fairy Palace&equo;. 
 Today it was closed but the delightfully cold ice-cream from the small shop at the entrance went down a treat. 
 After its underground journey through the Gaping Gill/Ingleborough system, Clapham Beck resurfaces nearby and the gentle, bubbling stream continues along its way through delightful landscaped woodlands in lower Clapdale. 
 Being tight-fisted individuals we by-passed the fee-paying nature trail through the woods and crossed the beck to join a Green Lane that led pleasantly back to Clapham and the end of a fine day's trek through Yorkshire's classic karst and pavement country. 
 Main picture: Crossing the limestone pavements below Simon Fell, photos Jerry Rawson. 
 Above: A Norber erratic on its limestone pedestal. 
 Right: Brightly clothed cavers gearing up to descend Gaping Gill. 
 Hooked on the fish 
 Tackling a modern rock wall in the Dolomites requires more than technical ability. 
 In fact, old fashioned cunning and the ability to suspend belief are just as important, as Roger Everett found out. 
 Twenty feet. 
 The pockets in the perfect grey limestone became smaller and more spaced, the footholds doubtful, sloping smears. 
 Nervously I left the safety of a good peg and did a few free moves towards the next one, 20 feet away on the blank left wall. 
 With the two crux pitches of VII apparently behind us, it seemed reasonable to expect some hidden jugs, as the guide promised moves of VI-. 
 Fifteen feet. 
 Perhaps it was a tiredness resulting from the previous 14 pitches, but I could see no way of free climbing it at less than E5, and I wasn't good enough for that, not now. 
 I fixed a poor nut in a flared pocket, and although it seemed unlikely to hold, attached a sling and stood in it. 
 Ten feet. 
 There seemed no hope now, nothing to go for except a curiously marked pocket which fitted two finger tips. 
 But surely this was just an aberration? 
 If I could reach the peg perhaps we could complete this amazing alpine climb? 
 I moved out of the slings onto smears and reached a one finger vertical slot. 
 Perhaps another nut? 
 Two feet. 
 The nut went in, but slid. 
 I think I knew it wouldn't hold, but I was so close. 
 Perhaps a quick pull and a dyno clip? 
 Only two feet. 
 Perhaps a slow, gentle easing up with as little weight on it as possible? 
 With no decision made, suddenly no decision was possible. 
 Forty feet. 
 &bquo;Down?&equo; 
 asked Mick. 
 Down. 
 Our first encounter with &bquo;The way through the Fish&equo;, a modern classic of the Marmalada South Face in the Italian Dolomites had ended with us well beaten and rather incomprehendingly abseiling down during a perfect alpine evening. 
 I looked back up the wall in wonder and doubt. 
 Yes, we had clearly failed on a hard pitch, but that bulging wall above, rising blank and massive into the sky, surely couldn't be climbed at the grade given in the guide? 
 It was a wall straight out of Verdon, with the same perfect grey rock, interspersed with pockets. 
 But unlike the modern crags, this wall had no bolts and the major difficulties ended only after pitch 23. 
 A return seemed unlikely, but at the same time there was this intriguing question: just what would it be like to be up there, 20 pitches out, on a wall as hard as many a belted route, but with no bolts? 
 While I sulked in the tent, nursing my wounds and recovering from the thorough sandbagging, Mick was hatching a plan. 
 The two feet would shrink with a cheating stick, and perhaps we could avoid some of the easier but time-consuming lower pitches by sneaking in along the first terrace from an easier route. 
 We spent a day driving round the villages, asking for information, suspecting that we were missing something vital. 
 &bquo;Skyhooks&equo; the man said. 
 Suddenly it was all clear. 
 That curiously marked pocket, that brief hint in an article in Mountain , so that's how you climb a wall like that without protection bolts! 
 We bought one (a mistake, we should have got two) to supplement an old ladle-handle type of thing dug out from my past, and a hammer and a few pegs to be on the safe side. 
 Mick even found a modern Italian guide. 
 Although we couldn't speak the language, there were enough &bquo;&hellip; issimos&equo; attached to the adjectives to give a good idea of what the locals thought of the route, and the frequent appearance of numbers like VIII, VII+, A4 and A3 on the topo seemed more in keeping with our previous experience than the more modest gradings given by Ron James. 
 Armed with the right gear and correct information, we were in business. 
 Once again we set out in the pre-dawn walk through the forest, the amble across the alpine pastures, and the short struggle up the screes to the foot of the wall. 
 The weather was not too promising, but we made good time and were soon at the first terrace. 
 At this point the difficulties gradually increase, culminating on the upper wall above the giant, whale-shaped niche which gives the route its name. 
 At first the climb follows grooves with good cracks giving regular nut and Friend protection. 
 Then it breaks out over an overlap onto the characteristic smooth slabs and walls which at the same time tempt and intimidate, attract but repel. 
 &bquo;It's brilliant, a Verdon for bumblies&equo; I had joyfully called down to Mick, on climbing the first of these pitches during an earlier attempt. 
 This time we knew better. 
 The pockets became smaller and further apart, as did the protection. 
 Now that we knew the line, we  progressed quickly into the wild world of the seemingly blank walls and hanging stances that made up the meat of the route. 
 The two pitches of VII, which we had innocently expected to be the crux, were rapidly overcome with the confidence that comes from prior knowledge. 
 And there we were again, at the foot of the pitch of our failure, two pitches from the Fish. 
 We had a short stop for refreshment, got out the pegs and the skyhook and secured an open krab onto the end of a three foot cheating stick (which we had carefully hauled up all the way from the woods). 
 Since it was his turn at the sharp end, Mick set out on what we thought would be the crux of the route. 
 On reaching the peg which had stopped my fall, he made a few trial attempts with the skyhook, just to find out how it worked. 
 Twenty feet. 
 He placed a peg. 
 Fifteen feet. 
 He cleaned out a pocket and tapped in a nut. 
 Ten feet. 
 He placed the hook in the worn pocket and stood in a sling. 
 Five feet. 
 He got out the cheating stick and clipped the peg, swarming up in a daisy chain of quick-draws. 
 It's much easier when you're properly equipped! 
 The remainder of the pitch gave brilliant, bold climbing up spaced but adequate pockets to yet another hanging belay. 
 As I seconded past the scene of shredded clothes and fingers I cursed my lack of imagination; the peg pointed skywards. 
 I could have lassoed it! 
 But it became obvious on the next pitch that even had I been so inspired we would not have progressed much further. 
 For us, the traverse to the Fish niche required a linked series of skyhook moves (which isn't easy when you've only got one). 
 On reaching the Fish I let out a cry of triumph, overjoyed to have got there while conveniently forgetting the Verdon-like wall which lay above. 
 Five pitches to go to the break at the end of the difficulties, four hours of daylight left. 
 Tired, indecisive, we watched the swirling clouds. 
 The Fish seemed amply big enough to bivouac in (it even sported the route's only bolts) and the walls above looked&hellip; well, not an evening stroll. 
 The bold gesture is often the one that brings success, but on this occasion our lazy decision to eat and try to sleep was justified. 
 Soon the evening storm was crashing about us, the whole wall a waterfall, cascading like a curtain across the mouth of the Fish, just beyond our feet. 
 It was an apt time for the old dilemma of trying to forget where you were (while being excited by the position) and trying not to think about the uncertainties of the morrow (while looking forward to them). 
 Sleep is the only cure for such turbulence, but it's difficult to achieve, and Mick was hardly rested by the time it was his turn to lead in the dampness of the new morning. 
 The climb continued in its honest way. 
 It looked hard and did not disappoint. 
 The first moves of the day were unprotected, thin, blind, difficult. 
 Mick disappeared from sight while the rope slowly crept out. 
 A hook solved the initial problem, then a long, unprotected traverse (great fun seconding!) led to more blank wall and what must have been some truly desperate leading. 
 We learnt why seconds frequently jumar on this wall. 
 The stance consisted of a couple of sprouting pegs but little else; Mick's home while it was my turn to try to link unlikely sequences of free and aided moves up the next 40 metres. 
 After some tricky aid above the pegs, a section of typically marvellous free climbing, on pockets and depressions with target features reasonably near at hand, took me to the edge of the abyss &mdash; a blank wall with a piece of tat weaving, taunting, 40 feet above. 
 With no obvious footholds, no reliable gear and no tempting jugs this was a free-climbing land for which I was simply not equipped. 
 Slowly I aided upwards, thinking only of getting to the sling; the rest would be a later worry. 
 Marginal nut followed marginal  nut, carefully cammed into unlikely positions in sloping pockets. 
 A flurry of pleasure as my favourite, stacked nuts, came to the rescue and then the sling was just a few feet away. 
 A skyhook, then an unbelieving lunge and there I was, like a shipwrecked sailor washed up on the shore of an uninhabitable island, safe for the moment but by no means home. 
 Across to the right a group of pegs promised a slight ledge and a belay, but in between lay an apparently blank wall, clearly a two hook job at the very least. 
 But we had only one serviceable skyhook. 
 A tiny, flared, inverted flake suggested a micronut. 
 Then the stance would only be ten feet away and perhaps there would be a hook placement? 
 Well, three nuts spat me out and I can honestly say that the first time I fell, headfirst, facing outwards, above the wall we had just climbed, I really did see stars. 
 I looked down to Mick. 
 Could I give up, here? 
 No. 
 Perhaps I could have freeclimbed it, but the problem was that I couldn't predict the pockets and I wouldn't have found out until it was too late to avoid a monster fall. 
 So it was back to the hooks in the faith that something must turn up. 
 And it did, after another couple of false starts, a hook placement that worked. 
 A gentle step into a short sling and then the real miracle, a tiny hole, just right for my ancient ladle handle, revived from the days when Drummond briefly made them almost respectable. 
 No doubt there are modern adepts who might scoff at our amateur efforts, but that's just what we were, amateurs struggling in a land for the E6 leader or the A3 and A4 aider, without being able to do either. 
 My relief on gaining the stance was matched only by the strength of my desire to finish the route. 
 We had tried so hard, we had to succeed. 
 The angle eased, and Mick smeared up to a high peg from which the guide suggested a rope move. 
 The goal was another peg, some 30 feet and almost horizontally leftwards across yet another blank wall. 
 Mich eventually resorted to placing a hook on tension, then continuing to tension from the hook to reach the first real crack line for ten pitches. 
 Even this was no pushover as he laybacked up towards a line of large intimidating roofs. 
 But our luck was in, the roofs sported an undercut crack and the mere VI + underclinging across on the next pitch was an exhilarating holiday with guaranteed holds and gear. 
 To our right a diedre  soared into the sky, menacing with its overhangs, but promising the end of the major difficulties above. 
 The wall was relenting now, there was another continuous crack in the corner. 
 Perhaps our predecessors felt like us, as suddenly the pegs multiplied to fill the crack available and it was a simple job to follow the line to easier ground. 
 It had taken us seven hours to climb five pitches. 
 Perhaps the mark of a great climb is its posing of difficult questions right to the end. 
 We were not at the end. 
 There were 18 pitches to go and six hours of daylight left. 
 Could we climb that fast, even allowing for the more modest grading of most of it? 
 And what if we were caught in the exit chimneys in a storm like the one the day before, stranded without head torches? 
 The 20 foot roof above our heads provided perfect shelter for all eventualities, so we decided to share our last scraps of food in another bivouac after fixing the ropes on the first two pitches above the terrace. 
 I slept. 
 I lay out, warm in the cloudy air, oblivious to the rain and hail which lashed the mountain and left its edges white. 
 Mick was less fortunate, and when I awoke in the depressing gloom of dawn, he reported that the weather was very much better than it had been for a long time. 
 Patches of blue sky appeared; it was time to go, to aim for the top, to get word to Dairena and Morag who must be wondering, waiting, worrying. 
 The top-rope on the first two pitches made them possible, and then we worked upwards, forcing tired bodies to perform and tired minds to keep them safe. 
 Slabs, grooves, the odd bulge, then chimneys; I mentally crossed off each successfully negotiated landmark as the cloud built up. 
 Slowly the tension eased as we realised that we were going to make it; we exchanged jokes, we moved with greater confidence. 
 It is pure irony that after a climb involving some of the most sustained smooth rock that I'd ever encountered, the finish involved a traverse of wire cable attached to a telepherique station, a swing down and across metal laddering and a hand-traverse of the spars which guide the telepherique into its housing. 
 We had emerged from a private wall into the crazy world of summer skiers, no doubt fresh from their BMWs in the car park below, and bemused by the intrusion of this odd, dilapidated pair of chastened alpinists. 
 One of them, a guide, asked what route we'd done. 
 &bquo;The Fish!&equo; 
 I offered. 
 &bquo;Strong, strong&equo; he replied. 
 I didn't feel it. 
 But I'm going to buy another skyhook. 
 Above: Marmalada South Face. 
 The Fish takes a line just right at the dark shadow in the centre, leading direct to the telepherique station. 
 The face is about 1000m high; photo D. Gaffney, other photos R. Everett. 
 Right: Mick Harris starting pitch 21, the last pitch below the major terrace. 
 Note the perfect rock! 
 Mick Harris contemplating the swing across the blank wall near the top of the second pitch on the second day. 
 The tension traverse with the skyhook on pitch 19 at the start of the second day. 
 &bquo;And Our Paths Through Flowers&equo; 
 Jim Perrin pays tribute to Evan Roberts, botanist and climber 
 You know the way it is &mdash; someone dies whose example was meaningful to you, who was significant in your mind's evolution, though you may have had only the most fleeting personal acquaintance with them. 
 So you wish to mark their passing with some action of respect to their memory. 
 That was the way I felt recently. 
 The rain sheaved down and Snowdon was wreathed in cloud. 
 It was June the fifteenth, and would have been Evan Roberts' 85th birthday, but he died a month before. 
 So I went to visit the plants for him, went to check, in his memory who can do so no longer, whether the recurrent spring miracle of the Welsh mountains was still taking place now that the man who had seemed almost to stand for its yearly renewal had gone. 
 I'll tell you about Evan Roberts later, and there's plenty to tell even to those who buy a magazine simply because it says Climber  on the cover. 
 But firstly, I'll tell you where I went, and why. 
 I went to Clogwyn Du'r Arddu, which was &bquo;humidis et densis nubibus circumdati&equo;  &mdash; enveloped in wet and dense clouds. 
 Why in Latin? 
 Because that 's the description Thomas Johnson gave of the place when he came here in 1639, and this was the self-same weather he experienced, and here's the point. 
 The Welsh mountains weren't first explored by alpenstocked Victorians after the glories of recorded ascents, nor, most certainly, by Lycra-clad gymnasts in pursuit of same. 
 No &mdash; their secrets were first revealed to curious scientific men, to apothecaries and simples-collectors, to people who could now be called botanists, and such was Evan Roberts. 
 Have you ever been up to Clogwyn Du'r Arddu in the pouring rain and the vilest weather? 
 Its atmosphere at those times is utterly special. 
 The trolled and gargoyled buttresses wheel around you through rifts in the cloud; they stretch, soar, disappear, solidify again suddenly out of the vapour then drift impossibly far up into the mist until your senses reel at the evanescent dynamism of the scene. 
 The only climber I know who goes there regularly at times like this is that perverse little bugger Joe Brown, who is clearly captivated by the magic of the place, though he'd never let you know as much in words. 
 He's climbed here often on such days, and so have I, and you never see or hear another soul. 
 It's not silent &mdash; there's the train on the ridge, the soughing of wind around the great buttresses above, lake-water lapping on the shingle shore where I was standing. 
 This is where the &bquo;wake-up-a-poet-or-a-madman&equo; legend is properly located &mdash; it was Mrs Hemans, I think, who transposed it from Maen Du'r Arddu to Llyn Cau. 
 But in a place like this you're more likely to turn from grand vacuous profundities to the rich detail around you &mdash; to the thriving, rare colony of alpine chickweed, for example, the lacy white delicacy of which brings this grey June landscape alive to the attentive eye.  
 I won't linger on the shingle flats, for I'd come to climb, and the route of my choice was the first to be recorded in Wales. 
 Here's the first ascent description: 
 &bquo;A clergyman of the neighbourhood, who was so obliging as to accompany me in this and several other rambles amongst these mountains, formed the wild idea of attempting to climb apparently up the face of the precipice, and I, eager in my pursuit, did not object to the adventure. 
 We began our laborious task without once reflecting on the many dangers that might attend it. 
 For a short time we got on without much difficulty, but we were soon obliged to have recourse to our hands and knees, and clamber thus from one crag to another. 
 Every step now required the greatest care, for even the mere laying hold of a loose stone might have proved fatal. 
 I had once taken hold of a piece of rock, and was about to trust my whole weight upon, it, when it loosened from its bed, and I should have been sent headlong to the bottom had I not instinctively snatched hold of a tuft of grass, which grew close by it, and was so firm as to save me. 
 &bquo;When we had ascended a little more than half-way, I was much afraid we should have been doomed to return, on account of the masses of rock, over which we had to climb, beginning to increase in size; we knew, however, that a descent would have been attended with infinite danger, and being urged on partly by eagerness in our pursuit, but more from a desire to be at the top, we determined to brave every difficulty. 
 This we did, for in about an hour and a quarter from the time of our beginning the ascent, we found ourselves on the top of this dreadful precipice, and in possession of some very uncommon plants&hellip;&equo; 
 The author is William Bingley, the date of the event was 1798, and the &bquo;wild idea&equo; was dreamed up by Peter Bailey Williams, a 35-year-old Welsh clergyman who was rector of Llanrug. 
 He impresses me enormously. 
 There's a portrait of him in Llanberis vicarage in which he looks as irrepressible and intelligent as this action implies. 
 Look at the Eastern Terrace without a climber's eye and the rocks pile up around it. 
 Who knows how hard they might be along this slash through the fiercest mountain crag in Wales? 
 But who knows also the beauty which lies in wait hereabouts, which led Williams and Bingley to make the climb? 
 I suspect that our generation, with so few and such honourable exceptions, knows less than theirs did. 
 How many E6 leaders each year pass by the ledge of Lloydia Serotina  &mdash; rarest of British plants &mdash; which is only yards from the path, and fail to bestow a second glance on its nodding, purple-veined understatedness? 
 Or as they descend the Eastern Terrace after climbing Psycho-Killer or MND, which of them notices the flowering profusion at the back of the terrace &mdash; the stonecrops, campion, roseroot and saxifrages? 
 Evan Roberts noticed them, and as I touched them, felt their cool cleanliness and the slight resilient weight on the backs of my fingers. 
 I thought of the example of Evan's life. 
 He was an ecologist of international significance, widely acknowledged &mdash; indeed revered &mdash; as the pre-eminent British field botanist of his time, and his prowess was the more remarkable given that he was born, blind in one eye, into a poor Welsh family, that he left school at 14, and that he spent the first 33 years of his working life as a North Wales quarryman. 
 He came into contact with our world of climbing early, delivering telegrams from the post office on his bike to Mr Winthrop Young and Mr Mallory at Pen y Pass, or to Mr Carr at Beddgelert. 
 But he, whose contribution to the history of these mountains now matches theirs, could not then mingle with them as an equal. 
 He was born in Capel Curig in 1906, and in that village he spent his whole life. 
 His first job, in 1920, was in the Rhos Slate Quarry high on the shoulder of Moel Siabod. 
 It was hard, perilous work which, by rockfall or dust, killed most of the men employed in it before their retirement age, and it left Evan with the gasping lungs of the silicosis-sufferer. 
 The bleakness, however,  was not the whole picture. 
 &bquo;Bywyd gwar mown byd gerwin&equo; runs the cynghanedd  &mdash; &bquo;a civilised life in a harsh world&equo;. 
 This was work with a tradition of culture and self-improvement. 
 The quarry caban  served as an extempore intellectual debating society. 
 It was the quarrymen's subscribed pennies which set up the University College of North Wales in Bangor at the turn of the century. 
 Amongst the dust and waste, characters who might have stepped straight out of the pages of Dickens or Mrs Gaskell bloomed. 
 Not that Evan in his youth was one of these. 
 His early infatuation was with motor-cycles, and he was a successful trials rider. 
 The financial stringencies which accompany marriage and child-rearing caused this interest to be set aside, and once it had gone, the cultural tradition asserted itself to remarkable effect. 
 Evan loved to tell you that it began with a minor domestic row. 
 His wife Mable scolded him out of the house on a bright May Saturday afternoon in the late 1920s. 
 In his chagrin he wandered up on to Moel Siabod above his home, where a clump of purple flowers amongst the grey rocks of the mountain caught his eye, just as they might that of some solitary wanderer today. 
 Evan didn't know what they were, determined to find out, and so began one of the great sagas of self-instruction. 
 The flowers were saxifraga oppositifolia , the purple saxifrage. 
 They were the gate by which he entered on to the path which led ultimately to his acceptance as the authority on the distribution of arctic-alpine flora in Britain. 
 I've often wondered about the origin of Evan's encyclopaedic knowledge on this topic. 
 It is an area of study with a strong academic bias, the foundations of which were nonetheless in local exploration. 
 This takes back to Thomas Jefferson and William Bingley, who were guided by natives of the region to plants whose efficacy and potency, in the view prevalent at the time, derived from the grandeur of their settlings. 
 (Johnson was an apothecary in search of medicinal plants, and Welsh plant names often reflect their medicinal usage.) 
 The fact of these men's having been guided argues a body of local botanical knowledge as early as the first part of the 17th century. 
 How did it come down? 
 Botanical guides had their heyday during the Victorian mania for fern-collection, which stripped the mountains bare of many of the rarest species &mdash; go and look at the grave of &bquo;Wil Boots&equo; in Nant Peris churchyard for the story of this in miniature. 
 Evan's grandfather was one repository of this local knowledge, and his fern-book came down to his grandson. 
 (The biography of Evan published in Welsh in 1987 appeared under the title Llyfr Rhodyn ei Daid &mdash; &bquo;His grandfather's fern book&equo;.) 
 But whereas this in all probability had previously been secret lore imparted through oral tradition, with Evan it was willingly shared and brought into the public domain. 
 His communication of it in precise, accessible detail was inspirational. 
 The students &mdash; and their professors &mdash; beat a path to his door. 
 And as if to make amends for the rapacity of his Victorian forebears and their employers, he re-discovered species &mdash; notably the holly fern &mdash; long thought extinct in Snowdonia. 
 But access to the sites where arctic-alpines grew often demands considerable rock-climbing expertise, so Evan touches upon our world again. 
 Major Bradley of the Bryn Tyrch Hotel in Capel Curig helped the local man to acquire the skills of protective ropework, and Evan spent the Second World War training the Commandos and the Lovat Scouts to climb. 
 After the war he was the first Welshman to become an accredited guide of the British Mountaineering Council. 
 Rhos Quarry closed in 1953 &mdash; a godsend to Evan's health as well as his career &mdash; and after working briefly in the forestry plantations he was taken on as the first National  Nature Reserve Warden of the newly-formed Nature Conservancy Council. 
 His special preserve was Cwm Idwal, and to be shown round that magnificent place, to have its intimacies and grand structure both explained and revealed to you by this gentle, wise old quarryman was one of life's great pleasures, to be stored and cherished in memory. 
 Evan's botanical records, kept meticulously for three decades, were placed immediately at the NCC's disposal and still underpin its botanical data base. 
 He worked for the NCC for 18 years, until his retirement (as Chief Warden for North Wales) in 1978. 
 Honours flowed: an honorary M.Sc in 1956 from the University of Wales; the MBE in 1964; and highest accolade of all, he was made a member of Bards in 1975. 
 Retirement allowed him the time to pursue his botanical interest, often in company with his children and grandchildren, between whom and Evan the devotion was mutual. 
 One typically frenetic four-day jaunt took him to Pontresino in the Alps to find Eritrichium nanum , &bquo;King of the Alps&equo; (on the way home Evan's chauffeur, the Snowdonia Park Head Warden John Ellis Reports, had to navigate by road-signs and instinct, Evan having filled the road atlas with pressed flower-heads of more common species). 
 As a septuagenarian, he made the trip to Ireland on the back of his son Eon's motor-bike to find the Killarney Fern &mdash; long since believed gone from its single recorded site on Moel Hebog in Snowdonia. 
 Evan continued to lecture and lead students to locations in the mountains right into his eighties. 
 He liked young women students, and they responded with delight to him. 
 I suppose you could call him something of a gear freak. 
 His child-like enjoyment of the new equipment and gadgetry he came to be able to afford in later life gave warmly affectionate amusement to his friends especially when they found him camping in his own front garden in the latest tent and sleeping bag, or were asked to take him, when he was stone-blind from glaucoma, to the locations of his favourite plants to photograph them with an auto-focus camera. 
 Before the darkness came, you might have come across him at times pushing a pramful of camping equipment, perhaps with a grandson straggling at his side, on some remote road through Eigiau, Abergeirw or Pennant Lliw. 
 If that's to be counted eccentricity, then Evan was an eccentric. 
 He was never a man to be deprived of the sun and the soft wind in his face. 
 After his death, the local paper carried a simple headline in Welsh, &bquo;Mae Taid wedi mynd&equo; &mdash; Grandfather's gone. 
 That was the measure of affection and esteem in which he was held. 
 Which is why, for this On the Rock, I climbed Eastern Terrace alone in the rain, and with every bright flower glowing out through the dismal weather in that majestic place, as I struggled to identify it, in my memory Evan was there behind me, as he always will be now, nodding with that peculiar wise grace of his, smiling, showing the way, &bquo;&hellip; as when our days were a joy, and our paths through flowers.&equo; 
 Left: Snowdon from Penllyn, with Clogwyn Du'r Arddu prominent. 
 Below: Thrift was one of the surprises which greeted Thomas Johnson when he visited the Devil's Kitchen in 1639. 
 Photos by Jim Perrin. 
 The shingle flats of Llyn Du'r Arddu are home to a spectacular colony of alpine chickweed, first recorded here by Edward Lhoyd ub 1682. 
 A century later, Peter Bayley Williams and William Bingley made their historic climb of Eastern Terrace. 
 Evan Roberts 
 Mountain Walking 
 Kenya's other mountains 
 There's much more to walking in Africa than Mount Kenya, as David Else discovered with a group of walkers from Sheffield 
 &bquo;Quiet!&equo; said the guide, and we all stood still, listening. 
 From the bushes came a low snort and the scraping of branches. 
 It was a buffalo, one of Africa's most unpredictable and dangerous animals, out of sight but just a few feet away from where we were standing. 
 Suddenly, Snowdonia and the Lakes seemed a million miles away. 
 We were all keen walkers, and enjoyed the challenge of remote places, but nothing in Britain could have prepared us for this close encounter of the furry kind. 
 This was Africa at its wildest! 
 Our guide was from the Samburu tribe; he was tall and muscular, with painted skin and dyed hair, dressed only in loin cloth and a thick, red robe. 
 He signalled us to keep still as he stood upright, tightening the grip on his spear. 
 A strange feeling of expectation mixed with our fear as we became caught up in the thrill of the hunt. 
 Were these our primeval human instincts emerging? 
 Was there some kindred spirit that linked this Samburu tribesman with a group of walkers from Sheffield? 
 Slowly, the guide bent down, as if to steel himself for the fight. 
 Instead, he picked up a stone and threw it into the bushes, then made a noise that sounded suspiciously like &bquo;shoo, shoo&equo;. 
 There was another rustle of branches as the buffalo ran off without so much as another snort. 
 So much for a daring display of primitive combat! 
 Feeling somehow cheated, but also extremely relieved, we carried on along the trail&hellip; 
 We were in Kenya, and our buffalo encounter was in the Leroghi Hills, a small range to the south of Lake Turkana, the &bquo;Jade Sea&equo; of John Hillaby's book. 
 The main objective of our visit was to climb Mount Kenya, Africa's second highest mountain, but walking in the Leroghis formed an important part of our preparation. 
 Before leaving Britain we'd learnt that the hike up to Mount Kenya's &bquo;walkers summit&equo;, Point Lenana, was not too demanding, and that the climbing route up to the twin summits of Batian and Nelion was graded mainly Diff, with a few patches of Severe, so we weren't expecting any technical problems. 
 But Mount Kenya is over 17,000ft (5100m) and we'd also learnt that many walkers and climbers fail to reach the top simply because of altitude sickness. 
 So, instead of going straight for the big one, we decided to build up our acclimatisation by first visiting some of Kenya's other mountains. 
 The Leroghi Hills are near the town of Maralal, about 250 miles north of Nairobi, part of the homeland of the Samburu, a semi-nomadic, cattle-rearing people. 
 As we walked through the hills we saw several large herds of long-horned cattle, guarded by warriors called morani  who were stern but not unfriendly, and brightly decorated, like our guide, with their faces painted and hair thick with ochre. 
 We camped at a hostel near Maralal, run by a local company Yare Safaris. 
 In the Samburu language &bquo;yare&equo; means &bquo;quest&equo;, so it seemed an appropriate place to stay. 
 The hostel staff advised us about the best areas for walking, and also arranged for the essential guide, to keep us on the right path and to protect us from the buffalo. 
 One of our walks took us to the top of a huge escarpment at a place called Losiolo, or World's View. 
 It was well named: this was the edge of the Great Rift Valley, a gigantic dyke which cuts across the entire continent of Africa from the Red Sea to Mozambique, and from our vantage point the ground fell away, almost sheer, to the flat valley floor, some 2,000 feet below. 
 We followed a narrow path that snaked precariously down the escarpment side. 
 As we descended it became increasingly hot, and in the space of two hours we had dropped from rolling grassy hills to a sandy, semi-desert plain. 
 In these lower, drier areas the Samburu keep camels, introduced from neighbouring Somalia, to use as beasts of burden. 
 The hostel even had its own fleet of camels on its regular Hillaby-style treks, used them to carry supplies or provide a mount for weary walkers. 
 It sounded an ideal way to explore some of the remoter parts of this region, but our time was limited and we wanted to move on to the higher mountains. 
 Above: Richly robed, the Samburu tribesman who acted as guide to the party. 
 Left: On Mount Elgon, looking towards Koitobos Peak (Photos by the author). 
 So we travelled west from Maralal to the Cheranganis &mdash; a large range of mountains which include Nakugen Peak (11,580ft. /350m), the fourth highest mountain in Kenya. 
 The Cherangani range is home to the Pokot and Marakwet tribes, who are skilled cultivators and have cleared areas of natural forest for farmland. 
 There were a few villages in the lower hills and, further up, small groups of round mud-huts, each housing a couple of families, were dotted across the fields. 
 These mountains were not as wild as the area around Maralal. 
 In these pleasant surroundings, we &bquo;bagged&equo; several of the main peaks, but the most interesting and spectacular walk was to the summit of a mountain called Koh, in the far north of the range. 
 The walk began by following a track which climbed steeply up a narrow, twisting valley. 
 On the valley floor was a fast-flowing river and, wherever space could be found, the earth had been levelled to form terraces. 
 The most common crops were maize (corn on the cob), the local staple, and large, bushy plants that looked like spinach. 
 At the head of the valley we reached a tiny settlement and stopped to ask the way. 
 We were taken to the chief who instructed four young boys to show us the path up to the top. 
 The boys asked if we could pay them some &bquo;small money&equo; to buy pens for schools. 
 Impressed by their studiousness, we carefully counted out some coins, making sure each boy got the same amount. 
 After thanking the chief, we continued up the mountain with the boys leading the way. 
 As the path climbed higher it got increasingly steep and narrow. 
 In some places the topsoil had been eroded and we had to zigzag up on loose scree. 
 Despite their bare feet, our young guides strolled nonchalantly across these sections, apparently unconcerned that a single slip could send them plummeting down the mountainside. 
 Nearer the top, all the soil and loose stones had been completely eroded away, leaving a huge dome of smooth grey rock. 
 It was steep and exposed but solid, and the final push for the summit involved some exhilarating scrambling. 
 As we sat on the top, recovering from the steep walk and admiring the view down into the valley and out to the plains beyond, the boys produced a rather crushed packet of cigarettes and all four of them puffed away merrily. 
 We wondered about the pen money, but said nothing. 
 Back at the village we were invited to join the chief and some of the older men for a drink of maize beer. 
 This was a brown, evil-looking brew, topped by grey scum, with the taste and texture of fine silt. 
 It was also fairly strong. 
 Traditionally, African beer is drunk from a large cup, passed round the groups of drinkers, but in this village they had a different technique: they brewed the stuff in an old oil drum and served it up in buckets. 
 Not wanting to appear rude we ploughed our way through a bucket between us and then left while we could still walk. 
 Needless to say, the rest of the day passed in a pleasant haze. 
 After the fun and games of the Cheranganis it was time for something a bit more serious, so we headed for Mount Elgon, in the far west of the country, straddling the border between Kenya and Uganda. 
 The highest point on Elgon is over 14,000ft (4,300m), making it the second highest mountain in Kenya. 
 Like Mount Kenya, Elgon is the remains of an ancient volcano, and rises as a gigantic dome high above the surrounding plains. 
 At the crest of the dome is a large crater (more correctly called caldera), with its rim surmounted by a circle of large, steep-sided, flat-topped peaks. 
 The highest of these peaks, Wagagai (14,177ft/4321m), is in Ugandan territory and officially out of bounds, but our map showed the international boundary passing through the summit of the second highest peak (just 20 metres lower than Wagagai), called Lower Elgon, so we decided to stay legal and aim for that instead. 
 Part of Mount Elgon is a national park, a protected area for several species of animals, including elephant and buffalo. 
 Remembering the close encounter near Maralal, we arranged for an armed park ranger to accompany us, so that we would also be protected in case of emergency. 
 A narrow track wound steeply up the lower slopes through dense forest, and then areas of bamboo and giant heather. 
 We kept a sharp lookout for animals and saw several waterbuck &mdash; timid, deer-like creatures &mdash; and colobus monkeys, with shaggy black and white coats, but there was no sign of anything large, grey and dangerous. 
 At about 10,000ft (3300m) we broke out of the trees into an area of grassland that looked vaguely like a Scottish moor and decided to camp for the night. 
 As we were pitching the tents, a herd of buffalo wandered by, this time plainly visible, less than 500 yards away. 
 They seemed unconcerned  by our presence, and the ranger said they were probably deliberately moving out of our way, but once again we were reminded that, even though this part of Elgon might look like Scotland, we were still most definitely in Africa. 
 Next day we followed a faint path that continued up a steep-sided valley towards the crater. 
 At several points the route was unclear, where the buffalo and other animals had churned the grass into a mass of muddy trails, so we trended upwards, away from the boggy sections and towards the crest of a broad ridge that formed one side of the river valley. 
 Along the crest of this ridge the rock had been exposed in several places, and eroded into a line of towers and pinnacles. 
 After a few hours' walking along the ridge we could clearly see Koitobos, one of the peaks surrounding the crater rim &mdash; a long, flat-topped buttress with a steep cone at one end, composed of large, dark brown, vertical columns. 
 To the left of this peak was Koitobos Col, a low gap in the crater rim, and we aimed straight across the top of the valley towards it. 
 We passed through the col, with the main peak of Koitobos towering up to our right, and then suddenly we were right on the edge of the rim with the giant bowl of the crater itself spread out below us. 
 The view was doubly breath-taking firstly because we were now at 13,000ft (4000m) and, after a long morning's walk were beginning to feel the effects of the thin air; and secondly because the vista before us was absolutely astounding. 
 The crater was about two miles across, almost perfectly circular, with several steep-sided peaks evenly placed around the rim. 
 The floor was undulating, covered in grass and a few patches of exposed rock. 
 A large stream, fed by several smaller tributaries, flowed across it, escaping through a cleft in the rim which formed a deep gorge. 
 On the far side of the crater, faint plumes of steam from a hot spring drifted into the air, and dotted across the grass were weird plants called groundsels, looking like dried cabbages on poles, and clumps of bright flowers, with red poker-shaped buds. 
 We established a &bquo;base-camp&equo; and spent the next two days exploring this bizarre landscape. 
 First we circled round the crater, walking across fine, open grassland or weaving our way through dense patches of groundsel, to bag Lower Elgon Peak, our highest point in Kenya so far. 
 Then, on the second day, we dropped down into the lowest part of the crater to reach the hot springs. 
 These were deep enough to bathe in and, after three days of sweaty walking, this open-air jacuzzi was most welcome! 
 During the four days we spent on Elgon we saw no other people and only one solitary gazelle. 
 Although the walking on the other ranges had been enjoyable, it was particularly pleasing to be in this wild and seldom-visited area, and to enjoy the unique feelings of solitude and peace that only mountains can inspire. 
 After Elgon we felt fit, strong and fully acclimatised. 
 So we left the remote mountains of the north and west and headed back towards the central highlands and Mount Kenya, the main objective of our visit. 
 The precaution paid off and we had no problems with the altitude, enjoying seven excellent days of walking and climbing. 
 Information 
 Mountain Walking in Kenya  by David Else, published by Robertson McCarta (071 278 8276). 
 For flights to Kenya, or information about walking and camel trekking safaris, contact the Africa Travel Centre in London (071 387 1211). 
 In the Cherangani mountains, looking towards Sondhang, one of the highest peaks in the range. 
 Middle grade limestone 
 French without tears 
 You don't have to be climbing in the high E-grades to enjoy a visit to the south of France. 
 David Pickup offers some encouragement 
 Reading climbing magazines can be disheartening &mdash; almost a disincentive to going climbing, in fact! 
 It's bad enough looking through the new sections and the main articles and seeing nothing mentioned less than E4, 6b. 
 What can finish you off is reading about crags which &bquo;also contain worthwhile medium grade routes at E2, 5c.&equo; 
 You think of the glow of pride that still lingers from your last HVS triumph with embarrassment and try to console yourself with the mitigating circumstances of age, heavy work responsibilities, duty to family, your back problem&hellip; 
 Don't be bullied into making excuses for yourself. 
 Obviously things have changed: not that long ago &bquo;medium grade&equo; meant VS and the centre of gravity has certainly moved up from there &mdash; but I bet the majority of climbers are still performing regularly at &bquo;only&equo; HVS/E1. 
 This article suggests that there masses of superb routes in the VS to E1 range on the crags of Southern France &mdash; even on the most illustrious and intimidating of them. 
 Excellent climbing can be combined with a family holiday in beautiful surroundings, with a virtual guarantee of sunshine. 
 Remember these routes are all on limestone, which rarely gives good routes at less than VS, but a line of bolts, ending at a firmly anchored chain, up dry and solid rock, means that a much bolder approach can be adopted than on the polished, easier routes of Stoney or the vertical scree of Swanage. 
 Climbing outside the usual circuit of The Pass, The Lakes, Stanage etc can be a real boost to your enjoyment and, I think, to your performance. 
 It is difficult to equate French and British grades. 
 The received wisdom is that you knock off two letters from the French; so 5c becomes British 5a. 
 That's OK as a rough guide but I think that, at this level anyway, the routes are easier than this would suggest. 
 I have yet to find a French 5c as hard or as scary as Kipling Groove! 
 I will use the French system for the numerical grades from now on, since they will be used in topos and in conversation with continental climbers. 
 Let's jump in at the deep end &mdash; literally. 
 Verdon. 
 This has to be the most spectacular and atmospheric rock climbing area in Europe, outside the Alps. 
 It is well worth visiting just as a tourist or to do the five-hour walk along the bottom of the gorge. 
 But there are many routes at VS to E1, which are approached by one abseil from the rim. 
 This is the mental adjustment that has to be made at Verdon &mdash; you start your route with several hundred metres already below you, but once you rationalise this it's just a steep, very solid crag! 
 Most climbers park at the Belvedere de la Carelle , a viewing point on the loop road that follows the rim of the gorge and ends at the little village of La Palud. 
 A steep slab at right angles to the viewing balcony gives several routes at about VS and is a poseur's paradise as you have a continuous battery of video cameras pointing at you. 
 The problem here is that having so easy access and the largest concentration of easy routes, it is very crowded at holiday time. 
 A growing menace in Verdon is the determination of many climbers to lower down a pitch and then be top-roped up it. 
 Groups can monopolise a route for hours like this, or, worse still, drop someone on your head while you're trying to lead it! 
 Below and just to the right of the balcony are several one pitch climbs: Delirium tr&egrave;s mince (6a) is probably the hardest. 
 A short walk from this belvedere takes you to a wonderful steep wall which at its outer edge is taken by the final pitches of some famous harder routes like Spitophage Pervers and Dingomaniaque. 
 It is covered with jugs and pockets and several HVS routes start at a ledge one abseil down, of which Triongle (5c) is typical. 
 A two-pitch 6a also comes up here &mdash; Arabe D&eacute;ment. 
 The second pitch is often climbed as a single pitch and is a lot easier than it looks from the top. 
 This is a good place to abseil down the face without committing yourself to a hard route out again. 
 Four abseils down the corner (the first chain is on the path) will take you to Le Jardin , a hanging terrace complete with mini-forest. 
 From here Dalles Grises takes six pitched of VS worthwhile for the feeding of doing a longer route in such an impressive place. 
 Next to it goes a soft touch 6a, Cocoluche, which has an easily avoidable 6b section. 
 Another 6a is Afin que nul ne meure, which goes up a very dramatic section of cliff to the right of the famous Pichenibule. 
 It is never harder than HVS and highly recommended. 
 The best way of escaping from the top-ropers is to go on one of the long classics. 
 The longest, and easiest, is La Demande, which climbs the whole 500 metres of the face and gives a unique day's adventure. 
 You walk to it along the foot of the gorge, through tunnels at one point, and then climb about twelve pitches that are never harder than HVS. 
 The bolts have recently been renewed but traditional protection is also necessary. 
 There can be no other climb at this standard which gives such a big-wall feel. 
 I thoroughly recommend it but it is a long route, so take a water bottle and a good look at the weather. 
 It is perhaps worth mentioning a recently developed crag which is just off the Moustiers road, about four kilometres outside La Palud. 
 It is ideal for people who want to relax from the exposure of the gorge, or have children who want to do some climbing. 
 It is a low cliff, approached by a path, and can be done in all the beauty of the Verdon scenery but with none of the problems of the big cliffs. 
 You turn off the road into a wooded parked area opposite the first house on the right after leaving the village. 
 It is called the Falaise d'Ayen . 
 The other most famous crag in Provence is Buoux. 
 It has to be said that there are no easy routes here; even the 5cs would probably be a 6a anywhere else. 
 The older climbs often take steep cracks so gritstone aficionados should feel more at home. 
 Many of them are only followed for the first pitch, either because they finish up easier slabs (which might well suit some people) or become much harder. 
 The first pitch of Pilier des Formis (5c) is a good, steep bridging and jamming corner. 
 Near this is Les Barouilles (6a) whose crux is a thuggish jamming crack over a bulge. 
 A less strenuous 5c in this area is Gougousse. 
 The old test-piece Pepsicomane, a hard 6b, locates the sector which contains many classics  of 5c/6a: Franco-Belge, Marabunta, Touloum and others. 
 Although, as I've said, you cannot expect to find anything easy here, it is worth a visit. 
 It's a beautiful valley and if nothing else you can get a close look at some ridiculous overhanging walls decorated with lean supermen (and women) swinging around on one finger. 
 The cautionary phase here is watch where you're putting your feet. 
 There is plentiful evidence of the emetic of the climbing! 
 For sheer enjoyment of climbing at this standard the routes on the Clapis sector the Dentelles de Montmirail take some beating. 
 This is set in the hillside below the actual Dentelles &mdash; a line of rock blades which run like a dragon's spine along the top of the hill above the wine village of Gigondas, near Carpentras. 
 The Clapis area is reached by taking the road to the Col du Cayron, just before Gigondas, then a forestry road which goes right at the col and contours round the hill. 
 Park at the layby on the left just before the stone gateway to a vineyard about five kilometres along this road. 
 A pleasant 15-minute walk brings you to the first two faces, which contain dozens of routes at VS to E1. 
 There's no point picking out individual climbs &mdash; they're all good. 
 Whilst belaying you can look across a sweeping valley covered by vineyards and broken up by lines of cyprus trees. 
 It's a very beautiful place where the friendly feel of the climbs reflects the gentle scenery. 
 Not far away is the village of Buis les Baronnies, dominated by a steep hill topped by a spectacular blade of rock similar to those of the Dentelles. 
 The south face of this crag has many three and four pitch routes at 5b to 6a. 
 Many pitches are on steep slabs with wonderful &bquo;letter-box&equo; holds you can sink your whole hand in! 
 Here you gaze across the terraced vineyards and orchards to the bare limestone summit of Mont Vertoux. 
 Do Pilier Gris, La Rampe, Tourniayre, Bouscade, Voie des Trous and especially Bibus, which has to be one of the best HVS's in France! 
 For those too old, lazy or hungover to face the 15-minute slog up this hill, a crag has been developed just outside the village right beside the D546 road to Sederon. 
 It has many one-pitch routes, few of which are more than 6a. 
 There are two recently developed areas which are perfect for lesser mortals. 
 Orpiere, reached by turning west off the N75 Grenoble road about 25km north of Sisteron, is a little village which lies at the foot of a cirque of crags. 
 Looking up from the village &mdash; you can park next to the graveyard! 
 &mdash; there are three obvious sectors. 
 Those to the left (The Ch&acirc;teau and opposite (The Belleric) contain the majority of routes. 
 There are masses at 4c to 5c, the rock is sound and the protection excellent. 
 The sector to the right (The Quiquillon) has only a few hard climbs, but its other side, hidden from the village and approached from a parking place reached by driving through a housing estate just before the village, has many fine, steep routes, often with three pitches, at all standards. 
 There is one section on this face specially for beginners, so although the climbs are steep and 4c to 5b they are very well protected. 
 Again, this is a very friendly area ideal for building up muscles and confidence. 
 Among many, recommended are: Think Punk (5b), Racines du Ciel (6a), Moulinette Endimanch&eacute; (6a), Tropique du Capricorne (5a), Violence and Passion (5b), Amour Toujours (6a), La Grotte (4c/5c/5b+), N'Importe o&ugrave; hors du Monde (5c/6a) and Bas les Pattes (5c+/6a). 
 The other similar development is at Orgon, near Cavaillon. 
 Another cirque of crags is riddled with excellently protected routes of VS to E1. 
 The sector called Le Mur du Six can be blitzed; apart from two or three 6b's virtually everything is 5c/6a, with a few even easier. 
 Crowds can be problem here too, especially at Easter. 
 There are many less well known, but very worthwhile places, which I suppose need to be dealt with in another article. 
 I have not included The Calanques. 
 By the time you've booby-trapped your car, or hired an armed guard for it, walked miles, found the crag and avoided the most polished routes you might not consider it worth the hassle. 
 This is obviously a wildly prejudiced view, but if you are keen to climb on sea cliffs, go to Cornwall or Pembroke! 
 A word about guidebooks. 
 They are expensive, specific to individual crags and often just lists of names and dotted lines up a very crude drawing of a face. 
 Unless you are spending a long time somewhere I suggest you simply turn up at a crag and scrounge a look at someone else's. 
 There'll always be someone around at the places described here and the grumpiness that seems to infect so many British crags these days hasn't spread here yet. 
 Most climbers, French or whatever, are very happy to swop information and generally be helpful. 
 Also, many names are painted on the bottom of the routes &mdash; ecologically unsound, but convenient! 
 Let the argument rage about the ethics of bolting. 
 These crags are already equipped, and there's nothing you can do about it except enjoy the security. 
 When in Rome etc. 
 Unless you are thinking of doing La Demande, put away your chocks and Friends and just take about a dozen quick-draws. 
 So, lay in a good stock of chalk, get your ear pierced and head for the sun. 
 There's no need to let E numbers damage your health! 
 Climbers on the first pitch of Pilier Gris, Buis les Baronnies (Photo Tom Prentice). 
 Louis Carraz (aged 12) on Empire du Soleil (5c) at Mur du Six, Orgon. 
 (Photo David Pickup). 
 Mountaineering Eastern Europe 
 Europe's Ice Crown 
 The demolition of the Iron Curtain has made the Caucasus much more accessible to western mountaineers. 
 Kev Reynolds tested the strength of Russian glasnost 
 When asked to name the highest mountain in Europe most people, I imagine, would nominate Mont Blanc. 
 But they'd be wrong. 
 Far to the east, on the very borders of Europe and Asia between the Black Sea and the Caspian Sea, a range of mountains of great beauty and ultra-alpine dimensions holds a central knot of peaks 1,000 metres higher than almost anything in the Alps. 
 This is, of course, the Caucasus, a landscape jewel in the crown of the USSR, until recently little known to Westerners other than a few privileged mountaineers lucky enough to be invited to climb there. 
 Historically, though, it was mountaineers from Britain who opened up the central part of the range in the heyday of Victorian adventure. 
 As Victor Saunders points out in his chapter on the Caucasus in The Mountains of Europe (Oxford Illustrated Press), of the ten highest summits, nine received their first ascent from members of the Alpine Club &mdash; admittedly including honorary member Vittorio Sella who was Italian, not British. 
 However, once the Revolution closed much of the USSR behind its invisible Iron Curtain, both bureaucratic difficulties and high expense effectively put these mountains out of reach to all but a few fortunate climbers. 
 Now, thanks to glasnost , the Caucasus range is being made more accessible, with some beautiful valleys headed by powerful and impressive peaks available for exploration. 
 The mountains have an undisputed lure, the Russian people a warmth and generosity that will come as a very pleasant surprise to all who arrive with an open mind and a readiness to respond with a smile. 
 With this new-found relaxation in official attitudes and an encouragingly open-hearted welcome from Russian climbers extending to visitors from the West, I travelled to the USSR on behalf of Sherpa Expeditions to see just what the Caucasus held in store. 
 It was to be a memorable trip in so many different ways. 
 So what is the highest mountain in Europe? 
 It is, of course, Elbrus, a huge dormant volcano with two summits at 5642 metres (18,510ft) and 5621m, the Western top being more than 800 metres higher than that of Mont Blanc. 
 And all around it rise some of the most shapely and challenging mountains in Europe: Ushba, Schkelda, Dykhtau, Koshtan Tau, the great block of Dongus Orun and countless others crying out for attention. 
 The Baskan Valley rises at the foot of Elbrus, with its subsidiary valleys of Cheget, Adyl Su and Adyr Su leading to some of the most spectacular climbing available. 
 In the upper Baskan accommodation is in multistorey hotels lively with the comings and goings of mountaineers of all nationalities. 
 Buses trundle up and down the valley easing the walk-in, and Elbrus even has cable-car access to the snowline and a mountain refuge, Priut, an hour or so above it. 
 It's almost like being in the Alps &mdash; but not quite. 
 Many of the peaks have routes on them that can be described as forming a midway point between hard Alpine and Himalayan standard &mdash; long ridge routes that take several days to accomplish; big face routes on rock and ice. 
 Others, like Schkelda and Ushba, have been partially developed but still have plenty of scope for new routes. 
 Yet the highest of them all, Elbrus, has a route that would be accessible to many a mountaineer with only one of two alpine seasons behind him; a route that demands no real technical expertise, but an ability to adapt to altitude, and a fair degree of stamina. 
 It's a long day out, but a most rewarding one, as I was to discover. 
 I began by taking the cable-car and the chairlift beyond it, then wandered up the lower glacier to the hut. 
 This came as something of a surprise, for nothing Victor Saunders had told me about the Priut refuge quite prepared me for my first sight of this three-storey silver sausage &mdash; an amazing futuristic construction with a dining room that looks out on a wonderland of peaks, and with some four-bedded dormitories which, if you're lucky enough to be allocated one, ensures a degree of comfort far different from alpine-style overcrowding. 
 Busy, yes, but since everything is strictly  regulated, there's bed-space for nearly everyone. 
 The hut stands at 4157 metres, which still leaves nearly 1500 metres to climb. 
 That's quite enough for one day at altitude, there and back. 
 I joined a small group of three Germans, a Dutchman and an American who, with a young interpreter and a terrifyingly fit-looking guide from Kiev, set out for Europe's icy crown at four o'clock one morning last July. 
 Before we'd gone far from the hut we had lost one of the Germans with sickness, and an hour later the Dutchman had to turn back when he had trouble with his crampons. 
 Two down, six to go. 
 It was cold that early in the morning, with a sliver of moon hanging among the stars. 
 But the stars soon lost their sheen and went out as the first strain of light eased away the darkness. 
 Then jagged peaks came out of cloud-filled valleys to steal all colouring from the sky and day flooded the glacier ahead, painting it with a palette of new-formed pastel shades. 
 We made it to the Pastukhov rocks without a break and steered left where the slope steepened considerably. 
 It was then we lost our guide, who was called to help a Bulgarian who'd had an accident. 
 Instead of accompanying us, he carried the Bulgarian bodily down to the refuge. 
 Three down, five to go. 
 In truth, a guide wasn't really necessary for our party that good-weather day. 
 The route was obvious, we were all experienced and we were not exactly alone. 
 But it was still comforting to have with us little Liena, our 19-year-old interpreter who was a very competent rock climber and all-round mountaineer, for she had climbed Elbrus in the past and could give assurance that we were on the right course. 
 She held the lead and quietly plodded upward through the crisp snow that covered the long Baskan Glacier. 
 In a way, climbing Elbrus is a bit like climbing Mont Blanc, for you'll seldom be alone. 
 So I was particularly pleased to find at one point, when I'd indulged in a lengthy photo session, that the rest of the party had gone over the brow and out of sight and I was left for a while with the world to myself. 
 It was a world of pristine beauty and breathless calm &mdash; all the wind was beyond the ridge &mdash; and I revelled in it. 
 On and upward, slow now with the altitude telling on legs and lungs alike, the route was measured in numbers of steps before a rest was needed. 
 And with every rest so the views increased. 
 They demanded attention, more photography, and the remainder of the party drew further away. 
 It didn't matter. 
 There was time. 
 Time to reach the top, and time to enjoy the way there. 
 Time, in fact, had ceased to have meaning. 
 Only now mattered, for the present moment was so filled with beauty that it smothered the effort of climbing, and with every gasp of breath came a physical response to the glory of the day. 
 Weariness was almost an essential part of it. 
 One had to earn the wonder of that morning. 
 The slope eased, and I came over what had seemed from below like a ridge, but in fact was merely the folding of ice from a long saddle that ran like a narrow valley between west and east summits. 
 Ahead I could see the rest of my party plodding towards the final slope that leads to the west (main) summit. 
 That summit was partially hidden, however, for when you get to the top of the final slope there's a level stretch that takes you just out of view. 
 It all looked so close, so welcoming, so immediate. 
 I'd meet up with the others again on top and we'd descend together. 
 Or so I thought. 
 But as I ploughed through the trough in the snow, a lone figure came weaving drunkenly towards me. 
 As we drew closer I recognised Liena, our interpreter. 
 As we met she slumped in the snow. 
 The altitude had suddenly hit her and she was feeling rough. 
 Not for her the summit this day; she'd left the others to it. 
 Four down, four to go. 
 I sat with her, gave her my drink bottle, stuffed her with glucose and encouraged her to rest for a while. 
 In half an hour she felt a lot better, but I knew now it would be my job to see her safely down to the hut. 
 I couldn't leave her to descend alone. 
 But then when she realised this, she offered to go to the east summit with me. 
 It would not be the main top, but a consolation prize. 
 &bquo;You sure you're up to it?&equo; 
 &bquo;I think so,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Then we'll take it very slowly&equo;. 
 There was a good ice slope leading up to rime of rocks that would take us to this secondary top. 
 I went at it with pleasure, front-pointing happily and resting on my ski poles, watching Liena's progress with concern. 
 Fifty metres or so up the slope, she began to waver and looked ready to collapse again. 
 That was it. 
 The altitude was really affecting her and it was important to get her down now. 
 Five down, three to go! 
 We turned and descended slowly to the tracks we had made on the ascent earlier that morning, then sloughed our way down. 
 Twenty minutes later we met our guide, seated in the snow making radio contact with the hut. 
 Having delivered the injured Bulgarian to safety we had then returned to the ascent, hoping to catch our party. 
 He and Liena conversed for a while before he announced his decision to wait there for the return of Tony and Ferdy (the Germans), and Dave the American, asking me to take care of Liena on the way down. 
 It was a magnificent descent. 
 As we lost height, just the two of us in a landscape of dazzling white, so Liena regained strength and interest in the day, and we would stop every now and then to sit on our rucksacks in the snow that coated the glacier and gaze in awe at the beauty of the scene. 
 There were peaks in view that reminded me to the Matterhorn, of Ober Gabelhorn and Wellenkuppe. 
 There were others with stark walls that invited, with summit domes of brushed snow that gleamed in the sunshine; others with fish-tail crests or long ribs topped with cornices to remind me of scenes from the Himalaya. 
 But it was pointless trying to compare or liken these mountains to others, they had individual stature and grace, they rose with their own majesty from valleys I could only dream about. 
 We gazed at glaciers and icefalls, at clouds spiralling from far-off valleys, at soft blue shadows and crests of ice and dark, barren faces of rock. 
 I gave thanks that I had time and energy to simply enjoy and absorb. 
 Not for one moment &mdash; not then or since &mdash; did I regret being denied the summit. 
 For that very denial had, in fact, given me far more. 
 It had given me a world of wonder and time to draw it all in. 
 It was one of the finest mountain panoramas and one of the finest of mountain days. 
 It was a day to remember, to savour. 
 It was one of the very best I've spent in 30 years of climbing round the world. 
 Which just goes to prove, the summit is not all. 
 The icy crown of Europe is surrounded by jewels more lasting than diamonds. 
 Information 
 The Caucasus Mountains are partly in the state of Russia, partly in Georgia. 
 The border line between the two states runs across the summit of Elbrus. 
 There are several other peaks, apart from Elbrus, that are accessible to mountaineers of modest abilities. 
 One or two seasons of alpine experience on snow and ice should be sufficient background to tackle them. 
 Altitude sickness is probably the most common cause of failure to reach a summit. 
 No technical climbing skills are required, but double boots and crampions, ice axe or ski sticks, a good duvet and thermal gloves and overmitts are essential. 
 In 1991 Sherpa Expeditions are mounting trips to the Caucasus (Elbrus and elsewhere). 
 Details of these and other treks worldwide are also available from: Sherpa Expeditions, 131a Heston Road, Hounslow, Middlesex TW5 ORD. 
 The Caucasus contains Europe's highest mountain &mdash; Elbrus, over 18,500 feet high and surrounded by shapely, challenging peaks. 
 Above are two of them: Ushba and Dongus Orun (Photo Kev Reynolds). 
 Equipment 
 Backpacks 
 A wide range of backpacking sacks are available on the market. 
 Our reviewers selected four 60 litre plus models and weren't disappointed. 
 PULSAR 60 BC PLUS 
 Berghaus Approx retail: &pound;107 
 This was the first Berghaus sack to incorporate &bquo;exploding sidepockets.&equo; 
 Well, they don't literally explode, but they are gusseted and expand dramatically, taking the sack from 60 to 75 litres. 
 On a backpacking trip side pockets are a great benefit, allowing on-the-road brews, by giving easy access to water bottle, billies, stove and food. 
 These pockets are so voluminous that you can get a whole lot in besides &mdash; suntan lotion, midge repellent, etc. 
 Packing the side pockets requires some skill to balance the weight on either side, or the sack can feel uncomfortably lopsided. 
 Both pockets have two retaining straps with quick release buckles and this does mean a lot of excess strapping when the pockets aren't full. 
 Otherwise this a comfortable two-compartment sack with well padded hipbelt and shoulder straps. 
 The Pulsar range is only available in one size, adjustable over a limited range, unlike the Laser and Cyclops which will fit more sizes. 
 I'm about 5'7&equo; and found it fitted me fine, although as with all sacks, it took a couple of days of walking to get the best adjustment. 
 Walking 90 miles of the Pyrennean High Route with your house on your back is a fair test of any sack. 
 I have few comments to make, except that the sack survived very well, save for some sections of the Advent material used for the back and inside the shoulder straps, which were eaten by salt-seeking grasshoppers! 
 However, this is unusual and was fully repaired by Berghaus without quibble in double-quick time. 
  Tom Prentice  
 BIG PACK XR TOP 70 
 UK distributor Ardblair Sports Approx retail: &pound;130 
 This is indeed a big pack. 
 With a top capacity of some 75 litres it's large enough for a week's backpacking, or even extended expedition use, although I do have some doubts as to whether it could stand up to the rigours of expedition life. 
 When I first loaded up the pack I really thought it would be a bit top heavy &mdash; it's a longer and slimmer pack than most British models &mdash; but I was delighted to discover that my fears were unfounded. 
 Loaded up with about 45 pounds the carry was excellent, largely due to the very comfortable hipbelt and harness system. 
 Over several weekends I humped big loads, all over 40 pounds, and actually became very fond of this pack. 
 A lower compartment with a curved zipper offers easy and quick access to things like waterproofs or extra sweaters, and the main bag itself has a zip-out divider, which I found to be quite useful. 
 I tend to be rather disorganised when packing gear, so anything that helps me keep things in the right place has got to be a bonus. 
 Unlike most modern packs, the Big Top has an adjustable hip belt instead of an adjustable shoulder harness. 
 Unfortunately there are only three positions, so adjustability is limited, especially if you are tall or short. 
 The adjustment system is not particularly good, something of a nut-and-bolt operation, and looks as though it could well be vulnerable to failure as the bolt wears through the covering fabric. 
 On the plus side the harness and especially the hip belt is extremely comfortable, its extra wide shape wrapping round the hips with more than a hint of luxury. 
 All in all this is a very good pack for the price; made from 1000D Cordura, with two main compartments and four pockets, three in the lid and one in the front. 
 The top lid is detachable, and the main pack extends quite easily. 
 I was also attracted by the weight, only 1.9kg, which is uncharacteristically light among today's generally heavy packs. 
  Cameron McNeish  
 Top: Berghaus 60 BC Plus with &bquo;exploding&equo; pockets. 
 Above: Backpack XR 70 Top. 
 CONDOR 60&ndash; 80 
 Karrimor Approx retail: &pound;170 
 The Condor combines Karrimor's sophisticated and fully adjustible SA back system with a cavernous internal space, just right for long expeditions and long distance backpacking. 
 A correctly fitting sack is essential to enjoyable walking, especially when carrying a heavy load and the SA harness and hip belt on the Condor have been beefed up a bit from the Jaguar and Panther models. 
 The SA system allows the shoulder straps to be adjusted up and down aluminium struts and held in place with straps and buckles, while the lumber support pad and hip belt remain stationary. 
 A smaller SA system is available for people with smaller backs, but unfortunately not on the Condor. 
 Size is quickly adjusted with compression straps and full-length zipped gussets, although this system all adds to the sack's 2.4kg. 
 Pockets, attached via Karrimor's Klasp system, boost capacity to a massive 100 litres. 
 This is a two compartment sack, the lower section accessed by a curved zip, with a drawcord divider designed to allow tent poles to run the whole length of the sack with the divider closed. 
 The lid has a large top pocket accessed by a two way zip. 
 I found this an extremely comfortable sack for lugging climbing equipment, tent and food into some of the more remote Scottish crags for a weekend's sport. 
 The sack won an award from the Design Council and comes with a number of extras including an eternal document wallet. 
 A couple of hooks in the main compartment allow the wallet to be hung inside. 
  Tom Prentice  
 Lowe Alpamayo 
 UK distributor Europa Sport Approx retail: &pound;136 
 Latest in a long line of internal frame alpine packs from Lowe, the Alpamayo has an easy-to-use stepless and lockable Wedge Adjustment back systems which makes achieving a good fit simple. 
 The shoulder straps, hipbelt and lumbar pad are all well padded and a chest strap is fitted as standard. 
 The packbag has two compartments with a zip-out dividing shelf. 
 A curved zip gives easy access to the lower compartment. 
 The lid is extendible and removable and has two zipped pockets, one inside, one out. 
 The pack also has side compression straps to which side pockets can be attached, wand pockets, two ice-axe loops and straps on the front of the lid from crampons or foam pad. 
 The material is Cordura. 
 Basic capacity is 70 litres but this can be increased by 20 litres using the extendible lid; side pockets add another 10 litres to give a maximum of 100 litres. 
 I've used the Alpamayo for backpacking and Nordic ski touring and found it very stable. 
 The pack is very comfortable with heavy loads (23+kg), due in the main to the excellent hipbelt which spreads the weight over the hips without causing the sore spots that occur with some belts. 
 The only flaw I can find with the Alpamayo is that the hipbelt won't fit small waists (those much below 80cm). 
 There is a Lady Almayo available, but the capacity is only 49 litres. 
 Otherwise I can't fault this pack. 
 Even the price is, these days, quite reasonable for a quality pack. 
  Chris Townsend   
 Camming devices 
 Clog Quattros, HB Fix, Flexible Friend 3 and Lowe ball-nuts reviewed  
 CLOG QUATTRO 
 Wild Country Approx. retail: &pound;29 to &pound;31 
 Considering the success of Flexible Friends, its a bit strange that Wild Country say they need to develop a twin wire camming device. 
 One can only presume that another, more competitive product was needed to counter the twin stem camming devices made by Hugh Banner and Faces. 
 Furthermore, twin stem devices are very popular in the USA and that's a big market. 
 The Quattro uses Friend cams with the twin stem giving a narrower profile, helping the device to fit in cracks and pockets too restricted for a Friend. 
 The stems are roll swaged to the wires in the same way as Flexible Friends. 
 Moulded nylon is used for the free-floating trigger bar which can be used with one or two fingers, inside or out. 
 I quite like the design of the Quattro, the trigger mechanism is very smooth and easy, although the thick thumbed may have trouble getting it past the tape loop. 
 If this is the case the end of the U-wire is broad enough to sit comfortably in the palm of the hand. 
 Sizes range from 1/2 to 2&ndash;1/2. 
  Tom Prentice  
 THE FIX 
 hb Climbing Equipment Approx retail: &pound;23.50 to &pound;28.70 
 While camming devices with flexible stems give the most secure placements in awkward and horizontal placements, even they won't take repeated loading over an edge. 
 The Fix is a rigid camming device, with a specially forged alloy stem, designed to give a higher level of strength to the stem. 
 In practical terms this means The Fix can be placed in a horizontal crack with a large proportion of the stem sticking out and fallen on in the knowledge that the device has been specifically designed to give an increased safety margin. 
 As well as strengthening the stem The Fix has a new trigger mechanism for retracting the cams. 
 A finger lever on each side is hinged in the middle and allows greater control of individual sets of cams, particularly useful when trying to extract the unit. 
 To finish off, there's a small and neat Spectra sling in a wide eye designed to allow easy movement of the sling and reduce walking. 
 They come in sizes 1 to 3.8. 
  Tom Prentice  
 FLEXIBLE FRIEND 3 
 Wild Country Approx retail &pound;36 
 &bquo;They&equo; said it couldn't be done. 
 &bquo;They&equo; said the head would be so big it would be unwieldy. 
 In fact &bquo;they&equo; said a lot of things when Wild Country decided to make a Flexible Friend 3. 
 Most of it has been proved wrong. 
 On the face of it, the Friend 3 seems the model least likely to benefit from flexibility &mdash; the thick stem interferes little with the working of the cams, both designs have the same strength rating and there's only a few grams difference in weight between them. 
 Yet a flexible stem makes such a difference; horizontal placements, angled placements, pockets, all gobbled up by its voracious cams. 
 Certainly my wire is yet to get bent and distorted with use &mdash; the real durability test of any flexible camming device. 
 But, having used a number of different twin stem units I've found the single wire stem much more versatile, although sometimes a little harder to remove from stubborn placements. 
  Tom Prentice  
 LOWE BALL 1&ndash;3 
 UK distributor Allcord Approx retail: &pound;25.50 
 Mechanical, sliding nut devices never seem to have become that popular in Britain. 
 Perhaps it's just that we don't have enough of those long, thin granite cracks. 
 Yet climbers appear willing to put an inordinate amount of faith in a long line of brass nuts and then show surprise when they pull like a hot knife through butter. 
 Lowe ball-nuts have been around for a while and they are one of the best devices of this  sort that I have used so far. 
 The principle is a simple one. 
 A semi-circular wedge is moved up and down an inclined groove in an aluminium nut, with a trigger. 
 The wedge is retracted when the device is placed and then released. 
 When fallen on, the wedge is retained in the groove and forced against the nut and up the incline. 
 But, the width of the crack prevents this and the nut remains solid. 
 The wires are soldered into the nut and the device appears well engineered. 
 One benefit of this over similar units is that the groove retains the semi-circular wedge, so it is hard to separate this moveable part from the nut. 
 On some units this can be done by rotating and will cause total failure. 
 Ball-nuts fit in all sorts of parallel sided, finger-tip cracks. 
 Deeper cracks are undoubtedly the best &mdash; this isn't a unit for marginal placements or pockets. 
 Potentially a life-saver. 
  Tom Prentice  
 Top: HB Fix 2-1-2 extra strength stem for horizontal placements. 
 Above: Clog Quattros 1/2 and 1 1/2. 
 Above: Flexible Friend 3. 
 Above: Lowe ball-nut placed in a horizontal finger-tip crack. 
 Below: Lowe Ball-nut showing working parts 
 Reports 
 LAKES 
 By Bill Birkett 
 Langdale bolt wrangle 
 Dave Birkett, following toprope practice and utilising two poor pegs for protection, led Daws Rides The Shovelhead. 
 This a direct finish to Centrefold on Raven Crag Langdale (the one above the Old Dungeon Ghyll Hotel). 
 While only offering about 20ft of new climbing, it solves the main challenge of the capping roof: a formidable test piece with potentially fatal consequences in the event of a fall. 
 He graded it an unlikely E7 6c &mdash; unlikely in that it is, in all probability, much harder. 
 Having done the climb in this manner, Dave thought the route unjustified in this state, feeling that as the pegs deteriorated with age no-one would repeat it. 
 Presumably this was important to him (it always was to me and I can fully understand this) for he wrote the route up in the new routes books asking how others would feel if he subsequently went back and placed a single bolt runner to protect the route. 
 Of the climbers who made written comment, the majority were in favour of a bolt placement. 
 It should also be said that people of influence, who haven't put it in writing, also openly agreed with the placing of a bolt. 
 Discussing the matter with me, Dave (my nephew) put forward his convictions regarding the bolt and sought my feelings. 
 These were mixed. 
 I was sad and angry that he should want to place a bolt and go so radically against the grain; sympathetic with Dave's strong conviction; peeved that my own route &mdash; Centrefold &mdash; had been usurped. 
 While acknowledging his argument for the bolt placement, I advised that he had done the route; if others thought a bolt should be placed, let someone else go ahead and place it. 
 Shortly afterwards Dave placed a protection bolt in the roof just above the pegs. 
 The blatant placing of a bolt in a Lakeland mountain crag produced considerable reaction throughout the rock climbing fraternity. 
 Removal squads descended on the Lakes, threatening and verbally abusing and the bolt has now been hacksawed through, leaving a useless stump. 
 Personal reflections 
 My gut reaction has always been against the placing of bolts, and I've never used them. 
 For the last few years I have sat on the sidelines watching bolt-protected climbing mushrooming throughout the USA, Europe and, not least, Britain: in quarries, but also, let's be completely truthful, on natural crags. 
 Scotland, Yorkshire, the Peak District, Wales, the South West and so on. 
 But not in the Lake District &mdash; the last bastion. 
 My own personal statement was to refrain from the practice and to convey my anti feelings in print whenever possible (see my book Modern Rock and Ice Climbing , chapter 7 &mdash; Ethics). 
 Then it started on Cumbrian limestone, blossomed to Lakeland quarries and so, finally, to Raven Crag. 
 And when the perpetrator was my own nephew, it couldn't have hit any harder. 
 Dave is very much his own man &mdash; young and impulsive and finally the arbiter of his own convictions. 
 Yet virtually the first time we climbed together, hadn't we spent nigh on a month clipping bolts in France and loving it? 
 So inevitably, I feel at least partly responsible. 
 Forced to examine the situation anew, I have come to the following conclusions: 
 &bull; 
 It really must be the cutting edge of the climbing fraternity that decides the ethics &mdash; those who are active at the forefront of climbing development. 
 Influence depends upon respect. 
 &bull; 
 Sawing through the bolt on Raven is an act of stupid vandalism. 
 As an anti-bolt statement it fails for a number of important reasons: 
 1) 
 The anonymous person who did it does not have the respect of the locals currently active on the scene and the bolt will, in all probability, be replaced. 
 2) 
 It makes no ethical statement whatsoever. 
 A route must be led, on sight, without clipping the bolt, to make an ethical statement. 
 Only then can it be deemed unnecessary and removed. 
 3) 
 From an environmental point of view a bolt (galvanised or stainless steel) causes less impact than a peg. 
 All pegs that are placed damage the cracks (look at The Nose on El Cap for the ultimate statement on the process). 
 All regular steel pegs rot and become unsafe and then unusable in a relatively short space of time. 
 In conclusion 
 After first leading the route without the bolt, Dave certainly has the respect of his Lakeland contemporaries. 
 If anyone had the right to place the bolt it was him. 
 Having done this, after carefully considering his actions, he has made a statement which may well become the accepted ethic of Lakeland/British climbing. 
 Many will say &bquo;About time&equo;. 
 My main fear, I think, is that bolt ladders will appear on beautiful, clean stretches of rock. 
 This is precisely what has happened at Malham (and though I find it visually offensive I still climb there, as do hundreds of others). 
 Analysing the situation on Lakeland rhyolite more closely, I think this has probably been a false fear. 
 The placing of bolts should be self-regulating. 
 Anyone capable of sight-leading a route protected by bolts without clipping them has the right to remove them (a regular bolt hole closed by a rock dust/epoxy mix is virtually undetectable, and no meaningful harm will have been done to the crag environment). 
 No bolts should be placed where removable &bquo;natural&equo; gear (nuts, Friends etc) can be placed. 
 No retro-bolting should take place without a common consensus of opinion, including that of the first ascentionists. 
 I have not reached these conclusions easily; they involved much discussion and soul-searching. 
 Really it's a case of head versus heart. 
 I say that because I think it's the logical way free rock climbing will progress. 
 I find it hard to accept. 
 I would rather have no bolts and the romantic ethic &mdash; leave it for the next generation if it requires a bolt. 
 But it looks like the next generation is here.  
 PEAK 
 by Graeme Alderson 
 Cheedale, as ever, still yields a few goodies on its more open crags. 
 On Two Tier, Simon Cundy claimed his &bquo;Reward&equo; by climbing the wall right of The Tier Drop Explodes past the girdle break to a BB. 
 On the same crag Speedmetal Bedmoshin at E1 5c, which takes the wall right of Big Jesus Trashcan, is the work of the Honda works team Tony Coutts and J. Dunlop. 
 Over the river on Riverside Buttress, Chris Wright had his morning cup of Maxwellhouse (ingredients: flavour enhancer E6 5b and preservative 2BR) on the wall right of the Max Museum. 
 At t'other end (and t'other side) of t'Dale, Chee Torr has a rare addition, with the wall between Changeling and Doggone Groove done: Doggy Style at E3/4 6b. 
 Tideswell Dale has also seen some activity. 
 On Junction Buttress, Malc Taylor put All my Pegs in one Basket and then left them in the obvious overhanging crack, which is now E7 6c. 
 A little bit further up (or is it down?) the valley on Freda's Buttress, M. Evans and A. Thornton have been &bquo;Frolic&equo; ing around on the rightward starting corner at the lefthand end of the buttress, the result being E5 4c. 
 Over on the brown stuff, Andy Barker has been seeking out those remaining gems. 
 Partnered by Martin Veale and the Famous Chris Ellis, he crowned himself the King o'Crookrise at E36a, attempting to usurp Chris's crown, up the arete left of the Cioch LeftHand. 
 At Wharncliffe, Andy added a direct finish to Ca ne Fait Rien to give Well Now It Is at E26a. 
 At Banford Quarry, the evergreen pair of Stu Bolton and Sebastian Grieve had their Big Excellent Adventure on the obvious arete at E5 6b, before moving across to Staffordshire for more excellent adventures on Never Never Land, pair of them making 2nd and 3rd ascents of this nasty E6 6b. 
 Back on the white(ish) stuff, John Welford made the second ascent of Simon Nadin's 1987 testpiece Gonads giving it F8a+, and then red-pointed Out of my Tree at Raven Tor as a warm down. 
 John, who is a full time shift worker, has been polishing off most the Peak's F8a+ in good time, having also recently red-pointed Boat Boys, Chimes of Freedom as well as making the 6th ascent of Zeke the Freak (F8b). 
 One little snippet from Down Under, where Peak raider Robin Barker sneaked the 3rd (and first Sheffield ie British!) ascent of Stefan Glowacz's Lord of the Rings, one of Australia's two grade 32's (F8b or E8 6c). 
 They may beat us at cricket and bike racing, but we are better on crags! 
 That other well known Peak raider, Ben Moon, the real king o'Crookrise, has just repeated Jerry Moffatt's testpiece of last year, Liquid Amber at L.P.T, confirming grade and quality. 
 Ben has also been giving those Yorkshire boys a good seeing-to with an on-sight flash of Kleptomanis (F8a) at the Holywood Bowl, a one-day ascent of the Yorkshire Ripper (F8b) at Kilnsey, and he got Magnetic Fields (F8a/8a+) first red-point. 
 All of this and he's not even recovering from any broken bones (Ben's specialty over the last few years has been to break a bone and then come back and do or repeat the world's hardest route!) 
 Maybe he'd better go and buy himself a new bike, that's always a good way to break bits of the human body. 
 Wales 
 by Andy Newton 
 Although at the time of writing the weather has reverted to the usual Icelandic summer, there was considerable new route activity in April and May. 
 Not too much has been done in the mountains, hardly surprising given the length of time they have been dry, but Dai Lampard snatched a great ascent with Mother of Mercy E5 6a. 
 This lies on Craig Yr Ysfa, taking the groove between Amadeus and Agrippa and was climbed with N. Bonnet and C. Fletcher. 
 Rather lower down, a new crag was discovered by Niget and Dave Carson &mdash; Craig y Frank Carson &mdash; which lies parallel to, but behind, Carreg Hyll Drem. 
 The discoverers added a number of routes, the best of which seem to be Cookie Monster E7 6b, and the most popular Wagtail E3 5b. 
 Ben Pritchard added Sad Cow E7 6b, and Gwion Hughes and Ann Bierd contributed Caleb E2 5b. 
 George Smith, aided and abetted by Martin Crook, unearthed Big-Fin-Reef-Squid E5 6b on the left of Hyll Drem itself before going on to tackle the fins of rock between Primus and Burner, resulting in Of All the Bars in All the World, E6 6b; apparently every other move involves a knee-bar, but probably only if you're as tall as George &mdash; the rest of us should merely levitate. 
 Pat Littlejohn and P. Judge made Craig Y Dynewydd a little more worthy of the walk with Skyline E2 5c and End of an Era E4 6a, which disappointed a couple of ole cronies who had designs on those lines! 
 Steve Meyers claimed one of the very few good problems left at Tremadog when he found a way through the steep ground right of Erebus, providing No Holds Barred E6 6c. 
 Gogarth has also seen action from Meyers, who braved the wall right of Hunger to provide Extinction E7/8 6b &mdash; an obviously scary number. 
 Paul and Ben Pritchard fared slightly more amenably with Food, E6 6b which takes a direct line on Graduation Ceremony and was climbed with CT's Speed Feed in Holyhead in mind! 
 On North Stack Wall The Wrath of Deadly Lampshades E5 6b was a contribution to the real bad route names competition from Alistair Hopkins and George Smith. 
 The route takes cracks left of Le Bon Sauveur to surely fill the last remaining square metre of unclimbed rock on this wall. 
 Thunderbird Zawn has also been the scene of recent activity with routes from The Wraith, Steve Haston and your correspondent. 
 It seems that there is always someone around to make life difficult: sometime this spring the New Routes book was stolen from Pete's Eats. 
 This not only gives guidebook compilers a hard time but also stops new lines getting repeated while the weather's good. 
 If you wrote up a route between September 1990 and April 1991 it would be helpful if you repeated the description in the new book. 
 Information on the whereabouts of the old book would also be welcome! 
 Scotland 
 by Rick Campbell 
 He made such a fine job of the earth, the sea and the hills; He made an equally fine job of the creatures, large and small that run around on the land; He even gave us the best crags in the world&hellip; 
 So why did He make such a pig's ear of the climate? 
 Throughout this miserable summer, Scottish climbers have been forced to climb in places like Malham Cove: hardly the place to nourish the soul (and the routes are a bit hard!). 
 However, some new routes have been climbed by various intrepid amphibians. 
 On the Etive slabs Rab and Chris Anderson climbed three lines on the section of slab some 70m right of the Coffin Stone, and gave them punny names as usual. 
 They are: Seams Blanc E3 5b, Vein Rouge E1 5a and Raspberry Ripple E2 5a. 
 In Glen Nevis, Gary Latter climbed the vitrified cornflake wall up left from the George Wall. 
 The grade is E5/b 6a: a fine effort from Gary not 50 yards from where he broke his back last year! 
 It's called Carpe Diem. 
 Up above Loch Morar is the craggy hill top by the name of Sgurr Bhuide. 
 Near the summit on a steep, south-facing crag Going for the Jugular, which climbs the left-hand crack up the steep buttress on the left. 
 The grade is E5 6b and is described (by myself, oops) as being &bquo;totally brilliant&equo;. 
 The team was Rick Campbell and Gary Latter. 
 In North Queensferry Quarry, George MacIntyre led Nearly An Angel, E3 6a, having briefly inspected the line the previous year. 
 Very briefly, it has to be said: next time clip both abseil ropes, George&hellip;  
 Books 
 Ticking off the Alps and rambling with Captain Budworth 
 The Alpine 4000m peaks by the classic routes 
 by Richard Goedeke, Diadem, &pound;12.99 
 The Weisshorn, Jungfrau, Grandes Jorasses and Mont Blanc will be familiar names, but have you heard of the Parrotspitze of Vincent Pyramide? 
 They, too, top the magic 4000m mark. 
 In all there are 61 independent 4000m alpine peaks with a further 89 neighbouring peaks (peaklets) which are considered subsidiary summits. 
 The analogy with Munros and their associated Tops is obvious, and to collect either is likely to involve above average commitment and dedication over a sustained period of years, and require a broad spectrum of mountaineering skills. 
 And just as there are books on the Munros, Richard Goedeke has written a guide to their alpine equivalents, describing each peak and the easiest way up it. 
 The text follows a distinct format. 
 There is an introductory passage describing the peak and its climbing history, followed by grading, time, objective dangers and pleasures (views and historical significance). 
 A detailed description of the hut approach and the climb itself then follows, and if necessary the descent is described as well. 
 I couldn't fault the descriptions, although I did find it a little irritating to be several paragraphs into each section before the actual route of ascent was revealed. 
 I feel it would have been better to include this as a subheading to each mountain. 
 Ascents are individually described by peak, but logical linked ascents such as the Nadelgrat or the Mont Blanc-Maudit-Tacul traverse are also mentioned. 
 A simple map is provided for each peak, and there are a number of topos. 
 The book is unashamededly aimed at peak baggers, although the author does let slip the occasional tedium of a pre-defined list. 
 For example the Balmenhorn &mdash; &bquo;4000er it may be, but mountain it is not&hellip; there are a couple of dozen more prominent adjacent peaks exactly like this nunatak.&equo; 
 Or the pleasure of climbing the Ludwigshohe &bquo;Another 4000er crossed off.&equo; 
 In general, though, the book is written in a fresh style and conveys a real enthusiasm for the high alpine peaks. 
 Other worthwhile routes, both easy and difficult, are listed at the end of each chapter &mdash; which might inspire some to venture off the beaten track or on to more technically exacting ascents, although some of the gradings are a little overdone. 
 For instance, the note describing the Central Pillar of Freney is likely to tickle a few egos: &bquo;ED+, rock to VI and A3, mixed &mdash; at the end of the world and, given bad luck, delivered up to all the hells of weather.&equo; 
 Overall the book works well. 
 It's small enough to carry on the hill, but the historical introductions get together to give a good potted history of the Golden Age of Alpinism. 
 It also manages to tie the Alps together as one whole, treating them as a range of mountains rather than just a list of routes. 
 Time will tell whether collecting the alpine 4000ers will become as popular as Munro bagging, but for a real challenge, how about going for a complete set of 150 peaks and 4000m tops! 
 Simon Richardson 
 The Rock Climbing Guide to Europe 
 by David Jones, The Crowood Press, &pound;12.95 
 Let's start by saying that David Jones has done an excellent job here. 
 As with any guidebook, especially one which covers an area as large as this, you can pick out numerous faults. 
 However, since the practicality and advantages of this guide far outweigh any problems, I don't propose to mention any of its negative points. 
 Being a regular to the attractions of the Continent and its sunnier climes, I started by skimming through and picking out a few of the relatively recent crags that I have visited, such as Ceuse &amp; Oppede le Vieux: they are in &mdash; fine. 
 Then I remembered the location of a luxurious caravan a relative has near Perpignan, so I looked up the guide, and found that there are a number of crags nearby &mdash; even better. 
 So guess where one of my weeks will be spent this summer? 
 Surface only scratched and the guide has proved its worth already. 
 The introduction tells you how to decipher the crag listings which provide information such as: crag name, sun hours, number of routes (including number in the grades), province and crag number (to locate the crag on the maps which are sprinkled throughout). 
 Descriptions give a brief introduction about the climbing, rock type, size and style of route, together with the type of in situ protection. 
 There is also information on where the local topos/guides can be bought (that is assuming they are still in stock by the time you get there). 
 If camping is a problem in an area, specific sites are suggested. 
 Finally and most importantly there are simple and easy-to-follow directions on how to find each crag, including the page and cross-reference of that crag on the road atlas (a list of the road atlases used is given). 
 A lot of information has been crammed into this guide and if you intend going to the Continent, then this is one item you should definitely put on your list of things to take. 
 Rab Anderson 
 A Fortnight's Ramble to the Lakes 
 by A Rambler (Capt. J. Budworth), Preston Publishing, &pound;5.95 
 As time goes by, and our mountain activities acquire a gloss of history, there is an increasing interest in early accounts of the hills and those who ventured into them. 
 The Lake District has seen new editions of Wordsworth's and Harriet Martineau's guides, and now comes the reminiscences of Capt. Budworth, who walked the fells in 1792. 
 Budworth is particularly important because he was the first fell walker to record his ascents with the same attitude and feelings as we have today. 
 His ascent of Helvellyn is fascinating, not only because it can be followed in detail, but also because of his comment on his guide Partridge, from the Salutation Inn: 
 &bquo;Partridge, who acts as guide, as boots, postilion, and boatman, at the Salutation Inn, might have brought us down an easier descent; but as he had been out with a chaise all night, he was perhaps induced, from fatigue, to take us the nearest way. 
 We never rested five minutes that he did not fall asleep and gave us a little nasal music, and which hindered me nothing so fully as I wished to have done. 
 I think it proper to give this caution, that future ramblers may make choice of which road they please. 
 As to honest Partridge, he meant no wrong, for he is so bold a mountaineer, he can go anywhere that a sheep can; and I dare say thinks every person can do the same.&equo; 
 He died in 1815. 
 The book forms a compact paperback and is available post free from Preston Publishing, Wansbeck, Bethesda Street, Upper Basildon, Berks RG8 8NT. 
 Walt Unsworth  
 Rockgear 
 by Layne Gerrard, Ten Speed Press (imported by Airlift Book Co) &pound;12.95 
 My first thought on picking up this very substantial volume, was how on earth can information on rock gear fill so much space. 
 The answer quickly became apparent: there is an awful lot of padding. 
 Not only does the text tend to be repetitious but each item of gear if prefaced by an otherwise blank page informing us of the Key Point to be gleaned in that section, pearls of wisdom such as: &bquo;A file is useful for sharpening the edges of your&hellip; hooks. 
 You can buy a fine metal file at any hardware store&equo; or &bquo;Superglue is not healthy. 
 It contains Cyanoacrylate which is a powerful bonding chemical.&equo; 
 Sub-headings seem to take up an inordinate amount of space; do we really need separate headings for &bquo;What is Tincture of Benzoin&equo;, &bquo;How to use Tincture of Benzoin&equo;, &bquo;How to carry Tincture of Benzoin&equo;, and &bquo;Where to buy Tincture of Benzoin&equo;? 
 There are copious drawings by the author, perhaps too copious. 
 Is it necessary to use half a page to illustrate a light walking boot or a full page for a very small drawing of a three-print sit-bag? 
 And, after a while, I found the repeated use of the same illustrations from Whymper's &bquo;Scrambles in the Alps&equo; irritating. 
 Basically, the book could be condensed into half the space without losing anything of value. 
 What of the actual content? 
 Well, it is written by an American for Americans so some of the gear and some of the terminology will be unfamiliar to British climbers, but most of it is very relevant. 
 There are sensible discussions of things like bolts, falling off and full-body harnesses, interesting snippets such as wire-brushing the soles of your rock-boots occasionally or using superglue to protect your fingersss and, of course, lots of detail on gear: nine pages on pulleys, six on chalk bags, six on copperheads, four on gear slings etc, etc. 
 However, problems arise when the author describes how to actually use the gear. 
 The illustration of double ropes being used to protect a second on a traverse is incorrect; the drawing of a double-fisherman's knot is actually of a single-fisherman's; the section on rigging anchors seems very sketchy with no consideration of using the rope to equally load them, rather than slings; different types of shunt are discussed for self-protection on abseils but there is no mention of the cheap, simple prussik knot as an alternative, or the even more effective French prussik linking the controlling rope to the leg-loop of the harness. 
 And so on. 
 My main complaint about this book, however, is that it encourages us to become not so much rock climbers as consumers. 
 Although the author pays lip-service to the idea of climbing as a form of meditation and the reward lying in the process rather than the achievement, the main thrust seems to lie in the opposite direction, in the acquisition of things. 
 There is little here about improvising or making do. 
 Instead, preceding even the title page is the injunction &bquo;Immediately after buying this book, send off for the eight mail order catalogues listed on p.357&equo;. 
 Sensible advice, really, but its positioning in the book says everything. 
 The means are becoming as important as the ends. 
 Although there is much good stuff here and I shall undoubtedly find it a useful reference, on putting it down my chief desire was to out and solo something barefoot! 
 Rob Callister 
 Nepal: The Mountains of Heaven 
 by David Paterson, Hamish Hamilton, &pound;30.00 
 By a remarkable coincidence this book arrived on my desk for review a matter of weeks after I had first seen it and browsed through it in a bookshop in Kathmandu. 
 I chose not to buy it that day, so I was interested to see whether a longer look at it would change those initial impressions. 
 This work is described as a personal celebration of the mountains and landscapes of Nepal, but it turns out to be a pictorial account of six treks and climbs in the more popular areas of the country. 
 Fortunately David Peterson's obvious talent and self-confessed passion for the country have enabled him to present a balanced and interesting collection of images. 
 The high peaks, the glaciers, the lowland valleys, the paddy fields, the people, the culture and the colour have all been captured to equal perfection. 
 To his credit he has avoided giving us familiar images of Everest, Machhapuchhare and the like, and instead has chosen to be more creative in his choice of viewpoints, angles and lighting. 
 Some shots, particularly the front and rear covers of the book, are quite stunning. 
 But others are less impressive and I wonder how and why they made it through to the final selection. 
 The chapter on Annapurna contains several images which I felt were well below the overall standard. 
 Perhaps they have lost something in the printing, but the reader will never know. 
 If you are looking for a picture book on Nepal for a present or a memento of a trip then this is certainly as good as, if not better than, many of its rivals. 
 But my opinion of the book is much the same now as it was that day in Kathmandu. 
 No matter how well intentioned an author may be, no matter how good his work is considered, a lavish photographic book of this kind, and of this price, must stand or fall on the sheer quality of the pictures selected and the way in which they are presented. 
 Frankly there just isn't enough original or really exceptional material to tempt me to part with thirty pounds of my hard-earned cash. 
 Ian Evans 
 Walking the Great Views 
 by Roland Smith, David and Charles, &pound;16.99 
 When this book crashed through my letterbox recently and I read the title my heart sank. 
 Not another &bquo;Great Walks&equo; book. 
 Then I reread the title: &bquo;Walking the Great Views&equo;. 
 Could that mean a great view, but not necessarily a great approach walk? 
 My concerns were unfounded because Roland Smith has managed to select walks over 60 of some of Britain's finest hill and high places which offer excellent viewpoints ranging from Quiraing on Skye to the Dorset Coast. 
 The outings are grouped under such unusual headings as &bquo;Folklore and Legend&equo;, &bquo;Monarchs of all they Surveyed&equo;, &bquo;Monumental Viewpoints&equo; and &bquo;Literary Landscapes&equo;. 
 Not surprisingly the choice of &bquo;Great Views&equo; is a very personal one and many favourites are missing, including my own cherished ones of the Cuillins from Elgol or the summit of Sgurr na Stri at the entrance to Loch Coruisk, or Rannoch Moor seen from Buachaille Etive Mor at the head of Glen Coe. 
 In fact only a few of Scotland's great views are included but many well known ones elsewhere are covered such as Cat Bells and Snowdon, plus a few less familiar ones such as Mow Cop on the edge of the Cheshire Hills and Bennachie in Aberdeenshire. 
 The various viewpoints and their approach walks are entertainingly described in the author's competent, easy to read style and contain anecdotes, useful information about the legends, history and geology of the area along with other fascinating disclosures. 
 The lengths of the outings varies from a gentle stroll to long mountain days, details of which are shown on maps in the now familiar pen and ink style of Mark Richards. 
 The inclusion of John Cleare's name on the book cover usually guarantees quality photographs, and the colour and atmospheric black and white images were no disappointment. 
 Let's face it, it's usually good photographs that attract walkers to a specific place and often convey far more than words can. 
 After seeing the picture of Scafell Massif taken in evening sunshine from the summit of Yewbarrow, I couldn't help wishing I'd been there. 
 Roland Smith has provided us with a fascinating and interesting book that should whet the appetite of many hill walkers and will certainly provide a wealth of useful background information when planning a walk to some of the &bquo;Great Viewpoints&equo; of Britain. 
 Highly recommended. 
  Jerry Rawson   
 Mail 
 A season ticket that does climbers no favours 
 In your May issue you carried a letter from two climbers from Tunbridge Wells who announced that they had negotiated a season ticket agreement for users of High Rocks. 
 This has not been publicised elsewhere to date, and that is the one redeeming feature of this otherwise unwelcome and ill-considered arrangement. 
 The BMC and the London and SE Area Committee wish to dissociate themselves completely from this scheme, and recommend that would-be visitors to High Rocks do so too. 
 We are implacably opposed to the concept of payment to climb. 
 There are, however, two longstanding situations on Southern Sandstone where payment of an admission fee has been customary for many years. 
 High Rocks is one of these. 
 The other site has showed a commendably restrained policy in its charge levels for many years, and has been rewarded by a regular and large climbing clientele. 
 Not so High Rocks, whose owners have steadily raised their admission charges in the last few years, threatened climbers with access restrictions, and put nothing at all back into the maintenance of the rocks, save to enclose them in a sturdy, reinforced fence. 
 The entry charge now stands at &pound;3 per climber, with threats to confiscate the equipment of climbers not paying. 
 No convincing answer has been given as to why picnickers only pay &pound;2. 
 Efforts over a prolonged period by the BMC and the Sandstone Climbing Club have failed to win reductions in the excessive charges here, but these efforts will continue. 
 The season ticket agreement John Horscroft and Pat Shilland hope climbers will avidly welcome ever more firmly establishes that climbers should be asked to pay for their climbing. 
 To the casual or occasional visitor to High Rocks, the season ticket agreement may seem irrelevant at the moment &mdash; just something to please climbers living nearby who go there regularly. 
 But given the discrimination shown against climbers in the present price structure, how long might it be before you climb at High Rocks by season ticket, or prior arrangement and private fee only? 
 No, this arrangement does climbers no favours. 
 Given the delicate access positions at other sandstone crags it is an inept and unhelpful piece of privateering. 
 It will serve only to complicate further an already very difficult situation. 
 There are no easy answers at High Rocks, but privately negotiated fee deals can only serve to make the right solution even harder to find. 
  Tom Phillips, Chairman, BMC London and SE Area.  
 Holiday camps or bothies? 
 Over the last five years the bothies have become something of an open invitation for exploitation. 
 They are now regularly used by groups of people involved in Outward Bound activities and school parties. 
 Visiting certain bothies in the Affric and Dundonnel areas during 1989, I was amazed to find things regulated by a dinner gong! 
 On Skye during the summer of 1990, I visited a bothy not far from the Cuillins to find certain people staying two weeks (fishing), one week (canoeing) and no room at the inn for overnighters. 
 This year I have come across a group using a bothy as a base from which to run mountain walking courses. 
 Reading their literature, it would appear that their charges include accommodation. 
 Making money out of the use of bothies! 
 The MBA do a superlative job maintaining these simple buildings, and set out a clear set of guidelines for their useage. 
 Something has obviously got to be done to make sure that these simple shelters, which are there to offer overnight shelter for anyone in need of it, are not used for holiday centres and the like. 
 It would also appear that many of the people who abuse the code of these shelters are not members of the MBA, so contribute nothing to their maintenance. 
 If the current trend continues, the landowners to whom the bothies belong, could decide that enough is enough and withdraw their permission for usage. 
  Mike Wilson-Roberts, Christchurch, Dorset.  
 Two fine hills, but they are not Corbetts 
 While I agree heartily with Cameron McNeish's praise of the Scottish Mountaineering Club volume &bquo;The Corbetts&equo; (May issue, p.58), I feel constrained to point out that Stac Pollaidh and Suilven are not Corbetts, as he records. 
 As Cameron recounts, they are both fine hills, but both are considerably below 2,500ft, the Stac especially so. 
  James Petre, Oakley, Bedfordshire.  
 One top too many is against tradition 
 The article &bquo;Snowdon the Hard Way&equo; by Jerry Rawson (June 1991) revived many pleasant memories of long days spent over 40 years ago in the mountains of Snowdonia. 
 This was in a period when I was based at Llandudno and every available minute of spare time was spent in climbing and scrambling among those delightful hills. 
 We scaled the 3000'ers many times individually but never completed the walk which incorporated them all, although two unsuccessful attempts were made. 
 On the first occasion, when a clear moonlight night was forecast, the most atrocious storm developed and we were forced to spend an uncomfortable few hours benighted near the summit of Elidir Fawr. 
 On the second occasion we were overcome by severe stomach pains (a touch of food poisoning, I guess), which caused us to abandon the attempt, again on Elidir Fawr &mdash; obviously our jinx mountain. 
 I notice that Jerry refers to the &bquo;15 3000 feet tops&equo;. 
 We always understood there to be 14 and in his book &bquo;I Bought A Mountain&equo;, Thomas Firbank defines the walk as covering &bquo;the fourteen peaks in Wales which exceed three thousand feet in height. 
 It seems that Carnedd Uchaf has crept into the list, but is this not subsidiary summit of Foel Gras rather than a 3000'er in its own right? 
 A small point to raise maybe, but as a sentimental traditionalist I feel we should stick to the original figure of 14 as adopted by those early pioneers. 
  Colin Cowman, Grange Over Sands, Cumbria   
 Selling off Lakeland's climbing soul for bolts 
 An open letter to the climbers who recently placed a bolt on Raven Crag, Langdale. 
 Dear Lads, 
 I wish to congratulate you on exposing the hypocrisy of the Lakeland climbing scene. 
 At last someone has had the nerve to bring the area in line with the rest of British climbing: no longer will it be a quiet backwater resigned to a few lines in the climbing press about some brilliant new VDiff on a puny little crag in the back of beyond. 
 Now the area will be seen for what it has to offer: superb technical lines of good rock and ace protection. 
 In the 70s the efforts of the locals were eclipsed by the activities in North Wales and the Peak. 
 We didn't shout loud enough; those who came left impressed, but kept quiet in order to preserve their own reputations. 
 After all, if you're a superstar, it's no good admitting that you found a route given three grades easier than your latest creation anything but a path! 
 In the 80s we fell even further behind. 
 Micro-routes in the Duddon are no match, after all, for a route on any of the limestone crags in Yorkshire or Derbyshire. 
 As for Scafell, well, how often can you climb there? 
 How often have  you climbed there? 
 I've forgotten when I was last there. 
 Get my drift? 
 Why get all worked up about a crag that is unclimable for most of the time? 
 The young lads have the right idea. 
 Get to where the action is and hang in there; sod Scafell, those routes can wait until later. 
 Climbing has no rules, as the Old Guard are proud of telling us, so what's wrong with what you've done? 
 Nothing, no rules! 
 So the Old Guard have got upset &mdash; well sod 'em eh? 
 After all, they've had their say years ago and made a meal of it: undeclared top-roping, hold chipping, secret rests, etc. 
 Now it's your turn. 
 No underhand tactics as then, everything out in the open, everyone operating to the same rules. 
 The new rules. 
 Where to next? 
 Let the dust settle then go for broke &mdash; by the time anyone realises what's going on it will be too late and everyone can have a good time and relax. 
 The dinosaurs can have Scafell until they die out, then if anyone can still be bothered to walk (!) up there, I'm sure a line or two of bolts wouldn't go amiss. 
 In the end I suppose you'll get everything, which is what you wanted all along really but haven't dared to say it. 
 Though what you'll actually get is nothing. 
 No past, no future, no hope. 
 Just thought you ought to know before you sell your soul; you can't get it back. 
  Bob Wightman, Llanberis, Gwynedd.  
 * See our Lakes Report in this issue for the definitive story on the Raven Crag bolt placement. 
 Stares, whispers and the route to colour prejudice 
 I have noticed recently that in the climbing world some consideration is being given to the lack of participation by black people. 
 I have certainly been party to one or two discussions amongst friends, and as part of my work I take groups of young people away on climbing trips, most to very white-dominated areas where the mere appearance of a black face in a pub or at a crag is enough to cause stares and whispers. 
 This has resulted in discussions about the occurrence and effects of racism. 
 Well this is all very admirable, you might say, and isn't the climbing world just as helpful and welcoming to one newcomer as the next? 
 In answer I would draw your attention to the report from the Lakes in your April issue, where incidental mention is given to a climb named &bquo;Blind Nigger&equo;. 
 Might I suggest to whoever has the power &mdash; the first ascentionist, the local guidebook compilers, that this and any other racist names are changed. 
 After all, I'm sure a climb title which includes obcenities would not be accepted by a guidebook. 
 To me and, I'm sure, to many others, the title above is far more offensive. 
  Susan Williams, London.  
 Range West is in the best hands 
 Although agreeing in principle with the views expressed by Jim Perrin in his article &bquo;Range War&equo; (May issue), I feel I must take issue with one or two of his conclusions, which I think require further examination. 
 Opening an area such as this to the public means just that, and together with genuine walkers and climbers arrive the wild flower pickers, the egg stealers and the litter louts. 
 And despite the Ramblers' Association suggestion of management etc, we have not made too good a job of protecting other wilderness areas open to the public. 
 Secondly, it appears that the military do not use Range West much. 
 This statement can defend both sides of the argument. 
 1) 
 Therefore, why can't the public have access. 
 2) 
 If the military don't use the area often, they cannot cause as much distress to the natural environment as opening it to the public would. 
 Lastly, I think Jim Perrin is being more than generous to suggest that climbers and walkers have an exemplary record in observing agreements and their respect for the environment. 
 One has only to read recent editions of Climber and Hill Walker  to see evidence of atrocious behaviour by climbers and walkers: abuse, noise, breaking down fences, fouling areas with litter and excrement and climbing in areas when specifically requested to desist for good safety reasons &mdash; at Cheddar and Upper Pentrwyn. 
 The mindless few maybe, but what happens when these people have access to areas like Range West? 
 Another gate closed for ever, another genuine unspoilt area ruined. 
 Maybe it's best left in military hands until we have a generation of truly environmentally friendly humans. 
 P.S. I have no military connections. 
  David Beere, Finchfield, Wolverhampton.   
 Zero credibility 
 Peter Livesey 
 One of the problems with not getting killed climbing while still young is that you reach such a great age that your standard falls mercilessly, and it is only possible to relive great exploits by reading about yourself in guidebooks. 
 I was practising this the other day, in preparation for the time when my climbing standard drops slightly, and was surprised to read some interesting facts about myself. 
 Did you know, for instance, that I led Birdman on Kilnsey Crag, or that I spent several days top-roping and practising Zero on Idwal's Suicide Wall? 
 Now, while I'm quite happy to take the credit for Birdman I'm not sure that Ron Fawcett feels the same way, but what really bugs me is Zero. 
 That route I always consider one of the best and most adventurous of my climbing career; most adventurous because this very serious route (even by today's standards &mdash; or perhaps especially by today's standards) was first attempted on sight. 
 A precarious failure at 50 feet was followed immediately by an abseil inspection, then a week later by the ascent itself. 
 That was a total of two visits to the crag, some 3 hours in all. 
 Where the printed story came from I don't know, but basically it was made up somewhere along the line; a fairy story. 
 Those fairy stories prompted me to read a couple of the latest guidebooks, one Welsh and one from the Lake District, plus a recent history of Lakeland rock climbing. 
 In each case the accuracy rate concerning events of which I had first-hand knowledge was about 50%; half the information correct, half wrong. 
 I have to assume therefore that the rest is equally bad and that little of what we read in guidebooks as climbing history should be taken seriously. 
 I'm not the only one to notice this; Geoff Birtles has related his own experiences with fairy-story history in the recent Gogarth guide. 
 More serious perhaps was Paul Ross and his brush with the FRCC guidebook writers. 
 Ross, on his return to Britain, went back into the new route business as an outsider to the establishment scene &mdash; a position I know only too well. 
 On one Borrowdale route, Deja Vu, he left a long sling dangling down to aid an injured second. 
 A chance observer saw the sling being used by the second and soon the rumour was circulating that Paul Ross had used &bquo;dubious tactics&equo; on Prodigal Sons (a later companion route to Deja Vu). 
 Some time later that same rumour appeared as historical fact in Ron Kenyon's Borrowdale Guidebook. 
 That the wrong route was cited is bad enough, but the inclusion of unchecked rumour is inexcusable, and unfortunately turns error into fact. 
 No matter how much Ross protests in magazines, they are only transitory statements, while the guide is a permanent tablet of stone where history, now made, is reprinted wholesale in the next edition. 
 Ross's experience struck an identical chord with me, for John Sheard and I had exactly the same experience on the first ascent of Face Route where the second, hanging on a sling to remove gear, was observed by a member of the establishment and a rumour immediately started that was rapidly translated into guidebook writer's &bquo;fact&equo;. 
 Ross explains the process precisely in pointing out that most guidebook history is written from the editor's perspective, and he believes what he wants to believe. 
 This means in practical terms that friends and club are OK, and are to be believed, while &bquo;outsiders&equo; of all kinds are not, nor are they worth contacting to check information. 
 The history of Lakeland climbing is therefore the history, according to the FRCC, of the guide editor's climbing friends, and similarly in Wales, history is the CC perspective of what went on. 
 Nor is the distortion of fact or the deification of rumour the only problem; there is also the considerable problem of the temporal nature of commenting on climbing style. 
 What could legitimately be described as &bquo;dubious tactics&equo; on Malham Cove in the early 70s would have been regarded as quite normal in the early 60s and would be considered style of pathological purity in the 90s. 
 A typical example is the 1978 Tremadoc Guidebook comment after the first ascent of Fingerlicker in 1975, where alone in that guide it was pointed out that the route had only been climbed after two &bquo;Yo-Yo's&equo; (according to the 1975 definition of a Yo-Yo). 
 The 1975 definition was an exceptionally pure version that had not been current previously and only lasted a year or two. 
 Once the definition has changed (and that was before publication of the guide) then the criticism of the style of ascent could have been dropped, but of course it was not, and can still be seen amidst ascents where the rock is scarcely touched. 
 This is not a plea for historical recorders to get their act together and check facts first-hand &mdash; I think the forces of establishment and vested interest are too strong for that to work, and anyway it wouldn't solve all the problems. 
 No, forget the history in guidebooks completely, leave history to the writers of climbing epics where no one cares if the facts are bent to make a good story &mdash; or do they? 
 THE PRACTICAL HOME IMPROVEMENT MAGAZINE SEPTEMBER 1991 &pound;1.40 DIY DO IT YOURSELF POWER TESTS CERAMICS FOR WALLS &amp; FLOORS SPECIAL JOBS SECTION BRIGHT IDEAS Decorating &pound;5,000 GUINNESS HOLIDAY COMPETITION &pound;2,500 MAKITA POWER TOOLS TO BE WON  
 CONTENTS 
 4 UPDATE 
 What's making the news in home improvements. 
 More on 34, 41, 54 
 5 WOODFINISHING 
 We help you choose the best materials for the precise finish you want. 
 14 LIGHTING 
 You choose lighting for mood and activity &mdash; here's a complete house guide 
 21 JOBBING NOTEBOOK 
 This month you can find out how to: 
 Fix kitchen door fronts 
 Produce a limed wood finish 
 Repoint brickwork 
 Fit a fire surround 
 Lay a slab path 
 Plumb-in a bath 
 Stencil on varnish 
 Lay a workshop base 
 Roof a conservatory 
 Fix fence posts 
 35 CERAMIC TILES 
 What to use on walls, floors and worksurfaces 
 43 TOOL TESTS 
 This month we look at a 
 Rotary hammer drill 
 Orbital sander 
 All-purpose saw 
 Disc grinder 
 47 LETTERS 
 Share ideas, opinions, and hints with other readers &mdash; and there's a prize for this month's star letter 
 48 SPECIAL OFFERS 
 Wall chaser, bench sander, non-return valve, RCD adaptor 
 50 NEXT MONTH 
 Find out what's in your next DIY &mdash; including a fabulous free gift 
 51 &pound;2,500 COMPETITION 
 Win a compendium of Makita power tools 
 52 GARDENWISE 
 This month we look at gardens which have a rustic appeal 
 57 &pound;5,000 COMPETITION 
 Another chance to win a fabulous Caribbean holiday with Guinness Original 
 ADVICE CENTRE 
 58 FIDOR 
 How the Fibre Building Board Organisation can help you 
 59 EXTERIOR PAINTS 
 What to use on rendered or pebbledashed walls 
 60 GARDENING 
 Creative lighting, bird protection, containers, bulbs and safety 
 63 PATIO DOORS 
 If you are in the market for new doors, read this first 
 64 FINANCIAL AND REGULATIONS 
 Insurance, debit cards and building notices are discussed 
 65 PROBLEMS 
 Our experts answer another batch of your questions 
 70 BUILDER'S DIARY 
 Our professional casts his eye over burglar alarms 
 NEWS UPdate 
 HALF-PRICE TICKETS FOR SELF BUILD HOMES SHOW 
 The second Self Build Homes Show is being held in the Great Hall at Alexandra Palace, from 18 to 22 September. 
 It will be at least three times larger than the first show, held last year, and will represent every area of self build, from finance to land plots, as well as house design &bquo;packages&equo; and most related building and interior products. 
 One of the major features is a timber-framed house which will be under construction throughout the show, allowing visitors to see the various elements and skills involved. 
 A free seminar programme entitled A step by step guide to building your own home  will also run hourly throughout the show. 
 And to keep the children amused, a Lego competition will be held in the creche, so that junior selfbuilders can also build their own houses, and perhaps win some Lego, too. 
 Tickets are &pound;5, or &pound;2.50 for senior citizens or children between 5 and 16. 
 But anyone booking in advance can get their tickets half-price. 
 The telephone hotline is 081 547 2080. 
 HIGH GLOSS LACQUER NOW IN AEROSOL FORM 
 International Paint's well-established Jet-Dry Japlac now also comes in a handy aerosol to complement the existing range of standard cans, available in 750ml, 500ml, 250ml, and 125ml sizes, and to facilitate application in awkward areas, or where speed and convenience are prime considerations. 
 Japlac is a high gloss lacquer which produces a mirror-like finish that leaves ordinary paints looking lacklustre in comparison. 
 Its hard, shiny finish means it not only looks smart, but withstands knocks, bumps and scrapes. 
 It is easy to apply and can be used on wood or metal, inside or out, and its quick-drying formulation means it is touch-dry in two hours and ready for over-coating in six. 
 Japlac complies with BS 5665 Part 3 1989 and the European Toy Safety Standard EN71 Part 3 1988, enabling you to give an exceptionally glossy finish to toys, nursery furniture, climbing frames, and indeed any surface where the safety of a child is of tantamount importance. 
 The 300ml aerosol dispenser is ozone-friendly and CFC free. 
 It is available in five attractive colours &mdash; Jet Black, Arctic White, Signal Red, Gold, Silver &mdash; and Clear. 
 It costs &pound;4.99 from good d-i-y stores.  
 DOUBLE OR TRIPLE GLAZED READY-TO-FIT REPLACEMENT WINDOWS 
 Fitting replacement windows is not necessarily a job for a professional builder. 
 Swedhouse &bquo;instant&equo; windows are supplied ready for installation by the more accomplished d-i-yer. 
 They are made to measure and supplied pre-glazed &mdash; double or triple &mdash; with all the fittings and screws in place ready for immediate, trouble-free installation (as long as measuring up has been done carefully, and the hole for the window is square). 
 The frames are made from Swedish redwood timber which comes from regularly replanted forests, and they are engineered to keep the warmth in and the cold out. 
 The new windows are wedged in the window opening, fixed to the sides of the opening with frame fixers, and the gap between the window frame and the wall is sealed with nonabsorbent flexible sealant.  
 MODULAR ALUMINIUM TOWER IS ANSWER TO ACCESS PROBLEMS 
 The 6&times;2ft Modular Aluminium Tower launched by Youngman's could be the all-in-one answer to household access problems. 
 The simple to erect system is designed for d-i-y and light trade use, and consists of three main packs; a Base pack (&pound;132), Platform pack (&pound;108), and Extender pack (&pound;135). 
 Different combinations of the packs provide a range of heights from 12ft (3.6m) to 24ft (7.2m). 
 all braces are fitted with locking claws, and the hinged working platform is made of non-slip Combiboard for additional safety. 
 The tower can be used indoors and out, and the lightweight system can be transported on a car roof rack, and is also easy to store. 
 Adaptable for staircase use, the tower includes adjustable base plates.   
 WOODCARE Finished to perfection 
 Staining or bleaching, varnishing or waxing&hellip; choosing and using the most suitable finish is the secret of good wood care. 
 It may seem strange to start by describing the best method of removing old finishes, but there is probably more work done on renovating old furniture and existing woodwork than on new wood. 
 OFF WITH THE OLD 
 Old finishes  can be removed with a blow-lamp, hot air stripper, by sanding or with a solvent paint and the varnish remover. 
 However, all but the last method can damage the wood, which is not important if the wood is to be painted, as this will obliterate any damage. 
 The best method of removing old finishes from wood that is to be re-finished with a transparent or semitransparent coating, is with a solvent paint and varnish remover. 
 There are several types available; those containing methylene chloride are quick acting and are usually free from caustic or acid and will not harm the wood. 
 The surface should then be damped again with the paint remover and the wood rubbed with the grain with small pieces of grade 2 or 3 steel wool, wiping afterwards with rag and white spirit.  
 The solvent type paint removers do not normally raise the grain and it is not necessary to sand after stripping. 
 This is important, as many woods, particularly mahogany, acquire a beautiful patina on ageing, which is immediately destroyed by even the lightest sanding. 
 STARTING FROM SCRATCH 
 All the processes that follow apply to wood that has been stripped and to articles made with new wood. 
 Bleaching : is a process that may be necessary, either to remove stains caused by weathering, ink or water, or if the article that is to be finished is required in a lighter shade. 
 Wood can always be stained to a darker shade than its present state, but cannot be lightened other than by bleaching. 
 Wood can be lightened with oxalic acid, but as it is a poison it would be better to use a proprietary two part bleach. 
 Bleach will only work on bare timber, so any existing finish must be removed first. 
 The &bquo;A&equo; or No. 1 solution is then applied liberally and after about 10 minutes the second solution is applied. 
 Do not worry that the first solution will actually make the wood darker. 
 It is applied to turn the wood into an alkaline condition, so that when the &bquo;B&equo; or No. 2 solution is applied, it will liberate oxygen, thus bleaching the wood. 
 The second solution can be left for several hours, or overnight, when the wood should then be scrubbed with clean water to which a little acetic acid has been added. 
 If the wood is very badly stained, it may require two applications of bleach. 
 If the  wood has been bleached because a light coloured timber is required, then a very pale finish must be applied to prevent darkening the surface. 
 Suitable finishes are transparent or white French polish, a cold cure lacquer or an acrylic varnish. 
 Wood dye : if the colour of wood is to be changed, then probably the most dramatic effect is obtained when the bare wood is coloured with a penetrating wood dye. 
 At one time the word &bquo;dye&equo; was used for exotic colours, such as reds, blues etc, and the word &bquo;stain&equo; was used when colouring woods to natural wood shades. 
 A true dye or stain does not leave anything on the surface that will obscure the grain, unlike a paint which is made by grinding pigments into a binding medium and, because they are opaque, will leave the wood a uniform colour. 
 In recent years the situation has become confused, because there are now exterior wood stains available, which differ from a true dye or stain, as they leave a coloured film on the surface of the wood and do not require another finish to be applied over them. 
 When wood is coloured with a penetrating dye and then sealed with a transparent finish, there is no change in colour, other than after the first coat of finish has been applied, whereas with an exterior type of wood stain, each extra coat will make the surface deeper in colour. 
 Until a few years ago most wood dyes tended to fade in strong sunlight, but now many of them contain transparent iron oxides, which do not fade and can be used on interior and exterior woodwork. 
 Wood dyes are best applied with a cloth, because if applied with a brush, there will be dark areas where the brush first touches the wood. 
 It is important that if wood is being dyed, areas round joints are completely free from any glue, as this will prevent the dye penetrating and will leave a lightercoloured patch. 
 Some woods, such as mahogany and teak, darken considerably even when a completely clear finish is applied and before dyeing wood. 
 It is always advisable to try a small area first with the finish that is to be used, or damp a small area with water, as this will give some indication of the change in shade that will occur. 
 There are a wide range of finishes which can be used after the preparation process is complete. 
 Which one to use depends, to some extent, upon the appearance which you wish to achieve, which may be an oiled or waxed appearance, a high gloss, satin or matt finish, and on what is being finished. 
 Floors, for instance, require finishes that are hard, water resistant, but at the same time flexible, so that the surface is not brittle and will not crack when objects are moved across the surface. 
 Furniture requires finishes that can be made perfectly smooth to the touch and  that can be brought to a mirror-like gloss, if required. 
 Some finishes can be used for all purposes.  
 Beeswax : is one of the oldest types of finish, although most modern waxes now contain other waxes, such as Carnauba or micro-crystalline waxes, to improve the performance. 
 Paste waxes are best when applied to bare wood, while liquid waxes are suitable for use on furniture that has been French polished or lacquered. 
 Any type of wood can be waxed, although it is usually applied to pine or oak. 
 Before waxing, the wood should be sealed with shellac sanding sealer or white or transparent French polish, as these will prevent the wax soaking into the wood and will enable a shine to be obtained with much less effort. 
 Waxing is a very laborious process and the wood will require re-waxing at regular intervals. 
 Oil : is probably the easiest way of finishing wood. 
 Linseed and boiled linseed oil are the traditional types but both are slow drying; linseed oil takes approximately 3 days and boiled oil 24 hours. 
 Modern oils, such as teak and Danish oils, dry in 4&ndash;6 hours and usually contain tung oil, which has far better water resistance and durability than linseed oil. 
 Teak oils leave the wood with a slight sheen; Danish oil with a natural low lustre. 
 All oils can be applied with a brush or with a cloth, the surplus being wiped off with clean rag or paper kitchen towel. 
 It is important that the rags or paper kitchen towel are not left crumpled up after use, as they can catch fire, due to spontaneous combustion.  
 They should be either burnt or laid out flat to dry, or kept in an airtight tin. 
 It is advisable to apply three coats of oil to new wood, and as oiling does not leave a thick protective film on the surface (as does a varnish), exterior wood has to be re-oiled at least once a year to keep the surface in good condition. 
 Varnishes : are probably the most commonly used finishing materials. 
 A varnish is a transparent coating based on drying oils, resins and solvents. 
 There is now a growing trend towards the manufacture of environmental friendly finishes which are solvent-free, and acrylic varnishes are being produced by many manufacturers. 
 Traditional varnishes dry by evaporation of the solvents and then by oxidisation and polymerisation of the oils and resins. 
 Acrylic varnishes are emulsions of dispersed acrylic resin, coalescing agents and water. 
 They are milky-white whilst liquid, but when dry are completely clear and transparent. 
 As the water evaporates, the coalescing agents cause the acrylic dispersion to fuse and form the surface coating. 
 They are very quick drying, with a low odour, and have the advantage that the brushes can be cleaned with water. 
 Because they contain water, they must be stored in conditions where the temperature will not drop below 5&deg;C, and must not be applied in cold, damp conditions, or when there is high humidity. 
 As they are fast drying, usually about 30 minutes, the application technique is slightly different from the traditional varnishes. 
 They should not be &bquo;brushed out&equo; in the same manner, but applied fairly liberally across the grain and then the brush should be drawn lightly along the surface with the grain. 
 As they contain water, the first application may cause the grain to raise on some woods, and a light sanding is recommended before applying the second coat. 
 Some manufacturers recommend a light sanding between the second and third coats and it is important, as with all types of products mentioned, that the instructions are read carefully before use. 
 Although acrylic varnishes are dry in about 30 minutes, they continue to harden over a period of 24&ndash;48 hours, but here again this time may vary between different makes. 
 Acrylic varnishes have good resistance to heat and alcohol, but are not resistant to strong solvents. 
 Gloss acrylic varnishes are available, but the gloss is not as high as that obtained with a polyurethane or oil varnish. 
 Varnish stains : as well as using dyes, wood can also be coloured using varnish stains. 
 These are clear varnishes to which either dyestuffs or transparent pigments, or both, have been added. 
 Unlike wood dyes, varnish stains can be applied to previously coated surfaces, as long as they are clean and free from wax or grease. 
 As a varnish stain colours and finishes in one operation, they are very popular, but it should be noted that because the colour is in the finish, each extra coat will make the surface darker, and if the varnish stain is not applied evenly, where the film is thicker, the colour will be darker. 
 If the desired shade is obtained with one coat of varnish stain, then further protection should be given with extra coats of clear gloss, satin or matt varnish. 
 French polish : furniture usually requires a finish of higher quality and appearance than one applied to, for instance, doors or wall cladding. 
 The traditional finish is French polish, which is so-called because it was invented by a French cabinet maker in about 1825. 
 French polish is a solution of shellac dissolved in alcohol, which is applied with a &bquo;rubber&equo; made by wrapping a piece of cotton wool in cotton or linen rag. 
 French polish is usually a dark brown colour, but as a collective noun it includes button, white, transparent and garnet polishes, which are made with various types of shellac. 
 Button polish is usually a more orange colour than French, and garnet is darker. 
 White French polish is milky-white and is used on bleached wood and marquetry, and in all cases where it is desired to keep the wood as light as possible. 
 French polishing requires a higher degree of skill than any other method of wood finishing, and there is no doubt that when done properly it gives a very lovely appearance to furniture. 
 However, it is easily marked by heat, solvents and scratching and if starting with bare wood, it would be better to use a cold cure lacquer. 
 Cold cure lacquers : are usually based on urea formaldehyde and melamine and &bquo;cure&equo; after mixing with a hardener. 
 Once mixed, the shelf life in an open container is about 3 days, but this can be extended if the container is sealed after mixing, and kept in a cool place. 
 Unlike French polish, cold cure lacquers can be applied liberally and it is not necessary to use a good quality brush. 
 Three coats are usually sufficient if a high gloss finish is required. 
 The last coat is rubbed down with wet and dry paper and brought to a high gloss with a burnishing cream. 
 Alternatively, the surface can be rubbed with grade 00 or 000 steel wool and wax polish to produce a smooth satin or matt finish. 
 When dry the surface is resistant to heat, solvents and abrasion. 
 APPLICATION 
 Traditional varnishes should always be applied in a warm, dry atmosphere and, when used inside, in a well-ventilated area. 
 It is also important that the areas where the varnish is being applied are dust-free and that you are not wearing clothes which will shed dust or fibres on to the surface. 
 Clear gloss varnishes should not be stirred or shaken before use, as this would cause air bubbles to form which would might spoil the appearance of the varnish. 
 The non-drip thixotropic varnishes should also not be stirred, as this would destroy the gel structure. 
 Satin and matt varnishes and varnish stains must,  however, be thoroughly stirred before use until there is no more sediment on the bottom of the container. 
 THis is because they contain special matting agents, which cause the varnishes to dry with an irregular surface, so that light is reflected at random angles. 
 If these matting agents are not thoroughly dispersed before application, then the varnishes or varnish stains will dry to a gloss. 
 Varnishes can be used direct from the container if the diameter is large enough for the brush being used, but it is better to pour the varnish into a paint kettle which has a wire stretched across the middle, so that excess varnish can be scraped off on the wire. 
 Use a good quality paint or varnish brush, and the size should be suitable for the surface being coated. 
 If varnishing a door, it is better to use a 2&frac12; or 3in brush, rather than 1 or 1&frac12;in. 
 If varnishing a floor, use a 6in brush or even a roller. 
 When using a new brush, try to remove all loose bristles by opening them with your fingers and thumbs, pulling out any loose bristles which may appear. 
 The brush should be suspended in linseed oil, so that the bristles are in the oil, but not touching the bottom of the container, as this would distort the bristles. 
 Leave the brush in the oil for several hours, or longer, and then remove it and squeeze out the oil and work the brush backwards and forwards over plain brown paper or the side of a clean carton. 
 Wash in white spirit or a proprietary brush cleaner. 
 Straighten the bristles after cleaning and wrap with clean plain paper, so that the bristles maintain their shape, and then lay it on its side until it is required for use. 
 A good varnish brush is expensive &mdash; a 2in brush can cost as much as &pound;10, but when used correctly and cleaned properly after use, it will last for many years and produce excellent results. 
 BRUSH STROKES 
 When applying a varnish, the brush should be dipped into it for about one-third of the length of the bristles and then, holding the brush in a similar way to a pencil, with the fingers holding the metal ferrule and the handle resting between the thumb and first finger, spread the varnish quickly and evenly over a small area. 
 The first coat should be applied across the grain and then with the grain, to make sure that the surface has been covered completely. 
 Repeat the process on an adjacent area, drawing the full brush towards the previously coated area. 
 Use light even strokes so as not to cause bubbles to form in the film. 
 The first coat of varnish applied to new wood can be thinned with approximately 10% of white spirit. 
 When the first coat is dry, lightly sand with fine glasspaper or wet and dry paper to remove any nibs or particles of dust which may have settled on the surface. 
 Further coats of varnish should be applied undiluted and with care to avoid runs and an uneven surface. 
 Apply the second and subsequent coats, initially with the grain, with even backward and forward strokes, then with slightly less pressure across the grain, and finally with the grain again, drawing the tips of the bristles very lightly across the surface. 
 This procedure should ensure that no brush marks are left to mar the appearance. 
 If, despite the precautions to remove loose bristles, one does drag on to the varnish, remove it using the corner tip of the brush, or with a toothpick or cocktail stick. 
 EXTERIOR WOODWORK 
 The choice of finishes for exterior woodwork is not as great as that for interior woodwork. 
 Exterior wood stains, which can be solvent or water based, tend to mask the grain of the wood, but have good resistance to ultra-violet light and do not fail by peeling or flaking. 
 Some exterior finishes are microporous which, it is claimed, allows the wood to breathe. 
 Other manufacturers prefer to use flexible alkyds, as it is the continual movement of external wood as the moisture content varies, that causes varnishes to crack. 
 Once this occurs moisture penetrates, causing the varnish to flake or peel from the surface. 
 A marine or yacht varnish is recommended when a clear film is required that will not obliterate or mask the natural grain configuration of the wood. 
 It is important that at least three coats are applied and that the top and bottom edges are given at least one coat to prevent moisture being absorbed.   
 THE IMPORTANCE OF SANDING DOWN 
 It is important to remember that however carefully the wood is finished, any imperfections will be apparent, particularly if the work is finished with a high gloss. 
 New wood must be fine sanded and if an orbital sander has been used, it is essential that the final sanding is done by hand with the grain, otherwise small circular marks will be seen in the finish. 
 Small cracks, nail holes or sunken screws can be filled with woodstopping  or plastic wood . 
 Unfortunately, where woodstopping has been used, it is usually apparent as it breaks the natural grain configuration. 
 The stopped areas can be made less noticeable by imitating the grain with a fine artist's brush and paint, usually using a mixture of ochres and siennas, according to the type of wood.  
 ACHIEVING A MIRROR FINISH 
 If a high gloss or mirror finish is required, then it is necessary to use either a grainfiller to fill the pores of the wood, or to apply extra coats of finish, rubbing down between coats until the grain has been filled. 
 Grainfillers are available in paste form, which can be thinned with white spirit before use. 
 The filler is rubbed hard across the surface of the wood, wiping off the surplus filler with a clean cloth. 
 If wood is to be stained as well as filled, then it is possible with some makes to thin the filler with the wood dye, so that dyeing and filling can be carried out in one operation. 
 A &bquo;malachite&equo; finish created by combing a piece of card in circular motions across a still wet coat of acrylic varnish (Cuprinol) Below: the water-resistant qualities of Cuprinol's Decorative Wood Preserver 
 Above: The beauty of natural wood &mdash; a combination of clear and coloured varnishes from Ronseal 
 Below: Hall floorway finished with Cuprinol's Enhance for Interior Floors 
 Above: Antique pitch pine in the stairway of a Victorian house. 
 Treads and spindles have been stripped and finished with Langlow's Patina 
 Left: Gloss and satin varnishes applied to a panelled hallway (Ronseal) 
 Left &amp; below: Liberon's Black Bison wax is available in thirteen wood tints. 
 Applied with fine steel wool, the wax can darken faded wood and provide a resistant finish. 
 Coloured woodwork (Dulux Woodtones) 
 Left: Sadolin's Classic is water repellent and contains fungicide 
 Right: Yacht varnish provides a durable coating (International Paint) 
 LIGHTING Let there be light 
 Follow our guide to updating and improving the lighting in your home. 
 Most homes have inadequate provision for lighting. 
 The average builder will probably have put in just a single central pendant light in each room, so we have to add extra lights by plugging them into precious socket outlets (precious because the builder doesn't put enough of these in either!). 
 But if you're prepared to learn how to do the wiring and to do the &bquo;building&equo; work (and redecorating) involved, it's not difficult to improve the lighting arrangements in your home by fitting new permanent lights, and by doing something about the switching set-up. 
 LIGHTING DESIGN 
 Light performs four main functions in the home. 
 It can provide general lighting  so you can move around safely and see more or less what you are doing when it's dark outside; task lighting  when you want more concentrated light in a particular area for a particular job (including reading); mood lighting  to provide different atmospheres in different rooms at different times; and it can also be used to illuminate the outside  of the home. 
 Before planning your new lighting, you will want to think about how you use different rooms, and whether the lighting will have to cope with more than one use of a room (often the case in sitting rooms). 
 It's a good idea to experiment with different set-ups, using temporary light fittings until you are happy, before making holes in the wall or the ceiling to fit the lights. 
 General lighting  means having around 20 watts of normal tungsten light (or 10 watts of fluorescent) for every square metre of floor area. 
 Pendant lights, usually hanging on their own flex from a ceiling rose, are the most common form of general tungsten lighting &mdash; ideally, there shouldn't be just one light in the centre of a room, but two or more around the room,  including over any table. 
 Decorative pendants, supported by a chain or screwed brass rod, may need a special ceiling fitting (see FITTING LIGHTS TO THE CEILING ). 
 General light can also be provided by recessed ceiling lights (either downlighters, which give a pool of light, or eyeball spotlights, where the beam is adjustable), or tracklights attached to the ceiling, fitted with spots, spotlight clusters and flush-fitting ceiling lights. 
 Recessed lights, positioned over the front edge of a worktop, are particularly effective in kitchens; enclosed ceiling light fittings are good for bathrooms. 
 In other rooms, interesting effects can be achieved with wallmounted or free-standing uplighters, which bounce their light off the ceiling, and with special recessed ceiling lights which &bquo;wash&equo; a wall with light. 
 Fluorescent lights are mounted on the ceiling, and are cheaper to run than normal lights, but the colour is not so &bquo;warm&equo; &mdash; though you can get special warm white tubes, usually on order. 
 Task lighting  is best achieved with individual lights &mdash; desk lamps, striplights under cupboards (in the kitchen), standard lamps, and table lamps. 
 These types of light fitting are the easiest to install, as you simply plug them into a 13amp socket &mdash; provided, that is, there is a convenient socket. 
 The lights must be positioned (or shielded) to avoid glare, and must be placed so you are not working in your own shadow. 
 Task lighting must be combined with general lighting &mdash; on its own, it could give you eyestrain. 
 Mood lighting  can be used not only to create an atmosphere, but also to highlight features of the house, such as decorative cornices, ornaments (especially inside glass-fronted cupboards), or pictures. 
 Several different types of light fitting can  be used, and some of the best effects can be achieved with the use of pastel-coloured light bulbs, and by fitting dimmer switches. 
 Outside lights  include lanterns, bulkhead lights and other designs, with the important proviso that the fitting is weatherproof. 
 A special type of outside light is the security light , which is switched on by a passive infra-red (PIR) sensor (usually, but not always, part of the light fitting), whenever someone approaches. 
 LOW-VOLTAGE LIGHTS 
 Most house lighting runs at the full mains voltage of 240 volts. 
 The latest type of lighting, widely used in shops and offices, but only recently available for the home, is low voltage lighting. 
 This runs at 12 volts, and has two big advantages over normal lighting: the bulbs can be very much smaller (and often come in small attractive fittings), and the light bulbs last longer, and are much cheaper to run. 
 The disadvantage is that they require a transformer to step down the voltage, which either means fairly expensive fittings (incorporating the transformer so they can replace existing fittings), or expensive wiring from a central transformer to the light fittings &mdash; low voltage means high current, so the wires have to be much bigger than normal lighting wiring. 
 LAMPS 
 A &bquo;lamp&equo; is the correct name for what most of us call a light bulb, and the common or garden light bulb is known as a GLS  (general lighting service) lamp. 
 These days, GLS lamps come in a variety of designs (including some with glitter on them) and in &bquo;soft&equo; light versions, as well as pastel shades. 
 Many spotlights, recessed lights and other modern fittings are designed to take internally-silvered reflector  lamps. 
 These usually come with an Edison screw (ES) connection, rather than the more common bayonet cap (BC) with the two familiar side pins. 
 Note that there are two  sizes of both ES and BC (the smaller ones are labelled SES and SBC), so it is vital that you check which one of the four connections your light fitting takes before buying the lamps. 
 One special type of reflector lamp is the PAR  (parabolic aluminised reflector), which can give a very defined beam, and has the advantage that it is resistant to changes in temperature, making it ideal for use outside. 
 Another type of light bulb you may come across is the tungsten halogen  bulb. 
 This gives a crisper, brighter light than a normal light bulb, and is used outside for floodlights and inside for uplighters. 
 It generates a lot of heat, so care needs to be taken positioning the fitting. 
 Normal fluorescent tubes are familiar enough, but the main development in recent years has been in compact fluorescent  lamps, which take the place of normal light bulbs. 
 The advantages of these are that they last much longer and cost much less to run (the saving well outweighs the higher asking price); their disadvantages are that the light they give is not quite so &bquo;warm&equo; and does not come on instantly. 
 With some, you'll also need an adaptor, which you buy separately &mdash; it will also do for all subsequent lamps in that fitting. 
 LIGHT SWITCHING 
 The common type of light switch is the rocker  switch &mdash; rock it downwards for on, and upwards for off. 
 This comes with one or more switches on the same &bquo;plate&equo;, operating different lights. 
 Most rocker switches are wired for one-way operation &mdash; that is, the light is turned on and off from just the one position; but most are capable of two-way operation, where the light is turned on or off from two places &mdash; in a through room, in a bedroom, or top and bottom of the stairs, for instance. 
 A simple way of upgrading switching is to fit dimmer  switches, which alter the light level. 
 Most simply replace the existing rocker switch, but cannot be used for controlling the fluorescent lighting. 
 Dimmer switches can usually be fitted for one or two-way operation; with two-way switching, only one switch can be a dimmer type. 
 A security  light switch also replaces an existing light switch. 
 What it does is to turn the light it controls (typically a hall light or an outside light) on and off, according to how you set the timer, to give the impression (to a potential burglar) that the house is occupied. 
 LIGHTING WIRING 
 All lighting circuits are radial ones &mdash; that is one cable goes from the fuseway in the consumer unit to the first light position, and then on to the second, and so on to the last on the circuit. 
 Most houses will have two lighting circuits &mdash; one for upstairs and one for downstairs &mdash; wired in one of two ways: junction box or loop-in. 
 The maximum number of light fittings on a circuit is 12. 
 In junction box  wiring, the lighting cable goes from the consumer unit to a series of four-terminal junction boxes, each usually positioned roughly over the appropriate light switch; cables lead from each junction box to a ceiling rose and to the switch. 
 In loop-in  wiring, the circuit cables go direct to the ceiling roses, and all the connections are made there. 
 The ceiling rose has &bquo;banks&equo; of terminals to take all the wires. 
 Loop-in wiring is more straightforward to do, but junction box wiring is a better system for light fittings (other than simple pendant lights) and is easier to add to. 
 With either system, the easiest place to add is the last light in the circuit, which is often the hall or landing light. 
 RUNNING LIGHTING WIRING 
 The upstairs lighting circuit is laid out on the floor of the loft, taking care not  to put it under any loft insulation (where it could overheat), and not to put junction boxes where they could be damaged by careless feet. 
 The downstairs lighting circuit is run under the first-floor floorboards, with cables preferably threaded through holes drilled in the centre of joists, or clipped to the sides of the joists. 
 To run cable down to light switches or to wall lights, it will usually be necessary to &bquo;chase&equo; slots in solid walls, though if you are rewiring a house which was originally  wired in metal conduit, you may be able to use the existing conduit buried in the plaster leading to light switches to feed the cable down. 
 Chasing solid walls is done with a bolster chisel and club hammer, and it is important to keep the cables vertical so that you know where they are. 
 Ideally, cables should be covered with metal half-channel before the plaster is made good with filler or a d-i-y plaster: you will, of course, have to redecorate the wall afterwards. 
 With hollow walls (plasterboard or lath-and-plaster on timber studs), you can run the cable for wall lights and switches in the void behind the wall surface, starting by drilling a hole in the top timber member. 
 The problem comes when you meet a horizontal nogging &mdash; the positions of which you can determine with a joist and batten detector. 
 The answer is to cut out a small square of plasterboard (or to cut through the laths in the same way), cut a narrow notch in the nogging to allow the cable through, and then replace the plasterboard, nailing it in place either side of the notch, and making good with filler. 
 Repairing cut-out lath-and-plaster is more difficult, but is generally best done with a small piece of plasterboard. 
 If there are problems getting the cable to the right place, start off with a piece of weighted string, which you can &bquo;fish&equo; through the hole you have cut, and then use this to pull the cable through. 
 The alternative to burying cable in the walls is to run it on the surface in mini-trunking, and then use surface-mounted light switches. 
 Although the mini-trunking will be fairly obvious, it does save a lot of work, especially on decorating. 
 SECURING LIGHT FITTINGS TO THE CEILINGS 
 Any light fitting which is secured to a ceiling should ideally have at least one of its screws going into a joist, but where this is not possible, it is best to secure a piece of wood between the joists to take the securing screws, rather than relying on hollow wall fixings into plain plasterboard or, especially, into lath-and-plaster. 
 Decorative pendant lights which have chains or screwed brass rods can be supported in one of two ways. 
 The first is to cut a hole in the ceiling and to fit a metal or plastic BESA box (designed for use with conduit wiring), with its face flush with the ceiling, and with the box screwed to a supporting piece of timber fixed between the joists; the BESA box has two screwed holes which match the holes in the plate supporting the chain or screwed rod. 
 The second method is use a Ceiling Maestro, which is screwed to a joist or a piece of timber between the joists, and which has a hook for a chain and a screwed hole for a rod. 
 Several manufacturers make Luminaire Supporting Connectors (LSCs) which (like the Ceiling Maestro) come in two parts which can be separated, allowing lights to be changed easily or removed for cleaning, but not all LSCs are designed for use with heavy fittings. 
 Fluorescent lights and track lighting can be screwed to the ceiling using hollow wall plugs, but if you can arrange for at least two screws to go into a joist, the fitting will be more secure. 
 Recessed ceiling lights (eyeball spots and downlighters) are fitted in circular holes which you cut out of the ceiling with a padsaw. 
 Normally, they need not additional support, but you must take care to ensure that the position is between  joists, and that there is sufficient clearance above the light to prevent overheating. 
 SECURING LIGHT FITTINGS TO THE WALL 
 Many wall lights, like some decorative pendant lights, will come with a backing plate, with two screw holes exactly 2in (50mm) apart. 
 This matches the holes in a BESA box, so one way to fit a wall light is to bury a BESA box in the wall, and then to secure the light fitting to it (the wiring connection is made via a terminal connector strip with three terminals). 
 The alternative is to bury an architrave switch mounting box in the wall to take the terminal connector strip, and secure the light fitting centrally over this, so that the securing screws can go into wall plugs fitted in holes, which you drill in the wall either side of the box. 
 It is not good practice simply to leave the cable poking out of the wall, and many wall light fittings will not have space in their backing plate to make the connections. 
 SECURING LIGHT SWITCHES 
 For flush-mounted switches, you will have  to make a hole in a solid wall to take a metal mounting box &mdash; most light switches fit into a 16mm plaster &mdash; depth wall box, so you don't have to cut away any of the brick or block. 
 Secure the box to the masonry behind with wallplugs and screws &mdash; don't rely on filler to hold it in place. 
 For hollow walls, you can get special plastic boxes with &bquo;wings&equo; which open up behind the plasterboard to hold the box in place. 
 You can get special surface-mounting boxes which have a slot to take mini-trunking, but if these are not available, simply run the mini-trunking up to the edge of the box and knock out one of the holes in the side. 
 In bathrooms, you must use ceiling-mounted pull-cord switches, not  wall-mounted ones. 
 TYPICAL WIRING JOBS 
 Adding a new light: 
 To put in a new light which is independently switched, there are two choices for the wiring. 
 One is to take a supply from an existing loop-in ceiling rose or junction box to a new junction box, and then wire to the light switch and light fitting. 
 The other is to take a spur from the socket outlet circuit, via a switched fused connection unit, fitted with a 3amp fuse, and use this to feed the light &mdash; the switch will then turn the light on and off. 
 This latter method is often a good way of wiring outside lights. 
 Replacing a pendant light: 
 If you want to fit a fluorescent light, recessed light(s), ceiling light, or track lighting in place of an existing pendant light, you will normally want to remove the ceiling rose. 
 With the junction box method of wiring, you may simply be able to re-use the cable for the new light fitting. 
 With loop-in wiring, the wires are labelled carefully, and drawn up into the space above the ceiling, where they should be reconnected in a junction box, in exactly  the same way that they were connected in the ceiling rose, and a cable taken from this junction box to the light fitting through the hole in the ceiling (if the new light fitting is in the same place). 
 If you are fitting several lights (downlighters or eyeball spots, say), run this cable to the nearest fitting, and then run cable from this to the next nearest, and so on to the last. 
 Fitting two-way switching: 
 Converting an existing light &mdash; in the hall or the bedroom &mdash; to two-way switching is not difficult. 
 The existing wiring is left in place, and a length of three-core  and earth lighting cable is run from the existing light switch (which must be two-way) to a new two-way light switch. 
 Fitting a dimmer or security light switch: 
 No extra wiring is necessary to fit dimmers or security light switches, as they simply replace the existing switch. 
 The only problem comes where the existing switch is part of a two-way system, where you might need some technical help understanding the instructions, which are often written in electrician's jargon rather than plain English. 
 You might also need to fit a standard depth (25mm) box if the existing switch is in a plaster-depth one. 
 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION&hellip; 
 Anglepoise Lighting Ltd. 
 Wide range of task lighting, including low-voltage &amp; energy-saving, flexible low-energy uplighting system 
 Ashley &amp; Rock Ltd 
 KLIK modular plug &amp; socket connector systems, ceiling &amp; wall 
 ELEC 
 Electrical installation materials, plus full range of pir security lanterns/floodlights, garden lighting, low-voltage fittings, uplights, burglar alarms, etc. 
 Four branches in south, plus mail order nationwide. 
 Free colour catalogue 
 GE Thorn Lamps 
 Low-energy replacement bulbs (+ adaptor). 
 Decor Rounds + Candles, Softglow coloured range, shaver &amp; striplights, garden &amp; security lighting 
 Lumiance 
 Several ranges of downlighters, wall &amp; ceiling luminaires, track &amp; spotlights, &amp; tubular lighting systems; includes low-voltage, compact fluorescents, etc 
 Maestro Light 
 Ceiling Maestro (plug-in ceiling rose, also suitable for wall lights 
 Micromark Lighting 
 Range of decorative pendant &amp; wall lights, rise &amp; fall pendants, spotlights, desk &amp; nursery lights, uplighters, downlighters &amp; eyeballs, garden &amp; security lighting, &amp; electrical accessories 
 MK Electric Ltd 
 Electrical accessories &amp; switches, LSCs, etc 
 Philips Lighting Ltd 
 Range of energy-saving lightbulbs with bayonet fittings (no adaptor needed), &bquo;natural sunlight&equo; Halogena bulbs (bayonet &amp; screw fittings), high performance spotlight bulbs, Softone pastel range, &amp; security lighting 
 Quest Emess Ltd 
 Full range of decorative &amp; modern indoor lighting, including low-voltage, track &amp; spot, low-voltage downlights, outdoor &amp; security lighting 
 Wickes Building Supplies Ltd 
 Basic range of interior &amp; exterior lighting. 
 Includes low-energy, low voltage, &amp; cabling, electric fittings, etc. 
 Left: A Hint of Peach for a living room, with Philips' Softone bulbs 
 Right: Stylish Vogue uplighters, from Mazda's Interiors range, produce a subtle, sophisticated effect. 
 Available in four designs 
 Rise and fall pendants are ideal above dining areas, especially when connected to a dimmer switch. 
 These from Micromark have perforated metal shades, in white, grey, red or black 
 Get more light for your money with Philips' concentrated-beam Spotline bulbs 
 Above: Sparkling Crystal Gold finish from Mazda's Images collection looks just as appealing when bulbs are not lit. 
 Three finishes are available, in decor rounds and candle bulbs 
 Left: Freestanding Quad Uplighter from Anglepoise provides efficient but well-diffused lighting 
 Left: Wall-mounted Athena metal uplighter from Micromark, available in matt black, white and gold 
 Cutout, below: Improve your home security with a Philips automatic floodlight system, which includes a passive infra-red sensor to trigger the light when someone approaches 
 Adjustable floodlight with PIR sensor: the economically priced Powerflood from ELEC has a range of 12m 
 Suitable for porches and covered areas, ELEC's PIR Lantern Light in black has an adjustable sensor range of up to 50ft 
 JOBBING NOTEBOOK 
 REPLACING DOOR FRONTS 
 When you think about it, the beauty of even the smartest kitchen is only skin deep. 
 It is the doors and drawer fronts which provide the main attraction, and the rest of the construction is hidden behind them. 
 So, replace the doors and drawer fronts and you can totally transform the appearance. 
 The owners of this modern kitchen preferred a wood appearance and so they rang the changes. 
 In selected independent stores you will find a range of replacement doors and drawer replacement doors and drawer fronts in some 40 sizes. 
 You have a choice of pine which can be varnished, stained or painted &mdash; or there is a very attractive solid cherry. 
 Prices range from around &pound;5 for a door in pine, to &pound;7.50 in cherry. 
 Conversion is simple. 
 1 
 Remove the old door and hinge from the cabinet. 
 And, hopefully, you will be able to re-use the hinges 
 2 
 Most modern cabinet hinges require a circular hole to be bored in the door, so use the hinge as a guide 
 3 
 Use an end mill for boring the holes. 
 And as an aid to drilling, make a simple template from a length of batten. 
 As solid cherry doors are pre-varnished, protect the surface of the door when using cramps 
 4 
 When boring the holes, take great care not to go too deep or you'll come through the face of the door! 
 Ideally use a drill stand with a depth stop 
 5 
 Screw the hinge to your new door. 
 It is wise to drill small start holes to make the insertion of screws easier 
 6 
 Fit the new door to the unit and make the necessary adjustment to the hinge to ensure the door sits correctly 
 With the drawer fronts, it will be necessary to top off the existing fronts using a rubber hammer or mallet. 
 Check to ensure no screws are holding the fronts in place. 
 Then glue on the new fronts. 
 With doors and drawers in place, you have the choice of replacing old handles or investing in new. 
 But new will certainly add to the transformation. 
 If you experience difficulty in locating the doors, contact Leboff International Ltd    
 LIMING AN OAK TABLE 
 If you have one of the thousands of barley twist-legged tables produced from the Edwardian period onwards, the chances are that it will be coated with a dark, almost black varnish. 
 These tables can be easily lightened to produce a limed-oak effect. 
 1 
 Strip off the old varnish with a chemical stripper and wire wool. 
 Once back to bare wood, raise the grain by rubbing briskly with a stiff wire brush 
 2 
 If a different base colour is required, now is the time to apply a wood dye 
 3 
 Once the dye has dried, apply a coat of protective transparent polish 
 4 
 Rub white undercoat paint into the grain with a circular motion 
 5 
 Remove excess with white spirit. 
 Finish with wax or Danish oil 
 Materials available from Rustins Ltd   
 CREATING A LIMED PINE EFFECT 
 Wood finishes that let the natural beauty of the grain show through are becoming more and more popular. 
 A d-i-y alternative to limed oak can be created by treating pine to a coat of liming wax. 
 1 
 These pine cabinet doors were sanded to a smooth finish before being given one coat of Antique Pine wood dye. 
 Brush on the dye, working with the grain, and rag off any excess. 
 This darkens the very white new pine and provides more depth to the finished effect 
 2 
 Liming wax is scrubbed on to the door when the dye has completely dried. 
 Work with the grain, forcing the wax into the grain with 0000 gauge wire wool 
 3 
 Once dry, the excess white wax is removed by rubbing the wood with clear wax polish. 
 This seals and protects the door. 
 Buff the wax with a soft cloth or polishing bonnet fitted to an electric drill 
 4 
 The finished door &mdash; because of the soft wax finish, this is not suitable for areas of heavy use eg kitchen units. 
 For these areas, use white undercoat paint to &bquo;lime&equo; the wood, followed by clear varnish 
 Liming wax, clear polish, wood dye and wire wool available from Liberon Waxes Ltd    
 FITTING A FIRE SURROUND 
 The lounge with fireplace and living fire is back in vogue. 
 So, when you next plan to change the lounge d&eacute;cor, why not add a new fireplace? 
 Kits are available with four basic components &mdash; surrounds, inserts, hearth and the fire itself. 
 And the combination of all four illustrated costs in the region of &pound;500. 
 This includes hardwood surround, marble inserts and gas flame effect fire. 
 1 
 Remove any existing heater and fireplace &mdash; and take great care with old tiled surrounds. 
 They are extremely heavy 
 2 
 Hack out the old fire surround. 
 This fireplace succumbed to the blows of club hammer and bolster. 
 This is a good time to have the chimney swept 
 3 
 The components involved, laid out for inspection. 
 Keep in mind at this stage that a gas supply is needed. 
 Contact your local Gas Board in good time 
 4 
 To set the hearth, measure the centre of the wall and drop a plumb line to the base of the opening. 
 Lay a piece of masking tape at the centre point of the hearth, then line it up with the plumb bob 
 5 
 Lay a bed of mortar (1 cement to 3 soft sand) in the form of a rectangle, and place the marble hearth on it. 
 Check for level 
 6 
 Attach two brass mirror plates to the wood blocks at the rear of the back panel 
 7 
 Tape glass fibre rope around the fire opening. 
 This forms a smoke seal once the panel is fixed in place 
 8 
 Offer the marble to the wall, making sure there is an equal amount of hearth either side of the panel 
 9 
 Before screwing to the wall, fit the brass frame around the flue opening. 
 This is held in place by four metal lugs which are bent around the opening 
 10 
 Fix the mahogany legs to the top mantel using brackets and screws. 
 Work on a carpet or dust sheet to avoid marking the surround 
 11 
 Now screw the two keyhole slotted brackets to the inside of the surround legs 
 12 
 The unit can now be offered to the wall and the gas pipework and setting of the fire undertaken. 
 The actual surround can be removed during the process to avoid damage 
 In case of difficulty, further information is available from Wickes Building Supplies Ltd .   
 LAYING A PAVING SLAB PATH 
 The simplest but least permanent method of path making is to lay slab on sand. 
 And sand will provide a stable base providing rainwater cannot reach it. 
 So it is important to ensure all joints are well pointed and sides are sealed against the ingress of water. 
 Where a lawn is involved, cut away the turf and loose topsoil. 
 Then consolidate soft areas by ramming in rubble. 
 You need a firm base allowing for about 30mm of sand plus the thickness of the slabs so your path will lie flush with the lawn soil level. 
 This will make lawn mowing easy. 
 1 
 Treat exposed soil with weedkiller, then tip sand on to the prepared foundation, and rake smooth 
 2 
 Use a garden roller to consolidate the sand. 
 Add more until just the thickness of the slabs remains 
 3 
 Lower each slab on to the sand so as not to disturb it. 
 Use a rubber hammer or the handle of a club hammer to level each slab. 
 Add or remove sand as necessary to ensure slabs sit correctly. 
 Leave a gap of about 15 to 18mm between slabs 
 4 
 Seal all joints with mortar. 
 Use a mix of 1 cement to 4&frac12;l; soft sand by volume, and add a minimum of water to produce a dryish mix. 
 It should be dry enough to brush off the slabs without staining 
 ALTERNATIVE METHODS 
 For a more permanent path, where perhaps there is likely to be heavy foot traffic, slabs can be laid on large blobs of mortar. 
 Prepare the ground as already described, then make up a mix of 1 cement to 5 sand, with a minimum of water. 
 Place a blob for each corner and one for the centre of each slab. 
 Lower the slab in place, then tap down with the handle of a club hammer. 
 Check with a spirit level. 
 For even better bedding, prepare the site, then lay an even bed of mortar over an area which can be paved in about half an hour. 
 Lay it to a depth of at least 25mm (1in); rake smooth, then lay each slab in place, lowering it so as not to disturb the mortar bed. 
 Tap in place with the club hammer handle and check with a spirit level as work progresses.  
 RE-POINTING BRICKWORK 
 Re-pointing defective mortar is vital to prevent damp in walls. 
 First rake out all loose mortar to a depth of about 12mm. 
 For a small job use a bag of mortar mix. 
 This should be mixed, with clean water to produce a dry mix which can be lifted on a trowel without sagging or sliding off. 
 The makers of the Jarvis Painting Hawk, used here, claim it allows you to work 400% faster. 
 1 
 Place mortar on the hawk and hold it in line and just below the joint to be filled 
 2 
 Lift a wedge of the mortar up the vertical face of the hawk and press in place with trowel edge 
 3 
 With the hawk still held in place smooth out the mortar for the length of the hawk 
 4 
 Carefully lift away the hawk and trim away any surplus mortar with the trowel tip 
 5 
 To fill the vertical joints, turn the hawk and separate off a small amount of mortar, lifting it on the underside of the trowel 
 6 
 Turn the trowel and apply the mortar to the joint, lifting away any surplus with the trowel point. 
 Note brickwork stays clean 
 FIT A SMOKE DETECTOR 
 Despite new regulations, there are still plenty of materials in most homes which could produce lethal fumes if fire broke out. 
 So, to provide ample warning, fit smoke alarms. 
 Ideally, site one in the hall and another on the landing. 
 Avoid fitting one in the kitchen, as fumes from cooking are often enough to activate the alarm. 
 The one illustrated is by First Alert: like most types it can be simply screwed into a ceiling. 
 SEALING GLAZING BARS 
 After painting glazing bars, cover them with a self-adhesive weatherproofing tape such as that produced by Aquaseal. 
 This will ensure the paintwork stays in good condition, and it will make the roof watertight. 
 Once positioned, press into tight contact with the glass.  
 PLUMBING-IN A PLASTIC BATH 
 The modern plastic bath is so much easier to handle than its heavier metal counterpart. 
 And this in turn makes it easier to connect the various fittings. 
 But because of the flexible nature of plastic, correct support is vital so the bath cannot move while in use. 
 Check movement by filling with cold water. 
 1 
 As the bath is plastic, you screw the legs to location spigots situated under the bath rim. 
 Then screw them to the baseboard. 
 Screw the small leg to the centre of the base 
 2 
 Hold the bath/shower mixer in place on the bath by tightening the back nut on each tap tail. 
 A rubber gasket is sited under the top body to protect the surface of the bath 
 3 
 Connect the pop-up bath waste from the rear of the bath, adjusting the waste so the components match up with the holes in the bath. 
 Then screw overflow and waste grids to the waste pipe sections 
 4 
 Attach a shallow-seal bath trap to the waste outlet, then connect to the waste pipe by means of a swept-tee 
 5 
 The hot and cold water supply pipes can be simple handbendable sections. 
 Bend the pipes to connect each tap tail to the supply pipes 
 6 
 In this case, straight sections of Kopex connectors were pushed into Acorn connectors after the pipe ends had been smeared with lubricant. 
 The tap connector screws to the tap rail 
 7 
 To complete the job, clip the moulded bath panel in place. 
 There should be clips attached to the bath frame at the top, and at the base the panel will be held by sticky pads located on a floor-mounted batten. 
 This bath is from Armitage Shanks 
 STENCILLING ON VARNISH 
 Large areas of cabinet or wardrobe doors can look very plain. 
 Stencilling is an easy way of producing a complex decoration that will add interest to any area of bare wood. 
 Choose one of the many pre-cut stencil designs on the market, or make your own from card. 
 The Ronseal varnishes used here can also be applied to a painted or previously varnished surface that has been rubbed down with a fine abrasive paper. 
 WHAT YOU NEED 
 Stencil (form your own using card, if desired) 
 Stencil crayons &mdash; available from art shops and branches of Laura Ashley 
 Stencil brush 
 Masking tape 
 Ronseal Pine Satin Varnish 
 Ronseal Clear Satin Varnish 
 White spirit 
 Lint-free cloth 
 1 
 Bare wood should be rubbed down with fine grade abrasive paper, working along the grain, and the dust removed with a cloth moistened with white spirit 
 2 
 If you wish to antique new wood, apply one coat of Ronseal pine coloured Satin Varnish. 
 Brush along the grain and allow to dry for at least six hours. 
 3 
 Stick the stencil in position using masking tape and cover any areas around the designs that may be accidentally brushed with colour 
 4 
 Solid areas of colour can be applied with a stencil crayon 
 5 
 To give stencil designs such as fruit a three dimensional look, use a stencil brush to create areas of light and dark colour. 
 Brush lightly to give a lighter tone and use more pressure to give a darker &bquo;shadow&equo; around the edge of the fruit. 
 Hold the brush at right angles to the surface and use circular motions 
 6 
 Brushes may also be used to colour larger areas such as the blue ribbon of this design. 
 Remember to mask adjoining cutouts. 
 When all the colours have been applied, remove the stencil sheet and leave to dry for about 48 hours 
 7 
 Seal the whole door with Ronseal Clear Varnish to protect the design from wear 
 For more information contact: Ronseal, Sterling Roncraft    
 LAYING A WORKSHOP BASE 
 The base of a garden shed mainly used for storage can be supported on a number of paving slabs, but a workshop, which may house heavy machinery, needs a good firm base. 
 And it is wise to spend time getting it smooth and level so that all the bolt holes in a prefabricated building line up correctly. 
 An uneven base can make assembly really difficult. 
 Clear off all loose top soil within an area slightly larger than the size of the workshop. 
 Then dig out to allow for a layer of hardcore plus about 75mm (3in) of concrete on top. 
 A base up to 3m (10ft) long can be cast in one slab. 
 But anything over that size should be divided into two equal slabs with a dividing board between. 
 This ensures that the concrete slab won't crack. 
 Use a mix of 1 cement, 2&frac12; damp sand and 4 coarse aggregate &mdash; or 1 cement to 5 mixed sand and aggregate. 
 Use the minimum of water, to produce a dryish mix. 
 1 
 Drive in pegs to match the proposed height of the formwork. 
 Check between pegs with a spirit level 
 2 
 Fix boards to the pegs, checking for horizontal as work progresses 
 3 
 Check that both sides of the formwork are level &mdash; and this may involve adding a central peg from which to check 
 4 
 Use a builder's square to check that corners are true right-angles 
 5 
 Apply rubble and tamp well down, leaving enough space for 75mm of concrete on top 
 6 
 Tip on the concrete and level out with a rake until it is just about the level of the formwork 
 7 
 Select a straight board which is wider than the base and use it to tamp down the concrete&hellip; 
 8 
 &hellip; then move it across the area &mdash; zig-zag fashion &mdash; to get it level. 
 Fill in any voids as you progress 
 9 
 cover the concrete with either polythene sheeting or wet sacking while it cures. 
 This is particularly important in hot weather 
 10 
 Before the concrete sets, the surface can be given a final smooth in a number of ways. 
 A soft broom produces a smooth surface; a stiff broom a lightly textured surface, and a wood float a smooth, non-slip surface. 
 If the workshop has a timber floor, obviously the finish is not important 
 ROOFING A CONSERVATORY 
 If you're planning to build your own lean-to sun room or conservatory, it is essential to get the roof right. 
 If you don't, there will be endless problems with leaks. 
 One efficient method of covering the roof is to combine twin wall Lexon Thermoclear sheeting with Twinfix aluminium structural glazing bar. 
 So before launching out to buy materials, send for literature from each company. 
 This will help with recommendations such as the ratio between sheet thickness, width and the distances between glazing bar centres. 
 Addresses are given below. 
 Illustrated is the system used for securing sheets to a simple lean-to verandah roof with timber frame. 
 This incorporates Twinfix 261 Rafter Gasket and 226 aluminium glazing bar. 
 1 
 When ordering Thermoclear always state width and length carefully &mdash; and ensure that the ribs will run from top to bottom (ridge to eaves) and NOT sideways. 
 Also always ask for the swarf to be blown out of cut sheets, and for the ends to be temporarily taped up to keep the sheets clean inside 
 Before installing on a roof, peel back a little of the protective masking and remove the temporary tape. 
 Place aluminium tape over the ridge (top) ends of the sheets, and aluminium antidust breather tape over the eaves (bottom) ends. 
 This helps to prevent rainwater ingress from the top, and also helps to keep the sheets clean, while allowing any condensation which may develop in the flutes to evaporate 
 2 
 In order to protect the aluminium breather tape, and give a neat rigid finish at the edge of the sheets, cover the breather tape at the eaves with an aluminium &bquo;U&equo; channel 
 3 
 Place the rafter gasket centrally on the wooden rafters and nail down through the centre channel, with galvanised nails 300mm apart 
 4 
 Remove the protective masking from the Thermoclear. 
 Ensure the side with the UV protection faces outwards (ie the side with the pictorial masking) and place the Thermoclear panels on the rafter gasket 
 5 
 Insert the gaskets in the aluminium glazing bar cap; place centrally over the rafter gasket and screw down no more than 400mm apart, using matching coloured acetal headed stainless steel screws. 
 Do not overtighten as this prevents expansion and contraction of the Thermoclear. 
 Screw-on glazing bars are preferable to snap-fits as they hold this flexible glazing sheet more securely in place 
 6 
 Place a simple push-fit polycarbonate stop and cap over the end of the capping bar to give a neat finish 
 7 
 An &bquo;F&equo; profile supports the sides of the sheet and protects the edge of the roof slope. 
 Use a spirit level to ensure that the glazed sheet is horizontal before fixing it to the barge board with stainless steel screws 300mm apart. 
 Finish off the ridge with lead flashing, and fit guttering at the eaves 
 SUPPORTING A DAMAGED FENCE POST 
 Where a post has rotted, to avoid dismantling fencing, plan to use a concrete spur. 
 These may be plain or, if the post can be cut, a stepped spur is available upon which the post can rest. 
 To make the spur less conspicuous, it can be stained brown with a special concrete stain. 
 When you buy your spur, also buy bolts sufficiently long to pass through both spur and post to leave at least 25mm (1in) protruding. 
 1 
 Clear the ground around the damaged post. 
 Buy a spur of suitable length, allowing for at least 2ft. into the ground 
 2 
 Dig a hole, keeping the sides as near vertical as possible. 
 Remove the rotted section of post 
 3 
 Anchor the post in a truly vertical position, insert the spur and mark and bore holes in the post for the bolts 
 4 
 Ram rubble around the spur then fill with quick-setting concrete, tamping well down. 
 Check that bolt holes align before the concrete sets 
 5 
 Insert the bolts; add washers, grease the threads then tighten nuts 
 6 
 use a hacksaw to remove surplus bolt thread 
 ADJUSTING A BALL VALVE 
 Methods vary for ball valve adjustment, according to the type of valve involved. 
 1 
 With a modern diaphragm valve, it may only be necessary to move the float up or down on the serrated spindle connected to the valve arm 
 2 
 But some modern valves have a small adjusting screw close to the actual valve mechanism. 
 Screw it further in to lower the water level &mdash; or out to raise it 
 3 
 With the older Portsmouth valve, adjust by carefully bending the ball arm. 
 Never hold the ball while bending. 
 It may snap off from the arm 
 4 
 A damaged ball from an older pattern can be unscrewed and replaced. 
 As a temporary repair, empty out water and encase the ball in a polythene bag tied with elastic 
 NEWS UPdate 
 INSULATION BOARD REDUCES NOISE THROUGH WALLS 
 A new product from Heraklith is available to improve the sound insulation properties of various types of walls. 
 Heraklith Sound Insulation boards, for example, will improve the  airbourne  sound insulation index of a solid 250mm brick wall by 13dB (10dB means a reduction in sound level of 50%). 
 The boards, 25 or 35mm thick, are a laminate of layers of Heraklith-M-Original magnesite-bound wood incorporating a flexible foam core. 
 It is the careful balance between the dynamic rigidity of the core and the weight of the surface layer which prevents significant resonance incursions. 
 The boards are fixed to existing walls by adhesive or dowel fasteners, and the M-Original surface may be directly plastered or have plasterboard attached. 
 The fixing process is simple and clean, and only minimally increases wall thickness and adds little dead weight to the structure.  
 SAFETY WINDOW FILM OFFERS PROTECTION AND PEACE OF MIND 
 Although glass surrounds us, if a glass window shatters it may cause horrific and perhaps even lethal injuries. 
 Courtalds Performance Films has launched Protech Safety Window Film to prevent precisely this type of domestic tragedy. 
 Protech is a polyester-based film which is easily fitted to flat glass, providing all the benefits of toughened glass at a fraction of the cost. 
 Fitting the film is easy. 
 The glass must be thoroughly cleaned and made dust-free. 
 It is then sprayed with water, for which an ordinary hand-held plant sprayer is ideal. 
 The backing sheet is then removed from the film before wetting it and applying it to the window. 
 A squeegee tool is used to smooth out the film and the excess film around the edge of the window is trimmed off with a safety knife. 
 The film gives peace of mind to the potentially vulnerable, such as the elderly, and to the parents of young children, and it is also a deterrent to the intending intruder. 
 In addition, Protech has excellent solar control properties, the clear film screening out 95% of damaging ultra-violet rays and giving 13% solar energy rejection. 
 Bronze and smoke-tinted film is also available. 
 As a guide to price, 7ft &times; 24in of clear film costs &pound;14.  
 NEW LIGHTING EQUIPMENT IMPROVES HOME SECURITY 
 In 1990 nearly a million homes were burgled, almost 20% up on the previous year. 
 This has urged Bosch to make its debut in the security products market with a range of sensor-controlled security lights, movement detectors, and mini alarms. 
 All are simple to use and compatible with existing lighting systems in the home. 
 The range includes a decorative security light with a clear or frosted glass globe, a traditional lantern light in black or white, and a floodlight security kit with a powerful 500watt halogen bulb. 
 All will welcome you or your guests, but startle intruders. 
 All lamps have a built-in passive infra red sensor which react to invisible thermal radiation emitted by people or other sources of heat. 
 Any movement detected by the sensor is signalled to the electronic switching circuit which automatically turns on the lights. 
 Using a pre-set timer, the lights can be set to stay on for a period from 25 seconds to 12 minutes. 
 The range of detection is approximately 15m, and the detection angle is 120&deg;. 
 The sensor can be adjusted through 180&deg; horizontally and 90&deg; vertically, so the detection zone is therefore almost infinitely variable. 
 All lamps can also be used as dusk to dawn security lights and have a daytime &bquo;test&equo; facility. 
 Prices range from &pound;40.82 for an Automatic Porch Light to &pound;81.69 for a Security Light Lantern.  
 CORDLESS DRILL WINNERS 
 The winners of Black &amp; Decker 9032 cordless hammer action drills which were the prizes in a competition which appeared in the May issue of DIY are as follows:   
 TILING For a lasting impression 
 Ceramic tiles offer an excellent range of properties for use on wall and floor surfaces. 
 They are easy to handle, fixing is simple, and the resulting surface is waterproof, easy to keep clean, hard-wearing and extremely long-lasting. 
 Ceramic tiles are thin slabs of fired clay decorated on one side with coloured glazes, and often with a printed or handpainted pattern too. 
 They have been around since Egyptian times, which makes them one of our oldest decorating materials. 
 They are popular these days because of the huge range of patterns and designs now available. 
 The only drawback is their price &mdash; anything from about &pound;8 per square metre for the plainest types, up to &pound;20 per square metre, or sometimes a lot more for elaborate designs. 
 TILES FOR WALLS 
 Ceramic wall tiles are generally about 4mm thick, and come in a number of regular sizes. 
 The most popular size used to be the 4&frac12;in (108mm) square tile, still available in a limited number of ranges, but displaced from the No 1 position by larger 152mm  (6in) square tiles, which are quicker to fix (you need only 44 to cover a square metre of wall, compared with 86 of the smaller tiles, and there's less grouting to do as well). 
 Rectangular tiles are becoming more popular too; common sizes are 200&times;100mm (8&times;4in) and 200&times;150mm (8&times;6in), with coverages of 50 and 33 to the square metre respectively. 
 You can also buy tiles in interlocking shapes &mdash; hexagons, curved &bquo;Proven&ccedil;al&equo;, and so on. 
 Some ranges include tile &bquo;slips&equo; &mdash; slim tiles 150mm (6in) long and 25mm (1in) wide (although lengths and widths vary with the particular range), which can be used to create coloured stripes or narrow borders to tiled areas. 
 Apart from the different sizes available the packaging of ceramic wall tiles is confusing, to say the least. 
 Depending on the tile size and on the manufacturer concerned, you are likely to be offered packs containing anything from 6 to 50 tiles, and some packs &mdash; of 13, 22 and the like &mdash; don't make estimating quantities any easier. 
 Fortunately, most retailers will split packs for you if buying whole packs would be uneconomical, so it's best either to count up the numbers you need from a scale plan of the area to be tiled, or else to use the &bquo;number per square metre&equo; figures given above. 
 Tile designs alter with changing fashions in interior design, and current demand seems to be mainly for large areas of neutral or small-patterned tiles, perhaps interspersed with individual motif tiles on a matching background. 
 Plain tiles, often with a simple border frame, are also popular, as are tiles which create a frieze effect when laid alongside one another. 
 There are also sets of tiles which build up into larger designs (known as feature panels), and which can look quite striking when surrounded by an area of plain tiling. 
 Some tile ranges still include what are known as insert tiles &mdash; tiles carrying moulded bathroom accessories such as soap dishes and toilet roll holders, though these are not as common or as popular as they once were. 
 The same applies to the small quadrant-shaped tiles used for finishing off the junction between baths and tiled walls still available, but in a limited range of colours these days (sealants and plastic trims have taken their place). 
 The surface of ceramic wall tiles is no longer always highly glazed, as it traditionally was. 
 You can now choose semi-matt finishes instead if you prefer, often with a slight surface texture that softens the somewhat harsh glare of a high-gloss surface. 
 Since colours can vary slightly, it's important to buy all the tiles you need  at once to ensure that they're from the same batch; it's also a good idea to unpack and mix them before fixing them, to even out any colour variations. 
 The other important point to remember about wall tiles is that spacer lugs are no more, and the old-fashioned types that are rounded on one (RE) or two (REX) edges, used to finish off the perimeter of half-tiled areas, have virtually disappeared too. 
 Most tiles now have square edges; these are sometimes glazed on one or two edges, sometimes not, so if you want an exposed glazed edge, check the actual tiles before you buy. 
 Otherwise, you'll have to use some form of edge trim. 
 Tiles glazed on all four edges are described as &bquo;universal&equo;. 
 TILES FOR FLOOR 
 Floor tiles are less widely used than wall tiles, but are a popular choice for heavy traffic areas such as porches and hallways, and also for conservatories. 
 They are generally thicker and harder-fired than wall tiles, to enable them to stand up to heavy wear without cracking. 
 They may be glazed, with a plain colour or a printed design, or unglazed &mdash; more commonly known as quarry tiles &mdash; and many have textured surfaces to make them less slippery underfoot. 
 Most are square-edged, so spacers have to be used to guarantee an even grouting gap; some ranges (especially quarries) still include RE and REX tiles for finishing off parttiled areas or forming tiled skirtings. 
 Common sizes are 150mm (6in) and 200mm (8in) squares, and 200&times;100mm (8&times;4in) rectangles; hexagons are also available in plain colours, and a popular variation is a plain octagonal tile which is laid with small square coloured inserts at tile intersections. 
 Pack sizes vary, but boxes of five or 10 are the most common. 
 As with wall tiles, most retailers will break packs to help you buy economically. 
 Note that special frost-proof grades are available for use outdoors on steps, passageways and so on; ordinary indoor grades will be damaged by frost. 
 TILES FOR WORKTOPS 
 You can of course use ordinary ceramic tiles as a worktop surface. 
 Special shaped tiles are available for finishing off the edges of the worktop, and consist of straight strips with an L cross-section, plus mitred lengths for internal corners, and square &bquo;caps&equo; for external ones. 
 As with bath trims, there is a limited colour range. 
 MOSAICS 
 Mosaics are just tiny tiles &mdash; usually plain in colour, sometimes with a pattern &mdash; which are sold made up in sheets on a tough fabric backing. 
 They are laid just like tiles, in a bed of adhesive, and the gaps are grouted afterwards. 
 Square mosaics are the most common, but discs, hexagons and other interlocking shapes are also available. 
 Sheets are usually 300mm (12in) square, and are often sold in packs of five or 10; the best way of estimating quantities is to work out the area to be covered, and to divide that by the coverage figure given on the pack, which will tell you how many packs to buy. 
 Note that wall and floor types are of different thicknesses, just like ordinary ceramic tiles. 
 TOOLS &amp; EQUIPMENT 
 For almost any tiling job, large or small, you will need the following: tile adhesive; a notched adhesive spreader; some tile spacers (unless you are using universal tiles); lengths of tile edge trim (optional); grout plus a flexible spreader; a steel tape measure; some lengths of 38&times;12mm (1&frac12;&times;&frac12;in) softwood battening plus masonry pins and hammer for large wall areas; a spirit level; a tile cutter; tile nibblers, pincers or tile saw; some dowelling for shaping the grout lines; a pencil and felt-tip pen; and some sponges and cloths for wiping and polishing. 
 You may also need some silicone sealant for sealing joints where tiling abuts baths, basins and shower trays, and maybe a profile gauge if laying floor tiles around awkward areas like architraves, etc. 
 Both adhesive and grout for wall tiling are usually sold readymixed, in plastic tubs complete with a notched plastic spreader. 
 For areas that will get the occasional splash or may suffer from condensation, a water-resistant adhesive and grout is perfectly adequate, but for surfaces such as shower cubicles, which will have to withstand prolonged wetting, it is essential to use both waterproof adhesive and waterproof grout. 
 Always use waterproof grout on tiled worktops; ordinary grout will harbour germs. 
 Grout is usually white, but you can buy coloured grout if you want to make a feature of the grout lines (an effect that looks best with plain or fairly neutral patterned tiles). 
 Floor tile adhesive is widely available in powder form as well as ready-mixed, and the former is generally more economical to use. 
 It's best always to use a waterproof type (plus waterproof grout), even in theoretically non-wet areas. 
 Adhesive and grout are both sold in a range of pack sizes, sometimes labelled by weight (in kilograms), sometimes by volume (in litres); always check the coverage given by the manufacturer when buying, so you don't over-buy or run out half-way through the job. 
 TILING WALLS 
 The best way to practise your tiling skills if you've never done any before if by covering just a small area such as a washbasin splashback, where setting out the tiles so they are centred on the area concerned is a simple job, and you have the minimum of tile cutting to do. 
 When you are tackling a larger area &mdash; a whole wall, or perhaps even a complete room &mdash; you use exactly the same techniques; the big difference is the sheer scale of the job, which makes the preliminary setting-out by far the most important part. 
 The problem is that unless you have absolutely plain walls, there will be a number of obstacles to tile round, and you have to decide how to get the best fit round them with your inflexible tile squares, without ending up cutting impossibly thin slivers to fill in all the gaps. 
 You may also want to tile awkward shapes such as the window recesses, or things like bath surrounds. 
 Here, extra care is essential to get professional-looking results. 
 PLANNING THE LAYOUT 
 If you're tiling a whole wall or room, the most important thing to do is to plan precisely where the whole tiles will fall. 
 On a flat, uninterrupted wall this is quite easy; you simply find the centre line of the wall and plan your tiling to start from there. 
 However, you will probably have obstacles such as window reveals, door openings and built-in furniture in the room, all competing to be the centre of attention, and you have to work out the best &bquo;centre point&equo; while trying to avoid having very thin cut-tile borders and edges anywhere. 
 It's best to use a device called a tiling gauge &mdash; a batten marked out in tile widths (and spaces between tiles) &mdash; to work this out. 
 It's easy to make your own from a straight piece of timber about 1.2m (4ft) long, marked off with pencil lines to match the size of tile you will be using. 
 You can then use this to ensure that on each wall your tiles will be centred accurately on  major features such as window reveals, with a border of cut tiles of equal width at each side. 
 Now turn your attention to the actual setting-out. 
 With large areas of tiling, two things are vitally important. 
 Firstly, the tile rows must be exactly horizontal; if they're not, errors will accumulate as you tile across the wall, throwing the verticals out of alignment, with disastrous results. 
 And if you're tiling right round a room, inaccurate levels will mean your rows don't match up at the start and finish point. 
 Secondly, the tiles need some support while the adhesive sets; without it, the whole tiles area could slump down the wall. 
 What you do is to fix a line of battens across the wall (or right round the room) just above skirting board level, securing them with partly-driven masonry nails so you can remove them later when the adhesive has set. 
 The precise level will be dictated by your setting-out with the tiling gauge, but will usually be between half and three-quarters of a tile width above the skirting board. 
 Don't rely on this being level; it probably won't be. 
 Draw the line out in pencil first, using your spirit level, and then pin the battens up and check the level again. 
 If you intend to tile over existing tiles, you will have to drill holes through them for the masonry pins. 
 Drill nail holes in the batten, hold it up to the wall, and drill through one batten hole into the tiling. 
 Pin this end in place, then swing the batten up to the horizontal, and drill through its other end, ready for nailing. 
 Once you have got all the battens in place, the hard part is over and you can start fixing the tiles &mdash; a job that is repetitive and boring, at least until you get to the cut bits at corners and edges. 
 Even these should fit nicely if you did your planning carefully. 
 TILING A FLOOR 
 Start with the tiles themselves. 
 Once you've decided on the type (and design, if relevant), make a note of the tile and pack size so you can work out how many to buy. 
 Some packs give a total coverage on the wrapping, but it's best to work out the total by accurately measuring the room size so you can calculate how many rows, containing how many tiles, will be needed. 
 Count part tiles as whole ones, then add an extra 5% to allow for wastage. 
 You'll also need special floor tile adhesive; there's a waterproof type for bathrooms, and a flexible type which you use when tiling on a suspended timber floor. 
 You'll need grout too, plus a tile cutter, preferably heavy-duty type, especially if using quarry tiles (Vitrex makes one which will cut wall and floor tiles); and it's worth investing in a tile file or saw if you anticipate a lot of fiddly cutting round pipes and similar obstacles, and a tile gauge if you have any really awkward shapes to tile around. 
 Quarry tiles are usually laid in a mortar bed, although you can use thick-bed tile adhesive instead. 
 It's worth hiring a heavyduty cutting jig if you have a lot of quarries to cut; ordinary cutters aren't strong enough for the job. 
 PLANNING THE LAYOUT 
 This is far easier than setting out wall tiling, because floors have far fewer obstacles than walls do. 
 The first step is to find the centre of the room by linking the mid-points of opposite walls with string lines. 
 Dry-lay a row of tiles from this point out to each wall so you can see how wide the cut border pieces will be, and adjust your starting point if necessary, to avoid having a very narrow border strip which will be difficult to cut. 
 When you're happy with the layout, mark your starting point clearly on the floor, ready for the tiles. 
 The only exception to this method is when you are laying quarry tiles in mortar; then, having set out the tiles dry, you start laying in one corner of the room, using battens as guides, and work across the room in bays four or five tiles wide. 
 FOR FURTHER INFORMATION&hellip; 
 Building Adhesives Ltd 
 All types of tile adhesives 
 Candy Tiles Ltd 
 Wall tiles include Victorian styles &amp; very modern; floor tiles include &bquo;granite&equo;, geometric terracotta &amp; patterns 
 Cristal Tiles 
 Wall tile range includes borders, floor tiles include Provencal shape 
 Dennis Ruabon Ltd 
 Quarry &amp; floor tiles, including &bquo;3D&equo; geometric shapes, in range of colours; frost-resistant 
 Fired Earth 
 Range of hand-made tiles, wall &amp; floor 
 Homelux Products Ltd 
 Tile trim, strip, corner trim, cover &amp; sealing strips 
 John Burgess Tiles 
 Range of quality reproduction Victorian &amp; Art Nouveau embossed ceramic wall &amp; floor tiles (for restoration work) 
 Langley London Ltd 
 Villeroy &amp; Boch wall, worktop, floor &amp; mosaic tiles, &amp; moulded border tiles 
 Merchant Tiler 
 Range of mainly hand-made wall &amp; floor tiles, many imported, includes terracotta &amp; slate 
 Pilkington's Tiles Ltd 
 Wall tiles 
 Ramus Tile Co Ltd 
 Range includes mosaics, wall and floor tiles 
 Royal Dutch Sphinx Ltd 
 Wall &amp; floor tiles, feature &amp; relief tile strips 
 Vitrex Ltd 
 Wide range of tiling equipment 
 Wellington Tile Co 
 Range of glazed &amp; unglazed floor quarry tiles &amp; inserts, &amp; some handmade imported wall tiles 
 Wickes Building Supplies Ltd 
 Floor &amp; wall tiles, border tiles 
 Autumn wall tiles from the New Season Collection by Cristal 
 Above: From Langley, Series Adeline Beige tiles for walls, floors and worktops 
 Left: Sphinx Corniche with fruit panel 
 Cut-outs on this page are from Dennis Ruabon's range of geometric quarry tile shapes; use as borders, or for threedimensional effects 
 Left: Cut-out from Dennis Ruabon's Start-Border design; in red, ironstone and black, it can be combined with the six standard quarry colours 
 Right: Part of a nine-tile panel design of daffodils, in black, blue and gold, Panel-Accent Orpheus, from Royal Dutch Sphinx, can be used as a feature in bathroom, hall, or even the bedroom 
 NEWS UPdate 
 ALARM AND LOCK BAR SECURES PATIO DOORS AND SLIDING SASH WINDOWS 
 Older style sash windows, modern sliding windows, and patio doors can all have added security with the new all-in-one Security Alarm and Lock Bar from Smiths Industries. 
 These battery-operated devices fit tightly between the door or window and its frame, preventing it from being forced open. 
 If there is an attempt at a forced entry, the Alarm and Lock bar flashes a bright light and sounds a loud alarm. 
 The Smiths Alarm and Lock Bar is cylindrical in shape with a diameter of 40mm to fit neatly into any door or window frame. 
 Two versions are available; one to suit lengths of between 610mm and 1040mm (24in and 41in), and one to suit lengths between 370mm and 610mm (14&frac34;in to 24in). 
 A mounting clip is available for fixing the alarm in larger openings. 
 Prices are around &pound;29 for the larger (ALB41) model, and &pound;24 for the smaller (ALB24).  
 VERTICAL BLIND HAS ALUMINIUM SLATS FOR HEAVY SERVICE 
 Faber is introducing a new vertical blind called Uprite which has aluminium slats and will give unequalled service as it can be washed and re-hung immediately. 
 The perforated slatting is ideal for kitchens at the front of the house (or overlooking the garden) as it allows privacy, conceals work areas, yet allows a view of the outside &mdash; the garden, the horizon, or just the weather! 
 The 2in (50mm) slatting has 180 pin-fine holes to the square inch and is available in eight colours: black, white, red, grey, eggshell, flint, pink, and marine blue. 
 As with all Faber vertical blinds, damaged slats can be replaced individually. 
 Vertical blinds are also practical for doorways, and can be used as shown in the photograph as a &bquo;concealer&equo; between breakfast bar and kitchen. 
 They can be parked left or right, or have a split centre draw leaving a clear throughway. 
 Two or more colours can be ordered if wanted for a specific scheme.  
 &bquo;WATER&equo; PAINT IS A PLEASANT ALTERNATIVE TO TRADITIONAL FINISHES 
 D-i-yers have a pleasant alternative to traditional paints with the launch of an innovative range of water-based paints by Dulux. 
 Available in gloss and satin finishes, the new paints result in a lower odour than traditional solvent-based paints, making home decorating a more enjoyable task for both the applier and the occupants. 
 Easy to use, the new paints require no undercoat and are quick to dry &mdash; touch dry in two hours and recoatable after six. 
 Additionally, paint brushes can be cleaned in water. 
 Dulux's water-based gloss paint comes in six ready-to-use colours, including Magnolia, Whisper Grey, and Misty Glade. 
 Both the water-based gloss and satin paints come in pure brilliant white and not only start whiter, but stay whiter than other traditional solvent-based paints. 
 Formulated for interior use only, the range is suitable for windows, doors, picture and dado rails, and skirtings. 
 The new paints are available from major d-i-y, department, and specialist decorating stores, priced from around &pound;7.49 and available in 750ml and 2.5 litre (pure brilliant white only) sizes.  
 EASY WAY TO FIX SLIPPED AND REPLACEMENT SLATES 
 Ubbink's Sim-Fix is a simple yet effective way of fixing slipped or replacement slates in an existing roof. 
 The Sim-Fix is a strap and clip made from nylon rather than upvc. 
 Nylon was chosen for its strength and its resistance to extremes of temperature and atmospheric pollution. 
 The clip is dual-purpose in that as well as holding the slate in position, it also secures it against wind uplift which is a possible cause of the original slippage. 
 With the Sim-Fix it is unnecessary to punch extra fixing points in the slate and the strap is quickly and easily nailed to the batten with three optional fixing points, making it possible to use it with any size of slate. 
 It is very light in weight and its dark colour makes it almost invisible once in place. 
 Unlike a lead tingle fixing, the Sim-Fix cannot be pushed out of place by snow slippage. 
 The strap costs around 30p and is available from Ubbink UK and its network of stockists.   
 MAKITA 9045N ORBITAL SANDER 
 This Makita finishing sander simply oozes quality. 
 As soon as you pick it up you know it is going to work well, and it does! 
 This is basically an industrial tool built for professional use, and the build quality is superb. 
 It is comfortable to hold, feels &bquo;solid&equo;, and is obviously well assembled around a die-cast aluminium frame. 
 Before you can start using the tool, a 13amp plug must be fitted to the rubber-covered lead. 
 This is 2.65m (8ft 8in) long so you are not forever dragging an extension lead socket around the workplace. 
 While it is hard-wearing and safe, rubber-covered cable has the additional benefits of being very flexible and resistant to kinking in use. 
 The machine is supplied with a pack of ten half-sheet abrasive papers to fit the 234 &times; 114mm (9&frac14; &times; 4&frac12;in) base pad. 
 To fit the abrasive sheet it is first necessary to push the dust frame cover off the front or back of the machine. 
 Fitting the abrasive sheet under the end clamps is easy to achieve by easing the push buttons on the deck of the machine inwards using a thumb. 
 The instructions supplied with the tool recommend pre-bending the paper to help in fitting it tightly, but we found this unnecessary. 
 The machine can be used without the dust frame cover which simply snaps on to the decking, but in this case you will lose the benefits of dust extraction; to this end, a dust bag is supplied and this very simply pushes into a part of the side of the machine. 
 There is a small spring catch to hold the dust bag in place and at the correct alignment. 
 The bag should be emptied before it gets about half full and this is achieved by turning the bag anti-clockwise so that the spout can be pulled out of the dust port. 
 You would not expect a well-made machine like this to be light, and at 2.8kg (6.2lb) it isn't, so you need the two handles moulded into the case of the machine to help hold it. 
 These make it easy to control the tool, but it is still best to sand surfaces horizontally whenever possible. 
 The on/off switch at the top of the main handle is very easy to operate with the thumb. 
 The sander has a smooth and powerful 520watt motor and its easy action is helped by the ball-bearing construction. 
 The pad oscillates very fast (10,000 orbits/min), with an orbit diameter of 2.4mm, and this makes for quick and efficient swirl-free sanding. 
 The dust extraction system is quite efficient; it certainly keeps a lot of the dust out of the air, but there is still quite a bit of dust on the surface of the workpiece after you finish sanding. 
 The dust cover prevents the machine from sanding right up to return edges; it keeps it away about 10mm (&frac38;in) at the sides and 15mm (&frac58;in) at the ends. 
 However, the cover is very easily removed if you need to get into a tight corner. 
 WHAT IT COSTS 
 At &pound;175 including VAT this is not a cheap sander, but you get what you pay for and for the keen d-iyer or woodworker, or even a tradesman, this is an excellent tool that should last a lifetime.   
 Push buttons on deck make it easy to clamp abrasive sheet in place 
 Dust frame cover simply snaps into place on the base pad 
 On/off switch is conveniently placed on the main handle 
 This sander smooths large areas of timber very efficiently 
 BOSCH ALL PURPOSE SAW MODEL PFZ 550 PE 
 At the start of this test we thought that we were reviewing an all-purpose saw, but in fact we discovered that the Bosch All Purpose saw, model PFZ 550 PE, is a lot more &bquo;all purpose&equo; than we thought. 
 With the right accessories it can also be used for metal filing, wood and plastic rasping, and for brushing! 
 The saw has a 550watt (input) motor and features variable speed and orbital action saw blade, yet it  weights  only 3kg (6.6lb) so it is quite light to use. 
 The blade, which is something like a large jigsaw blade, protrudes from the front of the saw to give a cutting capacity of 150mmin wood and 12mm in steel, as long as the correct blade is fitted. 
 The blade has a stroke of 26mm (about 1in) and the noload stroke rate is between 500 and 2600/minute. 
 This tool is supplied with a plug ready-fitted (well done Bosch!) 
 and a generous 4m (13ft 1&frac12;in) of cable lead. 
 Fitting the blade is easy using the allen key supplied to clamp the blade between the blade holder and a clamping plate as often found on jigsaws. 
 To start the saw, the starting lock at the top of the handle has to be pressed forwards and at the same time the trigger switch is squeezed. 
 The saw is fitted with a quick-stop blade system, and as soon as the trigger is released, the blade stops almost instantaneously; a good safety feature. 
 The stroke rate is controlled by squeezing the trigger, and a particular stroke rate can be pre-selected by turning a small thumb wheel situated on the trigger. 
 The orbital movement of the blade, which helps to speed cutting by aiding the removal of sawdust, has three settings. 
 One setting gives the full orbital movement for fast, rough cutting in wood and softer materials. 
 A lower setting gives slight orbital movement for harder materials, while the third setting allows the orbital action to be switched off for a straight reciprocating movement for filing or rasping, or fine cutting in hard materials. 
 For most cuts, the work is steadied against the foot plate which can be angled to bring it into contact with the workpiece; because the teeth of the sawblade tend to become worn close to the foot plate, the plate can be unclamped and moved forwards to bring a fresh section of the blade into use. 
 The saw is supplied with a general purpose wood cutting blade which is ideal for rough cutting. 
 However, with a five-piece saw blade set (Part No 2 608 650 330) the use of the saw is considerably enhanced. 
 This kit contains a blade suitable for cutting wood with nails, plasterboard and non-ferrous metals; a fast-cutting blade for wood and plastics; a blade for iron and non-ferrous metals; a rough/fast cut blade for wood; and a useful flexible blade for non-ferrous metals. 
 In one of the photographs we show the latter being used to cut off a water pipe close to the floor. 
 Also available is a file for metal and a rasp for wood which we found very useful for shaping and smoothing these materials. 
 Although we didn't try them, a selection of brushes is also available. 
 We would imagine that the wire brush is very handy for cleaning up old iron and steel. 
 It is no good pretending that you are ever going to do fine woodwork with this All Purpose saw, but for rough cutting and shaping it has many uses around the house. 
 One useful technique is plunge cutting into a surface, such as floorboards when these need to be lifted. 
 You hold the machine on the surface and gradually tilt the blade downwards to saw through. 
 It takes a bit of practice, but this is a useful technique to master. 
 Of course, if you prefer, you can drill a hole through which the tip of the blade can be inserted. 
 WHAT IT COSTS 
 At &pound;151.83 this would be a very useful tool to buy for those odd jobs about the house and garden.   
 Blade fitting and a selection of blades available 
 The saw is ideal for rough cutting, such as sawing logs 
 Shaping wood with the rasp tool fitted. 
 Metal file also available. 
 Using the flexible blade to saw through a water pipe flush with floor 
 HITACHI FG10SA DISC GRINDER 
 Disc grinders are still generally associated with trade use &mdash; cutting paving slabs, car bodywork repairs and the like. 
 However, their use to the d-i-yer can be worth the &pound;50&ndash;&pound;100 investment. 
 The Hitachi FG10SA is the Japanese company's answer to the home improvement/small tradesman market. 
 Based on the smallest of the commonly available disc sizes, the 100mm (4in), the machine is almost identical to its larger brother, the FG12SA. 
 Setting up the tool requires only the two spanners provided as standard accessories. 
 One holds the spindle steady whilst the other fits into the twin holes on the wheel nut and tightens the disc in place. 
 Also provided with the grinder is a disc for use on metalwork. 
 Finally, a screw-in side handle is fixed on to the alloy gear cover, offset either to the left or right depending on the user. 
 Once in place, Hitachi recommends a trial in a safe area to ensure everything is properly assembled. 
 This, like all safety instructions, should always be followed. 
 Damaged discs or grinders can be very hazardous and gloves and goggles must be worn. 
 Like all disc grinders, the body shell is basically a cover for a powerful motor which drives the disc at high speed. 
 In this case, a 550 watt motor provides the power behind the 11,000rpm disc. 
 Unlike some machines of this wattage, noise was well suppressed and only became excessive when the disc was used on stonework. 
 Applying the 1.6kg tool to metalwork proved easy, even for the inexperienced. 
 We put the machine to the test removing rust from a section of decorative ironwork and the only problem was the tendency of the disc to bite into the metal if too much pressure was applied. 
 This will happen with all grinders if used too enthusiastically. 
 It is important to let the tool's weight do the work. 
 The only control on the single speed machine is the on/off rocker switch mounted on the top of the machine, towards the front of the green plastic casing. 
 To turn the grinder on, the switch is eased forward until it clicks downwards. 
 As a safety feature, the rocker need only be lightly touched on the back section to cut the motor. 
 Hitachi have also taken the trouble to make the control large enough to operate when wearing thick gloves. 
 Grinders should be held at a shallow angle of between 15 and 30&deg; to the work when they are used to abrade the surface. 
 This offers the maximum amount of disc edge to the work and does not overload the motor. 
 When in use, the semi-circular wheel guard of the Hitachi deflects sparks, chippings etc away from the operator. 
 Two screws hold the guard in the optimum position, the open sides pointing directly away from the body of the machine. 
 However, the guard can be loosened and repositioned for particularly awkward jobs, as long as it is fully retightened. 
 In all, the FG10SA performed well on metal and stone. 
 The machine comes with a 100mm disc but the guard will allow the fitting of the standard 115mm disc. 
 Build quality seemed good and there are now enough agents in this country to make servicing and spares less of a worry. 
 WHAT IT COSTS 
 The Hitachi FG10SA recommended retail price is &pound;80.65. 
 Spare discs are &pound;1.64  
 Changing the 100mm discs using the spanners provided 
 For grinding, the disc is kept at a shallow angle to the work 
 Scoring a paving slab with a stone cutting disc 
 Screw-in handle can be attached to either side 
 PROLINE PL28 ROTARY HAMMER DRILL 
 If you think you've already got a hammer drill, then it's time to think again! 
 With the Black &amp; Decker Proline PL28 Rotary Hammer Drill, drilling holes in masonry and concrete takes on a whole new meaning. 
 It differs from ordinary hammer drills (which operate on a ratchet/percussion mechanism) because it is operated by an electro-pneumatic mechanism. 
 This is like a road-maker's pneumatic breaker in miniature, except that the drill bit rotates to clear the debris from the hole. 
 With this new drill, the energy from the motor is transmitted directly to the drill bit via a piston and beat piece. 
 The material being drilled is effectively broken up by the drill bit, and the rotary action of the drill bit is primarily to remove debris from the hole. 
 To make a hole in masonry or concrete you do not need to exert anything like the pressure you do with a conventional percussion/ratchet hammer drill which basically relies on drill rotation to wear away the material. 
 The new rotary hammer virtually smashes its way through hard materials. 
 When you look at the new PL28 drill, the first thing you notice about it is the absence of a conventional three-jaw chuck for holding the masonry bit. 
 Instead there is a special tool holder to take SDS (special drill system) drill bits. 
 The SDS drill bits have four slots in the shank which are quickly slotted into place in the tool holder. 
 Removing them should also be quick by simply depressing the sleeve of the holder in the direction of the arrow so the bit can be pulled out. 
 Probably due to the newness of our sample, this proved quite difficult to do, but by the end of the test it was getting easier, either because the sleeve was wearing in, or because we were developing the knack &mdash; you must push the sleeve right back. 
 Incidentally, all sizes of SDS drill bits have the same size of drill shank to fit the standard tool holder. 
 The tool is supplied without a plug, but the lead is a generous 4m (13ft 1&frac12;in) of rubber-covered flex so there should not be too much need for trailing extension leads. 
 For a 450 watt electro-pneumatic rotary hammer drill, the PL28 is compact, but with an overall length of about 12&frac12;in (without the drill bit) you need a fairly unobstructed area in which to work. 
 It works with a variable speed trigger, but the speed (0&ndash;400rpm) is considerably slower than a normal percussion drill. 
 However, it drills three times as fast with only one third of the effort required with a normal percussion drill. 
 It has reverse action which is basically used for removing debris and jammed drill bits. 
 Its relatively light weight (1.9kg/4lb) makes drilling above shoulder height a lot less tiring than with the normal electropneumatic hammer drills which you may hire. 
 The drill is basically designed for drilling holes into extremely hard masonry, usually for some type of fixing, or to clear a way for cables or pipes. 
 It does this extremely efficiently, but if you want to use the tool for conventional drilling and screwdriving, the hammer action must be switched off and you need an SDS adaptor (Part No A13123) which will screw into a &frac12;in chuck with a &frac12;in female thread fitting (part No. 
 A5223). 
 It is important not to use conventional chucks for hammer drilling. 
 WHAT IT COSTS 
 At &pound;117.95 the B &amp; D Proline PL28 is an excellent buy for anyone who frequently needs to drill into materials .  
 Slide the sleeve right back in order to fit an SDS drill bit 
 A conventional chuck being fitted using an SDS adaptor 
 Drill held by side handle with two fingers on the trigger 
 Drilling a bolt hole in a concrete floor is easy with pneumatic action 
 YOUR SAY 
 If you've an interesting d-i-y tale to share, we'd like to hear from you. 
 We pay &pound;5 for every letter published. 
 Write to  
 SAW POINT 
 Some years ago, my father built an 8in rise-and-fall tilt arbour saw bench from a set of plans produced by Cliff Bowers. 
 Over the years, he has used it for many successful d-i-y projects. 
 However, he eventually sold it, and replaced it with another model. 
 Following in my father's footsteps, I would like to build myself a Cliff Bowers saw bench. 
 I have scoured magazines for any information on this subject, but so far, to no avail. 
 I would be very grateful if any of your readers could assist me in obtaining an address to write to, or better still, a copy of the plans. 
 I would be pleased to reimburse any costs incurred. 
  KE Smith, Newport, Isle of Wight  
 Can any of our readers help? 
 If you can, write to the address at the top of the page, and we'll forward your letters to Mr Smith &mdash; Ed. 
 NO PROBLEM 
 Many household jobs are basically easy, and are only made difficult because they're so inaccessible. 
 I found this to be the case when trying to replace a ballcock valve washer in a hot water tank in a very narrow airing cupboard. 
 I overcame the problem by making the shelves in the cupboard easily removable. 
 Using 3&frac12;&times; &frac34;in wooden slats resting on battens, I made spacers from the same wood, and glued these to the battens. 
 There's no need to nail the shelves down, as they can't move sideways because of the spacers. 
 Except for the few slats supporting the tank, all the shelves in the cupboard can be removed in a moment, making access really easy. 
  S Cox, Gosport, Hants  
 ICE IDEA 
 When inserting posts or stakes into the ground for use as fence supports, good rigidity can be ensured by inserting the post through the centre of a four-litre plastic ice cream carton, then filling it with concrete mix. 
 The carton and post are then buried at the required depth. 
 The container holds the mix until set, and can be left in the ground. 
  L Stringer, Derby, Derbyshire  
 STAR LETTER PRIZE 
 The lucky winner of this month's Star Letter Prize will receive a free pack of essential Evo-Stik products worth over &pound;50. 
 The pack includes some of the ever popular Make 'n' Mend range, such as Evo-Stik Household Adhesive, Fabric Adhesive and Super Glue. 
 Other products are Evo-Stik Wood Adhesive Waterproof, the ideal choice for all general woodworking jobs, Bath, Sink and Shower Sealant, Outdoor Sealant and All Purpose Silicone Sealant, from the market-leading Evo-Seal range. 
 Last but not least, the pack includes Evo-Stik Impact 2 Adhesive, which is a safe, solvent free and non-flammable contact adhesive. 
 Happy sticking! 
 STAR LETTER 
 NUTS 'N' BOLTS 
 I do the odd bit of d-i-y round the home, which I don't find too difficult, being an engineer by trade. 
 But my pet hate is woodwork joinery. 
 When faced with a request for a garden seat, similar to the one on a recent DIY front cover, I searched high and low for one which I could buy, rather than make myself. 
 But a well-built version cost over &pound;100, and one at about &pound;50 seemed far too rickety. 
 I eventually resolved to make one, but overcame the drudgery of all those mortise and tenon joints by developing the following method: 
 1 
 Mark positions of the joints. 
 2 
 Buy some long bolts, 3in long, &frac14;in diameter, with slotted heads and square nuts. 
 3 
 Drill a hole just oversize for the bolt head diameter, about &frac14; to &frac38;in deep. 
 4 
 Drill through a &frac14;in diameter clearance hole. 
 5 
 With the bolt in the hole, bring up the second part of the joint, and mark round the circumference of the bolt. 
 6 
 Drill the end of this piece with a &frac14;in diameter clearance hole to required depth. 
 7 
 Cross-drill on the mark, to about three-quarters of the total thickness, or right through. 
 8 
 Coat the end of the wood with quick-set glue. 
 Use tweezers to put a nut on the end of the bolt in the cross-hole, and screw the bolt tight, initially preventing the nut from turning by using a screwdriver. 
 9 
 When set, fill the holes with matching dowelling and glue, or plastic wood. 
 Result &mdash; a rock-steady garden seat, built in less than a day, for less than &pound;40. 
 And no fiddly joints to cut! 
  M J Pinner, Sheffield, Yorks  
 DIY DISASTER 
 We've all had our d-i-y disasters &mdash; but some are worse than others!  
 Douglas Kane Ltd, distributor of the famous OBO range of home improvement products, is inviting you to send in details of your worst d-i-y disaster. 
 In return they will give &pound;30, and a range of OBO fixings worth another &pound;20, to the most amusing letter each month &mdash; to make sure you get it right next time! 
 Each OBO fixings prize pack will contain a selection of Terrier Nails (a wood-to-wood nail specially designed to provide the fixing strength of a wood screw), special Masonry Nails (general purpose nails which fix wood to all kinds of masonry without drilling, plugging or screwing), and Timber Connectors (for creating a permanent fixture without the need for screwing or nailing).  
 A CRACKING TIME 
 When we redesigned the bathroom in our Victorian terrace, we fitted a shower in one of the bedrooms, to allow dismantling and fitting to proceed at a more leisurely pace. 
 Working late one Saturday night, wanting to finish &bquo;just one more job&equo;, I was hammering in a cross-piece on the adjacent wardrobe, when my hammer  slipper . 
 I watched it float in slow motion towards the ceramic shower base, which it cracked neatly in two. 
 The whole unit had to be dismantled to allow a new base to be fitted &mdash; a costly and time-consuming disaster, which taught me that 11pm on Saturday, at the end of a tiring day, is not the time to be doing d-i-y! 
  AG Regan, Gosforth, Tyne &amp; Wear   
 SPECIAL OFFERS 
 WOLFCRAFT BENCH SANDER FROM &pound;34.95 
 You will probably never realise how useful a bench sander can be until you have tried one. 
 While self powered bench sanders are available an excellent introduction to this machine is via the Wolfcraft Bench Sander drill attachment. 
 This sander was featured in our May 1991 issue. 
 We were so impressed with the unit that we have arranged a Special Offer for DIY readers. 
 It is made to the usual high Wolfcraft standards using thick steel for the bench table and a cast alloy housing for the disc. 
 The disc itself spins easily on a sealed ball-bearing race. 
 The sander is clamped on to the edge of a workbench so the disc is vertical and the shank of the disc is locked securely into your power-drill chuck &mdash; most drills with a standard 43mm diameter neck are suitable. 
 It is important to set the drill on a high speed setting (5,000rpm maximum), and the disc must turn in the direction shown by the arrow on the housing. 
 The bench table is clamped securely in position by means of two tommy bar bolts. 
 For most applications, you can use a try square to set the table at 90&deg;, but the table can be angled downwards and locked for sanding angles down to 45&deg;. 
 The bench table is fitted with a very useful horizontal angleguide which can be locked into any position in front of the disc, or it can be locked at the desired angle while being free to slide in a slot parallel with the disc face. 
 The Wolfcraft Bench Sander is ideal for truing up faces of timber prior to making joints, especially mitre-joints (ideal for frame makers!) 
 In addition, you can use it for metal-grinding, for instance when sharpening cold chisels, rotary-mower blades and other cutting tool blades. 
 The Wolfcraft Bench Sander normally comes with three grades of sanding/grinding discs &mdash; coarse, medium and fine. 
 These simply and securely fit on to the 178mm (7in) diameter disc using a Velcro-type fastening. 
 It is very easy to change the discs when necessary. 
 We are including an extra pack of two coarse discs for you in the pack &mdash; worth &pound;2.69. 
 The Wolfcraft Bench Sander normally sells for &pound;35.35 but we are offering the complete kit for only &pound;34.95, saving over &pound;3 on the usual prices. 
 Use Ref: WBS on the order form when ordering. 
 Extra sanding discs are available for only &pound;2.49 if ordered at the same time as the Bench Sander. 
 Use Refs: WBDC (coarse); WBDM (medium); and WBDF (fine) on the order form when ordering. 
 WOLFCRAFT WALLCHASER ONLY &pound;15.95 
 Anyone who has ever tried chiselling out a channel in a wall to accommodate electrical conduit or other piping will appreciate this useful accessory from Wolfcraft. 
 It simply fits on to a standard 43mm diameter drill chuck and uses a 12mm diameter tungsten-carbide tipped cutter to channel into breeze-block, brick, plaster and other wall surfaces. 
 The Wallchaser can be easily guided along using the control handle and support wheels. 
 It usually sells for &pound;18.13 but we are offering it for only &pound;15.95, saving over &pound;2. 
 Use Ref: WWC on the order form when ordering. 
 Additional 12mm diameter cutting bits are available for &pound;6.50 each if ordered at the same time as the Wallchaser. 
 Use Ref: WWCB on the order form when ordering.  
 C.K. 
 NON-RETURN VALVE ONLY &pound;16.95 
 GARDEN TAPS AND THE LAW 
 There are new, far-reaching water bye-laws now operating. 
 These came into force January 1989 but they are still not widely known. 
 Bye-laws 17, 18 and 22 deal with back-siphoning: wherever a cold water supply is connected to a flexible hose, the law insists that the tap or outlet is fitted with a non-return valve to prevent contaminating liquids being sucked back into the mains system by any fall in pressure. 
 It does not take much imagination to realise the very serious risks if, for instance, a modern weed-killer solution contaminated drinking water supplies. 
 Most modern household appliances, such as washing machines and dishwashers are already fitted with non-return devices. 
 As a householder you should pay particular attention to outdoor threaded bib-taps which are usually used for garden hoses and sprinklers. 
 Unless you already have a non-return valve fitted (and only the very newest installations will have this built-in) a double-check and drain valve is needed to comply with the law. 
 We have arranged a special offer with C.K. 
 Tools this month: their swivel-action valve is made from rust-proof solid brass. 
 It comes complete with all fittings for usual tap-threads, and all you will need is a wrench to tighten it in position to comply with the law &mdash; incidentally, a fine of up to &pound;400 can be imposed for non-compliance with the law! 
 The C.K. 
 non-return valve is Water Research Council listed and the patented, lock swivel fitting prevents removal, plus giving a kink-free movement to your hose. 
 You can pay up to &pound;20 for similar valves but we are offering the C.K. non-return valve for only &pound;16.95 including VAT and carriage  &mdash; a small price for such a sensible permanent accessory. 
 Use reference CK on the attached order form when ordering.  
 RESIDUAL CURRENT ADAPTOR OFFER ONLY &pound;18.95 
 If you use any mains electrical appliance or tool outdoors, or where there is a possibility of water spillage, or even using ordinary power tools indoors like drills and saws, you could be putting yourself at risk. 
 Frayed or cut wires, for instance, can destroy expensive property by fire or even kill through electrocution. 
 We have arranged a special offer with one of the UK leading manufacturers for their new RCD adaptor. 
 The INPUT SHOTECTOR works by monitoring the current flowing in the &bquo;live&equo; and &bquo;neutral&equo; wires and is activated by any leakage of current to earth &mdash; perhaps through you! 
 It senses the danger and almost instantaneously cuts off the power with a speed of reaction which can prevent a tragedy occurring. 
 The Shotector simply plugs into any standard &bquo;square&equo; pin socket. 
 You then plug your appliance into the adaptor &mdash; absolutely no wiring or electrical know-how is needed. 
 The Shotector has an easily accessible Test/Reset button to give you additional peace of mind each time you use it. 
 It is made to BS1363 and 4293. 
 You can pay up to &pound;24.95 for RCD adaptors in the shops, but we can supply the INPUT SHOTECTOR for only &pound;18.95 including VAT and carriage.  
 Please use reference PRCD on the order form.   
 MAKITA COMPETITION 
 WIN! &pound;2,500 WORTH OF POWER TOOLS 
 Makita power tools are the very best quality and are built to industrial standards, not only to take hard work, but also to incorporate many safety features. 
 Now the range has been extended with the Makita &bquo;Pro-Range&equo; and in this exclusive competition, we are pleased to offer compendium kits of these fabulous tools as prizes. 
 Each tool kit contains SIX Makita power tools and is worth &pound;760, and we have THREE of these sets as prizes. 
 In addition, there are 21 runner-up prizes of leather tool holsters worth over &pound;10.50 each. 
 These are just the job if you need to carry a rechargeable drill around with you, especially when working from a ladder or steps. 
 One of the first prizes is shown in the main photograph. 
 It comprises model 6092 DWK Drill/Driver; model 1901 82mm Power Planer; model 3620 Plunge Router; model 4320 Jigsaw; model 500 140mm Circular Saw; and model BO4510 Palm Sander. 
 The 6092DWK Drill/Driver is at the top of the Pro-Range of cordless drills. 
 This 9.6 volt machine with a 10mm chuck, two speed gearbox, variable speed trigger and electric brake makes the 6092DWK a very capable power tool for any job, whether it involves drilling or screwing in materials such as wood, metal, plastics or laminates. 
 Where a power planer is required, then the Pro-Range's 1901 is the machine to have. 
 With an infinite adjustment depth of cutting control mounted on the front of the machine, coupled to the TCT mini blades, the power to produce 3200 cuts per minute and a non-marking die-cast aluminium base, all mean accuracy, and that a professional finish is made so much easier. 
 The Pro-Range Router is one of the most versatile machines available for the woodworker, being lightweight and highly manoeuvrable, with a three stage depth stop. 
 Whether for chamfering, grooving, templating or using it for intricate decorative work, this machine will help you do it cleanly and quickly. 
 The 4320 jigsaw has a variable speed control mounted in the trigger, a lock-on button to maintain the desired cutting speed and has the air flow cleverly directed forward to clean dust off the cutting line. 
 The bevel allows cuts of 0&deg;&ndash;45&deg; to both right and left, and the machine comes with a Perspex guard over the front of the blade to protect the operator. 
 The 500 Circular Saw has a bright red lock-off switch fitted which only allows two-handed operation for operator safety, and prevents the machine from being started accidentally. 
 There is also a telescopic blade guard to protect the operator, and a riving knife to stop the timber from jamming. 
 Standard equipment includes a tungsten carbide-tipped (TCT) blade. 
 The BO4510 Palm Sander is the ideal tool for all those small awkward jobs involving sanding into tight corners or confined spaces, or sanding between staircase rail supports. 
 It is a light-weight, yet incredibly powerful machine which offers finger-tip control and over 12,000 sanding orbits per minute.   
 Rustic appeal 
 Create your own oasis of rustic charm with an intimate and cosy garden like this. 
 Use plenty of shrubs for privacy as well as a profusion of blooms, and use rustic features to create a focal point and provide useful extra height&hellip;   
 How to make a rustic arch 
 Assemble the sides on the ground, using stout rustic poles treated with a timber preservative and galvanised nails. 
 The top should be at least 2.4m (8ft) above ground level 
 Excavate holes for the support poles, and wedge them in place with broken brick and rubble. 
 Top off with a concrete mix to fix the supports securely 
 Nail the cross members to join the two sides. 
 To make the structure more rigid cut and fix four angled poles into the corners as shown to act as braces  
 NEWS UPdate 
 MAINTENANCE-FREE AND TROUBLE-FREE PLASTIC BOARDS 
 Plastic windows are widely fitted as maintenance-free alternatives to timber. 
 Now it is possible to have maintenancefree plastic boards fitted on the exterior of the home to replace timber fascia boards, barge boards and weatherboards. 
 Made from cellular upvc, they are ideal for replacing those boards which are on a high level and consequently difficult to paint. 
 Once installed, they cannot rot or be attacked by woodworm, and will never need painting. 
 One supplier of this type of boarding, Caradon Celuform, now offers much more than just a maintenancefree material. 
 It has introduced a scheme whereby householders who have Celuform materials fitted by a Company-approved installer are protected by an insurance-backed guarantee on labour and materials. 
 In addition, they are protected against the insolvency of the installer. 
 Under the Celuform scheme, the Company guarantees that faulty workmanship and materials is put right even if the installer has ceased trading.  
 PORTABLE DOORCHIME SOUNDS ANYWHERE 
 The limitations associated with conventional doorbells and chimes which cannot be heard clearly in rooms far away from the source of the sound, or in the garden, are overcome with a new portable wire-free doorchime from Friedland. 
 Suitable for use both indoors and out, with a range up to 50m, the new Courier chime enables the presence of visitors at the front door to be signalled clearly to homeowners no matter where they are located, whether in the house or garden. 
 In addition to its use as a versatile doorchime, the Courier can also be used by the elderly, the disabled and bedridden as a handy low-cost call device. 
 The Courier operates from batteries and therefore is very easy to install. 
 It comprises a transmitter and a portable receiver which is designed to be moved from one location to another as required. 
 As a doorchime, the transmitter is connected to a conventional bell-push, with the receiver unit simply positioned in any location within a 50m radius of the transmitter. 
 The Courier chime retails at around &pound;38 and is available from leading department stores, d-i-y stores and most good electrical stockists.  
 MINIATURE MEASURING TAPE AVAILABLE FOR FREE 
 The Stanley Powerlock, the world's best-selling pocket measuring tape, is being given away in miniature to help keep house, car and office keys easily to hand. 
 The keychain Powerlock, worth &pound;5, is being given away free of charge with each purchase of 5m/16ft, 8m/26ft and 10m/33ft Powerlock tapes. 
 Stanley Powerlock rules have chromium-plated cases for strength and durability. 
 The steel blades are protected by a Mylar coating for wear resistance, giving protection up to 10 times longer than the blade's normal life. 
 Clear graduations are printed in black and red, whilst &bquo;true-zero&equo; sliding hooks maintain a high degree of accuracy.  
 CONSIDER WINDOWS IF YOU ARE REPLACING AN OLD GARAGE DOOR 
 If you are thinking of replacing an old garage door, consider all the options which have &bquo;opened up&equo; since you last fitted one, say specialists Cardale Doors. 
 Changing a garage door, they say, has become a simple home improvement which can result in ongoing maintenance simplicity. 
 Ready-finished doors are now among those on offer and these require just an occasional wipe over to keep them looking immaculate. 
 Cardale have around 350 design, material and size options, with an additional choice of operating gear. 
 Steel, coated steel, timber and glass fibre are the commonly used materials for up and over doors, but you should also consider steel curtain roller doors, and doors with windows, as shown here. 
 This is an easy way of getting light into a garage, and the glazing material used by Cardale is said to be 100 times stronger than glass. 
 It is available in frosted, diamond and square-leaded designs, and even in &bquo;stained-glass&equo; forms.   
 TEST YOUR DIY SKILLS WITH GUINNESS ORIGINAL&hellip; and win a holiday for two to the Caribbean 
 In this fun competition from Guinness Original and DIY, you can test your d-i-y skills, pass on useful tips that can win you &pound;100, and  have a chance to win a dream holiday for two to the Caribbean worth up to &pound;3,500, with another &pound;500 spending money. 
 The Star Prize is a two-centre holiday for two the sunny Caribbean islands of Antigua (pictured above) and Barbados, organised by Kuoni Worldwide. 
 The winner and their partner will spend the first week in Antigua, based at Hawksbill Bay, with its four magnificent beaches. 
 They'll be able to bask in the sun, visit some of the hundreds of palm-fringed coves around the island, or participate in excellent watersports. 
 For the second week they'll be whisked off to lively Barbados, where they will stay at the Discovery Bay Hotel on the fashionable West Coast of the island. 
 The competition is being run for five months, of which this is the fourth, so you've still got two chances to win this holiday of a lifetime. 
 Each entry goes into the Grand Draw, so the more monthly competitions you enter, the greater your chances of winning. 
 As well as the Star Prize, each month we'll be choosing the best Original Tip from those sent in, and the winner will receive a &pound;100 bonus prize. 
 The entry will go back into the bag for the Grand Draw, so you'll have the chance of winning more than one prize if you fill in this section &mdash; but it is entirely optional. 
 As a final bonus, the senders of the first 500 entries received each month will be sent a 50p money-off voucher redeemable against any future purchase of Guinness Original. 
 HOW TO ENTER 
 All you have to do is study the picture printed on the Entry Form, circle the 10 deliberate d-i-y mistakes it contains, and locate the hidden bottle of Guinness Original, which you should also highlight with a circle. 
 Remember to add your Top Tip if you wish to enter the optional part of this fabulous competition. 
 You may include a separate piece of paper for this, but print your name on it very clearly. 
 Fill in your name and address, and send the Entry Form to the address on the form to arrive by 16 September 1991. 
 If you include a tip, put a &bquo;T&equo; on the back of the envelope. 
 Then sit back and relax by opening a chilled bottle of Guinness Original. 
 Pour it slowly into a glass, study the rich oatmeal head and dark velvet body, then enjoy its distinctive bitter taste as you slowly drink it. 
 What better way to reward yourself! 
 Don't forget, the first 500 entrants each month will receive a 50p money-off voucher for Guinness Original, so don't delay &mdash; post your entry today!   
 ADVICE CENTRE 
 FIDOR 
 If you're converting your loft, or want a fitted bedroom or bathroom, you'll probably be making use of fibreboards in one shape or another. 
 To help you get to grips with the different grades, types and finishes of these products, you'd be well advised to contact FIDOR (Fibre Building Board Organisation), the trade association for the fibre building board industry. 
 FIDOR was formed in 1953 to promote and develop the UK market for fibre building boards. 
 It is an international trade association whose members include distributors, importers, processors, UK and overseas manufacturers, and UK agents; and it currently represents over 90% of suppliers to the UK market. 
 There are three basic types of fibreboards: mdf (or medium density fibreboard), hardboard, and softboard (often called insulating board), and within these categories boards may also vary in size, grade, properties and finish. 
 Possible applications range from loft insulation to making fitted furniture, so selecting the right board for the job is vital. 
 FREE ADVICE 
 The association offers specialist advice, literature and information free of charge. 
 On average FIDOR handles around 10,000 enquiries every year, and of these, around 50% are from members of the general public. 
 Many requests are for details of fibreboard d-i-y projects &mdash; FIDOR can supply booklets which will enable you to construct a serving trolley, make a bedhead, build a stylish fire surround, or a kitchen island unit. 
 For the more ambitious, these brochures also include design ideas for carrying out a loft conversion and constructing a fitted kitchen, bathroom or bedroom &mdash; each contains full working instructions and lists of materials needed. 
 Technical queries handled by FIDOR staff range from the fixing and finishing of mdf &mdash; a grey area to many d-i-yers; to advice on how to &bquo;condition&equo; fibreboards to prevent warping. 
 Other queries involve a spot of detective work, such as trying to identify a particular type of fibreboard needed for refurbishment work. 
 FIBREBOARDS 
 Standard hardboard  provides a durable, cost effective floor overlay. 
 Laid mesh side up it gives a good base for carpets and tiles, and smooth side up it can be painted and stencilled to match design schemes. 
 Hardboard is also ideal for facing walls with problem surfaces. 
 Panels can be painted, papered or purchased in pre-decorated finishes to simulate anything from tiles to woodgrain. 
 Tempered hardboard  (tempered with oil or resin) is more durable and water-resistant, so can be used outdoors, eg as a wall lining or cladding; or indoors as a very hard-wearing floorcovering. 
 Softboard  has a spongy texture, which gives it good sound and thermal insulation properties. 
 It can be used under hardboard to cover floors (where it improves noise insulation and cuts heat loss), or in sheet or tile form to improve the appearance of ceilings. 
 It is easy to cut and handle and can be decorated with paper or textured paint. 
 All the association's leaflets make extensive use of mdf , a fibreboard that handles like solid wood, and is stable and smooth on both sides. 
 Mdf's smooth surface enables it to accept all types of finishes, from veneers and laminates, to paints and varnishes. 
 The absence of knots also means there is little wastage. 
 Commonly used for furniture units, panelling and partitions, the scope of mdf is increasing all the time, as moistureresistant, fire-resistant and exterior grades are coming on to the market, together with pre-finished d-i-y products such as skirtings, covings, architraves, mouldings and floor panels. 
 Fibreboards are also a fairly &bquo;green&equo; product, as wood fibre comes mainly from plantation sources, wood waste and forest thinnings &mdash; and they're relatively inexpensive to buy. 
 Both hardboard and softboard can be specified with Class 1 &bquo;Surface Spread of Flame&equo; ratings. 
 CONDITIONING 
 In common with all woodbased materials, fibre building boards must be conditioned before they are cut or fixed in place. 
 This means that their moisture content should be in balance with their surroundings. 
 If boards take up moisture once they've been fixed, they will expand and distort. 
 To condition hardboards, leave them in the room where they are to be fixed for a minimum of three days. 
 Place them so that air can freely circulate around the back. 
 The above method will be adequate in most cases, such as in occupied, heated buildings. 
 However, if the house has been unoccupied for some time, the boards will need to be conditioned with water &mdash; this method can also help to flatten wavy boards. 
 (FIDOR's data sheet SR/2 gives full information on both types of conditioning). 
 FLOATING FLOORS 
 On concrete : These consist of a standard or impregnated softboard, in combination with a hardboard overlay. 
 Standard softboard has good heat insulation properties, and the impregnated version will resist moisture ingress. 
 Any irregularities in the concrete will be &bquo;absorbed&equo; by the softboard, giving a better surface to walk on. 
 On timber : Floating floors are commonly used where existing floorboards are basically sound, but not in good enough repair to sand and seal. 
 Hardboard is laid mesh side up, to provide a nonslip surface for carpeting; and a key for adhesive, if tiles are to be fixed on top. 
 If the board is intended to be on view, it should be laid smooth side up, then finished with a paint or varnish coating. 
 The floating floor itself consists of a &bquo;sandwich&equo; of softboard laid underneath the hardboard. 
 This method serves a dual function &mdash; it will absorb irregularities in the existing floorboards, and also muffle sound. 
 FIDOR also supplies leaflets on the use of fibreboard for floors, walls and ceilings, and can give details of stockists in your area. 
 For further information contact:  
 EXTERIOR PAINTS 
 Rendered or dashed walls can always benefit from a coat of good exterior wall paint, and surfaces which are already painted will probably need recoating every few years. 
 We review some of the materials available. 
 If you have a good facing brick, it is generally best not to paint it or seal it with any kind of coating. 
 Once on, paint is virtually impossible to remove. 
 If you have a penetrating damp problem, treat brick with a silicone water repellent. 
 TYPES OF PAINT 
 Some water-based emulsion  paints are suitable for use outside. 
 They must contain a fungicide for this use (to inhibit mould growth), and the surface needs to be clean, dry and free from cracks or blemishes. 
 Most manufacturers describe their exterior wall paints as masonry paint . 
 Usually, these are water-based (emulsion type) paints which, as well as containing a fungicide, have been reinforced with sand, stone, granite or fibre to enable the paint to fill in and disguise small cracks. 
 Two finishes are commonly available: smooth and sand-textured. 
 Expect to pay around &pound;16 to &pound;18 for five litres in white (colours are generally more expensive). 
 Coverage on smooth surfaces is normally 8 to 12m &sup2/litre; for smooth masonry paint, 4 to 6m &sup2/litre; for textured (on rough surfaces halve these figures). 
 Both Sandtex and Dulux Weathershield are widely available; Sandtex also now makes a glass masonry paint. 
 Crown masonry paints are solventbased for extra toughness. 
 You can also get thick-bodied textured  coatings, such as Sandtex Fine Build, suitable for use outside. 
 Generally, these require only one coat. 
 Around &pound;16 for 7.5kg, to cover 1 to 2m &sup2/kg; on smooth surfaces. 
 (It's traditionally sold by weight because of its density). 
 All of these paints should last for between 4 and 7 years. 
 There are also professionally-applied textured coatings which are sprayed on, and should last for 10 years or more. 
 Finally, you can get cement-based  wall paint (Snowcem) in the form of a powder you mix with water, which is applied with a roller or synthetic bristle brush, and gives a coarse-textured finish. 
 This should last for five to seven years, and costs around &pound;14 for a 7kg packet, to cover 20 to 40m&sup2; (don't apply over masonry paint). 
 All surfaces should be clean and dry before applying masonry paint with a brush, roller or spray. 
 Any mould growth should be killed with a fungicide wash , and loose or powdery surfaces should be treated with a stabilising solution . 
 Cracks should be repaired with a filler , and porous surfaces primed with a sealant  or a diluted coat of masonry paint. 
 WHO MAKES WHAT 
 BLUE HAWK   Two non-drip masonry paints in white or magnolia, generally needing just one thick coat. 
 Wallshield  gives a smooth finish, and Sandshield  a fine sand-textured finish. 
 Claimed coverage 4m &sup2/litre.; 
 CEMENTONE BEAVER   Trade vinyl matt  and vinyl silk  emulsions are both suitable for outside use. 
 Stoneface  masonry paint a flexible and tough acrylic-based film, which covers hairline cracks and allows minor structural movement, is available in smooth or sand-textured finishes in white and colours. 
 CROWN   Smooth , solvent-based, masonry paint with a matt finish. 
 Water-based Stronghold smooth , and Stronghold textured  masonry paint, reinforced with rock aggregate for extra durability. 
 Dries quickly; available in white only. 
 The new solvent-based Stonewall  Allweather High-performance Masonry Coating, manufactured with Plioway resin, will tolerate very damp surfaces. 
 It can be applied easily even at high or low temperatures (down to -20&deg;C), is unaffected by rain 15 minutes after application, and resists marking. 
 Available in 10 colours. 
 DULUX  . 
 Weathershield  smooth masonry paint gives a smooth, protective, durable finish and is available in white and 13 ready-mixed colours (plus 98 colours from Definitions, the Dulux tinting system). 
 Claimed coverage 14 to 16m &sup2/litre.; 
 The textured  version hides fine surface cracks, and is available in white and three colours. 
 JOHNSTONE'S PAINTS   Pliolite  Masonry Finish, with a smooth matt finish, is available in white and 11 colours. 
 Jonsil Silicone Alkyd  finish is a masonry paint ideal for inner city and coastal environments. 
 Jon-Tex High Build  (in nine colours) is a ready-mixed, water-based paint, which gives even badly weathered masonry a heavy-duty finish in one coat. 
 Stormshield  is an acrylic-based masonry paint, available in either smooth or textured finish, in a range of colours. 
 MACPHERSON PAINTS   Valspar  smooth and fine textured masonry paint will cover hairline cracks and needs only one or two coats. 
 Available in a wide range of colours. 
 Marbletex  fine and smooth textured masonry paints, are both water-based and flexible, so resist flaking. 
 Marbletex fine  has a plastic vinyl resin base, reinforced with mica and fine marble aggregate, producing a tough, weatherresistant finish. 
 Marbletex smooth  contains a tough flexible resin to provide weather resistance. 
 Spreading rate is up to 7sq m/litre for fine, and 10sq m/litre for smooth. 
 Powercote  is an oil-based coating, based on a special synthetic resin called Pliolite. 
 It can be used on exterior stucco, cement, stone, precast concrete (within three days of shuttering being removed), pebbledash and asbestos. 
 Surface-dry in two hours, it can be recoated overnight. 
 Coverage is 6.5sq m/litre. 
 OWN BRANDS . 
 All the large d-i-y superstores (B&amp;Q, Do It All, Homebase, Texas and Wickes) have their own ranges of masonry paints available in smooth or sand-textured finishes. 
 SANDTEX   Masonry paints in a choice of finish: Sandtex Smooth  and Sandtex Matt  (with a very fine texture) in white and 23 ready-mixed colours (and almost any colour can be matched with the new Colour Bank machine); the new Sandtex Classic Stone Gloss  (white and five colours); and Sandtex Fine Build , a highly durable, fine-textured coating which will cover fine cracks and surface imperfections in a single coat. 
 Also Sandtex Highbuild , for renovating uneven and irregular surfaces. 
 SNOWCEM   Cement  paint, in white or five colours, supplied in powder form. 
 Provides water-repellent coating on both exterior and interior surfaces. 
 Two coats usually recommended: can be mixed with sand if required. 
 Cannot be used over masonry paint. 
 TETROSYL   Textratex  exterior wall paint, available in a wide choice of colours and white, with either a smooth or sand-textured finish &mdash; the textured finish will cover hairline cracks.  
 GARDENING 
 CREATIVE LIGHTING 
 For anyone who goes out to work or has to leave home early during the week the garden is a weekends-only pleasure for almost half of the year. 
 Early dusk makes it impossible to enjoy the garden during the week, except in the middle of summer. 
 The flick of a switch can change all this if you install garden lights. 
 They need not cost you more than a meal out and a trip to the theatre, yet they will provide many more hours of pleasure. 
 Mains lights  are available from good garden centres and d-i-y stores, and the most versatile type for creative garden lighting is a spotlight with a spike that can be pushed into the ground and a head that swivels so that the beam can be adjusted. 
 Wall-mounted spotlights are useful, but the ability to reposition the light slightly as well as alter the direction of the beam is especially desirable as it enables different features to be highlighted as the seasons change. 
 Some wiring instructions will come with the lamp, but there may be no advice about running the actual power supply into the garden. 
 You must plan the circuit carefully, especially if you intend to move the lights around, and run suitable cable underground (use armoured cable or run the cable in conduit, at least 450mm (18in) deep, connected to the main house consumer unit. 
 If in any doubt, consult an electrician. 
 Always use a circuit breaker for added safety. 
 If you are having a mains garden lighting circuit installed, it makes sense to have power points suitable for power tools such as mowers and hedge trimmers put in at the time. 
 Even if a permanent garden circuit is contemplated, it makes sense to try out the lights on a temporary basis to find the best positions to fix your power points. 
 Low voltage lights  are widely available and simple to install with no worries about safety. 
 They usually operate at 12 volts, but in the darkness of the garden even a low-powered light can seem surprisingly bright. 
 The transformer simply plugs into a mains socket indoors or in a garage, and only the low-voltage wire is taken outside. 
 You can have the lights installed and working within an hour. 
 Bear in mind that even though the wire will not present an electrical hazard, it should still be buried: trailing cables are dangerous by day and even more so in the dark. 
 Most low-voltage lights cast a localised beam or a diffused glow. 
 Those with a mushroom-style head are intended to cast the beam downwards on to the flower beds below, others with a pencilshaped lamp are suitable for using along the edge of a path or for illuminating an area of border. 
 But all of these are rather conspicuous by day and are difficult to hide in the way that spotlights can be masked by plants. 
 You can dispense with all trailing wires by using solarpowered lights . 
 Six hours of daylight is claimed to give 12 hours of night time light, but of course these cast a soft diffused light rather than a beam you can direct creatively like a spotlight, and they have limitations during the dull days of a typical British winter. 
 But for summer barbecues and evening entertaining, they provide a useful light. 
 RULES FOR CREATIVE LIGHTING 
 Mask spotlights with dwarf shrubs or other plants so that the lamps are not obtrusive by day. 
 Use white lights rather than coloured ones, which generally create disturbing colour effects with foliage and flowers. 
 Illuminate flowers and foliage that show up well in the dark. 
 White flowers will look better than, say, red or blue blooms; yellow leaves will be more striking than green foliage. 
 Shape is more important than colour at night. 
 Use a spotlight on plants with a strong profile, such as a yucca or red hot poker, or a tall, feathery fennel. 
 These will look imposing and create a dramatic effect with shadows. 
 Ornaments, such as an interesting pot or a bust on a plinth, which make good daytime focal points, also look good at night. 
 Avoid allowing light to shine into neighbours' gardens or into windows. 
 Do not direct a beam where people will walk through it: eyes take time to readjust to dark areas again, and this can be a potential hazard. 
 BIRD PROTECTION 
 Most of us appreciate the beauty that birds can bring to the garden, but when they spoil our fruit and vegetables they become less desirable garden visitors. 
 Bullfinches may strip buds from fruit trees in early spring, wood pigeons ruin winter cabbages and cauliflowers and uproot seedlings of peas and beans in spring, or strip buds of fruit from blackcurrants and other fruits. 
 Blackbirds and thrushes will make a meal of ripening strawberries, pears etc, and even blue-tits can damage ripening apples and pears by pecking them and letting in fungi and bacteria that may cause the fruit to rot. 
 The best solution is to erect a permanent fruit cage, though this is not always practical for tree fruits. 
 If you have just a few bushes, drape individual plants with nets, burying or pegging down the edges during vulnerable periods. 
 Unfortunately small animals such as hedgehogs can get entangled in the net, and removing it to pick the fruit can be tricky. 
 Because the net will inevitably be in close contact with some of the fruit, birds will still do some damage where they can peck through the mesh. 
 BUYING THE FRAMES 
 Fruit cages are relatively expensive and you have to consider whether it would be cheaper to buy from a pick-your-own farm than to pay for a fruit cage. 
 The choice is mainly between galvanised steel, painted steel, and aluminium frames. 
 Painted steel is likely to be less durable than the other kinds, but it is equally important to choose strong frames that are not likely to buckle: (aluminium may be more likely than steel to bend under strain). 
 The size and type of netting is equally important if a fruit cage is to last and serve its purpose. 
 A 25mm (1in) mesh will exclude most birds, but if tits are a problem it is best to choose an 18mm (&frac34;in) mesh. 
 A 10cm (4in) mesh may be adequate to keep pigeons off winter greens, but isn't practical for a fruit cage. 
 The smaller the mesh the more expensive the net, so there is no point in using a smaller mesh than necessary. 
 Snow is more likely to cause damage to a small-mesh net. 
 Netting is likely to be made from either polypropylene or polythene. 
 Ordinary polythene netting will deteriorate within two or three seasons, but manufacturers usually add a uv stabiliser, which considerably extends its useful life. 
 Different manufacturers claim widely different life expectancies for both materials, but you can reasonably expect a five-year life from most types (but as some manufacturers claim a life of only half this, and others double, check before you buy). 
 The majority of bird netting is likely to be knotted (this produces a fine and very flexible net) or knitted, but the thickness of the thread is likely to be more important than the type of assembly. 
 A reinforced edge adds strength and is useful for a fruit cage. 
 MAKING YOUR OWN 
 A fruit cage is a practical d-i-y project. 
 You could use galvanised steel tubing (try a scrap merchant) for the uprights, and metal tubing or galvanised wire across the top. 
 An all-timber construction is easy to assemble. 
 Suitable netting is available from garden centres as well as by mail order. 
 Clips for fixing and joining the nets are available from some cage and netting manufacturers. 
 PROTECTING STRAWBERRIES 
 Cloches are widely used to protect strawberries in spring and to produce an early crop. 
 Some can be fitted with a net to provide bird protection once the glass has been removed. 
 Netting can also be stretched over the hoops used for the popular polythene tunnel cloches. 
 So after the early strawberries have been protected, use the cloches as a fruit cage.  
 KEEP CONTAINERS BLOOMING 
 Windowboxes and other containers often begin to run out of flower power towards the end of summer, but it is usually possible to give them a boost to sustain interest until it is time to plant them up for a spring display. 
 Dead-head  regularly. 
 Plants like pansies will flower for longer, but even those that flower for a long time anyway, like African and French marigolds, will look neater and tidier if dead-headed, and the dead flowers will not detract from flowers that are still blooming. 
 Remove plants that have finished . 
 they make the container look untidy; often neighbouring plants will fill the spaces vacated. 
 If most of the plants have finished, discard them and plant up with spring-flowering bulbs or winter-interest dwarf shrubs. 
 Use fillers , such as all-year-round chrysanthemums, potgrown busy Lizzies, or even small foliage plants like pots of ivy, to fill in gaps. 
 These can give a new lease of life to a jaded windowbox or tub. 
 Feed  with a liquid fertiliser &mdash; at this time of year quick results are needed, which granular or slow-release fertilisers may not provide. 
 Regular feeding will often extend the life of container-grown plants by many weeks. 
 CUTTING TIME 
 Geraniums are an excellent investment. 
 Once you have a few plants, they are easy to propagate from cuttings. 
 Plants from cuttings taken now will produce better, more shapely plants than old plants overwintered, and of course you will have more of them. 
 Choose healthy and vigorous non-flowering shoots (if this is difficult just trim off any flowers), and make the cuttings about 10cm (4in) long. 
 Cut just below a leaf joint, and trim off the bottom leaves together with the stipules (the small scalelike growths at the base of each leafstalk). 
 Dip the end of each cutting in a rooting powder (even this is optional) and insert round the edge of a 15cm (6in) pot &mdash; or plant individually in 8&ndash;9cm (3&ndash;3&frac12;in) pots. 
 Place in a cold frame or on a windowsill out of direct sunlight, where they will soon root at this time of year. 
 Pot individually when rooted, and overwinter the young plants in a light, frost-free place. 
 GARDEN IN SAFETY 
 Do you think of your garden as somewhere to relax, and where the children can play in safety? 
 Then beware, because your garden can be dangerous: 320,000 people were injured in gardens last year. 
 There are all sorts of hazards in gardens: electrical equipment which can kill if not used correctly, or if it is faulty; tools which are easy to trip over; garden canes, which cause many eye injuries; loose paving and muddy surfaces; and sharp implements and thorns. 
 And for children, there are even more hazards: from ponds to poisonous plants and chemicals. 
 The Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents, the Consumers' Association, and the Department of Trade and Industry have got together to produce a leaflet to warn you of garden hazards which you may not be aware of, and may not be aware of, and how to safeguard against them. 
 Entitled Do it safely , it's available free from garden centres and d-i-y stores, as well as local trading standards and environmental health departments. 
 BULB BARGAINS 
 Bulbs are a good long-term investment if you choose them wisely. 
 Those that tend to split up into smaller bulbs the following year, then take several years to reach flowering size, can be disappointing unless you replant with fresh bulbs each year. 
 Hyacinths, most tulips and some of the dwarf irises, such as Iris danfordiae , fall into this category. 
 By choosing bulbs that multiply that flower prolifically, however, your investment shows good dividends every year. 
 These are often inexpensive bulbs too, and most of them can be left to naturalise freely with the minimum of attention. 
 Some good ones to try are suggested in the table. 
 Although most can be planted in a lawn, the grass in that area must be left uncut until the leaves begin to die down. 
 If this is unappealing, plant them in bold clumps or drifts in front of shrubs or towards the front of a mixed or herbaceous border. 
 They will provide pockets of interest early in the year before the herbaceous plants make an impact. 
 Bluebell 
 Best for moist shade &mdash; ideal for a woodland area but good in grassed areas planted with shrubs 
 Usually sold as a mixture, but separate blue, pink and white varieties are available 
 Crocus 
 The large-flowered dutch crocuses need no description. 
 C chrysanthus  varieties are smaller but flower earlier and naturalise well in the rock garden or grass 
 For naturalising, large-flowered mixtures are best for lawns. 
 Try the separate varieties of C Chrysanthus, such as &bquo;Ladykiller&equo; (purple and white) and &bquo;Blue Pearl&equo; (soft blue) 
 Daffodil (narcissus) 
 The large-flowered trumpet daffodils are widely grown everywhere, but some of those with short, contrasting cups are just as attractive as the trumpet varieties, and there are charming miniatures too 
 Mixtures of the large-flowered kinds are likely to be best for naturalising, as they are often sold in bulk very cheaply for this purpose. 
 For a more &bquo;old world&equo; appeal, try the pheasant eye narcissus (N Poeticus) with its tiny yellow cup edged crimson against white petals. 
 One of the finest miniatures for naturalising in grass is the hoop-petticoat daffodil, N. Bulbacodium 
 Erythronium 
 Charming plants for a damp position, perhaps beneath deciduous trees. 
 There are several kinds but of all have nodding flowers with turned-back petals 
 E Revolutum, which grows to about 25cm (910in) is one of the most dependable. 
 &bquo;Pagoda&equo; is a good strong yellow hybrid with marbled foliage 
 Glory of the snow (chionodoxa) 
 Nodding star-like blue and white flowers on spikes about 10cm (4in) tall 
 All species will do well, but C luciliae is one of the most widely available and dependable 
 Grape hyacinth (muscarl) 
 Clusters of tightly packed small blue flowers on stems about 23cm (9in) high 
 M armeniacum is cheap and excellent for naturalising. 
 M botryoides &bquo;Album&equo; is white 
 PATIO DOORS 
 Patio doors are big business these days. 
 There's a wide range of products at a wide range of prices, and deciding which to go for can be a difficult decision&hellip; and an expensive one to get wrong. 
 So if you're in the market for some new doors, here are some of the things you need to know. 
 If you are replacing existing patio doors, you have two options. 
 The first is to fit doors of a similar type and style to those you already have. 
 Doors with wood or aluminium frames are widely available from builders' merchants and timber yards, and you can either do the work yourself or call in a local builder to do it for you. 
 This is the cheaper option, but does not generally give you a great deal of choice in terms of design, features or finish. 
 Your second option is to go for tailor-made and professionallyinstalled doors that combine the latest design and construction techniques with materials that promise minimal maintenance, and which include the bonus of having extra-wide sealed-unit double glazing and built-in weather-stripping. 
 The only difficulty you might face is in getting the right look &mdash; doors that match the style of your house &mdash; but manufacturers have come a long way from the early aluminium-framed types, and a range of styles is now available. 
 Choosing this road is likely to cost more than the first option, but you will at least ensure that your doors are the best that money can buy. 
 That's the theory, anyway. 
 WHAT'S ON THE MARKET? 
 Patio doors are made in timber, aluminium and plastic (unplasticised polyvinyl chloride, or upvc for short). 
 These materials are sometimes used in combination &mdash; aluminium doors may be set in a timber sub-frame, for example, and upvc doors usually have steel reinforcement inside their box sections for extra strength. 
 Timber  doors are usually made either from preservativetreated softwood, or a rot-resistant hardwood such as mahogany, and many have high-performance specifications that include integral weather-stripping and sealed-unit double glazing. 
 Their advantages are: 
 Wood is an excellent insulator. 
 They come in a fairly wide range of standard sizes. 
 You can paint or stain them to any colour you want. 
 Set against these points is the maintenance problem; softwood doors need regular decoration to keep rot at bay, and even hardwoods require regular treatment with preservative and stain to keep them in good condition. 
 Aluminium  doors are still the most common (and the cheapest) type of patio door. 
 They are usually fitted into a timber sub-frame (hardwood, in preference to softwood; there's little point in fitting an indestructible door in a frame that could rot in 10 years), and come with either a silvery finish or a factory-applied coating in a limited range of colours. 
 Their advantages are: 
 They also come in a reasonably wide range of standard sizes for d-i-y installation; professional installers usually make to measure, so awkward sizes aren't a problem. 
 They need minimal maintenance. 
 They usually have integral weather-stripping. 
 Their drawbacks are that the frames are prone to serious condensation unless a thermal break is incorporated in their construction, and uncoated types may suffer surface corrosion in industrial or coastal areas. 
 They also tend to be aesthetically unsuited to many older-style properties. 
 Plastic (upvc)  doors are the latest arrival on the scene, although they have been widely used on the continent for around 25 years. 
 They usually incorporate internal steel members for extra strength, and because of the relatively large cross-section of the various stiles and rails they can make an appropriate replacement for many older-style houses with timber windows. 
 Their advantages are: 
 The frame members are good insulators, so condensation is not a problem. 
 They can be fixed directly to masonry. 
 They need virtually no maintenance. 
 Some colours and wood grain effects are beginning to find their way on to the market, although most are still white. 
 They are usually made to measure, so matching awkward sizes is easy. 
 Their two main disadvantages are that they can discolour with time unless an ultra-violet light stabiliser is incorporated in the plastic, and that it's difficult to fit security devices to them (make sure good locks are fitted as standard by the manufacturer and frames are strengthened). 
 They are, generally speaking, the most expensive type. 
 Most patio doors consist of one fixed and one sliding panel, up to widths of about 3050mm. 
 Wider openings may have three or even four panels, and you can generally choose which are open and which are fixed. 
 GLASS CHOICES 
 As already mentioned, choosing patio doors that suit your house is one of the most important points to consider. 
 Most look similar except for the frame material; choose this to match your windows if possible. 
 Some firms which tailor-make doors offer obscured or patterned glass &mdash; usually only to order. 
 Make sure that the doors you buy are fitted with safety glass  to the requirements of British Standard BS6206. 
 For safety and  security, install laminated glass  in your patio doors. 
 Safety glass will break into relatively harmless pieces when it's hit hard, but laminated glass is much more difficult to break, and will deter most burglars after their first attempt. 
 For information, contact The Laminated Glass Information Centre on: 071 499 1720. 
 The most recent glass development is the growing use of solar control  and low-emissivity glass , which helps to retain heat in the winter and to prevent unnecessary solar gain in summer. 
 OTHER FEATURES 
 Once you have chosen the basic type of door you want, there are two other important features to check. 
 The first is security : the doors should have a key-operated lockable handle, ideally shooting bolts into the top and bottom of the door frame, and should incorporate anti-lift devices so the doors cannot be removed from their tracks from the outside. 
 The second is ventilation . 
 If the doors are the room's only opening to the outside air, you should choose a type with a trickle ventilator built into the top frame member to meet the requirements of the Building Regulations. 
 FITTING 
 There are literally thousands of firms that offer a supply-and-fit service nowadays, and choosing the best one for your home can be difficult. 
 Personal recommendation is still the safest method of selection, but members of the Glass and Glazing Federation (GGF) have to abide by the federation's code of practice and so should be a safe bet. 
 For a list of members, contact them on: 071 792 2614. 
 If you want to save money and fit your own patio doors, builders' merchants and timber merchants offer a small range of standard-sized doors. 
 Some window and door specialists also offer a supply-only, made-to-measure service. 
 In some cases the firm will do all the measuring up; others rely on the customer to do it.  
 FINANCIAL 
 ARE YOU SURE YOU'RE INSURED? 
 Suppose you're decorating the living-room, insulating the loft, or knocking two rooms into one. 
 Will your household insurance pay for the damage if you spill a can of paint over your wall-to-wall carpet, put your foot through the bedroom ceiling, or demolish a load-bearing wall and bring half your home tumbling about your ears? 
 Policies differ, but let's look first at the basic type which covers buildings and/or contents against a set list of risks such as fire, theft, subsidence and earthquakes. 
 Loss or damage caused by accidents is not generally included, though you may be able to claim under some other section. 
 If you accidentally caused a fire with your blowlamp, you would be covered by the fire section. 
 If you caused a flood by knocking a nail through a water pipe, the flood section would cover you for damage caused by the water, but not for the damage to the pipe. 
 Most basic building policies do, however, cover accidental damage to underground gas, electricity, oil, water and sewage pipes or cables. 
 So you could claim the cost of repair if you chopped one while digging in the garden. 
 You usually get free accident cover, too, for glass in doors, windows and skylights, and also for baths, washbasins and wcs. 
 Most basic contents policies cover accidents to mirrors and fixed glass in furniture and some even include TVs, videos, satellite dishes, home computers and audio equipment. 
 Beyond that, you can usually buy extensions covering accidental damage to the buildings, eg; by putting your foot through the bedroom ceiling, or to the contents, eg, by spilling paint on a carpet. 
 Yet another option is to buy a policy which itself covers accidental damage without the need for buying a separate extension. 
 Naturally, it will cost more than a basic policy. 
 Most expensive of all is an all-risks policy which also gives wide cover against accidental damage. 
 But watch out. 
 Some policies which otherwise give good cover specifically rule out damage caused to the buildings in the course of repair, demolition or any work on the structure. 
 So you couldn't claim if you knocked down a load-bearing wall. 
 You might also be unlucky if you put a foot through the bedroom ceiling while repairing the inside of the roof; but you should be covered if you were insulating the loft. 
 If in doubt, ask your insurance agent &mdash; and read your policy before  disaster strikes. 
 DELTA DEBIT CARDS 
 Yet another logo has appeared on the plastic card scene &mdash; Visa Delta's interlinking triangles. 
 You'll see it outside shops and on your Visa Delta debit card when it comes up for renewal. 
 Visa Delta is a debit card network linked with the Visa credit card network. 
 It includes Barclays' Connect, Lloyds' Payment and TSB's Bank Card. 
 You can use these to pay for goods wherever the Visa &mdash; or new Visa Delta &mdash; logo is displayed. 
 The money is automatically taken out of your current account in the same time it takes to clear a cheque, roughly three days. 
 HELP WITH THE LAW 
 Suppose your new washing machine is on the blink; or your neighbour puts up a fence inside your boundary; or you trip over a paving stone and break your leg. 
 Polite letters of complaint get you nowhere. 
 What do you do next? 
 In theory, the law should come to your rescue. 
 But your earnings, or savings, rule you out for Legal Aid, and you're reluctant to splurge money on lawyers. 
 That's where legal expenses insurance helps &mdash; it protects against the cost of taking legal action. 
 Bought as an &bquo;add-on&equo; with a house contents policy for a few pounds a year, it should cover you for consumer, household and personal injury claims. 
 A separate, dearer policy would also cover you for job, tax and inheritance disputes. 
 For more details, send an sae to the Association of British Insurers, Aldermary House, 10&ndash;15 Queen Street, London EC4N 1TT, for the free leaflet, Legal expenses insurance . 
 REGULATIONS 
 BUILDINGS REGS APPLICATIONS 
 The next time you call at your local council offices to collect some forms for making a Building Regulations application, don't be surprised if you are asked, &bquo;What type of forms do you want &mdash; Full plans or Building Notice?&equo; 
 The reason for this is that there are now two ways of getting your council's blessing to proceed with the work you have in mind. 
 The Full Plans method is the old system that has existed for many years, whereby detailed plans of your proposal are submitted in duplicate, along with an application form. 
 The plans are examined by the council for compliance with the Building Regulations, and if everything is in order you will receive an Approval Notice in due course, which you can then file away with your deeds. 
 The Building Notice procedure is a comparatively new system and does not require the submission of any detailed plans. 
 With this method a simple form (Notice) is deposited with your council, which gives brief details of the work you want to do. 
 Although no detailed plans are necessary, you will be required to provide a location plan showing the siting of your building, the boundaries of the site and particulars of any drainage works. 
 Once a Building Notice has been submitted and accepted by your council you can start work within 48 hours. 
 As there are no plans to examine, the council is not obliged to issue any formal letter of approval. 
 Compliance with the Building Regulations is enforced by means of site inspections during the progress of the work. 
 A question which is often asked is, &bquo;Are there any risks involved in using the quicker procedure of submitting a Building Notice rather than depositing full plans?&equo; 
 The answer is yes, although the risk may only be minimal in the case of minor projects associated with dwelling houses. 
 Unlike the Full Plans method, the use of the Building Notice procedure does not entitle you to any documentary proof from your council that your proposal is satisfactory, or that the work will be accepted by the Buildings Control Officer who is required to inspect the work as it proceeds. 
 A good working knowledge of the Building Regulations requirements is therefore necessary. 
 The council is also empowered to ask for details of any unusual part of the project to prove compliance with the Building Regulations, eg special foundations for building on doubtful ground. 
 Another disadvantage of the Building Notice procedure is that if your work is to be financed by a bank or building society, then you may be required to produce some form of documentary proof that your proposal is satisfactory when you are negotiating for your loan. 
 Your council will only provide a Building Regulations Approval Notice when Full Plans are deposited, so you will have to use this method. 
 The Building Notice is most suited for minor jobs associated with dwellings. 
 Unfortunately, there is no difference in the amount of fees payable with the two systems.  
 PROBLEM SOLVER 
 For free advice on any d-i-y problem, write to . 
 We can reply only if: 1: You enclose a valid Free Advice Coupon with each query. 
 2: Also enclose an sae. 
 Each separate query must be accompanied by a valid Free Advice Coupon and an sae and each query should be written on a separate piece of paper. 
 We regret that we are unable to answer multiple queries that do not comply with these instructions. 
 And we are unable to supply plans for projects. 
 DECORATING 
 Painting sills  
 My window sills are badly rotting in places. 
 How should I prepare them for repainting? 
 Wood generally, and wooden windows in particular, are prone to rotting. 
 Test the surface for sponginess by probing it with a screwdriver and renew rotten timber either by replacing complete sections with new preservative-treated wood, or by cutting-in new sections of wood, or if the area of rot is not too extensive, by replacing the decay using a modern wood repair system as made by Ronseal and Cuprinol. 
 The basis of both these systems is a wood hardener which strengthens the decayed wood fibres, and a two-part high performance wood filler. 
 In both cases, the wood should be as dry as possible when the wood hardener is applied, and when this is dry, the two-part epoxy-resin wood filler is pressed into the cavity to give a noncrack, non-shrink repair. 
 A sander will be required to remove excess filler and shape it to match the existing timber. 
 A second application of filler may be required to fill cavities which sanding reveals. 
 On completion the repair is primed and painted in the normal way. 
 RUST 
 Hinges and latches  
 How can garden gate furniture be protected from rust?  
 Hinges and latches on garden gates are very prone to rust &mdash; the action of opening and closing them will wear away any protective coating you may apply. 
 While you should try to keep most of the hinge and latch painted for appearances sake (unless it is brass or galvanised), you must accept that the main working parts will rust; so be prepared to apply regular coatings of oil or WD40 to protect them. 
 This will not only make the hinge or latch work evenly but will provide a medium in which any existing rust is worn away and any future rust is prevented. 
 A jammed hinge or latch can be freed with a penetrating oil such as Plus Gas. 
 All locks on external doors are candidates for rust: the answer again is to squirt in a lubricant on a regular basis. 
 DRIVES 
 Crack repair  
 How do you deal with cracks in a concrete drive?  
 Settlement cracks go in various directions and result in a depression that collects water. 
 The cure for this is to break up and remove all the affected concrete, right back to sound material. 
 Some of the foundation hardcore may also have to be removed, and any soft ground dug out till you reach a firmer base. 
 Extra hardcore is then rammed well down into the hole and the concrete replaced, using a mix of one part cement to two sand and three of 20mm gravel. 
 Alternatively, you can use a mix of one part cement to five parts ballast. 
 Finish the surface to match the rest of the drive. 
 Sloping drives are often left with the parallel ridges made by the tamping board. 
 Smooth-trowelled finishes can be slippery in winter, so it's best to finish with a wooden float as this will give a slightly textured surface. 
 WATER GARDENS 
 Fitting a pump  
 How should a submersible pump be fixed?  
 Submersible pumps should always be completely submerged (remember to allow for the inevitable drop of water level through evaporation in warm weather). 
 But don't sit them directly on the base of the pond, where the filter will soon become clogged with sediment. 
 If possible, raise the pump on bricks, or a small plinth. 
 STAIRCASES 
 Filling a gap  
 A gap has appeared above the string of our new loft staircase. 
 How should I fill it? 
 Use either a flexible mastic sealant or pin a wooden bead or moulding in position. 
 A standard cellulose filler would very quickly crack and fall out again due to normal movement. 
 CENTRAL HEATING 
 Corroding radiators  
 What are the symptoms of corrosion taking place in central heating?  
 Corrosion in central heating systems is a major problem and can result in a build-up of sludge, the main symptom of which is cold areas at the bottom of the radiators. 
 When corrosion really takes a hold, the radiators themselves may start to leak, and the overall effect is to reduce the system's efficiency. 
 Corrosion can be avoided in central heating systems if an inhibitor is added to the feed- and &mdash; expansion cistern. 
 Choosing the right inhibitor (which may need to include anti-freeze) and deciding on the correct procedure (which may involve cleansing the system first) is not always easy. 
 ELECTRICITY 
 Bell push  
 Is an illuminated bell push heavy on batteries?  
 Illuminated bell pushes should only be used with transformers as they get through batteries extremely quickly. 
 They should also not be used with certain electronic chimes as the current they use may trigger the chime. 
 If you are buying a 12 volt chime, you'll need to use special bulbs in the bell push. 
 The illuminated versions can be handy if sited near the keyhole &mdash; they will probably give you just enough light to stop you fumbling in the dark with your key. 
 You can also get them with space for a name card behind a clear plastic window. 
 PATHS 
 Brickwork  
 Can any bricks be used to lay a path?  
 With bricks you must be sure to use the correct variety. 
 Ordinary flettons or stocks can be used for garden walls, where water will run off them, but for paving you need special quality frost-proof or engineering bricks, otherwise they will quickly disintegrate. 
 PLUMBING 
 Shower pressure  
 Despite raising the cold water cistern in the loft, shower pressure is poor. 
 What else can I do to improve things? 
 If you have sited the cold water storage cistern as high as possible, yet your shower still lacks pressure, then the answer will be to fit a shower booster pump. 
 Such a pump will even allow you to have a shower where the cold water storage cistern is below the level of the shower rose. 
 Most major companies in the shower pump market, like Stuart Turner, offer a technical advisory service which can advise on the correct choice of pump and its installation. 
 Adding a waste  
 I have a 1930s house. 
 I want to run a waste from a shower. 
 Are there any snags to watch for? 
 Older houses will have a two-pipe drainage system with the wc waste going into its own soil stack. 
 And the waste from bath and basin are taken into a hopper head which connects to a drainpipe running into a gully (often the same gully as the kitchen sink). 
 This type of system is easy to add to. 
 You make a hole in the outside wall and run the waste pipe through, fit an elbow and lead another pipe into the hopper head. 
 Cold water cisterns  
 How should you deal with rust in a cistern?  
 Metal cold water cisterns are covered with an internal galvanised coating to prevent rusting of the underlying iron. 
 However, with time, the galvanised coating will be worn away (especially if there is a copper pipework in the system) and the cistern will start to rust. 
 Not only will this make the water unpleasant but it may cause leakages if the corrosion goes right through the cistern. 
 At one time, painting the inside of cold water cisterns with bituminous paint was the answer when it had corroded, but this is no longer recommended. 
 The best thing to do when an old galvanised cistern has started to rust is to replace it with a modern plastic type. 
 PRESERVATIVE 
 Treating battens  
 Do battens need to be treated in any way before fixing? 
 They are to be used outside under cladding. 
 Wherever possible, buy pre-treated (often called Tanalised) battens. 
 These will have been pressure-impregnated, and will be resistant to damp and insect attack. 
 If you can't get treated timber, soak it in a simple preservative-filled trough made of bricks covered by a heavy gauge polythene sheet. 
 This is far more effective than brush application. 
 HAMBONE by Mike Flanagan 
 SO I SAYS TO HIM, OK LOUDMOUTH, LET'S SEE YOU TAKE OVER MY COMPANY!  
 TIMBER CLADDING 
 Rot prevention  
 What is the best way to prevent timber cladding from rot?  
 The biggest enemy of timber cladding &mdash; and its supporting battens &mdash; is rot. 
 If water can penetrate and collect in joints, the wood will rot quickly unless steps are taken to prevent it. 
 For this reason, all wood used for cladding &mdash; unless it is naturally rot-resistant, like Western red cedar &mdash; should be pretreated with preservative before use. 
 Ideally this should be carried out by the timber supplier (treated wood is described as &bquo;Tanalised&equo; or &bquo;Celcured&equo; by timber merchants and other stockists) to ensure thorough and deep penetration of the wood. 
 But d-i-y treatment will go a long way towards keeping rot at bay, and you should be prepared to give freshly exposed cut surfaces of both cladding and battens an extra coat of preservative during installation for extra protection. 
 Drawbacks  
 I want to fix waney-edged boards on my house. 
 Are they suitable? 
 Waney-edged boards have irregular-shaped bottom edges (often with the outside bark of the log still attached) and are generally of uniform thickness. 
 They suffer from the drawback that warping can leave open gaps in the cladding (waney-edged boards are particularly prone to this because of the way they are sawn), and so they tend to be used more on out-buildings than on house exteriors, except as feature panels. 
 Battening out  
 What size should battens for supporting cladding be, and how are they fixed?  
 Wall battens are usually 38&times;119mm, or 50&times;25mm in cross-section, and should be fixed to the walls either with masonry nails or with non-rusting screws driven into wallplugs. 
 Nails should penetrate about 10mm into solid masonry and should not be driven into mortar joints. 
 If you are fixing battens over existing rendering make sure they are long enough to give adequate penetration into the brickwork or blockwork beneath. 
 While cladding can be fixed directly to existing masonry walls, it is good practice to cover them with waterproof building paper first to prevent any moisture that gets behind the cladding from penetrating the wall itself. 
 It can be held in place by the battens. 
 DRIVES 
 Gravel  
 How is gravel laid and are weeds likely to be a problem later?  
 Like all other paving materials gravel depends on its foundations for its efficiency. 
 If all the weeds and garden loam are dug out when the drive or path is laid, there should be no serious problem with weeds. 
 The base for gravel is hardcore or hogging, which is a rough, unwashed gravel. 
 This has to be well compacted before the 20m gravel is laid &mdash; to a depth of about 50mm. 
 A small sized gravel, (about 10mm) can be used for paths, but not for drives, as it would get into tyre treads. 
 The edging for a gravel drive must be deep enough to keep in the gravel which is below ground level, and high enough to prevent the gravel being spread on to the garden. 
 Cars tend to roll gravel on to the pavement. 
 To reduce this problem you could insert a low edging across the end of the drive. 
 If it has a rounded top, projecting only about 25mm above the gravel, it will not harm the tyres. 
 Depressions are usually caused by tyre tracks and simply need filling with more gravel. 
 Where most of the gravel has been compacted into the soil below, weeds have to be removed and a good general weed-killer applied. 
 Then new gravel is laid directly on top &mdash; the old gravel will form a firm foundation. 
 DECORATING 
 Painting metal  
 How do you prepare and paint metal gutters and windows?  
 Preparation consists of cleaning and degreasing: iron and steel need to be cleaned of rust. 
 All encrustment and blisters must be scraped off and then the metal is wire-brushed to remove loose fragments. 
 When cleaned, non-ferrous metals are best brought to a bright finish before priming with zinc chromate or zinc phosphate. 
 Iron and steel can also be primed with these materials for interior work, but for exterior work calcium plumbate primer is best. 
 Calcium plumbate primer can also be used on galvanised iron, but zinc chromate or zinc phosphate is used on aluminium alloys. 
 Iron and steel can also be treated with a cold galvanising paint, which reacts with a thin layer of rust to form a rust-proof coating that can be painted. 
 After priming, the metals can be painted in the usual way. 
 A popular paint for iron railings, gutters and downpipes is black bitumen, which though it loses its gloss quickly still retains its protective qualities. 
 When dealing with windows, remove all traces of rust and apply a neutralising agent to badly affected areas. 
 This makes rust inert. 
 Rub down with abrasive paper then degrease the surface with white spirit. 
 Apply one thin coat of primer immediately (rust can reform rapidly) and allow to dry before coating with gloss. 
 CLADDING 
 Choosing plastic  
 I want to use plastic cladding but a friend says it will soon crack. 
 Is he right? 
 Early versions were comparatively flimsy mouldings which tended to suffer from brittleness and yellowing as they aged, and which relied on complicated channellings and fixing clips for their installation. 
 Later developments, however, have produced greatly improved versions of this type of cladding. 
 It is widely available and is now much simpler to fit. 
 There is also a &bquo;second generation&equo; of plastic cladding materials which have none of these drawbacks and which are also extremely easy to handle and install. 
 These have a solid cellular core of unplasticised polyvinyl chloride (upvc) enclosed in a smooth, durable outer skin, and they can be sawn and drilled just like timber. 
 They are rigid, completely impermeable to water and almost maintenance-free, simply requiring occasional washing to remove surface grime. 
 Another major advantage over the thinner types of cladding is that they provide additional insulation to exterior walls (which can be augmented by fixing them over an extra layer of insulation). 
 A range of profiles is available from the various manufacturers, and while most come in white only, a few are also made in cream, green and brown. 
 FLOORINGS 
 Quarry tiles  
 What are the pros and cons of quarry tiles?  
 These are similar to ceramic tiles, but are unglazed and come only in a range of earth/terracotta/red colours as they are made from unrefined clay. 
 They are usually associated with farmhouse kitchens and look good with real wood and natural materials. 
 While extremely hardwearing, they aren't a good idea if you're prone to dropping things &mdash; the tiles won't break, but whatever you drop will. 
 They're ideal for porches and conservatories &mdash; and for kitchens with careful cooks! 
 Tiles are usually 4 or 6 in square, &frac12;, &frac58; or 1&frac14;in thick, and some hexagonal, rectangular, and with anti-slip surfaces are available, as well as skirting tiles. 
 WINDOWS 
 Steel frames  
 I will soon be installing newer windows. 
 I like the idea of using steel but is there a problem with rusting? 
 Steel frames were widely available in the 1930s, but these early frames were liable to rust and could soon look tacky. 
 However, the latest frames have a galvanised coating which keeps them rusts-free. 
 A wipe down with a damp cloth is all that's needed to keep them clean, and if they have a factory-finished polyester powder coating, they won't need to be redecorated for 15&ndash;20 years. 
 If you choose metal windows, ensure that they're fitted with a &bquo;thermal break&equo; to reduce condensation problems &mdash; windows without this feature can stream with moisture in cold weather. 
 DAMP 
 Using mastic  
 Is bituminous mastic useful for filling cracks in roofs?  
 Bituminous mastics, applied with a trowel or putty knife, can be used for cracks in roofs, but shouldn't be applied in very cold weather. 
 You'll probably need to apply a liquid waterproofer on top of the mastic. 
 Left: Paint and stencil hardboard floors to suit design schemes exactly 
 Below: Veneered mdf architectural joinery is ideal for skirting boards and architraves 
 Protect your home with a durable exterior masonry paint. 
 This is Weathershield, from Dulux, available in a wide choice of colours 
 Feed and dead-head plants regularly for a long-lasting display 
 When choosing aluminium doors, look for a thermal break to prevent condensation, and a trickle ventilator built into the top frame 
 DIARY 
 BURGLAR-PROOFING 
 Extracts from the diary of the working supervisor for a small building company, with useful tips on all sorts of building problems 
 Summer's back, but it never seems to last long enough. 
 Those who haven't taken advantage of early season low prices still have to take their hard-earned rest. 
 But before you jet off to soak up sun and sangria , or cruise around the Norfolk Broads give some thought to security. 
 Is your home a burglar's paradise? 
 We'd called at a house to install some concrete steps in the rear garden, and learnt that they had been burgled the previous night. 
 We continued our work until the fingerprint man arrived to dust that dreadful black powder everywhere. 
 Being the nosy type, I thought I'd pick his brains. 
 Apart from the basic security arrangements that we're probably all familiar with by now, he offered some interesting information. 
 There are basically two types of thief: the opportunist and the pro. 
 The first quickly takes advantage of a window carelessly left open or a house that's in darkness. 
 Some people even leave notes on the front door for a delivery man &mdash; you might as well put an invitation in the front garden. 
 The second is a slick operator, who studies his victim's habits for a few days to establish a safe crime time. 
 This guy is the most difficult to deter, and uses some devious methods. 
 The pro isn't put off by time switches. 
 When the light comes on at precisely the same time each night and the curtains aren't drawn, it's clear the house is empty. 
 Neighbours who will do this service for you should use the back door, where there's less chance of them being seen going in and out. 
 Careless talk can be disastrous. 
 If you are going away, tell only those who need to know &mdash; a slip of the tongue in the street, pub or corner shop could be overheard by the wrong sort. 
 Addresses don't have to be mentioned, they can easily be looked up in the electoral roll just from a name. 
 If you're in the phone book, it takes only a couple of rings to confirm your absence before some toe-rag pays an unwelcome visit. 
 British Telecom will disconnect your phone at the exchange while you are away, so that callers will hear the discontinued number tone, suggesting that you've changed the number, didn't pay the bill, or there's a fault on the line &mdash; BT won't tell them. 
 Or you could always take it off the hook, which has a similar effect. 
 You get what you pay for with locks. 
 Two-lever morsite locks are very easy to pick compared to their five-lever counter-parts, and deadlocks are a perfect menace to a would-be intruder. 
 A pro can identify the mock burglar alarm, but the genuine article is a real deterrent. 
 Some work on electronic beams, while others are activated by air movement &mdash; just opening the door can be enough to set off this type. 
 It is important to make sure there are not too many false alarms. 
 Rotten pun, but seriously, it drives the neighbourhood wild when the thing rings for hours, and most importantly, nobody takes any notice if it happens too often. 
 It could be just one of these occasions when your home really is being ransacked. 
 Alarms and Neighbourhood Watch schemes not only improve security, but with some insurance companies can lower your premiums too. 
 Small items of both financial and sentimental value should never be left in the house unless a good safe has been installed. 
 The best precaution would be to deposit them with the bank. 
 Sadly, the thief who leaves no clues and is careful disposing of his ill-gotten gains is unlikely to be caught. 
 The bottom line on who pays is the insurance companies and the householder. 
 I've seen many concrete steps, otherwise well constructed, crying for a little finishing and more support at the time of casting. 
 Initially, that gaping space can be a little puzzling, but it's quite simple really. 
 The horizontal distance for the flight of steps can be divided equally to establish the depth of each step, correctly called the &bquo;going&equo;. 
 This shouldn't be less than 225mm, but before deciding on a firm measurement, the same calculation should be applied to the vertical measurement, between the highest and lowest points. 
 This will give a height (riser), which ideally needs to be around 150mm, but not more than 200mm. 
 From here it's a simple juggling act to find the best sizes to suit the application. 
 Where a wall encloses the sides of the steps, fixing the shuttering couldn't be easier. 
 Open steps will need shuttered stringers, simply cut from the two measurements calculated. 
 Our shuttering had been fabricated in the workshop, complete with risers reinforced with some 75 &times; 50mm timber, but we could have made it up on site. 
 It can be surprising the amount of pressure a little wet concrete puts on shuttering. 
 Economically, thinner ply is preferable, but needs strengthening to prevent curved steps. 
 We manhandled the formwork into position, digging out here and there to get it level in both directions. 
 Although the formwork was quite heavy, we pegged it down at the four corners as a precaution. 
 Available hardcore can be placed in each step, saving on concrete, which should cover by at least 40mm on all external faces. 
 The strength can be 6:1, or for the most durable surface, 3:1 may be used. 
 It goes without saying that you start with the bottom step, to prevent the concrete falling through to the one below. 
 Once filled, the sides and riser were gently tapped with a hammer for a couple of minutes to expel trapped air, which can cause surface voids. 
 As each tread was scraped flush and tamped, we moved up to the next; when the surface water had run off, the step could be finished. 
 We made the non-slip surfaces by stippling the tops with a bass broom &mdash; a fairly new one works best. 
 The outer edges were rounded and smoothed with a small edging trowel, which gives a very attractive finish. 
 Covering the work to protect from frost and rain, we left it for a few days to dry, which helps the shuttering to loosen itself too. 
 We didn't get any tea that day, but under the circumstances were quite forgiving. 
 DOGS TODAY AUGUST 1991 We meet the man who turned his suburban semi into a Rottie sanctuary Sinitta's hectic life doesn't easily suit dogs. 
 She relies on roast chicken. 
 Win a holiday at a five-bone hotel. 
 Sally gives Bona-Fido breaks the paws-up Your invite to Top Dog '91 &mdash; the biggest and best doggie party ever staged PLUS! 
 Dobermanns * See Dunbar, Neville &amp; Fisher live on stage * Diabetic Dogs * Win 10 VIP Working Dog of the Year tickets * Pet Census Results * Acupuncture * New Dog Video&hellip; 
 AND MUCH MORE His Master's Voice says NO  What other shops say to dogs PUPPY OF ALL BATTLES We help bring Des back from the Gulf 
 Contents  
 Special features 
 PUPPY OF ALL BATTLES Des the Desert Dog has landed  
 DOGGED DISCRIMINATION? 
 Which shops are dog-friendly?  
 SINITTA Singing the praises of dog ownership  
 A BONA-FIDO HOLIDAY Sally enjoys a five-bone break  
 ESCAPE FROM EGYPT Scottie travels from Cairo to Chorley  
 ROTTIE TO THE CORE Rescuing Rottweilers from rotten homes  
 PET CENSUS RESULTS We introduce our typical reader  
 DIABETIC DOGS Living with the condition  
 IN THE FRAME Do you have a masterpiece on your walls?  
 SEEING FOR MILES A story of love, devotion and miracles  
 TOP DOG '91 An invite to the biggest dog party ever  
 NEEDLE WORKS Acupuncture is available for dogs, too  
 DOBERMANN &mdash; DOG DILEMMA This breed needs careful owners  
 Competitions &amp; Offers 
 CAPTION COMPETITION Prizes from Pedigree Petfoods  
 WIN A SCOTTISH WEEKEND For two plus one dog  
 PHOTOGRAPHIC COMPETITION Win Pet Value insurance  
 ARE YOU TYPICAL? 
 We're looking for our average reader  
 CROSS-QUESTION What's this month's mystery mix?  
 WORKING DOG OF THE YEAR Ten pairs of VIP tickets  
 AUGUST READER OFFERS New video and the Walk-Easy Collar  
 SHRINK THINK TANK Another chance to attend  
 GYLES BRANDRETH'S PRIZE CROSSWORD Omega Tasty prizes  
 Regular features 
 NEWS HOUND 
 FOGLE'S FILES Puppy parties  
 HOROSCOPES Roar of the lion-heart  
 MEMOIRS OF A DOG SHRINK An unusual phobia  
 POSTER PULL-OUT Lorimer's &bquo;A Dog and a Mirror&equo;  
 VET'S CORNER Food for thought  
 COPING WITH PET LOSS Sharing grief  
 DOGGIE POST BAG Featuring the Good-boy star letter  
 FIDO FACTS Dobermann Pinschers  
 TRUE CASE HISTORIES Peter Neville: From stage fright to limelight  
 CAREERS WITH DOGS Becoming an RAF police dog handler  
 SHORT STORY Big is Best, by Robert Killick  
 TAIL ENDING 
 KATIE'S PROBLEM PAGE The puppy-farming plague  
 Dear Readers 
 I'd like to apologise most sincerely to everyone who was concerned about the advert for the electronic training collar in our July issue. 
 I was as shocked as you to find the advert in our magazine and fully understand and applaud the concern of all those who telephoned. 
 In future we will not be accepting any similar adverts and we'll be donating the revenue from this advert to the RSPCA. 
 We've received reports of dogs which have reacted adversely to low-dose electric shock training. 
 Next month we will print animal behaviourist John Fisher's views on this and other extreme training devices. 
 Please try to persuade anyone contemplating using this method to seek advice from a vet, animal behaviourist or reputable dog trainer. 
 Reward-based training is the method our experts advocate for most situations. 
 If there's a very serious canine-life threatening problem, experts need to be consulted. 
 Once again we're very, very sorry. 
 I hope you enjoy this month's magazine. 
 We've never given you quite so many opportunities to get involved. 
 Attend the Shrink Think Tank, Top Dog '91, or take advantage of some of the competitions and offers. 
 Sally recommends a five-bone break. 
 Read about her holiday on page 18. 
 Beverley Cuddy, Editor 
 Beverley and Sally enjoy their five-bone break 
 Caption Competition  
 Can you think of a suitable caption for this picture? 
 To win a prize send in your captions as well as any photographs you think could feature in this section to: Dogs Today   
 Entries to be received by September 2nd 1991. 
 The best caption wins 24 tins of Pedigree Chum, a big bag of Mixer, a sack of Pedigree Formula, and four packets of treats. 
 Five runners-up will receive 24 tins of Chum and a bag of Mixer.  
 News Hound  
 NO SAFE SEX FOR DOGS 
 Dickie the Great Dane has been entrusted with the unusual task of demonstrating that safe sex has its place in the canine world. 
 The RSPCA first unveiled this eye-catching poster in Liverpool, where local RSPCA centres have to destroy hundreds of unwanted pets every week. 
 POLITICAL ANIMALS 
 The Dangerous Dogs Bill was rushed through the Lords and is expected to become law before the summer recess. 
 Owners of &bquo;dangerous&equo; breeds are likely to have a three-month period &mdash; until the end of November &mdash; to obtain a police permit for their animals. 
 RSPCA spokesperson Amanda Avis explained: &bquo;Owners are likely to be required to: Have the animal neutered; get compulsory thirdparty insurance; have the dog permanently identified and registered, and; when in public, comply with muzzling and leashing regulations.&equo; 
 More than 300 owners of &bquo;dangerous&equo; dogs rallied outside the Houses of Parliament earlier this summer. 
 Organiser Kevin Horton said there was plenty more support as yet untapped. 
 &bquo;The night before the protest rally Mr Baker pulled back on the destruction order he'd originally announced,&equo; Kevin explained. 
 &bquo;Had that not happened we would've had a lot more people at the rally. 
 &bquo;The ball is now in the Government's court. 
 We are ready and willing to bring further pressure on them if we see it as necessary in the future.&equo; 
 DOG-AIDS HELP 
 We are planning an investigation into autoimmune problems. 
 If you have had any experience of Aids-like illnesses in dogs, please write to us enclosing as many details as possible and giving a daytime telephone number. 
 HEN RUSSELLING 
 Two-year old bantam hen Betty was so taken by a pair of new-born Jack Russell pups, she decided to take them under her wing. 
 Farmer Tom Savage, from Worcester, told Dogs Today : &bquo;I couldn't believe it when I saw them. 
 I've been farming for the last 70 years and never seen anything like it.&equo; 
 The real mother seems more than happy to feed the pups, then allow them to nest under the bantam.  
 CRAZY FOR CRISPS 
 A four-year-old Labrador has discovered a passion for crisps &mdash; he even buys them himself. 
 JB, who lives with his publican owners, always makes a bee-line for the regulars as soon as he hears the last orders bell. 
 They usually give him a 20 pence piece and he heads straight for the bar to buy his favourite ready-salted snack. 
 Margaret Price, landlady of the Four Alls in York, told Dogs Today : &bquo;He's so human. 
 He opens the packet of crisps himself and starts munching away.&equo; 
 JB is also very tidy &mdash; he always puts the empty packet in the bin when he's finished. 
 EXTREME PRESSURE 
 The Canine Crisis Council (sponsored by Hugo Summerson MP, Baroness Phillips and Lord Ross of Newport) has called for all dogs to be muzzled in public places and for large dogs to be kept muzzled even in the privacy of their owners' garden. 
 They want all existing large dogs to be included in the provisions of the Dangerous Wild Animals Act and to ban Alsatians, Dobermanns, Rottweilers and other big breeds from future private ownership. 
 They seek to restrict town-based owners to one dog per household and legislate for all puppies to be neutered before being sold. 
 Their literature states: &bquo;We have a dog crisis which we must seek to eliminate&equo;. 
 If you would like to contact the Canine Crisis Council to give your opinion of their policies or find out more write to: PO Box 76, Leicester or fax: 0533 743141 
 We are grateful to the concerned Dogs Today  reader who informed us of the lobbying activities of this organisation. 
 MERKIN STOLEN 
 Actress Arkie Whiteley's collie-cross, Merkin, was stolen from outside a shop on the Portobello Road, London, on April 29. 
 Despite extensive newspaper and TV coverage, Arkie has uncovered few clues as to the whereabouts of the black, tan and white dog she rescued from an RSPCA pound three years ago. 
 &bquo;The night he disappeared I got a call from a woman who said she'd taken him because he looked abandoned,&equo; Arkie explained. 
 &bquo;but he was wearing a collar and I'd tied him to a lamppost.&equo; 
 The actress, currently appearing in Jeffrey Bernard is Unwell , said the woman claimed to live in Kent. 
 Sightings in Kent suggest Merkin may now be wearing a new red collar. 
 If you have any information about Merkin, call 071 727 1361. 
 ROBBED OF MEMORIES 
 Florrie Thompsett, (as featured in February Dogs Today ) was devastated when thieves broke into her home in Kent. 
 Florrie, 85, well known for her rescue work with Greyhounds, lost her many coursing trophies collected over the years. 
 Among the thieves' haul were an engraved silver salver, awarded to Florrie as part of her Rescue Personality of the Year prize, and bronzes of Greyhounds. 
 &bquo;I've got nothing to show for what I've won over the years,&equo; a distraught Florrie said. 
 SHORT LEADS 
 RAVING BULL 
 Britain's first Raving Loony councillor, Stuart Hughes, has launched the Raving Loony Staffordshire Bull Terrier Party. 
 Hughes, from Sidmouth in Devon, decided on the new political group to highlight the confusion between the Staffie and the Pit Bull Terrier. 
 BARDOT BACKS OPS 
 Actress Brigitte Bardot has launched a campaign to have France's 35 million dogs and cats sterilised. 
 Brigitte wants to stop the destruction of unwanted pets. 
 WHAT A PICTURE 
 The Rottweiler Welfare Association is pleased to announce the winner of its most photogenic rescue dog competition ( Dogs Today  April issue). 
 Molly is a Labrador cross, owned by Gay Cosens from Reigate, Surrey. 
 When she was dumped she was in terrible condition, coping with seven young pups. 
 Now, well down the road to recovery, Molly looks in fine health. 
 Molly receives a box of doggie goodies and the runners-up will receive, by post, a special gift. 
 PAW-O-VISION 
 Does your dog like to sing to the soaps? 
 If so, we want to hear from you as quickly as possible. 
 Please send us a photograph and a tape recording of your dog's best singing efforts &mdash; or even a video. 
 Please complete this coupon or carefully copy all the details on to a plain sheet of paper and return to: Paw-o-Vision Song Contest  
 If you'd like to listen to five of our Paw-O-Vision entrants, call 0898 100 239. 
 Calls cost 34p per minute at cheap rates and 45p per minute at all other times (VAT included).  
 Your dog can't prevent unwanted litters. 
 Neutering can. 
 Pit Bull owners demonstrate outside Parliament. 
 Police banned the Pit Bulls from taking part. 
 PUPPY OF ALL BATTLES 
 War brought Des and his troops together. 
 Peace pulled them apart. 
 Dogs Today, Eukanuba and British Airways reunited them  
 SEAN KEEBLE 
 Des is a Desert Rat &mdash; or Desert Dog, to be precise. 
 The eightmonth-old cross-breed with marked Saluki and retriever influences was adopted by Warrant Officer second class Dave Forster and seven other members of the Royal Army Ordnance Corps Expeditionary Forces Institute (RAOC/EFI) unit based at Jubail, Saudi Arabia, during the Gulf War. 
 Des was one of a litter of seven pups found at the EFI compound at Jubail. 
 Most of the other pups were &bquo;shipped out&equo; to other units and their respective fates are unknown, but Dave and his mates &mdash; two others based with Dave at RAOC/EFI Headquarters at Claygate, Surrey, and five more still stationed in Germany &mdash; were determined to hand onto their new recruit. 
 At the end of the Gulf War, British Army authorities announced they would have to destroy all dogs which had been picked up and kept by British units in the war zone, but Dave and his colleagues decided they weren't going to let this cruel fate befall Des. 
 Letters were written; faxes were sent; phones rang hot as Dave set the wheels in motion on the mission to rescue Des. 
 That's where Dogs Today  was able to take a hand. 
 We contacted British Airways Flying Pets Club and they kindly agreed to fly Des home. 
 One call to pet food company Eukanuba and the expensive quarantine and complicated paperwork were taken care of. 
 The result: Des was airlifted out of the Gulf in mid-May and, on May 29, at Arden Grange International Quarantine Kennels in Albourne, Sussex, Dave saw Des for the first time since March 23. 
 &bquo;I was both thrilled and relieved to see him again,&equo; Dave said. 
 &bquo;When I left Kuwait, I didn't know what was going to happen to Des. 
 I was one of the first ones to be flown out and then there was a postal hold-up so I had real trouble finding out what was going on, and also trying to organise to have him brought home. 
 &bquo;I wrote to the Daily Mail , which is affiliated with Dogs Today , and your magazine very kindly took up the campaign on our behalf. 
 &bquo;Everything's looking up now.&equo; 
 Indeed, three-quarters of Des's existence, so far, has been fraught with hazard. 
 &bquo;We have no idea who his father was and his mother, while not actually wild, was roaming around the compound for weeks,&equo; Dave said. 
 &bquo;We found the pups, fed them and looked after them until we were moved out in January when the war build-up escalated. 
 We took Des with us and put up notices for the other dogs, which were replied to by various other units.&equo; 
 By this stage, Des was more than just a mascot. 
 He was bestowed with the rank of War Dog First Class and his fame spread quickly. 
 Dave takes up the story. 
 &bquo;He travelled with us from Saudi, along the border and into Kuwait, and, amazingly enough, finished up 30 kilometres northwest of Kuwait City, which is where I last saw him. 
 &bquo;What was even more astonishing was the fact that people travelled miles to come and see him. 
 He was particularly popular with nurses, especially the American ones.&equo; 
 Dave is a dog lover but because of his army routine and duties, he has not had the time or lifestyle to be able to keep a dog. 
 But that will change this month, when he will be permanently based in Surrey. 
 Des will be cleared from quarantine on November 6 so until then, he will have to make do with a weekly Saturday visit from Dave and fellow home-based squadron mates Corporals Brian McCourt and Richard Starkey. 
 &bquo;There's a major reunion for all Gulf troops planned, and the other five, who are now in Germany, will be here then,&equo; Dave said. 
 &bquo;I'd imagine they'll be very happy to get the chance to see Des again.&equo; 
 According to Dave, Des has &bquo;doubled in size since I last saw him&equo; and has settled in well to his quarantine kennel life. 
 &bquo;He seemed very happy. 
 He's being well looked after and everything's going smoothly,&equo; Dave added. 
 After a glittering military career, Des is ready for what will be a comparatively unexciting civilian life. 
 Des proved a real handful 
 Sheltering from the desert sun 
 Desert Rats together 
 &bquo;Phew &mdash; I made it!&equo; 
 Dogged  DISCRIMINATION? 
 Our investigative researchers ventured into the centre of London to find out if High Street shops are dog-friendly and if they're not, why not?  
 CHAIN STORE MASSACRE? 
 JOHN LEWIS 
 Although no one stopped us entering the store, it was obvious we were being scrutinized by both shop assistants and the public. 
 Nevertheless, we were given the green light &mdash; unfortunately, poor Molly was accidentally stepped on a couple of times. 
 SELFRIDGES 
 Stickers on most doors around the store clearly indicated &bquo;No Dogs Allowed&equo;. 
 However we pushed our luck and took Molly in, with no protests whatsoever. 
 Spike then followed, but was immediately challenged. 
 We concluded that as Molly was so small, nobody had noticed her. 
 BARKERS 
 No signs and no specific policy. 
 Staff seemed evenly divided &mdash; we received some smiles but also caught some rather unsavoury glances. 
 Generally, no problems. 
 MARKS &amp; SPENCER 
 No. 
 Well-known rule here, and generally accepted. 
 Food in store. 
 Harrods  
 For many years Harrods had a creche where customers could leave their dogs while they shopped in the store. 
 Sadly, due to refurbishment and a desire to create more shopping space, the kennels have been closed. 
 THE ENTERTAINERS? 
 HMV 
 Biggest shock of our day &mdash; no dogs allowed into a shop worldrenowned for its dog logo. 
 Quite farcical. 
 Uniformed security guard said: &bquo;Only guide dogs, you know what I mean. 
 There's no need for dogs to be in here.&equo; 
 DILLONS 
 The manager was very helpful and happy to tell us dogs were certainly OK. 
 &bquo;Dogs are welcome in here as long as they don't wee on the carpet,&equo; she said. 
 Most staff here seemed quite happy to have dogs with owners in the store. 
 A very warm atmosphere. 
 TOWER RECORDS 
 A round of applause for Tower Records; finally, a dog-friendly music store. 
 As long as your pet is under control you're welcome to take a spin round the store.  
 OWNER-DOG DUOS: Christine Davis, with her 18-month-old Border Collie, Spike, and Fiona Watson, with her Shih Tzu pup, Molly.  
 NO SHOPS CONTACTED PROHIBITED GUIDE DOGS OR HEARING DOGS  
 SHOO SHOPS? 
 DOLCIS 
 Manager and staff were a little bemused by our request, but were happy to co-operate. 
 Fiona tried on a very bright pair of shoes. 
 One assistant said: &bquo;Dogs are fine, as long as they don't disgrace themselves&equo;. 
 FASHION DISASTERS? 
 MONSOON 
 Love having dogs in the store. 
 Spike was again very well-behaved, lay down immediately when told, waited for instructions. 
 Manageress Jaci Henderson said: &bquo;We have no problems as long as they aren't running around, through clothes, making a mess, etc. 
 &bquo;Quite a few of our customers have dogs and there are some large ones among them, although most of the ones who come in here are small. 
 But whatever they are, we have no objections at all.&equo; 
 BENETTON 
 Friendly assistant manager, Colin McPherson, had no objections. 
 &bquo;Yeah, we allow dogs in here. 
 Well, you've managed to get one in, anyway,&equo; he laughed. 
 &bquo;I don't see why not.&equo; 
 Benetton's true colours shine through. 
 HORNE BROS 
 Apparently no specific policy but managers told us they had some problems in the past with dogs messing in the store. 
 One spokesman said: &bquo;We usually deal with any dogs as individual cases. 
 If they're not giving trouble and no one complains, then they're fine.&equo; 
 NEXT 
 Company policy is to prohibit dogs from entering the store. 
 The staff were polite but when asked why there was no sign on the shop door, we got a rather unsatisfactory answer. 
 We were told that previously, when dogs were allowed, there'd been problems, so they decided to stop letting them in. 
 &bquo;We do not have a sign on the door. 
 We usually have a sign near the main till but it's not here today.&equo; 
 We were not convinced. 
 SCOTTISH WOOLLEN 
 A strict anti-dog policy. 
 One shop assistant was polite, but adamant and explained: &bquo;Dogs are not allowed because of the risk of soiling or damage to the woollen clothes.&equo; 
 PRESENT &amp; CORRECT? 
 BODY SHOP 
 The sweet smell of success: Staff happy to allow owners with dogs to browse. 
 We received some odd looks from customers but most smiled and fussed over Spike &amp; Molly. 
 CLINTON CARDS 
 Manager Mr Cutts said: &bquo;Provided they're with their owners and are on leads, they're welcome, but to be honest, we don't get many in.&equo; 
 Clearly no anti-dog policy here. 
 OTHER DEPARTMENT STORE POLICIES: 
 Store 
 Policy 
 Comments 
 BHS 
 No 
 Health &amp; safety reasons 
 Harvey Nichols 
 No 
 Company policy 
 C&amp;A 
 No 
 Company policy 
 Army &amp; Navy 
 No 
 Hygiene &mdash; sells cosmetics clothes and food 
 Peter Jones 
 Yes 
 As long as well-behaved 
 Harrods 
 No 
 Company policy 
 OTHER BOOK/RECORD STORE POLICIES: 
 Store 
 Policy 
 Comments 
 W H Smith 
 No 
 Children sit on the floor and read books 
 Virgin Records 
 No 
 Operational policy 
 Our Price Open It either depends on the shopping centre or individual managers 
 Waterstones 
 Yes 
 Happy, if well-behaved 
 BOOKS etc. 
 Yes 
 If under control 
 John Menzies 
 No 
 Because we sell food 
 Rymans 
 Yes 
 People usually leave dogs outside 
 OTHER SHOE SHOPS POLICIES: 
 Store 
 Policy 
 Comments 
 Russell &amp; Bromley 
 Yes 
 If well-behaved 
 Bally 
 Yes 
 If not unruly 
 Ravel 
 No 
 Customer complaints 
 Clarks 
 Yes 
 If well-behaved 
 OTHER GIFT STORES POLICIES: 
 Store 
 Policy 
 Comments 
 Ratners 
 Yes 
 If well-behaved 
 H Samuel 
 Very welcome 
 If under control 
 Zales 
 Yes 
 If clean 
 OTHER CLOTHES STORES POLICIES: 
 Store 
 Policy 
 Reason 
 Top Shop 
 Yes 
 No problem 
 Burtons 
 Yes 
 Operational policy 
 The Gap 
 No 
 Corporate policy from the USA 
 Austin Reed 
 Yes 
 No problem 
 Laura Ashley 
 Yes 
 Ditto 
 Hennes 
 Yes 
 If well-behaved 
 River Island 
 No 
 Store policy 
 Richards 
 Yes 
 No problem 
 Sock Shop 
 Yes 
 If under control 
 Fogle's Files  
 Puppy Parties 
 The whole family joins in with these parties &mdash; dogs and all. 
 It's the ideal way to socialise your pup 
 BRUCE FOGLE 
 If you've been to a puppy party you'll know how much fun it can be to train your pup in a positive and natural way. 
 Families learn how to handle dogs and dogs learn how to live with each other and all sizes and varieties of humans. 
 We all realise puppyhood is the most important time in a dog's life. 
 The experiences during those first 16 to 18 weeks affect your dog's personality forever. 
 And it's so easy to create good and practical experiences for your pup's benefit. 
 Puppy parties work this way: someone organises a weekly gettogether for pups and owners. 
 The pups are not fed their meal before the party but, instead, the organiser provides every human a small bag of dry dog food. 
 This is important, because at puppy parties, the pups are fed by strangers. 
 The first few times, the pup gets his food for free to demonstrate to him that people are nice, but after a few treats he has to sit for his stranger and for his supper. 
 All the family come to the party and children take an active part. 
 This is especially important and valuable for puppy owners who do not have young children, because this is how pups learn about kids &mdash; and how much fun they can be. 
 During the first party, children give the dogs treats. 
 That's a good introduction to kids. 
 At the next party a week later, the children learn how to get their pups to sit by simply using a hand signal. 
 Once they learn how to do that with their own dogs, they can't resist commanding other pups to sit for their food rewards. 
 The result is that the children learn how to control dogs and the dogs learn that obeying children is simply part of life. 
 And the extra reward is that if a dog learns to sit when he sees a child, it means he doesn't jump up. 
 Fun, isn't it? 
 THROWING A GOOD PARTY 
 I started organising puppy parties for my clients a few months back, using a good dog trainer to co-ordinate the parties and a local church hall as the venue. 
 During the six weekly get-togethers, open only to pups under 18 weeks old, they and their families learn the basic commands &mdash; &bquo;come&equo;, &bquo;sit&equo;, &bquo;heel&equo; and &bquo;wait&equo; &mdash; as well as how to toilettrain, groom and road-walk their dogs. 
 Owners get information on pet health insurance,  kenneling  and more advanced training. 
 For too long I thought this type of training was not the responsibility of the vet. 
 After all, we're trained to a superbly technical level of scientific competence. 
 My job is to treat cancer, repair fractures or control disease. 
 Why should I possibly become interested in the emotional development of my young patients? 
 LESS NEEDLE 
 The answer is strikingly simple. 
 The most common cause of death in dogs under one year of age in the UK is &bquo;elective euthanasia&equo;, the active decision by owners to put their dogs to sleep. 
 The most common reason why so many families come to such a harsh decision is because their dog has behaviour problems they can't control. 
 It is far easier to prevent behaviour problems from developing than it is to correct them once they have become entrenched habits. 
 By providing patients and their owners with organised puppy parties, I can save more lives than I will with drugs or scalpel. 
 This case is one which emphatically supports the old axiom: &bquo;Prevention is better than cure&equo;. 
 SCRUFFS 
 by Russell Jones 
 HOW COMFORTING TO KNOW THAT WHEN ONE IS FINDING CITY LIFE A TRIFLE TIRESOME, ONE HAS FRIENDS IN HIGH PLACES GRACIOUS ENOUGH TO INVITE ONE OUT FOR A DAY IN THE COUNTRY&hellip; 
 TO THE WOODS KEVIN MY GOOD MAN AND DON'T SPARE THE HORSES!!  
 Sinitta  SINGING THE PRAISES OF DOG OWNERSHIP 
 Sinitta's whirlwind lifestyle in the pop world doesn't easily match the routine demands of dog ownership. 
 It takes effort, planning&hellip; and roast chicken 
 JOHN RICHARDSON 
 Many of us know the difficulties of having a dog and holding down a job. 
 For a chart-busting pop star with a heavy travelling schedule &mdash; like Sinitta &mdash; it is particularly hard. 
 She is, however, determined to make a success of everything she does, including being a dog owner. 
 For as long as Sinitta can recall, she has owned a dog. 
 As a child of 11, she had one which featured with her in her first professional engagement, as Dorothy in The Wiz , the all-black version of The Wizard of Oz , at the Sheffield Crucible. 
 Her Yorkshire Terrier played Toto. 
 When Sinitta was with David Essex, her Mutiny on The Bounty  costar, he presented her with Fletch, a Cairn Terrier named after Fletcher Christian, the character he played in the show. 
 Shortly afterwards, Sinitta and David split up and she signed a major recording deal which culminated in her single So Macho  reaching number two in the charts, only missing the top spot because of Chris De Burgh's Lady in Red . 
 The record company prepared her an exhaustive schedule which made it impossible for her to give Fletch the attention he deserved so, reluctantly, she gave him to friends. 
 For the next couple of years, Sinitta was dog-less as she ran up an amazing string of chart hits with the guidance of the nowlegendary Stock, Aitken and Waterman. 
 By the end of the 80s, Sinitta had established a stable home life suitable for a dog, even if she wasn't always able to be around. 
 When she got engaged to  Shakespearian  actor Tom Harklie, she bought an Australian Silky Terrier puppy called Mr Cod. 
 &bquo;He earned his name because of the expression on his face. 
 &bquo;Cod&equo; is a word we use if someone is a bit off or fishy,&equo; Sinitta explained. 
 &bquo;Mr Cod could be very fishy when he wanted, but he was also very nice!&equo; 
 Sadly, Mr Cod was destined to  be with them for only a short time. 
 While Sinitta was on tour, she loaned the recording studio in the basement of her home to another songwriter. 
 He left a gate open and Mr Cod wandered off, never to be seen again. 
 As this happened two weeks before Christmas, Sinitta hopes someone scooped him up for a Christmas gift. 
 Extensive efforts to trace him turned up nothing. 
 When Mr Cod was a puppy, Simon Cowell, the man who signed Sinitta to her first recording deal, bought her a Yorkshire Terrier to keep Mr Cod company. 
 He was named Massino &mdash; Max for short &mdash; and is currently &bquo;number one&equo; canine in Sinitta's life. 
 Since Mr Cod's disappearance, Max goes to the country to stay with friends whenever Sinitta has to go away. 
 &bquo;He really loves his country visits as he is very pampered and fed on roast chicken,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;He is quite a character. 
 When he comes back he goes on a hunger strike for chicken. 
 He usually stops eating for a couple of days but I talk him out of it. 
 On occasion I have stopped eating, too. 
 Soon he is back to his normal diet. 
 &bquo;I recently bought lots of special doggie chews back from the States. 
 He has ignored them all. 
 &bquo;He quite enjoys singing along to records at parties, except when one of mine is played! 
 He tries to figure out why my lips aren't moving.&equo; 
 Max has been to numerous rehearsals with his celebrity owner and once appeared on breakfast TV. 
 &bquo;One of the other guests made a great point of saying she would never work with children or animals,&equo; Sinitta explains. 
 &bquo;She looked Max and I up and down in a most condescending manner. 
 Max took an instant dislike to her and from then on, when she tried to speak, he would howl like a wolf and I got a dreadful fit of the giggles! 
 I couldn't help myself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Eventually, Max had to be escorted off the set. 
 I got bags of letters, all giving Max tremendous support. 
 Actually, I think the woman was envious that I was sexy and Max was cute &mdash; or the other way round!&equo; 
 Among Max's other hobbies are going for long walks, travelling in the car and sitting on the fax machine, which always gives him a surprise when it starts working. 
 &bquo;Lately, he's been very much in love because he saw the April issue of Dogs Today  with Julian Clary's dog, Fanny, on the cover. 
 He spent two days drooling over her. 
 Perhaps we should do a little bit of matchmaking,&equo; she suggested. 
 Sinitta has a very serious involvement with animals. 
 She is the chairman of the Animal Defenders Youth Group, whose aim is to expose and alleviate animal suffering. 
 She designed a T-shirt for them and has written their anthem Children of the 90s . 
 The group recently opened a shop in Birmingham selling only crueltyfree products. 
 In coming months, Max may be spending a bit more time in the country, as Sinitta is on the brink of signing a world-wide recording contract and a movie deal. 
 He can take some comfort in the fact that, while his mistress works on becoming music's &bquo;Name of the 90s&equo;, he can fully indulge his passion for roast chicken.  
 Dog Stars  
 JACK RUSSELL GRANT 
 Virgo (Aug 24&ndash;Sept 23) 
 You feel a bit dozy and dull this month, with a propensity for lying on your back in the sun, dreaming of bygone days. 
 Try to think more positively about walks, and wake up to new opportunities outside your immediate area. 
 Green grass and fresh fields are there for the taking. 
 Libra (Sept 24&ndash;Oct 23) 
 This is the month for new ventures, whether it be in the form of a dog show, obedience class or merely a fraternisation with local canine characters. 
 Your owner will indulge your whims and you'll feel favoured by all. 
 Scorpio (Oct 24&ndash;Nov 22) 
 Your down-to-earth, no-nonsense mood will endear you to your owner, who may well remark on this new change of character. 
 Now is the time to consolidate your gains by asking for more walks and extra perks, as your sensible attitude will enhance your standing during this fruitful period. 
 Sagittarius (Nov 23&ndash;Dec 21) 
 The middle of the month arrives with you really having a fling. 
 You are popular with canines and humans alike, so get out and about. 
 If entering a show, you may well find you come up trumps, mainly because you feel so fit and full of life. 
 This is definitely a phase when you can wag your tail with impunity at both friend and foe. 
 Capricorn (Dec 22&ndash;Jan 20) 
 Family friendships are becoming increasingly important to you, especially those involving the young fry, so make the most of this camaraderie and enter into the spirit of things. 
 Canine relationships are also good and you may meet a long-haired mutt of doubtful pedigree but winning ways, who will prove a good chum. 
 Aquarius (Jan 21&ndash;Feb 19) 
 The somewhat revolutionary character of the true Aquarian is showing through this month and you're definitely on the lookout for subversive activities, such as home-wrecking or a protest howl-in. 
 Try to neutralise these tendencies by taking heed of your owner's complaints, or you may finish up the underdog. 
 Pisces (Feb 20&ndash;March 20) 
 Caution should be your watchword this month. 
 Keep well away from disputes involving dogs, cats and any other species of small creature. 
 Learn to appreciate your home comforts. 
 Concentrate on indoor delights rather than outdoor fights and you'll be much better appreciated. 
 Aries (March 21&ndash;April 20) 
 The leadership traits of the Arien bring your talents to the fore, but don't get too carried away. 
 Earn your freedom by behaving well and keeping in with your owner. 
 Although you are all for outings with a pack, you will have to be content with your lot for now. 
 However, brighter times are ahead, when you will get the opportunity to realise your full potential. 
 Taurus (April 21&ndash;May 21) 
 An unexpected outing comes your way and you'll feel buoyant liberated; willing and able to cope with new demands upon your intellect and personality. 
 Strange canine characters are pleased to get acquainted and never have you been more popular. 
 Keep up the good work during this exhilarating time. 
 Gemini (May 22&ndash;June 21) 
 Frustrations will cloud your horizons for a time but you will shake them off and emerge well pleased with your efforts. 
 A surprise gift is forecast, in the form of some mouth-watering delicacy, but watch your figure and don't over-indulge 
 Cancer (June 22&ndash;July 23) 
 There'll be an unexpected meeting with a rakish hound which, initially, may cause a few problems. 
 However, owner know-how will extract you from trouble. 
 Just keep your cool and you'll yet emerge as top dog. 
 LEO (July 24&ndash;August 23) 
 Roar of the lion-heart 
 An amorous meeting is forecast, so keep yourself smart, sociable and suitably alert for what promises to be an interesting episode. 
 Your owner may not be too happy but persevere and you'll emerge triumphant and glorious. 
 Other outings will bring further adventure. 
 Owner's tip: Try to remember that every dog must have its day.  
 A Bona-Fido  holiday 
 Chesterfield's Ringwood Hall is part of the Consort hotel chain, which welcomes dogs to its establishments. 
 Our canine consultant, Sally, was only too keen to check out its bona fidos. 
 BRIAN KELLY 
 No pain, no sprain; not even a yelp. 
 Bearded Collies can show all the grace of drunken  hippoes . 
 As with most good tumbles, you could see this one coming a mile off &mdash; and could do nothing to prevent the inevitable. 
 We humans used the bridge, but of course, Sally had to negotiate this dry Derbyshire creek bed her own way. 
 She took a run-up, carved quite a beautiful arc against the sky and promptly vanished, with a shoosh, into very long, dry grass. 
 Her paws kept reaching for the ground, but it was not there. 
 She tried gamely to hold her head high and proud, but to no avail. 
 She simply disappeared. 
 Looking back, it was bloody hilarious. 
 A shocked demeanour and a couple of nettle stings to valiant rescuer Beverley were the only legacies. 
 Luckily, it was the worst thing to happen to poor Sal all weekend. 
 After all, this adventure was definitely her holiday. 
 Best alternatives for holidaying dog owners have traditionally been kindly neighbours or kennels, but a York-based hotel chain say you can take it with you (your pup, that is). 
 More than 170 Consort hotels welcome dogs, with about a third offering something a bit special &mdash; Bona-Fido &mdash; which operates a bit like the AA's rating, but with stars switched for bones. 
 Ringwood Hall, a gentry dream built about 1805 and now overlooking Sheffield's satellite towns and remaining greenery, boasts the full five bones. 
 If you think your dog is spoilt rotten at home, check out what's on offer here. 
 There's a &bquo;chat-and-pat&equo; service; staff call your hound by name, and tiptoe past your room at night so as to let sleeping dogs lie; your dog's photograph is taken in the hotel; the hotel manager appears for a final &bquo;wave-and-wag&equo;; there's a VIP service for show-winning dogs; and a discount for families whose dogs are better behaved than the owners! 
 Of course, it's not all free-range. 
 Dogs can't go in eating areas, and it's preferred that they don't climb all over furniture in sitting rooms, but there's a good acre or 27 of space for romping and rambling. 
 Ah yes, digging up the bowling green would probably mean some explaining, as well.  
 Assistant manager Nicholas Tindall said not all staff were madkeen on dogs and neither were all guests, but wishes were always respected and the dogs were generally well accepted. 
 &bquo;We've been doing Bona-Fido for about two years but still get some guests who don't realise they could have brought their dogs along,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Ringwood's history with dogs goes back a bit further. 
 Somewhere in the grounds there's a grave for Lady, who was the pet of the original family here last century. 
 Most hotels offer a one-bone service, welcoming well-behaved dogs and providing doggie bowls on request. 
 Add another bone and you also get a list of recommended walks for dogs and tinned dog food made available, to your canine chum. 
 Three bones gets you an official welcome and 15-minute walkies with a staff member. 
 A quartet means the first refusal of all carvery scraps and use of a dog-sitting service. 
 Bones don't appear just in the rating. 
 A &bquo;real&equo; shaped version was offered to our Sal &mdash; and popular it was, too. 
 It's now a well-gnawed stump on our sitting room floor. 
 It's a nice idea. 
 In an allegedly animal-friendly society, where the rules for pets in public places are generally blurred and often very bad, it's pleasing to put your head down on a strange pillow knowing your pet is just a pat away. 
 Having dogs catered for is fine, even if they are clumsy oafs! 
 WIN A WONDERFUL WEEKEND WITH CONSORT 
 Consort Hotels have generously offered a free weekend for two &mdash; plus one dog &mdash; at The George Hotel, Montrose, Scotland. 
 Our lucky free draw winner will be treated to dinner, bed and breakfast, but the holiday must be taken before December, 1991 (subject to availability and excluding bank holidays). 
 To enter, send a postcard (or closed envelope) with your name and address to Bona-Fido  
 The winner will be drawn on September 1st. 
 If you would like a Consort Short Breaks brochure, listing all bone-rated hotels, phone 0904 620137 or write to Consort Hotels Ltd, Ryedale Building, Piccadilly, York, YO1 1PN. 
 All callers will receive a special Dogs Today  10% discount voucher, redeemable against any holiday listed in the brochure and booked through Consort Central Reservations.  
 ESCAPE FROM EGYPT 
 From Cairo to Chorley is an incredibly long journey. 
 Thanks to an abandoned mutt, a whole family decided to take the slow boat home 
 ANNABELLE FLEMING 
 Scottie and her sister were found in the boot of a car. 
 The car was in Cairo and belonged to my brother, who was working there on a six-month contract. 
 That was 1984. 
 Whether the pups had been put there in the hope they would be cared for, or just dumped, is not exactly known. 
 All enquiries as to their ownership produced no clues. 
 The abandoned pair were orphans and obviously unwanted. 
 The pups had the appearance of a Pharaoh Hound crossed with a rough-haired terrier. 
 Scottie is mainly black, with a white chest and white ankle socks on black legs. 
 In contrast, her sister is self-coloured grey. 
 My brother, a dog lover, whose own elderly dog was being cared for back in England, decided to take the pups home to the family. 
 An American expatriate offered to take the grey. 
 That left Scottie, a gentle beast, to settle in, make friends with the children and grow very tall and healthy. 
 As the weeks passed and the time to leave drew nearer, the family became worried about Scottie's future. 
 Now used to kindness, she would not survive the streets of Cairo if they left her behind. 
 A new home would have to be found. 
 Adverts extolling her virtues were placed at every suitable vantage point. 
 &bquo;Gentle dog adopted by British family needs kind replacement home. 
 Good with children and house-trained, very obedient.&equo; 
 No one seemed to want Scottie, virtues or no virtues. 
 Only one option remained. 
 Scottie's visa was applied for; she was coming to England. 
 Her application was not processed in time for her to fly home on British Airways with the rest of the family so the flight was cancelled. 
 They would have to come home the long way round. 
 They sailed to Italy. 
 The boat docked at Ancora, where Scottie was accepted and allowed to land. 
 Then it was on to Switzerland and, finally, by road to Belgium. 
 Scottie loved travelling and behaved splendidly during the long drives and sailing periods. 
 Reluctantly, Scottie had to be left in kennels in Ostend while her family applied for her entry papers in England. 
 Once they were granted, the ship sailed with her to Dover. 
 There she was met by her family and, after a joyful reunion aboard ship, she was collected by kennel staff and quarantined in Manchester. 
 Her kennel fees and fares cost more than &pound;1,000. 
 Scottie is very happy in Lancashire and she is patient with the elderly, family dogs. 
 Scottie is afraid of men, perhaps some remnant of her unknown past. 
 She continues to love children and mothers all small animals.  
 Rottie  to the core 
 Steve Norman is a real-life hero to hundreds of Rottweilers, going against the weight of public opinion to turn his own home into a Rottie rescue centre 
 JONATHAN CRAYMER 
 The spate of Rottweiler horror stories in the press last year resulted in dozens of owners turfing their dogs out. 
 Horrified by this trend, Steve Norman, a joiner from Berkshire, turned his home into a shelter for unwanted Rotties. 
 He's not popular with some of the neighbours but Steve couldn't sit back while the animals suffered. 
 &bquo;Devil dogs&equo;, the headlines screamed; &bquo;killers&equo;, &bquo;murdering beasts&equo;. 
 The tabloid press and the film industry (for example, The Omen ) unnecessarily portray the Rottweiler as an evil beast with insatiable bloodlust. 
 In 1989, an 11-year-old girl was killed by two Rotties and public terror reached fever pitch. 
 Fortunately, much of the fuss has abated, but not before hundreds of the dogs were abandoned or, worse still, brutally mistreated in the name of discipline. 
 SEXUALLY ABUSED 
 One of the first dogs Steve rescued &mdash; four-year-old Tyler &mdash; had an eye poked out by a loutish owner wielding a screwdriver. 
 It wasn't the first such attack. 
 &bquo;Some of these people think you have to treat &bquo;tough&equo; dogs brutally,&equo; he said, bitterly. 
 &bquo;You couldn't print my personal opinion of them. 
 Many of the lowlife characters who get hold of Rottweilers have the same mentality as child abusers. 
 In fact, some of the dogs brought to us have been sexually abused.&equo; 
 Steve and Joanne de Nobriga set up the refuge in mid-1989. 
 I first went to meet some of their charges in April last year at Steve's rescue home in Bracknell. 
 I knew I'd come to the right place. 
 The ground shook with a chorus of deep barks. 
 I imagined Gregory Peck running for cover in that spooky cemetery in The Omen . 
 I hoped the dogs would be in the garden but the moment I stepped inside I was surrounded by five of the massive dogs. 
 All I could think of was that joke &mdash; &bquo;What has four legs and an arm? 
 A Rottweiler.&equo; 
 I hoped the dogs hadn't heard it. 
 I needn't have worried. 
 All I could feel were five soft muzzles have a friendly sniff. 
 Stumpy tails wagged. 
 Then the ground shook again; this time it was Steve, ordering them back to the kitchen. 
 They obeyed, instantly. 
 As we chatted, most of the five dogs sat on my feet. 
 &bquo;They're very human orientated,&equo; Joanne said, encouragingly. 
 Brought in early last year, Max had been so badly kicked by a sadistic owner that most of his bodily organs were in the wrong places. 
 His digestive system developed a cyst, requiring a special diet &mdash; no meat, eggs or milk. 
 Veterinary nurse Tracey Chamberlain, a Rottie rescue helper, said: &bquo;Some people are so sick. 
 When the owner had finished beating him, he was advertised in the local paper as &bquo;a loving dog needing a new home&equo;. 
 &bquo;His new owners wondered why he wouldn't come out of his kennel. 
 He was too scared.&equo; 
 Sadly, Max never fully recovered. 
 &bquo;He was distressed from all the moving, so it was kindest to put him down,&equo; Steve said. 
 Steve has kennels for between eight and 10 dogs. 
 Where possible, he tries to rehome dogs directly. 
 Last year he rehoused 165 Rotties. 
 Of those, only two had to be destroyed. 
 One was Max, the other was a bitch which had never been socialised. 
 &bquo;She was kept in a garden by an anti-social owner,&equo; Steve explained. 
 &bquo;She never met anyone or anything. 
 She wanted to bite and kill everything.&equo; 
 When we talked again, Steve had two dogs in the house &mdash; Branston and Dennis. 
 Dennis had been abandoned and, having wandered about long enough, he climbed into a passing car and wouldn't budge. 
 The perplexed driver took him to a police station &mdash; which then contacted Steve. 
 The RSPCA hands out Steve's phone number to anyone having difficulties with Rottweilers. 
 He's had dogs from as far afield as London and Liverpool. 
 Branston came from Birmingham. 
 A couple with two children, expecting a third, decided their house was getting too crowded so the dog had to go. 
 Thankfully, as many people ring up wanting Rotties. 
 &bquo;People who've lost a Rottweiler often want another adult dog, rather than encourage the puppy market. 
 They usually provide good homes.&equo; 
 In fact, Steve's relieved to see the need for his work diminishing. 
 &bquo;Much of the media hype has gone, and the Rottweiler Association asked owners not to breed their dogs, so there's a lot less of them about. 
 Breeders can be more fussy about who buys them.&equo; 
 This year Steve's rehoused just 40 dogs. 
 Because of business commitments he's cut down on his rescue work. 
 However, Steve's 20-year-old son Mark looks after the dogs when dad's away. 
 Recently, Steve gave up his joinery business to set up a small security firm, hoping for more time to devote to the much-needed rescue. 
 When doing his night work he takes his dog, Kessler. 
 &bquo;He barks on command and looks aggressive, but he's trained not to bite.&equo; 
 Steve is a trained dog-obedience instructor and believes people are to blame in almost every headline-hitting incident involving Rottweilers. 
 Indeed, the Kennel Club describes the Rottweiler as: &bquo;Goodnatured, not nervous or vicious.&equo; 
 The Kennel Club's Bill Edmond added: &bquo;225 Rottweilers were shown at Crufts last year without a snarl or a growl from any of them.&equo; 
 &bquo;The key is train them properly  from the word go,&equo; Steve emphasised. 
 &bquo;They must be socialised, meet people and children, and get used to busy streets, fairgrounds and traffic. 
 Dogs missing these early experiences could end up frightened of anything &mdash; and, yes, a potential menace. 
 &bquo;Also, leaving dogs alone in a yard will tend to make them aggressive and anti-social.&equo; 
 &bquo;Often, what's perceived to be aggression is simply fear or nervousness,&equo; Joanne added, recalling the first dog they rescued. 
 &bquo;It was awful. 
 An owner, who'd clearly been mistreating it, gave it back to its breeders. 
 They couldn't cope either and, in desperation, literally dumped it on the doorstep. 
 WOODEN LEG 
 &bquo;I was alone and had no idea if it was going to attack. 
 But, after half an hour prowling round the kitchen, the dog &mdash; Rudy &mdash; came over to me. 
 I stroked him, he gave me a big lick, and I could see relief sweep over him knowing I wasn't going to hit him.&equo; 
 Ideally, Steve would like more space for the rescue operation. 
 He is hoping a local farm owner will rent him space to run a boarding kennels and rescue side by side &mdash; one supporting the other. 
 Steve's immediate neighbours are terrific. 
 There've been no complaints when rescued dogs have howled through the night. 
 However, others are less supportive. 
 Rubbish, dog excreta, broken glass and other unpleasant items have been thrown into Steve's garden and his tyres have also been slashed. 
 Joanne and Steve work closely with the RSPCA. 
 An RSPCA spokesman said: &bquo;We welcome any organisations working for animal welfare. 
 &bquo;But we would like to see dog owners registered &mdash; a move we feel would cut out a lot of bad apples and would also make much rescue work unnecessary.&equo; 
 Steve and Joanne took in Captain Pugwash &mdash; a 17-stone Great Dane-Mastiff cross &mdash; after it bit a pensioner's leg off. 
 The story made News of the World . 
 &bquo;It was only a wooden leg, though,&equo; explained Steve. 
 The two owners were aged 84 and 71 and, after the chewing incident, the RSPCA swapped it for a smaller dog. 
 &bquo;We obedience-trained him and found him a new home. 
 He didn't chew anything after that. 
 &bquo;I think he'd been fascinated by the wooden leg banging on the floor. 
 It was just a stick to him.&equo; 
 RESULTS PET CENSUS 
 Are you typical? 
 Thanks so much to the thousands of you who took the time and trouble to fill out the Pet Census in the April issue. 
 We now know so much more about you! 
 Now we can introduce the typical Dogs Today reader. 
 She is a 34-year-old lady who lives in the suburbs of a city with her husband or partner. 
 They own a retriever called Ben. 
 She collected Ben from his breeders when he was eight weeks old, having paid &pound;175. 
 Both parents were registered with the Kennel Club and the mating was planned rather than accidental. 
 Ben is fairly obedient but he won't beg or fetch slippers. 
 He's allowed the free run of the house. 
 He sleeps in his owner's bedroom, but he's got his own bean bed. 
 When he travels in the car, he's safe behind the dog guard. 
 Ben gets two or more walks a day and plays with a rubber ring. 
 He's usually walked on a flexible lead. 
 Ben's owner always carries a poop scoop and is very aware of the anti-dog brigade. 
 Ben's favourite treat is a dog chew, but dog biscuits and bones aren't far behind. 
 Every few months his owner gives Ben a bath. 
 He has his own towel and shampoo, but she uses the family bath and sometimes her own hairdryer. 
 She chooses Ben's food &mdash; a dry, complete diet, twice a day &mdash; because it suits his digestion and he likes it. 
 Price is a minor concern, as is packaging. 
 She first saw Dogs Today  on the newsstand, reads it from cover to cover and then keeps it. 
 Her partner reads the magazine, too, and sometimes she lends a copy to a friend. 
 Her favourite article is Peter Neville's True Case Histories. 
 She likes all our regulars but finds the crossword a bit hard! 
 Ben always goes on holiday with his owner. 
 When she's got a moment she probably reads Bella , Best  or Take a Break , and regularly buys the Daily Mail . 
 She sometimes goes to agricultural shows and exemption dog shows. 
 Is this typical reader you? 
 If so, we'd love to hear from you! 
 The most typical reader will win a special golden bone award. 
 Send us your photo and tell us how similar you are to our average reader. 
 Send your letters to: Typical Readers    
 Memoirs of a Dog Shrink  
 Watt phobia? 
 Jess was a mellow sort of chap until he came face to face with a light bulb  
 Cartoonist Russell Jones takes a ramble through Peter Neville's files 
 Case number: 72 
 Name: Jessie 
 Breed: Collie 
 Problem: Light bulb phobia 
 Jess the collie was a laid-back sort of hound who spent most of his life stretched out on a fireside rug in his large Surrey home. 
 The closest he came to exercise was to open one eye every so often, if someone entered the room, or to open both eyes, smile, and wag his tail as he'd done on one occasion when confronted by a housebreaker! 
 This extremely lazy lifestyle was one long yawn from dawn to dusk. 
 Only the odd bouts of involuntary twitching in his sleep reassured his owner that Jess was still safe and sound in the land of the living! 
 One winter night, as the mutt twitched away in front of the fire, his mind somewhere between Basingstoke and the twilight zone, a 100-watt light bulb in the standard lamp above his head suddenly exploded without warning! 
 According to his owner, who witnessed the spectacle, Jessie rose gracefully toward the ceiling like a space shuttle and, after lingering in mid-air for what seemed an eternity, crashed to the floor and fled the house with a speed and agility the owner found quite amazing. 
 Jessie did not return home for several hours. 
 When he eventually did show up, it was obvious to all that he was a changed dog! 
 What plodded through the front door was not the lovable, lazy hound who had once lived there but a grim-faced light bulb serial killer! 
 Within seconds of his return, Jessie launched a vicious attack on a table lamp, popping the bulb and wrecking the shade before charging into the lounge. 
 There, in a frenzy of violence, he reduced the standard lamp to a table lamp in 10 seconds flat! 
 After a room-to-room chase lasting several minutes, during which every lamp in the house was turned to sawdust, the dog was finally caught and wrestled to the ground. 
 With his house plunged into darkness, Jessie's owner sought my help. 
 SIMPLE SOLUTION 
 When I first saw the dog, it was quite obvious he'd been deeply affected by the explosion and had developed a 100-watt phobia for light bulbs! 
 By placing his feeding bowl closer each day to a table lamp the dog gradually learned to live with his enemy. 
 Within a couple of weeks, his killer instincts had disappeared and he was back where he belonged &mdash; twitching away peacefully on the fireside rug. 
 CROSS QUESTION 
 Can you guess which breeds Peggy's parents are? 
 She is a first cross between two well-known breeds. 
 The first correct entry out of the hat on September 2nd will win a prize. 
 If your dog is an unusual first cross, please send us a photo and all the relevant details so we can include him or her in a future issue. 
 Send your answer to Cross-question  
 JUNE SOLUTION 
 Ben's parents were a Gordon Setter and an Afghan Hound. 
 The first correct entry drawn out of the hat came from Caroline Fitzgerald from Stamford Brook, London, who wins a Golden Bone Award.  
 Diabetic dogs 
 Diabetes in humans is not pleasant, but nowadays it can be dealt with and controlled without too much inconvenience. 
 Similar advancements have also made life easier for diabetic dogs like Jasper  STEPH FREEMAN 
 Dogs Today  's Launch issue cover story last November featured Guinness, who earned a Bounce Superdog award when he saved his owner from a diabetic coma by fetching him a Mars bar. 
 Many humans are diabetics (this writer included!) but did you know one in 200 dogs also live with this condition? 
 So what is diabetes all about? 
 Diabetes mellitus occurs when the body is unable to convert carbohydrates (for example &mdash; in a dog's case &mdash; choc drops, dog biscuits and cereal products) into energy. 
 This is due to a lack of the hormone insulin, normally produced in the pancreas. 
 Insulin controls the body's blood sugar level. 
 The effect of this can be quite shocking, because the body's reaction is to start breaking down fat stores and tissue in order to produce energy. 
 The resulting high blood sugar level &mdash; the unconverted carbohydrate &mdash; means the kidneys must work harder, thus requiring more water to flush out waste products. 
 Not surprisingly then, common signs of diabetes mellitus include increased urine production, weight loss despite a healthy appetite, increased thirst and tiredness. 
 Possibly a smell similar to pear drops will also be present on your dog's breath. 
 Despite the frightening connotations, with careful management and medication your dog will regain weight and can live a fully active life. 
 Should these symptoms become apparent, get your dog to a vet &mdash; quickly! 
 Neglect and lack of treatment will eventually result in a coma and possible death. 
 Diabetes is not curable. 
 It is known, rather alarmingly, as a chronic condition. 
 Good control of the condition is vital and this is achieved through a combination of insulin injections, diet regulation, control of exercise and careful monitoring of the condition &mdash; in other words, a regular routine. 
 ROAD ACCIDENT 
 Jackie Sinclaire, from Horncastle, Lincolnshire, has a seven-year-old Golden Retriever named Jasper who was diagnosed diabetic about 18 months ago. 
 &bquo;It was a bit of a shock at first,&equo; Jackie said. 
 &bquo;I'd never heard of it before in relation to dogs but our vet was wonderful. 
 &bquo;He explained everything to us and was always available when he was needed. 
 Jasper had been in a road accident a few months before the diagnosis. 
 He wasn't badly hurt but people have since told me that shock sometimes starts the onset of diabetes. 
 &bquo;I've also been told a prolonged illness can start it and, of course, some dogs just have a weakness. 
 Jasper had been fine until the accident &mdash; very healthy in fact &mdash; but soon after, he showed all the symptoms of the condition. 
 &bquo;He was drinking a lot, eating loads and still losing weight. 
 &bquo;The worst thing was the puddles on the kitchen floor! 
 He obviously felt really guilty about that. 
 He'd always been so clean before, so we knew there was something wrong and took him to the vet immediately.&equo; 
 How does Jackie cope with the injections? 
 &bquo;Well, it was a bit difficult at first,&equo; she explained. 
 &bquo;I'd only ever given him pills before, and I'm not medically trained, but it's surprising how quickly you get used to it. 
 &bquo;It becomes part of the daily routine, like brushing your teeth. 
 Jasper wasn't too keen to start with and you can hardly blame him, but now he's fine about it. 
 It's all done very quickly.&equo; 
 Are there any problems? 
 &bquo;No, not really. 
 I do have to watch what he eats very carefully, give him his injections and make sure he eats regularly. 
 &bquo;If I don't, he has a hypo (hypoglycaemic attack), when his blood sugar dips too low. 
 You have to remember the amount of insulin he's given dictates how much he is allowed to eat and that's OK. 
 &bquo;The problems start when he becomes more excited and frisky than usual. 
 I can tell when he is having a hypo because he gets disorientated and confused. 
 He also twitches a lot. 
 &bquo;He knows what to do though &mdash; he comes straight to me, whining a bit. 
 I carry sugar lumps around with me and feed him those. 
 He gets over it very quickly.&equo; 
 So do dogs like sugar? 
 &bquo;Well, I must admit he wasn't so keen to start with,&equo; Jackie said. 
 &bquo;He never really had a sweet tooth, not even for choc drops. 
 Now he realises a sugar lump will make him feel better so he doesn't mind. 
 &bquo;Funnily enough, Jasper and I once helped a human diabetic out of a hypo with Jasper's stash of sugar lumps!&equo; 
 Jackie is maintaining an optimistic outlook for the future. 
 &bquo;I've still got Jasper and he's going to have a long and happy life,&equo; she declared. 
 &bquo;All the effort is worth it. 
 I wouldn't give him up for the world.&equo; 
 UNDER CONTROL 
 Your dog's vet will count carbohydrates by prescribing a set diet, through which, with regular exercise, the insulin can be balanced. 
 This is relatively easy with dogs. 
 In the long term, provided care is taken, there should be relatively few problems. 
 Poor control of diet and insulin intake will cause problems. 
 A diabetic dog's wounds must be carefully monitored and bad control means wounds heal more slowly. 
 There is also a risk of gangrene due to poor circulation, plus cataracts and possible kidney failure. 
 However, as Jackie said, it isn't too difficult to take adequate care and avoid these problems. 
 Diabetes mellitus does not mean the end of the world. 
 With a little commitment from you, as well as the expert help of your vet and cooperation from your dog, the risks are greatly reduced. 
 Jackie concluded: &bquo;Jasper certainly wasn't born with a silver spoon in his mouth, but there are quite a few occasions when he needs one now &mdash; of the sugar variety, of course!&equo;  
 In the frame 
 Old master or not? 
 Everyone dreams of finding a masterpiece in the attic. 
 That picture hanging over your fireplace might just be worth more than your whole house. 
 Why not check it out? 
 MAGGIE CROWLEY 
 Hanging proudly and prominently in many houses is a favourite doggie painting. 
 Whether inherited or picked up from an antique shop, it often holds a sentimental value &mdash; but what is it really worth? 
 That dusty old painting on the wall could well be worth a small fortune once inside an auction house. 
 But for many, the idea of selling those treasured pieces at a major sale has never crossed their mind; either that, or they just don't know how to do so. 
 In fact, it's relatively easy, provided there is a market. 
 Leading auctioneers, Bonhams and Christie's, have regular dogrelated sales every year and welcome any potentially valuable works of art. 
 Bonhams have a sale of canine art every January to coincide with Crufts, in which every doggie artefact imaginable can be found. 
 Bonhams press officer Jill Potterton told Dogs Today : &bquo;We are happy to give free evaluations to members of the public who come to see us. 
 &bquo;If it is any good, and the owner wants to sell, we will put the article into the January sale.&equo; 
 Christie's hold similar auctions twice a year; the first in January &mdash; also to mark Crufts &mdash; while their most recent, &bquo;Man's Best Friend&equo;, was held in July. 
 This auction included the largest single collection of paintings and sculptures of cats and dogs, from a deceased estate, but Christie's spokeswoman Susan Adams added: &bquo;We do have mixed properties, too. 
 This auction is unusual as the deceased had quite a lot of paintings of cats &mdash; we normally have more pictures of dogs at this particular auction. 
 &bquo;If anyone wanted to sell their piece, and we can see it's of sufficient quality or by a popular artist, we'll give an evaluation. 
 No one should be put off trying.&equo; 
 The Man's Best Friend sales attract potential buyers from around the world, with particular interest from America, which may indicate a growing market for animal art. 
 &bquo;I think there's a market, even though it's a narrow field,&equo; said Susan. 
 &bquo;Collectors are very active and are prepared to pay for a painting of a particular breed or artist.&equo; 
 However, Bonhams auctioneer Alastair Laird believes the actual numbers of artwork coming on the market is not as great as 10 years ago. 
 &bquo;When we first held these sales, we'd have up to 600 lots but now it's less than that,&equo; Alastair explained. 
 Whatever the current market climate, Christie's expect success with the Man's Best Friend auction, which features works by celebrated artists John Emms, Maud Earl, and John Henry Lorimer. 
 However, George Earl's oil painting &bquo;St Bernards in a snow drift&equo;, (above) is expected to attract the highest bid. 
 It is valued at &pound;18,000. 
 So, if you're on the lookout for a nice little earner, dust off the cobwebs and take your painting along to the professionals. 
 Once inside the auction room, it's just a matter of crossing your fingers and hoping somebody takes a fancy to it, too. 
 WIN free tickets 
 Working Dog of the Year Show 1991 
 The second Working Dog of the Year Show, sponsored again by Pedigree Chum, will take place at Wembley Arena on Sunday, 13 October. 
 Dogs Today  has joined forces with Pedigree Chum to run an exciting competition for 10 lucky people to win free tickets to see this thrilling doggie spectacular. 
 The Working Dog of the Year Show is scheduled for the Sunday after the horse of the Year Show and is set to become the top spectator event in London for dog lovers . 
 The 10 winners will see dramatic displays by working dogs from all walks of life. 
 There'll be demonstrations by the Metropolitan Police and Royal Army Veterinary Corps, showing how the military use dogs in their work. 
 There'll also be the Pedigree Chum Professional and Fun Agility Challenge finals, the Pedigree Formula Working Dog of the Year Awards and the fun Flyball competition. 
 Racing for Sled Dogs and Whippets will also be conducted and, to complete this canine extravaganza, there'll also be demonstrations by the International Sheep Dog Society and Guide Dogs for the Blind. 
 This event is a must for all dog enthusiasts! 
 Our lucky Dogs Today  winners and their guests will spend an afternoon at the show, with special Champagne tickets and VIP dinner included. 
 All winners will have their travel expenses paid. 
 Remember, if you'd prefer not to cut-up your magazine you can always photocopy the entry form &mdash; it will still be valid.   
 Seeing for Miles  
 Pete was Andrew Miles' guide. 
 He even introduced Andrew to the woman he would marry. 
 The doctors believed he would never see again. 
 They were wrong 
 ALAN COMBES 
 Surprisingly, not all blind people that own guide dogs are dog lovers &mdash; fortunately, however, Andrew Miles was. 
 I'd been officially blind for five years when I met Pete at the Guide Dog Centre in Wokingham, Berkshire,&equo; Andrew Miles explained. 
 &bquo;His trainer remarked at the immediate bond which formed between Pete and I.&equo; 
 Andrew was born with congenital glaucoma. 
 For his first 20 years, Andrew could see out of his left eye. 
 However, specialists told him glaucoma was slowly attacking the sight in his good eye. 
 &bquo;In the year before my vision went, I didn't let it get me down,&equo; Andrew said. 
 &bquo;I did a parachute jump, abseiled the White Cliffs of Dover and rode tandem to Paris. 
 &bquo;I've always believed in living life to the full.&equo; 
 Not only did Andrew meet Pete at the Guide Dog Centre, he also met his wife-to-be. 
 Wendy looked after the dogs, one of which was Pete. 
 During the 30 days of training at Wokingham, Pete and Andrew became the best of buddies and Wendy accepted a delighted Andrew's marriage proposal. 
 Four months later, Andrew, Wendy and Pete moved to Middlesborough to live. 
 Pete fulfilled the best man role and, during the wedding (in July, 1987), Pete wore all the gear and carried the rings in a little pouch on his harness. 
 Andrew was determined to pursue a computer career. 
 Pete accompanied him to training and Andrew was at last offered a Civil Servant post. 
 &bquo;Pete became very popular. 
 Everyone made such a fuss of him,&equo; Andrew said. 
 While on holiday in Scotland, Andrew and Wendy met a Christian group. 
 &bquo;Those people just had something special and we got to know them well,&equo; Andrew said. 
 &bquo;We decided to make a commitment and moved down to Malton in North Yorkshire so we could go to Bible College. 
 &bquo;As part of the college course we took a trip to Bristol to help with an evangelistic outreach. 
 &bquo;As I was blind, it was arranged for me to stay at the organiser's house. 
 His wife, Shirley, believed we'd been brought together for a reason and, after a while, she reckoned my sight would be healed. 
 &bquo;A lot of prayers were said for me but for six weeks absolutely nothing happened. 
 Then one morning Wendy left a pair of rubber gloves between the kitchen taps. 
 The sun was shining through the window and illuminated them. 
 I saw them and felt moved to pick them up. 
 &bquo;That was in July, 1990. 
 By September, I was driving a car and my sight was restored in both eyes. 
 &bquo;The doctors are completely baffled. 
 Medically, it's impossible for someone who has lost their sight due to glaucoma to get it back.&equo; 
 Incredible as this story is, it presents problems for Pete, the well-known and loved retriever cross. 
 Andrew and Wendy plan to work with drug addicts in Hong Kong and they will soon embark on a two-month trial period. 
 In their absence Pete will be looked after by the Bible College's bursar and husband in Malton. 
 Indeed, if things work out, this may be Pete's future. 
 &bquo;Leaving Pete is hard but we know he gets on well with these people and he's very adaptable.&equo; 
 How did Pete react to the restoration of Andrew's sight? 
 &bquo;Shortly after it returned, Pete was rolling around on the carpet and found a titbit,&equo; Andrew explained. 
 &bquo;Guide dogs are trained not to pick up such morsels because they may eat something unpleasant or possibly even dangerous. 
 &bquo;So I gave him a clip across the back and told him &bquo;No!&equo; 
 He just looked at me as if to say &bquo;how did you know I was doing that?&equo; 
 &bquo;The first time I took him for a walk without a harness, he had a bit of a job to work that out as well. 
 He kept looking round at me.&equo; 
 When I spoke to Andrew, he and Wendy were tending a farm for friends away on holiday. 
 Pete had established an amazing rapport with all the animals. 
 Lambs rubbed against the fence adjacent to Pete and cows seemed to smile at him across the farmyard. 
 Andrew and Wendy will miss Pete in Hong Kong, but so intelligent and sensitive a canine is he, they can expect the warmest Yorkshire welcome when they pay a return visit. 
 Dogs like Pete don't forget their friends! 
 Quick Bites by David Appleby 
 &bquo;HE KNOWS HE'S DONE WRONG!&equo; 
 This is what most owners say when confronted by cherished furnishings, door frames or personal items, such as books or the remote control for the TV, that have been torn to shreds by beloved Rover in their absence, or nearly as distressing the evidence of his lack of toilet control. 
 Their assumption that &bquo;he knows what he has done wrong&equo; is based on the fact that Rover is slinking along the floor with its head and tail down looking for all the world like a naughty school boy who's just broken the headmaster's window. 
 On the basis of this evidence they proceed to chastise Rover to a degree consistent with their temperament. 
 They are always surprised, however, that Rover never seems to learn, whatever tactics they employ. 
 This is not surprising as the dog's capacity to associate a form of behaviour and the consequences of it are limited to less than two seconds. 
 The owners are not seeing guilty behaviour when Rover slinks across the floor, they are seeing the submissive behaviour Rover displays in anticipation of the aggression, however mild, the owners are about to use in attempt to reprimand him. 
 If they do, the next day Rover may believe the owners will come home and become aggressive without any reason. 
 This will make it anxious. 
 Two of the things dogs often do when anxious are to chew or lose toilet control &mdash; and so the whole situation becomes a vicious circle.  
 Vet's Corner 
 Food for thought 
 This month I've been inundated with more questions about dog foods, and feeding in general. 
 I couldn't be more pleased, so keep sending them in. 
 Some of you are also sending me labels and leaflets because you find the information on them confusing. 
 Not only will I be dealing with some of your concerns through &bquo;Vet's Corner&equo;, but I am taking them up with the very people who make the food &mdash; with some eye-opening results! 
 WEIGHTY SUBJECT 
 Q I have two working retrievers &mdash; a three-year-old and a two-year-old. 
 They are both fit and active but I find it very difficult to keep their weight up. 
 I was told by their breeder that I wasn't giving them enough protein. 
 Dutifully, I changed them to a complete muesli-type food which is described on the bag as &bquo;Hi Protein Fitness Food&equo;. 
 A Your dogs need more fat, not more protein, but for some reason most of the dog-owning world believes otherwise.  
 Perhaps it's because we humans tend to associate protein with fitness and athleticism. 
 Who knows? 
 The fact is there is no real evidence to suggest high-protein diets improve performance or are likely to prevent weight loss in working dogs. 
 The good news is that you are not on your own; many owners share your problem. 
 I quite often see underweight dogs in my surgery. 
 Generally, they are either very active working dogs, or very excitable ones, who work incredibly hard even though they don't really achieve anything. 
 The answer is relatively straightforward. 
 The diet they're being fed doesn't contain enough energy or calories. 
 That's why your dogs are eating so much. 
 They're craving calories! 
 No matter how much they eat of their current food, they just can't get enough energy from it. 
 Energy can be supplied in a variety of ways but the best source is fat. 
 However, before you go adding vast quantities of fat to your dogs' food, spare a thought for what it will do to the rest of your diet. 
 For a start, both dogs will eat less of the food itself and, as a result, will take in less vitamins and minerals. 
 By adding the extra fat, you will have altered the balance of the diet. 
 You could add extra vitamins and minerals but how much should you give? 
 Remember, too much could be just as harmful as too little. 
 The easiest way to solve the problem is to feed a high-fat, complete food which has been scientifically balanced for the working/hyperactive dog, rather than to play around with the ingredients yourself. 
 If their work is seasonal, don't forget to change them back to a standard adult food (so-called &bquo;maintenance food&equo;) when they're not working. 
 When they come back into work, begin feeding the highfat/performance-type diet about six weeks in advance while you are training them up for the extra work ahead. 
 Working dogs &mdash; even those dragging sledges across the snow for days on end &mdash; should not look like hat stands. 
 And they won't if they're fed properly. 
 Ah well, I can get down off my hobby horse now! 
 TICKED OFF 
 Q I live out in the open country and my adorable springer, Sally, is forever picking up ticks. 
 I've heard ticks can carry a nasty disease which can affect humans as well as dogs. 
 I would be grateful for more information. 
 A The disease you refer to is called Lyme Disease and, as you rightly point out, it can affect people and other animals.  
 The disease is widespread in America and quite recently there have been reports of cases in dogs in the UK. 
 One such case was reported in my home county of Sussex. 
 However, the truth of the problem was lameness, which may affect more than one leg. 
 Other signs include lethargy and loss of appetite. 
 The condition can be confirmed by taking blood tests and is treatable with antibiotics. 
 The signs may wax and wane, and the longer it is before a diagnosis is made, the more likely the dog is to end up with long-term arthritis, another disease where preventive measures are very easy and effective. 
 Regular treatment of your dog and your home with a suitable insecticide is all that's required, so it's no more than you should already be doing to control our old friend the flea! 
 Do make sure the method you employ against fleas will also work against ticks. 
 Many collars, sprays and powders are only claimed to be effective against fleas. 
 It's a good idea to check with your local veterinary centre. 
 PRICEY PROCESS 
 Q What does spaying &mdash; or is it spading &mdash; a bitch really entail? 
 I've always owned bitches and I've always had them done. 
 My youngest girl has just been operated on and I couldn't believe she only had two stitches. 
 That's more than &pound;30 per stitch! 
 A Where does this word &bquo;spading&equo; come from?  
 The correct term is spaying, or if you want to be really scientific, panovariohysterectomy! 
 &bquo;Panovarious&equo; refers to both ovaries; &bquo;hyster&equo; refers to the uterus or womb, and &bquo;ectomy&equo; simply means &bquo;cutting out&equo;, so there is your technical answer. 
 Spaying is the complete surgical removal of the entire uterus (womb) as far as the cervix, together with both ovaries. 
 The surgical procedure is now so refined a skilled surgeon &mdash; with small hands &mdash; can complete the operation through a very small incision. 
 But slick surgery and bikini-line sutures may be doing us vets more harm than good! 
 In general, owners seem fascinated by the number of stitches their pets have after surgery. 
 Very often, they believe the more stitches, the more difficult the procedure. 
 So, according to that logic, if there are only two stitches left after spaying, the operation must be a very simple one. 
 Well, although spaying is a common operation (not common enough for my liking!), it's a very intricate operation and, on a scale of 0&ndash;10 for complexity, rates a good five. 
 In reality, if your pet is left with a small, beautifully-sutured wound, then all credit must go the skill of your veterinary surgeon and it's worth remembering that, for the time and skill required, spaying is a very cheap and justifiable operation. 
 The reason is simple. 
 Vets, like all those involved in promoting responsible ownership, want to encourage owners to have their pets neutered and, while many charities talk about trying to set up discount neutering schemes, vets have been running their own for years. 
 The problem is they don't shout about it &mdash; they just get on with it! 
 If you have any problems or questions about the health of your pet, please write to Vet's Corner   
 Mark Evans is a small-animal vet currently  practicing  in Surrey. 
 As a TV-am After Nine contributor, he is used to answering all types of questions. 
 If you have any medical queries, from how to clip your dog's nails to how to cope with hip dysplasia, you can be sure of sound advice 
 TOP DOG NINETY ONE 
 YOU ARE INVITED TO THE BIGGEST CANINE BIRTHDAY PARTY EVER 
 The National Canine Defence League (NCDL) celebrates its centenary this year and Dogs Today  has joined with the NCDL to sponsor Top Dog '91. 
 This will be a show the like of which has never been seen. 
 The emphasis is on fun &mdash; for the scruffiest to the Cruftiest. 
 Keep the date free in your diary &mdash; October 13th, 1991, at the National Agricultural Showground, Stoneleigh, Warwickshire &mdash; for a once-in-a-lifetime experience people will be talking about for the next 100 years. 
 The final of the famous Paw-O-Vision song contest will be one of the highlights of the show. 
 There's still time to enter Paw-O-Vision (there's a special entry form on the News Hound  pages). 
 However, you don't have to be Shirley Basset or Tom Bones to take part in Top Dog '91. 
 It'll be a great day out for everyone. 
 There'll be demonstrations by working dogs, plenty of doggie experts and celebrities giving talks, shaking paws and meeting the crowds. 
 If you want to be a part of Top Dog '91, fill in the entry form opposite &mdash; and do it now. 
 As class sizes will be limited, the earlier you get your entry in the more chance you have of being included in your preferred classes. 
 Remember, it only costs &pound;1 a class and all the money is going to a very worthy cause, so why not enter as many different events as you can. 
 There'll be lots of prizes, rosettes and trophies but, more importantly, you'll be helping to raise money to open the NCDL's 14th rescue centre. 
 There are eight classes you can enter in advance. 
 The best turned-out class provides plenty of opportunity for diversification. 
 You can interpret it in any way you like &mdash; it could mean the best groomed, it could refer to canine  coats, attractive collars and leads. 
 The judges may even take the owner's appearance into consideration when making their minds up! 
 The Lookalike competition could also provide a chance for using your imagination. 
 Very few of us naturally look like our dogs so a little augmentation might be called for. 
 The veteran classes are our equivalent of the  glamourous  granny or grandpa competitions! 
 Dogs must be seven years old or over and we'll be looking for good health and condition as well as stunning good looks. 
 The child handler competition is open to anyone under 16 and the judges will be looking for a good rapport between kids and dogs. 
 The canine talent competition is fairly self-explanatory. 
 We're looking for dogs with star quality. 
 If your dog has a party piece don't be afraid to show it off. 
 It could be a trick, an impression (we've heard of a dog who impersonates an anteater!) it's up to you. 
 Feel free to bring any props you might require. 
 Competitions for the most handsome dog and prettiest bitch need no explanation. 
 Suffice to say Kennel Club standards will be out the window on Top Dog Day. 
 The last class is quite exclusive; only dogs rehomed from an NCDL kennel are eligible. 
 There'll be plenty of activities to participate in when you get there. 
 The waggiest dog side-stall should prove popular. 
 A special wag-o-meter (a person with a stiff neck and a stopwatch) will assess each individual dog's wag rate. 
 There'll even be eating races for both human and canine competitors. 
 Dogs Today  readers will get a discount of &pound;1 on admission charges to Top Dog '91 if they produce a copy of the magazine. 
 Otherwise, it costs &pound;3 per car-load of people. 
 We look forward to seeing you there. 
 You can help make Top Dog '91 the top dog event of the year.   
 Coping with Pet Loss  
 Sharing grief 
 We know our pets won't live forever but, having shared many happy years together, the idea of putting your companion to sleep is almost unbearable 
 LAURIE LEE 
 The decision to end the life of a trusted and devoted animal friend can be the most difficult an owner has to make. 
 When you have shared years of happiness and companionship, making that final choice seems like an act of treachery but it will probably be the kindest, bravest decision you will have made for your pet. 
 When children leave home, parents feel somewhat redundant, while a pet can enter our lives at any stage, providing hours of pleasure, love and immense fulfilment. 
 This was the case with Marjorie, who'd just accepted voluntary retirement after 20 years in her office. 
 Her children had families of their own and her husband wasn't due to retire for several years. 
 Marjorie was looking forward to her freedom; no need to be up at seven o'clock to go to work, no rushing back to make the tea. 
 Yet, when her freedom arrived, something was missing. 
 Suddenly, it didn't matter what Marjorie did. 
 She was accountable to no one and was no longer relied upon by anyone. 
 She felt unwanted and unneeded. 
 Life drifted aimlessly, until a friend came visiting with her Labrador Retriever. 
 When Marjorie saw how close the pair were, she had an idea. 
 But would husband Bill allow her to get a dog? 
 He'd never given the impression of being a dog lover. 
 To her amazement, Bill was keen, so they immediately began their search. 
 Impressed by her friend's Retriever's good nature, Marjorie decided on a Labrador. 
 She and Bill went to see a litter of pale, yellow puppies and Marjorie fell in love with the smallest bitch. 
 Marjorie named her Lizzie (she'd always intended to call a daughter Lizzie but had produced only sons!) and the two forged a strong bond. 
 When such a close relationship develops between pet and owner, a certain empathy also builds. 
 Just as Marjorie stayed up all night while Lizzie was recovering from a womb infection, so Lizzie stayed by Marjorie's bedside while she recuperated after a gallstone operation. 
 Marjorie was astonished at how attached Bill became to Lizzie, as if Lizzie was the daughter they'd longed for. 
 Many happy hours were spent walking in the woods, chasing elusive rabbits and splashing through the muddiest water. 
 Lizzie became the focal point of Marjorie and Bill's life; holidays were only taken if Lizzie could go too. 
 The thought they would one day lose Lizzie never occurred. 
 Even when their vet warned them that Lizzie was getting on, they didn't realise just how much she had aged. 
 One morning Marjorie noticed Lizzie hadn't moved from her basket. 
 Alarmed, Marjorie made an appointment to see the vet that evening. 
 As soon as Bill came home, they carried Lizzie, in her basket, to the car. 
 They drove in silence, unable to discuss their worst fears, clinging to the faint hope that the vet would make things right again. 
 The vet was very kind but had to explain that Lizzie had severe heart failure, repeating himself several times before Marjorie and Bill could comprehend the situation; he was asking them to make a decision &mdash; a decision to end Lizzie's life. 
 The vet left them in the staff room while they tried to discuss Lizzie's future. 
 They sat in silence, unable to look at each other, struggling to keep control of their emotions. 
 Eventually, Bill blurted out &bquo;just do it&equo; and rushed from the room, back to the sanctuary of his car. 
 Marjorie steeled herself, asked to see the vet again, and said she would stay while Lizzie was put to sleep. 
 Surprisingly, Marjorie didn't cry. 
 The tears wouldn't come. 
 She held Lizzie's paw, looked into her big, brown eyes, wishing Lizzie could live forever. 
 All the love and devotion which had poured out of those once-bright eyes reassured Marjorie that, somehow, Lizzie actually understood. 
 Marjorie left Lizzie's body at the vet's and arranged for her to be cremated. 
 She left the surgery clutching Lizzie's collar; in the space of a few minutes it was all she had been left with, apart from memories. 
 BRAVE FACE 
 Marjorie and Bill were left to cope with their own personal loss while putting on a brave face for each other. 
 For weeks life was very difficult as they both tried not to upset each other, even slightly. 
 Finally, Bill couldn't stand it any longer and one night he just clung to Marjorie and cried. 
 He'd never realised he had become so attached to Lizzie and his own pain was unbearable. 
 Marjorie cried too, and at last they were able to release much of their pent-up grief. 
 The next day they found the courage to collect Lizzie's ashes and bring them home. 
 They placed them in their bedroom, together with a vase of flowers. 
 They have also requested in their wills that Lizzie's ashes be buried with them to ensure that, one day, they will all be together again. 
 If you would like to write to Laura about any bereavement problem or issue, please mark your letters Coping , Dogs Today    
 DOGGIE POST BAG 
 We love reading your letters and we'll try to publish as many as possible. 
 Our STAR letter wins a Good Boy hamper full of doggie goodies, and every letter published will win a special golden bone award. 
 The editor reserves the right to edit letters. 
 Please write to this address:  
 SEEDS OF DESPAIR 
 Dear Dogs Today  
 I am writing to warn other dog owners of the potential hazard of the rape plant (you'll have noticed the bright yellow flowers now covering so many fields). 
 Last month we endured the loss of our beautiful, two-year-old Airedale, Ben. 
 Ben loved to run along the public footpath through the rape fields, but at times, although not to venture into the field itself, he would often spot a rabbit and give chase. 
 Once he came back sneezing and coughing. 
 His nose was obviously irritating him and he banged it both with his paw and on the stone road until it actually bled. 
 The sneezing bouts continued for a couple of days, accompanied by shivering and coughing fits. 
 We took Ben to the vet and he was given a course of antibiotics, which seemed to do the trick. 
 We did not venture near the fields again until a friend with children came to spend a weekend. 
 The children took Ben for long walks, again crossing the rape fields. 
 By Monday, Ben was terribly ill and, once more, we took him to our vet, who gave him an antihistamine injection. 
 About 20 minutes after the injection Ben began hallucinating and having fits. 
 We rushed him to the veterinary hospital, where he was given an antidote which should have worked within 20 minutes. 
 Unfortunately, the injection did not work and despite much medication to calm his heart, he passed away in the early hours of the morning. 
 He was a young, strong dog. 
 Mrs Samah Green, Nr Saffron Walden, Essex  
 Has anyone else experienced a problem with rape fields? 
 BEST OF BRITISH! 
 Dear Hagler 
 I've noticed that your walks in Windsor Great Park have been somewhat curtailed recently, due to your shoulder injury. 
 So I thought I'd drop you a line through the magazine to convey my get-well-soon message and show the rest of the readership what a handsome chap you are. 
 May I also pass on my thanks to your master for providing such a great venue for my business lunches. 
 The Two Brewers pub is indeed an enlightened establishment, encouraging such a highclass canine clientele. 
 Sally, Canine Consultant,  Dogs Today 
 LITTLE PARCELS 
 Three weeks ago I became the proud owner of a Chihuahua and he's changed my life completely. 
 I am a nurse working shifts and enjoyed, and needed, early nights and morning lie-ins. 
 Now I'm up early, full of energy and have a new outlook on life all because of Rags, my wonderful dog. 
 He comes to work with me, in a residential home, and has also changed the lives of four mentally-handicapped people with whom I work. 
 I could never believe how much such a beautiful, tiny dog could alter the lives of so many people in such a short time. 
 Miss N Green, Moseley, Birmingham  
 STAMP COLLECTING 
 Thank you for publishing my letter ( Stamps for the National Canine Defence League ) in your June edition. 
 I am receiving, on average, four envelopes full of stamps per day. 
 Your magazine has really helped to boost my appeal. 
 I returned home from work one day to find a parcel from Armitages for the star letter of the month. 
 I can honestly say I was not expecting it. 
 I feel the dogs at the NCDL's kennel at Kenilworth should be the benefactors. 
 When I go to take the stamps I have collected, I will take the parcel of toys and goodies with me. 
 I hope you don't mind but I believe my own dog would not appreciate the goodies as much as those who are in the kennels. 
 Julie Brown, Coalville, Leicester  
 It's good to hear the stamp appeal is going so well. 
 In case anyone missed it, Julie's address is:  
 We hope the stamps keep coming. 
 I'm sure the dogs at the kennels will love your prize. 
 EAR EAR! 
 My name is Bonnie and I'm a Miniature Schnauzer. 
 I don't see many of my kind, so people look at me strangely and ask &mdash; rudely &mdash; what I am. 
 But I don't care, as my Mummy says I'm unique because my ears stand up when they should be down. 
 As you can see, I'm quite vain. 
 If there's a camera around, I'm there like a shot. 
 Now everyone can see how unique a Schnauzer I am. 
 I might not fit the breed standard, but who knows? 
 I could start a trend and all Schnauzer owners might change the looks of their dogs. 
 If not, well I'll just be me &mdash; an individual. 
 If there are any other Schnauzers like me out there, please send a photo to Dogs Today  so I can see. 
 Bonnie Newman, Hounslow, Middx  
 Is your dog an &bquo;individual&equo;? 
 Please send us a photo and tell us what sets your dog apart from the crowd. 
 RESCUE A ROTT 
 After reading your All I want is a room somewhere , I decided to write in case any of your readers were considering a home to Carla. 
 Six months ago I acquired a Rottie and can honestly say I am absolutely delighted with my dog. 
 My husband and I bought Millie as a companion for Mac, my Standard Poodle, and for my peace of mind, as my husband is a police officer who frequently works nights. 
 I recently took Millie to her vet. 
 He agreed that she was very good natured and nearly all Rotties he saw were calm and friendly. 
 I am not saying they're all pussycats but if you love and respect them, they will return those qualities tenfold. 
 What they also need is a good half-hour run  off the lead, daily, in a safe place, to maintain a well-balanced mind. 
 Of course, that goes for any large dog. 
 So, if anyone does want to rescue a dog, don't automatically overlook the Rottie. 
 You could be passing up the chance to obtain the most loving, loyal friend anyone could wish for. 
 Mrs H N Elcock, Telford  
 You must have read our minds! 
 Turn to the article on page 22. 
 I'm sure you'll be very pleased to hear the NCDL received over 100 enquiries about Carla. 
 She is now settled in to her new home, which she shares with another Rottie and a German Shepherd. 
 POODORBOX 
 I was very interested in your article on the Labradoodle Dandy in the June issue of Dogs Today . 
 I thought you might be interested in seeing my adorable mutt, Bubbles, pictured (below) with her superior companion our Yorkshire Terrier, Boswell. 
 The reason the Labradoodle caught my eye is that Bubbles is the result of a liaison between a Miniature Poodle and &mdash; wait for it &mdash; a Labrador/Boxer cross. 
 We call our rather unusual breed a Poodorbox! 
 She is roughly Cocker Spaniel weight, but taller. 
 Her gorgeous tail curls right up over her back and wags incessantly. 
 She is chocolate-brown but has fair-coloured highlights (the poodle was champagne-colour), and you'll also see she has a white beard and a tiny dab of white on one of her back paws. 
 She is, however, only two years old but is often mistaken as being older. 
 She has many Poodle traits, including standing up on her hind legs and walking. 
 She casts her coat like a Labrador. 
 Yes, she's quite a mixture as you can gather! 
 Patricia Robertson, Helensburgh, Dunbartonshire  
 DEVON DELIGHT 
 I enjoyed the article entitled Run of the Mill  in the June issue of Dogs Today . 
 Would you be kind enough to forward the address of this seemingly delightful establishment. 
 My dog, Tess, and I would love to stay there. 
 Mrs June Ingram, Gamlingay, Cambs  
 For a brochure, contact Una Cornthwaite at Hayne Mill  
 COLLECTING CANS 
 In your June Doggie Post Bag  you mentioned you were unable to trace any animal charity which collected aluminium cans for funds. 
 We do! 
 We would appreciate any quantity, people can deliver or send, and we also collect can ring-pulls. 
 Please help us raise funds now so our four-legged inmates can celebrate our centenary in 1992. 
 Beryl Romand, Appeals Manager, Birmingham Dogs Homes, Birmingham, B5 5QS.  
 I collect aluminium cans for the local branch of Guide Dogs for the Blind. 
 I must stress that only aluminium cans are acceptable and, if possible, they should be crushed as they take up less room. 
 Any readers who want to collect aluminium cans can either send them to me or contact local scrap metal dealers and take them there, where they can then donate the cash to a charity of their own choice. 
 As a point of interest, our branch also collects used English and foreign stamps, while any foreign coins left over from your holidays would be welcome, too! 
 June Chapman, 22 Hosker Close, Oxford OX3 8EN  
 WRITE TO ESTHER 
 You may recall my story from the April issue, headlined No Protection . 
 (The sad story of how a new dog harness snapped and Putzie the Yorkie was run over and later died &mdash; Ed) 
 I have since written to Esther Rantzen. 
 Esther is keeping my letter until she hears of more complaints about faulty harnesses, leads or dog toys. 
 Consumer laws must be extended to protect our pets. 
 If any readers have had similar experiences with bad goods, please write directly to Esther Rantzen, or to me, and I will post all letters to her team. 
 I want to stop this injustice. 
 Why should people get rich from selling shoddy goods, causing us and our pets distress and even death. 
 Miss M Boothroyd  
 If you've had similar experiences, please write to Esther Rantzen at &bquo;That's Life&equo;, BBC Television, Lime Grove Studios, London W12 7RJ, or to Miss M Boothroyd, &bquo;The Dog House&equo;,  Good luck with the campaign; if we can be of any further help, let us know. 
 STAR LETTER 
 BULLIES GETTING BULLIED 
 I am 30 and have owned Bull Terriers for the past five years. 
 I have a dog, Billy, and a bitch, Becky. 
 I am an avid dog shower and do very well. 
 I love all dogs but, to be fair, Bull Terriers are my first real love. 
 My home is a shrine to them and a talking point for my friends, who think I'm completely nuts. 
 I feel the brunt of unwarranted anti-dog prejudice almost every day. 
 My dogs wouldn't hurt a fly. 
 I am scorned often, even by other dog owners, for owning &bquo;damn Pit Bull Terriers!&equo; 
 All this is due to newspaper picture editors' inability to distinguish between a Pit Bull, Staffie or, my beloved breed, the Bullies. 
 Matt Smith, Peckham, London  
 PS. 
 Billy Boy and Becky Lou say: &bquo;There's not a bad bone in our bodies&equo;.   
 Needle Works  
 Acupuncture is widely used in human alternative medicine. 
 So why not canine? 
 Lots of vets now grasp the point as dog owners needle them to learn the art 
 STEPH FREEMAN 
 In the wake of major advances in medicine and technology it's interesting to hear that not only is acupuncture still used for many human conditions, but there is also an increasing trend toward using acupuncture for pets. 
 Perhaps this is not so surprising, since the nation's pet population often suffer from similar complaints to those of their owners. 
 Acupuncture is used for the healing and relief of pain such as arthritis, muscle and ligament strains, and some forms of paralysis. 
 Some vets also claim acupuncture has aided considerably in the treatment and control of a variety of other disorders, including false pregnancies, non-specific vomiting, ear diseases, nerve degeneration, kidney problems and auto-immune joint disease. 
 It sounds impressive and the major advantage is that use of drugs is minimal, if at all. 
 Where the technique was first practised is unknown, although it is traditionally thought to be of Chinese origin, although there are accounts of it being used in India around 550 BC. 
 Practitioners use fine needles &mdash; normally stainless steel &mdash; to stimulate specific anatomical points of the body. 
 To prevent the spread of infection (and because we live in a throw-away society) disposable needles are often used, although if your dog requires prolonged treatment your vet may keep a &bquo;permanent&equo; set especially for that purpose. 
 The anatomical points used are vital and specific combinations correspond to the particular ailments. 
 Most vets use about 40 anatomical points, although very experienced practitioners may use up to 360, which seems a lot, but on the human body there are 1,000 possible sites. 
 The placid dog is a more promising patient and the treatment, I am assured, is so relaxing that dogs often fall asleep. 
 The insertion of the needle is less painful than the hypodermic counterpart, but may cause an animal to arch his back or tighten his muscles. 
 Nasty as this sounds, it is what your vet is looking for. 
 This means the vet has hit the right spot, but, despite giving the appearance of a canine pin cushion, it is obviously not too unpleasant an experience. 
 The needles are usually left in for about 15 minutes and are vibrated at intervals to achieve the required effect. 
 The highly aromatic herb Moxa is sometimes used. 
 It is rolled into a pellet and fastened to the end of the needle and lit so that it smokes. 
 Supposedly acting as a healing herb, it presumably also heats the needle to give an additional, soothing effect. 
 However, there is something rather disturbing about the thought of having your pet stuck with needles, let alone seeing smoke rise from him as well. 
 There are two main theories as to why acupuncture is so successful. 
 The first is that the needles act to stimulate the nerves, causing the brain to produce endomorphins. 
 These are the body's pain suppressors, rather like a natural form of the drug morphine. 
 This theory would explain why many quite aggressive dogs are calmed by the treatment. 
 Aggression may be caused by nagging pain, which your dog is unable to express to you, and which is soothed by acupuncture. 
 The second hypothesis is the much more traditional Yin &amp; Yang theory. 
 Here, we enter the realms of fantasy, because Yin &amp; Yang are related to light and dark or sun and shade. 
 The idea behind this theory is that these should be in perfect balance within the body. 
 The introduction of acupuncture apparently restores this balance when it's been lost. 
 It may sound rather fanciful to our western world, but many such ancient ideas are associated in some way with established scientific fact. 
 Surely the proof of any pudding, however, is in the eating and there is little doubt that acupuncture has gained credence and acceptance in the past decade or so. 
 There is no guarantee it will work on any specific case &mdash; the first treatment often causes the condition to briefly worsen. 
 Most vets work on the assumption that if, after the third session, no improvement is noticed, acupuncture is not going to be effective. 
 Nevertheless, many pet owners are now requesting acupuncture &mdash; often because they have been treated successfully by it themselves. 
 It is quite a commitment on behalf of the owner. 
 Sessions generally last for about 40 minutes and are required, by necessity, on a regular basis. 
 The longer the treatment continues, the better the results &mdash; but it is heavy on your vet's time and an appropriately heavy hole will appear in your bank balance! 
 If you want to try acupuncture, ask your vet and he should be able to &bquo;point&equo; you in the right direction! 
 Quick Bites 
 by David Appleby 
 PLAYING FOR KEEPS 
 Owners of domestic dogs do not normally expect their pets to be out hunting prey, bringing it down and killing it, in the same fashion as their wild cousins &mdash; the wolf on the Arctic Tundra or the Cape hunting dog of the African Serengeti. 
 In fact, most owners would be horrified if they did. 
 But often, unknown to them, their dogs are exercising those inherent hunting instincts. 
 Just as the wolf will chase its prey, Fido chases his ball. 
 In the heat of the moment, the grey-coated wolf will wrestle with its quarry and Fido will violently shake rags until they lie motionless or chew squeaky toys until they squeak no more. 
 The pack will pull the carcass apart, competing for the best of the kill, and Fido plays tug-of-war games, hoping to win the toy. 
 Once successful, he will run around and not allow you to get hold of his prize. 
 Not only do dogs play games to exercise their hunting skills, they play to determine who is boss. 
 If we were to introduce a new toy to a litter of puppies, they would play with it. 
 Invariably, during the play period, the dominant puppy would get the toy and keep it. 
 This helps to reinforce his status within the group. 
 Fido's owners should be aware of this and take steps to play him at his own game. 
 Toys should become the owners' possession and be placed where Fido cannot get them. 
 As often as possible, they should invite Fido to play and play nicely for some time so Fido enjoys himself. 
 As the game progresses, owners should start to win the chase or the tug-of-war so, by the end of each game scenario &mdash; before Fido has lost interest &mdash; they are in possession of the toy, playing with it and not allowing Fido to have it. 
 Finally, they should put the toy away. 
 To Fido, this is a signal that he is subordinate to the rest of the family or pack. 
 If he loses games to them he is more likely to accept their authority, resulting in a much better-behaved dog all-round.  
 Dobermann Pinscher  
 ROBERT KILLICK'S FIDO FACTS 
 Breed: 
 Dobermann 
 Group: 
 Working 
 Place of origin: 
 Germany 
 Original function: 
 Guarding 
 Availability: 
 Moderate 
 Average life span: 
 10 years 
 Age of maturity: 
 Three years 
 Height and weight: 
 Dogs 27&ins;, bitches 25&frac12;&ins;; medium size 
 Is the breed a natural guard dog 
 Yes, strong instincts 
 Attitude to strangers: 
 Can be aloof 
 Coat type: 
 Smooth 
 Colour(s): 
 Black/tan; brown/tan; blue/tan; fawn/tan; 
 Does coat mat? 
 No 
 Does coat tangle? 
 No 
 Does coat need professional grooming? 
 No 
 Maintenance of coat: 
 Very little, a hound glove may be used. 
 Coat maintained by balanced diet and exercise 
 Exercise: 
 Twice daily, combining free running with road walking on lead 
 Food: 
 Two tins and mixer for adults but varies with size 
 Ease of training: 
 Moderate 
 Good family dog? 
 Good, if treated with respect 
 With other people's children: 
 Suspicious until known 
 With other dogs of same breed: 
 Males can be difficult together 
 Other breeds: 
 Ditto 
 With cats: 
 Generally not good, but OK with own 
 Can they live in peace with other pets? 
 Not advisable 
 Town or country? 
 Should have a garden 
 Adapt to a flat? 
 Not completely &mdash; needs some space 
 Good kennel dogs? 
 Not an ideal kennel dog 
 Does the breed suffer from cold, heat or wet? 
 Suffers from cold and wet and is OK with heat 
 Hereditary anomalies? 
 Cervical spondalopathy and some hip dysplasia 
 Special considerations? 
 Likes warmth. 
 Should be trained from young age. 
 Needs human capacity and to be treated with respect. 
 Not a dog for everyone. 
 Character sketch: 
 Faithful, reliable dog provided it is treated properly and trained with firm kindness. 
 Care should be taken to buy from a breeder with a reputation for breeding good temperaments 
 Dobermann &mdash; dog dilemma 
 by JOHN RICHARDSON 
 Debonair and dignified, or a danger to the community? 
 The Dobermann has been the focus of much controversy since being introduced to Britain 50 years ago 
 The Dobermann is a smart-looking breed of German origin. 
 Standing about 27 inches at the shoulder, the Dobermann is usually black and tan in colour, but can be bred in any of four other colours. 
 The breed is currently undergoing a backlash of adverse publicity in light of the Government's ban on &bquo;aggressive&equo; dogs, such as the American Pit Bull Terrier and Japanese Tosa. 
 Some people are trying to include the Dobermann in that dangerous category. 
 The Dobermann first came to the UK in the late 1940s, imported from Holland by a keen &bquo;stockman&equo;, Lionel Hamilton-Renwick. 
 Mr Hamilton-Renwick won Best of Breed at Crufts in the early 1950s, with Birling Rachel, the first of the breed to attract serious interest. 
 Mr Hamilton-Renwick soon moved on to the Dobermann's smaller relative, the Miniature Pinscher. 
 The Dobermann really came into its own as a domestic dog in the 1980s and, subsequently, far too many were bred. 
 One young and conscientious breeder, Graham Hunt, could foresee problems for the breed. 
 Graham is the breeder of the top-winning Dobermann, Champion Sallates Ferris, who was the winner of the Working Group at Crufts in 1987 and 1989. 
 He has bred four other champions and captured the top Dobermann awards of 1987, 1988 and 1989. 
 He owns just five dogs, including an imported dog and a bitch. 
 &bquo;I saw problems coming for the breed and in 1984 I started a training club for Dobermanns and, more specifically, for their owners,&equo; Graham said. 
 &bquo;We have about 200 in training in any one year.&equo; 
 If you still want a Dobermann and can handle any adverse public reactions, you'll need to know the specific requirements of the breed. 
 &bquo;Firstly, they need lots of exercise and they must be welltrained and socialised,&equo; Graham explained. 
 &bquo;When buying a puppy, try and ensure it is well-bred and reared by a breeder who has some aim to produce well-tempered stock.&equo; 
 Graham emphasised the fact that the breed needs plenty of mental exercise, too, even if it's only basic obedience training. 
 It is no good you being a couch potato and having a Dobermann, only to wonder why it seems so frustrated with its existence. 
 As kennel dogs Graham doesn't feel they really thrive, as they have thin coats and can feel the cold. 
 They can also develop pressure sores on the elbows and other joints. 
 They can adapt to kennel life but they MUST have lots of human contact. 
 HEALTHY EATERS 
 As a general rule, Dobermanns usually have good appetites and, therefore, it is not uncommon for them to get fat &mdash; a combination of too much food and too little exercise is not good for this breed! 
 Graham advocates an hour of free running every day. 
 The breed is prone to occasional stomach troubles and bouts of enteritis so a good-quality diet is essential. 
 It will cost you an estimated &pound;10 per week to feed one dog. 
 And what of the aggression aspect the media has made so much of? 
 &bquo;All dogs, of any breed, have a degree of aggression,&equo; Graham said. 
 &bquo;This is how they establish their pecking order in the pack. 
 It is a trait which is essential to any canine's make-up. 
 What is important is how humans react to it. 
 You should not tolerate your dog doing something you feel strongly against. 
 &bquo;Also, if you allow the dog to sit on your settee, then replace that settee with a new one you don't want the dog to sit on, you must not expect it to suddenly understand why it cannot sit there.&equo; 
 If your dog shows a marked degree of aggression with which you cannot cope, you must get it to someone who understands the breed and can help. 
 If, after that, you can't get it to live amicably in a domestic situation, there is not much hope left, although Graham stressed he has had some success with temperament improvements by castrating the males.  
 True Case Histories  
 Moby: Stage fright to limelight 
 Dear Mr Neville, 
 We recently acquired a large, boisterous and wonderful blue Great Dane called Moby. 
 Generally, Moby seems as playful and excitable as the next puppy, but he occasionally becomes nervous and withdrawn, sometimes even panicky, especially on walks. 
 Odd things alarm him and he is inconsistent. 
 One day he will happily walk along a busy road. 
 The next day he starts at one car coming around a bend a little fast. 
 Sometimes he is oblivious to the sound of aircraft; other times it panics him. 
 More worrying, perhaps, is that he happily accepts most people at home and outdoors, but sometimes shies away, even from people he's met. 
 We're sure Moby's behaviour is simply a phase. 
 After all, he's only been experiencing the outside world since his vaccination course was completed a few weeks ago. 
 But, with him already so large and strong, we're concerned he shouldn't panic unnecessarily, or become uncontrollably excited. 
 One problem is the conflicting advice we've received. 
 Some people tell us to keep Moby on a tight lead and only walk him in one or two places; others tell us not to let him off the lead as his bones aren't yet strong enough to take the strain; some tell us to relax and hope he grows out of it. 
 What should we do with our enormous dog during his puppyhood? 
 Yours sincerely 
 Jeanne and John Hursey 
 Peter Neville is a consultant in animal behaviour and  Honorary  Secretary of the Association of Pet Behaviour Consultants (APBC), 50 Pall Mall, London SW1. 
 He also co-presents the pet slot on BBC1's Daytime UK morning programme with Frisky (above) and Cassie 
 I first saw Moby at the photo session for the cover of the new video &bquo;It's a Dog's Life&hellip; and how to enjoy it&equo;. 
 When Moby and I met, he was the biggest Great Dane I'd seen and full of confidence! 
 He even jumped on me when asked to pose for a photo and, towering above me with his paws on my shoulders, gave me the most enormous, slobbering lick imaginable. 
 Yuk! 
 No sign of nerves, but Moby was definitely still in that highly excitable stage where everything in life is fun and needs exploring. 
 There were legs flying in all directions as Moby dashed around on the front lawn of Bradley's smart surgery near Harrow. 
 However, he calmed down beautifully when Jeanne called, and posed delightfully (just check out the video's cover shot!). 
 But life had not always been that way with Moby. 
 When Jeanne contacted me, she and husband John were, indeed, unsure exactly how to handle Moby, or how to prevent his nervousness and excitability becoming normal behaviour without inhibiting his need to experience his surrounding environment. 
 I felt I didn't need to see Moby unless matters deteriorated in the weeks after Jeanne contacted me. 
 I was happy to offer advice by telephone while Moby was still a puppy &mdash; simple and, better still, free! 
 Moby should be gradually introduced to as much of life as possible! 
 I advised Jeanne to take Moby to as wide a variety of different places as possible and encourage him to meet many more people and dogs. 
 Of course, Jeanne would have to be careful with such a large dog that, in his enthusiasm, he didn't bowl other dogs or people over, or frighten them. 
 I advised Jeanne to ignore the old nonsense about not letting young Great Danes off-lead to run around, and to seek the advice of their vet about correct feeding of a rapidly-growing dog. 
 EXCESSIVE CALCIUM 
 My veterinary colleagues tell me one of the main dangers with such large dogs is not that they injure themselves (through overexercising before their skeletons can carry their weight) but that their diets are over-supplemented, particularly with excessive calcium, which damages bone growth and hinders development. 
 All young dogs have the need to play, exercise and socialise with people and their own kind. 
 For Moby it was especially important because, as with most pups, he had correctly been kept away from parks and streets for health reasons during that critical early period of socialisation until his vaccination course had taken effect. 
 There was no other option as the Hurseys live in a known highrisk parvovirus area  and carrying around a Great Dane puppy in a blanket to acclimatise him to street life &mdash; as one might with Yorkshire terrier pup &mdash; is hardly practical AND needs a very large owner! 
 Owners should make up for any lost socialising time with large dogs because, while lack of socialisation can mean problems for any dog, the big boys are that much more of a handful in later life. 
 Obviously, I wasn't suggesting Moby should simply be allowed to run off-lead. 
 Instead, I suggested Jeanne and John tire Moby with a few chase and throw-fetch games in the garden before taking him out for a walk on an extendable lead. 
 I asked that they take a different route each time, as far as possible, and to occasionally drive him there. 
 I also proposed they aim for all other dogs (except known or obvious &bquo;nasties&equo;) and people, and to speak encouragingly to Moby as they did so, to keep him relaxed. 
 If he became excitable, I advised they gently apply the brake on the lead and calm Moby down with quiet words and perhaps a short &bquo;sit&equo;, before leading him off toward the dog or person again, allowing Moby to become used to their presence. 
 If Moby became nervous or anxious, I suggested Jeanne and John tried to ignore it and simply jolly him along unless he became overtly upset, in which case they were to offer short, protective verbal reassurance, insist gently on a &bquo;sit&equo;, then gradually lead him off again toward the object or person which had spooked him. 
 Too much protection of young, nervous dogs can lead to a condition known as learned incompetence, whereby the dog fools the owner into always being ready to protect him. 
 If Moby became mildly excited, or interested in another dog, he was to be allowed forward on the extendable lead to meet it. 
 If this went well, he could be allowed off the lead to play with his new friend for a short while. 
 I asked Jeanne to find as many friends as possible to accompany her on walks with Moby, and to give them control of the lead and take him away to explore without her if they felt confident. 
 This would help expand Moby's loyalties and prevent him from becoming too dependent on his main daytime companion. 
 While this was a general, day-to-day policy for Moby, it was also essential he start to receive some structured contact with his own kind, and begin basic training as soon as they possibly could. 
 So many dog training clubs only take dogs when they are six months old&hellip; well past the steep part of the learning curve and often at an age when male dogs, especially, are starting to grow up (and become as rebellious and resistant to authority as any human adolescent!). 
 Particularly with large dogs, it's essential for their future control and success as a pet that simple training in the basic commands, such as &bquo;sit&equo;, &bquo;stay&equo;, &bquo;down&equo;, &bquo;come&equo; and &bquo;stop&equo; are taught as soon as the puppy is taken on. 
 When still young, they are willing to please and respond well to their new &bquo;mother figures&equo;. 
 Concentration spans are short at this age but, once commands are taught on a &bquo;reward-for-getting-it-right/patience-not-punishment-for-getting-it-wrong&equo; basis, it's just a case of frequent practice. 
 Fortunately, Jeanne and John live very close to Bradley's clinic and were able to attend excellent puppy classes run by Jenny Williams (owner of Moby's Chinese Crested video cover colleague Chan.) 
 Here, Moby could acquire basic social and communication skills with other dogs, get used to being handled by many different people and Jenny could show Moby and the Hurseys how to start a course of basic obedience training. 
 Watching puppies of all different shapes and sizes, hair types and characters, rushing around together at these classes is great fun, and they're learning how to be dogs and human companions all at once! 
 TRAINING CLASSES 
 As soon as Moby was too old for puppy classes, he went to the bigger-dog classes, run by Jenny, to reinforce what he'd been taught at puppy classes and, most importantly, what he'd learned at home. 
 A bad training class, of which there are sadly too many, could have set Moby's development back months, or even permanently ruined his character. 
 I've seen so many clients train dogs in classes too large and too loud, where the pup becomes confused and unsure of what is expected of him. 
 Others have been half-trained on slippery floors, where they worry about keeping their feet, yet are yelled at for failing to respond quickly enough to commands. 
 Sadly, so many dogs seem to end up in classes run by loud, aggressive people, where they are yanked cruelly on choke chains and punished physically if they don't do as they're told. 
 It's unnecessary and unkind for any dog but disastrous for the likes of Moby. 
 Fortunately, the number of these old-fashioned classes seems to be gradually falling. 
 How nice it was to reassure Jeanne and John to follow their own judgement and instincts and carry on socialising Moby as much as possible &mdash; with a little proper help from Jenny. 
 All they had to do, as they knew already, was to apply love and patience to Moby's upbringing and all would be well. 
 And all was well, as everyone could see when big, proud, handsome and scatty-but-obedient Moby launched himself out of the car (on command, of course!) for the video cover photo call. 
 From a nervy start to cover dog; a nice story about a dog anyone could be proud of!   
 Part 8 Careers with Dogs  
 Could you handle it? 
 Dog squadron instructor Keith Waugh was born to be in the RAF and, after 11 satisfying years, he's happy to say his family's links with the force have gone to the dogs  
 SEAN KEEBLE 
 Keith Waugh was armed with only the vaguest canine knowledge when he took the first steps along his career path. 
 Eleven years down that path he now has a far greater appreciation of dogs and the people who handle them professionally. 
 Keith, 32, is the NCOIC (non-commissioned officer in charge) of the dog squadron at RAF Northolt and as such, has learned what is required to make a special working partnership successful. 
 &bquo;Above all else, you've got to be 100 per cent committed to the job and, most importantly, to your dog,&equo; Keith advised. 
 &bquo;When you're responsible for one dog, you form a special partnership with him. 
 You work with your dog so you have to look after him very carefully. 
 &bquo;You feed, clean, groom and exercise him &mdash; it's not difficult to see how the bond develops.&equo; 
 Being a dog handler with the RAF involves frequent night shifts; usually security work, such as patrolling of airfields and any RAF installations and property. 
 &bquo;It can be a very lonely job, for both man and dog, which is why it involves such a special relationship,&equo; Keith explained. 
 Despite the obvious satisfaction with which he carries out his work, Keith admits, when it became time, he didn't have much of a say in choosing a career in the RAF. 
 &bquo;I was a forces child,&equo; he explained. 
 &bquo;My father was a flight sergeant caterer and I suppose I just followed in his footsteps. 
 &bquo;When I was a kid our family was constantly moving, between the UK, Cyprus and Singapore. 
 &bquo;My father retired when I was 10 years old and I started in 1980.&equo; 
 As Keith explained, it was not any easier for him to take up employment with the RAF because his father had been a career forces man. 
 The first step is an interview at the RAF Careers Information Office and sitting for an induction test to gauge the individual's suitability for the RAF. 
 &bquo;You're first asked what trade you're interested in,&equo; Keith said. 
 &bquo;Everyone starts with basic training at RAF Swinderby, in Lincolnshire. 
 &bquo;The only real pre-requisite for a trade within the forces police is a GSCE grade C or better in English and a special forces driver's licence which I had to qualify for at RAF St Athan. 
 &bquo;Apart from that, all you need is to be passed fit and healthy for a doctor's examination.&equo; 
 There is a height minimum for potential recruits &mdash; 5&ft;7&ins; for men, 5&ft;4&ins; for women. 
 FEMALE RECRUITS 
 Keith had to complete a 13-week basic RAF police training course before moving on to a waiting list for the eight-week doghandler training programme, which is completed at RAF Newton in Nottingham. 
 &bquo;There's usually 12 to 15 people in the dog training classes. 
 You qualify out of that as an acting corporal, then you're used by other classes; for example, as a helper or decoy in staged attacks. 
 &bquo;You're also required for demonstration work with your own unit during the waiting period before starting the dog-training course. 
 &bquo;Completing your dog-training course could take a couple of months but it could also take a couple of years because of the waiting period.&equo; 
 A spokesman for the Police Dog Training School at RAF Newton said the need for instructors and dog handlers fluctuated. 
 &bquo;It depends on the demand in the trade at the time but some years the training classes are full and sometimes there's hardly any recruits at all,&equo; he explained. 
 &bquo;The field has been open to females only during the past year but we soon expect at least 10 per cent of dog-training course applicants will be female.&equo; 
 Keith was an instructor at the training school for 4&frac12; years, working with a variety of dogs. 
 &bquo;I worked with more than 20 dogs, including German Shepherds, Labradors, springers, retrievers and Pointers,&equo; he said. 
 Those breeds are used specifically for drug and firearm-explosive detection, because of their natural gundog instinct. 
 Postings to specialist courses are made by the Personnel Management Centre, for which recruits can apply to be nominated after one year in the service. 
 At the end of that 12-month period, a recruit qualifies as a Senior Aircraftman or woman (SAC acting corporal), before earning the rank of Substantive Corporal, which is when the recruit is eligible for a specialisation course. 
 &bquo;My work has helped me appreciate dogs a lot more,&equo; Keith explained. 
 &bquo;You learn what they can and can't do and that experience becomes useful as you go on. 
 &bquo;The most satisfying thing about working with dogs is seeing the results of any work as I go. 
 It gives me a good feeling.&equo; 
 As a dog handler, Keith has worked with two German Shepherds in the past five years. 
 &bquo;German Shepherds are great dogs to work with,&equo; he declared. 
 &bquo;Every dog has a different character. 
 I had my first dog for 18 months and have had my second one for 3&frac12; years.&equo; 
 Joining the RAF usually means a minimum nine years in the service, followed by a six-year term on reserve. 
 However, a RAF careers information officer explained a recruit can leave the service by giving 18 month's notice through a &bquo;notice engagement&equo;. 
 Keith Waugh has managed to make a career in the RAF a family concern &mdash; and is making a tremendous success of it. 
 For more information on a dog-handling career with the RAF, contact: RAF Police Dog-Training Squadron, Newton, Notts, NG13 8HL, or phone 0949 20771 (extension 453 or 426), or the RAF Careers Information Office on 0734 590650.   
 Short Story  
 Big is beautiful&hellip; bigger is better 
 It was love at first sight but, little did they know, this growing pup &mdash; out in the big, wide world for the first time &mdash; would wreak havoc 
 ROBERT KILLICK 
 I was born in a barn, never knew my father, but was a very goodlooking baby &mdash; I could've won prizes. 
 My best feature was my big, black eyes; I could really melt hearts. 
 I was a stocky baby with good bone, but perhaps my ears were on the large side &mdash; but then so were Clark Gable's and he didn't do so bad. 
 They said my father looked a bit like Clark Gable, bold and bad, by all accounts a big guy. 
 Mum's big too but it's really all just fat. 
 We were a family of nine. 
 I don't know how Mum managed but we were never without food, although we were short on other things &mdash; I never saw a television. 
 Still, it didn't matter, we spent the days rolling the hay. 
 My favourite trick was to hide above everyone and jump on them. 
 One of my sisters got quite hysterical when I did it to her, so Mum had to give her a good shaking! 
 One day they came to take us away, saying it would be better for us &mdash; what do they know? 
 We hid but it made no difference, they still found us. 
 We were taken to this orphanage kind of place, separated, and put into little rooms. 
 We didn't like the food, we preferred Mum's. 
 There was nothing to do all day so we just lay about. 
 If we made a noise somebody shouted at us. 
 Boring, boring, boring! 
 One Saturday a woman came in and took me to a big room where there was another woman with two children. 
 She picked me up and held me in front of her face. 
 &bquo;What a lovely baby-waby,&equo; she said, in a silly voice. 
 Baby-waby indeed! 
 I bit her nose &mdash; only a little and the tiniest bit of blood. 
 She screamed, I laughed and she dropped me. 
 I expect you've guessed by now I'm a dog. 
 I went to the smallest girl who grabbed my tail and hit me. 
 I bit her, too! 
 I stood in the middle of the room growling and showing my teeth, then I made a puddle! 
 That did it. 
 They left. 
 I was taken away in disgrace and I didn't care. 
 The next time they took me to the room, a man and a woman were waiting. 
 I didn't like them from the start &mdash; they smelt funny, like dirty dogs. 
 The man picked me up, roughly, and hurt me. 
 &bquo;She'll do, I only want her for breeding,&equo; the nasty woman said. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 I thought, &bquo;Not on your nelly!&equo; 
 I scuttled to the corner and crouched, trembling and moaning. 
 The man chased me but I ran. 
 Then I stood and drooped everything; my head, ears, tail. 
 You name it, I drooped it! 
 &bquo;I don't want a temperament like that,&equo; the woman said, as they left. 
 I must admit I was getting a trifle worried but then I met them. 
 It was love. 
 I came into the room with some trepidation and there they were, two little round people speaking with a strange accent. 
 &bquo;Vot a darlink&equo;! 
 she cried. 
 She came to pick me up. 
 This was my chance and I grabbed it. 
 I rolled on my back, stuck my legs in the air and laughed. 
 I knew these people would be good owners. 
 &bquo;I vant zis dog to 'ave,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;But you are vanting zer schmall dog&equo; said zer man. 
 &bquo;Ou seely man, 'e ist schmall!&equo; 
 &bquo;She might, 'ow you say, grew a bit,&equo; he schmiled. 
 She didn't care. 
 They paid their money and we left together. 
 These lovely people were from Holland, on holiday over here. 
 We had a long journey back to Holland. 
 I don't know what it was about Holland, whether it was the food, the water or all the chocolates they gave me, but I grew, how I grew. 
 I weighed 10 stone before I was nine months old; by 14 months I was 15 stone and six feet tall standing on my back legs. 
 When I put my front paws on my lady's shoulders, I was about a foot taller than her. 
 I slept on the bed with them but they kept falling out, so they bought another bed, for themselves. 
 When we were camping there wasn't enough room inside the van, so they bought an awning, which they slept in, of course. 
 And she still called me her &bquo;leettle doggie&equo;. 
 We went camping in Seville, Spain and because I liked to walk about they chained me to their table. 
 Looking around, I saw this man with a beard, who smelled nice and friendly, so I thought I'd go and say &bquo;hello&equo;. 
 Unfortunately, I completely forgot I was attached to the table &mdash; all the lunch things fell off, the wine spilt and the glasses shattered. 
 The man spoke gently and patted my head. 
 I thought how nice he was and decided to give him a treat and sit on his lap. 
 I climbed up but his seat collapsed and, as he fell, he knocked his table over. 
 What a clumsy person. 
 He should've brought better chairs. 
 I think he broke something because a big white van took him away and he returned with plaster on his arm. 
 My lady and gentleman took him out that night and he drank a lot of fizzy stuff and fell over &mdash; I'm black and I don't think he saw me in the darkness. 
 He must've broken the other arm because the next day he had both arms in plaster. 
 My people drove home without stopping, except for petrol &mdash; all 900 miles. 
 A pity. 
 I could have become fond of the bearded man even though he was the clumsiest chap I knew. 
 I wonder how he drove home.  
 Katie's Problem Page  
 If you've got a problem with your pet or any question about dogs generally, this is your page. 
 Katie Boyle, TV and radio personality, is here to help. 
 Britain's foremost agony aunt has, in common with the rest of us, a real and genuine love of dogs. 
 BREEDIN' DISGRACE 
 Puppy farms continue to thrive. 
 Dogs at these establishments are merely forlorn breeding machines with frightened eyes, their wretched pups caged in hellholes, often left to rot in their own dirt and squalor. 
 Are the continual efforts of Puppywatch &mdash; set up by Alan Clark and Tricia Roberts, with their circulation of vividly illustrated leaflets &mdash; being ignored? 
 Are those shock reports and sickening pictures of so many suffering animals just forgotten? 
 Thankfully, no, there has been some progress. 
 Dr Alan Williams, the caring Swansea West MP, has shown unflinching determination in his campaign to get the powers-ofentry law changed. 
 Dr Williams' Breeding of Dogs Bill, allowing authorities access to unlicensed breeding premises, was approved by the House of Commons on June 21. 
 Dr Williams has also taken his campaign to the Kennel Club, and I feel he is in no small way responsible for having persuaded that eminent body to tighten up its act. 
 Kennel Club chairman Mr John McDougall has assured me, personally, that the new rules are already in force: Six litters only to each bitch, and none after the age of eight. 
 After that the bitch will be spayed and, hopefully, rehomed happily. 
 All dog lovers can help thwart the puppy farmers. 
 Never flinch from informing the RSPCA or giving details to Puppywatch  
 Inform them, in complete confidence, of any suspicions you have of people breeding dogs on unlicensed premises (where more than two bitches are kept for profit). 
 We mustn't lose heart because continued pressure from a caring public can influence even the most apathetic government &mdash; eventually! 
 WOOD YOU BELIEVE IT? 
 My 10&frac12;-month-old Bearded Collie is obsessed with wood. 
 At home he has chewed the door frame and part of the back door, as well as the kitchen cupboards, although these were done when he was a lot younger. 
 However, he is still obsessed with wood and eating it in the park. 
 He picks up sticks and sits down to eat them. 
 I try to get them off him but am not always successful. 
 I've taken some of his toys with me to get his attention, which works for a while but he soon loses interest. 
 What can I do? 
 Karen Lavender Middlesborough, Cleveland 
 There are two possible reasons for your Bearded Collie being wild about wood, the first being a second teething period, which some dogs go through. 
 This can be uncomfortable and requires plenty of gnawing to relieve the growing pain. 
 Then again, this passion for wood could be related to a lack of fibre in his diet. 
 I'd take him along for a veterinary verdict on these possibilities and take it from there. 
 FIRST TIME FEARS 
 I am not quite sure how to train my dog. 
 Whenever I say &bquo;sit&equo; he doesn't listen but if I have a biscuit in my hand he does it straight away. 
 We got him from the RSPCA and he is my first dog. 
 He's very friendly toward people and usually lets anyone pick him up and stroke him, even when he's eating. 
 But, when he gets too close to any dog he growls and barks. 
 He also has scabs all over his nose and ear. 
 Do you think this may have something to do with his behaviour toward other dogs? 
 I am 11 years old so please help in any way you can. 
 Rachel Brockelsby Hull 
 Your dog is responding beautifully to the &bquo;do and be rewarded&equo; training techniques just as he should. 
 As for the other matter, it sounds like your dog could have earned his scabs by either defending himself, or having an argument with a cat. 
 Get a vet to check him over to be sure. 
 Either way, the problem you describe, combined with the fact that this is your first dog, makes me think you should go back to the RSPCA and ask them to put you in touch with the most suitable, local training club. 
 You and your pet have much to learn and it will be both fun and fruitful if you go along together. 
 However, it would be helpful if your parents &mdash; at least one of them &mdash; went with you. 
 There will probably be times, when you are at school, that they will be in charge of him so it's very important they should enjoy this part of his education and development, too. 
 DIET DOUBT 
 I have a seven-year-old Rottweiler named Luke. 
 In the past year Luke has developed arthritis and a thyroid problem &mdash; the vet has prescribed thyroscin for him. 
 The vet also explained Luke had to get some weight off and instructed me to change his diet of cooked chicken and switch to a dried food called Eukanuba. 
 I am not very happy about this. 
 Mrs P Heath Wandsworth, London 
 Your vet is right. 
 To allow a dog with arthritis to be overweight is tantamount to cruelty and Eukanuba is excellent as a complete food. 
 Do give it a try &mdash; you'll find his waistline improves immediately 
 A word of warning: please consult your vet as to exactly what quantity of Eukanuba you should give your Rottweiler each day &mdash; it is very easy to put ON weight with Eukanuba if you aren't careful &mdash; and the instructions on the bag do suggest you allow your dog to take as much as he wished during the 24-hour period. 
 In your case, I'm sure a specific quantity &mdash; which you can divide into two or three meals a day, so he doesn't get too frustrated on a diet &mdash; is the simplest solution. 
 I'm sure Eukanuba will prove successful but you could ask your vet about Waltham's Canine Low Calorie Diet as an alternative. 
 DOUBLE DILEMMA 
 I wonder if you could possibly give me the address of the &bquo;Dogs for the Disabled&equo; charity, as I would like to send a donation but don't know where to send it. 
 I would be most grateful for any assistance offered. 
 Mrs Heather Rubin Manchester 
 I'm sure Dogs for the Disabled will welcome any donation for the wonderful work they do. 
 Their address is: Brook House, 1 Ladyes Hills, Kenilworth, Warks CV8 2GN. 
 SHIRTY SHEPHERD 
 I adopted an eight-year-old German Shepherd who'd spent his life in kennels as a show/stud dog. 
 He has been no trouble with my two GSD bitches but while out walking, he flies at other dogs. 
 Even when at training classes he doesn't recognise the dogs he has spent his previous life with. 
 He has a wonderful temperament. 
 Do you think he has become jealous or possessive? 
 Mrs May Toms Leighton Buzzard, Beds 
 Your German Shepherd feels insecure away from familiar territory and his aggression is a defence mechanism &mdash; a typical syndrome of long-term kennelling, where there has been little socialisation. 
 I'm afraid no dog club training will be the answer. 
 Ask your vet to put you in touch with the nearest, most suitable member of the Association of Pet Behaviour Consultants. 
 You'll need lots of patience, but as you say your boy has a good nature otherwise, the chances are you'll succeed. 
 Don't forget a muzzle is very helpful in those early days. 
 If you have any problems or questions about your pet, please write to Katie's Problem Page, Dogs Today, 10 Sheet St, Windsor, Berkshire, SL4 1BG. 
 Katie regrets she can only reply through this page. 
 Crime and Punishment  
 (i) 
 In the mid-1860s Dostoevsky developed a marked tendency to fuss about the relation between real life and fiction, between the goings-on in the newspapers and what he was saying or wanted to say in his novels. 
 I stress the newspapers. 
 He was altogether more interested, on the surface at any rate, in what he found there than in what he could observe of people and events around him. 
 A draft letter to his publisher Katkov &mdash; the fair copy is lost &mdash; discusses the plot of the as yet unwritten Crime and Punishment . 
 It states defensively: 
 You'll find in our newspapers many signs of a extraordinary mental instability leading to terrible deeds (that theological student who killed a girl he had arranged to meet in a shed, and who was arrested a hour later eating his breakfast &mdash; and so on). 
 In short, I'm convinced my theme is partly justified by contemporary life. 
 For once he was underplaying his hand. 
 Crime and Punishment  did not merely reflect or even confirm that strange and removed elsewhere, the world journalists write about. 
 It anticipated that world. 
 Readers were settling down to the novel's opening instalment &mdash; not a venture to be recommended for &bquo;people with weak nerves&equo; remarked Strakhov, the gifted critic &mdash; when a murder story broke in the newspapers. 
 Danilov, a student who had tried to live by private teaching, intelligent, handsome, dark-haired, solitary, killed and robbed a money-lender and his maid. 
 In the course of the trial one Glazkov made a false confession which he later retracted. 
 The newspapers themselves leaped on the parallel with Raskolnikov and his crime and with the innocent Nikolai's declaration of guilt. 
 Nature had followed art. 
 Danilov, The Voice  observed, had probably not even begun to contemplate his murder when Dostoevsky was shaping Raskolnikov's. 
 The  two cases were laid side by side, and likenesses and differences were solemnly analysed as if we had here before us two &bquo;real&equo;, directly comparable objects. 
 All this brought joy to the novelist. 
 He often spoke to Strakhov of his &bquo;pride as an author&equo; in his creative foreshadowing of facts, and to A. N. Maikov he enlarged: 
 Oh my friend, I have completely different notions of reality ad realism from our realists ad critics. 
 My idealism is much more real than theirs &lsqb;meaning &bquo;than their realism'&rsqb;&hellip; 
 Their realism won't help you explain a hundredth part of the real events which have actually occurred. 
 But we by our idealism have even prophesied events. 
 It has happened. 
 We are on familiar ground, since this idealism is none other than his deeper &mdash; sometimes he called it deepest, sometimes highest &mdash; realism; but with new implications in that he is beginning to show a sensitiveness to the actual which no doubt existed before but was rarely evident, a sensitiveness which is now coming out like a bruise. 
 This is an important aspect of the process I have called his working his way backwards into the Nineteenth Century. 
 Crime and Punishment  takes its place in a perfectly obvious and open fashion among the international classics of naturalism (or realism), and it is the first of his novels to do so: the earlier and great book The House of the Dead  walks so close beside personal history as to rule itself out in this connection; formally it is a freak, so I argued, a quasi-novel; and as regards fact and fiction, since he is recounting not &bquo;prophesying events&equo;, Dostoevsky cannot have found much in the Dead House to get excited about. 
 Whereas in Crime and Punishment  and in the novels which follow he can, though his narrow glee over being ahead of the fact is unworthy of his art and of what &bquo;idealism&equo; and &bquo;deeper realism&equo; intend. 
 Shrewd guessing at tendency is not the jewel in his casket. 
 The interest of how things are resides in their figuration, discernible and expressible by the deeper realist, of how things will be only in so far as that futurity is the truth and the end of how they are and always have  been. 
 His naturalism is apocalyptic. 
 The social and psychological trends that were bound to produce Raskolnikov/ Danilov are the mere phenomenology of a transcendent mystic and Biblical cryptogram. 
 The Book of Revelation, which Tolstoy said &bquo;reveals absolutely nothing&equo;, is more heavily marked than anything else in the New Testament which Dostoevsky took to prison with him, and we know that huge overarching shapes like Baal, the Kingdom of Antichrist, are beginning to appear in his writing from the early 1860s. 
 Danilov's double murder looks small beer in comparison. 
 Indeed it is pertinent to ask what scope of revelatory prophecy Crime and Punishment  is aiming at. 
 An ambitious impression is created by Raskolnikov's delirium and nightmare:. 
 In his illness he dreamt that the whole world was condemned to fall victim to some terrible and unknown pestilence that was coming upon Europe out of the depths of Asia. 
 Ali were doomed to perish except a chosen few, a very few. 
 There appeared a new strain of trichinae, microscopic creatures parasitic upon the bodies of human beings. 
 But these creatures were spirits endowed with intelligence ad will. 
 People who were infected by them immediately became as men possessed ad out of their minds. 
 A grand and dread apocalypse. 
 But this occurs in Crime and Punishment's  Epilogue. 
 It is aftermath rather than the novel itself. 
 And the Epilogue also points forward in its closing words to &bquo;a new tale&equo;, because &bquo;our present one is ended&equo;, and the narrator says he has in mind the slow regeneration of Raskolnikov, now in prison, through love and suffering. 
 No such novel ever got written. 
 But Raskolnikov's nightmare calls to mind one that did, namely The Possessed , while the specific link between &bquo;as men possessed&equo; ( besnovatimi ) and The Possessed  ( Besi , literally The Devils ) is inescapably obvious &mdash; just as the word &bquo;Socialism&equo; which Dostoevsky has written against the beast in Revelation coming out of the earth with horns like a lamb and speech like a dragon shows the general way his thoughts are tending.  
 And again this is the way of The Possessed  rather than Crime and Punishment . 
 However, a second marginal comment in his New Testament both latches on to Crime and Punishment  and provokes a backward thought. 
 His note on the beast of Chapter Seventeen of Revelation, the beast which doesn't exist and still has to appear and is destined for perdition, is &bquo;generalhuman&equo; &mdash; the word he coined for Notes from Underground  and incidentally never used again in his fiction. 
 At the end of the underground man's tirade &bquo;generalhumans&equo; appears as the notional creatures we are trying to turn ourselves into because &bquo;we feel it's too much of a burden to be men &mdash; men with real bodies, real blood of our own' . 
 How can we have any other bodies and blood than our own? 
 We can't. 
 We can only think about it. 
 And Notes from Underground  is precisely such a fable of disembodied consciousness. 
 But in the opening paragraphs of Crime and Punishment  consciousness has found a home in the unnamed and very physical young man who leaves his stuffy little top room and slips downstairs like a cat, out into the street. 
 This young man is also very mental. 
 His being is riddled with theory and hypothesis. 
 He has a plan. 
 Rather, he has a plan of a plan: the plan being to murder an old money-lender, while the plan of that plan is to embark here and now, out of doors, in the glare and summer stench of Petersburg, upon a rehearsal of the murder. 
 The question of motive hangs over these first pages, and over the whole novel. 
 Dostoevsky's letter to Katkov asserting that crimes like Raskolnikov's can be found in the newspapers also discusses motive. 
 The old money-lender with her &bquo;Jewish&equo; interest rates is to be murdered because her life is worthless and her hoarded wealth can be put to good use; when the unimportant deed is done the doer will launch himself into something that really matters, a large-scale  philanthropic exercise. 
 But Crime and Punishment  didn't work out like that. 
 The letter to Katkov belongs to the autumn of 1865. 
 Between then and the end of the year Dostoevsky put aside every word he had written and began again. 
 And in this new version the philanthropic rationalist and utilitarian Raskolnikov has almost completely disappeared. 
 And in his place we have a murderer fascinated by the Napoleonic idea. 
 Repeatedly, he says that to brush a vicious old woman aside like a swatted fly and get on with life is to prove oneself a Napoleon &mdash; not Napoleon himself who lost whole armies and forgot about them, but a  Napoleon. 
 He finds out that there is no such person. 
 In a  Napoleon he cannot discover anybody to be; a  Napoleon is a projected, dreamed-up, aimed-at type, a &bquo;generalhuman&equo;. 
 Dostoevsky's home-made word doesn't appear in Crime and Punishment ; it has been left behind (unlike the mind that coined it) in the much more theoretical Notes from Underground . 
 With Raskolnikov the issue has been naturalized into a restless and greedy discontent. 
 &bquo;Mere existence had never been enough for him; he had always wanted something more.&equo; 
 And it follows from this calculatedly vague &bquo;something more&equo; that the Napoleonic idea doesn't settle the question of motive either. 
 Its domination of the final text only means that it is Raskolnikov's favourite way of rationalizing his malaise. 
 Nothing in him matches his deed. 
 Dostoevsky exhorted himself in his notebooks to &bquo;explain the whole murder one way or another  and make its character and relations clear&equo;, but the artist in him wouldn't allow it. 
 On one occasion, lashing about for reasons after the event, Raskolnikov cries out &bquo;I simply wanted to dare, Sonya, that was my only motive&equo;; and next to &bquo;I just did it&equo; this must be  reckoned his least untrue account of himself and his deed. 
 Wanting to dare is his opposite number to the underground man's wanting to want, because whereas wanting to want holds fast to the earlier novel's metaphysical spareness and abstraction, wanting to dare opens up the whole huge circumstance of the murder itself, the thing that in fact gets done. 
 (ii) 
 Though Conrad's Narcissus  runs it close, Crime and Punishment  remains for me the most accessible and exciting novel in the world. 
 It is the king of murder stories. 
 And of detective stories. 
 And of thrillers. 
 Its atmosphere and suspense are nursed by locality &mdash; Petersburg &mdash; in ways which can't be escaped but which often get misreported. 
 Commentators are fond of discovering and praising a guidebook clarity in the novel. 
 They have been deceived by the plethora of streetnames, bridges, islands, and so forth. 
 All these topographical details are there and are correct. 
 But they don't cohere, don't add up. 
 You couldn't find your way round this city any more (and here is a strange thought) than you have got the practical hang of the little fortress prison at Omsk by the end of The House of the Dead . 
 To compare Raskolnikov's haymarket with Kim's bazaar is to see that Kipling has done all the work so that you don't have to go there to know what it's like at the level of vivid and varied description, whereas Dostoevsky leaves his reader with an impression which hovers between smell and vapour and dream. 
 In fact the street names and the rest belong with the extremely important disjunctive flotsam of the book: paintpots, old rope, the odd sock, boots that once belonged to the Secretary at the English Embassy, twists of paper, egg-shells, fish-guts, frayed blood-soaked strips torn from trouserbottoms and coat-pockets, an axe-sling in ribbons (&bquo;Little bits of tom linen cannot possibly arouse suspicion!,&equo;) half-eaten meals, small change, miscellaneous pawned objects, candle-ends, trousseau-stuff (&bquo;fancy boxes, dressing-cases, ornaments, dress material, and all that sort of junk from  Knopf's and the English Shop&equo;) broken crocks ( cherepki) , and skulls ( cherepi) . 
 And what the commentators are really paying homage to, what prompts their sense of coherence and a world revealed, is a feat of illusionist sorcery. 
 In a notebook, beneath the underlined word &bquo;tone&equo; and &bquo;NB&equo; penned three times, Dostoevsky has written among other jottings &bquo;summer, dust, mortar&equo;; and in this case the man and the artist are at one. 
 This  is that city which readers of Crime and Punishment  carry with them for the rest of their lives. 
 The novelist stayed away from &bquo;stinking petersburg&equo; during the unbearably hot summer of 1866, to avoid his creditors but also on his guard against what he called &bquo;false inspiration&equo;. 
 He relied on his mind's eye and ear &mdash; and nose. 
 The result is a townscape of &bquo;terrible despairing cries&equo; which mean, and mean more than, that the drunks are leaving the pubs between two and three o'clock in the morning, the pubs that reek of alcohol and cucumber and fish. 
 A townscape of nightmare yellows: sky, buildings, furniture, wallpaper, faces &mdash; the colour of age, heat, pestilence, bile and jaundice, bruisings and stainings, with a stronger connotation of dirt in Russian than in English; the colour of the tickets of identification which prostitutes were required to carry; the colour of Raskolnikov's &bquo;cubbyhole&equo; of a room; and the colour which greets him when he comes to after fainting at the police station and sees a man &bquo;holding a yellow glass filled with yellow water&equo;. 
 Looking over Dostoevsky's shoulder, we find him first writing &bquo;small yellow glass&equo;, then deleting &bquo;small&equo;; and writing &bquo;water&equo; then adding &bquo;yellow warm&equo; to the water, then deleting &bquo;warm&equo; &mdash; the final text uniting an apocalyptic starkness of yellow meets yellow with the topicality of Petersburg's notoriously filthy water supply, a subject of much comment and complaint in the newspapers. 
 At such moments we come  as close as it is possible to get to the spirit of Crime and Punishment . 
 Having, as I say, abandoned everything he had done, he sat down and wrote a six-part novel within a year which included a twenty-six day break in which he threw together and dictated The Gambler , itself not a small book nor a negligible one, to satisfy the terms of a contract he had made with a shyster publisher. 
 &bquo;The very thought would be enough to kill Turgenev,&equo; so he told a friend, and posterity salutes a marvel of concentrated effort. 
 He wrote month after month with fearful haste, and yet the Soviet editor only exaggerates slightly when he says that the manuscripts reveal &bquo;immense, most rigorous work, literally over every phrase&equo;. 
 This combination of speed and close attention may have a lot to do with the narrative thrust and atmospheric coherence and intensity that make this the most gripping of his novels. 
 Then there's the energy generated by frustration. 
 The thing had refused to come right. 
 His notebooks show him hesitating between reminiscence (&bquo;It was exactly eight years ago&equo;) and testimony during trial (&bquo;I am on trial and will tell everything&equo;). 
 Note the &bquo;I&equo;. 
 He was thinking in terms of first-person narrative &mdash; Raskolnikov's own story. 
 This proved unmanageable. 
 Much of what the novelist wanted to say lay outside the murderer's ken, and, as we shall see, Raskolnikov's consciousness was in other, subtler ways too confining. 
 Also, Raskolnikov's narrative was to have been &bquo;A Confession&equo; &mdash; Dostoevsky's own title &mdash; and this wouldn't work either. 
 We recall that the confessional idea has a long history. 
 First the pre-Siberian &bquo;confessions&equo;. 
 Next the unrealized plan for a full-length novel, Confession , which got switched to the shod Notes from Underground . 
 And now another failure. 
 And still, after Crime and Punishment , the idea of a confession novel or story tugs at the edge of Dostoevsky's vision, and continues to do so for the rest of his life in the form of The Life of a Great Sinner  which he planned on the scale of War and Peace , but which never got written though it fed previous material into his novels of the seventies, and  especially Karamazov  at the turn of the next decade. 
 (Dmitry didn't kill his father but he keeps baring his breast to people about how much he wanted to.) 
 So the idea of Raskolnikov's &bquo;Confession&equo; ran into the ground. 
 But there it encountered another ruined project, a work to be called The Drunks  of which only a tiny fragment survives, and the marriage of these two constitutes the success of Crime and Punishment . 
 The drink theme too, broadly understood, goes back a very long way. 
 Behind the truant husband Marmeladov, perhaps the greatest feat of instant creation in all Dostoevsky as he buttonholes Raskolnikov in the pub with hay sticking to his clothes and vodka at hand &mdash; behind that immortal Russian drunkard stretches a long line of urban dropouts and psychological cripples, of paupers and other victims of the ravages of early capitalism (think of Petersburg as several decades behind Manchester), of the &bquo;insulted and injured&equo; in the novel of that title and elsewhere, back to the beginning, back to Mr Devushkin with his teapot and pipe and his &bquo;fearful lapses&equo; over the bottle. 
 Why does Marmeladov drink? 
 The Crime and Punishment  notebooks expend considerable effort trying to establish an overarching reason or at least an empirical scatter of factors, and failing. 
 Compare Dostoevsky's attempt, frustrated by the good angel of his genius, to explain Raskolnikov's motive for his crime. 
 In the novel itself, where we might expect Marmeladov to speak of solace, respite, forgetting, companionship, he grasps the paradox that he drinks because he is in search of suffering, of &bquo;tears and tribulation&equo;. 
 And, he adds, &bquo;I have found them.&equo; 
 This has the same free, metaphysical bearing on his being a drunkard that Raskolnikov's wanting to dare has on his being a murderer. 
 Moreover, as always in Dostoevsky, the search for suffering refuses to settle into coherent masochistic focus. 
 Marmeladov's wife, he says, &bquo;has a consumptive tendency, and I feel it. 
 How could I not feel it? 
 And the more I drink the more I feel it. 
 Indeed that's why I drink, to find compassion and feeling in drink. 
 It's not happiness but sorrow that I'm looking for. 
 I drink because I want to suffer more and  more.&equo; 
 So his intensified sorrow is the intensified compassion and feeling for his wife which drink whips up. 
 This is the Marmeladov who married his present wife &mdash; not that that did any good either &mdash; because he could not bear to see such suffering. 
 We have here the grand selfish selfless nonlogic, the deeper realism, of his drinking. 
 And so the drunkard wants to suffer, while the murderer wants to dare. 
 The one is the passive and the other the active form of a single human truth, as Dostoevsky sees it and realizes it fictionally. 
 The singleness of this truth is what I called the marriage of the Drunks  project and the &bquo;Confession&equo; project in Crime and Punishment . 
 The novelist is now of course in middle age, but right back in his teens he wrote to his brother &bquo;Man is a mystery&equo;, adding that a lifetime spent trying to unravel the mystery would not be wasted. 
 On its own this reads like a perfectly ordinary youthful Europeanized sententious romantic flourish. 
 But now comes the idiosyncratic twist. 
 &bquo;I am devoting myself to this mystery because i want to be a man.&equo; 
 He doesn't mean that he wants to become mature or to quell the beast within or anything else comfortable to the understanding. 
 It's a very personal way of thinking and writing which we have encountered several times already, and which now, twenty-seven years after that letter to his brother, appears most insistently with Raskolnikov as he Paused for a moment to take breath, to collect himself, and to enter as a man &equo; and tell the police who it was killed the old money-lender and her sister. 
 But since Crime and Punishment  encompasses the drinking as well as the confessional theme, we can approach Dostoevsky's abiding human question &mdash; what is it to be a man? &mdash; also by way of the minuscule Drunks  fragment: 
 &bquo;The reason we drink is we're at a loose end.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nonsense. 
 We drink because we've got no morals.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, and the reason we've got no morals is that for a long time (150 years) we've been at a loose end.' 
 And that's all. 
 put most simply, being at a loose end leads men to the vice of drunkenness and the crime of murder; and the jobless Marmeladov and the ex-student Raskolnikov are both very pointedly at a loose end. 
 But to say that the devil finds work for idle hands to do is misleading because hypermoralistic or (if meant literally) hypertheological. 
 In that little exchange which is the entire Drunks  fragment the &bquo;loose end&equo; idea undercuts the moral and every other aspect of the matter, and once again there's a link with journalism, this time Dostoevsky's own. 
 He specifies 150 years because he has in mind the social and political reforms of Peter the Great in the early Eighteenth Century. 
 This subject had interested him, both as contributor to and editor of the magazines Time  and Epoch  in the years immediately before he wrote Crime and Punishment . 
 He believed that Peter's reforms had disrupted society by creating a Western-type bourgeoisie and separating the educated class from the common people. 
 What Peter had damaged, and what one might hope to restore, was the natural soil-based unity of Russia. 
 And so, as in Winter Notes , Dostoevsky is really talking about pochvennost , his own brand of romantic conservatism, half history, half dream. 
 In Crime and Punishment  itself the Petrine reforms get the merest glancing reference, and only one, when Raskolnikov's friend Razumikhin speaks of &bquo;us&equo; (compare the &bquo;we&equo; of the Drunks  fragment) as &bquo;divorced from practical affairs of every sort for nearly two hundred years&equo;. 
 This is a hasty throw-off in the middle of a wide-ranging argument, and it has no particular bearing on drink. 
 Nor for that matter on crime. 
 Nor has it any more to do with Peter's reforms than might perhaps justify an editorial footnote. 
 But the underlying idea of being at a loose end, or out of the practical swim, is a different matter altogether. 
 It is the very clay out of which Dostoevsky shapes his fictions of solitude and society. 
 And while it might be said that his version of pochvennost  comes from this same source, and while it is certainly true that pochvennost  deserves a longer footnote than the Petrine reforms, a footnote is all it should  be. 
 For the novelist works to one side &mdash; hence parajournalist &mdash; of the writer busy with magazine polemics in Time  and Epoch , just as his novel exists to one side &mdash; parajournalism &mdash; of the double murder in the newspapers and of scary sciencefictionish forewarnings about microbes. 
 This to-one-side posture of novelist and novel explains how it is that Raskolnikov and Marmeladov are pointedly at a loose end while Crime and Punishment  is anything but pointedly sociological. 
 The thrust of their loose end, as of details like the murderer's yellow cubby-hole &mdash; coffinlike, his mother calls it &mdash; and Marmeladov's greenish-yellow face and the mortal yellow-black bruise over the heart after he gets run over, is metaphysical and apocalyptic, not documentary. 
 &bquo;Every man must have somewhere to go,&equo; Marmeladov tells Raskolnikov who has dropped into the pub after his &bquo;rehearsal&equo; of the murder. 
 &bquo;For there comes a time when he absolutely must go somewhere.&equo; 
 Raskolnikov is young, preoccupied and merely puzzled &mdash; &bquo;young, abstract and therefore cruel&equo;, the severe voice of the novel descries him elsewhere &mdash; but the reader attends in tragic wonder, for he understands that Marmeladov has indeed nowhere to go, a nowhere which is the finality of his loose end, at once in character, at once personal to the selfish selfless rationale of one man's marriage and his other circumstances, personal to his &bquo;destitution&equo; or &bquo;extremity&equo; or &bquo; mis&egrave;re&equo; (nishcheta , which he is careful to distinguish from his poverty), and at the same time an objective and transpersonal theme running through all Dostoevsky's work. 
 From the novelist's journalism and notebooks and letters we glean the almost comically unresonant information that being at a loose end leads men to drunkenness and murder. 
  His novels, though, suggest a mental movement not unlike Vergil's thought to the effect that bees are working animals and don't retire and spend their sunset years playing golf:. 
 being at a loose end is not the condition of us spiritual and working animals, it is not being a man among men. 
 Marmeladov doesn't think of a drunkard as a human being but as a brute, a beast, a swine. 
 He lives a swine and he dies a swine. 
 But on the Last Day certainly God will call the drunkards of the world to Him:. 
 He will summon us also: &bquo;Come forth,&equo; He will say, &bquo;ye also! 
 Come forth ye drunkards, come forth weak ones, come forth children of shame!&equo; 
 And we shall all come forth, and yet not in shame, ad we shall stand before Him. 
 And He will say: &bquo;Ye are swine! ye are made in the Image of the Beast and bear his mark; yet come ye also!&equo; 
 And the wise ones ad the men of learning shall say: &bquo;Lord, why dost tho, receive these?&equo; 
 And He shall say: &bquo;I receive them, O ye wise ones, I receive them, O ye men of learning, inasmuch as not one of these has deemed himself worthy.&equo; 
 And He will stretch forth His arms to us, and we shall fall down before Him ad weep, and we shall understand all things. 
 So the swine &mdash; swine in God's eyes too &mdash; will appear on judgment Day immortal souls capable of penitence and knowledge. 
 This tirade, carried on vodka-laden breath, is a classic instance of Dostoevsky's apocalyptic naturalism working on two levels at once. 
 Marmeladov projects the Christian Revelation on the church-slavonic plane of his and every Russian's Bible and liturgy, remoter from everyday usage than the English Authorized Version; and he indulges a maundering drunken account of himself. 
 The second is an untidy surgical exposure, the more convincing and moving for its incompetence, of the first's withheld human inwardness, while the first is a theological drama in which the must  of &bquo;a man absolutely must go somewhere&equo; gets tortured on the rack of faith. 
 The one point on which Mr Golyadkin and Double were agreed was that there is nobody like God, but it follows pat and false that if a man has nowhere to go God will look after him. 
 In the notebooks of Crime and Punishment , Marmeladov (at this stage called &bquo;the civil servant&equo;) is made to argue that &bquo;if only a man is really alive , then he suffers, and therefore he needs Christ,  and therefore Christ will come.&equo; 
 Such explicitness would be a disaster in the novel, but it underlies the final text of the pub tirade like a geological substratum, and it reflects the great and growing importance of mystic suffering in Dostoevsky's post-Siberian work. 
 Even more damaging would be the inclusion of the following thought about Raskolnikov: &bquo;NB. 
 With the crime itself begins his moral development, the possibility of those questions which didn't exist before. 
 In the last chapter, in prison, he says that without the crime he would not have found within himself such  questions, desires, feelings, needs, strivings, and development.&equo; 
 Were he to say any such thing we would be left with a therapeutic murder. 
 But again Dostoevsky is fumbling after a creative or regenerative suffering, because it is of the essence of Raskolnikov's questions, desires, feelings, and so forth (which of course do appear in the novel) that they should be agonized. 
 The fictional morphology of this suffering is more aptly suggested by the novelist and critic Akhsharumov, writing the very year Crime and Punishment  appeared in hard covers, who observes that Raskolnikov's mental torment, which is  his punishment in all but its public aspect, begins with his first promptings towards the crime. 
 Thus Akhsharumov directs the reader to something that makes him certain he holds a masterpiece in his hands before he has read half a dozen pages: a single pre-natal life, a foetal stirring and growth, no ordinary robust narrative sense of something afoot. 
 Raskolnikov's first thought on slinking down the lodging-house stairs is one of surprise at himself that he should be &bquo;simultaneously&equo; in terror of his landlady and planning a murder. 
 The mental suffering and the evil intent won't be separated. 
 Raskolnikov doesn't put it to himself like that. 
 We do. 
 He is just surprised. 
 On the surface of his mind lies the contrast between a trivial though tormenting fear and a monstrous scheme; and beneath that contrast appears a positive contradiction: for a few sentences earlier we have been told &bquo;He was not really afraid of any landlady&equo;.  
 The question, who tells us?, recalls the most important of Dostoevsky's many changes in the course of writing Crime and Punishment , his switch from first-person narration &mdash; the murderer's story &mdash; to what is formally third-person but proves so supple, so volatile, that the distinction between the inside and outside of Raskolnikov's head disappears when his creator wants it to. 
 The solution to &bquo;He was not really afraid of any landlady&equo; might appear to be that we have here a masked first-person avowal, and that it is simply an indication of Dostoevsky's boldness that it should be surrounded by authorial statements which are firmly outside and (so to say) on top of Raskolnikov in the classical omniscient third-person mode: for example, information about his poverty, irritable frame of mind, withdrawal from society, his &bquo;not naturally timorous and abject&equo; disposition. 
 But masked first-person narrative turns out to be deflected stream of consciousness &mdash; &bquo;He was not really afraid&equo; will only transpose into &bquo;I'm not really afraid&equo; flitting through his head as he passes the landlady's open kitchen door &mdash; so that the past tense collapses into the present, and we find we have put our finger on something pertinent to the novel's urgency and attack and (to borrow Andrew Forge's ugly but useful key-term for late Monet) its frontality. 
 That Raskolnikov is not by nature timorous is the author's assurance to his readers, dependable through nineteenthcentury novelistic convention. 
 That Raskolnikov is not really afraid is, in its latent truth and force, what he tells himself. 
 The two narrative modes walk side by side in bold yet relaxed society, and support each other in the face of the fact that Raskolnikov is shaking in his shoes. 
 The author knows (even if Akhsharumov has to remind him) that the natural man in his hero has been laid low by the combined psychic onset of crime and punishment. 
 Raskolnikov knows (but leaves us to infer) that his present state of mind renders chatter on the stairs intolerable, which looks like fear of his landlady but &bquo;really&equo; isn't. 
 As to state of mind, Raskolnikov lives with his own continuously but inspects it only intermittently, like the rest of us; whereas the author surveys the whole truth the whole time, so that we never find him wondering whether perhaps Raskolnikov is thinking this or  perhaps he is thinking that: a fact which isolates Crime and Punishment  among the mature novels, because elsewhere Dostoevsky loves the unsettled and unsettling narrative posture of &bquo;perhaps&equo;, particularly with his contracting and dilating collective voice, the &bquo;we&equo; swept by rumour and speculation which arrives in The House of the Dead  and reaches its full flowering in The Possessed . 
 While Crime and Punishment's  author (or omniscient narrator) knows the truth, he picks his moment to tell it. 
 He bides his time. 
 Then he moves in, for example to reveal that the young hero-murderer, once the deed was done, had a completely new experience &bquo;of infinite loneliness and estrangement&equo;; and that this experience &bquo;was most agonising in that it was a sensation rather than knowledge or intellectual understanding, a direct sensation, the most painful sensation he had ever experienced in his life.&equo; 
 Raskolnikov could never have said that &mdash; which introduces the deeper issues involved in the switch from first-person to a nominal thirdperson narrative. 
 Raskolnikov lives with his pain, but most of the time he doesn't focus on it. 
 He rubs it absently, accosting strangers in the street, seeking out a friend and within minutes exclaiming that he wants to be by himself, watching children wistfully, accusing wellwishers of persecuting him with their kindness; until at last he explodes on the brink of confession in a terrible universal cry: &bquo;Oh, if only I were alone and nobody loved me, and if only I had never loved anyone!&equo; 
 Of course he doesn't really want to be alone. 
 He is still just rubbing his pain when he says that. 
 What he really  wants is a business of the inside and outside of his head, in this case of his &bquo;alone&equo; juxtaposed with the authorial &bquo;loneliness and estrangement&equo;: a rich relationship, not a flat contradiction or dead end, a relationship which evokes and nurses a distinction established as far back as The Double , between false solitude (&bquo;loneliness and estrangement&equo;) and true solitude which is the obverse of true society and meaningless without it.  
 But occasionally, as I say, Raskolnikov contemplates the pain he lives with: 
 The conviction that everything, even memory, even the simple power of understanding, was deserting him, began to torture him unbearably. 
 &bquo;What if it is beginning already, what if my punishment is already beginning? 
 Look, over there &mdash; I thought so!&equo; 
 And indeed the frayed scrappy edges he had cut off from his trousers were lying strewn on the floor, in the middle of the room for everyone to see! 
 &bquo;What on earth can be the matter with me?&equo; he cried again like a man utterly lost. 
 And this in fact, not in theory, is how crime &mdash; the bloody evidence on the floor &mdash; and punishment &mdash; Raskolnikov's agony &mdash; intertwine in the novel. 
 A wonderful moment. 
 It sets one hesitating between general admiration and the attempt to give point to frontality or some such term: anything to obtain leverage on a narrative mode which sweeps up event and idea, fictional past and stream-ofconsciousness present, into a single impulse of this immediacy and power. 
 (iii) 
 For a moment Raskolnikov wonders if his punishment has already begun. 
 Now the reader met a suffering young man on the first page of the novel. 
 And having met him, he at once began studying him and suffering with him: observing him ab extra  and sharing the inside of his head; hence his sense that he is both witnessing and experiencing the &bquo;strange smile&equo; which accompanies Raskolnikov's surprise at his own dread of meeting his landlady. 
 That &bquo;strange&equo; which would be a lazy gesture in another novelist is indeed strange to the reader, strange as the feline, supremely observed  young man himself; and yet he feels the very muscles and skin-surface of Raskolnikov's smile &mdash; a prelude to the way in which the book's entire action is simultaneously read about and lived through. 
 Common sense may deem this a highfalutin account of a quality possessed by every exciting story. 
 Well yes, in so far as it's a question of degree, though if Crime and Punishment   really is the king of thrillers then there's something unique to remark in it and even to wax a bit pompous about. 
 For in a monarchy, as Beethoven remarked of Handel, one knows to whom one must bend the knee. 
 But also: well no. 
 Sometimes there's no question of degree. 
 The wrath of Achilles doesn't work like Dostoevsky's novel at all, and not because it's an old tale. 
 The ship Narcissus  in her fight to the southward doesn't work like this either. 
 The truth is, not all exciting stories are properly thrillers. 
 Being gripped by a narrative is an altogether wider notion than what is presaged by the two-in-one of being outside yet inside Raskolnikov's &bquo;strange smile&equo;: the rehearsal of the murder, the murder sequence itself, the three long duels with the detective Porfiry, the suffering, the hesitation, the final climb up the police-station stairs. 
 Dostoevsky's own attempt to suggest how he disposes his reader in relation to these events goes as follows: &bquo;Narration by the author, a sort of invisible but omniscient being who nevertheless doesn't leave him &lsqb;meaning &bquo;his hero'&dollar; for a moment&hellip; 
 &equo; So, after appearing to settle for third-person narrative, he doubles back on himself and leaves us to make what we can of an omniscient author who is bound hand and foot to a far from omniscient protagonist. 
 That he succeeds in having it both ways is our experience of reading his novel in its dominant and thriller aspect. 
 His Petersburg counts for an awful lot. 
 The illusionism which conjures a complete and natural (I would prefer apocalypticnatural) city out of materials as unpromising as the colour yellow, also yields up Raskolnikov like a natural secretion, and this vouchsafing process encompasses and transcends the resources both of first- and third-person narrative. 
 To stay with yellow for a moment: we noted a paring-down to the bare bones of yellow water in a yellow glass when Raskolnikov comes to after fainting on his first visit to the police station. 
 An opposite movement occurs with the elements of oppressive heat and smell on that same momentous fourth floor. 
 In the first draft of the scene neither are mentioned. 
 Then, as an afterthought, Dostoevsky wrote &bquo;the air was  terribly stifling&equo; and &bquo;in addition, a smell of wet paint assailed the nostrils&equo;. 
 Our final text elaborates this to &bquo;the nauseating smell of fresh paint which had been mixed with rancid oil&equo;. 
 Rancid oil is simply right. 
 Hundreds of such details mark Dostoevsky's year-long burst of composition, hour upon hour, &bquo;Without straightening my neck&equo;, he said. 
 Thus he caught the police station and the whole city during those few fictional july days when everything except the Epilogue happens. 
 And he caught his hero too since a man is (among a million other things &mdash; but art concentrates attention) the yellows he sees and tastes, and the evil rancid oil he smells. 
 Also, and perhaps to a greater extent, a man is what he has  smelt: later in the novel Raskolnikov gives the police-station smell as the reason for the suspicious circumstance of his fainting, which is neither the whole truth nor a straight lie but the blending of the guilty man with the Poison of the city. 
 Crime and Punishment's  Petersburg does not produce the murderer with the inevitability shown by the &bquo;abstract&equo; city in the novel immediately preceding it, where the underground man &bquo;was bound to appear in our midst&equo;. 
 The draft letter to Katkov merely claims that crimes like this fictional one can be found in the newspapers, and that the fictional murderer has come under the influence of certain half-baked ideas which happen to be in the air at the time. 
 Here, despite life following art with Danilov's double murder, we have an ordinary modest contingent naturalism, and in this area the novel bears out the letter to Katkov. 
 Inevitability, at once psychological and religious, enters (so the letter goes on) after the crime has been committed, in the shape of &bquo;the truth of God and the law of nature&equo; which compel Raskolnikov first to be exiled from the humanity he has outraged, and then to confess and accept the public consequences of confession as the only way to become a man among men again. 
 Here we have the apocalyptic naturalism which marks out Dostoevsky absolutely, and in this area too, though we shall find an overreliance upon the Epilogue, Crime and Punishment  follows the Katkov letter while breathing life into its dry and sketchy determinism.  
 Moreover the novel takes up the remark to Katkov that the criminal &bquo; himself morally demands &equo; his punishment (which on its own might mean no more than that Dostoevsky had been reading Hegel or popularized Hegel), and builds some marvellous effects upon it. 
 Raskolnikov has of course outraged the human being in himself too; the pad pad pad of the hunter and hunted relationship with Porfiry is intertwined with self-pursuit to the point where the murderer actually makes the running in the second of the three long interviews, arriving unsent-for and demanding interrogation &bquo;according to the rules&equo;, if interrogation there must be; which leads Porfiry to exclaim: &bquo;Good heavens! 
 What do you mean? 
 What is there for me to question you about?&equo; 
 And in the third interview, the net now drawn tight about him, when Porfiry makes a sudden little feint which suggests he won't be accused after all, &bquo;Raskolnikov felt a rush of a new kind of fear. 
 The thought that Porfiry believed him innocent suddenly began to frighten him.&equo; 
 The reader is both astonished and utterly convinced, as he is later on in the interview when Porfiry plays the dangerous game of saying he has got no real proof, he's going on hunch and &bquo;psychology&equo; &mdash; so Raskolnikov had better confess. 
 It's up to you, he's saying, to satisfy the hunger which the letter to Katkov and the Crime and Punishment  notebooks rationalize as the criminal's moral demand. 
 Porfiry is also asking Raskolnikov to recognize his hunger for what it is. 
 Both he and Sonya Marmeladov, in their separate areas of the novel, impress the need to accept suffering. 
 Now suffering is a vast and many-sided fact of Crime and Punishment , as of all mature Dostoevsky &mdash; larger than the &bquo;loose end&equo; idea of The Drunks  which produced Marmeladov the marmeladey wallower in abasement and humiliation, the man who seeks suffering and finds it (and so finds satisfaction too) at the bottom of his vodka jug, who screams &bquo;I'm loving this!&equo; when his wife pulls him across the room by his hair; and larger than the &bquo;out of the practical swim&equo; idea of &bquo;A Confession&equo; from which emerges the murderer, the man with something to confess, who doesn't seek  suffering but learns, though only in the Epilogue, to accept it. 
 Prostitution is the hardest labour in the world, Dostoevsky thought, and Sonya of the yellow ticket who sells her body to buy her family's bread has no loose-end aspect to her suffering. 
 Nor has her consumptive step-mother, Marmeladov's wife, endlessly busy with children and no-home. 
 One can only regard them as victims of other people's loose ends, just as the terrible sustained anxiety of Raskolnikov's mother and sister on his account is the measure of his power to make others suffer as well as himself in that limbo which his friend &mdash; his only friend &mdash; Razumikhin calls being out of the practical swim. 
 Nastasya, the general maidservant at Raskolnikov's lodging-house, finds him in bed, where he often is nowadays: 
 &bquo;You used to give lessons to children, so you say. 
 Why are you doing nothing now?&equo; 
 &bquo;I am doing &mdash;&equo; Raskolnikov began reluctantly and grimly. 
 &bquo;What are you doing?&equo; 
 &bquo;Work.&equo; 
 &bquo;What sort of work?&equo; 
 &bquo;Thinking.&equo; 
 Nastasya fairly shook with laughter. 
 Murderous and anguished work &mdash; the thinking that goes on between the rehearsal and the deed itself. 
 This thinking is the mental pulse which registers the single prenatal life of his crime and his punishment. 
 Razumikhin would not have laughed like the jolly Nastasya. 
 Nor would Raskolnikov's poor mother and sister: &bquo;but I'm afraid, afraid &mdash; oh God he's so strange. 
 He speaks kindly but I'm afraid. 
 What am I afraid of?&equo; 
 We recall that in the notebooks Dostoevsky has Raskolnikov reflect upon his crime and declare he had to commit it to achieve moral development and get himself out of the mess he was in. 
 A comically facile conclusion. 
 Nevertheless he was  in a festering condition, and the murder did  induce a crisis. 
 In his exchange with Nastasya he reveals himself an underground man who has wandered into a nineteenth-century naturalistic novel, a bohemian Hamlet. 
 The point of contact with the fable of disembodied consciousness  is that thinking has become Raskolnikov's work, it has almost become Raskolnikov, and if he did and were nothing but this work we would have the first part of Notes from Underground  repeated. 
 And of course committing the murder is an act of perverse self-assertion, like the underground man's notional sticking his tongue out &mdash; with the difference that the anti-hero's mind movement breaks no bones, and hurts no feelings except his own. 
 With the murder Raskolnikov erupts into the full glare of the actual, and parts company with his predecessor. 
 But Dostoevsky did not want to surrender the tract of suffering bounded by the sense of being and doing nothing but one's thoughts. 
 The result is Svidrigailov. 
 The notebooks show Svidrigailov developing from a minor into a major character while Crime and Punishment  was being planned and written, and they show his growth as interdependent with Raskolnikov's final definition. 
 In some early drafts Raskolnikov commits suicide, and the striking thing here is that it's never suggested he does so out of remorse or because he thinks he's going to get caught or even from some vaguer, larger self-loathing. 
 He appears to lose interest in life. 
 He is bored. 
 Sonya asks him, &bquo;I don't understand: how will things be for you, how will you marry and have children?&equo; &mdash; of course thinking about his estrangement from human kind; and he replies (Dostoevsky's italics): &bquo; I'll get used to it .&equo; 
 During the year in which the final version was written it became clear that Raskolnikov must be freed absolutely from suicide and blanket boredom and ripostes like the one about family life which issue out from beneath that boredom. 
 All these are inconsistent with &bquo;living life&equo;, the two words which are placed between inverted commas and imposed at the level of mere idea upon Notes from Underground , but which truly drive Raskolnikov, which are his need to become a man  again. 
 Mere existence had not been enough for him, in the Epilogue's diagnosis; he had always wanted something more. 
 This wanting teased him on as it happened &mdash; contingent naturalism &mdash; to murder. 
 Then murder led him inexorably &mdash; apocalyptic naturalism &mdash; to confess and accept suffering, and acceptance of suffering took him back to mere existence which is living life, neither more nor less. 
 Life is life. 
 It has no outside to it (hence Dostoevsky's ready acceptance of Christ the complete man and his difficulties with God). 
 To theorize about life is not to live. 
 But on the last Page of the novel &bquo;life had taken the place of dialectics&equo;, and Raskolnikov is on his way home. 
 Meanwhile Svidrigailov has taken over the suicide role, which is to say the blanket boredom has become positively terminal. 
 &bquo;You know, I take no particular interest in anything,&equo; he tells Raskolnikov musingly on their first encounter; &bquo;especially now, I have nothing to occupy me.&equo; 
 In his time he has tried a lot of things: card-sharping, prison, wife-thrashing and perhaps wife-murder, child-violation, even good works. 
 He contemplates balloon-travel and a journey to the North Pole. 
 &bquo;All my hopes rest on anatomy now, goodness me they do!&equo; 
 &bquo;On anatomy?&equo; asks Raskolnikov, understandably mystified. 
 But Svidrigailov ignores the question and starts talking about politics. 
 He puts in a word on behalf of debauchery because &bquo;it's an occupation of a sort&equo;. 
 Yes and no. 
 The notebooks are beginning to pull him into shape with their &bquo;NB. 
 Not an occupied  man.&equo; 
 In fact nothing binds him to life. 
 He pictures eternity as a filthy Russian bathhouse with spiders in the corners, and yet he blows his brains out to send himself there. 
 It's difficult to avoid making his suicide sound too purposeful. 
 Again the notebooks can be seen moving in the right direction with &bquo; Svidrigailov : I'm happy to go to America at once, but somehow nobody really wants to.&equo; 
 America is his favourite way of talking about the undiscovered country, and it shows that as well as suicide and blanket boredom he has taken over the flavour of Raskolnikov's joke about getting used to family life. 
 Dostoevsky's notebook word &bquo;tone&equo;  amounts to more than dust and mortar and summer smells; it catches up human beings and entangles them with the city. 
 It's no accident that Svidrigailov is the only one in the novel to handle yellow paper money, just as it's no accident that children are frightened of him and run away &bquo;in indescribable terror&equo; because (so we understand in our bones) they smell death on him, or rather the unattachment to life which defeats even Sonya Marmeladov. 
 The girl who has reached the human being in Raskolnikov the murderer is left for the last time by Svidrigailov &bquo;bewildered and frightened, and filled with vague and oppressive suspicions&equo;. 
 He has just walked out into a spectacular summer storm. 
 As he leaves, she asks him &bquo;How can you &mdash; how can you go now, in such rain?&equo; 
 &bquo;What! 
 All set for America and afraid of the rain!&equo; 
 America is his bleak private fancy, the loneliest of witticisms. 
 He shares the rain, though, which comes evenhandedly to city and inhabitants, a psychological force like the heat it dispels. 
 The rain brings him an end-of-time vision, solitary as his sense of humour, of flooding cellars and emerging rats. 
 To others it brings relief from the merciless summer heat. 
 Raskolnikov is one of the others, though it's only through the long crime-and-punishment process that he comes to understand this: he had &bquo;wanted something more&equo; &mdash; more than our mere-existence rain. 
 He had wanted to be a Napoleon and special. 
 In the closing moments of their final interview Porfiry wonders if there's a storm coming &mdash; &bquo;and it would be no bad thing&equo;, he says, &bquo;to freshen the air&equo;; which is a literal rephrasing of the metaphorical &bquo;All you want now is air, air, air!&equo; with which he presses home his argument for confession and acceptance of suffering, and for life. 
 Porfiry's words have a heightened transpersonal effect because Svidrigailov has just told Raskolnikov the same thing. 
 &bquo;Ah, Rodion Romanovich,&equo; he says completely out of the blue, &bquo;what every man needs is air, air, air! 
 That above all!&equo; 
 He doesn't exclude himself. 
 Balloon-travel, debauchery,  card-sharping and so forth are frustrated struggles for air, and he knows it. 
 When eavesdropping (a vicarious ghost-life he goes in for), he hears Raskolnikov tell Sonya about the crime, and later, without openly referring to it, the potential suicide twits the actual murderer: Sell, you can certainly do a lot.&equo; 
 The irony of murder as doing a lot &mdash; doing anything  &mdash; bears the stamp of Svidrigailov. 
 He is probably a murderer himself; the lightmindedness of his retrospective half-confirmations and half-denials is oddly disgusting; and for him killing people is no more doing something than sleeping with little girls or setting off for the North Pole. 
 It's just another struggle for air, for living life. 
 He recognizes in Raskolnikov a fellow-struggler, and repeatedly he says that the two of them are birds of a feather; but he also bids him farewell with a pointed &bquo;You to the right and I to the left, or the other way round if you like&equo; towards the end of their final meeting, because setting off for America, unlike the North Pole, while it may or may not amount to doing anything ( Crime and Punishment  doesn't raise the question) marks a parting of their ways. 
 In Svidrigailov's America there is no air to struggle for, and no rain to soften hearts and freshen cities and give the excluded (or self-excluding) man occasion for jokes about fear and death. 
 Most people breathe naturally, they don't struggle for air. 
 In the underground man's sick yet piercing analysis, most people are roadbuilders, instinctively being somebody, doing something, going somewhere. 
 Not so the antihero himself paralysed by the disease of hyperconsciousness in abstract Petersburg. 
 And not so Svidrigailov and Raskolnikov, both hyperconscious men, and both (as we shall see) linked by their condition to the city which Peter the Great pondered over and then ordered to be built. 
 Svidrigailov's answer, when Raskolnikov asks him Shy don't you see a doctor?&equo; is that he doesn't need to be told he's ill. 
 It doesn't follow that he knows what the matter is &mdash; &bquo;honestly, though, I don't know what's wrong with me,&equo; he adds. 
 He hasn't got the underground man's bodiless analytic clarity. 
 He only knows that he needs air and can't get it; a state evinced by  his terminal boredom, and by single sovereign descriptive strokes like the fact that his eyes are &bquo;a little too blue&equo; leaving the reader to imagine a pair of empty summer-sky souls, very bright and staring in pain. 
 One of the marvels of Crime and Punishment  is its clear distinguishing, untainted by clinical knowingness, of Svidrigailov's and Raskolnikov's ways of being (as the saying is) not with us. 
 Svidrigailov appears not to notice insults and rudenesses. 
 Nothing signifies for him, yet he seizes on details with a toneless precision, almost pedantry: when Raskolnikov calls him a gambler he says he is actually a card-sharper. 
 Observing Raskolnikov wince at the idea of eternity as a bathhouse, he murmurs &bquo;with a vague smile&equo; that he would certainly have made it like that himself. 
 He suggest that behind Raskolnikov's sister's loathing of him there lurks attraction, and he states flatly that she and his own wife were once in love with each other; and perhaps he is right. 
 Ghosts visit him, he says. 
 He frequents a seedy restaurant &mdash; &bquo;You see this wretched tavern I spend all my time in, and I enjoy it, or rather it's not that I really enjoy it, but one must have somewhere to perch&equo;: this is the form which the Dostoevsky no-home takes with him, likewise the transpersonal motif first voiced by Marmeladov in this novel, that a man must have somewhere to go. 
 He is absent yet meticulous, paying for a missing drink-shop teaspoon which has nothing to do with him, and spending a long time in the &bquo;interesting occupation&equo; of trying to catch a fly. 
 (Recall &bquo;not an occupied  man&equo; from the notebooks. 
 And recall Kafka on incidental madness in Dostoevsky; it's not just the children whom Svidrigailov terrifies.) 
 Raskolnikov is not with us either, but in the novel's final text he could not have done or said any of the things I have just mentioned. 
 Even his way of throwing his money about, what he has of it, is immediately distinguishable from Svidrigailov's, while with both of them money is the very image of merely imputed and therefore reversible value in a loose-end world: &bquo;You to the right and I to the left, or the other way round if you like.&equo; 
 Cocooned in false-Napoleonic narcissism  he reads about his own deed in the newspapers. 
 He goes in for a sort of hall-of-mirrors self-impersonation, telling people how he would have done the murder if he had done it (which he has). 
 His crime-and-punishment existence is a process of endless self-monitoring: 
 What Razumikhm had just said about Porfiry also disturbed him. 
 &bquo;I'll have to play the sick ma act with him too,&equo; he thought, white in the face, his heart pounding, &bquo;and I'll have to do it naturally. 
 But the most natural thing of all would be to do nothing. 
 Make a point of doing nothing. 
 No, making a point would be unnatural again. 
 Oh well, it depends how things turn out &mdash; we'll see &mdash; soon enough &mdash; is it a good idea to go there or not? 
 The moth flies into the flame of her own accord. 
 My heart's pounding and that's bad!. 
 A normalizing and fleshing-out of Mr Golyadkin deciding to adopt a passive role. 
 And the details of Raskolnikov's alienation show Dostoevsky at his most unrelentingly careful and sensitive. 
 In another passage our final text reads &bquo;His words were as if meant for himself, but he spoke them aloud, and he continued for some time to look at his sister like a man perplexed.&equo; 
 The first draft has &bquo;he thought to himself&equo; but nothing about the sister. 
 The second draft introduces the sister and cuts the thinking to himself. 
 The magazine text brings in the paradox of public and yet as if  private utterance: &bquo;His words were as if spoken to himself, but he spoke them aloud, and he continued for some time to look at his sister like a man perplexed.&equo; 
 And that is how the passage appeared in volume form, in the editions of 1867 and 1870. 
 But in 1877, the last text overseen by the novelist, &bquo;as if spoken to himself&equo; becomes &bquo;as if meant for himself&equo;, shifting and refining nuance while involving the change of a single word in Russian, and enabling the artist to get at last the effect he had been working towards. 
 The naturalness of doing nothing. 
 The unnaturalness of making a point of doing nothing. 
 These are underground and pre-Siberian thoughts. 
 But a new sort of humour has arrived: witness the exquisite dew-drop exchange between Svidrigailov and Raskolnikov:  
 &bquo;Incidentally, do you believe in ghosts?&equo; 
 &bquo;What kind of ghosts?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ordinary ghosts, of course.' 
 And with the young doctor who tries to help Raskolnikov, the voice of the underground man has become more accessibly funny: &bquo;I admit there's scarcely such a thing as a normal human being. 
 You might find one in tens or perhaps hundreds of thousands, but even he will turn out a rather feeble specimen.&equo; 
 We all limp, more or less, was the antihero's way of putting it, and for him all consciousness was a disease. 
 His own hyperconsciousness, the disease in an acute form, he considered a product of nineteenth-century civilization, rendered yet more virulent by the &bquo;abstract and intentional city&equo; he lived in. 
 This tight argument becomes relaxed and humanized in Crime and Punishment . 
 The hyperconscious Double Act in which Svidrigailov's terminal boredom plays opposite the greedy, theoretical self-assertion of Raskolnikov's wanting &bquo;something more&equo; than &bquo;mere existence&equo;, becomes grounded in suicide and murder; and the Petersburg where these things happen gains a fuzzy-edged documentary aspect which never comes anywhere near dominating the novel, but which is there. 
 Once and once only a finger is placed, by Svidrigailov appropriately, on the fact that Peter's city turns people odd. 
 He mentions the climate, but without filling in the summer smells of this novel, or the fog and white nights and wet snow of others. 
 And he observes in a flat parajournalistic way that Petersburg is &bquo;the administrative centre of all Russia&equo;. 
 This makes it a city of arrivers. 
 Some come like Marmeladov to get a job on the appropriate rung of the bureaucratic ladder. 
 Others are in search of justice, &bquo;with a petition to some Minister&equo;. 
 Others again, like Mr Luzhin, Dunya Raskolnikov's middle-aged suitor, want to make a lot of money: there's a Dick Whittington side to Petersburg. 
 Speaking for himself, Svidrigailov says he is after the women, which isn't untrue but we know what it's worth. 
 Raskolnikov  has been here three years. 
 He arrived from the deep country to attend university. 
 His friend Razumikhin, a truthful witness, has known him for eighteen months. 
 Razumikhin himself may or may not have come from the country, but he is certainly a member of the floating, unbelonging population of students and ex-students, and he records in simple puzzlement that Raskolnikov has been growing increasingly moody and suspicious and introverted; &bquo;he has no time for anything, people are always in his way, and yet he lies about and does nothing&equo; &mdash; a confirming echo of Raskolnikov on his bed telling Nastasya the maid that he is working, by which he means thinking. 
 His mind's not right. 
 Petersburg encourages his vicious loose-end tendency, as it teases Svidrigailov with phantom images of what it would be like to be an occupied man. 
 Raskolnikov's &bquo;incomplete smile&equo; is the index of those &bquo;half-baked&equo; (literally, &bquo;incomplete&equo;) ideas which Dostoevsky writes about in the letter to Katkov. 
 (iv) 
 Among Crime and Punishment's  major characters only Porfiry the detective is in no sense an arriver. 
 It will appear mechanical, when plucked out of the huge and vital narrative flow, that Dostoevsky has given him &bquo;a sickly dark yellow complexion&equo; as a mark of his belonging to Petersburg. 
 Nevertheless he does possess a yellow face as opposed to lodging in a yellow room, or handling yellow money, or being issued (the bureaucracy!) with a yellow ticket. 
 He also belongs for the reason suggested by Svidrigailov; Petersburg is the administrative centre of Russia, and Porfiry occupies his position there as an official examining magistrate within the metropolitan and national legal system. 
 Therefore he has a public front and function as well as an unhealthy yellow human face. 
 It's his job to bring the murderer of the old money-lender and her sister to justice. 
 The job occupies him, as Svidrigailov would say; it involves  both the man and the salaried magistrate, and it defines the part played by Porfiry in the apocalyptic naturalism of the crime-and-punishment process. 
 But what is there for Porfiry to do? 
 We have just caught Raskolnikov saying to himself that the moth seeks the candle-flame, and Porfiry says similar things aloud; while behind both of them Dostoevsky is telling Katkov that the murderer demands punishment and bends to an inexorable divine and human law when he gives himself up. 
 At one level, as in all picturings of God's rule and man's free will, there is nothing for Porfiry to do; he just has to sit and wait, which he is good at. 
 And at another level he has to know and play every trick of the detective's trade, which he is good at too. 
 Cat and mouse has no less force, in this fated relationship, than moth and candle-flame. 
 &bquo;I won't allow myself to be tortured,&equo; Raskolnikov tells Porfiry, but our sense of their three long encounters is that there's nothing either of them can do about it. 
 In a single serpentine sentence Porfiry seems to dissolve into his own prose, showering Raskolnikov with a patter of tiny verbal blows as if exercising the Russian particle for its own sake ( nu da uzh) , telling him that he considers him &bquo;quite incapable&equo; of committing suicide, and in the same breath to leave &bquo;a short circumstantial note if he does. 
 This, in the blood and bone of the novel, is how the doubleness &mdash; the two levels &mdash; appears, in which all is destined and anything can happen. 
 It might be objected that the doubleness is just a trick of Porfiry's. 
 But this wouldn't match up to the greatness of the Porfiry-Raskolnikov scenes. 
 It isn't just  a trick. 
 And it isn't just Porfiry's  trick. 
 Life in the guise of the crime-and-punishment process snatches up hunter and hunted into the contradictions and cruelties and deceits and frailties which are, in a word, life &mdash; not the whole of life of course, but life. 
 Porfiry misquotes Raskolnikov back at himself. 
 He commends him for the wit and wisdom of things he hasn't said. 
 He tacks on tendentious continuations to things Raskolnikov has said. 
 He suggests that he's got no evidence, then that he's got some evidence, then both at once: &bquo;There's nothing here, precisely nothing,  perhaps absolutely nothing&equo; &mdash; the torture tune. 
 Surrounded by &bquo;government furniture of polished yellow wood&equo;, he proffers blandishing diminutives; Mow about a spot of open window?&equo; ( okoshechko ) he asks the ready fainter. 
 He drops, or there happen to be dropped, sore words like &bquo;Napoleon&equo; and &bquo;axe&equo; into his discourse. 
 He scrambles his own identity as a man and magistrate: &bquo;Do you suppose I didn't come to search your room at the time? 
 I did, I did &mdash; ha, ha! &mdash; I was here when you were lying ill in bed. 
 Not officially, and not in my own person, but I was here.&equo; 
 What is Raskolnikov supposed to make of that? 
 Or the reader? 
 Or Porfiry himself? 
 Crime and Punishment  is a ghostly book in which all three &mdash; murderer, detective, reader &mdash; tiptoe mentally round dubitable presences and absences, and create between themselves strange large silences. 
 Again and again the murder of Lizaveta is ignored. 
 And yet Raskolnikov's greater enormity is that having forgotten to bolt the door after killing the money-lender he is surprised by her half-sister, the woman who mends linen and has mended his in her time, apparently always pregnant, through simplicity, not waywardness, meek-eyed though &bquo;she looks like a soldier dressed up as a woman&equo; (who but Dostoevsky!) and Raskolnikov kills Lizaveta too. 
 Since Porfiry wants to break Raskolnikov, why doesn't he exploit Lizaveta's murder? 
 Raskolnikov is no moral idiot. 
 He recognizes an atrocity when he commits one. 
 Equally, why is it not pointed up that philanthropic murder and the Napoleonic idea and all other theorizing come unstuck here? 
 There seems no reason, and the very business of raising such questions is itself part of a widespread collusive conjuring of absences and of whole worlds of what might have been. 
 The fact remains that Porfiry does break, or tame, Raskolnikov, and that an enterprise lucid in prospect becomes fogbound by the chance which brings Lizaveta home unexpectedly. 
 She, the simple mender and dealer in second-hand clothes, happens to return as she happens to keep getting pregnant &mdash; and what fuller and neater manifestation of chance than that, than conceiving and being conceived?  
 Lizaveta's final outrage is inflicted by a man who almost cleaves her head in two. 
 Raskolnikov uses the blade of his axe on her, whereas he has just used the back of it on the older woman, crushing her skull. 
 Again these things happen as they do happen, the magic narrative containing spur-ofthe-moment impulse within trancelike inevitability. 
 Readers are at one, levels of sophistication vanish, in those cinematic sequences on stairs and landings, where footsteps echo and distant doors slam, and in a flat below two workmen fool about and daub each other with paint. 
 We all see with one pair of eyes, Raskolnikov's, when the visual field narrows upon the back of an old woman's head, her hair &bquo;thick with grease, twisted into a rat's-tail plait and gathered up under what was left of a broken horn comb which stuck out at the nape of her neck&equo;. 
 That broken comb exemplifies the apparently inexhaustible strength of the novel's flotsam, its disjunctive detail which makes nevertheless for tonal coherence. 
 The painters downstairs, skylarking on the fringe of the main action, celebrate (though they would be surprised to hear it) the living life which was, I said, merely imposed on Notes from Underground , but which now surrounds both crime and punishment and makes the whole novel responsive like a touched spider's web. 
 Nastasya the maid has only to hand Raskolnikov a bowl of soup for his mental structures to be set trembling in their unrealism. 
 Lizaveta once mended his clothes: when we puzzle over the chance-induced actuality of her murder being so largely left to speak for itself  we are creating a false problem by the inertness of our own metaphor. 
 &bquo;Didn't I live just now?&equo; 
 Raskolnikov asks himself after he has helped the Marmeladov family and been in contact with little children. 
 Other existences rub off on him, as can be shown at the grammatical level when he overhears a student  and an army officer discussing the money-lender. 
 &bquo;I would kill that damned old woman without a single twinge of conscience,&equo; says the former, and proceeds to give his reasons. 
 &bquo;Here you are talking and holding forth,&equo; says the latter, &bquo;but tell me this: are you going to kill the old woman yourself ?&equo; 
 Translators have &bquo;would you kill?&equo; here, but Dostoevsky uses the future tense for the officer, whereas the student's &bquo;I would kill&equo; is genuinely in the conditional. 
 This distinction should be preserved (even though the Russian verb is not quite square with the English), since it belongs to the novel's overall life-against-logic argument: in theory the student would kill her, but in fact he won't. 
 &bquo;Of course not!&equo; he tells the army officer, and that's the end of it. 
 Acting by theory, Raskolnikov does kill her, and life impinges. 
 The two painters downstairs impinge &mdash; directly through their crazy behaviour arousing suspicion against themselves, and indirectly through Porfiry. 
 Porfiry uses them to try and catch Raskolnikov out. 
 They were working in a flat below the old money-lender's at the time of the murder, but not at the time of the &bquo;rehearsal&equo; three days earlier. 
 Raskolnikov has admitted to visiting the old woman on the first occasion but of course not on the second. 
 Pretending to be worried about the painters and the incriminating evidence against them &mdash; &bquo;It's very, very important for them!&equo; &mdash; Porfiry asks Raskolnikov if he has any recollection of passing an open door on the lower landing and seeing two men at work inside. 
 For a split second Raskolnikov is thrown. 
 His attention has been decoyed. 
 He gropes mentally, &bquo;straining every nerve in an agonised attempt to divine as quickly as Possible where the trap lay&equo;. 
 And then he sees it, and the moment is successfully negotiated. 
 Porfiry's bait for Raskolnikov (&bquo;a precious question&equo; Dostoevsky calls this dangled interrogative hook in his notebooks) holds a different but equally potent fascination for the reader, instancing the story's inexorable grip and the virtuosity of the examining magistrate at work. 
 Porfiry is, as we say, very human. 
 He smokes too much and is overweight,  altogether in poor physical shape. 
 This simply goes along with his being the archetypal great detective, and even with Dostoevsky making him a vehicle for the airing of central thematic issues. 
 In their third and last encounter Porfiry tells Raskolnikov that what he needs more than anything is somebody to be &mdash; &bquo;life and a definite position&equo;. 
 This echoes the statement in their second encounter that he, Porfiry, has no intention of making an immediate arrest because by doing so he would give the murderer somebody to be: &bquo;I'd give him, so to say, a definite position, I'd give him psychological definition and peace.&equo; 
 Peace! 
 The out-of-the-practical-swim ex-student, ex-teacher, the worker at thinking in bed, would be able to call himself an arrested man! 
 We think back to the antihero of Notes from Underground  lamenting that he can't even call himself a lazy man, and we think sideways to Svidrigailov: &bquo;Believe me, if only I were something; a landowner, say, or a father, a cavalry officer, a photographer, a journalist say &mdash; but I'm nothing, I've no speciality.&equo; 
 He too (&bquo;birds of a feather&equo;) has nobody to be, and the ice-cold comedy of his father/photographer/landowner m&eacute;lange  projects the disjunctive genius of Crime and Punishment  on yet another plane. 
 In any case, says Porfiry, there is no need to lock Raskolnikov up, because &bquo;you won't run away&equo;. 
 He has nowhere to run to, nowhere, absolutely nowhere, to go. 
 His crime has brought him to the extremity which Marmeladov was telling him about and tasting at the bottom of his own vodka jug in the opening pages of the novel. 
 Moreover, Porfiry adds, &bquo;what will you run away with?&equo; 
 An amazing stroke. 
 Raskolnikov is Mr Naked done again. 
 Porfiry means that he doesn't really believe in his theory; to wonder if he is a Napoleon is to prove to himself that he isn't. 
 It is to steal his own clothes, and by the time he comes to Sonya to confess, the Napoleonic idea is already crumbling into wanting to dare or something even vaguer. 
 And nobody else can be a Napoleon either. 
 A Napoleon is a non-person, a &bquo;generalhuman&equo;; and although the word doesn't appear in Crime and Punishment  itself, the notebooks  make the point that one can't just live &bquo;the general life of humanity&equo;. 
 In this general-human life there would be &bquo;nothing whatever to do&equo;, the notebook continues. 
 Napoleon himself had plenty to do, but a  Napoleon is a member of a conceptual class of people who are like each other; and likeness, the &bquo;unseemly likeness&equo; of The Double , is fraught throughout Dostoevsky. 
 When Raskolnikov goes to Sonya to declare himself, she implores him to tell her &bquo;straight out &mdash; without examples&equo;. 
 She doesn't want to know what he's like . 
 She wants to know him , in his unique humanity. 
 Which also means his shared humanity. 
 &bquo;But how,&equo; she cries, Mow can you live without human society?&equo; (literally, &bquo;without a human being&equo;). 
 She knows he can't, as does Porfiry who will soon rephrase her question in statement form: &bquo; You can't get on without us .&equo; 
 His typically unspecific and floated &bquo; us &equo; is the human family which Raskolnikov must rejoin, and he can't rejoin it without accepting suffering. 
 Both Sonya and Porfiry tell him so. 
 The words come easier from Porfiry who speaks for public justice than from Sonya on whom falls the main and mystic burden of creative, regenerative suffering. 
 Marmeladov's huge notebook gesture towards Christ and the Russian people and suffering constitutes one warning that Dostoevsky was, at one stage, after something too big or too difficult or perhaps simply wrong for Crime and Punishment ; and Sonya's declaration, again in the notebooks, makes a second: &bquo;The Russian people have always suffered like Christ, says Sonya.&equo; 
 In the novel itself we meet the Russian people, the folk, only once, and then as inflictors of suffering, in Raskolnikov's half-dream (which is also half-memory) of a little mare being tortured and finally clubbed to death by drunken peasants. 
 Mrs Marmeladov's death is very like an animal's, like this mare's: &bquo;Her bloodless, yellow, wasted face dropped back, her mouth opened, her legs straightened convulsively. 
 She heaved a deep, deep sigh and died.&equo; 
 The  whole novel reeks of pain. 
 We mustn't think of its Petersburg crowds as the folk ( narod ); they are a medley of exploiters and exploited, above all of arrivers and non-belongers. 
 When, on his final journey to the police station, Raskolnikov kneels down in the middle of the Haymarket and kisses &bquo;the earth, the filthy earth&equo; ( zemlya ) as Sonya has bidden, it is entirely calculated by Dostoevsky that a tipsy artisan should laugh at the strange young man who &bquo;is bowing down to the whole world and is kissing the capital city of St Petersburg and its soil&equo; ( grunt , the German Grund ). 
 This has no more to do with Christ and regenerative suffering than Dr Rutenspitz telling Mr Golyadkin that Licht  will be provided for him where he's going at the end of The Double . 
 But in the Epilogue, as opposed to the body of Crime and Punishment , people don't torture animals or bear the mark of Peter the German. 
 We are back in the world of the Dead House, of simple Russian convicts and Sorrel the horse, their pride and joy. 
 In effect Dostoevsky is revisiting his own fortress prison at Omsk. 
 Raskolnikov is here, serving an eight-year sentence. 
 He has got off lightly: we learn with mildly comic surprise of mitigating circumstances: he had been good to a consumptive fellow student, and he had saved two children from a blazing house, getting burnt himself while doing so. 
 More important, and very surprising, we are told that &bquo;he did not repent of his crime&equo;. 
 So his rallying himself to enter the police station &bquo;as a man &equo; and confess was not the acceptance of suffering which Sonya and Porfiry both &mdash; but separately &mdash; urged him towards. 
 Or rather, it was not yet that acceptance, something in Raskolnikov remained obdurate. 
 Prison finds him longing to feel contrite, to feel he deserves his punishment, but only able to believe he has committed &bquo;a simple blunder  which might have happened to anybody&equo;. 
 Then, as the notebooks put it, &bquo;Sonya and love broke him&equo;. 
 On the same page we read about a vision of Christ and a seeking forgiveness of the common people &mdash; two ideas which were abandoned. 
 And it should be noted that the actual breaking point for Raskolnikov in the novel is the  illness which induces his apocalyptic science-fiction nightmare of germs and Possessed  -type madness and destruction, bringing him literally to Sonya's feet and both of them to &bquo;the dawn of a new future, of a full resurrection into a new life&equo; which will be the subject of another story. 
 So having laid the weight of mystic, creative suffering on Sonya, the novel proceeds to hive it off into its own Epilogue where all strains and difficulties are waved away. 
 What the Sonya of the novel has to do with Christ and resurrection and creative suffering remains fleeting and indirect, though no less wonderful for that. 
 In the original version, now lost, of the chapter in which she reads to Raskolnikov the gospel story of the raising of Lazarus, Dostoevsky intended and wrote a head-on debate about Christianity; but his publishers refused to print it. 
 The novelist was very distressed. 
 And yet he took no steps to reintroduce it in later editions. 
 I believe he came to see it would not do. 
 As with the censored Christian argument in Notes from Underground , I believe an unfathomable good luck wearing the face of bad luck was on his side at the start. 
 If Raskolnikov was to have mounted an assault of something like Grand Inquisitor proportions, if he was to have expatiated on the whole God business not being worth the pain of one misused child, then the time wasn't ripe; we must wait for Ivan Karamazov. 
 And if Sonya was to have replied to him, what could she have said? 
 No more than the answer she gave in the Crime and Punishment  which did get printed, to the not quite taunting question &bquo;And what does God do for you?&equo; 
 &bquo;He does everything,&equo; she says, but there is no debate. 
 Sonya is the church-slavonic &bquo;daughter&equo; ( dshcher ) whom Marmeladov introduces in his pub tirade. 
 God will call her to Him on the Day of judgment, asking &bquo;Where is the daughter who had pity on her earthly father, the filthy drunkard, and was undismayed by his beastliness?&equo; 
 There must be many who are touched to the heart by that phrase &bquo;earthly father&equo; and yet who don't believe a word of the novel's religion; just as, and more obviously, Raskolnikov's kissing the dirt in the middle of the Haymarket doesn't stand or fall by  Dostoevsky's Soil Philosophy. 
 For the earth and the filth are the realized human stuff of the book. 
 Not, of course, all its human stuff; when Dostoevsky told his biographer that the task of his own deeper realism was &bquo;to find the human in the human being&equo;, he meant there is more to us than filthy earth, and this &bquo;more&equo; must be found. 
 In extremity, with nowhere to go, and not even a believed theory to wear or hold his mind's hand (&bquo;what will you run away with?&equo;), 
 Raskolnikov turns to Sonya; &bquo;it was to her, Sonya, that he first went with his confession; when he felt the need of a human being, he sought the human being in her&equo; &mdash; which does indeed isolate for a moment, and emphasize, the mystic business of his alienation from the human family; and for this moment the dross (as it were) of Sonya and of Raskolnikov is withheld; the god in his humanity is looking for the god in hers. 
 But the Raskolnikov of the notebooks who joked grimly about getting used to being married and having children will do that average and earthy thing, though in a different spirit; and in another story, as the Epilogue tells us. 
 The Raskolnikov of Crime and Punishment  has got unused  to everything; all the calm pressures of habit are denied him, his punishment has begun. 
 And the Sonya of the novel is very slightly indicated. 
 She is little more than her blue eyes and green shawl, the blue and the green undismayed by the yellows and reds of the book, as the girl is by her father. 
 He, the loose-end, filthy-earth drunkard, introduces the shawl as he does so many motifs. 
 He describes how Sonya is driven out onto the streets by her step-mother's gibe &mdash;  &bquo;Why not? 
 What is there to preserve so carefully?&equo; &mdash; and returns and lays thirty roubles on the table. 
 &bquo;She looked at her step-mother but uttered not a single word; she simply picked up our big drap-de-dames  green shawl (it's a shawl we all use, a drap-de-dames  one), and covered her head and face entirely with it ad lay down on the bed with her face to the wall, ad her little shoulders and her whole body were trembling.' 
 His &bquo;which we all use&equo; is authorially bold. 
 We are never told what use Marmeladov might have had for the shawl. 
 But, &bquo;We are one, we live as one,&equo; says Sonya in the Lazarus chapter, and that is much bolder. 
 Greater disunity than that of the Marmeladov non-home can scarcely be imagined. 
 I've just mentioned the taunt that drives Sonya to prostitution. 
 Members of the family are sleeping in three different places. 
 Even the father's funeral feast explodes in chaos &mdash; the classic Dostoevsky skandal . 
 And yet, while God doing everything for Sonya remains shielded by her faith, the green shawl keeps cropping up through the novel for all to see. 
 She puts it on to follow Raskolnikov on his final journey to the police station, and through his mind flashes the thought that this is the shawl Marmeladov referred to in the pub as &bquo;the family one&equo;. 
 Actually Marmeladov said &bquo;Which we all use&equo;. 
 Dostoevsky will have remembered that; it is one of those overlapping cumulations, sameness with difference, which reveal simultaneously the closeness of his workmanship and his imagination's bias. 
 Our last sight is of the shawl flitting about among the convicts in Siberia: not altogether happy, like many things in the Epilogue. 
 Again it should be seen as close and calculated that the shawl which wraps the head in shame at first, becomes at last a green emblem of mercy. 
 And yet the effective place of this life-soiled object is in the body of the book, nourishing the reality of the whole Marmeladov set-up, like the children's washed day-clothes drying overnight. 
 For there are no spare things. 
 On second thoughts there is nothing surprising in &bquo;which we all use&equo;; how could it be otherwise in a family  like the Marmeladov's? 
 And Sonya's We are one, we live as one,&equo; while it remains  authorially bold, has nothing to fear at the hands of readers quick to sniff out dogma. 
 Crime and Punishment  naturalizes the mystic brazenness of Sonya's statement, as it does Porfiry's &bquo; You can't get on without us' . 
 Parajournalism, creating to one side of the actual, seems to me the nub here. 
 When Svidrigailov and Porfiry, who never meet &mdash; bold again &mdash; and who have nothing to do with each other, both tell Raskolnikov that a man needs air, my business is to try and suggest how it is that Dostoevsky's reader finds himself in immediate dual touch with a Petersburg july day and a universal truth. 
 He senses, too, that the actual has more than one side to it. 
 Thus when the girl secretary who was to become Dostoevsky's wife rang the bell of his flat for the first time, the door was opened by an elderly woman servant with a green shawl thrown over her shoulders. 
 Anna Grigorevna had been reading Crime and Punishment  in the magazine Russian Herald , and she thought she recognized the object &bquo;which played such a big part in the Marmeladov family&equo;. 
 No doubt she did. 
 And soon afterwards, in the first week of their marriage, Dostoevsky showed her the stone under which Raskolnikov hid the stuff he had taken from the old moneylender. 
 She asked her husband what had brought him &mdash; Dostoevsky &mdash; to this deserted yard. 
 He replied, &bquo;The reason that does in fact bring people to secluded places.&equo; 
 Now that's our man.  
 The Possessed 
 (i) 
 In the 1860s Dostoevsky was spending a lot of time abroad. 
 That made the tie between him and journalism even stronger than it had been. 
 From his letters and his wife's memoirs we picture him in cheap caf&eacute;s hunched up in his greatcoat over a cup of coffee, with Russian and European newspapers spread about him. 
 Or spending his evenings in public libraries. 
 The scene is Dresden Library. 
 He is picking his way through the Moscow Record  of 27 November 1869, and there he reads about a murder which had occurred six days earlier. 
 An unnamed man had been killed and his body dumped in a pond in a park. 
 The alarm had been raised by two peasants who, as the first sentence of the newspaper story recounts, were walking in the park and noticed a cap lying on the ground, together with a hood and a cudgel. 
 Dostoevsky had no use for the two peasants or for the hood and the cudgel, but he wanted the cap. 
 In The Possessed , the conspirators have enticed their victim to a dark remote spot where nothing will be seen or heard, and have done the deed and tied two heavy stones to the body so that it is sure to sink, and have carried it to a pond and thrown it in: then, &bquo;With extraordinary carelessness&equo; they overlook that cap which has no doubt fallen off in the struggle, and which the police will soon find. 
 The carelessness cuts as much creative ice as the cap. 
 It interknits with that world of chances and mischances, improbable or absurd or grotesque or just neutrally happening as they do happen, which we meet everywhere in later Dostoevsky and specially in The Possessed . 
 The conviction carried by how things are in his fiction cannot be separated from the sense that they might be otherwise. 
 The cap that  happened to get overlooked returns the reader's gaze blankly yet unavoidably, like the bill from a restaurant abroad which the conspirators find when they turn out the dead man's pockets, and like the child's clay whistle which one of them has provided himself with to give the agreed signal &mdash; for he has lost so many teeth that he can't trust himself to produce the sound naturally. 
 The cap, then, falls within an overall grand vision of chanciness and risk; Liputin's teeth are by no means the only things that hang by a thread. 
 But, I repeat, Dostoevsky wanted the cap for its own sake. 
 The overlooked  hood in the newspaper scanned by the parajournalist would not have done equally well, nor would the cudgel. 
 The cap is comparable with, while absolutely distinguishable from, the broken horn comb and other odds and ends &mdash; the disjunctive flotsam &mdash; of Crime and Punishment . 
 On one level it is yet another accident, and on a second level it is inevitable, it must be so because it belongs here and nowhere else, as the foreign restaurant bill belongs to a novel about human birds of passage, and as the whistle belongs to a novel, in fact the only late Dostoevsky novel, with no children in it but haunted by the toys of absent innocence and peace: the governor of &bquo;our province&equo; where these crazy terrible events take place was disappointed in love as a young man and consoled himself by making a paper theatre with curtains, actors, audience, orchestra, conductor &mdash; the lot. 
 Then he wrote a novel and sent it to a magazine which rejected it. 
 On the other had he constructed an entire model railway, ad again the result was most successful. 
 Passengers came onto the platform with their trunks ad bags, their children ad dogs, and got into the carriages. 
 The guards and porters walked about, the bell was rung, the signal was given ad the train started off. 
 He spent a whole year over that clever toy. 
 But he still had to find a wife. 
 And at last, and most imprudently, he married an ambitious tyrant who drove him up the career ladder, and when things began to get too much he set to work on a toy church with pastor, pulpit, congregation, organ and so forth. 
 But she discovered what he was up to and confiscated the church. 
 So that  when Von Lemke came to &bquo;us&equo; as governor and felt himself overwhelmed by &bquo;our&equo; troubles and scandal; s, he had no toy-making to turn to, he had nowhere to go &mdash; his version of the abiding Dostoevsky extremity &mdash; and in fact he went mad. 
 He sent for his carriage and jumped in, and after telling his coachman to drive fast he ordered him to stop. 
 They were now miles out of town. 
 Von Lemke got out and crossed the road and went into a field. 
 The coachman thought he wanted to relieve himself. 
 But he just stood still and gazed at some withered autumn flowers. 
 The narrator can't be sure but guesses he wasn't even aware of the existence of the flowers. 
 On the other hand the Police Inspector of the district found him standing with a bunch of yellow flowers in his hand. 
 That is typical of The Possessed  's speculative openness, within which a reader is entitled to his own view. 
 The flowers caught Von Lemke's fancy as ruined but at least not forbidden toys, perhaps. 
 But back to that dropped and overlooked cap. 
 The word in the Moscow Record  story is shapka . 
 The name of the murdered man first appears in the Possessed  notebooks as Shaposhnikov. 
 What's in a name? 
 There is no simple answer with Dostoevsky any more than with Dickens. 
 Certainly, while he is alive, Shaposhnikov the cappy man refuses to be parted from his headgear; he grabs it when he determines to leave, and he drops it when he is persuaded to stay. 
 It is a mark of his abrupt nature. 
 However, in the novel's final text the shapka  becomes a peaked cap ( kartuz ) and Shaposhnikov's name gets changed to Shatov which has nothing to do with caps or hats at all. 
 It doesn't follow that the cap/name link disappears but  that it becomes so to say transpersonalized. 
 Kartuz  itself is pinned to a Captain Kartuzov who appears just once in The Possessed , and then only by name. 
 We learn not a thing about him. 
 But this Captain is prominent in the notebooks:. 
 a chivalric Don Quixote figure of absolute non-compromise in matters (as he sees them) of virtue and truth, in effect an overspill from The Idiot  &mdash; which Dostoevsky seems to have recognized, for he abandoned the positive and sublime venture, and hived off the comic material he had accumulated into the drunken buffoon Captain Lebyadkin who grows into a substantial second-rank character in The Possessed ;, and as to Kartuzov, the novelist left us with nothing more than his cappy surname. 
 At the same time the final text propagates caps like overnight mushrooms. 
 We begin with Shatov. 
 The object goes, as I say, with his impulsiveness; he is the man who roars &bquo;Shatov is out&equo; when an unwelcome visitor knocks at his door. 
 The cap also goes with Shatov as migrant, as a railway-station man, a traveller between Russia, Switzerland, and America, a man with an old foreign restaurant bill in his pocket. 
 It also goes with the people he moves among, the &bquo;circles&equo; and &bquo;sets&equo; of The Possessed , many of whom are travellers too, and with the &bquo;quintet&equo; which he doesn't belong to but is entangled with, which he tries to kick himself clear of, and which dumps him in that pond and leaves his cap behind. 
 Peter Verkhovensky, the real murderer, who manipulates the members of the quintet, whose dupes they are, travels more than anybody. 
 The novel's atmosphere is thick &mdash; sticky! &mdash; with news and rumours from abroad, and we learn that Shatov once spat in Verkhovensky's face in Geneva. 
 Taxed with this incident as his reason for contriving Shatov's murder, Verkhovensky replies: &bquo;For that reason, and for something else, too. 
 For many other things. 
 But without any hard feelings.&equo; 
 But on the next page he speaks of &bquo;that swine Shatov&equo;. 
 And in any case what can it mean to murder a man for spitting in one's face and yet feel no spite towards him? 
 A breach of objective decorum? 
 And what are the many other reasons? 
 And so on.  
 Such questions begin to evoke the crumbling processes of The Possessed , the instability which flushes its entire structure. 
 To ask them, and equally (or even more) to wave them away absentmindedly like circling insects, is to greet the novel, to respond to its personality which is the same thing as the tonal area colonized by the novelist for his present purpose. 
 He gives us a murderer whose &bquo;words pattered out like smooth large grains&equo; &mdash; clear and distinguishable, and yet somehow there is nothing to get a purchase on. 
 It's no great surprise that a lecture on Othello  is mooted in the Possessed  notebooks, and that &bquo;O, Iago, the pity of it&equo; gets quoted in Russian. 
 While Dostoevsky was interested in the noble Moor and the jealousy question, he will also have been pondering ghost-reasons for his own villain. 
 That Shatov spat in Verkhovensky's face is one. 
 That the members of the quintet will be &bquo;bound&equo; to each other in secret guilt by the cement of blood, having been tricked into thinking Shatov is a danger and must be removed, is another and a promising rationalization which reveals a local shrewdness like Iago's. 
 I stress local: Verkhovensky's group psychology is plausible enough but it doesn't engage with anything wider or further that he proposes to do. 
 He postures as a political activist, and the solidarity forced on the quintet by Shatov's murder might be expected to make them a more effective instrument. 
 But the notion of an instrument turns out to be as empty as his posturing. 
 There is nothing he wants to use the quintet for. 
 Having entangled them in crime, he catches a train and goes away. 
 And he takes a travelling rug with him &mdash; another of those fussy bag-and-baggage objects which assert the novel's tonality. 
 For he is an eternal traveller. 
 As well as a rug he takes a book, author and title unspecified; the eternal traveller is also the eternal student, and it is as &bquo;the student&equo; that Verkhovensky first appears in the manuscript drafts. 
 From the start, as in Crime and Punishment , Dostoevsky is projecting a theoretical murderer, the difference being that Raskolnikov was an ex-student, only potentially an eternal student, because in the event he got pulled back out of theory into living life. 
 Murder brought  Raskolnikov to see that he didn't believe his reasons for committing it. 
 Now the other young man never believed any of his professed and contradictory reasons in the first place. 
 That last fact carries with it an unjust overall valuation of student status, eternal or otherwise, and one which Dostoevsky was not prepared to stand by; which is why &bquo;the student&equo; becomes Peter Verkhovensky in The Possessed . 
 His argumentation is diminished and made much less coherent through successive drafts of the novel, while the sheer rattle or patter of those smooth large grains which are his discourse gets carefully worked up. 
 It's not that he ceases altogether to be the eternal student, but that he becomes reshaped and misshaped into an aberration. 
 Nor is the consecutive argumentation &mdash; the theorizing &mdash; lost. 
 It gets parcelled out among the society he moves in, or rather flits in and out of, while himself belonging elsewhere, which means nowhere. 
 This is a novel of talk and opinions got out of books, and at one stage Dostoevsky proposed &bquo;NB. 
 A Title:  PAPER PEOPLE&equo;, which survives as a phrase in Shatov's mouth, tossed up twice by the polemical flood. 
 A paper person is a walking theory, and one which may not even believe in itself; and then the paper person will not merely have nobody, he will have no theory to be. 
 He belongs to a paper society which goes through the motions of life, in the air, notionally. 
 Many a reader of The Possessed  will have smiled at Von Lemke's paper cut-outs &mdash; the conductor waving his baton, the bustling railway porter, the hell-fire gesticulating preacher &mdash; and at the same time he will have wondered why the microcosmic animated toys feel so supremely right for this novel. 
 Shatov directs his paper-person thrust against himself too. 
 &bquo;Since I cannot be a Russian,&equo; he says, &bquo;I became a Slavophil&equo; &mdash; an articulator, that is, of romantic church-andstate conservatism in the debates of the time: indeed a walking, talking theory. 
 In the notebooks Shatov (as Shaposhnikov) calls Slavophilism &bquo;a gentleman's fancy&equo;. 
  We are back in the area of Peter the Great's reforms. 
 Peter tried to rouse his countrymen from their aboriginal stupor and turn them into Europeans; but a Russian isn't and can't be a German or a Frenchman, and the result of Peter's efforts was to produce an educated class who can't be Russians either. 
 They can of course call themselves Slavophils, but that is to try and wish away Peter, to perform an act of mental regression, not to be a Russian. 
 It is a paper act in a paper situation, inflammable and precarious. 
 The dangerous consequences of Peter are much canvassed in the notebooks: &bquo;the social unsteadiness ( shatost ), as Shatov says&equo;. 
 Thus the cappy man has become the shaky man, the waverer. 
 And once again the motif is transpersonalized, for in the novel Shatov proves himself more than ordinarily resolute; his paper Slavophilism doesn't touch his human courage as husband and friend &mdash; and enemy. 
 Events and tendencies are bigger than he is, and while not shaky in himself he gets dealt the final shove of murder. 
 (ii) 
 So on first consideration it seems odd that in the early days of planning The Possessed  Dostoevsky should write to his friend Maikov and describe his new venture as &bquo;like Crime and Punishment  but even nearer to reality, even more urgent, and directly concerned with the most important contemporary question&equo;. 
 &bquo;Like Crime and Punishment &equo; &mdash; another murder story &mdash; is obvious enough. 
 What falls less easily into place is the judgment about relative importance, urgency, contemporary relevance, nearness to reality; because Raskolnikov comes over as a very grand and accessible conception, a nineteenth-century bohemian Hamlet was one way of putting it, whereas Verkhovensky is just a wrecker. 
 That is our starting point. 
 It could be said as brusquely of Iago that he is just a wrecker. 
 And of a terrorist in today's headlines: one of those inscrutable middle-class Germans, for example. 
 Thus what I called Crime and Punishment's   apocalyptic naturalism is its most vital link with The Possessed ; I mean, when Dostoevsky read about that gang murder in the Moscow Record  his mind's eye was caught not by a bizarre and therefore very newsworthy incident but by the seed of a foul commonplace: the seed in eternity, in the deepest realism, though also in the mere mundane future, for Dostoevsky did imagine a time when only the most spectacular acts of terrorism would get headline treatment. 
 Shatov's murder, in the world of this novel, is momentous because it is potentially unremarkable. 
 Crime and Punishment  was different in that Dostoevsky never supposed lots of people would begin committing Raskolnikov-type murders; Danilov doing so was enough to produce from him the exclamation &bquo;It has happened!&equo; 
 For Raskolnikov is incorrigibly patrician and rare at heart (which is one reason why the Epilogue does not convince), even if I have overstressed the Hamletish side to him. 
 Nevertheless his crime, like the tawdry footloose elimination of Shatov, springs from unsteadiness ( shatost) . 
 The word appears twice in Dostoevsky's letter to Katkov outlining Crime and Punishment , in the phrase &bquo;unsteadiness of ideas&equo; &mdash; which is natural since a drama of reflection is about to unfold: thinking is Raskolnikov's work, as he tells the maid Nastasya. 
 Unsteady work, we might add. 
 Moreover the surname Shatov appears once in the notebooks relating to Crime and Punishment . 
 But nothing further. 
 It's as if the name were waiting for the man, and for the novel which will transpersonalize or socialize the murderous concept: &bquo;social unsteadiness, as Shatov says&equo; and as we read in the Possessed  notebooks. 
 And in his definitive text the novelist voices social unsteadiness as empty groupings and vapid motions. 
 Von Lemke's cut-outs are phantom human concourses (theatre, station, church), and they are mobile. 
 The quintet is Peter Verkhovensky's plaything. 
 He tricks its members into thinking they are part of a revolutionary network extending across Russia, and at the local level he generates pseudo-purposeful activities which culminate in Shatov's murder. 
 There's a littleness about it all: again it must not be seen as mere  chance that we encounter Swift's Lilliput on the first page of the novel. 
 This littleness is at once paltry and menacing and never in repose. 
 One of the members of the quintet bears the quaint name of Tolkachenko. 
 Dostoevsky followed the trial proceedings closely, and I think the Soviet editor is right to put his finger on the verb tolkatsya , to loaf or lounge about, which occurs in a speech by the prosecuting lawyer. 
 The editor might also have noted the colloquial sense of roaming around which the verb shatatsya  carries, for this may perhaps have encouraged the switch from Shaposhnikov to Shatov as the novel began to define itself. 
 Loafing and roaming cohere into a larger whole, together with such imaginative furniture as hats and travelling rugs and passports and foreign restaurant bills and trashy pamphlets printed abroad and incompetently circulated. 
 This novel seems, but only seems, but does seem insistently, to come from a man who knew nothing but was very opinionated, who checked no facts and guzzled rumour scraps, whose mind was uncouth, raggity, raucous, florid. 
 For it is a condition of Dostoevsky's art to arouse our longing for the settled and the normal and the beautiful itself. 
 The Possessed  swarms with amateurism and with fooling about and make-believe just as childish as Von Lemke's, but dangerous. 
 And if not immediately dangerous, then wanton and sinister in its curious evil comedy. 
 Another member of the quintet, one Lyamshin, a post-office clerk, gets himself asked to parties where &bquo;he would give imitations of a pig, a thunder storm, a confinement, with the first cry of the baby, etc., etc.; that was what he was invited for&equo;; and later we hear of him &bquo;mimicking, when requested, various types of jews, a deaf peasant woman making her confession, or the birth of a child&hellip;&equo;. 
 Note the single common element, Lyamshin's confinement act. 
 Masked by the apparently careless tumble of examples (&bquo;etc., etc.&equo;) is a calculated insistence on the sore spot, on what Shatov in the notebooks calls social unsteadiness, a small but virulent secular profanity standing over against the noble, perhaps the noblest sequence in The  Possessed , where Marie Shatov returns to her husband to give birth to another man's child. 
 Peter Verkhovensky can't be fitted into this picture because his raison d'&ecirc;tre  is outside it, manipulating. 
 He plays with the quintet in a quite different sense from that in which they play at revolutionary politics; though, bemused by him, set at odds, their purposes deflected and their fantasies fed and coaxed along, it doesn't seem like playing to them. 
 One of the quintet not only means business but high-minded, selfless business. 
 Virginsky &mdash; the surname once more points the way &mdash; is a utopian socialist of &bquo;rare purity of heart&equo; and &bquo;honest fervour&equo;; Horace would have called him candidus . 
 &bquo;I will never, never abandon these bright hopes,&equo; he used to say to me with shining eyes. 
 Of his &bquo;bright hopes&equo; he always spoke quietly, in a blissful half-whisper, as it were secretly.&equo; 
 And of the tribulations of his personal life, which were in fact grievous: &bquo;It's of no consequence. 
 It's just one particular case. 
 It won't interfere with the &bquo;cause&equo; in the least, not in the least.&equo;&equo; 
 One senses a rush of creative warmth as this lonely rapt figure is conjured in a few sentences. 
 Virginsky will always belong to the Petrashevsky Circle of Dostoevsky's own youth, as well as to the ill-assorted group that dances to Verkhovensky's tune in the late 1860s. 
 How to describe that tune? 
 I called Peter Verkhovensky a wrecker. 
 I might also have said a nihilist. 
 Nihilist is the case but it risks confusion between Dostoevsky and Turgenev who may not have invented the word but certainly gave it very wide currency. 
 In his novel Fathers and Children  which (as the title suggests) is about the generation gap, Turgenev pinned &bquo;nihilist&equo; to the son Bazarov. 
 The heart of this new word and new conception is a humane, scientific, and Germany-focused enlightenment, a delayed Aufklarung  hitting Russia's young &eacute;lite of the 1860s. 
 Bazarov is an idealist and a brave man, and his aims are rational. 
 Verkhovensky has courage (though in its lower forms of which Plato speaks), but otherwise there is nothing in common between the two young men except the times they live in. 
 After the non-fictional Sportsman's Sketches, Fathers and  Children  is Turgenev's best book, and the best thing in it, apart perhaps from the bereaved old couple at the end, is the sensitive give-and-take marriage of its hero's idealism to his scepticism, a questing, generous idealism and an undestroying scepticism. 
 So the novel strikes me, and at one time Dostoevsky thought so too. 
 At least he said he did. 
 One can't be sure. 
 He was at his most two-faced in his dealings with Turgenev. 
 Anyhow, he praised Fathers and Children  to its author, and in his own Winter Notes  he remarked Bazarov's &bquo;greatness of spirit, in spite of all his nihilism&equo;. 
 Then later, in the Possessed  notebooks, we read: &bquo;Bazarov was created by a man of the 1840s, and was created as a figure without affectation, which means that a man of the 1840s could not create Bazarov without violating the truth.&equo; 
 A remarkable statement, and a difficult one. 
 It needn't mean that Dostoevsky had been telling lies and is now telling the truth in the privacy of his own notebooks. 
 He may very well have changed his mind. 
 But if he has, I don't think it follows that Fathers and Children  has become a bad book in his eyes, but rather, it is now not all that good. 
 A rift has opened between realism and something beyond, and at the same time a link has been forged between Dostoevsky's favourite phrase, the deeper realism, and my own apocalyptic naturalism. 
 If Turgenev is a man of the 1840s (which he is), what is he supposed to do about it? 
 And if Turgenev were to object that one could not find a more typical product of the 1840s than the Petrashevsky Circle to which Dostoevsky belonged, how would the other man reply? 
 Over both questions, and over all plausible answers to them, I see hovering those common Dostoevsky ideas of split and break and rent. 
 The raskol  of Raskolnikov means split with a further specialized religious sense of schism. 
 Raskolnikov is self-divided and also separated from the human family in a way which for Dostoevsky is both social and religious. 
 But, as Porfiry tells him, &bquo; You can't do without us' . 
 Nor can he do without his undivided self. 
 And that is how the body of the novel leaves the matter. 
 It's only in the Crime and Punishment  notebooks that we read &bquo;Love and Sonya broke him&equo;. 
 Confusion &mdash; the  sundering of raskol  &mdash; was thus itself confounded; and the crisis or breaking point of his illness followed by his &bquo;regeneration&equo; ( voskresenie ) and his &bquo;passing from one world to another&equo; and his &bquo;acquaintance with a new and hitherto unknown reality&equo; are merely affirmed at the end of the Epilogue. 
 Just as raskol  means split and religious schism, so voskresenie  means regeneration and theological Resurrection. 
 Both areas, breaking and mending, engrossed Dostoevsky from the time when the shared convict existence of prison snapped him like a dry biscuit yet also made him new, so that in the closing words of The House of the Dead , with the knocking off of his fetters, the narrator greets &bquo;a new life, voskresenie  from the dead&equo;. 
 Of his attempts to realize this experience over again in his post-Siberian fiction, the bald Epilogue to Crime and Punishment  is an early and unpromising instance. 
 We have here perhaps the most delicate of all points of contact between his life and his art: hence the impression that further and very private issues are involved in, even shielded by, the assertion that &bquo;a man of the 1840s could not create Bazarov&equo;. 
 As I suggested apropos the Petrashevsky Circle, one feels an urge to smoke Dostoevsky out with the question, who's talking? 
 &bquo;The epileptic&equo; makes a neat reply, again touching life and art simultaneously: the author and hero of The Idiot . 
 I have in mind the experience of being suddenly thrust outside time, which constitutes in The Idiot  and elsewhere the epileptic aura. 
 When this and the regeneration/resurrection theme are brought to bear upon the remark about Bazarov and the 1840s, what seemed a difference of degree turns out to be one of a kind. 
 The criticism of Turgenev is only incidentally that he is stuck in the 1840s and not far-sighted enough. 
 New-sightedness, the timeless standpoint, &bquo;hitherto unknown reality&equo; &mdash; these have an air of mystical hubris when dragged  into the open, but they are what Dostoevsky is really talking about. 
 And so while he sat in a German public library and the story of the murder in the park unfolded before him in the newspapers, a novel began to stir. 
 Or, in mystic vein, an order of being was glimpsed in which the 1840s, the 1860s, nihilism, Bazarov, found themselves apocalyptically and teleologically disposed &mdash; those two polysyllabic adverbs embracing and transcended all nature, including futurity. 
 As one would except, pre-existing material got sucked into this new world. 
 First, the murdered man: he turned out to be a student at the Petrine Agricultural Academy, and his name was Ivanov. 
 It so happened that the novelist's wife had a younger brother at this Academy who knew Ivanov. 
 Now the remarkable circumstance, recorded by Anna Dostoevsky in her memoirs, is that her husband had a foreboding of political disturbances at the Academy, and fearing that his brother-in-law &bquo;because of his youthfulness and weakness of character might take an active part in them&equo;, he persuaded Anna's mother it would be a good thing if the young man came to them in Dresden: which he did in October of 1869, the month before Ivanov was murdered. 
 Next the murderer, the original of Peter Verkhovensky. 
 He was Sergei Nechaev. 
 In defensive mood, and not with complete truth, Dostoevsky wrote to Katkov: &bquo;I do not know and never have known either Nechaev or Ivanov, or the circumstances of the murder, except from the newspapers. 
 And even if I had, I would not have begun copying them. 
 He had reason to be touchy about Nechaev. 
 This ascetic, strong-willed young man, dominating yet dull-toned in personality to the point of satanic flatness, captured as if in his own despite the imagination of the day. 
 Ordinary people talked about him. 
 He even disquieted the hardened revolutionaries he moved among, most notably old Bakunin. 
 His Catechism of a Revolutionary  is a classic in the tactics of terrorism, and it came with an agreeable click of fittingness  to learn recently that this work earned a place on the bookshelves of Stalin. 
 Dostoevsky wanted to stifle the thought that he was riding on the back of Nechacv's perverse glamour. 
 Thus Nechaev forms the most important part, but still only a part, of the perennial parajournalistic debate about actuality and fiction. 
 In the same letter to Katkov Dostoevsky also claimed that the murder was itself the merest peg; &bquo;I am only taking the accomplished fact&equo;; and he went on to assert that the human type &bquo;which corresponds to this crime&equo; was the creature of his imagination. 
 At one level, he got there first. 
 At another, we are still getting there, and the man whose bomb explodes at Bologna railway station one summer day in 1980 while I am pulling this page into shape falls straight back inside The Possessed . 
 At yet another, we will never get there since a stream of tendency has been caught and held in new-visioned (as opposed to far-sighted) iconic stasis, and there can be no movement on out of the world we live in into the book we read. 
 Katkov, therefore, is being asked to accept that &bquo;my Peter Verkhovensky may in no way resemble Nechaev&equo;. 
 This of course won't do. 
 The identities need switching and the whole statement inverting, thus: &bquo;The historical wrecker and terrorist, whether in Petersburg or Bologna, must bear the mark of the fiction and thereby confirm it.&equo; 
 For the moment Dostoevsky has been sidetracked by his immediate anxieties. 
 As I say, he had reason to feel touchy about Nechaev. 
 It is also important to note the time gap of nearly a year between the murder and the letter to Katkov. 
 Initially, a swift, artistically rough job was contemplated, a &bquo;tendentious piece&equo; which would take a few months to write and would enrage &bquo;the nihilists and Westerners&equo; and set them &bquo;howling about me that I'm a retrograde . 
 Well, to hell with them, but I will say everything to the last word.&equo; 
 It was to be topical and polemical, and among other things a direct challenge to Fathers and Children . 
 The enlightened Bazarov had inherited, was continuous with, took a stage further, the liberal and  Westernizing impulse of the 1840s which itself followed the Decembrist uprising of 1825, an aristocratic bid for reform by men who had chased Napoleon out of Russia and had later felt the civilizing influence of Paris. 
 But Verkhovensky the wrecker is unrelated to anything that had gone before, except in the new-seeing eye of his creator. 
 He articulates the Dostoevsky split ( raskol ) in terms of a generation-gap story. 
 Obviously the other side of the gap had to be blocked in, and to represent the 1840s the choice fell on Timofey Granovsky, in his time a renowned liberal professor and public speaker, and to a lesser extent a man of letters. 
 Dostoevsky wrote for Stankevich's published critical study of Granovsky &mdash; &bquo;material absolutely indispensable for my work&equo;, a life-and-death necessity &bquo;like air&equo;. 
 All was bustle and confidence. 
 In the earlier Possessed  notebooks Granovsky appears under his own name, and Peter Verkhovensky (it must be recorded) is often Nechaev. 
 The &bquo;tendentious&equo; story would soon be out of the way, making possible a return to what Dostoevsky thought was much more important, the Life of a Great Sinner  project. 
 But it didn't come out like that. 
 He found he had taken on more than he bargained for. 
 (iii) 
 Painfully &mdash; for no work cost him more or perhaps as much as this one &mdash; Dostoevsky came to see that The Possessed  wasn't a sideshow. 
 In its essentials it wasn't a diversion of any kind. 
 It proved in due course, and in its own degree, the Life of a Great Sinner  itself. 
 Looked at another way, The Possessed  and the two remaining novels he had in him to write, A Raw Youth  and The Brothers Karamazov , are all generation-gap stories, and for Dostoevsky the generation gap is only subordinately topical and tendentious and mixed up with Turgenev. 
 How much of the great-sinner project remained unachieved and how much dissolved itself into the books that  in fact got written, can be debated endlessly. 
 His own discussion of the project tended to be vague and large. 
 In any event the last three novels juxtapose fathers and sons in an effort to gain access to or leverage upon some further thing. 
 The October letter to Katkov envisages this world beyond The Possessed's  initial scope in forthright great-sinner terms. 
 Nicholas Stavrogin has arrived during the summer months of 1870s, and has established himself as the one &bquo;who might really be called the chief character of the novel&equo;. 
 He is &bquo;a villain&equo;, but &bquo;tragic&equo;, and Dostoevsky continues in his most pushy vein, anxious that Katkov shall take notice, &bquo;I have taken him from my heart&equo;. 
 He means the heart of his creative instinct. 
 There is nowhere else to take Stavrogin from, no other link between the middleaged overdriven novelist and his idle young well-connected &bquo;chief character&equo;. 
 Dostoevsky also calls him his &bquo;real hero&equo; and his &bquo;new hero&equo;, and I think he might not object to &bquo;antihero&equo; if the suggestion were put to him. 
 For Stavrogin reaches back, or rather Dostoevsky reaches back in himself, brushing against Raskolnikov and Svidrigailov as he does so, and makes common cause with the underground man. 
 Let me try and bring this out by means of a single phrase in Stavrogin's suicide letter. 
 The final text has &bquo;When all's said and done I've got the habits of a decent man&equo;. 
 Five drafts of the relevant passage survive, the first reading &bquo;When all's said and done I'm a decent man&equo;. 
 The simple end-product arrives only at the fifth attempt. 
 With hindsight one can point to the underground man complaining that if he could manage even to loaf and idle around wholeheartedly he would be able to call himself a lazy man. 
 This is the rationale of the movement from &bquo;a decent man&equo; to &bquo;the habits of a decent man&equo;. 
 Stavrogin can't, and in our definitive text doesn't, claim to be a decent man or to have any other thing to be; all his letter indicates is a deathlike mime or sleepwalk within behaviour patterns determined by upbringing, class, and kind.  
 This must appear implausibly neat. 
 But so do many things once the dust of composition has settled and the builder's yard of notebooks and rejected drafts can be studied at leisure. 
 The neatness comes afterwards; it gets imposed when a long and laborious and very untidy process is shortcircuited by the observation (which Dostoevsky himself may never have made) of a direct link between Stavrogin and the underground man. 
 Fumbling after phrases in the suicide letter and a thousand other places, the novelist strives to clarify an idea, but also to purge his understanding of great-sinner preconceptions and ambitions which the developing Possessed  refuses to accommodate. 
 It isn't because Stavrogin is not  a decent man that the form of words has to be changed; he also says &bquo;I'm bored&equo; in the earliest draft of the letter, and this assertion goes completely. 
 The reason is the underground one I have just stated. 
 Stavrogin acts bored, other people call him bored: he is  bored! 
 But he lacks the minimal ontological ballast to call himself bored. 
 Or anything else. 
 He writes in that same letter &bquo;I can't hate anything&equo;, and he admits he can't even own to &bquo;despair&equo;. 
 And so he drifts towards vanishing point: &bquo;One may argue about everything endlessly, but from me nothing has come but negation, with no magnanimity and no force. 
 Even negation has not come from me.&equo; 
 Only negation. 
 But really not even negation. 
 Nothing. 
 Which leads one to ask what becomes of the sinner &mdash; let alone the great sinner. 
 What counts as sinning greatly? 
 Or, what does sinning greatly count as? 
 One recalls Svidrigailov and Raskolnikov, the potential suicide twitting the actual murderer with &bquo;well, you can certainly do a lot&equo;. 
 Stavrogin writes: &bquo;I've tried the depths of debauchery and wasted my strength over it; but I don't like debauchery and never wanted it.&equo; 
 It doesn't and didn't amount to anything. 
 There is nothing (so to say) deedy in his actions. 
 This crablike sidling away from all he is and does catches the tune of the achieved, fully formed Stavrogin; unlike Svidrigailov, who incidentally makes great play with the fact that he's bored, he would &mdash; could &mdash; never call himself a debauchee. 
 He is a different sort of great sinner, or essay upon the great-sinner theme, which is why I stress the aspect of return to the  Vicious and tragic antihero who can't even call himself lazy. 
 The underground man's heart is no more in being idle than in anything else, however much, as he himself puts it, he &bquo;wants to want&equo;. 
 Stavrogin naturalizes this thought by observing &bquo;My desires are too weak&equo;. 
 But the suicide letter also keeps a foot in the abstract world, the world of metaphysics in my extended sense. 
 Between them Stavrogin and Dasha Shatov, Shatov's sister, the girl to whom the letter is addressed, have conjured the word &bquo;nurse&equo; which is a term of art as metaphysical as anything in Notes from Underground  and impossible to match in the other post-Siberian novels. 
 &bquo;Nurse&equo; is a sort of code between them. 
 She invented it and he picks it up. 
 He has promised that in extremity he will send for her, and she will come and be his nurse. 
 He is perching on the railway, six stops down the line, with a stationmaster he got to know somehow when he was on the town in Petersburg &mdash; the Dostoevsky no-home at its most stripped and strange in this novel of aimless movement. 
 She never comes because he hangs himself, she has nobody to be nurse to, but her journey &mdash; were she to have made it &mdash; would prove as nugatory as his. 
 The letter declares Stavrogin's fear of killing himself. 
 It comes no closer than that to threatening suicide. 
 Nor does it have to: we know his fears are as weak as his desires. 
 Nature is likely to follow art, art here being the pure abstraction of Stavrogin's remark that even negation is more than he can manage. 
 Svidrigailov would never have said that; he would have gone on making jokes about America. 
 And how different the tone of the two men and their two suicides! 
 The nurse trope, I admit, shares America's power to open human doors the further side of whimsicality, but that is because the suicide letter has only one foot in the completely flat uncomic abstract world of negation talk. 
 The other foot remains in Dostoevskian nature. 
 Dasha actually wants to come and look after Stavrogin, as actually as Svidrigailov is bored &mdash; &bquo;especially now&equo;, he says, as America looms. 
 The two worlds of nature and abstraction meet when Stavrogin asks Dasha whether by coming to be his nurse &bquo;you hope to set up some aim for me at last&equo;. 
 This thought combines the antihero wanting to want and Svidrigailov trying sex, balloon-travel,  good works even, in his struggle to latch on to life. 
 As nurse, Dasha's aim  would be to give Stavrogin an aim  &mdash; simultaneously an underground and an American idea. 
 In the Possessed  notebooks Dostoevsky tries a snatch of dialogue in which Stavrogin is asked &bquo;Why don't you just simply live?&equo;; and he replies &bquo;Ah, that's the hardest thing of all&equo;. 
 The novel itself foregoes many such touches which aren't quite true because they betray a teasing Svidrigailov-like zest, or, if you prefer, counterzest; just as, on the secondary plane, Lebyadkin's reply to the man who tells him to stop getting drunk is wonderfully funny but wrong. 
 &bquo;What a strange demand!&equo; says Lebyadkin with an effrontery beyond the man we have been given, though not of course beyond old Karamazov. 
 The long disciplining process of notebooks and drafts reduces Stavrogin to a state very near automatism: the habits  of a decent man. 
 In rejecting drafts he is constantly saying he's bored. 
 In the book we have in front of us &mdash; and it is a long one &mdash; he never does. 
 But, as I say, he acts bored. 
 Peter Verkhovensky is telling him about a religious conversation among some army officers. 
 The mood of the party, according to Verkhovensky, was atheistic. 
 As a group &bquo;they gave God short shift&equo;. 
 But 
 One grey-haired captain, a rough old chap, sat and sat not saying a word, mute as a mackerel, then suddenly got up in the middle of the room ad, you know, said aloud as if speaking to himself, &bquo;If there's no God then what sort of a Captain am I after that?&equo;, ad seized his cap and threw up his arms and went out. 
 &bquo;He expressed a rather sensible idea,&equo; said Stavrogin, ad yawned for the third time. 
 A wine-breath intellectualism hangs over the sturdy little comedy of the captain who has found his own words for declaring God to be the ground of his being. 
 And if there is no God? 
 That brings us to Stavrogin's third yawn. 
 He has grasped the neat theological and ontological crux implicit in the captain's statement, and has acted bored at it. 
 If he  could help himself this would be mental vandalism; but he can't; Stavrogin's are yawns that refuse to be stifled; automatism and involuntarism are finally one, and the tragic villain-hero who at once apprehends the &bquo;sensible idea&equo; and yawns at it betrays a high but helpless intelligence recalling Raskolnikov as well as Svidrigailov. 
 Stavrogin is no more an atheist than Raskolnikov was, but his belief &mdash; all his beliefs &mdash; are weak, as the suicide letter to Dasha Shatov makes plain, and their weakness corresponds to the instability ( shatost ) of Raskolnikov's. 
 Equally, to yawn is to act bored, to admit and even to flaunt kinship with Svidligailov, and the evil-omened word listless ( vyali ) that dogs Stavrogin, though he never uses it himself, corresponds to the other man's terminal boredom. 
 This is what it means to say that Dostoevsky brushes against Raskolnikov and Svidrigailov as he reaches back towards the underground man. 
 The object of the reaching exercise is of course to arrive at Stavrogin. 
 It holds more true of some of us than of others, that in the struggle to make it new we are writing the same book all our lives; and with Dostoevsky this truth is very true. 
 His post-Siberian great-sinner project won't convincingly disengage from his interest in the confessional form, and, as we have seen, the Dostoevsky Confession was afoot before Siberia. 
 With Stavrogin, confession and the great sinner come together in the chapter &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo;, often referred to as Stavrogin's Confession. 
 Dostoevsky set great store by this chapter which marks the acutest phase of his tribulations over The Possessed , because his editor Katkov refused to print it. 
 We recall the same editor's objection to the debate about Christianity between Raskolnikov and Sonya Marmeladov in Crime and Punishment , and, before that again, the censor's blocking of the positive Christian counteraffirmations in Notes from Underground . 
 But this time the rejected text survives: we have the galley proofs of &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; submitted to the magazine Russian Herald , and Dostoevsky's alterations to those proofs, and his widow's list of further variants.  
 Therefore it becomes possible at last to read and evaluate what was earnestly planned, executed, fought for, tinkered with in a vain attempt to propitiate Katkov (but also, as we shall see, for another reason), and finally surrendered. 
 Furthermore, &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; provides the chance to get a look at the figure named by me Dostoevsky's good angel, because here again, as in the two earlier cases, the novelist took no steps to restore the deleted material at some future date when he was his own master; and I think he was right. 
 My Proposition, embracing The House of the Dead, Notes from Underground, Crime and Punishment, The Possessed, Karamazov , and, negatively, by way of relative failure, The Idiot , is that Dostoevsky could only promote his dearest values by creeping up on their blind side: in other words that he had an urge towards crisis and clarity which he could only satisfy by yielding it to the enemy &mdash; to the horror of the flogging routine in the &bquo;Thy kingdom come&equo; episode in the Dead House at one chronological extreme, and to Ivan Karamazov's showdown with the Religion Swindle at the other. 
 Clarity appears in those self-directed exhortations of the novelist to elucidate Raskolnikov's motive for murder. 
 The novel itself ignores them. 
 Crisis introduces the word podvig , translated &bquo;exploit&equo; or &bquo;feat&equo;, though Jacques Catteau remarks that avancement  sometimes renders it best. 
 Podvig , also prominent in the Crime and Punishment  notebooks, gets relegated in the final text to the Epilogue where it is seen at its simplest in the mitigating circumstance that the murderer is discovered at his trial to have burnt himself rescuing two little children from a blazing house. 
 With both the motive for the murder and the brave rescue Crime and Punishment  sets the pattern for later Dostoevsky; his post-Siberian notebooks swarm with admonitions like &bquo;Decide the matter definitely one way or the other&equo;, and with the X marks the spot of &bquo;Here a podvig  is achieved&equo;; and in the other novels, as in Crime and Punishment , the actual outcome of such promptings makes an interesting study. 
 Crisis and clarity are notebook froth whipped up by a single hidden energy. 
 I ask, what does Dostoevsky's gambling  mania aspire towards? 
 And I answer, breaking the bank of all banks, busting Plato's very Idea of a bank; and also being cleaned out absolutely &mdash; but absolutely: body, mind, immortal soul: in fact the Dostoevsky apocalypse where all shall be revealed, where crisis is  clarity. 
 And obviously the novelist's apocalypse is by no means identical with his received Christian one; hence, in part, the divergence of his art from the things his notebooks show him wanting to say. 
 It's a reflection on sadomasochism, and on negation, and on the Underground throughout these novels, that the true gambler's urge to lose is as strong as and not ultimately separable from its opposite. 
 All this bears closely on Stavrogin and his so-called confession. 
 In &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; he goes to the holy man with a document which he gives him to read, and which he does read, and which Stavrogin next proposes to publish. 
 I see the whole chapter as a subtle but misconceived footnote to Crime and Punishment ; in these pages, instead of brushing past Raskolnikov and Svidrigailov in his return upon the underground man, Dostoevsky has allowed himself to be obstructed by them, and the result is a Stavrogin who compounds Raskolnikov's bracing himself to enter the police station &bquo; as a man &equo; and confess with Svidrigailov's reaching out in all directions, including the far extremes of moral and physical debauchery, in the hope that something, it doesn't matter what, will make him unbored. 
 After a sleepless night Stavrogin sets forth. 
 Then outside the monastery where Bishop Tikhon lives, &bquo;he stopped, hastily and anxiously felt something in his side pocket and &mdash; smiled&equo;. 
 That is Raskolnikov's smile. 
 We know it well. 
 And the gesture is Raskolnikov's too, for example when he feels for the axe slung inside his overcoat. 
 Even the sudden stopping is tell-tale. 
 Stavrogin would never stop in the street like that, his psychophysical being is other. 
 This is not a Possessed  moment, not a Possessed  sentence. 
 At the outset we are aware that the chapter &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; is going wrong. 
 Not bad but wrong. 
 When, driven by unbearable mental torment, Raskolnikov  enters the building and climbs the stairs, a splendidly ample and imaginative podvig  seems to be in prospect, un avancement spirituel . 
 It's only afterwards, in the Epilogue, that we learn with surprise and perhaps some vexation that repentance and acceptance of suffering come to him not then but much later, in prison; his confession was not the decisive moral feat we took it for. 
 It was not a heart-and-soul confession but an admission of guilt. 
 And what about Stavrogin as he stands smiling, not of course a happy smile, no kind of unambiguous smile, about to enter the monastery, fingering the pages in his pocket? 
 The man as I say is all Raskolnikov. 
 The document which Bishop Tikhon will read puts Raskolnikov in Svidrigailov's shoes because it is a record of the excesses a mortally jaded palate has got up to. 
 And as Stavrogin describes his search after new and ever stronger and more bizarre sensations, and as he laments his boredom, and as suicide is touched on, tracts of Crime and Punishment  open up again: but without the astral, feathering humour of America, anatomy, and ordinary ghosts. 
 And as he mulls over his reasons for behaving as he has and for writing and publishing this record, the footnote status of &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; causes it to embrace a wide range of familiar themes. 
 To loose them off together, scatter-gun fashion: Stavrogin says &bquo;I am making this statement, incidentally, to prove I am in full possession of my mental faculties and understand my position&equo;; &bquo;I want to forgive myself, this is my chief aim, my whole aim&equo;; &bquo;I want everyone to look at me&equo;; &bquo;I fall back on this as my last resource&equo;; &bquo;The thing about me then was I felt bored with life, sick and tired of it&equo;; &bquo;I am seeking boundless suffering&equo;; &bquo;I took it into my head to mutilate my life somehow&equo; (not necessarily the same thing as seeking suffering, any more than seeking suffering need entail accepting it). 
 Let us pause for a moment over &bquo;I want everyone to look at me&equo;. 
 And I would also like to add yet another &bquo;reason&equo; to the already formidable pile, which is that Stavrogin intends a &bquo;challenge to society&equo;. 
 Now the first is one of Dostoevsky's alterations to the galley proofs of &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo;, and the  second is a variant recorded by his widow. 
 I draw attention to their provenance because commentators have focused on the family-magazine question, on the attempt, that is, to get the chapter past Katkov in some shape or form, and I think this is only half the story. 
 I think in all this textual fussing Dostoevsky was also &mdash; and increasingly &mdash; troubled by the chapter's footnote status and by the problem which I picture as obstruction by Raskolnikov and Svidrigailov in his backward groping towards the underground man. 
 The sharpened exhibitionism of Stavrogin's wanting everybody to look at him will not have helped Dostoevsky with Katkov, but it does mark a step away from Crime and Punishment  and closer to Notes from Underground . 
 The &bquo;challenge to society&equo; seems to fit Raskolnikov's Napoleonic idea &mdash; until we read on in Anna Dostoevsky's manuscript where it is at once and directly linked to &bquo;the governor's bitten ear&equo;, that is to one of those sudden sallies of Stavrogin's elsewhere in The Possessed , sallies hovering between outrage and prank. 
 The instance here is of Stavrogin pretending to the provincial governor that he has a secret to communicate to him, and, when the unsuspecting old man &bquo;hastily and trustfully&equo; inclines his head, seizing his ear in his teeth and holding on to it, biting hard. 
 &bquo;Nicholas, what kind of joke is this?&equo; moaned the governor mechancally in a voice unlike his own. 
 It is a Possessed  kind of joke, inconceivable in Crime and Punishment , and there was no reference to it in the version of &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; submitted to Katkov initially. 
 Once again the change can have nothing to do with making the chapter more acceptable. 
 This incident of the bitten car, presented explicitly as &bquo;a challenge to society&equo;, has no tonal affinity whatever with Raskolnikov's murder, its home is with the underground man sticking his tongue out; the hesitant backward movement towards the world under the floor is also a forward fumble towards Stavrogin and The Possessed . 
 And what of the document itself? 
 Since &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; is constantly referred to in Russia and the West as Stavrogin's  Confession, it occurs to me to note that the word confession does not appear anywhere in the chapter. 
 That the written statement and its publication add up to a true Dostoevsky confession, to repentance and acceptance of suffering, to &bquo;a wonderful podvig &equo; in Tikhon's words, is one possibility among many. 
 Stavrogin s prodigal scattering of reasons does more than leave the question open. 
 It leaves all questioning behind. 
 It muddies the waters of speculation utterly. 
 If we take wanting everybody to look at him as the &bquo;real&equo; reason, then the case of Stavrogin is (in the lawyer's phrase) on all fours with that of the underground man's indecent exposure of consciousness. 
 However, &bquo;I invite nobody into my soul&equo; he declares, as if to banish the exhibitionist thought.44 And then if the search for suffering is allowed to eclipse the rest, we are back with Marmeladov squinnying into the bottom of his vodka jug; whereas Stavrogin saying he wants to forgive himself might be Raskolnikov pondering retrospectively, selfcritically, on his admission of guilt at the police station. 
 To Marmeladov, Raskolnikov, and the underground man, I now add Svidrigailov, because the chief enormity which is being confessed, or merely admitted to, or flaunted, or feigned, binds Stavrogin to the America-minded debauchee no less tightly than does the boredom theme of the &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; chapter. 
 As with the highly misleading phrase Stavrogin's Confession, critics and commentators behave as if they had got into a huddle. 
 Everybody, including the present Soviet editor, talks about Stavrogin's forcing or rape of a young girl. 
 So to sort the thing out: Stavrogin has designs on the child; he kisses her hand, puts her on his knee, whispers to her. 
 She is in terror. 
 Then 
 At last there occurred, suddenly, a most strange event which I shall never forget ad which astonished me: the little girl flung her arms round my neck ad in a rush began kissing me frenziedly. 
 Her face expressed complete rapture. 
 I nearly got up ad went away out of pity, I found this so unpleasant in a slip of a child. 
 But I overcame my immediate fearful feeling, ad I stayed. 
 And that's that. 
 The next sentence begins a new paragraph: &bquo;When all was over, she was covered in confusion.&equo; 
 Therefore no rape occurs. 
 The child is sexually responsive and perhaps dominant. 
 Hence her smile &bquo;as if ashamed, a kind of twisted smile&equo; after her terror and immediately before the passage I have just quoted. 
 Hence, later, her words &bquo;I have killed God&equo;, and her suicide. 
 Getting this right obviously matters in itself, but also for its bearing on two further issues. 
 First, it drives Stavrogin even closer to Svidrigailov than I have suggested so far. 
 The episode with the child is a reworking of Svidrigailov's nightmare immediately before his suicide, in which he finds an abandoned little girl and carries her upstairs and puts her in his bed, and goes back later to see how she is. 
 Now, without any further concealment, she opened both her eyes; they turned a blazing, shameless glance upon him, they invited him, they laughed&hellip; 
 &bquo;Damn you!&equo; 
 Svidrigailov cried in horror, raising his hand to strike her. 
 But at that moment he woke up. 
 Second, it discredits those &mdash; and again the Soviet editor is among them &mdash; who seek to explain Dostoevsky's failure to reinstate &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; solely by the prevailing conditions of censorship. 
 He got Svidrigailov's nightmare past the censor, and there is a good deal more to that horror than I have quoted; and &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; could have been got past him too. 
 It is unsound to argue that Svidrigailov's experience was only a bad dream, because the manuscript variants prove that Dostoevsky was prepared at one stage to forego the actuality of the sexual outcome between Stavrogin and the child. 
 &bquo;It was just a psychological misunderstanding,&equo; so Stavrogin reassures the bishop in Anna's text: 
 &bquo;Nothing happened. 
 Not a thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, God be praised,&equo; said Tikhon, and crossed himself. 
 Amidst this confusion, my view of &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; as a hyperlucid footnote to Crime and Punishment , as misconceived crisis and clarity, needs justifying: the very point of Stavrogin's scattering of &bquo;reasons&equo; is that he and his document  shall not come clear or clinch anything. 
 But, as to clinching things, Stavrogin is not Tikhon, which evokes another of my dicta: Dostoevsky could only satisfy his urge towards crisis and clarity by surrendering it to the enemy. 
 For sure he takes pains to make Tikhon a human puzzle so that he shan't in any obvious way speak God's truth. 
 He looks a bit ill, smiles vaguely, and has a strange rather shy expression. 
 His furniture is a jumble of good and bad; a magnificent Bokhara carpet lies next to straw mats, and engravings of fashionable society and sacred icons confront one another. 
 He appears to enjoy light reading. 
 Perhaps even salacious reading. 
 But nothing, and certainly not articulating his words &bquo;cheerfully and artlessly&equo;, can muffle Tikhon's diagnosis which is that Stavrogin suffers from &bquo;indifference&equo;. 
 At once the two of them fall into a kind of trance. 
 Stavrogin asks the bishop (in cool reason a preposterous question) if he has read the Christian Apocalypse. 
 He then directs him to the message to the angel of the church at Laodicea in the third chapter of Revelation. 
 Tikhon knows the passage by heart and recites it word for word. 
 Its burden is: 
 I know thy works, that thou art neither hot nor cold: I would that thou wert hot or cold. 
 So then because thou art lukewarm ad neither hot nor cold, I will spew thee out of my mouth. 
 The &bquo;lukewarm&equo; state is of course a biblical and transcendental and authoritative anchoring of &bquo;indifference&equo;. 
 It isolates and ratifies the reason among so many reasons which Stavrogin himself gives: &bquo;the disease of indifference&equo;. 
 Tikhon and Stavrogin have both got it right. 
 But this it  cannot be said, can only be shown forth as in the suicide letter where Stavrogin writes &bquo;My desires are too weak; they cannot guide me.&equo; 
 We aim straight at the art of The Possessed  by observing that the follow-up, I'm a lukewarm man, or I'm an indifferent, an apathetic man, is beyond Stavrogin. 
 All self-definition, as Dostoevsky finally shaped and gave Stavrogin to the world, is beyond him. 
 That is why, instead of taking the weakness of his desires to himself, Stavrogin continues in figurative, musing vein, sad and free, very beautiful in context: &bquo;You can  cross a river on a tree-trunk, but not on a chip of wood.&equo; 
 This is the same young man who bit the ear of the governor &mdash; and we can only meet and get to know him in the novel itself. 
 Get to know as opposed to get at. 
 The &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; chapter, rejected by the editor and finally abandoned by the novelist, gets at, ponders the case of, somebody we never even meet there: the smiling man outside the monastery is Raskolnikov, and the document in his pocket recounts Svidrigailov's deeds. 
 The pondering, the getting at the absent Stavrogin, proves successful; many acute observations buttress the central &bquo;lukewarm&equo; truth about him, and analysis spills over into the notebooks where Tikhon's God's-voice function appears at its clearest. 
 &bquo;Try to hold something sacred, no matter what it be,&equo; he exhorts Stavrogin who replies &bquo;What for?&equo; 
 And then the punch line: &bquo;This isn't done for something , it is done just so .&equo; 
 At which moment we can sense the warm breath of composition coming off the page, for Dostoevsky first had Tikhon continue &bquo;It carries its own reward&equo; and then crossed these words out in his notebook, no doubt because they are too obvious and touched by the world's wisdom. 
 They aren't worthy of the silent spiritual gesture made by that italicized &bquo; just so' . 
 Nor is Stavrogin's pert Svidrigailov-like &bquo;What for?&equo; worthy of it, or of himself. 
 And Tikhon's own further move isn't right either: &bquo;If you do not feel a need, and if you love nothing, it follows you are incapable of it.&equo; 
 To this severe driving home of the issue in pursuit of crisis and clarity, Stavrogin might fairly reply that he didn't create himself lukewarm. 
 He would never have had it so. 
 &bquo;I want to want&equo;, the underground man's lonely cry, is also his though he doesn't utter it, and biting the governor's car, like sticking the tongue out, is a one-against-all drumming of the heels of consciousness &mdash; but again with a difference which is that the biting extends beyond the notional; it happens and it hurts, though it's a minor foray compared with Raskolnikov's spectacular eruption into actuality with the murder. 
 And at the same time, since Svidrigailov too has been brushed against in this reaching back which is also a  reaching forward, the incident of the governor's ear can be understood in all its matchless comedy as a desperate man's recourse against boredom. 
 (iv) 
 The mere mention of the biting in Anna's manuscript record of &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; variants is enough to pull the reader back into The Possessed , and he can't experience the sudden fierce tug of that novel without realizing simultaneously that the whole &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; chapter belongs elsewhere, to a different masterpiece. 
 Its footnote status in relation to Crime and Punishment  constitutes, I admit, a funny sort of belonging, as does the obstructive force of Raskolnikov and Svidrigailov upon Dostoevsky's attempt to give decisively new shape to the Great Sinner of his notebooks and letters and fondest creative hopes. 
 A negative belonging, if you like. 
 But narrative tone is a different and affirmative matter. 
 A minute later I looked at my watch ad noted the time. 
 Evening was drawing in. 
 A fly was buzzing over my head ad kept settling on my face. 
 I caught it, held it in my fingers and put it out of the window. 
 A cart drove very loudly into the yard below. 
 Very loudly (ad for some time before), a tailor had been singing as he sat at a window in a comer of the yard. 
 He sat at his work ad I could see him. 
 It occurred to me that as I had met nobody as I walked through the gate and went upstairs, there was no need to encounter anyone now, going down, and I moved my chair from the window. 
 I picked up a book, but put it down again and began looking at a tiny red spider on the leaf of a geranium, ad lost count of time. 
 I remember everything to the very last moment. 
 This sequence could not occur in The Possessed  &mdash; a dangerous thing to say about a very long and diverse book, but true. 
 Despite the fact that spiders are all over the place in Dostoevsky, not just in Svidrigailov's dirty bathhouse vision of Eternity, and that urban potted plants go back to the beginning in Poor People , we are here firmly inside Crime and Punishment  in its abandoned first-person narrative form (&bquo;I am on trial and will tell all&equo;): Petersburg evenings and their hanging summer light, noises from below, happy workmen,  blessed &bquo;living life&equo; elsewhere, a lonely man in pain passing through gates, over thresholds, slipping up and down staircases, the buzzing By of Raskolnikov's dream and his awakening, intense time-consciousness alternating with time-oblivion. 
 &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; has strayed out of a metropolitan novel into a provincial one which won't accommodate it. 
 To take one's finger off the bounding narrative pulse of Crime and Punishment  and to open The Possessed  &mdash; to open it anywhere &mdash; is to find oneself out in the sticks once again: the &bquo;our town&equo; of the novel and the voice relating its affairs bring back the &bquo;we&equo; of convict life in The House of the Dead  and the more sketchy collective of that remote Siberian community outside the prison walls. 
 The same dilating and contracting principle informs both novels, a first-person narrator who moves between &bquo;we all thought&equo; and &bquo;it was just my hunch&equo;, though the swing is greater in The Possessed  and its figuration much more complex. 
 If any House of the Dead  notebooks had survived I would expect them to contain sudden leaps of discovery and creative arrivals like &bquo;Most important &mdash; it's a chronicle  'and 
 &bquo;I've had breakfast. 
 I'll keep the secret. 
 I am a character.&equo; 
 By drawing a rectangle round &bquo; it's a chronicle &equo; Dostoevsky suggests a framed narrative for The Possessed  like the story found by the frame narrator among a deceased ex-convict's effects in The House of the Dead ; and by declaring &bquo;I am a character&equo; ( kharakter : a person, not a literary personazh ) he puts himself inside that frame. 
 The result, therefore, is a framed narrative without a frame narrator &mdash; not that he reached the two sides of this conclusion simultaneously. 
 The first came early and firmly, in February of 1870: &bquo;From a provincial chronicle&hellip;. 
 The system I have adopted is that of a CHRONICLE.&equo; 
 The second was an untidy and protracted business, stretching on through the spring and summer and coinciding with the refusal of The Possessed   to be contained within the limits of a &bquo;tendentious&equo; sideshow. 
 The novel insisted on reverting to the ampler great-sinner pattern; hence Stavrogin's emergence as &bquo;chief character&equo;, &bquo;tragic villain&equo; and so forth during this period, and Peter Verkhovensky's withdrawal to the second rank: Verkhovensky the mere wrecker, the nihilist, the man of the 1860s, the deeper realist's answer to Turgenev. 
 I look in the same direction to account for the charming note &bquo;Granovsky has got a bit out of hand&equo;. 
 Taken more or less straight from life, Granovsky was to have represented the liberal 1840s in a crisp, neat, polemical generation-gap story. 
 In The Possessed  he becomes Stepan Trofimovich Verkhovensky (hereafter Stepan), Peter's father and one of the best things Dostoevsky ever did. 
 But in the mean time, whose hand has Granovsky escaped from? 
 This pinpoints the issue of Dostoevsky as author and as &bquo;a character&equo; in the provincial chronicle, the framed narrative. 
 Again we are at the tip of his pen as he draws a box to put himself inside, and as the most private and informative area of the Possessed  notebooks begins to open up. 
 At first he hadn't even settled on first-person narration; the voice from inside the frame is sometimes &bquo;the chronicler's&equo; or &bquo;the author's&equo;, sometimes &bquo;mine&equo;. 
 A double stance develops &mdash; inevitably, since the figure inside the frame can't wish away the novelist bent over his notebooks. 
 Thus: &bquo;ABOUT NECHAEV &dollar;Peter Verkhovensky&rsqb;: NECHAEV PLAYS TWO ROLES, THE SECOND OF WHICH I, THE CHRONICLER, DON'T KNOW AT ALL AND AM NOT PRESENTING.&equo; 
 Sometimes we catch the novelist positively shaping and manipulating the narrator: &bquo;The chronicler pretends for his part that he feels the sorrow of a Christian&hellip; 
 &equo; And from, or nearly from, the outset there is the hint of a three-cornered relationship in which the future reader of the as yet unwritten Possessed  joins novelist and narrator in a conspiracy to uphold the truth of the fiction: &bquo;Altogether, when I describe conversations, even t&ecirc;te-&agrave;-t&ecirc;te  conversations between two people &mdash; don't worry: either I have hard facts, or perhaps I am inventing  them myself &mdash; but in any case rest assured that everything is true.&equo;  
 The man being reassured is the reader. 
 The man reassuring him is, or has the authority of, the omniscient and omnipotent novelist. 
 The &bquo;I&equo; describing conversations he hasn't direct access to, which he wasn't present at, which he may not even have been told about and so may be inventing, is the &bquo;character&equo; Dostoevsky has turned himself into for the purpose of narrating the provincial chronicle. 
 This one sentence from the notebooks goes straight home to the novel which eventually got written. 
 And the novel which got written breathes life into this sentence's very unpromising warrant for the &bquo;truth&equo; of what is being told, namely that there are hard facts or perhaps it is just being made up. 
 Reassurance is another matter, except at the level where all great art reassures; for a spirit of slippage presides over The Possessed . 
 In the opening paragraphs we are introduced to Stepan Verkhovensky: 
 Nevertheless he was a most intelligent ad gifted ma, even, so to say, a scholar, though, as far as his scholarship was concerned, well, in a word, his scholarship didn't amount to much, to nothing at all I think. 
 A scholar. 
 Not much of a scholar. 
 Really no scholar. 
 Recall Stavrogin's suicide letter. 
 Only negation. 
 Not even negation. 
 Nothing. 
 Doubling in Dostoevsky, which goes back to the very beginning, to Mr Devushkin living and not living in the kitchen, which has its post-Siberian developments in the underground man's now-you-see-me-now-you-don't &bquo;flashing&equo; of his consciousness, in Raskolnikov's and Svidrigailov's different ways of being among but not with us and Porfiry's torture tune of &bquo;There's nothing here, precisely nothing, perhaps absolutely nothing&equo; &mdash; doubling takes on a new form in The Possessed , closer to the I/We/They/Everybody/Nobody shifts of The House of the Dead  than anything else before it or to come. 
 The slippage sentence just quoted concludes with a &bquo;I think&equo;. 
 This &bquo;I&equo; is the first-person narrator inside the frame of  the provincial chronicle, the &bquo;character&equo; Dostoevsky has turned himself into. 
 He is a young friend of Stepan Verkhovensky, and when the notebooks record that Granovsky (Stepan's prototype) has got out of hand they are also heralding the novelist's escape into a fictional mode of enormous suppleness. 
 That Stepan's scholarship amounts to nothing is only what &bquo;I think&equo;. 
 Others may and do think otherwise. 
 A freedom is generated which has its phases of indiscipline, licence, chaos. 
 The book is a stampede, faithful to its title and its Epigraph which is the story of the Gadarene swine possessed by devils and rushing into the lake of Galilee and drowning themselves. 
 The fury, the energy of The Possessed  seems quite magicaally unconvenanted. 
 The slippage principle should make for enervation and a general whittling away. 
 But on the contrary, this world of &bquo;it was rumoured&equo; and &bquo;that may well have been so&equo; followed at once by &bquo;it is more likely that nothing of the sort happened&equo; &mdash; again in the opening paragraphs &mdash; is as exhilarating as the challenge of life's opacities to a healthy curiosity. 
 Indeed the overall triumph of art in this case is that the novel walks out into our fact rather than ourselves entering its fiction: a very primitive and absolute form of consumer capitulation. 
 Dostoevsky has an impudent way of making his narrator declare &bquo;As a chronicler I confine myself to presenting events exactly as they happened, and it's not my fault if they appear incredible&equo; &mdash; like the son of the house writing home about his time on the North-West Frontier of India. 
 The imperial-provincial id&eacute;e  is a sovereign one. 
 We read about the governor's bitten ear with the fascination of doting remoteness. 
 Likewise the Audenesque opprobrious act which precedes it. 
 One of the most respected of our club members, on our committee of management, Pavel Pavlovich Gaganov, an elderly man ad highly esteemed, had formed the innocent habit of following anything he had to say with the vehement addition, &bquo;No, sir, you can't lead me by the nose!&equo; 
 Well, there's no harm in that. 
 But one day at the club when he trotted out this phrase during some heated discussion in the midst of a  little group of members (all of them persons of some consequence), Nicholas Stavrogin who was standing to one side alone and unnoticed, suddenly went up to Mr Gaganov and, taking him unexpectedly and firmly with two fingers by the nose, managed to drag him two or three steps across the room. 
 Cantonment goings-on in Peshawar! 
 Goings-on of cruel and rootless hilarity. 
 This is how there is no getting at Stavrogin, and how getting to know him proceeds. 
 And this is what happens to the podvig  tic which obsesses the notebooks and the &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; chapter: it becomes deflected and surrealized into eruptive impenetrable little freaks. 
 Or Dostoevsky holds firm to a certain grandness and climactic force, while inverting the podvig  and rendering it passive, when Stavrogin &bquo;endures&equo; a tremendous punch in the face from Shatov. 
 Stavrogin is a killer &mdash; or can be &mdash; but he does nothing: &bquo;the light in his eyes seemed to go out.&equo; 
 Though untalkative, he is as inspectable as Hamlet, and no less inscrutable. 
 Quite late in his notebooks Dostoevsky puts the matter thus: Stavrogin &bquo;confides in nobody and is a mystery all round&equo;. 
 Then a few lines further on: &bquo;Stavrogin reveals himself gradually through the action without any explanations&equo;. 
 But the self that gets revealed in the novel's action is a bundle of contradictions, like some people we know well. 
 So there's no inconsistency when Dostoevsky says that what is &bquo; most important &equo; is the &bquo; special tone of the narrative &equo; whereby &bquo; everything will be saved' , and that the tone of the narrative rests in Stavrogin &bquo;not being elucidated&equo;. 
 Stavrogin's ear-biting and nose-pulling present two small samples of this all-important narrative tone. 
 The first of these revelations which elucidate nothing is introduced as &bquo;completely unthinkable but from another point of view and in one respect all too easy to envisage&equo;. 
 Slippage again: the crumbling, self-thwarting surface of the prose. 
 From what &bquo;point of view&equo; and in which &bquo;respect&equo;? 
 We are never told. 
 Furthermore, unthinkable to whom and envisageable by whom? 
 The chronicler wasn't present at the incident. 
 As with large tracts of The Possessed  this is in effect third-person narrative, recalling the notebook assurance that whether &bquo;my&equo;  story is based on hard facts or has simply been made up, it is all &bquo;true&equo;. 
 Nor does the chronicler say whether he was present at the nose-pulling. 
 But nor does it matter; &bquo;our club&equo; will have been seething with talk for days, and &bquo;I&equo; am bound to have heard about Stavrogin's escapade. 
 And the &bquo;they&equo; of more or less the whole town will have heard too. 
 Here The Possessed  draws close to the I/We/They/Everybody shifts of The House of the Dead , and the tone of the narrative, which (Dostoevsky said) is to save everything, demonstrates its airy yet potent, rather Proustian anecdotal scope. 
 &bquo;Our club&equo; presumably overlaps while being smaller than &bquo;the best circles&equo; of this society, whereas the &bquo;they&equo; of &bquo;the whole town&equo; is sometimes, but only sometimes, the &bquo;we&equo; of &bquo;our town&equo;; and &bquo;our group&equo; which springs out of &bquo;my&equo; special relationship with Stepan Verkhovensky and which gathers round Mrs Stavrogin, Nicholas's mother and Stepan's patroness, is different again and again overlapping; and the &bquo;all&equo; buried inside the phrase &bquo;our &bquo;old man&equo; &mdash; as we all used to call Stepan Trofimovich among ourselves&equo; is probably though not certainly synonymous with this &bquo;group&equo;; while Dostoevsky delights in sly collective evocations like &bquo;civic grief&equo; and in parcellings-out like &bquo;the poorest expectant mothers of the town&equo;, and in fouling the whole snobbish provincial nest with such carefully calculated absurdities as &bquo;almost the whole town, that is of course the entire top stratum of our society&equo;. 
 So there is no difficulty in imagining how the news of the senior citizen's pulled nose got around. 
 In the general excitement &mdash; the novel has scarcely begun &mdash; it gets borne in upon the reader that Stavrogin's conduct is not the only thing to be puzzled by. 
 Not one of &bquo;us&equo; in the whole town ascribes his action to madness. 
 That means we were inclined to expect such behaviour even from a sane Stavrogin.&equo; 
 That means  &mdash; the unsettling authorial logic is neutrally deployed, with no follow-up. 
 Something has bitten &bquo;us&equo;. 
 &bquo;Our&equo; mentality is odd too. 
 The reader must make what he can of it. 
 Everybody in &bquo;our town&equo; feels indignant about the insult to the respected old gentleman, and a proposal gets off the ground  to give a subscription dinner in his honour; but finally &bquo;we&equo; think better of it, &bquo;perhaps realizing at last that a man had, after all, been pulled by the nose, so there really wasn't any cause for a celebration.&equo; 
 &bquo;Social unsteadiness ( shatost) , as Shatov says.&equo; 
 What has bitten &bquo;us&equo;, the transpersonal Gadarene motif of The Possessed , manifests itself through the dotty plan for a dinner just as eloquently as through the murder in the park. 
 It's a mistake to have a narrowly political view of the novel, as it is to regard its comedy as somehow decorative. 
 The lightness of its light relief is shatost  too. 
 &bquo;We&equo;, the provincial society, display all the loose-end symptoms of Peter the Great's reforms &mdash; though Dostoevsky's overt theorizing about Peter gets left behind in the notebooks. 
 The novel articulates the loose end as boredom, again transpersonalized. 
 &bquo;I find it strange looking at you all,&equo; says Marya Lebyadkin, the crazed visionary cripple, the fool-in-Christ ( yurodivaya) , in a touchstone meditation; &bquo;I don't understand how it is people are bored.&equo; 
 Uniting boredom, provinciality, the Gadarene stampede, and paper people, Peter Verkhovensky says: &bquo;I realize that in this godforsaken town you are bored, so you make a rush for any piece of paper with something written on it.&equo; 
 This boredom rotates upon a frivolous-menacing, frenetic-slack, comic-terrible axis which is the book's living principle. 
 In itself the dim complacency of gossip and cards at &bquo;our club&equo; would seem harmless, familiar, merely social; but &bquo;in itself&equo; denatures The Possessed  where groupings dissolve or collapse into each other, and where the &bquo;merely&equo; social has no place. 
 On his death-bed Stepan Vcrkhovensky returns to the swine of the gospel story and paraphrases the devils which enter them as a disease afflicting all Russia. 
 In Eternity, like the madman in the story who got rid of his devils when they were driven out of him and into the swine, Russia will sit healed at the feet of Jesus. 
 This dubious eschatology need not worry us because the novel makes no attempt to encompass it. 
 Jesus and Holy Russia at his feet remain harmlessly, hypothetically beyond the apocalyptic naturalism  which is everything the book is about: the devils, the disease, the all-pervading unsteadiness. 
 (v) 
 Those &bquo;poorest expectant mothers of the town&equo; are the objects of Mrs Stavrogin's competitive philanthropy. 
 She and the new governor's wife, Mrs von Lemke, enter upon a tussle for local ascendancy through their rival charitable undertakings. 
 In the end Mrs Stavrogin and her expectant mothers lose out &mdash; if indeed there was ever any winning &mdash; while Mrs von Lemke's needy governesses bring that determined woman victory, but then defeat. 
 The fund-raising f&ecirc;te for the governesses is the biggest set-piece skandal  in all Dostoevsky. 
 Drunks and gatecrashers move in. 
 Grotesque isolated figures &mdash; &bquo;a huge pock-marked retired captain&equo; &mdash; loom out of the chaos and disappear again. 
 Humble clerks who have gone a bust on clothes for marriageable daughters are outraged but too timid to protest. 
 The book itself seems to go mad. 
 Its flickering epidemic relish at the expense of clerks and governesses and expectant mothers is wilder than irresponsibility and more furious than Saturnalian record. 
 Out of sight, shielded by riot and revelry and now a quarter of a century older, lurks the poet who boasted he had not shown his young mug in Poor People : the sober laborious craftsman determined that his tone shall save everything. 
 An extraordinary number of subscribers ad donors had turned up, all the select society of the town; but even the most unselect were admitted, provided they brought the cash. 
 Trouble ahead! 
 Trouble conveyed in one exactly placed slippage sentence. 
 That is before the f&ecirc;te begins. 
 And at the end, after twelve cancelled variants in one short paragraph, a single sentence, itself the third attempt, tells us &bquo;They would not let the orchestra go, and musicians who attempted to leave were beaten up&equo;, which says all we need to know about the unstated &bquo;Keep playing!&equo; whereby the liveliness of the small hours will have been sustained.  
 On the other hand this skulking novelist told himself in a notebook, as we recall, &bquo;I am a character&equo;; and there is every reason why the narrating &bquo;I&equo; of The Possessed  should be perfectly visible. 
 Sometimes he is just a secondary figure floating in the novel's bloodstream, as at the f&ecirc;te where he has got roped in with a few other young men to be a marshal and make sure everything goes smoothly. 
 Of course he is incompetent, and as well as being swept along in the muddle and uproar he shares &bquo;our town's&equo; positive transpersonal complicities in what goes on here. 
 All over the place, not only at the f&ecirc;te, a psychic infection rages and erupts in small ugly-comic jests &mdash; &bquo;They put a dead cat in my trunk&equo; &mdash; but also in affronts to the human self as massive and immemorial as those Homer describes. 
 A very young man has shot himself and &bquo;we&equo; ride off in an inquisitive Gadarene &bquo;cavalcade&equo; (&bquo;our ladies had never seen a suicide&equo;) to view the corpse; &bquo;everything's so boring&equo; &mdash; recall Marya Lebyadkin's words &mdash; &bquo;one can't afford to be squeamish about one's amusements so long as they are fun&equo;; and Lyamshin, the man who gets himself asked to parties to mimic women in labour, new-born babies, and peasants in the confessional, steals a bunch of grapes from the room of death. 
 It's not easy to say what the narrating &bquo;I&equo; is doing at such a scene. 
 Again and again he seems to be in and yet dubiously of the party. 
 In fact the chronicle succeeds in having its cake and eating it, all the way back to the stir caused by Nicholas Stavrogin's arrival in &bquo;our town&equo;, when it is recorded among other things that he seemed to know a lot &mdash; &bquo;But of course it didn't take much knowledge to astonish us&equo;. 
 Isolated, that looks like straightforward double focus: the first-person narrator inside the chronicle box, unaware of his provincial limitations; and Dostoevsky outside it. 
 One's overall sense of The Possessed  absolutely refuses to confirm any such duality, and one can pay the novel no simpler or fuller tribute than by saying so. 
 The slippage principle which should, I remarked, enervate but in truth exhilarates, has a way of positioning the reader  on the side of the narrative against the narrator. 
 The troubles of the new governor are being described. 
 Cattle plague is life. 
 Fires keep breaking out. 
 Rumours &mdash; that Fama of The Possessed  which can swell to a raging flood but equally can sink into a hoarse inward whisper &mdash; rumours of incendiarism abound. 
 &bquo;Cases of robbery were twice as numerous as usual. 
 But all this, of course, would have been perfectly normal had there not been other more weighty reasons which disturbed the composure of the hitherto cheerful von Lemke.&equo; 
 How can twice as many robberies as usual be perfectly normal? 
 Of course they can't. 
 Simultaneously the reader responds to the transpersonal unsteadiness, the possessed state of the book, and feels an urge to thrust aside the irresolute self-contradictory narrator and repose upon the story of von Lemke with his cut-out toys and yellow autumn flower. 
 &bquo;However hard it may be to imagine, it was so.&equo; 
 Thus speaks the fool narrator. 
 But this incomparable narrative needs no shoring-up by him. 
 He might as well ask the reader to believe in those supremely credible terrorized musicians scraping and blowing through the small hours. 
 The intrusive chronicling &bquo;I&equo; can't even make up his mind about numbers. 
 Once the rosetted marshals at the f&ecirc;te are six, and once they are twelve. 
 Very few readers will notice this discrepancy, but all are flicked and jabbed at and irritated &mdash; those circling insects &mdash; by contradiction, by undetermination followed by overdetermination of reasons, by the narrator's fuss over details which don't matter, his youthful sententiousness about women (&bquo;the depths of the female heart&equo;) and other irrelevancies, his moralizing, his way of wantonly bleeding a robust narrative with &bquo;However, that may only have seemed so&equo;, his &bquo;I have already described&equo; when he hasn't, his promises to explain later which aren't kept when the reader doesn't want explanation anyhow, he wants the story. 
 Once and once only in six hundred and seventeen pages the narrator gives his readership a disconcerting, impertinent prod by addressing it directly as &bquo;Gentlemen&equo;. 
 These things add up.  
 They add up to a novel of leaking secrets and amputated thoughts, of wildly comic material sometimes dully, almost dutifully deployed, as if the humour had escaped the teller; of people &bquo;missing&equo; each other in dialogue 
 &bquo;Perhaps he didn't go out of his mind at all.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh you mea because he started biting people?' 
 and clashing head-on unforgettably 
 &bquo;But I'm your uncle; I carried you about in my arms when you were a baby.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do I care what you carried? 
 I didn't ask you to carry me.' 
 A novel scatty yet dense, as when events are badly related in real life. 
 A novel of little sprouting aphorisms: &bquo;Every man is worth an umbrella&equo;. 
 And enchanted ghost-voice exchanges of extremest purity: 
 &bquo;What's that? 
 An allegory?&equo; 
 &bquo;N-no &mdash; why? 
 Not an allegory, just a leaf, one leaf.' 
 A novel where actions get unhooked from their (or any) waking rationale: 
 The prince too looked at the German, turning his head and collar towards him and putting on his pince-nez, though without the slightest curiosity. 
 And words as well as actions: 
 &bquo;Suppose you had lived on the moon,&equo; Stavrogin interrupted&hellip; 
 &bquo;I don't know,&equo; replied Kirillov. 
 &bquo;I've not been on the moon,&equo; he added, without any irony, simply as a statement of fact. 
 And here's another fact: 
 &bquo;Nowadays they carry corpses by rail,&equo; said one of the most insignificant young men unexpectedly. 
 A toneless, disjunctive fact, droll and very uneasy, one of those amputated thoughts I have just mentioned and &ndash;so a sensation, a crawling sensation of the time being out of joint; there is more Hamlet  to The Possessed  than what is personal  to Stavrogin, &bquo;the Prince&equo; as he first appears, though on the surface of his mind Dostoevsky evidently meant Prince Hal, not the Prince of Denmark. 
 Nevertheless Stavrogin does contemplate suicide, and the notebook entry &bquo;to be or not to be&equo; bears the date 16 August, so it belongs to the summer when the &bquo;tendentious&equo; political story gets tugged back into great-sinner orbit, growing physically and imaginatively larger and more formidable all the time. 
 Dostoevsky's main troubles were with Stavrogin himself, his new-found &bquo;chief character&equo;. 
 His first and continuing urge was to drive him towards crisis and clarity, which involved, one might almost say which meant, finding a podvig  that would satisfy his idea of Stavrogin. 
 And thus suicide comes in. 
 Now the underground man would have extinguished his consciousness if he could, but since the fable of life under the floorboards renders him bodiless and one can't kill consciousness without laying hands on one's body, the matter doesn't arise. 
 Svidrigailov possesses a body, and destroys it. 
 Whether the suicide who teases the murderer about his ability to do something is himself achieving anything deedy by going to his America &mdash; that question Crime and Punishment  never voices, and it is a crucial and inspired omission. 
 And now, writing the same novel all his life, Dostoevsky finds himself doomed to confront suicide as deed, perhaps life's one deed and therefore the podvig  he is seeking. 
 During his struggle to get The Possessed  into shape he came to see that his conception of Stavrogin, as well as obsessed by crisis and clarity, was hopelessly overcrowded. 
 With cornucopian largesse and ramification the notebooks polarize the emerging hero into a man indulging all vileness and in love with the good. 
 In the novel he stays polarized, but without bulk and in a tragic sense without force; he goes through the motions (&bquo;the habits of a decent man&equo; and so forth) while his great-sinner infamies are unloaded upon a past which he cannot even renounce. 
 The final letter declares: &bquo;Indignation and shame I can never feel; therefore not despair, either.&equo; 
 His inability to despair makes the soaped rope and spare nail of his suicide at once meticulous and completely open-ended. 
 The doctors rule out insanity, God knows why,  just as the club and other circles of &bquo;our town&equo; think a sane Stavrogin capable of ear-biting and nose-pulling. 
 One recalls the disease of indifference in the abandoned &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; chapter and observes how odd its symptoms are; or one quotes Stavrogin's notebook rejoinder that simply to live is the hardest thing of all. 
 Anyhow, he kills himself and there is no more to be said. 
 Suicide as podvig , on the other hand, must drag a verbalized freight of theory behind it. 
 So the novel frees Stavrogin from &bquo;to be or not to be&equo; and all other trammels of the notebooks, and transfers them to Kirillov. 
 Like Svidrigailov, Kirillov comes to the fore very late and very fast in the process of composition, but unlike Crime and Punishment's  self-slaughterer the man in The Possessed  parades an entire philosophy and theology of suicide. 
 This theorizing is the last thing of all to arrive. 
 Initially, in November, which is three months after Stavrogin was quoting Hamlet, Kirillov's &bquo; ROLE IS A FACTUAL ONE &equo; &mdash; by which Dostoevsky means he &bquo;volunteered to shoot himself for the common cause&equo; and leave a letter claiming responsibility for Shatov's murder, thus diverting the attention of the police from Peter Verkhovensky and the quintet. 
 This framework of suicide and untruthful self-incriminating letter remains. 
 But at the last minute, apparently under the immediate pressure of writing the magazine version of the novel, Dostoevsky realised that &bquo; FACTUAL &equo; is precisely what Kirillov's role must not, in essence and impact, be. 
 Kirillov is needed to give The Possessed  its strand of theoretic absolutism. 
 He is as Gadarene, as possessed, as any one, but at the level of total ideal obsession. 
 While Shatov expounds and disputes ardently, and incidentally takes a lot of good- and God-focused material off the shoulders of the notebook Stavrogin (&bquo;&bquo;Shatov must be tied up before you can argue with him, '&equo; Stepan Verkhovensky sometimes joked'), only to Kirillov can it be said and is it said, &bquo;you haven't swallowed an idea, but an idea has swallowed you&equo; &mdash; to which he responds delightedly with &bquo;That's good. 
 You've got a bit of sense.&equo; 
 The idea which has swallowed Kirillov is suicide, not  suicide for the common cause of the quintet as Dostoevsky first proposed, but to achieve a metaphysical and religious purpose; and thus he plays a big part in the transformation of a neat political generation-gap story into a larger, more complicated object. 
 He writes the self-incriminating letter because he has promised to. 
 He kills himself, as innumerable commentators have paraphrased and elaborated, in order to kill God. 
 Suicide for this reason &mdash; to free mankind of the consoling yet imprisoning fictions of religion &mdash; is the highest expression of self-will, a perfectly free action, a divine gesture. 
 The man who kills himself thus , becomes god. 
 More exactly, he becomes man-god as opposed to God-man who is the Christ of Christianity. 
 There have been millions of suicides in the history of the world, but none, according to Kirillov, for this  reason. 
 Therefore mankind, history, eternity, God, all wait upon him and his deed. 
 While doing rough justice to what Kirillov says, to his brand of mystical atheism, this more or less agreed summary is not convincingly inward with Dostoevsky's creation. 
 In trying to improve on it, perhaps the best plan is to enter where Kiriliov does. 
 He is introduced as a &bquo;structural engineer&equo;. 
 I think we should prick our ears at that. 
 Dostoevsky's groping backwards past Crime and Punishment  towards Notes from Underground  is not just a matter of arriving at Stavrogin. 
 The seed-bed of Kirillov's structural engineering is the underground man's image of normal human beings as roadbuilders: being somebody, doing something, going somewhere. 
 Of course Kirillov is anything but a normal human being; and that is just the point. 
 His structural engineering never happens. 
 He has arrived from abroad, yet another bird of passage, &bquo;in the hope of getting a job building our railway bridge&equo;. 
 But, so Stepan Verkhovensky tells him, &bquo;They won't let you build our bridge.&equo; 
 Why not? 
 And who are &bquo;they&equo;? 
 A sudden whiff of Kafka. 
 This is the world of the underground man's eruptive and unexplained &bquo;They won't let me &mdash; I can't be &mdash; good&equo;; which world is itself continuous with that of the pre-Siberian stories, particularly The Double  where Dostoevsky says he found his underground type. 
 As to  &bquo;our bridge&equo; (which is never mentioned again), the reader can if he likes reflect that Kirillov is an odd fish and will no doubt prove himself persona non grata  in &bquo;our town&equo;, or that the local bureaucrats are an officious and/or corrupt lot, or that the central authority thousands of miles away in Petersburg enjoys throwing its weight about. 
 But this would be moving in and making up the message in the style of the &bquo;missing&equo; letters in Poor People , the first story of all. 
 The fact is that The Possessed , which can be circumstantial to a calculated fault when it chooses, in this case chooses to say nothing. 
 The novel proposes a man who has been swallowed by a theory of suicide. 
 He lives for us, we can feel him kicking inside the idea's belly, because the bridge-builder who does no bridge-building is vitalized by the nobody to be and nowhere to go of Dostoevsky's inexhaustible inventive fascination. 
 Here, self-exclusion from the feast of life takes a fresh turn. 
 And a new twist is given to the urge to be a Napoleon. 
 In the immediate context of The Possessed  Kirillov delights even while he is dismaying us by pushing theory &mdash; the novel's Paper Person motif, that is &mdash; to the very limit, the born gambler's limit. 
 He may be mad. 
 Stavrogin says he is. 
 If so, he is incidentally mad in accord with Kafka's piercing throw-off. 
 He embraces suicide as deed, as the one true act in a false world, as supreme podvig , as feat to end feats, God-killing, god-making; and in doing so he exemplifies, as others before and Ivan Karamazov after him, the truth that Dostoevsky can only satisfy his hunger for crisis and clarity by bestowing it on the enemy. 
 No jokes about America from Kirillov. 
 He has actually been to the actual America &mdash; and come back.It was a failure.The novel handles the subject brusquely, whereas a notebook entry about Stavrogin back in the Spring of 1870 suggests a position midway between Svidrigailov and Kirillov: &bquo;Sometimes he complains all of a sudden: &bquo;I'm bored!'&equo; 
 The S.S. Alabama: &bquo;I'll get there! '&equo; (dream).&equo; 
 But an unmetaphorical America in The Possessed  does not mean an unwitty treatment of suicide. 
 What makes the commentators on man-godhood and related themes misleading, why they fail to evoke the real thing, is that they suggest an object which is stable and personal (as opposed to  volatile and transpersonal). 
 The obsession has become Kirillov's alone. 
 But the sunrise of impending suicide bathes him and others in fiery metaphysical comedy;, &bquo;be as free as you like,&equo; Peter Verkhovensky tells him, &bquo;so long as you don't change your mind&equo; &mdash; that is &bquo;so long as your entirely free intention is carried out&equo;. 
 &bquo;Free intention&equo; is the crux. 
 As Kirillov puts it, &bquo;I am killing myself to show my rebelliousness and my new terrible freedom.&equo; 
 He asks rhetorically, apropos the idea which has swallowed him, &bquo;Who will prove it?&equo; and answers &bquo;I&equo;. 
 But Kirillov has himself pointedly ruled out life after death: &bquo;the laws of nature did not spare even Him &equo; &mdash; Jesus, that is. 
 Then what of this proof and this freedom? 
 Kirillov alive has proved nothing, and Kirillov dead will himself be nothing. 
 Stepan Verkhovensky's naked transcendental &bquo;They won't let you&equo; turns out to be a very suitable preface to a logical joke about time and identity. 
 Stepan's forward-pointing negative &bquo;won't&equo; is no less important than his collective &bquo;they&equo;. 
 As The Possessed  is a novel  of groups, circles, sets, quintets, real and imagined, so it is a novel of empty or baffled futurity. 
 Bridge-building is empty because it never happens, God-killing and god-making suicide is baffled because there is only a corpse to point at, there is nobody to attach a fulfilled &bquo;free intention&equo; to. 
 Peter Verkhovensky attacks this bafflement from the other end, from the standpoint of afterwards, as well as that of the not-yet-dead Kirillov who is arguing with him here and now. 
 How is the world going to know it has received a boundless freedom at the hands of an obscure young man lying in some back room in a provincial Russian town? 
 Kirillov replies: &bquo;There is nothing secret that will not be made known. 
 He  said so.&equo; 
 And with these words he points towards an icon of the Saviour before which he has lighted a lamp &mdash; &bquo;to be on the safe side,&equo; Peter suggests. 
 But in response to this Voltairean jest, the lonely, agonized, perhaps crazed man &bquo;made no answer&equo;. 
 He was no doubt contemplating not futurity but baffled Eternity itself: a universal Revelation outside nature guaranteed by a Christ whom the laws of nature did not spare. 
 When Stavrogin, who &bquo;poisoned&equo; Kirillov, and who also kills himself, wrote that letter to Dasha Shatov asking her to come and be his nurse, his mind won't have been bent either on or away from suicide; he was neutrally wondering whether she hoped &bquo;to set up some aim for me at last&equo;. 
 He is both rudderless and becalmed, and the futurity conjured by his letter blends the metaphysical frustration of a brilliant unhoused intellectual torpor with human impossibility: you can't cross a river on a chip of wood. 
 This single great emptiness before him has lots of smaller ones inside it. 
 For example, when Dostoevsky abandons the &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; chapter but retains the brief exchange in which Shatov urges Stavrogin to go to Bishop Tikhon, and Stavrogin replies &bquo;Thank you, I will&equo;, let nobody persuade us the novelist has made a mistake. 
 And the same future tense &mdash; &bquo;I will&equo; &mdash; has Shatov in its grip. 
 Stavrogin, needling away, elicits from him that he believes in Russia and the Orthodox Church and the body of  Christ. 
 &bquo;But in God? 
 In God?&equo; 
 Stavrogin persists. 
 &bquo;I &mdash; I will believe in God,&equo; says Shatov. 
 While Stavrogin never gets to see Tikhon, the immediate future holds murder in store for Shatov. 
 One of his killers is the high-minded Virginsky who &bquo; will  never, never abandon these bright hopes&equo; (my italics), and another member of the quintet is Shigalov who pulls out of the affair at the very last moment, not from fear or pity or remorse but because the murder &bquo;is in direct contradiction of my programme&equo; &mdash; of Shigalov's own brand of revolutionary ideology. 
 He's not going to warn Shatov or tell the police, he's going to make a statement &bquo;for general edification&equo; &mdash; words but no deeds, a turn towards sanity and life that might have been , and a horrific-comic Possessed  moment of subtlest art. 
 Shigalov does make his statement. 
 The murder goes forward. 
 Thus some things that are said to be going to happen, do happen. 
 &bquo;But they will lose their reason,&equo; says Peter Verkhovensky's lieutenant when Peter has argued that the quintet will hold together after the murder &bquo;unless they've lost their reason&equo;. 
 And sure enough they do panic and run amok, and &bquo;the almost mystical terror which suddenly took hold of our authorities&equo; completes the ruinous and negative side of the Gadarene story. 
 (vi) 
 It may be asked what other side The Possessed  has. 
 For it's no use looking to this novel for even a premonition of a cleansed Russia sitting at the feet of Jesus. 
 Well now, to hand over crisis and clarity to the enemy is not to revile the hunger, not to mock the passion itself; the handing over resolves an otherwise intractable problem of art; it is not a disavowal; and in any case &bquo;enemy&equo; is only my image. 
 The broader truth is that Dostoevsky cannot foster any  of his dearest values except obliquely, by stealth, by catching them napping. 
 In The House of the Dead  he makes us feel that the grim actualities of prison life do this job for  him. 
 The Possessed  works differently. 
 We have already met Lyamshin, the member of the quintet whose party act is to mimic women in labour and new-born babies. 
 Flanking him as it were is the wife of another familiar figure and quintet member, Virginsky. 
 Mrs Virginsky is &bquo;our town's&equo; midwife, a modern woman in Dostoevsky's reshaped generation-gap story, a nihilist and free-thinker. 
 Our official town doctor Rozanov, himself an accoucheur, declared quite positively that on one occasion when a patient in labour was screaming and calling on the name of the Almighty, a free-thinking sally fired off like a pistol-shot by Mrs Virginsky struck such fear into the patient that delivery was greatly accelerated. 
 In that sentence humour really is the only thing. 
 Not the next man's humour. 
 A strange wild land out the other side of mockery, even of irresponsibility, indeed beyond all attitude and judgment. 
 No other novelist can reach it. 
 And as I say, some absolutely precious quarry is being stalked by means of Lyamshin and Mrs Virginsky. 
 Opposite them stands Shatov, and when his wife's and Stavrogin's baby is delivered by Mrs Virginsky, the man who will believe in God declares 
 &bquo;The mystery of the coming of a new creature is a great mystery ad incomprehensible, Mrs Virginsky, and what a pity it is that you don't understand it.' 
 He goes on 
 &bquo;There &mdash; ere two ad suddenly there's a third human being, a new spirit, whole, complete, unlike the handiwork of men&hellip;&equo;. 
 In this childbirth sequence the prose of an essentially devious and turbid writer clears like a tangled sky. 
 It's not that Shatov is somehow proved right and Mrs Virginsky wrong about new life and (by implication) God, but that the most natural hope begins to stir in the merely legal father's heart; so it would be pompous and artificial to go on  talking about futurity, this is the  future in the mind's eye of one rejoicing man: shared, beautiful, fragile; and the whole novel seems braced to tear itself free of the devils possessing it: 
 &bquo;Marie,&equo; he cried, holding the child in his arms, &bquo;the old nightmare is over &mdash; the shame ad the death things! 
 Let us work hard ad begin a new life, the three of us &mdash; yes, yes! 
 Oh yes, and what shall we call him, Marie?&equo; 
 A new life. 
 The Dostoevsky voskresenie , at once regeneration and Resurrection. 
 The knocking off of fetters at the end of The House of the Dead.  
 Crime and Punishment's  Epilogue. 
 Shatov's actual words are &bquo;a new road&equo;, recalling man the roadbuilder and Kirillov the structural engineer. 
 In a novel where expectations are not so much unfulfilled as positively spited, Shatov's future, his hope, suffers simple tragic extinction with his murder. 
 But he has had his vision of family, home, and work, and that is as real as the thwarting of it. 
 Note work. 
 In The Possessed  nobody does any work except Mrs Virginsky. 
 The sky clears in the childbirth sequence because of Shatov's sublime murmurings about the arrival of a new human being, but also because the midwife has her sleeves rolled up, because she is attacking a difficult and strenuous professional job, organizing essentials, masterminding the whole exercise, scolding Marie Shatov who allowed Shatov to get between her and the family in which she was a governess &bquo;with the egotistical object of marrying you, laughing at the distraught husband on his knees  unable either to bear the sound or block his ears before the birth; and when all is tidied up, &bquo;after some pleasant&ndash;es about &bquo;the happy couple'&equo; which were not without a touch of contempt and superciliousness, she went away as well satisfied as before.&equo; 
 She has good reason to be pleased. 
 She has done something, something on a different plane from making a toy church or pipping a social rival at the post or committing a mindless atrocity. 
 Her actions are unquestionably deedy; they bear no theoretical burden, unlike Kirillov's suicide; they run deeper &mdash; while she is on the job &mdash; than the paper person in her, and they make a rigid, final opposing of the profane midwife and the God-seeking husband academic and quite inadequate to the novel. 
 Nor does it get us anywhere to learn from Anna Dostoevsky's Memoirs  that the story of the frantic Shatov, where phrasing seems inevitable and images unsought &mdash; it doesn't help to be told by the novelist's widow that these flawless pages lean heavily on his own behaviour while their first child was being born. 
 It's all a question of what a writer can use, what the work in hand will let him use. 
 For example, there's a minor character in The Possessed , a quarrelsome eccentric lady, and she believes Lake Geneva gives people toothache. 
 Exactly right &mdash; for her. 
 So it produces an odd sensation to learn, again from Anna, that this superstition was in fact Dostoevsky's. 
 He also goes in for creative self-plundering by way of rhetorical and dialectical self-parody. 
 At the f&ecirc;te Stepan Verkhovensky, the man of the 1840s, makes a speech arguing that Shakespeare matters more than boots, and Raphael more than petroleum; whipping himself up in his peroration to declare that mankind can get on without bread but not without beauty. 
 This is another instance of the novelist promoting his dearest values by stealth. 
 Stepan's aesthetic convictions are Dostoevsky's, and Stepan's speech is an hysterical, summarizing take-off of Dostoevsky's journalism, itself no model of temperateness. 
 The narrative maximizes  Stepan's vulnerability, perching him on a platform amid the malcontents and troublemakers and the much larger number of those humble, obscure people who are enduring more or less passively the chaos of the f&ecirc;te. 
 He is holding forth about beauty to an audience which has been short-changed over food and drink and entertainment. 
 Therefore he is asking for trouble, and he receives it suddenly and in full measure, above the groundswell of heckling, at the hands of a divinity student who reminds him at the top of his voice about Fedka, a dangerous escaped convict now roaming &bquo;our town&equo; and originally a serf of Stepan's whom he sold into military service to pay a gambling debt: 
 &bquo;If you had not lost him at cards, would he have got into prison? 
 Tell me, please. 
 Would he be murdering people now in his struggle for existence? 
 What do you say to that, Mr Aesthete?' 
 A knock-down blow to the beauty-before-bread man. 
 But far from the end of him. 
 He picks himself up and declares about Fedka, later in the novel, &bquo;I suffered for ten years  on his account, more than he suffered as a soldier, and &mdash; and I'll give him my purse.&equo; 
 Selling was more painful than being sold, a variant of this hurts me more than it hurts you and a comic resourcefulness worthy of Falstaff in his &bquo;let him kill the next Percy himself&equo; vein. 
 But there the likeness ends. 
 Stepan Verkhovensky is prissy, frenchified, very feminine though not at all homosexual. 
 On the one hand, &bquo;My friend, I have discovered something awful: je suis un ordinary hanger-on, et rien de plus!  
 Mais r-r-rien de plus !&equo;; and on the other, and also out of his own mouth, &bquo;sponging has never been the guiding principle of my actions. 
 It just happened like that.&equo; 
 It did. 
 Stepan Trofimovich Verkhovensky is the most  suggestive of all Dostoevsky's accidental men, and it is fitting that the phrase itself should never be used of or by him. 
 He lives and breathes fortuity. 
 Profoundly yet lightly and yet again oh so generously imagined, he turns the novel's transpersonal unsteadiness to joy for us and sheer astonishment, and its cancer-growth of rumour to life's health through art's freedom. 
 The thought of Dostoevsky fostering, however stealthily, his dearest values, through Stepan on beauty, as through Shatov on new life, must be entertained in the context of the journalistic piece on Dobrolyubov: 
 You must not prescribe aims and preferences for art. 
 Why prescribe anything for it&hellip;? 
 It will never get lost or lose its way. 
 It was always true to reality and always walked in line with man's progress and development. 
 The ideal of beauty and normality cannot perish in a healthy society; and for this reason you ought to let art go its own way ad be confident that it will not go astray&hellip; 
 A single ma cannot divine fully the eternal and universal ideal, were he Shakespeare himself, ad therefore he cannot prescribe either the ways or the aims for art. 
 The Possessed  looked for a long time like losing its way, and Dostoevsky would surely concede that in so far as the design was, to use his own word, tendentious, this was bound to be so. 
 And yet a novel doesn't write itself, even if some of the very greatest ones appear to; it is written by a man with &bquo;aims and preferences&equo;. 
 But these just happen to be his, he can't &bquo;prescribe&equo; them &bquo;for art&equo;; what he wants to say must come to terms with what the form allows him; art refuses to be imposed upon, to be dictated to, and Dostoevsky's dictum will stand. 
 (vii) 
 Perhaps the most remarkable entry in the Possessed  notebooks is the one which directly opposes Stavrogin and Stepan Verkhovensky. 
 The narrative tone &bquo; which will save everything &equo; consists in &bquo;not explaining&equo; Stavrogin but projecting him &bquo;through the action&equo;, and equally (and on the contrary) it consists in presenting Stepan &bquo; always with explanations &equo;. 
  This belongs to the last days of 1870, more than a year after the murder in the park. 
 It signals the transformation of the large, lucid Great Sinner into the man who is beyond definition and self-definition, beyond calling himself bored, and whose actions &mdash; whether he is biting an ear or enduring a punch in the face or hanging by a well-soaped rope &mdash; explain  nothing and nobody. 
 A sort of paring-down: in my analysis a surrender of the crisis-and-clarity urge, and an unloading of all the consecutions of theory upon others, principally Kirillov and Shatov. 
 And conversely, the same notebook entry celebrates the rounding-out of a comic conception miles away from the original, historic Granovsky, scarcely less free than Dostoevsky's ideal of art and lying too deep for tears. 
 &bquo;He, too, saw through me; I mean he clearly perceived that I saw through him&hellip; 
 &equo; Stepan and &bquo;I&equo;, his young friend, are locked in such mutualities throughout. 
 &bquo;We&equo; are both characters inside the provincial-chronicle box, the framed narrative without a frame narrator, and out of this enclosure liberty proceeds. 
 Stepan reverses the news-from-Peshawar standpoint of the novel by wondering what &bquo;they&equo;, those powerful officials in the metropolis, are thinking about &bquo;us&equo; and most especially about himself; the picture of Stepan Trofimovich Verkhovensky as a marked man because of the liberal views he held and very faintly expressed long ago, both frightens him and feeds his self-importance. 
 So that when, in an access of zeal, von Lemke has Stepan's house raided and some old-fashioned radical literature removed, the narrator finds him &bquo;in a surprising condition: upset and in great agitation, but at the same time unquestionably triumphant&equo;. 
 A manuscript draft of this passage survives, and in the draft the narrating &bquo;I&equo; remarks the strange clash of Stepan's emotions. 
 The final text leaves this clash alone, free to speak for itself in a world where the reader believes he understands Stepan better than the narrator does. 
 Still not satisfied with the delicious idea of a soldier taking the doubtful reading matter away in a wheelbarrow, Dostoevsky adds, in Stepan's reportage, &bquo;and covered it with an apron; oui ,  c'est cela , an apron&equo; &mdash; as if in the eyes of Stepan there was something specially affronting or sinister, anyhow notable, about the apron. 
 Relatively weak description of the &bquo;he was very glad of my arrival&equo; sort is cut, and we are left with the histrionic handclasp of Stepan Verkhovensky the actor manqu&eacute;  whom no reader of The Possessed  will ever forget. 
 He imagines he is going to be arrested and whisked off to Siberia. 
 After two fumbled attempts Dostoevsky lands with a leap upon &bquo; Il faut &ecirc;tre pr&ecirc;t, voyez-vous &equo; &mdash; he gave me a meaningful look &mdash; &bquo; chague moment  &mdash; they may come and take me, and phew! &mdash; a man has disappeared!&equo; 
 In the draft he has hidden thirty-five roubles inside a slit in his frock-coat pocket. 
 The final text substitutes waistcoat for frock-coat &mdash; &bquo;I don't think they'll get as far as taking my waistcoat off&equo; &mdash; even better for the pampered softy with his vein of oldwomanish guile. 
 And here the manuscript fragment ends, so we can't tell how much work lies behind such simple touches as Stepan's fear that &bquo;they&equo; will flog him. 
 The narrator objects that he has done nothing. 
 &bquo;All the worse,&equo; replies Stepan. 
 &bquo;They will find out I've done nothing and flog me for it.&equo; 
 Nor can it be denied that he has done nothing. 
 Nor, unfading in our mind's eye, will this hanger-on and fantasist and self-dramatizer ever do anything, though it's difficult to say so without a chilling, denaturing hint of analytics. 
 Dostoevsky owed a lot to Moli&egrave;re who is to be met in the notebooks but not to be pinned down in the major fiction. 
 While it's true that nobody does any work in The Possessed  except delivering babies, and true also that Stepan Verkhovensky flowers into a veritable presiding genius of sloth in the guise of footling bustle, nevertheless the reader's heart is not with Mrs Stavrogin, Stepan's patroness, when she hisses at him on his deathbed &bquo;you futile, futile, ignoble, chickenhearted, always, always futile man&equo;. 
 The reader refuses to let it rest at that. 
 He has been with &bquo;our old friend&equo; too long. 
 It's not the severity that worries him but his inability to  universalize the verdict and therefore take it to himself as he can take &bquo;Vous l'avez voulu, Georges Dandin,&equo; the thing of Moli&egrave;re's Dostoevsky liked to quote. 
 Stepan's own pronouncement, again on his deathbed, strikes more devastatingly deep than Mrs Stavrogin's, and yet the reader inclines his head as to an act of natural justice. 
 &bquo;My friend, all my life I have been lying. 
 Even when I spoke the truth. 
 Never did I speak for the truth's sake but for my own&hellip; &bquo; 
 One judges better of others than that, but can only hope better of oneself. 
 And in observing and judging Stepan Verkhovensky one becomes aware that the novelist's selfadmonition to present him &bquo; always with explanations &equo; has been both obeyed and transcended. 
 Details of background, opinions, foibles, are lavished on him as on nobody else. 
 His &bquo;peculiar gloating obsequious humour&equo;, his &bquo;sort of capricious self-satisfaction&equo; lurking in the very midst of &bquo;plaintive protestations&equo;, are described and pondered. 
 We learn that &bquo;he began to pay great attention to his dreams&equo;. 
 We learn it, though, as a sign of his going to seed &mdash; and we wonder. 
 We pause and wonder. 
 We recall that the narrator is a young man. 
 Why going to seed? 
 Leave our friend alone! 
 Don't presume! 
 Why shouldn't he just be getting old? 
 (vii) 
 Dostoevsky owed even more to Cervantes than to Moli&egrave;re, and here again, as in his relations with Shakespeare and Pushkin, it's a visitation with no very palpable memorial. 
 An account of how Dostoevsky extrapolated his lifelong leading themes of somebody to be and somewhere to go from Cervantes's huge rhetoric of quest, would be doomed from the start. 
 In fact it is only with Mr Golyadkin very near the beginning of his writing career, and with Stepan Verkhovensky towards the end, that Quixotic features of courtesy and romance become prominent. 
 Mr Golyadkin's response to the elopement letter was a two-in-one attempt to assume a  chivalric role and reach a lovers' destination. 
 Stepan Verkhovensky has only himself to elope with, and it remains an open question whether he will go on enduring the indignities of his hanger-on position, or cut and run, somehow, somewhere. 
 He remarks to his son that unhappiness is just as necessary to mankind as happiness &mdash; one of those cherished convictions of Dostoevsky that get slipped in when our attention is elsewhere. 
 But, as Peter immediately tells his father, this is just the sort of bon mot  to expect from an idler who is being kept in the lap of luxury. 
 Such taunts hurt. 
 They are bound to come to something, Stepan confides to the narrator; &bquo;usually in our world things come to nothing, but this will end in something, it's bound to, it's bound to!&equo; 
 Stepan crystallizes this &bquo;something&equo; in Golyadkin and Quixote terms when he tells Mrs Stavrogin &bquo;You have always despised me; but I will end like a knight faithful to my lady, for your good opinion has always been dearer to me than anything.&equo; 
 Also, in the same passage, he says he is going to pack his bag &mdash; &bquo;my pauper's bag&equo; &mdash; and end up either dead of starvation in a ditch or earning his keep as a tutor in some merchant's house. 
 This might seem to be moving away from Golyadkin, but in point of tone The Double  and The Possessed  draw closest to one another, and to Don Quixote , in the ludicrous materialities of preparation, and in their juxtaposing of very particular odds and ends with an airy universality which in lesser hands would be emptiness. 
 Mr Golyadkin has mustered socks, shirts, shirtfronts, flannel vests, uniform, spare trousers, sheets, blankets, pillows, and a featherbed; but he also tells his servant &bquo;And now, my friend, I am going away. 
 My dear chap, a different path lies before each man and no one of us can tell what road he may chance to follow.&equo; 
 Stepan Verkhovensky kits himself up with umbrella, travelling-bag, walking stick, broad-brimmed hat, belted overcoat and top-boots like a hussar's; and &mdash; Quixote overlaid for English readers by Pickwick, the White Knight, Mr Toad &mdash; he talks the language of &bquo;high adventure&equo; and the open road: &bquo;there's a great idea in the open road too!&equo;  
 But he avoids the language of destination. 
 Whereas Mr Golyadkin, incidentally mad, swaddled in a dream of silk ladders and Spanish serenades, aims for Schiller's happy-everafter hut on the shore, Stepan understands he has nowhere to go: &bquo;to order post-horses one must at least know where one is going. 
 But herein lay his greatest distress at this moment: he was utterly unable to name and fix on a place.&equo; 
 And so he sets off on foot, aiming nowhere. 
 Even to have imagined a destination would have been to raise the question, why this place rather than that? 
 Therefore he keeps walking, &bquo;thinking of nothing so long as he could refrain from thinking&equo;. 
 Golyadkin country. 
 Our novelist's intellectual humour is asserting itself beneath the narrative. 
 And what narrative! 
 Narrative of Conradian nobility at this suspended moment while Stepan Verkhovensky's road stretches mile upon mile ahead of him &bquo;like a man's life, a man's dream&equo;. 
 There's a quick glance between novelist and reader in that &bquo;dream&equo;. 
 Stepan is falling ill without knowing it; his unspoken, unimagined destination is delirium and death. 
 Chance brings the accidental man up short at a village across a lake from a place called Spasov. 
 The root of that word is &bquo;save&equo;. 
 Chance also throws him together with the itinerant bible-selling woman who was outraged by the hooligans of &bquo;our town&equo; and whom Stepan now, just once, calls his &bquo;saviour&equo; ( spasitelnitsa ). 
 She reads him the story of the Gadarene swine, the novel's Epigraph. 
 Also the Revelation passage on the lukewarm spiritual state. 
 Thus Dostoevsky rescues the disease of indifference from the abandoned &bquo;At Tikhon's&equo; chapter, but also eases its throttling normative grip. 
 In fact there is no grip, it's all drift, in this sequence, as illness brings back Stepan's childhood Church Slavonic, mixed up with Quixotic politesse  and flagrant falsifying of his own past, and cant about the Russian soul. 
 And as to Spasov and being saved &mdash; &bquo; Il me semble que tout le monde va &agrave; Spassof &equo; &mdash; there is still some comic devillife in him as he quotes the Saviour against his bible-selling saviour because she is taking thought for the morrow, and as he turns the gospel on its head with &bquo;Happiness doesn't pay me because I start at once forgiving all my enemies.&equo;  
 That's no way to set about being saved, so an entirely solemn reader would be bound to think. 
 But, in terms of the tragicomical life of the book, such a reader is himself a fiction, and an empty one. 
 We are all bound for Spasov, and all the fun as well as the sorrow lies in aiming that way. 
 Arrival has no reality in the updated, transposed Quixotic journeying whereby the forward-tilting existential present of The Double  is rephrased in The Possessed . 
 Parajournalist and apocalyptic naturalist through and through, the novelist records anxious speculation in &bquo;our town&equo; as to whether the seventy representatives of the nine hundred workmen at the Spigulin factory are too many to constitute a delegation. 
 We might be reading this morning's dreary inconclusive state of play over secondary picketing. 
 And the sense in which there is no arriving in The Possessed  is very like that in which there is no reading tomorrow's newspaper. 
 We can only imagine it. 
 When we do we tend to imagine outcomes. 
 For The Possessed , outcomes (including Dostoevsky's healed man at the feet of Jesus) are consoling myths. 
 Never trust the artist, trust the tale. 
 And the tale images tomorrow's newspaper as empty or thwarted futurity. 
 I would add open futurity, the future of the open road. 
 After the dying Stepan Verkhovensky has taken the sacrament he says &bquo;however, tomorrow &mdash; Tomorrow we shall all set off.&equo; 
 Certainly we are all on the move, if only mentally, and perhaps the open road of Stepan's &bquo;gentle and unresentful heart&equo; will see him to Spasov before nous les autres . 
 But in its very nature a possibility is not an outcome.  
 Electronics World + Wireless World September 1991 &pound;1.95 
 Computing 
 What's in a graphics file? 
 Hypothesis 
 Why power lines kill 
 Circuits 
 The very best from the US 
 Development 
 Working with DSP 
 Design 
 Scientific magnetometer 
 Contents 
 Features 
 726 Cover: Fluxgate magnetometery 
 Measuring the directions of the Earth's magnetic field provides the basis of an electronic compass while the strength of the field says much about solar activity &mdash; a factor important to HF radio propagation. 
 Richard Noble describes a science quality instrument. 
 738 What's in a graphics file? 
 David Bacon looks into the proliferation of complex graphical file formats and explains their structure and how information is transferred. 
 743 Review &mdash; Table Curve 
 Manually adding best-fit curves to data plots can be laborious and prone to error. 
 But Don Bradbury reviews TableCurve and finds it has all the right lines. 
 747 PC Review: Hard to resist? 
 Rescalc 2.0 resistor calculator has been much improved since its original release. 
 Ben Duncan analyses the differences. 
 759 A toolbox for DSP engineering 
 Allen Brown looks at how to choose the best DSP engineering tools for application in a fast-developing market. 
 764 Lessons in applied science 
 Some of the most exciting and practical research in electrical, electronic, fibre optic and communications engineering is being carried out at London's Kings College. 
 Andy Gothard reports. 
 774 Killing fields: a cause? 
 Living close to overhead power lines may increase the risk of cancer. 
 Harold Aspden hypothesis on cyclotron resonance as the cause. 
 777 Waves, wind and the Teredo worm 
 Plans for global communications now often seem to rest on the semantics of international standards. 
 Greg Grant looks back to the Victorian adventurers who conquered nature to put a communication girdle around the world. 
 788 Who designed this? 
 How close is the innovative audio circuit patented by Matsushita in 1983 to the Class S amplifier designed by Aubrey Sandman in 1982. 
 Dr Sandman presents his case. 
 Regulars 
 715 Comment 
 Analogue changes 
 716 Update 
 Getting the measure of superconducting buckyballs, is &pound;420m enough for EC R&amp;D? 
 720 Research notes 
 Discovering new galaxies, superconducting in a perfect world, the coldest place on earth, fast SiGe devices, high speed low power flip-flop, and did you know&hellip; 
 743 Letters 
 Cuk vs Buck, watching HDTV, whither Class D, Ferrite aerial response, telepointless?, any old valves, light hearted. 
 748 Circuits, Systems and designs 
 In the first of a regular series, we bring together some of the practical designs and circuits which first appeared in the US magazine EDN. 
 753 Circuit ideas 
 Sound sampler filter, multimeter as frequency meter, sine waves from 4046 VCO, motion direction detector, D-to-A converter current booster, speech compressor. 
 771 Applications 
 Amplifier for microphones and moving-coil pick-ups, low-power frequency synthesizer, power mos electronic ignition, applying multipliers. 
 783 New products 
 EW  + WW  's round-up of all that's new in electronics. 
 794 Broadcast 
 Could RDS change the shape of broadcasting? 
 Starting next month: Technical software discount purchase scheme. 
 See page 776 for details 
 In next month's issue. 
 John Linsley Hood on filters. 
 JLH provides the definitive guide to audio filter design. 
 Change in publishing date 
 Starting with the October issue, Electronics World  + Wireless World  will appear about week later than before. 
 The publishing date will be last Thursday in the month. 
 Hence the October issue will appear on September 26.  
 Comment 
 Analogue changes 
 Editor Frank Ogden 081&ndash;661 3128 
 Deputy Editor Jonathan Campbell 081&ndash;661 8638 
 Design &amp; Production Alan Kerr 
 Editorial Administration Lindsey Gardner 081&ndash;661 3614 
 Advertisement Manager Jan Thorpe 081&ndash;661 3130 
 Display Sales Manager Shona Finnie 081&ndash;661 8640 
 Advertising Administration Kathy Lambart 081&ndash;661 3139 
 Advertising Production Neil Thompson 081&ndash;661 8675 
 Publisher Rob Marcus 081&ndash;661 3930 
 Facsimile 081&ndash;661 8956 
 You can't please all of the people all of the time. 
 And there are a few people who won't be pleased whatever you do. 
 Thus when we present an article on structured programming electronics, a proportion of our readership will relate the subject to their own interests while an equally large cross-section will simple regard its inclusion as a displacement of their own preoccupation. 
 We can't win but we must keep trying. 
 Although the electronics industry has changed greatly, possible the greatest change is that very little component level manufacture is done in this country. 
 In general, designers no longer work with a heap of transistors and a hot soldering iron. 
 Systems are build from board level products designed and manufactured somewhere in the Far East. 
 Their assembly into something functional requires the subtle application of a screwdriver allied with a complete grasp of the operating software. 
 Indeed, there is very little in the real world of electronics which doesn't involve digital techniques and computing. 
 DSP seems a particularly important topic since it represents the doorway between the way that people do things and the tasks which they expect electronics to do. 
 One could argue that digital technology isn't the only way to solve a particular circuit problem; a nifty bit of design work with a couple of op-amps plus a few Rs and Cs can replace a complex digital filter system. 
 Furthermore, it can be done in a language with which many EW  + WW  readers will be totally familiar. 
 However, the same little collection of components wouldn't allow a robot arm to interpret the signals from a CCD sensor in a manner which allows the arm to be placed reliably alongside an item on a conveyor belt. 
 And if the robot control function requires a signal filter, it would seem sensible to incorporate the filter block as part of the DSP recognition software rather than reach for discrete analogue components. 
 The same arguments for use of digital electronics apply equally to communications systems, test and measurement, broadcasting and consumer electronics. 
 Indeed, if we as a magazine were to reflect accurately the role of &bquo;traditional&equo; design relative to its actual usage, we might manage about one page per issue. 
 It should be said that we have no intention of implementing this ratio. 
 Analogue design remains important because it accommodates and defines the basic building blocks of electronics. 
 It is very hard to design a house if you don't know the shape of the bricks. 
 While there are a few things in digital technology which have no possible representation in analogue form &mdash; infinite impulse response filters are a good example &mdash; most digital blocks derive their shape from the original analogue function. 
 There is another aspect. 
 Although the changing voltage on a line connecting a pair of gates may be classed as digital, it remains an electrical signal like any other. 
 A design engineer might well require an appreciation of transmission line theory to ensure that the two connect together without data corruption. 
 The same goes for the avoidance of earth loops, common mode inductance nodes and all the other pitfalls. 
 We will continue to accord analogue design the importance which it deserves. 
 But we must also acknowledge the significance of computing and digital design. 
 EW  + WW  has enjoyed an illustrious past by presenting the important technology of the day. 
 We must continue to do this if we are to safeguard its future reputation. 
  Frank Ogden   
 Reed Business Publishing Group 
 REGULARS 
 UPDATE 
 EC announces &pound;420m for R&amp;D &mdash; but is it enough? 
 Research grants worth &pound;420million have been announced by the EC, revealing its plans for the third set of Esprit projects. 
 But it may not be enough according to some industry commentators. 
 US-based companies will play a major role for the first time, but the Japanese are not expected to be heavily involved. 
 Main change introduced in the Esprit III programme is a new category of research called the Open Microsystems Initiative (OMI). 
 Its aim is to establish R&amp;D projects so as to: &bquo;Make the European Industries competitive in the design, manufacture and use of future integrated circuit microsystems,&equo; according to the EC's documents inviting companies to take part. 
 US companies are expected to be involved in the research, backed by &pound;65 million of EC money. 
 Rosalie Zobel, deputy director of the Esprit projects told EW  + WW  that Mips Computer Systems, Sun, Motorola, DEC and IBM have all been invited to preliminary OMI meetings. 
 Motorola is interested in joining some of the projects, according to Barry Waite, general manager of the company's European semiconductor group. 
 But he questions whether the programme as a whole is too ambitious. 
 &bquo;I'm very sceptical whether the grand aims can be met in that time scale with that amount of money,&equo; he says. 
 Zobel said that there had been no approaches from Japanese companies wanting to work in the OMI. 
 The Esprit III work programme, which is backed by 600 million ECU, is split into six sections. 
 As well as the OMI and microelectronics research, there will information systems and advanced home systems projects. 
  Rob Causey  
 Unappealing face of Blumlein biography 
 Francis Thomson, the man who for nearly twenty years has been promising to write a biography of Alan Blumlein is once again appealing for more material on Blumlein. 
 Thomson's latest letters to the media very, but in some he explains the decades of delay with a puzzling tale of his attempts to &bquo;shield the Blumleins from the belated discovery that a person close to them had supplied me with letters&hellip; stolen from the late Mr A K Van Warrington&equo;. 
 As before, Thomson, who has also put out calls for biographical material on other subjects, including S G Brown, signs himself a Member of the Institution of Electrical Engineers, helping establish credibility with editors unaware of the fact that he started collecting original papers in 1972. 
 But he has published nothing, refuses third parties access to his collection and will not catalogue what he has. 
 Although some editors have treated the &bquo;biographer's&equo; latest call with suspicion and either ignored his request or published it with qualification (eg Hi-Fi News , other have simply regurgitated Thomson's plea for &bquo;letters, notes and photographs&equo;. 
 Unqualified appeals have already been published in Television  (journal of the Royal Television Society), Image Technology , (journal of the BKSTS), Nature  and the AES  Journal. 
 Charlie Chester obligingly broadcast the appeal on Radio 2. 
 The IEE has tried to negotiate with Thomson, offering help with writing and publishing his biography in time for the fiftieth anniversary of Blumlein's death in June 1992. 
 But Thomson has rejected the IEE's offers and it now looks certain that the anniversary will be missed. 
 Some members want the IEE now to use more muscle, with threats of expulsion from the Institution, if Thomson does not at least provide a catalogue of the material he has collected and give rock solid guarantees on its long term security, after his death. 
  Barry Fox   
 Preparing to test an underwater optical fibre cable joint on the 600kV DC test set at the new high voltage laboratory at Southampton University. 
 Photo STC Submarine Systems 
 Superconducting buckyballs 
 A new method of producing very pure samples has allowed researchers at Los Alamos National Laboratory and UCLA to make two crucial measurements of superconducting compounds built with &bquo;buckyballs&equo;. 
 The compounds' responses to magnetic fields and pressure have boosted scientists' hopes that they will form the basis of practical superconducting. 
 Buckyballs, of buckminsterfullerene, are soccer-ball-shaped assemblages of 60 carbon atoms. 
 Earlier this year researchers learned that inserting a few atoms of potassium into a framework built of buckyball molecules makes the compound a superconductor: below a critical temperature of about 19 Kelvin &mdash; or 19 degrees above absolute zero &mdash; the material conducts electricity with no resistance. 
 The Los Alamos and UCLA researchers measured the critical magnetic fields of the material &mdash; which point to how useful the superconductor may be. 
 The researchers relied on the ability of the material to repel a magnetic field, a trademark of superconductors. 
 They cooled the sample below its critical temperature so it became superconducting, then applied an increasingly strong magnetic field. 
 At a certain field strength &mdash; the lower critical field &mdash; the magnetic field began to penetrate portions of the sample and so the sample was a mixture of superconducting and normal states. 
 At the upper critical field the magnetic field completely penetrated the sample and it reverted entirely to its normal state. 
 The upper critical field was estimated to be about 800,000 times stronger than the earth's magnetic field, advantageous for applications of the superconductor. 
 Researchers used the measurements to estimate the value of the critical current, or how much electricity the material can carry in its superconducting state. 
 &bquo;The critical current calculated is already higher than the critical current first reported for the high-temperature superconducting materials based on copper-oxide compounds,&equo; says George Gruner, director of UCLA's Solid State Science Centre. 
 Researchers have also measured the response of the superconducting properties of a potassium-doped buckyball compound to changes in pressure &mdash; one of the fundamental measurements of any new superconductor, as it sets immediate constraints on the theoretical interpretations of the material's behaviour. 
 Results showed that as pressure was increased, critical temperature of the material dropped dramatically, a behaviour opposite to that predicted. 
 In general, increasing the pressure on a material pushes atoms together, stiffening the lattice. 
 Under certain circumstances, this allows an electrical current to begin moving without resistance at a higher temperature, as found in the high-temperature copper-oxide superconductors. 
 In copper-oxide superconducting materials, this suggest that to raise the critical temperature you want to make the lattice smaller. 
 But the buckyball compounds' opposite behaviour suggest that researchers should pursue &bquo;negative pressure&equo;, created by inserting a larger atom into the lattice. 
 In fact doping the buckyball compound with rubidium &mdash; a larger atom than potassium &mdash; raises the critical temperature to nearly 30K. 
 Researchers at AT&amp;T Bell Laboratories reported the discovery of superconductivity in buckyball compounds at the American Chemical Society meeting in April. 
 But only a small portion of their material had superconducting properties. 
 The UCLA team has refined the method for manufacturing sample of potassium- and rubidium-doped buckyball compounds so that the entire sample is superconducting. 
 They believe that the measurements were possible because of the high quality of the samples prepared by the UCLA scientists. 
 Russia is hi-tech 
 There is no technology gap between the Soviet Union's and the West's electronic research activities. 
 But the country's production facilities lag the west by about ten years. 
 The assessment is made by analysts Instat, following a visit by Instat's European president, Malcolm Penn, to the Soviet Union in April to assess its technical capabilities. 
 His view is that what the Soviet Union has in small quantities is as good as the technology of the West, but that the country lacks the ability to turn out production volumes. 
 One facility visited, NPO &bquo;SVT&equo;, is developing a Mezaepiplanar cmos process using ferro-magnetic masks &mdash; giving the ability to make non-planar ICs without relying on photolithography. 
 Penn says that engineers have built chips on the outside of cylindrical substrates. 
 The masks hold the key to the technology. 
 They are made using precision alloys which are thermally matched to the temperature expansion characteristics of the substrate materials. 
 Each mask is pulled down onto the base, which can be variety of shapes, by a magnetic catcher. 
 Plasma etching and ion implantation techniques are then used to build up transistor structures, rather than diffusing them into the substrate material. 
 Various materials can be used as a base, such as silicon, gallium arsenide, germanium and some metals, cmos, bipolar and bi-cmos circuits have been built. 
 The features on the masks can vary in size between 10 and 0.2mm with the whole mask measuring up to 400 by 500mm. 
 They range from 0.01 to 0.5mm in thickness and are made from copper, nickel or iron-nickel alloy depending on the application. 
 By avoiding the use of some of the more active chemicals needed for photolithography, the Soviet scientists believe the process will reduce the environmental damage caused by chip fabs. 
 They hope to make between 10,000 and 100,000 chips a year using the equipment. 
  Rob Causey   
 The BBC is to shut down its shortwave broadcasting facility at Daventry. 
 The station, which also houses the longwave domestic service has been in continuous operation since 1925. 
 Shortwave broadcasting began from the site in 1932. 
 The photograph shows the station as it was in 1937; its appearance has changed little to the present day.  
 Euro-supercomputing boost 
 Europe's supercomputing industry has received a boost with unveiling by German company Parsytec of plans for a new range of parallel machines. 
 Parsytec intends to use the same basic design of a 1.6Gflop processing unit as a building block for systems executing up to 400Gflops. the largest computers on sale now can perform tens of Gflops. 
 Parsytec will sell the single processing unit, about the size of two briefcases, and larger computers made up of different configurations of the blocks. 
 &bquo;We set design goals to make a 400Gflop machine. 
 Then we broke it down into smaller components to set us scale it down.&equo; 
 said Francis Wray, head of product development. 
 The company has used a modified version of the design in its proposal for the European Teraflop initiative. 
 This is a project aimed at building a computer which can process one million floating point operations per second. 
 The systems will be built using Inmos' T9000 transputer. 
 Parsytec has received assurances from Inmos that it will be able to buy the transputer in large enough numbers to build the computers. 
 Each 1.6Gflops module, of Giga Cube, contains 18 T9000s. 16 for processing, one redundant device and one configuration controller. 
 If a failure occurs in one of the 16 on-line chips, the controller detects it and switches in the redundant chip. 
 The array of processors is linked using four of Inmos' C104 communications chips. 
 The Giga cubes each have their own cooling system. 
 Heatpipes draw energy away from the electronics and pass it into a cooling unit where either air or water is used to dissipate the heat. 
 Systems processing up to 50GflopS, with 16 Giga Cubes, can be cooled by air. 
 A water system and a lot of plumbing is needed for bigger machines. 
  Rob Causey  
 Digital TV connection 
 The European Eureka programme has brought together 32 organisations from 12 countries in a bid to develop the technology needed to bring all-digital TV to the home or office. 
 The Vadis project (video-audio digital interactive system) aims to develop coding techniques to compress digital TV signals by a factor of between 20 and 40 while retaining most of the original quality. 
 The compression will let digital audio-visual services be carried by terrestrial and satellite channels, telecommunications networks or digital storage devices. 
 Companies involved include Aspex Microsystems, the BBC, BT, Italtel, Philips, Olivetti, Siemens and Thomson-CSF. 
 UK attracts foreign money 
 Record numbers of overseas companies are investing in the UK, according to industry minister Edward Leigh. 
 In the year ending March 1991 he says there were 350 direct investment projects by foreign owned companies into the UK, recorded by the DTI's Invest in Britain Bureau. 
 Can Babbage help Science Museum balance books? 
 Charles Babbage's Difference Engine will form the centre-piece of a new gallery at the Science Museum next year &mdash; if fundraisers can find the &pound;4.5million needed to build the new show. 
 The working version of the machine, built to celebrate the bicentenary of the mathematician's birth, will be moved into the new Information Age gallery which will replace the current computer gallery. 
 The museum hopes to display and explain telecomms systems as well as the history of more traditional technology. 
 &bquo;We're at the final state of putting proposals together.&equo; 
 says Lynn Foster, the Science Museum's main fundraiser. 
 &bquo;We hope for support from telecomms as well as computer companies and users&equo;. 
 The museum believes that the fundraising will take about eight months. 
 Once the commitments are in place, it will then need to decide which exhibits its wants to build. 
 There are examples of the interactive displays in the current Babbage exhibition, which runs until 31st December. 
 UCM, a software house from Hove, has developed an animated video showing the workings of the Difference Engine No 2. 
  RC  
 Toshiba-IBM LCDs on-stream 
 Display Technologies, a Toshiba-IBM joint venture, has completed construction of its manufacturing plant in Himeji and has started production of large size, LCDs for computer terminals. 
 The plant produces 10.4-in (640 x 480 pixel) LCDs and will gradually add large size units. 
 The plant is said to be a state-of-the-art facility that forms transistors onto large glass substrates, in a class-100 clean room that has the similar level of air cleanliness to those used in the manufacture of LSI chips. 
 Total production management is coordinated using a cim system. 
 Superconducting gradiometer 
 Researchers at IBM TJ Watson research centre report the first high-temperature superconducting magnetic gradiometer to operate at liquid-nitrogen temperatures. 
 The ability to operate at these temperatures is advantageous, because liquid nitrogen is cheap and the devices need less thermal insulation. 
 Fabrication of the gradiometers &mdash; which measure magnetic gradients &mdash; relies on IBM's wet-etching process. 
 The technique depends on a highly selective etchant solution that etches patterns in the thin film of material used to insulate layers of superconductor in the thin films of material used to insulate layers of superconductor and stops when the superconducting is reached.  
 David Edward Hughes, whose experiments with the &bquo;printing telegraph&equo; led to the development of an efficient microphone during the 1870's, has been honoured with a plaque at his former lodgings. 
 Exactly how long Hughes lived at 94 Portland Street, London, is uncertain but the first experiments which led to the development of the microphone were conducted here during 1878&ndash;80. 
 The house is prominently sited on the corner of Portland Street and Langham Street. 
 RESEARCH NOTES 
 New galaxy throws bright light on quasar formation 
 A British-led team of astronomers has discovered a new very-distant galaxy which is radiating three hundred million million times as much energy as the sun. 
 The galaxy, known as IRAS F10214+4724, is in fact the most luminous object ever found in the universe. 
 But it is not radiating its energy at visible wavelengths like previous contenders for the title, all of which were quasars (quasi-stellar objects). 
 Instead it is a massive cloud of dust, radiating 99% of its energy at far infrared wavelengths. 
 Astronomers believe ( Nature  Vol 31 No 6329) that it is either a massive galaxy in the process of formation or a quasar buried within a dust cloud. 
 The team, led by Professor Michael Rowan-Robinson of Queen Mary and Westfield College, University of London, includes astronomers from Cambridge, Oxford and Durham Universities as well as QMW, and from Caltech, Pasadena and Charlottesville, Virginia. 
 They discovered the object with the UK's 4.2m William Herchel telescope (WHT) on La Palma in The Canaries on the last night of a 40-night observing campaign, studying very faint sources detected by the IRAS infrared astronomical satellite with optical ground-based telescopes. 
 Subsequently the team obtained images of this mysterious object with the 200in Mt Palomar telescope and the WHT. 
 It was slightly fuzzy and presumably a distant galaxy. 
 The spectrum was that of a very distant galaxy with redshift of 2.3 (spectral lines shifted in wavelengths towards the red by 230%). 
 Such information implies a distance of 16 thousand million light years and that the galaxy is seen at a time 83% of the way back to the Big Bang. 
 Previous high redshift for a galaxy or quasar discovery by IRAS was 0.4. 
 The powerhouse responsible for heating up the dust is hidden from view but the team believes it is either a quasar or a massive burst of star formation. 
 In the latter case we would almost certainly be seeing the galaxy during its formation phase. 
 Either way it is a unique object and will shed light on how galaxies and quasars form. 
 Superconducting in a perfect world 
 If you were to draw up the specification for the ideal material for electronic engineering, I guess it would be something combining the properties of the perfect conductor, the perfect insulator and the ideal semiconductor. 
 Such a material does not of course exist&hellip; or does it? 
 A paper recently published by Jacek Baranowski et al  working at the University of California, Berkeley and the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory ( Phys Rev Lett , Vol 66 no 23) describes a new form of gallium arsenide that will superconduct at a temperature of 10K. 
 LT-GaAs as it is called, is made by molecular beam epitaxy (MBE) at the relatively low temperature of 200&deg;C. 
 Chemically it contains about 1.5% excess arsenic in the form of crystal defects. 
 At ordinary temperatures the material is quite conductive. 
 But below 10K it is possible by means of field-modulated microwave absorption (FMMA) and the Meissner effect (magnetic field expulsion) to demonstrate clearly the existence of a hitherto unknown superconducting phase within the material. 
 Baranowski and his team attribute this to a layered arrangement of atoms &mdash; visible in the electron microscope. 
 In addition to this superconducting phase, and the well known semiconducting properties of GaAs, LT-GaAs can be made into a well-nigh perfect insulator by annealing at 500&deg;C so that As-rich material precipitates out. 
 Such insulating GaAs can be used for gate isolation in metal-insulator-semiconductor fets and, because of its short minority-carrier lifetime, in high speed optoelectronic devices. 
 With such a range of useful properties, the Berkeley team envisage as chip in which insulating, semiconducting and superconducting components are fabricated together, based on epitaxial layers. 
 This, they say, might result in completely new directions for device technology including epitaxial superconducting interconnects, junctions and switches. 
 Obviously there is a price to be paid in holding the liquid helium temperatures. 
 But the group is convinced that it is only a matter of time before someone discovers superconducting semiconductors that will work at the economically viable temperatures of liquid nitrogen. 
 Optical image of IRAS F10214+4724 taken with the Mt Palomar telescope. 
 Ellipse shows the estimated location of the infrared source. 
 F if the high redshift galaxy. 
 Colorado: absolutely the coldest place on earth 
 American scientist working for the Astrophysics Institute at the University of Colorado in Boulder have created the lowest temperature ever recorded &mdash; one millionth of a degree above absolute zero. 
 This is approaching the temperature below which theoreticians expect atoms to fuse together in a new kind of matter. 
 When things are cooled to within a few degrees of absolute zero &mdash; minus 273.16&deg;C &mdash; strange things happen. 
 Metals and some new ceramics lose their electrical resistance completely. 
 In addition to superconducting, another spectacular low temperature phenomenon called superfluidity occurs. 
 At about 2&deg; above absolute zero &mdash; 2K &mdash; liquid helium develops the peculiar ability to flow through tiny holes without friction. 
 Small wonder that scientists are searching for every lower temperatures, nearer still to absolute zero, where even more mysterious effects may be waiting. 
 But it is no easy task. 
 Conventional refrigeration, where heat is removed by evaporation, will work down to about 1K. 
 Below that, different approaches are necessary, until recently involving extracting energy from atoms using magnetic fields. 
 Heat is nothing more than energy of atoms in motion, so if you can slow down atoms, you are in effect cooling them. 
 Within the last few years, physicists have come within a few thousandths of a degree of absolute zero using a new technique called laser entrapment. 
 The idea is to hit atoms head-on with laser beams, slowing them down. 
 Laser beams consist of photons which, though small by atomic standards, have a cumulative inertial effect, Dr Carl Wieman of the University of Colorado, who heads one research group, says that cooling an atom with a laser beam is like trying to slow down movement of a heavy object by bombarding it with ping-pong balls. 
 In practice it is quite complex because you need at least six lasers to trap a clump of atoms; the lasers also have to be tuned to the natural movement of the atoms. 
 Otherwise the effect is to add heat energy rather than remove it. 
 What Wieman has done &mdash; as well as reaching the lowest temperature on record &mdash; is to simplify what has been an immensely complex piece of laboratory apparatus. 
 Not only has the essential large vacuum cell been reduced to a small glass cell, but Wieman has also been able to replace gas lasers with solid state devices. 
 In fact what he has been using are exactly the same as the cheap mass-produced lasers used in CD machines. 
 They cost around &pound;50 a piece, less than a tenth the cost of the gas lasers. 
 Wieman told EW  + WW  that the great benefit if this simplification is that it will enable a greater number of laboratories to participate in low temperature research and discover more and more bizarre properties of matter. 
 Most exciting is creation of a &bquo;Bose-Einstein&equo; condensate &mdash; a weird state of matter, predicted by Einstein and the Indian physicist Satyendranath Bose, where individual atoms lose their identity and merge into a kind of atomic soup. 
 When asked what temperature at which this transformation would occur, Wieman commented: &bquo;It depends on the density and the number of atoms in your trap, the more atoms you've got, the higher the temperature. 
 We're at one millionth of a degree above absolute zero. 
 We need to get between ten and a hundred times lower&equo;. 
 Design opens up fast SiGe devices 
 Researchers at IBM have built an experimental p-channel mosfet that uses both silicon and germanium and delivers high performance. 
 Scientist believe the device &mdash; which makes use of novel design and new materials &mdash; could lay the ground for a promising future for silicon-germanium transistors in future chips. 
 Details of the improved mosfet were revealed at a recent VLSI technology symposium in Japan. 
 The mosfet is less than 1&micro;m wide and operates at liquid nitrogen temperatures (-196&deg;C). 
 Improved performance is obtained through building an ultra-thin channel of silicon-germanium alloy under the silicon surface of the mosfet to restrain mobility of the charges carrying current through the device. 
 The germanium layer confines the charges just under the skin, preventing them from bumping into the surface and scattering from their designated path through the transistor. 
 Researchers built the channel so that it is free of dopants, stopping the charges from bumping into impurity atoms along the way. 
 Instead, a layer of doped silicon is placed directly underneath the channel. 
 This dopant layer sets the voltage at which the transistor turns off and on. 
 As a result, the mobility of the charges as they travel through the transistor is twice as good as any similar, submicron p-channel mosfet transistor yet built. 
 A p-channel transistor, relying on hole mobility, is usually slower than an n-channel device. 
 The goal is to use the improved p-channel transistor to boost the speed of complementary circuits where both types of transistors work together. 
 Complementary metal oxide semiconductor (cmos) circuits save power, allowing designers to put more circuits on a chip. 
 Dr Carl Wieman (left) and his team has opened up research into low temperature physics. 
 Tests confirm high speed/low power flip-flop 
 A team at the Fraunhofer Institute for Applied Solid State Physics in Freiberg has reported a breakthrough in high speed frequency dividers. 
 What the German group has done ( Electronics Letters , Vol 27 No 13) is to create a static master-slave flip-flop which operates at 14GHz but has a dissipation of less than 35mW. 
 Until now, there has been a choice between high speed (22GHz) together with high dissipation (&gt;0.5W per flip-flop) or medium speed (9&ndash;12GHz) with medium dissipation (&lt;180mW). 
 The development, they say, will make it easier to integrate high-speed prescalers onto counter circuits, multiplexing circuits and other multi-function chips used in communications. 
 The circuit comprises two D-latches, each constructed in source-coupled fet logic. 
 (In the diagram, E indicates enhancement mode and D depletion mode fets.) 
 To achieve the extremely low power consumption, D-fet active loads were used with gate widths of only 5mm. 
 This ensured that pumped charge on the chip was kept to a minimum, helped by a reduction in wiring capacitance. 
 On test with no load the divider chip consumed only 19mA at a supply voltage of 1.8V. 
 Maximum operating frequency was 14.2GHz at which the minimum required input power was 8.3dBm. 
 At lower frequencies (&lt;10GHz), the flip-flop toggled reliably will less than &mdash; 15dBm on the input. 
 Psst &mdash; want to know a secret? 
 Did you know that upgrades to the EW  + WW  office software mean that in future it will be possible to print three-dimensional graphics and stereoscopic photographs? 
 Unfortunately, I'll have to come clean; that story is only a rumour. 
 But while some rumours are harmless &mdash; like the persistent one about certain restaurants serving up dead dogs &mdash; others can be very damaging for businesses, especially in the volatile electronics sector. 
 Over in the US, psychologists at a number of universities are making a serious study of how rumours are born, how they propagate and how they can finally be killed off. 
 The analogy is so close that Alan Kimmel of Fitchburg State College describes rumour ( New York Science Times , June 4 1991) as a sort of opportunistic virus that thrives on fear and uncertainty. 
 Some rumours, he says, have survived for centuries, merely by mutating and reappearing in a different guise. 
 What, then, about anti-rumour software? 
 As a personal contribution to the stability of British industry (who on earth invented that one?) may I pass on a few nuggets of advice: 
 1. 
 If possible, track the rumour back to its origin. 
 In nine cases out of ten it turns out to be the office cleaner's milkman's financial adviser. 
 2. 
 Evaluate the rumour. 
 See if it really is lowering sales of demoralising staff. 
 Check how many people believe it. 
 3. 
 Plan a counter-attack immediately. 
 Check all the facts and refute them with sound evidence. 
 Latest research suggests that a firm rebuttal will kill any rumour within 24 hours. 
 &hellip; 
 Tell that one to the Palace press office! 
 D-latch constructed in source-coupled fet logic. 
 E indicates enhancement, D, depletion mode fets. 
 Design 
 Fluxgate magnetometery 
 Measuring the direction of the Earth's magnetic field provides the basis of an electronic compass while the strength of the field says much about solar activity, a factor important to HF radio propagation. 
 Richard Noble describes the heart of an instrument which can be used for serious scientific study. 
 Traditional magnetometers use inductive loops and long wire lines to measure magnetic flux by induced EMF. 
 Such instruments are bulky. 
 Hall effect semiconductors will measure low flux levels although their response tends to be non-linear and temperature dependent. 
 The fluxgate magnetometer, which depends for its action on the detection of saturation occurring in magnetic material, can be made both small and highly accurate. 
 In explaining its operation, it is easier to describe a simpler arrangement that would actually be used in practice. 
 In its most basic form, it comprises a single straight nickel-iron alloy core carrying two windings. 
 One winding functions as an excitation coil in which current flowing creates a field to magnetise the core in alternate directions. 
 The other acts as a pickup coil producing a voltage proportional to the rate of change of magnetic flux linking it. 
 At low levels of excitation this structure, outlined in Fig. 1, will obviously behave as if it were an inefficient transformer. 
 To convert it to a fluxgate transducer, the excitation is increased so as to force the core into saturation on alternate peaks. 
 This would be undesirable behaviour in a transformer but is the essence of fluxgate operation. 
 A square voltage waveform is applied to the excitation coil, of sufficient magnitude to saturate the core. 
 During the periods when the core is not saturated, the inductance of the coil causes the current passing through it to change linearly from one saturation state to the other. 
 As the core reaches saturation the inductance falls to a low value and the current rises rapidly to a limit set by the DC resistance of the coil forcing the core well into saturation. 
 The waveform of this current is shown in Fig. 2 which also serves as an illustration of the magnetic field produced by the coil, since this must be directly proportional to the current. 
 The induction in the core is magnified by the high permeability, except in the saturation regions where the result can be seen to be a trapezoidal induction waveform (Fig. 3). 
 The voltage induced in the pickup coil by this waveform is directly proportional to the rate of change of magnetic induction. 
 During the periods of saturation, there is no change and no signal voltage, but during the linearly changing regions there is a constant voltage output of appropriate polarity, as shown in Fig. 4. 
 All of the above assumes that the only influence on the core is the magnetic field produced by the excitation coil. 
 If this is not the case and the core is affected by an additional external field, a small change takes place in the output. 
 The component of external  field which is in line with the core axis either aids or opposes the excitation field in its alternating polarity phases. 
 When it aids the excitation field, the entry into saturation occurs slightly earlier and the departure from saturation occurs slightly later than would be the case. 
 The opposite effect arises when the external field opposes the excitation field. 
 For clarity, this is illustrated in very exaggerated form in Fig. 5. 
 The amount of advance and delay in the waveform corner is proportional to the size of the external field. 
 In this way the desired object has been achieved in the form of a signal variation which is the function of the external magnetic field strength. 
 It remains to exploit this. 
 Since a perfectly symmetric waveform foes not contain even harmonics and an asymmetric one does, a possible technique would be to isolate the even harmonics as the usable signal. 
 However the presence of very large fundamental and odd harmonic components in the output makes the isolation of the small even harmonics a very daunting task. 
 A Better Technique 
 Fortunately there is a very effective simple solution in the form of two parallel cores with opposing excitation windings and a single overwound pickup coil (Fig. 6). 
 The inductions in the two cores cancel out precisely when the cores are placed in a zero external field; an external field causes asymmetric pulses of amplitude and position dependent on the polarity and strength of the external field. 
 The resultant waveforms are shown in Fig. 7. 
 In this way, the trick of using two cores has performed the seemingly impossible task of isolating the tiny wanted signal from the comparatively huge unwanted one. 
 If the pulses marked with arrows in Fig. 7 are isolated from the others and applied to an appropriate low pass filter, the output is a DC or slowly varying voltage whose magnitude and polarity model the external field. 
 It would appear that isolating the set of pulses not marked with arrows would work equally well and, in fact, combining both in a suitable way could double the sensitivity. 
 For low gain systems such as fluxgate compasses or short range metal detectors this is true, but for high sensitivity application such as the magnetometer described here, there are good reasons to avoid this approach. 
 A practical solution 
 All of the foregoing assumes perfectly matching cores and windings and in practice is not easily achieved without individual and fiddling adjustment. 
 The problems associated with the need for perfect matching can be avoided by one further design change. 
 The long straight cores are abandoned. 
 They are instead bent into semicircles and joined together at their ends to form a solid circular toroid. 
 The two opposing excitation coils merge into a simple, single, full toroidal winding. 
 The pickup coil remains a single winding over the toroid (Fig. 8). 
 By these modifications the sought-after simplicity is achieved, coupled with the virtual elimination of all high-level signals. 
 As an additional benefit, the closed magnetic circuit of a toroidal core greatly reduces the drive requirements to produce saturation levels, simplifying the circuitry need by the system. 
 It may be felt that replacing two straight cores with a ring structure is too drastic a change to gloss over, but the mechanism is not too different in the two cases. 
 Figure 9 represents the way in which the lines of force are concentrated from the immediate vicinity and makes plausible the idea that an overwound coil would not see much difference in the flux changes it experiences from either system. 
 An additional advantage of the ring core is that it will accept more than one overwound pickup coil and they have different orientations to the external magnetic field. 
 For example while the coil orientation shown in Fig. 10a produces the largest output, that 10b links none of the changing flux and has a null output. 
 Angles between these produce an output which varies as the cosine of the angle, leading to the familiar figure-of-eight polar diagram for directional sensitivity. 
 This is the characteristic which is exploited in the design of a fluxgate compass.  
 The trace on the left hand page shows the disturbances caused to the earth's magnetic field by a solar storm occurring between June 12 and 14, 1991. 
 The measurements were made with the system described in this article. 
 The double coil structure is also of interest in the observation of the earth's magnetic field. 
 By making a magnetometer with two pickup coils at right angles and orienting it to give the maximum and null outputs referred to, the magnitude variations and angular variations are effectively separated. 
 In the maximum output direction the polar diagram is almost insensitive to small angular variations and the signal represents earth's field magnitude changes. 
 In the null output direction the signal changes are almost solely due to angular movement of the earth's field and over the small range involved are linearly proportional to angle. 
 To do a complete job would of course require two rings and three pickup coils. 
 If the toroid is inclined at the earth's field dip angle for the locality, (about 67&deg; in the UK) and the pickup coil is positioned for a null output, the system should have maximum sensitivity and there is no requirement for an offset null arrangement prior to large amplification to reveal the fluctuations. 
 If the coil is positioned for maximum output an offset adjustment equal to the mean magnitude of the field is required, but need be no more complicated than an offset bias to the following amplifier input. 
 A more usual setup would probably be to fix the core in a horizontal position, aligned so that one pickup coil responds to the maximum horizontal component of the earth's field, in which case the other would respond to the variations in declination or angular change in direction. 
 This corresponds to two of the standard measurements made by recording stations and should provide adequate indications for radiocomms prediction. 
 Instrument design 
 A simple RC oscillator supplies trigger pulses to a frequency divider formed from two D-type bistables. 
 Complementary outputs from the lower frequency bistable are used to operate voltage switches which connect the full supply voltage across the excitation coil in alternate directions thus providing the square voltage waveform. 
 A small resistor is connected in series with the coil to limit the current during core saturation. 
 The frequency is chosen to make sure that the core reaches saturation at each alteration, but does not spend any more than a short time in this condition so as to maximise the final output signal; the circuit should produce as many saturation signals as possible. 
 The pickup coil signals connect to analogue switches controlled by the first (and higher frequency) bistable in the driving divider chain, in order to isolate only those signals which coincide with the saturation waveform transitions. 
 The signals from the two switches are fed to two operational amplifiers configured as simple RC low-pass filter/integrators. 
 A second pair of amplifiers provide additional outputs at higher sensitivity. 
 The first stages are fitted with input offset adjustments just large enough to cancel the largest field likely to be encountered, namely the total inclined component in the middle latitudes. 
 They also have a gain setting which will allow a field of this magnitude not to overload the output of the stage. 
 This is useful in setting the zero field output correctly. 
 Fields in the range of interest are usually measured in gamma, one gauss being 100,000 gamma. 
 The total component of the earth's magnetic field in the UK is around 47 000 gamma inclined at around 67&deg; to the horizontal. 
 The particular core and winding arrangement used in the design has an intrinsic sensitivity of about 12mV/gauss or  0.12&micro;V/gamma. 
 A gain of 400 in the first amplifier/filter will then produce an output of almost two and a half volts from the total earth's field vector, avoiding overload and permitting a peak-to-peak measurement by rotating the core. 
 Calibration 
 The core is aligned with one coil picking up the north-south field and inclined at roughly 67&deg; to the horizontal and adjusted so as to produce the largest positive output from the amplifier. 
 It is then rotated through approximately 180 degrees to find the largest negative output. 
 This process is repeated, while the zero offset is adjusted, until the positive and negative readings have the same magnitude. 
 The amplifier will then have been adjusted so that zero field corresponds to zero output, the first step in achieving calibration. 
 The next is to calibrate the gain, using a pair of Helmholtz coils. 
 These are not the expensive-looking, beautifully crafted works of art found in old school laboratories. 
 With a sensitive magnetometer all that is needed is a few turns of enamelled wire reasonably carefully wound onto a piece of plastic drainpipe. 
 The requirement is a pair of close-wound coils, mounted on the same axis and separated by a mean distance equal to their mean radius, as shown in Fig. 12. 
 The result is a fairly large volume between the coils of almost uniform field strength given by: where r is the mean radius of the coils in  meters, N  is the number of turns in each coil and I  is the current flowing in the coil in amperes. 
 Using a 110mm diameter piece of plastic tubing as a former, a pair of coils wound with 24 turns/coil of 0.2mm wire give a coil constant of 3.95 gauss/ampere. 
 The calibration is carried out by mounting the magnetometer core centrally in the coils and adjusting the peak-to-peak output while reversing the coil current, set to a constant value appropriate to the range being calibrated. 
 This would range from about 125mA to match the earth's field to 0.75 mA to set the most sensitive range. 
 The first stage amplifier has a gain of only 400 giving a sensitivity near 20000 gamma/volt. 
 This could show a severe magnetic storm but a higher sensitivity is desirable for serious observation. 
 A second stage amplifier provides a gain of around 200, increasing the instrument sensitivity to 100 gamma/volt. 
 This is high enough to permit observation if the diurnal variation. 
 At this gain the noise level of the instrument can be seen in quiet periods to be approximately 10 gamma &mdash; 15 gamma over a bandwagon of the order of 0.3Hz, reasonable enough for serious studies. 
 If the instrument is only to be an indicator of magnetic activity then calibration is not really necessary. 
 However a small scattering of calibrated stations could provide an interesting and potentially significant source of scientific date on radio propagation. 
 Quantitative information, even of limited accuracy is often useful if enough people collect it. 
 Sensor design 
 The core used in the magnetic sensor is made by Telcon Metals of Crawley and consists of a toroid wound from a flat tape, one thousandth of an inch thick HCR alloy. 
 This metal was specially developed for use in magnetic control systems and amplifiers and has a remarkably rectangular hysteresis loop in which the remanent flux is only 2.6% less than the saturation flux. 
 As supplied the core is protected by being enclosed in a toroidal shaped hollow plastic case. 
 This makes the winding simple since the wire can be applied directly over the case. 
 The only toroidal wound coil is the excitation coil and it should be made up using 0.5mm diameter enamelled wire. 
 Start with a length of about seven metres of wire, precisely half of which should be spooled onto a shuttle thin enough to pass through the centre of the toroid. 
 The other half should be neatly coiled and taped for the moment. 
 Temporarily secure the centre of the length to the core with a piece of tape and begin winding by passing the shuttle through the core centre repeatedly. 
 As winding progresses, unloop from the shuttle just enough wire at each stage to make handling as reasonable as possibly, taking care to avoid kinking the wire. 
 Keep the turns close wound on the internal diameter and reasonably evenly spaced on the outside. 
 This is easily said and less easily done, but it is not critical to the final working. 
 Be careful however to avoid overlapping turns. 
 When the winding extends around approximately half of the core cut off the end, leaving a few inches of spare wire and tape the wire down temporarily. 
 Repeat the whole exercise with the other half of the original length of wire until the entire core is filled. 
 Secure the wire ends by twisting them together for a short distance to prevent the turns trying to unwind themselves. 
 The total number of turns need not be exact but will be around 170. 
 The next stage is to find a piece of plastic or card tube which will just slide snugly over the wound coil to provide the former for the pickup coils. 
 It is possible to make up  a tube by winding and gluing layers of brown paper round a suitable former. 
 Shallow slots should be cut or filed into the top and bottom of the tube as shown in Fig. 13. 
 These are to facilitate the winding of the pickup coils. 
 Next wind some tape through the slots and around the core to provide a base for the pickup windings. 
 The coils themselves should consist of 500 turns of 0.2mm enamelled wire scramble wound as neatly as possible over the core, the second winding crossing over the top of the first at right angles. 
 The whole assembly can then be given several coats of varnish to help hold the windings in place and glued down to a square mounting board, etc. 
 The ends of the coil should be soldered to the termination strips to allow for the later attachment of heavier gauge connecting cable. 
 Electronic Design 
 The detailed electronic circuit is shown in Fig. 14 and consists of three basic sections, a power driver for the excitation coil and two identical sense amplifiers. 
 The driver section starts with an RC oscillator made from two 4011 gates wired as inverters. 
 The component values are chosen to give a frequency of 720Hz. 
 The output is fed to a two stage frequency divider formed from the D-type 4013 bistables, producing a final output square wave at 180Hz in both normal and inverted phases. 
 These two signals are connected to two pairs of complementary emitter followers in bridge connection for core driving. 
 The excitation winding is connected in series with a small current-limiting resistor. 
 The current in the coil rises rapidly to a value limited by the series resistor when the core reaches saturation. 
 At this point the voltage drop across the emitter followers also increases causing a sudden small reduction in the available square wave voltage, which persists until the signal reverses. 
 This effect causes the pickup coil pulses associated with entry to saturation to be noise and undesirable for use in the final measurement system. 
 The reason for this is that as the core begins to saturate, the voltage available for saturation falls, tending to slow down the approach to saturation. 
 This makes the transitions less well defined and subject to jitter in rather the same way as a multivibrator will jitter if the initial approach to transistor turn-on is not rapid. 
 The signals generated in the pickup coils are not neat rectangular pulses although their amplitudes very with the external field. 
 The lack of perfect balance and coil symmetry also allows some of the fundamental switching frequency to leak through. 
 However, the key fact remains true that the area under the pulses is proportional to the external magnetic field, after discounting the small offset caused by the fundamental breakthrough. 
 The waveforms look something like Fig 15. 
 The pickup coil in each amplifier is loaded by a 1k&ohm; resistor and applied to one section of an quad analogue switch. 
 The output is loaded by a 10k&ohm; resistor to avoid the following circuitry seeing a high impedance when the switch is open, thus becoming susceptible to interference or hum pickup. 
 The control signal for the switch is derived from the first divider bistable (at twice the core switching frequency) by differentiating the square wave and clipping off the negative pulses with a diode. 
 This results in short positive pulses coincident with the core switching transitions to select the desired pickup of coil signals. 
 The signals from the switch go to an inverting DC coupled operational amplifier with lowpass filter characteristics through the addition of a capacitor in parallel with the feedback resistor. 
 The variable input resistor allows for gain calibration. 
 The corner frequency of the filter is about 0.3Hz. 
 The signal then goes to a second  amplifier/filter of the same configuration also with a corner frequency of about 0.3Hz. 
 This second stage has two alternative gains of x20 and x200 selectable by 4016 switch. 
 The non inverting input of the first stage amplifier is connected via a resistor to a potentiometer linked across positive and negative voltage divider chains to provide an adjustable input offset. 
 The potentiometer is a stable cermet multi-turn type to allow the high resolution setting required at the highest sensitivity. 
 (One tenth of a turn corresponds approximately to 500 gamma, the full range covering 100,000 gamma). 
 There is nothing particularly remarkable about the power supply. 
 Setting up 
 If this all appears to work, an oscilloscope should show a pickup coil signal similar to Fig. 15, variations depending on the individual winding symmetry. 
 Amplitude changes should occur as the core is rotated in space. 
 Similarly, a DC voltmeter connected to the test point at the output of the first stage should see a voltage which varies as the core is moved about. 
 The trimpot used to set the first stage gain, should be set at maximum resistance and the multi-turn zero offset trimpot to the centre of its range before this check. 
 If the first stage functions then the final second stage output is likely to be hard against the positive or negative amplifier limits, but very careful manipulation of the core orientation will find a position in which tiny movements will flick the output between limits. 
 Even more careful adjustment may permit the output to settle somewhere between the amplifier limits. 
 Try to bring the output voltage to zero either by moving the core or adjusting the zero-offset trimpot. 
 Shorting the gain change control line to ground will increase the second stage gain by a factor of ten and should reveal micropulsations in the shape of an output which fluctuates randomly by about 0.2V. 
 At this level of sensitivity metal objects in the vicinity should have a marked effect if they are moved. 
 A mildly magnetised screwdriver may drive the system right off-scale from a foot away and a small magnet can be detected at six to eight feet. 
 Even the car keys or a belt buckle may upset things if placed too close. 
 The second amplifier should perform in the same way, but the core will have to be rotated through about 90&deg; to find the corresponding zero field position. 
 Calibration 
 Select one amplifier for calibration and connect a voltmeter to the test point at the first stage output. 
 Place the sensor on a flat surface and rotate it slowly through 360&deg;. 
 The voltmeter should show a maximum (positive), a minimum (negative) and two zero crossings approximately at right angles to the maximum and minimum. 
 Make a note of the values at maximum and minimum and if they are not of equal magnitude adjust the zero-offset trimpot so as to make them equal. 
 This may take a few iterations to achieve a good balance, but should eventually make the zero crossings correspond to more or less zero field. 
 Next rotate the sensor to locate the maximum again and, while trying to maintain the heading, tilt it upwards to find the absolute maximum reading. 
 In the UK this will be at about 67&deg; to the horizontal, but it is not critical, as the maximum is quite broad and not very sensitive to angle. 
 Compare this positive reading with the negative minimum found by rotating the sensor by 180&deg; in the same 67&deg; plane to the horizontal. 
 The magnitudes of these two readings should not be the same, if the zero-offset has been set correctly. 
 This is not as difficult to do as it sounds, simply because of the very broad maxima and minima. 
 If the intention is to make serious measurements calibration with a Helmholtz coil will be required. 
 The outlined design produces a field of 3.95 gauss/ampere. 
 Strictly this implies a precision greater than is reasonable and should probably be read as 4.0 gauss/ampere or 400 gamma/mA (one gauss = 100 000 gamma). 
 The sensitivity sought at the test point is 20 000 gamma/volt: + 2.5V corresponds to a range of 100,000 gamma so the initial Helmholtz coil current setting should cover this. 
 At 400 gamma/mA this calls for a current of 125mA variable. 
 This should include a reversing switch to enable the current through the coils to be reversed easily. 
 Place the sensor in the centre of the Helmholtz coils with one pickup winding aligned to pick up maximum flux. 
 Monitor the appropriate amplifier test point with a voltmeter or calibrated oscilloscope and rotate the Helmholtz coils and sensor to give zero volts. 
 Switch on the coil current (set to 125mA) and the test point voltage should change by about two volts or so, positively or negatively. 
 Using the amplifier gain trimpot, adjust so that the output changes by 5V when the coil current is reversed. 
 (+2.5V range). 
 Since the final stage gains are set by 1% tolerance fixed resistors, this completes the calibration, the output sensitivities being either 1000 gamma/volt or 100 gamma/volt. 
 Repeat the exercise to calibrate the second pickup winding and the instrument is ready for use. 
 The core used in this design is a Telcon Metals HCR alloy core type 7a and is available from Telcon Metals, phone 0293 528800 
 The flux gate transducer outlined in this article can be used at the heart of a scientific magnetometer of highly accurate electronic compass 
 Fig. 7. 
 The filter output is derived from the sum of the core contributions to the pickup coil output 
 Fig. 8: the toroidal core winding system. 
 The finished transducer includes a second pickup coil at right angles to the first. 
 Fig. 9: a toroidal core tends to concentrate the magnetic field tangentially producing the same sensitivity pattern as a pair of bar cores. 
 Fig. 10: The toroid exhibits greatest sensitivity at right angles to the pickup coil 
 Fig. 11: The electronics divides into two parts: the exciter section drives the core into saturation with a current ramp of alternating polarity while the measurement section integrates the pickup coil pulses caused by the action of a static magnetic field on the core. 
 Fig. 14: complete circuit diagram in three parts. 
 Note the bridge driver for the exciter coil allied to the synchronous rectifier downstream of the pickup coil 
 Second measurement channel mirroring the bottom half of the upper diagram 
 Power supply circuit. 
 There is nothing special here. 
 Fig. 12 winding details for the Helmholtz calibration coils 
 Fig. 15: the sort of waveform expected across the  picup  coils. 
 The amplitude and polarity of the pulses changes with strength and direction of the static magnetic field. 
 Magnetometery and radio communications 
 The study of propagation is one of the important aspects of radio comms activity. 
 The ability to forecast ionospheric conditions is related to solar activity. 
 A magnetometer, detecting changes in the magnetic fields arising from charged particles deflected around the earth, measures the effects of corpuscular and non-corpuscular radiation emanated from the sun during solar flares and other events. 
 Non-corpuscular radiation is in the form of high energy X rays which, assuming that the earth is in the path of the rays, will reach the earth in fifteen minutes. 
 This radiation may increase the depth of the &bquo;D&equo; layer due to ionisation and produce the all too well known Dellinger face out when long-distance HF communication ceases abruptly. 
 Corpuscular or particulate radiation appears in the form of protons and neutrons which take longer to reach the earth's upper atmosphere than the higher energy radiations. 
 These nuclear particles arrive at the F1 and F2 layers approximately 48 hours following a solar event and produce ionisation by colliding with gaseous molecules and cosmic particles. 
 This explains why so few protons are detectible at the earth's surface except after very major events. 
 The increased ionisation along the earth's lines of magnetic force make them more conductive and leads to an increased current flow with consequent rise in magnetic flux levels. 
 It is under these conditions that the magnetometer is useful in detecting the fluctuations in the magnetic fields. 
 In terms of radio propagation, varying electrical conductance in the ionosphere influences either the absorbency or reluctance of radio emissions. 
 A knowledge of the ionospheric status will often suggest which bands will be more productive. 
 It is interesting to note that a Dellinger fade out is often followed by a magnetic field change around 48 hours later. 
 Many articles have appeared in the amateur radio press and elsewhere describing the many aspects of propagation and giving more detailed information on the theory of and effects of solar radiation on communications systems. 
 This brief and simplified introduction has been included for completeness, and hopefully to show that the examination of the earth's magnetosphere in relation to propagation is not a difficult project to undertake, the equipment is easy to build and has the advantage of being a both interesting and useful addition to your capability. 
  David Lomax GW0FXA   
 Regulars 
 Letters 
 Cuk vs. 
 Buck 
 According to Terrence Finnegan, the Cuk power converter offers the best of all power supply worlds, approaches 90% efficiency, requires few components, and produces minimal amounts of interference (EW + WW July 1991). 
 The rather woolly nature of these claims aside, readers might be forgiven for wondering why, if the Cuk converter offers so many desirable features, it is not more commonly used. 
 The fact is that in the world of switch-mode power supplies (and it is a very large world indeed, covering PCB, mainframe computers, electronic telephone exchanges, military equipment, aerospace, and more besides) it is rare to come across a Cuk converter. 
 Interestingly, even Dr. Cuk himself, after starting up his Teslaco power supply consultancy, did not use the Cuk converter for his early power supply contracts. 
 The lack of popularity with the Cuk topology may be due to its problems relating to the energy-coupling capacitor. 
 In the non-isolated version of the topology, as used in Terrence Finnegan's design, the capacitor is, as he says, smaller than the equivalent magnetic component used for energy transfer. 
 However, this seems to be a red herring, since the standard Buck topology uses a pair of inductors (though not coupled) and a single transistor switch just as the Cuk topology does, but need no other energy coupling device. 
 Most power converters are required to provide transformer isolation between input and output, and the isolated version of the Cuk converter has to have energy coupling capacitors on all its windings, so that they then have to be provided as energy coupling devices plus the transformer. 
 Regardless of whether we are talking isolated or non-isolated, however, the capacitors introduce two entirely non-trivial problems. 
 First, at currents of more than a few amps, capacitors that can carry the current without suffering di/dt stress, heating stress, and MHz ringing tend to be physically large, and expensive compared with normal power supply capacitors. 
 Furthermore, the required low series resistance results in high Q resonances with the inductors at audio frequencies. 
 These will then have to be damped by paralleling each capacitor causing this problem with another of higher value and higher series resistance. 
 In addition, during start-up and overload conditions the capacitors (and their larger parallel damping capacitors, if fitted) find themselves with the wrong DC bias, and charging occurs through potentially very low impedances. 
 Care has to be taken to make sure no excessive currents can flow during these transients. 
 Furthermore, these DC offsets across the capacitors appear on the transformer windings, causing shifts in the core operating flux. 
 Therefore, extra headroom has to be provided for the operating flux. 
 As a result another apparent advantage often cited for the Cuk converter (that it can use the full peak-to-peak bidirectional flux swing) is, in practice, whittled away. 
 As for the claim that the Cuk converter approaches 90% efficiency and produces minimal RF interference, exactly the same claims can be made for well-designed standard topologies. 
 Good efficiency is mainly a matter of using good switches and rectifiers, since they are where most of the losses occur. 
 The low RF interference and low component count claims are usually made because the Cuk topology is not only able to accommodate the input and output filter chokes on the same magnetic core as the transformer, but it can also reduce the input and output ripple currents to very low levels. 
 This does indeed seem like getting something for nothing, but is it really? 
 Since the input and output inductors store energy, then just like any other inductor, they produce flux in their common core and they require space for large enough diameter wire to keep I2R losses reasonable. 
 Extra core volume and winding window area must be provided to support these. 
 What no one, as far as I know, has ever done is to show whether there is any space, weight, efficiency or cost saving that results from assembling all the windings onto one core. 
 Standard bobbins cannot be used for E cores, since all three legs have to be used for the isolated topology. 
 Of course, if the standard easy-to-use E-core bobbin is dispensed with, there is automatically more room for the windings, so increased copper area is traded for increased difficulty of manufacture. 
 This trade-off may be acceptable in the military and aerospace fields, but not in the commercial field. 
 The large reduction in ripple currents is an advantage, but input and output decoupling capacitors are still required. 
 Those on the input will be similar to what the standard Buck topology requires; those on the output(s) could be made smaller, though the reduction is limited by the need to keep enough capacitance  to absorb fast load transients. 
 To summarise, the Cuk converter has an apparent advantage over standard Buck topology in that it uses an integrated magnetic structure and can reduce input and output ripple currents to very low levels. 
 On the other hand, the required energy coupling capacitors cause problems and can be expensive at higher current levels, and there does not seem to be any proof that there is a volume, weight, or cost saving over the standard Buck topology for any given equivalent performance level. 
 All credit is due to Terrence Finnegan for his two recent articles which, for the first time, have made available useful and usable designinformation. 
 Nevertheless the Cuk converter topology seems likely to remain an outsider until a true trade-off comparison can be made between Cuk and Buck at a series of realistic equivalent performance levels, a task that would take a lot of time, but whose results would be of great interest to many in the power supply design field. 
  Brian J. Pollard Watford Herts  
 To be Class D or not 
 Why has Class D not been more widely used? 
 It is very efficient from a power dissipation point of view, not suffering from cross-over distortion. 
 In addition, even if overall negative feedback is used, it has low overall distortion. 
 On the surface it would appear superior to Classes A and B. 
 It was invented by my late friend, Dr A H Reeves, who also invented pulse code modulation and the capacitor microphone, both of which have enjoyed enormous success. 
 In my view and also, if my memory serves me correctly, in Dr Reeves' view, this is quite simply because it doubles up as a transmitter with very sharp rise and fall times on its pulse width modulated waveform. 
 This means it needs effective screening and filtering which can be difficult, bulky and expensive. 
 I fully accept that in Andy Gothard's article ( EW  + WW  July 1991) about King's College, there is a circuit system developed by Dr Mark Sandler which produces a very accurate, and indeed ideal, analogue output from the digital (CD) to analogue (PWM power amplifier drive) converter. 
 But Dr Sandler's circuit has at least three problems. 
 First, there are unwanted transmissions over the RF spectrum as mentioned earlier. 
 Secondly, there is distortion introduced in the power amplifier following conversion since unavoidable rise and fall times of the output power stage introduce non-linearity if they are not equal which, in practice and for a number of reasons, they will not be. 
 Thirdly, overall feedback is not possible in this arrangement, unlike Class D. 
 Because of the practical difficulties in overcoming the first of these problems, I cannot see, even if the price of the D-to-A converter were a few pence, Class D in its Reeves or Sandler guise making much progress. 
 This is a shame, since switching in some ways is much better than linear amplification. 
  A Sandman London  
 Watching for the HDTV con trick 
 The impressions gained by the Waddington experiments suggest there were more habitual television viewers (4:3) than avid cinema goers (16:9). 
 Nearly two generations have passed since Hollywood introduced the larger format (incidentally not 16:9) in an attempt to halt the then falling box office revenues. 
 Since then home viewing has largely taken over from cinema going but there does not seem to have been much criticism of the format as such but perhaps more so the screen size. 
 Today the increased reliability of television receivers causes commercial concern for set manufacturers and hence their hopeful exploitation of so-called HDTV and change of format. 
 So-called? 
 Yes. 
 The human eye in its best years has a maximum angular resolution of one minute of arc. 
 In other words it can just distinguish stationary 1mm black vertical lines 1mm apart on a white background at a distance of 3m. 
 A little mathematics shows that with a monochrome 4:3 70cm CRT one could just resolve a 625 line black and white stationary picture consisting of 4MHz dots using today's European standards at the normal viewing distance. 
 Any increase in these standards therefore could not be resolved by any earthbound human being. 
 The introduction of colour and moving scenes involves other aspects. 
 With the colour mask tube the horizontal definition is theoretically reduced by a factor of three but the eye is quite tolerant to small changes of detail in moving scenes in the opposite direction. 
 The use of correctly converged colour television projectors with pixels superimposed rather than being shown side by side allows present television standards to be used satisfactorily, and economically, unless and until genetic engineering succeeds in altering human optics. 
 Incidentally, I have used projection television receivers at home for the last 40 years and, possibly their use does not require the eye to be concentrated in one continuous subtended angle, my in eyes in their fourth quarter century still resolve that one minute of arc! 
 Based on the above, which HDTV hype cannot alter, I suggest that commercial technical research should concentrate on larger flat screens with superimposed pixels with change of standards but with some attention to the basic defects in the NTSC, Pal and Secam systems which are only mildly irritating. 
 In any technical comment you make, please remember that a former editor made a passionate technical plea for the retention of 405 lines but failed to realise the commercial advantages which had then already accrued in the 625 line camp. 
 These do not yet apply in HDTV. 
  M Le M Manson Squadron Leader RAF (retired) Rome, Italy  
 Baffling stabilisation 
 Comparison with the original ring-of-two current stabiliser of Peter Williams (WW September 1966) reveals that V Lakshminarayanan has over simplified the circuit to such an extent that it no longer works as a current stabiliser ( EW  + WW  July 1991). 
 The fault cannot be attributed to a draughting error because the 2N3904 and BC546 are npn transistors and the circuit will pass only 5mA when 2.7V is between A and B. 
 As for the zener diode D, that is described as being in series with the base of Tr3 which has me completely baffled. 
  John C Rudge Harlington Middlesex   
 Aerial confusion 
 J.J. Gameson seems a little confused in his letter in the July issue. 
 Everything appears OK until he introduces the ferrite rod antenna (aerial). 
 The null in the directional response of such an antenna is quite independent of the Q of the coil. 
 It is linked to the magnetic field of the transmitted wave &mdash; not the turns of the coil. 
 Null depth varies in practice, because some antennas respond to the electric field component of the wave as well as to the magnetic field component. 
 When we come to whip and dipole antennas, Gameson criticises the whip for not being directional and the dipole for being directional! 
 Incidentally, a horizontal dipole without parasitic elements is not unidirectional it is bi-directional, having exactly the same &bquo;figure-of-eight&equo; response as a ferrite rod antenna! 
 Having noted Gameson's earlier remarks about a &bquo;deep null&equo;, it is surprising to read that &bquo;The ferrite rod is electromagnetically non-directional&equo;, and then to return to the &bquo;very sharp null&equo; idea in the next paragraph. 
 Furthermore, VHF ferrite rod antennas are not less affected by standing waves than whips. 
 Unfortunately Gameson's remark about listeners' confusion is true. 
 Broadcasters do try to offer advice, but it often goes right over the heads of enquirers. 
 However, there are two solutions for the quality enthusiast. 
 In a fringe area, or where distant stations are wanted so that a directional antenna is essential, a rotator can be purchased for quite a modest by today's standards. 
 Maplin Electronics have one at just under &pound;41. 
 For those who only need relatively local stations, advantage can be taken of the fact that nearly all FM stations now radiate, either slant-polarised or circularly polarised signals, so that a vertical dipole, completely non-directional in the horizontal plane, gives as much signal as a horizontal one. 
 This does not of course, apply to Yagi antennas, which are more or less unidirectional. 
 The BBC Research Department have built FM receivers with ferrite-rod antennas, and published reports on them, but the fact that such receivers are not commercially available, strongly suggest that any technical advantages (if any) do not justify the extra cost. 
 The wideband cable systems which were trumpeted some years ago could well carry high quality sound as well as umpteen television channels but their development has run into serious economic problems. 
 There is a new sound broadcasting system under study, for introduction early in the next century. 
 This is Digital Audio Broadcasting (DAB), which without mathematics, it would be impossible to explain its mechanism in words. 
 But you will still need an antenna! 
  J M Woodgate Rayleigh Essex  
 Telepointless 
 I am bemused by the media attention being focused on the fate of the telepoint services. 
 The public is being asked to believe that an ill-conceived government has it in for these companies. 
 This argument just does not hold water. 
 The whole system was ill-conceived from the outset. 
 That some very large companies should have lost a great deal of money on their little experiment shows only how unwise their decision to pursue the technology was. 
 Look at the arguments. 
 Since calls must be made close to a node, then why not simply find a telephone kiosk &mdash; must work these days and the cost will only be at the standard rate. 
 Then there is the absurd lack of ability to receive calls. 
 This alone was surely enough to doom the venture from the outset. 
 Then there is the cost: cellphone equipment is virtually given away with crisp packets and the running cost is only fractionally greater. 
 Did you ever hear the cellphone operators complaining that the early competition adversely affected their business? 
 Did you heck! 
 Given that this was all well-known at the outset what utter fool would believe there could be any money to be made out of such a system. 
 Well we learned all too well, didn't we? 
 If any other pioneering company had brought out a call-only cordless telephone, I wonder who would shed tears when it failed to sell. 
  Peter Johnsonn Electronic Design Laboratory Bristol  
 We told them so &mdash; Ed. 
 Any old valves 
 It was good to see a reference in your magazine to valve amplification ( EW  + WW  August 1991), but I still have a certain frustration that you may be able to help me with. 
 I have for many years enjoyed dabbling with valve amplifiers, usually modifying old ones, but all the information I have has to be gleaned from circuit diagrams or an old Mullard handbook containing a selection of designs (I'm sure you know the one!). 
 Despite many years of searching, I have not yet been able to track down any other source of reference on the design and construction of valve pre and power amplifiers. 
 Can anyone help? 
 There must have been text books around at one time but I cannot even identify any titles let alone suppliers. 
  DA Ellis Shipston-on-Stour Warwickshire  
 Light hearted 
 With regard to the debate about c  and Doppler shifts in the letters pages, light (velocity c ) reflected or emitted from a surface moving with velocity v  towards an observer appears to be blue shifted, or red shifted in the case of a receding surface. 
 As a non-physicist I have often wondered if the difference in photon energy ( E' &mdash; E = hf' &mdash; hf ) of the shifted and unshifted light could be wholly accounted for by the effect of the surface velocity ( v ) acting together with the particle equivalent mass of the photon. 
 The extra energy not being allowed to be expressed as an increase in c appears as a commensurate increase in f, that is: (formula included) where m is the photon equivalent mass (yes I know it is related to E  but I am trying not to confuse myself), E  is the energy, and h  is Mr Plank's claim to fame. 
 I write this letter in the hope that someone will explain the errors of my ways, forgive me for mixing relativistic and Newtonian physics, and enlighten me. 
  Steve Bennett IDT Europe  
 Bad vibes 
 I detect all kinds of vibrations and illnesses in people, animals and plants simply with an old motor car speedometer cable which starts swinging in my hand. 
 The combination of electric fields ( EW + WW  February 1990) and earth energy lines is deadly. 
 When the patient is removed there is a dramatic change for the better! 
 I have been told the Chinese have a simple inexpensive instrument to trace extra low frequencies. 
 Could you help me find out if such an instrument is available in the UK? 
  George Heye Somerset West South Africa  
 For those not familiar with the effects of earth energy lines, Mr Heye sent further documentation with his letter that listed some of the tell tale signs that may show someone is suffering from bad earth vibes. 
 These include: home making expansion and contraction noises at night (stronger during full moon); cracks in walls and pools; ants and reptiles laying eggs; car battery often flat; suffering pot plants; and twisted trees. 
 He added that people usually pale below the eyes and above the cheek bones, have many dreams including nightmares and hallucinations, suffer disturbed sleep especially at full moon, get up tired and listless, are prone to attacks of flu, and are driven to drink, drugs and heavy smoking. 
 He also said that most Westerners laugh at these ideas. 
 &mdash; Ed.  
 Computing 
 Graphical formats and file transfer 
 There is a proliferation of complex graphical file formats. 
 David Bacon explains how these files are structured, and how graphical information is transferred. 
 If a picture is worth a thousand words, it might take a thousand words to describe a picture. 
 This is the first thing you notice about graphics interchange files &mdash; they tend to be long. 
 The second thing is that there are an awful lot of them. 
 Do we really need. 
 CGM,. 
 CUT,. 
 DXF,. 
 EPS,. 
 GIF,. 
 IMG,. 
 PCX,. 
 PIC,. 
 TIF, and many other types of file, all to do the same job? 
 Standardisation has never been the IT industry's strong point, and the answer is &bquo;probably not&equo;. 
 However, they don't actually all do the same job. 
 The application of computer graphics is wide &mdash; from management pie-charts to mapping Mars. 
 Broadly speaking, however, there are about four general reasons for files which transfer graphics information: 
 &mdash; 
 To save or transfer drawings made on cad systems; 
 &mdash; 
 To save or transfer images from computer art systems, scanners, or acquired from a camera; 
 &mdash; 
 To control advanced printers; 
 &mdash; 
 To communicate between networked graphical user interfaces (GUIs) and host computers. 
 Inside such files there are two fundamentally different methods of describing graphical information. 
 Some graphics files use one method or the other exclusively, others can mix the two methods in the same file: 
 &mdash; 
 A high-level approach, sometimes referred to as a drawing description or vector file, or &bquo;meta file&equo;; 
 &mdash; 
 A low-level approach based upon the pixel information used to display a digital image, sometimes referred to as bit mapped, raster based, or image file. 
 Drawing description files 
 The main application of these files is in cad. 
 Computer aided design (cad) systems are the draughtsman's equivalent of a word processor. 
  For a skilled operator it is faster and easier to produce a new drawing, and once a drawing is on file, making changes and producing updated versions becomes much more efficient. 
 In a large team effort, different people can be working on separate aspects of a design, with changes rapidly distributed to all of them. 
 Cad transfer files normally describe drawings in a way which is referred to &bquo;device neutral&equo;. 
 To give an example, a statement in a cad file might consist of &bquo;CIRCLE 10.5 24.75 3.9&equo;. 
 It doesn't take too much imagination to guess that this means &bquo;draw a circle centred at x = 10.5, y = 24.75, and of radius 3.9, in whatever units we happen to be using at the moment&equo;. 
 This is describing the circle, not how the circle is drawn. 
 In fact, it is describing the circle in the most accurate way possible. 
 Any attempt to actually draw the circle is bound to have some kind of imperfection, such as the irregularities if a bit mapped device, or servo non-linearities in an X-Y plotter. 
 But the cad transfer file is concerned with the object itself, not how it is portrayed. 
 (The Greek philosophers were aware of this point, that perfection only exists in virtuality. 
 Any attempt to produce something in reality leads to imperfection. 
 For example, we can all sing perfectly in tune in our heads.) 
 However, although &bquo;device neutral&equo; in the above sense, a cad file must support the features of the cad system which produced it. 
 Since such features, which can be very powerful, differ for various cad systems, output files tend to be &bquo;system specific&equo;. 
 Transferring work between systems which do not support a common interchange file format requires translation software, and raises the problem of how to handle features of one system not supported by the other, or handled differently. 
 Drawing description files are normally ascii text files, with the drawing attributes and all relevant set-up information described in a suitably coded but printable form. 
 One reason for this, rather than the use of binary data, is that it allows the file to be sent via communications channels coded for 7-bit plus parity. 
 Another advantage is that the file is printable, and can be checked by eye if necessary. 
 The coding normally consists of keyboards and parameters. 
 For instance, we could have &bquo;CIRCLE X Y R&equo;, or &bquo;LINE X1 Y1 X2 Y2&equo;. 
 POLYLINES is another useful device, consisting of an indefinite sequence of X/Y pairs to be interconnected by straight lines. 
 Polylines can efficiently describe shapes made from visibly straight lines, such as rectangles, or by using points sufficiently close together, complex curves such as spirals. 
 In similar ways, arcs, ellipses and regular polygons can be described. 
 A more advanced drawing &bquo;primitive&equo;, as these basic shapes are called, is the spline. 
 This was originally a flexiblestrip used by railwaymen to get smooth curves when laying railway lines. 
 In a cad system it is an electronic &bquo;French curves&equo;. 
 The basic idea is that a few parameters are turned into a smooth curve by a standardised computation. 
 One particularly useful type, shown in Fig. 1, is defined by the position of each end (x and y), plus the direction of a tangent to the spline at each end (a). 
 Fig. 1 illustrates that by linking such splines at a common point and opposite tangent directions, an indefinite length of smooth curve can be defined with relatively little data. 
 Providing the underlying maths is the same for all systems using the file, the same shape will be reproduced each time. 
 Cad systems which work in 3 dimensions will produce &bquo;drawing&equo; description files which actually describe the object being drawn, using 3D position co-ordinates. 
 To get a view of the object a viewpoint and direction must be stated, and the system then computes the required 2D projection. 
 This is ideal for visualisation applications, such as planning the use of 3D space, impact of new buildings, style of a car body, etc. 
 System parameters also need to be described in drawing description files, such as: &mdash; 
 &mdash; 
 Definition of fonts for textual information; 
 &mdash; 
 Line styles, widths, varieties of dashed lines, etc; 
 &mdash; 
 Styles of area fill, hatching patterns, etc; 
 &mdash; 
 Layers. 
 Layers are an important part of most cad systems. 
 They allow a drawing to consist of several layers, equivalent to overlaid transparent sheets, each containing a different aspect of the drawing. 
 For instance, an architect may want an office floor plan with walls, furniture, plumbing, electrical wiring, and air conditioning all shown on different layers. 
 The plan can then be produced in different versions showing different aspects of the overall design. 
 All such detail goes into the drawing description of file. 
 The result can be a very long document in a complicated coding scheme, but it forms a powerful description of design information without any compromise made in accuracy. 
 Examples of drawing description file formats are: &mdash; 
 &mdash; 
 Initial Graphics Exchange Specification (Iges): this appeared in 1980. 
 It uses ascii character coding, and tends to produce very long files. 
 Perhaps in view of this, a compressed format is available. 
 &mdash; 
 Computer Graphics Metafile (CGM): this became an ansi standard in 1986. 
 There is a choice of file coding in ascii or binary form to suit different applications. 
 &mdash; 
 Drawing Exchange Format (DXF): this originates from AutoCad. 
 It is in widespread use, and is supported by other cad systems. 
 A glance at a short section of a DXF file, see Fig. 2, might lead to the conclusion that whoever designed the format either had shares in a paper manufacturing company, or a grudge against rain forests. 
 A printed DXF file is quickly recognisable by consisting mainly of a narrow strip of short lines down the left hand margin of each page, usually a large number of pages, and a great deal of white paper. 
 It needs to be remembered that the format is not primarily designed for printing on paper; this is just a handy feature.  
 Part of the power of cad is how the powerful graphics capabilities can give a friendly solidness to engineering drawings. 
 Unfortunately, much less friendly is the relation between systems when it comes to file transfer. 
 AutoCAD picture by Nick Manning, AutoDesk  
 Fig. 1. 
 Smooth join between two splines 
 Fig. 2. 
 Binary tree to generate variable length codes 
 Fig. 3. 
 Fragment of DXF file with comments 
 Another feature of DXF files is that alternate lines consist of a simple integer. 
 This is a key point of the format. 
 Each item of information is wrapped up in two lines of the file. 
 The integer declares what kind of information is on the next line, and the following lines gives a name or a numerical value. 
 Fig. 3 shows the same section of DXF file with explanatory comments. 
 It is a long way short of defining the format, but gives the flavour. 
 The very rigid structure looks tedious and clumsy to us humans, but we are not meant to be reading it. 
 Processors like it. 
 Bit image files 
 As powerful as drawing description files can be, they would get a bit unworkable if faced with, say, a colour photograph of a budgerigar. 
 This is exactly the kind of picture which we might want to save from a screen paintbrush job; lovely blends of colour, subtle shades and shapes, and not a straight line anywhere. 
 Images captured from TV, sent back from space, or more prosaically produced by a document scanner, are likely to fall into the same category. 
 For this type of picture the bit image file comes into its own. 
 The picture is written to file in terms of pixels, individual spots of light or ink which, in suitably large numbers, create the picture. 
 In some cases a bit image is little more than a memory dump of video ram. 
 Video ram like most memory, is usually organised in 8-bit wide words, or bytes, but interpreted in a bit oriented manner. 
 Fig. 4 shows the first few bytes of video ram, with addresses running from the base address upwards. 
 For a monochrome monitor, where each pixel is either ON or OFF, each bit will control one pixel. 
 Typically, bits are taken in most significant to least significant order in each byte, and in ascending address order. 
 So starting with b7 of the base address byte and reading left to right across the diagram, the sequence of bits controls the pixels of the top row of the screen, also from left to right. 
 At the end of the top row the sequence of bits starts at the left hand end of the second screen row, and so on. 
 It is obviously convenient for line boundaries to coincide with byte boundaries, and the horizontal resolution of VDU screen is invariably a multiple of eight. 
 For a colour monitor, more than one bit is needed to describe each pixel, and there are two approaches to this. 
 In the &bquo;packed-pixel&equo; method, the sequence of memory bits is divided into blocks according to the number of bits required per pixel. 
 Thus for 16 colour screen, where each pixel requires four bits, each byte would describe two pixels. 
 Typically, bits b7 to b4 of the first byte would control the top left hand pixel, and so on. 
 This is illustrated in Fig. 5, where the first few pixels are more widely spaced simply to fit everything into the diagram. 
 In the &bquo;bit plane&equo; method, Fig. 4 is, in effect, duplicated for as many bits as are needed for each pixel. 
 For a 16 colour monitor, there would be four such sequences of bytes in different blocks of memory, each starting from a different base address. 
 Each memory block is called a &bquo;bit plane&equo;, and supplies one of the bits needed for each pixel. 
 This is illustrated in Fig. 6, showing typical mapping from the start of the four bit plane base addresses and the first line of pixels on the screen. 
 The main body of a bit image file consists of data bytes with bit mapping similar to figs 3 to 5. 
 Bit image files normally have a fixed format header giving general information about the file and its format. 
 One way to handle different bit mapping schemes is to include in the header details such as the number of bit planes, bits per pixel, pixels per scan line, and the number of scan lines. 
 This low level pixel oriented approach obviously makes sense for complex images with no formal structure, such as budgerigars. 
 It does, however, have its drawbacks. 
 One is length. 
 a 640 by 480 pixel 16 colour screen has 307,200 pixels, each described by four bits, thus requiring 153.6 Kbyte of storage. 
 So bit image files frequently use data compression. 
 Since data compression relies on redundancy in the information to be compressed, performance is affected by the nature of the data. 
 There are various methods which can be used for  computer files (see box &bquo;Getting quarts into pint pots&equo;). 
 Run Length Limitation (RLL) is probably the most common for bit image files, although the LZW algorithm is also in use. 
 In the future, compression using techniques from digital TV, or based on fractal theory, could become important. 
 Another problem is compatibility. 
 While a cad transfer file can describe objects with the accuracy of floating point numbers, a bit image file is restricted to a digitising process. 
 Far from being device neutral, the image file is usually coded in a way which reflects the device which first produced it. 
 How should it handle transfers between different resolutions? 
 At first sight the obvious answer might be to convert all images to some enormously high resolution which would satisfy any possible requirement. 
 Mature reflection &mdash; say two seconds &mdash; makes this less attractive. 
 However high you choose this super resolution, the day will come when it's not enough. 
 Another point is that it would make most bit image files far longer than necessary. 
 The best scheme, by far, is to do what is normally done, ie., write a bit image file in terms of the resolution available at the time it is created. 
 If you want to display it on a device with different resolution, you have the following options: &mdash; 
 &mdash; 
 If the new resolution is greater than the original, you can show your entire image at its original resolution in part of your new display device, ie., in a window of it. 
 If you want to, you can expand it to fill the complete display by using a suitable expansion algorithm. 
 &mdash; 
 If the new resolution is less than the original, you can show part of the original at full resolution, and pan it around if appropriate, or compress it to make it all visible. 
 In any case, keep the original bit image file. 
 It represents all of the available picture information, and no surplus information. 
 Remember that any compressed or expanded version of a bit image will contain distortions of the original, however, intelligent the algorithms used. 
 Examples of bit image file formats are: 
 &mdash; 
 Paintbrush/Frieze PCX format: Paintbrush is a screen drawing programme from Zsoft, and Frieze is a terminate-stay-resident utility which can be used by other applications to capture a screen to a. 
 PCX file. 
 I can find Frieze invaluable for capturing graphical output from number crunching software. 
 The PCX format starts with a 128 byte header giving various general details, including bits/pixel, the number of bit planes, and the size of the image in pixels. 
 This is followed by the binary pixel data, compressed with bit oriented Run Length Limitation coding (see box). 
 &mdash; 
 Bit Image (IMG) format: this is used by the GEM system. 
 The header information includes the physical size of each pixel, in microns, thus linking the image firmly to its original representation. 
 The binary pixel information is compressed by RLL coding which can define repetitions of a single bit value, or of a repeated bit pattern. 
 &mdash; 
 Screen files, or SCR, are used by a number of screen painting programmes, including VGA Paint. 
 This format handles the problem of different screen sizes and resolutions by using a filename extension of. 
 SCX, where &bquo;X&equo; indicates the format. 
 Thus, for example, a 16 colour 640 by 480 screen would generate an. 
 SCV file. 
 &mdash; 
 Tag Image File Format (TIFF) (file extension. 
 TIF.) 
 This was developed by the Aldus Corporation and Microsoft particularly for images obtaining from scanning devices, and is widely used in desk top publishing. 
 It is supported by many scanner manufacturers, and can in some cases be produced from fax. 
 It is also supported by a number of screen based graphics applications. 
 The format has a tree like structure which provides more flexibility than most bit image files, and a powerful range of alternative compression methods. 
 Other bit image formats are GIF, which uses LZW compression and is widely used for clip art; PIC, which is used by the Halo screen art programme; and CUT, which uses the enhanced small disk drive RLL compression algorithm. 
 Colour and dithering 
 Like video ram most graphics files support colour by, in effect, indexing into a look up table. 
 If a drawing description file refers to &bquo;COLOUR 1&equo;, the actual colour will be whatever colour 1 is set to. 
 Similarly, if a 16 colour bit image file format refers to red, green, blue and intensity planes, this will only be true of the default palette settings. 
 However, it is quite common for graphics files to allow a colour table to be included, thus defining the palette. 
 A 16 colour PCX file header, for example, includes a 48 byte colour table. 
 Each colour is defined by 3 bytes, one for each of the primary additive colours, red, green and blue. 
 Most printers are monochrome, but the often have a higher resolution than bit image date. 
 Thus they can convert colour to a grey scale by a process called dithering. 
 Although each printer pixel can normally be only black or white, a grey scale can be produced by varying the proportion of black to white dots. 
 Some screen graphics utilities allow the user to improve an image by &bquo;hand dithering&equo;. 
 Page description formats 
 In the early days of computers, printers were basically electrically controlled typewriters. 
 All you could send to them were the printable characters, plus a few simple commands like &bquo;carriage return&equo; and &bquo;line feed&equo;. 
 The ascii code allows for these by setting aside the first 32 values, from 00h to 1Fh, as &bquo;control characters&equo;. 
 As printers became more powerful, it became necessary to send more control information to them, such as to set margin widths or select fonts. 
 The original 32 control codes became inadequate, and &bquo;escape sequences&equo; came into use. 
 The ascii &bquo;Escape&equo; character, 27 or 1Bh, allowed the control process to escape from the limitations of 32 control codes. 
 The convention was adopted that 1Bh introduced a specific sequence of (normally printable) characters which should be interpreted as control information. 
 However, the coding which follows an ESC character tends to be specific to each application. 
 This is a major issue, since not only must the control information be interpreted correctly, but the printer must know when the control characters have finished and it should start interpreting the following characters as text again. 
 One question which arises is why, with 256 code values available in each byte, has this control process limited itself to the 128 7-bit codes? 
 Probably the main reason is the number of printers controlled by RS232 communications using 7 bits plus parity. 
 There is a side benefit, however. 
 Printer control information in 7-bit form remains printable. 
 For de bugging special printer  control software, it is handy to be able to read escape sequences. 
 For this purpose some printers can be put into a special mode in which they print the escape sequences rather than interpret them. 
 Even so, escape sequences are only barely legible. 
 At the start of a document on my printer, a typical command sequence might be: ESC/ESC&lsqb;? 1; 4; 5; 81ESC&lsqb;11hESC &lsqb;? 2hESC&lsqb;7IESC &lsqb;? 0KESC&lsqb; etc 
 Again it needs to be remembered that this sort of coding is designed to be read by a machine, not a human. 
 It is all perfectly logical and unambiguous, but not designed for people. 
 Examples of page description formats are Hewlett-Packard's printer command language (PLC) used for the LaserJet series of printers and the many which emulate it, and the Canon printing system language (CaPSL). 
 Control formats based on escape sequences can be of indefinite length, and page description languages can be extremely powerful. 
 They need to be. 
 The modern printer is normally a bit-mapped device with a wide range of facilities. 
 Before printing a page, the printer's processor assembles a complete bit mapped image into its memory. 
 Like other graphics, fonts can be described in a high level manner, or as bit mapped images. 
 Those stored in high level form are called &bquo;outline&equo; or &bquo;stroked&equo; fonts, and scale much more gracefully than bit image fonts, particularly to large sizes. 
 A pixel addressable printer can obviously reproduce a bit mapped image, and page description formats have developed to allow this. 
 A special escape sequence defines a rectangular area of the page and then introduces a block of pixel data, very similar in principle to a bit image file. 
 The pixel data may be in 8-bit binary words, but it is common for them to be 7-bit binary words, to preserve the capability of 7-bit transmission or coded as ascii hex characters, ie., 0&ndash;9 and a-f, thus also preserving printability. 
 Such a bit image blocks are not normally compressed, and anyone using graphics in a document is familiar with the time it takes to load the printer. 
 A similar process can be used to download soft fonts, which means that a bit mapped printer can be programmed to handle any font, including fonts designed by the user. 
 The flexibility of such printers makes desk top publishing possible, and can also internationalise computer printout with non Latin fonts, such as Japanese characters. 
 Page description languages 
 A more advanced approach to page description is to design a software language which can be used to control the processor of a display device. 
 It may be difficult to define a formal distinction between this and the page description formats described above, but a glance at the results makes the difference obvious. 
 Compare the set of escape sequences in the previous section with Fig. 7, which shows a fragment of the Postscript language. 
 The difference is clear. 
 Postscript is recognisable as something which can be written and read by us humans. 
 It is not the easiest language to learn, but it has structure and legibility. 
 Postscript originated from Adobe Systems, and has become something of a de facto standard for desktop publishing. 
 It is widely supported and cloned, which proves its success. 
 As a language it has some particular features: 
 &mdash; 
 It is an interpreted language. 
 In each application a source file is interpreted in real time. 
 Thus a printer which supports it must contain a Postscript interpreter. 
 The advantage of this approach is compatibility. 
 There are no hardware dependent &bquo;executable&equo; files floating around. 
 &mdash; 
 It is a stack based language. 
 This is the main feature which saves Postscript from the slow execution normally associated with interpreted languages. 
 In some situations Postscript can be faster than the escape sequence type of printer control file. 
 &mdash; 
 It uses post fix notation, where arguments come first and operators follow. 
 This is basically the same as Reverse Polish Notation as used on certain calculators, and follows directly from the stack based approach. 
 &mdash; 
 It can include blocks of bit image graphical data, coded in hex characters. 
 &mdash; 
 It is a large language, with over 300 operators. 
 &mdash; 
 Although it has loops, procedures and conditional operators, in terms of modern software theory it is not strongly structured. 
 Although in theory Postscript could be viewed as a general purpose programming language, it is strongly biassed towards visual representation. 
 However, it should not be viewed simply as a means to control powerful printers. 
 It has an important application in screen graphics, as described below. 
 Graphical User Interfaces 
 A final major application of graphical interchange is in the area of networked computer systems. 
 Early computers were boxes with ports for terminals. 
 The terminals worked on a line by line basis, with the screen information scrolling upwards just as it would on a teleprinter roll. 
 When personal computers became popular (ie., cheap) the fact that the processor was close to the screen was rapidly exploited by application software to give the user a much more dynamic look and feel. 
 Data could pop up in boxes around the screen, and in due course graphics, mice and icons led us into the wimps era (window, icon, menu, pointer). 
 Initially this left the larger machines, with consoles scattered around on the end of RS232 cables, somewhat behind. 
 The line by line console had a distinctly old fashioned look and feel. 
 If PCs were networked, it was normally to share expensive resources, such as printers or mass storage. 
 The application still ran close to the user to give a crisp look and feel. 
 When wider bandwidth networking became available, the ability to move graphical information quickly around a network brought the cental multi user processor concept into the wimps era, and this has required clearly defined standards for the Graphical User Interface (GUI). 
 One such standard is the X Window system, developed by an industry collaboration group and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. 
 It is largely based on the bit image approach, and assumes a resolution of around 100 pixels per inch, which could become a limitation in the future. 
 However, X is very widely supported, and is associated with the Unix operating system and the move to open standards in the IT industry. 
 A competitor to X is Sun Microsystem's Network extensible Window System (NeWS) which in some ways is technicalsuperior. 
 It uses Postscript as the transfer format, thus providing hardware independence. 
 It also makes more powerful features available at the user interface, such as image transformations. 
 Another very neat feature is that one Postscript interpreter can handle both the user's screen and a printer directly from the same source material. 
 Commercial battles are not always won on technical merit, and at present X Windows is probably winning. 
 Whatever the outcome, the movement and control of graphical information is here to stay. 
 Data compression methods 
 Data representation. 
 Economy in bits can be achieved by using more efficient ways to represent data. 
 One example is to pack the seven bits of the ascii code contiguously into 8-bit bytes, thus getting eight characters into seven bytes. 
 Another method is to convert ASCII numerical values into binary words. 
 Such methods are built into several drawing description file formats. 
 Run Length limitation (RLL). 
 This exploits repetition. 
 Instead of &bquo;AAAA&equo;, send &bquo;4A&equo;. 
 Lempel Ziv Welch algorithm (LZW): this uses a larger coding space than necessary for the symbols to be transmitted, and allocates the extra codes to sequences of symbols which occur in the message. 
 Thus each extra code describes a block of several symbols, and with suitable data this can lead to considerable compression. 
 Huffman coding: this is approximately the opposite of LZW, and generates a set of variable length codes for fixed length data items, using the shortest codes for most common data items. 
 Digital TV video compression. 
 The same techniques can be used for bit image files. 
 The most common method is to divide each picture into square blocks of pixels. 
 A mathematical process called the discrete cosine transformation (DCT) is then used to convert pixel values to Fourier coefficients in terms of the frequencies represented by the digitising process in both the horizontal and vertical directions. 
 Fractals, using simple mathematical algorithm to produce complex objects typical of those which occur naturally.  
 Fig. 5 Typical packed-pixl mapping 18-colour screen 
 Fig. 6 Typical bit-plane mapping for 16-colour screen 
 Fig. 7. 
 Fragment of Postscript file 
 pc engineering 
 Curve package that really fits the bill 
 Manually adding best-fit curves to data plots can be laborious and prone to error. 
 Don Bradbury finds Jandel Scientific's TableCurve curve-fitting program has all the right lines. 
 You don't need to be statistician or a graphic artist to be able to use TableCurve &mdash; the professional-standard curve fitting program designed for scientists and engineers. 
 But to benefit from its more esoteric features you certainly need a good comprehension of the underlying processes. 
 Demands made on personal computing skills are minimal, and installation is simple. 
 One command-line switch will make use of a maximum of 512K of expanded memory, either EMS 3.2 or 4.0; another will put overlays into extended memory; a third disables the &bquo;degree of freedom&equo; facility for errors in curve fitting, and a fourth can be used to disable a mouse even if one if fitted and nominally active. 
 If any further additions are made to the dos command line, they are assumed to refer to an ascii file to be loaded directly. 
 Other importable file formats can only be loaded from within the TableCurve environment, so suitable data need only be typed into an ascii file with a word processor or line editor to be used, and a path to any directory on the disk can be included if necessary. 
 Where operation is to be directly from a different data file directory then TableCurve has to be in the dos path. 
 Program start-up is rather annoyingly interrupted by a 15s delay at a screen showing Jandel Scientific's reminder of the licence agreement, followed by a summary screen showing the program's status in terms of memory use, maths coprocessor installation, estimated processing speed rating for the detected hardware, and various user-modifiable program settings. 
 When a file is loaded, the summary screen also shows various details of the data ranges &mdash; minimum, maximum, standard deviation and so on. 
 After processing the data, the equation, selected by the program or user, is also displayed on return to the summary screen. 
 Using the menu system, which can itself be modified to give pop-up, pull-down, or first letter selection of options, the colour scheme can be selected from a choice of four. 
 Other modification options include video mode, in the unlikely event that hardware has been incorrectly read, mouse response speed adjustment, EMS/help arrangements, printer selection, setting of a user option for function key F3 and so on. 
 Help is context-sensitive and very useful, though there can be some delay in retrieval sometimes prompting the worry that the program has not received an instruction. 
 Even longer delays can occur when the printer is set to work. 
 But what looks like a lock-up just means that the program needs time to respond before any further keys are struck &mdash; a &bquo;wait&equo; sign or similar signal could be usefully displayed here. 
 Curve fitting 
 FILE option allows import of any data file in Lotus 1-2-3 worksheets up to version 3.0, dBase, Symphony, Quattro, ascii or directly from the keyboard. 
 Data can also be imported from defined binary files. 
 All these files are listed for cursor selection if the file is in the current directory. 
 Useful demo files plus the &bquo;Mini-Tour&equo; section of the manual demonstrate many of the most-used features of TableCurve. 
 Up to 1500 data points can be accepted on a 640K machine, or up to 3000 points through use of expanded memory. 
 If data is loaded from a spreadsheet file, for example, X and Y variable columns to be used can be selected, and default labels the program  expects to use can be edited. 
 Automatic prescan of data follows for the summary screen, and calculations can be made on a range. 
 If the range maximum is 40 but 100 is preferable, then Y=Y*100/40 could be entered to transpose the range before plotting. 
 TableCurve can calculate the data's best fit to one of its equations, or the plot of the data can be previewed to decide whether any data needs to be edited or excluded, or weighting factors applied prior to processing. 
 Weighting allows pre-judging of the relevance of any points and so reduces emphasis on suspect data. 
 The weighting screen presents twenty options including on-line help, and saving of changes, while others allow sorting of data, changing of titles, reversing of the XY ranges and so on. 
 Data processing is achieved automatically: TableCurve can use all of its 221 equations to find a best fit, or the &bquo;special function&equo; equations can be omitted or &bquo;simple&equo; equations selected. 
 Curve fitting parameters include the correlation coefficient, R-squared, and ranking of fit is according to that factor. 
 But &bquo;goodness of fit&equo; is not the whole of the art of curve fitting &mdash; users are encouraged to step through other equation fits, viewing the data and residuals plots as well as the data tables, and all are very conveniently accomplished. 
 Linear, log, inverse, negative or positive exponential, power, polynomials up to 10th order, rational and special functions including Gaussian, sigmoidal, sine-wave, and user-defined functions are all available. 
 Other parameters of fit include residuals, standard error for coefficients, standard error of fit, analysis of variance, prediction and confidence limits, and descriptive statistics. 
 Processing involves floating point calculations, and speed of processing is heavily dependent on hardware. 
 A maths coprocessor is highly desirable, especially for large data sets, though I didn't use one and the 16MHz 80286 review machine was not unduly slow with files of modest size. 
 Typically, 20 or 30s was required for a full evaluation using all the equations, though processing could have been ten times as quick with an 80287 fitted. 
 Plotting 
 Plotting functions encourage experimentation, allowing not only trials of equations other than that selected as optimum, but also zooming parts of plots to amplify relevance of the fit and resizing the graph to judge extrapolation effects. 
 Four different parts of a plot can be viewed at once on the screen, the X and/or Y scaled between linear and logarithmic and size of the plotted data points changed. 
 Colour scheme can be modified to taste. 
 Variable confidence and prediction internals can be activated, special function parameters displayed, a data summary for a selected equation viewed, and data residuals displayed &mdash; either directly as data, in percentaged form, or graphically. 
 There are also facilities to display the data's standard errors and select polynomial and rational functions. 
 Equations can be evaluated with an &bquo;equation preview&equo; option which provides a calculator-like evaluation process based on the equation currently being reviewed. 
 Various X or Y values are entered, and the corresponding calculated Y or X value, based on the equation in use, is put into the table. 
 In all of these processes, table or graphic, a Micro-Soft-compatible mouse can be used for screen navigation, graphic manipulation help screen calls, item selection, and menu operation. 
 Speed of response can be set over a range of five steps, and may well have to be reset because, particularly in graphics mode, if it is too sensitive, loading up several movement commands into the buffer will require having to wait for them to clear. 
 This is principally because the mouse can roll in  four directions to replicate the equivalent +, &mdash;, * and / keyboard commands to zoom and relocate the graphics. 
 Using a mouse is very convenient &mdash; but some might prefer the keyboard. 
 Output 
 TableCurve output options include printing the curve-fit graphs and the data summaries in a high quality monochrome mode. 
 Choices include full-page graphs alone; to half page graphic and equation summary, or extended equation summaries. 
 Graphic output may be in standard form, a partition (zoomed-in) or extrapolated (zoomed-out) graph, or it may be of residuals alone. 
 Graphic output, printed reports and files of many different types can be produced for use with other programs such as Jandel Scientific's own SigmaPlot. 
 But output can also be used with Lotus 1-2-3 in all versions up to 3.0, Symphony, Quattro and Harvard Graphics. 
 PCX format files can be used with Ventura, Pagemaker and other desk top publishing programs, and metafiles with WordPerfect 5.0 or Word 4.0. 
 Some formats then allow further resizing, editing, and enhancement of the graphic output. 
 Ascii output can also be requested for viewing residuals or generated X-Y data. 
 Avoiding poor analysis 
 Referred to as possible &bquo;pitfalls&equo; in the excellent manual, some of the more likely situations where erroneous deductions should be anticipated are presented. 
 Noise on a signal producing the data points is one, though there is a smoothing routine which effectively overcomes this &mdash; provided it is used with caution. 
 Ill-defined regions of the data, rational equations, unjustified polynomial fits (particularly for extrapolations), failure to examine data at low X and Y values sufficiently, reversing X and Y values, and as the manual puts it, &bquo;trusting numbers rather than the evidence of your own eyes&equo; are some others. 
 Most TableCurve users will already have acquired the necessary good sense to avoid such pitfalls. 
 Those who haven't would do well to browse the informative manual &mdash; an impressive publication liberally sprinkled with graphic illustrations of the program's functions and various points to note. 
 An appendix lists all 221 equations used by the program, and a redefined special functions section deals with non-linear equations which cannot normally be solved by the one-pass direct solution methods used in TableCurve. 
 The program implements a prescan of the data to determine parameters that cannot be resolved by the direct leastsquares method of analysis. 
 In this way, Gaussian, log-normal, sigmoidal, and sinewave data are treated just like the program's other functions of X. Transformed equations, power-fit, exponential, hyperbolic, and others are also discussed in an appendix. 
 Highly recommended 
 TableCurve is intended to be a fast, one-pass curve-fitting program, with minimal user input. 
 Data sets precluded from analysis are well documented, but the great bulk of typical experimental data will be handled. 
 I thoroughly recommended it. 
 Its price reflects the fact that it is not in the category of software expected to sell in millions of copies. 
 But it is undoubtedly easy to use. 
 I was up and running with the package within ten minutes, applying the automatic mode of analysis &mdash; and making sense out of it &mdash; without reference to the manual. 
 Hardware 
 640K allows 1500 data points 512K expanded memory can be used. 
 Maths coprocessor desirable but not essential. 
 MicroSoft-compatible mouse can be used. 
 Supplier details 
 &pound;305 plus &pound;10 postage and VAT. 
 Available in the UK from Jandel Scientific, who also provide support, at The Core Store Ltd., The Studio, Hawthorn Cottage, Marbury Road, Comberbach, Northwich, Cheshire CW9 6AU. 
 Tel: 0606 891980.  
 Confidence and prediction intervals for curve fitting evaluation are available 
 Result of fitting data to lower ranked equation 
 Zoomed-in partitions can be displayed on a single screen 
 Review 
 Hard to resist? 
 Invaluable time-saver for analogue design, Rescalc release 2.0 is much improved and pays for itself within hours, says Ben Duncan 
 Rescalc V2.0 is a nifty &pound;10/&dollar;20 shareware program from the US, for carrying out resistor calculations. 
 It has been designed to streamline the nitty-gritty business of balancing accuracy against available resistor values, tolerances and cost. 
 Version 1 of Rescalc has been around for some years and is today regarded as rather palaeolithic. 
 But this new version has been re-written in Power-Basic. 
 Basic it still is; even so it does more than many scientific calculators, and release 2 computes faster, has a proper menu structure, EGA colour capability and is generally bullet-proof. 
 S for simplicity 
 Instal and test are painless &mdash; taking under five minutes including entry into the menu batch file &mdash; and operation is intuitive. 
 But for users that need more help, documentation is contained in a four-page README.DOC written in &bquo;engineerspeak&equo;. 
 My own copy has been printed and reduced for reference. 
 To start, type S for series or P for parallel, and enter any desired (non standard) value in the range 100R to 1M or more. 
 Rescalc will respond with standard resistor values, listed by accuracy or ascending value, for series or parallel combinations. 
 Accuracy is cited both in percent error and as the shortfall in ohms. 
 For critical missions a single resistor value can be entered, and the package will suggest what value(s) to parallel if, say, a production run of PTH PCBs have been fitted with a 17.4k precision resistor which should have been 14.7k&hellip; 
 Resistors listed all belong to a specific tolerance set. 
 To repeat the calculation for another tolerance set (will a cheap 1% E24 series value give a close enough fit?), just type T and select from the E12, 24, 48 or 96 series, listed under their US aliases, eg 0.1% MIL is E96, and 5% alternative commercial is actually 1% E24. 
 Dividing with E48 into X 
 Dividers and padded dividers or trimmers are handled: enter input and output voltage, and the upper and lower arm values are listed. 
 Typing S (sort) toggles the list on any screen; order of tolerance puts + and &mdash; % ranging either side of zero, otherwise values are listed in ascending numeric order. 
 Percent error is listed for output voltage vs target and sensitivity of output voltage vs resistor values. 
 Fig. 1. 
 screen dump demonstrates biasing a comparator with 240mV for a 2.45V reference source, using E24, alias standard 1% metal film resistors. 
 For padded dividers, the pot or present assumes an E6 value eg 10, 20 or 50k&ohm;. 
 In calculating dividers, all values are condensed into medium values (above 100R). 
 For many circuits, practical values will need to be derived by scaling: but be cautious about accuracy. 
 There is no problem with comparators fed from voltage references. 
 But in many circuits, significant source and load resistances will need factoring out from the upper and lower arm values respectively (and scaled pro-rata), otherwise the implied accuracy will be false). 
 Also rounding errors can affect cases where extreme accuracy is required. 
 It also performs Wye-Delta transformations (handy for network analysis simplification) and defined multi-tap dividers, for up to ten output voltages. 
 Characteristics 
 Speed is fine. 
 On an XT fitted with co-processor, calculation is under 1s for any mode. 
 Scientific notation is accepted (1.23e+8) but not engineering units (n, m, k). 
 README.DOC warns of large values &mdash; I found it would accept up to 9M in series calculations, and 1M in parallel. 
 Values below 10&ohm; are also restricted, but scaling results should hardly tax the brain &mdash; even brains without co-processors. 
 In divider calculations, maximum input voltage is 1kV. 
 As a result of these limits, the maximum divisive ratio is 80dB or 10,000:1, enough for 99% of jobs. 
 Printing (see print dump) is dos PRTSC: boring but reliable. 
 In any future release, two welcome refinements would be the simultaneous inclusion of source and load resistances in divider computations; and audio and communications designers would like to be able to toggle divider ratios and percent error, to read out in dB voltage (log20) and maybe power (log10) deciBels. 
 But, overall, Rescalc V2 will prove invaluable for analogue designers and equipment manufacturers. 
 It should quickly pay for itself by saving computational time, increasing accuracy and reducing parts costs by minimising expenditure on E48 or E96 parts where cheaper E24 values will do.  
 Fig. 1. 
 Biasing a comparator with 240mV for a 2.54V reference source. 
 EDN Design Spotlight 
 Circuits, Systems &amp; Standards 
 First published in the US magazine EDN and edited here by Ian Hickman. 
 NOR gate controls oscillator frequency 
 You can make a simple, stable frequency-shift-keying (FSK) generator by adding an exclusive- OR  gate to a standard cmos oscillator. 
 In this circuit (figure), the data input controls gate IC ID  establishing positive or negative feedback around the oscillator formed by IC IA IC IB  and IC IC . 
 When the data input goes low, IC ID  enters its non-inverting mode, and R2  increases capacitor C's charging rate. 
 When the input returns high, IC ID  inverts, and R2  reduces C's charging current, thus lowering the oscillator's frequency. 
 R1  and C set the oscillator's frequency range, and R2  determines the circuit's frequency shift. 
 To ensure frequency stability, make R3  much greater than R1  and use a high-quality feedback capacitor. 
 Note that the three gates constituting the oscillator itself need not be exclusive-OR types &mdash; you can use any cmos inverter. 
  Richard Rice  
 Simple FSK generator 
 There is an elegance about a circuit which achieves its function with great simplicity. 
 This FSK generator certainly falls into that category. 
 Both centre frequency and shift will be subject to component tolerances, but the circuit fills the bill as is for undemanding applications; alternatively, present can be designed in to allow adjustment to a standard I.H shift such as 170 or 850 Hz. 
  IH  
 Circuit converts voltage ratio to frequency 
 Eaton Corporation 
 The circuit accepts two positive-voltage inputs VN  and VD  and provides a TTL-compatible output pulse train whose repetition rate is proportional to the ratio VN/VD . 
 Full-scale output frequency is about 100 Hz, and linearity error is below 0.5. 
 The output Fo  equals KV N/VD , where K=1 ( 4R2C1 ) and provided R1=R3 . 
 Op amp  IC1A  alternately integrates VN/2  and -VN/2  producing a sawtooth output that ramps between the VD  level and ground. 
 When transistor Q1  is on, for example, IC  integrates -VN/2  until its output equals VD . 
 At that time, the IC IB  comparator switches low, causing IC ID  'S bistable output to go low, which turns off Q1 . 
 IC 1A  's output then ramps in the negative direction. 
 When the output reaches 0V, the IC IC  comparator switches, Q1  turns on, and the cycle repeats. 
 Transistor Q2  converts the IC ID  output to TTL-compatible output logic levels. 
 Setting VD  to 1.00V yields a linear V/F  converter ( Fo=KVN ), and setting VN  to 1.00V yields a reciprocal V/F  converter ( Fo+K/VD ). 
 Find the ratio of two voltages 
 This circuit provided an output voltage proportional to the ratio of two steady input voltages. 
 The same thing could of course be done with two ADCs and software, but in a system without those facilities, this circuit provides a purely hardware implementation. 
 Watch out for settling time when one of the input voltages changes, though. 
  IH  
 Diodes and capacitors: imitate transformers 
 The diode-capacitor network of Fig. 1 accepts low current at a high voltage and delivers higher current at a lower voltage, behaving like a step-down transformer. 
 You drive the circuit with a square wave input signal a shown. 
 When the input is at its peak voltage, Vp,  current through D10, D7, D4 , and D1  charges series capacitors C4, C3, C2 , and C1 . 
 The voltage on each capacitor reaches approximately 1/4 ( VP-4VF ), where VF  is the forward-voltage drop across one diode. 
 However, the total output voltage doesn't equal the sum of the voltages on the four capacitors; it's less than that by two diode drops. 
 Consequently, the circuit is inefficient for low-amplitude drive signals (too much voltage is lost across the diodes). 
 For 15V and 60V p-p inputs, the circuit's corresponding outputs are approximately &mdash; 1.65V and &mdash; 12.9V, depending on the load. 
 An input of 28V p-p produces about &mdash; 5V. 
 Notice that the square-wave generator must sink more current than it sources: it charges the capacitors in series, but discharges them in parallel. 
 When the input terminal switches to 0V, it connects the capacitors in parallel by pulling the positive side of each capacitor near 0V. 
 The capacitor voltages then produce current flow that creates a negative charge across the load capacitor ( CL ). 
 The voltages in ( C3, C2, and C1 ), each charge CL  through two diodes in series, but the charging path through C4  has only one diode, D11 . 
 This configuration results in a higher surge current through D11  and C4  and a slightly higher negative output voltage, unless you add a diode in series with D11 . 
 You can change the output voltage by adding or subtracting sections; C1, D1, D3 , and D2  constitute one section, for example. 
 Make the series capacitors equal in value and the total value of these capacitors equal to the load capacitor: CL = 1/2Vrf , where I is the load current, VR is the maximum allowed p-p ripple voltage, and f  is the output frequency. 
  Rudy Stefenel, Luma Telecom.  
 DC transformer 
 Here is an intriguing circuit which provides a low voltage high current output from a high voltage low (mean) current source. 
 The nominal transformation ratio n in the instance shown is 4:1 step down, but unlike some other voltage-changing schemes using capacitors, n can be any whole number; it is not limited to powers of 2. 
 This advantage apart, the circuit is of limited practical use as the efficiency is not too high due to all the diode drops. 
 But one day someone will invent the perfect rectifier, and then. 
  IH  
 Electronic Circuits, Systems &amp; Standards edited by Ian Hickman, published by Butterworth Heinemann Newnes. 
 ISBN 0 7506 0068 3. price &pound;20. 
 Since its appearance in 1956 the US-based EDN has established itself as a leader in controlled circulation electronics magazines. 
 Now this 'best&equo; of EDN &mdash; with useful information on components, equipment, circuits, systems and standards is available in a 216 page hardback publication. 
 Available from bookshops, or direct by postal application to EW  + WW , Quadrant House, The Quadrant, Sutton Surrey SM2 5AS. 
 Cost &pound;20 plus &pound;1.50 post and packing.  
 An exclusive-OR gate (IC1D) turns a simple cmos oscillator into an FSK generator. 
 When the data input goes high, IC1D inverts, and negative feedback through R2 lowers the circuit's output frequency. 
 A low input results in positive feedback and a higher output frequency. 
 Fig 1 &mdash; This voltage-ratio/frequency converter produces a TTL-compatible output pulse train that equals KVN/VD, where VN and VD are the inputs and K=4R2C1. 
 Linearity error is less than 0.5. 
 Fig 1 &mdash; This diode-capacitor network converts an input square wave to a negative dc voltage. 
 Phase-modulate signals digitally 
 With two low-cost ICs, you can modulate a square-wave carrier's phase in direct proportion to the value of a 4-bit data input. 
 In the required circuit (figure, part (A)), a clock signal running at 16 times the desired carrier frequency drives the 4-binary counter IC1 . 
 The counter's outputs are binary numbers representing 16 equidistant, cyclically generated carrier phase angles. 
 IC2 , a 4-bit full adder, implements the phase modulation by summing the modulating data with each of the carrier phase angles. 
 The instantaneous binary representation of phase angle at the adder's output is offset from the original by a quantity proportional to the input's value (b). 
 Each new data input results in proportional shift in the cyclically generated phases. 
 The adders MSB output is the required phase-modulated square-wave carrier at frequency Fc. 
 If you need a sine wave rather than a square wave, you can add the shaping circuit (reference). 
 The table (c) shows the required data-input connections to the adder for two, four, eight and 16 phases. 
 Note that the circuit is not restricted to 16 phase levels. 
 Using an n-bit counter and an n-bit full adder, you can generate a 2n-level phase-shift-keyed (PSK) signal. 
 Remember, however, that the clock signal driving the binary counter must run at 2n times the required phase-modulated carrier's frequency. 
 For higher speeds, use high-speed logic (ECL, for example). 
 Reference 
 McGuire, Electronics, October 2, 1975, pg 104.15  Nick Boutin, University of Sherbrooke.  
 Digital phase modulator 
 A neat little circuit this, providing up to +180 degrees phase modulation in 22.5 degree steps. 
 If you are going to subsequently multiply, or frequency shift, the output to arrive at the final transmit frequency, then the optional sine shaper can be omitted &mdash; leaving a phase modulator which could scarcely simpler. 
  IH   
 Phase-modulate a carrier with this simple circuit (a). 
 To obtain a sinusoidal output, add the optional shaping circuit: Choose CF for optimum response at the desired frequency. 
 Part (b) shows the phase shifts for the 16 combinations of a 4-bit data input: (C) gives the adder input connections for 2-, 4-, 8- and 16-phase resolution. 
 Interfacing with C 
 by Howard Hutchings 
 Interfacing with C can be obtained from Lindsey Gardner, Room L333, Quadrant House, The Quadrant, Sutton, Surrey SM5 2AS. 
 Please make cheques for &pound;14.95 (which includes postage and packing) payable to Reed Business Publishing Group. 
 Alternatively, you can telephone your order, quoting a credit card number. 
 Telephone 081&ndash;661 3614 (mornings only, please). 
 A disk containing all the example listings used in the book is available at &pound;25.50 + VAT. 
 Please specify size required. 
 C Here! 
 If you have followed our series on the use of the C programming language, then you will recognise its value to the practising engineer. 
 But, rather than turning up old issues of the journal to check your design for a digital filter, why not have all the articles collected together in one book, Interfacing with C? 
 The book is a storehouse of information that will be of lasting value to anyone involved in the design of filters, A-to-D conversion, convolution, Fourier and many other applications, with not a soldering iron in sight. 
 To complement the published series, Howard Hutchings has written additional chapters on D-to-A and A-to-D conversion, waveform synthesis and audio special effects, including echo and reverberation. 
 An appendix provides a &bquo;getting started&equo; introduction to the running of the many programs scattered throughout the book. 
 This is a practical guide to real-time programming, the programs provided having been tested and proved. 
 It is a distillation of the teaching of computer-assisted engineering at Humberside Polytechnic, at which Dr Hutchings is a senior lecturer. 
 Source code listings for the programs described in the book are available on disk.  
 Regulars 
 Circuit ideas 
 Sound sampler filter 
 Using an 8-bit sound sampler board with Atari, Archimedes or Amiga computers for sound analysis in physics and biology requires a sample rate of at least twice the highest signal frequency &mdash; around 20kHz. 
 Some samplers possess a simple low-pass filter rolling off at about 16kHz, but do not remove enough of the signal above 20kHz to allow a sample rate of 40kHz. 
 The diagram shows a low-pass filter to give the necessary performance using an inexpensive LC element which is intended for Nicam systems. 
 Buffering is provided by (formula provided) matching the output to the filter input impedance. 
 Resistor R3 matches the output to IC2 and, together with R4, sets the gain of the circuit, which is 0dB overall when circuit losses are taken into account, Components C1 and R1 form a high-pass filter, rolling off at 3.4Hz or 340Hz, depending on which value is used. 
 Prototype performance was within 1dB between 700Hz and 14.5kHz, with roll-off points at 330Hz and 15.2kHz; above 19.7kHz, signals are at least &mdash; 51dB. 
 The filter is a Toko part, an A258BLV-5085N , from Cirkit and Maplin. 
  L May Rochdale Lancashire  
 Multimeter as frequency meter 
 A digital multimeter makes a good frequency meter with the addition of the circuit shown. 
 In principle, the average direct voltage of a rectangular waveform depends on the ratio of a fixed-width part of the waveform to the variable width of one cycle. 
 In the diagram, the input signal, after any prescaling in IC3a, b, and IC 4a, generates a very narrow pulse at the output of the second Nor, which is used to reset 14-stage binary counter IC1. 
 The counting then proceeds under the control of a built-in crystal-controlled oscillator until Q10 becomes 1, whereupon the oscillator is made to stop. 
 The crystal ensures that the interval between reset and stop is stable and accurate. 
 The width of the interval is (formula supplied) and the cycle time is (formula supplied), so that the average output direct voltage is (formula supplied) where Vdd is the voltage of the power rail. 
 Since Vdd and Tc are constants, output voltage is proportional to input frequency, R5 and C2 smoothing the square wave to give the direct voltage to drive the voltmeter. 
 Switch positions 1 to 4 select the divider outputs to give full-scale ranges of 19.99kHz to 19.99MHz. 
 To calibrate, adjust R3 to give a 1.9V direct-voltage output when the input is 19kHz. 
  Yongping Xia West Virginia University Morgantown WV USA   
 Low-pass filter is steep enough to allow sound sample rate of twice signal frequency, with attenuation of better than 50dB at 20kHz. 
 This circuit, in conjunction with a digital voltmeter, gives a stable and accurate digital reading of frequency from about 50Hz to 19.99MHz. 
 Sine waves from a 4046 VCO 
 AM detection and waveform generation are two of the expanding number of uses for the phase-locked loop IC, the one in question being the 4046 cmos type. 
 Quadrature sine or triangular waves are derived from the VCO timing capacitor in a similar manner to that described in ref.1. 
 Voltage across the timing capacitor C1 is a linear differential sawtooth having a constant peak voltage with frequency. 
 The two fets make up a high input-impedance differential pair with unity gain and over 10MHz bandwidth, which maintains linearity at low charging currents and at high frequencies up to 18MHz. 
 Summing the two fet outputs in Tr3 gives a triangular wave and a small square component, which is removed by taking some of the squares at the VCO output to the summing point. 
 To obtain a sine output, use the two schottky diodes back to back on the summing point to round the triangle: the resulting sine is accurate to about 1% THD. 
 Adjusting VR2 gives a symmetrical waveform and you can do it by ear by reducing the frequency so that only harmonics can be heard. 
 The timing capacitor must be changed to 10nF to do this. 
 With C1 at 40pF and R1 at 3k&ohm;, the HC4046  works up to 18MHz typical, drawing around 10mA. 
 Values of 10nF and 1M&ohm; produce 20Hz. 
  Ian Hegglun Manawatu Polytechnic New Zealand  
 Reference 1. 
 XR-S200 data sheet, Exar Data Book . 
 Motion direction detector 
 I suggest that a simpler approach to detecting the direction of motion of an object, one method of which was put forward by M Kumaran in July, is to use half a 74LS74  D-type flip-flop, as shown in the diagram, which performs exactly the same function. 
  A Clark Boldon Colliery Tyne and Wear  
 D-to-A converter current booster 
 An increase in output current from the popular DAC 08  D-to-A converter is obtainable by means of this circuit, the current accuracy being better than 1% and offset current less than 0.1%. 
 Current gain is 16 precisely and output voltage lies between &mdash; 8V and +25V. 
 The only thing to watch is the likelihood of oddities at large transitions &mdash; all 0s to all 1s, for example. 
 The relatively low slewing rate of the LM308A is responsible for this and imposes a limit on clock frequency of 15kHz if such an eventuality is at all likely. 
  Alexandru Ciubotaru Galati Romania   
 Function generator using a PLL produces square and sine or triangular waves from 20Hz to 18MHz. 
 A simpler motion detector 
 Precisely sixteen times the 2mA output current from a DAC 08, with a low current offset error 
 Speech compressor 
 An article in the July issue reported a method (Simitar) of increasing loudness of communications signals by up to 20dB, mentioning work at Swansea University about 14 years ago. 
 It is possible that an IC will eventually emerge to perform the function but, until then, the following description should allow people to develop their own system. 
 Figure 1 shows the principle. 
 Signal is filtered, digitised and sampled by a microprocessor at a rate of at least 8kHz, samples being processed by the micro and output via a D-to-A converter. 
 At the output, two D-to-As are needed, as seen in Fig.2. 
 Input signal from the micro goes to DAC1, the scale factor being written to DAC2 which, in this configuration, act as a divider to modify the output by the scale factor input from the micro. 
 Any 8-bit microprocessor will work, since no multiplication or division is necessary in the software, although it would be of advantage to use a 16-bit device to do the scaling of signals internally. 
 Software is shown in flowchart form in the table. 
 The micro stores samples as sign/magnitude values in a 64-wide array (SAMPLES) indexed by pointer (PTR). 
 Before doing that, it takes the old sample and writes it to DAC1, so that the array behaves as a 64-character circular buffer which merely delays the samples. 
 This delay allows the micro to determine the signal peak value between zero crossings, each being compared with the last one (IN0) and with a threshold value (THRESHOLD). 
 If greater, the sample is stored in the array PEAKS, indexed by PIN. 
 When a zero crossing is detected, PIN is incremented and PEAKS and IN0 reset. 
 When samples are retrieved they are also zero-crossing tested, the peak value being taken from PEAKS with the second pointer POUT. 
 The DACs give the function OUT1/SCALE to scale each half cycle to the same magnitude, which is said to provide a 20dB increase in loudness, subjectively, with none of the usual speech compression problems. 
 Looking at Fig. 2, The DACs are multiplying current-output types such as the AD7528  from Analog Devices. 
 Current I1 from the first is  
 A somewhat simpler circuit in Fig. 3 eliminates the amplifier and two resistors, the gain being (formula provided) but two low-impedance references are now needed, since high-impedance ones introduce distortion. 
  David Gibson Leeds West Yorkshire   
 Fig. 1. 
 Speech compressor in essence. 
 A sample rate of at least 8kHz is needed and the microprocessor can be any 8-bit variety with simple software. 
 Fig. 2. 
 Two separate DACs perform the functions of conversion and scaling. 
 Fig. 3. 
 Simpler embodiment of the idea with the slight drawback that two high-Z voltage references are needed. 
 Table 1: software flowchart for implementing David Gibson's processor proposal. 
 There is no connection with Dr Louis Thomas' work. 
 signal processsing 
 Building a toolbox for DSP Engineering 
 Allen Brown looks at how to choose the best DSP engineering tools in response to a fast-developing market 
 Digital signal processing (DSP) is generally regarded as one of the fastest expanding areas of electronics. 
 Advent of low cost processors allowing DSP algorithms to be implemented with relative ease means electronics engineers now have much greater awareness of its potential &mdash; certainly not the case five years ago. 
 Continuing commitment and investment by IC manufactures in developing high performance DSP chips points to a very promising future for DSP. 
 The four front runners with the highest market profiles are Texas Instruments (with its ever expanding TMS320 series), Motorola (DSP56000 and DSP96002), Analog Devices (the versatile family of ADSP-210x devices) and AT&amp;T (the long standing DSP32C among others). 
 Several second row contenders such as Zoran, Thomson and Philips are struggling to capture a sizeable foot hole in the market. 
 But it is the Japanese manufacturers who have made a poor showing in the DSP arena &mdash; probably due in part to a lack of commitment and feeble marketing. 
 Other reasons for their conspicuous absence could be an apparent weakness in software, as DSP requires powerful software support tools and availability of these tools is a prime consideration when specifying a DSP for a design project. 
 Initially, when the market was small there were several contestants but some have subsequently fallen. 
 National Semiconductor made a brave attempt with its LM32900, and the take-over of Fairchild saw the demise of the FSP100. 
 Now it appears that the four main front runners will continue to dominate the scene though we are likely to witness some elbowing in the scrum. 
 PC as development tool 
 Despite the degree of criticism levelled at the PC, it remains the most popular tool for developing software for microprocessor and DSP systems. 
 Reasons are that the PC has become the conventional engineering tool; most DSP applications programs run under ms-dos; hardware interfacing of target DSP boards to the PC has become a standard practice, and the PC represents a low cost entry point into the field of DSP development. 
 Windows 3 or other multitasking environments have made software development a little easier because each window can feature a different software tool. 
 But most DSP development software is also available for workstations and Macs. 
 The four main processor manufacturers produce a wealth of software and hardware-development PC-compatible tools so much of the DSP development software will run under ms-dos. 
 Over the past couple of years we have seen application tools embrace the facilities offered by the Windows front end or graphics user interfaces (GUIs). 
 An example of a respectable product which embraces the full potential of GUIs is Texas Instrument's debugger for its TMS320C30 evaluation module &mdash; it has the same screen format as the simulator for the new TMS320C40). 
 However this has not always been the case; the first version of the Texas Instruments TMS32010 simulator had an appalling screen display which relied on scrolling instead of bit mapped refresh. 
 Software development products 
 A suite of software development tools for digital signal processor should include a cross assembler, a linker, a software simulator and a high level language (HLL) compiler which usually means a C compiler. 
 C has become the de facto  primary HLL  now taught as a matter of course to all emerging electronics engineers and their education would be regarded as incomplete without it. 
 Before C, the only method of programming compilers for digital signal processors was to use assembly language, a restriction probably delaying acceptance of DSPs as viable devices. 
 A new assembly language entails yet another learning curve. 
 A language compilers allow a stepping into the shallow end with a gentle wade towards the awaiting DSP sharks in the deep end. 
 In practice, a mix of assembly language and C will be needed. 
 Real-time applications used to require coding exclusively in assembly language whereas the house keeping tasks could be coded in C. But now that the practices of software engineering are coming to bear on DSP projects, the emphasis is on a system approach ensuring quality becomes an intrinsic aspect of design. 
 C's attraction is that it lends itself to structured programming more readily than assembly language programming and it is within a C language shall that the assembly language modules should be inserted. 
 Each assembly language module can be considered as an object with a specific set of rules for data input and output, thus enabling methodical testing techniques to be used. 
 Suspect C compilers 
 Most C compilers conform to the Kernighan and Ritchie standard!, but there is a strong variation in quality of compilers for DSP devices. 
 Whether a compiler is a quality product soon becomes evident, and with some there is the suspicion that they were cobbled together as a response to opposition product innovations. 
 This has resulted in poorly-engineered products &mdash; particularly true for Motorola's C compiler, Version 1.233, for the DSP56001 which is hopelessly inefficient and inserts NOPs (no operation instructions) after every three or four compiled instructions due to pipeliners in the processor. 
 The assembly language code generation from the compiler fails to capitalise on the superb architecture of the chip and in many cases just does not produce executable code from a tried and tested C language source. 
 When the new version of the C compiler is released, I sincerely hope that Motorola does not charge for the update, I also hope it provides an adequate manual not like the scant document which accompanied version 1.233. 
 Analog Devices also has a tarnished image with its C compiler for the ADSP-2101; it was not until version 4 that the maths runtime library became available &mdash; surely a little late in the day for a fundamental component. 
 Texas Instruments, having recognised the wider implications of producing high performance processors, has attached great importance to its C compilers and produces them for their TMS320C25 and TMS320C3x. 
 Compiler for the TMS320C3x produces high optimised code and is supplied with an extensive range of run-time library facilities. 
 Documentation is well written and contains detailed information on usage of the function calls. 
 Of interesting recent developments in C compilers, one which deserves a mention is the XCC (eXtended C Compiler) for the AT&amp;T DSP32(C) floating point processor. 
 Issued by Rich Software and distributed by Bores Signal Processing it contains a number of library functions which allow the DSP32(C) to access the bios of the hose PC. 
 If a user has an expansion card featuring the DSP32(C), then source code can contain the usual graphics and normal input/output instructions found in Microsoft C. 
 As a result C language programs can be run on the DSP32(C) instead of the PC's CPU, giving a quite remarkable increase in performance. 
 A Pascal compiler is also available. 
 Cross assemblers 
 Many real-time applications require source code written in assembler, and most assemblers have relatively steep learning curves for DSPs. 
 The reason for this stems from the parallel and/or pipelined architecture. 
 for number of DSPs a single line of assembly code may contain four or more sub-instructions and learning how to capitalise on the architecture through efficient use of the instruction set does take time. 
 With pipelined architecture, learning is even more difficult since the processor can be executing parts of four lines of code simultaneously. 
 Most assemblers have facilities for creating macros and library functions and have the appropriate facility to allow parameter passing. 
 To accompany the cross assembler a linker will perform the usual task of allocating addresses to the assembled code modules and attaching the run-time libraries to generate an executable program. 
 When programming in assembler, the role of the simulator, copying operation of the DSP chip, can be quite invaluable especially if testing performance of numerical operations. 
 Simulators have come a long way in recent years and today many of them use screen addressing to update the information. 
 An example is the Avocet Avsim321 TM32010 simulator &mdash; a good product as it gives instant visual access to all registers of the processor so users can monitor progress of the program, line by line if required. 
 For processors which have more complex architectures it is not always possible to have all features present on the screen simultaneously &mdash; unless you have dynamic windowing. 
 An example of a software product incorporating this feature is Analog Devices's  simulator for its ADSP-2101. 
 Nature and number of windows is defined by the user and size of the windows is defined by the user and size of the windows is adjustable. 
 An attractive aspect of this approach is that it enables the designer to concentrate on particular areas of the processor's operation. 
 Texas Instruments also has a quality simulator for the TMS320C30 processor which provides the designer with an extensive range of options evoked through the command menu. 
 The help file is well thought out, but not all simulators are as clean to use. 
 The simulator for the AT&amp;T DSP32C (provided by AT&amp;T) has a poor screen display which relies on scrolling refresh. 
 It is not user-friendly and leaves a lot to be desired for a software support product &mdash; rather surprising considering that the DSP32C is a very impressive device. 
 Hardware development tools 
 Simulators are effective for testing small segments of code. 
 But problems do arise when attempting to test complete programs of several segments. 
 They are slow and inappropriate, especially if time is at a premium as is most often the case. 
 In this case, the expansion card hosting the target processor comes to the fore. 
 Success of the PC as an engineering tool must in part be due to its expansion bus and the fact that nearly every type of facility can be found on a PC card. 
 Cards are by far the most effective means of investigating performance of a DSP device. 
 But the user must be patient when learning the ins and outs of an expansion card. 
 Information in the user manual is almost always inadequate leaving new users to find out for themselves how it works &mdash; although this does enhance practical knowledge of the processor. 
 Many companies manufacture expansion cards featuring DSP chips (for example Burr Brown, SMIS and Loughborough Sound Images) and it is true to say that every major DSP chip is available on an expansion card. 
 Choice of an expansion card, with a particular processor, will be determined largely by intended application for the device. 
 If for a general purpose need, then the board should have at least two independent analogue I/O channels, which means two separate A-to-Ds and D-to-As. 
 These should be a minimum of 12-bit, or 16-bit if possible with sampling rates of at least 100kHz. 
 Serial interfacing with appropriate amplifiers should be provided in support. 
 Amount of memory to be found on expansion cards will usually be small owing to cost (a minimum of 16K depth). 
 Fast, zero wait state sram is expensive and since many DSPs have 24-bit data buses, can prove to be quite costly. 
 If you are lucky you might get a codex thrown in for a good measure for telecomms application. 
 An attraction of the PC expansion card is the ease with which data can be transferred between the card and memory on the host PC &mdash; particularly useful for testing and debugging software. 
 Instead of using the traditional patch in the machine code, the user can switch to an editor in another &bquo;window&equo; to allow the changes to be made at source. 
 Considering the options 
 The PC expansion card is not the only standard to host DSPs; VME boards have also proved to be a popular choice with several manufacturers. 
 Of course they represent a greater investment than PC cards. 
 But flexibility of the VME standard does have its advantages especially if previously designed systems were based on it. 
 Data Beta of Theale, for example, produce a VME board hosting two Motorola 96002 floating point processors. 
 It is a particularly potent device for signal analysis since it can perform a 1024 point FFT in under 700&micro;s. 
 Of late, stand-alone evaluation boards have fallen out of favour, mainly for two reasons; many evaluation boards use difficult to standardise RS-232 links, and the boards require a power supply with +-12V for the RS-232 link and another 5V for the power rail. 
 Using a PC expansion card drawing power from the PC avoids the hassle of both problems. 
 Their advantage is the presence of a wire wrap area found on some for user modifications. 
 But on the whole they are expensive and because the RS-232 link communications is slow, it is difficult to take advantage of a GUI environment. 
 Once a user is convinced that the DSP chip is capable of fulfilling the system requirements then it is time to start the design for  real, probably design of an embedded system. 
 Two main hardware tools are at the disposal of the designer, an in-circuit emulator and a logic analyser with processor's code dis-assembler. 
 Needless to say these represent a large investment costs at several &pound;k for the logic analyser. 
 A belief held by a number of software designers is that if the software is properly designed then there should be no need for an emulator; it should work first time. 
 But few engineers subscribe to this theory and at the end of the day it is the hardware engineer who has to &bquo;get the thing working&equo;. 
 Emulators will still be needed, for the foreseeable future at least, though their design is becoming increasingly more difficult with every rising clock speeds. 
 Emulators are available for the major DSP chips and their facilities can show considerable variation &mdash; getting inside the processor to determine its state, especially during interrupts is often a necessary requirement. 
 Core features 
 Features expected in a DSP emulator are not too different from those for general purpose micros. 
 In many cases they are actually simpler since a complete instruction is executed in a single machine cycle unlike a microprocessor which may make several memory access when executing a single instruction. 
 But what are these facilities? 
 Some processor memory should be available to act as external emulation memory for the processor and there should also be adequate memory to allow a trigger trace analysis to be performed. 
 There should be scope for at least 256 instructions traced before the trigger and possibly 256 instructions traced after the trigger. 
 Trigger condition should be configured from multiple logic conditions. 
 Ability to set multiple software and hardware break points is also necessary. 
 Software application products 
 There is a range of other software application programs on the market which may be described as design aids. 
 Most common category is that of digital filter design programs and there are several of these and most of them have common features. 
 Broadly speaking these include: 
 FIR filter design using the Parks McClellan and Window design methods, Differentiator and Hilbert transform design, IIR filters based on bilinear transform method, Display transfer functions, impulse response and pole/zero positions, Design filter directly from transfer function plane by specifying frequency cut-offs and attenuation levels, Quantise coefficient to a given word size, and Code generation for specified DSP device. 
 Most digital signal design application programs have emanated from US (reviews of a number of these products will appear in forthcoming editions of EW  + WW ). 
 One of the first to emerge was DFDP from Atlanta Signal processing (Fig. 1), at one time marketed by Texas Instruments. 
 Sourced in Fortran it contains several of the features listed above. 
 Momentum Data Systems of Costa Mesa produces a filter design program, Filter Design &amp; Analysis, which performs well (Fig. 2.) 
 Monarch of Gainesville also produces a filter design program entitled DSP Development System, containing a wide selection of filter design features). 
 These packages are dedicated filter design programs. 
 But another group of commercial programs offer filter design as a part of the package. 
 Hypersignal Workstation (reviewed May 1990) and DisPlay-XL (reviewed May 1991) are two such products. 
 Signal Technology of Goleta, produces a comprehensive application product (Integrated Laboratory Systems &mdash; ILS) having digital filter design as a part. 
 Although not as extensive in its filter design as some of the above, it is still an impressive product. 
 DSP and software engineering 
 Future systems which contain DSP technology will have to be properly engineered. 
 Since they will have a substantial amount of software embedded, then techniques of software engineering will have to be heeded in their manufacture &mdash; a necessary step in ensuring quality and verification. 
 Techniques such as object oriented design and structured programming will have to be followed to conform to engineering practice. 
 Power of DSP devices will necessitate multitasking in real-time, invariably involving operating systems with real-time kernels. 
 Spectron of Santa Barbara has already recognised this requirement and produced a real-time operating system for DSP applications. 
 Referred to as Spox, the OS can be hosted by Texas Instruments third generation products and by the Motorola DSP96002 processor. 
 Normal features expected in an OS are present including task scheduling, interrupt handling and resource management. 
 DSP based products will represent a rich blend of several engineering disciplines, signal processing, digital and analogue hardware design, systems engineering and software engineering. 
 Finding engineers able to master all these areas is going to be difficult. 
 But help is at hand. 
 Products mentioned all run under dos and many are available to run under other operating systems used by workstations. 
 A software product which runs exclusively on workstations is Signal Processing WorkSystem of SPW from Comdisco. 
 This is a very comprehensive development tool allowing the engineer to make an entry at virtually any level in the design phase of a DSP based product. 
 (A full review will be appearing in a later edition of EW  + WW . 
 References 1. 
 B.W. Kernighan and D M Ritchie. 
 The C Programming Language , Prentice Hall, second edition (1978).  
 Computer General Panther with TMS320C30 processor can turn the PC into a 33Mflop workstation. 
 Applications can be written using the T1 software suite supplies consisting of a C compiler, assembler and linker. 
 Fig. 1. 
 Display from DFDP (the current version uses EGA) showing plot of a response of a filter design. 
 Fig. 2. 
 Momentum's filter design product performs well; characteristic plot of a filter transfer function. 
 Fig. 3. 
 Digital filter design is part of ILS's product and though not as extensive in its filter design as some of the others, it is still impressive. 
 Education 
 Lessons in applied science 
 King's College recently opened its doors to show off research work at the department of Electrical and Electronic Engineering. 
 Fibre optics, communications systems, integrated circuits and digital signal processing were all well represented and, strikingly, most of the research is aimed at practical applications. 
 Andy Gothard returns to the Alma Mater. 
 One might not expect sawing a Renault 5 in half to constitute part of an electronics research project, but that's what they call it at sub-basement level, below the Strand. 
 The &bquo;Renault 2.5&equo; is part of Drivage , and EC-funded project intended to assess the performance of older drivers, and work out what technical advances might be useful to older age groups. 
 The project has involved collaboration with the college geography department, and the traffic studies centre of the University of Groningen, in Holland. 
 The car is part of a driving simulator, which uses a Philips video disc player, in conjunction with an Acorn Archimedes A440 computer, to project video images onto a screen. 
 The screen replaces the car windscreen, and on it is shown a road scene that has been recorded on video tape, and transferred to disk. 
 A C program runs on the Archimedes, and controls the playback rate in response to the subject &mdash; the &bquo;driver&equo; of the car &mdash; working the brake and accelerator. 
 The task is to follow lead car, which also appears on the screen, and travels at a varying rate. 
 The subject is told to keep the lead car at a constant, safe distance. 
 Alarm messages appear on the screen if the chase car gets too close to, or too far from, the lead car. 
 System state is recorded three times a second, the data being preprocessed on the Archimedes before being passed to the college VAX cluster for statistical analysis. 
 Although drivers cannot &bquo;steer&equo; the car in the current simulation, they do get a convincing impression of speed and distance, as well as  a scene recorded from real life. 
 It is also possible to set drivers a distracting task &mdash; for instance, a led on the car dashboard may light occasionally, requiring the driver to push a switch to cancel it. 
 The research should help quantify the differences between older and younger drivers. 
 So far, 150 have been tested, and the full statistical results will be available soon. 
 The research team's David Fraser says that preliminary results indicate that the range of driving performance is age independent, far outstripping variations between groups. 
 So next time you're stuck in your car behind that little old lady's Austin 1100, remember, statistically, she's probably no worse a driver than the 20-year-old in the Porsche which is about to overtake you both. 
 The sound of fractals 
 Chaos and fractal imagery have hit the technical and popular imagination over the last few years, and the King's DSP group is working on a number of applications for this new branch of mathematics. 
 In one of them, researcher Jonathan Mackenzie is using the ideas behind fractal geometry to synthesise sounds. 
 Mackenzie's technique uses a variant of Michael Barnsley's iterated function system, called a fractal interpolation function. 
 Taking a (sampled) waveform as its starting point, the function fills in gaps between samples with a replica of the original waveform, contracted in time. 
 Results are &bquo;self-similar&equo; waveforms which, like the classic fractal patterns, look the same as magnification increases. 
 All this is achieved using some C code, running on an IBM clone. 
 The sounds produced have a fractal sound quality &mdash; they sound the same whether the sample generated by the program is delivered quickly or slowly. 
 The most interesting noises emanating from Mackenzie's bench are quite hard to describe, being a combination of rhythm and timbre. 
 The next stage in the work, Mackenzie says, will be to produce a real-time version of the system, using a Texas Instruments TMS320C30 DSP chip, which will be able to deliver a short sequence of the waveform, while doing the maths to generate the next section. 
 This in turn will allow the generation of continuous sounds, and sounds which change with time. 
 It should also be possible to use the computer screen as a kind of operator panel, allowing the user of the system to modify, in real time, the interpolation points. 
 Mackenzie is also looking at other mathematical techniques for  analysing  and synthesising waveforms. 
 These include the wavelet transform, which can give a measure of the fractal qualities of a given sound, and something called the granular synthesis model, which considers sound as consisting of quanta localised both in time and frequency. 
 Gallium arsenide filter 
 Downstairs, under the aegis of Professor Garth Swanson, researcher Jim Luck is looking into the possibilities of designing and fabricating monolithic high-frequency filters, using gallium arsenide GaAs insulated gate field effect transistors (igfets). 
 Igfets have strange characteristics, which mean that they are not much use at frequencies of below a few kilohertz. 
 They are essentially depletion mode devices, which might suggest that they conduct electricity when no bias is applied, and conduct less under bias. 
 In fact, the same igfet can operate as &bquo;normally on&equo;, or &bquo;normally off&equo;. 
 The reason lies in what happens at the insulated gate itself.  
 The structure of the igfet leads to what are known as surface states. 
 This means that, where GaAs meets the insulating layer, electrons can exist at energies not usually allowable in plain old n-type GaAs. 
 Surface states are neither in the conduction band (i.e. free, and able to conduct electricity) nor in the valence band (busy keeping the crystal structure together), but somewhere in between. 
 The net result is that trying to create a region beneath the gate where there are no electrons (a depletion layer) becomes very hard work indeed. 
 Putting a negative bias on the gate simply frees up electrons living in the surface states, which promptly (within 1ms) undeplete the layer. 
 This seems to indicate that the igfet should not be of much use and, indeed, this is the case at low frequencies of operation. 
 But if the gate voltage is clocked very quickly (at tens of megahertz), the negative-going edges of the clock pulse produce depletion, and the positive-going edges (which restore the previous status quo) arrive before the surface charge has had a chance to confuse matters. 
 This is why the devices can be both normally on or normally off. 
 They respond to changes in gate potential, not absolute levels &mdash; switching between 0 and 3V looks the same to an igfet as switching between &mdash; 3 and 0V. 
 Perhaps the easiest way of looking at this is to think of the surface states as a charge store, which effectively shifts the switching level of the device. 
 In addition to its unusual electrical properties, the igfet is simple to make, and, because of the insulated gate structure, current into the gate is virtually eliminated. 
 All of this makes it very attractive for the application which Luck and Swanson have been working on &mdash; the construction of switched capacitor filter circuits. 
 Switched capacitor circuits normally use silicon mosfets, of GaAs mesfets. 
 But the former will only switch at a relatively low speed (42MHz), and the latter produce complex, power-hungry circuits. 
 The igfet SC implementation constructed at King's uses a chip designed at University College, and fabricated at Plessey III/V for the operational amplifier and capacitor parts of the  circuit. 
 King's itself made the igfets, using a gate length of 5micron, and 5micron access regions. 
 The resulting first-order filter circuit clocks at 25MHz, and produces a measured characteristic which is within 0.04dB of the theoretical value at the 1MHz cut-off frequency. 
 The DC power consumption of 190mW is entirely dissipated in the operational amplifiers and, when operating, the igfets consume around 20&micro;W per switch. 
 This, says Luck, compares with 80mW per switch for a corresponding mesfet implementation. 
 Luck also managed to demonstrate the circuit's insensitivity to the DC level of the clock signal using a low-frequency version. 
 Changing the DC level by 5V produced a change in filter characteristic of less than 0.1dB. 
 Garth Swanson says that the existing work could be extended fairly easily to switching speeds of 625MHz by making the igfets on a 1&micro;m process, now standard fare in the semiconductor industry. 
 In fact, the idea lends itself to fabrication as a single IC- clock distribution is not much of a problem, because of the insensitivity to DC level, and transistor count is low, because each of the switches is formed by a single igfet, rather than, for instance, several mesfets. 
 The switching elements are also micropower. 
 Semi chips are a gas 
 Swanson is also involved in studies on fabrication techniques for III/V ICs. 
 Part of this is Patrick Dainty's work on a technology called remote plasma enhanced chemical vapour deposition (RPECVD). 
 Although III/V substances such as GaAs and InGaAs are increasingly being used commercially, their usefulness is still constrained by what is known as final passivation &mdash; the last layer of the IC structure which protects the works against mechanical shocks and contamination (for instance by water), and also provides electrical isolation. 
 The problem is to produce a high quality insulator, without heating the substrate so much that the substrate itself suffers. 
 The temperature needs to be kept below 400&deg;C, which compares with a figure of 1200&deg;C for thermal oxidation of the other main semiconductor, silicon. 
 The substance of choice for passivation layers is silicon nitrite, Si3N4, and the manufacturing technology is plasma enhanced chemical vapour deposition (PECVD). 
 The whole growth process takes place in a plasma chamber, and therein lies the problem. 
 The high energy plasma can cause damage at the semiconductor/insulator interface, which in turn gives rise to leakage currents and poor isolation (this mechanism actually involves the creation of the surface states used to good effect in Jim Luck's igfets). 
 This, according to Dainty, causes low-frequency noise in microwave circuits, and can increase the dark-current of photodiodes. 
 The answer, apparently, is remote PECVD which removes the substrate from the plasma chamber. 
 Dainty's work has so far concentrated on using the technique to grow silicon nitride on silicon, with the hope of a later move to III/V substrates. 
 The way it works is by injecting nitrogen gas into a 2.45GHz microwave plasma. 
 This produces so-called activenitrogen, which passes out of the plasma region. 
 Silane, SiH4 is injected into the active nitrogen stream, and reacts with it to produce SiH. 
 When this jet of gas reaches the substrate, reactions with other nitrogen species produce a passivation layer. 
 The resulting layers have high breakdown electric fields (3MV/cm), and are highly uniform. 
 The layer thickness is around 0.1&micro;m, with a tolerance across an entire wafer of +-5%. 
 The layer quality is assessed primarily by capacitance measurements, which can be used to demonstrate the low occurrence of surface states. 
 The next stage of the work, says Dainty, is to eliminate a layer phenomenon called ionic motion, which shows up as slight hysteresis in the capacitance/voltage plot of the layer. 
 There are also prospects for the deposition of silicon dioxide, and silicon oxy-nitride. 
 Measuring current with light 
 Another area of activity for King's is in fibre optics. 
 Research projects presided over by professor Alan Rogers include the identification of large molecules, such as those of interest in medical tests, the production of fibre lasers, and the design of distributed measuring systems. 
 One of the projects close to commercial realisation uses optical fibre to sense a current flowing in a conductor. 
 The interesting part is that the measuring fibre does not need to be part of the current carrying circuit, giving a high degree of electrical isolation. 
 The physical basis of the measurement leads to a linear response over a wide dynamic range, and reduces saturation and hysteresis effects. 
 The technique relies on the use of high birefringence fibre. 
 This supports two distinct modes of light propagation polarised at right angles to each other. 
 Under normal circumstances, there is no coupling between the two modes, which have different propagation constants. 
 However, when the fibre is put into a spatially varying magnetic field, a phenomenon called Faraday rotation comes into play. 
 This effectively changes the polarisation direction, and can cause coupling between the two modes. 
 So, if the current of interest can be made to produce a magnetic field which varies in the right way along the length of the fibre, this can be used to measure current. 
 Danny McStay and Welland Chu are the researchers working on the project. 
 They have devised several ways of producing the required magnetic field, including a slotted busbar (such as might be used in a power station) around which the fibre can be wrapped. 
 It should be possible to dope or magnetically insulate the fibre itself, producing an effective periodic variation in field, without any mechanical changes to the conductor itself. 
 Temperature dependence is an area which requires further development. 
 The characteristics of optical fibre change with temperature, sufficiently to change the required magnetic field period. 
 This problem can be eliminated by, for instance, producing a bus bar with a range of slot spacings or doping the fibre to produce a slight spread of magnetic field period. 
 This effectively spreads out the resonance peak (which at a steady temperature is very sharp), and produces strong coupling at a range of temperatures.  
 Measuring current with light: Danny McStay (left) and Welland Chu harness Faraday rotation to vary the degree of coupling between a pair of optical fibres carrying polarised light. 
 This has obvious implications for making floating current measurements in high voltage distribution systems. 
 The inset picture shows a slotted bus-bar for use with the optical sensor. 
 A fractal description originally developed by mathematician Michael Barnsley, has been adapted to digitally sampled audio. 
 The result is the unusual sound of fractal based audio. 
 King's Researcher Jonathan Mackenzie used Barnsley's Iterated Function System to fill in the gaps between sample points with a fractal representation of a low frequency signal. 
 Fig. 1 shows the waveform resulting from three iterations of a sine wave. 
 Note the high frequency content appearance in contrast to the squarewave which results from the addition of simple waveform harmonics. 
 Mackenzie went on to produce fractal sounds from sampled real world waveforms. 
 Figs. 2a, b and c show successive waveform expansions of fractal processed wind noise. 
 The visual similarity in the detailed structure is obvious as is the regular nature of the rhythm (Fig. 3 above left). 
 Mackenzie reports that the resulting sound is &bquo;disappointing&equo; and has a low volume &bquo;wind like rumble in the background with a louder whine on top&equo;. 
 However, it remains exciting from the experimental point of view. 
 The sound remains the same when played back at half the speed but lasts for twice as long. 
 Galluim Arsenide fets processed with a special surface deposition exhibit indeterminate switch-on thresholds at low frequencies but work like normal transistors at higher frequencies. 
 In other words, they only respond to the differential of input signal waveforms to create single transistor hi-pass filters. 
 The circuit (Fig. 4a, middle left) shows a first order switched capacitor integrator where each switch element is implemented with a single GaAs igfet device replacing the multi-device circuits required by standard mesfet technology. 
 The accompanying graph (4b, bottom) shows the predicability &mdash; with 0.04dB between measured and theoretical &mdash; of the filter circuit when clocked at 25MHz. 
 RPECVD removes the substrate and one of the reactant gases from the plasma zone 
 Regulars 
 Applications 
 Amplifier for microphones and moving-coil pickups 
 Low-noise (formula provided), low-distortion microphone preamplifier enables phantom powering of the microphone and allows the use of a 20dB pad at the input. 
 The circuit at the amplifier output is an automatic DC restorer to remove DC offsets from the output, with an LF cut-off of 1.6Hz. 
 Gain of the INA103  is present by the connection of internal resistors to provide gain of 1 or 100, but the potentiometer (right) shows how external resistors can be used to obtain other settings; gain is determined from RG = 6/ (G-1) k, G  being the gain. 
 Feedback resistors of 3k&ohm; are included in the chip but, again, external resistors can be used for other gain settings; care must be exercised here, though, to avoid instability, increased noise and reduced bandwidth. 
 Output voltage offset is trimmable in the usual way by a pot between null pins, although this method does have the slight disadvantage that input offset is affected: 1mV of output offset change alters input offset by about 1&micro;V, also altering output offset drift by 3&micro;V/&deg;C per 1mV. 
 The application note provides details of other offset adjustment circuits. 
 Burr-Brown International Ltd, 1 Millfield House, Woodshots Meadow Watford, Hertfordshire WD1 8YX. 
 Telephone 923 33837. 
 Low-power frequency synthesizer 
 A cmos high-performance frequency synthesizer, the UMF1009T  from Philips is intended for use in channelled VHF/UHF equipment such as portable and mobile radio and is programmable via the standard two-line serial I2C bus. 
 The main divider consists of a 7-bit binary counter and two rate selectors to control the external programmable prescaler and the 7-bit internal programmable divider ( n2/n2+1 ). 
 The total division ratio from the DIV input to the input to the phase detector (Fig.2) is N = (128. n2 + nl) *A + n0 , where n0, n1 and n2 are less than 128. 
 If this ratio is expressed  as a binary number and A is 128, the n0 selector contains least significant bits, n1 the next seven bits and n2 the MSBs. 
 The output of this divider is taken to the phase detectors. 
 Also driving the phase detectors is the reference oscillator chain, which consists of a crystal oscillator with an external crystal resonating at up to 16.8MHz and a reference divider in two sections. 
 The first section is programmed to give an output at 1.2MHz and the second to produce 12.5kHz or 15kHz output to the phase detectors, a wide choice of frequency input thereby being possible. 
 Two phase detectors, analogue and digital, work together to produce good noise performance and fast locking. 
 When lock is achieved, the digital detector is switched out of circuit to avoid noise denigration in the analogue circuit. 
 Philips Semiconductors Mullard House Torrington Place London WC1E 7HD 071 580 6633. 
 Power mos electronic ignition provides an alternative to contact breakers. 
 As is pointed in International Rectifier's note AN-969m power mosfets possess advantages over bipolar transistors for ignition circuits, chiefly because of the high voltages then must withstand when used in place of a conventional mechanical contact breaker. 
 Power mosfets exhibit no secondary breakdown and can be avalanched to clamp excessive overvoltage due to leakage inductance or a disconnected HT lead. 
 Also, they need no base drive, being voltage controlled. 
 The note explains that the series resistance of the mosfet need not lead to inefficiency and a circuit performing at higher efficiency than the one using bipolars is feasible. 
 Modern ignition coils are of low inductance with ballast resistors for improved cold starting; inductive discharge circuits, as opposed to the older capacitive discharge types, require the discharge of typically 6A, a bipolar transistor needing safe-operating-area clamps, which increase both cost and dissipation. 
 Mosfets do not suffer from this limitation. 
 Figure 1 shows a practical ignition circuit with a built-in test oscillator R (formula provided). 
 Mosfet Q6 avalanches repetitively and absorbs the energy stored in the leakage inductance of the coil. 
 The photograph shows the waveforms of HT voltage (upper) at 5kV/div and drain/source voltage across Q6 at 100V/div. 
 Battery voltage is 4.5V and HT terminal unterminated. 
 The photograph shows conditions equivalent to an engine speed of 6000rpm for a n eight-cylinder engine. 
 At idling speed, increased dwell angle would increase aiming voltage to around 16kV. 
 International Rectifier, Hurst Green, Oxted, Surrey RH8 9BB. 
 Telephone 0883 713215.  
 Use of the INA103: this is a microphone preamplifier with the microphone phantom powered and a DC-restoration circuit at the output. 
 Circuit to adjust offset with no effect on input offset or input offset drift. 
 INA103 block diagram 
 Fig. 1. 
 Application of the UMF1009T. 
 The arrangement of counters allows a range of oscillator frequencies to be adopted. 
 Fig. 2. 
 Internal block diagram of Philips's UMF1009T low-power frequency synthesizer for mobile and portable VHF/UHF use. 
 All division ratios are programmable via a standard 12C bus 
 Fig. 1. 
 circuit diagram of electronic ignition circuit using power mosfet and low-inductance coil. 
 The IC is a 556 (dual 555) operating as a charge pump to provide gate drive voltage for the IRF740 power switching transistor. 
 The oscilloscope picture shows the plug voltage and the voltage across the mosfet switch. 
 The battery voltage is just 4.5V and the plug unterminated. 
 The spark duration is much longer than the 150&micro;s indicated by this trace. 
 Applying multipliers 
 Accuracy normally found only in more expensive hybrid or modular designs is provided by the Analog Devices AD534 IC four-quadrant multiplier. 
 Internal trimming allows a claim of better than +-0.25% multiplication error with no external trim and AD says it is the first type to offer fully differential, high input-impedance working on all inputs, including the Z input. 
 A maximum gain of 100 and noise down to 90&micro;V eliminate the need for a following amplifier in many cases, the gain being available in all operating modes. 
 There is a differential Z input and all the standard multiplication, division, squaring and square-rooting functions are possible, with no input/output polarity limitations, current output being allowed, if required. 
 The device uses the Gilbert technique, shown in Fig. 1, in which X, Y and Z inputs are converted to currents, trimmed for zero offset, the products of X and Y currents being multiplied using Gilbert's translinear technique which is described in the Analog Devices Non-linear Circuits Handbook. 
 A buried zener provides a 10V reference, so that the output voltage is XY/10-Z. 
 Scale factor is adjustable by an external resistor connected to SF and &mdash; Vs. 
 For signals applied to the Y input, with X at 10V, non-linearity is +-0.005% in full scale, although a different input arrangement with X variable leads to reduced non-linearity claims. 
 Figure 2 shows connection for multiplier, where the output is (formula provided). 
 When minimum AC feedthrough is needed in, for example, a suppressed-carrier modulator, a +-30MV trim voltage can be applied to the X or Y input. 
 Input Z can be used as a summing input. 
 When used as a squarer, X and Y are in parallel, the differential inputs giving polarity information (negative output if either of the inputs is reversed). 
 For low inputs, a feedback attenuator compensates for the reduced output; the difference-of-squares circuit in Fig. 3, for example, used the attenuator to cancel the factor of 2 loss in gain caused by the sum term generation. 
 Figure 4, an RMS-to-DC converter, also used the difference-of-squares function. 
 The filter is an integrator, its input being zeroed by the feedback loop when (formula provided). 
 As a divider (Fig.5), the Z input becomes the numerator, the denominator being at X. Gain is, again, adjustable by the use of an attenuator between output and Y2, a technique that is used to advantage in the percentage computer in Fig. 6, which gives the percentage deviation of A against B on a scale of 1 V per 1%. 
 AD's 1990/91 Linear Products Data Book gives more applications for the device, as well as general information on the use of this and other products. 
 Analog Devices Ltd, Station Avenue, Walton-on-Thames, Surrey KT12 1PF. 
 Telephone 932 253320.  
 Fig. 1. 
 Functions of the AD534, a four-quadrant IC multiplier with an accuracy associated with hybrid devices. 
 The device uses the Gilbert technique, shown in Fig. 1, in which X, Y and Z inputs are converted to currents, trimmed for zero offset, the products of X and T currents. 
 Fig. 2. 
 Connecting the AD534 as a unity-scaled multiplier. 
 Fig. 3. 
 Difference-of-squares circuit uses feedback attenuation to compensate for lost output 
 Fig. 4. 
 Wide-band RMS-to-DC converter, using difference-of-squares technique 
 Fig. 5. 
 AD534 used as a divider, providing differential operation on both numerator and denominator 
 Fig. 6. 
 Percentage computer to give percentage variation of one input against the other. 
 Hypothesis 
 Power lines, cancer and cyclotron resonance 
 Living close to overhead power lines may increase the risk of cancer in humans. 
 Harold Aspden hypothesises on the cause&hellip; and the cure. 
 But PowerGen and National Power won't like it. 
 Living close to overhead electric power lines causes health hazards. 
 At least this appears to be the conclusion of epidemiological studies about weak electro-magnetic exposure and cancer. 
 This might be attributed to cyclotron resonance induced in human body cells by weak electromagnetic fields. 
 This effect can be eliminated, but only if we cease to use our 50Hz or 60Hz frequencies and rely on DC exclusively or, alternatively, double the operating frequency to 100Hz or 120Hz. 
 A possible link between cancer and electromagnetic radiation from power lines and appliances has now been accepted by the US Environmental Protection Agency. 
 I suggest that the effect can be traced, experimentally, to a resonance effect known in physics as cyclotron resonance. 
 In a cyclotron, a modest electric field can accelerate a moving ion into enormous energy levels by a gradual resonant build up. 
 This is caused by energy from a weak field pulsating in harmony with the resonant frequency of ion motion in a steady magnetic field. 
 In the case of the human body, that steady field is the Earth's magnetic field. 
 The ions in motion are those chemical ions in body fluids and present within body cells. 
 The activating field producing resonance is the electric and magnetic field set up by an overhead power line or magnetic field producing appliance such as an electric blanket, etc. 
 On this matter, some point out that, assuming electromagnetic radiation does have an effect, it can only proliferate cancers already present. 
 This view is not convincing given that we all have a latent capacity to develop cancer cells through oncogene gene sectors; exposure to fields might reasonably be supposed to accelerate transmutations. 
 Hazardous frequency range 
 Cyclotron resonance by my theory only occurs if the hazardous frequency range lies with the exciting field. 
 Unfortunately, the 50Hz or 60Hz frequencies, relating to the two-pole magnetising rotor fields on synchronous alternators (running at a speed of 3,000 or 3,600 rpm), happen to be close to the frequency at which ions in bodies respond to, while in 50&micro;T of the geomagnetic field. 
 The cyclotron formula requires that the angular frequency of the resonance should be simply Hq/m, where H is the strength of the geomagnetic field and q/m is the charge to mass ratio of the ion. 
 For a unit atomic  mass q/m is 96 million coulombs per kg. 
 Therefore, if H is 50&micro;T, an ion of unit atomic mass and the normal unit charge will have a cyclotron angular frequency of about 4800 rad/s or about 760Hz. 
 In a separate publication1, I feel that I have shown that the inter-reaction processes involved when two dominant forms of ion are present can cause one ion form to screen the geomagnetic field effective on the other form to bring about a resonance at a frequency of up to 1.5 times higher that that for a single ion. 
 In effect, this occurs by what we can regard as a self-timing of the system. 
 This condition is limited by the higher frequency listed. 
 In other words, over a frequency range above that of natural resonance of the single ion form, there will be perfect resonance of one of the ion forms even though the external frequency is not exactly the frequency required for that form. 
 The data in Table I (drawn from work published by B R McLeod and Abraham Liboff) assumes that H is exclusively the geomagnetic field strength. 
 Doubling the frequency saves lives 
 I am aware of the extensive experimental research which has focused on ion forms involving Ca++ Na+ etc2, but what seems to have been missed in this prior research is the appreciation that water forms its own ion form in that it dissociates into hydroxyl and hydronium ions as listed on the table. 
 It would seem that the prevalence of such ions and their rather special relationship to the 50Hz and 60Hz frequencies, both of which they encompass by their combined effect, and as illustrated in Table I, has to give the underlying basis for field induced activity in body fluids. 
 However, this is not a critical point. 
 What is critical is the need to realize that, if one accepts that AC fields are dangerous but inescapable, then one should choose a power line frequency which won't set our ions jangling. 
 For instance, at a power line frequency between 100 and 120Hz, only lithium of atomic mass 7, if it were present in solution as a free single-atom ion, could come near to satisfying the resonance requirement. 
 In this situation, bearing in mind that the very prevalent hydroxyl and hydronium ions are probably the dominant cause in the hazard risk at 50Hz or 60Hz, it can be presumed that a hazard free situation prevails at 100Hz or 120Hz. 
 Therefore, as a simple expedient, the object should be to eliminate the 50Hz or 60Hz basic frequency and operate instead at twice this frequency. 
 Now, this may not seem to be a feasible solution, except for the odd application such as electric blanket or underfloor heating where full wave rectified unsmoothed 50 or 60Hz AC will produce heating from a mixture of 81% DC and 19% AC at 100 or 120Hz and above. 
 In the case of the overhead power lines, unless we think in terms of screening power lines, which seem uneconomic, or using normal closely wound cable forms, as used underground, the most appropriate, but drastic, remedy is to adopt a new standard frequency for power generation and supply, such as 100Hz. 
 Electric blankets or underfloor heating can be remedied by using DC power excitation. 
 However, the solution to be applied to overhead power lines, short of conversion to underground cable or high voltage DC transmission, is not so easy considering the very substantial voltages and currents involved and the heavy capital investment in existing structures. 
 The question is not so much that of understanding the cause, but rather one of eliminating the possibility of cyclotron ion resonance brought about by AC field in a domestic or normal commercial environment where the only prevalent DC magnetic field is that provided by the Earth itself. 
 Given that weak electromagnetic fields at the power frequencies 50Hz and 60Hz do pollute the environment in the sense that they make it hostile for the chemistry of body functions, there is no real choice other than making sure we live well removed from power lines or accept the higher incidence of cancer and leukaemia as tolerable. 
 We can only hope that the future will see technological advance: perhaps overhead power lines will carry DC in preference to AC to the extent that converters are used to generate AC domestically or industrially. 
 Ideally conversion could be to 100Hz to reduce risk. 
 Dr Harold Aspden works at the Department of Electrical Engineering, University of Southampton. 
 References 
 1. 
 H Aspden. 
 Cyclotron resonance in human body cells  Sabberton, Southampton, p8 &mdash; 15, 1990. 
 2. 
 B R McLeod, A Liboff Dynamic characteristics of membrane ions in multifield configurations of low frequency electro-magnetic radiation  Bioelectromagnetics 7: 177 &mdash; 189 (1986) 
 The Human Cyclotron 
 The cyclotron used in particle physics to speed charged particles up to very high energy levels combines the action of a powerful magnetic field and a high frequency pulsating electric field. 
 However, the weaker the magnetic field, the lower the frequency needed for a given ion mass. 
 The weaker the AC electric field, the longer it takes to build up the power of those ions, but the build-up is unavoidable if the particle mass, the magnetic field strength and the AC signal frequency satisfy the formula for resonance. 
 In a cyclotron the energy of the particles is deployed into an orderly spiral motion around the axis of the magnetic field and the pumping action of that weak pulsating electric field progressively adds to that energy and causes a pressure build-up at confining surfaces as the particles are driven in spirals of larger radius. 
 A cyclotron is fine-tuned to a resonant frequency specific to one chosen ion type. 
 In the blood stream, as in any ionised plasma, gaseous or liquid, there is a mix of positive and negative ions. 
 Cyclotron action implies that one polarity would spiral clockwise as the other spirals anticlockwise. 
 Collisions don't preclude the build-up of the resonance effects as the health hazard reports imply. 
 Indeed there is a case for saying that it is the mix of ions of opposite polarities that makes the resonance formula adaptable and actually causes a self-tuning resonance. 
 This explains why resonance of the ions typically in water or blood can occur either at 50Hz or 60Hz. 
 Can body cells be the seat of a human cyclotron effect? 
 The cyclotron needs a magnetic field and a transverse AC electric field to pump energy into ions in motion in that field. 
 There are ions activated by thermal motion in blood and these are always subject to the Earth's magnetic field. 
 Proximity to a weak 50Hz or 60Hz electric field therefore means that ions in a certain mass range can respond to cyclotron action. 
 The ions in water and blood happen to be in the critical mass range.  
 Table 1 shows the resonant cyclotron frequencies of single ions of different forms when subject to the steady geomagnetic field. 
 The lower frequency expressed in Hz is that of a single ion type. 
 The presence of other ions may raise the resonant frequency by up to 50%. 
 Table 2 shows how the power supplied to a purely resistive load is, by conventional electrical engineering analysis, divided between the lower frequency components of an unsmoothed full-wave rectified sinusoidal 50Hz voltage source. 
 submarine cables 
 Waves, wind and the teredo worm 
 At a time when plans for global communications seem to rest on the semantics of international standards, Greg Grant looks back to the Victorian adventurers who conquered nature to put a communication girdle around the world. 
 Integrated-systems digital-networks, open systems interconnections and 1992 are popular subjects of conversation at the moment. 
 The consensus is that such technologies will require international standardisation, long-term planning and organisational coordination. 
 But it has obviously been forgotten that a near-similar system was in place almost exactly a century ago &mdash; the submarine cable system, a communicative technique in which the British were supreme. 
 It too was digital in its way, planned with the varied organisations involved coordinating well. 
 Impetus behind the endeavour was the fact that &bquo;&hellip; use of the telegraph increased in significance, the greater the distance that had to be covered&equo; 1. 
 With the British having more distance to cover at that time than any other nation, including the Americans: &bquo;Cable enterprises supplanted the railways as popular investments&equo; 2. 
 First toe in the water 
 Britain became involved with cable early on, the first worthwhile trial being that &bquo;&hellip; carried out in 1838 by Brooke, an Englishman, across the river Hoohley in India&equo; .3 Even as early as 1840 a House of Commons committee had looked into the possibility of connecting Dover with Calais. 
 First attempt to link the opposite shores of a considerable stretch of water was the link between Dover and Cap Griz Nez in 1850. 
 It was the work of John and Jacob Brett their cable being &bquo;&hellip; made up merely of wire insulated by gutta percha&equo; 4, the whole effort being undertaken at their own expense. 
 The initiative failed shortly afterwards however due &mdash; it was said &mdash; to a French fisherman cutting the cable. 
 In the following year another cable was laid, consisting of four copper wires 1.7mm in diameter, insulated with gutta percha and tarred hemp. 
 Strengthening was by an armoured shield of 7.6mm iron wire and it established the standard for undersea cable design for years to come. 
 But two major problems were encountered;  the cable's weight and the fact that it fell short of its intended destination. 
 However after successful joining of an additional length, the task was completed on the November 13, 1851. 
 It was the first truly successful undersea cable, continuing in business for the next 24 years. 
 The very considerable size of this achievement can be appreciated by looking at the hydrostatic pressure undersea cables may have to endure &mdash; up to 4t/in2, at a depth of three miles. 
 Moreover, the cable will move with the current, more violently in shallow water and close to a shoreline. 
 In tropical oceans, there is also the problem of the teredo worm, one of the lamellibranch family of boring molluscs, whose destructive vigour proved as deadly to submarine cables as it had previously done to ships' timbers, wharves and sea dykes. 
 Atlantic crossing 
 In May 1853 another narrow waterway was conquered by cable; that between mainland Britain and Ireland. 
 Earlier attempts had been made to bridge St George's Channel but had failed, largely because of the treacherous currents and deeper water. 
 The Magnetic Company under chief engineer Charles Bright laid a six-wire cable between Donaghadee in Ireland and Portpatrick on the Stranraer peninsula in south-west Scotland. 
 The operation had been far from easy, the cable being &bquo;&hellip; manhandled out of the hold of a steamer, over a pulley and round a drum which measured the speed, and then several times round a brake drum before passing into the sea&equo; .5 
 Elsewhere too, river estuaries and narrow seas were interconnected by cable. 
 It was in the course of one such exercise the British engineer Frederick Gisborne decided to span the Atlantic Ocean by submarine cable. 
 While seeking more financial support for the final leg of another project &mdash; that of connecting New York and Newfoundland by cable &mdash; Gisborne held discussions with American entrepreneur Cyrus Field, in the course of which the Atlantic cable was mentioned. 
 Field in turn, immediately sought advice on the feasibility of the concept from a US Naval hydrographer and oceanographer, Lieutenant Matthew Maury. 
 Maury had just completed Physical Geography of the Sea , the first textbook on oceanography published in 1855. 
 In it, his recently-prepared chart of the Atlantic Ocean showed that this huge stretch of water was shallower in the centre than at the edges. 
 He assured Field that it was possible to lay a cable on the ocean floor. 
 For the next 12 years, Field relentlessly pursued his project, winning support of distinguished scientists and electrical engineers such as John Brett, Charles Bright and William Thomson (later the first Lord Kelvin of Largs). 
 Probably the greatest scientific panjandrum of the 19th century, Thomson had a long association with transoceanic cables. 
 Indeed the basic telegraphic equations  were &bquo;&hellip; in their simplest form&hellip; first given by Lord Kelvin in 1855&equo; .6 Another of Kelvin's achievements was development of the concept of inductance, the practical importance of which was first brought to the attention of engineers by &bquo;&hellip; the problems  experienced in&hellip; the Atlantic cables&equo; .7 
 Another of Thomson's originations was the siphon recorder, a device developed especially for telegraphic working over an under sea cable. 
 Atlantic Telegraph Company 
 Perhaps it was hardly surprising that the British had a near-monopoly on both cable technology and signal equipment techniques. 
 But dominion in the Atlantic cable ventures came about not through technological pre-eminence but via another British near-monopoly at that time: capital. 
 Having failed to raise sufficient funds for such an undertaking in America, Field came to Britain and, supported by Samuel Morse, their target of &pound;350,000 was passed in two weeks; the Atlantic Telegraph Company was registered on the October 20, 1856. 
 Initially views differed on the technology to be employed and the cable-laying techniques. 
 This was to be expected given the experience and personalities involved such as Morse, Thomson, Field, Bright and Brunel. 
 Brunel of course was deeply involved in the completion stage of the massive &bquo;Great Eastern&equo; &mdash; the largest ship the world had so far seen, and could not devote quite as much time to the project as the others. 
 Thompson on the other hand was keen to await the Great Eastern's launch, for he envisioned it as the ideal cable-layer. 
 Furthermore, he had reservations about the quality of the cable and he was not alone in this. 
 Bright too had misgivings in this area, particularly about size of the single conductor, and asked for it to be enlarged. 
 He also sought to have the cable spliced in mid-Atlantic with the freighting vessels sailing for America and Britain simultaneously. 
 Bright was turned down on both counts by Field, whose principal consideration was the weather. 
 Field already had two vessels on loan from the American and British navies and wanted cable-laying to be carried out within what we today would term the summer weather window. 
 As a result HMS Agamemnon and USS Niagara took their cable on board and began laying in early August 1857. 
 But the first break happened after only 8km and the second after nearly 612km. 
 So the project was called off. 
 The cause was mainly the cable's specific gravity, which resulted in it sinking too fast, overstretching and over-stressing the remainder. 
 Nor did its low tensile strength help either. 
 A second attempt was also a failure, this time after 257km. 
 But despite bitter disagreements Field convinced the company that they should try again. 
 This time they took up Bright's original suggestion and spliced the cable in mid-ocean on July 29 1858. 
 By August 5 the cable had been laid, and Thomson had sent the first two messages over it. 
 Technical hitches 
 The circuit however &bquo;&hellip; lasted only about a month. 
 The fault was in part with construction of the cable and in part with the high voltages&hellip; forced on it&equo; .8 
 Electrical and communications technology at this time was such that induction coils were thought to allow faster working than batteries. 
 Operators used high-voltage induction coils, with the result that the insulation deteriorated, probably causing the cable's failure. 
 Nevertheless, some 730 &bquo;cables&equo; had been transmitted over the line and so Field and his colleagues had proved that a transoceanic cable was not only feasible, but could also take a great deal of traffic. 
 In the following year another problem arose for the British; the Red Sea cable to India had failed. 
 The Board of Trade promptly set up an enquiry into the industry and its methods and techniques. 
 In 1861 it reported, having unearthed some disturbing facts. 
 Out of 18,000km of cable a mere 5000km &mdash; less than one third &mdash; were in working order. 
 As to the recent faults the committee concluded that they were due to careless handling of the cable during laying, to poor design and to bad practices in overall manufacture. 
 But a great deal of knowledge was gleaned concerning impurity effects on the conductivity of copper; the myriad problems of laying an undersea cable, and the terse frustrations of manufacturing one. 
 A new Atlantic cable was designed (Fig. 2.) consisting of seven wires of high-quality copper, insulated with four coats of gutta percha, the whole surrounded with hemp and armoured with ten iron bar-wires. 
 The Great Eastern was again chosen as the laying vessel, work beginning in July 1865, and the attempt got within 966km of the Newfoundland coast before the cable sheared again. 
 Another attempt was made in the following year between July 13 and 27 and was completely successful. 
 The shore ends of the cable used solid armoured wires instead of the stranded type and the cable itself was gradually reduced in size between the shore and the deep sea section in three stages &mdash; a practice still followed today. 
 The mighty Great Eastern not only laid a new cable; it succeeded in hauling up the earlier one splicing on a centre-piece, and lowering it again to the sea-bed. 
 In every way, the submarine cable was proving to be &bquo;&hellip; one of the great technical adventures of the 19th century, something akin to exploration of space today&equo; .9 
 Three years later, the Siemens brothers extended cable communications even further by implementing an 11,000km telegraph line between London and Calcutta, a very considerable achievement, one which had been yet another adventure, the sort that provided &mdash; like the Atlantic cable saga &mdash; the densely-packed reports and darkly realistic illustration for which the Illustrated London News  had become justifiably renowned. 
 The cable has left Britain at Lowestoft, a North Sea cable bound for Germany. 
 Having crossed the Siemens' Brothers homeland, it  then clipped through a southern corner of Russia heading for Tehran, where it had its only interconnection before continuing on to the Indian sub-continent. 
 In the course of construction engineers and technicians survived fearful seas; had been protected by Russian soldiers; used, along with their equipment, as a form of target practice by turbulent natives and &mdash; on an individual level &mdash; had fallen victim to a positively bewildering variety of exotic diseases. 
 The line itself was very much state-of-the-art for the time, driven by punched paper tape and the section between London and Tehran had ten Wheatstone automatic repeaters installed as standard. 
 Clear signals 
 In the early days of cable, manual signalling was employed, using what are known as cable code signalling (Fig. 3.). 
 Transmission was by reverse-battery polarity, a simple yet efficient way of ensuring that dots and dashes used exactly the same voltage. 
 With no traffic, both stations would put their send/receive switches to receive, so as to be on &bquo;stand-by&equo; to receive any incoming signals. 
 Signal capacitors would be at earth potential. 
 On transmitting, at station A say, the send/receive switch was depressed to send, so earthing the signalling capacitor via the dot-dash keys. 
 Operation of the dot key earthed the battery positive terminal, putting a negative potential on the signalling capacitor. 
 The reverse occurred on restoration of the dot key and depression of the dash key. 
 Cable code signals &mdash; three-condition signals &mdash; were sent to line via the siphon recorder and its shunts SS1 and RSI giving pulse working to the distant terminal where the received signals passed through the recorder coils, the high-resistance inductive shunt RS2 to earth, via SR2. 
 In 1870 however, the brilliant Sir Charles Wheatstone invented the first, effective automatic telegraph equipment. 
 The message to be sent was transposed &mdash; corresponding to the dot/dash Morse code of the message &mdash; into perforations on a paper tape (Fig. 4). 
 The tape was then passed through an automatic transmitter, turning individual perforations into dot/dash signals for the line and considerably improving speed of the telegraph. 
 The first Atlantic cable operated at a speed of around 3 words/min, equating to a bandwidth of about 1.5Hz/s. 
 Cable code was faster, operating at about 54 words/min, or 20BAud. 
 Wheatstone's invention was almost twice as fast at 100 words/min (see box). 
 But this was only one of three such communicative tracks. 
 The second cable again crossed Europe. 
 Its route took it to Constantinople prior to passing through the southern part of the sprawling Ottoman empire to the Persian Gulf there to revert to a submarine route again before continuing to Karachi. 
 Unfortunately its path was not so very efficient &bquo;&hellip; because of the murky inconsistencies of Turkish administration&equo; .10 
 Source of Alice Springs 
 In 1870, the Victorians created a third electric avenue to the Orient, another submarine cable routed via Gibraltar, Malta, Alexandria, Suez and Aden, terminating at Bombay.  
 It was the sort of route the British had long been anxious to create, an all-red one, passing through either British-owned, British-run or British-controlled territory. 
 Security of these communication pathways meant headaches for the British &mdash; some real but more frequently imagined. 
 Keeping them functioning, not to mention well-maintained, was a formidable task, as not all routes could traverse the world on purely British turf. 
 The East and West African cables for example had to cross Portuguese territory, as did the South America cable which used the island of Madeira as a way-station. 
 No less tortuous was the route chosen for the Australian cable, crossing the island of Java, at that time a Dutch possession. 
 The British insisted that it be worked by British operators &mdash; reluctantly agreed to &mdash; and it finally entered Australia in the Northern Territories. 
 3220km and 36000 telegraph poles later it terminated at Adelaide. 
 The communications link had taken two years to pioneer, in situ long before a road or railway. 
 Its central way-station was located at one of the most remote places in the British empire; Alice Springs. 
 Indeed the telegraph was the sole reason for the existence of this huddle of buildings named after the wife of the cable station's chief engineer. 
 By 1894 British cable connections were branching out again, this time from Singapore to Hong Kong via the British possession of Labuan. 
 But the Hong Kong to Shanghai leg was another matter. 
 The last thing Britain was prepared to entertain was insecurity of relay stations on the Chinese mainland. 
 So an elderly hulk was stationed in the Min river estuary as an interconnection at once secure and free from prying. 
 Myriad troubles from which cable systems could suffer included &bquo;&hellip; silt, uncharted currents&hellip; winds &mdash; during the monsoon no Indian Ocean cable could be mended at all. 
 Even the webs of the more portly tropical spiders could interrupt an imperial dispatch&equo; .11 
 Electronic and electrical knowledge was advancing apace however, eg the discovery that signal attenuation was proportional to square root of the signal frequency. 
 Thanks also to the mathematical work of Oliver Heaviside, transmission techniques were steadily improved. 
 He realised that the ratio R/L = G/C  give the necessary condition for distortionless transmission, where R = resistance; L = inductance; C = capacitance and G = leakage (conductance). 
 From this ratio, Heaviside established that attenuation constant a =  So distortionless conditions could only be attained with a very large increase in either the leakance or the inductance. 
 Increasing leakance had the disadvantage of increasing attenuation. 
 Increased inductance was usually adopted, using a technique known as &bquo;loading&equo;, involving wrapping &bquo;a continuous nickel-iron wire&hellip; around the copper conductor&hellip; to neutralise the harmful effect of copper capacitance&equo; .12 
 This work led to an equation that determined the maximum frequency of signalling:  
 This work led to an equation that determined the maximum frequency of signalling:  
 Looking back to the &bquo;global village&equo; 
 The reality of world-wide communications was indicated by Queen Victoria's Diamond Jubilee celebrations. 
 On June 22 1897, the Queen, in the telegraph room at Buckingham Palace, pressed the button activating the Central Telegraph Office's equipment in St. Martin's Le Grand. 
 It sent her jubilee greeting throughout the empire in a powerful demonstration that the global village was a possibility, some 14 years before the birth of its future prophet Marshall McLuhan. 
 It is doubtful if anything remotely striking will be forthcoming as regards either ISDN or OSI in the two years remaining before dawning of the brave new communicative continent in 1992. 
 A quick glance at the seven-layer decision-making ladder of the OSI, makes plain the potential for querulous technical in-fighting over a near-interminable period. 
 Where is the adventure in grappling with RS232, network layers and Hayes compatibilities, however necessary? 
 That sort of activity is light years removed from the drama of the Russian steppe, the pioneering excitement of the outback or the storm-lashed sense of achievement that taming the Atlantic brought. 
 But this is what it comes down to. 
 Any high drama that remains is found deep in technical working party country. 
 Yet there is  still hope. 
 Some half dozen new submarine cables have been laid annually since 1945, the longest of which runs for 15,032km. 
 The Commonwealth Pacific cable, Compac, runs from Alberni in Canada to Sydney, Australia, interconnecting at Hawaii, Fiji and Norfolk Island, almost mimicking the cherished all-red routes of the Victorians. 
 The UK remains a major influence in the communications business and is the undoubted European leader in electronics information systems with 15% of world markets, second only to the US. 
 At the same time Russia and Eastern Europe are discarding the shackles of the last 40-odd years. 
 If that market open up, it could require nothing less that a Sovpac. 
 Now that would be an adventure. 
 References 
 1. 
 Science &amp;: Western Domination , Kurt Mendelssohn. 
 Thames &amp; Hudson, London. 
 1976, p. 176. 
 2. 
 A Social History of Engineering . 
 WHG. 
 Armytage. 
 Faber &amp; Faber, London. 
 1976, p. 36. 
 3. 
 A Century of Technology 1851&ndash;1951 . 
 Ed Percy Dunsheath. 
 Hutchinson's Scientific &amp; Technical Publications, London. 
 1951, p. 272. 
 4. 
 Ibid , p. 273. 
 5. 
 Pioneers. 
 Dr WA Atherton, EW + WW , August 1989, p. 811. 
 6. 
 Telegraphy &amp; Telephony. 
 E Mallett. 
 Chapman &amp; Hall Ltd. 
 London. 
 1941. 
 Page 66. 
 7. 
 Syntony &amp; Spark  &mdash; The Origins of Radio . 
 HGJ Aitkin. 
 John Wiley &amp; Sons, New York. 
 1976. 
 Page 87. 
 8. 
 From Falling Bodies to Radio Waves . 
 Emilio Segre. 
 WH Freeman &amp; Co, New York, 1984, p. 209. 
 9. 
 From Compass to Computer . 
 WA Atherton. 
 McMillan Publishers Ltd, Basingstoke, 1985, p. 92. 
 10. 
 Pax Britannica: The Climax of an Empire . 
 James Morris. 
 Faber &amp; Faber, London, 1968, p. 62. 11. 
 Ibid , p. 62. 
 12. 
 Telecommunications Principles . 
 RN Renton. 
 Sir Isaac Pitman &amp; Sons Ltd, London, 1950, p. 134. 
 Undersea technology &mdash; by gum! 
 In 1842 gutta percha was introduced into Great Britain &mdash; the coagulated latex of the gutta and other trees such as the bassia pallida found mainly in Malaysia and the East Indies. 
 Its ability to repel water along with its excellent insulating properties were immediately noted by leading engineers and scientists of the day such as Faraday, Siemens and Wheatstone. 
 Having a resistivity of some 10M&ohm; and a permittivity of 3, it would remain the first choice of insulation for undersea cables until development of para gutta, composed of wax and deproteinised rubber. 
 This too would retain its pre-eminent position as an insulator until replaced around 1933 by Polyethylene developed by ICI. 
 Thomson's siphon recorder 
 An operation, a moving coil D'Arsonval galvanometer connected to the line was arranged so that coil deflections, brought about by an incoming signal, controlled movement of a writing head across a moving paper tape. 
 The tape was driven by either an electric or clockwork motor and the writing head was supplied with ink from a reservoir by siphon action, as the tape was being driven. 
 Writing head deflections were proportional to the received signal current, and so the graph produced indicated magnitude of the line current. 
 Dots and dashes could therefore be identified by the upward and downward movements of the current curve. 
 Wheatstone's 100 words/min 
 If a transmitter operates at 6m of perforated tape/min and there are ten centre holes per 2.54 cm of tape, this would amount to 40 centre holes per second or, put another way, 40 dots/s. 
 Since each dot is followed by a spacing period equal to the dot duration, the dot signal length &mdash; shortest element in the code &mdash; is 1/80th of a second and the telegraphic speed is 80 Baud. 
 Morse code is unequal in length so conversion of the above information into words per minute requires knowledge of the average number of unit elements, equal to a five-letter word plus one word space. 
 In plain English this is 51.6. 
 For telegraphic traffic however it is taken as 48. 
 Therefore a telegraph modulation rate of 80 Baud equates to 80/48 x 60; 100 words per minute. 
 The falling price of technology 
 Technical advances and the increasing demand for long distance communication meant but one thing; lower prices. 
 In 1866 an Atlantic telegram cost &pound;20 or &dollar;100. 
 Just two years later, rates had come down to &dollar;1.57/word. 
 A decade later, submarine cable were carrying about 27 million words per annum, their most regular and demanding customer being the governments of the day. 
 In 1870, for instance, the British Colonial Office's telegraph bill was around &pound;800. 
 By 1897, it was &pound;8000 annually and rising. 
 In the following year there were 14 cables connecting North America to Europe, 12 of which were in operation. 
 A further 3 would be set down before the century's end. 
 One result was that the British were the world's major communications operators.  
 HMS Agamemnon laying the Atlantic cable in 1857&hellip; but disappointment was to follow. 
 Second attempt to lay an Atlantic cable also failed due to the cable stretching during the operation 
 Fig. 1. 
 The siphon recorder, adapted by Lord Kelvin from the Gauss/Weber mirror galvanometer. 
 Writing head S is attached to lightweight plate P, which is axially supported by wire W. Plate P is capable of angular rotation about axis W, controlled by the silk fibres x and y which are attached to opposing corners of the galvanometer coil. 
 Coil movements produce angular movements of P, causing horizontal movements of the writing head over paper tape t. 
 One end of W is rapidly but delicately electrically vibrated allowing the writing head to make equally rapid, if intermittent, contact with the paper. 
 It also reduced friction at the point of contact. 
 Fig. 2. 
 Improved Atlantic cable consisted of several copper wires, insulated with gutta percha and surrounded with hemp and armoured with ten iron bar wires. 
 Laying the first cable across the English channel in 1850. 
 The cable hold of the Great Eastern: Siemens brothers implemented an 11,000km telegraph line between London and Calcutta. 
 Fig. 3. 
 The earliest form of submarine cable telegraphy: manual simplex working using a cable code key. 
 C1 and C2 are signalling capacitors; K1 and K2 sending keys and S1 and S2 siphon recorders. 
 SR1 and SR2 are the send/receive switches connecting the transmitting or receiving equipment to the cable, while SS1 and SS2 are variable low resistance transmitting shunts. 
 RS1 and RS2 conversely, are high-resistance inductive receiving shunts, adjusted for optimum received current to operate the recorders. 
 The transmit shunts bypass the record coils when the send/receive switch is at transmit and are adjusted such that the current through the recorder at the transmitting station is equal to that present on reception. 
 The battery connections are reversed at one end of the circuit, so that each recorder can operate when the station is transmitting. 
 Fig. 4. 
 Wheatstone Morse perforated tape or slip and the corresponding Morse signals. 
 Audio 
 Who designed this? 
 &bquo;a manufacturer cannot contact all potentially interested parties&hellip; 
 &equo; Panasonic UK Legal Department 
 In September 1982, this magazine published a brilliant piece of lateral thinking in audio design, a Wheatstone bridge type circuit which should rid transistor audio amplifiers of crossover distortion originating in the output transistors. 
 The designer, Aubrey Sandman, believes that a student working for Matsushita devised a circuit arrangement based on his own, later patented by the Japanese electronics giant. 
 Dr Sandman presents his evidence. 
 Technical literature is full of unpatented though useful information. 
 But it is essential that the originators receive due recognition. 
 The importance of this cannot be overstated if this flow of information is to continue. 
 In September 1982, I published an original article which suggested the use of a subsidiary power amplifier to make the load seen by a low power main voltage amplifier seem very much greater than it was in reality. 
 This arrangement greatly reduced both crossover and other distortions. 
 It also did away with the need for bias adjustment on the output devices &mdash; a most desirable quality. 
 I called it Class S . 
 Based on the simple concept of maintaining balance in a bridge, it managed this without being intrinsically sensitive to loudspeaker load impedance variations. 
 In other words it rendered, at a stroke, conventional Class B circuits obsolete for serious audio systems. 
 Indeed there is a strong case for using it generally, even among lower quality systems when the lack of setting up is taken into account. 
 In 1983, the international electronics company Technics, a subsidiary of Matsushita, patented a circuit which it called Class AA , a strikingly similar design to my Class S arrangement shown in Fig. 1. 
 The Technics arrangement is shown in Fig. 2 for comparison. 
 The Japanese patenting of the Technics Class AA circuit was quite unknown to me, not having associated their advertisements for Class AA with anything I may have done until I read John Linsley Hood's article in this journal for December 1989. 
 Since then I have been trying to gain recognition from Technics. 
 The following letter from Panasonic (UK), the Technics holding company, present Matsushita's position: 
 &bquo;We can be certain that the designer of Class AA (an undergraduate student) did not read your article in Wireless World unless it was translated into Japanese; he cannot, read, write or speak English. 
 &bquo;As far as the involvement of one of his tutors is concerned, this is purely surmise on his part, and was always expressed as such. 
 Basically he felt that as Class AA was his freshman project, any exposure to your article would have had to have been indirect via his teachers. 
 However, he has never stated that this was in fact the case. 
 &bquo;I would also state my belief that in relation to Class AA, our parent company has behaved entirely properly; the process of applying for a patent necessarily entails wide publication and ample opportunity for opposition. 
 I willingly accept that an inventor cannot scrutinise every patent application; by the same token a manufacturer cannot contact all potentially interested parties.&equo; 
 My view about the Matsushita response is simply that the Japanese higher education system generally requires knowledge of English, which seems at odds with the Technics explanation. 
 The basic variation in the Technics circuit  arrangement has necessitated a set-up procedure, not present in my circuit. 
 Furthermore, my own analysis of the Technics arrangement suggest that it is sensitive to loudspeaker impedance variations; under some conditions the performance is worse with the subsidiary amplifier than it would be without it. 
 At the same time, even when the circuit performs better at some loudspeaker impedances than the traditional Class B circuit, it still has worse performance than that of Class S because of the low, yet varying impedance seen by the main voltage amplifier for all loudspeaker impedances bar one. 
 Analysis 
 Both circuits attempt to tackle the problem of crossover distortion in a basically identical manner: they try to make the load impedance, RL, appear to be very much higher to the main amplifier than it really is. 
 Class S works on the clear principle that the inputs to A2 must both be driven to the same potential regardless of the input voltage to AL, ie, a virtual earth. 
 In other words if the non-inverting input is at +3V that will also be the value of the inverting input. 
 References 
 1. 
 Sandman, A.M., Wireless World , September 1982, pp. 38&ndash;39. 
 2. 
 Linsley Hood, J.L. Electronics World , December 1989 pp 1164&ndash;1168. 
 Pictures from the past 
 Sounds of the century 
 Ever since the first distant sounds of music and odd snatches of alien speech began interrupting the 1920s' world of Morse, better (and louder) reproduction of audio has been at the forefront of development priorities for engineers. 
 It all became feasible with the thermionic valve, introduced during WW1, which rapidly and irrevocably supplanted all other methods of audio amplification, including the electromechanical types (one of which used compressed air controlled by an electromagnetic air valve). 
 Wireless World  almost created civil war in the audio industry at about this time over its publication of one of the first RC-coupled amplifiers. 
 Transformer coupling was then unchallenged and the journal's championing of the RC technique caused rioting among the transformer makers (and there were many), with threats of withdrawal of advertising and worse. 
 A devious editorial calmed things down and peace reigned again. 
 The culprit is shown in the picture &mdash; the RC-coupled amplifier itself, published in the issue for October 10, 1923, with its complement of &bquo;R&equo; valves. 
 At about the same time, 1926 to be exact, Walter Cocking produced what became known as Everyman Four receiver, originally called Everyman's Four-valve, one of which is now in the Science Museum. 
 It appeared in WW  for July 28 and August 4, 1926 and owed it considerable success and subsequent fame to the new technique of neutralising the RF stage triode and to the use of an RF coil design by Cocking. 
 The picture shows the construction standard of the day, with 90-degree bends in all wiring and metalwork and woodwork that should be in the Guggenheim Museum. 
 The circuit shows a neutralised triode RF, anode-bend detector, transformer-coupled gain and triode output producing around 150mW! 
 Going back to amplifiers, the third picture is of Cocking's Push-pull Quality Amplifier, published by WW  in 1934. 
 There were two MHL4s driving a pair of PX4s in push-pull, the MHL4s deriving the double-ended drive from a concertina phase splitter. 
 It gave 4W output at a &bquo;low&equo; distortion. 
 Some are still around and, although they do not have the power, compare reasonably well in quality with modern wonders. 
 Moving on to speakers, there were many methods of moving a mass of air. 
 Moving-iron and reed types were produced in dozens of variants, in addition to the odd-ball kinds  like the compressed-air type, but the breakthrough came with the moving coil, which had been modernised from its Siemens 1874 patent and Lodge's 1898 one by Rice and Kellogg in 1924. 
 The fourth picture shows a magnificent affair made by Paul Voigt, which had twin diaphragms and 20kilogauss field magnets. 
 It was possibly the first time the BBC had had to take other equipment out of service because someone (Voigt) complained of its bad performance, which had shown up on this speaker. 
 If proof were needed of the new-found fascination with sound reproduction in the 1950s, the last picture should supply it. 
 It is of one of the unforgettable demonstrations by G.A. 
 Briggs of Wharfedale, who challenged his audience to distinguish between live performers and loudspeakers. 
 Thousands rallied to the call, as the picture shows, and many were sadder and wiser after the event.  
 Push-pull Quality Amplifier, again be Cocking. 
 It gave 4W at a lowish distortion and worked in &bquo;nearly Class A&equo;. 
 Loudspeaker by P.G.A.H. Voigt, which sported a 20 kilogauss magnet and twin diaphragms. 
 It also brought a delicate blush to the BBC cheek. 
 First RC-coupled amplifier, constructional details of which were published by WW in 1923, brought murder to the hearts of transformer makers in the land. 
 Walter Cocking's Everyman Four TRF receiver, which set a standard of performance for the rest to try to emulate. 
 One is now in the Science Museum. 
 Everyman Four and (below) the original circuit diagram 
 Broadcast 
 Radio with vision 
 &bquo;Arguably the most important development in radio since the invention of the transistor&equo;. 
 This was the assessment of RDS by Johnny Beerling, controller of BBC Radio 1 and chairman of the EBU Programme Experts Group in an introduction to a special issue of the EBU Review &mdash; Technical  devoted to radio data system (RDS). 
 In his world, the &bquo;Utopian world of RDS&equo;, everyone is equipped with the new technology &mdash; in cars, at home and on foot. 
 When that day arrives, in the not-too-distant future, Beerling says listeners to the radio will find themselves &bquo;better-served by their equipment than at any time since the wireless was first invented by Marconi in 1895&equo;. 
 Strong words, but certainly European broadcasters have shown remarkable unanimity in rapidly implementing at least some basic RDS facilities on their national and local services. 
 Yet RDS remains low on the list of consumer priorities. 
 Even when aware of its existence, more important to most is the question of security, making digital VHF car radios less vulnerable to theft. 
 Second generation impetus 
 Benefits of RDS as a source of traffic information have penetrated the consciousness of only the relative few making top-of-the-range car-radio purchases. 
 This may change later this year with the first &bquo;second-generation&equo; RDS set incorporating RDS-EON (enhanced other networks) function. 
 This feature can be used to update information stored in a receiver about programme services other than the one to which the set is tuned. 
 So a driver could listen, for example, to one of the BBC national networks, while the set automatically switches temporarily to a local station making a traffic announcement. 
 BBC has been testing EON on its local radio traffic experiment in south-east England and the Midlands for about two years, and several other European countries are already, or soon will be, implementing EON, although none of the 50 or so existing RDS models is suitable for this function. 
 BBC claims that it would not have decided to go ahead with EON on a country-wide basis unless it had received assurances that other firms will have suitable second generation RDS receivers on the market soon. 
 DoT's rosy future 
 In an IEE lecture: &bquo;Broadcasting traffic information&equo;, Simon Shute (BBC) and Alistair Robertson (Dept of Transport) presented a generally rosy view of the future of RDS. 
 The DoT believes that traffic information broadcasting, and in particular RDS, will have an important role to play in reducing delays and driver frustrations. 
 Better network management has, as a prime objective, constant awareness of network conditions, providing accurate and timely information to permit the network capacity to be used to greater effect. 
 Similarly, Shute emphasises that traffic broadcasts must be timely, relevant, accurate and sufficient. 
 He believes that EON will much improve the service. 
 It was perhaps a coincidence that chairman of the IEE meeting was RS Sandell who in the 1970s, with SM Edwardson, developed the BBC's medium-wave Carfax system that was later aborted. 
 Carfax was, compared to RDS, a low-technology system based on a dedicated network of synchronised, time-multiplexed, low-power (0.5kW) transmitters to which the car radio (or player) was switched automatically when a local traffic announcement was made. 
 It was estimated that a lattice network of sone 80 transmitters would give nationwide coverage, with more than 80% of road traffic covered from only 20 stations. 
 For several years, the BBC enthusiastically promoted the low user costs of Carfax and at Warc 1979 even succeeded in obtaining a special footnote to ITU Radio Regulations permitting establishment in the UK of a &bquo;public utility information service&equo; between 519.5 to 526.5kHz, just below the lower-frequency edge of the broadcast band. 
 But the footnote did not apply to other European countries. 
 In effect it gave the UK all the frequencies needed for a nationwide Carfax service on a dedicated lattice. 
 Indeed, in 1978, the BBC concluded: &bquo;the only really satisfactory solution for the broadcasting of traffic information is to provide a separate, dedicated service&equo;. 
 Official abandonment 
 Officially, Carfax was abandoned on the grounds that &bquo;frequencies were not available&equo;. 
 In view of the Warc footnote, this statement seems to have been economical with the truth. 
 At the time, most observers believed that the real reason was that the BBC had been unable to persuade the newly-elected Conservative government to contribute towards the cost of setting up (about &pound;3million at 1977 prices) or running a dedicated traffic service. 
 Despite the far greater sophistication (and cost to users) of RDS, Carfax appears to remain the superior approach, permitting local traffic announcements to be made as soon as information is available to broadcasters. 
 This is a significant advantage over RDS-EON which has to be slotted into programmes intended also for domestic and &bquo;walking&equo; listeners. 
 Such listeners would soon be annoyed were announcements to be made too frequently, at intervals of less than say 20&ndash;30 minutes, or if programmes were rudely interrupted. 
 Traffic message control 
 Traffic message control (TMC), under development as one of the European Drive projects, may bring RDS a little nearer to Carfax. 
 This is seen as using RDS as a data channel of very limited capacity in conjunction with a speech synthesis chip or possibly some form of printer in the car (it could provide automatic translation when travelling abroad) as a means of sending &bquo;traffic telegrams&equo; to cars without interrupting the radio programmes. 
 But TMC seems bound to add much extra intricacy to the already complicated RDS receiver. 
 D Kopitz (EBU) in discussing  development of TMC admits that: &bquo;The TMC device will probably be too complex to permit its incorporation within a standard car radio case. 
 It will also require it own RF tuner (VHF) to permit the car radio listener a free choice of listening entertainment, without obligation to tune to the particular programme service which carries TMC information. 
 So a complex &mdash; and still rather expensive &mdash; receiving device is needed, in addition to a car radio (which may, or may not, be equipped for conventional RDS decoding). 
 Presently-available RDS radios cannot be used for TMC, and cannot be adapted. 
 Ergonomic features and acceptability of TMC functions by the driver, have not yet been assessed. 
 After a standard for TMC has been agreed, perhaps in 1991 or 1992, it will take many years, perhaps five to ten, until RDS-TMC receivers first reach the market. 
 This means that conventional spoken broadcast traffic messages will have to be continued for many years. 
 Indeed, they will remain the major source of information for car drivers for the foreseeable future&equo;. 
 Restrained consumer response 
 Although broadcasters may feel that RDS is user-friendly the consumer-industry is only gradually responding to the growing dislike of over-complex and often confusing controls; c.f. video recorders easily set to record the wrong programme on the wrong channel at the wrong time, and teletext units that remain under-used. 
 A typical consumer reaction is summed up by a correspondent writing earlier this year in the New Scientist  concerning trends in digital car radio design: &bquo;Previously it was simple, while driving to cope with two big knobs and six decent-sized push buttons to get a useful selection of stations. 
 Now one is faced with several, barely identifiable minuscule buttons packed side by side or on top of one another&equo;. 
 The simplicity and low user cost of Carfax with its medium-wave capabilities seem more attractive than ever. 
 Admittedly, RDS, unlike Carfax, was designed to have many functions for home as well as in-car listeners. 
 For example station identification &mdash; particularly useful in countries such as Holland where a large number of FM broadcasts from neighbouring countries can be received. 
 Programme related announcements, claimed as one of the attractions of RDS, even when scrolled require displays with more alphanumeric elements than are usually fitted at present. 
 Potentially attractive is pin (programme item number), enabling receivers and recorders to respond to particular programme items preselected by a user. 
 The code contains the scheduled time of the start of the programme, plus day of the month. 
 It's useful, but there are already available on the market audio recorders with conventional time switches. 
 Several countries, but not the UK have radio-paging systems based on RDS which provides a user-attractive function for car radios. 
 But all in all, it seems likely to be a long time before we reach that &bquo;Utopian world of RDS&equo; for all listeners in cars, at home or on foot! 
 Promising start 
 Some nine or ten firms are manufacturing the special RDS transmission equipment (VG electronics in the UK). 
 Rhode &amp; Schwarz take space to congratulate EBU on &bquo;the great success achieved with RDS adding, not too disinterestedly, &bquo;the fact that our equipment is supporting RDS in more than a thousand FM radio stations worldwide makes us rather proud&equo;. 
 The BBC alone has RDS going out on over 700 FM transmitters. 
 More than 20 receiver firms have RDS models in their ranges, mostly car radios, with about five firms offering domestic audio tuners with RDS, though still no portable sets. 
 This must seem a promising start for RDS for which first receivers appeared only in 1987. 
 Consumers wary of poor performance 
 Broadcasters have been none too happy with performance of some of the earlier sets. 
 Mark Saunders (BBC Radio) in a personal review of design requirements for RDS car radios points out that one of the problems that RDS poses for both broadcaster and receiver manufacturer is that, with the exception of obvious features such as the display of the programme service name, an RDS receiver is not apparently different in performance, or looks, when observed in the static environment of the dealer's showroom. 
 So from the point of view of the consumer, there are few tests that can be done prior to purchase, to ascertain how well a product will perform when fitted into the car. 
 He says that it is a sad fact that many early RDS receivers failed to perform even basic tasks adequately, and many people have been put off RDS for life because of: &bquo;experiences with receivers that performed inadequately and which failed to live up to the promises the broadcasters made for them&equo;. 
 Mr Saunders goes on to admit that broadcasters are not entirely blameless in this respect: &bquo;More should no doubt have been done at an earlier stage in development of RDS to give the receiver manufacturing industry some guidelines setting out the minimum levels of RDS performance that should be achieved&equo;. 
 His belief is that it is preferable if the RF tuner and RDS processing stages of the receiver are continuously active whenever the vehicle ignition is switched on. 
 The on/off switch on the front panel should only control the power amplifiers and display functions. 
 Advantage of powering the receiver all the time the vehicle is moving is that, even though the driver is not listening to the receiver, it is continuously being updated by RDS data, in the same way as if the driver were listening to the CD player. 
 If the vehicle has an electrically powered antenna, arrangements should be made to ensure that it is raised whenever the vehicle is moving &mdash; with an over-ride switch allowing the driver to avoid damage when entering a garage or car park. 
 Mark Saunders admits that car receivers should not rely exclusively on reception of the CT (clock) and date information but use the RDS to set and correct the displayed time. 
 Otherwise the clock would stop if the set were tuned to a transmitter not transmitting CT or if the set were switched off. 
 Furthermore it cannot be assumed that all RDS information will be received accurately at all times. 
 In areas of multipath, several minutes may elapse between successive occurrences of successful reception and decoding of the groups carrying the CT data.  
 Fig. 1. 
 Three different communications protocols for the broadcasting of spoken and coded traffic messages on RDS. 
 Fig. 2. 
 RDS interface scenarios in car radios. 
 Fig. 3. 
 Basic features of an integrated Carfax receiver for 1977 trials on 534kHz. 
 Carfax adaptors were designed for use with existing car radios. 
 Index to advertisers 
 Abracadabra Electronics 
 791 
 Adept 
 IFC 
 Adept 
 754 
 American Automation 
 787 
 Anchor Surplus 
 789 
 Antex Electronics 
 756 
 Audio Electronics 
 746 
 Audio Visual Research 
 770 
 Autona 
 797 
 A.O.R. (UK) 
 746 
 Billington Valves 
 799 
 Chelmer Valve Company 
 766 
 Citadel Products 
 OBC 
 Dewsbury 
 Electronics794 
 Digitask 
 714 
 Display 
 Electronics719 
 Halcyon 
 Electronics721 
 Hoka Electronics 
 737 
 Icom (UK) 
 763 
 Institute of 
 Electrical 
 Engineers 
 735 
 IPK 
 721 
 John's Radio 
 782 
 J. and N. Bull 
 Electrical751 
 J.B. Designs 
 794 
 Kestrel 
 Electronic 
 Components 
 756 
 Langrex Supplies 
 756 
 Lloyd Research 
 791 
 Matmos 
 800 
 Micro Amps 
 758 
 MQP Electronics 
 758 
 M. and B. Electrical 
 733 
 Number One Systems 
 723 
 Research Communications 
 721 
 R. Henson 
 763 
 Sherwood Data Systems 
 766 
 Signals Research 
 763 
 Smart Communications 
 770 
 Stewarts of Reading 
 737 
 Surrey Electronics 
 737 
 Talent Computers 
 787 
 Taylor Brothers 
 IBC 
 Those Engineers 
 746 
 Thurlby Thandar 
 758 
 Thurlby Thandar 
 766 
 Tsien (UK) 
 769 
 Wood and Douglas 
 776 
 THEORY AMONG THE ENGLISH  
 Theory is what is generated when some aspect or literature, its nature, its history, its place in society, its conditions or production and reception, its meaning in general, or the meanings or particular works, ceases to be given and becomes a question to be argued in a generalized way. 
 Theory is what inevitably arises when literary conventions and critical definitions once taken for granted have become objects or generalized discussion and dispute. 
 Gerald Graff 
 The related themes I am pursuing are difficult to keep apart, and really require a contrapuntal or fugal exposition. 
 But that would not make for easy writing, still less reading. 
 In practice one can only talk about one thing at a time, and in this Chapter I shall risk a distorting simplicity by looking at questions of theory largely in isolation from institutional matrices and situations, and concentrating on British activities to the exclusion of the American ones that accompanied or preceded them. 
 I defer those contexts to later Chapters. 
 The word &bquo;theory&equo; has always aroused suspicion amongst the English, who see themselves as practical people and sound empiricists. 
 Indeed, it is often assumed by Continental and North American commentators that there has never been any significant literary theory in England. 
 This ignores I. A. Richards, a pioneer modern theorist, who was very much an Englishman. 
 Michael Edwards, taking a paradoxical approach, has argued that the English have always been strong on literary theory, instancing a distinguished succession of poet-critics: Sidney, Dryden, Johnson, Wordsworth, Coleridge, Shelley, Arnold, Eliot. 
 Most of their important critical texts, Edwards remarks, are theoretical, in that they prompt fundamental reflections about the basic nature of writing, even if, &bquo;One notices about such writing that it does not necessarily offer itself as theory, that it is directed towards what we now call literature and not towards something else.&equo; 
  Edward's comment is clearly correct, and could be extended: Hopkins's letters and notebooks, for instance, contain a weight of original theorizing that is more substantial and more interesting than much recent writing. 
 But present-day theorists are likely to be dismissive of what has been called &bquo;writers' speculation about their art&equo;, finding it impressionistic and unsystematic. 
 &bquo;Theory&equo;, to be intellectually respectable, has to be presented as such, and to be a product of the academy, not of the amorphous institution of literature. 
 In the early 1970s, academic literary theory established bridgeheads in Britain, entering at first directly from France, and then via American translation and intermediaries. 
 When conservative academics eventually became aware of the supposed invasion, they viewed it with alarm, as a threat to their, and their students', proper activity of reading, studying, and enjoying literature. 
 Increasing resistance to the alien forces led to the clashes and controversies described in an earlier Chapter. 
 In my judgement, the advent of theory was not a cause of disruption, but a symptom of it, for reasons suggested in the above quotation from Gerald Graff. 
 For as long as the &bquo;English&equo; synthesis was adequately functioning there was no need or place for theory. 
 Once the consensus began to fragment, theoretical challenges found room to enter. 
 There is an approximate parallel in the history of religion: precise theological definitions of doctrine are called for only when doubters and heretics enter the picture. 
 Until then, shared traditions of worship and devotion are sufficient to unite the believers. 
 It is often argued, as Graff does in the final chapter of Professing Literature , that all literary activity is really if implicitly theoretical, and that a self-respecting critic will be specific about theory sooner rather than later. 
 This was Ren&eacute; Wellek's position in his debate with Leavis in 1937. 
 But there are other ways of looking at the question. 
 Christopher Ricks, trailing his coat in the wake of the MacCabe Affair, claimed that the critic should have &bquo;principles&equo; rather than &bquo;theory&equo;, while Stanley Fish has made a comparable distinction between &bquo;theory,&equo; and &bquo;belief&equo;: &bquo;A theory is a special achievement of consciousness; a belief is a prerequisite for being conscious at all. 
 Beliefs are not what you think about  but what you think with &hellip; 
 &bquo;. Theory emerges as and when texts or  issues are theorized, usually by academics who are dissatisfied with the status quo . 
 The idea of &bquo;theory&equo; has now become so pervasive, so much a part of the terms of current debate, and so visibly incorporated into institutions, that I shall not resist using it. 
 There has, indeed, been a change from traditional, empirical, English ways. 
 Nevertheless, the idea of theory may itself need to be theorized and regarded with a measure of scepticism, like other honorific terms in contemporary discourse, such as &bquo;politics&equo; and &bquo;history&equo;. 
 My present use of the word can be understood as being, in Derridean terms, lightly sous rature . 
 What Stanley Fish calls &bquo;belief&equo; is close to what Wittgenstein denotes by a &bquo;form of life&equo;, where practice and guiding assumption form a seamless unity. 
 In the recent history of British culture the study of English Literature in secondary and tertiary education comprised a recognizable form of life, principled but not theoretical. 
 In institutional practice, &bquo;English&equo; in public schools tended to be marginal and somewhat disregarded, but became central in the culture of the grammar schools, in ways adumbrated and advocated in the Newbolt Report. 
 That culture presupposed a high degree of what E. D. Hirsch calls &bquo;cultural literacy&equo;, particularly in respect of English history and the Christian and classical heritages, requiring competence in Latin and at least one modern language, as well as wide reading in English Literature over and above the demands of the curriculum. 
 This form of life was shared by the sixth forms of grammar schools and the universities to which their students proceeded, and it did not greatly differ whether the frame of reference was &bquo;Cambridge&equo; or &bquo;Oxford&equo;, or to import an Arnoldian variation on this model, Hebraic or Hellenic, directed towards &bquo;criticism&equo; or &bquo;appreciation&equo;. 
 (Leavis, a forceful opponent of traditional literary education, indicated in Education and the University  just how much cultural competence he took for granted in the student.) 
 Judith Grossman's novel, Her Own Terms , published in 1988, looks back at a working-class scholarship-girl in the 1950s, who goes to Oxford from a South London Grammar school; Grossman shows in passing how formidably well-read and linguistically equipped her heroine was. 
 The basic assumption of this form of life, extending from school to  university, was that imaginative literature was inherently valuable, and that it was valuable because it pleasurably conveyed emotion and profound insights into the life of things. 
 True to the Romantic tradition from which this belief sprang, the imagination was valued more than the analytical intelligence, the specific more than the general, experience more than discourse, connaitre  more than savoir . 
 If ideas as such were discounted, it was because imaginative literature, in its richness and blend of diversity and harmony, had other things to offer. 
 It is arguable that the disappearance of grammar schools was a further factor in the weakening of the English synthesis, in addition to those I have discussed. 
 At all events, when the innovative literary theory derived from structuralism began to arrive about twenty years ago it found actual or potential fissures in the form of life and it sought to enlarge and penetrate them. 
 An adversarial stance appeared in literary study. 
 It is evident in a curious book, edited by Stephen Heath, Colin MacCabe, and Christopher Prendergast and published in Cambridge in the early 1970s: Signs of the Times: Introductory Readings in Textual Semiotics . 
 It was a collection of essays designed to introduce la nouvelle critique  to ignorant English readers: apart from the editors, the contributors included Julia Kristeva and Philippe Sollers, and there was an interview with Roland Barthes. 
 A polemical note is sounded in the unsigned preface. 
 It acknowledges that the following texts and their arguments are difficult, but 
 the difficulty is not to be hidden &mdash; we ourselves have no right to hide it. 
 Nor, however, is it to be submitted to the terrorism or plain language, that mythical weapon or those who prefer the comforting repetition or the ideological caress; who do not want to READ. 
 Or, in the slogan of American aerobics teachers, &bquo;No Pain, No Gain&equo;. 
 It was a note often sounded in battles to come. 
 MacCabe and Heath had studied in Paris, and Signs of the Times  has its niche in postwar cultural history, marking the first major re-entry of French intellectual influences since Eliot's adherence to Remy de Gourmont and the French neoclassicists, half a century earlier. 
 For the sake of convenience I shall apply the term la nouvelle critique  to the complex  of ideas emerging from the Paris of the 1960s, including many diverse strands: the &bquo;classical&equo; structuralism of the early Barthes, the poststructuralism of his later work, the deconstructionism of Derrida, and whatever name one gives to the work of Foucault and Lacan, in taxonomic historiography and dissident psychoanalysis respectively. 
 Frank Kermode was the first senior academic in English studies to take a sympathetic interest in la nouvelle critique , particularly its analysis of narrative. 
 For some years before his move to Cambridge he chaired a seminar at University College London, which discussed the literary implications of structuralism, semiotics, and emergent poststructuralism. 
 He has remarked, &bquo;No other phase of my academic life has given me so much pleasure and instruction.&equo; 
 Kermode's seminar established a useful informal link with the work going on at Cambridge, and the participants included Stephen Heath, Jonathan Culler, who was at that time teaching at Cambridge, and Culler's then wife, Veronica Forrest-Thomson. 
 Other literary, theorists who attended were Christine Brooke-Rose, Christopher Norris, and Shlomith Rimmon, and the novelist, B. S. Johnson. 
 Once, Roland Barthes himself came. 
 Kermode recalls the seminars as occasions of good humour and tolerance, despite sharp intellectual disagreements, and he laments that their humane spirit did not survive later events. 
 By the late seventies some British academics were displaying a wary but sympathetic interest in early or classical structuralism, particularly as it was expounded in Culler's widely read Structuralist Poetics , a lucid, urbane work which suggested that structuralism might, without too much difficulty, be adopted to existing academic practice. 
 I was partly convinced by Culler's power of persuasion, and for some time thought that the kinds of analysis he described could be assimilated to practical criticism and the English synthesis. 
 Eventually I decided that assimilation was not possible, given Culler's lack of interest in the interpretation of particular texts and his commitment to the uncovering of the generalized principles of literariness. 
 In Structuralist Poetics  Culler took an unenthusiastic view of deconstructionism, but he shortly  returned to the United States and succumbed to the deconstructive wave that swept through the American academy in the late seventies, and into which I did not feel inclined to plunge. 
 David Lodge was another established British academic and writer who took an early interest in formalist and structuralist methods and principles. 
 In 1977 he published The Modes of Modern Writing , an illuminating and original application of Roman Jakobson's distinction between &bquo;metaphor&equo; and &bquo;metonymy&equo; to the criticism and history of twentieth-century literature. 
 My main reservation about the book, which is more evident to me now than when it first appeared, is that Lodge has too direct and univocal an understanding of the elusive concept of &bquo;literature&equo;. 
 His book showed that new ideas were in the air, and senior academics began to drop passing references to Barthes or Derrida, not always accurately. 
 Others, more inward with la nouvelle critique , adopted a polemical rhetoric. 
 Veronica Forrest-Thomson &mdash; a brilliant though unstable poet and critic, who died tragically young in 1975 &mdash; referred in a review to the work of Barthes, Foucault, and Derrida &bquo;which has led to a literary revolution in France and will lead &mdash; at last &mdash; to revolution in our theory and practice of literature in this country.&equo; 
 The breathless phrase, &bquo;at last&equo;, is revealingly placed. 
 The idea of &bquo;revolution&equo; can set the pulses racing, for a time at least, and in 1980 it was invoked by Catherine Belsey: &bquo;Only by closing the doors of the English department against theoretical challenges from outside can we continue to ignore the &bquo;Copernican'&equo; revolution which is currently taking place, and which is radically undermining traditional ways of perceiving both the world and the text.&equo; 
 Belsey's Critical Practice , like MacCabe's study of Joyce, is fairly aggressive in its tone. 
 I would agree that the doors of the English department should not remain closed to theoretical challenges, and in this book I am trying to respond to them. 
 But applying a mildly deconstructive reading to her words, it is worth remarking that &bquo;revolution&equo; is an ambivalent trope. 
 On the one hand, it denotes an absolute, once-and-forall change: the Copernican revolution, or the French or Russian Revolutions. 
 On the other hand, if we think of a wheel or turntable, &bquo;revolution&equo; implies a mere turning,  continual movement without progress. 
 Nearly ten years after Belsey's book appeared, there has been no revolution in the first sense, and it does not look as if there will be. 
 Critical Practice  was one of the early titles in the &bquo;New Accents&equo; series published by Methuen, under the general editorship of Belsey's colleague at Cardiff, Terence Hawkes. 
 The series aimed to introduce to English readers la nouvelle critique  and literary theory, along with associated areas such as linguistics, translation, and the study of mass culture. 
 It was from the beginning very successful, which I take to be evidence of the growing sense that the established English synthesis was weakening, with a corresponding desire among students and teachers for new orientations. 
 The series did not have a uniform intellectual line and many varieties of opinion could be found in the contributors. 
 But it appeared at precisely the right moment to catch the poststructuralist tide associated with Derrida and the later Barthes, and several of the most influential titles brought together, rather uneasily, poststructuralism and Marxism. 
 This is true of Belsey's book, of Hawkes's own Structuralism and Semiotics , of Tony Bennett's Marxism and Formalism , of many of the contributions in Peter Widdowson's Re-Reading English , and of Anthony Easthope's Poetry as Discourse . 
 These texts share a fighting tone and a conviction that established forms of literary study, and in some cases even the concept of literature itself, have to be overthrown. 
 There is a great readiness to invoke the French, and a conviction, drawn from Saussure and classical structuralism, that language has no necessary connection with reality. 
 In a poststructuralist development of the idea, it is claimed that the most literary texts can offer is the endless &bquo;free play of signifiers&equo;. 
 In the late seventies some people in the mainstream of literary study were inclined to believe, or halfbelieve, these ideas, or to try them on for size. 
 David Lodge was one; in his inaugural lecture as Professor of Modern English Literature at Birmingham in 1976 he slid from the supposed arbitrariness of language as defined by Saussure to the way in which the masterpieces of modernist literature emphasized form rather than content. 
 This is at best a corrective belief, for whatever else Ulysses  or The Waste Land  are doing, they are also invoking for us the Dublin of 1904 or  the London of 1921. 
 Lodge himself, in his own admirable novels, has never been hampered by any lack of conviction that the language he employs is really about the social realities that he wittily records. 
 Frank Kermode in The Genesis of Secrecy  seemed to be engaging in a severance of world and word, and was called to account by Helen Gardner for doing so. 
 It is significant that neither Kermode nor Lodge have inclined towards the more radical deconstructionist road. 
 Kermode has set out his reasons for refusing it in Essays on Fiction , and Lodge has remarked, &bquo;To open a book or article by&hellip; 
 Derrida or one of his disciples is to feel that the mystification and intimidation of the reader is the ultimate aim of the enterprise.&equo; 
 There was less caution in the &bquo;New Accents&equo; camp where the incapacity of language to convey anything about the &bquo;real&equo; world was eagerly asserted. 
 Belsey wrote: 
 From this post-Saussurean perspective it is clear that the theory of literature as expressive realism is no longer tenable&hellip;. 
 If discourses articulate concepts through a system or signs which signify by means or their relationship to each other rather than to entities in the world, and ir literature is a signifying practice, all it can reflect is the order inscribed in particular discourses, not the nature or the world. 
 No more seeing into the life of things, in short. 
 Belsey attempts to unite the poststructuralist and the Marxist parts of her mind by invoking Lacan, Althusser, and Macherey, but signs of strain or outright contradiction are not hard to find. 
 One can compare the passage just quoted, which insists on the unknowability of the real world, with some of her subsequent remarks; as, for instance, when she refers to her argument &bquo;that literature represents the myths and imaginary versions of real  social relationships&equo;, and claims that &bquo;a form of criticism which refuses to reproduce the pseudo-knowledge offered by the text provides a real  knowledge of the work of literature&equo;, or says that &bquo;the task of criticism, then, is&hellip; to produce a real  knowledge of history.&equo; 
 My italics: some reality, at least, is knowable, it seems. 
 The contradictions in Belsey's text have been examined sharply and at some length by Patrick Parrinder. 
 One notes in passing that the passages just quoted from Belsey contain abstract nouns, &bquo;literature&equo; and &bquo;criticism&equo;,  which take active verbs, &bquo;represent&equo; and &bquo;refuse&equo; and &bquo;provide&equo;. 
 This is a common rhetorical device in contemporary theoretical writing, and has been usefully analysed &mdash; and condemned &mdash; by Roger Poole as &bquo;Hegelian grammar&equo;, which is &bquo;the use of verbs of decision, movement, or responsibility which are illegitimately coupled to grammatical subjects which are neither animate nor conscious.&equo; 
 In fact, it is a latter-day version of the figure known in classical rhetoric as prosopopoeia. 
 The observant reader may have noticed that I used this construction myself above on p. 98; this was done consciously. 
 I have sometimes whiled away idle moments in speculating how far one could elaborate this figure before the reader became suspicious. 
 Consider, for instance, the following string, and see where implausibility enters: &bquo;the text makes no response&hellip; the text evades the reader's interrogation&hellip; the text is frequently silent&hellip; the text is idle and will not get up in the morning.&equo; 
 Or this: &bquo;At this point ideology makes a forceful intervention&hellip; the voice of ideology is frequently heard&hellip; ideology never stops talking.&equo; 
 The effect of the device is to remove or reduce human agency, making events seem the consequence of impersonal forces such as ideology, the unconscious, history, or language itself. 
 Terence Hawkes's Structuralism and Semiotics  appeared in 1977 as a timely primer on la nouvelle critique  and it presents much information in a readable form. 
 It is, however, written in a crusading spirit, without any critical distance, and it is informed, like Belsey's book, by the assumption that language &mdash; or literature &mdash; can give us no certain knowledge of the world. 
 Hawkes's polemical purpose becomes more and more apparent as the book develops: it is to undermine, not only established literary study, but liberal humanism itself. 
 His arguments are fast-moving but inexact, and he engages in some wild flourishes of Hegelian grammar: &bquo;Writing, in short, does not &bquo;reproduce'&equo; a reality beyond itself, nor does it &bquo;&bquo;reduce'&equo; that reality. 
 In its new freedom, it can be seen to cause a new reality to come into being &equo; (Hawkes's italics). 
 Or consider the density of trope and implication in the following: &bquo;New&equo; New Criticism would thus claim to respond to literature's essential nature in which signifiers are prised utterly free of signifieds, aiming, in its no-holds-barred  encounter with the text, for a coherence  and validity  of response, not objectivity and truth&equo; (Hawkes's italics). 
 Raymond Tallis has described this passage as being &bquo;of great interest to the pathologist of modern literary theory.&equo; 
 In certain respects, what Hawkes calls the &bquo;New&equo; New Criticism&equo; had what looked like connections with the older version. 
 Both were directed towards the formalist reading of literary texts, and some anglophone academics tried to minimize the strangeness of French imports by saying that la nouvelle critique  was only offering a new version of what had long been familiar in the Anglo-American academy. 
 This assumption ignored great differences in contextual forms of life and conceptual foundation. 
 Nevertheless, Lodge was able to use classical structuralism and aspects of Russian Formalism to refine and extend the existing approaches of formalist criticism. 
 Resemblances were apparent between Northrop Frye's system of archetypes and structuralism; indeed, Hawkes refers, without qualification, to Frye's Anatomy of Criticism  as a &bquo;classic of North American structuralism&equo;. 
 As I have remarked, Culler's Structuralist Poetics  encouraged some readers to think in terms of rapprochement  between the New and the Newer Criticism. 
 Anthony Easthope's Poetry as Discourse  offers a complex blend of old and new. 
 He takes poststructuralist assumptions about the death of the author and the disappearance of the self-subsistent ego, and applies them to the history of English poetry, in a work which combines ingenious close reading, impressive knowledge of metre, and an overall argument of stratospheric thinness and remoteness. 
 Easthope believes that the modernist concept of &bquo;impersonality&equo;, later systematized in the New Criticism, and theorized by Wimsatt and Beardsley in their famous essay &bquo;The Intentional Fallacy&equo;, was on the right lines, but did not go far enough, as the author was not really banished. 
 Some of Easthope's approach recalls that of C. S. Lewis in The Personal Heresy . 
 He does not mention this book, but he does quote Lewis to the effect that &bquo;nearly all our older poetry was written and read by men to whom the distinction between poetry and rhetoric, in its modern form, would have been meaningless.&equo; 
 In this aspect, at least, there is a traditional slant in Easthope's argument. 
 He sets up poetry, rhetoric, and textuality,  as against the myth of presence, the poem as the life-blood of a master spirit, and the Romantic ideal of expressiveness. 
 Thus far Easthope's ideas have affinities both with the New Critical applications of modernism, and Lewis's independentminded traditionalism. 
 Yet this is only part of his argument. 
 He goes much further, in taking Pound's phrase about the need to break the pentameter, and projects it back over six hundred years of English poetry. 
 Easthope has his own version of the myth of catastrophe that has possessed so many critics and theorists. 
 His villain is the iambic pentameter, often seen as basic to English poetry, but according to Easthope an alien and bourgeois importation, brought in by Chaucer, to the detriment of the truly native measure of the four-beat-line with a varying number of syllables, found in the old alliterative verse. 
 This survived only in an underground way in folk song, nursery rhymes, children's counting verses, and so on. 
 From the Renaissance onwards, metrical repression reigns: &bquo;Once established as national poetic institution pentameter becomes a hegemonic form.&equo; 
 Only in our century has relief come, when modernist poetry, particularly pound's Cantos , breaks away from the pentameter. 
 Easthope's objections are entirely political, focused on the objectionableness of the &bquo;bourgeois&equo;, that great unexamined transcendent signified of marxisant  theoretical writing. 
 In Easthope's hands it becomes a particularly malleable concept. 
 He believes that the bourgeois epoch of history is in its terminal crisis, but concedes that this crisis may have been going on since 1848, which stretches not only &bquo;bourgeois&equo; but &bquo;crisis&equo; to breakingpoint. 
 Easthope acknowledges that the pentameter line had qualities which made it more resourceful than the older accentual metre, since one could achieve a great range of poetic effects by counterpointing intonation against metre, which is what nearly all the major English poets have done, though supposedly imprisoned in this bourgeois strait-jacket. 
 Easthope concedes, &bquo;Spoken performance of pentameter is accordingly open to variation in a way accentual verse is not&equo;, and this points to the massive lacuna at the heart of his book. 
 There is no mention at all of Elizabethan poetic drama, where the pentameter line is used with increasingly greater freedom and  flexibility. 
 Shakespearan drama is usually thought of as the embodiment of a truly popular art, whatever &bquo;bourgeois&equo; or aristocratic dimensions it also possesses. 
 But Shakespeare remains something of an embarrassment to contemporary theorists of levelling tendency. 
 One contributor to Re-Reading English  wants to deconstruct Shakespeare and his texts into the socio-economic-cultural-political contexts in which they originated. 
 He writes, &bquo;The notion of the sacrosanct text is alien to the period and yet it is central to the literary criticism of Shakespeare.&equo; 
 In what spirit, then, was the First Folio produced in 1623? 
 The work of recent British theorists does have lines of connection with older forms of discourse, whether the New Criticism, traditional scholarship, earlier Marxist criticism, or the Cultural Studies approach given a fresh impetus in the 1950s by Richard Hoggart and Raymond Williams. 
 Even Terry Eagleton, the eminent Marxist now installed at Oxford to teach critical theory exclusively, has, as I have elsewhere argued, never completely escaped from the Leavisite Cambridge of the sixties. 
 His most rebarbative work, Criticism and Ideology , is an Althusserian rewriting of The Great Tradition . 
 As an American commentator has remarked of Eagleton, &bquo;You can take the boy out of Cambridge, but you can't take Cambridge out of the boy.&equo; 
 Yet whatever continuities there are, the general impression, whether pleased or panicky, that recent theoretical work represents something new is broadly correct. 
 The newness is apparent in manner as well as in matter; a rude, derisive tone is noticeable, particularly in the prose of Eagleton and Hawkes. 
 The latter concluded an argument with Graham Hough in the correspondence columns of the London Review of Books  with the suggestion that Hough should &bquo;piss off&equo;. 
 Some readers may have been shocked that one professor of English should thus refer to another, but these are robust times. 
 The objects of derision may be placed, in order of increasing generality, in the following list: the institutional study of English Literature in British higher education; English Literature; Englishness; literature; bourgeois society (which includes racism and sexism); late capitalism; Western culture. 
 These items are all connected, and any of them may be used  as analogies or homologies for each other. 
 The polemic is supported by an implicit mythology, in which English culture is presented as insular, complacent, empirical, philistine, unreflective, untheoretical, and generally slumped in dogmatic slumbers. 
 Against the dominant dullness and grossness a growing band of lively and intelligent spirits have embarked on a hopeful struggle, calling in aid the power of ideas from other parts of the world, particularly, France. 
 This looks very like the rerun of a scenario first enacted in the early years of this century, when two unknown expatriate American poets attacked a torpid English literary establishment in the name of nascent modernism, looking to France for their intellectual inspiration and their models of literary achievement. 
 Eliot and Pound did establish a poetic revolution, and in the seventies and early eighties the rhetoric of revolution became attractive to anglophone poststructuralists. 
 But it remained rhetoric, language rather than achievement. 
 The breakdown of English intellectual insularity is welcome in principle, but a few things need to be said about this new turn to France. 
 It has become common form to invoke the magic names of the French theorists, as if the names alone would cause a torpid academic establishment to collapse. 
 The use of names rather than arguments as ammunition has become noticeable in such exercises, on both sides of the Atlantic, as Chris Baldick remarks in a review of Frederick Crews's Skeptical Engagements : 
 One lamentable practice which Crews rightly scorns is the increasingly revived trick or medieval rhetoric in which one attempts to substantiate one's theoretical argument not by anything so vulgarly empirical as a fact or a text but merely by invoking a name from the sacred pantheon. 
 Derrida, Foucault, Kristeva, Lacan, Barthes: just reeling off their names is (as Auden said in a very different context) ever so comfy, since it safely defers the issues at hand to nothing less than a transcendent signified: in short, to a star. 
 This clinging to authority has, in my experience, become noticeable in graduate students and young academics in the past ten years or so. 
 I take it to be a product of the myth I described above: &bquo;I am fighting against the entrenched forces of insular stupidity, and I call upon the French to aid me!&equo; 
 Such invocations are, in fact, very vulnerable. 
 French  intellectual debates and revolutions are part of a specific history and culture, expressing their complex dynamics. 
 Thus, classical structuralism, with its cold, formal impersonality, occurs as a reaction to the 1940s existentialist emphasis on the individual ego; and becomes itself overturned or deconstructed by poststructuralist &bquo;playfulness&equo;. 
 Marxists become nouveaux philosophes ; Julia Kristeva, lecturing at Warwick in 1987, speaks scornfully of the Left&hellip; 
 English poststructuralists, when wearing their Marxist hats, would undoubtedly want to insist that ideas belong in larger contexts, social, cultural, and political, and cannot easily be abstracted and appropriated to other ends. 
 Terry Eagleton came some way to acknowledging this, in a quasi-refutation of his Althusserian phase, when he included himself among the English Marxist intellectuals who &bquo;managed the difficult dialectical trick of appropriating certain Althusserian concepts in blithe ignorance or disregard of their guilty political context.&equo; 
 This is not to say that the English cannot absorb or debate French or other foreign ideas. 
 This was evidently done in the friendly but sharp exchanges in Kermode's seminar in the early seventies. 
 But it is another matter to use these ideas, or rather the names of their originators, primarily as weapons against an insular establishment. 
 How thoroughly, one wonders, have the ideas been understood? 
 Some English academics are genuinely at home with them, in a way that is directly related to their familiarity with French intellectual culture. 
 Christine Brooke-Rose, for instance, is a bilingual English critic and novelist, who taught in a Paris university for many years. 
 Her substantial and brilliant book A Rhetoric of the Unreal  uses the work of French intellectual stars in a familiar and matter-of-fact way, without any of the bedazzlement that surrounds them on this side of the Channel. 
 Stephen Heath has some claim to be the only begetter of the English version of la nouvelle critique . 
 He studied with Barthes in Paris when Barthes was unknown in England, and later wrote a book on him in French (&bquo;Barthesian French&equo; Hough has observed). 
 However much some people at Cambridge disapproved of him, there can be no doubt of Heath's high professional competence in the understanding of structuralism and poststructuralism.  
 Heath has appended a pertinent note to his translation of Barthes's collection of essays, Image-Music-Text , in which he scrupulously discusses the problems in lexis and idiom of translating Barthes. 
 This raises the large question of the role of translation in the transmission of French ideas to English readers. 
 In her book Beautiful Theories , the late Elizabeth Bruss made a revealing examination of the way in which Barthes's different translators carried out their task; she shows that whereas Heath did not disguise the difficulty and opacity in Barthes's texts, his American translators turned them into smooth narratives. 
 Other translations from modern French theorists are, one hears, very inadequate. 
 One would not want to suggest that the academics who contribute to the New Accents series (or who write similar texts) cannot read French with ease. 
 Nevertheless, it is noteworthy from the annotation of their books that they use translations wherever possible (as indeed I do myself, life being as short as it is). 
 And, as Marjorie Perloff has remarked, &bquo;in the case of writers like Derrida, Lacan and Barthes, for whom the materiality of the signifier is central, translation is nearly a contradiction in terms.&equo; 
 The use of translation is the most obvious but not the only problem in the transmission of what are cultural as well as intellectual texts. 
 There are French qualities &mdash; of irony, wit, cerebral play &mdash; that are remarkably difficult to get across, even in a good translation. 
 Nicolas Tredell has said of some New Accents contributors, &bquo;despite their ostensible Gallic sympathies, they crash down on French jouissance  like a ceiling-full of cold showers.&equo; 
 More importantly, there is the possibility that ideas have been simply misunderstood in their transmission from one cultural context to another. 
 This is the position of Christopher Norris, who modestly but firmly maintains that all anglophone readers except himself have misunderstood Derrida. 
 I am all too ready to admit that I may have misunderstood what I have read in modern French theory; the problem is in getting any minimal intellectual purchase on it at all. 
 David Lodge, who was prepared to go public as one who &bquo;worked with&equo; structuralism, nevertheless wrote in a newspaper article in 1980:  
 As an academic critic and university teacher specializing in modern literature and literary theory, I spend much or my time these days reading books and articles that I can barely understand and that cause my wife (a graduate with a good honours degree in English language and literature) to utter loud cries of pain and nausea if her eye happens to fall on them. 
 Young academics and critics do not seem to have had the same difficulty, or if they do, are not letting on. 
 Indeed, &bquo;lucidity&equo; is liable to be condemned as a form of bourgeois mystification. 
 The struggle to decipher has been presented as a good thing in itself, though construing sentences is not the same thing as achieving intellectual understanding. 
 This, however, raises obscure and vexing questions about the nature of &bquo;textuality&equo;. 
 There is no thesis without an antithesis, and polemic called forth counter-polemic, and mockery, counter-mockery, in works by conservative academics, such as George Watson's Modern Literary Thought , Helen Gardner's In Defence of the Imagination , and some of the contributions to Reconstructing Literature , a collection of essays edited by Laurence Lerner. 
 More interestingly, theory called forth counter-theory, in the late Geoffrey Thurley's Counter-Modernism in Current Critical theory , A. D. Nuttall's A New Mimesis , Patrick Parrinder's The Failure of Theory , and Raymond Tallis's not Saussure: A Critique of Post-Saussurean Literary Theory . 
 All of them argue, in different ways and with different emphases, for the realistic and expressive functions of literature; or, in philosophical terms, for the validity of the idea of reference. 
 Agreeing that na&iuml;ve empiricism is insufficient and that language does not tell us about the world in any simple, unmediated, or transparent way, they still believe that a sense of reality can be conveyed by language (the position derided as mere &bquo;common sense&equo; by the Newest Criticism). 
 Thurley locates la nouvelle critique  in a particular French intellectual tradition, which makes its uncritical adoption in the anglophone academy peculiarly problematical: 
 If it is the defining error or empiricism to assume that only statements meant to be checked up on deserve serious attention, it is the defining error or the new French criticism (Foucault, Piaget, Barthes, Derrida and others) to assume that because some statements cannot be verified, no statements can, and hence that all statements rail to refer, leaving us with discourse &mdash; language without anchorage in time, psyche or history. 
 Nuttall makes similar points. 
 The first part of his book is an extended essay in counter-theory, intended as a prolegomenon to the second part, which offers a study of Shakespeare in terms of moral and psychological realism. 
 Hawkes had dismissed the ideas of &bquo;objectivity&equo; and &bquo;truth&equo; in Structuralism and Semiotics , but Nuttall insists that such dismissals are pragmatically self-refuting. 
 We may assert that there is no such thing as truth, but we regard that as a true statement. 
 The point has a particular relevance to the work of those who believe, like Foucault, following Nietzsche, that truth is a mere rhetorical device, employed in the interests of oppression, and say so at length. 
 What then is the status of Foucault's saying so? 
 Nevertheless, the very concept of truth seems to be an irritant for some. 
 Nuttall has elsewhere given a mischievous account of an academic occasion in which a speaker insisted on asserting, &bquo;It is a truth that the workers are oppressed.&equo; 
 This, Nuttall remarks, &bquo;acted as a red rag. 
 It was as if the &bquo;logical conservatism'&equo; of his remark was more significant and more offensive to his (predominantly left-wing) audience than its thoroughly socialist content.&equo; 
 In A New Mimesis  Nuttall accused Hawkes of &bquo;collective cultural solipsism&equo;. 
 Hawkes, in turn, gave the book a mockingly dismissive review in the TLS , without mentioning Nuttall's accusation against him. 
 Nuttall, like Thurley, writes with a polemical edge, but both of them present their cases in a seriously philosophical fashion. 
 What emerges from recent counter-theory is that French-inspired theory tends to destroy straw men in its attack on reference, insisting that the relation between words and meaning is entirely arbitrary, a matter of difference only. 
 The point has been frequently made that there is no necessary reason why &bquo;dog&equo; should mean the familiar, faithful, barking, domestic quadruped, which in other languages, gets referred to as chien, Hund, cane , etc. 
 And within the language-system of English, the sounds and letters of d-o-g are recognizable as such simply because they are not d-i-g, or d-o-n, or l-o-g. 
 Nevertheless, if we say not &bquo;dog&equo; but &bquo;My &mdash; dog-Rover-with &mdash; the &mdash; white &mdash; spots- and &mdash; the-stumpy-tail&equo;, there can be no doubt that we intend not only a specific but a unique reference. 
 There is still a sense in which the relation between words and object can be called &bquo;arbitrary&equo;, since we  are not dealing with onomatopeia, but it is quite unproblematical. 
 These questions are central to Raymond Tallis's recent book, not Saussure , which is concerned with the relation between signs, meaning, and reference in the critical and intellectual tradition deriving from Saussure. 
 Tallis is a witty and combative writer, who is opposed to la nouvelle critique  but who is prepared to take it seriously and engage with it at length. 
 He recognizes the mythology of its English adherents, in which all criticism of their ideas attracts the charge of &bquo;a characteristically insular suspicion of nasty foreign ideas&equo;, but he is prepared to risk it, continuing: 
 Those who feel hostile to much recent literary theory but are unwilling or unable to formulate their objections often lazily dismiss it as merely another Parisian fashion, citing the rapid displacement or structuralism by poststructuralism as evidence that the writings or Barthes, Derrida, Lacan and their American epigones constitute a craze rather than a serious intellectual movement. 
 There may be some justification for the (insular) suspicion that when the Emperor is restocking his wardrobe he usually shops in Paris; but the rashionability or ideas does not or itself constitute an honest argument against them; indeed, to offer this as one's main response is to betray intellectual bankruptcy. 
 It is less easy, but more interesting, to try to understand why  ancient radical doubts about the ability or language to express a genuine extra-linguistic reality have been revived in recent decades to the point where they seem to have achieved an almost popular appeal. 
 Tallis sets himself the task of showing that much of the structuralist and poststructuralist enterprise is based on a misreading of Saussure. 
 Two aspects of Saussure's thought that have become well established in popular-academic consciousness are the distinctions between (a) langue  and parole , a language-system and its particular manifestations; and (b) &bquo;signifier&equo; and &bquo;signified&equo;. 
 It is the latter which, Tallis argues, has been generally misapplied. 
 In Saussure's original exposition, signifier and signified, though distinct and only arbitrarily related, were supposed to be as indivisible as the two sides of a piece of paper. 
 We recognize a sign as a set of letters on a page, or an intelligible series of sounds, or an iconic device, and in the same perception we grasp what it stands for: signifier and signified together make up the sign. 
 GDO or ODG are random collections of letters, not signs (unless we  suspect that they are unfamiliar acronymics, or words in an unknown language), but DOG is the signifier of a sign whose signified is what is elsewhere understood by chien , etc. 
 This has nothing to do with reference to any particular dog, or even whether dogs actually exist at all. 
 One could do the same thing with &bquo;unicorn&equo;, which has sense but no verifiable reference. 
 Tallis invokes Frege's distinction between &bquo;The Morning Star&equo; and &bquo;The Evening Star&equo;, which are different expressions with different senses or meanings, as would be apparent if we tried to translate them into another language, but they have the same referent (the planet Venus). 
 &bquo;Meaning&equo; is a slippery term, since it can cover both sense and reference. 
 In the poetry of Mallarm&eacute; the words &bquo;mean&equo; what a French dictionary tells us they mean, but they also take on the private and idiosyncratic meanings that Mallarm&eacute; gives them. 
 Poststructuralism, deriving from Mallarm&eacute; as well as Saussure, has developed a heady rhetoric in which signifiers are prised apart from signifieds, in Hawkes's phrase, and then fly away in all directions in their &bquo;free play&equo;. 
 Tallis argues that people talk of &bquo;signifieds&equo;, when they should say &bquo;referents&equo;; there is nothing new or unfamiliar in the idea of verbal signs having multiple or even clashing references, and they have long been exploited by poets and punsters, as Tallis does in the title of his book. 
 Interestingly, Anthony Easthope acknowledges the distinction at one point in Poetry as Discourse : &bquo;Failure to distinguish clearly between signified and referent, the object it may refer to, has led to serious confusion in some accounts of the ideogram.&equo; 
 Yet it is a confusion he frequently falls into elsewhere, as do other &bquo;New Accents&equo; writers. 
 Tallis's case is convincing, though he has certainly not said the last word on the matter, and there may well be further arguments from those who are professionally engaged in linguistics. 
 There is interesting supporting material in a book by the American critic Robert Scholes, Textual Power , published in 1985 and not consulted by Tallis. 
 In Tallis's reading, Saussure did not move from the sign, which comprised signifier + signified, to reference, because he was not interested in doing so, being concerned only with the internal aspects of a language-system. 
 He did not intend to exclude  reality. 
 The error lies with Saussure's expositors. 
 Scholes, however, believes that Saussure is himself inconsistent, and responsible for later confusion, but the thrust of his argument is very close to Tallis's, and both of them are concerned &mdash; as were Thurley and Nuttall &mdash; to reinstate the validity of reference and to deny that language is a system of &bquo;pure differences&equo;, without relation to reality. 
 Scholes provides a useful table, divided into three columns, showing how linguists and philosophers have agreed in making a tripartite division between signifier, signified, and reference, though they present it in a variety of terminologies. 
 For Frege, it was Expression, Sense, Reference ( Ausdruck, Sinn, Bedeutung) . 
 For Carnap, Expression, Intension, Extension. 
 For Ogden and Richards, Symbol, Thought, Referent. 
 For Pierce, Sign, Interpretant, Object. 
 But in Saussure's system there are only the two terms, Signifier and Signified, with nothing in the third column. 
 Scholes comments, 
 The Saussurean formulation, like many &bquo;linguistic&equo; views of language, eliminates the third term and with this gesture erases the world. 
 For Saussure this was perhaps mainly a methodological convenience, a way of concentrating on the aspects of language that interested him. 
 For deconstruction, however, this erasure of the world is crucial. 
 Scholes's case is the more telling in that he is far from being a conservative opponent of all recent developments in theory; he has written favourably of structuralism, and unsympathetically about fictional realism (for which, indeed, he has been attacked by Tallis), and elsewhere in Textual Power  he finds deconstructive reading &mdash; as opposed to the theory underlying it &mdash; a useful critical method. 
 The arguments of Tallis and Scholes against a major aspect of poststructuralist theory and practice should be attended to on the level at which they are advanced. 
 But one rather doubts if they will be. 
 Those who are addicted to the vertiginous rhetoric where language tells us nothing about reality, merely about other language, and where signifiers float in endless unattached free play, are apt to be contemptuous of demonstration and logic, seeing them as forms of bourgeois intellectual oppression. 
 Dropping reference is not a matter of tentative acceptance of an unlikely position, but of  doctrinal insistence. 
 A. D. Nuttall recalls an occasion when &bquo;an authoritative figure in the world of critical theory announced to a submissive informal circle of coffee-drinkers: &bquo;Reference is out .'&equo; 
 I thought at the time: &bquo;Is Sinn  really conceivable with no Bedeutung  at all?'&equo; 
 But I said nothing.&equo; 
 The connection between poststructuralist conviction and political radicalism is both arbitrary and tenuous, but it is insisted on by some contemporary theorists, with their readiness to invoke analogies between cultural processes, however disparate. 
 Thus, a critical theory seminar engaged in the deconstructive analysis of a poem (or, more likely, of another theoretical text) is seen, in some muffled way, to be striking a blow against Thatcherism. 
 Patrick Parrinder has looked sardonically at this comforting but self-deceiving state of mind. 
 In the Preface to The Failure of Theory , he observes, &bquo;To judge by a good deal of recent writing, the following resolutions would attract majority support at a conference of devotees of literary theory.&equo; 
 Among the resolutions are these: &bquo;The theorist is no longer a servant of the literary critic. 
 Theory and criticism should not take second place to imaginative writing&equo;&hellip; 
 &bquo;All utterances are implicitly theoretical. 
 All theory is political. 
 The task of the theorist is to uncover, and where necessary to denounce, the theoretical-political implications of all discourse whatever&equo;&hellip; 
 &bquo;The enemies of theory are politically conservative. 
 Theory is radical, and so are its advocates. 
 Pragmatists are not to be trusted.&equo; 
 Parrinder's attacks are justified. 
 The insistence on the supremacy of the political has become a clich&eacute; of recent thinking. 
 But if everything  is political, as is often proclaimed, then nothing is; one can invoke Saussure in the assertion that meaning is a matter of differentiation. 
 &bquo;Red&equo; is only meaningful in a world where other colours exist. 
 Admittedly, the politically radical implication of poststructuralist and deconstructive theory is a highly problematic idea, and has been resisted by some on the Left such as Terry Eagleton and Frank Lentricchia, and the contributors to a largely Marxist collection of essays, The Theory of Reading . 
 Most recently, the discovery that the late Paul de Man, the doyen of American deconstructionists, had been a young collaborationist journalist in Nazi-occupied Belgium has made the issue painfully  acute in the United States. 
 Given the sources of deconstructionism in Nietzsche among others, it is just as likely to have a nihilist-reactionary dimension as a progressive one. 
 In practice, left-wing theorists tend to form part of a rainbow coalition where poststructuralist or deconstructionist positions exist alongside Marxist, Freudian, and feminist ones. 
 Such disparate allegiances are more likely to agree on what they oppose than in what they support. 
 The different colours of the rainbow of theory are evident in &bquo;New Accents&equo; titles, and in the various journals devoted to theoretical discourse. 
 Some of this writing is acute and interesting, the product of lively minds with genuine insights into the state of contemporary culture. 
 I would often rather read it than more conventional forms of literary scholarship. 
 Yet it is frequently open to pragmatic self-refutation: it argues against reason by the processes of reason, and a political cause, however radical, cannot be advanced without the traditional processes of argument and attending to evidence. 
 There is admittedly the playfulness of some versions of deconstructionist rhetoric, which read like prose-poetry. 
 But such texts are subject to the limitations of purely aesthetic discourse, with no through road to action, and must become politically suspect. 
 In fact, one does not have to be a committed deconstructionist to find a split between meaning and rhetoric in the work of recent theorists. 
 The rhetoric may point to extreme scepticism or Pyrrhonism but its users, if pressed, are likely to retreat to positions which are no more than a modified version of traditional ones. 
 As Nuttall has remarked, they claim that, 
 the dissolution of truth does not mean that no statements are true but only that there is no stable, unchanging absolute truth, and that certainty is persistently elusive. 
 And the embarrassed questioner retreats, apologising profusely, wondering why he ever fell into such absurd anxiety about this luminously sensible body of doctrine&hellip; 
 In that case, where is the theoretical revolution? 
 Patrick Parrinder, focusing on such contradictions and inconsistencies, has concluded that theory is a failure. 
 My own position is rather different. 
 Believing that the recent emergence of theory in literary education is a symptom of disorder, I find the contradictions as symptomatic as the coherences. 
 A high  temperature and a rash may be signs of a failure in the functioning of the organism, but cannot themselves be termed a &bquo;failure&equo;. 
 Of the elements composing the rainbow coalition, Marxism is the most prominent and intellectually respectable. 
 It has been a major political and cultural force for a hundred years. 
 A large part of the world is notionally governed according to Marxist principles. 
 Yet the people in those countries show little sign of believing in Marxism in the way that some Western intellectuals do. 
 Globally, Marxism has run out of steam, persisting merely as sentiment and tradition, despite its conspicuous presence in parts of the Anglo-American academy. 
 The dominance of right-wing ideas has done little to avert the decline; to invoke Marxism against Thatcherism is to employ an obsolete weapon. 
 The present generation of British and American literary Marxists remind me of the small boy in Joyce's story, &bquo;Araby&equo;, who got to the bazaar just as it was closing. 
 After a century of immensely influential life, Marxism is becoming a dying culture, to adapt the phrase of an earlier Marxist thinker, Christopher Caudwell. 
 Things looked different about a generation ago, when the New Left was still new and the texts of the young Marx were in fashion. 
 Then Marxism did seem to represent a serious and dynamic challenge to liberal assumptions. 
 French intellectual life, largely marxisant  if not wholly Marxist, provided a substantial and supportive hinterland to the New Left. 
 That has now disappeared, and anglophone Marxists are subject to a disabling isolation, despite their energetic activity in the realm of literary theory. 
 They need their allies in the rainbow coalition, it seems. 
 In a longer perspective, the contribution of Marxists to literary criticism is considerable. 
 It is sufficient to invoke the names of Luk&agrave;cs, Benjamin, Goldmann, and, with reservations, Raymond Williams. 
 Throughout his career Williams had an uncertain relation to Marxism, sometimes adversarial, sometimes allied, and was uncomfortably conscious of paradoxes and difficulties in his establishment position as a professor at Cambridge and a leading British intellectual. 
 On balance, Williams probably gained more than he lost from his attempt to bring &mdash; and keep &mdash; together the separate traditions  of Marxism and British cultural criticism, though as Parrinder has shown in a sensitive discussion of Williams, he made needless difficulties for himself by abandoning the concept of literature. 
 Without doubt, a Marxist approach can be very illuminating when directed at particular cultural and intellectual phenomena. 
 Francis Mulhern's study of Scrutiny  is a case in point. 
 In fairness, too, one has to admit that Marxism is not monolithic, and that in literary and cultural criticism it provides many possible positions. 
 Terry Eagleton, the leading Marxist critic in England, has occupied most of them in his time. 
 Recently, Eagleton, in denying the total centrality of the class struggle, reached a point that some might claim was no longer compatible with Marxism. 
 Eagleton's Althusserian phase of the mid-1970s was strongly attacked by a Marxist academic, Kiernan Ryan, who has since taken issue with another Marxist, Alan Sinfield, on the extent to which the great literary works of the past can transcend the reactionary ideologies that produced them. 
 Sinfield believed that they were often irredeemably tainted by ideology, at best to be read only in historical terms, or subject to symptomatic readings, seeking the fractures and fissures in the mystified surface of the text that showed the &bquo;true&equo; ideological conditions in which it was produced. 
 Against this, Ryan advanced the humanistic belief that the major canonical texts are not inherently reactionary, and that they contain implicit images and models of human freedom which transcend their immediate historical context and which later readers can respond to. 
 This is an interestingly eclectic argument which recalls Gadamer on the &bquo;fusion of horizons&equo; (the reader's and the text's), Marcuse on the utopian possibilities of high culture, and Sartre on the necessarily progressive implications of major literature. 
 Ryan represents a kind of Marxism that non-Marxists might do business with, in the sense that one can make a rational engagement with it. 
 This is not always the case. 
 Marxists have the dogmatic assurance that comes from possessing a world-view that offers total explanations of social and cultural processes, and which is mysteriously immune to the ideological determinism ind deformation that they diagnose in others. 
 It is not easy to engage in discussion with someone who regards other opinions as no more than  symptomatic of the way a bourgeois intellectual thinks under late capitalism. 
 Ryan is representative of that traditional kind of Marxism, variously represented by Trotsky or Luk&agrave;cs, that regards the great literature and art of the past as a common human inheritance, which should be wrested from the exploiting classes and made available to the whole of humanity. 
 Set against it is the Marxist-structuralist position, that finds the concepts of art and literature inherently oppressive. 
 Here, &bquo;symptomatic&equo; reading is central: the literary text does not offer aesthetic or moral value, but is to be interrogated for its ideological implications. 
 In some respects, this is a return to a very traditional kind of cognitive reading, in which the literary work is not read for its &bquo;beauties&equo; but its message, though the &bquo;message&equo; is now likely to be diagnostic rather than uplifting. 
 In the spectrum of contemporary theory, Marxist symptomatic reading has something in common with the deconstructive reading which discovers in the end, not harmony and organic unity, but contradiction and aporia . 
 Deconstructionists, though, tend to make the triumphant exposure of aporia  a goal in itself, whereas Marxists incorporate their findings into a political and ideological system. 
 Nevertheless, this apparent similarity of method has been used as the basis for attempts, tentative and unlikely as they are, to find a rapprochement  between Marxism and deconstruction. 
 But it is with psychoanalysis that the more obvious affinities of symptomatic reading lie. 
 The Marxist critic reading a text for the ideological traces that it attempts to conceal &mdash; &bquo;Hegelian grammar&equo; is inescapable in such contexts &mdash; by its evasive gaps and silences, has an obvious resemblance to the Freudian analyst examining the manifest content of a patient's dream for the repressed realities that are concealed within it. 
 Moving on to psychoanalytic, by which I understand Freudian, criticism, I am in a difficulty. 
 Though neither a Marxist nor a Freudian, I find Marxist criticism deeply interesting, but not the Freudian equivalent. 
 The revival of psychoanalytic criticism, usually in its Lacanian version, has been a disconcerting surprise to someone who came to intellectual maturity in the 1950s, when Freud seemed a  figure of increasing remoteness. 
 I have no difficulty in accepting certain supposedly key Freudian notions, such as the existence of the unconscious mind and its effect on our daily living, and the self-contradictory and self-defeating quality of much human behaviour, but these are far from being original discoveries. 
 Freud himself said that the poets, not he, discovered the unconscious. 
 Beyond this, I do not accept much of the Freudian mythological apparatus, though Civilization and its Discontents  has always seemed to me a penetrating if deeply pessimistic work of cultural analysis. 
 Sometimes psychoanalysis claims to be a genuinely scientific activity, in contrast to, say, Jungian mystagogy; at other times, when confronting the proponents of a hard scientific approach to psychology, like behaviourism, psychoanalysis presents itself much more in terms of myth and metaphor and explanatory fictions. 
 It is never very apparent what Freudian claims are based on, though they are widely accepted in our culture. 
 My scepticism has been reinforced by the recent work of Frederick Crews, who for many years was a leading psychoanalytic critic in America. 
 During the 1970s he began to lose faith in the whole Freudian programme, and in his recent book, Skeptical Engagements , he provides detailed and substantially supported arguments for abandoning it. 
 Freud is not, however, likely to be generally rejected, since he is so much part of the valued cultural furniture of the West. 
 Furthermore, attacks such as Crews's are, as he acknowledges, not taken seriously and replied to in their own terms, but treated as symptoms of repressed disturbance. 
 Freudians, like Marxists, cannot step outside their own forms of thought to admit that they might be wrong (unless, like Crews, they undergo a deconversion). 
 The recent revival of interest in psychoanalysis among literary theorists has come from France, and in particular from the work of Jacques Lacan, who brought together Freud and Saussure and produced the slogan, &bquo;the unconscious is structured like a language&equo;. 
 Lacan has been very influential, although he is an almost impenetrably obscure writer. 
 The obscurity is not incidental, a product of carelessness or incompetence in writing, but a deliberate attempt to enact  the wayward processes of the unconscious. 
 As his admirer Malcolm Bowie acknowledges, Lacan's style is marked by, 
 disturbances of conventional word order, literal and metaphorical senses interwoven, periphrasis, ellipsis, leading notions alluded to rather than declared, abstractions personified, persons becoming abstractions, widely different words becoming synonyms, synonyms being given widely different meanings&hellip; 
 This is a literary use of language rather than an expository one, though poststructuralists frequently try to blur the distinction. 
 Indeed, Lacan was much influenced by surrealism, and Bowie compares his writing to Finnegans Wake . 
 Lacan is a revisionist Freudian, whose effect is to dissolve terms and concepts that Freud, with his positivistic formation, kept clear and distinct. 
 Lacan's work is not subject to empirical verification, and indeed is not meant to be. 
 Nevertheless, Raymond Tallis, whose own training is in medicine, has shown to what extent one of Lacan's key concepts, the importance of the &bquo;mirror stage&equo; in the development of the infant's sense of self, has no base in clinical experience. 
 As far as Tallis is concerned, Lacan is a charlatan, the L. Ron Hubbard of psychoanalysis. 
 Yet his system, like others on the contemporary scene, is constructed so as to repel argument or contrary evidence. 
 Bowie, whose admiration is tinged with honest caution, has summed up the Lacanian system in these words: 
 Just as you can gain access to the cave of the unconscious only by being inside already, he seems to be saying, so you can gradually reach towards an understanding of my work only by understanding it in advance. 
 Lacan offers us a new conception both of science and of truth, and asks us to abandon many of the procedures for verification or falsification on which the credibility of scientific enquiry traditionally rests. 
 Not everyone wants to enter the cave on such terms. 
 Lacan wished to get back to the original subversive spirit of Freud's writings, which had been simplified or distorted by their vulgar popular currency, and by the professionalism of psychoanalysis. 
 But a similar vulgarizing process has been applied to Lacan's own ideas, first in France, and then in the English-speaking world. 
 In Bowie's words, &bquo;Future sociologists of knowledge will no doubt study the mechanisms whereby an enfeebled &bquo;Lacanism'&equo;&hellip; has come to loom larger within the intellectual life of a society than the original  ideas and texts.&equo; 
 In England, Lacanian ideas have been linked with Marxist ones, as in MacCabe's James Joyce and the Revolution of the Word ; Catherine Belsey's Critical Practice , which identified Lacan's &bquo;symbolic order&equo; of language, into which the infant enters, with the Althusserian realm of ideology; and Anthony Easthope's Poetry as Discourse  which related Lacan's dissolution of the ego to New Critical impersonality and structuralist &bquo;dropping of the author&equo;. 
 One would have thought that Marxism and Lacanism would inhabit wholly disparate worlds of thought; the former is rationalistic and teleological, whereas for Lacan, as Bowie says, &bquo;arguments directed towards a terminus are falsehoods&equo;. 
 Yet there are affinities, as Frederick Crews points out: 
 In Althusser's and Lacan's hands, then, both Marxism and psychoanalysis exchange an adaptive materialism for allegory. 
 There is no point at which they unambiguously intersect experience and therefore no point where one of their contentions could be modified by behavioural data. 
 They have become, not critiques of inhuman arrangements or guidelines for practical interventions, but master transcoding devices which will sort any text or problem into sets of formally opposed categories. 
 Both belong to what Geoffrey Thurley diagnosed as the sealed world of French rationalism; the difficulty of convincingly transplanting such forms of intellectual discourse from a French to an English context remains formidable. 
 The last component of the rainbow coalition that I want to refer to is feminism. 
 Here the difficulty I found in talking about psychoanalytic criticism is compounded, not because I am an unbeliever, but because anything that the middle-aged male commentator says about feminism is liable to be wrong: to be approving may be condemned as patronizing, and to be critical is to be sexist. 
 Compared to the movements I have discussed, feminist criticism has little theoretical coherence, though it draws eclectically on poststructuralism, Marxism, and psychoanalysis. 
 The lack of a single recognizable approach has been acknowledged by Kathleen McLuskie: 
 Every feminist critic has encountered the archly disingenuous question: &bquo;What exactly is feminist criticism?&equo; 
 The only effective response is &bquo;I'll send you a booklist&equo;, for feminist criticism can only be defined by the multiplicity of critical practices engaged in by feminists. 
 An obvious characteristic of feminist practice in the academy, unlike the other approaches I have discussed, is the extent to which it immediately does intersect with experience. 
 Classes or discussion groups on women's writing command an enthusiastic response that is often lacking in mainstream teaching. 
 The enthusiasm has, of course, been exploited, in the opportunistic launching of courses in women's studies, and by the publishing industry which has filled the shelves of bookshops &mdash; general as well as academic &mdash; with books with &bquo;women&equo; in their titles. 
 One of the most interesting and welcome results of literary feminism has been the reprinting of forgotten texts, usually by women but occasionally by men. 
 In an earlier Chapter I argued that the canon is &bquo;bursting&equo;, because of the advent of other anglophone literatures, and the increasing interest in contemporary writing. 
 Undoubtedly, the new availability of earlier texts of feminist interest is helping the explosion. 
 At the same time, at the level of practical pedagogy, there is a counter-tendency in the study of the national canon to concentrate more and more on a small and diminishing number of texts. 
 Anything which attempts to reverse this by bringing in unfamiliar work from the past which students have a positive motive for wanting to read must be a good thing, and strikes a blow against cultural amnesia. 
 At the same time, there is an ambiguity in this backwards opening of the canon. 
 Much of the work that is rediscovered may have the literary qualities that will satisfy readers without particular feminist interests: the poems by women that Roger Lonsdale included in The New Oxford Book of Eighteenth-Century Verse  are a small-scale, easily accessible instance. 
 Nevertheless, in a feminist academic context writing may well be studied, not primarily for its literary but for its cultural interest. 
 This question provoked arguments in America about the Norton Anthology of Literature by Women , some of the contents of which were said to have had little value as literature. 
 A common feminist response is to say that the whole idea of &bquo;literary standards&equo;, even &bquo;standards&equo; as such, is a form of male domination. 
 I refer to this significant dispute in passing, without engaging in it, except to say that feminists are divided on whether they want to establish a countercanon or extend the existing one. 
 But the distinction between  literary texts and cultural texts is important, and I shall return to it. 
 A further consideration about feminist criticism, is that it is more practical than theoretical, in a familiar English way, and that unlike other schools in the rainbow coalition, it is actively concerned in producing readings of particular texts. 
 Most of them are produced by women, who provide insights that come from relating female experience to a body of writing; logically, there is no reason why these insights should not be available to male critics with the right sympathies and sensibility, but in practice most of this criticism is by women. 
 Such criticism, it is worth noting, is basically mimetic; literature is assumed to relate to experience. 
 Feminist criticism, like Marxist, is avowedly evaluative, which sharply distinguishes it from the generality of current academic criticism, of whatever school. 
 This is desirable in itself, though I do not warm to the feminist MacCarthyism which subjects texts to a close, hostile interrogation in a search for sexist attitudes. 
 I have attempted to take a rapid view of developments in critical theory, or criticism with a theoretical consciousness, as they have appeared in British culture in the past twenty years. 
 There is an immediate contrast with the literary criticism and theory of the early twentieth century, in that most recent work begins and ends in the academy, and has little contact with current literary practice. 
 Both the New Criticism and Scrutiny  were products of the modernist literary revolution, and drew on it for their methods and their assumptions. 
 The American critics were usually poets themselves; Leavis made no attempt to be a creative writer &mdash; though he has been claimed as such by Ian Robinson &mdash; but his own criticism emerged from the Cambridge milieu of the twenties, where Eliot was a dominant influence. 
 A little earlier there was the remarkable work of Edgell Rickword as poet and critic, and, as editor of The Calendar of Modern Letters , a setter of the agenda for modern criticism. 
 Earlier still, in Russia, the Formalists had close connections with the Futurist poets, and attempted to provide a rationale for their revolutionary work. 
 Within the academic theory of the present time, approaches may either begin with literature, or with disciplines external to it. 
 Nicolas Tredell has usefully developed this distinction:  
 There are, broadly speaking, two kinds of theories which now bear on literary studies. 
 First, there is the kind specifically concerned with literature, or with an aspect of it: for example, the Russian Formalist notion of &bquo;literariness&equo; as linguistic defamiliarization; Bakhtin's view of the novel as &bquo;heteroglossic&equo;, a carnival of competing voices; Todorov's poetics of narrative, German and American reader-response theories. 
 Against such theories, Tredell sets those which emerge from other disciplines, and which have lately been more commanding and influential. 
 Such theories, he remarks, &bquo;are not centrally concerned with literature; indeed, they may marginalize or abandon it as a category&equo;, and he instances their source in such fields as philosophy, psychology, sociology, anthropology, linguistics. 
 In literary theory they emerge as Marxism, phenomenology, existentialism, structuralism, poststructuralism, deconstruction. 
 Tredell's analysis is perhaps too synchronic, suggesting that the various modes of literary theory coexist, whether easily or uneasily. 
 And so they do, on the shelves of libraries, or in the pages of textbooks. 
 In practice, though, in terms of what people are currently interested in, a diachronic model is needed. 
 Consider the implications of successiveness and change in the titles or subtitles of some recent books: After the new Criticism  by Frank Lentricchia; On Deconstruction.: Theory and Criticism After Structuralism  by Jonathan Culler; Displacement.: Derrida and After , edited by Mark Krupnick; Beyond Deconstruction  by Howard Felperin; The Contest of Faculties.: Philosophy and Theory After Deconstruction  by Christopher Norris. 
 Significantly, most of them are by Americans, for it is in the American academy that the pressure for change, for constantly new forms of newness, is greatest. 
 Things move more slowly in Britain, but the same pressures exist among that small but active segment of the academy that is concerned with critical theory. 
 This state of affairs has complicated my present task, since what was current when I began thinking about this book a few years ago, and, indeed, when working on earlier drafts of it, is now ceasing to be so. 
 In the present Chapter I have written of movements in theory in the present tense, whereas what is ideally required is something grammatically subtler &mdash; perhaps there are languages where it exists &mdash; like a special tense in which the present extends back  to include actions or events that are already in the recent past. 
 This would be the appropriate tense for the writing of that paradoxical genre, &bquo;contemporary history&equo;. 
 What I have presented as analysis of current movements may well have acquired a historical flavour by the time these words are read. 
 If so, I am not abashed. 
 Contemporary intellectual history is an element in my present enterprise, though the very recent past is hard to see clearly. 
 I move towards the conclusion of this Chapter by invoking a further term in the sequence of titles quoted above: a recent paper by David Lodge called &bquo;After Bakhtin&equo;. 
 Bakhtin is a latecomer on the anglophone critical scene. 
 His major work was done in Russia in the 1930s and 1940s, he suffered Stalinist repression, was partly rehabilitated, and died in 1975, at a time when very few people in the West had heard of him. 
 But, as Lodge says, &bquo;he was thinking his way, with the minimum of intellectual and material support, through the questions which preoccupy us, decades before we even thought of them.&equo; 
 Bakhtin is a theorist in Tredell's first category, those whose work originates in literature itself. 
 In contrast to the poststructuralists, whose concern with actual literary texts is perfunctory or marginal, Bakhtin's work is focused on two major European authors, Dostoevsky and Rabelais. 
 Though Russian, Bakhtin wrote in a tradition of Germanic scholarship, and his work, particularly in the collection of theoretical essays, The Dialogic Imagination , can be prolix, repetitive, and opaque. 
 But the opacity, unlike the ludic obscurities of French poststructuralists, is not intended to undermine traditional meaning. 
 Bakhtin means to mean something, however difficult the meaning, and reading him is recognizably like reading the great critics of the past. 
 As is becoming well known, Bakhtin's central ideas are basically straightforward, and prominent among them is &bquo;dialogue&equo;. 
 Speech implies other speech, either preceding it, or as an anticipated rejoinder. 
 As Lodge puts it, &bquo;According to Bakhtin, language is essentially social or dialogic . 
 The words we use come to us already imprinted with meanings, intentions and accents of others, and any utterance we make is directed towards some real or hypothetical Other.&equo; 
 Bakhtin established the kind of binary opposition that is almost commonplace in  modern critical theory; it was between the &bquo;monologic&equo; and the &bquo;dialogic&equo;. 
 The former was dominated by a single mode of utterance, as in the traditional literary genres, the lyric, epic, and tragedy. 
 The &bquo;dialogic&equo;, which involves a plurality of voices, was particularly characteristic of the novel. 
 At first Bakhtin found this quality, otherwise &bquo;polyphony&equo; or &bquo;heteroglossia&equo;, to be particularly characteristic of Dostoevsky, but he later extended it to typify the novel as a genre. 
 Bakhtin is unusual among literary critics in making the focus of his activity the novel rather than lyric poetry or drama. 
 In practice, binary oppositions are very liable to favour one term at the expense of the other, and there can be no doubt that Bakhtin preferred the dialogic to the monologic (a bias that is evident in everyday English, where to engage in dialogue is good, and to utter a monologue is rather bad). 
 This emphasis made the so-called &bquo;monologic&equo; forms of literature problematical, and Lodge quotes from an interesting late essay by Bakhtin which seems to suggest that all  literary discourse is to some degree dialogic. 
 To remove the distinction completely would seem to undermine the insights that had given force to Bakhtin's earlier criticism. 
 Lodge suggests that this need not happen, if one sees the monologic and dialogic as dominant tendencies rather than mutually exclusive terms. 
 &bquo;Dialogic criticism&equo; can provide new ways of reading. 
 It is distinct from the methods of the old New Criticism, which though believing that lyric poems were dramatic utterances, still read them as the utterance of a single voice. 
 Even when applied to the novel, as in Leavis's writings on novelists or Lodge's own early critical book, Language of Fiction , the New Criticism looked for passages of quasi-authorial description, or the exploration of consciousnesses that seem to carry authorial support. 
 Dialogic reading can also defuse poststructuralist scepticism about the possibility of meaning. 
 To quote Lodge again, &bquo;instead of having desperately to defend the possibility of a fixed or stable meaning in isolated utterances, we can cheerfully accept that meaning exists in the process of intersubjective communication, since no utterance ever is truly isolated.&equo; 
 One has the sense that everyone now thinks well of Bakhtin, whether a Marxist like Terry Eagleton, a historical scholar such as Jerome J. McGann, or a practising  novelist and critic of fiction, David Lodge. 
 One must resist seeing Bakhtin as the US Cavalry, riding in to rescue a threatened humanism from howling poststructuralists. 
 Bakhtin was, I think, a humanist, but not in any obvious traditional mould. 
 He remained some kind of Marxist, and his concept of the &bquo;carnivalesque&equo;, drawn from Rabelais, was presented as a mode of ideological subversion, a pulling down of the mighty from their seats. 
 It will take time for the implications of his work to be properly assimilated and understood; the process involves transposition from a cultural context that is more remote than the French. 
 But the growing interest in it suggests that it offers both a possible way out of present impasses and a way forward.  
 WHO IS DERRIDA, WHAT IS HE ? 
 During the 1980s the stars of French thought fell from the heavens at a disconcerting rate. 
 Louis Althusser, the severe exponent of anti-humanist Marxism, lapsed into uxoricidal depression and was placed in confinement. 
 Then came the deaths of Barthes, Lacan, Foucault. 
 The currency and power of ideas does not depend on their authors' continued physical presence. 
 Indeed, Bakhtin provides an example of someone whose thought has only become influential in the years following his death. 
 Nevertheless, the versions of structuralism and poststructuralism associated with these French masters have not advanced since they left the scene, and if anything have tended to decline. 
 This may be coincidence, or it may be that the star system in French intellectual culture requires its major performers to be visibly on stage. 
 And what was true of France has also been true, a little later, of the English-speaking world. 
 The major exception to these considerations is the vigorous Jacques Derrida, an admired figure in both the French and the American academic worlds, and a man whose dominance in contemporary critical theory is inescapable. 
 He deserves separate attention, though I shall not attempt an exposition or interpretation of Derrida's thought, which I am incompetent to undertake. 
 My concern is with the nature of his reputation, and the striking extent to which both his admirers and his detractors are unable to agree on what kind of writer Derrida is, or even what he is actually saying. 
 The one thing all readers are likely to agree on is that Derrida is a very difficult writer, whether he is read in French or in English translation. 
 This charge might be dismissed, of course, as one more example of Anglo-Saxon empirical ignorance, complacent insularity, intellectual laziness, and so forth. 
 Yet the philosopher John Searle has recorded that Foucault once described Derrida's prose style to him as &bquo; obscurantisme terroriste &equo;. 
 From such a quarter this is significant testimony (though it prompts in me the reflection that it takes one to  know one). 
 Searle glosses Foucault's comment by saying, &bquo;The text is written so obscurely that you can't figure out exactly what the thesis is (hence &bquo; obscurantisme &equo;) and then when one criticizes it, the author says, &bquo; Vous m'avez mal compris; vous &ecirc;tes idiot  '&equo; (hence &bquo; Terroriste &equo;).&equo; 
 The counter-move to such complaints is to say that the concept of lucidity is itself repressive, and that unravelling Derrida's meanings is itself a deconstructive act, directed against hegemonic ideological positions. 
 Yet despite the obscurity, Derrida's reputation has spread remarkably. 
 In 1983, visiting a university in provincial Norway, I found students of English grappling perplexedly with Derrida, having been encouraged to do so by their British professor. 
 A year or so before that I was at a conference in America where deconstruction bulked largely on the agenda. 
 Between formal sessions I asked an amiable American academic precisely how he managed to familiarize his students with it, given the difficulty. 
 He admitted that it was not easy, and said that, in effect, what one did was to get them to read the first chapter of any book by Derrida. 
 In such ways, fashion and triviality can go hand in hand. 
 It is noticeable that though Derrida is a philosopher, albeit one interested in literature, and has always worked in an academic-philosophical context, even if on the margins of the subject, his major impact in North America has been in literature departments. 
 Though some of his followers have philosophical training and interests, and are acquainted with the matrices of Derrida's thought in Hegel, Husserl, and Heidegger, his transmission in literary and cultural contexts has meant that his ideas have become simplified, his paradoxes and contradictions tamed and diminished. 
 One writer, whose interest in poststructuralism is primarily philosophical, has commented: 
 the reception of Derrida's work, perhaps more than that of any other recent French thinker, has been marked by an astonishingly casual and unquestioning acceptance of certain extremely condensed &mdash; not to say sloganistic &mdash; characterisations of the history of Western thought, as if this history could be dismissed through its reduction to a set of perfunctory dualisms. 
 People in literature departments are not used to handling ideas, it not being their m&eacute;tier , and traditionally they were not  required to, beyond such elementary tokens as the Elizabethian World Picture or the Death of God. 
 So it is not surprising that deconstruction was reduced to what could be easily handled and passed on. 
 Why Derrida has had such a vogue in America is indeed a puzzle, as Searle and others have acknowledged. 
 His name has been moderately conjured with by British academics, but there have been few attempts to systematize his work for the classroom, as has happened in the United States. 
 One obvious explanation is that deconstruction provided a convenient successor to the New Criticism in mass higher education, providing a form of detailed close analysis of texts which does not require much in the way of contextual cultural literacy. 
 But Norris has given a further and suggestive explanation: &bquo;The possession of a written  Constitution whose principles are yet open to all manner of far-reaching judicial review&hellip; gives a political edge to questions of textual and interpretative theory that they do not have in the British cultural context.&equo; 
 It is true that deconstructive approaches have emerged in American law schools as well as in literature departments. 
 The more simplistic versions of Derrida are common both to those who admire him and those who detest him. 
 In admiring expositions revolutionary rhetoric is apparent: Derrida is said to have subverted Western thought, and called in question the customary concepts of philosophy, literature, and criticism. 
 A key text is his early essay, &bquo;Structure, Sign and Play in the Discourse of the Human Sciences&equo;, which concludes that there are two possible interpretations of interpretation: &bquo;The one seeks to decipher, dreams of deciphering a truth or an origin which escapes play and the order of the sign, and which lives the necessity of interpretation as an exile. 
 The other, which is no longer turned toward the origin, affirms play and tries to pass beyond man and humanism&hellip; 
 &bquo;. Derrida says that these two interpretations are absolutely irreconcilable, even though, he adds in his gnomic fashion, &bquo;we reconcile them in an obscure economy&equo;. 
 It is his second interpretation, deriving substantially from Nietzsche, that has become dominant in deconstruction as popularly understood, where all meaning is turned into &bquo;play&equo;. 
 And it is this approach which leads to denunciation of Derrida as a  nihilist; in Frederick Crews's words, &bquo;an intellectual nihilist, though a learned and exuberant one&equo;. 
 Raymond Tallis expands the charge, towards the end of his long negative analysis of Derrida's thought: 
 His is in some ways a tragic case: a man of immense talent and massive erudition, gifted with profound insights, who could not say the things he most wanted to say but who, nevertheless, has gone on to say them. 
 The publicity his ideas have attracted has only deepened the tragedy: the bad influence of those he has himself influenced has added frivolity to the obscurity&hellip; 
 Derrida's admirers, and perhaps some disinterested observers, would reject such charges as based on misunderstandings of his work. 
 This, indeed, is the most common defence of Derrida, whether advanced by himself or by his disciples. 
 And yet what does it mean to understand the formulations of someone for whom, on the face of it, final understanding is impossible, or never to be fully achieved? 
 It is this built-in contradiction and barrier to explication that leads to so much discussion of what Derrida really means by those riddling notions that have become slogans: such as, there is no such thing as perception; writing is prior to speech; there is nothing outside the text. 
 These phrases, and others like them, have been debated and pondered, interpreted and reinterpreted, as though they were the formulations of the great philosophers of the past, like Plato or Kant, rather than the work of a living thinker in mid-career. 
 There is a sense in which interpretation without conclusion is a mode of &bquo;play&equo;; deconstruction insists that philosophical texts must be read as though they were literary texts, with full attention to their ambiguities and irresolutions. 
 In this light, arguments about Derrida's &bquo;meaning&equo; have the fascination and intractability of arguments about the interpretation of, say, Eliot's poetry. 
 Indeed, it is a central assumption of deconstruction that the distinction between literature and philosophy is exaggerated, or arbitrary, or even meaningless. 
 Certainly, some of Derrida's later work, such as The Post Card , looks more like &bquo;experimental&equo; literature than philosophy in the normal sense. 
 But provisionally granting the premiss that philosophical texts should be interpreted like literature, with careful attention to their textuality, then the question of language intervenes. 
 Arguments in anglophone circles about Derrida's  possible meanings are usually based on translations, without reference to the French originals. 
 Perhaps Derrida's most famous slogan, from Of Grammatology , is &bquo; il n'y a pas de hors-texte &equo;. 
 This can be, and has been, taken in all sorts of ways. 
 At one extreme, it is regarded as self-evidently nihilistic, a dissolution of reality into textuality. 
 At the opposite extreme, an English philosopher has tamed it to a position of common-sense moderation: 
 If meaning is brought to birth within the text, the text itself is the bearer of all the Reality that inheres in meaning; and that, when one thinks about it, is, while by no means all the Reality there is, quite a good portion of that part of Reality which matters to us. 
 Allan Megill has pointed out that an alternative &bquo;meaning&equo; of the phrase is, &bquo;there is no inserted plate&equo; (a French dictionary defines &bquo;hors-texte&equo; as &bquo;Gravure, planche tir&eacute;e &aacute; part et intercal&eacute;e dans un livre&equo;). 
 Those who take Derrida seriously fall broadly into two camps. 
 There are those who accept him as a subverter of meanings, including his own, an anti-philosopher, a disconcerting jester, gleefully overturning accepted habits of thought. 
 In the second camp are those who regard him as a true philosopher, however provocative his manner, who is restating traditional philosophical problems in a new way. 
 This position is evident among English writers such as Bernard Harrison, Peter Dews, and Christopher Norris. 
 The first approach is more common in the United States. 
 It was brashly exemplified by Geoffrey Hartman, in his tediously playful book, Saving the Text: &mdash; Literature/Derrida/Philosophy . 
 Hartman presents himself in a complicated relationship with Derrida: engaging with him, succumbing to him, imitating him, and trying to resist him. 
 In the last of these veins, Harman acknowledges, &bquo;The problem, on the surface at least, is the persistence, the seriousness, with which an intelligence of this order employs devices that seem to be at best witty and at worst trivial.&equo; 
 Here Hartman is also covertly speaking of himself, for his puns and wordplay and his jokey chapter headings are seldom far from the trivial. 
 Hartman is in the forefront of those deconstructionists who want to abolish the distinctions between philosophy, literature, and criticism,  reducing them all to a rich textual stew. 
 In so far as Hartman's book wants to be read as a form of fiction, one can make the adverse literary-critical point that the prose is dense and cloyingly arch, with a crooning, caressing quality about it, suggesting the tone of a man talking quietly and earnestly to himself rather than trying to communicate anything to others. 
 Hostile critics have given Hartman a hard time. 
 Crews has referred to &bquo;a self-congratulatory hermeticism whose purpose seems to lie somewhere between the dropping of names, the displaying of tidbits of esoterica, and the muddling of agency&equo;, and Tallis has written a cruel parody of Hartman's prose. 
 There is a more serious account of Derrida as subverter in Allan Megill's elegant and impressive book, Prophets of Extremity: Nietzsche, Heidegger, Foucault, Derrida . 
 Megill writes not as a literary critic but as a philosophically trained historian of ideas. 
 He regards Derrida as an &bquo;artist-philosopher&equo;, owing much to Nietzsche, who saw the world as a work of art. 
 Megill discusses Derrida's early interest in French imaginative writers &mdash; Mallarm&eacute;, Bataille, Sollers, Ponge, Blanchot &mdash; whose work was directed to calling the idea of literature in question. 
 He points to Derrida s fascination with fourfold elements, evident in his deconstruction of the Hegelian triad &mdash; thesis, antithesis, synthesis &mdash; to add a fourth element, which is deconstruction itself. 
 Beyond this specific instance, fourfoldness has a life of its own in his thought; it appears in card-games &mdash; &bquo;le jeu des cartes&equo; relates to &bquo;le jeu Descartes, &mdash; where there are four suits, plus a joker, whom Megill identifies with Derrida himself. 
 Derrida as joker undermines all practices and ideas, including his own. 
 Megill stresses Derrida's debt to Mallarm&eacute; and Nietzsche, two strange masters from the last fin de si&egrave;cle  who are exercising such an influence in our own. 
 Nietzsche is Megill's first and greatest example of the &bquo;artist-philosopher&equo;, who has been followed by other &bquo;prophets of extremity&equo;. 
 By the time one gets to Derrida, the latest and youngest of the sequence, Nietzsche's myth of art has itself been dissolved by Derrida's pervasive irony: &bquo;If Nietzsche is an ironic mythmaker, Derrida seems only ironic: the radicality of his irony undermines any pretension to myth. 
 Thus instead of articulating a justificatory art, he chooses to  question the myth of art itself.&equo; 
 And yet what Derrida writes is as much art as philosophy; Megill compares his glas  to Finnegans Wake . 
 He remarks, &bquo;the movement of a text by Derrida is directed less by the logic of an argument than by word play, free association, and an almost obsessive recurrence of a limited number of motifs.&equo; 
 Megill himself, in his discussion of Derrida, as in the whole of his book, combines detailed knowledge of the texts, sympathetic treatment of his subject, and an ultimate detachment from it, so that it is not easy to discern his own attitudes. 
 Indeed, he brings his own delicately poised irony to bear at the end of his book when he writes, 
 If, upon hearing of the manifest truth of the work of art or of the textual, fictional character of the world, the reader will let a knowing smile play upon his face where previously he maintained an attitude of high seriousness, then the aim of this book will have been in part achieved. 
 Finally, for Megill, the artist-philosophers are more concerned with interpreting reality as an aesthetic phenomenon than with traditional truth-telling. 
 Their value for the reader lies in enlarging or changing our perceptions, in helping us to break out from a deadening routine; in short, the carnivalesque: &bquo;The prophets of extremity put up a distorting mirror against our world &mdash; but one which properly attended to, can tell us something about that world, and about the possibilities of changing it, or changing ourselves.&equo; 
 This hortatory and vaguely uplifting conclusion is out of key with the body of Megill's book, which is distinguished by the penetrating quality of its readings, and which, among much else, offers a very persuasive presentation of Derrida as joker. 
 It is, however, the philosopher rather than the joker who is in evidence in Imre Salusinsky's interview with Derrida, conducted in 1985. 
 It is straightforward and lucid, in great contrast to Derrida's impenetrable interviews with French interlocutors in the late 1960s and early 1970s which are collected in Positions . 
 Derrida comes across as seriously concerned with philosophy and the problems of teaching it; and he is non-committal in his response to a question about the possibility of introducing deconstruction into high schools. 
 At one interesting moment he reflects on his responsibilities as a teacher in a very serious-minded way:  
 I wouldn't advocate a university that would be cut off from society. 
 We know that we have to train people towards a profession. 
 I'm against some sorts of professionalization, but it would be silly to think that the university should have nothing to do with any profession. 
 You have to train people to become doctors or engineers or professors, and at the same time to train them in questioning all that &mdash; not only in a critical way, but I would say in a deconstructive way. 
 This is a double responsibility: two responsibilities which sometimes are not compatible. 
 In my own teaching, in my own responsibilities, I think I have to make two gestures simultaneously: to train people, to teach them, to give them a content, to be a good pedagogue, to train teachers, to give them a profession; and at the same time to make them as conscious as possible of the problems of professionalization. 
 These admirable sentiments are certainly not those of a nihilist. 
 Elsewhere in the interview Derrida invokes his key word &bquo;play&equo; in much the same sense in which Arnold employed it in the &bquo;free play of mind&equo;. 
 Those who take Derrida seriously as a philosopher can either agree or disagree with him. 
 John Searle is one of the latter. 
 In the late 1970s he clashed with Derrida in the pages of the poststructuralist yearbook, glyph , where Searle made some sharp remarks, such as that Derrida &bquo;has a distressing penchant for saying things that are obviously false.&equo; 
 Derrida's reply did not take the form of a reasoned rebuttal but of ninety pages of verbal clowning, which put Searle in his place by referring to him throughout as &bquo;Sarl&equo;, an acronym for &bquo;Societ&eacute; &agrave; responsabilit&eacute; limit&eacute;e&equo;, which means a limited company. 
 Derrida thus turned his opponent from a person into an institution, and his piece was called &bquo;Limited Inc abc&equo;. 
 Searle returned to the attack in 1983, in a review of Jonathan Culler's On Deconstruction . 
 He claimed that Derrida was in error in his claim that throughout the history of Western philosophy speech had been privileged above writing. 
 He further argues that Derrida's fundamental claim that speech is really writing, and that writing is prior to speech, is based on a redefinition of terms, and that by such methods one could prove anything, that the rich are really poor, that the true is really false, and so on. 
 Searle characterizes Derrida as a genuine philosopher, who, because modern philosophy had undermined the transcendental grounding for reality offered by traditional metaphysics, concludes that there is nothing left but the free play of signifiers. 
 Searle finds this an unwarranted conclusion.  
 Christopher Norris also reads Derrida in philosophical terms, even though professionally he teaches English in the University of Wales. 
 Unlike Searle he admires Derrida, and believes that he is genuinely concerned with major philosophical questions. 
 Indeed, Norris looks for a possible rapprochement  between deconstruction and the Anglo-American philosophical tradition exemplified by Searle, though he finds that Derrida has more possible affinities with Searle's master, Austin. 
 Norris is at some pains to extricate Derrida's meanings from the American literary critics whom he believes have misappropriated them. 
 An unfamiliar Derrida emerges from Norris's book on him, not a nihilist, an artist-philosopher or a joker, but a profound thinker who does not uphold the positions that are popularly ascribed to him: irrationalism; interpretation as an unending free-for-all; meaning disappearing in a cloud of dispersing signifiers; the abandonment of reference and the disappearance (or death) of the author. 
 Norris writes: 
 Certainly it has been a main object of Derrida's texts to show how philosophers, from plato to Husserl, have striven and failed to suppress the signs of rhetorical disruption in the discourse of philosophic reason. 
 But he has also been careful to repudiate that facile misreading of deconstruction &mdash; prevalent among literary critics &mdash; which thinks to turn the tables on philosophy by proclaiming that &bquo;all concepts are metaphors&equo;, or that philosophic truth-claims are really metaphorical through and through. 
 Such readings or misreadings tend to originate in Nietzsche. 
 For Norris, and, as he claims, for Derrida, deconstruction is 
 a rigorous attempt to Think the limits  of that principle of reason which has shaped the emergence of Western philosophy, science and technology at large&hellip; the activity of deconstruction is strictly inconceivable outside the tradition of enlightened rational critique whose classic formulations are still to be found in Kant (Norris's italics). 
 Norris's book is, in its own terms, persuasive and carefully argued. 
 He shows himself to be here, as he did in his earlier Deconstruction: Theory and Practice , an admirably lucid and urbane expositor of difficult ideas. 
 Anyone who can say so clearly just what Derrida is saying, or doing, immediately puts the reader in his debt. 
 Yet the clarity and rigour may in themselves be problematical. 
 This was the position argued some years ago by practitioners of la nouvelle critique , who  believed that clarity in argument was a form of ideological mystification, reinforcing the status quo . 
 Put in such extreme terms, the position is clearly absurd and self-defeating. 
 But, for Derrida, whose fusion &mdash; or (con) fusion &mdash; of obscurity and playfulness is an essential element in his textuality, Norris's exposition may represent a process of intellectual tidying up which leaves out something important. 
 Working hard against the prevalent impression of Derrida as some kind of irresponsible comedian, Norris continually insists on his &bquo;rigorous&equo; and &bquo;scrupulous&equo; reading of philosophical and literary texts. 
 One takes the point, whilst insisting that scrupulosity and rigour are matters of means not ends. 
 A generation or so ago, New Critics and Scrutineers did assume that scrupulosity and rigour were selfjustifying ends in criticism. 
 Since then much theoretical work has been directed at this short-sighted empiricism, uncovering the pattern of cultural or ideological assumptions that supported it. 
 Norris falls short of isolating or defining the actual end to which Derrida's scrupulous and rigorous readings are directed. 
 This is perhaps inevitable since deconstruction resists teleology, and it is this resistance that has enabled its enemies to call it nihilist. 
 Leaving intellectual content aside, there is an obvious contrast between Norris's manner, which is in the best English academic tradition, clear, cautious, attentive to evidence, moving from one conclusion to the next, and Derrida's exuberant obfuscation. 
 In his introduction Norris acknowledges the difficulty of writing about him at all in such a context: 
 That he should now figure as an addition to the Modern Masters series is yet another irony of Derrida's ascent to intellectual stardom. 
 No philosopher has done more to disown the idea that his writings embody some kind of masterly or authoritative wisdom. 
 And the irony is compounded by the fact that Derrida goes out of his way to resist any kind of adequate treatment in a book like this. 
 Norris's book is, in fact, more than adequate as a title in a series on Modern Masters. 
 Yet it is likely that he has imposed a colour-filter on Derrida, which lets through the rational elements and occludes the irrational ones. 
 Norris virtually admits as much from time to time. 
 Discussing Of Grammatology , he says he will treat it as a book with a theme, even though Derrida wants to discourage such an approach to it. 
  Derrida's famous paper &bquo;Structure, Sign and Play&equo; aroused much excitement when it was delivered at a conference on structuralism at Johns Hopkins in 1966, and has since acquired a mythological significance as the fountainhead of American deconstruction. 
 In so far as that essay gives some warrant to the idea of free-for-all hermeneutics, then, concedes Norris, &bquo;&bquo;Structure, Sign and Play'&equo; is a text which, at least in its closing paragraphs, falls below the highest standards of Derridean argumentative rigour.&equo; 
 Despite these occasional reservations, Norris writes as a disciple, who believes that other disciples, as well as Derrida's enemies, have got him wrong. 
 Arguing for what he believes to be the right way of reading Derrida, Norris makes what is essentially a forensic case. 
 What does emerge from it is that Norris's way of reading Derrida is likely to make considerable demands on the reader. 
 The texts are to be read and reread, with all the scrupulosity and rigour that Norris attributes to Derrida, and if not wholly in French, at least with frequent references to the original. 
 For Norris the provocative sloganistic phrases by which Derrida is best known will make true sense only when restored to the contexts from which they have been taken. 
 Norris may well be right that Derrida deserves such attention, but he is not often likely to receive it in the conditions of actual pedagogy, or in the random public exchanges of higher cultural life, which put a premium on the simplifying and the reductive. 
 It is, nevertheless, interesting that Norris should say, in passing, of Nietzsche; &bquo;there are many competing versions of Nietzsche, none possessing any absolute claim to articulate the &bquo;truth'&equo; of his text, but all  of them &mdash; and this is Derrida's point &mdash; made possible by something in the logic, the syntax or the structural resources of his writing.&equo; 
 What is true of Nietzsche is surely true of Derrida, of whom there are many competing versions; Norris presumably believes that his contains the truth, without distancing quotation marks. 
 But the other versions, admiring ones like Hartman's or Megill's, and hostile ones like Tallis's, are all based on something in his writing. 
 And it is their Derrida, the nihilist or joker, who has been so influential in literature departments. 
 There are other possible interpretations. 
 Michael Ryan has looked for a  rapprochement  between deconstruction and Marxism. 
 Edward Said discovers a kind of negative theology in Derrida's writing, and Nicolas Tredell says something similar, &bquo;one might draw some interesting comparisons between, for instance, deconstruction and Nagarjunan Buddhism, which dissolves a metaphysics of presence into a metaphysics of absence, the Void.&equo; 
 One may, in Derridean terms, play with these conflicting versions of &bquo;Derrida&equo;, but sooner or later, if one is writing about him, or teaching him, then one has to choose, since they are competing  versions. 
 It may be that to choose is to distort so protean an entity. 
 If so, this is yet one more of the paradoxes attending this remarkable figure, who, disavowing mastery has become a Master, and who undermines his meanings in advancing them.  
 SPLENDOURS AND MISERIES OF THE ACADEMY  
 I  
 Traditionally, people who wrote criticism often also wrote poetry or novels, and engaged in the discussion of politics and public affairs. 
 Things are now otherwise. 
 As Frank Kermode has put it, 
 You won't find it easy to name an important critic who was a critic, and nothing else; that is, until quite recently. 
 The world is now full of literary critics, some held to be important, who do nothing else but write literary criticism, and they all work in universities. 
 Kermode is referring to the demise of the man of letters, or the &bquo;bookman&equo; as he became known in late-Victorian England, and his replacement by the professionalized university critic. 
 Kermode sees this change &mdash; which is at the heart of what I am writing about &mdash; as having radical implications for letters, comparable to such things as the advent, first of printing and then of cheap paper; the bourgeoisie's greater leisure for private reading; and the abandonment by circulating libraries of the three-volume novel, which had been the favoured vehicle for fiction during much of the nineteenth century: Kermode exaggerates a little, I think; nothing in the establishment of university English is as important as the innovations in culture and technology which established the book in its modern form. 
 But he is right in seeing the movement of criticism from literature to the academy as having large cultural implications. 
 Kermode thinks that this process, with all that it implies, is a fact of life, which has to be lived with, whatever we think of it. 
 We may have no choice but to do so, though I believe that the change has been more damaging than beneficial. 
 There is the further consideration that universities may not indefinitely be secure havens for literary criticism, in the cold economic climate and rampant anti-intellectualism of Thatcherite Britain, and of many other parts of the world.  
 When English was established in British universities criticism played at best a minor part in it. 
 There was a &bquo;critical paper&equo; in the Oxford degree, but the emphasis was substantially on scholarship of a tough traditional kind, without much concession to the Arnoldian free play of mind. 
 For a long time Oxford English was directed towards scholarship and was suspicious of criticism, and this attitude was reflected in its house organ, The Review of English Studies . 
 Helen Gardner, for many years an Oxford luminary, did not believe that the purpose of &bquo;English&equo; was to turn out critics, any more than it was to produce poets and novelists. 
 The graduate in English was to be to some extent a scholar, in so far as he or she had a sense of the past and the capacity to understand literature in its historical contexts, particularly linguistic; beyond that, what was looked for was wide reading, an appreciation of masterpieces, and a capacity to write well, attend to evidence, and disentangle sense from nonsense in argument. 
 It was not, in fact, a bad educational programme, but it did not have the glamour of Cambridge English, where the idea of criticism was central, as instanced by the great success and influence of Richards's Practical Criticism . 
 Gardner, like other Oxford Anglicans, resisted &bquo;the religious and missionary approach to the study of literature evident in the Newbolt report and the Cambridge pioneers. 
 She was not positively hostile to criticism, indeed, she produced a book called The Business of Criticism . 
 But her concept of criticism was that it should be elucidatory and illuminating rather than evaluative. 
 Her assumptions are broadly Crocean; value appeared in the individual's response to the particular work, but should not be erected into hierarchies, and the reader should cultivate &bquo;the receptiveness and disinterestedness which are the conditions of aesthetic experience.&equo; 
 Non-evaluative criticism, as propounded by the successive Merton professors, Gardner and Carey, has long been a popular ideal at Oxford. 
 But another Oxford professor, John Bayley, sees things differently. 
 Discussing a book on Dostoevsky, he remarks that while the author has much of interest to say about The Idiot  &bquo;she does not quite persuade one that it comes off, indeed she does not really try, because like many scholars  today she is more concerned with showing how the thing works than with judging if it works well.&equo; 
 From the beginning academic literary study was divided between those who saw it as inevitably involved with making judgements and those who did not. 
 Cambridge English represented the former: Richards and Leavis wanted an evaluative criticism, because they did not believe that literature was simply a matter of disinterested individual response; it was an index to the condition of civilization, which made judgements imperative. 
 Wherever Leavis exerted an influence, either directly, on his pupils, or via Scrutiny , then criticism was emphatically evaluative. 
 In practice this often meant that immature minds would take over Leavis's own evaluations without relating them to their own experience of literature, resulting in the diffusion of callow or inept judgements that has been condemned from the right by C. S. Lewis and from the left by Catherine Belsey. 
 Although the New Criticism in its later American manifestations generally pursued a purely formal and elucidatory analysis, Gerald Graff reminds us that the original New Critics were  evaluative, since they wrote as conservative Southerners who were much concerned with ideals of cultural health. 
 They were also, for the most part, practising poets and men of letters, who would want to make judgements. 
 Similarly, Cambridge English was originally sustained by the achievements of literary modernism which had a new agenda to write. 
 In later academic criticism, it is only among Marxists and feminists that we had an overt evaluative pressure. 
 Elsewhere the idea of a supposedly non-evaluative criticism has become general. 
 I have remarked on its dominance in Oxford English, and a generation ago it was given magisterial expression in Northrop Frye's Anatomy of Criticism , which aspired to a &bquo;scientific&equo; criticism where there would be no place for evaluation, since it is not nobler to study stars than earthworms. 
 In the recent work of the global anglophone academy, evaluative criticism has largely disappeared. 
 In its simpler, popularizing aspects the emphasis is on illumination and elucidation, and in its more advanced interpretative reaches the critic is concerned to trace unnoticed patterns of coherence and unity, or, more probably these days, incoherences and aporias. 
 Yet vestigial  gestures towards value persist, usually at the end of an exposition, where the critic in a final flourish claims, or at least hopes, that something valuable has emerged from the analysis; a revelation of the quality of the author's imagination; or of the inevitable tendency of all texts to be about their own processes of composition, or to come apart in the reader's hand; or of the aesthetic fascination of the patterns of imagery that have been revealed; or, at the very least, and least interestingly, that something &bquo;interesting&equo; will have been said. 
 Most of this academic activity is not, in fact, criticism as traditionally understood but something else, which is fundamentally a form of technical description. 
 Helen Gardner was aware of the problem, observing that the pursuit of image patterns, or of the ideas in a poem, can be useful to the interpreter, but cannot &bquo;be more than auxiliary in leading us to the true &bquo;meaning'&equo; of the work, which is the meaning which enlarges our own imaginative life.&equo; 
 What Gardner calls &bquo;meaning&equo; is, I take it, the work's unique expression of value, which we grasp intuitively. 
 John Bayley, after the remark quoted above, goes on to complain about &bquo;the almost purely technical nature of this modern criticism, even more unsuited to how we actually respond to Dostoevsky than it is to most authors.&equo; 
 Long ago, in the heyday of Cambridge English, Richards was making a similar distinction between the &bquo;critical&equo; and the &bquo;technical&equo;: &bquo;All remarks as to the ways and means by which experiences arise or are brought about are technical, but critical remarks are about the values of experiences and the reasons for regarding them as valuable, or not valuable.&equo; 
 Geoffrey Thurley claimed that much modern criticism, so-called, was mainly concerned with &bquo;scansion&equo;, which is the description, often very close and attentive, of the structural, formal, and technical features of a text. 
 Such criticism Thurley argued, very convincingly, never bridges the gap between description and interpretation, which for Thurley involves evaluation. 
 In practice, much academic interpretation &mdash; whether New Critical, archetypal, deconstructive, or whatever &mdash; is really, in his terms, a more or less refined form of description or &bquo;scansion&equo;. 
 He is very dismissive about the famous reading of a Shakespeare sonnet by Jakobson and Jones, which minutely analyses its linguistic features,  and emerges with a banal paraphrase which, Thurley remarks, &bquo;any schoolboy would scorn to produce&equo;. 
 If we take criticism out of its academic context and apply it to more things than literature, it is evident that comparisons of value are fundamental to it. 
 Consider, for instance, informed discussions of sporting events, which are always displays of evaluative analysis: who played well, who disappointingly, and why and how; or whether a team has played better at home or away, this season or last. 
 It is true that in such discussions the judgemental element does not exist in isolation, since it is interwoven with description, technical assessment of moves in play, and so forth, in ways suggested in Wittgenstein's lectures on aesthetics. 
 But to remove this element results in, at best, a decaffeinated criticism. 
 It has been taken for granted for a long time that criticism and the academy go naturally together, and a large pedagogic and publishing industry has been built on that assumption. 
 Nevertheless, I believe that the marriage, whatever its public appearance, is a difficult one, and results in bad faith and deception. 
 Helen Gardner was not a deep thinker, but she saw certain things more clearly than many sharper minds. 
 She was wrong to think that genuine criticism could be severed from evaluation, but right to think that there was no place for such criticism in the academy. 
 The &bquo;criticism&equo; which is copiously produced and read in literature departments eschews judgement for &bquo;scansion&equo;, technical analysis, and elaborate interpretations which nevertheless remain fundamentally descriptive. 
 This state of affairs is not, I think, an aberration, but is inevitable in the structures of higher education. 
 The example of Leavis and Scrutiny  may suggest otherwise. 
 Leavis was a major critic and a very influential educator, who was convinced both that criticism was essentially evaluative and that it was at the heart of English studies. 
 Yet Leavis was in many respects not a man of his time; though himself a dedicated university teacher, he was in spirit the last of the Victorian sages, who were men of letters and of affairs, not academics (prescinding from Arnold's and Ruskin's marginal tenure of chairs at Oxford). 
 Scrutiny  had an enormous influence on English studies, particularly in England, but its  immediate model was the non-academic Calendar of Modem Letters , and more remotely the great Victorian reviews, whose contents might be described as the higher literary journalism. 
 In its early years Scrutiny  was a fine embodiment of the spirit of criticism, literary and cultural. 
 Leavis's judgements were very much his own, laboriously arrived at, and presented with subtlety and rigour. 
 But these judgements were then taken over and pre-packaged for pedagogic purposes, so one had the spectacle of the Leavisite schoolmaster or university teacher who presented his students with duplicated copies of, say, sonnets by Hopkins and Rossetti, which they were invited to compare and contrast in evaluative terms. 
 There was no doubt that they were expected to admire the former and scorn the latter; anyone misguided enough to get the preference the wrong way round, would be regarded as at best na&iuml;ve and misguided, and at worst corrupted in sensibility. 
 Denys Thompson's Reading and Discrimination  (1934) is a collection of such comparative exercises. 
 Leavisism assumed that its rewriting of the canon had a once-and-for-all quality, so that it was inconceivable that anyone could come to admire Shelley again, though this is precisely what has happened under the influence of Harold Bloom, who is dedicated to overturning the Eliot-Leavis version of poetic history. 
 The attempt to enforce an evaluative criticism in the academy inevitably results in rigidity and dogmatism and, ultimately, a form of brainwashing. 
 Leavisites, of course, claimed that they were committed to discussion, argument, the free play of mind; in so far as they were, it was contained within the enclosing form of life, not directed against it, rather like arguments within Marxist-Leninist ideology. 
 It was this aspect of Leavisism that Oxford English, with its broad though often flaccid eclecticism, was most opposed to. 
 Venturing to propound a law of intellectual life, I suggest that evaluative criticism enters institutional literary study under the influence of practising writers, or of critics who have a close discipular relation to them, but that in time it is rejected, like an alien organ. 
 Writers, whose criticism arises directly from the problems and possibilities of their art, are inevitably evaluative; Baudelaire showed how being a poet also involves being a critic. 
 Eliot's early and best criticism  was what he called &bquo;workshop&equo; criticism, an attempt to realign literary tradition in the interests of the kind of poetry he wanted to write. 
 Leavis, at the beginning of his career a whole-hearted admirer of Eliot, took over Eliot's tentative critical models and systematized them. 
 Later he responded in a similar way to D. H. Lawrence's criticism, as well as to his creative achievement. 
 In America, as I have remarked, the original New Critics were evaluative, in ways closely connected to their own poetic practice. 
 Also in America there is the singular example of Yvor Winters, sometimes seen as an equivalent of Leavis, who was a poet of conservative but original talents, and a fiercely judgemental critic, who weirdly redrew the canons of English and American literature, so that T. Sturge Moore and Elizabeth Daryush emerged as major twentieth-century poets. 
 Unlike Leavis's, Winters's deconstruction of tradition proved too extreme to have even a temporary lodgement in the academy, though his readings of sixteenth-century poetry have had some influence, and a theorist such as Gerald Graff acknowledges a debt to Winters, who was his teacher. 
 It remains to show why genuine criticism is not at home in the academy; or, more precisely, why it is irreconcilable with pedagogic practice. 
 Criticism, I take it, is an activity that occurs between equals, whatever its object. 
 The critic is an unusually acute and well-informed reader, but there should be equality of esteem between the critic and other readers. 
 What he or she has to say is always open to comment, questioning, refutation. 
 This is apparent in the correspondence columns of those publications where the tradition of public criticism continues, like the Times Literary Supplement  and the London Review of Books . 
 There is, of course, an immense amount to be learned from good critics, but the critic's role and tone are not those of a teacher. 
 Critical seminars within the university may sometimes blur this distinction if they contain elements of genuine intellectual exchange. 
 Leavis defined critical discussion as taking the form, &bquo;This is so, isn't it?&equo; expecting the answer, &bquo;yes, but&hellip;&equo; (though never, &bquo;I very much doubt it&equo; or &bquo;No, in thunder!&equo;). 
 This formula may characterize the best form of discussion. 
 But it is disingenuous for academics to pretend that they can participate in such  discussion on terms of complete equality with their students, for there are questions of power and authority involved; at the end of the day, grades and marks, assessing and examining, come into the picture. 
 Students do not forget these overshadowing realities even if academics, caught up in the euphoria of a &bquo;really lively discussion&equo;, sometimes do. 
 The reality is often closer to that memorably described by David Lodge: 
 occasionally one feels, as a teacher, rather like a soccer referee who, having blown his whistle for the kick-off, finds the players disconcertingly reluctant to make a move and is reduced to dribbling the ball himself furiously from end to end, scoring brilliant goals in undefended nets, while the motionless players look curiously on. 
 Not only should there be equality of esteem and status between critic and readers, though the former may appear as first among equals, they should all be in possession of the subject of discussion. 
 They should all have read the book, in short. 
 This is why reviewing is not properly speaking criticism, though it calls for critical qualities, and an extended review-article, looking at a whole oeuvre, may well be. 
 This is true in all aspects of culture. 
 If we are discussing a football match or a meal in a restaurant, then at the very least we should all have seen the match or eaten the meal. 
 Furthermore, we should have a shared understanding of the rules of discourse about such subjects. 
 A proper discussion of a football match cannot occur if one of the participants is quite ignorant of the rules of the game; and the kind of assessment of a restaurant meal that would involve the possible insertion of the establishment into a good food guide (or perhaps its deletion from it) will not get very far if one of the diners does not care for the meal because his idea of a gastronomic treat is a cheeseburger and french fries (though within the order of the burger discriminations are possible). 
 The critical reader of a poem needs to have some idea of what a poem is, which need not be a theoretically sophisticated idea, and some acquaintance with poetry already. 
 In this context I want to refer to a brief but highly significant passage in Richards's Practical Criticism . 
 In the latter part of the book Richards discusses the reports on the  &bquo;protocols&equo;, the anonymous reports on the anonymous poems or extracts the respondents had been given to read. 
 He examines their various kinds of failure in reading, arising from the reader's susceptibility to personal fantasy, dominance by dogma, over-literalness, careless construing, and so on. 
 Most of these failures are in the order of mental operation, which is in accordance with Richards's dominantly psychologistic approach. 
 This is still true when he says that some of the respondents lacked the emotional maturity to respond adequately to poetry. 
 But he then goes on to remark that a further cause of inadequate response is the reader's unfamiliarity with poetry: &bquo;A lack of experience with poetry must be placed next to general inexperience of life in this list of deficiencies.&equo; 
 Here Richards switches from a psychological to a cultural factor. 
 The remark has not been much noticed, but its implications must undermine the way in which &bquo;practical criticism&equo; is often employed in literary education. 
 It has long been common practice to give students isolated passages of poetry or prose, often but not always anonymous, to analyse, discuss, and respond to, in the manner of Richards's original undertaking. 
 In this exercise students are urged to clear their minds of presuppositions, to concentrate on &bquo;the words on the page&equo;, and then to write down their responses. 
 The reading is deliberately contextless, and the mind is assumed or encouraged to be a Tabula rasa . 
 (More traditional pedagogy went for appreciation rather than analysis, urging the reader to a direct experience of the poem, perhaps inhaling its beauty like the scent of a flower; but the underlying process was similar.) 
 Such assumptions are quite contrary to what we know of how perception works. 
 The practice of &bquo;practical criticism&equo; in fact unconsciously takes it for granted that the readers already know enough about poetry to have a grasp of rules and conventions sufficient to make adequate sense of the passage. 
 Richards had to acknowledge that what he called &bquo;the relatively cultivated youth of our age&equo; were not very familiar with poetry. 
 If that was true, then, how much more true is it now, given the vast changes in education, society, and culture that have ensued since 1929? 
 I am not now going to engage in lamentations about the ignorance and lack of reading of present-day undergraduates, though I have done  so in my time, and could be easily provoked into them again. 
 I merely want to make the limited point that many of these students &mdash; who may be highly intelligent &mdash; do not have the existing familiarity with poetry, not to mention the general knowledge and cultural literacy, that would enable them to engage as equals in genuinely critical discussion. 
 Leavis held firm to the idea that any kind of responsible discussion of literature was a critical act, so that the academic was inescapably engaged in criticism when lecturing or conducting a seminar. 
 In reality this is unlikely to be true, as student and teacher do not have an equal possession of the text. 
 In other academic areas it is assumed that the teacher knows more than the student, and is there to convey this knowledge, whether as a corpus or a skill. 
 The conveying need not, indeed should not, be done in an authoritarian way. 
 In seminar teaching it should elicit feedback, questioning, the bringing out of implications or contradictions, and the opening up of fresh aspects of the subject. 
 Nevertheless, teaching implies an imbalance of knowledge, otherwise it would not be necessary. 
 The formal lecture, that archaic but strangely persistent mode, makes this apparent. 
 In literature teaching the emphasis is on shared experience rather than the conveying of information; a lecture is supposed to provide knowledge, elucidation, or interpretation of texts on the assumption that the auditors have already read them. 
 As anyone who has worked in an English department will know, many of those listening to the lecture will not have done the necessary reading, and are so reduced to hearing about and taking notes on something of which they have not had direct literary experience (even passing on their notes to friends who were absent from the lecture). 
 In a Crocean or Leavisite perspective this conveying of knowledge without experience is a useless activity. 
 It is, however, a common one, and a kind of collective bad faith. 
 Attempts are still made to introduce an element of evaluative criticism into academic teaching, whether from a surviving Leavisism, or under Marxist or feminist auspices. 
 My own efforts to do so have been instructive, but discouraging. 
 Judgements made in the course of a lecture will be taken down in notes as if they were facts, whereas it is in the nature  of critical judgements that they cannot be taken over by others; it is on this dilemma, I believe, that Leavisism ultimately foundered. 
 In the habitual contexts of English Literature teaching, students assume that if a work is on a reading list then it must be of approved quality, otherwise why is it there? 
 Attempts to provoke adverse judgements on canonical works tend to be resented as &bquo;finding fault with&equo; or &bquo;picking holes in&equo; these works of established merit, the result of a tiresome foible on the part of the teacher, and leading to disorientation if persisted in. 
 In these matters, I think the students may have a more realistic sense of the situation than the teacher. 
 There has been much discussion recently of the nature of literary canons; university teachers of English are seen as both initiators and guardians of the canon (as, for instance, by Kermode in his essay, &bquo;Institutional Control of Interpretation&equo;). 
 The academic institutionalizing of literary study inevitably leads to the establishing of canons (made necessary, among much else, by the logistic requirements of reading lists and bookshop orders), and where there are canons evaluation is, in the context of pedagogy, either impossible or unrewardingly difficult, since canonization implies merit. 
 And what is true of undergraduate teaching in England is equally true, mutatis mutandis , of the high-pressure environment of American graduate schools. 
 Furthermore, the great mass of academic critical writing produced in the United States is elucidatory, analytical, descriptive, scansional, not evaluative. 
 What is everywhere assumed, if not always made explicit, is that literary judgement has no place in the academy. 
 This is a correct assumption, since the institutional conditions preclude its effective existence. 
 Academics can still write evaluative criticism of course, and in so far as they do they are producing the kind of criticism practised by men of letters. 
 John Bayley provides an interesting instance. 
 Remarking that Dostoevsky's The Idiot  does not altogether &bquo;come off&equo;, he is making a coherent and discussable point, whether or not one accepts it. 
 Samuel Johnson might have said something similar, though in a very different idiom, about some accepted masterpiece of European literature. 
 But it is possible that the Dostoevsky scholar whose book prompted Bayley's comment might not have understood it &mdash;  how could an acknowledged great novel, worth writing about at length, be said not to &bquo;come off&equo;? 
 Bayley is a senior academic who has kept his distance from institutional pressures and writes in the manner of the traditional man of letters. 
 The despised belletrist criticism of an earlier day could make radical judgements in an off-hand manner; those articles, for instance, with titles like &bquo;On Rereading Stendhal&equo;, which come to the conclusion that Stendhal has been much overrated. 
 An established professor of French Literature might nowadays privately believe as much, but would probably think it unprofessional or damaging to argue the case publicly. 
 Leavis, who notoriously had no hesitation about attacking canonical figures, was closer to this tradition, however much he detested the belletrist spirit, than he was to later developments in academic criticism. 
 His iconoclasm about Milton, for instance, was anticipated by Walter Bagehot. 
 Conversely, men of letters have always been ready for exciting literary discoveries. 
 The young T. S. Eliot, coming across Laforgue as a Harvard undergraduate is a celebrated instance; there is Andr&eacute; Gide, well on in middle age, registering his delight and astonishment at James Hogg's Confessions of a Justified Sinner . 
 Donald Davie, in a dispirited essay called &bquo;Criticism and the Academy&equo;, ruefully acknowledges that the belletrist criticism of men of letters such as Edmund Wilson and Cyril Connolly (unequal figures, these, one has to remark) might have more to be said for it than he, as a lifelong academic, would be happy to acknowledge: 
 Edmund Wilson and Cyril Connolly were as ready to talk of Ovid as of the memoirs of Ulysses S. Grant, and indeed ready to illuminate the one by shafts of light thrown from the other&hellip; 
 Connolly and Wilson, we may agree, lived dangerously; they took risks, knowing full well that they were not au fait  with the latest scholarship, had not mastered &bquo;the secondary material&equo;. 
 And we tell our graduate students that they must never take such risks, construing as scruple what in fact is timidity. 
 Davie himself provides the example of a dedicated university teacher, who is at the same time a fine poet, a practitioner of rigorously evaluative criticism, and a judicious reviewer. 
 He is, in fact, a rare surviving embodiment of those long-vanished  ideals of the 1950s, when it briefly seemed that University English might provide a terrain where all these practices could converge. 
 Morris Dickstein has contributed an excellent essay to the collection in which Davie's piece appears, called &bquo;Journalism and Criticism&equo;. 
 Acknowledging the apparent opposition between these two terms, he goes on to argue, and to show from historical evidence, that throughout the nineteenth century, and into the early twentieth, much of the central function of criticism was carried by literary and cultural journalism, most of it, admittedly, of a more spacious and literate order than is common today. 
 It is to this tradition, I have suggested, that Scrutiny  was indebted. 
 At the present time, it has become attenuated but not extinct, and it continues in the long review-articles in the new York Review of Books  and London Review of Books , and a few other periodicals. 
 Academics contribute to it, certainly, but writing as critics, not academics, for it involves judgement as much as elucidation. 
 To take a particular instance, Martin Amis's The Moronic Inferno , published in 1986, is a collection of reprinted journalistic pieces on life, literature, and culture in contemporary America, a country for which he has mixed feelings of attraction and repulsion. 
 It is the work of a novelist and Journalist, not an academic, and notwithstanding the sometimes excessive brightness of the prose and the shortwindedness of the articles it seems to me a brilliant late embodiment of the Anglo-American tradition of literary and social criticism. 
 A central figure in Dickstein's essay is Henry James, a great critic, who could be subtly descriptive, elucidatory, analytical, and judgemental within the same piece of writing. 
 As Dickstein points out, much of James's critical writing was produced according to the exigencies of journalism and magazine publication; nevertheless, as now brought together in two large and handsome volumes in the Library of America series, it must be the finest body of literary criticism in English from a single author. 
 The whiggish notion that such writing might be somehow improved on or even supplanted by the critical mass-production of the anglophone academy is quite self-delusory.  
 II  
 Richards, as we have seen, thought that in order to be a good reader of poetry one must already be a reader of poetry. 
 This is true, to a lesser extent, of all forms of imaginative writing, but poetry is the most obviously governed by convention and genre, and in the eyes of both the Russian Formalists and of non-literary readers the most likely to display linguistic deformation. 
 In many academic disciplines no prior knowledge is required or assumed. 
 It is possible for sixth-form students in British secondary schools to take the Advanced- (&bquo;A&equo; &mdash;) level examination for school-leavers in such subjects as philosophy or economics or sociology, but it is not at all common, and incoming university students of these subjects usually begin at the beginning, with open minds but with the necessary commitment to learning. 
 In principle it would be quite possible for the study of English poetry to begin in a similar ab initio  fashion, except that it would be fruitless for someone to embark on it who did not have at least some familiarity with poetry and a wish to read more. 
 This is because the study of poetry as  poetry &mdash; rather than as historical or cultural material &mdash; is a matter of intuitive and affective response, not just of willingness to accept an intellectual discipline, as might be the case with philosophy, economics, and so forth. 
 (I grant that the difference is not absolute, and there may be elements of the affective and the intuitive in the pursuit of any intellectual discipline, but they are likely to be marginal.) 
 It could be a rewarding form of teaching to help an uninformed but well-motivated student to come to terms with poetry, but it would involve time and leisure. 
 The student would need to read as widely as possible in different kinds of poetry, to learn something about literary history, genre, and convention, and to acquire the practical-critical skills of close reading. 
 All this might well be accomplished in the comparatively open-ended context of adult or continuing education, which is not dominated by the teleology of the examination system. 
 In the high-pressured and directive context of undergraduate teaching it may be desirable, but is not practically possible. 
 Too often, even the desirability is not recognized.  
 It is my experience that many students of English Literature with good A-level results dislike poetry, or at least feel baffled by it, and can go through a three-year degree course without this attitude being radically changed. 
 There are elements of a vicious version of the hermeneutic circle involved: people don't like poetry because they haven't read enough to come to terms with it, and they haven't read enough because they don't like it. 
 Several factors are involved in this unhappy state of affairs: a general decline in cultural literacy, and in skill and practice in reading. 
 Poetry demands a form of reading that, though rewarding, is unusually intensive, and it is often avoided in sixth-form English teaching. 
 Work for the A-level examination in English Literature means a narrow concentration on a limited number of texts, and curricular pressures do not leave time for the undirected contextual reading that would provide broader literary experience. 
 Furthermore, I suspect that many sixth-form English teachers have acquired an Honours degree in the subject without ever coming to like or appreciate poetry, and they pass on their incapacities. 
 Hence the concentration on plays and novels, often modern ones, which is made increasingly possible with A-level syllabuses governed by the specious lure of relevance. 
 There are, of course, complex social and cultural factors to consider. 
 It is a common leftist belief that poetry is an &bquo;&eacute;litist&equo; mode, precisely because of the cultural literacy it presupposes, which gives an unfair advantage to students from middle-class homes with books. 
 The advantage is undeniably there; but what of the ever-increasing number from middle-class homes without books? 
 The grammar schools once provided the necessary culture of learning, as well as specific instruction, for students from under privileged homes, as we see in Judith Grossman's Her Own Terms , or Anthony Burgess's autobiographical recollection of reading English at Manchester University in the late thirties (some twenty years before I started teaching there myself). 
 Many things have changed since then. 
 Not only have the grammar schools disappeared, but the number of students going into higher education to read English has greatly increased, the social catchment is wider, and reading has come to seem more difficult.  
 It was a recurring motif in the Newbolt Report, echoed by Leavis, that English was not just another school or university subject, to be placed alongside geography or geology. 
 There is some truth in this, but not altogether in the sense that was there intended. 
 Unlike other academic disciplines, English in higher education presupposes both an existing knowledge and an existing competence, which in practice is often lacking. 
 As I have suggested, up to a generation ago a common form of life united sixth-form and university English, regardless of whether their orientation was &bquo;Oxford&equo; or &bquo;Cambridge&equo;, since the latter made much the same assumptions about literacy and competence as the former. 
 That shared culture has gone, though its traces have persisted for a long time, at least among those unworldly older academics who assume that students of English will have read the whole of Shakespeare in the sixth form, or that they can readily identify classical or biblical references. 
 The belated realization that these things are no longer so leads to the embittered and baffled reaction that they ought  to be so. 
 However, that is a declining reaction; the experience of regularly interviewing would-be entrants to an English degree course soon induces a sense of realism. 
 In the state of affairs that still obtained when I entered the profession in 1959 the grammar school teacher and the university teacher of English were not radically different kinds of person; indeed, contingent or accidental factors might have determined which career path was followed. 
 Since then there has been a marked divergence between school and university; students have become less well equipped, and academics, particularly young ones, have become more high-powered, ambitious, and professionalised. 
 I am convinced that many students often do not understand what is being said in teaching situations, though they become adept at pretending to, as they do not wish to lose face. 
 There is a further factor that feminists have drawn attention to, which is that the majority of students of English are women, whereas the majority of academics teaching it are male, and that the female students have a built-in deference to male teachers and to the minority of male students. 
 This is broadly true, and has long distorted the group dynamics of seminars, though I have the sense that things are changing as women become more self-confident (the arrival in increasing  numbers of female mature students has been helpful). 
 At the same time, I have noticed that women academics can be ruthless bullies of girl students, with the possibly laudable motive of giving them the equivalent of a good shake. 
 David Lodge, whose experience as novelist, critic, and professor of English has given him many insights into the situation I am describing, provides in his recent novel Nice Work , a neat instance of the gap between students and teacher. 
 Dr Robyn Penrose is a recognizable type of advanced young academic, leftist, feminist, poststructuralist: 
 She probably knows more about the nineteenth century industrial novel than anyone else in the entire world. 
 How can all that knowledge be condensed into a fifty-minute lecture to students who know almost nothing about it? 
 The interests of scholarship and pedagogy are at odds here. 
 What Roby, likes to do is to deconstruct the texts, to probe the gaps and absences in them, to uncover what they are not  saying, to expose their ideological bad faith, to cut a cross-section through the twisted strands of their semiotic codes and literary conventions. 
 What the students want her to do is to give them some basic facts that will enable them to read the novels as simple straightforward reflections of &bquo;reality&equo;, and to write simple, straightforward, exam-passing essays about them. 
 In an American context, E. D. Hirsch has remarked on a similar conflict of interest between students who want to know the basic meanings of texts, in their historical contexts, and junior academics who believe there are no basic meanings, only a multiplicity of interpretations. 
 Such divisions are not, so to speak, purely academic. 
 They lead to confusion on the part of students, and it may be too glib to say, as one sometimes hears, that such confusion and disorientation are an inherently desirable part of the educational process. 
 It does not always work like that, for they can lead to real difficulties in study, and sometimes to pastoral problems. 
 III  
 One of Lodge's earlier novels, Changing Places , hilariously exploits a series of typological oppositions. 
 The fundamental one is between a famous university on the American West Coast, Plotinus, and a more modest but still self-respecting one in the English Midlands, Rummidge. 
 These places are not, as the phrase goes, a million miles away from Berkeley  and Birmingham respectively (each of whose campuses is dominated, as it happens, by a tower copied from the Palazzo Publico at Sienna; in the novel these are transformed to upright versions of the Leaning Tower of Pisa). 
 The two central characters are both academic teachers of English: Morris Zapp is one of the biggest guns in the Plotinus faculty, who elects to take a visiting professorship at Rummidge in order to escape from his marital problems; his place is taken by Phillip Swallow, a na&iuml;ve, amiable, unambitious Rummidge lecturer. 
 As the novel moves, with much formal inventiveness, back and forth between Plotinus and Rummidge, we observe Zapp and Swallow coping with different forms of local culture shock. 
 They go on to exchange roles as well as jobs, and finally, for a time, wives. 
 In sociological terms they are &bquo;ideal types&equo; and the differences between them have all kinds of thematic and representative significance. 
 They enact a polarity between American and British academic life in general, and English studies in particular. 
 Zapp is the supreme professional, who embodies, albeit comically, those ideals of professionalism that have long been dominant in the North American academy and are becoming so in the British. 
 His aim is simple: to write a series of commentaries on the novels of Jane Austen which would say everything that could be said about them, from every conceivable angle: 
 historical, biographical, rhetorical, mythical, Freudian, jungian, existentialist, Marxist, structuralist, Christian-allegorical, ethical, exponential, linguistic, phenomenological, archetypal, you name it; so that when each commentary was written there would be simply nothing further to say  about the novel in question. 
 The object of the exercise&hellip; was not to enhance others' enjoyment and understanding of Jane Austen, still less to honour t e novelist herself, but to put a definitive stop to the production of any further garbage on the subject. 
 The commentaries would not be designed for the general reader but for the specialist, who, looking up Zapp, would find that the book, article or thesis he had been planning had already been anticipated and, more likely than not, invalidated. 
 After Zapp, the rest would be silence. 
 Zapp is impatient of other academics with tentative minds, who begin articles, &bquo;I want to raise some questions about soand-so.&equo; 
 &bquo;Any damn fool&hellip; could think of questions; it was answers  that separated the men from the boys.&equo; 
 He regards the  Splendours and Miseries of the Academy  1 59 study of literature as quite separate from life, with evaluation and affective responses rigorously excluded: 
 The failure to keep the categories of life and literature distinct led to all kinds of heresy and nonsense: to &bquo;liking&equo; and &bquo;not liking&equo; books for instance, preferring some authors to others and such-like whimsicalities which, he had constantly to remind his students, were of no conceivable interest to anyone except themselves (sometimes he shocked them by declaring that, speaking personally on this low, subjective level, he found jane Austen a pain in the ass). 
 Changing Places , published in 1975, is set in 1969; when Zapp reappears in a later novel, Small World , set ten years later, he has changed his attitudes, in accordance with major shifts in the Zeitgeist . 
 He is now a poststructuralist and has abandoned the great Jane Austen project, as he disbelieves in the possibility of any kind of definite textual meaning or interpretation: &bquo;every decoding is another encoding.&equo; 
 Zapp is simply keeping up with the state of the art; he is more convinced than ever that professionalism is its own justification and reward. 
 When an anguished Phillip Swallow asks him what, in Zapp's scheme of things, is the point of engaging in literary study, he serenely replies, &bquo;The point, of course, is to uphold the institution of academic literary studies. 
 We maintain our position in society by publicly performing a certain ritual, just like any other group of workers in the realm of discourse &mdash; lawyers, politicians, journalists.&equo; 
 In Changing Places  the Englishman Swallow is Zapp's opposite in all possible respects. 
 If Zapp believes that writing about literature has nothing to do with liking it, Swallow likes it all too much to be able to write about it: 
 This undiscriminating enthusiasm&hellip; prevented him from settling on a &bquo;field&equo; to cultivate as his own. 
 He had done his initial research on jane Austen, but since then had turned his attention to topics as varied as medieval sermons, Elizabethan sonnet sequences, Restoration heroic tragedy, eighteenth-century broadsides, the novels of William Godwin, the poetry of Elizabeth Barrett Browning and premonitions of the Theatre of the Absurd in the plays of George Bernard Shaw. 
 None of these projects had been completed. 
 Seldom, indeed, had he drawn up a preliminary bibliography before his attention was distracted by some new or revived interest in something entirely different. 
 He ran hither and thither between the shelves of Eng. 
 Lit. like a child in a toyshop &mdash; so reluctant to choose one item to the exclusion of others that he ended up empty-handed. 
 Swallow's predicament is a very familiar one in British academics of his generation, as is his non-possession of a Ph.D., that basic certificate of academic professionalism in American eyes (and now in English ones). 
 This is remarked on in an exchange between Zapp and Luke Hogan, chairman of the Plotinus English Department, before Swallow arrives: 
 &bquo;any clown with a Ph.D. 
 should be able to teach English 99.&equo; 
 &bquo;He doesn't have a Ph.D.,&equo; Hogan said. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;They have a different system in England, Morris. 
 The Ph.D. 
 isn't so important.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mean the jobs are hereditary?&equo; 
 The Americans are professionals and Swallow is an amateur, which, we recall, has the primary sense of &bquo;lover&equo;. 
 Yet there is one sense in which Swallow has thoroughly assimilated the professionalism of the academy. 
 Though he has difficulty in writing anything for publication, he is a scrupulous and painstaking examiner, and his own examination papers are carefully pondered, finely drafted works of art. 
 He even dreams of publishing a concise, comprehensive survey of English Literature in the form of examination questions: &bquo; Collected Literary Questions , by Philip Swallow. 
 A book to be compared to Pascal's Pens&eacute;es  or Wittgenstein's Philosophical Investigations &hellip;&equo;. 
 Older academics, of whatever persuasion, were hostile to the idea of overt professionalism in literary study. 
 Their position was not altogether consistent, since they were committed to professional standards of achievement within the discipline, and, as they were paid to engage in it, were themselves professionals. 
 Yet, without doubt, they would have been horrified by Morris Zapp and what he stood for. 
 In Britain university English was developed with undergraduate teaching primarily in mind, in a culture that included the sixth forms of schools. 
 Until recently, graduate teaching was a very marginal activity. 
 In the United States the graduate school is the major arena of pedagogic activity and intellectual life. 
 It is here that research papers are generated and read and discussed, and where the academic superstars go through their paces and inspire their dedicated students. 
 As early as 1921, the Newbolt Report, summarizing the evidence of  Professor Ernest de S&eacute;lincourt, expressed deep unease about the American approach to literary research: 
 Many of the elaborate theses on English Literature produced by American students for their Doctorate, and afterwards published, were monuments of misdirected effort; in short, a true sense of literature as a living thing was lost, and in its place was substituted an investigation after the worse pattern of German &bquo;research&equo;, deadening alike to those who wrote and those who read it. 
 The anti-Germanism reflects the Report's composition in the aftermath of the First World War; at the same time, this passage looks far ahead, already foreshadowing the opposition between Zapp and Swallow as representative figures. 
 In 1963, Leavis published an essay called &bquo;Research in English&equo;, attacking what he called &bquo;a menacing academicism against which we have to be militantly upon our guard &mdash; a form of academicism institutionally established in America, and one the tendency towards which in this country &mdash; the developments of civilization favouring it &mdash; is much strengthened by American influence&hellip; 
 &bquo;. One particularly undesirable consequence of this tendency was the &bquo;proliferation of the blankly or brutally crass kinds of doctoral manufacture&equo;. 
 Leavis was suspicious of the PhD, though he acknowledged that good work could, in the right circumstances, be produced in that medium, such as his wife's Fiction and the Reading Public . 
 He is insistent that the only students who should work at doctoral level are those of first-class ability, who are independent of mind and inner-directed, so that they can work without much supervision, apart from &bquo;a standing relation with a congenial senior to whom he can go now and then for criticism and advice.&equo; 
 Leavis accepts that this admirable but stern ideal was already under threat: 
 the university has a new duty, we are told: there is a besieging host, everincreasing, of Indians, Africans, Commonwealth people in general, Levantines, who aspire to become university teachers of English literature, and must therefore have a PhD &mdash; preferably a Cambridge one (though it is admitted that a large proportion of them couldn't hope to take the English Tripos with much credit &mdash; even if they could pass). 
 As a university teacher of English, one reads this abrasive passage, twenty-five years on, with a painful sense of recognition. 
 There can be no doubt that the PhD, no longer seen as  a sign of unusually high scholarly achievement, has become simply a certificate of professional competence, and that intellectual standards have declined accordingly. 
 The decline has been inconspicuous rather than dramatic, and is patchy; the existence in British academic life of external examiners is something of a safeguard (they are unknown in American universities, where quality control is even less secure). 
 Even so, potential examiners are known qualities: some are likely to be severe, some lenient, and the experienced and canny supervisor or head of department is likely to make nominations accordingly. 
 Nevertheless, weak candidates still get failed, which is always a bitter and embarrassing business, negating the value of several years' work, often leading to anger within a department, internal enquiries about the quality of supervision, and even threats of legal action from the disappointed candidate. 
 I have declined to act as external examiner to candidates whose subject or thesis title seemed to be so dubious that a successful treatment of it could only be done by a candidate of exceptional brilliance; in such cases it is likely that the candidate has had inadequate or misguided supervision. 
 In a busy life, it is easier to avoid embarrassment than to have to extricate oneself from it. 
 Much difficulty could be avoided if the only candidates permitted to work for a PhD were those who were virtually certain to obtain it, but that is not a feasible option in the modern university. 
 Similar considerations make me sometimes decline to examine students from foreign parts. 
 This is not because of xenophobia, still less &bquo;racism&equo;; prudence is the principal consideration. 
 Leavis's tirade against such students was an insensitive treatment of what was already a sensitive topic, and is now far more so. 
 In the 1980s, following on government cuts in finance, British universities have been engaged in a desperate scramble for overseas students and the more-or-less economic fees they are required to pay. 
 It is an undignified business, but survival demands it. 
 Higher degrees in English are an obvious target for foreign students who have been trained in the subject in their own country, and who wish to obtain a doctoral qualification in an anglophone university before themselves becoming teachers. 
 The university welcomes them as a source of income; some students are funded  by their own governments to obtain a doctorate and enter public service. 
 There is, in one way, an admirable balance of supply and demand, and some applicants are good by any standards. 
 Nevertheless, this situation presents hard decisions to those responsible for graduate admissions. 
 Should one turn away weaker candidates, and so lose the university income, or admit them, with the possibility of academic, cultural, and pastoral problems ensuing for several years? 
 Furthermore, there can be no absolute certainty that a candidate's thesis will pass in the end, however carefully the examiners are selected. 
 In such cases failure is even more painful than with a home student, and one has heard rumours of failed candidates having to return several years of fees to their government, and suffering even worse penalties. 
 The problems are not universal, one must emphasize. 
 Some students, particularly those from the Indian subcontinent who have been selected for Commonwealth Scholarships, are capable of performing very well at higher degree level, and then returning to an academic career in their own countries. 
 When overseas students do present difficulties &mdash; and I am sure many academics will be familiar with distressing or scandalous cases &mdash; it is not because they are lacking in industry or intellectual ability. 
 Many of them would do perfectly well in disciplines which are less idiosyncratic than English and have a more obvious international currency, like linguistics or economics or marketing. 
 But in this respect, at least, English in the English academy, as Leavis liked to emphasize, is not just another subject. 
 It expresses a mystique, is to a high degree culture-specific, can seem elusive, and is not easily reduced to the rules and agreed procedures of other disciplines. 
 It is not just overseas graduate students who have problems. 
 We must all have known home undergraduates who have worked very hard on an English course, who may be ambitious to do well, and who still, to their intense disappointment, end up doing badly. 
 This is not a matter of poor teaching, for such students can be the despair of conscientious teachers. 
 What is involved is an inability to penetrate the culture of the subject and to achieve the appropriate blend of knowledge, analysis, and affective response that is needed to  perform well in an English course. 
 Their minds are somehow not right for it; in some other discipline they might have performed quite respectably. 
 Protests about professionalization also came in the 1960s from the prominenti  of Oxford English. 
 C. S. Lewis wrote: 
 What is&hellip; surprising and disquieting is the fact that those who might be expected ex officio  have a profound and permanent appreciation of literature may in reality have nothing of the sort. 
 They are mere professionals. 
 Perhaps they once had the full response, but the &bquo;hammer, hammer on the hard, high road&equo; has long since dinned it out of them. 
 I am thinking of unfortunate scholars in foreign universities who cannot &bquo;hold down their jobs&equo; unless they repeatedly publish articles each of which must say, or seem to say, something new about some literary work&hellip; 
 By foreign universities Lewis presumably meant American ones. 
 A few years later, Helen Gardner, in her inaugural lecture, lamented the &bquo;pressure to publish&equo; on people working in English studies: &bquo;there is something peculiarly distasteful and peculiarly absurd about forced labour in my field. 
 A real deformation of values is suggested by the common use of such terms as &bquo;productive scholars'&equo; and &bquo;&bquo;scholarly output'&equo;.' 
 Gardner suggested that there was nothing wrong with apparent idleness, since it could often in the long run prove to be &bquo;the true seed-plot of thought&equo;. 
 Twenty years on, the phrases which she saw as indicating a deformation of values have become commonplace in the Thatcherite academy, where contemplation is regarded as idleness, rather than the other way round, and Leavis's abominated &bquo;technologico-Benthamism&equo; is firmly in the saddle. 
 Despite the contempt expressed in the past for the American principle of &bquo;publish or perish&equo;, British universities are more and more looking at volume of publication &mdash; otherwise, &bquo;performance indicators&equo; &mdash; as a sign of virtue. 
 Quantity is easier to consider than quality, of course, and I have found that a promotions committee can be thrown into bemusement and mild disarray by suggesting that many of the publications on a candidate's CV might better have not been published. 
 To express such thoughts is to feel oneself uncomfortably situated between opposed concepts of what a university is. 
 Leavis, Lewis, and Gardner shared traditional values, even though Cambridge and Oxford spoke with different accents. 
  Common to the passages quoted above is the assumption that it is possible to denounce &bquo;academicism&equo; or &bquo;professionalism&equo; whilst being a member of the academic profession. 
 That spirit persists, particularly in Oxford; witness John Bayley: &bquo;Most of the theories Eagleton expounds may soon seem outlandish curiosities, cooked up by teachers of literature who need to feel professional, in the sense that philosophers or scientists do, or powerful, like politicians.&equo; 
 As I have remarked, the Warton Professor habitually adopts the attitude of a traditional man of letters rather than a paid academic. 
 It takes enviable sprezzatura  and self-confidence to perform as a teacher of literature who does not  need to feel professional. 
 There is, of course, nothing to prevent an academic from criticizing professionalism, which is indeed what I am doing now. 
 But I am conscious of a sense of contradiction that clearly did not afflict those illustrious figures. 
 When literary criticism moved into the academy, it received obvious privileges and status. 
 Critics and scholars had access to libraries, and the paid leisure to think, read, and write during university vacations, and, sometimes, sabbatical leave. 
 There was the intellectual stimulus to be gained from discussion with colleagues, and the challenge of teaching lively young minds. 
 And for some there were conferences and congresses in glamorous places, the glittering prizes satirically displayed in Lodge's Small World . 
 None of this was available to the hard-pressed scholarly hacks in Gissing's new Grub Street , or to the real-life Francis Thompson, keeping himself just alive by high-quality literary journalism, which involved working for twelve hours every day and taking no holidays. 
 But, in the words of the old Spanish proverb, &bquo;Take what you want, said God, and pay.&equo; 
 There was a high price to be paid for these amenities and privileges, which was, quite simply, professionalism. 
 This was not the relaxed professionalism of the man of letters, but the stringent new professionalism of the academy. 
 For a time teachers of literature could assume that they were in but not of the academy, and keep a healthy distance from institutional pressures. 
 But universities have changed immensely in recent decades, and because of their close, complex and sometimes difficult relations with the public world, their procedures have become standardized and  uniform, reflecting concern about justification and accountability. 
 In this situation, the teaching of English Literature has not, on the face of it, done badly. 
 It is a large subject, much in demand, and is very cheap to teach. 
 Within the modern academy, English is treated with respect, though those teaching it may feel themselves impaled on the perennial dilemma of making it appear either a soft option or inhumanely technical and jargon-ridden. 
 The Newbolt &mdash; Leavis claim that English was not just one more academic subject does not survive well in this climate. 
 English is  treated as one subject among many, albeit an important one, and has to assume institutional responsibilities as well as accepting privileges. 
 The task of the academic is to teach and engage in research, and, if required, to take on administrative duties. 
 Although there is parity of esteem among academic subjects, and dog is careful not to eat dog, at least in public, a scientific model of knowledge has, I believe, come to dominate the modern academy, and to affect attitudes to and within humanistic learning. 
 Such knowledge is progressive, rendering earlier versions of itself obsolete, and it circulates quickly and visibly through the accepted professional channels, like journals and conference-papers. 
 It is also subject to quantifiable assessment, in terms of volume of publication, frequency of citation, amounts of research funding, and the calibre of referees. 
 In English Studies this is the world of Morris Zapp, not of Phillip Swallow. 
 It has long been established in American universities; hence the acute consciousness of period, and the rapidity with which, in the state-of-the-art graduate schools and research establishments, critical approaches have followed one another: New Critical, structuralist, poststructuralist, deconstructionist, feminist, Marxist, New Historicist, dialogic. 
 It is not that academic critics make a conscious effort to imitate their colleagues in the sciences, it is that they have come to adopt their concept of knowledge, and its professional servicing and supportive structures. 
 The path that the young academic must follow who wants tenure, and still more advancement and fame, is clearly marked. 
 Morris Zapp had published four books before he was thirty. 
 &bquo;Research&equo; in English has never been easy to define. 
 There are still many able academics who see their activity as  research in the traditional sense, by engaging in biographical, historical, or editorial work. 
 But where English departments are concerned &bquo;research&equo; is more usually understood in the broader sense of adding conceptual rather than factual knowledge, which in practice means the proliferation of interpretation. 
 The brighter sort of aspiring academic is more commonly found marking up paperback copies of standard texts in different coloured inks than delving in libraries. 
 Indeed, Terence Hawkes has defined and defended what he calls &bquo;paperback research&equo; as a proper activity for those who lack the scholarly resources of the ancient universities. 
 The advent of poststructuralism has given a great impetus to interpretive productivity, since all the literary texts that were once interpreted to show organic unity and complexity of meaning can now be interpreted to reveal underlying clashes. 
 Research in this sense and teaching can be in conflict, for the reasons suggested by Hirsch. 
 In an article reviewing Culler's On Deconstruction , Hirsch flatly rejects the idea that knowledge in English is continually developing. 
 He observes, 
 &bquo;English&equo; in American schools and universities has always been a cultural, not a progressive, intellectual subject. 
 Although &bquo;English&equo; does have connections with the genuine disciplines of history and philosophy it came into being for cultural rather than disciplinary reasons. 
 English, for Hirsch, is basically to do with educational and cultural values, helping &bquo;to provide the myths and values we live by&equo;, rather than generating ever new and more narrowly directed interpretations. 
 Hirsch is here defiantly looking back to something like the spirit which, in England, inspired the Newbolt Report and Scrutiny  in its heyday, and which no doubt still evokes a sympathetic response in teachers on both sides of the Atlantic. 
 But it is hard to see it making much headway against the ideology that now pervades academic institutions. 
 The fundamental model is the physical sciences, but in the current transactions and debates in and around English, social studies offers a closer and more approachable example. 
 Michael Edwards refers to 
 the assumption that only enquiry into literature that is founded on the state of the art in sociology or other adjacent disciplines is valid, the rest being impressionist and subjective. 
 I once asked a colleague in linguistics if this  meant that the criticism of, oh, Addison, Keats, Hopkins, Forster, was valueless. 
 I thought of the question as rhetorical, but his reply was &bquo;Yes&equo;. 
 The assumption that the cultural achievements of the past are actually obsolete is more likely to be implied than so explicitly stated, but it is a logical implication of a progressivist concept of knowledge. 
 Less radically, intellectual fashion means that some names are in, and others out. 
 Marjorie Perloff has remarked that young American academics and students have a shared culture based on having read or studied the same books: &bquo;they have, by and large, taken courses that expose them to writers like Freud, Nietzsche, and Marx, whereas the odds are that they have not taken a course in, say, the lyric poetry of Goethe, the fiction of Stendhal, or the theatre of Moli&egrave;re.&equo; 
 In America fashion can actually be enforced. 
 A few years ago, as part of an annual round-up of critical books for Encounter , I reviewed an interestingly speculative work on modern fiction by an American academic. 
 My feelings about the book were positive rather than the reverse, but I complained in my review that it was studded with references to fashionable French gurus that were purely cosmetic, adding nothing to the author's argument. 
 A year or so later I chanced to meet him and he acknowledged that this was just criticism, but that he had been obliged to insert these names so that his book would look like a truly up-to-date, intouch work of scholarship. 
 In 1982 at Stanford I heard similar accounts of academic publishers requiring appropriate names and references in books. 
 Despite the protective embrace of professionalism and the general mutuality of respect and acceptance that pertains between disciplines, the academic teacher of literature is in a peculiar position in relation to his colleagues elsewhere, in ways that have been remarked on by John Bayley and Raymond Williams, and no doubt by others; in certain respects English does remain an essentially different subject. 
 We see history produced in history departments, philosophy in philosophy departments, sociology in sociology departments, and so on, by academics for whom teaching and research are two aspects of a unified activity. 
 This is not true of literature departments; what they produce is criticism and  scholarship, not literature, leaving out of account the occasional scholar-poet or writer in residence. 
 This situation has left literature teachers with the sense that compared with their colleagues they are not masters in their own house, since they are dependent for their material on a product manufactured elsewhere by shifty and unreliable suppliers. 
 The attempt to remedy this deficiency and achieve a true professionalism may be one reason for the rapid growth of literary theory in the anglophone academy. 
 If the academy cannot itself produce literature, and if even criticism can be written outside of it by novelists, poets, and literary journalists, then what it, and only it, can  produce is theory. 
 Here is the authentic product of the English department, parallel to the history and philosophy which are generated down the corridor. 
 It is an error to assume, as I did myself at one time, that theory necessarily exists in an ancillary and elucidatory relationship to criticism, which is in turn at the service of literature. 
 That is a common-sense way of looking at it, but in practice literary and critical theory has become an autonomous subject. 
 Poststructuralists aspire to remove what they regard as the arbitrary distinctions between literature, criticism, theory, and philosophy, and Geoffrey Hartman has made it clear that he believes what he writes to be worthy of the esteem and attention normally given to &bquo;creative&equo; writing. 
 So, looked at in some lights, theory becomes literature. 
 This was the contention of Elizabeth Bruss's perverse but deeply interesting book, Beautiful Theories . 
 She writes: 
 And if the reading public as a whole is shrinking, if literature is increasingly relegated to the schools as something &bquo;to be studied&equo; &mdash; if, in a word, the majority of readers now are scholars (whether students or professional academics) &mdash; then the claims of literary theory to be our representative literary genre become stronger still. 
 What better inspiration could a literature of theory have than an audience composed of theorists and critics? 
 This is not, I think, meant to be ironical, and it represents a quite logical development from the premiss that the whole production, definition, and reception of literature has now become intramural to the academy. 
 In this context, what goes on outside, what is actually written by poets and novelists, is of minor interest. 
 Paul de Man is reported to have said that a  literary work is merely an event in the history of interpretation. 
 A natural response to this state of affairs would be to say that theory cut off from the writing of literature is no more than a sterile academicism. 
 But that misses the point, if theory can be identified with literature. 
 These are the symptoms of a triumphant professionalism, which is sustained by the particular conditions of American academic life: the intensely competitive environment of the prestigious graduate schools, the free market in salaries which entices the superstars of the profession from one campus to another, the large funds available for research, journals, and conferences. 
 Admittedly, conditions in the American academy are a little tighter than they once were, but what looks like stringency by American standards is still lavishness by British ones. 
 Britain can never hope to compete with all this. 
 Nevertheless, professionalism on American lines is still the ideal that academic administrators uphold, since it can indicate to sceptical politicians and the public at large that universities are engaged in the visible activity which generates &bquo;performance-indicators&equo;. 
 In this climate, the academic in English and other subjects in the humanities, who is busy, who publishes a lot, who goes to conferences, cannot but be preferred to the quiet scholar, who keeps a low profile, even seems rather idle, but is taking his time over a major piece of scholarly writing that may involve many years' work and which he does not intend to give to the world until he is ready. 
 Such people have in the past been left to go their own way without interference. 
 Nowadays they may be esteemed by their peers who know something of their work, but this esteem has little currency value in the committee-rooms where performance is appraised. 
 These academics may be respected, but they are also regarded as tiresome. 
 The culture of science looks for rapid and visible results, and it is this, despite occasional formal disavowals, that is setting the agenda. 
 Wittgenstein, widely thought of as the greatest philosopher of the twentieth century, published very little in his lifetime, and is unlikely to have got tenure in a modern British university. 
 To see these activities as representing the apotheosis of Morris Zapp and the eclipse of Phillip Swallow is tempting but too simple. 
 British versions of Zapp are probably now in  America anyway, finding a proper market-based reward for their talents and energy. 
 American professionalism may be the ideal, but differences between the British and American academic systems are noticeable. 
 The greater spread of American higher education means that, proportionate to population, there are far more universities, all with English departments; if they were as proportionately numerous in Britain, we would have about 1,000 universities. 
 Hence the wide and generally understood variations in academic calibre between American universities. 
 Furthermore, the greater commitment to undergraduate teaching gives English studies in Britain a different character. 
 And, least definably, there is the cultural nationalism, the concept of &bquo;Englishness&equo; that, from the beginning, has been a major element in the subject. 
 It produces a mystique which obstructs total professionalism and separates British from American attitudes. 
 Yet despite these differences, English English has gone quite a long way down the road of a more-or-less Americanized professionalism, as identified and rejected in the 1960s by Leavis, Lewis, and Gardner. 
 From the point of view of those who are currently in charge of higher education, English must be an awkward subject. 
 It is popular, in demand, and cheap. 
 Yet its quasi-mystical elements prevent it from fully using its potential. 
 It is the heir of a nineteenth-century ideology that, though supposedly liberal and contemplative, is also &eacute;litist, anti-vocational, antimarket, and indeed downright hostile to the idea that higher education should prepare young people to take their places in a wealth-producing economy. 
 An excessively elevated sense of standards means that there are difficulties about English Departments taking on overseas research students in numbers sufficient to help the university in its financial difficulties. 
 Academics in English are loners reluctant to engage in team projects or pull together in research centres. 
 They can be irritatingly slow to publish, and it is often difficult to know how they spend their time. 
 On the brighter side, there are those younger and more active lecturers who do their duty and generate performance-indicators in the form of books and articles. 
 It is true that in some cases these publications may be of extreme radical tendency, attacking the established  practices of academic English teaching, but that is no objection, since it is the fact of publication that counts, not its content. 
 The real problem is that the writers of such texts may make political difficulties within a department, or teach in ways difficult for students to understand. 
 Again, English departments can be unhelpful about participating in schemes for training academics how to teach, claiming that teaching literature is less easily defined and methodologized than teaching engineering or economics. 
 At a time when a good public image is essential for universities, English is unable to explain itself in ways immediately intelligible to the outsider, is notoriously riven with doubts and disagreements that prevent it from having a shared sense of purpose, and may at intervals erupt into crises that attract the wrong sort of publicity. 
 It is time, it is thought, for English to organize itself in ways that make it more like a proper academic discipline, with clear procedures and goals. 
 The adjacent social sciences provide the model for a genuine professionalism and accountability. 
 As long ago as 1969 a small committee asked to report, from outside the Faculty, on the perennially troubled state of Cambridge English concluded, 
 we believe that undergraduates in English would benefit from more &bquo;systematic&equo; and less &bquo;inspirational&equo; instruction and that this systematic instruction and its associated reading lists should be agreed by the teachers concerned and closely related to the needs of the Tripos course. 
 I have never heard this case made in anything like the explicit fashion in which I have just outlined it, and I do not think it ever would be publicly made. 
 Yet one picks it up, in hints and implications, in the not-quite-concealed exasperation of polite administrators, in the raised eyebrows and brief knowing smiles of senior academics on committees; indeed, it is as much a matter of what is significantly not said, as of what is said; in poststructuralist terms, of lacunae, vides , silences. 
 The people who teach in English Departments are certainly aware of a lurking, inchoate threat to their peace of mind, and there is no successor to Leavis as a force to strengthen morale and defy institutional pressures. 
 Traditional English teaching is also under attack from the rainbow coalition of the left. 
 There are curious parallels and  similarities between bureaucratic calls for gleichschaltung  and radical subversions of bourgeois humanism. 
 Both have the effect of weakening still further the synthesis of approaches that have characterized academic English since its inception. 
 We can again turn to Morris Zapp as the embodiment of a thorough-going professionalism. 
 (It may be objected that I am taking far too earnest a view of a wonderfully comic fictional character. 
 But Lodge's sociological understanding is considerable, and Zapp serves very well as an &bquo;ideal type&equo; of a present-day academic. 
 Dempsey in Changing Places  and Small World  is an approximate British equivalent.) 
 Zapp wants the subject to be organized, systematic, objective, in a word &mdash; though it is not a word he uses &mdash; scientific. 
 There is to be no nonsense about value, preferring some books or authors to others, or personal responses, which have a merely anecdotal or autobiographical interest. 
 Working on Jane Austen was not all that different from working on trade cycles, or lowtemperature physics; these were the kind of things that went on in the modern university. 
 Admittedly, in his later appearances Zapp has gone poststructuralist, and abandoned system and objectivity; but his commitment to professionalism is greater than ever. 
 Traditionally, the notion of personal response and what the Newbolt Report called &bquo;literature as a living thing&equo; were regarded by all schools as at the heart of English study, but there is no place for them in Zapp's perspective. 
 They would be signs of an unprofessional subjectivism and impressionism; in recent radical discourse they indicate an undesirable mystification. 
 Alan Sinfield, in a revealing Marxist analysis of the way Shakespeare is treated in public examination papers, remarks that they &bquo;construct Shakespeare and the candidate in terms of individual subjectivity through their stress upon Shakespeare's free-standing genius, their emphasis on characterization and their demand for the candidate's personal response.&equo; 
 Elsewhere, Sinfield makes the cogent point that the idea of a personal judgement that nevertheless has to approximate to an accepted opinion involves the candidate in learning tricks. 
 This is true, and points to one of the central problems in institutionalized literary pedagogy. 
 Nevertheless, it is not clear from current Marxist criticism and theory, which in the  rainbow coalition is often buttressed by Lacanian ideas of the decentred self, whether it is prepared to accept any  form at all of a personal, subjective or affective response, or whether all that must wait until after the revolution. 
 In the latter case, it will meanwhile have the effect of turning literary study into something much closer to the sociology that Marxists have colonized in the modern academy. 
 I argued in an earlier section of this Chapter that questions of value have always had an uncertain place in institutional literary study, and Catherine Belsey explicitly seeks to banish them. 
 She argues for a study of reading that would work towards political ends and &bquo;replace the mysterious objectives of aesthetic satisfaction and moral enrichment.&equo; 
 In such a perspective, &bquo;literary value becomes irrelevant: political assassination is problematized in Pickering's play, Horestes  (1567) as well as in Hamlet .&equo; 
 Bureaucrat and radical have no time for each other, but they are both undermining traditional humanism. 
 IV  
 The so-called New Historicism provides a curious fusion of academicism and radicalism. 
 In 1986, J. Hillis Miller, than whom no one is better placed to judge, told the Modern Language Association of America that by the mid-1980s critical theory had shifted from invoking &bquo;language&equo; as a prime foundational term to a cluster of words which included &bquo;history&equo;, &bquo;politics&equo;, &bquo;society&equo;, and &bquo;culture&equo;. 
 &bquo;History&equo; has been given prominence by the New Historicists, while for some graduate students and younger academics &bquo;politics&equo; has come to seem, as the Goldsmiths Professor at Oxford lately remarked to me, a kind of vital protein, without which a literary work is fatally impoverished. 
 In Britain the other terms referred to by Miller, &bquo;society&equo; and &bquo;culture&equo;, have been familiar at least since the 1950s, which saw the early work of Hoggart and Williams and the cultural climate of the New Left, which in turn drew on Scrutiny  and the Victorian debates on the Condition of England. 
 At a superficial glance, the New Historicism can seem, especially to an Oxford graduate of my generation, rather like  old-style historical scholarship. 
 When Fredric Jameson exhorts the reader, &bquo;Always historicize!&equo; one recalls Helen Gardner's assertion, 'All art, including contemporary art, is historical.&equo; 
 But there are important differences. 
 The older scholarship treated history as the march of events, combining change and continuity, but without a mind or will of its own. 
 The contemporary historicism, fuelled by Marx and Foucault, presents history as a force in its own right, ceaselessly dramatizing clashes of class and power. 
 It has particularly focused on Renaissance literature and the struggles for dominance which are enacted in it, or are assumed to be. 
 The New Historicism refuses to treat the literary works of the past as transcendent entities, removed from social and historical contexts, and embodying supposedly timeless values. 
 Yet it contains a contradiction, since the class-struggle, or more generally the struggle against oppression, is thought of as always visibly at work in history in a clearly timeless way. 
 Freud, in Civilization and its Discontents , advanced the profoundly historicist suggestion that we should be cautious about interpreting the miseries of earlier times, since what now looks like unacceptable suffering may have felt less so in a different culture. 
 If one rejects Freud's suggestion &mdash; for instance, by quoting contemporary accounts from the victims &mdash; then one is inescapably positing a transhistorical human nature. 
 In practice the Marxist practitioners of the New Historicism tend to interpret Shakespeare plays in accordance with the political interests of the late twentieth century. 
 Thus, The Tempest  is about colonialism; not only The taming of the Shrew  but King Lear  and Measure for Measure  are a focus for feminist readings; while Henry V  encodes a contemporary Elizabethan colonialist endeavour, &bquo;the fantasy of a successful Irish campaign&equo;. 
 These readings are intermittently illuminating, if reductive, and basically they are doing what criticism has always done, which is to interpret the works of the past in the terms and concepts of the critic's own age. 
 It is precisely this capacity for renewed interpretation that makes literature of more  than simply historical interest. 
 Latterday Marxist interpreters of Shakespeare are doing much the same as the conservative proponents of the Elizabethan World Picture did thirty or forty years ago, though with a different  conceptual model. 
 The contemporary New Historicists, however, are unlike interpreters of the past, in that they are concerned with exclusively political readings, without any possibility of aesthetic or affective responses. 
 Shakespeare provides a particular problem for radical critics who ideologically object to eminence. 
 Sinfield observes that Shakespeare is made &bquo;to speak mainly for the right&hellip; as the great National Poet whose plays embody universal truths&hellip; 
 &bquo;. Yet Shakespeare has more than a merely national reputation, kept in being by those who manipulate ideological power. 
 He has, to a remarkable extent, a global reputation. 
 Despite the barrier of translation, his plays are known and enjoyed and regularly performed in many countries. 
 This is a phenomenon which I find impressive and mysterious. 
 It suggests that there are  universal human qualities, and that people can recognize them in Shakespeare's dramas, over the centuries and through many cultural mediations. 
 Sinfield, I imagine, would decline to accept this. 
 The problem about Shakespeare for critics of his mind-set is that to take him seriously at all is to accept an alien agenda. 
 A truly revolutionary approach to Shakespeare would be to dismiss him, on the lines of the Dadaist and Futurist campaigns against the venerated high art of the past. 
 But that might be going too far for academic professionals, however radical their stances. 
 The more feasible alternative is to dismember his plays between the history of his own day and the ideologies of ours. 
 Marxists invoke &bquo;History&equo; as a &bquo;transcendent signified&equo;, the ultimate in terms of which everything else is to be explained; but there are many histories, not one, and we choose those which suit us. 
 As Edward Pechter puts it, &bquo;History does not tell us what the text is, because we decide what history is, and then put history into the text, rather than the other way round.&equo; 
 Something similar is true of &bquo;politics&equo;, another transcendent signified and argument-stopper. 
 Since politics is traditionally one of the major defining activities of a rational humanity, the discussion of literature in political terms is not only possible but desirable, as the major critics of the past have shown. 
 But the word &bquo;politics&equo; itself needs to be deconstructed, since politics is to do with our ideals of what human life should be, about which there has never been agreement;  indeed, it is out of the disagreement that politics arises. 
 In point of fact, when radical theorists invoke &bquo;politics&equo; they mean Marxist politics, in the paradoxically timeless fashion I have just referred to. 
 An awkward truth though is that in the twentieth century some of the most committed political criticism has come from conservatives, like Eliot and the Southern Agrarians. 
 An erudite work by an Oxford New Historicist, David Norbrook's Poetry and Politics in the English Renaissance , illustrates the structuralist truism that in a binary grouping one of the two terms tends to assume dominance. 
 Norbrook's interest is clearly far more in politics than in poetry. 
 The most significant aspect of the New Historicism, political questions apart, is that it represents a move away from the contextless, intensive concentration on particular texts equally characteristic of the New Criticism, classical structuralism, and deconstruction. 
 This has major pedagogic implications, since students can no longer hope to make sense of poems or plays just by reading them carefully, but must spend time in libraries getting up on the historical context. 
 Or, if they do not, they have to take on trust the material that the New Historicist scholar-critic hands them. 
 This seems to me retrogressive, and in some respects a return to the kind of thing I heard in my younger days in Oxford: &bquo;One cannot  hope to understand A, unless one also knows about B, C, D, etc.&equo; 
 A literary text is, manifestly, the product of a particular historical situation, and may be interpreted in the light of its origins and initial reception, as has been done in the discussions of Romantic literature by Marilyn Butler and Jerome J. McGann, who can be called New Historicists minus the ideological charge. 
 Yet historical interpretation of literature fairly easily loses sight of literary interests; if it goes far enough, the interpreter may assume that the idea of poetry or drama as art can be abandoned, since what counts are cultural traces, of whatever kind, and the ideological impressions they appear to bear. 
 In which case &bquo;history&equo; becomes a force to be resisted by readers who like literature, and who may also like history, but have never thought they were one and the same thing.  
 V  
 No discussion of the institutionalizing of literary study in higher education would be complete without a mention of the academic publishing that exists in a close, indeed symbiotic relation with it. 
 &bquo;Publication&equo; is increasingly important, not just to secure advancement in an individual academic's career, but as a sign of an institution's status. 
 I think it true to say that at the present time it is not at all difficult for academics to appear in print. 
 I am not thinking primarily of the well-established learned journals, which have high editorial standards and a long queue of articles waiting to appear. 
 (In the pursuit of performance-indicators, publication in &bquo;refereed journals&equo; counts for much, though I am not sure if I have ever appeared in a refereed journal in my life.) 
 However, new academic journals are regularly launched, devoted to one or other of the many specialisms into which English is fragmenting, and in their earlier issues, at least, are likely to be looking for contributions. 
 It is, however, in the vastly expanded world of academic book publishing that the greatest opportunities lie. 
 I do not claim to understand the economics of this system, which depends on small print-runs and numbingly high prices, and the assumption that institutional libraries will &bquo;want&equo;, or need, to buy these books. 
 But it is evident that publishers, to stay in business, need to bring out a large number of titles every year. 
 This is true in other academic areas, of course, but English is one of the largest earners, since books in this area can be hopefully addressed to &bquo;general readers&equo;, in a ritual recognition that there is a world elsewhere, as well as to students (though I suspect they are mostly read by teachers). 
 University teachers of English are regular recipients of visitations from hopeful, fresh-faced publishers' editors trawling for new titles. 
 Even PhD students can be approached before they have finished their theses, though the publication of unrevised theses seems to me undesirable, common though it has become: a thesis is written, as a rule, for two examiners, whereas a book, however specialized, should have a rather wider readership in mind. 
 Certainly, any academic who wants to write a book on a canonical author, topic, or period, is likely to get a contract  without very much formality (particularly if it has to do with &bquo;women&equo; or &bquo;theory&equo;, or ideally both). 
 This is not the case, though, if the proposed subject is outside the catchment area of school and university examinations, as Terry Lovell discovered when she offered to write a book on Gissing for a leftwing series, which had asked for one on Jane Austen. 
 There is, I have found, some gentle entertainment to be had in discussion with publishers' representatives, observing the wide-eyed eagerness with which they greet potentially saleable ideas, and their clenched, wary, glazed-eyes response to proposals they feel negative about, or perhaps do not understand. 
 The discussion may be restricted to impeccably intellectual topics, but the play of market forces is going on all the time just below the surface. 
 In one sense, everyone benefits from the buoyancy of academic book publishing. 
 The academic gets the publication record that leads to tenure or advancement, and his or her name becomes known in the profession; the institution gains performance-indicators; and the publisher keeps a full and interesting list. 
 It is hard to speak against a situation that makes everyone happy, but one has to say it represents a form of intellectual inflation that is just as pernicious in its way as monetary inflation. 
 Far too many inferior or unnecessary academic books are published each year. 
 Some publishers maintain traditionally stringent standards, but others, in a competitive market, are relaxed about quality control. 
 It is far from unknown for an expert reader who provides an unfavourable report on a book in manuscript to find it nevertheless being published a year or so later. 
 The book from its invention has been a commodity, dependent on patronage or the market for its circulation, and this is a fact of history that there is little point in complaining about. 
 But in the present economic state of academic publishing the encounter between market forces and intellectual value tends to subordinate the latter to the former. 
 This situation is common in many academic areas, as I have discovered talking to colleagues, and it may be that this state of inflation and over-production is economically unavoidable, that many inferior books have to be published in order to let the good ones appear. 
 But what is unavoidable may still be  undesirable, and one might as well say so. 
 Where literary criticism is concerned, we are faced with the depressing reality that this is now just one more academic specialism, a large specialism, admittedly, produced by and consumed within the academy. 
 The price of books of academic criticism indicates that they are not aimed at the educated general reader (once they cost about the same as a bottle of whisky; now they cost three to four times as much). 
 So many books, to pick up a point once made by Malcolm Bradbury, are published primarily to be stored, moving smoothly from publishers' warehouse to library stacks without arousing much disturbance on the way, and are discussed, if at all, only in scholarly journals. 
 I have already remarked on the different situation thirty years ago, when criticism still occupied a traditional place as part of public discourse, and the first books of a distinguished generation of British critics &mdash; Bayley, Davie, Hoggart, Kermode, Wain, Williams &mdash; were reviewed in the daily and weekly press. 
 At the present time interpretation, often of a narrow and unrewarding kind, flourishes, usually though falsely claimed on publishers' blurbs to be saying something completely new and important. 
 Many interesting works of English Literature of the past remain unedited and unavailable, and it is a pity that the ingenuity and assiduity that goes into the labour, or play, of interpretation could not be directed to the truly useful work of editing these texts. 
 Meanwhile the publishers' catalogues arrive regularly, with their copious listings not just of new titles, but of new series, aimed to appeal to the collecting instinct. 
 I dutifully read through them with sinking feelings and, sometimes, a touch of nausea. 
 I do not seem to be alone in this response. 
 The writer of an admirable article on research in the humanities published in the TLS  in 1987 wrote, &bquo;I believe passionately in the value of those activities we call &bquo;the Humanities'&equo;, yet when I see a compilation like the British Library's Current Research in Britain (1986): The Humanities &hellip; 
 I feel sick.&equo; 
 CULTURAL STUDY, POETIC ART  
 I  
 Consensus is too much to expect in the present state of English Studies, but I detect a convergence of ideas among those whose starting-points and ideological assumptions are very different. 
 There is an emerging belief that the study of &bquo;literature as literature&equo; needs to be replaced by, or incorporated into, a form of cultural studies. 
 On the Left it was advanced by Raymond Williams; Dollimore and Sinfield, in their introduction to Political Shakespeare , argue for &bquo;cultural materialism&equo;, which brings together historical context, theoretical method, political commitment, and textual analysis in an effort to overturn established readings of Shakespeare. 
 In America, there are similar moves from Marxists, but also from those who are in cultural terms centrists or moderate conservatives. 
 As we have noted, literary study in the United States involves a large quantitative spread of the subject, intensive professionalism, and a virtual absence of the national mystique that characterizes English English. 
 There is a variety of approaches in graduate schools and change is more easily envisaged. 
 Robert Scholes writes in Textual Power : 
 interpretation is not a pure skill but a discipline deeply dependent on knowledge. 
 It is not as much a matter of generating meanings out of a text as it is a matter of making connections between a particular verbal text and a larger cultural text, which is the matrix or master code that the literary text both depends upon and modifies. 
 In order to teach the interpretation of a literary text, we must be prepared to teach the cultural text as well. 
 Such an approach is, of course, counter to the contextless concentration on the single text that characterized the New Criticism, and which served American literary education for many years. 
 Nevertheless, Scholes is right to say that &bquo;interpretation is not a pure skill but a discipline deeply dependent on knowledge&equo;; as much was conceded by Richards in Practical Criticism , a fundamental text of the New Criticism, when he acknowledged that those who had not already read  enough poetry would read poems badly. 
 Scholes makes useful and practical suggestions for helping students to read better in this situation. 
 Like the English Marxists, though for more pragmatic reasons, he wants to demystify literary study, and to substitute &bquo;textual study&equo; for it. 
 This would not abolish literature but would remove its exclusivity as a category; the task of the English Department is to be redefined as &bquo;studying texts&equo; rather than &bquo;teaching literature&equo;. 
 Gerald Graff, in Professing Literature , is sympathetic to Scholes's approach, quoting him to the effect that what we call skill in reading involves &bquo;a knowledge of the codes that were operative in the composition of any given text and the historical situation in which it was composed.&equo; 
 Graff also invokes the Bakhtinian concept of dialogue, where every utterance implies another utterance, which it answers, attacks, continues, or relates to in some way. 
 Such contextualizing tends to do away with the modernist and New Critical elevation of the Poem in Itself, the verbal icon, the well-wrought urn, the jar upon a hill in Tennessee. 
 In a return to the Latin origin of the word, &bquo;textuality&equo; weaves everything together. 
 When Scholes proposes &bquo;studying texts&equo; he invokes the terminology of semiotics, but he is, in effect, working in a tradition of rhetorical analysis that has always been an element in institutional English study, and which in the 1930s resulted in the work of Leavis and Thompson and other Scrutineers on contemporary culture and its artefacts. 
 Scholes's proposal to teach the &bquo;cultural text&equo; as well as the &bquo;literary text&equo; makes good sense; but, for the best of motives, he tends to a brisk simplification in his approach. 
 In truth, there is not one cultural text, but a multiplicity of them, both concentric and overlapping. 
 As Henry James so memorably put it in his great essay, &bquo;The Art of Fiction&equo;, &bquo;Experience is never limited, and it is never complete&hellip; 
 &bquo;. If we assume &mdash; and it is probably the right assumption &mdash; that students can no longer easily read isolated literary texts, but need to make sense of them in a variety of contexts, much power is given to the teacher who decides which are the relevant cultural codes to be invoked and expounded; Marxists, at least, are specific on the matter. 
 Graff acknowledges the problem and proposes an openly dialectical and adversarial form of teaching. 
 Literary theory, he says, should not just be one more academic  subject, to be taught by a &bquo;theory-specialist&equo;, but should inform the way in which an English Department organizes itself. 
 It should acknowledge that there are conflicts between critical approaches, and should make the students' confrontation of them part of the pedagogic process. 
 As an example, Graff raises the relation of a feminist literary canon to more familiar ones. 
 Such a canon has been attacked for proposing &bquo;political&equo; rather than &bquo;literary&equo; values as its foundation. 
 Graff suggests that students should be familiarized with the conflict by being asked to compare The Norton Anthology of Literature by Women  with a traditional anthology and come to their own conclusions. 
 He makes the reasonable point that the upholders of traditional positions might achieve a new plausibility if they could be seen actually arguing for them, rather than merely asserting them. 
 I like Graff's proposals, but they seem to me utopian. 
 They might work in the graduate school of a good American university, where a variety of methods already abounds. 
 I cannot see how they could be established in British literary education, where there are no graduate schools as such, and the narrow, uphill tunnel of A-level work leads on to the rocky, cloudy uplands of the undergraduate degree, with its confused mixture of practical criticism and thematic study, analysis and literary history, coverage and special subjects. 
 Undergraduates of moderate ability do not much like being asked to choose between differing judgements on the same text; I can imagine them becoming confused and resentful if they were asked to choose between different critical approaches and all their attendant ideological baggage. 
 Certainly, I have known some undergraduates who would rise brilliantly to such a challenge; but they are an exception, and one cannot base a course on what would suit the exceptional student, much as one would like to. 
 Indeed, &bquo;mixed ability teaching&equo; is a major if not often acknowledged problem in higher education, particularly in English, where the extent of prior knowledge is so variable. 
 Graff's proposals for a structured pluralism are admirable in theory, but in practice they would, I fear, merely increase the demoralization of students and teachers. 
 E. D. Hirsch, in his recent book, Cultural Literacy , has  moved far beyond the problems of literary study to provide an agenda for American society itself. 
 He raises large issues: how much does one need to know to understand and engage in the dialogues within society, and between past and present, on the simplest level of knowing what is being talked about? 
 Even casual acquaintance is better than total ignorance, and &bquo;it's acceptable to take one's entire knowledge of Romeo and Juliet  from Cliff Notes . 
 That is because cultural literacy is a canon of information not texts.&equo; 
 Hirsch is trailing his coat, but he is concerned with what takes place in society at large, not in college courses. 
 Yet within the context of organized literary study, it is true that much of the difficulty students have in making sense of texts comes from a lack of information, or to use the older term, a deficiency in general knowledge. 
 As a scholar and theorist, Hirsch is known, apart from his unfashionable but vigorously argued advocacy of intentionalism, for his conviction that literature is not a coherent concept, and has no definable essence, and that by extension &bquo;English&equo; as a discipline has no absolute method. 
 He believes that literary study has a cultural and humane rather than an intellectual value; and the implication of his recent work is that there are other ways of attaining cultural value. 
 This has some affinity with the Marxist position. 
 In a published argument between Scholes and Hirsch, the former made the following statement, on the assumption that the conservative Hirsch would disagree with it: 
 At the heart my belief&hellip; is the conviction that no text  is so trivial as to be outside the bounds of humanistic study. 
 The meanest graffito, if fully understood, can be a treasure of human expressiveness&hellip; 
 The best texts for this purpose should be determined locally, by local conditions, limited and facilitated by local wisdom. 
 Above all, they should not be imposed and regulated by a central power. 
 Nevertheless, Hirsch responded that (apart from a phrase which I have elided), &bquo;There is not a single one of these platitudes that I don't subscribe to wholeheartedly&hellip; &bquo;. 
 There are continuities between the positions I have so far outlined, despite their differing ideological biases. 
 Scholes is not a Marxist, but his American cultural populism has affinities with recent Marxist writing; at the same time, Hirsch and Scholes find themselves in unexpected agreement. 
  One might reach out to other affinities. 
 When Scholes writes that &bquo; no text  is so trivial as to be outside the bounds of humanistic study&equo;, I am reminded of C. S. Lewis's argument that any piece of writing has a claim to being literary if someone can read it in a &bquo;literary&equo; &mdash; i.e. an absorbed, attentive, loving &mdash; fashion. 
 The effect of all these approaches is to remove &bquo;literature&equo;, as conventionally defined, canonized, institutionalized, and taught, from the exclusive and isolated position which it has long occupied in the anglophone academy. 
 Even the modest proposal that literature should be read in its cultural context has large implications. 
 I am very sympathetic to it, and have tried to put it into effect in some of my own writing, but there is an accompanying danger that literature becomes absorbed by culture, and that literary values are superseded by cultural ones. 
 This may seem innocuous and acceptable, but the implications should be understood. 
 The kind of poem that a literary critic would regard as banal, ill-written, shallow in feeling, and platitudinous in sentiment, might have major human interest for the cultural historian. 
 Granted that there is an absolute need for humanistic values to prevail in a neo-utilitarian and materialistic age, one is faced with a significant divergence in the nature of these values. 
 The experience of reading major works of literature can have an overpowering effect on the responsive reader (usually, but by no means invariably, the young reader). 
 Kafka wrote that a book should be an axe to shatter the frozen sea within us; Eliot said that we should properly &bquo;find Othello  or Lear  frightful&equo;. 
 The right sort of literary experience can be like a nuclear explosion, whereas the &bquo;human expressiveness&equo; that Scholes detects in the humblest graffito is more like the low-level radioactivity that is always present in the natural environment. 
 There is, in fact, a good case for resisting the takeover of literature by culture, though it is not as strong as I once thought it was. 
 My doubts have grown during the years I have been thinking about and then writing this book, but for the moment I will concede that for many scholars and teachers a clarion-call to defend &bquo;literature as literature&equo; would prove rousing and timely. 
 It was sounded a few years ago by Helen Gardner in In Defence of the Imagination , by the contributors  to Laurence Lerner's Reconstructing Literature , and in America by Gerald Graff's Literature Against Itself  (Graff's position has shifted somewhat in his more recent Professing Literature) . 
 It was heard loud and clear in the unedifying battles of the early eighties. 
 And turning away from calls to battle and the accompanying rise in blood pressure, it seems reasonable for teachers of literature to go on teaching what they have been trained to teach, and what they like, understand, and are familiar with, without also having to take on many varieties of history &mdash; intellectual, cultural, political, social, economic, artistic, and musical &mdash; not to mention sociology, the study of popular culture, including the merest graffito, and, inevitably, literary theory. 
 The contextualizing of even the simplest poem has no obvious point to end at, once begun. 
 And the process by which the contextualizing is carried out would itself invite interrogation and theorization; Marxists committed to &bquo;cultural materialism&equo; would be impatient of a form of contextualizing founded in the history of ideas. 
 Similarly, to look at our activity in the self-reflective consciousness provided by &bquo;theory&equo; can be salutary; it is a good thing to know what we are doing, and, if possible, why. 
 But as Morris Zapp puts it in his poststructuralist phase, &bquo;every decoding is another encoding.&equo; 
 When we have given, or been given, a seemingly adequate theoretical account of our processes, then that account may itself need to be understood and analysed in a further, meta-theoretical discourse, and so on. 
 Why stop? 
 Although literature is increasingly explained by &bquo;culture&equo;, in an instance of the principle that one of the terms in binary opposition always becomes dominant, the process might be reversed. 
 A thoroughgoing deconstructive analysis would show culture being absorbed into literature, or at least into textuality and verbal play. 
 It is for this reason that deconstruction remains a fundamental threat to Marxism, and by implication to other culturalist and contextualizing approaches. 
 Experienced teachers ought to be able to deflect the na&iuml;ve foundationalism that insists that literary works &bquo;can only be understood&equo; in such-and-such a cultural, social, or ideological context, by contextualizing the proponent's own discourse. 
 One can invoke, too, Ricks's insistence that the language of the agenda sets the terms of the debate: to speak  of &bquo;principles&equo; and &bquo;faith&equo; is to offer an alternative discourse to the invocation of &bquo;theory&equo; and &bquo;ideology&equo;. 
 To speak personally, I might have found life easier, though possibly less interesting, if the English synthesis had continued to exist in approximately the same state as when I became a university teacher at the end of the 1950s: a genuine humane discipline, self-respecting, enjoyable, expanding, with methods that were established and familiar, if subject to variation between the different emphases associated with Oxford and Cambridge. 
 As we know, this agreeable stasis did not continue; the synthesis started to come apart for reasons which I have tried to explain. 
 A further disrupting factor was the academy's assumption that knowledge did not stand still but was advancing and progressive; if English accepted the security and opportunities of academic institutionalization, then it had to accept its concept of knowledge, and generate appropriate forms and volume of research. 
 If this meant there were potential conflicts between research and pedagogy, that was a price that had to be paid. 
 With the passing of time, the subject expanded further, institutional pressures became greater, and a gap widened between the professionals who taught literature and the poets, novelists, and dramatists, somewhere out in society, who wrote it, notwithstanding the increasing presence of contemporary literature as a university subject. 
 In this last respect, American experience is significantly different; writers-in-residence are common on campuses as teachers of creative writing, though literary theorists show little interest in what is being written. 
 Donald Davie has suggested that one reason for the explosion of theory is that it provides &bquo;a stamping ground for the innumerable people in departments of English (also of French, of German, of Classics) who have energy and intelligence but no literary sensibility.&equo; 
 Davie's provocative point is well taken. 
 &bquo;Literary sensibility&equo; is easier to recognize than to define, but it is analogous to having an unusually good ear for music, and has something in common with the creative faculty, even when the critic who possesses it is not an imaginative writer. 
 It has never been de rigueur  for academics who rise to high places in English departments, and, conversely, students who possess it may not do well in formal  examinations. 
 The idea of literary sensibility would probably be dismissed by the culturalists of the Left as a piece of mystification, and certainly few of them have shown signs of possessing it, on either side of the Atlantic. 
 It implies that capacity for personal affective response that is dismissed by those who wish to transform literature into a purely cognitive discourse. 
 The most visible and vocal theorists have high energy and intelligence; they also seem to find imaginative writing rather boring before it is processed into theory. 
 The drift of my rhetoric might seem to be taking me towards a traditional defence of literature, of the imagination, of creativity, of humane values in general. 
 I believe profoundly in all these things, it goes without saying; my difficulty lies in knowing how defensible they are in the form in which they are visibly institutionalized in the anglophone academy. 
 My reflections are not encouraging, though they are not altogether negative. 
 The first line of defence of established literary study against culturalist pressures is to emphasize &bquo;literature as literature&equo; rather than as a version of philosophy, history, sociology, and so forth. 
 Hirsch has rejected this phrase as delusive and logically meaningless, and this rejection might itself be rejected as an instance of the rat-trap logic to which he is inclined, an improper attempt to define a subject in more rigorous terms than the subject requires. 
 Utterances about literature make sense, and are generally understood, within the form of life in which they are habitually made. 
 Nevertheless, long before Hirsch, C. S. Lewis wrote that many discussions about &bquo;literature&equo; are discussions of a nonentity; for Lewis, literature was about as non-specific a term as &bquo;talking&equo; or &bquo;utterance&equo;. 
 It was what was said that was important. 
 If we look at what is located at present under the general heading of &bquo;literature&equo; we find an extraordinary variety of texts, with only very tenuous family resemblances between them. 
 How far, for instance, do Middle-March  and an imagist haiku resemble each other? 
 Very little, I would have thought, though the student of nineteenth- and twentieth-century literature is likely to encounter both of them. 
 The idea of literature that currently informs English teaching makes arbitrary associations and exclusions. 
 Novels, for instance, have less in common with lyric poetry than with  other forms of extended narrative, such as historiography, biography, autobiography &mdash; a genre of which there have been some interesting studies lately &mdash; or even some kinds of essay. 
 Conversely, poetry is in many ways closer to music than to the more extended and discursive literary forms. 
 The canon of literature as currently studied has, in some respects, expanded enormously, by the introduction of contemporary literature, of American and other anglophone literatures, and of work by marginalized social groups. 
 But in other ways the core canon has shrunk, by being limited to the obviously fictive genres, poetry, drama, and the novel. 
 This represents a much narrower view of the subject than was common in the early days of institutional literary study, when works of history, biography, philosophy, and divinity were part of the canon. 
 Today, even the most traditional courses in English Literature do not, as a rule, include the English Bible, reasonably thought to be one of the masterpieces of our literature. 
 Underlying the restriction of the canon are a number of interrelated factors, unified by the institutional need to give the subject a proper identity. 
 In a view of the subject radically different from Hirsch's or Lewis's, &bquo;literariness&equo; emerges as an essential concept, akin to &bquo;philosophy&equo; or &bquo;history&equo;. 
 A text of the past may be of interest to a critic, a philosopher, and a historian, and each would discover his appropriate interest within it. 
 &bquo;Literariness&equo; is to be found as a basic principle in the work of the Russian Formalists and the New Critics, and, elaborately formulated, in Frye's Anatomy of Criticism . 
 It inevitably presents itself in formalistic terms, and sometimes in overtly aesthetic ones. 
 The latter presentation is not so common, because of the generally unfavourable associations of &bquo;aesthetic&equo; in our culture, though it is implied whenever students are asked to approach a poem as a work of art, rather than as an historical document or a philosophical argument. 
 Indeed, a diluted Croceanism underlies much of our critical and pedagogic discourse, with its references to &bquo;expression&equo;, &bquo;feelings&equo;, &bquo;intuitions&equo;, and &bquo;unique personal responses&equo;. 
 Poems are more plausibly referred to as works of art than novels; the latter may have obviously aesthetic qualities, but have many other things in them as well. 
 Some  of the greatest novels ever written, James's &bquo;great fluid puddings&equo;, are hard to make much of in purely aesthetic or formalistic terms. 
 Nevertheless, the ultimate defence of literature against the culturalist or contextualizing pressures which want to turn it into something else is usually along aesthetic lines. 
 At this point I shall return to Hirsch, who argues that there can be no intrinsic understanding of literature, only a variety of understandings: &bquo;Aesthetic categories are intrinsic to aesthetic inquiries , but not to the nature of literary work. 
 Exactly the same can be said of ethical and psychological categories, or any critical categories whatever.&equo; 
 This points the way to the culturalist approach to which Hirsch has elsewhere shown himself sympathetic. 
 Music, I take it, could be defended in essentialist and aesthetic terms, but not literature; this point, also, was made by Lewis in The Personal Heresy . 
 Hirsch's formulation does not exclude the possibility of understanding literature in aesthetic terms, it merely prohibits us from claiming that this is how literature is, essentially, to be comprehended. 
 In practice, it weakens the claim of literary study to be a coherent and self-sufficient discipline. 
 One may choose to adopt a broadly aesthetic approach to texts, as is often done, perfectly appropriately, but one then encounters what seems to me a potentially disabling contradiction. 
 In practical pedagogy the student is encouraged to read, carefully, attentively, sensitively, a particular text. 
 As we have seen, there may be cultural barriers to such reading, but leaving aside that potential difficulty, we invite the student to make a unique, personal response to the text, to tune in to the true voice of feeling, to participate in its expressiveness; in short, to have an aesthetic experience. 
 This is true even of the seemingly tougher-minded Cambridge approach. 
 Williams has referred to &bquo;a conception of literature as a series of authors to whom there must, must  be &bquo;personal evaluative response'&equo; or its available facsimile.&equo; 
 In Romantic-Crocean terms, the experience is assumed to be both unique and ineffable, to be undergone in a form of negative capability, without, in Keats's words, any irritable reaching after fact and reason. 
 Croce, in the ninth chapter of Aesthetic , attacks the idea of applying rhetorical or critical terms to the unique act of  aesthetic expression. 
 Nevertheless, this, in one way or another, is what we then require the student to do; the ineffable is to be transformed into efficient communication, whether in seminar discussion, an essay, or an examination answer. 
 Fact and reason are to be reached after. 
 The contradiction has long been lived with in practice, and students become adept in faking responses. 
 Nevertheless, it points to a flaw in the aesthetic defence of literary education, and one which implicitly encourages culturalist claims to take it over. 
 I should add that my own understanding of literature is largely in aesthetic terms; at least, of poetry; where fiction and drama are concerned, aesthetic approaches can, at best, only be partial. 
 The idea of aesthetic education, as formulated by Schiller, seems an entirely noble one; the difficulty is in accommodating it to contemporary pedagogy. 
 This dilemma has been present since the beginnings of institutionalized literary study. 
 It was nicely illustrated in F. H. Townsend's satirical addition to Wordsworth's address to the cuckoo: 
 O Cuckoo! shall I call thee Bird, 
 Or but a wandering Voice? 
 State the alternative preferred 
 With reasons for your choice. 
 It largely disappears when literary texts are treated as cultural traces in a cognitive rather than an affective reading. 
 I am conscious that to question publicly the established methods of English study is to lay oneself open to the charge of giving aid and comfort to the philistines and utilitarians who want to remake higher education according to their own ideals, if that is the word for them. 
 My position is, I hope, straightforward. 
 I am a firm believer in extending higher education and in preserving the humanities, by all possible means, against technologico-Benthamite attacks. 
 But the humanities comprise a number of disciplines and subjects, of which English is only one; the Leavisite attempt to turn it into the Queen of the Sciences never looked like succeeding. 
 To identify English as peculiarly problematical should not weaken the general defence of humane values in education, and may in the longer run help to strengthen them. 
 A successful military campaign may require giving up some  tactically untenable territory. 
 Having taught English Literature for a long time in universities, on both sides of the Atlantic, and having spent some years pondering the questions raised in this book, I have come to some very tentative conclusions about what might be done; they are not, I might add, of the kind I thought I would come to when I began working on it. 
 In the wake of the MacCabe affair in 1981, an editorial in the Times Higher Education Supplement  said that a fissiparous discipline such as English had a number of hard choices in front of it: it could become even more pluralistic and diffuse, with accompanying pedagogic problems; it could repressively impose one favoured approach; or it could split. 
 Raymond Williams came to think that a splitting of the discipline was increasingly likely, since cultural materialism and radical semiotics were not compatible with the dominant paradigm of literary study: &bquo;For these necessarily include the paradigm itself as a matter for analysis, rather than as a governing definition of the object of knowledge.&equo; 
 In this situation, the question had to be raised: 
 can a radically different work still be carried on under a single heading or department when there is not just diversity of approach but more serious and fundamental differences about the object of knowledge (despite overlapping of the actual material of study)? 
 For reasons which are much more pragmatic than ideological, I have come to think that a separation of Cultural Studies from English, though not easy, would be the least damaging way forward for both parties. 
 It would represent a realignment within the humanities, not a diminution of them. 
 Cultural Studies would be visibly plural and fragmented, involving the study of literary texts, alongside others in history, philosophy, politics, sociology, film, and other disciplines. 
 Students' expectations would be shaped accordingly, and they would be spared the struggle to grasp the elusive &bquo;point&equo; of the subject which is a feature of life in English Departments. 
 There are quite good educational reasons for believing that a diverse spread of subjects is more suitable for the late twentieth-century academy than the traditional single-honours degree, as is suggested by experience in America, and in Britain in polytechnics and colleges of higher  education. 
 (Not to mention PPE, otherwise Modern Greats, at Oxford.) 
 In so far as literature would inevitably play a substantial part in any such course, the students reading it would learn the appropriate cultural codes rather than being expected to know them already. 
 They would also be spared the fall-out from damaging academic debates about the nature of the canon, and the virtues of coverage versus concentration. 
 There would be no fixed canon, and no coverage. 
 Such a degree course would not suit everyone, but it might well be attractive to the late entrants and mature students who are increasingly common participants in higher education, particularly in the humanities, and who bring valuable experience of life and work to their study, but may have rather little formal preparation. 
 It would also be more appropriate for the unambitious students of moderate talents who currently apply for an English degree, but would be more at home in a less intensive programme of liberal study. 
 Cultural Studies would provide a more productive environment for the radical aca-English Departments, who have conspicuous energy and intelligence, but little literary sensibility or aesthetic interests. 
 Literature, when taught in such a context, would, no doubt, be given a culturalist and contextualist treatment, and I believe that there is nothing inherently objectionable about this. 
 But I am also attracted by Graff's suggestion that those who favoured a &bquo;literary&equo;, aesthetic, affective way of reading would then experience the satisfaction of working against the prevailing grain. 
 Once established, &bquo;Cultural Studies&equo; might show structural affinities with Social Studies and move closer to that area. 
 It might also become dominated by Marxists and cultural materialists, but not inevitably so; academic sociology offers points of comparison here. 
 And in any case, Marxism looks like a declining force. 
 My proposal will, I know, appear as selling the pass, to traditionalist teachers of English Literature, and perhaps upset them, which I am sorry for. 
 I will point out, though, that it is in some ways a very conservative proposal, inviting a return to origins. 
 When &bquo;English&equo; first came on the scene in the nineteenth century, it was precisely as a form of Cultural Studies, involving not only language and literature, but history, geography, philosophy,  and so on, requiring the first professors of the subject to be polymaths. 
 It was only later that the aesthetic dimension of literary study became emphasized, with an accompanying concentration on the fictional genres. 
 The other part of my proposal will probably prove annoying to radicals, thereby ensuring a proper balance. 
 If Cultural Studies goes its own way, what happens to what is left? 
 I would certainly not favour a rump version of one of the current forms of English degree, with their recurring arguments about canons and coverage, the definition of literature, and the place of theory. 
 Instead, I propose taking the logic of generic concentration as far as it can go, with a degree which would study, in detail, a single genre, poetry. 
 There are certain academic precedents, particularly the uncontroversial establishment in a number of universities of degrees in drama, which do work previously thought of as belonging to an English degree. 
 The other model I have in mind is the degree in music, which is intensive, technical, and demanding, and attracts a small number of well-qualified entrants. 
 A degree of a comparable kind, directed at poetry, is, I think, feasible, and would be more coherent and rewarding than existing degrees in English Literature. 
 It would attract the automatic charge of &bquo;&eacute;litist&equo;, but so, potentially, do many worthwhile kinds of intellectual activity. 
 The reason for concentrating on poetry is that it is the most visibly &bquo;literary&equo;, formal, and conventional of the major genres, and would provide the best scope for study within an aesthetic frame of reference. 
 &bquo;Poetry&equo; is itself a very flexible term, extending from Elizabethan lyrics to Don Juan , and from Paradise Lost  to imagist epiphanies. 
 In my suggested scheme it would certainly include Elizabethan and Jacobean poetic drama. 
 By dropping the novel and other kinds of drama, more time would be provided for the extensive reading of poetry which is so essential if one is to make sense of any one poem. 
 There might be regrets over giving up the novel, but after having been deeply interested in that form for many years (even to the extent of writing one) and often teaching courses on the novel, I have come to the conclusion that the pedagogic difficulties involved are extreme. 
 Percy Lubbock, at the end of The Craft of Fiction , acknowledged that as soon as we have finished reading a novel we begin to forget  it, and what is left to talk about is a vague cloud of fading impressions: &bquo;the book vanishes as we lay hands on it.&equo; 
 In the face of this central problem, the valuable work that has gone on in recent years in narratology, and other aspects of fictional form, is curiously difficult to apply in practice. 
 Teaching often involves looking in detail at particular passages, in the hope that the part will relate coherently to the whole, but the doctrine of the hermeneutic circle reminds us that we cannot understand the parts until we understand the whole (and vice versa). 
 Fredric Jameson has made a vigorous statement of this difficulty: 
 Every serious practising critic knows a secret which is less often publicly discussed, namely, that there exists no ready-made corridor between the sealed chambers of stylistic investigation and that equally unventilated space in which the object of study is reconstituted as narrative structure. 
 In practice, whatever the solution adopted there is always an uncomfortable shifting of gears in the movement from one of these perspectives to the other: nor does the assertion of this or that &bquo;homology&equo; between style and narrative do much more than to pronounce resolved in advance the dilemma for which it was supposed to provide a working answer. 
 If novels are to be studied as part of an exclusive course, they might be better located in Cultural Studies. 
 The teachers on such a programme would have to confront the difficulty I have just raised, as well as questions about the mimetic values of fiction in the face of structuralist and poststructuralist assertions that word and world have no necessary relation. 
 Something of the problem defined by Jameson would also apply to the reading of longer poems, but I believe it would be more manageable; with poetry, a better case can be made for homologies between style and structure. 
 A course dealing with poetry would certainly raise theoretical problems, whose discussion would be part of the programme. 
 The most demanding would be one I have previously raised: namely, that though the successful encounter with a poem may result in a unique aesthetic experience, academic practice demands that it be turned into non-aesthetic discourse. 
 Furthermore, not everyone who is invited to respond to an admired poem will have any such experience. 
 And although talking about poems &bquo;as poetry&equo; will imply an aesthetic reading rather than a culturalist or historical one, it must be acknowledged that  there is inescapable culturalist and historical underpinning of the idea of a canon; not all the poems to be read will have much aesthetic value. 
 What one hopes for is for the student to remain open to the possibility of aesthetic experience, to accept and enjoy it when it occurs, but not to fake responses if it does not. 
 Such a course would be primarily concerned with the formal, technical, and conventional aspects of poetry, considered both synchronically and diachronically; in a word, &bquo;rhetoric&equo;. 
 Its starting-point might be Hopkins's definition of rhetoric as &bquo;the common teachable part of poetry&equo;. 
 Such a statement implies that there are aspects of poetry which may not  be so easily teachable. 
 Indeed, Hopkins distinguished between &bquo;rhetoric&equo; and &bquo;poetical insight and inspiration&equo;. 
 The model, as I have said, would be a degree in music, and would include history and theory as well as analysis. 
 Most importantly, it would also include exercises in composition, of the kind once common in the study of classics. 
 I prefer not to call this &bquo;creative writing&equo;, since the late-Romantic ideological implications of &bquo;creative&equo; are irrelevant, even undesirable. 
 The intention is that students of elaborate structures in language should be able to construct them as well as receive and consume them, if only to achieve a better understanding of how poems are made. 
 Something of the sort has already been introduced into some English degrees, under the aegis of the Verbal Arts Association, who have made a welcome start with such work. 
 The reading of English poetry would be accompanied by a consideration of historical as well as current theories of poetry. 
 These would include the arguments of the major poet-critics of the past: Sidney, Jonson, Dryden, Johnson, and on to the Romantics, Victorians, and modernists. 
 I cannot see how the canon of poetry could avoid being constructed along historical lines, though the problem and implications of canon-formation should be faced, as part of theoretical study. 
 It could take account of recent attempts to enlarge the canon, particularly by the addition of poetry by women, and other marginalized groups. 
 Indeed, such an academic structure might provide a good opportunity for the exercise suggested by Graff, in which students (many of whom would probably be women) would consider a feminist anthology of women poets  of the past, and discuss how far they are admissible into the existing poetic canon, and what theoretical criteria might govern such admission. 
 The canon would be largely English, not for a priori nationalistic reasons, but because it is written in English, and until fairly recently most poetry written in English was also written in England, or at least, in the British Isles. 
 There is no reason why American poetry, or poetry from other anglophone literatures, should not be read, given a minimal amount of culture and contextual instruction (which may also be needed, of course, in the reading of English poems). 
 To what extent students on such a degree would also need to read poetry in another language is a difficult question. 
 In principle it is extremely desirable, not only because of the basic &bquo;otherness&equo; of foreign poetry, but because such knowledge gives one a better sense of what English poetry can and cannot do. 
 In practice, given the monoglot tendency in secondary education it might be difficult to recruit students with the necessary competence. 
 The University of Warwick has for some time provided the possibility of studying both English and foreign texts in a comparative way at undergraduate level. 
 The lessons have, however, been inconclusive. 
 It is certainly the case that a student with, say, a moderately good pass in A-level French may have little capacity for the responsive reading of French poetry. 
 Within the Warwick structure students have the possibility of learning another language intensively from scratch in the first year, so they can read straightforward literary texts at the end of it. 
 That, at least is the assumption, but there have been disagreements about how well it works. 
 Some years ago the teachers of one language pronounced themselves satisfied that at the end of a year the students of it had the capacity for literary reading; the equally competent and concerned teachers of another language were convinced that their students had achieved no such capacity, and that the process was rather a waste of time. 
 Much, of course, depends on individual motivation and capacity. 
 Many people who are accomplished linguists have no literary sensibility. 
 On the other hand, there are those who have only an imperfect formal competence in a language but  who by a combination of guesswork and intuition can somehow make contact with the aesthetic qualities of a foreign poem. 
 Impressive translations have been made on such a basis, though usually by poets. 
 It is not a quality that it is sensible to expect in the generality of students. 
 For those who do not have much real competence in other languages, there is the possibility of coming to terms with poems in the older, more remote forms of English. 
 Chaucer, I assume, would form part of such a programme anyway. 
 Langland and the Gawain poet, read in the original, would extend both poetic experience and linguistic understanding. 
 Indeed, the historical study of language together with contemporary stylistics, probably ought to feature in any such course. 
 Personally, I reject the Oxford claim that English Literature begins with Anglo-Saxon, and would not make it a required subject. 
 But an option in it might be provided for those who were curious about what English poetry was like before, so to speak, it became English. 
 I already seem to be overloading a non-existent syllabus. 
 There is an element of utopianism in drafting such proposals, though I believe these ideas are worth pursuing. 
 The student intake would be limited to those who have a genuine literary sensibility, who are interested in poetry, and are already in the habit of reading it. 
 This might exclude many students who are currently enrolled in English degrees, even those with good A-levels which can now be obtained very largely by studying drama and fiction. 
 Indeed, I am not sure what the correlation would be between formal attainments and the right qualities needed to take a degree in poetry. 
 Some students entering it could have quite other claims and qualifications than A-level English. 
 It might well appeal to poets or would-be poets, who, contrary to popular myths about inspiration, are usually keenly interested in the technical aspects of composition. 
 What I have proposed in the foregoing pages is a conscious surrender to the culturalists of much of the activity that now goes on in English degrees, in order to retain something more coherent, defensible, and inherently valuable. 
 Culturalists will point out &mdash; as C. S. Lewis once did &mdash; that much poetry of the past was not written for aesthetic ends, but for religious,  political, or other social purposes. 
 This is true; but such poems have outlived their original purposes and now survive as aesthetic entities. 
 We may, following Hirsch, accept that there is no such thing as a poetic or aesthetic essence; but we can say that such texts are rewarding when approached in aesthetic terms, or, in Lewis's words, are read in literary ways. 
 The parallel with studying music has more than structural significance. 
 Music is the most obviously aesthetic of the arts &mdash; to whose condition they all aspire, according to Walter Pater &mdash; yet it submits easily to formal and technical analysis. 
 Interestingly, music, though a major cultural form, has not attracted the attention of contemporary culturalists. 
 It may be that there is literally nothing they can say about it in the terms they are accustomed to using. 
 The sociologists of art who discuss music have to restrict themselves to the conditions in which it is performed, produced, or received, rather than the music itself. 
 The affinities between music and poetry have been familiar since antiquity, though they are largely ignored in the current intellectual climate. 
 Poetry, of course, can never become  music, despite the dream of nineteenth century symbolists, since, as Eliot's Sweeney put it, &bquo;I gotta use words when I talk to you.&equo; 
 But a restatement of that ancient affinity should strengthen poetry against political and culturalist claims. 
 The academic study of music may be a specialist field, but music, of every kind, is widely diffused and performed; only a small percentage of those attending concerts or recitals will have taken degrees in music. 
 Similarly, one would like to see a state of affairs in which many more people read and enjoyed poetry than had taken a degree in it. 
 The degree in poetry I have outlined would attempt to be open about its theoretical assumptions. 
 I do not believe there is any absolute virtue in such openness, in fact, I think that education is ideally carried on in a shared form of life where there is agreement about fundamentals and attention can be concentrated on the task in hand. 
 But no such state of affairs exists in our culture, and it is self-delusory and damaging to pretend that it does. 
 The challenge to one's premisses and assumptions will be made and has to be faced, though one might prefer to reply in terms of &bquo;principles&equo; rather than of  &bquo;theory&equo;. 
 The reply I envisage is likely to prove unsatisfactory to radicals and utilitarians alike, since it would state that poetry is ultimately its own justification, like music or games. 
 One hopes that reading it may have good effects, of the kind described by Wordsworth in the 1800 Preface, or more succinctly summed up by Lewis in the conclusion to An Experiment in Criticism , where he says that literature heals the wound without undermining the privilege of individuality. 
 Yet to study literature, or poetry, in the hope of achieving these effects is perverse, like playing a game, not for the pleasure of the game, but simply in order to keep fit. 
 The latter is a desirable by-product, but it is not what the game should be about. 
 The humanizing and moral effects of reading literature must be left to occur as and when they will, which will be different in every individual. 
 They certainly cannot be turned into the stated goal of an academic programme. 
 The attempt to do just this, pursued with inappropriate insistence, ultimately vitiated the Leavisite campaign. 
 II  
 I have tried to show in this book that though the academic institutionalizing of vernacular literary study which began about a century ago had good, even inescapable reasons in its origins, its later progress has not had the effects the founders hoped for. 
 This is largely because, once incorporated into the academy, this study had to adopt the values and principles of the academy, and develop as the institution developed. 
 An ideal of professionalism became dominant, and teachers of English did their best to adopt it, producing an ever greater volume of critical and scholarly writing whose motive was as much career development as the expansion of knowledge. 
 And yet, they could never become as truly professional as their colleagues in other disciplines, since &bquo;literature&equo; did not belong in the academy and was not generated there, though criticism and scholarship might be. 
 English, as the Newbolt Report and Leavis had insisted, was not like other academic subjects, though all the pressures of the modern academy, which include both privileges and responsibilities, have tried to make it come in line. 
 The professionalized academic critic  wanted to forget that there had been a time when criticism was part of literature; and the belief that criticism or theory could be literature in themselves was perhaps part of the process of exorcizing other values and attitudes. 
 Poets and novelists see the situation differently, and so, indeed, do many students, who tend to want something different from what their ablest teachers wish to give them. 
 The complex of disparate elements comprising academic English was always unstable, though they might have stayed together longer if it had not been for the demands of the academic environment. 
 In the 1950s, it seemed as if there might be a place for literature in the academy, so that the writing of fiction or poetry, of criticism, and the teaching of literature would become a unified form of life. 
 As we know, it did not happen. 
 Thirty years on, English is a large and entrenched subject, and there is no likelihood of putting the clock back, and starting again in some other way: my proposal for a division between Cultural Studies and a degree in poetry is a pragmatic proposal for a way out of current difficulties. 
 Other factors, like the institutional need to advance knowledge, to publish, to engage in research, and generate performanceindicators, would remain, whatever new academic structures emerged. 
 There is, however, another way in which a useful advance might be made. 
 Again, one looks back to the nineteenthcentury origins of English literary studies, when the first pioneers and missionaries, men such as Morley and Furnivall, travelled all over the country to talk about English literature in adult education classes and working men's clubs. 
 Indeed, it was the pressure from this large and disadvantaged constituency that helped to establish vernacular literary education. 
 There has always been a vigorous tradition of English studies in adult education, and indeed it was through such classes that I was myself able to become a mature student in the early 1950s. 
 In the present situation, there is more and more scope for adult or continuing education, with an older or academically late-developing constituency. 
 In such work there is an opportunity for English to, in a sense, escape from the academy, literally to go extra-mural, and to re-establish those connections with the larger society that were originally  part of its raison d'&ecirc;tre . 
 Literature classes with older people can be rewarding; they bring a longer experience of life to bear on the subject, and often a wide range of reading. 
 They are also exempt from the demands of examination passing, assessment, and certification, that I believe have a more distorting effect in the teaching of literature than in other academic areas. 
 The subject can be pursued for its own satisfaction. 
 However, a difficulty with extra-mural study is that teachers have to work very hard in order to keep classes in being, since there are no external compulsions on students to attend, and their motivation and level of interest are very variable. 
 Malcolm Bradbury's story, &bquo;The Adult Education Class&equo;, nicely dramatizes the difficulties and dangers. 
 Adult classes, in fact, require exceptionally good teaching, of a kind that may be remote from the professional ideals of many presentday academics. 
 At the present time, there is much interest in the English past, evoked in exhibitions commemorating historical events, and evident in the spread of museums and the great popularity of visiting country homes. 
 This interest has several aspects. 
 One of them, as the Left disapprovingly points out, is a mythologized version of past greatness which obfuscates the disagreeable realities of the present. 
 Certainly there are many bogus images of the national past around, culminating in the dream world peddled abroad by the British Tourist Board (though this is, alas, what Americans and others want to visit). 
 But people need myths of one sort or another, and the Left has its own, in memories of Wat Tyler, Cromwell, the Tolpuddle Martyrs, and the heroic industrial struggles of the past. 
 Mythology, however partial, is better than blank amnesia. 
 This current feeling for the past might provide a way in adult classes of shifting the emphasis from popular modern writing to earlier literature. 
 Chaucer looked at in isolation can seem daunting, but Chaucer read in a cultural and historical context, with visual and other aids, could come alive as a great poet, speaking across six centuries, in a Gadamerian fusion of horizons. 
 I am not, though, recommending the ideological antiquarianism of the New Historicism, which has little interest in poetry as such. 
 This is a speculative proposal, merely, and it may fall foul of the fact  that in our image-ridden culture reading is difficult, and literary texts still demand to be read , rigorously and carefully. 
 In cultural history reading &bquo;about&equo; something may be good enough; in studying literature it is not. 
 There is a good deal more to say, and to think about, concerning the relations between the intra- and extra-mural teaching of literature. 
 The above considerations are simply meant to signal my conviction that a change of balance is desirable, with a move away from the narrow professionalism of the academy, and a modest return to the original motives of the discipline of English. 
 Something similar is true of literary criticism. 
 At the moment the academy has a nearmonopoly of the subject, and I would like to see it broken, in a recognition of the traditional cultural truth that good criticism can be written by poets and novelists, and indeed by people whose professional concern is not with literature at all. 
 Reviewing and criticism are separate activities, but the best literary journalism can provide genuine and valuable criticism, as Morris Dickstein has pointed out. 
 What is needed are more journals that are prepared to publish long, serious, reflective essays or review-articles, as the London Review of Books  does. 
 Victoria Glendinning, writing as a biographer and literary journalist, has offered some judicious thoughts on the question, which summarize much of my argument: 
 No one could doubt that the application of the academic mind to literature has been salutary in bringing rigour and discipline into criticism: cleaner texts, scholarly annotations, precise analysis, intelligent &mdash; even transforming &mdash; interpretations and readings; and an intolerance for woolly emotional responses, vague inflated recommendations, and subjective wallowings of all kinds. 
 But the academic mind, and the exigencies of the academic career, have had the effect of splitting off academic approaches to literature from the &bquo;reading&equo;, in that word's widest sense, of ordinary people&hellip; 
 An ambitious lecturer in an English Department is writing for his peer group, not for the general public. 
 The tenor of this book has been pessimistic, but not, I hope, despairing. 
 Some readers will find its arguments unconvincing, believing that what I see as problems are not problems at all. 
 I can conceive of such a response coming from two quite different kinds of reader. 
 The first would be moderate conservatives of placid and unreflective temperament who are happily engaged with their research and their  teaching, and who believe that the discipline of English is in good heart, with lots of interesting books coming out and buoyant student demand. 
 They support a genial pluralism in English studies, encouraging a hundred flowers to bloom, though putting up a cautious resistance to the extremes of foreign ideology and theory. 
 The other kind would be academics who are committed to a tough professionalism on the American model, who believe that knowledge advances and becomes obsolete, that theory is essential, and that nothing of interest can be said about literature outside an institutional framework. 
 In Lodge's characterology, they are Robyn Penroses aspiring to be Morris Zapps. 
 What I have deplored or been sceptical about they would find admirable. 
 They tend to be young, energetic, and ambitious, but there are by now professors of that outlook. 
 All I can say to the objectors in both categories is that those who do not see a problem do not have a problem, and they can happily ignore what I have written. 
 But other readers will, I imagine, accept the general drift of what I have said, whilst disagreeing on many points of detail. 
 Not wanting to seem too negative, I have outlined ways in which the discipline of English as currently constituted might divide, to the benefit of both parties. 
 But knowing how the academic mind works, I am not optimistic about change. 
 As Noel Annan wrote in his life of Leslie Stephen: &bquo;The ingenuity in argument, the subtlety in drawing distinctions, the dexterous prevarications, the imperative reasons for procrastination, perpetually bewilder and confound the novice in university administration.&equo; 
 In this respect, at least, little has altered since the nineteenth century. 
 The most likely future is no overt change, with the discipline of English becoming less and less coherent, riven by feuds and revolts, but still presenting the external appearances of a large, well-established and respectable academic subject. 
 It could go on for a long time in this condition, like the Spanish Empire in its centuries of decline.  
 Chronicle 
 The Cantos: Towards a Pedestrian Reading  
 Pound appears the most crucial case, at least among poets writing in English, of those whose poetry &mdash; for those who value it &mdash; has to survive a self-evidently and perilously wrong understanding of history, and hence of politics. 
 And yet, as may be seen from the cardinal importance he attaches to a Herodotean term like the peri  - plus , Pound can be invoked by poets for whom the natural subjectmatter is topographical rather than historical, or at any rate historical only so far as history is checked against, and embodied in, and qualified by, topography. 
 This indeed is the burden of Pound's own poem, &bquo;Near Perigord&equo;, which argues that the puzzle of a particular poem by Bernard de Born &mdash; a historian's puzzle about the reasons for certain historically recorded vents &mdash; is to be solved only by realizing the strategic implications of the location of Born's own fortress of Hautefort. 
 At a time when Pound was principally a student of Proven&ccedil;al poetry, he appears to have been as good as his word, and to have travelled on foot over the terrain in question. 
 This seems to have been, at least in part, the motive behind a walking-tour which Pound took in 1911, of which we learn in chapter 16 of his Guide to Kulchur , written twenty years later: 
 If a man can't afford to go by automobile, and if he is content with eating and architecture, the world's best (as I have known it) is afoot from Poitiers, from Brives, from Perigord or Limoges. 
 In every town a romanesque church or chateau. 
 No place to stay for any time, but food every ten miles or fifteen or twenty. 
 When I say food, I mean food. 
 So, at any rate, was it. 
 With fit track to walk on. 
 This experience is referred to many times in the Cantos:  what its author most values in theory, the weighing of syllables in the line and the leading on of the reader's breath from one syllable to the next. 
 As for the case made against the versions in the Classic  Anthology  &mdash; that by using rhyme they align themselves with the closed poetry of print and not with the open poetry of the speaking breath &mdash; the obvious retort is that, although in these poems Pound often rhymes, he writes them in free verse, and in a free verse where the syllables are weighed, and the varying pace controlled, as scrupulously as in anything else he has written. 
 The freedom is earned and justified by the poet's acceptance of this responsibility, a responsibility more onerous than any incurred by the writer in regular meter. 
 And the verse is accordingly irregular and gnarled and yet sappy, far more like growing timber than like steel rails. 
 As for the rhyme, these are poems that characteristically celebrate the decorous in private and public life, and the verse must be in keeping; rhyme, when it occurs, is one of several concessions to decorum. 
 But there seems no room for any notion of the decorous in Olson's &bquo;objectism&equo;, any more than there is room for it in the lawless world of the Cantos , or in Pound himself when he is without a master to translate, whose example makes him surpass himself. 
 When we turn from the Rock-Drill  cantos to the Classic Anthology , something is lost but much is gained. 
 And the Classic Anthology  shows, therefore, that Williams was in the right when, to close his sour and justifiably contemptuous statement of 1945, he wrote: 
 When they lock the man up with Jim and John and Henry and Mary and Dolores and Grace &mdash; I hope they will give him access to books, with paper enough for him to go on making translations for us from the classics such as we have never seen except at his hands in our language. 
 First published by Oxford University Press (New York), 1964.  
 The valley is thick with leaves, with leaves, the trees, 
 The sunlight glitters, glitters a-top 
 Like a fish-scale roof 
 Like the church roof in Poictiers 
 If it were gold. 
 (4/14:18) 
 And a quarter-century later, in the Pisan cantos, when the poet is imprisoned in the American Army detention-camp at Pisa, these are among the memories which come back to him most poignantly. 
 In Canto 74 for instance, there are lines which allude to the Magdalenian cave-paintings discovered at Lascaux and elsewhere in this region of Perigord and Limousin: 
 and at Limoges the young salesman 
 bowed with such french politeness &bquo;No that is impossible.&equo; 
 I have forgotten which city 
 But the caverns are less enchanting to the unskilled explorer 
 than the Urochs as shown on the postals, 
 we will see those old roads again, question, 
 possibly 
 but nothing appears much less likely 
 (74/428:455) 
 And in Canto 76, altogether more plangently: 
 But to set here the roads of France, 
 of Cahors, of Chalus, 
 the inn low by the river's edge, 
 the poplars; to set here the roads of France 
 Aubeterre, the quarried stone beyond Poitiers 
 (76/455:482) 
 It seems to have been this last line which caused the editors of the Annotated Index to the Cantos of Ezra Pound  to provide one of the few pieces of misinformation in that admirable work. 
 For they give, against &bquo;Aubeterre&equo;, &bquo;A church just outside Poitiers, France&equo;. 
 In fact the Aubeterre that Pound means is Aubeterre-sur-Dronne not in Poitou at all but southward, in Perigord. 
 The proof is in the very beautiful early poem, &bquo;Provincia Deserta&equo;: 
 At Chalais is a pleached arbour; 
 Old pensioners and old protected women 
 Have a right there &mdash; 
 it is charity. 
 I have crept over old rafters, 
 peering down 
 Over the Dronne, 
 over a stream full of lilies. 
 Eastward the road lies, 
 Aubeterre is eastward, 
 With a garrulous old man at the inn. 
 I know the roads in that place: 
 Mareuil to the north-east, 
 La Tour, 
 There are three keeps near Mareuil, 
 And an old woman, 
 glad to hear Arnaut, 
 Glad to lend one dry clothing. 
 Anyone who opens before him Carte Michelin No. 75, can see the places named, related just as Pound says: Chalais, on the main line from paris to Bordeaux; Aubeterre in the valley of the Dronne, twelve kilometres to the east; then thirty kilometres north-eastward a little place called La Tour Blanche; and perhaps fifteen kilometres further, just on the edge of the map, Vieux-Mareuil. 
 The Michelin guide to Perigord will reveal a castle either preserved or in ruins at each of these places, though one would need to go off the map to Mareuil-sur-Belle, as well as Vieux-Mareuil, to identify all the three donjons which Pound speaks of in that vicinity. 
 Equally, one needs to have walked these roads oneself if one is to locate &bquo;the inn low by the river's edge&equo;. 
 That inn is what Pound always remembers of Aubeterre, for instance in Canto 80: 
 and at Ventadour and at Aubeterre 
 or where they set tables down by small rivers, 
 and the stream's edge is lost in grass. 
 (80/509:544) 
 And yet that inn, the Hotel de perigord, being set down by the Dronne, is on the outskirts of Aubeterre. for Aubeterre is a hilltown, set on a chalky cliff above the river (whence the name &mdash; Aubeterre, Alba Terra). 
 I suspect that Pound never went further into Aubeterre than this inn, and one needs to have walked in his footsteps from Chalais to Aubeterre to see how he could well have done this, skirting the hill, stopping for perhaps a mid-day meal  in the inn, and then pushing on at once for La Tour Blanche. 
 If he did this, Pound missed a great deal, for Aubeterre is one of the most beautiful and delightfully peaceful places in the whole of old Aquitaine. 
 (In the days of Bertrand de Born, Aquitaine of course was a province of the English crown; Eleanor of Aquitaine, the princess whose marriage to an English King brought this about, is one of the femmes fatales  of the Cantos; and Richard Coeur de Lion, trying to make good his claim to all this part of France, was killed at Chalus &mdash; a place in this area to which the Cantos refer repeatedly in connection with the King's death.) 
 If Pound in this way did bypass Aubeterre, he missed something after his own heart. 
 For one of the curiosities of Aubeterre is a church in the form of an artificial cave hewn in the face of the chalk cliff. 
 The Michelin Guide to the C&ocirc;te de l'Atlantique  says that this eerie and impressive cavern, which communicates by a passage through the cliff to the ch&acirc;teau on the summit, was probably made in the twelfth century to shelter the relics of the Holy Sepulchre at Jerusalem brought back from a Crusade by Pierre II of Castillon, who at that time held the ch&acirc;teau. 
 Now Pound has interested himself a great deal in the order of the Templars, to which Pierre of Castillon belonged. 
 In fact it is the Templars, some of whose ritual survives in the practices of modern Freemasonry, who account for Pound's interest in Poitiers, one of their principal centres. 
 In the thirteenth century the King of france, abetted by a weak Pope, very brutally suppressed the Order of Templars and appropriated their enormous wealth. 
 The Grandmaster of the Order at this time was Jacques de Molay. 
 And that name, Jacques de Molay, is evoked by Yeats in Section VII of his &bquo;Meditations in Time of Civil War&equo;: 
 &bquo;Vengeance upon the murderers&equo;, the cry goes up, &bquo;Vengeance for Jacques Molay&equo;. 
 In cloud-pale rags, or in lace, The rage-driven, rage-tormented, and rage-hungry troop, Trooper belabouring trooper, biting at arm or at face, Plunges towards nothing, arms and fingers spreading wide For the embrace of nothing; and I, my wits astray Because of all that senseless tumult, all but cried For vengeance on the murderers of Jacques Molay. 
 Yeats learned about Jacques de Molay in Thomas Wright's Narratives  of Sorcery and Magic  (1851). 
 Pound's source, on the other hand, was almost certainly chapter 6 of The Law of Civilization and Decay  (1896) by Brooks Adams, Henry Adams's brother. 
 In Canto 90 we read: 
 to the room in Poitiers where one can stand 
 casting no shadow, 
 That is Sagatrieb, 
 that is tradition. 
 Builders had kept the proportion, 
 did Jacques de Molay 
 know these proportions? 
 and was Erigena ours? 
 Mr Noel Stock, who speaks as one who had Pound's confidence in recent years and was in daily contact with him, explains that this passage derives from a hint thrown out by Jessie L. Weston in her from Ritual to Romance , to the effect that the charges of heresy brought against the Templars were not wholly unfounded, since some of the practices of the Eleusinian mystery-cults from the pagan Near East survived in the heart of Christendom in the rituals of the Templars, a survival to be traced in literature in the stories and poems about the quest of the holy grail. 
 From Ritual to Romance  came out in 1920, and was a new book when T.S. 
 Eliot borrowed from it for The Waste Land , thus making it permanently famous; Pound could not have known of it in 1911, but if he had then visited the Templars' cavern-church in Aubeterre he could hardly have failed to remember it in the light of jessie Weston's argument. 
 Certainly in recent years Pound's interest in mystery-cults has been more than antiquarian; in &bquo;was Erigena ours?&equo; he asks whether the philosopher Scotus Erigena was one of the Eleusinian brotherhood, and &bquo;ours&equo; can be given full weight &mdash; Noel Stock goes so far as to claim (op. cit. p.22) that some of the obscurity of these later Cantos is deliberate and arcane &mdash; &bquo;he writes about them as an initiate in words that are both &bquo;published and not published&equo;&hellip;&equo;. 
 Fascinating as this is, it is surely with relief that we return from thus checking printed source against printed source, cross-referring and tentatively identifying, to the open air of &bquo;the roads of France&equo;. 
 And indeed I would insist on this: the first requirement for a study of Pound is a set of maps (preferably half an inch to the mile) of at any rate certain regions of France, Italy and England; the second requirement is a set of Michelin Green Guides for France and Italy, and (if one is American) similar guides to the South of England. 
 In this, the case of Pound is no different from other writers, or it is different only in degree. 
 Yet, oddly, the only authors for whom we are ready to make this provision nowadays are the Irish ones, Joyce and Yeats. 
 Everyone knows that a Street Directory of Dublin is essential to the reading of joyce. 
 There would be general agreement  that maps of County Sligo and County Galway are essential aids to the study of Yeats. 
 And perhaps most people qualified to judge would concede that there comes a time early in any study of Joyce where the student has to beat the Dublin streets on foot. 
 Similarly no one who has attended the Yeats Summer School in Sligo will deny that the seminars and lectures are less profitable than driving to Glencar, or Gort, and walking in those places, or wandering in the demesne of Lissadell and under the shoulder of Ben Bulben. 
 And yet we are shamefaced about this. 
 It smacks of the Dickensian Society making pilgrimages to Rochester and Dover and Yarmouth; or of &bquo;poetry-lovers&equo; haunting Grasmere and Coniston Water. 
 Perhaps it does. 
 But I incline to think that our grandfathers and grandmothers were in the right of it, and that no one can claim to understand Wordsworth who has not been to Hawkshead and Ambleside. 
 The reason why we are embarrassed to admit this is that we have lived in an age when the self-sufficiency, the autonomy of poems has been elevated into dogma. 
 Poems can  be self-sufficient, leaning on no reality outside themselves other than the history and usage of the words out of which they are made. 
 But in every age there have been poets who were uninterested in thus cutting their poems free of any but a linguistic reality, poets who are &bquo;realistic&equo; and &bquo;mimetic&equo; in the most straightforward senses of those two complicated words. 
 In our age Pound, far more than Eliot or Yeats, is such a poet. 
 And yet we have seen that the topography of Sligo (to which one should add the topography of at least one part of London, Bedford Park) is illuminating for the reader of Yeats. 
 And who is to say that the topography of the Somerset village of East Coker is unimportant to a reading of Eliot's four Quartets ? 
 And yet how few of us have made that pilgrimage! 
 Chalais and Aubeterre figure at least once in the Cantos that Pound has written more recently. 
 In Canto 101, which was published in the volume Thrones  (1960) we read: 
 Finding scarcely anyone save Monsieur de R&eacute;musat 
 who could understand him 
 (junipers, south side) M. Talleyrand 
 spruce and fir take the North 
 Chalais, Aubeterre 
 snow-flakes at a hand's breadth, and rain. 
 Trees line the banks, mostly willows 
 (101/722:75) 
 Here only the place-names refer to france; the junipers, the spruce and fir, and the falling snow are taken over by Pound from a  landscape at the other side of the world. 
 So are &bquo;the willows&equo;. 
 What is amusing and significant about this latest reference to &bquo;the roads of france&equo; is the name of Talleyrand. 
 For Charles Maurice de Talleyrand-Perigord, Bonaparte's grand chamberlain, is one of several new heroes who have appeared in the Cantos written since 1945. 
 He appears once or twice in earlier cantos, but not flatteringly; whereas in Canto 105 for instance we are told, by no means persuasively: 
 Talleyrand saved Europe for a century 
 France betrayed Talleyrand; 
 Germany, Bismarck. 
 And Muss saved, rem salvavit, 
 in Spain 
 il salvabile. 
 (105/746:98) 
 (&bquo;Muss&equo; is Mussolini.) 
 Now, the Talleyrand-Perigords have, as their name implies, been mighty lords in Perigord since the early Middle Ages, and in the early poem &bquo;Near Perigord&equo; Talleyrand is one of the powerful and menacing neighbours whom Bertrand de Born has to play off one against another, thus earning (so Pound's poem suggests) the title which Dante gives him in the Inferno , &bquo;sower of strife&equo;. 
 The ch&acirc;teau of Chalais has been a stronghold of the Talleyrands from that day to this, and when Pound in recent years read about Napoleon's grand chamberlain, notably in the memoirs of Madame de R&eacute;musat (a principal source for Canto 101), this new association with Chalais re-activated his memories of that place, which accordingly is named afresh, bringing &bquo;Aubeterre&equo; with it, but in a quite different tone and spirit from &bquo;to set here the roads of France&equo;. 
 The trees that &bquo;line the banks, mostly willows&equo; are still there, and there are places in the town of Chalais crouched underneath its ch&acirc;teau, where Pound might still creep over old rafters in search of &bquo;a stream full of lilies&equo;. 
 Pound seems to have misremembered, however, for at Chalais the river is not the Dronne but a smaller stream, the Tude. 
 And although the Tude has plants in its waters, I am reluctant to believe that any of them are lilies; for Chalais has suffered from the twentieth century as Aubeterre has not, and the Tude is polluted whereas the Dronne runs clear. 
 Already in 1915 Pound was making this mistake about the rivers, for in &bquo;Near Perigord&equo;, which he published in that year, he declares:  
 Chalais is high, a-level with the poplars. 
 Its lowest stones just meet the valley tips Where the low Dronne is filled with water-lilies. 
 A map could have put Pound right, as it can put us right. 
 But no map, nor guide book either, can vindicate for us, &bquo;Chalais is high, a-level with the poplars&equo;. 
 To confirm this we have to pause and look back from the road to Aubeterre as it climbs the eastern slope of the valley of the Tude, just as Pound must have paused in 1911; and then we see that, whereas the modern town of Chalais is in the river bottom, old Chalais, a manorial village grouped round the gate of the ch&acirc;teau, does indeed stand on the ridge behind, so that the tops of the tallest poplars by the river wave just below the walls of the ch&acirc;teau. 
 Some poetry is &bquo;true&equo; in just this literal fashion. 
 And in the case of a poet like Pound, who presses upon as as &bquo;truths&equo; so many readings of history which in fact are dangerous errors, truths like these are precious. 
 To take one last example, when we read in Canto 101 (and many other places) about &bquo;Mont S&eacute;gur&equo;, the gloss we need is in the Michelin Guide to the pyrenees, where we learn that the Ch&acirc;teau of Mont S&eacute;gur saw the last stand of the Cathars or Albigensians, another heretical movement of the Middle Ages which is mysteriously connected with the quest of the grail. 
 But I feel sure that only by going to St Bertrand de Comminges (another name that crops up in the Cantos), and from there to Mont S&eacute;gur, shall we see the point of: &bquo;at Mont S&eacute;gur the chief's cell / you can enter it sideways only&equo; (101:725:77). 
 Place and spirit of place is the inspiration of more poetry than we nowadays like to admit; and to do that poetry justice, the critic needs to turn himself into a tourist.  
 Paideuma  I: 1 (Spring-Summer 1972); reprinted in The poet in the  Imaginary Museum , ed. 
 Barry Alpert. 
 Manchester: Carcanet New Press, 1977. 
 Six Notes on Ezra Pound 
 Ezra among the Edwardians 
 If I wanted to be pretentious, I might call this paper an investigation of the sociology of literature. 
 It is at any rate a sketch of what might be involved in restoring a writer &mdash; in this case, the young Pound &mdash; to the highly specific social milieu, that of Edwardian England, in which he moved and on which he impinged. 
 It is thus a contribution to biography, not to criticism. 
 Among Pound's associates in that vanished world, the most instructive figures, I'm inclined to think, are Frederic Manning and Allen Upward; but unfortunately we're still very far from recovering from oblivion the lineaments of either of these men. 
 (Recovering them is a matter of great urgency; and a start has been made, but there's a long way to go &mdash; especially with Upward, whom oblivion has enveloped with a completeness that is startling and significant.) 
 Since Manning and Upward are in this way for the moment denied us, I shall make do with two other names: Maurice Hewlett and Laurence Binyon. 
 And Hewlett is the one to start with, probably the best peg on which to hang a necessarily rash characterization of that literary world of late-Edwardian England which Fred Manning entered from Australia, and Pound from the United States. 
 Not that Hewlett was a representative figure, if by that we mean a sort of undistinguished average. 
 On the contrary he was taken to be something of a maverick and flutterer of dovecotes. 
 Or so it appears from the valuable memoirs of Mrs Belloc Lowndes, in chapter nine of her Merry Wives of Westminster : 
 On the whole he had a poor opinion of human nature, and he felt an angry contempt for politicians. 
 Indeed he was apt to take violent prejudices against certain men and women in public life with whom he was not personally acquainted. 
 On many a winter morning I jumped out of bed and put a letter of his in the fire, feeling it would be wrong to allow it to survive; and when some years ago I was asked by a distinguished man of letters if I could help him to write an account of Maurice 
 Hewlett, I rashly said I would send him some of the letters I had received from him. 
 But when I looked over those I had kept, I decided I could not do so. 
 If many of Hewlett's correspondents felt as Mrs Lowndes did, this explains why Hewlett's letters as edited by Laurence Binyon (1925) make such unexciting reading; she herself records that of the three hundred letters printed by Binyon there was only one &bquo;which I felt to be characteristic of the man I knew so well&equo;. 
 Binyon's volume does however bear out quite touchingly one point that Mrs Lowndes makes: that Hewlett's ambition was to be known as a poet rather than novelist, though it was his historical romances in Wardour Street prose that brought him fame and money. 
 (And some of those romances were set in medieval Aquitaine of the troubadours &mdash; which certainly constitutes one common interest that drew Pound and Hewlett together.) 
 Hewlett and Mrs Lowndes moved in the same influential circles. 
 And Pound was not above using his connection with Hewlett so as to get entry to those circles. 
 Thus in a letter to his father of 3 June 1913, all the names are of people who figure in Mrs Lowndes's memoirs: 
 We had a terribly literary dinner on Saturday. 
 Tagore, his son and daughter-in-law, Hewlett, May Sinclair, Prothero (edt. 
 Quarterly Rev .) 
 Evelyn Underhill (author of divers fat books on mysticism), D . 
 and myself. 
 The name to give us pause here is that of G.W. Prothero. 
 For Prothero is the demon-king of the Poundian pantomime, ever since Pound cast him for this role by printing, at the end of his essay on De Gourmont &mdash; originally in the Little Review , then in Instigations  (1920) &mdash; the letter which Prothero wrote him in October 1914: 
 Dear Mr. Pound, Many thanks for your letter of the other day. 
 I am afraid that I must say frankly that I do not think I can open the columns of the Q.R. &mdash; at any rate, at present &mdash; to any one associated publicly with such a publication as Blast . 
 It stamps a man too disadvantageously. 
 Yours truly, G.W. Prothero 
 Of course, having accepted your paper on the Noh , I could not refrain from publishing it. 
 But other things would be in a different category. 
 And Pound understandably gets all the mileage possible out of the ill-starred history of &bquo; QR &equo;: 
 I need scarcely say that The Quarterly Review  is one of the most profitable periodicals in England, and one of one's best &bquo;connections&equo;, or sources of income. 
 It has, of course, a tradition. 
 &bquo;It is not that Mr. Keats (if that be his real name, for we almost doubt that any man in his senses would put his real name to such a rhapsody)&equo; &mdash; wrote their Gifford of Keats' Endymion . 
 My only comment is that the Quarterly  has done it again. 
 Their Mr. A. Waugh is a lineal descendant of Gifford, by the way of mentality. 
 A century has not taught them manners. 
 In the eighteen-forties they were still defending the review of Keats. 
 And more recently Waugh has lifted up his senile slobber against Mr. Eliot. 
 It is indeed time that the functions of both English and American literature were taken over by younger and better men. 
 As for their laying the birch on my pocket, I compute that my support of Lewis and Brzeska has cost me at the lowest estimate about &pound;20 per year, from one source alone since that regrettable occurrence, since I dared to discern a great sculptor and a great painter in the midst of England's artistic desolaton. 
 (&bquo;European and Asiatic papers please copy.&equo;) 
 Waugh's &bquo;senile slobber&equo; against Eliot &mdash; he as good as called Eliot &bquo;a drunken helot&equo; &mdash; has been remarked on several times, notably in his son Evelyn's autobiography, A Little Learning . 
 Prothero the demon-king has never bounded on to the stage more sulphurously than in Hugh Kenner's The Pound Era : 
 Abstract and remote though the contents of Blast  might be, the establishment had bared its fangs and invoked its ultimate weapon, the boycott. 
 To men who lived on what they could pick up from articles and reviews, the ultimate weapon implied more than lack of a showcase: it implied starvation&hellip; 
 . Prothero was snarling like a guilty thing surprised. 
 Of what was he guilty? 
 Of reverence for death, or perhaps decorum&hellip; 
 . The long-term psychic damage Pound underwent is beyond calculation. 
 On the continent men were soon killing each other. 
 A third of a million Frenchmen died in the first five months&hellip; 
 Hugh Kenner doesn't need to be told how much I admire The Pound  Era . 
 Accordingly I ought to be able to say that at this stage his comments seem to me beside the point, or more exactly in excess of  it. 
 What with all this baring of fangs and of ultimate weapons, these snarlings and &bquo;long-term psychic damage&equo;, how is one to protest mildly that Prothero is &mdash; with an engagingly archaic elegance (&bquo;stamps a man too disadvantageously&equo;) &mdash; telling Pound that he needn't waste his time submitting manuscripts to the Quarterly Review  for the time being? 
 Would it have been more honourable for Prothero to let Pound go on submitting, when there was no hope of his being accepted? 
 It helps, I think, to take note of Conrad Aiken on &bquo;Ezra Pound: 1914&equo; ( Ezra Pound: Perspectives , ed. 
 Stock, 1965): 
 But it was typical of Pound's kindness, even to a potential enemy or rival, that he should have so persisted in trying to give me the right contacts. 
 Contacts: yes, these, as I was to discover, were of prime importance: they were part of the game . 
 And for Pound it was  a game, a super-chess game, and not without its Machiavellian elements. 
 For example, this was the summer of the famous Blast  dinner for the Vorticists, in which Wyndham Lewis was of course much involved. 
 Pound sent me a card, which I still have, naming place and date, and saying, rather peremptorily, &bquo;I think you had better take this in.&equo; 
 This put my back up. 
 I had no intention then, or ever after, of joining any group or &bquo;movement&equo; and I therefore sidestepped the Vorticists just as I sidestepped both the Imagists and the Amygists. 
 I didn't attend the dinner, for which in a way I'm now sorry, and Pound never forgot or forgave. 
 Nineteen years later, in an angry letter from Italy about some review I'd written which began: &bquo;Jesus Gawd Aiken, you poor blithering ass&equo; he concluded by saying: &bquo;I've never forgotten that you wouldn't go to the Blast  dinner.&equo; 
 It was a game, which Pound had played trickily and with zest When he joined in with Blast , he miscalculated and overplayed his hand. 
 And just that, nothing more, is what Prothero is telling him. 
 If the game was for high stakes, if Pound's livelihood was at stake, the more reason for playing the game circumspectly. 
 He didn't; and he paid the price. 
 What is there in this to evoke the shades of a third of a million dead Frenchmen? 
 Or to make a Lucifer figure out of G.W. Prothero? 
 It could be argued that Blast  was a miscalculation all round, even for Wyndham Lewis. 
 Certainly it was for Pound. 
 And Violet Hunt, loyally selling copies at half-price in her drawing room, confesses in her memoir I Have This to Say  that she was at a loss to explain why the damned were damned, and the blest were blest. 
 Among the  blest, &bquo;Lady Aberconway was put in to please me&equo;, and &bquo;Madame Strindberg, who ran the Club of the Golden Calf for the sake of the set, could hardly escape a favourable mention.&hellip;&equo; 
 But &bquo;Mrs Belloc Lowndes felt, I am sure, that she needed no blessings from anyone but her Church&equo;. 
 On the other hand, among those blasted, if one understood well enough about &bquo;Rabindranath Tagore, from whose recitations ad infinitum we all suffered a great deal about this time&equo;, why pick on Thomas Beecham, who at this time with the backing of Lady Cunard was embarking on a lifelong crusade for English opera? 
 Hugh Kenner veers unexpectedly into the idiom of the British schoolboy: &bquo; Blast  should have been a great lark&equo;. 
 But even a schoolboy's jape is supposed to have some ascertainable point; and Blast  had none. 
 As for Hewlett, how far he knew that he was being &bquo;used&equo; by Pound is what at this point no one can determine. 
 I'd guess that he knew, and didn't resent it. 
 For &bquo;the game&equo; was one that everyone played, and that was all right so long as you took your losses without squealing. 
 In any case it didn't preclude, on Pound's part, genuine affection. 
 As we see from Canto 74: 
 Lordly men are to earth o'ergiven 
 these the companions: 
 Fordie that wrote of giants 
 and William who dreamed of nobility 
 and Jim the comedian singing: 
 &bquo;Blarney castle me darlin' 
 you're nothing now but a stOWne&equo; 
 and Plarr talking of mathematics 
 or Jepson lover of jade 
 Maurie who wrote historical novels 
 and Newbolt who looked twice bathed 
 are to earth o'ergiven. 
 (432:459) 
 Later in the Pisan Cantos  (80/515:550) we read of &bquo;that Christmas at Maurie Hewlett's&equo; &mdash; Christmas 1911 in Hewlett's fifteenth-century house outside Salisbury &mdash; to which Pound was driven from Southampton across a tract of Hardy's Wessex which his imagination peopled with phantoms out of Under the Greenwood Tree . 
 Henry Newbolt was at this time Hewlett's neighbour in Wiltshire, and it seems to have been at this Christmas time that Hewlett took Pound to see Newbolt, who figures elsewhere in Canto 80: 
 &bquo;He stood&equo;, wrote Mr Newbolt, later Sir Henry, &bquo;the door behind&equo; and now they complain of cummings. 
 (507:541)  
 But the Pisan ordeal had shocked Pound into recovering a compassion and tenderness which we look for mostly in vain in the Pound of the years preceding. 
 And in the 1930s he had been unforgiving towards these friends of his youth. 
 In 1939, for instance, in an obituary of Ford for The Nineteenth Century and After , he had written of &bquo;the stilted language that then passed for &bquo;good English&equo; in the arthritic milieu that held control of the respected British critical circles, Newbolt, the backwash of Lionel Johnson, Fred Manning, the Quarterlies and the rest of &bquo;em&equo;. 
 And this echoed a letter of 1937 to Michael Roberts, extolling Ford and saying, &bquo;The old crusted lice and advocates of corpse language knew that The English Review  existed&equo;. 
 In Ezra Pound: The Image and the Real , Herbert Schneidau reasonably enough names three of the &bquo;crusted lice&equo; as Henry Newbolt, Frederic Manning, and G.W. Prothero, and with a proper scrupulousness he notes that all these &bquo;were treated with great deference in Pound's early letters and writings&equo;. 
 Schneidau follows Pound's own broad hints by tracing his gradual alienation or liberation from these early admirations according as Ford's demands for a prosaic strength in verse writing gradually won Pound over from the Wardour Street language of his own early poems (such as &bquo;Canzone: The Yearly Slain', written in reply to Manning's &bquo;Kor&egrave;&equo;). 
 The story is an intricate one, as Herbert Schneidau acknowledges; and Pound's holding out against Ford for the Dantesque principle of a &bquo;curial&equo; diction (see his introduction to the poems of Lionel Johnson) represents to my mind an objection that can still be raised to Ford's principles of diction, salutary as Ford's polemics undoubtedly were for Pound at this time. 
 Moreover Prothero, a historian, perhaps had no ideas about poetic diction one way or the other; Pound, as we have seen, thought himself victimized by Prothero not for anything to do with writing but for having championed Lewis the painter and Gaudier the sculptor. 
 All the same Schneidau's argument is just and illuminating, so far as it goes. 
 But does it go far enough? 
 It is worth looking again at Pound's letter to Michael Roberts, strident though it is. 
 Pound there, it is plain &mdash; for instance, in his comment on Hilaire Belloc &mdash; is as unwilling as any Marxist to abstract a question like the proper language for poetry from the whole social matrix and milieu in which such a subject may get itself debated. 
 Pound speaks of the &bquo;order of a pewked society&equo;. 
 And indeed it is, for us too, evasive and misleading to abstract the manageably limited issue from the larger one. 
 For instance, nothing is more likely than that Prothero, when he said that association with Blast  &bquo;stamped a man too disadvantageously&equo;, had in mind among other things Ford's connection with the magazine  and the scandal of Ford's relations with Violet Hunt &mdash; a scandal that had already made a breach between Violet Hunt and the cruelly timorous Henry James, as told painfully in I Have This to Say . 
 This is where Mrs Belloc Lowndes is so illuminating. 
 She writes well, though carelessly. 
 And in The Merry Wives of Westminster , knowing just what she is doing, she recreates a world as exotic as that of the Andaman Islanders: the world of cultured Edwardian London. 
 I am not concerned to defend that world; I am merely trying to understand it, and the rules by which it lived. 
 Some features of that world are nowadays entirely inscrutable &mdash; notably, what it was in Frederic Lowndes's self-effacing position on The Times  which gave him and his wife access to a society of international aristocracy and even royalty, and to the inner circles of the cabinet, as well as the society of novelists and playwrights. 
 What is clear is that this was all one  society, in which the wives &mdash; like Mrs Lowndes herself &mdash; wrote books or maintained salons, while their husbands were functionaries, some of them much in the public eye as ministers of the Crown, others &mdash; like Frederic Lowndes &mdash; no less influential and esteemed for operating under wraps, as grey eminences. 
 Barrie and Arnold Bennett, Hewlett and Henry James, were free of this society whenever they chose. 
 It was &bquo;the establishment&equo;, or one very thick and influential layer of it; but it certainly was not made up of stuffed shirts and Colonel Blimps along with their twittering wives. 
 Indeed, if we can suppress the automatic &bquo;liberal&equo; prejudice which indexes &bquo;Newbolt, Sir Henry (1862&ndash;1938)&equo; as &bquo;English imperialist poet&equo; (in Ezra Pound. 
 Penguin Critical Anthology , ed. 
 Sullivan), we have to acknowledge that it was in many ways an attractive society, and an admirable one. 
 That we are dealing with a privileged &eacute;lite goes without saying; as also that it depended on the institution of domestic service. 
 But there appears not to have been, for instance, any of that sterile rivalry between man and wife which is now the bane of middle-class society with any claims to cultural or intellectual interests; plainly Mrs Lowndes and the young matrons who were her friends did not seethe resentfully at having their intellectual and imaginative capacities shackled to kitchen and nursery, whereas their husbands could exercise theirs in the great world. 
 Moreover &mdash; and more to the point &mdash; if as literary intellectuals we feel frustrated at having no channel of access to the figures who exercise decision-making power in our societies, Mrs Lowndes shows us a society in which literary intelligence had direct access to such centres of power, by way of the conjugal bed as well as over the dinner table. 
 Pound &mdash; thanks to Hewlett probably more than anyone else &mdash; had, at the time of his dinner party for Hewlett and Prothero and the rest, the chance of moving into that society. 
 His espousal of Blast  closed to him just  those doors that were on the point of opening; and twenty years later, when he desperately wanted such access to the power-wielding centres of society, he was condemned to the world of fantasy in which he thought he could influence United States policy by way of such unlikely intermediaries as Senators Borah and Bankhead, and Italian policy by way of Ubaldo degli Uberti. 
 (This is not to say that Pound's decision was wrong. 
 For Eliot, who chose the other way, earned entry into nothing more seriously influential than the circles of Bloomsbury, where the Edwardian pattern survived only in an attenuated and largely illusory version.) 
 If we ask what it was about this society which made Pound and also Lewis affront it more or less deliberately, to ensure that its doors were closed to them, I think only one answer is possible: it was ineradicably vowed to the idea of the artist as the amateur. 
 It is true that Arnold Bennett, for one, refused to conform to that stereotype; and doubtless one could find other exceptions. 
 But it is plain than in Mrs Lowndes's society, writing, for instance, was conceived of as typically a spare-time activity. 
 It could not be otherwise if literary intelligence was to make itself available in drawing-rooms to administrative and political decision making. 
 That English tradition of the amateur is of course a long one, and by no means ignoble, reaching back as it does through John Morley to Walter Bagehot, to Burke, to Addison, and so all the way to Philip Sidney and the Renaissance all-round man. 
 But both Pound and Lewis were American or Americanized enough to have on the contrary a professional  attitude to their respective arts, in the quite precise sense that they saw the continuity of art traditions ensured by the atelier , the master instructing his prentices. 
 The renegade or maverick Englishmen with whom they allied themselves &mdash; Ford, and at another level A.R. 
 Orage &mdash; shared this un-English conviction and habit. 
 And this difference between them and such initially sympathetic Englishmen as Hewlett and Newbolt went very deep; for ultimately it meant that, when the question arose whether the artist's first responsibility was to his art (his trade ) or to his society, Pound and Lewis and Ford would opt for the first alternative, Hewlett and Newbolt for the second &mdash; as indeed we soon see them doing when both of them answer the call of First World War patriotism by writing moralebuilding poems and stories. 
 It is not hard to see that in Homage to  Sextus Propertius  Pound is centrally concerned with just this question, and is defending his own scale of priorities against Hewlett's or Newbolt's. 
 Something had certainly gone wrong &mdash; gone soft and mawkish &mdash; with the English tradition of the amateur, when we find Hewlett on facing pages of Binyon's volume of Letters , writing in 1916 to  E.V. 
 Lucas, &bquo;My Dear Lad, That will be jolly indeed&equo;, and to J.C. 
 Squire, &bquo;Dear Squire, I am very glad to have your quire of poetry&hellip; which is in jolly type and on jolly paper&hellip;.&equo; 
 It is not thus, one cannot help feeling, that the serious artist addresses a fellow practitioner. 
 And even before the War, though Hewlett in correspondence with Harold Monro and Newbolt could give and take hard knocks by way of semi-technical criticism, yet it is enveloped and emasculated by similarly anxious camaraderie. 
 Still, Newbolt at any rate was able to understand something of what was at stake. 
 In his &bquo;A Study of English poetry&equo;, which ran in The English Review  from March to June 1912, Newbolt refers to Pound as &bquo;a critic, who is himself a poet, and whom I always read with great interest&equo;. 
 Those who think of Pound as a great liberator from stiff and hidebound conventions will be disconcerted to find that Newbolt on the contrary treats him as an academic formalist. 
 Newbolt says: 
 The vast majority of what are generally called well-educated persons in this country have, in the very process of their education, been impressed with the belief that metre is an arrangement of language which can be judged by the application of a mechanical test, and that the poet who produces a line which does not answer to the test is a fit subject for correction by any critic who can point out the discrepancy. 
 It is true that we are more enlightened than we were; there is a public which has learnt to smile at the reviewer who declares that a line &bquo;will not scan&equo;, or that it contains a &bquo;trochee&equo; where it should have had an &bquo;iamb&equo;, without considering whether it was ever intended to &bquo;scan&equo;, or whether there is anything in English verse which can be treated as the absolute equivalent of a Greek or Latin trochee. 
 But&hellip; the fallacy does appear, in much subtler forms. 
 In the Poetry Review  for February, 1912, a critic, who is himself a poet, and whom I always read with great interest, speaks of the struggle &bquo;to find out what has been done, once and for all, better than it can ever be done again, and to find out what remains for us to do&equo;&hellip;. 
 But if every work of art is simply the expression of the artist's intuition, it is evident that an absolute or complete pattern would be useless, since the intuitions of two different minds could never be expressed by the same form: nor can anything in art be said to have been &bquo;done once for all&equo;, since if it were &bquo;done again&equo; by another hand &mdash; used, that is, to express the intuition of another spirit &mdash; it would be no longer what had been done before. 
 Newbolt's attitude is still very common &mdash; not only among the British  (especially those who have come under the influence of F. R. Leavis), but also among American free versifiers who think they are an avantgarde and who are muddled enough to think that they have Pound's authority to back them. 
 Whether they know it or not, they are in fact endorsing Henry Newbolt against Pound! 
 All the same, there is by and large a crucial difference here between British and American attitudes, and one that is today every bit as marked as it was in 1912. 
 For on nearly every American campus there is an atelier  in the shape of a &bquo;Creative Writing programme&equo;, whereas on no British campus is there any such thing, and indeed the British scoff at the mere possibility &mdash; on precisely the grounds that Newbolt here puts forward. 
 Pound's exasperated bewilderment before the spectacle of British loyalty to the amateur, and British readiness to pay the price in tolerance of the amateurish, is nowhere so evident as in his lifelong esteem for Laurence Binyon, the editor of the Hewlett Letters . 
 According to Noel Stock's Life , Pound first met Binyon in the second week of February 1909, and early in March he found &bquo;intensely interesting&equo; a lecture by Binyon on European and Oriental art, for which the lecturer had sent him a ticket. 
 Some time that year there occurred a famous meeting at the Vienna Caf&eacute;, in New Oxford Street near the British Museum, when Pound as Binyon's &bquo;bulldog&equo; met Wyndham Lewis as the &bquo;bulldog&equo; of T. Sturge Moore. 
 This, nearly forty years later, was celebrated in Canto 80: 
 Mr Lewis had been to Spain 
 Mr Binyon's young prodigies 
 pronounced the word: Penthesilea 
 There were mysterious figures 
 that emerged from recondite recesses 
 and ate at the WIENER CAFE 
 which died into banking, Jozefff may have followed 
 his emperor. 
 &bquo;It is the sons pent up within a man&equo;, 
 mumbled old Neptune 
 &bquo;Laomedon, Ahi, Laomedon&equo; 
 or rather three &bquo;ahis&equo; before the &bquo;Laomedon&equo; 
 &bquo;He stood&equo; wrote Mr Newbolt, later Sir Henry, 
 &bquo;the door behind&equo; and now they complain of cummings. 
 So it is to Mr Binyon that I owe, initially, 
 Mr Lewis, Mr P. Wyndham Lewis. 
 His bull-dog, me, 
 as it were against old Sturge M's bull-dog, 
 Mr T. Sturge Moore's 
 bull-dog, et 
 meum est propositum, it is my intention 
 in tabernam, or was, to the Wiener cafe 
 you cannot yet buy one dish of Chinese food in all Italy 
 hence the debacle 
 &bquo;forloyn&equo; said Mr Bridges (Robert) 
 &bquo;we'll get &bquo;em all back&equo; 
 meaning archaic words&hellip;. 
 (506:540) 
 For &bquo;prodigies&equo; (&bquo;Mr Binyon's young prodigies&equo;) surely we ought to read &bquo;prot&eacute;g&eacute;s&equo;; and then it becomes possible to wonder whether the jocularity about bulldogs doesn't mark a wistful or resentful sense that Binyon and Sturge Moore (&bquo;old Neptune&equo;) might have done more with their respective prot&eacute;g&eacute;s than merely set them to sniff and snarl at each other's heels; to question whether the two senior writers could not have established themselves &mdash; at least for some purposes &mdash; as masters of ateliers  in which the two young hopefuls might have enrolled as apprentices. 
 Instead, the outcome of what seems to have been an uncomfortable occasion was merely that Pound and Lewis took that much longer to find out that they were natural allies. 
 It was probably on this occasion that Binyon said something that Pound, misdating the event 1908, recalled in the postscript to a letter to Binyon in 1934: 
 I wonder if you are using (in lectures) a statement I remember you making in talk, but not so far as I can recall, in print. 
 &bquo;Slowness is beauty&equo;, which struck me as very odd in 1908 (when I certainly did not believe it) and has stayed with me ever since &mdash; shall we say as proof that you violated British habit; and thought of it. 
 Who  thought of it? 
 Binyon, or Pound? 
 Hugh Kenner is no doubt right to suppose that it was Pound who had been thinking of it. 
 For it crops up in the Rock-Drill  Canto 87, in the 1950s: 
 Only sequoias are slow enough. 
 BinBin &bquo;is beauty.&equo; 
 &bquo;Slowness is beauty.&equo; 
 (572:608) 
 The mingled exasperation and admiration that Pound felt for  Binyon are nowhere so explicit and appealing as in what he wrote for Blast  (July, 1915), so as to introduce into that inappropriately vociferous context nine quotations from the demure prose of Binyon's The Flight of the Dragon. 
 An Essay on the Theory and Practice  of Art in China and Japan  (London, 1911): 
 We regret that we cannot entitle this article &bquo;Homage to Mr Lawrence (sic) Binyon,&equo; for Mr Binyon has not sufficiently rebelled. 
 Manifestly he is not one of the ignorant. 
 He is far from being one of the outer world, but in reading his work we constantly feel the influence upon him of his reading of the worst English poets. 
 We find him in a disgusting attitude of respect towards predecessors whose intellect is vastly inferior to his own. 
 This is loathesome (sic). 
 Mr Binyon has thought; he has plunged into the knowledge of the East and extended the borders of occidental knowledge, and yet his mind constantly harks back to some folly of nineteenth century Europe. 
 We can see him as it were constantly restraining his inventiveness, constantly trying to conform to an orthodox view against which his thoughts and emotions rebel, constantly trying to justify Chinese intelligence by dragging it a little nearer to some Western precedent. 
 Ah well Mr Binyon has, indubitably, his moments. 
 Very few men do have any moments whatever, and for the benefit of such readers as have not sufficiently respected Mr Binyon for his, it would be well to set forth a few of them. 
 They are found in his &bquo;flight of the Dragon&equo;, a book otherwise unpleasantly marred by his recurrent respect for inferior, very inferior people. 
 It isn't hard to see here, once again, Pound's baffled exasperation that, instead of setting up shop as ma&icirc;tre d'&eacute;cole , &bquo;the very learned British Museum assistant&equo; should resolutely duck back into doing such a worthy and humane but undoubtedly over-modest activity as editing such of the letters of his old friend Hewlett as could not conceivably give offence. 
 Yet Binyon knew the unformulated rules of the society that he moved in, and played the game consistently as the amateur that that society required him to be. 
 It is true to this day in England that, if one has learning, one must wear it so lightly that it is unnoticeable. 
 It would be tedious to quote and consider every one of the tributes that Pound paid to Binyon. 
 One is at the end of Gaudier-Brzeska  (1916); another is in a Criterion  article of 1937, &bquo;D'Artagnan Twenty Years After&equo;; in that year appeared Polite Essays , which includes Pound's review of Binyon's translation of the Inferno  (originally  in The Criterion  for April 1934); there are two tributes to Binyon in Guide to Kulchur  (1938); in 1948 at St Elizabeth's Pound was still pressing Binyon on the attention of Charles Olson; and as late as 1958 he took the opportunity of Pavannes and Divagations  to get back into print his appreciative note on The Flight of the Dragon . 
 None of these items is without interest. 
 But &bquo;Hell&equo;, the review of Binyon's Inferno , is particularly important; for it may well be one of the most careful and illuminating acts of criticism that Pound ever performed. 
 It includes this passage: 
 I do not expect to see another version as good as Binyon's&hellip; 
 Few men of Binyon's position and experience have tried or will try the experiment. 
 You cannot counterfeit forty years' honest work, or get the same result by being a clever young man who prefers vanilla to orange or heliotrope to lavender perfume. 
 &bquo;La sculpture n'est pas pour les jeunes hommes.&equo; 
 (Brancusi) 
 A younger generation, or at least a younger American generation, has been brought up on a list of acid tests, invented to get rid of the boiled oatmeal consistency of the bad verse of 1900, and there is no doubt that many young readers seeing Binyon's inversions, etc., will be likely to throw down the translation under the impression that it is incompetent. 
 The fact that this idiom, which was never spoken on sea or land, is NOT fit for use in the new poetry of 1933&ndash;4 does not mean that it is unfit for use in a translation of a poem finished in 1321. 
 Pound may be right or wrong about the merits of Binyon's version, as about the sorts of language that are acceptable in verse translation; what is certain is that he's here applying to diction a sort of sliding scale or set of variable standards such as Ford's principles didn't allow for. 
 At any rate, Pound's enthusiasm for Binyon's version had led him to re-open correspondence with Binyon. 
 And a letter of 30 August 1934 is particularly interesting, since it is rather plainly a reply to protests from Binyon about Pound's contemptuous treatment of Rubens. 
 Pound's humility under Binyon's supposed rebuke is very striking: 
 Dear L.B: When one has finally done the job and found the mot juste , I dare say violent language usually disappears. 
 Rubens' technique (at least in one painting about 4 ft. square)  is not stupid. 
 I dare say I damned him, for the whole grovelling imbecility of french court life from the death of Francois premier to the last fat slob that was guillotined. 
 &hellip; And my use of &bquo;idiotic&equo; is loose. 
 You are quite right about that. 
 Have always been interested in intelligence, escaped the germy epoch of Freud and am so bored with all  lacks of intelletto that I haven't used any discrimination when I have referred to &bquo;em&hellip;. 
 If, as I'm inclined to believe, this unwonted willingness to kiss the rod represents one last offer by Pound (at this time, aged forty-eight!) to enrol in Binyon's seminar if Binyon would only call it into being, Binyon once again knew better than to understand what Pound was driving at. 
 Oddly enough, the last word &mdash; though a mournful one &mdash; can be with Maurice Hewlett. 
 For in 1920, when Binyon began work towards his version of the Inferno , he exchanged letters with Hewlett, who had translated the first canto years before, and now urged Binyon to shorten his measure to tetrameters, pointing out that this was what he himself had done in his &bquo;Song of the Plough&equo;, a long poem in terza rima in which he had invested a great deal. 
 Hewlett remarked: &bquo;Another thing: putting in eights compels the terseness of Dante, wh. amounts sometimes to a vice in him. 
 Still, there it is, and you must reproduce it&equo;. 
 How could Binyon have failed to remember this, when Pound complimented him by saying, &bquo;He has carefully preserved all the faults of his original&equo;? 
 In Guide to Kulchur  (chapter 30) Pound was to say, again with Binyon's translation specifically in mind, &bquo;Honest work has its reward in the arts if no other where&equo;. 
 How one would like that to be true! 
 But turning over the pages of poor Hewlett's unreadable but honest &bquo;Song of the Plough&equo;, one wonders about that. 
 One does indeed.  
 Paideuma  5: 1 (1976). 
 Ezra Pound Abandons the English 
 Ezra Pound's long love affair with England, and his angry and wounded turning against her in 1917 or 1918, cannot of course bulk so large in an American's sense of him as in an Englishman's. 
 It is an American, Herbert Schniedau, who has asked: 
 Can any man who identifies himself with the British world of letters, however independent and tolerant he may be, write a fair-minded book about Pound? 
 What Pound did to English literature and British sensibilities doesn't seem forgivable, and I really think that the English were more offended by Pound's political obsessions than were the countrymen he ostensibly betrayed. 
 This is fair comment; and the last clause in particular is, surprisingly, manifestly true, explain it how we may. 
 And yet an Englishman's relation to English culture and its traditions may be more tormented than Schniedau allows for, especially if the Englishman in question defines himself as, or aspires to be, an English artist . 
 Such a one may feel that Pound's &bquo;writing off&equo; of England, his abandonment of her &mdash; physically in 1920, in imagination some years earlier &mdash; was abundantly justified, to the extent indeed that it was not so much his justified rejection of her, as her  unjustifiable rejection of him . 
 And yet such an Englishman must wonder: Was there once virtue in England, which subsequently went out of her? 
 If so, when did this happen? 
 In the casualty lists from the Battle of the Somme? 
 (Or is that merely rhetoric?) 
 And can the virtue that thus went out of the spiritual reality called England ever be restored? 
 Has there been such a restoration, since 1920? 
 If so, when did it happen? 
 And if not, when will it ever happen? 
 When, and how? 
 These are serious and painful questions. 
 At all events there are Englishmen who find them so. 
 To take one example out of many, the native Englishman D. H. Lawrence reached just the same conclusion  as Pound at just the same time, and Lawrence's letters record it; he concluded, just as Pound did, that England after the First World War was, for the artist, uninhabitable. 
 The names of Robert Graves, W.H. Auden, and Christopher Isherwood may serve to remind us of English writers who seem to have reached the same dismaying conclusion over the years since. 
 However that may be, there are reasons for thinking that the abandonment of England, and of any hopes for her, was not much less momentous for Pound than it is for his English readers. 
 After all, Pound had married  England &mdash; not figuratively, but literally, in the person of Dorothy Shakespear; and Ben Hecht in 1918 reported that Pound was &bquo;a doting monogamist&equo;. 
 It didn't last; his alienation from England seems to have coincided with an alienation from Dorothy, for within five years he had a child by Olga Rudge. 
 And this is not altogether surprising; for Dorothy Pound seems to have been English in a singularly entire and uncompromising fashion. 
 The daughter of Olivia Shakespear, who had been briefly Yeats's mistress and had bought Wyndham Lewis's canvases and Gaudier's drawings, Dorothy told Hugh Kenner in 1965, &bquo;I read poetry only with difficulty. 
 I never did much care for it&equo;. 
 She said also, recalling Pound translating Noh plays on their honeymoon at Stone Cottage in Sussex, &bquo;I was not then preoccupied with plays and characters. 
 I was trying to make out what sort of creature I was going to be living with&equo;. 
 Moreover, Dorothy's Englishness was centuries old: among her cousins was one Charles Talbot &mdash; &bquo;one of the Shakespear names&equo;, she said &mdash; who owned a medieval abbey, &bquo;and once Ezra and I crawled over the roof in a turret to see a copy of the Magna Charta, kept there in a glass case&equo;. 
 In 1945, in an American prison camp near pisa, Pound remembered that (Canto 80): 
 To watch a while from the tower 
 where dead flies lie thick over the old charter 
 forgotten, oh quite forgotten 
 but confirming John's first one, 
 and still there if you climb over attic rafters; 
 to look at the fields; are they tilled? 
 is the old terrace live as it might be 
 with a whole colony 
 if money be free again? 
 Chesterton's England of has-been and why-not, 
 or is it all rust, ruin, death duties and mortgages 
 and the great carriage yard empty 
 and more pictures gone to pay taxes 
 When a dog is tall but 
 not so tall as all that 
 that dog is a Talbot 
 (a bit long in the pasterns?) 
 When a butt is &frac12; as tall as a whole butt 
 That butt is a small butt 
 Let backe and side go bare 
 and the old kitchen left as the monks had left it 
 and the rest as time has cleft it. 
 (Only shadows enter my tent 
 as men pass between me and the sunset)&hellip; 
 If, as Hugh Kenner believes, Pound never ceased to love Dorothy even while he loved Olga, this is surely part of what he loved in her, an aspect of what she meant to him; and so Pound's feelings for and about England were, right to the end, not much less tormented than any English reader's can be. 
 And the English reader who does not understand that the punning on &bquo;Talbot&equo; is painful and all but hysterical, like the punning of Shakespeare's Hamlet, does not understand Pound at all. 
 As for Dorothy's loyalty, it proved equal to any occasion; and in particular through the years of Pound's incarceration in St Elizabeth's her devotion was exemplary. 
 Certainly she was no philistine, but a graphic artist herself. 
 And yet&hellip; 
 &bquo;I read poetry only with great difficulty. 
 I never did much care for it&equo;. 
 It is at any rate possible that in her a certain ethical rightness and decency coexisted with aesthetic stiffness and suspicion. 
 It was a not uncommon combination in a certain breed of Englishman and Englishwoman &mdash; a breed perhaps now vanished, which is not to say, improved upon. 
 As for Canto 80, it continues, and closes upon, &bquo;the matter of England: 
 beyond the castern barbed wire 
 a sow with mine boneen 
 matronly as any duchess at Claridge's 
 and for that Christmas at Maurie Hewlett's 
 Going out from Southampton 
 they passed the car by the dozen 
 who would not have shown weight on a scale 
 riding, riding 
 for Noel the green holly 
 Noel, Noel, the green holly 
 A dark night for the holly 
 That would have been Salisbury plain, 
 and I have not thought of 
 the Lady Anne for this twelve years 
 Nor of Le Portel 
 How tiny the panelled room where they stabbed him 
 In her lap, almost, La Stuarda 
 Si tuit li dolh ehl planh el marrimen 
 for the leopards and broom plants 
 Tudor indeed is gone and every rose, 
 Blood-red, blanch-white that in the sunset glows 
 Cries: &bquo;Blood, Blood, Blood!&equo; against the gothic stone 
 Of England, as the Howard or Boleyn knows. 
 Nor seeks the carmine petal to infer; 
 Nor is the white bud Time's inquisitor 
 Probing to know if its new-gnarled root 
 Twists from York's head or belly of Lancaster; 
 Or if a rational soul should stir, perchance, 
 Within the stem or summer shoot to advance 
 Contrition's utmost throw, seeking in thee 
 But oblivion, not thy forgiveness, FRANCE. 
 as the young lizard extends his leopard spots 
 along the grass-blade seeking the green midge 
 half an ant-size 
 and the Serpentine will look just the same 
 and the gulls be as neat on the pond 
 and the sunken garden unchanged 
 and God knows what else is left of our London 
 my London, your London 
 and if her green elegance 
 remains on this side of my rain ditch 
 puss lizard will lunch on some other T-bone 
 sunset grand couturier. 
 &bquo;That Christmas&equo; (not that it matters) was Christmas 1911, which Pound spent as a guest of Maurice Hewlett's at the Old Rectory,  Broad Chalke, Salisbury &mdash; a house which had once been a nunnery, dating back to 1487. 
 Hewlett, author of The Queen's Quair , brings to mind another writer who had similarly concerned himself with Mary Queen of Scots (&bquo;La Stuarda&equo;) &mdash; that is to say, Swinburne in his Mary Stuart . 
 Swinburne is alluded to, here as elsewhere, by the place-name &bquo;Le Portel&equo;, where &mdash; so Pound seems to have believed (wrongly, for the name is &bquo;Yport&equo;) &mdash; Swinburne on a famous occasion was saved from drowning by French fishermen. 
 At Holyrood House in Edinburgh one is still shown the room where Rizzio was stabbed &bquo;in her lap almost&equo;. 
 The line in Proven&ccedil;al is from Bertran de Born's &bquo;Planh for the Young English King&equo;, which Pound had translated splendidly as early as 1909. 
 The &bquo;leopards and broom plants&equo;, Plantagenet emblems, signify the dynastic reasons for which Henry the young king was killed, as were Rizzio and Mary's husband Darnley centuries later. 
 Anyone is free to decide that life is too short for such unriddlings; others (I speak from experience) may develop a taste for them. 
 A more important point is that passages of this sort, spliced as they are with images like the lizard from the immediate foreground of Pound's tent inside the wire-mesh cage of the prison camp, do not come into being out of the free associations of idle reverie, though in these Pisan cantos Pound exploits the illusion of that, as Joyce did in Ulysses  when he pretended to transport himself and us into the mind of Leopold Bloom. 
 The reason we are reminded of these historical episodes, rather than any of a hundred others, comes clear only with the surprising and congested line that closes the quatrains about the Wars of the Roses: &bquo;But oblivion, not thy forgiveness, FRANCE&equo;. 
 The England that Pound mourns the loss of is, as it had been for him from the first, an integral province of western Europe, sharing a common culture with France and always reaching out, through France, to the shores of the Mediterranean. 
 This emphasis will not commend itself to the English reader whom Herbert Schniedau envisages. 
 Such a reader is likely to define his Englishness as precisely that which continental Europe is not. 
 And in fact, of recent years Dickens's Mr Podsnap has walked again, cherishing insularity as a patriotic duty. 
 But of course there are other things in this passage which will put English teeth on edge. 
 Colonel Blimp today is likely to be a Roundhead colonel, in his professed sentiments a Leveller, though not of course in his practices. 
 And his egalitarianism will be offended by &bquo;the great carriage yard empty&equo;, and by &bquo;more pictures gone to pay taxes&equo;. 
 Especially as voiced by an  American who had disloyally taken the wrong side in a war just successfully completed &bquo;for democracy&equo;, the sentiments must have seemed &mdash; in 1948, when The Pisan Cantos  appeared &mdash; nothing short of shameless! 
 An English writer who went into self-exile just when Pound and Lawrence did, Ford Madox Ford, had always been denied serious consideration (as he is denied it still), in part for having, in No More Parades  at the end of a previous war, envisaged the England he was leaving in just such manorial terms: and if the Englishman could not be forgiven, how forgive the American? 
 (Lawrence, it is true, envisaged the England he  was relinquishing very largely in the image of Garsington Manor; but then, Lawrence's origins are so impeccably proletarian that the aberration can be overlooked!) 
 And then there is the insolence of the last line: &bquo;sunset grand couturier&equo;. 
 Isn't that the giveaway? 
 It will certainly seem so to the Englishman (as I take him to be), who found in the &bquo;Envoi&equo; to Hugh Selwyn  Mauberley  &mdash; Pound's most explicit farewell to England, as he prepared to leave her in 1918 &mdash; &bquo;externality: an externality which, considering what Mauberley  attempts, is utterly disabling&equo;. 
 This is the same reader who, having decided that the &bquo;Envoi&equo; is &bquo; literary , in a limiting sense&equo;, is provoked by the word &bquo;magic&equo; in the middle stanza into deciding that &bquo;the term &bquo;literary&equo; becomes a good deal more limiting, for the term &bquo;aesthetic&equo; rises to our lips, and so, perhaps, does &bquo;American&equo; ' And there we have it! 
 For this sort of Englishman, &bquo;externality, &mdash; to things English &mdash; is what any American is condemned to; and per contra &bquo;inwardness&equo; &mdash; with things English &mdash; is what an Englishman quite simply has, painlessly, as a birthright. 
 From this point of view, the only good American is one who stays shamefacedly mute about his English cousins, however many years he may have lived among them. 
 The same rule does not hold, it will be noticed, when there is any question of Englishmen talking about Americans. 
 The comment I have been quoting from appeared in 1965. 
 The vocabulary is different from the comments of fifty years earlier which wounded and infuriated Pound, and drove him out of England, but the sentiments are identical. 
 And indeed even the vocabulary is  sometimes the same. 
 The horrifying thing about, for instance, Robert Nichols's review in the Observer  for 11 January 1920 &mdash; &bquo;Mr Pound, indeed, serves his lobster &acirc; l'Am&eacute;ricaine&equo; &mdash; is that it could perfectly well have appeared in the Observer  last Sunday. 
 It is entirely possible to think that if &bquo;literary&equo; and &bquo;aesthetic&equo; are words that go naturally with &bquo;American&equo; but not with &bquo;English&equo;, so much the worse for the English. 
 Ah, but we mean &bquo;literary&equo; &mdash; presumably &bquo;aesthetic&equo; also &bquo;in a limiting sense&equo;. 
 Yet from those English lips which utter this face-saving locution, one has yet to hear the words uttered in any sense that is not  &bquo;limiting&equo;. 
 And from a set of preconceptions like that there is no way into Pound's universe at all. 
 As regards &bquo;externality&equo;, for instance, Pound may be thought to admit the charge, and to glory in it. 
 for he applauded Wyndham Lewis's alter ego in Tarr , when the latter explained that it is a condition of art &bquo; to have no  inside, nothing you cannot see. 
 It is not something impelled like a machine by a little egoistic inside&equo;; and again, &bquo;deadness, in the limited sense in which we use that word, is the first condition of art. 
 The second is absence of soul , in the sentimental human sense. 
 The lines and masses of a statue are its soul&equo;. 
 Between a limiting  sense (for &bquo;literary&equo;) and a limited  sense (for &bquo;deadness&equo;), we are here navigating in light and tricky airs. 
 And Pound had later to explain what he meant, and what he did not  mean, by his endorsement of Lewis. 
 After all, he was later to applaud Hardy's poetry for having precisely, &bquo;the insides&equo;. 
 Yet he never retracted this avowal; nor &mdash; given what he meant by it &mdash; did he need to. 
 The clue to what he meant is the last sentence from Lewis: &bquo;The lines and masses of a statue are its soul&equo;. 
 That &bquo;inwardness&equo; so prized by some English readers, and characteristically found by them (implausibly) in Lawrence, is an attention directed so far &bquo;inward, that it can never come to the surface for long enough to notice how the sunlight breaks upon the edges and volumes of a piece of sculpture; and that is why indeed such readers cannot use the word &bquo;aesthetic&equo; except &bquo;in a limiting sense&equo;. 
 Accordingly, the most instructive gloss on &bquo;externality&equo; is to be found where we might expect it, in Pound's 1916 memoir of the sculptor, Gaudier-Brzeska, where he writes of Gaudier and Lewis and other &bquo;vorticists&equo;, painters, and sculptors: 
 These new men have made me see form, have made me more conscious of the sky where it juts down between houses, of the bright patterns of sunlight which the bath water throws up on the ceiling, of the great &bquo;Vs&equo; of light that dart through  the chinks over the curtain rings, all these are new chords, new keys of design. 
 It is in this profoundly grateful and reverent sene, certainly not with any heartless flippancy, that forty years later in the prison stockade Pound greets the sunset as a designer &mdash; &bquo;grand couturier&equo;. 
 Plainly the man who wrote this was the man who in Hugh Selwyn Mauberley  took as his model and master Gautier, who described himself proudly as a man &bquo;pour qui le monde visible existe&equo;. 
 But the English reader has a label ready to tie on to Theophile Gautier; and by this time we can guess what is written on it &mdash; &bquo;arid aestheticism&equo;. 
 When Schniedau says, &bquo;What Pound did to English literature and British sensibilities doesn't seem forgivable&equo;, he doubtless has in mind certain passages from How to Read , which was originally addressed to the American readers of the New York Herald Tribune  Books  on 13, 20, and 27 January 1929. for instance: 
 The Britons have never shed barbarism; they are proud to tell you that Tacitus said the last word about Germans. 
 When Mary Queen of Scots went to Edinburgh she bewailed going out among savages, and she herself went from a sixteenthcentury court that held but a barbarous, or rather a drivelling and idiotic and superficial travesty of the Italian culture as it had been before the debacle of 1527. 
 The men who tried to civilize these shaggy and uncouth marginalians by bringing them news of civilization have left a certain number of translations that are better reading today than are the works of the ignorant islanders who were too Proud to translate. 
 Whereupon Pound applauds, as he had done before and was to do again, Gavin Douglas's translation of Virgil and Arthur Golding's and Marlowe's translations of Ovid. 
 Again (where Pound's addressing himself to Americans is especially evident): 
 We are so encumbered by having British literature in our foreground that&hellip; one must speak of it in disproportion. 
 It was kept alive during the last century by a series of exotic injections. 
 Swinburne read Greek and took English metric in hand; Rossetti brought in the Italian primitives; Fitzgerald made the only good poem of the time that has gone to the PeoPle; it is called, and is to a great extent, a translation or mistranslation. 
 There was a faint waft of early French influence. 
 Morris  translated sagas, the Irish took over the business for a few years; Henry James led, or rather preceded, the novelists, and then the Britons resigned en bloc ; the language is now in the keeping of the Irish (Yeats and Joyce); apart from Yeats, since the death of Hardy, poetry is being written by Americans. 
 All the developments in English verse since 1910 are due almost wholly to Americans. 
 In fact, there is no longer any reason to call it English verse, and there is no present reason to think of England at all. 
 This is unfair? 
 Yes, of course it is. 
 Elsewhere in How to Read  Pound remembers Landor and Browning, and has to make special provision to exempt them from these strictures. 
 Moreover, when Pound revised and expanded How to Read , to make ABC of Reading  (1934), he obliquely admitted the unfairness of these passages. 
 But they are not manifestly  unfair; there is a case to answer. 
 We English have never answered the case, because we have refused to recognize that the case was ever made. 
 And so the case against us has gone by default. 
 Among serious writers and readers in the United States (as distinct from shallow and modish Anglophiles mostly around New York), it is taken for granted that Pound's caustic dismissal of us in 1929 was justified, and that nothing has happened in the forty-five years since to alter that picture significantly. 
 Hugh Kenner, for instance, in a work of massive scholarship, The Pound Era  (1971), can write: &bquo;By the mid-1920s a massive triviality, a failure of will on a truly forbidding scale, was allowing English culture to lapse into shapes characterized by childishness, self-indulgence, utter predictability&equo;. 
 And throughout Kenner's book &bquo;English&equo; is taken to imply arrogant obtuseness, complacent inertia, and effeminate enervation. 
 If we resent this (as we should), we ought to realize that it is we who are to blame for it. 
 For neither Kenner nor Pound is a professional or obsessive Anglophobe. 
 Both men are reporting what seem to them the facts of the case, and they are the more confident about doing so because no Englishman has arisen to rebut their arguments. 
 For us to respond with sneering anti-Americanism is the merest childishness. 
 After this, Pound's relations with England and the English were for the most part an aspect of his relations with that one of his erstwhile prot&eacute;g&eacute;s who had become, surprisingly, a pillar of the English establishment &mdash; Eliot, editor of the Criterion . 
 And these negotiations are mostly conducted in a tone of high comedy; after 1930 Pound's anger is virtually monopolized by Roosevelt's USA, and English culture is for him just something that he can't take seriously. 
 This does not prevent him from honouring English  writing when it is honourable; for instance Binyon's Dante, Rouse's Homer, the early books of Adrian Stokes, and the poems of Basil Bunting. 
 But the preferred tone is one of indulgent banter. 
 (And at the risk of labouring the obvious, let it be said that Pound is often a very funny writer, in verse and prose alike.) 
 If the English reader doesn't like this, let him ask himself if Housman's Name and Nature  of Poetry , or &mdash; touching as it is, and as Pound acknowledges &mdash; the career of Harold Monro, is not treated with as much compassionate indulgence as possible in the Criterion  articles by Pound which he reprinted in Polite Essays  (1937). 
 Still more to the point is another essay in that volume, &bquo;Mr Eliot s Solid Merit&equo; (originally in the New English Weekly  for 12 July 1934). 
 Considering that this was written at a time when Pound's reputation was eclipsed as Eliot's rose towards the zenith, the generosity of this essay, its lack of rancour, is admirable. 
 And Pound's generosity towards Eliot did not fail through subsequent decades, when nothing was more common among the English intelligentsia, especially the academic part of it, than to assail Pound with weapons picked from Eliot's armoury. 
 This strategy is still in high favour among us. 
 It consists of making categorical and systematic certain distinctions made, and preferences expressed, by Eliot in his essays; and then dismissing Pound merely because he writes with a measure of respect of certain writers (Swinburne is one example) on whom Eliot, the arbiter of taste, is supposed to have conclusively turned down his thumbs. 
 At its most ludicrous, this makes the &bquo;Envoi&equo; to Hugh Selwyn  Mauberley  suspect, or worse than suspect, simply because it alludes to Edmund Waller, whereas the okay authors from Waller's period, among pedestrian readers of Eliot's essays, are taken to be Donne and Marvell. 
 Eliot, needless to say, never countenanced these devious manoeuvres. 
 We should now be in a position to answer Herbert Schniedau's question: &bquo;Can any man who identifies himself with the British world of letters&hellip; write a fair-minded book about Pound?&equo; 
 The answer is: Yes, this can be done, and it has been  done &mdash; by G.S. 
 Fraser, for one. 
 If the English writer stops short of uncritical adulation, and also has a longer memory than the Americans for the loathsome politics that Pound was infected by, that is all to the good. 
 There are  British Poundians, and they are among the best. 
 If there are few of them, we have seen why. 
 It is because trying to give credit to this great poet commits a patriotic Englishman (or Scotsman for that matter &mdash; Fraser is a Scot) to very tormenting and unwelcome questions and reflections about the spiritual state of England or Scotland today, and over the last fifty years. 
 It is therefore inevitable that our Poundians will be exceptions, and that majority opinion for the foreseeable  future will be more or less hysterically hostile to Pound. 
 This would not matter so much if Pound had not been a great technical innovator in verse writing. 
 Because the British world of letters as a whole has refused, and still refuses, to consider Pound temperately, it refuses to acknowledge &mdash; indeed, it cannot even understand  &mdash; the poetic forms that Pound invented, or the principles of form which he enunciated. 
 And in saying this, one has in mind not the Cantos  but the much more straightforward and generally serviceable forms which Pound put into currency in collections like Ripostes  (1912) and Lustra  (1916). 
 One thinks, for instance, of imagism, and of the treatment which the TLS  meted out to Peter Jones's anthology of imagist poetry. 
 In short, what happens is that in England &mdash; and here one does  mean England, rather than Scotland or Ireland &mdash; the non-academic makers and moulders of literary opinion are judging poetry by standards which are sixty years out-of-date. 
 The rest of the world surveys this spectacle with amused disbelief.  
 Poetry Nation  (Manchester) no. 4 (1975) 
 Pound and The Exile  
 If we look at Pound in 1927 and 1928, when he instituted from or through Paris his periodical, The Exile , and sustained it through four issues, we get the impression of a man yawing about without direction, as at no time either earlier or later in his career. 
 The very pages of his own magazine express the discernibly patronizing indulgence that it seems the American expatriate community extended to him. 
 Robert McAlmon, writing reportage in The Exile  number 2, noted: &bquo;At the Stryx, I found Ezra Pound talking to an English girl, and describing America as it never was, is not, and never will be. 
 I was glad to see Ezra, because what biased attitudes he has are so biased that he manages to be, all round, a more generous-minded and discriminating person that others who spread their capacity for bias over their entire mental outlook&equo;. 
 This is certainly not the language that one uses of a resident sage or recognized &bquo;master&equo;; and it seems that in Paris at that time there was in fact no one who esteemed Pound in either of those ways. 
 For just this reason the issues of The Exile , though they provide only conflicting evidence about Pound's acumen as an editor, are very instructive about the cast of his sensibility. 
 Particularly interesting is the fact that, after backing so many winners, Pound in The  Exile  backed unmistakably at least one loser. 
 This was Ralph Cheever Dunning, whose &bquo;Threnody in Sapphics&equo; appeared in The  Exile  number 2, and was strenuously defended by Pound in number 3: 
 My present feeling is that any one who cannot feel the beauty of their melody had better confine his criticism to prose and leave the discussion of verse to those who understand something about it&hellip;. 
 It still seems to me that the acting critics of poesy are for the most part incapable of looking for more than one thing at a time, having got started about 1913 (I mean a few of &bquo;em got started about 1913 and a lot have started since) to look for a certain plainness and directness of speech and simple order of words; and having about 1918 got started  looking for Mr Eliot's rather more fragile system (a system excellent for Mr Eliot but not very much use to any one else), they now limit their criticism to inquiring whether or no verse conforms to one or other of these manners, thereby often omitting to notice fundamentals, or qualities as important as verbal directness and even more important than &bquo;snap&equo;. 
 The meaning of &bquo;snap&equo; in relation to Eliot's &bquo;rather more fragile system&equo; is at this date, I suppose, irrecoverable; but the general drift of these remarks is clear. 
 And this is not the only place in The Exile  where Pound shows himself restive inside the image of himself that had been built up among initiates by his propaganda of fifteen years before, when he had taken over &bquo;imagism&equo; and championed Ford Madox Ford's ideas about a diction for poetry that should be &bquo;plain&equo; and &bquo;direct&equo;. 
 At the end of this same issue of The Exile  there appears from Pound a page headed &bquo;Desideria&equo;: 
 Quite simply: I want a new civilization. 
 We have the basis for a new poetry, and for a new music. 
 But this ringing declaration is no sooner issued than it has to be qualified virtually out of existence. 
 In the first place, 
 I say new civilization, I don't know that I care  about its being so very different from the best that has been, but it must be as good  as the best that has been. 
 And secondly, much more to our present purposes: 
 (Parenthesis. 
 No, dearie, when I say, the basis for a new poetry, I don't mean the vers libre movement as it was in the year 1912.) 
 Of course the most cursory glance at Dunning's &bquo;Threnody in Sapphics&equo; (not to speak of more miserable performances like &bquo;Isabelle of Hainault&equo; in The Exile  number 3) shows that Pound had, as it were, no alternative; there was no way to vindicate Dunning by imagist principles. 
 He could not be vindicated by any other principles, either. 
 But before we jump to the conclusion that Pound had simply had a brainstorm, or had been trapped by misplaced compassion for Dunning as a lame duck, we ought to consider another possibility &mdash; that imagism, and Pound's endorsement of Ford's insistence on &bquo;the prose tradition&equo;, had never been for him more than an aberration, though in the short term a very profitable one, from a  way of feeling that impelled him always toward the cantabile , a proclivity that would, in the interests of melody, tolerate notably eccentric diction. 
 It is thus that he declares himself for Dunning's sapphics, flashing out at &bquo;any one who cannot feel the beauty of their melody &equo; (my italics). 
 And within six years, wanting to register (in The Criter  - ion  for 1934) the distinction of Binyon's version of the Inferno  despite its consistent inversions of prosaic word order, Pound found himself in the same situation, having to contend with those who had learned too well or too inflexibly the lessons he himself had taught them: 
 Before flying to the conclusion that certain things are &bquo;against the rules&equo; (heaven save us, procedures are already erected into RULES!) let the neophyte consider that a man cannot be in New York and Pekin at the same moment. 
 Certain qualities are in OPPOSITION to others, water cannot exist as water and as ice at the same time. 
 Moreover these were the years when Pound was writing Canto 30: 
 Compleynt, compleynt I hearde upon a day, 
 Artemis singing, Artemis, Artemis 
 Agaynst Pity lifted her wail: 
 Pity causeth the forests to fail, 
 Pity slayeth my nymphs&hellip; 
 and Canto 36: 
 I have no will to try proof-bringing 
 Or say where it hath birth 
 What is its virtu and power 
 Its being and every moving 
 Or delight whereby tis called &bquo;to love&equo; 
 Or if man can show it to sight. 
 To be sure, both of these cantos are special cases &mdash; as was, we may suppose, the &bquo;Envoi&equo; to Hugh Selwyn Mauberley , written many years before. 
 Yet in one sense the circumstances of any and every poem are &bquo;special&equo;; and at any rate all these instances show that, in his own writing as in the writing of others, Pound was prepared to recognize circumstances which justified departing very far indeed from Ford's and the imagists' precepts about diction, indeed flying in the face of them. 
 But what, then, are we to make of it when, in 1939, writing an obituary of Ford, Pound lumped together two old associates of his,  Fred Manning and Henry Newbolt, and excoriated them for continuing to use the &bquo;poetical&equo; diction from which Ford's timely polemics had weaned Pound himself? 
 Is this inconsistency? 
 Is it worse &mdash; positive dishonesty? 
 And what's to be said of his declaration, as late as 1964 (in Confucius to Cummings , the anthology he put together with Marcella Spann), that Ford's insistence on &bquo;the limpidity of natural speech, driven towards the just word, not slopping down&hellip; into the more ordinary Wordsworthian word&equo; was &bquo;the most important critical act of the half-century&equo;? 
 How could Pound continue to proclaim this, when his own writing for decades before had belied it? 
 (For undeniably, the cantos are not limpid ; much of them isn't &bquo;speech&equo; at all, but &bquo;song&equo;; and of the parts that are speech, by no means all are &bquo;natural&equo;.) 
 Have we convicted Pound of inconsistency, or worse? 
 I think not. 
 Pound knew enough of his own gifts, and of the protracted strenuousness of his apprenticeship, to know that what was safe for him was not safely available to others, least of all to those he called &bquo;the neophyte&equo;. 
 He knew too that the poem he was engaged upon, The Cantos , was unprecedented and (he must have thought) sui generis . 
 (He was not to know that Charles Olson, after next to no apprenticeship at all, would recklessly try to emulate him.) 
 But in any case, the best proof of the pudding is in the eating &mdash; by which I mean that any one who has tried to help young poets over the years, whether in Britain or America, knows that Ford's and the imagists' precepts about diction are what most of them most need to learn &mdash; no novelty, after all, since they can learn the same lessons from the preface to Lyrical Ballads , if they choose to. 
 What they learn in such a case is, of course, only a rule of thumb; for if criticism sometimes has to be prescriptive, its prescriptions are never applicable except &bquo;by and large&equo;. 
 Rules of thumb are the only rules there are, in the atelier . 
 But experience has taught me that this is the rule of thumb that can be most profitably proposed and acted upon. 
 I dare to go further: some of the most gifted and earnest among my contemporaries &mdash; I think of Edgar Dowers in the United States and Geoffrey Hill in the United Kingdom (though I except Hill's wonderful Mercian Hymns ) &mdash; fall short of pleasing me as they might, because they seem not to have followed this rule of thumb, and their language is habitually for my taste a shade, or several shades, too grandiloquent or &bquo;literary&equo;. 
 I conclude that Ford's &bquo;critical act&equo; was indeed (by and large, always by and large) the most important of the first half of this century, and that it is, moreover, irreversible.  
 Sicily in The Cantos  
 When was Pound in Sicily? 
 How many visits did be pay to the island? 
 What particular cities and districts did he visit? 
 For which of these excursions was he in the company of Yeats? presumably from the Pound papers now at New Haven it would not be hard to come up with answers to these questions. 
 But in the meantime the printed sources are hazy, if not quite contradictory. 
 According to Noel Stock ( The Life of Ezra Pound  &lsqb;1970&rsqb;, p.251), &bquo;about the middle of February 1923 the Pounds went to Sicily with Yeats and his wife&equo;. 
 On the other hand, in Joseph Hone's W.B. Yeats, 1865&ndash;1939  (1942, p.367) we read that the Yeatses went to Sicily in November 1924 and stayed for two months, &bquo;the attraction there being, besides the sunlight, the presence of Ezra Pound on the island, and the Byzantine mosaics of Monreale and the Capella Palatina at Palermo&equo;. 
 Certainly Pound was writing from Taormina in December 1924, and writing to Joyce from Syracuse on 21 January 1925 ( Pound/Joyce  ed. 
 Forrest Read, 1967). 
 And Richard Ellmann, in New Approaches to Ezra Pound  (1969), names 1925 as the year in which the two poets, with their respective wives, were together in Sicily. 
 All one can say with any certainty is that the Pounds (and probably the Yeatses also) paid at least two visits to Sicily in these years, and that on at least one occasion &mdash; probably on more than one &mdash; they stayed there for some weeks, if not months. 
 If we look in The Cantos  for traces left by this experience, we are surprised to find how few they are, and how meagre. 
 We might think that &bquo;Naxos&equo; in Cantos 2, 24, and 78 is the place of that name beneath Taormina, the site (lately and partially excavated) of the earliest Greek colony in Sicily, and thereafter the port whence the teams from all the Sicilian Greek cities made a ceremonial departure to compete in the Olympic Games; but the Annotated Index  is doubtless right to identify Naxos, on the contrary, with an island in the Aegean. 
 Apart from that, we have (at 25/1 15) &bquo;that serene Lord King Frederic of Sicily&equo; &mdash; which is to say, Frederick of Aragon (1272&ndash;1337), who was Frederick II, king of Sicily (1296&ndash;1337). 
 At27/129, we hear  of &bquo;the earthquake in Messina&equo; (28 December 1908), but this is merely incidental to the vast blague  perpetrated by Romains, Vildrac, and others in Paris &mdash; to be nostalgically remembered years later in the Pisan Canto 80 (see Richard Sieburth in Paideuma  2, p.280). 
 At 77/467 and again at 80/512, reference to the &bquo;quai&equo; or &bquo;quais&equo; at or of &bquo;Siracusa, seem not much less adventitious, in the sense that location in the Sicilian city of Syracuse seems, at first sight anyhow, not to be significant. 
 Rather more arresting is 80/503: 
 hurled into unstillness, Ixion 
 Trinacrian manxman 
 &mdash; where &bquo;Trinacria&equo;, the ancient Greek name for Sicily, is related to the legend of how Vulcan the divine smith, somewhere in the island, solved the problem of perpetual motion, by a wheel with three dogleg spokes, its never ceasing to roll recalling the wheel that was the hellish and interminable torment of Ixion. 
 (The same threespoked wheel is the heraldic emblem of the Isle of Man.) 
 There remains the joke, at 82/524, on the name of Frederic W. Tancred, a member of the Hulme-Flint circle (c. 1909), chiming with that of Tancred, Norman king of Sicily (d. 1194). 
 This is a poor harvest from those weeks or months that the Pounds spent in Sicily; and indeed it is no harvest at all, since none of these allusions depends in any way on the poet's having been physically present in the island. 
 The same is true of a passage in the Rock-Drill  Canto 94 (640&ndash;41): 
 Acre, again, 
 with an Eleanor 
 who sucked the venom out of his wound, 
 and came up via Padua, 
 for a balance of wine &amp; wool, 
 distraint and tolls not unbridled 
 and in 1288 a thunderbolt passed between them 
 this wd / be in the time of Federico Secondo, 
 Alfonso, St. Louis, and Magnus of Norway 
 and two years later she died and his luck went out, 
 Edwardus, who played Baliol against the Bruce 
 and brought the stone down to London 
 where it is seen to this day 
 PACTUM SERVA 
 Be Traist. 
 Here the Sicilian reference, in itself a very slight one but worth pointing out for reasons that will emerge, is in &bquo;Federico Secondo&equo;,  who is identical with the &bquo;Frederic&equo; of canto 25, glossed above. 
 It is essential not to confound him with the greater Frederick II (Hohenstaufen), holy Roman emperor from 1215 to 1250, and before that (1198&ndash;1212) king of Sicily as Frederick I. For this great figure, author of The Book of the Falcon  and a hero for Dante as well as Pound, is to figure portentously in the Thrones cantos to come as we shall see. 
 By the same token, we have to keep a watch on dates so as to see that this Eleanor is not  Eleanor of Aquitaine, but her great-greatgranddaughter, Eleanor of Castile, wife of Edward I of England. 
 The possibility of confusion is very great; for just as Eleanor of Castile landed at Acre in 1270, accompanying Edward on the seventh crusade, so Eleanor of Aquitaine had landed there 120 years before, accompanying her  husband (that is, her first, Louis VII of France) on his  crusade &mdash; which is presumably what Pound means by &bquo;Acre, again &equo;. 
 (This &bquo;rhyme in history&equo; between namesakes is doubtless meant to strengthen the already well-established conflation of these Eleanors with their near namesakes, Helen of Troy and Helen of Tyre.) 
 Most of the details about Eleanor and her relations with Edward, including his attempts to subjugate Scotland, symbolically signified by his removing the Stone of Scone to London, are found in the first volume of that small classic, Agnes Strickland's Lives of  the Queens of England  (1864). 
 At 97/681&ndash;2, we get: 
 PUER APULIUS 
 &bquo;Fresca rosa&equo; sang Alcamo. 
 Of Antoninus very little record remains 
 That he wrote the book of the Falcon, 
 Mirabile brevitate correxit, says Landulph, 
 of Justinian's Code. 
 And here is the other Frederick, the Hohenstaufen emperor, he who wrote The Book of the Falcon (The Art of Falconry, being the De Arte  Venandi cum Avibus , tr. 
 C. A. Wood and F. Marjorie Fyfe, 1943). 
 He appears under the name he was given in his orphaned youth &mdash; the Boy from Apulia. 
 And with him comes Ciullo d'Alcamo, whose &bquo;Rosa Fresca aulentissima&equo; was translated by D.G. Rossetti: &bquo;Thou sweetly-smelling fresh red rose/ That near thy summer art&hellip;.&equo; 
 This poem, and its author, figure in The Spirit of Romance , as showing that Italian poetry taking up from Provence originated not in Tuscany but Sicily. 
 Though Ciullo by Rossetti's reckoning composed  the poem in the 1170s, at least twenty years before Frederick Hohenstaufen came to the throne of Sicily, Pound in The Spirit of  Romance  juxtaposes the two names, presumably as &bquo;an instigation&equo; &mdash; though to what, it is not easy to say. 
 Fifty years later, in Thrones , this is still the best he can do &mdash; juxtaposing the two authors, and the two compositions, as here, so also at 98/689, 100/719, and 103/736. 
 If significance is supposed to accrue with each repeated conjunction, it fails to do so for me. 
 However, at Canto 106/753&ndash;54 (there is a brief allusion at 104/745 to the mosaics at Monreale), we do at last find a Sicilian allusion in the context of writing that we can recognize as distinguished: 
 That the goddess turn crystal within her 
 This is grain rite 
 Luigi in the hill path 
 this is grain rite 
 near Enna, at Nyssa: 
 Circe, Persephone 
 so different is sea from glen that 
 the juniper is her holy bush 
 between the two pine trees, not Circe 
 but Circe was like that 
 coming from the house of smoothe stone 
 &bquo;not know which god&equo; 
 nor could enter her eyes by probing 
 the light blazed behind her 
 nor was this from sunset 
 Enna, traditional location of the rape of Persephone (see Milton), is in mid-Sicily. 
 But the location is, as it were, accidental, and contributes nothing to the tension between Circe and Persephone as it has been teased out, in this passage along with others, by Guy Davenport (see his &bquo;Persephone's Ezra&equo;, in New Approaches to Ezra Pound ). 
 In Canto 107, the Sicilian references suddenly come quite thick and fast, spliced into numerous quotations from Sir Edward Coke. 
 This makes sense to the degree that one of the legal authorities whom Coke most often cites is Bracton (Henry de Bracton, De Legibus et  Consuetudinibus Angliae ), who dies in 1268, having flourished under Henry III of England and during the minority of Henry's son, the future Edward I. Moreover Edward and Eleanor spent the winter of 1270&ndash;71 in Sicily, en route to the Holy Land, and returned there in 1272 for Edward to learn that, his father having died, he was king of England. 
 These are frail reasons, but the best I can find, for canto 107 to begin with a flourish of Sicilian place-names:  
 The azalea is grown while we sleep 
 In Selinunt', 
 in Akragas 
 Coke, Inst. 2., 
 to all cathedral churches to be 
 read 4 times in the yeare 
 20. 
 H. 3. 
 Like so much else in these cantos, the last line is  midleading , since it suggests it was by an edict of Henry III that the Magna Charta was sent to all cathedrals and read four times a year, whereas Coke's Institutes  make it clear that this was on the contrary an enactment of Edward I. &bquo;Selinunte&equo; and &bquo;Akragas&equo; (the old name of Agrigento) are ancient Greek cities in Sicily. 
 Later in the canto (107/757&ndash;58) we come upon: 
 OBIT Coke 1634 &amp; in &bquo;49 
 Noll cut down Charlie 
 Puer Apulius&hellip; ver l'estate 
 Voltaire could not do it; 
 the french could not do it. 
 they had not Magna Charta 
 in ver l'estate, Queen of Akragas 
 resistent, 
 Templum aedificavit 
 Segesta 
 I think I know what this might mean, or what it might be made  to mean. 
 But I can hardly care. 
 For this is wretched writing by any standards. 
 I said as much when Thrones  first came out, remarking on the insanely pointless jocularity of &bquo;Noll&equo; for Oliver Cromwell and &bquo;Charlie&equo; for Charles I. Harsh words! 
 But I repeated them in Ezra Pound.: Poet as Sculptor , and nothing that has come to my notice since, including an erudite and adulatory article on these cantos by David Gordon in Paideuma  4 (1975), has made me want to retract my words or change my mind. 
 Those of us who want to champion Pound do him no service at all when we try to excuse the inexcusable. 
 And writing like this, if not indeed the writing of Thrones  in general, I take to be inexcusable. 
 Moreover the style faithfully mirrors the  puerility of the content: to think that the barons who faced King John at Runnymede were anything like the Cokes or Hampdens who challenged the royal prerogative of the Stuarts in the seventeenth century, or that these in turn had much or anything in common with Sam and John Adams or Tom Paine, is to adopt the notorious &bquo;Whig interpretation&equo; of English history in a sort of parody version for grade school. 
 At 107/759, lo and behold, yet another  Eleanor! 
 In fact she has made a cryptic entrance already in the fifteenth line of this canto: &bquo;&hellip; of Berengar his heirs was this Eleanor&equo;. 
 This points to Eleanor of Provence , Edward's mother and consort of Henry III, whose reputation is as bad as that of Eleanor of Castile is good &mdash; though not for David Gordon, who seems to think that because she's said to be &bquo;of Provence&equo;, this puts her above suspicion. 
 At any rate, this identification is now confirmed: 
 &amp; this Helianor was of the daughters, heirs 
 of Raymond Berengar 
 and sister of Arch. 
 Cantaur 
 &bquo;Cantaur&equo; should of course be &bquo;Cantuar&equo;, the Latin abbreviation by which the primate of England signs himself. 
 For we read in Agnes Strickland: &bquo;The death of St. Edmund, archbishop of Canterbury, furnished Henry with a further opportunity of obliging Eleanor, by obtaining the nomination of her uncle Boniface to the primacy of England&equo;. 
 Pound, it will be noticed, gets the kinship wrong, as well as the spelling. 
 If there were not this evidence that at this point he is only hazily in command of what he is doing, we might ask &mdash; though to no purpose, I think &mdash; whether Eleanor's fiddling of her uncle into the see of Canterbury is presented to us for our approval, or the reverse. 
 I don't believe Pound knows any more than we do. 
 And so to the last of the Sicilian references, 109/774: 
 Clear deep off Taormina 
 high cliff and azure beneath it 
 form is cut in the lute's neck, tone is from the bowl 
 Oak boughs alone over Selloi 
 This wing, colour of feldspar 
 phylotaxis 
 And doesn't this give us &mdash; faintly indeed, but unmistakably &mdash; just what we've looked for in vain in all the other Sicilian allusions: that's to say, evidence that when Pound was in Sicily he didn't go around with his eyes closed, his ears and nostrils stopped? 
 For that surely is the disconcerting, downright depressing, reflection that this sorry catalogue must leave us with. 
 Sicily for Pound never but once had  any existence that wasn't either verbal  (as in the wordplay on &bquo;Trinacria&equo; or the Eleanors), or else notional , ideological (as providing a sort of slender mnemonic crutch for a tendentious reading of history). 
 The contrast with Yeats is instructive, and it doesn't work in Pound's favour. 
 The effect of the Sicilian experience on Yeats is disputed by Yeats scholars, but it is generally agreed that some effect there was. 
 Certainly, when Yeats chaired the Irish Senate committee that commissioned the Irish coinage (so wonderfully handsome as it turned out to be), it was photographs of Sicilian Greek coins that went out to prospective designers to show them what the committee had in mind. 
 In Pound, on the other hand&hellip; are we to believe that he, the long-time admirer of Pisanello, when he was in Syracuse never visited the unrivalled collection of ancient coins in the museum there? 
 Apparently we must believe that; at least there is no evidence that, if he did visit the collection, it impinged on his consciousness. 
 And indeed what evidence is there that Sicily as a physical presence, a quite insistent presence as generations of travellers have found it, ever modified Pound's sensibility in the least? 
 We are not looking for additions to the canon of &bquo;sacred places&equo;. 
 We can accept that by 1923 or 1924 the sacred places had been settled on, and there were quite enough of them. 
 What we seek is merely evidence that Pound didn't go to Sicily with a closed mind. 
 Pound was to mock Yeats indulgently for seeing in Notre Dame not a physical presence in worked stone, but only a symbol; yet in Sicily Pound's seems to have been the mind that was symbologizing . 
 I do not like being forced to this conclusion. 
 It pushes back, to a disconcertingly early period in Pound's life, the first signs of that aridity, that closing of the doors of perception, which &mdash; drastically arrested and reversed though it was, at Pisa and through the first years at St Elizabeth's &mdash; reasserted itself and wreaked the desolation of Thrones . 
 Does not the use of the Na-Khi material in those cantos tell its own tale? 
 This was material which the poet did not and could not perceive . 
 Between the verbal and the notional, the perceived and perceptible were dropped out of his world. 
 When he wrote in the last fragments 
 &bquo;That I lost my center 
 fighting the world&equo; &mdash; 
 this  was the centre that he had lost. 
 And when he wrote &bquo;Tho&equo; my errors and wrecks lie about me', I believe that cantos like 107 and 108 were those that he had in mind; and that he was right to judge them thus harshly.  
 Paideuma  6: 1 (1977). 
 Two Kinds of Magnanimity 
 &bquo;Olson saved my life&equo;. 
 Thus Pound in January 1946, in his first days at St Elizabeth's, appealing in terror at the prospect of losing whatever sanity remained to him. 
 How that life was saved live can now know, thanks to Catherine Seelye who has put the story together, mostly out of Olson's posthumous papers at the University of Connecticut. 
 Her tact and scrupulousness are beyond praise, and the book she has made cannot be recommended too urgently &mdash; even (perhaps especially) to those who have no special interest in, or liking for, either Charles Olson or Ezra Pound. 
 What to do in a democratic society with the errant or aberrant citizen of genius &mdash; this question, fumbled at or glossed over by everyone who has written on Pound's case (jurists and psychiatrists, as well as biographers and critics), is here posed more starkly, and explored more searchingly, then ever before. 
 We might have guessed that Olson would do it, if any one could.&hellip; 
 And yet this probably is the first point to make. 
 To take the force of this testimony that none of us deserves to avoid, it's not necessary to like either Olson or Pound, but it is necessary that we respect  them. 
 And it's not always easy to respect the author of The Maximus  Poems , marred as they are on nearly every page by solecisms and gaucheries, by arbitrary coarseness in diction, punctuation, syntax, lineation. 
 This endemic failure at the level of execution is counterbalanced, for those who are patient and sympathetic, by the audacity and grandeur of the conception. 
 But for the moment, that's not the point &mdash; which is rather that those who have been, legitimately or at least understandably, affronted by the pretensions of Olson as poet should not therefore write him off as anything but what he was: an exceptionally earnest and magnanimous man, and a man moreover who knew, as few poets since John Milton have known, what the polity looks like from the point of view of those who administer it  day by day. 
 It's because of this &mdash; the magnanimity even more than the political expertise &mdash; that Olson's appalled and self-questioning reflections on Pound's arraignment and incarceration make all others seem puerile at best. 
 By &bquo;magnanimity&equo; the last thing one means is a willingness to forgive and forget. 
 On the contrary Olson is to be praised in the first place for the relentless hostility with which he presses the charge home: 
 Pound can talk all he likes about the cultural lag  in America&hellip; but he's got a 200 year political lag  in himself. 
 It comes down to this: a rejection of the single most important human fact between Newton and the Atomic Bomb &mdash; the sudden multiple increase of the earth's population, the coming into existence of the MASSES. 
 Pound and his kind want to ignore them. 
 They try to lock them out. 
 But they swarm at the windows in such numbers they black out the light and the air. 
 And in their little place Pound and his kind suffocate, their fear turns to hate. 
 And their hate breeds death. 
 They want to kill. 
 And, organized by Hitler and Mussolini, they do kill &mdash; millions. 
 But the breeding goes on. 
 And with it such social and political change as they shall not understand. 
 Pound's admirers will protest at this, but they will be wrong. 
 If they ask for proof, let them look into their own hearts. 
 Do they not find there (I know I do) just that suffocation Olson speaks of? 
 Just that panicky fear, always on the verge of turning into hatred until we shamefacedly choke it back? 
 The Masses! 
 How can we not fear them, and fearing them, how not hate them? 
 Olson, in several illwritten but splendidly honest verse diatribes against MUZAK, showed that he knew that fear and hatred as well as any of us. 
 For we cannot feel what we know we ought  to feel &mdash; that &bquo;the masses, are &bquo;just folks&equo;. 
 (It isn't true anyway.) 
 The fear and the incipient hatred are something that we impenitent elitists must learn to live with, not anything we can deny. 
 For this is part of what &bquo;democracy&equo; means, or has come to mean. 
 And yet we haven't come to terms with that. 
 Which is partly what Olson meant when, linking Pound with Julius Streicher, he declared: 
 Our own case remains unexamined. 
 How then shall we try men who have examined us more than we have ourselves? 
 They know what they fight against. 
 We do not yet know what we fight for. 
 That is as true now as it was in 1945, when Olson wrote it.  
 What Olson drives at in Pound is his Fascism, not his anti-Semitism. 
 Of the latter he gives horrific examples, which sicken him and enrage him (though as much in Mrs Pound's genteel English version as in Pound's red-necked American). 
 But he always treats the Fascism and the anti-Semitism as two separate heads on the bill of indictment; and this I think (again 1 speak for myself) is what most of us stopped doing long ago. 
 We act as if the anti-Semitism comprehended the Fascism &mdash; which would be true only if all Fascists were anti-Semites (they aren't), and if all anti-Semites were Fascists (even less true). 
 Hatred of Jews is something that the Fascist is especially prone to, but it isn't a necessary consequence of his Fascism, and in any case it's only a symptom, certainly not the root cause of his disease. 
 (In Italian Fascism it showed up only quite late, as Giorgio Bassani may remind us.) 
 When we denounce the anti-Semitism and let the Fascism take care of itself, we are fastening on what is prepolitical or sub-political, and refusing to engage ourselves on the plane of politics where, as Olson insists, we're required to vindicate our own sorts of polity against the Fascist sorts. 
 What we gain from this is obvious: our own consciences are clear, and we're no longer implicated. 
 Or if we are implicated a little (since doubtless some Gentiles and even some Jews have anti-Jewish feelings that they're ashamed of), the implication I would guess is altogether more manageable than what happens when &mdash; Jew and Gentile alike, black as well as white &mdash; the educated elite is forced to confront its feelings about &bquo;the Masses&equo;. 
 And Olson won't let us squirm off the hook &mdash; for him the anti-Jewishness is symptom, not cause: 
 There it is. 
 It stops you. 
 You feel him imagining himself as the last rock of culture and civilization being swept over by a wave of barbarism and Jews (communism and commercialism), the saviour of more than the Constitution, the saviour of all that has been culture, the snob of the West. 
 For he is the AESTHETE, as I had Yeats speak of him. 
 All &mdash; his pride in his memory, his sense of the internationale of writers, painters, musicians, and the aristocrats, his study of form as technique (no contours, no edges, intellectual concepts, but rounding, thrusting, as a splash of color, as Yeats described his aim in the Cantos&hellip;) it is all a huge AESTHETICISM, ending in hate for Jews, Reds, change, the content and matter often of disaster, a loss of future, and in that a fatality as death-full as those for whom the atom bomb is Armageddon, not Apocalypse. 
 Again, Pound's admirers will protest; and they will be right, insofar as  Yeats's account of the Cantos  isn't so definitive as Olson takes it to be. 
 But the main thrust of Olson's argument is unaffected, and it can't be set aside: this great American poet (and Olson knows that Pound is all of that) was a Fascist, profoundly, and no amount of talk about his affinities with Whitman will save him for democracy, nor will any attempt to treat his anti-Semitism as an unrelated pathological aberration. 
 Another escape hatch that Olson slams shut upon us is the device of distinguishing between Pound-the-man and Pound-the-poet. 
 The trouble with this manoeuvre is that it cannot help but demote poetry. 
 And Olson will have none of that: 
 Can any man, equipped to judge, find Pound other than a serious man? 
 Can any writer honestly argue with those who shall, do, call him a crank? 
 It's no good, that business. 
 Around his trial you will hear it again and again. 
 Just one of those goddamned writers. 
 They're crazy. 
 A Bohemian. 
 There are writers who are such, but not Pound, despite all the vomit of his conclusions. 
 Pound was a serious man, and never more serious than when he was writing poetry; and his poetry drives towards just those unpalatable conclusions that Olson forces us to look in the face. 
 If, on the other hand, from some consciousness of immaculate rectitude, we follow Allen Ginsberg in giving Pound a kiss of forgiveness &mdash; and it is in effect what David Heymann does towards the end of The Last  Rower  &mdash; it is poetry that we are presuming to forgive, not the man but &bquo;the-man-as-poet&equo;. 
 How deep one has to go, to distinguish not &bquo;the man&equo; from &bquo;the poet&equo; but &bquo;the-man-who-is-the-poet&equo;, appears from Olson's splendid essay of 1949, &bquo;Granpa, Goodbye&equo;. 
 It is impressionistic? 
 You bet it is impressionistic, and would that we had more such &bquo;impressions&equo;: 
 His power is a funny thing. 
 There is no question he's got the jump &mdash; his wit, the speed of his language, the grab of it, the intimidation of his skillfully-wrought career. 
 But he has little power to compel, that is, by his person. 
 He strikes you as brittle &mdash; and terribly American, insecure. 
 I miss weight, and an abundance. 
 He does not seem &mdash; and this is a crazy thing to say in the face of his beautiful verse, to appear ungrateful for it &mdash; but I say it, he does not seem to have inhabited his own experience. 
 It is almost as though he converted too fast. 
 The impression persists, that the only life he had lived is, in fact, the literary, and, admitting its necessity to our fathers, especially  to him who had such a job of clearing to do, I take it a fault. 
 For the verbal brilliance, delightful as it is, leaves the roots dry. 
 One has a strong reeling, coming away from him, of a lack of the amorous, down there somewhere. 
 Wait. 
 I think I've got it. 
 Yes, Ezra is  a tennis ball, does bounce on, off, along, over everything. 
 But that's the outside of him. 
 Inside it's the same, but different, he bounces, but like light bounces. 
 Inside he is like light is, the way light behaves. 
 In this sense he is light, light is the way of E.P. 's knowing, light is the numen  of him, light is his way. 
 Maybe now I can get at this business of amor  as of Ezra, and get at it right. 
 It isn't a lack of the amorous, perhaps, so much as it is a completely different sense of the amorous to that which post-Christian man contains, to that which&hellip; the likes of Duncan, say, or myself may feel. 
 Of the likes of Bill W.? 
 I am struck by the image of &bquo;fire&equo; in &bquo;Paterson.&equo; 
 Maybe fire is the opposite principle to light, and comes to the use of those who do not go the way of light. 
 Fire has to consume to give off its light. 
 But light gets its knowledge &mdash; and has its intelligence and its being &mdash; by going over things without the necessity of eating the substance of things in the process of purchasing its truth. 
 Maybe this is the difference, the different base of not just these two poets, Bill and E.P., but something more, two contrary conceptions of love. 
 Anyway, in the present context, it serves to characterize two different personal via : one achieves its clarities by way of charitas , the other goes about its business blind, achieves its clarities by way of what you might call confusio . 
 And this would be the point from which to look back at Olson, as Catherine Seelye wants us to, and to regard The Maximus Poems  as embodying &bquo;the way of confusio &equo;. 
 Which would raise the further question whether this way, as practised by Olson, and by Williams in Paterson , isn't so unlike the ways of poetry as we have known it that to call their works &bquo;poems&equo; doesn't merely confuse the whole issue. 
 But that would be a strictly literary question; and it's for raising quite other questions that this book is momentous and irreplaceable.  
 New York Review of Books , 1975. 
 Ezra Pound and the English 
 I have the impression that the novels of Phyllis Bottome are now little read, though I remember my mother borrowing them from the local library in Barnsley in the 1930s, and speaking of them with respect. 
 They are too good to be forgotten, or some of them are. 
 The one that in its day attracted most attention was The Mortal  Storm , about the Nazis: though Phyllis Bottome herself seems to have preferred Old Wine , set in Vienna. 
 The book of hers that stayed with Pound was Private Worlds , which he reviewed in the New English  Weekly  in 1935, and referred to twice in Guide to Kulchur . 
 Pound had known Phyllis Bottome between 1905 and 1907, when they were fellow students at the University of Pennsylvania, and it's not clear whether it is that early association, or a period later when she had caught up with him in London, that Phyllis Bottome had in mind when she wrote of how Pound tried to transform her as a writer from a talented amateur into a professional: 
 I had successfully entered, at seventeen, precocious, and without a standard, the market of a profession which was, at the time I stormed it, financially profitable rather than intellectually exacting. 
 Ezra provided me with a standard; and gingered me into an attempt to train towards it. 
 Certainly it is the Pound of the London years, who had profited from Ford Madox Ford's pronouncements on diction, that Phyllis Bottome must have had in mind when she wrote: 
 The concrete image, unruffled by an adjective, was  a thing Ezra would willingly have died for. 
 Rhetoric  was a thing he would gladly have murdered; and he had already carried out his theory of honest thinking at the expense of considerable financial and perhaps emotional sacrifices. 
 His passionate and austere sincerity acted like a torch upon the young intellectuals of his day. 
 He cast off his home and his country because he  was disgusted by its slovenliness of intellectual outlook, although he was certain (with his gifts) of success and reputation had he remained in his own land; and he was wholly unknown and unsupported when he attempted to browbeat London. 
 &bquo;His passionate and austere sincerity acted like a torch&hellip;.&equo; 
 This emphasis is significantly different from what it is nowadays common form to acknowledge &mdash; Pound's kindness and generosity to other writers, particularly in his London years. 
 Behind the geniality and the ebullient showmanship, something &bquo;passionate and austere&equo; &mdash; I know of no other testimony which strikes that necessary note so firmly. 
 And yet this testimony is little known. 
 It's to be found in From the Life  (1944): one hundred sheets of wartime austerity paper to which Phyllis Bottome commits &bquo;six studies of my friends&equo; &mdash; that's to say, Alfred Adler, Max Beerbohm, Ivor Novello, Sara Delano Roosevelt, Ezra Pound, and Margaret MacDonald Bottome (this last the writer's American grandmother who in her forties became an influential evangelical orator). 
 The pages on Pound are not the only ones worth reading. 
 In particular the essay on Beerbohm is startlingly good: temperate, appreciative, sympathetic, yet in the end unsparing. 
 And it is worth dwelling on that, to the extent of calling into evidence another of Bottome's books, The Gaol  (1962), p.240: 
 Ezra would have liked to see more of Max Beerbohm, whom he at least partially admired for his wit, although of course he could not have tolerated his philosophy of life. 
 But although they lived as the only intellectual representatives of their own language in so small a place as Rapallo, they were not destined to decrease each other's mental loneliness. 
 I found that Max Beerbohm, having once met Ezra, declined to enlarge their acquaintance. 
 &bquo;I do not really see Ezra Pound in Rapallo,&equo; Max Beerbohm told me. 
 &bquo;He seems out of place here. 
 I should prefer to watch him in the primeval forests of his native land, wielding an axe against some giant tree. 
 Could you not persuade him to return to a country in which there is so much more room?&equo; 
 The consummate silliness  of Beerbohm's sneer, quite apart from showing just how brittle and thin was that famous &bquo;wit&equo; of his, has alas a representative significance also, as we see when we put beside it Maurice Bowra, another famous &bquo;wit&equo;, saying of Pound that he was, not just a bore, but an American  bore'. 
 Such frightened insolence  about Americans is still to be found in England, and among what the English regard as their intellectual and artistic elite. 
 Often enough it takes the same form as with Beerbohm: the affectation of an anachronistic ignorance about what life in North America is like. 
 And it shows, in Beerbohm and Bowra and as it survives today, how inevitable it was that Pound should have abandoned England and the English just when he did. 
 He had no alternative; had he remained in London after 1920, the antagonism to him could only have got more obdurate and more brutal. 
 This is something that the Anglo-American Phyllis Bottome, writing in England in wartime, finds hard to accept: 
 &hellip; 
 I like to think he will be forgotten as the belligerent sycophant of Fascism and remembered as what he was when I first knew him, in the years before our little war of 1914, when he was trying to take London by storm. 
 Foreigners always find that a difficult process &mdash; in fact only one of them made a real success of it &mdash; and Disraeli possessed what Ezra had been denied &mdash; the elasticity and toughness of a good Jew. 
 Ezra had neither toughness nor elasticity: he was as rigidly intelligent as a Plymouth brother; and as vulnerable as a sea-anemone. 
 His unquiet personality could not outface the somnolent arrogance of the greatest city in the world. 
 Yet Britain needed the youthful Ezra, almost as much as Ezra needed the thickly padded hide of this favoured country&hellip; 
 Or again: 
 &hellip; 
 Had Jonah been less indigestible how can we be sure that the whale would have expelled him? 
 Yet it was, I think, a tragedy for both parties that the whale of London could not keep down this nimble Jonah who distracted, but so well stimulated, her lethargic stomach. 
 From the moment Ezra left the Anglo-Saxon world he began to suffer more and more from the isolation of his intellectual exile. 
 This wild and wayward child of the Prophets &mdash; &bquo;a Daniel come to Judgment&equo; &mdash; needed the thick padded hide of the antediluvian monster, whose maw he had so precipitately fled from. 
 One thinks rather the better of Phyllis Bottome for wanting to believe that what had  to happen could in fact have been averted. 
 But it should be clear to us now that the English hide which she thought so &bquo;thickly padded&equo; was in fact morbidly sensitive &mdash; certainly as long ago as Beerbohm's spitefulness in the 1930s, and perhaps as long ago as Robert Nichols's inexusable review of &bquo;Homage to Sextus Propertius&equo; in 1920. 
 If Pound had been different&hellip;? 
 He would have had to be as different as T. S. Eliot; and there's an end of that  speculation! 
 (For Bottome herself says: &bquo;No one could write better than Ezra when he was not trying to score off T.S. 
 Eliot by writing as badly as he knew how&hellip;.&equo;) 
 What Phyllis Bottome wants to do &mdash; what, in 1944, she needs  to do &mdash; is to shift the blame for Pound's Fascism on to something other than the heedless impetuosity of Pound himself. 
 On the one hand she makes a speculative diagnosis of him, out of Adlerian psychology; on the other hand she half believes &mdash; but can't quite bring herself to say &mdash; that the blame lies with England, for virtually expelling him a quarter-century before. 
 Even as she offers her diagnosis, she very touchingly envelops it in a renewed insistence on how he was still, in 1935, &bquo;passionate and austere,: 
 Even as a young man, Ezra had always taken a determined stand on general decencies. 
 It was not licence he wanted; alas! not even freedom &mdash; his goal was the forcible enlightenment of mankind&hellip;. 
 Even as a good Fascist Ezra found it hard to swallow the persecution of the Jews. 
 He got away from the subject when I pounced upon it. 
 The Teutonic mind, he said quickly, was no favourite of his: Mussolini, he implied, did not particularly dislike the Jews. 
 It is necessary to turn back to Ezra's childhood to find a key to that dire impatience which has led him into so strange a spiritual home as Fascist Italy. 
 It is, alas, the spoiled and wilful child who makes whips and bloodshed take the place of wisdom and social interest! 
 Nevertheless in Ezra we are dealing with a creative artist who never &mdash; however impatient he was &mdash; sold his birthright for a mess of pottage. 
 Ezra can be mistaken &mdash; more thoroughly mistaken than most people &mdash; but he has never been venal. 
 He is one of the few people I have ever met who has never been either inflated or deflated by personal possessions. 
 There is  practically no limit to his asceticism for any purpose &mdash; other than asceticism. 
 He lived in 1935 (when I last saw him) in the utmost simplicity, although if he had been a little more conciliatory he could always have earned enough for his comfort &mdash; and his wife's; but he never valued anything that money could buy as he valued the integrity of his sharp-shooting mind. 
 Elsewhere in this memoir there is more that is notable &mdash; both of documentation and diagnosis. 
 In 1944 it took courage to write so favourably about Pound; and it may even be that Phyllis Bottome foresaw, and was trying to guard against, the peril that Pound would be in as soon as hostilities should be over. 
 In any case, what she produced was something generous, anxious, and grateful. 
 It should be remembered, and she should be honoured for it. 
 I do not forget that my subject is Ezra Pound, not Max Beerbohm. 
 Yet the circumstance of the two writers being noncommunicating neighbours in Rapallo is too piquant not to be instructive. 
 And so I think it is worth recalling what W.H. Auden wrote of Beerbohm in 1965: 
 Greatly as I admire both the man and his work, I consider Max Beerbohm a dangerous influence &mdash; just how dangerous one must perhaps have been brought up in England to know. 
 His attitude both to life and art, charming enough in him, when taken up by others as a general cultural ideal becomes something deadly, especially for the English, an intelligent but very lazy people, far too easily bored, and persuaded beyond argument that they are the Herrenvolk . 
 One may be amused &mdash; though not very &mdash; that after living in Italy for forty-five years Max still could not speak Italian, but such insularity is not to be imitated. 
 &bquo;Good sense about trivialities&equo;, he once wrote, &bquo;is better than nonsense about things that matter.&equo; 
 True enough, but how easily this can lead to the conclusion that anyone who attempts to deal with things that matter must be a bore, that rather than run the risk of talking nonsense one should play it safe and stick to charming trifles&hellip;. 
 This, remember, is W. H. Auden, whom for many years some people in England have regarded as himself too anxious not to bore, too anxious always to amuse. 
 If this suggests that there are other sorts of English people than the sort Auden has in his sights, on the other hand it lends point and force to his censure of Beerbohm, and of what Beerbohm stands for in English life. 
 Auden goes on:  
 As it is, he slyly suggests that minor artists may look down their noses at major ones and that &bquo;important&equo; work may be left to persons of an inferior kennel, like the Russians, the Germans, the Americans, who, poor dears, know no better. 
 The great cultural danger for the English is, to my mind, their tendency to judge the arts by the values appropriate to the conduct of family life. 
 Among brothers and sisters it is becoming to entertain each other with witty remarks, hoaxes, family games and jokes, unbecoming to be solemn, to monopolize the conversation, to talk shop, to create emotional scenes. 
 But no art, major or minor, can be governed by the rules of social amenity. 
 The English have a greater talent than any other people for creating an agreeable family life; that is why it is such a threat to their artistic and intellectual life. 
 If the atmosphere were not so charming, it would be less of a temptation. 
 In postwar Britain, the clothes, accents, and diction of the siblings may have changed, but, so far as I can judge, the suffocating insular coziness is just the same. 
 Here, as often with the author of Thankyou, Fog , we may well suspect that Auden generalizes about English life too much on the basis of his own late-Edwardian childhood in a comfortable rentier household. 
 And yet I wouldn't dismiss out of hand Auden's claim that what he says of our family life holds as true of Coronation Street as of Lowndes Square. 
 In any case, enveloped though it is in ingratiating compliments to us on how charming we are in the bosoms of our families, the indictment is quite firm and it is unsparing: &bquo;Suffocating insular coziness&equo;. 
 Most of all worth remembering is the trenchant declaration: &bquo;&hellip; no art, major or minor, can be governed by the rules of social amenity&equo;. 
 It was because Pound behaved always in the spirit of this remark that he could not fail to offend Englishmen of the type of Beerbohm and Bowra, and that he continues to offend their likes and their successors (in all social classes) at the present day, as, for instance, his confrere T.S. 
 Eliot did not and does not. 
 On this issue indeed the comparison with Eliot is inescapable, Eliot very early learned and bowed to the English rule that social amenity must not be disturbed &mdash; alike in his life-style and, after Poems 1920 , in his poetic style also, he observed this rule punctiliously. 
 Pound saw him doing it, and chuckled indulgently; it was what he meant by dubbing Eliot &bquo;the Possum&equo; (opossum, the creature that escapes danger by shamming dead). 
 And when we remember what Eliot did with the gibe, taking it over in the title of Old Possum's Book of Practical Cats , that collection of whimsical fireside charades in verse, we may well think again about Auden's  comment that in English family life &bquo;it is becoming to entertain each other with witty remarks, hoaxes, family games and jokes&equo;. 
 Is it perhaps true that for many of the English, poetry has never been anything else but a superior parlour game? 
 We might begin to think so if we reflected that in parlour games the rules never change, and then noticed that this year the most accomplished of our poets in their forties published, sixty years after Pound's Lustra  and Eliot's Prufrock , an ambitious poem in the shape of fifteen interlinked pentameter sonnets. 
 However, a safer and a wiser idea is to take up what I began with: Phyllis Bottome telling how Pound, when they were both young, tried to turn her as a writer from an amateur into a professional. 
 It was, of course, what he tried to do with everyone that he thought worth the trouble. 
 And once again it was this unrelenting professionalism in Pound that set, and continues to set, Englishmen's teeth on edge. 
 For in our national tradition, in the arts as until recently in sports, it is the amateur who is most admired; and Auden's charming joker by the Christmas hearth is only a particular version of the amateur. 
 He observes the prohibition against &bquo;talking shop&equo;, whereas Pound through his London years seems never to have talked anything else. 
 (Once again Eliot knew, or soon learned, better.) 
 And the most Anglophobe of Pound's books is, appropriately, the one that is most full of shoptalk &mdash; though of shoptalk of a special kind, the talk of the master to his apprentices in the shop that is a workshop, the atelier  where the talk that goes on is the vehicle by which an artistic tradition is transmitted, not in conceptualizing, and tendentious readings of history, but where it is concrete , in tricks of the trade and rules of thumb and words to the wise. 
 I have in mind How  To Read , a disastrously misnamed little treatise, since its real subject is How to Write, and it is addressed to what Pound called (with the engagingly dated Edwardian elegance that he never wholly shed) &bquo;the neophyte&equo; &mdash; that is to say, to the young American writer who wants to know as soon as possible, though at the expense of considerable exertion which he is prepared for, how to assemble his kit of tools for the job in hand and others that he can dimly foresee. 
 When Pound revised and expanded this to make The ABC of Reading  (the title is still  a misnomer), he winkled out of it most of the anti-Englishness that had been present in the first version, when Pound was still smarting from what he took to be England's rejection of him eight years before, in 1920. 
 I have argued elsewhere that Pound was prepared to take instruction, as well as to give it; that when he first came to London in 1908, he was looking for masters to whom he might apprentice himself; that he found them in the Irishman W.B. Yeats and the maverick Englishman Ford Madox Ford (whose  professionalism about writing still denies him in England the recognition that he gets abroad); and (so I have speculated, though I know it cannot be proved) that Pound sought the same relationship with another Englishman, Laurence Binyon, who was too cagey to go along with the idea. 
 Before we leave this topic, with some doubtless well-received witticisms about the American ateliers  that are called Schools of Creative Writing, let us ask ourselves how an artistic tradition is  transmitted from generation to generation in England, if it is not transmitted in the way that Pound took for granted. 
 And let me assist such reflections by reporting that a gifted and earnest English poet of thirty-two, whom I met this very summer, not only confessed that he had never read through Basil Bunting's Briggflatts , but quite plainly saw no reason why he ever should. 
 We can stage a little comedy for ourselves if we pick out two expressions that I used in my last paragraph, and imagine ourselves presenting them to the startled and unwelcoming gaze of Max Beerbohm. 
 They are the expressions &bquo;kit of tools&equo; and &bquo;job in hand&equo;. 
 We may doubt that Beerbohm had the acumen or the catholicity to respond to this provocation as conclusively as he should. 
 But in that case, let us do it for him. 
 The conclusive objection to &bquo;kit of tools&equo; or &bquo;job in hand&equo; as appropriate expressions when we talk of poetry, is in some late lines by Eliot: 
 Because one has only learnt to get the better of words For the thing one no longer has to say, or the way in which One is no longer disposed to say it. 
 It is the occasion which determines what figurations of language are appropriate to it, and no one poetic occasion duplicates any other. 
 To this extent and in this way the English distrust of the professional writer can and must be vindicated. 
 It was what Pound found out the hard way, when the recurrent occasions of The Cantes  compelled him time and again, not infrequently, to go against the precepts that he had promulgated himself when he was the fugleman for imagism and vorticism &mdash; for instance (and it is  only the most obvious instance), the prohibition against archaic diction. 
 What's more, though it seems not to be generally realized, Pound recognized what had happened and acknowledged it; he did so in the public welcome he gave to Binyon's translations of Dante, which employ a very archaic and convoluted diction indeed. 
 And this was not the only occasion on which he protested, in the 1920s and 1930s, at having the precepts that were formulated to meet the special conditions of 1914 taken as absolute and binding for all poetic situations at all times. 
 He does not, however, retract his proposal that the precepts of the imagist  manifesto are  still the best rules of thumb for &bquo;the neophyte&equo;, the beginner in his &bquo;prentice-work; and for what it is worth my own experience in the workshop certainly bears that out. 
 The notion that we crucially need, I think, to do justice to the conflicting claims of the amateur and the professional in these matters, is the idea of thresholds . 
 In verse writing, as in virtually any other human activity we may think of, there are thresholds to be reached and crossed: below a certain threshold of practice and expertise, the attitude of the amateur produces only work that is &bquo;amateurish&equo; (and heaven knows, we see plenty of that all around us); above a certain threshold of facility, the attitude of the professional produces work that is glib, facile, heartless, and academic &mdash; and we see plenty of that, too. 
 Though I think neither Eliot nor Pound explicitly used the idea of &bquo;the threshold&equo;, the idea is surely implicit in the criticism of both men; and it is an implication that in our own criticism, and our own practice as verse writers, is almost universally ignored. 
 At any rate, in this way if in no other, the English ideal of the artist as amateur has a continuing validity &mdash; and one that it behoves us, as Poundians, to acknowledge more often than we do. 
 It is an idea &mdash; the idea that the practice of our art should ideally  be an avocation rather than a vocation &mdash; which has a distinguished and ancient lineage, to be traced back through the English bourgeois idea of &bquo;the gentleman&equo; to the Italian aristocratic idea of &bquo;the courtier&equo;. 
 Yeats's poem, &bquo;In Memory of Major Robert Gregory&equo;, is centrally concerned with this, as when he associates Robert Gregory with that paradigm of the English courtier, Philip Sidney. 
 And during the years when Pound was most under Yeats's influence, Pound too embraced this ideal &mdash; as when in 1912 he went with Yeats and some others to pay an act of homage to one of the last English representatives of the type, the Sussex squire Wilfred Scawen Blunt: 
 But to have done instead of not doing 
 this is not vanity 
 To have, with decency, knocked 
 That a Blunt should open 
 To have gathered from the air a live tradition 
 or from a fine old eye the unconquered flame 
 This is not vanity. 
 Here error is all in the not done, 
 all in the diffidence that faltered. 
 However, we know from Yeats's letters even more than his poems that he thought the last possibility for aristocratic ease in the arts had disappeared when Robert Gregory was shot down over France in 1915. 
 And I think it could be maintained that when Pound left  
 England in 1920, it testified to a similar recognition by him that the amateur ideal in the arts, however admirable in the abstract, and however rich its achievements under earlier structures of society, under the conditions of mass democracy could mean only amateurishness in technique, and thin-skinned insolence in debate. 
 Who is to say that Yeats and Pound were wrong? 
 Not I, certainly. 
 What is important to realize is that for Yeats certainly, and I think at times for Pound also, the only alternative open was a sorry second best. 
 Yeats in a letter specifically invoked the name of Wilfred Scawen Blunt on one of many occasions when he girded in rage against the &bquo;unnatural labour&equo; that verse writing had become for him, with the disappearance of the less egalitarian society that Gregory and Blunt stood for. 
 Professionalism in writing was what Yeats resentfully found himself condemned to; but he didn't like it, and he never pretended to. 
 Obviously, the same cannot be said of Pound. 
 On the contrary, as I have insisted, one indelibly American thing about Pound from the day when he first reached London was his, as it must seem to us, excessive faith in know-how, in a communicable &bquo;bag of tricks&equo;. 
 And yet there is his tribute, as late as the Pisan years, to Blunt; there is the fact that his friendship with Yeats did not end except with Yeats's death; and there is above all the fact that his disenchantment with mass democracy kept pace with Yeats's, and culminated for him as for Yeats in the false alternative of Fascism. 
 I believe a close examination of his recorded opinions, and of the idiom in which those opinions were expressed (an idiom, even to the end, as much British as American), would show that Pound too was not insensible to the ideal of the aristocratic amateur in the arts, and was at least sometimes resentful, just as Yeats was, that political and socio-economic developments had made that attitude to the arts impracticable and sterile. 
 If so, we English Poundians, even as we castigate our countrymen for clinging to the norm of the amateur in an age when that norm is unserviceable, may well spare more than just wistful nostalgia for this ideal that survives among us only in a debased and anachronistic version. 
 One reason for insisting on this possibility is to prevent us from being too complacent and self-congratulating about what we are engaged in, here and now. 
 We should beware of supposing that, if Pound from the shades is looking at this present occasion, he is unreservedly gratified by what he sees. 
 Weekend conference and seminar and study group, doctoral dissertations, and communally compiled working papers toward another Annotated Index  &mdash; we may agree, as I do, that in present historical conditions these are the best or the only ways of responding to the achievement of a very great, though of course imperfect, poet. 
 We may even feel, as certainly  I do, that some of the later cantos are of such a nature that it's hard to conceive in any  age of a way of encountering them other than the way we're here embarked upon. 
 And yet we need to remember &mdash; Pound, I think, would have wanted us to remember &mdash; what a latecome development this is in the relations between a poet and his readers, how recent this is, and, in the perspective of history, how bizarre. 
 We may surely placate the shade of Max Beerbohm sufficiently to acknowledge that the danger we run in approaching poetry this way is indeed the danger of one sort of professionalism &mdash; specialized and therefore blinkered, inflexible, and humourless. 
 I suspect that Pound is rueful at best when he looks down and sees us industriously annotating out of Sir Edward Coke Canto 107, without noticing that the English language is in that canto handled with none of the sensitivity that would make those labours worthwhile. 
 What I am saying is that a lot of the common English objections to Ezra Pound have substance, and would be worth taking seriously, if only we could be sure that they were advanced in good faith, in humility, and with compassion. 
 Unfortunately the tone in which they are expressed, and the language they are couched in, prevent our taking them in that way, and recall for us rather the heads of Auden's indictment: &bquo;lazy&hellip; too easily bored&hellip; persuaded beyond argument&hellip;&equo; 
 Accordingly, an assembly such as this in England &mdash; and let me remind you there have been earlier ones, at Sheffield and Keele &mdash; is an act of homage to a great and greatly maligned poet; but it is also, and cannot help but be, a patriotic demonstration against &bquo;suffocating insular coziness&equo;.  
 Paideuma  7: 1&ndash;2 (1978). 
 This was originally a lecturer to a London conference of Pound studies in 1977. 
 Virgil's Presence in Ezra Pound and others 
 Most considerations of Virgilianism in our modern poetry have concentrated on, have been perhaps mesmerized by, the figure of T.S. 
 Eliot. 
 This is natural: the exceptionally influential eminence that Eliot achieved through the second half of his life, together with his almost explicit (though characteristically demure) donning of the Virgilian mantle himself, have made it inevitable. 
 And Eliot is still the massive figure that must be circumvented if we are to see Virgil as having exerted a powerful influence on our modern poetry in ways more partial, devious and oblique than Eliot allowed for. 
 For Eliot was intransigent. 
 Like the less diplomatically suave authority, Theodore Haecker, whom Eliot was at times glad to call on, the author of Four Quartets  and editor of The Criterion  required us to take Virgil as, above all, the author of the Fourth Eclogue, the pagan poet who prophesied Christianity, whose vision of human history must accordingly be seen as completed and vindicated by The Divine Comedy . 
 Eliot, it seemed, would have us take Virgil on his terms, or not at all. 
 And his terms were unyielding. 
 They were the same terms which Dante and the mediaeval jurists insisted on: Virgil was great, was perpetually relevant and in that sense &bquo;a classic&equo; (if not, more exactingly, the one indisputable &bquo;classic&equo;), because in him could be found what Dante teased out of him &mdash; the vision of Empire, of the divinely appointed imperium , which must be reconciled (this way and that, for the reconciling was not easy) with the no less divinely intended ecclesia . 
 The Holy Roman Empire, of Charlemagne, of the Ottonian emperors, through to the Hohenstaufens, was to be seen in all seriousness as the legitimate heir of &bquo;the Augustan peace&equo;: a dispensation which, though seldom or never actualized through the last five centuries, must be held in mind as the one and only imaginable harmonizing of Church and State, of religion and politics, at least throughout Europe. 
 Nothing less than that potentiality  could, so Eliot seemed to suggest, give order and significance to the otherwise squalid and meaningless turbulence of the middle decades of the present century. 
 The vision was grand and, in its intransigence, breath-taking. 
 But how it could be brought to bear on specific political decisions that had to be taken in for instance the 1930s &mdash; this was far from clear even to Eliot himself, if we judge from the dryly disenchanted tone of many of his editorial pronouncements and observations in The  Criterion . 
 Others before Frank Kermode, in his suave and erudite but ultimately acidulous The Classic  (New York, 1975), had protested that as a framework inside which real political decisions and actions could be taken, Eliot's Virgilian-Dantesque perspective was not just useless but dangerous. 
 After all, had it not led Eliot into seeming to endorse the anti-semitic French royalism of Charles Maurras? 
 In recent years the one English voice that has seemed to reiterate the Eliotic thesis in anything like its entirety has been the voice of C.H. Sisson: 
 The case of Virgil is a crucial one&hellip; 
 For anyone for whom literary education &mdash; like any other &mdash; is an exploration of the meanings we have and live by, so far as we do live by meanings, Virgil and Dante are connecting rooms&hellip; 
 To talk of getting the full charge of the Divine Comedy &mdash; or more modestly and exactly, the fullest charge the particular reader is capable of getting &mdash; while treating Dante's master as an irrelevance, is nonsense;&hellip; 
 This is part of a polemic (reluctant, because in other contexts and on other grounds Sisson venerates Pound) against Ezra Pound's treatment of Virgil: &bquo;&hellip; there are such absurdities in Pound as the assertion that Gavin Douglas's excellent Aeneidos  is &bquo;better than the original&equo;, together with other devaluings of Virgil'. 
 For Eliot and Sisson it is unthinkable that one can venerate Dante without venerating Virgil, and vice-versa ; whereas Pound was firmly pro-Dante, and yet often raucously dismissive of Virgil. 
 The divergence is important, perhaps crucial, because Pound and Eliot, American expatriates of roughly the same generation, in the London of the second decade of this century made common cause and thereafter &mdash; despite ever wider ideological disagreements &mdash; remained friends, mutually respectful and mutually supporting, until Eliot's death in 1965. 
 Even today the two-headed chimera &bquo;Pound-Eliot&equo; (not in  all ways chimerical) still stalks at large in literary discourse. 
 Some part of Sisson's censures must surely be conceded: whatever esteem we have and should have for Gavin Douglas's translation of the Aeneid , we can hardly believe that the Philadelphian Ezra Pound was any more at ease than most of us with Bishop Douglas's sixteenth-century Scots. 
 And some of Pound's many tributes to Douglas admit as much. 
 Pound's championing of Douglas had much to do with a polemic, in itself just and timely, against the presumed and unearned superiority of metropolitan English over the dialects of the British Isles, and of the English-speaking world. 
 At any rate it should not surprise us that when Virgil most startlingly irrupts into Pound's Cantos  (rather late &mdash; it is in Canto 78), he should be heard speaking in the Caledonian accents of Gavin Douglas. 
 The question can still be raised whether Pound had any access to Virgil except through translation. 
 Pound, following a polemical strategy which served him well in the short run (but which later back-fired) deliberately provoked the academic classicists of his day; and his use of his sources, classical and other, was always both hasty and high-handed. 
 And so there are still to be found Latinists who think that the hilarious mistranslations in his Homage to Sextus  Propertius  (1919) were inadvertent rather than mischievously deliberate. 
 Accordingly the point must be made that the young Pound, as a doctoral student grounded quite rigorously in the Romance languages, certainly could and did read Virgil in the Latin. 
 Evidence of this is in the play he makes with the Virgilian aether  and patet  ( Aeneid  6, 127, 130) in the puzzling but impressive Canto 16. 
 But even more telling is the negative evidence that, with the confessedly eccentric exception of Gavin Douglas, none of Virgil's translators have left their footprints on The Cantos . 
 Particularly conspicuous by his absence is that verse-translator of Virgil who is generally held (in my view, rightly) to have set a standard that no other can equal, except momentarily; that is, Dryden. 
 One commentator has indeed thought he found an echo of Dryden's translation of Aeneid  2, 417-20, in the opening lines of Canto 4; but I am persuaded by later scholars that the case is untenable. 
 This conspicuous absence of Dryden, though it helps to show that Pound needed no intermediary in his traffic with Virgil, also exposes a dispiriting limitation to Pound's taste, so catholic as he meant it to be: he never stretched his originally late-Victorian conditioning so far as to appreciate the masters of the English heroic couplet. 
 So in his late anthology,  Confucius to Cummings  (New York, 1964, with Marcella Spann), he explicitly preferred George Chapman's Homer to pope's, even though he had admitted that Chapman is unreadable, except for a few pages at a time. 
 And we cannot help but contrast the generous appreciation of Dryden by Eliot, who might have been expected to be temperamentally less in tune with him. 
 There is a more telling comparison. 
 Thomas Hardy, of an older generation, had implicitly claimed to be, and in the event had proved to be, a profoundly Virgilian poet. 
 Hardy was self-educated. 
 But his self-education had been very thorough, so that he turned himself into a good Latinist and a good Grecian also, as Pound in Confucius  to Cummins  acknowledged. 
 It is the more remarkable that Pound, no more than any one else for fifty years after Hardy died, pondered the Virgilian epigraph that Hardy put at the head of his &bquo;Poems of 1912&ndash;13&equo;, originally in Satires of Circumstance , (London, 1914). 
 The epigraph is Veteris vestigia flammae  from Aeneid  4, 23, where Dido confesses to her confidante that the love she once felt for her now dead husband is about to renew itself for Aeneas. 
 The same phrase had been translated and mordantly placed by Dante in Canto XXX of the Purgatorio ; and so, when Hardy in these poems confronts the shade of his recently deceased and estranged wife Emma, not only does Aeneas in Aeneid  6 confront the reproachfully haughty ghost of Dido, but Dante's pilgrim confronts for the first time the shade or apparition of his lost Beatrice. 
 In fact the original eighteen poems of the Hardy sequence, (in the Collected Poems  of 1919, he damagingly extended it by three extra pieces) tell a story of the poet's pilgrimage to his and Emma's early haunts, matching the stages of the journey there and back to specific stages of Aeneas's journey, in Aeneid  6, to the abode of the blest. 
 It thus represents, on the part of the supposedly non-modernist Hardy, a stratagem often taken to be definitively modernist: the use of an ancient fable to structure and resonate with a twentieth-century narrative, as the Odyssey  structures and resonates with James Joyce's Ulysses . 
 Yet so firmly established is the image of Hardy as a rustic provincial that Virgil rates not a single entry in the index to J.O. 
 Bailey's 700-page Poetry of  Thomas Hardy, A Handbook and Commentary , (University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, 1970). 
 Hardy undoubtedly read Virgil in the original; yet we know that long before he taught himself Latin his remarkable mother gave him (on his eighth birthday) a copy of Dryden's translation of the Aeneid . 
 And so there is reason to look  in Hardy's poetry not just for allusions to Virgil's Latin but for echoes of Dryden's English. 
 The only scholar as yet to have followed this scent is Tom Paulin in his Thomas Hardy; The Poetry of Perception  (Totowa, New Jersey, 1975). 
 Paulin for instance considers some lines from Aeneid  11, in which Dryden makes Diomede say, of the war dead: 
 Transform'd to Birds, my lost Companions fly: 
 Hov'ring about the Coasts they make their Moan; 
 And cuff the Cliffs with Pinions not their own. 
 The masterly masculinity of &bquo;cuff&equo; may be thought to belong with Dryden's conception of the grand style more than with Virgil's. 
 There is nothing exactly comparable in the poem by Hardy which Paulin brings into comparison, &bquo;The Souls of the Slain&equo; (1899, about the dead of the Boer War), but whether or not Dryden was the intermediary, the conceit and fable of the poem undoubtedly derive from this moment in Virgil: 
 Soon from out of the Southward seemed nearing 
 A whirr, as of wings 
 Waved by mighty-vanned flies, 
 Or by night-moths of measureless size, 
 And in softness and smoothness well-nigh beyond hearing 
 Of corporeal things. 
 And they bore to the bluff, and alighted &mdash; 
 A dim-discerned train 
 Of sprites without mould, 
 Frameless souls none might touch or might hold &mdash; 
 On the ledge by the turreted lantern, far-sighted 
 By men of the main. 
 Hardy's diction here is certainly pre-modernist, though in matters other than diction Hardy was more of a modernist than we commonly suppose. 
 At any rate such verses prevent us from supposing that only with modernism could fruitful contact with Virgil be resumed, or that late-Victorian Virgilianism was the perquisite of Alfred Lord Tennyson. 
 The Virgilianism of Hardy cries out for further investigation. 
 Pound greatly admired Hardy the poet &mdash; as Eliot did not, nor Yeats either. 
 But if Hardy's Virgilianism had been pointed out to Pound, this would not have counted in Hardy's favour. 
 For Pound's animus  against Virgil was deep-seated and virulent from the first,  and it persisted. 
 Already in 1914 he was exhorting the readers of Poetry  (Chicago): 
 Let us choose: Homer, Sappho, Ibycus, Theocritus&equo; idyl of the woman spinning with charmed wheel; Catullus, especially the Collis O Heliconii . 
 Not Virgil, especially not the Aeneid, where he has no story worth telling, no sense of personality. 
 His hero is a stick who would have contributed to The New Statesman . 
 He has a nice verbalism. 
 Dante was right to respect him, for Dante had no Greek, and the Aeneid would have stood out nobly against such literature as was available in the year 1300. 
 And three or four years later, in an essay that is still valuable inasmuch as it is a catena  diligently culled from curious reading, Pound urges readers of The Egoist  to pay attention to Ovid rather than &bquo;the more Tennysonian Virgil&equo;. 
 In 1916 Pound recommends to the neophyte, Iris Barry, readings in Catullus, Propertius, Horace and Ovid, but warns her against trafficking with Virgil (or Pindar). 
 Most tellingly, in his Homage to Sextus Propertius  (1919) he coerces Propertius into avowing anti-Virgilian sentiments that in fact Propertius did not profess. 
 From a different position, independently arrived at and much less troubling, the animus was to be shared lifelong by Robert Graves. 
 The grounds of Pound's hostility show up much more respectably than in any of his slashing prose in a passage of verse that has seldom been remarked. 
 It is in Canto 7 (originally 1921): 
 Dido choked up with sobs, for her Sicheus 
 Lies heavy in my arms, dead weight 
 Drowning, with tears, new Eros, 
 And the life goes on, mooning upon bare hills; 
 Flame leaps from the hand, the rain is listless, 
 Yet drinks the thirst from our lips, 
 solid as echo, 
 Passion to breed a form in shimmer of rain-blur; 
 But Eros drowned, drowned, heavy, half dead with tears 
 For dead Sicheus. 
 Life to make mock of motion: 
 For the husks, before me, move, 
 The words rattle: shells given out by shells. 
 The passage, even when returned to context, will obviously abide more interpretations than one. 
 (For good or ill, it is the poet's strategy that it should.) 
 Having lived with the passage for years, I am persuaded that it represents &mdash; based, as it plainly is, on Aeneid  1, 341ff., and 4 &mdash; a response to veteris vestigia flammae  drastically at odds with Hardy's response (which, as we have seen, Pound had apparently not noticed in any case). 
 &bquo; New  Eros&equo; &mdash; carried as it is on an elaborately established sobbing and languorous rhythm, the word &bquo;new&equo; denies itself. 
 How can the erotic stirring for Aeneas be &bquo;new&equo;, when it is explicitly saturated with sentiment for the old, the dead, for &bquo;Sicheus&equo;? 
 Dido's sobbing for her old lover even as she lies in the arms of her new one &mdash; this melancholy, which Virgil, and following him Hardy, responded to with such sympathy, is for Pound deathly, it precludes the genuinely &bquo;new&equo;, which he urgently wants to find and to celebrate. 
 The Canto as a whole, whatever its incidental obscurities, is plainly concerned with the phenomenon of &bquo;the living dead&equo;, focussed in part, as Ronald Bush has invaluably pointed out, on the old men, Clemenceau, Lloyd George and Woodrow Wilson, legislating at Versailles for a future they had no part in. 
 (They were thus represented in Maynard Keynes' Economic Consequences of the  Peace , which Pound had read by 1920.) 
 The lines quoted, for instance, lead directly into a portrait of Alessandro de Medici as a personification of abuleia , with more than one indication that it will serve also as a portrait of Henry James: 
 And the tall indifference moves, 
 a more living shell, 
 Drift in the air of fate, dry phantom, but intact. 
 O Alessandro, chief and thrice warned, watcher, 
 Eternal watcher of things, 
 Of things, of men, of passions. 
 Eyes floating in dry, dark air,&hellip; 
 There are gradations among the living dead. 
 Some shells are more living than others; some &mdash; Alessandro, Henry James &mdash; carry off their condition of living death with a dignity that compels admiration. 
 Nevertheless, shells is what they are, husks, as earlier in this Canto:  
 Thin husks I had known as men, 
 Dry casques of departed locusts 
 speaking a shell of speech&hellip; 
 Propped between chairs and table&hellip; 
 Words like the locust-shells, moved by no inner being; 
 A dryness calling for death;&hellip; 
 What has failed in them is Eros; wherever erotic stirring in them seems to be new, it is nothing of the sort but a reminiscence of a stir that once was. 
 If Pound had attended to Thomas Hardy's marriage to Florence Emily Dugdale within two years of the death of his first wife, Emma, there can be little doubt that this is the verdict he would have passed on the transaction. 
 The break that Pound thus makes, not just with Hardy and James (his two acknowledged mentors &mdash; one English, one American), but with a succession of revered masters reaching back to Virgil, is momentous. 
 What he denies is not just veteris vestigia flammae  but what Racine makes his Ph&egrave;dre say, in appalled awareness of her own condition: C'est V&eacute;nus tout enti&egrave;re &agrave; sa proie attach&eacute;e . 
 In that incomparable verse Racine surely articulates the classical and terrible conception that underlies also Virgil's treatment of Dido: sexual passion, the erotic, understood as one undifferentiated energy running wild, fastening itself seemingly at random on this person or that one, and switching from one to another in a way that discredits all human vows of constancy. 
 This was Hardy's conception also, as we see from poem after poem and story after story. 
 But of course the erotic can be conceived quite differently, as it was by Pound. 
 For him it was a matter of great moment, for he was one of those artists who hold that the energy of artistic creation is itself erotic, indeed (in his most extreme formulations) positively genital . 
 As the child that comes or may come from a sexual encounter between a man and a woman differs from the child born from that man and some other woman (or from the same man and the same woman on another occasion), so every genuine poem is the unique product of one unrepeatable encounter between the artist and an unearthly partner who may be called &bquo;Muse&equo; or &bquo;goddess&equo;. 
 &bquo;Make it new!&equo; was notoriously Pound's cry. 
 Though every responsible artist must know the annals of his art (no one more than Pound insisted on that), still every artwork that is worth anything not only can be but has to be new , unprecedented. 
 For Pound, alike in his sexual and artistic life, &bquo;Make it new&equo; was incompatible with &bquo;Here we go again' (if that vulgarity be permitted). 
 Those who know the life of P.B. Shelley, or of many another, will undoubtedly reflect that a man with this exalted view of the erotic life commonly makes a less  reliable consort than one with more modest expectations. 
 And it is true that whereas on the whole Pound managed his amorous career with more decorum than Shelley, still the pattern was, so far as we can discern, not very different. 
 It seems that on the basis of Canto 7 we can explain Pound's hostility to Virgil very simply indeed: it was precisely Virgil's melancholy, the lacrimae rerum  which endears him to so many, that Pound could not stomach, so sanguine as he was and so determined to remain so. 
 In this stubborn bent towards the hopefully open-ended (which he lost before the end), Pound may legitimately seem to us more indelibly American than his fellow expatriate, Eliot. 
 But anyone who is tempted to affect an Old World condescension to the New (&bquo;a young  nation&equo;, and similar self-servings) should consider again the date at which Canto 7 was written. 
 Because Pound was not a combatant, and because he resolutely resisted making easily patriotic and self-righteous gestures (this is what Homage to Sextus  Propertius  is about, very largely), the impact upon him of the First World War is under-estimated. 
 Yet he was to say that the entire enterprise of The Cantos  was undertaken so as to uncover the reasons why war happens, so as to preclude its happening again. 
 In 1919, as the old men negotiated at Versailles, hope did not come easy, yet imposed itself as an unavoidable necessity. 
 After the four years of murderous deadlock on the Western Front &mdash; most of Canto 16 is concerned with that &mdash; &bquo;Here we go again&equo; or &bquo;plus &ccedil;a change&equo; expressed a sentiment that was intolerable. 
 The new, the really new, had to be possible, since all the old wisdoms had proved themselves ineffective. 
 The hopefulness of Canto 7 is desperate. 
 Moreover, even if we allow &bquo;America&equo; to mean only the United States, the Old World needs to remember that there are more Americas than one. 
 Pound speaks for one, Eliot for another. 
 In many ways they differ, these two Americas, but they are alike in never having known defeat. 
 There is another America which neither of them knew, except tangentially: the America of the Old Confederacy which had  known defeat, and was committed to living with that knowledge. 
 To the citizens of that America, Virgil's story in the Aeneid  could have a painful immediacy. 
 Hence, Allen Tate's &bquo;Aeneas at Washington&equo; (1933): 
 I myself saw furious with blood 
 Neoptolemus, at his side the black Atridae, 
 Hecuba and the hundred daughters, Priam 
 Cut down, his filth drenching the holy fires. 
 In that extremity I bore me well, 
 A true gentleman, valorous in arms, 
 Disinterested and honourable. 
 Then fled: 
 That was a time when civilization 
 Run by the few fell to the many, and 
 Crashed to the shout of men, the clang of arms: 
 Cold victualing I seized, I hoisted up 
 The old man my father upon my back, 
 In the smoke made by sea for a new world 
 Saving little &mdash; a mind imperishable 
 If time is, a love of past things tenous 
 As the hesitation of receding love. 
 Here the first four lines are a translation, and surely a fine one, of Aeneid  2, 499&ndash;502. 
 But the city that goes down, the civilization &bquo;run by the few&equo; which &bquo;fell to the many&equo;, is not Ilium but Richmond or Montgomery or Atlanta, any one of the cities of the Confederacy finally sacked by Grant or Sheridan or the specially hated Sherman, generals of the victorious Yankee North. 
 The association is pressed home when the action resumes. 
 The destroyed South is named in &bquo;Blue Grass&equo;, byword for Tate's native Southern state of Kentucky, rammed hard against &bquo;Troy&equo; in controlled synaesthesia that identifies conflagration with fruition: 
 I saw the thirsty dove 
 In the glowing fields of Troy, hemp ripening 
 And tawny corn, the thickening Blue Grass 
 All lying rich forever in the green sun. 
 I see all things apart, the towers that men 
 Contrive I too contrived long, long ago. 
 Now I demand little. 
 The singular passion 
 Abides its object and consumes desire 
 In the circling shadow of its appetite. 
 There was a time when the young eyes were slow, 
 Their flame steady beyond the firstling fire, 
 I stood in the rain, far from home at nightfall 
 By the Potomac, the great Dome lit the water, 
 The city my blood had built 1 knew no more 
 While the screech-owl whistled his new delight 
 Consecutively dark. 
 Stuck in the wet mire 
 Four thousand leagues from the ninth buried city 
 I thought of Troy, what we had built her for. 
 There is plenty of lacrimae rerum  here, and one may legitimately wish for a touch of Dryden's bluffness or of Pound's impatient suspicion  of the elegiac note. 
 This is a comment not just on poetic style, but on the substance of the political alternative that Tate and some fellow Southerners were in these years trying to put together, to challenge the industrial capitalism of the restored Union. 
 Certainly Tate is not prepared to see the Federal capital, Washington, as a restored Richmond, as Virgil's Aeneas sees Rome as a second Troy. 
 Accordingly the phrase &bquo;a new world&equo; is mordantly, if a little cheaply, ironical. 
 The same irony is enriched and plangently deepened in another fine poem by Tate of the same year, in which once again the many Virgilian echoes point to a deeper affinity &mdash; with the fable of the Aeneid  as making more sense than he can find anywhere else, for the historical predicament that the American Southerner has inherited and must make sense of. 
 This poem, now entitled &bquo;The Mediterranean&equo;, was originally called &bquo;picnic at Cassis&equo;, and that first title invaluably brings out the occasion of the poem &mdash; that is to say, a holiday excursion by boat taken by expatriate Americans along the coast of Southern France. 
 The last three of its nine pentameter quatrains read thus: 
 Let us lie down once more by the breathing side 
 Of Ocean, where our live forefathers sleep 
 As if the Known Sea still were a month wide &mdash; 
 Atlantis howls but is no longer steep! 
 What country shall we conquer, what fair land 
 Unman our conquest and locate our blood? 
 We've cracked the hemispheres with careless hand! 
 Now, from the Gates of Hercules we flood 
 Westward, westward till the barbarous brine 
 Whelms us to the tired land where tasseling corn, 
 Fat beans, grapes sweeter than muscadine 
 Rot on the vine: in that land were we born. 
 It is not outlandish to see in these verses a modern American so estranged from modern American society &mdash; its wastefulness (&bquo;Fat beans&hellip; 
 Rot on the vine&equo;), its heedlessness (&bquo;with careless hand&equo;), and its enervation (its land is &bquo;tired&equo;, its conquest of that terrain &bquo;unmanned&equo;) &mdash; that he would like if he could to unravel the threads of history, and become again a citizen of that Old World which his ancestors should never have left. 
 ln that case the last clause &mdash; &bquo;in that land were we born&equo; &mdash; is no patriotic bugle-note, but rather a flat acknowledgement of what cannot be helped. 
 Even if this is only one of possible readings, these stanzas and the poem as a whole  surely represent an extraordinarily searching and painful exploration of what may be involved, for people of today, in the Virgilian pietas. 
 Despite his metrical conservatism (his strenuous handling of the pentameter is surely surprising and admirable) and his unfashionable addiction to the grand manner and the high style, Allen Tate was certainly a modernist; that is what he was thought to be, and it is how he conceived of himself. 
 However, his allegiance to the cause and principles of international modernism never comprehended an allegiance to Ezra Pound as a modernist master. 
 Given Tate's deepseated and as it were forefated Virgilianism, it hardly could. 
 Eliot was his master, and in some measure Yeats. 
 Yeats divagated into Virgil's territory only when, in 1915, he wrote Per Amica Silentia  Lunae , going for that title to Aeneid , 2, 255: A Tenedo tacitaeper amica  silentia lunae . 
 But no one has ever thought that Yeats's temperament was Virgilian, and characteristically, in this momentous book of verse and prose mixed, he glimpsed Virgil momentarily only through the spectacles of &mdash; of all unlikely people &mdash; Paul Verlaine. 
 However, the poem that opens the volume, &bquo; Ego Dominus Tuus &equo;, is in the form of an inconclusive dialogue between two persons &bquo;Hic&equo; and &bquo;Ille&equo;, who it is generally agreed might as well be named at certain points as &bquo;Ez&equo; and &bquo;Willie&equo;. 
 These identifications will not hold good throughout the poem, precisely because the two poets were so intimate, and would remain so: each could and did &bquo;internalize, the other, in the sense that within Yeats there was a voice that spoke the sentiments of Pound, and within Pound a voice that spoke like Yeats. 
 One of the things they seem to have agreed about, among innumerable disagreements, was the irrelevance of Virgil to their concerns. 
 Not all the commentators on The Cantos  have remarked how conspicuous is the absence of Virgil's name and presence, among the numberless names and presences which jostle on Pound's pages. 
 peter Makin for instance, in general one of the very best such commentators, misleads when he glosses a passage from Canto 23 by remarking: &bquo;Troy was the citadel of a culture, and when it fell&hellip; the priest-king Aeneas (guided by the chthonic deities) took the heritage to Italy, where his descendants planted Rome&hellip; 
 &bquo;. All quite true of course, but it has little or nothing to do with the passage in question,  whoch  focuses very markedly not on Aeneas but on his father Anchises: 
 And that was when Troy was down, all right, 
 superbo Ilion&hellip; 
 And they were sailing along 
 Sitting in the stern-sheets, 
 Under the lee of an island 
 And the wind drifting off from the island. 
 &bquo;Tet, tet&hellip; 
 what is it?&equo; said Anchises. 
 &bquo;Tethn&eacute;k&eacute;.&equo;. said the helmsman, &bquo;I think they 
 &bquo;Are howling because Adonis died virgin.&equo; 
 &bquo;Huh! tet&hellip;&equo; said Anchises, 
 &bquo;well, they've made a bloody mess of that city.&equo; 
 &bquo;King Otreus, of Phrygia, 
 &bquo;That king is my father.&equo; 
 and saw then, as of waves taking form, 
 As the sea, hard, a glitter of crystal, 
 And the waves rising but formed, holding their form. 
 No light reaching through them. 
 In a passage like this (and there are several very like it, as we shall see), Pound's interest in Aeneas is limited to the matter of his semidivine birth, how he was conceived by Aphrodite after she had assumed human form so as to lie with Anchises. 
 The source is not Virgilian, but the fifth of the so-called Homeric Hymns, &bquo;To Aphrodite&equo;. 
 Aphrodite's lie about a non-existent human father, &bquo;King Otreus, of Phrygia&equo;, is designed to conceal her divinity from her human mate, who is applauded for seeing through the fiction because of something uncanny in his bed-mate's bearing &mdash; sometimes specified as her gait, her way of walking. 
 Anchises is the hero, not Aeneas. 
 And he is the-hero-as-artist, who is called upon to make just such recognitions, of the divinely eternal through the veil of the quotidian. 
 The last lines quoted, which are also the last lines of the Canto, reveal this clearly for those who know The Cantos : the paradoxical coupling of the fluid (the waves) with the fixed (the crystal) is what Pound regularly sees as the essence of the authentic artifact. 
 Pound here is very close to Yeats who is, for instance in his great sonnet &bquo;Leda and the Swan&equo;, fascinated similarly by the moments when the inhuman &mdash; it may be bestial, it may be divine, subhuman or superhuman hardly matters &mdash; invades the human. 
 To neither Pound nor Yeats did it seem that Virgil had much or anything to say about this matter which so preoccupied them. 
 More than twenty years later, at the end of World War Two, Pound, in a prison-stockade awaiting trial for treason, was still celebrating Anchises in the same strain, and for the same reason:  
 each one in his god's name 
 as by Terracina rose from the sea Zephyr behind her 
 and from her manner of walking 
 as had Anchises 
 till the shrine be again white with marble 
 till the stone eyes look again seaward 
 (Canto 74) 
 Or again, in Canto 76: 
 or Anchises that laid hold of her flanks of air 
 drawing her to him 
 Cythera potens,  
 no cloud, but the crystal body 
 the tangent formed in the hand's cup 
 as live wind in the beech grove 
 as strong air amid cypress 
 The &bquo;tangent&hellip; in the hand's cup&equo; has to do with the legend that the shapes of the finest Greek vases were replicated from the contour of the divinely beautiful woman's breast, as cupped in her lover's hand and thereafter imprinted on his mind &mdash; obviously a powerful emblem of how the impulse to artistic manufacture is erotic. 
 For present purposes the point is that such passages, which because of the name &bquo;Anchises&equo; may seem Virgilian, are nothing of the kind. 
 Accordingly, when the Virgilian voice does  irrupt into these relatively late Cantos, it does so with all the more force for being unheralded. 
 It speaks Scots, as we have intimated: 
 &bquo;Who says  he is an American&equo; 
 a still form on the branda, Bologna 
 &bquo;Gruss Gott&equo;, &bquo;Der Herr!&equo; 
 &bquo;Tatile ist gekommen!', 
 Slow lift of long banners 
 Roma profugens Sabinorum in terras 
 and belt the sitye quahr of noble fame 
 the lateyn peopil taken has their name 
 bringing his gods into Latium 
 saving the bricabrac 
 &bquo;Ere he his goddis brocht in Latio&equo; 
 &bquo;each one in the name&equo; 
 in whom are the voices, keeping hand on the reins 
 Gaudier's word not blacked out 
 nor old Hulme's, nor Wyndham's&hellip; 
 This is Canto 78, another of those composed in the Pisan prison-stockade while their author awaited transportation and trial for treason. 
 The opening lines of Gavin Douglas's Eneados  (printed 1553) read: 
 The batellis and the man I will describe, 
 Fra Troys boundis first that fugitive, 
 By fait to Itale coyme and coist Lavyne; 
 Our land and see cachit with mekle pyne, 
 By force of goddis abuif, fro every steid. 
 Of cruell Juno throw ald ramembrit feid. 
 Greit pane in batell sufferit he also, 
 Or he his goddis brocht in Latio, 
 And belt the ciete, fra quhame, of noble fame, 
 The Latyne peple takin hes thair name&hellip; 
 The commentator who has done most justice to this appeal to Virgil by way of Gavin Douglas is the South African, Anthony Woodward. 
 But even Woodward fails to bring out how surprising it is (as well as how the line Roma Profugens Sabinorum in terras , has been enigmatically inserted in the preceding Canto 77). 
 Pound in this passage recollects how, late in the war, he set out with borrowed boots and haversack from Rome, already doomed to fall to the advancing Allied armies, for the Italo-Austrian domicile of his natural daughter, Mary, and how, hiking and hitch-hiking, he encountered much kindness from Germans and Italians alike. 
 What strikes him of a sudden, as he remembers this experience, is how it had been foreseen and marmoreally recorded by Virgil: as Virgil's Aeneas left doomed Troy, carrying his household and ancestral gods, so Pound leaves the doomed Rome of fascist Italy, carrying in his haversack his  gods &mdash; books by Henri Gaudier-Brzeska and T. E. Hulme and Percy Wyndham Lewis. 
 For a poet so hostile to Virgil to discover that in extremis  only Virgil had foreseen and foresuffered his predicament, and thereby eased it &mdash; this surely constitutes a very poignant moment in literary history, and in a history rather larger than &bquo;literary&equo; may suggest.  
 Virgin in a Cultural Tradition , eds R.A. Cardwell &amp; J. Hamilton. 
 University of Nottingham, 1986. 
 Eliot, Williams and Pound in the Twenties 
 Harold Monro, writing in the London Chapbook  in February 1923, observed of T.S. 
 Eliot's Waste Land  that &bquo;in England it was treated chiefly with indignation or contempt&equo;, whereas in America The Dial  had awarded the author its annual prize of &dollar;2,000. 
 But the implied contrast is misleading. 
 Allowing for the conventions of sedate amenity that governed American reviewing (as for the most part they still do), one can detect in the American reviewers of Eliot's Poems  (1920) and of The Waste Land  (1922) the same recalcitrance that the British reviewers expressed more cheekily. 
 Louis Untermeyer, Robert Frost's correspondent who was to be an influential anthologist, wrote of Poems (The Freeman , 30 June 1920) that &bquo;Eliot cares more for his art than he does for his attitudes&equo;; and that &bquo;the exaltation which is the very breath of poetry &mdash; that combination of tenderness and toughness &mdash; is scarcely ever present in Eliot's lines&equo;. 
 When The Waste Land  appeared, Untermeyer had become more irate: &bquo;The Dial's  award to Mr T. S. Eliot and the subsequent bookpublication of his The Waste Land  have occasioned a display of some of the most enthusiastically naive superlatives that have ever issued from publicly sophisticated iconoclasts&equo;. 
 The poem itself he found &bquo;a pompous parade of erudition&equo;, and he decided that &bquo;were it not for the Laforgue mechanism, Mr Eliot s poetic variations on the theme of a super-refined futility would be increasingly thin and incredibly second rate&equo; ( The Freeman , 17 January 1923). 
 Obviously a writer who is happy with &bquo;super-refined&equo; (elsewhere he says that Eliot's &bquo;Portrait of a Lady&equo; is &bquo;extraordinarily sensitized&equo;) is not a critic worth pausing on for long; and yet when Untermeyer cites all too patent imitations of Eliot's &bquo;Sweeney Among the Nightingales&equo; in quatrains by Osbert Sitwell and Herbert Read and Robert Nichols, one can see good reason for him to think that Eliot s reputation, achieved so fast on such a slender body of work, was no more than modish. 
 And indeed it asks no great exertion of the historical imagination to recognize that, at a time when &bquo;the Sitwells&equo; were taken to be &bquo;modernists&equo; equal with Eliot and Pound, modish  was just what Eliot's reputation was. 
 The achievement was quite otherwise; but it would be several years before that could be perceived, and the perception validated. 
 For this no one in American deserves more credit than Edmund Wilson. 
 He wrote, in The Dial  for December 1922, the most emphatically welcoming and apparently influential review of The Waste  Land , and although this reads a little quaintly now because Wilson took very seriously Eliot's supposed debt to Jessie L. Weston's From  Ritual to Romance  (which later criticism has taken lightly), his piece had the great virtue of conceding valid points to the opposition: 
 It is true his poems seem the products of a constricted emotional experience and that he appears to have drawn rather heavily on books for the heat he could not derive from life. 
 There is a certain grudging margin, to be sure, about all that Mr Eliot writes &mdash; as if he were compensating himself for his limitations by a peevish assumption of superiority. 
 But it is the very acuteness of his suffering from this starvation which gives such poignancy to his art. 
 However, it was more than three years later ( The New Republic , March 1926) that Wilson brought Eliot's poetry home to the bosoms of his countrymen. 
 He did so, having &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; before him, by insisting on the extent to which Eliot was indelibly American: 
 Mr Eliot has lived abroad so long that we rarely think of him as an American and he is never written about from the point of view of his relation to other American authors. 
 Yet one suspects that his real significance is less that of a prophet of European disintegration than of a poet of the American Puritan temperament. 
 Compare him with Hawthorne, Henry James, E.A. Robinson and Edith Wharton: all these writers have their Waste Land, which is the aesthetic and emotional waste land of the Puritan character and their chief force lies in the intensity with which they communicate emotions of deprivation and chagrin. 
 It is not at all incongruous that Wilson, who thus insisted on Eliot's Americanness, should a few years later, in his pioneering classic Axel's Castle  (1931), insist on Eliot's Frenchness, thus giving substance and weight to Untermeyer's too glib acknowledgement of &bquo;the Laforgue mechanism&equo;. 
 By taking seriously Eliot's debt to the French symbolistes  (as before him only Allen Tate had done, in The New  Republic , 30 June 1926), Wilson was still stressing Eliot's Americanness by showing at any rate how un-British he was. 
 Not surprisingly,  though deplorably, British and also many American readers continued to ignore Eliot's French affinities, following instead the hints that Eliot had dropped for their benefit in his criticism, implying his kinship with such solidly English writers as Donne and Webster. 
 As Tate remarked austerely, &bquo;His Eliabethanism has indubitably been too ingenuously appraised by some critics&equo;. 
 If we chronicle not how Eliot's reputation was advanced, but how Eliot's poetry (and all modern poetry) came to be understood, the part played by Allen Tate bulks very large and honourably. 
 He was among the first to champion Eliot. 
 Already as a young man of twenty-four he had pressed Eliot's claims upon his seniors, John Crowe Ransom and Donald Davidson, in the circle of the Nashville &bquo;fugitives&equo;; and this initially provincial dispute was played out on a national stage as early as 1923 when, in the New York Evening Post  Literary Review , Ransom, with the courtly composure that was to be his hallmark, tried to promote Robert Graves before Eliot, only to be taken to task in the same columns by his younger associate. 
 The exchange shows neither Ransom nor Tate at his best. 
 But both were themselves poets, and by that token were concerned more urgently than other commentators, even Edmund Wilson. 
 From 1927 onwards, as the consequences of Eliot's baptism into the Anglican church showed up in the imagery of &bquo;Journey of the Magi&equo;, &bquo;A Song for Simeon&equo;, &bquo;Animula&equo;, and most conspicuously &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo; (1930), Tate, open to the solicitations of Christian belief, took up the running on Eliot's behalf from the non-believer Wilson. 
 It was not easy. 
 Tate, an ambitious poet whose few irreplaceable poems were yet to come, was by 1927 in animated correspondence with two poets, Yvor Winters (1900&ndash;1968) and Hart Crane (1899-1932), who were at one, if in little else, in their certainty that Eliot's fame and Eliot's precedent were bad news for American poetry. 
 Already in 1926 ( The New Republic , 30 June) Tate was obliged &mdash; faced with the aridity in diction and imagery of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; &mdash; to concede that &bquo;It is possible that he has nothing more to say in poetry&equo;. 
 Yet this admission was not so grievous for Tate as it would have been for others. 
 For Tate's very distinguished criticism, then and afterwards, was always more concerned with the socio-cultural conditions for poetry than with poetry itself. 
 And so it was not with any special disappointment that Tate envisaged how Eliot's message, his distinctively American apprehension of Europe, might thereafter be conveyed less in poems than in his conduct of The Criterion , the magazine he had begun to edit in 1923: 
 Going home to Europe, Mr Eliot has had to understand Europe; he could not quite sufficiently be the European simply  to feel that he was there; he has been forced to envisage it with a reminiscent philosophy. 
 And it is not insignificant that the quarterly of which he is the editor is the first British journal which has attempted to relate the British mind to the total European mind; that has attempted a rational synthesis of the traditions of Roman culture; that has, in a word, contemplated order. 
 And Tate proceeded to cite, with equanimity and approval, some of the non-English writers whom Eliot had solicited for The Criter-  ion , or else had approved there: Charles Maurras, Paul Val&eacute;ry, Henri Massis, Oswald Spengler &mdash; several of whom would not unjustly, though with the benefit of hindsight, be condemned later as Fascist or proto-Fascist. 
 But in any case there was a grave difficulty. 
 For if Eliot's debt to the French poets went beyond an easy charting of &bquo;influences&equo;, or the neat and better than neat adaptation of French lines (for instance, from Laforgue) into English, it could only have meant an elimination from poetry of any notion of &bquo;message&equo;. 
 &bquo;Message&equo; was precisely whit French poetry, at least since Mallarm&eacute; if not before, had set its face against. 
 But alike in the British and the American traditions the expectation that the poet would have a message was so ingrained that even by those readers most alert to and informed about Eliot's French connections The Waste Land  was still thought to deliver an urgent signal &mdash; usually about the bankruptcy of the European, or the Western, cultural and civic traditions. 
 In this dilemma, Eliot was less than helpful to his apologists. 
 The editor of The Criterion , from 1923 and more insistently from 1926, revealed himself as a writer with indeed a message, of a very bleak and uncompromising sort, affronting at almost every point the suppositions of secular liberalism. 
 And it was asking too much of readers that they should insulate Eliot the editor and editorialist from Eliot the poet; so that they should read &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo; without feeling that they were being nudged into the Roman Catholic or the Anglo-Catholic church &mdash; 
 At the first turning of the second stair 
 I turned and saw below 
 The same shape twisted on the banister 
 Under the vapour in the fetid air 
 Struggling with the devil of the stairs who wears 
 The deceitful face of hope and of despair. 
 At the second turning of the second stair 
 I left them twisting, turning below; 
 There were no more faces and the stair was dark, 
 Damp, jagg&egrave;d, like an old man's mouth drivelling, beyond repair. 
 Or the toothed gullet of an ag&egrave;d shark. 
 At the first turning of the third stair 
 Was a slotted window bellied like the fig's fruit 
 And beyond the hawthorn blossom and a pasture scene 
 The broadbacked figure drest in blue and green 
 Enchanted the maytime with an antique flute. 
 Blown hair is sweet, brown hair over the mouth blown, 
 Lilac and brown hair; 
 Distraction, music of the flute, stops and steps of the mind 
 over the third stair, 
 Fading, fading; strength beyond hope and despair 
 Climbing the third stair. 
 Lord, I am not worthy 
 Lord, I am not worthy 
 but speak the word only. 
 It is perfectly true that there is nothing conclusively in the poem to make us identify the first stair with Dante's Inferno , the second with his Purgatorio , the third with Paradiso ; as there is not (a more piercing uncertainty) anything to determine for us whether &bquo;the broadbacked figure drest in blue and green&equo;, with his &bquo;music of the flute&equo;, is an image of what must be renounced in order to achieve Paradise, or else an image of how terrestrial life can most nearly attain the paradisal. 
 But no one will seriously maintain that the verses do not have a design upon us; that they do not promulgate a message &mdash; the message that all secular explanations of human life are vain and inadequate. 
 That the alternative religious explanation should still not know what value to put on &bquo;music of the flute&equo; &mdash; this will be experienced by some as a cruel disappointment, by others as a welcome acknowledgement that dogmatic certainty on the large scale can comprehend uncertainties on the small. 
 But in either or any case their verses must surely confound the French theorists: the poem as a construction of words must be &mdash; at least when the words come from such a charged area of human experience as these do &mdash; a construction also of sentiments and ideas. 
 The poem does convey a message, though the message cannot be at every point decoded. 
 Allen Tate rose to this challenge. 
 His essay on &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo;  ( The Hound and Horn , January-March 1931) has been anthologized many times, and rightly. 
 It is a masterpiece of literary criticism, precisely by being much more than that; under its surface is the furious rejection by Tate, now consciously an alienated Southerner and impenitent Confederate, of the scientific humanism of Yankee America. 
 Tate saw clearly the point at issue: &bquo;Mr Eliot's critics are a little less able each year to see the poetry for Westminster Abbey; the wood is all trees&equo;. 
 And his retort, masterfully bold though disingenuous, is that &bquo;in a discussion of Mr Eliot's poetry, his doctrine has little to command interest in itself&equo;. 
 Of &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo; Tate said, among much else that was penetrating: 
 These six poems are a brief moment of religious experience in an age that believes religion to be a kind of defeatism and puts its hope for man in finding the right secular order. 
 The mixed realism and symbolism of &bquo;The Waste Land&equo; issued in irony. 
 The direct and lyrical method of the new poems creates the simpler aesthetic quality of humility. 
 The latter quality comes directly out of the former, and there is a nice continuity in Mr Eliot's work. 
 Before he is through, Tate is claiming that &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo; represents &bquo;probably&hellip; the only valid religious poetry we have&equo;, and he isolates two features of the writing which lead him to think this. 
 One, which need not concern us, has to do with imagery. 
 The other emerges when he remarks in the opening lines &bquo;the regular yet halting rhythm, the smooth uncertainty of movement which may either proceed to greater regularity or fall away into improvisation&equo;. 
 This perception is picked up later, more than once, as Tate moves through the poem: &bquo;subtly and imperceptibly the rhythm has changed&hellip;&equo;, &bquo;there is constant and sudden change of rhythm&hellip;&equo;, &bquo;a broken and distracted rhythm&equo;. 
 If we read &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo; through with Tate's commentary at our elbow, we see at any given point what he means: he has a good ear, as we might expect from his own poems (which are however metrical, as &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo; isn't). 
 And we may agree that what binds together the six parts of &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo; is in large part something rhythmical. 
 It remains true that in Tate's criticism and since (for no advance has been made in this quarter) &bquo;rhythm&equo; and &bquo;movement&equo; are wholly impressionistic &mdash; you hear what the critic is talking about, or else you don't. 
 This is one area where modern criticism has notably failed. 
 To be sure, the vocabulary for defining such rhythmical effects is yet to seek; but should not critics apply themselves to seeking and finding that vocabulary, instead of pursuing semantic and allusive niceties? 
 In all the many thousands  of words that have been expended on Eliot's achievements, this crucial matter &mdash; his alertness to, and exploiting of, the rhythms of the English verse-line &mdash; remains a vacuum, occupied only by unsupported and insupportable appeals to &bquo;the ear&equo;. 
 In 1927 Tate's correspondents Winters and Crane had been discussing between themselves not Eliot but William Carlos Williams (1883&ndash;1963). 
 On 19 March that year Crane told Winters that &bquo;Williams probably means less to me than to you&equo;, and then proceeded to a hesitant account of how he felt about this one of their older contemporaries: 
 &mdash; There is no doubt of the charm of almost all of W's work. 
 I except the Paterson and Struggle of Wings lately published in the Dial. 
 I think them both highly disorganized. 
 But in most of Williams' work I feel the kind of observations being &bquo;made&equo;&hellip; seem to me too casual, however delightfully phrased, to be especially interesting&hellip; 
 Later in the letter, considering apparently a different sort of poem written by Williams, Hart Crane confesses: 
 Personally I often delight in some of these excursions of W's &mdash; but I won't &bquo;approve&equo; of them. 
 They are too precious, insulate to all but &mdash; at least I fancy &mdash; a few &bquo;choice spirits&equo;, and even then rather toylike. 
 I don't mean that I'm a democrat. 
 But I don't believe in encouraging the fancy &mdash; as long as there is imagination. 
 It is impossible to recognize in the poet thus characterized &mdash; &bquo;precious&equo;, &bquo;insulate&equo;, &bquo;toylike&equo; &mdash; the William Carlos Williams whom American  opinon  over the last thirty years has promoted as a respectable, and better than respectable, counterweight to Eliot. 
 For one thing, the poet thus extolled has been presented as above all poetically &bquo;a democrat&equo;. 
 Yet Crane's assessment of Williams still has its validity, as is apparent if we consider (wearily, for it is the instance always cited) Williams's &bquo;The Red Wheelbarrow&equo;. 
 The British poet Charles Tomlinson has cited this piece to enforce his contention that &bquo;There is no occasion too small for the poet's celebration&equo;. 
 But is this, in any case, true? 
 Commonsense, not without distinguished endorsement from past centuries, thinks as Hart Crane did that it is not true  at all; that on the contrary there are occasions too trivial, too lacking in dignity or resonance, to deserve the ceremoniousness that, as Tomlinson perceived, verse-writing always brings with it. 
 The unfortunate effect in such cases is portentousness; and &bquo;The Red Wheelbarow&equo; is surely in this way portentous : 
 so much depends 
 upon 
 a red wheel 
 barrow 
 glazed with rain 
 water 
 beside the white 
 chickens. 
 &bquo;So much depends&equo;, says the little squib (for it is nothing more), on the wheelbarrow, the glaze of rain, the chickens. 
 But just how much does  depend? 
 The momentousness of the sparsely furnished scene is blankly asserted, not proved. 
 Or rather it is  proved &mdash; by sleight of hand; for if the little scene is not momentous, how did it come to be framed, in all its sparsity, by so much white paper? 
 The reverential hush is thus not only demanded, but enforced. 
 The poet cannot lose; whatever claims he makes for the momentousness of his subjectmatter are vindicated simply by the way those claims are made. 
 Such poetry is invulnerable, existing in a self-sealed and selfjustifying realm called &bquo;aesthetic&equo;, from which no appeal is allowed, or can be made, to other realms like the ethical or the civic. 
 The literary histories invite us to associate such a belief in the unbreachable autonomy of art with haughty and disdainful decadents of the 1880s and 1890s. 
 The achievement of Williams, of his followers and admirers, has been to show that the most secure haven for such doctrines is on the contrary in an ideology that is aggressively egalitarian, and also secular. 
 For the belief that &bquo;there is no occasion too small&equo; is naturally at home in a society that resists any ranking of certain human and civic occasions below or above certain others. 
 And thus it seems that liberal social democracy cossets and protects the aesthete as no other form of society does. 
 Williams's &bquo;It all depends&equo; asserts and takes for granted the absence of any agreed hierarchies, hence the freedom of any individual to establish and assert his own hierarchy, without fear of challenge. 
 &bquo;Spring and All&equo;, a more substantial and widely praised poem, follows the same procedure as &bquo;The Red Wheelbarrow&equo; with the added spice of faux-na&iuml;f   cuteness (announced in the very title, and taken up in epithets like &bquo;twiggy&equo;). 
 One hopes that is not what Crane had in mind when he credited Williams's poems with &bquo;charm&equo;. 
 Williams had certainly written better poems than these, and doubtless Yvor Winters had those others in mind when, in Poetry  for May 1928, he wrote of &bquo;the most magnificent master of English and of human emotions since Thomas Hardy, William Carlos Williams&equo;. 
 Significantly, this was in a review mostly concerned to deplore Eliot's influence on poetic style. 
 At that time hardly anyone but Winters would have named Williams in the same breath as Eliot, and it is characteristic of Winters's perversity (or his independence) that thirty years later, when it had become usual to set Williams up against Eliot, Winters's opinion of Williams had long been much less favourable. 
 However, he never ceased to admire a poem like &bquo;The Widow's Lament in Springtime&equo;: 
 Sorrow is my own yard 
 where the new grass 
 flames as it has flamed 
 often before but not 
 with the cold fire 
 that closes round me this year. 
 Thirtyfive years 
 I lived with my husband. 
 The plumtree is white today 
 with masses of flowers. 
 Masses of flowers 
 load the cherry branches 
 and color some bushes 
 yellow and some red 
 but the grief in my heart 
 is stronger than they 
 for though they were my joy 
 formerly, today I noticed them 
 and turned away forgetting. 
 Today my son told me 
 that in the meadows 
 at the edge of the heavy woods 
 in the distance, he saw 
 trees of white flowers. 
 I feel that I would like 
 to go there 
 and fall into those flowers 
 and sink into the marsh near them. 
 This must be the sort of writing that Crane had in mind when he applauded Williams (still rather grudgingly, however) for sometimes attaining &bquo;the classic manner of the old Chinese poets&equo;. 
 Certainly the deliberate na&iuml;vet&eacute; here is not in the least false, but has the limpid directness of some of the Chinese poems that Pound had marvellously transfigured in Cathay  (1915). 
 And so it was reasonable for Crane and Winters, who in the twenties was reaching for this style in his own poems, to call such writing &bquo;imagist&equo;. 
 (Williams however in such a poem beautifully weaves the syntax of the sentence into and over his verse-lines &mdash; which is not a resource that most imagists were aware of.) 
 Certainly this limpidity is not within Eliot's reach even when he is trying to be limpid, as in &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo;;, and of course the experience of a simple person enduring a commonplace and unavoidable sorrow &mdash; is such as Eliot could never manage, early or late. 
 It has to be pointed out, to those who are sure that Eliot is a great poet, what vast tracts of human experience are never touched on in his poetry. 
 Williams himself had entered the lists against Eliot, saying of Eliot's early poetry (and Pound's also): 
 It is the latest touch from the literary cuisine, it adds to the pleasant outlook from the club window. 
 If to do this, if to be a Whistler at best, in the art of poetry, is to reach the height of poetic expression, then Ezra and Eliot have approached it and tant pis  for the rest of us. 
 And Williams jeered: 
 I do not overlook De Gourmont's plea for a meeting of the nations but I do believe that when they meet Paris will be more than slightly abashed to find parodies of the middle ages, Dante and Langue D'Oc foisted upon it as the best in United States poetry. 
 This was in The Little Review  for May 1919, where Williams was taking issue with praise of Eliot by one of Pound's British friends, Edgar Jepson; but Williams's hostility to British culture ran deeper than that, and was to be a permanent feature of his outlook. 
 His malevolence towards Pound, his friend since their college days in Philadelphia, is extraordinary; and when in 1920 he amplified this piece in the prologue to his Kora in Hell , Williams compounded the offence by quoting selectively from a private letter that Pound had written him. 
 Astonishingly, Pound did not break off relations. 
 Instead he was provoked, in a letter, into one of the most illuminating  and betraying comments that he ever made, on Eliot, Williams and himself: 
 There is a blood poison in America; you can idealize the place (easier now that Europe is so damd shaky) all you like, but you haven't a drop off the cursed blood in you, and you don't need to fight the disease day and night; you never had to. 
 Eliot has it perhaps worse than I have &mdash; poor devil. 
 You have the advantage of arriving in the milieu with a fresh flood of Europe in your veins, Spanish, French, English, Danish. 
 You had not the thin milk of New York and New England from the pap; and you can therefore keep the environment outside you, and decently objective. 
 ( Selected Letters , ed. 
 D.D. 
 Paige, p.158) 
 Pound here anticipates, and paints in a blacker hue, Edmund Wilson's recognition that Eliot is &bquo;a poet of the American Puritan temperament&equo;, and Pound claims to be tarred with the same brush himself. 
 One must mind one's manners (and one's metaphors &mdash; tarring with brushes, for instance!) when venturing on to the territory that Pound opens up with his reflections on the ethnic mix of the American population, and the distinction that he makes between the older stock (Eliots and Pounds) and the relative late-come immigrants (Williams's stock on both sides). 
 Moreover Pound's anti-Semitism, later so notorious, certainly casts a sinister light on his readiness to broach these issues. 
 Yet these matters, it has been suggested, lie deep &mdash; indeed, unutterably  deep &mdash; in every American psyche; and it is good that from time to time the unutterable be uttered &mdash; it is, one might say, one of the things that we look to poets for. 
 There can be little doubt for instance that the doubtfulness or downright hostility felt towards Eliot by some Americans, particularly in recent decades, derives from the sort  of American Eliot was &mdash; and remained, long after he had taken British citizenship. 
 Eliot hailed from St Louis, but the Eliots there seem to have regarded themselves as Bostonian and Unitarian missionaries to that mid-western Philistia. 
 The poet did not share this sense, he actively disliked it, but he could not escape &mdash; not even in Europe &mdash; from what he saw as the balefulness of that inheritance. 
 He was what we have learned to call a WASP, and his lifetime coincided with the process, not yet quite completed, by which that caste &mdash; white Anglo-Saxon protestants of the northeast &mdash; was supplanted from the position of privilege that they had enjoyed from the first days of the Republic. 
 That privilege, and the airs and presumption that went with it, are still resented; and some of the resentment has rubbed off on the poet.  
 Pound's case is by no means so clear-cut. 
 At least one of his grandparents had made a career on the frontier; and in The Cantos  this forebear, Thaddeus Coleman Pound, makes several entries, always with an encouraging flourish on the drums. 
 It is the more remarkable that Pound in his letter to Williams should diagnose himself as suffering from a milder form of Eliot's disease; most of the time, alike in his life and his poetry, he seems to be denying it by strenuously over-compensating. 
 Only once, late in life when he made as much of an excuse as he would ever make for his anti-Semitism, did Pound ever again enter the plea for himself that he suffered from the cultural anaemia of growing up in a suburb of an Eastern seaboard city. 
 As for Williams, who had an English father, it would be easy to explain away his hostility to England; but the sorrier likelihood is that he saw quite justly the baleful mixture of timidity and arrogance which characterized literary London in his lifetime. 
 However, Pound's diagnosis of Williams's condition was surely perceptive: Williams could abide American reality (where Pound and Eliot had to flee from it) because, as in the admirable &bquo;To Elsie&equo; (&equo; The pure products of America / go crazy'), he remained the immigrant, the outsider looking in on the behaviour of the nation that he had been, by the sheerest accident, born to. 
 Yvor Winters, eschewing lurid and unstable metaphors of bloodpoisoning and leukaemia, applied the discipline of intellectual history to isolate the virus that for him too disabled American literature of the north-east. 
 It was, he decided, Emersonianism &mdash; a disease (if that is what it is) which is certainly no less rife now than it was when Winters made his diagnosis fifty years ago. 
 This investigation was part of the wholesale scrutiny and revaluation that Winters was shocked into by the suicide of Hart Crane in 1932. 
 In that revaluation, whereas Pound held his modest but respectable place, Williams was drastically denoted with Eliot rising in the scale against him. 
 Winters in California perhaps thought himself securely distant from the seat of the infection; he never visited Europe, still less was he tempted to expatriate himself. 
 Pound's forbearance towards Williams remains astonishing, the more when we realize that Williams's challenge to him came when he was remarkably uncertain and at sea about his own talents and the direction in which he should go. 
 Bowled over by the originality and assurance of Joyce's Ulysses , which was being sent to him by the author in typescript section by section, Pound was between 1920 and 1922 dismantling the several hundred lines of The Cantos  that he had written and published, and recasting them radically, using some of the same material but trying for a less personalized presentation. 
 Moreover Pound had reached Williams's conclusion about  literary London, and in 1920 left for Paris, whence in 1924 he moved to Rapallo. 
 His acrid and accusing farewell to London was Hugh  Selwyn Mauberley  (1920). 
 But the poem of his that he most needed reassurance about was Homage to Sextus Propertius  (1919), and for that he had to wait a long time. 
 When Eliot in 1928, loyally reciprocating services rendered, edited Pound's Selected Poems , he insisted on excluding the propertius poem, and it was not until 1932 that Basil Bunting wrote, already retrospectively, &bquo;In my considered opinion, &bquo;Propertius&equo; was the most important poem of our times, surpassing alike &bquo;Mauberley&equo; and &bquo;The Waste Land&equo;.&equo; 
 This was in The New English Weekly , a London journal of very limited circulation; there appears to have been no comparable acknowledgement in the poet's native land. 
 Bunting, who respected Eliot, applied himself first to rebutting the reasons which Eliot gave, in his Introduction to Selected Poems ; for omitting this long and elaborate poem: 
 It is impossible to understand why Eliot should have excluded the &bquo;Propertius&equo; from his selection of Pound's work. 
 The plea of its difficulty will not hold, for as a consummation is always simpler than a beginning, the &bquo;Propertius&equo; is certainly much simpler than some of Pound's shorter earlier works whose content is sometimes elusive, tenuous, evanescent&hellip; 
 &hellip; 
 The question of the relation of Pound's poem with the book of Propertius's elegies does not arise, except for the literary historian. 
 There is no claim that this is a translation. 
 The correspondence, the interpenetration of ancient and modern, is Pound's, not Propertius's&hellip; 
 Half a century later, such commentary as there is on Pound's poem is still for the most part concerned with this question that for Bunting &bquo;does not arise&equo;. 
 When he goes on to justify his high estimate of the poem, Bunting specifies: 
 The beautiful step of the verse, the cogent movement of thought and feeling throughout, the sensitive perception of the little balanced in the great and their mutual dependence, the extraordinary directness, here and there quite naked, achieved in spite of the complexity of the whole conception;&hellip; 
 Some of these claims can be considered, and either allowed or disallowed, only by looking at the work as a whole; others can be at least understood after reading only a few lines:  
 My cellar does not date from Numa pompilius, 
 Nor bristle with wine jars, 
 Nor is it equipped with a frigidaire patent; 
 Yet the companions of the Muses 
 will keep their collective nose in my books, 
 And weary with historical data, they will turn to my dance tune. 
 Happy who are mentioned in my pamphlets, 
 the songs shall be a fine tomb-stone over their beauty. 
 But against this? 
 Neither expensive pyramids scraping the stars in their route, 
 Nor houses modelled upon that of Jove in East Elis, 
 Nor the monumental effigies of Mausolus, 
 are a complete elucidation of death. 
 Flame burns, rain sinks into the cracks 
 And they all go to rack ruin beneath the thud of the years. 
 Stands genius a deathless adornment, 
 a name not to be worn out with the years. 
 Noting in passing how conclusively the &bquo;frigifaire paten&equo; rules out any notion of a translation of propertius (unless it were a translation in the sense of a raucous travesty or &bquo;put-down&equo; &mdash; and indeed some academic latinists did misconceive Pound's poem in that way), some early readers were understandably disconcerted by the inversions of conversational or prosaic word-order &mdash; &bquo;Happy who&equo;, &bquo;Stands genius&equo; &mdash; especially from a poet who some years before had seemed to polemicize for just that rule about word-order which he here flouted. 
 But these inversions were quite different in purpose and effect from those that Pound had practised indiscriminately in his earliest collections, and thereafter castigated; these were not poeticisms, but indications that he was addressing a sophisticated urban intelligentsia, that of Great War London, just as propertius had addressed the sophisticates of Augustan Rome. 
 The clue is in the diction, which gives &bquo;are a complete elucidation of&equo;, for &bquo;clears up&equo; or &bquo;makes clear&equo;. 
 The poet writes for, and gives a voice to, people whose privileged education has closed off for them the possibility of speaking as limpidly and directly as the speaker of &bquo;The Widow's Lament in Springtime&equo;. 
 A special pathos is achieved when the poetry acts out the predicament of people whose all too expert command of language debars them (paradoxically) from expressing a common human sorrow &mdash; mortality, the fear of it, and its conclusiveness &mdash; as limpidly as could Williams's &bquo;widow&equo;. 
 In the end the speaker of Homage to Sextus Propertius  wins through to articulating that common  plight as memorably as Williams's speaker does &mdash; with, as Bunting says, &bquo;extraordinary directness&hellip; quite naked&equo;. 
 But Pound's speaker, so far from na&iuml;ve, has had to struggle through to that desired but unfamiliar nakedness; and Pound's verse enacts the struggle. 
 It may seem that when Bunting speaks of &bquo;the beautiful step of the verse, he is gesturing into a void not much less than Allen Tate when he wrote of the &bquo;rhythm&equo; and the &bquo;movement&equo; of Eliot's &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo;. 
 But in fact the metaphor &bquo;step&equo;, implying tread, implies also volition and direction. 
 More important, since Pound's use of indentations conveys visually the effect of the verse-lines being &bquo;stepped&equo; down the page, to speak of &bquo;step&equo; shifts attention from what rhythmically happens between the start and end of a line to how the poet manages to turn from one line to another. 
 (And &bquo;verse&equo; from versus , means precisely &bquo;turn&equo;.) 
 To be sure, this is still rudimentary and indefinite. 
 But certain writings by Pound, Bunting and a couple of others can take us a little further. 
 What all of them contend is that the auditory effect of all  English-language verse can only in a schematic and starveling fashion be pin-pointed by applying the only two measurements that traditional scansion recognizes: on the one hand the number of syllables, on the other the number of occurrences of ictus  or &bquo;stress&equo;. 
 One feature of English verse that is scanted by this method, or can be acknowledged only incidentally, is one that every careful reader knows from his or her experience: tempo , the speeding up or slowing down of enunciation, and therefore of apprehension, as we read through a line or through several lines in sequence. 
 This seems to be intimately connected with another principle, which is more radical and therefore more important: that of quantity , of syllables as being, in relation to their contiguous syllables, either long or short. 
 The variation between English-language speakers about what syllables, in effect what vowels, they treat as long or short, is so great that there can be no question of imposing on English verse a quantitative metre such as was used for ancient Latin (doubtless with some strain for those who spoke classical Latin with dialectal variations as to quantity). 
 This granted, it remains true, as anyone's experience of his own and others' speech-habits will confirm, that some English vowels are experienced and expressed as relatively long, others as relatively short. 
 Not just unmetrical poets like Pound (for the most part) and Bunting, but also a strictly metrical poet like the later Yvor Winters, came to think that the finest auditory effects in English-language verse were attained by those poets who attended to the quantitative elements in British or American speech as an incalculable dimension super-added to the recognized and calculable dimensions of syllable-count and stresscount. 
 Quantity in this sense, duration , is what musicians and musical  composers are continually concerned with; and so it is not surprising that poets of this way of thinking, like Pound and Bunting, show themselves avidly interested in poetry which has been, not at a level of theory but as a fact of performance, intimately associated with music: poetry that has been set, or has been written in the hope of being set, to music. 
 It is notable that it was Bunting, in his generation the only British emulator of Pound, who was most confident and insistent that in these matters Pound's immediate master was American, the Walt Whitman of &bquo;Out of the Ocean Endlessly Rocking&equo;. 
 It is in any case certain that for years before Homage to Sextus Propertius  Pound had been studying, not for their content chiefly but as models of musical form, the poems in quantitative metre of ancient Greece. 
 (His British predecessor in such technical study had been Thomas Hardy; but that is another, and difficult, topic.) 
 These matters are important because they explain how Pound and Eliot, who had campaigned as a team and would help each other for many years to come, radically differed not just in themes and attitudes (of which something will be said hereafter) but at this deep level, in the not altogether conscious interstices of their craft. 
 Fortunately Eliot declared himself unequivocally, in an essay, &bquo;Reflections on Vers Libre :&equo;&hellip; the ghost of some simple metre should lurk behind the arras in even the &bquo;freest&equo; verse; to advance menacingly as we doze, and withdraw as we arouse'. 
 This is what Pound could never have said. 
 When, infrequently, he wanted to write in &bquo;some simple metre&equo;, he did so; but when more often he wanted to get away from standard metres, he left them behind altogether, no ghost of them lurking behind his arras. 
 The difference between the two poets corresponds (not quite exactly, because the nature and history of French verse differs so greatly from English) to the distinction that the French make between vers libre  and vers lib&eacute;r&eacute; ; between, we may say, free verse and freed verse. 
 Eliot's practice, as his remarks just quoted make clear, was always &bquo;freed&equo; verse: verse freed indeed from the constraints of traditional prosody, yet rather constantly recalling to the reader's ear one of the traditional patterns it was departing from. 
 (Hence, notably in &bquo;Gerontion&equo;, Eliot's ability to approximate and even conform to Jacobean blank verse, yet to depart from it smoothly when he pleased.) Pound's verse on the contrary was, at least after Homage to Sextus Propertius , free, not &bquo;freed&equo;: the rhythms that he sought and attained either had never appeared before in the language, or else had not appeared there for many centuries. 
 His departure was much more radical. 
 And yet he was not doctrinaire about it, having declared on the contrary (as early as 1917, significantly in a review of Eliot's Prufrock and Other Observations) :  
 Unless a man can put some thematic invention into vers libre , he would perhaps do well to stick to &bquo;regular&equo; metres, which have certain chances of being musical from their form, and certain other chances of being musical through his failure in fitting the form. 
 The one who was  doctrinaire was Williams, who regarded the iambic measure as a chief curse of the English legacy from which American poetry must free itself if it was ever to stand on its own. 
 However, Winters was to decide that Williams was &bquo;wholly incapable of coherent thought&equo;, and when Williams tried to explain his own rhythmical procedures he invented &bquo;the variable foot&equo; &mdash; which is, as has been remarked, the equivalent of a rubber inch. 
 Williams had a good ear, and since his death some of his admirers have made more sense of his procedures than he could ever make for himself, but the lamentable effect of his example has been to lead poets to trust their ear implicitly, thus discrediting the very notion of measure . 
 The closeness of Pound's and Eliot's collaboration when they were young did not become clear Until 1972. 
 In that year comparisons of Eliot with Pound were stimulated, and exacerbated, by the publication of what were called the &bquo;drafts and transcripts&equo; of The Waste Land ; that is to say, the heterogeneous packet of typescripts and manuscripts which Eliot had dumped on Pound in Paris, out of which Pound had helped Eliot to extricate the poem that for forty years had been known under that title. 
 In most ways this book reflected great credit on both poets, and was affecting evidence of their mutual trust, of how their common dedication to the poetic calling had precluded any taint of rivalry or wounded amour-propre . 
 On the other hand the material which Eliot had put into Pound's hands turned out to be so inchoate that many readers were led to wonder how far the poem as they had it all these years was in any authentic sense Eliot's at all. 
 To be fair to him, he had repeatedly hinted that, when the evidence was in, it would show that Pound's contribution went far beyond the mere passing of judgement on particular passages; and indeed it turned out that the very structure of the poem had been extricated by Pound, rather than conceived and composed by the poet whose name appeared on the title-page. 
 This was disconcerting, to say the least. 
 It was not easy to think of a precedent, and one could be forgiven for concluding that the notorious obscurity of the poem came about not by the author's design but accidentally, because the work was the product not of one mind but of two. 
 The poem, we might say, is in two minds about itself and its own meaning.  
 But that is not the whole story. 
 For Pound undoubtedly made the poem more obscure by asking for the excision of some transitional and bridging passages where the language was not at full pressure, but on the other hand he caused to be removed some extended sections which, being plainly extraneous, could only have added to readers' bafflement. 
 Moreover in some important respects Pound was more old-fashioned than Eliot. 
 As his later disastrous interventions in politics would make clear, he was a realist in quite a simple-minded sense, one who was concerned for public life, and believed (like activists of the Left) that a poet had the right and the duty to act in and upon that life quite directly; whereas the oddly distant weariness of Eliot's political pronouncements, even when he was most engag&eacute;  as editor of True Criterion , revealed a man for whom the psychological reality of private torments took priority over any reality which announced itself as social and public. 
 Thus Pound was quite ready, and became eager, to deliver a message, though with more obliquities and delays than the impatiently moralistic reader could see reason for; whereas Eliot, true to his inheritance from French symbolisme , was sceptical and chary of conveying in poetry any message at all. 
 (Pound had studied some of the same French poets, notably Laforgue and Rimbaud, but he had profited by them in a quite different way from Eliot, and he was averse to the central thrust of the symboliste  endeavour, to which indeed the imagist or imagiste  movement which he had sponsored had been intended as a challenging alternative.) 
 The difference between the two of them showed up in The Waste , Land  drafts. 
 For among the rather few objections by Pound that Eliot paid no attention to were one or two which would have required him to make consistent, in terms of locality and historical period, some of his references to London life. 
 Eliot seems to have ignored these suggestions because for him the physical and social landscape of London was no more than a screen on which to project a phantasmagoria that expressed his own personal disorders and desperations (partly sexual, as one might expect, and as the drafts make clear); whereas Pound seems to have supposed that the subject of the poem was London in all its historical and geographical actuality, much as the city of Dublin was from one point of view the subject of Joyce's Ulysses . 
 Quite independent of Pound, most admiring commentators have read the poem more nearly as Pound read it than as Eliot intended. 
 They could always have maintained of course that, whatever the poet's intentions, the poem as an achieved entity answered to their interpretations. 
 But critics of the twenties, knowing nothing of Pound's part in the poem, and ignorant also of Eliot's private sufferings through his wretched first marriage,  saw no need to go so far around, to support their conviction or assumption that The Waste Land  was a poem with a message. 
 What was known about Pound's association with Eliot did Pound's reputation no good at all. 
 The insufferable Untermeyer in 1923 castigated the texture of The Waste Land  as &bquo;that formless plasma which Mr Ezra Pound likes to call a Sordelloform&equo;; and in the same year in London, Clive Bell, the voice of &bquo;Bloomsbury&equo;, said of Eliot that &bquo;no aesthetic theory can explain his indiscreet boosting of&hellip; the lamentable Ezra Pound&equo;. 
 But the most vicious  discriminiation  had come in the previous year, from Edmund Wilson, who applauded the structure of The Waste Land  by contrasting it to &bquo;the extremely ill-focused Eight Cantos of his imitator Mr Ezra Pound, who presents only a bewildering mosaic with no central emotion to provide a key&equo;. 
 Eliot, distressed, wrote to Wilson and to another of his champions, Gilbert Seldes, protesting that he did not want to be praised at Pound's expense since be was indebted to Pound (as indeed his dedication to Pound as il miglior fabbro  had elegantly acknowledged). 
 Eliot told Wilson and Seldes that &bquo;I sincerely consider Ezra Pound the most important living poet in the English language&equo;. 
 But the damage had been done, and Wilson's elevation of Eliot at Pound's expense was to be Echoed time and again for at least thirty years, and indeed is still to be heard even today. 
 Pound suffered immediately, in his pocket-book. 
 Always short of money, Pound in the twenties found one outlet after another closed to him and had great difficulty making ends meet. 
 He seems not to have whined, and his only complaint, posthumously recorded by Bunting in his obituary of Pound, is drily judicious: he &bquo;said in the Thirties that Eliot had got stuck because he could not understand Propertius &lsqb;i.e. Pound's Homage &rsqb; and ill the rest had not stuck a few books earlier still&equo;. 
 How early Pound came by this perception is not clear, but certainly he had no illusions from the first that his Cantos , building as they did on the rhythmical and thematic procedures of Homage to  Sextus Propertius , would be found readily acceptable. 
 In 1922 he explained in a letter: 
 Perhaps, as the poem goes on I shall be able to make various things clearer. 
 Having the crust to attempt a poem in 100 or 120 cantos long after all mankind has been commanded never again to attempt a poem of any length, I have to stagger as I can. 
 The first 11 cantos are preparation of the palette. 
 I have to  get  down all the colours or elements I want for the poem. 
 Some perhaps too enigmatically and abbreviatedly. 
 I hope, heaven help me, to bring them into some sort of design and architecture later. 
 ( Selected Letters , p. 180) 
 Excusably perhaps, neither Edmund Wilson nor any one else could understand, or could credit, the scale on which Pound was working: 120 cantos, and by the time Pound died in 1972, the poem had fallen only just short of that. 
 In a poem designed on such a scale (and this evidence of &bquo;design&equo; on such a scale from the first is astonishing) it was obviously illegitimate to look, as Edmund Wilson did, for emotional or affective unity in each or any Canto in isolation. 
 As Pound confessed in another letter in 1933: &bquo;Most Cantos have in them &bquo;binding matter&equo;, i.e. lines holding them into the whole poem and these passages don't much help the reader of an isolated fragment&hellip; 
 More likely to confuse than help'. 
 Pound was in all seriousness embarked on an epic poem (which he defined, following of all unlikely authorities Rudyard Kipling, as &bquo;the tile of the tribe&equo;); he could not and did not expect understanding from readers who supposed that the epic poem had died in the seventeenth century if not before, whose expectations therefore were conditioned by their experience of the brief or else extended lyric. 
 There are lyrical passages or interludes in The Cantos , as in any epic poem, but to excerpt these for applause while deploring their context is to fudge the issue, and evade the challenge of the poem as a whole. 
 The scale on which Pound was working was not clear even to the poet himself; so that the eleven cantos which he originally designated as &bquo;preparation of the palette&equo; are now by responsible commentators considerably extended &mdash; to the extent that the first thirty cantos, which are all that the twenties knew of the poem ( A Draft of XVI Cantos  (Paris, June 1925); A Draft often Cantos  17&ndash;27  (100 copies, September 1928); and A Draft of XXX Cantos  (210 copies, August 1930)), are now often regarded as laying out no the painter's palette the hues that only in subsequent cantos would be combined to polemical and imaginative purpose. 
 Certainly only in the next batch of cantos (post-1930), which began with extended excerpts from the founding fathers of the Republic, would the scale of magnitude of the poem become apparent, also its topicality and its Americanness. 
 Of the first thirty cantos by themselves, no account is more plausible than that of a writer in the New York Herald  Tribune Books  for 9 January 1927, who decided: &bquo;Mr Pound is avowedly writing a history of the Mediterranean basin'. 
 The writer  was Ford Madox Ford, who was among the most loyal as he had been among the first of Pound's friends; in the twenties he was as penurious and as out of fashion as Pound. 
 It is easy to cheat when quoting from these early cantos: either by imposing a seeming self-closure on passages that are in fact open at both ends, or (and as well) by presenting a lyrically appealing passage as typical of the whole. 
 Any quotation must in any case be extensive: 
 So that the Xarites bent over tovarisch. 
 And these are the labours of tovarisch, 
 That tovarisch lay in the earth, 
 And rose, and wrecked the house of the tyrants, 
 And that tovarisch lay then in the earth 
 And the Xarites bent over tovarisch. 
 These are the labours of tovarisch, 
 That tovarisch wrecked the house of the tyrants, 
 And rose, and talked folly on folly, 
 And walked forth and lay in the earth 
 And the Xarites bent over tovarisch. 
 And that tovarisch cursed and blessed without aim, 
 These are the labours of tovarisch, 
 Saying: 
 &bquo;Me Cadmus sowed in the earth 
 And with the thirtieth autumn 
 I return to the earth that made me. 
 Let the five last build the wall; 
 I neither build nor reap. 
 That he came with the gold ships, Cadmus, 
 That he fought with the wisdom, 
 Cadmus, of the gilded prows. 
 Nothing I build 
 And I reap 
 Nothing; with the thirtieth autumn 
 I sleep, I sleep not, I rot 
 And I build no wall. 
 Where was the wall of Eblis 
 At Ventadour, there now are the bees, 
 And in that court, wild grass for their pleasure 
 That they carry back to the crevice 
 Where loose stone hangs upon stone. 
 I sailed never with Cadmus, 
 lifted never stone above stone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Baked and eaten tovarisch! 
 &bquo;Baked and eaten, tovarisch, my boy, 
 &bquo;That is your story. 
 And up again, 
 &bquo;Up and at &bquo;em. 
 Laid never stone upon stone.&equo; 
 &bquo;The air burst into leaf.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hung there flowered acanthus, 
 &bquo;Can you tell the down from the up?&equo; 
 As &bquo;tovarisch&equo; quite raucously announces, Pound here in Canto 27 reflects on the October Revolution in Russia in 1917. 
 And not only the Xarit&egrave;s (or Charit&egrave;s, the Greek Graces) bend some solicitude over the unnamed revolutionary comrade, so does the poet &mdash; for indeed in 1930 Pound's desire for an authoritarian leader in politics was as ready to fix on Lenin as on Mussolini. 
 Rather plainly the poem decides, as others have decided before and since, that the revolution's humble heroes, revolution once accomplished, did not know what to do with the liberation they had achieved. 
 One needs Ford Madox Ford's emphasis on &bquo;the Mediterranean basin, to understand that &bquo;tovarisch&equo; is being dignified by having his exploits measured against the myths of ancient Greece &mdash; for instance, that of Cadmus, founder of Thebes, who sowed dragon's teeth from which sprang warriors which fought among themselves until only five remained. 
 Pound has no recourse to that staple of anti-Russian propaganda in every generation (some of it was being aired in these years in Eliot's Criterion ) according to which the Russian is &bquo;asiatic&equo;, outside the confines of Europe. 
 What will disconcert readers who come to Pound after Eliot, what they will find either refreshing or exasperating, is the literalness of Pound's imagination. 
 When he has tovarisch say, &bquo;Nothing I build&equo;, this is to be understood not allegorically but literally: working of stone, either architecturally or sculpturally, was for Pound the register of culture &mdash; a conviction which he shared in his lifetime with few except the British art-critic whom he knew and esteemed, Adrian Stokes. 
 Thus the reference to the ruined walls of Eblis, in Aquitaine, is not gratuitous; and we know from other passages that Pound's refusal in the last resort to take seriously Russia's contribution to European culture was grounded in his notion that Russia had never produced an indigenous tradition of stone architecture. 
 On the other hand, when in the ruined court of Eblis the bees find &bquo;wild grass for their pleasure&equo;, that is good too. 
 For human building (art) and the processes of germination (nature) are not in this vision opposed, as alternatives we must choose between. 
 The one mirrors the other, and is nourished by the other. 
 To build is as  natural as to procreate. 
 Accordingly tovarisch condemns himself not only because &bquo;nothing I build&equo;, but also because &bquo;I reap/Nothing&equo;; the failure in the one capacity implies a failure in the other. 
 The identity of the two activities is asserted, with a succinctness that only the build-up has made possible, in &bquo;flowered acanthus&equo; ( acanthus , a classical motif of architectural sculpture, is also the stylized representation of specific foliage), and also in &bquo;Can you tell the down from the up?&equo; (for there is no way of deciding whether &bquo;nature&equo; is the &bquo;up&equo; and &bquo;art&equo; the &bquo;down&equo;, or vice-versa). 
 This sanguine trust in the unity and coherence of the universe is as far as possible from &bquo;the American Puritan temperament&equo;, as Eliot suffered it and articulated it. 
 And nearly half a century later, when The Cantos  would tail off (not discreditably) in &bquo;Drafts and Fragments&equo;, Pound would still be purveying the same message, in terms of &bquo;the gardens of Proserpine&equo;, the mineral and metallic gardens that Proserpine according to the myth created in the underworld, to duplicate as &bquo;art&equo; the springing herbage that she inspired in spring and summer through her six months in the overworld. 
 No one in the twenties could have divined this over-arching design, nor did Pound suppose that anyone would. 
 How any of this was relevant to twentieth-century America was precisely the question that Williams had raised when he jeered at &bquo;parodies of the middle ages, Dante and Langue D'Oc&equo; being presented as &bquo;the best in United States poetry&equo;. 
 And it is true that Williams was aware of creative work in American photography and painting, as Pound in his self-exile could not be. 
 But Pound with his invaluable na&iuml;vet&eacute; really believed that the United States was &bquo;a land of opportunity&equo;; that his nation's glory was all in the future, and would be achieved if only Americans would sort out those achievements of European culture (and of non-European cultures also) which were worth their emulating and trying to surpass.  
 Pound as Critic 
 Pound belongs in that sub-class of the species &bquo;critic&equo;, which we call &bquo;poet-critic&equo;. 
 So does Eliot of course, so does William Empson; not to speak of Dryden, Johnson, Coleridge, Arnold. 
 Yes, but unlike Eliot and Empson, Pound &mdash; by the abrupt, brusque and aphoristic way in which he delivers his critical judgements &mdash; insists that we understand them as immediately spun off from the imaginative work, thrown over his shoulder, as it were, as he hurries from one part of the workshop to another. 
 In this, of the great poet-critics of the past the one he most nearly resembles is Dryden, whose criticism virtually always comes before us as the preface to a volume of original imaginative writing &mdash; including translations which, in this too like Pound, Dryden considers no less &bquo;original&equo; than poems he has made up for himself. 
 Eliot and Empson take off their poet's hat, and wear a critic's hat &mdash; that at least is the decorous illusion which, by their style and procedures, they try to maintain; Pound and Dryden on the contrary wear the poet's hat all the time, even when they criticize. 
 To some this seems presumptuous. 
 Perhaps some of Dryden's early readers objected to this presumption in him; there is no doubt that many of Pound's readers have felt affronted, and feel affronted still, by the authority he claims, the impatiently magisterial tone of much of his criticism. 
 For the abrupt, hasty manner of Pound's criticism seems to some readers to carry the implication (to which Pound in fact did not subscribe) that no critic is worth listening to unless he has laboured at the maker's workbench; that all worthwhile criticism of stories comes from story-tellers, that only poets are worth listening to about poems. 
 In the 1930s critics so variously and widely influential as Allen Tate, Yvor Winters and F. R. Leavis each in his own way considered Pound's criticism, or some of it, and then instructed their readers that that criticism could safely be ignored. 
 An instance, and a momentous one, is Tate's review in Poetry  for November 1932, of Pound's How To Read : 
 The real criticism of Mr Pound is not to be directed against his theory as such, but rather at the hasty headlong fashion  in which he presents it, at the logical confusion of his intellect when it is not performing the task which is specifically his own, that task being poetry. 
 The justification of Mr Pound's thesis in How To Read  is not his arguments, but his poetry. 
 Leavis, who countered How To Read  with a booklet, How to Teach  Reading , and Winters, who declared in 1937, &bquo;Mr Pound resembles a village loafer who sees much and understands little&equo;, told the same story as Tate: Pound was a na&iuml;f , an imagination and sensory apparatus that consistently performed better than it knew, in ways that the maker's own discursive intelligence failed to comprehend or measure up to; in Winters's memorable and mordant judgement of 1943, &bquo;a sensibility without a mind, or with as little mind as is well possible&equo;. 
 Take Pound the poet (though in strictly limited dosages, if you listened to Leavis or Winters), and ignore Pound the critic &mdash; the message was loud and clear, and it was attended to. 
 The damage this did to our criticism was as nothing compared with the harm it did to our poetry. 
 Tate, so devoted to Eliot's precedent, appears to have dismissed as amiably perfunctory the respect that Eliot, not quite consistently but repeatedly, accorded to Pound's prose-writings and Pound's literary opinions; and &mdash; so it might be argued, though this is not the place for it &mdash; Tate's own verse, and the verse of those he influenced, were the worse for having taken note of Eliot's precedent without attending equally to Pound's. 
 (For the two sensibilities were radically different.) 
 As late as the 1960s the translations and imitations of Robert Lowell, who had sat at Tate's feet, were widely supposed to have been validated by Pound's precedent in this kind of writing, whereas in truth Lowell's Imitations  allowed themselves liberties such as Pound would never have condoned. 
 Moreover, the advice that in 1932 Tate implicitly offered &mdash; &bquo;Read Pound's poetry, and ignore his criticism&equo; &mdash; was disingenuous. 
 For it turned out that Pound's poetry &mdash; The Cantos  certainly but much of the earlier work also &mdash; could be understood and enjoyed only by those who had attended to Pound s criticism enough to grasp what it was that Pound was trying to do, or conceived himself to be doing, in his poetry. 
 And it was 1952 before that road was taken &mdash; by Hugh Kenner; it was only then that responsible criticism of Pound became possible &mdash; everything before that belongs, as it were, in pre-history. 
 Because Pound the critic seems to be always in his shirt-sleeves sparing a few distraught hours or minutes from the more serious business of writing poems or translating them, his criticism is dispersed, though there is much more of it than we are likely to remember. 
 Much of it indeed &mdash; art criticism and music criticism as well as  criticism of literature &mdash; still languishes in the files of defunct magazines, from which no one seems anxious to rescue it. 
 For the rest, his exceptionally loyal publisher, James Laughlin of New Direc  - tions , exerts himself to keep in print as much as possible. 
 But there is no one book, not even any two or three books, that can be pointed to as constituting the corpus or the canon of Pound's criticism. 
 The chronologically first and formally most decorous of his critical books, The Spirit of Romance  (originally 1910), can very profitably be used &mdash; I speak from experience &mdash; as a manual for able undergraduates; especially if taken along with Confucius to Cummings , the anthology that many decades later Pound compiled along with Marcella Spann. 
 The Spirit of Romance  is undertaken on the principle that Pound never ceased to hammer home, notably in How To Read  and The ABC of Reading : the principle that no one can understand the history of poetry in English unless he or she takes note of poetry in, or responsibly translated out of, other languages than English. 
 Perhaps no one would deny this; but as each generation of students arrives more defiantly or hopelessly monoglot, as a whole new discipline (called &bquo;Comparative Literature&equo;) has come into being to cater for those exceptional persons who can read more languages than one, the need for a classroom manual to redress this state of affairs becomes ever more urgent. 
 And yet, to the best of my knowledge, The Spirit of Romance  and Confucius to Cummings  have no competitors. 
 It is entirely typical of Pound that he should want his criticism to be immediately useful &mdash; to, as he says, &bquo;the neophyte&equo;. 
 And not just students but their teachers would do well to acknowledge themselves neophytes. 
 It is true that Pound does not readily conceive of a reader who is not also an aspiring writer &mdash; something that led Leavis astray when he tried to retort to How To Read ; but there is no harm, and much profit, in letting the student of the history of poetry suppose that he or she is in due course going to write poems. 
 A very different book, much more idiosyncratic in its structure and its procedures, is the one of 1938 called in the American printing Culture , and iii the London edition Guide to Kulchur . 
 This is not a work of criticism though it contains much criticism along the way, and of the first order &mdash; for instance, Pound's respectful demurrer from the high valuation that Eliot had put on Johnson's Vanity of  Human Wishes. 
 Guide to Kulchur  gives us Pound at his most personal, at his most deliberately vulnerable; it is here that we find him wondering aloud, for instance, if the body of his work to that date could be mentioned in the same breath with Thomas Hardy's. 
 Three years before this, Yale University Press had brought out in a very handsome volume called Make It New  seven essays representing Pound's criticism at its most scholarly, on such recondite  topics as Cavalcanti, and Elizabethan Classicists, and early translations of Homer. 
 Pound's point, of course, in these essays reprinted from magazines and from earlier collections like Pavannes &amp; Divisions  (1918) or Instigations  (1920), is that these matters that we think of as recondite should not be so regarded. 
 Perhaps no one has been persuaded of this except those &mdash; a growing number, after all &mdash; who find that knowledge in these areas is indispensable for the understanding of The Cantos  and of Pound's later translations, for instance from Sophocles. 
 But the thrust of these essays is not so special, nor so self-serving; those who nowadays gird at &bquo;the canon&equo;, as an array of allegedly classic masterpieces in literature, their classic status imposed as an instrument of cultural oppression, need to take account of how in these essays Pound challenged the canon, requiring that it be revised. 
 Arthur Golding's translation of Ovid's Metamorphoses  may not yet be &bquo;canonical&equo;; but it is a lot nearer to being so because Pound campaigned for it. 
 The canon may or may not be oppressive: it is not inert, as Pound's revisions of it prove. 
 Fortunately, most of the essays in Make It New  were brought back into print in 1954, when Eliot edited Literary Essays of Ezra Pound . 
 Of the many loyal services that Eliot did for his old comrade-inarms, this may be the most notable. 
 Given the dispersed profusion of Pound's criticism, neither the choice of what to reprint, nor the arrangement of it when chosen, can have been easy. 
 And Eliot lets us know that he had to argue with Pound, who wanted in some items that Eliot excluded, and wanted out some items on which Eliot insisted. 
 In the event, Eliot's selection and his arrangement are admirable; and undoubtedly a sure sense of what is great and irreplaceable about Pound as critic can be gained from this one volume. 
 ln his Introduction Eliot declares roundly: &bquo;Pound's critical writings, scattered and occasional as they have been, form the least dispensible  body of critical writing in our time&equo;. 
 The italics are Eliot's. 
 Those who have read him know how seldom he declares himself thus roundly and emphatically. 
 And in 1954 Eliot's influence and authority were unparalleled. 
 Yet this criticism which he declared indispensable has by and large been dispensed with, since 1954 as earlier. 
 It is not easy to understand why. 
 But it is charitable to assume that it has something to do with the kind  of critic that Pound is. 
 And about this Eliot is again uncharacteristically emphatic, as well as eloquent. 
 Pound, Eliot says, 
 would cajole, and almost coerce, other men into writing well: so that he often presents the appearance of a man trying to convey to a very deaf person the fact that the house is on fire. 
 Every change he has advocated has always struck him as being  of instant urgency. 
 This is not only the temperament of the teacher: it represents also, with Pound, a passionate desire, not merely to write well himself, but to live in a period in which he could be surrounded by equally intelligent and creative minds. 
 Hence his impatience. 
 For him, to discover a new writer of genius is as satisfying an experience, as it is for a lesser man to believe that he has written a great work of genius himself. 
 He has cared deeply that his contemporaries and juniors should write well; he has cared less for his personal achievement than for the life of letters and art. 
 One of the lessons to be learnt from his critical prose and from his correspondence is the lesson to care unselfishly for the art one serves. 
 This is a noble tribute. 
 And yet it ends by striking a note that is not altogether happy, nor altogether adequate to what Eliot had said earlier. 
 &bquo;To care unselfishly for the art one serves&hellip;&equo; &mdash; that is right, of course, and no more than just. 
 But in Eliot's earlier sentences we have been told of Pound's serving not &bquo;art&equo;, but artists; of his being concerned that they should each realize his or her full potential, so that the level  of accomplishment (in &bquo;letters&equo; as well as &bquo;art&equo;) should be raised all round. 
 In that way, so Eliot has suggested, Pound made himself responsible for a whole &bquo;period&equo;, the period of his lifetime, anxiously impatient that it too lift itself to a higher level. 
 If this is so, then it seems that for &bquo;the art one serves&equo; one might as well read: the culture  one serves, the historical period  one serves, even the society  one serves (perhaps an international society). 
 In short, Eliot has delineated a critic who recognizes public or civic responsibilities; and unless we are very careful, to say of this critic that he &bquo;serves his art&equo; may seem a rather sudden cramping and diminution of the claims made for him. 
 The same thing happens when, later in the essay, Eliot defines the limitation of Pound's kind of criticism (for &bquo;any kind of criticism has its limitations&equo;): &bquo;The limitation of Pound's kind is in its concentration upon the craft of letters, and of poetry especially&equo;. 
 To move from &bquo;art&equo; to &bquo;craft&equo; is rather plainly a further contraction, or diminution: and it will be radically misunderstood unless we remember that for Pound the level of craftsmanship (not just in letters, but in supposedly humbler trades also) is a register, a thermometer-reading, of the good or ill health of a period or of a society. 
 (His most categorical assertions of this are in Guide to Kul-  chur .) 
 It is just here, I suspect, that we &mdash; many of us &mdash; are &bquo;turned off&equo;. 
 In the first place, this is Pound at his most old-fashioned. 
 John Ruskin, it might be said, was the last considerable figure before Pound to hold in all seriousness, as Pound did, that the level of craftsmanship  and artistry in a society was the one infallible measure of that society's moral and civic health. 
 And many of us, I dare say, have tacitly (perhaps wistfully) consigned Ruskin's views to the ash-can of history, along with other Utopian systems put together in the nineteenth century which the desolate history of our own century has made no longer tenable. 
 Moreover, when we consider the courses that Pound was led into by his conviction of the civic responsibility of the man of letters &mdash; his money pamphlets of the 1930s, his desperate visit home in 1938 to keep the USA out of war with Italy, particularly his wartime broadcasts over Rome radio &mdash; we have some right to conclude either that the artist has no civic responsibility at all, or else that that responsibility can safely be discharged only in his art and nowhere else. 
 Understandable as it is, this reaction is plainly not altogether reasonable. 
 For Pound may have been wrong in selecting Fascist Italy as the modern society than came nearest to satisfying his Ruskinian demands, and yet right in thinking that societies should be judged according as they met, or failed to meet, that standard. 
 That he went grossly wrong in applying the standard does not mean that the standard as such was inapplicable. 
 However, most of us either no longer want to believe in the Ruskinian and Poundian relation between craftsmanlike performance and civic health, or else we tell ourselves (perhaps with Pound's fate before us as a cautionary tale) that we can no longer afford  to believe it. 
 We are only just beginning to recognize that if we take this attitude, we are denying to arts and letters, and to the criticism of them, any bearing at all on public life &mdash; including, for instance, public education. 
 At any rate, though we would most of us like to maintain that Pound's Fascism is a quite distinct issue from Pound's poetry and his criticism, it is plain that we cannot do this. 
 His anti-Semitism may be a separate issue (though many of course will deny even that); but his Fascism cannot be, since it represents a disastrously false judgement made in the course of following through a conviction not  self-evidently false &mdash; about there being a connection between the health of letters and the health of the commonweal. 
 It so happens that this troublesome question, or complex of questions, is not raised by the piece in Eliot's selection that I shall take to represent Pound's criticism at its irreplaceable best. 
 This is the brief article (less than five printed pages) which originally appeared in Poetry  for February 1918, under the title, &bquo;The Hard and Soft in French Poetry&equo;. 
 The title alone is enough to show that this piece, if it avoids giving offence in the ways just glanced at, will offend none the less. 
 For hardness and softness in relation to poetry &mdash; where have these qualities been defined? 
 Does Pound define them? 
 No, he does not, except circuitously and by implication. 
 However, he begins,  after a fashion that is less rare with him than is commonly supposed, by apologizing for the impressionism that supplies him with the terms he needs: 
 I apologize for using the semimetaphorical terms &bquo;hard&equo; and &bquo;soft&equo; in this essay, but after puzzling over the matter for some time I can see no other way of setting about it. 
 By &bquo;hardness&equo; I mean a quality which is in poetry nearly always a virtue &mdash; I can think of no case where it is not. 
 By &bquo;softness&equo; I mean an opposite quality which is not always a fault. 
 Annoyed as we may be at having the cardinal terms left thus undefined (for Pound proceeds no further towards defining them), we are compelled to see that this criticism is not of the chalk-or-cheese, sheep-and-goats variety; the discrimination proposed is more subtle &mdash; between a quality in poetry that is &bquo;nearly always&equo; a virtue (&equo; I can think of no case where it is not'), and an opposite quality that is &bquo;not always&equo; a fault. 
 This is a critic who uses sliding scales, not one fixed Procrustean rule. 
 The bluffly categorical manner is misleading; Pound is always ready to concede that &bquo;circumstances alter cases,. 
 One reason why Pound's scales must &bquo;slide&equo; is that nowhere in his criticism does Pound forget chronology &mdash; literary history and literary criticism are for him two aspects of one unified act of attention. 
 But there is more to it than that. 
 For Pound all dates are important but none more so than the date on the calendar above the critic's desk. 
 This is what Eliot means by insisting: &bquo;It is necessary to consider Pound's literary pronouncements in the light of the circumstances in which they were written&hellip;&equo; 
 This sounds defensive, even apologetic. 
 But Eliot doesn't mean it so, as we see from the notorious case that he cites in illustration: 
 A great writer can have, at a particular time, a pernicious or merely deadening influence; and this influence can be most effectively attacked by pointing out those faults which ought not to be copied, and those virtues any emulation of which is anachronistic. 
 Pound's disparagement of Milton, for instance, was, I am convinced, most salutary twenty and thirty years ago; I still agree with him against the academic admirers of Milton; though to me it seems that the situation has changed. 
 In Eliot's view, the circumstances have changed so greatly over thirty years since 1924 that what was rightly said of Milton in that year cannot rightly be said of him in 1954. 
 This is relativity with a vengeance, and many of us have felt than in a case like this the scales that  Eliot measures by are not so much sliding as slithering. 
 In this instance Pound, we notice, stood firm. 
 But he was nearly as ready as Eliot to insist that all critical judgements and pronouncements are relative &mdash; relative, above all, to the date at which they are made. 
 Already in 1928 he was protesting that his own pronouncements at the time of the Imagist manifesto were tailored to the specific needs of 1914, and should not be taken as binding fourteen years later. 
 To minds of absolutist temper like Leavis and Winters, this was contemptible; and undoubtedly it is next to impossible to establish criticism as an academic discipline on grounds so sandy and shifting. 
 But perhaps the moral we should draw is that criticism is not, and cannot be, such a discipline (though literary history is, or may be). 
 A great mystery is why Eliot, who was more of a relativist than Pound, should have been accepted by the academic establishment whereas Pound was not. 
 Instead of defining &bquo;hardness&equo; in poetry, Pound rapidly cites three poets where he finds the quality in question: Gautier, H&eacute;r&eacute;dia, Albert Samain. 
 He distinguishes among them, cursorily, as he cites them in order. 
 Turning to English (where, he assures us, the quality is much harder to come by), he reviews the claims of a Ben Jonson lyric, of George Herbert, Christina Rossetti and LionelJohnson. 
 He by no means dismisses the claims of these poets, but gently and respectfully sets them aside &mdash; &bquo;I do not feel that they have much part in this essay. 
 I do not feel that their quality is really the quality I am seeking here to define&equo;. 
 Why, then, are they named? 
 For a very good reason. 
 Pound says, in effect: &bquo;If your French isn't good enough to go where the quality is both defined (metaphorically) and exemplified, i.e. in Gautier's &bquo;L'art&equo; specifically and in his Emaux  et Cam&eacute;es  as a whole, or in the work of followers like H&eacute;r&eacute;dia and Samain, then remind yourself, or re-experience, what it is like to read George Herbert and Christina Rossetti and Lionel Johnson. 
 Ask yourself what these three poets in your experience of them have in common, and in answering that you will get near to  the quality I am trying to isolate.&equo; 
 Nothing, after all, could be more scrupulous; this is how a truly empirical criticism proceeds and must proceed. 
 An array of instances, almost of specimens, is set before us; and we are invited to make our own observations, inferring from them as much as they will bear. 
 This was, Pound believed (and with good reason), the method of a great biologist, Louis Agassiz; and when pressed Pound was ready to call the procedure not just &bquo;empirical&equo; but &bquo;scientific&equo;. 
 What is likely to strike us, however, is the compliment that Pound pays us; his courteous confidence in our disinterestedness, our patience and eagerness, and our capacity to experience what is on the page before us, whether in French or English, without  needing to have him constantly at our elbows, nudging us and crying, &bquo;Can't you see ?&equo; 
 No aspect of Pound is more widely misunderstood. 
 It is rightly said of him that he was always a pedagogue, but he is a pedagogue in the courtly nineteenth-century mode of Professor Agassiz, who sets up the controlled experiment and invites us to participate in it, not in the hectoring and charismatic mode of the star of the lecture-hall. 
 Meanwhile Pound has proposed an English poet who is more nearly an analogue to Gautier than any so far mentioned, a nearer analogue and yet still not wholly trustworthy because he is &bquo;from poem to poem, extremely uneven&equo;. 
 This is Walter Savage Landor; and this short article explains why Landor figures repeatedly, and always with respect, not just in The Cantos  and in Pound's later criticism, but in Yeats's poetry and prose also. 
 Probably not in this essay as such, but in that area of Pound's conversation of which this essay is a distillation, we find the reason &mdash; so I believe &mdash; why Yeats said admiringly of Landor in 1917: &bquo;He had in his Imaginary Conver  - sations  reminded us, as it were, that the Venus de Milo is a stone.&equo; 
 And I submit that out of this same background &mdash; conversations with Pound &mdash; comes that surprising coupling of names with which Yeats ends &bquo;To a Young Beauty&equo; (1918): 
 There is not a fool can call me friend, 
 And I may dine at journey's end 
 With Landor and with Donne. 
 What we are groping for, what Pound (we now see) is inciting us to grope for, what Yeats is laying claim to, is that effect in writing which an earlier criticism knew as &bquo;lapidary&equo;: that is to say, the effect or the illusion of words as not written or printed on a page, but as incised on a stone block. 
 The aspiration after this effect is very ancient, as we know from the Greek derivation common to both &bquo;epigram&equo; and &bquo;epitaph&equo;. 
 Certainly the aspiration is not limited in modern times to those who have read Emaux et Cam&eacute;es , the French book that Pound respectfully pillaged for Hugh Selwyn Mauberley ; it is to be found in all modern poetries known to me, Russian and Polish as well as French, and (more faintly) in British and American. 
 In short, what this has to do with modern poetry is very clear; what it has to do with modern criticism is not clear at all, since that criticism has, as we have seen, no vocabulary for dealing with it, and moves further and further from finding such a vocabulary, the more it takes its lead from linguisticians like Saussure and Jakobson. 
 After he has made his first claim for Landor, Pound writes two paragraphs of the sort that have provoked near-apoplexy, because they have not been taken in the spirit that Pound intended:  
 We have in English a certain gamut of styles: we have the good Chaucerian; almost the only style in English where &bquo;softness&equo; is tolerable; we have the good Elizabethan;&hellip; and the bad, or muzzy, Elizabethan; and the Miltonic, which is a bombastic and rhetorical Elizabethan coming from an attempt to write English with Latin syntax. 
 Its other mark is that the rich words have gone: i . 
 e ., 
 words like preluciand , which have a folk tradition and are, in feeling, germane to all Europe: Leuchand, luisant , lucente : these words are absent in Miltonism, and purely pedantic words, like irriguous , have succeeded them. 
 We have Pope, who is really the Elizabethan satiric style, more or less born out of Horace, and a little improved or at least regularized. 
 And we have Landor &mdash; that is, Landor at his best. 
 And after that we have &bquo;isms&equo; and &bquo;eses&equo;: the pseudoElizabethanism &mdash; i.e. , bad Keats; the romantics, Swinburnese, Browningese, neo-celticism. 
 And how the devil a poet writing English manages to make or find a language for poems is a mystery. 
 No, Professor X, Pound does not  say that Landor, or Landor at his best, is better than Keats; and no, sir, he does not  say that Chaucer is better than Milton. 
 He is concerned with &bquo;the Miltonic&equo;, with &bquo;Miltonism&equo;, not with Keats but with &bquo; bad  Keats&equo;, not with Browning but with &bquo;Browningese&equo;. 
 He is not talking about any one of these great writers (his devotion to Browning was well advertised) but about, in Eliot's words, the &bquo;pernicious or merely deadening influence&equo; that &bquo;a great writer can have, at a particular time&equo;. 
 A great writer's idiom is, by himself when he nods and more certainly by his epigones who emulate and copy him, rigidified and adulterated. 
 And the more idiosyncratic his genius (this is the case of Milton, surely), the more likely it is that what will be copied is his mannerisms. 
 If it be objected that no beginning writer shops around in this way among the idioms handed down to him from the past, the evidence is that certain beginning writers do  shop around in just this way; Ezra Pound was one of them, and he is by no means so exceptional as is supposed. 
 For such a beginning writer in such a situation, it may well turn out that a minor master like Landor is more fruitfully instructive than a major master like Milton or Keats: and if it does turn out so, one has a certain debt of honour that must be paid to the past master by whom one was liberated. 
 Two-thirds of the way through his essay, Pound apologizes again: &bquo;If this seem an over-long prologue&hellip;&equo; 
 And we are astonished. 
 It had not occurred to us that this ranging survey of the idioms of English and incidentally French verse had been no more than a  &bquo;prologue&equo; &mdash; and to what, for heaven's sake? 
 But Pound has not forgotten what his assignment is. 
 He believes, or he chooses  to believe, that in Chicago or somewhere else there were readers of Poetry  magazine in 1918 who zealously and in all seriousness wanted to know what French poets of that time they might profitably read, and what in the broadest terms they should look for in each of them. 
 And so the last page or so is given over to French names: Corbi&egrave;re and Jammes and De Regnier; Tailhade and Romains; Vildrac, Spire and Arcos &mdash; poets who at the present day have few readers even among the French. 
 Pound has been conned by French reputationmaking? 
 Not at all; good writing is so infernally difficult that even the most modest achievement (and Pound's claims for some of these poets are modest indeed) should not go unacknowledged. 
 Pound was to acknowledge some of them, all over again, years later in the Cantos . 
 And meanwhile, what courtesy to the readers of Poetry! 
 How confident he is, or affects to be, about their disinterestedness, their alertness, the range of their sympathies, the use that they will make of the gentlest hint or nudge! 
 That deference towards the well-disposed reader is hard to find in later criticism &mdash; for good reason, no doubt. 
 Well, but &mdash; so some readers may be saying or thinking &mdash; what about the content  of these so numerous poems? 
 What are they saying, these poets, French and English? 
 Pound seems to have no interest in that. 
 Is it not the case that George Herbert and Christina Rossetti and even Lionel Johnson are devoutly Christian poets, whereas Pound is militantly non-Christian? 
 And if Pound so blithely overlooks that difference, doesn't that mean that we have in him a critic who attends to form, to style, at the expense of what that form and that style are used so as to convey? 
 Don't we have in him a formalist, in fact an aesthete? 
 This is the brickbat that has been thrown at Pound from the first, and is thrown at him still, because of his unswerving attention to what makes poetry poetry, and not some other sort of discourse versified. 
 It was the accusation, or the selfaccusation, that Pound wrestled with in Hugh Selwyn Mauberley , and settled not wholly to his own or any one else's satisfaction. 
 In &bquo;The Hard and Soft in French Poetry&equo; Pound confronts the issue very early, and deals with it to my mind conclusively. 
 This is when he discriminates H&eacute;r&eacute;dia from Gautier: 
 Heredia is &bquo;hard&equo;, but there or thereabouts he ends. 
 It is perhaps that Gautier is intent on being &bquo;hard&equo;; is intent on conveying a certain verity of feeling, and he ends by being truly poetic. 
 Heredia wants to be poetic and  hard; the hardness appears to him as a virtue in the poetic. 
 And one tends to conclude that  all attempts to be poetic in some manner or other defeat their own end; whereas an intentness on the quality of the emotion to be conveyed makes for poetry. 
 To go for the lapidary effect as such is sterile; one tries for the lapidary because, if achieved, it is a guarantee of the verity of one's feeling &mdash; Christian or non-Christian, as the case may be. 
 Aestheticism, l'art pour l'art , is identified, and impaled, in H&eacute;r&eacute;dia (though with a beguiling hesitancy &mdash; &bquo;perhaps&equo;, &bquo;one tends to conclude&equo;); to aim for the poetic ends up in something other than poetry, or else in inferior poetry. 
 In conclusion, and to end near to our starting-point, we should look at Pound's second apology. 
 In context, the effect of it is hardly apologetic at all: 
 If this seem an over-long prologue, think how little discussion there is of these things. 
 Only a few professors and their favourite students seem to have read enough to be able to consider a matter of style with any data at their disposal &mdash; these and a few poets of the better sort&hellip; 
 &bquo;With any data at their disposal&equo; &mdash; the terminology puts us back into Louis Agassiz' laboratory. 
 And is it not a true bill, now as in 1918? 
 Who would assert with confidence that there now are more professors with &bquo;data at their disposal&equo; than there were in 1918? 
 And of such professors, how many would rest content with the conclusion that Pound reached in 1918: &bquo;A critic must spend some of his time asking questions &mdash; which perhaps no one can answer. 
 It is much more his business to stir up curiosity than to insist on acceptances., Pound as critic cuts the critic down to size; which is, one may think, a pressing need, now, in 1984.  
 Adapted from The Sewanee Review , 92: 3 (1984). 
 Pound and the Perfect Lady 
 Pound 's Artists: Ezra Pound and the Visual Arts in London, Paris and Italy , introduced by Richard Humphreys. 
 London: Tate Gallery Publications, 1985. 
 Ezra Pound and Dorothy Shakespear: Their Letters 1909&ndash;1914 , edited by Omar Pound and A. Walton Litz. 
 Faber, 1985. 
 Thanks to Clive Wilmer among others, an exhibition of paintings, sculptures, photographs and printed material bearing on Pound's interests in &bquo;the visual arts&equo; was mounted for the Cambridge Poetry Festival on 14 June, and could be seen in Cambridge's not sufficiently renowned Kettle's Yard Gallery until 4 August; it will now be at the Tate from 11 September to 10 November. 
 Humphrey Carpenter's report on the exhibition for the TLS  of 28 June will hardly choke the turnstiles. 
 The show has, he said, &bquo;something of the air of a school reunion about it&equo;, and with a few exceptions &bquo;it is the Pound business much as usual&equo;. 
 No one, he thinks, who is unfamiliar with &bquo;Pound's P.T. Barnumising for the visual arts&equo; will know what to make of it. 
 This tone is intolerable, and augurs very ill for Carpenter's biography of Pound, said to be in the works. 
 No one who reads the three solid essays in what is described as the catalogue of the exhibition (though it isn't quite that) can think that &bquo;Barnumising&equo; in any way describes Pound's ardent response to painting and sculpture, photography and architecture, first in London 1908&ndash;1920, then in Paris 1920&ndash;1925, and thereafter in Italy. 
 Carpenter, predictably, finds the three essayists &mdash; Richard Humphreys, John Alexander and Peter Robinson &mdash; &bquo;taking a rather solemn approach to the whole thing&equo;; whereas, he assures us, Pound's exertions on behalf of these arts partook &bquo;more than a little of the amiable joke&equo;. 
 Before it is through, Pound's centenary year will bring on indigestion in even the most devoted Poundians. 
 But whether his artistic life was, as a few think, exemplary, or, as rather more think, a fearsomely cautionary fable, it is at all events a matter of some solemnity, and the amused weariness of we-have-heard-it-all-before will not serve in 1985 as it did in 1920 or 1940 or even, scandalously, as late as fifteen  years ago. 
 We have not  heard it all before, unless we have read, as few of us have, Harriet Zinnes's compendium Ezra Pound and the  Visual Arts , which all these essayists draw on very heavily. 
 Amiable joking was never what Pound intended, and only a total insensitivity to his tone of voice could lead one to think otherwise. 
 Solemn? 
 &bquo;Sedate&equo; is a better word for these essays. 
 And two of them might be called even pedestrian. 
 No harm in that: pedestrian documentation is what there is a call for &mdash; Pound himself, and his admirers emulating him, have been so sprightly for so long that they have persuaded people they, and he, cannot be in earnest. 
 All the same, John Alexander's piece on the Paris period would have made livelier and easier reading if he had not, like Richard Humphreys on the London years, limited himself so self-effacingly to the documentation, necessary though that is. 
 The problem, for instance, of Pound's admiration for Brancusi, and of how that fits or does not fit with his other proclivities and principles, cannot for much longer be left where Alexander leaves it. 
 On the other hand, his account of Pound's attitude to Fernand L&eacute;ger is new to me, and fascinating. 
 Peter Robinson's essay on Pound and Italian art is quite another matter: altogether more ambitious and probing. 
 Out of D.S. Chambers and Michael Baxandall and some Italian scholars Robinson measures up Pound's ideas about the right relation between artist and patron against what we know of how patronage in fact worked in the ducal fiefs of Renaissance Italy; and when he deals with the closeness of Pound's views on this and related matters to Ruskin's ideas (a theme common to all these essayists), Robinson dares to broach the too long forbidden topic of the poet's antagonism &mdash; inertly received, so some would say, rather than considered &mdash; to Christian faith and Christian ethics. 
 Ruskin's espousal of a craftsmanly aesthetics, Robinson points out, is grounded in Christian convictions about the humility proper to a fallen creature: lacking such grounds, Pound's holding to the craftsmanly not only seems arbitrary and unargued, it is as often presumptuous as humble. 
 It's Peter Robinson, too, who won't stay content with ritually shocked head-shaking at Pound's Fascism. 
 When Pound in an early Canto includes among a hero's conversational topics 
 And men of unusual genius, Both of ancient times and our own, 
 Robinson detects &bquo;a severe confusion of categories and contexts&equo;, and he asks: &bquo;Might we not distinguish in kind between literary promotion, such as Pound's for Joyce, in war or peace, and advocacy such as Pound's for Mussolini in war rather than peace?&equo; 
 Well, so we  might, but we might also think that &bquo;literary promotion&equo; is an inadequate description of Pound's sustained and inventive activities on behalf of his notably non-reciprocating Irish colleague. 
 In any case, Pound has the centuries on his side when he equates a genius in statecraft &mdash; Jefferson if not Mussolini &mdash; with a genius in an art or in speculative thought. 
 In fact, the equation is more challenging the other way round: Pound thinks Joyce a Phenomenon deserving equal attention with Mussolini &mdash; a temperate judgement that the years may be thought to have vindicated. 
 Art is at least as important as Politics, whether in Peace or war, and it is Pound's intransigent conviction of this that brings out the philistine in others beside Peter Robinson. 
 The statesman as artist &mdash; God knows it is a dubious and dangerous idea, but to get rid of it Probably involves demoting statesmen and aspiring statesmen from the privileged position that they still enjoy in public estimation. 
 Omar Pound, with Walton Litz of Princeton, has edited the letters that his Parents exchanged through their protracted courtship, and their Publishers have made of this a very pretty book. 
 This is appropriate, for the story that the letters not so much tell as adumbrate comes through with a wistful fragrance that is very affecting if one reads slowly. 
 Omar Pound must know the full story, but rightly I think, though surely austerely, he has left it for us to piece together. 
 And some of the nuances are lost on us, or left hanging as possibilities. 
 Was Frederic Manning, for instance, the Australian who would later write Her Privates We , in love with Dorothy, and wounded when she preferred Pound? 
 We are not told. 
 This is not to say that the letters can be left to speak for themselves. 
 On the contrary, the two young persons communicate in a jokily affectionate private language, often about people in a not undistinguished but certainly restricted circle of acquaintances and Shakespear connections, who lived according to social codes now utterly unremembered. 
 Accordingly, even those who have learned some of the relevant names from Pound's biographers would be quite at sea if the editors had not marshalled, deftly and compactly and sometimes wittily, some very out-of-the-way information. 
 Even so, the world that we have to enter &mdash; the world of the solidly professional bourgeoisie and minor gentry of pre-1914 England &mdash; is so remote from us, so exotic, that we can't always keep our bearings. 
 One is astonished, for instance, at how the daughter of Olivia Shakespear, no ordinary mother, was restricted, even in the arty society that she and Olivia frequented, by the still rigid conventions that wheeled her, uncomplaining but always chaperoned and often bored to tears, through a round of pointless visitings. 
 Dorothy Shakespear, one sometimes feels, was not much less imprisoned than Elizabeth  Barrett had been, and in not much less need of a poet-errant to liberate her. 
 Neither the captive nor her would-be liberator wasted much time complaining: these were the rules of the game, and the two of them could only be patient. 
 Patience is not what we associate with Pound, and from time to time he seems to have kicked over the traces (at least once to be ticked off for it by Dorothy): yet we see all over again that the young Pound was well content with Edwardian England, was hopeful of it and ready to abide by its rules in everything that mattered. 
 Of course, where Dorothy was concerned, that was his only strategy if he wanted to secure her in the end. 
 And in fact that is one of the affecting things: the story that we read is undoubtedly a love-story. 
 One had doubted this. 
 Our information about the later phases of the Pound marriage is certainly imperfect. 
 (And why should it not be? 
 So Omar Pound might legitimately ask.) 
 But such information as we have undoubtedly reflects more credit on Dorothy than on Ezra. 
 One was forced to envisage the possibility that Ezra courted Dorothy, not cynically indeed, but abstractedly, impulsively, without due consideration. 
 This correspondence, though Dorothy figures in it more prominently than Ezra, I believe puts paid to such suspicions. 
 By 1913 Pound is confiding in his fianc&eacute;e as, we must believe, he did to no one else. 
 In their private code Yeats, who was to marry Dorothy's cousin and best friend Georgie Hyde-Lees, figures as &bquo;the Eagle&equo;. 
 And in 1913 we have Pound writing of Yeats, who had just published &bquo;The Grey Rock&equo;, that the latter is &bquo;very fine, but his syntax is getting obscurer than Browning's&equo;, then confessing: &bquo;I wonder which is worse, to die in the aromatic subtlety of a disappearing cadence ( &agrave; la  ME) or to stodge one's nobility into an incomprehensible narrative, &agrave; la  The Eagle&equo;. 
 (The allusion to Pope's &bquo;Essay on Man&equo; is one of the few that the editors pass over.) 
 This is very astute criticism of Yeats: but more to the point is that Pound here confesses self-doubts such as he would have concealed from anyone he did not trust absolutely. 
 As we read the correspondence we seem to see Dorothy growing out of the gushing flibbertigibbet that she was in 1909 into a person altogether more substantial. 
 But this is almost certainly an illusion: as she becomes surer of her hold on the affections of her poet, so she becomes surer of herself, can dispense with affectations, and dares to speak with a certain authority about compositions that her lover sends to her &mdash; animadversions that the poet in turn receives quite humbly. 
 Although students of Pound will fasten with delighted alacrity on such passages as the one just quoted about Yeats, and on one or two similar passages (for instance, one of January 1914, where he speaks with hostility about symbols and symbolism), still this book  doesn't really belong with other Poundiana. 
 Its place is at least equally with The Diary of an Edwardian Lady , or even, since through long months the lovers are at opposite ends of Italy, with E.M. 
 Forster's Room with a View . 
 Its fragrance is real, and penetrating: but it does not release itself at the first casual opening of the pages. 
 And yet the fact must be faced: however much patient sympathy we bring to our reading, we close the book feeling frustrated. 
 For Dorothy is still not in focus, and one begins to think that she never will be, even if the correspondence of the Pounds' later years is some day published. 
 Dorothy, one suspects, was always too much &bquo;the perfect lady&equo;, and schooled too thoroughly in the pre-1914 code of proud reticence (a code which incidentally her husband also adhered to), for her to escape the role of &bquo;poor Dorothy&equo; that some recent writers have cast her in. 
 Certainly she could not compete on anything like equal terms with Hilda Doolittle, the poet H.D. who, having mythologised her relations with Pound in a roman &agrave; clef  many years ago, did it all over again just before her death in End to Torment , a supposed &bquo;memoir&equo; which people seem disposed to take literally, though in its scattiness it may well be as fictionalised as the novel had been. 
 It does not help, I'm afraid, now when American cultural chauvinism wants to reclaim Pound, that Dorothy was an Englishwoman whereas Hilda, the childhood sweetheart from Bethlehem, Pa., was echt  -American. 
 H.D., nicknamed &bquo;the Hama-dryad&equo;, is the subject of much high-spirited comedy in the letters that Ezra and Dorothy exchanged, and this ought to provoke second thoughts in those who want to take Hilda's account at face-value: H.D. may have honestly persuaded herself that she was the great (though virginal) love of Pound's life, but it's unlikely that Pound thought so, nor need we. 
 Dorothy however remains, not nebulous exactly, but enigmatic. 
 The odd anecdote &mdash; for instance, James Laughlin's of 1965 about how she advanced his education in Rapallo by reading to him the stories of Henry James &mdash; brings her momentarily into focus, but then she disappears again behind a smokescreen of gracious good breeding. 
 The loss is grievous. 
 For when the Pisan detention-camp in 1946 compelled the poet to breach, though guardedly, the barrier of his reticence, he certainly wrote about the women he had loved; and if Dorothy is of that company (as she must be, surely), we need to know just where she figures, and on what terms. 
 It is the reader of moving and extraordinary but cryptic poetry who needs to know this, not the perhaps nosey biographer.   
 London Review of Books , 19 September 1985. 
 TELEVISION / Broken English: Mark Lawson on Home Run, and BBC2's Red Dynasty 
 By MARK LAWSON 
 THERE were several scary moments in Home Run (BBC 1), a thriller by Andy Armitage, but few as terrifying as the early revelation that the central character was called Billy English. 
 It was a christening that seemed to hunger for significance. 
 Certain newspapers and television programmes have long enjoyed surname humour &mdash; the mid-wife called Miss Stork, the taxi-driver Mr Hanger &mdash; but few such features have unearthed a Mr England, Miss English or Mrs Albion whose character is, in some obscure way, an embodiment of the national one. 
 This is one significant difference between fiction and existence. 
 In real life, men called England end up as football manager of Wales. 
 In a story, such a guy is the Isles. 
 Billy English stood for an English clan wider than his immediate family. 
 Born to salty, honest East End folk &mdash; this was hinted at, the script sensibly avoiding the risk of fleshing them out &mdash; he had risen in the City to a financial position which permitted him to park his BMW beside the flash docklands flat, close to his rough but pure roots, in which he kept his nice French bird. 
 Billy's only problem was that someone or something was pursuing him. 
 The phantom was initially nameless but the viewer knew that, if he had shouted Class or Guilt after it, it would probably have answered. 
 Television was so quick to join the Yuppie Backlash that there is now a real danger of a Yuppie Backlash Drama Backlash, in which the viewer starts muttering about not being able to switch on the bloody set without seeing a broker being broken. 
 That said, Home Run was a strong competitor in the market, with a quirky eye. 
 At the end, the traitor of the English clan hurled his credit cards at his parents&equo; grave in what seemed to be a symbol for throwing bad money after good. 
 Michael Kitchen played Billy with some finely judged deliberate accent slippage. 
 At least, I hope it was deliberate. 
 It probably was, as the producer David Snodin and the director Nicholas Renton are one of the hottest teams in television drama. 
 Last week, they were responsible for A Wanted Man (BBC 2), a powerful trilogy of plays by Malcom McKay about the police interrogation, trial and attempted rehabiliation of a murderer. 
 A few months ago, Snodin also produced Tony Marchant's acute and bruising Take Me Home, the best drama serial of the year, in which another Yuppie (he doesn't like them, does he?), this time in a new town, lost his wife and lifestyle to a mini-cab driver. 
 If you achieved such a quantity of quality work in the theatre, they would be tipping you to lead the RSC. 
 In television, it just slips quietly by, but we should hope that there will always be people to run the kind of BBC in which such drama &mdash; literate, socially sensitive and lovingly crafted &mdash; can be done. 
 &bquo;Should television be the voice of the party or the voice of the people?&equo;, asked a witness in Red Dynasty (BBC 2). 
 The speaker was a Chinese television news producer, acknowledging a debate within her industry. 
 A new kind of documentary was on offer for viewers in Beijing: populist, slightly Wilcocksy people shows. 
 Her remarks were recorded before events in Tianamen Square and it was clear by the end of the programme that the proper function of current affairs television was less of a live debate inside the country than it had been. 
 However, Peter Firstbrook's series, lucidly scripted and fronted by Edward Behr, makes no secret of having set out to make one kind of series (Wither China?) and then being armlocked by events in to another (Withered China?) 
 Turning its wrecked agenda in to a benefit, this film presented four brief lives, with Tianamen as merely one event. 
 The most startling yarn was that of Zhang Quo Zhi, who enjoyed a lifestyle which, if you did know better, you would describe as that of a successful capitalist. 
 Worth &pound;20 million, he had a limousine and 11 bodyguards. 
 The one serious omission of Behr's script was to discuss from whom they were shielding him: is kidnapping an inevitable corollary of even relative economic freedom? 
 Just before Tianamen, Zhang got the Entrepreneur Of The Year Award, presented by a party chief who has since been redeployed. 
 Alfred Yu, a university lecturer who had openly criticised that government, has remained in Australia, where he was teaching, too nervous to return. 
 Despite the crushing of the students, he still hoped that &bquo;a phoenix will rise up from the ashes.&equo; 
 This is one of those English expressions so weathered that their emotional batteries are irretrievably flat but, from the lips of someone who spoke English with the cool precision of a fluent foreigner, the phrase was terribly affecting. 
 He probably intended it as an exact classical allusion. 
 In a solid South Bank Show (LWT) on Jimi Hendrix, Eric Clapton swore while describing his feelings when the guitarist died. 
 Such are the times in which we live that the decision to leave his expletives unbleeped prompted tabloid news stories but, really, the programme was quite intensely moral. 
 Any child watching will have learned that even geniuses need to practice (Jimi riffed even while cooking breakfast) but that talent can be undone by sex and drugs. 
 The programme might have said more about technique &mdash; what, at plectrum level, made him tangibly different from the folk-group strummer - but was a thorough biography and survived the expressive limitations of rock anecdotage: &bquo;His attack to a guitar was, oh, something else&hellip; &bquo;  
 DANCE / Taking a rain check: Judith Mackrell on Burrows and Smith at The Place, and The Royal Ballet's La Bayadere 
 By JUDITH MACKRELL 
 WITH at most one new work a year to his name, Jonathan Burrows is hardly a prolific choreographer. 
 Yet it is not just his commitments with the Royal Ballet that hold him up, it is also his unusually intense way of making a work. 
 Each piece feels like the product of long slow hatching, like a closely-guarded experiment. 
 And in each piece this is matched by a peculiarly private quality of movement and motivation. 
 This personal stamp is partly created by the unique range of Burrows&equo; influences &mdash; British folk dance from his training at the Royal Ballet School, ballet itself, and at the opposite extreme the minimal, unburnished style of Rosemary Butcher, with whom he has performed several times. 
 But it is also that the worlds which Burrows evokes are very intimate and very enclosed. 
 Hymns was an alternately brutal, comic and touching study of pubescent schoolboys while his new work, dull morning cloudy mild, stems from the diary of an old man whose memories are bound up with his obsessive recording of the weather. 
 Matteo Fargion's specially composed music for piano, strings and brass does much to set the tone of the piece, with its clouded dissonances and flurries of bright jazzy melody. 
 The choreography likewise evokes changes of weather and mood but without displaying any overt narrative development. 
 The two central, baggy-suited dancers, Lynne Bristow and William Trevitt, either mirror each others' movements (the old man perhaps communing with his diary) or else dance as a couple (the man reliving past relationships). 
 Thus some slow, desiccated waltzing and gentle leans have the quietude of an old couple on a dull mild day; sequences of deft, steppy footwork and sharp edged leaps have the high spirits of blustery sunshine, while a duet of rhythmic fidgety gestures has the feel of a lifelong argument continued during a rainy afternoon. 
 The other four dancers regularly interrupt or echo these sequences with images from the past &mdash; a robust trio, whose folk steps and causally thrown jumps have the coltish energy of adolescence and two couples who look like lovers courting in the 1920s. 
 By the end this quartet depart the stage in a halting dance of death and Trevitt is rolled up in a carpet, leaving Bristow alone without partner or diary. 
 This presumed death is the only unequivocal event in the whole work, however, and there are moments where its meditative air threatens to become bafflingly introspective. 
 Burrows seems to have lived with his material for so long that he has forgotten to throw out enough clues for the rest of us, and there are few hints as to why certain sequences are so important that they should be repeated over and over again But what constantly saves the piece from disappearing into itself is the obliquely moving nature of the central relationship and some patchy but startlingly lovely dance images. 
 The performances too are excellent, with all six dancers (from the Royal) sensitively adapting to the small scale of The Place (no stagy projection or glazed expressions). 
 Bristow and Trevitt never waver in the closeness of their mutual dialogue and move easily between forceful classical dynamics and quiet self-containment. 
 At 40 minutes this is an odd but oddly engrossing private journey. 
 Equally personal is Janet Smith's The World Outside My Window, the first piece she has made since disbanding her company and the first in a long time that she has made to please herself. 
 It is based on poems by a woman (apparently her sister) who became disabled by a viral disease. 
 But while Burrows' concerns are revealed only tangentially, Smith's are delivered with her usual immediacy. 
 The frustrations of the cripple are rawly evoked as Smith is bundled, like so much insensible flesh, through the hands of the other dancers. 
 Her hankering for the outside world is shown through a solo where she is cruelly tangled in the legs of a chair. 
 And her flights of memory are carried through lyric dance sequences that nicely exploit the five dancers' fluent technique. 
 The World Outside My Window encompasses an unusually broad range of movement for Smith and shows encouraging signs of fresh invigoration. 
 But for all its individual strengths it doesn't evolve a satisfying shape. 
 The choreography remains a moment by moment response to the poems and, awkwardly, these themselves are not especially good. 
 Their images rarely arrest and their rhythms sound clumsy both in sung and spoken delivery. 
 Naked emotion grants the work an uneasy power &mdash; but at times it feels like special pleading. 
 After all this, the plot of La Bayadere comes as outrageously irresponsible nonsense. 
 Yet during his Saturday night guest appearance Julio Bocca danced the ballet with a heroic degree of conviction. 
 As the warrior Solor he possessed neither the exotic glamour of Ruzimatov nor the romantic height of Cope &mdash; and a dispassionate viewer would admit that his turban gave him an unfortunately gnome-like appearance. 
 But he is not only a fine actor and an even finer dancer he is also uncommonly and unabashedly sexy. 
 In the long opening mime section Bocca's graceful arrogance was eloquently coupled to the desperate impatience to meet Nikiya (Viviana Durante), and once dancing with her the two qualities sparked into a heady ardour. 
 When he brushed his cheek against hers or supported her waist in multiple pirouettes the sensual heat was unmissable. 
 Even Durante, who has a tendency to forget her character when she is dancing, responded at times with an uncharacteristically voluptuous abandon. 
 For those of us less fortunate in the audience Bocca's technical prowess was devastating enough. 
 In the austere Shades act he perhaps overdid the stunts -but otherwise the height of his jumps coupled with the careless speed of his preparation was breathtaking. 
 So too was his exceptional ability to accelerate or delay his pirouettes at will &mdash; a dancer for whom gravity is only a trivial inconvenience. 
 THEATRE / Making more of the Moor: Paul Taylor on Trevor Nunn's Othello at the Young Vic 
 By PAUL TAYLOR 
 TREVOR NUNN'S &bquo;chamber&equo; production of Othello, now transferred to the Young Vic, is both intricately sketched-in and lengthily drawn-out. 
 Lasting well over four hours, it is patently in no hurry to come to conclusions or to an end. 
 But in return for its rich density of lovingly dwelt-on, almost novelistic detail, what you lose is any sense of a strong forward pulse or of the play's irresistible sweep towards doom. 
 The pace is often dilatory and this, reinforced perhaps by the nineteenth-century costumes and setting, can give the proceedings an at times bizarrely Checkhovian cast. 
 Arriving in Cyprus ahead of Othello, an understandably nervous Desdemona is forced to hang around on the quay and, in an effortful charade of lightheartedness, swap bawdy banter with Iago and company. 
 In Nunn's way of orchestrating the scene, however, the forced merriment comes across like the willed time-killing in Three Sisters, less the whiling away of a few specific minutes than the attempt to shake off a pervasive ennui. 
 Never less than thoroughly fascinating, the production is dominated by Ian McKellen's extraordinary Iago, a performance which feels like a shifting palimpsest of impersonations. 
 Partly, with his flat Northern vowels, tight blue uniform and fusspot bracings and flexings, he is the officious British bobby of the Derek Guyler school. 
 But in the discreet, epicene efficiency with which he clears away Casio's bowl of vomit or dusts down Othello after his fit, he is the finicky gentleman's gentleman, his body language strongly reminiscent of Dirk Bogarde in The Servant. 
 It is an eye-catching portrait of twisted repression, but to my mind it fails to conveys the essentially diabolic nature of Iago's negativity. 
 The nearest you get to this is the thrilling moment at the end of Act One when, as though he had engendered them, the thunder and lightning which usher in the next act and a complete change of country, melodramatically erupt during Iago's concluding lines. 
 Elsewhere, the close-up, detailed approach which works brilliantly, say, for Imogen Stubbs's affecting Desdemona (the pathos of her disoriented, jittery jauntiness intensified by beautiful touches such as the sepia photograph of her estranged father she keeps on the bedside table in Cyprus or the chocolates from Casio that she has secreted in a locked draw, not because she fears sexual misconstruction but because she would like to be thought too grown-up for frivolous sweet-guzzling by Othello) paradoxically diminishes Iago because it encourages the belief that he can be realistically &bquo;explained&equo; like a figure in a novel. 
 With Willard White's massive, resonantly spoken (if rhythmically uncertain) Moor, the slight mismatch of scale between the size of performance and the chamber-dimension of the production is all to the good. 
 Othello is larger-than-life and never more so than when determined to die, as White demonstrates in a nobly paced resumption of dignity in the difficult final scene. 
 But, with Iago, Nunn has opted for a congruence of scales. 
 He has decided that the reason Iago proffers for his villainy (especially the absurd idea that both Casio and Othello have slept with his wife) are genuine, if deranged convictions, rather than the dispassionately improvised rationalisations of a mind that cannot even account to itself for its limitless evil. 
 Accordingly, bitter, accusing looks flash between McKellen and Zoe Wanamaker's excellent, bleakly disillusioned Emilia. 
 When Othello and Desdemona lovingly embrace, Iago grabs his wife in a rough, lewdly competitive clinch. 
 The production's passion for substantiating things also has the effect of downgrading Iago's freewheelingly malign genius. 
 The inspired stroke of telling Othello that he has been witness to one of Casio's incriminatingly erotic dreams is here popped into Iago's head because Casio does, at one point, actually hug him in his sleep. 
 The perverted originality of Iago's ruse, now linked to a cause, thereby loses its lurid gleam. 
 All that said, this is a production which any serious lover of Shakespeare should try to see. 
 If it stimulates you to dissent, it is precisely because it is so closely pondered in its own terms and it never, throughout its four hours, loosens its grip on you. 
 MUSIC / Gone up in smoke: Tosca &mdash; Grand Theatre, Leeds 
 By JULIAN RUSHTON 
 OPERA NORTH's Tosca, first produced last year, is revived with a new conductor and two new principals, once again headed by the flame-haired Tosca of Mary Jane Johnson. 
 If its dramatic focus seems different, it is because Carlo Rizzi's tempi are rather faster than those adopted by Clive Timms; the action progresses less with inexorability than by abrupt shifts of mood. 
 Perhaps not every chord was quite in place, but this remains orchestrally an exciting performance; occasional poor balance between voice and stage emanates, I think, from the acoustic properties of the set. 
 Johnson remains nearly ideal as the jealous, mercurial prima donna. 
 Her powerful and eloquent singing really does not need to be supplemented by low-register Sprechstimme; one can see the point, but Puccini is near enough to raw melodrama without such mannerism. 
 Only the otiose &bquo;Vissi d'arte&equo; actually misfired; should she really be expected to sing it lying down? 
 And given the inevitable draining of tension at this point, it was remarkable indeed how she and the Scarpia, Keith Latham, revived the scene for its murderous climax. 
 Latham stood in without notice for the indisposed Donald Maxwell, anticipating his own planned debut in the role by three months. 
 There was no sign of being unprepared in his typically confident singing, audible even at the end of Act One. 
 He already has a conception of Scarpia, a cunning brute who veers from calculated anger to cool appraisal of Tosca's bottom while her lover is being tortured. 
 One must hope that Maxwell will be well enough to assume the role next week, but meanwhile the company is to be congratulated on replacing him with so sterling a performance by this seasoned professional. 
 Edmund Barham makes Cavaradossi almost as formidable, a convincing aristocrat, tender with Tosca, arrogant with Scarpia, and sung with true tone and great power. 
 Among minor roles I enjoyed Roger Bryson's fussy Sacristan, setting the scene of pious hypocrisy by lighting up during the Angelus. 
 If memory serves, Ian Judge's excellent production, Ann Curtis's fine costumes, and Gerard Howland's half-baked set remain as they were. 
 The problem with the latter is that, despite superficial alterations, principal architectural features remain constant within the distinct localities of the three acts, nicely illustrated in the programme. 
 Judge's ability to achieve a forceful interaction of character would be better served by something more abstract, like the current Peter Grimes set. 
 As it is, grandly pedimented doorways and fluted columns are miraculously transposed from the church to the fortress. 
 Perhaps the final act, with its slow playing out of Scarpia's macabre joke, is beyond redemption dramatically; but how, pray, does Tosca, who exited through vast double doors into a corridor in Act Two, know that the same doors provide, in Act Three, a convenient jumping off point to eternity? 
 THEATRE / Spandau ballad: HID (Hess is Dead) &mdash; RSC Almeida season 
 By MICHAEL CHURCH 
 IN a pre-production interview with this paper Howard Brenton and his director Danny Boyle offered helpful hints as to how we might best grasp the meaning of HID (Hess Is Dead). 
 The play would turn on two questions: did the man officially claimed to be Rudolf Hess really hang himself, and was he Hess at all? 
 In essence, though, it was to be &bquo;a play about modern Europe and the peace we're living in&equo;. 
 The pivotal notion of Spandau prison being pulled down and replaced by a supermarket was one which greatly excited Brenton, signifying at a stroke both Western Europe's descent into cynical consumerism and the wiping out of history. 
 The production would be high-tech, with key scenes performed simultaneously on stage and on videotape. 
 Watching the characters being bugged on TV monitors, the audience would themselves be made to feel under surveillance. 
 Not a madly promising menu, and fraught with predictable dangers. 
 Compared with the mysteries surrounding the deaths of President Kennedy or Marilyn Monroe, the controversy surrounding Spandau's 93-year-old inmate is about as interesting as the fall of a dead leaf. 
 And dispersing the audience's attention among nine separate TV sets is a sure way of dispersing any atmosphere you may have been lucky enough to set up. 
 In the event &mdash; 90 minutes without an interval &mdash; it quickly became clear that all the surveillance in the house would be cruelly trained on those unfortunates doomed to flesh out Brenton's thoughts. 
 The plot, insofar as one could discern it, was both labyrinthine and self-cancellingly ambiguous, built round an interview in a psychiatric hospital between a journalist and the grief-obsessed widow of a German professor who had bequeathed a videotape casting doubt on the official version of Hess's death. 
 The other characters were a sold-out leftie academic (who drew much knowing laughter from the first-night audience), a right-wing academic, a military automaton, and an Amstrad word-processor which enigmatically took the floor in a central scene. 
 The script cut from psychiatry to politics to history to Euro-moralising with dizzy speed; film-clip collages of Hitler saluting, Hess (or not-Hess) in the mortuary, hamburger ads, crumbling buildings, a screaming man in seventeenth-century dress, and the widow miming Hess's improbable suicide all chimed in an unholy jangle with the events on stage. 
 The questions raised may have been interesting, but the answers given were tritely familiar; the authorial tone was relentlessly baleful. 
 David Calder and Polly Walker performed heroically in the leading roles: in their hands Brenton's crudely stereotyped hack and his tediously distracted wench almost became convincing. 
 But one was left wondering at the decision to commit time, money and talent to this dingy piece of hokum. 
 In December HID will be produced in a seventeenth-century dissecting theatre in Amsterdam, thus assuming yet another layer of pseudo-significance. 
 THEATRE / Frozen attitudes: Nearly Siberia &mdash; Soho Poly 
 By ALEX RENTON 
 OME props ought to carry a warning. 
 A good example is the Russian matrioshka doll &mdash; the fat mother with smaller clones within &mdash; that the heroine of poet Carol Rumens's first play Almost Siberia twists apart in a central crisis scene. 
 She is, admittedly, pregnant at the time, but the problem with this familiar literary symbol is that it has rather more inside it than the play does. 
 Almost Siberia is a glasnost spin-off piece: a genre that was bound to have a vogue. 
 When writers go abroad they bring back ideas, understandably enough, and the Russian souvenir shop is no less full of wonders for having had its door opened further. 
 And writers are going to Russia: at the Barbican Pit at the moment is Robert Holman's enchanting play for the RSC, Across Oka, which uses the relationship between an English and a Russian adolescent to say some pithy things about divides both cultural and geographic. 
 Rumens's play has similar concerns, though they are rather less delicately expressed. 
 She pictures the relationship between Katherine, the brash and rather unlikely features editor of Woman Now magazine (do these people really stand around in camisoles dictating gory details about gynaecological examination over radio-phones?) and a Russian exile, Slava. 
 Concealed within Rumens's story is one other &mdash; a fairly familiar account of how jealousy can enfeeble the strongest of us, and how when that jealousy is of the past and of cultural differences it is probably unbeatable. 
 Some of those differences are nicely illustrated. 
 That their duvet cover is made of the Russian flag and the Union Jack can be passed by; better are such details as the fact that Russians call spam &bquo;Roosevelt smile&equo;; the question of whether Down's syndrome chidren are known as Mongols in the USSR, and a dispute over private medicine: &bquo;You think I've fled 1,000 miles from scientific communism just to live with Mrs Engels?&equo; asks Slava. 
 Urbane Slava, nicely played by Peter Silverleaf even though he is much too young for the part, has a fairly dangerous past. 
 The two wives and two children he left behind in Russia call strongly to him, and when, under glasnost relaxations, he gets the chance to visit them, the relationship with Katherine cannot take the strain. 
 The play's chief problem lies in the fact that its Russian aspects, and particularly Slava's mysterious second wife, refuse to become real. 
 This is enhanced by director Julia Pascal's insistence on bathing in red and blue light the scenes where, perhaps in Katherine's imagination, the ex-wife meets Slava. 
 Fairly soon one realises that red means melodrama, and blue means romance, and you wonder if you have stumbled across the first romantic novel of the post-communist era. 
 A genuine, old-fashioned, bedroom surprise scene contributes to the impression. 
 If, perhaps, Katherine was a little more credible (and Gerardine Hinds's rather uncertain playing doesn't help), there might be more to grapple with. 
 But despite Rumens's wit and some good supporting acting, this gets to be little more than one of those stories that might grace Woman Now's problems page. 
 Latest corporate unbundler reveals laid-back approach: Roland Franklin, who is leading a 697m pound break-up bid for DRG, talks to Frank Kane 
 By FRANK KANE 
 IT SEEMS that Roland Franklin, the latest unbundler to appear in the UK, has made a fatal error in the preparation of his &pound;697m break-up bid for stationery and packaging group DRG. 
 He has not properly investigated the target's dining facilities. 
 The 63-year-old head of Pembridge Investments, through which the bid is being mounted says, &bquo;rule number one in this business is: the more luxurious the luncheon rooms at headquarters, the more inefficient the business&equo;. 
 If he had taken his own rule seriously, he would have found out that DRG has a very modest self-service canteen at its Bristol head office. 
 There are other things he has, on his own admission, not fully investigated, like the value of the DRG properties, or which part of the DRG business he would keep after the break up. 
 When the bid was launched last week, Mr Franklin faced some criticism from City commentators on both those counts. 
 He regards the charges as unfounded. 
 On property, he is blunt. 
 &bquo;I do not regard property profits as earnings. 
 We have made a bid of nearly &pound;700m for a company with a book value of &pound;200m &mdash; we've acknowledged there is some extra worth there, but I cannot see the sort of value they are talking about in property. 
 If they can prove it is there, we might pay for it,&equo; 
 On the other criticism he is equally dismissive. 
 &bquo;That point about the core business is very unfair,&equo; he says. 
 It is difficult to decide when you are an outsider what the business is like. 
 We would eventually like to do it along with the management, within the philosophy we will impose.&equo; 
 The Franklin philosophy was learnt in the US leveraged buyout business at the side of Sir James Goldsmith. 
 Mr Franklin went there at the end of the 1970s, after the collapse of Keyser Ullman, the merchant bank where he was a director that was rescued by the Bank of England. 
 He feels that Keyser's problems were hastened by an unwise acquisition. 
 He went to the US because &bquo;Goldsmith decided that if you wanted to be a capitalist the UK and France were not the places to be&equo;. 
 Along with Sir James he found the US much more attractive, taking over and breaking up some fairly hefty US corporations. 
 He rejects charges that he was partly responsible for the &bquo;casino atmosphere&equo; that gripped US corporate life in the early 1980s. 
 &bquo;We stirred it up, yes, but we never lost any money for anybody and we never added to the unemployment figures.&equo; 
 What he has learned from Goldsmith (&bquo;the only genius I have ever come across&equo;) is that the holding company is not the most important unit of corporate organisation. 
 &bquo;The concept of the company does not interest me - it's the businesses that are important. 
 It does not matter whether or not DRG makes sellotape or Basildon Bond &mdash; it's of no consequence to anybody if somebody else makes them.&equo; 
 And there is always the ultimate unbundler's defence &mdash; that he will make money for his backers. 
 In a takeover campaign that has already seen vitriolic language, he responds to the charge that he is mounting the bid to enrich himself and his friends by saying: &bquo;Nobody could take that as a criticism &mdash; this is an investor group. 
 It would be a criticism if I was doing it to impoverish myself&equo;. 
 Square Mile: Stock Exchange takes the bull by the horns 
 By JOHN MOORE 
 SLOW developer; confusing thinker who is liable to cause controversy and conflict. 
 These are the characteristics of the International Stock Exchange's own Taurus programme rather than one of the signs of the zodiac. 
 For years the International Stock Exchange has been attempting to reduce the flow of paper on share transactions through the evolution of a computerised system known as Taurus. 
 With its enthusiasm for acronyms, the exchange has taken the &bquo;Taurus&equo; title for its computerised settlement masterplan from the full title of the scheme, the ponderously named Transfer and Automated Registration of Uncertificated Stock system. 
 Such a scheme will allow firms operating on the exchange to hold and transfer shares without the need for share certificates. 
 Proposals for the development of a Taurus system have been under consideration for much of this decade. 
 But, even at this stage, there are many hurdles to overcome, as a conference of City experts highlighted last week. 
 At the core of the problems in the development of the Taurus system is the rapidly changing character of financial markets and their structure. 
 When original objectives were set out in the early 1980s for improving services and reducing costs at the exchange through cutting down on the amount of paperwork, more detailed efforts were made to put the objectives into action. 
 These were overtaken by the Government's plans to deregulate the British securities market, announced in 1983, which were to lead to Big Bang. 
 There were then more pressing priorities. 
 But since 1987 there has been added impetus to the development of the Taurus programme, triggered largely by the post-Big Bang boom in share dealing and the subsequent crash in 1987. 
 Huge backlogs of work built up in the securities dealers' back offices as deals could not be completed within the exchange's usual accounts periods. 
 According to Anthony Preece, director of operations at investment group Citicorp Scrimgeour Vickers, speaking at last week's conference, there were at least 13 different design concepts for the future Taurus system under discussion in the City as of March this year. 
 Aside from the technological requirements of the new system, other important issues have to be resolved. 
 The participants in Taurus, the requirements needed for the participants, and the international consequences of the new system, are receiving detailed consideration. 
 Potential members of Taurus include the listed companies affected by the scheme, registrars, private client brokers, retail brokers, custodian banks, institutional investors, and money brokers. 
 Yet as Andrew Palmer, deputy finance director at Legal &amp; General Investments warned at the same conference, &bquo;like all chains, Taurus is only going to be as strong as its weakest link. 
 And technology could easily become the weak link with some participants&equo;. 
 He said that in the last two years he had met very few institutions which had not cut back their system budgets following the 1987 crash in share prices in the stock market. 
 &bquo;It would be a serious mistake for them to believe that they could put the whole Taurus market place at jeopardy by cutting back on their Taurus budget.&equo; 
 On the international front Bill Widdis, director of systems development at the stock exchange, is wary of arguments calling for full transnational integration of share clearing systems. 
 &bquo;We must note that the nations of Europe have evolved their national clearing and depository systems over many years and, for many reasons, they are all different from one another,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;Some systems serve markets in only one member state, while others, specialising in cerain types of instruments, are of European importance,&equo; he stresses. 
 &bquo;Any developments towards integration should take this diversity into account and not seek to prescribe a uniform model when national differences do not compromise the objective of efficient and secure international settlement.&equo; 
 BIIBA-Fimbra battle worsens 
 THE gentlemanly war between the British Insurance and Investment Brokers Association (BIIBA) and the Financial Intermediaries, Managers and Brokers Regulatory Association (Fimbra) appears to be escalating. 
 BIIBA has now made a strong complaint to Fimbra about the latter's decision to withdraw from an agreement made on 18 September which would have allowed BIIBA members, who held existing professional indemnity cover, to renew their existing policies. 
 Fimbra, as the regulatory body of middlemen who sell investment and insurance products, is attempting to require that these intermediaries hold professional indemnity insurance cover through a centralised scheme provided by Fimbra. 
 The insurance cover is designed to protect intermediaries against suits for damages brought by irate customers. 
 BIIBA, as the trade association attempting to represent most middlemen, is equally unhappy that Fimbra is attempting to bring in a centralised insurance scheme, as most of BIIBA's members have their own professional indemnity insurance cover. 
 A centralised scheme would disrupt existing relationships between BIIBA members and their insurers, and lose them valuable financial advantages such as a no claims bonus. 
 BIIBA wanted a stay of execution on Fimbra's plans and thought that it had gained such a deal when its chairman, David Palmer, met Fimbra chairman Lord Elton. 
 In those discussions BIIBA claims that it was agreed that its members would be allowed to renew their existing policies up to 31 October 1990. 
 A misunderstanding then seems to have occurred with Fimbra writing to its members last week saying that its scheme had not been altered in any way and that members could not renew existing policies if the renewal date was after 1990. 
 BIIBA's director of public affairs commented: &bquo;Fimbra have clearly reneged on their agreement. 
 In view of the rumours of meetings between it and the underwriters of the Fimbra scheme it appears that the insurers are calling the shots. 
 For a scheme which was claimed to take independent financial advisers out of the power of insurers, this is an ironic situation for Fimbra to have got itself into.&equo; 
 The campaign continues. 
 A new aroma THE International Stock Exchange started out life as a London coffee shop. 
 Last week it admitted its 400th member, the Swedish-owned United Securities Fondkommission, the first time that level has been reached in its 300-year history. 
 Perhaps the ISE ought to bring out a commemorative and suitably international blend. 
 View from Manhattan: Airlines fly into regulatory storm 
 By LARRY BLACK 
 RE-REGULATION is the buzzword on the lips of the US airline industry, as the worst excesses of the oligopoly bred by its predecessor, deregulation, once again became evident. 
 While the stock of yet another carrier soared on buyout speculation, a fatal crash at New York's La Guardia Airport, again brought lax airline safety to public attention. 
 And another bankruptcy, involving Braniff Airlines, reminded everyone of the stranglehold the Big Eight carriers have over the domestic market. 
 But it was neither safety, monopoly nor dangerous debt loads that precipitated the first major intervention in the industry by Transportation Secretary Samuel Skinner last week. 
 It was &bquo;national security concerns&equo;. 
 On Friday, citing worries about foreign influence over civil aviation, Mr Skinner issued a &bquo;consent order&equo; on NorthWest Airlines, forcing it to reduce the involvement of KLM, the Dutch carrier, in its recent buyout. 
 Earlier his office issued a request for information to United Airlines, whose &dollar;6.8bn staff buyout is to be part-financed by &dollar;750m from British Airways. 
 Foreign involvement in US carriers, Mr Skinner argued recently, could compromise response to a national emergency. 
 &bquo;Civil aviation must have a clear commitment to America,&equo; he said. 
 KLM's part in the NorthWest deal falls short of the 25 per cent limit placed on foreign ownership by the Federal Aviation Act of 1958. 
 But the Dutch airline has had to agree to reduce its &dollar;400m investment in NorthWest to about &dollar;175m, or about a quarter of the equity involved in the takeover being led by Los Angeles businessman Al Checchi. 
 The &dollar;3.65bn buyout will increase the airline's debt-equity ratio from less than 50 per cent to 585 per cent and NorthWest operates one of the oldest fleets in the industry, but Mr Skinner's chief concern was the citizenship of KLM's representative on the NorthWest board. 
 &bquo;I can't figure out why foreign investment is the battlefield he decided to pick,&equo; one official said on Friday. 
 Washington's stance seems sure to complicate the United Airlines buyout, which was to close a few days after the 10 October deadline set by Mr Skinner for information on BA's involvement. 
 Though BA would have only 15 per cent of the voting shares in United, the second-largest US airline, its investment represents almost 80 per cent of the equity in the deal. 
 Under the apparent terms of the Transportation Secretary's new regulations, BA would have to slash its contribution by &dollar;500m &mdash; probably killing the staff buyout &mdash; and would effectively lose its representation on the UA board. 
 Changing the ground rules has angered investors on both sides of the Atlantic, and Mr Skinner's mandate for this is being widely questioned - particularly as foreign carriers are already represented on US airline boards. 
 British Department of Transport officials have expressed concern about the probable restrictions and urged &bquo;an open and free investment climate&equo;. 
 The irony of Mr Skinner's re-regulation of the airline industry, say Wall Street analysts, is that it comes after the shake-out among domestic carriers has taken place and serves only to reinforce the advantages enjoyed by the surviving majors. 
 Mr Skinner's real concern is not United's loyalties in the event of an Anglo-American war but the bargaining strength of the US industry in international negotiations. 
 Bilateral treaties now regulate trans-Atlantic air traffic, and 1992 has US carriers worried about their strength in future talks. 
 US airlines not involved in partnerships complain Europe does not allow reciprocal investments in flag carriers, and argue that protectionism will worsen with continental integration. 
 US airlines already find themselves at a disadvantage because of &bquo;open sky&equo; policies during Reagan-era deregulation, they say. 
 Mr Skinner in speeches decrying &bquo;unparalleled levels of foreign investment&equo;, has made references to &bquo;the covenants that spell out the opportunities&equo; for the airlines of each nation. 
 Foreign influence over major US airlines would mean &bquo;this framework would be radically altered,&equo; he said. 
 What could rescue the United Airlines deal is the nature of the buyout; United employees will control 75 per cent of the airline's voting stock, making it by far the largest employee-owned corporation in the US. 
 A strong political lobby has already been mounted in Washington, arguing United &bquo;will remain a truly American asset&equo; because of the staff participation. 
 Democrat Robert Byrd, the former Senate leader, has criticised Mr Skinner's actions in the NorthWest deal, and warned against interfering in United. 
 United is also arguing that employee concessions in the deal should be considered &bquo;sweat equity&equo;, reducing BA's contribution to 35 per cent. 
 If BA can resell &dollar;300m of its United investment &mdash; ideally to US citizens - then its remaining equity share could be said to be only 21 per cent, airline officials in New York argue. 
 Mr Skinner's action also raises the possibility of retaliation by other governments, and of slower international liberalisation if not an outright global re-regulatory war. 
 &bquo;The US may find it fairly unfriendly when some of its carriers want to make deals in Europe,&equo; said Jon Ash of Global Aviation, an airline consulting firm. 
 &bquo;It has major implications for all future transactions.&equo; 
 USM: Remedial action at Lincat has results 
 By JOHN SHEPHERD 
 THE SHARE price of Lincat Group, maker of commercial catering equipment, is getting a boost after being toppled from its perch of 175p this summer when news of continuing problems at three subsidiaries filtered through to the City. 
 Analysts downgraded four-year profit projections and exposed Lincat to the harsher side of stock market life, culminating in a fall in the share price to 127p. 
 Apart from its loss-makers Lan-Elec and Abbey Clocks, the cost-cutting programme at a large profit generator, Corsair, was running behind schedule. 
 Group profits before tax for the first six months of the year soared by 46 per cent but the final result to 30 June, announced last week, showed a less than sparkling advance of 26 per cent to &pound;1.28m compared to earlier City predictions of &pound;1.4m-plus. 
 The poor second half performance, however, masks the changes that have been made at Lincat, which is now placed to deliver more acceptable returns. 
 The ill-fitting Abbey Clocks and most of the assets of Lan-Elec have been sold, and Corsair's problems have been rectified by a new face behind its managing director's desk. 
 Attention has also been focused on expanding through acquisition, removing doubts about the board's ability to mix lateral movements with logical progression. 
 July saw the purchase of Colbrook Equipment, a designer of food display units, for a maximum profits-related payment of &pound;2.16m &mdash; less than seven times Colbrook's pre-tax earnings of &pound;329,000 in 1988. 
 Lincat also announced last week its first overseas acquisition. 
 Douglas, the leading US maker of pan washers for the bakery trade, provides a profitable US base and the chance to undercut the market by setting up more cost effective production facilities based on Lincat's UK operations. 
 The purchases, together with the remedial action, should ensure that Martin Craddock, chairman and chief executive, can at least match analysts' forecasts of &pound;1.8m pre-tax when he reports on the 1989-90 year. 
 Taking last Friday's price of 160p, Lincat is on an undemanding p/e of 9.5 and less than eight the following year. 
 Guy Bell of Beeson Gregory, a new name dealing in USM shares, says the company is under rated and is set for medium-term expansion. 
 MB and Caradon stay quiet on bid rumours 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 MB GROUP, the old Metal Box company, refused to confirm yesterday that it was on the verge of a &pound;300m-plus bid for Caradon, the building products group. 
 Caradon also refused to comment, but has already announced that it was involved in talks which could lead to a bid. 
 Its share price closed on Friday at 474p, valuing the group at &pound;282.2m. 
 A rise of 14p amid speculative interest added almost &pound;10m to the value of the bathroom fittings and showers business on Friday. 
 Analysts expect the company to make &pound;36m pre-tax profits for the year to March. 
 The price has risen by 119p since Caradon announced a possible bid on 31 August. 
 While MB is refusing to comment on what it called &bquo;market rumours&equo;, senior executives, including chief executive Murray Stuart were involved in meetings at MB's head offices yesterday. 
 City sources believe MB is the most likely suitor for Caradon as it reshapes into an international trading company. 
 Last week it announced first-quarter contributions of &pound;11.1m from CMB &mdash; the result of the &pound;900m merger between Metal Box and the French Carnaud company. 
 MB has two core businesses along with its CMB shareholding &mdash; security printing and heating and bathroom products. 
 Last month it agreed to spend &pound;194.2m on the US-based ABS cheque-printing business. 
 A pro-forma statement of the combined companies' net assets was &pound;294m. 
 MB's building products division has a large overlap with Caradon's operations. 
 Caradon was floated in July 1987 with a market value of &pound;134m following a &pound;61m management buyout from Reed in 1985. 
 A slow down in the bathroom business &mdash; identified by MB when it announced its results last week &mdash; affected City confidence in Caradon. 
 But it has a range of highly-regarded brand names including Mira showers, Twyford bathroom fittings and Celuform plastic timber systems. 
 Last year Caradon bought the Everest double-glazing business from RTZ for &pound;32m and was thought to be stalking further acquisitions. 
 MB last week admitted its Stelrad central heating and bathroom products business was operating in a reduced UK market for central heating and stagnating bathrooom products market. 
 European markets are more buoyant, and some analysts believe Caradon's products could be sold more strongly in Europe. 
 B &amp; Q team buys Kent Garden Centres 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 THE MANAGEMENT team which helped develop the B &amp; Q DIY business is on the acquisition trail again &mdash; this time in the gardening business with a &bquo;multi-million pound&equo; deal to buy Kent Garden Centres, writes Jerry Connolly. 
 The acquisition, announced yesterday, brings five centres and two development sites into the Retail Corporation, which plans a nationwide chain of 50 garden centres under its Gardenstore operation within two years. 
 Retail, which refuses to disclose the terms of the deal, was set up last year with &pound;10m of City capital and is headed by Malcolm Parkinson, the former B &amp; Q managing director. 
 Mr Parkinson says Gardenstore, with 11 outlets on more than 66 acres, &bquo;is one of the top four garden centre chains in turnover and number of sites, and largest in square footage terms&equo;. 
 John Kennedy, former B &amp; Q financial and systems director, is also on the Retail board along with Alan Greensides, former buying and merchandising director at the DIY concern. 
 They believe the garden centre business is at the same stage of development as DIY was a decade ago. 
 A spokesman said: &bquo;The industry is highly fragmented and business will be growing through acquisitions for some time. 
 Retail is unwilling to help the opposition by saying what it paid for Kent.&equo; 
 Europe's mobile phones top the 2 million mark 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 EUROPE'S cellular radio market broke the two million subscriber barrier in September, a rise of 26 per cent since the beginning of the year. 
 According to the Fintech Mobile Communications newsletter, the UK is still by far the largest market with almost 700,000 subscribers split between Racal Telecom's Vodafone and British Telecom's Cellnet. 
 But although the UK now has 12.28 cellular telephones per 1,000 inhabitants, Norway leads the penetration stakes with almost 40 handsets per 1,000 inhabitants. 
 Apart from the UK and Scandinavian countries, penetration is still low in Europe, but this is expected to change over the next few years as telecommunications markets are opened up. 
 West Germany, for example, is to introduce a digital cellular radio service in competition with that offered by the Deutsche Bundespost, and France has already licensed a private operator. 
 The real boost for cellular radio will come in two to three years' time with the introduction of the Europe-wide service, GSM. 
 33m pounds buyout of FIG goes ahead 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 THE &pound;33m management buyout by Fenchurch Insurance Group from GPG has been completed despite pressure for a better price from GPG shareholders including Robert Maxwell. 
 Mr Maxwell, with 15 per cent of GPG, the old Guiness Peat Group, and Lord Kissin, with a five per cent stake, strongly opposed plans to sell off three of GPG's operating companies. 
 But shareholders voted by three to one last week to back the sell-offs which will reduce borrowings to a consortium of banks, who acquired 61 per cent of GPG after the collapse of the New Zealand Equiticorp business. 
 The mbo of Fenchurch was engineered by JO Hambro Magan, whose managing director Alton Irby said: &bquo;It shows that leveraged buyouts can be done, even if this one was difficult. 
 &bquo;The problem was that an insurance broker is not asset-backed. 
 It has cash flow but its assets are its people. 
 The insurance business cycle is also at a low ebb. 
 Around a hundred of the staff have taken part in the buyout, which we are very pleased with. 
 It shows they have confidence in the management.&equo; 
 The mbo is being led by six senior executives. 
 The buyout involves an initial payment of &pound;30m, with a further &pound;3.2m of deferred payments including &pound;2.7m for contingencies. 
 Equity in the mbo vehicle is being provided by FIG staff, with mezzanine finance arranged and under-written by Intermediate Capital Group. 
 Senior debt is underwritten by National Westminster Bank. 
 Economic Outlook: A deficit between consenting adults 
 By SARAH HOGG 
 The Chancellor is trying to convince his political audience that Britain's deficit (now running at close on 4 per cent of national income) is not a problem; and to convince the markets not to sell sterling. 
 In both arguments, the next two weeks &mdash; which include a probable German interest-rate rise and an unavoidable Conservative Party conference &mdash; will be critical. 
 If Mr Lawson can hold off a base rate rise at least until he can blame the Germans, that will make his political task a fraction easier; but not much. 
 The balance of payments is a circular identity of inflows and outflows, which must necessarily match each other. 
 You can start the argument at any point on the circle. 
 Viewed from one angle, a current account deficit is merely the necessary counterpart of a capital account surplus, and it is from this point that Nigel Lawson's defensive intellectual outworks run. 
 Britain's kind of deficit arises not because the Government needs to borrow; the public sector itself is in heavy surplus. 
 The deficit is created by the actions of the private sector. 
 If &mdash; so his argument goes &mdash; consenting adults in the private sectors of different countries lend money to each other, all that shows is that capital markets are usefully redirecting the surplus savings of one economy to the investment opportunities in another. 
 That detached observer, the International Monetary Fund, calls this kind of deficit &bquo;efficient and self-correcting&equo;. 
 History shows it can go on for a long time, as deficits and surpluses did during the golden age before the First World War. 
 Very recent history suggests the world has become much more like that again, with investment in each country breaking free from the constraint of domestic savings. 
 Evidence of excessive demand There is some observable good sense in this argument, and it helps to explain why sterling has not hit the fan a lot earlier, during a truly spectacular swing from surplus to deficit over the past two years. 
 But its limits are exposed by asking a simple question: why, then, should Mr Lawson not be quite happy to see the deficit get even larger? 
 Why should a &bquo;good&equo; deficit not get even &bquo;better&equo;? 
 The first reason the Chancellor gives is that there is some &bquo;bad&equo; froth on the &bquo;good&equo; deficit: that is to say, evidence of excessive domestic demand. 
 This argument starts from a different point on the balance of payments circle, with the excess of imports over exports. 
 Even here, something can be found to say for the deficit, as a safety valve for inflationary pressures. 
 But it still has, willy-nilly, to be financed by attracting capital inflows. 
 Now, this surge in demand was equally clearly created by the grown-up private sector, not by a government binge. 
 But here Mr Lawson does not seem to be quite so indifferent to the behaviour of consenting adults: he has been endeavouring to control their behaviour by altering the price at which they can borrow. 
 Answer number two turns on another price that bothers him. 
 International borrowing nowadays takes place in a world of moving exchange rates. 
 In pre-1914 days, there was a gold standard, and a single world capital market centred on London. 
 Today there is again a global capital market, but no gold standard, no fixed exchange rates, for Britain not even a European Monetary System. 
 That is not Mr Lawson's fault, of course, but he has to live with the danger that while the world's capital markets will duly bridge the gap between Britain's domestic savings and investment, they will only do so at a lower price for sterling. 
 If you take the argument about consenting adults to its logical conclusion, that price &mdash; Britain's exchange rate &mdash; should be left to them, too. 
 But however suspicious Mrs Thatcher may be of managed exchange rate systems, she dislikes a falling pound as much as anyone. 
 So we come back around the circle to the capital side of the balance of payments, and the operationally interesting question: for how long can we expect the world's savers to make up our domestic shortage? 
 Mr Lawson is right to say that deficits are more sustainable than they were in the 1970s. 
 There is indeed a world market for savings, although that is not a wholly comforting fact: the Chancellor himself foresees a world shortage of savings, which means everyone is going to have to compete harder (ie, pay more) for them. 
 Meanwhile, market operators take due account of exchange rate risk; and what alarms them is not so much the size, but the direction of a deficit. 
 Over-optimism at the Treasury Through the summer, the signs of a slowdown in domestic demand had come reasonably on cue: the inflation figures duly peaked, retail sales tailed off, even labour costs did not accelerate as fast as feared. 
 Car sales were uncomfortably large, and with them the July trade deficit; but the Treasury thought it detected more comforting underlying trends. 
 Last week it was obliged to admit, yet again, to over-optimism. 
 The Chancellor is now prepared to claim no more than that the deficit is &bquo;more or less flattening out&equo;. 
 Not much of a claim, more than a year after he started trying to turn the tide; and one yet to be proven, anyway. 
 There are such awkward critics as Fred Bergsten, of the Institute of International Economics in Washington, who argue that a private-sector induced deficit might actually be more tiresome than the US-style &bquo;twin deficits&equo; &mdash; in public finances and the current account &mdash; because however much he deprecates the latter, at least it is clear what ought to be done. 
 It is, he argues, not at all clear how you raise private savings to close the other kind of gap. 
 This point should not be pushed to perversity: the IMF is still clear that a US-style deficit is worse, and it certainly is not being quickly corrected. 
 But Mr Lawson has to show he knows how to do the trick, before he can win his argument, in theory or in the markets. 
 Corporate Profile: French flair and Le Mortgage push Compagnie Bancaire ahead: Michael Prest takes a look at one of Europe's most unusual and successful financial groups 
 By MICHAEL PREST 
 BRITISH yuppies yearning for that charming little place they saw in the Dordogne last summer have probably never heard of Compagnie Bancaire. 
 But since 1988 they may well have taken out &bquo;Le Mortgage&equo; offered by the French company's British offshoot, UCB Group, to finance their terrain gastronomique. 
 In so doing, they will have added their mite to the expansion of one of Europe's most unusual and successful financial groups. 
 Le Mortgage offers fixed-rate sterling finance to Britons wanting to buy second homes in France. 
 CB takes care of the notaire who is the dread of British buyers of French property. 
 It is a tiny part of CB's business. 
 But in several ways it illustrates the group's strengths: size combined with flair, a strong French base from which to develop business abroad, and a flexible structure. 
 CB is certainly successful. 
 Consolidated net operating income has risen from FFr880m (&pound;86.3m) in 1984 to FFr1.34bn last year. 
 Over the same period new business almost doubled to FFr68.4bn, total loans and other financings grew from FFr94.3bn to FFr146bn, and savings managed jumped from FFr6.3bn to FFr29.9bn. 
 In 1988 the group had 8,000 employees, of whom 500 were outside France. 
 More important, perhaps, CB is an unusual organisation. 
 As a massive lender which takes no deposits, a marketer of industrial and consumer finance, and increasingly a purveyor of insurance-related products to an under-insured French public, CB probably embodies a unique combination of strategy and interests. 
 There is definitely no parallel in Britain. 
 CB originated in the ruins of France one year after the end of the Second World War as Union Financiere d'Enterprises Francaises et Etrangeres. 
 Its founder, Jacques de Fouchier, is still closely associated with the group as Chairman Emeritus &mdash; itself an unsual idea &mdash; of the supervisory board. 
 In the early years, the company was involved mainly in financing imports of raw materials and factory equipment, and its chief shareholders were the leading French banks. 
 Since then two related developments have given the group its unusual character. 
 One development was a network of stakes in the principal companies in each type of business. 
 Four of these companies are quoted separately from CB on the Paris Bourse (CB received a London listing in 1973): UCB (33 per cent owned by CB, in housing and property finance), UFB Locabail (66.2 per cent, business equipment finance), Cetelem (67.7 per cent, consumer finance), and Cardif (56 per cent, life insurance and savings products). 
 The man who runs the group is 51-year-old Andre Levy-Lang. 
 He is the engaging chairman of CB's management board, whose education at the Ecole Polytechnique and doctorate from Stanford University create an aura of international competence one meets too rarely in British companies. 
 He explained that the structure evolved because the group needed equity to finance growth. 
 Several of the quoted subsidiaries and associates also control other businesses, for example Solveg, a property portfolio management company, in which several CB group companies have stakes. 
 This structure is typical of the continental, as distinct from the British, firm: the holding group, particularly the bank holding group, stems from equity involvement in industry, an involvement shunned by British banks. 
 At the same time, CB, as it became in 1959, has seen the source of its earnings diversify as consumer finance became more and more important to the group. 
 Loans made in 1979 totalled FFr59.1m, of which property accounted for FFr40m and consumer finance accounted for FFr9.29m, or 15.7 per cent of the total. 
 By 1988, however, the picture had changed dramatically. 
 Consumer finance contributed FFr40m, or a quarter, to all loans that year of FFr147m, while property made up FFr75.1m of the total. 
 The tell-tale sign was that at FFr29.5m, consumer finance was easily the biggest component in new lending last year. 
 In the early 1980s, new lending was roughly the same in consumer finance as in housing and property finance. 
 Another simultaneous change of long-term importance to CB is the growth of overseas business. 
 The total of loans and other financings to customers outside France has gone up from FFr28m in 1981 to FFr10.7m last year. 
 Mr Levy-Lang said that this year a quarter of new lending will have been outside France, and 90 per cent of that will have been in the United Kingdom. 
 CB already claims 2 per cent of the British fixed-rate mortgage market. 
 Mr Levy-Lang is casual about CB's expansion. 
 The move into consumer finance, he said, was chiefly caused by restrictions on lending, the corset, to other areas. 
 &bquo;Regulation made us do that,&equo; he said. 
 CB, he claimed, had in mind no particular balance between its components. 
 &bquo;We have no ratio in the mix of business. 
 We want to grow as fast as we can.&equo; 
 But there are disciplines. 
 The key objective is a 15 per cent return on equity, and all business within the group is conducted at arm's length on guidelines laid down by CB at the centre. 
 Mr Levy-Lang said: &bquo;It is a financial discipline in a way. 
 We can't do anything we want within the group.&equo; 
 There is also a shrewd understanding of what consumers want. 
 With a wry smile, Mr Levy-Lang observed: &bquo;I have a great belief in the rationality of consumers. 
 They are very intelligent economists, all of them.&equo; 
 He acknowledges that as a result, the consumer finance and investment markets are very competitive, not least in France where savers now have more faith in money, as distinct from assets, and the big banks are muscling in. 
 One solution for CB, according to Mr Levy-Lang, is attention to detail. 
 &bquo;We approach every problem as a specific problem. 
 It is what makes us different from the commercial banks. 
 You have to offer specific services to specific people.&equo; 
 Despite its rate of return target, the average between 1984 and 1988 was 12.7 per cent, slipping to 12.4 per cent last year. 
 Several factors are inhibiting growth of earnings: a weaker domestic loan market, tighter interest rate margins, and slow growth by some subsidiaries. 
 The latter is within CB's competence to remedy. 
 Cardif, the insurance company, and Cortal, the asset management division of CB, have both grown too slowly recently for the group's taste. 
 CB is also trying to substitute floating rate for fixed rate mortgages in France. 
 These problems will take a while to sort out. 
 CB is also most unlikely to reach its ambitious goal of generating half its earnings outside France by 1992, despite having started 20 new businesses in Europe over the last few years. 
 Mr Levy-Lang is characteristically disingenuous about the talismanic date of 1992. 
 &bquo;It led us to speed it up,&equo; he said, while denying that the alleged single market would of itself promote business. 
 Blessed with tight and impressive management, however, and its firm French base, CB's long-term growth seems assured, whatever the specific problems. 
 And there will be no difficulty in following events. 
 The group's financial yearbook, beautifully produced in English, is as comprehensive as the most demanding analyst could wish. 
 Perhaps after Le Mortgage the British will see &bquo;Le Life Policy&equo; and &bquo;Le Loan&equo;. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By MICHAEL PREST 
 TODAY: Revised UK retail figures for August. 
 Change in UK credit business. 
 US August construction spending. 
 Japanese foreign exchange reserves (September). 
 West Germany current account (August). 
 WEDNESDAY: UK housing starts and completions (August). 
 UK overseas travel and tourism contribution to invisible earnings (July). 
 THURSDAY: UK second quarter personal income and expenditure figures. 
 UK second quarter industry finance statistics. 
 Bundesbank council meeting (West Germany) FRIDAY: UK second quarter steel consumption and stock changes (final). 
 US unemployment (September). 
 US non-farm payrolls (September). 
 Commodities: Reading higher prices in the tea leaves 
 By MICHAEL PREST 
 SINCE we are in the middle of the International Coffee Organisation meeting -how do they pass a week without a visible result? &mdash; I thought it appropriate to think about tea. 
 It is not such a perverse idea, because a lot of people have recently become interested in that noble beverage. 
 As always, the interest is not unconnected with a little matter of price. 
 At last Monday's weekly London tea auction, prices reached their highest for three years. 
 Many in the trade expect prices to go up further today, and possibly for quite a few auctions to come. 
 Richard Howell of Sheppards, the London stockbrokers, has been following tea and plantation shares for 20 years. 
 &bquo;My anticipation is that we will certainly see a rise on Monday &mdash; not of the same proportion, but there's clearly going to be a rise. 
 What's developed in 1989 is a genuine shortage of teas of all grades.&equo; 
 Over the past 12 months the price of lower medium quality tea, which is the main ingredient in the British cuppa and imparts that unique lorry-driver flavour, has almost doubled from 78p a kilogramme to 135p. 
 Medium qualities have also risen noticeably, from 98p to 145p, over the same period. 
 But quality teas, the best grade, have hardly changed at around 200p a kilogramme. 
 The rise is particularly interesting because it confounded expectations. 
 The Economist Intelligence Unit concluded in its World Commodity Outlook 1989: &bquo;Short of climatic intervention &mdash; to which tea is less vulnerable than most other major crops &mdash; a continuation of the downtrend seems unavoidable: we expect London auction prices to average &pound;1/kg, or even less, in 1989.&equo; 
 At the beginning of the year, however, the trend argument was much more plausible than it is today. 
 World production of tea (black and green) grew from 2.27m tonnes in 1985 to 2.34m tonnes in 1987, and rose again in 1988. 
 Whereas, according to the United States Department of Agriculture, world production rose by 4.5 per cent, consumption, on estimates by the International Monetary Fund, went up by only 2.6 per cent. 
 At the same time, the main import markets continued to decline. 
 In 1987 imports into Britain fell by 12 per cent, although with around a fifth of the market we remained easily the world's biggest tea importers. 
 The Irish, however, drink an average of 3 cups a day, fractionally more than the British. 
 But beware of extrapolations, my daughter. 
 Expectations were upset for three basic reasons: First, the long Tamil insurgency in Sri Lanka has finally taken its toll of the tea estates. 
 Exports from that lovely island could be 40 per cent lower in 1989 than in 1988. 
 Since Sri Lanka previously exported about 200,000 tonnes of tea annually, only a little less than India, the biggest exporter, the loss is crucial. 
 Second, there was a climatic disaster. 
 Malawi, which exports normally about 40,000 tonnes a year, has suffered from a serious drought. 
 Only a good crop in Kenya has saved Africa from another disaster. 
 Third, Indian exports have been depressed by a combination of politics and nature. 
 The political factor is the imminent general election. 
 Fearful of the consequences of higher tea prices, the government has sought to stabilise them by fiddling the weekly Calcutta auctions. 
 In alternate weeks the auction is wholly devoted to domestic buyers or to foreign buyers. 
 Since the bulk of the tea at the Calcutta auctions is low medium quality, the dual auction has a disproportionate impact on tea prices generally, and on London prices especially. 
 This effect has been compounded by the natural factor, a disappointing crop in southern India. 
 There are other elements in the price rise as well. 
 At the end of last year, again largely for political reasons, the Pakistan government granted licences to importers to bring in tea. 
 Pakistan is now a net tea importer. 
 In a different and much more alarming category is the fate of the Soviet industry. 
 The Soviet Union used to produce about 150,000 tonnes of tea a year, making it one of the biggest growers. 
 But nuclear power changed that. 
 According to Mr Howell, all the bushes in Georgia were polluted by radiation, and have been destroyed. 
 For the first time that anyone can remember, the Soviet Union has been buying at the London auction. 
 Mr Howell is convinced that the tea market under-supplied for several years. 
 &bquo;This genuine shortage is occurring for the first time ever. 
 This is the great genuine move in the tea price.&equo; 
 There is evidence to support the case that prices will remain high for a while. 
 Despite the withdrawal of the Indian army from Sri Lanka, peace may not be established. 
 Even if it is, some estates could take years to rehabilitate. 
 A tea bush requires constant attention: if not plucked for a year it can take two years to return to normal; if bushes have to be uprooted, new ones take seven years to come into production. 
 Despite the relative growth of consumption and demand in the mid-1980s, the market for black tea alone was finely balanced at around 1.67m tonnes. 
 Moreover, the four biggest growers and exporters &mdash; India, Sri Lanka, China and Kenya &mdash; also have large populations and / or high birth rates. 
 As the Indian example shows, domestic consumption is a vital factor. 
 Yet one must be cautious. 
 Historically tea has been a fairly dull market, dominated by trade interests &mdash; two arguments against the London Fox's efforts to excite interest in a tea futures contract. 
 A balanced market, by definition, can swing surprisingly fast in the opposite direction: the chances are, for example, that Malawi will not have a drought next year. 
 But for all I know, the ICO could still be meeting then. 
 International Capital Markets: Accountants face hard task in search for global harmony 
 By DAVID FRANK 
 YESTERDAY was the last day for comments from the public on a paper issued in January entitled: &bquo;Comparability of Financial Statements&equo; published by the International Accounting Standards Committee. 
 This is hardly the sort of catchy title guaranteed to get most of us rushing to our desks in search of pen and paper, nor is it easy to imagine squeezing into packed village halls to listen to speeches demanding a rewrite of the rules on deferred taxation. 
 In acknowledgement of this, IASC, which comprises the leading world accounting bodies, sent out a separate invitation to interested parties asking for their views on the subject. 
 It called this: &bquo;Towards the International Harmonisation of Financial Statements&equo;. 
 Harmonising international accounting standards is more important than one might think. 
 In today's markets, where increasingly companies are looking to raise funds beyond their own national borders, agreement on an objective standard for measuring the financial health of a business is vital. 
 The world's top securities market regulators, who met recently in Venice, cited the need to reconcile financial statements to local accounting standards as a significant factor in any company's decision on which markets to target or not for an international offering of new shares. 
 The lack of accounting harmonisation, particularly between the US and the UK, is seen by many bankers as the key issue in the development of the Euro-equity market, where new issues of shares are offered in more than one country simultaneously. 
 Two examples highlight the problems. 
 When British Telecom was privatised, shares were issued both in the US and the UK (and other jurisdictions). 
 BT's registration statement for the US showed that &bquo;net income&equo; and &bquo;shareholders&equo; equity' under UK generally accepted accounting principles (Gaap) were each double the US Gaap figures and retained earnings were three times the US Gaap equivalent. 
 When BP made its disastrous privatisation offering at the time of the crash, its profit forecast for the year ending 31 December, 1987, computed in accordance with UK Gaap, was &pound;1.45bn whereas its forecast based on US Gaap was 25 per cent lower at &pound;1.1bn. 
 Both forecasts were included in the US and Canadian prospectuses. 
 The UK prospectus, however, contained only the UK Gaap computed forecast. 
 The problem IASC, and the market regulators' body Iosco, faces though is determining how harmonisation can be brought about. 
 Everyone might agree that financial statements should be based on the same standard but the inevitable follow up comment is: &bquo;Yes, ours&equo;. 
 According to bankers active in the Euro-equity market this cry is heard most frequently from US accountancy firms which believe their standards, being the most conservative, provide the safest blueprint. 
 Without the support of the Americans, harmonisation seems a distant ideal. 
 And yet applying US standards in this country for example, could require a massive downward restatement of corporate profits and net worth, which would be resisted fiercely. 
 What some experts would like to see is a system of reciprocity whereby companies could make international equity offerings using their home market accounting standards without the need to reconcile their financial statements to the standards of each jurisdiction in which shares are offered. 
 This probably provides the best way forward, not least because of the major markets only the US, Italy and Canada explicitly require foreign companies to restate their figures according to local standards. 
 The UK by contrast requires only that figures are prepared and audited to internationally acceptable standards but not necessarily UK Gaap. 
 If the US could be persuaded to take a similar line, many of the problems for companies contemplating an international issue would disappear. 
 The Eurobond market is on course for a record year after registering a volume of &dollar;165bn for the first nine months according to Euromoney Bondware. 
 At this rate 1989 volume should comfortably surpass 1986's record figure of &dollar;179bn, and may yet reach the magic &dollar;200bn. 
 40% of shareholders approve Ferranti demerger plan 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 MERCHANT bankers proposing a demerger of Ferranti International into two separate businesses have received the initial approval of 40 per cent of the company's shareholders. 
 Hill Samuel said yesterday that the plan to put Ferranti's naval and avionics businesses into a separate company and to merge it with another UK defence company, thought to be Thorn EMI, is to be investigated further. 
 Christopher Baker of Hill Samuel said the plan was presented in writing to the Ferranti board on Friday. 
 Sir Derek Alun-Jones, Ferranti's chairman, announced on Friday that the beleaguered company would have to write off &pound;185m. 
 Ferranti is now convinced that it was the victim of fraud perpetrated by International Signal and Control which it took over two years ago. 
 A report by Coopers &amp; Lybrand into suspect ISC contracts and the nature and extent of any fraud is expected to be delivered to Ferranti today or tomorrow. 
 Ferranti then hopes to decide on a course of action and in particular on how to restructure its capital base. 
 It has already undertaken to sell off &pound;100m worth of businesses and to raise &pound;150m through a rights issue or by attracting a suitor. 
 Sir Derek said last night that he had &bquo;glanced&equo; at the Hill Samuel plan and was interested to see how it works out. 
 But he stressed: &bquo;It's only an idea, not a proposal, and it needs a lot more work.&equo; 
 The Hill Samuel plan envisages splitting off the UK naval and avionics businesses and giving shareholders one share in the new company for every share they hold in the existing organisation. 
 Talks are believed to have been held with Thorn EMI, whose defence interests are up for sale. 
 A successful merger could create a defence company with estimated sales of &pound;800m. 
 Ferranti's naval and avionics businesses are thought to have a turnover of about &pound;500m. 
 According to Mr Baker, Thorn's ground-based radar activities would dovetail with Ferranti's airborne radar and result in a formidable force in European defence electronics. 
 Ferranti's annual meeting, adjourned until 10 October, will now almost inevitably be put back for a further four to six weeks in the light of recent events. 
 Meanwhile, the company hopes to go ahead later this month with the launch of its Creditphone mobile telephone service. 
 Ferranti is one of four licencees starting these low-cost services, intended to bring mobile communications to the masses. 
 The company also said that it will continue with its application to the Department of Trade and Industry to operate a &bquo;personal communications network&equo;, which is expected to present the same opportunities in the next decade as cellular mobile radio is doing in this. 
 Lawson's battle for base rates 
 By PATRICK HOSKING, Banking Correspondent 
 NERVOUS investors and hard-pressed mortgage borrowers face another anxious week as Chancellor Nigel Lawson battles against continuing pressure to lift base lending rates. 
 Analysts expect the pound to come under renewed pressure in the run-up to Thursday's Bundesbank meeting, which will decide whether and by how much to raise West Germany's key Lombard interest rate. 
 The markets have already fully-discounted a half-point rise in the German rate to 7.5 per cent. 
 However, a full one-point rise would probably trigger another run on sterling and force a one-point base rate rise in the UK. 
 The Government has signalled its determination to resist raising the 14 per cent base rate during the politically-sensitive fortnight of the Labour and Conservative party conferences. 
 According to Bill Martin, economist at UBS-Phillips &amp; Drew: &bquo;The only thing the Chancellor fears more than the currency speculators are the rows of blue rinses at Blackpool next week&equo;. 
 Building societies would respond to a base rate increase with a hike in their mortgage rates. 
 A one-point rise in the mortgage rate to 14.5 per cent would increase the monthly payment of a &pound;30,000 endowment mortgage-holder by &pound;17.75 to &pound;271.88. 
 There are fears that share prices could tumble again, even after last week's 70.8 point drop in the FTSE-100 index to 2,299.4. 
 &bquo;The cosy notion of a soft landing has now evaporated in investors&equo; minds,&equo; Mr Martin said. 
 However, on Friday the Confederation of British Industry accused the financial markets of &bquo;hysterical over-reaction&equo; and said there was &bquo;plenty of good news&equo; on the real economy. 
 Final retail sales data for August, published today, will test the accuracy of the provisional 0.4 per cent growth rate. 
 Results this week from Next and Sears will also give a measure of the retail downturn following the 1,850 job cuts announced by Littlewoods last week. 
 Results from four TV companies this week may give clues as to any slowdown in corporate expenditure. 
 Pearl chief to meet Australian Mutual amid bid rumours 
 By JOHN MOORE, Assistant City Editor 
 DAVID ANDERSON, chairman of Australian Mutual Provident, Australia's biggest life insurer, and Einion Holland, chairman of Pearl Group, the British life insurance company, are meeting over the next few days amid speculation that the Australian group is poised to mount a takeover bid for Pearl worth at least &pound;1bn. 
 Australian Mutual Provident executives were yesterday believed to be mounting plans for a takeover which could be one of the largest acquisitions made in the British life insurer sector. 
 &bquo;Any bid which has not been discussed with us will have to be considered,&equo; said Mr Holland, yesterday. 
 &bquo;I have a long standing arrangement to meet Mr Anderson this week. 
 But so far we have received no direct approach. 
 The last time I met AMP was over two years ago.&equo; 
 The news of the meeting of the two executives follows a steep rise in Pearl's share price last Friday. 
 It rose 44p to 552p. 
 There has been intense interest in the British life insurance sector by Australian, New Zealand and Continental interests for some time. 
 Australian Mutual Provident has been building up its stake in Pearl for the last two years. 
 In June this year AMP's shareholding jumped to 18 per cent when it acquired a block of over 23 million shares, representing 13 per cent of Pearl's equity, from FAI Insurances, a leading Australian insurance and investment group. 
 Australian Mutual received approval from the Department of Trade and Industry which it needed if it was to hold more than 15 per cent of Pearl's shares, the level at which a shareholder is regarded as &bquo;controlling&equo; an insurance company. 
 At the time of the acquisition insurance analysts said that AMP had aspirations to expand, and since it controls one third of the Australian life insurance market its opportunities were limited in that country. 
 Earlier this year AMP acquired London Life, the mutual British life insurer, for just &pound;15m which, with its own operations in the UK, gives it about a 1 per cent market share. 
 AMP would like 5 per cent of the life insurance market in Britain, which experts feel can only be achieved through acquisition. 
 Buying Pearl would give AMP a further market share of over 2 per cent. 
 Pearl was founded in 1864 and is the UK's second largest life office after the Prudential which specialises in door-to-door collection of insurance premiums from customers. 
 Following legislative reforms, it has recently been making a big drive for personal pensions business which has proved successful. 
 In its last financial year ending December 1988, Pearl reported pre-tax profits of &pound;66.2m compared with &pound;48.34m a year earlier. 
 Last month Pearl announced pre-tax profits for the six months ending 30 June of &pound;31.1m, an increase of 8 per cent on the previous year. 
 The directors recommended that the dividend payout to shareholders should be increased by 25 per cent to 7.5p a share which was widely regarded as a move designed to ward off a takeover bid. 
 If Pearl decided to resist the overtures of AMP it will be the second major takeover battle in the British life assurance sector in barely two years. 
 In 1987 the Compagnie du Midi, the French financial and insurance group, moved to acquire British life insurer Equity &amp; Law, which was also under siege from the New Zealand entrepreneur Sir Ron Brierley, whose interests owned 29.6 per cent of Equity &amp; Law. 
 Equity &amp; Law finally recommended acceptance of the &pound;448m takeover by the French group. 
 Japanese to buy 25% of Virgin 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 A JAPANESE company is to buy 25 per cent of the record business of the Virgin Group, which Richard Branson took private in October of last year. 
 Virgin, which owns the sixth largest record company worldwide, will make the formal announcement today in London, writes Mary Fagan. 
 The buyer is said not to be one of the large five record companies &mdash; Thorn EMI of the UK, Sony, Warner, Polygram and Bertelsman &mdash; which between them dominate 70 per cent of world sales. 
 Virgin last night refused to comment, but estimates are that the deal could be worth well in excess of &pound;50m, making it one of the largest investments by a Japanese organisation in a UK company. 
 With a turnover of about &pound;250m, Virgin Records is one of the few independents left in the music business. 
 In August the Virgin Group sold its film and video distribution arm, Virgin Vision, to Management Company Entertainment in the US. 
 But in spite of clear signals from Virgin Records that it wants to remain independent, speculation was rife that the purchaser might be Sony. 
 Industry observers fear that this would be another nail in the coffin of the independent record industry. 
 In 1988 the Japanese giant bought CBS records for &dollar;2bn and last week it announced that it would take control of Columbia pictures. 
 Virgin sources said yesterday, however: &bquo;We want a minority partner. 
 The last thing we want is to lose our independence to one of the big five.&equo; 
 The deal is the latest in a spate of mergers and takeovers in the music publishing business. 
 Earlier this year, Thorn EMI paid &pound;187m to US-based SBK for a large catalogue of songs, and subsequently also bought a half share in Chrysalis Records in the UK. 
 Since then, Polygram has bought Island Records and has anounced the takeover of A&amp;M records. 
 Both Virgin and Thorn EMI are thought to be vying for the lucrative Jobete in Detroit, which controls the publishing rights to a catalogue of 15,000 Motown titles. 
 The decision to look for a significant equity partner appears to be Virgin's attempt to keep out of the clutches of the five majors while remaining a credible force in the worldwide music business. 
 Leading Article: Still a need for the big idea 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 NEIL Kinnock and the party he leads are looking better than they have done at any time since he took office in 1983. 
 There will be ritual rebellion in Brighton from the Transport and General Workers Union over Labour's belated renunciation of unilateral nuclear disarmament. 
 But Ron Todd, the union's general secretary, is expected to concede defeat gracefully. 
 Even if other antinuclear fundamentalists threaten to fight, fight and fight again, Mr Kinnock need have no fear. 
 The more firmly he tells them and the country that, as Prime Minister, he and not they will rule, the more likely it is that he will eventually reach Downing Street. 
 On other issues, crucial victories have been won before the Labour Party's annual conference opens. 
 Relatively few influential activists would now quarrel with the recognition that markets are an effective way of generating wealth and indicating consumer preferences. 
 Few want the wholesale repeal of industrial relations legislation. 
 Even the popular belief that the unions exercise too much power over Labour policies is gradually being accepted by a number of union leaders. 
 Paradoxically, the more moderate of them are insisting on the maintenance of their block votes because the party is still not fully democratic. 
 They see themselves exercising the restraining, moderating role they played in the 1940s and 1950s. 
 Once one-person-one-vote is accepted, some have already signalled a willingness to surrender much of their power. 
 Mr Kinnock hinted at the weekend that direct democracy was likely to become mandatory relatively soon. 
 To list the opponents of Mr Kinnock's revisionist policies is to invite boredom and a sense of deja vu rather than any great fear. 
 The electorate has long since rumbled Tony Benn, Eric Heffer, Dennis Skinner, Ken Livingstone and the rest. 
 The prospect of Arthur Scargill entering Parliament invites mild derision rather than anxiety in the suburbs. 
 Potential Labour voters are coming to accept that an increasingly confident (but mercifully less cocky) Neil Kinnock has rumbled the fundamentalists too, and is neither impressed nor cowed by them. 
 In his pre-conference interview this weekend the Labour leader demonstrated a restrained confidence and authority which is new and, if it can be maintained in the heat of battle, likely to prove appealing to the sort of people whose votes he must win. 
 Even so there remain causes for concern in the Labour camp. 
 Yesterday, Labour's leader dismissed both electoral reform and pacts. 
 Yet for Labour to win on its own at the next general election would be a victory on a scale comparable with that achieved by Attlee in 1945. 
 Moreover, Mr Kinnock brushed aside the suggestion that he needed a big idea or unique selling point to challenge the appeal of Thatcherism. 
 He went on to say that there was nothing at all from the last decade for which he could give Mrs Thatcher credit. 
 The latter point was silly, coming from a man who has spent much of the last five years persuading his party that the world had changed since May 1979 and that there was no going back. 
 The former is debatable. 
 Mr Kinnock is a relatively recent convert to revisionism. 
 If he can produce no grand reason for abandoning left-wing Labour attitudes, people will be forgiven if they conclude that the change was cynical and opportunistic and that Mr Kinnock is more interested in gaining office than in doing anything in particular once he has arrived at the top. 
 This was not the basis on which Attlee reached No. 10 at the end of the war with a mandate to build a welfare state. 
 Work-out with the trolley freaks 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 DO YOU sometimes feel you should take more exercise? 
 But just don't seem to have the time or even the energy? 
 Then the answer is to combine a fitness routine with something you're doing already &mdash; and that's why we've come up with our great series of supermarket trolley exercises! 
 Yes, you can actually get all the body work-out you need while you're just wheeling your shopping round your local supermarket. 
 That lump of metal on wheels can actually be the most useful exercise machine you ever meet &mdash; but ONLY if you know how to get the maximum use out of it. 
 And that's why we asked Professor James Leotard, who researches Body Culture at Milton Keynes University, to devise a series of six simple trolley toning exercises. 
 Here they are. 
 1. 
 When turning a corner into the next aisle of the shop, don't tamely walk round behind the trolley and push it in the new direction. 
 Make the trolley turn ONLY by using the strength of your arms. 
 Tones up arms, shoulders and stomach. 
 2. 
 Try to push and lift at the same time &mdash; go on, try to get the back wheels off the ground as you go along! 
 Not easy, is it, especially when you've got the mineral water and bags of flour aboard? 
 But it's a lovely feeling when you finally find you can do it. 
 Excellent for arms, shoulders, legs, heart and best end. 
 3. 
 Normally you wouldn't be seen dead doing a knees bend keeping your back straight, but if you're getting something off the bottom shelf you won't look ridiculous at all. 
 Here's how it goes. 
 You say: &bquo;Ah, tinned water chestnuts. 
 Just what I need.&equo; 
 You go down, slowly, slowly, don't rush it, pause five seconds, take the tin, then up. 
 Then you say: &bquo;Ugh! 
 Preservatives!&equo; and do the same movements to replace the tin. 
 This can be repeated at every new shelf. 
 Wonderful for thighs, stomach, calves, hams and smoked bacon. 
 4. 
 Lift yourself off the ground as you go along. 
 Go on, push yourself up on the handles and let the trolley take you for a ride, just like a child! 
 Fine for shoulders, arms, kidneys, liver and offal. 
 You meet lots of new people too. 
 5. 
 Here's one you can do when you're waiting in that boring old queue. 
 Stand up straight. 
 Hold trolley at arm's length. 
 Now, without moving your feet from where they are, let the trolley slowly roll away from you until you feel it start to go out of control &mdash; then pull it back. 
 This exercises all the muscles in the body, and in your neighbours' as well! 6. 
 Finally, just try to wrench your trolley to pieces. 
 Go on, try to twist and buckle it with your bare hands. 
 Pull it apart. 
 Tear bits off it. 
 Turn it into the sort of jangled pile of metal the Tate Gallery would be glad to make an offer for. 
 You won't be able to make any impression with your bare hands, of course, unless you're a trained weight lifter, but you'll feel your body really working! 
 (A word of caution: watch out for that yoghurt on top.) 
 After a few weeks of this, I can guarantee you'll be feeling quite a different person, and unable to wait to get out for your Sainsbury's session, or your Waitrose-lifting! 
 When you hear the word shopping in future, your pulse will race and your red corpuscles will be off and away before you can say &bquo;This Week's Special Offer&equo;. 
 Truly, your shopping list will become your freeway to fitness! 
 From Dr Armand Pastor GP Sir, I have started to get an extraordinary amount of patients with minor and sometimes major physical injuries caused by supermarket trolleys - pulled muscles, dislocated cartilages, broken fingers and limbs, ruptured yoghurt, etc. 
 My inquiries reveal that most of these are caused by exercise programmes devised by ignorant charlatans feeding off our need for health. 
 These fads for physical fitness invariably, in my experience, lead to two things: a great deal of unnecessary injury and a lot of profit to the people behind the scheme. 
 Mark my words, at this very moment someone is trying to cash in on this supermarket trolley fetish with some useless bit of equipment or other. 
 You just wait and see. 
 Yours fearfully AN ANNOUNCEMENT You know, your weekly visit to the supermarket is a good start. 
 But it isn't really enough to have a work-out on the trolley once every seven days, is it? 
 So we have devised a genuine exercise supermarket-type trolley for you to use in your own home. 
 Styled in hard-wearing canadium, it has a built-in meter so that you can know at a glance if you're applying enough pressure. 
 At last, you can go trolley training every day! 
 Give yourself a treat and go shopping for a new body with the INDEPENDENT TROLLEY TRAINER! 
 Only &pound;179.99. 
 (Warning: Not suitable for shopping.) 
 Leading Article: Morality and the market 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 THE Friends of Thatcherism are working themselves into a fine old lather about the interview given by the Archbishop of Canterbury to the magazine Director. 
 They regard the article as being primarily an attack on the Prime Minister, and one which is improper almost to the point of being constitutional. 
 They want the Prime Minister to use the Conservative Party conference next week to slap down this turbulent priest. 
 They are wrong on all counts. 
 It is the business of the head of the established church to express his worries about the state of the nation and the moral mood of the times. 
 It would be foolish and unseemly as well as counter-productive for the Prime Minister to enter into an undignified slanging match with him every time he does so. 
 If Dr Runcie sees self-interest, self-righteousness and an intolerant and uncharitable disregard for the unsuccessful and the unemployed, it is not merely his right but his duty to speak out. 
 If, further, he feels that the free market policies and values embraced by Mrs Thatcher have done much to create a divided nation, dominated by Pharisees, he should feel free to offer his opinion. 
 This is not, however, to say that Dr Runcie is correct. 
 In so far as the interview is a critique of Thatcherism &mdash; and that is not as far as might have been supposed from the headlines in yesterday's papers &mdash; it is misplaced. 
 Rulers do not set the moral climate of their nations except, perhaps, at the extremes. 
 Hitler and Stalin debauched the moral climates of Germany and Russia respectively. 
 But it would be hard to argue, say, that Greeks are less moral because of the appalling corruption of and greed demonstrated by senior figures in the government and party of the socialist Andreas Papandreou. 
 Dr Runcie acknowledged that &bquo;wealth creation&equo; was the necessary precondition for &bquo;doing all the things we ought to do&equo; but added that there was no automatic connection between wealth creation and a happy society. 
 Amen to that. 
 Market economics is about efficiency, not morality. 
 Government can do much to set the boundaries in which it is possible to create wealth. 
 It is for others to offer moral guidance to the newly prosperous Pharisees. 
 The latter need not wait for a change of heart on the part of the Prime Minister, or the election of a new government, before translating guilt about the condition of those less fortunate than themselves into action. 
 There are numerous worthy charities, many run by the church which Dr Runcie heads, in need of donations of money or skills. 
 It is possible to love, and to aid, thy neighbour without state intervention. 
 If people are unwilling to recognise this it represents a failure of church leadership rather than political leadership. 
 Letter: Full-cost fees for students 
 From Mr JONATHAN INGLESFIELD 
 Sir: I refer to Peter Wilby's Viewpoint (29 September). 
 The proposals for student fees hold especially worrying implications for the training of doctors in the UK. 
 I am 22, but I will not be able to earn my first salary until I reach 24. 
 From that time, I will be obliged to pay off an ever-increasing student loan. 
 It now appears that, in addition to this, I will be expected to part with a further portion of my income as a graduate tax to pay for my education, the last three years of which I am spending in hospitals, not only studying, but assisting on a voluntary basis with essential clinical procedures and tests. 
 It seems odd that I should be expected to pay for the privilege of assisting in this way, in particular, as I doubt that these changes will alleviate the falling numbers of applicants to medical schools in the UK. 
 Letter: Full-cost fees for students 
 From Professor The EARL RUSSELL 
 Sir: The Vice Chancellors' proposal (29 September) to charge students full-cost fees will doubtless create protests. 
 But these protests should not be aimed at the Vice Chancellors. 
 They are undoubtedly right that it has now become clear that the Government will not pay for the expansion it desires at a level which will protect high quality. 
 Though the powers of Vice Chancellors are considerable, they do not include the power to make two and two make five. 
 They cannot deal with this situation by cutting quality: in a university, quality is the object of the exercise, and a university which sets out to lower quality is no more likely to survive than an army which sets out to lose its battles. 
 Faced with a persistent excess of expenditure over income, they may cut student numbers or they may increase income. 
 Since it seems they are not to be permitted to cut student numbers, they are attempting to increase income. 
 However, to say all other courses are impossible is not to say this course is possible. 
 The Vice Chancellors are looking for scholarships to meet these fees, and money for those scholarships may come from government, industry, benefactors or private individuals. 
 If the Government were likely to meet the full cost, the proposal would be unnecessary. 
 Industry is in no position to undertake a surcharge on its costs, and will probably reply, as it has just done on the question of arts funding, that industrial sponsorship is a supplement to government funding: it is not available as a substitute for it. 
 A record balance of payments deficit is not the right background for enforced increases in industrial costs. 
 We lack rich benefactors, and the Private Sector Borrowing Requirement, which last year had reached &pound;200bn for mortgages, and &pound;36.4bn for credit cards and hire purchase suggests that the private purse is no more inexhaustible than the public. 
 The plan to raise full-cost fees is likely to fail. 
 The problem will then return to the Government's desk, and I hope it will then accept that the country can have no more universities, and no more university places, than it can afford. 
 Letter: Policy and politics at the Labour Party Conference 
 From MR DAVID SOSKIN 
 Sir: I was interested by your juxtaposition of &bquo;Poll predicts 42-seat majority for Labour&equo; with &bquo;Tories hold on&equo; (30 September), the latter referring, of course, to the Conservative victory in Wandsworth, the significance of which appears to have been almost totally ignored by the media. 
 Electors are always prepared to criticise the Government in answer to pollsters' questions, but when the same individuals arrive at the polling booth they simply cannot bring themselves to vote Labour into power. 
 Letter: Policy and politics at the Labour Party Conference 
 From MS MOLLY MEACHER 
 Sir: Despite a significant gap in the Labour Party's education and training proposals, their objective to double the number of 16-18year-olds in full-time education must be welcomed (28 September). 
 England's full-time staying-on rate stands at 28 per cent according to the latest statistics available. 
 This compares with 79 per cent in the US, 86 per cent in Sweden, 45 per cent in West Germany and 69 per cent in Japan. 
 To add the part-time education and training statistics to those figures does not improve our relative position. 
 Labour hopes to transform the situation by increasing the number of A-levels to five for the brighter youngsters and providing grants for four-year training courses (two years in a Further Education college followed by two with an employer) for the rest. 
 These reforms will only achieve their objective if accompanied by the implementation of the 1944 Education Act provision for compulsory part- or full-time education or training up to the age of 18. 
 This clause has never yet been activated. 
 The sharply reduced number of 16-18-year-olds will inevitably lead employers to bid up the wages of that age group to entice young people away from education and into unskilled or semi-skilled jobs. 
 Employers must be required to release 16-18-year-olds for education and training for at least two days per week. 
 Only then will two vitally important and complementary goals be achieved: to improve Britain's general educational and vocational competence, and hence our productive capacity; and to reduce our gross educational inequalities between the elite who receive a narrow education to a very high standard, and the rest. 
 Letter: Policy and politics at the Labour Party Conference 
 From MR JOHN PERTWEE 
 Sir: Labour does not need a commitment to proportional representation in order to scoop most of the centre ground at the next general election. 
 All it needs is to promise a high-powered investigation, such as a Royal Commission, into the practicalities of an alternative voting system (surely justified by the intense public interest now abounding). 
 Such a promise would be the only hope of a breakthrough for the disenfranchised voters and would have them flocking to the polls for Mr Kinnock. 
 His problem will be that Mrs Thatcher might decide to do it first, and then she will garner the votes. 
 Letter: Policy and politics at the Labour Party Conference 
 From MR DENIS MacSHANE 
 Sir: If Labour is to suggest the setting up of a specialist labour court (30 September), then such a momentous change in the industrial relations system deserves more discussion, and needs to be taken out of the hot-house of Labour Party conference politics. 
 For three reasons such a move should be welcomed. 
 First, it would bring Britain into line with the best European practice, notably in Germany where local, regional and federal labour courts handle problems in a fair, dispassionate way based on law, precedent and judicial expertise in the labour field. 
 Second, it would ensure that workers enjoyed positive rights under law and reduce the emphasis of union immunities. 
 Labour law will always reflect the balance of power in society, and a fully fledged labour court system will not remove class and fundamental employer-employee differences. 
 But it should be possible to create and enforce enough common rules to prevent the absurd see-sawing of industrial relations legislation we have seen since 1969. 
 Third, a labour division of the High Court would contribute to the process of constitutional reform in Britain which surely is to be a key political issue in the 1990s. 
 The &bquo;trade union question&equo; would cease to haunt the Labour Party and while that might upset some Conservatives it would be good for the country. 
 Letter: Independence of no-fixed-abode 
 From The Rev NERISSA JONES 
 Sir: On Saturday you published an advertisement for the 10 extra pages of news and features that you, The Independent, will carry from 2 October. 
 &bquo;What do independent experts say about our 10 extra pages?&equo; asks the advertisement. 
 The supposedly jokey answers are illustrated by photographs of people sleeping outside covered by copies of The Independent: they look like some of the hundreds of visitors who come to St Botolph's Crypt Centre for homeless people every day. 
 Given the already appalling and growing rate of homelessness and lack of hostel facilities in London, when more people than ever will not only have to endure the freezing nights of the coming winter on the streets, but perhaps permanent homelessness, it was terrible to see the situation being exploited for a joke by your advertisement: &bquo;Just the thing now the evenings are drawing in. 
 . &bquo;; &bquo;The added coverage is exactly what I wanted&equo;. 
 How much &bquo;independence&equo; do you suppose a person has who exists on the no-fixed-abode Giro of &pound;34.90 a week? 
 Letter: EC immigration checks on trains 
 From The Rev J. GILMORE 
 Sir: The contents of Sarah Helm's article &bquo;Immigration checks to be made on trains&equo; (25 September) are extremely worrying. 
 During the recent European Community elections the representatives of EC governments promoted the ideal of a border-free Europe by 1992. 
 Now, it would appear from this article, that this ideal is shattered and a two-tiered Europe is on the cards. 
 One for those who travel by aircraft and one for those who travel by train between London and Paris. 
 The presence of immigration officials and police on board trains is comparable to the scenes of 1930s America where migrant labourers were turned back at state boundaries. 
 What criteria would police and immigration officials use in their search for &bquo;potential terrorists&equo; on a train that they could not use at a static checkpoint or airport? 
 Do terrorists or illegal persons travel exclusively by train? 
 This is a clear example of the extension of the Prevention of Terrorism Act where criteria for stopping, questioning and searching are purely subjective to the official involved. 
 Will a person's accent, dress or skin colour indicate the potential terrorist or, for that matter, football hooligan or drug pusher? 
 This is a recipe for fear and anxiety. 
 It may mean the detention of innocent people and indeed their imprisonment. 
 Letter: Cardinal sins 
 From Mr JIMMY DONOGHUE 
 Sir: The North-east publishers of Viz are nearer the truth than they realise with their soccer strip (29 September). 
 Cardinal Hume has not only the cross of being a fervent Newcastle United supporter to bear; he is also known to irreverent members of Mayfair's Jesuit Farm Street Church by his initials, George Basil Hume. 
 Letter: Bruges and the future of a federal Europe 
 From Mr ALAN HASELHURST MP 
 Sir: William Cash (letter, 26 September) suggests that democracy is at risk through our continued membership of the European Community. 
 He even implies that those who sacrificed themselves in the Second World War are in danger of being betrayed. 
 His distrust of federalism has to be very great to make such absurd claims. 
 The United Kingdom signed the Treaty of Rome of her own free will. 
 Those of us who helped constitute the large House of Commons majority in favour of the principle of joining the community did so with our eyes open. 
 We actively desired an ever closer union of the European peoples, but it was not laid down how and when this was to be achieved. 
 It was a matter first of embarking on practical ways of increasing harmony and creating a single market. 
 Mr Cash is convinced he knows where this is all leading. 
 I am not aware of any preconceived plan. 
 Proposals for economic and monetary union are just another phase of the journey. 
 Doubtless, in time, we will consider adjusting the democratic framework to suit new circumstances. 
 In an interdependent world, the inability of a national state to exercise effective control of its own affairs has long been apparent. 
 How each generation of parliamentarians in member states will try to guide the community's political institutions will be for them to determine. 
 I suspect the evolutionary process will be lengthy. 
 Mr Cash and his Friends of Bruges seem to want to fight a battle against federalism today which may not have to be fought at all. 
 In any case, what is inherently undemocratic about federalism? 
 The Americans manage quite well. 
 The terrors which Mr Cash expresses about our future in the community have a familiar ring about them. 
 Nationalists in Scotland say much the same thing about being part of the UK. 
 Those of us who want the Scottish people to stay in the UK can see nothing logically wrong or abhorrent in the UK developing its constitutional relationship with its community partners. 
 Finally to cite the independence movement in Eastern Europe as the antithesis of what is happening in the community is the ultimate absurdity. 
 Countries such as the Baltic states hardly signed up with the Soviet Union as free agents. 
 It is small wonder that they want out. 
 Once armed with that freedom they might surprise Mr Cash by also seeking membership of the community. 
 Letter: &bquo;Inexplicable&equo; libel awards 
 From Mr ROGER COOMBS 
 Sir: Marcel Berlins (' Good men and generous'; Law, 29 September) calls the absurdly high awards made by juries in libel actions &bquo;inexplicable&equo;. 
 The most probable reason, considering the fanciful and irresponsible way the tabloid press operates these days, is a wish to punish newspapers for libel in a way that hurts and deters. 
 This could be done more effectively if the law was changed so that it became the jury's responsibility to assess only the actual damage to the plaintiff and the judge's responsibility to impose an unlimited fine on the defendants according to his view of their culpability. 
 Letter: Portrait of a nation's values 
 From Dr BEVERLEY HALSTEAD 
 Sir: A nation's perception of itself and its values are reflected in the portraits on its banknotes. 
 Ours currently extol the virtues of Britain's response to the French Revolution (&pound;5), remind us of our traditional relationship with Russia (&pound;10), the danger implicit in teenage romance (&pound;20) and the importance of our architectural heritage (&pound;50). 
 The withdrawal of the pound note with Sir Isaac Newton leaves no place in the nation's pockets for science. 
 Would it not be appropriate for this situation to be remedied by putting Charles Darwin on a new &pound;100 note to emphasise to the world, in these uncertain times, our tradition of change by evolution and not revolution? 
 Letter: Recycling waste 
 From Professor R. A. SMITH 
 Sir: Your reports today quite rightly praise the efforts being made in Sheffield to extract energy from waste and to recycle paper, glass, plastics and steel cans. 
 Much as I wanted to read the good news on my walk home from the newspaper shop, I was forced to concentrate on my footing on broken and delapidated pavements, strewn with take-away food rubbish, wrappings of all kinds, and collections of weeds, heaps of dog dirt and drinks cans. 
 In a few weeks' time, the fallen leaves will have risen from ankle to knee deep. 
 It is a wonderful thing to spend one's everyday existence paddling in a cesspool of untapped energy. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Unhappy and glorious: &bquo;Churchill's Black Dog&equo; -Anthony Storr: Collins, 16 pounds 
 By MICHAEL CHURCH 
 ISAAC NEWTON, Franz Kafka and Winston Churchill were, as infants, united in common misfortune: physically puny and starved of parental love, each was condemned to a lifelong wrestle with potentially annihilating depression. 
 In their achievement as adults &mdash; each imposing his order on an external world he made his own &mdash; they were united in triumph. 
 Anthony Storr's project, in this collection of essays, is to use psychoanalytical principles to show how in each case weakness produced strength. 
 The fullest and most fascinating case study is that of Churchill, whose famous &bquo;Black Dog&equo; depressions are shown to have sprung ineluctably from childhood traumas. 
 Comparing him to Demosthenes, in whom oratory compensated for a speech impediment, Storr juxtaposes two key scenes: young Winston being pelted with cricket balls and hiding behind a tree, and a slightly older Winston terrifying his friends (and all but killing himself) by jumping 30 ft off a bridge. 
 Until the day he died Churchill kept a photograph of his nanny by his bed. 
 His mother had had no time for him, and his father disapproved of him. 
 As Storr points out, he only felt entitled to love insofar as his deeds merited it: deprived of the total, irrational acceptance which loved children routinely enjoy, he was doomed to an endless pursuit of this ideal state, but never with any real hope of success. 
 &bquo;This cannot be accident, it must be design,&equo; he commented when at the age of 65 his great hour came. 
 &bquo;I was kept for this job.&equo; 
 Churchill had at moments in the First World War manifested great strategic prescience; his intuition swung into action even more powerfully the second time round. 
 Rational judgement might have told him that the nation's plight was hopeless, but his was the vision of an avenging prophet. 
 &bquo;It is probable,&equo; Storr observes, &bquo;that England owed her survival in 1940 to this inner world of make-believe.&equo; 
 What psychoanalysis calls fantasies of infantile omnipotence thus came into play, together with other attributes of infantility &mdash; greed, paranoia, and an inability to follow complex rational arguments. 
 Churchill demanded that all ideas be submitted to him on a half-sheet of paper; he was frequently insensitive, a bad judge of character, and a sucker for flamboyant charlatans; intensely loyal, he demanded uncritical loyalty in return. 
 The end of the war meant the end of the blissful congruence between fantasy and reality, and Churchill turned to painting and writing in an effort to regain that happy state. 
 But as Storr demonstrates with the aid of two stunningly beautiful passages from Churchill's early novel Savrola, the pen was better suited to delineating the bleak impotence he felt at his innermost core. 
 Franz Kafka perfectly exemplifies the efficacy of art in counteracting emotional wounds, if not in healing them. 
 He felt powerless in the face of his father, and was cursed with the unshakeable conviction that he was to be punished throughout life for some unspecified crime. 
 Anthony Storr shows how these depressive fears were magically transmuted in the literary sphere. 
 Kafka's gift to posterity lay not in any facile adumbration of the Nazi concentration camps, but in his ability to articulate terrors which we all have lurking in the recesses of our minds. 
 Newton spent more time and energy on alchemical speculations than on the scientific discoveries which galvanised the Western world: Storr reconstructs the neurotic drive which impelled him to heroic intellectual feats. 
 Like Einstein he distrusted the senses, like many philosophers he was incapable of sustaining close emotional relationships, and within his cloistered concentration miracles took place. 
 &bquo;I keep the subject constantly before me, and wait till the first dawnings open slowly by little and little into the full and clear light.&equo; 
 This chapter makes heartening reading, as does the entire book. 
 Churchill's Black Dog may be marred by cut-price literary criticism, and its construction may be slapdash, but its armature is a belief that people can, by an act of creative will, save their souls at any stage, that fundamental personal change is possible after 40, 50, even 60. 
 As our population grows older, this is an idea whose time has come. 
 What Kinnock must say: Giles Radice on the Labour leader's opportunity to set the political agenda 
 By GILES RADICE 
 NEIL KINNOCK'S speech at the Labour Party conference tomorrow will be the most important he has ever made. 
 For the first time since he became leader, he is in the position to set the political agenda. 
 As he prepares his text, he might recall Harold Wilson's speech to the 1963 Scarborough conference. 
 After 12 years in power, the Tories had run out of steam. 
 Wilson's task was to project his party as an alternative government and associate Labour with the agenda of the 1960s. 
 He succeeded triumphantly. 
 His &bquo;white heat&equo; speech not only demonstrated that he was aware of the scientific revolution that was changing Britain but also associated Labour with efficiency, modernisation and planning. 
 Labour won the 1964 election and was in power for 11 of the next 15 years. 
 As in 1963, so today there is a strong sense that the tide is turning. 
 But the Tories still have time to recover, especially if they jettison some of the more unattractive aspects of Thatcherism. 
 Mr Kinnock's job at conference must be to demonstrate Labour's electability by confirming the party's new revisionism, by reassuring voters on issues where there is still doubt and, above all, by helping set the agenda for the 1990s. 
 The party has abandoned policies which made it unelectable in the 1980s. 
 It is no longer the party of traditional nationalisation; it is no longer anti-European; above all, it is no longer unilateralist. 
 Mr Kinnock must stress the extent to which Labour has really changed. 
 Defence, which lost Labour so many votes in 1983 and 1987, is especially important. 
 Here Mr Kinnock should set out clearly why, in the Gorbachev era, negotiated rather than unilateral disarmament is almost always preferable. 
 On the economy, there is still work to do. 
 Polls show that, despite impressive performances by John Smith and Gordon Brown, many voters still believe Labour is a party of high taxation and inflation. 
 But there is strong support for sensible increases in public spending, provided this does not lead to massive hikes in taxation. 
 The party has to emphasise that, in contrast to the Tories, it believes public spending should rise in line with growth in output, but that it will pursue responsible fiscal policies. 
 Labour's hand on inflation would be strengthened if its leader were able to announce that it now supported early British entry into the exchange rate mechanism of the European monetary system. 
 Mr Kinnock will also have to clarify several confusions in policy. 
 He should repeat his assurance that, while Labour is opposed to the privatisation of water and electricity and wants to see a return to public control, it is not the party's intention to clobber those who buy shares. 
 Muddle over trades union legislation must also be cleared up. 
 UK employees, among the least protected in Europe, need more extensive statutory rights. 
 But that does not mean the repeal of all Conservative legislation, nor that unions should be immune from penalties. 
 It is essential that the modern Labour Party should not be in hock to the unions. 
 But perhaps Mr Kinnock's most important task next week is to look forward. 
 Labour's acceptance of the market strengthens the increasingly powerful case for government intervening selectively. 
 The classic example of market failure is environmental protection. 
 Education and training and research and development are other areas where government intervention is badly needed. 
 The dilapidation of our transport system and the shoddy state of our national services underlines the argument for more public investment. 
 Labour's change of policy on the European Community puts it in a strong position to argue that economic and industrial decisions are increasingly likely to be made on a European basis and it is essential that Britain plays a more constructive role. 
 We shall need to develop, for example, a viable policy on economic and monetary union. 
 At the time when Poland has its first Solidarity prime minister, Hungary is to have free elections, and Britain is fed up with Mrs Thatcher's authoritarian style, Labour should be seen to take democratic issues seriously. 
 I am disappointed the policy review has adopted such a negative attitude both to a Bill of Rights and electoral reform. 
 A new agenda, centred on citizens' rights and democratic reform, selective government intervention, environmental protection and a more positive role in Europe would provide the basis for a new progressive majority. 
 It must be Mr Kinnock's task this week to capture this new agenda for Labour and set the party on the path to power. 
 Disturbingly quiet on the Western front 
 By WILLIAM REES-MOGG 
 THE HISTORIC roots of culture are extremely deep. 
 I can remember sitting at Professor Hayek's feet in the company of Margaret Thatcher, a fellow disciple. 
 Yet I do not doubt that Aristotle and St Paul have done more to frame the Prime Minister's mind and therefore the destiny of her Government than any thinkers who have been dead for less than 1,900 years. 
 The great dead have framed our culture: our culture shapes our political life; therefore the great dead have shaped our political life. 
 If one wants to explore the possibilities of Europe's political future, one needs therefore to examine the development of European culture. 
 I have tried to focus such an examination by playing the parlour game of making a list of the 50 Europeans who have most influenced the consciousness of Europe in the last 1,000 years. 
 Such a proceeding is, of course, arbitrary to the point of being ridiculous. 
 I have excluded from my list politicians as such &mdash; hence the absence of Napoleon &mdash; but have allowed in Lenin and Hitler because they largely invented their own ideologies. 
 I have no doubt excluded towering figures who ought to have been included, and included some less important. 
 To have found no space for Scott, Kant, Gibbon, Pushkin, Copernicus, Boyle, Pope, Nietzsche and Racine will seem to many to have been an impertinence. 
 From the lists I made, I came to feel that European culture in the last millennium may have had some 100 real heroes, the mastersingers of Europe, of which I have tried to identify half. 
 However, at least 10 of my cultural heroes would appear on almost all lists, and perhaps 30 would appear on most. 
 Nobody could deny the place of Michelangelo, Shakespeare, Newton, Mozart or Voltaire in the firmament of European culture. 
 I was surprised by two conclusions that came from making such a list. 
 I had not expected the twentieth century to show such a steep decline both in numbers and in quality, though I was less surprised to see the cultural importance of the nineteenth century. 
 I was also surprised to see how great the Germanic contribution to European culture had been. 
 No doubt one could easily design a more Francophone list, but with nine Germans and three Austrians, the German-language contribution was close in number to the 13 English-language and outnumbered the eight French. 
 In this field there are two common ideas, of which one is true and the other is false. 
 The true idea is that Italy is the cradle of European civilisation. 
 Italy, as the centre of the Roman world, conveyed the classical idea to a barbarian Europe; Rome, as the site of papacy, propagated the faith of the Catholic Church. 
 Down to the end of the fifteenth century, Italians dominate European culture in literature, in science, in scholarship, in painting and in architecture. 
 The Renaissance is an Italian phenomenon which spread to the rest of Europe. 
 The false idea is that French culture took over the leading position of Italy. 
 That was divided between Britain, Germany and France and the other nations in more or less equal proportions. 
 Britain probably made the greatest contribution in literature and science, Germany certainly in music, while in the late nineteenth century, France dominated the world of painting. 
 The enlightenment was split between France and Scotland. 
 The Netherlands provided Erasmus, Rembrandt and Van Gogh. 
 Judaism produced Marx, Freud and Einstein, none of them Orthodox but all influenced by Jewish culture. 
 Spain provided two saints, out of a total of five; I was sorry to leave out Thomas More, though he was clearly a less important European influence than Erasmus. 
 What is horrifying is the decline in our own century. 
 Again I am suspicious of my own bias of taste. 
 I am not a modernist, though I presided at the Arts Council with liberal equanimity over the public funding of much modernist art which I did not understand. 
 Yet in other centuries I was being forced to omit, for sheer lack of space, figures of the highest cultural importance. 
 There was no room for Haydn or Hume in the eighteenth century, for Verdi or even Dostoevsky in the nineteenth. 
 Examining the twentieth century was like having to apply a quota to allow the underprivileged into college. 
 It is also true that the twentieth century list contained more than its fair share of abnormal personalities. 
 The general impression conveyed by the earlier centuries is one of wisdom, harmony, humanity. 
 Not perhaps in the cases of Wagner or Rousseau, but in the general run of Europe's cultural heroes. 
 In the twentieth century only Einstein and Stravinsky have undamaged personalities; the others are in varying degrees diabolical, mad, bad, neurotic, tragic or agonised. 
 That has not prevented them exercising a great influence on our cultural development. 
 They are also all dead. 
 There is no twentieth-century master who belongs to the second half of this century. 
 Europe experienced in the first half of the twentieth century a simultaneous cultural, spiritual and political breakdown. 
 The political breakdown was manifested in the two world wars, in the Holocaust, in the severity of the slump, in the doctrines of Nazism and totalitarian communism, both of which were a defilement of human nature. 
 That breakdown was reflected in the art of the period, which &mdash; as in Francis Bacon &mdash; partly protested and partly rejoiced in the excremental quality of the age. 
 Now all is quiet on the Western front. 
 The European mind has no great spokesman. 
 There are philosophers, but no great philosopher, composers, but no great composer, poets, but no great poet, painters, but no great painter. 
 After the storm of the breakdown, Europe is in a period of convalescence, perhaps sedated convalescence. 
 Yet at least the storm does seem to be over, and the peasants are picking up fallen sticks in the devastated forest. 
 50 Mastersingers of Europe 13th century: Thomas Aquinas Italy; Francis of Assisi Italy; Dante Alighieri Italy 14th century: Geoffrey Chaucer Britain 15th century: Joan of Arc France; Michelangelo Buonarroti Italy; Christopher Columbus Italy; Johann Gutenberg Germany; Leonardo da Vinci Italy 16th century: Teresa of Avila Spain; Desiderius Erasmus Netherlands; Ignatius Loyola Spain; Martin Luther Germany; Niccolo Machiavelli Italy; Michel de Montaigne France; William Shakespeare Britain 17th century: Francis Bacon Britain; Rene Descartes France; Galileo Galilei Italy; John Locke Britain; Moliere France; Isaac Newton Britain; Rembrandt Van Rijn Netherlands 18th century: Johann Sebastian Bach Germany; Johann Wolfgang Von Goethe Germany; Samuel Johnson Britain; Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Austria; Jean-Jacques Rousseau Switzerland; Adam Smith Britain; Voltaire France 19th century: Jane Austen Britain; Ludwig Van Beethoven Germany; Paul Cezanne France; Charles Darwin Britain; Charles Dickens Britain; Vincent van Gogh Netherlands; George Gordon, Lord Byron Britain; Georg Hegel Germany; Victor Hugo France; Thomas Robert Malthus Britain; Karl Marx Germany; Leo, Count Tolstoy Russia; Richard Wagner Germany 20th century: Albert Einstein Germany; Sigmund Freud Austria; Adolf Hitler Austria; James Joyce Ireland; Lenin Russia; Pablo Picasso Spain; Igor Stravinsky Russia 
 Monument to the power of the gun: Andrew Higgins revisits Tiananmen Square for communist China's 40th birthday party 
 By ANDREW HIGGINS 
 At a distance &mdash; the only vantage allowed anyone except soldiers and carefully vetted civilians &mdash; it could almost be the Goddess of Democracy. 
 Sculpted from white plaster like the students' statue, the new monument has been erected on the spot where the democracy movement's impertinent icon of defiance stood until the People's Liberation Army arrived on 4 June. 
 For the few considered politically reliable enough to get a closer look, there can be no mistake. 
 The 25 ft statue marking the 40th anniversary of the People's Republic of China is an altogether different creature from its smashed predecessor. 
 Far from mimicking the Statue of Liberty, the new statue holds a gun &mdash; not just any gun but an AK-47, the weapon used by the army to blast its way into Peking. 
 Its barrel, pointed by a helmeted soldier, is sticking into the chest of a worker in overalls. 
 A peasant stands next to them; behind is a bespectacled intellectual. 
 Tiananmen Square may have been &bquo;handed back to the people&equo;, according to Peking's mayor, Chen Xitong, but, as the statue makes clear, real power comes not from the people but from the gun. 
 In an unsubtle reminder of the importance of firepower, Deng Xiaoping and other Chinese leaders gathered in Tiananmen last night to celebrate the 40th birthday of &bquo;new China&equo; with a deafening display of pyrotechnics. 
 For more than an hour, rockets exploded across the sky &mdash; an extravaganza that for many Peking residents recalled not so much the glory of the revolution as the tracer bullets and machine-gun fire of early June. 
 If the Goddess of Democracy symbolised a vision of China alien to the Communist Party, the new figures are equally alien to the students: the obedience of the intellectual and unflinching solidarity of the &bquo;workers, peasants and soldiers&equo;. 
 Ironically, neither of these visions is Chinese. 
 While the students looked to the West, China's hardline leadership has found its inspiration in the pre-glasnost Soviet Union of Stalinist aesthetics - muscular arms, square jaws and stiff poses. 
 The official blurb explains that the plaster figures &bquo;stand as if boldly forging ahead, their eyes fixed on our motherland's beautiful future&equo;. 
 Perhaps unwittingly, the new statue hints at a deeper truth underpinning the hardline triumph: the worker, the peasant and the intellectual gaze wistfully towards the Forbidden City, the grandest monument to the genius of Chinese civilisation, but the soldier has his eyes fixed in a different direction &mdash; down the Avenue of Eternal Peace towards Zhongnanhai, the walled compound where party leaders live and work. 
 For as Mao decreed, if power grows from the barrel of a gun, it is the party that must control, and if necessary use, that gun. 
 Four months after the People's Liberation Army stormed central Peking with the loss of hundreds of lives, few can have any doubt about the party's determination to enforce this Maoist maxim. 
 As many as 100,000 soldiers are still encamped around Peking. 
 Soldiers stand guard on street corners and roam the city at night. 
 Occasional gunshots can still be heard, though no one seems to know who fires the guns and if anyone is hit. 
 The leaders remain haunted by the forces of dissent they ordered the army to crush. 
 Across China there has been a ritualistic cleansing to erase the symbols of the student movement. 
 Noticeboards have been scrubbed clean of posters, walls of daubed slogans and minds of memories of what really happened. 
 Imitating the students' tactics, the party has ordered shops and houses be strung with banners praising the &bquo;great and glorious Communist Party of China&equo;. 
 And, again like the students, it has issued an official list of permitted slogans, ordering citizens to memorise 40 different chants to mark the 40th anniversary of communist rule. 
 Not as stirring as the protest movement's shouts of &bquo;long live democracy, down with autocracy&equo;, they include cumbersome chants hailing &bquo;the great achievement of socialism&equo; and &bquo;warmly hail the victory over the turmoil and counter-revolutionary rebellion&equo;. 
 Nowhere has the leadership struggled to exorcise the memory of the student- led revolt as in Tiananmen itself, the symbolic heart of the nation where, on 1 October 1949, Mao Tse-tung proclaimed the People's Republic of China. 
 The students who occupied the square for three weeks in May and early June have been banished. 
 So, too, has anyone without the special pass needed to get through military cordons. 
 The Monument to the People's Heroes, the stone obelisk in the middle of the square where student leaders had their &bquo;command centre&equo;, has been declared a forbidden zone because it is felt to have been contaminated by the students' presence. 
 In an attempt at gaiety before the national day, fairy lights were strung on trees where political banners and cartoons lampooning the leaders once hung. 
 There is no doubt now who controls the square. 
 China's leaders have become so fearful of revolt that Tiananmen is guarded round the clock by uniformed soldiers with guns while the rest of Peking remains firmly under martial law. 
 Scores of Tiananmen's paving stones have been replaced to remove the evidence of anti-government messages. 
 Others have been covered with flower pots to hide the traces of the student occupation or scars left by the tracks of tanks and armoured personnel carriers. 
 Try as the leadership might to erase what happened, nothing can be done to change the one fact on which the future of China turns: the men who ordered the assault on Tiananmen Square will surely die long before the youth they ordered to be killed. 
 Deng Xiaoping is 85, and while apparently in reasonably good health, will not outlive the instigators of the &bquo;counter-revolutionary rebellion&equo;. 
 Other veteran revolutionaries on whose longevity the current leadership depends are all in their eighties. 
 Some, like the hardline godfather Chen Yun, are so infirm they are rarely seen in public. 
 Others do occasionally venture out but are painful to watch. 
 At a state banquet on the eve of the national day in the Great Hall of the People, the head tables were cluttered with ageing revolutionaries slumped in their seats. 
 When Li Peng, the Prime Minister, tried to share a toast with his adoptive mother, the venerable widow of Chou En-lai, he was met with an uncomprehending stare. 
 In desperation, he finally raised not only his own glass but also hers &mdash; a graphic reminder of how fragile the veterans', and by association Mr Li's own, power may turn out to be. 
 But if they are physically weak, the old guard remain politically strong. 
 Refighting the battles of their own youth, they have tried to fix China's eyes firmly on the past. 
 The party may claim to be in the vanguard of history, but its clock seems to have stopped in the 1950s. 
 Propaganda campaigns, class struggle, the cult of the model worker and even the almost evangelical rhetoric of the cold war are all back with a vengeance. 
 Television and newspapers no longer praise model entrepreneurs but heroic labourers such as Zhang Fuxin, praised for throwing himself into a pit of polluted mud to retrieve a piece of equipment. 
 People are told that Mr Zhang was so dedicated that he cut short his honeymoon to return to work, telling his new wife: &bquo;One day without hearing the sound of the drill, my heart is heavy. 
 One day without wearing work clothes, it's as if I lack something. 
 I feel ill at ease.&equo; 
 In deference to ageing stalwarts, the Communist Party's new leader, Jiang Zemin, recently made a pilgrimage to Yenan, the remote village where the Red Army took refuge at the end of the Long March. 
 The future of China, he pronounced, depends on reviving the &bquo;Yenan spirit&equo; of hard work and plain living. 
 So strong is the nostalgia, that Mao, Chou En-lai and other founders of &bquo;new China&equo; often seem to have returned from the dead. 
 The front page of the People's Daily and every other major national newspaper last week featured a picture of the new Politburo standing committee meeting with actors from a People's Liberation Army theatre troupe made up to look like the dead founding fathers. 
 Mao lookalikes also dominate the cinema. 
 The country's best known Mao impersonator, an actor called Gu Yue, has made a startling comeback in a new 90-minute epic portraying the last months of China's civil war. 
 In a further nod of respect to the great helmsman, his portrait on the Forbidden City has been given a new look. 
 Already replaced once in June after being splattered with paint, it was replaced again last week with a new painting featuring a bluer sky. 
 In Peking at least, the resurrection of past models and heroes has provoked more giggling than respect, spawning a rash of political jokes. 
 Take for example the peasant who visits the mausoleum housing Mao's corpse in Tiananmen Square. 
 &bquo;Where is Mao? 
 I want to talk to him,&equo; he says to the guard at the door. 
 &bquo;You can't talk to him; he's dead,&equo; replies the guard. 
 After touring the mausoleum, the peasant returns and again asks where he can find Mao alive. 
 Again the guard replies that he is dead. 
 The peasant then walks past the corpse for a second time and emerges to ask the same question. 
 &bquo;I told you, he's been dead for years,&equo; the guard snaps. 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; the peasant answers, &bquo;but I just love to hear you say it.&equo; 
 Another joke is about a student marching down the Avenue of Eternal Peace with a banner saying &bquo;Li Peng is a pig&equo;. 
 The student is arrested, tried and sentenced to 20 years. 
 He complains that illegal protests carry a maximum sentence of five years. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; replies the judge. 
 &bquo;Five years for an illegal protest and 15 for revealing state secrets.&equo; 
 Such is the mood of quiet irreverence and anger that street hawkers have begun selling buttons with the two-finger victory sign that became the symbol of the student movement. 
 As an ingenious precaution against charges of &bquo;counter-revolutionary&equo; tendencies, the buttons carry a small legend: &bquo;Victory! &mdash; I climbed the Great Wall of China.&equo; 
 Tigrayans advance on a helpless Addis Ababa 
 From RICHARD DOWDEN in Addis Ababa 
 THE ETHIOPIAN army is failing to halt northern rebels advancing rapidly southwards to the capital and its vital lifeline road. 
 Some observers are predicting the imminent collapse of the military regime which has ruled Ethiopia for 15 years. 
 The rebels, the Tigrayan People's Liberation Front (TPLF), are threatening to cut off Dese, a key garrison town protecting part of the road linking Addis Ababa with the port of Assab. 
 They have advanced down the Asmara road in the past four weeks and are now reported to be operating south of Dese. 
 They have surrounded a garrison at Bati, to the east, and on 19 September they attacked Mile on the Assab road, closing it for 36 hours. 
 Helicopter gunships ply constant missions from their base at Kombolcha: yesterday I watched MiG-21 fighter-bombers, loaded with bombs and rockets, take off from Dire Dawa and head west. 
 The estimated 40,000 troops in Dese are being joined by the remnants of the defeated Third Army, which is struggling down the road or surrendering to the rebels. 
 One estimate puts government losses in the past four weeks at 20,000 killed, captured or deserted. 
 The government in Addis Ababa will say nothing about the situation, and the war is not reported by the state-run media. 
 However, recent visitors to Dese describe the areas as chaotic, with whole units leaderless and unwilling to fight. 
 Soviet advisers have been withdrawn from Dese and Kombolcha. 
 A Soviet Deputy Defence Minister, General Varrenikov, has been in Addis Ababa for the past week. 
 He is reported to be negotiating the complete withdrawal of the 1,500 Soviet military advisers. 
 The Russians have said they believe in a negotiated settlement to the civil war, but they are continuing to supply arms to President Mengistu, apparently to allow him to negotiate from a position of strength. 
 A large consignment of weapons was unloaded from a Soviet ship at Assab on 21 September. 
 Weapons will not, however, save President Mengistu if no one is willing to use them. 
 The Ethiopian army, the biggest in sub-Saharan Africa, consists largely of press-ganged young peasants or unemployed urban teenagers who have been drafted to the front after a few weeks' training. 
 At the end of a spectacularly successful year, the TPLF drove the Ethiopian army out of Tigray province in February. 
 Few people thought the Tigrayans could continue their success outside their own province, but on 26 August the TPLF began an advance which drove the government forces out of Korem and Kobo. 
 Three weeks ago, the 102nd Airborne Division, Russian-trained and regarded as a crack unit, was rushed from its base at Asmara to the front line, but it too has been mauled by the rebels, who swept through the mountains flanking the main road, capturing all the towns as far as Woldiya. 
 Meanwhile, in Eritrea, to the north, a de facto ceasefire is holding between the government and the Eritrean People's Liberation Front (EPLF), which is seeking independence for Eritrea. 
 Peace talks began in Atlanta, Georgia, last month and are due to resume in Nairobi on 18 November. 
 The only government-controlled areas in highland Eritrea are the road between Asmara and Massawa and the garrisons of Keren, Senafe and Adi Kwala. 
 Government troops are digging deep defences at Asmara and there is no doubt that, should the peace talks fail, the EPLF will resume fighting and attack it, or try to cut it off. 
 One option for the TPLF is to strike east, to the Assab-Addis Ababa road. 
 If they succeed in cutting it, they will have achieved checkmate. 
 They could strike west and try to cut off Gonder, another heavily-fortified garrison, or they could try to continue rolling south towards the capital. 
 Addis Ababa is guarded by about 20,000 troops, including President Mengistu's Praetorian guard, which saved him during the coup attempt in May. 
 No one believes the TPLF can take the capital, but their continuing success could persuade senior army officers that President Mengistu should be replaced by someone who can stop the war and negotiate. 
 &bquo;The situation is very, very fluid and there is a possibility that the regime will disintegrate,&equo; said one Western diplomat. 
 The TPLF has recently transformed itself into the Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Movement to give itself more national credibility, but its core remains the Marxist-Leninist League of Tigray, whose political model seems closest to the late Enver Hoxha's Albania. 
 Much as many Ethiopians fear and loathe the government, they are calling for more political and economic freedom, and would not feel liberated by the TPLF. 
 Nor would they welcome a takeover by the Tigrayans. 
 Most of the people between Dese and the capital are Maharan and Oromo. 
 Nevertheless, there have been several incidents in the capital recently. 
 Bombs were placed in the fuel depot at the airport last month, and a small power station nearby was blown up. 
 Tribalism and liberation meet at Transkei burial 
 From JOHN CARLIN in Bumbane, Transkei 
 WHEN is an independent state not an independent state? 
 When it's a homeland. 
 Bumbane, otherwise known as &bquo;the Great Place&equo;, is the royal burial site of the Tembu tribe here in what South Africa insists on calling the Republic of Transkei, a so-called &bquo;homeland&equo; for black people upon which Pretoria imposed political independence in 1976. 
 This helps explain the extraordinary spectacle here yesterday of 5,000 loudly &bquo;anti-colonial&equo; black people clamouring against independence and for political re-integration with South Africa. 
 The occasion was that black South African speciality, the political funeral. 
 Behind it all was the hand of Nelson Mandela, which may lend the event much significance should it turn out that President FW de Klerk is serious about negotiating with black leaders. 
 Mr Mandela belongs to the royal family of the Tembu tribe. 
 The man buried yesterday was the king of the Tembus, the most powerful of the half dozen tribes who speak the Xhosa language. 
 Since there are six million Xhosas - one million more than the entire white population of South Africa &mdash; they are potentially a serious force for Mr de Klerk to reckon with. 
 They count among their number more than 70 per cent of the leaders in the executive of the African National Congress. 
 The ANC does not like this fact to be mentioned, because it purports to eschew tribalism in favour of an all-embracing black nationalism. 
 All the more odd, then, that yesterday's funeral should have been both a celebration of time-honoured Tembu ritual and the most vocal demonstration in years on what the rest of the world calls South African soil of the strength of the ANC and its far from tribalistic affiliate, the South African Communist Party. 
 The imprisoned Mr Mandela has met in recent months more than a dozen of the chieftains and assorted dignitaries &mdash; his Xhosa wife, Winnie, among them - who were on the podium. 
 Yesterday not only were the Xhosas out in force, it seemed that a convention of the entire Mass Democratic Movement - essentially the exiled ANC's internal representatives &mdash; had been called. 
 King Sabata Dalindyebo would have been pleased. 
 He died three years ago. 
 But his body was exhumed last Monday for the ceremonial reburial yesterday. 
 The problem had been that there was no ceremony the first time around. 
 He was buried, under orders from the corrupt and usurping Matanzima brothers who used to run Transkei, in a commoner's grave. 
 The Matanzimas were forced out after a military coup nearly two years ago. 
 The benign ruler who took over, Major-General Bantu Holomisa, spoke at the graveside. 
 In so doing he also gave his blessing to &mdash; what in effect proved to be the case &mdash; declaring the Transkei, or at least Bumbane, the first ANC liberated zone, however fleetingly, yesterday afternoon. 
 Draped over the king's coffin was an ANC flag. 
 He had vehemently opposed Transkei's bogus independence and, hounded by the Matanzimas, had fled to Zambia, where he joined the ANC. 
 Much plotting went into the organisation of the event. 
 Major-General Holomisa met the president of the ANC in London recently. 
 His brother, who lives in the same house, spoke with Mr Mandela for five hours on 4 August. 
 Mrs Mandela has been shuttling back and forth with messages from her husband's prison home near Cape Town. 
 The tribal leaders who visited Mr Mandela have also met the top ANC leaders in Zambia. 
 The upshot of it all is that Major-General Holomisa has made Transkei a haven of sorts, a thorn in Pretoria's side, for the ANC. 
 He will no doubt tread very carefully, but the consequences of his stand could be far-reaching. 
 He said yesterday that he meant to conduct a referendum to test whether Transkei's three million people wished to retain &bquo;independence&equo; or not. 
 If the answer is &bquo;no&equo;, South Africa may have to confront the beginning of the end of the &bquo;homelands&equo; system. 
 Swapo remains favourite to win the United Nations-supervised elections next month 
 From JOHN CARLIN in Bumbane, Transkei 
 A woman shows her support for the South West Africa People's Organisation (Swapo) at an election rally in Windhoek. 
 Swapo remains the overwhelming favourite to win the United Nations-supervised elections next month, but claims that the organisation has detained and tortured many of its members in Angola and Zambia may deprive it of the two-thirds majority needed to form a government in an independent Namibia without holding another election. 
 The UN is investigating the allegations. 
 Swapo and its main rival, the Democratic Turnhalle Alliance, have accused each other of violent intimidation during the campaign. 
 Out of India: The snow-wreaths melt away in the heat of battle 
 By TONY ALLEN-MILLS 
 BHARATPUR &mdash; The monsoon rains are lifting across the Gangetic floodplains, and there is a hint of magic in the air. 
 The winter migrations are beginning, and the skies over northern India are alive with transiting birds. 
 In the next few weeks, as the seasons change in eastern Europe and central Asia, spectacular colonies of painted storks will descend on the lakes and marshes of Uttar Pradesh and Rajasthan. 
 They will be followed by flocks of pintail ducks and greylag geese. 
 Tens of thousands of birds, navigating with miraculous precision, arrive each year at their Indian winter homes. 
 But for one tiny group of exquisitely beautiful long-distance travellers, the coming journey may prove their last. 
 Somewhere along the Ob river in central Siberia, slowly building strength for a 3,500-mile flight, wait perhaps 50 Siberian cranes. 
 They are, as far as naturalists are aware, the only surviving members of a rapidly dwindling population of a bird the Siberians call the &bquo;snow-wreath&equo;. 
 Every autumn, the birds rise from the Ob river swamps to begin a perilous journey south. 
 One small group heads for Iran; the rest fly through the Soviet Union, across the battlefields of Afghanistan and past the guns of Pakistani poachers to the monsoon-soaked plains of India, where they pass a lazy winter feeding on plants. 
 But each year fewer arrive. 
 A century ago, more than 200 Siberian cranes were recorded in the jheels and marshes of Uttar Pradesh. 
 In 1984, there were 41; two years ago, 31. 
 Last year 23 arrived. 
 Only 13 reached Iran. 
 The Siberian crane stands four and a half feet tall, its brilliant white plumage offset by a blood-red beak, face and legs. 
 Jet-black wing quills are visible in flight. 
 Like most birdwatchers, I have only seen them in pictures -invariably in supremely elegant poses, their long, thin beaks delicately probing the water for weeds. 
 Unlike most birdwatchers, I am lucky enough to live less than four hours' drive from their regular winter home &mdash; a wildfowl marsh constructed by one of the Maharajahs of Bharatpur. 
 I was there recently, talking to Dr Lalitha Vijayam about her research on the Siberian crane's problems and about my chances of seeing one before the Ob river race becomes extinct. 
 The Maharajahs of Bharatpur were dedicated hunters, famous for their prodigious shoots. 
 A plaque in the Bharatpur marshes records the November day in 1938 that the then Viceroy of India, Lord Linlithgow, bagged 4,373 wildfowl, 3,044 of them before lunch. 
 The royal guns did not fall silent at Bharatpur until 1964. 
 Soon after, thanks largely to the endeavours of India's finest ornithologist, Salim Ali, the ex-Maharajah's swamp was turned into a sanctuary unequalled in Asia. 
 It is now formally known as the Keoladeo Ghana National Park, and its own guide book charmingly and accurately boasts: &bquo;Birds! 
 Birds!! 
 Everywhere Birds!!!&equo; 
 Of all the species visible in Bharatpur, none is more romantic or mysterious than the Siberian crane. 
 There are many suitably marshy habitats in the Ganges basin, yet the bird has invariably stopped at Bharatpur. 
 There are other beautiful cranes in the park &mdash; my favourite is the demoiselle, a slender grey bird with delightful black plumes and ear-tufts. 
 But no other bird exerts quite the appeal of the annual visitor from the river Ob. 
 Every year the Indian newspapers chart Siberian crane sightings with the devotion and enthusiasm the British press usually only musters at times of royal births. 
 Dr Vijayan, a research scientist with the Bombay Natural History Society, is leading a study of the Siberian crane that began in 1980. 
 She confesses her team can only guess at the causes of the bird's decline. 
 &bquo;We think they are being shot for meat when they land in Afghanistan,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;And we know that some have been poached in Pakistan.&equo; 
 The cranes may also have suffered from Bharatpur's environmental problems. 
 Scientists are trying to calculate the long-term impact of the catastrophic drought of 1987. 
 There have been rows over cattle-grazing and other encroachment. 
 Fortunately, this year's monsoon was short but sharp, and improved water management has produced good floods. 
 Dr Vijayan also reports that after a long struggle to arouse their interest, Pakistani environmentalists are aware of the threat to the bird. 
 But the war rages on in Afghanistan, and crane protection is understandably a low priority in Kabul. 
 The war, and the region's complex geopolitical concerns, are also preventing naturalists from undertaking the most effective means of monitoring the Siberian crane - ringing the flock with miniature transmitters that could be tracked from space. 
 The prospect of Moscow, Kabul, Islamabad and New Delhi all agreeing on a joint satellite monitoring venture is not great. 
 The scientists can only wait and hope. 
 Which is what I shall be doing for the next three months. 
 Given the awesome sum of human misery in this part of the world, I suppose I shouldn't get too worked up about the fate of a flock of birds &mdash; particularly as the much larger eastern race of the Siberian crane, which migrates from north-eastern Yakutia to the lower reaches of the Yangtse river in China, is apparently surviving well. 
 But if the snow-wreaths of the Ob river don't reach Bharatpur this year, I shall feel inescapably sad. 
 Russians send Kabul 2,000 supply trucks 
 From AHMED RASHID in Kabul 
 THE SOVIET UNION is supplying the Afghan government with another 2,000 trucks to step up the supply of food, fuel and ammunition to Kabul's 1.5 million people before the winter snows affect the roads. 
 The unconditional Soviet support to the Kabul regime is on such a scale that the US and Pakistan cannot hope to match it. 
 Every few minutes a truck thunders down the strategic Salang Highway on its way from Hiratan on the Soviet border to Kabul. 
 Convoys half a mile long are watched over by scattered Afghan army outposts on the hills by the road. 
 Drivers report no guerrilla attacks, even though security north of the Salang Tunnel has been largely handed over to local militia units and the army withdrawn. 
 After setting up a bitumen plant and providing earth-moving machinery, the Soviets helped cut a new road east of the old Salang Tunnel. 
 The highway, which links up with the old road south of Charikar, avoids mujahedin territory and and passes through a region where the Kabul regime has concluded deals with local guerrilla commanders. 
 &bquo;We are receiving 300 trucks of supplies a day from the Soviet Union,&equo; said the deputy prime minister, General Mohammed Hakim. 
 A US-trained officer, 48-year-old General Hakim is the most experienced convoy trouble-shooter in the regime, having organised the relief convoy to the besieged city of Khost two years ago and saved Kabul from near starvation last year. 
 &bquo;The government's main preoccupation is getting supplies to the cities before winter,&equo; he said. 
 This year, government-held countryside produced only 150,000 tonnes of wheat, or 10 per cent of Afghanistan's total consumption, due to a bad harvest and the war. 
 Of the 90,000 tonnes of wheat needed in Kabul to survive the winter, 37,000 tonnes have already been stockpiled, General Hakim said. 
 Afghan and diplomatic sources said that the Soviets would provide 2,000 more trucks and fuel tankers, but General Hakim admitted that the real problem will be fuel, which is already in short supply in Kabul. 
 Diesel prices on the black markeat are ten times higher than the official price. 
 Even for some government cars, diesel is only available on the black market. 
 For the past few weeks President Najibullah has been meeting militia commanders from around the country offering them more weapons and money to maintain their loyalty and keep the roads open. 
 Since all private truck owners are now allowed to bring food from Hiratan and sell it in Kabul, some militia commanders, most of them former mujahedin, are buying trucks and becoming traders. 
 The Soviet relief effort is also employing aircraft. 
 Up to 40 flights a day bring in weapons and ammunition, including Frog 7s, a short range surface-to-surface missile that is less expensive than the Scud missiles already provided. 
 The flights that circle Kabul every quarter of an hour are a morale booster for the hard-pressed population. 
 &bquo;The Soviet Union is giving us oxygen &mdash; bread and weapons to defend ourselves,&equo; said Suleman Laeq, the minister for tribes and nationalities. 
 Soviet aid to Kabul is estimated at between &dollar;250m (&pound;154) and &dollar;300m a month. 
 The US and Saudi Arabia will have funnelled some &dollar;700m to the Pakistan-based mujahedin by the end of this year. 
 Soviet aid has helped in maintaining the population's morale and the regime's credibility and unity, while US aid to the to the mujahedin has done little to increase their unity, morale or fighting ability. 
 WASHINGTON &mdash; The US should explore the possibility of an agreement with the Soviet Union to cut off military supplies to Afghanistan, a leading senator said in a report published yesterday, Reuter reports. 
 Claiborne Pell, chairman of the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee, also called for a neutral government in Kabul to hold elections or seek a traditional Afghan consultative assembly. 
 Mr Pell issued the report after a trip to Pakistan in August and talks with Pakistani leaders and leaders of the US-Pakistan-backed provisional government. 
 Army on guard as China fetes its Revolution 
 From ANDREW HIGGINS in Peking 
 CHINA'S leaders celebrated the 40th anniversary of Communist rule yesterday, protected from their people by the biggest security operation undertaken in the capital since the People's Liberation Army stormed into Peking four months ago. 
 Standing exactly where Mao Tse-tung proclaimed the People's Republic of China on 1 October 1949, paramount leader Deng Xiaoping joined other party leaders atop the Gate of Heavenly Peace to preside over a night of fireworks and martial music in Tiananmen Square. 
 Fearful of protests or violence by citizens outraged by the army's brutal assault on Tiananmen on 4 June, armed troops cordoned off a large area of central Peking, admitting only hand-picked spectators into the square. 
 Among the guests were thousands of plain-clothes police and out-of-uniform soldiers, some of whom arrived in military trucks, dressed as clowns. 
 Authorities have themselves acknowledged fears that &bquo;counter-revolutionaries&equo;, still at large despite a nationwide crackdown on dissent, might try to sabotage the anniversary. 
 Throughout the day, thousands of troops patrolled central Peking, while police set up road-blocks to check cars in the city's north-west university district of Haidian, the birthplace of China's seven-week-long pro-democracy movement. 
 Many students, still bitterly hostile to the government despite a barrage of propaganda and weeks of political study classes, refused to take part in the celebrations, spending the day inside their dormitories. 
 On instructions from authorities, Peking University, the focus of the student rebellion, sent a dance troupe, one of scores of similar groups dragooned into the celebrations. 
 Although sullen opposition and private anger still shadows the Communist Party, no disturbances were reported during yesterday's events. 
 Hundreds of thousands of people poured into the streets to watch the firework display - a fact which, Mr Deng boasted, proves that &bquo;China's social order has returned to normal&equo;. 
 He made the comment in remarks to a visiting official from North Korea, one of only a handful of foreign countries to send special delegations for national day. 
 Others included East Germany, Cuba and the Soviet Union &mdash; a list that reflects China's sudden dependence on the Communist bloc for its friends. 
 Most Western ambassadors boycotted the firework display but did attend a reception on Saturday hosted by the Prime Minister, Li Peng. 
 Many Western businessmen attended both. 
 Strident editorials in the official press condemned foreign interference and predicted the worldwide triumph of socialism. 
 The Peking Daily accused the West of trying to subjugate China for 40 years and of now waging &bquo;psychological warfare and dreaming of victory without war&equo;. 
 The unusually confrontational rhetoric suggests that Mao was perhaps less than correct when, 40 years ago yesterday, he announced to Tiananmen: &bquo;The Chinese people have stood up&hellip; we have friends all over the world.&equo; 
 HONG KONG &mdash; More than 3,000 people marked the 40th anniversary of Communist rule in China yesterday by rallying to protest against the suppression of the pro-democracy movement in Peking, AP reports. 
 Szeto Wah, a Hong Kong legislator, told the crowd: &bquo;A republic ruled by the people has not yet been realised.&equo; 
 The three-hour rally was organised by the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of the Patriotic Democratic Movement of China. 
 Cambodia puts in more troops 
 From ANDREW HIGGINS in Peking 
 ARANYAPRATHET, Thailand (UPI, AP) &mdash; Heavy fighting continued in western Cambodia yesterday as the Vietnamese-backed government brought in reinforcements to face a drive by non-communist resistance forces, resistance officials and military sources said. 
 &bquo;We might have to stop our advances if there are a lot of reinforcements,&equo; said a senior official of the Khmer People's National Liberation Front (KPNLF), Ieng Mouli. 
 Military reports showed the KPNLF offensive launched on Saturday had made quick initial progress, he said, and troops had captured at least 10 government positions and large quantities of weapons. 
 The acting commander-in-chief of the KPNLF, Dien Del, said the fighting had continued overnight and had been &bquo;more than 70 per cent successful&equo;. 
 He expected his troops would take two more towns and said his fighters now controlled the whole of Highway 69, along the Thai frontier, north of Sisophon. 
 Western sources at the Thai-Cambodian border confirmed the KPNLF had scored some major gains, and military sources there said the fighting was continuing. 
 The low rumble of artillery fire could be heard from this nearby Thai border town. 
 One source attributed the quick victories of the initial push to agreement by the ill-trained Heng Samrin forces to accept payments to abandon their positions before the assaults. 
 Military sources said the Chinese-backed Khmer Rouge guerrilla group had joined the KPNLF in a pincer attack on Sisophon. 
 Earlier, Abdul Gaffar Peang-meth, the assistant to the KPNLF commander-in-chief, Ak Sutsakorn, had denied any knowledge of co-ordination with the Khmer Rouge. 
 Prisoner of Conscience: Burmese prisoners face death: Moe Kyaw Thu, Zwa Gyi and Nyi Nyi U 
 By CAROLINE MOOREHEAD 
 A BOY of 17 and two men in their twenties face execution in Burma for planting a bomb, but others involved in the crime say they took no part in it. 
 Human rights organisations maintain that the men have been wrongly convicted and are being victimised for being members of the leading opposition political party. 
 were arrested on 17 July in connection with a parcel bomb which exploded in the Syriam state oil refinery 10 days earlier and killed two people. 
 Violent incidents of this kind have become commonplace in a country where all human rights are being eroded. 
 Nothing was known of the fate of the three men, all of them active on behalf of the National League for Democracy, until 27 July, when the official radio announced that they had been condemned to death. 
 Their trial had been completed in a single morning session before a military tribunal inside Insein Prison, an overcrowded place notorious for torture. 
 The trial was conducted under martial-law provisions proclaimed only on the day of their arrest, and was the first to be held under these procedures. 
 Lawyers said the prosecution was allowed to present evidence, but that there was no mention of any defence evidence. 
 Martial law orders empower military tribunals to &bquo;waive unnecessary witnesses&equo; and to impose death sentences &bquo;regardless of the provisions under existing laws&equo;. 
 It emerged that not only was there no reliable evidence of guilt, but, on the contrary, there was considerable proof of innocence. 
 The Karen National Union, which admits to violent opposition to the military government, denies the three men were in any way involved. 
 A fourth man, said to have provided the bomb, has added that they had nothing to do with it. 
 No appeal is allowed under Burma's new martial law orders and Amnesty International fears that Moe Kyaw Thu, Zaw Gyi and Nyi Nyi U may be executed any day. 
 Aquino prepares for clash over Marcos body 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Manila 
 PRESIDENT Corazon Aquino of the Philippines is bracing herself for a legal battle over her decision not to allow the remains of the former president, Ferdinand Marcos, to be returned home from Hawaii for burial. 
 At the behest of Marcos' family, Vice-president Salvador Laurel, Mrs Aquino's estranged deputy and now head of an opposition party, and a group of &bquo;loyalists&equo; will today attempt to reverse an earlier Supreme Court ruling to uphold Mrs Aquino's decision to prohibit Marcos' return. 
 But at the weekend, although Mrs Aquino said she would respect any Supreme Court decision, she said she had received &bquo;highly sensitive&equo; information that strengthened her resolve. 
 She said yesterday that Marcos's remains may be brought to the Philippines when emotions have subsided. 
 Mrs Aquino cited the case of Napoleon, who died in exile in 1821 and remains made &bquo;a very triumphant return&equo; to France in 1840 when &bquo;things had settled down&equo;. 
 Marcos ruled the Philippines for 20 years before Mrs Aquino was swept to office on a wave of &bquo;people power&equo; in 1986. 
 The Aquino government accuses him of having stolen up to US&dollar;10bn (&pound;6.1bn) from the country during his reign. 
 He died in Honolulu on Thursday. 
 Calling Mrs Aquino's decision an infringement of universal human rights, Mr Laurel said: &bquo;The ban is contrary to the constitution and is therefore illegal.&equo; 
 But citing &bquo;national welfare&equo;, the Supreme Court earlier voted eight to seven to uphold the ban imposed by Mrs Aquino. 
 Mr Laurel said: &bquo;Now that he is dead, that makes a lot of difference.&equo; 
 Details of the &bquo;highly sensitive&equo; information have not been made public, but it is understood to have originated from intelligence and diplomatic sources and probably relates to plans by Marcos loyalists to capitalise on his return to the country. 
 At meeting on Saturday Mrs Aquino gave aides details of this information. 
 The military is on alert, with half of its troops confined to barracks as a precaution against disturbances. 
 There has, however, so far been little popular reaction in the country to the death of Marcos. 
 Several hundred people have been attending a nightly candle-lit vigil, and there has been one other small protest. 
 Mubarak peace proposal exposes Israeli tensions 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Jerusalem 
 THE ISRAELI cabinet is being called this week to debate for the first time proposals made by Egypt for advancing the search for a settlement of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. 
 The cabinet session &mdash; billed, like many before, as &bquo;crucial&equo; &mdash; is to discuss the 10 points submitted by President Mubarak to clarify Israel's initiative for elections in the occupied territories. 
 They have directed a powerful light on the ambiguities of the initiative. 
 This has not only exposed the underlying differences between Likud and Labour which the initiative papered over. 
 They have also highlighted old rifts and stimulated new ones within the parties themselves. 
 Mr Mubarak's proposals were first formally presented to Israel on 16 September. 
 The Israeli Prime Minister, Yitzak Shamir, procrastinated and postponed discussion of the points at the cabinet, the inner cabinet, or the top decision-making body known as the &bquo;forum of four&equo; senior ministers, in the hope that the problem would go away. 
 In the meantime, ministers conducted individual diplomatic initiatives on the basis of Egyptian ideas not yet discussed by the government. 
 The Defence Minister, Yitzhak Rabin, met Mr Mubarak in Cairo, and in the US, Mr Arens and Mr Peres separately met President Mubarak and the US Secretary of State, James Baker. 
 The two issues at the heart of the disagreement are those which have killed at birth any attempt in the past dozen years to address the Palestinian question: Who speaks for the Palestinians and what are the limits of the Palestinian problem? 
 The first centres on the composition of a Palestinian delegation that would hold talks with Israel in Cairo. 
 Mr Rabin has suggested including Palestinians deported by the Israelis. 
 This would satisfy demands by the Palestine Liberation Organisation for delegates from outside to underline the principle that the Palestinian issue deals with a whole people. 
 At the same time, Israel could maintain they were still legally residents of the occupied territories. 
 But Mr Shamir has given no sign of softening his opposition to any contact with the PLO, or with Palestinians from outside, including those deported for activities hostile to Israel. 
 And the depth of his ideological commitment to maintaining Israel's hold over the West Bank rules out any acceptance of the principle that negotiations should eventually lead to an exchange of land for peace. 
 Israeli troops killed four Palestinians yesterday and a fifth was beaten to death by fellow Arabs for alleged collaboration with Israel, Reuter reports. 
 Lebanese MPs scrape rust off government machinery 
 From ROBERT FISK in Taif, Saudi Arabia 
 IT IS difficult to know who is the more isolated: the 62 members of the Lebanese Parliament or the 73 members of the Lebanese press corps. 
 Lebanon's MPs &mdash; 31 of them Muslims, 31 of them Christians &mdash; have left the militia leaders behind in Beirut to keep the peace. 
 The MPs are here to scrape the rust off the derelict machinery of government, to recreate the corroded institution that will have to elect a president and produce a government which can impose its rule on Lebanon &mdash; and on the militia leaders. 
 Hence the isolation. 
 Closeted in the conference palace at Taif &mdash; itself built by a Lebanese-born millionaire &mdash; the MPs found themselves unable to exercise their normal function of playing to the gallery. 
 Lebanese parliamentary sessions have to be open to the public. 
 They also, by law, have to be held in Beirut. 
 So this was therefore called &bquo;an informal meeting of Lebanese parliamentarians&equo; &mdash; which effectively closed the doors of their marble debating chamber to the press. 
 In equal isolation at the Intercontinental Hotel, 16 miles away, Lebanese journalists found themselves restricted to the parliament's two opening statements and a diet of gentle assurances from Prince Saud al-Feisel, the Saudi Foreign Minister, that optimism was the order of the day, but while he had heard of some disputes in the parliamentary chamber, he had every reason to believe the Lebanese would accept the Arab League peace plan. 
 Christian MPs close to General Michel Aoun wanted to talk first about a Syrian withdrawal, in according with the general's instructions. 
 And it is perfectly clear that the old representatives of Lebanese democracy are under considerable pressure to talk about reform and not withdrawal. 
 Saeb Salam made this perfectly evident. 
 Mr Salam, 84, a Sunni Muslim, is the most impressive of Lebanon's dying breed of elder statesmen, but his words could have been those of a much younger man. 
 &bquo;It is not appropriate to insist upon an immediate Syrian withdrawal,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We must admit that a Syrian withdrawal could provoke many dangers for which no one would want to take responsibility. 
 This is true, regardless of the opinion that some people have of Syria, and of their unhappiness at Syria's presence in Lebanon. 
 Among the dangers that this could bring about would be the emergence of small concessional states governed by the militias.&equo; 
 All this was shorthand for a simple warning: that if the Syrians pull out of west Beirut, the militias would go to war again in its streets, and there would be nothing the Christians could do about it. 
 Coach death 
 From ROBERT FISK in Taif, Saudi Arabia 
 (First Edition) LYONS (AFP) &mdash; A British girl, Yvonne Brigden, 16, was killed and two other Britons were injured when their coach collided with two lorries in southern France on Saturday. 
 Boris is back 
 From ROBERT FISK in Taif, Saudi Arabia 
 MOSCOW (Reuter) &mdash; Thousands of Soviet television viewers yesterday heard Boris Yeltsin, the Communist Party rebel, warn of a &bquo;revolution from below&equo; if radical economic changes did not happen within a year. 
 His remarks, during his recent US tour, were shown only days after Pravda reprinted &mdash; and then apologised for &mdash; an Italian newspaper article accusing him of drunkenness and high-living during the trip. 
 Afghan rockets 
 By AHMED RASHID 
 KABUL &mdash; Fifteen mujahedin rockets slammed into residential areas of Kabul over the weekend, killing 10 people and wounding 27, writes Ahmed Rashid. 
 Heavy fighting was also reported around the city of Khost. 
 The government said three soldiers were killed in a nearby village, and 41 guerrillas died in a retaliatory attack. 
 Party time 
 By AHMED RASHID 
 BULAWAYO, ZIMBABWE (Reuter) &mdash; Joshua Nkomo, 72, threw a huge birthday and 40th wedding anniversary party at the weekend and President Robert Mugabe was there to seal the unity between the former rivals. 
 During the two-day festivities at Barbourfields stadium, politicians and business leaders, city workers and Matabeleland villagers, ate and mingled. 
 Iran quake 
 By AHMED RASHID 
 TEHRAN (AFP) &mdash; At least 300 homes were destroyed in an earthquake which shook the south-western Iranian town of Sisakht on Mount Dena early yesterday, the news agency IRNA reported. 
 Most of the damage was caused by landslides. 
 Japan poll 
 By AHMED RASHID 
 TOKYO (Reuter, AFP, AP) &mdash; Japan's Prime Minister, Toshiki Kaifu, scored an important victory in a parliamentary by-election in Ibaraki prefecture, north of Tokyo, yesterday. 
 Thus, Mr Kaifu is likely to be re-elected president of his Liberal Democratic Party next month, and retain the post of prime minister. 
 Turnaround 
 By AHMED RASHID 
 ISLAMABAD (Reuter, AP) &mdash; The Queen has sent a message to Pakistan, welcoming its formal return to the Commonwealth. 
 Nicholas Barrington has ceased to be Ambassador, and is now High Commissioner. 
 When the plaque on the home of the &bquo;British Ambassador&equo; was removed, the words &bquo;Residence of the British High Commissioner&equo; were found on the back, a relic from 1972 when Pakistan left the Commonwealth in protest at its recognition of Bangladesh. 
 Libyan medal 
 By AHMED RASHID 
 NICOSIA (Reuter) &mdash; Libya has awarded Charles De Gaulle the medal of the Great al-Fateh Revolution for campaigning to free France from &bquo;American imperialist domination&equo;. 
 Outback protests 
 By AHMED RASHID 
 SYDNEY (Reuter) &mdash; Police arrested more than 200 anti-nuclear protesters at a military base in the south Australian outback yesterday, bringing the total detained to nearly 500 in three days of protests. 
 Chemical Mace was used against the demonstrators at the US-Australian communications installation at Nurrungar, and the police were backed up by 50 unarmed soldiers. 
 Talks with ANC held in Britain 
 By JOHN BULLOCH 
 LONDON &mdash; A group of prominent white South Africans, including Wimpie de Klerk, brother of President FW de Klerk, began a series of meetings with the banned African National Congress in Britain yesterday, writes John Bulloch. 
 The ANC team was led by Thabo Mbeki, the organisation's chief of information and the man regarded as a likely successor to Oliver Tambo. 
 Reports in South Africa said a number of members of the Broederbond, the secret Afrikaner pressure group, were included in the talks, as well as individuals known to be close to Gerrit Viljoen, the Constitutional Planning Minister. 
 It is his task to try to involve black leaders in negotiations on constitutional reform. 
 Kohl party expected to lose again 
 By JOHN BULLOCH 
 BONN (Reuter) &mdash; Chancellor Helmut Kohl's Christian Democrats suffered their fourth successive election setback this year in voting yesterday in North Rhine-Westphalia, West Germany's most populous state. 
 Computerised projections showed the party's share of the vote for regional and city councils had fallen to 37.9 per cent from 42.2 per cent in 1984. 
 The Social Democrats increased their share slightly to 43.1 per cent from 42.5. 
 The World This Week 
 By FIONA LENEY 
 THERE WILL be little cause for celebration when East Germany marks the 40th anniversary of its founding on Saturday. 
 The government is planning lavish festivities to entertain all the friends that it claims to have. 
 But the jamboree could well turn into one of those parties where half the guests fail to turn up, and everyone else tries terribly hard to pretend that they are having a marvellous time. 
 Unsurprisingly, among the &bquo;friends&equo; attending will be the Romanian President, Nicolae Ceausescu, and the Czechoslovak leader, Milos Jakes. 
 The Chinese will also be represented, by their Vice-Prime Minister, Yao Yilin. 
 More interesting will be the presence of Mikhail Gorbachev, whose reforms are viewed with disapproval and alarm in East Berlin. 
 Also attending will be Poland's President, Wojciech Jaruzelski, considered by East Germany as one of Communism's sounder sons who has gone lamentably astray in handing power over to non-Communists. 
 A different sort of jamboree, arguably of greater use to mankind, kicks off in Oslo on Thursday, when the Nobel Peace Prize is announced. 
 One of the candidates this year is the entire population of Peking, apparently in keeping with the tradition of off-beat nominees for the prize. 
 The 1989 awards are each worth &pound;300,000, 20 per cent more than last year, due to particularly good returns on investments made by the Nobel Foundation. 
 Hungary's Communist Party is expected to formalise radical political and economic changes at its special congress on Friday. 
 The congress has been brought forward by a year, in what is being interpreted as a victory for the leader of the reformist wing of the party, Imre Pozsgay. 
 He is reportedly hoping to oust Karoly Grosz as General Secretary. 
 The party may well face further depletion with the expected defection of some members to set up yet another social democratic opposition party. 
 Mr Grosz, 59, has been overtaken, some would say swamped, by the wave of reforms he unleashed after displacing Janos Kadar as Hungarian leader in May 1987. 
 Now he finds himself in the same position as his predecessor &mdash; a relative conservative whose time is past. 
 The Pope, a conservative whose grip on the reins of power has never been firmer, is setting off on a tour of the Far East on Friday. 
 He will start in Seoul, where he is to officiate at the 44th International Eucharistic Congress. 
 He will also celebrate mass for about one million Korean faithful and 20,000 clergy members and laymen from 120 foreign countries in a ceremony on Sunday. 
 The Pope is expected to meet President Roh Tae Woo. 
 A more controversial moment may come when he visits East Timor, since the Vatican refuses to recognise the annexation of the island by Indonesia. 
 The Soviet Defence Minister, Dmitri Yazov, visits the Pentagon today for a meeting with the US Defence Secretary, Dick Cheney. 
 His visit is the first by a Soviet defence minister to the US. 
 He is due to get a comprehensive view of the country this week, from watching marines train in California and visiting the 82nd Airborne Division in North Carolina, to a touch of military tourism on the site of the Civil War battlefield at Gettysburg. 
 EC foreign ministers, meeting today, have already drawn up their battle-lines over the much-vexed topic of safeguarding European culture on television. 
 They will be debating a European Commission directive which only calls on EC television stations to screen a majority of European programmes, where possible. 
 The British, perhaps sensitive to intense American lobbying over the issue, want to adopt the directive as it stands. 
 The French want a mandatory minimum level imposed of 60 per cent of programmes made in Europe. 
 If no accord is reached by Friday, the directive will die anyway, under a time limit rule. 
 Botswana goes to the polls on Saturday, when seven parties will contest 34 seats in the country's single chamber. 
 President Quett Masire is expected to be nominated again as the presidential candidate of the Botswana Democratic Party, which has ruled since independence in 1966. 
 Finally, a special celebration takes place on Friday, when the famous Parisian cabaret, The Moulin Rouge, celebrates its 100th birthday. 
 Genscher cheered as 4,000 refugees leave for the West 
 From EDWARD LUCAS in Prague 
 EARLY yesterday morning, the increasingly squalid West German embassy in Prague finally disgorged its cargo of more than 4,000 dirty, dazed and exhausted East German emigrants. 
 Conditions and hopes at the embassy had been declining rapidly, given the apparent reluctance of Czechoslovakia to contemplate even a temporary humanitarian solution to ease the overcrowding. 
 Early on Saturday evening, however, while Prague seemed sunk in its customary weekend torpor, West Germany's veteran foreign minister, Hans-Dietrich Genscher, arrived unannounced, hotfoot from the United Nations. 
 From a balcony overlooking the embassy grounds, and to wild cheering from the thousands of would-be emigrants in the &bquo;tent village&equo; below, he announced all those staying in the embassy would be allowed to leave immediately for the West. 
 The deal Mr Genscher struck with his East German counterpart, Oskar Fischer, remains as unexplained as it was unexpected. 
 Many of the East Germans assumed West Germany had again dug into its pocket to &bquo;buy out&equo; East Germans seeking to come to the West. 
 Better informed sources suggested Soviet pressure on East Germany was responsible for the climbdown. 
 Others pointed to the inevitable and embarrassing shadow the embassy occupation would have cast over next weekend's celebrations of the 40th anniversary of the founding of East Germany. 
 But the questions were forgotten in a scramble to cram grubby possessions into muddy rucksacks and carrier bags, and then stream out of the embassy to queue for buses in the long, cobbled, dimly-lit street. 
 For some, it was the first step outside the embassy grounds for three months. 
 An end-of-term atmosphere, tempered by extreme exhaustion, prevailed. 
 People embraced and wept, promising to stay in touch, only to realise in some cases that they had no addresses to exchange. 
 Some sang &bquo;Auld Lang Syne&equo;, and &bquo;Tannenbaum&equo;. 
 West German tourists and Czechoslovaks gathered on street corners to cheer and wave as seven chartered Czechoslovak buses began many hours of ferrying the East Germans to the distant suburban rail terminus where trains arrived through the night to take them to West Germany. 
 Women with children were in the first buses. 
 Even when, after several hours, the majority of emigrants had set off, a group of young men wearing track suits remained in darkness at the back of the embassy, helping the most recent arrivals over the railings. 
 At Liben railway station in the northern outskirts of Prague, East Germans queued cheerfully in drizzle for more than an hour to enter the departure hall. 
 Most were content to contemplate their deliverance, but some were more boisterous. 
 Young men carrying home-made West German emblems chanted &bquo;Long Live Germany, Long Live Genscher&equo;. 
 Few appeared perturbed at beginning a new life in such unusual circumstances. 
 Many of the emigrants are skilled workers confident of their job prospects. 
 By far the greatest worries were those of divided families. 
 A small group was reported to have stayed in the embassy in the hope of avoiding separation from friends or family en route from East Germany. 
 Yesterday morning the police, conspicuous but inactive in past weeks, blocked East German latecomers from access to the embassy garden. 
 The embassy grounds, emptied of their temporary visitors, were unrecognisably battered. 
 The once crowded white and khaki tents sagged emptily over mud. 
 A sour smell of overcrowded humanity hung in the air. 
 The embassy gardener is said to be planning &bquo;to start again'. 
 Prayers and protest over Chernobyl 
 From EDWARD LUCAS in Prague 
 MINSK (Reuter) &mdash; A thousand people packed the main Catholic church here yesterday to pay tribute to victims of the Chernobyl nuclear disaster, a day after an unprecedented protest march through the city. 
 Kalvariskii Church overflowed with people, many wearing armbands with radioactivity symbols. 
 They sang hymns and said a prayer for the 31 people who died and those who suffered from radiation in the April 1986 accident. 
 &bquo;We must not forget the sufferings that occurred,&equo; the priest, Yan Adamovich, told the congregation in Polish and Byelorussian. 
 Hundreds of people stood outside unable to get in. 
 Similar services were scheduled for later in the day in the Byelorussian capital's two Orthodox churches. 
 On Saturday, more than 15,000 demonstrators ignored an official ban and rain to march through Minsk demanding local authorities do more to clean up the Chernobyl accident. 
 For four hours they chanted &bquo;Down with (Yefrem) Sokolov&equo; -the republic's party chief &mdash; and cheered calls for the prosecution of those running the republic's government at the time of the disaster. 
 Around 100,000 people were evacuated from the Ukraine and Byelorussia immediately after the disaster, but Byelorussian activists say this was not nearly enough. 
 Latecomers who continue to hope 
 From ANNE APPLEBAUM in Warsaw 
 DOZENS more East German refugees arrived outside the West German embassy yesterday seeking asylum and passage to the West, including some who missed by only a few minutes a train that took more than 800 of their compatriots to West Germany. 
 Many of the new arrivals, who waited in the street outside the embassy, said they were convinced there would be another train for them. 
 The one they missed pulled out from Warsaw's East Station at 2.50am yesterday carrying 809 cheering East Germans bound for the Rhine region of West Germany. 
 Once upon a time another German government let Lenin cross another Germany in a sealed train on his way to Russia. 
 More than 80 years later, Lenin's heirs are allowing refugees from their Communist regime escape in the opposite direction, in an East German-made train travelling across East German territory. 
 Among those leaving was Cornelia, 22, a young East Berliner destined, she said, for West Berlin via a very circuitous route. 
 &bquo;I still don't know if my family know where I am or if they will suffer from my decision. 
 But I saw no other way out: I didn't know if I would ever have a chance again.&equo; 
 Some of the refugees had been living in Polish exile for as long as seven weeks, while others arrived only a few hours before West German diplomats announced they could leave. 
 Only two failed to go: a new mother and her child, who was born in a Polish hospital four days ago. 
 The East German government's decision to let the refugees leave across their own country came as a surprise to many, including some West German diplomats. 
 Some of the refugees originally refused to touch East German territory again, but were reassured when two of the West German diplomats said they would accompany the train, to ensure that the rules were followed. 
 During the journey, East German officials will enter the train, and collect all East German passports. 
 West Germans will then issue new ones. 
 Legally, the refugees have been expelled from East Germany, meaning that under current rules they cannot return. 
 According to unofficial reports, the arrangement was designed by the West German Foreign Minister, Hans Dietrich Genscher, the new Polish foreign minister, Krzystof Skubiszewski, and the Soviet Foreign Minister, Eduard Shevardnadze, who met recently at the United Nations in New York. 
 Communists allow burial of Montenegro's last king 
 From MARCUS TANNER in Cetinje, Yugoslavia 
 THE PEOPLE of Montenegro yesterday welcomed home the remains of Nicholas I, their first and last king, after 70 years' exile in Italy, in belated fulfilment of his last will and testament. 
 Thousands of Montenegrins, many in national costume, waited at the quayside in Bar for the Italian warship that would bring him home. 
 Then they formed a slow procession behind the coffin into the mountains to the old royal capital of Cetinje for his reburial in the monastery there. 
 What was surely the last ever Montenegrin &bquo;royal event&equo; was masterminded by the republic's new Communist leadership, which has abruptly stopped describing Nicholas as a class enemy, to ride the same wave of popular patriotism and royal fervour which swept Serbia in the recent celebrations of the 600th anniversary of the battle of Kosovo. 
 The latest biography now calls him &bquo;an outstanding statesman, warrior and man of letters&equo;. 
 &bquo;If I die abroad in exile, let my body rest in a temporary grave until my mortal remains be transferred to our dear homeland,&equo; said the Montenegrin President, Branko Kostic, reading the royal will and testament to the crowds in Cetinje Square, who carried flags and portraits of Nicholas and his queen, Milena. 
 &bquo;Today the people of Montenegro fulfill the wish of their first and last king guided by innate love and respect for their history,&equo; he went on. 
 &bquo;Our tourist organisations are counting on big profits,&equo; said Srdan Darmanovic, a member of the Montenegrin Central Committee. 
 &bquo;This will be good for the Montenegrin economy too.&equo; 
 Montenegro's young and go-ahead leadership, which came to power this year amid furious popular dissatisfaction with the &bquo;old men in grey suits&equo;, sponsored the gathering of Nicholas's surviving relatives &mdash; the first &bquo;royal reunion&equo; organised by a Communist government. 
 &bquo;A letter dropped through the post from the President of the Socialist Republic of Montenegro, inviting me to the funeral,&equo; said John Kennedy, a Conservative Party member who lives in Barking and is a distant relative of Nicholas. 
 Montenegro's sudden rehabilitation of Nicholas's memory is a popular move. 
 &bquo;He liberated us from the Turks and fought for our independence,&equo; said a small boy who waited at the quayside amid a jostling crowd of former monarchs, visiting Serbian bishops and television crews. 
 Marko Radoman, 103, and a veteran of both Balkan wars, was given a place at the front as one of the few with personal memories of Nicholas's reign. 
 For a man whom Rebecca West, a contemporary Balkan observer, called &bquo;repulsive&equo; and &bquo;treacherous&equo; for deserting his Serbian son-in-law, King Alexander, in the First World War, it is a sepia-tinted view of history. 
 Nicholas was known as &bquo;the uncle of Europe&equo; for his success in marrying his beautiful but penniless daughters into the grander royal houses of Russia, Serbia and Italy. 
 This furthered his long-term ambition to rule a large &bquo;south Slav&equo; kingdom when the Ottoman Empire finally collapsed. 
 One daughter, a grand duchess of Russia, even gained a footnote in history by introducing an unknown monk, Rasputin, to the Russian Tsarina Alexandra. 
 In his minute, inaccessible capital, which today has only 15,000 inhabitants, Nicholas erected a miniature European court and an exquisitely furnished Victorian palace. 
 He even persuaded 12 European powers to turn cottages into full embassies. 
 It was a fair achievement in a town which an earlier observer described as &bquo;44 hovels&equo;. 
 But Nicholas's grand design collapsed in 1918 when his Serbian son-in-law, Alexander, deposed him and incorporated Montenegro into Yugoslavia. 
 For church and state it's divorce &mdash; Italian style 
 From MICHAEL SHERIDAN in Rome 
 EVEN THOSE students of Italian Catholic politics enchanted by Byzantine matters are nostalgic this autumn for the days when schism was a simple affair. 
 Important changes are afoot within the network of personal relationships which have cemented state and church power in Italy since the war. 
 The church hierarchy, which daily seems to see less that is Christian in the Christian Democrat party, is divorcing itself from its traditional allies. 
 Ironically, it is the proconsuls of that great exemplar of Vatican influence, Giulio Andreotti, Prime Minister for the sixth time, who are exciting church disapproval. 
 His faction has triumphed over the reformist elements of Christian Democracy, headed by the ousted leader and premier, Ciriaco De Mita. 
 In the sweetness of victory, Mr Andreotti's Roman cohorts have forgotten that they are mortal and, in the eyes of many churchmen, their greed and arrogance now risk bringing Catholic politics into disrepute. 
 The Pope's Vicar of Rome, Cardinal Ugo Poletti, has taken to scolding the Christian Democrats for their divisions which may bring victory for the secular parties and the Communists in city elections on 29 October. 
 A public rift in Catholic politics surfaced last week when the Communion and Liberation movement severed its ties with a powerful weekly magazine, Il Sabato, run by Andreotti supporters. 
 The magazine exploited popular Catholic themes, such as anti-abortion campaigning and family values to channel middle-class resentment into a political movement. 
 The movement promoted single-issue politics but invariably delivered its machine vote to the Christian Democrats. 
 The Pope's initial enthusiasm for its stridency has waned, as has his toleration for the way Rome is governed beyond the Vatican walls. 
 &bquo;A place with corners that resemble the Third World&equo; was his verdict this year on the city's mixture of new private affluence and public squalor, its Mafia-like interest groups and its grotesque inefficiencies. 
 His newspaper, L'Osservatore Romano, spared no criticism of the Christian Democrats who divided the spoils in city hall. 
 The mayor, Pietro Giubilo, had to quit in the face of corruption allegations involving companies linked to Communion and Liberation. 
 He was never more than the creature of Mr Andreotti's key fixer, Vittorio &bquo;The Shark&equo; Sbardella. 
 Yet Mr Andreotti moved smoothly into the premiership. 
 One senses that people do not trifle with &bquo;The Shark&equo;, whose background is in the seedier recesses of legal neo-fascism. 
 Between the embarrassment of frank sleaziness, the vicious campaigns of Il Sabato against Mr De Mita (then a serving prime minister) and the evidence of its own eyes, the Italian church began distancing itself from both Communion and Liberation and Mr Sbardella. 
 Frightened, Communion and Liberation has now disowned Il Sabato, removing its directors and leaving the weekly in the hands of Mr Sbardella. 
 The Bishops applauded. 
 Mr Andreotti's supporters may triumph in the elections. 
 But their patron, though ensconced in the Prime Minister's palace, is clearly more estranged from the mainstream of Catholic politics than at any time in his 40-year career. 
 It is a sin for which neither absolution nor salvation may readily be forthcoming. 
 Bush's tax cut tests Democratic mettle 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Washington 
 DEMOCRATIC leaders will make desperate attempts this week to prevent President Bush from claiming a Congressional majority for conservative economic policies, similar to the one enjoyed by President Reagan in his early years. 
 The Democratic leadership in the Senate is anxious to reverse the handsome victory by Mr Bush in the House of Representatives last week, when 64 Democrats voted with the Republicans to sweep through a two-year cut in capital gains taxes. 
 Senator George Mitchell of Maine, the Democratic majority leader in the Senate, said yesterday that he was confident that the senior house of Congress would dismantle the temporary tax cut. 
 Congressional officials predict, however, that a truncated version of the tax break will pass the Senate this week, allowing the White House to trumpet a one-two victory over the relatively untried Democratic leadership on Capitol Hill. 
 Such a victory would also permit Mr Bush to claim a Republican-conservative Democrat working majority in Congress for his &bquo;no new taxes, growth will solve everything&equo; economic policy. 
 It would, however, leave prospects for medium-term, or even short-term, progress in solving the federal budget deficit more confused than ever. 
 The dispute has left the bipartisan efforts to reduce the deficit in, at least temporary, tatters. 
 The Republicans claim that the capital gains cut (from 28 per cent to 19.6 per cent for two years) would stimulate investment and create jobs. 
 The Democratic leaders insist that the cut is an unwarranted giveaway to the wealthy which will have no significant effect on the economy and deepen the deficit. 
 In reality, the squabble is more over slogans and symbols left over from the Reagan years than anything substantial. 
 This begs the question why the Democrats and the White House are staging such a divisive quarrel, at a time when agreement on a deficit-cutting budget for 1990 is already overdue (the nominal deadline passed yesterday). 
 Some pundits suggest that the capital gains tax battle is a shrewd White House softening-up exercise for an even more aggressive assault on the Democratic leaders in the next two to three weeks, designed to force a 1990 deficit-cutting agreement on Republican terms. 
 This flies in the face of the cautious nature of the Bush administration. 
 Congressional sources believe the White House saw the chance for a quick, psychologically valuable victory over the Democratic leaders. 
 Ecuador holds drug lord 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Washington 
 BOGOTA (Reuter) &mdash; Colombia was reported yesterday to be seeking the extradition of a suspected cocaine baron held in neighbouring Ecuador as a wave of bombings, believed to have been carried out by drug traffickers, continued. 
 Police sent a five-man mission to Ecuador to bring back Evaristo Porras Ardila, the most important figure detained in the government's six-week crackdown, according to the daily El Tiempo. 
 Mr Porras, considered a chieftain of the Medellin cocaine cartel, was arrested on Thursday in the northern town of Tulcan, about 10 miles from the Colombian border, and was to be handed over to Colombian authorities &bquo;as a show of Ecuador's support&equo; for the drug crackdown, an Ecuadorean spokesman said. 
 News of Mr Porras's arrest followed the explosion of 13 bombs at the weekend, some of which damaged six schools in Bogota. 
 Two teenage girls and a woman were hurt. 
 In Medellin, a three-week lull in bombings was broken on Saturday night when a dynamite blast damaged two telephone control boxes. 
 Baby deaths &bquo;due to crack&equo; 
 By JOHN LICHFIELD 
 WASHINGTON &mdash; The city's infant mortality rate has surged to the level of some Third World countries, largely as a result of cocaine-addiction among young women, writes John Lichfield. 
 Some 169 Washington babies died before their first birthday in the first six months of this year, bringing the capital's infant mortality rate to 32.3 deaths for every 1,000 live births, a 50 per cent increase on 1988. 
 This is more than triple the national average, itself one of the worst in the developed world. 
 Health officials blame the increasing use by women of crack, the smokable form of cocaine. 
 Smoking crack during pregnancy can cause low birth-weight, respiratory problems and premature labour. 
 In acute cases, the babies are born addicted to cocaine. 
 Officials also blame last year's Congress decision to ban the public funding of abortions in Washington. 
 They say drug-abusing mothers who would previously have had an abortion are bearing sickly babies with low chances of survival. 
 The city's baby death rate now compares with that of Argentina, Venezuela, Thailand and Paraguay. 
 Court Circular 
 By JOHN LICHFIELD 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 30 September: The Princess Royal this morning visited Hampshire and was received on arrival by the Deputy Lieutenant for Hampshire (Captain MPR Boyle). 
 Her Royal Highness, President of the Royal Yachting Association, attended the 1.3 Litre World Powerboat Championships and opened the Southampton Vessel Traffic Services Centre. 
 The Princess Royal travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 Major Nicholas Barne was in attendance. 
 1 October: The Prince of Wales attended a service in Dornoch Cathedral to celebrate the 750th anniversary of Dornoch Cathedral Parish. 
 Subsequently, His Royal Highness visited the Lawson Memorial Hospital, Golspie. 
 Commander Richard Aylard RN was in attendance. 
 1 October: The Princess Royal, Patron, Royal Lymington Yacht Club, this morning attended the X One-Design Class Division Invitation Race at Lymington, Hampshire and was received on arrival by the Vice-Commodore (Mr John Guillaume). 
 Her Royal Highness travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Princess of Wales, Patron, Help the Aged, attends the annual council meeting of HelpAge International at 77 Crouch End Hill, London N8. 
 The Princess Royal opens the new Hassy Carrot Growers' New Packhouse at Whitehall Farm, Iselham, Cambridgeshire; visits Lincolnshire; opens the new George Adams and Sons Factory at Spalding; visits the recording studios of the National Tape Magazine for the Blind at Lilac Cottage, New Bolingbroke; as President, National Agricultural Centre Rural Trust, opens a new housing development at Mareham-le-Fen; opens the extension to Kirkby on Bain Church of England Primary School; and this evening, as Patron, College of Occupational Therapists, attends a reception and dinner at St James's Palace. 
 The Duke of Kent, Vice Chairman of the British Overseas Board, visits Sweden and Finland. 
 The Duchess of Kent, as Patron, attends the launch of Cancer Relief Macmillan Fund's leaflet &bquo;Help is There&equo; as part of the Europe Against Cancer Year at London Weekend Television, South Bank Television Centre, London SE1. 
 Appointments 
 By JOHN LICHFIELD 
 Maj-Gen Sir Christopher Airy, to be Private Secretary to The Prince and Princess of Wales, in succession to Sir John Riddell. 
 Mr BGJ Canty, to be Governor of Anguilla, in succession to Mr GO Whittaker. 
 Admiral Sir Derek Reffell, to be Governor and Commander-in-Chief, Gibraltar, in succession to Air Chief-Marshal Sir Peter Terry. 
 Mr Christopher Starns, to be secretary of the British Importers Confederation. 
 Mr Angus Stewart Macdonald, to be a Crown Estate Commissioner, in succession to Sir Iain Mark Tennant. 
 Mr Oscar Henry Colburn, and Mr John Nigel Courtenay James, to be re-appointed. 
 Anniversaries 
 By JOHN LICHFIELD 
 On this day: Saladin entered Jerusalem, 1187; the Duke of York captured Alkmaar in the Netherlands, 1799; Rome became the capital city of Italy, 1870; Brigham Young, Mormon leader, was arrested for bigamy, 1871; the first Royal Naval submarine was launched at Barrow, 1901; the first rugby football match was played at Twickenham, 1909; Italy invaded Ethiopia, 1935; the liner Empress of Britain, bound for Canada with refugees, was sunk, 1940; the British Council received a Royal Charter, 1940; 338 people died when the Queen Mary liner collided with the British cruiser Curacao, which sank off the coast of Donegal, 1942; a new island, with a volcano at the centre, appeared off Fayal Island, Azores 1957; Guinea became an independent republic, 1958; the first London performance of the musical show Promises, Promises was presented, 1968. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 24 
 Obituary: Jean-Louis Tixier-Vignancour 
 By PATRICK MARNHAM 
 THE HIGHPOINT of the life of Jean-Louis Tixier-Vignancour came in 1968 when, against all odds, he saved the mutinous General Raoul Salan (head of the Organisation de L'Armee Secrete) from an expected death sentence for treason. 
 With his deep voice, crumpled face, huge nose and ears and streak of cruelty, Maitre Tixier-Vignancour willingly symbolised all that was most demonic about France's extreme right. 
 After a brilliant student career at the Sorbonne he was called to the Paris Bar in 1926. 
 He started in political life as he meant to go on, sympathising with &bquo;Action Francaise&equo; and making his first political gesture at the age of 26 as one of the threatening, right-wing mob who were driven back by police gunfire when they tried to storm the Chamber of Deputies in February 1934. 
 In July 1940, following France's military defeat and occupation by the German army, Tixier-Vignancour was one of the majority of deputies who abolished the Third Republic and voted plenary powers to Marshal Petain. 
 He was appointed to the post of &bquo;Deputy Secretary-General of Information&equo; in the Vichy regime but resigned in January 1941. 
 He was briefly interned by the Germans in Tunis, then liberated by the Americans. 
 He ended the War holding both the Croix de Guerre and the petainiste decoration, the &bquo;francisque&equo;. 
 In 1945 he was arrested by the new government and tried for collaborating. 
 This charge could not be proved but the military tribunal condemned him to 10 years absence from public life. 
 Tixier-Vignancour emerged from this period of enforced reflection with a deep loathing for General de Gaulle and when he returned to politics in 1955 he was one of the architects of the revival of the extreme right, using the popular cause of &bquo;Algerie Francaise&equo; as a rallying point. 
 When those who fomented civil war in Algeria were brought to trial, Tixier-Vignancour was the natural choice to defend them. 
 Four of his clients were executed, including Lt Degueldre, head of the Delta Commando and Col Jean-Marie Bastien-Thiry who nearly succeeded in blowing up General de Gaulle and his wife at Petit-Clamart in 1962. 
 As their advocate, Tixier-Vignancour had to accompany these four officers to the firing squad, thus witnessing a fate which might have been his own in 1945. 
 He was appalled by the experience. 
 He subsequently popularised his political movement, the &bquo;Rassemblement National&equo; with the memorable slogan &bquo;Against de Gaulle and Communism&equo;. 
 During the treason trials Tixier-Vignancour became notorious for a tactic known as &bquo;the defence of blackmail&equo; when he repeatedly threatened to call eminent witnesses such as General de Gaulle and the Prime Minister Michel Debre, hinting that they too were involved in criminal plots. 
 He pulled this trick once too often against Debre, and was horrified one morning to see the Prime Minister sitting in the witness box, waiting to be cross-examined. 
 Since Tixier-Vignancour did not actually have any questions to ask him he decided to bluff it out to the end. 
 &bquo;You are Michel Debre,&equo; he said in his most sardonic tones. 
 &bquo;That is correct.&equo; 
 'You are (even more menacingly) the Prime Minister of France.&equo; 
 'Yes'. 
 Long pause. 
 &bquo;Thank-you very much. 
 No more questions&equo;. 
 End of the defence of blackmail. 
 Tixier-Vignancour's success in retricting General Salan's punishment to life imprisonment in 1968 so angered President de Gaulle that he considered resignation. 
 By then &bquo;Tixier&equo; had taken his anti-Gaullist crusade to the point of running himself as a presidential candidate. 
 Without any proper party organisation he fought a brilliant campaign in 1965, canvassing the French throughout August &bquo;on every beach from Dunkirk to Menton&equo;. 
 He was eliminated in the first round, coming fourth behind de Gaulle, Mitterrand and Jean Lecanuet. 
 He promptly consigned his five per cent of the vote to Mr Mitterrand in the second round, a gift whch the Socialist candidate happily accepted. 
 With the death of Tixier-Vignancour a distinctive line of French politicians seems to have come to an end. 
 It can be traced directly back to the anti-Dreyfusard cause of the late nineteenth century. 
 Tixier-Vignancour declined to be described as &bquo;anti-semitic&equo; (he once sued Sam White of the Evening Standard for calling him this) but he was in no danger of winning a &bquo;righteous gentile&equo; award. 
 His political heirs include Jean Marie Le Pen, leader of the &bquo;Front National&equo; and the left-wing advocate Maitre Jacques Verges who attempted to revive the &bquo;defence of blackmail&equo; during the 1987 trial of the SS officer Klaus Barbie. 
 But neither of them can match the pungency of the original, an atmosphere of beaujolais, cigars and malevolence, and of political or legal plots being brewed in the all-night brasseries of Les Halles. 
 Tixier-Vignancour's declared hobby was collecting lead soldiers. 
 Obituary: Virgil Thomson 
 By PETER DICKINSON 
 VIRGIL THOMSON was a composer and writer of originality, courage and wit formed by a unique mixture of American and French influences. 
 Thomson was born in Kansas City in 1896, studied at Harvard, and then mostly lived in Paris until 1940. 
 His Missouri childhood gave him access to Baptist hymns and church music, but at Harvard he was introduced to the writings of Gertrude Stein and the music of Erik Satie. 
 These influences laid the foundations for the blend of the naive and the sophisticated which is the hallmark of Thomson's maturity. 
 Like many young American composers he studied with Nadia Boulanger, but after 1925 set out to achieve the &bquo;discipline of spontaneity&equo; which he found in Stein's writings. 
 When he collaborated directly with her in opera the result was of historical significance. 
 First came Four Saints in Three Acts, produced in 1934, and then The Mother of Us All (1947), which demonstrated a new kind of plotless opera only now reaching a wider currency through the stage works of Philip Glass. 
 In Four Saints Thomson's informality was given free reign since he first of all improvised the music at the piano then, when it stuck, wrote it down to a figured bass. 
 He said: &bquo;I had wondered whether a piece so drenched in Anglican chant (running from Gilbert and Sullivan to Morning Prayer and back) could rise and sail.&equo; 
 But the resulting mixture of hymns, folksy tunes and recitatives &mdash; at times of intoxicating banality &mdash; was a sensation. 
 The opera, like Gershwin's Porgy and Bess the following year, used an all-Black cast and the staging and choreography gave it a British connection since it was by Frederick Ashton. 
 The Mother of Us All shows more continuity, but again much depends upon production in what is still a largely non-narrative opera. 
 In 1936, three years before Aaron Copland, Thomson started writing film scores which were a model of unobtrusive clarity and pertinence, combining American materials to suit documentaries such as The Plow that Broke the Plains and The River with the musique d'ameublement approach of Satie. 
 His score for the film Louisiana Story was awarded the Pulitzer Prize in 1948. 
 Another response to a visual stimulus was Thomson's series of musical portraits of people such as Picasso and Aaron Copland. 
 The first of these was written in 1928 and they number about 150. 
 Just as Thomson transferred Stein's literary abstraction to music, so these portraits unusually employ the painter's technique of drawing the sitter from life: an ideal combination of Thomson's habit of immediate response with an actual subject. 
 The results are terse and sharply etched, like the best line drawings. 
 Thomson could control words with the same fastidiousness as notes. 
 He always felt that effective musical criticism began by being well written, and he never lost his liveliness. 
 One never quite knew what he was going to say next. 
 He started by writing occasional articles but in 1939 he wrote The State of Music, a trenchant and provocative assessment of the machinery of the musical profession at the time. 
 From 1940 to 1954 he wrote regularly for the New York Herald Tribune and four volumes of his notices have appeared in book form. 
 He wrote a fulsome 400-page autobiography, characteristically entitled Virgil Thomson on Virgil Thomson, and a personal survey, American Music since 1910, appeared in 1972, followed recently by a selected edition of his letters. 
 As both composer and critic he touched both sides of the coin: A climate of receptivity is what the artist most desires. 
 It is also a thing that even the most experienced reviewer cannot always offer. 
 Thomson's judgements about music were not always as accurate as his confident expression implied: he invited discussion. 
 Above all he restored the focus of music criticism onto the music itself. 
 He made no secret of his Francophile enthusiasms, in reaction to the earlier domination of American music by Germans, and he was one of the first writers to register the importance of jazz. 
 He fearlessly attacked convention, which caused problems when he pitched into established reputations. 
 It has become increasingly apparent that Thomson belonged to the American experimental tradition. 
 He anticipated some of the enthusiasms of John Cage, whom he first met in 1941. 
 A few years later Thomson recognised Cage as &bquo;the most original composer in America, if not the world&hellip;&equo; and Cage repaid the compliment by writing the works section of a monograph on Thomson. 
 But finally, in spite of their common roots in Satie and Stein, Thomson felt that Cage's aesthetic was destructive. 
 Thomson's songs contain some of his finest work. 
 There are Stein settings, such as &bquo;Portrait of FB&equo;, but also cycles such as Five Songs from William Blake, Prayers and Praises and a cantata based on poems by Edward Lear. 
 Thomson was also prolific in instrumental music on both chamber and solo scale. 
 For many years Thomson lived in New York in his apartment at the Chelsea Hotel. 
 From there, like a buzzard in its eyrie, he would make forays round the US and abroad in spite of his advanced age. 
 He seemed a genial and indestructible landmark in the history of American music, in spite of defective hearing which had bothered him since the late Seventies. 
 He had a photograph of himself on his postcards and he signed his letters following the original tailpiece &bquo;everbest&equo;. 
 Thomson came from a generation of American composers which had to find its own way without benefit of university patronage. 
 In that kind of free market he thrived and survived &mdash; and so will the best of his work. 
 Obituary: Thomas Keller 
 By HUGH MATHESON 
 THOMI KELLER is the outstanding figure in the history of international rowing. 
 He was President of FISA (Federation Internationale des Societes d'Aviron), the world governing body, for 30 years; and most of this body's attitudes and practices reflect the force of his strict, but genial personality. 
 Most athletes first encountered him as a voice, bellowing in multi-lingual fury at officials who had broken rules or arrangements designed to make racing safer or more fair. 
 He was elected to succeed Gaston Mullegg as President of FISA when he was 33 and still competing in the Swiss rowing team. 
 He did not loosen his links with the athletes when projected upwards into the Presidency. 
 Provided their behaviour was sportsmanlike and safe, oarsmen found only encouragement and humour from a President who was always among them. 
 Keller's Zurich upbringing made him into a skiier and sculler, and he raced for the Grasshopper club. 
 He competed for the Swiss cross-country and ski-jumping team at the Student Winter Games and later concentrated on single sculls. 
 In 1950, he was Swiss sculls champion and finished third in the European championships before moving to Manila to work for his family's private multinational company, Eduard Keller Ltd, for four years. 
 On his return, Keller was Swiss champion again in 1955 and was bitterly disappointed when the Swiss chose to boycott the 1956 Olympics after the Russian intervention in Hungary. 
 FISA was then a relatively unimportant body which organised European and other championships and participated in the running of Olympic regattas. 
 As a rich, forceful young man, Keller had been earmarked as a likely future president, even before Mullegg was killed in an aircrash in 1958. 
 Rowing was transformed in the breadth and depth of participation over the 30 years of his term. 
 He sat on the appropriate boards of the International Olympic Committee and was President of the General Assembly of International Sports Federations for 17 years. 
 These positions were not held for his own status but to promote the cause of rowing where it needed clout. 
 He successfully defended rowing as an Olympic sport and in 1976 introduced women's events, which have now expanded to six classes. 
 His personal preference for sculling over rowing assisted the introduction of quadruple sculls to world championship and Olympic competition. 
 Keller was made a Steward of Henley Royal Regatta in 1976, a time when the proliferation of new six-lane, still-water courses around the world, which had emerged under his guidance, seemed a threat to the regatta founded in 1829. 
 But it was the spirit of Henley, with huge crowds enjoying amateur sport, presented with administrative finesse, which Keller took as the yardstick for the international circuit. 
 He loved the place and he returned every year to play an often small part as umpire of races between undistinguished clubs far below the Olympic standard he was obliged to administer. 
 He said this summer that as he gradually wound down his involvement in sport, Henley would be the last thing he would give up. 
 During his term as President of FISA he gradually reduced his role in Eduard Keller Ltd and used the company offices to provide a world headquarters for rowing. 
 The sport is now obliged to find income from the more normal sources of television and sponsorship, to replace his largely unacknowledged private patronage. 
 In spite of his gift to the sport, Keller was anxious not to abuse his status as President and never went to a rowing event unless invited. 
 Because of this, he had never seen the Oxford and Cambridge boat race until this year. 
 He was enthralled by the entire proceeding and remarked that only the English could make a contest between two crews which would not rank in the World's top 10 into a bigger spectacle than the Olympic final. 
 The final task he set himself for his Presidency, which was due to end next year, was to weed out of the Regatta calendar all the rowing courses which could be made unfair by the wind. 
 He had recently travelled from Tasmania to Norway in search of the perfect 2,000 metres of flat water. 
 It was a blessing that, in response to congratulations on the superb World Championship Regatta at Bled in Yugoslavia three weeks ago, he was able to reply, &bquo;Yes&hellip; and best of all, the conditions were fair throughout&equo;. 
 The Bar Conference: Donaldson sets the tone for battle over rights of audience 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 BARRISTERS could retain much of their monopoly over advocacy in the higher courts under a subtle agenda for discussion spelled out by Lord Donaldson, the Master of the Rolls, as he opened the Bar's annual conference in London at the weekend. 
 Signalling the beginning of a lower-key campaign against the plans of the Lord Chancellor, Lord Mackay of Clashfern, to give increased rights of audience in the High and Crown court to solicitors, Lord Donaldson called on the Bar to put aside the &bquo;trauma, the acrimony and the recriminations&equo; which followed Lord Mackay's Green Papers and to abandon the hustings. 
 Lord Donaldson said objectives due to be included in this autumn's Bill were &bquo;total freedom of choice for the client, unless the interests of justice otherwise require&equo;. 
 &bquo;When those concerned turn their attention to this problem, they may find they have to make a distinction between litigation in which there is a direct public interest in the result and that in which the public interest is limited to ensuring that an adequate system of justice is available. 
 &bquo;In the first category we have criminal cases, judicial review and cases which involve matrimonial status and the welfare of children or those under a disability. 
 In many of them, particularly criminal cases, the interests of the client may be quite different from those of the public. 
 &bquo;In these cases the interests of justice may demand special requirements such as, for example, that the preparation and presentation of the case be in separate and independent hands&equo;. 
 In the second category, general civil cases, parties should be able to choose their own lawyers because the interests of justice would be inherently less likely to fetter the client's right of choice. 
 Lord Donaldson implied, however, that solicitors who exercised their new rights of audience in these cases ought to be expected to concentrate on advocacy. 
 While emphasising that he had not reached any firm conclusions, Lord Donaldson's voice will be a powerful one in behind-the-scenes manoeuvres as rules governing the exercise of the new advocacy rights are hammered out away from the parliamentary battlefield. 
 The rules will be drawn up by the Law Society &bquo;having regard&equo; to suggestions made by a new lay-dominated independent advisory committee on legal education and conduct. 
 They will have to be approved by the Lord Chancellor and be subject to the &bquo;concurrence&equo; of four senior Supreme Court judges, of whom Lord Donaldson will be one. 
 In practice, initial drafts of rules will be the subject of ongoing discussions between all four parties. 
 The four will have to have regard to the &bquo;interest of justice&equo; objective. 
 But on the other hand, the statute will also include a clear intention that extended rights of audience are put into practical effect as soon as the necessary conditions have been met. 
 A majority of judges said in their response to the Green Papers that standards of conduct and competence might decline if lawyers who worked in partnerships and took instructions directly from clients (most solicitors) were allowed widespread access to the higher courts. 
 Lord Donaldson's formula for settling the rights of audience controversy was viewed as an adept political move by some delegates. 
 Alternative dividing lines which have been informally mooted, such as simply restricting solicitor-advocates in Crown Court jury trials to the less serious cases, had been viewed as difficult to support as a matter of principle. 
 Lord Donaldson's remarks were greeted with cautious enthusiasm by Bar leaders. 
 Desmond Fennell, QC, the Bar's chairman, said that he was &bquo;greatly encouraged&equo; by Lord Donaldson's indication that the interests of justice objective would prevail. 
 Roger Henderson, QC, the Bar's public affairs spokesman, warned that the words used in the White Paper were open to different interpretations, but said: &bquo;Lord Donaldson has plainly interpreted the White Paper on the basis that there has been a major change from the Green Paper.&equo; 
 John Hayes, secretary general of the Law Society, said he regarded the entire matter as up for debate. 
 &bquo;We look forward to the discussions. 
 The Master of the Rolls has always been keen to find a middle way.&equo; 
 Lord Donaldson attacked the White Paper's suggestion that it might be in the public interest to allow other professions, such as accountants, to be given rights of audience in the courts. 
 The Bar Conference: Aid fund for injury claims &bquo;should be tested&equo; 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A TRIAL SCHEME should be set up to assess the validity of a contingent legal aid fund to finance personal injury claims for those too well-off to qualify for legal aid but too poor to pay fees, the conference was told. 
 Under the scheme, successful claimants would pay about 10 per cent of their winnings to a central fund which would meet the costs of unsuccessful claims. 
 George Pulman, QC, a member of the Bar Council's working party on contingent fees, told a conference workshop on financing litigation that unlike other forms of contingency fee arrangement, lawyers would have no personal interest in the outcome of litigation and there would be no &bquo;legal aid blackmail&equo; &mdash; where cases are legally aided the normal &bquo;costs follow the event&equo; rule does not apply and defendants have to meet their own costs even when they win. 
 In working out the percentage deduction from the damages of successful claimants, comparison should be made with trade union funded personal injury litigation where costs were paid to winning defendants. 
 &bquo;My initial inquiries suggest that a figure of significantly less than 10 per cent is a real possibility,&equo; Mr Pulman said. 
 Initial government money would be needed to get the scheme off the ground. 
 But Mr Pulman estimated that could be repaid within two years. 
 A four-year trial scheme should be set up using firms outside London specialising in actions for trade union members. 
 Legal Aid Board proposals to grant &bquo;franchises&equo; to selected solicitors' firms doing legal aid advice work under the &bquo;green form&equo; scheme will enable the board and lawyers to jointly improve the system, John Pitts, the board chairman, said. 
 In return for assurances of service to a defined quality, franchised firms would enjoy benefits such as easier administration, devolved responsibility for some aspects of case management, and faster payment. 
 John Hayes, secretary-general of the Law Society, said the advantages ought to apply to all solicitors and the board should not seek to produce artificial criteria for selection. 
 &bquo;There should be a much higher threshold at which solicitors would need to consult the board. 
 The system I would like to see is solicitors being given the job of approving up to &pound;500 of legal aid work, with spot checks on quality, taking off any who are found to have abused it.&equo; 
 The means test for all legal aid work could also be simplified and handled directly by solicitors, again subject to careful spot check monitoring, Mr Hayes said. 
 The Bar Conference: Plea for new &bquo;lawyer-free&equo; hearings on small claims 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A LAWYER-FREE small claims procedure, easily operated by the do-it-yourself litigant and staffed by a new body of volunteer &bquo;civil justices&equo;, is needed to combat problems of cost and delay Lord Donaldson, the Master of the Rolls, said. 
 The new breed of civil justices would be similar to JPs in the criminal field but would act as arbitrators in county courts. 
 &bquo;The only qualifications they would need would be common sense, a judicial temperament and an elementary knowledge of the limited aspects of the law which are applicable to such disputes,&equo; Lord Donaldson said. 
 &bquo;At the risk of deeply shocking you, I have to say that in relation to small claims, we have to get rid of the lawyers.&equo; 
 They were &bquo;overqualified and not cost-effective for small cases&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;The aim must be to produce small claims procedures which can be understood and followed by the do-it-yourself litigant.&equo; 
 If assistance was needed it should be provided by the courts themselves, by Citizens Advice Bureaux or by similar agencies. 
 In the minority of cases where representation was really needed it should be provided by &bquo;para-legals&equo;, able to charge less, in line with their lower qualifications and overheads. 
 Lord Donaldson said afterwards that his proposal would not lead to a downgrading of justice. 
 &bquo;At the moment county court registrars are often just using their common sense, not their knowledge of law. 
 I can't see why the ordinary housewife shouldn't do it.&equo; 
 He predicted there would be no shortage of volunteers, who could acquire the necessary skills on short courses. 
 &bquo;There is nothing so fascinating as other people's disputes.&equo; 
 The system outlined by Lord Donaldson, a man not known for his left tendencies, bears marked similarities to those operated in a number of eastern bloc countries. 
 The drift of his remarks is likely to find favour with the Lord Chancellor, Lord Mackay of Clashfern, who said last year that many litigants wanted fuller participation in the legal process rather than acting as bystanders in cases conducted by lawyers. 
 Lord Donaldson then attacked Lord Mackay's White Paper proposals for banks and building societies to undertake conveyancing. 
 Although the near-monopoly enjoyed by solicitors was indefensible because it related only to the preparation of documents, &bquo;there is a real need for consumer protection and I am far from sure that the White Paper proposals meet this need,&equo; he said. 
 Conveyancing documents should include a certificate by the purchaser saying either that he had been fully advised by a wholly independent practitioner or that he had declined such advice &mdash; and the certificate should contain a prominent &bquo;health warning&equo; against declining to take it. 
 The Bar Conference: Commercial judges &bquo;need highest pay&equo; 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 JUDGES in the Commercial Court should get higher salaries than other High Court colleagues, the conference heard. 
 There was a pressing need for more judges to help to reduce increasing delays, Richard Williams, a solicitor, said. 
 &bquo;The unedifying scramble for a free judge causes great embarrassment to solicitors vis-a-vis their clients.&equo; 
 Extra appointments could be financed by the court's customers paying higher charges when cases were set down for trial. 
 A more difficult problem was ensuring the extra judges were of a sufficiently high calibre. 
 &bquo;If more judges are required because of the greater degree of litigious activity it is logical to assume that those successful counsel of high calibre who would be candidates for judge's office would find it economically more gratifying to remain as advocates&equo;, he said. 
 Bearing in mind the commercial raison d'etre of the court, there was a case for paying its judges more than those in other divisions. 
 There could also be a Commercial Court of Appeal with its own, higher paid, judges. 
 Mr Williams said delay was the main complaint solicitors faced from clients. 
 The Bar Conference: Children's recollection usually reliable says psychiatrist 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 RESEARCH shows that a child's recall is usually accurate, and errors are of omission rather than commission, Dr Danya Glaser, a consultant child psychiatrist, said. 
 But this does not ensure credibility, which is related to the way the child's account is obtained. 
 &bquo;If details are requested which, from the child's point of view, are peripheral to the event and therefore not recalled, the child may feel obliged to fabricate one.&equo; 
 Research had found that even very young children do not &bquo;go along&equo; with erroneous suggestions concerning the essence of their experiences. 
 It was vital to take account of children's cognitive and emotional responses when evaluating their evidence. 
 &bquo;Denial is present in 85 per cent to 90 per cent of cases. 
 It is in this context that a reticent, hesitant and anxious account, sometimes followed by a retraction, is likely to be credible,&equo; she said. 
 The Bar Conference: Barristers in sex trials defended 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 REPEATED attacks on cross-examination by defence barristers of the victims of alleged sexual offences were misplaced and naive, David Cocks QC, chairman of the Criminal Bar Association, told the conference. 
 Cross-examination was &bquo;the greatest legal engine ever invented for the discovery of truth&equo;, he said. 
 Mr Cocks predicted that advocates would have to adapt their techniques in cases involving children and other vulnerable witnesses, but warned: &bquo;It would be disastrous for an excessive preoccupation with welfare to erode the defendant's rights and to undermine the role of his advocate.&equo; 
 The climate of opinion that children never lie about sexual abuse was &bquo;dangerous&equo;, he added. 
 Mr Cocks also criticised judges for making uninformed pronouncements about whether child witnesses were old enough to give evidence. 
 Under the Children and Young Persons Act 1933, judges must be satisfied that the child is of sufficient intelligence to justify the reception of the evidence and understands the duty of telling the truth. 
 In practice, children under the age of eight are rarely called as witnesses and judges still follow a 1958 House of Lords ruling that a jury could not attach any importance to the evidence of a child of five. 
 &bquo;This is a subject on which judges need, and should have, expert assistance from a clinical psychologist and not be left to flounder through what may be an ill-informed and perfunctory form of inquisition before the child gives evidence.&equo; 
 Mr Cocks went on to criticise video interviewing techniques of police and social workers. 
 &bquo;Might there not be a case for putting the initial interview in the hands of an educational psychologist skilled in eliciting a history without being committed to what the social workers revealingly call &bquo;disclosure&equo;? ', he suggested. 
 Once initial interviews with children had been videotaped, the prosecution should have the right to apply for a pre-trial hearing before the judge, in informal surroundings, at which the child could be examined and cross-examined. 
 But there were serious objections to using the videotaped interview as a complete substitute for the child's evidence in chief at the trial, because of the unsatisfactory nature of the questioning and because it would cause difficulties for the prosecution. 
 First Birdwatching Fair in Rutland Water, Leicestershire 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 Some of the &bquo;twitchers&equo; at Britain's first Birdwatching Fair, held at Rutland Water in Leicestershire over the weekend. 
 Proceeds went to a campaign against the annual slaughter of 900 million migrating birds around the Mediterranean. 
 Contemporary Art Market: Paintings poised between Expressionism and Romanticism 
 By EDWARD LUCIE-SMITH 
 MUCH OF the painting in London commercial galleries hovers somewhere between Expressionism and a more traditional British Romanticism. 
 A good example is the William Tillyer show at Bernard Jacobson. 
 Tillyer sees nature as luscious and womb-like. 
 The way he interprets it owes a lot to the work of the late Ivon Hitchens, who used a similar technique, with broad swirls and patches of paint, and little attention to details. 
 The exhibition indicates that Tillyer's work has been moving away from Hitchens and closer to American landscape-abstractionists, notably Helen Frankenthaler. 
 Some of the pictures are American in scale &mdash; very much bigger than anything he has shown before &mdash; and this makes the resemblance more apparent. 
 (Prices from &pound;7,000-&pound;40,000). 
 Kark Weschke, at the Redfern Gallery, is Expressionist in a more orthodox fashion &mdash; not surprisingly, since he was born in Germany in 1925 and did not come to England until 1948. 
 His painting, now, is a slightly odd mixture of German and British influences. 
 One very ambitious painting, of Gordale Scar, challenges recollection of the huge romantic canvas showing the same spot, painted by the early nineteenth-century British Romantic artist James Ward and now in the Tate Gallery. 
 Other canvases, such as Weschke's awkward but powerful version of Europa and the Bull, are much closer to German Expressionism of the pre-First World War variety. 
 (Paintings from &pound;7,000-&pound;12,000. 
 Drawings from &pound;500-&pound;1,200). 
 Agnew's has an exhibition by the Yorkshire artist Len Tabner. 
 Most of the works are either pastels, often with the addition of charcoal and graphite, or watercolours. 
 There are seascapes, bleak, upland landscapes and industrial scenes. 
 All are themes Turner might have used and Tabner is clearly conscious of his example. 
 David Brown, in an introduction to the show, also suggests an affinity with the Scottish painter, William McTaggart (1835-1910). 
 This is appropriate in more ways than one, since, like McTaggart, Tabner has remained somewhat apart from the more experimental tendencies of his time. 
 But there are many good things here, nevertheless - these are skillful, powerful drawings, which impress by their sure sense of rhythm. 
 (From &pound;1,000-&pound;9,000). 
 The Scottish Gallery has an exhibition of paintings by Roderick Carmichael, an Edinburgh-born artist who has spent the last 10 years in Australia. 
 Few of the canvases are primarily concerned with landscape, but it tends to find its way into most of them. 
 The technique and colour are Expressionist, but the paintings also have a lingering hint of Pop Art because they are frequently concerned with symbolic objects. 
 A rather kitsch ceramic stool in the form of an elephant wearing a howdah is the chief image in a couple. 
 (From &pound;4,500-&pound;10,000). 
 Prisoners of war fund &bquo;is failing needy old soldiers&equo; 
 By JAMES DALRYMPLE 
 A FUND standing at about &pound;200,000 which was raised to give aid and comfort to homecoming British prisoners after the Second World War is alleged to be growing in direct proportion to the number of old soldiers dying without ever seeing a penny of it. 
 The fund, raised in 1944 in the Midlands, was invested by officials of the Royal Warwickshire Regiment and, apart from the stock market crash of two years ago, it has steadily increased. 
 In one 10-year period from the mid-1970s it rose from just over &pound;30,000 to nearly &pound;250,000, and analysts calculate that in 20 years - when all the men it was specifically designed to help will be long dead &mdash; it will be worth well over &pound;1m and increasing in value at more than &pound;100,000 a year. 
 Yet, the Labour MP Jeff Rooker claims, there have been examples of Royal Warwickshire prisoners of war seeking desperately needed help who have been given as little as &pound;25, while many more have been means-tested and found &bquo;unqualified&equo; for even basic financial assistance. 
 There has also been malpractice in the past by officials administering the fund, he claims, in which thousands of pounds were used to foot the bill for regimental social functions. 
 This was privately admitted by senior officers who took over the running of the fund two years ago, and after an inquiry by the Charity Commission more than &pound;3,000 was repaid from regimental funds. 
 Mr Rooker, MP for Perry Barr in Birmingham, discovered the existence of the POWs Fund in 1976 and publicised it in the Midlands. 
 He received about 20 letters from ex-regimental POWs who were in need; these were passed on to the regiment. 
 Mr Rooker said that the 20 letters resulted in only seven men receiving financial help. 
 The highest-paid got &pound;40 and the lowest-paid, &pound;25, in a payout of &pound;220 &mdash; even though the fund then stood at &pound;58,000. 
 Of the other 13 POWs, six were given nothing, five either died at that time or could not be traced, and two refused to submit to means testing. 
 &bquo;Some of these men had been so badly damaged, both physically and mentally, by their experiences on the battlefield and in POW camps that their lives were ruined.&equo; 
 Mr Rooker said money from the fund &bquo;simply never got to the people who needed it because it wasn't publicised enough and because the regimental administrators were inefficient. 
 Now it is standing at a huge sum, growing rapidly, and it is still not going where it is needed&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;The sane thing to do would be to take perhaps half of the total sum, make a determined effort to find every surviving POW, and share the money equally with them.&equo; 
 The man in charge of the fund, Brigadier Jimmy Chater, admitted that there had been problems with finding and helping Royal Warwickshire POWs, and agreed that the income from the fund exceeded the benefits paid out. 
 He said that some time ago the POWs fund was merged with a general purposes benefit fund for all old comrades of the regiment, but that POWs were given priority in any benefit payouts. 
 &bquo;I wish it were true that the fund will continue to grow, but we are at the mercy of the markets, and we must keep a healthy capital amount for all needy old soldiers down on their luck. 
 If we were to wind up the POWs fund and pay out the money once and for all to all POWs that we could find, we could run into severe problems in the next 10 to 15 years as these chaps get very old and need help even more. 
 &bquo;There were problems in the past with the way the fund was run, but when I took over a couple of years ago we took a very long look at our accounting system and put matters right. 
 &bquo;Now, we advertise repeatedly for any POWs who are in trouble, and we are only too pleased to help them. 
 I regret the allegation of means testing. 
 When we are asked for assistance we call in the Services&equo; social services people, the SSAFA (Soldiers', Sailors' and Airmen's Families Association), who decide what help is needed, and we provide it.&equo; 
 Whitehall Watch: Poacher turns gamekeeper to scrutinise Civil Service: Peter Hennessy talks to Sir Angus Fraser, head of the efficiency unit 
 By PETER HENNESSY 
 A YEAR ago Sir Angus Fraser took over from Sir Robin Ibbs as the Prime Minister's efficiency adviser and part-time head of her efficiency unit. 
 It was a tough assignment for two reasons. 
 First, Sir Robin and his team had developed, and persuaded ministers to adopt, the most radical plan &mdash; the so-called Next Steps &mdash; for restructuring the Civil Service in nearly 150 years. 
 No successor could hope for such an earth-moving tenure as that. 
 Secondly, Sir Angus was barely a year out of the Civil Service after a career which had taken him to the chairmanship of the Customs and Excise. 
 Wouldn't today's permanent secretaries rather resent one of their own returning to tell them how to overturn the habits of a lifetime? 
 Twelve months on, Sir Angus is not really worried on either score. 
 Preparing the Next Steps &mdash; the conversion of the Civil Service's businesses into executive agencies standing free of policy-making departments &mdash; tended to monopolise the attention of the efficiency unit with its tiny staff. 
 The Next Steps is now a separate project run by Peter Kemp in the Cabinet Office. 
 Renewing the emphasis on the unit's original raison d'etre created by Lord Rayner, the Prime Minister's first efficiency adviser &mdash; the scrutiny programme of efficiency studies &mdash; was necessary, Sir Angus said, as &bquo;it had taken a bit of a setback&equo;. 
 He is very pleased with the &bquo;good meaty topics&equo; departments have been suggesting for scrutiny this year. 
 He mentioned the Home Office-led investigation of state funding of the voluntary sector; the Department of Education's investigation of educational support grants, about &pound;650m worth, given to local education authorities for tasks deemed especially important; and the Department of Social Security's review of the shortfall of contributions to contributory benefits, amounting to nearly &pound;500m a year. 
 As for old colleagues resenting his intrusion on their territory: &bquo;Any external agent is going to be viewed with a certain amount of suspicion. 
 I haven't noticed it. 
 Having done the job myself, it helps me to understand that departments are being asked to review everything continuously. 
 It doesn't mean they get an easier ride, but it does mean I'm not going to be utterly unreasonable in the demands I make.&equo; 
 One thing Margaret Thatcher asked him to concentrate on in his Whitehall travels is the quality of departments' planning machinery. 
 This has been a focus of his first year and will be of his second. 
 Occasionally, the efficiency unit scrutinises itself. 
 So I asked Sir Angus to answer the basic questions he tells scrutineers to apply. 
 Every scrutineer begins by asking &bquo;What's it for?&equo; 
 Sir Angus replied: &bquo;We are for advising the Prime Minister, who is very interested in efficiency and effectiveness in the Civil Service. 
 We are for bringing outside analysis to departments along with the office of the Minister for the Civil Service and the Treasury. 
 The Treasury are the regulars. 
 We are the irregulars.&equo; 
 How much do you and your staff of eight cost? &bquo;&pound;374,000 a year.&equo; 
 Who are your customers? 
 &bquo;I am a servant of the Prime Minister. 
 In another sense, it's the departments with whom we work. 
 In another sense, it's the consumer or the taxpayer.&equo; 
 Is the efficiency unit necessary? 
 &bquo;It's necessary because the PM wants it. 
 The question is whether the same remit could be fulfilled by different means? 
 We find that being cast in the role of external stimulator does serve a useful function. 
 &bquo;If a department has an internal review it can get bogged down in internal considerations. 
 We guarantee high-level attention from the permanent secretary and the minister. 
 The results are less likely to seep into the sand.&equo; 
 Like everyone else in late 1980s Whitehall, the words &bquo;changing the culture&equo; are constantly on Sir Angus' lips. 
 That, he says, is what the Next Steps is all about: &bquo;It will succeed only if it changes the way business is done and accounted for.&equo; 
 Is it going to work? 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 When I left the Civil Service in 1987 I was rather pessimistic. 
 But the way it's moved on has been quite good. 
 I reckon it's pretty well irreversible.&equo; 
 Salary increases for managers average 11% 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT, Labour Editor 
 PAY RISES for managers are averaging 11 per cent, almost double the level of a year ago, and accelerating, according to research published today. 
 Those aged over 35 are receiving increases of 8.5 per cent, while younger colleagues are getting 12.9 per cent, the Reward Group reports in its biannual survey. 
 Younger, more mobile employees, on an average of &pound;13,700 a year, are enjoying bigger increases because companies are &bquo;desperate&equo; to keep them. 
 Older managers, on &pound;16,650, are regarded as more stable and having reached their &bquo;ceiling&equo;. 
 Overall, salary rises have almost doubled in a year. 
 The average increase reported in the March survey was 8.5 per cent. 
 In September last year it was 6.4 per cent. 
 Four regions were found to be above the average: Scotland, 12.2 per cent; the West Midlands 12 per cent; the South-west 11.6 per cent; and London 11.5 per cent. 
 Rates in the West Midlands, however, are still 8.3 per cent below the national average. 
 The biggest rises &mdash; about 12.6 per cent &mdash; are being won in smaller companies with a turnover of less than &pound;5m. 
 This suggests that such firms are reacting on a more ad hoc basis to pressure in the market, the report says. 
 The mechanical engineering sector has seen the largest increase, at 15.3 per cent, although pay is 7.3 per cent below the national average. 
 The &bquo;love affair&equo; with company cars is becoming more intense despite the Chancellor's best efforts. 
 Companies find it increasingly difficult to attract the right people in the &pound;14,000 to &pound;18,000 range unless they offer a car. 
 Two years ago, less than 25 per cent had a car, now almost 35 per cent. 
 The survey analysed nearly 21,000 salaries of senior managers to supervisors at more than 900 companies with a total workforce of 824,000. 
 Millions at risk in loan swap challenge 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 A High Court case starting today pits local authorities and the City's financial institutions against each other. 
 Millions of pounds are at stake and one side is certain to receive a bloody nose. 
 The legality of money market dealings by Hammersmith and Fulham Council in west London, which once amounted to exposure of &pound;5bn is being challenged by its auditor, Anthony Hazell, a partner in Deloitte Haskins and Sells, with the support of the Audit Commission, the local authority financial watchdog. 
 The council embarked on a series of complex and sophisticated manoeuvres, including interest rate swaps, swap options, and cash options which initially proved profitable &mdash; earning &pound;13m &mdash; but which would now result in massive losses. 
 Essentially, these manoeuvres are a way of managing debt to take advantage of interest rate changes, but the council went way beyond debt management into pure financial speculation. 
 There are 77 other local authorities playing the markets in a similar, though less extensive, way, and a similar number of financial institutions are involved. 
 All these transactions could be declared ultra vires, beyond the legal powers of local authorities and therefore invalid, if Hammersmith loses. 
 The judges could complicate matters by ordering that the outcome of the deals be reversed, necessitating a mind-numbing series of calculations by the City. 
 But, if Hammersmith wins and the deals are declared legal, the council will have to pay the losses on the transactions. 
 These have mounted because in February Nicholas Ridley, then Secretary of State for the Environment, stopped any new deals and Hammersmith's portfolio was largely weighted to the expectation that interest rates would be low, preventing the council from improving its position in the market. 
 The council had wound down its holdings from &pound;5bn to &pound;2bn but its advisers had backed the wrong horse by predicting low interest rates. 
 In an affidavit to be presented to the hearing, the auditor calculated that Hammersmith could lose &pound;74m at current levels of interest rate and &pound;186m if rates rose by 1 per cent. 
 Given that this sum represents more than half the council's average annual spending, the poll tax payers would be faced with a nightmare. 
 The council's fund established after Mr Ridley blocked the deals to pay back any losses is currently less than &pound;20m. 
 Fortunately for Hammersmith and its citizens, legal advisers for all parties concerned have been unequivocal, all suggesting a defeat for the council, which would mean Hammersmith would not have to pay the losses on the transactions. 
 The deals stretch back to 1983 when the council was run by a Conservative-Liberal coalition. 
 For several years the market playing was limited but early in 1988, finance officers began taking options out on a massive scheme. 
 The council's Labour leadership, who have been in control since 1986, have argued that they had no control over the transactions as the day to day running of the finance department is in the hands of expert financial staff. 
 Publicly the banks have suggested that there could be dire consequences for the City should the deals be ruled illegal. 
 They feel that as innocent parties they are being cheated. 
 However, insiders reckon that the councils will get away with it if Hammersmith loses. 
 While the banks may then try to sue the council or even individual officers the risk is very widely spread and no financial institution will be put in danger. 
 City schools face cash cuts 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 HARD-PRESSED inner city comprehensive schools are likely to lose thousands of pounds a year under government plans to devolve financial management to heads, one of the largest teachers' unions warns today. 
 However, comprehensives in relatively affluent rural and suburban areas will become richer. 
 A survey by the National Association of Schoolmasters/Union of Women Teachers reveals that under the new financing formula nearly 60 per cent of secondary schools will be less well funded and about 40 per cent better resourced. 
 The study of 1,544 secondary schools in 43 local education authorities in England and Wales shows 882 schools will lose nearly &pound;55m between them annually &mdash; an average of &pound;62,663. 
 In particular, the survey suggests 71 per cent of secondary schools in metropolitan authorities will lose money and that the average cut in Liverpool, Manchester, Rochdale, Salford and Derbyshire will be more than &pound;100,000 a school. 
 Fred Smithies, union general secretary, said that the redistribution of resources would result from budgets being calculated according to total pupil numbers instead of classes taught. 
 Budgets would also be calculated to meet average teaching costs &mdash; not reflecting actual staff salaries. 
 &bquo;The school curriculum will be devastated,&equo; Mr Smithies added. 
 &bquo;Pupils&equo; educational prospects will be blighted.&equo; 
 Leaders of the Association of University Teachers, representing university lecturers, are recommending a claim which would mean a 27 per cent pay increase for its 30,100 members. 
 The claim, drawn up by the national executive, will be discussed by a union council meeting on 14 October. 
 A MORI poll commissioned by the Independent Schools Information Service, representing most private schools, suggests 57 per cent of Labour supporters do not want such schools abolished. 
 A similar poll last year showed 52 per cent favoured retention. 
 The poll, of nearly 2000 adults, showed 72 per cent favoured the retention of independent schools. 
 Among trade union members 70 per cent were in favour, while 75 per cent of Green Party members opposed abolition. 
 Teachers ready to walk out in &bquo;oversize&equo; classes protest 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 TEACHERS in east London are set to walk out of schools today if asked to take classes which they believe are too large. 
 Members of the National Union of Teachers in Hackney and Tower Hamlets have voted, by a 95 per cent majority, to refuse to teach classes of more than 30 pupils. 
 The limit for first-year infants classes will be 27 and for classes of children of mixed ages, 24. 
 The action will affect 107 schools but it is not clear how many have what the union regards as oversized classes. 
 Shortages mean supply teachers are acting as permanent class teachers, leaving schools with no reserves to cover for sickness. 
 When staff are absent, a class is split between other teachers. 
 Hackney and Tower Hamlets are among the boroughs worst affected by shortages. 
 Inner London as a whole has 653 primary teacher vacancies. 
 Mike Loosley, general secretary of the Inner London Teachers' Association - the area union branch &mdash; said yesterday: &bquo;There's no getting away from the fact that a child sent home on a particular day as a result of our action will be suffering. 
 But our belief is that, in the long-term, we shall improve education because even this Government will see the need to pump in more money to get teachers.&equo; 
 It is estimated that about 75 per cent of the union's members in Hackney and Tower Hamlets voted in the ballot, supported officially by NUT national leaders. 
 Embryo Bill to be used in fight against abortion 
 By SARAH HELM, Home Affairs Correspondent 
 &bquo;PRO-LIFE&equo; campaigners pledged at the weekend to launch a &bquo;make or break&equo; drive to roll back the abortion laws. 
 Experts on both sides of the debate believe the parliamentary campaign has the best chance of success since abortion was legalised in 1967. 
 Phyllis Bowman, national director of the Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child, told its annual conference at Keele that a dual attack on abortion and embryo experimentation will be launched in the autumn when the Government announces its Bill on embryo research. 
 The society, which claims wide support in the Commons and the Lords, will campaign against embryo research and aim to introduce its own amendment to reduce the time limit for abortion to 18 weeks. 
 The Government has indicated it will make provision in the Bill for such an amendment. 
 That means it will be the first time abortion has been debated as part of government legislation, rather than on the basis of a private member's Bill. 
 As a result, the amendment cannot be &bquo;talked out&equo; as has happened on every previous occasion, but will have to be resolved through a free vote. 
 The society move was immediately condemned yesterday by the British Pregnancy Advisory Service as &bquo;an attempt to hijack government legislation&equo;. 
 Diane Munday, for the service, said: &bquo;Embryo experimentation and abortion are two different issues. 
 This is another attempt to waste parliamentary time &mdash; already 280 hours has been wasted in this way in the past two decades.&equo; 
 The society argues, however, that the announcement of the Bill itself is a success, showing how &bquo;pro-lifers&equo; have forced the Government to resolve the issue both on embryo research and abortion. 
 &bquo;We have taken single issue campaigning beyond the text book by forcing the Government to take responsibility itself,&equo; Ann Winterton, Conservative MP for Congleton and secretary of the all-party parliamentary Pro-Life Group, said. 
 The society has started raising funds for the campaign. 
 It estimates it will need about &pound;200,000 and has been pledged &pound;65,000 by the millionaire property developer Godfrey Bradman, chairman of the society's Education Research Trust. 
 Mrs Winterton said the campaign would be the most complex fought by the sociey because it linked the two issues. 
 Some MPs and peers were in favour of one but not the other. 
 In addition, the Bill would be introduced in the Lords first &mdash; and while the society had &bquo;clout&equo; with MPs, peers were less assailable, she said. 
 Nevertheless, its members were all urged to target MPs and peers - particularly the &bquo;waverers&equo; &mdash; with letters and personalised press releases, issued at the conference. 
 Mrs Winterton said letters should not be sent to the &bquo;converted&equo; who might find them an irritant, suggesting a change of tactics since the campaign over the Alton Bill. 
 The Government's Bill on embryo research comes after the report of the committee chaired by Baroness Warnock which recommended experiments on foetuses be allowed up to 14 days. 
 There will be two alternative clauses - one calling for a ban on research and one for research to be allowed up to 14 days. 
 The Bill will also set up a statutory licensing body to police experimentation. 
 As well as campaigning for the first of the two alternatives, and for balanced representation on the licensing body, the society will introduce the abortion amendment. 
 Phyllis Bowman said at the weekend that the best the society could hope for would be reducing the time limit to 18 weeks. 
 The society claims, however, that recent votes show it has 3-1 support in the House of Lords and more in the Commons. 
 Health authorities face cuts in beds and services 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 HEALTH authorities look to be at risk of another round of bed closures, service cuts and deferred developments this winter, despite the fact that the year's financial settlement for the NHS originally looked generous. 
 In London, St Bartholomew's Hospital has closed 75 beds to combat a threatened &pound;2m overspend. 
 Tower Hamlets health authority is considering action which may involve service cuts to tackle a feared &pound;1.4m deficit. 
 In King's Lynn, Norfolk, 12 orthopaedic beds plus a small ward have closed and operating sessions are being reduced after a &pound;238,000 overspend in the first five months of the financial year. 
 In Kettering, Northamptonshire, new operating theatres which would have cost an extra &pound;250,000 a year to open will stand unused until at least next April. 
 Oxfordshire health authority has decided that a threatened &pound;500,000 overspend means it cannot open a new cardiology unit which would have freed beds for other uses. 
 North-West Thames regional health authority has several districts with significant overspends, while South-East Thames is facing a potential &pound;5m shortfall with many of its 15 districts &bquo;walking a tightrope&equo;. 
 Districts in the region are already looking at deferring planned developments, extending Christmas ward closures and freezing staff appointments. 
 Clive Minty, manager of Plymouth health authority and chairman of the NHS finance officers association, said the situation looked tight. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't rule out the need for some extra cash for the service between now and the end of the financial year, although we haven't quite arrived at that stage yet.&equo; 
 The scale of the financial problem is much smaller than in 1987 when nearly 4,000 beds were closed, triggering the NHS review and an emergency injection of &pound;100m to keep the service going. 
 But several senior finance officers said last week that between two and three dozen health authorities could face bed closures and service cuts in the next couple of months, with others deferring developments. 
 Problems have arisen despite this year's cash for the NHS appearing, when it was announced last November, to allow for real growth for the first time in years, even after taking into account inevitable pressures such as the rising number of elderly people. 
 Since then, however, a whole range of staff from administrative and clerical, to senior managers, anciliaries and technicians have won pay rises above, and sometimes well above, the 5 per cent the NHS was given for inflation. 
 Non-pay items such as drugs and equipment have been running above 7 per cent as inflation generally has risen. 
 Cost-improvement programmes, which are meant to generate internal savings, are proving far harder to deliver, finance officers say. 
 Appeals over the nurses' regrading are coming through with no extra cash to pay for them, and, ironically, in the Thames regions the slump in house prices has slowed staff turnover; vacancy levels, which helped balance the books at the cost of quality and volume of service, are lower. 
 Water warning 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 (First Edition) Thousands of householders in the Pontnewydd area of Cmwbran in Gwent have been warned to boil their cooking and drinking water after vandals threw debris into a nearby reservoir during a break-in. 
 Dearer letters 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 The cost of first and second-class letters rises 1p today to 20p and 15p respectively. 
 Composer's visit 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 Walter Kent, the American composer of The White Cliffs of Dover, visited the town for the first time yesterday and presented an original of the song manuscript to the district council, which will display it in the &pound;14m &bquo;White Cliffs Experience&equo; due to open in 1991. 
 Oil spilled 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 An emergency clean-up operation was launched last night after the MV Worthy spilled about 50 tonnes of oil during a delivery to the marine terminal of the Fawley oil refinery, Southampton. 
 Bridge fall 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 A man is recovering in Frenchay Hospital, Bristol, after falling from the Severn Bridge. 
 Dean White, 23, from Chepstow, Gwent, who suffered cracked ribs and bruising, was swept on to a mudbank in the dark and found by members of the Army Apprentice College at Chepstow, after coastguards with spotlights and a helicopter with heat-searching equipment had searched without success. 
 Murderer escapes 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 A convicted murderer was on the run last night. 
 Richard Dennick, 22, who was convicted at Chester Crown Court in 1983, is thought to have used a blanket rope to escape from Lewes prison, East Sussex. 
 He is described as 5ft 10ins, slimly built, with a fresh complexion and ginger hair, and should not be approached if sighted, police said. 
 Gambling aid 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 An organisation has been set up in Leicester to help the growing number of young people addicted to gambling. 
 The UK Forum on Young People and Gambling aims to act as a co-ordination and information centre, and to provide counselling and advice to youngsters with gambling problems &mdash; mainly with fruit machines. 
 Bus fracas 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 A double-decker bus overturned in Dublin when fighting broke out among passengers. 
 Twenty-four passengers were still being detained in two Dublin hospitals last night with fractures, and one with spinal injuries. 
 New security measures, including video surveillance cameras, come into force on the city's bus fleet this week. 
 Kidnap hunt 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 Police in the Irish Republic are searching for Damien Hulme, 40, who was abducted from his home in Dundalk, Co Louth, by a gang wearing masks and carrying sledgehammers. 
 The police suspect the IRA may be connected with the incident. 
 Sixteen in court after drugs raid 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 Sixteen people will appear before magistrates at Highgate, north London, today in connection with the police raid on the Broadwater Farm estate. 
 The majority would face drugs charges, a Scotland Yard spokeswoman said. 
 A further 22 arrested in the raid on Friday, and 51 detained on the Tottenham estate in the week leading up to it, had been charged and would appear in court at a later date. 
 Yesterday, the police denied that drug dealers were tipped off before the operation. 
 However, it emerged last night that a reporter from London Weekend Television unwittingly tipped off residents about the raid when he phoned contacts on the estate to ask if there had been a raid &mdash; before it had actually happened. 
 Speelman facing classical opponent in chess contest 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 This afternoon, at Sadler's Wells theatre, he begins his attempt to progress to the final of the world chess championship candidates matches. 
 His opponent will be the Dutch grandmaster Jan Timman, 37, and their match may last three weeks. 
 They will share the stage in the Pilkington Glass World Championship semi-finals with two Soviet grandmasters, Anatoly Karpov and Artur Yusupov. 
 In a brief ceremony yesterday evening, Timman and Yusupov drew the white pieces for today's opening games. 
 While the officials, commentators and chess groupies then lingered over an enjoyable buffet, the players and their seconds rushed off to put the finishing touches to six months of preparations. 
 The visiting players have been in England for some days, and all four are becoming understandable twitchy as the time to make the first moves approaches. 
 Karpov is the best known of the contestants. 
 World champion for 10 years between 1975 and 1985, he has, since losing the title, been doggedly pursuing the man who took it from him, Garry Kasparov. 
 Karpov is the only semi-finalist who appears relaxed and confident. 
 While his delegation (two grandmaster seconds and a doctor) have stayed out of sight, performing their analytic labours, Karpov has attended receptions, even sometimes looking as though he is enjoying himself. 
 His opponent, Artur Yusupov, 29, looks worried. 
 A raggedness around the edge of his thick, ginger beard seems a symptom of the nerve-fraying tension that surrounds a match of this importance. 
 Tall and slightly stooped, Yusupov normally shows a shy good humour in his conversation, but he has looked increasingly serious these last few days. 
 He brings to his games an intensity of concentration few can match, but he has always found Karpov a very difficult opponent. 
 The match between Timman and Speelman has no clear favourite. 
 Speelman has the reputation of being a very solid player with occasional flashes of mercurial originality and brilliance. 
 Timman, 37, is a more classical player, but inconsistent. 
 While Speelman can be relied upon to finish just above half-way in any international event, Timman's name frequently features either at the top or near the bottom. 
 Over the next two weeks, each pair will contest eight games. 
 If the score is tied at 4-4, the match will go into overtime. 
 At this level, eight games are too few to allow any margin for error (in world championship matches, they play 24). 
 But with each loser taking home about &pound;28,000 in prize money courtesy of Pilkington Glass, even the underdogs could afford to be a little more cheerful. 
 As if deliberately to disconcert the semi-finalists, the world champion, Garry Kasparov, has registered one of his most impressive performances. 
 With one round still to play in the Interpolis tournament in Tilburg, Holland, he is already sure of first place. 
 Nine wins and four draws from thirteen games give him a score of 11 points, three points ahead of Viktor Korchnoi in second place. 
 Such a huge margin of victory has rarely been seen in a tournament of this class. 
 Runcie attack on &bquo;Pharisees&equo; revives rift with Tories 
 By JAMES DALRYMPLE 
 IN A RASPING attack on the &bquo;Pharisees&equo; of British society who decry the unsuccessful, the jobless and the poor, the Archbishop of Canterbury has returned to his attack on a decade of Conservative government. 
 Dr Robert Runcie links drug and alcohol abuse, crime and vandalism, debt and family break-up with a section of the political and commercial leadership that says: &bquo;We have made the people wealthy, it's the Church's job to make them good.&equo; 
 In an interview in the magazine Director to be published this week, Dr Runcie denies that there are &bquo;tensions and suspicions&equo; between Lambeth Palace and 10 Downing Street, but he points out that the Church of England is active in parts of the country where the Conservative Party has little support. 
 &bquo;This makes the church sensitive to the needs of those areas and that section of the population which has not benefited from the last 10 years of Conservative government,&equo; he says, claiming that there is &bquo;no automatic connection between wealth creation and a happy society&equo;. 
 He also says: &bquo;Jesus reserved his most astringent criticism for the Pharisees. 
 We tend to think that the Pharisees were unscrupulous, double-dealing, untrustworthy. 
 That was not the case. 
 Most of them led lives of exemplary moral rectitude. 
 That did not cause them to escape the sharp edge of Jesus's tongue. 
 He disliked their self-righteousness and their judgemental attitudes. 
 &bquo;Those are the real dangers in our society today. 
 I sense they are both increasing. 
 The successful are always tempted to regard their success as a sort of blessing or reward for righteousness. 
 &bquo;This can lead to judgements being made about the unsuccessful, the unemployed, the poor and the unintelligent which are both uncharitable and untrue. 
 &bquo;I'm thinking of the sort of attitude that suggests the unemployed do too little to help themselves, that if only you have determination and drive you can get on in the world.&equo; 
 He says there are positive factors in the new atmosphere between local authorities and private enterprise, but it &bquo;hardly touches on the problems of poor housing, lack of amenities and the continuing unemployment&equo;. 
 &bquo;These problems are what lead to that sense of being left out, of isolation and despair, which in turn can lead to the symptoms we are familiar with &mdash; drug and alcohol abuse, crime and vandalism, debt and family break-up.&equo; 
 A Downing Street spokesman said yesterday that &bquo;there was absolutely no reaction at all&equo; to Dr Runcie's latest broadside. 
 Ivor Stanbrook, MP for Orpington, who chairs the Conservative backbench constitutional affairs committee and is an Anglican, said: &bquo;The ills of society are as much the responsibility of the Church as of political parties. 
 The Archbishop should be thoroughly ashamed of himself at the failure of the efforts of the Church to create a better society. 
 &bquo;Despite their differences, the philosophies of the two main political parties in Britain can be supported quite sincerely by Christians.&equo; 
 Frank Field, Labour MP for Birkenhead and also an Anglican, said Dr Runcie was right to attack government polices but he should also direct his attention to the Church, which was &bquo;self-righteousness on stilts&equo;. 
 Support came from one unlikely quarter, Peter Bottomley, the Northern Ireland minister. 
 He said Dr Runcie was being attacked by people who had not read the article in its entirety. 
 &bquo;What he actually says is a very proper reminder that you can do more good with wealth in the nation, in the community and in the family, but wealth for its own sake is not a good thing.&equo; 
 Pharisee: &bquo;One of an ancient Jewish sect distinguished by their strict observance of the traditional and written law, and by their pretensions to superior sanctity. 
 A self-righteous person, a hypocrite&equo;. 
 Police attacked at acid house parties 
 By JAMES DALRYMPLE 
 SIXTEEN police officers were hurt, including seven sprayed with CS gas, and 51 people were arrested at an acid house party, police said yesterday. 
 Drugs worth &pound;2,000, including LSD, ecstasy and cannabis, were seized. 
 Thirty-three people were charged with drug offences, the other 18 with possessing offensive, weapons and offensive behaviour. 
 The police were attacked as they tried to break up a crowd of about 10,000 people gathered in a field at Sidlow Bridge, near Reigate, Surrey. 
 Roads were jammed with traffic. 
 Supt John Hoyle said he and his 25 officers feared for their lives as about 100 guards and party organisers smashed their vehicles, let off the gas, and menanced them rottweiler and dobermann dogs. 
 &bquo;I was forced to make a tactical withdrawal for the safety of myself and my officers. 
 We had to allow the party to continue through the night.&equo;. 
 Reinforcements were called in from the Surrey, Kent, and Sussex forces. 
 About 150 police moved in at daylight to make arrests. 
 In Harlow, Essex, police arrested at least 45 people when they closed down an acid house party attended by 3,000 to 4,000 people at a disused warehouse at 6am yesterday, a police spokesman said. 
 The arrests were for alleged public order, criminal damage or drugs offences. 
 Tests were being carried out on suspected drugs thought to include heroin, ecstasy, cocaine, LSD and cannabis. 
 Officers also found two hammers, two knives, a knuckleduster and three clubs. 
 No one was charged. 
 An acid house party attended by children as young as 12 was broken up by police yesterday. 
 Cigarettes thought to contain cannabis, and illegally-sold alcoholic drinks were seized. 
 About 500 people were at the party, in a barn at Elmstone Hardwicke near Cheltenham, Gloucestershire. 
 Forty people are to appear in court in Blackpool today after Birmingham City supporters went on the rampage before and after their team's Third Division match with Blackpool, wrecking a pub, smashing dozens of windows and bombarding police with bottles and glasses. 
 Two policemen and about a dozen supporters were injured. 
 Chance to damn Rushdie &bquo;missed&equo; 
 By NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 BRITISH Muslims have missed a great opportunity to turn public opinion against Salman Rushdie, an Islamic scholar said yesterday. 
 Ahmed Deedat told thousands of Muslims who filled the Albert Hall in central London that if they had only shown the non-Muslim majority that Mr Rushdie had grievously insulted the Queen, Margaret Thatcher and all white women in The Satanic Verses, then the author would have been condemned by all of society and the book banned. 
 But Sheikh Deedat, who is based in South Africa, avoided a straight answer when asked if Mr Rushdie should be killed. 
 His talk was peppered with quotations from The Satanic Verses, none of them put in context and almost all involving obscenities. 
 The sheikh, a white-bearded man with the charisma of an American TV evangelist, is a specialist in the comparison of other faiths with Islam. 
 His lecture tour will continue in five cities, ending in Birmingham on Sunday. 
 &bquo;I would have been one with you in marches, burning books and so on,&equo; he said. 
 But being in Durban, far from the turmoil over the book's publication, he had been able to read it and ponder. 
 His conclusion was to turn the tables on those in the West who defended Mr Rushdie. 
 The Satanic Verses referred to Mrs Thatcher as &bquo;Maggie the bitch&equo;. 
 Worse still, the central character dreams of &bquo;making tender love to the Monarch&hellip; she was the body of Britain, the avatar of the State&equo;. 
 If all British people did not feel deeply hurt by this &bquo;there's something wrong with you&hellip;&equo; 
 Sheikh Deedat quoted one sentence which said white women were useful only for copulation. 
 He linked public readings of the book in New York with the rape of a young, white woman jogger in Central Park by six blacks. 
 Afterwards, Ali, 19, from Luton, Bedfordshire, said he approved of the sheikh's message. 
 &bquo;I'm a Muslim fundamentalist, but if I had a knife and I saw Rushdie I wouldn't kill him, I'd talk to him. 
 A lot of this is political. 
 Plenty of those who talk about killing him would never do it themselves.&equo; 
 Relaxation &bquo;better than some drugs&equo; 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 MANY of the four million people prescribed drugs for mild high blood pressure could take smaller doses or live without them by learning to relax, Drug and Therapeutics Bulletin says today. 
 Breathing exercises, meditation, and deep muscle relaxation, or simply &bquo;imagining pleasant experiences&equo; can produce a significant fall in blood pressure. 
 The Bulletin, which gives impartial advice on medicines to doctors, says more GPs and nurses should learn these skills to pass on to patients. 
 People with mild high blood pressure are at a slightly increased risk of a stroke, heart attack, or heart failure. 
 But the drugs that can reduce it have to be taken for life, and many have unpleasant side-effects. 
 Patients have complained of impotence, skin rashes, dry eyes, nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, fatigue or insomnia, and problems with circulation. 
 But relaxation therapy is not an easy alternative, the Bulletin says. 
 Patients must practise the techniques for up to 20 minutes a day. 
 Further, large-scale studies are needed to confirm the encouraging results obtained so far. 
 &bquo;It is a sad reflection on the financing of drug research that so much more is spent on the development of new and &bquo;me too&equo; drug therapies,&equo; it adds. 
 Clarke's strategy set at secret talks 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correspondent 
 HEALTH MINISTERS met secretly at Chevening last week to agree a strategy for winning the propaganda battle over the Government's NHS changes. 
 The first step will come next week when Kenneth Clarke, Secretary of State for Health, uses the Conservative Party conference at Blackpool to reaffirm his commitment to changing the NHS and set out a justification for the forthcoming legislation. 
 Mr Clarke is also keen to avoid further conflict with GPs. 
 Although he will take urgent steps to impose a new contract, which they have rejected, he has told the doctors' and dentists' pay review body that he is prepared to tackle any problems arising in the first year. 
 One source said: &bquo;He gave an undertaking to the DDRB in his submission last week that we will monitor very closely the effects of the contract in the first year. 
 If there are any problems in performance-related pay, we can iron these out. 
 We are not saying it is fixed in concrete. 
 We are saying it is the best we can do and we must judge how it is operating.&equo; 
 Mr Clarke's undertaking will be seen as a promise to provide more money, if it becomes necessary, in an effort to assuage the doctors' concerns about the contract. 
 New pay recommendations are due in the new year and, although Mr Clarke has told the review body that there must be pay restraint, ministers appear likely to press for the award to be met. 
 The meeting at Chevening, the Kent home taken from Sir Geoffrey Howe and handed to his successor as Foreign Secretary, John Major, was also a stock-taking exercise. 
 It took place after the BMA leadership agreed to call off its damaging campaign against cash restraint on GPs' drug budgets, a move regarded by Mr Clarke as a &bquo;breakthrough&equo; in his efforts to win wider support. 
 The Government is hoping the BMA's acceptance of assurances that patients will not be denied drugs for cash reasons will also end allegations that doctors will not take the elderly and chronically sick on lists because they are too expensive to treat. 
 Ministers say they have deliberately avoided &bquo;sounding triumphal&equo; about the BMA's backdown to avoid rekindling the controversy. 
 They are keenly aware the BMA leadership could come under attack from its rank and file. 
 The BMA decision came with perfect timing for Mr Clarke, who was facing serious Conservative unrest at Blackpool about the presentation of health policies. 
 He will lay an order in the Commons in a fortnight, immediately after the summer recess, to impose a new contract on GPs. 
 He aims to have it debated and passed by next month. 
 Ministerial sources confirmed the contract will be the &bquo;same in every particular&equo; as the deal reached with the BMA leadership which was rejected in a ballot by doctors. 
 Ministers say Mr Clarke's decision not to drop the concessions on targets for performance-related pay, given in talks with the BMA, and return to the tougher limits for higher pay underlines his determination to seek peace. 
 However, it also reflects government recognition that health has become one of its most vulnerable policy areas. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Policy review throws a spanner in the Whitehall machinery 
 By COLIN HUGHES, Political Correspondent 
 AN INCOMING Labour government would turn large areas of Whitehall upside down &mdash; but the party's policy review barely considers the implications of its plans for restructuring government departments. 
 Scattered through the policy review are proposals to: Drastically alter the status and organisation of the Department of Trade and Industry; Create two departments &mdash; a Department of Consumer Affairs, and a Department for Legal Administration; Create a Department of Environmental Protection within the existing Department of the Environment; Set up a plethora of new commissions and executive agencies; Set up a Women's Ministry. 
 Those are only the most overt changes advocated in the review papers. 
 The only department which explicitly escapes unscathed is the one which Conservatives would most like to abolish: the Department of Energy. 
 In virtually every case the aim of causing upheaval is explicitly declared, because Labour's aim would be to upset the bureaucratic order it inherits. 
 New departments and quangos would, according to the review, be designed to act as irritants and antagonists within the Civil Service system. 
 But the policy review nowhere considers the overall effect of the individual changes proposed, or how they might be co-ordinated. 
 Nor does it contemplate the knock-on consequences for Labour ministers of attempting to implement their programme while rebuilding the governmental machine. 
 The &bquo;medium term industrial strategy&equo; which would form the centrepiece of Labour's economic policy would, according to the Productive and Competitive Economy review group, be &bquo;administered by a transformed Department of Trade and Industry&equo;. 
 The review adds: &bquo;What we now seek is a DTI which will have an equal, if not superior status, to that of the Treasury.&equo; 
 That approach would seek to knock out a keystone of Civil Service tradition. 
 Labour policy has long sought to challenge the Treasury's dominance in government. 
 But its last effort &mdash; the Department of Economic Affairs, set up by Harold Wilson and headed by George Brown &mdash; ended in futile departmental and ministerial infighting. 
 There would in addition be a minister for Science and Technology at the newly supreme DTI, with responsibility for determing investment in research. 
 There is no mention in the education policy of how that might affect the Department of Education and Science. 
 But while the DTI would override the Treasury, a new &bquo;powerful Department of Consumer Affairs&equo; would antagonise the DTI. 
 It would be headed by &bquo;a minister of Cabinet rank&equo; and act as &bquo;the consumers&equo; voice with other government departments'. 
 Its remit for inter-departmental intrusion would be wide, with &bquo;a watching brief over government action&equo; and the ability to initiate consumer legislation. 
 Only the Women's Ministry would be given equal license. 
 It would be able to &bquo;require each government department to review its policies, practices, and existing and proposed legislation&equo;. 
 While new departments are born and others extended, one of the oldest &mdash; the Home Office &mdash; would become a shadow of its present self. 
 Labour's proposed Department for Legal Administration would take over responsibility for courts and tribunals; court procedures; organisation, training and appointment of the legal profession, magistracy and judiciary; legal aid; legal services; and the Sentencing Council. 
 That would leave the Home Office with policing, penal policy and the criminal law. 
 Responsibility for the Sex Discrimination Act, the Equal Pay Act and the Equal Opportunities Commission would be given to the Women's Ministry. 
 The concept of a minister having Cabinet rank &mdash; and therefore implicitly not being a member of the Cabinet proper &mdash; crops up again on environment. 
 A &bquo;new Minister of Environmental Protection&equo; would operate inside the DoE. 
 That could work &mdash; though it is easy to imagine conflicts of interest with the housing and planning functions of the department. 
 More problematic will be Labour's plan for the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. 
 &bquo;The priority of MAFF must become food, not farming,&equo; the policy review says. 
 &bquo;Its main concerns would become food and the people who consume it, not farming and those who produce it.&equo; 
 But the regulatory functions over the food industry, now split between MAFF and the Department of Health, would transfer to a new Food Standards Agency. 
 That is the first of many agencies, executives, commissions, and other quango-like bodies recommended by the review. 
 In some cases Labour's quangos merge existing ones, or replace well-established bodies. 
 The funding of higher education would become the responsibility of one body, rather than two. 
 Labour's Quality Commission would replace the Audit Commission. 
 But there would be new regulatory commissions and consumer councils for every utility, along with ombudsmen, and public interest commissioners appointed by the Secretary of State. 
 There would be Skills UK &mdash; a locally structured training commission &mdash; a Fair Wages Commission, a Health Technology Commission, a Health Quality Commission, an Education Standards Council, an Independent Sentencing Council, a Children's Commissioner, an Environmental Protection Executive, and a Social Insurance Fund administered by&hellip; &bquo;an independent commission&equo;. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Cook appeals for Labour to accept electoral reform 
 By COLIN HUGHES and COLIN BROWN 
 AN IMPASSIONED appeal for Labour to back electoral reform was made by a leading Shadow Cabinet member yesterday after the national executive decided overwhelmingly to oppose a proportional representation motion. 
 Robin Cook, a member of the national executive and the health spokesman, said that a Labour government which sought to force its programme on an unwilling nation would be unsocialist. 
 He told a Labour Co-ordinating Committee rally that it was not enough for Labour to win the next election. 
 It would also be necessary &bquo;to smash the decrepit, effete constitution that allows a minority to capture power, and then use it ruthlessly in the interests of the privileged few&equo;. 
 Mr Cook argued that 10 years of Thatcherism had been forced on most people, who had never voted Conservative, and that many of those who opposed PR in the Labour Party wanted to use the same undemocratic power &bquo;to ram socialism down the throats of a majority who didn't vote for it&equo;. 
 Advocates of the first-past-the-post system argued that it was the only way of delivering strong government, Mr Cook said. 
 But after 10 years of Tory rule, he had had enough of that approach to politics. 
 Labour would be acquiescing in a &bquo;democratic outrage&equo; if it continued arguing that, because the Conservatives had got away with being undemocratic for so long, it was now Labour's turn. 
 Mr Cook also countered the argument that PR would build in a pull towards the centre ground, preventing Labour from implementing a radical programme. 
 It seemed strange to make that argument, Mr Cook said, when it was clear the whole policy review process was designed to placate the centre ground. 
 &bquo;I cannot honestly see that a system which would require us to compromise the morning after the election is really so morally inferior to a system which has already obliged us to compromise our policies two years before polling day.&equo; 
 His speech, however, came aftera 24-4 vote in the national executive to oppose a proportional representation motion which will be debated on Thursday. 
 The four were Mr Cook, Ken Livingstone, John Evans and Clare Short. 
 Mr Livingstone said he was against pacts, but 10 years of Thatcherism had demonstrated the dangers of giving power to elites. 
 However, Neil Kinnock, the Labour leader, and Roy Hattersley, his deputy, both opposed the motion. 
 Mr Hattersley said giving disproportionate power to small, minority centre parties would not improve democracy. 
 Mr Kinnock said it was wrong to propose a fundamental change in the voting system for a short-term tactical vote to get rid of the Thatcher Government. 
 The only way to remove the Government was for Labour to win the next general election. 
 Mr Kinnock intends to reinforce his conviction that Labour is in a position to win in his keynote speech tomorrow. 
 Party organisers want the conference to show that the party is united as never before, leaving Mr Kinnock free for the first time to sell the policy package to voters without worrying about splits. 
 There is expected to be a close vote on defence, but Mr Kinnock is confident the new policy will be affirmed today. 
 The executive is recommending rejection of a motion calling for unilateral disarmament. 
 It is also urging the conference to oppose a motion, supported by the National Union of Mineworkers, to commit a Labour government to abolishing all nuclear power within 15 years. 
 There could also be controversy over the executive's rejection of demands for the age of consent for homosexuals to be reduced to 16 years. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Scargill may stand for Barnsley seat 
 By COLIN HUGHES and COLIN BROWN 
 ARTHUR SCARGILL, the miners' president, refused yesterday to deny reports that he was to become a Labour MP. 
 Mr Scargill is said by sources in the National Union of Mineworkers to be putting his name forward for the Barnsley West and Penistone constituency. 
 The NUM leader &mdash; vice-chairman of the constituency party &mdash; said any such decision would have to be taken by the Yorkshire area of the NUM. 
 Mr Scargill would seek to become an NUM-sponsored MP. 
 The present Labour MP in Barnsley West, Allen McKay, is to retire before the next general election. 
 Mr McKay had a majority of 14,191 at the 1987 election. 
 Mr Scargill's election to Parliament would acutely embarrass Mr Kinnock, but would pave the way for the NUM's merger with the Transport and General Workers' Union. 
 TGWU members have said they would resist attempts to make Mr Scargill leader of a new energy section within their union. 
 It is also possible that party members in Barnsley would prefer a more moderate candidate. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Rough-edged voice of the grass roots 
 By COLIN HUGHES 
 JOHN PRESCOTT did not go to university, was never a television presenter, and finds it exceedingly difficult to complete a grammatically correct sentence. 
 Those are three reasons why he will today be elected to Labour's national executive, writes Colin Hughes. 
 The other main reason is that, having been sidelined by Neil Kinnock last year into the job of transport, Mr Prescott has found himself appearing on the early-evening television and radio bulletins more often than any other member of the Shadow Cabinet. 
 His brief has converted him into Labour's chaos and disaster spokesman. 
 From clogged skies to choked motorways, from Clapham Junction to the Marchioness, Mr Prescott has been Labour's voice of protest on an issue that has moved to the heart of the &bquo;quality of life&equo; agenda increasingly dominating the political agenda. 
 The former ferry steward, who rose through the National Union of Seaman before being elected MP for Hull, wears every thought and feeling on his sleeve. 
 He is therefore easily riled or mocked. 
 Nicholas Soames, the aristocratically toned and booming Tory MP for Crawley, can still make him stumble at the despatch box by muttering &bquo;Another G and T, Giovanni&equo;. 
 Though he is neither intellectually sharp nor verbally articulate, Mr Prescott is intelligent in a self-schooled way, and speaks in a language that many Labour voters understand. 
 The smooth style of Bryan Gould and the calm air of managerial competence conveyed by John Smith are deemed essential to make southern voters feel confident about the new Labour Party. 
 Mr Prescott's rough-edged style conveys a sense of honest indignation, where soothing strokes of eloquence might seem insincere. 
 On top of that, he enjoys an unusually untainted popularity among activists and grass-roots trade unionists. 
 Having devoted most of his political life to touring constituencies and union branches, he has barely needed to campaign for the constituency section of the executive over the past two months. 
 When Mr Prescott first backed off standing against Roy Hattersley for the deputy leadership last year, and then changed his mind and decided to contest it after all, Neil Kinnock expressed unrestrained irritation. 
 But the pair, openly hostile by the end of last year, will patch up their mutual differences. 
 Mr Kinnock will want Mr Prescott's national executive support &mdash; and may sometimes even need his constructive criticism. 
 Mr Prescott is unquestionably closer to a large swathe of the rank and file than most other members of Labour's Shadow Cabinet. 
 Maybe it was for that reason that the party leader singled Mr Prescott's past year performance out for praise in an interview in The Sunday Correspondent yesterday, calling him, chummily, &bquo;Johnny&equo;. 
 All the signs, it seems, of an overnight rehabilitation. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Conference condemned by activists as &bquo;farce&equo; 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 AN ATTEMPT by party activists to empower the Labour conference to amend the leadership's policy review was defeated with the aid of union block votes. 
 Constituency party delegates declared the conference was being reduced to &bquo;a rubber stamp&equo;, a &bquo;farce&equo; and &bquo;a mirror image&equo; of the Conservative's conference. 
 But Larry Whitty, general secretary, said under party rules policy statements, such as the manifesto, were not amendable. 
 Out of 10 speakers from the floor on two composite motions reaffirming the conference's right to the final word on policy determination, only one backed the procedure adopted by the leadership for the review. 
 Trade union delegates remained silent during the short debate but voted solidly behind the leadership. 
 A composite requiring a separate vote where part of a policy document conflicted with a conference resolution was defeated by 4,921,000 votes to 1,057,000. 
 Les Huckfield, a former Labour minister, moving the composite on behalf of Co-operative Retail Services, said resolutions from the 1988 conference on social ownership, unilateralism and repealing anti-trade union legislation were ignored in the review. 
 &bquo;We are talking about the right to behave as members of a democratic organisation and introduce amendments to our own fundamental policies. 
 It is hypocritical that we praise Gorbachev and perestroika, praise what is happening in Poland and Hungary, when we can't even amend basic policy.&equo; 
 A second composite instructing the National Executive Committee to treat conference resolutions as amendments to review documents was defeated by 3,704,000 to 2,245,000. 
 Moving it, Ken Slater, of Hyndburn, pointed out there were some 60 resolutions on the conference agenda endorsing existing party policy for unilateral nuclear disarmament. 
 But if the review document, Britain in the World, was adopted those would be ignored. 
 Florrie North, of Eltham, said, after 53 years as a party member, that &bquo;it seems conference is being asked to rubber stamp policies made elsewhere&equo;. 
 Martin Smith, of Brighton Kemptown, protested: &bquo;We want a Labour government, but that does not mean to say that we are going to meekly accept inadequate policies and an economic policy that is doomed to failure.&equo; 
 Mr Whitty told delegates the NEC had given them &bquo;adequate time to look at the reviews&equo;. 
 He said there would be a debate on reform of conference procedures and policy-making on Friday. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Compromise over black sections set for defeat 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT, Labour Editor 
 NEIL KINNOCK'S attempt to defuse the long-standing controversy over black sections looks set for a conference defeat. 
 The three largest unions are refusing to vote for his compromise which would let whites belong to a black socialist society. 
 The Transport and General Workers' Union, which has the largest block vote (1.3m), is abstaining. 
 The GMB general union and the Amalgamated Engineering Union, with 800,000 and 600,000 votes respectively, are casting theirs against. 
 The decisions of the union delegations will probably mean a continuing wrangle. 
 A hardline motion calling for black sections is almost certain to be thrown out on Friday and the party could be left without a policy as support for a proposition calling for societies with exclusively black members is also in doubt. 
 Mr Kinnock's compromise would have created one society, with a national executive seat if it attracted more then 3,000 members. 
 The NEC adopted the plan by 21 votes to five. 
 Bill Morris, deputy general secretary of the TGWU and the most influential black trade unionist, believes society membership should be restricted to representatives of ethnic minorities. 
 Mr Kinnock and his deputy, Roy Hattersley, have consistently opposed exclusively black sections. 
 The party's campaign to win mass membership has failed, the GMB leader, conceded yesterday. 
 John Edmonds, a confidant of Neil Kinnock, said the party needed to talk to potential members rather than rely on advertisements and mail shots. 
 His union will spend &pound;1.5m over the next two years in an attempt to increase individual membership. 
 Membership dropped by 23,000 last year to 265,000, although officials say additional members attracted this year has almost offset that loss. 
 In 1952-53 membership peaked at a million. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Left rejects appeals for unity 
 By JOHN PIENAAR 
 PROMINENT left-wingers yesterday rebuffed appeals for unity behind Labour's policy review and accused the party leadership of a calculated effort to stifle grassroot dissent. 
 Tony Benn, Ken Livingstone and Dennis Skinner, Labour chairman, joined in an attempt to rally opposition to the review at a pre-conference fringe meeting. 
 As Labour leaders predicted a smooth ride for the policy overhaul this week, the three &bquo;hard left&equo; national executive committee members attacked the main elements of the package, from its abandonment of nuclear unilateralism to the shift away from all out renationalisation. 
 Mr Benn told the Campaign for Labour Party Democracy rally: &bquo;Now we have a leadership that claims the right to control the party entirely from the top. 
 They aim to win by detaching the Labour Party as a whole.&equo; 
 He cited the decision to deny local activists the chance to amend the review, the leadership's refusal to restore all trade union immunities, the rejection of demands for all-black sections within the party and the strengthening of Shadow Cabinet power. 
 &bquo;They are moving towards American politics. 
 We shall have four-yearly conventions&hellip; you can drop your resolutions and buy balloons; because that is all you will be able to release when you come to these conventions.&equo; 
 He and Mr Skinner urged a future Labour government to give those not paying the poll tax an amnesty. 
 And the party chairman derided the differences between Neil Kinnock and Bryan Gould, the trade and industry spokesman, on the value of water industry shares. 
 &bquo;Let's tell them we are going to take them back without compensation.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;The whole balance of the party is being moved away from the conference and the NEC to the Shadow Cabinet.&equo; 
 Mr Livingstone urged Labour activists to strengthen the left wing faction in the NEC elections. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Skinner cheered over water shares 
 By JUDY JONES 
 DENNIS SKINNER, the Labour Party chairman, won loud cheers from conference delegates yesterday when he demanded the return of water to public ownership without compensation to shareholders by the next Labour government. 
 He also urged the party not to turn its back on traditional principles and values in its drive to agree an election-winning package of policies this week. 
 In a speech that blended music-hall style with soap-box rhetoric, the veteran left wing MP for Bolsover, said: &bquo;For too long the Labour Party has been trying to follow in the wake of Mrs Thatcher's agenda. 
 We have to escape from the time warp in which, unfortunately, some people are still caught after three election defeats in a row.&equo; 
 Mr Skinner insisted: &bquo;There will always be a need for socialism, whether in Britain or anywhere else, so long as there are millionaires living in the lap of luxury and other people living in cardboard boxes, so long as we have a system which allows the poor countries of the world to hand over &dollar;50m to the rich.&equo; 
 He maintained there was only one way to resolve differences within the party leadership over Labour's policy towards a privatised water industry: &bquo;Take water back without compensation.&equo; 
 However, Mr Skinner firmly supported Neil Kinnock's rejection of electoral pacts with other parties to help to defeat the Tories. 
 He portrayed the Tories as the party of worn-out ideas, led by a Cabinet of incompetents. 
 More people had seen Sky television than John Major, the new Foreign Secretary. 
 John Wakeham, the new Secretary of State for Energy, had risen to public prominence in his previous Cabinet job by refusing to have nuclear waste dumped in his constituency. 
 Chris Patten, hailed the new ozone-friendly Secretary of State for Environment, had now been exposed as the &bquo;dirty water salesman of Europe&equo;. 
 The Prime Minister had spent 10 years trying to destroy the human spirit in Britain, but &bquo;she has failed because we in this movement are not going to allow her&equo;. 
 PUB ROCK / Pint-sized rock &bquo;n&equo; rollers: Jim White steps back in time to sample the fare at his local 
 By JIM WHITE 
 According to those on the inside track, Raggahouse is the latest fad in clubland. 
 This hybrid mix of reggae and hip hop follows acid jazz, Belgian New Beat and acid swing &mdash; the wholly forgettable contribution of Jive Bunny &mdash; as the sound to set disco feet tapping. 
 But no matter how often the archives are ransacked for old genres to bastardise, you don't have to be at the forefront of style-making to foresee that very few clubs will be swaying this time next year to Pub Acid, Hip Malt` n&equo; Hops, or Sweaty Backroom House. 
 The grunge and grime of pub rock has been credited with many things, including the invention of punk rock, but being remotely fashionable isn't one of them. 
 At the Bull &amp; Gate, next door to the Town &amp; Country Club in London's Kentish Town, the management has been promoting pub rock in a back room with adjoining outer bar for almost as long as the form has existed. 
 Last Thursday night the pub presented a triple bill described in Time Out magazine, the Baedeker Guide for London pub rock fans, as &bquo;melodic pop rock&equo;. 
 At the door the man taking the money was dirtying patrons' hands with one of those rubber stamps no-one thought existed outside student discos. 
 When pressed he was unable to give an accurate answer why this was necessary, nor why the stamp read &bquo;Do Not Bend&equo;. 
 For your &pound;3 entrance fee, you were invited into a dingey outer bar, packed to capacity with strange anarcho-punk types who only appear at night. 
 At the bar a leather-clad schoolboy was buying a pint of lager, served in a plastic beaker. 
 Occasionally, the decibel level would rise from the merely conversation-stopping to Heathrow proportions. 
 This was when somebody opened the door to the inner sanctum where the support band was playing. 
 Here, in a room even estate agents would have difficulty describing as anything other than small, 20 people clung to the perimeter walls as a man with a Chris Waddle haircut hammered out some old rock cliches. 
 One fan sang along and plucked at an imaginary guitar, but he turned out to be the roadie. 
 At the end of their set the roadie applauded wildly, and everyone else wandered back to the bar. 
 No wonder the Waddle-alike kept his eyes firmly shut throughout. 
 The headline band was called Girl With A Blue Guitar. 
 They were what is known as indie-poppers, which means that they play guitars rather than synthesisers, wear black leather biker's jackets and have a female lead singer with peroxide blonde hair. 
 The twist here was that the guitarist was also female (her guitar was blue) and the singer had an Australian accent. 
 The crowd had swollen to about 70 by now, standing in a respectful arc, as if the stage was protected by a sci-fi forcefield. 
 A couple of girls danced enthusiastically and several others tapped their feet. 
 A friend of the band weaved in and out of the crowd, recording their performance on a video camera. 
 It was the only indication, apart from the price of the beer, that this wasn't a decade ago. 
 For the players, there was the prospect of returning to their day jobs with &pound;50 in their pockets, for the landlord there was a healthy night's takings and for the crowd, even those who had stayed in the bar all evening, there was a nasty ringing in the ears the next morning. 
 That's the thing about pub rock &mdash; everyone goes home happy. 
 PUB ROCK / Pint-sized rock &bquo;n&equo; rollers: Jim White selects the best of the London pub venues and gigs in the weeks ahead 
 By JIM WHITE 
 GENERAL TIPS A general rule for pub rock patrons is that the quality of music will be in inverse proportion to the quality of the beer (except at Finsbury Park's Sir George Robey where an excellent music policy comes complete with a decent pint of Guinness). 
 Another rule of thumb is that if the act is obliged to rest their microphone stand and amplifiers on beer crates instead of the stage, it will be a good evening. 
 There are two types of pub rock occasions: those, like the one described above, where the band is likely to suffer from agrophobia; and those where the pub is so crowded, death through asphixiation seems to be the only way to get out. 
 There is no half-way house. 
 If it's a comfortable evening's entertainment you're after, stay at home with the video. 
 Dress varies, but will never be up. 
 WHO TO WATCH While the best that chart music can manage in the way of band names is Black Box, the pub circuit has always been ripe with imaginative handles. 
 Cheerfully bending ears this week somewhere in London are Bald Howlin' Bastard, Daisy Chainsaw, The Wandering Crutchless, Benny Profane, The Gordon Jackson Five and New Fast Automatic Daffodils. 
 We have no idea whether the music matches the nomenclature, but it must be worth &pound;5 of anyone's money to encourage them. 
 PLAYING THIS WEEK TONIGHT Bop Brothers Blues Band The plethora of litigation surrounding Blues Brothers lookalikes almost matches that attached to the release of Wired, the unofficial biography of the original brother, John Belushi. 
 Suffice to say, whether Boogie, Bop or simply Blues, this set of Brothers, whatever they once were before they fell out and dispatched solicitors to sue their siblings, will be wearing dark glasses, pork pie hats, black side-burns and will be playing Stax/Atlantic type material. 
 Can't fail to be entertaining. 
 Oh, all right it can. 
 Weavers Arms, 98 Newington Green Rd, N1 (226 6911) 8.30pm &pound;2. 
 Near Death Experience Hopefully simply a band name, not a prediction. 
 Loud and tuneless, but has that ever been a problem before? 
 King's Head Fulham (details below) 8pm &pound;2. 
 Well Loaded Much talked-about guitar rockers, generally regarded as destined for the bigger stadia of life, unless they self-destruct en route. 
 Catch them young. 
 Powerhaus, at the Pied Bull 1 Liverpool Rd, N1 (837 3218) 7.30pm &pound;3. 
 The Vapour Corporation Power pop, which means don't expect to leave with your eardrums intact. 
 Cricketers, Kennington Oval (735 3059) 8pm &pound;3. 
 Johnny Mars Blues Band Unrepentant Smiths fans need not beat a path to the door, this is nothing to do with Johnny Marr. 
 Dog &amp; Trumpet 38 Great Marlborough St, W1 (437 5559) 8pm Free. 
 Primal Scream Not a name which would lead you to expect self-absorbed acoustic doodlings. 
 Which is just as well, because long-haired rock is what you will get. 
 Plough Kenton, Kenton Rd, Harrow (907 2498) 9pm &pound;3.50. 
 FRIDAY Dr &amp; The Medics Silly hippies in Roy Wood cast-off costumes don't sound like the most appetising evening out, and their brief foray into the charts was a considerable embarrassment, but the good Dr's tongue is in the right place (in his cheek) and a jolly time is guaranteed. 
 Powerhaus N1 (837 3218) 8.30pm &pound;5. 
 MON 9 OCT Steve Marriott &amp; Mickey Hutton In among those on their way up, and those who will never go anywhere, the pub rock circuit plays host to those who were once really something. 
 Marriott was the chirpy Cockney sparrer who lead The Small Faces, who performed that strange pigeon-toed shuffle on Top of the Pops and wrote &bquo;Lazy Sunday Afternoon&equo;. 
 Now he steps out on beer-stained carpets and decaying floor-boards, but the conviction remains as strong. 
 Best of all he seems to enjoy himself. 
 Not, in truth, a pub rock venue, but certainly a pub rock act. 
 The Monday Club, The Limelight, Shaftesbury Ave, W1 434 0572. 9pm. 
 WHERE TO GO Bull &amp; Gate, 389 Kentish Town Rd, NW5 (485 5358). 
 Small but perfectly formed for pub rocking (ie sweaty and restricted view from all but the front three rows). 
 The front bar, if the noise level becomes too oppressive, has prints of Lester Piggott decorating the wall, and a pool table. 
 Dog &amp; Dumpling, 13 Southgate Rd, N1 (359 6596). 
 Not sure of the music policy, but the name sounds like the ingredients of a takeaway from a less salubrious Chinese. 
 Dublin Castle 94 Parkway, NW1 (485 1773) Beloved of Camden's grunge rock enthusiasts, a temple to R'n'B, complete with priceless memorabilia decorating the brown-painted (or nicotine-stained) walls. 
 Back room stage so small the performers have to rest their mike stands on the floor in front. 
 Fulham Greyhound 175 Fulham Palace Rd, W6 (385 0526) Home of heavy rock, so take your ear-plugs. 
 Consistently fine and determined music policy. 
 Half Moon Putney 93 Lower Richmond Rd, SW15 (788 2387) Better known for its jazz, but a good, wholesome venue for rock nonetheless. 
 King's Head, Fulham 4 Fulham High St, SW6 (736 1413) L-shaped room, part corridor, part bar, part dance-floor, with the stage in one corner, ensuring restricted view from virtually everywhere. 
 Perhaps the best atmosphere around, with uninhibited dancing and whelping. 
 New Pegasus 109 Green Lanes, N16 (226 5930) Pub which has gone through several incarnations, most recently known as Chas'n'Dave's. 
 The odd policy to put the stage in the middle of the room rather than at one end leads to a diminishing of the atmosphere (the corners are seldom filled). 
 The stains on the carpet have survived every name change. 
 Sir George Robey 240 Seven Sisters Rd N4 (263 4581) Named after an old musical hero, located opposite the old Rainbow, the venerable old rock institution which is now home to a religious sect. 
 Lots of old posters on the wall. 
 Smelly back room, perfect for the sweatier excesses of the form. 
 ROCK / Wilko Johnson, pub rock king 
 By JIM WHITE 
 Wilko Johnson is, without reservation, the best performer in pub rock. 
 The former Dr Feelgood and Blockhead, owner of chameleon eyes and a manic Chuck Berry-like duck waddle, now leads a fearsome three piece. 
 Bassist Norman Watt Roy, who was the power behind Ian Dury and has a set of eye-baggage that must be the envy of Barry Norman, puts so much into thumping out a rhythm that the sweat drips from the end of his guitar. 
 He takes his work-ethic from his leader who, rather than stop, has been known to replace broken guitar strings while hammering out a perfect twelve-bar blues riff. 
 The music is that perfect staple of pub rock, good old Brit R'n'B, which was nurtured and cultivated in Wilko's home-town of Southend. 
 Never mind the band's recent elevation to the &pound;2,000-a-night world of the society ball circuit, the pub is the perfect forum to enjoy them. 
 Back In The Night, the old Feelgood stomp, is the highlight and, usually, the closing number - though the number of encores varies according to how well the concert is going. 
 Guaranteed the best fun you could have in a London pub, unless George Michael reformed Wham and chose the Fulham Greyhound to warm-up for their comeback world tour. 
 Sat 7 October, Powerhaus, 1 Liverpool Rd, N1 (01-837 3218). 
 &pound;5. 
 Ripping yarns and moral minefields: Allan and Janet Ahlberg talk to Celia Dodd about their bestsellers for children 
 By CELIA DODD 
 THESE days, no one questions the importance of good books for the under-fives. 
 But books that appeal to adults too are just as important; we are, after all, the ones who have to do the reading. 
 There are few things worse than being bludgeoned into reading a book you hate. 
 Story-reading should be one of the great joys of parenthood, a real meeting of adult and child minds. 
 With the Ahlbergs' books, it very often is. 
 The husband-and-wife partnership behind such classics as The Jolly Postman, Burglar Bill and The Baby's Catalogue win children over with ripping yarns and a wicked sense of humour. 
 They win their parents over with a rose-tinted vision of the world which is decidedly reassuring. 
 Their books are usually set nostalgically in the past &mdash; the Thirties and Forties are favourite periods &mdash; and often feature the perennial characters of fairy tales and nursery rhymes. 
 Yet they are saved from sentimentality by the wry humour of both text and pictures. 
 The Ahlbergs have been accused of not facing up to the harsh realities of life, of being too cosy and sweet, but their latest picture book, Bye Bye Baby, published today, breaks the mould. 
 In it, a small child roams the streets, talking to strangers, until he finally goes off with a woman who has been wandering about pushing an empty pram. 
 Curious subject matter for a children's picture book, you might think, and hardly guaranteed to win the approval of the gimlet-eyed children's book world. 
 But the Ahlbergs have no time for literal interpretations of their work. 
 How, they argue, would Alice, or The Wind in the Willows, stand up against such scrutiny? 
 The way to look at Bye Bye Baby, they insist, is as a &bquo;light, surreal comedy&equo;. 
 &bquo;Certainly if you bring a literal interpretation to the story, it's a minefield,&equo; Allan Ahlberg says. 
 Bye Bye Baby gets away with its particular minefield thanks to the sleight of illustrator Janet Ahlberg's hand. 
 The visual inspiration for the book was the famous advert for Start-rite shoes, showing a small boy and girl walking off down a tree-lined avenue &mdash; an innocent image if ever there was one. 
 The Ahlberg version features a solitary figure. 
 The advert gave the story its vaguely Thirties setting. 
 The success of the Ahlbergs' working relationship must have a lot to do with their long and happy marriage. 
 In spite of apparently incompatible personalities &mdash; she is small and shy, he is large and does most of the talking &mdash; they have an empathy which is essential to the way they work, a persistent mutual pestering. 
 The strength of the partnership is highlighted for Allan, who also works with a number of other artists. 
 The time-consuming nature of Janet's part in the process, combined with a bad back which prevents her spending more than a couple of hours at the drawing board every day, means she cannot keep up with her husband's prolific output. 
 &bquo;With other illustrators, I work at a distance &mdash; we visit and phone, but there is a point at which I can't pester them any more,&equo; Allan says. 
 They see themselves not as author and illustrator, with separate roles, but as a partnership of &bquo;book-makers&equo;, contributing equally to the process. 
 Allan Ahlberg says: &bquo;In the past, a lot of children's books seemed to be the work of talented illustrators whose pictures looked brilliant framed in a gallery, but when you tried to read the book, there was nothing there, because the words started as a coat-hanger to hang pictures on.&equo; 
 Given the importance they place on the interrelationship of words and pictures, the couple's working lives are surprisingly separate. 
 They claim to see each other less than couples who go out to work, meeting for the occasional cup of coffee in the kitchen. 
 Their 10-year-old daughter, Jessica, who is likely to be seen with her head buried in The Beano or a Roald Dahl novel, has provided the inspiration for many of her parents' books. 
 As a baby, she was fascinated by the Mothercare Catalogue, and so The Baby's Catalogue, which documents the paraphernalia of the infant's small world in minute detail, was born. 
 Allan's experience as a primary school teacher is another rich source of ideas. 
 The couple still maintain close links with local schools, where they spend hours researching, sketching and absorbing jokes. 
 After 10 years of teaching Allan had had enough. 
 &bquo;I ran out of steam. 
 It's a killing job. 
 Little kids eat you alive, they want so much physically and emotionally.&equo; 
 Every year he would have half a dozen nine- and 10-year-olds in his class who could barely read. 
 He treated reading as a team effort, getting them to read the Daily Mirror rather than the dull, babyish books on offer. 
 These days, he writes the books intended to help children learn to read. 
 &bquo;A lot of books used in schools are technically readable but rather drab stories. 
 There's no reason why they shouldn't be funny or gripping even if they don't use many words.&equo; 
 Writing books for children is becoming increasingly complex, as the arbiters of the modern child's mores &mdash; librarians, teachers and publishers &mdash; lay down ever more stringent criteria. 
 &bquo;The problem with children's books increasingly is that there are armies of people who are properly concerned with, for example, the way girls were always discriminated against in the past,&equo; says Allan. 
 &bquo;That is bad, and must be thought about. 
 But people seem to think that stories are written to a prescription, that you sit down and say, you don't want it to be sexist, you don't want it to be racist. 
 In reality you just invent a tale, as if you were sitting round a fire in a cave.&equo; 
 In fact anti-racism and anti-sexism seem to come naturally to the Ahlbergs. 
 Their books are full of female breadwinners and New Men changing nappies and comforting bawling babies in the small hours. 
 Although they are a principled pair &mdash; they once turned down the Smarties Award on moral grounds &mdash; the Ahlbergs reject the notion of children's author as moralist. 
 &bquo;I would say, just sit down and tell a good story, and to hell with the morality,&equo; Allan Ahlberg declares. 
 With that characteristically strong statement, he puts his finger on the secret of the Ahlbergs' phenomenal success with adults and children alike. 
 A manifesto for fashion from an idea by Lenin: Helen Womack on the stylish clothes being inspired by communism's icons 
 By HELEN WOMACK 
 RUSSIANS are numb to the red of the Communist Party and the face of Lenin which has stared at them in public places for decades. 
 Not surprisingly, they failed, with the first outbreak of Gorbymania, to see the fashion asset in the political imagery all around them. 
 It was left to Western businessmen to manufacture CCCP T-shirts which ended up on the Soviet black market, an acute case of carrying coals to Newcastle. 
 But one Moscow designer, at least, has been able to look at the familiar with a fresh eye and use the symbols of Soviet power with wit and imagination. 
 Yelena Khudiakova's exhibition of &bquo;high fashion using imagery from behind the Iron Curtain' opens at the Birch and Conran gallery in London's Soho today. 
 Ms Khudiakova herself may, from time to time during the week of the show, model some of the 20 outfits &mdash; a red silk skirt patterned with the heads of workers who look as if they are marching when you walk in it, a red evening dress decorated with a swath of flowers reminiscent of the relief on a pavilion in Moscow's Stalin-era Exhibition of Economic Achievements. 
 The latter dress shows something of the influence of her education at the Moscow Institute of Architecture in the early Eighties: &bquo;We studied sculpture, graphics and composition as well as architecture. 
 It was a good grounding for an artist.&equo; 
 Opportunities to be creative as an architect are limited, so many look for other artistic challenges, she explained. 
 But her main inspiration is the post-revolutionary school of constructivist art. 
 Her idol is the 1920s artist Varvara Stepanova, whose clothes designs she has reconstructed for museums and whose portrait, along with that of the revolutionary poet Mayakovsky, she has stitched on to another of her own red dresses. 
 Developing the constructivist style, Ms Khudiakova, 31, has created straight cotton dresses with cog-wheel patterns in primary colours. 
 She has also designed black-and-white striped or chequered dresses, inspired by the shadows and dramatic diagonals in Eisenstein's films. 
 She modelled these under the chandeliers in the grand marble foyer of one of the seven Stalin-gothic skyscrapers in Moscow, which she describes as &bquo;a perfect example of Soviet pokazukha (window-dressing). 
 The outside of the building is splendid, but the flats inside are cramped.&equo; 
 Why is she fascinated by a style perfected under a dictator whose crimes the Soviet people are just beginning to understand? 
 &bquo;I know it is sometimes ugly and has bad political connotations. 
 But it is special. 
 You won't find it anywhere else in the world &mdash; the Moscow metro or the boards of honour (hoardings where photos of model workers are displayed). 
 I'm trying to make it more beautiful and transform it into the language of clothes. 
 &bquo;Ideology is one thing, but it is possible to enjoy a visual impression without thinking of history. 
 Art is higher than politics.&equo; 
 She is not a member of the Communist Party. 
 A sense of humour redeems her designs from some of their associations. 
 &bquo;Fashion is extravagant. 
 You should enjoy yourself. 
 This is not satire, but there is an element of a joke.&equo; 
 She indicates a necklace made up of military insignia to illustrate her point. 
 One can imagine a Soviet general fuming to see it around her neck. 
 Her clothes are extravagant but not beyond the means of, say, Russian stars of stage and screen. 
 The red silk skirt with workers' heads and a gold top that goes with it, both cut from silk bought in Soviet Central Asia, would cost about 1,000 roubles (the average Soviet wage is 200 roubles a month) or &pound;700 in London. 
 Ms Khudiakova also provides sketches for Dom Modi, the state fashion house which mass produces clothes. 
 &bquo;I design what pleases me and if customers like it that's fine&equo;. 
 Asked what she thought of Slava Zaitsev, the man who has dressed rich Soviet women and diplomats' wives since the Brezhnev era and the only Soviet fashion designer well known in the West, she curled up her nose. 
 It seems Mr Zaitsev may be about to lose his monopoly on fame. 
 The revolution the countryside needs: Christian Wolmar says Britain is lagging behind in setting up &bquo;telecottages&equo; 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 THE information technology revolution has left large swaths of rural Britain untouched. 
 The only computers in many villages are those owned by the teenage boys of the affluent to play their wham-bam games. 
 Ashley Dobbs, an engaging young entrepreneur, is setting out to change that by creating a nationwide network of &bquo;telecottages&equo;. 
 This clever name, with its neat evocation of new and old, describes a concept which was developed in Sweden and is spreading to rural areas across the world. 
 In Mr Dobbs's words, a telecottage is &bquo;a room in a village filled with computer communications that can be used by local people to learn and work&equo;. 
 The equipment consists of, perhaps, four word processors, a modem, a laser printer able to produce artwork-quality output, a fax and a photocopier. 
 Software programmes for desk-top publishing, word processing, accounting and business planning are also essential. 
 Mr Dobbs, who is chairman of Telecottages UK, warns possible users not to get bogged down with the technology: &bquo;The equipment is a tool to overcome what needs to be done. 
 People mustn't think that because there's a computer, they've got to think of a use for it.&equo; 
 He reckons there are no shortages of possible uses &mdash; farmers can use it to do their accounts, women with child-care responsibilities can work in their own time on the word processors, publicity material for local craftsmen can be produced and so on. 
 This may sound utopian, but it has been borne out by the experience of existing telecottages. 
 So far about 100 have been established, mainly in Scandinavia but also in Japan and several third world countries. 
 As the network expands, so do the uses. 
 The first was opened in the village of Vemdalen in the remote forests of Sweden in September 1985. 
 The impact, according to Henning Albrechsten, president of Telecottages International who has been involved in their development since the outset, was immediate. 
 &bquo;By holding open meetings for children and having the telecottage above the local store, people of all walks of life came in - small-scale entrepreneurs and their spouses, shop assistants, craftspeople and children. 
 Now, 15 per cent of the village regularly uses the telecottage and at least 20 per cent has taken courses there.&equo; 
 Britain is lagging behind. 
 No telecottages have been established, but there are several initiatives in the offing. 
 The most advanced is a plan for five in the north of Scotland which will be funded by the Highlands and Islands Development Board and British Telecom. 
 Colin Pavey of British Telecom hopes that they will be running by the end of the year. 
 &bquo;Two would be business-orientated and three would be community-orientated and located in schools. 
 We are most interested in the idea of networking, sharing skills such as translation and using them for distance learning.&equo; 
 Telephone cables in the region are being upgraded to ensure they are capable of handling faxes. 
 Mr Dobbs's more unlikely allies are the Women's Institutes. 
 Most of the workers in telecottages and many of the users are women. 
 He says: &bquo;In villages there are many women with skills who aren't using them because of child-care problems. 
 But they are interested in working. 
 Users of telecottages are given the key and people can use them at any time, which means that women can come in during the evening, early in the morning or whatever.&equo; 
 He is working on a scheme with the National Federation of WI to organise a competition to celebrate next year's 75th anniversary by offering 10 telecottages as prizes for its 9,000 branches and he is hoping the WI will establish a pilot telecottage near its college in Denman, Oxfordshire. 
 While telecottages should become self-financing once established, they do need initial subsidy. 
 The cost of providing the start-up equipment is in the order of &pound;10,000 and Mr Dobbs thinks space is not much of a problem: &bquo;There's usually the village hall or an empty shop.&equo; 
 Henning Albrechsten reckons that it takes three years for a telecottage to be able to function without subsidy. 
 In Scandinavia, with their mixed economies, money is always available, after a bit of persuasion, from both local and central government. 
 In Britain, the tight financial regime imposed on local councils and the reluctance of central government to take on any new expenditure makes it necessary to seek funds from the private sector. 
 The only government support so far has been a recommendation by the Rural Development Commission, part of the Department of the Environment, to establish a pilot scheme. 
 Mr Dobbs sighs: &bquo;This is a typically British bureaucratic response. 
 It's been proved elsewhere that they work. 
 We don't need pilots, we need telecottages.&equo; 
 As for the private sector, while BT may be happy to provide pump priming for five telecottages in the north of Scotland, it is not about to bankroll a nationwide network. 
 Nor, it seems, is anyone else. 
 There is more at stake here than just bringing boxes of sophisticated equipment to remote areas. 
 As Mr Dobbs, who runs a country house restoration business from his home in Micheldever, Hampshire, says: &bquo;Villages are good places to live and work. 
 The village is a fantastic institution and they make people happier.&equo; 
 But the villages are dying, becoming suburbs or dormitories where few people work but many sleep. 
 Employment in agriculture, still the main rural industry, fell from over a million in the mid-Sixties to under 100,000 now. 
 The aim of telecottages is to create well-paid, flexible employment which will provide new jobs and make existing rural industries more competitive. 
 The emphasis on high wages is important. 
 Villages are expensive to live in and if they are to become vibrant communities again, local people must be able to earn enough to be able to continue living in them. 
 There is a wider impact, too. 
 The abstract talk of commuting by rail or road being replaced by information technology finds a concrete expression in the idea of telecottages. 
 Once people overcome their fears about computers and begin to use them in telecottages, they acquire their own equipment. 
 Many may eventually be able to work from home rather than commute to an office. 
 Henning Albrechsten says: &bquo;Modern information technology has given people in remote regions the opportunity to overcome their worst handicap; their distance from the centres of learning and development.&equo; 
 He sees them as not only strengthening small communities, but also as actually beginning to reverse the population flows from the countryside to the towns. 
 Britain, with its growing traffic problems, seems an ideal place for the onset of this revolution. 
 Despite Mr Dobbs's tireless efforts, this is another revolution which Britain is likely to be viewing from the sidelines. 
 The busy sex life of the nice male: Chris Barnard explains why patting children on the head could help a man curry favour with their mother 
 By CHRIS BARNARD 
 I REMEMBER once seeing a small girl remove a tin of soup from halfway down a display stack in a supermarket. 
 The predictable, and very satisfying, result attracted the attention of a nearby assistant, who strode towards the offending infant with an expression of undisguised anger on her face. 
 Suddenly she caught sight of the child's mother. 
 Immediately, her expression and pace of approach changed and instead of the lambasting, or worse, she had seemed about to deliver, she gave the child a tolerant smile and began to pick up the scattered cans. 
 Most of us have experienced similar examples of such &bquo;audience effects&equo; on behaviour: playing a game to perfection (or otherwise) when the team selector is present, for instance. 
 What you do depends very much on who might be watching, often with good reason. 
 Prudently taking cognisance of onlookers also turns out to be important in the social behaviour of other primates. 
 Frans de Waal, in his book Chimpanzee Politics, relates a number of instances among groups of captive chimps. 
 One of the most striking concerned a male called Yeroen which was hurt in a fight with another male, Nikkie. 
 For nearly a week after the injury, whenever he was in Nikkie's field of view, Yeroen would hobble pitifully, generating an air of pain and dejection. 
 As soon as he moved out of Nikkie's view, however, his demeanour changed and he walked normally without discomfort. 
 What Yeroen hoped to gain by his play-acting is not clear, though it may have helped to defuse further aggression. 
 What is clear is that his behaviour was geared to the available audience. 
 Some recent work on green vervet monkeys shows that audience effects can be important in other contexts in which their functional significance is a little easier to identify. 
 Anne Keddy Hector, Robert Seyfarth and Michael Raleigh at the Universities of California and Pennsylvania have been studying parental behaviour among captive vervets to see if males' parental ability affected the females' choice of mate. 
 Their argument was that a male's potential quality as a parent might be important because, in many species of Old World monkeys, males form strong protective relationships with females and their young, which are crucial in reducing the amount of harassment and competition the young suffer from other members of the group. 
 In a number of species, bonds between males and infants within a group may influence the chances of males mating with certain females. 
 In baboons and Japanese macaques mothers resuming their sexual cycle are more likely to mate with males who have formed a relationship with their offspring. 
 Demonstrating parental behaviour towards infants may be a ruse by which low-ranking males are able to gain mating opportunities. 
 If this is true, then males should respond differently towards an infant depending on whether or not its mother is arou.d to be impressed. 
 Keddy Hector, Seyfarth and Raleigh tested this in an ingenious experiment. 
 They looked at the behaviour of a male and infant under one of three conditions. 
 In one, the infant's mother was placed behind a clear screen so that the male and infant could see her and she could see them. 
 In a second, the screen was replaced with a one-way mirror so that the mother could see the interacting pair but could not herself be seen. 
 In the final condition, the mother was hidden behind a metal screen so that she could neither see nor be seen by the pair in the observation room. 
 After half an hour in each case, the mother was released to join her infant and the accompanying male. 
 The experiment revealed a complex interaction between male and female dominance rank and visibility of the mother in determining male responses to infants and female behaviour towards males. 
 Males of all dominance classes (alpha, subordinate and newly introduced) were less aggressive towards infants when the mother was in sight. 
 Alpha males were consistently friendlier than others towards male infants but were particularly nice if there was a chance that the infant was their own. 
 Subordinate males, on the other hand, were friendlier towards the infants of high-ranking females, perhaps because their own rank might increase if they managed to associate themselves with such females. 
 They were also friendlier towards female infants and those not fathered by the current alpha male. 
 Newly introduced males were the least friendly to infants. 
 If being nice to infants is a way of currying favour with females, the benefits ought to be discernible in the way males were treated once the observer females were let loose. 
 This seemed to be the case. 
 Overall, females were friendliest and least aggressive towards alpha males, regardless of their treatment of infants. 
 Since females reap substantial protective benefits from associating with alpha males, this is perhaps not surprising. 
 When it came to subordinate males, however, there was a strong relationship between how nice males had been to infants and how likely they were to be attacked by the female: nicer males fared better. 
 In the one-way mirror treatment, when males were unaware they were being watched, they were more aggressive towards infants than in the clear screen treatment and as a result they received a drubbing from the female. 
 The experiment thus suggests that while alpha males can trade on their superior competitive ability to obtain mates, subordinates may have to wheedle their way into favour. 
 Judiciously patting junior on the head when mum is watching may be a useful way of doing it. 
 Dr Chris Barnard works in the Department of Zoology at Nottingham University. 
 Cool solutions for hot climates: David Spark looks at tropical temperature controls for vaccines 
 By DAVID SPARK 
 WHEN smallpox was wiped out by a campaign led by the World Health Organisation, the campaigners were fortunate in that smallpox vaccine remains effective even when stored at relatively uncontrolled temperatures. 
 Vaccines against measles, polio, whooping cough and other killing infections prevalent in the third world are much more sensitive, however. 
 On behalf of WHO and Unicef, the Consumer Research Laboratory (CRL) at Harpenden, Herts, has set up a special facility to test the equipment used to carry and store vaccines. 
 CRL is allocating the equivalent of one person working full-time to the programme. 
 The CRL's main task is testing products for the Consumers' Association, publisher of Which? magazine. 
 Since 1978, it has also tested equipment used in the &bquo;cold chain' &mdash; the succession of insulated containers which ensures that vaccines and other sensitive materials reach their destinations, often isolated villages without electricity, in good condition, on which WHO's immunisation campaign depends. 
 In 1983, CRL helped to set up a test facility at the University of Cali in Colombia. 
 With more equipment coming on the market, WHO decided that Cali should concentrate on long-term research and that a full-time test facility was needed in Europe. 
 Other laboratories test particular products, but CRL is probably the only one which can cover the full range of equipment needed in the cold chain. 
 The range is wide. 
 Manufacturers dispatch vials of vaccine &mdash; along with frozen carbon dioxide for cooling &mdash; in large, insulated cartons which must be tested for both strength and the efficiency of the insulation. 
 From the cartons, the vials are unloaded into freezers and refrigerators. 
 The Harpenden test facility will show how these stand up to the high temperatures of the tropics. 
 Thermocouples at critical points in each fridge or other piece of equipment will show, through a computer print-out, how the temperature varies inside it. 
 Other items on test include the cold boxes in which vaccines are carried to villages, sterilisers for the syringes, stoves for the sterilisers and thermometers. 
 The outcome of the tests is to be a book of approved equipment, with details of performance, published by WHO and Unicef. 
 An obvious snag is the power cuts which are common in third world countries. 
 The CRL tackled this problem a few years ago, developing ice-lined refrigerators: tubes of water surrounding the fridge compartment freeze; if the power fails, the tubes keep the vaccines cool until all the ice has melted. 
 Designs are now being considered for small ice-lined cabinets for doctors&equo; surgeries, so that doctors can have vaccines at hand to immunise any child who comes for treatment. 
 A drop in voltage can be more serious than a power cut. 
 Below a given voltage, the compressor in a refrigerator burns itself out. 
 So there must be a voltage control unit to cut the power supply if the voltage fails, and these units must also be tested. 
 Ken Mills, manager of external projects at Harpenden, says that in some developing countries the control units themselves were blowing up. 
 It was thought that people tapping into the power supply illegally were sending high-voltage &bquo;spikes&equo; down the line. 
 So control units must be designed to withstand these spikes. 
 &bquo;We have to create the spikes here, to see how the units withstand them,&equo; he says. 
 Last year, WHO presented CRL with another problem: disposing of used syringes. 
 &bquo;You can't just dig a hole and bury them. 
 After use, the needles can be infected. 
 Kids dig them up and can scratch themselves.&equo; 
 CRL worked with a box-maker, Cundell Decorprint of Somercotes, Derbyshire, who produced a box in which discarded plastic syringes can be burned. 
 The box had to be flat-packed but assembled without glue; it had to be portable and reasonably waterproof. 
 When the box is full, you drop in a burning match. 
 The plastic of the syringes catches fire and the fire kills any infection on the needles. 
 Science and Technology Viewpoint: Checks for man-made genetic time bombs 
 By TOM WILKIE 
 PLUTONIUM, more than any other element in the periodic table, is capable of arousing strong public emotion, bordering at times on hysterical fear and loathing. 
 Yet plutonium has been intensively studied, is well understood, and it decays away into harmlessness with a half-life of about 240,000 years. 
 Consider instead, living creatures. 
 They interact with the natural world in complex, ill-understood ways &mdash; ecology is the youngest science. 
 Individuals may die, but plants, animals, and micro-organisms, are capable of reproducing and increasing their numbers. 
 It is surprising therefore, that there has been so little public interest in this country in proposals to release into the environment living, man-made creatures. 
 Genetic engineering has reached a point of such sophistication that there are clear benefits to be gained by releasing from the laboratory living organisms upon which have been conferred characteristics they could never have acquired through the normal processes of evolution or selective breeding. 
 For example, it is possible to snip through the genes of the vaccinia viruses (one of which is the basis for the vaccine against smallpox) and stitch in some threads of DNA from the rabies virus. 
 To the immune systems of the animals that it may infect, the resultant mutant virus will look as if it is rabies and so will trigger antibodies and generally stimulate immunity against the disease. 
 But because the virus is &bquo;really&equo; vaccinia, the infected animal will suffer none of the ill-effects of rabies while becoming proof against infection by any &bquo;real&equo; rabies virus. 
 We stand to derive immense benefits from such releases of genetically engineered organisms into the environment &mdash; providing they do what we expect them to. 
 But there is a risk. 
 What if, by some unforeseen mischance, the vaccinia-rabies hybrid turned into an organism that actually spread rabies - a disease that has always been comparatively difficult to catch &mdash; with smallpox-like contagion? 
 This scenario is unlikely in the extreme. 
 But research over the past 40 years or so has revealed some great surprises in the natural world. 
 Genes - for resistance to antibiotics, for example &mdash; can be swapped between micro-organisms of completely different species naturally, in the wild. 
 There are almost certainly other surprises out there which, by definition, we cannot speak about today. 
 We must try to ensure that, as a result of our own genetic manipulation, they do not turn out to be unpleasant surprises. 
 So the civil servants in the Department of the Environment are to be congratulated. 
 They have recognised that the laws to protect our environment need to be extended and revised to cope with the situation genetic engineering presents. 
 They have, sensibly, realised that the benefits from proceeding with caution outweigh the risks and there is no case for banning the practice outright. 
 They have recommended that anyone who intends to release a genetically manipulated organism into the environment should first seek consent of some &bquo;competent authority&equo; which must be satisfied that the proposed release is as safe as reasonably practicable. 
 Release without consent will be a crime, regardless of the innocuousness or otherwise of the organism. 
 So far, so good. 
 But the civil servants have been vague when it comes to the detail of who is to be the competent authority, who is to foot the bill for its work (and any extra studies it may require before giving consent), and how much of its deliberations are to be made public. 
 Moreover, it seems as if the Thatcherite revolution has still not penetrated the dark towers of Marsham Street. 
 For there is no mention of how capitalism or the consumer can play their proper roles in determining the future of genetic engineering. 
 This is a serious omission, redolent of the old habits of thought that if only the public will trust Whitehall, all will be well. 
 One of the first commercial products to derive from this biotechnology is likely to be genetically engineered tomatoes. 
 By manipulation of the tomato's genetic blueprint, scientists can alter the rate at which it ripens. 
 This reduces the wastage due to damage in the journey from greenhouse to supermarket shelf. 
 There is a dual benefit to the consumer: because there is less wastage, the genetically engineered tomatoes ought to be cheaper; and they ought to taste better too. 
 Well then. 
 Let the consumer make the choice. 
 Let us make sure that the law to be put before Parliament this autumn requires genetically engineered products to be clearly labelled as such. 
 All the submissions to the Government from the biotechnology industry have called for greater public information about genetic engineering, so no one can object to giving consumers the chance to make informed choices as they push their supermarket trolleys. 
 It is also right that consumers should pay the full price of the advantages they will enjoy as a result of genetic engineering. 
 The market has a mechanism for ensuring even that the potential risk of damage to the environment can be costed. 
 It is called insurance. 
 Before the &bquo;competent authority&equo; sanctions any release into the environment it should stipulate that the releaser has to take out an insurance policy that will cover it for any consequential damage to the environment and necessary clean-up operations. 
 The cost of the premiums would, of course, be passed on to consumers in the price of the products. 
 After all, I am not allowed to drive a motor car without having proved my ability to a &bquo;competent authority&equo; &mdash; the driving test examiner. 
 But once I have passed my test, I am not allowed out on the road without insurance. 
 If such stipulations are made for so mundane a practice as motoring, they would seem to be reasonable precautions for protecting our environment for the rest of time from possible damage by man-made creatures. 
 How hot summers brought us stripped pines: Scientists now believe a dramatic loss of conifer needles which struck West German forests may have been caused by the weather, rather than pollution. 
 Martyn Kelly reports 
 By MARTYN KELLY 
 IN THE mid-1980s press stories about coniferous trees in German forests losing their needles were at their peak. 
 Half a decade on, global warming has become the biggest environment story. 
 However, the cause of tree blight has remained the subject of intense speculation, being variously attributed to &bquo;acid rain', ozone, a mystery disease, or any combination of these. 
 But now scientists believe the root cause of Germany's problems could simply be drier weather, albeit aggravated by acid deposition and by the growing tendency for forests, like farmland, to be planted as monocultures. 
 In German forests, there was a consistent pattern of damage to Norway spruce, the main species affected, beginning with a yellowing of the upper surface of older needles and progressing to the death of the needle and a marked thinning of the crown of the tree as dead needles dropped off. 
 The colour change from green to yellow suggested that the key may lie in chlorophyll, the compound responsible for photosynthesis. 
 They followed this up to show that affected leaves had lower concentrations of magnesium, an important part of the chlorophyll molecule. 
 The disease theory was discounted early on by Reinhart Huttl of the University of Freiburg, who grafted affected shoots on to otherwise healthy trees. 
 The mystery virus, it was thought, would spread into the healthy tree, causing that too to become diseased. 
 In fact, the opposite was the case; the grafts became green. 
 If disease was not responsible, then perhaps the answer lay with a physical cause such as air pollution. 
 There were two contenders for this: acid deposition (in all its various forms) and ozone. 
 Bernard Ulrich and colleagues at the University of Gottingen had proposed that deposition of sulphur and nitrogen compounds (originating from industrial activity and power generation) led to the release of aluminium from minerals in the soil. 
 This, in turn, was toxic to the tree roots responsible for uptake of nutrients such as magnesium. 
 Meanwhile, in laboratories in Essen, Bernard Prinz was suggesting that forest decline was caused by damage to foliage by ozone, another gas produced as a by-product of industry. 
 However, Siegfried Fink, a colleague of Huttl at Freiburg, found that needles exhibiting the symptoms of forest decline showed changes initially in the vascular cells of needles, which transport nutrients from the roots. 
 From here, damage spread to the cells responsible for photosynthesis. 
 A needle exposed to gaseous pollutants such as ozone, on the other hand, showed signs of damage first in the more exposed photosynthetic cells and only later in the better-protected vascular tissues. 
 Scientists working for Britain's Central Electricity Generating Board also found flaws in the experimental techniques used by Prinz and his colleagues. 
 The Germans used a machine which converted oxygen in air into the ozone which they used for their experiments. 
 However, Drs Keith Brown and Mike Roberts found that nitric acid was produced from atmospheric nitrogen at the same time and that this was responsible for most of the damage. 
 When they repeated their experiment with ozone produced from pure oxygen they found very little effect. 
 Mike Roberts and colleagues at the CEGB's research laboratories now think that air pollution plays only a minor role after all (Forestry, vol 62, pp 179-222). 
 They agree that yellowing needles are caused by magnesium deficiency. 
 However, they are not convinced that the primary cause of this is toxic concentrations of aluminium released into the soil as acidity increased. 
 Instead they see low concentrations of magnesium as a natural phenomenon exacerbated by air pollution. 
 The prime cause, they believe, was a succession of dry summers in the mid-1970s. 
 Drought resulted in decreased root growth and slower breakdown of soil litter, an important source of magnesium for forest trees. 
 A further factor complicating the story is the trend towards monoculture of timber trees such as spruce. 
 This increases soil acidity, and encourages trees to form shallow roots, which are less efficient and more prone to the effects of drought. 
 It was a slowing down of the spread of forest decline in the late 1980s that first pointed the CEGB scientists towards climate as the cause. 
 In 1984, foresters found that 20 per cent of the Norway spruce in West Germany's forests had lost more than a quarter of their needles. 
 By 1988 this had dropped to about 15 per cent of spruce, and other species such as pine and fir showed similar improvements. 
 In other words, the symptoms were at their worst during the hot, dry summers of the early Eighties and started to improve in subsequent wet summers. 
 It is, cynics might say, exactly the conclusion one would expect from scientists in the pay of the CEGB. 
 However, Mike Roberts, now director of the Natural Environment Research Council's Institute of Terrestrial Ecology (South), is quick to point out that acid deposition does exacerbate the problem, in particular by washing magnesium from an already nutrient-poor soil. 
 Deposition of nitric acid in particular may contribute to the equation as a fertiliser as well as a pollutant per se. 
 This is because the increased supply of nitrogen may encourage tree growth at a faster rate than the amount of magnesium in the soil can support. 
 The mechanism which Roberts proposes might be expected to work anywhere that spruce is grown. 
 However, forest decline was far more extensive in Germany and continental Europe than, for example, in Britain and Norway. 
 This he attributes to our oceanic climate. 
 Proximity to the Atlantic means rainfall in Britain contains quite a lot of dissolved salts from the sea. 
 So although the wet climate in the west of Britain causes more magnesium to be washed from the soil than in Germany, this amount is far less than that added to the soil each year from rainfall. 
 The conundrums surrounding forest decline were many. 
 Why was it so regional in character? 
 Why did pollution-sensitive lichens survive on affected trees? 
 Demonstrating climate to be the primary cause clears up many such problems. 
 At the same time, it gives foresters and the power industry a much clearer picture of how their activities are affecting the trees. 
 Ironically, Mike Roberts is one person who welcomed the drought earlier this summer. 
 The extra stress that it will have caused to forest trees in Britain and the continent will provide one of the first tests of his new ideas. 
 Cricket First Test: Azharuddin's daring defiance 
 AS anti-climaxes go, they do not come better than this. 
 As history, nothing that happened here yesterday was ever likely to match the events of Friday, but as entertainers, the Indian batsmen generally hold their own. 
 They are still 277 behind England and only 43 ahead of Graham Gooch, but for exhilarating strokeplay, the honours are all with the Indian captain, Mohammed Azharuddin. 
 The unchallenged winner of the wooden spoon after putting England in on Thursday, he bounced back yesterday with an innings of magnificent irresponsibility. 
 He reached three figures, for the fourth time against England, in only 130 minutes and 87 balls. 
 It was the fastest hundred in a Test match in England since the heady days of 1981, and as a gambler's last throw, it was in the same class as Botham's 149. 
 In three innings against England this summer, he has yet to be out. 
 Not that Gooch was finished. 
 Four years ago, when Ian Botham returned from suspension and took a wicket with his first ball, Gooch trotted up from slip and asked him, &bquo;Who writes your scripts?&equo; 
 Whoever it was, Gooch seems to have hired them. 
 Yesterday, not content with turning England into a winning team and making the highest Test score of the modern era, he threw himself the ball &mdash; and removed the dangerous Sanjay Manjrekar with his third delivery. 
 The next wicket to fall was that of Ravi Shastri: Gooch caught him. 
 At pounds 150, the fee paid to the man-of-the-match adjudicator, Ray Illingworth, will work out at about pounds 300 per second's thought. 
 Unless, that is, Azharuddin gets another 217 tomorrow. 
 India had resumed at 48 for no wicket, needing another 406 to avoid the follow-on. 
 Shastri and Navjot Sidhu continued to enjoy both good fortune and the spaces which Gooch's attacking field left open. 
 Devon Malcolm and Angus Fraser opened the bowling and both started as they were to go on. 
 Malcolm's first ball was cut for four by Sidhu. 
 Fraser's first ball beat Sidhu outside off-stump; his second, angled in, was worth a shout for lbw. 
 The disappointing slowness of the pitch allowed both openers to play Malcolm off the back foot, and therefore to drive his attempted yorkers. 
 He has two kinds of Test performance &mdash; five for very few, and none for a lot, and this was looking like the latter. 
 But Fraser, steady as ever after missing five Tests through injury, found enough lift to have Sidhu sharply caught off bat and pad by John Morris. 
 Morris's contribution to this match is unlikely to find much space in Wisden, but he already looks the part. 
 When Chris Lewis replaced Malcolm, ball dominated bat for the first time in the match, with nothing to show for it. 
 Lewis bowled a yard quicker than on his debut at Edgbaston, hit an impeccable length, and moved the ball away. 
 When he was not bowling, his cat-like fielding at midwicket kept an appreciative crowd happy. 
 Shastri had gone on, barely noticed, to 50, when Gooch's gentle swingers drew Manjrekar into a loose cut and Jack Russell took the catch. 
 Dilip Vengsarkar came in looking for his fourth hundred in as many Lord's appearances and immediately joined Shastri in exploiting the unpatrolled third-man boundary. 
 After lunch (123 for two off 45 overs), India stepped on the gas and Gooch turned, not before time, to the off-spin of Eddie Hemmings. 
 Shastri blocked his first three balls, and hit the next three for 4-4-6 with a straight drive and two elegant swings over mid-wicket. 
 Malcolm's return brought him a straight push for three and a ninth Test hundred, but he immediately drove half-heartedly at Hemmings and gave Gooch a simple catch at mid-on. 
 Vengsarkar, who had been ticking along nicely, was now upstaged by Azharuddin. 
 Whatever the opposite of a captain's innings is, he was intent on playing it. 
 He got off the mark with an uppish straight drive for four, which might have given a less myopic bowler than Malcolm a return catch, and in Malcolm's next over, he attempted a square slash which, if he had got an edge, might have prevented him ever setting foot in India again. 
 Happily he missed, tried the shot again a few minutes later, and middled it. 
 He was sufficiently troubled by Malcolm's bouncer to stand frozen at the crease and take it on the helmet, but sufficiently brave to try to hook the inevitable follow-up. 
 He took three audacious fours off an over from Hemmings, and the loss of Vengsarkar, flicking at one of Fraser's worst deliveries, did nothing to sober him up. 
 His fifty contained 11 fours, and he celebrated with three more. 
 Sachin Tendulkar came in to a reception whose volume and pitch tended to confirm what Bishen Bedi had been saying about his sex appeal, and there was the arresting sight of a 41-year-old bowler taking on two batsmen whose combined age was 42. 
 After an hour had been lost to rain straight after tea, Tendulkar drove loosely at Lewis and lost his middle stump. 
 The only man capable of stopping his flow of boundaries was Dickie Bird, who took the players off for bad light for quarter of an hour at 5.30. 
 The new ball was taken as soon as it was available, and entrusted to Lewis. 
 Azharuddin gave him the three-fours-in-an-over treatment, driving all three off the back foot. 
 He may have been missed on 96 by Morris, low at mid-wicket; Morris may have decided that sections of the crowd would riot if he held it. 
 Lewis gave way to Fraser, and Azharuddin brought up a great hundred, and 1,000 for the match, with an easy clip for three. 
 He lost Manoj Prabhakar, carried away by the exuberance of his own and everybody else's strokeplay, but Kapil Dev survives - and he is the only Indian who has made a faster Test hundred than Azharuddin's. 
 If the follow-on now loomed large, Azharuddin could not see it. 
 The batting triumphs of Graham Gooch and Graeme Hick... 
 Page 24  
 Motor Racing: Fighting Senna refuses to succumb: Brazilian overcomes cramp and gremlins to keep Prost waiting 
 From MAURICE HAMILTON in Jerez de la Frontera 
 AYRTON SENNA did all he could to keep the championship open by yesterday winning the Spanish Grand Prix which, after a week of accusations and exclusions, was something of an anti-climax. 
 Senna led from the start and, apart from a brief skirmish in the opening laps, never came under serious pressure. 
 The Ferrari of Gerhard Berger finished second, 26 seconds ahead of Alain Prost's McLaren. 
 Prost's result does little to further his cause in the championship if he has to drop his lower scores but Senna now knows that he must win the final two races in Japan and Australia. 
 Prost, meanwhile, can do no more and the pressure is now with his team-mate to repeat yesterday's performance. 
 While Senna's steady but swift progress made his 20th Grand Prix victory look easy, the reigning world champion says this race has been one of the toughest. 
 &bquo;This is a very difficult circuit,&equo; Senna said. 
 &bquo;I expected it to be hard because, when we tested here last February, I did a full race distance and it was hard work, very painful.&equo; 
 After almost two hours at the wheel yesterday, Senna limped away from his car, the only obvious sign that he had suffered from brake trouble during the last quarter of the 73-lap race. 
 &bquo;I had cramp in my right leg,&equo; the Brazilian explained. 
 &bquo;I was going as carefully as I could because I had a 25-second cushion over Berger so I was able to slow down a bit and the pain eased. 
 Also, I had trouble with the gearbox, the lever became spongy and I wasn't sure what was happening. 
 It was quite a fretful race for me in many ways.&equo; 
 If Senna had not either won the race or finished second, he would have been out of the championship. 
 Senna said he realised that a good start was vital. 
 If Berger took the lead into the first corner, then Senna would have difficulty getting by on such a tight and twisting circuit. 
 Berger said: &bquo;He made it to the first corner ahead of me and I tried to hang on. 
 I pushed as hard as I could but it was obvious there was no chance of passing him.&equo; 
 Berger then decided to wait until the scheduled pit stops in the hope that the Ferrari crew could steal an advantage over the McLaren mechanics. 
 Unfortunately for Berger, both stops were exceptionally slick and, judging by the controversial aftermath of Nigel Mansell's botched pit stop in Portugal last week, perhaps that is just as well. 
 It is fair to say that this race lacked the energetic input normally associated with Mansell, banned from yesterday's Grand Prix after breaking the regulations at Estoril last Sunday. 
 Once the pit stops, shortly before half distance, were over, the race became even more tedious as Berger heeded sagging oil pressure and reduced his pace. 
 There was not even the threat of an attack by Prost since he, too, was suffering from gearbox trouble. 
 &bquo;This result is exactly what I was looking for,&equo; Prost said. 
 &bquo;It is very difficult to overtake on this circuit, so it was really mission impossible to get ahead of Senna and Berger in the early stages. 
 Shortly after the start I had problems with Gerhard's oil all over my visor, so I just drove my taxi home to take third place.&equo; 
 Clearly, the gearbox remained the Achilles' heel for the McLaren-Honda and it will doubtless cause Senna one or two anxious moments before this season ends in Adelaide on 5 November. 
 &bquo;I know it's going to be very hard for me,&equo; said Senna. 
 &bquo;But I don't intend to give up. 
 I will fight all the way.&equo; 
 That is a sentiment which is quietly echoed by McLaren and Honda since, if Prost wins the title, he will take the coveted No. 1 to Ferrari next year. 
 While Prost and Senna continued their dispute for this year's title, Jean Alesi reinforced pit lane opinion that the young Frenchman is a future champion. 
 After a stirring drive, Alesi finished fourth for Tyrrell and, along the way, he had to deal forcefully with Britain's Martin Brundle, the Brabham driver eventually spinning off. 
 Brundle's trouble had been caused by a split exhaust pipe which overheated a shock absorber. 
 An eventful race for Derek Warwick brought the British driver ninth place but only after he had wiped off a nose cone on his Arrows when he tangled with Nelson Piquet's Lotus. 
 The penultimate round of the championship will be in Japan on 22 October. 
 Golf: Calcavecchia digs in for consolation prize 
 By TIM GLOVER at St Andrews 
 IT COULD be said that the Scottish appetite for golf is so healthy they would turn out to watch anybody play. 
 Even Americans against the Japanese. 
 An uncommonly large crowd walked the links here yesterday, a neutral army encouraged to watch the final of the Dunhill Cup by the prospect of topping up a tan in October sunshine. 
 Some of them, by no means all, paid &pound;7 to witness Mark Calcavecchia, Curtis Strange and Tom Kite win &dollar;100,000 (&pound;62,000) apiece. 
 This particular America's cup bears no comparison to the trophy they failed to capture at The Belfry. 
 Even so, the money helps. 
 Asked if this was consolation following the tie in the Ryder Cup, Kite replied: &bquo;Yep. 
 We had our minds made up that we were going to win this thing. 
 We were all disappointed with the Ryder Cup. 
 Everybody talked about the good of golf but I don't think any of the 24 players were satisfied with the outcome.&equo; 
 Calcavecchia, who defends the Open Championship here next summer, had never seen St Andrews before and he improved with every round. 
 In the 36-hole final yesterday, he went round in a five-under-par 67 to defeat Hajime Meshiai by a stroke. 
 Kite and Naomichi Ozaki shot 68 and Strange defeated Koichi Suzuki with a 72 to a 75. 
 Thus the United States established a 2&frac12;&ndash;&frac12; lead. 
 Calcavecchia was again first out in the afternoon and he gave poor Meshiai no respite, scoring 66 to a 73. 
 On the day Calcavecchia was 11 under par and had 12 birdies and an eagle. 
 However, he became a victim of Sod's Law and not everybody appreciated his play. 
 On the 12th green second time around he was so far from the hole he decided to use his wedge instead of his putter and took a six-inch divot out of the hallowed ground. 
 Some people booed. 
 He repeated the act (the greenkeeper would probably say it was vandalism) at the 14th green. 
 It mattered not that Kite was beaten by Suzuki and Strange by Ozaki for the Americans already had an unassailable 3 &frac12; points on the board. 
 &bquo;I really enjoyed it,&equo; Calcavecchia said, yawning in mid-sentence. 
 &bquo;I knew I was going to be tough to beat this week. 
 I think I'm a great putter, sometimes an incredible putter. 
 It seems that every time I come back from a big disappointment I win.&equo; 
 For putter read wedge. 
 His big disappointment in the Ryder Cup was losing to Ronan Rafferty on the final day after twice putting the ball into water. 
 Earlier in the season, in the final round of the Bob Hope Classic, he putted like the comedian and lost the tournament by a stroke. 
 The following week he won in Phoenix by seven strokes. 
 Over the next two weeks West Germany will have the pleasure of his company. 
 &bquo;I've had enough of this team stuff,&equo; he said. 
 In the play-off for third place &mdash; &dollar;36,666 (&pound;22,773) per man - England beat Ireland 2-1. 
 The match hinged on the confrontation between Christy O'Connor Jnr and Mark James and it was effectively settled at the first hole. 
 It is a hole in the head as far as the Irishman is concerned. 
 Against the United States on Saturday, O'Connor Jnr, in a sudden-death play-off against Kite, hit a wedge into the Swilken Burn which runs across the front of the green. 
 Yesterday he hit an eight-iron into the same stream and took a triple-bogey seven to James's four. 
 At the second he had a bogey five to James's three and was five strokes adrift. 
 &bquo;I'm done,&equo; O'Connor Jnr said. 
 &bquo;I was like a zombie out there.&equo; 
 Rugby Union: The dye is cast for injured Richards 
 By STEVE BALE 
 ENGLAND will almost certainly be without their inspirational Lions No. 8, Dean Richards, when they play Fiji in five weeks. 
 Richards, who did not attend yesterday's badly disrupted squad session at The Stoop, is to have dye injected into his injured shoulder to show up the extent of the damage. 
 &bquo;You can't predict anything until he has seen the scan, but Dean is looking very doubtful,&equo; England's manager, Geoff Cooke, said. 
 Wade Dooley and Paul Rendall were also absent. 
 Seven players &mdash; Carling, Oti, Hill, Moore, Mullins, Linnett and Teague &mdash; attended the session but did not train with the squad. 
 Two, Bailey and Egerton, finished early. 
 Cooke accepts that Chris Oti will not be ready to face Fiji. 
 Mike Teague (who now has a knee, as well as a shoulder, injury) is doubtful but Will Carling, the captain, says he will be fit despite being concussed in Harlequins' win over London Irish. 
 Carling has already targeted Quins' First Division game with Orrell on 28 October for his return. 
 In Wales, battle lines are being drawn for Friday's meeting to debate the severing of links with South Africa. 
 Clive Rowlands, the Welsh RU president, has written to member clubs urging them to follow this course. 
 &bquo;We have been brought to our present position by the policy and behaviour of the South African Rugby Board,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They have been ready to give priority to their own interests regardless of the effects on other unions and particularly on the Welsh Rugby Union.&equo; 
 Rowlands has been critical of Welsh officials who went to the SA Rugby Board celebrations. 
 But Terry Vaux, the WRU committeeman who resigned from the International Board because of the row, has written to clubs in his area, Gwent, informing them that Rowlands had encouraged him to attend. 
 Welsh rugby is also in trouble on the field &mdash; on Saturday, five weeks before Wales play New Zealand, they lost to Bridgend &mdash; and a thigh injury in that debacle has put David Young out of the Home Unions XV who play France on Wednesday. 
 Jeff Probyn, the England and Wasps prop overlooked for the Lions tour, has been called up as his replacement. 
 Donal Lenihan, who had been named as captain, has also withdrawn after injuring a shoulder. 
 His place in the second row is taken by Scotland's Damian Cronin, with England's Rob Andrew taking over the captaincy. 
 Football: FA investigates crowd trouble 
 By STEVE BALE 
 THE Football Association is to launch an inquiry into the crowd trouble involving Birmingham City supporters at Blackpool on Saturday, when police in riot gear had to move into the terraces to part fighting fans. 
 Adrian Titcombe, the FA's crowd management co-ordinator, said: &bquo;We want to be clear where the trouble occurred so we will study all the reports before coming to any conclusion.&equo; 
 The FA made Birmingham's away matches all-ticket after trouble at Crystal Palace last season and Chief Supt Kenneth McKay, head of Blackpool police, said fans without tickets caused most of the trouble. 
 &bquo;Two hundred fans arrived without tickets and there were 3,000 in the town causing all manner of problems, terrorising elderly women and children,&equo; he said. 
 The FA will also investigate Dunstable's bizarre exit from the FA Cup on Saturday when the entire team walked off in their second-round qualifying tie at Staines after having three players sent off in the first 38 minutes. 
 The Southern League team are expected to be expelled from the competition. 
 Kevin Drinkell, the Rangers striker, will join Coventry City today for &pound;800,000 and make his debut against an old club, Grimsby, in the Littlewoods Cup on Wednesday. 
 Peter Davenport, who joined Middlesbrough from Manchester United for &pound;700,000 less than a year ago, may seek a move after being left out of the squad for Saturday's game at Watford. 
 Cycling: Vanderaerden's Classic clout 
 By ROBIN NICHOLL with the Nissan Classic 
 AFTER four days of sparring, Eric Vanderaerden unleashed his Sunday punch to knock out the fading hopes of Sean Kelly, and the whole of Ireland, in the Nissan Classic, which finished in Dublin yesterday after five days and 925km. 
 The Belgian, who had popped out of the clinches to snatch narrow verdicts in three mass sprint finishes, settled the race with a remarkable show in the 40km time trial. 
 Not since 1985, when he won a Tour de France time trial, had Vanderaerden shown such form against the clock. 
 Not only did he catch a crestfallen Kelly, who had started a minute ahead of him, but he socked the hopes of Frenchman Charly Mottet and the Swiss powerhouse Thomas Wegmuller. 
 Vanderaerden averaged more than 46kph to beat Mottet by nine seconds, then, aided by his Panasonic teammates, carefully controlled the afternoon race through the Wicklow mountains. 
 &bquo;I now feel that I am back to the form I had three years ago, and after my performances in Ireland, I feel I can win the Paris-Tours classic next Saturday,&equo; he said. 
 Kelly finished fourth overall, ousted from second place by Mottet and Wegmuller, and came close to losing the King of the Mountains honour. 
 Only on the final climb of Sally Gap did he clinch victory as his rival, Gary Baker, was struggling back from two punctures. 
 Kelly, who has won this race three times, said: &bquo;It has been a very long and hard season for me, and I feel very tired. 
 Still, the best man won.&equo; 
 Rugby League: Kiwis humbled by Saints 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 St Helens.... 27 New Zealand.. 26 THE meagre attendance of 6,940 at Knowsley Road was hardly surprising, given Alex Murphy's under-selling of his own side, but the Saints supporters who stayed away missed a rare and unexpected rugby league treat. 
 Tony Gordon's Kiwis, who will now find it difficult to go through the remainder of their tour undefeated, are not as tight and efficient a force as Graham Lowe's team of four years ago, but with a virtual Test side out, should have been far too strong for Murphy's collection of reserves. 
 That Saints managed to cause an upset with nothing more than direct running and honest endeavour, bodes well for Great Britain, though the Kiwis cannot be expected to enter the Test arena in such a generous mood. 
 Gary Freeman, for instance, the scorer of the tries which knocked Britain out of the World Cup last year, was yesterday to be seen vainly flapping after Roy Haggerty, prior to Neil Holding's all-important drop goal. 
 The Kiwis wasted two excellent try opportunties with careless forward passes, and gifted St Helens the opening try when David Watson allowed Alan Hunte a 15th-minute interception. 
 Quick replies by Kelly Shelford and Mark Elia led to the suspicion that New Zealand could score at will and were easing themselves into their stride, but doubts arose early in the second half with a succession of missed chances. 
 It was Stuart Evans, bringing a touch of Cardiff Arms Park to the proceedings with a pushover try in the right corner, who brought Saints to within a point at 14-15. 
 New Zealand pushed out to 26-15 with a Kevin Iro try and a second from Elia, but after David Tanner had pegged two points back with a penalty, the winger claimed the try of the match by finishing a thrilling move between Phil Veivers and Mark Bailey. 
 Paul Forber scored from close range three minutes from the end to give Saints a one-point lead and the crowd, such as it was, went wild. 
 There was even closing drama when Shelford missed a penalty, and a chance to save the game, with the last kick of the match. 
 It was entertaining viewing for Mal Meninga, watching the game with his Canberra colleagues, but the Australian declined a &pound;50,000 offer, made after the game, to rejoin St Helens. 
 Athletics: Elliott's win saves blushes 
 By NEIL WILSON 
 PETER ELLIOTT saved England's selectors from any embarrassment yesterday, finishing his track season unbeaten by domestic rivals. 
 Southwark Park, beside the Thames in London's former docklands, on a cool, grey October evening, is hardly Auckland, and Steve Cram was nowhere in sight. 
 But a victory by Elliott in the final event of General Portfolio's grandly mis-named Mile of Miles series was all that mattered to selectors three days after they chose him ahead of Cram for the Commonwealth Games. 
 It was never in doubt. 
 Only Said Aouita has beaten Elliott since the Yorkshireman returned to the track after an injury postponed the start of his season until mid-August. 
 Only a week ago, he was in New York beating the world champion, Abdi Bile, and the best of the rest at this distance. 
 Nobody remotely approaching that calibre threatened him yesterday. 
 Having won two of this series in the fastest times already, he would have had to finish four seconds behind the steeplechaser Mark Rowland to lose the first prize of &pound;5,000. 
 Elliott was not entirely satisfied. 
 He hoped to surpass Cram's fastest mile time of the year to remove the last argument against his own selection, but after two laps of inadequate pacing, he was never in prospect. 
 &bquo;This late in the year even pacemakers are tired,&equo; Elliott said after finishing in 3min 54.46sec. 
 He managed to complete the last lap with a flourish in a little under a minute, opening up a 10-metre lead down the back straight. 
 The &pound;3,000 prize in the women's event went to Bev Nicholson, another athlete bound for Auckland. 
 Rugby Union: Welsh horizon all turns black 
 By STEVE BALE 
 EACH new indignity in the heap visited on Welsh rugby seems worse than the last. 
 The selectors knew they were playing with fire when they decided to arrange a couple of club fixtures and they have duly been consumed in a conflagration of their own making. 
 The New Zealanders, appropriately garbed in funereal black, arrive next week to scatter the ashes. 
 On and off the field the national game of the Land of Song is in a discordant mess. 
 Losing was one thing but to lose as spinelessly as the Welsh XV did to Bridgend on Saturday was to add insult to severely injured pride. 
 &bquo;In all honesty we should have won by at least 15 points,&equo; Brian Nicholas, the Bridgend coach, said. 
 As if 24-17 and derisive chants of &bquo;Easy, easy&equo; were not bad enough, this humiliation was against a side who have made a wretched start to the season &mdash; a week earlier Pontypool had given them a 35-6 going-over &mdash; and were short of at least half-a-dozen first-choice players. 
 Four of the absentees suffered the squirming discomfort of being among the Welsh squad. 
 &bquo;It's not that I don't want to say anything but I just don't know what to say,&equo; John Ryan, the Welsh coach, sighed. 
 His plans in ruins, he is now reduced, Micawber-like, to hoping something will turn up before his players face the All Blacks in five short weeks. 
 At Bridgend he looked in despair, and he almost admitted as much: &bquo;I hope we can pull it together but sometimes I have my doubts.&equo; 
 Nicholas was sympathetic: &bquo;He is only as good as the players we give him.&equo; 
 But another selector confided the truth that Wales should be giving club opposition a hammering &mdash; and at half-time, building on their win over Newbridge, it looked as if they would. 
 They had weathered Bridgend's early fury, conceding a try before coming back with some confidence to score three of their own. 
 But Wales were having us on. 
 From the comparative opulence of 17-6 they then slipped into penury by conceding 18 unanswered points. 
 Bridgend raised their game against Wales; now Wales must do precisely the same against New Zealand. 
 No one who was at the Brewery Field (perhaps not even the selectors) would give twopence for their ability to do so. 
 The backs were mainly pedestrian but the fundamental problem lay elsewhere. 
 Apart from Kevin Moseley's steady supply from the line-out, there was nothing much to commend in a Welsh forward effort which reverted to the very worst Eighties stereotype of static, cumbersome donkeys only too willing to slow the game to walking pace. 
 &bquo;When the pressure comes on, players revert to bad habits,&equo; Ryan said. 
 The All Blacks would treat such an outmoded approach with the scorn it deserves, although on the other hand they might have been impressed with Bridgend's contrasting mobility and aggression. 
 The back row were swifter to the loose ball, had a clearer idea of what to do with it when they got there, and their impressive half-backs were given every opportunity &mdash; which they eagerly took &mdash; to control the game. 
 This was conveniently encapsulated in the first try. 
 Wales, characteristically, delayed the heel at a scrum, putting Robert Jones in trouble when the ball finally emerged. 
 He was scragged by Mike Budd, Jeremy Cooper came away with the ball, Owain Williams acted as the link, and Kevin Ellis scored: three back-row forwards and their scrum-half in perfect harmony. 
 Wales's instant reaction, a try by Arthur Emyr, and subsequent steady improvement, bringing well-crafted tries for Emyr and Robert Jones, promised more than was later fulfilled. 
 In the third quarter Bridgend had little difficulty in wiping out an 11-point deficit, Huw Bevan supporting Aled Williams's break for their second try. 
 It was a magnificent fightback and such was Welsh distress that they never looked like preventing it. 
 &bquo;We have taken a step backward,&equo; Ryan said &mdash; and on this sorry evidence it looks as if it will be backwards all the way when the Test takes place at Cardiff Arms Park on 4 November. 
 As the Welsh squad do not meet again until 30 October, time has all but run out. 
 Rugby Union: Summit a total success for Bath 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 Neath..... 13 Bath...... 17 WHEN the undisputed club champions of Wales and England collide, sparks can be expected to fly, and Saturday's game provided the perfect blend of drama, skill and excitement. 
 Since Neath were without five of their Welsh squad members, including their inspirational leader Kevin Phillips, when something had to give it was the home side. 
 Defeat for the Welsh All Blacks, particularly at the fortress that is The Gnoll, is a rare occurrence, hated by the players, frowned upon by the coaches and detested by the increasing army of fans who continue to pack the ground. 
 But whatever their collective response to coming second, no one could complain of losing to a Bath side so replete with experienced English caps and burgeoning talent. 
 The English Cup and league champions brought to an end a 33-match unbeaten home run by Neath, dating back to Pontypool's visit on 8 March, 1988, and recorded their first win over Neath since 1983. 
 Yet what pleased the Bath coach Jack Rowell more than the cold facts and figures was that his team had come to terms with Neath's &bquo;unique style of total rugby&equo;. 
 That was the greatest triumph. 
 &bquo;The only way forward for British rugby is to play that standard of game every week,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;Playing regularly in south Wales has helped us to go places and 10 years on it's nice to crown it with a win like this. 
 Now we must look to the next stage of development. 
 &bquo;As a side you have to learn to cope with new styles, temperaments and pressures. 
 That's one of the reasons why we want to play the best sides in Europe.&equo; 
 Having dispatched the pride of Romania, Steaua Bucharest, and the cream of Wales, Neath, Toulon are next on the Bath hit-list. 
 To succeed again they will have to improve their fitness and concentration, the only flaws in an otherwise faultless game-plan. 
 Having raced into a 14-point interval lead, thanks to two tries from Tony Swift, another from Richard Lee and a Jonathan Callard conversion, they nearly allowed themselves to be knocked out of their stride by Neath's bludgeoning approach. 
 Tries by Allan Bateman and Colin Laity brought the home team back into the hunt and set up a stirring finale to the heavyweight contest. 
 Rugby Union: Snook's struggle for survival 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 Bedford..... 6 Wasps...... 57 BEDFORD have now conceded 117 points in their last two matches and this latest reversal served only to illustrate the plight of a club who a few months ago were celebrating their arrival in the Courage First Division. 
 In theory, things can only get better; in practice, they may well become a lot worse before Wasps return in the league next March. 
 While Wasps could relax and enjoy their Goldington Road romp, Bedford learned nothing that they did not know already. 
 Frailties throughout the team had been ruthlessly exploited at Leicester, where they were taken for 60 points. 
 Here, within three minutes, Mark Bailey had rounded their defence for the first of his side's dozen tries. 
 It will require a miracle for Bedford to retain their status, even allowing for their few plus points &mdash; a top New Zealand coach, the arrival of a useful looking New Zealand scrum-half, and the fact that if the three national divisions are expanded, as proposed, next season, only one team will be going down from the First Division. 
 So Bedford must make the most of limited resources &mdash; and pray. 
 The Taranaki coach, Ian Snook, accepts that it is a hard task trying to keep Bedford afloat but, sink or swim, he will be grateful for any signs of improvement. 
 As for Grant Patterson, Snook's countryman may prove a crucial figure in Bedford's cause. 
 A sniping and competitive scrum-half straight out of the All Black mould, he has to serve out his time but qualifies to play in the league in the new year. 
 By then, Bedford will be left fighting for survival in four crunching closing fixtures and when Patterson makes his likely league debut it will be in Bath, of all places. 
 Then come Wasps, Rosslyn Park and finally Bristol. 
 Luck they need because on Saturday Wasps, one of the main contenders for the heavyweight Bath title, inflicted much mental and physical damage. 
 From Bailey's first thrust to Simon Smith's closing dig there was only one side in it as Bedford stumbled to their fourth defeat in five matches. 
 Rugby Union: Bowling swings it for Llanelli 
 By JIM HILL 
 Llanelli....... 27 Leicester....... 8 GOING for the gap took on a painful new meaning for Steve Bowling when he helped Llanelli claw their way back to win this entertaining game. 
 In scoring the try which restored Llanelli's lead and waning confidence deep in the second half, the left wing Bowling got an accidental boot in the mouth. 
 It left him dazed, bleeding profusely and minus a front tooth. 
 Bowling took no further part in the proceedings, but he may think it a small price to pay for providing one of the turning points in a memorable match. 
 It was a contest to restore one's faith in a game which is allegedly losing its way. 
 Llanelli, who had six of their best with Wales and several others injured, replaced experience with unbridled exuberance. 
 Leicester, who arrived without four regulars, were no less adventurous. 
 Orchestrated by their stand-off and acting skipper Les Cusworth, they were even prepared to run the ball from behind their own line and the kick to touch was an absolute last resort. 
 Rarely can two sets of forwards have covered so much ground and sustained so furious a pace in their efforts to set up scoring chances. 
 And outstanding among them were the visiting prop Wayne Richardson and Llanelli's hooker Andrew Lamerton. 
 To illustrate the excellence, the brothers Underwood combined to produce the best of the seven tries. 
 Tony, on the Leicester right, started it five yards from his own line with a brilliant burst which took him over the half-way line. 
 Richardson then made more ground and, when Cusworth spun out the scoring pass, England's Rory Underwood obliged with a typical one-handed touchdown. 
 John Liley converted to give Leicester a 12-10 lead which they stretched to 18-10 before Bowling and Llanelli hit back. 
 Rugby Union: Students deliver a lesson 
 By STUART ALEXANDER 
 Cambridge University.... 28 Northampton.............. 4 THE Light Blues looked anything but lightweight in their first run-out of the season against supposedly senior opposition. 
 First they had to lend some maroon LX Club shirts to a Northampton side who had forgotten to bring theirs along, and then the students gave a lesson in speed about the field, quick thinking and teamwork. 
 No wonder their coach Tony Rodgers could scarcely restrain a grin at the end as a cluster of Northampton committee men tried to work out why they had also travelled with little sense of direction, wit, wisdom or work rate. 
 Rodgers knows there is a long way to go before the big one in December, but he has the makings of a strong, hard pack and the chance of additional talent behind them providing injury does not intervene. 
 Although the No. 8 Rob Wainright broke his leg in midweek, he could be back in training in November, and in John Wilby he had a deputy who shone in the back row. 
 Northampton, too, were missing key players, going down by five tries to a consolation one. 
 Two tries, the first in under two minutes by Simon Holmes and the fourth by the hooker John Ashworth, were from alert attention to the ball at their own throw-in near their own line. 
 Andrew Davies, Paul Reed and captain Alan Buzza coped with the slippery drizzle to score the others, and Saints were spared another 14 points in missed kicks. 
 Rugby Union: Kelso in need of their imports 
 By BILL LEITH 
 Kelso........ 18 Heriot's FP.. 29 KELSO, the champions, languish bottom of the Scottish First Division &mdash; in the illustrious company of Hawick, among others &mdash; ironically after preparing more thoroughly than usual. 
 The harvest was early and they had a pre-season tour. 
 Hopes of a title hat-trick hang by a thread, but all is not quite lost. 
 Gary Callander, the former Scotland hooker, is in cracking form again and, with John Jeffrey staying down and grafting at second row, they took particular encouragement from their scrummaging in an 18-29 defeat by the powerhouse Heriot's. 
 Any real revival hopes, however, hinge on the New Zealanders Brian Bellingham, a wing, and Steve Autogavea, a lock, who are due to arrive from Auckland in midweek. 
 Since Sean Lineen changed nationality to win four caps last season, every Kiwi migrant is now the subject of intense scrutiny and great expectations. 
 In Bellingham's case, there is the added pressure of impressive advance billing from his ex-clubmate Lineen. 
 Had they seen Saturday's encounter, the Kiwis might have been tempted to catch a plane home. 
 Heriot's, stronger in the set-piece and sharper on the rare occasions play flowed, scored tries through Cameron Glasgow, Gary Kenhard and Peter Steven and kept their own line intact. 
 Some 35 penalties were awarded, the teams occasionally shaking their heads in bafflement. 
 Fortunately, frustration surfaced only in sporadic back-chat, but when teams such as Kelso and Heriot's, each with a tradition of expansive back play, fail to put on a show in glorious conditions something, surely, is wrong. 
 Rugby Union: Yorkshire's home works 
 By PAUL STEPHENS 
 Yorkshire.... 29 Durham....... 16 FORCED to abandon the selection policy that in recent seasons embraced many of the top players qualified for the county but living well out of it in favour of those representing clubs within the broad acres, Yorkshire made an emphatic and ebullient start at Otley in an effort to regain the title they last won in 1987. 
 The immediate benefit of discarding established regulars was an accumulated perception and zest for attack that Durham were unable to match. 
 Notwithstanding a marked inferiority at centre and back row, the champions, with only nine of their title-winning side and four newcomers to county rugby, made an unstinting contribution to a fluid game in which they were outscored in tries only three to four. 
 It was as well for Yorkshire that John Howe and John Dixon were unable to assert any aerial authority for, early in the first half, John Orwin collided with the newcomer Steve Harris, suffered a neck injury and, though he stayed on, was a virtual passenger. 
 He will miss tomorrow's encounter with Cheshire. 
 It meant that Yorkshire, if not previously committed to open plan, had no choice than to adopt one. 
 This suited Peter Buckton and Simon Tipping admirably; they made the best possible use of the loose ball, punching holes through the Durham defence so that, as the final quarter was reached, Yorkshire led 25-6. 
 Powerless to halt the irresistible Simon Irving and Paul Johnson, Howe led a spirited fightback with a try, to which Dave Cooke &mdash; the best of the title holders' backs &mdash; added another, but Johnson later confirmed Yorkshire's legitimate hopes of being northern group winners with a third score from the backs. 
 Basketball: Roberts walks tall to fell Giants 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 BRACKNELL Tigers maintained their run as England's most successful pot hunters when they defeated Manchester Giants 97-91 in the final of the Tournament of Champions at the Granby Halls, Leicester. 
 For the Tigers, who won the Coca-Cola National Cup and NatWest Trophy last season, Dale Roberts collected 34 points and the game's Most Valuable Player award. 
 Kingston, whose coach Kevin Cadle watched Friday night's semi-final, did not qualify for the tournament because they did not compete in the League last season although their form over the past three weeks suggests they will be front runners over the next seven months. 
 Just five minutes into Saturday's final Giants lost the 6ft 9in England forward Dave Gardner with a sprained ankle. 
 His departure, combined with those of Chris Kearney and Jason Fogerty who both fouled out in the last five minutes, proved crucial to the outcome. 
 In the first half Bracknell, inspired by another England player, Tony Balogun, had opened a 36-24 lead. 
 But they trailed 58-53 early in the second period after Giants' Kevin St Kitts and Jerry Johnson spearheaded a 14-0 spurt. 
 From then until the final three minutes rarely more than one basket separated the teams, as Tigers came back again, until Roberts scored and free-throws from Tom Seaman and Paul James gave Bracknell breathing space at 95-92. 
 Roberts, fittingly, scored the game's final point from the foul line. 
 Australian Rules: Hawks swoop to be team of the decade 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 (First Edition) HAWTHORN won their second consecutive Victorian Football League premiership on Saturday, defeating Geelong by six points before more than 100,000 spectators in Melbourne. 
 The victory, 21-18 (144) to 21-12 (138), established the Hawks as the club of the decade, it being the team's fourth title in seven years, and their ninth consecutive grand final. 
 Hawthorn took the lead early in the first quarter and the Cats then had to play catch-up. 
 Geelong forward Gary Ablett led his team with a record-breaking nine goals and became only the second person to win the most valuable player award while playing on a losing side. 
 Geelong, who finished ninth last year, were the underdogs for the match but came within one straight kick of achieving the impossible dream, in coach Malcolm Blight's first year. 
 Football: Hazard hints at the missing gifts 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY 
 HOW TO describe Saturday's match between Chelsea and Arsenal? 
 Well, I seem to recall a London gallery exhibiting a pile of rubbish, which was considered valid art by the proprietors and drew a large attendance. 
 The only redeeming feature of a goalless, worthless event at Stamford Bridge was that it did not require a grant. 
 Yet the Chelsea manager, Bobby Campbell, and Arsenal assistant, Theo Foley, agreed it had been a good match, and the spectators' complaints were muted. 
 Some even applauded the players at the end. 
 It takes all sorts. 
 Bobby Robson was there to assess World Cup candidates, but nothing positive emerged from 90 minutes of scuffling that made one almost yearn for the more measured boredom of Rangers' European Cup exit in Munich three days earlier. 
 At least the outcome was appropriate. 
 Had either of the teams won, they would have taken the League leadership. 
 Instead Liverpool stayed top without kicking a ball. 
 Television had postponed Manchester United's scheduled visit to Anfield so it could be shown live on 22 December, the longest night. 
 London's leading pair, as if piqued by this, turned 30 September into the longest afternoon. 
 On and on it dragged. 
 Lacking a goal that might have altered its chemistry, it remained a matter of dull physics. 
 Yet many of the crowd were kept interested by the possibility of victory, which is, I suppose, what derbies are about. 
 They are so frequent these days in London, which has eight of 20 First Division clubs, that we must expect aesthetic considerations to be overridden. 
 Why, though, could these supposed championship contenders not have tried to emulate the fine passing that had sprinkled the previous weekend's Merseyside joust? 
 The simple answer is that Chelsea are in a false position and Arsenal, on this evidence, slightly jaded champions. 
 They ought to have pocketed three points in the first half-hour but Tony Adams, a more threatening centre-forward on his forays than the current Alan Smith, missed the target with two headers and David Rocastle let Dave Beasant save a penalty, much as the stretch-version keeper had done for Wimbledon in the 1988 FA Cup final. 
 Now an Arsenal team in peak health would have kept a grip on the match. 
 This one could not. 
 As George Graham indicated upon his side's accession to the title, they would need more composure and sophistication to match Liverpool in the longer term. 
 He chose not to hasten the process by buying. 
 After all, he had just the man on his staff. 
 But Paul Davis remains unfit. 
 His absence is increasingly conspicuous and Liverpool, for the moment, in a super league of one. 
 Davis, of course, would have walked into England's team in Poland a week on Wednesday; until last season's prolonged suspension, followed by injury, Bobby Robson had him firmly pencilled in as Bryan Robson's replacement. 
 Michael Thomas, several years younger, is not quite in the same class yet but may have to play in Chorzow. 
 If so, it will be a gamble, because he flopped on his only previous international appearance in Saudi Arabia. 
 The odds are favourable enough according to Chelsea's Mike Hazard, who said of his adversary: &bquo;He could cope in Poland, not just because of his ability to close people down and use the ball well, but temperament &mdash; you saw that when he scored the goal that won Arsenal the League.&equo; 
 Very kind, but international players are supposed to be habitually influential, and it was Hazard who in the second half, with a few incisive passes, gifts from the heavens on a day like this, left a greater mark. 
 Chelsea might have won had the ball not kept turning into a Mexican bean at Kerry Dixon's feet. 
 Campbell's hard-working side are still trying to sort out their system, which involves a spare defender and, as far as one can see, a good deal of improvisation. 
 It should suit Tony Dorigo, the unblooded England left-back, though oddly his rival, Nigel Winterburn, did more rampaging on Saturday; neither, in truth, made the heart pound. 
 Dorigo at least had the satisfaction of seeing his direct opponent and England colleague David Rocastle withdrawn. 
 All in all, Bobby Robson must have found it about as fruitful as a day trying to get in touch with Brian Clough. 
 There was, however, one aspect that deserves commendation. 
 After 16 minutes Graham Roberts was injured by a tackle for which Perry Groves was booked (Steve Clarke took over as sweeper, and is likely to have several weeks in which to build on a promising display). 
 Roberts's ankle appeared broken, but the Chelsea players were not interested in retribution and the club, as soon as they knew the injury was less serious, put a message on the electronic scoreboard: an example of public relations from which others could learn. 
 Football: Lineker crackers paper the cracks 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 Tottenham Hotspur..... 3 Queen's Park Rangers.. 2 THE GROUND is beginning to look like the finished article, but work on the team is still behind schedule. 
 The East Stand at White Hart Lane, open for business for the first time, provided a gleaming backdrop for Gary Lineker's first hat-trick for two years, but Gary's glory game served only to paper over Tottenham's cracks. 
 QPR are not good enough to finish in the top six, according to Trevor Francis, their player-manager, but they should have won and would surely have done so but for a mind-boggling miss by Andy Sinton when it was 2-2. 
 For the second week in succession, Spurs' dodgy defence had thrown away a 2-0 lead. 
 Lineker spared their blushes this time, but not even the striker acclaimed by Francis as Europe's best (Gullit may sue) can oblige every week if the requirement is two goals for a draw, three for a win. 
 &bquo;Of course, some things are still not right,&equo; Terry Venables, approaching the second anniversary of his appointment, said. 
 Two new players were needed to take Spurs where they wanted to go. 
 Murmurs of discontent off-stage. 
 &bquo;He has signed 12 already. 
 Where are they going &mdash; Twickenham?&equo; 
 The most pressing need is for a centre-half to prevent the sort of soft header with which David Bardsley brought QPR back into contention, and a more productive partner for Lineker. 
 Venables continues to pursue Mark Wright, Derby County's England defender, and is giving serious consideration to the swap proposed by Everton which would take Paul Stewart, Tottenham's blunt instrument of a centre-forward, to Goodison Park in exchange for Tony Cottee. 
 The deal would have been done by now but for Venables's reservations about playing two penalty-area sniffers together without an orthodox No. 9 to provide an aerial target. 
 It worked at West Ham, where Cottee enjoyed a profitable partnership with Frank McAvennie, who is scarcely from the Mick Harford mould. 
 And anyway, the bottom line should be Cottee is unquestionably a better footballer than Stewart. 
 In contrast to his partner's thud and blunder, Lineker's finishing was of the highest order. 
 His second goal was the highlight of the afternoon &mdash; the single-minded determination to score almost as impressive as the execution which saw him hold off Paul Parker and Alan McDonald and allow the ball to run past him before spinning and shooting across David Seaman, from right to left. 
 Two-nil up at home against moderate opposition &mdash; it would have been downhill all the way for most teams. 
 But then most teams are not lumbered with Spurs' defence. 
 Bardsley and Francis profited from their collective inadequacy, and at 2-2 it was anybody's game. 
 It should have been QPR's, when Sinton, set up by Bardsley, somehow contrived to shoot wide. 
 Instead, Nayim's cutback from the byline on the left enabled Lineker to win it for Tottenham. 
 Four goals in two games. 
 Was he over his illness and restored to peak efficiency? 
 A thin smile. 
 &bquo;Not that one again. 
 Every time I go through a lean spell I've lost a yard; every time I score a goal it means I'm over the hepatitis. 
 I always knew the goals would come.&equo; 
 Football: UEFA Women's Championship Group Three game at Brentford 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 Jan Murray, the England left wing, avoids becoming the filling in a Finnish defenders' sandwich during the UEFA Women's Championship Group Three game at Brentford yesterday. 
 England failed to take their chances, many of which were created by Gillian Coultard in midfield, and the game finished goalless Photograph: Peter Jay  
 Football: Platt ploughs a lone furrow of excellence 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 Aston Villa....... 1 Derby County...... 0 WHEN the tough get going, to paraphrase that wonderful bit of locker-room nonsense, the Villa usually get left behind. 
 In defeating Derby they simply got lucky. 
 Villa began the afternoon where they finished in May, one rung above the relegation places, although this time last year they stood fifth in the First Division. 
 That they are already struggling clearly troubles Graham Taylor. 
 The Villa manager spent &pound;1.2m in February on Ian Ormondroyd and Nigel Callaghan &mdash; neither of whom made Saturday's starting line-up &mdash; and a further &pound;1m during the summer. 
 Taylor wanted the Rangers striker Kevin Drinkell &mdash; now Coventry-bound &mdash; but chairman Doug Ellis was apparently reluctant to back his judgement. 
 A separation may now be imminent. 
 David Platt is making a brave fist of replacing Alan McInally &mdash; his goal, brilliantly struck from an angle after he had gone round Peter Shilton, was his fifth this season &mdash; but he cut a solitary, composed figure in a side bereft of confidence and quality. 
 Derek Mountfield and Kevin Gage were horribly out of touch; the scalpel tongues went for Chris Price in that peculiarly cutting way reserved for baldies playing badly; and the introduction of Ormondroyd, the forward built like a Handsworth tower block, brought cruelly sarcastic cheers. 
 Where does that leave Derby? 
 Aggrieved after looking the more cohesive, balanced unit; incredulous that after so many chances they still have just five goals. 
 Dean Saunders should at least have emulated Trevor Francis's hat-trick at Villa Park a week earlier, and Paul Goddard's anger at being substituted suggested all is not well with last season's fifth-placed team. 
 Arthur Cox's admiration for John Fashanu is well known, and perhaps it is time for the Maxwell millions to be used to purchase just such a battering Ram. 
 The need for an element of surprise is also glaring, and it would be worth Cox's monitoring the John Sheridan situation at Forest. 
 Both sides are in Littlewoods Cup action this week. 
 Derby start 2-1 down to Cambridge and Villa defend the same score at Wolves, where Taylor may have to trust in another piece of sports sagacity. 
 Fast guys tire, a basketball coach once said of his own high-rise team, but big guys don't shrink. 
 Football: Bowen belittles the Millwall machismo 
 By NICK DUXBURY 
 Millwall........ 0 Norwich City.... 1 GRAFFITI displaying the legend &bquo;lesbians ignite&equo;; T-shirts bearing the sinister slogan &bquo;These colours do not run&equo;; and simulated sex over the Tannoy gave every indication that Millwall was still a Den of iniquity. 
 Innocuous would be nearer the mark. 
 The activists' message scrawled on a wall near the ground is some way removed from the burning passions normally aroused by football, while the T-shirts are more machismo than menace, and pop songs peppered with heavy breathing are apparently in vogue if not in keeping with pre-match entertainment. 
 Cold Blow Lane no longer chills the blood for all the wrong reasons, but that is not to say the Lions have gone soft. 
 Norwich will testify to a victory hard won. 
 Millwall were unbeaten at home and only the Canaries' ability to metamorphose into a giant yellow sponge kept Teddy Sheringham and Tony Cascarino soaked in sweat and starved of success. 
 The squeeze was on from the start, Mark Bowen clearing off the line in the fourth minute and again in the 84th from Terry Hurlock's drive as Norwich maintained a startling statistic of having yet to concede an away goal. 
 They have also yet to lose in the League, Millwall's threat being thwarted by a dogged defence and a dollop of luck. 
 The Lions like the high way but are not rigid disciples of one code, and passes to feet compared favourably with passes measured in feet from the ground. 
 The pass master was Gary Waddock, playing only his second First Division game after a two-and-a-half year absence caused by a knee injury. 
 Waddock even overshadowed Hurlock until the sting of falling behind injected the long-haired harrier with more drive. 
 Millwall's chagrin was heightened by the knowledge that their redoubt had been stormed by a full-back, Bowen's 60th minute winner being a cold blooded execution from Robert Fleck's spear of a short through-ball. 
 As Bowen admitted, it had been &bquo;like the Alamo&equo; for Norwich and bastions was on the lips of every Millwall supporter as they headed home complaining of an iniquitous defeat, their moans contrasting the broadcasted cries of consummation. 
 Football: Nicholas needs live bullets 
 By DON LINDSAY 
 Aberdeen.... 1 Celtic...... 1 AS A CHEEKY teenager who was capable of scoring more than 30 goals a season, Charlie Nicholas earned the nickname the Cannonball Kid. 
 Sadly, Charlie's arsenal has been dampened and diminished in his post-Parkhead years, and finding the back of the net now has become rather less of a habit. 
 So far this season, Nicholas has fired only blanks, 13 matches having passed by without him hitting the target. 
 &bquo;He's not the first striker to go a few games without scoring,&equo; Alex Smith, the Aberdeen manager, said. 
 &bquo;It will eventually happen and when it does it will be like a release valve. 
 But as long as he is setting up things for other people, that's fine by me.&equo; 
 Nicholas's lack of success in front of goal, though, underlines Aberdeen's Achilles' heel &mdash; the inability to make pressure tell. 
 In Jim Bett, Paul Mason, Brian Grant and Craig Robertson, they have an effective and, at times, elegant midfield, which can impose its will on opponents, but too often the opportunities created come to nought. 
 Saturday's goal was the product of some poor defending by Celtic and the alertness of Mason in picking out the ginger nut of Alex McLeish, but, again, they relied on a defender to score. 
 Although two points clear of the pack, the writing is on the wall for Aberdeen unless someone starts banging goals away. 
 Joe Miller was the subject of praise from Billy McNeill, the Celtic manager. 
 The winger, who last Friday withdrew a transfer request, scored the equaliser and generally did his bit to rally the troops. 
 European Football: Maradona's restoration period 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 THE FORM book proved a poor guide yesterday when Napoli, who stumbled into the UEFA Cup's second round in midweek on penalties, won 3-0 against Milan, who had breezed through their first defence of the European Cup, writes Phil Shaw. 
 Internazionale shrugged off defeat by Malmo to beat the leaders, Roma, also by 3-0. 
 As if to underline the point, Malmo completed their regular season by losing 2-0 to relegated Vastra Frolunda, although they now play off for the Swedish title with Norrkoping. 
 Diego Maradona did most to restore Napoli to the top, creating headed goals (18 and 45 min) for Andrea Carnevale and scoring a virtuoso third (84). 
 Inter's treble came from Lothar Matthaus (26, 39) and Andreas Brehme (51). 
 In Spain Real Madrid now lead on goal difference from Atletico Madrid and Sevilla after a 4-1 win over Cadiz, Hugo Sanchez scoring two and Bernd Schuster one. 
 Basque nationalism surfaced during Athletic Bilbao's match against Atletico. 
 Demonstrators invaded the pitch, but they were repelled and play continued. 
 At half-time a giant Spanish flag was burned, and Atletico sent on Paolo Futre. 
 He made a goal (65) for Baltazar, but Howard Kendall's side equalised (70). 
 Football: Palace rise above Everton's kneading 
 By JONATHAN FOSTER 
 Crystal Palace.... 2 Everton........... 1 LIKE other Merseyside institutions before them, Everton can find scapegoats on their own left wing. 
 Passes played into space there created a two-goal, first-half deficit, which the patient patterns Everton built down their right flank ultimately merited to cancel: a team, in fact, of two halves. 
 The sinister side included Norman Whiteside, still short of full fitness and substituted after his irritability got him booked, and the right-footed Neil McDonald, an obviously uncomfortable deputy at left-back for Neil &bquo;Disser&equo; Pointon. 
 So the thrust of Everton movement was provided down the other side by Ian Snodin and Stuart McCall, to such effect during the second half that Steve Coppell, the Crystal Palace manager, likened the impression on his defence to kneading dough. 
 Maybe, but Palace were nothing if not doughty. 
 Geoff Thomas, a makeshift centre-back, put head, toes and abdomen to the ball in exemplary manner, and Andy Gray's defending was even more impressive than the passes he timed to perfection for both Palace goals. 
 The first was simple, after Gray had intercepted some sloppy play and sent Mark Bright through: goalkeeper Neville Southall parried the shot, but Ian Wright converted his fourth League goal of the season. 
 The second was altogether more clever: McDonald isolated and an offside trap jammed by a pass that Alan Pardew collected before shooting diagonally past Southall. 
 By then, the game was set in an exciting crescendo, Palace interrupting the openings contrived down the right by Mike Newell and Pat Nevin with breaks aimed at Wright's speed and control. 
 Wright looked acclimatised to the First Division, more so than his partner Bright, who has yet to score this season. 
 Newell has also arrived impressively from the Second and took his goal with poise. 
 Football: Bassett hounded by comparisons 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 Sunderland.......... 1 Sheffield United.... 1 WHAT gets up Dave Bassett's nostrils, as he so vividly put it after his side's draw at Roker Park, are the people who make comparisons between Sheffield United and his former club, Wimbledon. 
 &bquo;It's not the Wimbledon style of play with us, it's the Sheffield style. 
 You have to play according to the players you've got,&equo; he said. 
 All the same it is hard to resist the temptation to describe United's style as Wimbledon Mk II. 
 For a start, you have goalkeeper Simon Tracey, signed from Wimbledon last year. 
 He regularly plays the ball outside the 18-yard area before kicking it upfield. 
 Where did he learn that move? 
 At the heart of the defence is Mark Morris, a first-team regular with the Dons for seven years. 
 Then there is John Gannon in midfield. 
 He was six years with Wimbledon. 
 It does not really matter how you describe the style &mdash; Wimbledon, long ball, direct. 
 The fact is, it works and it has taken United to the top of the Second Division, unbeaten in nine League games. 
 Sunderland were handed an early goal by Brian Deane who headed Gordon Armstrong's inswinging corner high into his own net. 
 United completed the scoreline after 19 minutes through an Ian Bryson header. 
 Sport in Short: Volleyball 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 THE unseeded Anders Jarryd of Sweden overcame a shaky start to beat fifth-seeded Kevin Curren in the semi-finals of the San Francisco Grand Prix tournament. 
 Jarryd won 3-6 7-6 7-5 in 2hr 37min and now plays Brad Gilbert. 
 THE All England Club chairman, R E H &bquo;Buzzer&equo; Hadingham, 73, is to step down in December after six years in charge of Wimbledon. 
 JOHN McENROE and Michael Chang head the entries for the grand prix tournament at Wembley on 7-12 November. 
 Revised first-round draw: Italy v New Zealand; Soviet Union v Switzerland; Canada v Brazil; Spain v France; United States v Greece; Czechoslovakia v Belgium; Sweden v Japan; West Germany v Finland; Australia v China; Argentina v Philippines; Bulgaria v South Korea; Netherlands v Yugoslavia; Denmark v Poland; Britain v Indonesia; Austria v Mexico; Hungary v Thailand. 
 Sport in Short: Swimming 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 STAFFORD MURRAY, 19 days short of his 14th birthday, became the youngest winner of a senior county closed championship at the Leominster Leisure Centre, Herefordshire, yesterday when he defeated his coach, Peter Ratcliffe, 9-5, 9-7, 9-2 in the final. 
 Sport in Short: Speedway 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Snooker 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Sailing 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Rowing 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Rhythmic Gymnastics 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Rallying 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 JIMMY McCRAE, of Scotland, won the 2,200-mile round-Britain Autoglass Tour by 22 minutes at Brands Hatch yesterday when he finished second to Wales's David Llewellin in the final stage. 
 Sport in Short: Olympics 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 THE SPORTS COUNCIL is to support Manchester's bid to host the 1996 summer Games by giving the city &pound;50,000 towards staging 15 major sports events. 
 They will include the English Open table tennis tournament, the women's world and European weightlifting championships and the British and European 10m airgun championships. 
 Sport in Short: Motor Racing 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 DICK JOHNSON and John Bowe of Australia, in a Ford Sierra, led from the start yesterday to win the Bathurst 1,000-km touring car race from the West German pair of Klaus Niedzwiedz and Frank Biela, in another Ford Sierra. 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 BILL BRITTON won his first PGA Tournament without hitting a ball yesterday when the final round of the &dollar;750,000 Tallahassee Classic was rained out. 
 Sport in Short: Cycling 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 JEANNIE LONGO, of France, beat her own world 10km and 20km records and her one-hour high-altitude record yesterday. 
 Longo, a triple gold medallist at this year's world championships, clocked 12hr 59min 50sec in the 10km, 25:59.96 in the 20km and covered 46.35268km in one hour. 
 Sport in Short: Cricket 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 JESUS ROJAS, of Venezuela, won the World Boxing Association flyweight title from Fidel Bassa, of Colombia, after 12 rugged rounds in front of the champion's home crowd, in Barranquilla, on Saturday night. 
 Sport in Short: Bowls 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 SCOTLAND scored a crushing 20-5 victory over England in the Players' Association international at Carlisle. 
 The Scots, who led 12-3 overnight, needed only one more point to secure overall victory and clinched it in the first match to finish yesterday when Jim Muir beat Mike Marsden in straight sets. 
 Two Scots, Willie Wood and Hugh Duff, finished with 100 per cent records from their five matches. 
 Sport in Short: Baseball 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 GEORGE BELL drove in the last of three runs in the eighth inning as the Toronto Blue Jays came from behind for a 4-3 victory over the Baltimore Orioles in the SkyDome on Saturday and reached the American League championship series against the Oakland Athletics. 
 The first game of the best-of-seven series between the winners of the West and East divisions will be in California tomorrow. 
 Sport in Short: Badminton 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 ALLAN BUDI KUSUMA, thriving on the confidence gleaned from his victory over Denmark's world No. 1, Morten Frost, in the semi-finals, beat fellow Indonesian Eddy Kurniawan 15-7 15-12 to win the Dutch men's open title and move to the top of the world rankings. 
 Sport in Short: Athletics 
 By JOHN DOUGRAY 
 DOUGLAS WAKIIHURI, Kenya's premier marathon runner, took the lead after 10km of the 30km Lidingoloppet in Sweden and won the world's largest cross-country festival by two minutes. 
 Britain's Angela Tooby broke 4km from the finish to win the women's 15km race. 
 ROSA MOTA, Portugal's Olympic women's marathon champion, won a 10-kilometre race in a suburban Tokyo park, in 32min 31sec. 
 Sport in Short: American Football 
 Sport Page 28 
 Rugby League Round-Up: Eagles making a soar point 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 THE FORTUNES of two clubs who joined the League together during the summer of 1984 could hardly be more contrasting. 
 Sheffield Eagles' fortunes are soaring in the top flight; the 28-16 win at Wakefield was their third in four matches. 
 They came from 14-2 down at the break, and Trinity's failure was compounded by the sending off of Mark Conway. 
 Nottingham City, originally named Mansfield Marksman after a lager, remain marooned in the depths of the Second Division. 
 They led Halifax 8-4 at half-time only to collapse, punch-drunk, to a 72-20 defeat. 
 The only consolation was a crowd at the Harvey Hadden Stadium of 2,581, boosted by visiting fans. 
 In a bad-tempered match, Jason Ramshaw, the Halifax hooker, had his jaw broken, while his team-mate Richard Fairbank and Nottingham's Craig Whitehead were sent off. 
 Remarkably, Halifax's performance meant that the First Division leaders Wigan, 66-0 winners in a 12-try romp at Barrow, were not the day's top scorers. 
 Steve Clayton's eighth-minute dismissal for tripping hardly enhanced the home team's prospects. 
 Hull ended their four-game losing streak by beating Leeds 8-7 at The Boulevard. 
 Richard Gay, their teenage stand-off, set up the decisive try as Hull came from 7-4 behind in the closing minutes. 
 There were calls for the resignation of coach Kevin Ashcroft as Salford went down to another heavy defeat, 36-12 at home to a Bradford side inspired by their Canberra Raider, Ivan Henjak. 
 Three players were banished at Workington &mdash; Dave Lowden and Paul Penrice of the home side and Basil Akey from runaway winners Ryedale York. 
 Resurgent Fulham, home from Hendon, overran Carlisle 50-6 at Chiswick. 
 Hockey: Holwell quickly sets ball rolling 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 SUE HOLWELL, the England sweeper, had the honour of scoring the first goal in the Women's Typhoo National League when it got underway on Saturday. 
 In an early-start game her goal after seven minutes from a penalty corner set Leicester on their way to a 2-1 win against Exmouth. 
 Holwell got a second after the interval with the Exmouth captain, Rosie Goodridge, pulling one back in the last minute. 
 Chris Lysons, Great Harwood's goalkeeper, will remember her first National League game for different reasons. 
 Against Slough, she saved a penalty stroke from Karen Brown but was beaten six times &mdash; twice by Brown and twice by another GB striker, Kate Parker, the Slough captain, with further goals coming from Lesley Hobley and Sue Chandler, Slough's latest recruit. 
 Ealing were quickly into action in their game against Orpington, with Jane Jagger opening the scoring in the second minute following a brilliant move involving Joan Lewis and Mandy Langridge. 
 Lewis and Langridge added further goals before the interval with Anne Green and Andrea Gallyer completing the scoring in the second half for a convincing 5-0 win. 
 To complete an opening day which was lacking in surprises, Sutton Coldfield won 2-0 away at Chelmsford with goals from Jane Swinnerton and Sian Jones. 
 Meanwhile, Hightown were 3-0 winners against Clifton on the Bristol University ground. 
 Their goals were scored by Jackie Crook, Sue Jones and Maggie Souyave, England's former indoor captain. 
 A game with a difference took place at Wimbledon, the oldest women's club in the world, as part of their centenary celebrations &mdash; a costume game between a side representing the pioneers of the club and one representing the swinging Thirties. 
 Hockey: Hacker to the four 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 Wales.... 4 Italy.... 0 WALES'S men extended their unbeaten run to seven matches yesterday when they defeated Italy at the National Sports Centre, Cardiff, writes Bill Colwill. 
 This followed their 2-0 win over the Italians on Saturday. 
 Hounslow's David Hacker, who got both goals in the first match, opened the scoring yesterday after 10 minutes as Wales established quick control. 
 Hacker and his Hounslow club-mate, Jon Rees, were in dominant form in the Wales midfield, putting the Italian defence under constant pressure and it came as no surprise when Owen Mackney put Wales further ahead on the half hour. 
 Hacker put the match beyond doubt two minutes after the interval with his second strike, although Jeremy Fry in the Welsh goal was called upon to make two smart saves before, in the last minute, Mark Lewis, one of only two home-based Welsh players in the side, sent Antony Colclough away for the final goal. 
 As Welsh hockey moves up a step and they prepare for their European Cup qualifier next year, their next games are against Belgium at Newtown at the end of the month. 
 They will be more than grateful to the English Poundstretcher League for the experience being gained by 13 of their 16-man squad. 
 Tennis: Jones fears second lightning bolt 
 From Our Correspondent in Tokyo 
 WHEN Sara Gomer, Clare Wood and Julie Salmon collapsed to a 2-1 defeat to Indonesia in the first round of the Federation Cup in Melbourne last December, they were the laughing stock of the tennis world, writes our correspondent from Tokyo. 
 Tomorrow at the sprawling Ariake Tennis Centre here a changed, but not new, British team will face the same opponents, desperate to restore some of their lost pride. 
 Wood remains, but Jo Durie replaces Gomer while Anne Hobbs will take over from Salmon. 
 Although last year's result shocked most people in the sport the British team captain, Ann Jones, claims she was not among them and therefore she had a firm eve-of-play warning for her players. 
 &bquo;I have told them not to think that lightning can't strike twice,&equo; the former Wimbledon champion said. 
 &bquo;I have been in tennis long enough to know that it can. 
 It is nice that we can play them again so soon, but since last year I think they have improved.&equo; 
 Jones based her judgement on the fact that yesterday Indonesia crushed Malaysia in the qualifying round, losing just two games in their 3-0 win. 
 In many eyes, Britain could leave Tokyo as winners anyway. 
 In yesterday's opening ceremony they wore one of the most striking two-piece outfits which put them in the running for the &bquo;elegance&equo; award for the best dressed team. 
 The award will be presented tomorrow night. 
 The Soviet team had a go, too. 
 They marched into the stadium in matching denim jackets, mini-skirts (which were brought into the country by the US team captain, Marty Reissen) and dark glasses. 
 The most notable absentees were Martina Navratilova and Chris Evert, who will arrive today after playing an exhibition in Philadelphia, and Gabriela Sabatini and Monica Seles, who withdrew because they were too tired. 
 Bodybuilding: Charlie rules on pure flex appeal: Joe Lovejoy enters the oily domain of the muscled where Surrey's incredible hulk uncovers a universal truth 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 MR UNIVERSE will gird up his loins in briefs which bring a new meaning to the term bikini line, clip his diamond ear-stud into place and take the rattler from his Guildford home to Luton this week to begin his reign by promoting a new range of office furniture. 
 &bquo;Strong and reliable stuff, see. 
 A good tie-up and a nice little earner.&equo; 
 &bquo;Earners&equo; like these keep Charles Clairmonte's body and soul together &mdash; no small task when the body in question is 17 stones of unadulterated muscle. 
 The 31-year-old ex-paratrooper's prize for retaining his title at Wembley on Saturday night was &pound;10,000, which does not go far for a full-time body builder who downs half a dozen eggs after his breakfast cereal and eight to 10 chicken breasts a day when &bquo;bulking up&equo;. 
 Charlie's weekly food bill comes to rather more than &pound;100. 
 In his amateur days he was an &bquo;eviction technician&equo; (a fashionable euphemism for bouncer) but such work is regarded as unseemly for the standard bearer of a sport which prides itself in its healthy clean-living image, and he now supplements his income from the few competitions which pay more than a pittance by personal appearances. 
 Clairmonte was a popular choice for the title first won by John Carl Grimek, America's &bquo;Monarch of Muscledom&equo; back in 1948, but his victory had been a close run thing. 
 Edward Kawak, who won in four successive years (1982-1985), mysteriously representing France, Lebanon and West Germany, was too close for comfort in second place (he was French this time). 
 Out in the audience it was bedlam, each Rodin pose greeted with wolf whistles, cat calls and enough indecent suggestions and doubles entendres to script a new &bquo;Carry On&equo; series. 
 Pecs mad, this body building lot. 
 Out on the stairs a piece of paper as worthless as Chamberlain's prohibited the use of body oils. 
 Back stage was like the Costa Brava: everyone oiling themselves and each other. 
 If they had all gone for a midnight swim, we would have had the worst slick since the Torrey Canyon. 
 What were they using if not the stuff Johnson intended for babies' bums? 
 &bquo;You don't expect me to give away the tricks of the trade, do you?&equo; snapped Casey Kucharyk, who was to win Amateur Class II (up to 5ft 9in). 
 Sorry, Casey &mdash; the secret's out. 
 The colour and smell were a giveaway. 
 The magic potion was nothing more sinister than Hawaiian Tropic sun tan oil. 
 Upstairs in the Hampton Room Kawak was preening and strutting his stuff with a worried frown, pondering perhaps in which language to prepare a winner's speech. 
 Tatyana Scholl, the West German who was to win the Miss Bikini (physique) class, took time out from her press-ups to waddle around nervously like a weight-lifter eyeing the bar. 
 Someone suggested she touch up her lipstick, but make-up only made her look more than ever like the Spitting Image puppet of Bette Midler. 
 There were two classes for the ladies: Miss Bikini (figure), which was like Miss World without the breasts (pumping iron, paradoxically, serves only to deflate them) and Miss Bikini (physique) in which the girls resemble scaled-down versions of the men, without the knobbly bits. 
 Tatyana the Terrible won the Amazons' title, our own Tracey Citrone the more aesthetic section. 
 Charlie Clairmonte was the real winner, though &mdash; the one the highlighted products of London's solariums wanted to be photographed with. 
 How had he first got into body building? 
 &bquo;By reading super hero comics,&equo; Flash Charlie said. 
 Surrey's own incredible hulk is available for personal appearances. 
 The odd chicken or a carrot cake would be much appreciated. 
 Sailing: Soviets slide to seventh place 
 By STUART ALEXANDER 
 BY a margin of two minutes 40 seconds the Soviet yacht Fazisi, with co-skippers Alexei Gryshenko and the American Skip Novak, finished sixth in the first leg of the Whitbread Round the World Race to Punta del Este, Uruguay. 
 But, by the even narrower margin of 38 seconds after handicap correction, they had to concede the place to Italy's Gatorade. 
 Both had finished just over six hours behind the Swedish ketch The Card with Pelle Petterson in the crew. 
 All agreed that the tactical decision on whether to go east or west at Cape Finisterre had been the key to success. 
 Half the fleet had arrived by last night, including the joint services yacht Satquote British Defender, which was beaten for eighth place by only 37 minutes by the first of the three Finnish challengers, Martela OF. 
 Defender also had the distinction of having the first woman finisher, Mandy Gallow. 
 Then, in the space of 31 minutes, came Spain's Fortuna Extra Lights, France's Charles Jourdan and the second Finnish maxi, Belmont. 
 Ireland's NCB and the third Finnish challenger, UBF, were due in last night. 
 Snooker: Top spot for Davis 
 By JANICE HALE 
 STEVE DAVIS might have begun his season behind the other players but he started it in style by capturing the first British ranking event, the BCE International, when beating Stephen Hendry, his most obvious rival, 9-4 at Trentham Gardens, Stoke, writes Janice Hale. 
 Davis, who won the world title for the sixth time in May, decided not to compete in the first two ranking events in Hong Hong and Bangkok. 
 He also did not compete in the European Open and will be absent from the Dubai Classic, which are also ranking events. 
 Consequently, after the Asian Open &mdash; which Hendry won &mdash; his No. 1 position in the world was taken over briefly by the 20-year-old Scot. 
 But his victory at Stoke on Saturday has him back at the top of the list. 
 He had only won one match prior to the international, in the Regal Scottish Masters, but is well aware of his own capabilities. 
 &bquo;I raised my game just enough to get through the early rounds,&equo; he said of his performance. 
 &bquo;It was a hell of a standard and an enormous challenge. 
 It stretched you to the limit. 
 I love playing great players and he's (Hendry) a great player.&equo; 
 Equestrianism: Whitaker in search of rich picking 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 IF John Whitaker can repeat last year's form at The Horse of the Year Show, which begins today at Wembley Arena, he will be the taker of rather more than a whit. 
 He won five of the 1988 contests and a total of &pound;42,399, writes Genevieve Murphy. 
 Whitaker, the European champion, rides the same three horses as last year &mdash; Next Milton, Gammon and Hopscotch. 
 Milton's three 1988 victories included the winner-takes-all prize of &pound;25,000 in the first running of the Next International Masters, which will be staged again on Friday evening. 
 This evening's opening performance begins with the final of the first Olympic Star Spotters Championship, which aims to give riders of young horses the chance to test their potential stars. 
 The idea has been warmly welcomed by David Broome, who has qualified Paul Schockemohle's seven-year-old Lotus for this evening's contest. 
 New Zealand's dual Olympic three-day event champion, Mark Todd, will also be in action on his latest Kiwi import, Double Take. 
 Squash: Parke's pay-off 
 From RICHARD EATON in Kuala Lumpur 
 SIMON PARKE, whose selection for England in the World Championships was dogged by controversy, began to repay the selectors' faith as he beat the Canadian No. 1, Sabir Butt, and the effects of influenza here yesterday, writes Richard Eaton from Kuala Lumpur. 
 Parke, 17, needed all his creativity and courage to hold on for a 15-10, 9-15, 15-12, 15-14 victory just when his resources were beginning to flag. 
 It was the Yorkshireman's second win in two days and his reward was to move within one win of a place in the last 32. 
 Another English selection for the team event, Jason Nicolle, the British Under-23 champion, also came through, winning 15-9, 15-11, 17-15 against Florian Possl, the West German who recently beat the England No. 1 Del Harris in New Zealand. 
 However, the Australian Geoff Hunt, joint holder of the record of eight British Open titles, just failed to make it. 
 He lost the toughest tussle of the day, against another former world champion, Maqsood Ahmed. 
 Hunt went down 15-9, 15-17, 15-13, 8-15, 15-5. 
 The Pakistani today plays the former British champion Geoff Williams for a place in the main draw. 
 Racing: The Trainers and Jockeys Making The Running on The Flat 
 Sport Page 29 
 Racing: Slippers comforts Sangster: Changing fortunes for a former leading owner and changing jockeys for Europe's richest race 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 OIL RICH beats filthy rich every time, but after several years of battling to remain buoyant in the remorseless wake of the Maktoums, Robert Sangster clambered back on to terra firma with his most significant win for a long time in Saturday's Hoover Fillies' Mile at Ascot. 
 Silk Slippers enabled Sangster &mdash; slowly-sinking in the super league of owners &mdash; to regain a foothold by wearing down the red-hot favourite, Moon Cactus, owned ironically by Sheikh Mohammed, in the dying strides of an event that has become a fertile proving ground for Classic fillies. 
 What a difference a few precious centimetres can make in this game of high stakes. 
 On both her outings Silk Slippers has thrust her attractive nose in front just where it matters and in so doing has established herself not merely as a valuable stud prospect, but an exciting candidate for next year's 1,000 Guineas and Oaks. 
 Sangster had been leading owner in this country five times in eight years up to 1985 when Sheikh Mohammed led the Maktoum charge, taking the No. 1 spot four times in row in the past four seasons. 
 And the Sheikh's dominance has been maintained this year as he heads the table with some &pound;1.75m in prize money, half a million ahead of his older brother, Hamdan Al Maktoum, who owns Nashwan, with Sangster languishing in 10th place with a mere &pound;250,000 or so in the kitty. 
 Silk Slippers may not enable Sangster to challenge the Arab supremacy, but an English Classic success after a five-year gap would come like manna from heaven. 
 Silk Slippers certainly looks the part, being a staying filly with speed in the mould of Midway Lady, who took the 1,000 and Oaks three years ago. 
 What was so impressive about Silk Slippers's victory was that she twice had to overcome difficulties in running and William Hill's offer of 33-1 about the daughter of Nureyev for the Oaks is particularly tempting. 
 She certainly looks a more attractive three-year-old prospect than Digression, who won the big juvenile colts' event, the Royal Lodge Stakes. 
 Digression won well enough, but the big minus factor against him is the fact that he is by the American stallion, Seattle Slew, whose progeny have tended not to train on over here. 
 Sheikh Mohammed's Bridal Toast, who finished powerfully to take second place could have more scope to progress as a Derby contender. 
 Fascinating though they are, thoughts of Classic confrontations to come were put on to the back-burner by another dazzling performance from Zilzal, who stamped himself as one of the outstanding milers of recent years with a thrashing of the French champion, Polish Precedent. 
 Walter Swinburn finds it hard to believe Zilzal will ever be beaten and the son of Nureyev will attempt to extend his sequence to six out of six in next month's Breeders' Cup Mile in Florida. 
 The good news is that he will not be rushed off to stud afterwards and will campaign for further honours next year when a move up to a mile and a quarter might be considered. 
 Meanwhile, as Ladbrokes shortened Nashwan's odds for next Sunday's Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe from 2-1 to 7-4 with a run, French Glory came down a point to 7-1 amid rumours that Pat Eddery would switch to him from Khalid Abdullah's other probable runner, Assatis. 
 Even more intriguing was a strong rumour that Steve Cauthen is to replace Greville Starkey on Cacoethes, who is trained like Assatis by Guy Harwood. 
 Starkey said yesterday that he knew nothing of the move and as far as he was concerned he was still on Cacoethes. 
 &bquo;I shall sleep easy tonight,&equo; Starkey said. 
 Willie Carson will also resting easy after suggestions that he had been wrong to bring about the withdrawal of the red-hot favourite, Superoo, before the start of Ascot's opening event on Saturday, having done a similar thing with the favourite, Red Paddy, before the Royal Hunt Cup. 
 &bquo;I was angry for a while because I was confident that the horse would win, but Willie did the right thing,&equo; John Sutcliffe, Superoo's trainer, said yesterday. 
 &bquo;It's true the horse was 100 per cent sound five minutes afterwards, but there was definitely something wrong down at the start and Willie had advice from the starter and a vet.&equo; 
 Racing: For the Notebook 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 A weekly list of horses to follow HUFOOF: Had her stands-side rivals beaten in a 24-runner sprint at Haydock on Saturday but was kept out of the frame by the finishers on the far side of the track. 
 Coming back to winning form. 
 (H Thomson Jones). 
 KATAHDIN: Unplaced behind Triomphe Modest over 6 furlongs at Nottingham on Tuesday, but this colt was not given a punishing race when running on very well to finish only a few lengths off the winner. 
 Will do better over longer distances. 
 (G Wragg). 
 SHIELING: Ran a marvellous race under a sizeable burden behind Kiya at Ascot. 
 She looked the possible winner a furlong from home, but faded near the finish as the task of conceding so much weight told. 
 (L Cumani). 
 TAILSPIN: Looked likely to be unplaced in Double Dutch's race at Ascot, but finished powerfully to take third place and must be followed in similar company. 
 (B Hills). 
 Pope rejects Runcie's vision of church leadership 
 From ANDREW BROWN, Religious Affairs Correspondent, in Rome 
 THE ARCHBISHOP of Canterbury, Dr Robert Runcie, exchanged a symbolic kiss of peace with Pope John Paul II yesterday at a mass attended by thousands in St Peter's Square, Rome. 
 But Dr Runcie's ideas of a limited primacy &mdash; recognising the Pope as a central figure in the Christian Church, who would exercise &bquo;a primacy for the sake of unity and mission&equo; &mdash; have been rejected as insufficient by the Pope. 
 They have also aroused Protestant anger against Dr Runcie, at the same time as he has become involved in a row over his attack on the &bquo;Pharisees&equo; of British society. 
 Though Dr Runcie and his party could not take Holy Communion at the papal mass, he had earlier celebrated the eucharist at the Anglican church in Rome after three demonstrators rose from the congregation as he ascended the pulpit; the visit has been dogged by protests from supporters of the Rev Ian Paisley. 
 In his sermon, Dr Runcie said: &bquo;We should ever recognise the scandal that Anglicans and Roman Catholics must celebrate two eucharists to make one memorial of our redemption on the day of our Lord.&equo; 
 Dr Runcie has gone out of his way on this visit to concede many of the doctrinal points and practices which large elements of the Church of England have traditionally found offensive in Roman Catholicism. 
 The Pope, too, has spoken warmly of unity. 
 On Saturday the two prelates attended a service of vespers at the Church of San Gregorio, which stands on the site where Pope Gregory sent St Augustine of Canterbury off to become the first Archbishop of Canterbury in 597. 
 But in their prepared homilies the Pope and the Archbishop addressed quite different problems. 
 Dr Runcie repeated his offer of a limited primacy, involving the limited powers exercised by the popes in the first few centuries of the Christian Church. 
 However, the Pope's account of the role of the papacy went a great deal farther than that: Christian unity, he said, must be founded on the faith in Christ that was handed on by the Apostles; what this faith is must be determined by the Roman Catholic Church. 
 He quoted the Second Vatican Council: &bquo;The task of giving an authentic interpretation of the Word of God&hellip; has been entrusted to the living teaching office of the Church alone. 
 The specific role of bishops which is to be exercised in communion with the see of Peter in ensuring the unity and continuity of the faith is vital if we are to hand on the faith of Peter, Gregory and Augustine. 
 All our efforts to restore unity among Christians will be in vain if they are not carried out in total fidelity to the faith in Christ&hellip; handed on by the Apostles.&equo; 
 In a statement afterwards Dr Runcie stressed that he was not proposing any change in the British constitution. 
 &bquo;The phrase &bquo;universal primacy&equo; has a spiritual meaning. 
 It does not imply political supremacy, and does not suggest that the Pope should administer the affairs of the Church of England,&equo; he said. 
 Both prelates referred to the consecration in February of the Rt Rev Barbara Harris as the Anglican Assistant Bishop of Massachussetts. 
 Bishop Harris is quite unacceptable to the Vatican. 
 The Pope said: &bquo;Events in recent years have seriously aggravated the differences between us.&equo; 
 The Independent has learnt that 1,800 American Roman Catholic nuns wrote last winter to Dr Runcie, urging him to defy the Pope over the ordination of women. 
 Sister Margaret Traxler, of the National Coalition of American Nuns, said that she had told Dr Runcie: &bquo;The Roman Catholic Church says this is a deterrent to unity; but we say, how can this be a deterrent to unity when discrimination against women is evil?&equo; 
 She said she had received a &bquo;friendly and brotherly&equo; reply from Dr Runcie. 
 East Germany lets 7,000 take the train west: More refugees join queue to escape through Prague and Warsaw embassies after cave-in by Berlin 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn and EDWARD LUCAS in Prague 
 AS SOME 7,000 exhausted but happy East Germans arrived in West Germany on special trains early yesterday, hundreds who missed the trains joined the queue to go west at embassies in Prague and Warsaw. 
 In Prague last night, more than 200 were allowed into the West German embassy after spending the day on the pavement outside. 
 Most arrived in the morning, some only minutes after Czechoslovak police sealed off the building. 
 The West German Ambassador, Hermann Huber, who earlier in the day told the new arrivals the transfer of 4,000 to West Germany was a &bquo;one-off action&equo;, appeared again to tell them: &bquo;For the time being we are letting you in.&equo; 
 Hans-Dietrich Genscher, the West German Foreign Minister, went on television to say he hoped for a &bquo;parallel solution&equo; for the new arrivals. 
 In Warsaw, dozens of East Germans were last night waiting in front of the embassy, filling out forms and wondering where they would spend the night. 
 As the East German trains pulled into the border station of Hof the first refugees, many of them in tears, were greeted with cheers, applause and a local youth group singing the Beatles song &bquo;Let It Be&equo;. 
 They were welcomed by government officals, Red Cross teams with hot tea, soup and nappies, and local people with clothes and toys. 
 Doctors had been deeply worried about the 4,000 refugees from Prague, who had been camping in the embassy grounds in squalid conditions, surrounded by ankle-deep mud and sleeping in shifts on the available beds. 
 They were quickly sent on to reception camps. 
 Yesterday's sudden departure followed what appeared to have been an almost total cave-in by East Germany, anxious to have the matter out of the way by the country's fortieth anniversary on Saturday. 
 All but about 300 of the East Germans had flatly refused an offer of guaranteed permission to go to the West providing they returned to East Germany first. 
 So, under what appeared to be an informal deal between Bonn, Berlin, Prague and Warsaw, the special trains passed through East German territory on the way out &mdash; but with senior West German officials on board as a guarantee. 
 Soon afterwards the embassy in Prague was sealed off unilaterally by Czechoslovak police. 
 This prompted the Foreign Ministry in Bonn to lodge a protest with the Czechoslovak ambassador. 
 Last night, the East German Foreign Ministry issued a statement attacking the attitude of the refugees: &bquo;Some East German citizens will justifiably ask why we let these people emigrate to West Germany via East Germany, even though they had grossly violated our laws,&equo; said the statement read as the main television news item. 
 &bquo;Among these people there are anti-social elements who have a bad attitude to work and also to normal living conditions.&equo; 
 Earlier, East Germany had announced the solution as a &bquo;humanitarian act&equo; by the government, adding that it hoped Bonn in future would run its embassies &bquo;in normal manner according to international usage&equo;. 
 West Germany had expected around 5,000 refugees &mdash; including 809 from Warsaw, who arrived in Helmstedt &mdash; but more kept pouring from the special trains. 
 Hundreds had evidently gone straight to the station in Prague without contacting the embassy. 
 There were also reports that some had jumped on the trains as they passed through East Germany, or that the numbers could have included previously uncounted children. 
 Another 735 East Germans arrived by way of Hungary and Austria, bringing to 31,000 the total of East Germans who have come out since Hungary opened its borders on 11 September. 
 &bquo;The journey through East Germany was terrible,&equo; one woman said yesterday. 
 She feared a trap when the train stopped for 45 minutes on the way. 
 It turned out that East German security merely wanted to take away their identity cards so they could be formally &bquo;expelled&equo;. 
 At the Prague embassy on Saturday night, cheers greeted the news that the refugees would be leaving the same night as Mr Genscher. 
 Mr Genscher, who appears to have arranged the solution in talks with his East German, Czechoslovak and Polish counterparts in the United Nations, said his trip to Prague was the most moving of his career. 
 The refugees were the same age as he was when he escaped from East Germany 37 years ago. 
 In his special broadcast last night, Mr Genscher said he hoped President Gorbachev, who will visit East Berlin for the anniversary this weekend, &bquo;will try to convince East Germany that political reforms are also in its own interest&equo;. 
 Labour &bquo;would keep tight rein on spending&equo; 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 JOHN SMITH, the shadow Chancellor, yesterday set the overriding tone for this week's Labour Party conference with a warning that he would impose tough spending controls if Labour won the next election. 
 His warning casts doubt on Labour's commitment to increase spending on &bquo;priority&equo; programmes for the health service and pensions. 
 Mr Smith said in an interview on BBC television's On the Record that he did not expect his colleagues to &bquo;spend and spend again' when they took office. 
 He conceded that there would be disputes with colleagues, but said: &bquo;There are no quick fixes, and I will not be indulging in any quick fix. 
 A quick fix clearly becomes unfixed. 
 There are realities that I cannot change. 
 There will be the reality of the economic situation which we inherit, which will not be our fault, but it will be our responsibility. 
 When we've got an economic mess, the first duty of a government is to clear up the economic mess. 
 &bquo;Now if that means we have to postpone some of our social ambitions, then we may have to do so. 
 But it will not mean that we are abandoning them. 
 We will tackle putting our economy in order so that we can achieve that social ambition, so that the strong economy is used to finance and develop the fair society.&equo; 
 As for his colleagues, Mr Smith said: &bquo;We're all agreed that we cannot spend what we have not earned and we intend to earn it before we spend it. 
 That will be the guiding light of the next Labour government. 
 When I insist on that priority, as I can tell you I most certainly will &mdash; with the full support of the Prime Minister in doing so &mdash; then I'm sure my colleagues will see the point of that. 
 &bquo;Now it is quite right of them, of course, to allow our social obligations not to be forgotten; there'll probably be an argument. 
 There are in all governments between the Treasury and spending ministers. 
 But they will take into account the need for that balance that says that social spending without underpinning by economic growth will not be sustained in any event.&equo; 
 Mr Smith's warning coincided with a call by Ken Livingstone, the Labour MP for Brent East, who said on London Weekend Television's The Walden Interview: &bquo;You can be miles ahead in the polls, but when you get to the last three weeks, people think, &bquo;Can I afford a Labour government?&equo; 
 We need to say now what we are going to spend: where the money is going to come from.&equo; 
 Mr Livingstone called for cuts in defence spending. 
 David Blunkett, another member of the national executive, told a conference fringe rally organised by the soft-left Labour Coordinating Committee that Labour would have to find additional funds for its social programme by cutting &pound;9.5bn from defence spending over five years, and raising the level of taxation on the rich. 
 The policy review's top rate of income tax - 50 per cent &mdash; was too low, he said. 
 Although the policy review will be endorsed by the conference, giving Neil Kinnock the freedom to go on to the offensive against the Conservatives in the run-up to the next general election, there are a number of areas of potential conflict. 
 Calls for consideration of electoral reform and a new form of black representation are both expected to be defeated. 
 Ron Todd, the general secretary of the transport workers' union, said that today's vote on the multilaterist nuclear defence policy would not yield the &bquo;massive and overwhelming&equo; majority predicted by right-wingers, and he warned that party leaders could not expect everybody to &bquo;goose-step&equo; in the same direction once the policy had been carried. 
 The conference opened with Labour buoyed by a series of weekend opinion polls giving leads of from 5 to 12 points. 
 Soviet Union faces serious energy shortage 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 AN OMINOUS combination of industrial unrest, transport problems, investment cutbacks and unrelenting public suspicion over nuclear power is causing mounting problems for the Soviet energy industry. 
 Officials now warn that fuel supplies could be seriously disrupted this winter. 
 This is the last thing President Mikhail Gorbachev needs, as he tries to contain a staggering economic crisis. 
 But every sign now is that to shortages, inflation and a runaway budget deficit must be added serious shortfalls in output of coal, oil and nuclear energy. 
 The troubles of the nuclear industry in the aftermath of the Chernobyl disaster of 1986 are well known: a slowdown or halt to construction of new plants, plus the closedown earlier this year of the nuclear power station near Erevan in Armenia because of safety worries after last December's earthquake. 
 Now, in the space of four days, two key ministers have given bleak warnings over the state of affairs in both the oil and coal industries, the largest of their kind in the world. 
 In oil, the main problem is administrative disruption following last June's merger of the oil and gas industries and the switch to greater financial autonomy for individual production units, coupled with intended massive cutbacks in capital investment plans as the government seeks to balance its own books. 
 &bquo;The situation is desperately serious,&equo; the Deputy Oil Minister, Vladimir Filanovsky-Zenkov, told the Socialist Industry newspaper last week. 
 &bquo;The vast bulk of enterprises are not ready for change. 
 They do not want to operate independently because they are unable to do so.&equo; 
 Oil output would be at least 12 million tonnes below the planned 1989 level of 624 million tonnes. 
 Over the next five years there would be shortfalls of &bquo;tens of millions of tonnes&equo; unless new investments came on stream, he warned almost as the government announced that capital spending in the energy sector would be slashed by 40 per cent. 
 The coal industry faces similar problems following last summer's strikes in the Ukraine and central Siberia. 
 Mikhail Shchadov, the Minister for Coal, told the Trud newspaper yesterday that so far this year, deliveries were 18.5 million tonnes less than planned, while 35 million tonnes of mined coal was lying at pitheads for want of freight rolling-stock. 
 But the strikes themselves have left the most disturbing legacy. 
 Of late &bquo;productive and technological discipline&equo; had worsened. 
 In the Donetsk region of the Ukraine, production in September alone was a million tonnes down. 
 TELEVISION / Bout of morning sickness 
 By MARK LAWSON 
 THE STORY was that Breakfast News (BBC 1), the third relaunch of the cereal television which began in 1983 as Breakfast Time with Frank Bough and Selina Scott chummy in jumpers, was going serious. 
 As the new presenter, Nicholas Witchell is chiefly celebrated for sitting on a lesbian during a news bulletin, you switched on at dawn with some cynicism. 
 It was soon clear, however, that this was broadsheet television. 
 Witchell would be doing his party trick only in special circumstances. 
 The programme pretty well began with an interview with someone from the Bundesbank which, as running orders go, is a bit like a long-jumper beginning his approach with his laces tied. 
 In fact, almost everything before seven is business news with men in suits watching over the pound like doctors: &bquo;And the latest news from Tokyo &mdash; it seems to be a little better. 
 ..&equo; Nor is it merely the heavy stuff which comes with serious credentials. 
 Sally Jones, the sports presenter, clearly knew what the plural of Grand Prix was. 
 Even the lighter stories tended to be along the lines of parrots who played the commodities market. 
 There was, it is true, still a funny, tubby chap in a bow-tie &mdash; in 1983, Frank and Selina had Russell Grant filling this position of studio poodle &mdash; but, where Grant was an astrologer, Paul Callan reviews the newspapers. 
 Of the original concept, only weatherman Francis Wilson survives and even he seemed to be making conscious efforts not to call clouds &bquo;white, fluffy bits&equo;, as has been his trick. 
 Perhaps, though, Wilson was merely distracted by the fact that, during his first appearance, he briefly disappeared before returning partially superimposed on a map. 
 His eyebrows floated over Glasgow and his mouth seemed to toy with eating Leeds. 
 The debut of Breakfast News was technically imperfect to a surprisingly high degree. 
 Apparently uncertain as to camera angles, Witchell and the others frequently gave the impression of having spotted a lesbian stalking across the floor. 
 But it is better, with a relaunch, to have technical rather than conceptual failings and Breakfast News should yet become a decently serious morning service. 
 Even so, breakfast television is still one of two areas of programming (situation comedy is the other) in which Britain trails America for quality. 
 The drive and fire of cereal television like NBC's Today show makes you understand the line about waking up in a city which doesn't sleep. 
 The British imitators are still whispering to a city that's still in bed. 
 The hissing cousins of Monday night current affairs coverage &mdash; rivals World In Action (Granada) and Panorama (BBC 1) &mdash; were both in impressive form. 
 World In Action questioned the Animal Liberation Front about the paradox of saving dumb animals by exposing dumb humans to incendiary devices. 
 Because of the Broadcasting Act, four ALF members in Balaclavas were shown on screen but their answers read by an actor. 
 Once again, it struck you that an actor was more likely to win sympathy from an audience than a slack-jawed garrulous Balaclava. 
 John Simpson's lucid report for Panorama, following groups of mujahedin through most of this year, attested to both the benevolent power of photography &mdash; cameramen Chris Hooke and Peter Juvenal courageouslycaught images of broken bodies and wrecked villages, of fire and snow &mdash; and the more dubious power of America and Russia, picking up the tab for the fighters but not the victims. 
 RADIO / Double acts: Robert Hanks on sexual antics in the Middle Ages and modern-day mirth 
 By ROBERT HANKS 
 IF IT worries you that the national survey on sexual habits is not going to take place, you could take comfort from the thought that it probably won't make a vast amount of difference in the long run. 
 As Jeffrey Richards showed in the first of three talks on Sexuality in the Middle Ages (Radio 3, Monday), you can always get past a lack of obvious data to find out the sort of thing that goes on in bedrooms. 
 It's a question of finding the right sources &mdash; like penitentials, books prescribing penances for a variety of sins, of which sexual sins formed the largest category. 
 Modern penitentials won't be of much use to future historians of the twentieth century, but eleventh-century penitentials might be, rich as they are in the prejudices of our enlightened age &mdash; particularly the inferior status of women. 
 Richards made it worryingly clear how far the Church was responsible for enshrining such illiberal attitudes, though to do it credit, the Church also introduced consent to marriage and made rape a crime against the person, rather than property. 
 The essential point was that the medieval Church was a &bquo;sex-negative&equo; institution &mdash; sex was a bad thing because it interfered with the search for spiritual perfection. 
 This held true even in marriage (a man who loved his wife too passionately was an adulterer, said St Jerome, who was not a man you'd invite to parties); and rampant millenarianism encouraged the tendency, since if you think that the end of the world, no, this world, is imminent, then procreation must seem something of a waste of time, and preparing your soul for Judgement Day will be pushed up your list of priorities. 
 The justification seems to have got lost along the way, but the attitude has prevailed until recently &mdash; you could argue about precise dates, but Philip Larkin plumped for 1963 &mdash; and it's not done for yet. 
 As Richards pointed out, the fact that the history of sexuality has had to wait so long to be written shows the strength of the taboos we have inherited. 
 Still, the taboos have been the source of much mirth: the stand-up's traditional reliance on smut and mothers-in-law could only exist in a largely sex-negative society. 
 But then there came &bquo;new&equo; comedy to blow away the medieval cobwebs; and then there came Russell Davies to make documentaries about it, with titles like There's A Racial Stereotype In My Soup (Radio 4 Saturday). 
 It's only ten years since the Comedy Store opened, but already there is a note of wistfulness creeping in for the good old days. 
 Arthur Smith sighed for political satire, and wondered what was going to happen to political comedy if we get a Labour government. 
 In retrospect, though, it was a touch too apparent how many comedians in 1979 thought it was enough just to say, um, &bquo;Bleep&equo; &mdash; rather tamely, nobody got past the bleeper: for shock value, you're better off with Radio 3. 
 MUSIC / A sometime thing: David Fanning reviews Porgy and Bess in Liverpool 
 By DAVID FANNING 
 IT SEEMS remarkable that Gershwin's Porgy and Bess should have to be the object of rediscovery. 
 If a great opera such as this has difficulty holding a place in the repertoire, what hope is there for the merely excellent? 
 The main problem is the large, virtually all black cast &mdash; chorus, children and all. 
 Colour-blind casting would be as pointless as translating the libretto into Home Counties English. 
 So if, as seems likely, we have to wait a long time for a follow up to the triumphant Glyndebourne production, we should be all the more grateful for occasions like the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra's concert performance (sponsored by English Estates). 
 As it happens, the problems of an unstaged Porgy are hardly less acute &mdash; a cast of 24 soloists and a duration of three and a quarter hours are not easily managed in the concert hall. 
 Doubling up roles and cutting up to two fifths of the score may be practical necessities, but weaken the impact of the whole. 
 This is not so much in narrative coherence &mdash; the programme book gave the complete synopsis &mdash; as in dramatic timing. 
 If the complete Porgy reveals anything, it is that Gershwin did not go straight from one hit to another (as we did here, from &bquo;Summertime&equo; to &bquo;A Woman is a Sometime Thing&equo;). 
 Perhaps even more destructively, the Philharmonic Hall acoustic does not make for the clarity of diction experienced in the average theatre. 
 Take the orchestra out of the pit, and unless you emasculate their contribution, the problem is compounded. 
 Microphones may be no real answer, but with the exception of Louis Hagen-William's Porgy and Daniel Washington's Crown none of the voices had adequate carrying power without them. 
 Happily these two roles are crucial ones, and the powerful delineation of this central rivalry gave the whole performance its backbone. 
 Wayne Williams as Sportin' Life justly drew applause for his succulent rendering of &bquo;It Ain't Necessarily So&equo; and Jo Ann Pickens had some touching moments as Bess; but none of the female voices sounded entirely in their element. 
 That the evening could still be counted a success was partly down to the attack and verve of the Liverpool Philharmonic Choir. 
 It was also partly down to the well-disciplined orchestra, although the jazz idiom of, for instance, Crown's &bquo;A Red-Headed Woman&equo; is not really in the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra's blood, and Libor Pesek was inclined to take more time than some of his soloists wanted. 
 Above all, the evening's success should be put down to music which never ceases to delight by the sophistication of its continuity, by its sheer inspiration. 
 Commodities: Cocoa 
 By DAVID FANNING 
 RUMOURS that the Ivory Coast had sold 200,000 tonnes of cocoa to a French trade house sent futures to a four-month low. 
 The December price dropped &pound;34 to &pound;706 per tonne. 
 There were less widespread suggestions of a 100,000 tonne purchase by another international operator. 
 Technology: Problem of dividing up radio frequencies 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 THE GOVERNMENT faces controversy over plans to sell off the spectrum of radio frequencies. 
 From a commercial point of view, there are not enough to go round. 
 More television and radio, telephones that go everywhere with you, and in particular the defence of the nation, all take a toll on the frequency spectrum. 
 Radio waves, like light waves and sound, are a means of transmitting energy. 
 The signals fluctuate in cycles: if radio energy fluctuates at one cycle every second, then it has a frequency of one Hertz. 
 The more cycles per second, the higher you go in the so-called spectrum of frequencies. 
 A &bquo;hum&equo;, for example, is a vibrating sound signal in the audio range of frequencies. 
 Go further up and you reach ultrasonic frequencies where the noise can be heard by dogs and not humans. 
 Radio is higher still. 
 At these higher frequencies, radio uses a mixture of vibrating electric and magnetic fields instead of fluctuating sound waves. 
 This is so that the energy can be made to travel a much greater distance. 
 Radio waves are useful as we can make them carry information by modulating them &mdash; for example, changing the amplitude of the fluctuations so that the change represents information. 
 At the receiver, the signal is demodulated and the information &mdash; the voice - extracted. 
 Radio programmes are transmitted at frequencies of hundreds of thousands of hertz (kilohertz) or millions of hertz (MHz). 
 These high frequency radio programmes can be bounced off the ionosphere which at certain high frequencies acts like an electrically charged mirror. 
 The fades, whistles and crackles reminiscent of old Tony Hancock programmes came through because the ionosphere is not as stable as broadcasters would have liked. 
 Satellites, when they arrived, were much more effective. 
 Apart from the armed forces and civil and military users such as air traffic control, the biggest inhabitants of the spectrum are telecommunications and television. 
 TV takes up vast chunks mainly in the 470MHz-850MHz range. 
 Sea-going radio and radio communications on aircraft also take their fair share, as does land-mobile radio. 
 It is introducing more of the latter which is posing the biggest problems. 
 At low frequencies the signals do not have much carrying capacity, but go too high and the oxygen and hydrogen molecules in the atmosphere can actually vibrate in sympathy with the radio waves, absorbing the signals. 
 According to the Department of Trade and Industry, underneath 900MHz or so, things are clogged up. 
 The European Commission is having a hard enough job getting all its members to clear out the same few channels so that Europe can have a paging system which could be used in any of its countries. 
 Every country has its own system for using frequencies, and they have to think about each other &mdash; radio waves, after all do not stop at national boundaries and without international collaboration there could be interference and general chaos. 
 Similarly, there is an international agreement to have special &bquo;windows&equo; left clear in different parts of the spectrum for astronomical telescopes. 
 In the UK, the Government took a long look at the spectrum before launching a fifth and sixth TV channel. 
 It decided it could squeeze in a fifth, but there is no room for a sixth channel and by the time you add up the extra transmission channels needed for relaying the signal onwards, there will not be enough spectrum to allow the fifth channel to cover the whole country. 
 The example of the police radios shows the relative permanence of being allocated a piece of spectrum &mdash; radios and other broadcasting equipment, whether for entertainment or communication, are designed to sort out what it wants to pick up from the rest of the signal. 
 To perform well it has to be tightly targeted to cope with quite a narrow band of frequencies. 
 Even tuning your radio can be done over a very limited range. 
 The latest problem for the Government is increasing competition for mobile cellular radio services, which have a small bunch of frequencies around 900 MHz. 
 Cellular radio is so called because it divides the country into small areas served by a radio base, and then divides each of these areas into &bquo;cells&equo;. 
 The cells are distributed so that callers travelling through cells a fair distance apart can use the same frequencies without interfering with each other, making most use of the limited spectrum available. 
 But even with this technology, there was not enough room to bring in any more rival services. 
 So the Government had to choose much higher frequency and new devices will have to be developed before new mobile telephone services can begin. 
 The problem turned into an advantage. 
 At the higher frequencies chosen, the cells need to be made much smaller but have the benefit that the telephones can be built to need a great deal less power. 
 This in turn makes them cheaper and small enough to fit the average pocket in every sense. 
 So in a few years' time mobile phones will be brought to the masses. 
 Still, those who manage Europe's frequencies are trying to struggle with other problems. 
 They have agreed a frequency which will allow mobile telephones to be used throughout Europe. 
 But the reason we, unlike the Americans, have no telephones on planes is largely because a consensus on frequencies was a long time coming. 
 Turriff shares get boost from 30% profits rise 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 SHARES in Turriff Corporation, the Midlands-based construction and plant hire group, put on 1p to 334p against the market trend on the announcement of a 30 per cent rise in pre-tax profits to &pound;1.76m. 
 The profit rise came despite a decline in sales from the housebuilding business, which is concentrated in the area worst hit by the property slump, the South-east of England. 
 Chief executive John Wyatt said he was still hopeful the target of 78 house sales by the end of the year would be achieved, with 41 sold so far. 
 The housebuilding downturn will be largely offset this half by the sale of a commercial property development in Witney, Oxfordshire, Mr Wyatt said. 
 Construction improved and cost pressures are easing, he added. 
 In plant hire, the main profit earner, the larger-scale plant items are successful and profitable, but smaller ones are affected by the decline in the housing market. 
 Mr Wyatt said action would have to be taken at the Total Power Tools offshoot, which has not been performing well. 
 In information and marketing, trading has been adversely affected by the downturn in consumer spending, and the group does not see the position being reversed this year. 
 &bquo;The concern must be whether interest rates have already been too high for too long,&equo; Mr Wyatt said. 
 Earnings were 32 per cent up at 14.1p, covering a 21 per cent increase in the interim dividend to 4.25p. 
 Analysts predict &pound;5.8m taxable profits for the year, with the second half traditionally stronger. 
 Company News in Brief 
 Business and City Page 28 
 Rentokil sells US timber side for 5.8m pounds 
 By TERENCE WILKINSON, Assistant City Editor 
 RENTOKIL, the environmental and property care group, has sold its loss-making US timber preserving business to Laporte, the specialty chemical maker, for &pound;5.8m in cash. 
 Clive Thompson, chief executive of Rentokil, said the company was only a small player in the US timber preserving market and had decided to concentrate on the UK, European and Asian markets where Rentokil has large market shares. 
 The business being sold, which does not include a freehold site at Atlanta, Georgia, makes timber treatment chemicals under the &bquo;Supatimber&equo; name. 
 In 1988 the operations lost &pound;100,000 after meeting central group charges. 
 &bquo;We plan to use the cash proceeds to build up our environmental service business in the US particularly to expand our &dollar;42m Tropical Plant Rental business which we acquired last year,&equo; said Mr Thompson. 
 Tropical Plant Rentals, acquired in October 1988 for &dollar;41.5m, is believed to have accounted for a decline in margins in Rentokil's environmental services division from 25.8 per cent to 23.1 per cent in the first half of 1989. 
 Because its results were not up to expectations Rentokil is paying &dollar;2m less for the business than planned. 
 Laporte also announced yesterday that it has bought Woodtech, an independent supplier of wood treatment plants, and has spent &pound;6.3m buying the speciality building products division of ICI Australia and two other minor operations. 
 Armchair Investor: Headland Group 
 By TERENCE WILKINSON, Assistant City Editor 
 THE BRIEF history of Headland Group, created when the management consultants Octagon rode to the rescue of troubled Compsoft Holdings in 1987, is a story of recovery. 
 Yesterday the group moved into its growth phase. 
 Tied in with encouraging half year figures, Headland announced a &pound;11m acquisition and its shares were temporarily suspended while an offer document is printed. 
 Headland is buying Multisoft, a software group which makes business accounting systems designed for the personal computer market. 
 Headland believes Multisoft's experience, especially in open systems &mdash; computers of different makes that integrate with each other &mdash; can be married with systems developed by Mega, Headland's own accounting software house which produces larger systems sold directly to clients. 
 The purchase is being paid for with &pound;1.1m cash and the balance satisfied by a share issue, which has been underwritten. 
 Research shows that there are currently 960 accounting systems on offer in the UK, and Headland thinks there might be some consolidation. 
 If there is, the group is geared up to exploit it. 
 Pre-tax profits this year should reach &pound;2.45m putting the shares, 42p when suspended, on a prospective multiple of 15.5. 
 One to tuck away when they are relisted. 
 Market Report: Merchant banks in demand on bid expectations 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 THE STOCK market senses another big financial bid following the &pound;1.1bn offer for Pearl Group from Australian Mutual Provident. 
 As Pearl shares raced ahead there was some determined buying of merchant banks, particularly Morgan Grenfell. 
 In often active trading its shares climbed 21p to 357p with, once again, insurance group Willis Faber rumoured to have sold its 20.5 per cent holding. 
 Credit Lyonnais, the French group which owns the Alexanders discount house and stockbroker Laing &amp; Cruickshank, was the suggested buyer. 
 Stories that the Willis Faber stake is on the move have circulated in the past, with West German banks the favourites to pick it up. 
 Morgan shares were also given a helping hand by the AMP offer. 
 The bank is advising the Australian group and it has been calculated that if its bid succeeds Morgan's commission will add 6.5 per cent to its earnings. 
 But Morgan was not the only merchant bank in favour. 
 Kleinwort Benson, which disclosed it had purchased 200,000 of its own shares at 353p each, rose 11p to 366p and Hambros edged ahead 3p to 232p. 
 S G Warburg gained 9p to 420p. 
 The revival of takeover speculation &mdash; there is little doubt that European and Japanese buyers lurk &mdash; has occurred at a time when the merchant bankers, after a long period in the doldrums, are enjoying a rerating on trading considerations. 
 On the insurance pitch Pearl romped ahead 87p to 639p, with many suggesting AMP will have to pay more than 700p a share to win the battle. 
 Other life insurers to draw encouragement from the bid were Britannic, up 27p to 520p, and Refuge Group, 26p higher at 604p. 
 Prudential Corporation slipped 3.5p to 195.5p on worries that it could emerge as Pearl's white knight. 
 Composites, which have attracted takeover speculation, were inclined to ease on disappointment that Pearl had been targeted. 
 But Commerical Union, the favourite for bid attention, recovered to close little changed at 451p. 
 The rest of the market remained weighed down by interest rate pressures, with Thursday's West German decision anxiously awaited. 
 But, after a bleak opening, prices improved although trading was again thin. 
 At the close the broadly-based FT-SE share index was down 10.2 points, an effective 7.4 points fall after allowing for dividend payments. 
 Stores remained in the doldrums, with the latest retail sales figures confirming the difficulties of the high street. 
 Dixons, which had a gloomy message last week, fell 2p to 140p after touching 138p. 
 Eurotunnel had an active session as Channel tunnel costs were revised upwards to &pound;7bn. 
 The shares ended 45p down at 650p. 
 SmithKline Beecham, which has underperformed, gained 8p to 554p. 
 There are rumours of a London investment presentation, to be followed by a US roadshow. 
 Amersham International dropped 9p to 408p. 
 County NatWest West WoodMac has downgraded. 
 Interim figures, due next month, are expected to be &pound;7m against &pound;10.8m, with the year's results predicted at &pound;20m (&pound;25.3m). 
 Problems in Japan are blamed for the setback. 
 After a flat opening beers perked up when it became known that August beer production was up 8 per cent and the year's output had edged 0.6 per cent ahead of last year's corresponding performance. 
 But many had anticipated far stronger growth following the long hot summer. 
 Environmental engineer Wheway slipped 2p to 142p. 
 Nearly 95 per cent of its one-for-four rights issue was taken up, with Panmure Gordon placing the remainder at 140p. 
 Blenheim Exhibitions was unchanged at 895p as the rump of its open offer was placed by Barclays de Zoete Wedd and Laing. 
 Bettaware, the curtains group where former Debenhams chief Robert Thornton is chairman, enjoyed a speculative run with some talking about stakebuilding by a determined buyer. 
 The shares rose 20p to 190p. 
 Property group Five Oaks Investments improved 5p to 77p. 
 London Securities, the property to venture capital business, has lifted its shareholding to 6.3 per cent, buying 445,000 shares. 
 Shares made a poor start to the account. 
 At one time the FT-SE share index was down 27.5 points. 
 But shares clawed their way back and by the close the fall had been cut to 10.2 points at 2,289.2. 
 The FT 30 share index ended at 1,876.9. 
 Government stocks were little changed. 
 Interest is building up in Waterford Wedgwood, makers of the famous crystal glassware and bone china. 
 The shares were firm at 68p. 
 There are suggestions that bid action is about to break out with Fitzwilton, the vehicle of Dr Tony O'Reilly, the favourite to strike. 
 WW has had a difficult time, suffering heavy losses on its glass side, but profits could be achieved this year. 
 Blue Arrow, with 70 per cent of its capital now held by US investors, is to adopt the American quarterly reporting policy. 
 But there are, apparently, no plans to move the group from the UK. 
 Andrew Mills and Brian Sturgess at Barclays de Zoete Wedd expect full-year profits to fall from &pound;75m to &pound;70m. 
 They rate the shares, at 112.5p yesterday, a sell. 
 View from City Road: AMP tries to knock out Pearl 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 WITH Antipodean brashness, Australian Mutual Provident has launched its &pound;1.1bn takeover of the Pearl. 
 Conventional wisdom suggests that agreed takeovers in the financial services sector are preferable since they tend to avoid mass defections of staff in the target company. 
 Such a tactic does not appeal to the Australian group. 
 Even during its last acquisition, which was an agreed &pound;15m purchase of the British mutual insurer London Life, the City was deafened by the sound of falling bodies during the deal. 
 The gentlemen of the Pearl are taking off their jackets to fight the bid so the British insurer's shareholders are in for an unpredictable time. 
 AMP has attempted to produce a knockout offer. 
 A cash offer of 605p for each Pearl share has been slapped on the table with a loan note alternative. 
 Roughly 40 per cent of the consideration will come from borrowings and the remaining 60 per cent from existing resources. 
 Evidently, the stock market believes that matters will not rest there and Pearl's share price raced up 87p to 639p. 
 AMP has made its play for Pearl as part of long-term expansion plans. 
 The group has dominant market share down-under, taking about a third of Australia's life insurance business, and needs to look beyond its local market for opportunities. 
 The Australians produced an impressive array of statistics to explain why the Pearl was underperforming and how it was losing market share. 
 So far AMP executives are not sure where the Pearl is going wrong nor what they would do about it, other than perhaps improve the British group's technology and have more centralisation of the selling operations. 
 Yet AMP is prepared to embark on a &pound;1bn adventure, representing over 6 per cent of its assets, which at best will only give it a share of the British life insurance market of between 2 and 2.5 per cent. 
 As a mutual company AMP is accountable to its 2 million policyholders. 
 They will not get an opportunity to vote on the deal because AMP says that the acquisition does not involve a change in its main activities. 
 No meeting of AMP policyholders will be called. 
 Before any eventual takeover of the Pearl is completed by AMP, their voice should be heard. 
 But it is the voice of Pearl investors which will have more influence on the outcome and they should keep quiet for the time being. 
 View from City Road: Lacklustre Tootal 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 ALL THE indications are that the Monopolies &amp; Mergers Commission report, published next week, will give the green light to Coats Viyella's &pound;395m bid for Tootal Group. 
 So as yesterday's half-year figures could be the last Tootal releases as an independent company, it is no surprise it worked hard to make them look good. 
 Out of pre-tax profits that rose &pound;175,000 to &pound;19.25m in the six months to July, some &pound;6.7m could be described as exceptional if not extraordinary. 
 Earnings on an englarged share capital fell 7.6 per cent to 4.65p, and the interim dividend is 1.9p (1.8p). 
 Tootal's 50 per cent stake in Da Gama, the South African textile business, is being sold off in five tranches, the second of which came through in this half bringing &pound;3.3m of profits with it. 
 Being charitable, this could be considered ongoing profit, but what is to be made of Sandhurst Marketing? 
 Tootal bought Sandhurst in 1986 for &pound;21.7m, and sold it in July for a mere &pound;4.38m. 
 However, rather than realising a &pound;17m loss, Tootal's figures show a &pound;3.4m profit, with most of the difference written off earlier through the balance sheet. 
 Sandhurst, which has performed dreadfully under Tootal's control, made a &pound;2m loss up to the point when WH Smith was persuaded to buy it, and three out of the four ongoing Tootal businesses showed disappointing results. 
 The exception was clothing, which bucked the trend of the rest of the UK textile industry partly because it supplies Marks &amp; Spencer, and partly because it makes very little in the UK. 
 Threads, the core of Tootal, saw margins sliced by poor markets in the UK and US. 
 Specialised materials, which Tootal promised would be an engine of growth, has yet to prove its worth, though continued heavy investment could be blamed for a 40 per cent fall in profits. 
 The fabrics side was held back by a decline in demand for batiks in West Africa. 
 Conventional wisdom is that Tootal will add management expertise to Coats, but on the evidence of the first half neither is skilled at controlling working capital. 
 Tootal's is around 35 per cent higher than the group would like, and an interest charge that should be declining was a fifth higher than last year. 
 Pre-tax profits this year will be lower than last year's &pound;42.3m and the shares, which slipped 1.5p to 127p, are only being held up by the Coats offer, worth 133p. 
 If it fails, sell Tootal. 
 If it succeeds sell Coats. 
 View from City Road: Grim prospects for Ferranti 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 FERRANTI'S shares return to active trading today after a three-week suspension and are expected to open at around 45p. 
 That is a sharp decline from the 73.5p at which they were suspended and reflects the financial havoc which has been wrought on the company's accounts as a consequence of the problems at its ISC Technologies subsidiary. 
 Ferranti has said that its revised net worth will have to be reduced by &pound;185m forcing the company to abandon the final dividend payment for the year to March 1989. 
 Restated pre-tax profits for that year will be halved to &pound;27.5m and the current year's profits will also be reduced. 
 It is a grim picture. 
 The company is undercapitalised and overborrowed. 
 It has suffered a severe blow to trading confidence and the only glimmer of hope for the shares appears to be the prospect of a takeover. 
 However, it would be dangerous for investors to pin their colours too firmly to that particular mast. 
 The problem shareholders face is that while there is inherent value in Ferranti's continuing operations, the management is not well placed to exploit it. 
 The company desperately needs a fresh injection of capital but its financial predicament, where the full implications are still far from clear, does not give it a strong hand at the negotiating table. 
 There is a further constraint in that the Ministry of Defence will keep a watchful eye on any potential partner or owner. 
 This could restrict the list of prospective bidders and push Ferranti down a distress sale path. 
 That will be bad for shareholders but something they will have to accept unless they are prepared to fight for fair value. 
 Column Eight: Freezing out the opposition 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 Another accolade has fallen at the feet of Patricia Grant, already honoured with an OBE by the Queen for her efforts in building up Norfrost, the domestic freezer supplier which exports 75 per cent of the 5,000 units it produces each week. 
 On Friday, Mrs Grant will pick up the 1989 Captain of Industry award from the Livingstone Industrial and Commercial Association. 
 She will be the first woman in the award's 10-year history. 
 Chosen as Businesswoman of the Year in 1986, Mrs Grant is no stranger to this sort of publicity. 
 Even so, she seems particularly chuffed. 
 &bquo;It places me alongside such distinguished past captains like Sir Monty Finniston, Sir Campbell Adamson and Sir Matthew Goodwin', she said. 
 Neil Kinnock has again declined an invitation to brief the media's industry hacks at the Labour party conference. 
 This is the second year in a row that the Opposition leader has claimed to be too busy to talk to the boisterous crew. 
 But, explained John Gapper, the secretary of the Labour and Industrial Correspondents Group: &bquo;His office says this is not because he does not like us&equo;. 
 British Business, for 103 years the official weekly organ of the Department of Trade and Industry, has not passed into history without comment. 
 Indeed, there are two versions of the final edition in circulation this week. 
 Presumably the one featuring a gravestone on the front cover is the handiwork of the magazine's journalists. 
 On the inside back cover can be found a crafted allegory. 
 A sad tale about a man who died at the age of 103 because no one would give him any money. 
 The headline is simple. 
 It is the DTI's dynamic enterprise initiative logo. 
 The lab crew at Ciba-Geigy, the Swiss chemical and drugs giant, continues to seek out niche markets with a vengeance. 
 The latest development is a drug called clomipramine which has the endearing quality of reducing the desire to pull your hair out when under stress. 
 The affliction is not as rare as you might think. 
 Apparently eight million Americans pluck their eyebrows, eyelashes and heads when under pressure. 
 The six-mile long bridge linking Japan's largest island, Honshu to Shikoku island is not paying its way. 
 Built over 10 years at a cost of &pound;6bn, the state-of-the-art construction is carrying less than half of the projected amount of traffic. 
 Cynics have pointed out that this might have something to do with the toll. 
 At &pound;55, it is a good deal more expensive than a ticket on the high-speed train which runs just below the bridge. 
 Unilever buys Boursin French Cheese Group 
 By TERENCE WILKINSON, Assistant City Editor 
 UNILEVER, the Anglo-Dutch consumer products group, has bought the Boursin French Cheese Group for an undisclosed sum as a step in its campaign to exploit the underdeveloped &bquo;branded&equo; cheese market in the UK and Europe. 
 Boursin, best known for its Boursin soft cheese and Boursault brands, made a net profit of &pound;3.4m in 1988 on sales of &pound;30m. 
 Unilever is not revealing the price but analysts speculated that on the basis of recent transactions in the European branded food business, such as the French BSN's purchase of HP Sauce and Lea &amp; Perrins from Hanson, a figure of between &pound;30m to &pound;40m may have been paid. 
 With a workforce of 160, Boursin holds about one third of the French speciality cheese market in France and exports to the UK, Benelux, Switzerland and Germany. 
 Unilever, in addition to gaining a strong position in the large French cheese market, sees potential for the international development of the Boursin brand name. 
 Unilever's own cheese interests, which have worldwide sales of &pound;200m a year, are based in Europe with manufacturing operations in Germany, the UK, Belgium and Italy. 
 It exports to most other European countries and also has a presence in the US and Brazil. 
 Bolstered by the acquisition of Asda's West Yorkshire cheese manufacturing operation, Unilever makes full fat, hard and soft cheeses and processed cheeses under the Milkana name. 
 It also makes and distributes low calorie cheeses and polyunsaturated cheese alternatives under the Flora, Becel, Liners, Du Darfst and Vive la Vie brand names. 
 UK consumers have a much smaller appetite for cheese than their continental neighbours. 
 Annual average consumption in the UK is running at 7.5 kilograms per head compared with 16.8kgs in Germany, 17.5kgs in Italy and 21.5 kgs in France. 
 And unlike markets such as the US, the UK cheese eater is not wedded to branded products. 
 Almost three-quarters of the 398,000 tonnes of cheese sold in the UK each year is either cheddar or &bquo;territorial&equo; cheeses such as Cheshire and Red Leicester. 
 Low fat hard and soft cheeses account for 8 per cent of sales. 
 Fund targets Eastern Europe 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 A MUTUAL investment fund for Eastern Europe is being launched today with the backing of Continental Grain, the private American company which is one of the world's biggest grain suppliers. 
 The &dollar;250m Emerging Eastern Europe fund will endeavour to provide capital for businesses in the region and offer Western banks a form of debt-for-equity swap. 
 Continental has traded in Eastern Europe for 20 years and now supplies 25 per cent of the region's imported grain. 
 Previous investments in Eastern Europe have been mainly in the form of joint ventures. 
 But the fund that Continental, through its ContiTrade Services subsidiary, has established with Tyndall Holdings, the fund management group, intends to invest in established companies. 
 The fund will take out insurance against confiscation and government interference in the repatriation of profits. 
 But it has not sought to gain the backing of an official international financial institution. 
 The fund is aiming to raise &dollar;50m from investors initially and a further &dollar;200m from banks looking to reduce their exposure to Eastern Europe. 
 The British banks which have written down the value of their loans most aggressively may be attracted by the fund, says Jim Mellon, a director of Tyndall. 
 Cadbury buys into Iberian soft drinks 
 By TERRY WILKINSON 
 CADBURY Schweppes is building up its presence in the Spanish and Portuguese soft drinks markets with the &pound;45.3m acquisition of several brands together with a fruit plant and bottling plant, writes Terry Wilkinson. 
 The deal will lift its share of the Spanish soft drinks market from 8 to 10 per cent and of the Portuguese market from 3 to 8 per cent. 
 The price paid for the acquisition, including a fruit plant near Valencia and a bottling plant in Barcelona, appears high since the businesses being acquired had sales of &pound;29.6m in 1988 and trading profits of &pound;2.2m, implying a p/e on conventional terms of almost 30. 
 But Cadbury Schweppes, which last month completed the &pound;141m purchase of Crush International from Procter &amp; Gamble, says the brand values being acquired justified the price and it expects to find synergy benefits with its own extensive bottling operations in Spain and Portugal. 
 The Crush purchase boosted Cadbury Schweppes' soft drinks volumes by 30 per cent to over four billion litres a year, which places it third equal with Dr Pepper-Seven Up behind Coca-Cola's 46.5 billion litres and Pepsi's 21.5 billion litres. 
 The McLean family, principal shareholders in Canada Packers, Canada's largest food processor, is putting its 30 per cent stake up for auction. 
 Canada Packer shares rose C&dollar;5 &frac14; to C&dollar;19 on the news, valuing the company at C&dollar;660m (&pound;347.4m). 
 French link gives boost to WCRS 
 By TERRY WILKINSON 
 THE ACQUISITIVE advertising and marketing company WCRS Group more than doubled pre-tax profits to &pound;38.1m for the year to June, largely the result of a first full year contribution from its French affiliate Carat. 
 The result, on revenues which totalled &pound;568.86m (&pound;407.68m), was bloated by a 14 months accounting period as the UK-listed group fell into line with French reporting practice. 
 Even so, the slightly better-than-expected performance translated into earnings per share which rose 26 per cent to 26.92p, fully diluted for preference share conversions. 
 WCRS is paying a 5p final dividend, up from 3.95p last time. 
 The group, which began as a four-way partnership in 1979, is on the verge of lifting its stake in Carat, Europe's largest independent media buying company, as part of its continuing metamorphosis. 
 However, yesterday's announcement shed no more light on the moves which are also likely to involve Eurocom, the French advertising group. 
 &bquo;Negotiations are continuing and shareholders will be advised of the outcome as soon as possible,&equo; WCRS said. 
 BP office deal with EIE put at 200m pounds 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 BP PROPERTIES has sold a central London office to EIE International, the Japanese property investment group, in a deal thought to be worth about &pound;200m. 
 EIE has bought 446,000 square feet of offices in two blocks of 11 and 15 storeys which make up Britannic House West, built 10 years ago and close to the Bank of England. 
 It has been bought on a long lease which also gives BP, which uses the offices, a five-year lease-back arrangement. 
 EIE also has the right to buy the freehold from Whitbread for a nominal sum. 
 The Tokyo-based company refused to confirm the price, but said the deal was the first of &bquo;a number of long-term investments in Britain'. 
 It is planning to build up a portfolio of property and leisure-related developments across Europe. 
 EIE, owned by the businessman Harunori Takahashi, has world-wide assets estimated at more than &dollar;9bn (&pound;5bn), including holdings in Australia, Hong Kong and the United States. 
 Housebuilders are using &bquo;creative accounting&equo; 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 HOUSEBUILDERS are hiding the full impact of the industry recession by using creative accounting to keep the cost of unsold homes off their balance sheets, according to a bank report. 
 Although the worst of the depression may now be over there will be a longer-term impact on compny profits, said Dr Richard Roberts, construction economist with Barclays Bank. 
 In a new survey of the industry he said: &bquo;Housebuilders appear to be using techniques to remove unsold homes from their balance sheets, including &bquo;selling&equo; houses to associate companies. 
 &bquo;The overall effect has been to sustain apparent sales volumes and reduce work in progress. 
 For many housebuilders their day of reckoning in profit terms is still to come.&equo; 
 As a result the financial position of housebuilders is almost certainly worse than appears, with higher building costs and falling sales highlighting the rapidly deteriorating trend in cashflow in 1989 and 1990. 
 Outlook: Crisis? 
 What Channel tunnel crisis? 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 It is Alastair Morton's style to gloss over the tribulations of the Channel tunnel &mdash; such is the Eurotunnel co-chairman's faith in the project. 
 But the latest upheaval must register 10 on the Richter scale. 
 The political and financial capital already invested in the Channel tunnel project should ensure it bores on somehow &mdash; but that is not the same thing as Eurotunnel's survival. 
 On independent advice, the syndicate of more than 200 banks appears to have decided Eurotunnel is no longer a bankable proposition. 
 That, at least, is the clear implication of yesterday's statement from Eurotunnel &mdash; indicating that the bankers believe their own forecast does not provide an appropriate basis for further finance. 
 A three-way dispute has developed about the costs of the venture. 
 According to Eurotunnel it is &pound;7bn; the contractors put it at &pound;7.5bn. 
 Ominously, the highest estimate comes from the bankers' own technical adviser, who puts it at &pound;8.1bn. 
 &bquo;We and the banks are agreed that this is not an appropriate basis for further finance&equo;, Eurotunnel's press release warns. 
 Eurotunnel appears to be hanging on only by the skin of its teeth. 
 The banks have decided that the company is in default on its loan agreements. 
 This would entitle them to sack Eurotunnel's management, bring in new equity participation, and pull the plug on the &pound;1bn invested by existing shareholders in the project. 
 They have decided not to declare the company in default for the time being only because of the continuing discussions between Eurotunnel and the contractors, Transmanche Link. 
 Eurotunnel's only hope seems to lie in satisfying the banks' technical adviser that his forecast can be reduced &mdash; which means at least to the contractors' &pound;7.5bn, if not to Eurotunnel's own &pound;7bn estimate. 
 Even then there is going to have to be a &pound;300m-350m rights issue. 
 The critical decision for the banks will come if their own adviser sticks to his view of the costs. 
 What then? 
 The problem with ditching Eurotunnel's management would be that there is no certainty anybody else could do a better job. 
 Ditching its shareholders is an equally daunting prospect. 
 Not even Mr Morton can play down the gravity of this latest crisis. 
 Outlook: Virgin tune plays on 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 Richard Branson was characteristically cock-a-hoop yesterday as he announced a partnership with Japan's largest record company. 
 Virgin's sale of one quarter of its music business to the entertainment and leisure giant, Fujisankei, ensures that it will remain the last of the world's independent record companies &mdash; for the time being, at least. 
 The price tag of almost &pound;100m, and the fact that Fuji has agreed to a minority stake, has clearly also provided Mr Branson with reassurance &mdash; if he needed any &mdash; that taking Virgin private last year was the right thing to do. 
 Virgin paid &pound;248m last year to remove the group from the scrutiny of the City, saying the business was misunderstood and the stock undervalued. 
 Less than a year later, Fuji seems more than willing to pay &pound;100m for a minority share in the music arm which, with sales of &pound;260m, represents much less than half of the Virgin empire. 
 What remains a mystery is how Virgin would have fared had its directors decided to weather the storms in the stock market. 
 The recent spate of takeovers in the record industry has obliterated the independents and left the big five of Sony, Thorn EMI, Bertelsman, Warner and Polygram with 70 per cent of the market. 
 But the price tags attached to the various deals over the past year have also shown that musicians and copyright have become big business. 
 Sony's recent acquisition &mdash; for &dollar;3.4bn &mdash; of Columbia pictures highlights still more the fact that artists and portfolios of titles, whether music, films or television programmes, are considered very precious indeed. 
 Virgin's boast is that it has grown organically and can continue to do so. 
 It has never lost an artist from its record label, supposedly because it consists of many small and friendly individual companies. 
 Keeping things that way would almost certainly mean that it has to remain independent. 
 Fujisankei, itself privately owned and independent, seems the ideal partner. 
 But the question must remain as to whether a Japanese giant with five times the turnover of the Virgin group will be content to stay a minority player in the long term. 
 Outlook: Riddle of the trade figures 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 The final retail sales figures for August &mdash; barely changed on the provisional statistics &mdash; provide no simple explanation for the trade figures. 
 By volume, retail sales grew just 1.2 per cent in the year to August and in the latest three months they were 1 per cent lower than in the previous period. 
 However, retail sales account for only 40 per cent of consumer spending. 
 It is clear that a roaring trade in cars (not included in retail sales) was part of the reason for the &pound;2bn current account deficit that month. 
 It is possible that the deficit was fuelled in part by stockbuilding. 
 The latest CBI surveys suggest that more stockbuilding has indeed occurred, although not on a scale sufficient to explain the trade figures. 
 Yesterday sterling enjoyed its first quiet day since the trade figures were released a week ago. 
 But the pound will face another test on Thursday when the Bundesbank council meets. 
 A half-point increase in West German interest rates is already more than discounted; a one-point rise may still force a base rate increase on a reluctant Chancellor. 
 Nevertheless, a quiet build-up to Thursday would weigh in his favour. 
 The main central banks exploited yesterday's thin market to launch another visible assault on the dollar. 
 They are still struggling to push the US currency safely back to spring levels. 
 But yesterday's report from the US Purchasing Managers, which put the index of export performance at its highest level since April, is another red rag to dollar bulls looking for a narrower US trade deficit. 
 Hawke tries to shoot down the rebel pilots: Robert Milliken reports on a bitter dispute which could cost the Australian government A100m dollars 
 By ROBERT MILLIKEN 
 AUSTRALIA is now in its seventh week without domestic air services because of a pilots' pay dispute which has begun to have a serious impact on the economy and has left Bob Hawke's Labor government few options for reaching a settlement. 
 After the breakdown last week of an attempt by the Industrial Relations Commission to settle the dispute by arbitration, Mr Hawke's government has begun its controversial plan to compensate the three main domestic airlines &mdash; Ansett, jointly owned by the TNT transport empire and Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation, East-West, an Ansett subsidiary, and the government-owned Australian Airlines. 
 The compensation deal will cost the government an estimated A&dollar;100m and involves Canberra waiving airport landing charges for as long as it takes the airlines to recoup their losses from keeping about 21,000 non-pilot employees on their staff during the dispute. 
 The airlines themselves will next week step up their recruitment drive for pilots in North America and western Europe, where they have also chartered aircraft, by extending their search for flight crews to South Africa and central Europe. 
 The dispute between Australia's 1,700 pilots and the airlines has turned into the country's most bitter industrial confrontation for many years. 
 The pilots resigned six weeks ago when the airlines refused a demand by the Australian Federation of Air Pilots for direct negotiations over their claim for a 29.5 per cent pay rise. 
 The airlines insist the pilots must submit their claim to the regulated wage-fixing system, under whose guidelines most pay rises are now limited to 6 per cent. 
 With deregulation of Australia's domestic air system from next year foreshadowing greater competition, both the pilots and the airlines see the dispute as a final show of strength. 
 Mr Hawke has embarked on a crusade to join the airlines in smashing the pilots' claim, seeing it as a crucial challenge to the cornerstone of his government's economic policy, the wages accord between government, employers and unions. 
 Mr Hawke last week repeated his support for the airlines recruiting new pilots overseas and re-hiring their former pilots on individual contracts. 
 &bquo;The airline operations will be restored without these people,&equo; he said. 
 Paul Keating, the treasurer in Mr Hawke's government, told American bankers, in response to their concern about conducting business in Australia: &bquo;The pilots&equo; federation is not a trade union. 
 It is a rogue professional body, and it is being treated with the same kind of contempt that the air traffic controllers were treated by the Reagan administration in the United States.&equo; 
 However, despite claims by Mr Hawke and Sir Peter Abeles, Ansett's joint managing director and a close friend of Mr Hawke, that air services would be back to normal by next month, there is no sign of this happening. 
 Less than 5 per cent of the Ansett and Australian Airlines fleets have been in the air, using management pilots in a skeleton service supplemented by Royal Australian Air Force planes and overseas airlines. 
 Mr Hawke's handling of the dispute has come under increasing fire from business, unions and the press. 
 The tourism industry, Australia's biggest foreign currency earner, is losing A&dollar;35m a day from the dispute, which would put its losses so far at almost A&dollar;1.5bn. 
 Nearly 15,000 tourism workers have lost their jobs and the industry has lost almost 300,000 tourists a week. 
 Tourism industry leaders have called on the government to compensate them as well as the airlines. 
 At the congress of the Australian Council of Trade Unions in Sydney last week Bill Kelty, the ACTU's secretary, strongly attacked the pilots: &bquo;They are not after an olive branch. 
 They are after an olive tree.&equo; 
 But the union congress also passed a motion condemning the tactics of the airlines and the government, particularly the use of air force planes and foreign pilots to break the dispute. 
 The unions also attacked the Labor government's precedent in compensating employers in an industrial dispute. 
 The government's compensation of the airlines comes when it has also announced a compensation deal worth A&dollar;60m with the troubled Australian subsidiary of the American photographic giant Eastman Kodak. 
 In a recent editorial The Australian Financial Review, the national daily newspaper, said of the pilots' dispute: &bquo;Relentless rhetoric, cynical misinformation and myopic stubbornness have coalesced to provide such a poisonous setting to the dispute that any compromise will be presented as defeat. 
 This is especially the case for the prime minister.&equo; 
 Groupe Bull buys Zenith Computer 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 GROUPE BULL, the French computer company, has launched itself into the personal computer market with the &dollar;635m acquisition of Zenith Computer Group of the US, writes Mary Fagan. 
 The deal doubles Bull's presence in the US and should boost turnover of the Bull group to about &dollar;7bn. 
 Zenith Computer, part of Zenith Electronics Corporation, is a manufacturer of IBM personal computer &bquo;clones&equo; and is an important player in the market for portable computers. 
 But Zenith recently announced second quarter losses due to the strong dollar, high interest charges, and squeezed margins in the computer sector. 
 The acquisition will pitch Bull into the front line of the competitive PC market and is part of the group's overall drive to become a leader in international information technology. 
 Jerry Pearlman, Zenith Electronic's chairman, said that the net proceeds &mdash; about &dollar;22m after taxes and expenses &mdash; would be used to boost investment in lucrative consumer areas, such as high definition television. 
 Zenith is the last US-owned TV manufacturer in a market dominated by Japan. 
 McKinsey in talks with IC Group 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 NEY YORK (Reuter) &mdash; McKinsey and Co said yesterday it was discussing the possibility of the entire staff at Information Consulting Group joining McKinsey. 
 It said it would absorb Information Consulting but could not disclose details of the transaction. 
 Information Consulting, while independent, was formed about a year ago by five former Arthur Andersen partners with financial backing from Saatchi and Saatchi, the advertising and consultancy group. 
 McKinsey said it had several programmes in place to build the information technology capability of its consulting staff, and Information Consulting could accelerate the process. 
 McKinsey said it was dealing directly with Information Consulting on the transaction but the latter would have to be relieved of an option owned by Saatchi before any definitive pact. 
 In return for financial support, Saatchi acquired an exclusive option to buy Information Consulting that would have to be exercised by June next year. 
 But last June Saatchi said it would try to sell its consulting unit. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 Plastic card investment: Barclays Bank looks set to tighten its stranglehold on the processing of plastic card transactions and will invest more than &pound;22.5m in the service. 
 The bank, with 60 per cent of the &bquo;retail acquisition&equo; market, plans to install 20,000 terminals in shops in the next 18 months. 
 Sterling calmer: The pound won respite from last week's onslaught partly due to confirmation that retail sales were subdued last month and as fears of a rise in interest rates faded. 
 This page and Outlook, page 25 Payment withheld: Abbey National intends to refuse to pay the remaining &pound;7m it nominally owes Lloyds Bank Registrars for the handling of its share distribution. 
 Page 24 Shares probe: The Stock Exchange is investigating Friday's steep rise in the share price of Pearl Group, the life insurer, ahead of a &pound;1.1bn takeover bid by Australian Mutual Provident. 
 This page and View from City Road, page 27 Exchange change: The end of the alpha, beta, gamma system of share classification, as well as a change in the International Stock Exchange's working hours, are likely as a result of the Elwes committee's review. 
 Page 24 Century stroke: The Hundred Group of senior British finance directors has urged the Government to consider giving greater commercial freedom to nationalised industries rather than privatising them outright. 
 Page 24 Virgin record sale: Virgin has sold 25 per cent of its music business to Japanese media and entertainment group, Fujisankei, for &pound;96m. 
 Outlook page 25 Profits up: Pre-tax profits at Tootal rose &pound;175,000 to &pound;19.25m in the six months to July ahead of next week's MMC report on Coats Viyella's &pound;395m bid. 
 View from City Road page 27 Tunnel shock: Eurotunnel, the Anglo-French consortium which will operate the twin-rail tunnel when it enters service in June 1993, announced that costs have risen by &pound;2.2bn to &pound;7bn. 
 Outlook page 25 ICI green plant: Chemicals giant, ICI, is to build a &pound;100m plant in Louisiana for the production of alternatives to chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), widely used compounds which deplete the earths ozone layer. 
 Board demands: Trustees representing the interests of the Ferranti family have written to chairman Sir Derek Alun-Jones asking for the board to be replaced or supplemented by new directors. 
 Page 24 and View from City Road, page 27 Gollancz buy: US-based Houghton Mifflin intends to purchase Victor Gollancz, the privately owned London publisher, subject to the approval of shareholders. 
 Proposed terms were not disclosed. 
 Iberian additions: Cadbury Schweppes is building market share in Spain and Portugal with the acquisition of several drinks brands and fruit and bottling plants for &pound;45.3m. 
 Page 27 World Markets New York: Blue chips achieved good progress, pushing the Dow Jones Industrial Average 20.9 points higher to 2,713.72 by the close. 
 Tokyo: Prices rose at first after the ruling Liberal Democratic party's by-election victory but drifted later to close mixed, with the Nikkei average 13.79 points lower at 35,622.97. 
 Hong Kong: Dull trade in the absence of clear direction saw an 11.55-point fall in the Hang Seng index to 2,746.7. 
 Singapore: Profit-taking cancelled out early gains and the Straits Times index closed just 0.07 up at 1,375.25. 
 Sydney: Continued activity in the banking sector helped the All Ordinaries index to close 7.4 points higher at 1,743.4. 
 Paris: Eurotunnel was the most active stock and one of the heaviest fallers as the CAC-40 index plunged 29.88 points to 1,876.24. 
 The group's shares fell 5.6 per cent after it announced a revised estimated cost for the Channel tunnel project. 
 Frankfurt: Turnover was moderate on expectation of higher interest rates. 
 The DAX index added 3.43 points to 1,577.8. 
 Zurich: Uncertainty over the market's short-term trend combined with interest rate fears to push the all-share index down 15.5 points to 1,161.2. 
 Milan: Operators reacted with frustration to a spate of new capital increase operations announced late last week. 
 The MIB fell 0.92 per cent to 1,182. 
 Madrid: Firm electrical stocks were a highlight as the index rose 0.52 to 325.8. 
 AMP offers 1.1bn pounds for Pearl 
 By JOHN MOORE, Assistant City Editor 
 THE International Stock Exchange is mounting a preliminary investigation into the steep rise in the share price of Pearl Group, the British life insurer, last Friday ahead of the announcement yesterday of a &pound;1.1bn takeover bid for the group by Australian Mutual Provident, Australia's largest life insurance group. 
 On Friday the share price of Pearl Group rose 44p to 552p as news of the bid began to leak out. 
 After the formal announcement by Australian Mutual Provident yesterday of its bid Pearl's share price rose a further 87p to 639p. 
 Officials at the exchange said yesterday that its current investigation was a matter of routine. 
 If they discovered evidence of share dealing ahead of the takeover by individuals using confidential information they would institute more formal inquiries. 
 As officials began their investigations the board of directors of Pearl, led by chairman Einion Holland, said AMP's takeover bid &bquo;is unacceptable and totally inadequate because it fails to reflect the group's financial strength and prospects&equo;. 
 Pearl advised its shareholders to take no action. 
 Mr Holland was due to meet AMP's chairman, David Anderson, today in a meeting which had been planned since June. 
 Because of the takeover moves the meeting was cancelled. 
 &bquo;We are better served as an independent company getting on with our own plans without the involvement of any Australian freebooters,&equo; said Mr Holland. 
 In its takeover deal Australian Mutual Provident is offering 605p in cash for each share investors hold in the Pearl. 
 Instead of accepting the cash deal Pearl shareholders can sell their shares in return for AMP's loan notes. 
 Pearl Group executives were angry at an attack on the company's performance by AMP. 
 AMP said that over the past 10 years, measured in terms of new annual premiums, Pearl's market position has fallen sharply and its share has declined consistently. 
 Pearl specialises in door-to-door collection of insurance premiums from customers who have taken out insurance policies. 
 Australian Mutual Provident said yesterday that this type of business was a declining sector of the UK. 
 The Australian group said it believed that Pearl, &bquo;if left to itself, will continue the long-term downward trend in its market position and is unlikely to meet the challenges presented by the developments in the UK and European life insurance markets.&equo; 
 In June this year AMP increased its shareholding in Pearl to 18 per cent when it acquired a 13 per cent stake from FAI Insurances, a leading Australian insurance and investment group. 
 Although AMP has a significant stake, other British insurance companies own over 20 per cent of Pearl's shares. 
 Allianz AG Holding, the West German insurer, is to pay Fr6.5bn (&pound;644.8m) for 50 per cent of the insurance assets of the French financial and industrial holding concern Compagnie de Navigation Mixte. 
 Giant with international intentions: Australian Mutual Provident 
 By JOHN MOORE, Assistant City Editor 
 AUSTRALIAN Mutual Provident was founded as a mutual life society in 1849 and has grown to be the largest life office in Australia and New Zealand. 
 It claims to rank among the 20 largest mutual life offices in the world. 
 AMP has approximately 30 per cent of the life insurance and superannuation markets in Australia and is the largest manager of private retirement funds in that country and New Zealand. 
 It handles the pension planning arrangements for 40,000 Australian companies and is a leading promoter of regular premium private pension plans. 
 AMP currently employs over 9,000 people worldwide and has a sales force of over 4,300 agents. 
 AMP has had a business in the UK since 1908. 
 In March this year it increased its presence in the UK with the acquisition of London Life, the British mutual insurer, which attracted a measure of opposition from the British group's policyholders. 
 AMP argues that its proposed acquisition of Pearl represents a significant step in its plans to become a major force in international life insurance markets. 
 The Australian group said that Pearl's policyholders will benefit from the deal through its capacity to bring new products and marketing skills and expertise in administration, computing and product development. 
 If successful in acquiring the British group it intends to operate Pearl as a separate entity with its own sales force. 
 Ferranti family calls for management changes 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Business Correspondent 
 THE FERRANTI family has demanded senior management changes at the troubled electronics company bearing its name. 
 This is the first visible sign of a shareholders' revolt against the chairman, Sir Derek Alun-Jones, since the discovery of a &pound;185m fraud which threatens the group's future. 
 Sir Derek believes he should not be held to blame since the fraud occurred in the accounts of International Signal and Control, which had received a &bquo;clean&equo; audit when Ferranti bought the company two years ago. 
 Trustees representing substantial family interests have written to Sir Derek asking for the board to be replaced or supplemented by new directors. 
 &bquo;It is an accepted practice in dire situations such as this that the board is replaced or supplemented by a new board charged with the function of restoring the fortunes of the company and the confidence of customers,&equo; the letter says. 
 &bquo;You may care to consider whether this is not a practice to be followed in the case of Ferranti.&equo; 
 The Ferranti family's demands came to light as a result of an approach by representatives of Hill Samuel and Murray Johnstone, who are canvassing support among shareholders for a plan to make Ferranti hive off its core UK defence interests and merge them with the defence activities of Thorn EMI. 
 Trustees of Ferranti family shareholdings in the company wrote back saying there was an urgent need to reinforce the board so that proposals and the inevitable approaches that the company would receive could be reviewed by a strengthened board. 
 &bquo;The statements that have been made by the company have made no reference to board changes,&equo; the letter said. 
 The family's interests include shares owned by the estate of the late Basil de Ferranti, a former chairman of the company. 
 Sebastian de Ferranti, Basil's brother and now a director of Ferranti's competitor GEC, is a trustee of the interests but it is not clear whether he shares these views. 
 Basil de Ferranti was chairman of the company until it merged with International Signal and Control, a takeover which he supported. 
 As part of the deal Mr de Ferranti agreed to stand down in favour of Sir Derek and to allow James Guerin, International Signal's founder, to come on to the board as deputy chairman. 
 Ferranti expects to take delivery today of the report it commissioned from Coopers and Lybrand on the alleged fraud. 
 Since the report is expected to form the basis for an investigation and possible action by the Serious Fraud Office, it is highly unlikely that it will be published in full. 
 However, it could provide ammunition for legal action which Ferranti intends to take against advisers and individuals in an attempt to recover some of the losses it has suffered. 
 Abbey to withhold 7m pounds Lloyds payment over bungled issue 
 By PATRICK HOSKING, Banking Correspondent 
 ABBEY NATIONAL intends to refuse to pay the remaining &pound;7m it nominally owes Lloyds Bank Registrars for the handling of its share distribution and it is planning to claim additional compensation for the bungled flotation. 
 The former building society is understood to be prepared to take court action if it does not wrest the compensation from Lloyds. 
 It made a &pound;3m upfront payment to Lloyds out of the total &pound;10m agreed. 
 The dispute between Abbey and Lloyds appeared increasingly acrimonious yesterday. 
 Abbey said there was a meeting planned to discuss the contract this week. 
 Lloyds said there was not. 
 The two sides are also split over whether all share certificates and refund cheques are now safely delivered to the Abbey's 5.5 million shareholders. 
 Abbey says it is still receiving complaints. 
 Lloyds claims the problem is resolved. 
 Leonard Winbolt of Kings Lynn in Norfolk is typical of the remaining aggrieved would-be shareholders. 
 His cheque for &pound;1,950 was cashed on 6 July. 
 So far all he has received are 100 free shares. 
 He has yet to receive his paid-for shares or a refund. 
 In addition Lloyds, having cashed his cheque, later demanded a photocopy of it as proof he had made the payment. 
 &bquo;It's really not good enough,&equo; Mr Winbolt said yesterday. 
 Around 600,000 members of the former building society have still not registered for their entitlement of free shares. 
 The Abbey is now planning a fifth mailshot to alert them to their windfalls. 
 The Department of Trade and Industry has ruled out an official Companies Act investigation of the flotation, in which the ashes of up to half a million share certificates were discovered in a skip in South London and tens of thousands of other documents were botched. 
 Grand Met bid for Whyte &amp; Mackay 
 By FRANK KANE 
 GRAND METROPOLITAN, the international food and drinks group, has put in a &pound;150m bid for the Whyte &amp; Mackay spirits business being sold by leisure group Brent Walker. 
 However, it looks as though Grand Met's bid is going to be beaten by a management buyout which is in the final stages of negotiation. 
 The Grand Met offer was made as the two companies were negotiating the sale of the William Hill chain of betting shops, which Brent Walker has agreed to buy for &pound;685m. 
 It was revealed yesterday when the document detailing the William Hill sale was sent to shareholders. 
 A statement from Grand Met said: &bquo;In a limited auction conducted recently by Brent Walker, Grand Met agreed to purchase Whyte &amp; Mackay at a price of up to &pound;150m. 
 &bquo;However, a consortium led by its management reached agreement with Brent Walker at a higher price. 
 At that time, Grand Met entered into an option whereby Brent Walker could sell Whyte &amp; Mackay to it for &pound;150m at any time before October 31.&equo; 
 If the buyout, which is expected to offer about &pound;160m for the Haig and Claymore whisky group, is completed before that date, Grand Met's option would lapse. 
 Brent Walker said it expected the buyout negotiations &bquo;would be successfully completed shortly&equo;. 
 Brent Walker bought Whyte &amp; Mackay from Lonrho earlier this year for &pound;180m in a deal that included four French vineyards, which are also for sale for as much as &pound;60m. 
 State firms &bquo;should be free to borrow&equo; 
 By JEREMY WARNER 
 A HIGH-POWERED group of finance directors has urged the Government to consider giving greater commercial freedom to nationalised industries such as British Rail and the Post Office rather than privatising them outright. 
 They should be made to correspond more closely with private sector practice and allowed the freedom to borrow from the market place, the group says. 
 They should also be given permission to issue some form of fixed interest profit-related bond, be allowed to raise a proportion of their equity direct from the public and be subject to independent regulation similar to that of privatised utilities. 
 These are the main recommendations of a report from the Hundred Group of senior British finance directors, published yesterday and circulated to ministers and senior civil servants. 
 At the moment nationalised industries are severely restricted in the way they borrow money. 
 Though state-owned companies are able to achieve keener interest rates by borrowing from the Government through the National Loan Fund, they are constrained in the amount they can borrow and the uses to which the money can be put because all such borrowings count towards the public sector borrowing requirement. 
 The Hundred Group recommends that nationalised industries should be allowed to borrow without Government guarantee and that the borrowings should be excluded from the PSBR. 
 Edward Weiss, chairman of the report's working party, said the recommendations were being put forward as an alternative to privatisation. 
 &bquo;If the objective of privatisation is to improve management performance, it can be achieved in ways other than all-out privatisation,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The black and white approach used in this country, where a company is either wholly in the public sector or wholly in the private sector, is not mirrored on the Continent. 
 &bquo;The fundamental problem with state-owned industries is that they are rationed of capital. 
 &bquo;Our proposals would offer them an alternative market for capital.&equo; 
 One possible application of the proposals would be to the Civil Aviation Authority, which desperately needs new capital to deal with the problems of air traffic congestion in Europe. 
 ISE considers Elwes report 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 THE END of the alpha, beta, gamma system of share classification, as well as a change in the International Stock Exchange's working hours, are likely as a result of the Elwes committee's review of ISE working practice. 
 The ISE Council yesterday considered a progress report from the special committee on the domestic equity market, chaired by Nigel Elwes, which was set up last year to examine stock market procedures in the wake of the October 1987 crash. 
 The Council confirmed the broad outline of the present Stock Exchange automated quotation system (Seaq), but agreed to look more closely at specific areas of operation. 
 These include: Proposed revisions to market hours in order to make official dealing times, mandatory quote periods and Seaq dealing times overlap more closely than at present. 
 The new set-up would stipulate 8.30am to 4.30pm as the official trading day. 
 A new basis for classifying stocks, which are currently graded on the number of market makers, market capitalisation and quarterly turnover into alpha, beta and gamma categories. 
 The proposal would rank them according to liquidity (how regularly a stock is traded) and turnover. 
 A proposal to introduce a limited order facility to enable clients to execute transactions automatically at pre-set prices. 
 It is aimed at private clients dealing in individual stocks. 
 The redesign of the Daily Official List, the ISE's record of dealings. 
 The aim would be to make the much-criticised publication more &bquo;user friendly&equo;. 
 Andrew Hugh Smith, ISE chairman, said: &bquo;Turnover in UK equities has seen an increase of almost 50 per cent over the past year, alleviating some of the problems caused by the very low volumes after the market crash. 
 &bquo;Nevertheless, the council believes we must ensure the market structure provides the right balance of benefits and obligations for market practitioners, whilst offering investors and issuers the opportunity to do business efficiently and cost effectively.&equo; 
 The council has endorsed a recommendation from the committee that there should be no change to the restrictions placed on inter-dealer broker services, which many market makers have criticised. 
 The committee's full recommendations are expected towards the end of this year or early 1990. 
 EC reaches accord with US on steel subsidies 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Washington 
 THE US and EC have reached agreement in principle on common limits for public subsidies to the steel industry on both sides of the Atlantic, based closely on existing Community rules. 
 But the two sides were still at loggerheads yesterday on the details of expanded, voluntary limits on EC steel exports to the US, to replace five-year-old quotas which expired on Saturday. 
 In extensive talks in New York and Washington over the weekend, the European Commission and US government also radically disagreed on how a transatlantic steel subsidy code should be policed and enforced. 
 But official negotiations were still in progress yesterday. 
 The EC commissioner for external affairs, Frans Andriessen, who took part in the first stage of the negotiations in New York last Friday, will report on progress to Community foreign ministers in Luxembourg today. 
 It is envisaged that a joint EC-US subsidy agreement would open the way for freer trade in steel across the Atlantic. 
 It is also envisaged that some other steel exporting countries would ultimately accept the rules, creating an &bquo;International Consensus&equo; on public aids to steel producers, which could be formalised under the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT). 
 Those countries inside the agreement would conduct relatively free trade in steel; those countries unable to meet the conditions would continue to be heavily restricted. 
 According to Washington sources, the first step towards this new world order for steel has been agreed in principle by Brussels and Washington: the 1985 EC steel subsidy code, in slightly adapted form, would be applied jointly to US and EC producers. 
 All capital and operating subsidies to steel producers would be banned; limited public subsidies would be allowed for research and development, environmental improvements, closures and redundancies. 
 This would be the first example of Community rules crossing the Atlantic. 
 But acute difficulties remain on how such a code would be enforced. 
 The Community wants to create bureacratic machinery for joint arbitration of disputes. 
 But it is understood that the US Trade Representative, Carla Hills, is insisting the US retain powers to act unilaterally against European steel producers judged by Washington to be breaking the code. 
 Respite for pound in sales figures 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 THE POUND won some respite yesterday from last week's onslaught partly due to confirmation that retail sales were subdued last month and as fears of an imminent rise in base rates faded. 
 In London, sterling ended slightly higher and the dollar finished little changed after resisting another round of intervention by the main central banks, which at best took the steam out of a small-scale rally. 
 As expected, the volume of retail sales rose 0.5 per cent in August &mdash; barely changed on the provisional figure. 
 In the year to August, sales were just 1.2 per cent above a year ago. 
 In the latest three months the volume overall sales were down 1 per cent with the steepest falls registered by retailers of clothing and footwear, down 5 per cent and household goods, 4 per cent. 
 Meanwhile new credit was a record &pound;4bn in August, partly because of strong car sales and also credit card holiday bookings. 
 BOOK REVIEW / The spy who lunched me: &bquo;The Ultra Spy&equo; &mdash; F W Winterbotham: Macmillan 12.95 pounds 
 By C J FOX 
 FOR A gang conspiring to conquer Europe, the Nazis were capable of conduct weirdly out of character. 
 There they were in 1934 hatching plans for invading Russia but allowing one of their army chiefs &mdash; &bquo;a typical monocled, duel-scarred, square-headed general of the High Command&equo; &mdash; to reveal the lot to an RAF veteran over lunch at a plush Berlin restaurant. 
 The astonished Briton, who recounts the event in this new autobiography, also recalls how his Nazi host remarked to him after the general had finished spouting: &bquo;I'm sure it's not necessary to ask you not to pass any information on to the Communists.&equo; 
 Even the most myopic Teuton must have been able to see that the politely inquisitive Englishman being entrusted with these confidences had to be an Intelligence man. 
 Perhaps it was F W Winterbotham's languid County and Oxford bearing that seduced these ruffians. 
 Or it might have been his membership of that dashing elite, the air fighters of World War I. 
 In any case, Fred Winterbotham first succeeded in charming the Nazis' arch-ideologue Alfred Rosenberg and through him mingled attentively with the highest elements of the Party. 
 Amazingly he was permitted to witness the illicit Luftwaffe build-up of the mid-Thirties, the preparations in East Prussia for the drive on the USSR, and much else. 
 The astounding indulgences granted Winterbotham by the regime apparently formed part of a scheme to woo ranking foreigners and through them impress their governments with Germany's mounting might. 
 From Britain, Hitler wanted nothing more than neutrality. 
 Winterbotham, a future mastermind of the &bquo;Ultra&equo; miracle that decoded wartime German communications, naturally reporting his chilling discoveries back from the Reich to the minions of MacDonald, Baldwin and Chamberlain. 
 Too often the evidence of devilish intent was received with disbelief or electorally inspired inaction (though Winston, waiting in the wings, gobbled it up). 
 The bizarre story of Winterbotham's unhindered wanderings round Hitler's domain is one of the two highlights of The Ultra Spy, the other being his adventures as organiser of the information later garnered from Ultra. 
 That system of wholesale electronic eavesdropping Winterbotham proudly dubs &bquo;the greatest war-winning achievement by British brains and money&equo;. 
 Yet his claims for Ultra, which he originally set out in his book The Ultra Secret, sometimes sound overwrought. 
 Commanders who undervalued or ignored Ultra get short shrift. 
 One such sceptic, a certain Montgomery, is likened to a prickly housemaid. 
 US General Mark Clark passed up Ultra and duly paid the price, according to Winterbotham, by failing to take two objectives at a nasty stage of the Italian campaign. 
 Later Clark did heed Ultra. 
 The result: triumph as the first Allied general to enter Rome. 
 It was in 1929, aged about 30, that Winterbotham came to the momentous realisation, worthy of Bertie Wooster, that &bquo;I should have to get a job&equo;. 
 This turned out to be running an RAF section of the Secret Intelligence Service; and it was as an SIS functionary that he criss-crossed Germany. 
 In The Ultra Spy, he provides some enthralling verbal snapshots of the Nazi moguls he met. 
 A typical eruption of shouting by the Fuhrer, complete with bristling moustache, flushed neck and bulging eyes, was elicited by Winterbotham's demure suggestion that the leader of the Third Reich &bquo;obviously felt very strongly about Communism&equo;. 
 As for Himmler, he &bquo;looked at you with his beady eyes through his thick-lensed, rimless glasses, yet never seemed to see you. 
 Perhaps he was only locating the jugular vein for future use. 
 His handclasp was cold; his black uniform befitting the poisonous beetle that he was. 
 He had no social graces whatever.&equo; 
 This last must be the understatement of the century. 
 There is much of the airy clubman, in fact, about Winterbotham. 
 For instance, while admitting that Goebbels resembled an &bquo;evil gnome&equo;, he adds: &bquo;At least he stood by his leader to the end. 
 Unless you are insane, it takes guts to sacrifice your whole family and die with them.&equo; 
 And Rosenberg: &bquo;Utterly misguided he may have been, but he was honest in his own belief in what he was doing.&equo; 
 Damn fine fighter, that Winterbotham, but a good sport. 
 Illiberal liberalism: John Torode finds a seminar on the Salman Rushdie affair dispiriting 
 By JOHN TORODE 
 THE Salman Rushdie affair has had two consequences. 
 It has rendered untenable the simplistic belief that members of all ethnic minorities are part of one undifferentiated &bquo;black&equo; mass, supposedly united in making &bquo;progressive&equo; demands, stemming from the economic and social disadvantages they suffer. 
 Second, it has splintered the liberal establishment. 
 On one side stand the absolutists, such as Fay Weldon and Harold Pinter, who feel that burning and banning books is intolerable; on the other stand the pragmatists who feel that freedom of expression is not an absolute good and that censorship (self-imposed, imposed by neighbours or by Parliament) is justified to protect the sensibilities of those whose views are fundamentalist, and thus illiberal. 
 The Commission for Racial Equality and the liberal Policy Studies Institute this week conclude a series of seminars provoked by the Rushdie affair. 
 I was invited to chair one session last week. 
 It was a dispiriting occasion in which the seeds of a repressive new &bquo;liberalism&equo; were apparent. 
 The conference was dominated by pragmatist liberals. 
 They included academics, members of the race relations industry and journalists. 
 There were also a few devout Muslims. 
 I was told that both the new right and those who support the Government's view &mdash; that the present blasphemy laws which protect only Christianity should be retained &mdash; had been excluded. 
 Members of both groups either behaved badly at conferences or had no interest in improving race relations. 
 Fay Weldon and her allies had not been invited either, because, it was felt, they held racist attitudes, consciously or not. 
 The liberal establishment believes that the law should apply equally to all religions. 
 Its members would prefer the repeal of the blasphemy laws rather than their extension. 
 And they insist patronisingly that the religious fervour displayed by some British Muslims symbolises a wider social distress. 
 Give Muslims decent housing and better job opportunities, put an end to racist attacks and insults, and youngsters will cease to carry banners reading: &bquo;Die, Rushdie bastard.&equo; 
 The Muslims present last week were not interested in earthly equality. 
 Nor did they want equal non-protection from the law &mdash; they wanted censorship. 
 In Shabir Akhtar, an articulate Cambridge graduate in philosophy and a PhD from the university of Alberta, they have a formidable spokesman. 
 He has an impressive grounding in Western thought and argues that book-banning is an honorable part of the Western liberal tradition. 
 Dr Akhtar pointed to incitement to racial hatred, libel, obscenity, and breaches of national security as areas in which the liberal state bans publication. 
 He demanded &bquo;negotiated compromise&equo; with Islamic leaders. 
 Such compromise would, he suggested, lead inexorably to censorship to &bquo;protect Muslim sensibilities against gratuitous provocation&equo;. 
 In other words, if Dr Akhtar has his way, it would become unlawful to vilify a person's religion, just as it is to humiliate him because of the colour of his skin. 
 Superficially, Mr Akhtar's compromise has appeal in a liberal/secular society because it is designed to protect human sensitivities which we all recognise, rather than to appease a deity in whom relatively few believe. 
 Yet the effect of the proposal would be to ban, for example, Voltaire's Candide, Tom Paine's Age of Reason, Bertrand Russell's Why I Am Not a Christian, Scorsese's The Last Temptation of Christ, as well as Monty Python's The Life of Brian. 
 It would erode the precious British freedom, gained at considerable cost over several centuries, to shock and insult and to ridicule as a way of testing the faiths of our forefathers. 
 Even so, no liberal voice was raised in dissent. 
 Indeed, philosophers such as Susan Mendus, of York University, produced a novel apologia for liberal book-banning: &bquo;Where free speech is employed in such a way as to destroy the possibility of communication and of mutual understanding, then its raison d'etre is destroyed,&equo; she argued. 
 What we are witnessing, I fear, is the birth of a new and dangerously illiberal &bquo;liberal&equo; orthodoxy designed to accommodate Dr Akhtar and his fundamentalist friends, who do not pretend to be part of the Western liberal tradition. 
 I long for the protection of a written constitution like that of the US with its First Amendment, which elevates freedom of expression above freedom to hide from intellectual challenge, or even vulgar verbal abuse. 
 A quote away from glory 
 By PETER JENKINS 
 BRIGHTON: In six verbose years as leader of his party, Neil Kinnock has not a memorable phrase to his credit. 
 Although not exactly stuck for words, nothing that he has said has yet entered the language. 
 His speechwriting aides confessed themselves stumped for a Kinnockism worthy of inclusion in a dictionary of modern political quotations. 
 The best they could recall was his one-liner to Derek Hatton, the Liverpool militant, at Bournemouth in 1985: &bquo;You don't play politics with people's jobs,&equo; Mr Kinnock told him. 
 But that falls into the somewhat different category of intra-party polemic. 
 I am talking about phrases which speak to the country by capturing its mood or its hopes. 
 Harold Wilson's words are remembered today, 25 years after he led Labour back to power, from 13 wilderness years. 
 &bquo;The white heat of the scientific revolution&equo;, which he spoke of in his Scarborough speech of 1963, caught and mobilised the spirit of those times. 
 &bquo;The candyfloss society&equo; stung and stuck as a comment on Harold Macmillan's seedy and stagnant Britain. 
 His mocking of his opponent, Lord Home, served not only to challenge the competence of the Establishment but equally to advertise the superior competence of Harold Wilson. 
 Wilson said it all when he said &bquo;after half a century of democratic advance, the whole process has ground to a halt with a fourteenth earl&equo;. 
 He tagged the Tories with a grouse moor image and mocked Home for his &bquo;matchbox economics&equo;. 
 He used language, the politician's only weapon, to build a momentum for change sufficient to carry Labour to power on a modernising platform. 
 Here in Brighton this week reams of revisionism are being pulped through the decision-making process of the Labour Party conference, loads of ideological lumber jettisoned as Labour endeavours &bquo;to meet the challenge and make the change&equo;. 
 In the country, the underlying tide of opinion is favourable to Labour: in six months, Gallup's &bquo;fitness to govern&equo; test has turned from a negative to a positive while, remarkably, two-thirds of respondents believe they would be better off under Labour. 
 For all that, behind the new ring of confidence from Mr Kinnock and the Labour leadership lies a certain hollowness of conviction. 
 Nobody quite has an answer to the question &bquo;why Labour for the Nineties?&equo;. 
 Brains are racked, in vain, for that elusive &bquo;big idea&equo; &mdash; what comes after Mrs Thatcher, the next item on history's agenda &mdash; if there is one. 
 In the absence of the big idea, one good phrase would be a help, something to focus the uncertain and suggestible mood of the country and put its finger on what it is that is missing and wanted after 10 years of Mrs Thatcher. 
 By the end of this week we shall know what the Labour Party no longer stands for, such as unilateral nuclear disarmament and full-scale nationalisation; but what, in essence, does it stand for? 
 If it did not exist, would anyone trouble to invent it at a time when, from the Atlantic to the Urals, socialism in all its manifestations is losing the argument to liberal capitalism? 
 For we should not become too carried away by Labour's changed face and tone of voice, nor too dazzled by the Peter Mandelson image-conjuring. 
 The party may have put on a collar and tie but it is still the Labour Party, prone to its old reflexes (as it reminded us yesterday on defence spending), prisoner still of its anachronistic structure, its mind set in 100 years of working- class history. 
 Listening to the first day's proceedings, I found myself not transported into the future so much as revisiting the past. 
 Here was the Labour Party reverting to its old self, a better self, yes, than the monster it became under the demonic spell of Tony Benn; here was a party responsive once more to its own people, the people it so shamefully betrayed at two successive general elections since 1979, but a party &mdash; as somebody once said of the SDP - &bquo;promising a better yesterday&equo;. 
 Here it is still with its delegations and block votes, composite motions and reference backs of its convoluted proceduralism, its quaint forms of speech and styles of address &mdash; comrades, brothers, sisters, chair. 
 A sufficient moral universe it may remain for those who inhabit it, but they are a dwindling band and for large areas of the country Labour's world is a cultural world apart. 
 Amid the euphoria of its seven-point opinion poll lead, the party's own pollsters have reminded it that in the South the Conservatives lead 47-33 while in the Midlands and Wales the race remains too close to call. 
 In these regions, the Conservative vote is down respectively by only 5 and 3 per cent on 1987, not enough to suggest widespread Labour gains come 1992. 
 In a masterly television interview on Sunday, John Smith, the shadow Chancellor, exuded competence and an almost Gladstonian fiscal probity, but there was a ring of the Sixties about the accompanying discussion between MPs and experts which left the impression that, in squaring circles, the Labour Party remains endemically the party of inflation. 
 The abandonment yesterday of unilateral nuclear disarmament (although not the intention of abandoning Britain's nuclear deterrent at the earliest opportunity while other countries keep theirs) was done in the same spirit of moralism which had gone into the banning of the Bomb. 
 Once more the world was treated as a convenience wrapping for Labour's parochial and predominantly internal preoccupations. 
 The symbolism of Ron Todd succumbing to superior card power, and pointedly declining to fight, fight and fight again, is electorally helpful but not enough to dispel the persisting impression that Labour is not quite serious about defence. 
 Today gives Mr Kinnock his chance, not to be serious about wanting to win - he has amply proven that &mdash; but to say why he deserves to win. 
 If he could find convincing words to say it in one striking and memorable phrase, he might be truly on his way. 
 A pot of hubris at the rainbow's end: Fukuyama may have miscalculated &bquo;the end of history&equo; by discounting religion, says Eamon Duffy 
 By EAMON DUFFY 
 THE view from Francis Fukuyama's window at the State Department in Washington (reflected in his two-part article on 20 and 21 September) is evidently reassuring. 
 The collapse of Marxism-Leninism has brought us to that &bquo;absolute moment&equo; which marks the end of humanity's long journey through the night of political confusion and abortive social and economic experiment. 
 Everywhere the nations bow in recognition that the political and ethical values and free market economics which characterise the USA represent the &bquo;final, rational form of society&equo;. 
 There are now no &bquo;fundamental contradictions in human life that cannot be resolved in the context of modern liberalism&equo;. 
 What then will humanity find to do with its hitherto misdirected energies? 
 Here Fukuyama concedes a snag. 
 Whatever the past illusions of the imperialist and nationalist ventures of nations, or of the master error of Marxism-Leninism, they did evoke from people &bquo;daring, courage, imagination and idealism&equo;. 
 But in the &bquo;final, rational form of society&equo;, there will be no more of that beautiful nonsense, just as there will be no art and no philosophy. 
 The virtues born during the millennia of delusion before everybody saw the importance and inevitability of becoming American will be replaced by &bquo;economic calculations, the endless solving of technical problems, environmental concerns and the satisfaction of sophisticated consumer demands&equo;. 
 Was it for this that earth grew tall? 
 Confronted with the evaporation of virtue, heroism, art and philosophy, does Fukuyama feel rage, despair or at any rate some doubt about whether such an ordering of life can really be the &bquo;final, rational form of society&equo;? 
 None of these. 
 He acknowledges that &bquo;the end of history will be a sad time&equo;, he admits the &bquo;spiritual vacuity of liberal consumerist societies&equo;, but, in the face of their inevitable triumph, feels, and notices in his friends, only &bquo;ambivalence (and) a powerful nostalgia&equo; for a world that has passed away. 
 The hubris of all this is breathtaking. 
 The whole human enterprise has been designed to produce Fukuyama and his like. 
 Anything better, anything different, is hardly conceivable. 
 The economic casualties of capitalist society in America he explains away as &bquo;the legacy of a pre-liberal past&equo;, and appears to make no connection between Western prosperity and the victim economies of the third world, still regrettably &bquo;mired in history&equo;. 
 Nor is there any need to risk being challenged by alternative social visions, to attend to the views of &bquo;every crackpot messiah round the world&equo;, since &bquo;it matters very little what strange thoughts occur to people in Albania or Burkina Faso, for we are interested in what one could in some sense call the common ideological heritage of mankind&equo;. 
 Just so might the exhausted arrogance of a dying empire have expressed itself on the lips of a Roman senator waving away the news of a &bquo;crackpot messiah&equo; among the Jews, and the strange thoughts that occur to people in Jerusalem or Galilee. 
 It does occur to Fukuyama that religion might have some sort of unease to express with all this, but he appears to conceive of religion under only two modes. 
 On the one hand, there is fundamentalist counter-ideology, such as the Islamic theocratic state. 
 This, it is to be assumed, his liberal readers may take seriously as a threat, but hardly as an option. 
 And on the other hand, there are &bquo;less organised religious impulses&equo;, religion as individual preference. 
 This he knows can readily be accommodated as yet another sort of consumer commodity, &bquo;within the sphere of personal life permitted in liberal societies&equo;. 
 But there is no need to look to &bquo;crackpot messiahs&equo; or fundamentalist theocracies to find a decisive religious rejection of Fukuyama's reading of human history. 
 For him, the energies driving history have been derived from the interplay between external forces, conflicting visions of the right ordering of society. 
 With the unchallenged victory of one such vision the conflict ceases, and the millennium arrives. 
 Catholic Christianity, however, insists that social, political and economic tension, discord and conflict are manifestations of sin, springing from humanity's fallen nature. 
 According to St Augustine, &bquo;fellowship among men is secured by giving and receiving&equo;. 
 But such mutual exchange is just what human beings are incapable of sustaining consistently. 
 As a result, &bquo;human society is generally divided against itself, one part, the more powerful, oppressing the other&equo;. 
 The struggles of history are not, therefore, part of an external dialectic resolvable in principle by the overthrow of one of its polarities. 
 Instead they issue from the divided heart of humanity, perpetually institutionalised in sinful social and political structures. 
 One modern variety of this Catholic critique of structural sin in society is represented by the Liberation theology evolved in Latin America, which sees in the economic and political structures of capitalism itself a principal manifestation of sin, oppressing God's poor and subverting true human community. 
 Fukuyama is unlikely to attach much weight to Liberation theology, which he would no doubt classify as a doomed subspecies of Marxism-Leninism. 
 He might be less likely to dismiss Pope John Paul II as the stooge of a defunct ideology, yet there is plenty in the conservative tradition of Vatican thinking which is just as subversive of his attempt to present consumerist liberal society as &bquo;final&equo;. 
 The head of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, sees in America not the &bquo;final, rational form of society&equo;, but &bquo;a world where money and consumption appear to be the measure of everything&equo;. 
 The liberal bourgeois ethic of the West is a force for alienation, &bquo;bringing men and women into conflict with themselves and subjecting them to new forms of slavery while claiming to free them&equo;. 
 Pope John Paul, in his encyclical Sollicitudo Rei Socialis, has repudiated not only Marxism but the &bquo;so-called civilisation of consumerism&equo; as destructive of true humanity, substituting &bquo;having&equo; for &bquo;being&equo;, and rooted in structural oppression of the poor. 
 This is not to propose Christianity as a counter-ideology. 
 There can be no Christian blueprint for the &bquo;final&equo; form of society, since it is part of its perception of the human condition that all forms of society are provisional, reflecting human sinfulness, though not always to an equal degree. 
 It does, however, have a missionary vision of what it means to be truly human, derived partly from rational reflection on human capacities and desires, but supremely from its conviction that we glimpse true humanity in the life, death and teaching of Jesus. 
 Both Liberation theologians and the policy-makers of the Vatican are agreed that, measured by the pattern of self-giving love revealed in that life, Western consumerism offers a perverted account of humanity. 
 Both affirm the necessity of translating into social terms a Christian critique of existing society, and both emphasise the theological centrality of the notion of God's &bquo;preferential option for the poor&equo; in any such critique. 
 Fukuyama averts his eyes from the poor, and fears no real threat to the permanent triumph of consumer capitalist society except nostalgia and boredom. 
 But even by his standards, Catholic Christianity is one of the &bquo;important social or political forces which are part of world history&equo;. 
 He would be unwise to underestimate the disruptive potential of its particular form of divine discontent. 
 Dr Eamon Duffy is fellow and tutor of Magdalene College, Cambridge, and a lecturer in divinity at the university. 
 English pragmatism and patronising the papacy 
 By ANDREW BROWN 
 POOR Dr Runcie! 
 He has been savaged throughout his visit to Rome by an unusual alliance of fundamentalist Protestants and Tory MPs not usually known for their theological knowledge or zeal. 
 They are offended by his tentative steps towards recognising a role for the Pope even outside the Church of England. 
 And while he has successfully offended the doctrinaire Protestants, he does not seem to have pleased the Pope. 
 So why does he do it? 
 And why does he look so happy as a result? 
 Part of the answer is to be found in the life of Cardinal J H Newman. 
 Newman died in 1890 after a career in which he had been successively the most influential thinker in the Church of England, and then in English Roman Catholicism. 
 The second Vatican Council is said, at least by English Catholics, to have been the culmination of Newman's ideas. 
 The Anglo-Catholic movement in the Church of England certainly sprang from the activities of Newman and his friends. 
 The movement became a tradition which is only now degenerating to a faction, and it is from that tradition Dr Runcie springs. 
 Newman's central idea, both as a Catholic and as an Anglican, was that one holy Catholic and apostolic Church exists. 
 This may seem meaningless to non-churchgoers and trivial to churchgoers since it is part of the Athanasian Creed recited every Sunday. 
 But if you admit the existence of this supernatural body, the question then becomes, where on earth can it be found? 
 Newman came to the answer Rome; the former friends he left behind in the Church of England replied that the early undivided Church had been the only one wholly to contain this supernatural essence. 
 Since the great schism and the Reformation, the single truth had been broken up, but the Anglicans, the Orthodox and the Roman Catholics had and have part of it. 
 No part of the Church has all of it to itself. 
 All are partially in error and not just by the fact of their division. 
 Even from this &mdash; Anglican &mdash; point of view, a papacy makes sense. 
 But is this in a rather different sense to that in which the papacy understands itself? 
 Dr Runcie's vision of a primacy for the Bishop of Rome is that when the whole Church is almost agreed on something, the Pope is the man who can articulate this agreement to all Christians and non-Christians with the greatest authority. 
 Dr Runcie's Pope would be, as it were, the speaker of the universal Church, perhaps with some power to rule members out of order. 
 Some Anglicans would certainly go further: the Bishop of Birmingham, the Right Rev Mark Santer, who is the Anglican co-chairman of the theological commission trying to overcome doctrinal differences between the two Churches, says: If Anglicans and other non-Roman Catholics really do believe that the Christian Church is called to be at peace with itself, how &mdash; given the fact that Christians are sinful &mdash; do you actually keep the show together? 
 &bquo;In the end, you do have to have some sort of juridical power if you are going to keep the institution together.&equo; 
 This a very English and pragmatic argument for the necessity of a central authority in the Church. 
 It has been greatly influenced by the tangled confusion into which the Anglican Communion has stumbled over the ordination of women. 
 It starts from the fact of disunity and asks which existing political mechanism can work best for unity. 
 But looked at from a Roman point of view, the papacy is not one system of Church government among others. 
 Primacy is not a technique for resolving difficult questions: it is the logical and necessary outcome of the way God works in history. 
 The papacy encapsulates the meaning of history. 
 This used to be a perception shared with Protestants. 
 When Ian Paisley calls the Pope &bquo;the Antichrist&equo;, he is not just picking a choice term of abuse from the Bible, but referring back to what was once the mainstream Protestant and Anglican belief that the papacy does play one of the most important parts in sacred history and the Romans are absolutely mistaken about which. 
 To most Anglicans now, though, the main thing about the papacy is not that it is evil &mdash; that seems an absurd accusation &mdash; but that it is frequently silly and wrong. 
 A prime example of this is the genuine difficulty any Pope would have in recognising that Anglican priests are real priests since this would mean that when Pope Leo XIII declared in 1896 that Anglican orders were &bquo;utterly null and void&equo;, he was either silly or wrong or both. 
 There is still an atavistic streak of no popery in the English, but it is non-dogmatic. 
 The liberty of the freeborn Englishman now consists in the right, not to defy the Pope, since that is no longer necessary, but to patronise him. 
 This actually makes the obstacles to any acceptance of papal authority much greater than the dignitaries gathered in Rome this weekend have realised. 
 Leading Article: Investing in the long term 
 By ANDREW BROWN 
 EUROTUNNEL is in trouble. 
 The estimated cost of the Channel tunnel continues to rise at an alarming rate, to the distress of both shareholders and the company's bankers. 
 The initial forecast was &pound;4.7bn. 
 The last published estimate was &pound;5.4bn. 
 Only weeks ago speculation was that a further &pound;1bn might be needed. 
 Now Eurotunnel says that &pound;7bn could be nearer the mark, while the banks and the consortium involved in the construction work believe that far bigger sums will be necessary. 
 The tunnel is due to open in 1993. 
 Who knows what the costs will look like by then? 
 Eurotunnel's bankers are therefore putting increasing pressure on Alastair Morton, British co-chairman of the project, to raise significant new equity. 
 It will not be easy for him to do so. 
 Yet, if he refuses, or if he fails in any attempt, the banks could, in theory, take over the company which is in default of several loan agreements. 
 Mr Morton and his colleagues will have to answer some awkward questions, not least from small investors, many of whom bought into the company attracted by the perks and the sense of excitement as much as by a detailed understanding of the economics of the enterprise. 
 They will want to know how Eurotunnel got its sums so badly awry. 
 There are answers to be had of course. 
 The most powerful is that the figures, inaccurate as they have turned out to be, convinced experts employed by big investors and banks such as National Westminster. 
 Moreover, it is notoriously difficult to predict the costs of major infrastructural projects, almost all of which run wildly over budget. 
 In this case, the construction timetable proved wrong, as did very optimistic forecasts concerning the rates of inflation and interest. 
 Even so, the quality of project management is surely open to examination. 
 It is not as if Eurotunnel was working at the leading-edge of technological innovation. 
 It was indulging in a relatively straightforward exercise in civil engineering which could have been undertaken at any time during the last 100 years or more. 
 The Channel tunnel project is the largest enterprise of its kind to be financed from private sources. 
 The Prime Minister was adamant on this point. 
 Yet, whatever the short- and medium-term vicissitudes, it will almost certainly be completed, if only because any other course would be seen, however unreasonably, as a failure of political and diplomatic will on the part of this country. 
 Once fully operational, the tunnel will generate considerable income. 
 (Cross-Channel traffic may, according to some estimates, double by the early years of the next century.) 
 The question for the Government is whether the British financial markets, with their notoriously short-term horizons, are capable of handling long-term projects of this magnitude. 
 If they are not, Mrs Thatcher will either have to reconsider her faith in the private sector always to do what she deems to be the right thing, or she will have to promote changes in the way in which the markets go about their business. 
 Whatever the ideological preoccupations of the Prime Minister, it is impossible for the Government to take no view and to play no role when the future of an infrastructural project with the potential impact of the Channel tunnel is in question. 
 Beware the treachery of autumn 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 A HEALTH scandal of unimaginable proportions is about to burst on the Government, experts believe. 
 It will make the Black Death look like a mild dose of flu. 
 It will make salmonella and listeria look like peanuts. 
 It will make peanuts look like microdots. 
 Because Britain has been covered, during the last few weeks, with record levels of toxic and other dangerous substances. 
 Here are three typical case histories. 
 1. 
 A young boy in Hartlepool picks some bright red berries from the hedgerow. 
 He takes them home. 
 He offers them to his friends. 
 They all nearly die. 
 His mother says: &bquo;Why, oh why, must they put these poisonous berries in colours so tempting to children? 
 It's little short of criminal.&equo; 
 2. 
 Somewhere in Lincolnshire, an old man's beard entwines itself around and covers a sign reading: &bquo;Danger &mdash; Unmanned Level Crossing Ahead With Freight Trains Full Of Nuclear Waste Passing Frequently.&equo; 
 Failing to see this masked sign, a family out for a drive goes on to the crossing at the very same moment as a rare Leopold's Toad, and runs it over. 
 The father says: &bquo;It was just sheer luck that that was a toad, not a nuclear train.&equo; 
 3. 
 A family go mushroom-hunting in the woods in Yorkshire. 
 They bring home their haul and cook it. 
 They all die, except a 15-year-old who had behaved so badly that he was forbidden to taste what turned out to be deadly toadstools. 
 He says: &bquo;Well, there you go &mdash; crime seems to pay after all.&equo; 
 What all three things have in common is that they were caused by autumn. 
 Autumn has occurred every year since records began. 
 The Government must have known it was coming again, yet has done absolutely nothing to prevent the side-effects. 
 &bquo;They have no excuse,&equo; says Stan Gilligrew, secretary of Action Against Autumn. 
 &bquo;They have known that leaves will fall, and branches be blown across roads and berries go toxic, but what have they done? 
 Absolutely nothing. 
 It's a scandal.&equo; 
 Is Mr Gilligrew saying that the Government is responsible for every leaf that falls, every poisonous berry that turns purple or crimson? 
 &bquo;I certainly am. 
 Somebody must be responsible, otherwise who is there to sue? 
 And if not the Government, then who? 
 My members demand action now!&equo; 
 Mr Gilligrew seems ideally cut out to be leader of a protest group: insecure, loud, unhumorous, indignant, unpleasant, small and much given to counting points off on his fingers. 
 &bquo;We must have a five-point plan for autumn safety: 1) Get all poisonous plants clearly labelled; 2) Put government health warnings on toadstools; 3) Secure all dangerous-looking branches; 4) Spread polythene sheets beneath all major leaf-producing trees; 5) Have a national warning system for cold days on which apples, conkers and so on, are much more likely to fall out of the trees and cause these horrendous injuries.&equo; 
 What horrendous injuries? 
 &bquo;The ones we have described in our booklet.&equo; 
 Like all protest lobbyists, he has a booklet. 
 Autumn &mdash; Action Now! contains horrific pictures of children in agony, car crashes caused by skids on leaves and Fred Astaire. 
 Fred Astaire? 
 &bquo;Yes, sorry, that was a mistake,&equo; says Stan Gilligrew. 
 &bquo;We're a bit new to this game. 
 It's our first season as a protest group and we haven't quite got the publishing side sorted out. 
 But the message is loud and clear. 
 Autumn is dangerous. 
 And it must be stopped.&equo; 
 Is there nothing that the average man wandering down a country lane can do about the effects of autumn? 
 &bquo;Certainly there is. 
 He can buy a large tube of Autumnola, the 2-in-1 action cream which not only reduces the risk of bruising to a minimum, but has anti-toxic qualities proof against the most virulent poisoning from autumnal pests.&equo; 
 Hold on. 
 This sounds suspiciously like advertising. 
 And now we look closer at Stan Gilligrew, he bears more than a passing resemblance to a certain well-known PR consultant. 
 We tear off his false moustache and sun-glasses. 
 Yes, it's our old friend Adrian Wardour-Street. 
 &bquo;A good little campaign, eh?&equo; he laughs. 
 &bquo;We've really got the Government on the run with this one. 
 Apparently Maggie is going wild trying to find out who is responsible for seasonal changes. 
 Anyway, any publicity you can give Autumnola in your paper would be very welcome. 
 Now, a spot of lunch?&equo; 
 Leading Article: History outpaces Honecker 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 IT IS almost possible to feel a twinge of sympathy for Erich Honecker, the ailing but obdurately anti-reformist leader of the German Democratic Republic. 
 Only a few days before his state's 40th anniversary celebrations, he has been obliged to accept a deal permitting several thousand of its citizens to flee to the capitalist Federal Republic. 
 Some 5,000 East Germans had sought refuge in the West German embassies in Prague and Warsaw. 
 Among those applying the heaviest pressure for their free passage to the West were the Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev and his foreign minister Eduard Shevardnadze. 
 The state formerly reviled for cleaving too closely to Moscow's line now finds itself berated by the Kremlin as well as the Western world for not following the path of glasnost and perestroika. 
 In the past few weeks, some 30,000 East Germans have expressed their lack of faith in the GDR's future by abandoning their homes and, often, their relatives for the freedom of the West. 
 This haemorrhage of enterprising and skilled young people promises to cause serious damage to the GDR's economy. 
 If it continues, it will cumulatively demolish the government's principal justification for refusing all political reforms: that the country's economy is healthy, and there is no need for change. 
 For the GDR's ageing leadership, the political pressures are building up inexorably. 
 In the short term, the crowded encampments of GDR citizens in the West German embassies in Prague and Warsaw would have humiliatingly underlined the emptiness of next weekend's 40th anniversary celebrations in East Berlin, which President Gorbachev is due to attend. 
 In the medium term, the pace of political reform in neighbouring Poland and in Hungary is bound further to increase the dissatisfaction of East Germans. 
 If the GDR government cuts off escape routes by banning travel to Czechoslovakia, Hungary and even Bulgaria, the risk of a political explosion will greatly increase. 
 Although the recent exodus has acted as a temporary safety valve, there is evidence that the more politically minded opponents of the present regime have stayed behind, knowing that reforms cannot be indefinitely postponed. 
 But reforms to what end? 
 To implant multi-party democracy in ancient nations like Poland and Hungary makes historical sense. 
 The GDR is a state trying to be a nation. 
 Much determination and hard work have gone into that attempt, but it is now seen to have failed. 
 Without reforms, failure will become more complete. 
 Yet if the GDR were to become a multi-party democracy, it would lose its identifying ideology and become a pallid shadow of the Federal Republic: less grossly consumerist, perhaps, but also less desirable. 
 In Bonn it is hoped that there can be orderly change across the border, soon enough to convince more East Germans that life is worth living there. 
 Perhaps because to think about reform is to think about its purposes, Mr Honecker and his colleagues keep their minds closed to such challenges. 
 Yet the West Germans, too, may be underestimating the pace at which history is moving today in central Europe: too fast, in all probability, for the smooth transitional arrangements which the Kohl government in Bonn likes to think will one day lead to a painless form of reunification. 
 Letter: Anticipating a degree of elitism 
 From Dr ERWIN KRONHEIMER 
 Sir: Has anyone a suggestion about how, once we have made all our graduates pay for their own education through some sort of lifelong surtax, we should set about stopping those with any marketable skills and sense leaving the country as soon as they possibly can? 
 Would it be a good idea, perhaps, to introduce exit visas? 
 Letter: Anticipating a degree of elitism 
 From Ms ALICE GOLDIE 
 Sir: I am studying for A-levels at the moment and have just sent off my application form to study medicine at university. 
 I realise that, if I am accepted, once I have completed my degree I may often have to work for over 80 hours at a stretch during a weekend on call. 
 But I read in an article this morning ('Students set to pay full fees', 29 September) that if I were applying in a few years' time, I would have to ask my parents to pay the full cost of my tuition. 
 I have calculated that my tuition, rent and equipment for the five years of my degree would cost at least &pound;54,500. 
 My parents both have well-paid jobs but without selling their house they could not afford such a sum, and I doubt if many people could. 
 The Government says that many scholarships will be on offer to make up for the charges, but surely this means that only rich people and the very brightest of the less well-off will be able to afford a degree. 
 According to another article ('Hospital closes beds as cash crisis bites', 28 September), Barts hospital in London, one of the best teaching hospitals in England, is having to close 75 beds. 
 The Government seems to be trying to destroy the education and health services in Britain and to set up an alternative system in which wealth rules. 
 I still intend to train as a doctor, because I feel there is no more interesting and worthwhile way to spend my life, but how many other people will be able to or want to in the future? 
 Letter: False police statistics 
 From Mr BARRIE IRVING 
 Sir: Alan Eastwood, chairman of the Police Federation (letter 28 September), puts the manipulation of crime figures in Kent down to misplaced zeal. 
 There is lot of it about these days and not just in the police service. 
 However, such zeal does not fool a wise assessment system which accounts for quality of performance, and does not rely too much on facile numerical criteria. 
 Mr Eastwood and his colleagues are aware of this &mdash; they are therefore concerned about leadership (desirable) and the &bquo;science of management&equo; (overdone). 
 But this opposition misleads; charisma is cold comfort without expert management. 
 Together they are a vital, but a very scarce resource: police centralisation, of which the Federation disapproves, could help optimise the use of available talent. 
 Mr Eastwood argues it would break ties with local communities. 
 But where is the evidence for that? 
 Arguably centralisation would release resources for local purposes. 
 A decade after the Scarman report on Brixton and on the evidence from our more troubled communities, this is no time for any of us to strike traditional postures. 
 Letter: False police statistics 
 From Mr NORMAN GODFREY 
 Sir: If one wants to understand the reasons for growing public concern about the police one need look no further than the letter from the Police Federation (28 September). 
 So there was nothing harmful in Kent police officers conspiring with criminals to boost clear-up statistics. 
 Are we to believe that false confessions were made purely out love of the police? 
 At the very minimum they must have been made on the basis of a police guarantee that matters would be manipulated so that courts would not impose additional punishment for the illusory offences. 
 And why should any criminal have co-operated in this process of falsification unless an inducement had been on offer? 
 Comparable conduct by non-police officers would surely have led, in less than four years, either to criminal charges or to punishment for contempt of court. 
 Letter: Excessive damages for libel 
 From Mr GEORGE STERN 
 Sir: France deals with libel in a simple, cheap and civilised way, illustrated by a case in July where a paper investigated corruption among local authorities. 
 This was advertised in Tours by the line: &bquo;Is your mayor corrupt?&equo; 
 The mayor alleged libel. 
 Libel in France is a crime, but, as with all crimes, there is a partie civile &mdash; the person damaged who is compensated. 
 The case was heard as a minor offence before a low-level court, the tribunal correctionel in Tours, at which three judges ruled that, although the article exculpated the mayor, the advertisement did smear him, and the newspaper was ordered to pay him Fr10,000 (&pound;1,000 approx). 
 In Britain, massive libel awards have abolished free speech where criticism of, or reporting about, rich people is concerned, because a rich man can bankrupt anyone by suing for libel, win or lose. 
 In France, honour is satisfied by a low-level court case taking half an hour. 
 Our lawyers and judges will never turn off this mad process which, for them, is a fountain of dollars and a source of power: it is up to the Press to publicise civilised European libel procedures and insist that we get them too. 
 Letter: Excessive damages for libel 
 From Dr PAUL ROBERTSHAW 
 Sir: Marcel Berlins's instructive and provocative article (29 September) on juries and libel damages prompts supplementary comment on two points. 
 He writes that the trial judge is not allowed to give the jury any guidance as to the amount that it can award. 
 That is somewhat misleading. 
 What is remarkable &mdash; and, I think, indefensible -about English libel trials is that the judge gives directions and guidance on the measure of damages as part and parcel of a single summing-up on the substantive issue. 
 For example, the last four pages of Sir Bernard Caulfield's summing-up to the jury in the Archer case is concerned with damages, and heavily stresses the aggravating factors. 
 It is true that no figures are mentioned in such summings-up, but they can certainly point towards the minimal or astronomical. 
 What is legally disturbing is that this aspect appears in a summing-up at all, since it encourages an assumption that a libel has been perpetrated. 
 It is as if prosecutors could suggest the sentence while presenting evidence for a conviction. 
 Marcel Berlins also, rightly, mentions the confusion between recompensing an aggrieved plaintiff and punishing the gutter press with its huge financial resources. 
 It is worth pointing out &mdash; as did Dr Akena Adoko in his book on the Jeffrey Archer trial &mdash; that there may have been an additional development in the folkways of the juryroom: the frequent practice of the rich (the typical plaintiffs) to pass on their damages to charity, as did Mr Archer, might act as an additional, and self-legitimating, incentive to take awards through the ceiling. 
 Maybe excessive and erratic awards are the fault of the jury. 
 Maybe not. 
 If it were not for Section 8 of the Contempt of Court Act, we might be able to make reforms more rationally on the basis of, at least, a minimal sample of the recorded deliberations of informed and unidentified jurors. 
 Letter: Labour's attitude to homosexual law reform 
 From Mr JOHN JACKSON 
 Sir: Earlier this year, the Labour Party's National Executive Committee voted to replace a policy commitment to homosexual equality with a reference to &bquo;greater equality&equo;. 
 This took place amid rumours of a split within the NEC over support for a common age of consent, and was widely seen as a response to tabloid hysteria on such matters. 
 This organisation has since been in correspondence with Neil Kinnock's Westminster office, but has yet to receive any clear indication of whether Labour would indeed reduce the age of consent for gay men from 21 to 16. 
 The Campaign for Homosexual Equality's policy, in favour of such reform, reflects our concern about the inaccessibility to those under 21 of specifically gay safer sex information. 
 The present law makes it more difficult for counselling organisations to reach gay men in this age group. 
 Equally alarming, we feel, is the fact that 35 young men aged between 16 and 21 were convicted for a consensual homosexual relationship during 1987; one was sentenced to a year in youth custody. 
 These are the very same young people whom advocates of the present law would argue receive its &bquo;protection&equo;. 
 We naturally welcome Labour's existing promise to repeal Section 28 and to legislate against discrimination in the workplace. 
 And few would disagree that, given the fanaticism and sheer ferocity of tabloid prejudice, it would be unreasonable for gay people to expect that Labour should adopt our cause as an election issue. 
 However, the watering down of a basic and principled commitment, within Labour or any other libertarian party, especially in response to intimidation by newspapers of such a spurious morality, could prove deeply discrediting. 
 It is with regard to this principle, but more importantly to the actual facts of persecution, that we urge the support of Labour's leaders and membership by restoring, this week, a policy commitment to full equality for lesbians and gay men. 
 Letter: Israeli motives 
 From Mr GEOFFREY D. PAUL 
 Sir: The world must be grateful to Charles Richards for his exposure ('Intifada brings out the best in Israel's black art', 30 September) of the depths to which Israelis will sink in what he rightly describes as their news manipulation. 
 Can there be anything more telling about the deviousness of these people than his account of how they actually put on television and interviewed a man who was said to have died while in a prison cell, and that, moreover, they did it with the sole motive of demonstrating that he was alive and in good health. 
 They did it &bquo;hastily&equo; too, which is also an indication of their amazing, but altogether typical, ruthlessness. 
 Cannot the British Government instigate action at the United Nations to prevent the Israeli authorities from using television to tell the truth in these matters? 
 In the unlikely event of this kind of thing being allowed to spread to other countries, it will, mark my words, mean the end of all baseless rumours and a subsequent serious dearth of causes for riot. 
 Letter: Uppark should be fully restored 
 From Professor ANDOR GOMME 
 Sir: Uppark is the third great house which the National Trust has lost through fire since the last war. 
 Both Coleshill (burnt in 1953) and Dunsland (1967) were subsequently entirely destroyed &mdash; decisions which have been deeply deplored ever since. 
 Uppark is a house of comparable importance and value, and its full restoration is essential. 
 Anna Pavord's proposal (27 September) that the interior should be rebuilt as &bquo;a series of simple, clean well-designed rooms&equo; for the display of the contents saved from the fire ignores the fact that the furniture and paintings at Uppark were either designed or collected by the Fetherstonhaugh family over numerous generations especially for the rooms in which they lived. 
 Shorn of these surroundings the furnishings would be just another museum collection. 
 Ms Pavord supports her &bquo;purist&equo; proposal by arguing that the National Trust already owns two &bquo;real&equo; houses &mdash; Dyrham and Hanbury &mdash; designed by Talman, &bquo;the first architect of Uppark&equo; and two &mdash; Felbrigg and Nostell &mdash; by Paine, &bquo;thought to have made the saloon at Uppark&equo;. 
 Recent scholarship has rejected the view (based only on nineteenth-century say-so) that Talman designed Uppark, and there is no evidence of his having had anything to do with Hanbury (stylistically most unlikely). 
 And though Paine designed a London house for Sir Matthew Fetherstonhaugh, there is nothing else to connect him with Uppark, which he mentions nowhere in his thoroughly documented account of his own works. 
 But the important thing is that there is nothing at Felbrigg or Nostell &mdash; or elsewhere in National Trust houses &mdash; which closely resembles the saloon (or the drawing room) at Uppark: these rooms were unique and we need them back. 
 Had Germany taken the &bquo;purist&equo; line after the war, we should be without the wonders of Bruchsal and the Residenz at Wurzburg, and the great churches of Nurnberg would look like the clean, well-designed &mdash; but totally anaemic - interiors of those in Kassel and Stuttgart. 
 Where, as appears to be the case at Uppark, it is physically possible to make an accurate restoration of a great building, it should be made &mdash; and not jeered at as the creation of a theme park of misnamed pastiche. 
 Letter: A very Catholic affair 
 From Mr ALASTAIR FORBES 
 Sir: In your interesting article (30 September) about the sale to the British Library by Lord Norwich (for a sum left tantalisingly undisclosed) of Evelyn Waugh's letters to his late mother, Lady Diana Cooper, the library's curator of modern literary manuscripts, a Ms Brown, was quoted as follows: I am sure that they did not have a physical affair. 
 He was a very strict Catholic. 
 This egregious non sequitur requires further clarification, if only for your myriad younger readers. 
 Much more cogent reasons for Ms Brown's correct conviction are to be found in Lady Diana's own words, which I quote from Philip Ziegler's biography and which amply confirms others, just as forceful, that she used to me in the course of our more than 40 years of close friendship: I never responded to his dribbling, dwarfish little amorous singeries. 
 Letter: Facts on embryos 
 From Dame MARY DONALDSON, GBE 
 Sir: Your report (2 October) on the Pro-Life conference in Keele must fill many of your readers with dismay. 
 Deliberately to introduce an amendment dealing with abortion law reform into a Bill dealing with embryos is a blatant attempt to cause confusion. 
 There is no logic in the Pro-Life argument. 
 To ban research on a fertilised egg unless it is to be reimplanted, and in the same Bill wish to permit abortion up to 18 weeks demonstrates the movement's illogicality. 
 We welcome legislation founded on proven facts. 
 We are in our fifth year as the now Interim Licensing Authority for Invitro-Fertilisation and Human Embryology. 
 We are accepted as such by all centres undertaking this work. 
 We have neither the resources nor the finance to launch a campaign to promote any particular aspect. 
 Nor do we feel that this is necessary. 
 We feel that our function is to convey accurate information. 
 With this in mind, each year we publish details of all our licensing. 
 This year we are producing further information on all research projects licensed since our inception. 
 We will also be showing why continued research should be permitted, and how disastrous it would be for all women if the policy advocated by the Pro-Life lobby were to be adopted. 
 I think it will be found that our record and findings are more worthy of public acceptance than the emotional, uninformed and often inaccurate outbursts of this very vocal lobby. 
 PCBs explained 
 From Dame MARY DONALDSON, GBE 
 PCBs &mdash; polychlorinated biphenyls &mdash; are very inert organic substances, which were prized because they were flexible (being liquids) but had very high insulating properties for electricity. 
 They were also used in hydraulic systems because they did not react with the materials used in the pipes and pistons. 
 They do not occur naturally, but were produced commercially for 50 years, beginning in 1929. 
 They are extremely hard to dispose of. 
 Incineration, which claims a 99.999 per cent destruction rate, is the only known way of eliminating them. 
 But PCBs are a disappearing problem. 
 In the late Seventies many countries, including the UK (in 1978), banned their manufacture. 
 Remaining stocks (in electrical equipment, mostly) are being burned, but traces will remain for many years. 
 PCBs are now ubiquitous at very low levels in the environment, in both town and country. 
 They are found at about 0.05 parts per million in Northern Europe. 
 The concentrations are very variable, but though there is evidence of their being at higher levels near cities and urban areas, there is no necessary connection with waste-disposal sites. 
 At least one study has suggested that high PCB levels in mothers' milk is linked with a higher-than-normal incidence of haemolytic disease, a blood disorder. 
 PCBs can create dioxins &mdash; polychlorinated organic chemicals &mdash; if they are burned at low temperatures. 
 Animal studies have shown dioxins to be carcinogenic and to cause birth defects in rats at very high doses. 
 There was, therefore, great concern that PCBs should not be subject to inadequate heat treatment. 
 There is no evidence that dioxins &mdash; any more than PCBs themselves &mdash; are carcinogenic in humans. 
 But medical opinion seems to hold that both should be treated as though they were. 
 In any case, the controlled combustion of PCBs must be a diminishing source of the national load of dioxin pollution. 
 Government research says that the presence of dioxins in flue gases from plants such as that at Pontypool &bquo;are in the low range of parts per trillion&equo; (one part per trillion is of the order of 30 seconds in a million years, or one ounce in 28 million tons), and that all the UK PCB-destroying plants together emit only a &bquo;few grammes per year&equo;. 
 Ageing municipal domestic waste incinerators are a far greater source of dioxins (and are slowly being upgraded); domestic fires and unleaded petrol are the next biggest sources. 
 PCBs: The incinerators 
 From Dame MARY DONALDSON, GBE 
 THE incineration of PCBs requires a furnace which will hold the material at 1,100C for at least two seconds, in the presence of plenty of oxygen. 
 Companies wishing to enter the waste disposal business at this level must demonstrate to the local Waste Disposal Authority (usually a county council, but in some cities and in Wales a more local authority) that they can meet various criteria, although the authority may be over-ruled on appeal to the Secretary of State for the Environment. 
 Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution is now the custodian of national standards on emissions from such plants, of which Britain currently has three. 
 Rechem can take solid and liquid wastes contaminated with PCBs at its plant at Pontypool (30,000 tonnes a year), and liquid wastes (20,000 tonnes a year) at its plant at Fawley, near Southampton. 
 Cleanaway can take liquid PCBs at its Ellesmere Port establishment, where it is building another plant which will take capacity there to 48,000 tonnes annually. 
 Ocean Environmental Management has applied for a 30,000-tonne plant at Seal Sands, Teesside, and is appealing against the local authority's refusal to allow it. 
 Leigh Environmental wants to build an incinerator plant near Doncaster, but also faces local authority opposition, and International Technology Corporation has submitted a joint application with Northumbrian Water for incinerators at Teesside and Tyneside for the incineration of sewage sludge and organic wastes, with a capacity of 43,000 tonnes each. 
 The figures quoted are for a mix of wastes requiring incineration. 
 Only a fraction is PCB-contaminated material: the bulk of the load must be wastes with a higher calorific value for the incinerator to work. 
 About 80,000 tonnes of waste for incineration or treatment is imported every year, as against the five million tonnes which England and Wales produce. 
 All these incinerators offer what is called &bquo;merchant capacity&equo; &mdash; they sell their facilities to dispose of other people's waste, but do not produce the waste themselves. 
 There are no in-house incinerators licensed to take PCBs, though many firms run incinerators which can take simpler chemical wastes. 
 There are a few merchant facilities licensed to take dangerous organic wastes, which are nonetheless not the worst-case highly chlorinated wastes (one of these is the Leigh plant at Killamarsh near Sheffield). 
 PCBs: What Rechem says about Pontypool 
 From Dame MARY DONALDSON, GBE 
 HIGH-temperature incineration converts the carbon and hydrogen in organic chemicals into carbon dioxide and water. 
 Many of these chemicals also contain chlorine, which is converted to common salt in the gas-cleaning plant. 
 Stack emissions, which are continuously monitored, meet the strictest standards in the world. 
 PCBs are used as a &bquo;marker&equo; to measure the incinerator efficiency, because they are very stable organic compounds. 
 Measurements taken over many years show that levels of PCBs in grass and soil in the area impacted by the stack plume are indistinguishable from background levels. 
 The stack emission comfortably meets the American standard for breathing air. 
 The stack plume is normally barely visible but appears more prominent at night, when lower ambient temperatures lead to increased condensation of the water vapour. 
 The water used by the gas-cleaning plant is cooled by a cooling tower which itself emits two water-vapour plumes, the density of which varies according to climatic conditions. 
 The quality of these plumes is well within the American PCB standard for breathing air. 
 The inert ash removed from the incinerator and the filter cake produced from the solids washed from the combustion gases are landfilled with a PCB content less than normal background soil levels. 
 The water effluent from the cleaning process is discharged to sewer with a PCB content less than the level in the blood of the general population. 
 Finally, the air leaving site is continuously monitored to show that there are no significant chemical releases. 
 The PCB content is less than one-fiftieth of the American breathing air standard. 
 Unfortunately, because of mankind's carelessness with PCBs in the past, they are already ubiquitous. 
 By destroying these wastes Rechem is significantly helping to prevent further pollution of the local and world environment. 
 An atmosphere poisoned by mistrust 
 By NICHOLAS ROE 
 The disposal of toxic wastes is one of the most intractable problems facing industrialised societies. 
 Even though some of the most dangerous and persistent toxins, including polychlorinated biphenyls, PCBs, are no longer manufactured, quantities of them still exist, and must be got rid of. 
 But how? 
 And where? 
 On this page, Nick Roe visits a plant which, despite strenuous public relations efforts, has failed to convince its neighbours that it has come clean. 
 And Richard North looks at current provisions for the destruction of PCBs, and at the history of British involvement in a rather uncomfortable growth industry The security guard at the entrance to one of Britain's mightiest hazardous waste disposal plants pressed a button and the gate opened. 
 Then he pressed another knob and a big toy doll in his office window dropped its trousers. 
 You had to laugh. 
 Yet this was Rechem International's high-temperature incineration plant at Pontypool in Gwent, South Wales. 
 Hardly a laughing matter, surely? 
 Beyond the barrier lay some of the most toxic chemicals known, awaiting destruction by fire. 
 What else? 
 A vast, smoke-blackened furnace; 100 people to do the work; massive investment &mdash; the company spent &pound;2m last year on cleaning up smoke emissions. 
 Plus a backdrop of houses covering the valley walls on either side, a reminder that wherever industrialised societies decide to deal with their most intractable problems, they are unlikely to find a place to do so which is not in somebody's back yard. 
 Britain grinds out almost five million tonnes of hazardous waste each year, of which about 63,000 tonnes are so difficult to store or treat that they are burnt at high temperatures here in Gwent or at one of three other centres: Ellesmere Port; Fawley, near Southampton; and the unfortunately named Killamarsh, near Sheffield. 
 Five more incinerators currently proposed in various parts of the country will double capacity. 
 Then there are the imports: 83,000 tonnes of toxic waste enter British ports annually for incineration or other treatment, a figure which has increased 20-fold in just eight years. 
 In these environmentally conscious times, this is an uncomfortable growth industry. 
 Liverpool dockers recently turned back parts of a 1,500-tonne consignment of Canadian PCBs (polychlorinated biphenyls) bound for this plant in Gwent. 
 In doing so, they underlined a fact which is likely to attract more and more attention as tankers continue to shift toxins from town to town, country to country: the waste chain is long. 
 It snakes in and out of ports, along our busiest highways and through our most crowded cities. 
 Anxieties which are currently felt most acutely by those living near destruction plants themselves may not always remain so localised. 
 At Pontypool, the collision between a precise, scientific industry and a diffuse, unscientific local suspicion is painfully apparent. 
 Local people mutter and march, make speeches and throw things; staff face sarcasm in nearby pubs; and for years there have been demands for a public inquiry. 
 Rechem has responded with a rather desperate open-door policy aimed at soothing fears, and more recently by issuing about a dozen writs against the fiercest critics. 
 &bquo;We are an aggressive company,&equo; admitted David Wheeler, operations director at this plant and at Rechem's other incinerator, at Fawley. 
 For a place so hated, the Pontypool plant looks innocuous inside, like a cross between an oil refinery and a crematorium. 
 Mr Wheeler, an engineer who worked for many years in the oil business, is a pleasant, slightly worried-looking man who cannot bear the fact that no one seems to realise just what lengths he goes to in order to keep the plant squeaky clean and emission-free. 
 In hard hats and protective glasses, we walked past the huge &bquo;fume cupboard&equo; where the most noxious barrels are opened, and arrived at the vast, closed mouth of the furnace itself. 
 It was hot, but not burning. 
 There was a fault on the computer governing the plant, said Mr Wheeler, and the fire had automatically shut down. 
 These pipes stretching thinly in a bridge across the service road injected a mix of chemicals into the walls of the furnace itself; did I know that fuel was only used in the start-up process, after which the chemicals themselves provided the fire? 
 Workers in blue overalls drifted around us and cracked jokes in gentle Welsh accents. 
 In the furnace control office I found shift foreman Keith Thomas and asked innocently if he had any physical problems: &bquo;Not since my vasectomy.&equo; 
 A grin. 
 He lived locally, so how did neighbours view his job here? 
 &bquo;You get sarcasm mainly. 
 A lot of my friends are pleased that the company is doing the job they are doing. 
 Others are not so well informed. 
 You couldn't hope to convert them.&equo; 
 At a nearby house, Leonard Hough, a retired schoolmaster, had earlier told me about &bquo;the fog&equo; which he says comes from the factory. 
 &bquo;It blows along the valley. 
 They've improved the chimney recently and it's very much better than it was but we still get the smells. 
 And since they've refused repeatedly to have a public inquiry into what is going on there we're not certain of the safety of what's coming out. 
 We get smoke from the steel works across the valley, but we know what that is and we're not afraid of it.&equo; 
 Keith Thomas pressed a button and a huge door clanked upwards so that I could peer into the heart of the furnace. 
 Piles of ruddy-brown ash lay heaped on the floor. 
 Pumps sucked air inwards. 
 Heat shone out. 
 In here, they burn about 30,000 tonnes of chemicals a year, a quarter originating outside Britain. 
 The waste arrives at the rate of up to seven tanker-loads every day &mdash; that is seven lorries passing thousands of doorsteps. 
 Right here, in this gaping mouth, lies the end of the chain. 
 The wastes include lindane, DDT, out-of-date drugs, carcinogenic chemicals, old cigars and even pornography (a different kind of pollution). 
 About 7,000 tonnes of the total waste is PCB-contaminated. 
 PCBs are so difficult to destroy, that Rechem's emission-monitoring systems are geared to detecting them on the grounds that if you destroy PCBs you destroy everything. 
 This, of course, is a key point. 
 If you did not burn chemicals like PCBs, what else would you do with them? 
 The sea? 
 The earth? 
 &bquo;We are not in the business of polluting the environment,&equo; Mr Wheeler insisted. 
 &bquo;We are on the side of the angels.&equo; 
 Environmental organisations, however, put the emphasis elsewhere. 
 &bquo;There is no incinerator which completely destroys toxic wastes,&equo; Madeleine Cobbing, Greenpeace's toxics campaigner, told me. 
 &bquo;The crux of our argument is that we don't need to have toxic wastes and the fact that plants like Rechem exist, providing easy options for companies, is acting as a disincentive for companies to clean up.&equo; 
 But &mdash; another but &mdash; what about the PCBs that already exist? 
 Although they are no longer manufactured, they are still present, for example in electrical equipment. 
 No one could therefore call for the closure of incineration plants at a stroke, because noxious chemicals have to go somewhere. 
 So a part of the argument switches to the kind of incinerators you allow while industry is forced to clean itself up. 
 Also, how these should function and &mdash; perhaps most important of all &mdash; where you put them. 
 Mr Wheeler, now moving to the rear of the plant to show off the &pound;2m smoke-cleaning section, which had just broken down, pointed out that his company achieved destruction of at least 99.9999 per cent of all materials. 
 The company's figures imply that when you have burnt 99.9999 per cent of a 30,000-tonne annual throughput, a figure of 0.03 of a tonne remains. 
 In 1986, according to Friends of the Earth, a survey of the homes clustered on the surrounding hills found that three-quarters of 800 residents were opposed to the Rechem plant. 
 &bquo;The plant should be relocated because it's in the wrong place,&equo; Llew Smith, the local Euro-MP, told me. 
 &bquo;It is in a valley and in a highly populated area.&equo; 
 What did Mr Wheeler make of that? 
 &bquo;If we do it properly any spot is the right spot,&equo; he insisted. 
 Stack emissions of PCBs were below the American standard for breathing air - 1,000 times lower than the British equivalent. 
 Regular soil and grass tests showed no difference between PCB contamination in the immediate area and elsewhere in Wales &mdash; though there are no established &bquo;safe&equo; levels for these. 
 Five air-monitoring plants had been installed (he took me to see them). 
 And here were drums of chemicals, each labelled, each with a job number to check against sampling. 
 And yet there are accidents. 
 In 1987, aluminium melted in the furnace, reacted with water and exploded, sending a black cloud over nearby houses. 
 Later, drums supposedly containing carcinogenic drugs were not opened for checking before burning (for health reasons) and three were &bquo;misdescribed&equo;. 
 They, too, reacted with water, and a plant operator was burned by a cloud of acid gas. 
 We walked past a tanker where a huge man named Andy Matthews was pumping vinyl acetate into a 10,000-gallon vat, wreathed in its sweet, sickly smell: &bquo;I've been here two years,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;My father was an industrial chemist and he said if you want to go and work for them, go and work for them.&equo; 
 Were there any spillages? 
 He shrugged. 
 &bquo;Nothing major. 
 I might drop a pipe &mdash; a little bit of a splash.&equo; 
 In a large, prefabricated shed we wandered past stacks of 45-gallon drums of PCBs, two drums high, about 10 deep; and there were contaminated transformers waiting to be cut up and roasted in the flames. 
 Back along the waste chain, the Liverpool dockers who objected to the import of exactly this type of chemical should be aware that PCBs are moving about our roads all the time. 
 There was no difference between the liquid in these drums and the liquid in the cargoes they refused to touch. 
 In Liverpool, a dockers' spokesman with the Transport and General Workers Union admitted: &bquo;Drivers aren't happy handling some of these commodities, but at least a lorry-driver has more idea of what he is handling than a docker, who could have a consignment and just not know what it is.&equo; 
 Yet he did not oppose all toxic waste movement (after all, the same union represents workers at Rechem itself); he simply didn't like the idea that big industrial nations like Canada could dump their dirty problems on this country and his members. 
 Driving away, I noticed that the vast chimney was still not functioning, but when I called at a neighbouring house a woman showed me videos she had taken of smoke coming from the plant, settling in her garden. 
 Certainly the incinerator seems well controlled. 
 Certainly there is no scientific evidence that living nearby increases the risk of sickness. 
 Certainly, Mr Wheeler convinced me that his company was going to huge lengths to keep itself clean. 
 &bquo;We must run it safely in the short term and long term,&equo; he said, &bquo;because if people are able to demonstrate that we are causing an environment problem we will be shut down.&equo; 
 In April 1985 a tanker spilled 200 litres of PCBs over the main Trans-Canada Highway on the border between Ontario and Manitoba. 
 A section of the road was shut for a week and motorists were warned to clean their cars and to dispose of the rags in plastic bags. 
 PCBs: The relative risk of grilling a kipper 
 By RICHARD NORTH 
 THE most curious thing about the transport and incineration of PCB wastes is that they are, amongst professionals, the least controversial of all the problems they deal with. 
 Indeed, they see incineration as a solution to toxic waste whose usefulness should be employed on a greater range of materials. 
 The House of Commons Environment Committee (which could be presumed to care about being popular), the House of Lords Science and Technology Committee (which has more expertise and rather less concern with popularity) and the Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution (which has most expertise of all and absolutely no interest in popularity) have all been robustly and consistently critical of most parts of the waste-disposal chain. 
 They all endorse the technology of incineration used to destroy PCBs. 
 The only variation is between those who say the provenance of the wastes is irrelevant, and those who argue that imports of PCBs and other hazardous material should be discourged, because only a tough import policy will ensure that other countries build their own plants. 
 David Mills, the erstwhile head of the Hazardous Chemical wing of Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution (HMIP) &mdash; and well known for his criticisms of the lack of effective policing of what he defends as largely sound rules &mdash; says that placing high-temperature incinerators in some sort of hierarchy of risks is &bquo;a terribly subjective business.&equo; 
 But Mr Mills, who is now a director of Aspinwalls, an environment consultancy firm, goes on: &bquo;Because of what I know, I would be perfectly content to live next to any of the plants we have. 
 They are managed well, they have appropriate technology and conduct an environmentally safe process. 
 If you compare the transport of PCBs with that of a 5,000-gallon tanker of petrol, or liquid petroleum gas &mdash; or any of the hazardous chemicals which are routinely trundling about our roads &mdash; PCBs are of a very low order of toxicity or risk. 
 &bquo;PCBs were designed to be inert. 
 They are not going to explode or burn. 
 They are not a risk if you happen to come across them inadvertently. 
 Compare them with a tanker full of chemicals which are corrosive, taint water at minute levels and kill living organisms at low doses: PCBs aren't like that. 
 &bquo;What you have to do if there is an accident &mdash; and there hasn't been one, thank heavens &mdash; is keep the spilled PCBs out of watercourses, because they would accumulate in the fat of organisms which came into contact with them. 
 But that's not an acute risk; it's a long-term risk. 
 &bquo;Many other chemicals are far more highly reactive, probably more toxic, certainly more flammable. 
 &bquo;Look: I can't say this strictly, as a scientist, but it is my feeling that a bonfire, grilling a kipper or lighting a cigarette all release greater concentrations of dioxins than you'd be likely to find at the end of the pipe of a properly run high-temperature incinerator.&equo; 
 David Mills says that there was increasing pressure in the early Seventies to see a higher percentage of waste materials incinerated. 
 &bquo;There was general anticipation of regulations which would insist that more difficult wastes were burned instead of being sent to landfill.&equo; 
 Soon there were 12 high-temperature merchant incinerators, of which four employed the highest technology. 
 To the regret of professionals such as David Mills, the regulations never materialised and the market for merchant incinerators fell away. 
 Most, except the PCB burners, have since closed. 
 This chain of events suggests that Britain got into medium- and high-level waste technology early, but then abandoned the middle tier. 
 It also means that we now landfill wastes that should be incinerated. 
 But one cannot have it both ways: for UK wastes (the import of wastes for landfill is now outlawed) the options are landfill or incineration, and people local to either hate the one near them. 
 There is another option: export. 
 The UK exports no wastes, but accepts them from countries which either have or should have the capacity to destroy their own &bquo;chemical arisings&equo;, as scientists call waste products. 
 The Netherlands, for example, accounts for 43.26 per cent of wastes imported to the UK for incineration or treatment. 
 There is PCB-burning capacity in Sweden, Finland, Germany and France, of which only the last is, like Britain, prepared to import such waste. 
 Citizen protest is making the whole industry very cagey; governments are reluctant to allow planning permission or import licences. 
 On imports, Britain has been uniquely robust in the face of protest. 
 Less determined countries export their waste and thus acquire an undeserved reputation for being green. 
 It is a matter of judgement whether Canada, Australia and Japan should be able to dispose of their own PCBs. 
 At present, none of them can. 
 Margaret Thatcher will next month tell an international conference that the trade in wastes for incineration should be allowed where it is the best environmental option for existing wastes. 
 In other words: keep a legal route open, sooner than see dumping. 
 But, says a refinement of this view &mdash; and Mrs Thatcher and Chris Patten, her Secretary of State for the Environment believe this too &mdash; wastes should be disposed of in their country of origin: that is a new drift in British policy. 
 It is a proposal which would still leave small countries, and especially poor countries, with a requirement to export wastes. 
 It would also leave the neighbours of the incinerator plants exposed at least to UK wastes, and probably to some imports. 
 These people have fears which the media has shamelesslessly played on over the years, but which are genuine. 
 Rechem, which runs two of Britain's three plants equipped to incinerate PCB- contaminated wastes, says that local politicians take various approaches. 
 The firm claims a good relationship with its Fawley neighbours, and has always said it regrets the difficulties with Torfaen council (the local authority for Pontypool). 
 It hints that it is politicians, not disposal plants, which make the two places differ. 
 There is a clear value in reducing the amount of chemical waste which has to be got rid of &mdash; and that thinking has a long way to go. 
 What is not at all clear is whether one highly visible target &mdash; incineration &mdash; is anything like a major ingredient in the pollution cocktail, even at Pontypool. 
 Hong Kong Special Report: Portugal takes a stand and Macao celebrates a passport to security: Unlike Britain, Portugal offers a guaranteed home to many of the citizens of its enclave in the Pearl River delta when China takes over in 1999. 
 Many skilled people are nevertheless still expected to flee, Kevin Hamlin reports 
 By KEVIN HAMLIN 
 WHILE the people of Hong Kong, stripped of any useful British nationality by successive immigration laws, fear for their future after the massacre at Peking in June, many Macao citizens, just 40 miles away across the Pearl River delta, rest secure in the knowledge that Portugal will offer them a guaranteed home of last resort after it returns their territory to China in 1999. 
 Portugal announced earlier this year that it would give up to 130,000 passports to people born in Macao before 1981. 
 Ironically, the European Community's proposed &bquo;Europe Without Frontiers&equo; stands to give these recipients the right to live in Britain which is denied to 3.25 million &bquo;British&equo; passport-holders in Hong Kong. 
 Though Macao's small population made it easier for Portugal to make a grand gesture, it triggered renewed bitterness in Hong Kong. 
 &bquo;There are no Portuguese first-class or second-class citizens,&equo; said Manuel de Silva, Macao's Secretary for Administration and Justice, alluding to Britain's progressive downgrading of Hong Kong people's nationality status. 
 &bquo;People born here before 1981 are as Portuguese as myself and they hold Portuguese passports in completely equal conditions.&equo; 
 Though 130,000 passports represent only about a quarter of Macao's population, most recipients are the professionals and businessmen who make up the backbone of the enclave economy. 
 It is people of this class who are now fleeing Hong Kong in droves. 
 When the enclave returns to Chinese rule, it will do so on similar terms to those promised for Hong Kong, with Peking guaranteeing that a capitalist system and lifestyle will be maintained for at least 50 years. 
 But despite those promises, and despite Portugal's generosity, a recent public opinion survey showed that about 50 per cent of Macao residents had no confidence in the future under Chinese rule.&equo; 
 The Tiananmen Square incident had a very negative effect on professionals and the upper-class,&equo; said Alexandre Ho, a member of the Legislative Assembly and nominal leader of Macao's liberals. 
 &bquo;Their confidence has been shattered. 
 Many of my friends are preparing to leave.&equo; 
 Macao's government does not deny the existence of a confidence crisis, but places responsibility for it squarely on Peking. 
 &bquo;Portugal has completely fulfilled its obligations as far as the Deed of Declaration is concerned,&equo; Mr De Silva said. 
 &bquo;We hope very strongly that the attitude of China's authorities will be adequate to change the significant percentage of people who seem to say they have little confidence.&equo; 
 He added that he could not see &bquo;what the Portuguese administration can further do to enlarge the Macanese people's confidence&equo;. 
 Despite reports of strong objections from Peking, Mr De Silva said the government would proceed with plans to increase the number of seats in the Legislative Assembly. 
 Macao already has a significantly more representative government than Hong Kong. 
 The Assembly, of 17 seats, has five appointed members, six directly-elected and six indirectly-elected members. 
 Hong Kong's Legislative Council as yet has no directly-elected seats. 
 The proposals to increase the number of seats to 23, likely to be made later this year, will not change the balance of power in the Council: two seats each will be added to appointed, directly- and indirectly-elected categories. 
 Nevertheless, local newspaper reports say Peking is concerned that this could further fuel calls for greater democracy in Hong Kong, where the British government now seems more committed to increasing the pace of political reform. 
 Despite the democratic element in government, however, the liberal-leaning elected members of the Assembly have little power, because the conservatives dominate the body through appointed indirectly-elected seats. 
 &bquo;We so-called liberals are very weak in terms of funding and organisation,&equo; said Mr Ho. 
 &bquo;It is very difficult to achieve anything against the strength of the conservatives.&equo; 
 A big problem for the liberals is that recent immigrants from China, who make almost half of the population, have so far not been greatly moved by ideals of democracy. 
 &bquo;They are too busy fighting for a stable life,&equo; said Mr Ho. 
 Despite this, liberals won a virtual landslide at elections last October. 
 They took 45 per cent of the vote, and took three seats, against one previously. 
 Macao's economy has weathered the turmoil in China with few signs of damage. 
 Tourist arrivals have actually increased as a result of Hong Kong people choosing to visit the enclave instead of China. 
 There have been murmurs of discontent among manufacturers considering diversifying away from Macao, but businessmen say that the only impact so far has been a shift of orders from China to Macao. 
 The government is now moving ahead with several new infrastructure projects, which it cites as evidence of its own &mdash; and China's &mdash; commitment to the enclave. 
 By 1993, a HK&dollar;4bn airport that is to be built on reclaimed land off the island of Taipa is due to be opened. 
 A new HK&dollar;350m seaport is also planned and there will be a second bridge linking Taipa with the Macao mainland. 
 This will eventually be extended to Zhuhai, the special economic zone just across the Chinese border. 
 China is taking a 33 per cent shareholding in the airport, which will have a capacity for 6.5 million passengers annually. 
 In a related development, the government has recently decided to approve the setting up of a &bquo;national airline&equo; and is currently thinking about who should own it. 
 The result will probably be a deal to allot equity stakes to the Chinese and Macao governments, alongside some private investors. 
 Though these developments are seen as part of moves to reduce Macao's dependence on gambling (which contributes 25 per cent of government revenue) and Hong Kong (which provides most of its gamblers), they leave some residents uneasy about China's growing involvement in the local economy. 
 Portugal's rapport with Peking is certainly far more cordial than Britain and China's sometimes frosty relations. 
 Following Portugal's revolution in 1974, Lisbon tried to hand back Macao to China. 
 Peking was not interested, but in 1979 Lisbon formally renounced sovereignty over the enclave, which is now officially a &bquo;Chinese territory under Portuguese administration&equo;. 
 As a result, administrative arrangements can be countenanced which would be anathema to Hong Kong's British rulers. 
 The proposed airport, for example, will have facilities to function as a Chinese domestic facility, with immigration arrangements for visitors to both Macao and China. 
 Arguably, Macao would worry less about its future were it not constantly exposed to the nervousness of Hong Kong across the water. 
 The British territory is just an hour away by hydrofoil, and its newspapers, television, and radio carry frequent accounts of the current confidence crisis in the territory. 
 &bquo;We depend so much on Hong Kong,&equo; said Mr Ho. 
 &bquo;Our casinos depend on Hong Kong, our exports depend on it and most of our tourists come from there. 
 Macao people see a lot of Hong Kong people going, and they too will go. 
 What is happening in Hong Kong is contagious.&equo; 
 Hong Kong Special Report: The snakes are in good form, despite the wind: The feet are made for wokking, Robert Cottrell concludes as he adds the extremities of chickens to his range of culinary delights, along with the mysteries of tea, rice and appropriate poetry 
 By ROBERT COTTRELL 
 A MILESTONE in food-fetishism: my first chicken's foot, eaten at Zen, Hong Kong, on 13 September. 
 Boneless. 
 Chicken's feet used to give the lie to my bravura claim to Eat Anything, so long as it was recently dead. 
 I would go out of my way to crunch on crisp, mustardy jellyfish; an oily, tissuey-textured sea-slug, slipped into a congee of boiled rice, was my idea of a hearty breakfast; and the pig, from the brains to the balls (of the feet) seemed like a gourmet's theme-park. 
 So why not chicken feet? 
 Mainly because they looked like chicken's feet. 
 Toes, tiny ankles, skin, heels, as per when still attached to the chicken. 
 Also, because as served in 99 out of 100 Chinese restaurants, they would arrive sticky with grease and boiled to a hue of nauseously vivid waxy-yellow. 
 Nor could you just shut your eyes and throw them down the hatch; because the whole pleasure of a chicken's foot would come from sucking and nibbling it slowly, seeking out the tasty skin and the fragments of flesh like the last moments of a particularly luscious spare rib. 
 You have to like them as feet. 
 Zen, a newly-opened offshoot of the British restaurant group, is in the basement of a just-finished office and shop development called Pacific Place. 
 Its translucent glass, bare concrete ceilings, exposed pipework and Rennie Mackintosh-ish chairs are miles away from the gilt-and-gingerbread kitsch of the Hong Kong restaurant mainstream. 
 The menu reads more conventionally, but the food has been thought through with unusual care: witness the unexpected sweetness in the crab and sesame tart; the vinegary bite to a plate of matted e-fu noodles; and, of course, that small plate of perfection, within the narrowly-defined limits of its raw material, the chicken's foot. 
 The Zen foot is not yellow, but white. 
 The skin not waxy, but translucent; the texture not oily, but clean and dry. 
 It still looks like a foot, but a very nice foot really. 
 Affecting nonchalance, I pluck it up, and begin nuzzling; and, yes, it is a fairly rewarding sort of thing to eat. 
 Not much flavour, but a fibrous-to-spongy chewiness which sets it apart from the average savoury snack. 
 Now for the sheep's eyes. 
 DRINK TEA with Chinese food. 
 It aids digestion, prevents obesity, soothes the spirit and quickens the mind &mdash; or so its addicts would have you believe. 
 You can try to impress the waiter as a serious customer by specifying the type of tea you want, rather than just the brew in general. 
 The default blend in Hong Kong restaurants is usually the Yunnan tea called bo-lei in Cantonese dialect, and pu-erh in Mandarin. 
 Dark, hard and faintly bitter, it is said to have the side-effect of lowering blood-pressure, unlike most other things in Hong Kong. 
 The restaurant teapot is usually free, and bottomless. 
 When you have reached the lees, leave the pot on the table with the lid overturned or tilted to one side. 
 This will cue the waiter to refill it. 
 Etiquette requires more or less continuous competition among diners to keep one another's tea-cups topped up. 
 You will often see recipients tapping the table with the three middle fingers of one hand while their cup is being filled. 
 The gesture conveys gratitude for the kindness, and allegedly commemorates an emperor who, curious to taste the life of his common people, stayed incognito at an inn with two companions. 
 When the emperor took his turn at dinner pouring the tea, an unimaginable reversal of protocol, his awestruck fellow-travellers tapped the table to signify the kow-tows of abasement which they would ordinarily have been performing before him. 
 Chinese philsophers, gourmets and poets have produced over the centuries an extensive literature devoted to tea and its presumed effects upon the body and soul. 
 For a short and poignant reflection, consider this fragment from Lo Tong, an eighth century poet, translated by T C Lai in his book At the Chinese Table: The first bowl &mdash; how soothing to the throat! 
 The second bowl &mdash; all feeling of loneliness vanishes; The third bowl &mdash; I start searching my soul to find five thousand volumes of ancient tomes; The fourth bowl &mdash; a slight perspiration which washes away all unhappy things; The fifth bowl &mdash; my bones and muscles all cleansed; The sixth bowl &mdash; I establish communication with the immortal spirit; The seventh bowl &mdash; this must not be taken, Already a cool ethereal breeze Emanates from underneath my arms. 
 HALF THE pleasure of a southern Chinese meal ought to be the rice; its humble utility need not obscure its noble worth. 
 Traditionally, the fan, the cooked rice, is the essential element of the Chinese meal prepared south of the Yangtze River; north of the Yangtze, breads and noodles take its place. 
 The function of the cai, or choy &mdash; whatever else might be eaten with the staple &mdash; is to supply a little variety and additional nourishment. 
 The finest rice in all China used to be grown in fields around the village of Shatin, in Hong Kong's New Territories. 
 So distinctive were its qualities that the entire crop was bought by the Imperial Court. 
 Nowadays, the Shatin rice fields have long vanished beneath a new town of skyscrapers and motorways, with a racecourse at one side and a university at the other. 
 Chinese rice served in the course of a meal is always white, and usually prepared by steaming. 
 Ideally, it will be long-grained, rich in taste and slightly sticky. 
 The grains will be chewy, much as pasta should be al dente; it will be without lumps; and it will be fragrant. 
 It can be eaten without inhibition, the bowl raised to the lips and the chopsticks used to rake the grains into the mouth. 
 About the only serious mistake you can make with rice is to stick your chopsticks upright in the bowl: to do so mimics the Buddhist ritual for offerings to the dead, and will quickly reduce your table to an awkward silence. 
 The autumn winds have risen, The snakes are in good form, It's time to nourish yourself. 
 (Restaurant advertisement, translated by T C Lai) THE FRENCH gastronomic journal, Gault-Millau, caused major ructions this summer by applying its critical eye to the grandest of Hong Kong's hotel restaurants. 
 It found, high prices; a frequent want of authenticity in purportedly French cuisine; and it concluded that the least snooty of the bunch, the Restaurant de France at the Regal Meridien, Tsimshatsui, was also the best. 
 It liked the fact that the chef there, Jean-Yves Gueho, was actually French &mdash; as opposed to Swiss, German or Chinese; and that the long dining room, decorated with glass cupolas, achieved an ecclesiastical dignity. 
 The inspectors awarded Mr Gueho 17-18 marks out of possible 20, a ranking which would put him among the very best chefs of France. 
 Of his dishes, they recommended lobster with coriander, loup de mer, and pigeon with foie gras and truffles. 
 They were less enthusiastic about two places which would consider themselves several cuts above the Meridien. 
 The Pierrot restaurant at the Mandarin, they said, achieved some &bquo;great successes,&equo; but also some &bquo;real disasters&equo;. 
 The Plume at the Regent Hotel was noted both for its &bquo;unbeatable view&equo; and for its prix impitoyables. 
 Hong Kong Special Report: Future Leaders &mdash; Lo Tak-Shing 
 By ROBERT COTTRELL 
 &bquo;The trouble with T S,&equo; says one long-time acquaintance, &bquo;is that he cannot bring himself to confide in anybody.&equo; 
 Although many attribute to Lo Tak-shing possession of the most byzantine &mdash; and very possibly the cleverest -mind in Hong Kong politics, few claim to understand quite what he seems to be doing with it. 
 A big, physically powerful lawyer born into the most distinguished of the half-dozen Hong Kong families with a genuine claim to &bquo;old money&equo; status, T S Lo was by his early forties one of the grandest figures in the colonial establishment. 
 Appointed by Lord MacLehose to the territory's Executive Council, he advised the governor, and his successor, Sir Edward Youde, on major policy decisions culminating in sovereignty negotiations with China. 
 But in 1985, after the Sino-British settlement was announced, he resigned, declaring the move to be a protest against Britain's withholding of full citizenship from Hong Kong passport holders, and set up a trust to advise would-be emigrants on alternative rights of abode. 
 After a year in the margins, Mr Lo re-entered the political mainstream in a new job &mdash; and one which clearly indicated where he thought Hong Kong's future would now be decided. 
 He was elected vice-chairman of the Basic Law Consultative Committee, the body set up by Peking to promote awareness and discussion of post-1997 constitutional arrangements in Hong Kong. 
 He began developing his own contacts with the Chinese government, and advocating the view that Hong Kong should learn to accept China as a &bquo;protector and friend&equo; with whom a deepening relationship was both desirable and necessary. 
 &bquo;The illusion that China is our enemy,&equo; he argues, &bquo;must be replaced by the reality that on the fundamental questions of Hong Kong's peace and prosperity, China's interest coincides with that of Hong Kong.&equo; 
 Mr Lo is a central figure in the New Hong Kong Alliance, one of the territory's embryonic political parties. 
 Its recent proposal for a &bquo;bicameral&equo; legislature after 1997, in which directly-elected members would fill just half of one chamber, was derided by local liberals but liked in Peking. 
 Though he would never say as much, and though his own British nationality might create technical difficulties, few doubt that Mr Lo would like the job of &bquo;chief executive&equo; &mdash; in effect, governor &mdash; of Hong Kong after 1997. 
 Of those commonly identified as potential contenders, he commands some of the shortest odds. 
 Hong Kong Special Report: The business of realism and caution: As hardliners tighten their grip on Peking, uncertainty has swept industry, Andrew Higgins reports 
 By ANDREW HIGGINS 
 AFTER three years of inconclusive negotiations, the Hong Kong conglomerate Hutchison Whampoa had no doubts about the difficulties of doing business in China. 
 &bquo;There was always one more layer of bureaucracy,&equo; recalled Simon Murray, Hutchison's managing director. 
 Talks dragged on so long that some doubted whether the project &mdash; an aircraft maintenance joint venture with Lockheed and CAAC, China's national carrier &mdash; would ever materialise. 
 &bquo;Central bureacuracy smothered the deal,&equo; he said. 
 But almost overnight, the tables were turned. 
 Suddenly it was the Chinese, not the foreigners, who were pressing for a deal. 
 On 8 June, four days after the Tiananmen massacre and the day after rioting in Hong Kong, Chinese negotiators announced they were ready. 
 &bquo;They were pressing us like hell to sign,&equo; said Mr Murray. 
 &bquo;Everything was suddenly ready.&equo; 
 But, three months on, the venture is still not finalised. 
 Lockheed is now hesitating. 
 &bquo;At the moment we are waiting for the Americans. 
 By the time they make up their mind, the Chinese will probably be back to their old ways.&equo; 
 Many Hong Kong businessmen can cite similar experiences in the period since the massacre. 
 Struggling to keep the door open to its largest source of foreign capital, China &mdash; particularly the southern coastal provinces of Guangdong and Fujian &mdash; has been bending over backwards to encourage new investment and calm investors they already have. 
 &bquo;They are ten times easier to deal with today than they were six months ago,&equo; said Mr Murray. 
 In the short term at least, Hong Kong seems to have succumbed to China's charm offensive. 
 Despite the anger in Hong Kong over Tiananmen, no major company in the colony has pulled out of China. 
 Even Mr Murray, who appeared on television to condemn Peking for its butchery, has since acknowledged that &bquo;at the end of the day, we have to live with these guys. 
 It is not business as usual with China. 
 We have sent lots of messages that we are outraged. 
 But one has got to be realistic. 
 I don't think this is the moment to go slamming the door&equo;. 
 The economies of Hong Kong and China have grown so interdependent over the past decade that neither could easily contemplate a rupture. 
 Hong Kong's investment and know-how have helped transform the Pearl River delta of Guangdong Province into China's most prosperous region. 
 It accounts for 90 per cent of Guangdong's foreign investment, while 60 per cent of Guangdong's production is exported to Hong Kong. 
 Cheap land and labour are the main attractions. 
 With Chinese wages still roughly one-seventh of those in the colony, so many companies have shifted production across the border that at least two million Chinese workers &mdash; twice the size of Hong Kong's manufacturing workforce &mdash; are employed in Guangdong, processing goods for the textile, toy and electronics firms which are the backbone of Hong Kong's industrial sector. 
 &bquo;Hong Kong is is a money machine,&equo; says Dr Miron Mushkat, chief regional economist for Baring Securities. 
 &bquo;It is not dominated by emotions. 
 If it was, it would jeopardise its position as the gateway to China.&equo; 
 Apart from delays at border crossings during the June crackdown, Hong Kong firms experienced little or no disruption at their Guangdong operations. 
 The province has since been in the forefront of China's efforts to reassure foreign businessmen that its door will be staying open for &bquo;business as usual&equo;. 
 &bquo;We are dedicated to the export-oriented economy,&equo; promised Wu Binghui, the director of the provincial capital's Commission for Foreign Economic Relations and Trade. 
 &bquo;Our existing policies not only remain unchanged after the Peking incident, we will move forward in pushing forward the economic reform and open door policy.&equo; 
 But if the anger has faded, and Hong Kong companies continue to trade with and manufacture in China, Peking's crackdown has not been forgotten. 
 While companies with factories in China show few signs of pulling out in a hurry, some have lost enthusiasm for further expansion. 
 A survey conducted by the Hong Kong General Chamber of Commerce showed that 55 per cent of companies had postponed further investment decisions, while another 36 per cent were still debating what to do. 
 For example, Tomei Industrial (Holdings), an electronics company with 95 per cent of its production in China, accelerated expansion plans in Malaysia and Thailand, and hopes to cut China-based output to about 50 per cent of total production. 
 Another company, Gold Peak Industries (Holdings), which makes car audio equipment, is also trying to hedge future risks by setting up new factories elsewhere. 
 In both cases, the companies were worried less about producing the goods than selling them. 
 Hong Kong manufacturers depend almost entirely on export markets, many of which have been less willing to forgive and forget. 
 Many buyers, particularly in the United States, have felt uncomfortable buying goods made in China. 
 Though southern China suffered little disruption, many foreign buyers still look askance at relying on China for goods. 
 Anger and fear in North America and Europe have also stymied dozens of Hong Kong-led investment projects in China. 
 Just as unease about China's reliability as a production base has hurt Hong Kong manufacturers, anxiety over China's stability has undermined foreign financial confidence. 
 Before Tiananmen, Jardine Fleming Investment, a Hong Kong firm specialising in China investments, was exploring 25 possible ventures in China. 
 After the massacre, enthusiasm plummeted. 
 Four of the prospective ventures have been dropped and another eight placed &bquo;on hold&equo;, under pressure from queasy foreign investors. 
 The most important question mark, however, remains, as always, uncertainty about the future. 
 Even before 4 June, Hong Kong businessmen had serious doubts about China's economic direction. 
 An austerity programme begun in September 1988 was beginning to bite, raising fears that Peking would try to rein in the independent-minded southern provinces. 
 If Guangdong and other coastal regions were to lose their virtual autonomy in dealing with foreign investors and their privileged access to raw materials and fuel supplies, the effect would be far more damaging to Hong Kong's confidence in China than the sight of tanks rolling into Tiananmen Square. 
 Alarm about China's economic prospects and possible policy changes have also heightened anxiety in Hong Kong about one of its main assets &mdash; personal connections in China. 
 Many businessmen fear that, while Peking may stick to its open door and reform policy in name, officials responsible for implementing it in the southern provinces may lose their jobs as hardliners attempt to tighten their political grip. 
 A widely-cited instance of this is Hopewell Holdings, the construction and property group controlled and managed by Gordon Wu. 
 Until 4 June, Mr Wu could boast perhaps the best connections of any Hong Kong businessman. 
 In 1981, Zhao Ziyang, then China's prime minister, praised him as a &bquo;bold and patriotic capitalist&equo;. 
 Mr Wu then enlisted Mr Zhao's support to clear bureaucratic obstacles to his risky brainchild, a 186-mile tollway linking Hong Kong with Canton and the special economic zone of Shenzhen. 
 But with Mr Zhao in disgrace, Hopewell's prospects have dimmed. 
 The group has decided to shelve several projects, and to scrap a HK&dollar;3.8bn share issue. 
 Other Hong Kong businessmen may never have had quite the high-level political contacts of Mr Wu, but they too have cause for concern. 
 Many have spent years establishing close working relations with officials in Guangdong, Fujian and Hainan Island. 
 But some of these officials will now be tainted by associations with Zhao Ziyang, who spent much of his early career in Guangdong. 
 The governor of Hainan, a firm supporter of Zhao's liberal economic policies, has already been sacked amid allegations of corruption. 
 More disturbing still for Hong Kong businessmen, the governor of Guangdong, Ye Xuanping, is said to be under pressure to leave the province to take a new job as vice-premier in Peking. 
 For Hutchison's managing director, and other investors in Hong Kong, such shifts suggest that a prolonged power struggle may be underway. 
 &bquo;Where the uncertainty lies is what comes after Deng,&equo; said Mr Murray. 
 &bquo;Tiananmen has obviously moved us towards an attitude of caution.&equo; 
 Hong Kong Special Report: After the traumas, the colony picks up the pieces 
 By ROBERT COTTRELL 
 FOUR months after the traumas of 3-4 June, Hong Kong has picked up most of the pieces. 
 The demonstrations have faded away. 
 The stock market, which crashed after China's declaration of Martial Law, has recoupedits losses. 
 The property market has softened, but not collapsed. 
 Talks with China over the Basic Law, suspended after the massacre, have resumed. 
 Economic growth is slowing, but should still be a respectable 5 per cent this year. 
 The public figures who denounced China in June are now sounding more conciliatory notes. 
 Life has returned to normal, more or less. 
 In some important ways, the shock of mid-1989 was containable because Hong Kong had learnt from past crises. 
 During the sovereignty negotiations of 1982-84, for instance, social order had shown its most serious signs of fragmenting when, in the autumn of 1983, accelerating speculation against the Hong Kong dollar sent the exchange rate into free fall. 
 The Hong Kong government, with considerable help from John Greenwood of the GT fund management group, devised a self-righting mechanism for &bquo;pegging&equo; the Hong Kong dollar to the US currency, which has since worked perfectly. 
 Thus, whatever consequences Hong Kong feared from Tiananmen, a currency crisis was one. 
 To take another example: Hong Kong's banks were rotten for lack of regulation five years ago, when a series of collapses frightened the government into spending billions of dollars of public money on rescues. 
 After those expensive lessons in prudence, banks are now properly policed. 
 Had a serious run developed on the Bank of China in 1983, which thankfully it did not, the result would probably have been catastrophic. 
 When a run did develop on the bank after Tiananmen, the Hong Kong government was ready to deal with it. 
 It knew the bank's position; it knew how much liquidity to inject to relieve the pressure. 
 The most serious damage was to the Bank of China's amour-propre. 
 Proper regulation of banks, together with the generally lower interest rates made possible by a stable currency, also reduced worries about the property market. 
 Investors could generally assume, as they could not in 1982-84, that most bank loans made to developers and speculators had been adequately secured and documented. 
 While the market might continue softening for psychological and cyclical reasons, its woes would probably not be compounded by fraud-tainted defaults. 
 More recently, and equally significantly, the colony's stock market had mended its ways. 
 In October 1987, when share prices crashed around the world, Hong Kong disgraced itself by closing for four days to protect local speculators. 
 Afterwards, the government was finally moved to insist that the stock exchange appoint a competent new management. 
 Under the ancien regime, the exchange might well have shut again after Tiananmen. 
 Instead, the management kept it open, and has seen its judgement vindicated by the subsequent recovery. 
 Tiananmen did not, therefore, produce specific local crises. 
 If anything, it provided some pleasant surprises &mdash; about, for instance, the ability of large crowds to demonstrate peacefully, and the ability of Hong Kong-financed factories in southern China to be all but unaffected by turmoil in Peking. 
 There will, however, be longer-term consequences which flow from those dramatic weeks, which are still working themselves out and which may prove more serious. 
 The first is likely to be an increase in emigration. 
 The government, which used to play down the &bquo;brain drain', now accepts the need for frankness. 
 It estimates that 42,000 people will leave this year, 55,000 next year, and perhaps up to 60,000 the year after. 
 The emigrants are predominantly young and skilled: Hong Kong is now losing more graduates each year than it produces. 
 Officials describe the exodus as &bquo;quota-driven&equo;, meaning that numbers are limited only by the number of places made available in resettlement countries. 
 If South Africa or a South American country made a pitch for Hong Kong entrepreneurs, numbers could rise sharply yet again. 
 It is a matter of principle for the Hong Kong government that it should not seek to restrict the numbers leaving, whether directly or by influencing resettlement countries. 
 But, particularly since Tiananmen, it has been echoing the argument that people would be less concerned to leave Hong Kong before 1997 if they could be absolutely confident that other countries would accept them after that date. 
 The Governor, Sir David Wilson, has argued for a general &bquo;right of entry&equo; to Britain &mdash; though such a &bquo;right&equo; could not be of much value if it were not ordinarily convertible into full citizenship. 
 Officials also talk of an &bquo;armageddon scenario&equo;, asking that Britain secure international agreement to accommodate millions of Hong Kong refugees in the event of Tiananmen-style repression after 1997. 
 But this notion would probably do little to slow the emigration rate even if it were realised. 
 Who, after all, would decline a chance to emigrate because they thought they might later qualify as a refugee? 
 Though the issue no longer commands the same urgency it did immediately after Tiananmen, &bquo;right of abode&equo; has been adopted as a cause by a wide variety of business and professional lobby groups. 
 The most substantial, &bquo;Honour Hong Kong,&equo; is sponsored by many of the colony's biggest companies. 
 It argues that Britain has a moral responsibility to its citizens in Hong Kong; that Hong Kong people &bquo;do not want to leave&hellip; they seek an insurance policy&equo;; that Britain is &bquo;markedly ungenerous to its colonies&equo; compared with other European countries; and that &bquo;insofar as any Hong Kong people were to move to Britain, they would be a valuable asset to the British economy&equo;. 
 Hong Kong companies are not well-known moralists: their main interest lies in staunching their own losses of trained workers, and preserving the machinery of government. 
 To answer that immediate need, the British government has been agonising over how to offer a single tranche of passports, perhaps 100,000, to Hong Kong, in such a way as to target recipients whom it believes play vital roles in the public and private sector. 
 It had originally hoped to make some sort of announcement last month; but the practical complications have proved immense. 
 How could the &bquo;right&equo; people be identified? 
 How could they be tied to Hong Kong as a condition of receipt? 
 Would the anger of those denied passports exceed the gratitude of those who received them? 
 Hong Kong government officials shudder privately at the thought of having to organise the allocation. 
 A second legacy of Tiananmen has been increasing tension over the course of Hong Kong's political development, with just six months remaining before China's parliament is due to enact the mini-constitution, or Basic Law, setting out the pattern of post-1997 government. 
 China has fiercely opposed the introduction of democracy to Hong Kong, and has threatened to reverse any moves in that direction made by Britain before 1997. 
 Before Tiananmen, Britain had ducked the question by professing to believe that most Hong Kong people cared little about politics, and that those who did favoured little or no change. 
 Now, though so politically convenient a view is no longer tenable, no easy alternative presents itself. 
 So far, drafts of the Basic Law have skated awkwardly around the the post-1997 political structure and the role of direct elections. 
 China has recognised that to rule out direct elections would be bad public relations, but has yet to settle on how to describe its proposed dictatorship. 
 In the most recent interim text, published last February, the Basic Law Drafting Committee &mdash; appointed by Peking but including a minority of Hong Kong members &mdash; relegated the problem to an appendix which outlined a scheme to raise the number of directly-elected seats in the Legislative Council, Hong Kong's rubber-stamp parliament, from 15 out of 55 in 1997 to 40 out of 80 two terms (six years) later. 
 A referendum in 2011 would decide whether to progress to full democracy. 
 Louis Cha, the Hong Kong member who devised the system, and who resigned from the Drafting Committee in protest against Tiananmen, believes that the referendum would go in favour of democracy, but that the waiting-period would allow Hong Kong people to get used to new political responsibilities. 
 But would Hong Kong ever get a referendum under Chinese sovereignty? 
 Peking's response to other calls for &bquo;democracy&equo; this summer raised enough doubts. 
 When the House of Commons foreign affairs committee published its report on Hong Kong soon afterwards, it set democratisation as an urgent priority. 
 Emboldened by its example, Hong Kong's Legislative Councillors decided that not less than half their number should be directly elected in 1995, and the rest 10 years later; they later scaled the first figure down to 40 per cent, to win the suport of more conservative interest groups. 
 Rather than risk a clash between the Cha and Legislative Council models, China has opted to muddy the waters by indicating support for proposals unexpectedly advanced last month by Lo Tak-shing, of the New Hong Kong Alliance, for a &bquo;bicameral&equo; legislature, in which directly elected seats would account for half of a single house. 
 Since Chinese officials have also said recently that there will be few major alterations to the Basic Law between its interim and final drafts, their intention may be to declare that proliferation of ideas about political reform indicates an absence of consensus in Hong Kong, and leave Mr Cha's proposal in place. 
 But they could equally well deem Mr Lo's proposals to enjoy popular support &mdash; since Mr Lo is, as it happens, vice-chairman of China's own Basic Law Consultative Committee &mdash; and adopt those instead. 
 Either way, since Peking denies the legitimacy of the Legislative Council, it can afford to deny any special status to its views. 
 Britain has been muttering that if it perceives a &bquo;consensus for democracy&equo; in Hong Kong, it will start &bquo;talking tough&equo; to Peking at a diplomatic level, and perhaps even adopt the Legislative Council proposals for 1995 in the teeth of Chinese opposition and without regard to &bquo;convergence&equo; with the Basic Law. 
 If so, it will come to the negotiating table severely handicapped by its past history of deference: it could as easily have confronted the issue four years ago, when it would have stood more of a chance of winning. 
 It would also now risk being seen to act as much in the interests of its own credibility, as in support of a sincerely-held belief. 
 Another post-Tiananmen worry, greater for for Hong Kong than for any other interested party, must be the future of China's economy and economic policies. 
 The colony has grown rich over the past decade as gatekeeper to China's open door. 
 Its manufacturers employ more workers in Guangdong than they do in Hong Kong; its hotels are filled with tourists and salesmen en route for Peking and Guilin; its accountants, bankers and lawyers service thousands of foreign firms wide-eyed about the profits which they believe will one day be made from a billion Chinese consumers. 
 So far, only Hong Kong's tourist trade has visibly suffered, with year-on-year visitor numbers down 22 per cent in July, and 17 per cent in August. 
 But even the most mercenary of foreign firms grows a little queasier about trading with a regime which shoots dead its citizens, and then tries to score popularity points by offering convict labour to foreign factories; and even the most unreconstructed optimist can see that the resurgence of hard-line Marxists in the Peking power structure is likely to militate against further free-market reforms. 
 And if, as China warns may happen, foreign debt repayments start causing headaches in 1990-91, then even the most gung-ho foreign lender will grow cautious. 
 At the very least, Hong Kong must prepare to be a little more self-reliant for growth in the 1990s: public spending, particularly on infrastructural projects, is likely to assume a bigger and more virtuous role. 
 What, finally, of liberty and justice? 
 If such notions did not worry Hong Kong before Tiananmen, they ought not to worry it now. 
 China maintains the same professed intentions. 
 The Basic Law will still be enacted, promising a panoply of rights and freedoms for 50 years beyond 1997. 
 But the Chinese Constitution contains all sorts of promises, too &mdash; so many that it could probably have been construed to forbid the People's Liberation Army from shooting dead hundreds of unarmed civilians, and to prohibit the arbitrary arrest, summary trial or execution of thousands more. 
 Tiananmen demonstrated what most people in Hong Kong well knew, but preferred not to admit: that the leaders of the Chinese Communist Party can and will do absolutely anything, however brutal and illegal, to further their grip on power. 
 The notion that they will be circumscribed by a &bquo;Joint Declaration&equo; or a &bquo;Basic Law&equo;, so confidently advanced in 1984, now seems like a distant dream; 1997, by contrast, suddenly seems very real, and very close. 
  More than 50,000 Vietnamese &bquo;boat people&equo; waste their lives in squalid, overcrowded prison-like camps in Hong Kong, almost certainly having lost their gamble to secure a new life in the West. 
 Hong Kong says that only a handful of them should qualify as true refugees fleeing persecution, while the rest are &bquo;economic migrants&equo; escaping the pitiful poverty of their home country. 
 It argues that the understanding reached at the United Nations-sponsored Geneva refugee conference in 1979, for South-east Asian countries to offer &bquo;first asylum&equo; while Western countries provided permanent resettlement, has now collapsed. 
 Having attempted, unsuccesfully, to discourage further arrivals by imposing increasingly harsh regimes in its holding-camps, Hong Kong now wants Britain to authorise compulsory repatriation, in defiance of humanitarian objections from the United States. 
 Hong Kong Special Report: Future Leaders &mdash; Vincent Lo Hong-Shui 
 By ROBERT COTTRELL 
 THE 41-year-old chairman of the Shui On property and construction group, Vincent Lo, has risen sharply to political prominence since he was chosen by Peking in 1985 as one of the 180 members of its Basic Law Consultative Committee. 
 A year later, he played a central role in founding the Group of 89, a faction made up of business and professional members of the BLCC who wanted to see a conservative model for Hong Kong's political development. 
 The group quickly gained substantial influence; its success reflected upon Mr Lo, whose abilities caught the eye of the colonial government. 
 He was appointed to numerous official committees; a rumour, denied by Mr Lo, held that he was also offered a seat on the Legislative Council. 
 The Group of 89 first espoused a &bquo;gradualist&equo; approach to democratisation in Hong Kong, and was seen in more liberal quarters as pandering to Peking. 
 This year, shocked by the 3-4 June massacre, Mr Lo decided that Hong Kong was ready for a quicker pace of democracy. 
 He proposed a slightly more &bquo;progressive&equo; political model, and argued that Hong Kong people should unite in order to influence their own affairs. 
 Mr Lo thus put himself in the forefront of consensus politics in Hong Kong, thereby leaving his unrelated namesake, Lo Tak-shing, to seize the high ground further to the right. 
 Mr Lo's star is still in the ascendant. 
 The business community regognises him as &bquo;one of us&equo;, and he belongs to the generation which will be in its prime in 1997. 
 He has not sacrificed his credibility by undue deference to Peking, nor has he courted prestige within the British establishment. 
 He might, for those reasons, be an attractive compromise candidate for the job of post-1997 chief executive; but his abilities as a manager have yet to be underpinned by the more visceral instincts of a committed politician. 
 Hong Kong Special Report: Future Leaders &mdash; John Chan Cho-Chak 
 By ROBERT COTTRELL 
 ALTHOUGH the British government would deny &bquo;grooming&equo; a candidate from within the ranks of its Hong Kong civil service for the job of chief executive after transition in 1997, it has given John Chan, 46, a series of fast-track official posts which make him a credible contender for the job. 
 Mr Chan, now the government's Secretary for Trade and Industry, has been a civil servant since 1964 &mdash; almost all his working life, with the exception of a two-year excursion as executive director and general manager of a local finance company in 1978-80. 
 Finding the charms of the private sector unexpectedly resistible, he returned to government, and subsequently caught the eye of Sir Edward Youde, the Governor of Hong Kong from 1982-85. 
 Under Sir Edward's tutelage, he was closely involved in the Sino-British negotiations which culminated in the agreement to transfer Hong Kong in 1997. 
 He was also associated with the preparation of the 1988 White Paper on political reform, another constitutional milestone, and is now tipped to succeed Donald Liao, the outgoing Secretary for District Administration, as a member of the Sino-British Joint Liaision Group, the diplomatic body which monitors technical aspects of the transition. 
 Mr Chan is also considered a probable future member of the Executive Council, the Governor's &bquo;cabinet&equo;. 
 Not an obviously charismatic figure, Mr Chan's principal qualities are those of a high-order bureaucrat. 
 He is held to be efficient, fair-minded, scrupulously honest, and is well-liked by his colleagues. 
 He also has a sense of humour. 
 Short and chubby, he once said that he was the only senior Hong Kong official who could see eye-to-eye with the equally diminutive Deng Xiaoping. 
 Hong Kong Special Report: A brave new world tumbles down: Hong Kong tried to be optimistic about Chinese rule. 
 Tiananmen ended that, Robert Cottrell reports 
 By ROBERT COTTRELL 
 IN 1984, when Britain and China initialled their momentous Joint Declaration on the Question of Hong Kong, the colony still had the successful salesman's ability to counterfeit boundless enthusiasm. 
 Having learnt its worst fears were about to be realised, that it would be handed over to Chinese rule in 1997 without external protections or guarantees, it immediately put the best possible face on its situation. 
 Businessmen argued that there would, at worst, be 13 years in which to make money and get out. 
 More likely, they said, was that China would continue to modernise its economy, so that by 1997 the situation would be more one of China's adjusting to Hong Kong, than of Hong Kong's trimming itself to China. 
 Others said Hong Kong should be optimistic, not because 1997 meant so much, but because it meant so little. 
 Britain had governed Hong Kong for at least the past 25 years only because China allowed it. 
 Had China not, in reality, been the sovereign power for many years? 
 Would it not continue to need the hard currency and expertise which a westernised Hong Kong attracted? 
 The form might change, but not the substance. 
 So why worry? 
 The stock market's Hang Seng Index doubled within a year of the agreement; over the next two years, it doubled again. 
 Property prices soared. 
 But some people did worry, notably those who argued that Britain, having ruled Hong Kong as a benign dictatorship for more than 140 years, should institute a fully democratic government before 1997. 
 They cited the Joint Declaration's promise of &bquo;a legislature constituted by elections&equo;, and warned that without democracy, the autocratic machinery of colonial government might prove far less benign in China's hands. 
 Others worried about passports. 
 Successively more stringent British nationality laws had denied Hong Kong Chinese the right to live and work in Britain. 
 After 1997, their &bquo;British Nationals (Overseas)&equo; passports would confer no real benefit since, in the eyes of the Chinese government, they would be Chinese citizens. 
 But if the desire for democracy and passports reflected pockets of anxiety, 1984 to 1989 were remarkable more for their lack of political activism. 
 The broad mass of people, though worried about Peking rule, also felt twinges of chauvinistic pleasure at the forced departure of Britain. 
 They felt that the course of events was beyond their influence; they were living well. 
 For five years, Hong Kong was a bubble of optimism, growing fatter and fatter while its walls stretched thinner. 
 But when China sent its army into Tiananmen four months ago, the bubble burst. 
 Before Tiananmen, when the Peking students' mourning for Hu Yaobang, the deposed Communist Party boss, was evolving into political protest, Hong Kong had watched with amazement. 
 Businessmen fretted that no good could come of such defiance; students delighted in the courage of their mainland counterparts. 
 But as the Tiananmen movement grew and grew, more and more Hong Kong people were stirred into sympathetic action. 
 On 4 May, more than 3,000 Hong Kong students from 14 universities and colleges gathered in Chater Gardens, next to the Legislative Council building. 
 They carried banners, chanted slogans in support of the Tiananmen protest, and collected more than &pound;3,000 to send to Peking. 
 A small group began a hunger strike outside the Xinhua (New China) News Agency, China's quasi-diplomatic mission in Happy Valley. 
 It was, by Hong Kong's modest standards, a substantial demonstration, and the nerve it touched was quickly apparent. 
 Taxi drivers cruised around Xinhua, honking their support. 
 The agency's own staff gave water and blankets to hunger strikers and let them use the office telephone. 
 A student union called for a one-day strike at local colleges. 
 A three-day sit-in at the Star Ferry terminal raised almost &pound;10,000 for Peking. 
 A student petition calling for the Chinese government to negotiate with student leaders attracted 80,000 signatures and was presented to Xinhua after another rally on 17 May. 
 The Joint Committee for the Promotion of Democratic Government in Hong Kong, a coalition of 1997-oriented liberal pressure groups, threw its support behind the Tiananmen campaign by staging a rally on 20 May, the day Martial Law was declared in Peking. 
 Despite an approaching typhoon which ordinarily would have left the streets deserted, the march attracted 40,000 people - the largest political demonstration locally for 20 years. 
 The committee urged a further show of sympathy with the Tiananmen demonstrators the next day. 
 It was astonished by the result. 
 At 2pm, about 100,000 people had gathered at its rallying point in Chater Gardens. 
 By the time the crowd reached Happy Valley, two miles away, it had swelled to between 500,000 and one million people &mdash; 10 to 20 per cent of Hong Kong's population. 
 &bquo;Down with Li Peng,&equo; chanted the marchers, &bquo;It is no crime to love your country. 
 Long live democracy. 
 Down with repression. 
 Free the press.&equo; 
 Shops and offices hung out banners of support. 
 Ta Kung Pao, the Communist newspaper regarded as the most reliable voice in Hong Kong of the Peking leadership, displayed a poster reading: &bquo;Wash away the shame of the country.&equo; 
 Xinhua staff issued a statement declaring &bquo;firm support for the patriotic democratic movement of the Peking students and the broad masses. 
 Long live the students! 
 Long live the people! 
 Long live the patriotic unity of the Hong Kong compatriots!&equo; 
 The rally encompassed students, politicians, teachers, religious groups, businessmen, trade unionists and television stars. 
 The organisers announced the birth of a &bquo;Hong Kong Alliance in Support of the Patriotic Democratic Movement in China&equo;, and proposed a motto: &bquo;Today Peking, tomorrow Hong Kong&equo;, which was as close as Hong Kong came to making explicit its interest in the struggles to the north. 
 The newly-formed Alliance channelled cash and supplies to Peking. 
 On 27 May it organised a &bquo;Concert for Democracy in China&equo; at the Happy Valley racecourse, which attracted 300,000 people, and was broadcast live on two television and two radio stations. 
 Fifty telephone lines received pledged donations. 
 The event raised &pound;1m, most of which was set aside for investment in a trust fund. 
 Some was taken in briefcases to Peking. 
 Some was used for food and shelter, including the red and blue tents which sprang up across Tiananmen Square at the end of May. 
 After the 21 May rally, demonstrations became relatively commonplace and on a scale which would have been unthinkable a month earlier. 
 On 23 May, tens of thousands of school students rallied at Xinhua, subscribing 72,000 names to a petition and collecting about &pound;35,000. 
 On 24 May, 100,000 people marched through the Causeway Bay shopping district. 
 On 26 May, a rally organised by Christian students attracted 200,000 people. 
 Students at the University of Hong Kong announced that they would be organising groups in which students could be &bquo;educated in concepts of democracy and freedom&equo;. 
 Members of the medical faculty said they would fax press reports of the Peking democracy movement to as many recipients as they could find in China, to overcome censorship. 
 After a century or so of political apathy, Hong Kong's young people were making up for lost time. 
 It was a brave new world - but one which, a week later, came crashing down. 
 On 4 June, the same crowds which had filled Happy Valley with rallies of pop music and bright colours gathered, now in mourning clothes of black and white. 
 Many had been awake all night, listening with increasing horror to the first confused reports of the massacre in Peking. 
 The rally was peaceful, the slogans were angry. 
 &bquo;Down with the regime of killer warlords,&equo; read one banner. 
 Thousands queued to sign an unofficial book of condolence at the Xinhua News Agency. 
 Along its high white granite walls, hundreds of funeral wreaths were coalescing into one great hanging garden of remembrance. 
 In the days which followed, a whispering campaign against the Peking-owned Bank of China snowballed into a bank run. 
 Embassies were swamped by would-be migrants. 
 On 6 June, a demonstration against a Chinese bank in the tough, working class district of Mongkok turned into a night of localised rioting. 
 The Alliance called a general strike the next day, but cancelled further demonstrations, fearing fresh violence. 
 Schools and most offices closed; taxis flew black flags; shops draped black banners from their windows; convoys of lorries clogged roads towards the Chinese border. 
 A mile-long queue of mourners carried a black coffin to the Xinhua building. 
 Hong Kong's immediate response to the massacre was, naturally enough, horror for the Peking dead. 
 Then it began to understand the horror of its own predicament. 
 It had lost all faith in China; it had sided against the leadership which had prevailed; and now, in its hour of need, it found no prospect of comfort from its own supposedly sovereign power, Britain. 
 The protesters outside Xinhua now waved banners proclaiming: &bquo;Wake up Maggie Thatcher&hellip; 
 Rescind the agreement with the barbarous Chinese government.&equo; 
 But in the House of Commons, when Mrs Thatcher rose on 6 June to express &bquo;revulsion&equo; for the massacre, she also restated her government's intention to proceed with the handover in 1997. 
 Sir Geoffrey Howe, then Foreign Secretary, also spoke, but only, from Hong Kong's viewpoint, to add insult to injury. 
 Grim as events might seem, Britain could not contemplate a &bquo;massive new immigration commitment&equo; which could &bquo;more than double the ethnic minority population of the United Kingdom&equo;. 
 He also said that the Prince and Princess of Wales would not make a planned visit to China in November &bquo;so long as those responsible for the atrocities over the past weekend remain in control of the Chinese government&equo;. 
 China could be trusted with almost six million people in perpetuity, but not the royal family for a weekend. 
 Sir David Wilson, the Governor of Hong Kong, did his best to reconcile the passions of his subjects with the caution of his masters. 
 Before the massacre, he had allowed Hong Kong's sympathies for the Peking protests to flow freely, judging that demonstrations could and should be allowed to proceed without police interference. 
 But after the massacre, as his city raged and mourned, his expressions of distress were encoded in the Mandarin of Whitehall, rather than the Cantonese of Hong Kong. 
 He &bquo;deplored&equo; the violence; he &bquo;understood&equo; Hong Kong's feelings; he felt Britain needed to provide &bquo;positive support&equo; to the colony. 
 The Governor had been due to fly to London on 5 June to testify to the Commons foreign affairs committee on the condition of the colony following the Joint Declaration. 
 He delayed the trip by two days, arrived in London on 8 June, and went into a series of meetings with the Commons committee, Sir Geoffrey, Mrs Thatcher and the Press. 
 He urged the Government to restore a &bquo;right of entry&equo; to Britain for Hong Kong people, which would fall technically short of right of abode, but would imply surety of refuge. 
 He was rebuffed. 
 He pressed particularly for the granting of full British right of abode to Hong Kong's civil servants, a category which, on the broadest interpretation, might embrace 180,000 public-sector employees. 
 Again he was rebuffed, though with indications of &bquo;flexibility&equo; for some smaller number. 
 He returned to Hong Kong with his own credibility increased, and that of his government diminished. 
 At the end of June, Sir Geoffrey made his own last vain attempt to reassure Hong Kong, flying in briefly for one of the most uncomfortable few days of his long diplomatic career. 
 On his return, he said a Bill of Rights would be entrenched into Hong Kong law. 
 The foreign affairs committee rushed out its revised report, supporting the Government's closed-door policy towards immigration, but saying more emphasis should be placed on introducing democratic government. 
 The latter view might have been applauded a year previously: after Tiananmen, it sounded merely cynical. 
 A member of Hong Kong's Legislative Council, Nellie Fong, said the British were &bquo;trying to wash their hands in the mantle of democracy&equo;. 
 Another, Selina Chow, said the MPs had &bquo;an unwavering determination to ignore the single most urgent problem that our people are facing &mdash; fear&equo;. 
 But the question which struck at the heart of the matter was put to Sir Geoffrey on 5 July in the Commons by Jim Sillars, the Scottish Nationalist. 
 &bquo;If the people in Hong Kong were white,&equo; he asked, &bquo;would you be taking the same view?&equo; 
 Hong Kong Special Report: The spectre haunting Hong Kong's future: The &bquo;Jewels of the Orient&equo; are now a string of tarnished beads. 
 Derek Davies, editor-in-chief of the Far Eastern Economic Review, fears that this is the fate which might befall Thatcherite Hong Kong. 
 The British government, he says, has capitulated too readily to the demands of Peking 
 By DEREK DAVIES 
 OLD ASIA hands still talk nostalgically about the Good Old Days in many of the region's cities and ports, which have since had much of their former life and glamour squeezed out of them by oppressive regimes, overcrowding or economic decline. 
 Several such cities once claimed the title of &bquo;Jewel&equo; or &bquo;Pearl&equo; of the Orient. 
 Today they make up a sad string of tarnished beads, from Bombay, Calcutta and Rangoon to Saigon (now Ho Chi Minh City), Hanoi and Canton. 
 The city which became the most depressing ghost of its former self was Shanghai. 
 Although it harboured the worst sort of poverty, inequality and exploitation during the 1930s and 1940s, not least because its bright lights attracted millions from the surrounding countryside, it seethed with exuberant life and economic activity. 
 Then, under Mao Tse-tung's triumphant Communists in the 1950s and 1960s, it declined into a depressing, monochromatic shell of its former self. 
 Today, the spectre of Shanghai's past haunts the Hong Kong's future. 
 There was a time, just after Britain and China signed in 1984 their Joint Declaration on the Question of Hong Kong, when the colony looked forward with high hopes to the 50 or more years of capitalist autonomy which both parent-governments had promised would follow its reversion to Chinese sovereignty in 1997. 
 After two years of difficult negotiations, the agreement seemed to be a brand plucked from the burning. 
 Hong Kong adopted Deng Xiaoping, China's leader, as its political pin-up boy. 
 Business and political leaders praised his liberalism and his pragmatism, the assurance with which he presided over China's opening to the West and the dexterity with which he dumped much of its communist ideology. 
 But they failed to notice, or preferred to ignore, that Deng's &bquo;liberalism&equo; was limited exclusively to matters of an economic nature. 
 When he brusquely told visitors that of course China was going to station units of the People's Liberation Army in Hong Kong after 1997, the colony shuddered. 
 But it took five more years, and the Tiananmen massacre, for its residents fully to grasp their prospective vulnerability as citizens of China. 
 Peking officials now seek to excuse the June atrocities by claiming &mdash; all too credibly &mdash; that they had neither the resources nor the expertise to cope with the escalating civil disorder culminating in the Tiananmen Square assault. 
 But Hong Kong was chilled as much by the implications of Tiananmen as by the spectacle. 
 On its own streets, too, massive crowds had gathered during those remarkable weeks to demonstrate support for their Peking compatriots. 
 There, too, under China's post-1997 regime, Peking would be free to declare Martial Law; and there, too, a garrison of the People's Liberation Army would stand ready to suppress opposition or criticism by whatever means Deng and his successors deemed appropriate. 
 More grist has filled the pessimists' mill in the years since the Joint Declaration, as Peking has grown more assertive and London more timid. 
 Within months of the signing ceremony, China was objecting vigorously to British proposals for introducing a meaningful degree of democracy to Hong Kong's political structure. 
 Britain bowed limply to China's demands &mdash; even though this meant weaseling-out of previous pledges to put a representative elected government into Hong Kong before 1997, and even though Peking itself had promised a &bquo;Hong Kong run by Hong Kong people&equo;. 
 The Foreign Office and the Hong Kong government tried to camouflage their retreat with windy evasion, talking piously of the need to create &bquo;convergence&equo; between what Hong Kong wanted for its future, and what China was prepared to permit. 
 The British allowed other principles to crumble in the face of Chinese displeasure. 
 They accepted an objectionable, racially-discriminatory basis on which Hong Kong citizenship would be decided. 
 They accepted limitations on the jurisdiction of Hong Kong's post-1997 Supreme Court, and proposals which would diminish the independence of judges. 
 They refrained from responding to a long series of statements by senior Chinese officials which contradicted both the letter and the spirit of the Joint Declaration - including an assurance, for example, that the post-1997 Hong Kong press would be free for &bquo;as long as it did not publish anything detrimental to China's national interest&equo;. 
 London was all too obviously selling Hong Kong down the Pearl River, despite its protestations to the contrary. 
 Even now, and though the events of June triggered a brief period of reappraisal, the British still seem besotted by their vision of China as a billion-strong market for their goods and services &mdash; and either unaware, or unimpressed, that their exports to Hong Kong itself are currently worth three times as much as those to its northern neighbour. 
 The optimists dismiss China's ballooning inflation and swelling money supply as mere potholes on its road to the level of prosperity already enjoyed by many of its East Asian neighbours. 
 Nothing, as responses to the June crackdown have confirmed, can puncture their confidence in Peking's authority or China's stability. 
 Already, President George Bush is talking about a full restoration of Sino-US relations. 
 Other nations, especially Japan, wait impatiently in the wings with their offers of soft loans. 
 To those who see China in primarily economic terms, the &bquo;golden goose&equo; argument comes most easily: that its government would never be so foolish as to constrict or repress Hong Kong, the tiny territory which has proved such a powerful catalyst for the growth of its hinterland. 
 In eight years, such optimists claim, China will be adjusting to Hong Kong, rather than vice versa. 
 Great tracts of the Middle Kingdom will be virtually indistinguishable from the tiny entrepreneurial enclave. 
 Already, China is breeding its own Hong Kong-style businessmen &mdash; financiers who welcome foreign investors into joint enterprises to build everything from factories to golf courses, former peasants making fortunes from rural industries, former factory workers opening photographic shops and beauty salons. 
 Such optimism may still prove to be justified: but the bets are much riskier, now that China's leadership has shown its continued reliance on the mailed fist and its continued vulnerability to factional disputes. 
 While Deng is doing his best to assure the world that nothing has changed, that China will push ahead with its reforms and will hold its door open for foreign business and investment, the post-Tiananmen purging of liberal intellectual elements and the new emphasis on &bquo;political education&equo; have enormously strengthened the position of the Communist Party's hardline Marxists, led by Yang Shangkun, the president, and Li Peng, the prime minister. 
 The People's Liberation Army has strong-armed its way back into the centre of China's political power-structure, after a decade of relative decline. 
 As a consequence, though Deng is advertising the moderate Jiang Zemin, recently appointed Party general secretary, as his heir-apparent, the hardliners may have it in their power to change China's course when the 85-year-old leader dies. 
 Britain, too, has been reshuffling its politicians. 
 A new Foreign Secretary, John Major, has replaced Sir Geoffrey Howe. 
 Francis Maude has replaced the unimpressive Lord Glenarthur as the minister in charge of Hong Kong affairs. 
 Though both are still being briefed, there are indications that they would like to use the shock of the Tiananmen massacre as a negotiating tool with which to recover some of the concessions made by their predecessors in respect of Hong Kong. 
 But that hope seems slim. 
 Mildly critical statements have been greeted angrily by Peking as intolerable acts of interference in China's sovereign affairs. 
 Senior Chinese officials have blamed the damage to Hong Kong's confidence variously on Hong Kong people themselves, for daring to demonstrate; and on the British, an astonishing claim which was made by China's principal representative in Hongkong, Xu Jiatun, the director of the New China News Agency, who said that the responsibility for restoring confidence in Hong Kong rested with London. 
 Rather than match China's firmness, it can be confidently predicted, the Hong Kong authorities will follow past form, cease muttering about their shock and horror over Tiananmen, and return to bland assurances that the negotiations with Peking about a post-1997 &bquo;Basic Law&equo; for Hong Kong are going well. 
 This patronising obfuscation was never very convincing. 
 Now, after every Hong Kong citizen with a television set has seen how Peking treats its dissenters, it offers nothing to a public whose mood has become one of restrained panic. 
 Hong Kong was always a free-wheeling, highly materialistic city, with more than its full share of pirates and crooks. 
 Today, the pressure to make hay while the sun fitfully shines has led to a massive slump in both public and private standards. 
 The professions have lost many of their better men; many of those who remain are concentrating on maximising profits and fees to feather nests in the US, Canada or Australia. 
 It has been estimated that about &dollar;280m a month has been flowing out of Hong Kong into the city of Vancouver this year. 
 Scandals have proliferated in business and banking, and have tainted the civil service and the judiciary. 
 Retiring public servants now routinely move into jobs where their previous contacts and responsibilities can enrich themselves and their employers. 
 Recruitment is increasingly difficult, particularly to the police force where morale has sunk to a new low. 
 The sense of community has not been improved by Britain's promise of an ungenerous package which will limit refuge to those deemed to have served the Crown well, or to hold &bquo;sensitive&equo; positions. 
 For obvious reasons, the people of Hong Kong have long been reluctant to speak their minds. 
 Chinese and expatriates alike, they have the resilience of refugees. 
 They have survived civil unrests, bank runs, the Cultural Revolution, and soldiered on in silence. 
 When Tiananmen finally broke their reserve, a million or more, a fifth of the population, turned out for the biggest of several demonstrations in sympathy with the Peking students. 
 In its wake, tens of thousands are slipping off, quietly once more, to sanctuaries abroad. 
 The Hong Kong government, no longer able to down-play the exodus, admitted that at least 45,000 of its best and brightest left last year. 
 The 1989 total is likely to be at least a third higher. 
 If this trend continues, Hong Kong could lose 750,000 or more of its better-qualified people, leaving behind a sandwich-society with capital on top, unskilled workers beneath, but little or no middle-class in between. 
 The emigration has been encouraged by a series of British Nationality Acts stripping even the 3.25 million people holding Hong Kong &bquo;British&equo; passports of any rights to residence in Britain. 
 The sense of betrayal has been deepened by London's refusal to acknowledge any moral responsibility to provide general refuge; instead, it has claimed that domestic political considerations demand the exclusion of potentially millions of Chinese immigrants. 
 It has, meanwhile, steadfastly ignored the argument that people who cannot get out will do their best to leave; while those with the &bquo;insurance policy&equo; of a passport in their back pockets are more likely to stay on and try to make their home-town work. 
 Those who ultimately fail to get out of Hong Kong will do what Hong Kong people have always done. 
 They will adjust, bending like bamboos before the prevailing wind from the north. 
 As they do so, yet another Asian city - ironically in the circumstances, the most Thatcherite of them all &mdash; will be dying. 
 Hong Kong Special Report: Slogans 
 By DEREK DAVIES 
 &bquo;Hong Kong People Rule Hong Kong&equo;: the slogan propagated by China during the 1982-84 sovereignty negotiations, to encourage popular local support for its demand that Britain withdraw completely from the administration of Hong Kong on 30 June 1997. 
 The &bquo;Basic Law&equo;: a mini-constitution for post-1997 Hong Kong now being prepared by a Peking-appointed committee. 
 Two drafts have already been published. 
 A final version is due to be endorsed by China's parliament, the National People's Congress, in March. 
 &bquo;Convergence&equo;: China's strategy for influencing Hong Kong's development in the remaining years of British rule. 
 It argues that Britain must move Hong Kong into alignment with the terms of the Basic Law before 1997, to avoid instability during the transition itself. 
 Hong Kong Special Report: Future Leaders &mdash; Martin Lee Chu-Ming 
 By DEREK DAVIES 
 DEPENDING on who you talk to, Martin Lee is the most admired or most reviled public figure in Hong Kong; a man of principle and courage, or a megalomaniac; a defender of democracy, or an advocate of chaos. 
 Reputedly Hong Kong's highest-paid barrister before politics began to consume virtually all his time, he has many fans among other lawyers, who elected him to the Legislative Council in 1985 and 1988 as their profession's representative. 
 A few businessmen admit privately to admiring his honesty, if not always his fervour. 
 The British still tend to treat him with a faintly hostile embarrassment: as well they might, since for the past four years, his principal message has been condemnation of their duplicity in, as he sees it, backing away from promises to introduce democratic government by 1997. 
 If Hong Kong does espouse democracy, Martin Lee will be unbeatable. 
 Alone of its present legislators, he accepts the demands of grassroots politics, building support through ceaseless slogging, always available for a meeting here, a press conference there, a Sunday rally or a television interview. 
 He unnerves and often offends colleagues on the Legislative Council, many of whom believe their institution is safer in the hands of appointees and amateurs than of populists. 
 It is easy enough to say What Makes Martin Run: a sincere belief that Hong Kong needs true democracy, even if most of its present leaders disagree. 
 The more difficult question is how long he can continue as a one-man movement. 
 He has been one of the Legislative Council's most diligent members, a demanding enough job; he accepted China's offer of a seat on the Basic Law Drafting Committee, helping to write Hong Kong's post-1997 mini-constitution, and was embroiled in more unsuccessful arguments for direct elections, opposed by mainland communists and Hong Kong conservatives. 
 He has been an energetic supporter of the democracy movement in China; and of Hong Kong campaigns to secure right of abode in Britain. 
 Not surprisingly, from time to time, his fatigue shows: the voice cracks, the temper frays, the judgement falters. 
 He never seems to take time off: a friend tells of how Joey, Mr Lee's young son, once protested by scrawling his own name in his father's diary for an appointment. 
 If Hong Kong ever does achieve democracy, it will owe Mr Lee a monument: for the time being, it owes him a holiday. 
 The monster of Greater Lebanon: In the first of two articles on the origins and architects of the situation in Lebanon, Robert Fisk describes the events which Muslim historians would later refer to as &bquo;the betrayal&equo; 
 By ROBERT FISK 
 IN THE FADING sepia postcards on sale in the antiquarian shop in Makhoul Street, General Henri Gouraud appears as a stiff little figure in a dark kepi, his right hand held out to a British officer. 
 The 69-year-old photograph shows him arriving in Beirut in the aftermath of the First World War. 
 The British officer got there first, but knew there was a secret agreement for the French to control Lebanon. 
 To the right of the picture, ignored by Gouraud, is a small group of Beirut notables, preparing for what several Lebanese Muslim historians would later refer to as &bquo;the betrayal&equo;. 
 Its effects were to be felt long after Gouraud and his successor, General Weygand, had died. 
 Today there are a few very old men in Lebanon who have lived to watch the monster which the general helped to create. 
 For most Arabs, the original betrayal occurred at the height of the First World War, when the allied powers made conflicting promises to each other, as well as to the Jews and Arabs. 
 Britain told the Arabs they would receive independence in return for help in the struggle against the Turks. 
 But they also said the Jews would have a homeland in Palestine and agreed that when the war ended the French would control Syria and what was then called Mount Lebanon. 
 As the Turkish forces collapsed, King Faisal's army advanced on Aleppo, while Arab cities in the Levant rose up. 
 Even today Lebanon's Christian leadership is unwilling to admit that Lebanon has an &bquo;Arab identity&equo;, although the people of Beirut, Tripoli and Baalbek joined the rising. 
 Even then, however, this fact was to be obscured. 
 Here, for example, is an extract from a memorandum to a US delegate to the Paris Peace Conference by Lawrence of Arabia, who had led the Arabs to victory while torturing himself with the secret knowledge of his part in their betrayal: &bquo;On 1 October (1918), the people of Beyrout, in emulation of the Damascenes, turned on their Turkish garrison of 700 men, and took them prisoner&hellip; 
 On 8 October allied troops entered Beyrout. 
 The Arab rising there had been suppressed in the newspapers, so that the French troops might claim the honour of its liberation from the Turks.&equo; 
 At the Paris conference the Lebanese Christian Maronites fought hard to have their small area of Mount Lebanon extended into a Greater Lebanon, which would include Tripoli, Sidon, Tyre and Baalbek at Syria's expense. 
 The French, traditional protectors of the Christians since the Druze massacres of 1860, at first resisted, but the Maronite patriarch, Elias Hoyek, personally demanded the expansion of Mount Lebanon. 
 He did this even though the large Maronite majority in Mount Lebanon would be much reduced if the extra territories were taken from Syria. 
 If the Christians obtained their enlarged Lebanon, they would only be in a small majority over the Sunni and Shia Muslims. 
 The Shias of the south, the Sunnis of Sidon and Tripoli, would not only oppose such a state, but produce more children than the Maronites, who would then be a minority in the country they had created. 
 But the Maronites persisted and on 1 September 1920, Gouraud, the newly-installed French high commissioner, proclaimed from his Beirut residence &bquo;the state of Greater Lebanon&equo;. 
 It was a fateful, many would say tragic, announcement, for from that day the seeds of Lebanon's disintegration were sown. 
 In retrospect, it was ironic that a year after Syria was partitioned, another small ethnic group took the opposite path to protect its identity. 
 While Lebanon's Christians were demanding more territory, Protestants in the north of Ireland were safeguarding their future statelet within the United Kingdom by accepting less than they might have claimed. 
 Under the Government of Ireland Act of December 1921, Ireland was partitioned. 
 Northern Ireland came into being, but only after the Protestants had decided to give three of the counties of historic Ulster to the new Irish Free State. 
 The Unionist leader, James Craig, abandoned the Protestants in those three counties because their Catholic population was so high. 
 Thus the Protestants preserved their future, although it was to be one which mimicked, in smaller fashion, the tragedy of Lebanon. 
 If the Maronites had taken a similar path, perhaps seeking a confederated state within a Greater Lebanon, the catastrophe that befell their grandsons might have been averted. 
 The Christians gave no indication at the time that they foresaw any such developments, although Arab nationalists in Lebanon and Syria at first refused to recognise that a nation-state existed which was separate from Syria. 
 This is the genesis of so much of the rhetoric from Syrian leaders today who talk of Syria and Lebanon as &bquo;one country&equo;. 
 Despite all the criticism of President Assad, there is no evidence that Syria wishes to annex Lebanon. 
 But the Arab nationalist belief that the two countries contain one Arab people &mdash; that there was therefore something immutably wrong in the creation of Greater Lebanon &mdash; has never been abandoned. 
 Maronite collaboration with the French &mdash; and the support for a Maronite state which later came from Israel &mdash; contaminated the community in the eyes of its opponents. 
 The change in the Christian community from the largest community to minority status has never been officially acknowledged in Lebanese statistics. 
 The last official census was in 1932, when France was still exercising its League of Nations mandate for Lebanon in neo-colonial fashion. 
 It showed that the Maronites constituted 29 per cent of the population (229,378), the Sunnis 22 per cent (175,925) and the Shias 19 per cent (154,208). 
 When the Maronites were added to other Christian groups (Greek Catholics, Greek Orthodox, Armenians and others), the Christians formed 52 per cent of the population. 
 Together with the Druze, the Sunnis and Shias comprised a Muslim total of 48 per cent. 
 The French were not blind to the bitterness of many Muslims in Lebanon, especially the Sunnis, who under Turkish rule had held a privileged position. 
 The Turks, after all, were also Sunnis. 
 When the French proclaimed the Republic of Greater Lebanon in 1926, they proposed a Greek Orthodox as president, because he would be acceptable to Muslims, as well as trusted by the French and the Maronites. 
 But in 1932 the French suspended the constitution to prevent election of a Muslim as president. 
 For the Maronites, a Muslim leader represented the victory of Arab nationalism (and Islam) over a country which they and the French regarded as a pro-Western, Christian homeland. 
 US steps in to back the League 
 From ROBERT FISK in Taif, Saudi Arabia 
 THE United States has discreetly intervened in the gathering of Lebanese parliamentarians in Taif by sending two State Department officials to emphasise Washington's support for political reform in Lebanon. 
 David Sutherfield &mdash; who was a political counsellor at the US embassy in east Beirut until American diplomats were evacuated a month ago &mdash; arrived here over the weekend in the company of another American official for talks with Hussein Husseini, the Speaker of the Lebanese Parliament. 
 Christian deputies have been trying to obtain some form of timetable for a Syrian military withdrawal before accepting political reforms, but at their fifth meeting yesterday, the 62 MPs &mdash; half of them Christians &mdash; were persuaded to debate the future powers of a Christian Maronite president. 
 The Arab League's proposals call for cabinet veto power over presidential decisions, thus reducing Maronite control over the government and more accurately reflecting the strength of Lebanon's majority Muslim population. 
 Mr Sutherfield and his colleague, Richard Johns, presented to Mr Husseini a letter from 16 members of the US Congress who supported the league's peace plan. 
 According to Lebanese Muslim deputies, the Americans assured Mr Husseini that the Bush administration was &bquo;100 per cent&equo; behind the Arab League. 
 For their part, the Saudis are applying more pressure upon the Lebanese Assembly members. 
 Prince Saud al-Feisal, the Foreign Minister, has been calling upon the MPs to urge them to put the future of their country before any factional ambitions. 
 He has been telling them that both the Soviet Union and the United States have reiterated their support for the league's plan and that political reform is the only way for the Lebanese to solve their crisis. 
 What this means is that Christian Maronite domination of the Lebanese body politic appears to be effectively at an end. 
 Whatever future peace Lebanon can obtain, it is not going to be under the power-sharing system that existed before the start of the civil war. 
 If the parliamentary debates here have aligned Christians against Muslims they have also proved that both sides appreciate the need for change. 
 MPs spent two hours discussing the make-up of a committee to draw up a new system of presidential power and cabinet veto, and it was significant that the 12 names mentioned for the committee included several Christian deputies, but only one Maronite. 
 BEIRUT &mdash; Syrian forces freed a Lebanese air force pilot who had been picked up by a gunboat after ditching his plane in the Mediterranean yesterday, Reuter reports. 
 Security sources said Major George Serhal was handed over to the former Lebanese president, Suleiman Franjieh. 
 Christian political sources had warned that unless Major Serhal was freed immediately the incident would be a severe blow to Arab-sponsored peace efforts. 
 Britain and US &bquo;gave new rockets to the mujahedin' 
 From AHMED RASHID in Kabul 
 THE HEAD of Afghanistan's Supreme Defence Council has accused Britain and the United States of supplying the mujahedin with long-range cluster-bomb rockets and additional supplies of the British-made Blowpipe anti-aircraft missiles. 
 He also said that the Soviet Union was ready to supply any sophisticated weapons that the Afghan regime wanted. 
 Lieutenant-General Abdul Haq Ulomi, who heads the country's most powerful military and political body, said in an interview the two countries were testing the new surface-to-surface rockets in Afghanistan by supplying them to the mujahedin to use on Kabul. 
 &bquo;These new cluster rockets have a range of 30 to 40 miles, and each one has 90 small mines in it. 
 These are weapons of mass destruction,&equo; he said in his well-guarded office near the presidential palace in Kabul. 
 The mujahedin have been using US-supplied Chinese and Egyptian-made rockets in recent years to shell Kabul, but there has been no previous evidence of Western rockets being given to the guerrillas. 
 There are no American or British diplomats in Kabul to answer the allegations because both countries pulled out their embassy staffs before the Soviet troop withdrawal last February. 
 General Ulomi said that as more powerful rockets were provided to the guerrillas, so the Afghan army is extending its security perimeter around the city. 
 The outer security ring is about 22 miles from the city and this would be extended to about 62 miles as deals are struck with local tribes, he said. 
 The guerrillas still fire rockets from well inside the security perimeter. 
 General Ulomi also accused Britain of sending more Blowpipes to the mujahedin. 
 Last week an Afghan army helicopter crashed between Bagram and Kabul, killing 26 soldiers. 
 The government attributed the crash to a technical fault, but foreign diplomats speculate that the helicopter was shot down by a Blowpipe. 
 Britain first supplied Blowpipes to the guerrillas in 1986 and since then there have been no reports of additional supplies. 
 The combination of Blowpipes and US-supplied Stinger missiles has been effective in the past, because the Blowpipe is best against low-flying aircraft, while the Stingers are best against high-flying aircraft. 
 In a long briefing on the country's military situation, General Ulomi said the Afghan army has proved since the Soviet withdrawal it is too powerful to be defeated and that the military option pursued by Pakistan and the US will fail. 
 He said the military's main task is to keep open main roads and supply routes, and that about 60,000 former guerrillas are acting as pro-government militias, helping the defence forces. 
 &bquo;There will soon be 100,000 such militias, which will mean we have won over two thirds of the opposition,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Another 45,000 guerrillas have secret protocols with us not to fight.&equo; 
 He strongly denied the suggestion that the militias were unruly, and said they were being slowly incorporated into the regular army. 
 He exuded confidence, and even cracked jokes, at what he described as the pitiful state of the mujahedin's strategy conducted by Pakistan. 
 He and his brother, Colonel-General Nurul Haq Ulomi, the governor of Kandahar, play a decisive role in Kabul's military strategy. 
 Asked if the Russians had provided the Afghans with the latest MiG-29s, he said: &bquo;Anything we desire will be given to us but we do not want to escalate the war.&equo; 
 He said the Afghan army had enough ammunition to defeat even a regular army. 
 Pakistani regular army units took part in the summer fighting around Jalalabad, he said, but had moved back, although Pakistani artillery experts, commandos and officers are still fighting with the mujahedin. 
 Pakistan has frequently denied such allegations. 
 TEHRAN &mdash; Afghan mujahedin leaders and delegates from the Soviet Union, Pakistan and Iran began a three-day meeting here yesterday to discuss a future government for Kabul and an end to outside interference in Afghanistan, AFP reports. 
 The Iranian press said a solution to the Afghan war was unlikely. 
 Aquino in favour of US base plebiscite 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Manila 
 A PROPOSAL for a referendum on the future of US military bases in the Philippines has paved the way for the possibility of keeping them there. 
 Opinion polls show that most Filipinos want the bases, which are the biggest employer after the government, to stay. 
 One diplomat said he saw the referendum, proposed by an important ally of President Corazon Aquino, as &bquo;a way to manoeuvre around the Senate block, to isolate the Senate as an elite that is unresponsive to public opinion&equo;. 
 The referendum, put forward by Ramon Mitra, the speaker of the House of Representatives, was backed by Cardinal Jaime Sin. 
 Fifteen members of the 23-member senate, which must ratify any new treaty with a two-thirds majority, want the US bases, which provide 68,000 jobs, out of the country. 
 Mr Mitra said Mrs Aquino &bquo;has agreed to (the referendum) in principle, and most likely she will ask the senators to look at the proposal with an open mind&equo;. 
 But senators opposed to the bases vowed to block its passage, calling it illegal. 
 During a visit to Manila last week, Dan Quayle, the US Vice-President, expressed confidence that Manila and Washington could reach a new agreement. 
 Communists opposed to the bases shot dead two US base employees during his visit. 
 The lease on Clark Air Base and Subic Bay naval base, two of the biggest military facilities in the world and the centre of the United States' military presence in Asia, expires in 1991. 
 Washington and Manila will in December begin discussions on a new lease. 
 Mrs Aquino has said she is &bquo;keeping her options open&equo; on whether to renew the lease, but diplomats say the US is privately confident her administration will agree to a five-to 10-year extension. 
 But they add that Washington knows the Senate will be a difficult obstacle to overcome. 
 Diplomats say the referendum would probably violate the constitution. 
 &bquo;There are hopes that the senate can be out-manoeuvred and forced into reluctant acquiescence,&equo; the diplomat said. 
 Speculators haunt Cambodia's Riviera: Cambodia hopes to restore Kep to its former glory as a holiday resort. 
 But Terry McCarthy sees little immediate prospect of package tours 
 By TERRY MCCARTHY 
 THE SEAFRONT at Kep, on the southern coast of Cambodia, is lined with villas built in the dashing concrete style of the 1950s. 
 During Prince Sihanouk's rule, he and the Phnom Penh aristocracy would drive down to Kep for weekend parties and gambling in the casino. 
 By the early 1970s, the Khmer Rouge controlled the surrounding countryside, and the parties stopped. 
 Since Pol Pot took power in 1975, Kep has been deserted, and the villas stand windowless and empty. 
 The locals say the villas are haunted, but party officials from the provincial capital of Kampot, 15 miles away, have no such fears. 
 In 1987, when hopes of a political settlement in Cambodia were raised, the People's Committee ditched Marx and quickly moved into real estate, buying up all the villas in anticipation of a tourist boom. 
 Sok Hay, the 35-year-old head of propaganda for the Kampot People's Committee, proudly showed the two-storey villa he had bought for 20,000 riels (&pound;65). 
 Today, he could sell it for 300,000 riels, he said. 
 And the tourists have not started coming yet. 
 Even Hun Sen, the Prime Minister, has asked the province committee to find him a village in Kep, according to Mr Sok Hay. 
 This may be difficult, because most of the villas have already been spoken for &mdash; &bquo;except Sihanouk's house. 
 That hasn't been sold&equo;. 
 It stands on a small hill, higher than the other villas, with a private approach road and a large balcony looking out to sea. 
 Whether the government, which is collecting the money from the sale of the villas, was hoping Prince Sihanouk would come back, or whether no one dared to take over the house, Mr Sok Hay would not say. 
 Further down the seafront, past the pedestal on which a statue of a naked woman, now smashed, used to stand, is the domed casino. 
 It is set back from the road with a sweeping drive and an ornamental fish-pond in front, now stagnant. 
 The gaming tables are long gone, and the building is now used as a cattle shelter. 
 The cowherds have covered the walls with graffiti. 
 One grotesque figure with a snarling beast's head and enlarged genitals is captioned &bquo;Pol Pot&equo;. 
 Close by are the old Shell petrol pumps, which became a killing station for the Khmer Rouge. 
 The underground petrol tank was used as a mass grave for the bodies of those judged to be tainted by Western decadence. 
 Human bones and scraps of clothing are still strewn through the undergrowth. 
 Kep is suffering the same fate as the 800-year-old temples of Angkor in the north of Cambodia. 
 The luxuries of the past are being reclaimed by the jungle in both places. 
 But the authorities in Kampot are already dreaming of an influx of tourists, and have ordered the villagers in Kep to start clearing some of the undergrowth from the villas. 
 A travel company from Thailand has contacted the People's Committee about the possibility of bringing in tourists, and the governor of the province, An He, is keen to talk to the few foreigners who pass through about his hypothetical Riviera. 
 But only days before Mr Sok Hay stood in front of his villa speculating on how much his property might be worth in the future, Khmer Rouge guerrillas had ambushed a Phnom Penh army patrol in the hills close by. 
 Unfortunately for the landowning gentry of the Kampot People's Committee, Kep is likely to remain slightly too exotic for package tour operators in the foreseeable future. 
 Cambodian guerrillas raiding from Thailand 
 By TERRY MCCARTHY 
 BANGKOK &mdash; Cambodian guerrillas are staging raids from Thailand on government positions in the northwest of the country but are not trying to hold territory, a guerrilla spokesman said yesterday, Reuter reports. 
 Maen Reuan, a spokesman for the Khmer People's National Liberation Front, said fighters of the non-communist movement killed eight soldiers in attacks on government outposts on Sunday. 
 He said that up to 1,000 guerrillas were trying to rout or encircle government posts to force defenders to flee. 
 The KPNLF, which launched an attack on Saturday, four days after the withdrawal of Vietnamese troops, had given up attempts to occupy the town of Svay Cheak and the capital of Banteay Meanchey province, Sisophon. 
 Crew survives 4 months adrift 
 By TERRY MCCARTHY 
 WELLINGTON (AFP, AP) &mdash; Three New Zealanders and an American given up for dead were found alive yesterday after drifting for four months on an upturned trimaran in the south Pacific. 
 The ordeal ended when they were picked up from Great Barrier Island, 123 days after they had set out from New Zealand. 
 They were thin and weak, but looked surprisingly well. 
 The skipper, John Glennie, said he and his crew members &bquo;needed a miracle, and we got one&equo;. 
 Mr Glennie and the other men, Phillip Hoffman, Rick Hellriegel and Jim Nalepka, were washed ashore on Saturday night, after drifting since 3 June. 
 The men said they had survived by eating seabirds, fish and seaweed, in addition to a limited supply of stores, which included apples and kiwi fruit, mouldy rice, tinned soft drinks and a small amount of fresh water. 
 The four, in their thirties and forties, had set out on board the 43ft Rose Noelle on 1 June for a three-week voyage to Tonga, but were reported overdue on 24 June. 
 An aerial search of the area proved fruitless, and they were presumed dead. 
 Mr Glennie, who designed the trimaran, said it had turned over about 700 nautical miles east of the International Date Line during a gale. 
 They were trapped inside, but were able to cut a hole through the hull. 
 Mr Glennie activated an emergency locator beacon, and they were confident of being rescued within a week. 
 He said there was never a day when he did not believe they would survive. 
 Around the World 
 By BRUCE PALLING 
 Uncle Sam's man in Madrid THE BEST way to become an American ambassador to a Western country is not to be a good diplomat, but merely to contribute hefty sums to the winning presidential candidate. 
 Spaniards are now discovering the rude truth of this following the naming of the Bush administration's ambassadorial choice for Madrid. 
 He is Joseph Zappala, a Florida property developer, who has never been to Spain and perhaps, more to the point, speaks no Spanish. 
 American diplomats were so appalled by Mr Zappala's nomination that they leaked to the Spanish press a copy of the misnamed competence certificate, which is sent to the Senate, which has the final say on ambassadorial posts. 
 Mr Zappala's qualifications, even padded out, only filled three paragraphs. 
 All that could be dredged up was that, apart from owning a property firm, Mr Zappala is also an active member of the Florida Policemen's Athletic League. 
 The second paragraph goes straight to the core: Mr Zappala is a member of the 100 Team of Republicans, who chipped in with more than &dollar;100,000 (&pound;62,000) to elect Mr Bush. 
 The report says &bquo;Mr Zappala's&hellip; experience&hellip; along with his civic activities make him an ideal candidate for the US embassy&equo;. 
 Spaniards and many diplomats may think otherwise. 
 Gentler salute President FW de Klerk's government is very keen to present a modern progressive image, to dispel any nagging doubts the rest of the world may harbour about what a deeply repulsive ideology apartheid really is. 
 In line with this cosmetic policy, out went the sjambok, the rhino-hide whip used by police. 
 As another step in this direction, the South African army is toning down its salute from the existing bellicose method of raising the entire arm above the shoulder. 
 Instead, General Jannie Geldenhuys, head of the armed forces, has decreed that when saluting, soldiers will now raise their right forearm only and touch their eyebrow or cap with the tip of the index finger. 
 The general told a news conference that it had not been copied from the Americans, but because it was an &bquo;easier, natural movement&equo;. 
 Taxing problems The arrest of the former head of the Mexican Treasury's personnel section may go some way to explaining why government departments always appear to be overstaffed, but incapable of offering decent service. 
 Amadeo Franco Perez allegedly spent six years sending himself more than &pound;1.25m of pay cheques for non-existent employees and selling fake tax receipts. 
 He and nine accomplices were said to have hacked into a bank's computer and gained access to the Treasury's accounts. 
 When in Auckland A cultural misunderstanding has led to a young Cook Islander being fined &pound;75 by a New Zealand judge for squeezing the buttocks of two white women in a Wellington street. 
 Auckland District Court heard that the 20-year-old man &bquo;was merely trying to attract their attention, so he could start a conversation&equo; and that such behaviour was perfectly normal on his archipelago. 
 However, the judge said that even though the man promised not to do it again, he found such behaviour extremely offensive and ordered him to give &pound;50 to each of the women. 
 Court faces dilemma of right to life and death 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Washington 
 THE GREAT modern, moral questions of the right to life and the right to death will dominate what may be a landmark session of the US Supreme Court which begins this week. 
 With the political dust not yet settled from a controversial abortion ruling in July, the nine Supreme Court justices must rule in the next nine months on three other attempts by US states to regulate abortion as well as the right of parents to terminate the life of a brain-dead daughter. 
 The cases should provide evidence on the conservative course of a court heavily influenced by appointments made during the Reagan years. 
 But its decisions also have implications for an international debate on the frontiers of medical science, morality, government action and individual privacy. 
 The three abortion cases, which may be reached in December, are unlikely to lead to a clean reversal of Roe v Wade, the 1973 Supreme Court ruling which granted an absolute right to abortion in the first three months of pregnancy and an almost unrestricted right in the next three. 
 On the basis of a 5-4 majority in a Missouri case judged in July, the cases are expected to lead to expansion of the right of individual states to pass laws regulating abortions. 
 Laurence Tribe, Professor of Law at Harvard University, said he thought the session would continue to chip away at the broad right to abortion. 
 &bquo;The court may never say Roe v Wade is overruled, but it is likely to say, &bquo;Roe v Wade&hellip; never heard of it&equo;.' 
 In two cases, involving a Minnesota state law and an Ohio law, the court must decide whether a teenager should inform one or both parents before having an abortion. 
 The Minnesota law, requiring both parents be told, was upheld by a local federal appeals court, since the parents' consent was not required. 
 But another federal appeals court struck down an Ohio law requiring a doctor to inform at least one parent before performing an abortion on a teenager, on grounds that it infringed Roe v Wade. 
 In the third abortion case before the Supreme Court, the state of Illinois is appealing against a federal appeals court decision to quash a law which obliged abortion clinics to be designed and equipped like small hospitals. 
 Perhaps the most emotive case of the Supreme Court's term involves a young Missouri woman kept alive for six years in what doctors call a &bquo;persistent vegetative state&equo;. 
 The Missouri Supreme Court rejected efforts by her parents to allow Mary Beth Cruzan, 32, to be disconnected from her life-support machines. 
 The state court said the state's &bquo;unqualified interest in life&equo; should prevail over their assertion that her right to privacy gave her the right to die gracefully. 
 There is no previous Supreme Court ruling on this subject, although state courts have made conflicting judgments since the 1970s. 
 Race politics prove the wrong card for Giuliani 
 From LEONARD DOYLE in New York 
 THE TACTICS which brought George Bush back from the political dead in last year's presidential election have backfired badly on Rudolph Giuliani, the Republican candidate for mayor of New York. 
 Five weeks before the election, he lags behind his black opponent, David Dinkins, in the polls. 
 Now his campaign is threatening to self-destruct because of a controversy over racial politics involving the comedian Jackie Mason. 
 The Bush campaign used the story of a convicted black murderer and rapist to convince voters that Michael Dukakis was soft on crime &mdash; especially black crime. 
 The Giuliani campaign &mdash; advised by Roger Ailes, the media guru who turned the Bush campaign around &mdash; has been trying to persuade Jewish voters that Mr Dinkins is a clone of Jesse Jackson and no friend of Israel. 
 The racial card has been used to effect in previous New York elections, but in Mr Giuliani's case he is being criticised as an opportunist for his attacks on the city's first black Democratic nominee. 
 The problems began when Mr Mason said that Jewish support for Mr Dinkins was a manifestation of Jewish guilt. 
 &bquo;There is a sick Jewish problem of voting for a black man no matter how unfit he is for the job,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;All you have to do is be black and don't curse the Jews directly, and the Jew will vote for the black in a second. 
 Jews are sick with complexities. 
 They feel guilty for the black predicament, as if the Jews caused it.&equo; 
 Mr Mason resigned as a Giuliani volunteer when the remarks were published in the Village Voice newspaper. 
 Then Newsweek magazine dredged up some remarks which Mr Mason made at a lunch a few weeks earlier. 
 The comedian had described Mr Dinkins as a &bquo;fancy shvartzer with a moustache&equo;, using a derogatory Yiddish term for black servants or employees. 
 To make matters worse, Newsweek said that &bquo;Giuliani joined in the nervous laughter&equo; and made no attempt to rebuke Mr Mason. 
 From extradition chief to lawyer for extraditables 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 THE Colombian drug wars have added a new variation to Washington's &bquo;revolving door&equo; syndrome, whereby former US officials use the knowledge they gained in government for profit on returning to the private sector. 
 It now appears the lawyer representing some of the drug cartel's &bquo;extraditables&equo; once headed the Justice Department's extradition division. 
 Michael Abbell worked at the Justice Department for 17 years until 1984, the last five of them as first the director and later deputy director of the Office of International Affairs. 
 According to Mr Abbell, his case is of interest only because of the nature of his clients. 
 It is a rule of honour in the US legal profession that all criminals equally deserve representation, drug barons included. 
 And, according to Mr Abbell, it is common for US attorneys to use their experience in government once they move to private practice. 
 Yet at the same time as he was representing members of the Cali cartel, Mr Abbell was on Capitol Hill lobbying for changes in the international treaty on extradition which would favour the defendants in such cases. 
 Last month, at the height of terrorist violence in Colombia, he also floated a &bquo;compromise&equo; plan between the US and the cartel leaders, under which the drug lords would stand trial in the US, but return to Colombia to serve their sentences. 
 State Department officials variously described that idea as &bquo;surreal&equo; and &bquo;wacky&equo; last week, rejecting out of hand any negotiations with the cartel. 
 &bquo;The question that has to be put is, do we have a cartel lobbyist in Washington?&equo; said Jack Blum, a former chief investigator for the Senate Foreign Relations sub-committee on terrorism and drugs. 
 But Mr Abbell is adamant that he is doing nothing untoward. 
 When he appeared in a Spanish court as an expert witness concerning US extradition laws for Gilberto Rodriguez Orejuela, otherwise known as &bquo;The Chessplayer&equo;, the prosecutor pilloried him as a turncoat. 
 In Los Angeles, prosecutors yesterday charged four men in connection with the world's largest drugs seizure. 
 The four, believed to be Mexicans and described as major drug dealers, were arrested on Friday after police seized 20 tons of cocaine from a Los Angeles warehouse. 
 &bquo;They are about as large as you get outside Colombia,&equo; said a Los Angeles county district attorney, Ira Reiner. 
 BOGOTA &mdash; The most important drug suspect seized since Colombia began its big crackdown on the cocaine barons six weeks ago will shortly be flown to Bogota to face smuggling charges, authorities said here yesterday, Reuter reports. 
 Evaristo Porras Ardila, linked to the powerful Medellin cocaine cartel, was being held in the south-western city of Pasto after being deported from Ecuador on Sunday night. 
 The authorities said that Mr Porras, who was deported on the grounds of having an expired visa and using falsified documents, had lived in Ecuador under an assumed name since 1987 and ran a Quito company trading in farm machinery, glassware and industrial security equipment. 
 Mr Porras is not on the list of 12 &bquo;most wanted&equo; suspects whose extradition is sought by the US. 
 Bogota's El Tiempo newspaper said Mr Porras was the administrator of the Medellin cartel's operations in southern Colombia, especially its Amazon cocaine laboratories on the borders with Brazil and Peru. 
 President Rodrigo Borja of Ecuador said the decision to extradite Mr Porras was a sign of support for Colombia's crackdown. 
 Moscow reviews aid to Managua 
 From DAVID ADAMS in Managua 
 THE SOVIET Foreign Minister, Eduard Shevardnadze, arrives in Nicaragua today, the highest-ranking Moscow official to visit the country in its 10 years of revolutionary rule. 
 The hastily-arranged visit has been prompted by growing concern in the Soviet Union over the state of economic ties between the two countries. 
 As a by-product of perestroika, Moscow is keen to reduce and restructure its aid to Nicaragua, and to put it on a more commercial footing. 
 Officially, the visit marks the 10th anniversary of diplomatic relations between the two countries. 
 But its last-minute scheduling following disarmament talks in the United States between Mr Shevardnadze and the US Secretary of State, James Baker, suggests a more urgent agenda. 
 During those talks, Mr Shevardnadze said all military aid to Nicaragua has been frozen since the beginning of the year, but that weapons may still be reaching Nicaragua from Cuba. 
 Mr Shevardnadze will be travelling from Managua to Havana tomorrow, where he will meet the Cuban President, Fidel Castro. 
 The Sandinistas recognise that perestroika will bring changes in their relationship with Moscow, which has in recent years been worth around &pound;625m annually, according to European diplomats. 
 &bquo;The USSR has gone through very profound changes and these changes require a reappraisal of our commercial and economic relations,&equo; said President Daniel Ortega. 
 The Sandinistas may also use the visit to discuss US foreign policy in Central America, and the question of whether improved Soviet-US relations could lead to a lifting of the US economic embargo on Nicaragua. 
 Yazov marches into history at the Pentagon 
 By MARC CHAMPION 
 WASHINGTON &mdash; General Dmitri Yazov became the first Soviet defence minister to visit the US yesterday, beginning a week of talks as the guest of his opposite number, Dick Cheney, writes Marc Champion. 
 Mr Cheney greeted General Yazov, who was resplendent in his uniform and military ribbons, and the Soviet ambassador to the US, Yuri Dubinin, in the pouring rain outside the Pentagon. 
 The two men then retired for goodwill talks, which one US official described as &bquo;not negotiations&equo;. 
 General Yazov is expected to meet President George Bush on Friday. 
 Today he is to visit Gettysburg, Pennsylvania, the site in 1863 of the bloodiest battle of the American Civil War. 
 In the afternoon he will go to Capitol Hill for discussions with members of Congress. 
 For the remainder of the week General Yazov will visit army, navy, air force and marine bases in California, Arizona and North Carolina. 
 The tour will include a look at the air force's newest operational bomber, the B-1B, but not the radar-evading B-2, also known as the Stealth bomber. 
 General Yazov is also due to address the Council on Foreign Relations in New York and Washington's National Defence University. 
 The visit completes a number of exchanges which began after General Yazov met the former US Defence Secretary, Frank Carlucci, in Switzerland last year. 
 As a result of that meeting, the first face-to-face talks between senior US and Soviet defence leaders since the Second World War, Mr Carlucci later visited the Soviet Union. 
 The two countries' chiefs of staff, Admiral William Crowe and General Sergei Akhromeyev, have also exchanged visits since then. 
 Admiral Crowe was replaced as chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff on Sunday by General Colin Powell. 
 General Powell was present at the meeting between the two defence ministers yesterday. 
 As Mr Cheney and General Yazov walked down a Pentagon corridor, Mr Cheney stopped General Yazov to point out a display honouring Dwight Eisenhower, who commanded Allied forces in Europe during the Second World War. 
 Blind despair 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 MADRID &mdash; A distraught blind man, Manuel Eulogio Suarez, cornered his three tiny children in their flat in Vigo, north-west Spain and tossed them over the sixth-floor balcony, apparently after a row with his estranged wife. 
 Then he jumped after them, writes Tim McGirk. 
 Mr Suarez, who sold lottery tickets on the street to support his family, died instantly, and so did his two-year-old daughter and his five-year-old son. 
 Another son, six, survived the 70ft push but died in hospital from his injuries. 
 Marcos petition 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 MANILA (AP) &mdash; Ferdinand Marcos' followers petitioned the Philippine Supreme Court to allow the late president's body to be returned from Hawaii, and one of them threatened a huge protest if the tribunal turned them down. 
 Keep it quiet 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 JAKARTA (Reuter) &mdash; Indonesia's President Suharto, who heads the world's largest Muslim nation, told his country's five million Catholics to give a modest welcome to the Pope next week. 
 &bquo;Catholics should not be demonstrative in welcoming the Pope. 
 It is hoped they will be calm,&equo; he said. 
 Proksch caught 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 VIENNA (Reuter) &mdash; Austria's most wanted man, Udo Proksch, a coffee-house owner sought in connection with a &pound;10m shipping insurance swindle, was arrested at Vienna airport. 
 He was carrying a false passport when he arrived from London but was recognised during a routine check. 
 Deaths mar truce 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 COLOMBO (AP) &mdash; Soldiers retaliating for an ambush at Girikola village shot dead six Sinhalese extremists in southern Sri Lanka during a ceasefire due to end today. 
 Some 21 other people were killed in Sri Lanka within 24 hours. 
 Ceasefire offer 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 NEW YORK (Reuter) &mdash; El Salvador's President, Alfredo Cristiani, announced in a speech to the UN that he would make a proposal for a ceasefire in his country's 10-year-old civil war at a meeting with FMLN rebels in two weeks' time. 
 Short stay 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 BANGKOK (Reuter) &mdash; Eduard Ryabtsev, a Soviet political columnist, said the Soviet Union would withdraw from Cam Ranh Bay in Vietnam because the military base cast a shadow on Moscow's policy of promoting peace in the Pacific region. 
 Poll delay 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 KAMPALA (Reuter) &mdash; Uganda's President, Yoweri Museveni, whose government's four-year term ends in four months, wants to extend it by two years to draft a new constitution. 
 Polish message 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 PRAGUE (Reuter) &mdash; The Czechoslovak dissident playwright Vaclav Havel said he had received a message from Poland's Prime Minister, Tadeusz Mazowiecki, that he would work for the release of two Czechoslovak human rights campaigners, Jan Carnogursky and Miroslav Kusy. 
 Opponent seized 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 PANAMA CITY (AP) &mdash; Panamanian police arrested Ricardo Arias Calderon, the Christian Democrat former vice-presidential candidate, and some supporters as they toured remote provinces urging people to boycott the military-controlled government. 
 The military said Mr Arias Calderon and others were later released. 
 Hungary rejects interference 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 BUDAPEST (AFP) &mdash; Hungary rejected calls by Romania for action by Warsaw Pact nations to prevent a Solidarity-led government in Poland from taking office, Geza Kotai, the head of the central committee's international department, said. 
 He said the party told Romania last month it was up to the Poles to choose their future through free elections. 
 Kaifu vows to keep sales tax 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 TOKYO (AP) &mdash; Japan's Prime Minister, Toshiki Kaifu, said his government would strive to restore public trust, but would fight opposition efforts to abolish Japan's new sales tax. 
 &bquo;It is the most urgent task for the cabinet to restore public trust in politics,&equo; he said in his first important policy speech since taking office. 
 &bquo;I am determined to promote political reforms.&equo; 
 Mr Kaifu said he was not considering scrapping the 3 per cent sales tax that contributed to severe election setbacks for his party in July. 
 He said the levy was &bquo;absolutely essential for Japan's future&equo;. 
 De Klerk gives ANC talks the seal of disapproval 
 By CHRISTOPHER GILBERT 
 SECRET talks in London between the African National Congress and a group of liberal Afrikaners, including President FW de Klerk's brother, ended yesterday with the ANC playing down the significance of the event and President de Klerk dissociating himself from it. 
 Thabo Mbeki, the ANC's external relations director, who led the movement's delegation, said in Washington yesterday that the talks were informal. 
 He was swift to deny that the Afrikaners were an official delegation from the Broederbond (Brotherhood), an influential secret society with close links to South Africa's ruling National Party. 
 &bquo;The people that were there were not representing anyone except themselves,&equo; said Mr Mbeki. 
 &bquo;They were not representing the Broederbond, and they were not representing the government.&equo; 
 Another ANC spokesman said: &bquo;It's possible some were members, but this was a meeting with Afrikaner intellectuals, not the Broederbond.&equo; 
 The talks should be seen in the context of previous meetings in recent years between the ANC and Afrikaner verligtes. 
 Although Willem &bquo;Wimpie&equo; de Klerk, the President's brother, was a member of the team, it is not the first time he has met Mr Mbeki. 
 Dr de Klerk, who has acted as an adviser to the anti-apartheid Democratic Party, is known to be close to his brother, but politics is rarely on the agenda when they meet. 
 In a statement issued in Pretoria yesterday, President de Klerk made it clear that the South African government was not involved in the London talks, and disapproved of them. 
 &bquo;The general result of such discussion is that they are exploited by the ANC and others to conceal the true nature of revolutionary organisations,&equo; he said. 
 It is also extremely unlikely that the ANC would ever receive an official Broederbond delegation. 
 &bquo;We've had 20 meetings with Afrikaner intellectuals in recent years, in various places, most of them unpublicised,&equo; the ANC spokesman said. 
 &bquo;This only aroused so much attention because of the press reports that we were meeting the Broederbond.&equo; 
 JOHANNESBURG &mdash; An estimated 25,000 blacks demanded clemency for two condemned African National Congress guerrillas yesterday in the largest protest march ever held in one of South Africa's nominally independent tribal homelands, AP reports. 
 The marchers, most of them schoolchildren, paraded peacefully through the centre of Umtata, capital of Transkei. 
 Some carried ANC flags and displayed placards urging the release of the two, who are on death row in Transkei. 
 They were convicted for a 1986 bombing in which two people were killed at the Wild Coast Sun, a gambling resort overlooking the Indian Ocean. 
 The plane that would not take off without the khat 
 From RICHARD DOWDEN in Djibouti 
 CAPTAIN Mirko Pintar stormed out of the cockpit and sat down in a passenger seat. 
 &bquo;I am the pilot, I will not take the responsibility. 
 The plane is overloaded,&equo; he shouted at the ground staff, the colour rising in his face. 
 Overloaded? 
 A DC-9 with 39 passengers? 
 The Air Djibouti flight from Addis Ababa had stopped at Dire Dawa but had picked up no passengers. 
 It had, however, collected eight and a half tons of khat, the mild narcotic leaf on which Djibouti feeds like caterpillars on cabbage. 
 With a street value of &pound;18.50 a kilo, it is more valuable than airline passengers. 
 Eat your hearts out Colombian drug barons, this is legal. 
 The arrival of the flight from Dire Dawa, where the khat is grown, is met by crowds desperate for the leaves. 
 The little country goes into withdrawal if it is delayed. 
 No one would take responsibility for off-loading it, and Captain Pintar and his Yugoslav crew would not fly with it. 
 &bquo;You see that mountain at the end of the runway &mdash; I have to get round that,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If the plane is overloaded and I lose an engine, maybe we don't make it.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Air Djibouti manager is away &mdash; it's not my department. 
 I am just a hireling. 
 I cannot take the decision,&equo; said the man from the airline. 
 &bquo;If we take off the khat&hellip;&equo; said the air hostess, drawing her finger across her throat. 
 A terrible argument ensued, involving the passengers, crew and ground staff. 
 The air was heated with French, Arabic, English and Amharic, Somali and Serbo-Croat. 
 The small khat traders from Djibouti, who travel the route as if it were the local bus, shrieked and angrily rearranged their shawls and robes. 
 Their brows were fierce and their teeth flashed gold every time they shouted. 
 The Austrian Ambassador tried to make peace. 
 A Kenyan chartered accountant threatened to sue for loss of business. 
 A senior Ethiopian civil servant said he would stay in Dire Dawa, for a week if necessary, rather than fly on an overloaded plane, a sentiment we all shared. 
 Everyone discussed the khat trade. 
 Some said the syndicate that runs it is so powerful it can order the airline, and even the government, to do whatever it wants. 
 Someone said it owned the airline and was the government. 
 Despite the ambassador's protest that he would have to present his credentials in his shirt-sleeves the next morning, our baggage was unloaded. 
 Two bulky Somali women were persuaded to stay behind. 
 Captain Pintar did his sums again and agreed to fly, three hours late. 
 As we thundered down the runway, the ambassador asked: &bquo;Do you think they weighed the khat properly?&equo; 'Almost certainly not,&equo; replied the civil servant. 
 &bquo;It won't have been on a weighing machine since it left the village where it was grown.&equo; 
 The plane climbed ponderously but the mountain slid beneath us. 
 There was a round of applause for Captain Pintar. 
 Soviet Union helped the refugees go West 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 THE SOVIET UNION played a key role in the agreement under which thousands of East Germans who had taken refuge in the West German embassies in Prague and Warsaw were allowed to go to the West on Sunday, government officials said yesterday. 
 Eduard Shevardnadze, the Soviet Foreign Minister, worked for a solution in telephone calls with East German, Czechoslovak and Polish leaders, they said. 
 President Gorbachev, with whom Chancellor Helmut Kohl had been in frequent contact, clearly gave his approval. 
 Since the agreement to let the original refugees out had been on a once-only basis, it was not clear what was going to happen to yesterday's 1,000-plus new arrivals in Prague. 
 West German officials said they hoped similar arrangements could be made. 
 But the East Germans, apparently furious at the latest development, accused West Germany of a &bquo;gross breach of trust&equo;. 
 The head of the Bonn Chancellery, Rudolf Seiters, said the West German government had made it clear that it could not make any concessions regarding its embassies in other countries and that no East German would be turned away from any West German mission abroad. 
 Government officials insisted that they were not going to build walls or put up barbed wire round the embassies. 
 When Czechoslovak police sealed off the Prague embassy on Sunday, Bonn protested and they left. 
 The first hope of a breakthrough in the saga emerged during a meeting between Mr Shevardnadze and Hans-Dietrich Genscher, the West German Foreign Minister, at the United Nations. 
 The Soviet minister was &bquo;shattered&equo; by Mr Genscher's account of the nightmare conditions in which the refugees were living in Prague and promised to do all he could to help. 
 Even if the Soviet Union is no longer able to give orders, it still has great influence, and Mr Shevardnadze is believed to have used this in calls to Prague, Warsaw and East Berlin. 
 Mr Gorbachev's role is unclear: Hans Klein, the West German government spokesman, would say only that Mr Kohl's last telephone message to the Soviet leader was on Friday, with a reply on Sunday. 
 The final decision, it is believed here, was made by Erich Honecker, the East German leader. 
 West German officials imagine that the Russians were particularly keen for an end to the crisis because President Gorbachev would have disliked attending East Germany's 40th anniversary celebrations on Saturday while this spectacular testimony to his hosts' illiberalism continued. 
 Mr Honecker doubtless also wanted no unpleasantness to cloud the great event. 
 Pressure on East Germany to solve the problem of its fleeing population by reform has redoubled. 
 Chancellor Kohl again urged East Berlin not to isolate itself and to open the way for change. 
 MOSCOW (Reuter) &mdash; Thousands of Soviet citizens crowded outside the American embassy yesterday clamouring for new forms to apply for emigration to the United States. 
 The US Consul General, Max Robinson, said 30,000 forms had been distributed and a further 270,000 would be available within a week. 
 He said the US authorities planned to allocate 50,000 places to refugees from the Soviet Union in the next 12 months. 
 New defeat spells bleak forecast for Kohl and party 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 HOPES THAT Chancellor Kohl's Christian Democrat party can reverse the long downward slide to possible defeat in next year's Bundestag elections have been dashed by its poor showing in Sunday's North Rhine-Westphalia municipal polls. 
 At the same time the success of the West German foreign minister, Hans-Dietrich Genscher, in getting an agreement to bring out the thousands of East Germans from the West German embassies in Prague and Warsaw in the 24 hours before the polls closed boosted the results of his small Free Democrat party. 
 It gained 1.7 per cent to reach 6.5 per cent. 
 The elections, which involved well over a quarter of the electorate, were seen both as a dress rehearsal for the North-Rhine Westphalian Land elections in May next year and as a test of the political mood in the country. 
 The CDU, led by the relatively popular health minister, Norbert Blum, suffered more heavy losses, dropping by 4.7 per cent to hit 37.5 per cent, its worst result in municipal elections for 33 years. 
 The Social Democrats who have ruled the Land for many years, although in opposition in Bonn, emerged strengthened by the CDU's defeat, although their own share of the vote only grew by 0.4 per cent to reach 42.9 per cent. 
 Many of the CDU votes went instead to the ultra right-wing Republicans who polled over seven per cent in the bigger cities with problems of unemployment, the housing shortage and a high percentage of foreign immigrants. 
 The Republicans also picked up an estimated 14,000 votes from the Social Democrats and yet more from people who have not bothered to vote before. 
 The Republicans put up candidates in about half the constituencies and their overall share of the vote stayed low at 2.3 per cent. 
 Hundreds of young people chanting &bquo;Nazis get out&equo; demonstrated in Dortmund, Dusseldorf and other cities in protest against the election of Republican members to the city councils. 
 In Dortmund a 56-year-old man, apparently an even more extreme right-winger, was in a critical condition after being kicked and pelted with bottles by left-wingers. 
 And in Dusseldorf police said a member of the Republican party suffered a heart attack after being beaten up by demonstrators. 
 The Greens remained the third strongest party with 0.2 per cent more than before at 8.3 per cent. 
 Mr Blum tried his supporters saying they had done better than predicted. 
 But it was a bad start for the CDU to the series of eight rounds of municipal or Land elections between now and the Bundestag elections. 
 It showed that despite the Chancellor's unopposed re-election as chairman of his party and his tactical victory over leading rivals, voters are unimpressed with his performance and that of the CDU. 
 A car and a life left on the other side of the fence 
 From EDWARD LUCAS in Prague 
 DIPLOMATIC niceties have been exploited to the utmost during the continuing occupation by would-be East German emigrants of the West German embassy in Prague, where a West German diplomat yesterday intervened dramatically to add to the number of new arrivals inside. 
 An East German &mdash; unwisely, perhaps, in view of the easy access through the front door &mdash; made a desperate bid to scramble over the embassy railings. 
 When he was half-way over, the Czechoslovak police guarding the back of the embassy grabbed the man's belt and began hauling him down. 
 Alerted to the scuffle, East Germans inside the building seized his arms and legs. 
 As more East Germans joined the cries for help, the diplomat burst through the front door and sprinted 300 yards around the embassy perimeter until he reached the grotesque tug-of-war. 
 He leapt into the tussle and embraced the man from behind. 
 The police, on realising that he was a diplomat, drew back. 
 Conferred temporary and somewhat metaphysical diplomatic immunity by the embrace, the would-be emigrant and the diplomat walked, with their arms on each others' shoulders, into the embassy. 
 For many of the East Germans arriving in Prague, there is a unique emotional wrench when the time comes to make their way to the embassy doors. 
 Every one of the scores of abandoned Trabants and Wartburgs which clog the streets around the embassy has been one of the most cherished possessions in its owner's life. 
 The price of a car in East Germany can be a significant proportion of a lifetime's earnings, and the wait for the car can last a significant part of that lifetime. 
 The congestion caused by their hurried, and sometimes vengefully random, parking is a source of great aggravation to Prague's citizens, for whom it is a major talking point of the emigration crisis. 
 Although police remove the illegally-parked cars almost as fast as they are abandoned, the local body responsible for administering parking is insisting that someone pay the hefty excess charges incurred by the prolonged presence of other cars in legal spaces. 
 This has not, however, prevented a touching detail in the exodus of the original 4,000 emigres over the weekend. 
 As they left the embassy, those who had arrived in cars were invited to leave their keys, and in return were promised that their vehicles would be brought eventually to the West. 
 Comrade Springer tries to liven up the party 
 From ANNE APPLEBAUM in Lublin 
 &bquo;JUST because I wasn't interned in 1981 doesn't mean I'm not a Polish patriot too,&equo; fumed a member of the Karczmiska Communist party committee. 
 &bquo;We simply went to work like normal citizens during martial law and now it seems that's a crime,&equo; he went on, gesturing at the 20 heads of party factory cells who were gathered to discuss the future of communism in Poland. 
 The meeting was in its third hour. 
 Andrzej Springer, a Central Committee member and the first secretary of the Lublin region, was there. 
 Comrade Springer, as his subordinates addressed him, was collecting &bquo;views and opinions&equo;. 
 According to a recent Politburo dictum, the party will turn itself into a &bquo;left-wing parliamentary party&equo; at its next congress early next year, and the Central Committee members were consulting local leaders about how to do it. 
 Mr Springer held a questionnaire, distributed to all party members. 
 The group was analysing the results, which are to be discussed by a local central committee plenum today. 
 &bquo;A motion has been put forward that the Polish United Workers&equo; Party (the Communist Party) should&hellip; give the right to vote to all of its members. 
 Is the comrade in favour of this solution? (a) yes, (b) no?&equo; 
 The most heated discussion revolved around the question of changing the party's name. 
 One delegate opted for Polish Labour Party because he thought the present name would scare away farmers and intellectuals. 
 &bquo;Maybe people would think we were something like the British Labour Party,&equo; he said hopefully. 
 Another disagreed. 
 &bquo;If we change the name, we show disrespect for all of the good things the party has done for Poland.&equo; 
 Mr Springer then took the floor -for 30 minutes. 
 &bquo;The party must fight for its new image, not only for its own members, but also in front of the whole nation.&equo; 
 He sat down. 
 It was not clear whether he thought the name should be changed or not. 
 The next meeting was in Opole Lubelski. 
 The local party secretary opened the meeting by welcoming the Lublin first secretary, and announcing the presence of a Western journalist. 
 &bquo;Comrade Rakowski (the party leader) set the precedent for this by allowing some foreign journalists into the last meeting of the Central Committee,&equo; he explained nervously. 
 The Opole meeting was dominated by elderly party members, who refused to talk about such problems as names, new programmes, and new membership laws. 
 &bquo;I want to talk about socialism,&equo; said one. 
 &bquo;This new government, what is it doing? 
 Is it realising the socialist ideals that we stood for? 
 Before I joined the party 46 years ago, there wasn't even a paved road from Lublin to Warsaw.&equo; 
 Throughout the day, Mr Springer diligently took notes, nodding when members complained that the Communists had no economic programme to match Solidarity's, and when others questioned the acceptance of privatisation. 
 Later, Mr Springer said he had attended dozens of these meetings in recent weeks all over his district. 
 &bquo;You can see, there are no more hysterical discussions. 
 Now, after three change of government, people are calmly discussing the future.&equo; 
 Is he an optimist? 
 Mr Springer joined the party 25 years ago, and admitted that this era could be the most difficult he had ever lived through. 
 &bquo;But, Madam, I have a university education, and I'm a teacher by profession. 
 I will have no trouble finding something else to do.&equo; 
 ZURICH &mdash; Switzerland was responding to Polish appeals for economic aid by sending five million Swiss francs (&pound;1.9m) of food &mdash; 40 per cent of it wheat bought in Hungary &mdash; the Foreign Ministry said yesterday Reuter reports. 
 Last month President George Bush announced that the US was sending &dollar;100m in food aid to Poland. 
 SPD still fails to ride the wave: Setbacks for Chancellor Kohl and his team have not convinced voters the Social Democrats would do any better, writes John Eisenhammer 
 By JOHN EISENHAMMER 
 MUCH TO their chagrin, the woes of Chancellor Kohl's centre-right coalition have yet to produce a solid wave of support for the Social Democrats. 
 Successive state elections have seen the governing parties pummelled by a dismayed electorate. 
 But the SPD, instead of exuding the sort of assurance suggesting that the general election in December next year belongs to it, struggles to hide its edginess. 
 The party reacted with unnecessary embarrassment and defensiveness to government attacks on general talks it has been holding with the Greens, and its desire, as part of its traditional Ostpolitik, to press on with contacts with the Communist party in East Berlin despite the sudden surge of open opposition to the government by East German citizens. 
 Two impressive victories this year, in Berlin and in Frankfurt, producing municipal coalitions with the Greens, were a fillip for party morale. 
 But at the European elections in June the SPD failed to break through despite heavy CDU losses. 
 The West German electorate lacks confidence in Chancellor Kohl and his team, but has yet to be convinced that the SPD, with whatever future coalition partner it chooses, will do much better. 
 The Social Democrats have come a long way since the early 1980s when, newly tossed into opposition, the party was crippled by defeatism. 
 It is now rushing to finalise a bold programme of reforms. 
 But the emphasis on new priorities is troubling some of its traditional clientele. 
 The change has been striking in two areas, with women's issues and environmental concerns thrust to the head of the party agenda. 
 There has been an influx of women into the party, accompanied by a decision to have equal representation at all levels of the party by the mid-1990s. 
 And the party has been devising an environmentally-friendly economic strategy. 
 Its central theme is to make polluters pay, starting with a proposed 30 per cent rise in the price of petrol. 
 &bquo;We are getting away from the labour party for industrial workers,&equo; says Walter Momper, the SPD mayor of Berlin and one of the new generation of leaders. 
 &bquo;We are strong now on women's rights, the environment and disarmament.&equo; 
 This sort of language dismays the traditional ranks of SPD supporters, especially the big trade unions, who fear their voice within the party is being muffled. 
 It has not always been easy for those working class voters who see the Greens as an undisciplined bunch, inimical to the interests of industrial society, to keep up with the SPD's enthusiastic appetite for environmental matters. 
 There has been a noticeable shift of working class support from the SPD to the far-right Republicans &mdash; not as much as the losses from the Christian Democrats, but enough to worry party managers. 
 &bquo;The differences in our electorate are much bigger than for the conservative parties,&equo; says Heidi Wieczorek-Zeul, a member of the party praesidium. 
 &bquo;Tactically to combine the interests of a miner and an environmentalist just does not work. 
 It can only be done with conviction, with the sort of approach we used in 1969 with Ostpolitik. 
 Today, ecological and women's issues are the equivalent of Ostpolitik for us.&equo; 
 The party leader, Hans-Jochen Vogel, a rather uninspiring figure, has nonetheless proved adept at managing this delicate evolution which, bolder than anything the Labour party ever contemplated, has avoided the sort of fratricidal bloodletting which ravaged its British counterpart. 
 The traditionalist camp has had to swallow some bitter pills. 
 Oskar Lafontaine, the SPD leader in the Saarland, has argued vociferously that a modern mass party like the SPD could not afford to have its policies confined to the narrow interests of employed industrial workers. 
 In the party's new programme, the trade unions have had to backtrack on their central demand, now accepting that a shorter working week will mean reduced wages. 
 But Mr Lafontaine, standard-bearer of the up-and-coming generation, and the second most important figure after Mr Vogel on the committee drafting the party programme for the next decade, has certainly not had things all his own way. 
 His attempts to link reductions in working hours to more flexible work practices, for example, have run into powerful union resistance. 
 The SPD's candidate for Chancellor seems to be narrowing to a choice between Mr Vogel and Mr Lafontaine, between a cautious compromiser and an erratic reformer. 
 The party is far from sure which message it wants to send to voters, and is likely to leave the choice until the last minute. 
 Neither of these two men can control with any certainty, however, the factor that will perhaps exert the most influence on the SPD's election chances. 
 Whether the party likes it or not, its fortunes are hostage to the still youthful coalitions in Frankfurt and Berlin, and their notoriously unpredictable Green allies. 
 If these coalitions fall apart, as an earlier version did in Hesse in 1987 amid much rancour, the repercussions could be disastrous, with the Christian Democrats poised to exploit any hint of &bquo;red-green chaos&equo;. 
 &bquo;If we are not successful in Berlin, then the chances of a red-green coaliion in Bonn are gone for five to ten years,&equo; says Walter Momper. 
 &bquo;If it works, it will be a model for government whether the SPD likes it or not.&equo; 
 Court Circular 
 By JOHN EISENHAMMER 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 29 September: The Duke of York, Colonel-in-Chief of The Staffordshire Regiment (The Prince of Wales's) this evening received Lieutenant-Colonel NHC Brown upon relinquishing his appointment as Commanding Officer of the 1st Battalion and Lieutenant-Colonel CT Rogers upon assuming the appointment. 
 2 October: The Princess Royal this morning opened Hassy Carrot Growers' new Carrot Complex at Whitehall Farm, Isleham, and was received on arrival by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Cambridgeshire (Mr Michael Bevan). 
 Her Royal Highness subsequently visited Lincolnshire and was received on arrival by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Lincolnshire (Captain Henry Nevile). 
 The Princess Royal opened the new George Adams &amp; Sons Factory at Spalding. 
 Afterwards Her Royal Highness visited the Recording Studios of the National Tape Magazine for the Blind, Lilac Cottage, New Bolingbroke. 
 In the afternoon Her Royal Highness, President of the National Agricultural Centre Rural Trust, opened a new Housing Development at Mareham Le Fen. 
 The Princess then opened the extension to Kirkby on Bain Church of England Primary School. 
 Her Royal Highess travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 Mrs Richard Carew Pole was in attendance. 
 The Princess Royal, Patron, College of Occupational Therapists, this evening attended a Reception and Dinner at St James's Palace and was received on arrival by the President of the College of Occupational Therapists (the Right Hon Lord Ennals of Norwich). 
 Mrs Malcolm Wallace was in attendance. 
 Mrs James Lonsdale and Lieutenant-Commander Patrick Jephson RN were in attendance. 
 YORK HOUSE 2 October: The Duke of Kent, as Vice Chairman of the British Overseas Trade Board, today left Royal Air Force Northolt for a visit to Sweden and Finland. 
 His Royal Highness, who travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight, is attended by Mr Andrew Palmer. 
 The Duchess of Kent, as Patron, this morning attended the launch of Cancer Relief Macmillan Fund's leaflet &bquo;Help is There&equo; at London Weekend Television, South Bank Television Centre, London SE1. 
 Her Royal Highness was attended by Miss Sarah Partridge. 
 THATCHED HOUSE LODGE 2 October: Princess Alexandra and Sir Angus Ogilvy were present this evening at a Reception given by the Prime Minister and Mr Denis Thatcher at 10 Downing Street to launch the Harold Macmillan Trust. 
 The Lady Mary Mumford was in attendance. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Princess of Wales, President, Wales Craft Council, presents prizes to the winners of the Council's Daffodil Design Competition at West Glamorgan County Hall, Swansea; and, this evening, as Patron, Swansea Festival of Music and the Arts, attends a concert to be given by the London Philharmonic Orchestra in the Brangwyn Hall, Swansea. 
 The Princess Royal, President, Save the Children Fund, visits the Save the Children Fund Shop at 104 High Street, Orpington, Kent; opens and tours the new Head Office Building of the Woolwich Equitable Building Society, Watling Street, Bexleyheath, Kent, and receives a cheque from the employees for the Save the Children Fund; as Chancellor, London University, visits the Institute of Zoology, London Zoo, Regent's Park, in celebration of the accession of the Institute of Zoology of the Royal Zoological Society to the University of London; and, this evening, as Patron, The British Nutrition Foundation, attends a dinner at the Natural History Museum, South Kensington, London SW7. 
 Princess Alexandra attends a Service being held in Westminster Abbey to celebrate The Revised English Bible. 
 Anniversaries 
 By JOHN EISENHAMMER 
 On this day: the Kingdom of Serbs, Croats and Slovenes was renamed Yugoslavia, 1929; the first British atomic device was exploded in the Monte Bello islands in the Pacific, 1952; the Bolshoi Ballet appeared at Covent Garden for the first time, 1956. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 16 
 Obituary: Manuel Clouthier 
 By CHRIS MCGREAL 
 MANUEL CLOUTHIER, last year's presidential candidate for Mexico's conservative National Action Party (PAN), made civil disobedience a by-word of his short political career. 
 The heavily-built millionaire businessman, commonly known by his childhood nickname &bquo;Maquio&equo;, helped put conservative thought back into Mexican politics after he entered the fray outraged at the nationalisation of the banks in 1982. 
 His anger set the tone for his aggressive campaigns against the ruling Institutional Revolutionary Party (PRI) 's long history of corruption and election fraud. 
 PAN members chose him as their presidential candidate because privately he scorned his party's old and, as he saw it, timid leadership almost as much as he scorned the PRI. 
 The white-bearded campaigner prided himself on blunt, outspoken views. 
 Despite his lack of political experience, Clouthier's 20-year leadership of business organisations stood him in good stead. 
 After the banks' nationalisation he sold most of his interests in the dozen or so companies he had created and drawn his wealth from, and committed himself to combating the existing political system. 
 He quickly established himself within the PAN, challenging its professional politicians with the support of his business colleagues and unifying the fractious party. 
 He took conservative ideas on privatisation and land reform, gave them a populist anti-government bent and managed to woo over many poorer voters - especially in northern Mexico &mdash; who previously feared that the PAN represented only business interests. 
 He promised to demystify the all-powerful presidency and make it more accountable to congress and the voter. 
 Clouthier's policies were frequently ill-defined but they nevertheless brought back into the political debate conservative ideas that had been scorned since the 1917 Mexican revolution. 
 At times his language turned crude and made him look foolish. 
 Some of his tactics were similarly frowned upon. 
 During one of his many civil disobedience campaigns, which ranged from non-payment of taxes to blocking border posts into the US, he led a hunger strike in protest at alleged vote rigging in the presidential race. 
 But few people took seriously the idea of such a hulk of a man going without food. 
 When he called off his fast a week later, a pro-government newspaper headlined its story &bquo;Maquio ends his diet&equo;. 
 Shortly afterwards Clouthier suffered a heart attack. 
 He was popular as a man of the people who toured Mexico with his wife and 10 children in a mobile home during the presidential campaign, a very different strategy from the typically aloof approach of the PAN's other wealthy and middle-class leaders. 
 His blustery manner brought out large crowds despite frequent government attempts to intimidate rural populations into staying away. 
 Ultimately Clouthier's campaign fell victim to the rise of the left and the governing party's shift to the right. 
 Clouthier pulled in 17 per cent of the vote, falling into third place. 
 Many of the PAN's traditional supporters appeared to abandon the party to support Salinas for fear the left might win. 
 President Carlos Salinas de Gortari's policies reflect the Clouthier manifesto, especially on privatisation. 
 Similarly the many Mexicans looking simply to cast an anti-government vote supported the left, which stood a greater chance of winning and emerged in second place amid evidence of substantial fraud by the government. 
 But Clouthier remained at the centre stage of Mexican politics, as the most visible leader of the PAN. 
 In July he saw his party make history when it won the first governorship conceded by the ruling party in 60 years. 
 Clouthier was travelling to a rally for the victorious PAN candidate when he was killed in a car accident. 
 Obituary: Professor Henricus Kuypers 
 By GEORGE GORDON 
 A GENERATION ago mammalian neuroanatomy seemed a scholarly subject, a frame for functional studies but unlikely to provide an impetus for the astonishing advances in understanding of the brain over the last four decades, in which Hans Kuypers became one of the leaders. 
 It cannot be given to many scientists to be outstanding as experimenter, technical innovator and teacher; Kuypers was unquestionably all of these. 
 As a young doctor in Leiden he paid a seminal visit to the neuroanatomist WJH Nauta, at that time developing a revolutionary anatomical technique for investigating the nervous system by staining degenerating fibres cut off from their parent cell-bodies. 
 Kuypers was the first to use this technique in studies of the brain and over the next 10 years, now in the United States, he charted at a new level of detail the connections made by the cerebral cortex with nervous elements in the brain-stem and spinal cord that control movement in a number of higher mammals. 
 Kuypers then started a long series of collaborative studies in which injuries to some of these connections in the monkey's brain were correlated with the defects they produced in performance of movements; the poising of an arm, for instance, to carry out an operation with the fingers could be dissociated from the ability to use the fingers skilfully. 
 These studies continued, with increasing sophistication, after his return to Europe in 1966 as Professor of Anatomy at the new Erasmus University in Rotterdam. 
 He showed that injury to connections within the cerebral cortex could cause the dissociation of hand movements guided by vision from those guided by touch. 
 Separation of the two hemispheres of the brain showed each could only sustain a full range of visual control over the opposite hand. 
 These studies bear directly on defects seen in human disease. 
 His primary insight being anatomical, Kuypers was concerned with increasingly powerful ways of tracing fibre connections. 
 He was among the first to exploit the fact that living nerve fibres pick up and transport protein molecules like the enzyme horseradish peroxidase, whose presence is easily demonstrated and so acts as a marker. 
 In a similar way, he developed a totally new technique for studying branching fibres by using pairs of fluorescent dyes, with the potential for being picked up by separate branches. 
 In his last few years Kuypers and Gabriella Ugolini made use of viruses which travel into the nervous system and multiply in a pathway so that they cross nervous junctions and spread detectably along a whole connected system: a quite novel labelling technique whose full potential now remains to be realised. 
 In 1984 Kuypers accepted the chair of Anatomy at Cambridge. 
 He was nearing 60, with warnings of ill health, but immediately undertook with his departmental colleagues an imaginative restructuring of anatomical teaching, introducing new techniques and persuading the university to fund new posts. 
 He was himself a greatly talented teacher, a master of clear explanation and a fine blackboard artist. 
 He also had a feeling for phrase and idiom and a very personal way with English, all of which endeared him to his audience. 
 I recall a Saturday midday lecture to Oxford undergraduate and graduate students in the 1970s when, after riveting them with a talk about double fluorescent labelling, he asked if they would be interested in hearing about experiments on motor systems; they said they would and they abandoned lunch to listen. 
 Hans Kuypers thrived on communication with other scientists. 
 On his return to Europe he missed the wide forum he had experienced in America, and was instrumental in founding two European neuroscience societies, at whose meetings he was constantly receptive to new ideas. 
 A vigorous and sociable man, he attracted loyalty and friendship. 
 He was a man with whom, often far into the night, I have had the most challenging and memorable scientific discussions of my life. 
 He disliked long-term plans. 
 He was a scientific adventurer, for whom every discovery revealed immediate new possibilities; and he saw no end to his work. 
 Obituary: Professor Roger Howell 
 By DAVID UNDERDOWN 
 THE AMERICAN liberal arts colleges &mdash; small, intimate, of high quality academically and often capable of inspiring deep devotion in their graduates -have no real counterpart in Britain. 
 Their very excellence makes heavy demands on the time and energy of their teaching faculty, so people who stay long in such places rarely produce the books and articles commonly published by their counterparts in bigger universities, and are therefore often little known outside their own institutions. 
 Roger Howell was an exception: for many years a professor at Bowdoin College in Maine, he was also an historian with a considerable reputation, and many friends, in Britain. 
 Howell was unusual not only in combining attachment to a small college with a distinguished scholarly career, but also in his success in continuing that career even while president of the college. 
 Throughout his life he had an enthusiastic curiosity about British history and culture. 
 He came to England as a Rhodes Scholar in 1958, and after a year of teaching at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore he returned to Oxford for three years in the early 1960s as research fellow and junior dean at St John's College. 
 His first book, Newcastle-upon-Tyne and the Puritan Revolution (1967), quickly established him as an important contributor to seventeenth-century studies, and put him in the forefront of the group of scholars who were beginning the process of reinterpreting the English Revolution of the 1640s at the grass roots. 
 Among a number of significant later works were biographies of Sir Philip Sidney and Oliver Cromwell, as well as a long list of stimulating articles, essays and reviews. 
 Howell was a Fellow of the Royal Historical Society, and he gave unstinting service to the promotion of the study of British history in the United States. 
 He edited a new journal, the British Studies Monitor, and was an active figure in the New England Historical Association, the North American Conference on British Studies, and other professional societies. 
 This was one side of Roger Howell. 
 But there was another side, marked by loyalty to the college which he had attended as an undergraduate (he received his BA from Bowdoin in 1958) and whose history faculty he joined after his return from Oxford. 
 In 1969, at the early age of 32, he became president of Bowdoin. 
 It was a turbulent time for college principals, and many were unable to cope with the urgent demands for change which constantly assailed them &mdash; not least from their own undergraduates. 
 Howell rose to the occasion and during the following nine years Bowdoin was transformed: among other changes, women were admitted for the first time, and hitherto neglected subjects like Afro-American studies added to the curriculum. 
 He also did what any American college president is expected to do &mdash; he raised money, leaving the college on a sounder footing, both financially and academically, than it had been when he took office. 
 Attempts to lure Howell away from Bowdoin to larger and better-known institutions all foundered on his love for the college and for the state which had adopted him. 
 Obituary: Superintendent Mhoira Robertson 
 By JOAN BURNIE 
 HIGH-RANKING women police officers, even in the 1980s, are fairly unusual anywhere in the UK. 
 But senior women officers in Scotland are very rare indeed. 
 For the Scots do not like their women tough and authoritarian. 
 And Scottish policemen do not like women much at all. 
 So for Mhoira Robertson to achieve the rank of superintendent while still in her early forties was as surprising and, to some of her colleagues, as unwelcome as female preachers were to Dr Johnson. 
 Robertson recognised that women in her profession must be twice as good as men to progess as far in their work. 
 And progress she did, by application to her duties. 
 Mhoira Robertson was always ambitious and passed the sergeants' examination at 24. 
 But the police force she joined in 1963 was a very different and difficult place in which to be ambitious. 
 Not only did women earn less than male officers but they were kept to shoplifting, domestic violence, child cruelty and sexual crime. 
 All of it important and worthwhile work but not giving the breadth of experience which is necessary for promotion into the higher grades. 
 But the Equal Pay and Opportunities Acts, introduced in Scotland in 1975, changed all that. 
 Or were meant to. 
 Above the rank of inspector, promotion is a matter of performance and most tellingly, other senior (male) officers' assessment. 
 There were times, as Mhoira once wryly remarked, when she wished she could join the Masons or even use the gents' lavatory. 
 Mhoira Robertson did take up golf, which became her favourite pastime, and eventually the promotions came, first as Director of studies and Chief Inspector at Tulliallan Police College and finally in 1987 as Superintendent within the Lothians and Borders force. 
 Mhoira hugely enjoyed being one of only two women to reach this rank in Scotland. 
 It was as well that she did because she had forfeited most of her private life for the sake of her chosen career. 
 Not that she would have seen it as any sacrifice that she had neither husband nor child. 
 Especially the former. 
 Having worked with too many men for too long, she confessed to having found them out only too soon. 
 But there were times when the superintendent's hat sat a trifle uneasily on the severe grey-haired head. 
 Superintendent Robertson did not care about the mutterings from the lower ranks against her strict disciplinarian attitude. 
 Particularly towards the proper wearing of uniforms. 
 In fact she agreed cheerfully that she liked to see the whites of the eyes of any constable stupid enough to encounter her with tie undone or shirt unbuttoned. 
 Nor did she worry overmuch that she had a reputation for being harder on women officers than men. 
 In her opinion it was necessary if they were to have any hope of advancement. 
 However Mhoira Robertson did accept that the rank cut her off from any real intimacy with ordinary people who were in awe of her power. 
 At the same time she knew that her gender isolated her from the ritualised socialising of other senior officers. 
 You could never, as she said, pretend to be one of the boys in a skirt. 
 But Mhoira, in and out of the uniform she wore with such pride, was equal to any of them. 
 Obituary: Gordon Hargreaves 
 By PATRICIA INGLETON and JOHN BALL 
 GORDON HARGREAVES was a man of strikingly diverse interests and achievements and an engaging and well-loved character in London's academic, musical and artistic life. 
 Born in 1930 in Southport, he was schooled in his home town before studying chemistry at Liverpool University. 
 After a few years in atomic energy research he then discovered his vocation as teacher and enthusiast as a lecturer in chemistry at Birkenhead Technical College, where he also voluntarily taught about theatre, literature and music in a humanities section. 
 At this time he published his widely used text-book Elementary Chemical Thermodynamics, which was translated into several languages. 
 Hargreaves returned to research in 1965 as Senior Experimental Officer in the Sheffield University zoology department, where he gained his PhD. 
 He was vital to much of the department's internationally distinguished research in comparative endocrinology, assaying minuscule levels of hormones in experimental animals by physico-chemical techniques. 
 Even this demanding job left energy for much else, and at this time he began to organise art exhibitions, building on his own strong interest in the visual arts which had been fired by visits to Florence and Venice and by the mammoth Van Gogh show in the 1950s, and which led early to his abiding love of the Italian Renaissance giants and of such British artists as Prunella Clough, Keith Vaughan and RobertMedley. 
 Hargreaves mounted each year a series of exhibitions, mainly of young artists, but also including two important shows by Clough and Vaughan. 
 These exhibitions became central to Sheffield's cultural life, and were the turning-points in the careers of several young artists. 
 To his professional duties he had added the role of Departmental Safety Officer, and it was this experience which took him in 1977 to Imperial College in the new post of College Safety Director. 
 This was a time when the universities were meeting the new challenge of implementing the Health and Safety at Work Act, which was designed for industrial and commercial organisations much less individualistic and varied than academic institutions. 
 The Safety Director's is a delicate job, requiring diplomacy in dealing with academics and researchers traditionally used to autonomy in their laboratories. 
 Very much to the benefit of the college, Hargreaves had the personality and the authority of experience needed to implement the legal requirements in the academic workplace without causing rancour or resentment. 
 Hargreaves continued the Sheffield pattern by mounting exhibitions by young artists in Imperial's Consort Gallery, quality shows that soon attracted a following and that for years formed a regular feature of the London art scene. 
 His advocacy aroused the interests of some of his many friends in the gallery world, bringing several artists to wider notice. 
 Hargreaves was a rich amalgam of natural gifts and sensibilities. 
 His lively and passionate nature, disciplined by a formal scientific training, was expressed creatively in his own paintings, his intense love of music, and in his relationships, personal and professional. 
 He retained his northern direct honesty of judgement, was absolutely without pretence and intolerant of humbug; he could be devastatingly acid in deprecating affectation in others, yet was, in so many ways, unfailingly and practically kind. 
 One of his greatest pleasures came from the landscapes of the Lake District, a life-long source of spiritual renewal. 
 He did not know that in his last months he had developed a fatal heart condition. 
 It seems extraordinarily right that he should have died, suddenly and without struggle, on a lovely day, gazing from the Catbells ridge over Newlands to the Derwent Fells. 
 Obituary: Walter Mimpriss 
 By MARION CROUCHMAN 
 I WAS SAD to hear that &bquo;Gaffer&equo; (Walter Mimpriss) is dead, but sadder still that his obituary (by John MacDougall, 25 September) did not evoke the memory of a tall, lean, gangly man, with bent shoulders, who always looked as if he should have cow-dung on his theatre wellies, writes Marion Crouchman. 
 I remember his telling us how the first time he encountered stress incontinence was as a young boy standing at the foot of the ladder while a little old country woman handed him down apples from the tree. 
 The other story &mdash; perhaps apocryphal &mdash; was supposed to explain why he would never allow us women to assist at operations. 
 It was said that on the first occasion that a female student &bquo;scrubbed&equo; with him he was reaching the end of a long case and held up the piece of cat-gut slung under the ureter (to identify it and keep it safe during the dissection), saying &bquo;Cut!&equo; 
 Instead of cutting the sling, she cut the ureter, and the rest of us were henceforth dismissed as equally brainless. 
 Male chauvinism was rife in medicine in those days, and he is forgiven. 
 Obituaries 
 By MARION CROUCHMAN 
 Archbishop David Penman of Melbourne, died Melbourne 1 October aged 53. 
 One of the new generation of non-English church leaders in Australia, he led the campaign for Anglican women priests, and planned to ordain the first in Melbourne next year. 
 He was ordained in 1961 and appointed Archbishop in 1984. 
 John Bright, scriptwriter, died Los Angeles 14 September aged 81. 
 Wrote screenplay for The Public Enemy, based on his own novel Blood and Beer, including the scene where the character played by James Cagney pushes a grapefruit into the face of his girlfriend. 
 He was one of the co-founders of the Screenwriters' Guild in 1933. 
 Health: Lively young woman seeks normal life: Elaine Heath, who is severely paralysed, tells Cherrill Hicks of the daily constraints she faces 
 By CHERRILL HICKS 
 ELAINE HEATH likes pink eye glitter and a vodka and orange before lunch. 
 She reads Lenin, Lawrence and supports CND. 
 Elaine is also severely disabled by cerebral palsy: she can use neither her arms nor legs, and she can only communicate by making noises, or by operating an electric typewriter with her nose. 
 In spite of her disability, Elaine has in the past led a remarkably active and normal life. 
 She has been through a marriage, a divorce, and a serious love affair; learnt Russian, written regularly for a local paper and taught a young child disabled by a stroke to read again. 
 But Elaine no longer has a close relationship to give her the support she needs. 
 Without it, she has become a virtual prisoner in her own home; she is ruled by the clock and the hours worked by her local authority helpers. 
 Unable to go away for weekends or holidays, she never goes out at night to dinner parties, discos or evening classes. 
 Her life has become intolerable, she says, ever since she became a social services &bquo;project&equo;. 
 In the mornings Elaine cannot get up before 9am &mdash; which is when her care assistant starts work. 
 In the afternoons, she must always be home at 4.30 &mdash; so that the carer can take her to the lavatory before leaving for the day. 
 (Even her bladder has to be regulated, she points out.) 
 In the early evening, almost as soon as she finishes her meal, it is time to have her make-up taken off and her nightdress put on &mdash; before the nurse leaves. 
 Elaine is excited that a reporter from The Independent is visiting. 
 She laughs, shouts, refuses to give her age and is impatient to explain her problems. 
 It takes time and effort for her to do this: constantly tapping her nose on the typewriter is exhausting, but then so is making her noises understood. 
 We manage, with the help of Sylvia, her care assistant. 
 Elaine gets a lot more help than many disabled people, and some would say she is lucky not to be in residential care. 
 She lives in a large, sunny and specially adapted local authority bungalow in Northampton: the walls of the living room are decorated with her paintings (done when she still had some use of her right hand) and her kitchen cupboard is covered with postcards, love letters from old boyfriends and local newspaper articles. 
 Sylvia comes from nine to five each weekday, and nurses are on duty between six and 10 every evening and for a few hours at the weekend. 
 But Elaine says that despite this help, she might as well be in an institution. 
 Her life is a monotonous routine. 
 As long as she is &bquo;fed and watered&equo;, she writes, the local authority is satisfied: &bquo;It has forgotten about the quality of my life.&equo; 
 Unlike other single women, Elaine cannot stay out late at night: she has to be home in time to be put to bed by a nurse. 
 She can never go out and meet men; and, after two close relationships, the prospect of staying single depresses her. 
 &bquo;I desperately want to love and be loved,&equo; she types with her nose. 
 &bquo;I'm terrified of growing old alone. 
 Life is for sharing.&equo; 
 Sylvia is one of the few people who has learnt to interpret Elaine's noises. 
 She has never cared for a disabled person before, but there is a natural love and empathy between them: she hugs Elaine a lot and they are very close. 
 &bquo;My old mum,&equo; Elaine calls her. 
 &bquo;I would describe Elaine as beautiful with sexy legs,&equo; jokes Sylvia. 
 And, more seriously: &bquo;I try to do things the way she wants. 
 Staff who have worked in the homes become institutionalised; they say this is the way we've always done it. 
 But if you employ someone in your house, you want them to do it your way, not theirs.&equo; 
 The nurses who come in the evenings and at weekends are from an agency - which can mean, for Elaine, a new face every night of the week. 
 Every new nurse needs detailed instructions about how to care for her &mdash; down to details such as pulling her bra on properly and making sure she is dry before getting her dressed. 
 &bquo;Please treat me normally. 
 I'm not daft. 
 My brain is perfectly unimpaired,&equo; writes Elaine at the end of her list. 
 The nurses are nice, well-intentioned young girls who do their best. 
 But because they have to leave by 10pm, all they have time for are the basic tasks, such as cooking dinner, feeding Elaine, taking off her make-up and getting her ready for bed. 
 Many of them are not used to disabled people, and, being temporary, they rarely get to know her anyway. 
 &bquo;Elaine can't talk and that can be very disconcerting for the nurses,&equo; says Sylvia. 
 Elaine interrupts. 
 She does not need nurses in uniform, she almost shouts: just because she is disabled, it does not mean she is medically ill. 
 There is no conversation with the nurses, she says. 
 &bquo;My day ends at five. 
 The shutters come down.&equo; 
 When they leave, Elaine has no professional support until Sylvia comes in the morning. 
 But for the help of a friend who sleeps in the bungalow at night, and who can help her go to the toilet if she needs to, she says she would have to go into a home. 
 Elaine went into a home last week when Sylvia was on holiday. 
 She says she would rather die than do that again. 
 She may not have any speech, but she has no problems in making her feelings clear: she wails at the memory. 
 Sylvia translates her noises: &bquo;It was hell on earth.&equo; 
 The home had set times for the toilet: 9am, 3pm, and 9pm. 
 &bquo;They had their own routine,&equo; says Sylvia. 
 Life hasn't always been so dull for Elaine: she has managed, in the past, to survive the same upheavals as many able-bodied people. 
 Sent away to boarding school when she was six (she rarely sees her family now), she got three A- levels at college and shortly after got married: a mistake, she now realises, but she was pregnant at the time. 
 She lost the baby and she and her husband divorced three years later. 
 It was then that she met &bquo;the love of my life&equo;: he answered an ad she placed in the local paper for someone to read to her. 
 &bquo;He was a middle-aged guy who thought he was coming to read to a sweet old lady,&equo; she writes. 
 They fell in love; eventually he moved in. 
 &bquo;My life was a dream.&equo; 
 The relationship ended after five years: her lover grew too tired to cope with caring for her. 
 He lives in the same town and it still hurts her to see him. 
 For a while Elaine was cared for by young volunteers who used to come and stay with her for a few months at a time. 
 But the volunteers moved on &mdash; to college or jobs &mdash; and she found the change unsettling. 
 In 1986 she contacted her local authority for help; it was then, she says, that her life changed for the worse. 
 Northampton social services department says the problem is one of finding and hiring the right quality people. 
 &bquo;Northampton is an expanding area and wages for care assistants cannot match those to be found in industry,&equo; says Bill Aitken, the department's operations manager. 
 He is clearly doing his best to make Elaine's life more bearable, to create the schemes and find the care assistants with the commitment needed to befriend her, on the funds available. 
 Elaine desperately wants to be free: free to fall in love, work hard and have fun. 
 All she is asking for, she says, is to live the same kind of life as everyone else. 
 This would only be possible if she had intensive 24-hour cover: if she could employ carers both night and day who could be flexible enough to adapt to her needs rather than vice versa. 
 &bquo;Perhaps I am being selfish,&equo; she writes. 
 &bquo;But my life as it is now isn't worth living. 
 It's a living death. 
 I've already experienced a full life and now it's been taken away.&equo; 
 Elaine is an extraordinary woman: clever, lively and capable of leading a full life. 
 But she is rapidly growing demoralised by her situation and is increasingly disinclined to do very much. 
 She has even given up her beloved Russian, learnt painstakingly with the help of an old Cyrillic typewriter. 
 &bquo;She laughs a lot. 
 She seems like a very happy person,&equo; says Sylvia. 
 &bquo;But it's false &mdash; it hides a lot of sadness.&equo; 
 Health: Faith, courage, will &mdash; and a cancer therapy: The Gerson technique ended her marriage and took over her life, but Renee Henry believes it works. 
 Liz Hunt reports 
 By LIZ HUNT 
 RENEE HENRY remembers quite clearly when she decided that she was going to live. 
 It was a warm, sunny afternoon four years ago, and she was lying on her back in the park feeling too weak to move. 
 She could hear her three- year-old son Rufus laughing as he played on the swings nearby. 
 Her other son, Barnes, just six months old, was asleep in the pram beside her. 
 &bquo;The thought of not being there for them as they grew up was too much to bear,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I had to get well.&equo; 
 Renee Henry was a &bquo;rare bird&equo;, according to her surgeon. 
 At the age of 33 she had breast cancer. 
 But in the months following the diagnosis, Mrs Henry found that it was not only a life-threatening disease that she had to contend with. 
 Her decision to refuse orthodox medical treatment and follow an &bquo;alternative&equo; regime &mdash; the Gerson therapy &mdash; provoked outrage and hostility from her husband, her family and her friends. 
 &bquo;At a time when I needed all possible support, I was left alone,&equo; said Mrs Henry. 
 Like most people who are told they have cancer, Renee Henry was, at first, in shock. 
 She didn't think to question the treatment her doctors advocated - as a research biochemist who had worked in the pharmaceutical industry for 10 years, the benefits of modern medicine had been instilled in her. 
 She underwent a lumpectomy and then a course of radiotherapy, and was due to start drug treatment when she met another cancer patient. 
 This woman was 37 years old, and she too had had a lumpectomy and radiotherapy four years earlier. 
 She had taken drugs ever since, but the cancer had returned. 
 &bquo;When I heard that I went straight into the toilet and threw up. 
 She was just like me, she had been told that her prognosis was good and yet here she was four years later. 
 I didn't want to live with cancer hanging over me. 
 I walked out of the hospital and didn't go back.&equo; 
 Mrs Henry found out all she could about alternative cancer treatments and dabbled in some of them. 
 &bquo;At this time, I was living in a sort of Walter Mitty world. 
 I had a husband who was pretending that I did not have cancer, and a mother who tried to inspire me by showing me pictures of Page Three girls under banner headlines of &bquo;How I conquered cancer&equo;. 
 They were both trying to persuade me to continue with the radiotherapy and drugs.&equo; 
 Mrs Henry embarked on a course in herbal medicine and it was during this that she heard about the Gerson therapy. 
 She learnt that it had been developed in the 1920s by a German physician, Dr Max Gerson. 
 He had suffered severe migraine which did not respond to conventional treatment. 
 He had experimented with various foods and found that by restricting his diet to one of fresh fruits and vegetables he could control his migraine. 
 Some of Dr Gerson's patients &mdash; including those with TB &mdash; tried the diet. 
 Their health improved and a cure was claimed in many cases. 
 More patients with various illnesses were put on the diet, and good results were reported. 
 Dr Gerson became convinced that the treatment helped the body to heal itself, regardless of the nature of the disease. 
 This diet now forms the basis of the Gerson Cancer Therapy. 
 It claims to eliminate toxins from the body, to restore a normal potassium and sodium balance in cells (which is thought to be disturbed in cancer patients), to boost liver function (also affected by the disease) and to reactivate certain enzymes. 
 The more Renee Henry learnt about the therapy, the more she became convinced that it was right for her. 
 The therapy is a full-time occupation. 
 It involves taking 13 juices every hour. 
 They are freshly prepared from organic fruit and vegetables and consist of four carrot and apple juices, four green leaf juices, four juices extracted from calves' liver and one orange juice. 
 Oats, salads and baked potatoes form the basis of three daily meals. 
 Caffeine enemas are given four hourly, as well as castor oil &mdash; orally or by enema &mdash; to aid detoxification. 
 At this point, the strain on Renee Henry's marriage became too much, and what had been a troubled relationship crumbled. 
 &bquo;The day my husband left was the day I started Gerson in earnest. 
 I went to a shop that sold organic food and bought everything.&equo; 
 That was the start of the two most demanding years of her life. 
 She had to commit herself totally to the therapy, while looking after two young children. 
 Large quantities of organic food were not easy to come by in Surrey. 
 &bquo;At night I would wrap the children in blankets, put them in the car, and drive down to New Covent Garden to collect the fruit and vegetables.&equo; 
 She suffered chronic diarrhoea and vomiting as, she says, her body started to detoxify itself. 
 &bquo;It was like having a severe bout of food poisoning that never got better,&equo; she recalled. 
 &bquo;I developed chronic asthma and eczema and cold sores. 
 And all the time, I was working away until midnight preparing the juices.&equo; 
 Three months into the therapy she began to suffer severe psychological traumas &mdash; she says she was in a state of constant terror. 
 This is the point at which many patients give up the therapy, said Mrs Henry. 
 But she underwent counselling, and also received support from Sheila McLean, a Gerson therapist and former nurse. 
 Today, Renee Henry is convinced that she is cured and that the Gerson therapy is responsible. 
 She acknowledges that such a claim cannot be substantiated because she also received orthodox medical treatment. 
 She refuses to undergo any medical checks because she &bquo;has no need of further proof&equo;. 
 Mrs Henry's encounter with cancer has, not surprisingly, changed her life. 
 Next week is Europe Against Cancer Week, and she and Sheila Mclean are launching a charity called the Karnak Charitable Trust. 
 It aims to make more information about Gerson available, fund research projects, and eventually it hopes to set up a centre for people who want to try it, in combination with psychological counselling, according to Renee Henry. 
 &bquo;In fighting cancer, the most critical point is when you decide that you are going to survive. 
 You need a focus for that desire to live, so you pick a therapy, orthodox or alternative, and you use it. 
 But the most important thing is to believe that you will survive.&equo; 
 Health Update: Crack connection with Aids 
 By OLIVIA TIMBS 
 THERE is much concern in the US about the addiction to &bquo;crack&equo; (purified cocaine) within inner-city communities. 
 Doctors are worried that women turning to prostitution to finance the habit are at risk of contracting Aids. 
 This problem has spread to the UK. 
 In the past two months, doctors at the Regional Addiction Treatment Unit in Birmingham have come across five patients addicted to crack. 
 Three are prostitutes introduced to the drug by pimps. 
 According to them, crack is widely available in Birmingham and most prostitutes they know use it daily. 
 The doctors point out in the British Medical Journal that, though crack dependency is not a direct risk factor for Aids, prostitutes &bquo;trying to maintain expensive crack habits may be tempted into unsafe sex practices&hellip; which in turn may lead to an increase in the spread of Aids&equo;. 
 Health Update: Zinc deficiency in pregnancy 
 By OLIVIA TIMBS 
 FADS for vitamin supplements have been overtaken by a vogue for minerals and trace elements. 
 Zinc is the latest: lack of it supposedly causes a range of problems, although little scientific evidence supports the link. 
 But some reports have suggested that low zinc levels may lead to problems in pregnancy, from difficult labour to congenital malformations in children. 
 There is stronger evidence that a zinc deficiency may cause the foetus to grow slowly in the womb. 
 Doctors in Bristol decided to test the theory. 
 In a study of nearly 500 women, they found that zinc supplements did not improve either foetal health or reduce the number of pre-term labours. 
 The doctors conclude in the British Medical Journal that there would be little benefit if all women in the UK were given zinc supplements during pregnancy. 
 They recognise, however, that the women in their study were largely middle-class, who might well have sufficiently large zinc stores because they were well nourished. 
 Further studies, the researchers believe, should concentrate on pregnant women known to have a zinc deficiency or to be at risk from problems during labour. 
 Health: Alternative cures &bquo;not proven&equo; 
 By OLIVIA TIMBS 
 RENEE HENRY underwent a lumpectomy and radiotherapy for her breast cancer. 
 Dr Maurice Slevin, a consultant physician at the department of medical oncology at St Bartholomew's Hospital, London, said the chances of a woman being alive and well four years after such treatment were at least 75 per cent. 
 Mrs Henry refused the drug treatment given to reduce the chances of a relapse, but there are many who would remain well without it, Dr Slevin said. 
 Part of the attraction of alternative cancer treatments such as the Gerson therapy is that they allow a patient to feel more in control of the treatment. 
 Dr Slevin agreed that this is often beneficial, but is concerned about other aspects of such therapies. 
 Very few have been evaluated, and the evidence is largely anecdotal, he said. 
 Some of the treatments have dramatic side-effects. 
 &bquo;If they do work, that is wonderful &mdash; but we have no way of knowing for sure. 
 There have been no controlled trials of the Gerson therapy. 
 &bquo;If one of my patients wants to give up a potentially curative treatment in favour of an alternative therapy, then I will try to dissuade them. 
 But it is essentially up to the patient.&equo; 
 He said the NHS should address itself more to the needs of cancer patients so that they do not feel they have to go outside the system. 
 They should be offered relaxation therapy and stress management, and advice on diet and exercise, he said. 
 The Imperial Cancer Research Fund and the Cancer Research Campaign are conducting a joint study of the Bristol Cancer Help Centre, which offers a holistic programme &mdash; dietary advice and emotional counselling &mdash; to complement medical treatment. 
 Law Report: Solicitors' copy of affidavit not covered by privilege: Dubai Bank Ltd v Galadari and others &mdash; Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Dillon, Lord Justice Farquharson and Sir John Megaw), 7 August 1989 
 By YING HUI TAN, Barrister 
 A photocopy of an affidavit in the possession of solicitors was not privileged by the mere fact of its being handed to the solicitors for the purpose of legal advice if the original was not privileged. 
 The Court of Appeal dismissed the first and second defendants' appeal against Mr Justice Vinelott's order that the defendants permit the plaintiff's solicitors to inspect and take copies of an affidavit in the possession of the defendants' solicitors. 
 A former employee of the defendants swore an affidavit relating to his claim against the defendants for wrongful dismissal. 
 The second defendant was sent a photocopy of the affidavit and he sent it to the defendants' solicitors for advice in the context of the wrongful dismissal claim. 
 That claim was then settled. 
 Subsequently, in an unrelated claim by the plaintiff bank against the defendants, the bank sought discovery of the copy of the employee's affidavit in the defendants' solicitors' possession. 
 The defendants objected to disclosure on ground that it was protected by legal professional privilege. 
 Mr Justice Vinelott ordered discovery. 
 Nigel Davis (Norton Rose) for the defendants; John Mowbray QC and Claire Staddon (Lovell White Durrant) for the plaintiff bank. 
 LORD JUSTICE DILLON said that it was not in doubt that if the copy was privileged in relation to the employee's then claims because obtained for the purpose of advice in relation to those claims, it retained its privileged condition in respect of the subsequent claims now being advanced by the bank: Pearce v Foster (1885) 15 QBD 114. 
 The basis of the privilege on grounds of law went back many years. 
 It was for the party refusing to disclose to establish his right to refuse. 
 The onus therefore was on the defendants. 
 Affidavits from the defendants' solicitors established that the photocopy affidavit was supplied to them by the second defendant for the purposes of seeking legal advice in circumstances where litigation was contemplated, but did not indicate whether the photocopy sent was a photocopy which the second defendant made for the purpose of instructing his solicitors or a photocopy which had been sent to the second defendant by the employee himself, prepared for the employee's own purposes which had nothing whatever to do with the defendants obtaining legal advice from their soliticors. 
 On the facts the court had no clear evidence that the copy sent to the defendants' solicitors was made by or on behalf of the second defendant. 
 It could equally well have been a photocopy supplied by the employee. 
 Accordingly, it must follow on the facts that the claim to privilege was not made out. 
 Quite apart from the facts, however, his Lordship found the greatest difficulty in seeing that the claim was made out in law. 
 Pearce v Foster indicated why it was that if the original affidavit or a copy made by the employee had been sent to the solicitors, that would not have been privileged from disclosure by the first and second defendants, although sent to the solicitors for the purpose of advising them on their position against the employee. 
 The document itself was not privileged and to that extent the other side was entitled to see part of the materials with the brief. 
 There were two decisions which were binding where the rule of privilege had been applied to copied documents: The Palermo (1883) 9 PD 6, and Watson v Cammel Laird &amp; Co (Shipbuilders and Engineers) Ltd (1959) 1 WLR 702. 
 The principle indicated in those cases was a long way from the circumstances of the present case and was far from warranting the conclusion that by making a photocopy of a document which in the hands of the maker of the photocopy was not privileged, and then sending the photocopy to a solicitor for the purposes of obtaining advice, privilege was thereby cast on the copy sent to the soicitor. 
 The employee's affidavit was already in existence and the copy when first received by the defendants was not privileged. 
 To produce a further copy, albeit for the purposes of obtaining advice, was closely parallel to obtaining further copies for the purposes of litigation when the original was not privileged, so that Chadwick v Bowman (1886) 16 QBD 561 was closely in point. 
 The difficulty arose in the present case because of the Divisional Court's decision in R v Board of Inland Revenue, Ex parte Goldberg (1989) QB 267. 
 The applicant, a member of the Tax Bar, had been served with notices under the Taxes Management Act 1970 requiring him to produce copies of documents which were in his possession for the purpose of providing legal advice to clients, who had not authorised disclosure. 
 The Divisional Court felt that the copy documents which the solicitor had prepared for counsel were necessarily franked by professional privilege. 
 The solicitor confirmed in his affidavit that he had photocopied the documents which he sent to counsel for the sole purpose of obtaining legal advice from him. 
 The Divisional Court felt that it followed inexorably that privilege must attach to the photocopies made in those circumstances. 
 The circumstances of Goldberg's case and of the present case were distinguishable from those of The Palermo, and of Watson v Cammel Laird in the way indicated in Watson v Cammel Laird when explaining the decision in Chadwick v Bowman. 
 With deference to the Divisional Court and without considering whether its decision could be supported on alternative grounds, his Lordship took the view that the Divisional Court's judgment went too far and did not support the conclusion it reached. 
 Anger over proposal for toll bridge to Skye 
 By MARK DOUGLAS HOME, Scottish Correspondent 
 THE NARROW stretch of sea dividing the island of Skye from the Scottish mainland is embroiled in a debate over private investment in road building. 
 The famous ferry crossing between Kyle of Lochalsh and Kyleakin on Skye attracts enough traffic to justify a bridge. 
 But the Government has said public money will not be available for at least 15 years. 
 It is backing a privately-built toll bridge, the first of its kind in Scotland. 
 The proposal provoked anger on Skye and the mainland. 
 But fresh controversy arose after the Scottish Office said discussions with industry indicated that the tolls would, at most, be no more than ferry fares &mdash; currently &pound;3.80 for a car. 
 The &pound;18m project, including a government offer to pay for approach roads, will be discussed this month by the Highland Regional Council which must decide whether a private toll bridge is better than no bridge at all. 
 Alexander Russell, the council's convener, said: &bquo;It's a Hobson's choice&equo;. 
 But Duncan Grant, councillor for South West Ross which includes Kyle of Lochalsh, said: &bquo;The Government should be forced to change its mind. 
 I don't accept there is no public money. 
 I'm going to be arguing and voting for a no-toll bridge.&equo; 
 The debate about linking Skye and the mainland has continued for 20 years. 
 The latest proposals coincided with yet another summer of delays as tourist traffic queued to go over the sea to Skye. 
 Caledonian MacBrayne, the State-owned ferry company, runs two car ferries on the crossing. 
 They are almost 20 years old and should have been replaced, but the company has accepted that it is unlikely to get government approval for new ferries until the bridge controversy has been resolved. 
 It intends to switch the boats to other routes if the bridge goes ahead. 
 The earliest completion date is 1994. 
 The most likely route is from the Plock of Kyle, west of Kyle of Lochalsh, landing on Skye west of Kyleakin. 
 Despite frequent delays on both sides of the crossing, a Skye lobby still says there should be no bridge. 
 Elizabeth Tolan, who runs a coffee house in Kyleakin with her husband John, said: &bquo;We don't want it. 
 It's going to ruin the village and cut it off completely.&equo; 
 Mike Barlow, who has a tourist business in Kyleakin, opposes the bridge because it would spoil the island's &bquo;magic&equo;. 
 &bquo;Part of the charm is that you cross the sea to Skye.&equo; 
 But Angus McHattie, chairman of the Sleat and Strath branch of the Scottish Crofters Union in south Skye, said: &bquo;Not everybody is in favour of a bridge, but the vast majority are. 
 The general opinion is that a bridge is necessary, though not a toll bridge.&equo; 
 Lord James Douglas-Hamilton MP, Scottish Office environment minister, described the private toll bridge proposal as &bquo;a very practical way forward&equo;. 
 Highland Regional Council had to judge &bquo;the balance of advantage&equo;. 
 In a letter to Brian Wilson MP, Labour's Scottish transport spokesman, Lord James added that the bridge could become toll free in about 15 years. 
 It would be better than the ferries, cost travellers no more and &bquo;would be toll free before it was ever likely to be publicly funded&equo;. 
 Local people and regular travellers would also retain their concessionary fares on the crossing. 
 However, Mr Wilson said that other Scottish bridges, like the one being built at Dornoch, had been publicly-funded. 
 Skye was next on the priority list. 
 He accused Scottish Office ministers of &bquo;doing their bit for the ideological shift on road building in the Department of Transport&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;If they get away with this one it won't be the last.&equo; 
 Private cash to build &bquo;fastlink&equo; 
 By MARK DOUGLAS HOME, Scottish Correspondent 
 PROPOSALS for a &pound;100m, privately financed dual carriageway linking the M8 and M74 motorways in Scotland were unveiled yesterday by the Government. 
 It could be the first modern private toll road north of the border. 
 Lord James Douglas-Hamilton MP, Scottish Office environment minister, said it would be &bquo;additional&equo; to the public road building programme and could start by 1992 or 1993 &mdash; against a delay until the next century if it had to await public funding. 
 He added: &bquo;At this stage I can't give you any indication of what level the toll might be&hellip; it depends on the amount of interest from industry and commerce.&equo; 
 He expected it to become toll free after 15 to 20 years. 
 The project is contained in a Scottish Office consultation document proposing &pound;200m-plus of improvements to the trunk road system south of Edinburgh. 
 It describes the suggested &bquo;fastlink&equo; &mdash; stretching 25 miles from the M8 Edinburgh-Glasgow motorway to the M74 at Douglas in Lanarkshire &mdash; as &bquo;the most important road proposal to emerge from the study&equo;. 
 It adds: &bquo;The viability of this proposal will need to be further explored with the private sector and others as it is too early at this stage to value the commercial opportunities a road might bring for improved coal and mineral extraction, forestry, recreation and other developments to defray construction costs.&equo; 
 However, Lord James seemed in no doubt it would be &bquo;particularly attractive&equo; to private industry and commerce. 
 They had &bquo;called for its development&equo;. 
 The Scottish Office has asked for responses to the consultation document by 27 November. 
 The Government intends to hold a competition for the &bquo;fastlink&equo; road if investors are found. 
 The document also proposes extending the dual carriageway section of the A1 east of Edinburgh to Haddington and, eventually, to Dunbar. 
 Other main proposals concern the two main roads leading from Edinburgh to the Borders, the A7 and A68. 
 The &bquo;most important immediate improvement&equo; for the Borders would be the A68 Dalkeith by-pass. 
 But, longer term, the Scottish Office is proposing to improve either the A68 or A7 to dual carriageway. 
 Accident prevention schemes are also planned and regional councils will be invited to suggest schemes costing up to &pound;1m. 
 The Government has already announced two private toll road proposals in England &mdash; the Birmingham northern relief road and a Birmingham to Manchester road, parallel to the M6. 
 Russia launches space technology sales drive 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 RUSSIA is coming to Britain to sell space technology &mdash; including materials for hip joints, rocket sub-assemblies, superglues and remote sensing data on Earth &mdash; and cash in on what they believe to be a treasure trove of research. 
 A clutch of companies involved in technology from the Soviet space programmes has been given permission for the first time to deal direct with foreigners. 
 The marketing drive is their latest attempt to commercialise space and earn hard currency, Until now any deals have been largely through the Soviet Space Agency, Glvacosmos. 
 Mark Raggett, a businessman spearheading the effort, said: &bquo;If I was to take some of these materials and technologies back to the Soviet Union, I would probably be breaking the law.&equo; 
 Many Western companies, frustrated by restrictions on sales to the eastern bloc, are likely to find the Soviet technology sales drive particularly galling. 
 Last year, the Russians spent 1.3bn roubles on space research for science and economics, but made 2bn roubles in profits. 
 According to Soviet sources, a catalogue of 600 scientific and technical innovations from the space shuttle Buran and the giant rocket booster Energiya have been prepared for exploitation worldwide. 
 Many of these will be unleashed in Britain by Lynmart, a company headed by Mr Raggett, who worked closely with the Russians to set up the British Astronaut Project, JUNO. 
 &bquo;In the past one Soviet space firm was not allowed contact with another, let alone with companies in the West,&equo; he said. 
 The Russians say that work on Energiya and Buran has yielded more than 20 new metals, alloys and materials which can operate in temperatures from minus 253C to 800C. 
 Using anti-friction materials developed for space, excavators can be made to work at very low temperatures without lubrication, while materials developed for Buran are ideal for artificial limbs and, in particular, hip joints. 
 Of great interest, Mr Raggett says, are sophisticated aluminium metal matrices which are lighter than aluminium yet stronger than steel. 
 The Russians are also keen to sell their Earth remote sensing data and sophisticated systems which they claim can improve monitoring of hurricanes. 
 Next year, a technology module will be docked on Mir, the Soviet space station, and used as a futuristic electronics laboratory. 
 In conditions of zero gravity, the Russians will begin experimenting with making semi-conducting materials for electronic chips. 
 Mr Raggett says he is interested in finding industrial partners and financial backing to set up companies to sell and make products under licence in the UK. 
 Bank opens nursery for staff 
 By HELEN HAGUE 
 MIDLAND BANK launches its first nursery today in Sheffield, spearheading a national drive to retain and recruit staff as the jobs market tightens, writes Helen Hague. 
 Up to 300 more are planned over the next four years, under a plan to help parents on the bank's payroll. 
 Midland, whose staff is 56 per cent female, is the first major clearing bank to start a nursery programme: others are expected to follow in the drive to woo mothers back to work. 
 The Sheffield nursery, costing &pound;35 a week for each child, has spaces for 46 children aged between six months and five years. 
 It will be open between 8.15am and 6.15pm, with provision for care outside these hours. 
 Anne Watts, Midland's equal opportunities director, said: &bquo;When a women gives up her job to care for children her employer loses immeasurable training and experience. 
 If industry wants to retain its increasingly-important female workforce, employers must be sympathetic to the needs of women to balance work and family life&equo;. 
 The bank already runs a five-year career-break scheme as part of its equal opportunities policy. 
 Nurses' lobby 
 By HELEN HAGUE 
 The Royal College of Nursing is to lobby Parliament on 24 October in protest at the Government's plans to shake up the National Health Service, the union has announced. 
 The nurses will be joined by Age Concern, Mencap and the Carers' Association. 
 Murder charge 
 By HELEN HAGUE 
 A man has been accused of murdering his wife &mdash; 10 years after her body was found in the Grand Union Canal at Berkhamsted, Hertfordshire. 
 David Lockley, 43, of Sussex Road, Lowestoft, Suffolk, who changed his name by deed poll from John Byatt, was remanded in custody until Friday when he appeared before Hemel Hempstead magistrates charged with killing Mary Angela Byatt in August 1979. 
 Broadlands store plan is rejected 
 By HELEN HAGUE 
 A plan to build a superstore and garden centre at Broadlands in Hampshire, the former home of the late Lord Mountbatten, has been rejected by Chris Patten, the Environment Secretary, overturning a decision of the inquiry inspector. 
 During the inquiry, Lord Romsey promised he would spend &pound;9m on urgent restoration work on his estate, but that the income from visitors to Broadlands was insufficient to carry out the renovations. 
 The Environment Department said yesterday that Mr Patten could not agree with the inquiry inspector's judgement that the needs of the historic house justified the introduction of unacceptable shopping developments in the countryside. 
 Radio 2 chief will play to &bquo;her peers&equo; 
 By MAGGIE BROWN, Media Editor 
 FRANCES LINE was appointed controller of BBC Radio 2 yesterday. 
 Aged 49, married, and living in Croydon and Eastbourne &mdash; &bquo;a lovely place&equo; &mdash; she seems to personify the Radio 2 listener. 
 &bquo;I suppose you could say I am playing to my peers.&equo; 
 The network deliberately woos the over-40s and housewives. 
 The first woman controller of Radio 2 has risen from the BBC typing pool, where she started 32 years ago. 
 The BBC has a much-trumpeted equal opportunities policy. 
 &bquo;But you can't be generous, you have to go for the best person for the job. 
 Through the BBC giving opportunities to women I was there to be chosen.&equo; 
 As head of Radio 2's music department for the last four years, Ms Line has been responsible for the blend of easy listening that makes up 80 per cent of its 24-hours-a-day output, along with presenters such as Derek Jameson and Jimmy Young. 
 Before moving to Radio 2 she was chief assistant at Radio 4, handling schedules. 
 She favours a bit of &bquo;danger and adventure&equo; as far as musical output is concerned. 
 &bquo;I am always sending my producers off to the BBC music library, telling them to seek a breadth of listening: let's be adventurous, dangerous and interesting.&equo; 
 She says the extensive music library represents a unique resource which the BBC can draw on in its forthcoming battle for listeners with new national commercial radio channels. 
 &bquo;We can go from opera, to the Beatles, to a 30s classic, then back to the 60s. 
 Others can't do that: they haven't got the records to choose from.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Deadline for end of nuclear power narrowly rejected 
 By JUDY JONES 
 THE LABOUR leadership won a narrow victory over hard-line opponents of civil nuclear power yesterday when the conference rejected attempts to impose a strict deadline for phasing it out. 
 It accepted the policy review proposals for an open-ended programme of diminishing Britain's reliance on nuclear energy despite demands led by Arthur Scargill, the National Union of Mineworkers' president, for a commitment to complete the process within 15 years. 
 Delegates agreed by 3,243,000 votes to 2,859,000 to throw out the NUM's proposed deadline, which was overwhelmingly supported by last month's TUC, against the wishes of the trade union leadership. 
 Mr Scargill said Labour's commitment to strengthening environmental protection would ring hollow with the electorate without a target date for eliminating nuclear power. 
 &bquo;Nuclear power is not needed. 
 It is 40 per cent more expensive than coal, and there is an abundance of alternative energy sources. 
 If the worst conceivable accident were to occur in Britain at a nuclear power station, one million men, women and children would die. 
 It is a price too high to pay.&equo; 
 Frank Chapman, an executive council member of the EEPTU electricians' union, was hissed and slow-handclapped when he asserted that scaling down nuclear power would put a brake on economic development in third world countries. 
 &bquo;If we abandon nuclear power, we abandon them to competing for declining energy sources at a price they will clearly not be able to afford.&equo; 
 To scoffs of disbelief from some delegates, he asserted that, where managed safely and sensibly, nuclear power was one of the few energy sources which did not pollute the atmosphere. 
 Moreover, to close all nuclear power stations would consign 100,000 workers to the dole queues. 
 But John Evans, for the national executive, insisted that it was unreasonable to tie the party to a strict timetable since scientists and technologists did not yet agree on how nuclear plants could be decommissioned safely. 
 &bquo;For us to promise the removal of nuclear power generation within 15 years would be to delude ourselves and mislead others.&equo; 
 The Labour leadership's alternative strategy for the industry would produce a &bquo;substantial reduction&equo; in nuclear power generation by 2000, he said. 
 Tony Blair, Labour front-bench energy spokesman, said the next Labour government should seek a higher aim than &bquo;meeting some arbitrary timetable&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;For the first time in energy policy history, the environment will govern our energy policy. 
 We will attempt to meet a substantial part of our energy needs from benign, renewable sources of energy.&equo; 
 Anxious to exploit government embarrassment over the delay in its programme for electricity privatisation, he added: &bquo;Energy policy is too critical to the future of this nation to leave to the short-term whims of market forces. 
 We don't want privatisation to be postponed. 
 We want it abandoned.&equo; 
 In the vote on the NUM motion three factors helped to tip the balance in favour of the Labour leadership: the NUM lacked the support it commanded last month at Blackpool from Nalgo, the local government officers' union, since the latter is not affiliated to the party; the pro-nuclear EETPU, absent from Blackpool since its expulsion from the TUC, cast its votes in favour of the leadership's stance; and Ucatt, the construction union, previously in favour of the 15-year deadline, has recently withdrawn its opposition to the policy review plan. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Gould tells of economic plans 
 By JUDY JONES 
 BRITAIN'S projected &pound;20bn trade deficit for this year is the market's &bquo;definitive judgement&equo; on a decade of Tory government, Bryan Gould, Labour's trade and industry spokesman told the conference yesterday, writes Judy Jones. 
 He told delegates: &bquo;After all the Tories have taken, the end result is a country which cannot pay its way, which lives on tick and with the highest interest rates of the advanced world. 
 That is why things have got to change and a Labour government is needed to bring about that change.&equo; 
 Labour would not tolerate the regional imbalances that disfigured the economy, and the waste of resources which had occured under the Tories. 
 Rather, it would intervene where needed and invest in research and development and training, he said. 
 Mr Gould promised the party would restore &bquo;the great utilities&equo; to public ownership and insist on higher standards of regulation than those which had prevailed under the Conservatives. 
 However, the conference overwhelmingly rejected attempts from the left to commit the party to a major extension of public ownership, and to take control of at least one leading company in each of the main manufacturing sectors. 
 Roger Lyons, of MSF, the scientific and manufacturing union, welcomed the leadership strategy for expanding and modernising the manufacturing base. 
 But he warned that correcting the mistakes of the present administration would not be easy. 
 He said: &bquo;Look at the problems 12 years of Tory mismanagement will bequeath to us; a balance of payments deficit financed by hot money, casino-type operation &mdash; money which will fly away at the prospect of a Labour victory.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Policy review &bquo;a symbol of party renewal&equo; 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 LABOUR'S policy review was a symbol of the party renewing itself and becoming again a force for change, Tom Sawyer, deputy general secretary of Nupe, the public sector workers' union, said at the start of four days of debate on the review reports. 
 Mr Sawyer, chairman of the party's home policy committee which co-ordinated the work of the seven policy review groups, insisted there had been no sacrifice of principles. 
 Values and principles did not change, he said, but the times in which they had to be applied did change. 
 There had been changes in technology, in the workforce and in the class system. 
 That was why the party's polices had been reviewed. 
 He attributed recent by-election and European Parliament election success to the review. 
 &bquo;We are 10 points ahead in the polls two years after starting the policy review.&equo; 
 Giving strong backing to participation in the European Community, Mr Sawyer continued: &bquo;We are now Britain's European party. 
 Europe must be a social and environmental Europe, a full-employment Europe, not a Europe divided between rich and poor as Britain is under Mrs Thatcher.&equo; 
 The Tories had promised bigger incomes and delivered bigger debts. 
 Margaret Thatcher had created a &bquo;supermarket society&equo; where the only thing a society needed was a credit card and the only freedoms that mattered were those that could be bought. 
 &bquo;We have the agenda for the Nineties,&equo; Mr Sawyer said. 
 Labour was moving on as a renewed party &mdash; &bquo;a party that cares as much about consumers as it cares about producers; a party that wants to make the economy work as much as it wants to change the economy; a party that embraces as much of the green as it does of the red&equo;. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Voices labouring for a lost cause 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 PENNED-IN by steel barriers between a noisy crowd of gay liberationists and the lonely emissary of the oppressed African Dinkas, few of the street-corner causes besieging this week's conference seem as hopeless as the campaign for Labour to organise in Ulster. 
 About 15 mainly Protestant and professional Belfast-based activists have made the trip to Brighton this year, adding their voices to the clamour as the largely indifferent stream of Labour delegates pours from the conference centre at lunchtime. 
 The speaking invitation to Gerry Adams, the Sinn Fein president and MP for West Belfast, and vague expectations that a Tory Party branch may be recognised in North Down, have provided little encouragement of a parallel shift by Labour. 
 &bquo;It is an absolute bloody shame that the Labour Party won't take this thing seriously,&equo; David Morrison, 45, a systems analyst and secretary of the campaign of 200-300 members, said. 
 &bquo;I don't know why. 
 You will have to ask them &mdash; they won't even talk to us. 
 If we planted a bomb in the conference hall, they would listen to us soon enough.&equo; 
 In the meantime, they were pressing on with the task of handing leaflets to anyone prepared to take one, and taking limited encouragement from the presence of a junior Labour front-bencher, Kate Hoey, at their conference fringe meeting. 
 The party leaders show no sign of relenting. 
 Extending Labour's front into Ulster, they say, would run counter to the policy of reunification of Ireland by consent. 
 There is also a suspicion in some circles that the campaign is to some extent driven by a form of &bquo;closet unionism&equo;; a motive the Belfast campaigners attribute freely to their Tory counterparts. 
 They angrily deny any such hidden agenda in their own ranks, insisting their campaign spans the religious divide and citing non-sectarian politics as the route to breaking down traditional divisions. 
 Mo Mowlam, a Labour Northern Ireland spokeswoman, was prepared to accept their good faith. 
 But she said: &bquo;Because Labour is for a united Ireland, nationalist support would home in on us. 
 Unionists would move towards the Conservative Party, and all we would be doing is providing another cul-de-sac for the people of Northern Ireland.&equo; 
 Outside, the Campaign for Labour Representation in Northern Ireland was already planning to return next year, spending around &pound;250 a head on travel and accommodation and hoping for an unforeseen breakthrough. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Anger as new defence policy is accepted 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 A UNILATERAL move by a Labour government to get rid of nuclear weapons could be reversed by a later administration, Gerald Kaufman, the party's foreign affairs spokesman, argued yesterday as the Brighton conference swung behind a multilateral approach to disarmament. 
 &bquo;I share the objective of all in our party who want a nuclear-free Britain. 
 But I want a Labour Britain to play its full part in bringing about a nuclear-free world,&equo; Mr Kaufman said. 
 The debate on the defence section of the party's policy review report, Britain in the World, brought to a head the anger felt in sections of the party over Neil Kinnock's shift away from unilateralism. 
 Joan Ruddock, former chair of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament and now a member of Labour's front bench team in the Commons, said she and many others were &bquo;deeply saddened&equo; by the change. 
 &bquo;Of course most of us, including myself, will accept the democratic decision. 
 But we cannot change our view that no political system, and no national interest, can justify the threat to devastate this planet. 
 I believe that in time our view will prevail,&equo; Ms Ruddock said. 
 British nuclear weapons were &bquo;a total anachronism&equo; in an era when political reform had swept the Soviet Union and Poland had a non-communist government, she said. 
 &bquo;No responsible leader would press the button and we should have the courage to say so.&equo; 
 Mr Kaufman called in his support the view of Hans-Dietrich Genscher, the German foreign minister, who he said had told the review group in Bonn that &bquo;agreements are better than unilateral moves because they can be verified and cannot be reversed&equo;. 
 &bquo;A move by a Labour government to get rid of nuclear weapons without agreement internationally could be reversed by a non-Labour government for humankind can never unlearn how to make nuclear weapons &mdash; but a nuclear disarmament treaty signed on behalf of Britain by a Labour government could not be reversed.&equo; 
 Mr Kaufman began the debate with a resume of the &bquo;encouraging and exciting&equo; developments of the past year in eastern Europe and disarmament. 
 To assist this process, the review group recommended that in Nato a Labour government would oppose modernisation of short-range nuclear weapons. 
 It should press for Nato to make its objective the removal of all short-range tactical nuclear weapons from Europe &mdash; the third zero option. 
 He said by the time of the next election it would no longer be possible to cancel Trident. 
 Most of the money would have been spent or committed. 
 One of the four subamarines would be complete and construction work well advanced on two others. 
 A Labour government should cancel the fourth and end all British nuclear testing. 
 Supporting the leadership, Garfield Davies, general secretary of the shop workers' union Usdaw, said delegates should not forget the objective was to create a nuclear-free world, not just a nuclear-free Britain. 
 Bruce Kent, chair of CND, was cheered when he declared his belief that nuclear weapons did nothing for Britain's security. 
 &bquo;They are suicidal and nuclear threats by anybody are wicked.&equo; 
 But he maintained that was not the purpose of the composite he moved on behalf of the Tottenham constituency party. 
 It aimed at reducing defence spending to the European average and transfering the savings to the health service, pensions, housing and education. 
 &bquo;If we pass this policy we can save at least &pound;5bn to help to put this country on its feet again and to make decent lives for ordinary people possible,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It is a time of historic opportunity. 
 We do not face outside military threats. 
 We face real threats internationally from pollution, over-population, from famine, from nuclear accidents and from the collapse of an unjust world economic order which means we take more money from the poor than we lend them every year.&equo; 
 Ron Todd, Transport and General Workers' Union general secretary, was applauded as he reaffirmed his union's commitment to unilateralism. 
 &bquo;I am convinced that we need to push the British disarmament boat out from the shore. 
 Once it's properly launched, where everyone can see it, you won't have to worry too much about rocking the boat,&equo; he said. 
 Labour should &bquo;face the challenge&equo; &mdash; the slogan of the policy review &mdash; by carrying out a full-scale programme to implement nuclear disarmament, he told the conference. 
 &bquo;Labour needs to walk tall in a world of challenges. 
 The challenges of hunger, of poverty, of ecological crisis. 
 We can't be credible in that great human crusade if we can't face the real challenge of getting rid of British nuclear weapons.&equo; 
 Barbara Switzer, deputy general secretary of the manufacturing, science and finance union MSF, condemned the review as &bquo;dated and timid&equo;. 
 &bquo;We are unilateralist because it is the only sane, only moral and only effective thing to be. 
 But we are not pacifists so we will keep conventional weapons to defend our shores and our land,&equo; Ms Switzer said. 
 Supporting the review, Tom Burlison, northern regional secretary of the GMB general union, said the public would expect a Labour government to use whatever was the most effective means of eliminating nuclear weapons.&equo; 
 Let's have the courage to admit that there is no betrayal in providing the next Labour government with the scope to give Britain a leading role in a movement to a non-nuclear Europe,&equo; he said. 
 Martin O'Neill, the party's defence spokesman, said the road to arms control now lay through the process of negotiation. 
 It would require patience and a Labour government would have to continue to meet its obligations to Nato, to service personnel and to workers in the defence industries. 
 &bquo;Most of all we cannot renege on our responsibilities to our own people,&equo; Mr O'Neill said. 
 A Labour government would immediately initiate the widest possible review defence commitments world-wide and set up an arms conversion agency. 
 Tony Benn, who Mr O'Neill recalled was a member of a Labour Cabinet committed to nuclear defence, insisted that Britain did not need nuclear weapons because there was no Soviet threat. 
 &bquo;Every Labour MP was elected two years ago on a pledge to rid Britain of nuclear weapons. 
 We cannot go back on this pledge,&equo; Mr Benn said. 
 &bquo;Who would believe us if we said we are changing our policy to win votes? 
 Who would believe us on anything if that was the basis of our policy?&equo; 
 Bill Jordan, president of the engineers' union AEU, was hissed when he told delegates a Labour government should be ready to play a positive role in a Nato that was now &bquo;reaping a spectacular harvest of peace&equo; from years of multilateralism. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Sinn Fein president defends IRA's barracks bomb attack 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 GERRY ADAMS last night discounted the anger and embarrassment of Labour leaders as he used a party conference fringe meeting to defend IRA terrorism, including the bomb attack on the Royal Marines at Deal, Kent. 
 The Sinn Fein president's appearance, and the invitation of the unofficial Labour Committee on Ireland, was condemned by senior party figures, and was met with a candlelight protest by local Conservatives. 
 Inside, about 12 demonstrators, believed to be National Front members, were ejected by police after attempting to disrupt the meeting. 
 Mr Adams scotched speculation that he might take up his Belfast West parliamentary seat, and use parliamentary privilege to overcome the broadcasting ban against Sinn Fein. 
 And he told reporters before the meeting: &bquo;I support the IRA's right to engage in armed struggle &mdash; where it wages armed engagements is a matter for itself.&equo; 
 Pressed on the justification for killing non-combatant musicians at Deal, he added: &bquo;Your Minister of Defence gave the answer to that when he said they were marines first and musicians second.&equo; 
 Earlier Kevin McNamara, Labour's shadow Northern Ireland Secretary, described his own meeting on Ulster policy as &bquo;overshadowed by a man coming to gloat at the scene of one the gravest blows to democracy carried out in these islands: the bombing of the Conservative Party conference&equo;. 
 Mo Mowlam, a Labour Northern Ireland spokeswoman, said it was appalling that Mr Adams, &bquo;supporting violence as he does&equo;, had been invited to speak. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Livingstone loses his seat on the national executive 
 By COLIN HUGHES 
 KEN LIVINGSTONE was yesterday knocked off Labour's national executive in a vote which took the Brent East MP and his left-wing associates by surprise. 
 The likeliest explanation of his defeat in the executive's constituency section vote is that party activists wanted to rebuke him for publicly rocking the boat during the passage of the policy review. 
 Robin Cook, the party's health spokesman, who retained his executive seat by coming second, said the vote showed the degree to which the party wanted to elect people who devoted their energies to helping Labour to win the next election. 
 &bquo;Ken Livingstone's problem is that he is always on the television slagging the party off.&equo; 
 It may also turn out Mr Livingstone lost because more constituencies this year balloted their full membership, rather than leaving it to their activist general committees to decide. 
 The party leadership &mdash; Neil Kinnock included &mdash; could barely conceal their delight when the vote was declared. 
 His defeat gives a further boost to Mr Kinnock's already overriding executive majority. 
 The confirmed hard left on the executive is now reduced to two: Tony Benn, and Dennis Skinner. 
 Mr Livingstone was replaced by John Prescott, the transport spokesman, who came third and said he would work for organisational and campaigning reforms in the party. 
 He added: &bquo;Of course I'll support Labour policy and the leadership, but I also believe constructive criticism has a role to play.&equo; 
 Mr Kinnock said he was delighted at Mr Prescott's election, adding he was &bquo;a dear and close friend&equo;. 
 He made it plain that he now wants to forgive and forget Mr Prescott's deputy leadership challenge to Roy Hattersley last year. 
 It had been thought that Mr Prescott would replace Bryan Gould, the trade and industry spokesman. 
 But Mr Gould took the sixth out of seven constituency places. 
 The vulnerable national executive member is now Jo Richardson who came seventh. 
 David Blunkett, MP for Sheffield, Brightside, was top. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Conference quotes 
 By COLIN HUGHES 
 &bquo;My view of the Common market can be summed up in four words and three of them are&hellip; the Common Market.&equo; 
 &mdash; Austin Mitchell, MP for Great Grimsby. 
 &bquo;I am not representing CND, I am not representing the Vatican, I am representing Tottenham and I think many other people as well.&equo; 
 &mdash; Bruce Kent. 
 &bquo;I want to tell you fellas, if you are at risk (from nuclear contamination) it's your semen and sperm which is at risk.&equo; 
 &mdash; Elaine Kidney, Stafford Labour Party. 
 &bquo;If the price of ending nuclear power is to close every pit I will pay it because my interest is in the future of the human race,&equo; &mdash; Arthur Scargill. 
 &bquo;It is for a constituency Labour Party to welcome Mr Scargill with open arms, or any arms.&equo; 
 &mdash; Roy Hattersley, on Mr Scargill's reported attempt to become an MP. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Revised policies approved 
 By COLIN HUGHES 
 The conference approved the Productive and Competitive Economy policy review, which proposes: A full employment target; the creation of a strengthened trade and industry department to steer strategic investment; A nationwide information technology cable network; Anti-inflation measures; Intervention only where the market fails; To regain a majority shareholding in British Telecom by buying 2 per cent of privatised shares at the market price; To regain majority control of other privatised utilities when funds allow. 
 The conference also approved the Britain in the Modern World policy review, which proposes: Cancelling one of the four planned Trident submarines; Putting other Trident missiles and Polaris into international arms reduction talks; Opposing the modernisation of short-range nuclear weapons in Europe; A commitment to continued Nato membership, while arguing for the abandonment of its flexible response strategy; Aiming to eliminate all nuclear weapons by 2000; Adoption of a policy of no first use of British nuclear weapons; Decisions The conference yesterday: Rejected a motion which would have committed the party to phasing out nuclear power stations within 15 years. 
 Affirmed the party's commitment &bquo;to reduce defence spending initially to equal the average level of other West European countries&equo; and use savings for social spending. 
 Approved a committment to secure the reduction of conventional and nuclear weapons by taking advantage of multilateral and bilateral negotiations, and unilateral initiatives. 
 Rejected reaffirmation of Labour's former policy of unilaterally renouncing the use or possession of British nuclear weapons, and the &bquo;unconditional removal of all nuclear weapons and nuclear bases from British soil and waters within the first parliament of the next Labour government&equo;. 
 Reaffirmed its support for the Palestine Liberation Organisation as the &bquo;sole legitimate representative&equo; of the Palestinian people and stated that it should play a full role in a UN conference to negotiate a settlement to the Middle East conflict. 
 Rejected moves to make the European Parliament the principal legislative body of the EC, and transform the Council of Ministers into a consultative body with no powers of veto over the parliament. 
 Today the conference will debate representation for black members; the policy review report on economic equality; discipline procedures, constituency rules; and women's representation and organisation in the party. 
 Neil Kinnock will deliver the leader's speech. 
 Smacked children are more likely to become delinquent 
 By PETER WILBY, Education Editor 
 CHILDREN who are smacked or beaten are more likely to become troublesome adolescents or to have a criminal record before they are 20, new research shows. 
 The link between corporal punishment and delinquency remained strong even when the researchers had allowed for class, sex and family size. 
 The findings are from John and Elizabeth Newson, founders and joint directors of the Child Development Research Unit at Nottingham University. 
 They have followed the histories of 700 families in the city since the late 1950s. 
 Their research is published by Approach (Association to Protect All Children), which wants to extend to the home the ban in schools on physical punishment. 
 Despite changes in official and media attitudes to corporal punishment, the Newsons' research suggests parental habits have altered little in nearly 30 years. 
 In 1958, some 62 per cent of mothers smacked their year-old babies. 
 For another generation, in 1985, the proportion was 63 per cent. 
 The research suggests smacking reaches a peak at four years but remains significant &mdash; particularly for working-class boys &mdash; at 11. 
 At four, three-quarters of all children were smacked at least once a week and only 3 per cent were never smacked. 
 The large majority of the mothers believed in smacking; only 17 per cent disapproved on principle. 
 By the age of seven, more than half the boys and nearly a third of the girls were being hit at least once a week. 
 Some 22 per cent of the mothers had used an implement &mdash; a strap, cane or slipper &mdash; and another 53 per cent had threatened one. 
 By 11, the majority of children were hit less than once a month or never. 
 But 18 per cent were still being struck at least once a week. 
 An implement was used by mothers &mdash; apparently the main punishment agents &mdash; on 15 per cent of boys and 3 per cent of girls. 
 At all ages, boys are hit more frequently and more severely than girls. 
 Boys from unskilled, working-class homes tend to have the hardest time; at 11 years, 36 per cent were beaten with an implement by the father, the mother or both. 
 On an index of potential or actual delinquency at the age of 11 &mdash; based on stealing, truancy and trouble with neighbours, police or school &mdash; high scores were associated with severe or frequent corporal punishment. 
 The question whether the children are delinquent because they are smacked, or the reverse, cannot be answered, the Newsons add. 
 &bquo;What we can say, however, is that smacking and beating mothers do not succeed in producing non-delinquent children.&equo; 
 Among those with a criminal record at 20, some 73 per cent had been smacked or beaten at least once a week when aged seven and 40 per cent when they were 11. 
 Corresponding proportions for other children were 47 per cent and 14 per cent. 
 The Newsons suggest these associations stand out to such an extent that they &bquo;can be fairly assumed to be causative&equo;. 
 Fathers who are highly involved with their children at 11, but who do not punish them, are the best protection against a criminal record in adolescence, the research suggests. 
 Salesman jailed for food poison plot 
 By PETER WILBY, Education Editor 
 A SALESMAN who threatened to poison food at Marks and Spencer stores unless his demands for &pound;140,000 were met was jailed yesterday for five years. 
 William Shooter's blackmail scheme was described by the judge, Lord Allanbridge, as &bquo;a calculated, carefully planned and shocking crime&equo;. 
 Shooter, 40, tampered with the labels of three soft drinks bottles at company stores in Luton, Leicester and Derby, Glasgow High Court was told. 
 Then, in a letter to the company's London headquarters, he said that unless he was paid, items would be injected by a qualified chemist, causing &bquo;pain, suffering and possibly death&equo; to customers. 
 Shooter, of Southbrae Drive, Jordanhill, Glasgow, claimed to represent an organisation called Midas which had political objectives and was in desperate need of funds. 
 He went on to threaten to give details to the media, backed by further contamination of items of food throughout the country, the court was told. 
 By this time the money involved would be &pound;200,000 and the blackmail would run for two years. 
 Kevin Drummond QC, for the prosecution, said Shooter had hatched the elaborate plot on his home computer. 
 Details of it were stored on a floppy disk. 
 Shooter, described in court as a salesman, was caught after a plain-clothes police officer posed as a courier taking the first of the blackmail money to a pick-up point at Edinburgh Airport. 
 The court heard that a desperate financial crisis and debts of more than &pound;40,000 drove Shooter to hatch his unsuccessful plot. 
 Edgar Prais QC, for the defence, said the offence was committed in a climate of food poisoning scares. 
 He appealed for leniency on the grounds that nothing had been touched. 
 He said Shooter, who admitted the blackmail plot at an earlier hearing, was an author of several works of fiction. 
 In one unpublished crime novel, the extortion plan was mentioned, he added. 
 In a statement read to the court, Shooter described his crime as &bquo;a cry for help from someone who could no longer handle the pressures of life&equo;. 
 Lord Allanbridge said he took into account the stress Shooter was under at the time. 
 Hospitals may refuse no-contract patients 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 PATIENTS needing non-emergency treatment will face hospital checks to see if their health authority will pay &mdash; and may be turned away if the doctor sending them is from a district not having a contract with that hospital. 
 The need to check if, and how fully, an authority will meet the cost in such cases is outlined by the Department of Health in guidelines to authorities on how the NHS market will work. 
 The department adds that GPs must remain free to send patients to hospitals with which their district has no contract. 
 Such freedom is one of the most controversial areas in the scheme. 
 The general principle is that the cost of those referrals will be met by each district's contingency reserve, the guidance says. 
 They will only be challenged if &bquo;it can be shown that the proposed referral is wholly unjustified on clinical grounds, or where an alternative referral would be equally efficacious, taking into account the patient's wishes&equo;. 
 But it adds that the principle &bquo;cannot be interpreted as a licence for GPs to disregard the contract arrangements&equo;. 
 And it warns: &bquo;A presumption of the right to make an extra-contractual referral cannot be a guarantee that the DHA would in all cases agree to meet the cost.&equo; 
 To cope with such cases a &bquo;simple, quick, non-bureaucratic&equo; procedure is needed. 
 Each district should have a clinical panel of doctors whose advice can be sought. 
 The document says such cases should be minimised by discussions with GPs on where they wish to refer patients before contracts are agreed. 
 Consultants will remain free to refer patients to a specialist in another hospital although the department has yet to decide the mechanism for payment. 
 The decision, however, will be that of the case doctor &bquo;and must be made solely for clinical, not financial reasons&equo;. 
 Firms win TV rights to Commons committees 
 By MAGGIE BROWN, Media Editor 
 A PRIZE contract to televise the select and standing committees of the House of Commons, which handle much of the nitty-gritty of government, has been won by George Carey, founder editor of Newsnight, a year after leaving the BBC to start his own company. 
 Coverage for an initial eight-month experiment starts next month alongside the introduction of cameras to Parliament. 
 The contract, which contains the same strict rules as those governing coverage of Parliament, has been awarded to Barraclough Carey Productions - which Mr Carey founded with a BBC documentary producer, Jenny Barraclough - and Sevenday Productions, whose director, John Underwood, is a former ITN home affairs correspondent. 
 Mr Carey, 46, a distinguished BBC journalist for 23 years, said he expected to liaise constantly with broadcasters on what footage they required. 
 Payment would be based on a pooled system: if everyone wanted the same coverage costs would be shared. 
 If only one broadcaster wanted something, it would bear the cost. 
 Covering the mass of routine committees raises many more problems of choice, discretion and topicality than recording events in the main chamber. 
 Very little debate about how to manage it has taken place. 
 The contract was first advertised in August and attracted bids from Visnews; WTN, part-owned by ITN; and a host of independents. 
 Mr Carey said: &bquo;We submitted a bid which tried to be clear about the problems, and to arrive at a view of what is practicable, which disturbs MPs as little as possible, while giving the broadcasters what they want. 
 Many details still have to be sorted out. 
 &bquo;Our job will be to be flexible. 
 I think it could really be interesting, a view of democracy in action, where backbench MPs, expert witnesses, judge whether the Government is performing. 
 A lot depends on how the public's taste of committees is cultivated.&equo; 
 Oil spill clean-up in Southampton Water 
 By MAGGIE BROWN, Media Editor 
 TEAMS of workmen yesterday cleared oil-covered shingle from Calshot Spit (above), a nature conservation area, as part of a big clean-up operation after a tanker spilled 6,000 gallons of heavy Middle East crude into Southampton Water. 
 Booms stayed on standby at the mouth of the Hamble River to protect it from the slick. 
 Tidal action prevented the oil, which spilled from the Cypriot-registered MV Worthy, from washing into the Solent. 
 A sea valve had been left open on the tanker as she discharged her cargo at Esso's Fawley Refinery on Sunday. 
 The tanker had earlier been involved in a collision in Spain, but the refinery manager, Reg Clay, said there was no underwater damage that could have contributed to the incident. 
 Refinery staff, who had earlier feared that more oil had been lost, launched contingency plans and the nearby Oil Spill Service Centre was placed on alert. 
 Booms were used to contain the oil, and tugs sprayed hundreds of gallons of chemical dispersant on the oil, which had initially formed a 100ft slick. 
 Skimming operations recovered about 1,000 gallons. 
 Fawley power station, which supplies electricity to the National Grid, operated at reduced capacity to avoid sucking up the oil in its water cooling system. 
 By last night, six oil-soaked birds had been found and taken to an RSPCA shelter at Fareham, Hampshire. 
 Mike Ward, the shelter's manager, said birds covered in oil became waterlogged and were unable to fly, but the biggest danger was that they could be poisoned. 
 Esso said a veterinary surgeon was also standing by. 
 Grotesque and tragic images of the embryo overshadow debate: The &bquo;pro-life&equo; lobby is to launch its biggest campaign to limit abortion. 
 Sarah Helm profiles a leading group 
 By SARAH HELM 
 OUTSIDE the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children conference hall at Keele last weekend, two young women from Antrim branch were discussing how a woman had recently given birth to a hairy baby with dog's ears. 
 They were planning to raise the issue. 
 &bquo;We read about it just the other day. 
 The baby is 13 months old and is 70 per cent dog and 30 per cent human. 
 The woman was impregnated with a dog's sperm. 
 &bquo;After a year a dog is a fully grown, fully independent individual, but the baby is still dependent on its mother. 
 How do you bring up a child like that? 
 It's just terrible,&equo; Siobhan Gallagher, 18, said. 
 Nearby, pale young men wearing Save the Baby T-shirts were selling Let me Live tapes, Silent Scream videos, Mother Teresa postcards, &bquo;precious feet&equo; badges, &bquo;stop doctors starving babies to death&equo; stickers, Even Nice Girls. 
 .. comics &mdash; and a pile of pink things in plastic wrappers. 
 &bquo;There you are &mdash; you'd better have one to remind you what a foetus looks like at 12 weeks,&equo; an enthusiastic PR said. 
 &bquo;You can even see it's a boy, look.&equo; 
 Celeste Hinds, mother of a Down's syndrome child, took her place at the rostrum, dominated overhead by SPUC's ubiquitous emblem: the crying foetus. 
 &bquo;The handicapped reach out to us in simplicity and trust&hellip; rejecting them we create a cynical selfish world for us to live in&hellip; we are walking a path which after Nuremberg it was said we would never be walking again,&equo; she said to loud applause and a standing ovation. 
 At the back of the hall a handicapped woman sat quietly in a wheelchair and a man paced up and down, a tiny Down's syndome baby gurgling in his arms. 
 This was a conference where images of the macabre and the grotesque mingled with the moving and the tragic; where the children and the handicapped were feted as survivors of a silent holocaust; where people went to learn the difference between pro-life and pro-death, between cloning and twinning, between a blob of jelly and a living foetus, between a terminated pregnancy and murder and to learn how to counter difficult questions. 
 For members of the society it has never been so important to know these things. 
 With the forthcoming publication of a government Bill on embryo research, SPUC has probably its best chance to challenge abortion laws. 
 As well as campaigning against embryo research, it plans to introduce an abortion amendment to the Bill, thereby forcing a free vote for the first time since abortion was legalised in 1967. 
 The society was founded in 1966 when David Steel's abortion Bill was moving fast towards the statute books. 
 It was the first anti-abortion group in the world. 
 When first formed it had only 12 members; it now has 30,000. 
 Despite a large Roman Catholic following and a Catholic convert, Phyllis Bowman, as its national director, the society's leadership has always insisted that it is not &mdash; unlike its ally Pro-Life &mdash; a primarily Catholic organisation. 
 It argued in the early days that to be too closely allied with Catholicism would deter a broad membership, which is now drawn from among protestants, muslims, baptists, Jews &mdash; and, it emphasises proudly, atheists. 
 The religious group increasingly providing new membership is the evangelicals. 
 Politically, the organisation says its grass roots are in working class Labour-voting families. 
 The age range is wide and the sexes balanced equally. 
 Large women sit knitting alongside neat men in tweed jackets, teenagers in torn jeans, mothers and children and the elderly. 
 A SPUC conference generates little fundamentalist fervour, just a quiet earnestness and obedience to the call from the rostrum: &bquo;We have ways of making you sign your commitment forms,&equo; grinned John Smeaton, the grey-suited general secretary. 
 &bquo;If are late for workshops you will be penalised. 
 And remember to go to the video boutique if you haven't seen the videos recently. 
 We have the old favourites &mdash; The Silent Scream and a number of new hits as well.&equo; 
 Members also obediently answer the calls for funds. 
 The society raises about &pound;250,000 a year from membership contributions &mdash; about a third of its annual income. 
 Its biggest benefactor is the property developer Godfrey Bradman, who is believed to have donated &pound;250,000 to the last campaign, and has pledged &pound;65,000 to the embryo Bill campaign. 
 Much of its money comes from church fund-raising groups, although the society denies there are direct church contributions. 
 To its opponents, who often complain that the Roman Catholic Church gives SPUC an unfair advantage -an automatic communication network &mdash; it is quick to point to the feminist movement, trade union affiliations and Labour Party pro-abortion campaigns which it says ignore the views of the membership. 
 The organisation finances a full-time staff of about 20 with offices in Westminster, Preston and Glasgow. 
 It has about 200 branches, the most active in the North, Scotland and Northern Ireland. 
 Leaders say students and trade unionists are joining in increasing numbers. 
 The society boasts that it has become the most successful single-issue pressure group since William Wilberforce and opposition to the slave trade. 
 It believes its success has come because of the &bquo;single issue&equo; approach. 
 This has avoided complex questions, debate or dissent in its ranks &mdash; it has blocked from their vision that difficult and muddling word emblazoned on every pro-abortion banner: &bquo;choice&equo;. 
 Being &bquo;single issue&equo; means SPUC has no position on contraception or women's rights. 
 Its policy is damage limitation, not prevention. 
 It will campaign on support for single mothers and on care for the disabled, and pay for research into Down's syndrome. 
 But it has no position on pre-marital sex or on censorship. 
 It allies itself with no political party, no outside cause. 
 The society, which has a permanent parliamentary lobbyist, has always been politically pragmatic and astute, compromising to make any progress, however small. 
 &bquo;We are not absolutists. 
 We never pretend we have majority support for all the hard cases &mdash; pregnancy through rape, for example,&equo; Mrs Bowman said. 
 But concession and compromises are still made only with one end in sight. 
 This approach makes campaign by diktat clear and simple. 
 &bquo;Please make sure you go to the press desk and get your personalised press release to send to the local papers,&equo; Mr Smeaton announced. 
 And at the press desk the computer churns them out, photograph and all. 
 Days later, MPs and newspapers will be swamped by Identikit letters and Identikit amendments tabled to numerous parliamentary Bills. 
 Concentrating on the single issue, the conference talks &mdash; for there can be no debates &mdash; pose no questions, and therefore no reason to tone down emotions. 
 Abortion clinics are &bquo;killing centres&equo; the media set out to &bquo;betray&equo; and &bquo;sabotage&equo; and abortion is &bquo;killing for convenience&equo; or &bquo;the holocaust&equo;. 
 The approach deters anyone who doubts. 
 &bquo;They just wanted me to swallow it hook, line and sinker,&equo; a disillusioned student said. 
 Society leaders argue that their single issue approach works &mdash; which is all that matters to them. 
 For every supporter who becomes alienated, there is another who is moved by The Silent Scream. 
 And SPUC does not have a monopoly on horror. 
 For every image of &bquo;foetuses down the sink&equo;, the pro-abortionists can conjure up visions of a knitting needle back street abortion. 
 The society's old adversary, the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, says the society is in disarray after so many defeats. 
 But SPUC says BPAS is in decline, hit by the loss in feminist fervour and decline in powers of the pro-abortion lobby in the trade unions and Labour. 
 Who is really winning will not be known before the free vote on the embryo Bill in the new year. 
 Ban urged on firms' HIV tests 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 TESTING for HIV as a condition of employment should be banned except where the absence of Aids or HIV infection is a bona fide requirement of the job, the Council of the International Bar Association decided at the opening of its ninth biennial conference in Strasbourg yesterday. 
 A resolution calls on the 21 member states of the Council of Europe to bring forward effective legal measures to ensure equal access to employment and prohibit HIV tests as a condition of employment in most cases. 
 The association recognises Aids and HIV infection as requiring laws to prevent discrimination in housing, employment, public housing, granting of credit and the delivery of services. 
 It says that employers should be encouraged to make reasonable workplace accommodation for people with HIV and draw up guidelines and educational programmes for dealing with Aids at work. 
 Mosaics focus attention on Cyprus politics 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 SMUGGLED mosaics go on show at the Mall Galleries today in a highly political show of artistic treasures from the area around Famagusta in Cyprus, writes Geraldine Norman. 
 It spans 36 centuries, from 1600BC to AD1974 &mdash; the date of the Turkish invasion which left the ancient city of Famagusta in their hands. 
 The exhibition, mounted until Sunday by the Cypriot government, aims to make propaganda over what it calls the cultural devastation of the Turkish sector since the invasion &mdash; a claim disputed by the Turks. 
 Attention has recently focused on four sections of the sixth century wall mosaics from the church of Panayia Kanakaria, near Famagusta, which the Cypriot government is seeking to reclaim through the courts from an Indianapolis dealer. 
 The two mosaic sections from the church which went safely home to Cyprus in the early 1980s have, however, avoided the limelight. 
 These pieces, on view in London, also went along the smugglers' network. 
 They were first sighted in the Munich home of the Turkish art dealer Aydin Dikmen in 1983. 
 Walter Hopps, curator of the Menil Foundation, a museum in Houston, Texas, and the London dealer Yanni Petsopoulos, visited Mr Dikmen's and Mr Petsopoulos recognised a panel over the mantelpiece as a section from the Kanakaria murals. 
 Mr Hopps later mentioned to the Cypriots that the Kanakaria mosaics might be on the market. 
 Mr Petsopoulos was contacted by Constantine Leventis, the Cypriot delegate to Unesco. 
 While the dealer refused to reveal the mosaics' whereabouts, he succeeded in obtaining four mosaic sections from Mr Dikmen which were deposited in a Frankfurt warehouse. 
 He sent Mr Leventis the weigh bill and the Cypriot embassy in Bonn picked them up and sent them to Cyprus. 
 Two turned out to be genuine while two, according to the Cypriots, were fakes. 
 Mother is &bquo;saved&equo; by liver transplant after TV appeal 
 By ANDY GLINIECKI 
 THE MOTHER of a five-week-old girl was critically ill but improving last night after undergoing a liver transplant made possible by a television appeal. 
 Doctors at King's College Hospital, London, believe that Aisling Barnett, 35, who suffered liver failure after reacting to a drug prescribed after the birth of her daughter, would have died yesterday if not for the operation. 
 A donor was found within 24 hours of a television appeal by her husband Colin, from Hackney, east London, after all other avenues had failed. 
 Dr Roger Williams, director of the hospital's liver unit, last night called for change in legislation in line with American law which would oblige medical staff to approach the relatives of suitable donors for permission to transplant healthy organs. 
 At the moment this was not done systematically. 
 Dr Williams said: &bquo;The operation was very difficult because of the poor condition of the patient. 
 All seems well at the moment.&equo; 
 Simon Griffiths, a hospital spokesman, said last night: &bquo;Mrs Barnett's general condition has improved over the last few hours and her liver is functioning well.&equo; 
 She was still critically ill. 
 Speaking as the operation began, Mr Barnett thanked the person who gave permission for the donation: &bquo;I know that Aisling, even if she does not survive, would want me to express my eternal gratitude to them for giving her the chance to live.&equo; 
 Mrs Barnett was in the operating theatre for 11 hours. 
 The transplant was carried out by a team of surgeons headed by Kai-Chah Tan. 
 She returned to the liver unit ward just before noon but was not expected to regain conciousness for some hours. 
 Her husband was allowed a visit. 
 The liver donation came from a UK resident but hospital authorities are releasing no further details. 
 It was rushed to King's College Hospital by an emergency medical team. 
 Dr Williams said problems relatedto blood pressure and her recent pregnancy meant that Mrs Barnett's condition was perilous. 
 Before yesterday's operation she spent three days in a deep coma as a result of liver failure. 
 &bquo;Another 12 hours and I am sure she would have been dead.&equo; 
 He said that there was a 65 per cent chance of survival for liver transplant patients with complications in the hospital's specialist unit and that the next 24 to 48 hours would be crucial. 
 Mrs Barnett fell ill because of a drug prescribed after the birth of her daughter. 
 But Dr Williams said it was a &bquo;very rare&equo; reaction and the drug would continue to be used because it was safe for most patients. 
 The hospital refused to reveal the name of the drug. 
 Dr Williams said doctors should be put under a legal obligation to approach relatives of patients who have died in intensive care units and would make suitable organ donors. 
 Special counsellors should be employed to aid this process. 
 &bquo;At the moment this is not always done and yet there are people who, if they'd been approached, would have been willing to give permission.&equo; 
 Radio wave users may have to bid for space 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 PLANS to sell the UK's radio waves to the highest bidders are likely to be considered by Department of Trade and Industry ministers within the next few weeks. 
 Department sources said: &bquo;We want to increase the efficient use of the spectrum by introducing market forces in what is a very scarce commodity and a finite resource.&equo; 
 Overcrowding is becoming a significant problem with the explosion in mobile communications and broadcasting services. 
 An auction would increase prices for spectrum users. 
 Licence fees are little more than department administration costs. 
 Police, emergency services and military users would almost certainly be exempted from any auction. 
 Defence now takes up half the frequency spectrum, with broadcasting and telecommunications using a large slice. 
 The Government is keen to increase competition in broadcasting and mobile telephone services. 
 To do so, the UK must clear out parts of the spectrum being used by something else, or develop technology to squeeze more into a given piece. 
 This year, the police and fire services will be removed from their radio waves. 
 Switching to another bit of spectrum means new radios and transmitters have to be developed and installed. 
 A draft consultative document approved by Lord Young of Graffham will go before his successor as secretary of state, Nicholas Ridley. 
 If he gives the go-ahead, the auction plan would be submitted to industry and other users for comment before any necessary legislation was considered. 
 Good diet &bquo;curbs cancer risk&equo; 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 WOMEN who have abnormal cervical smears can reduce the risk of developing cancer by improving their diet, a leading nutritionist said yesterday. 
 Low levels of vitamin C and another nutrient, beta-carotene, have been linked with abnormal smear tests, Dr Vishwa Singh, an American clinical nutritionist from New Jersey, said. 
 An abnormal smear shows that there are pre-cancerous cells in the cervix. 
 These may or may not progress to cervical cancer. 
 Dr Singh said the findings were preliminary, but he would &bquo;have no objection to a woman increasing her intake of these nutrients&equo;. 
 Yellow-green fruit and vegetables such as carrots, apricots and water melon, broccoli and other leafy greens, are rich in beta-carotene, which is converted to vitamin A by the body. 
 Citrus fruits are a good source of vitamin C. 
 Dr Singh was speaking on the opening day of a three-day international conference in London on antioxidant vitamins and beta-carotene in disease prevention. 
 During the meeting, doctors and nutritionists will report on studies from around the world which show that certain vitamins may prevent or halt the progression of heart disease, cancer, rheumatism, and nervous disorders such as Parkinson's Disease. 
 More and more doctors realise that diet can influence disease, William Pryor, professor of chemistry and biochemistry at Louisiana State University, USA, told the conference. 
 The National Cancer Institute was sponsoring more than 30 studies to assess the role of certain nutrients, he said. 
 Radioactive dust &bquo;forced move&equo; 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 LEVELS OF radioactive dust found in a home near the Sellafield nuclear reprocessing plant in Cumbria were so high that the owners felt they had to move their two young sons to safety immediately, the High Court was told yesterday. 
 But no one wanted to buy Mountain Ash, their four-bedroom house with its panoramic view over the Ravenglass estuary, because of its contamination with plutonium. 
 After two years, Christine and Christopher Merlin were forced to sell the property at auction for &pound;35,500 &mdash; compared with its valuation of &pound;60,000 &mdash; to a worker at the nuclear plant. 
 In a case which could pave the way for other people living near Sellafield to bring similar claims, the couple are suing British Nuclear Fuels, which weekly pumps millions of gallons of low-level nuclearwaste into the Irish Sea from Sellafield. 
 They are claiming more than &pound;100,000 compensaion for what they allege was the &bquo;catastrophic&equo; effect the contamination has had on their lives. 
 Stephen Sedley QC, for the family, told Mr Justice Gatehouse that radioactivity in the Merlins' house dust was &bquo;enough to cause real concern, in particular about the health of their two young boys, Sam and Ben. 
 &bquo;It was an extremely painful decision to leave the house. 
 It was not alarmist or panicky, but a rational response to a real risk.&equo; 
 Mr Sedley said the Nuclear Installations Act, 1965, required BNFL to recompense the family for the catastrophic effects on their property, direct and consequential, from the &bquo;massive discharge of radioactive waste into the local environment&equo;. 
 The couple were also forced to sell at a loss, the nearby post office and general store, which were also found to be contaminated. 
 Since 1982 they have been living at Grass Gars Farm, Ulpha, Broughton in Furness, in the Lake District &mdash; bought with a bridging loan, until Mountain Ash was sold in November 1984. 
 BNFL claims the levels of contamination in the house dust are harmless. 
 Kenneth Rokison QC, for BNFL, said the company would not be contesting the alleged levels of radioactivity in Mountain Ash, but would contest the levels at the post office. 
 The Merlins moved into Mountain Ash in 1973. 
 In the early 1980s the contents of a vacuum cleaner bag were analysed and &bquo;worryingly high levels of radioactivity in the house dust&equo; were disclosed, Mr Sedley said. 
 The case, which is expected to last several weeks, continues today. 
 Acid house riot charge 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 HORACE NOTICE, a former British and Commonwealth heavyweight boxing champion, was one of four men remanded in custody last night for a week accused of rioting at an acid house party. 
 Mr Notice, 32, of Welling, Kent, undefeated before detached retinas forced him to retire from the ring, appeared before a special magistrates' court in Reigate, Surrey. 
 Another four men face riot charges today. 
 He was one of 60 security guards at the weekend party in a field near Reigate. 
 Sixteen policemen were injured in clashes. 
 The Home Secretary has asked the chief constable for a report. 
 Inner Circle claim over RUC fuels security row 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 THE ALLEGATION that the Royal Ulster Constabulary contains an &bquo;Inner Circle&equo; of officers preparing private lists of IRA suspects and working against the Anglo-Irish agreement has lent a new dimension to the security force-loyalist collusion saga. 
 The claim came in yesterday's Irish News, Belfast's Roman Catholic morning paper. 
 Terry McLaughlin, its deputy editor, said he had been shown sensitive and detailed files by a representative of the &bquo;Inner Circle&equo;. 
 He said he had met the man, whose bona fides he had checked. 
 The man said his group held 64 documents relating to IRA suspects in the Irish Republic and claimed the group had members in every police sub-division, of which the RUC has 38. 
 The RUC said: &bquo;It appears the journalist met a man who is unknown to him and whose identity he is unable to verify. 
 He did not actually handle or take possession of any documents, and is unable to substantiate the detail or authenticity of papers of which he had some sight.&equo; 
 The existence of &bquo;Inner Circle&equo; was immediately questioned by loyalists. 
 Nonetheless, the fact that there have been up to a score of document leaks in the past month means the report is being given widespread credence. 
 The problem for the authorities is that it may be impossible to confirm or disprove the existence of &bquo;Inner Circle&equo;. 
 The Northern Echo, based in Darlington, Co Durham, yesterday said it had received pictures of 150 terrorist suspects from a former soldier who said he wished to illustrate &bquo;shambles&equo; of Ulster security. 
 Sinn Fein said 49 such photographs had been sent to its office in Monaghan in the Irish Republic. 
 Runcie ends talks with dream of unity 
 From ANDREW BROWN in Rome 
 THE ARCHBISHOP of Canterbury ended his ecumenical talks in Rome yesterday with an agreed statement that reaffirmed the commitment of the Roman Catholic and Anglican churches to unity, yet admitted they saw no solution to the difficulties presented by the Anglican ordination of women. 
 Ian Paisley, who had travelled to Rome to disrupt the visit, accused Dr Robert Runcie of &bquo;treacherous and lawless behaviour&equo; when talking of the Pope's role in the universal Church. 
 Dr Runcie denied his vision of a universal primacy would affect the Queen's position under the British constitution, which lays down that the monarch must be a Protestant. 
 &bquo;I was talking about a spiritual leadership,&equo; Dr Runcie said. 
 He explained his vision of primacy stemmed from the way the Pope can sometimes speak for all Christians in a way that no other bishop can. 
 The only concrete point to emerge from the visit was a reaffirmation that the long-delayed Roman Catholic response to the authoritative statements of theological agreement on ministry, eucharist and authority, known as Arcic I, will be forthcoming. 
 &bquo;Even if we don't like everything in the response to Arcic I, it will be progress,&equo; Dr Runcie said. 
 The declaration, with its renewed emphasis on the importance of unity and on the obstacles to it, reads like the triumph of hope over experience: &bquo;We urge our clergy and faithful not to neglect or undervalue that certain yet imperfect communion we already share. 
 &bquo;Against the background of human disunity the arduous journey to Christian unity must be pursued with determination and vigour, whatever obstacles are perceived to block the path. 
 We here solemnly recommit ourselves and those we represent to the restoration of visible unity and full ecclesial communion. 
 This is by no means to be unrealistic about the difficulties facing our dialogue. 
 The question and practice of the admission of women to the ministerial priesthood in some provinces of the Anglican communion prevents reconciliation even where there is otherwise progress towards agreement in faith of the meaning of the eucharist and the ordained ministry.&equo; 
 Cardinal Johannes Willebrands, head of the Vatican Secretariat for Christian Unity, said: &bquo;There has been real ecclesial community. 
 I am sure that Arcic has had a new encouragement to continue.&equo; 
 Dr Runcie said that the great point of the meeting would be in its ripple effect and symbolic effect all round the world. 
 Buckingham Palace distanced itself from claims of a constitutional row over Dr Runcie's remarks about Papal primacy and the Anglican Church. 
 Reports of a crisis meeting between the Queen and legal experts were mistaken, a spokesman said. 
 He declined to say if the Queen had been informed in advance of Dr Runcie's statement or if she was concerned about its content. 
 Church-state law experts said a role for the Pope in the Anglican church was unlikely to provoke a constitutional crisis, if he was given only an honorary position. 
 &bquo;RUC cell working against the IRA&equo; 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 First Edition THE ALLEGATION that the Royal Ulster Constabulary contains an &bquo;Inner Circle&equo; of officers preparing private lists of IRA suspects and working against the Anglo-Irish agreement has lent a new dimension to the security force-loyalist collusion saga. 
 The claim came in yesterday's Irish News, Belfast's Catholic morning paper. 
 Terry McLaughlin, its deputy editor, said he had been shown sensitive and detailed files, including &bquo;top secret&equo; material, by a representative of the &bquo;Inner Circle&equo;. 
 He said he had met the man, whose bona fides he had checked, in a Belfast hotel, and had been told his group held 64 separate documents relating to IRA suspects in the Irish Republic. 
 The man claimed the group had members in every police sub-division, of which the RUC has 38. 
 Mr McLaughlin was interviewed by detectives twice yesterday. 
 Afterwards the RUC said: &bquo;It appears the journalist met a man who is unknown to him and whose identity he is unable to verify. 
 He did not actually handle or take possession of any documents, and is unable to substantiate the detail or authenticity of papers of which he had some sight.&equo; 
 The existence of &bquo;Inner Circle&equo; was immediately questioned by loyalists. 
 Peter Robinson, a Democratic Unionist MP, said people were sceptical of &bquo;the idea of rogue cops going around to take out IRA terrorists &mdash; it's the sort of stuff you might expect to see on television with Clint Eastwood&equo;. 
 Nonetheless, the fact that there have been up to a score of document leaks in the past month means the report is being given widespread credence. 
 Seamus Mallon, an SDLP MP, said if the report was true it was a direct challenge from within the police to the authority of the Chief Constable and the Government. 
 The problem for the authorities is that it may be impossible to confirm or disprove the existence of &bquo;Inner Circle&equo;. 
 There is no doubt that almost every officer in the RUC, a largely Protestant force, would be opposed to the Anglo-Irish accord. 
 It is also clear that an unknown number of officers have individually, over the years, passed material to loyalist terrorists. 
 But it is impossible to say whether a structure, along the lines alleged, exists. 
 One widespread assumption is that the documents shown to the Irish News were probably genuine, but this does not necessarily indicate an organisation is in operation. 
 Nonetheless, given the scale of recent leaks, many will now suspect that &bquo;Inner Circle&equo; is an actual organisation, an illustration of the significant decrease in nationalist confidence in the security forces which the controversy has brought about. 
 The Northern Echo yesterday said it had received pictures of 150 terrorist suspects from an ex-soldier who said he wished to illustrate &bquo;the shambles of security in Northern Ireland&equo;. 
 Sinn Fein said a further 49 photographs had been sent to its office in Monaghan in the Irish Republic. 
 Council says 6 billion pounds money market deals &bquo;unlawful&equo; 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 A LONDON borough has admitted &pound;6bn worth of deals it undertook on the money market were unlawful, the High Court was told yesterday. 
 The admission by Hammersmith and Fulham was disclosed on the first day of a case brought by Anthony Hazell, the local district auditor. 
 He wants the transactions declared ultra vires &mdash; beyond the council's legal powers. 
 John Howell, for Mr Hazell, told Mr Justice Woolf and Mr Justice French the council would suffer &bquo;very substantial losses if the deals proved enforceable&equo;. 
 All were transactions &bquo;depending on movements in the interest rate market&equo;. 
 The majority were interest rate swaps or options. 
 Mr Howell said: &bquo;The council has accepted the deals carried out in its name were unlawful.&equo; 
 Financial staff had not given councillors detailed information about the scope or extent of its involvement on the money market. 
 If the deals are proved to be legal, &bquo;it is a potentially grave situation&equo; since the ratepayers and future community charge payers would have to meet the bill. 
 On the other hand, if they are not enforceable, it would be the banks, with whom the transactions were arranged, that would lose out as they had taken out further deals to offset their exposure. 
 As a result, five banks &mdash; Midland, Security Pacific National, Chemical Bank, Barclays Bank and Mitsubishi Finance Corporation &mdash; have been joined as respondents with the council. 
 In the two financial years 1987-88 and 1988-89, the council had been involved in 592 deals amounting to a notional &pound;6,052.5m. 
 On 31 March this year 297 deals were still current, representing &pound;2,996m. 
 Hammersmith's portfolio was almost entirely geared to an expectation that low interest rates in 1987-88 would remain. 
 Mr Howell said: &bquo;Those dealing in the council's name had no previous experience of these markets.&equo; 
 That inexperience was to prove disastrous, although in the first two financial years there was a &pound;12.5m profit. 
 Last February, Phillips and Drew, a stockbroking firm, said if interest rates stayed at 13 per cent, losses would amount to &pound;292m. 
 If they remained at the current 14 per cent rate, they would be &pound;402m. 
 Hammersmith has been prevented from alleviating its position because in February Nicholas Ridley, then Environment Secretary, blocked further transactions. 
 Mr Howell said Phillips and Drew calculated in February that to sell the portfolio would have cost the council &pound;69.1m. 
 The first swap was in December 1983 but the council had not begun to play the market in earnest until late 1987. 
 However, there was no committee report until February 1988 and even then information was sketchy, providing merely a summary of activity which did not reveal its scale. 
 Mr Howell added: &bquo;No advice was obtained about the legality of the deals.&equo; 
 That lack of authorisation by councillors was one of the four grounds on which the auditor was trying to prove the transactions were unlawful. 
 The others were that there was no power conferred on the council by Parliament, that the activity would not have been engaged in by a &bquo;reasonable&equo; authority, and the capital markets fund, through which the transactions were undertaken, &bquo;was not reasonably organised or maintained&equo;. 
 Speelman makes nervous start to chess tournament 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON 
 ANATOLY KARPOV looking pensive at the Pilkington Glass World chess championship semi-finals, which opened with considerable elegance on the grey and green carpeted stage of Sadler's Wells theatre yesterday, writes William Hartston. 
 Two huge screens above the chess boards carried illuminated chess graphics to display the games. 
 After short speeches, the national anthems of The Netherlands, the USSR and Britain sounded through the theatre before silence fell and the chess clocks were started. 
 The opening moves were automatically registered on the screens, then the lights over one game failed, the press room photocopier jammed and the typewriter refused to function. 
 Five minutes later, however, everything was working again. 
 The speed of the opening moves reflected the nervousness of the occasion. 
 Jonathan Speelman and Jan Timman rattled off a dozen moves each and Karpov and Artur Yusupov sped to move 15. 
 Speelman, with the black pieces, found himself under pressure after Timman produced a new idea late in a Queen's Gambit. 
 Timman won a pawn, then Speelman gave up a second one to create counterplay. 
 With the white pieces Yusupov copied an opening that had brought Karpov success in an international tournament game last year. 
 Karpov came prepared with an improvement and it equalised comfortably. 
 At one moment he even seemed to have a small advantage, but after 44 moves a draw was agreed in a level position. 
 The other game was far more interesting with Speelman looking for much of the time as though he was spending a very unhappy 33rd birthday. 
 Surprised in the opening by a new idea from Timman, he lost one pawn, then gave up another in order to create activity. 
 After 40 moves, he had regained one of the pawns, but had a miserably passive position to defend. 
 In the last hour of play, however, he played with great accuracy to keep the Dutch grandmaster at bay. 
 When the game was adjourned after 60 moves and six hours play, he was still a pawn behind but is now within sight of salvaging a draw. 
 Today the second games of each match will be played; the unfinished game between Timman and Speelman will be resumed tomorrow. 
 Reservoir body 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON 
 The body of a man shot, trussed and dumped in a reservoir near Halifax, West Yorkshire, has been identified as that of Laurence Conrad Winstanley, 24, who owned a motor repair business in Oldham, Greater Manchester. 
 He was last seen alive on 2 October last year. 
 3,000 pounds fine for polluting stream 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON 
 Thames Water Authority was fined &pound;3,000 with &pound;1,000 costs by Newbury magistrates after it admitted pumping &bquo;virtually raw&equo; sewage into a stream flowing through land owned by Peter Palumbo, chairman of the Arts Council, at Bagnor Manor, Winterbourne, Berkshire. 
 Mr Palumbo took out a private prosecution on his behalf and that of other residents after the sewage killed animals, fish and plants. 
 Ford plant &bquo;worst in Europe&equo; 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON 
 The Ford plant at Dagenham in Essex, has the worst record for stoppages and vehicle quality in Europe, according to management, which has urged union leaders to co-operate to improve the production record. 
 The criticisms come ahead of pay talks due to begin on Thursday. 
 An increase of at least 10 per cent will be demanded by union representatives, who will argue that only a substantial rise will improve morale. 
 Last night, speaking in Brighton, Jack Adams, a national officer of the transport workers' union, said directors had warned that, although they had no plans to shut Dagenham, employees themselves could close it if their work record did not improve. 
 Pollution inspectorate unable to recruit staff 
 By NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 THE GOVERNMENT admitted yesterday that its pollution inspectorate lacked almost a quarter of its quota of professional inspectors, nine months after saying it was recruiting 13 extra staff, writes Nicholas Schoon. 
 None of these posts has been filled, and it is now short of 27 professionals out of a complement of 119 &mdash; with little immediate prospect of filling the vacancies. 
 The vacancies came to light as the Department of the Environment announced a reorganisation of Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution, prior to giving it new powers in the &bquo;green&equo; Bill. 
 Environmental groups said the long-running shortages cast severe doubts over government commitment to the environment. 
 The Commons' Environment Committee also accused the Government of starving the inspectorate of resources and staff. 
 The Department of the Environment admits it is almost impossible to recruit the calibre of inspectors it wants on salaries starting at about &pound;15,000. 
 It has been negotiating with the Treasury for a pay increase. 
 &bquo;We are now in our second recruitment round, and if that doesn't succeed we will go on to a third.&equo; 
 The inspectorate was formed in 1987 from the inspectorates for hazardous waste, radioactive chemicals, industrial air pollution and water pollution. 
 It has suffered staff shortages since its inception. 
 Lonrho boss intervenes in Ward case 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 &bquo;TINY&equo; ROWLAND, chairman of the Lonrho group, which has extensive interests in Kenya, yesterday said he had discussed the Julie Ward case with the country's president, Daniel arap Moi. 
 He was replying to the disclosure by John Ward, the dead woman's father, that he had written to Mr Rowland earlier this year asking for assistance in persuading the Kenyan authorities to open a murder inquiry. 
 Throughout the long inquest, which resumes on Thursday, Mr Ward's counsel has suggested there was a sustained cover-up after her disappearance and the discovery of her severed and charred remains in the Masai Mara game reserve. 
 One of the mysteries of the case has been how high up the Kenyan establishment the details of the case were known. 
 During the latest six-day adjournment &mdash; to allow two witnesses to be called from abroad &mdash; Mr Ward said he had written to Mr Rowland on 31 January, asking for his help and recounting details of his daughter's death. 
 Mr Ward told The Independent: &bquo;Mr Rowland himself telephoned me the next day, said he was appalled at what had happened to my daughter, and gave me his direct line telephone number, saying he would be there every day from 9 to 6. 
 &bquo;He said he would be seeing Mr Moi in Bonn the following week, and asked if I would like him to set up a meeting with the president. 
 I said, &bquo;great&equo;.' 
 He had since heard nothing from Mr Rowland. 
 Yesterday, Mr Ward's account was put to Paul Spicer, a Lonrho director. 
 He said Mr Rowland had spoken to Mr Moi about the case. 
 Mr Spicer declined to disclose details. 
 Archbishop sees letters that led to split 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 THE ARCHBISHOP of Canterbury was yesterday shown love letters written by King Henry VIII to Anne Boleyn, the affair that caused the Church of England to break with Rome. 
 Dr Robert Runcie visited the Vatican archives and looked at original documents relating to the split between the the Anglican and Roman Catholic churches in the sixteenth century. 
 A Vatican statement said he saw love letters written by Henry VIII to Anne Boleyn before the schism. 
 These had been in Rome since at least the end of the sixteenth century. 
 The king wrote to his bride-to-be: &bquo;I promise to take you as my only lover, banishing from my mind and heart all others and serving only you.&equo; 
 The churches split in 1534 after the Pope refused to annul the king's first marriage to Catherine of Aragon so he could marry Anne. 
 MacGregor delays teacher appraisals 
 By NGAIO CREQUER 
 A SCHEME for appraising teachers' performance is being delayed because they are overloaded with extra work for the national curriculum and school budgets, writes Ngaio Crequer. 
 John MacGregor, Secretary of State for Education, made the announcement to the Secondary Heads Association, in Huntingdon, Cambridgeshire, yesterday. 
 But Her Majesty's Inspectorate, whose survey of appraisal in the education service was published yesterday, suggested the delay was due to teacher shortages and cost. 
 Its report said a good national appraisal system needed the equivalent of another 1,800 teachers and increased spending of &pound;35m a year. 
 The Government had planned to make regulations this autumn requiring statutory appraisal. 
 Mr MacGregor told the meeting he was &bquo;sensitive and sympathetic to your pleas that overstraining goodwill and commitment can endanger the very success of the reforms themselves&equo;. 
 Sports Talk / Botham's alternative winter tour: James Rampton previews An Evening With Ian Botham 
 By JAMES RAMPTON 
 Ian Botham can't have been expecting to have such a free winter, but he's certainly filling it innovatively with a national tour of his show, An Evening With Ian Botham. 
 Clips of his &bquo;Greatest Hits&equo;, various filmed interviews and the odd surprise guest are promised, followed by &bquo;Both&equo; taking questions from the floor. 
 Audiences might like to quiz him about his favourite sporting moment. 
 Was it the 1974 Benson And Hedges Quarter-Final when, as a 15-year-old, he lost two teeth to the fearsome Andy Roberts before hitting the winning six? 
 Was it the remarkable 1981 Headingley Test against Australia? 
 No, apparently: &bquo;Beefy's&equo; own most cherished memory is playing in the Scunthorpe v Hull City football match on Boxing Day, 1982. 
 The evenings will be hosted by David English, a cricketer (formerly with Middlesex and now captain of the Eric Clapton XI); journalist (on the London Evening News); actor (Lisztomania, the stiff-upper-lip Captain Andrew in A Bridge Too Far); scriptwriter (the Timothy Dalton vehicle Hawks); and author (of The Legend, an animated book on the Bee-Gees, and of the children's Bunbury Tales). 
 He also accompanied Botham on his walk with the elephants across the Alps for Leukaemia Research. 
 He has now launched a scholarship to find the best young cricketers in England. 
 Botham has always had a taste for showbiz. 
 Remember his pigtailed ex-manager Tim Hudson's trumpetings about Ian going to Hollywood? 
 &bquo;Ian's a hero, man. 
 He's Biggles, Raffles and Errol Flynn all rolled into one&hellip; 
 He's England's answer to Tom Selleck and I think he should be the next James Bond, man&equo; The cricketer was allegedly slated to appear in a film opposite Oliver Reed, and his humorous performances on Question Of Sport surprised many. 
 So, this should prove an entertaining night out, especially if the name Ted Dexter crops up&hellip; 
 Going Out to Galleries: Debate / Public test of a private Vision: Hildi Hawkins follows the progress of A Vision of Britain 
 By HILDI HAWKINS 
 IT began with the Prince of Wales's celebrated remark, in a speech to the Royal Institute of British Architects in 1984, likening a proposed extension to the National Gallery to &bquo;a monstrous carbuncle on the face of a beloved friend&equo;. 
 Next came his BBC film, A Vision of Britain; and the book of the film; and &mdash; at the Victoria and Albert Museum &mdash; the exhibition of the book. 
 That the book is topping the bestseller lists, and (according to a recent poll), 87 per cent of the public agree with the Prince's attack on modernist architecture, it is clear that the heir to the throne and self-appointed mouthpiece of the people has found something significant to say. 
 Now you, too, can contribute to the debate: on 2 November, voice your opinion at a Question Time-style discussion organised by the Victoria &amp; Albert Museum &mdash; &bquo;The Prince of Wales rules OK? 
 Modernists versus Traditionalists&equo;. 
 The panellists include Colin St John-Wilson, architect of the new British Library, Leon Krier, urban planner and architect of the Prince's Dorchester Project. 
 Chairman is Charles Jencks, architect and author, who will preside over a small invited audience of architects and developers, as well as members of the general public. 
 Go first to the albeit small exhibition: in Prince Charles the backlash against modernism has an impassioned protagonist and the display leaves one in no doubt about his views. 
 His self-deprecating prose &mdash; &bquo;You may be forgiven for thinking I only like the architecture of the past&equo; &mdash; is reinforced by videos broadcasting extracts from the television film. 
 In his patrician tones, he puts over his message: thatmodernist architecture is a failure. 
 The central exhibit is a bright pink, skeletal temple in which the Prince's central advice to architects is enshrined. 
 This concerns matters such as heirarchy, scale, harmony, decoration and art. 
 There is also a photograph and model tour of the buildings the Prince likes and dislikes, including the development of a new suburb for Dorchester. 
 At the very least, the exhibition provides food for thought: as the 21st century nears, do we really want architecture that looks as if it was built in the 18th? 
 WHAT THE CRITICS SAID Prince Charles &bquo;is incapable of distinguishing between the good and the bad, only between what looks old and what looks new&hellip;&equo; 
 Martin Pawley, Daily Telegraph. 
 &bquo;His instincts are absolutely sound about the ruination of our cities and it is a sad reflection upon governments and planners that such damage has already been done&hellip;&equo; 
 Colin Amery, Financial Times. 
 Although the exhibition illustrates some pretty horrifying mistakes that we made, A Vision of Britain is not pessimistic. 
 Charles Knevitt, Times. 
 Going Out to Galleries: ARCHITECTURE / Georgian values: Geraldine Prince on Georgian DIY for the home; plus selected lectures and courses 
 By GERALDINE PRINCE 
 IF you own or hope to buy an 18th or 19th century terraced house or rural cottage that needs doing up, where do you go for advice about historically appropriate restoration methods and techniques? 
 The Georgian Exteriors Course (11th-15th October) combines practical advice on renovation with a historical guide to the practices of Georgian building. 
 Although some lectures appear to be for the committed DIY enthusiast such as &bquo;Mortar mixing and brick laying&equo;, the organiser Steven Parissien, insists that the course is more about &bquo;making people aware of which things are structurally disastrous and visually awful.&equo; 
 One particular bete noire is double-glazing. 
 &bquo;Fine for a 1950s semi, but old buildings weren't intended to be hermetically sealed; preventing moisture getting in and out causes real damage.&equo; 
 The course gives advice on a range of subjects: town gardens, metalwork, stucco and door furniture, but it's not all classwork. 
 There are trips to the Lime and Flint centre in Winchester and the Bellingdon brickworks in Buckinghamshire. 
 A visit to a traditional glassmaker in Wembley and tours of fine examples of Georgian buildings. 
 With an eye on the trend for people with time on their hands to take up neglected crafts such as paint finishing and upholstery, Parissien notes, &bquo;There are lots of courses on 101 things to do with furnishing fabrics, but there's less for the layperson about structure, about actually saving your house.&equo; 
 Parissien acknowledges another benefit: &bquo;the bottom line, for those who want to see it that way, is that the course is also a guide to how to put money onto a house, rather than take it off.&equo; 
 Georgian Exteriors Course 11-15 October. 
 Lectures, visits, demonstrations around the south of England, plus events including Georgian music, food, opera. 
 Further information on 01-377 1722. 
 SOUTH QUEENSFERRY Hopetoun House The Architectural Heritage Society's Annual Conference celebrates the tercentenary of the Scottish classical architect William Adam (1689-1748) on Saturday 28 Oct in the elegant ballroom at Hopetoun House &mdash; William Adam's most important commission. 
 It will be devoted to a re-assessment of his life in the light of recent research &mdash; and coincides with the Scottish National Portrait Gallery exhibition (which ends 8 Oct). 
 Topics for lectures include &bquo;The Patron's Part: Living in a William Adam House, 1726-1989&equo;; &bquo;Adam: the latest research&equo;; and &bquo;Adam: the practical architect&equo;. 
 Sat 28 Oct 9.15am-9.45pm. 
 Conference tickets (&pound;11 with lunch, &pound;8 without lunch, &pound;6 students) from Department of Extra-Mural Studies, 11 Buccleuch Pl Edinburgh EH8 9LW. 
 Cheques payable to the University of Edinburgh. 
 A special coach will run between Edinburgh Waverley to Hopetoun (return fare, &pound;1), leaving Waverley Bridge at 8.45am and returning from Hopetoun at 5pm. 
 British Museum Lunchtime talks and lectures every day. 
 Topics include Islamic Architecture, 11 Oct. 
 Dulwich Picture Gallery No previous knowledge is required for a five-day course on Conservation, Care and Appreciation of Old Master Paintings (22-26 Jan and repeated 29 Jan-2 Feb 1990). 
 Illustrated lectures, gallery discussions and practical demonstrations will be held by Helen Glanville, conservator. 
 College Rd SE21 (693 5254). 
 Tate Gallery A series of lectures focusing on single masterpieces in the collection, Braque's Bottle and Fishes (lecturer, Carole Conrad) 5 Oct. 
 Millbank SW1 (821 1313) All at 1pm. 
 BRIGHTON ART GALLERY AND MUSEUM Treasures from Sussex Churches. 
 To coincide with this exhibition, a study day on church art and architecture from Medieval to Victorian times on Saturday 14 October. 
 Talks include 14th-century wall paintings; English monumental effigies; and the Victorian Church. 
 14 Oct 10am-4.05; tickets &pound;6 (&pound;4 concs) from Administration Section (Study Day in Church Art and Architecture) 4-5 Pavilion Buildings Brighton BN1 1UE. 
 Cheques payable to Brighton Borough Council (include SAE). 
 Going Out to Galleries: OPENINGS / Includes Aids depicted in a church setting and Iris Murdoch at the National Portrait Gallery 
 By GERALDINE PRINCE 
 MERZ CONTEMPORARY ART Artists against Apartheid &mdash; shows work that reflects a &bquo;humanitarian impulse&equo; and includes the paintings of Jock McFadyen, which concentrate on deprivation in London's East End. 
 62 Kenway Rd Earl's Ct From 9 Oct, to 21 Oct. 
 NICOLA JACOBS GALLERY First British show for the New York artist Marilyn Minter. 
 Like Warhol and Lichtenstein, she draws objects, images and motifs from popular culture and advertising. 
 Her sensual work addresses sexual stereotyping in mass and high culture. 
 9 Cork St W1 (437 3868) From tomorrow, 4th, to 4 Nov. 
 MANCHESTER CORNERHOUSE Posada: Messenger of Mortality &mdash; Jose Guadalupe Posada (1852-1913), one of the most popular illustrators in Mexico City at the turn of the century. 
 In the Twenties, he was an inspiration to the young muralists Diego Rivera and Jose Clemente Orozco and was revered by the Surrealists. 
 He cast his satirical eye over subjects from assassinations to riots. 
 Most macabre are the Calaveras &mdash; a celebration of the Day of the Dead (when Mexicans commemorate the deceased) &mdash; a depiction of skeletons drinking, dancing and riding bicycles. 
 70 Oxford St (061-228 2463) To 15 Oct. 
 Modern methods to make history more accessible: New management is set to boost British Historic Royal Palaces, as Neasa MacErlean reports 
 By NEASA MACERLEAN 
 WHEN parts of Hampton Court were damaged in a fire two years ago, few could see the silver lining. 
 It finally became apparent on 1 October when the day-to day control of Hampton Court and the other Historic Royal Palaces changed hands, from the civil servants to a group of commercial managers. 
 &bquo;The fire had the effect of attracting ministerial attention to Hampton Court in a way that would not otherwise have happened,&equo; said Genie Turton, under-secretary at the Department of the Environment. 
 &bquo;The last thing a Secretary of State would normally have time to do is to see if the Historic Royal Palaces are being run in a way to maximise profit.&equo; 
 Nicholas Ridley, after surveying the ashes, set in motion a revamp of the palaces' operations. 
 But lovers of the palaces need not fear that the overriding aim of the new management is to turn the current &pound;5m annual loss into profit regardless of the consequences. 
 Far from lowering the tone, the changes are set to improve it. 
 Value for money is a primary aim. 
 But, within the context of the priceless heritage and history of the palaces, value for money is a concept which cannot be satisfactorily turned into a numerical equation. 
 The first priority is to preserve the dignity of the palaces. 
 The second is to present them to the three million visitors each year in &bquo;an educative and enjoyable way&equo;. 
 And only third is to close the gap between an income of &pound;12m and outgoings of &pound;17m. 
 The Historic Royal Palaces &mdash; palaces owned by the Queen but not inhabited by her &mdash; comprise the Tower of London, Hampton Court Palace, Kew Palace and Queen Charlotte's Cottage, Kensington Palace and the Banqueting House. 
 Over the past 20 years the Department of the Environment, its Property Services Agency, English Heritage, the Queen's household and, in the case of the Tower of London, the military have run the palaces together &mdash; with the success normally associated with widely-drawn committees. 
 Statistics for the years 1975 to 1987 show an 18 per cent drop in the number of visitors to the palaces, while the National Trust has seen a 48 per cent rise. 
 But the Historic Royal Palaces were given &bquo;agency&equo; status on 1 October to remedy the ills of years of committee-style management and neglect. 
 Peat Marwick McLintock was appointed a year ago to introduce basic systems for management accounting and financial reporting purposes. 
 Until last year the accounting systems were largely used as a means of record, not for planning. 
 The major exception to this, the palace shops, have had great success. 
 Profits have increased nearly eight-fold in that period to &pound;500,000. 
 The new chief executive, David Beeton (a descendant of the famous Mrs), put his feet under the desk just two weeks ago. 
 He was formerly secretary to the National Trust. 
 &bquo;We don't think the product is right yet,&equo; he said, &bquo;so there is no use marketing it until we have got it right. 
 But the product is an educative experience.&equo; 
 At the moment the presentation of the palaces tends to be rather plain and unimaginative. 
 Mr Beeton is considering a range of options to embellish their presentation without substituting fiction for reality. 
 Exhibitions, educational films, period plays, even music, are all on the agenda but medieval banquets are firmly off it. 
 The bland presentation of the palaces is something which, in Ms Turton's view, leaves them vulnerable to gross misinterpretation: &bquo;If you were an American visitor you could almost think the Tower of London was built by Walt Disney. 
 We have built up a great deal of knowledge about the historical side of the palaces but that has not been presented to the public.&equo; 
 Rise of chartered secretaries 
 By MAX DE TRENSE 
 The author is public relations adviser to the Institute of Chartered Secretaries and Administrators ALLEN SHEPPARD, chairman and group chief executive of Grand Metropolitan, reckons that business is now becoming so complex that he needs a new core of trained administrators. 
 &bquo;In fact, this could well become essential during the 1990s,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;A good team of administrators can provide the logistical support and the efficient administration &mdash; the service element, if you like &mdash; necessary for the new entrepreneurs. 
 &bquo;This way, organisations can develop a tightly knit, well-run inner core, which can form a secure, cost-effective administrative base. 
 You can then add to this the more pro-active and aggressive corporate functions needed to trade successfully and keep ahead of your competitors.&equo; 
 These sentiments are beginning to be echoed by others in similar positions. 
 Not least because of the mass of recent company legislation, notably the codes relating to take-overs, mergers, insider dealing and financial services. 
 Mr Sheppard believes the task calls for accomplished generalists who know something of law, accounting, commercial practice, people management and administrative systems, without being confined to a narrow, specialist niche. 
 Chartered secretaries have had to develop during the 1980s in much the same way as their nearest counterparts, lawyers and accountants. 
 Mr Sheppard, who qualified as a chartered secretary at the beginning of his career, believes their skills will become highly relevant during the 1990s. 
 The Institute of Chartered Secretaries and Administrators says that demand for good qualified chartered secretaries has rocketed over the last three to four years. 
 This is confirmed by recruitment consultancies such as MSL International, which runs a chartered secretaries recruitment unit. 
 While the functions of lawyers and accountants are largely self-evident, those of chartered secretaries can be more varied. 
 Chartered secretaries are the professionally trained administrators and managers, who occupy a variety of senior organisational positions. 
 They are most widely known as company secretaries (which is the function of roughly 20 per cent of the UK's chartered secretaries). 
 In addition, they occupy senior positions in pensions, financial services and multinational companies. 
 They are also found in the top levels of local government, the health service and privatised industries. 
 It is, incidentally, a career in which women are making particular headway. 
 The Institute of Chartered Secretaries and Administrators has over 44,000 members worldwide, including 22,000 in the UK and Ireland. 
 Training is based on up to six years' relevant job experience and includes on average two to three years' study. 
 Members of the Institute are known as ACIS (associate) and can ultimately become an FCIS (fellow). 
 A recent survey conducted by ICSA of its members in management roles, showed that a high proportion served at or near board level. 
 Mr Sheppard, who is now a fellow of ICSA, began his career with an economics degree specialising in business administration from the London School of Economics. 
 He wanted job-related, professional qualifications as well as a degree, though did not want to enter articles to become a lawyer or accountant. 
 &bquo;Grand Met employs 25 qualified chartered secretaries throughout the company&equo;, said Mr Sheppard. 
 &bquo;Many of those are in line management. 
 Various Grand Met managers and executives now take the Institute of Chartered Secretaries&equo; exams for the same reason that I did. 
 &bquo;In addition, the training gives you a broad base in actually running an organisation. 
 Again, this will become increasingly important as the complexity of these organisations increases,&equo; he said. 
 Salaries too have become comparable to those earned by other professionally qualified people in industry and commerce with the top levels earned by company secretaries or senior corporate administrators. 
 Younger company secretaries, for example, can earn &pound;40,000-&pound;50,000 a year, while more experienced ones or those working for large companies can earn &pound;70,000 a year. 
 It has not been so long since the average chartered or company secretary was something of an eminence grise, rather than being in the front-line. 
 The position is changing rapidly, but they can still be powerful, behind-the-scene figures. 
 &bquo;Often you don't realise the sheer range of functions of a good company secretary or administrator until they leave, because they've been so efficient,&equo; said Mr Sheppard. 
 &bquo;However, unless you have good succession planning when they do leave, everything tends to fall apart!&equo; 
 Football: Robson's cure eases Polish problem 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY, Football Correspondent 
 FOR Captain Marvel read Captain Miracle: Bryan Robson, whom England had sadly written out of their plans for the World Cup qualifying match against Poland a week tomorrow, may be fit to play in Chorzow after all. 
 The England and Manchester United captain was named yesterday in his club squad for the Littlewoods Cup second round, second leg against Portsmouth at Old Trafford tonight, a hairline fracture of the leg having healed with remarkable speed. 
 Bobby Robson, the England manager, who had spent the weekend pondering the merits of possible deputies for his club colleague Neil Webb, a long-term casualty, expressed &bquo;surprise and delight&equo; at the news that England midfield disruption may be kept to a minimum. 
 Bryan Robson's injury, a legacy of previous combat, was diagnosed when he had to be substituted 20 minutes from the end of the first leg at Portsmouth only 13 days ago. 
 United, leading 3-0 at the time, conceded two goals at the final whistle. 
 It was immediately assumed that Robson, who had missed England's 0-0 draw in Sweden last month because of bruised ribs, would again be absent when his country strove to acquire the further point they need in Poland to ensure qualification for the World Cup finals next summer. 
 But Bobby Robson said yesterday: &bquo;Manchester United have obviously not made the decision to recall him lightly. 
 Now I'm looking forward to reviewing the situation after the Portsmouth match. 
 If he comes through unscathed, he can be added to the squad. 
 There is no problem about having another player.&equo; 
 He can say that again. 
 If Robson could be paired in central midfield with Steve McMahon, who deputised so impressively for him in Stockholm, a great deal of England's anxiety about the trip to Poland would be relieved. 
 Until yesterday the favourite to partner McMahon had been the 22-year-old Michael Thomas of Arsenal, who has only made one appearance for England: a disappointing debut in Saudi Arabia late last year. 
 Andy Jones, the Charlton striker, has been recalled by Wales to help fill the gap created by the suspension of Ian Rush and Mark Hughes for the Group Four match against The Netherlands at Wrexham a week tomorrow. 
 Also included in manager Terry Yorath's 16-strong squad is the uncapped Watford striker Iwan Roberts, while Southampton's midfielder Barry Horne returns after serving a FIFA suspension. 
 Ian Dowie, a former missile engineer, was launched into international football by Northern Ireland yesterday &mdash; less than 48 hours after he was grounded by a red card while on loan with Fulham. 
 The 24-year-old Luton striker was sent off at Chester after scoring his first goal of the season, but Billy Bingham has called him up for next week's Group Six qualifier against the Republic of Ireland in Dublin. 
 &bquo;He's a big strong boy, very much in the mould of Billy Hamilton. 
 He puts himself about a lot, tackles hard and works hard,&equo; Bingham said. 
 Equestrianism: Whitaker's wonder horse wraps it up 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY at Wembley 
 JOHN WHITAKER began The Horse of the Year Show on the same high note as in 1988 when winning last night's Corda International Stakes on the flawless grey, Next Milton. 
 He has a long way to go before equalling last year's prize money of &pound;42,399, but the wonder horse proved that he is again in irresistible form when opening Whitaker's account with a first prize of &pound;3,700. 
 Milton, the winner of this year's European Championship, finished with 2.92sec in hand over Jos Lansink and Optiebeurs Felix, who won the European bronze medal. 
 Third place, with the only other clear round of the 10-horse jump-off, went to Belgium's Evelyne Blaton on Careful. 
 Earlier, Malcolm Pyrah had won the first Olympic Talent Spotters Championship on It's Me and, though he does not believe the small seven-year-old chestnut is potential Olympic material, he echoed the widespread praise for this new series of competitions. 
 Speed was required last night, and It's Me won the &pound;3,000 first prize by 0.98sec from Marie Edgar on Everest Sure Thing. 
 Pyrah's winning partner is qualified for the top competitions here but, because of his youth, the rider intends &bquo;to use him with discretion&equo;. 
 The &pound;2,000 which Andy Austin collected, by finishing fourth on Elusive and sixth on Zobias, was considerably more than the meagre &pound;240 he won when riding River Hill to victory in yesterday's first leg of the Grade A Championship. 
 &bquo;It was very hard work for that sort of money and I consider it an insult,&equo; Austin said of the earlier award. 
 If he wins the next two legs, today and tomorrow, his total prize money as overall Grade A champion will only amount to &pound;970 &mdash; but he will have the opportunity to compete at Wembley for the rest of the week. 
 . New Zealand's Olympic gold medallist, Mark Todd, has accepted a last-minute ride for today's Working Hunter Championship. 
 He agreed to partner Seabrook, who has won the Show Hunter of the Year title here three times, after the horse's joint owner, Vin Toulson, was injured yesterday. 
 Toulson was unloading a horse from his lorry when the animal landed on top of him. 
 He sustained a broken rib and pulled ligaments in his right leg. 
 Golf: Seve has eye on Player's record 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY at Wembley 
 The Spaniard, a 7-2 favourite, has a bye into the second round, where he will meet either America's Chip Beck or Japan's Aki Omachi, one of seven newcomers. 
 Ballesteros won the title in 1981, 1982, 1984 and 1985, and will make a record 14th successive appearance. 
 He has been seeded third behind the defending champion, Sandy Lyle, and the US Masters winner, Nick Faldo. 
 Ian Woosnam is the other seed sent through to the second stage. 
 Three of the four 1989 major title winners &mdash; Open champion Mark Calcavecchia, US Open champion Curtis Strange, and USPGA title-holder Payne Stewart &mdash; are missing from the 12-man line-up, along with the world No. 1, Greg Norman. 
 &bquo;There are almost 20 tournaments offering a similar top prize and we have to keep pace,&equo; Peter German, the tournament director, said. 
 &bquo;We are trying to build up the event and, as we do not pay appearance money, the best way to do that is to offer rewards that will attract the best players,&equo; he added. 
 Football: Rangers survive Angell onslaught 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 Stockport County............ 0 Queen's Park Rangers........ 0 (Rangers win 2-1 on agg) ON tight, little Edgeley Park where some famous names have been rolled into the infant Mersey, Rangers did a smart professional job to reach the third round of the Littlewoods Cup. 
 There is a tradition here, dating back to the days of &bquo;Go-Go County&equo;, of First Division embarrassment if not failure but Rangers survived the early onslaught and, before an all-ticket 5,997 crowd on a clear mild night, emerged as worthy winners on aggregate after a goalless draw. 
 Rangers, precariously ahead 2-1 from the first leg, conceded four corners in 12 frenetic minutes. 
 County are a tall, muscular team and their football, if not subtle, is effective as demonstrated by their fifth place in the Fourth Division. 
 They flung the ball wide down the right, defenders raced in to support and in a sequence far too rapid for Dave Seaman's comfort, Brett Angell and Ian McInerney contrived four chances. 
 Rangers needed all of 20 minutes to catch their breath, responding to this constant raiding with play that was neat but frantic, despite Seaman's signals to slow down the game. 
 Trevor Francis was as guilty as anyone, but after 26 minutes the Rangers player-manager provided a beautifully weighted cross which Simon Barker headed just wide. 
 As County's rushes subsided, Francis was able to find space more easily and one shot, left-footed, taken quickly, was a superb demonstration of the striker's art. 
 Nevertheless, Rangers were grateful that Alan McDonald was under the bar to head away after John Cooke had eluded Kenny Sansom. 
 County's heroes were their midfielders, Mick Matthews and Andy Thorpe; faced with the glitter of Nigel Spackman and Peter Reid they challenged for control throughout. 
 They even doubled back to watch Francis yet still managed to send away their forwards. 
 Late on, County replaced the striker Gary McDonald with Mark Howard, who might have scored from his first kick, shooting wide five yards out at the far post. 
 Football: Howell demands riot charges for ticketless 
 By JONATHAN FOSTER 
 RIOT and conspiracy charges should be brought against those who travelled ticketless to football matches determined to confront police, the Birmingham MP and former sports minister, Denis Howell, said yesterday. 
 Howell, Labour MP for Small Heath, claimed that violence at the weekend was caused by groups of Birmingham City followers &mdash; totalling at least 300 - arriving in Blackpool without tickets for the Third Division match. 
 As courts began dealing with charges of theft and public order offences, a qualified referee was told he may be jailed for his part in the looting of a Blackpool jewellers. 
 Nigel Profitt, 21, of Erdington, Birmingham, and three other City supporters, were told by John Pryce, chairing a magistrates' court hearing yesterday: &bquo;You are nothing more than looters. 
 You will be remanded in custody for three weeks with a view to a custodial sentence.&equo; 
 Profitt, Michael Cook, 18, Adrian Sinclair, 19, and Lee Scrivens, 19, all from Birmingham, admitted theft charges; another six City supporters were also remanded in custody or on bail, and 23 were fined a total of &pound;8,600 for admitting charges arising from a weekend in the Lancashire resort which a Football Association inquiry may punish by banning City supporters from remaining away games; all their away matches were made all-ticket for an indefinite period after trouble last season at Crystal Palace. 
 &bquo;It should now be apparent to everyone that such a riot cannot be dealt with by any football Bill,&equo; Howell said. 
 &bquo;It requires major investigation and grave charges of conspiracy and riot.&equo; 
 Chief Superintendent Ken Mackay, in charge of the operation, said police had been aware of the large number of City supporters planning to arrive from Friday. 
 He rejected claims that clubs like Birmingham should not be allocated fixtures in resort times at attractive weekends like the present Blackpool illuminations season. 
 &bquo;We've had other clubs here with 3,000 supporters, like Bolton and Burnley, with no trouble,&equo; Mackay said. 
 &bquo;I do not think identity cards would have changed things &mdash; I suspect they would not have deterred people from travelling without tickets.&equo; 
 Torquay United are expected to appoint Dave Smith manager today in succession to Cyril Knowles, the former Tottenham player who took the club from the verge of relegation to promotion play-offs in 1988 and the Sherpa Van Trophy final four months ago. 
 Knowles, in the final year of a three-year contract, decided to resign on Saturday after the team lost for the eighth time in 10 games. 
 &bquo;I feel that I've gone as far as I can here,&equo; Knowles said. 
 Smith formerly managed Dundee, Plymouth Argyle and Southend United. 
 Kevin Drinkell, 29, became Coventry City's record signing yesterday when his transfer from Rangers cost &pound;800,000 &mdash; &pound;20,000 more than the fee paid in 1987 to Chelsea for David Speedie. 
 Dunstable withdrew yesterday from the FA Cup, but face disciplinary action after their remaining players walked off in the 38th minute of the tie at Staines after the referee Stephen Head sent off a third member of their team. 
 Rugby Union: Paterson leads NZ tour 
 By BILL LOTHIAN 
 DUNCAN PATERSON, the former international scrum-half from Gala, will manage a party of 30 Scotland players on the eight-match tour of New Zealand next May and June. 
 The trip, featuring two Tests, is an integral part of the build-up to the 1991 World Cup, and, significantly, Paterson &mdash; the 46-year-old managing director of a hosiery firm &mdash; was also confirmed yesterday as manager of Scotland for that tournament. 
 Ironically, Paterson's 10 caps, gained between 1969 and 1972, include appearances against every International Board country except the All Blacks. 
 Particularly tough tour games are expected against Wellington and Canterbury, and outlining the itinerary Bill Hogg, the SRU secretary, thanked New Zealand for managing to fit the tour into a domestic schedule which also includes a 13-match visit by Australia as well as Romania. 
 &bquo;Our original tour, in 1987, was cancelled because of the World Cup and we were not due to visit New Zealand again until 1996,&equo; he said. 
 Hogg's tone changed dramatically when announcing official reaction to the number of dismissals &mdash; up from 18 to 32, plus one match abandoned &mdash; in the first four weeks of the season. 
 &bquo;The committee are absolutely appalled,&equo; he said, &bquo;particularly in view of a directive sent to clubs in regard to foul play.&equo; 
 It was not, Hogg insisted, simply a matter of stricter refereeing. 
 Another letter is being sent to every club president, but suggestions that the SRU should make public the names of offenders and their sentences have been rejected. 
 &bquo;This was discussed. 
 But it was felt anomalous to take it all the way down to fourth XV, even under-18, level,&equo; said Hogg. 
 Athletics: Scots &bquo;short-changed&equo; 
 By BILL LOTHIAN 
 THE SCOTTISH Commonwealth Games selectors were heavily criticised yesterday for naming a team of just 18 athletes for the Games in Auckland early next year. 
 The team selected by the Scottish Commonwealth Games council is the smallest Scottish contingent since the 1966 Games in Jamaica, and brought an immediate response from David Lease, Scotland's national athletics coach. 
 Lease said: &bquo;This is undoubtedly a serious setback for the long-term development of the sport. 
 It now seems easier for Scots to get into a Great Britain senior team than it is to get into the Commonwealth Games team. 
 In future, UK teams will have to be our priority.&equo; 
 Ewan Murray, the Games council's chairman, said cost was not a factor in selecting the team, but only 15 athletes achieved the stringent qualifying standards set down by the Scottish Amateur Athletic Associaton &mdash; and one, Allister Hutton, is not going to Auckland because he wished to run in the 10,000 metres instead of the marathon, for which he had qualified. 
 &bquo;We only wanted athletes of distinction and no one is going along for the trip,&equo; Murray said. 
 Among the eight extra nominations by the Scottish women's AAA rejected by the selectors were sprinter Janise Neilson, a member of the Great Britain relay squad at the Seoul Olympics, and Dawn Kitchen, one of the British 4x400m squad for the European Cup finals at Gateshead. 
 Hilda Everett, the president of the Scottish AAA, insisted that the additional nominations were worthy of selection. 
 She said: &bquo;Seven of the eight have competed for Great Britain and we certainly would not have submitted any we thought would go just for the trip.&equo; 
 Commonwealth Games: Welsh go public for cash 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 THE Commonwealth Games Council for Wales are hoping that the Welsh public will come to their aid to finance the sending of 89 competitors and 27 officials to Auckland next January. 
 Announcing the Welsh line-up last night, the general team manager, Myrddin John, said there was still &pound;50,000 to find of the &pound;172,000 needed. 
 &bquo;By tradition the money always comes in at the end. 
 We have got terrific faith in the Welsh public,&equo; John said. 
 &bquo;I'm not making light of the situation, it's very very serious, and we are still hoping that somebody in Wales will come forward to be our main sponsor. 
 &bquo;Under no circumstances will any of those competitors who have been chosen be told they cannot go.&equo; 
 Despite the money problems, the team have a golden glint. 
 Colin Jackson is the favourite for the 110m hurdles title, while the mens' team captain, Andrew Morris, could strike gold in gymastics. 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Speedway 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Roller Hockey 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Ice Skating 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Ice Hockey 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Gymnastics 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 AMATEUR PLAYERS are to have the maximum value of prizes they may accept increased to &pound;300 from 1 January, 1990. 
 The increase from &pound;170 for a 54- or 72-hole event is to bring such awards in line with inflation. 
 The new limit for an 18 or 36-hole event goes up from &pound;110 to &pound;200, and for junior competitions from &pound;50 to &pound;100. 
 Sport in Short: Equestrianism 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Cycle Speedway 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Commonwealth Games 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Baseball 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: American Football 
 Sport Page 39 
 Motor Racing: McLaren try for peace in private war 
 By MAURICE HAMILTON 
 WHEN Ron Dennis, the managing director of McLaren International, goes to the trouble of stressing that his team intend to continue giving Ayrton Senna and Alain Prost impartial treatment during the final two races, such a commendably even-handed approach immediately arouses suspicion in a sport governed by an organisation which is not exactly noted for its equitable methods. 
 As Senna raced towards the victory he needed in Spain on Sunday, James Hunt, a driver familiar with the pressures of a late challenge for the championship, was saying Senna had no right to be on the track at all. 
 Or, at least, not if you compare Senna's comparatively lenient fine for ignoring a warning flag last Friday with the harsh justice delivered to Nigel Mansell earlier in the week. 
 The argument is that Senna's crime as he rushed past the scene of an accident was infinitely more dangerous than Mansell's failure to stop on the command of a black flag. 
 Although guaranteed the drivers' championship, McLaren are on a loser no matter what happens. 
 If Prost wins, then he takes the title with him to Ferrari and, in exchange for the highly desirable numbers 1 and 2 the Italians will present 27 and 28 to McLaren, a particularly irksome detail for such a dominant team to accept. 
 If Senna becomes champion, and to do it he must win in Japan and Australia, then Prost's recent criticism of his treatment at the hands of Honda will immediately spring to mind regardless of a subsequent and rather naive document, signed by all sides and designed to give the impression that all is sweetness and light. 
 Ever since Prost confirmed his intention to leave McLaren, he claims to have been increasingly isolated within the team. 
 Prost's observations need to be weighed against his mounting paranoia as Senna continually proves to be the faster of the two but, when you see only one member of the McLaren-Honda management standing by Prost's car on the grid in Spain while five key people fussed around Senna, Prost's fears would appear to have substance. 
 Equally, when Prost won the Portuguese Grand Prix a week ago, he received but a cursory welcome home from the McLaren pit when compared with the reception given to Senna's victory in Jerez. 
 But, to be fair, the McLaren directors had other matters on their mind in Portugal as they moped Senna's fevered brow and cursed Mansell's unwelcome intrusion into a family affair. 
 FISA, the governing body, went some way towards assuaging Senna's grief by banning Mansell from Sunday's race even though the court of appeal is not due to sit until Thursday. 
 Jean-Marie Balestre, the president of FISA, has pointed out that the regulations permit an immediate ban regardless of any appeal and there would appear to be no further argument on that point. 
 Senna capitalised on the absence of Mansell, the one driver who could have beaten the Brazilian and wrapped up the world championship in Prost's favour. 
 Now Senna has three weeks to plan his attack in Japan. 
 And Prost knows that Honda would hate to see a future employee of Fiat, the owners of Ferrari, win the championship on their doorstep. 
 If Dennis can maintain parity in the midst of such vested interest, then the credit really should rest with McLaren International rather than the drivers, neither of whom has had an entirely blemish-free season. 
 Soldiers put their shoulders to the wheels of a trolley representing a bobsleigh at Thorpe Park, Surrey, 
 By MAURICE HAMILTON 
 Soldiers put their shoulders to the wheels of a trolley representing a bobsleigh at Thorpe Park, Surrey, yesterday. 
 Paratroopers (from the left) Alex Poole, Eric Sekwalor, John Sowerby and Sean Ollsson came third in the four-man push competition organised by the British Bobsleigh Association to find crews for the new season. 
 The four-man winners were a team led by the former British champion Tom De La Hunty  
 Cricket: Question time at Yorkshire 
 By MAURICE HAMILTON 
 YORKSHIRE are to hold a special full committee meeting at Headingley on 10 October to discuss &bquo;all aspects of cricket&equo;. 
 This move follows the worst season in the county's history which culminated in a call from the captain, Phil Carrick, for the introduction of non-Yorkshiremen into the team. 
 The extra meeting was called for by several committee members. 
 The county chairman Brian Walsh said: &bquo;We have a very full agenda for our scheduled meeting on October 26 so it was decided to meet on the 10th with cricket as the sole topic of discussion.&equo; 
 The cricket chairman Brian Close is away on holiday but he is likely to face some testing questions on the 10th. 
 Jeremy Batty, an 18-year-old off-spinner, has been given a two-year contract by Yorkshire after his first-class debut in the last game of the season against Lancashire at Scarborough when he had match figures of 8 for 193. 
 Mohinder Amarnath, the all-rounder who angered the Indian selectors last year by labelling them a &bquo;bunch of jokers&equo;, has been recalled to the Indian team for the three-nation Sharjah Cup cricket tournament from 12 to 20 October. 
 Dilip Vengsarkar, who lost the captaincy after taking part in an unauthorised tour of North America, has also been included in the squad. 
 Tennis: A Kiwi's promise bears fruit 
 From Our Correspondent in Tokyo 
 CLAUDINE TOLEAFOA, a little-known 19-year-old from New Zealand, scored the kind of victory upon which solid careers are built, at the Federation Cup in Tokyo yesterday. 
 Toleafoa had been a promising junior when she joined the circuit full time, just over a year ago. 
 But a world ranking of 222 shows there is still a lot of room for improvement. 
 Yesterday, she showed promise again, however, when she outlasted experienced Italian, Sandra Cecchini, who is ranked 25th in the world, 6-4, 4-6, 10-8, in a match of rollercoaster emotions that lasted three hours. 
 &bquo;Something like this makes you believe in yourself that much more,&equo; said Toleafoa, whose father is a consulate-general for Western Somoa, but who qualifies to play for New Zealand because of her mother. 
 It was a triumph that also set up the Kiwis nicely for a surprise win over the seventh-seeded Italians. 
 Belinda Cordwell followed Toleafoa's lead by defeating Italy's No. 1, Raffaella Reggi, 6-4, 6-1. 
 The latter victory was also somewhat remarkable as Cordwell, who is ranked one place above Reggi in 19th, was playing her first serious singles match since a back injury forced her out for the game almost six months ago. 
 Italy were, however, the only casualties on a day otherwise marked by a five-hour rain delay and cold, blustery conditions. 
 The British team were smart. 
 They practised early in the morning before the rains came and then went shopping. 
 After watching them work out, team captain Ann Jones decided to put Jo Durie and Clare Wood in against the Indonesians. 
 Ice Hockey: Wasps find it tough going to the top 
 By STEVE PINDER 
 ONLY goal difference saw Durham Wasps reach the top of the England north table and qualify for home and away games against Cardiff Devils, runaway winners of the southern league. 
 The winners will meet the Scottish champions, Murrayfield Racers in the final in two months' time, writes Steve Pinder. 
 The England north league was always the tightest with, in theory, four of the five teams all able to finish top right up to the weekend's matches. 
 Only Telford Tigers were out of the running. 
 In the first period of their game against Solihull Barons, they were 2-0 ahead and hit the upright four times. 
 But Barons came back to lead 4-3 at the end of the second and Tigers looked like they were heading for another defeat. 
 Dave Wensley's hat-trick in the opening 10 minutes of the final period gave Tigers a 6-5 lead and with 28 seconds left, Alan Gould's goal made it a 7-5 win for Telford. 
 Wasps went 5-1 down at the end of the second period against Barons before Anthony Johnson and Rick Brebant pulled back three goals. 
 Despite scores by Tom Krug and Jere Gillis for Barons, the final scoreline of 7-4 to Barons was one short of the four-goal margin needed and Wasps, breathing a huge sigh of relief, were through. 
 With victory over the Racers, Cleveland Bombers would have made their way to the final ahead of the Scottish team. 
 However, Racers, leading 9-0 after 35 minutes, cruised to an 11-2 victory. 
 Squash: Kenyon begins monkey business 
 From RICHARD EATON in Kuala Lumpur 
 SIMON PARKE, the 17-year-old Yorkshireman, made the selectors feel a little more comfortable by qualifying for the World Open here yesterday. 
 But still there may be some wriggling to come. 
 A group of English players are reported to be bitter at having been left out of the squad for next week's world team championships, and inevitably, the name of the game for the next couple of days in the Open, which starts today, will be to try to make monkeys of those who omitted them. 
 The man with the most to prove is Phil Kenyon, who has accused the selectors of favouritism and goodness knows what else besides. 
 He could start with a win against Frederik Johnson, the Swedish international, but it is hard to see any of the other rejects surviving, except perhaps Jamie Hickox or Chris Walker. 
 Parke, however, has a marvellous draw and could go further. 
 His reward for surviving against Robert Owen, in a contest between Englishmen riddled with stomach bugs, is a first round with the Scottish No. 1, Mark Maclean. 
 The seed in this section is the most vulnerable of them all, Pakistan's Umar Hyat Khan. 
 The other youngster controversially chosen for England, Jason Nicolle, kept the selectors more on edge. 
 He only just qualified by winning 15-12 in the final game against a West German, Hansi Wiens, and will need to produce something extra today against the most improved Pakistani of the lot, Mir Zaman Gul. 
 Yet another Pakistani, the former world champion Jansher Khan, was rather prematurely in the news for being rebuked by Chris Dittmar, the president of the players' association, for allegedly being too demanding of the tournament organisers. 
 Neither Dittmar nor two other Australians, Rodney Martin and Chris Robertson, can be dismissed as outside contenders for the title. 
 However, Jansher's continuing rivalry with Jahangir Khan is likely to be the highlight of the first World Open to use the lower 17-inch tin. 
 Volleyball: Tennant returns to make Knights' day 
 By MIKE SPENCER 
 BRIXTON KNIGHTS have enticed Lyn Tennant out of retirement as they plot the downfall of the English women's champions, Britannia, writes Mike Spencer. 
 The London club have opened their season with three successive 3-0 victories in the Royal Bank English League. 
 Tennant, a former Scottish international, created a stir four years ago when she switched allegiance and opted to play for England in international competition. 
 A member of the Hillingdon side which won six successive English League titles between 1980-85, Tennant, a centre net player, gave up the game after Hillingdon disbanded following their capture of the League title in 1985. 
 She has played in two of Brixton's three matches so far &mdash; including Sunday's 15-1, 15-10, 15-11 win over Southgate &mdash; and believes the standard has improved since she last played. 
 &bquo;The Brixton squad has a depth that Hillingdon never had and we are strong not just on court but also on the bench,&equo; she said. 
 In the men's First Division, there were no surprises with Malory, the champions, beating MGI Wessex 15-6, 15-13, 15-13 and Polonia, who have made such a fine start to the season, defeating Hilton Leeds in five sets. 
 Why ITV are pulling plugs: Neil Wilson looks behind the screens at the changing picture of televised sport 
 By NEIL WILSON 
 AT THE Isleworth headquarters of Sky Television today, Rupert Murdoch will announce that in association with the BBC he has bought exclusive coverage of England's cricket tour of the West Indies from an independent producer. 
 Three hours later, in the boardroom of London Weekend Television, will follow a lunch bidding farewell to Dickie Davies. 
 Two unconnected events, but they present a picture of sport on television which brings the state of play in the battle for the sporting viewer into sharp perspective; BBC, centre circle, triumphant; ITV pushed to the wings; and the satellite and cable companies warming to the game after their first year's play. 
 Davies is the former face of Independent Television sport. 
 Officially, today's luncheon honours his contribution to ITV Sport over 25 years. 
 In fact, it brings down the curtain not only on his role but on ITV's epic struggle to match BBC in the sporting field. 
 Davies, who has not renewed his contract as ITV's sports presenter, is one of 17 whose names appeared on ITV Sport's credits who have jumped ship this year alone. 
 Richard Worth, producer of Saint and Greavsie, will be next to leave and Jim Rosenthal, the public face of ITV athletics whose contract has expired, is considering an offer from a satellite channel as well as one from ITV. 
 So, has ITV conceded in the sporting rivalry with BBC which has lasted as long as Davies's smile? 
 &bquo;I think you have found the right word for it,&equo; Jonathan Martin, head of sport at the BBC, says. 
 &bquo;I don't agree,&equo; John Bromley, his opposite number at ITV, counters. 
 &bquo;There's been a definite change of policy and philosophy. 
 But if it is quality and exclusive, sport still has a place on ITV.&equo; 
 But not much of one. 
 ITV spent &pound;44m buying the exclusive rights to live Football League matches. 
 It has yet to show a match this season. 
 It claims to be the athletics network, having bought exclusive rights to the sport in Britain for &pound;10.5m in 1985. 
 It showed just 25 minutes of the three-day World Cup in Barcelona (the rest of its coverage was on Channel 4). 
 Bromley's own leaving party is scheduled for late autumn. 
 Having been replaced as head of ITV's sports committee by LWT's controller of programmes, Greg Dyke, he is off to be chairman of TSL, an independent production company. 
 ITV Sport's new on-screen logo tells the story. 
 It illustrates just four sports: football, boxing, athletics and snooker. 
 &bquo;We must conserve our money and our time in the schedules for the big ones,&equo; Bromley says. 
 &bquo;Everything else, the minorities, go to Channel 4 where they fit comfortably.&equo; 
 Cricket and golf, Bromley says, are both minorities, judging by the size of their television audience. 
 Cricket had the fourth largest aggregate audience on television in 1988, according to the figures of AGB Sports Watch/ BARB, but over so many hours that its audience at any one time is insignificant. 
 The final climactic day of golf's Ryder Cup last week still attracted fewer than five million viewers to BBC's Sunday Grandstand. 
 The Wimbledon's men's and women's finals on the same Sunday this year drew only 7.7 million. 
 Sunday Grandstand's average is just two million. 
 &bquo;Even a repeat of Hawaii Five-O will get more viewers than most sport,&equo; Derek Brandon, of the independent sport producers, Grandslam, says. 
 BBC can live with that. 
 Martin has dropped next month's Grand Prix tennis at Wembley from his schedule but on sporting grounds. 
 Last year's entry was not of sufficient quality. 
 The Wightman Cup is no longer shown for a similar reason. 
 Only on ITV are the rat- ings the foremost consideration. 
 &bquo;We are very different organisations,&equo; Martin concedes. 
 &bquo;For quite proper commercial reasons they have chosen to be selective. 
 After all, they have to take business decisions and use sport as part of a commercial product. 
 We have to serve sport and sports viewers and keep a broad range of people happy.&equo; 
 Bromley admits that there have been reductions in ITV's coverage. 
 Darts is out, and so is gymnastics, once a feature. 
 More sophisticated presentation and the buying of exclusive rights affect the budget for other sports. 
 &bquo;It's getting ridiculous,&equo; Bromley says. 
 &bquo;The French FA asked Scottish ITV for &pound;450,000 just for France versus Scotland.&equo; 
 But the ITV companies' disinclination to schedule sport is more critical. 
 &bquo;If a sport offered me 12 hours free, I would have to say I have nowhere to put it,&equo; Bromley admits. 
 Even the mid-week football slot has been pushed back to 11.20pm from its prime slot after News at Ten. 
 &bquo;We're still fighting that one,&equo; Bromley says, &bquo;but peak-time scheduling has got harder and harder to break into. 
 There's no slack space anymore.&equo; 
 Again, ratings decide. 
 Sport can still pull an armchair crowd. 
 Stephen Hendry's UK Championship final with Doug Mountjoy drew 13.2 million. 
 Ironically, it was on BBC. 
 The Grand National always attracts around 15 million. 
 But only BBC win when an event is screened simultaneously. 
 &bquo;Sharing isn't attractive any more to us,&equo; Bromley says, a verbal throwing in of the towel. 
 Even at the World Cup finals next year there will be an arrangement to alternate coverage of matches, and ITV will not screen the next Olympic Games. 
 &bquo;The Olympic decision was the death of ITV as a credible channel for sport,&equo; said Richard Russell, a former ITV executive producer and now controller of programmes for Eurosport. 
 Not surprisingly, morale is low in their team. 
 &bquo;We're not in the game any more but don't quote me,&equo; one of their &bquo;names&equo; said. 
 &bquo;My contract's still got time to run.&equo; 
 When it has, a satellite company is his likely destination. 
 Given time, it may also be the sporting viewers'. 
 Bromley was quoted by The Listener in August as saying of Sky: &bquo;We intend to shoot them out of the sky.&equo; 
 But this year Sky's associate, Eurosport, covered 14 of athletics' 16 grand prix meetings. 
 ITV, the &bquo;athletics channel&equo;, covered two. 
 Rugby Union: Lions to meet France under plain wrapper: Steve Bale on the Home Unions&equo; Bicentennial blunder 
 By STEVE BALE 
 THE HOME unions committee in its implacable pedantry refuses to recognise its French Bicentenary selection as Lions. 
 But Ian McGeechan, the coach, will be dependent on the successful work he did on tour in Australia to get his players ready for tomorrow's game against France at Parc des Princes. 
 &bquo;We have to try to build on what we did in Australia because we haven't time to do anything else,&equo; McGeechan said. 
 &bquo;All we can hope to do is get ourselves organised. 
 The fact that so many of them played together for the Lions will be an important help.&equo; 
 It is hard to view the Home Unions XV as other than Lions when McGeechan and Roger Uttley are the coaches and Clive Rowlands the manager &mdash; the managerial troika Down Under, back in harness. 
 After Donal Lenihan's withdrawal, the captaincy yesterday passed to Rob Andrew, the Lions stand-off in the second and third Test wins over the Wallabies, with Damian Cronin coming in at lock for the injured Irishman. 
 Last night, the No. 8 Phil Davies, protecting a rib injury, also dropped out. 
 Even with injury added to injury, the French make no bones about it: they style their visitors Les Lions Britanniques. 
 But events have conspired to leave McGeechan well short of a full Lions choice. 
 Finlay Calder's reasonable insistence that all of the Lions party who wished should be included on the trip, accompanied by wives or girlfriends, followed by his non-availability when this chance of expressing gratitude was rejected, have seen to that. 
 McGeechan regrets that the home unions committee has adhered so rigidly to the terms of its acceptance of the invitation 12 months ago. 
 &bquo;I was disappointed that the situation had to arise at all,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We can never re-create Australia but if the French were calling the side the Lions it would have been an appropriate thank-you to the players.&equo; 
 Some of them will be further reunited when the Barbarians round off the All Blacks' tour at Twickenham on 25 November. 
 First the Baa-Baas play Newport next Tuesday and there are seven Lions &mdash; Dods, Hall, Mullin, Guscott, Chalmers, Armstrong and Smith &mdash; in the side announced yesterday. 
 Rugby Union: Student leaders veto sponsors' deal 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 UNIVERSITIES' rugby, poised to sign a long-term sponsorship contract, has missed out on an immediate injection of &pound;35,000 after an embarrassing hitch resulted in the deal being kicked firmly into touch by student authorities. 
 Instead of a cause for celebration, yesterday's conference to announce the game's latest financial windfall was more like a wake as agents representing the sponsor explained the sorry situation. 
 In simple terms, sponsorship of the Universities' Athletic Union rugby championship alone is not acceptable to the UAU's hierarchy, who seek money for all student sporting activities and are looking for something in the region of &pound;100,000 to spread around. 
 If that were the case then rugby, the high profile student sport, would lose out financially. 
 Alun Evans, secretary of the Welsh football association who doubles up as chairman of the UAU committee, said: &bquo;I was informed by the chairman of the UAU rugby committee that he was discussing the possible sponsorship of its championship and I received a copy of a proposal&hellip; it contained a number of features which were not acceptable to the union and it was therefore with great surprise that we learned a launch for the sponsorship had been called and it was decided that the union could not agree to this action.&equo; 
 While UAU rugby has lost out on money, Blackheath have lost the services of their coach, Alex Keay. 
 &bquo;He's having a sabbatical while he sorts things out,&equo; Paul Rossiter-Marvell, the club's secretary, said yesterday. 
 &bquo;We've now got more coaches at the club than National Express, but he can come back if he wants to. 
 In my day the only coaches we had were called charabancs and had four wheels and a man in a peaked hat.&equo; 
 All that Keay is prepared to say on the subject is that he will continue to coach Middlesex in the county championship. 
 Schools Rugby: McCarthy is the key for Mount's 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 AMPLEFORTH entertained Mount St Mary's on Saturday to lose by a penalty to a goal, a try and two penalties, the 16-3 result ending the run of three unbeaten Ampleforth teams. 
 Mount's, who won at Rosslyn Park the previous year, seem certain to enjoy a profitable season. 
 Their key player is the fly-half Matthew McCarthy, who opened their scoring against Ampleforth with a penalty, and went on to make and then convert a try by Neil Ryan. 
 Another Yorkshire school, Hymer's, are showing excellent early form, following good wins against Ashville, 39-0, QEGS Wakefield, 18-8, and Silcoates, 20-13, with a much closer contest against Pocklington, 10-6. 
 The National Westminster Bank Sevens, at Sydenham, were won for a third successive time by Brynteg CS, who enjoyed a comfortable semi-final against St Benedict's, 20-4, before a demanding final against Campion, 10-6. 
 Campion had been cruelly extended in their semi-final, beating Judd 14-10. 
 Already this season Newcastle-under-Lyme School have beaten Bradford GS 12-7, and Ellesmere 10-6. 
 Newcastle, still unbeaten after victory away at Stockport GS last Saturday, 10-32, have demonstrated what brave tackling and team spirit can achieve. 
 Loretto, despite losing their first match to George Watson's, 3-19, have good wins over King's, Tynemouth, 24-0, and Glenalmond, 24-0, to their credit. 
 Scottish schools dominated the Hull University Schools' Festival, where Edinburgh Academy beat Merchiston Castle in a hard-fought final, 7-0. 
 Rugby League: Saints' raid irks McIntyre 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 CANBERRA RAIDERS arrived at Old Trafford yesterday with a complaint. 
 Their preparations for tomorrow's world club challenge against Widnes are being hampered, they allege, by would-be raiders from the English league. 
 John McIntyre, Canberra's chief executive, accused St Helens in particular of putting Mal Meninga under undue pressure. 
 Not only had Saints offered the Canberra captain a lucrative contract, McIntyre said, they had asked him to canvass his team-mates as well. 
 That Meninga would receive overtures from Knowsley Road was one of the more predictable consequences of Canberra's qualification for Old Trafford, but Hull were almost as quick off the mark with an approach for Chris O'Sullivan, and other players have apparently been contacted. 
 &bquo;All our players are contracted, and naturally we object to these unofficial approaches,&equo; McIntyre said. 
 &bquo;It is not just the lack of manners which appalls us, but the sheer bad timing. 
 We have come all this way to take part in a major game, not put ourselves up for auction.&equo; 
 Meninga, it must be said, did not look like a man under undue pressure as he genially fended press questions yesterday, even laughing off a suggestion from one of his braver interlocuters that his weight had recently ballooned. 
 At 29, the head Raider does not appear to accept that his best years are behind him, bad news perhaps for Jonathan Davies, for whom the press conference provided a first glimpse of a man whose reputation travels before him. 
 Doug Laughton, with injuries to Emosi Koloto and Mike O'Neill, toyed with the idea of moving Tony Myler into the pack and playing Davies at stand-off, but decided to keep the Welshman at centre, where he will come into direct confrontation with Meninga. 
 Davies can at least reflect that after tomorrow, his rugby league education will be complete. 
 New Zealand have named a changed side for the second match of their tour at Castleford tonight. 
 Only one player, Tawere Nikau, took part in the defeat at St Helens. 
 Castleford will again be without Kevin Ward and Keith England, and Graham Steadman and Ron Gibbs are doubtful. 
 Rugby Union: Rugby to view tape &bquo;evidence&equo; 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 OFFICIALS from Rugby will look at video evidence before deciding to take any action arising from their Courage Championship Second Division game with Richmond, during which Paul Gutteridge the Richmond tight head prop had his nose broken. 
 Richmond allege that it was a punch that shattered Gutteridge's nose and have studied video evidence before writing to Rugby, who now want to see the tape before making any response. 
 &bquo;Richmond's complaint is based on what they say was shown up by the video. 
 We feel we cannot comment on their allegations until we have seen it too,&equo; Roy Batchelor, Rugby's spokesman said. 
 Keith Cresswell, the Richmond secretary, has said that his club will not allow the matter to be swept under the carpet. 
 Lancashire have made two changes for their Toshiba County Championship match against Cumbria at Orrell tonight. 
 The lock Alan Wylie (Vale of Lune) replaces the injured Dave Cusani, and the wing forward Mark Hesketh (Fylde) is preferred to John Ingram (Orrell). 
 Both players will be making their debuts. 
 Lancashire will make a late fitness check on Orrell hooker Neil Hitchen, who is recovering from a neck injury. 
 Racing: Windway to breeze in again 
 By HYPERION (CHRIS CORRIGAN) 
 LARGE bundles of cash taken out of the Redcar betting ring on Saturday appear certain to turn up 275 miles away in the south of England today, writes Hyperion (Chris Corrigan). 
 Beneficiaries of Saturday's successful gamble, in which a dozen big bets cost the bookmakers more than &pound;25,000, are ready to play up their winnings when the same horse, UNIROYAL WINDWAY (nap 4.0), makes a quick reappearance this afternoon at Brighton. 
 The Redcar win, as 2-1 favourite in a seller, was the three-year-old's first success in 18 starts. 
 Today's run in a handicap is a step up in class, but David Chapman, who trains at Stillington, North Yorkshire, has clearly brought about a change in the colt's attitude since acquiring him from a Lambourn yard just two months ago. 
 At Wolverhampton, the bookmakers could also be dealt a blow by Shillelagh (next best 4.45). 
 This filly ran well behind Halstead at Sandown two weeks ago, and 7lb claimer Anthony Procter again takes the ride. 
 Racing: Nashwan steers wide of the Arc for finale 
 By JOHN COBB 
 NASHWAN'S owner and trainer yesterday decided against the only course of action that could have restored the reputation of their Derby winner as one of the outstanding racehorses of the post-war era by opting to by-pass the richest and usually most competitive race in Europe, the Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe. 
 Instead of returning on Sunday to Longchamp, the scene of his only defeat, Nashwan will head for Newmarket on 21 October and the Champion Stakes. 
 That race had been touted as a possible target for the French and Irish Derby winner Old Vic, who like Nashwan carries the colours of a member of the Maktoum family. 
 But Anthony Stroud, racing manager to Old Vic's owner, Sheikh Mohammed, believes it highly unlikely that the confrontation that every racegoer would love to witness, will take place. 
 &bquo;I would be surprised if it was decided to bring Old Vic back to tackle a mile and a quarter, even though it would be a nice idea,&equo; he said. 
 So Old Vic will probably make his last appearance of the year in Canada's International Stakes at Woodbine, Toronto, on the day after Nashwan runs in the Champion. 
 Travelling half-way round the world to run in a race that is two furlongs longer than one taking place in the town where Old Vic is trained seems a rather extreme route away from providing what could have been a thrilling contest. 
 But at least Old Vic is likely to be around next year, when Nashwan will be in residence at the Shadwell Stud of his owner, Hamdan Al Maktoum, vigorously trying to justify a syndication value of &pound;18m. 
 What is most disappointing though is that Nashwan is not to return to Paris to try to prove that his defeat in the Prix Niel by Golden Pheasant and French Glory, who now occupy prominent positions in the Arc betting, was because he was having an off-day rather than because he has deteriorated since his magnificent victories in the 2,000 Guineas, Derby and Eclipse Stakes earlier in the year. 
 Dick Hern, who announced the decision yesterday, would not elaborate on the reason for choosing the easier option of the Champion Stakes, but Willie Carson, Nashwan's rider, has said he would be loathe to try the horse at Longchamp again. 
 Without Nashwan, the chief British-trained challenger in the Arc will be Aliysa, who is competing with the recent winner of the Prix Vermeille, Young Mother, for favouritism. 
 Cacoethes, whose partner has yet to be confirmed, and Carroll House, for whom the going is likely to be a little on the fast side, are also certain runners, but Luca Cumani will not decide until today whether Legal Case will take his chance. 
 The Maktoums' main hope is now In The Wings, who has spent most of the season recuperating from an operation on a chipped knee. 
 He returned to action just over a week ago to show an impressive turn of foot in winning the Prix du Prince d'Orange. 
 Cash Asmussen is likely to be on board the unbeaten colt. 
 Racing: Shellac still in the running 
 By JOHN COBB 
 THE SENDER of the letter threatening Luca Cumani with violence unless he saddles the heavily backed Shellac in Saturday's Cambridgeshire will have been appeased, temporarily at least, by the fact that the colt was one of 42 horses declared yesterday at the five-day stage for the race, writes John Cobb. 
 Less happy will be those punters who supported Jamarj from 25-1 down to 16-1, as Peter Easterby, believing that the going at Newmarket is unlikely to ease in his filly's favour before the weekend, has withdrawn her. 
 &bquo;The ground is like cement here in Yorkshire and it is difficult to train the horses,&equo; Easterby said. 
 Instead of threatening Cumani, the punter with the violent rather than lucky streak should be kicking himself for not biding his time before backing Shellac. 
 William Hill, who sponsor the big handicap, are now offering with-a-run odds against the whole field and quote Shellac, who has alternative engagements, at 6-1. 
 Michael Roberts has been booked for another fancied horse in Red Paddy, but the best-backed horses yesterday were Blue Orca, who is as low as 12-1 with Ladbrokes but still 16-1 with Hills, and Tafila, who was offered at 33-1 yesterday morning but by the evening was generally 16-1. 
 &bquo;Independent&equo; features more news and sport 
 By JOHN COBB 
 A MAJOR expansion of The Independent begins today with more space for news, features and sport. 
 There will be an extra page of sport every weekday; today's five pages of unrivalled coverage starts on page 28. 
 The redesigned editorial page gives more space to readers' letters (page 18). 
 William Rees-Mogg's column moves to Monday and appears, with the book review, on page 19. 
 Peter Kellner moves to Friday. 
 Peter Jenkins will continue on Tuesday, Wednesday and Thursday. 
 An additional feature page, Focus, will appear every Tuesday and Thursday. 
 Tomorrow's Focus will examine the toxic waste chain and take an in-depth look at the problem of PCBs. 
 Wednesday sees the introduction of another new feature page, committed to architecture. 
 We believe these improvements will ensure that The Independent remains second to none in the breadth and depth of its coverage. 
 Dutch urge end to trade in rare wild orchids 
 From FRANCES WILLIAMS in Geneva 
 MANY OF the 60-odd species of slipper orchid, the best known and most popular orchid in the West, could be extinct within 10 years without tough measures to halt the vast illegal trade in wild varieties. 
 The Dutch government is so concerned that at next week's 103-nation conference in Lausanne of the Convention on Trade in Endangered Species (Cites) it will call for a total ban on trade in the plants. 
 It says the present system, which allows controlled international trade, has failed to prevent heavy illegal smuggling of wild Paphiopedilum (slipper) orchids. 
 High prices for rare specimens &mdash; one plant recently sold for &dollar;3,500 (&pound;2,170) &mdash; are an obvious incentive. 
 But even for more common varieties big money is made. 
 Plants can be bought in tens of thousands for 50 cents each in Bangkok, and sold for &dollar;10-&dollar;15 in the West. 
 Demand is steadily rising. 
 Ger Van Vliet, a Dutch botanist who heads the EC scientific working group on Cites, says wild orchids are easy to steal: &bquo;I could walk into a forest in Sabah (Borneo) and take away the last remaining specimens of a rare species in one suitcase.&equo; 
 Denmark and West Germany have now outlawed all imports of slipper orchids, and Britain has banned imports from Thailand, but environmentalists say comprehensive international action is needed. 
 Though orchids are easy to propagate from seed, and exporting them is exempt from Cites rules, traders have found it more profitable to dig plants up instead. 
 Dr Van Vliet wants the growing countries, including Burma, China, India, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines and Thailand, to be given help for artificial propagation when the trade in wild plants is banned. 
 Dr Van Vliet admits botanic gardens are among those who obtain rare orchids from the wild with no questions asked. 
 But the main culprits, he says, are private collectors prepared to pay extraordinary prices for rare specimens, and nurseries who buy more common types in huge quantities, most of which die after flowering. 
 Gorbachev bans strikes in key Soviet industries 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 THE SOVIET government is introducing emergency measures to stave off a winter economic crisis, including a 15-month ban on strikes in key industries and drastic moves to ensure the normal operation of the country's railways &mdash; above all to break Azerbaijan's blockade of Armenia. 
 A resolution enshrining the decisions is to be voted on by deputies today. 
 Last night a large majority approved a motion to that effect by Mikhail Gorbachev, who admitted more bluntly than ever before that reforms, far from strengthening the economy, were merely adding to its immediate difficulties. 
 &bquo;We cannot wait any longer,&equo; the Soviet leader said. 
 &bquo;Every extra day brings terrible consequences. 
 We have started to lose control of things. 
 New methods have not taken root, the old ones work no longer.&equo; 
 Lev Voronin, the Deputy Prime Minister, said it was essential to guarantee the functioning of the economy, especially with the harsh Soviet winter and its heavy demands on fuel and energy supplies approaching. 
 The measures will run to the end of 1990, the same period as wage controls imposed at the weekend. 
 They come amid rumblings of new strikes in several key sectors, after disruption which has already cost 5 million lost working days this year, and production shortfalls of billions of roubles. 
 The measures also outlaw &mdash; except in cases specifically approved by the government &mdash; any move to cut output of consumer goods, and place the railways in anarchic Soviet Transcaucasia under &bquo;direct rule&equo; by Moscow. 
 In an attempt to halt the shootings and bombings of recent months, key points like bridges and tunnels will be placed under permanent military guard. 
 Vadim Perfilyev, the Foreign Ministry spokesman, said yesterday that the contested region of Nagorny Karabakh, at the heart of the Azeri-Armenian conflict, was almost completely paralysed by the blockade. 
 In Armenia itself things are scarcely better. 
 All attempts to lift the blockade promoted by the powerful Azerbaijani Popular Front have failed. 
 The logjam on the railways is now playing havoc with the national economy. 
 Apart from the effect of the turmoil in Transcaucasia, Mr Voronin said the protracted rail strikes in Moldavia, which ended last month, had blocked 130 trains carrying consumer goods from Hungary, Czechoslovakia and Romania. 
 In September alone rail freight &bquo;disorganisation&equo; had cost 600,000 tonnes of scheduled deliveries of food and industrial supplies. 
 With winter just a month away, fuel stocks at power stations were 4.5 million tonnes below target, and the metallurgical sector was &bquo;critical&equo;, said Mr Voronin. 
 His words illustrate the growing disarray of the economy, caught between workers venting long-suppressed grievances and vague blueprints for change issued from the top. 
 Hours before Mr Voronin spoke, Nikolai Ryzhkov, the Prime Minister, presented no fewer than five ambitious draft bills on property, a single taxation system, companies, land ownership and leaseholding. 
 RUC faces claims of &bquo;loyalist force within' 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 A CLAIM that an unofficial loyalist &bquo;force within a force&equo; exists inside the Royal Ulster Constabulary gave fresh impetus yesterday to the long-running collusion controversy in Northern Ireland. 
 The allegation was made to a Belfast newspaper by an individual who showed a journalist documents containing the names of 233 people. 
 Terry McLaughlin, the deputy editor of the Irish News, said some of the material shown to him was marked &bquo;top secret&equo;, the highest security classification, and went beyond the type of photo-montage material that has been widely leaked over the past month. 
 The man claimed he spoke for a large group of serving and former policemen who styled themselves &bquo;the Inner Circle&equo;. 
 He said their aims were the removal of republican terrorists and the ending of the Anglo-Irish Agreement. 
 The RUC said the claims would be investigated. 
 A nationwide alert went out in the Irish Republic last night for Patrick Sheehy, one of Scotland Yard's most wanted terrorist suspects. 
 He is believed to have been one of two armed men who last month hijacked a police car, prompting a manhunt over three Irish counties. 
 Detectives have been hunting him since the discovery of a bomb factory in a London flat shortly before last Christmas. 
 Channel tunnel funding crisis deepens: Consortium seeks fresh finance after costs soar by 50 percent to 7 billion pounds 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON and COLIN BROWN 
 THE FUTURE of the Channel tunnel was in doubt last night after confirmation that costs have escalated by 50 per cent to at least &pound;7bn and a warning that its bankers may not provide fresh loans unless the financial crisis surrounding the project is resolved by Christmas. 
 Eurotunnel, the Anglo-French consortium that will operate the twin-rail tunnel when it is scheduled to enter service in June 1993, shocked the City by announcing that costs had risen by &pound;2.2bn from an original estimate of &pound;4.8bn, with the 50-kilometre tunnel still only one-quarter built. 
 The consortium also disclosed that it would need up to &pound;1.6bn in fresh finance on top of the &pound;6bn already raised. 
 The gloom was deepened further by the disclosure that the independent technical adviser to banks financing the project puts the cost at &pound;8.1bn and believes the tunnel will open six months late, in December 1993. 
 The crisis surrounding the tunnel threatens to embarrass the Government, which insisted it be financed entirely by the private sector. 
 The escalation in costs is certain to shake the confidence of private investors who have spent &pound;1bn on the project. 
 The news of the cost overrun caused Eurotunnel's share price to fall 100p at one stage, although it recovered slightly to close 45p down at 650p. 
 Labour's transport spokesman, John Prescott, called on the Government to rescue the project by taking it into public control. 
 However, sources close to the Secretary of State for Transport, Cecil Parkinson, dismissed this possibility. 
 &bquo;There is no way we are going to support it with public money. 
 We are not going back on that,&equo; a source said. 
 At the heart of the funding crisis is a continuing dispute over costs between Eurotunnel and Transmanche Link, a consortium of 10 British and French construction firms building the tunnel. 
 In a statement to stock exchanges in London and Paris yesterday morning, Eurotunnel said: &bquo;In those circumstances, the banks&equo; technical adviser produced a high cost estimate for the current banking case. 
 We and the banks are agreed that this is not an appropriate basis for further finance.&equo; 
 Eurotunnel, which is already in default of its credit agreement with the banks, has in effect been given until the end of the year to settle its differences with the contractors to permit &bquo;a viable financing strategy to be put in place&equo;. 
 If agreement cannot be reached, the banks, which include National Westminster and Midland, have the power to close the project or bring in fresh management. 
 Last night Alastair Morton, the British co-chairman of Eurotunnel, said the banks could be driven to this &bquo;by sheer exasperation through lack of progress in the talks&equo;. 
 However, Mr Morton added: &bquo;Technically it is serious. 
 The banks can pull the plug. 
 Practically, the banks are not wishing to pull the plug. 
 They are not wishing to stop the project.&equo; 
 In a statement issued with Andre Benard, his French counterpart, Mr Morton said he believed agreement could be reached in time to put a fresh financial package in place by early next year. 
 This would involve raising an extra &pound;1.2bn to &pound;1.6bn. 
 Of this, 25 per cent would come from a share issue in 1990 or 1991 and new bank borrowings. 
 However, a number of &bquo;essential differences&equo; between Eurotunnel and Transmanche Link need to be resolved. 
 These include agreement on curbing the cost of terminals and equipment &mdash; where the contactors' estimate is &pound;382m higher than that of Eurotunnel. 
 Mr Prescott's demand for the tunnel to be taken into public ownership goes beyond existing Labour Party policy. 
 Although he did not commit a future Labour government to taking the tunnel into public ownership, he made it clear that he believed it would require a public stake to complete the project. 
 Mr Parkinson is to defend the Government's stand at the Conservative Party conference next week. 
 He is also expected to attack Mr Prescott's call for public control of the tunnel. 
 Mr Prescott said: &bquo;If private capital cannot produce the goods as it said it could, they should be given a short period of time to clear the mess up, or we will take it over. 
 I don't think there is any reason to feel obliged to people who put the capital in. 
 &bquo;The main concern is to get the tunnel built with the French. 
 If it requires public money to sustain it, it then directly becomes a public project because the private sector have failed to achieve it.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Labour votes to cut defence spending 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 LABOUR LEADERS last night suffered the first setback of the Brighton conference when delegates overwhelmingly rejected pleas for unity by demanding heavy cuts in defence spending. 
 As expected, the conference carried the policy review statement on multilateral nuclear disarmament &mdash; with the objective of achieving a nuclear-free world by the end of the century. 
 The debate was enlivened by contributions from long-standing unilateralists like Tony Benn, Ron Todd and Bruce Kent, the former leader of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament. 
 Labour leaders were strongly criticised for embracing an &bquo;unprincipled&equo; U-turn away from unilateralism in an attempt to win votes at the next election. 
 Neil Kinnock, who will make his keynote speech today, said last night: &bquo;It's difficult for people who have held an opinion for a long time, and possibly haven't considered all of the aspects. 
 &bquo;As I've said before directly to the Labour Party, &bquo;You must make up your minds. 
 Do you want to talk about disarmament or do you want to help those in the White House and in the Kremlin who are really trying to do something effective about it?&equo; 
 The only way in which we can help is having a Labour government that has a policy to secure verifiable arms reductions. 
 That's our policy. 
 We're looking forward to the opportunity of helping.&equo; 
 But Mr Kinnock's delight with the defence statement victory was marred by the successful left-wing rearguard action, calling for a cut in defence spending, &bquo;initially to equal the average level of other West European countries&equo;. 
 Proposing the resolution, Mr Kent said it would mean a cut of at least &pound;5bn &mdash; a quarter of this year's defence budget. 
 Before the debate, Gerald Kaufman, the party's foreign affairs spokesman, criticised the resolution for its imprecision in not giving a time scale, and for ambiguity in not defining the precise level of spending required. 
 He also warned: &bquo;I prefer it not to be carried because the Conservatives, who are desperately clinging at straws because of the popularity of our policy, against the irrelevance of theirs, would do what they could to make mischief about it.&equo; 
 In the event, the resolution was carried by a two-to-one majority. 
 A party spokesman then suggested that it would be ignored, saying: &bquo;Future levels of defence spending will be considered by a Labour government solely in the context of implementing the policy review.&equo; 
 In the debate itself, some of the behind-the-scenes tensions were reflected by party spokesmen attempting to discredit Mr Benn's contribution, pointing out that he had served in Labour governments which maintained nuclear weapons. 
 In spite of the setback on the defence spending vote, Mr Kinnock later scored a further advance with the results of the national executive elections, which saw Ken Livingstone replaced by John Prescott, the party's robust transport spokesman. 
 Architecture: Invisible buildings that reflect nothing: The subtopian, A-road design of many of our cities is destroying their character, Jonathan Glancey believes. 
 Most critics ignore the dreariness of our streets, but it is time for the public to demand better 
 By JONATHAN GLANCEY 
 THIS is the architecture that dare not speak its name. 
 It professes no particular architectural creed; it belongs to no recognisable school of design. 
 Tags such as Modern, Post-Modern, High-Tech or even Neo-Classical are wholly redundant when you stare at this subtopian, A-road architecture. 
 The specialist architectural press ignores this amorphous school of design, while even the Prince of Wales has nothing to say on the subject, reserving his spleen for imaginative buildings that he and so many of his future subjects profess to hate. 
 The current architectural debate has served to polarise popular opinion on modern architecture. 
 Richard Rogers and the bravura City of London headquarters he designed for Lloyds are presented as unmitigated villains. 
 The burgeoning Neo-Classical architects, such as John Simpson and Quinlan Terry, are, by nature of the style they choose to work in, a good thing. 
 Modern British architects worth their salt, or future knighthoods, can be counted on a few colour spreads of the Prince of Wales's bestselling book A Vision of Britain. 
 But a national debate on architecture at this level is as banal as it is unhelpful. 
 It is an easy trick to target controversial buildings and, in the mind's eye at least, to pull them down. 
 Of course the Lloyds building is hard for many people to swallow. 
 A highly crafted, hugely sophisticated building-machine that rewrites so many rules of conventional corporate architecture is inevitably hard to digest. 
 So were the great Victorian railway stations that we now profess to admire, almost uncritically. 
 Like the best wines, distinguished architecture matures over time: 50 years from now, Lloyds will be championed by as yet unborn conservationists, fought over in the media and ultimately listed Grade One. 
 Lloyds is no more outlandish or intrusive than Tower Bridge and much less so than the monstrous and melancholy Battersea Power Station, a sublime work of imperious architecture that Londoners once loved to hate but now admire. 
 But neither Londoners nor Mancunians, Geordies, Scousers, Brummies nor Bristolians appear to have anything to say about the almost invisible architecture that continues to destroy the character of British cities: the architecture with no name. 
 Take, for example, the Hammersmith Road in west London. 
 It links Hammersmith Broadway with the brutal concrete-and-steel Thirties exhibition halls at Olympia. 
 This clotted traffic artery is lined from one end to another with new office buildings of the type illustrated in the picture above. 
 No one looks at these buildings. 
 They have no remarkable features to catch the eye, nor, in tandem, do they form a satifying or picturesque group as a street of Georgian terraces does. 
 Each is different in mild degrees and minor sensations from its neighbours. 
 But because each refuses to acknowledge its neighbours, the net effect in terms of the streetscape is less than zero. 
 Some of the buildings are faced in a swathe of reflective glass that merely reflects other mundane buildings, some in brick, some with half-hearted Post-Modern details. 
 Because each has nothing to say, the mirrored buildings simply reflect a bigger nothing. 
 Each building along the Hammersmith Road is a mishmash of tired cliches, from mirrored wall glazing to low brick walls studded with small withered plants separating entrances from pavement. 
 Each is meant to be an improvement on the overwhelming developers architecture of the Sixties, of which Hammersmith is a shrine. 
 But the use of inexpertly laid and brightly coloured bricks, token pitched roofs and arched windows does not make for likeable architecture. 
 Nor does the fact that the latest buildings are uniformly low; they are simply low and boring rather than high and boring. 
 This new wave of anonymous buildings, designed to slip as quickly as possible through local authority planning procedures, has ripped the heart out of Hammersmith. 
 But the area is not unique. 
 In fact, Hammersmith Road might belong to any British city that has been silently raped during the past few years. 
 Hammersmith Road and its schlock architecture is proof that conservationists are not as powerful as the architectural profession likes to believe. 
 Those who design, develop and approve this marginally acceptable architecture must be delighted that its very banality keeps critics and hostile public opinion at bay. 
 These buildings are not so controversial that passers-by, princes or those who work in them feel moved to express an opinion, either positive or negative. 
 We continue to turn a blind eye to the architecture with no name, preferring instead to attack the buildings that future generations will admire. 
 What can be done to stop the spread of this silent architectural disease creeping through the veins and arteries of our cities? 
 First, it should he held up for critical inspection, pilloried when necessary. 
 Second, the British public needs to see exactly what good modern architecture is, to be shown what a city street such as Hammersmith Road could become if served by the best architects and developers. 
 Third, people should get hot under the collar when presented with dreary architecture. 
 When the designs for I M Pei's steel-and-glass pyramid at the Louvre were unveiled four years ago, there was a running battle between police and conservationists in the hallowed courtyards of the rambling museum. 
 Right or wrong, the incident showed that people cared about what would happen to the Louvre. 
 Pitched battles in Hammersmith Road, London's Docklands, Birmingham or Edinburgh are unlikely, but local people must express their opinions. 
 Architectural plans are not local authority or state secrets. 
 All have a right to see the new architecture planned for their town. 
 In Birmingham, local residents are struggling to stop, or at least change the nature of the giant new retail redevelopment, designed by Chapman Taylor &amp; Partners for the developers London &amp; Edinburgh Trust, which is planned to replace the infamous early Sixties Bull Ring. 
 In Leeds, local councillors have been sheepish about releasing plans to local people for what might just prove to be one of the most inspired and humane post-war city centre redevelopments masterminded by the architects Terry Farrell and Rob Krier for the Dutch developer MAB. 
 The more people get used to prodding, weighing and evaluating new planning proposals, the less likely it is that the Hammersmith effect will spread further. 
 Architecture: The eagle is landing in west London: Swedish architect Ralph Erskine has designed an office block in which Dan Dare would feel at home, should he wish to work in Hammersmith 
 By JONATHAN GLANCEY 
 HAMMERSMITH in west London, home of some all too visible faceless architecture, has been chosen as the site of what promises to be one of Britain's most remarkable buildings, an enormous office block designed on natural lines by the Royal Gold Medallist Ralph Erskine, Jonathan Glancey writes. 
 Developed by Talgarth Estates for the Swedish firms Ake Larson and Enator, the Erskine building will rise, like a submarine breaking the ocean surface, alongside the Hammersmith flyover and London Underground's Piccadilly and District lines. 
 It would be difficult to imagine a more unnatural site for Ralph Erskine to work on. 
 Erskine, long resident in Stockholm, is known for the warm, humane domestic, public and commercial buildings he has designed in Sweden over the past 50 years. 
 In Britain he is best known for the remarkable Byker Wall housing scheme in Newcastle-upon-Tyne. 
 At Byker, Erskine built some of the most likeable local authority housing of the 1970s behind a massive and sinuous brick wall designed to keep the roar of a proposed urban motorway at bay. 
 The motorway was never built, but Byker has become a model of how to build low-cost housing on a large, yet humane scale. 
 At Hammersmith Erskine's building will sit on an island site, doing its best to protect those who work in it from the surrounding aural and visual pollution. 
 In terms of context, Erskine is shooting in the dark. 
 He could hardly adapt the style of the building's closest neighbour, the Soviet-like Novotel Hotel. 
 Although large, the building will be no leviathan. 
 The nautical outline will reduce its bulk, while the periscoped roof will curve over a central atrium open at the edges to the elements. 
 On the flyover side, the building will be nine storeys high, declining to five storeys on its south side. 
 Designed unfashionably from the inside out (Erskine remains a committed Modernist), the building should provide some of the most relaxed office space in London. 
 Given its hostile setting, the office needs to pamper those who work in it with a range of leisure facilities, including restaurants, squash courts and a gymnasium. 
 The upper floors give on to stepped and landscaped terraces, some internal, some external protected by the umbrella roof. 
 Equally significant is the fact that the developers are providing a two-storey building alongside for use by the London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham. 
 The borough plans to house its archives in this &bquo;lilla huset&equo; (Swedish for &bquo;little house&equo;), together with an urban study centre for local schools and a business studies centre for the borough's training programme. 
 Erskine's office will be faced in bronze between tinted glass, stand on a highly textured brick base in a sea of foliage and be topped by a copper roof. 
 Given its setting, the building is almost inevitably a little like a spaceship settling on the dangerous surface of an alien planet. 
 It is designed to cosset its crew. 
 Perhaps the nearest the British have got to a building like this has been in the pages of The Eagle. 
 Frank Hampson's brilliantly executed colour illustrations in the &bquo;Dan Dare&equo; strip of the Fifties and early Sixties often depicted futuristic buildings of the 1990s which bore a remarkable similarity to the Erskine block. 
 It is unlikely, however, that the 75-year-old Erskine has been influenced by Dan Dare. 
 The truth is that comic illustrator and award-winning architect have both been greatly influenced by the architecture of Frank Lloyd Wright. 
 From some angles it is clear that the Hammersmith building is a homage to Lloyd Wright's spiralling Guggenheim Museum in Manhattan. 
 On another level, the building can be seen as an ark bearing its precious human cargo through a decidely rough sea of bad urban planning and even worse architecture. 
 The London Borough of Hammersmith has previously rejected inspired schemes by at least two of Britain's most interesting architects. 
 Both Norman Foster, architect of the Hong Kong and Shanghai Bank headquarters, and Terry Farrell, designer of the new-look Charing Cross station complex, developed highly intelligent proposals for the reconstruction of Hammersmith Broadway. 
 Instead of Farrell or Foster, Hammersmith settled for a flashy Post-Modern office and retail development which, while providing the sort of covered spaces the borough wanted, led nowhere architecturally. 
 By voting for Ralph Erskine there is a chance &mdash; assuming that executive architects Rock Townsend and Lennart Bergstroms can reach the meticulous standards set by their Swedish master &mdash; that Hammersmith will point the way ahead for a new generation of user-friendly, environmentally soft commercial architecture. 
 Architecture Viewpoint: Redemption for the developer 
 By ROWAN MOORE 
 The author is an architect in private practice IN MODERN demonologies, property developers rank high. 
 While other ways of making money become more respectable and sometimes laudable, developers are still seen as the spiritual heirs of Victorian millowners and slum landlords, people who, even as they tear the hearts out of cities, simultaneously give then a fatal sclerosis. 
 It is not inevitable that this should be so. 
 Developers' ancestors include such admired figures as John Nash, the Adams brothers together with the builders of Bath, Bloomsbury and the New Town in Edinburgh. 
 The London we have now is predominantly the work of developers. 
 Such people are not all motivated simply by money, but by an interest in building and in architecture and, like everyone else, they have to live with their creations. 
 In theory, market forces ought to ensure that the consumer rejects inferior products and makes them unsellable. 
 Of course, distance lends enchantment to the work of developers of the past. 
 To Dickens, Georgian terraces were both barren and vulgar, just like modern suburban estates. 
 To a disenchanted eye, Nash seems not quite the genius he is generally thought to have been: he was a notorious jerry-builder who pillaged and cheapened classical motifs as does the builder of the modern executive home. 
 If he had had fibreglass Corinthian columns at his disposal, he would have used them. 
 Many of the spaces he created, such as those in the Mall or Waterloo Place, are distinctly dismal and void. 
 Yet the London we inherited from the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries is more or less a success. 
 Today, with projects as large as Canary Wharf, Broadgate and King's Cross, the developer is once again a town planner. 
 Current proposals for Birmingham envisage that the centre of the city be privately owned, closed at night if necessary, and guarded by private security. 
 The rise of the speculative office block presents problems with which someone like Nash would have been unfamiliar. 
 With offices, the purchaser is not necessarily the user. 
 The people most affected by them &mdash; office workers and passers-by &mdash; have little or no influence on their design, and are dependent on the benevolence of the developer and on planning laws. 
 Commercial pressures are hostile to the creation of space, except in the most limited and functional sense, either inside or out. 
 The ideal interior is neutral and unobstructed, while the demand for floor area pushes buildings to the limits of their sites, making public spaces, or any but the thinnest facades, unprofitable. 
 As the creation of space is the primary concern, it is not surprising the interests of developers and of the well-being of cities are so often in conflict. 
 The struggle between commercial pressure and good architecture is an unequal one, on which many developers are not prepared to expend much energy. 
 They value their architects more for their business demeanours than for their designs, and choose them from a limited number of established companies, more valued for reliability than originality. 
 These architects are good at dissembling the bulkiness of their buildings to planning committees, less so to the passer-by when they are actually built. 
 The bulk of new buildings in Westminster and the City are by such firms, in styles ranging from corporate Modern to corporate Post-Modern. 
 An important challenge facing a developer is that of getting the most out of the planning system. 
 The more creative will experiment with less conventional architects if it will help them win planning permission. 
 At Richmond Riverside, an unpopular, over-dense office development was rendered quite acceptable when the developers brought in Quinlan Terry to redesign it. 
 There are developers for whom a building is not just another source of profit and who want to be good patrons. 
 At one extreme is Ian Pollard, creator of the Marco Polo building in Battersea. 
 His designs borrow freely from both ancient Egypt and modern architecture's greatest hits &mdash; Beaubourg, the Stuttgart Staatsgalerie, the Louvre Pyramid; he reapplies them to office blocks and shopping centres in Peckham with unabashed irrelevance. 
 At another extreme is Peter Palumbo, still struggling to realise his Stirling-designed scheme opposite the Mansion House. 
 If Pollard's architecture is so disposable and flippant that it is odd to call him a &bquo;patron&equo;, Palumbo's patronage is so single-minded that he can hardly be called a developer. 
 He has yet, in fact, to get something built. 
 In the middle are figures such as Godfrey Bradman and Stuart Lipton who build a great deal. 
 Like Palumbo, they embody an image of developers both more friendly and more respectable: Bradman is a prominent Friend of the Earth; Lipton is a member of the Royal Fine Arts Committee. 
 Armed with Lipton's motto &mdash; &bquo;Good architecture is good business&equo; &mdash; they employ a wide range of architects, both established and up-and-coming, commonly thought of as &bquo;good&equo;. 
 The main source and authority in selecting architects is the consensus created by the trade press. 
 The theory is that &bquo;quality architecture&equo; not only helps you get planning permission, but attracts tenants and employees. 
 Sometimes the buildings even function better. 
 The policy has been only an equivocal success. 
 Bradman's and Lipton's demands on speed, cost and high-floor areas are no less than other developers'. 
 In addition, they promote fast-track, prefabricated building techniques that further restrict the architect's freedom. 
 As a result, they have the knack of employing the best architects, but not getting the best out of them. 
 Given the requirements of speculative offices, it is perhaps inevitable that this should happen, but it is preferable to getting average work out of average architects. 
 More curious is the extreme catholicism of their patronage. 
 In an architectural world supposedly rent by stylistic conflict, Lipton and Bradman both employ architects ranging from the most modernist to the most traditional; from Foster and Rogers to Quinlan Terry and Leon Krier. 
 Their architects can be bland multinationals, such as the American SOM, to rampant individualists such as John Outram. 
 At Paternoster Square, Lipton was involved in the competition that led to the appointment of Arup Associates, whose scheme was promptly criticised by Prince Charles. 
 The architect John Simpson then produced a Neo-Classical counter proposal, which Bradman, Lipton's former partner, is now proposing to build. 
 The implication is that style is inconsequential and almost content-free, and that speculative buildings are not really designed by architects, but by commercial forces. 
 In this case, the stylistic promiscuity of an Ian Pollard or a Nash is simply an exceptionally accurate reflection of their culture. 
 On the other hand, extreme plagiarism, banality or cynicism still induce a certain queasiness in the beholder, which suggests there is some point in good architecture. 
 Given the demands of their business, it is improbable that developers will commission masterpieces, but it is in their power to avoid monstrosities. 
 Architecture Update: Pleasing for a fee 
 By ROWAN MOORE 
 OCTOGENARIAN American architect Philip Johnson once said: &bquo;Architecture is very much like the oldest profession in the world. 
 It has only one aim and that is to please for a fee.&equo; 
 I wonder what Johnson might make of this press release from the British architects RMJM? 
 &bquo;Architects/Engineers RMJM have been flying high recently, rubbing shoulders with royalty, not once but twice within a week. 
 First the Princess of Wales opened a new annex to Chelmsford College of Further Education&hellip; and secondly, HRH The Prince of Wales opened the exhibition &bquo;A Vision of Britain' at the Victoria &amp; Albert Museum, which was designed by David Lloyd-Jones of RMJM. 
 What will RMJM's next royal project be?&equo; 
 All suggestions gratefully received. 
 Architecture: Stairway to fashion: Joseph Ettedgui's latest emporium 
 By ROWAN MOORE 
 FASHION (Azzedine Alaa) and architecture (Eva Jiricna) fuse in a perfect match at the new Joseph shop in London's Sloane Street. 
 The centrepiece of Joseph Ettedgui's latest emporium is this complex glass stair held together by a delicate spider's web of steel rods, split pins and steel rings. 
 This is the latest and most daring in a sequence of dramatic stairs designed by Jiricna. 
 It links the three floors of the shop and makes for a glamorous, if vertiginous, catwalk. 
 It was as expensive as it looks, but then, Alaa bolero tops do not come at bargain basement prices and in any case who could resist the temptation to pirouette up stairs like this? 
 TELEVISION / Trading places 
 By THOMAS SUTCLIFFE 
 THE promising first episode of The Paradise Club (BBC 1) turns out to have been, if not actually lying, then at least telling some fibs. 
 Or, as the characters would probably say, this being a series infatuated with villainous jargon, &bquo;You've bin telling porkies, PC &mdash; and in my manor we're strictly kosher&equo;. 
 The promise was for an own-brand Minder; cocky and cockney like the original &mdash; low- or middle-brow entertainment with a high gloss. 
 Such programmes are sometimes dismissed as being merely &bquo;slick&equo;, when slickness is anything but mere, or as if &bquo;sloppy&equo; were somehow preferable. 
 Three weeks on, The Paradise Club proves the contrary: it is now looking less like a showroom model than a motor on which the clock has been wound back and the polish is beginning to fade. 
 The problems with the vehicle are not so much with the engine (Murray Smith's script) as with the bodywork (Anthony Wilkinson's direction). 
 One symptomatic scene concerned the robbery of a petrol station by a young saxophonist considering a criminal career. 
 He was filmed prancing round the forecourt like a wayward member of a modern dance troupe; the witnesses in the passing cars wouldn't just have noticed his approach, they would probably have pulled up to watch, so bizarre and entertaining were his surreptitious motions. 
 The fact that this was credible only if the youth was retarded made the moral crux which followed rather pointless. 
 Elsewhere the errors were more elementary &mdash; during a scene which looked suspiciously like product placement for a Canadian lager there was a continuity error which would have been embarrassing in a home-movie. 
 If the BBC is to be persuaded to buy more drama from the independent street traders outside the building the merchandise will need to be a little better finished than this. 
 Despite the emetic title and glittering opening sequence, The Famous Teddy Z (BBC 2) turned out to be in control of Hollywood glitz rather than in thrall to it. 
 A comic fairy tale about innocence triumphant in the snake-pit of a Los Angeles talent agency, it has a likeable hero and a nice line in deflating humour. 
 &bquo;What do they make at this place?&equo; asks the disapproving Greek matriarch when her grandson returns from work. 
 &bquo;Telephone calls&equo; he replies hesitantly. 
 Teddy gets his promotion after punching the agency's biggest client, a sociopathic film-star, thus proving his honesty in a town of yes-men. 
 In real life he would have been sued for millions and his story turned into a mini-series, but it's nice to dream. 
 INTERVIEW / Industrious relations: Novelist David Lodge talks to Mark Lawson about the television version of his latest book Nice Work 
 By MARK LAWSON 
 THE MAKING of Nice Work, David Lodge's adapation for the BBC of his 1988 novel which divides between academia and industry, required extensive filming in both a foundry and a lecture hall. 
 On screen, the workers look convincingly swarthy and the students credibly dazed but two different levels of reality are involved. 
 The Equity rules demand the use of actors unless a special skill or talent is required. 
 Therefore, the background of the factory scenes features men doing their real work but the scarved and denimed wraiths seen taking lecture notes are actors, it apparently being the Equity assumption that to be a student requires no particular talent or skill. 
 Universities attract this kind of attitude, as, to some extent, does the campus novel, a brand of fiction which is probably the closest English departments have previously come to industrial production. 
 David Lodge, whose Changing Places (1975) and Small World (1984) are among the best of the Higher Education narratives, admits that Nice Work was the novel with which he consciously tried to lose the name of campus novelist. 
 His neat modern home &mdash; his study stuffed with the 100 or so original runners for the 1989 Booker Prize, whose judging panel he is chairing &mdash; is still close to the University of Birmingham, where he became Professor of English in 1976, but he took early retirement two years ago. 
 Completed shortly after he got out of the university, Nice Work retreated from academe to the extent of featuring a central character &mdash; Vic Wilcox, a dour Midlands MD &mdash; who, almost uniquely among his fictional creations, would not have read the novels of David Lodge. 
 Appropriately, the Wilcox narrative seems to be the book of his most widely read by the kind of people who have just put in a tough day at the office or have two weeks on the beach before clocking back on. 
 With paperback sales of 200,000 and rising, far more than any of his previous titles, the novel was jostling in the lists this summer with Jeffrey Archer and Wilbur Smith. 
 The television serial should return it there. 
 If Nice Work was the novel with which Lodge gave two of his keenest preoccupations the slip &mdash; the university, partially, and Catholicism, totally &mdash; it was also the book which should end the habitual conflation in some minds of his own career and output with that of Malcolm Bradbury. 
 Once colleagues and still friends, their similar redbrick-professor-writer lifestyles and largely campus subject-matter have made them a joined personality. 
 Typically, the Birmingham man's interest in writing for television coincided with the East Anglia one's. 
 Lodge was recently amused by the arrival from America of the first critical monograph about him. 
 Titled The Dialogic Novels of Malcolm Bradbury and David Lodge, it may yet turn out to be a joke played by Bradbury. 
 Lodge, an amusing and amiable 54, has previously enjoyed much flirtation but little consummation from film and television. 
 A work as early as The British Museum Is Falling Down (1965), about the Rhythm Method of Catholic-approved contraception, was conceived as a movie by Mel Frank but never born. 
 A different kind of period piece, Changing Places, was optioned for Hollywood by Otto Plaschkes but never reached the screen. 
 Subsequently, the apotheosis of Lodge's treatment of the comedy of Catholicism, How Far Can You Go? (1980) was bought for LWT by its then head, John Birt, a lapsed Catholic. 
 He left during pre-production and it is said on the South Bank that nobody even dared tell Birt's successor, the more ruggedly populist Greg Dyke, of the project's existence. 
 Small World, bought by Granada, did reach the viewers but also reviewers who had doubts as large as those of the novelist's most apostate Catholic characters. 
 When BBC Birmingham bought Nice Work, Lodge signed to write the screenplay himself. 
 One of the difficulties with interpreting Small World visually had been that, like many of his texts, it features extended literary pastiche. 
 Should you, for the screen, attempt to find some equivalent visual pastiche or try to carry the original concept through dialogue? 
 The writer acknowledges this difficulty but thinks that the most recent novel fits the screen more easily. 
 The original text cut in celluloid editing fashion between Wilcox's factory and Rummidge University, an invented Midlands campus, from which a feminist lecturer, Robyn Penrose, was despatched to observe Wilcox in action as part of a Shadow Scheme to mark Industry Year 1986. 
 Lodge, who had originally planned a potentially sombre first-person novel about the mid-life crisis of a Brummie businessman, invented the Shadow Scheme as his cover story while following around an executive for research. 
 &bquo;It's a rather scenic novel, anyway, so that helps the adaptation,&equo; says Lodge. 
 &bquo;Even so, there is a certain brutality involved in the adaptation of it. 
 The scene in the book where Robyn arrives at the factory for the first time and goes and has a conversation with Wilcox, that's four pages, which would take 15 minutes in playing time if you acted it out. 
 In fact, it's two minutes on screen. 
 What you leave out isn't bad dialogue, it's book dialogue.&equo; 
 Within certain laws of the land, a novelist can do what he wants. 
 A television production is attended by many more restrictions. 
 A scene in the book singled out by many of its critical admirers &mdash; in which Robyn instructs Vic in the theories of metaphor and metonymy with reference to a Silk Cut commercial on a hoarding &mdash; is absent from the serial. 
 This is partly because of the speech's length but also partly because of the difficulty of showing the advert on the BBC; even if the corporation agreed, the manufacturers would not. 
 Equally, the key word in Robyn's deconstruction of what Silk Cut really means is one which could not be spoken on television. 
 Most of the sex in the original text survives but the producers are aware that fictional nipples are being counted by the kind of heaving bodies which consist of several men in suits. 
 One scene in the BBC Nice Work will present an interesting test-case for Lord Rees-Mogg. 
 Thoroughly modern Robyn is into non-penetrative sex. 
 His Lordship will need to assess whether the nudity involved in the depiction of this is more corrupting to young eyes than the safety of the encounter is exemplary. 
 Another ethical aspect of the passage of words into pictures is that of filming permissions. 
 The organisers of a Dusseldorf trade show for manufacturers withdrew permission to film there after reading a scene in which German businessmen try to trick Wilcox. 
 In a previous BBC serial about the moral bankruptcy and satanic drabness of a fictional new town, the polite credits' acknowledgment to the real modern conurbation which had admitted the cameras had an inadvertent satirical ring. 
 Accordingly, in the television Nice Work, Rummidge University is played by Birmingham University and fears that some may find the performance too convincing have prompted a closing caption, of conspicuously meticulous wording, thanking the real campus for its &bquo;good-humoured co-operation&equo;. 
 &bquo;Rummidge is a fictional construct,&equo; explains Lodge. 
 &bquo;The fact that it has some kind of playful relationship with Birmingham is something with which readers of my novels can easily cope. 
 Television works with the literal image, so if you know Birmingham University as a bloody great clock tower, that's what you get&hellip;&equo; 
 Even in book form, his novels have required the amused tolerance of colleagues. 
 &bquo;In the Eighties, a lot of people felt, I think, that any satirical comment on the university was inopportune, some kind of betrayal. 
 I don't think novelists can be responsible for the PR consequences of what they write.&equo; 
 In two other senses, though, Lodge has also operated as the enemy within. 
 He still attends Mass on Sunday although he must be, to some of the more conventional believers kneeling beside him, what Philip Roth is to orthodox Jews. 
 He admits: &bquo;I am a Catholic of a very marginal, demythologised kind&hellip; 
 I realised writing How Far Can You Go? how little of the conceptual faith I had grown up with I still retained&hellip;&equo; 
 In the church of the new literary criticism, he has also prayed and mocked, publishing critical books of his own but satirising the gurus of metafictional inquiry in his novels: Nice Work's laconic demolition of Lacan has survived to reach the BBC. 
 A French lecturer at a symposium he addressed complained that he and Bradbury &bquo;let the side down, by mocking when there is so much philistine opposition&equo;. 
 Neatly, for a writer whose work is characterised by the comic accomodations of the half-believer, the terms in which Lodge's defence is couched once again join them to beat them. 
 &bquo;I think one of the functions of the novel is to offer a critique of the totalising claims of discourse to give a total explanation, whether the discourse be literary, religious or industrial.&equo; 
 MUSIC / Some swan songs: Elisabeth Soderstrom 
 By MEREDITH OAKES 
 ELISABETH Soderstrom was ill the Monday before last, and had to postpone her recital in the Blackheath International Song Series by a week. 
 She was not particularly well last Sunday, when she gave it. 
 The programme had some good out-of-the-wayish music: notably songs by Stenhammar and Rachmaninov, and Prokofiev's brilliantly direct, inventive setting of The Ugly Duckling. 
 Everything was Nordic or Russian except the Lehar group that came at the end. 
 Jubal, by Sibelius, made the cruellest possible start for an unwell soprano. 
 It had bare, exposed recitative telling how Jubal killed a swan and learnt music from its dying song, and twanging, soft, oscillating piano octaves within which the voice was supposed to lodge with accurate purity. 
 Soderstrom &mdash; who later in the concert jokingly apologised for her scratchiness &mdash; was obviously miserable, more miserable than she needed to be, about the quality of the sound she was making, and her misery took the form of distinguished concentration on pitch, so that there were many small uncharacteristic faults in her intonation. 
 High notes were a bit of a nightmare too. 
 But Soderstrom, introducing the songs set by set, was good company; the recital hall at Blackheath, rescued from years of abuse by the government department that used to inhabit it, had a good sound and an airy Victorian grace; and Roger Vignoles, the accompanist, was as clear and gifted as ever; so the capacity audience wound up feeling happy, especially when treated to confident versions of Lehar's Vilja Song or My Lips They Kiss So Hot. 
 Soderstrom has been, in her distinguished career, much more than an operetta singer, but her virtues, solid attack, excellent diction, and a clear, fine voice appealing more through its silvery edge than through depth or human vulnerability, are essentially charming rather than thought-provoking. 
 In serious songs, when her voice is not working, there is not enough personal extraordinariness to make the lack seem unimportant. 
 But there is always intelligent communication. 
 Sibelius and Stenhammar were shown setting the same text (The Girl returned from meeting her lover) with Stenhammar providing a sharp, sweet, highly contrasted little folkloric scena complete with sad introductory Schubertian piano tune. 
 Sibelius only managed plump chords like swags of roses here, with the piano pounding more to match the betrayed girl's despair towards the end. 
 Nordic composers around the turn of the century were not immune from quasi-medieval minstrelsy, or from routinely voluptuous piano arpeggios like Mendelssohn's. 
 Two songs by Ture Rangstrom (1884-1947) have unusual chromatic colours in hypnotic repeating figurations around simple lines. 
 We got two Grieg classics &mdash; Spring and I Love You &mdash; and then the Prokofiev, a delight with its roaming tonalities, its incisive sketches and its shafts of psychological insight (like the thrilling high speeded-up waltz, with music-box runs all over the place, that played in the duckling's mind as he looked at his reflection and found he was a swan). 
 Among the four Rachmaninov songs, the oriental-sounding Never sing to me again the songs of Georgia was particularly dark, rich and poignant. 
 THEATRE / White wash: Alex Renton reviews The Struggle at The Gate 
 By ALEX RENTON 
 THE VILLAINS in the cop thriller Lethal Weapon II are South African, for a change: there's a very nasty-piece-of-work consul played by Joss Ackland, and a horde of elongated Aryan thugs all as ugly as their accents. 
 And, although you do get Patsy Kensit to show that not all Boers are boors, there can be little doubt that casting like this will in the long run do more to bring about the end of white rule in South Africa than Robert Royston's worthy but long-winded drama of apartheid horrors. 
 Or indeed the dozens we have seen like it. 
 It is sad how boring the reiteration of undeniable truths can become. 
 But a time arrives when you would rather do almost anything rather than sit in a stuffy fringe theatre on a Saturday night with a dozen heads all nodding aggrievedly in agreement on how South Africa is now really rather a nasty place. 
 Royston's play attempts (and fails) to do rather more than that. 
 He tries to concern us with the problem of liberals: &bquo;When I trained,&equo; says Gumede, an ANC guerrilla, &bquo;they said that the liberal was more dangerous than the enemy.&equo; 
 The liberal in question is journalist Ruth, a South African who has ended seven years of English exile ostensibly in order to visit her elderly father. 
 In fact, liberal or not, she has come back to work for the ANC, though her exact capacity is not made clear. 
 But anyway she is arrested within hours of her arrival and successfully interrogated. 
 The chief lesson you gather is that the South African police are remarkably well-informed and the ANC recruitment procedure sadly lax. 
 Telling this are Ruth herself (Carol Been), her tragically decaying father (Alfred Hoffman), and a very nasty policeman (Saul Reichlin). 
 All three do their best under Penny Ciniewicz's rather heavy-handed direction, but they cannot beat a first play that has just got too much to say. 
 Cutting back and forward furiously, Royston tries to include the complex relationship between Ruth's father and his ageing &bquo;boy&equo;, Tim (Ilarrio Bisi-Pedro); as well as a portrait of Gumede, a freedom fighter on the verge of lunacy &mdash; excellently played by Osei Bentil; and an analysis of a South African police Colonel who is affably stark mad. 
 There is not room for all of this. 
 Which is a pity, because one would have liked particularly to hear more of the ebullient Gumede, a sort of Mad Max of the townships. 
 &bquo;White people!&equo; he spits disgustedly at Ruth, &bquo;you talk of life and death and other rubbish &mdash; because you have a future.&equo; 
 In a finale the police colonel complements Gumede as he describes his ideal home: &bquo;Freedom, man. 
 Nice walls and a big sky to look at.&equo; 
 What the two enemies share is a tragic and terminal separation from any conceivable reality, a theme that with a sharper editor's sense Royston might have usefully explored. 
 MUSIC / Steamed up about nothing: Boiler Room Suite - Cardiff 
 By STEPHEN WALSH 
 A PAIR of tramps in the cellar of an abandoned hotel lengthily airing their psychological underwear until evicted by a (superficially) heartless boilerman: we seem to have been here before. 
 But there is not much Pinter, and definitely no Beckett, about this solid piece of middle-class music theatre by the Canadian composer Quenten Doolittle, which began its short British tour by the Banff Music Theatre at the Chapter Arts Centre, Cardiff. 
 Doolittle has based himself on what seems a pellucidly consequential and intelligently written play by Rex Deverell (also the librettist); and though the piece is offered as &bquo;best suited&hellip; to alternative audiences&equo;, it cuts an oddly respectable figure in the modestly louche surroundings of Chapter. 
 Two reasons strike me for this. 
 First, the work is dramaturgically polite; it consults its audience too much to be taken seriously as drop-out theatre. 
 And secondly, its music is too operatic &mdash; too Brittenesque &mdash; to excite us searching spirits who trek through gaslit suburbs in quest of aesthetic deprivation. 
 Like the artists in La Boheme, Aggie and Sprugg &mdash; Deverell's two winos - spend a good deal of time play-acting, in an operative sort of way. 
 Sometimes they speak, sometimes they break into song. 
 They tell each other stories (Sprugg is a poet, like Rodolfo); they flirt harmlessly, get quietly drunk, but they don't swear and they don't you-know-what &mdash; it's a family show, in fact, though any child would faint with boredom. 
 All this is followed meticulously if at a respectful distance by Doolittle's seven-piece band, written for with a sure ear for tonal balance and a strong sense of the orchestra's role as a virtual extension of the voice, but with little willingness to let the musical idea take over the action. 
 It remains background music, and not just because, in Keith Turnbull's tidy production, the players are neatly packed away behind Gavin Semple's wonderful, octopoid hotel boiler. 
 Stylistically it asks few questions, becoming quickly locked into a limited area of harmonic discourse. 
 The show is redeemed by its performance. 
 Fides Krucker and Chris Enns are superb as the two down-and-outs, using their voices with extreme cleverness to depict the alternate venality and heroic detachment of the trampish life. 
 Kevin Power has less luck with the gauchely conceived part of the boilerman. 
 But the playing, under Peter Stranger, is fluent and stylish, a tribute to the high musical standards of the Music Theatre programme at the Banff Centre in Alberta (where the piece originated). 
 Only the Centre's music-theatrical astuteness remains, perhaps, in question. 
 Armchair Investor: Barry Wehmiller 
 By STEPHEN WALSH 
 BARRY WEHMILLER International's particular manufacturing niche of specialist packaging equipment may not be the most easily understood business but it is a profitable one. 
 Wehmiller has made five acquisitions in the last year, the largest being the US group's Holmatic and Kartidg Pak. 
 These companies have given Wehmiller a useful exposure to the US, where demand has been buoyant. 
 This is just as well because high interest rates have led to some of Wehmiller's customers in the UK deferring capital purchases in the short term. 
 Eventually equipment purchases will have to be made so long as the demand for packaging is there. 
 The cost of introducing new products at Inex Visions also impacted on margins and the profits from that side were adversely affected. 
 Wehmiller's pre-tax profit growth, 55 per cent to &pound;8.1m in the year to July 31, was almost all from acquisitions. 
 Share issues and a rising tax charges meant earnings rose just 25 per cent to 22.5p and a final dividend of 3p makes a total of 5.6p (4.5p). 
 This year, however, organic growth will resume and even if interest rates remain high in the UK, customers will have to make some of those deferred purchases. 
 Profits should rise to &pound;10.5m pre-tax. 
 This would put the shares at 274p, up 4p yesterday, on an earnings multiple of 10.5. 
 Armchair Investor recommended the shares at 235p and they remain a firm hold. 
 Column Eight: Game show winner for Exchange 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 Sir Nicholas Goodison, the former chairman of the International Stock Exchange, once appeared on television's Jim'll Fix it to hang a badge around a small child's neck. 
 The tradition of taking part in Saturday tea-time programmes on the cathode ray by senior stock exchange officers continues with the appointment of Peter Rawlins as the exchange's chief executive. 
 Fifteen years ago he and his mum appeared on Bruce Forsyth's The Generation Game. 
 By participating in a range of tourneys and pantomime, both Rawlins and his mother reached the final. 
 Young Rawlins went on to the most arduous part of the game &mdash; attempting to memorise the host of gifts on a conveyor belt, ranging from a cuddly toy to a microwave. 
 If contestants successfully remembered the prizes they won them. 
 Legend has it that Rawlins remembered the lot although yesterday he confessed he might have forgotten one. 
 There is, however, a video of his performance which he is encouraged to play from time to time by his two children. 
 Meanwhile, he has won &pound;150,000 in capturing the chief executive's job at the exchange. 
 Didn't he do well? 
 Hunter Howerton, an American secret service agent, has been reminiscing about the days when counterfeiting was a specialist art form. 
 Now he says, the only skill a would-be villain needs is the ability to press a button. 
 The blame, said Mr Howerton, lies in the sophistication of the modern photocopier. 
 He was speaking after a man was convicted in Charleston, West Virginia, of printing &dollar;800,000 in US and Canadian currency. 
 Experts said that the &dollar;20, &dollar;50, and &dollar;100 bills, which had been copied on a Canon Colour Laser, were virtually indistinguishable from the real thing. 
 The frentic merger activity among the nation's accountants (or not, as the case may be) has spread to the wilds of Yorkshire where the tiny firm of Rawlinsons is linking with the equally tiny Milne Booth. 
 The news will be particularly interesting to Sir Trevor Holdsworth, the piano-playing president of the Confederation of British Industry. 
 He spent seven happy years at Rawlinsons after the war. 
 It is not clear where Sir Trevor learned to tickle the ivories. 
 But he goes down a treat at the annual summer conference of the Institute of Chartered Accountants in England and Wales. 
 Pleas from the Prince of Wales for corporate help to rebuild the inner cities has not fallen on deaf ears. 
 Grand Metropolitan is to sponsor five sportsmobiles &mdash; Landrovers and trailers packed with sports equipment. 
 The vehicles will be given to the National Association of Boys' Clubs and will tour run-down inner-city areas. 
 View from City Road: MB's boldness is acknowledged 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 ONLY a dealer who had just come back from a weekend in the Kalahari desert would have been surprised to hear of yesterday's agreed &pound;337.6m bid by MB Group for Caradon, the Twyfords and Everest building products group, so comprehensive has been the pre-match publicity. 
 But a 2p rise to 208p in MB Group's share price, partly reversing Monday's 6p drop, is a cautious acknowledgement of the logic of the deal and the boldness of a move that has brought not only Caradon products but its highly professional directors into key positions, including chief executive and finance director, on the MB Group board. 
 Investors in MB Group have become used to bold initiatives by the company. 
 Its restructuring three months ago into two core businesses &mdash; heating and bathroom products and security printing &mdash; and a 25.5 per cent stake in CMB, the merged interests of MB Group's worldwide packaging interests with Carnaud of France, has been well received. 
 A month ago MB Group used up the &pound;164m cash proceeds of its Carnaud merger by purchasing ABS Holdings for &dollar;300m (&pound;194m) to make it the second largest cheque printer in the US. 
 Now it is doubling the size of its Stelrad baths, boilers and radiators division with the Caradon purchase. 
 At the same time it is bringing a new generation of management into the MB Group boardroom to mastermind the next phase of the company's expansion. 
 This may seem an unorthodox way of assuring management succession but then MB Group has been rearranging itself into a new structure for the future. 
 As for the price paid of 550p, half in cash and half in convertible preference shares, the prospective p/e may be around 14.5, to judge from an estimated 10 per cent rise in Caradon's pre-tax profits to &pound;17m in the half year to 1 October. 
 Retiring MB Group chairman Dr Brian Smith said yesterday that any short term dilution in the company's earnings would be &bquo;minimal&equo;. 
 The impact on MB Group's balance sheet of acquiring sizeable goodwill in both ABS and Caradon is mostly offset by the issue of &dollar;150m US preferred stock and a handy &pound;80m revaluation of its CMB stake to leave pro forma gearing at 24 per cent. 
 This suggests that the next MB Group foray will require fresh equity of some sort but investors may not find that too alarming. 
 View from City Road: Flirtatious Deloitte 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 DELOITTE Haskins &amp; Sells in the UK has firmly established itself as the Zsa Zsa Gabor of the accountancy profession. 
 No sooner, it seems, has one prospective long-term partner been secured than it is ditched. 
 Both Price Waterhouse and now Touche Ross have dallied with the Deloitte domestic partnership and been given the cold shoulder. 
 Having been bitten by PW it may have made Deloitte shy of Touche. 
 However that does not square somehow with the suggestion that Deloitte is poised to announce a link-up with Coopers &amp; Lybrand which until now has been a wallflower at this rather bizarre accountancy barn dance. 
 The Deloitte fiasco is not the first big eight merger to fall apart and these ridiculous posturings must leave the clients, who are supposedly served by their auditors, completely baffled. 
 Chairmen and chief executives will eventually become weary of their audit partner explaining why a particular merger with another firm was first a good idea and then a bad idea. 
 And the contempt and disinterest with which the corporate sector has greeted the recent spate of accountancy firm mergers is testimony to how insignificant the role of the auditor has become. 
 The problems faced by the accountancy profession are of its own making. 
 For too long the big firms in particular relied on the cosy requirement of a statutory audit to ensure their bread was generously buttered. 
 It is only within the last decade that the concepts of service, growth, competitiveness and value for money have begun to feature on accountants' list of priorities. 
 However, the physician which has been more than happy to dish out expensive advice to clients on how they they should deal with their own ills, has been unable to heal itself. 
 The blind pursuit of size in an attempt to indicate success and quality of service has been misguided. 
 It is a strategy which is not supported by an appropriate infrastructure. 
 More importantly, it is a strategy which has no benefit to clients or shareholders. 
 There will be no outcry from the corporate sector about the disarray in the accountancy profession. 
 Some companies would prefer a disorganised and confused auditor. 
 The losers are the shareholders on whose behalf the auditors are, in theory, supposed to act. 
 View from City Road: Smurfit late with good news 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 JEFFERSON SMURFIT is winning no friends this side of the Irish Sea despite its undoubted skills in the paper and packaging business. 
 Yesterday it announced figures for the first half of 1989 so late in the day that the London market had mostly packed up and gone home by the time the screens showed that profits had risen from Ir &pound;109m to Ir &pound;121m and earnings were up from 21.7p to 25.4p basic. 
 The City put the shares up 4p to 565p, but that seems to have been largely on the basis of the optimistic tone of the statement and the general state of the market than from any in-depth analysis of the figures. 
 If London had been given time to study these, it would have seen that Smurfit is looking well placed in a world market notoriously prone to cyclical demand. 
 The philosophy that if it goes down in the US it must be going up in Europe has meant that Smurfit is looking to Europe as its main engine for growth in the months to come, when it must decide how to spend the &dollar;1bn cash raised from the recent financial restructuring with Morgan Stanley. 
 Shareholders will be circulated with details of this &bquo;in a matter of weeks&equo;, according to yesterday's statement, and they will be interested to hear the details of what was dismissed by London as a &bquo;piece of financial engineering, pure and simple.&equo; 
 That did no good for the Smurfit price in Dublin, and maybe the nonchalance with which the group now treats the Square Mile reflects the hurt it felt at that piece of analysis. 
 In its defence, Smurfit would say that it is an international company and it should pay as much intention to its US hinterland as it does to London. 
 After all, the US has done well by Smurfit in the past. 
 Market Report: Goldsmith talk puts life into beer shares 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 THE Goldsmith factor had beer shares on the hop yesterday. 
 Grand Metropolitan, which is believed to be keen to sell its extensive brewing interests, came to life in late trading, jumping 21p to 599p as the story flowed that Sir James Goldsmith and friends were stake-building. 
 Grand Met was also the busiest option stock, claiming nearly 2,800 contracts. 
 It was suggested Goldsmith interests already had two per cent and were planning to build a significant shareholding to encourage the Grand Met board to consider a breakup. 
 The stock market theory is that the Goldsmith contingent needs a new challenge now its bid for BAT Industries has effectively evaporated. 
 The Goldsmith plan to break up BAT has been overtaken by BAT's decision to do the job itself. 
 Sir James was first detected on the Grandmet share register earlier this year. 
 But at that time he was fully occupied with BAT. 
 The suggestion is he has topped up his stake in the past few weeks when Grand Met's shares have been weak, falling from 658p. 
 He could feel an &bquo;unbundling&equo; assault on Grandmet would strike a receptive cord in the City. 
 There has been criticism of the group's wheeling and dealing which came to a head with the surprise sale of the William Hill / Mecca betting shops chain to Brent Walker. 
 But Grand Met did not have the beer pitch to itself. 
 Allied-Lyons was also said to be on the Goldsmith hit list. 
 It is widely believed he already has a short two per cent stake although Allied has not detected his presence on its share register. 
 It has been calculated that Allied's breakup value is about 1,000p a share. 
 Scottish &amp; Newcastle Breweries also joined the ferment. 
 Goldsmith rumours were helped along by talk Anheuser-Busch, the US brewing giant, had acquired Elders' 23.7 per cent stake ahead of a bid. 
 The rest of the stock market was dominated by Ferranti's hectic return, with Seaq putting volume at a remarkable 115 million shares. 
 With at least three securities houses chasing stock the shares opened at 47.5p and climbed to 55p. 
 Sentiment was bouyant, however, with bargain hunters taking advantage of the recent decline, shopping for stock. 
 The broadly based FT-SE share index rose 29.4 points in often, by post crash standards, busy trading. 
 However, interest rate fears remain in the background and the undertone is still fragile. 
 A &pound;1.9bn US takeover bid, by McCaw for Mteromedia, excited telecommunication shares. 
 The Racal &bquo;twins&equo;, British Telecom, which has 24 per cent of McCaw, Cable and Wireless and Securicor moved ahead. 
 Racal Electronics, up 10p at 237p, had to contend with a down and up grading by County NatWest WoodMac. 
 It has trimmed this year's forecast by &pound;5m to &pound;235m and lifted next year's by &pound;20m to &pound;340m. 
 Insurance shares continued to attract support with Pearl Group edging ahead a further 7p to 646p following the &pound;1.1bn bid from Australian Mutual Provident. 
 Takeover speculation lifted merchant bank Morgan Grenfell another 13p to 370p and Kleinwort Benson 8p to 374p. 
 Building materials group Caradon, on the MB Group offer, jumped 45p to 533p. 
 Chemical group Evode held at 154p as James Capel placed the Bowater Industries 11 per cent shareholding at 148p a share. 
 Together with a preference placing Bowater raised &pound;16.6m. 
 Trafalgar House advanced 3p to 388p. 
 Nomura, forecasting year's profits of &pound;273m against last time's &pound;229.1m, has put the shares on its buy list. 
 Eurotunnel had another unhappy session, falling 50p to 600p on the dramatic costs over run. 
 The shares touched 1,172p earlier this year. 
 Jaguar improved 26p to 599p on talk the signalled bid or deal with Ford or General Motors (or even a European group) is near. 
 Guinness, interim figures tomorrow, gained 6p to 573p. 
 Kevin Feeny at Warburg Securities is looking for &pound;242m against &pound;183m with &pound;650m pencilled in for the year. 
 Newcomer Essex Furniture, placed at 50p, closed at 51p. 
 Clothing group Casket edged forward 1p to 67p as York Trust declared a 12.2 per cent interest. 
 Tullow Oil, moving to the USM this week, is likely to support its graduation with a set of interim figures showing operating profits a shade below &pound;400,000. 
 The company is due to meet analysts on Friday. 
 Set up by Aidan Heavey four years ago, it operates in the UK, Senegal and Italy and hopes to clinch exploration concessions in Syria and Pakistan. 
 The shares are 17p. 
 Salomon Brothers yesterday placed with City institutions the US chunk of British Airways' &pound;320m convertible bonds rights issue. 
 With American ADR holders unable to take part in the rights, the stock, around 20 per cent of the issue, was acquired by Salomon from Morgan Guaranty, the ADR keeper. 
 BA, up 2p to 211p, wants the cash for its share of the UAL buyout. 
 Bid for Eagle Trust withdrawn by Fitton 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 ANDREW Fitton, the chief executive of Braithwaite, has withdrawn the consortium bid he was preparing for Eagle Trust, the Midlands mini-conglomerate currently under investigation by the Serious Fraud Office and the West Midlands fraud squad. 
 Mr Fitton, backed by merchant banker Henry Ansbacher, first came up with the offer six weeks ago. 
 It would have involved his consortium ploughing between &pound;10m and &pound;15m into the troubled Eagle as part of a recapitalisation that would have left them controlling 29.9 per cent of Eagle's equity. 
 Withdrawing the bid yesterday, Mr Fitton said the original discussions with Eagle, which was then chaired by Malcolm Stockdale, were amicable, but when company doctor David James took over as chairman of the group last week it was clear any approach would have to be aggressive. 
 Mr James was brought in by Eagle's creditor banks &mdash; the group has debts of over &pound;80m &mdash; and has been given until the end of next year to turn the business around. 
 He has said that the &pound;15m on offer was either too little or too much &mdash; too little to pacify the bankers if Eagle was in trouble but if the group could be turned around a recapitalisation would not be needed. 
 Mr Fitton yesterday made clear that he had always been acting in an independent capacity in the offer for Eagle, and that it had no connection with Braithwaite. 
 &bquo;Whoever sorts Eagle out will make a lot of money,&equo; Mr Fitton said. 
 &bquo;Beneath the can of worms there are some very good businesses.&equo; 
 However, Braithwaite, which specialises in plant hire, had tried to take over Samuelson, the film equipment hire company bought by Eagle in 1987. 
 Mr Fitton confirmed that Braithwaite is interested in two Eagle businesses, Samuelson and Trio Containers, which is involved in the rental of waste disposal loading equipment. 
 Mr James has put a hold on all disposals from Eagle while he completes a strategic review of the business, which was rocked by the liquidation of Connect Parcels and the disappearance of &pound;13.7m of funds. 
 He is keen that any refinancing will be done while getting fair market values for the companies in Eagle, not a fire sale. 
 HTV profits top City forecasts 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 HTV Group, the Swansea-based Independent Television contractor and fine arts dealer, beat all City forecasts with a 25.4 per cent increase in pre-tax profits to &pound;18m in the year to 31 July. 
 Earnings rose 20.3 per cent to 17.25p and a final dividend of 3.5p makes a 39 per cent increase in the total to 5p. 
 The group's share rose 6p to 135p on the news. 
 The figures were helped by a review of the group's stocks, both in television programmes and in paintings and prints, which added &pound;1.1m to operating profits. 
 However, there was an exceptional cost of &pound;2.1m due to the staff reduction programme which cut 160 from the head count. 
 The broadcasting levy paid to the Government rose a third to &pound;4.8m. 
 HTV's advertising revenue rose 11.8 per cent to &pound;101.8m, and the group managed to hold on to a creditable market share of 6.4 per cent as advertising has been sucked to South-east England. 
 The chief executive, Partick Dromgoole, said sales in September were down on last year. 
 The year has been good for programme sales, particularly overseas where sales increased more than a half to &pound;18.8m. 
 Mr Dromgoole said this would flatten, if not drop in the new year, as the group reins back its activities to minimise the amount of levy paid to the Government. 
 HTV's objective is to have half its revenues coming from other than advertising sales. 
 So far non-advertising revenue stands at 38 per cent of turnover and around 30 per cent of profits, though HTV does not have plans to make any large acquisitions, such as the purchase of CCA Galleries last year. 
 CCA was in these figures for just three months and fine art contributed &pound;849,000 of profits, up from &pound;156,000. 
 HTV is also redeveloping a 21 acre parcel of land close to its studios at Culverhouse Cross which could realise more than &pound;5m of profit. 
 It has already revalued its properties, bringing a &pound;7m surplus. 
 To tie in with the new broadcasting levy system, which starts in January, HTV is changing its year end from July to December. 
 Anglo United to sell eight Coalite firms 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 ANGLO UNITED, which won its &pound;478m bid for Coalite in July, has put eight Coalite businesses up for sale. 
 The price tag is expected to be about &pound;150m. 
 The businesses include two in waste disposal &mdash; essentially landfill operations &mdash; two in quarrying, two in the manufacture of scientific instruments plus a chain of builders' merchants and a maker of specialised grouts. 
 David McErlain, the chairman of Anglo, said over 300 potential bidders had shown interest in the eight operations. 
 He said Anglo expects the sales to be completed by Christmas. 
 &bquo;These disposals will break the back of our &pound;200m bridging finance, taken on to fund the bid,&equo; said Mr McErlain. 
 He added that the group would be making further disposals in the new year, including Coalite's North Sea oil interests and its contract hire operations. 
 Hargreaves Quarries is expected to excite the most interest. 
 Many of its quarries are located next to sites owned by large players such as Tarmac and ARC. 
 City analysts have put a price tag of as much as &pound;60m on Hargreaves and some potential bidders, including the Irish group CRH, have intimated that the business would be worth more to an existing player in the market than a newcomer. 
 Advertising group rakes in new work 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 ADVERTISING and public relations group, Lowe Howard-Spink &amp; Bell, yesterday saw its shares rise 9p to 422p on the announcement of a 16 per cent rise in profits before tax to &pound;7.7m for the half year to end June. 
 The company said that the first six months of the year &bquo;have seen more new business than during any previous period&equo;. 
 Most of this was due to PR work from the financial side of the company, Lowe Bell Financial, which has been bought out by management since the period end. 
 &bquo;Lowe International is continuing to study potential for expanding its operations in European countries and is progressing in this area,&equo; it added. 
 Worldwide, Lowe International won over &pound;100m of new business in the first six months, more than double the total 1988 increase. 
 &bquo;Lowe Marschalk, together with the existing US agencies, now has US billings in excess of &dollar;500m,&equo; a statement added. 
 City analysts said that the full year should see a profit of &pound;19.5m, to give 43.5p of earnings and a 14 per cent discount to the market. 
 &bquo;Your view of the shares depends how you view the management,&equo; one expert said. 
 &bquo;If you think they are good, they are reasonable value. 
 But if you think they are beginning to lose it, the shares are fairly priced.&equo; 
 Company News in Brief 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 REG VARDY, the Northern car dealer, is seeking a full listing via a &pound;7.1m placing. 
 The new shares will account for 25 per cent of the enlarged group and will be placed at 90p. 
 OCEAN Transport &amp; Trading has expanded its environmental services with investments totalling &pound;12m. 
 Housebuilding boosts Raine finals to 23.2m pounds 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 A 150 per cent rise in housebuilding profits helped Raine Industries, the contracting group, to raise pre-tax profits by 73 per cent from &pound;13.4m to &pound;23.2m in the year to 30 June. 
 The Hassel Homes division increased profits from &pound;5.7m to &pound;14.3m by avoiding the depressed South-east market and concentrating on improving margins in the North and Scotland. 
 Hall &amp; Tawse, the commercial property division, raised profits from &pound;6.4m to &pound;7.2m. 
 The interiors contracting operation, enlarged by the &pound;26m acquisition of Plumb Holdings in May, improved profits to &pound;1.6m. 
 Outlook: Quids in, dollars out of the reserves 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 In a world of dubious economic statistics, changes in the official reserves must rate as one of the most unreliable indicators. 
 Last month's underlying decline of only &dollar;142m in the reserves seems an especially unrealistic guide to the actual level of intervention by the Bank of England &mdash; in concert with other central banks &mdash; to depress the dollar, and also &mdash; on its own account &mdash; to defend the weakening pound. 
 For a start, the figures exclude transactions that occurred on the last two business days of the month &mdash; the very time when pressure on the pound was thought to be most intense. 
 Even during the recorded period, however, there are persuasive reasons for believing that the actual quantity of reserves used for intervention was at least &dollar;650m-&dollar;700m. 
 Sales of reserves were offset by an inflow of &dollar;260m of foreign currency receipts from the final instalment of the sale of British Steel shares. 
 And the net change is reduced by interest on the &dollar;42.88bn of outstanding reserves &mdash; probably worth between &dollar;250m and &dollar;300m a month. 
 Then there is the tricky question of forward market operations. 
 The Bank is known frequently to support the pound in the forward market. 
 But of course such operations affect the reserves in the month in which the forward purchase matures, not in the month in which the transaction is executed. 
 It is thought that in January the Bank sold pounds nine months forward when it was engaged in the task of restraining the pound's advance. 
 And any such maturing sales would mask the extent of support for the pound last month. 
 Expectations now focus on tomorrow's Bundesbank meeting, and a widely expected rise in German interest rates. 
 But the Chancellor may be looking and hoping further ahead, to Friday's US employment report and the possibility that a bit of a dollar rebound might haul the pound up against the mark. 
 Outlook: Switching tack on plastic 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 People in Britain spend about &pound;20bn a year using plastic cards. 
 The processing of these transactions on behalf of shops &mdash; known as &bquo;merchant acquisition&equo; in banking jargon &mdash; is worth no less than &pound;400m annually. 
 For the banks chasing this lucrative and growing business, the gloves are now definitely off. 
 Yesterday Barclays and Lloyds announced they wanted to join Switch, the debit card network founded by National Westminster, Midland and Royal Bank of Scotland. 
 Yet Barclays and Lloyds have spent much time and energy privately rubbishing Switch, in efforts to promote their own debit cards. 
 The truth is that neither applicant actually wants to issue Switch cards, though Barclays says it is prepared to consider it. 
 Both, however, want the right to process Switch transactions on behalf of their retail clients. 
 The catalyst is the Government's decision in August to uphold a recommendation from the Monopolies and Mergers Commission that the credit card networks Visa International and Mastercard should alter one of their membership rules. 
 This rule, still in existence while Visa and Mastercard fight a rearguard action with the Office of Fair Trading, prevents banks from processing card transactions until they have built up a large base of card-holders. 
 Now Lloyds and Barclays argue that the debit card network should bow to the same principle &mdash; and that they should be allowed to process Switch transactions without first issuing Switch cards to their account-holders. 
 Switch is likely to resist any such application. 
 It says a &bquo;fundamental requirement&equo; is that its retail acquirers should be issuers too. 
 However, it may yet be tempted to bend the rules to admit the two newcomers. 
 Its problem is not the size of its card-holder base &mdash; there are 10 million Switch cards in circulation already. 
 It is the paucity of its retail base which is stunting growth. 
 Only 10,000 of the necessary terminals are so far installed in shops, though the target is 20,000 by the New Year and 100,000 by the end of next year. 
 Moreover, its big-name client base so far is largely confined to Sainsbury, Gateway and the main petrol retailers. 
 Barclays has 12,000 terminals installed in stores and another 30,000 on the way. 
 Lloyds too is a substantial merchant acquirer and was the first to offer the convenience of processing both Visa and Mastercard vouchers. 
 Bringing the two banks into the fold would do much to raise the credibility of Switch with sceptical retailers. 
 Outlook: Topping up top pay 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 To him (or, very occasionally, her) that hath shall still clearly be given. 
 Both the P-E Inbucon annual survey of executive salaries, and the much smaller Jonathan Wren city salary survey, confirm that salary increases have been bigger at the top end of business and the City than at the bottom. 
 The P-E Inbucon survey is truly massive, based on data for executives in 872 UK companies. 
 It fairly claims to be the largest in Europe. 
 The results put into perspective the hefty pay rises recently secured by certain notorious chief executives; but they still show boardroom salaries growing faster than middle management's. 
 Some 18 per cent of managing directors secured pay increases of over 20 per cent in 1988-89, compared with only 8 per cent of executives below board level. 
 Including all remuneration (the majority of managing directors received a bonus averaging around one-fifth of their salary), half of all managing directors received about 14 per cent or more. 
 For executives below board level the median increase was about 10 per cent. 
 The Jonathan Wren survey is more modestly based on 453 City placements over the past six months; but these, too, show much bigger increases achieved by mobile fund managers (over 26 per cent, with an average salary of over &pound;50,000) than messengers (less than 10 &frac12; per cent, with an average salary of under &pound;7,000). 
 But the market seems to have been generating some big increases for certain quite junior City people &mdash; notably in foreign exchange and swaps. 
 Commodities: Coffee 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 Coffee second position futures fell to a 14-year low of &pound;693 in quiet trading awaiting the conclusion of International Coffee Organisation talks. 
 Brazil's rejection of export quotas was seen as blocking any positive outcome to the talks, now nearing a conclusion. 
 Manufacturers were sidelined as producers held stock until after the talks. 
 Japanese pursue European ambitions in financial services: Virgin's deal with Fujisankei is the continuation of a trend, Frances Moss reports 
 By FRANCES MOSS 
 A RECENT trend in Japanese preparations for 1992 is becoming evident, particularly in the financial services sector. 
 Strategic alliances are being forged with major European companies. 
 These deals are often sought by the European companies, as they are seen as a reciprocal entry ticket to the Japanese market. 
 They are part of the increasing worldwide trend where knowledge, goods, services and markets are being exchanged between players each hoping to become &bquo;global&equo; organisations. 
 The Japanese have internationalisation as a national objective, which makes them particularly enthusiastic players in this exchange. 
 There is a huge Japanese presence in the City, but much of it is in commercial banking. 
 Many of the new moves are into more sophisticated areas such as investment banking and specialised services. 
 There is more involvement with companies on mainland Europe as an insurance policy against any loss of London's pre-eminence after 1992. 
 The giant Nomura has stakes in Banco Santander of Spain (which owns 10 per cent of Royal Bank of Scotland), Francois-Dufour Kervern, a French stockbroker, and Matuschka Group, a fund management company in West Germany. 
 As part of the deal in Spain, a Nomura representative will have a seat on the board of the investment bankers, Banco Santander de Negocios. 
 In 1988 the Long-term Credit Bank of Japan set up a joint investment advisory company with Foreign &amp; Colonial Management. 
 The deal was said to enable LTCB to gain information and knowledge in international asset management while providing F&amp;C with a way of entry into the pensions market in Japan. 
 In July of this year the Taiyo Kobe Bank agreed to buy a 5 per cent stake in Credito Commerciale, a merchant banking subsidiary of the 500-year-old Monte dei Paschi di Siena. 
 The deal includes a place for a Taiyo Kobe employee on the Credito Commerciale board. 
 Okosan Securities, one of Japan's 10 largest securities companies, has declared that it is considering tying up with a London-based company to take advantage of its knowledge and expertise in the specialised area of offshore investment. 
 In the insurance market, there has been an upsurge in activity. 
 In life insurance in particular, Japan's domestic market is extremely mature. 
 There are about 100 million policies for a population of 122 million. 
 This provides still stronger motivation to seek new markets. 
 Sedgwick, the UK's largest insurance broker, has a co-operative agreement with Ginsen, which is affiliated to the giant Sumitomo group. 
 In February 1989, Dai-ichi Mutual Life Insurance, the second-largest life insurance company in Japan, bought 2 per cent of Compagnie Financiere de Suez of France. 
 Legal &amp; General reached a co-operation deal in August 1989 with Kyoei Mutual Fire &amp; Marine Insurance Company of Tokyo. 
 Included in the arrangement was provision for some joint training. 
 The advent of 1992 was explicitly given as one reason for the Japanese company being interested in the deal. 
 The Japanese are getting two things from these deals. 
 First they will gain influence. 
 A Japanese on the board will probably be a business school graduate with extensive overseas experience, who will speak from a position of strength. 
 Second, and more important, they will gain information. 
 The Japanese are the most inveterate information gatherers in the business world. 
 Their much-derided &bquo;copying&equo; focus is now seen with more respect as showing a complete absence of the NIH (not invented here) syndrome that causes so many Western companies problems when new but not original ideas are introduced. 
 With a growing network of alliances, the potential access to key market information and expertise has grown enormously. 
 It is unlikely that the opportunities will be wasted. 
 So far, with the number of Japanese-speaking graduates in the UK scarcely being measured in three figures, any reciprocal learning will depend mainly on what Japanese companies choose to make available. 
 In addition, there is a revolution going on in Japan in the financial services sector as it faces deregulation. 
 Knowledge of how to operate in the relatively unrestricted European markets could be vital to enable Japanese institutions to survive. 
 They have an enormous advantage in the strength of the yen and the size of their asset base. 
 So there is no doubt about the ability of the Japanese to pay for this information and knowledge, nor about their strong motivation for acquiring it. 
 The doubt is really whether Western companies have put a sufficiently high price on the information they are providing. 
 Akio Morita records that his fledgling company Sony was, in 1953, able to buy a licence from Western Electric to develop transistor technology. 
 Ultimately, this enabled Sony to make huge inroads into US electronics companies' sales and profits. 
 For a short-term gain of a one-off windfall profit, far greater future losses were stored up. 
 The implication is that Mr Morita thought that he had a bargain. 
 Are there many such bargains being struck today, as the key resource of the information age is being liberally shared about? 
 The Japanese are no longer shying away from outright acquisition, as the recent purchase of the merchant bank Guinness Mahon by the Bank of Yokohama shows. 
 It will be interesting to see whether Japanese management practices likely to be brought in by the new top management will work in an environment where aggressive individual success, rather than collaborative teamwork has been the norm. 
 So far Japanese management expertise seems to have been transferred more successfully into the manufacturing sector than into financial services. 
 However, co-operative agreements and alliances, which represent far less risk while still providing access to markets and information, are much more common than M&amp;A activity as yet. 
 Recent research has shown that not all joint-ventures or alliances between Western and Japanese companies are a complete success. 
 The expectations of the two parties may be very different, as may be the amount of time and effort they each put into the deal. 
 The enormous losses of at least &dollar;10m apiece that the big four securities houses, Nomura, Yamaichi, Daiwa and Nikko, made in the US in 1988 can be seen in two ways. 
 Either they show that the Japanese magic touch is concentrated mainly in manufacturing, or, more worryingly for the West, they demonstrate the costs of entry into unfamiliar markets that Japanese firms are willing to pay. 
 The big four may well have learnt so much about how to negotiate with the US regulatory and financial authorities to justify the cost of this investment. 
 If the Western part of these alliances in the financial sector wish to make them work, they will have to put as much effort into learning as the Japanese will. 
 They will also need to take the same long-term view. 
 Otherwise, they may find that they have given a huge advantage to their competitors, without benefiting sufficiently from the opportunities that have been made available to them. 
 The author is senior lecturer in accounting and finance at the Polytechnic of Central London. 
 Intel confirms 264m pounds Irish Republic plant 
 From ALAN MURDOCH in Dublin 
 INTEL, the California-based semi conductor manufacturer, yesterday confirmed its first European manufacturing base is to be in the Irish Republic. 
 Its Ir &pound;300m (&pound;264m) plant will employ 2,600 workers within 10 years. 
 The decision will come as a disappointment to development agencies in Scotland and Wales &mdash; both countries were shortlisted. 
 The company is to invest Ir &pound;250m on research and investment and staff training. 
 A spokesman for Intel said no specific sites had been earmarked in the west of Scotland or in the M4 electronics belt in Wales. 
 The decision to go to Ireland &mdash; made on labour, grant aid and broader economic grounds &mdash; was also made before the actual location was selected. 
 Intel, with a 1988 turnover of more than &dollar;2.8bn, is the world's fifth largest manufacturer of semi conductors for the computer industry. 
 Founded in 1968, it pioneered the modern micro processor and now mainly supplies components for other electronics firms. 
 These are used in machines from desktop computers to super computers. 
 About 70 per cent of personal computers worldwide incorporate parts made by Intel, which employs 20,000. 
 An initial Ir &pound;20m is to be invested in the plant at Leixit in County Kildare, which in the first phase will produce computer systems. 
 Dr Gordon Moore, Intel chairman, said: &bquo;We are badly in need of extra systems capacity and this part of the project will go ahead extremely rapidly.&equo; 
 He said this will be followed by a wafer fabrication plant on the same site at a cost of at least I &pound;150m and finally a finishing and test centre. 
 Total construction costs are projected to reach Ir &pound;125m. 
 Intel has set up a recruitment office in Dublin. 
 More than 25 per cent of the 2,600 employees will be graduates. 
 The Irish Industry Minister, Des O'Malley, stressed that a key factor in winning the project had been availability of computer scientists. 
 BAT bid boosts merchant banks 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 THE &pound;13.5bn takeover battle for BAT affected the reputations and fees of all the City's big merchant banks in the first nine months of 1989, according to figures announced yesterday by the magazine Acquisitions Monthly. 
 Seven of the top 10 places in the table went to banks which had a role in the BAT bid. 
 The most notable inclusions in the list were Lazard Brothers and Hambros, which rose from eleventh to second place and nineteenth to third place respectively. 
 The last time Hambros was so well placed was in 1986 when it advised on another mega-bid, by Hanson for Imperial Group. 
 Warburgs, which acted for BAT, was ranked first in the table, with &pound;23.6bn of deals done in the period. 
 It also acted for Isosceles in its takeover of the Gateway supermarkets business, and for GEC in its bid for electronics group Plessey. 
 Morgan Grenfell amd Kleinwort Benson, each of whom played no role in the BAT bid, were also in the top 10. 
 County NatWest, the merchant bank heavily censured by inspectors from the Department of Trade and Industry for its role in the Blue Arrow affair, has dropped out of the table for the first time. 
 A spokeswoman for the bank said: &bquo;You have to remember that the rankings are made on the basis of value of bids, which are all down to BAT. 
 &bquo;We have had no significant losses of clients since the publication of the DTI report. 
 The year will be disappointing, but we are very confident that we will be back in the league table next year,&equo; she added. 
 Another notable movement in the charts was from Schroders, which recorded 23 deals worth &pound;13.2bn. 
 &bquo;If this bank had played a role in the Hoylake/BAT battle it would have been top of the table,&equo; said Philip Healey, editor of Acquisitions Monthly. 
 Designer Nina Campbell has licensed the manufacture and distribution of her wallpaper and fabric designs to quoted group Osborne and Little in a cash deal expected to be worth &pound;200,000 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 Designer Nina Campbell has licensed the manufacture and distribution of her wallpaper and fabric designs to quoted group Osborne and Little in a cash deal expected to be worth &pound;200,000  
 Decision near in US battle over cellular phones 
 From LARRY BLACK in New York 
 THE LENGTHY battle for control of New York's cellular telephone franchise took an unexpected turn yesterday as McCaw Cellular announced a &dollar;1.9bn deal to acquire the half stake owned by the Metromedia group. 
 The move puts new pressure on Metromedia's partner in the New York franchise, LIN Broadcasting, which has been the object of a hostile tender offer by McCaw since early summer. 
 LIN, which last month entered into a merger agreement with Bell South in an attempt to repel McCaw, has the right of first refusal on Metromedia's stake, which would pre-empt the deal with McCaw. 
 LIN now has 45 days to decide whether to buy the balance of the franchise. 
 Meanwhile, the &dollar;110-a-share cash bid for LIN by McCaw, which is 20 per cent owned by British Telecom, expires on 13 October. 
 LIN's merger agreement with Bell South has been valued at between &dollar;108 and &dollar;112 a share, but the deal will not reward shareholders until early next year. 
 Major holders of LIN stock are sharply divided on which offer to accept. 
 &bquo;McCaw's move forces LIN to make a decision,&equo; said Guy Weyser-Pratt, a market strategist with Prudential-Bache Securities, yesterday. 
 &bquo;Either LIN buys the rest of the franchise it doesn't already own, or it has to come to terms with McCaw.&equo; 
 McCaw has been pursuing LIN since June, and some analysts had expected it to raise its bid in wake of the merger agreement with Bell South, the regional telephone utility based in Atlanta, Georgia. 
 One New York arbitrageur described McCaw's move as a smart one, and went on to predict that LIN would now finally agree to negotiate with its unwanted suitor. 
 &bquo;LIN could live with this,&equo; he said, noting that the company would still control large parts of the cellular market in other US cities. 
 In announcing its deal with Metromedia, McCaw also said it planned to sell its stake in a number of smaller cellular franchises in Alabama, Kentucky and Tennessee to Contel Corporation for &dollar;1.3bn. 
 New York-based Metromedia is controlled by businessman John Kluge. 
 In 1986 Metromedia's six US television stations were sold to Rupert Murdoch, who has grouped them into the Fox Television network. 
 BAe plans new 35m pounds long-range business jet 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Correspondent 
 BRITISH Aerospace yesterday announced the &pound;35m launch of a new mid-sized, twin-engined business jet capable of carrying passengers non-stop to the United States and the Middle East. 
 The BAe 1000, a derivative of the highly successful BAe 125-800, will be produced at its Chester factory. 
 Seven orders have been received for the new jet which will have a 3,600-mile range. 
 Production of the two aircraft is scheduled to rise from 35-40 a year to 50 aircraft by 1992, 60 per cent of which will be acounted for by the BAe 1000. 
 Deliveries of the new jet &mdash; which is designed to tap the market for business aircraft with an intercontinental range &mdash; are due to begin in the first quarter of 1991. 
 The BAe 1000, claimed by BAe to be two years ahead of the competition, will be able to fly up to 15 passengers direct from London to the West coast of the US, Rio de Janeiro or Singapore with one stop-off. 
 BAe said its range would be up to 50 per cent greater than the existing 125-800, cutting 50 minutes from the flight time of coast-to-coast operations in the US and Australia. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Correspondent 
 Pearl investigation: The Office of Fair Trading has begun its investigation into the &pound;1.1bn bid for Pearl Group by Australian Mutual Provident. 
 The OFT will advise the Secretary of State for Trade and Industry on whether he should refer the bid to the Monopolies and Mergers Commission. 
 MB well leaked: The agreed &pound;338m bid for Caradon by MB Group was well publicised before it was announced yesterday. 
 This page and View from City Road, page 33 Fitton drops bid: Andrew Fitton, the chief executive of Braithwaite, has withdrawn his recapitalisation offer for Eagle Trust. 
 Page 33. 
 Egerton name change: Egerton Trust, the housebuilder and property developer, has changed the names of six of its subsidiaries to Egerton to reflect the exposure of the group. 
 Still running: Visa and Mastercard are continuing to operate membership rules that were decreed anti-competitive by the Government six weeks ago. 
 Page 30 NY cellular telephones: McCaw Cellular has bought the half stake owned in the New York cellular telephone franchise by Metromedia. 
 Page 31 Accounting mergers: Deloitte Haskins and Sells has pulled out of its merger with Touche Ross and is expected to join up with Coopers &amp; Lybrand. 
 This page and View from City Road, page 31 Mitsubishi listing: Mitsubishi has became the first Japanese general trading company to be listed on the London Stock Exchange. 
 Dealings in its shares begin today. 
 BAT distortion: Seven out of the 10 leading merchant banks in the Acquistions Monthly league table of corporate finance activity were involved in the Hoylake bid for BAT Industries. 
 Page 31 Decline encouraging: The &dollar;142m deline in Britain's reserves of gold and foreign exchange to &dollar;42.88bn was less than many had been fearing. 
 Page 30 Dow record: A surprise buying rush took the New York Stock Exchange to a record close. 
 Page 30 Anglo sell-off: Eight businesses worth &pound;150m are being sold by Anglo United following its takeover of Coalite. 
 Page 33 Switch applications: Barclays and Lloyds banks have applied to join the Switch debit card network. 
 Outlook, page 31 Smurfit rise: Jefferson Smurfit announced a rise in profits to Ir &pound;121m (Ir &pound;109m) after the stock market had closed yesterday. 
 View from City Road, page 33 Ferranti support: Ferranti shares were relisted at 47.5p yesterday but were well supported and ended at 56p. 
 This page and View from City Road, page 33 Pay rises: Two surveys show that pay is rising faster at the top end of the scales than at the bottom. 
 Outlook, page 31 World Markets New York: Programme buying and a rush of panicky short-covering saw the Dow Jones Industrial Average finish at a record 2,754.56, up 40.84 Tokyo: A flood of sell orders from investment trusts redeeming funds for clients brought a sharp fall in the Nikkei average, down 256.6 to 35,366.37. 
 Hong Kong: Buying by London institutions helped the Hang Seng index to climb 39.95 points to 2,786.65 in moderate trade. 
 Singapore: Undeterred by Tokyo's fall, bargain-hunters took the Straits Times index 13.07 points higher to 1,388.32. 
 Sydney: The market rallied on Wall Street's gains, a softer Australian dollar and a jump in futures prices. 
 The All Ordinaries index added 28.8 to 1,772.1. 
 Johannesburg: Gold shares eased as the bullion price continued to languish. 
 The rest of the market drifted in sympathy. 
 Bombay: Prices fell on heavy speculative selling after the long weekend. 
 Doubts were expressed about last week's rumour of moves to end steel price control. 
 Frankfurt: Strong demand for Daimler, AEG and other selected stocks pushed interest rate fears into the background. 
 The DAX index, at a day's high of 1,602.4, was 24.6 points ahead. 
 Paris: Peugeot recovered from its recent weakness, gaining eight francs to 902 on hopes of ending the strike at two plants. 
 Madrid: Further profit-taking bought a marginal 0.8-point fall in the index to 324.87. 
 New match for Deloitte UK 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 THE MERGER initiatives of the large accountancy firms were thrown into further disarray yesterday when the UK firm of Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells pulled out of the worldwide merger with Touche Ross. 
 Deloitte is expected to announce a UK merger with Coopers &amp; Lybrand this morning. 
 The decision by Deloitte to pull out comes just one week after the collapse of talks between Price Waterhouse and Arthur Andersen. 
 And it was leaked barely hours before Edward Kangas, head of Touche Ross International, announced that the proposed merger to create the giant international firm of Deloitte Ross Tohmatsu (DRT) would go ahead with Touche Ross as the sole UK representative. 
 Mr Kangas said: &bquo;Firms in the US, Japan, France and the UK have agreed to become members of DRT. 
 In most cases these agreements reflect national mergers between (members of) Deloitte Haskins and Sells International and Touche Ross International.&equo; 
 He added that these countries reflected more than 75 per cent of the total revenues of the two seperate firms. 
 J Michael Cook, head of Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells International, was keen to minimise the impact of the defection. 
 A statement said he had &bquo;expressed enthusiasm for the decision&equo;, which leaves Touche Ross as the sole DRT representive in the UK. 
 Mr Cook added that Canada and other countries were rapidly moving toward merger agreements and that DRT would boast a fee income in excess of &dollar;3.3bn in the current year. 
 This would still leave DRT as the world's third largest accountancy firm behind KPMG and the recently merged Ernst &amp; Young, so far the only two successful mega-mergers. 
 In the UK, however, the position is radically altered. 
 If a merger between Coopers and Deloitte is successful, it will become the largest firm in the country and would have posted fee income of &pound;413m based on 1988 figures. 
 Senior members of both firms refused to confirm or deny the story last night. 
 But Coopers' employees said that they were informed of the decision to merge with Deloitte yesterday morning. 
 &bquo;It came as quite a surprise&equo;, said one. 
 The move marks an extraordinary volte face on the part of Coopers, which until last week was the only remaining firm in the original &bquo;Big Eight&equo; without a potential partner. 
 Brandon Gough, the chairman of Coopers, had publicly condemned the concept of large mergers as a nonsense. 
 But senior directors at Coopers yesterday told staff that the move would provide the firm with a wider audit base. 
 Deloitte has an impressive list of audit clients although its management consultancy practice is only half the size of Coopers. 
 However, there are doubts about how much of the Deloitte client list will be left intact once it has left the international organisation. 
 In particular, the firm handled the UK end of clients such as Merrill Lynch and General Motors. 
 These audits will more than likely switch to Touche Ross as the UK member of DRT. 
 Staff at Touche Ross were unaware of the planned link between Coopers and Deloitte UK yesterday. 
 But sources at Touche Ross said that the loss of revenue to Deloitte UK as a result of a cessation of referred work from the international organisation could be up to as much as &bquo;tens of millions of dollars&equo;. 
 One said that the US firm of Deloitte has a &bquo;wonderful client list which will now be served from here&equo;. 
 Also, it is unlikely that the new firm of Coopers and Deloitte will be able to incorporate the word Deloitte in its new name. 
 That will technically belong to Touche Ross as part of Deloitte Ross Tohmatsu. 
 Staff at Coopers were told that a name for the new firm had not been decided, but that it was likely that it would start with Coopers. 
 MB and Caradon agree on 338m pounds bid 
 By TERENCE WILKINSON, Assistant City Editor 
 MB GROUP, the heating, bathroom products and security printing group which also has packaging interests, has made an agreed &pound;337.6m bid for Caradon, the Twyfords and Everest building products company. 
 If the deal goes through, Dr Brian Smith will step down as chairman of MB Group to make way for Murray Stuart, currently group chief executive. 
 Mr Stuart's place will in turn be taken by Peter Jansen, deputy chairman and group chief executive of Caradon. 
 Daniel Cohen, finance director, and Tim Walker of Caradon, will also join the MB Group board. 
 &bquo;This is not an ordinary acquisition,&equo; Dr Smith said yesterday. 
 &bquo;The Caradon management team is joining MB Group and bringing their company with them.&equo; 
 Dr Smith explained that MB Group, formerly Metal Box, had identified Caradon 18 months ago as a suitable means of expanding into building products but the company had had to reorganise itself and create a new management team to make the current deal possible. 
 Earlier this year MB Group merged its world-wide packaging interests with the French Carnaud to form CMB in which it has a 25.5 per cent stake. 
 This meant it could concentrate on two core businesses &mdash; security printing and heating and bathroom products. 
 Caradon was bought from publishers Reed International for &pound;61m in 1985 and came to the stock market in June 1987 with an initial market value of &pound;134m. 
 The management team, led by Peter Jansen, which originally put up 10 per cent of the &pound;12m equity element of the buyout, has seen its investment increase 60-fold at the MB Group offer price. 
 The offer of 550p a share, half in cash and half in convertible preference shares, has received undertakings to accept from 35.8 per cent of Caradon shareholders but of these only 12 per cent, mainly Caradon directors, have given irrevocable undertakings. 
 Caradon shareholders are entitled to retain an interim dividend of 4p a share. 
 Interim pre-tax profits rose by an estimated 10 per cent to &pound;17m in the six months to 1 October. 
 Caradon shares closed 45p higher at 533p while MB Group, whose shares fell 8p on Monday amid speculation that it would bid for Caradon, recovered to close 2p higher at 208p. 
 The acquisition of Caradon, whose brands embrace Twyfords, Mira showers and Everest double glazing, will more than double the size of MB Group's building products business which feature Stelrad and Henrad radiators, Ideal boilers and Stelrad Doulton sanitary ware. 
 Hectic return as 15% of Ferranti changes hands 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Business Correspondent 
 FERRANTI'S shares encountered hectic trading when they returned from suspension yesterday as a host of conflicting rumours swept the stock market over the company's future. 
 Most stockbroking analysts believe it inevitable that the troubled electronics group will be taken over. 
 The only questions are by whom and at what price. 
 Frontrunners are said to be British Aerospace and Daimler Benz. 
 According to Seaq, the Stock Exchange's automated dealing system, about 115 million shares were traded, amounting to more than 15 per cent of the company's stock. 
 The shares closed at 56p &mdash; much higher than most analysts had been predicting given the &pound;185m hole which has appeared in Ferranti's accounts as a result of the International Signal and Control fraud. 
 The shares opened at 47 &frac12; p and climbed rapidly to 56p as a number of brokers came in as heavy buyers. 
 Hoare Govett was identified as an early buyer, pointing the finger at British Aerospace, one of the stockbroking firm's corporate clients. 
 Another Hoare Govett client is STC. 
 British Aerospace added to the speculation by refusing officially to confirm or deny the story. 
 However, well-informed sources ruled out both British Aerospace and STC as buyers, saying they believed Hoare Govett was acting on behalf of normal investment clients or Middle Eastern investors with an interest in Ferranti's future. 
 Stock market sources said that the Hoare Govett buying dried up after about 60 million Ferranti shares had been traded, at which point Smith New Court stepped in and remained an aggressive buyer at 56p until the close. 
 Some market men said they believed Smith was trying to support the price because the firm was already heavily exposed to Ferranti, having picked up the bulk of shares placed at 81p in July by Jim Guerin, International Signal and Control's former chairman. 
 British Aerospace is said to be one of the key contenders to mount a rescue bid for Ferranti, a vital subcontractor providing navigational and radar equipment for BAe's military aircraft. 
 Another company to which Ferranti is known to be talking is Daimler Benz, the giant West German vehicles, aircraft and electricals group. 
 According to some stock market sources, Ferranti was in talks with Daimler about the possibility of a partnership before the fraud which now threatens its future came to light. 
 Parkinson rules out tunnel aid 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Correspondent 
 EUROTUNNEL'S share price continued to fall sharply yesterday as Andre Benard, the consortium's French co-chairman, conceded that the &pound;2bn cost overrun on the Channel tunnel was causing &bquo;serious problems&equo;. 
 Meanwhile, Cecil Parkinson, the Secretary of State for Transport, said the Government had ruled out any idea of helping to fund the ailing project. 
 Shares in Eurotunnel fell a further 50p to close at 600p, making a 15 per cent drop in the Anglo-French venture's stock market value in the two days since it disclosed a 50 per cent rise in the cost of the tunnel to at least &pound;7bn. 
 Interviewed on the French TV channel Antenne 2, Mr Benard conceded that the underestimate of the project's costs &bquo;poses really serious problems for us&equo;, although he added: &bquo;There is no question of stopping work at this time.&equo; 
 The banks financing the huge project have given Eurotunnel until the end of the year to come up with an agreed costing for completion of the tunnel sufficient to enable them to release fresh loans. 
 Their technical advisers, the American engineering consultancy Parsons de Leuw Cather and the German consultancy Lahmeyer International, estimate the cost of the project now at &pound;8.1bn. 
 Eurotunnel, which is already in default of its credit agreement with the synidcate of 200 banks, is seeking an extra &pound;1.2bn to &pound;1.6bn on top of the &pound;6bn raised so far. 
 The Bank of England is understood to be keeping a watch as discussions continue between Eurotunnel and its four agent banks, which include the Midland and National Westminster. 
 Speaking during a visit to the Transport and Road Research laboratory at Crowthorne, Berkshire, Mr Parkinson said: &bquo;A way will be found around these problems. 
 Eurotunnel co-chairman Alastair Morton has a difficult job on his hands but he has shown he can handle it. 
 This is not a matter for the Government.&equo; 
 Later in the day, following a meeting in Dartford, Kent, with Tory MPs and members of the public protesting over the route of the planned Channel tunnel high-speed rail link, Mr Parkinson reiterated his faith in a private sector solution to the funding crisis. 
 Peter Rawlins takes over at the exchange 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Correspondent 
 PETER RAWLINS, a former partner with accountants Arthur Andersen, has emerged as the International Stock Exchange's next chief executive following the decision of Jeffrey Knight to stand down from the post, writes John Moore. 
 Mr Rawlins, 38, has spent the past seven years working with the Lloyd's insurance market and was once personal assistant to the first chief executive of that community, Ian Hay Davison. 
 Since 1985 Mr Rawlins has been a director of Sturge Holdings, the publicly quoted Lloyd's underwriting and stockbroking group, and managing director of its principal operating subsidiary, R W Sturge. 
 He has been a director of Wise Speke, one of the largest regional stockbrokers in the UK since its acquisition by Sturge in 1987. 
 Mr Rawlins announced his intention to leave Sturge at some time in the future towards the end of last year although he had no specific plans for the next step in his career. 
 He said yesterday that he was approached by headhunters for the &pound;150,000 a year stock exchange job in August. 
 Andrew Hugh Smith, chairman of the exchange, said yesterday he was delighted that Mr Rawlins had accepted the appointment. 
 &bquo;He brings considerable outside experience and proven ability in defining practical business strategies and putting them to work in a market environment,&equo; Mr Hugh Smith said. 
 &bquo;His understanding of the application of modern information technology solutions to complex business problems will be of particular benefit.&equo; 
 Mr Rawlins takes up his appointment on 27 November. 
 Millwall Football Club seeks listing 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Correspondent 
 MILLWALL Football Club, which is playing only its second season in the First Division in its 104-year history, is to obtain a Stock Exchange listing. 
 The club has enjoyed a single year of profit since Reg Burr took over as club chairman three years ago. 
 The listing, which is to raise &pound;4.8m through a 38.5 per cent placing, will give the club a market capitalisation of &pound;13m, worth about the same as Tottenham Hotspur, the only other English football club to be publicly owned. 
 It is just a few years since the club &mdash; whose anthem was: &bquo;We are Millwall. 
 No one likes us. 
 We don't care&equo; &mdash; had the worst reputation for hooliganism in the League. 
 In 1985, during an away match with Luton, Millwall fans invaded the pitch, forcing police to retreat under a barrage of seats ripped from the stands. 
 Millwall is now to join the junior Unlisted Securities Market while Tottenham has a full quotation. 
 The club is planning to sell its present ground in east London and move half a mile down the road to create a leisure and community centre. 
 Just over one-third of the company's shares &mdash; 20 million &mdash; are to be placed at 20p with institutional investors and a further five million will be put on offer. 
 Mr Burr said the rump of the shares on offer would be aimed at the 11,000 members of the club as Stock Exchange rules did not allow shares to be allotted to them directly. 
 Figuring out the typical company executive 
 By SARAH HOGG 
 BRITAIN'S typical executive is male, 44 years old and has a salary of &pound;30,355 (including &pound;4,826 in bonus pay), according to a comprehensive annual survey conducted by P-E Inbucon, writes Sarah Hogg. 
 But he probably received a pay rise of less than 10 per cent in 1988-89. 
 Only 36 per cent of managers and executives received double-digit pay rises, though top executives did markedly better. 
 The typical executive has a company car, private medical insurance and a company pension scheme. 
 He has probably been with his company for 13 years and in his present job for four. 
 The survey is large enough &mdash; covering 11,179 executives &mdash; to provide detailed information on particular groups. 
 It shows that: The average managing director's salary in companies with turnover of more than &pound;1bn was &pound;141,000. 
 In companies with turnover of less than &pound;3m the average salary was &pound;34,724. 
 Executive salaries in financial services and the communications industry were 18 per cent above average. 
 Low payers were public administration, wholesale distribution, metal manufacture and mechanical engineering. 
 London salaries were only 11 per cent above average, with executive salaries in Yorkshire, Humberside and the East Midlands 5 per cent below average, showing much less of a regional difference than is often assumed. 
 Bonuses are spreading to more than half of all managing directors. 
 They received an average cash payment of &pound;12,468. 
 Executive share option schemes are also spreading. 
 More than a fifth of all executives were covered last year. 
 Although personal pension plans are now being taken up fast enough to alter the Chancellor's tax sums, there was little evidence of their popularity in the survey. 
 Wall Street closes at new high 
 By SARAH HOGG 
 NEW YORK (Reuter) &mdash; Programme buying and a rush of short-covering sent US blue chips to new highs, with the Dow Jones Industrial Average closing 40.84 points up at 2,754.56. 
 Richard Meyer, managing director of institutional trading at Ladenburg Thalmann and Co, said the market's strong gains were unusual in light of bellwether International Business Machines Corp's weakness. 
 IBM closed down 27 8 at 1053 4. 
 &bquo;It appears that Big Blue does not lead the market. 
 The old rule of thumb does not apply,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;This is a market of the nineties.&equo; 
 A strengthening in the dollar on reports of turmoil in Panama provided some overall support. 
 Donald Selkin, head of stock index futures research at Prudential-Bache, said &bquo;panic short-covering&equo; might have boosted prices toward the end. 
 Sterling slipped marginally yesterday in advance of a widely-expected increase in West German interest rates tomorrow, writes Peter Torday. 
 The pound eased 0.39 pfennigs to close at DM3.0283 in London and a stronger dollar pushed it down 1.3 cents to &dollar;1.6050. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Quiet flows the don: &bquo;Dick Crossman&equo; &mdash; Tam Dalyell: Weidenfeld &amp; Nicolson, 14.95 pounds 
 By J ENOCH POWELL 
 WHAT A lucky man Dick Crossman was &mdash; and now he's gone and been lucky again. 
 He has had his portrait drawn by Tam Dalyell, who happens (though, parliamentarily speaking, an awkward cuss) to have the gift of deep and sympathetic insight into character. 
 It was just what Dick Crossman needed from a non-hagiographer. 
 I belonged to that great multitude who couldn't help liking Dick Crossman: he and I were always nice to one another, right to the day in 1974 shortly before his death when he came to the Birmingham Bull Ring in acute physical discomfort to hear me advise my fellow-electors to vote Labour if they wanted out of the Common Market. 
 (Times have changed.) 
 &bquo;Was Crossman a snob? 
 My wife, who liked him and to whom he was always charming, thinks he was a snob. 
 I think he was not.&equo; 
 Well, Tam has asked the question but answered it elsewhere, writing that Crossman's &bquo;sense of his own position in the elite of the nation never deserted him&equo;, and that &bquo;he seldom if ever had any doubts about his place at the very epicentre of the British Establishment&equo;. 
 That, in my opinion, is dead right. 
 But the important quality about Dick Crossman, which made him unique among Members of Parliament and made his testament to the understanding of British Government unique, is that he was the pure, 100 per cent archetypal don, a don through and through, albeit a don whose special subject was politics in practice. 
 &bquo;Crossman tended to presume that all those he came across, at work or socially, liked nothing better than to have their intellectual sacred cows challenged, their arguments questioned and their assumptions subjected to loud investigation.&equo; 
 That is the portrait of a don, a don in his supreme incarnation, a don going about the business that he was designed for by nature. 
 Of course, as should be the way with a don, he excited dismay - dismay more than dislike or distrust. 
 I can see now a typical speech of Crossman's from the back benches. 
 Before long, Members around him were spellbound, like disciples, by the dialectical and philosophical success with which he was defending their case and trouncing their opponents. 
 Then the same thing, as always, would happen. 
 Looks of admiration changed to signs of unease and bewilderment, and the chorus of &bquo;Hear, Hear&equo; was stilled. 
 Like some great vessel swinging at anchor, Crossman's argument had come round half circle, as he failed to resist the seduction of the alternative, opposite or incompatible theory. 
 He sat down at last to silence, but as a man fulfilled: the tutorial was over. 
 I believe it to have been factually true that Crossman's ambition to gain and retain Cabinet office was the aspiration to be in a position to observe what goes on as an academic or a philosopher observes. 
 Unlike Plato, from whom he never escaped, Crossman was not satisfied to &bquo;stand behind a wall out of the storm of wind and dust&equo;. 
 The wind and the dust were what Crossman wanted to know about; and he went in search of them and found them, in Coventry, in the Commons and in the Cabinet. 
 What is good about this portrait and serves Dick Crossman's memory well is that Tam Dalyell is so candid with his reservations, despite the contrary pull of loyalty and affection. 
 &bquo;I had the impression that unlike the principled left, Crossman did not ever quite make up his mind whether or not to crawl for office.&equo; 
 Or again, in the matter of the Labour government's covert development of a British nuclear bomb: &bquo;Crossman, in my view, does not emerge from this controversy in a favourable light. 
 Almost alone among MPs he latched on to the truth. 
 He had the potential for massive press coverage. 
 Yet he kept quiet. 
 I am afraid it was because he did not want to get entangled with the left on such an emotional issue.&equo; 
 I have italicised the words which, in my judgment, contain the solution. 
 The don in him could be satisfied and its conscience allayed by having intellectually broken into the truth. 
 Despite Dick Crossman's native love of a row, there was not sufficient of the political fighter about him to light the blue touchpaper regardless. 
 &bquo;Crossman never, to my knowledge, considered resigning.&equo; 
 That is a politician's saddest obituary. 
 Each for himself: David Blunkett on the Government's inconsistency over collective self-help 
 By DAVID BLUNKETT 
 THE Government has a clever knack of stealing other people's clothes, never more so than in its espousal of &bquo;active citizenship&equo; as a desirable virtue. 
 Of course, giving time and helping others is important: but it goes hand in hand with collective action to bring about wider change. 
 It therefore comes ill from this Government to appeal for people to accept greater obligation to each other, when its policies have accelerated the decline of mutuality and neighbourliness. 
 Collective self-help and co-operative ways of tackling problems go back a long way. 
 In the nineteenth century, the Goose and Burial Clubs were the forerunner of the social security system and the welfare state &mdash; the goose was for Christmas, the burial speaks for itself. 
 The right-wing ideologue Frederich Hayek wrote: &bquo;Obligations can only exist towards known and identifiable individuals. 
 They cannot exist to society as a whole&equo;. 
 This view sums up the present Conservative philosophy, seen in government policies towards the welfare state, local government and taxation. 
 In many ways, the poll tax embodies the attitude which dismisses our interdependence, and therefore our obligations towards each other. 
 This is why the Government's present enthusiasm for volunteering is hard to stomach. 
 Making a political virtue out of cutting taxes to the better off, in order to encourage them to give money to charity to meet the needs of others, is, to say the least, contrary. 
 Voluntary help comes in all shapes and sizes, from large national organisations to simple individual kindnesses. 
 Whatever form it takes, it offers no personal recognition or status, and nor should it. 
 It is necessary, however, that society recognises the importance of caring for others as a fundamental part of living. 
 No one would deny that enterprise and competitiveness are important; but what we see around us today is the elevation of self-interest as something to be applauded. 
 If we are brought up to accept the doctrine of looking after number one, it is not surprising to find the result of that upbringing reflected in society. 
 This inevitably leads to a climate in which the likelihood of giving not only money but also one's time is reduced. 
 The sheer pressure of life pushes people into having less time for each other, rather than more. 
 To give time, you must have it &mdash; and to have it, you must either be out of work or able to spare valuable hours outside your job. 
 Recent calls by the Home Office Minister, John Patten, for those who are successful to give three hours a week to voluntary causes could be taken more seriously if overall government policy were not pushing people in the opposite direction. 
 In a world where money and material reward are held in far higher esteem than quality of life, their response will be predictable. 
 Government policy has pointed the direction &mdash; others have merely followed. 
 Yet there is hope. 
 Attitudes are changing and concern for others is re-emerging from the recent dark decade. 
 The Speaker of the House of Commons, Bernard Weatherill, has lent his name to a Commission on Citizenship in which the organisation Community Service Volunteers has taken a lead. 
 Aided by the Prince's Youth Business Trust and others, the intention is that the Commission should produce guidance to encourage greater active citizenship from our earliest school days through to our retirement. 
 The Prince of Wales's recent initiative forms part of this detailed consideration of options. 
 But for any good ideas to work, we have to restore a sense of decency, of caring and an understanding of shared concern for the fabric of our community. 
 Dependence on charity is just as debilitating as dependence on the state, if not more so. 
 Neither is desirable or necessary. 
 True independence and self-determination come from recognising that we not only have responsibility for ourselves, but also obligations to others. 
 This means that through the raising and spending of taxes, locally and nationally, we provide a fairer and more just society. 
 Through the development of community services and a decentralised, non-bureaucratic welfare state, we can lift people out of poverty and deprivation. 
 In this way, individuals can develop their full potential and contribute to their own well-being and that of others. 
 What the state can never offer, however, are befriending, time to talk and share, personal kindness and a spontaneous response to need. 
 So it is that we must also support voluntary action and volunteering as essential in a healthy democracy in a civilised society. 
 Still an Everest climb to power 
 By PETER JENKINS 
 BRIGHTON: &bquo;We are fit to serve our country,&equo; said Neil Kinnock, the Labour Party leader, in the peroration to the peroration of an epic speech to conference. 
 If that sounded a bit like the result of an army medical board it was appropriate enough: the chief purpose of this year's conference is to signal that the Labour Party is ready once more for active service. 
 Indeed, Mr Kinnock called for a modest celebration at Labour's recovery: it was an encouragement, an inspiration to see the party working together once more, he said. 
 This was his way of declaring that the battle for the Labour Party was won and the Battle for Britain about to commence. 
 Such declarations are of little intrinsic importance but they tell us something of how a politician sees the world and his own place in it. 
 This was the first year since he became leader of his party six years ago that Mr Kinnock was relieved of his preoccupation with an ungovernable party and was able to turn his attention properly to the government of the country. 
 Hence, this was the first of his conference performances which was aimed primarily at the nation. 
 It was a severe test for him, for it is a widely held view that his talents as a party manager are not matched by his capabilities as a potential Prime Minister. 
 How did he do? 
 Not badly at all, given the immense difficulty of restoring credibility to Labour as a party of government. 
 Mr Kinnock staggers under the additional handicap of having no ministerial experience which would equip him for the supreme office to which he aspires. 
 He is the child of Labour's crisis which resulted in his ideological credentials being preferred to the experience and qualifications of his rivals. 
 Today he has shed a good deal of that ideology &mdash; his speech yesterday was social democratic through and through &mdash; but he remains devoid of the work experience relevant to his next task which is to convince the country that he, and Labour, are qualified to form the next government. 
 The most successful feature of his speech was his recruitment of the future to Labour's cause. 
 All elections in two-party parliamentary systems are essentially about whether or not it is time for a change. 
 Yesterday Mr Kinnock presented a picture of a world changing so rapidly around the present government that the Prime Minister had become &bquo;out of touch, out of date and out of step with the British people&equo;. 
 As she enters her second decade in power, this promises to be an effective line of attack. 
 Mr Kinnock has learnt that it is more effective to mock the Prime Minister as an anachronism in a brave new world than snarl the word &bquo;Thatcherism&equo; and present her as the personification of all evil. 
 He has grasped that it is more profitable to attack the Government for incompetence and negligence than to present it as a systematic and all-too-competent conspiracy against the people. 
 The theme he hammered in yesterday's speech was that here was an administration increasingly losing its grip, its miracles turning to dross, the &bquo;Thatcher Revolution&equo; shown up as a fraud. 
 It may be a mistake to allow the Prime Minister no credit at all. 
 Since around 1982 real living standards have risen continuously and substantially. 
 Prosperity twice swept Mrs Thatcher back to power. 
 People know the evidence of their pockets and are unlikely to be easily persauded that Mrs Thatcher's Britain has been, or has yet become, the economic disaster area which Mr Kinnock depicted. 
 Moreover, to predict that an incoming Labour government would surely be faced with a mess far greater than any previous inheritance by a new administration is a double-edged weapon. 
 Would such a mess be safe in Labour's hands? 
 Its record in economic crisis-management does not inspire confidence. 
 Voters do not instinctively turn to Labour in time of trouble. 
 They turn to it when conditions seem ripe for social advance. 
 When governments change it is also sometimes due to pressures to open and enlarge the elites of wealth and power. 
 In 1964, it was proverbially the white-coated technicians of ICI Billingham in Cleveland who typified the swing to Labour and the Wilsonian scientific revolution. 
 Mr Kinnock took a leaf from Harold Wilson's book &mdash; and coined a goodish phrase &mdash; when he declared that &bquo;education and training are now the commanding heights of the economy&equo;. 
 That is the sort of talk which must find a response in a country in which acute labour shortage coexists with unconscionably high unemployment. 
 Foreign affairs are not often an important factor in British general elections. 
 But the rapid and dramatic changes which are taking place in the world today, changes of a hopeful and not a frightening kind, could help to make a long-serving government more vulnerable to the time-for-a-change mentality. 
 Everywhere today expectations of a better world are running high, excited primarily by Mrs Thatcher's friend Mikhail Gorbachev. 
 It was in the context of what Mr Kinnock presented as her increasing isolationism within this changing world that he pressed the charge that she was &bquo;out of touch, out of date and out of step&equo;. 
 A speech is a speech is a speech &mdash; like one of Peter Mandelson's roses. 
 The hard reality of Labour's electoral predicament remains the same today as yesterday. 
 There is an Everest to climb to power. 
 Meanwhile, the Government is doing not as badly, nor Labour as well, as it can appear amid the heady enthusiasm of a conference. 
 City pundits see troubles for the economy in the coming months but are much more optimistic about prospects a year or more from now. 
 There is a lot of dying yet in Mrs Thatcher's administration. 
 For all that, party conferences are powerful image-making events and a good success like yesterday's will make Mr Kinnock a more confident and formidable contender. 
 The spectre at the birthday feast: Patricia Clough predicts a humiliating time for Erich Honecker at the GDR's 40th anniversary celebrations 
 By PATRICIA CLOUGH 
 One might almost pity the frail old man in East Berlin, seemingly helpless and uncomprehending as his life's work crumbles around him. 
 The fortieth anniversary of the founding of East Germany on Saturday could have been a crowning moment in Erich Honecker's career. 
 He could have boasted to world leaders of the model communist state he and his comrades have created, now widely recognised in the world, with happy contented people enjoying the highest standard of living in the Eastern bloc. 
 He could have basked in the illusion of being a benevolent father-figure to his people, actually loved and appreciated and secure in the knowledge that even after he went, things would go on along the tracks he had laid down. 
 Now he must be wondering how he is going to get through the week. 
 The thousands of East German refugees in West German embassies, the tens of thousands who have poured out to the West through Hungary are a terrible and unending indictment of his Stalinist regime. 
 Worse still, the embassy refugees manoeuvred him into an impossible corner. 
 They knew how desperately he and his comrades wanted to celebrate their day amid sweetness and light. 
 How could he receive Mikhail Gorbachev and other leaders while the world watched 4,500 of his people voluntarily submitting to horrific conditions in the embassy in Prague just to get to the West? 
 (Alternatively, how could Mr Gorbachev come?) 
 He has &bquo;temporarily&equo; imposed visa requirements for Czechoslovakia, the one place where East Germans could go without passports or permission. 
 That will make East Germans feel even more imprisoned and could heat up resentment against the government to explosion point. 
 Opposition groups are springing up like mushrooms, calling ever more boldly and openly for reforms &mdash; freedom of opinion, democracy, justice, freedom to travel. 
 Although Mr Honecker warmly supports the old men who crushed the uprising in Tiananmen Square, he seems to have no stomach for a brutal crackdown. 
 Demonstrators are being treated with restraint, and dissidents, although under surveillance and sometimes harassed, are still at the moment free to speak out. 
 No one seriously expects revolution in East Germany from below. 
 Troublemakers have been deported and the education system has trained the population to obedience. 
 But sheer pressure &mdash; from within, from the Soviet Union and other allies and from the West &mdash; could conceivably do the job. 
 The secret police will doubtless try to make sure there are no reformist demonstrators chanting &bquo;Gorbi, Gorbi&equo; in the streets on Saturday, as thousands did in Leipzig on Monday night. 
 The honoured guest will doubtless not be encouraged to take a crowd bath. 
 But Mr Gorbachev's very presence will be a reminder of how very wrong things have gone. 
 Mr Honecker and his men, boasting confidently that their economy was so well run it did not need Soviet-style reforms, were banking on the expectation that Mr Gorbachev would fail. 
 The Soviet leader is far from succeeding but he is still very much there, while the East German old guard is looking ever more like yesterday's men. 
 The more stubbornly East Germany's old men resist change, the greater becomes the danger that the whole edifice they have constructed will collapse around them, threatening stability in Europe and raising the question of reunification for which no one is prepared. 
 No one wants chaos in East Germany &mdash; not the West Germans, nor the internal opposition, nor the Russians. 
 Everyone is telling Mr Honecker what he should do, the East and West Germans openly, the Soviets more subtly: ask yourselves why people are leaving and save your country through reform. 
 Mr Gorbachev may refrain from saying it publicly on Saturday but he can be expected to press Mr Honecker all the more urgently in private. 
 But the East Germans, deaf to all advice, are lashing out in fury and bitterness, blaming everyone but themselves for their predicament. 
 Just as it did during the mass exodus in the weeks before the Berlin Wall was built, the state propaganda machine is claiming that the current wave of emigration is due to a campaign organised by West Germany to lure their people away. 
 Those who went have &bquo;betrayed&equo; their country. 
 Bonn's principle that East Germans have an automatic right to West German citizenship and protection is &bquo;revanchism&equo;, its refusal to turn refugees away from its embassies is a &bquo;provocation&equo;. 
 The decision to &bquo;expel&equo; the first batch of embassy refugees to the West was a &bquo;humanitarian act&equo; done in the interests of the many children involved and to avoid epidemics. 
 The &bquo;expellees&equo; have in any case &bquo;isolated themselves&equo; from East German society, they are &bquo;mindless strays&equo;, many of them are &bquo;antisocial&equo; and the country is better off without them. 
 A recent Protestant Church Synod, where speakers aired grievances and called for change, was a conspiracy &bquo;to prepare the way for reunification&equo;. 
 East Germany has defeated the &bquo;class enemy&equo; and created a superior society where human beings can develop free of exploitation. 
 What do fast cars and travel count for, the party's youth organ asked, compared with the warmth of family, love, friendship, security and harmony? 
 The whole thing, of course, is being blown up out of all proportion by the Western media. 
 Absurd though it may seem, it is quite likely that Mr Honecker and his companions genuinely believe all this. 
 For the East German state is the realisation of the dreams of a young roofer as he grew up among the filth of the coal mines and steel mills of the Saarland in the Thirties. 
 He and his fellow communists, enraged by the poverty, the unemployment and exploitation of the workers, would fight with the Nazi gangs, their strident shawm pipe bands competing in decibel levels with the Nazis' drums and trumpets. 
 He dreamed of a society where there would be no capitalist bosses; no unemployment; with food; housing and medical services for all; where old women would not be thrown out of their lifelong homes to make way for richer tenants and children would never go hungry. 
 When the Nazis took power he went underground and worked in the communist resistance, was arrested and did eight years' penal servitude. 
 He was released when the war ended. 
 Immediately he joined the group of hard, inflexible German communists the Soviet Union had sent to set up a puppet government in the sector of Germany they occupied. 
 After the Western allies turned the western part of Germany into a sovereign state, the Soviets followed suit and the German Democratic Republic was founded on 7 October 1949. 
 As the hated capitalist rival, West Germany quickly took off with its economic miracle, for a long time East Germany remained poor, grim and repressive as the regime struggled to get a communist system working. 
 That much of the population could not see the superiority of their society did not deter them: a workers' uprising was crushed, the Wall was built, travel was extremely limited, all criticism rigorously suppressed. 
 But things did get eventually get better. 
 German ability and hard work made the economy the most efficient in the Eastern bloc, helped by generous injections from West Germany as relations improved. 
 Although reality never matched the propaganda, people were better off, they had plenty to eat, the housing shortage was less critical, the atmosphere more relaxed. 
 Once the shunned and despised puppet, East Germany was officially recognised by most countries. 
 Years of struggle for legitimation and equal status with West Germany were crowned by a state visit to Paris and a historic official visit to West Germany. 
 Two goals remain &mdash; a state visit to Britain (little hope there, but a visit by some crowned head to East Germany remains a burning ambition), and to the President of the United States in the White House. 
 East Berlin is being rebuilt and restored at vast expense as a full-scale capital and show-window. 
 Mr Honecker evidently felt that things were going so well he could afford to relax and give his people what they wanted most: more freedom to travel to the West. 
 That was a disastrous mistake. 
 Glimpses of the West whetted appetites and fuelled discontent at home. 
 Quickly it became clear that he had mistaken quiet and comfort for contentment. 
 The moment Hungary began to dismantle its part of the Iron Curtain, hundreds began to leave. 
 It looks as if Mr Honecker, 77 and only slowly recovering from a gall-bladder operation, is incapable of grasping the situation in his country. 
 He and the other leaders, at the pinnacle of the fossilised hierarchy they have constructed, seem isolated from reality. 
 They lead privileged lives in official residences, are driven everywhere in official cars, buy from special shops and, it is said, have unpleasant facts screened from them by fawning officials. 
 Last year, Johannes Rau, the Social Democrat Prime Minister of North Rhine-Westphalia, asked Mr Honecker why the mood among his people was so bad. 
 He replied, &bquo;the unity of the masses with the party was never so strong as now. 
 The people are behind the party.&equo; 
 And he invited him to come to the Mayday parade to see for himself. 
 Nevertheless, as he began to recover from his operation, Mr Honecker clearly had to face the problem of the embassy refugees and the mass emigration, and the decision to let the first batch go was obviously his. 
 But drawing the consequences is something else. 
 How can a 77-year-old man with a mission admit that he was wrong all along? 
 Mr Honecker is up a pole and all the ladders offered him to climb down would be an admission of failure. 
 As the anniversary approaches, he seems bewildered and uncertain what to do. 
 That nobody else, including the West Germans, does either, is little consolation. 
 Meanwhile speculation is mounting in the West that hardliners are beginning to dictate what he should do, and he is no longer in full control. 
 As Saturday draws near, the communist dream he thought he had helped realise is in danger of turning to ashes in his hands. 
 Leading Article: The birth of a grand theme 
 By PATRICIA CLOUGH 
 ALMOST inadvertently, Neil Kinnock has stumbled on his &bquo;big idea&equo;. 
 The Labour leader made formal obeisance to the language of socialism when he complained of the &bquo;neglect of the productive base&equo;. 
 But his theme &mdash; that Labour would concentrate on supply-side deficiencies of the British economy -was one which would naturally appeal to non-political parents and teachers and to business people seeking literate and numerate employees. 
 In much the same way his reference to the rundown, dirty and potentially dangerous state of public transport would strike a chord with commuters who use our shoddy and dilapidated railways or who drive on potholed roads. 
 Education and training were, Mr Kinnock said, &bquo;the commanding heights of the modern economy&equo; and human skills were the nation's most precious resource. 
 An undertrained and under-educated work-force led inexorably to balance of payments problems. 
 The next Labour government would, therefore, as a deliberate choice of priorities, concentrate investment in these areas, on technical research and development and on the modernisation of the transport system. 
 This is a far cry from the days when increases in national income were committed by the conference before they were generated and the economy's commanding heights were deemed to be heavy, smokestack industries. 
 The debate within Labour's ranks was then about how far and how fast they should be brought under the direct control of the state. 
 The Labour leader yesterday intoned the word &bquo;socialism&equo; in a purely ritualistic sense from time to time. 
 More significantly, he redefined socialism as a marriage of &bquo;necessary regulation and the dynamic of the market&equo;. 
 There is nothing in this phrase with which David Owen could quarrel. 
 There is growing, matter-of-fact, support for the proposition that significantly greater public investment in schools and colleges, in roads, railways and on the environment would be money productively spent, and that it is only the damaging and doctrinaire intransigence of Mrs Thatcher which obstructs such expenditure. 
 It is shrewd of Mr Kinnock to attempt to enlist this mood and to link Labour with such concepts as patriotism, efficiency and plain common sense, virtues which have more often been associated with the Conservative Party. 
 Similarly, it is shrewd of him to play for the internationalist vote after a prolonged period of sullen Little Englandism during which Labour threatened to withdraw from the Common Market and called into question this country's role within Nato. 
 Increasingly the Prime Minister is regarded by many swing voters as unconstructive and isolationist rather than a determined defender of British interests. 
 She, and not Mr Kinnock, is constantly at odds with the European Community and the Commonwealth. 
 A stance which was appropriate for the Age of Brezhnev and Galtieri now seems out of date and out of touch with the spirit of the times. 
 Mr Kinnock has yet to put flesh on his &bquo;big idea&equo;. 
 Until he does so, his enemies will, somewhat unfairly, compare his dedication to the contemporary economy's commanding heights with Harold Wilson's more grandiose, though ill-focused, flirtation with &bquo;the white heat of the scientific revolution&equo;, which came to nothing. 
 Ideas as well as money will be needed to improve education and training. 
 Science and technology need a focus for investment as well as funds. 
 Yet the Labour leader has finally found a theme which can appeal to traditional Labour voters and, more crucially, also to those voters from the political centre who now feel disenfranchised. 
 Letter: Overlooked genius in the twentieth century 
 From Mr GEOFF FOSTER 
 Sir: Your contributor William Rees-Mogg identified his list of 50 &bquo;mastersingers of Europe&equo;. 
 He normally takes great care to keep us informed of the central part he plays in the worlds of affairs and ideas. 
 I was therefore surprised to see that he excluded his own name from the list. 
 What can have occasioned this sudden lapse into modesty? 
 Letter: Overlooked genius in the twentieth century 
 From Mr FRANCO GALGANI 
 Sir: As a Tuscan expatriate in Britain, I feel duty bound to point out that five out of the eight Italians included in the '50 mastersingers of Europe' were from Tuscany: Dante, Michelangelo, Leonardo, Machiavelli and Galileo. 
 Taking one of William Rees-Mogg's conclusions further, is it not logical to deduce that while &bquo;Italy is the cradle of European civilisation&equo;, Tuscany is right at the centre of it. 
 Letter: Overlooked genius in the twentieth century 
 From Dr JONATHAN MILLER 
 Sir: Returning from a long stay abroad, it is depressing to find so much rubbish in the streets, but it is even more upsetting to find it deliberately included in the newspapers as well (2 October). 
 The frivolous folly of trying to identify 50 geniuses who have shaped European culture is matched by the failure to recognise the distinctive achievement of our own era. 
 Although Lord Rees-Mogg's confession that he is not a modernist can just about explain his neglect of artists such as Schoenberg, Proust, Kafka, Beckett and Auden, sheer ignorance is the only way in which one can account for the omission of Charles Sherrington, Alan Hodgkin, Lord Adrian and David Hubel, to name but four in neurophysiology; Rutherford, Bohr, Planck, Heisenberg, Dirac and Gell-Man in physics. 
 And since the image of life on earth has been virtually redrawn as a result of the rapidly developing science of molecular biology, how can anyone fail to mention Crick, Monod, Bragg or Delbruck; and since the picture of the human mind has to be radically reconstrued following the work of von Neumann, Turing, Shannon and Wiener, it is hard to understand how none of these people received a mention. 
 Chomsky is no slouch either. 
 And what are we to make of the claim that the twentieth century has seen no philosophical achievements on the scale of Locke and Descartes? 
 What about Wittgenstein, Frege or Russell? 
 Or Quine for that matter? 
 And let's add Godel for good measure. 
 Rawls? 
 But the most objectionable aspect of his article is the airy complacency with which he identifies the psychological morbidity of all but his chosen few. 
 Psycho-history is a derelict enterprise at the best of times, and who can be sure about the mental health of any of the great heroes of the past? 
 I wouldn't like to meet Caravaggio on a dark night and who can be sure that Darwin's life-long illness was really the result of Chagas' disease? 
 In any case, this type of speculation is a complete waste of time and anyone who seriously thinks that all is quiet on the western front as the twentieth century draws to a close must be dozing in his dug-out. 
 Leading Article: Life behind bars at Number 10 
 From Dr JONATHAN MILLER 
 NUMBER 10 Downing Street is not Buckingham Palace. 
 Nor is it the Forbidden City or the Kremlin. 
 Margaret Thatcher is Prime Minister of an ancient and still fully functioning democracy. 
 Despite her occasional lapses into the royal &bquo;we&equo; and her desire to give comfort to victims of disaster, she is not monarch, head of state, nor dictator. 
 Why then must the street in which she lives, in a row of handsome but not very grand Georgian houses, be protected by gates and railings which can without hyperbole be described as neo-palatial? 
 Let's be fair. 
 If Mrs Thatcher is touched by paranoia, it is not without reason. 
 She knows the IRA would like to get her. 
 They murdered her friend and political ally, Airey Neave. 
 They tried to kill her and her Cabinet, and nearly succeeded, when they blew up the Grand Hotel, Brighton, during the 1984 Conservative Party conference. 
 That assault claimed five lives and injured many others. 
 Only this August, an Arab extremist thought to be a member of Hizbollah died in a London hotel while strapping a bomb to his body. 
 Was his target political, or &bquo;merely&equo; literary? 
 A certain nervousness on the Prime Minister's part, and on the part of those obliged to protect her safety, is in order. 
 All due precautions must be taken. 
 No reasonable person could have objected &mdash; nor did they &mdash; when, shortly after the death of the Hizbollah bomber, an impressive steel anti-terrorist shield was installed close to No. 10. 
 It lies flat in the road about half-way down the street, and can swiftly be raised to block the progress of an unauthorised vehicle. 
 Since August, it seems, official minds have been working. 
 One day the inspiration came: why not block off any such potential assault vehicles, as well as bomb-laden or armed individuals, before they get half-way down the street? 
 The waist-high barrier which has limited public access since 1981 was &mdash; doubtless correctly &mdash; judged to be too flimsy to block a suicide mission. 
 One of its virtues was that it looked temporary: these may be abnormal times, it seemed to proclaim, but one day terrorism will be beaten, and once again doting parents will be able to photograph ambitious children on the steps of No. 10. 
 The message from the proposed new gates and railings is that bad times are here to stay. 
 Equally regrettably, they suggest that she who (presumably) approved them is not so much a Pharisee as a Philistine: one, moreover, who has been impressed by too many drives down The Bishop's Avenue, where Hampstead's temples to new money are built, en route to the Finchley constituency. 
 It is not surprising that the Royal Fine Art Commission should have considered the design inappropriate. 
 Its efficacy may also be questioned: the RFAC's chairman, Lord St John of Fawsley, has pointed out that gates which must be opened and shut will merely attract attention to the Prime Minister's movements. 
 She and her security advisers should go back to the drawing board. 
 Answers to silence a smart-ass 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 YOU'RE having a conversation about traffic problems. 
 You're waxing lyrical about the M25 and the hopelessness of building more roads. 
 Suddenly the man next to you says: &bquo;Of course, you realise that more than 50 per cent of all road journeys are less than three miles long?&equo; 
 What do you do? 
 If you are at all normal, you bypass the urge to throttle him, or to shake him by the head and shout: &bquo;What's that got to do with anything?&equo;, and find yourself nodding in agreement as if he has just proved something. 
 That's because we are all impressed by authoritative statements spiced with statistics. 
 We cannot help it. 
 He might just as well have said: &bquo;It's all very well asking for more money for the railways, but if the volume of rail freight were doubled, it would still be only a mere 16 per cent of the rail-and-road total.&equo; 
 You would feel equally unnerved and change the subject just as fast. 
 I actually heard a minister say that on the radio last week. 
 The interviewer was unnerved and changed the subject quickly. 
 The statement does not have to be true or relevant, of course &mdash; it just has to sound true and relevant. 
 And as luck would have it, I just happen to have a list of apparently germane truths which I have been maturing during the last month or so, after being worsted in various conversations. 
 Here are a few for you to use. 
 I hope they work. 
 TRANSPORT &bquo;Did you know that lorry drivers who pick up hitch-hikers have 73 per cent fewer accidents than those who don't?&equo; 
 &bquo;The average train may leave 10 minutes late, but it has been proved that the average car journey sets off at least 40 minutes after the announced time.&equo; 
 &bquo;Black cars are involved in 83 per cent more crashes after dark than during the day.&equo; 
 &bquo;What people never take into account about the M25 is that it is also designed as a defence barrier against an invading force. 
 Apparently no known tank force could break through a six-lane snarl-up, so the authorities have to be able to whistle up a traffic jam within minutes. 
 That's why there are so many jams on the M25. 
 They're practising.&equo; 
 CRIME &bquo;The prison population of the USA is bigger than the civilian population of seven member states of the United Nations, and better behaved than four of them.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, but in more than three-quarters of the murders committed in the UK, the murderer knew the victim already &mdash; and quite liked them.&equo; 
 &bquo;The figures for drug usage are highest among people who are actually already in prison convicted of drug offences. 
 Drug usage is lowest among drug-dealers.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you say that capital punishment is a deterrent, how do you explain that 87 per cent of all murderers convicted over the last 10 years thought there still was capital punishment?&equo; 
 AMERICA &bquo;Latest estimates show that by the year 2010, the USA will be a Japanese-owned country speaking Spanish. 
 That's why more than 43 Japanese universities have started Spanish courses this year.&equo; 
 &bquo;The reason that Hollywood keeps selling all its film companies to the Australians, the Japanese, and so on, is to prevent them falling into the hands of people from New York.&equo; 
 &bquo;Psychologists now think that America has never recovered from the traumatic blow of introducing baseball into the Los Angeles Olympics and then losing in the final to Japan.&equo; 
 SOCIAL &bquo;Sociologists apparently have come round to the belief that 50 per cent of middle-class parents who send their children to private schools would be happy to put them in the state system if dinner money was renamed lunch money.&equo; 
 &bquo;No famous athlete has ever gone into politics by joining Labour. 
 Nobody is more capitalist than the amateur athlete.&equo; 
 &bquo;The only place where all classes of British society mingle on equal terms is the motorway service area. 
 Did you realise that 43 per cent of all sociological surveys are carried out on the M1, M4 and M6? 
 By people disguised as waitresses or RAC recruiting officers?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fifty per cent of all people in Britain are educationally below average.&equo; 
 If none of these works, you can always try throttling your interlocutor, crying as you do so: &bquo;Did you know that 63 per cent of all smart-ass know-alls meet a violent and hideous end?&equo; 
 Letter: The future of Uppark 
 From Mr CHARLES BLACKETT-ORD 
 Sir: Surely with building as with anything else there is a distinction between maintenance and renewal. 
 The reconstruction of the interior of Uppark cannot reasonably be described as maintenance. 
 Complete renewal, while providing a stage for experts to display their knowledge would deflect this limited resource from the true maintenance of historic houses, which is clearly a more valuable outlet for their talents. 
 One of the important aspects of country house building that is rarely demonstrated is the basic structure &mdash; your photograph shows, in admirable clarity, the arrangement of load-bearing walls (and, incidentally, a precarious water tank in the roof) which are the bones on which the skin and organs are built. 
 If Uppark is stabilised and retained as a ruin, as it should be, the basic structure can be seen as an education itself. 
 Most of what is now visible internally is important historically but would be covered or damaged if the building were to be reconstructed as a modern pastiche within an original veneer. 
 The National Trust has already betrayed its trust, albeit accidentally, by allowing the building to burn down. 
 It should not betray it any further by building new architectural history. 
 Letter: The future of Uppark 
 From Lady JANE HOWARD 
 Sir: Professor Gomme (letter, 3 October) argues the case for the exact recreation of the interior of Uppark most cogently; and certainly, careful and committed reconstruction, such as can be seen at Chatelherault where Hamilton district council has faithfully, and against all the odds, achieved a marvellous reproduction of William Adam's hunting lodge for the fifth Duke of Hamilton, is not to be jeered at. 
 But Anna Pavord's recognition (27 September) of the opportunity for the twentieth century boldly to turn Uppark's tragedy to advantage, is a more compelling argument. 
 Why not create an exhibition centre inside a perfectly restored exterior for exhibitions of all that is best in furnishings in National Trust ownership - a Burrell within a Claverton? 
 There could be exhibitions of the best tapestries and textiles, the finest portraiture, the most outstanding silver; or the best of a certain period drawn together from National Trust houses; and perhaps linked displays on craftmanship, techniques, restoration and conservation. 
 It was said that the &bquo;Treasures of Britain' exhibition could not be seen in England for lack of somewhere suitable to mount it. 
 Uppark could fill that gap. 
 Letter: Green circle 
 From Professor RICHARD MACVE 
 Sir: Your special report on the green revolution and how the investment industry is now wearing an ecological heart on its sleeve (27 September) was timely. 
 The following day I received a mail-shot from the Friends Provident promoting the merits of the &bquo;ethical investment policy&equo; of the Stewardship Savings Plan. 
 They offered not only to plant a tree in my name, if I applied for a policy, but also the choice of a free radio alarm clock or a telephone. 
 I could only speculate whether the industrial activity required to produce the clock radio and the telephone they wanted to give me, and all the ongoing activity to service those industries and their customers, would not cause more pollution, lead to more acid rain, and so destroy more trees than the one they planned to plant for me. 
 This raises two important issues. 
 First, is it an ethical investment policy to encourage people to try to have their cake and eat it? 
 Second, isn't there an urgent need for a fundamental rethinking of the accounting conventions by which company performance is measured, if would-be ethical investors are to know how environmentally friendly the companies in which they invest really are? 
 Letter: Future of Germany 
 From Dr CHRISTOPHER HILL 
 Sir: Timothy Garton Ash ('The sickly child of the cold war', 29 September) speaks for himself when he talks of &bquo;our ideal &mdash; a larger European Community&equo;. 
 His preference for a free vote in East Germany, enabling that country to join its western neighbour, is excessively sanguine even in the medium term, in its assumptions about the consequences for the international system as a whole. 
 Quite apart from the destabilising effects of such a precedent on (say) Yugoslavia, and the echoes of the Anschluss and Sudetenland issues of 50 years ago, the creation of a large, united Germany would make consensus-building far more difficult inside the European Community, and reinforce the hand of the security lobby in the USSR. 
 A much safer route to travel is that which Mr Garton Ash approves only as a means to an end, namely that of encouraging urgent reform in the German Democratic Republic, but as a separate state with a future of its own. 
 This would take the steam out of the refugee crisis and help us on towards the relaxed and variegated community of states across Europe as a whole which is likely to be the real guarantee of security. 
 Letter: Over the shop 
 From Mrs HILDA M. HAGGIE 
 Sir: Gail Counsell's article ('When living over the shop pays dividends', 30 September) gave me nostalgic memories of the advantages of this way of living 50 years ago. 
 From 1935-39 I lived in a flat on the top floor of number 45 in the &bquo;high street&equo; in Knightsbridge. 
 My job gave me awkward hours and frequent short-notice travel both at home and abroad. 
 Security and my creature comforts were cared for by a dry-cleaners on the street level; a cafe on the first floor that would send me up something on a tray when I came home late and tired; a retired beautician on the second floor who would revive me with an evening &bquo;facial&equo;; while the grocer round the corner saw to it that my larder was replenished for my homecomings. 
 The unfurnished rent for a bedroom looking through the tree tops to Wilton Place, a long-windowed living room overlooking Hyde Park, and access to my own flat roof, was &pound;2 per week in those halcyon days. 
 Letter: The real Pharisees 
 From Rabbi JOHN D. RAYNER 
 Sir: While tending to agree with the Archbishop of Canterbury's social critique as reported in your paper ('Runcie attack on &bquo;Pharisees&equo; revives rift with Tories', 2 October), I find his reference to the Pharisees more than a little unfortunate. 
 For about 100 years Jewish and Christian scholars have demonstrated over and over again that the stereotype of the Pharisees found in the Gospels is a distortion which reflects the animosity of the Evangelists rather than the historical truth or even the attitude of Jesus himself. 
 Far from being inclined towards self-righteousness, the Pharisees taught &bquo;Be humble before all men&equo;, and revered their teacher Hillel for his extreme humility; and far from being judgemental, they urged &bquo;Do not judge your fellow man until you are in his position&equo; and &bquo;Always judge others by the scale of merit (that is, charitably)&equo;. 
 Surely the Pharisees themselves should be judged, if not charitably, at least fairly: from their own literature (which the Jewish and Christian scholars referred to above have taken the trouble to study) rather than from the taunts of their opponents. 
 It is high time to abandon that caricature, too long perpetuated by dictionary definitions such as the one you quote from Chambers, both for the sake of historical justice and because, in the present as in the past, anti-Pharisaism and anti-Judaism have a nasty way of feeding on each other. 
 Letter: Pressure for federalism in Europe 
 From WILLIAM CASH, MP 
 Sir: Robert Hughes and Alan Haselhurst (letters, 29 September and 2 October) have avoided my main point about the future of democracy in Britain and Europe. 
 Those of us who support the European Community and the Single European Act (which I voted for as it stands) reject his misleading allegation that we think &bquo;democracy is at risk through our continued membership of the European Community&equo;. 
 Mr Haselhurst clearly thinks it is &bquo;absurd&equo; to be concerned about prospective federalism in Europe. 
 He prefers to allow this &bquo;journey&equo;, as he puts it, to continue on the principle of wait and see. 
 It is wholly unreal for anyone to imagine that such an issue, which he merely describes as &bquo;adjusting the democratic framework to suit new circumstances&equo; can be so lightly put to one side. 
 There is no blank cheque. 
 The real problem is that, unless resisted, the vigorous pressure for federalism by some leaders in Europe will become an assumed part of our involvement in the European Community. 
 We did not agree to this on accession in 1972, nor again in 1975 in the Referendum, nor in the acceptance of the Single European Act in 1986. 
 Mr Haselhurst claims that he is &bquo;not aware of any preconceived plan&equo; but seems unaware that Michel Rocard, Prime Minister of France, describes himself as &bquo;a complete federalist&equo; and of the recent advocacy by the five Christian Democrat leaders in Europe of a Single European Government and a Single European Parliament. 
 That is what convinces me where they would like to take us. 
 This would inevitably imply the end of our Westminster Parliament in any real sense and the loss of our freedom to decide our political, economic and social priorities and, with it, the loss of our hard won democratic system. 
 He does not seem to have noticed that the United States federal system is inherent in the constitution which those who joined the federation accepted on clearly defined terms. 
 He misunderstands events in the Baltic, Eastern Europe and East Germany. 
 Theirs is a bid for freedom of choice and democracy. 
 They are accused of nationalism but they would be, wouldn't they? 
 Letter: Student fees 
 From Dr JOHN SLOBODA 
 Sir: Peter Wilby's endorsement of the vice-chancellors' proposal to charge undergraduates full fees (29 September) confuses two quite different issues; expansion and access. 
 It is likely that the Government will not fully fund the required expansion in overall student numbers. 
 That being so, the vice-chancellors are acting responsibly to explore alternative sources of funding. 
 However, a widening of access requires that the universities attract and support under-represented groups, such as working-class school-leavers, black and Asian students, parents and mature workers. 
 Simply increasing the number of university places will not in itself increase access. 
 Without a major programme of &bquo;affirmative action&equo; in recruitment, admission, teaching, and assessment, any expansion of higher education will result in more privileged middle-class young people gaining degrees. 
 The majority of British people do not find universities attractive or accessible. 
 If the current proposals are not informed by an accurate assessment of the attitudes of a representative sample for working-class school leavers and their families, then their relevance to the issue of access is unproven. 
 Letter: The price of advice 
 From Dr E. D. IRVINE 
 Sir: The internal market advocated by the Government for the NHS (in particular for the hospitals) may not be as new an idea as may be thought. 
 When I was a junior doctor in hospitals in the late 1920s, I had under my care a doctor, then over 60, who told me that when he was young in London, he knew of a doctor's plate which conveyed this message to prospective patients: Medicine and advice fourpence, superior ditto sixpence. 
 Letter: Virgin independence 
 From Mr RICHARD BRANSON 
 Sir: Your Outlook Column (3 October) ended with the statement: But the question must remain as to whether a Japanese giant with five times the turnover of the Virgin Group will be content to stay a minority player. 
 I believe your correspondent forgets we are a private company still in absolute control of 75 per cent of it. 
 Our Japanese partner has no right to increase its shareholding. 
 We value our independence as much as you do. 
 Najibullah urges US to face &bquo;reality&equo;: Afghanistan's president tells Ahmed Rashid in Kabul that the powers backing the mujahedin will have to recognise that he is there to stay 
 By AHMED RASHID 
 PRESIDENT NAJIBULLAH of Afghanistan says he has no intention of resigning and the United States and Pakistan should accept reality and negotiate with him. 
 He urged the Western governments which withdrew their diplomats from Kabul on the eve of the Soviet military withdrawal in January to send them back and stop the psychological war they were waging against his government. 
 &bquo;It is ridiculous that somebody should talk to a party and at the same time dictate to that party who should be heading it,&equo; he said in an interview with The Independent. 
 He was replying to demands that he should resign to pave the way for talks between the Pakistan-based mujahedin resistance and Kabul's ruling Peoples Democratic Party (PDPA) on a peace settlement. 
 The President said that if the United States and Pakistan were really serious in wishing to settle the Afghan problem they should acknowledge the new reality in Afghanistan, where seven months after the departure of Soviet troops the PDPA had become more united and strengthened, while the guerrillas were in total disarray. 
 He and his government colleagues were confident they could hold their own against the mujahedin. 
 Pakistan and the United States would eventually have to accept direct talks with the PDPA, he said, adding that neither country had so far implemented any peace process. 
 The West &bquo;gave us hours to survive, then days, then weeks and now they give us seasons, but they should learn from the time that has elapsed already&equo;, he said. 
 He dismissed reports that his party was divided over tactics and personalities. 
 &bquo;Rivalry within the PDPA is a phenomenon that more or less belongs to the past,&equo; he said. 
 The President said his government had the right to acquire any sophisticated weapon from the Soviet Union, &bquo;if Pakistani intervention in Afghanistan expands&equo;, but he wanted a political settlement in which Afghanistan would be demilitarised and given international guarantees of permanent neutrality. 
 He criticised the Prime Minister of Pakistan, Benazir Bhutto, saying she had become &bquo;a cover&equo; for continuing the war in Afghanistan by providing military help and training to the mujahedin. 
 Afghans, he went on, had been optimistic when Miss Bhutto came to power but she had betrayed all her promises to settle the Afghan conflict. 
 &bquo;Miss Bhutto has harmed her political career&equo; by bowing &bquo;to the militarists and ultra-right opposition in Pakistan,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The ruling Pakistan Peoples Party was a prestigious party that was popular and they have let its prestige be ruined.&equo; 
 President Najibullah, like most Afghan officials, was cool about a possible role for ex-King Zahir Shah in any settlement: &bquo;For all forces who can play a role in the peace mechanism, the door is open directly to Kabul airport. 
 If anyone wants to come from some other way then he does not belong to us.&equo; 
 The former king condemns the Kabul regime with the same tone he used when the Soviet troops were in Afghanistan and has also refused to endorse the mujahedin interim government in Peshawar. 
 President Najibullah has been helped since the Soviet withdrawal by a a revival of Afghan nationalism, which his government has cleverly exploited to present the mujahedin as foreign-backed invaders. 
 His government has had considerable success in winning over guerrilla field commanders and turning them into semi-autonomous militias with lavish handouts of money and arms. 
 &bquo;The secret of our success lies in these militias,&equo; said President Najibullah. 
 Morale is high, especially after the mujahedin failed to capture Jalalabad as they said they would. 
 Although his personal popularity is difficult to gauge most Afghans in Kabul respect President Najibullah because he is the only Afghan leader talking peace. 
 Pressure grows to allow Marcos a burial at home 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Manila 
 HE ALLEGEDLY stole up to &dollar;10bn (&pound;6.2bn) of their money, jailed 60,000 of them, and tortured and killed hundreds more. 
 But now they want him back. 
 Filipinos have not demonstrated in the streets, but it has become increasingly clear they want Ferdinand Marcos, the former Philippine president who died in exile in Hawaii last week, to be allowed home for burial. 
 But his successor, Corazon Aquino, has ruled that out, citing concerns over national security. 
 The issue has divided the country more than any since Mrs Aquino was swept to office on a wave of &bquo;people power&equo; in 1986. 
 She has suddenly become the oppressor, the Marcos family the oppressed. 
 &bquo;A common public perception is that the Aquino government is doing something that goes against the time-honoured Filipino tradition and cultural values,&equo; said Alvin Capino, a newspaper columnist. 
 Others believe that Mrs Aquino, by making a political decision on grounds of national security, is transgressing her own leadership principles. 
 &bquo;The death of Marcos offers a momentous opportunity for the Aquino government to rally the people behind the ideals which swept it to power: freedom and democracy, bread and justice. 
 The alternative is one-man rule, thievery and special privileges,&equo; said one newspaper editorial. 
 Aware of the strength of public opinion, Mrs Aquino ordered flags on government buildings to be flown at half mast in a conciliatory gesture. 
 Yesterday she emphasised again that her decision was based on &bquo;sensitive information&equo; that showed Marcos's return could be destabilising. 
 &bquo;I am doing this in the interest of the great majority of our people,&equo; she said. 
 A group of Marcos loyalists yesterday filed a petition to the Supreme Court seeking to reverse an earlier ruling that upheld Mrs Aquino's decision to bar Marcos's return. 
 Mrs Aquino has said she will bow to its decision but is confident it will again rule in her favour. 
 Whatever the outcome, Marcos's death has opened old wounds. 
 Marcos loyalists now poke fun at the Aquino administration's boast that it has built a new stability, arguing it is pretty fragile if it won't allow a dead man home for burial. 
 They say Mrs Aquino is seeking revenge for the murder of her husband Benigno &bquo;Ninoy&equo; Aquino, at Manila airport in 1983. 
 The Marcoses are widely blamed for Ninoy's death. 
 Even some of those who suffered most under Marcos's dictatorial reign felt he should be allowed home. 
 Among them is Senator Orlando Mercado, who was hounded and jailed as a broadcaster, and Senator Wigberto Tanada, whose family was persecuted by Marcos through much of his rule. 
 They argue that Mrs Aquino can heal old wounds by allowing the former dictator to come home, at the same time disarming his supporters who scream that he is being done an injustice. 
 Though many analysts believe the desire for Marcos's return to be based on Filipino culture and tradition, others feel Marcos's 20 years of corrupt rule has produced a psychologically damaged people. 
 &bquo;An entire generation of Filipinos grew up in the shadow of dictatorship,&equo; wrote Sheila Coronel of the Manila Times. 
 &bquo;Their concept of politics has been warped and corrupted by Marcos. 
 No one is now demanding justice for the dead and disappeared (during Marcos's rule), today the clamour is for justice for one dead man. 
 There is something tragic about this.&equo; 
 Others have overwhelming compassion for their former president. 
 Mr Capino, remembering the bloody massacre in Peking's Tiananmen Square in June, says at least Marcos did not turn the army on his own people. 
 &bquo;For this reason alone, Mrs Aquino should allow Marcos a burial in his own country and with his own people.&equo; 
 Rebels in Sri Lanka disregard ceasefire 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Manila 
 COLOMBO &mdash; Sri Lankan troops went on the offensive at first light yesterday after left-wing rebels defied a six-day government ceasefire and burnt dozens of vehicles and buildings, killing 61 people, Reuter reports. 
 A government spokesman said 59 post offices, 53 other buildings, 75 vehicles and a rubber factory had been set ablaze since security forces stopped searches, ambushes and raids against the People's Liberation Front (JVP) last Wednesday. 
 General Cyril Ranatunga, defence ministry secretary, said operations against the JVP resumed when the unilateral truce lapsed at 6am. 
 General Ranatunga said the leftist rebels had done an &bquo;unbelievable&equo; amount of damage during the ceasefire. 
 &bquo;A large number of houses, post offices and government buildings were burned. 
 Last night two factories went up in flames,&equo; he said. 
 The JVP, fighting to overthrow the government for the past two-and-a-half years, did not respect the ceasefire, first imposed by the government for 72 hours on 27 September. 
 It was extended for three days after officials reported violence had dropped below the average 30 killings a day. 
 A government statement said that 1,120 &bquo;subversives&equo;, the official term for the JVP, surrendered in the six days in return for rehabilitation and the promise of jobs. 
 It said 21 people were killed in the 24 hours to Tuesday morning. 
 Thirty official buildings, 17 post offices and six buses were set ablaze in the period. 
 Five members of a policeman's family, a soldier and an airman were among Monday's victims. 
 In one incident, rebels shot dead the father, brother, brother-in-law and a friend of a policeman at Gampaha in Western province. 
 A doctor was also gunned down at his dispensary at Hakmana, in the south. 
 Right to censure textbooks is upheld 
 From DAVID POWERS in Tokyo 
 A TOKYO court ruled yesterday that the Japanese Education Ministry was within its rights to ban a textbook which detailed Japanese war atrocities, even though the court couldn't fault any of the assertions made by the author. 
 What made the ruling even more surprising was that the Japanese government had pledged to correct bias in school textbooks after South Korea and China lodged diplomatic protests in 1982, when the book was originally banned. 
 The reason given for the ban was that Professor Saburo Ienaga, a noted historian, had refused to strike out a reference in his book to bacteriological and other experiments carried out on Chinese prisoners of war by the now-defunct Imperial Army. 
 He also objected to having to tone down a description of the 1937 Rape of Nanking, when Japanese troops went on the rampage, killing tens of thousands of Chinese civilians and prisoners. 
 The ministry demanded more than 400 changes altogether &mdash; which Professor Ienaga described as tantamount to censorship and a violation of the constituional right to freedom of expression. 
 Judge Kazuo Kato declared that &bquo;having received the trust of the people, the state has the authority to determine the content of a child's education&equo;. 
 Consequently, he ruled, the Education Ministry had been perfectly within its rights to ban the book. 
 On only one point did the judge concede that the ministry had acted outrageously &mdash; in suppressing the description of how Imperial troops crushed a volunteer army more than 100 years ago. 
 In compensation, he awarded Professor Ienaga 100,000 yen (&pound;435). 
 Professor Ienaga pledged to fight the case right through to the Supreme Court. 
 He is a veteran campaigner against the screening system, but at 76, time is not on his side. 
 Professor Akira Fujiwara, an acknowledged expert on the Rape of Nanking who was called as one of the witnesses in the case, said that &bquo;in spite of the government's promise to correct bias in history textbooks, the screening system has actually got worse since the 1982 diplomatic protests. 
 The people of Nanking, Korea and Singapore haven't forgotten the cruelties of the past. 
 The Japanese are now the only ones who don't know what went on.&equo; 
 There was equal indignation from the other side. 
 Shigeru Tokinoya, who was in charge of textbook screening at the time Professor Ienaga's book was banned, said: &bquo;All of our corrections should have been upheld&hellip; 
 Screening is always carried out in an academic, conscientious and rational manner.&equo; 
 MPs seek common ground 
 From ROBERT FISK in Taif, Saudi Arabia 
 A CONVOY of black limousines conveyed the 31 Lebanese Muslim MPs in Saudi Arabia on an extra-parliamentary pilgrimage to Mecca yesterday afternoon, leaving their 31 Christian colleagues behind in Taif to ruminate on how best they might protect Christian political power in a new Lebanon. 
 No-one is yet talking about a &bquo;new&equo; Lebanon but there is now widespread acceptance among both Muslims and Christians in the Lebanese parliament that the country's unwritten national covenant is now obsolete. 
 It is this covenant which ordains that the Christian Maronites hold the presidency, the leadership of the army and the head of the judiciary while Sunni Muslims provide the prime minister and Shia Muslims the speaker of the Lebanese parliament. 
 Already, however, a committee of assembly members - among them only one Maronite &mdash; has been instructed to draw up a report, once the debates are over, on the changes in the covenant which a majority of parliamentarians will accept. 
 While real political power still resides with the militia leaders back in Lebanon, it is perhaps misleading to regard the parliamentary meeting here in conventional terms. 
 Yet its debates are beginning to acquire a democratic flavour, even though they are along confessional lines. 
 One MP, Tewfiq Assaf (Druze member of the &bquo;National Struggle Front&equo; from Aley) is demanding a second parliamentary chamber in Lebanon to extend political power to the Druze &mdash; a Druze, he maintains, should be the speaker of this new parliamentary chamber. 
 Jamil Kebbe (Sunni member of the &bquo;Salam Bloc&equo; from Sidon) has dedicated himself to removing as much political power from the Maronites as possible. 
 Zaher el-Khatib (Sunni, of the &bquo;Marxist Bloc&equo; from the Chouf) and two other deputies are campaigning for an end to confessionalism. 
 There is still no consensus over the issue of a Syrian military withdrawal from Lebanon &mdash; which the Christian MPs have been obliged by their militia leaders and by General Michel Aoun to discuss, although the Muslims are reluctant to debate the topic at present. 
 The Lebanese parliament is expected to continue its informal sessions here until the weekend &mdash; when the MPs will face the real (and potentially frightening) task of returning to Lebanon to account for their words in front of the sometimes sinister figures who still control the land. 
 French balancing act tipped Beirut into war: In his concluding article on Lebanon's history, Robert Fisk examines how France's &bquo;political solution&equo; created a war 
 By ROBERT FISK 
 THE Second World War wrought as great a change in Lebanese history as the First. 
 It was also &mdash; although it is now forgotten in the West &mdash; the scene of some of the fiercest fighting between Axis and Allied forces in the Middle East. 
 The Vichy authorities in Lebanon ordered French troops loyal to Petain to stand their ground against the Allied invasion from Palestine in 1941. 
 The Australians won their first VC of the campaign in a tank battle outside a village called Marjayoun in the south of the country which is now the headquarters of Israel's proxy South Lebanon Army militia. 
 In the village of Damour, a young Jewish member of the Allied forces, Moshe Dayan, was shot in the eye. 
 During an attempt to outflank Damour, the Allies shelled the town of Moukhtara where Kemal Jumblatt, the father of Walid Jumblatt, the present Druze leader, lived. 
 The Vichy French drew up two defensive lines &mdash; at Damour and along the Dog River north of Beirut. 
 They did this to spare the city's civilians from artillery barrages. 
 It was a sensitivity not exercised in recent months. 
 When the Vichy French fled, de Gaulle's Free French and the British took over the capital. 
 A British officer also took over the Vichy commander's mistress, a fact noted by a young British intelligence officer named Quintin Hogg. 
 The French had promised independence to Lebanon but &mdash; to Churchill's deep concern &mdash; de Gaulle seemed intent on clinging to France's colonial power. 
 During a visit to Beirut in 1942, de Gaulle announced that, despite French promises to the contrary, elections could not yet be held. 
 Many Maronites and other Christian groups turned against the French. 
 A Lebanese writer, Eugenie Elie Abouchdid, was so appalled by French provocation during the Beirut Victory in Europe Day celebrations that she wrote: &bquo;Poor Lebanon &mdash; a beautiful and magnificent country, devoured by wolves and thieves. 
 Among the celebrating parties, you could see&hellip; those that were cheering for la France and de Gaulle, others for Stalin, others for el-Hussaini (the Palestinian grand mufti), but you could scarcely see any that were cheering for Lebanon.&equo; 
 This has been the cry of Lebanon's distress since 1945. 
 The presence of foreign armies on its soil and the suborning of its communities by regional superpowers is a consistent theme. 
 The Maronite leader, General Michel Aoun, wants the withdrawal of all foreign troops from Lebanon, but there is nothing new in such an idea. 
 In 1946, Hamid Franjieh, Lebanon's foreign minister and elder brother of the surviving Maronite elder statesman, Suleiman Franjieh, asked the UN Security Council for &bquo;a total simultaneous and immediate withdrawal of all foreign troops&equo;. 
 Under British pressure, the French eventually departed in humiliation, but only after presiding over a covenant that gave the Lebanese republic the system of power-sharing which is now disintegrating. 
 Under this system, the Maronites would hold the presidency and the leadership of the army while a Sunni Muslim would always hold the less important post of prime minister. 
 A Shia would be the speaker of parliament. 
 The Maronites believed they would control the new state. 
 Already, statistics were catching up on them. 
 Estimates in 1956 showed the Muslim population was increasing faster than the Christian. 
 By 1982, the Minority Rights Group in London was unofficially estimating the Muslim population was more than two million while the Christians numbered barely 1.5 million. 
 Power-sharing and Christian domination remained. 
 This unequal balance is at the heart of the Muslim (and Syrian) demand for political reform in Lebanon, a demand which General Aoun will only accept, he says, once the Syrians have left the country. 
 For the fact is that the Christians now hold a power out of proportion to their numbers, thanks to the French. 
 And while France formally supports the need for reform, it has given considerable support to General Aoun. 
 Indeed, the French press has produced the dangerous illusion in Lebanon that French soldiers might land in the Christian enclave to protect the Maronites. 
 In principle, it is not hard to see how political reform could be achieved. 
 If the presidency was given only a nominal role, for example, the Maronites would still hold the most honoured post in the country while more executive power could be given to the Sunni Muslim premier. 
 General Aoun's &bquo;war of liberation&equo; against Syria served the Christian cause because it effectively postponed discussion of the reforms which Muslims believe are essential if their numbers are to be fairly represented in a future government. 
 The general says the Syrians must leave before he discusses these changes. 
 But the Muslims, though they despise Syrian rule in Lebanon, need Syria's presence to ensure that real political reform takes place. 
 The last time the Maronites promised reforms &mdash; when the multi-national force was in Beirut &mdash; Christian units of the Lebanese army arrested hundreds of Muslim Lebanese and the reforms never materialised. 
 So what evidence is there to suggest that General Aoun would discuss the issue once the Syrians left? 
 In the meantime, the Lebanese parliament, whose members are meeting in Taif a year after their failure to elect a president led to the creation of rival Lebanese cabinets, is itself in the last stages of life. 
 For it is the president's job to reconvene parliament. 
 And if there is still no president when the current assembly session expires in December 1990, the very mechanism that is intended to ensure the continuation of the Lebanese state will cease to exist. 
 The unhappy truth is that foreign armies have been marching backwards and forwards across Lebanon for hundreds of years. 
 Weapons have flooded into the country since the 1860s when the Royal Navy delivered arms to the Druze. 
 Syria is still supplying guns to the Muslims, just as Iraq is supplying guns to the Christians. 
 It is the task of Lakhdar Ibrahimi, the Arab League envoy, to struggle through a tangle of sub-issues in the hope that he can persuade the Lebanese to renegotiate France's political legacy and the policies that began when General Henri Gouraud, who became the French high commissioner of Lebanon in 1920, stepped ashore. 
 Activist jailed for PLO contact 
 By FROM CHARLES RICHARDS in Jerusalem 
 ABE NATHAN, the former RAF Spitfire pilot who for 23 years has led an often lonely crusade for peace, was jailed for six months yesterday by a Ramla court for breaking an Israeli anti-terrorism law by meeting the PLO chairman, Yasser Arafat, in September last year. 
 He had travelled to Tunis for the meeting, using his British passport. 
 Mr Nathan, 62, is the first Israeli jailed under the law, passed in 1986. 
 He decided not to appeal in order to highlight what he regards as the absurdity of the law in light of the increasing acceptability of direct and indirect contacts between Israelis and the PLO. 
 His campaign for peace has been original, gimmicky and, above all, successful in securing publicity for a cause. 
 He has flown planes into Egypt, when it was still at war with Israel, and his ship has cast 100,000 flowers on the Suez Canal as a gesture of peace. 
 On the eve of his sentencing, Mr Nathan spoke to The Independent in the Tel Aviv office of the institution for which he is best known, his popular offshore radio station. 
 Its call sign &mdash; &bquo;This is the Voice of Peace, broadcasting from somewhere in the Mediterranean&equo; &mdash; is familiar to millions of listeners. 
 The office walls are covered with plaques and certificates testifying to his charitable works and his drug rehabilitation centre in the Negev. 
 &bquo;Whatever happens, I don't care how long I spend in prison, because I'm going to keep fighting it (this law) from the prison depending on what the reaction of the public is&hellip; 
 Somebody's got to do it. 
 I believe I have got the means because of my radio station. 
 I believe especially I never came on this campaign until after I went to see Arafat. 
 And I never went to see Arafat since 1982 because we had not heard of any mood or climate of change in the attitude of the PLO. 
 The moment I heard there were rumours that the PLO is willing to be more moderate, that's when I went on the first plane and went to Tunis. 
 &bquo;Having seen him about six times, and having spoken to most of their leaders, I believe that the time is right for us to talk to them now, to end this whole conflict once and for all. 
 All other things which are done instead of talking are a waste of time, are being used as excuses to delay the whole process, and will bear no fruit whatsoever, except the killing which is going on every day&hellip; 
 I refuse to stand by and do nothing.&equo; 
 Mr Nathan lamented the fact that for 40 years Israel had been saying it had no one to talk to and now that the other side was prepared to talk, Israel refused. 
 &bquo;This business of &bquo;I will never talk to the PLO&equo; is absolutely ridiculous. 
 Unfortunately we do not have today either a Ben Gurion or a Begin. 
 Either of them would have grabbed the hand. 
 For God's sake, unless we talk to these people, there's going to be no answer. 
 Look at this weekend. 
 Eight people killed. 
 It's ridiculous. 
 There are dangers people don't see ahead. 
 Every time somebody is killed, there's more hate. 
 It will be very difficult to subdue it.&equo; 
 Mr Nathan said that once he was jailed, members of the Knesset planned to try to call a special session. 
 They need 25 signatures. 
 He also plans to take out full-page newspaper advertisements, listing the names and telephone numbers of all the members of the Knesset who opposed repealing the law. 
 &bquo;It's no holiday to be in prison. 
 I did it before, when I flew to Egypt (in 1968). 
 I could easily appeal, or get off. 
 But I'm fighting the law. 
 The issue is the law. 
 Is it productive to peace? 
 Can men of good will play a role in the making of peace? 
 Is it not enough that the government has a monopoly on war?&equo; 
 But is Yasser Arafat a man he can trust? 
 &bquo;What's a man you can trust? 
 I managed to speak to the leader of the PLO. 
 I haven't managed to speak to my own government. 
 Who trusts whom in our government? 
 What's the meaning of this word trust? 
 Everybody says trust. 
 Can we trust the Germans? 
 The Germans killed six million and a few years later we invited them to be our guests over here? 
 How can anybody trust the Germans? 
 Where does trust play anything? 
 They said that about Sadat: &bquo;How can you trust him? 
 He's a Nazi.&equo; 
 And what happens when Sadat dies? 
 You've got Mubarak. 
 He's even stronger for peace than Sadat.&equo; 
 Out of France: A curious institution where the pendulum never swings 
 By PATRICK MARNHAM 
 PARIS &mdash; All this week France held its breath while the Senate, the upper house of parliament, chose its new president. 
 The previous holder of the office, Alain Poher, was aged 80 and had first been installed on his throne in 1968. 
 Since then he had been re-elected six times. 
 There was a feeling in the air that it might be time for a change. 
 The voting continued throughout Monday night, eight candidates putting themselves forward for the honour. 
 Then at 4am yesterday, France could breathe again. 
 After three ballots, the new president of the Senate, who ranks third in the French political hierarchy, was&hellip; 
 Alain Poher, for the eighth time. 
 If the good Lord spares him (and why not) he will probably run again in 1992, when the Single European Act will become law and the Senate will need an experienced hand at the helm. 
 For Mr Poher this long-drawn out struggle was something new &mdash; on the seven previous occasions he had been elected on the first ballot. 
 But so much the better; not every 80-year-old survives an entirely new experience so succesfully. 
 &bquo;This is the first time anything unusual has happened here since Goering occupied the building in 1940,&equo; one veteran observer was heard to remark. 
 Other senators, responding to Mr Poher's insistence that his age was irrelevant, said in that case, why not vote for Senator Geoffroy de Montalembert, who is only 91 and was first elected in 1945. 
 (Mysteriously enough, one senator did vote for Mr Montalembert in the first two ballots; no prizes for guessing who.) 
 But the others didn't want an entirely new hand on the helm, so they gave it back to Poher. 
 The French Senate is a curious institution. 
 Unlike the House of Lords it is elected, but it is elected by local councillors, an overwhelming majority of them from small country &bquo;communes&equo;. 
 This means that the cities of France are under-represented and there is a considerable right-wing majority, three-quarters in 1986 when the rest of France voted 52 per cent for the right. 
 There is no question here of &bquo;the swing of the pendulum&equo;. 
 It is rather comforting in a way. 
 Chesterton said that &bquo;tradition is the democracy of the dead&equo; but in France &bquo;the dead&equo; get a seat in parliament, together with three secretaries each, interest-free loans, subsidised foreign travel and an income of about &pound;40,000, half of which is tax free. 
 Those who attack the Senate say that it should be abolished, that it is useless and corrupt. 
 Those who defend it say that it repesents &bquo;an area of moderation and wisdom in French democracy&equo; and that both are sorely needed. 
 In fact the Senate is important, but for quite different reasons. 
 It does represent two fundamental political principles, the first is hierarchy, the second is influence, or &bquo;le piston&equo; as it is informally termed. 
 The average age of the senators is just under 70. 
 This is usually seen as a weakness but it is equally a strength. 
 For what else could so many well-connected old buffers do if not manoeuvre themselves into and around the Senate? 
 When French politicians achieve a certain dignity and experience, and lose a certain up-to-dateness, off they go to the Senate, where the marble floors of the National Assembly are replaced by thick carpets (softer when they fall over) and where the young are kept firmly in their place. 
 The Senate is notorious for closing ranks against any young politicians who try to use it as a springboard for something grander. 
 As for &bquo;le piston&equo;, it is true that three senators have been accused of fraud, bribery and tax evasion in the past three years, but they have all been cleared of these charges by other senators. 
 And since senators are elected for 9 years, it is natural that they should keep in close touch with the local councillors who elected them &mdash; they don't want to be completely forgotten. 
 And sitting, as they do, in parliament, but without real power, they are perfectly placed to intervene with ministers who are making decisions which might affect their own region. 
 A mayor who cultivates his senator has a hot line to the ministry, and can always find his niece a job with a pension. 
 A senator who cultivates his mayors will be given useful things to do and will be re-elected. 
 It is a beautiful relationship. 
 Without the Senate both hierarchy and influence would be seriously weakened in France, and that would leave a lot of people not knowing which way to turn. 
 France sends army into prisons 
 By SARAH LAMBERT 
 PARIS &mdash; A strike that threatens to paralyse France's prison service spread yesterday as more prison officers were recruited to the cause. 
 For the first time in the history of the service, army units have been sent in to maintain order in prisons, writes Sarah Lambert. 
 According to the justice ministry, staff at 70 of the country's 180 prisons are on strike, compared with 22 at the end of last week. 
 In France's biggest prison, Fleury-Merogis, outside Paris, 240 soldiers are now supervising 4,500 detainees. 
 In some prisons, inmates have shown solidarity with their jailers by refusing to return to their cells after exercise. 
 The prison officers want pay-parity with the police force. 
 The prison authorities refuse to accede to their demands and have issued 176 dismissal notices. 
 Striking workers at Peugeot plants in eastern France are refusing to abandon their week-long sit-in until the management agrees to negotiate on ways to end the five-week stoppage. 
 On Monday, the managing director, Jacques Calvet, met the unions for the first time but said there could be no discussion of pay until production was resumed. 
 Transkei forges a link with Mandela 
 From JOHN CARLIN in Umtata, Transkei 
 IF THERE is one person who clearly has no doubt that the South African government shall release Nelson Mandela, it is Nelson Mandela himself. 
 Plans are under way, it was confirmed yesterday, to build a home for him, evidently on his own instructions, here in the capital of the so-called Republic of Transkei. 
 So-called, because, except for Pretoria, no one in the world recognises the sovereignty of the Transkei, which is otherwise perceived to be simply a geographical region in the south-eastern corner of South Africa. 
 Mr Mandela's son, Makghatho, has been visiting his father at his prison house near Cape Town on a weekly basis for some months. 
 It is he who is making arrangements with the Transkei government to decide when and where the house is to be built. 
 The Transkei's military leader, Major General Bantu Holomisa, said yesterday that he had no objection to Mr Mandela setting up home in his territory. 
 All of which tends to confirm a belief that General Holomisa has advanced far on a scheme to forge an informal alliance with Mr Mandela and his organisation, the African National Congress. 
 The General has frequent contact with Winnie Mandela &mdash; and through her indirectly with her husband - as well as with the ANC leadership. 
 Recently, he has met the ANC president, Oliver Tambo. 
 His younger brother, who lives in the same house in Umtata, met Mr Mandela in August and subsequently travelled to ANC headquarters in Lusaka. 
 The plan, evidently, is to hoist Pretoria with its own petard. 
 The Transkei had &bquo;independence&equo; imposed upon it by South Africa in 1976 as part of a broader scheme to brush the whole racial problem under the carpet by packing off the black majority of the population to a series of impoverished rural &bquo;homelands&equo; dotted around the country. 
 General Holomisa, the first black officer to graduate from the South African army's War College, must have seemed to be the perfect instrument, or stooge, of such a policy. 
 Pretoria was wrong on both counts. 
 Things have backfired and the ANC, previously reluctant out of principle to have anything to do with the Transkei, has pragmatically leapt to exploit the opportunity. 
 The possibility of the Transkei becoming a base of operations for the ANC does not, suddenly, seem far-fetched. 
 Not least if Mr Mandela means to live there. 
 With the full blessing of General Holomisa, who came to power in a coup in December 1987, the ANC held its biggest public meeting on Sunday in the Transkei since Pretoria deemed the organisation unlawful in 1960. 
 The occasion was provided by a funeral for a local tribal king who defected to the ANC in 1980. 
 Mr Mandela, himself a royal member of the Tembu tribe, had a big hand in organising the event, as the General, a dapper 34-year-old in a double-breasted silk suit, readily recognised in an interview at his office here. 
 Were relations between himself and the ANC warm? 
 &bquo;In a nutshell: Yes. 
 But not only with the ANC, with all those fighting apartheid. 
 We must close ranks with them because we talk the same language. 
 We say: Don't reform apartheid. 
 Scrap it.&equo; 
 Unlike the leaders of the other three &bquo;independent&equo; homelands &mdash; all toadies of Pretoria &mdash; he is more than ready to pour scorn on the fundamental fraudulence of the nation he purportedly leads. 
 &bquo;In the end the stipends come from Pretoria,&equo; he said, noting that more than half the Transkeian budget came out of the South African coffers. 
 Clearly a man with a future in the politics of liberation, he concluded the interview with a flourish: &bquo;Transkei will be used to liberate the black people of South Africa.&equo; 
 That was not what apartheid's engineers had in mind. 
 EC adopts guidelines to limit foreign television programmes 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Luxembourg 
 THE EUROPEAN Community yesterday adopted common guidelines for the content of television broadcasts, designed to limit programme imports from America and ensure minimum quality standards on private, including satellite, channels. 
 The agreement, reached at a meeting of foreign ministers in Luxembourg, will barely affect BBC and ITV programming but has more sweeping implications for nascent commercial companies as well as for the poorer public channels in southern Europe. 
 It is also likely to provoke at least a verbal protest from the United States, which has warned against any attempt to stem the flow of American programmes across the Atlantic. 
 However a mixture of careful diplomatic packaging and the vague nature of some of the key provisions make a confrontation with Washington unlikely. 
 The key clause asks that all EC governments ensure that a &bquo;majority proportion&equo; of programming broadcast by domestic television companies should be European-made. 
 This is tougher than it first looks as it does not cover news, sport, game-shows or teletext services. 
 Under British and West German pressure, however, ministers agreed that even this requirement should be regarded more as a &bquo;political objective&equo; than a legal obligation (the non-respect of which would lead to prosecution in the EC Court of Justice). 
 The ministers reached their agreement despite lingering differences over the toughness of the text. 
 In the event, Denmark and Belgium were alone in voting against. 
 France, meanwhile, would have liked tougher quotas, while Britain wanted no import limits at all. 
 The British Foreign Secretary, John Major, attending his first EC Council meeting, stressed that the undertaking to maintain a majority of European programmes was non-binding, and should therefore not cause offence to the US. 
 The directive was ostensibly conceived to ensure the free flow of programming across EC frontiers after 1992. 
 However since almost all domestic broadcasts spill over borders nearly all EC programming will be subject to the new guidelines. 
 Among the provisions is the understanding that any country will have the right to ban broadcasts that may &bquo;seriously impair the physical, mental or moral development of minors&equo;. 
 There are also rules on the placing of advertising that will bring minor changes to British practice. 
 Party members in Poland want change of name 
 From ANNE APPLEBAUM in Warsaw 
 WITH ITS power and prestige slipping away and its leaders calling desperately for unity, 72 per cent of Polish Communists have voted to find a new name for their party, the Polish United Workers' Party. 
 At a meeting of the Party's Central Committee yesterday, a Politburo member, Leszek Miller, said that a nationwide plebiscite also showed that more than half of the Party's two million members agreed that &bquo;the present form of the party is outdated and cannot face the new conditions&equo;. 
 Party members voted to give the organisation a more democratic structure. 
 These results came as no surprise. 
 Unused to internal democracy, party members continue to vote as their leadership obviously wishes them to vote. 
 The plenum agreed a date for the 11th party congress, on 27 January, and called for elections for congress delegates under new democratic rules. 
 The congress, which will be attended by up to 2,000 delegates, is intended to re-make the Party in a &bquo;European&equo; image, as Party spokesman Jan Bisztyga has said. 
 Leaving behind their Stalinist-era organisation and programme, Poland's Communists want to become a left-wing parliamentary party capable of winning elections. 
 &bquo;If we remain in unity for three months then we will win the battle,&equo; said Mr Bisztyga at a briefing before yesterday's Central Committee plenum. 
 &bquo;If the Party is destroyed, then the Polish left will cease to exist.&equo; 
 Privately, not all of Poland's Communist leaders believe the pro-democracy forces at the Party's local level to be as strong as the survey indicated. 
 One Communist member of parliament said the results were &bquo;all very nice, if they are true&equo;. 
 Like other reform-minded Communists in Warsaw, he finds he has less and less in common with the Party's local base. 
 Party leaders are concerned at the growing gap between Communists active in parliament in Warsaw, and those in the provinces who have been slow to catch on to the change. 
 In a recent editorial, the Communist daily Trybuna Ludu alluded to this problem, when it warned that &bquo;many comrades don't see the danger which has appeared in recent months&equo;. 
 With local elections looming in the near future, Communist leaders in Warsaw are already fearing another serious loss, possibly even more humiliating than the loss to Solidarity in national elections last June. 
 East Germany blocks refugees' last escape route 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 EAST GERMANY yesterday effectively barred its citizens from Czechoslovakia, but agreed to allow the second wave of refugees crammed into the West German embassy in Prague to leave for the West. 
 The news that &bquo;for the time being&equo; they can only go to or through Czechoslovakia with a visa, left East Germans stunned. 
 Czechoslovakia was the last place they could travel to without restrictions. 
 Now their country has become a prison which they can only leave with special permission &mdash; a situation which is guaranteed to fuel bitterness and resentment against the hardline regime. 
 &bquo;I can hardly believe it. 
 Who wants to celebrate (East Germany's 40th anniversary) on 7 October?&equo; said one East Berlin resident. 
 East Germans now have to wait for weeks or even months for replies to their applications for visas to Hungary, through which more than 31,000 have escaped since August. 
 The East German government clearly felt this was the only way it could agree to the departure of more than 5,000 East Germans who had flooded into the Prague embassy since the first batch were allowed to leave on Saturday night. 
 Rudolf Seiters, the head of the Bonn Chancellery, announcing the move last night, said he expected that 11,000 East Germans currently in Prague would join the special trains heading west. 
 East Germany is obviously reluctant to see a repetition of the situation, especially before the all-important 40th anniversary on Saturday. 
 Mr Seiters said he was convinced a similar solution will be found for the 250 refugees in the embassy in Warsaw. 
 In a clear sign of the tension in East Berlin where, as in Bonn, crisis meetings were held yesterday, the East German leader, Erich Honecker, refused to have a telephone conversation with Helmut Kohl, the West German Chancellor. 
 The refusal to talk, believed to have been decided in a meeting of the Politburo, contributed to renewed speculation here that Mr Honecker may no longer be in full control. 
 It was also noted that Wolfgang Vogel, the lawyer to whom Mr Honecker had given the task of solving the refugee problem, had had his mandate drastically cut back. 
 At the same time, there are reports that workers' militias had been used to cordon off streets during the demonstration in Leipzig on Monday night when some 10,000 people marched through the streets chanting &bquo;Gorby, Gorby&equo; and calling for the legalisation of the opposition group New Forum. 
 Workers' militias &mdash; factory workers who are supposed to defend the Socialist system against its enemies &mdash; are reportedly also being trained in various parts of the country to control demonstrations and arrest supporters of the opposition. 
 Walter Priesnitz, the state secretary in the Inter-German Ministry in West Germany said yesterday that he feared the situation inside East Germany could become explosive as the anniversary approached. 
 Jurgen Warnke, the deputy chairman of the right-wing Christian Social party warned that there could be violence and the whole East German security apparatus could be deployed to ensure the survival of the regime. 
 Several politicians, including the opposition Social Democrat leader, Hans-Jochen Vogel, urged the East Germans to reform before it was too late. 
 EC keen to reward East Bloc reform 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Luxembourg 
 FOREIGN ministers of the European Community lent enthusiastic support yesterday to a Commission plan to give Poland and Hungary food and financial aid worth &dollar;215m (&pound;140m), together with loans worth up to &pound;700m. 
 The plan was put forward in Brussels last week in line with the mandate to orchestrate the aid effort given to the European Commission at a meeting of 24 Western nations in Paris in July. 
 A second meeting of the 24, including the US, Japan, Canada and Australia, took place in Brussels 10 days ago. 
 In its proposal for short-term action, the Commission suggests a five-point programme focussing on giving both countries huge amounts of food aid and concessionary loans to assist with reform, especially in the farm sector. 
 Proceeds from the food aid would be directed into funding reform. 
 Management training and assistance with environmental protection would be made available, and steps would be taken further to open Western markets to Hungarian and Polish goods. 
 Among EC ministers most supportive of the Commission's plan yesterday was the British Foreign Secretary, John Major, attending his first EC Council meeting. 
 He stressed that the aid was in recognition of the moves in both countries toward economic reform and democracy. 
 &bquo;It is a historic moment,&equo; he told journalists. 
 &bquo;It is very exciting what is happening in these countries&equo;. 
 In a statement, the foreign ministers said political and economic reforms in Poland and Hungary had made considerable progress but added: &bquo;The process remains fragile and could be called into question by economic problems. 
 Bearing in mind the need for Poland and Hungary to reach rapid agreement with international financial institutions, the Council (of ministers) recognises the urgent need for additional measures of support.&equo; 
 Most significantly, Mr Major gave no sign of questioning the generous financial provisions of the proposed package. 
 The Commission wants &pound;140m written into the EC's 1990 budget for the programme and suggests that an extra &pound;300m be provided bilaterally by all the 24 donor states. 
 Moreover, it is proposing that funds managed by the EC's own loaning organisation, the European Investment Bank, should be made available to Hungary and Poland. 
 EIB money has never before been offered to Eastern Europe. 
 A final decision on the details of the EC's own contribution is expected at a meeting of EC finance ministers in Luxembourg next week. 
 The level of EIB loans could extend to &pound;700m over three years. 
 The Foreign Secretary stressed, however, that aid on its own can never ensure reform is successfully carried through in the two countries. 
 &bquo;We ought to be under no illusion that the success or otherwise of what is happening in Poland and Hungary will substantially rest upon the actions of the two governments,&equo; Mr Major said. 
 He hinted, however, that greater sums of money could be made available by the Community to Poland and Hungary after 1990. 
 &bquo;I have little doubt that more help will be needed after next year,&equo; he said. 
 Britain has already announced it has extended a &pound;25m &bquo;know-how&equo; fund to Poland to help it cope with reform. 
 Pravda assails Bonn on refugees 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 IN THE FIERCEST Soviet reaction yet to the East German refugee crisis, the Communist Party daily Pravda declared yesterday that Bonn's &bquo;open door&equo; policy at its embassies in Warsaw and Prague was creating a situation which threatened to destabilise all of central Europe. 
 &bquo;West Germany's actions are utterly shortsighted,&equo; wrote Pravda in the guise of a &bquo;commentary&equo; by its correspondent in East Berlin. 
 They were an &bquo;assault on the stability in the centre of Europe, in which every nation of our continent places its hopes&equo;. 
 What the paper scathingly called the &bquo;story of the refugees&equo; had been whipped up by a &bquo;noisy propaganda campaign dripping with chauvinism and nationalism&equo;. 
 And behind the West German media stood the country's politicians, nursing illusions about the recreation of a new &bquo;German Reich&equo; with the pre-war frontiers of 1937. 
 Such language is infinitely more virulent that anything emanating from the Soviet foreign ministry after the deal four days ago between Bonn and East Berlin, which allowed some some 5,000 East Germans who had taken shelter in the two embassies to leave unmolested for the West. 
 Hitherto its spokesmen have insisted that the affair was essentially one for East Germany to settle, albeit urging that West Germany must operate its embassies abroad &bquo;in conformity with standard international practice&equo;. 
 To an extent, the anger is to be expected from a newspaper which has become a strident mouthpiece of conservative elements in the Kremlin leadership. 
 But its anxiety on this occasion surely reflects the worries of Mr Gorbachev himself, who is to take part in this weekend's celebrations in Berlin of the 40th anniversary of East German statehood. 
 For some while, the trip has had uncomfortable similarities to the Soviet leader's visit to China last May, when the presence of the man who incarnates reform in the Communist world served as a combustible in the &bquo;Peking Spring&equo; that was to be forcibly suppressed a fortnight later. 
 Like their counterparts in China four months ago, East German demonstrators are chanting Mr Gorbachev's name, while another 4,000 would-be refugees are choking the premises of Bonn's embassy in Prague. 
 It was no co-incidence, said Pravda yesterday, that this &bquo;giant provocation&equo; from the West Germans had coincided with the East Germany's anniversary. 
 Battle chic 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 PARIS &mdash; The French Army, fatigued by khaki, is to get a new &bquo;modular&equo; uniform designed by Pierre Balmain and made up in a grey-blue colour known as Terre de France. 
 The Defence Minister, Jean-Pierre Chevenement, described it as &bquo;tres elegant&equo;. 
 Rebels give up 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 DHAKA (Reuter) &mdash; Thirty-five Shanti Bahini tribal rebels in Bangladesh's Chittagong Hill Tracts surrendered during a month-long amnesty that included offers of land, money and jobs for those giving up. 
 Etna tremors 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 CATANIA (AFP) &mdash; Powerful new tremors shook Sicily's Mount Etna, increasing the danger that three villages in the path of flowing lava would be engulfed. 
 Back to barracks 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 SUVA (AP) &mdash; Major General Sitiveni Rabuka, leader of Fiji's two military coups, said he was returning to the army rather than accept the post of civilian deputy prime minister. 
 Turkey visas 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 ANKARA (Reuter) &mdash; Turkey will require British citizens to have entry visas from 1 November. 
 Britain cancelled a 1960 no-visa agreement in June and imposed entry visas for all Turks after more than 1,500 Turks flew to Britain and applied for political asylum. 
 Peru inflation 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Political deaths 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 GUATEMALA CITY (Efe) &mdash; At least 18 people, including two children, were murdered in four days in a mounting wave of political violence in Guatemala. 
 President Vinicio Cerezo has blamed the killings on right-wing extremists trying to destabilise his government. 
 Strike call 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 JERUSALEM &mdash; The Unified Leadership of the Uprising, in a sudden hardening of the 21-month-old intifada, distributed a leaflet calling for general strikes in the occupied West Bank and Gaza strip on five days during the next week, beginning on Thursday. 
 Police evidence 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 CAPE TOWN (AP) &mdash; Lieutenant Gregory Rockman of the South African police, speaking at the trial of two white colleagues, testified that riot squad members with whips and clubs attacked peaceful demonstrators like a &bquo;pack of wild dogs&equo; at an anti-government protest on 5 September in the Mitchell's Plain township. 
 He said he witnessed repeated instances of police brutality in August and early September, when activists held almost daily demonstrations in townships outside Cape Town. 
 Apartheid talks 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 JOHANNESBURG (Reuter) &mdash; A French human rights group has invited South African government officials and exiled African National Congress leaders to meet in Paris on 20 November to discuss reform of apartheid, the South African newspaper, Business Day, reported. 
 The French embassy said the conference was a private initiative by the France Liberte Foundation, run by Danielle Mitterrand, wife of the French President. 
 Extradition of Marks seems close 
 By TIM MCGIRK 
 MADRID &mdash; Howard Marks, the Briton accused by US police of being the &bquo;Marco Polo&equo; who led an international ring of hashish smugglers, yesterday took one step closer towards extradition to the US, where he faces up to 113 years in jail, Tim McGirk writes. 
 A Madrid criminal court yesterday rejected Mr Marks' appeal for a re-trial of his extradition hearing. 
 His lawyers are protesting to the constitutional court, but if Spain's highest legal body refuses the appeal of Mr Marks he will be sent to stand trial in Florida. 
 Los Angeles plans to stop slowly choking to death: John Lichfield, in Los Angeles, finds out how California's biggest city intends to reverse 20 years of lax pollution control with an assault on its &bquo;drive-in&equo; lifestyle 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Los Angeles 
 SOUTHERN California is high-octane America; more self-confident, more optimistic, more prosperous, even more self-regarding than the other 49 states. 
 A bumper sticker on the San Diego Freeway speaks with the authentic, sunny voice of greater Los Angeles: &bquo;People are fantastic. 
 Business is booming. 
 Life is wonderful.&equo; 
 But, despite 20 years of desultory pollution control, southern California has also become heavy-tar America (complete with government health warnings). 
 One day in two, judged by federal standards, the soft California air is not fit to breathe. 
 On any day, many of the lovely blue Pacific waves are not fit to swim, or surf, in. 
 The freeways are crowded and crumbling. 
 Los Angeles is the archetypal 20th-century conurbation. 
 Since the turn of the century, it has grown from 50,000 people to 14 million. 
 In the process it invented mass entertainment, the 10-lane freeway and smog. 
 LA now plans to become the first conurbation in the world to grapple comprehensively with the most pressing international problem of the next century: how to remain prosperous without choking to death. 
 The South Coast Air Quality Management District is a body with considerable powers over greater LA. 
 Earlier this year, after five years of agonising, it published the LA Plan, a document 5,500 pages long and a yard thick. 
 The Plan laid out a 123-point, three-stage strategy to make the air of Los Angeles 70 per cent cleaner by 2009. 
 The Plan amounted, according to the critics, to a declaration of war on the southern Californian way of life, assaulting everything from drive-in movies to Burger Kings and, most of all, automobiles. 
 Under the Plan, by 1998, 40 per cent of the cars in the region must run on methanol or other &bquo;clean&equo; fuels. 
 By 2008 all new cars, and lawnmowers, must run on alternative fuels or electric motors of a kind not yet invented. 
 Companies will be punished unless they give their employees financial incentives to commute by bus, car-pool, or by rapid-transit rail lines not yet built. 
 Restrictions will be placed on drive-in cinemas, banks, hamburger restaurants and, presumably, LA's solitary drive-through church. 
 New, less polluting designs will be required for a cornucopia of products made or sold in the city, ranging from aerosol sprays to roll-on deodorants, and paints and varnishes. 
 Non-radial tyres, which apparently launch miniscule fragments of rubber into the atmosphere, will be banned. 
 Breweries, bakeries and many other businesses will be forced to invest in new, cleaner machinery. 
 Some fast food restaurants will be obliged to install costly emission-control vents. 
 Back-garden barbecues will be barred from using chemical starter fluids. 
 To its critics, the Plan conjures a grim vision of a future in which the home of the Beach Boys, fresh air and freedom becomes a battle-ground between suffocating fumes and suffocating regulations. 
 Michael Antonovich, Los Angeles County Supervisor, was one of two members of the 14-man air management board to vote against the Plan. 
 &bquo;Isn't it ironic?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The Soviet Union and China are marching towards the open market and here we are, in southern California, the home of Ronald Reagan, talking about tying the economy down with a maze of petty regulations&hellip; 
 We should be looking for a market-based solution to our problems, not snooping in people's backyards to check out what kind of barbecue they are using.&equo; 
 Jim Lents, executive officer of the Air Managment District, and one of the main architects of the Plan, responded: &bquo;The plan does involve an element of changing the life-style of southern California. 
 But the population of greater LA is projected to rise from 14 million to 19 million in the next two decades. 
 Our present life-style can't survive that kind of increase anyway. 
 It's questionable whether it's surviving now. 
 Either we make some sacrifices&hellip; or we gradually choke in our own dirt.&equo; 
 The LA Plan has direct implications, practical and political, for the rest of the country, and the rest of the world. 
 The approach may well serve as a model for similar projects in other US conurbations. 
 The kind of technological developments demanded by the Plan, from new types of automobile propulsion to reformulated hair-sprays, will heavily influence technical research and development around the globe. 
 (LA is the biggest market in California; California is the biggest market in the US; the US is the biggest market in the world). 
 The Plan has already been approved by the state environment authorities and is likely to be approved shortly by the Environmental Protection Agency in Washington. 
 It was a series of financial penalties imposed by Washington for manifold breaches of the 1977 Clean Air Act which forced the LA authorities to formulate such an epic approach in the first place. 
 Some local politicians, led by Mr Antonovich, are threatening to block the necessary implementing regulations. 
 Attempts will be made to tag a Proposition (referendum) rejecting the Plan on to next year's congressional and state elections. 
 Mr Antonovich points out that air pollution in Los Angeles has been declining for a decade. 
 Why the need for such an ambitious plan now? 
 &bquo;It's the last hoorah of the economic regulators,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They lost the government spending argument in the late Seventies and Eighties, now they're trying the environmental route.&equo; 
 On a good day the climate in LA is close to perfection: it is possible to understand what brought all these millions to a vast, waterless, resourceless basin, between the mountains, the desert and the sea. 
 But Dr Lents says the blue skies and soft breezes are misleading. 
 &bquo;Sure, we have made some progress,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The air is 15 per cent cleaner than it was a decade ago. 
 If nothing is done, the regulations already passed will continue improving air quality until the mid-1990s but then the growth in population, and car numbers, will send pollution rising again, indefinitely.&equo; 
 The Plan requires a radical change in the structure but also the culture of the city. 
 In Greater Los Angeles area there are 7.5 million registered drivers and 8 million cars. 
 Scraps of the local railway system, which died in the 1930s, can be seen imbedded in Los Angeles boulevards like fragments of a lost civilisation. 
 At least 150 miles of new rapid transit and underground railways are envisaged in the next 20 to 30 years. 
 The first 4.4 miles from downtown Los Angeles towards Hollywood, under construction since 1986, is due to open in September 1993. 
 But how do you persuade the people of a drive-in city to cast aside their cars and walk, if only to the station? 
 Such are the present problems, Mr Lents believes, that it will be possible to persuade and coerce Angelenos to commute to work by train, bus or shared car. 
 &bquo;But the real difficulty arises with leisure and shopping journeys&hellip; it's almost impossible, at present, to go shopping or to the beach or to a restaurant in LA without going by car&hellip; 
 To change that will be difficult.&equo; 
 Britain concerned at Trident missile delays 
 From PETER PRINGLE in Washington 
 BRITAIN has launched a significant lobbying campaign on Capitol Hill, including letters to Congressmen from the British ambassador, Sir Antony Acland, in an effort to prevent delays in the US Trident D-5 nuclear missile programme. 
 Britain is due to have four submarines armed with the new Tridents but has been worried that recent votes in the Senate to cut funding for production of the missile could delay delivery of the weapons, scheduled to start next year, to the Royal Navy. 
 The US Navy, distraught at the prospect of having its own timetable for deploying the new missile delayed by budget cuts, has emphasised that relations with Britain could be affected if the money is not restored. 
 Admiral Carlisle Trost, the chief of naval operations, has warned Congressmen in a letter that any cuts could result in a &bquo;significant potential for strained relations with the United Kingdom&equo;. 
 Sir Antony, in a letter to Senator John Warner, who is the leading Republican on the Senate armed services committee, said that &bquo;any withholding of productive funding&hellip; would have a knock-on effect which could delay the arrival of the first missiles for the Royal Navy, and continue to impose time and cost penalties on the British Trident programme&equo;. 
 Last month, the Senate appropriations committee passed a bill that would cut &dollar;1.8bn (&pound;1.1bn) from the Trident D-5 programme, which has experienced a number of embarrassing failures in tests of the weapon. 
 Two sea tests, one in March and one in August, failed. 
 A second sea test in August was a success. 
 The budget cuts would mean significant delays in 1990 production of missiles, a handful of which are due to be sold to Britain. 
 An effort to restore half of the production funds failed in the full Senate. 
 Last summer, the House of Representatives passed a bill funding the full &dollar;1.8bn requested by the Navy, but the vote was taken before the second sea test failure. 
 The chairman of the House defence sub-committee, John Murtha, a Democrat from Pennsylvania, has indicated that he is open to the kind of budget cuts made in the Senate because of the continued restraints on total military spending. 
 &bquo;Something like the D-5 could fall out (of the budget),&equo; Mr Murtha said. 
 The issue is now being considered in a House-Senate conference. 
 Officially, Britain is keen to present its lobbying effort as a &bquo;gentlemanly exercise&equo; that falls in behind those being conducted by the American Navy, by the Lockheed Corporation, which is making the D-5, and also by the White House. 
 British officals have to tread a fine line between registering the &bquo;UK dimension&equo;, as they call it, in the Trident debate, and not offending Congressmen by being too heavy-handed. 
 The stern warning from Admiral Trost about possible effects on the special relationship between the United States and Britain came as a surprise to British officials. 
 In his letter to Congressmen, Admiral Trost added that if the budget cuts were sustained &bquo;there will be a catastrophic impact on the Trident programme&equo; that would involve losses of nuclear deterrent capability &bquo;for many years&equo;. 
 Coup attempt highlights corruption in Panama 
 By ISABEL HILTON, Latin America Editor 
 HAD GENERAL Manuel Noriega been overthrown by rebel troops, it would have meant the end of a two-year political crisis that has wrecked Panama's economy and brought political embarrassment and frustration to the United States. 
 It began in 1987 when civil disorder erupted in Panama after the general's second-in-command publicly accused him of drug-trafficking, electoral fraud and the murder of an opposition politician. 
 The US government, which had supported General Noriega in his ascent to power, openly backed the opposition. 
 A two-year stand-off between the two governments followed. 
 US officials said the general would fall quickly, but he has proved a resilient and cunning opponent. 
 He has played on Panamanian nationalism to exploit resentment at US interference in Panamanian affairs and met charge with counter-charge. 
 In February last year, the then president, Eric Arturo Delvalle, backed by the United States, tried to fire General Noriega as chief of the Panamanian Defence Force, but was himself swiftly replaced by another Noriega puppet. 
 The US continued to recognise Mr Delvalle and imposed economic sanctions on Panama. 
 In March 1988, a group of junior officers attempted a coup. 
 It failed, and the general purged the armed forces and created a power structure that strengthened his supporters' hold on the military. 
 As US officials produced evidence of his involvement in drug trafficking and appealed for support from other Latin American countries in their campaign to oust him, their case was weakened by evidence that the US had been an important supporter in the general's rise to power and that the CIA had known about his trafficking for years. 
 Worse were the revelations that the CIA tolerated his activities and had continued to pay him &dollar;200,000 (&pound;125,000) a year for at least 10 years. 
 At the same time, General Noriega had been flirting with the Soviet Union and, according to US intelligence sources, continues to receive arms from Moscow. 
 In spite of the sharp recession induced by US economic sanctions, General Noriega has played a skilful game of counter-propaganda. 
 He accused the US of attempting to destabilise him in order to revoke the Panama Canal treaty &mdash; signed by the former US president, Jimmy Carter, and the then strongman of Panama, General Omar Torrijos &mdash; under which control of the canal passes to Panama in the year 2000. 
 Attempts at negotiation between the US and General Noriega, formally indicted on drug trafficking charges in the US in February 1988, failed. 
 Presidential elections were held last May and the opposition candidate, Guillermo Endara, is believed to have won by a large majority, but the elections were annulled by the general amid renewed protests. 
 President Bush ordered 2,000 US troops to Panama in May, to reinforce the 10,000 troops based in the Canal Zone. 
 Although the option of US military intervention has often been canvassed, it has always officially been discounted. 
 The last hope of a mediated solution fell when the Organisation of American States failed to reach a constitutional solution before the formal expiry of the presidential term in September. 
 On 1 September, the general reaffirmed his defiance of US pressure by naming another of his collaborators, Francisco Rodriguez, as president. 
 UNITED NATIONS &mdash; Panama's provisional president barely touched on the military upheaval in his country yesterday in a 30-minute address to the General Assembly which was heavily critical of US policy towards Panama, Reuter reports. 
 In his only digression from prepared remarks, Francisco Rodriguez said: &bquo;The government today has had to control a new attempt at subversion frustrated by the will of our people and of our armed forces to wage struggle.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;The printed text which I'm delivering to the assembly today does not include the most recent examples of US action in my country.&equo; 
 Vultures discover dark side of Disney 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 DISNEY WORLD, home to Mickey Mouse, 101 Dalmatians and all manner of furry creatures, has been charged with beating wild vultures to death and illegally trapping other protected birds. 
 The vultures began the trouble by congregating in their hundreds to scavenge at Discovery Island, Disney World's 11-acre wildlife sanctuary near Orlando, Florida. 
 &bquo;They were a hazard to the Galapagos turtles, they were attacking the sand cranes and also the brown pelicans we brought in from the wild because they were injured,&equo; said John Dreyer, for Disney World. 
 So in May Disney obtained permission to move 100 of the bald, hunch-backed and unruly birds 60 miles away. 
 But after a four-month investigation, the State has charged that the methods used were abusive, worthy only of Cruella de Vil, Walt Disney's Dalmatian-murdering villain. 
 Nineteen of the birds died and others among the 149 moved were mistreated. 
 Disney initially claimed the vultures died while in a holding shed in which the ventilation system failed. 
 But witnesses later said they saw employees beating at least some of the birds to death, while the report found that the shed, which could properly hold only three birds, had been packed with 72. 
 Although common in Florida, the black vulture is a protected bird and so should be welcome at Discovery Island. 
 In fact, investigators found that migratory owls, falcons, hawks and ibises have been trapped at the sanctuary. 
 The company has now hired a consultant ornithologist, an interim manager and an advisory board for Discovery Island &mdash; all of whom have blue-chip animal rights credentials. 
 Obituary: Francis Goodman 
 By TERENCE PEPPER 
 FRANCIS GOODMAN was one of the many bright talents that flourished in the art of taking fashion and portrait photographs in London in the 1930s. 
 &bquo;Franzi&equo; was born in London in 1913, but was brought up from 1919 onwards in Munich, where he first experimented with photography. 
 The German-Jewish family moved back to London in 1931, where the 18-year-old Goodman took his first job as an apprentice to the leading commercial photographer of the day, Shaw Wildman. 
 Wildman pioneered advertising and fashion photography in Britain, specifically outdoor location work, as well as creating natural indoor lighting. 
 Darkroom work for Cecil Beaton (whom he also regularly photographed) and for Peter Rose Pulham (whose studio he took over in Berkeley Square when the latter went to Paris to become a painter) provided Goodman with the visual stimulus that helped create his most imaginative work. 
 By the mid-1930s his work was regularly appearing in all the society magazines as well as in Harper's Bazaar (then under the creative art editorship of AY McPeake), in the company of his avant-garde contemporaries such as Rose Pulham, Winifred Casson and Barbara Ker-Seymer and other innovators of the time. 
 Goodman's Thirties portraits taken in the studio often relied on specially-painted backdrops, such as John Banting produced for his work with Ker-Seymer, or echoed the classic compositional motifs pioneered by Hoyningen Huene and adapted by Wildman. 
 Unfortunately, most of his work from this period &mdash; with the exception of two portraits of Anna May Wong and Gertrude Lawrence &mdash; was lost in the Second World War, and is only traceable in the prestigious pages of The Studio's Photography Year Book of 1935. 
 Known as FJ Gutmann in the 1930s, he anglicised his name to Goodman for the war years, serving in the ranks as a soldier before becoming attached to the Royal Air Force's Photographic Interpretation Unit at Medmenham by the war's end. 
 He returned to portraiture in 1945, this time working out of the studio in his sitters' home environment with three portable floods. 
 An album of Goodman's contact prints, interleaved with letters from his sitters, survives in the National Portrait Gallery, and includes a variety of subjects from the worlds of art, theatre, design, cinema and society. 
 Georgia and Sacheverell Sitwell pose pensively. 
 His portraits of Terence Rattigan, Ralph Richardson and Peter Ustinov capture in their concentrated poses their innate intelligence and creative flair. 
 The baroque furnishings or simple motifs that accompany other subjects such as the stage designer James Bailey or Anne, Viscountess Norwich, give the portraits a resonance and pay tribute to the influence of Peter Rose Pulham as well as showing Goodman's own mastery of lighting to create sculptural effects. 
 Graham Sutherland, opposite a whole page of contacts, enthuses in a 1946 letter: &bquo;Your photographs are wonderfully good; easily the best we have ever had taken, and I can see how important was the time and care which you took over the composition and lighting and the idea&hellip; 
 I like them all without exception.&equo; 
 In the 1950s Goodman moved into more social photography for William Hickey, as well as fashion for magazines such as the Gentlemen's Quarterly, using trend-setters such as Douglas Fairbanks Jnr, Patrick Lichfield and David Hicks to model clothes. 
 But most of the rest of his career was as a travel photographer working for P &amp; O and Union Castle, as well as the tourist boards for the Bahamas, Barbados and Jamaica, where he went every second winter to photograph personalities such as Joan Crawford or Richard Lester, and incidentally took the last photographs of Ian Fleming and Noel Coward. 
 Goodman was always hard up and enjoyed the friendship and generosity of friends such as Francis Bacon who would help him out. 
 Always self-deprecating and modest, he fought bravely a long struggle against cancer, remaining cheerful and full of amusing unrepeatable anecdotes. 
 After much hesitation he had at last begun work on an autobiography which, sadly, remains unfinished. 
 Obituary: Chen Boda 
 By ANDREW HIGGINS 
 AN IDEOLOGUE dependent on others for ideas and a power broker with no real authority of his own, Chen Boda became one of China's most feared and then reviled political hatchet men thanks to one all-important trait &mdash; his unflinching loyalty to Mao Tse-tung. 
 As Mao's personal secretary and speechwriter for over 30 years, Chen was one of the &bquo;Great Helmsman&equo; 's closest confidants, writing countless tracts and playing a key role in the Cultural Revolution, Mao's catastrophic campaign to purify the Communist party hierarchy and revive what he imagined to be China's fading revolutionary ardour in the 1960s. 
 Born in the coastal province of Fujian in 1904, Chen began serving Mao in Yenan, the remote village in northwest China where the Red Army took refuge and regained its strength at the end of the Long March in 1937. 
 While holding no important posts within the party and often dismissed as little more than a colourless clerk of little talent by Mao's colleagues, he distinguished himself as a devoted and tireless servant both of Mao and his new wife Jiang Qing &mdash; qualities that would later prove far more important than any formal title. 
 After the Communist victory in 1949, Chen followed Mao to Peking, where he worked quietly and largely anonymously for nearly a decade. 
 But, as Mao grew increasingly suspicious of and isolated from more distinguished revolutionary veterans, he turned increasingly to his secretary for help as he tried to rally support for more radical, leftist policies. 
 Appointed to the politburo and then made founding editor of the theoretical journal Hong Qi ('Red Flag') in 1958, Chen wrote numerous articles attacking &bquo;revisionism&equo; and supporting Mao's disastrous &bquo;Great Leap Forward&equo;, an ill-conceived and brutally executed drive for rapid industrialisation and rural collectivisation now blamed for the deaths of more than 15 million people. 
 Chen is credited with coining the term &bquo;people's commune&equo;, the now discredited model of huge collective farms that, according to Mao, would catapult China into a state of pure communism almost overnight. 
 But as with all his writings, he contributed phrases rather than ideas, relying on Mao for the latter. 
 The subsequent economic ruin forced Mao to rein in the &bquo;Great Leap&equo; radical experiments in social engineering. 
 And, as Mao's reputation slipped, so too did Chen's. 
 In 1966, however, when Mao began his dramatic bid for absolute power, using young Red Guards to discredit and persecute his old rivals within the party, Chen again rose to the occasion, acting as a mouthpiece for Mao's increasingly scrambled thoughts and policies. 
 Chen is even said to have written, or at least supervised at Mao's behest, the Cultural Revolution's best-known tract &mdash; an hysterical call to arms against &bquo;counter-revolutionaries&equo; printed in the People's Daily in April 1966 under the title &bquo;Sweep away all ghosts and monsters.&equo; 
 To carry out a wholesale purge of the party apparatus, Mao appointed Chen as head of the Cultural Revolution Group, a kitchen cabinet of loyal disciples, including Mao's wife Jiang Qing, that was to lead the assault on the party hierarchy. 
 The group was finally disbanded in 1969, by which time China had been plunged into virtual anarchy and economic collapse. 
 Again forced to moderate his ambitions, Mao called in the army to restore order. 
 During his nearly three years as effective day-to-day leader of the Cultural Revolution, Chen, along with Jiang Qing and Mao's security chief Kang Sheng, helped orchestrate campaigns of vilification and persecution against thousands of party cadres, including the then head of state Liu Shaoqi, who later died alone in a bank vault used as a cell. 
 In a move for which he would later pay, he called for the persecution of Deng Xiaoping, who was banished from office and attacked as second only to Liu as China's &bquo;leading capitalist roader&equo;. 
 Perhaps still smarting from his lowly position and lack of respect in Yenan 30 years before, he publicly condemned Deng as arrogant and dangerously ambitious: &bquo;To discuss with Deng Xiaoping as equals is more difficult than to put a ladder against heaven.&equo; 
 As the fervour of the Cultural Revolution wound down, Chen too fell from favour, losing, it would seem, even Mao's confidence. 
 With no real power-base of his own, he was one of the first radicals to suffer disgrace. 
 Linked to an alleged coup attempt by Mao's then heir-apparent Lin Biao in 1971, Chen was arrested and reviled as a traitor. 
 His exact involvement, if any, with Lin Biao's purported plot remains &mdash; like the entire episode - shrouded in mystery. 
 To this day the party has never quite healed the deep wounds left by what remains probably its most traumatic internal crisis. 
 After years of silence about his fate, Chen reappeared in public in 1980 to stand trial along with Mao's widow Jiang Qing and other members of the so-called &bquo;Gang of Four&equo;. 
 Given a relatively lenient sentence of 18 years (Jiang Qing and others were given suspended death sentences), Chen was later released from jail &bquo;in consideration of age and poor health&equo;. 
 Despite his notoriety during the Cultural Revolution, Chen even secured a limited rehabilitation in the last years of his life and was allowed to do historical research at the Literature and History Museum in Peking. 
 In an unusual concession to a man once pilloried daily for his association with the Cultural Revolution and Mao's despised widow Jiang Qing, his remains were cremated at Peking's Babaoshan cemetery, a privilege normally reserved for senior cadres. 
 The People's Daily, the Communist party organ, published news of his death nearly two weeks late but avoided any harsh commentary. 
 Such signs of relative forgiveness on the part of the leaders he had persecuted so relentlessly in the past, particularly Deng Xiaoping, offer perhaps the clearest insight into Chen's career: he had never been a political force in his own right but merely a faithful interpreter and executor of Mao's will. 
 Obedience, even misguided, is a quality the Communist party admires. 
 Obituary: Denis Serjeant 
 By MICHAEL MANSER 
 LIKE the Royal Academy of Arts, Denis Serjeant, its Surveyor, was brilliant and mildly maverick. 
 His achievements at the RA in his 10 years of office were immense, innovative and all modestly carried through. 
 As architect to Burlington House, he was conscious of his debt to his predecessors: Sydney Smirke, EM Barry, Norman Shaw. 
 He introduced new boilers in the boilerhouse under the main galleries; he installed a completely new steel structure in the ceiling above the entrance hall &mdash; without harming the ceiling paintings by Benjamin West and Angelica Kauffmann; he rebuilt the goods lift to carry loads of up to three tonnes into the galleries; he refurbished the public cloakrooms. 
 More recently, he relocated the Schools Canteen from dingy basement to gleaming mezzanine and at the time of his death had nearly completed his greatest coup. 
 This is an ingenious and unique method, devised with Professor Pat O'Sullivan, of environmental tuning in the great Victorian galleries. 
 Rather than imposing artificial conditions, Serjeant allied Victorian engineering to twentieth-century control systems: he deployed the forces of natural convection, rather than cumbersome, mechanically-powered plant, to ensure a regulated flow of humidified and heated air through the galleries. 
 This will have been achieved at modest cost with, it seems likely, triumphant results. 
 Born in 1927, Denis Serjeant qualified as an architect the hard way, by taking external examinations whilst articled to an Oxford architect. 
 There followed three years in a furniture factory and 10 years working in the architectural practice of Sheppard Robson, where he was involved in educational buildings, including the chapel of Churchill College, Cambridge. 
 Serjeant was then stricken with severe arthritis and was for a period chair-bound. 
 Unable to practise, he turned to teaching at Cheltenham School of Architecture close to the home he had designed and substantially built at Malvern, despite his affliction, and became deputy principal. 
 He also initiated the successful architectural competition for the regeneration of a run-down area of Worcester. 
 In 1979 Serjeant's former employer Richard Sheppard recommended him for the post of Surveyor to the Royal Academy. 
 The offer coincided with a move to separate the Cheltenham Schools of Architecture and Art, with which he disagreed, so he applied for the post and succeeded despite his now apparent and debilitating illness. 
 Denis Serjeant and the Academy were a natural union. 
 In his letter of acceptance he wrote, &bquo;I gladly accept and I shall do all I can for you,&equo; and he did literally that. 
 He loved the place and everyone it involved. 
 In the then president, Sir Hugh Casson, he found a kindred spirit. 
 When asked later how he knew where to begin he replied, &bquo;I didn't &mdash; and Sir Hugh Casson said &bquo;Just absorb the atmosphere&equo;.' 
 Serjeant sustained his increasingly serious illness with signal fortitude and uproarious humour. 
 His many enthusiasms extended to owning a couple of elderly Rolls-Royces, attempting to restart a School of Architecture at the RA, submitting with success his own drawings to the Summer Exhibition and vigorously supporting home-town local causes, including the Malvern Arts Club. 
 He had a passionate interest in music and opera which led him to design several operatic sets. 
 In appearance tall, bald and gangling, eyes alight with pleasure, tufts of hair in disarray, he was the personification of a slightly mad professor. 
 His ritual annual speeches, as he welcomed the assembly to the Royal Academy evening of the RIBA Council Dinner Club, were exponentially hilarious. 
 Last July, in peak form, pirouetting on his toes and gesticulating wildly, he was wickedly funny and amazingly indiscreet. 
 At the same time he could be penetratingly serious; but, above all, he was poignantly lovable. 
 Obituary: David Cathcart King 
 By JOHN R. KENYON 
 DAVID KING, &bquo;King of the Castle&equo;, was one of the great authorities on the medieval castle and author of a definitive catalogue of all castles built in England and Wales. 
 Born in 1913, he was educated at Clifton College and went on to read law at Bristol University. 
 His service in the Royal Artillery in the Second World War took him to the Middle East, and there he was able to develop his interest in military architecture through the study of the citadel at Damascus, and the siege of the crusader castle of Krak des Chevaliers. 
 The results were eventually published after the war. 
 King lost a leg during war service in Italy, an event which makes his thorough surveys of castles, notably those in Wales, even more remarkable. 
 He made teaching his career and taught history and mathematics in preparatory schools in Somerset. 
 His spare time was devoted to the study of the castle, in which he was ably assisted by Clifford Perks, his former collaborator on several papers, and later by Mark Cheshire, a former pupil. 
 In the 1950s and 1960s the royal castles were examined in detail by various authorities, but it was the great baronial buildings in Wales that attracted King. 
 From the 1950s through to the early 1980s he published an important series of papers, the majority in the Cambrian Archaeological Association's Archaeologia Cambrensis, notably on the Pembrokeshire castles of Carew, Manorbier and Pembroke, and the native Welsh castles of Dinas Bran and Caergwrle in the north of the principality. 
 At the same time as he was working on individual buildings, King produced his lists of all the castles in Wales and the Marches, as well as more detailed papers on the counties of Breconshire and Cardiganshire. 
 His fieldwork in England and Wales led him to visit virtually every castle with visible remains, from humble earthwork upwards, culminating in the publication of his Castellarium Anglicanum (1983). 
 This two-volume work details all the castles built in England and Wales, and reference will always be made to it as long as castles are studied. 
 However, it is King's work in Wales that is his great legacy. 
 He was a frequent attender of the Chateau Gaillard European Castle Studies conferences, and contributed several papers to the published proceedings. 
 He always had a deep interest in siege engines and the construction of scale working models of these machines; one of the memorable events of the Chateau Gaillard conference at Durham University was witnessing David's experiments with his machines on the campus lawns, using marbles for ammunition. 
 In 1962 he was elected a Fellow of the Society of Antiquaries of London and later, from 1976 to 1977, he served as President of the Cambrian Archaelogical Association. 
 In 1987 the University of Wales Press published a collection of essays written by his admirers in his honour. 
 COURT CIRCULAR 
 By JOHN R. KENYON 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 3 October: The Princess Royal, President, Save the Children Fund, this morning visited the Save the Children Fund Shop at 104 High Street, Orpington, and was received on arrival by the Save the Children Fund Area Representative for South London (Lady Neil). 
 Her Royal Highness this afternoon opened the new Head Office Building for the Woolwich Equitable Building Society, Watling Street, Bexleyheath, and received a donation from employees for the Save the Children Fund. 
 The Princess was received on arrival by the Chairman of Woolwich Equitable Building Society (Mr Alan McLintock). 
 The Princess Royal, Chancellor of the University of London, this afternoon visited the Institute of Zoology at London Zoo, Regent's Park, in celebration of the accession of the Institute of Zoology of the Royal Zoological Society to the University of London and was received on arrival by the Lord Mayor of Westminster (Councillor Simon Mabey). 
 This evening Her Royal Highness, Patron of the British Nutrition Foundation, attended a Dinner at the Natural History Museum (Chairman of the Council of the British Nutrition Foundation, Dr Jack Edelman). 
 Mrs Malcolm Wallace was in attendance. 
 Subsequently Her Royal Highness, Patron, Swansea Festival of Music and the Arts, attended a concert given by the London Philharmonic Orchestra in the Brangwyn Hall, Swansea. 
 The Princess of Wales travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 Miss Anne Beckwith-Smith and Lieutenant-Commander Patrick Jephson RN were in attendance. 
 The Lady Mary Mumford was in attendance. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Duchess of York opens the new terminal at Kent International Airport; and later, as Patron of Museums Year 1989, visits the Minster Agricultural and Rural Life Museum, Thanet, Kent. 
 The Princess Royal, President, The Save the Children Fund, visits the Lifechance Project at Cricket Road, Cowley, Oxford; later, as Patron, Universiade &bquo;91 World Student Games, visits Sheffield; and, later, attends the Annual General Meeting and Conference of the National Association of Citizens Advice Bureaux at York University. 
 Princess Margaret, Grand President of St John Ambulance Association and Brigade, attends a reception and dinner to be given by Garrard and Company in aid of the Order of St John. 
 The Duke of Gloucester attends a Gala Concert and Dinner hosted by The National Trust, at Osterley Park House, Isleworth. 
 The Duchess of Kent, as Patron of the Royal Northern College of Music, presides at the launch of their Appeal; opens Phase of the Manchester Science Park; and attends the South Manchester Health Authority's Annual Nurse Prize Giving Ceremony. 
 Princess Alexandra opens the 1989 Park Lane Hotel Antiques Fair, London W1. 
 Appointments 
 Gazette Page 21 
 Anniversaries 
 By JOHN R. KENYON 
 On this day: Peterborough Cathedral was consecrated, 1238; Miles Coverdale's translation of the Bible was published, 1535; William Smith founded the Boys Brigade, Glasgow 1883; the first public escalator was opened, Earl's Court underground station 1911; Hitler and Mussolini met at the Brenner Pass, 1940; the USSR launched Sputnik 1, the world's first artificial satellite, 1957; the first transatlantic passenger jet service started operating, 1958; USSR's Lunik III, took the first close-up pictures of the moon, 1959; Pope Paul VI visited New York, the first pope to visit America, 1965. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 21 
 Wills 
 By JOHN R. KENYON 
 Sir Douglas Peter Crossman, of Sandy, Bedfordshire, former chairman of Mann Crossman Paulin and later of Watney Mann, chairman of the Brewers&equo; Society 1968-69 Deputy Lieutenant of Huntingdonshire 1958 and chairman of the National Union of the Conservative Party 1969, left estate valued at &pound;6,277,893 net. 
 He left &pound;1,000 to the Parish of Waresley, Sandy, for the upkeep of the church. 
 Law Report: English proceedings over ancient art work stayed: Cleveland Museum of Art v Capricorn Art International SA and another &mdash;Queen's Bench Division (Commercial Court) (Mr Justice Hirst), 2 October 1989 
 By YING HUI TAN, Barrister 
 An overseas company dealing in works of art which used premises in London for viewing and storing works of art and controlled access to a secure vault at the premises had an established place of business in Great Britain on the premises, although other works of art not belonging to the company were also on the premises and no outward sign of the company, such as a nameplate, was displayed on the premises. 
 The company had therefore been properly served with English proceedings by an American museum in Ohio, but since the Ohio court was the more appropriate forum for the trial of disputes between the parties, the English action would be stayed. 
 Mr Justice Hirst ordered a stay of English proceedings brought against the first defendant. 
 The first defendant, Capricorn, a company registered in Panama, was the owner of a valuable reliquary which was an important piece of ancient Pakistan art of the Gandhara period, dating from the first century AD. 
 The reliquary was a fine specimen of that type of art and of very good quality and in fine condition. 
 Part of the reliquary consisted of a gold inscription plaque which referred to the fourteenth year of a particular Gadhara king, enabling the experts to date it precisely. 
 The reliquary was held by Capricorn in a secure vault at an address in St John's Wood, north London, which belonged to an associate company of Capricorn. 
 The house was occupied as the London residence of an art dealer. 
 Capricorn, giving that address, had placed insurance policies at Lloyd's up to &pound;1.1m for a wide variety of categories of objects of art. 
 Capricorn agreed to loan the reliquary for display at an exhibition in Ohio, USA. 
 In September 1985, the second defendant collected the reliquary and packed it for shipment to the plaintiff, Cleveland Museum of Art. 
 After it was unpacked the plaque was found to be missing. 
 In 1987, Capricorn commenced proceedings in Ohio against the museum and the second defendant for negligence in handling the reliquary, claiming &dollar;400,000, representing the dimunition of value of the reliquary minus the plaque. 
 The proceedings had gone through interlocutory stages for two years. 
 The second defendant had notified the Ohio court it would decline to submit to the jurisdiction. 
 In 1989, the museum began English proceedings against Capricorn, with the object of forcing Capricorn to abandon its claim in Ohio. 
 The museum claimed that Capricorn or the second defendant, as Capricorn's agent, was responsible for the loss of the plaque. 
 The writ was served at the London address on the basis that it constituted a place of business established by Capricorn as an overseas company in Great Britain, rendering such service valid under section 695 of the Companies Act 1985, Capricorn had not registered the name and address of a person authorised to accept service. 
 Capricorn applied for the service of the writ to be set aside on the ground that the London address did not consitute a place of business in Great Britain or that if service was good, Capricorn sought a stay on the ground of lis alibi pendens in Ohio. 
 Simon Tuckey, QC, and Sarah Harman (Elborne Mitchell) for Capricorn; Nicholas Stewart, QC, and David Halpern (Reynolds Porter Chamberlain) for the museum. 
 MR JUSTICE HIRST said that the criteria in determining whether an overseas company had established a place of business in Great Britain were summarised in Palmers' Company Law, 24th edn (1987) page 1658. 
 Further, a visible sign or physical indication was not essential, though its absence was a factor to be taken into account: Re Oriel (1986) 1 WLR 180. 
 Evaluating the evidence, it demonstrated substantial storage by Capricorn of works of art on the premises in London. 
 The second defendant had made a large number of deliveries to and collections from the premises on Capricorn's account. 
 It was clear that the premises were used for viewing works of art stored there by Capricorn and that it controlled access to the vault. 
 The address on the insurance policy was also consistent with the premises being Capricorn's established business premises. 
 Storage and viewing were very important aspects of an art dealer's business. 
 The museum had demonstrated a sufficiently substantial scale of those two activities to make good its case that Capricorn had an established place of business on the premises. 
 The fact that other works of art not belonging to Capricorn were also on the premises did not affect that conclusion: nor did the absence of any outward sign of Capricorn on the premises have any significance, since it would be uncharacteristic for art dealers in objects of such high quality to place conspicuous nameplates on their premises. 
 It followed that the service of the writ was good service. 
 Turning to the stay of proceedings, the principles which applied were enshrined in The Abidin Daver (1984) AC 398 and The Spiliada (1987) AC 460. 
 There were a numbers of factors which pointed strongly in favour of Ohio as the more appropriate forum for the trial of the disputes. 
 The case had been under way in Ohio for more than two years and was now ready for trial. 
 Capricorn had already expended &dollar;75,000 in legal costs in those proceedings. 
 The law of Ohio was the proper law of the loan agreement. 
 Ohio was the more convenient forum for the witnesses. 
 Capricorn's choice of venue in Ohio was in all respect appropriate. 
 While it would have been preferable if the second defendant participated in the trial in Ohio, and that was a consideration to be taken into account on forum conveniens, that factor was insufficient to outweigh the other factors. 
 Further, pursuit of the English action would result in substantial additional expense, inconvenience and delay of the kind described in The Abidin Daver. 
 Following the approach ordained in The Spiliada, the Ohio court was another available forum, having competent jurisdiction, which was the more appropriate forum for the trial of the action. 
 Capricorn's application for a stay of the English action would be granted. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Executive votes show desire for unity 
 By COLIN HUGHES, Political Correspondent 
 THE BED-ROCK culture of the Labour Party is shifting towards an emphasis on loyalty and unity, according to an analysis of constituency party voting for Labour's national executive. 
 The significance of the defeat on Monday of Ken Livingstone, Brent East MP, could only be calculated for the first time yesterday when the detailed voting figures were published. 
 The left-wing former GLC leader said yesterday that left-wing opposition to the leadership remained strong. 
 But he accepted that his defeat revealed &bquo;a general reluctance&equo; in the party to see that opposition voiced too vehemently in public. 
 Mr Livingstone argued that the move towards unity was merely the normal pre-election loyalty which the party usually showed; the only difference this time was that it was happening 18 months earlier than normal. 
 But the Labour Co-ordinating Committee said that there was clear evidence of a cultural change. 
 &bquo;The oppositionist politics of the 1970s and early 1980s are over. 
 People want national executive members who are independent of the leadership, but not destructively critical,&equo; Mike Craven, its vice-chairman, said. 
 Between 30 and 50 per cent of constituency management committees voluntarily consulted their full membership before casting their votes. 
 The evidence showed, according to Mr Craven, that wherever individual party members were given the one member, one vote opportunity to voice their views, they rejected the hard left. 
 &bquo;There can be no doubt now that one member, one vote ballots will become compulsory.&equo; 
 Mr Livingstone agreed that the spread of individual ballots had undermined his vote. 
 &bquo;I would have survived if one member, one vote had not been introduced in the constituency section,&equo; he said. 
 Its extension would now oblige the left to find new ways of campaigning among party members, because they tended to cast their votes according to what they saw on television. 
 But the most convincing demonstration of the spread of change is that support was withdrawn from Mr Livingstone in every part of the country except London. 
 His vote was more than halved in the party's northern region, and nearly halved in both Yorkshire and the north-west. 
 But even in the eastern region Mr Livingstone lost 10 constituencies more than last year, and in the southern region he lost 20 more. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Kinnock hails party as fit for government: &bquo;We will keep on winning with no wheeling, no dealing, no horse-trading and no electoral pacts&equo; 
 By JUDY JONES and STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 NEIL KINNOCK yesterday hailed the Labour conference as a celebration of party unity and a demonstration to the electorate that the party was fit to govern Britain. 
 In his keynote speech, the Labour leader said it was an inspiration to see the party working together in support of its policy objectives. 
 &bquo;It is not an empty claim to say that this conference is one of progress, indeed one of celebration, not of relaxation or complacency.&equo; 
 The party was &bquo;not only telling itself, but exuding to the British public the feeling that we are fit to serve our country&equo;, he said. 
 Its advances in the local and European elections this year had shown the tide was turning towards Labour. 
 Increasingly, the Prime Minister was seen by the public to be working against political trends, both at home and abroad. 
 &bquo;Margaret Thatcher shows that she is from the Greta Garbo school of diplomacy: &bquo;I want to be alone.&equo; 
 It's not splendid isolation, or cunning or sagacity. 
 It's a fundamental failure to perceive and secure Britain's role in a rapidly changing world. 
 &bquo;She is out of touch, out of date and out of step with the British people. 
 We are in step.&equo; 
 Mr Kinnock opened his leader's speech with a forthright rejection of the idea of electoral pacts being mooted by David Owen, leader of the SDP. 
 In by-elections, county elections and in the European Parliament elections, the public, he said, was telling Labour: &bquo;You are doing the right thing. 
 Keep on doing it.&equo; 
 &bquo;We will keep on because it is the winning way. 
 It is the best way to serve the people we want to stand up for. 
 And we will keep on winning with no wheeling, no dealing, no horse-trading and no electoral pacts.&equo; 
 Labour would go on getting the public's support by constructing strong unity of purpose and by its conduct as &bquo;a serious, socialist, self-disciplined party&equo;, Mr Kinnock told delegates. 
 The policy review had produced &bquo;relevant and practical&equo; answers that offered the kind of socialism the British people understood and supported. 
 It was the kind of socialism that insisted the NHS was not split up or sold off, that resented the injustice of the poll tax, and opposed the centralisation, control and censorship which had eroded civil liberties over the last 10 years. 
 He predicted the Conservatives would hit back with personal attacks on Labour leaders, by ordering civil servants to waste time trying to &bquo;cost&equo; the party's programmes and then, next week at Blackpool, with &bquo;the Team&equo;. 
 At the back of the stage would be the new Tory slogan &mdash; &bquo;The Right Team for the Future&equo;. 
 &bquo;Margaret Thatcher's team &mdash; that's a bit of confusion in terms isn't it. 
 Like David Owen's legions.&equo; 
 Delighting delegates, Mr Kinnock likened the Cabinet to a team of sled dogs. 
 &bquo;They bound along, eager and unquestioning across the icy wastes with the driver with the whip over them saying &bquo;mush, mush&equo;. 
 And you know with huskies, if one of them drops dead, the rest of them eat him. 
 That's Tory team spirit.&equo; 
 Mocking Mrs Thatcher's claim that Conservative policies had achieved an economic miracle, Mr Kinnock said after 10 years with oil revenues not enjoyed by any of Britain's competitors, the country had 2 million unemployed, the highest inflation, highest interest rates and biggest balance of payments deficit of the industrialised countries. 
 Worse still was the Tories' refusal year after year to make the essential commitment to the productive base of the economy &mdash; education and training, research and development, science, transport and communication. 
 &bquo;The result of that was certain to be an unbalanced economy, under-equipped, under-skilled, inflating and increasingly importing. 
 Britain was bound to become a place of paralysing congestion in some parts, of miserable underdevelopment in others, a place of inefficiency, and because of the refusal to make public investment, a place of considerable danger too, for the travelling public and people working in those industries as we have seen so tragically demonstrated.&equo; 
 Mr Kinnock predicted that by 1992 and the advent of the single European market, the pound would be part of the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System. 
 Britain would be in an open economic zone and subject to even more direct competition from economies which had made a much stronger commitment to skills, research, science and transport. 
 &bquo;So that is the mess they are going to leave us, because some time before the completion of the single market, we shall have a Labour government.&equo; 
 Every in-coming Labour government had inherited a mess from the Tories, Mr Kinnock said. 
 But he warned the next would be bigger and would bear directly on what a Labour government could do. 
 &bquo;We are therefore going to have to be very deliberate in the choice of priorities. 
 And, having chosen them, we are going to have to stick to those priorities &mdash; and we will.&equo; 
 There was &bquo;no single solve-all strategy that can catapult Britain to economic strength&equo;, he said. 
 It had got to be worked for. 
 A Labour government would start to do what the Tories should have done in the oil-rich years. 
 &bquo;We are going to start to combat the transport congestion and make the investment in communications without which commercial Britain will judder to an expensive and dangerous halt in a very few years. 
 &bquo;We are going to build up the commitment to science, because if we carry on like the Tories are, Britain will be pushed down to the second or third division of industrial nations. 
 &bquo;We are going to develop inducements and encouragements for a major expansion of research and development, because if we are going to rival our major competitors we have a long way to go in catching up with them. 
 &bquo;Most importantly of all, we have got to increase the quality and the quantity of skills training and we have to make a new commitment to education.&equo; 
 Education and training were now &bquo;the commanding heights of every modern economy&equo;, Mr Kinnock declared. 
 Britain needed an economy of all the talents. 
 He said said the Government was keeping interest rates high because it did not know what else to do. 
 &bquo;What they will be hoping for is that they can get to a few months before before the next election, take the brakes off and try to deceive the people once again things are back on course. 
 It won't work. 
 It won't work for political reasons &mdash; it's one con-trick too far.&equo; 
 Everyone with a mortgage realised the Government's economic strategy was not working, he said. 
 Moreover, opinion polls suggested that huge majorities opposed the sale of the water and electricity industries. 
 The reasons were simple: &bquo;The British people are opposed to the sell-offs because they are more socially-responsible, more community-minded, more far-sighted, more patriotic than the Government that governs them. 
 &bquo;Privatisation of electricity and water also puts a hole straight through the Government's claim to be guardians of the environment. 
 This government cannot prove green credentials simply by moving Nick Ridley and replacing him with Patten, a much better public relations person, the slick following the Nick.&equo; 
 For the Tories to have any credibility as trustees of the environment they would have to have to change the whole basis of their philosophy. 
 Market sovereignty &bquo;the central canon of Thatcherism&equo; was incompatible with the investment in research and the co-operation that were essential to the conservation of the environment. 
 Labour would implement environmentally-progressive policies and press for reductions and possibly cancellations in third world debt. 
 This would help ensure the poorer countries did not repeat the environmental mistakes of the northern hemisphere as they pursued economic development. 
 Setting out Labour's case for international co-operation to strengthen world security and combat environmental degradation, Mr Kinnock said: &bquo;It is an argument for global citizenship &mdash; a recognition of the fact that in the world now and for the future, passive co-existence is not enough. 
 Active co-operation to defeat common problems is essential to environmental security for every country.&equo; 
 Labour sought to play a role in achieving those goals. 
 &bquo;We seek the power in order to do all that, to stop being spectators and start being negotiators, to take our country off the sidelines and put it in the mainstream of advance where it should rightly be. 
 That is what we shall do.&equo; 
 Turning to the dramatic developments in East European countries, the Labour leader warned that the taste of freedom their people had been yearning for would turn sour unless they gained material advancement. 
 &bquo;Those countries therefore have to make the leap from the command economy to the market economy, from the single party state to pluralism. 
 It is essential therefore that the West, and especially the countries of the European Community, give their support.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: NEC compromise on black sections defeated 
 By JOHN PIENAAR and JUDY JONES 
 NEIL KINNOCK'S fragile compromise on black representation was rejected by the Labour conference yesterday, threatening to prolong the internal conflict with black activists through the run-up to the next general election. 
 The leadership proposals &mdash; for an ethnic minority-led socialist society open to white voting members, and a future national executive seat &mdash; crumbled under pressure from supporters and opponents of separate &bquo;black sections&equo; at every level. 
 It left the Labour hierarchy acknowledging frankly that the long-running dispute had ended in stalemate, and with no clear plan for achieving a generally acceptable constitutional formula. 
 Yesterday's debate was dominated by black sections supporters who derided the compromise notion of a mixed-race &bquo;black and white minstrels&equo; society. 
 The outcome turned on the block votes of union delegations at opposite ends of the conflict; for and against establishing a separate body. 
 Or, in the case of the GMB general workers' union, backing an alternative federal grouping of ethnic minority organisations. 
 A call to implement an earlier proposal for a blacks-only society, amended by the leadership, was defeated by 3,363,000 to 2,715,000 Black activists were heartened by the support of the TGWU for a blacks-only body. 
 The union abstained on the NEC proposals. 
 But right-wing delegations, such as the AEU engineering union, came down against any &bquo;segregated&equo; affiliate. 
 Afterwards, Bernie Grant, the black Labour MP for Tottenham and chairman of the parliamentary black caucus, called for talks with Neil Kinnock to discuss a new compromise in which white members would join the organisation with no voting rights. 
 &bquo;Next year could be the last conference before an election, and we don't want another debacle,&equo; he said. 
 Marc Wadsworth, the black sections national organiser, said: &bquo;We can live with a long struggle. 
 But it won't be good for the party.&equo; 
 Narendra Makanji, the black sections' chairman, added that the unofficial organisation would continue to recruit locally, while campaigning to tilt the balance in trade unions such as the GMB. 
 In the conference hall, the debate was vitriolic, with only Jack Rogers, whose NEC working party proposed the mixed race organisation, defending the leadership's line. 
 Jatin Haria, national secretary of the unofficial black sections organisation, branded the NEC compromise the &bquo;choc-ice proposal &mdash; a thin coating of Uncle Tom black around a slab of white power.&equo; 
 Wilbert Hayes, of Brent South, declared: &bquo;No black worth his or her salt would touch such a black and white merry-go-round. 
 We are losing votes by the bucketful because black people feel they are being abandoned by this party.&equo; 
 The attack was stepped up by Raghib Ahsan, of Birmingham Ladywood, who told the conference: &bquo;We are offered scraps from the masters&equo; table, and hungry as we are for black representation, our response must be to spit them out.&equo; 
 Many speakers highlighted the apparent paradox of a party which gave its blessing to separate internal organisations for both women and young people, but which denied the same privilege to its black members. 
 Mr Rogers, for the NEC, insisted that the leadership's blueprint for black representation was a sincere attempt to resolve the issue. 
 &bquo;We have to recognise the strong feelings among black and white people that the party should not set up an organisation which is racially exclusive, and could be seen as a form of apartheid.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Women &bquo;turning backs on Tories&equo; 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correspondent 
 A PROFOUND shift away from the Tory Party among women voters was taking place, but many women still believed the Labour Party was too male-dominated, Clare Short warned the conference yesterday. 
 Ms Short, the Labour MP for Birmingham Ladywood, gave the warning as the conference agreed to give women a higher profile in the party with a 40 per cent quota for women on all party committees and local party delegations. 
 Ms Short said the women's vote could help Labour to win the next general election provided more women could be persuaded that Labour was sensitive to women's demands. 
 She said a majority of women had voted Tory since they got the right to vote, but a profound shift was now taking place. 
 An opinion survey by the party's communications group showed women had significantly different political views from men. 
 Women saw British society as too unequal, too competitive, too materialistic and too greedy. 
 Women wanted more equality, more social services, fewer weapons and less pollution. 
 But Ms Short added: &bquo;Women share our values but we are seen by these women as male dominated and the most unsympathetic of all the parties. 
 This debate should recognise our concern to put this right with more women at all levels.&equo; 
 But some women campaigners later protested that the debate, chaired by David Blunkett, had been rigged to silence their objections. 
 Glenys Ingham of Deptford constituency women's section said: &bquo;Some of us feel very angry about the way the system of submitting speakers&equo; cards is being used to stop us being called.&equo; 
 Several of the women who spoke in the debate represented trade unions. 
 They strongly denied that changes would be used to ensure that women's organisations were union-dominated. 
 But the protestors insisted that quotas would create &bquo;a caucus for careerists&equo;. 
 The results of a card vote will be announced today on a proposal by the NEC for the creation of a Labour women's committee. 
 The Parliamentary Labour Party has agreed to enhance the chances of women getting onto the Shadow Cabinet in the next elections in November. 
 It has increased the number of seats by three to 18 and will require that the MPs vote for at least three women. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Paths out of poverty defined by Smith 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 LABOUR delegates were warned yesterday that the party would lack electoral credibilty if it promised increases in public spending which could only be met by higher borrowing or taxes. 
 Underlining last weekend's commitment by John Smith, the shadow Chancellor, to control spending, Giles Radice, MP for Durham North, told the conference that properly financed public spending was not only good economics, but good politics. 
 Voters had to be certain Labour's programmes were properly costed. 
 &bquo;If we allow public spending to grow consistently faster than growth in output, then either public borrowing has to be increased or taxation,&equo; he said during a debate on the policy review report Economic Equality. 
 &bquo;John Smith was right to tell the country that a Labour government will only spend what it can afford. 
 This commitment brings credibility to our social programmes and adds to Labour's electability.&equo; 
 Opening the debate, Mr Smith did not return to this theme but dwelt on &bquo;the pathways out of poverty&equo; proposed in the review, notably the introduction of a statutory minimum wage and the restoration of a link between pensions and average earnings. 
 Initially the minimum wage would be 50 per cent of male median earnings. 
 Mr Smith said this first step would benefit some 4 million employees of which 80 per cent were women. 
 &bquo;Our aim is to raise low wages in Britain over time so that the lowest-paid worker will receive an hourly rate not less than two-thirds of that received by the male median full-time worker.&equo; 
 If the 50 per cent minimum were in force today, no worker would get less than &pound;112 a week. 
 Mr Smith said &bquo;market forces&equo; meant, for example, a 25-year-old shop worker in Liverpool earning just &pound;40 a week or a 35-year-old travel agent's employee in the Midlands being paid just &pound;1.11 per hour. 
 &bquo;The Conservatives may reject the idea of &bquo;a decent wage&equo;. 
 But can't they recognise that these are examples of indecent wages that should be considered illegal and unacceptable in a civilised society?&equo; 
 Pensioners, children, and people with disabilities were the groups with the first claim for an urgent improvement in benefits under Labour, Mr Smith said. 
 Supporting the pensions proposal, Alan Tuffin, general secretary of the Union of Communication Workers, said the Government had saved over &pound;16bn by breaking the link with earnings. 
 &bquo;I say to any pensioner in this hall or watching on the television, you have personally been robbed of over &pound;2,000. 
 &bquo;Since Mrs Thatcher came to power, the current weekly loss for a married couple by that callous act is &pound;17.50 a week.&equo; 
 Delegates gave overwhelming support to motions calling on the next Labour government to link pensions to average earnings or the retail price index, whichever was the higher; introduce retirement for both men and women at 60; and immediately reverse cuts in benefits for young people. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Philosophical Tendency jostles for literary recognition 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 MAYBE it is the hazy prospect of political power. 
 But if members of Labour's Philosophical Tendency, from Tony Benn to Bryan Gould, are choosing their words carefully it may be through fear of how they will look in each other's diaries. 
 Weary constituency and trade union delegates, queuing for a cup of tea and a sandwich, constantly risk ending up with a signed copy of someone's memoirs. 
 Around the Brighton Conference Centre, academic tracts on the party's past and future course seem to proliferate daily. 
 To a fevered imagination, it seems no one can turn a corner in the crowded conference complex without running into a mug shot of one or other high-theoretician leering pensively from a wall of hardback dust covers. 
 Their debate on Labour's plight rages far above the brawling oratory in the conference hall. 
 No speeches have yet been greeted with ecstatic cries of &bquo;author, author&equo; &mdash; probably because Denis Healey is not there &mdash; but the clash of rival socialist philosophies is no less cacaphonous. 
 It reached a pitch this week at a late night fringe meeting, appropriately held in the rooftop suite of a Brighton hotel, when four of the most saleable authors around turned out to promote their ideas and printed wares. 
 At one end of the book-strewn, red baize-covered table was Tony Benn (The Benn Diaries 1973-76). 
 He cited the experience of the last Labour government in being forced to deal with the International Monetary Fund as further proof of the need to stick to fundamental socialism. 
 His Cabinet experience, he unfolded, was but a small part of the assembled case. 
 &bquo;The pleasure comes later, when you elevate yourself to the status of a student and a teacher &mdash; that's how I see the job.&equo; 
 At the other end, Bryan Gould (A Future for Socialism) held his audience spellbound as he charted Labour's recovery from assumptions of unchallenged &bquo;rightness&equo;, once taken for granted and shattered by Thatcherism. 
 Austin Mitchell (Beyond the Blue Horizon), and Giles Radice (Labour's Path to Power &mdash; the New Revisionism) were there too. 
 And although their analyses overlapped only in the margins, there was a burst of literary bitchiness when Mr Radice's enthusiasm for the opportunties of the Common Market was excoriated by the other three. 
 &bquo;I happen to be the only person here who believes we have to make a response at the European level,&equo; Mr Radice said. 
 &bquo;I believe Tony used to believe that, in the days before he became&hellip; different.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Revised policy wins approval 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 The conference approved the Economic Equality policy review which proposes: Ending tax on childcare; Introducing a minimum wage starting at half of average male earnings (&pound;2.80 an hour), rising to two-thirds the average; Income tax levels of no higher than 50 per cent at the top, down to less than 20 per cent at the bottom; &bquo;A significant and generous increase in child benefit over the lifetime of the Parliament&equo;; To tax gifts and inheritance at the point of receipt; To crack down on tax loopholes; Raise pensions immediately by &pound;5 for single people and &pound;8 for couples; To introduce a new disability benefit; To simplify income support rules; To keep mortgage interest tax relief &bquo;at a single rate equivalent to the basic rate relief which we inherit&equo;. 
 Decisions The conference: Called on the next Labour government to introduce retirement for both women and men at 60 on full pension, with the option of early retirement at 55 and to take emergency steps to restore cuts in young people's benefits. 
 Agreed a quota of 40 per cent for women's representation on all party committees. 
 Rejected the NEC plan for a separate society for black and Asian members that would be open to voting white members. 
 Delegates also refused to give official recognition to existing black sections. 
 Today the conference will debate the policy review reports Physical and Social Environment, including housing and transport; People at Work; and the education section of the Consumers and the Community report. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Conference quotes 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 &bquo;I have progressed from being an underpaid woman worker to being an underpaid pensioner.&equo; 
 Neil Kinnock trying to end his 3min 25sec standing ovation &bquo;Some of us are worried that the conference may trough too early.&equo; 
 Frank Dobson, Shadow Leader of the Commons &bquo;I call upon the men in the party to prepare themselves to relinquish power and to loosen the male grip.&equo; 
 Dominic Gough, Newham NW &bquo;Education and training are now the commanding heights of every modern economy.&equo; 
 The International Bar Association conference: Punitive damages awards &bquo;necessary to protect public&equo; 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 CIVIL and criminal courts should have a new power to impose punitive damages awards on companies which demonstrate wanton or reckless disregard for human life, a lawyer said yesterday. 
 Rodger Pannone, a solicitor involved in the Piper Alpha, King's Cross and M1 air disasters, told the International Bar Association conference in Strasbourg: &bquo;Unless there are damages awards &mdash; which must be uninsurable - of hundreds of thousands, if not millions, of pounds in certain circumstances, bad companies have no threat or incentive to make products and services safer.&equo; 
 Only a small proportion of this extra money should go to the claimants, he argued, in addition to normal compensation for injury and loss of earnings. 
 &bquo;The remainder, at worst, would go to the state; or better, into a fund to promote industrial safety.&equo; 
 He said that a minority of companies demonstrated a reckless disregard for safety, and some intentionally put profit before safety. 
 Mr Pannone's comments reflect the philosophy of the American courts, where juries are able to award punitive damages. 
 &bquo;I find it difficult to justify enormous punitive damages being paid to victims on a first-past-the-post system. 
 However, courts in America take far more seriously than European courts their role in encouraging safe products and company practices,&equo; he said. 
 David McIntosh, a leading insurance company defence solicitor, who opposed Mr Pannone in the Opren drug case, attacked claims that British levels of damages were &bquo;miserly&equo;. 
 &bquo;Others, including myself, believe that non-punitive but truly compensatory damages awarded by the courts of the United Kingdom are preferable to the exorbitance of emotionally-driven jury awards,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Although it is argued that fear of punitive jury awards has made the US business safety-conscious, quite a price has had to be paid for that by way of corporate and insurance company bankruptcy, the closing of municipal facilities and the practice of defensive medicine.&equo; 
 The way to police safety, which hits at those responsible without penalising innocent shareholders, lies in the risk of criminal prosecution of senior management and others, where profit is put before life and limb, Mr McIntosh added. 
 But Mr Pannone said that while the Director of Public Prosecutions had decided eventually to prosecute P &amp; O European Ferries and directors and employees over the Herald of Free Enterprise tragedy, he had decided against prosecutions over the King's Cross fire. 
 &bquo;It remains to be seen, if there is a conviction in Zeebrugge, what the penalties will be. 
 Previous experience suggests that the penalties will be almost minimal.&equo; 
 Daniel Brennan QC, an English barrister, said that injury compensation awards should be based on generally accepted principles rather than the present &bquo;lottery&equo; of different rules in EC member states. 
 &bquo;Harmonisation must be pursued as an objective for 1992,&equo; he said. 
 The International Bar Association Conference: Lawyer warns of coal sale dangers 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES 
 POTENTIAL investors in a privatised coal industry face hidden dangers which could be financially disastrous, a former legal adviser to British Coal warned, writes Patricia Wynn Davies. 
 Spelling out the pitfalls at the conference, Ronald Cowles, who left British Coal last year, said major new mining developments would be opposed by residents and conservation groups and new businesses would be subject to stringent planning, environment and health and safety controls. 
 His remarks will not be welcomed by his former employers. 
 Casting doubt on the competitiveness of coal compared with other fuels, Mr Cowles warned: &bquo;Coal combustion is under attack as a major contributor to pollution, acid rain and the greenhouse effect and increasing controls are likely to be imposed in this area.&equo; 
 He predicted that the industry &mdash; which the Government has pledged will be privatised in the early 1990s &mdash; would be broken up before being sold, with each package containing a mixture of profit and loss-making pits. 
 Would-be investors would need their wits about them, he said. 
 &bquo;While some parts of the industry are likely to be very profitable, other parts will have concealed dangers, which could well carry with them the seeds of financial disaster.&equo; 
 He said that planning permission for a new pit would take two years and would normally involve a public inquiry. 
 Environmental impact assessments must accompany all applications and planning conditions covering subsidence, noise, traffic, dust, waste disposal and effluent were becoming increasingly strict. 
 There were also risks of legal liability for a growing number of pit accidents and industrial diseases. 
 Future mining disasters could well result in the criminal prosecutions of both the company and senior directors, Mr Cowles said. 
 British Coal is still handling claims from mineworkers for diseases contracted more than 40 years ago, before nationalisation. 
 Mr Cowles, who is a partner with Norton Rose, a firm of London solicitors, said a coal-mine also carried historical burdens of a physical kind. 
 Those included collapsing shafts, and escapes of contaminated water and gas. 
 Investors should expect to shoulder responsibility for any damage or injury arising after privatisation, and demarcation disputes were likely over liabilities from the past, he said. 
 Estuary plans &bquo;pose threat to wildlife&equo; 
 By CARMEL MCQUAID 
 ULSTER'S bird and marine life stands to be seriously diminished by new plans to develop areas around its estuaries, environmentalists were told yesterday. 
 Extensions to Belfast's port facilities and to its harbour airport, announced last week, must encroach further on the mudflats at Belfast Lough, Alison McCloy, of the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, warned in a lecture. 
 Already reduced to one-tenth of their original extent, these served as a breeding and wintering ground for 12,000 waterfowl. 
 Also, thousands of migrating birds from Canada, Iceland and Russia sought sustenance there on the way south, Ms McCloy said. 
 She added that other developments in Belfast dictated that the Kinneger Lagoon be filled in. 
 This would deprive wading birds such as curlew and snipe of an ideal breeding sanctuary. 
 What remained of Belfast's mudflats seemed certain to be diminished by unrestricted dumping. 
 A similar threat faced Lough Foyle, Londonderry, where the Culmore tip was encroaching on mudflats offering a winter home to hundreds of whooper swans migrating from Greenland. 
 Extensive stretches of mudflats also seemed likely to disappear at Strangford, Co Down, the province's most important estuary &mdash; endangering 50,000 waders, 25,000 wildfowl and 90 per cent of the pale-bellied Brent geese which wintered in the British Isles. 
 The threat came from proposals for a barrage across the lough's narrows to generate electricity from the tide's ebb and flow. 
 This would leave less of the mudflats exposed. 
 Gas explosion at maisonettes in Dagenham 
 By CARMEL MCQUAID 
 A WRECKED block of maisonettes at Dagenham, east London, where four people were taken to hospital yesterday after a gas explosion. 
 One of the victims was in a critical condition, suffering from severe burns, but the other three were allowed home after treatment for shock. 
 One-third of the block, (above) in Norton Road, was destroyed by the explosion and a fire brigade spokeswoman described the remaining structure as &bquo;extremely unsafe&equo;. 
 A spokesman for British Gas said: &bquo;It appears that gas was involved, although it looks as if it was a deliberate release rather than an accidental one.&equo; 
 Police could not say if charges would be brought. 
 Teachers &bquo;deprived of incentive pay by government error&equo; 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 THOUSANDS of classroom teachers in primary and secondary schools in England and Wales are being underpaid by up to &pound;2,500 annually because of a government error, one of the largest teachers unions claimed yesterday. 
 The Assistant Masters and Mistresses Association, representing about 131,000 teachers, estimates that about 7,500 teachers are not being paid incentive allowances worth &pound;858 a year, while a further 900 are missing out on additional annual payments of &pound;2,568. 
 The Government introduced incentive allowances for teachers in 1987 when it removed the profession's bargaining rights and imposed a pay settlement. 
 The payments were to be made to teachers with additional responsibilities; to outstanding teachers; to those teaching in shortage subjects; and for teachers taking posts that were difficult to fill. 
 However, the union says that when the incentive system was first introduced, the Government underestimated the number of senior teachers entitled to receive the new higher scale incentive allowances automatically. 
 The Government calculated that 88,000 teachers previously paid on the old Burnham pay scale were entitled to B, D or E allowances under the new system. 
 But government figures published this summer revealed that there were 93,720 teachers in this category, 5,720 more than it had thought. 
 Because insufficient allowances were allocated, the union argues, the local education authorities used much of the money that should have been paid in incentive allowances to classroom teachers to pay the senior staff their incentive entitlements. 
 The union estimates that local education authorities had to find an additional &pound;7m, as well as awarding 8,400 fewer classroom teacher incentive allowances, to meet the cost of incentives for senior teachers. 
 It calculates that the Government has underfunded the incentive allowances scheme by some &pound;12m a year. 
 The union is calling on the Goverment to correct its &bquo;mistake&equo; by making good the shortfall in allowances. 
 It wants the Interim Advisory Committee, which will determine the profession's pay increase for the 1990-91 year, to be allowed to remedy the error by using new money over and above the &pound;600m limit the Government has set on the global sum available for any increase. 
 John MacGregor, Secretary of State for Education, said yesterday that it was misleading for the union to say the Government had made a mistake. 
 All the teachers in 1987 who were entitled to an allowance received one. 
 Using union figures, allowances being paid at the start of this year exceeded the number originally intended by more than 3,000. 
 The smaller number of A and C allowances was more than made up for by the greater number of B and D allowances. 
 &bquo;The whole point of the incentive allowances system is for local authorities and schools to decide for themselves how many allowances to award and at what rates in the light of their particular circumstances,&equo; Mr MacGregor said. 
 &bquo;We would expect to see variations between authorities if the allowances had been used as intended. 
 Liberty chief 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 The civil rights organisation Liberty has appointed Andrew Puddephatt, 39, former Labour leader of Hackney council, London, as its general secretary. 
 He takes over from Sarah Spencer. 
 Water ban lifted 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 Anglian Water will today lift a ban introduced a month ago on windsurfing and fishing at Costessey Pits in Norfolk, Stoke Rochford lakes in Lincolnshire and seven lagoons at Newport Pagnell, Buckinghamshire, which were affected by toxic algae. 
 The ban will remain at Rutland Water, Leicestershire. 
 Plea for review of boat inquest 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 An application for a judicial review of an inquest on three fishermen drowned when their vessel foundered in the Irish Sea in September 1988 will be lodged in the High Court in London today. 
 The Fishguard-based crabber Inspire went down in a calm sea when a huge wave swamped it. 
 An inquest earlier this year returned verdicts of misadventure on its skipper, Terry Jones, and crewmen Ronald Laugharne and David Webster. 
 The coroner, Peter Brunton, rejected a request to submit a technical report pointing to the possible involvement of a submarine. 
 Aer Lingus faces Iran jet charges 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 Aer Lingus, the Irish Republic's national airline, confirmed that it was facing two charges in the United States that a subsidiary company illegally supplied aircraft parts to Iran. 
 It is understood the airline could face fines and costs totalling more than &pound;300,000 in connection with the case which relates to events over a six-year period from 1981. 
 Boeing components are alleged to have been sold to the Iranians by the London-based Aer Lingus controlled spares company Alpex, which has since been wound up. 
 The case arose through the servicing of small Iranian jets at Heathrow airport. 
 New firm in &bquo;unique&equo; link with Japan 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 JAPANESE technology will create more than 500 jobs in an umemployment blackspot in south Wales, marking a break from the &bquo;screwdriver&equo; plants which characterise much inward investment in the UK. 
 A new company is to be set up by Sanken Electric of Japan, and the Gooding Group of the UK, to manufacture special types of power supplies for the electronic and computer industry. 
 But, unusually, the venture will do everything from research and design through to manufacture compared with the now notorious &bquo;screwdriver&equo; assembly-only factories set up by many foreign investors in Britain. 
 The Gooding-Sanken company will be located at Aberaman in the Cynon Valley where unemployment is estimated to be 21 per cent &mdash; the highest in south Wales. 
 Four Japanese specialists will be sent to help train management and staff, but graduates and other workers will be recruited locally and sent to Japan for training as necessary. 
 Initially, the company will create 200 new jobs, rising to 520 over the next few years. 
 The venture, which will involve investment of &pound;8m, is believed to be receiving regional development grants worth up to 36 per cent of the total investment. 
 Malcolm Sanders, managing director of the new company, said the complete transfer of the Japanese company's technology to the UK was unique. 
 He said it would be the first of a series of ventures which Gooding was discussing with Japanese companies, aimed at bringing research and technology to Britain rather than just final assembly of goods. 
 The Welsh company, in which Gooding has the controlling 51 per cent stake, aims for revenues of &pound;70m within five years of operation. 
 The market for stable power supplies for sensitive equipment is worth &pound;1.2bn in Europe and is growing at 10 per cent per year. 
 So far it is dominated by Far East suppliers, including Sanken, Panasonic and TDK. 
 Archaeological site at Bristol Castle 
 By DAVID KEYS 
 SOME OF the 17ft thick walls of Bristol Castle's keep, built circa 1135 by the illegitimate grandson of William the Conqueror, Robert of Gloucester, are being revealed by an archaeological dig, writes David Keys. 
 For the past 300 years the substantial remains of one of medieval England's most important fortresses have lain hidden beneath part of the city centre. 
 The dig has shown that the 90ft long north wall of the keep and fragments of the east and west walls survive to a height of up to 18ft. 
 Part of a turret has also survived. 
 Excavation has also uncovered the impressive rock-cut ditch of the Norman motte and bailey castle, believed to have been built in the 1080s. 
 The site is particularly important because it is one of the few such castles to have developed out of an earlier Norman stone-built ring-work fort. 
 Apart from the keep, the only other remains of Bristol Castle to have survived are a small rock-cut entrance, 23 rock-cut steps and the thirteenth-century entrance vestibules of the royal banqueting hall &mdash; now a restaurant. 
 The keep's remains will be preserved as a historic monument. 
 Nuclear law &bquo;absurdity&equo; 
 By DAVID KEYS 
 A QC claimed yesterday it would be &bquo;absurd&equo; if the law did not allow people forced to leave homes made uninhabitable by radioactive contamination to be compensated. 
 Stephen Sedley was continuing his opening speech on the second day of a damages action against British Nuclear Fuels at the High Court in London. 
 Christopher Merlin, 48, and his wife, Christine, sold their home in Ravenglass, near Sellafield nuclear plant, Cumbria, at a loss after plutonium was found in house dust. 
 They say they are entitled to compensation against BNFL under the Nuclear Installations Act. 
 Mr Sedley said the court would have to decide if the damage to property under the Act included contamination by nuclear matter or waste or if it was limited to &bquo;injury&equo; to the fabric. 
 Psychiatrists explore hidden meaning of Thatchergate plan 
 By PETER DUNN 
 THATCHERGATE, the neo-nineteenth century railings which the Prime Minister wants to erect across the Whitehall end of Downing Street, sent a buzz of speculative excitement through psychiatric circles yesterday. 
 The 10-feet high palings, with their broad central gates and twin gas lamps, may not be as imposing as the metal fence around Buckingham Palace, but they do, in their modest way, suggest a sense of grandeur appropriate to a leader who has held office for 10 years. 
 Unlike the Queen's front gates, Thatchergate will also have a steel screen which will leap out of the Downing Street tarmac as an added defence against terrorists who manage to penetrate the fencing. 
 Lord St John of Fawsley, chairman of the Royal Fine Art Commission, who, as Norman St John Stevas, was an early ministerial victim of Mrs Thatcher's purge of the wets, has admonished the Prime Minister by reminding her she is not head of state; treating her as such, his lordship suggested, would simply arouse public hostility. 
 Psychiatrists see Thatchergate, the design of which has now been agreed with English Heritage, as evidence of the stress a decade in office has put on the occupant of No 10. 
 Dr Anthony Storr, author of the recently-published Churchill's Black Dog, in which he showed how senior politicans often turned stresses of up-bringing into strengths, said yesterday: &bquo;I'm interested because the gates must mean that she's feeling increasingly insecure and threatened in a simple, straightforward way; and that's an interesting phenomenum in itself because she's been so absolutely certain of herself. 
 I've found the increasing dogmatism and certainty that she's right the most sinister thing about her because that so often goes with paranoid feelings, and it may be that this is one manifestation of that. 
 &bquo;On the question of regality, it's very much a characteristic, her feeling how important she is. 
 People who think they're being persecuted always think people are paying them a great deal of attention so they come to believe that they must in a sense be very important people,&equo; he said. 
 A psychiatrist who specialises in executive stress thought the fencing indicated that the person it protected felt an enormous sense of isolation and betrayal at the hands of people who had failed to be grateful for years of selfless public service. 
 &bquo;At one level &mdash; and leaving out the executive stress &mdash; this woman has to cope with an enormous sense of personal threat,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Internally she has to say, &bquo;It won't happen to me&equo; or, &bquo;It's part of the job.&equo; 
 Externally she has to seek to diminish the threat by aggressive posturing and stamping and saying, &bquo;We'll get you, you bastards&equo;, or taking real measures like these gates. 
 &bquo;They must reflect some inner disturbance. 
 There must be an enormous sense of isolation, of being aware of being let down. 
 She's cut taxes, she's made concessions and somehow the British people simply haven't picked up the ball and run with it. 
 The gates are, in some way, an expression of anger towards the people she would like to trust. 
 That, in turn, makes her feel even more isolated. 
 Who can she turn to? 
 It's a reproach.&equo; 
 Aesthetically, Londoners will have to draw what consolation they can from the fact that Nicholas Ridley, the former Environment Secretary and a water-colourist with an eye for broader horizons, had some influence in the siting of the gates. 
 In practical terms, the gates and fence probably have little advantage over the waist-high barrier and high-profile police presence which has effectively sealed Downing Street from the public for eight years. 
 Lord St John thinks they will actually increase the security risk because the very visible opening of the gates will draw attention to the Prime Minister's movements. 
 Opponents may draw comfort from the fact that they are described officially as &bquo;a temporary obstruction on the highway&equo;. 
 Given the will, they could be pulled down within four hours. 
 Might that happen if Labour achieved office? 
 Peter Mandelson, the Labour Party's director of communications, said yesterday: &bquo;Mr Kinnock neither has the Prime Minister's folie de grandeur nor is he running scared of the British people. 
 I should not think that Mr Kinnock would have the same need for such structures.&equo; 
 So would Mr Kinnock topple Thatchergate if he became Prime Minister? 
 &bquo;That would be a decision Mr Kinnock would take at the time,&equo; Mr Mandelson declared loftily. 
 Hospital warned over emergencies 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 CONSULTANT surgeons at St Bartholomew's Hospital in London have warned managers that the hospital has &bquo;no alternative&equo; but to shut its accident and emergency department after the closure of 75 beds this week to head off a &pound;2m overspend. 
 The closures at Barts have come amid signs of a growing cash crisis this winter in several London health districts. 
 In a letter declaring no confidence in management, the consultant surgeons have told Dr Ken Grant, the authority's manager, that the 36 per cent cut in surgical beds means &bquo;we will be unable to offer an emergency service&equo;. 
 With the bulk of surgical patients consisting of urgent conditions, from cancers to vascular disease, Richard Wood, Professor of Surgery, has told Dr Grant that such surgery cannot be halted. 
 The surgeons, he said, are &bquo;unanimous&equo; that there is &bquo;no alternative to the closure of the accident and emergency department&equo;. 
 They fear that as winter approaches medical emergencies, such as elderly patients with pneumonia and strokes, will spill over into surgical beds, halting urgent operations. 
 Dr Grant said yesterday that the accident and emergency department would not be closing, not least because surrounding hospitals appeared unable to take the load. 
 &bquo;Everyone else seems to be in the same position. 
 &bquo;There is nowhere else emergencies can go,&equo; he said. 
 The hospital would have to make choices: &bquo;We are going to have to weigh up a hip replacement against a breast carcinoma.&equo; 
 After meeting the surgeons, he said they had agreed they could cope if medical emergencies did not spill over to their beds. 
 Dr Grant said that, since 1982, beds had been cut from 800 to 450, with Barts effectively running half empty and thus inefficiently. 
 &bquo;We see our only hope as being the White Paper where the money would follow the patients and give us the funds to treat the patients that arrive.&equo; 
 New guidance from the Department of Health says that with health authorities becoming purchasers of care from self-governing, directly managed and private hospitals, there has to be a risk of hospitals gaining a local monopoly of a particular service, or joining others in cartels. 
 Equally a health authority, as the dominant buyer in an area, might be able to dictate unfair terms to a hospital. 
 To deal with disputes over such matters, regional health authorities will act as conciliators. 
 Where that fails, the Secretary of State will have powers to arbitrate and impose a contract on the parties. 
 The guidance says that Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, &bquo;is minded&equo; to go for Japanese-style pendulum arbitration &mdash; where the arbiter would be free only to find for one party or the other, and would not be able to compromise. 
 Murder trial starts in sign language 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 SPECIAL interpreters assisted yesterday at the opening of a unique trial at Cardiff Crown Court, where a deaf man was accused of murdering a deaf woman who had speech difficulties. 
 Timothy Jack Robson, 28, a carpenter, denied murdering Suzanne Greenhill, 20, on 28 June 1988. 
 Her body was found at her flat where she lived alone in Tewkesbury Walk, Newport, Gwent, on 1 July 1988. 
 She had been raped and stabbed. 
 Mr Justice Roch said that because the defendant was deaf and had a speech disability a social worker, Jill Hughes, would sit in the dock and translate. 
 Another interpreter, Maurice Capewell, will assist at least four prosecution witnesses who are also deaf. 
 He will interpret their testimony for the court, and Mrs Hughes will then reinterpret it for Mr Robson. 
 Mrs Hughes used lip-reading, speaking, finger-spelling and British Sign Language to help Mr Robson, who has been partially deaf since he was three. 
 BSL involves simplification of terminology and has a different grammatical construction to spoken English. 
 Mr Robson has not been trained in more sophisticated and literal &bquo;sign supporting English&equo;. 
 Mr Justice Roch said the court would start early at 10am and adjourn for 30 minutes at hourly intervals to allow the interpreters to rest and to ensure the defendant had understood the evidence. 
 The trial is expected to last six to eight weeks. 
 A computer system is also available whereby the record kept by the court stenographer is fed to a print-out on a screen for the defendant. 
 Powerful earphones are also available to him. 
 The trial continues today with the opening statement from the prosecution. 
 Art Market: High price expected for &bquo;lost&equo; Picasso 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 AN EARLY Picasso painting, which most of the authoritative books on the artist recorded as lost or destroyed, is to be sold in Paris on 30 November and is likely to fetch one of the highest prices paid for a picture at auction. 
 Les Noces de Pierette, which is more than 6ft wide, dates from 1905. 
 Until recently it was only known from an early black and white photograph. 
 There was also uncertainty among experts as to whether it belonged to Picasso's Blue or Pink period. 
 It is now revealed to be Blue period &mdash; but one of the last paintings of this series. 
 It already uses the harlequin image which is characteristic of the Pink period paintings. 
 The harlequin is enamoured of a young dancer who has been forced to marry the proprietor of the troupe. 
 She sits at the marriage banquet, apparently in a cafe, and the harlequin has just presented her with a bouquet. 
 He bows before her and blows her a kiss. 
 The top-hatted old husband and three other, melancholy figures, are watching. 
 According to the French art magazine, Connaissance des Arts, the Picasso painting has belonged for more than 50 years to a collector who kept its existence secret &mdash; even from members of his family. 
 It is unclear whether it has recently changed hands. 
 Maitre Binoche, the auctioneer, says the picture belongs to a Swedish collector who is also a collector of contemporary paintings. 
 This is the field in which Binoche is noted as a specialist auctioneer and explains their acquaintance. 
 Binoche expects the painting to fetch about &pound;30m, but the figure depends on whether it gets a French export licence. 
 The auctioneers say that they have been assured that a licence will be forthcoming. 
 The highest price on record for a Picasso is &pound;28.1m which was paid in May for his self-portrait, Yo Picasso, of 1901; the highest price for any picture at auction is the &pound;30.9m paid in 1987 for Van Gogh's Irises. 
 Sotheby's will sell another Picasso on 15 November &mdash; Au Lapin Agile, from the Pink period &mdash; which is widely expected to break the previous price records. 
 Australia was the moneyspinner in the Phillips auction of topographical paintings yesterday. 
 A view of Hobart across the harbour with Mount Wellington beyond, painted in 1855 by Knud Geelmuyden Bull, a convict, made &pound;170,500 (estimate &pound;150,000-&pound;200,000). 
 A portrait of Commodore Sir John Hayes, one of the first men to explore the Tasmanian coast, sold for &pound;23,100 to an unnamed Australian institution. 
 Painted around 1806, it was catalogued as by John Opie; the auctioneers later changed their minds and attributed it to George Chinnery. 
 &bquo;Eye&equo; tells of newspaper's 25,000 pounds for Ripper wife 
 By JAMES DALRYMPLE 
 SONIA SUTCLIFFE, who was awarded &pound;600,000 in libel damages against Private Eye, gave a &bquo;misleading&equo; answer in court when she was questioned about a &pound;25,000 loan given to her by a friend, it was alleged in the Court of Appeal yesterday. 
 The friend was a newspaper reporter and the money was in fact paid to her by The Mail on Sunday, Gavin Lightman QC, representing the magazine in an appeal for a new trial, said. 
 The money was paid for articles concerning her life with her husband Peter, the Yorkshire Ripper, he said. 
 Mrs Sutcliffe, wearing dark tinted glasses, listened carefully in the packed public benches as Mr Lightman read out an affidavit by Oliver Duke, once the boyfriend of Mail on Sunday reporter Barbara Jones, in which he admitted taking part in a scheme to get the money secretly from the newspaper to Mrs Sutcliffe. 
 &bquo;Mr Duke had lived with Miss Jones,&equo; he told Lord Donaldson, the Master of the Rolls, sitting with two other judges, &bquo;and she told him that Mrs Sutcliffe had negotiated a contract with The Mail on Sunday. 
 &bquo;But before the payment could be made the owner of The Mail on Sunday, Lord Rothermere, issued a directive that no money should be paid to criminals or their families. 
 As a result, the payment to Mrs Sutcliffe had to be made in a roundabout way.&equo; 
 In his affidavit, Mr Lightman said, Mr Duke described how &pound;25,000 was paid into his bank account as a &bquo;consultancy fee&equo; and was later withdrawn in instalments and paid directly by Miss Jones &mdash; in cash &mdash; to Mrs Sutcliffe for the series of articles she had provided. 
 Mr Lightman said that at the time of the libel trial the defence had no idea that this payment had been made. 
 &bquo;If we had known we would have subpoenaed the editor of The Mail on Sunday, Mr Stewart Steven, and if a retrial is granted we will subpoena him and Miss Jones to give evidence. 
 We have written to Mr Steven, but he has ignored our letters.&equo; 
 Private Eye is appealing against the record &pound;600,000 damages paid to Mrs Sutcliffe after a seven-day trial last May, in which she alleged the magazine had libelled her by claiming in its &bquo;Street of Shame&equo; column that she had made a &pound;250,000 deal with the Daily Mail for her story after a night of &bquo;carousing&equo; with the paper's journalists in a hotel. 
 The magazine calls for a retrial on the grounds of the new evidence of the alleged Mail on Sunday payment, the &bquo;excessive&equo; amount of damages awarded, and misdirection of the jury by the judge on the amount of &bquo;aggravated damages&equo; they could award. 
 After listening to Mr Lightman's allegations, Lord Donaldson said that if Mr Oliver's affidavit was to be believed then The Mail on Sunday had acted in &bquo;a wholly hypocritical way.&equo; 
 On the amount of damages, Mr Lightman said the Court of Appeal had a special responsibility to bear in mind the &bquo;dangerous precedent&equo; which could be set by such awards, and added that in this case the award was out of all proportion to the alleged libel. 
 He added: &bquo;No real crime was alleged in the libel. 
 It was not in a national newspaper. 
 It was not a front page spread. 
 Nor was Mrs Sutcliffe a national character or a character of national reputation. 
 Her evidence of damage was limited and established that her reputation was already damaged.&equo; 
 The case continues. 
 Judge attacks &bquo;pools win&equo; libel payouts 
 By JAMES DALRYMPLE 
 IN A SUDDEN and scathing interjection during yesterday's hearing, Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, gave his view on the recent series of massive libel payouts by British juries, writes James Dalrymple. 
 After hearing defence submissions that the &pound;600,000 payout to Mrs Sutcliffe was &bquo;perverse and excessive&equo;, Lord Donaldson said: &bquo;It may be that the general jury approach to newspaper libel at the moment is tempered by some indignation at the way some branches of the Press are run &mdash; coupled with the feeling that, if you can get &pound;1m on the pools, why shouldn't you get &pound;1m on the newspapers too? 
 &bquo;The chances of being libelled in a big way are probably much the same as winning the football pools, and the results are very much the same.&equo; 
 Sitting below him in the well of No 3 Court, Private Eye's editor Ian Hislop nodded his head vigorously in agreement. 
 The court was packed throughout the day-long hearing, and Sonia Sutcliffe sat alongside her solicitor carefully taking notes on a clipboard. 
 Behind and to her right, impassive but occasionally smiling at a legal point, Richard Ingrams sat on his own. 
 He recently retired as editor of the Eye but he still spends much of his time at the magazine's cramped offices in Soho. 
 He, like other founders of the paper, fears that if the damages award is not lowered considerably it could be the end of the road for Pressdram Ltd, the Eye's publisher, after decades of public wars with the great and the powerful. 
 A few rows in front sat Peter Cook, the satirist, actor and comedian, who now owns a large slice of Private Eye. 
 He too listened closely to the arguments in the morning, but after a pub lunch with his staff, he did not return for the afternoon evidence. 
 Haddock skippers warn of crisis 
 By MARK DOUGLAS HOME, Scottish Correspondent 
 SCOTTISH fishermen's leaders warned yesterday that Britain's North Sea haddock quota will be exhausted within three weeks, leading to crisis in the industry and large-scale dumping at sea. 
 They forecast that the Scottish white fish fleet of more than 600 boats will have little choice but to continue fishing for species such as cod and whiting, even though haddock will also be caught. 
 Skippers will have either to throw away the haddock or risk prosecution by bringing them ashore. 
 One industry expert said up to 10,000 tonnes could be dumped by the end of the year. 
 John Goodlad, secretary of the Shetland Fishermen's Association, added: &bquo;The fish taken on board are perfectly marketable. 
 But they will have to be shovelled over the side. 
 That leads to anger and frustration.&equo; 
 The prospect of the North Sea quota of 54,800 tonnes running out this month has provoked talk of revolt by Shetland fishermen. 
 Their association has described the early closure of the haddock fishery as unacceptable, provoking speculation that the Shetland fleet will deliberately flout the quota regulations. 
 Skippers in the Scottish white fish fleet, which accounts for most of the UK's North Sea haddock catch, are particularly aggrieved at the EC's &bquo;swingeing&equo; cut in quota this year. 
 Last year it was 128,500 tonnes, but only 90,000 tonnes were caught. 
 George Sutherland, chairman of the Scottish White Fish Producers Association, said skippers could not afford to remain in harbour, and would have to continue fishing. 
 &bquo;There's no doubt that's going to lead to dumping. 
 That makes a total nonsense of conservation policy. 
 I know it's short-sighted and the politicians will point this out to us, but what alternative have we got?&equo; 
 Mr Sutherland, skipper of the Fraserburgh-based Sanspeur, will lead a delegation today to discuss &bquo;the critical situation&equo; with Lord Sanderson of Bowden, the Scottish Office fisheries minister. 
 It will coincide with the expected appearance at Aberdeen Sheriff Court of 10 fishermen on charges relating to quota breaking. 
 Margaret Ewing MP, the Scottish National Party's parliamentary leader, in a letter to Lord Sanderson, has accused the Government of &bquo;massive complacency&equo; towards the fishing industry. 
 She said that &bquo;vicious adherence to market forces&equo; as a way of reducing the fleet would drive out the youngest and the best. 
 She criticised the Government for not introducing a decommissioning scheme or compensation. 
 &bquo;Good, decent, hard-working men, dedicated to their tough industry, face financial ruin,&equo; she said. 
 The fishermen's response to the crisis will become clearer this week. 
 But they do not believe the solution lies in taking up the 15,000 tonne haddock quota available off the west of Scotland. 
 Mr Sutherland said the waters were dangerous at this time of year and contained almost no haddock. 
 Killer's voice may have been heard on M50 call 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 A RADIO controller probably heard the voice of the killer of Marie Wilks as she telephoned for help from the M50 motorway, a court was told yesterday. 
 Within minutes of making the call, Mrs Wilks, 22, who was pregnant, was dead, having been abducted and then stabbed in broad daylight, the prosecution alleges. 
 Peter Lunnen, who took the call, said at Shrewsbury Crown Court that as he shouted down the telephone line to Mrs Wilks, he heard her speaking in the distance. 
 He heard a male voice, and then the &bquo;throaty&equo; sound of a car speeding away. 
 Her last words to him were &bquo;call my father&equo;. 
 He dispatched a police patrol car, but when it arrived 16 minutes later the telephone was swinging on the end of its cord. 
 &bquo;Of Marie there was no sign. 
 It was as if she had vanished off the face of the earth,&equo; Anthony Palmer, for the prosecution, said. 
 Police found only the broken-down Marina car, which had left Mrs Wilks, her 13-month-old son Mark, and her sister, Georgina Gough, 11, stranded on the M50 near the Tewkesbury turn off. 
 The two children, Mark in Georgina's arms, were spotted along the hard shoulder. 
 A few spots of blood were found near the telephone, Mr Palmer said. 
 But the body of Mrs Wilks was not found until two days later, at the bottom of a motorway embankment two-and-a-half miles away, when a motorist took police to a spot where he had seen a silver Renault 25 parked. 
 Mrs Wilks's body lay twisted, as if she had rolled. 
 There was grass and vegetation in her left hand; her maternity smock was bloodstained from a stab wound in the side of the neck. 
 A post-mortem examination disclosed she had died from a single knife wound, which had severed the artery. 
 Her jaw was also broken from a punch and a kick. 
 Mr Palmer told the jury of eight men and four women that the pathologist also found that she was carrying a normally developed male child of between 30 and 32 weeks. 
 &bquo;She wore no pants, but there was no evidence of sexual interference, whatever her killer's intention may have been,&equo; he said. 
 Edward Browning, 36, a nightclub doorman and bouncer, of Vicarage Road, Cwm-parc, Mid Glamorgan, has denied murdering Mrs Wilks on 18 June last year. 
 The prosecution says he was the driver of the Renault 25. 
 Mr Palmer alleged that in a &bquo;wilful, impulsive and reckless&equo; frame of mind, he abducted, murdered and dumped the body of Mrs Wilks, in a matter of minutes. 
 Mr Palmer said that by any standards her killer's behaviour was extraordinary. 
 &bquo;He must have seen her standing or walking, a lone pregnant woman, as he went past and decided to pick her up.&equo; 
 Witnesses, including an off-duty police inspector, would describe how a silver Renault twice crossed the central reservation to go past the scene of the broken-down car. 
 One saw the driver talking to and touching Mrs Wilks at the emergency telephone box, the silver car parked near by. 
 Mrs Wilks had been visiting her husband, who was spending the weekend at a Territorial Army camp in the Forest of Dean, where he was a civilian instructor. 
 She had got lost, returning to their home in Ambleside Road, Warndon, Worcester, and found herself on the M50. 
 Her car started to overheat and she stopped on the hard shoulder. 
 Leaving her sister and her son in the car, she walked the half-mile to the telephone box. 
 Mr Palmer told the court that Mr Browning admitted being in his car at the time of the killing. 
 He was on his way to visit a friend in Aberdenn, more than 500 miles away. 
 But Mr Browning had told police his route took him via the M4, over the Severn Bridge, and not by the more direct route of the M50. 
 However, Mr Palmer said that a constant video of cars passing over the Severn Bridge at the time, showed no Renault 25. 
 In Scotland, Mr Browning's friend commented about blood on the rear wheel-arch of the Renault. 
 Mr Browning said it was probably a bird he hit on the way, and later cleaned the car. 
 Toxic waste monitoring row settled 
 By RICHARD NORTH, Environment Correspondent 
 THE TWO protagonists in one of the longest-running and most bitter rows about the conduct of Britain's toxic waste disposal industry settled their differences yesterday. 
 Rechem International, a major chemical incineration firm, and Torfaen Borough Council in Gwent, South Wales, agreed in an out of court settlement that a temporary injunction obtained by the company should be lifted. 
 Rechem also agreed to drop its request for a judicial review into Torfaen's monitoring of contamination supposedly caused by the firm, and of its publication of the results. 
 The injunction had forbidden the council from publishing results of monitoring around the site of the firm's incineration plant at Pontypool, which burns chemicals, including PCBs (polychlorinated byphenyls). 
 Rechem believes the results to be unscientific, and under the new agreement will be able to append its own commentary to the council's existing document, especially if it is to form part of a submission to the European Commission. 
 In future, Torfaen council will share with Rechem any samples it takes. 
 Both parties have also agreed that they will nominate representatives to begin discussions on setting up a community liaison committee. 
 Study finds ITV has most violence 
 By RICHARD NORTH, Environment Correspondent 
 PROGRAMMES on ITV contain far more violence than those on the other three channels, according to a psychiatrist. 
 In a study undertaken over a two-week period, Tom Tadecki, research director of the International Coalition Against Violent Entertainment, found that more than 33 per cent of its programmes involved some form of aggression, with violent acts occurring at a rate of 10 per hour. 
 By contrast, 1 per cent of Channel 4 programmes contained violence, with an average frequency of one violent act per hour. 
 The figures for BBC 1 and BBC 2 were 10 per cent, with violent acts occurring at a rate of 2.5 per hour on BBC 1, and two on BBC 2. 
 Although he found that television is far less violent than in Japan, the United States, France or West Germany, Dr Tadecki intends to campaign with Mary Whitehouse to curb violence on the screen. 
 Dr Tadecki said: &bquo;Research in America indicates that someone is up to 50 per cent more likely to lose their temper if they regularly watch violent television programmes such as The Equalizer.&equo; 
 He said he was shocked to monitor Miami Vice, shown on BBC 1, in which characters Crockett and Tubbs killed 43 people in 18 episodes &mdash; more than the real Miami vice department killed in a whole year. 
 Coronation Street, Britain's longest-running and most popular television soap opera which is transmitted on Monday and Wednesday, is to add a Friday edition from 20 October. 
 The Monday edition will be repeated on Wednesday afternoons, with the omnibus edition, incorporating the Wednesday and Friday editions, switching from Sunday to Saturday afternoon. 
 It had appeared for a while that Coronation Street's rival EastEnders, boosted by a weekend omnibus, would oust it from top spot in the ratings. 
 But it has fought back. 
 EastEnders, regarded by senior BBC managers as having lost its way with sordid story lines, is being given a new producer. 
 Barman survived &bquo;cliff-top murder plan&equo; 
 By RICHARD NORTH, Environment Correspondent 
 A BARMAN was pushed over a 200ft cliff after his wife agreed to a &pound;2,500 &bquo;murder contract&equo;, a court was told yesterday. 
 Stephen Brown survived because he landed on a narrow ledge about 18ft below the cliff edge at Sandy Bay, Exmouth, Devon, Charles Barton QC, for the prosecution, said. 
 He waited until his two attackers &mdash; each to be paid &pound;1,000, with &pound;500 expenses &mdash; disappeared in the dark before climbing to safety. 
 Mr Barton told Bristol Crown Court that neighbours of Mr Brown hatched the plot to rid Cathy Brown of her &bquo;unwanted and sometimes violent husband&equo;. 
 James Shaw, 33, unemployed, of Nelson Drive, Littleham, Exmouth, denies conspiring to murder Mr Brown between June 1 and September 14 last year and attempting to murder him between August 13 and 16. 
 James Palmer, a painter, also of Nelson Drive, had earlier pleaded guilty to attempted murder. 
 Garlic &bquo;good for the heart&equo; 
 By LIZ HUNT 
 PEOPLE who eat a clove or more of garlic a day are less likely to suffer a heart attack, high blood pressure or thrombosis, doctors said yesterday, writes Liz Hunt. 
 New clinical trials show that including garlic in the diet can significantly reduce cholesterol in the blood, according to Dr Jorg Grunwald, a research biologist from Berlin. 
 High cholesterol levels are associated with atherosclerosis, or &bquo;furring&equo; of the arteries with fatty deposits, which can lead to a heart attack. 
 Garlic could also reduce high blood pressure and prevent blood cells sticking together, risk factors for a heart attack, Dr Grunwald, head of the medical and scientific department of Lichtwer Pharma, a German company that manufactures garlic pills, said. 
 The active ingredient in garlic is thought to be the compound alliin. 
 Peer &bquo;falsely branded a war criminal&equo; over communist massacre 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 LORD ALDINGTON, a former deputy chairman of the Conservative Party and Warden of Winchester School, was falsely branded a war criminal on the scale of the worst butchers of Nazi Germany and Soviet Russia, his counsel, Charles Gray QC, told a High Court libel jury yesterday. 
 Lord Aldington, 75, is seeking damages from Nigel Watts, a property developer, who circulated a pamphlet accusing him of arranging every detail of the repatriation of 70,000 Yugoslav and Russian men, women and children who were subsequently tortured and massacred. 
 The action is jointly defended by the historian Count Nikolai Tolstoy, who supplied much of the information for the pamphlet. 
 Mr Gray said the fact of the repatriations from Allied-occupied Austria in May and June 1945 was accepted, but what was at issue was Lord Aldington's role, and the allegation that he knew that they would be killed. 
 Mr Watts and Mr Tolstoy deny libel, claiming the allegations are true. 
 Mr Gray, opening his case, explained how the the pamphlet was the culmination of a campaign against the peer by Mr Watts, who was pursuing an unpaid life insurance claim on the death of his brother-in-law in 1975. 
 At the time, Lord Aldington was chairman of Sun Alliance, which had refused the claim on the grounds that the dead man had withheld details about his ill-health. 
 From 1984 on, Mr Watts had repeatedly telephoned Lord Aldington, as many as 28 times in a weekend, and gathered a dossier of other allegedly unpaid claims by Sun Alliance, which he circulated to insurance brokers. 
 By February 1985, he had started to include allegations that Lord Aldington was a war criminal, and had made contact with Count Tolstoy, author of two books on the repatriations. 
 Mr Watts sent 10,000 copies of the pamphlet to MPs, peers, the Press, neighbours of Lord Aldington, the parents of pupils at Winchester and to former pupils, in an attempt to force Lord Aldington's resignation as Warden. 
 The pamphlet said: &bquo;The evidence is overwhelming that he arranged the perpetration of a major war crime in the full knowledge that the most barbarous and dishonourable aspects of his operations were throughout disapproved and unauthorised by the higher command, and in the full knowledge that a savage fate awaited those he was repatriating. 
 The man who issued every order and arranged every detail of the lying and brutality which resulted in these massacres was Brigadier Toby Low&hellip; subsequently ennobled (in 1962) as the first Baron Aldington.&equo; 
 Mr Gray said that Lord Aldington had a distinguished war record. 
 He had won the DSO in 1941 while defending Greece. 
 The citation described him as an officer of extreme gallantry, with the qualities of coolness and high powers of leadership under the most trying circumstances. 
 He had helped in the defence of Crete, and fought with the British Army in Italy and Austria. 
 Mr Gray said that, in February 1945, Britain and Russia had signed an agreement at Yalta under which Soviet citizens would be returned to Russia, and British prisoners of war held in Russia would be returned to Britain. 
 It was accepted that the British troops had used a substantial amount of violence and brutality to enforce the hand-over. 
 Witnesses told of beatings with rifle butts and sticks and the use of bayonets and guns, he said. 
 Many of the Yugoslavs and White Russians handed over were executed without trial by the Titoists and Russians. 
 This was criminal behaviour. 
 Many more were tortured, brutally treated and condemned to labour camps. 
 &bquo;Lord Aldington did not know about the massacre and brutality. 
 He accepts it happened and he is appalled by it,&equo; he said. 
 The hearing continues today. 
 Health test for hatcheries 
 By RICHARD NORTH, Environment Correspondent 
 EGG HATCHERIES will be monitored for salmonella, following a decision yesterday to tighten controls on the bacterium which has caused a rising tide of food poisoning cases in recent years. 
 The Ministry of Agriculture had imposed monitoring on breeding flocks &mdash; which supply the hatcheries with eggs, which go on to be egg laying hens or meat producing poultry &mdash; and on laying flocks. 
 The hatcheries have until now been the missing link. 
 &bquo;The idea of the new move is to get away from the possibilities of cross-contamination&equo;, a ministry spokeswoman said. 
 There will also be a new requirement for owners to register all flocks of layers containing more than 100 birds, and of breeding flocks containing more than 25 birds. 
 John Gummer, the Minister of Agriculture, yesterday defended the testing of birds even in the smallest laying flocks. 
 &bquo;The testing of all hens will continue to be compulsory if their eggs are sold to the public, however small the enterprise. 
 Our new sampling system uses the birds&equo; faeces and provides the same high level of protection. 
 It is done on a 12-week cycle and will lead to a reduction in the cost for a producer with, say, 60 hens, to about &pound;24 over the laying period. 
 The present system, which is not more effective, costs &pound;110 for the same result. 
 &bquo;I believe that the public must have absolute confidence in the British egg industry. 
 That is why I cannot exempt even the smallest flocks selling eggs for human consumption from our strict testing requirements.&equo; 
 Annesley dismisses RUC &bquo;inner circle&equo; claim as nonsense 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 HUGH ANNESLEY, Chief Constable of the Royal Ulster Constabulary, dismissed as &bquo;arrant nonsense&equo; yesterday the idea that a conspiratorial group of pro-loyalist politically-motivated officers existed within his force. 
 He was responding to Monday's claim in the Belfast Irish News that at least three dozen officers were members of a secret &bquo;inner circle&equo; which had the objects of &bquo;removing&equo; republican suspects and bringing down the Anglo-Irish agreement. 
 Mr Annesley's strongly-worded statement came as the agreement ran into yet another patch of stormy weather, with Dublin taking exception to remarks made by Peter Brooke, the Northern Ireland Secretary, about the Ulster Defence Regiment. 
 This latest dispute between the two governments indicates that tomorrow's Anglo-Irish ministerial meeting in London may prove difficult. 
 There were three official assurances yesterday that the inquiry by John Stevens, Deputy Chief Constable of Cambridgeshire, into security force collusion with loyalists is proceeding apace. 
 Mr Annesley said his senior officers were &bquo;rigorously assisting&equo; Mr Stevens, while Mr Brooke said the investigation was going on in a &bquo;thoroughly effective&equo; way. 
 Mr Stevens asserted that he had received the total support of Mr Annesley, his senior officers and all levels of the force. 
 &bquo;The investigation is being conducted vigorously and I am confident that that will become publicly clear in due course.&equo; 
 In his statement, Mr Annesley attacked Seamus Mallon, the SDLP MP who is regarded by members of the force as its most unremitting political critic. 
 &bquo;Mr Mallon stated that I was embarked on sweeping the RUC very clean and inferred for that reason that some senior people within the force did not wish that approach to continue. 
 I utterly repudiate that inference.&equo; 
 He said that while he viewed the &bquo;inner circle&equo; story as nonsense, the allegations could not be ignored and he had asked Mr Stevens to investigate. 
 Irish police believe they have foiled a major IRA kidnap attempt led by Patrick Sheehy, who is wanted for questioning in connection with the discovery in December of bomb-making materials in Clapham, south London. 
 He has now been positively identified by detectives as one of two men who hijacked a police car when traffic patrol officers checked out a suspect van in Co Limerick three weeks ago. 
 Army experts last night defused a land-mine packed with a hatchet head, knives, forks and nails at Dungannon, Co Tyrone. 
 Police divers also recovered a quantity of ammunition and a large collection of gun parts from a reservoir at Dungiven, Co Londonderry. 
 Funeral of Royal Marines bandsman killed at Deal Barracks 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 The flag-draped coffin of Musician Richard &bquo;Taff&equo; Jones, 27, one of the 10 Royal Marines bandsmen killed by IRA bombers at Deal, Kent, being carried from the barracks church, St Michael and All Angels, after a joint funeral service for him and Musician Bob Simmonds, 34. 
 There was also a service for Band Corporal David McMillan, 26. 
 Walk back in time 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 John Evans, 112, Britain's oldest man was asked to give evidence at a public inquiry to help prove a footpath linking Fforest-fach and Gowerton in West Glamorgan, has always been public. 
 &bquo;Eye&equo; damages 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 Teresa Gorman, Conservative MP for Billericay, accepted undisclosed libel damages at the High Court in London against the satirical magazine Private Eye. 
 On 27 May 1988 the magazine published an account of a social occasion at Mrs Gorman's flat, attributing to her an &bquo;unseemly and offensive&equo; remark. 
 Lead free 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 Nearly 19,000 motorists converted their cars to lead-free petrol on the AA's automobile association nationwide adjustment days last week. 
 Mother &bquo;peaceful&equo; 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 Colin Barnett, the husband of Aisling Barnett, the liver transplant patient, said she was still in a coma and looking &bquo;quite peaceful&equo; after her 11-hour operation. 
 Mrs Barnett, 35, suffered acute liver failure after a rare reaction to a drug. 
 Bail seized 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 Magistrates in Harwich, Essex, confiscated &pound;725,000 in cash after Jai Benie, 37, a rice importer, failed to answer bail on &pound;1.3m fraud charges. 
 They also ordered &pound;25,000 surety to be seized. 
 It is believed to be Britain's largest bail forfeiture. 
 Vauxhall strike 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 Car workers at Vauxhall's Luton plant staged an unofficial walk-out in protest at the company's 7.5 per cent pay offer. 
 Unions are claiming a &pound;25 a week. 
 Sunday editor 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 The Daily Telegraph appointed Trevor Grove as its Sunday editor. 
 The announcement makes clear that the newspaper group is moving towards a seven-day-a-week operation. 
 The announcement comes six days before staff are told of proposals to merge most of the two groups of journalists, involving redundancies. 
 Captain fined over oil spill 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 The Greek captain of a ship responsible for Sunday's oil spill in the Solent was fined &pound;3,500. 
 More than 400 birds were coated with oil when 50 tonnes of crude oil spilled out from an opened valve as the Cypriot-registered tanker Worthy discharged her cargo at Fawley Refinery. 
 Lymington magistrates found Captain Antoniades Ionnes guilty of negligence. 
 He was ordered to pay &pound;350 costs. 
 Government to curb acid house parties 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 The Government is today expected to announce moves to stop acid house parties, Virginia Bottomley, the environment minister, said last night. 
 She told the Association of District Councils' housing conference in Southampton she would announce a review of the regulations to see how such parties could be controlled. 
 Meanwhile the BBC have refused to hand over film of alleged rioting at an acid house party without a court order. 
 Surrey police say the film would help identify participants at the weekend party, near Reigate, Surrey, where 16 police were injured. 
 Speelman blunder &bquo;fatal&equo; 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON 
 JONATHAN Speelman endured a dismal day in the Pilkington Glass World Chess Championship semi-final at the Sadler's Wells in central London yesterday, losing the second game of his match against Jan Timman. 
 After his fine defensive effort in the opening game, Speelman's supporters had high expectations for the second game, in which he had the white pieces, but it all went horribly wrong. 
 After a quiet opening, Speelman committed a simple blunder, losing a piece for two pawns. 
 The game stuttered on to move 31, when the English Grandmaster resigned. 
 In his successful quarter-final match against Nigel Short last year, Speelman seemed full of energy and surprising ideas. 
 But so far, against Timman, he has unusually restrained and conventional, showing little of his usual creativity. 
 In both games, the Dutchman has sprung surprises in the opening. 
 After winning the second game, Timman immediately offered a draw in the unfinished opening game of the match. 
 Analysis had shown that, in spite of an extra pawn, he held no serious prospect of a win. 
 Timman now leads 1&frac12; to &frac12; with six games left to play. 
 In the other semi-final, Artur Yusupov and Anatoly Karpov, the former world champion, drew an explosive and entertaining game. 
 Yusupov was surprisingly aggressive with the black pieces, launching a quick attack. 
 With dangerous sacrifices threatening, and black knights cantering around his king, Karpov looked in trouble, but he defended accurately and a draw was agreed at move 33. 
 Both matches resume tomorrow. 
 The first game between Yusupov and Karpov had been a solid draw, with the position staying near to equality throughout. 
 Grandmasters were a little surprised by Yusupov's decision to surrender his bishop for a knight on move 22, but the resulting position never looked like ending in anything other than a draw. 
 Botham scores with warmth and honesty 
 By DAVID LISTER, Arts Correspondent 
 IAN BOTHAM, cricket's most entertaining all rounder, showed last night that as a comedian he is a great batsman and an even better bowler. 
 But he was able to overwhelm an audience of devotees by genuine warmth and frankness. 
 Discarded by England for their tour of the West Indies, Botham has launched an alternative and considerably more lucrative winter career, a grandly titled &bquo;Lecture Tour&equo; of Britain. 
 At Stourbridge Town Hall in the West Midlands last night, where Botham began his tour, those who came instead of a night out at the pictures were somewhat surprised to find themselves treated to a night out at the pictures. 
 The entire first half consisted of film of Botham's greatest moments, liberally interspersed with more film of him drinking the sponsor's lager. 
 But in the final hour he did deliver the goods, taking impromptu questions from the audience. 
 Not that it was going to be easy to improve on the earlier filmed interview when, asked why he rarely practised in the nets, he replied: &bquo;I don't like confined spaces.&equo; 
 One was tempted to applaud such spontaneous wit, but serious faces all around showed that this was not meant in jest. 
 He came closer to jest, though perhaps not close enough, when asked about his favourite curry: &bquo;I wish I had got that many runs this summer.&equo; 
 And whether his relationship with Ted Dexter, the chairman of selectors, was like Cane and Abel: &bquo;No, we're not that close.&equo; 
 What did emerge though was a personable and seemingly deeply caring young man, claiming not to understand why sportsmen could not go to South Africa but could go to India, which imported South African gold. 
 He was asked whether he thought he would get back his record for taking the most Test wickets. 
 &bquo;Probably not,&equo; he replied wistfully. 
 &bquo;You have to play for England to get the records.&equo; 
 One felt the full house would have preferred him a few thousand miles away this winter, rather than on the cabaret circuit. 
 US arrests mural artist 
 By DAVID LISTER, Arts Correspondent 
 GERARD KELLY, a well-known Belfast mural artist, is to appear in court in New York today in an apparent crackdown on Irish republicans with prison records who enter the US illegally. 
 Mr Kelly, who was expected to paint the portraits of the IRA trio killed by the SAS in Gibraltar and possibly the IRA fugitive Joseph Doherty, was arrested upon arrival from Ireland. 
 Mr Kelly, 32, who has been fighting deportation from Ireland to Britain for seven years, was invited by a left-wing publishing house to help complete a mural of revolutionary figures whose works and writings it publishes. 
 He is accused of making a false statement prior to entering the US, which carries a sentence of up to five years in jail. 
 He has been jailed for explosives offences in Ulster and has previously been denied a visa. 
 DAY OUT / Fields of human conflict: David Keys on permanent reminders of the Second World War&hellip; 
 By DAVID KEYS 
 The 50th anniversary of the outbreak of the Second World War has largely been an armchair affair, commemorated in newspapers and magazines, on the radio and television. 
 However, outside your sitting room thousands of wartime military installations still survive as historically important reminders of Britain's epic struggle. 
 Fighter and Bomber Command airfields, anti tank defences, gun emplacements, prisoner of war camps &mdash; and some 6,000 pillboxes still form part of the landscape in many areas of the country. 
 In the heart of London's Whitehall visitors can explore the warren of cramped underground rooms and passageways which served as the nerve centre of Britain's war effort. 
 Known as the Cabinet War Rooms, the complex has only been open to the public since 1983. 
 Inside, one can still see the Map Room, where Churchill used to study the progress of the war, the Cabinet Room where many of the Second World War's most important decisions were made, and Churchill's personal accommodation from which he made several of his wartime broadcasts. 
 In the space of 12 months the War Office built 25,000 pillboxes &mdash; almost a quarter of which still survive &mdash; and erected hundreds of miles of concrete anti-tank defences. 
 On windswept lonely Chesil Beach &mdash; that great ten mile long pile of pebbles which stretches westwards along the Dorset coast from Portland &mdash; one can still explore the pillboxes and anti-tank defences which were built in 1940 to resist the threat of invasion. 
 And later in the war, in 1943, it was this imposing natural wall of shingle which was used by the famous Dambusters as a practice target before their attack on the Mohne and Eder dams in Germany. 
 Fifty miles inland, the remains of the wartime government's fall-back line of defence still survives, mostly along the line of the Kennett-Avon canal. 
 Between Bradford-on-Avon and Reading are some 200 pillboxes built in 1940 to house mobile two pound anti-tank guns and machine guns in the event of invasion. 
 The recesses in the pillbox floors where the guns would have fitted are still there today. 
 The various different types of pillbox can be seen from the canal towpath. 
 Larger scale gun emplacements, however, are much rarer. 
 The only surviving group of such installations can be explored at Curry Mallet near Taunton, Somerset, where three large gun emplacements with three-foot-thick concrete walls were built to house six-pounder anti-tank guns with a range of half a mile. 
 Nearby are pillboxes designed to accommodate heavy machine guns. 
 This formed part of a defence line erected to defend Britain in the event of a German establishment of a beach head in Cornwall. 
 But in the end the Battle of Britain was not fought on the land, but in the air. 
 Today, one of the original air operations planning rooms is still preserved intact. 
 At Duxford airfield, the operations table from which aspects of the Battle of Britain were controlled can be seen along with the original control tower, hangar and runway. 
 A similar air-war tracking table -with different symbols for British and German aircraft &mdash; can be seen at the Royal Observer Corps Museum in Winchester. 
 It was the ROC's job to pass flight tracking information over to the RAF. 
 At aircraft museums like those at Hendon and Duxford visitors can see the legendary Spitfire and Hurricane fighters. 
 The only large British World War Two surface warship to have survived to the present day, HMS Belfast, is located on the Thames, just west of Tower Bridge. 
 Visitors can wander round the vessel and explore everything from the engine room to the galley and from the bridge to the gun turrets. 
 The Belfast helped sink the German battleship Scharnhorst off Norway in 1943 and led the naval bombardment in support of the Normandy D Day landing at Juno Beach. 
 At the Imperial War Museum, wartime historians have recreated a London street as it would have looked during the Blitz. 
 The full horror which Londoners had to endure is commemorated in the re-creation &mdash; complete with the sounds of anti-aircraft fire and the acrid smell of burning buildings. 
 Harwich, Roughs Fort 7 miles out at sea (viewable with binoculars). 
 Kennet and Avon Canal, Avon Long pillbox defence line. 
 Margate, Tongue Sand Fort 10 miles out tosea. 
 Shoeburyness, Red Sand Fort 5 miles out tosea. 
 REGIONAL THEATRE / West of the West End: Paul Arnott tracks Shadowlands from Plymouth to London 
 By PAUL ARNOTT 
 As Elijah Moshinsky looked out from the roof-top coffee shop of the plush hotel overlooking Plymouth Hoe &mdash; in which he is ensconced during rehearsals of Shadowlands &mdash; he confessed that this was the first time he had been to Plymouth in his life. 
 As a star opera director whose career is becoming increasingly orientated towards the theatre, it is understandable that he hasn't often found the time to stray from the great metropolises to mount a production. 
 Yet here he was, a man who is a reasonable outside bet for the vacant crown at the RSC, reading favourable reviews for his previous work, Another Time with Albert Finney (which had opened the night before in the West End), and preparing to rehearse in a Methodist Hall in the middle of Wesley country. 
 Waiting in the Methodist Hall to rehearse the roles of CS Lewis and the woman he spent three blissful years with before her death, Joy Davidman, were Nigel Hawthorne and Jane Lapotaire, another pair of stars not usually to be found out west. 
 The Theatre Royal, Plymouth, is about to send a highly commercial product into the West End. 
 For Elijah Moshinsky, there are great advantages to starting a show out of town. 
 &bquo;It seems to me that a new play like Shadowlands needs to be exposed to different audiences before it settles down. 
 It's especially important in a play like this, which is such a delicate and sensitive piece of writing, that the actors grow together as a cohesive group. 
 I think that it is much easier to create that atmosphere in a good out-of-town theatre like Plymouth rather than to prepare a star vehicle in a draughty rehearsal room somewhere in London.&equo; 
 If theatre artists of this calibre are prepared to launch a production from Plymouth, it seems a fair bet that the Theatre Royal management has got its act together. 
 As Moshinsky went off to rehearsals, I headed back to the office of the General Manager, Andrew Welch. 
 Welch is the first to admit that when the Theatre Royal opened in 1982 it was widely regarded as a white elephant, which quickly became little more than a stopping off point for second-rate touring products. 
 But since his arrival at the theatre five years ago he has worked with the artistic director, Roger Redfarn, to make full use of his evident skills in business management. 
 Under Welch and Redfarn, The Theatre Royal has co-funded productions with other theatrical managements and a consortium of West Country businessmen, embracing such shows as Up On The Roof, Brigadoon and the about-to-open Buddy, as well as working with touring companies such as Paines Plough to launch a national tour of The Art Of Success. 
 With Shadowlands, another co-funded production, Plymouth ventures into the area of the commercial straight play which may well lead to more similar productions of new work. 
 Welch believes that if regional theatres are to grow they will have to learn from his example, and seek the backing of local businessmen as well as the more traditional sources of commercial theatrical managements. 
 As I left his office a young woman from a Polish theatre company came in to discuss with Welch the principles of controlling &bquo;income streams&equo;. 
 Stage News 
 By PAUL ARNOTT 
 Direct from the Chichester Festival Theatre, Ian Judge's elegant production of A Little Night Music comes into the Piccadilly Theatre in preview from 6 Oct, opening on 11 Oct. 
 Peter McEnery and Dorothy Tutin (above) play the middle-aged ex-lovers who iron out the wrinkles and get together just in time for the final curtain. 
 The Independent can offer ten pairs of free tickets for Mon 9 Oct to the first ten readers who phone 01-436 0605 today (between 10am and 10.30am only) with the answer to the following question: which film is A Little Night Music based on? 
 A heartfelt plea to any theatre proprietors who have a venue available during November. 
 Laura Thompson is a young theatre director who is now in the middle of rehearsals for Romeo And Juliet. 
 Alas, Thompson and her chosen theatre were star-crossed and she now has a production but nowhere to stage it. 
 If you have a London theatre with a gap left in the November schedule, phone Laura Thompson on 01-969 6524. 
 Late news of an extra platform interview at the National to be held in the Cottesloe Theatre on Friday 6 Oct at 6.00. 
 Jenni Murray will be interviewing the excellent American actor Ed Asner (above) who, although best known to Brits as Lou Grant, has been involved in numerous political movements. 
 He is in England filming Not A Penny More, Not A Penny Less. 
 Tickets, priced &pound;2.50, are available from the National box office on 01-928 2252. 
 THEATRE / Lady Betty &mdash; Wilde Theatre, Bracknell 
 By LOUISE LEVENE 
 &bquo;What has Lady Betty done? 
 Why does blood seep from her son?&equo; runs the grisly ballad that tells the true story of a woman in 18th century Ireland, sentenced to death for the murder of a young gentleman who turns out to be the long-lost product of her liaison with the English gentry. 
 The sentence is commuted to a life within prison walls when she volunteers to hang those due to swing beside her. 
 &bquo;Lady&equo; Betty pursued a career of hanging and flogging well into the 19th century and Declan Donnellan's account of her life is told with a distressing mixture of savagery and sentiment; the hangwoman herself is portrayed by Sally Dexter with hateful harpiness relieved by startling moments of tenderness. 
 The play is enlivened by the vicious energy of the performances and by a variety of Irish music and dance which ranges from mournful ballads to the jolliest of jigs, transforming what could have been a dreary harangue into an invigorating ensemble work. 
 Louise Levene 
 THEATRE / Patricia Routledge in Come for the Ride - Greenwich Theatre 
 By KATHRYN MEAD 
 One-man shows are the high-wire acts of theatrical repertory, and all too often performers miss the trapeze. 
 In this case, however, the performer is Patricia Routledge, and such is the assurance of her grasp that the occasion is a masterclass in theatrical craft. 
 The cloying PR bills the evening as &bquo;unashamedly nostalgic&equo;. 
 This it is, but the miracle is not that Patricia Routledge can make the old weep with &bquo;Roses of Picardy&equo;, but that she can still move the young with it. 
 No actress alive better captures the ferocious pathos of the little heartbreak writ large, and although her immaculate comic technique sustains whole passages of visual lunacy, she has in addition the much rarer theatrical gift of being able to transmit emotion in its purest form. 
 The highlight of the evening is a heartstopping extract from Alan Bennett. 
 Here is sentiment salvaged by wit, rapture lit with an inner grace. 
 And, in Patricia Routledge, a real treasure. 
 THEATRE / The Astronomer's Garden, Royal Court, SW1. 
 By SARAH HEMMING 
 The Astronomer's Garden, Royal Court, SW1. 
 A play about rival 17th-century astronomers sounds like an arid evening's theatre &mdash; which is partly the point of Kevin Hood's piece. 
 While its base is the vicious rivalry between Flamsteed (Trevor Baxter, above) and Halley calculating longitude, its true subjects are sex, class and the real world they cannot catalogue. 
 Hood paints the two, irresistibly, as bombastic old sticks, but the play's real strength is its exploration of relationships, showing how Flamsteed's wife and maid navigate male ego-infested waters. 
 He works huge ideas about reason and feeling into a witty pastiche of Restoration comedy, and Croydon Warehouse's production is excellent. 
 Locked into poverty by poor language 
 By JANET DALEY 
 SOME months ago I saw a television documentary on hostels for young homeless people in London. 
 The voice-over described the need for accommodation for the thousands of unemployed youngsters who pour hopefully into London every year, while the camera panned around the sparse but well-kept lodgings. 
 We found ourselves in the kitchen where a well-groomed girl was washing up - one of the tasks for which residents were responsible in this co-operative household. 
 As the narrator explained that &bquo;Jane would soon have to move on&equo;, because she was reaching the limit of her maximum stay in the council-owned hostel, we watched her rinse the sink, wipe the draining board and hang up the dishcloth. 
 After the hostel, the voice persevered, the future for Jane looked bleak. 
 She had no prospect of a job and, without even a roof over her head, she was an automatic candidate for cardboard city &mdash; the community of derelicts who survive on the capital's streets, in danger of sinking into a subculture of drugs and crime. 
 I was frankly suspicious. 
 Why should this presentable, able-bodied girl who seemed so willing and meticulous in carrying out her chores, find herself in such a hopeless position? 
 Surely London employers were suffering from a desperate shortage of school-leavers? 
 Even without paper qualifications, a well-motivated young girl should be able to find work as a shop assistant, a waitress, an office junior. 
 There had to be some missing piece to Jane's story. 
 Then she was interviewed. 
 Out of the mouth of this serious, pretty girl came an impenetrable, sub-literate provincial dialect. 
 As it happens, it was Geordie in origin but it might equally well have been Liverpool or Sheffield. 
 Jane was not without either self-respect or sincerity. 
 She was not even inarticulate in the sense that she could express her own feelings convincingly. 
 She was just very nearly unintelligible and her speech was full of that idiomatic ungrammaticalness which characterises the true dialect speaker. 
 Her 12 years of compulsory schooling had left her exactly where they had found her &mdash; locked into the social and economic limitations of the milieu in which she was born. 
 Who was responsible for this pleasant girl being effectively unemployable? 
 Educational dogmatists who insist that middle-class values (and hence, speech) must not be foisted on working-class children; a society which has never had any real commitment to the idea of education as a key to social mobility; guilt-ridden liberal sentimentality about working-class cultural identity. 
 Complacency about teaching people to speak their own language has passed through many historical phases in Britain. 
 When education in the true sense existed only for the inheriting classes, acceptable spoken English was something one was raised with at home. 
 When the public schools were created to educate the children of the middle classes (as opposed to the aristocracy, who were educated by tutors) they could inculcate a more formalised standard English which would equip their pupils for empire, civil service and the cosmopolitan professions. 
 For the rest, standards of literacy were offered which were appropriate to the needs of an industrial workforce. 
 As compulsory state education absorbed the higgledy-piggledy assortment of church, charity and board grammar schools which had emerged over the 200 or so years of industrial Britain, the essentially utilitarian character of schooling was never quite extinguished. 
 Unlike the Calvinist idea of education which prevails in the United States where education is seen as essential to an informed, participating democratic citizenry, British education existed to produce people who would occupy certain slots in a structure. 
 Schooling was to train you for some largely predetermined end, whether it was a middle or a working-class one, not to equip you with the flexible, self-determining wherewithal for an open-ended future. 
 Hence, the traditional indifference (now obscured by educational theorists' cant) to the need to give children the uniquely essential means for social liberation: an ability to speak and write their own language correctly. 
 I am not talking here about accents. 
 There is no need to enforce a certain form of pronunciation on the varying regions of Britain (although the dropped &bquo;h&equo; is a borderline case &mdash; it is probably sufficiently stigmatising to require correction). 
 It is systematically ungrammatical colloquial speech which embeds people in their feudal ancestry. 
 American schools are widely criticised in Britain for their &bquo;authoritarian&equo; teaching of spoken and written language. 
 The rigidity of American standards is closely related to the seriousness with which meritocracy and classlessness are taken as ideals. 
 For the United States, the assimilation of wave after wave of immigrants into an egalitarian society was more than a pious hope. 
 It was an economic and political necessity. 
 It is only in the last generation that British education has begun to grasp the idea that schooling should maximise the opportunity of every individual child. 
 It was a cruel irony that that this movement coincided with a muddled, patronising reluctance to admit that working-class life was culturally impoverished. 
 Self-improvement and upward mobility became suspect in the general Sixties backlash against bourgeois materialism. 
 As a result, those at the bottom of the social heap were abandoned in a perverse kind of educational apartheid. 
 People like Jane are left to pay the price. 
 Smacking &mdash; a mother's dilemma: How should a child be punished? 
 Lee Rodwell on the conflicting views that leave her feeling muddled and guilty 
 By LEE RODWELL 
 MY MOTHER smacked me. 
 I smack my children. 
 The difference is that she never felt guilty about it, whereas I, who have devoured baby and child books since my first pregnancy test was positive, do. 
 I feel guilty because the current childcare experts tell me that &mdash; in the words of Penelope Leach (psychologist and author of the classic Baby and Child) &mdash; smacking is wrong. 
 That it is a short-cut to nowhere. 
 That, far from producing better disciplined people, smacking makes it much more difficult to teach children how to behave. 
 Yet parents who smack their children are far more common than those who do not. 
 John and Elizabeth Newson, authors of a report into the extent of parental punishment in the UK published yesterday, say: &bquo;The majority of British parents interviewed seems to believe that physical punishment is an inevitable and probably necessary aspect of ordinary child upbringing.&equo; 
 The message behind the report is that the majority of parents has got it all wrong. 
 The research, carried out over 30 years by the joint directors of the Child Development Research Unit at Nottingham University, shows that two-thirds of babies are smacked before the age of one, that three-quarters of four-year-olds are smacked once a week or more, and that by the age of seven, 22 per cent have been hit with implements. 
 By the age of seven, differences between boys and girls have emerged, with boys being more likely to be smacked once a week than girls. 
 The report has been published by Approach (the Association to Protect All Children Ltd), a new charity linked to Epoch (End Physical Punishment of Children), a national campaign which was launched in April. 
 When I read the Epoch literature I am always convinced by it. 
 Epoch says you should withdraw your attention when faced with a tiresome child. 
 If the behaviour cannot be ignored and it makes you cross, say so. 
 Talk, scream, walk out of the room, send the child out of the room &mdash; but do not smack. 
 It is only later, when I am faced with real life, that the theories no longer seem so reasonable. 
 Lynette Burrows agrees. 
 A teacher and mother of six children (the youngest is now 12), she used to run a playschool and was also a registered childminder. 
 A new edition of her book, Good Children, is being published this autumn. 
 She says: &bquo;These theories bear no relation to what children are really like. 
 Take the point about withdrawing attention. 
 For someone like me with a lot of children it would be like running a penal colony. 
 &bquo;You'd have to remember who you weren't speaking to, who was on fatigues. 
 Why should you have to go round with a frozen face because a child has kicked the cat? 
 It creates an unpleasant atmosphere for the other children and you are effectively punishing yourself. 
 &bquo;For some children it would give them the opportunity to wreak mayhem, while other, more sensitive children would be deeply affected out of all proportion to what they had done. 
 Smacking, on the other hand, is a short, sharp shock. 
 &bquo;As for saying that smacking can escalate into abuse, surely that's true of emotional punishment too. 
 If you are too stupid to know when to draw the line physically then you will be too stupid to know when to stop emotionally as well. 
 &bquo;It's absolute piffle to say that smacking children teaches them that using violence is OK. 
 There are two kinds of violence &mdash; good or bad. 
 It's the difference between the person who knocks you down to take your purse and the person who knocks him down to come to your rescue.&equo; 
 Burrows believes that smacking is as necessary as kissing and cuddling, and finds it ironic that the same kind of arguments about parents not knowing when to stop are used to undermine our instincts in both cases. 
 She says: &bquo;Smacking is a way of educating the aggressive instincts of children. 
 Aggression isn't something children learn from their parents, they are born with it. 
 I've talked to some of my son's teachers about bullying in schools and they say that these children whom no one has ever laid a finger on cannot imagine the pain they inflict on others. 
 &bquo;The other point is that once you have established a good system of discipline, you don't have to smack very often. 
 My children were rarely smacked after the age of nine or 10. 
 They knew the limits.&equo; 
 Burrows also believes that smacking can be started at an early age. 
 She disagrees with Leach's statement that &bquo;two-year-olds cannot be good or naughty on purpose because they do not yet know right from wrong or understand what makes the difference&equo;. 
 Burrows says: &bquo;You can have a one-year-old on your lap who discovers it is possible to stick a pencil up your nose. 
 One child will respond to the idea of not hurting mummy. 
 Another will want to do it again anyway for the effect. 
 These children are not wicked or evil &mdash; but the love of power is there.&equo; 
 Nor does she see anything wrong in smacking a toddler who is having a tantrum. 
 Smacking, says Leach, will not help the toddler's anger, frustration and fear, which create tantrums in the first place. 
 But Burrows counters: &bquo;Children need the security of knowing they have a mother who is bigger and stronger than they are, who is in control.&equo; 
 Child psychiatrist Dr John Pearce, author of a number of books about the role of parents, including the recently published Bad Behaviour, is one expert who tries to tread the middle ground. 
 While accepting that smacking is universal, he believes there are better methods of teaching children what is acceptable or unacceptable behaviour. 
 He says that &bquo;when children have limited communication and language skills, you often need to reinforce what you say to them in a physical form. 
 So when you remove a young child's hand from an electric plug you tap the back of it and accompany this action with a firm NO. 
 &bquo;Equally I believe that you should stop using smacking as a way of punishing a child when that child is big enough to hit you back &mdash; and that's at quite an early age. 
 If you continue to smack a two-year-old you are likely to make him more physical, you are effectively telling him that smacking (ie, hitting people) is OK.&equo; 
 That view is reinforced by the Newsons, who say: &bquo;The measures that stand out as the most predictive of criminal record before 20 years are having been smacked or beaten once or more a week at 11, and having a mother with a high commitment to formal physical punishment at that age.&equo; 
 And although the Newsons concede the chicken and egg possibility &mdash; do you smack a child because he is delinquent, or is he delinquent because he is smacked? &mdash; they argue that their findings do not support the old belief that sparing the rod spoils the child, but suggest that at the very least, mothers who smack do not succeed in producing non-delinquent children. 
 So where does all that leave me? 
 Muddled, mostly. 
 Probably with two juvenile delinquents (now aged five and eight) in the offing. 
 Burrows makes me feel slightly less guilty, and the less guilt, the better - for me and the children. 
 As a mother I warm to someone who observes that so many of the modern theories on childcare &bquo;show utter contempt for women's judgement&equo;, and who points out that, when it comes to smacking, &bquo;if we were talking about any other activity which was so widespread, people would say this was a method which was tried and tested and obviously worked. 
 Do these experts really think that mothers are so inept that they would go on doing something that is so ineffective?&equo; 
 Perhaps I should leave the last word to my son. 
 Asked about my smacking him, he said: &bquo;I don't like it,&equo; adding, &bquo;It doesn't hurt. 
 It's better when you send me to my room when I'm naughty. 
 Then I can play with my toys&equo;. 
 Hardly the ultimate deterrent? 
 Baby and Child by Penelope Leach is published by Penguin; The Extent of Physical Punishment in the UK by John and Elizabeth Newson is published by Approach; Bad Behaviour by Dr John Pearce is published by Thorsons; Good Children by Lynette Burrows is published by Newpoint Publishing. 
 A common or garden dispute: Peter Dunn and his beech hedge are maturing after a boundary battle 
 By PETER DUNN 
 A BEECH hedge, we thought, would be just the job. 
 A joy for all seasons, a haven for blackbird and robin and a screen between ourselves and our neighbours that we might go about our separate business unobserved. 
 Nobody, after all, moves to the country to share the kind of backyard intimacy readily available to mock-Tudor freeholders in the suburbs. 
 Autumn saw the planting of the bushes. 
 Spindly creatures barely 18ins tall, fertilised with optimism, they formed a picket line 150ft long up the garden's steep slope to a field of grazing horses. 
 &bquo;My surveyor says you'll have to move some of those bushes,&equo; said my neighbour cheerily. 
 &bquo;They're on my land.&equo; 
 And thus a boundary dispute was born. 
 The burgeoning of the property-owning democracy and the flight of refugees from city life has turned boundary disputing in the country into a sport on a scale comparable with fox-hunting or skittling. 
 The only difference, as any apple-cheeked country solicitor will tell you, is that in boundary disputing the only winners are apple-cheeked country solicitors who collect large fees from pushy incomers unable to live at peace with one another. 
 In the old days, when land was concentrated in the hands of the few, sensible rights of way were established between cottages tied to the Big House in order that Yeoman A could get to the pump shared with Yeoman B; Yeoman B, hurrying about his master's affairs, could cross Yeoman A's garden to get to the shed where the gaffer's carts were kept. 
 Since the freehold all belonged to the boss, wrangling over ownership was beside the point. 
 Also, I suspect, the real country people were better disposed towards each other, materially poorer perhaps, but richer in consideration and manners. 
 The battles and skirmishes of middle-class rural boundary disputing are of interest only to their panting protagonists. 
 Few of us, driven by the irrepressible instincts of the Stone Age, are capable of recognising that shifting your hedge is rather like moving the sitting room furniture around. 
 No one else notices, but it alters the way you go about things. 
 In the normal course of building and landscaping, the division between two adjoining cottages is marked by the internal wall which separates the two dwellings. 
 Twenty years ago, in all innocence, the occupant of my house stuck up a little fence, 15ft long, inside his own boundary. 
 It has left one of my downstairs windows stranded next door with a Cyclopean view of the neighbours, occasional week-enders, sun-bathing on their colourful suites of beach furniture. 
 The rest of the boundary was, until the beech hedge, unmarked. 
 Running along its dandelioned, rag-worted length, however, was next door's right of way, the classic ingredient of a truly ferocious, utterly trivial boundary war. 
 Boundary disputing is a demeaning sport. 
 It drains humanity of its humour, reduces adults' behaviour to that of petulant children. 
 My neighbour would patrol his right of way from time to time, an absurdly dignified figure in his familiar DIY boiler suit and woolly hat. 
 One evening, perched in his landing window, he shot towards my wife with an air rifle and I reported him to the police. 
 I put up an entirely illegal barbed wire fence. 
 He tore it down. 
 We faced each other across 12 ludicrous inches of disputed Dorset couch grass breathing stertorously. 
 Two years on and &pound;1,000 poorer (I've had to foot his costs to buy him off my land) the lawyers have patched up some sort of agreement. 
 Next door has given up a right of way that goes nowhere. 
 The beech hedge is trying to set an example by maturing. 
 Boundary disputing is more than demeaning; it is also expensive. 
 What has emerged in my neck of the woods is how common such conflicts have become in the newly-prosperous backyards of rural Britain. 
 There is a corker gathering steam not far from my cottage over the siting of a compost heap. 
 In the next village, where neighbours were quarrelling over a shared driveway, the judge pleaded with them, in vain, to go away and spend their money on a sea cruise. 
 The case cost the loser &pound;10,000. 
 He also sold up and left because the only alternative in these miserable circumstances is to spend the rest of your life living next door to someone who will never speak to you again. 
 The judge was, of course, right. 
 Most rural boundary disputes have their roots in the lackadaisical practices of country solicitors who never placed much importance on proper searches. 
 &bquo;Everyone wants to defend what they've got,&equo; one of them says. 
 &bquo;And what they've got is a legacy from the old days, all those little terraced cottages which never had boundaries at the back. 
 Over the last 20 years people have been buying as opposed to renting and once they own something they want to keep it separate. 
 The problems arise through what I call &bquo;rural conveyancing&equo; because years ago such conveyancing wasn't done with the necessary attention to detail.&equo; 
 Perhaps it would be better if the sport of boundary disputing was taken out of the hands of lawyers who are, by nature, adversarial. 
 This seems to be the view of Lord Donaldson, that truly sagacious Master of the Rolls, who has just called for a new corps of paralegal &bquo;civil justices&equo; to get people like me off the hook. 
 More power to his noble elbow. 
 Rural Britain is full of retired brigadiers and industrial captains, chaps who got where they were through diplomacy, cunning and an instinct for knocking heads together when the bugle blew. 
 Why not, as Lord Donaldson seems to be suggesting, appoint them to Rural Boundaries Tribunals, a sort of bucolic Acas, with powers to sort out neighbours who have temporarily taken leave of their common sense. 
 They may not always exhibit the wisdom of Solomon but at least they might know where to draw the line. 
 Talk of the Trade: Autumn price fall 
 By PETER DUNN 
 PETER FRASER, owner of the Classic Bookshop and opponent of the Net Book Agreement, has complained to Michael Joseph and the Booksellers' Association about The Sunday Times's special autumn offer of Edith Holden's The Nature Notes of an Edwardian Lady, published tomorrow. 
 He is aggrieved because, although it is being sold at the NBA price of &pound;15.95, purchasers are also receiving special prints with the book. 
 Michael Joseph says there has been no breach: &bquo;The Sunday Times's promotion is theirs, not ours.&equo; 
 Mr Fraser, with bookshops in Sherborne, Bristol and Bath, says he will probably sell the book for &pound;13. 
 Talk of the Trade: Victims' voice 
 By PETER DUNN 
 PEOPLE savaged by the tabloids are banding together to fight back. 
 On last week's Hard News on Channel 4, Linda Joyce, the Princess Royal's former maid, announced the formation of an organisation called Response, through which victims of the yellow press can compare experiences and seek redress. 
 When letters were stolen from the Princess Royal in April, Miss Joyce was questioned by police and some newspapers jumped to the wrong conclusion that she was responsible. 
 Joint founder of Response is Josephine Hunt, whose long-running battle with The Sun, which called her handicapped son &bquo;the worst brat in Britain', was also featured. 
 Talk of the Trade: Chamber chat 
 By PETER DUNN 
 A SATELLITE channel transmitting the proceedings of the British Parliament and overseas legislatures has been suggested by the Astra satellite company, Marketing Week reports. 
 Rupert Murdoch's Sky Television, which transmits four channels on Astra, would participate but would not own the channel. 
 Astra has already been talking to officials of the Commons about its planned service, based on the American C-Span cable network, which performs a similar function. 
 Apart from Westminster, the channel could relay reports from the European Parliament, the US Congress &mdash; and one day even the Supreme Soviet in Moscow. 
 Talk of the Trade: Floodtide for TV listings 
 By PETER DUNN 
 A FLOOD of new weekly television listings magazines will hit the market when what the Home Secretary calls the &bquo;dotty&equo; restriction on advance use of programme schedules is lifted in the next parliamentary session. 
 Not all will survive. 
 Rupert Murdoch's TV Guide could be in the strongest position, to scoop a lion's share of the market, since it is already established, listing all satellite channels and as much as it is allowed in the way of BBC and ITV previews. 
 It will be able to draw on material and expertise from Murdoch's American TV Guide, which has a stranglehold on the US market. 
 Radio Times and TV Times will start to print all terrestrial and satellite television listings. 
 Quite how the BBC will continue to &bquo;advertise&equo; the expanded Radio Times, exploiting its advantage of free airtime but implicitly promoting its rivals, remains to be seen. 
 Media: Return of the six-gun saga: Modern actors cannot ride and young viewers do not understand the cowboy code, but a revival of the western looms on the horizon, John Lichfield says 
 By JOHN LICHFIELD 
 Where are the TV westerns of yesteryear? 
 What happened to Ben Cartwright, Hoss and Little Joe? 
 Where is the Wagon Train that seemed permanently to be circling its wagons waiting for a drunken pioneer's wife to have twins in the last of them? 
 The TV western seemed to fade into the sunset some time in the mid-1970s, victim of a narcissistic age that preferred to look at prosperous, smart-alecky or violent images of itself (Dallas, Cheers, Miami Vice). 
 It was a time when children were encouraged to fantasize about machines and outer space rather than marvel at the open spaces where the deer and buffalo roamed. 
 Now, however, it seems, the wheel has turned full circle. 
 The western is being revived, reinterpreted for the 1990s. 
 One of the most successful Hollywood TV producers, David Jacobs, the creator of Dallas, believes the western also fell victim to late 1960s iconoclasm. 
 &bquo;The John Wayne stereotype was rejected, along with his conservative values,&equo; he said. 
 A series of spoof or obsessively realistic 1960s westerns (Cat Balou, Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, Soldier Blue, The Wild Bunch) stripped the mask from the Lone Ranger's face. 
 The legend could not be taken seriously any longer in what had been, admittedly, a threadbare form. 
 Howard Rosenberg, TV critic of the Los Angeles Times, said: &bquo;Just look at the re-runs of the old western series. 
 You had heroes scotch-taped to their horses and lightly sprinkled with dust. 
 You can't get away with that any more.&equo; 
 John Mantley, producer of Gunsmoke for CBS for 11 years, says elements of the old story began to fall apart. 
 &bquo;We all read Bury My Heart at Wounded Knee. 
 We knew that the US Government had signed 453 treaties with the Indians and broken every one. 
 A part of the myth just didn't work after that.&equo; 
 At their peak in the mid-60s, there were 39 western series on the three American TV networks &mdash; almost two a day on each channel. 
 In the US weekly audience ratings in 1965, there were three westerns in the top five, and seven in the top 10. 
 By the mid-80s they had all gone the way of the buffalo: extinct save for preservation in the national park of permanent re-runs. 
 Gene Autry, the first TV cowboy, now 82, says westerns dominated the early days of TV partly because they had lively, cheaply produced visuals, but mainly because early TV was starved of feature films by the studios. 
 Westerns were a handy substitute. 
 There are encouraging signs, however, that the TV western is struggling back into the saddle. 
 Paradise, launched on CBS last season and shown on BBC1 this summer, was the first new western serial for a decade. 
 It was the only new drama series in US network TV to be allowed a second series this year, despite a relatively lowly 49th ranking in the ratings. 
 Its creator and executive producer is, perhaps surprisingly, David Jacobs. 
 Why did he follow J R Ewing, the epitome of 1980s TV, with a western about a gunfighter turned foster father? 
 &bquo;I believed the genre was still an important and powerful one. 
 It's something I've always had an affection for. 
 I found it was possible with Paradise to talk about individual and personal responsibility, something which if set in a contemporary context would have had a preachy feel about it.&equo; 
 Lonesome Dove, a five-part story of a Texas-to-Montana cattle drive, also shown on CBS last year, was the best-watched TV mini-series of any kind in America for five years. 
 It won substantial critical acclaim and will show in Britain next year. 
 The 1989-90 season, which started this month, brought another new prime-time western series, ABC's Young Riders, which tells the story of the Pony Express. 
 It also says a lot about modern American TV. 
 Because the networks believe westerns appeal mainly to middle-aged men, Young Riders has a cast of five pouting young male actors, in an attempt to make a western with &bquo;good demographics&equo;. 
 The effect is rather like an extended advertisement for Marlboro Lights. 
 Westerns are no longer a cheap option. 
 The classic western TV series were filmed in back-lots, or in the semi-desert 20 miles from Los Angeles. 
 Modern audiences no longer accept plastic bushes, and the southern Californian suburban sprawl means the production companies have to take their horses and cows to locations far away in Arizona or Montana. 
 David Jacobs also points out that the cost of hiring a stage-coach is now prohibitive. 
 &bquo;At one time there were dozens of companies which specialised in renting out western paraphernalia. 
 Now there are maybe two. 
 The cost has gone through the barn roof.&equo; 
 And actors can no longer ride. 
 They have to be sent to &bquo;cowboy school&equo;. 
 Westerns, by their nature, demand more time on location. 
 As a result, Mr Jacobs says, it cost nearly as much to make an episode of Paradise, with relatively unknown actors, as an episode of Dallas, with its big stars. 
 Will the western ride again? 
 John Mantley is cautious. 
 &bquo;Westerns have a gladiatorial, timeless quality. 
 On the other hand you have a whole generation of TV watchers that doesn't really know the rules. 
 A western is like a Japanese Noh play. 
 It is a stylised drama with understated dialogue that depends on recognition of key words and concepts. 
 Many of the young people today haven't the first idea of what's going on.&equo; 
 In the inert 1950s the western represented a troubled, adventurous American past. 
 In the anxious and eventful late 1980s and 1990s, they may come to represent, like All Creatures Great and Small in Britain, a less confusing past with simpler, deeper values. 
 Maybe. 
 On the other hand The Young Riders came 51st in the ratings in its first week, trailing far, far behind all the modern myths about modern times such as The Cosby Show, Roseanne, Golden Girls, Cheers and Matlock. 
 It is premature, then, to say that the western has galloped back to centre screen. 
 But there is a puff of dust on the horizon. 
 Media: A discreet facelift for &bquo;Le Monde&equo;: Sarah Lambert greets the relaunch of France's august paper of record, now aiming at younger readers 
 By SARAH LAMBERT 
 THE LAST 10 days or so have not so much shaken the world as utterly changed it. 
 Le Monde, France's daily newspaper of record, has been redesigned and relaunched with the help of a Fr25m advertising campaign which proclaims: &bquo;Le Monde is changing.&equo; 
 Le Monde is not just a newspaper but an institution. 
 Founded after the war with de Gaulle's blessing, its official brief was to recreate a national consensus and rekindle public faith in the Press which the collaborationist &bquo;newspapers&equo; of the war years had almost extinguished. 
 That it is now required reading for the French Establishment and for anybody involved in business or education is a measure of how successfully it fulfilled its task without compromising a reputation for unbiased reporting. 
 Because the country has a very strong regional press, Le Monde is not France's bestselling paper but is unique in that 85,000 of the 385,000 copies bought daily are sold abroad. 
 For many readers, Le Monde's view of the world is France's view of the world. 
 That view is presented in a classical French, rarely illustrated, and then only with the smallest photographs or the occasional line drawing. 
 It follows an editorial policy that believes foreign news should lead the first three pages, that matters of national interest should be philosophically debated in the newspaper's columns, and that half a page of sport either side of the weekend is enough. 
 Having survived a financial crisis in the early 1980s, thanks to support from the banks and from a staff prepared to agree to a voluntary wage freeze, the paper is now making money and putting on readers, so why has the management now decided to modernise the title? 
 On first sight it might seem a case of plus ca change, plus c'est la meme chose. 
 The differences are minimal: cleaner print, a slightly smaller format somewhere between tabloid and broadsheet, the masthead underlined in blue and, the most striking development: the appearance of separate sections. 
 But, as the editor Andre Fontaine explains: &bquo;It is not so much a new layout as a new presentation. 
 Newspaper readers are very conservative &mdash; the changes are not supposed to shock.&equo; 
 As in Britain, French newspapers are having to respond to the growing demand for advertising space by adding extra pages. 
 Le Monde, one of the country's most profitable publishing concerns producing special supplements and books while printing other publications, has invested a sum conservatively estimated at not less than Fr350m in a state-of-the-art printing press. 
 The press, at Ivry, a suburb south-east of Paris, is the most technologically advanced in Europe and will enable Le Monde to print in colour and to produce 64-page newspaper, a third as much again. 
 With so many pages, the decision to divide the paper into separate sections: home and foreign news, society and culture, economics and business news with special supplements, books and ideas on Friday, arts and listings on Thursday and a radio/television guide at the weekend, has been dictated by the problems of readability as much as anything else. 
 &bquo;The paper was just getting too unwieldly, we needed to give our readers some help in finding their way around the paper,&equo; says Mr Fontaine. 
 He also hopes the new format will attract new readers, both those who do not regularly read a daily newspaper and converts from the rival Liberation - which has won an extraordinary success among younger readers with its mix of lively writing, news features and bold use of photography and design. 
 Mr Fontaine admits that the society and culture section of the new-look Le Monde has been inspired by Liberation's treatment of similar subject-matter. 
 &bquo;So many stories &mdash; drugs or immigration, for example &mdash; are international stories and should be written from a point of comparison, set in their international context. 
 That takes time to research, and space to display.&equo; 
 That so-called &bquo;soft&equo; subjects like health are now valid areas of inquiry and sport merits better and more detailed coverage has now been realised. 
 The colour-printing facility, initially to be used only for advertising, may be used to produce a weekend &bquo;leisure&equo; colour supplement early next year. 
 &bquo;I don't believe in the fatal decline of the written word,&equo; says Mr Fontaine, &bquo;but we are competing all the time &mdash; not so much against television, because the screen image and the printed word complement each other, as against magazines, and against the time people spend getting to work and then their leisure time &mdash; against music and the cinema.&equo; 
 Not all the Le Monde journalists support the change, which is the result of two years' market research and several dummy editions. 
 A professional designer, Jean Bayle, with a track record for breathing new life into tired titles, was hired but the changes he favoured were deemed rather too radical and, in the end &mdash; as is often the case on Le Monde where the staff hold a significant stake in the company &mdash; the consensus view prevailed. 
 For the chief sub-editor, Daniel Vernet, it has not been an easy transition: &bquo;We had to make sure that the paper read as a single publication, but that each section stood up on its own, while avoiding undue repetition,&equo; he explains. 
 All this disruption coincides with preparations to move to a new offices early next month, when all editing and layout will be done on computers. 
 Meanwhile, there are plans to change the management structure so as to divide responsibility for editorial content, day-to-day management and the business side of the Le Monde publishing empire more logically. 
 The task will undoubtably fall heaviest on Andre Fontaine, who with the death earlier this summer of the newspaper's founder Hubert Beuve-Mery, has to shoulder the burden alone. 
 &bquo;I look around,&equo; he says, &bquo;and there is no one there behind.&equo; 
 The differences he and his production team have introduced may be ones of detail, but are no less revolutionary for that. 
 Whatever the readers' perception, Le Monde is changing and will go on doing so for some time to come. 
 Media: Women's monthly magazines: circulation figures 
 By SARAH LAMBERT 
 WOMEN'S monthly magazines are battling it out in an extremely competitive market. 
 Sales were hit by the drop in retail spending during the first half of 1989. 
 Prima remains the bestseller but is down 17 per cent. 
 Essentials fell even more sharply, but is above target. 
 Marie Claire is below projections. 
 The explosion in advertising space has not been matched by demand. 
 Battles wage over display in newsagents. 
 Some magazines are responding to the new hard times by raising prices. 
 Rugby League: Brawlers fined by League 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 (First Edition) THE LEAGUE'S board of directors yesterday found Castleford and Hull guilty of bringing the game into disrepute by brawling in their Wheldon Road meeting 10 days ago, and fined each club &pound;3,000, writes Paul Wilson. 
 As is customary, only &pound;500 of each fine was payable, the rest suspended for 12 months and enforcable only if either club appears on a similar disrepute charge within that time. 
 Castleford were one of the clubs fined two seasons ago when an outbreak of brawling at several matches led to the League imposing new, stiffer penalties. 
 Batley and Sheffield Eagles received a severe reprimand yesterday for the fighting which took place during their first-round Yorkshire Cup tie. 
 Brent Todd, the Kiwi prop forward who plays with the Canberra Raiders in Australia, will not appear in his club's World Club Challenge match against Widnes tonight at Old Trafford. 
 Todd, who played briefly at Wakefield Trinity last season, is in the New Zealand touring squad currently in this country, and was refused an exemption to take part in the showpiece game. 
 Todd did appear in the Raiders side who beat Balmain in the Sydney Grand Final, but was replaced in extra time by Peter Jackson, who went on to score the winning try. 
 Jackson again deputises tonight. 
 Oldham have transfer-listed Keith Atkinson, a utility back, for &pound;10,000 at his own request. 
 Robert Myler, a 19-year-old half-back from the Widnes St Maries amateur club, has joined Warrington. 
 Sheffield Eagles, still homeless after being banned from the Owlerton Stadium, have brought forward their home match against Leeds from 29 October to Wednesday, 25 October, to enable it to take place at Wakefield. 
 The Eagles entertain Widnes at Bramall lane on Sunday, a venue arranged before the start of the season. 
 Widnes and Fulham are the season's first winners of the Stones Bitter Team of the Month awards. 
 Widnes are unbeaten in their first six matches and have amassed 238 points. 
 Fulham have registered four victories and are second behind Ryedale York in the Second Division. 
 Boxing: Biggs cut out to advance Mason's career: Ken Jones on the fragility a Briton aims to exploit tonight 
 By KEN JONES 
 THERE are two things to remember about Tyrell Biggs, the 28-year-old Olympic gold medallist from Orange County, California, who stands between Gary Mason and the rest of his career. 
 One is that he has been in the ring with Michael Gerard Tyson. 
 Two is that it would be extremely unwise for Biggs to engage in serious pugilistic activity without first retaining the services of an attendant unlikely to panic at the sight of a badly lacerated brow. 
 It is safe to assume that these were prominent factors when Biggs was considered as a possible opponent for Mason who will go to his corner at the Royal Albert Hall in London tonight with a record of 31 professional victories, 30 inside the distance. 
 Matchmaking is a precise art and never more so than when practised by Terry Lawless and Mickey Duff whose most notable achievement so far was to manoeuvre Frank Bruno into a hugely profitable contest against Tyson for the world heavyweight championship. 
 As Mason, the British heavyweight champion, has been brought forward along similar lines, his career nourished mainly by opponents who showed little inclination to remain upright, it should be clear that Biggs is thought to represent an ideal opportunity for advancement. 
 An impressive amateur, the 1984 super-heavyweight Olympic champion, Biggs had won all 15 professional contests and was reckoned to be a considerable prospect in the division until he was overwhelmed by Tyson in Las Vegas on 16 October, 1987. 
 As a result of that demoralising experience Biggs was inactive for more than a year, a cut eye then leading to a stoppage against Francesco Damiani, the Italian he defeated in the Olympic final. 
 More than 60 stitches have now been inserted in fragile brows but it is probable that Biggs will never recover from the beating he took from Tyson. 
 &bquo;Fighters who have been in with him are never the same again,&equo; he said last week. 
 This is certainly borne out by the World Boxing Council ratings. 
 Tony Tucker, Tony Tubbs, James Smith and Trevor Berbick have all tumbled out of the top 10 and Biggs is now ranked 27th. 
 Bold assertions are what we have come to expect from visiting Americans of dubious pedigree but they come to Biggs almost as an afterthought. 
 &bquo;I am not here to lose,&equo; he said, never far from the negative response. 
 A stand-up, straight-backed style has proved to be less effective against professional opponents although Biggs claims that attempts to make him more aggressive were counter-productive against Tyson. 
 &bquo;It was in me to beat him but not the way they wanted me to fight.&equo; 
 He was referring to Lou Duva, his former manager, and George Benton, then trainer. 
 It remains to be seen how much Biggs has got left and even Duff has made mistakes. 
 But this is not a fight Mason imagines he can lose and much of the interest tonight will focus on his ability to handle a taller opponent who has been in with better men. 
 It has been suggested that Biggs does not possess the heart but when so badly cut that he could not be allowed more than one more round he went back out and stopped David Bey. 
 Cus D'Amato, the famed trainer who shaped Tyson's career, was dismissive of teachers who believe that tall boxers were made to jab and move, relying mostly on their reach and mobility. 
 It is the way Biggs fights and he can be expected to steal the early rounds. 
 There remain doubts about Mason's stamina but encouraged by greater attention since Bruno's career was put on hold, he is fitter than at any other time in his career and is undoubtably the heavier puncher. 
 He is fancied to win inside the distance and the American's cut man can anticipate a busy night. 
 John Morris, secretary of the British Board of Control, has commended Bolsover's Ian Bulloch for helping to quell crowd problems at Hanley on Monday night. 
 Bulloch was knocked out after 53 seconds of the second round, in a challenge for the British cruiserweight title, by the champion, Johnny Nelson of Sheffield. 
 Some of his fans became involved in fighting and Bulloch had to return to the ring to appeal to them to stop. 
 Skydiving: British team &bquo;MO&equo; join World Skydiving Championship in Gerona, Spain 
 By KEN JONES 
 The British team &bquo;MO&equo; join high society for the World Skydiving Championship in Gerona, Spain. 
 The Kent-based team finished fourth out of 15 nations in the eight-way event. 
 They comprise Pete Allan, Sarah Brearley, Rob Colpus, Pam Duncan, Kevin Hardwick, Timothy Mace, Geoff Saunders and Andrew Woodmansey. 
 After a linked exit at 11,000ft there are 45 seconds of free fall when a maximum number of relative flying positions are attempted. 
 The sport is hoping to gain Olympic status  
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Table Tennis 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Rugby Union 
 By KEN JONES 
 WALES' B international against France on 12 November will be played in Lateste near Bordeaux. 
 The Welsh side's coach will be Stan Addicott, with Charlie Faulkner, the former British Lion, as assistant. 
 Sport in Short: Ice Skating 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 By KEN JONES 
 WENDY RUSSELL became the first woman to hole in one twice during a top-class event yesterday when she sank two tee-shots in the opening round of the British Women's Seniors' Championship at Wrexham. 
 Russell, 51, produced the shots with a seven-iron at the 127-yard fourth and the second with an eight-iron at the eighth which measures 118 yards. 
 Sport in Short: Football 
 By KEN JONES 
 FOLKESTONE had four players sent off but still 1-0 win away to Redhill, who also had a player dismissed by referee Steve Coffin, of Peacehaven. 
 In the 68th minute Folkestone's Phil Hancock, Lawrence Ward and Mickey Wells were sent off along with Redhill's Mark Hemsley. 
 Later Folkestone's Andy Allan was also ordered off. 
 On Saturday, Dunstable's match at Staines was abandoned after they walked off after three of their players were dismissed. 
 They later withdrew from the competition. 
 MATLOCK TOWN, the HFS Loans League team, are still in the FA Trophy - despite having been defeated in the first round. 
 Matlock, who won the Trophy in 1975, lost 1-0 at home to Stalybridge Celtic, but Celtic's centre half Micky Kilduff had signed for the club only six days before the game, instead of the seven laid down in the rules, so the match has been awarded to Matlock. 
 Sport in Short: Cycling 
 By KEN JONES 
 COLIN STURGESS, Britain's world pursuit champion, has pulled out of the final round of the McEwan's LA professional series in Manchester on Sunday because of tendinitis. 
 Sport in Short: Cricket 
 By KEN JONES 
 THE WINNERS of the Nehru Cup one-day tournament in India later this month will collect nearly &pound;25,000, but could lose money, too. 
 Each country will have three hours and minutes to bowl their 50 overs. 
 Falling one over short in any of the preliminary round games will cost &pound;775 and every over after that, &pound;1,080. 
 Both figures double for the semi-finals and rise to &pound;2,000 and &pound;3,000 in the final. 
 The winners will receive &pound;24,850, the runners-up &pound;15,500, and the losing semi-finalists &pound;7,750. 
 IMRAN KHAN will captain Pakistan on their four-Test tour of India beginning on 9 November and in the Sharjah Cup and Nehru Cup one-day tournaments. 
 Javed Miandad will be his deputy. 
 DEREK RANDALL, Nottinghamshire's former England batsman, is recovering from a cartilage operation to cure knee trouble that hampered him in the closing stages of the season. 
 Randall, 38, who hit more than 1,000 first-class runs for Nottinghamshire, said: &bquo;I've had a bit of cartilage trimmed off, but it feels fine now and shouldn't cause me any problems at all next season.&equo; 
 PETER RAWSON, Zimbabwe's former captain, will be banned for life after signing to play in South Africa. 
 The 32-year-old fast bowler has signed a two-year contract to play for Natal in South Africa's Currie Cup competition. 
 SUSSEX have created a fund to help their young players find coaching jobs overseas &mdash; except for South Africa &mdash; during the winter. 
 Any contracted player under the age of 22 will be eligible. 
 Barclays Bank have donated &pound;500 to the fund. 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 By KEN JONES 
 ROCKY GRAZIANO, the former world middleweight champion, is in a stable condition in hospital after collapsing at his home on Monday. 
 Graziano, 68, won the world title in 1947 with a sixth-round knock-out of Tony Zale but lost it to the same fighter less than a year later. 
 He finished his career in 1952 with a record of 67 wins, including 52 knockouts, six draws and 10 losses. 
 Sport in Short: Basketball 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Australian Rules 
 By KEN JONES 
 TWO LEADING teams will meet at The Oval this month in the final of the Foster's Cup. 
 The semi-finals, featuring the Melbourne Demons, the Geelong Cats, the Essendon Bombers and the Hawthorn Hawks will be held in Toronto (13-14 October). 
 Hawthorn beat Geelong in this year's Grand Final on Sunday. 
 Sport in Short: Athletics 
 By KEN JONES 
 SAID AOUITA, the 1500 metres, 3,000m and 5,000m world record holder, has criticised what he called lenient treatment of the disgraced Canadian sprinter, Ben Johnson, saying that athletes who take drugs should be banned from competition for life. 
 The Moroccan said that athletes might still take drugs if they thought being caught would mean only a temporary ban. 
 TERRY TULLETT, of Brighton and Hove, and Reading's Peter Sugden, both former winners, will run in the annual London to Brighton Road Race on Sunday. 
 Hilary Walker will defend the women's title. 
 Sport in Short: American Football 
 By KEN JONES 
 MIKE TOMCZAK, the Chicago Bears quarterback, threw for three touchdowns and Neal Anderson rushed for another as Chicago staved off a fourth-quarter rally by the Philadelphia Eagles on Monday night to win 27-13. 
 The Bears, with four wins this season, are one of three unbeaten NFL teams. 
 The New York Giants and the Los Angeles Rams are the others. 
 Amateur Rugby League: Uphill battle for armed forces 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 A MAJOR step in the development of the game in the ranks of the Services took place at St Helens on Sunday, when, in a curtain-raiser to the first match of the New Zealand tour, an RAF team defeated an Army XIII by 22-14. 
 The prize for the RAF players may be a match against the French Army when they arrive later this year for a short tour. 
 Notoriously strong, due to enforced national service, and generously funded for the same reason, French Army sides of the past have launched international careers like that of Eric Vergniol, who this year switched to rugby union. 
 Nothing could be further from the home life of our own Combined Services Sports Board, which has yet to recognise the 13-a-side code. 
 The efforts of Merlyn Rees, the former Defence Secretary, and Tom O'Donovan, the British Amateur Rugby League Association's national development officer, have failed to persuade Services officials to accept rugby league as a sport like any other. 
 &bquo;We are up against a substantial amount of red tape,&equo; O'Donovan said. 
 &bquo;The last official reason we received was that the Treasury was unwilling to approve any more sports.&equo; 
 In a shining example, the rugby union club at the Coningsby base in Lincolnshire agreed to accept league devotees and change its name to Coningsby rugby club. 
 New ground is also being broken in Wigan, where 15 women have enrolled in a coaching course at the Leigh school of excellence. 
 Most of the women are primary school teachers with responsibility for sports lessons, anxious to give all their budding Andy Gregorys the best possible advice. 
 Rugby Union: Moon shines to light North Midlands' path 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 Leicestershire.... 26 North Midlands.... 28 WITH the County Championship due for another facelift, this winter's finishing order will have a new significance and judging by last night's lively encounter at Welford Road, North Midlands are well up with the situation. 
 Next season, the old competition will be run on a national league basis - and on the same dates as the divisionals &mdash; with early rounds settled in two areas, the North and Midlands and London South-East and West. 
 While those selected for the divisionals will not be available for these matches in future, the County Championship, according to Sandy Saunders, the Rugby Football Union's president, plays an important part in the calendar. 
 Here, Leicestershire scored first, with a penalty from Paul Pugh, but North Midlands took most of the positive steps before reaching the break with a lead of 16-3. 
 Initially, there was a close range try from Tony Keegan and then a superb handling move involving sleight of hand from Martin Smith &mdash; an Old Edwardian who bears a striking resemblance to the Leicester maestro, Les Cusworth - resulted in Rupert Moon plunging over. 
 Then, just after the half hour, another sweeping exchange resulted in a try for David Curwen and John Watkins &mdash; enjoying a late call for this game - landed two conversions. 
 When Pugh closed the gap with his second penalty, the North Midlands' response soon followed with another try from Moon. 
 The best rugby, though, was yet to come stemming from a tigerish rally inspired by a local lad. 
 Three times the ball was spun out to the right and three times Claude Gerald left the North Midlands defence for dead with a stunning hat-trick of tries. 
 What appeared to be the last rites were then administered by Kevin McDonald, whoise storming try was converted by Pugh, but with three minutes to go Moon, not to be eclipsed, cut loose for his third try and Watkins landed the match-winning conversion from far out on the left. 
 Rugby Union: Linguistic hitch halts Neath case 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 THE WELSH Rugby Union's inability to interpret a communique from their French counterparts has given Neath a stay of execution following their pitch walk-off in France two months ago. 
 The Welsh Cup holders' departure at half-time led to their match against Brive being abandoned. 
 One Neath player had been sent off, another threatened with dismissal and, as a result, the Welshmen passed a vote of no confidence in the referee. 
 After Pontypool took similar action a decade ago, against California Golden Poppies in San Francisco, they were banned from touring for three years. 
 Neath could suffer a similar fate, but any punishment will be linked to the severity of the report. 
 &bquo;We have attempted to translate the report we requested from the French, but because of our linguistic inability it hasn't made complete sense,&equo; Edward Jones, the acting secretary of the WRU, said. 
 &bquo;We have sent it back and asked for a translation.&equo; 
 The special general meeting called by the Union for Friday will be held in camera following a general committee vote to exclude the press. 
 There will also be no chance for delegates from the 203 member clubs to probe the background to the South African Rugby Board centenary tour. 
 The only subject open for debate will be the Union's motion advocating a complete severance of links with the Republic. 
 The Union's case will be set out by their senior life member, Ken Harris, who said this week he will relinquish his post as a trustee. 
 That role will be taken over by Glanmor Griffiths, the WRU treasurer, who has been elevated, with Denzil Lloyd, to the International Board, Home Unions and Five Nations committees. 
 Rugby Union: Hesketh starts landslide 
 By PAUL STEPHENS 
 Lancashire.... 49 Cumbria........ 0 AFTER fluffing most of their lines in Saturday's matinee against Northumberland, Lancashire, with little time to rehearse their act, put a significantly more emphatic performance together against Cumbria. 
 It remains to be seen whether they will still be in business to take the show to London in April; it looks as if the outcome of the Northern group may rest on the Roses game later in the month. 
 Unfancied Cumbria were disappointingly unable to reproduce the form that produced that remarkable upset at Aspatria when they beat the title holders a year ago, and they were swept aside in a second-half torrent of scoring. 
 With full-back Ian Hunter not appearing Cumbria were in doubt about their line-up until a few minutes before kick-off, but showed no signs of uncertainty when the action began, winning a penalty from their first attack. 
 Andrew Harrison missed a straightforward chance from 25 metres. 
 He missed with two other attempts, one from longer range and a sitter from 20 metres, failing to reward the efforts of his pack, who were considerably outweighed by the Lancashire eight. 
 Cumbria threatened to fall apart when they lost their hooker, Derek Dougan, just before the interval, as Lancashire's Mark Hesketh finished off a surge by Shaun Gallagher, initiated by the lively Dewi Morris, to give Lancashire a 9-0 lead at the break. 
 Within moments of the restart, Simon Langford burst through the remnants of the Cumbrian midfield, Nigel Heslop getting the try. 
 Bob Kimmins heaved open the floodgates and Mike Fielden, Hesketh with a second, Brendan Hanavan, Allan Wyllie and Charles Cusani allowed Lancashire to pour through unopposed. 
 Three more conversions by Strett completed the rout. 
 Rugby League: Enduring gifts of a gilded wing: Paul Wilson reports on an unlikely &bquo;superman&equo; of rugby league whose longevity has become legendary 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 THE FERGIE expected to swell the gate at Old Trafford tonight is not Manchester United's wallet waver, nor even the creator of Budgie the Helicopter. 
 John Ferguson, the Canberra Raiders wing who lines up against Widnes tonight in the Foster's World Club Challenge, is little known outside rugby league circles, but within the game he commands a whispered respect his more famous namesakes might envy. 
 Ferguson is flawless, a folk hero in two countries. 
 In Australia, his try-scoring ability, self-effacing modesty and amazing longevity have set him apart. 
 In a competition renowned for its ferocity, where even forwards can be burned out in their twenties, a 35-year-old winger is most unusual. 
 Yet no one was in the least surprised when Ferguson scored the try which earned the Raiders extra time in the Sydney Grand Final, and subsequently a trip to Manchester. 
 His reputation in this country rests on 25 appearances for Wigan in the 1984-85 season. 
 He scored 24 tries, two of them in the epic Challenge Cup final victory over Hull. 
 The statistics are impressive enough, but they hardly tell the story. 
 Some of Ferguson's tries had to be seen to be believed. 
 Not endowed with remarkable physique (5ft 9in, 12st 2lb), or blessed with exceptional speed, Ferguson simply has a precious gift for going past defenders. 
 Deceptively strong, he can surprise opponents by riding heavy challenges. 
 But usually he manages to pre-empt the tackle by sleight of foot. 
 The classic example of his footwork was the first Wigan try in the 1985 final. 
 Dane O'Hara probably still wakes up at night and sees Ferguson oscillating in front of him. 
 The Hull man appeared to have the angles covered when Ferguson rocked back on his heels to accept Ian Potter's pass, but despite a standing start and only inches in which to operate, Fergie whisked past on the outside. 
 Alex Murphy's incredulous comment &mdash; &bquo;that's the best winger in the world he's just gone past&equo; &mdash; nicely captured the audacity of the moment. 
 Hull supporters, who have never seen their side successful at Wembley, have a list of what went wrong on each occasion. 
 &bquo;In 1985,&equo; a Boulevard fan told me last year, &bquo;Wigan had superman on the wing.&equo; 
 Some superman. 
 Even in 1985 Ferguson was being asked unkind questions about his age, and then, as now, he was partial to the odd pack of cigarettes before a game. 
 The first thing he did on arriving in Manchester at the weekend was pop over unannounced to Billy Boston's pub in Wigan, where his likeness jostles for space with the owner's on the tap room wall. 
 &bquo;I'll always have a soft spot for Wigan, my memories of 1984-85 are priceless,&equo; Ferguson said. 
 &bquo;Wembley and everything was like a dream, but even before that people treated me as a cult figure. 
 I was just an honest guy who wanted to get on with what he did best, scoring tries, and I think the supporters responded to that.&equo; 
 There will be a few moist eyes at Old Trafford if Fergie finds himself in dreamland again tonight, in what will surely be his last appearance in Britain. 
 Then again, retirement was mentioned after Wembley. 
 &bquo;People said I was too old in 1985, but I had confidence in my own ability,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I still have, but now my legs aren't quite as young as I feel.&equo; 
 Rugby League: Sherlock solves problem 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 Castleford..... 20 New Zealand.... 22 A TRY five minutes from the end by Kurt Sherlock, the former All-Black centre, brought New Zealand the first victory of their tour at Wheldon Road last night. 
 Castleford, who, like Hull, were fined &pound;3,000 yesterday for brawling in a League match, were in control for most of the game, but their young side was caught by a Kiwi revival in the second half. 
 The introduction of Gary Freeman, a former Castleford player, helped settle the tourists, who prevented any home score in the second half. 
 A rampaging break by Kevin Iro brought a try for Wayne Wallace, and Phil Bancroft's fifth goal took New Zealand to within two points, before Mike Kuiti, a second-row forward bound for Leeds after the tour, laid on Sherlock's saver. 
 Many of the Kiwis were playing their first rugby for several weeks, and in the early part of the game it showed. 
 Their first set move broke down through an elementary forward pass, and throughout the first half they were plagued by basic errors. 
 An unnecessary penalty conceded in front of their posts brought Castleford the first points. 
 St John Ellis, making his debut after signing from York, kicked the goal after Brendon Tuuta went high on Kevin Beardmore. 
 Tuuta and Morvin Edwards then allowed Gary French to claim the opening try, and an astute pass by John Joyner then brought Andy Clarke a second. 
 Iro, the only Kiwi of undoubted international calibre, made scoring look easy when he received his chance, but in a splendid move between the forwards, Castleford carved the tourists open again before half-time, 19-year-old Paul Crabtree taking a Beardmore pass to give the home side a 20-8 interval lead. 
 Ice Skating: Eldredge overtakes on merit 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 TODD ELDREDGE, the 18-year-old former world junior champion, skated superbly to take the overall lead after the original programme at the Skate Electric UK International at Richmond Ice Rink last night. 
 The American, who had been lying second after the morning's compulsory figures, was placed first by all nine judges for both technical merit and presentation. 
 Eldredge's performance took him past Grzegorz Filipowski. 
 The Pole was first in the compulsory figures but could finish only third in the original programme, behind both Eldredge, and Vladimir Petrenko of the Soviet Union, in a nine-strong field. 
 Britain's two skaters, the Welsh-based Steven Cousins and John Martin, the Scottish champion from Ayr, were both outclassed. 
 Cousins was eighth in both figures and original programme, with Martin last in each. 
 Boxing: Sky lines up for a classic TV fight: Neil Wilson on the big battle of the small screen and growing threat of the extra terrestrial to the conventional channels: &bquo;We're not averse even to putting major sport on our movie channel.. 
 There's no area which isn't open to us&equo; 
 By NEIL WILSON 
 WIMBLEDON restricted to a pay-to-watch satellite television channel? 
 Test matches from Lord's live only to those with a dish on the roof or a cable through the wall? 
 The spectre was raised yesterday. 
 Rupert Murdoch did not say that his Sky company and its associate Eurosport channel were ready yet to go head-to-head in rights fights with BBC when he announced a joint contract with them for England's Test series in the West Indies this winter. 
 But he left the possibility open. 
 Sky, he confirmed, are in the market for big sporting events. 
 &bquo;World title boxing,&equo; he suggested. 
 But traditional British classics? 
 &bquo;If it was big enough, attractive enough and our viewers would like it,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;We're not averse even to putting major sport on our movie channel, as HBO (a US cable company) do with Wimbledon.&equo; 
 Already &bquo;one or two phone calls&equo; have been made to the Test and County Cricket Board, according to Dave Hill, the Australian whose production of World Series Cricket for Channel 9 (remember floodlights, yellow balls and pink shirts?) ruffled so many establishment figures and who is now Murdoch's man running Eurosport. 
 &bquo;There's no area which isn't open to us.&equo; 
 For now, BBC sport and Britain's fledgling satellite companies are the best of friends. 
 Eurosport frequently puts out the BBC's own pictures simultaneously, and showed more of them live from the Ryder Cup last month than the Beeb itself. 
 It receives them automatically as a member of the European Broadcasting Union, a privilege granted to it because 15 member stations of that cosy cartel own the half of Eurosport which Murdoch does not. 
 In its first year Eurosport has enjoyed access to live transmissions of the athletics, motorcycling and Formula One Grand Prix circuits and acres of European football, an advantage which British Satellite Broadcasting, the &bquo;squarial&equo; company hoping to transmit next year, claims is unfair. 
 BSB itself went into partnership with the BBC to negotiate jointly with the Football Association for exclusive rights to England football and FA Cup matches, and Sky first got into bed with BBC to win exclusive British rights to the Mike Tyson-Frank Bruno world heavyweight title fight. 
 But how long can the honeymoon last? 
 BSB has its satellite in space but is not on the air, and Murdoch laid claim yesterday to reaching only 509,000 households in Britain. 
 Yet ITV regards its competition so seriously that it refuses even to allow Sky the traditional news access to its exclusive sponsored events or permit the EBU to pass on its pictures from events such as athletics' European Cup. 
 &bquo;I am not so complacent that I would say they won't become a formidable competitor but for now they are not,&equo; Jonathan Martin, head of sport at the BBC, said. 
 &bquo;We are complementary. 
 There's enough sport for all of us.&equo; 
 He agreed to share the costs of the West Indies series because &bquo;our service is complementary&equo;. 
 Sky will transmit live in its peak hours from 3pm to 11pm. 
 The BBC, who did not wish to go live, will take recorded highlights, the two companies agreeing on the same commentators. 
 The same is true of the BSB deal for football. 
 &bquo;No way would we transmit an FA Cup replay on a Tuesday evening live,&equo; Martin said. 
 &bquo;Our partnerships make sense, and our viewers will not lose out.&equo; 
 Martin, of course, is not unaware that Eurosport and Screensport, the WH Smith-owned channel which shares the Astra satellite with Sky's four stations, are insignificant still in audience terms. 
 Eurosport claims a potential audience of only 800,000 in Britain. 
 It is different on the Continent. 
 Satellite is more established because there cable companies take the service from the satellite and pipe it to customers. 
 There is no need to buy a dish, as most British viewers must. 
 Five million West Germans can already receive Eurosport, and 17 million Continentals in all, and this week the company will announce its first simultaneous commentaries in languages other than English. 
 Indeed West German satellite companies are so stong that one bought exclusive German rights to Wimbledon this year, just as a similar Swedish company did there, each denying the traditional terrestrial stations access. 
 Money seems little object, and one German satellite station has spent &dollar;25 million buying the rights to ATP's new tennis tour for the next five years. 
 How long will it be before Britain's three satellite companies are in that league? 
 &bquo;At present they are only alternative television,&equo; Martin said. 
 &bquo;Sport's interest must be in exposure and numbers, and for the foreseeable future that means BBC. 
 There is also the nitty-gritty of money.&equo; 
 But the satellite companies will not only have a rising income from subscriptions and a need to invest it in their struggle for a credible share of the viewing audience. 
 They also have a willingness to accept sponsored programming, something still denied the BBC by its Charter. 
 Many Eurosport programmes are sponsored already, and by major companies such as Volvo, and that offers it an edge. 
 &bquo;Of course we know they are going to get stronger but when are we looking at?&equo; 
 Martin asked. 
 &bquo;Think how long BBC2 and Channel 4 have been on the air and they still have barely 10 per cent of the British audience. 
 We are talking of them being competitive a long way down the road.&equo; 
 Yesterday, it was not how Murdoch was talking. 
 Equestrianism: Skelton is too wise for Boysie 
 From GENEVIEVE MURPHY at Wembley 
 NICK SKELTON'S refined skill on the mare Burmah Serenade was rewarded with a &pound;2,300 first prize in last night's Rover Classic at the Horse of the Year Show. 
 It was one of those rare occasions when neither of the Whitaker brothers reached the jump-off, but Skelton still had 11 to beat. 
 They included this year's Dubai Cup winners at Hickstead, Robert Smith and Brook Street Boysie, who threw down their usual serious challenge only to be bettered by 1.05sec. 
 Joe Turi, the first to go clear in the jump-off, was pushed back to third place on Country Classics Vital. 
 Emma-Jane Mac had earlier given Coomes Bookmakers a chance to recoup money given in sponsorship when winning their contest on the 14-1 Everest Gringo. 
 Her trainer, Ted Edgar, was on hand to give her advice, despite breaking his shoulder in a hunting accident last Saturday. 
 &bquo;I wasn't sure about making the sharp turn into the fifth fence, but Ted told me I had to go the fast way everywhere otherwise I had no hope of winning,&equo; Mac said. 
 Having done just that half way through this contest which was judged on time in the first round, she had an agonising wait to see whether anyone would catch her. 
 Only Nick Skelton was faster, but he had a single error with Burmah Grand Slam. 
 Mark Todd, who finished fourth on Double Take II, had a miserable ride in yesterday's Working Hunter Championship, which was won by Jean Harpham's Bootleg. 
 Todd was on Seabrook, who lowered three fences and had a refusal, leaving the New Zealand Olympic three-day event gold medallist without the slightest enthusiasm for this type of contest. 
 In the afternoon, William Halliday achieved his first Horse of the Year Show victory some 12 months after leaving his long-term employment as Harvey Smith's stable jockey. 
 He had been runner-up on several occasions during his 20 years with Smith, but it was Sheelagh Boon's six-year-old Smart Move who gave him his first win when taking the Senior Newcomers Championship. 
 &bquo;I'm 43 now and just peaking,&equo; Halliday said, with a self-deprecatory grin. 
 He now earns his living as a lorry driver, so he had taken a week's holiday to compete at Wembley. 
 His riding is otherwise confined to the evenings and show jumping contests to the weekends. 
 As first to go in the nine-horse jump-off, Halliday had seemed to be handicapped by the draw. 
 But Smart Move was fast and clear, leaving the others to chase his time in vain. 
 Keeley Durham came closest, just 0.77 of a second behind the winner, to be runner-up on Welham. 
 Joanne Atkins won yesterday's second leg of the National Grade A Championship but Andy Austin, the victor with River Hill on Monday, remains the overall leader in this three-part contest which will be decided today. 
 Tennis: Lendl lost in life's labours 
 From JOHN ROBERTS in Stuttgart 
 FACIAL expressions made it difficult to guess who was the man on a working honeymoon here yesterday. 
 In tennis terms, the differences in demeanours of the newly wed Ivan Lendl and the newly awakened Henri Leconte was that of one player whose year has ended and another whose may be about to begin. 
 Lendl, still trying to push the disappointment of his United States Open defeat by Boris Becker to the back of his mind and impatient for another crack at the elusive Wimbledon title, appeared to be going through the motions during his round-robin match at the Stuttgart Classic. 
 Leconte, by contrast, hit the ball with the joy of a player savouring rare moments free of physical pain and won, 6-4, 7-6. 
 &bquo;This has been the worst year for me,&equo; Leconte said, recounting his six months out of the game with back trouble. 
 &bquo;This match is going to help me. 
 To beat the World No. 1, even in an exhibition, gives me confidence for the future.&equo; 
 Leconte had reason to be pleased. 
 The mere fact he had been invited to the eight-man special event represented progress. 
 His computer ranking would not get him into a 42-man field. 
 Lendl has never found it difficult to look sullen, and while blaming his lack of form on the fact that this was his first match indoors since the final of the Nabisco Masters in New York last December, lack of motivation was perhaps a greater factor. 
 Asked if he was bored, he replied: &bquo;I'm a little bit tired, I wouldn't say bored.&equo; 
 But the mere mention of his commitment to the new Association of Tennis Professionals (ATP) Tour, which starts next year, caused a grimace. 
 In common with several top players, Lendl is less than enamoured of the delays in promulgating a set of rules for the Tour which meet the desires of the competitors. 
 In response, certain players are procrastinating over signing their contracts &mdash; the deadline was on Monday &mdash; with the tour organisers. 
 &bquo;I don't know what the position is,&equo; Lendl said disdainfully. 
 &bquo;I've told Peter Johnson (his agent) to do what everybody else is doing. 
 I'm really sick of it.&equo; 
 he added. 
 &bquo;I don't agree with many of the things that are going on.&equo; 
 He refused to elaborate, but is known to have expressed dismay at a proposed increase in prize money for doubles which would give singles only a 70-30 advantage. 
 It probably did not help Lendl's mood that the net posts were adorned, in large letters, with the words &bquo;ATP Tour&equo;. 
 He has been asked to commit himself to 10 of the new Grand Prix tournaments next year, aside from the four Grand Slam events. 
 &bquo;Ten, including the Grand Slams, would have been fine for me,&equo; he said. 
 The apparent indifference seems to have spread to Lendl's attitude to the remainder of this year. 
 &bquo;I just have to play out what I'm committed to,&equo; he said. 
 Happily Lendl's humour resurfaced when he was asked what difference marriage had made: &bquo;Before I could do everything I wanted to do, now I have to ask.&equo; 
 Carl-Uwe Steeb, a local resident who defeated Leconte in three sets on Monday, gave John McEnroe an unfriendly welcome, beating the New Yorker 7-5, 7-6. 
 Becker then pleased the locals by defeating Argentina's Alberto Mancini 6-2, 6-3. 
 Sailing: Nautical and nice for Nauta 
 By STUART ALEXANDER 
 EQUITY &amp; LAW, The Netherlands' 60ft yacht skippered by Dirk Nauta, yesterday became the first of the smaller boats and 15th so far to finish the first leg of the Whitbread Round the World Race to Punta del Este in Uruguay. 
 As the only boat in Division C she wins that but is also expected to take the joint C and D prize. 
 Leading the remaining eight and due to finish today is Bob Salmon in the old maxi, Liverpool Enterprise, formerly Atlantic Privateer. 
 France's Esprit de Liberte leads Division D just eight miles ahead of Belgium's Rucanor Sport. 
 These two, and the first cruising division entrant, Creighton's Naturally, are forecast to arrive tomorrow. 
 The all-women crew on the British 58-footer, Maiden, skippered by Tracy Edwards, has now slipped to 70 miles behind Rucanor, but is expected to lead in Friday's trio followed by the second cruiser, With Integrity, the old GBII, and the West German yacht, Schlussel von Bremen. 
 Bringing up the rear is the smallest yacht in the race, the 51-footer La Poste, which is due to arrive on Sunday. 
 The fourth-placed British maxi, Rothmans, became the first to use the hoist at Montevideo sent by Whitbread as a gift to Uruguay. 
 She is to undergo repairs following the crack which appeared in the deck. 
 &bquo;We are treating this like a medical problem,&equo; Mike Pavitt, the project manager, said. 
 &bquo;The boat will be examined, diagnosed and treated. 
 It is not terminal.&equo; 
 Squash: Beeson casts asides aside 
 From RICHARD EATON in Kuala Lumpur 
 BRYAN BEESON and Jason Nicolle, two members of the England team whose make-up has caused so much controversy, created sensations yesterday when each of them brought down members of Pakistan's defending world title team at the World Open Championships here. 
 Beeson, the England captain, scored his first victory over the world No. 9, Zarak Jahan Khan, with one of the finest performances of his career, and then complained about the remarks he claimed his opponent had been making during the rallies. 
 &bquo;I told him that was quite unnecessary,&equo; Beeson said. 
 &bquo;It made me angry, and that sort of thing makes me get stuck in.&equo; 
 These results caused Jonah Barrington, the former world No. 1 who has waited an age for signs of Englishmen who might become world beaters in the way that he did, to make an interesting boast. 
 &bquo;At last we are getting the reward for our hard work and we will be challenging for the world title ourselves in a couple of years,&equo; he said. 
 There was another major upset when Ross Norman, the sixth-seeded New Zealander who won the world title in 1986 by ending Jahangir Khan's 51 2 -year unbeaten run, was also eliminated from the first round. 
 Norman lost 15-14, 15-11, 5-15, 15-13 to Anthony Hill, the Australian who was runner-up in the world junior championships to England's Del Harris. 
 Another Australian, Tristan Nancarrow, had a harder time. 
 Nancarrow, who has only just finished a ban for venting his anger by making an obscene gesture to a referee during the British Open, was reported to the tournament director for abusing match officials, his opponent, and the court. 
 He was also warned three times and docked a penalty point before losing to Pakistan's Sohail Qaiser. 
 Tennis: Wood leads the revenge 
 From Our Correspondent in Tokyo 
 JO DURIE, Clare Wood and Anne Hobbs did their best to banish a nine-month-old nightmare yesterday when they defeated Indonesia 3-0 in some style in the first round of the Federation Cup here. 
 Even though Durie and Hobbs were thousands of miles away at the time of Britain's demise at the hands of the Asians in Melbourne last December, the pair nevertheless felt the pain their colleagues were suffering. 
 &bquo;I was very upset and felt for those players who played,&equo; Durie said. 
 Wood experienced the feeling first hand, and judging by the way she crushed the Indonesian No. 2, Suzanna Kusuma, in the opening match yesterday, she was not taking any chances. 
 The Sussex youngster was on court for only 52 minutes for her 6-2, 6-1 triumph. 
 &bquo;We wanted revenge and I think we all felt the pressure because we wanted to win so badly,&equo; said Wood, who looked more like she was enjoying herself. 
 In contrast, at times Durie looked ready to scream, especially when the errors started creeping in during the second set of her 6-2, 7-6 win over the promising Yayuk Basuki. 
 Indeed, it was something of a typically topsy-turvy but none the less gritty performance from Durie, who missed a match point at 5-3 and then had to wait an hour to complete the encounter after rain fell at the end of the ninth game. 
 She completed victory by taking the tiebreak 7-5 but not before she lost her serve to 5-5 and then saved a set point at 5-6. 
 Such was the importance placed on the result by the players themselves that team manager Sue Mappin felt she was able to describe the win as a &bquo;huge boost&equo;. 
 Durie then teamed up with Hobbs to complete the whitewash with a straight-sets doubles win to earn Britain a second-round confrontation against Austria, the eighth seeds. 
 Chris Evert was another player thinking of revenge yesterday. 
 The last time she played in this competition she suffered a disastrous defeat and is keen to make amends. 
 Two years ago in Vancouver Evert was partnering Pam Shriver in the deciding doubles match against West Germany in the final. 
 The American pair built a seemingly impregnable 6-1, 4-0 lead, only to lose in three dramatic sets. 
 After opening this campaign with a 6-0, 6-1 win over Greece's Christina Papaduka, Evert said: &bquo;I feel I let the team down in that match two years ago. 
 I felt really devastated that we lost and for that reason I have been looking forward to playing in this event again.&equo; 
 Schools Football: Latymer Upper downed by Walshe's double 
 By Our Correspondent 
 THE HAPPY knack of winning, despite occasionally playing badly, has been the cornerstone of many a well-built team. 
 The boys of Cardinal Vaughan Memorial School &mdash; four wins in four matches &mdash; are catching on to it. 
 Tom Conway, the London school's master-in-charge, felt such sympathy for the Latymer Upper side, who outplayed his own team and lost 2-1, that he popped his head around the visitors' dressing-room door to say &bquo;Sorry&equo;. 
 Latymer had taken the lead after 10 minutes but, despite playing the better football throughout, were beaten by two scrambled goals from Rodney Walshe, one just before half-time and the other 30 seconds from the end. 
 Scrappy success has not been typical of Cardinal Vaughan's start to the season. 
 Under the mature captaincy of Stephen Flannery, they have been far more convincing in victories over Sutton Manor (2-0), Hampton (2-1) and Dr Challoner's Grammar School (4-1). 
 In Blackburn, when Queen Elizabeth and Clitheroe grammar schools meet for their annual contests, the fierce but friendly local rivalry is as intense as at any of the better-known great North-western derby matches. 
 In front of a sizeable crowd at the weekend, Clitheroe, the visitors, won 2-0. 
 David Booth took 30 seconds to give them the lead, taking advantage of a defender's clearance which deflected freakishly off an onrushing forward and into his path. 
 More than an hour of cut-and-thrust football followed, and both goalkeepers, especially Simon Taylor of Clitheroe and Lancashire, were kept busy before David Mason sealed his team's first victory of the season. 
 Strangely, it coincided with Queen Elizabeth's first defeat. 
 The first round of the English Schools' Football Association Under-15 competition is now complete, and there has been some spectacular scoring. 
 South Nottinghamshire, 1-0 ahead against North-West Derbyshire with 15 minutes left, suddenly moved into overdrive and finished 10-0 winners. 
 In potentially the most exciting tie of the second round, they will meet Hull, who beat Lindsey 8-1. 
 A second-half penalty enabled West Lancashire to eliminate last year's winners, St Helens. 
 Other particularly successful sides were Portsmouth (8-1 winners at Banbury) and Coventry and Middlesbrough, who enjoyed 6-1 wins over South Birmingham and Darlington respectively. 
 The final of the Inter-County Under-16 competition will be between Berkshire, who came from 2-0 behind to beat Essex 4-2 at Wokingham, and Greater Manchester, who won 2-1 against Nottinghamshire at Meadow Lane. 
 Basketball: Giants cut down to size 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 Giants, trailing by seven points after the first leg, took an aggregate lead as early as the fourth minute, but their game never flowed as missed shots and tired, sloppy defence allowed the Finns to stay in touch through their prolific three-point shooters. 
 The brothers, Ron and Gerald Lee, the latter a former professional in the NBA, controlled the tempo and Ron shot the Finns back in front on the night at 24-23. 
 Apart from Jason Fogerty, Giants' tallest players offered little threat inside, while playmaker Jerry Johnson spluttered in the first half. 
 But it was Johnson who so nearly turned the game in the second period as Giants clawed their way back from an aggregate deficit of 16 points at 46-37 behind. 
 Johnson hit the first of four second-half three-pointers, 6ft 7in Chris Kearney began to use his muscle while England international Dave Gardner found his range. 
 Giants went ahead at 69-67 through Johnson and as the momentum swung away from the Finns, overall victory suddenly seemed a possibility. 
 Johnson's fourth three-pointer and two shots from Gardner put Giants 80-75 ahead, but then Baskerville Holmes found Gerald Lee unmarked under Giants' basket and the home team needed to find another four points. 
 Keith Ramsey supplied three of them with a long-range shot 15 seconds from time, but Gerald Lee marshalled his team through. 
 American Football: Shanahan fired by Raiders 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 THE Los Angeles Raiders, who have lost three of their first four games, yesterday fired their coach, Mike Shanahan, and replaced him with Art Shell, their offensive line coach who becomes the first black head coach in the NFL since 1926. 
 Shell, one of the League's top offensive tackles for 15 years, made the Pro Bowl eight times as a Raider. 
 He joined the team's coaching staff after retiring in 1983. 
 Shanahan, who joined Los Angeles from the Denver Broncos in February 1988, guided the Raiders to an 8-8 record last year in his first season as an NFL head coach. 
 This season, the Californians have thrown away two fourth-quarter leads and fallen behind 28-0 to Denver in another game. 
 The Raiders are last in both rushing yards allowed (653) and penalty yards committed (307). 
 The team have also been called for 11 holding penalties in the last two games. 
 If the Raiders lose to the New York Jets at the Meadowlands on Monday night, it will be their worst start since 1964. 
 The only other black head coach in NFL history was &bquo;Fritz&equo; Pollard more than 60 years ago and for years the NFL has been repeatedly criticised by American civil-rights groups for its failure to name a black head coach from its ranks of qualified assistants. 
 Kevin Mack, the Cleveland full-back and two-time Pro Bowl selection, was yesterday sentenced to six months in prison after pleading guilty in August to using cocaine. 
 Racing: Ratings added to the service 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 THE RACING service of The Independent has been improved with the introduction of individual ratings to the form guide. 
 The horse with the highest rating in each race is deemed to have the best chance on form, though other influences will be discussed in the guide. 
 In theory, a horse with a rating two points higher than his rivals is considered to be 2lb &mdash; the equivalent of a length over a mile and a half - superior. 
 Each day's race cards will indicate which meetings are to be shown live in betting shops by Satellite Information Services (SIS). 
 In addition, where necessary there will be notification of horses &bquo;out of the handicap&equo;, and who are therefore at a disadvantage. 
 These horses have a Jockey Club official handicap rating that merits carrying a weight lower than the minimum weight allotted for a race. 
 Other innovations include a comprehensive presentation of results from the previous day's principal meeting, featuring the breeding of winners, the successful trainer and owner, extended distances, and details of the first six finishers. 
 Racing: Haines takes reins for sweet surgery 
 By JOHN KARTER, Racing Correspondent 
 THE much-maligned men of the Jockey Club have found a &bquo;sugar daddy&equo; to boost their image with a little cosmetic surgery. 
 That has been the typically cynical reaction to the appointment of Christopher Haines, a high-flyer from the sugar industry, as the Club's first ever chief executive. 
 Constructive criticism is a healthy thing, particularly where a self-electing body like the Jockey Club is concerned. 
 However, the type of cynicism greeting the arrival of Haines, who was officially introduced to the media yesterday on his second day in office, smacks very much of a &bquo;Pavlov's dogs&equo; response which assumes every move the Club makes is anachronistic and autocratic and therefore automatically to be shot down in flames. 
 Haines himself admitted that as an outsider his preconception had been that the Jockey Club was &bquo;An old-fashioned, creaking organisation of part-timers.&equo; 
 However, he added: &bquo;On my few visits prior to my appointment, and in my short time here since, I have found it very far from that. 
 I have been extremely impressed by the professionalism of the Jockey Club.&equo; 
 Haines, 50, should certainly know exactly what it takes to run a multi-million-pound industry, having climbed through the ranks to become chairman of the United Sugar Merchants Association. 
 Cynics may scoff that he is yet another stiff-upper-lip, old-soldier type, having come like so many of the august men of the Club from a military background before moving on to sugar. 
 And, as he admitted yesterday, he has little knowledge of the racing industry, apart from having been &bquo;a very amateur rider&equo;. 
 Furthermore, the fact that Haines must report to the Jockey Club Stewards and has no authority to act unilaterally has inevitably led to suggestions that his is merely a token appointment. 
 However, despite the fact that Lord Hartington, the Chief Steward, appeared to bolster this view by saying: &bquo;We are not forfeiting any power to Mr Haines. 
 He will be advising us on ways and means forward&equo;, Haines subsequently made it clear that he will not be an impotent lackey. 
 &bquo;I will certainly not be an intellectual &bquo;hands-off&equo; guru merely thinking up schemes,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The Jockey Club are looking for action and I hope what I devise will be practical and can be implemented.&equo; 
 Haines's main tasks are to produce a &bquo;strategic plan&equo; for the Jockey Club, focusing on its role within the racing industry; ensuring that the needs of racing are effectively understood in Whitehall and Westminster; responsibility for the Club's financial planning and maintaining close liaison with the Levy Board and the Horseracing Advisory Council. 
 Possibly, Haines's public &bquo;unveiling&equo; should have been left for a while as he felt unable at this early stage to give firm views on major issues, such as racing's finances and Jockey Club justice. 
 In fact, the most eye-opening statement came from Lord Hartington in response to a question about Alan Meale, the Labour MP who has proposed legislation to abolish the Jockey Club. 
 &bquo;If Haines recommended the Jockey Club should be abolished we would have to consider it and if we felt it was for the benefit of racing we would do it,&equo; Lord Hartington said. 
 In this case the cynics might be right to say that pigs will fly. 
 However, the overall feeling is that the Jockey Club is genuinely concerned with helping the industry move forward and Haines should at least be a given a chance to show what he can do. 
 Racing: Cumani to steal the Thunder 
 By HYPERION (RICHARD EDMONDSON) 
 SUPPLEMENTARY benefit beckons for seven fillies today in Newmarket's Cheveley Park Stakes, the early 1,000 Guineas trial that has become more valuable than the Classic itself. 
 Connections of seven of the 11-strong field have persuaded themselves that their chances merit the late production of a &pound;10,000 entry fee, beliefs that have pumped up the penalty value to over &pound;133,000. 
 Two of the new participants, Chimes of Freedom and Dead Certain, look set to dominate the betting. 
 Chimes of Freedom, who came out a short-head in front when the pair met over course and distance in July, should emphasise her superiority judged on a recent defeat of Pharaoh's Delight at The Curragh. 
 However, she may not cope with another supplemented runner, LINE OF THUNDER (nap 3.10). 
 The daughter of Storm Bird has enjoyed a formative career typical of Luca Cumani's juveniles, having been heavily nursed on her debut, over course and distance, before showing the benefit on subsequent outings, at Yarmouth and Goodwood. 
 Cumani, unlike many of his counterparts in the vanguard of British trainers, has not given the Cheveley Park saturation coverage in the past. 
 His last runner, in 1985, was Embla, who won in the hands of Angel Cordero. 
 The man entrusted with the steering this year is Ray Cochrane, who proved that 20 days on the sidelines had not dulled either his skills or competitive edge when driving home a double at Wolverhampton on Monday, his first day back, and adding another winner yesterday. 
 The Bedford House team could hardly be in better form either. 
 Llanfranco Dettori, who completes a swift graduation from the apprentice nursery school to the academy of retained riders next season, won on all three Cumani runners at Brighton yesterday. 
 The destiny of another big race at this course, the Cesarewitch on 21 October, may become clearer after the performace of Beekman Street (1.30). 
 Victory for the colt who caught a diminishing view of Cesarewitch favourite Travelling Light at Ayr could see another shuffle in the ante-post market. 
 While Newmarket's competitive card will examine punters' emotions, there will be advice for the excitable at Cheltenham racecourse, where the Chest, Heart and Stroke Association will give visitors a &bquo;Human MoT Test&equo;. 
 Rugby Union: A French test for the Home Unions 
 From STEVE BALE in Paris 
 IF THE Home Unions XV are tempted &mdash; as they may be after all the disruptive absentees and injuries &mdash; to go into tonight's Parc des Princes Bicentenary bash less than seriously, they should consider the way the French are treating it. 
 For Jacques Fouroux, France's coach, the 1991 World Cup starts here. 
 Caps are to be awarded but after two Test defeats in New Zealand Fouroux has had a clearout which brings in four newcomers and creates a largely unfamiliar pack designed to take on Australia next month. 
 The French team have been together since Sunday &mdash; and even that was not enough for Fouroux. 
 He wanted them to gather last Friday and be absented from their weekend round of Championship matches, but even Albert Ferrasse, the autocratic French Federation president, would not stand for that. 
 In fact it worked out well for Fouroux, since most of his players ran into the sort of form which, if reproduced tonight, will make the Home Union's players wish they were just that &mdash; at home. 
 Philippe Sella, for instance, scored three tries for Agen against Ussel, and his co-centre Marc Andrieu two for Nimes against Lavelanet. 
 Unfortunately for the Lions, as the French persist in calling them, they will have had nothing like the preparation time of their opponents. 
 Having made what they hope will be their final change, David Egerton for Phil Davies at No. 8, they had a light run-out at a ground next door to Parc des Princes last night and will have another this morning. 
 It hardly augurs well &mdash; especially as none of them have won an international in Paris. 
 However, the Lions believe British Isles rugby to be on the way up after their win in Australia and at least feel they have something to prove. 
 &bquo;We need to uphold the growing reputation of British rugby,&equo; said Rob Andrew, who would confess to being third-choice captain (after Finlay Calder's non-availability and Donal Lenihan's withdrawal). 
 &bquo;We need to show this generation of British players that France are not unbeatable in Paris. 
 It's especially important for the seven England players because we have to come here in the Five Nations in the New Year.&equo; 
 Andrew might also consider it a useful opportunity to further his England captaincy claims, for which he has a growing number of supporters &mdash; although he expresses no such wish, since his old school-mate, Will Carling, currently holds the job. 
 Athletics: British athletics may be torn apart by ITV contract 
 From STEVE BALE in Paris 
 BRITISH athletics may be torn apart by a &pound;7m four-year exclusive contract the sport is about to sign with ITV. 
 A separate deal may be offered to the BBC by disgruntled factions. 
 The Southern Counties, the most powerful area within England's Amateur Athletic Association, has written to the AAA president Arthur McAllister protesting about an ITV deal which will eliminate cross-country and road running completely from its screens, as well as meetings in Edinburgh and Northern Ireland. 
 The South may withdraw their grand prix meeting from the ITV deal, and team it with the rejected meetings as an alternative package for ITV's rivals. 
 The South claim there is a lack of concern for the interests of the sport in the widest sense from TV negotiators. 
 Football: ITV ready to drop the Anfield spectacular 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 LIVERPOOL against Manchester United, one of the brightest jewels in ITV's Barclays League programming, will almost certainly not be seen on television this season. 
 Definite confirmation of ITV's withdrawal from the fixture can be expected today. 
 This First Division match, always one of the most emotional, fiercely fought contests of the season, was originally scheduled for last Saturday. 
 As this date did not come within ITV's planned winter programme of Sunday afternoon games a new date was proposed, December 22, a Friday night with a kick-off at 8.05, prime-time viewing guaranteed to capture a huge audience in holiday mood. 
 Neither club was pleased, supporters were furious and Liverpool were reported to have protested strongly. 
 There was much concern expressed on Merseyside about the safety aspects of a match kicking off that late in the evening on the day when all the tradtional pre-Christmas parties are held in offices and factories. 
 In the past it has taken great efforts by the Merseyside and Greater Manchester police to keep supporters apart in what is widely thought to be the most intense antagonism in the League. 
 Granada's Head of Sport Paul Doherty ruled out any likelihood of a Saturday afternoon fixture being screened: &bquo;We have contracted events, notably indoor athletics. 
 If the match isn't played on the Friday night then it's difficult to see when it could be scheduled.&equo; 
 A Football League spokesman admitted: &bquo;The fixture is still under review and we are aware that some concern has been expressed about playing on the Friday night.&equo; 
 Meanwhile the League has written to Sunderland, demanding an explanation for their refusal to admit cameras from Tyne-Tees Television to Roker Park for the game against Newcastle. 
 ITV is understood to be concerned about what it sees as a weakening of its expensive agreement by individual clubs. 
 Sunderland asked for a &pound;50,000 facility fee for admission to their match with Middlesbrough. 
 John Barnes and Gary Gillespie are misssing from Liverpool's squad to play Wigan in the Littlewoods Cup tonight, putting their participation for England and Scotland in World Cup qualifying games next week in doubt. 
 Both have hamstring injuries. 
 Mark Aizlewood, Bradford City's midfield player, has pulled out of the Welsh squad for their World Cup game against The Netherlands next week after having an operation on a fractured cheekbone yesterday. 
 He will be out of action for a month. 
 Tommy Wright, the Newcastle United goalkeeper, has withdrawn from the Northern Ireland squad for the World Cup qualifying tie against the Republic in Dublin. 
 He is suffering from an ankle injury and a virus infection. 
 Newcastle have signed 37-year-old John Burridge from Southampton for &pound;25,000 as cover. 
 Manchester City are making a new attempt to sign Colin Hendry, the centre-half who has not played for Blackburn Rovers since failing to agree personal terms with City and Chelsea a month ago. 
 Both clubs were prepared to pay the &pound;700,000 Rovers wanted for the 23-year-old, but withdrew when they heard the player's wage demands. 
 After four weeks without a game Hendry is prepared to moderate his terms, and City contacted the Second Division club on Sunday to resurrect the deal. 
 West Bromwich Albion hope to sign Chris Coleman, Swansea City's 19-year-old left-back, for a fee in the region of &pound;200,000. 
 Dave Smith was confirmed as the new manager of Fourth Division Torquay United yesterday. 
 He succeeds Cyril Knowles, who resigned on Monday. 
 Alan Curtis, the former Welsh international striker, yesterday signed for Swansea after being given a free transfer by Cardiff. 
 Football: Robson back in the swing 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 Manchester United.. 0 Portsmouth......... 0 (United win 3-2 on agg) THE NEWS for England is excellent. 
 Bryan Robson, doubtful for the World Cup match against Poland 24 hours ago, returned for United last night to cruise for 20 minutes before erupting into Captain Marvel, never shirking a tackle and being denied two goals only by the crossbar and a brilliant diving save from Alan Knight. 
 The news for United's vast following is less euphoric; a subdued crowd of 26,698, the backlash to the Derby defeat, saw them fail to add to the three goals of the first leg. 
 Portsmouth must take some of the blame for the stalemate for they came defensively formed and defensively minded, and content to rely on breakaways to snatch an equaliser and, faintly possibly, a winner. 
 They almost achieved the former on the stroke of injury-time when Kevin Ball headed against the underside of Jim Leighton's bar. 
 In a bright opening, Mark Hughes, 10 yards out, hit a cannonball that flew off Knight's legs. 
 In the second half, Paul Ince, running on to a free kick, beat Pompey's wall to see the ball deflected off Knight's body. 
 Ince and United's other huge investments, Mike Phelan and Danny Wallace made spasmodic contributions, Gordon Pallister looked considerably more settled but United's growing concern must be in the form of the striking partnership of Brian McClair and Hughes. 
 Both played well last night, infiltrating Pompey's blue barriers with speed, strength and footwork but again neither scored. 
 The suspicion is that they are too similar in style and are both playing the same game. 
 Afterwards Alex Ferguson had some heartening words for England manager Bobby Robson on the availability of his captain. 
 Ferguson said he would back the United and England skipper if Robson said he was fit to play. 
 Ferguson said: &bquo;I'd be happy to let him go because it is important for England and I don't want to seem obstructive.&equo; 
 Football: Drinkell steps up for Coventry 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 (First Edition) KEVIN DRINKELL, Coventry City's record signing from Rangers, is set to make his debut for the Sky Blues in the Littlewoods Cup tonight, against Grimsby Town, the club where he spent the first nine years of his career. 
 Drinkell will be joined by Cyrille Regis, the former England striker, at Highfield Road tonight. 
 Coventry, who have not won in the three matches Regis has missed with a calf-muscle injury, trail 3-1 from the first leg, but Drinkell was optimistic, saying: &bquo;It's not irretrievable. 
 All is possible in football.&equo; 
 Coventry are likely to be without three regular players: Brian Kilcline, the captain and centre-half who is still suffering from a leg injury, midfielder Dean Emerson (knee), and Micky Gynn (bruised shoulder). 
 Steve Bull, Wolverhampton's England striker, has a hamstring injury and may miss tonight's Littlewoods Cup tie with Aston Villa at Molineux. 
 Bull, who has scored four goals in the last two games, did not train yesterday after picking up the injury during Saturday's 5-0 win over Portsmouth. 
 Bull's absence would be a big disappointment for Wolves as his fellow striker, Andy Mutch, is almost certain to be sidelined for the third game in a row with a groin injury. 
 However, defender Nicky Clarke and midfielder Mick Gooding should have recovered from knee injuries in time. 
 Football: Whitton leads the rout 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 Aldershot.............. 0 Sheffield Wednesday.... 8 (Wednesday win 8-0 on agg) RON ATKINSON'S blue and white army marched down Ordinance Road, past the Cannon pub and fired the Shots out of the Littlewoods Cup with a devastating display of firepower which brought Steve Whitton four goals and Dalian Atkinson three. 
 Atkinson (the manager) says his bottom-of-the-table team were so bad in one of the five defeats they have suffered in eight First Division games that he found himself joining in with the cries for his dismissal. 
 Like Terry Venables calling for a pre-match arsenic, the old trouper knows that the best way to disarm your critics is to make &bquo;em laugh, but the joke has been wearing a bit thin, and it was with some relief that he swopped his sheepish smile for a satisfied one. 
 Wednesday may have started the season like a Second Division side, but for all the shortcomings exposed in the League, they are still much too good for opponents from the Fourth. 
 Aldershot's defence were as square and ragged as a new intake of squaddies having their first stab at the right dress, the gifts they distributed coming like manna from heaven to a team who had managed just two goals in their first nine games. 
 A goalless first leg at Hillsborough had left the whiff of an upset mingling with the burgers and Bovril, but Wednesday cleared the air ruthlessly with four first-half goals in the space of 23 minutes. 
 The first, after 22, saw Whitton dispatch Atkinson's cut-back from the byline on the right. 
 The second, seven minutes later, came courtesy of a ludicrous back-pass by Ian Stewart, which left Atkinson one on one against the unfortunate David Coles, who picked the wrong night to return to the Aldershot goal after injury. 
 Whitton's second, in the 38th minute, must have warned the crowd nearly 1,000 below the Recreation Ground's 5,000 capacity that they were in for a dispiriting night. 
 There was no challenge as the former West Ham and Birmingham forward buried Craig Shakespeare's corner with an emphatic downward header. 
 Atkinson, matching his attacking partner goal for goal, belted in the fourth from 20 yards, and the only question remaining after the most one-sided of first halves was which of them would be first to his hat trick. 
 Atkinson shaded it, but both were home and dry by the 53rd minute. 
 Whitton pulled ahead five minutes later when he cantered through a demoralised defence to shoot home unopposed, but it was Shakespeare (who else?) who had the last word, breaking the strikers&equo; monopoly with the eighth goal, 10 minutes from the end. 
 Would &bquo;Flash&equo; be breaking out the champagne? 
 Would he heck. 
 &bquo;We'll enjoy our fish and chips,&equo; he said, adding enigmatically &bquo;we're not that far away from Liverpool.&equo; 
 Football: Allen takes strain for City return 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 (First Edition) CLIVE ALLEN, the Manchester City striker, may be back in contention for the visit to Arsenal on 14 October. 
 City feared Allen would need an operation after the groin strain he sustained against Queen's Park Rangers, one of his former clubs, on 10 September. 
 Allen, who has missed the last four games, said: &bquo;I must admit I was a little concerned and went to see the same specialist that did the operation on my groin before. 
 He told me I could be back in a fortnight.&equo; 
 Garry Parker yesterday signed a new four-year contract with Nottingham Forest. 
 The midfield player, bought from Hull 18 months ago for &pound;250,000, scored 10 goals last season, including two in the Simod cup final against Everton. 
 Brian Clough, the Forest manager, said: &bquo;His contract was not expiring but he deserved a rise for the contribution he has made over the last 12 months -so he earned himself a new deal.&equo; 
 QPR explained yesterday how Kenny Sansom, their former England left-back, was left behind after the goalless draw against Stockport County on Monday. 
 Sansom, capped 86 times for England, was still talking to friends in the players' bar at Stockport County last night when the rest of the squad left on the team bus after their 2-1 aggregate victory. 
 &bquo;I don't know what all the fuss is about,&equo; Clive Berlin, QPR's managing director, said. 
 &bquo;Kenny had been given permission to fly up to Stockport later than the rest of the lads because one of his children was ill. 
 &bquo;It was always planned he would come back on the bus, but when the usual head count was made for the return journey we, of course, had the same number as when we started out &mdash; without Kenny.&equo; 
 The bus had gone only 150 yards before the mistake was realised. 
 &bquo;Stories about him having to get a taxi home are complete nonsense,&equo; Berlin said. 
 Goalkeeper David Seaman damaged a shoulder against Stockport but is expected to be fit to report to the England squad tomorrow. 
 The Sheffield United winger, Alan Roberts, is on the verge of moving to Fourth Division Lincoln City if the clubs can agree on a fee. 
 Roberts, on the transfer list at his own request, cost United &pound;15,000 from Darlington last year. 
 The United manager, Dave Bassett, now values him at &pound;70,000, but his Lincoln counterpart Colin Murphy will not go above &pound;50,000. 
 &bquo;Just because he wants to leave is no reason for us to strike a bargain price,&equo; Bassett said yesterday. 
 Marco van Basten, the European Footballer of the Year, gave European champions Milan a timely boost by returning to the squad for training this week for the first time since a cartilage operation on 1 September. 
 The Dutch striker, whose scoring touch has been badly missed, hopes to play for part of next Sunday's away game at newly promoted Cremonese. 
 More importantly, Van Basten has his sights on the European Cup second round, first leg tie on 18 October with Real Madrid. 
 Van Basten scored twice in last season's 6-1 aggregate semi-final victory over the Spaniards. 
 Milan, who faltered at the weekend with a 3-0 defeat at the hands of the current league leaders, Napoli, have slipped to seventh place, partly because of the absence of van Basten and his compatriot, Ruud Gullit, who is seeing a doctor on Monday about his cartilage injury. 
 Football: Motherwell climbs to top of the Scottish Premier Division 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 MOTHERWELL climbed to the top of the Scottish Premier Division for the first time since League reconstruction 14 years ago with a 1-0 win over Rangers at Fir Park last night. 
 Davie Cooper and Bobby Russell conspired against their old club, Cooper creating the opening for Russell to score after six minutes. 
 Football: Maskell's show of extra spirit extends Forest 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY at Leeds Road 
 Huddersfield Town.... 3 Nottingham Forest.... 3 (aet; score at 90 minutes 3-3; Forest win on away goals) NOTTINGHAM FOREST, the Littlewoods Cup holders, stayed in the competition by the skin of their teeth last night at Leeds Road, where it took the League's away goals regulations to defeat the otherwise indomitable spirit of Huddersfield in a stirring tie. 
 &bquo;Almost like old times, Denis,&equo; as a happily departing season-ticket holder remarked to Mr Law of the BBC, while in the directors' box Mr Boycott, a guest of Brian Clough, was unsure whether to smile for his friend or sigh for his county. 
 Forest, held to a 1-1 draw at the City Ground, were 3-1 ahead with 17 minutes of normal time left, and deservedly so; they had come out for the second half bristling with determination to make quality tell. 
 But Huddersfield refused to let them coast. 
 Craig Maskell scored his second goal, and when the 21-year-old striker helped Mike Cecere to bring the teams level even the deserted Cowshed, with its condemned roof, seemed to shake with emotion. 
 Huddersfield were more than resilient. 
 Some of their football was remarkably composed for a Third Division side in adversity. 
 But further heroics in extra time were beyond their weary limbs and so Stuart Pearce, the Forest captain required by England for next week's World Cup tie in Poland, completed a victorious return from injury. 
 It had been a fair old fitness test. 
 Forest had been comfortable enough for most of the first half. 
 They went ahead in the 30th minute when Tommy Gaynor skipped away from a couple of tackles and let fly from 25 yards: no sign of gratitude there for Eoin Hand, Huddersfield's manager, who had helped along his fellow-Irishman's career in the early days at Limerick. 
 Hand's team, however, replied impressively seven minutes later when Maskell, transfer-listed at his own request after scoring 33 goals last season, scored his first of this, Cecere laying the ball off to the ambitious young man whose crisp drive was a powerful argument for a rise in status. 
 Forest regained the lead four minutes into the second half when Gary Crosby, chasing Nigel Clough's clever pass, swept past Chris Hutchings and poked the ball between Steve Hardwick's legs. 
 It seemed all over in the 63rd minute when Clough, a few yards outside the penalty area, volleyed a headed clearance instantly into the roof of the net before Hardwick could move a muscle. 
 For Clough, too, that was the season's first goal, and a corker. 
 But Maskell was not finished. 
 His free-kick went through the Forest wall, and Huddersfield were in full cry. 
 Their football was a credit to Hand, and Cecere ensured that it would at least be rewarded by an extra 30 minutes when he collected Maskell's pass and tucked the ball behind Steve Sutton. 
 Kevin Ratcliffe, the Welsh international captain, was takenoff with a groin strain as Everton drew 2-2 with Leyton Orient in the second leg of their Littlewoods Cup tie, going through 4-2 on aggregate. 
 Ratcliffe, who is in the Welsh squad for next week's World Cup qualifier against The Netherlands was carried off after a fifth-minute collision with Geoff Pike. 
 He joins Neil Pointon and Martin Keown on Everton's injury list. 
 East Germany accuses Bonn over refugees 
 From EDWARD LUCAS in Prague and PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 AS SOME 3,000 East German would-be emigrants poured into West Germany's embassy in Prague yesterday, the East Germans, apparently furious at the latest development, accused West Germany of &bquo;gross breach of trust&equo;, claiming that Bonn had promised to stop the flow. 
 About 150 East Germans also entered the West German embassy in Warsaw. 
 In East Germany, the pressure for change continued to build, with about 10,000 demonstrators in Leipzig demanding reforms. 
 Some of them chanted &bquo;Gorby, Gorby&equo; in what was described as the largest protest in 35 years. 
 Government officials in Bonn said that the Soviet Union had played a key role in obtaining the agreement under which the thousands who had taken refuge in the Prague and Warsaw embassies were taken to the West at the weekend. 
 As news of the exodus spread, more East Germans, who were already in Prague, made their way to the embassy yesterday. 
 At one point more than 100 an hour were entering the embassy. 
 Police tried to pull away refugees climbing over the embassy's back fence last night, but they moved aside when the West German ambassador, Hermann Huber, appeared in the garden and said: &bquo;Let them go!&equo; 
 Members of a group attempting to reach the embassy the night before said policemen had hit them with rubber truncheons and turned them back. 
 As dawn broke yesterday, the same group, this time led by a mother with a baby in arms, faced down the police patrols and reached the embassy successfully. 
 On Sunday West Germany had complained about the police presence around its embassy, and the slackening of restrictions is thought to have reflected an apparent Czechoslovak desire to remain as far as possible on good terms with both Germanies. 
 West Germany has so far denied, although with a detectable degree of ambiguity, that any deal was made, preferring to point to the humanitarian reasons for allowing an evacuation of the embassy, and the pressure supposedly exerted on East Germany by the Soviet Union to bring the occupation to a speedy end. 
 But from East Germany's angry response to the opening of the embassy doors - echoed, ominously, by Czechoslovakia &mdash; it appears that East Germany was at least expecting a quid pro quo. 
 The desire of Hans-Dietrich Genscher, the West German Foreign Minister, to deliver the West German side of the bargain appears to have been dissolved by the prospect of television pictures showing young East German families, including pregnant women, hungry and crying on the pavement outside an unwelcoming West German embassy. 
 News of the Prague embassy's open door seems likely to provoke a greatly increased flow of new emigrants from East Germany. 
 Czechoslovakia remains in effect the only country to which East Germans can travel without a visa. 
 Although a change in this policy is now much talked about, it would be a dramatic concession of failure by the leadership, deeply unpopular, and therefore thought unlikely at least until after the increasingly macabre celebrations of East Germany's 40th anniversary on Saturday. 
 East Germany closes border as 6,000 more leave 
 From EDWARD LUCAS in Prague and PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 IN ANOTHER spectacular climbdown by East Germany, more than 6,000 East Germans, who had filled the West German embassy in Prague beyond bursting point, were allowed to leave for the West last night. 
 Earlier, East Germany imposed restrictions on travel to Czechoslovakia. 
 In the week of their country's fortieth birthday, East Germans were effectively imprisoned within their own borders. 
 Early yesterday morning the West German Embassy in Prague had done what it always denied it would do, and closed its doors. 
 The move &mdash; taken after senior Red Cross officials in the embassy said further arrivals would jeopardise the position of those already inside &mdash; left 1,200 new arrivals, including hundreds of small children and babies, sitting forlornly on the pavement for most of the day. 
 Inside the embassy, conditions were said to be worse that ever, with intense pressure on sanitary facilities. 
 More than a thousand children were inside; on Monday night, most had slept three to a bed. 
 East Germany's climbdown came after intense diplomatic pressure from Bonn. 
 Crisis meetings were held in Bonn and East Berlin all day, but Helmut Kohl, the West German Chancellor, was refused a telephone conversation with the East German leader, Erich Honecker. 
 In Moscow, Pravda published fierce criticisms of Bonn's open-door policy, complaining of an &bquo;assault on the stability in the centre of Europe&equo;, and of a &bquo;noisy propaganda campaign dripping with chauvinism&equo;. 
 Chartered trains were due to leave Prague yesterday evening, but had failed to appear more than two hours after the appointed time. 
 A West German government spokesman said there had been technical hold-ups, but he was confident the refugees would leave soon. 
 The key to yesterday's deal is that a problem of this magnitude is now unlikely to happen again. 
 So long as East Germany kept its Czech border open, any evacuation of would-be emigrants from the embassy was only a temporary solution, signalling to still more East Germans that a conduit to the West existed. 
 However, the problem is by no means solved. 
 Even though travel to Poland, for example, involves considerable difficulties for East Germans, several hundred have been able to seek refuge in the West German embassy in Warsaw. 
 The East German-Czechoslovak border is one of the most lightly fortified in Europe. 
 East Germans in Prague said they had seen building work begin at the weekend to make it more effective. 
 But many more East Germans may try to cross the Czechoslovak border illegally. 
 Others will continue to have legitimate reason to visit Prague. 
 There were more than eleven million trips from East Germany to Czechoslovakia last year. 
 East Germany has not introduced the tough visa requirements necessary for travel to, for example, Hungary. 
 During the early part of the day in Prague, East Germans waited quietly, apparently believing that the crowd outside the embassy was in fact a queue. 
 Even when told of the embassy's closure, few seemed alarmed: &bquo;Well, they can't just leave us here, and we're not going back, so they'll have to do something,&equo; said one. 
 Television pictures of the huge and well-organised exodus from the embassy over the weekend had clearly instilled a touching &mdash; and, so far at least, ultimately justified &mdash; faith in the Federal Republic's ability to look after all Germans, both East and West. 
 As the day went on, some became impatient. 
 About three hundred burst through a police cordon between the park behind the embassy and the road outside. 
 Using a stray plank, and ropes thrown over by those inside, they scrambled over a 12ft wall into the embassy grounds. 
 Police at first used rubber truncheons to prevent them, but then stood back. 
 Fifteen East Germans were slightly injured and one was receiving medical care for internal injuries. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Kinnock sets out policies to win power: Warmly-received conference speech seen as change of gear for Labour in run-up to general election 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 NEIL KINNOCK yesterday set investment in education and training as his top priority: the &bquo;commanding height&equo; to be scaled by the next Labour government. 
 In his address to the party conference at Brighton, Mr Kinnock said Labour was now ready, eager and able to take power from the Conservatives at the next election, and his confidence won him one of the most prolonged and enthusiastic ovations received by a Labour leader for many years. 
 His attack on the Conservative government, given added impact by passages of scathing wit, also included an analysis of Margaret Thatcher's &bquo;out-of-touch, out-of-date&equo; foreign policy. 
 Identifying her attitude to the emerging democracies of the Soviet bloc, disarmament, South Africa, the environment, Third World debt, and the EC, Mr Kinnock said: &bquo;Margaret Thatcher shows that she's from the Greta Garbo school of diplomacy. 
 &bquo;I want to be alone.&equo; 
 That's the constant theme.&equo; 
 Colleagues said last night that the speech marked a change of gear &mdash; as Mr Kinnock moved away from party organisation and policy and accelerated into the election campaign. 
 Lord Callaghan, the last Labour prime minister, said: &bquo;What happened in the 1980s was a temporary aberration from what has always been the real position of the Labour Party, and Neil Kinnock has recaptured the traditional position.&equo; 
 But Mr Kinnock stressed in his speech that given the inevitable and unprecedented &bquo;mess&equo; which would be left behind by Mrs Thatcher, a Labour government would have to set &mdash; and unflinchingly stick to &mdash; four basic priorities. 
 Warning that there was no single mechanism which would catapult Britain to economic strength, Mr Kinnock said: &bquo;Research and development, transport and communications, science, education and training; they are the priorities. 
 They are the productive base of our economy.&equo; 
 They were prerequisites &mdash; &bquo;an unparalleled priority&equo; &mdash; for dealing with inflation, the balance of payments deficit, unemployment, and funding the party's policies for social justice. 
 Having delivered his &bquo;tough&equo; message, Mr Kinnock turned to prime targets of the Conservative record &mdash; topped off with high interest rates, which he likened to a policy of assassination for mortgage-holders. 
 Even if the Conservatives took &bquo;the brakes off&equo; in the run-up to the next election, people would not be deceived. 
 &bquo;It's one con-trick too far.&equo; 
 Analysing the difference between Labour and the Tories, Mr Kinnock said that while Labour planned ahead for the future, the Government waited for the future to come and hit them. 
 They had neither made adequate preparation for the Single European Market nor allowed for proper funding for the Channel tunnel. 
 &bquo;That attitude towards the future is not good enough for the British people. 
 It's not good enough to serve the future. 
 They're not good enough for the British people. 
 We are now.&equo; 
 Concluding, Mr Kinnock looked beyond the conference: &bquo;It is an encouragement, an inspiration to see this party working together, coming to a joint position on objectives, and of not only telling itself, but exuding to the British public the feeling that we are fit to serve our country.&equo; 
 At the start of his speech Mr Kinnock repeated that Labour would win &bquo;with no horse-trading and no electoral pacts&equo;. 
 The party now offered &bquo;the kind of socialism that the British people want'- defending the NHS, opposing poll tax and the erosion of civil liberties. 
 The Labour Party Conference: The priorities: education, transport, science, research 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 EDUCATION AND training were now the &bquo;commanding heights&equo; of every modern economy, Mr Kinnock told the conference. 
 He said: &bquo;Now and for all time in the future, human skills and human talents will be the major determinants of success or failure &mdash; not just for individuals but for a whole society in all of its social, cultural and commercial life.&equo; 
 That was why investment in training would be the &bquo;most important&equo; priority of all. 
 But he also emphasised the need for greater spending on transport and communications, science and research and development &mdash; programmes which could yet take priority over health spending under a Labour government. 
 Mr Kinnock said: &bquo;We are going to start to combat the transport congestion and make investment in communications without which commercial Britain will judder to an expensive halt in a very few years. 
 &bquo;We are going to build up the commitment to science because if we carry on like the Tories are, our country is going to be shoved down to the second or third division of modern industrial nations&equo;. 
 As for investment in public and private research and development, Mr Kinnock said: &bquo;If we are going to rival our competitors, we are going to have to start by catching up with them.&equo; 
 Noriega troops foil Panama coup attempt 
 From LERNA LLERENA of Reuters 
 PANAMA CITY &mdash; Troops loyal to the Panamanian military leader, General Manuel Noriega, put down a coup attempt by junior officers in the capital yesterday after a day of heavy fighting, a spokesman for the Panama Defence Forces said. 
 At least 20 of the rebel junior officers who staged the uprising surrendered by late afternoon. 
 The Noriega forces had gained entrance to the barracks headquarters where a group of army offices mutinied early yesterday. 
 &bquo;Everything is under control,&equo; said Major Edgardo Lopez Grimaldo, a spokesman for the PDF and a senior Noriega aide, as the rebels, in civilian dress, were led from the barracks by members of the 2000 Battalion, the general's elite combat force. 
 In Washington, the White House said the coup attempt appeared to have ended in failure. 
 President Bush's spokesman, Marlin Fitzwater, admitted: &bquo;It does appear that his (General Noriega's) forces are in control.&equo; 
 Mr Fitzwater reiterated President Bush's denial earlier in the day that the United States, which has indicted General Noriega on drug trafficking charges and has been seeking to oust him for nearly two years, had initiated the revolt. 
 A communique read on Panama's national radio in the afternoon denounced the coup attempt and said General Noriega was still in control of the country. 
 The statement poured scorn on a rebel broadcast several hours earlier saying that the junior officers, led by a group of captains, had ousted the military leader and his general staff. 
 The broadcast said the coup attempt was led by Major Moises Giraldi, head of the battalion responsible for General Noriega's security. 
 It was also signed by two captains, Javier Licona and Jesus George Balma, known to be unhappy at recent promotions of majors loyal to the general, at the expense of officers considered of questionable loyalty. 
 Jose Blandon, former head of intelligence for General Noriega, now in exile in the US, said he understood that the latest attempt was timed to coincide with military exercises which stranded loyal troops on an island several miles from Panama City. 
 Fighting centred on the main barracks, the Balboa port section of Panama City, close to the main bridge leading over the canal, and in the old part of the capital, which is a maze of slums and anti-military feeling. 
 The decisive battle for control of Panama was fought at the building that houses military headquarters. 
 The compound is about 800 yards from the Pacific entrance to the Panama Canal, where the 12,000 US military personnel of the US Southern Command were put on full alert. 
 American helicopters hovered near the Panamanian Defence Forces headquarters, and US soldiers in combat gear took up positions a few hundred yards away to block a road leading to the canal. 
 Witnesses reported seeing dead soldiers and hearing rocket and machine-gun fire. 
 No casualty figures were available, but civilians living near the headquarters fled. 
 Woman &bquo;was seized during SOS call&equo; 
 By HEATHER MILLS 
 A PREGNANT woman who was beaten and stabbed to death in daylight had been abducted as she telephoned for help on the M50 motorway, a court was told yesterday, writes Heather Mills. 
 Just 700 yards away her baby son and 11-year-old sister sat in her broken-down car, Shrewsbury Crown Court was told. 
 The civilian operator who took the SOS call may have heard the voice of her killer. 
 He then heard the sound of a car driving away. 
 Two days later, the battered and bloodstained body of Marie Wilks, 22 and seven and a half months pregnant, was found dumped down an embankment two miles along the motorway. 
 A knife wound had severed her jugular vein and her jaw was broken from a punch or a kick, the jury was told. 
 Edward Browning, 36, a nightclub doorman, has pleaded not guilty to murdering Mrs Wilks. 
 Supreme Soviet bans strikes by workers 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 THE Soviet parliament last night imposed a ban on all strikes in industries essential for the smooth functioning of the economy this winter, and authorised the use of troops if neccessary to guarantee an immediate end to the rail blockade by Azerbaijan, which is crippling neighbouring Armenia. 
 The almost unanimous passage of the decree, by 364 votes to 6, came at the end of a day of turmoil at the Supreme Soviet sitting in the Kremlin. 
 A compromise solution, it was secured largely thanks to unashamed procedural bullying by Mikhail Gorbachev, who warned that only unequivocal, draconian measures could avert a slide into economic chaos. 
 The measure applies to the transport sector, to the fuel and energy industries, and to metallurgical and chemical enterprises. 
 Above all it is aimed at the country's railways, where disorganisation and disruption and not only in politically-inflamed Soviet Transcaucasia have caused dangerous shortfalls of coal and oil stocks at power stations, and of other raw materials at factories across the country. 
 The outcome was none the less a climbdown for the government, which was obliged to drop its original plan to outlaw strikes in all sectors of industry for 15 months, amid deep divisions among parliamentarians over the extent of the powers to be granted. 
 Instead, the new provisions will operate only until passage of a draft law on strikes, which itself bans such industrial action where it would endanger &bquo;lives and health&equo;. 
 This Bill, which sets out detailed mechanisms for settling disputes, could be passed early next week. 
 This in turn will be supplemented by other key decisions last night: for a law &mdash; unprecedented here placing emergency powers at the government's disposal by the end of October, and for another Bill within a month to regulate rail traffic. 
 In the meantime, central and local authorities have been told to take &bquo;immediate&equo; steps to stamp out vandalism and sabotage on the railways. 
 But the success has been hard-won. 
 Its manner has exposed the procedural inexperience of the first full-time Soviet legislature and the ideological divisions of its 542 members. 
 In the past, such a sweeping move would have taken the form of a peremptory decree, but the new parliament is committed to doing everything by the rules. 
 Thus the overnight talks produced a woolly draft which Leonid Abalkin, the Deputy Prime Minister in charge of economic reform, attacked as &bquo;too weak to have any effect&equo;. 
 By 391 votes to 6, the proposed text was sent back to the drafting committee. 
 Three hours of frantic work in the afternoon produced a new one, pushed through without ceremony by President Gorbachev. 
 Even so, it offers no guarantee of an early end to the month-old blockade of Armenia by Azerbaijan, an extension of their feud over the region of Nagorny Karabakh. 
 The rejected text gave the parties until Monday to resolve the dispute, failing which the government would take full powers for the railways in Transcaucasia, and send in the army to guard bridges and tunnels, and ensure the safety of rail workers. 
 Now they have been told to restore normal services &bquo;without delay&equo;, but no deadline is stipulated. 
 Today the Azerbaijani leadership is to hold emergency talks on the crisis. 
 The venomous exchanges between deputies from the two republics in the Kremlin yesterday offered little hope that reason would prevail. 
 FILM / Observing the breach: Kenneth Branagh's Henry V 
 By ADAM MARS-JONES 
 IN A culture and a century that have doubts about matching up to Prince Hamlet, feeling fitted at best to the role of attendant lord, it's astonishing that Shakespeare's Henry V should become, except at a time of national emergency, a resonant figure of any sort. 
 He has so few doubts, and his objectives are so suspect. 
 The England he represents is not so much irrelevant as antithetical to any modern image of Britain. 
 Nevertheless, Kenneth Branagh has saddled up the old warhorse and given it new colours. 
 As well as starring and directing, he has adapted the play for the screen, though that isn't to say, quite, that he has translated it into film language. 
 Branagh's version retains a Chorus &mdash; Derek Jacobi in voice-over or in twentieth-century mufti (greatcoat and scarf), sometimes even sharing the frame with the action &mdash; though arguably the camera can be trusted to set the scene unaided. 
 A camera tracking across an antiquated map of France, on the other hand, is being under-employed. 
 There are flashes here and there of more ambitious screen writing. 
 While Falstaff (Robbie Coltrane) is dying, Pistol (Robert Stephens) remembers him in former days, carousing and then pleading with Hal not to banish him when King. 
 But this flashback turns out not to represent a memory, or at least not Pistol's memory, since King-to-be Henry repudiates him in voice-over, without Hal's lips moving, though Falstaff reacts as if the words were spoken aloud. 
 Compression of this sort, practised more widely, might succeed in bringing the play over into a new medium. 
 In an isolated instance, it seems a sign of inexperience, of trying to include too much; and certainly the virtues of the film remain theatrical. 
 There are disadvantages to this, naturally, also. 
 Branagh himself, for all his vocal assurance, has a flat, thin-lipped, distinctly inexpressive mouth, a considerable drawback for a screen actor, especially in close-up, where a viewer's attention is likely to flicker back and forth between mouth and eyes. 
 The film reunites a number of the principal actors from the 1984 RSC production, but a true feeling of ensemble would be too much to hope for. 
 Inevitably, the impression is not of unified excellence, but of a sort of march-past of British theatrical talent. 
 Too many of the minor roles become cameos, and a cameo is either an ornament or a blot, but in either case tends to detract from the momentum of a film. 
 Before Bardolph opens his mouth, for instance, he is a strange-looking man with a nose like a pear marinated in port; but when he speaks, he is Richard Briers, trailing all his light-comedy associations. 
 Conversely, when a cameo works, it imposes its own dynamics on the film. 
 It is an irrelevant disappointment that after her delightful scene with Princess Katherine (Emma Thompson), Geraldine McEwan as Alice has nothing to do but adjust a veil or two and look pleased. 
 The irrational thought almost occurs that Shakespeare couldn't have been that smart if he didn't realise that he had here a performer who can turn sows' ears into silk purses, and silk purses into live butterflies. 
 How could he have failed to find some extra business for her? 
 Such are the perils of power-house casting. 
 To offset them, this new Henry V (PG) offers a well thought-out progression from peace to war, from council chamber to battlefield, from words to deeds. 
 Henry's court is a place of dramatic lighting and suppressed excitement, while the atmosphere of the French deliberations is more informal, full of frustration and weariness. 
 There is a certain amount of splendour at Harfleur, with Henry in the breached wall, back-lit by yellow explosions, but it doesn't last. 
 Before Agincourt, the French tents are well-appointed, and the mood is impatient, while the English soldiers huddle fatalistically under a hostile sky. 
 The battle itself is a welter of savage confusion. 
 It is in the battle scenes that the new film differs most from Olivier's prototype, and Branagh can fairly claim to have stripped the veneer of jingoism from the play, by showing war in its true horror. 
 But the situation isn't as simple as that. 
 For one thing, it is technically easier, and cheaper, to represent a battle as a series of muddy brutalities in slow motion than as an exhilarating spectacle. 
 But more to the point, Shakespeare didn't envisage Agincourt being fully enacted in the first place. 
 War in Henry V is a test of kingship rather than a subject in its own right. 
 Henry's achievement in the play is not military as such, but rhetorical. 
 He doesn't prove by feat of arms, but by words, that he is not any more the dissipated boy that he was; but that is enough. 
 He finds a way of talking about England, about right, about courage as a sort of secular sainthood, and it is his words, acting on his army, that bring France down. 
 The French messenger Mountjoy, bringing an insult from the Dauphin, is met with a fierce defiance that leaves him, in this version, visibly shocked. 
 There is no suggestion in the play that Henry's defiance might be hollow. 
 In this drama, words are deeds, and right from the start Henry talks like a winner. 
 At the siege of Harfleur, it is Henry's words that lead directly to the surrender of the town. 
 He gives a convincing account of what is in store for the inhabitants if they continue to resist, and his words acquire the force of the deeds he describes. 
 It is only late in the day that the weary French King (Paul Scofield) gears up his own hostile rhetoric, and then he entrusts the actual campaign to various representatives, the Dauphin, the Constable, Orleans, who cry up only their armour and their horses, and are rhetorically out-ranked even before the battle begins. 
 Seen from this point of view, the battle itself is actually irrelevant to Shakespeare's purpose. 
 So, what of Branagh's purpose, if the &bquo;realism&equo; of the film is beside the point? 
 Clearly, he has some sort of affinity with the part of King Henry, but it doesn't seem an actorly affinity. 
 Branagh, too, talks like a winner, and Henry V offers him better than any other play in the repertoire what might be called a yuppie dynamic, a mythology of success and self-definition rather than of struggle. 
 This is not to deny that Branagh is at his best as a performer in Henry's most anguished outpouring, his prayer to the god of battles before Agincourt; here Branagh the actor is least hampered by Branagh the self-publicist. 
 But it is fair to say that the real chemistry is not between actor and part, but between the idea of the star as entrepreneur and the idea of the king as a self-made man. 
 Both Kenneth and Henry, on the stage or battlefield and off it, talk their different ways to triumph. 
 This, though, unlike the identification that Henry makes in the course of the play between himself, his cause and his country, is not an identification easily shared by mere onlookers. 
 FILM / Tragic comedians, life in a miner key: Ariel, Wired, K-9, Cookie and Play Me Something 
 By SHEILA JOHNSTON 
 CINEMA outside Hollywood used to come in national waves, but no longer: China has been silenced for a while, and the work emerging out of Africa has been distributed too sporadically to seem like a movement. 
 But Aki Kaurismaki, who accounts, with his brother, for more than one-third of the Finnish film industry, makes a movie a year and has a stake in distribution, constitutes a national cinema, all by himself. 
 In Ariel (15) a miner who has been made redundant heads south to Helsinki and falls in love. 
 &bquo;I've got a kid,&equo; she warns him. 
 &bquo;Excellent,&equo; he ripostes. 
 &bquo;We'll save time starting a family.&equo; 
 Kaurismaki doesn't hang around either: dispensing with longueurs (Ariel runs 74 minutes, B-movie length), he traces the man's unsuccessful search for work and inevitable lapse into petty crime with clipped, deadpan comedy. 
 The cool narrative economy and unforced style recall early Fassbinder. 
 And, while none of the industrial townscapes could be described as pretty, he has a terrific eye. 
 Introducing Wired, his biography of John Belushi, Bob Woodward recalls how the rigours of research involved going to bed early so as to rise at 4am to visit one of the comedian's favourite watering holes. 
 Annotated, logged and indexed, his book scarcely illuminated Belushi's demons, or the system that supposedly destroyed him. 
 But it did summon up the delicious image of the straitlaced reporter gingerly dipping his toe, notebook in hand, into the showbiz underworld. 
 The film of Wired (18) features Woodward (J T Walsh) as straight man to the podgy comedian, but though subtitled &bquo;the laughs and times of John Belushi&equo;, it is woefully short on the former component. 
 While the book charted his passage through Chicago, New York and finally Los Angeles, it largely skips the first two circles of hell. 
 The story begins in a morgue, with Belushi (honourably played by Michael Chiklis), dead from drugs at 33, hopping off the slab to review his life with a guardian angel. 
 This ill-advised conceit casts a pall on the piece from the outset, and it doesn't help that the skits (rewritten and reconstructed) are crushingly unfunny. 
 But the trouble, you feel, lies with Belushi. 
 It may be that his gifts lay in the thrill and risk of live performance, losing their savour in aspic; or, more likely, that his genius was always over-rated. 
 Wired purports to be about America not just Belushi, but this is trite stuff about decadence in Tinseltown; what it has to say about the nation is nugatory, unless you count a depressing scene in which an audience collapses in laughter while the Voice of its Generation (as Bluto in Animal House) stuffs a sandwich down his pants. 
 &bquo;Belushi's a book,&equo; believes Woodward, but one is inclined to agree with the cop who pronounces him &bquo;just another fat junkie who went belly-up.&equo; 
 K-9 (12), which stars James Belushi, hints at the less than glittering screen career that might have awaited his elder brother, had he lived. 
 It concerns yet another pair of mismatched cops, with the disposable novelty of one of them being a dog, which tends to restrict verbal sparring, along with the mangy dialogue and Belushi's lack of manic spin. 
 Cookie (15) is a disappointment, for its credentials look promising on paper. 
 Directed by Susan Seidelman and co-written by Nora Ephron, it is a &bquo;high-spirited comedy&equo; about the Mafia, not an easy genre as Married to the Mob and even Prizzi's Honour have demonstrated. 
 Emily Lloyd is charmless as the daughter of Peter Falk's ageing gangster, though Dianne Wiest has her moments as a fluffy moll with claws of steel. 
 Play Me Something (15) is set on a small Hebridean island where a group of passengers await their plane. 
 A dapper stranger hoves into view. 
 &bquo;So many stories,&equo; he says with a puckish smile. 
 &bquo;So many stories here. 
 Waiting to be chosen.&equo; 
 Reason, one might think, for the wary traveller to duck behind the luggage lockers, but no, the assembly listens rapt as John Berger (for it is he) embarks upon a long yarn about two Italian peasants who meet at a Communist Party dance. 
 Timothy Neat directs tricksily; the aim is to reflect on different ways of telling stories. 
 But its insights rarely exceed the banal. 
 FILM / Rushes 
 By SHEILA JOHNSTON 
 COMING soon, maybe: a triumph for the gods of chaos, lunacy and bad taste - or, to put it more plainly, a film version of John Kennedy Toole's wonderfully funny cult novel, A Confederacy of Dunces. 
 As followers of these pages will know, this project was at one time to have been directed by a America's leading connoisseur of chaos, lunacy and bad taste, John Waters (who made Pink Flamingos and Hairspray). 
 This plan came to grief, however, when Waters, in an attempt to establish friendly relations, gave a prospective producer a copy of one of his books, which showed the idiosyncratic director palling up with one of Charles Manson's gang &mdash; a gesture which was in even worse taste than it might sound, as the producer proved to have been a good friend of one of the gang's victims. 
 Now, though, comes the word that Confederacy is being developed by Ivan Reitman &mdash; coming up soon in Ghostbusters II, which he also wrote &mdash; and if all goes well, he will be directing it for 20th Century Fox. 
 There is as yet no word on who will play the part of Toole's hero, the bloated medievalist Ignatius J Reilley, though earlier suggestions for the part have included the late Divine (Waters's idea) and the late John Belushi (the studio's idea). 
 As the part requires an actor of substantial proportions, the obvious choice would be someone like John Candy or John Goodman (of David Byrne's True Stories and Channel Four's Roseanne) &mdash; though he may be simply too nice to play Ignatius, and is anyway busy perfecting his bowling technique for his upcoming appearance as Fred in the live-action version of The Flintstones. 
 From a slightly more elevated plane of cinematic endeavour comes news to warm the heart of Woody Allen. 
 Ingmar Bergman, who for some years now has been insistent that Fanny and Alexander was his farewell to the moving image, has decided to stage a come-back with a project called The Good Will. 
 Set in Uppsala at the beginning of the century, it tells the story of Bergman's parents, and will be made for two different formats: as a four-part series for televsion, and as two feature films for cinemas. 
 Unfortunately, Bergman has decided not to direct his own script, but has instead put it in the hands of the Danish director Bille August, who made Pelle the Conquerer, which won last year's Palme d'Or at Cannes and which Bergman is rumoured to like so much that he has already seen it six times. 
 FILM &mdash; SET REPORT / Liver birds and lager louts: James Rampton visits Willy Russell's latest film 
 By JAMES RAMPTON 
 LOCATION shooting in Liverpool can present problems. 
 Failing to find an appropriate site for a shot, the location manager on the new Willy Russell venture, Dancing Through The Dark, decided to mock it up by erecting a spanking new bus shelter in Wavertree, one of Liverpool's livelier areas. 
 When the camera crew arrived three days later, the shelter was covered in graffiti and all its glass had been shattered. 
 Such unpredictability can offer advantages, however. 
 During a night shoot outside the Locarno Ballroom, a leather-clad punk skidded past on a skateboard &mdash; pulled by a pair of Dobermanns. 
 He was immediately roped in as an extra for the night. 
 There were no such thrills the day I visited the set of Dancing. 
 I had been promised a gripping afternoon's shoot in the Locarno Gents (where the original play was entirely set). 
 Unfortunately, they were behind schedule and I had to make do with a curry-house scene. 
 This turned out to be an object lesson in how to lay waste to an Indian Restaurant. 
 In welcoming the crew, the Rajah Curry House in Liverpool 13 cannot have anticipated the battlefield of cables, cameras and kormas it was to become. 
 The scene, a stag-party's post-pub, pre-dancing meal, was not going well: it was up to the fourteenth take, and the continuity man was looking frazzled. 
 Not only did he have to keep wafting a smoke machine to create that distinctive curry house fug, and smoking cigarettes down to the level of the previous scene; he also had to keep up a steady supply of fresh poppadums. 
 But I felt sorriest for the actor who had to down 14 half-pints of (non-alcoholic) lager. 
 With a tight budget of around &pound;2m, the crew must watch how much it lashes out on lager. 
 Adapted from Russell's 1978 stageplay, Stags And Hens, about a stag-night and a hen-party which converge at the same venue, it is the first BBC-funded film ever to receive a full cinematic release (next Spring) before its television broadcast (September 1991). 
 Inspired by the success of Film On Four and the ITV companies' recent forays into film-making (like Granada's My Left Foot), the BBC has finally taken the plunge into the feature-film market, in partnership with Palace Pictures and British Screen. 
 The co-producer is Russell's wife, Annie, who has long considered Stags And Hens a suitable vehicle for a film: &bquo;I badgered Willy into it&equo;. 
 Her presence now &bquo;makes script conferences a lot easier.&equo; 
 An American studio had approached Willy for the rights to the play, but &bquo;they envisaged a Brat Pack movie, packaging first and script later,&equo; and he turned them down. 
 What with one Oscar-nominated script (Educating Rita) and another potential hit (Shirley Valentine) behind him, ex-hairdresser Russell was not sniffy about translating his own work from stage to screen. 
 &bquo;Millions of people will see the film who'd never step into a theatre to save their lives. 
 You have to put on a completely different hat.&equo; 
 For Dancing Through The Dark, Russell has also had to wear his composer's hat, scoring five new songs and all the background music. 
 &bquo;It's a question of pragmatism, because we found to obtain rights to certain tracks would have cost more than the budget for the entire picture. 
 We were going to use a four-second snatch of The Hokey-Cokey, and were quoted &pound;3,000. 
 It pays to write your own stuff.&equo; 
 In a further cost-cutting exercise, Russell has volunteered to play a pub drunk. 
 He has confidence in the director, Mike Ockrent, experienced in theatre but a film debutant: &bquo;You don't do Follies or Me And My Girl by phoning it in.&equo; 
 He and Ockrent go back a long way &mdash; to a jointly written screenplay for Paul MacCartney, which &bquo;never saw the light of day &mdash; a damn shame, because it was a lot better than Broad Street. 
 The only problem was it had to incorporate Wings&hellip;&equo; 
 Ockrent is still trying to tone down his screen actors &mdash; &bquo;remember there'll be twenty feet of grimace up there&equo; &mdash; but he retains the keenness of a novice: &bquo;You get the excitement of a first night every ten minutes.&equo; 
 Not to mention the Dobermanns. 
 TELEVISION / Classy product 
 By FIONA MADDOCKS 
 BENEATH an excess of plum-coloured satin, two well-matured dormant bodies stir grumpily to the digital blips and bleeps of a high-tech quartz alarm. 
 Open-mouthed and stale-breathed, they greet the day with a groan. 
 The wife, a book called Enjoy Your Menopause almost sharing her pillow (a privilege unlikely to have been enjoyed by her husband since early days of marriage), slumbers on. 
 Vic, though, is a man of action. 
 Dragging himself through the daily routine which gets him into his beige-toned synthetic fibres and out of his neo-neo house, he roars off in his Jag (number plate, VIC 100), fag in mouth, Carly Simon on cassette, ready to take on the world. 
 Elsewhere, the twin bells of a sturdily traditional wind-up clock squeal, wakening another slumbering pair, younger, fresher, clearly less ossified in their morning habits than the first but equally resistant to the day. 
 Here she, not he, is the anxious worker, soon dressed, pausing briefly over The Guardian Women's Page and muesli before climbing into her clapped-out Renault and heading for her own day of action. 
 The opening of David Lodge's television adaptation of Nice Work (BBC 2), his latest novel, immediately establishes the contrasting worlds inhabited by Vic Wilcox, Managing Director of Pringle, a Midlands engineering firm (or &bquo;J Pringle-and-sons-how-may-I-help-you?&equo; as the dolly receptionist intones) and Dr Robyn Penrose, temporary Lecturer in English at Rummidge University, devout feminist and campaigner against education cuts, bombs, racism and most other things. 
 That this first episode entailed a prolonged bout of frenzied cross-editing -from bed to bed, car to car, lecture room to board room, production line to picket line &mdash; was, perhaps, inevitable. 
 Until Vic and Robyn's lives coincide, when she goes to &bquo;shadow&equo; him for an improbable Industry Year project, the viewer needs as much information as possible. 
 They begin, after all, as caricatures who only take on further dimensions as the tale develops. 
 But the technique felt laboured, and may have confused anyone not familiar with the book to which Lodge, in his own screenplay, sticks fairly closely. 
 A few scenes stood out awkwardly: Robyn soothing her tearful female student who can't do her essay because has to do a bit of modelling to make up her grant ('It's not fair,&equo; she sobs, in one of the script's less ingenious lines); Robyn's unlikely outburst at a Pringle meeting when an Asian worker is nominated for sacking. 
 But these are also weaknesses in the original, which won't worry Lodge fans but tend to agitate the unconverted. 
 In general, Nice Work transfers perfectly to television. 
 The dialogue is crisp and stinging, the setting (in Birmingham University and environs) authentic, the cast ideal. 
 Warren Clarke makes a superbly unattractive and boorish Vic, face in repose like a flat tyre. 
 Haydn Gwynne, looking uncannily like Meryl Streep, makes a rather better-groomed Robyn than expected, versatile, spirited and wholly watchable. 
 On this showing, people who avowedly hate his novels may find themselves hooked to this series. 
 A sober and numbing Inside Story (BBC 1), &bquo;The Forgotten Holocaust&equo; related how the gypsy population of Europe, like that of the Jews, was wiped out by the Nazis. 
 Survivors quietly described how families were destroyed, women abused, men castrated; how the Gestapo made them play their gypsy violins even while they performed their atrocities. 
 By its restraint, George Case's programme provided a long-overdue and eloquent epitaph. 
 MUSIC / Indian ghost dance: An opera by Ravi Shankar premiered: Ghanashyam &mdash; Birmingham 
 By JAN SMACZNY 
 PART OF the City of Birmingham Touring Opera's brief is to involve and appeal to a broad community. 
 CBTO's brief to Ravi Shankar in their first commission was &bquo;to create a piece which would be both beautiful and meaningful to today's audience&equo;. 
 What we were offered, if definition is needed, might be called ballet-pantomime: it was certainly not opera. 
 As in the best ballet-pantomimes, the message is direct in origin and presentation. 
 At times the method is decidedly crude, especially in a hint of West Side Story which concludes the overture, doubtless aimed at &bquo;today's audience&equo;. 
 Oddly enough, Ghanashyam (A Broken Branch) approaches opera in the nature of the story it tells: originating in village festivities, the tale unfolds a rake's progress towards perdition, in this case via drugs, but with an extra metaphysical twist when the spirit of the departed returns to inhabit his wife. 
 While the intentions of the plot are clear enough, it is not significantly developed by the dance. 
 Rather, the story acts as a framework for a series of ornamental tours de force. 
 The mime and dancing is throughout spectacular, a delight to the eye. 
 The performance of Durga Lal in the title role is a masterpiece of versatility and concentration: his delirium at the end of the first act is nothing short of hair-raising. 
 To say that the recipe is naive would be to miss the point, but with the predominance of so much dance, drama is often lacking. 
 For instance, the death of Ghanashyam is, frankly, anticlimactic with most of the emphasis thrown onto the lovely succeeding threnodic dance. 
 In the first act, where the action is presented in a series of tableaux, the dance enhances the spectacle superbly. 
 By the second act, with its greater density of incident, I found my sympathies withdrawing. 
 CBTO's production is a splendid frame for the work of some prodigiously talented performers. 
 Graham Vick produces the work effectively and unobtrusively, and Paul Brown's convincing three-dimensional set was a near-perfect match to the action. 
 Ravi Shankar's score, drawing elements in from a wide range of sources, is both seductively lyrical and at times rhythmically complex. 
 Providing a continuous texture, the music never pales and only in the shock-horror theme associated with drugs approaches banality. 
 Apart from some relentless over-amplification, the music, directed by Ashit Desai, emerges with enormous verve. 
 As a whole, this grand spectacle was a rare hit with what seemed to be as varied an audience as any opera company is likely to find these days. 
 Ravi Shankar has given his audience a work of undeniable beauty, but whether this captivating setting has rendered the tale equally &bquo;meaningful&equo; is another question entirely. 
 MUSIC / On the Golani heights: Canadian Music Festival &mdash; QEH 
 By ROBERT MAYCOCK 
 SPENDING last weekend at the National Federation of Music Societies' conference, it was heartening to see the determination of the amateur promoters to match the skills of the professionals. 
 It is a pity some of the professionals were not there learning alongside them: back on the South Bank a full-scale festival of Canadian music is running all week, but its profile has barely risen to the Plimsoll line. 
 If you were one of the few to risk the Queen Elizabeth Hall on Monday, you would have been able to find no information about the composers being played. 
 No Canadian jokes, please, but doing this on the nation's behalf just plays up to stereotypes. 
 There is a crack group like Nexus here, for heaven's sake, and nobody knows. 
 Two of the Nexus percussionists played on Monday, along with another musician who is one of the finest current exponents of her instrument, the violist Rivka Golani. 
 Considered purely as a recital by Golani, this was a riveting evening: in such a degree of intimacy her restless prowling, crouching, rising to full height, even stamping, combines with the intense commitment of her playing not to impede the music but to dramatise it, to add a further dimension to its urgency. 
 The page-turner wisely sat far back, following his own score. 
 Most of the pieces, certainly, needed all the dramatising they could get. 
 The better of them were for viola alone, including Brian Cherney's Shekhinah, in its first performance: this alternates furious tremolando, sudden violent attack, and wistful melody, invented or quoted. 
 Cherney said (in the only programme-note) that he had been inspired by Golani's bearing as well as her playing, and although the density of events was not high, the sense of concentration and unity between music and performer was total as the wilder elements were gradually exorcised and a numb calm remained. 
 Prousse, by Jean Papineau-Couture, argued an intense and clearly delineated course from climax to climax: the most powerful of the evening's compositions, and the one most likely to attract other players. 
 These were both composers of the middle generation, known quantities by name at least, like Michael Colgrass whose Variations for Viola and Percussion ended the official programme in Bartok-and-Brittenish style, unfortunately with a built-in wrecking device for its own atmosphere: the drums must constantly be retuned. 
 Robin Engelman, who coped patiently with the percussion part here, had a marginally less exciting time in Bruce Mather's Gatinara, where easy-going alternations of viola and marimba once took off in a bout of vigorous hocketing, but not for long. 
 Messages IV suggested greater youth in its composer, Stephen Tittle, who used a sort of minimalism with interruptions to build up a spirited and engaging little number, though hardly one to overstretch the skills of Bob Becker, the percussionist this time. 
 Becker and Engelman combined only for a pleasantly smoochy encore by David Jaeger, composed this year and arranged by Engelman from a piano accompaniment to the viola. 
 But it was Golani's night, even when hidden by scores that sprawled along a row of eight music stands, of which the eighth always stayed empty &mdash; just another of those little unexplained things. 
 THEATRE / The Southern cross: Michael Church on From the Mississippi Delta at the Young Vic 
 By MICHAEL CHURCH 
 THE STAGE is a backyard bounded by a palisade of rusty corrugated iron; two ladders lead up to a balcony, a tap drips into a can. 
 A black girl wanders on softly singing a country blues, and is joined by two others also singing; the light is dreamy, the harmony sweet. 
 The opening scene of From the Mississippi Delta is both beguiling and assured. 
 The girls then settle to tell a story: of a lady called Aint Baby, born with no parents and no name, and raised by her own efforts to local prominence as a midwife; of Aint Baby's daughter Candy, product of a night of casual lust with a passing drifter, and of Candy's haphazard rise to an academic doctorate at a university in the liberal north. 
 The daughter's story proceeds serenely at first, then hits a sickening crunch; raped at 11, she is shot into wary adulthood. 
 Transitory moments are offset by big set-piece scenes with many characters: a difficult birth, and a fair where Candy discovers she can upstage the leading lady by a lewd trick with a cigar between her legs. 
 Then comes the train journey to Chicago, the low life amid the bright lights, and the dawning of wisdom in the form of the Civil Rights brigade. 
 The rest is not so much history as anti-racist herstory. 
 The events are presented in episodic form, as a continuous narrative tossed antiphonally to and fro between the actresses. 
 This was the method pioneered in the RSC's Nicholas Nickleby but, in contrast to that brilliant tapestry, the effect here is one of relentless monotony. 
 Endesha Ida Mae Holland, the author of this veiled autobiography, is described in the programme as a popular lecturer and &bquo;story-teller&equo;: she works the same seam as Maya Angelou, Toni Morrison and Alice Walker (whose spirit she fulsomely invokes, and whose book The Color Purple she implicitly recalls at every turn). 
 But Holland's particular trademark is a cute and cloying sentimentality, with pathos laid on thick. 
 Her story-telling has no obliqueness, no mystery; everything is slowly and patiently explained, as though the audience was a fidgety bunch of six-year-olds. 
 The two directors have done their best, speeding the tale along on the wings of Bessie Smith and mouth-organ blues. 
 And the actresses themselves are a delight: Josette Bushell-Mingo has an extraordinarily mobile face and an infectiously comic manner, Joy Richardson shows an uncanny ability to get inside a 10-year-old's skin, and Angela Bruce, as the mother, has natural authority. 
 The rape scene takes place with breathtaking violence, the fair exudes riotous conviviality, and the Brer Rabbit japes come over with gusto. 
 The accents are entirely convincing and the authentically Southern atmosphere implies an ever-present threat from white oppressors lying in wait beyond the cosiness of the backyard palisade. 
 By the interval, though, the show already felt overlong; as Act Two ground into heavily didactic gear the procession of events seemed interminable. 
 I joined Endesha Holland's class eager to learn; I left it hating school. 
 THEATRE / An Inca's curse: Royal Hunt of the Sun &mdash; Palace, Manchester 
 By JEFFREY WAINWRIGHT 
 FROM Atahuallpa to Crazy Horse, whether represented as savage enemies of Christian civilisation or denizens of Utopia, the people of pre-Columbian America are a European invention. 
 Perhaps it is not possible to produce Peter Shaffer's 1964 play about the conquest of Peru in a way that is informed by our subsequently increased awareness of how such representation works. 
 But in wondering it is interesting to compare a much more recent success, David Henry Hwang's M Butterfly. 
 Hwang's devotion to theatrical effects suggests that he shares Shaffer's belief that &bquo;peacockery is one of the dramatist's obligations&equo;, and both plays concern an effort at a human relationship across cultural difference: Pizarro's fascination with the defeated Inca god-king Atahuallpa, and Gallimard's desire for his Butterfly. 
 But whereas in M Butterfly the theatrical flash and illusion is entirely implicated in the theme of the representation and misrecognition of one culture by another, in The Royal Hunt of the Sun, at least in this revival, it has no such purpose. 
 If anything, Tim Pigott-Smith's touring Compass production accentuates the way that the Inca are conceived in European terms. 
 Atahuallpa, 33-years-old we are carefully informed, is unmistakably a Christ-figure, and throughout the second half Jack Klaff is dressed and posed accordingly, culminating in a pieta in Pizarro's arms. 
 None of the cumbersome religious debate dispels the fundamental message of &bquo;Christ re-crucified-again'. 
 Certainly the foreign mystery of the Inca &mdash; part of it feminine &mdash; stirs Pizarro's bluff existentialist heart, but the play and production defines it too readily in familiar terms. 
 At a more basic level this version of Incadom is not remotely convincing. 
 Paul Hernon's costumes feature several vivid patchwork quilts for the nobility (though one seems to have made a pioneering landfall from The Mikado) and others suggest cousinship with Little Plum. 
 Apart from the thrilling cries that try to resurrect the king, and the still figure of Jack Klaff, there is nothing radical or dynamic in either the vocalisation or the movement. 
 Among the conquistadores only Robert Clare's Venetian artillerist has the scale and style to compel the Palace, much less Peru, though Matthew Sim's young Martin convinces. 
 As Pizarro, Denis Quilley is suitably grizzled but the character's ponderous despair seems to have submerged his generalship. 
 Is this a play still capable of generating new meanings? 
 Tim Pigott-Smith and his team have not to my mind found them. 
 I wish they had done better with the peacockery. 
 THEATRE / Miseries of the New Man: Marrakech &mdash; Lyric Studio, W6 
 By PAUL TAYLOR 
 I'M NOT a New Man; I'm a failed house-husband,&equo; moans Walter in Graham Swannell's self-directed two-hander. 
 By the same token, Marrakech is not a new comedy; it is a failed feasibility study for one. 
 All that it demonstrates, through a three-hours-seeming 75 minutes, is that counter-stereotypes tend to harden into stereotypes in their turn. 
 Certainly, after a brief period of novelty, the hapless, aggrieved house-husband threatens to become as rigid and unexamined a comic invention as the grotesquely intrusive mother-in-law once was. 
 At first, you are led to think that Marrakech means to start where A Doll's House (or more accurately here A Guy's House) ends. 
 The person preparing to slam the door is Walter (charming Gregory Floy), a landscape gardener who gave up his job to look after his GP wife Vivien (Morag Hood) and their (inevitably) stripped-floor, stripped-pine flat. 
 Fed up now with being a domestic skivvy, he is seen typing out the goodbye letter before leaving for Marrakech, where he plans to write a novel based on their sex life. 
 For the rest of this unbudgeably static play, the couple lounge around discussing the pros and cons of doing a bunk. 
 Equipped by Morag Hood with an accent that sounds strangely reminiscent of Edward Fox as the Duke of Windsor, Vivien stops Walter in his tracks by announcing that she is pregnant. 
 He suspects this is a ruse. 
 That he evidently supposes that a 43-year-old woman, hitherto miserably infertile, could make cod claims on such an issue tells you rather less about Walter than it does about Graham Swannell's flimsy and opportunistic approach to characterisation. 
 You also notice that, because this plot development requires the couple to have been childless, there was clearly no previous necessity for either of them to stay at home. 
 Walter's position as house-husband is just an affectation, the result of having read &bquo;all the right books&equo;. 
 Of course, handled well, this last fact could be a comic strength. 
 But, on the dodges and self-deceptions of role reversal, this play is indefatigably predictable. 
 Adjusting to middle-age is its other main concern, with Marrakech (perceived by Walter entirely through the lush vagueness of travel-brochure prose) standing for the life of exotic, unfettered opportunity that becomes increasingly unattainable. 
 In a couple of the play's best moments, Swannell craftily shows that the remembered adventurousness of youth is often just as illusory. 
 Walter claims to have journeyed as a student to Nepal ('didn't everyone? ') for purification, but Vivien reminds him that he only got as far as Ostend. 
 Middle-age is the time, Swannell deftly shows, when men say butch things like &bquo;I'm not going to die under a duvet,&equo; whereas, in truth, they would die if they couldn't. 
 Into the more general laments on modern living, Vivien inserts a couple of rather good jokes about the privatisation of the Health Service, but these feel like last-minute topical interpolations. 
 In any case, with her languidly top-drawer vowels and spaced-out grandeur, Morag Hood makes Vivien seem like the kind of woman who would find it taxing enough cutting the tape on the new ward, let alone fighting to keep the old ones open. 
 At one point, Walter tries to convince his wife that he has had a story accepted by BBC Radio. 
 Nothing in Swannell's direction of his play persuades you that this would not have been a better home for Marrakech. 
 Commodities: Coffee 
 By PAUL TAYLOR 
 ROBUSTA Coffee futures saw further losses, with prices falling to fresh 14 year lows in mid-afternoon trading. 
 Contracts closed with losses of &pound;32 to &pound;44 a tonne despite late shortcovering and technical buying which helped the market stage a partial late rally. 
 There was a similar move in New York. 
 Continued liquidation and heavy selling followed Tuesday's developments at the International Coffee Organization talks, where Brazil said there was no chance of bringing quotas back near-term. 
 Dealers said near December continued to have a large open position, causing some concern at the exchange. 
 Volume totalled 9,489 lots. 
 Small Business: Cut European red tape, says minister 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 TIMOTHY EGGAR, employment minister, underlined the Government's policy towards small businesses this week by attacking the European Social Charter, the proposal by the European Commission to harmonise working practices. 
 &bquo;The charter is ill-conceived and bad for small firms,&equo; he told the Confederation of British Industry's small firms council. 
 He argues that the small firms sector is particularly well situated to benefit from the wider enterprise opportunities offered by the single market and should not be tied down by EC red tape. 
 In the single market there was &bquo;more competition, more choice, more flexibility and a home market of 320 million people. 
 &bquo;The Social Charter could destroy this tremendous boost for enterprise,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The charter will potentially have a very large impact on small firms because it is about more regulation.&equo; 
 The effect on small firms could be greater than on their larger counterparts. 
 The bigger UK companies, hardly enamoured with the charter themselves, might have the administrative capacity to handle it whereas independent operators did not. 
 Under the Social Charter every employee, whether full-time or part-time, will require a formal contract. 
 This, says Mr Eggar, will create more red tape and more regulations which will directly harm the growth and development of the small business sector. 
 &bquo;Contracts of employment are agreements between employers and their staff - they are not the business of government,&equo; he said. 
 Proposals for minimum wage regulations also came under attack. 
 &bquo;Minimum wage regulations, far from protecting workers, will fuel inflation, lead to job losses and price many smaller firms out of the market,&equo; he declared. 
 &bquo;Part-time, temporary workers will be granted the same social provisions as full-time employees. 
 That will mean more costs for employers and businesses.&equo; 
 Besides monitoring the EC proposals, Mr Eggar is also keeping an eye on other government departments which he said had the tendency to introduce measures which, however well intentioned, could have the effect of strangling small businesses. 
 Since moving from the Foreign Office in Mrs Thatcher's reshuffle in July, he has found that the small business portfolio promotes a softly, softly approach. 
 &bquo;The Government has sought to get out of small firms&equo; way,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It is hands off. 
 We will create the conditions in which the small businessman can make decisions.&equo; 
 The number of self-employed had increased from two to three million in the past decade. 
 &bquo;New entrants put pressure on existing companies and make them change their existing practices,&equo; he said. 
 He also stressed that the personal satisfaction in working for a small firm was as important as the financial contribution the sector made to the economy. 
 Besides start-ups and growing firms, management buyouts exemplified the enterprise spirit. 
 &bquo;Men with big company cars, big mortgages, big family commitments are prepared to risk all that in order to have control of their own destiny,&equo; he said. 
 In addition to the potential problems from a Social Charter, the Community Charge, or Poll Tax, to be introduced in England and Wales next spring, has created worries among small businesses. 
 Companies across the country will be subject to a uniform rate set by central government, although Mr Eggar is attempting to calm these fears by pointing out that a special case has been made for small firms. 
 This will involve reduced rates and an extension of the phasing-in period. 
 Alongside the challenges of the Social Charter and the Community Charge he has to keep a firm grip on the Government's sponsored schemes. 
 These include the Loan Guarantee, Enterprise Allowance and Business Expansion Schemes, which he likened to an a la carte menu from which entrepreneurs could choose. 
 The challenge for him is to improve the service of the &bquo;head waiter&equo;. 
 Foremost in his attempt will be the Training and Enterprise Councils. 
 The first of the 100 private agencies, established to operate on a local basis, will start early next year. 
 Small Business: A go-between for recruitment deals 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 A TWO-WOMAN firm based in east London believes it has found a niche in the staff recruitment market by acting as a broker between companies and recruitment agencies. 
 Caroline Gordon, who has set up Beaver Recruitment Brokers with Joan Tannian, said that the market was flooded with recruitment agencies which created confusion among companies with positions to fill. 
 Companies can find it difficult to know which agencies they should approach and, according to Ms Gordon, often become frustrated with the agencies for sending along unsuitable applicants. 
 Instead of going through several channels to find suitable applicants, companies can simplify the selection process by going through Beaver Recruitment Brokers which will choose candidates drawn from a range of recruitment agencies. 
 Beaver has agreements with 15 recruitment agencies for 200 job vacancies that several companies are trying to fill. 
 Ms Gordon said the recruitment agencies were enthusiastic about broking as it meant less time was spent pairing applicants with jobs. 
 The company, based at Ms Gordon's home in Walthamstow, generates its income from the companies and pays the agency for supplying the successful applicant. 
 She has faced an unusual problem, however, in trying to get a licence to trade as a recruitment broker. 
 The Department of Employment said that the licence she wanted did not exist. 
 Licences are needed for other types of brokerage and she argues that it would give her business respectability. 
 The Department of Employment has now agreed and is processing her application. 
 Beaver hopes to recoup its &pound;7,000 start-up costs within the next six months and possibly sooner if negotiations on a couple of large deals come to fruition. 
 Hewden Stuart offsets problems in housebuilding 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 STRONG demand from other segments of the construction market left Hewden Stuart, Britain's largest plant hire group, virtually untouched by current problems in housebuilding in the first half of the year. 
 Pre-tax profits in the six months to end July soared 43 per cent to &pound;19.4m, with the help of &pound;1.3m of property sales. 
 The interim dividend was raised by 25 per cent to 0.75p. 
 Sir Matthew Goodwin, the chairman, said: &bquo;We are delighted with the figures and face the future with confidence.&equo; 
 This result continues the group's strong growth record. 
 Pre-tax profits in the last financial year were &pound;28.3m, having been &pound;9.4m in 1986-87. 
 City analysts are forecasting pre-tax profits of &pound;38m this year. 
 The shares moved up 2p to 132p yesterday. 
 Sir Matthew said that Glasgow-based Hewden Stuart was used to difficult times. 
 &bquo;We have operated in recessionary conditions in Scotland for some time so can cope with this. 
 &bquo;Hewden Stuart increased its profits steadily through the Stop-Go policies of the 1960s and 1970s but experienced a hiccough in 1979-80 when there was a fundamental reconstruction of British industry,&equo; he explained. 
 &bquo;In no way are we going back to a 1979-80 recession. 
 We have broadened our base since then and have strong finances.&equo; 
 Hewden Stuart has spent &pound;200m in recent years on plant replacement and modernisation. 
 This, together with depot refurbishment and tighter controls, will enable the group to deal with any falling off in demand, according to Sir Matthew. 
 Hewden Stuart has experienced some slackening in demand in the home counties and some pressure on margins, but direct exposure to housebuilding is apparently modest. 
 Even so, Sir Matthew admitted that the wider implications of the weak housing market on the industry were hard to quantify. 
 Orders from other market segments remained firm with demand patterns clear for more than two years, he said. 
 In 1988, Hewden Stuart made less than 15 per cent of its profits from selling equipment rather than renting. 
 This proportion is likely to fall in the current year as builders move from buying to renting plant. 
 Concrete cancer case dents Higgs and Hill 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 A SETTLEMENT dating from a project completed in 1973 knocked &pound;2.77m off the profits of Higgs and Hill, the construction group, in the half year to end June. 
 The pre-tax result was unchanged at &pound;11.3m, which included a &pound;1.6m profit from the sale of a 14.9 per cent stake in Rush &amp; Tompkins. 
 The commercial settlement was with the South Western Regional Health Authority and concerned an alkali silica reaction &mdash; concrete cancer &mdash; in the Royal Devon and Exeter Hospital. 
 Construction and property profits were well ahead, offsetting poor housing results. 
 Higgs and Hill sold 500 homes in 1988, but volumes dropped by 35 per cent in the first half of 1989. 
 Sir Brian Hill, chairman and chief executive, said there was no sign of an improvement. 
 In a board reorganisation, Sir Brian is stepping down as chief executive. 
 John Theakston, finance director, is replacing joint managing director Derek Ridout, who becomes a non-executive director. 
 The other joint managing director is David Hill. 
 Colin Archer is joining as finance director from British Home Stores. 
 Company News in Brief 
 Business and City Page 30 
 John Maunders ahead on buoyant demand 
 By NEIL THAPAR, City Reporter 
 BUOYANT demand for homes last year helped John Maunders Group, the Manchester-based housebuilder to boost taxable profits by 50 per cent to &pound;7.14m in the 12 months ended 30 June. 
 The profits growth came on the back of a 26 per cent rise in sales to more than &pound;53m, with the total number of units sold up from 676 to 745 in the year. 
 The average selling price of its homes increased sharply from &pound;52,000 to &pound;78,000. 
 The results were achieved against a background of differing regional markets with margins in East Anglia and the South deteriorating while conditions in the North-west remained buoyant. 
 However, chairman John Maunders said selling prices in the North-west &bquo;appear to have stablised&equo;. 
 He continued: &bquo;Assuming current market conditions do not deteriorate further, the group, with conservative borrowings, a prime land bank and a good forward sales position can look forward to another year of growth.&equo; 
 The group's policy is to sell ahead of construction and is currently selling for completions next spring. 
 Forward sales for completion in the first half of this year are sufficient to meet internal targets, Mr Maunders said. 
 Grampian disappoints 
 By NEIL THAPAR, City Reporter 
 SHARES in the Scottish pharmaceuticals and sportswear company Grampian Holdings dropped 26p yesterday to 190p as interim pre-tax profits fell short of City expectations. 
 In the six months to 30 June profit before tax was &pound;3.7m, up from &pound;3.2m, compared with analysts' forecasts of about &pound;4.5m. 
 However, Dermot Coleman, an analyst at BZW, said the price drop was an over-reaction. 
 He added that a tight market in the company's stock exaggerates any movement. 
 Profits advanced in the transport and pharmaceutical division but fell back in sporting goods, and losses deepened in retail. 
 The company blamed higher interest rates and reduced consumer spending for the problems. 
 Armchair Investor: John Beales 
 By NEIL THAPAR, City Reporter 
 THE GREEN bandwagon has provided a fillip for many companies concerned with tackling environmental problems. 
 But the market has neglected John Beales, the textiles to refrigeration group. 
 This, however, could soon be put right as investors begin to focus on changes which have taken place in the past few years. 
 The company was orginally involved in textiles but has diversifed into refrigeration and electrical activities. 
 The textile business is still ailing, but the two newer divisions have become increasingly important although their potential has not been fully appreciated by the market. 
 Demand is booming for modern refrigeration equipment for the food industry, and recent scares concerning food poisioning and legionnaires' disease have provided an additional boost. 
 Moreover, the refrigeration sector is fragmented and offers considerable scope for expansion by acquisitions. 
 The electricals side is also trading well and is poised to benefit from growing conern about CFC gases. 
 One of its subsidiaries has developed a machine capable of extracting the harmful gas from refrigeration plant with a environmentally sound technique. 
 Together the two divisions are likely to provide the entire increase in the company's taxable profits this year. 
 Profits should rise from &pound;2.09m to &pound;2.5m in the year to May 1990, rating the shares, down 1p to 242p yesterday, on a modest earnings multiple of around eight times. 
 Buy. 
 Column Eight: Sterling is part of DTI furniture 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 Secretaries of State for Trade and Industry may come and go but Sir Jeffrey Sterling, chairman of the P&amp;O group, has long been part of the furniture at 1 Victoria Street. 
 Sir Jeffrey, who has acted as unpaid and part-time special adviser to six trade and industry secretaries, yesterday added a seventh to his belt. 
 Nicholas Ridley, the latest incumbent, is retaining his silken skills to advise on &bquo;industrial and financial affairs&equo; and the Airbus programme. 
 Of course Mr Ridley already has Katharine Ramsay, his special adviser at both environment and transport. 
 The third member of the team is Michael Simmonds, a leading light in right-wing think tank the Adam Smith Institute. 
 The City continues to treat the Royal Yacht, Britannia, as its own. 
 Today, the barge docks in Kuala Lumpar where Sir Peter Carey, chairman of Morgan Grenfell, will trumpet the merits of the City on behalf of the British Invisible Exports Council. 
 Readers may have received mail shots with the Barclaycard logo suggesting that they stand a good chance of winning a six figure sum of money and a car in a prize draw. 
 With the possibility of recouping anything from Barclaycard, many have felt tempted to play. 
 When full details of the draw were finally dispatched it emerged that Readers Digest had a considerable involvement. 
 To stand a full chance of winning, contestants have to subscribe for a Readers Digest gardening book which can be paid for by Barclaycard. 
 Barclaycard admitted yesterday that there was a &bquo;financial arrangement&equo; with Readers Digest on the sales of the book. 
 &bquo;We have received some complaints from cardholders,&equo; said a spokesman, &bquo;which we will be studying.&equo; 
 Another victim of the high interest rate policy. 
 Shares in STC, the communications group, shot down 13p to 329p yesterday after chief executive Arthur Walsh unloaded 500,000 shares, almost half his personal holding. 
 An STC spokesman explained that the &pound;1.7m sale was made by Mr Walsh to escape the rising cost of the loan he took out to pick up an option on 1 million STC shares in February. 
 However, the overstretched executive still made &pound;1.3m profit when he sold at 339p. 
 He took up his options in February at 84p. 
 No prizes for guessing who Ian Chapman, the publisher sacked by Rupert Murdoch when he took over William Collins, was referring to yesterday when he launched his new company. 
 &bquo;You might think that I would have been happy to go on improving my golf handicap,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;But no one man has the right to end a person's life. 
 Publishing is my life. 
 And I don't see why I should let him end it.&equo; 
 View from City Road: Property profits underpin Sears 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 SEARS' thriving property activities have partly offset a disappointing performance in shoes, specialist retailing areas like Wallis and Horne and a dire time in housebuilding to limit the decline in the group's half-year pre-tax profits to 10.4 per cent at &pound;91.7m. 
 Indeed Sears points to &pound;6.3m worth of special factors, such as the rail strike, accounting for almost half the profits set-back. 
 Rental income and development profits doubled their contribution to &pound;10.5m and other property income brought in &pound;1.5m more. 
 Interest earned on the &pound;331m raised for William Hill offset the loss of &pound;9.6m of profits. 
 But since the stock market has not yet found a consistent way of valuing the property based content of retailers' profits, it is progress on the high street that will dominate Sears' share rating and the news, particularly from footwear, is not encouraging. 
 Footwear, where trading profits slipped by 23.5 per cent to &pound;31.6m or 40 per cent of the total before &bquo;one-off&equo; property income, has been especially poor. 
 The grand plan to segment the British Shoe Corporation's 22 per cent market share into four sections, catering to volume, family, fashion and quality has failed to shine. 
 With no volume gains and falling prices, like-for-like sales in shoes fell back by 1.5 per cent in the six months to 31 July. 
 Sears has been busily redirecting its 1,500 strong chain away from traditional sites and in the next 18 months a further 100 to 150 net closures are likely. 
 Like-for-like sales growth at Olympus was a hefty 18 per cent and Miss Selfridge chalked up gains of 17.4 per cent which owes something to comparatively grim weather in the previous year but also shows that mortgage pressures do not bear down on customers equally. 
 Selfridges did not do too badly, thanks to returning tourists, but a &pound;7m cut in non-shoe retailing profits reflects a shocking period's trading at Wallis and Horne. 
 Home shopping held its profits at &pound;13m which could well reflect the use of provisions raised on the Freemans acquisition to meet a net 10 per cent staff reduction. 
 Assuming pre-tax profits of &pound;230m, before one-off property income, Sears shares are on a p/e of 10.5 at 118p, a 10 per cent discount to the market, and are on a yield of over 6 per cent, exceeded only by Next and Storehouse. 
 Assets more than cover the price and the balance sheet is almost ungeared so there is limited downside. 
 View from City Road: Dealing with a miscellany 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 HARRISONS &amp; Crosfield must really dislike being classified as an overseas trader if it is willing to go through the complex process of changing its listing only to end up as a miscellaneous industrial. 
 The move is symbolic of what has been going on at H&amp;C since George Paul, the chief executive, took over two years ago. 
 H&amp;C's management knows where it does not want to be, and has distanced itself from the previously volatile structure with some skill. 
 But it has never really shown that it has any new ideas about where it should end up. 
 All H&amp;C's four major divisions &mdash; chemicals, timber, food and plantations - were there when Mr Paul took control. 
 True each of them has been finely tuned. 
 The minority stakes in plantations, notably Harrisons Malaya, have been sold, and the fragrances operation, Felton, will soon follow. 
 Southern-Evans, the timber yard chain, has been bought, along with another chain in the US and all sorts of chemicals operations. 
 But H&amp;C has never really addressed the question of why these diverse businesses should be together. 
 The half-year figures showed an 8 per cent increase in pre-tax profits to &pound;65.2m, and a similar rise in earnings to 7p. 
 A 13 per cent hike in the interim dividend to 3.4p was accompanied by the promise of a 10 per cent rise in the final dividend. 
 Beneath the bare result was the familiar curate's egg pattern of some bits doing well and some less well. 
 This time it was the turn of Pauls, the food division, to thrive on the back of high pig prices and strong demand for malt from the Japanese whisky industry. 
 Timber held its own, but needed a good showing from Southerns to do so. 
 Chemicals was flat, held back by shutdowns at two large plants, and the remaining plantations suffered from the weakness of world palm oil prices. 
 Selling the 30 per cent stake in Harrisons Malaya brought a &pound;75.9m extraordinary first half profit, and the sale of Felton should bring a &pound;25m excess in the second half. 
 That is significant given the group will be lucky to make more than &pound;135m pre-tax in the year. 
 At 160p, down 7p, H&amp;C's shares are on 9.4 times prospective earnings and have strong support from the dividend. 
 The discount to the market could be eradicated by some judicious pruning. 
 View from City Road: Gloom for ad agencies 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 THERE does not seem to be much good news about for any bulls in the advertising agency sector. 
 Worries about an impending slow down in advertising spending have been a considerable drag on agency shares this year. 
 And now these fears have been compounded by a sixth profitability study by accountants Spicer &amp; Oppenheim whose gloomy conclusions may well prolong the sector's agonies further. 
 Much of the concern is levelled at agency balance sheets which have been weakened by the sector's lust for acquisitions. 
 Quoted advertising agencies wrote off goodwill totalling &pound;1.7bn in the year to November 1988, leaving aggregate shareholders' funds in the sector below &pound;39m. 
 Some may argue that balance sheet numbers like these are not important for people businesses. 
 The figures are more a reflection of the inadequacy of accounting rules on goodwill than the quality of the underlying businesses. 
 Even so, the average debt to equity ratio in the sector has risen from 1.3:1 to 2.8 in the survey period, and Spicer suggests weakened balance sheets could bring liquidity problems. 
 And unlike in the past, fewer agencies are now earning investment income from surplus funds. 
 Spicer points out that the sector has thrived in a bull market but the advertising boom may be coming to an end. 
 That could have important implications for the industry. 
 In a tighter advertising market there could be a fall out among smaller and private agencies. 
 The spotlight may also fall on the managements of quoted agencies. 
 Many are still led by their founders whose skills are yet to be tested in a tougher economic climate. 
 They may well be tempted to take their businesses private again. 
 Market Report: Dearer money jitters as eyes turn to Germany 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 DALGETY, Delta and Jaguar were among the shares to march ahead yesterday as the stock market continued to fret and fuss about today's West German interest rate decision. 
 After a bright opening, inspired by Wall Street, prices retreated and by the close the broadly based FT-SE share index was down 6.5 points at 2,312.1. 
 Even a firm Wall Street opening failed to smother the dearer money jitters. 
 The market has probably discounted a 0.5 per cent German increase which may allow UK base rates to remain at 14 per cent. 
 But there is deepening pessimism that a full one point advance will be announced which will make it almost impossible for base rates to remain unchanged. 
 At one time Dalgety was up 16p as Elf Aquitaine, the French oil group, confirmed it had formed a joint company with Australian Robert Holmes a Court to hold a 5.5 per cent stake in the Dalgety agricultural and food group. 
 The shares closed 12p higher at 436p. 
 It is widely believed that Mr Holmes a Court, the so called Perth predator, is keen to buy Dalgety's extensive Australian land interests. 
 But the French connection is less clear. 
 An Elf spokesman described the link as &bquo;purely a financial investment&equo;. 
 There are suggestions the duo already has its eyes on a French food business. 
 Mr Holmes a Court has trimmed his Dalgety stake which was at one time nearer 5.8 per cent. 
 Delta, the electrical and engineering group, gained 18p to 353p, reflecting a near 2 per cent stake built by Tomkins, the industrial group created by Greg Hutchings. 
 Tomkins shares fell 7p to 276p on fears it is planning to mount a bid. 
 Jaguar was inspired by stories that General Motors was preparing to bid. 
 The shares roared ahead 34p to 633p. 
 Ford, the US car giant, has already declared its interest in moving in on Jaguar. 
 There are signs GM is preparing the necessary US filings and there is talk that it has already approached Jaguar's union leaders. 
 The car group's shares were the most actively traded option. 
 More than 2,000 contracts were completed. 
 Standard Chartered, the banking group, rose 4p to 535p. 
 It is forging a trading link with WestDeutsche Landesbank, a West German group. 
 It appears the Germans are taking over the running of Standard's European branches. 
 But there is little chance of the Germans buying into Standard. 
 Ferranti International, the troubled electronics group, had another rousing session with Seaq volume put at 38 million shares. 
 The price rose 2.5p to 57.5p. 
 Eurotunnel remained depressed on the costs over run. 
 The shares tumbled another 40p to 560p. 
 BPB Industries, the old British Plaster Board, which has been firm lately on stake building stories, fell 9p to 253p. 
 James Capel has, it appears, lopped &pound;25m from its profit forecast and now expects &pound;165m. 
 Last year BPB achieved &pound;202.3m. 
 Grand Metropolitan remained impressed by the thought that it could be Sir James Goldsmith's next target, The shares rose 6p to 604p. 
 The Whitbread brewing group was ruffled by stories it would be forced, under US legislation, to sell its US drink importing operations if it continued a trans-Atlantic restaurant build-up. 
 The &bquo;A&equo; shares fell 6p to 375p. 
 Whitbread's main US agencies cover Cutty Sark Scotch whisky and Beefeater gin. 
 Pearson, up 12p to 728p, was helped by a rumoured Kleinwort Benson upgrading, and Amersham International jumped 27p to 435p as Hoffman-La Roche, the Swiss group, emerged as a 5 per cent shareholder. 
 Hoffman has sold a US company to Amersham in exchange for shares. 
 Little Symonds Engineering rose 2p to 41p as JF Nash Holdings, a privately owned Midlands group, edged its shareholding up to 17.8 per cent. 
 BSG International rose 1.5p to 82.5p. 
 Sir Ron Brierley, the New Zealand financier, now has 12.6 per cent. 
 Redland, the building materials group, fell 4p to 550p. 
 Through stockbroker Cazenove it has purchased &pound;90.4m of its &pound;100m Euro-sterling bonds. 
 The bonds were issued seven months ago. 
 Amstrad was a weak market, falling 3.5p to 62.5p on worries that even more profit downgradings could be on the way. 
 WCRS Group, the advertising consultancy, enjoyed a late flurry, gaining 18p to 332p. 
 There is continuing speculation that the French Eurocom group, which has links with WCRC, could be preparing to bid. 
 WPP, the communications group created by Martin Sorrell, fell 9p to 709p. 
 Panmure Gordon rates the shares a buy. 
 Analysts Richard Sanderson and Chris Roberts expect profits this year, with the US Ogilvy group included for six months, to reach &pound;75m against &pound;40.3m. 
 Next year they see profits advancing to &pound;113.9m with &pound;143m pencilled in for 1991. 
 Cookson Group, which makes specialist materials for various industries, edged forward 3p to 324p following a meeting with the Society of Investment Analysts. 
 Share prices closed lower as fears of a rise in West German interest rates undermined the advances in early trading following Tuesday's surge on Wall Street. 
 The FT-SE 100 index closed 6.5 points lower at 2,312.1 after touching 2,331.1 at one stage. 
 The FT 30 fell 9.1 to 1,890.2 Boddington Group shares are a sell following the decision to dispose of its brewing operations, believe Martin Hawkins and David Baggs at Kitcat &amp; Aitken. 
 They say there are cheaper leisure stocks around such as Midsummer Leisure, which once bid for Boddies. 
 Shorn of the brewing side, Boddies' assets are about 210p a share. 
 Yesterday they closed at 187p. 
 Allied Restaurants, which aims to develop as a broadly-based leisure group, could be tempted to sell its 20 Wimpy restaurants. 
 There is speculation that Grand Metropolitan, challenging McDonalds for supremacy of the fast food market, could pay up to &pound;16m for the Allied branches. 
 The cash would eradicate borrowings, allowing Allied to expand. 
 The shares fell 2p to 72p. 
 Fraud office to get report on Ferranti 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Assistant Business Editor 
 THE Coopers and Lybrand report on how Ferranti came to be defrauded of &pound;215m after buying American arms firm International Signal and Control is expected to be handed to the Serious Fraud Office within days. 
 A board meeting of Ferranti was called to consider the report yesterday. 
 The SFO is expected to take a number of weeks to decide on whether to mount further investigations with a view to taking action against individuals and organisations. 
 Ferranti said the Coopers report confirmed what its own directors and accountants had already established &mdash; namely that &bquo;phantom&equo; assets and profits had been created in ISC's accounts worth some &pound;215m. 
 The group has said the write-off against its reserves after tax relief will have to be &pound;185m. 
 There had been suggestions that directors had jumped the gun by putting a figure to the fraud before Coopers had completed its report. 
 But Ferranti said yesterday: &bquo;The report confirms that Coopers &amp; Lybrand have found no information which would lead them to suspect that the Ferranti International balance sheet exposure to fraud was any different from that referred to in the letter to shareholders dated 29 September. 
 &bquo;Accordingly, the effect of the report is to confirm the conclusions the board has already reached on the financial effects of the fraud on Ferranti International.&equo; 
 The company said that complex negotiations were proceeding quickly but it would be some time before there was progress to report. 
 On the stock market Ferranti's shares jumped 4p in another day of hectic trading before settling to close 2.5p up at 57.5p. 
 Smith New Court, which already has a sizeable position in Ferranti shares, was a heavy buyer for the second day, as was Hoare Govett, which includes British Aerospace among its corporate clients. 
 Ferranti was unsure of what to make of the feverish stock market speculation. 
 &bquo;We believed the rumour on Tuesday that British Aerospace was building up a big shareholding but we are not so sure now,&equo; a spokesman said. 
 The Coopers and Lybrand report is believed to detail a highly complex fraud involving a string of bogus subcontractors and front companies to maintain the fiction of large contracts in Pakistan, China and Africa. 
 ISC is understood to have small contracts in each of these territories but further &bquo;phantom&equo; contracts are believed to have been invented to make the company seem more successful than it was. 
 The whereabouts of James Guerin, ISC's former chairman, are still unknown and he has yet to make contact with Ferranti's advisers. 
 Mr Guerin's lawyer said he had advised Mr Guerin to say as little as possible for the time being. 
 Dutch banks plan share flotation 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 AN INTERNATIONAL share issue and privatisation will follow the merger of two of the Netherland's largest banks, Nederlandsche Middenstansbank (NMB) and Postbank, the state-owned postal savings bank. 
 The merger agreement was signed yesterday after gaining approval from the Dutch regulatory authorities. 
 The new company, NMB Postbank, is listed in Amsterdam. 
 But the intention is for the 49 per cent Dutch government shareholding to be reduced later this year through an issue in Amsterdam, London, Frankfurt, Paris and New York. 
 The issue will complete the transformation of the Postbank, which is the world's largest postal savings bank, from a sleepy adjunct to the Dutch post office, which it was less than five years ago, to an international banking force. 
 Along with the merger, Postbank shareholders will be asked to approve a change to the bank's articles of association so that it can engage in wider areas of business. 
 It is not allowed to engage in securities trading or insurance, which would make the merger difficult as NMB is one of the leading options traders in the Netherlands. 
 NMB Postbank will have a dominant position in Dutch savings and money transfers. 
 Over 75 per cent of the Dutch population have accounts at Postbank, though many of these are dormant. 
 NMB Postbank estimates about 42 per cent of Dutch people will have active savings accounts with the new group. 
 PowerGen turns down cut price coal offer 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 BRITISH COAL yesterday offered to cut the cost of supplies to privatised electricity generators and guaranteed that price rises would be kept within the rate of inflation provided they agreed to sign long-term contracts. 
 The offer was immediately rebuffed, however, by one of the two big generating companies being created under privatisation, which said it would seek fuel from a wider range of sources, including imported coal. 
 Malcolm Edwards, British Coal's commercial director, told an electricity conference in London that the corporation was prepared to enter supply deals lasting eight years &mdash; the same period set down for the bulk of initial contracts between privatised electricity generators and distribution companies. 
 The proposal also included an offer to reduce the price of supplies in real terms over the first five years and a pledge that during the contract period prices would remain &bquo;within the general movement of prices in the economy&equo;. 
 But, speaking at the same conference, Ed Wallis, chief executive of PowerGen, the company which will inherit a third of the Central Electricity Generating Board's stations, warned: &bquo;We plan to burn a wider range of fuels from a wider range of sources &mdash; and we owe it to our customers to get the best possible deal.&equo; 
 Mr Wallis said there was &bquo;no way we want to see miners out of jobs&equo; but PowerGen's own survival would not be put at risk by limiting its range of suppliers. 
 He added that for environmental reasons PowerGen had &bquo;a considerable incentive to seek the low sulphur coals which are readily available on the international market&equo;. 
 Securing long-term contracts is of critical importance to British Coal, which supplies 75 per cent of its output to the electricity industry. 
 Mr Edwards reiterated his warning that the Government would find it impossible to privatise British Coal without such long-term supply deals. 
 Hoffman takes Amersham stake 
 By TERENCE WILKINSON, Assistant City Editor 
 SHARES in Amersham International, the healthcare and life science research products group, rose 27p to 435p yesterday after news that Hoffman-La Roche, the leading drugs company, would hold a 5 per cent stake in the group following the sale of a subsidiary. 
 Amersham is paying &dollar;61.3m (&pound;38.3m) to acquire Medi-Physics, the loss-making radiopharmaceuticals subsidiary of Hoffman-La Roche, to make the UK company the largest player in the &pound;300m world radiopharmaceutical market, whose products are used for imaging organs of the body for diagnostic purposes. 
 The sale price is to be met in three ways. 
 Hoffman-La Roche will take up new Amersham shares to give it 5 per cent of the UK company at a price of 460p, a 12.5 per cent premium to Tuesday's closing price. 
 At the same time Amersham is to issue &dollar;30m of loan notes and will make a cash payment of &dollar;12m from its own resources. 
 In 1988 Medi-Physics made operating losses of &dollar;7.4m on sales of &dollar;53.2m and its unaudited net assets at the end of August were &dollar;63.2m. 
 According to Amersham finance director Bill Ellaby, the purchase of Medi-Physics, which has already started to reorganise its business to eliminate losses before completion of the deal, will have a neutral effect on earnings per share at Amersham this year but a positive effect in 1990/1. 
 Amersham has a strong position in the European market for radiopharmaceuticals and sees the acquisition of a complementary manufacturing base in North America as improving its chances of supplying the global market for such products. 
 The Japanese company Nihon Medi-Physics, a joint venture between Sumitomo and Hoffman-La Roche, is excluded from the current deal but existing commercial and manufacturing links with Medi-Physics will continue. 
 Failed firm's shareholders lose tax gain 
 By JASON NISSE 
 THE Inland Revenue has decreed that both the ordinary and the preference shares of Sound Diffusion, the electrical company that went into receivership in December, are of &bquo;negligible value&equo; for taxation purposes, writes Jason Nisse. 
 Sound Diffusion ordinary shares were suspended in December at 22p and the group asked its bankers to appoint a receiver. 
 The Department of Trade and Industry has started an inquiry into the circumstances surrounding Sound Diffusion's demise. 
 The administrative receiver appointed, Touche Ross, was instrumental in persuading the Revenue to allow shareholders to write off the value of the shares against capital gains tax. 
 Chris Morris, the joint receiver at Touche Ross, said that some payments had been made to employees and priority creditors &mdash; essentially the banks &mdash; but said the chances of ordinary creditors receiving anything was &bquo;only around half a per cent&equo;. 
 A shareholders action committee has been formed to see if any value can be obtained. 
 Outlook: Europe heads for defensive mergers 
 By JASON NISSE 
 Professor Roland Smith, the chairman of British Aerospace, last night predicted that the European defence industry would be dominated by three or four major companies by the mid-nineties as a result of national and trans-national mergers. 
 Since BAe seems to be a front-runner to take over the ailing Ferranti group, Professor Smith may have a hand in self-fulfilment of his prophecy. 
 His reasoning, expounded in a lecture to an august gathering at the Royal Insitute of International Affairs, is nevertheless persuasive. 
 The slowdown in military spending and escalating costs of armament programmes will make it increasingly difficult for any company, even one the size of BAe, to go it alone. 
 The recent improvement in East-West relations must also make the market for military equipment less favourable. 
 But as Professor Smith himself notes, there is one important caveat to this argument. 
 Any increased concentration among defence suppliers will depend crucially on the attitudes of individual governments. 
 Past experience suggests that some governments, at least, may not be prepared to sit this one out. 
 Britain's Ministry of Defence was instrumental in blocking GEC's first attempt to merge with Plessey &mdash; and in extracting concessions in return for allowing GEC, in partnership with Siemens of West Germany, to acquire Plessey at the second bite. 
 It is one thing for a government to look benignly upon &mdash; say &mdash; a rescue of Ferranti; or on the swallowing up of much smaller players in the defence business. 
 It would be quite another to imagine it sanctioning full-blooded mergers between the likes of BAe and GEC, which is what Professor Smith's script implies. 
 It is not only defence ministries that would look askance at the creation of a defence oligopoly; competition authorities exist to keep a beady eye on such tendencies. 
 Even if cross-border mergers become a matter for Brussels - which might be expected to take a larger, continent-wide view &mdash; rather than national authorities, defence is specifically reserved for the attention of member governments. 
 Outlook: Income tax in disguise 
 By JASON NISSE 
 Budget tax cuts were a little late this year. 
 Nigel Lawson's most expensive change, to national insurance contributions, comes into effect today. 
 The boost to disposable income comes at an awkward time, when the economic slowdown is not sufficiently well-established to have even begun to close the trade gap; but the structural change is welcome. 
 There is a threshold level of income which is completely free of income tax. 
 But in the national insurance system, a bottom layer of income (up to &pound;43 a week) is only contribution-free for those whose total earnings are below such a level; once they cross the threshold, they are obliged to pay contributions on the lot. 
 This system bore heavily on people earning only just over the threshold - and their employers. 
 Nigel Lawson has now made two attempts to smooth the system out. 
 The obvious answer is to fuse national insurance with income tax, but this would offend against the notion (it is really no more than that) that the national insurance system is &bquo;contributory&equo;. 
 So it remains the case that everyone earning over the threshold has to pay contributions on every pound earned, up to the ceiling of &pound;325 a week. 
 But today's changes mean that the contribution rate on the first &pound;43 a week is only 2 per cent. 
 Previously, following changes made in 1985, the rate was 5 per cent of all earnings for those on between &pound;43 and &pound;75 a week, 7 per cent for those earning from &pound;75 to &pound;115 a week, and 9 per cent for those earning over &pound;115. 
 Employers' contributions were similiarly arranged, though with a further jump to 10.45 per cent on all pay-packets of over &pound;165 a week. 
 As the Institute of Fiscal Studies today points out, the new system in effect means there is a charge of 86p a week for belonging to the system; then there is a 9 per cent tax on income between &pound;43 and &pound;325. 
 The IFS argues that a similar change now needs to be made to employers' contributions. 
 But there is one change on the employers' side that needs to be mirrored for employees: the abolition of the ceiling. 
 And, as the IFS points out, the system still encourages perks in place of straightforward pay, because these still do not bear national insurance charges. 
 Nor, for that matter, does investment income. 
 It would make sense, at some stage, to equalise the tax treatment of earned and &bquo;unearned&equo; income; but then the perpetuation of distinct national insurance would look very silly indeed. 
 Which is what it is. 
 Outlook: High rises at the top 
 By JASON NISSE 
 Surveys of top pay are coming in thick and fast. 
 Top managers enjoyed an average increase in earnings of 17.8 per cent last year, according to the latest, from Charterhouse; like P-E Inbucon's, its results suggest that Lord King of British Airways was, shall we say, a bit ahead of the pack. 
 Even 17.8 per cent, however, was still more than double the growth of average earnings over that period. 
 Even excluding bonuses, British top managers beat their French, German and Dutch counterparts with a 12.1 per cent hike in basic pay (although their real increases &mdash; 5.1 per cent &mdash; were not much larger than on the continent). 
 Large companies still seem to be finding it increasingly difficult to retain top management. 
 The informal ceiling placed on share option deals by institutional investors is said to be one reason. 
 In any 10-year period managers should only be granted options on shares worth up to four times their annual earnings. 
 Most managers have already used up that leeway since share option schemes took off in 1985. 
 By moving to pastures new, successful managers can negotiate themselves a new package of options from scratch. 
 This partly explains London Weekend Television's battle with the institutions over its scheme for locking in key managers. 
 Meanwhile, salary surveys throw up evidence of the spread of cash bonuses. 
 Ian Chapman launches new publisher 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 IAN CHAPMAN, the former head of publisher William Collins who left in acrimonious circumstances when it was taken over by media mogul Rupert Murdoch, is back in the book business with a venture that links him with Sir David English, editor-in-chief of Associated Newspapers. 
 Mr Chapman yesterday announced the launch of Chapmans Publishers, which he said would be &bquo;an independent general publisher across a wide spectrum. 
 The main thrust will be in the middle ground, but we want to publish good quality literary works as well. 
 We hope we will give a voice to the authors of the '90s.&equo; 
 The new company is a three-way partnership between the Chapman family (his wife Marjory becomes editor-in-chief), a property and leisure group called Taylor Clark, and Associated Newspapers. 
 The Mail and London Evening Standard group is to put its book publishing interests into Chapmans. 
 The partners will each hold 31.1 per cent of the equity, and Chapmans will have an initial capital of around &pound;2.5m. 
 Sir David said that Associated would make further funds available for expansion. 
 Mr Chapman said: &bquo;I have usually got on well with newspaper proprietors, but this time I want to be in charge.&equo; 
 Chapmans has not yet signed up any authors, but is clearly hoping there will be an exodus of well-known names from Collins. 
 &bquo;We are opening up our store, and would be very happy to talk to them.&equo; 
 Mr Chapman is expecting to publish around 25 books in the first year, and could float the company within five years. 
 Machinist strike brings Boeing to a standstill 
 From LARRY BLACK in New York 
 WITH &dollar;80bn (&pound;50bn) worth of orders on the books and production already behind schedule, machinists at Boeing walked off the job yesterday. 
 The company's employees have embarked on a strike that could seriously disrupt international air travel if it lasts for more than a few weeks. 
 The strike by Boeing's 57,000 employees in at least seven states comes at a time when airlines with ageing fleets are already straining to find aircraft for use on their new routes. 
 The large aeroplane manufacturers have as much as 10 years' worth of future work on their order books, and an active market has developed among airlines and leasing companies for delivery slots. 
 The workers, members of the International Association of Machinists, are taking advantage of the boom to try to make up for years of contract concessions and stagnant income. 
 They are seeking wage increases several percentage points above prevailing wage settlements, and voted overwhelmingly to reject Boeing's three-year contract offer. 
 &bquo;You'll never be in a better position than you are now,&equo; Justin Ostro, union vice president, told a rally of 30,000 machinists earlier this week in Seattle, Washington, the site of Boeing's headquarters and main production facility. 
 Some 43,300 of the union members are concentrated in the Seattle area. 
 The Boeing machinists have not gone on strike since 1977. 
 The union argues that the workers deserve a greater share of Boeing's prosperity. 
 The company, the world's largest manufacturer of commercial aircraft, has experienced five straight years of record orders. 
 This year alone, almost 750 planes, worth &dollar;38.5bn, have already been ordered. 
 Meanwhile, labour agreements covering 20,000 workers at Lockheed Aircraft have also expired. 
 Machinists there, members of the same trade union, are to take a strike vote on 22 October. 
 Boeing sells a third of its aircraft overseas, making it the biggest exporter in the United States. 
 Economists are warning that a prolonged strike in the industry &mdash; one of the few sectors where the US enjoys a positive trade balance &mdash; would have a serious impact on the American trade deficit. 
 IBM negotiating for role in European Jessi chip project 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 IBM, the leading US computer company, wants to become part of a Ecu3.3bn European effort to develop an indigenous semiconductor technology. 
 John Akers, IBM's chairman, said yesterday that Europe must become self-sufficient in key technologies such as semiconductors. 
 His group was negotiating to take part in the Jessi project, led by Philips, Siemens and SGS Thomson, which is intended to reduce Europe's dependence on chips from Japan and the US. 
 European companies, however, have argued that they are cut out of parallel efforts in America, and in particular from Semantech, a big industry project in which IBM plays a key role. 
 Mr Akers said: &bquo;We are the leaders in the semiconductor industry. 
 We are the largest manufacturer in Europe and I think we have a lot to bring to bear.&equo; 
 He said it would be useful for the Jessi partners to consider his company's participation. 
 Europe depends for two-thirds of its chip supply on exports. 
 The aim of Jessi is to reduce that to one-third at most. 
 European Commission officials say the situation is totally unacceptable. 
 &bquo;Chips are the beginning and end of information technology,&equo; said one. 
 &bquo;We cannot tolerate such dependence.&equo; 
 In June the European Commission said it would help to fund the Jessi project and the governments of France, the Netherlands, Italy, Germany and possibly the UK are also expected to help. 
 But industry will have to find at least 50 per cent of the funds. 
 IBM, which had revenues of &dollar;60bn and profits of &dollar;6bn last year, shook Wall Street last week by warning that earnings forecasts for the third quarter and for the whole year would fall significantly below expectations. 
 But Mr Akers reiterated yesterday that he saw no long-term change in economic assumptions or any downturn in demand for the company's products. 
 Delays on certain products, the strength of the dollar and a shift to leasing computers rather than buying them had caused the company to issue the warning. 
 Mr Akers said the industry would keep expanding at two to three times the rate of world economic growth and that IBM would participate fully. 
 Europe, which accounts for one-third of IBM's revenue, is growing at twice the rate of the US market, but Asia continues to be the fastest-growing region. 
 Cheating the wind in Swindon 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 (First Edition) &bquo;MEN and women of metal (mettle?) must come together to cheat the wind,&equo; shouted the voiceover on the incomprehensible video, to the accompaniment of crashing cymbals and lurid flashing lights. 
 &bquo;Earth, wind and fire. 
 A movement of elements.&equo; 
 What men and women, including the DTI minister for Industry and Enterprise, Douglas Hogg, and the television celebrity Cliff Michelmore, had in fact come together for was the official opening of Honda of Japan's new engine plant at Swindon. 
 Soon it will also be the site of a &pound;300m car factory. 
 Under a giant makeshift marquee, Tadashi Kume, the president of Honda, promised that the Japanese company would become a &bquo;good citizen of Europe&equo; buying 80 per cent of components for its Swindon-built cars from European suppliers. 
 The man on the video took a rather different view, describing Honda's decision to join the flow of Japanese car makers into Britain as an opportunity to conquer a Europe soon to be &bquo;unchained and unfettered by regulations&equo;. 
 Quite what earth, wind and fire had to do with building a car factory on a former aerodrome in the Wiltshire countryside was never satisfactorily explained. 
 In any event, production at the plant will begin in late 1991 rising to 100,000 cars a year by 1995. 
 Rover, the British car maker, is taking a 20 per cent stake in the factory. 
 It is not thought to have had a stake in the video. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 SFO to get Ferranti report: The Coopers and Lybrand report on how Ferranti came to be defrauded of &pound;215m after buying American firm International Signal and Control is expected to be handed to the Serious Fraud Office within days. 
 A Ferranti board meeting considered the report yesterday. 
 Page 29 Property victims: Halifax Building Society announced a &pound;14.5m loss from its estate agency chain and Leeds Permanent closed 60 branches with 243 job losses. 
 This page Accountants merge: Coopers &amp; Lybrand and Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells are merging to create the country's largest accountancy firm with fees of &pound;413m. 
 This page Top earner: Lord Hanson was the highest paid director of a public company last year with &pound;1.24m, followed by &bquo;Tiny&equo; Rowland (&pound;1.01m). 
 This page and Outlook, page 27 Sears slows: Pre-tax profits at Sears, the retailing group, slumped by 10 per cent to &pound;91.7m in the six months to 31 July as high street spending waned. 
 This page and View from City Road, page 29 Chancellor's changes: Nigel Lawson's alterations to national insurance contributions, announced with the last Budget, come into effect today. 
 Outlook, page 27 Profits up: Pre-tax profits at Harrisons and Crosfield advanced 8 per cent to &pound;65.2m, and there was a similar rise in earnings to 7p in the six months to 30 June. 
 View from City Road, page 29 Cheap coal: British Coal offered to cut the cost of supplies to privatised electricity generators and said price rises would be kept within the rate of inflation. 
 Page 29 Report due: Coopers and Lybrand are expected to hand the Serious Fraud Office their report on how Ferranti came to be defrauded of &pound;215m within days. 
 Page 29 Market uneasy: Fears of a rise in West German interest rates today depressed share prices. 
 The FT 100 Index fell 6.5 points after rising 12.5. 
 Shares worthless: The Inland Revenue has said that ordinary and preference shares of Sound Diffusion are of &bquo;negligible value&equo; for taxation purposes. 
 Page 29 Going Dutch: An international share issue and privatisation will follow the merger of two of the Netherlands' largest banks, NMB and Postbank, the state-owned postal savings bank. 
 Page 29 Pound pressure: The Bank of England spent &dollar;1bn as the pound came under attack when it became clear that an increase in West German rates today is a virtual certainty. 
 This page Defence domination: The chairman of BAe says the European defence industry will be dominated by three or four major companies by the mid-1990s. 
 Outlook, page 27 IBM Euro link: IBM wants to become part of an Ecu3.3bn European effort to develop an indigenous semiconductor technology. 
 Page 27 World Markets New York: The Dow Jones Average reached a new peak of 2,772.80 at one point, but closed up 16.53 at 2,771.09. 
 Tokyo: Prices hardly moved all day in moderate trading, the Nikkei average ending just 16.43 points higher at 35,382.8. 
 Singapore: Reflecting Wall Street's overnight gains, the Straits Times index jumped 19.94 to 1,408.26 in brisk trade. 
 Sydney: Early buying petered out to leave the All Ordinaries index up 3.9 points at 1,775.6. 
 Bombay: Prices fell sharply for the second day running. 
 Frankfurt: Accepting an interest rate rise today as a foregone conclusion, the market continued to improve. 
 The DAX index gained 10.87 points to 1,613.27. 
 Zurich: Selected blue chips saw high turnover as shares firmed across the board. 
 The all-share index, at 1,178.8, was up 11.3. 
 Milan: The market edged up following several days of losses, but the underlying tone remained weak. 
 The MIB gained three points to 1,178. 
 Madrid: Shares closed weaker, with investors unwilling to take positions. 
 The general index slipped 0.69 to 324.62. 
 Amsterdam: Foreign demand boosted share prices, which ended a lively day firmer. 
 Istanbul: A frenzy of equity buying sent prices to their sixth consecutive high. 
 The index, at 1,834.83, is now 138 per cent up since the market was opened to foreign buyers on 9 August. 
 Sterling receives strong support 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 THE BANK of England yesterday spent a reported &dollar;1bn after the pound came under sustained attack once it became clear that an increase in West German interest rates today is almost certain. 
 Fears deepened yesterday that the West German Bundesbank might lift its key lending rates by as much as one full point &mdash; a move which could prompt a rise in UK base rates, now 14 per cent. 
 The Government is believed to be reluctant to push rates any higher, but City analysts predicted it would act if pressure on sterling became too great to hold with intervention alone. 
 Despite aggressive and highly visible intervention, which market estimates put between &dollar;750m and &dollar;1bn, the pound lost 1.8 pfennigs to close at DM3.0102, after sinking to DM3.009 at one stage. 
 Throughout the day the Bank sold both dollars and European currency units almost continuously in an effort to shore up the pound. 
 On the trade-weighted index, the pound fell 0.3 points to 90.9. 
 And in an indication of growing pressure for higher rates, the key three-month interbank rate firmed a quarter of a point to 1411 16 per cent. 
 Although the dollar ended lower against most other currencies in London, it finished unchanged at &dollar;1.6045 against the pound. 
 The US currency eased 1.07 pfennigs to finish at DM1.8748 and was 0.25 yen lower at Y140.90. 
 Analysts said that if sterling declined to 90 points on the index or plunged significantly below DM3 it would almost certainly trigger an increase in base rates. 
 Interest rate fears also drove down London share prices and the FT-SE 100 index of leading shares reversed a 12.5 point gain early in the day to close 6.5 points lower at 2,312.1. 
 Pressure on sterling resumed in New York late on Tuesday night after mounting speculation that the UK Treasury was extremely reluctant to raise base rates ahead of next week's Conservative party conference, and it continued in financial markets in the Far East. 
 The US Federal Reserve, the Bank of Japan and the Bank of England all stepped into the markets to defend the pound. 
 Margaret Thatcher, the Prime Minister, yesterday underlined that UK rates would remain &bquo;as high as necessary for as long as is necessary to keep downward pressure on inflation&equo;. 
 Her comments on interest rates had little impact on financial markets but they appeared to underscore the Government's commitment to holding up the pound. 
 But the commitment to a firm exchange rate may pose a dilemma as many economists believe the economy is now poised to slow down sharply. 
 And another increase in rates could increase the risks of recession. 
 David Walton, economist with Goldman Sachs, the US investment house, said: &bquo;They do run the risk of overkill, quite severe overkill if they push rates up.&equo; 
 Yesterday the Bundesbank drained funds in the German money markets pushing rates up to levels suggesting a full point increase in the Discount and Lombard rates, which stand at 5 per cent and 7 per cent respectively. 
 Official interest rates in several European countries are likely to be lifted when the Bundesbank decision is announced. 
 The leading central banks are expected to redouble their efforts to push down the dollar once the German decision is announced &mdash; something which may ease pressure on the pound if it changes the focus of attention in the foreign exchange markets. 
 But yesterday's sales of Ecus highlighted the conflict between official efforts to defend the pound and weaken the dollar. 
 The Bank's sales of Ecus for pounds were intended to shore up the pound against the mark, without resorting to outright sales of the German currency. 
 That could undermine the impact of Bundesbank sales of dollars for marks. 
 Anti-apartheid group End Loans to Southern Africa targets main banks 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 Demonstrators from the anti-apartheid group End Loans to Southern Africa outside National Westminster Bank's international headquarters in the City yesterday. 
 The group is targeting NatWest, Barclays and Standard Chartered - the three British banks on the technical committee negotiating the rescheduling of about &dollar;11bn of loans to South Africa. 
 The loans are due for repayment in June 1990. 
 Negotiations began last month in Zurich. 
 Photograph: Brian Harris  
 Halifax and Leeds join list of casualties 
 By PATRICK HOSKING, Banking Correspondent 
 THE property downturn claimed two more building society casualties yesterday, the Halifax announcing a &pound;14.5m loss from its estate agency chain and the Leeds Permanent closing down 60 branches and sacking 243 people. 
 The Halifax, Britain's biggest building society, also disclosed that it had set aside a &pound;20m provision against its loans to the collapsed London docklands developer Kentish Property Group. 
 On top of its building society branch closures, the Leeds is expected to dispose of 15 to 20 of its estate agency branches in what it called &bquo;selective pruning&equo;. 
 The cuts add to the increasing bloodshed in the property sector. 
 Last week the Nationwide Anglia announced it was closing 170 branches with 400 job losses and warned of more estate agency closures to come. 
 Other large estate agencies, including the Prudential, Black Horse and Hambro Countrywide chains have also had to shed large numbers of employees as home sales dry up. 
 Building societies face the threat of a further slowdown in their mortgage sales as pressure intensifies for an increase in base rates, and therefore mortgage rates. 
 The Halifax estate agency losses for the six months to 31 July compare with break-even in 1988. 
 The society remains committed to its 700-strong chain, though it said plans to create some new offices had been mothballed. 
 There might also be a very few closures, it said. 
 Overall the society produced a comparatively strong 6.4 per cent increase in pre-tax profits to &pound;237.7m for the half year. 
 Jim Birrell, chief executive, said: &bquo;The Halifax has proved its underlying strength in a subdued and difficult housing market.&equo; 
 However, the number of loans slumped from 150,000 last time, when the housing market was booming, to 97,000. 
 The Halifax share of total building society lending slipped from 22 per cent in 1988 to about 19.5 per cent. 
 A Halifax spokesman stressed the &pound;20m provision on loans to the Kentish development Burrell's Wharf was highly prudent and would not necessarily lead to a loss of the same magnitude. 
 Halifax was the lead lender on the project with total exposure of &pound;26m. 
 There were no plans to make major cuts in the 1,145-branch building society network, though there could be &bquo;the odd closure&equo;. 
 The Leeds said the plan to close 60 of its 481 branches across the country was part of its long-term strategy and had not been forced on it by the housing recession. 
 The closures are mainly smaller, less profitable branches or those with overlapping parishes: 150 full-time and 93 part-time staff will lose their jobs, some of them through voluntary redundancy and early retirement. 
 Some surviving branches will be expanded, others re-sited. 
 Mike Blackburn, chief executive, commented: &bquo;We will be able to reduce operating costs, increase branch profitability and take advantage of areas where there is more potential.&equo; 
 The society's 145-office estate agency chain, Property Leeds, is also to be cut back. 
 However, it is not commenting on the size of the cuts. 
 It hopes to sell some of the offices as going concerns. 
 The whole operation is thought to be loss-making, though the Leeds does not disclose its results. 
 Coopers and Deloitte in UK merger 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 COOPERS &amp; LYBRAND and Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells yesterday confirmed that they are to merge their UK practices to create the largest accountancy firm in the country with a fee income in excess of &pound;413m. 
 Brandon Gough, chairman of Coopers, said that heads of agreement have been signed and that the merger would be put into effect &bquo;as soon as is practicable&equo;. 
 The move, which has been presented as a fait accompli, effectively heralds the complete break-up of Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells International (DHSI), which until the beginning of this week was ostensibly in talks with another Big Eight firm, Touche Ross International. 
 Mr Gough said that the merger discussions had been completed in just three weeks. 
 But John Bullock, senior partner at Deloitte UK, admitted that Touche Ross had only been informed of his decision not to merge with them &bquo;a few days ago&equo;. 
 Touche Ross announced on Tuesday that it had formed a new international firm, Deloitte Ross Tohmatsu (DRT) without Deloitte UK. 
 There will now certainly follow a lengthy battle between Coopers and Touche Ross for the allegiance of DHSI members worldwide. 
 There is also likely to be a row over the name Deloitte, which neither party seems prepared to give up. 
 No name has been decided for the new UK firm. 
 But Mr Bullock said: &bquo;I can tell you that the name belongs to us.&equo; 
 As things stand, the Deloitte firms in the US, Japan and France have agreed to join DRT, with Canada expected to follow. 
 Coopers has Deloitte UK, which is the largest and most influential practice outside the US. 
 But there are rumours that France might be about to renege on its decision and Holland, which voted yesterday, is understood to have gone to Coopers. 
 Australia is likely to follow suit. 
 There is bound to be considerable upheaval among the blue-chip client list which Deloitte UK is bringing over to the new firm. 
 Mr Bullock said he hoped to retain the UK audits of multinational clients such as General Motors. 
 But in reality these are likely to go with the US firm to DRT. 
 There will probably also be problems on the grounds of competition. 
 Deloitte, for example, audits Cable &amp; Wireless, whereas Coopers audits British Telecommunications. 
 And there were reports yesterday that some of the major clients have not taken the news of the merger well. 
 Both Mr Gough and Mr Bullock said that the two firms had proved surprisingly compatible. 
 The new firm will boast a total staff of more than 10,000, including 637 partners, in 30 offices. 
 It will audit 175 out of The Times top 1,000 companies and 67 out of The Times top 500 financial companies. 
 Mr Gough is to be chairman and joint senior partner with Mr Bullock deputy chairman and joint senior partner. 
 Standard in 150m pound German deal 
 By PATRICK HOSKING 
 STANDARD Chartered yesterday announced plans to sell the bulk of its continental banking operations for &pound;150m in a pan-European tie-up with Westdeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale. 
 Standard is selling most of its continental commercial banking operations to WestLB for &pound;100m. 
 In a second deal, netting Standard another &pound;50m, the two sides are pooling their merchant banking units in Europe to form a 50/50 joint venture. 
 The deal has yet to be approved by the regulatory authorities. 
 Completion is expected by the end of the year. 
 The sale will strengthen Standard's balance sheet and improve its capital ratios, which have recently sunk close to limits set by the Bank of England. 
 Standard said it would add &pound;60m to its precious tier 1 capital. 
 Dusseldorf-based WestLB is the fourth largest bank in West Germany with total assets of &pound;55bn. 
 It has eight domestic branches and offices in 14 other countries. 
 Profit after tax in 1988 was &pound;38m. 
 Standard's commercial banking operations in Switzerland and Frankfurt are excluded from the sale, which hands over assets of &pound;2.5bn to WestLB. 
 The two sides will use one another's networks for correspondent banking. 
 The merged merchant bank comprises London-based Standard Chartered Merchant Bank and WestLB's much smaller corporate finance and third world debt trading units. 
 Sears hit by downturn in consumer spending 
 By TERENCE WILKINSON, Assistant City Editor 
 PRE-TAX profits at Sears, the Selfridges, Dolcis and Olympus retailing group, slumped by 10 per cent from &pound;102.3m to &pound;91.7m in the six months to 31 July as high street spending waned. 
 &bquo;High interest rates&hellip; have dampened consumer expenditure and impacted on retail spending,&equo; says the chairman, Geoffrey Maitland Smith. 
 &bquo;Increased costs, particularly wages and salaries, have also affected net margins.&equo; 
 The major setback to profits came in Sears' footwear division, about 40 per cent of total profits, where the trading surplus fell by almost a quarter to &pound;31.6m. 
 Sales, spanning Curtess, Trueform, Dolcis and Saxone, fell by 1.5 per cent on a store-for-store basis as volume was flat and prices fell. 
 Michael Pickard, chief executive, says that the hot summer weather favoured sales of sporting shoes, where Sears' footwear division is under-represented. 
 Sales here rose by 18 per cent, and the Miss Selfridge subsidiary also put in a strong performance with a sales gain of 17.5 per cent on a store-for-store comparison. 
 Against that Wallis women's wear and Horne had a tough half-year while Selfridges, helped by a return of tourism, held up. 
 Mr Pickard says that up to &pound;6.3m of special factors depressed profits. 
 These included a &pound;2m bill for the rail strike, &pound;2m on new catalogues, &pound;1m associated with a credit card scheme and &pound;1.3m on clearing out unwanted stock from the Horne menswear chain. 
 Although property activities forged ahead, the Galliford Sears housebuilding subsidiary saw profits fall from &pound;16m to &pound;9m as completions fell by more than 50 per cent. 
 The interim dividend is raised by 5.2 per cent to 1.525p. 
 Lord Hanson tops pay scales 
 By PATRICK HOSKING 
 LORD HANSON was the highest paid director of a public company last year, closely followed by Roland &bquo;Tiny&equo; Rowland. 
 The Hanson chairman earned &pound;1.239m; the Lonrho chief made do with &pound;1.015m. 
 Top pay increased by an average of 17.8 per cent, according to a survey and league table published yesterday by Charterhouse, the merchant bank. 
 A quarter of the country's highest-paid executives had pay rises of 36 per cent or more. 
 A quarter received increases of less than 7 per cent. 
 Fifth place in the top-earners league was taken by an unnamed director of Palmerston Holdings, the property company, who boosted his &pound;20,000 basic pay to &pound;911,608 with a bonus linked to growth in net assets. 
 There were 25 per cent pay cuts for Burton Group's Sir Ralph Halpern and John Gunn of British &amp; Commonwealth, who sank to earnings of &pound;996,000 and &pound;740,700 respectively. 
 Using data from 1,000 1988 annual reports, the survey found a close correlation between industry performance and pay increases. 
 The stores and construction sectors, which were then booming, produced average pay rises of more than 20 per cent. 
 Consumer goods manufacturers averaged only 12.5 per cent. 
 Larger firms and international companies tended to offer the biggest pay rises. 
 Banking is the occupation yielding the greatest number of high salaries. 
 Directors of financial institutions occupy seven of the top 25 places. 
 Earnings figures exclude share options and pension contributions. 
 According to the author of the report, Tony Vernon Harcourt, a director on base pay of &pound;100,000 typically enjoys a package close to &pound;200,000 after adding in a &pound;17,000 bonus, &pound;20,000 company pension contribution, car and other benefits worth &pound;10,000 and an annual profit on share options worth about &pound;50,000. 
 Traffic estimates knock Eurotunnel 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON and SARAH LAMBERT in Paris 
 EUROTUNNEL shares continued to plunge in London and Paris yesterday as investors took fright at indications that the spiralling costs of the Channel tunnel would not be offset by increased traffic estimates. 
 By the close, the shares had fallen a further 40p on the London market to close at 560p while they ended the day on the French bourse Fr3.6 lower at Fr59.9 amid heavy dealing in both markets. 
 As the shares continued to fall in the wake of Eurotunnel's estimate that the project would cost at least &pound;2.2bn more than forecast, Alastair Morton, co-chairman of the Anglo-French consortium was in Paris trying to persuade the French banks of the need for new financing. 
 Despite the jitters the cost escalation has caused in the City, the French appear to be taking a more sanguine view. 
 At Banque Indosuez, one of the French underwriters of the project, Jean-Michel Plou, said the tunnel had gone too far to fail. 
 Once Eurotunnel and Transmanche Link, the consortium of firms building the tunnel, had produced more precise figures detailing the projected cost over-runs, the banks would be more willing to stump up the extra money, raising borrowing costs if necessary, he added. 
 The fact that traffic estimates are not being increased to compensate for the rising construction costs is certain to raise fears that the cost of using the tunnel will be forced up by its scheduled opening in June 1993. 
 Mr Morton is certain to face a City grilling on the latest cost and traffic estimates when Eurotunnel presents its interim results next Monday. 
 Under the refinancing envisaged by Eurotunnel, private investors will be asked to raise up to &pound;350m through a rights issue in return for the project's banks agreeing to provide a further &pound;1bn in loans. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Poetry and the people: &bquo;Under Briggflatts&equo; - Donald Davie: Carcanet, 18.95 pounds 
 By KEVIN JACKSON 
 SOME years ago, the poets Hugh MacDiarmid and Basil Bunting dropped in to a bar in Moffat, Dumfriesshire. 
 It was a grim sort of place, and Bunting felt uneasy as a group of workmen began to stare at them and murmur ominously. 
 At length, Bunting recalled, &bquo;the largest workman rose frowning and came to our table; but what he said was: &bquo;Is it no the great poet, Hugh MacDiarmid?&equo; 
 '. Within seconds, the locals started buying the poets round after round of whisky, quoting enthusiastically from MacDiarmid's work. 
 It seems no more than a charming anecdote, but when Professor Davie cites Bunting's tale in Under Briggflatts, his history of British poetry since 1960, he calls the incident &bquo;challenging&equo;. 
 What prompts him to this unexpected adjective is that (as Bunting stressed) the poems these men admired were not &bquo;simplified to aim at the poor&equo;, but &bquo;written for a hard intellectual audience&equo;. 
 But there are further reasons for his choice of qualifier, and they involve Davie in cultural as well as literary criticism. 
 Though its accounts of individual poems are as searching as anything in Davie's earlier books (we owe Carcanet a debt: this is to be the first in a uniform edition of Davie's work), Under Briggflatts is also a mordant and compelling history of the social climates to which these poems were a response. 
 As such, it should command the attention even of readers who feel that they have no time for the art. 
 If that class is sadly numerous today, it may be because of a common belief that &bquo;British poetry has chosen to turn inwards, parochial, self-comforting and serviceable&equo;. 
 It is Davie's contention that this view is quite wrong: there are a great many outstandingly talented British poets, including Charles Tomlinson, C H Sisson, Elaine Feinstein and others (Davie, as distinguished a poet as any of his subjects, modestly excludes his own work) who do not answer to this description, and one purpose of Under Briggflats is to claim for them the attention they have often been denied; in some cases, indeed, to rescue them from scandalous neglect. 
 The most important figure in the latter group is Bunting himself, so little read these days that many readers will need to be told that the title of Davie's history refers to his masterpiece Briggflatts (1966). 
 Why the neglect? 
 Partly, Davie believes, because the British are now too ignorant of prosody to be able to hear Bunting's precise, subtle music; partly because, as an associate of Pound and Zukovsky, he is &bquo;an embarrassment to the numerous English historians who would have it that modernism in poetry was a temporary, American-inspired distraction from a native tradition&hellip;&equo; 
 In drawing attention to many such embarrassments, Davie's book is sure to provoke a good deal of rancour in certain circles. 
 Yet it would not be quite right to call Under Briggflatts &bquo;controversial&equo;, for that deadened word implies a self-serving wish to shock which is far from Davie's considered anger. 
 And if Davie's principles make him what some might call &bquo;elitist&equo; or &bquo;undemocratic&equo;, as in his stinging verdicts on &bquo;catchpenny enterprises&hellip; like the Arvon Poetry Competitions&equo;, it is not without his having pondered the arguments about the place and function of elites and of high art in a democratic nation far more deeply than the bulk of his fellow countrymen. 
 Just as importantly, he is possessed of a generosity of mind which allows him to be calmly judicious about the merits of writers who can advocate militant homosexuality and drug-taking (such as Thom Gunn), sympathise with feminism (Elaine Feinstein) or adhere to some variant of Marxism (Hugh MacDiarmid). 
 Both in his sternness and in his generosity, Davie is strongly reminiscent of a much earlier writer, whose name is invoked towards the end of Under Briggflatts. 
 Here, Davie pays a handsome compliment to one fellow critic by implying that the best of his prose can stand comparison with an eighteenth-century writer's &bquo;sharp and exact delineations of what in one poet's work distinguishes him from all others&equo;. 
 Davie's tribute applies still more precisely to his own writing in Under Briggflatts, a book whose perspicacity, range of learning and pitiless eye for cant can leave little doubt which modern critic most richly deserves comparison with Samuel Johnson. 
 Russian roulette: Dominic Lieven on the dangers in Gorbachev's bid to make strikes illegal 
 By DOMINIC LIEVEN 
 ON MONDAY the Politburo decided to ban all strikes for the next 15 months. 
 On Tuesday the Soviet parliament refused to accept this blanket ban, which it wanted confined to the railways and to other key industries, and only to remain in force until the new law on strikes was promulgated. 
 The Politburo has bowed to a considerable extent to the parliament's wishes. 
 The party leadership wanted to ban all strikes because it is terrified of an upsurge in Russian and Ukrainian working-class militancy which, it correctly realises, could be more dangerous to the regime than all the ethnic disturbances of the last few years combined. 
 The miners' strike in July showed how quickly workers' discontent can erupt, take organised and radical form, and acquire leaders. 
 The Politburo fears events similar to those in Poland in the late 1970s and the 1980s. 
 The scenario reads: pressure on living standards added to general contempt for the regime leads to massive strikes which cause the economy to nosedive and popular discontent to boil over. 
 The political consequences are first increasing loss of control and crumbling of the party apparatus, next the state's need to fall back on the army and police to preserve its own existence, public order and, it claims, the chance of imposing painful economic reforms. 
 Martial law, capable of preserving order but not reversing economic decline, in turn yields to semi-pluralism as the principle of the party's monopoly of power is jettisoned to create a national consensus behind measures to salvage the country's economy. 
 Army rule and multi-party democracy are, to an almost equal degree, anathema to the Soviet party leadership, Mikhail Gorbachev included. 
 Moreover the Politburo can argue both that political pluralism is no panacea for economic problems, and that it is much easier to apply in Poland than in the vast multi-ethnic Soviet empire. 
 In proposing a ban on strikes, the Soviet leadership therefore wished to nip the incipient labour movement in the bud. 
 But the Supreme Soviet has, at least temporarily, put a spoke in the wheels. 
 The parliament's deputies have displayed not only independence but an intelligent unwillingness to panic in the face of economic crisis. 
 For this, Mr Gorbachev will have cause to be grateful, for a 15-month total ban on strikes is dangerous and unworkable nonsense. 
 The ban would be a major blow to Soviet civil liberties, none of which is long-established or firmly rooted. 
 Nor is there any sense in banning strikes &bquo;temporarily&equo;, since the economic crisis which gives rise to labour unrest is anything but temporary, and the radical measures of economic reform (such as market prices) which might ultimately solve this crisis have not yet been adopted and will take years to yield results. 
 Above all, a ban on strikes is dangerous as it could only be implemented at the cost of Mr Gorbachev's package of political reforms. 
 Banned or not, strikes will happen, for the population is beyond the stage when harsh words will cow it into submissiveness. 
 Nor, when illegal strikes occur, will halfway measures of repression end them. 
 As the Polish authorities learnt in the 1970s, and the Soviet ones recently in Georgia, shooting strikers or demonstrators does not deter a mass movement but merely infuriates it and provides it with martyrs. 
 Woe betide a Soviet regime which shoots Russian and Eastern Ukrainian miners, the elite of the working class in the supposed land of the proletariat, and does so moreover in an era when suppression of news is no longer possible and society is rapidly organising itself autonomously of the state. 
 Such an event would represent the parting of the ways between Mr Gorbachev and the Slav masses, and would lead him almost inexorably down the road towards a full-scale assault on glasnost and civil liberties. 
 If Mr Gorbachev believed he could acquire a breathing space through repression, during which the economy could be transformed by unpopular but necessary reforms, he might be willing to pay the price, but this would reverse his strategy of the past three years. 
 In this period he came to believe that, to be effective, economic reforms must be accompanied by political liberalisation. 
 To crush strikes and abandon political reform would be to throw himself into the arms of those groups wedded not just to authoritarian politics but to neo-Stalinist economic institutions and principles. 
 At which point Mr Gorbachev's strategy of turning the USSR into a prosperous society in which intelligent Russians can take pride will be doomed. 
 In a capitalist country, political dictatorship is not incompatible with economic modernisation and can even facilitate it. 
 In a neo-Stalinist society in the 1990s, this is not the case, and therein lies one of Mr Gorbachev's key dilemmas. 
 His support for a 15-month blanket ban on strikes suggests that he is still not wholly aware of this fact. 
 When miners, chemical workers or railwaymen do actually defy the ban and strike this winter, he will need to be reminded or disaster will ensue. 
 The immediate casualty would be Mr Gorbachev's reform programme. 
 The longer-term one might be the Soviet regime itself. 
 There is more to it than tactics 
 By PETER JENKINS 
 BRIGHTON: This afternoon's debate about electoral reform is unlikely to lead very far, given the adamant opposition of the leadership. 
 All the same there is a growing swell of support for electoral reform within the Labour movement and a good deal of support among MPs. 
 According to a Mori poll conducted for the Electoral Reform Society, a commitment by Labour to proportional representation could result in a 2.5-3 per cent swing to Labour in a general election. 
 It would come predominantly from middle-aged, middle-class voters in the South and be chiefly at the expense of the Social and Liberal Democrats, Social Democrats and Greens. 
 These are exactly the sort of voters Labour needs in the South, where the Conservatives retain a 14-point mid-term lead. 
 On Sunday the national executive committee firmly rejected the proposal to set up a working party to study electoral reform. 
 The item is simply not on Neil Kinnock's agenda. 
 He said the proponents of proportional representation were advocating a gigantic and fundamental constitutional change for short-term tactical purposes. 
 And so they are. 
 The drive behind the campaign for so-called &bquo;fairer voting&equo; comes predominantly from leftish groups who believe there is an anti-Thatcher majority in the country which the electoral system enables her to flout on the strength of a 42 per cent minority. 
 This is a dubious proposition. 
 The last few years suggest that if there is a majority in the land it has been an anti-Labour majority. 
 The burgeoning of the Liberal-SDP Alliance was largely the consequence of Labour's perceived unfitness to govern. 
 Opinion polls suggested that the centre parties would have been hard put to deliver many of their supporters to Labour under an electoral pact. 
 Many would have preferred Mrs Thatcher. 
 A simpler solution than electoral reform is to abandon the policies and attitudes which have barred Labour from power, which is what Mr Kinnock has been about. 
 An unholy alliance with other minorities to preserve ideological positions otherwise unacceptable to the electorate does not appeal as a noble enterprise. 
 Refuting the argument that proportional representation would mean trimming to minority centrist positions, Robin Cooke, one of Labour's leading advocates of reform, said: &bquo;We have already gone to endless lengths to placate the centre ground.&equo; 
 Exactly. 
 A properly functioning two-party system has a centrifugal dynamic. 
 The growth of third parties in the Seventies and early Eighties was in a large part a product of the malfunctioning of the two-party system, partly as a consequence of Mrs Thatcher's rejection of the post-war consensus but chiefly as a result of Labour's leftward lurches. 
 Mr Kinnock is correct to insist that fundamental changes in the voting system should not be undertaken for short-term, tactical reasons. 
 Nor is there much in the fairness argument, although this is the reason offered by 46 per cent of the people interested in PR. 
 I cannot see that one voting system is intrinsically more fair than another. 
 It is not fair, perhaps, that with 23 per cent of the vote the Alliance should have won only 3 per cent of the seats in the House of Commons. 
 But nor is it fair that with 6 or 7 per cent of the vote, the West German liberals should be the sole arbiters of who rules in Bonn. 
 The case for electoral reform is best discussed in terms of the question: what kind of political system do we want? 
 Our electoral system strongly favours two-party government; other people's systems, in varying degree proportionate, result in coalitions of a usually centrist tinge. 
 The difference goes far deeper than the political complexion of the government. 
 The strong tendency of pluralistic systems of Europe is consensual and, in some cases, quasi-corporatist; on the other side of the coin, they enable extremist minorities to thrive. 
 Our system is adversarial in style, friendly to class-based, ideological parties, it effectively excludes minorities from the parliamentary arena, and results almost invariably in one-party rule. 
 Which has been better governed since the war, Britain or, say, the Federal Republic of Germany? 
 Economies, it would appear, thrive on the kind of continuity which coalition government helps to provide. 
 They also benefit from the higher degree of social solidarity which seems to accompany more pluralistic systems. 
 Such systems, moreover, encourage incrementalist rather than ideological approaches, which have resulted in a successful mix of market economics and welfare. 
 In Britain, the home of strong government and political stability, the post-war years &mdash; or, at least, since 1964 &mdash; have been marked by an instability of policy, intensifying social conflict and a record of economic failure. 
 These unfavourable contrasts were commonplace at the beginning of the decade and were at the heart of the centrist critique of two-party politics as then played. 
 Since then three things have happened. 
 First, Mrs Thatcher has, through policies of liberalisation, put the economy on a footing similar to the more efficient continental economies. 
 Second, Labour under Mr Kinnock is belatedly making the transition to continental-style social democracy. 
 Third, the centre has collapsed as a political force &mdash; although not as a constituency &mdash; and this obliges both major parties to compete more assiduously for middle-of-the-road votes. 
 The outlines of a new post-Thatcherite consensus begin to be visible. 
 Electoral reform would help to entrench this style of politics. 
 In debating it today the Labour Conference should focus not on its tactical advantages but on the kind of political system it wishes to see. 
 There is no more fundamental question. 
 Making the change with body talk 
 By TERRY COLEMAN 
 As I drove into Brighton, I did not see one sign to the Labour Party conference, but many directing me to something called Bodytalk. 
 And there was, as it turned out, a lot of body talk about Neil Kinnock. 
 For him to blow a kiss to the gallery was one thing. 
 But when last did a politician make such copious use of a handsome wife? 
 Taking his curtain calls after a successful speech, he drew her to him by the hand and entwined his arms with hers until she gently shook him off, whereupon he enjoyed his triumph for a while manfully alone, until he again resorted to his wife Glenys, going to fetch her, leading her again by the hand, and holding her by the waist. 
 He had, as it were, taken to heart Labour's advice to constituency parties on the display of their leaflets and other electioneering wares: &bquo;Use rose at the correct angle, and do not cut off stem.&equo; 
 He had after all had a good conference. 
 He had got rid of Ken Livingstone from Labour's national executive committee, and got rid too of Labour's unilateralist nuclear policy. 
 I suppose it does not matter that this was a policy until lately dear to his heart, and even dearer to his wife's. 
 I suppose he had forgotten that when Bill Jordan, president of the engineering workers' union, asked him during the 1987 election campaign to announce then that he would hold a referendum on unilateralism after the election, he declined and replied that people would come round to it once they understood. 
 I suppose he had, in good faith, forgotten &mdash; though Tony Benn in conference reminded him &mdash; that in 1987 every Labour MP, every one, was elected on that unilateralist promise. 
 But, as the conference slogan told us again and again, &bquo;Meet the Challenge: Make the Change.&equo; 
 Mr Kinnock has made the change all right, and, since he told us in his speech that he has acted with candour, we must believe him. 
 He says he has now produced answers that the people understand. 
 That's entertainment. 
 All in all, he has done well. 
 A Labour conference is a tricky thing. 
 It is not a well-drilled rally like the Conservatives'. 
 At a Labour conference you get Gerry Adams turning up at a fringe meeting, and he the leader of Sinn Fein, which is cousin to the IRA, which in 1984, in this same town, blew up the Grand Hotel in an attempt to murder the Prime Minister and Cabinet. 
 It is at Labour conferences that you hear international co-operation praised to the skies, while multinational corporations, presumably because they are mostly American, are big bad wolves. 
 It is at Labour conferences that you get the sweet nuttiness of Baby Milk Action, which proclaims, &bquo;Breast Milk: a World Resource,&equo; and tells you, as a fact, that it would take 114 million lactating cows to replace the milk of the women of India. 
 It is at the conferences of Labour, the party that killed the grammar schools, that you see one fruit of that enlightened policy, which is that many of the younger delegates are incoherently illiterate. 
 But change there is. 
 &bquo;Make the change&equo;, and Labour is a party on the make. 
 It is still a mix of ancient and modern. 
 Delegates are still addressed as brother, sister, or comrade, but this year there are electronic signs in the hall giving the speaker's name &mdash; as there have been at the Conservative conference for quite a while. 
 This is a conference which keeps very much in mind the symbolic advice offered in that pamphlet, to which I alluded just now, the one which tells you how to lay out election leaflets. 
 &bquo;Don't,&equo; it says, &bquo;confuse people by using out-of-date logos from years ago, such as flags, fists, or the pen/spade/sword.&equo; 
 Change, then. 
 But it was not Mr Kinnock whose speech brought about the miraculous change of heart on unilateralism. 
 I heard no trace of the word in his speech. 
 It was Gerald Kaufman, shadow foreign secretary, who did that for him, in a speech of vast sweeping grasp. 
 Most notably it swept southern Africa, though he did talk about a visit to Russia where his hosts had told him Labour would be good partners in disarmament. 
 No doubt. 
 But he dreamed of a free Namibia, and asked the conference to send Swapo a message of solidarity and support for a massive victory in a free Namibian election. 
 Of such an election, and its conduct, I trust he will give a report next year. 
 And then there was his visit to the Republic of South Africa. 
 Two months ago he went there and saw the usual places and people. 
 He said he had also been offered interviews with ministers in the South African government, so that he could form a balanced judgement, but had declined. 
 He had, he said, got his balanced view without shaking those bloodstained hands. 
 What a mind is Mr Kaufman's, so sure there is nothing to be learned but what it wishes to learn, so serenely confident in its own perfected little judgement of what is a great and complex tragedy. 
 He ended by saying that the prospect of a Labour government was a beacon of hope for millions of striving and oppressed people throughout the world. 
 If he believes that many of those millions have even heard of the party, he will believe anything. 
 Enough of him. 
 Now we come to the grey sections. 
 Labour, with its reasonable and historic fears of parties within the party, has often rejected the idea of separate black and Asian sections. 
 But this time the executive had come up with a compromise of sterling dimness. 
 OK, there should be an affiliated &bquo;socialist society&equo; for blacks and Asians, but whites could join too. 
 All this was to combat racism in all its manifestations. 
 At which the manifestations of blacks and Asians from the floor were as downright as might have been expected. 
 It was an insult: they didn't need white nannies &mdash; did more than two black people in a room constitute a riot? -were they to step back to the old plantation days? &mdash; had Kinnock and Hattersley been drunk when they drafted the proposal? 
 At which poor Jack Rogers &mdash; a former bricklayer and union leader, and the member of the executive taking the can back as he replied to the debate &mdash; innocently protested they hadn't been drunk, they hadn't even had a cup of tea. 
 (Consolatory cries of &bquo;Aah.&equo;) 
 The grey sections were chucked out. 
 &bquo;So,&equo; said the chairman, &bquo;we're back to square one.&equo; 
 At a Fabian fringe meeting, Andrew Neil, editor of The Sunday Times and executive chairman of Rupert Murdoch's Sky Television, made a speech, of course in his own and his boss's interest, which had a sense and vigour that the conference platform could dearly do with. 
 How was it, he asked, that Labour was opposed to a poll tax in local government, but in favour of a poll tax (the BBC licence fee) in television? 
 Then we went back for the long-service merit awards. 
 These, for me, are often the best bit of the conference. 
 The recipients are the party's living history. 
 This year they were Annie Huggett, aged 97, and Roy Hughes, aged 80. 
 Between them they had served the party for 139 years. 
 Mr Hughes's mother was a suffragette. 
 His wife's grandfather helped found the ILP (Independent Labour Party) in 1893. 
 Himself, he was a railwayman who travelled all over the country, campaigned in more than 20 constituencies and was elected a Labour councillor in three towns. 
 He was in hospital and unable to come to Brighton. 
 But Annie Huggett was there, alert and bright. 
 She has been a member of the party since 1911, and for 50 years, until a few weeks ago, collected subscriptions. 
 She addressed the conference. 
 She was plainly delighted. 
 She said one of her most memorable times was in 1924, when Malcolm Muggeridge's father was the candidate in her constituency. 
 Her dearest wish was to live another couple of years and see Neil Kinnock as prime minister. 
 The conference stood to her. 
 She is Labour past. 
 Labour present is Neil Kinnock, who speaks for 63 minutes and quotes Robert Frost about miles to go and promises to keep, and about a brighter dawn when poverty, privilege, fear, disease, woe, and war shall live only in the memory of time. 
 And who then talks about the security and liberty of the planet. 
 When, I wonder, did it become fashionable for politicians to talk not about the world but about the planet? 
 &bquo;Planet&equo; is greener. 
 But is Mr Kinnock wise, having trimmed &mdash; having trimmed to a wiser policy, but all the same egregiously trimmed &mdash; is he wise to insist that the British people respect Labour for the changes it has made? 
 Is he wise to say, and make much of it, that people come up and tell him so? 
 Having trimmed, a man might shut up about it. 
 But back to Bodytalk, whose convention happened to be at the Metropole, next to Labour's conference hotel. 
 It is all about health, fitness, training, tone and tanning. 
 There are acres of exercise machines for men and slimming machines for women. 
 Girls lie on machines which move their bodies in quasi-sexual transports &mdash; falling, opening, rising. 
 Weird. 
 I was found wandering by Mr Ozzy Dunk, a salesman for Golden Touch Sunbed Centres. 
 He demonstrated to me an Ergoline 35-tube sunbed in which a man lies full length. 
 He said it would change and tone a man in three five-minute sessions over a period of a week. 
 The Ergoline would tan a man top to toe and front and back. 
 The face was hardest to tan, and this model, which was for professionals and cost &pound;5,912 plus VAT, featured three facial tanning units, one to tan the front of the face and two others to tan the sides. 
 This is the easy way. 
 Thus can a man, in three five-minutes sessions, attain a multilateral tan. 
 Leading Article: Strike mentality at Brighton 
 By TERRY COLEMAN 
 THE vague and ill-considered commitment to dilute the Government's industrial relations reforms which was endorsed so easily yesterday by the Labour Party conference will return to haunt the party's leaders, rather as the question of nuclear weapons did until it was, apparently, laid to rest earlier this week. 
 Conservative Central Office will be able to make much of the suggestion that, under a Labour administration, secondary picketing would once again be lawful, that unions which ignored the courts would no longer face the possibility of sequestration and that it would not be possible for employers or other interested parties to apply for interim injunctions postponing precipitate strikes. 
 Yet union activists will read into the same policy review an endorsement of the main thrust of Conservative legislation. 
 Bill Jordan of the engineering workers and Eric Hammond of the electricians, the two union leaders who have consistently opposed law breaking and whose unions have long and honourable records of support for secret ballots, were, significantly, given a rough ride yesterday. 
 But Arthur Scargill, who repeated his contempt for ballots, was roundly applauded. 
 Moreover, the important, though limited, concessions to the unions which Neil Kinnock has now made, are based on the false premise that current legislation is unbalanced and unfair and renders effective strike action impossible. 
 For example, Ron Todd of the Transport and General Workers' Union blamed the systematic bias and ignorance of the courts, and the new freedom to dismiss strikers granted by this Government, for the failure of the dock strike which was called by his union this summer. 
 Mr Todd and his allies are mistaken. 
 The dock strike failed because the transport workers did not have the strength to defend the labour monopoly enjoyed by registered dockers in a number of ports once the Government removed its statutory underpinning. 
 At much the same time, however, workers on British Rail successfully defended their procedures in the courts and subsequently went on to conduct a very effective strike from which they emerged victorious. 
 Unions are demonstrating a growing sophistication and success in their use of the law, while the courts are increasingly aware of the difference between an employer who is frivolously testing his rights to its limits and an enterprise with genuine reason for seeking an interim injunction. 
 But the most dispiriting aspect of yesterday's debate was the preoccupation which union delegates had with rendering the strike weapon more effective. 
 In the present climate it is hard to see the function of strikes except in public-sector monopolies. 
 Unions such as the engineering workers and the electricians, which have been most successful over the past decade (and which, incidentally, embraced democratic reforms years ago), have attempted to improve the terms and conditions of their members by other means. 
 A Labour movement looking to the 1990s would have been been debating single union, no-strike deals and profit-related payment systems rather than how best to call strikes and whether a system of labour tribunals was needed to compensate for the supposed bias of the capitalist courts. 
 Letter: Police raid on the Broadwater Farm estate 
 From Mr MILLARD SCOTT and Mr SHAUN WATERMAN 
 Sir: Now that the dust kicked up by the mass raid on the Broadwater Farm estate last week has begun to settle, it is time to embark upon an assessment of its effects. 
 Dealing in drugs, particularly hard drugs, is not an activity condoned by any of the community organisations on the estate. 
 Indeed, the Broadwater Farm Youth Association has expressed its concern about the situation to the police on a number of occasions, and in August 1989 went so far as to close the youth centre on the estate for some time in an effort to stop dealers congregating there. 
 Police reports on the night claimed that &bquo;substantial&equo; seizures of cannabis and cocaine had been made &mdash; thus effectively labelling those arrested as &bquo;crack barons&equo; and prejudicing their chances of a fair hearing in court. 
 However, since then the police have been remarkably reticent about the exact quantity of drugs which they recovered. 
 It is our understanding that less than two grammes of cocaine were seized and that the police recovered no evidence whatsoever of any dealing of hard drugs on the estate. 
 Moreover, the tactics that the police employed raise wider questions about their motives in mounting this massive &mdash; and very costly &mdash; operation. 
 The police have had the estate under video surveillance for many weeks. 
 They claim to have carefully identified those that they wanted to arrest. 
 Why then did they seal off an area of Tottenham more than one mile across? 
 Why were a woman and her 10-month-old baby strip-searched, and other mothers separated from their terrified children? 
 Why are more than one-third of those charged accused of public order offences? 
 Why were the offices of the Broadwater Farm Defence Campaign illegally searched, and why were Defence Campaign staff arrested practically on site as they tried to enter the estate? 
 Why, in short, was it necessary to criminalise and terrorise our entire community? 
 In any other part of the country, police would have apprehended the drug dealers in a series of dawn raids. 
 Because of the Farm's history, they used the occasion to mount a show of force, and to do so at 5pm, when children playing on the estate would be terrified by the raid, but when they could be sure of a good spot on the Six O'Clock News. 
 Tottenham police are fond of saying publicly that they want to &bquo;build bridges&equo; with the community here. 
 They made much of the participation of so-called &bquo;community leaders&equo; in the raid, and of the &bquo;accountability&equo; that they demonstrated through the involvement of hand-picked representatives of the media. 
 If the police are truly interested in being accountable to and building bridges with those that they police, why did they not discuss their plans with representatives of the community organisations on the estate? 
 The observers that took part in the raid do not in any way represent the residents of this estate and are widely regarded here as being little better than police stooges. 
 The record of the police with respect to this estate is frankly appalling. 
 Hardly a week passes in which the Defence Campaign does not monitor incidents of harassment or malpractice by officers from Tottenham. 
 If the police hope to gain the trust of the people of Broadwater Farm, they must begin by showing good faith towards those that the residents have chosen to represent themselves &mdash; the local council and the community organisations here. 
 It is we, after all, who have to pick up the pieces and begin again the struggle to live our lives with dignity, and in freedom from arbitrary and authoritarian policing. 
 Leading Article: America's Panamanian legacy 
 From Mr MILLARD SCOTT and Mr SHAUN WATERMAN 
 GENERAL MANUEL NORIEGA, the military ruler of Panama, is largely a creation of the Americans, but one of whom Washington is now anxious to be rid: hence the unvarnished disappointment there at the failure of the latest attempt to topple him. 
 As head of its armed forces, General Noriega rules a country which was itself brought into being by the United States. 
 The territory through which President Theodore Roosevelt was determined to build a trans-oceanic canal belonged, inconveniently, to Colombia. 
 With the help of co-operative Panamanians, it was duly seized and a provisional Panamanian government established, with an American warship in the background. 
 The canal was completed in 1914. 
 For several decades, Panama was juridically a protectorate of the United States, and effectively an American colony. 
 Power was in the hands of the army, which the Americans had created. 
 But in the 1960s, thanks in part to the charismatic leadership of General Omar Torrijos, a strong sense of nationalism emerged. 
 The canal treaties were revised under President Carter, with control passing to Panama at the end of the century. 
 Meanwhile, American troops (12,000 of them at present) remain to protect the waterway and American lives. 
 General Noriega became head of intelligence under General Torrijos, and strengthened his links with the CIA by providing information about Cuba and left-wing movements in Central America. 
 He has ruled Panama since General Torrijos's mysterious death in a plane crash in 1981. 
 Until two years ago he was, despite his flirtations with the Soviet Union, seen as an ally in President Reagan's obsessional war against the Sandinista regime in Nicaragua. 
 His involvement with the drug barons of Colombia was known, but - like his thuggish way with political opponents &mdash; considered to be of secondary importance. 
 For the past two years, Washington has been desperate to unseat a ruler who, across the world, had come to symbolise the crass stupidity and shortsightedness of American policy in Latin America. 
 Ironically, the deep-seated mistrust, even hatred, left by a half-century of American support for despots and oligarchs in that region has helped keep General Noriega in power. 
 His defiance of Uncle Sam has even earned him a grudging respect. 
 The United States thus finds itself in a no-win situation: the more it is seen to be intervening against him, the more it is likely to reinforce his position. 
 Since Washington imposed economic sanctions on Panama last year, its economy has gone into a steep decline. 
 Yet General Noriega has not fallen, and evidently has sufficient funds to maintain the loyalty of the larger part of the armed forces: thanks in part, it is suspected, to the support of the drug barons of Colombia. 
 Several of the main fugitives from the present Colombian crackdown on the drugs industry are alleged to be sheltering in Panamanian safe-houses. 
 Against him are ranged Panama's middle classes and officers with a grudge: when promotion is based on loyalty rather than ability, there will always be those who advocate a coup. 
 But until there are enough to ensure success, the Americans will have to live with the legacy of their own poor judgement. 
 America: land of the rising Sony 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 I READ that the US is in the grip of Japanophobia following the purchase of Columbia Pictures by Sony. 
 Can this be right? 
 No. 
 &bquo;Phobia&equo; is from the Greek. 
 &bquo;Japan&equo; is a word of Eastern origin. 
 Therefore they should not be used together in the same word. 
 No, what I want to know is whether the US is gripped by a wave of fear of the Japanese. 
 Why not? 
 Nobody likes an absentee landlord. 
 Very droll. 
 Any other reason? 
 Yes. 
 Because it is Japan's turn. 
 Could you explain that? 
 Certainly. 
 You must remember that Americans are afraid of nobody. 
 They stand tall, jut their chins out, call no one Sir and can lick any man in the house. 
 They do not know fear. 
 But they have been dead scared of the Russians for 40 years. 
 That is what happens when you are afraid of nobody all the time. 
 It gets very tiring jutting your chin out, standing tall and being able to lick anyone in the house if you have nobody to do it to. 
 So the Americans, as well as not knowing fear, have to have an enemy to be afraid of. 
 But they are not afraid of the Russians any more. 
 Well, they have been afraid of the Russians for so long that they have learned to live with it. 
 So they need fresh enemies ordered up from time to time just to keep their chins jutting. 
 The Chinese. 
 The Vietnamese. 
 The Iranians. 
 The Libyans. 
 The Panamanians and Nicaraguans. 
 And now the Japanese. 
 But the Japanese are their friends. 
 No, they are their allies. 
 That is quite different. 
 The Americans have no real friends. 
 Goodness, how sad. 
 Not at all. 
 No other nation has any real friends either. 
 What is an ally, then? 
 An ally is a nation which you beat fair and square in a war some time ago and which is now on your side. 
 America put Japan back on its feet, dusted it down, shook hands with it and said let bygones be bygones. 
 As a result, Japan now wants revenge and sees peace as the best way of getting its own back. 
 How is it doing that? 
 By taking over ownership of America. 
 This will culminate in a celebration in 1991 to mark the 50th anniversary of the start of the war in the Pacific. 
 Japan will take America by surprise by storming in early one morning and buying Pearl Harbor. 
 Meanwhile, what are the immediate effects of Sony buying Columbia Pictures? 
 David Puttnam will be going round with a quiet smile on his face for a few days. 
 Apart from that. 
 Will Sony remake The Bridge on The River Kwai? 
 Very droll. 
 Of course not. 
 It is the Americans who remake foreign films, not the other way round. 
 Think of The Seven Samurai. 
 Think of Breathless. 
 Think of Three Men and a Baby. 
 Think of&hellip; 
 All right, all right. 
 So why does Sony want Columbia? 
 Sony has been working on a new Walkman which allows you to watch films as you go around. 
 Sony has made no films. 
 But Columbia has a library of 2,700 old pictures. 
 Why doesn't someone buy up Japan before it owns everyone? 
 It shouldn't be too difficult. 
 Unfortunately, their trade barriers are such that nobody can get inside and buy anything. 
 But wasn't Mrs Thatcher telling the Japanese to break down their trade barriers the other day? 
 Yes. 
 They did the opposite, as usually happens when she tells people to do things. 
 What is it with Mrs Thatcher? 
 Well, basically her problem is that she is afraid of nobody. 
 She juts her chin out, stands tall, and could lick any man in the house. 
 Hello, this sounds familiar. 
 Does this mean that she has to invent enemies too? 
 Sure. 
 That gate across Downing Street&hellip; the dismissal of the IRA as monsters&hellip; the same attitude to the train drivers, the doctors, the miners, Sue Lawley&hellip; 
 Good heavens. 
 By the way, I notice an increasing tendency for her critics to psychoanalyse Mrs Thatcher. 
 Is that because she is paranoid? 
 No, it is because they are. 
 They are siblings who feel they have to disagree violently with mother to demonstrate their own independence. 
 Incidentally, I notice you have steered the talk right away from the Japanese, to whom in fact you were rather nice. 
 Any reason? 
 Yes. 
 I have just discovered that this column is 75 per cent owned by a Japanese company. 
 I feel I ought to be nice to them wherever possible. 
 Thank you. 
 Letter: The Archbishop's critical duty 
 From The Rt Rev D. R. FEAVER 
 Sir: If, after the return of the Archbishop of Canterbury from Rome, the Church of England, without the concurrence of the Orthodox churches and of the Church of Rome, alters the nature of the Sacred Ministry, which we claim to hold in common with them, it will behave as a sect and will become a sect. 
 The bishops will betray that which is entrusted to them; and the irresponsible silliness of the Synod will be seen to be sinful. 
 I could have no place nor part in it. 
 No talk about &bquo;caring for conscience&equo; nor &bquo;compensation&equo; would mask the treachery and betrayal. 
 Letter: The Archbishop's critical duty 
 From The Ven WILLIAM PALEY 
 Sir: You refer to the Prime Minister (4 October) as &bquo;not so much a Pharisee as a Philistine&equo;, owing presumably to her supposedly vulgar tastes. 
 The Philistines were a people organised into a federation of five city states, who ruled over parts of Palestine from about BC 1175. 
 They are known by archaeologists for their distinctive ceramic work. 
 There is little to suggest any aesthetic vulgarity or antipathy to culture on their part. 
 The contemporary defamation of their name manifestly derives from Jewish (and thereby Christian) hostility and prejudice. 
 To quote one of your letter writers: &bquo;It is high time to abandon that caricature, too long perpetuated by dictionary definitions&equo;. 
 Anti-Philistinism and anti-Arab sentiment may have a nasty way of feeding on each other. 
 Letter: The Archbishop's critical duty 
 From The Rev Canon PAUL OESTREICHER 
 Sir: The Archbishop of Canterbury would be the first to agree with you (2 October) that personal generosity is a Christian duty. 
 But it is no substitute for social justice. 
 These are not alternatives. 
 Both are necessary. 
 Practice has shown that social justice cannot be achieved where the free market is idolised. 
 Our Prime Minister believes neither in the desirability nor the possibility of creating a compassionate society. 
 So, compassion, like virtually everything else, is to be privatised. 
 An archbishop who failed to challenge that kind of economic fundamentalism would virtually have abandoned the social hope of the Christian Church. 
 Dr Runcie affirms the need to create wealth and makes no plea for its collective ownership. 
 At least by implication he is calling for a social market economy. 
 In this he is at one with most Christian Democrats and most Social Democrats in Europe today. 
 No wonder Mrs Thatcher is so afraid of European integration and firmly rejects a social charter that the rest of Western Europe readily accepts. 
 It is fanciful to assume that a tight-fisted state will produce open-handed citizens. 
 Even if it did, personal generosity simply cannot cure basic social injustices. 
 Strange, that a Prime Minister who so passionately believes in military security rejects social security with such disdain. 
 In challenging such assumptions the Archbishop is simply minding his own business. 
 Whether or not that helps to fill church pews is totally irrelevant. 
 Letter: The rail and road links to the North 
 From JACK THOMPSON, MP for Wansbeck (Labour) and others 
 Sir: Although we are not necessarily personally supportive of the Channel tunnel, we accept that it will be completed and become part of the transport network of Europe. 
 Present planning, however, on this side of the Channel will not provide our industrial and commerical community with a reasonable chance of exploiting new opportunites in Europe. 
 Unless action is taken, increasingly more congestion will result in the already over-crowded South-east. 
 Investment in road and rail links, particularly the rail link from Folkestone to the north of London &mdash; and we would argue beyond there &mdash; is vital. 
 Without that investment and infrastructure, twenty-first century companies in the North will find difficulty penetrating the European market with a nineteenth-century transport system. 
 The Government must speedily ensure that the necessary public and private resources are made available to guarantee the investment takes place. 
 Failure to do so would confirm the fear of those who say that the Government is so hell-bent on pursuing ideology that it ignores the pressing needs of our industrial community in the build-up to 1992. 
 Future generations in both the North and the South will not forgive our generation if they have to bear the future cost. 
 Letter: Recycled plastics 
 From Mr D. J. BUCKLER 
 Sir: Increasing the recycling of plastics ought to be near the top of Britain's environmental priorities, as your article &bquo;The search to escape a plastic nightmare&equo; (27 September) suggests. 
 But those of us in the recycling business must take issue with the statement from the British Plastics Federation that recycled plastics cannot safely be used to package food. 
 Recycled plastic can be used, quite hygienically, to package eggs, tomatoes, apples and all manner of skinned food and vegetables. 
 The recycling of polystyrene, for instance, requires temperatures above 200C and the materials are extensively filtered during the procedure. 
 This produces materials which are as clean as first-use plastics. 
 Companies which make first-use plastic might prefer recycled plastic to be used in opening up new markets, rather than competing with their products - for example, by substituting for timber. 
 But if we are to move towards the maximum recycling of plastics, and the maximum environmental benefit, then food packaging should not be ruled out. 
 Letter: Shortage of donor organs 
 From Ms CAROLINE TAHOURDIN 
 Sir: Sunday's television appeal for a donor liver highlights the acute shortage of replacement organs but not its true extent. 
 Only a life-or-death issue such as a liver or heart will hit the headlines. 
 I recently had a liver transplant at Addenbrooke's Hospital and still feel guilty that inevitably the decision was made to give me a liver rather than someone else whose life expectancy may have been marginally longer. 
 Had I needed a kidney, where the demand is much higher I am sure my guilt factor would be far higher. 
 I am also extremely grateful that someone was generous enough to donate their relative's organ at a time of extreme personal stress. 
 Now that transplant technology has improved so much, is it not time to change the system for organ donation? 
 Dr Williams is quoted (3 October) as favouring mandatory requests to the relatives of all suitable donors. 
 I feel an opting-out system would be probably less distressing to the donor's relatives (who may find an approach for donation insensitive when they have just been told of an &mdash; often &mdash; unexpected death). 
 Few people are unwilling to give their organs posthumously &mdash; those that are, usually make their views clearer. 
 Letter: Coleman's jaundiced eye at the UN 
 From Mr EDWARD BRADBY 
 Sir: A few hours after reading Terry Coleman's article on the United Nations General Assembly (30 September), I came across this passage in Trollope's Barchester Towers, which exactly expressed my feelings, and, I hope, those of many others of your readers: I know no life that must be so delicious as that of a writer for the newspapers&hellip; to thunder forth accusations against men in power; show up the worst side of everything that is produced; to pick holes in every coat; to be indignant, sarcastic, jocose, moral, or supercilious; to damn with faint praise, or crush with open calumny. 
 What can be so easy as this when the critic has to be responsible for nothing? 
 Letter: Coleman's jaundiced eye at the UN 
 From Mr MICHAEL STOPFORD 
 Sir: Terry Coleman's sanctimonious report on the latest United Nations General Assembly (30 September) gives a pretty distorted view of proceedings in New York. 
 Foreigners (of whom there are quite a few at the UN) can do nothing right for Mr Coleman. 
 He can find only delusion, tyranny or demagoguery among the various heads of state and assembled representatives. 
 Dismissive of the &bquo;corridor opportunites&equo;, he fails to mention that, so far, the Foreign Secretaries of the UK and Argentina have had their first meeting since the 1982 Falklands War, that the Israeli and Soviet Foreign Ministers have got together as has the US Secretary of State with his Israeli and Egyptian counterparts, or that the two German Foreign Ministers have held extensive talks on the current crisis &mdash; all with apparently good results: quite useful when several of these countries have no diplomatic relations with each other. 
 Concentrating on the foreigners' comic aspects, Mr Coleman passes over, in almost complete silence, the Assembly's preoccupation with the environment, drugs, Aids and human rights, questions at the top of the agenda for the UN. 
 For his universally lauded efforts, successful or continuing, to help resolve diplomatically such issues as Namibia, Afghanistan, Iran-Iraq, Western Sahara, Central America, Kampuchea, Cyprus and the Middle East, Secretary-General Perez de Cuellar is deemed a &bquo;classic bureaucrat&equo;, while the peace-keeping forces are recalled for their funny names rather than for their receipt of the Nobel Peace Prize last year. 
 I wish Mr Coleman a safe trip home and a less xenophobic piece next year. 
 Letter: Libel and charity 
 From Mr STEPHEN CAMPBELL 
 Sir: Am I alone in seeing the debate focused at the wrong end of the argument? 
 If libel awards (decided by juries) appear high relative to, say, personal injury awards (made by judges against published scales), surely the latter ought to be revised upwards, not the former downwards. 
 Letter: Libel and charity 
 From Mr M. D. VARCOE-COCKS 
 Sir: Dr Paul Robertshaw (3 October) suggests that the frequent practice of the rich (typical libel plaintiffs) to pass on their damages to charity acts &bquo;as an additional and self-legitimating, incentive to take awards through the ceiling&equo;. 
 If the purpose of damages is to compensate a victim rather than punish the perpetrator, then a successful plaintiff who passes his award to charity cannot be said to have been compensated in any way. 
 As a matter of law, it is arguable that a plaintiff who announces before his case that he will pass on any damages to charity is not entitled to anything except costs if he wins. 
 Of course, it is difficult to pre-empt a jury's or judge's decision on damages, but the fact that a very rich plaintiff might hand over his damages to charity should and could be taken into account in any assessment. 
 It is even difficult to say that a very rich person could be compensated in money terms; thus, however heinous the libel, such a person should get not more than a nominal sum and his costs. 
 Letter: Scientific notes 
 From Mr NORMAN E. BUTCHER 
 Sir: Dr Beverly Halstead (letter, 2 October) should note that Scotland's banks still value science. 
 The Clydesdale Bank &pound;20 note bears the head of the physicist Lord Kelvin, and on the reverse side one sees his nineteenth-century lecture theatre in the University of Glasgow. 
 Letter: On the ball 
 From Mr MARTIN THOMPSON 
 Sir: Just before John Paul II was elected there was speculation that Cardinal Hume could become the first non-Italian Pope for several centuries. 
 The Newcastle Evening Chronicle reported the story under the headline &bquo;United supporter to be next Pope&equo;. 
 Education: Pupil pioneers enter the land of uncertainty: Five weeks into the new national curriculum, both teachers and pupils find they need further enlightenment. 
 Elisabeth Dunn reports 
 By ELISABETH DUNN 
 DRAINED by the exercise of inferring what was holding together two pieces of stick inside a cardboard box, a first-year science pupil at Gillingham comprehensive school in north Dorset advanced the opinion that the national curriculum was &bquo;just another posh name for different subjects&equo;. 
 She had done science before; this was just more science. 
 No big deal. 
 After a month of putting government education ideology into practice, life in her classroom is pretty much what it always was. 
 Even as the first-year girl drew her inferences, her headmaster, Manuel Lenarduzzi, was preparing for last night's meeting with her parents and those of other first-year children who are the guinea pigs of the new system and whose future is one of attainment targets. 
 Much of Mr Lenarduzzi's material for the meeting, designed to clarify the national curriculum, relied on inference because, as yet, only maths and science is actually taught under the guidelines issued by the Department of Education and Science, and nobody knows how attainment testing will work. 
 Rumour and uncertainty abound, suggesting, this week, that pupils' achievements will be measured by formal test rather than by their teachers' assessment. 
 But who knows what the grapevine will bear next week? 
 For all the absence of Bakerthink in the classroom, it would be misleading to suggest that nobody had taken any notice of the Education Reform Act. 
 At Gillingham, in close consultation with the primary and middle schools which feed the comprehensive, the science department is working on the list of 17 attainment targets including (5) Human Influences on the Earth, (15) Using Light and Electro-Magnetic Radiation, and (17) The Nature of Science. 
 Children's grasp of these knotty subjects is monitored and tested through the four Key Stages (aged 5-7, 8-11, 12-14 and 15-16) of their educational career. 
 But here, Mr Lenarduzzi and his staff perceive a recurrent problem: &bquo;How do you know when a child can do something?&equo; he asks. 
 To a roomful of shoulders raised in perplexity, he warms to his theme: &bquo;Is it when he has done something once? 
 Does he have to do it twice or explain how he's done it? 
 These questions are fundamental. 
 You are making a statement about a child and it is going on the child's record.&equo; 
 For the past decade, the teachers at Gillingham have been working towards something which looks very much like the national curriculum, to ensure a smooth transfer to the new system. 
 They agree that a regular comparison of notes with primary schools (which they have always enjoyed, if at lower intensity than presently) improves all their pupils' chances of entering secondary school by the same starting gate. 
 They are heartened by finding common ground between English and science for, if nothing else, the introduction of the national curriculum has encouraged teachers from different disciplines to talk to each other: &bquo;At one time, we could conceive of ourselves as subject teachers,&equo; said Mr Lenarduzzi. 
 &bquo;Now we are curriculum teachers.&equo; 
 And yet their horizon is not without its clouds. 
 The spectre of standard attainment targets (SATs) looms. 
 The targets will be the means by which pupils' progress is measured. 
 Gillingham's head of curriculum, herself an English teacher, reports with approval that at present GCSE in English is judged 100 per cent on coursework. 
 The introductory document on national curriculum English hints at formal examinations at the end of key stages and this saddens her. 
 Mr Lenarduzzi endorses her view: &bquo;If our concentration is going to be on testing, then that would not be welcome. 
 Our concentration has got to be on the teaching and on the stretching of children. 
 Few firms, if any, spend most of their resources on testing their product instead of producing it.&equo; 
 He frets that, when it comes to the point, the requirements for SATs may not tally with the requirements for GCSE; that he may have to regroup the whole school to align pupils according to their ability rather than their age. 
 And what, he asks, will happen to the child who does not, bureaucratically speaking, have special educational needs but who never manages to get past Level 2 in any given attainment target? 
 Mr Lenarduzzi's sleep is also disturbed by the thought that the interests of the nation may only be served at the expense of local needs or, indeed, that purely academic considerations might distort the wider implications of a proper education. 
 &bquo;The needs of a rural, 11 to 18 school are very different from an inner-city upper school. 
 We must have sport, drama and music to enrich the children, but I also have an objective to make the children aware of city life and the wider world outside the community of small agricultural villages. 
 This year, we sent 79 children to Germany, 42 children to France on two-week exchanges, 70 children on a weekend trip to France, the fifth-years went on a trip to Paris. 
 They need to be aware of a world outside their very pleasant rural environment. 
 &bquo;It would be a great tragedy if I lost the freedom to pursue educational objectives such as these. 
 What could I tell the parents about the national curriculum? 
 I'm afraid that the answer to most of their questions is: &bquo;We do not yet know.&equo;'  
 (Photographs omitted) 
 Education: Zoo trips hold on to their place in the management plan 
 By ELISABETH DUNN 
 AT THE Landscore primary school in Crediton, Devon, there is palpable evidence of the enthusiasm with which the national curriculum has been embraced. 
 The school has a new science teacher with a PhD and &pound;1,700 worth of new mathematical and scientific equipment &mdash; mostly instruments for weather-watching. 
 There is also an abundance of paperwork. 
 Mrs Janet Postance, Landscore's head, carries about with her a cardboard box which might once have held apples, now replaced with documents relating to the national curriculum, the Devon Education Authority curriculum and her own school curriculum. 
 For the moment, she is concerned with plaiting the three strands. 
 Traditionally, her top class has spent a residential week at Paignton Zoo and she is determined that, given the restriction on charging for activities within school hours, the tradition will be maintained ad infinitum. 
 It is no chimpanzees' tea party. 
 Pupils are required to write a biography of Herbert Whitley, the zoo's founder, to give an account of the explorations of Christopher Columbus, Captain Cook and David Livingstone, to study a species of animal in depth and to produce an organised diary of their week. 
 Thus the expedition is neatly manipulated to include many of the requirements of the national curriculum: &bquo;We are very keen to make sure that we don't lose all the good things that have been going on in schools,&equo; she says. 
 She defines as one of the good things the non-specialist character of primary school teaching. 
 &bquo;We would never let it become specialised, although, as children grow older, we've got to move towards a middle school model, so there is specialised teaching in maths and humanities; they actually go to different teachers for four complete sessions a week.&equo; 
 Until now, much of the thrust of the national curriculum has gone into preparing teachers. 
 In harmony with the new British philosophy of dynamism and efficiency, senior teachers favour the language of commerce in discussing the implementation of the curriculum. 
 Mrs Postance's opposite number at the Haywards primary school at the other end of town, Mike Palmer, talks of &bquo;tooling up&equo; for the undertaking: &bquo;I've had to use a large slice of my in-service training budget to release staff during the school day for quite substantial periods to match up their plans for the following year. 
 &bquo;One of the things that has been most useful has been our non-pupil days. 
 They have given staff in schools the space to meet as a group and get to terms with issues over a longer period, complementing the series of other meetings and team meetings that go on anyway. 
 We have a management plan now - and we haven't called it that before. 
 We don't want it to make teachers more accountable. 
 Its primary function is to sharpen up the best of good practice.&equo; 
 It nevertheless has increased teacher's accountability. 
 Mrs Postance recorded 29 governors' meetings between November last year and May &mdash; a sequence of events that has left parents on the governing body reeling from an onslaught of Key Stages and Attainment Targets. 
 Mrs Postance believes that the heavy digging already completed to prepare the ground for the national curriculum has had a beneficial effect, at least on the teachers, even if the children have yet to reap the harvest: &bquo;It's focused our minds on what we are teaching. 
 We welcome it and we feel very positive about it. 
 But it has to be applied properly or it will not improve the quality of education. 
 And if it does not do that, we've all been wasting our time. 
 &bquo;If there is one worry about it, it is that the national curriculum and the attainment targets will only partly tell you about a child. 
 They will not tell you whether a child is going to be a good citizen, when he's nice to know or whether he's well motivated. 
 They will not tell you a lot about what's going to make him tick as an adult, except that he might be good at a particular academic subject.&equo; 
 Education: The head who split a village: Simon Midgley on the latest argument between progressives and traditionalists 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 A LEICESTERSHIRE village is riven by controversy in a dispute over &bquo;progressive&equo; versus traditional teaching methods in a local primary school. 
 Friendships have been sundered, mothers have heckled one other in the street and schoolfriends have been separated in the row which has involved the withdrawal of scores of children from the Lady Jane Grey School in Groby, a commuter village near Leicester. 
 The row culminated in the headteacher, Jim Nind, asking to be transferred to another post and four of the seven teachers, apparently exhausted by the events, going on sick leave for a week. 
 Rival groups of parents have formed, some welcoming the head's departure, others petitioning County Hall for his re-instatement. 
 The question is whether young children learn best by studying at their own pace through relatively informal &bquo;activity&equo; methods in small groups (which, to some parents, looks suspiciously like playing), or whether they should learn the three Rs sitting at their desks in a more competitive and disciplined environment. 
 Leicestershire is widely regarded as a pioneer of &bquo;progressive&equo; primary methods. 
 The saga began last year when the council opened a new open-plan primary school to relieve overcrowding in Groby's two existing primary schools. 
 Jim Nind, a teacher with progressive views on primary teaching, was appointed head and the school opened in August 1988 with 137 pupils. 
 Within weeks, some parents started taking their children away from the school. 
 Yesterday the roll stood at 107 pupils, though the school has room for 210. 
 The gist of the parents' complaints is that children were allowed too much freedom and that there was too little formal instruction in the three Rs. 
 Terry Mulloy, chairman of the governors, who has a five-year-old son at Lady Jane Grey, says that if children, while being taught reading in a small group, got bored they would be allowed to wander off and do something else. 
 After attending a local nursery school, some children had been able to write their own names. 
 After a short period under Mr Nind's regime, they had started writing their letters backwards. 
 Another parent, Susan Dungworth, transferred her two eldest boys, aged 10 and seven, to Martinshaw, another local primary. 
 She says that the pupils were &bquo;not pushed or encouraged to do more than the basic minimum&equo;. 
 In their new school, their mother says, the Dungworth boys are &bquo;very happy&equo; taking spelling tests once a week and sitting down at desks. 
 Yvonne Clark also moved her six-year-old son Ryan to Martinshaw this August after a year at Lady Jane Grey. 
 She says that there was no regular programme of formal lessons where entire classes studied maths or science together. 
 Instead, children were asked to complete so many compulsory pieces of work in a week. 
 They could choose when to study what and play the rest of the time if they chose. 
 Competition was frowned upon, she said. 
 At football matches, parents were asked not to cheer. 
 Praise was never given to an individual child but only when the entire class did well. 
 &bquo;My son is quite a bright little boy,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;He could read and write before he went to school. 
 Surely if he has got it you ought to encourage it&hellip; 
 When it comes down to it you look after number one. 
 We decided to do what was best for Ryan.&equo; 
 Other parents are just as vehement in their support for Lady Jane Grey. 
 Tina Dicks, whose son Thomas, aged six, attends the school, said: &bquo;My little boy is extremely happy there and is coming on by leaps and bounds. 
 Personally I cannot see what all the fuss has been about.&equo; 
 By enjoying learning, she said, pupils understood and remembered things much better. 
 Desma Hagan, who has a 10-year-old son with special educational needs and a six-year-old daughter at Lady Jane Grey, said: &bquo;It is a really very good school. 
 The teamwork done there with the headmaster and teachers could not be better. 
 People tend to think, because they are not doing sums on paper they are not learning maths &mdash; but they are.&equo; 
 They learn maths through playing with dominoes or measuring the size of rooms, she says. 
 And they are taught in a caring way, about people and the environment. 
 Her son had made 10 months' progress in a year, against his usual six months before he started at Lady Jane Grey. 
 Mr Mulloy says that Lady Jane Grey is now paying more attention to the three Rs than it did previously. 
 But Pat Butler, a school governor and a Conservative county councillor, is less sanguine. 
 She said more parents were rumoured to be planning to transfer their children. 
 Were that to happen, she says, &bquo;they,&equo; (presumably the local education authority) would have to &bquo;do something&equo;. 
 Mr Nind this week declined to make any comment. 
 Education Viewpoint: Who will stand up against the idea of student fees? 
 By NGAIO CREQUER 
 I AM a romantic. 
 I am very fond of poetry by John Donne. 
 I believe that one day Manchester United will again win the league title. 
 I also became a university student in the days when it was axiomatic that higher education was &bquo;free&equo;. 
 Without a student grant I would never have got there. 
 It does not matter what happens to the public reputation of John Donne. 
 He is still there for me. 
 United, even if they have sold Strachan and Whiteside, still have Hughes, who scores goals Roy of the Rovers only dreamed about. 
 I suppose it will be said that it is the height of romanticism to cling to the idea that universities can remain largely publicly funded and that students will not inevitably have to pay fees. 
 But there I disagree. 
 I find it astonishing that, in less than a year since proposals on these lines by Robert Jackson, the higher education minister, were leaked, the majority of university vice-chancellors should have moved to a position whereby they are actively pursuing the option of charging students the full cost of their courses. 
 They say this is only one of several options. 
 But the only others they put forward at their recent press conference were a graduate tax, rejected by the Government under its student loans proposals, or a decline in the quality of higher education. 
 Once vice-chancellors start to think the unthinkable, then the issue becomes part of the agenda and it becomes harder to retreat. 
 Fees are now legitimate. 
 Instead of lobbying harder for increased funds for higher education, vice-chancellors have accepted the Government's arguments on their own terms and betrayed their consituency - their students. 
 Because, even if there were a scholarship scheme, it would not be enough. 
 Some of the poorest students might be assisted, but, as with legal aid, those just above the threshold would lose out. 
 And it is the students from families with no tradition of higher education &mdash; the new students everyone claims they want to recruit &mdash; who will be those most put off. 
 The prospect of students saddling themselves with enormous debts to pay their course fees and their maintenance is a frightening one. 
 Does anyone believe that, over time, the scholarships would keep in line with the fees? 
 We would end up with fewer students. 
 The country has to decide whether higher education is not only a private good but a public good. 
 It is the country which needs more graduates, it is industry which says demand outstrips supply. 
 The vice-chancellors asked for papers to inform their debate on fees at Leeds. 
 Only two vice-chancellors responded, and they both support some form of fees. 
 Was there really no vice-chancellor prepared to put another view? 
 The Government faces a difficult time as it prepares to get its legislation on student loans through Parliament. 
 Now is the time for vice-chancellors to go in hard and exact promises of increased funding. 
 Both sides want &bquo;dialogue&equo;. 
 John MacGregor, the Secretary of State for Education, has shown with the teachers that he actually listens to what they say. 
 This is a remarkable change in Government practice. 
 There is a great opportunity to be seized. 
 Access cards for access to higher education will not work. 
 The price that motorists must pay 
 By TERENCE BENDIXSON 
 Urban motorways have proved no solution to Britain's chronic traffic congestion &mdash; indeed some say they have made it worse. 
 Politicians are now making favourable noises about other countries' experiments with road pricing. 
 Terence Bendixson reports on an idea whose time may have come. 
 THE spectre of road pricing &mdash; charging for the roads on the basis of pay-as-you-drive &mdash; is again lurking in the political shadows. 
 &bquo;Moving Britain into the 1990s&equo;, the Labour Party's transport policy document, promises &bquo;a range of measures to restrict car use in the most congested areas, including road pricing&equo;. 
 The Government is, more discreetly, looking the same way. 
 Earlier this year, Paul Channon, then Secretary of State for Transport, agreed to a wide-ranging study of London's traffic problems. 
 Road pricing is part of it. 
 &bquo;If it cannot be avoided, it will have to happen,&equo; he told the Chartered Institute of Transport on 4 May. 
 &bquo;The Government has shown in the past that it is willing to grasp nettles that others have shied away from, and I have no doubt we shall grasp this one if we have to.&equo; 
 Cecil Parkinson, his successor, has yet to reveal his thinking on this awkward subject. 
 Of all transport policies, road pricing seems most likely to cause apoplexy everywhere, from the Royal Automobile Club to the bar at the Rover's Return. 
 It would be a new tax, involve paying for something that is at present free and would hit hardest at low-income car-owners. 
 It also conjures up fears of a huge Swansea-style computer keeping a Big Brotherish eye on every car. 
 What on earth can have induced Labour and Conservative politicians alike even to consider hitching their wagons to something which, at first sight, makes the poll tax look like a pre-election bonus? 
 The idea of road pricing first surfaced in the early Sixties. 
 Britain under Harold Macmillan was booming and new Austins and Morrises were flooding on to the country's antiquated roads. 
 New car registrations &mdash; only half a million in 1958 &mdash; jumped in 1963 to more than a million (Today, they are running at two million.) 
 Traffic in the bigger cities was chaotic. 
 Ernest Marples, Macmillan's Transport Minister, appointed two working parties to find solutions. 
 One led to Sir Colin Buchanan's &bquo;Traffic in Towns&equo; report &mdash; which, for the first time, counted the environmental cost of providing lebensraum for cars. 
 The second, much less well-known, was chaired by Dr Reuben Smeed, the outstanding transport statistician of his generation. 
 Smeed's report, &bquo;Road Pricing: The Economic and Technical Possibilities&equo;, is a classic of Anglo-Saxon economic pragmatism. 
 In it, a group of star economists, including Sir Alan Walters, Mrs Thatcher's personal adviser, showed how, in any stream of traffic, every additional vehicle slows down those already there &mdash; and that the slower the speed of the traffic stream being joined, the greater the hindrance caused by every joining vehicle. 
 Smeed went on to argue that if drivers were charged for the delays they impose on one another, some of them would travel at different times, by different means or to different places &mdash; and that time wasted by everyone in jams would be reduced. 
 Smeed's logic was overwhelming. 
 The Department of Transport awarded contracts to firms to develop electronics that would identify cars passing over buried toll &bquo;gates&equo;. 
 The data would be sent to a computer and, as with telephone calls, logged, costed and sent out in the form of a periodic bill. 
 Fear of the political consequences frustrated a public trial of the technology in Britain, but a low-tech variation was successfully pioneered in Singapore in 1975. 
 Singapore was then a fast-growing city-state of more than two million inhabitants. 
 A financial district was mushrooming, a proposed underground was years away from service and every rush hour saw a rising tide of cars jamming the roads. 
 The Prime Minister Lee Kuan Yew's dictatorial government moved with characteristic speed and confidence. 
 A central pay zone was marked out with huge signs and, during the morning peak, drivers were obliged to pay US&dollar;26 (&pound;16) per month and US&dollar;1.30 per day to drive into it. 
 Company cars were charged a double rate and &mdash; a master stroke &mdash; cars with four or more occupants were allowed in free. 
 At every point where a road entered the &bquo;restricted zone&equo;, Singapore's equivalent of Securicor officers stood, radios in hand. 
 Cars without stickers (or four-plus occupants) were reported and quickly fined. 
 The World Bank, which was keen for other cities to follow Singapore's example, reported a 44 per cent fall in traffic entering central Singapore between 7.30am and 10.15am. 
 Through traffic was driven out. 
 Many commuters took to car pooling. 
 Others drove to work before 7.30am or scheduled business calls first thing so that they could drive in later. 
 Bus travel increased hugely. 
 Road pricing is now firmly established in Singapore and the windscreen stickers are about to be superseded by electronics. 
 The pay zone will, for the time being, remain the same. 
 During the Seventies, several London-based studies of supplementary licences and electronic road pricing were made, all involving a pay zone covering the City and West End, but what officials proposed, politicians never disposed. 
 In 1975 a Labour Greater London Council backed down and in 1979, although the Evening Standard said &bquo;Londoners ready for the 50p toll&equo;, Sir Horace Cutler, leader of the by then Conservative GLC, dismissed such charges as &bquo;unfair and impracticable&equo;. 
 Movement for London, a road-users' pressure group, called them &bquo;totally ridiculous&equo;. 
 Confidence in road building has taken knocks too. 
 The state of the M25 has led to suggestions that bigger and better roads may lead only to worse jams. 
 And Dr Martin Mogridge, of London University's transport studies group, has persuasively argued that, in London, speedier trains and tubes will make road traffic go faster while new roads will do the opposite. 
 Another important development was the death, as far as road pricing is concerned, of Big Brother. 
 In 1985 the Hong Kong government, faced with 350,000 vehicles and only 1,227km of roads (an unequalled density) decided on an experiment with electronic toll collection. 
 Black boxes the size of video-cassettes were welded on to 3,000 cars and hundreds of loops were buried in the roads. 
 The boxes sent signals to the loops and thus to a central computer which clocked them up as tolls. 
 The tolls, which varied with the level of congestion and the time of day, were displayed on road-side signs. 
 The aim of the traffic engineers was to cut car journeys by up to 10 per cent, creating congestion-free running for buses, goods vehicles and the remaining cars. 
 The experiment gave every indication that this would be possible and was a great technical success &mdash; but when the elected representatives were asked to agree a city-wide scheme, they voted against it. 
 They feared among other things, that the records logged by the central computer would be a threat to the privacy and freedom of drivers. 
 The transformation of road pricing technology followed swiftly. 
 The latest proposals involve the use of pre-payment cards comparable to British Telecom's green phonecards. 
 Drivers would insert one of these &bquo;smart cards&equo; into tiny black boxes fixed to their windscreens. 
 Out on the roads, these boxes would be interrogated by toll collecting beacons. 
 Provided there was a valid card in the box, the beacon would deduct some of its value and record no details. 
 Only if there was no card or a dud card would the car be photographed as evidence for prosecution. 
 No less important is the work of the European Commission. 
 The EC rightly saw that with France and Italy moving towards electronic toll collection to save labour, and the Netherlands moving towards road pricing to deal with congestion, drivers travelling around Europe could be faced with having to plaster numerous different black boxes all over their windscreens. 
 &bquo;Drivers want to be able to put the same smart card in a holder (or a different card in the same holder) whether driving in the Netherlands or on a French autoroute,&equo; says Ian Catling, a member of an EC group which is ensuring that electronic Babel is avoided on the roads. 
 The work of the EC group illustrates the global significance of the electronic toll. 
 In its various forms it could be used to finance private roads, regulate traffic on the M25 and bring order to inner-city roads. 
 It could also become commonplace throughout Europe. 
 Electronic tolls could replace fuel and vehicle taxes as the main form of highway revenue. 
 Notwithstanding this promise, the use of road pricing to change travel habits still seems some way off. 
 The Dutch are widely expected to be the first to try it. 
 Not only is traffic on their motorways obstructing lorries going in and out of the vast Europoort, but public opposition to air pollution and the taking of scarce land for new roads is intense. 
 Economic and environmental arguments are thus in harmony. 
 Will Cecil Parkinson, the new Secretary of State for Transport, follow suit in London? 
 It is a daunting challenge. 
 More than a million and half vehicles enter or leave central London every working day. 
 Yet this area, which stretches from Hyde Park to Liverpool Street station and from the Angel, Islington, to the Thames, is the minimum practical initial pay zone. 
 Enforcement would be one problem. 
 Road pricing would soon fail if paying the charges could be as painlessly disregarded as parking fines. 
 No one should underestimate these problems, but nor should the waste and unfairness of existing conditions be overlooked. 
 Hidden in the cost of everything that goes by road in London is a tax imposed by congestion. 
 A recession would cut back London's traffic but so long as the economy keeps growing, the result will be more cars, more traffic and more pollution. 
 Mr Parkinson can turn his back on all this but if he decides to confront it, road pricing is one of the few tools at his disposal. 
 And if he can count on Labour support, it could be a brilliant move. 
 Dr Phil Goodwin, Oxford University's director of transport studies, believes that pricing could gain wide support provided that a &bquo;rule of three&equo; is followed in allocating its benefits. 
 Under Goodwin's rule, the road space freed by reducing traffic would be distributed: one-third to wider pavements and better pedestrian crossings; one-third to bus lanes; and one-third to increasing the speed of other traffic. 
 The revenue from road pricing would be allocated one-third to reducing general taxes, one-third to improving the roads and one-third to improving public transport. 
 Pay-as-you-drive charges would also bring cleaner city air and reduced rat-running. 
 If the new Transport Secretary can negotiate this kind of deal with the Treasury, he could give the phrase Parkinson's Law an entirely new meaning. 
 Note this man's words carefully at the Conservative Party conference. 
 The author's report, &bquo;Transport In The Nineties: The Shaping Of Europe&equo; is published on Monday by the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors. 
 Driving the hard bargain: Pay-as-you-drive would solve little and penalise motorists cruelly, Kenneth Faircloth argues 
 By KENNETH FAIRCLOTH 
 IN 1905, when the Automobile Association was founded, ownership and use of a car was the privilege only of the rich. 
 Today, most people regard cars as essential to family life. 
 There are now 18.5 million cars on Britain's roads, and by the year 2000 there will be 25 to 28 million. 
 We need to discover how to live with them. 
 The cost of running the car is already, in many families, the biggest item of household expenditure, after food and housing. 
 Road pricing &mdash; charging for road space as it is used &mdash; will merely add to the burden. 
 People choose to spend a high proportion of their disposable income on buying and running a car because car ownership enhances their lives. 
 The family that owns and uses a car, for work and play, is usually better off&hellip; simply because it owns and uses a car. 
 One of the most important uses of the car is the journey to work. 
 AA research shows that 64 per cent of motorists use their cars for this purpose -among them, semi-skilled and unskilled workers for whom the car is an absolute necessity. 
 Road pricing is inflationary: through demands for higher pay from car-users, and businesses passing on costs in prices. 
 Transport academics argue that road pricing would make drivers pay for the cost of congestion. 
 But drivers already pay &mdash; substantially &mdash; for the privilege of using their cars. 
 In 1988-89, the Exchequer received some &pound;17bn from motoring taxation. 
 Yet during the same period only &pound;3.8bn was spent on providing, improving and maintaining Britain's road network. 
 For every &pound;4 collected in motoring taxes, less than &pound;1 is spent on roads. 
 Britain collects far more and spends far less than any other EC country. 
 Of course something must be done to reduce road congestion: revenue taken from road-users urgently needs to be invested in roads. 
 Investment and commitment are also needed to rebuild a viable public transport system. 
 Where public transport is available, and where it is clean, efficient, safe and reasonably priced, commuters will use it. 
 Many commuting drivers, given the opportunity to combine use of the car with use of the bus or train, would happily park out of town in well-sited, inexpensive car parks. 
 London's traffic difficulties will never be &bquo;solved&equo; in the sense that every road will miraculously become congestion-free, and public transport suddenly meet the needs of every traveller. 
 But there are short- and medium-term measures that can contain and ease the problems. 
 All roadworks in peak-traffic hours should be prohibited. 
 Currently highways authorities and main services providers are allowed to cause chaos by digging up roads whenever and wherever they wish. 
 Much of the capital's road space is used for only part of the day. 
 More could be done to encourage flexible or staggered working hours and spread the traffic load. 
 Developers should pay for the cost of the additional traffic that they generate. 
 In urban areas especially, major developments place sudden and immense extra demands on the transport infrastructure &mdash; but no one considers this at the planning stages. 
 It would be a pity if talk of road pricing were to divert attention from commonsense action needed now, or if it were seen as a substitute for a properly funded roads programme. 
 The AA asks for more of the money taken in taxation from drivers to be put to work, and for road pricing proposals to be acknowledged as unnecessary, inflationary and, ultimately, inequitable. 
 A problem for the taxman: An extra levy on fuel would be a quick and cheap solution, Dr Mayer Hillman says 
 By DR MAYER HILLMAN 
 THE commonly-cited reason for opposing a charge for driving on particular urban roads is that it is a further restriction on those who have sufficient constraints already, what with parking meters, wheel-clamping and towing-away. 
 In any case, it is argued, motorists already pay a fair &bquo;whack&equo; in taxation for use of the roads. 
 Alternatively, it is claimed, such a system would be inequitable since poorer motorists would be driven off the roads. 
 However, road pricing is rapidly claiming widespread support &mdash; from organisations as different in their political perspectives as the Institute of Directors and the new Institute for Public Policy Research. 
 They claim this is the most effective way to eliminate road congestion in city centres. 
 It can be simply introduced, either by supplementary licensing, with a daily charge to drive in certain areas or by applying more sophisticated under-street and on-vehicle technology that would allow &bquo;fine-tuning&equo; of the charge according to the need to reduce traffic in particular areas prone to jams or at particularly congested times of day. 
 Such an approach would be widely welcomed. 
 It would demonstrate the Government's willingness to get tough with an influential sector of the community for an increasingly obvious worthy cause. 
 Drivers themselves cannot take the initiative since they can do nothing to relieve towns and cities of the extraordinarily wasteful and environmentally distasteful conditions which both they and the general public have to tolerate every day. 
 Indeed, there is no incentive for drivers to take any account of the environmental and social impact of their transport decisions on other people. 
 The question is whether road pricing is the best response to the problem, since it focuses on just one aspect &mdash; inadequate road space in central areas -as if road congestion and delay were the primary issues to resolve. 
 But the inordinately high volumes of traffic, forecast to rise substantially, bring in their wake a much wider range of adverse consequences. 
 First and foremost are road accidents and the impact of the risk of accidents &mdash; the two are not synonymous &mdash; on the behaviour of other road users such as the elderly and children. 
 In spite of higher volumes of traffic in urban as compared with other areas, the fatality and serious injury rate is lower. 
 Then there are toxic, corrosive and carcinogenic exhaust fumes and the spreading intrusiveness of traffic noise, which again are by no means limited to city centres. 
 Unless road pricing is applied to all roads, irrespective of their current state of congestion, it is likely to lead to further decentralisation as the motoring public and commerce move out to avoid extra transport costs. 
 Why not instead institute an additional environmental/carbon tax on motor fuels? 
 This would lead to a decline in the volume of less essential traffic in urban and rural areas and bring an overall reduction in all its adverse effects, including its contribution, through carbon dioxide, to global warming &mdash; certain to be very high on the political agenda in the next few years. 
 Such a tax could be introduced almost overnight. 
 It could be raised if found to be effective in achieving public interest objectives. 
 Moreover, it would not require the high administrative and technical costs of road pricing. 
 History shows that the long-term effect of altering the price of motorised travel does not necessarily affect the amount of money people and organisations spend on transport. 
 The likely effect of the additional tax would be to reverse the general direction of our increasingly motor-dependent patterns of activity, with all its attendant problems. 
 Meanwhile, still taking the strain&hellip;: 
 Gerald Kaufman negotiates an obstacle course of cancellations, malfunctions, meaningless messages and mountains of litter 
 By GERALD KAUFMAN 
 9am. 
 InterCity train from Manchester Piccadilly to London Euston. 
 A comfortable trip, apart from the almost incessant announcements over the public address system which interrupt work, leisure reading and, worst of all, an attempt at a nap. 
 The call that particularly mystifies me, when I am subjected to it on journey after journey, is the admonition from catering staff to intending consumers of their junk food to be sure to bring their small change with them. 
 Is it feared that, without this request, passengers would take small change out of pocket or handbag and deliberately leave it on their seat before they proceed to the buffet car? 11.33am. 
 Train arrives at Euston seven minutes late &mdash; not bad compared with recent performances, but still late. 
 On the suddenly silent intercom, no explanation offered, still less an apology. 
 Euston underground station. 
 Of 11 ticket machines, two are not working and only two provide change. 
 The southbound Northern Line train is litter-ridden. 
 Charing Cross underground station. 
 On my way to the District and Circle platform I pass a notice stating that an escalator is out of service. 
 The station is litter-ridden. 
 There is litter on the seats of the train I take to Westminster. 
 Mid-afternoon. 
 On my way to my London flat, as I walk through a passageway leading from the Strand to Charing Cross underground station, I pass two young men sitting on a sheet on the floor and begging. 
 Both down-escalators to the Jubilee Line are out of service. 
 I walk down one of these stationary escalators. 
 It is littered with rubbish. 
 On the next level, once again both down-escalators are out of service and once again the stationary escalator is littered with rubbish. 
 St John's Wood station. 
 As I ride the up-escalator, I see that the down-escalator is out of service. 
 A cheery hand-written notice recommends that passengers use the &bquo;Keep Fit Stairs&equo;. 
 St John's Wood station was closed for two months from February to April for repair of the escalators. 
 Since then, they have been out of order frequently &mdash; seven days in August alone. 
 Late afternoon. 
 On my way to an engagement in Bracknell. 
 St John's Wood station again. 
 The down-escalator is still out of order. 
 I walk down the steep flight of stairs. 
 A middle-aged disabled woman attempts to do the same, edging gingerly down the exactly 100 Keep Fit steps, one by painful one. 
 Baker Street station. 
 Change from Jubilee to Bakerloo Line. 
 No litter on floor or seats of train, but a youth sprawls with both his feet on the facing seat: a sort of human litter. 
 Waterloo underground station. 
 Of two up-escalators, one is out of service. 
 Hundreds of passengers are converging on the one in operation. 
 If there was a fire or other emergency, there could be panic and havoc. 
 I walk up a flight of steps, carpeted with discarded copies of a give-away magazine called Ms London, into Waterloo railway station. 
 I have some time to spare and would like to sit down and read my copy of the biography of Berlioz. 
 However, unless I want junk food from one of the many establishments purveying it in this thoroughly commercialised station, all I have available to sit on in the huge concourse is a grubby metal flip-up slat a few inches wide. 
 There are also red-painted railings, on which I assume I am invited to lean. 
 Hundreds of people are standing around, gazing up at the indicator and waiting for the platform of their train to be flashed up. 
 Many seem anxious, not surprisingly since a large notice announces, &bquo;Due to a shortage of train crews, the following services will not run.&equo; 
 Four services are listed, mine fortunately not among them. 
 I go into the information office and ask about times of return trains from Bracknell. 
 There is a queue. 
 When I reach its head the man in charge goes away to conduct a transaction involving cardboard boxes. 
 On returning, he very politely gives me a timetable. 
 I decide to take the 9.49pm back to London. 
 My train to Bracknell is announced. 
 I get into a No Smoking carriage and, since the station interior is rather dark, switch on a light so that I can read Berlioz. 
 No light comes on. 
 There is no bulb in the socket. 
 At least I have a seat. 
 People are standing in the corridor. 
 The carriage, however, seems very hot. 
 All my fellow passengers feel it. 
 We realise why. 
 The heating is full on, on this warm day, noon-time temperature 21C. 
 I look at the temperature controller. 
 It is turned to Cool. 
 We passengers discuss among ourselves what to do and, as their designated representative, I try turning the controller first to Hot and then midway between Cool and Hot. 
 No change. 
 A man walking through the carriage on his way to the corridor advises, &bquo;Blame the Government.&equo; 
 I wish I could join him in the corridor, but now it is so crammed that there is no room. 
 At Richmond a lot of people get off the train and I take refuge in a Smoking compartment where the heat is not on. 
 The train arrives at Bracknell seven minutes late on its 51-minute journey time. 
 Return to Bracknell station following my engagement, to catch the 9.49pm train back to Waterloo. 
 While I am waiting on the platform, a railway employee shouts across the track that the 9.49 is cancelled, and that the next train will be at 10.19. 
 I call across asking why the 9.49 is cancelled. 
 He calls back, &bquo;I've no idea.&equo; 
 The platform is chilly, and there is no waiting room. 
 The only waiting area is the equally chilly station foyer. 
 I go to a pub across the road to await the 10.19. 
 The train arrives on time. 
 I get into a carriage and take Berlioz out of my briefcase. 
 I turn on the light above my seat. 
 No light. 
 No bulb. 
 I turn on the other light on my side of the carriage. 
 No light. 
 No bulb. 
 Both lights on the other side of the carriage work, so I change seats. 
 It is now cold. 
 I turn the temperature controller to Hot. 
 Nothing happens. 
 A ticket-collector comes along. 
 I ask why the 9.49 was cancelled. 
 He says he did not know it had been. 
 &bquo;Management doesn't tell us.&equo; 
 Waterloo station. 
 The train arrives three minutes early. 
 One of the escalators down to my underground platform is out of service, but two others are working. 
 I change at Baker Street. 
 Litter on the train. 
 11.45pm. 
 I arrive at St John's Wood station. 
 The down-escalator is still out of service. 
 A London Underground employee descends the Keep Fit Stairs, wearily sweeping rubbish before him. 
 The author is Labour's foreign affairs spokesman. 
 Propaganda victory for Cambodian guerrillas 
 From TERRY MCCARTHY in Bangkok 
 CAMBODIAN guerrillas have captured a number of Phnom Penh government outposts in the north-west in the last week, but they have yet to mount an attack on a major town, according to a resistance spokesman and Western intelligence sources in Bangkok. 
 The offensive has slowed, and there are doubts whether the guerrillas can hold on to their recent gains for long. 
 But the resistance has already scored an important propaganda victory against government forces, only a week after Vietnam said it had withdrawn all its troops from Cambodia. 
 Last weekend about 1,000 troops of the non-communist Khmer People's National Liberation Front (KPNLF) attacked military outposts along Route 69, which runs parallel to the Thai border about 20 miles inside Cambodia. 
 They overran a number of small outposts but, according to the spokesman, heavy artillery fire from government troops prevented an advance on the provincial capital of Sisophon. 
 The town, with 36,000 inhabitants, would be an important strategic loss. 
 The acting commander-in-chief of the KPNLF, General Dien Del, said yesterday his men had taken control of 24 government posts, although this cannot be verified. 
 Casualty figures are low, indicating that neither side is prepared to engage in heavy fighting. 
 Government troops seem to have abandoned some positions quickly, while the KPNLF has avoided key garrisons. 
 The KPNLF, which has about 7,000 men, had until recently been dismissed by military analysts as a badly organised force more interested in black-market activities across the Thai-Cambodia border than military operations. 
 Diplomats in Bangkok say the movement is attempting to boost its credibility at a time when the US Congress is debating policy on Cambodia. 
 The United States provides the KPNLF and the other non-communist resistance group of Prince Sihanouk with non-lethal aid and is considering a programme of covert lethal aid. 
 PHNOM PENH &mdash; The Cambodian Defence Minister, Tea Banh, said yesterday that government troops repulsed an offensive by mostly non-communist resistance forces last week near Sisophon, AFP reports. 
 He denied charges that Vietnamese troops participated in the fighting. 
 Zimbabwe university shut down after clash 
 From TERRY MCCARTHY in Bangkok 
 HARARE (Reuter) &mdash; The Zimbabwean government ordered the indefinite closure of the country's only university yesterday after a day of violent clashes between police and students protesting against the arrest of two of their leaders. 
 The Vice-Chancellor, Walter Kamba, announced the immediate closure after meeting President Robert Mugabe and his ministers. 
 He said that all 10,000 students would have to leave the campus with their belongings by last night. 
 Helmeted riot police fired tear gas and chased students across the campus of the University of Zimbabwe after they boycotted classes and wrecked Mr Kamba's car when he refused to meet them. 
 Students said police entered the campus around 3am and arrested the left-wing president of their representative council, Arthur Mutambara, and the general secretary, Enoch Chikweche. 
 There were no reported injuries in the clashes. 
 Mr Mutambara tried to escape by jumping from a second-floor window, but he was caught and taken to hospital with unspecified injuries. 
 Police indicated that they would charge him under Zimbabwe's Law and Order Maintenance Act for a statement he issued on Monday accusing the government of &bquo;state terrorism&equo; against students. 
 The statement accused President Mugabe's Zimbabwe African National Union government of using riot police last week to suppress a student seminar to mark the first anniversary of an anti-corruption demonstration. 
 A total of 478 students were arrested at the time and held for several days. 
 The statement accused the government of &bquo;brute neo-fascism comparable only to that of South Africa&equo;. 
 It added: &bquo;This university is the last island of democracy in this country,&equo; and said that during Ian Smith's time as Prime Minister, students had the right to hold meetings on the campus without prior official approval. 
 This was no longer the case. 
 President Mugabe aroused the students' anger last weekend with a speech accusing them of drinking and smoking too much and misbehaving rather than studying. 
 Thatcher maintains firm anti-sanctions stance 
 By JOHN BULLOCH, Diplomatic Editor 
 MARGARET THATCHER said yesterday she intends to maintain Britain's opposition to sanctions against South Africa at the Commonwealth Heads of Government Conference later this month. 
 Answering questions from black South African journalists, Mrs Thatcher said the British attitude on sanctions would not provoke any break with countries such as Zimbabwe or Zambia. 
 &bquo;We played the leading role in bringing Zimbabwe to independence and have given a great deal of help to Zimbabwe since independence,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;The neighbouring countries would be the first to suffer from more general sanctions against South Africa, and for very understandable reasons have not imposed them themselves.&equo; 
 Mrs Thatcher said economic sanctions did have the effect of depressing an economy and depriving people of jobs, but rarely if ever had the desired political effect. 
 &bquo;I do not believe that making people poorer will stimulate change,&equo; she said. 
 Britain had played a positive role by supporting the Namibia settlement and by talking to South Africa rather than trying to ostracise it, she added. 
 &bquo;We believe we have some results to show for our efforts and if anybody in South Africa, white or black, believes that opposition to sanctions represents support for the status quo, they are deluding themselves.&equo; 
 Setting out the philosophy which guides her policy, Mrs Thatcher said: &bquo;I oppose absolutely political violence and terrorism from whatever quarter. 
 Nor do I believe in deliberately making people poor: that is why I oppose sanctions. 
 Nor do I believe in obstructing democracy: that is why I oppose repression and the state of emergency. 
 You cannot influence people without talking to them, and that is why I saw President (FW) de Klerk and Mr (Barend) du Plessis. 
 I impressed on them the need to bring independence to Namibia and progress in South Africa. 
 I frequently see Helen Suzman and Dr (Frederik van Zyl) Slabbert, whose efforts I admire. 
 I want to meet Nelson Mandela when he is free. 
 I want to help South Africa become democratic and prosperous and avoid descending into further violence and poverty.&equo; 
 Aquino warns of &bquo;malignant power&equo; of Marcos corpse 
 By JOHN BULLOCH, Diplomatic Editor 
 MANILA (Reuter) &mdash; President Corazon Aquino of the Philippines said yesterday that the body of Ferdinand Marcos still had a &bquo;malignant power&equo; that could be used by her opponents to seize power. 
 Justifying her decision to bar the return of the former president's body for burial, Mrs Aquino told judges and legal workers that there was &bquo;a clear and present danger of the ambition of some to destabilise the government&hellip;&equo; 
 Mrs Aquino's spokesman, Adolfo Azcuna, said the cabinet unanimously endorsed her decision to bar the body of Mr Marcos, who died in exile in Hawaii last Thursday. 
 Marcos supporters have asked the Supreme Court to reverse the ban, but Mrs Aquino, who ousted Mr Marcos in a &bquo;people's power&equo; revolt in 1986, said: &bquo;The return of this man and his minions poses a greater threat to the democratic constitution he ironically invokes than denying him entry would tend to subvert the fundamental law.&equo; 
 The Defence Secretary, Fidel Ramos, briefed the cabinet and senators yesterday on an alleged plot to assassinate Mrs Aquino, which came to light in February. 
 She has survived five coup attempts, two of them linked to Marcos loyalists. 
 Hong Kong angers Peking by letting swimmer go West 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 PEKING yesterday bristled at a decision by Hong Kong to allow a top Chinese swimmer, Yang Yang, who sought political asylum in the West, to travel to the United States. 
 It said the move was &bquo;certain to cast a shadow on other aspects of co-operation between Hong Kong and China&equo;. 
 Yang Yang, 20, a self-confessed member of China's pro-democracy movement, had been detained in Hong Kong for 10 days after being arrested for overstaying his visa. 
 His request for political asylum in Hong Kong was not granted. 
 The case became a hot potato for the government when Mr Yang was offered political asylum by Taiwan, China's old foe. 
 Peking said it would not persecute Mr Yang if he was returned to the mainland, a clear sign it would strongly disapprove of Hong Kong not returning him. 
 On Tuesday evening the US consulate issued a visa for Mr Yang to travel to San Francisco. 
 Hong Kong's decision to free him is understood to have been made after talks involving the governor, Sir David Wilson, and the territory's political adviser, William Ehrman. 
 Pressure on the authorities not to send Mr Yang back to China grew on Tuesday when Amnesty International requested all its members telex John Major, the Foreign Secretary, urging him not to allow Mr Yang to be returned &bquo;under any circumstances&equo;. 
 The US appears willing to take Mr Yang, but he may choose to live in Taiwan. 
 Xinhua News Agency, China's unofficial embassy in Hong Kong, yesterday released a statement regetting the government's decision as &bquo;an extremely bad precedent&equo;. 
 But it took pains not to criticise Whitehall. 
 The Foreign Office said it was not closely involved as Mr Yang had requested asylum in Hong Kong. 
 Whitehall did not &bquo;view too tragically&equo; what China had said. 
 The government, while praised by local politicians for letting Mr Yang travel to the US, was criticised after police on Tuesday raided two television stations to seize films of a clash between police and demonstrators last Friday Police stopped protesters from marching to the World Trade Centre, where Xinhua was hosting a celebration to mark Communist China's 40th anniversary. 
 Journalists' associations compared the seizing of the tapes to China intercepting satellite transmissions to track down &bquo;counter-revolutionaries&equo;. 
 LONDON &mdash; Margaret Thatcher said yesterday it was impossible for Britain to take in millions of refugees from Hong Kong and urged China to take steps to restore the colony's confidence, AP reports. 
 Answering questions at a meeting with foreign journalists, Mrs Thatcher said: &bquo;We are looking at a scheme to have some people from Hong Kong, but it couldn't be anything like the total number.&equo; 
 Disneyland date 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 LOS ANGELES (UPI) &mdash; The jury which convicted a confessed devil-worshipper, Richard Ramirez, of 13 &bquo;Night Stalker&equo; murders has recommended that he be executed. 
 &bquo;Big deal. 
 Death always went with the territory. 
 I'll see you in Disneyland,&equo; the defendant said as he left the court. 
 Stalinist crimes 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 WARSAW (AFP) &mdash; The Polish government is to take legal action against those responsible for torturing and murdering thousands of people in Poland during the Stalinist era. 
 SA gallows 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 PRETORIA (AFP) &mdash; Three blacks sentenced to death on murder charges were hanged yesterday while a white man, condemned for rape, was granted a last-minute reprieve. 
 Bishop shot 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 BOGOTA (Reuter) &mdash; The Catholic bishop of the Colombian town of Arauca has been found murdered with several bullet wounds in the head. 
 The army blamed a leftist rebel group, ELN, led by a renegade Spanish priest known as Ayala. 
 Peace moves 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 CAIRO (Reuter) &mdash; Egypt named 12 Palestinians, approved by the PLO, to negotiate with Israelis in a proposed face-to-face meeting. 
 They include Mohammed Milhem, and Akram Haniyeh as non-resident Palestinians, and Hanna Siniora, editor of the Palestinian paper al-Fajr. 
 Rebel attack 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Paraguay fraud 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 ASUNCION (Efe) &mdash; Paraguayan judges signed an extradition request for the former French information minister, Jacques Soustelle, accused of swindling &pound;62.5m from the state-owned cement industry during the regime of the former dictator, Alfredo Stroessner. 
 Vigilantes kill 22 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 COLOMBO (Reuter) &mdash; Pro-government vigilantes hunting left-wing rebels shot dead 22 people and dumped their bodies on roadsides in central Sri Lanka. 
 Hijack sentence 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Lebanese accord 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 TAIF (AFP) &mdash; Lebanese MPs agreed in principle to shift power from the country's traditionally Christian president to the Muslim-headed cabinet. 
 The 62 MPs reached a consensus ahead of their fifth day of talks on ending Lebanon's confessional political system. 
 But Christian MPs held firm to their demand for a programmed Syrian military withdrawal, brushing aside repeated verbal assurances from Arab countries that such a withdrawal would take place. 
 Angola meeting 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 WASHINGTON (AP) &mdash; Zaire's President, Mobutu Sese Seko, and President George Bush met to try to prevent the collapse of an agreement between Angola and the US-backed Unita rebels, reached through Zairean mediation in June. 
 Unita's leader, Jonas Savimbi, and the Angolan Foreign Minister, Pedro van Dunem, were also in Washington. 
 Pilots relent 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 SYDNEY (Reuter) &mdash; Australia's airline pilots said they were withdrawing the 30 per cent pay claim at the heart of a dispute that has disrupted domestic air services and were seeking instead an unspecified rise based on a 25 per cent increase in productivity. 
 Peugeot deadlock broken 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 PARIS &mdash; The five-week deadlock between striking Peugeot workers and their employer was broken yesterday when the management obtained a court order to end a 10-day sit-in at one of the two factories in eastern France, Sarah Lambert writes. 
 The workers occupying the Mulhouse forge were told that unless they left the premises immediately they would be &bquo;forced to do so&equo;. 
 The workforce at France's most successful car manufacturer has rejected an earlier management offer of a 1.5 per cent pay rise and, in the face of what is widely seen here as management intransigence, the government reluctantly got involved in the private sector dispute yesterday evening, announcing that it would appoint an official conciliator. 
 Gorbachev again the reluctant guest of honour: Rupert Cornwell, our Moscow correspondent, who accompanied Mikhail Gorbachev on his momentous trip to Peking in May, considers the possible parallels with East Berlin 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL 
 MIKHAIL GORBACHEV must feel himself a man cursed. 
 As on his visit to Peking in May, the Soviet President this weekend risks finding himself an unwilling player in a domestic political drama which eclipses the notional reason for his presence. 
 Five months ago it was tens of thousands, quickly to become millions, of Chinese invoking his name as a symbol of the political reforms which their own rulers would not give them. 
 Amid the tumult of Tiananmen Square, the end of 30 years' estrangement between the world's great Communist powers went almost forgotten. 
 This time the setting will be cooler, more ordered East Berlin, the occasion the 40th birthday of the first socialist state on German soil. 
 But like the Chinese students, crowds of East Germans &mdash; with chants of &bquo;Gorby, Gorby&equo; - may vent demands for liberalisation which their aged leader will not permit. 
 And, just as in May, Mr Gorbachev seems trapped. 
 However much he might like to duck out, he cannot. 
 Deng Xiaoping could not tolerate the loss of face of postponement. 
 Nor can Erich Honecker now ask the most important guest not to come to his party. 
 Outwardly, Moscow has reacted with remarkable calm to the great human flood from East Germany to the West, and the convulsions it has caused in relations among its allies. 
 But the Soviet Union's predicament is real enough. 
 Either it permits an obdurate East Berlin leadership to continue, at the risk of deeper disaffection among the population and growing isolation among its allies, or it encourages reform, and risks destroying the fragile foundations of East German statehood entirely. 
 Mr Gorbachev knows full well that, unlike his counterparts in Poland and Hungary, Mr Honecker cannot replace doctrinaire communism with appeals to nationalism. 
 His state is built on ideology; to replace it with a more liberal system might only hasten Moscow's nightmare &mdash; irresistible momentum towards a reunited Germany. 
 But there are consolations. 
 First, Mr Gorbachev knows that most of the West regards the prospect of a swift unravelling of his country's front-line Warsaw Pact ally with almost equal alarm. 
 Fears for the stability of central Europe so bluntly expressed by Pravda this week are shared in Bonn, London and Washington. 
 Second, he has a chance to assess the realities on the ground: East Germany's internal political balance, and the prospects for the Honecker succession. 
 The important words this weekend will not be the public proclamations of East Germany's &bquo;inalienable place in the socialist community&equo;. 
 They will be Mikhail Gorbachev's private discussions with Mr Honecker and his colleagues. 
 These are unlikely to be easy. 
 Pravda may write that the refugee mess has been caused by &bquo;provocations&equo; and &bquo;revanchist propaganda&equo; from Bonn. 
 But Moscow knows that is not the case. 
 Mr Gorbachev could be forgiven for wishing he could plead a diplomatic cold, and steer clear of celebrations where a wake would be more apt. 
 East Germans board trains to freedom after long, wet wait 
 From EDWARD LUCAS in Prague 
 ALMOST 24 hours late, the first of several chartered trains left Prague for the West last night, carrying some of the 12,000 East German emigrants who had spent another night and a day on the chilly pavements around the West German embassy or in the embassy's increasingly squalid grounds. 
 About 1,000 Czechoslovaks gathered to watch and applaud the departure, which had been delayed by crowds of would-be emigrants in East Germany who had jammed railway stations in the hope of hitching rides as the trains passed through. 
 Thousands blocked East German rail lines and crowded into stations to try to board the trains en route to Prague, and thus qualify for the trip to West Germany. 
 The trains were not allowed to pass until the East German authorities were certain that they could prevent such attempts. 
 In Dresden police removed about 3,000 people from the station and sealed it off. 
 For the Germans in Prague, gloating over the latest humilation for the East Berlin leadership on the eve of its birthday party seemed to compensate for the conditions of near-vagrancy. 
 For the first time in the saga of occupation and exodus, the organisational skills of the Red Cross began to succumb yesterday to the sheer magnitude of the task facing it. 
 By mid-afternoon many people were evidently hungry, and long queues formed at a field kitchen dispensing cabbage soup and rolls. 
 More than a thousand people had spent the night out of doors. 
 Many said they had not slept but had spent the night moving around to keep warm. 
 The prolonged delay, coupled with low spirits caused by cold, squalor and exhaustion, naturally gave rise to some suspicions that East Germany might, incredibly, have reneged on its deal. 
 But the news, later in the day, that the first of at least 10 chartered trains had at last crossed the border into Czechoslovakia revived the East Germans' spirit of solidarity in the face of inconvenience and discomfort. 
 There were few new arrivals at the embassy. 
 Although many East Germans will in future be able to go to Czechoslovakia with official permission, applications must now be made four weeks in advance. 
 The emigrants' discomfort was aggravated by tantalising radio reports of the steaming soup tureens, hot water and clean clothes waiting for them at the reception centre in Hof, West Germany. 
 Asked what she would do once she had satisfied her immediate needs, one emigrant said, pensively, &bquo;I shall watch the East German anniversary celebrations, but I don't know if I will be laughing or crying.&equo; 
 Belgian Jew killed by &bquo;professional murderer&equo; 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Brussels 
 BELGIUM launched an anti-terrorist investigation yesterday into the murder of a leading member of its 30,000-strong Jewish community, Joseph Wybran. 
 Professor Wybran, 49, the director of the Co-ordination Committee of Jewish Organisations in Belgium (CCOJB), died early yesterday after being shot in the head on Tuesday night outside the Brussels University Hospital, where he headed the Immunology Department. 
 The professor was closely involved in a series of benevolence programmes for Israel, including the B'nai B'rith charity organisation, and was recently in Poland to negotiate a settlement in the row over the presence of a Catholic convent on the site of the former Auschwitz concentration camp. 
 Although no one had claimed responsibility for the attack by last night, it was apparently being treated as a terrorist incident by the Belgian police. 
 &bquo;It is impossible to determine the precise motive,&equo; a spokesman for the Brussels prosecutor's office commented. 
 &bquo;But given the nature of his activities it cannot be excluded that this was a political attack.&equo; 
 Professor Wybran was shot in the hospital car park. 
 Police sources said the shooting had the hallmarks of a &bquo;professional execution&equo;: a light handgun was used that would only ensure death if used at point-blank range. 
 The hospital, moreover, is perfectly located for a swift getaway, just yards from the Brussels ring road and the motorway to Paris. 
 Officials said four units of the national police had been assigned to the case, including two specialist terrorist squads. 
 Although there was a tacit assumption among the Belgian authorities that the attack must have been anti-Semitic in nature, no one could speculate as to its source. 
 The Israeli embassy in Belgium denounced the attack last night. 
 &bquo;It is clear that Professor Wybran has been assassinated in cold blood because he was a Jew,&equo; it said. 
 &bquo;Fifty years after the Holocaust, a Jewish leader is killed in the heart of the capital of Europe.&equo; 
 The Israeli Prime Minister, Yitzhak Shamir, expressed his shock at the incident. 
 &bquo;The government and the people of Israel share in the grief experienced by Belgian Jews,&equo; he said. 
 Similar expressions of grief and outrage were made by Jewish organisations around the world, as well as by the European Commission and the Belgian Prime Minister, Wilfried Martens, who called the act &bquo;revolting and wretched&equo;. 
 Czechs may share peace prize 
 By JOHN BULLOCH, Diplomatic Editor 
 THE NOBEL PRIZE committee is expected to give a boost to the drive for political freedom in east Europe when it announces the winners of the Peace Prize in Oslo today. 
 It is expected that two Czechoslovak dissidents, spanning a 20-year period, will be chosen as joint winners to emphasise the durability of the movement towards liberalisation. 
 A former Czechoslovakian Foreign Minister, Jiri Hajek, one of the architects of the &bquo;Prague Spring&equo; of 1968, has been nominated, along with Vaclav Havel, the imprisoned playwright who helped to found the Charter 77 human rights group. 
 Unlike Western governments, which have been careful to avoid giving the appearance of fomenting unrest in eastern Europe, the Norwegian Nobel committee is thought to be ready to try to advance the cause of democracy in a country which has shown only the most rudimentary signs of change. 
 In 1983, long before the West felt able to give aid to Poland, the committee chose Lech Walesa for the Peace Prize in a gesture which embarrassed the Polish government and focused the attention of the world on the changes taking place in Warsaw. 
 In Oslo yesterday, diplomats warned that the Nobel committee had a reputation for security and the leaked forecasts might prove wide of the mark. 
 Even so, the committee is unlikely to match the surprises of the &bquo;alternative&equo; Nobel prizes, awarded yesterday by the Right Livelihood Society, which singles out ecologically-sound solutions to problems. 
 Among the winners: a society of Japanese housewives which distributes environmentally sound products; an Ethiopian agronomist who has built up a seed bank of plants for use in time of drought, and Survival International, which campaigns for the rights of tribal peoples. 
 &bquo;Red Caliph&equo; carves out an acceptable communist face: Tim McGirk, in Madrid, interviews Julio Anguita, Spain's popular Communist Party leader, a month before elections 
 From TIM MCGIRK in Madrid 
 JULIO ANGUITA, the leader of the Spanish Communist Party, is looking for the thief in Madrid who smashed his windscreen and broke into his car for the third time. 
 &bquo;First, I'd re-arrange his face a little with my fist,&equo; remarked the burly Communist chief recently. 
 &bquo;Then I'd talk to him about the socio-economic roots of poverty.&equo; 
 Mr Anguita has also been re-arranging the face of Spanish Communism recently &mdash; with notable success. 
 Elections are less than a month away, and Mr Anguita is probably Spain's second most popular politician after the Socialist Prime Minister, Felipe Gonzalez. 
 The &bquo;Red Caliph&equo;, as he is called, wears a beard shaped like a crescent moon. 
 Mr Anguita has knocked some discipline into a coalition of quarrelsome, microscopic Communist parties and renegades from the Socialist Party. 
 This Leftist Unity party may steal enough votes from the ruling Socialists in the 29 October elections to threaten the comfortable majority predicted for Mr Gonzalez's party, which seeks its third term in office. 
 Described by one writer as a cross between &bquo;a sultan and a bandolier, a caliph and an ascetic, and a rural schoolmaster and a guerrilla&equo;, Mr Anguita, 48, is the kind of politician who carries his own revolver. 
 Even so many years after the Spanish Civil War, the Communist tag brings reactions of fear and violence to many of his countrymen. 
 While Mayor of Cordoba, he received many death threats from Fascist groups. 
 He also earned the nickname of the &bquo;Red Caliph&equo; by trying to give back to the Muslims a grand old mosque which the Catholic church had converted into a monastery 500 years ago. 
 Ramon Tammames, an economist and ex-communist, explained: &bquo;Many Spaniards are still mortally afraid of the hammer and sickle. 
 The Leftist Unity party is, in effect, led and controlled by the Spanish Communist Party, but Mr Anguita has wisely realised that this new name is less dangerous.&equo; 
 But Mr Tammames, who once was one of the leading intellectuals of the Communist party, is no admirer of the &bquo;Red Caliph&equo;. 
 &bquo;Julio is nostalgic over Marxist-Leninism. 
 He doesn't realise that Gorbachev doesn't feel that way any more, and neither does the vast majority of Spaniards.&equo; 
 Leftist Unity is targeting its campaign on the big industrial cities, such as Madrid, Barcelona and Valencia, as well as the region of Andalucia, where centuries of serfdom to the local noblemen have left the working class with a strong streak of radicalism. 
 The biggest task of the Leftist Unity party will be to lure away the working class from the Socialists. 
 So far, Mr Anguita's party has failed to do this. 
 Spanish workers voted heavily Socialist in the European parliamentary elections even though Mr Gonzalez's tight economic policies has led to a 17.3 per cent jobless rate and running battles with the trade unions. 
 In the Euro-elections, the Leftist Unity party only gathered 6.5 per cent of the vote, far behind the Socialists, the Conservatives and the Centrists. 
 A party spokeswoman, Lourdes Ortiz, remarked: &bquo;It doesn't seem possible, but the workers may vote again for the Socialist machine.&equo; 
 Mr Tammames said: &bquo;The Socialists have set up a client state where the pensioners, the people on the dole, are all sucking sustenance through government tubes. 
 Under Felipismo, Spaniards have come to depend on the state again, as they did for so long under Generalissimo Franco's regime.&equo; 
 Explosion blamed for DC-10 disaster 
 From PATRICK MARNHAM in Paris 
 INVESTIGATORS have determined that an explosion destroyed the UTA DC-10 which crashed in the Sahara Desert on 19 September, killing all 171 people on board, but there is no evidence that a bomb was responsible. 
 Contrary to reports in Paris last week, government investigators working at the central police laboratory here have ruled out the presence of the Czechoslovak-made explosive Semtex, which caused the Lockerbie disaster. 
 They are now certain an explosion was caused by Pentrite, a plastic explosive which requires much less skill to handle than Semtex and has been used by a far wider range of terrorist groups. 
 Had the explosion been caused by Semtex, suspicion would have centred on terrorists allied to Hizbollah, the pro-Iranian Lebanese group. 
 But there have been no credible claims of responsibility, and the use of Pentrite suggests to secret service investigators that it may not have been aimed at French national interests but at someone on the aircraft. 
 Among the passengers was Mahamat Soumaila, Chad's Minister of Planning, seated next to Jacques Renaudat, a French arms dealer. 
 Mr Renaudat is believed to have been arranging a deal for a large supply of arms captured by Chad during the war with Libya to be sold to the Lebanese Christians, through intermediaries in Tunis and Iraq. 
 He had a colourful past. 
 In the 1970s, when he was known as &bquo;Jacky des Halles&equo;, he was prominent in the world of organised crime. 
 He turned to arms dealing in Africa and claimed, with some plausibility, to be an unofficial emissary of the French secret service. 
 The presence of Pentrite in the wreckage, especially in the remains of the forward hold, does not necessarily mean it was destroyed by a bomb. 
 It apparently blew apart when the Pentrite formed a fireball of 3,000C and 10 ft in diameter. 
 But the investigators said yesterday that the explosive could have been illegally packed into the hold as part of the cargo, without a detonator. 
 Pentrite can explode without a detonator if it receives a severe blow or strong friction. 
 It has been suggested that the presence of an arms dealer and a minister engaged in selling arms, makes such an illegal cargo less implausible. 
 US move to double aid for Poland 
 From PETER PRINGLE in Washington 
 UNDER intense pressure from congressional Democrats to increase aid to Poland and Hungary, the White House announced yesterday that President Bush will ask Congress for an additional &dollar;200m (&pound;125m) grant for Poland, almost doubling his previous request. 
 The White House spokesman, Marlin Fitzwater, said the aid would be contingent on completion of an economic stabilisation plan between Warsaw and the International Monetary Fund. 
 Mr Fitzwater added that Mr Bush has invited both the Polish President, Wojciech Jaruzelski, and Prime Minister, Tadeusz Mazowiescki, to meet him in Washington. 
 The decision to increase American aid reflected the &bquo;dramatic changes in Poland over the past two months&equo;, said Mr Fitzwater. 
 Previously, Mr Bush had asked Congress for &dollar;120m in economic and environmental aid for Poland and &dollar;100m in food assistance. 
 He also asked for &dollar;25m for Hungary. 
 The Senate Foreign Relations Committee has approved a &dollar;1.2bn aid package for Poland and Hungary to be spread over three years. 
 The Democrats have been calling Mr Bush's aid plan &bquo;grossly inadequate&equo; and have been determined to produce an alternative that would increase the aid to the eastern European countries. 
 Mr Fitzwater said the White House is willing to negotiate with Congress &bquo;on the amount and the nature of the package&hellip; the numbers are all negotiable.&equo; 
 Soviet villagers &bquo;prepare to fight&equo; 
 From PETER PRINGLE in Washington 
 MOSCOW (Reuter) &mdash; Armed insurgents were reported yesterday to be setting up camps in the hilly terrain of Nagorny Karabakh as tensions between the Soviet republics of Armenia and Azerbaijan threatened to erupt into full-scale confrontation. 
 A report in the weekly Moscow News did not make clear if the insurgents were Armenians or Azerbaijanis. 
 It said villagers were forming detachments, many of them equipped with automatic rifles and home-made explosives. 
 Nagorny Karabakh, which has a predominantly Armenian population, became part of Azerbaijan in 1923 after the consolidation of Soviet power in the Transcaucasus region. 
 It is now the subject of a bitter dispute between the neighbouring republics. 
 The camps were spotted by pilots flying supplies to Nagorny Karabakh, which has been sealed off from the rest of Azerbaijan for several months. 
 &bquo;There is a firm basis to say they are training camps for insurgents,&equo; the report said, &bquo;and the number of dead among the civil population and the military grows every day.&equo; 
 Last month Arkady Volsky, head of the Kremlin commission which has administered the province since January, told Moscow that Armenia and Azerbaijan were &bquo;on the brink of war&equo;. 
 On Tuesday the Soviet parliament approved special measures allowing the military to take over rail links to get supplies through to Nagorny Karabakh and Armenia. 
 But the action was swiftly denounced by the radical Popular Front movement of Azerbaijan, which has supported the two-month blockade aimed at starving Armenia into capitulating on the issue. 
 &bquo;There will certainly be a strike across the republic if the military takes over the railway,&equo; said the movement's spokesman, Nazim Ragimov. 
 Efforts to resolve the conflict, which has caused more than 100 deaths since February last year, have so far been fruitless. 
 An Armenian Foreign Ministry spokesman said yesterday there was no fresh food coming in from Azerbaijan. 
 Food was being sent in along the republic's only rail link with Georgia. 
 &bquo;We are getting trainloads of rotten food - full of worms. 
 People are wearing gas masks to unload the wagons,&equo; he said. 
 Moscow News quoted an Interior Ministry colonel as saying it was impossible even for convoys with a military escort to cross into Nagorny Karabakh. 
 Out of the West: Fast Icelander set to speed up the Bush image 
 By PETER PRINGLE 
 WASHINGTON &mdash; Like the whiting in Alice in Wonderland who wanted the snail to go faster because of the porpoise on his tail, Americans are constantly worried about the pace of their lives. 
 Should they be speeding up because someone is behind them? 
 Or, should they be slowing down because sooner or later their hectic pace will do them in? 
 Many studies have been made in an effort to assess the correct national speed, and to warn those in the fast lane of their ultimate folly. 
 For example, this month's issue of Psychology Today contains the result of a study of the pace of life in 36 American cities. 
 Researchers stood on street corners, checked the clocks in banks and the speed at which tellers cashed cheques and shop assistants gave change. 
 They watched how fast people walk and talk. 
 Not suprisingly, people in the north-east of the country, where the work ethic and the climate push the pace of life ever upward, reside permanently in the fast lane. 
 North-easterners generally walk faster, give change faster, talk faster, and are more likely to wear watches so that they can make every second count. 
 How much people are worried about time means a lot, of course. 
 For example, in the fastest city of them all &mdash; which turned out to be Boston, not New York, which was third after Buffalo &mdash; the researchers noted that to get the exact time of day the telephone company requires you to dial N-E-R-V-O-U-S. 
 (Something going on here, clearly.) 
 In the laid-back city of Fresno, California, the time-clock number is P-O-P-C-O-R-N. 
 (Well, naturally.) 
 The study concluded that Los Angeles had the slowest pace of all, and the West was generally slower-paced than the rest of the country. 
 In Massachusetts, for example, pedestrians walked 60 feet in an average of 11.1 seconds, 3.6 seconds faster than they do in California. 
 And Columbus, Ohio, postal clerks spoke 40 per cent more syllables per second than their colleagues in Los Angeles. 
 Unfortunately, the researchers missed out Washington DC, where many Americans have been worried recently about the pace of the Bush presidency. 
 Many would love to know, for instance, whether there any clocks in the White House which show the time in Moscow, or Warsaw, or Budapest, because people wonder why Mr Bush and Company appear to be falling so far behind in their reaction to the pace of life in those cities. 
 In short, after promising to hit the ground running, people wonder why the President has become the leader of the Slow Is Beautiful Movement. 
 Mr Bush has been having trouble with his speed, no doubt about it. 
 After nine months in office he still is uncertain whether to go fast or slow on any issue from the Russians to oil slicks. 
 The result is a presidency with an image of blandness much different from the glitzy campaign Mr Bush waged to win the White House from Michael Dukakis who, it is worth remarking, is governor of the speedy state of Massachusetts. 
 But it could be that President Bush is aware of this, and it could be that things are about to change because of the return to Washington this week of one Sig Rogich. 
 This untypically flashy Icelander, who has lived most of his life in Las Vegas, and worked on Mr Bush's election campaign, has recently been in charge of polishing the images of Frank Sinatra and Donald Trump, the New York city real estate person. 
 No one ever accused Old Blue Eyes or Mr Trump of being behind the times. 
 Supposedly, Mr Rogich arrived in the White House yesterday to re-style the President's image; to bring back razzmatazz to what he calls &bquo;the beautiful people&equo; in the Bush cabinet. 
 &bquo;Please don't portray me as some flashy Vegas gambler who's plopping into the White House in Italian suits and expensive watches,&equo; Mr Rogich told a reporter from The New York Times from his car phone. 
 (Apparently his life is so fast-paced that he was unable to talk from his office). 
 Well, flashy is exactly the word that fits the image Mr Rogich portrays. 
 He was the one who helped produce the Bush campaign's dirtiest &mdash; and most effective &mdash; commercials during the 1988 campaign, including the ones hitting Mr Dukakis on his liberal prison furloughs and filthy Boston harbour. 
 Mr Rogich is a &bquo;handler&equo; par excellence. 
 His arrival suggests that Mr Bush will appear more often on television, spend less time at his Maine seaside retreat, and less time playing with his dogs. 
 The Rogich plan is to sharpen up the focus, as well as the pace. 
 Does Mr Bush foresee some sort of crisis during which his image will suffer unless boosted? 
 Economic troubles, perhaps? 
 Or is he really planning to speed up his reaction to Gorbachev and Eastern Europe? 
 Or is he looking to 1992 and re-election? 
 Mr Rogich says, unhelpfully: &bquo;I look at everything from the historical point of view because I think that gives greater impact to the message.&equo; 
 Tell that one to the White Rabbit. 
 US doubted coup attempt in Panama would succeed 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Washington 
 THE US Secretary of State, James Baker, hinted yesterday that the US withheld military support for Tuesday's failed coup in Panama because it believed it had little chance of success. 
 Mr Baker said that Washington was prepared to use military force to oust General Manuel Noriega, but on America's own terms and timetable. 
 &bquo;You do so based on your own plans, at a time of maximum opportunity and advantage. 
 You don't do so on the basis of someone else's plans,&equo; Mr Baker told the US Senate finance committee. 
 But Panamanain exiles in the US complained that a small show of force by the US might have been enough to tip the balance in the rebels' favour. 
 Juan Sosa, former Panamanian ambassador in Washington, said that, if the US had been &bquo;more active&equo;, several battalions of wavering Panamanian troops would have joined in on the rebel side. 
 Administration officials said that an emergency meeting of the National Security Council (NSC) considered deploying US troops to back the rebels on Tuesday, but decided against it. 
 In the final weeks of the Reagan administration, State Department plans for a &bquo;surgical strike&equo; against General Noriega were scotched by the Pentagon, which estimated that any use of US troops would cause several hundred military and civilian deaths. 
 The Defence Department is believed to have strenuously opposed use of US forces, once again, during Tuesday's meeting. 
 It remains unclear to what extent the rebels thought they were operating with America's blessing. 
 The Washington Times reported yesterday that senior US military officers in Panama gave the rebel officers &bquo;tacit&equo; assurances of American assistance. 
 This was firmly denied by the Bush administration. 
 US officials admit that they knew about the coup plans as early as last Saturday, but say they were given little time to judge its chances of success or to plan any US involvement. 
 Mr Baker's comments yesterday implied that the US government would be prepared to use its troops to back a Panamanian coup, but not this coup. 
 This is, in itself, a shift in the US position. 
 Washington had previously stated that the 12,000 American troops in Panama would be used only to defend the Canal and themselves. 
 The Baker explanation was dismissed by some members of Congress as a lame attempt to deflect complaints, from both right and left, that the administration bungled a chance to remove General Noriega. 
 The arch-conservative, Senator Jesse Helms (North Carolina), complained that the administration should have mobilised the US troops, based less than a mile from the Panamanian Defence Force headquarters, to help the rebels. 
 &bquo;Once again, we snatched defeat from the jaws of victory,&equo; Senator Helms said. 
 The view on the left was that the Bush administration was more involved in the coup than it has admitted, but decided against a visible or military role for fear of the political consequences of failure and a heavy loss of American lives. 
 &bquo;Anyone who doesn't believe the White House was was deeply involved&hellip; doesn't understand the magnitude of the President's obsession with Noriega or the way Washington works in these areas,&equo; said Larry Birns, director of the respected liberal think-tank, the Council on Hemispheric Affairs. 
 He said the operation had the characteristics of the &bquo;plausible deniability&equo; approach, used by Washington in the Iran-Contra affair. 
 The rebel officers had probably been given US blessing on the understanding that it would not bail them out if things went wrong. 
 After two failed coups in 18 months, the US view is that the general is more entrenched in power than ever. 
 Royal Navy arrives in Colombia to join drugs war 
 From SIMON FISHER in Cartagena, Colombia 
 THE ROYAL NAVY frigate HMS Alacrity arrived in the Colombian port of Cartagena yesterday, in the first stage of a British aid effort to combat drugs trafficking in Colombia. 
 Britain will carry out a joint naval operation with Colombia in the Caribbean aimed at intercepting cocaine shipments. 
 The aid package is designed to support a crackdown against drugs by the Colombian government which was launched after the assassination of a leading presidential candidate weeks ago. 
 But Alacrity's high-profile visit comes as international response to the Colombian offensive is being criticised inside Colombia. 
 Alacrity was in Cartagena, Colombia's main naval base, on a preliminary visit to discuss strategies for future co-ordinated action against drugs shipments in the Caribbean. 
 Her captain, Commander Colin Fearbrache, described the talks as positive, although he would not say when the operations would begin or how often they would take place. 
 This visit is as much a political as a practical gesture. 
 Alacrity was scheduled to call in Cartagena before Virgilio Barco, Colombia's president, announced the crackdown. 
 After taking on water and supplies, she returned to regular duties within 24 hours. 
 Alacrity is the Navy's West Indian guard ship, on routine patrol duties in the Caribbean. 
 The international community, which has expressed overwhelming support for President Barco's offensive, is under pressure to be seen to be doing something to help, and quickly. 
 But so far, efforts have been focused on purely military solutions. 
 The United States sent &dollar;65m (&pound;40m) of military aid to Colombia, but this has been called inappropriate and is alleged to be more suitable for fighting Colombia's left-wing guerrillas than the cocaine mafia. 
 Evidence of infiltration of the army by the drugs cartels has added to reservations about how effective the American aid can be. 
 Britain has offered several million pounds of aid, which includes communications equipment, bullet-proof vests, naval patrol craft, police training and the joint naval patrol. 
 Embassy officials insist British aid will provide practical means of combating the drugs trade. 
 Colombians, however, are sceptical. 
 There is a strong feeling in the country that Colombia is footing the bill for what is really an international problem, and is paying a high price, in violence, in murders and the breakdown of state institutions. 
 Critics say that the real battle against drugs can only be won by international co-ordination and the development of a long-term growth strategy. 
 This would guarantee higher international prices for Latin America's produce and would free resources to fund social programmes, including a vital land reform. 
 They say help is needed to combat the poverty that has left peasants growing traditional crops in many parts of Latin America unable to survive. 
 The drugs barons often win the support of the poor because they provide the means for entire communities to make a living. 
 While most people strongly condemn the drugs traffickers, critics point to the recent drive by international markets to drive down the price of coffee, Colombia's main export &mdash; and to the continuing drain of resources into debt payments to Western banks &mdash; as evidence that the international community is not willing to make the kind of sacrifices needed to confront the social and economic roots of Latin America's drug problem. 
 Meanwhile, on the deck of HMS Alacrity, the crew are determined to do whatever they can to fight the drugs traffickers. 
 &bquo;I despise them,&equo; says Stuart Ellroyd, a seaman from Liverpool. 
 &bquo;They are making fortunes out of taking children's lives. 
 All they are doing is making a lot more money out of a lot more misery.&equo; 
 Court upholds traffickers' extraditions to US 
 By SIMON FISHER 
 CARTAGENA &mdash; The Colombian Supreme Court has upheld the extradition of drug traffickers, decreed by President Virgilio Barco as part of his offensive against the cocaine cartels, writes Simon Fisher. 
 The decree prompted the cartels to declare &bquo;total war&equo; on the Colombian government and led to a wave of bombings throughout the country. 
 At least 10 people were killed and 150 injured in bomb attacks last month. 
 The US administration has requested the extradition of 80 traffickers, but the drug barons have said they would prefer to die in Colombia than spend the rest of their lives in US jails. 
 The Supreme Court has, in effect, given President Barco the go-ahead to wage all-out war in reply. 
 Its decision, which was reached a week earlier than expected, came despite threats to kill 10 judges for every trafficker extradited. 
 The court also upheld a series of decrees allowing the seizure and confiscation of suspected traffickers' personal property. 
 Since 1981 at least 50 judges and about 170 judicial employees have been killed, mainly by cartel hit squads. 
 Another 500 judges and 5,000 court employees have resigned out of fear or in protest against inadequate protection. 
 Judges are receiving firearms training from police but have threatened to go on strike as promised protection has not materialised. 
 Since the government's offensive was launched on 19 August, more than 12,000 people have been detained and at least 1,000 luxury homes and farms seized. 
 US says Russians might put rouble on gold standard 
 By JOHN LICHFIELD 
 THE US Secretary of State, James Baker, yesterday raised the possibility that the Soviet Union might put the rouble on the gold standard as part of its programme of perestroika, writes John Lichfield. 
 US officials insist that Washington is not pushing the idea, but confirmed that it will be a topic of conversation when the chairman of the Federal Reserve, Alan Greenspan, visits Moscow this weekend. 
 Speaking to the Senate Finance Committee yesterday, Mr Baker said that a rouble convertible with other currencies was &bquo;necessary&equo; to generate market competition within the Soviet Union and to integrate the country's economy with that of the rest of the world. 
 He said that as the world's biggest gold producer, the Soviet Union might consider using its gold stocks to guarantee the value of the rouble and of Soviet government bonds. 
 Future gold production might be used as a regulator for the Soviet money supply. 
 US officials said this did amount to a description of a rouble gold standard, but emphasised that Mr Baker was not prescribing or even recommending policy to Moscow. 
 They said Mr Baker was simply listing one possibility among a number of other courses open to Mikhail Gorbachev in his restructuring programme. 
 Mr Baker's comments came, however, a few days before Mr Greenspan starts a four-day visit to Moscow. 
 This will be the first time that the chief of the US central bank, effectively head-keeper of the capitalist conscience, has visited the Soviet Union. 
 According to US officials, the technical problems involved in making the rouble a convertible currency will be among the issues discussed by Mr Greenspan during his trip. 
 Wayne Angel, one of the five governors of the Federal Reserve, visited Moscow last month and strongly endorsed the concept of a convertible rouble, backed by gold. 
 Federal Reserve officials declined to discuss Mr Greenspan's agenda yesterday. 
 But other US officials said they believed the subject of the convertible rouble, and the gold standard, would arise in Moscow. 
 One senior official said: &bquo;It's not uppermost in Soviet thinking at the moment. 
 On the other hand, things can change rapidly there. 
 The Soviets said to Greenspan, &bquo;Look, you're an expert in currency matters, and wouldn't it be interesting for us to chat about these things?&equo; 
 ' In his comments on the Soviet economy to the Senate Finance Committee yesterday, Mr Baker rejected the idea of early Soviet membership of international economic institutions such as the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade, the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank. 
 Mr Baker said it would be &bquo;exceedingly difficult&equo; for Mr Gorbachev to revitalise the Soviet economy but it was premature to predict failure. 
 In any event, the introduction of market pricers, and competition, was the key to success, he said. 
 And he added: &bquo;There is a reasonable case that price reform cannot proceed until the Soviets have stabilized the value of the rouble&hellip; a convertible rouble&hellip; is necessary for effective competitive interaction by the Soviet economy with the rest of the international economy.&equo; 
 Call for new inquiry into plane disaster: Marc Champion in Washington explains why some investigators suspect the US and Canadian governments hushed up the reasons for a 1985 plane crash 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 ALMOST four years after the 1985 crash of an airliner in Gander, Newfoundland, in which 248 US servicemen were killed, a group of congressmen are pressing for a new inquiry into the disaster. 
 Inconsistencies in the initial report on the crash have led some investigators to suspect that the US and Canadian governments took part in a cover-up. 
 The report concluded that the Arrow Airlines DC-8 crashed soon after take-off from Gander because of an accumulation of ice on the wings. 
 But that theory has since been discredited, and many critics, prompted by similarities between the Gander crash and the explosion of Pan Am flight 103 over Scotland last December, believe that the aircraft was blown apart by a terrorist bomb. 
 The White House, critics argue, failed to follow up the bomb theory because of the risk that it would have posed to negotiations with Iran for the release of US hostages in Lebanon. 
 The crash, on 12 December 1985, occurred before the Iran-Contra connection became public, and in the midst of sensitive negotiations between the White House, the Iranian government and Islamic Jihad, which claimed responsibility. 
 A judicial review by the Canadians dismissed the ice theory and, prompted by angry relatives of the dead soldiers, Representative Robert Tallon of South Carolina and 10 other congressmen have requested an investigation into the crash. 
 The House Armed Services Committee has turned down his request, but Mr Tallon yesterday sent a letter to all members asking them to petition President Bush. 
 The chartered jet was carrying 248 US servicemen home for Christmas to Fort Campbell, Kentucky, from their stations in the Sinai desert, where they formed part of the Multinational Force and Observers designed to monitor implementation of the Camp David accords between Egypt and Israel. 
 Four of the nine officials on the Canadian Airline Safety Board (CASB) panel which investigated the incident dissented from the report when it was issued in December last year. 
 They said that the computer models used to support the ice theory were &bquo;fabricated&equo;. 
 The evidence, including autopsies and eye-witness statements, pointed to a fire on board the DC-8 before it crashed, they said. 
 The fire could have been caused either by sabotage or the accidental detonation of a bomb being carried home by one of the soldiers as a souvenir. 
 &bquo;There were so many similarities between the Pan Am crash and this one that now I lean towards sabotage,&equo; said Les Filotas, one of the four Canadian dissenters. 
 &bquo;In both instances witnesses saw the glow of fires. 
 Both departed from West Germany. 
 Both carried US military personnel just before Christmas, and in both cases there was a terrorist claim of responsibility.&equo; 
 Marc Laframboise, an investigator for the Canadian Liberal Party, emphasised that Islamic Jihad in Beirut claimed responsibility between four and eight hours after the incident. 
 Even though it had detailed knowledge of the flight's route so soon after the event, the US government dismissed its claim out of hand hours later, and never explained why. 
 There were other strange omissions. 
 &bquo;There was no investigation of a possible explosion&hellip; no explosive experts to look for traces of Semtex,&equo; said Mr Laframboise. 
 The Canadian dissenters also said that information was withheld from them during the investigation. 
 One witness at the crash site said the US military commander there wanted to bulldoze the area immediately. 
 And the FBI said it had participated only to help fingerprint the victims; yet there is an FBI report on the incident with over 200 pages blacked out for national security reasons. 
 Arrow Air itself appears to have been involved in the Iran-Contra air supply operation. 
 Don Ewing, director of operations for Arrow, has acknowledged that the company carried arms from Portugal to the Nicaraguan rebels on at least two occasions in 1984. 
 And one of Arrow's pilots, Jacobo Bolivar, was one of the three principals of Sur International, the company which flew weapons from the US to Iran for Lieutenant-Colonel Oliver North in 1985. 
 &bquo;We need some people to be made to testify under oath so we can find out what went wrong with that investigation,&equo; said Mr Laframboise, stressing that, at this point, it does not matter that most of the physical evidence has been destroyed. 
 Neither Mr Tallon nor the families of the crash victims claim to know what occurred. 
 &bquo;But we know it wasn't ice,&equo; said Zona Phillips, who founded &bquo;Families for Truth about Gander&equo;. 
 Evidence of 66AD Jew's revolt found in desert caverns 
 By DAVID KEYS 
 (First Edition) DRAMATIC evidence of the First Century AD Jewish revolt against Rome, which led up to the famous siege and mass suicide of Masada, has been unearthed by Israeli archaeologists in the desert to the east of Jerusalem. 
 A detailed exploration of the area has succeeded in locating the headquarters of the rebel leader who led the revolt of 66-70AD and who fought alongside the Masada rebels for several years. 
 Archaeologists have discovered the Jewish headquarters located in a complex of hitherto unexplored caves in the Wadi Phara, six miles north-east of Jerusalem. 
 The complex, of some 20 caves, was the main base for rebels led by Shimon Bar-Giora, the chief commander of the Jewish revolt, who was captured in 70AD, taken in chains to Rome and executed outside the Capitol. 
 The site suggests that considerable preparation was made for the uprising. 
 The caves are man-made, hewn out of the rock by hand. 
 All of them, which are located 50ft up the side of a cliff, were equipped with plaster water-storage cisterns. 
 The complex included one particularly large cave - 33ft by 16ft &mdash; which may have served as Bar-Giora's personal accommodation. 
 The existence in the area of a cave complex which functioned as a rebel base is referred to by the First Century AD Jewish historian, Flavius Josephus. 
 Bar-Giora is thought to have used his desert headquarters not only in his struggle against the Romans but also while he was in conflict with rival Jewish rebel movements, including the Zealots. 
 Israeli archaeologists have also discovered two caves used by other Jewish anti-Roman activists, including a priest. 
 Inside the man-made cavern, located 100ft up the side of a cliff, an archaeological survey team found a hastily-written message recording that &bquo;Joezer (the priest) has just been killed (or wounded). 
 The (Roman) guards have entered (our hiding place).&equo; 
 The note was written in charcoal on the side of a plaster water-cistern, along with two drawings &mdash; also in charcoal -of the Jewish menora, the traditional seven-branched candlestick. 
 Also drawn in charcoal were two other features of religious importance: a group of five-pointed stars and a mystical two-line formula, each consisting of all 22 letters of the Hebrew alphabet &mdash; the ultimate anagram which, when rearranged, could quite literally be used to express all human knowledge and all experience. 
 The cliff hideout also possessed its own ritual bath, a mikveh, which would normally have been used by the priest for religious purification. 
 Besides the First Century cave, the archaeologists have discovered a group of other man-made caverns believed to have been used by the Second Century anti-Roman Jewish rebel, Bar-Kokhba. 
 The desert valley in which the complex is located, known as the Wadi Qelt, is referred to in ancient rabbinical sources as having been &bquo;flooded by the blood&equo; of the rebels. 
 The newly-discovered sites are of particularly great importance for Jewish history because the Roman repression which followed the revolts of Bar-Giora and Bar-Kokhba mark the beginning of the Jewish diaspora. 
 The rebel hideouts were discovered during a survey of Judean desert caves headed by the Haifa University archaeologist, Joseph Patrich, in association with the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. 
 So far more than 150 caves have been explored and surveyed. 
 Court Circular 
 By DAVID KEYS 
 BALMORAL CASTLE 4 October: The Queen was represented by Admiral of the Fleet the Lord Lewin at the Funeral of Field Marshal Sir Richard Hull which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, this morning. 
 The Duke of Edinburgh was represented by Admiral Sir David Hallifax. 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 4 October: The Duchess of York today opened the new terminal at Kent International Airport and later, as Patron of Museums Year 1989, visited the Minster Agricultural and Rural Life Museum, Thanet, Kent. 
 Her Royal Highness was received by Brigadier Maurice Atherton (Deputy Lieutenant of Kent). 
 Miss Lucy Manners was in attendance. 
 4 October: The Princess Royal, President of the International Equestrian Federation, this morning gave a Press Conference at Wembley Conference Centre. 
 Her Royal Highness, President of the Save the Children Fund, subsequently visited the Lifechance Project, Cricket Road, Cowley and the Barton Community Centre and was received on arrival by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Oxfordshire (Sir Ashley Ponsonby Bt). 
 The Princess Royal this afternoon attended the Annual General Meeting and Conference of the National Association of Citizens Advice Bureaux at the University of York and was received on arrival by Major-General H. Woods (Vice-Lord-Lieutenant of Yorkshire). 
 Her Royal Highness, Patron, Universiade &bquo;91 World Student Games, afterwards visited Sheffield to view facilities relating to preparations for the World Student Games and was received on arrival by her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for South Yorkshire (Lieutenant-Colonel Hugh Neill). 
 The Princess Royal travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 Mrs Malcolm Wallace was in attendance. 
 4 October: The Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon, President of the Girl Guides Association, attended a Meeting of the Executive Committee of the Council at the New Cavendish Club, Cumberland Place, this afternoon. 
 The Lady Juliet Townsend was in attendance. 
 Her Royal Highness, Grand President of St John Ambulance Association and Brigade, was present this evening at a Gala Evening at Garrard, Regent Street, in aid of the Order of St John. 
 The Hon Mrs Wills was in attendance. 
 The Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon was represented by Major The Lord Napier and Ettrick at the Funeral of Field Marshal Sir Richard Hull KG, which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, this morning. 
 4 October: The Duke of Gloucester this evening attended a Gala Concert and Dinner hosted by The National Trust at Osterley Park House, Isleworth. 
 Major Nicholas Barne was in attendance. 
 YORK HOUSE 4 October: The Duchess of Kent, as President, this morning presided at the launch of the Appeal for the Royal Northern College of Music, Manchester, and this afternoon, opened Skelton House at Manchester Science Park, and attended the South Manchester Health Authority's Annual Nurse Prize Giving at the Armitage Centre, Fallowfield, Manchester. 
 Her Royal Highness, who travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight, was attended by Mrs Peter Wilmot-Sitwell. 
 The Duke and Duchess of Kent were represented by Lieutenant-Commander Sir Richard Buckley at the Funeral of Field Marshal Sir Richard Hull KG which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, today. 
 Miss Mona Mitchell was in attendance. 
 Her Royal Highness, Colonel-in-Chief, 17th/21st Lancers, was represented by Colonel MC Watson, President of the Regimental Association, at the Funeral of Field Marshal Sir Richard Hull which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, this morning. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Prince of Wales opens the Lintrathen Water Treatment Works, Kirriemuir, Angus; as President, Scottish Business in the Community, visits the Dundee Enterprise Trust and the Whitfield Estate, Dundee; Patron, The Renaissance Theatre Company, attends the Premiere of Henry V at the Odeon Cinema, Leicester Square, London WC2. 
 The Princess of Wales visits London Lighthouse, 111-117 Lancaster Road, London W11. 
 The Princess Royal, President, Riding for the Disabled Association, visits the Abingdon Group, Longworth, Abingdon; attends the Annual General Meeting of the National Association of Victim Support Schemes at Central Hall, Westminster, London SW1; and as President, Royal Yachting Association, attends a Racing Rules Committee Meeting at the Royal Thames Yacht Club, 60 Knightsbridge, London SW1. 
 Princess Margaret, Patron of the Friends of St John's Smith Square, attends a concert to be given by Dame Joan Sutherland and Mr Richard Bonynge, at St John's. 
 The Duchess of Kent, as Patron of the Norfolk and Norwich Triennial Festival, attends their French Festival Concert, Norwich, Norfolk. 
 Prince and Princess Michael of Kent attend a film premiere of New York Stories in aid of the Sharon Allen Leukaemia Trust and Variety Club of Great Britain at the Odeon, Haymarket, London W1. 
 Woodland Trust buys Moncreiffe Hill Wood in Pertshire 
 By JOANNA GIBBON 
 Moncreiffe Hill Wood in Perthshire, which the Woodland Trust has bought from the Forestry Commission. 
 The 333-acre wood, the largest the trust has bought in Scotland, opened this week, writes Joanna Gibbon. 
 It stretches up a steep hill and overlooks the rivers Tay and Earn. 
 The trust plans to replace some of Moncreiffe Hill's conifers with broadleaf trees, to provide a balance between the two that will encourage wildlife. 
 The Woodland Trust was founded in 1972 and is the only charity in Britain which aims to safeguard native trees such as oak, lime, beech and ash. 
 Today's agricultural and forestry methods have caused a decline in broadleaf woodlands and coppices, affecting the animals and birds that inhabit them and the general landscape. 
 By buying woods and planting out broadleaf trees to create new woods, the Trust now owns 11,500 acres of woodland across 56 counties in Britain. 
 In addition it has encouraged other landowners to create 460 acres of new woods. 
 Almost all the trust's properties are open to the public. 
 Obituary: Dorothea Ramsey 
 By FRANCES M. BIRKETT 
 DOROTHEA RAMSEY was a pioneer in work for old people and one of the leading figures in establishing residential homes for the elderly during the Second World War. 
 From 1929 to 1939 Ramsey &mdash; trained as a classicist at Cambridge and fired with an enthusiasm for ancient Greece &mdash; had taught Greek and Latin in London. 
 As a voluntary worker in 1941 for the Bristol Council of Social Service in the War Emergency Bureau, she helped form the Old People's Welfare Committee of which she then became Secretary. 
 This committee set about establishing a small residential home for old people, the second of its kind in the country, and, by July 1942, thanks largely to her drive, West Town House in Bristol was opened. 
 Back in London in 1943, Dorothea Ramsey served on the Advisory Case Sub-Committee of the National Council of Social Service. 
 Pioneered by Miss Alice Green in 1941, this committee placed old people who needed care and attention, but not evacuation, in homes and hostels. 
 By 1943 the group of three full-time and three part-time workers were dealing with 2,000 requests a year from hospital almoners, social workers and individuals, placing 523 and advising 986, besides visiting homes to see if they were suitable. 
 Requests poured in, principally from London but also from other parts of the country. 
 The work was heart-breaking because of the shortage of homes and it showed that many old people were living in distress. 
 Not only was there physical weakness but also intense loneliness and sometimes mental anguish due to lack of occupation in the &bquo;workhouse&equo; and the chronic sick wards. 
 In 1940 the National Council of Social Service called together the chief national voluntary societies that were concerned with old people and invited as observers the government departments involved by statute in their care, of which the most prominent were the Ministry of Health and the Assistance Board. 
 The National Old People's Welfare Committee, later called Age Concern, sought to promote the welfare of old people throughout the United Kingdom and relieve the conditions which were revealed by the war. 
 In 1945 Ramsey became its Secretary and because of her past experiences was able to throw herself wholeheartedly into the work. 
 She proved to be a remarkably good co-ordinator in uniting the different societies in their drive to improve conditions and by touring the country, set up local Old People's Welfare groups to promote homes, clubs, visiting and other services. 
 She initiated training for matrons of residential homes, pressed for the chiropody service which is now available and urged that pensioners should have their own pocket money when they were in residential care. 
 During her time a remarkable change came over the attitude of authorities towards the care of the elderly. 
 This was largely due to the fact that Ramsey took every opportunity to ask that old people should retain their dignity and as much independence as possible. 
 &bquo;How would you like to have to ask for a penny to buy a stamp if you wanted to write a letter?&equo; she would ask. 
 &bquo;Measure the service you provide against what you would like in similar circumstances.&equo; 
 By 1952 the contacts Ramsey had made in the US led to her being awarded a Smith-Mundt scholarship and she toured the country speaking as an authority on what was then pioneering work being done in the UK. 
 While there she spoke at the International Gerontological Congress. 
 A pupil of Gustav Holst at St Paul's Girls School, Ramsey was devoted to music and as a flautist she played in the Cumberland Symphony Orchestra when she went to live in Cumbria. 
 She became chairman of the orchestra and later became a member and chairman of the Keswick Music Society. 
 But her chief work for music in Cumbria was as Secretary for 20 years of the Cumbria Rural Choirs. 
 Largely due to her courage and drive she enabled them to grow in stature so that the choirs were able to perform the major choral works drawing an audience of over 1,000 at a performance of the Dream of Gerontius and be broadcast with the BBC Scottish Symphony Orchestra on three occasions. 
 Ill-health dogged Dorothea. 
 Arthritis crippled her hands so she had to give up, most reluctantly, the flute and then a series of eye operations ended in virtual blindness. 
 She had to face the handicaps of severe diabetes but, true to Greek ideals, she endured them with stoicism; only on four occasions in 30 years did she break down under these cruel burdens. 
 Somewhat forbidding socially because of shyness, Dorothea had an absolute integrity which made her stand up for what she believed should be done. 
 Obituary: Helen Mason 
 By DEIRDRE CHAPMAN 
 IN THE LATE Fifties when news-gathering was still a soft-hat and trenchcoat job, Helen Mason became a reporter with the Daily Record. 
 Real life was then a male preserve but Helen had no interest in the usual option of the women's pages. 
 She became one of those women reporters whose listening ear and less judgemental approach to people in trouble helped to make the distillation of news the more respected practice it is today. 
 She was also fun. 
 For a memorable period she kept a pet monkey which travelled on her shoulder until its erratic behaviour had it banned from the newsroom. 
 In 1960 she joined the Sunday Express in London, where her news experience and personality quickly singled her out and in 1962 she was appointed the paper's chief American correspondent, choosing to cross the Atlantic by Cunarder. 
 This characteristic delight in style was balanced by a Scots impatience with the ritual of the career spiral. 
 Summoned to Lord Beaverbrook's presence on her departure for the US she listened to him develop a one-sided Scottish conversation which included the listing of many ancestors and their places of burial. 
 &bquo;And where will you be buried? 'said Helen. 
 Her American years encompassed the Kennedy period, the Cuban missile crisis and the dawn of the beautiful people. 
 Back in London in 1966 she married Hugo Young, the political columnist, biographer and broadcaster, in a ceremony conducted by Cardinal Hume, then Abbot of Ampleforth. 
 The bride wore a mini-dress. 
 The birth of the first of their four children signalled a complete change in her life as, lacking convincing models for the successful media personality and mother, she created her own. 
 She had no doubt that her children were too important to be brought up by anyone else and, as others went on to become household names, she became a full-time mother, writing occasional children's books as well as a storybook-guide to the handling of epilepsy based on experiences with her own son. 
 These experiences led her to become a member of the Council and Executive Committee of the British Epilepsy Association. 
 Later she also campaigned for a better understanding of anorexia. 
 With her children grown up, Helen returned to journalism, writing with humour but more particularly with balance and concern for the under-canvassed areas of life. 
 At the time of her death she was working on a novel. 
 In a profession often noted for self-promotion and expediency she had become a trusted friend, hostess and shoulder to lean on for many. 
 Over the months of her battle with lung cancer her unfailing humour and concern that others should be able to handle her illness without awkwardness were an example to all who knew her. 
 Her friends in Scotland will miss her most at Hogmanay when her feelings of nationhood tended to erupt satirically. 
 Shortly after midnight we would answer the phone to hear Helen in her Hampstead drawing room leading a massed choir of bemused MPs, writers and journalists whom she had coached in the proper rendering of &bquo;A guid new year tae een an&equo; a'.' 
 Holborn Law Society 
 Gazette Page 34 
 Appointments: Judicial Studies Board 
 By DEIRDRE CHAPMAN 
 The following appointments have been made to the Judicial Studies Board: Mr Justice Johnson, in succession to Lord Justice Butler-Sloss, (and will also serve as co-Chairman of the Civil and Family Committee); Judge Oddie, in succession to Judge White, (and will continue to serve as a member of the Civil and Family Committee); Mr Registrar Angel, a Family Division Registrar, (who will also continue to serve on the Civil and Family Committee). 
 Anniversaries 
 By DEIRDRE CHAPMAN 
 On this day: the Gregorian calendar was adopted in Italy and Spain and today became 15 October 1582; Spain declared war on Britain, 1796; Italian troops occupied Tripoli, 1911; the first air battle took place between German and French aircraft, 1914; the Allies landed at Salonika, 1915; Sir Arthur Lee presented the estate of Chequers as an official country residence for the Prime Minister, 1917; the Locarno Conference met and the great powers guaranteed frontiers and agreed to put disputes to arbitration, 1925; unemployed shipyard workers started to march from Jarrow to London, 1936; the Cominform (Communist Information Bureau) was set up to aid European Communist parties, 1947; tea rationing ended in Britain, 1952. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 34 
 Bridge 
 By ALAN HIRON 
 IT IS CURIOUS how an intervening bid, even if it does not have any great pre-emptive value, can throw a spanner in the opponents' works. 
 For example, suppose that a partnership is holding three low cards in the same suit. 
 Given a clear run, with plenty of other values, they would almost certainly have played in 3NT, but if an adversary has overcalled in that suit they will be apprehensive of the no-trump game in case there are five immediate losers. 
 On this hand, consider the problems that West's overcall seemed to set North-South: Game all, dealer West North 8 4 3 A A K 9 3 K Q 8 7 3 West A K J 10 6 5 2 10 4 J 10 9 4 East 7 2 10 8 7 J 7 6 5 2 A 6 2 South Q 9 6 5 K Q J 9 4 3 Q 8 5 West dealt and passed, North opened One Club and South responded One Heart. 
 Now West overcalled with One Spade. 
 It looked a pointless exercise, facing a passed partner, but West had his reasons. 
 North reversed with Two Diamonds and now it was up to his partner to make a descriptive bid. 
 South's hand did not look right for a rebid in no-trumps so, rather than explore with an ambiguous bid in the opponent's suit, he decided to stress the quality of his own suit with Three Hearts. 
 Now North had the problem - would Three Spades be taken as a probe for no-trumps (denying a guard in the suit) or some sort of control-showing bid agreeing hearts? 
 Overlooking the point that if it were the latter he could clarify the matter on the next round, he settled for a direct raise to Four Hearts. 
 This was not at all unreasonable but, looking at the full deal, you can see that Three No-Trumps would have been easy. 
 Four Hearts, on the other hand, was not a success although the play did not go quite as you might think. 
 West started with top spades and followed by giving his partner a spade ruff. 
 The ace of clubs would have defeated the contract out of hand but East mysteriously returned a diamond. 
 Understandably thinking that he had achieved an odd escape, declarer gleefully played off three rounds of diamonds to discard his losing club, but now it was West who took the setting trick when he was able to ruff. 
 You can see my point &mdash; that even the simplest of overcalls can steer opponents into strange misjudgements. 
 In case you think that I am advocating a policy of lunatic aggression, no, I am not. 
 Sometimes it will prove expensive. 
 At least here West's spades were good, if few in number. 
 Law Report: Employee not entitled to payment from redundancy fund: Secretary of State for Employment v Levy &mdash; Employment Appeal Tribunal (Mr Justice Wood, Mr R J Lewis and Mr J A Scouller), 4 October 1989 
 By YING HUI TAN, Barrister 
 &bquo;Pay&equo; within article 119 of the EEC Treaty did not include a statutory redundancy payment or a statutory payment under section 106 of the Employment Protection (Consolidation) Act 1978. 
 Accordingly, article 119 did not apply to the Employment Secretary's liability to make section 106 payments, and an employee who had become entitled to a state pension and was then dismissed for redundancy was not entitled to a payment from the Employment Secretary under section 106. 
 The EAT, by a majority, allowed the Secretary of State's appeal against an industrial tribunal's decision to award the applicant the sum of &pound;4,513.50 to be paid by the Secretary of State out of the redundancy fund under section 106 of the Employment Protection (Consolidation) Act 1978. 
 Article 119 of the EEC Treaty provides: &bquo;Each member state shall&hellip; maintain the application of the principle that men and women should receive equal pay for equal work. 
 For the purpose of this article, &bquo;pay&equo; means the ordinary basic or minimum wage or salary and any other consideration, whether in cash or in kind, which the worker receives, directly or indirectly, in respect of his employment from his employer.&equo; 
 The applicant was employed by a company from 1959 to 1987 until she was dismissed by reason of redundancy when she was a few months over 60. 
 She was disentitled to a redundancy payment by section 82(1) of the 1978 Act, which denied redundancy payment to women aged 60 or more. 
 She applied to her employer for a redundancy payment but was refused because of lack of funds. 
 She then applied to the Secretary of State for payment under section 106. 
 The Secretary of State maintained that because of section 82 the applicant was not entitled to a statutory redundancy payment. 
 The tribunal decided that a payment to be made under s 106 was &bquo;pay&equo; within article 119 of the EEC Treaty and, therefore, the Employment Secretary was liable to pay a payment. 
 The Employment Secretary appealed. 
 John Mummery (Treasury Solicitor) for the Employment Secretary; Richard Cole and Fernanda Pirie (Free Representation Unit) for the employee. 
 MR JUSTICE WOOD, giving the majority judgment, said that Mr Cole's submission that there must be implied into every contract of employment a term that the Secretary of State should make a payment under section 106 in the event of a redundancy and of an insolvency of the employer could not be accepted. 
 The wording of section 106 and of article 119 was clear. 
 A statutory payment under section 106 did not fall within the definition of pay in article 119. 
 The applicant then submitted that a statutory redundancy payment was &bquo;pay&equo; within article 119 and that on the employer's default to make that payment the Secretary of State guaranteed the sum under section 106. 
 When considering whether a statutory redundancy payment was pay within article 119, it was essential to appreciate that today there existed contractual redundancy payments &mdash; arising out of the contract of employment -and, by contrast, statutory redundancy payments arising out of the statutory scheme in the 1978 Act. 
 The following features of a statutory redundancy payment emerged: (1) The obligation was imposed on the employer; (2) It only arose on dismissal and might never arise if an employee worked until retirement, whether voluntary &mdash; early retirement &mdash; or at an agreed date, each of which was based on contract; (3) It only arose if certain preconditions were proved; (4) It applied to all employees who had worked for at least two years with an employer; (5) Certain classes of employee were excluded, eg redundant employees refusing suitable alternative employment; employees under a fixed-term contract of two years or more, who had renounced their redundancy rights in writing; (6) A voluntary redundancy could be under a contractual statutory scheme, and under such a contractual scheme it was often the equivalent of early retirement by agreement; (7) In no way could a redundancy payment be described as a deferred emolument or pay; it was a monetary compensation for the disappearance of a job. 
 The employee's problems arose because by section 82 the ages used for disentitlement were those at which the old age pension was payable &mdash; 60 for women and 65 for men. 
 A member state was entitled to discriminate in the ages at which men and women became entitled to state pensions but it was not acceptable for a distinction to be made between the sexes as to the age of retirement: see Marchall v Southampton and SW Hampshire Area Health Authority (Teaching) (1986) ICR 335; Roberts v Tate &amp; Lyle (1986) ICR 371. 
 In order to comply with Community law, it was now necessary to agree the same date of retirement for both sexes. 
 Thus, on the basis that state pensions became payable to women at 60 and to men at 64, if the retirement age was 55, neither would be in a position to claim a pension on retirement; if it was 60, women would, but men would not; if it was 65, women would have been able to receive since 60 and men would not. 
 Community law would not have been transgressed. 
 The logic of choosing pensionable ages for the purposes of disentitlement under section 82 must be that after retirement there could be no redundancy. 
 Having been referred to the cases dealing with the issue of pay within article 119, including Defrenne v Belgian State (no 80/70) and Worringham v Lloyds Bank Ltd (1981 ICR 558), there was no support for the submissions made on behalf of the employee. 
 Hammersmith and Queen Charlott Special Health Authority v Cato (1988) ICR 132 was distinguishable in that a contractual redundancy was being considered. 
 From article 119 itself and guidance from the cases, a statutory redundancy payment was not &bquo;pay&equo; within article 119. 
 Mr J A Scouller gave reasons for dissenting. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Straw calls for UK to become best trained and educated nation in Europe 
 By JUDY JONES 
 THE NEXT Labour government will abandon the &bquo;corrupt priorities&equo; of the Tories' education policies and make Britain the brains of Europe, Jack Straw, the party's education spokesman said yesterday. 
 He told the Labour conference: &bquo;It is no wonder that we are running a &pound;20bn sterling trade deficit. 
 For all those countries with whom we are failing to compete invest more in education, in science and training than we do. 
 Our aim is nothing less than than to make Britain the best trained and educated nation in Europe.&equo; 
 Speaking the day after Neil Kinnock depicted education and training as the commanding heights of every modern economy, Mr Straw insisted: &bquo;We do not believe in the best for the few, but the best for all. 
 In education, quality and equality must go hand in hand.&equo; 
 Labour's plans include a programme to provide nursery education to the parent of every child aged three or four who wants it and a doubling of the proportion of young people aged 16 to 18 in full-time education and high quality training within a decade. 
 They also promise a &bquo;return to learn&equo; entitlement of up to a year's full time education for people aged more than 50 and who left school at 15 or earlier. 
 Mr Straw said: &bquo;The Government says it wants an expansion of higher education. 
 But by the introduction of student loans, and the end of free tuition, it will make entry into higher education dependent more than ever on the size of a parent's bank balance. 
 It's private schools today. 
 It will be private universities tomorrow.&equo; 
 Tory policies had brought only teacher shortages and administrative chaos. 
 Its use of public money to set up a network of city technology colleges in joint ventures with businesses mocked the needs of the majority of children. 
 Up to 10 times more taxpayers' money was being invested in a single CTC than in all the county schools in the surrounding area, he said. 
 &bquo;No government which cared for the education of all our children would conceivably follow such corrupt priorities as this one.&equo; 
 Rodney Bickerstaffe, general secretary of the public employees' union Nupe, said that local management of schools, giving schools control over their own budgets would mean less money for education. 
 &bquo;Local management of schools has done to education what opted-out hospitals has done for the NHS. 
 Our schools will be filthy because of cuts in hours of non-teaching staff.&equo; 
 Eileen Lindley, of Doncaster, criticised the Labour leadership's intention to extend the national curriculum into the private sector. 
 &bquo;There should not be any private schools. 
 Labour has to create a state system which is so good that no one will want to send their children anywhere else.&equo; 
 Promises to establish Muslim schools could land a future Labour government with a problem as potentially explosive and insoluble as the Irish question, Neil Fletcher, Labour leader of the Inner London Education Authority, said yesterday at a conference fringe meeting. 
 The party's policy review paper says Muslims and other minority religious Home groups should be entitled to voluntary-aided schools provided they follow the national curriculum. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Left-right tension shows in debate on employment law 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT and STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 CRITICAL decisions on how employment laws would operate under a Labour government will be left until after the general election, Michael Meacher, the shadow Employment Secretary, said yesterday. 
 A new policy adopted by the conference failed to define a &bquo;lawful trade dispute&equo; and which forms of secondary action would be allowed. 
 Mr Meacher said that such details would have to be worked out between ministers and their officials, but he is likely to be pressed to be more specific. 
 The party's new policy is that workers taking sympathy action would have to demonstrate a &bquo;genuine interest&equo; in any dispute. 
 A Labour government would have to define what that meant. 
 Norman Fowler, Secretary of State for Employment, is likely to exploit the differences already emerging yesterday between right and left-wing union leaders over how far the definition should go. 
 Jimmy Knapp, left-wing leader of the National union of Railwaymen believes that his members had a &bquo;genuine&equo; interest in the miners' strike because pit closures would mean fewer coal trains. 
 Bill Jordan, right-wing leader of the Amalgamated Engineering Union, however argued yesterday that secondary action should be limited to direct suppliers and direct customers. 
 Mr Meacher indicated that a Labour government would be likely to set up new industrial courts presided over by judges with experience in industrial relations and two lay &bquo;assessors&equo; &mdash; one employer and one trade unionist who would advise the judge. 
 The form of the system would be settled within the next three to six months he said. 
 Labour's new policy, overwhelmingly endorsed, draws on Conservative legislation by backing pre-strike ballots and the democratic election of union leaders. 
 It does not restore the immunities enjoyed before 1979, but it confirms the right to strike and gives strikers protection against dismissal. 
 The rights of union membership would also be guaranteed. 
 Following the experiences of the dockers in the summer, Labour will seek to limit the opportunity of employers to seek interlocutory injunctions to stop strikes which have been endorsed by lawful ballots. 
 Discussions will be held with the TUC to see if there should be a threshold of union membership after which recognition by employers would be automatic. 
 A composite motion seeking the right to &bquo;struggle without restriction&equo; and strike without ballots was decisively defeated. 
 Mr Meacher said provided there had been a majority ballot decision trade unions must have the full protection of the law to pursue a lawful trade dispute. 
 Labour was determined that no judge would be able to circumvent protections provided by Parliament by &bquo;inventing new torts or arbitrarily changing the definition of a trade dispute&equo;. 
 Ron Todd, general secretary of the Transport and General Workers' Union, said they found in this year's dock strike that some judges had changed little since the days of the Tolpuddle Martyrs or Taff Vale. 
 &bquo;The truth is, that whatever we had done, both the Tory laws and the procedures of the courts are totally biased against unions and working people.&equo; 
 He continued: &bquo;I am looking forward to the next Labour government throwing out the Tory anti-union laws and giving working people the protection that they need to conduct legitimate industrial action. 
 &bquo;The days must go when they can wake up a judge at dead of night, give him a drop of brandy, show him a headline from The Sun and get him to sign an injunction,&equo; Mr Todd said. 
 The debate revealed again the traditional animosity between the right-wing engineers and electricians unions and the left-wing miners' union. 
 Eric Hammond, the electricians leader, said the Labour Party could not afford to return to the Seventies of &bquo;mindless militancy&equo;. 
 Nor would rank and file trade unionists give up their rights to be ballotted on strike action and the appointment of officials, Mr Hammond said. 
 From the opposing camp, Arthur Scargill, president of the National Union of Mineworkers, was cheered when he likened the review report to In Place of Strife &mdash; the Wilson government's attempt to curb union power. 
 &bquo;As far as we are concerned, if nurses are in conflict with their employer - and they are the least-able section of our society to fight &mdash; it is incumbent upon workers to take a stand to support nurses and other workers.&equo; 
 Mr Scargill pointed out that the Polish union Solidarity, repeatedly praised from the rostrum, had not held a ballot before taking strike action. 
 To jeers and a shout of &bquo;Join the Tories!&equo;, 
 Mr Jordan, told the miners' leader: &bquo;The armies of mass pickets have been demobilised and the next Labour government must not call them up. 
 Because, Arthur, today's party is a party of law makers, not law breakers.&equo; 
 John Edmonds, general secretary of the GMB general union, said the trade union laws had been judged by the International Labour Organisation, a UN agency, to be in breach of international conventions on eight counts. 
 &bquo;Tory laws have put Britain in the dock alongside Chile and Korea and all those nasty dictatorships that everybody here despises,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That's industrial law in Britain today. 
 So let us have no talk of building on the existing legislation. 
 You cannot build a fair system on that stinking swamp of menace and malice and neglect. 
 The whole lot must be swept away.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Buy-back call on water firm land sales 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN and JUDY JONES 
 CONFERENCE delegates yesterday swept aside a warning from the party leadership and called for the next Labour government to take back into public ownership immediately land sold off by privatised water companies. 
 The party is committed to renationalising the water industry, but Syd Tierney, on behalf of the National Executive Committee, said it could not promise to buy back, &bquo;acre by acre&equo;, any land which is sold. 
 The demand, contained in a composite resolution passed on a show of hands during a debate on the environment, would cover land &bquo;of environmental value or of natural beauty&equo;. 
 John Cunningham, the party's environment spokesman, told the conference the public detested the notion of water privatisation. 
 &bquo;It goes against all common sense to take the most fundamental element of ecosystem, with the land and habitats it supports, and sell it off for profit, as the Tories are trying to do,&equo; he said. 
 The 500,000 acres of water authority land, much of it in national parks and areas of outstanding beauty, was &bquo;a massive inducement&equo; to the City to take over the industry. 
 &bquo;It is an invitation to asset stripping.&equo; 
 He told delegates the party's programme for improving and protecting the environment was founded on four principles &mdash; &bquo;a presumption against pollution; the principle that the polluter pays; precaution as the basis for all policy; and freedom of environmental information&equo;. 
 Declaring global warming, caused by the build up of carbon dioxide and other gases, to be &bquo;the most worrisome&equo; of all environmental threats, Dr Cunningham promised a major long-term programme of energy conservation. 
 &bquo;This implies intervention in the economy in a way that is anathema to the Tories.&equo; 
 But he said Labour did not agree that Britain could or should abandon development, either for itself or for the developing world. 
 &bquo;Improved economic performance is, on the contrary, a prerequisite to the solution of the problems we and they face. 
 To argue otherwise is to betray millions of people, to condemn them to squalor, poverty, disease, starvation and death. 
 &bquo;The problem for this Tory government is that their ideology is out of phase with the demands of ecology.&equo; 
 Successful policies had to be complementary to sound environmental practice. 
 &bquo;It demands intervention and planning, interference in the market &mdash; something we know this Prime Minister can never stomach.&equo; 
 Labour would create an independent environmental protection agency, appoint a &bquo;green&equo; minister, introduce new planning laws and give local authorities powers and resources to improve the environment in their area. 
 Judith Chegwidden, of Putney CLP, said a Labour government must be tough enough to face up to special interest groups and those, including herself, who had &bquo;dangerous consumerist tendencies and want to own motor cars in urban areas &mdash; cars that pour out pollution and make people's lives a misery&equo;. 
 John Prescott, Labour's transport spokesman, made a blistering attack on the Government's under-investment in rail, and promised that Labour's transport policies would be geared to preventing environmental damage. 
 While the Government's plans to double spending on roads were at odds with its proclaimed conversion to green issues, Labour's new policies recognised the need to drastically cut congestion and pollution from vehicle emissions. 
 &bquo;We have got to do a great deal more about restrictions on motor vehicles and give the cities back to the people. 
 After 10 years of the Government's ideological obsession with privatisation, deregulation and competition, and reduced financial support, we have a transport system which is the shabbiest, most expensive, most congested, most environmentally damaging and least safe of any economy,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Prescott, who was given a rousing reception after his election to Labour's national executive earlier this week, condemned Paul Channon, the former Secretary of State for Transport, for refusing to accept that government policies had played a part in the series of transport disasters that had occured over the last two years. 
 &bquo;Now we have got Cecil Parkinson, a kind of Paul Channon with a chin and a smile, Maggie's trouble-shooter.&equo; 
 But Mr Parkinson was more concerned with getting a cheer at a party conference than with implementing the policies the country needed, he said.. 
 Bill Morris, of the Transport and General Workers' Union, also blamed government neglect of public services for the tragedies at Lockerbie, Clapham and Zeebrugge. 
 Supporting Labour's blueprint for an integrated transport system, he said: &bquo;Never again must we see a Prime Minister chasing coffins and attending funerals because of a lack of proper investment in transport. 
 Labour must offer a real voice for our passengers.&equo; 
 Jimmy Knapp, general secretary of the National Union of Railwaymen, predicted that the Government's scheme for selling off British Rail would help to guarantee the defeat of the Tories at the next election. 
 &bquo;There is no doubt that in private ownership, services will take second place to the search for profit, and there will be horrendous operating problems,&equo; he said. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Leaked document &bquo;shows scope for price increases&equo; 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 SCOPE for sudden increases in water prices, spelt out in a document leaked to the Labour Party, will remove all effective protection from consumers when the industry is privatised, John Cunningham, the shadow Environment Secretary, said yesterday. 
 The Labour spokesman produced a leaked draft of the water prospectus, which contained details of the mechanism for passing unforeseen costs on to customers. 
 &bquo;The documents show that the companies will be able to go straight to the director general of water services for extra price increases,&equo; he told the conference. 
 The &bquo;cost pass-through&equo; mechanism is designed to override the five yearly profit limits set by the director general, called the K-factor. 
 Dr Cunningham said this meant prices would rise &bquo;for the slightest reason. 
 . Consumers will pay and shareholders will be protected&equo;. 
 The document, released to reporters at a press conference, catalogued the unforeseen &bquo;changes of circumstances&equo; that could warrant additional price rises. 
 It cited legislation affecting the water industry, and EC regulations and decisions. 
 Ann Taylor, a Labour environment spokeswoman, claimed this meant consumers would be forced to pay for new sewage works if the European Commission banned the dumping of raw sewage at sea. 
 At one point, the prospectus states: &bquo;A Water Service Company may at any time require the Director General to determine whether, and if so how, K should be changed where other circumstances which would not have been avoided by prudent management action, have a substantial adverse effect on its water or sewerage business.&equo; 
 Dr Cunningham told the press conference: &bquo;There is virtually no protection for water consumers in these proposals at all.&equo; 
 The draft prospectus was accompanied by balance sheets for the water authorities projecting their finances 10 years ahead. 
 He told Labour delegates, &bquo;Over the next 10 years the water authorities are looking to pay out about five and a half billion pounds in dividends alone. 
 You can add to that an extra billion to pay for the interest in their borrowing. 
 That's seven billion pounds consumers are going to have to find.&equo; 
 However, Chris Patten, the Secretary of State for the Environment, said the proposals for passing unforeseen costs on to consumers were well-known and accused Dr Cunningham of whipping up unjustified concern. 
 And an Environment Department source insisted that the balance sheets were merely working assumptions used to calculate the initial ceiling on water company profits. 
 The projected dividends were not intended to be a forecast. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Policies approved 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 The conference approved the People at Work policy review which proposes: Replacing Tory trade union legislation with positive rights. 
 A change in the law to allow &bquo;sympathetic&equo; action. 
 Review the use by employers of interim injunctions to stop disputes. 
 Restoration of trade union immunity for certain kinds of secondary action. 
 Change in the law to stop sequestration of all a union's assets by the courts. 
 A Charter of Rights for Employees, including making it unlawful to dismiss an employee for industrial action. 
 A big expansion of child-care facilities, and full-time rights for part-time workers. 
 The conference approved the Physical and Social Environment policy review which proposes: A Ministry of Environmental Protection and an independent Environment Protection Executive. 
 A Wildlife and Countryside Service. 
 A Food Standards Agency to take responsibility for food hygiene and safety. 
 A Clean Water Act A &bquo;polluter pays&equo; principle and a ban on import and export of all toxic wastes. 
 A major housing programme. 
 A Freedom of Information Act Today the conference will debate health and care in the community; local government and the poll tax; the policy review group report Democracy for the Individual and Community; constitutional reforms; law and criminal justice; funding for political parties; Northern Ireland. 
 The Labour Party Conference: &bquo;Sun&equo; photograph criticised 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 A photograph on the front page of The Sun newspaper claiming to show three Labour Party delegates asleep during Neil Kinnock's keynote speech was criticised yesterday. 
 Derek Gladwyn, chairman of the conference arrangement committee, said: &bquo;The people photographed were not delegates at all.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Caustic Skinner sees no future for nice people 
 By JOHN PIENAAAR 
 THE POLICY overhaul was running smoothly and the conference looked like an adman's dream. 
 However, the chairman of the Labour Party was somehow managing to keep his spirits up. 
 &bquo;It could be another two years before the election,&equo; Dennis Skinner reflected between stultifyingly cordial debates, &bquo;and if it is, there is going to be a lot of water flowing under political bridges. 
 &bquo;The thinking is that everyone should be placid and passive, as if you can creep up to the polls in carpet slippers. 
 It won't work. 
 We are all supposed to look like nice people, with nice habits. 
 There's a song about that.&equo; 
 And just to prove it, he crooned out a few bars in an impressively melodious baritone: &bquo;Nice people with nice habits, and got no money at all.&equo; 
 The left-wing MP for Bolsover's term as party chairman ends tomorrow, but no one believes that this will lower the profile of one of Labour's most colourful and respected figures. 
 Down in the foyer, the audio tape of Mr Skinner's chairman's address to conference was already outselling every other cassette. 
 And descending from the dizzy heights of Labour's megalithic conference platform, he was as caustic as ever of the slick political selling job it symbolised. 
 &bquo;It gets bigger and bigger every year. 
 Now it looks like a scene set from Beau Geste, or one of those biblical epics. 
 We are the extras.&equo; 
 This week, as usual, he was scorning the attractions of Brighton's restaurants and plush hotel bars. 
 The option of a room at the five-star Grand Hotel was turned down in favour of bed and breakfast in St George's Terrace. 
 &bquo;When it comes to 12.45 I go behind the Ben Hur scenery and have a sandwich. 
 That's it. 
 I have never sat down and been waited on hand and foot, ever.&equo; 
 Despite his busy schedule, he made time to visit the conference &bquo;Geordie night&equo; &mdash; a gathering of north eastern MPs and activists &mdash; and was to be found one evening at the Brighton Trade Union and Labour Club with his friend Michael Elliot, a political comedian with whom he toured the coalfields during the 1984-85 pits strike. 
 In the hall, he has been making his accustomed mark from the chair. 
 More than once, right-wing union leaders have been left fuming in their seats as a stream of party activists were called to the rostrum. 
 A highlight of his week was the speech attacking nuclear power by Arthur Scargill ('a real professional'). 
 A low point was the removal of Ken Livingstone from the NEC. 
 But he perked up quickly and promised: &bquo;We will keep up the argument.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Conference quotes 
 By JOHN PIENAAAR 
 &bquo;Concern for the environment has always topped (our) agenda.&equo; 
 Syd Tierney, NEC member &bquo;The days must go when they can wake a judge at dead of night, give him a drop of brandy, show him a headline from The Sun, and get him to sign an injunction.&equo; 
 Ron Todd &bquo;If we are going to have a comedian as leader let's at least go for Dennis Skinner or Ben Elton.&equo; 
 Hard left pamphlet &bquo;You all sound so unhappy; it's been the best week of my life.&equo; 
 Eric Hammond, EETPU &bquo;Today's party is a party of law-makers, not law-breakers.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Less priority given to NHS spending plans 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correspondent 
 SPENDING ON some areas of the National Health Service could be downgraded in Labour's list of priorities as a result of the leadership's determination to make the productive economy the centrepiece of the party's programme for government. 
 Labour is certain to retain its commitment to spend more on the health service with a promise to restore the resources to the hospital sector it has lost in real terms since being in office. 
 But it has has dropped the commitment to increase NHS spending by 3 per cent a year in real terms on which it fought the 1987 general election. 
 Robin Cook, Labour's spokesman on health, said he believed that commitment may turn out to be &bquo;too modest&equo; by the time of the next general election. 
 &bquo;What I will be looking for is a commitment that spending (on the NHS) will be a priority and that the money is there,&equo; he said. 
 Neil Kinnock, the Labour leader, set out education, transport, science and research as key priorities for the party's programme in government in his speech to the conference on Tuesday. 
 The aim is to build Labour's credibility by creating an economy which will sustain higher spending on its social programme. 
 Party leaders will work on identifying the priorities for Labour's first term of office over the next year. 
 Shadow Cabinet ministers yesterday appeared united behind the leadership's strategy, but it could involve some tough choices. 
 Mr Kinnock underlined his determination to adhere to a prudent expenditure programme in an interview on the BBC World at One programme yesterday. 
 He said: &bquo;It's a question of definitions of purpose of establishment in a tough fashion &mdash; it cannot be anything else &mdash; of priorities. 
 And then, very much closer to the election and possibly even after the election really seeing what the possibilities are given the economic context of the time.&equo; 
 The Labour leader added that the Treasury could not get its own estimates right. 
 For the Opposition to make guesses at costings would be aimless. 
 &bquo;It is better for us to say we are going to have to institute a series of strict priorities. 
 It is no use us trying to clobber the economy with high taxation any more than it's any use Lawson clobbering the economy with high interest rates&hellip; 
 Prudence is the hallmark. 
 Any ambitions we have have got to be within the terms of those realities.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Maxwell forced to run gauntlet 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 ROBERT MAXWELL, publisher of Mirror Newspapers, was last night forced to run an embarrassing Labour Party gauntlet of workers sacked at his Pergamon Press company last May. 
 His annual conference reception, at the plush Grand Hotel in Brighton, was marred by what he was reported to have described as a &bquo;media circus&equo; of camera crews and reporters as former employees protested at their treatment. 
 Earlier, two Labour MPs, Brian Sedgemore and Tony Banks, were escorted from the hotel by police in an attempt to prevent them presenting a petition on behalf of 23 Pergamon Press workers sacked for going on strike. 
 Mr Sedgemore was later allowed into the hotel to put the protesters' case to Mr Maxwell, and the MP said afterwards that the millionaire publisher &mdash; who he described as a distinguished socialist &mdash; had insisted that he would under no circumstances take back his former employees. 
 &bquo;In fact,&equo; Mr Sedgemore said &bquo;his actual words were: &bquo;Grass will grow on my hands before I consider their re-employment&equo;.' 
 When Mr Maxwell eventually came out of a hotel lift to attend his own reception, he crossed the hotel lobby and went down a corridor, followed by shouts of &bquo;scab&equo; and other abuse. 
 Asked if he felt embarrassed, Mr Maxwell said, &bquo;I am as keen as a lovely lady.&equo; 
 During conference debate on industrial law, Brenda Dean, general secretary of the print union Sogat, attacked Mr Maxwell over the treatment of over 100 workers at the Nuffield Press in Oxford who, she said, had to agree to individual contracts or be sacked at the end of the week. 
 They had been told their union was no longer recognised. 
 Inspectors of schools &bquo;poorly equipped for curriculum&equo; 
 By PETER WILBY 
 SCHOOL INSPECTORS employed by local authorities are poorly equipped for their future role of monitoring the national curriculum, a report from the Audit Commission for Local Authorities says today. 
 In some authorities, the inspectors &mdash; who are quite separate from Her Majesty's Inspectorate &mdash; spend as little as 3 per cent of their time on direct observation of classrooms. 
 Authorities often had little idea how inspectors were spending their time, the commission reports. 
 Howard Davies, the commission's controller, says that, as schools are given more financial and managerial independence over the next few years, authorities should monitor quality on behalf of ratepayers and parents, rather than pretending that all their schools are equally good. 
 He said: &bquo;If the crypto-market in education is going to work, parents will need hard information, rather than relying on gossip in the local pub. 
 I am not sure that many authorities appreciate this.&equo; 
 The commission's report is based on investigations in 20 local authorities and on postal surveys. 
 Many authorities have advisers rather than inspectors indicating a belief in a supportive, rather than judgemental, role. 
 There are 2,500 inspectors and advisers in England and Wales, costing &pound;65m a year or &pound;8.05 per pupil. 
 But the size and role of the inspectorate varies widely. 
 In Rotherham, for example, there is one inspector or adviser to every 106 teachers, against one to every 313 in Leeds. 
 In 63 out of 78 authorities in the postal survey, one or more subjects in the national curriculum do not have a specialist adviser. 
 Yet in 13 of the 63, music or physical education, or both, have more than one. 
 On average, 22 per cent of the inspectors' time is spent on inspection, including observation, recording and analysis. 
 The commission says: &bquo;Advice in total is taking too large a proportion of the effort, around three times as much as is spent on inspection.&equo; 
 It adds: &bquo;The major influences on the use of inspectors&equo; time appeared to be ad hoc requests both from institutions and from a variety of officers, and the personal professional interests of individual advisers.&equo; 
 New inspectors and advisers, who are usually drawn from the ranks of teachers, are rarely trained, it says. 
 Administrative support is inadequate, so that inspectors spend too much time on routine, low-level, clerical tasks. 
 The commission calculates that all authorities will need at least 17 inspectors to cover the national curriculum as well as major areas of education such as primary, secondary and special needs. 
 Assuring Quality in Education: The role of local education authority inspectors and advisers. 
 HMSO, price &pound;4.50. 
 Comprehensives opt to keep status quo 
 By NGAIO CREQUER, Education Correspondent 
 GOVERNORS at two linked comprehensive schools in Milton Keynes, Buckinghamshire, have voted unanimously to seek opting-out status because they fear moves to introduce selection and impose grammar schools. 
 The Stantonbury schools, popular community comprehensives with a total of 2,240 pupils, have two governing bodies. 
 Both voted to invoke the procedure by which a school seeks to become grant-maintained. 
 Second meetings, as required by law, have been fixed for next month. 
 If the applications are pursued, it would embarrass the Government. 
 The Tories proposed the idea of allowing schools to opt out to enable them to get away from &bquo;loony left'authorities. 
 Milton Keynes is the only division in Buckinghamshire which does not have selective education. 
 The governors fear that a move to set up a panel to consider the introduction of grammar schools threatens their status and stability. 
 Tory councillors attempted a similar move 18 months ago, but gave it up after a panel reported that any reorganisation would cause 10 years of disruption. 
 Peter Tinworth, chairman of the governing body of one school, and a Tory party member, said: &bquo;We want to protect the character of our school, which is very successful. 
 If grammar schools were introduced then the existing comprehensives would suffer.&equo; 
 Rosalind Wingrove, education committee chairman, said it had set up a panel to consider how best to consult parents. 
 The matter still has to go before the committee and the county council. 
 Two-tier criminal offence urged for computer hacking 
 From PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES in Strasbourg 
 MOVES to outlaw &bquo;hacking&equo; will not tackle sophisticated computer crime unless a line is drawn between amateur hackers and professional criminals, a lawyer said yesterday. 
 Mark Tantum, a senior lawyer at the Serious Fraud Office, told the International Bar Association conference in Strasbourg that a bank robber who turned from a mechanical to an electronic chainsaw to open the cash-box deserved different treatment from the hacker who simply accessed computer systems. 
 &bquo;A two-tier offence is crucial if professional criminals are to be deterred from entering this profitable area,&equo; he said. 
 The lower-tier offence should cover simple hacking and the other, hacking with intent to steal or damage. 
 The gravity of the second would be reflected in heavier sentences. 
 A two-tier system would justify the vast resources that were needed to support investigations into computer-assisted crimes. 
 Collecting evidence was an enormous task involving tracking communications from their source across networks to target computers. 
 Mr Tantum criticised a suggestion made by the Law Commission this year that hacking in its simple form should be an offence which did not give the police powers to arrest suspects or search their premises. 
 &bquo;Without those powers, hacking would be almost impossible to prove, short of a confession from the culprit. 
 Other countries seem to have recognised the need to give the police full investigative powers as well as treating hacking simpliciter as a relatively serious offence.&equo; 
 He hoped the commission changed its mind on both counts. 
 It will publish final recommendations to the Lord Chancellor next week. 
 Describing English rules of admissibility of computer-related evidence as a nightmare, Mr Tantum warned that any new crime would be difficult to prove. 
 The rules mean that police would have to take control of the computer as soon as possible after the offence and establish that it was working properly at all times. 
 Fathers and other family members who admit they have sexually abused children in the home should not have to face criminal prosecution, the conference was told. 
 Caroline Willbourne, a London barrister specialising in family law, said decriminalisation of sexual offences within the family where the offender admitted the abuse was in the interests of child victims. 
 Court proceedings should be of a civil rather than criminal nature, she said. 
 &bquo;You often find the civil court has dealt with the abuse and the perpetrator in the context of what is in the best interests of the child.&equo; 
 But she added that prosecution and imprisonment by a criminal court did not serve the interests of the family as a whole, or of the child who remained part of it, or how victims would deal with contact with the abuser after release. 
 Ms Willbourne also called for the civil courts to be given new powers to exclude an abuser from the home instead of the child. 
 The Ukrainain State Dancers start nationwide tour 
 From PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES in Strasbourg 
 Members of the Ukrainian State Dancers, founded 50 years ago, display their skills before the start of their first British nationwide tour in 10 years. 
 They open tonight at Chichester Festival Theatre, West Sussex, the first of 20 engagements between Aberdeen and Paignton, and give their final performance in Cardiff on 30 November  
 Du Maurier will 
 Home News Page 6 
 Business plan 
 From PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES in Strasbourg 
 Labour-controlled Kirklees council, West Yorkshire, is reorganising its bureaucracy on commercial lines, with an executive board of directors and bonus incentives. 
 The council, which includes Huddersfield and Dewsbury, is making five departmental directors and the assistant chief executive redundant. 
 Prince's cash 
 From PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES in Strasbourg 
 The Prince of Wales is to help to fund a &pound;5m inner city regeneration project in Birmingham. 
 The Duchy of Cornwall is investing &pound;2.5m in the scheme to build 79 small business workshops in the Jewellery Quarter. 
 The money will be added to a &pound;934,000 Department of the Environment grant and &pound;1.6m from the city council. 
 Pilot ditches jet after hitting ship 
 From PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES in Strasbourg 
 A Sea Harrier pilot ditched his aircraft in the English Channel after damaging a wing while attempting to land on the carrier HMS Ark Royal. 
 The pilot apparently hit its mast. 
 He flew to the Royal Naval Air Station at Yeovilton, but damage to the wing meant he was unable to land, so he flew to open sea, put the plane in a nosedive and ejected. 
 The pilot was rescued by helicopter. 
 Man shot dead after party 
 From PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES in Strasbourg 
 A 19-year-old man died after being shot in the head in a north London street as his girlfriend and two-year-old daughter looked on, police said yesterday. 
 Alton Lawrence was shot soon after leaving a family birthday party on Tuesday night. 
 Scotland Yard want to hear from anyone who saw the shooting in Nevill Road, Stoke Newington. 
 &bquo;Nightmare&equo; of Ripper wife 
 By JAMES DALRYMPLE 
 SONIA SUTCLIFFE was upset by the fact that Private Eye called her Rowenta Ripper, or simply Mrs Ripper, the Court of Appeal was told yesterday. 
 On the second day of the magazine's appeal for a retrial of the libel action in which Mrs Sutclife was awarded &pound;600,000, Geoffrey Shaw, her counsel, said: &bquo;This woman has undergone more stress since 1981 than any of us are every likely to undergo. 
 &bquo;This was the wife of Peter Sutcliffe, who woke to a nightmare in January, 1981, and it was a nightmare that never went away.&equo; 
 The jury that awarded her &pound;600,000 may also have thought she had suffered enough in her life, he said. 
 Earlier, Mr Shaw had asked Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, to order photographers not to pursue or harass Mrs Sutcliffe outside the court. 
 &bquo;She doesn't want such photographs taken because she would not feel safe on the streets,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Shaw said that a jury's task in awarding damages would be very difficult: &bquo;It is probably a unique case, with a unique plaintiff, whom they probably felt shouldn't be made to suffer any more. 
 It was probable that with a type of aggravated libel, and a defence that was blatantly bogus and came apart during the trial, they decided to add a nought to the amount of damages.&equo; 
 Lord Donaldson asked if he was seriously suggesting that juries would multiply the award by 10 times. 
 Mr Shaw answered: &bquo;But they do, my lord. 
 And it can be seen&hellip; in recent libel awards.&equo; 
 &bquo;There must come a time when it is called to a halt,&equo; Lord Donaldson said. 
 Earlier, Lord Donaldson had commented that the &pound;600,000 would give Mrs Sutcliffe a permanent income of some &pound;60,000 a year for life &mdash; and when she died the &pound;600,000 would still be intact. 
 &bquo;This a pension of &pound;60,000 plus &pound;600,000 at the end &mdash; is it really possible?&equo; he asked. 
 Blood cholesterol filter to be given clinical trials 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 A TREATMENT to filter excess cholesterol out of blood is to begin clinical trials in Cardiff and London. 
 The technique, apheresis, involves passing blood from the patient through two filters. 
 One removes the red blood cells, leaving the plasma; the second removes the fatty cholesterol. 
 The blood cells and plasma are then remixed and returned to the patient, who is conscious throughout. 
 The procedure takes between two and three hours. 
 When apheresis is used in combination with the new drug simvastin, it can reduce cholesterol levels by up to 75 per cent. 
 It costs about &pound;600 a treatment and has to be done every two weeks. 
 People with high levels of blood cholesterol are at an increased risk of a heart attack. 
 Doctors at Leicester Royal Infirmary are to assess the benefits of giving magnesium to heart attack victims immediately after an attack. 
 Magnesium is thought to affect the heart muscle. 
 Preliminary research suggests that this can improve their chances of recovery, and a four-year study with 2,500 patients is under way. 
 Prince to invest 2.5m pounds in city's jewellery centre 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 (First Edition) THE Prince of Wales is to help to fund a &pound;5m inner city regeneration project aimed at transforming a derelict area of Birmingham into a small business centre. 
 The Duchy of Cornwall is investing &pound;2.5m in the scheme to build 79 small business workshops in the city's Jewellery Quarter. 
 It is the first time that Prince Charles has given direct financial help to a run-down urban area, and the Duchy has been granted a 125-year lease on the 0.6 acre site. 
 The Duchy's investment will be added to a &pound;934,000 grant from the Department of the Environment and &pound;1.6m from Birmingham City Council. 
 Work on the Jewellery Business Centre, which is expected to create more than 250 jobs, is due to begin next February. 
 David Landale, Duchy secretary, said there were numerous requests for help, but the Birmingham project &bquo;caught the Prince's imagination&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;This will be the pattern for future similar investments, and because it is a welding together of all those strands of interest which the Prince of Wales has, we consider it to be a very exciting new venture.&equo; 
 ILEA leader warns of sectarian conflict 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 (First Edition) PROMISES to establish Muslim schools could land a future Labour government with a problem as potentially explosive and insoluble as the Irish question, Neil Fletcher, Labour leader of the Inner London Education Authority, said yesterday. 
 Separate schools for children of different religions would lead to segregation and sectarian conflict similar to that in Northern Ireland, Mr Fletcher said. 
 Labour was in danger of backing &bquo;the mullahs and the bigots&equo;. 
 The party's policy review has said that Muslims and other minority religious groups should be entitled to voluntary-aided schools (for which nearly all the costs come from public funds) provided they follow the national curriculum. 
 At present, only the Christian churches and the Jews have voluntary-aided schools. 
 At a fringe meeting at the Labour conference in Brighton, Mr Fletcher named three MPs who, he said, backed Muslim schools because their constituencies had &bquo;been manipulated by unrepresentative fundamentalists&equo;: Jack Straw (Blackburn), the education spokesman; Roy Hattersley (Birmingham Sparkbrook), the deputy leader; and Ken Livingstone (Brent East). 
 He said: &bquo;How would a political party as totally committed as the Labour Party to equality of treatment and of opportunity for girls and women, lend its support to the introduction of schools in which men exercise all the power, and women are assigned a subordinate and restricted role?&equo; 
 Patten turns down Foxley Wood plan for &bquo;instant town&equo;: The decision to halt a scheme for 4,800 houses signals a shift in government policy, Richard North reports 
 By RICHARD NORTH 
 CHRIS PATTEN, the Secretary of State for the Environment, yesterday announced that he was overturning his predecessor Nicholas Ridley's &bquo;mindedness&equo; to allow an instant, private new town to be built on the Berkshire/Hampshire borders, south-east of Wokingham. 
 In a decision which was widely predicted, Mr Patten has declared himself minded to uphold the view of the department's inspectorate that Consortium Developments, representing several of the country's major home-builders, had not made a sufficiently strong case for the development of 4,800 houses in what is an abandoned quarry and a conifer plantation. 
 Explaining a new policy drift which will respect local political will at the expense of new development, Mr Patten said: &bquo;Over the next 10 or 12 years we are going to need substantial numbers of new houses. 
 At the same time we can expect people's interest in green issues and concern for their local environment to grow.&equo; 
 The decision is part of a much wider shift in government thinking, in which Mr Patten has clearly been given Cabinet permission to distance his own policy from that of predecessors, such as Michael Heseltine, and, to a lesser extent, Mr Ridley, now Trade and Industry Secretary, who believed that economic success depended on getting the planner off the backs of business and citizen alike. 
 Mr Patten yesterday issued a draft housing planning policy guidance note, which will update previous documents. 
 The new policy will drop, for the first time since its introduction in the early Eighties, a presumption in favour of house-building at the expense of other conservation considerations. 
 It reiterates a growing theme in government thinking: that if the local authorities would only firmly write their own development plans &mdash; as they are obliged to do, but which few have &mdash; then environment ministers would feel obliged to honour them. 
 Mr Ridley's &bquo;mindedness&equo; to allow Foxley Wood depended on his view that it was a sounder way of ensuring Hampshire's share of new housing in the South-east than the county's own thinking, which assumed finding dozens of smaller sites. 
 The new decision does not let Hampshire off the hook &mdash; the county must still find room for 66,500 new homes &mdash; but it accedes to the county's own view that it can find the space more sensibly outside the north-east or central parts of the county. 
 Dudley Keep, chairman of Hampshire County Council's planning committee, described Mr Patten's move as &bquo;a victory for people power&equo;. 
 He said: &bquo;We are absolutely delighted. 
 The new Secretary of State has recognised what we said all along should be the right and reasonable level of development in Hampshire. 
 It is also important that he has endorsed the county council's structure plan.&equo; 
 But Lord Northfield, chairman of Consortium Developments, said: &bquo;Foxley Wood is not going to go away&hellip; 
 A new settlement is going to be needed. 
 How many green fields will the county use, instead of our gravel working? 
 &bquo;This is a fudge rushed out to win cheers and adulation at the Conservative Party conference. 
 But the hard decision about how housing in Hampshire is to be provided has been weakly postponed,&equo; he added. 
 Fiendishly complicated balancing act that demands a subtle mind 
 By RICHARD NORTH 
 CHRIS PATTEN'S decision is not quite the fudge that Lord Northfield, the developers' chairman, called it yesterday. 
 Certainly, Mr Patten, a Roman Catholic, ought to be able to appreciate casuistry. 
 But the decision is not quite that either. 
 It is, rather, the example of what a robust and subtle mind can do when it comes to shifting British planning policy around the table a bit. 
 No other sort of mind is up to the demands of the system, which needs to seem to have judicial impartiality and a rocklike permanance while also being quickly responsive to the latest political fads. 
 Green has overtaken growth as the leading &bquo;g&equo; force in government thinking. 
 The planning system is designed to provide the reliable, long-term rules by which citizens know their surroundings, and house values, are not going to be altered by sudden development. 
 But it also has to provide the means by which a modern society provides houses and gardens &mdash; which the British love &mdash; where once they huddled in two-up-two-downs and the spec-built terraces which pre-dated the loathed Sixties &bquo;slums in the skies&equo;. 
 A decade ago, planning ministers were writing policy which said that houses must be built where the market wanted them, and quick. 
 Mr Heseltine, its chief architect, was one of the first to dump it, especially when he fought the proposal of Consortium Development to build a town whose name was as instant an invention as its community would have been: Stone Bassett, like Consortium's Tillingham Hall before it, was turned down by Mr Ridley, who was not the permissive planning minister he was often thought to be. 
 Mr Patten's new policy guidance does not say the South-east's housing provision can be held static, and it reminds planners that their job is to provide an adequate flow of land into new housing. 
 He believes that about a million new households will form in the South-east by 2001, most of them the sons and daughters and new elderly of the region itself. 
 He said yesterday that the share of urban land in the South-east would grow by about 1 per cent, at the expense of rural land. 
 Mr Patten also said that he believed in the validity of the present system for predicting what housing needs will be. 
 It is a fiendishly complicated negotiation between demographers and planners at local, regional and national level. 
 To that extent, he is going along with the orthodoxy, and not disturbing the papal infallibility of his predecessors and the process they have established. 
 But his latest &bquo;papal bull&equo; &mdash; that is what planning guidance notes are, announcing changes and yet stressing tradition as they do &mdash; emphasises that &bquo;town cramming&equo; is to be frowned on. 
 This is the process whereby every scrap of green land in a town is up for grabs by development. 
 Contradictorily, Mr Patten also declared himself in favour of seeing urban land recycled &mdash; it already provides nearly half the land used for new homes. 
 Yet only weeks ago he was saying that existing derelict land was needed for greening the cities, and providing amenities for citizens. 
 All the same, the Foxley Wood decision can be seen as sound enough. 
 Hampshire said it did not want to duck its share of the South-east's demand for housing, but would find land enough in the south of the county in preference to development nearer London. 
 Mr Patten spent much of yesterday emphasising that he wanted to respect local decisions, and that once the regions and his department had worked out overall allocations, it was for local electorates to decide where they put the bricks and mortar. 
 However, there are planning experts who say Hampshire has been adept at arguing down what its proper share should be. 
 Quite likely, within a year or two, it will be told to increase its share. 
 When it does that, Foxley Wood might be in the frame again. 
 Or perhaps the Government may decide that the provision of cheap houses to its young supporters in the South-east is not as important as holding the thin green line, while cultivating the older guard. 
 That is the drift of policy announced yesterday. 
 Move brings mixed reactions 
 By RICHARD NORTH 
 OPINIONS were mixed on yesterday's announcement that Chris Patten does not want Foxley Wood to proceed. 
 Peter Cole, chairman of Bramshill Parish Council, in whose bailiwick the town would have fallen, said: &bquo;I might have an extra beer today, but I am saving the champagne for another 21 days. 
 &bquo;As things stand Mr Patten is minded to turn down the application, but there will be a 21-day stay of execution for appeals.&equo; 
 He said the parish, which has just 100 people on the electoral roll, would have been swamped by the new town. 
 Mr Cole said the area was used for horse-riding, was a haven for wildlife and people came from miles around on summer evenings to hear the nightjars. 
 Mr Patten said that he had not turned against the idea of any and all new towns: &bquo;So long as the location is right and so long as people can have real confidence that a decision in favour of a new settlement will relieve development pressures elsewhere, then new villages and new settlements could have a part to play in increasing the acceptability of new housing decisions.&equo; 
 He also rejected claims that he had corrected errors of judgement by Nicholas Ridley. 
 &bquo;Mr Ridley is not guilty of having made mistakes&hellip; the Tory party always has been, and will be, a green party.&equo; 
 Richard Bates, senior planner for the Council for the Protection of Rural England, said it was clear Mr Patten was weighing the balance in favour of countryside protection. 
 But David Hall, director of the Town and Country Planning Association, described the decision as an abdication of Mr Patten's responsibilities as the minister also responsible for housing and regional planning. 
 &bquo;Without a regional programme of new settlements there will continue to be sprawl around old market towns and villages, a continuous free-for-all among the house builders, and an excess of appeals for the Secretary of State to consider.&equo; 
 Peer tells of horror at being branded as a war criminal 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 A PEER with a distinguished war record who became a Conservative minister, Warden of Winchester College and businessman, yesterday described to a High Court jury his horror when he realised a pamphlet described him as a war criminal. 
 Lord Aldington was taking the witness stand on the third day of his libel action against the historian Count Nikolai Tolstoy and Nigel Watts, a property developer, who circulated a pamphlet describing him as responsible for repatriating 70,000 Yugoslavs and Russian Cossacks to be massacred by the communists in 1945. 
 The defendants maintain that their allegations are true. 
 Asked how he reacted to the distribution of 10,000 copies of the pamphlet to Winchester parents, staff, old boys, MPs, peers and the Press, Lord Aldington said: &bquo;Horror. 
 Horror that anybody should actually think these things about me or indeed anybody else. 
 &bquo;Absolute horror, and then recognition that it had gone to the parents at the school for which I was responsible, and that this would inevitably result in the headmaster being approached by some parents objecting to having their child in a school with a warden like this. 
 &bquo;I decided that I had to put the headmaster in a position to answer and it was this problem that worried me most &mdash; more than the outrageous charges against myself and the effect on my family. 
 The only way I could show that in my opinion they were absolutely wrong was to start an action for libel.&equo; 
 Earlier Lord Aldington had been asked by his counsel, Charles Gray QC, about his war exploits as Brigadier Toby Lowe. 
 He was awarded the DSO and the military CBE by the British, the Croix de Guerre by the French and made a Commander of the Legion of Merit by the Americans. 
 Lord Aldington, 75, a frail and stooping figure, was allowed to give his evidence while seated. 
 His first action had been in Greece in late 1940: &bquo;We soon went to the border, and the Germans invaded from Bulgaria and Yugoslavia which they had romped through. 
 &bquo;I fought a number of battles but for the last 10 days before we left, because things didn't go too well, I was commanding the rearguard on the Aegean Sea.&equo; 
 He then spent between three and four weeks in Crete before moving, just after the German parachute invasion began, to Egypt. 
 &bquo;I was in the desert from 4 July until just after I was captured and escaped in May 1942,&equo; he told the court. 
 &bquo;I was captured in Rommel's last push. 
 There was chaos. 
 It was a very fluid, much like a naval war. 
 We were overrun by two German Panzer divisions. 
 &bquo;They kept us in a marshalling area surrounded by tanks being repaired. 
 Some British armoured cars came and began shooting from a distance, and in the chaos I shouted out to four or five brother officers and we drove off in a truck. 
 We were fired at but not hit.&equo; 
 He had then fought from Tripoli to Tunis and in July 1943 was shipped with Montgomery's Eighth Army to Sicily. 
 In September they had invaded the toe of Italy. 
 They encountered fierce resistance as they fought their way up to Austria for two years. 
 The fighting had stopped on 29 April 1945, and he had spent 11 days in Allied-occupied Austria, leaving on 22 May. 
 It was during this time that as a senior staff officer of V Corps he had been involved with some of the orders to repatriate the Russian and Yugoslav prisoners. 
 Mr Gray said the defendants accused the peer of having disobeyed an order issued by the Allied Forces HQ on 17 May 1945 known as the &bquo;Distone&equo; order. 
 This directed that a number of Czechs and dissident Yugoslavs, who had infiltrated an area in Austria east of that covered by the Allied V Corps, should be treated as disarmed enemy troops and evacuated to British concentration camps in Italy. 
 An earlier order the same day, known as the &bquo;Robertson&equo; order, had ordered the repatriation of all Russians and Yugoslavs in V Corps' area. 
 Mr Gray said the Distone order had not been to V Corps, but to the neighbouring XIII Corps, and Lord Aldington had been correct to follow the Robertson order. 
 Mr Gray read from the peer's service record showing he had left Austria on 22 May, before some of the crucial decisions about the repatriations were taken. 
 Richard Rampton QC, for Count Tolstoy, said he would be contesting this date. 
 Lord Aldington told the jury that the fate of many of those repatriated was awful. 
 &bquo;But in May 1945 I did not know that they would be killed and I did not know until Count Tolstoy drew it to my attention in 1979, 1980 and 1985. 
 &bquo;It was quite appalling and, had we known it was going to happen, I'm certain we would have found a different way of dealing with our problem.&equo; 
 The hearing continues today. 
 RAF technician preparing for Red Arrow display 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 Nigel Graham, an RAF technician, preparing a Red Arrow aerobatic display aircraft for a flight at RAF Scampton in Lincolnshire yesterday to mark the end of the team's 25th anniversary  
 Security forces judged in grades of disapproval: An Irish delegation is to discuss security leaks with Peter Brooke today. 
 David McKittrick considers the subtleties of the issues 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK 
 AS FAR AS Irish nationalists are concerned, the British security forces in Northern Ireland have never been in the running for prizes for popularity. 
 The 10 per cent or so of the population which votes for Sinn Fein appears to approve of, or at least to tolerate readily, the IRA's attempts to kill soldiers and policemen. 
 Non-violent nationalists condemn IRA actions but have traditional political reservations about the presence of the Army, and complain about security force policies, tactics, and the behaviour of individual troops and police officers. 
 Within this general picture of disapproval there are gradations. 
 The most unpopular of the security forces is the Ulster Defence Regiment, the locally-recruited and predominantly Protestant force. 
 Next, according to those who monitor the pattern of complaints, come certain regiments of the regular army; then the Army in general; and finally the Royal Ulster Constabulary. 
 Even when allowance is made for the authorities' claim that many complaints are made for propaganda, this pattern is well-established. 
 It helps to explain why the UDR is kept away from the toughest republican areas. 
 Among nationalist politicians, the main question on the UDR is whether the force should be abolished or whether, with radical changes, it could be rendered more acceptable to Catholics. 
 The UDR's low reputation among nationalists was reflected in the 1985 Anglo-Irish agreement, which looked forward to increasing the number of Catholics in the RUC but refrained from mentioning the UDR. 
 The communique which accompanied the agreement accepted the principle that, when the UDR and the Army came into contact with the public, a police officer should, whenever possible, be present. 
 That this objective has not been achieved continues to irritate Dublin. 
 When the current collusion controversy began, it was assumed that the bulk of the problem lay with the UDR. 
 Dublin regarded the revelations with dismay, but also saw them as an opportunity to renew and step up its criticisms of the regiment. 
 On 15 September, the Republic spent seven hours presenting its damning view of the UDR to Peter Brooke, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland. 
 But the pattern of leaks since then has complicated things for both the British and Irish. 
 It is now accepted that UDR members and RUC officers have been leaking to loyalists. 
 It is possible that Mr Brooke, or a successor, may begin to think in terms of reducing the UDR's role and size, and perhaps even phasing it out. 
 No such options exist for the RUC. 
 It is the largest and most central of the security forces: the Army and UDR take their orders from it. 
 It has increased from 3,000 to almost 13,000. 
 Many nationalists also admit that the RUC has shown improvement, while the UDR has not. 
 Dublin is uncomfortably aware of this. 
 On one level the Republic often criticises the northern security forces, but it too relies on the RUC: the Garda co-operate with the northern police force and do not, as a matter of policy, deal with either the Army or the UDR. 
 It also, more generally, looks to the RUC as the force most concerned with combating the IRA. 
 For this reason, Dublin's instinct will be to concentrate complaints on the UDR. 
 The police will not escape criticism, but this will tend to be softened by the unacknowledged consensus that the RUC is essential to the security approach of both governments. 
 IRA gunmen kill wrong man in street attack 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK 
 THE IRA in Belfast yesterday shot the wrong man when they killed a laboratory analyst, writes David McKittrick. 
 The organisation claimed he was a Catholic who had been involved with the Army, the Royal Ulster Constabulary and loyalist terrorists. 
 But the RUC said last night: &bquo;The victim of this foul murder was an entirely innocent man who was on his way to work. 
 No explanation by the IRA can take away from that fact.&equo; 
 The man shot outside a north Belfast school at breakfast time was James Henry Babbington, 52, a Catholic. 
 He was walking along a quiet street when gunmen shot him several times in the head. 
 The IRA statement of responsibility had incorrectly named another man, the brother of a well-known Belfast republican, as the victim of the shooting, accusing him of having a bizarre paramilitary career stretching for more than a decade. 
 The intended target was last night believed to be in RUC protective custody. 
 The IRA claimed the man, although a Catholic, was a &bquo;hit man and intelligence officer&equo; for the extreme Protestant Ulster Freedom Fighters and had been involved in a number of gun attacks on nationalists and republicans. 
 It further alleged that he had been a &bquo;fifth columnist&equo; working for the Army in west Belfast in the 1970s, and had been given immunity by the RUC to carry a gun and carry out robberies. 
 A second man was later seriously wounded in another north Belfast incident. 
 A relative of the Sinn Fein councillor Alex Maskey, he was shot in an industrial estate at lunchtime. 
 Responsibility for the attack was later claimed by the loyalist Ulster Volunteer Force. 
 Tories face increasing pressure on poll tax 
 By COLIN HUGHES, Political Correspondent 
 MINISTERS HAVE failed to find a way of fending off Conservative Party conference pressure for extra funds to ease the introduction of the poll tax, it emerged yesterday. 
 Meetings between the Prime Minister; Chris Patten, the Secretary of State for the Environment; and Nigel Lawson, Chancellor of the Exchequer, have been unable to come up with an agreed solution to put to today's Cabinet. 
 It is now unlikely that a solution will be found in time for next Wednesday's debate on the poll tax at the Tory conference in Blackpool. 
 David Hunt, the Minister for Local Government, will be vulnerable to an angry reaction when he tries to answer the expected protest from the Tory grass-roots &mdash; and Tory councillors in particular. 
 Nine Conservative MPs from the right and left of the party, including three former ministers, met Mr Patten last night to press their case for additional funds. 
 They said afterwards that Mr Patten listened sympathetically but gave no specific response. 
 The leader of the MPs' delegation, Sir Rhodes Boyson, the former local government minister, said afterwards that they had asked for an extra &pound;650m to offset the sums which some local councils will have to raise in poll tax to the pay their contribution to the nation-wide poll tax safety net. 
 But it is clear the Treasury is holding out against providing substantial extra central funds, arguing it has no way of being sure that extra money will go into reducing the impact of the tax, rather than into increased spending. 
 Sir Rhodes urged Mr Patten to reduce poll tax levels in London by imposing a cap of &pound;300 per adult, and he asked for special help for those people living in low rateable value homes built between 1860 and 1930. 
 He said afterwards that he and his colleagues impressed on Mr Patten their fear that the tax could be a &bquo;poisoned chalice&equo; if it was not made attractive to voters. 
 He had not found a single Tory MP who disagreed with his efforts to ameliorate the introduction of the tax in England and Wales next April. 
 Policeman on M50 saw alleged killer, jury told 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 AN OFF-DUTY police inspector saw the alleged killer of Marie Wilks but dismissed him as a good Samaritan, the M50 murder trial was told yesterday. 
 Insp Peter Clarke told the jury that he drove past Mrs Wilks, who was pregnant, after he saw the man pull on to the hard shoulder, towards a telephone box where she was making an SOS call to police headquarters. 
 &bquo;My obvious reaction was that he had gone to help her,&equo; Mr Clarke, a community affairs officer who was travelling to police headquarters, said at Shrewsbury Crown Court. 
 &bquo;There was no reason for me to pull in.&equo; 
 The court has been told that, minutes later and in daylight, Mrs Wilks, 22, was abducted, then stabbed to death. 
 Her body was found two days later, at the bottom of a motorway embankment. 
 Her jugular had been severed. 
 She had left her son Mark, aged 13 months, with her sister, Georgina Gough, 11, in the broken down Marina car, while she walked the half-mile to the emergency telephone. 
 Edward Browning, 36, a nightclub bouncer, has denied murdering Mrs Wilks on 18 June last year. 
 She was killed on her way home to Warndon, Hereford and Worcester, after spending the day with her husband Adrian at a Territorial Army camp in the Forest of Dean. 
 Mr Browning, of Vicarage Road, Cwm-parc, Mid Glamorgan, is alleged to be the driver of a silver C-registration Renault 25 seen parked on the motorway at the time Mrs Wilks was killed. 
 Mr Clarke said that it was the children who first drew his attention. 
 &bquo;I saw a child walking along the hard shoulder and she was carrying another on her hip.&equo; 
 Cross-examined by John Griffith Williams QC, about why he did not stop for the children, he said that he was concerned not to hit them and instinctively moved away into the fast lane. 
 &bquo;Was it not an instinctive reaction to break and see if you could help them, just in case you had to stop to do something about them?&equo; 
 Mr Williams asked. 
 &bquo;My concern was to keep away from them,&equo; Mr Clarke replied. 
 Mr Williams: &bquo;Although you did not, would you expect that some people seeing young children on the motorway would be so concerned as to slow down?&equo; 
 Mr Clarke: &bquo;I would expect that most would stop and offer assistance.&equo; 
 But, as he passed the children, he saw he was closing fast on a grey saloon car, which &bquo;appeared from nowhere&equo; in the fast lane, he added. 
 Mr Clarke said he assumed it had done a U-turn across the central reservation. 
 It accelerated and moved into the slow lane, as he passed. 
 He then noticed Mrs Wilks at the telephone box and, in his rear-view mirror, he saw that the grey saloon car had pulled on to the hard shoulder and was heading towards her. 
 Mr Clarke said that he commented to his wife: &bquo;That must be the reason why he came across. 
 He's come to help her.&equo; 
 Farmer's fight for bronzes hits setback 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 A SUFFOLK farmer trying to recover a hoard of Romano-British bronzes, which he claims were illicitly excavated from his land, has been told that the Office of Arts and Libraries cannot help him, writes Geraldine Norman. 
 John Browning, whose farm at Icklingham, near Bury St Edmunds, covers the site of a Roman villa, saw Charles Henderson, head of the office, yesterday. 
 He was told that the government department, with general responsibility for arts policy, has no means of helping him to reclaim the bronzes from the Ariadne Galleries in New York. 
 Mr Browning, who believes the bronzes were smuggled out of the country and later bought by the galleries, said that he felt he had been &bquo;led up the garden path&equo;. 
 Last July, when recovery of the bronzes was taken up with Richard Luce, Minister for the Arts, an MP was told that Britain &bquo;has existing channels for international co-operation to help trace stolen works of art&equo;. 
 However, it appears that there is no way of reclaiming stolen objects once they have been traced, largely because the UK has never ratified the 1970 Unesco convention on prohibiting the illicit export of cultural property. 
 Mr Browning said: &bquo;I shall now look for a lawyer to explore what the Ariadne Galleries are prepared to offer me.&equo; 
 Suffolk police have arrested six men on suspicion of involvement in the theft of the bronzes. 
 Deaf woman stabbed in flat 
 By JACK O'SULLIVAN 
 A DEAF woman with speech difficulties was stunned, sexually assaulted and stabbed repeatedly by a killer who got into the flat where she lived alone, a court was told yesterday. 
 Suzanne Greenhill, 20, had been blindfolded &mdash; depriving her of the last sense she could have used to identify the attacker &mdash; and her underwear had been stuffed in her mouth. 
 Her partially-clothed body was found in a pool of blood three days later by her finance, Anthony Wesson, 25, at her home in Tewkesbury Walk, Newport, Gwent, Cardiff Crown Court was told. 
 Philip Price QC, for the prosecution, said Mr Wesson, who is deaf, ran to a woman neighbour. 
 &bquo;She heard some sounds of howling. 
 He was on his knees outside the door of the flat with his hands encircling his head, making howling noises,&equo; he said. 
 Timothy Jack Robson, 28, a friend from schooldays who is also deaf, has denied murdering her on 28 June 1988. 
 A social worker is interpreting the proceedings for Mr Robson, a carpenter, who has speech difficulties. 
 His then wife, Tracy, told police he had returned unexpectedly early that evening to their home in Gaer Park Drive, Newport, Gwent, Cardiff Crown Court heard. 
 Mr Price said her statement described Mr Robson as having a swollen hand and scratches on his face. 
 He was shaking. 
 He had washed his bloodstained clothes, and the next day scrubbed blood from his trainers. 
 Fibres from the red acrylic jumper Mr Robson was allegedly wearing on the evening of the killing were found on Ms Greenhill's body, Mr Price said. 
 A stocking footprint in blood at her flat was consistent with the size and shape of Mr Robson's foot, he added. 
 Mr Robson had told his wife he had been scratched by a woman during a pub fight. 
 He had asked her not to tell the police. 
 Council &bquo;made deals after auditor intervened&equo; 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 HAMMERSMITH and Fulham Council in west London continued to take out options on the London money market even after the intervention of the district auditor, wrongly thinking that it was reducing its holdings, the High Court was told yesterday. 
 John Howell, for Anthony Hazell, the district auditor, said on the second day of a hearing into the legality of the council's &pound;6bn deals on the market: &bquo;The council sold 49 gilt options on the mistaken belief that it was reducing its exposure. 
 &bquo;It may be that those involved in the sale of gilt options did not realise that they actually increased the risk to which the council was exposed rather than reducing it.&equo; 
 The council should have stopped these dealings when the district auditor began to question their legality in the summer of 1988, but the new options were taken out between then and 23 February this year, when the council decided to cease making payments on the transactions. 
 During the 1987-88 and 1988-89 financial years, 592 deals were made with a notional value of about &pound;6.1bn. 
 Estimates of the council's losses vary between &pound;69m and &pound;406m, depending on how they are assessed and on interest rate movements. 
 Mr Howell said no legal opinion had been sought before entering into the transactions, although a council memo suggested that visits should be made to other local authorities. 
 &bquo;What you will note is strange about this, is that advice was not sought from the council's own solicitor,&equo; Mr Howell said. 
 Councillors were not kept informed of the deals either. 
 The first reference to them was contained in the Annual Borrowing Report dated 4 January 1988. 
 However, Mr Howell said &bquo;it gave no indication of the number of transactions arranged, the income and expenditure they had produced, the type of risks involved, the scale of any potential gains and the exposure to loss&equo;. 
 It was a brief paragraph under the heading &bquo;temporary investments&equo;. 
 A similar paragraph was contained in the subsequent year's report, but otherwise no information was given to council members about the deals. 
 The auditor is seeking to have the transactions declared unlawful because they were ultra vires &mdash; beyond the council's legal powers. 
 If he succeeeds, the council will be barred from paying the losses incurred on the transactions. 
 Five banks have been added as parties in the case. 
 John Chadwick QC, representing four of the banks, yesterday argued that they were innocent parties in these transactions. 
 He said: &bquo;The banks entered into these transactions in good faith.&equo; 
 The case continues today. 
 In Tuesday's report on the High Court case, the name of the fifth bank was wrongly given by the court as Mitsubishi Finance Corporation. 
 The correct name is Mitsubishi Finance International. 
 Extradition plea 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 Britain's longest-serving unconvicted prisoner, Lorrain Esme Osman, who has spent nearly four years in custody pending attempts by Hong Kong to extradite him on fraud charges, asked the High Court to rule that he was being held unlawfully. 
 The hearing is expected to last 10 days 
 Tamils arrive 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 Four Tamils who were deported to Sri Lanka more than 18 months ago arrived back at Gatwick Airport after a successful appeal from outside the country. 
 They will now renew their application for asylum. 
 Mother improves 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 Aisling Barnett, who had a liver transplant after a television appeal for a donor, showed the first signs of consciousness. 
 Her husband Colin noticed responsive movements in her hands and jaw as he continued a bedside vigil. 
 Hotel blaze 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 Four floors of a hotel development in central London were destroyed in a fire. 
 It took more than an hour to control the blaze at the former Langham Hotel. 
 No one was hurt. 
 Papers dumped 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 Police in Kent are investigating the discovery of a briefcase of Army training material found dumped outside the Intelligence Corps at Ashford. 
 An Army spokesman said the documents were of low classification and details of IRA activities in them were &bquo;purely fictitious&equo;. 
 Deal funerals 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 The last of the funerals took place in Deal, Kent, for the Royal Marines bandsmen killed in the IRA bombing. 
 Two separate services were held in the barracks church for five of the victims. 
 Party charge 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 A businessman who helped organise the weekend acid house party where violent scenes left 16 policemen injured appeared in court charged with riot. 
 David Lambert, 35, a video producer from Clapham, south London, was refused bail by magistrates at Reigate, Surrey. 
 The Department of the Environment said it was looking at the legal position of local authorities wanting to control parties. 
 Ford claim 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 Car workers' unions are today expected to demand a wage rise of at least 10 per cent for the Ford motor company's 31,000 hourly paid workers, when negotiations open in London. 
 Unions representing 12,000 Ford salaried employees have already lodged a claim for a &bquo;substantial&equo; rise. 
 Man dies in crash at rail crossing 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 One man died and another was critically injured when their car was hit by a train at an unmanned railway crossing. 
 The vehicle was shunted more than 200 yards down the line in the accident, which happened on the Halifax to Leeds line at Ducketts Crossing, West Yorkshire, at 4.45pm. 
 British Rail has launched an inquiry, but a spokesman said the alarm bells and gates appeared to be working properly. 
 Camera case man hunted 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 A police search is under way for a businessman accused of attempting to export a military camera to the Soviet Union after he failed to appear for committal proceedings at Rugby Magistrates Court. 
 Colin Gibbins was arrested this year by the customs authorities after they seized a high speed Imacon 790 camera, worth &pound;250,000, at Birmingham Airport. 
 Mr Gibbins, 46, of Drayton Leys, Rugby, broke a &pound;20,000 bail bond by failing to turn up in court on Tuesday. 
 The case was adjourned for five weeks. 
 Customs authorities confirmed that Mr Gibbins owns property in Moscow, but dismissed reports that he had gone abroad as speculation. 
 Health cash &bquo;crisis&equo; faces hospitals 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 INNER LONDON health authorities face a &pound;13m overspend this year, according to confidential figures compiled for London health authority chairmen. 
 The projected deficit, even after internal savings in some districts, comes amid signs of mounting pressure on NHS budgets in and around London from under-funding of pay awards, rising demand and the treatment of increasingly complex cases. 
 Queen Mary's Hospital at Sidcup has cancelled all waiting-list surgery for &bquo;at least&equo; five weeks after more patients than planned were treated in the first five months, producing a &pound;205,000 overspend on top of &pound;200,000 it has to find for under-funded pay awards and other pressures. 
 At St Bartholomew's Hospital, 75 beds have closed; Parkside Health Authority has closed a 20-bed ward it had just re-opened to try to tackle waiting lists; and proposals to close some beds at the London Hospital are expected to go next week to Tower Hamlets Health Authority, which faces a &pound;1.3m overspend. 
 Pressure on emergency services, rather than cash problems, has led to Whipps Cross Hospital in Waltham Forest closing for this week to all but the most urgent waiting-list cases. 
 According to the confidential figures, the 12 inner London authorities face an underlying deficit of almost &pound;30m this year, and have identified &pound;18m of savings. 
 The figures are due for revision before being put to David Mellor, Minister for Health, next month. 
 The Department of Health is understood to be highly sceptical. 
 But one health authority finance officer said it looked &bquo;inconceivable&equo; that the budget could be balanced without service cuts, in the winter or next year, unless extra cash was provided or health ministers allowed the deficit to be carried forward. 
 &bquo;We are getting hugely conflicting messages from the NHS management board. 
 On the one hand we are being told we must deal with the deficit, and on the other that we must not close things and rock the boat with the NHS White Paper around.&equo; 
 The document shows that, allowing for deficits carried forward to this year and other factors, and before this year's savings, Bloomsbury has to save &pound;8m to balance its budget, Lewisham &pound;6.6m, Riverside &pound;3.1m, Wandsworth &pound;2.8m, Hampstead &pound;1.4m, West Lambeth &pound;1.5m, with the rest, bar Greenwich, facing forecast deficits of at least &pound;1m. 
 A leak of an early draft of the White Paper on community care led to a clash yesterday between Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, and Harriet Harman, Labour's health spokesman. 
 The document says the new &bquo;enabling&equo; role of local authorities as purchasers and providers of services for the elderly, mentally ill and handicapped will mean greater use of private home helps and other services. 
 It showed the White Paper would be &bquo;a blueprint for privatisation&equo;, Ms Harman said, &bquo;with no protection for those who use the services&equo;. 
 Mr Clarke said social services departments would &bquo;use their own, voluntary or private provision, according to which they judge the best way of providing the best quality service&equo;. 
 Charge of rape on mentally handicapped girl dropped 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 A CHARGE of rape on a mentally handicapped girl was dropped yesterday after a judge ruled she could not give evidence against her alleged attacker. 
 The girl, now 16, was 14 at the time of the alleged incident. 
 A medical report estimated she had a mental age of seven years and nine months. 
 The charge of rape against Michael Richardson, a homeless, former fairground worker, was dropped after Judge Blofeld ruled in Norwich Crown Court that the girl could not be sworn in to give evidence. 
 Richardson, 37, who met the the girl while she was walking her dog beside the river near her home in King's Lynn, Norfolk, was given a 16-month sentence for having sex with a girl under 16, the legal age of consent. 
 Judge Blofeld said: &bquo;I am unhappy that an incident that requires a court hearing cannot have one.&equo; 
 Richardson, he added, had &bquo;set out to gratify himself casually&equo;. 
 The girl's mother was outraged by the ruling. 
 She said: &bquo;He has got away with less than two years in prison. 
 It is not fair. 
 We don't feel justice has been done.&equo; 
 The judge's ruling comes at a time when many legal experts are pressing for young children to be allowed to give evidence in court. 
 Maureen O'Hara, of the Children's Legal Centre, said: &bquo;The 1933 Children and Young Persons Act does not define an age when children are competent to give evidence, but case law has tended to set a figure of around seven or eight. 
 &bquo;We think that a girl with a mental age of seven years and nine months is quite capable of knowing when she has been raped.&equo; 
 The medical report shown to the court from the King's Lynn Health Authority on the girl's mental faculties assessed her on a variety of indicators, including mental arithmetic, reading ages, concepts, and spelling. 
 While she scored above eight on several factors, the judge was particularly concerned with her score of around six-years-old on the ability to answer questions. 
 An added problem in this case was that she was too old to give unsworn testimony. 
 David Cocks QC, chairman of the Criminal Bar Association, gave a speech on the subject earlier this week to the Bar conference. 
 He said yesterday: &bquo;The problem is that the law is artificial. 
 It relies on the physical age rather than the mental age.&equo; 
 A Home Office Advisory Working Group, chaired by Judge Pigot, on the question of children's evidence will report imminently and is expected to recommend that children as young as four or five should be allowed to give evidence if a judge rules that they are competent. 
 Mr Cocks said: &bquo;Some four or five-year-olds are perfectly able to give a coherent account of themselves, while some 16-year-olds cannot.&equo; 
 Safety data &bquo;kept from motorists&equo; 
 By ANDY GLINIECKI 
 DATA OF the sort released in Sweden, which warns that motorists are three times more likely to die in crashes in some makes of car, is kept from British drivers, the Consumers' Association says today. 
 The association's magazine Which? says that insurance companies and the Department of Transport collect accident details that could throw light on the cars which best protect their occupants, but this information is not made public. 
 Current regulations on safety are dismissed as &bquo;woefully inadequate&equo; and the association calls on drivers to boycott models if manufacturers fail to make safety a priority. 
 Which? has deduced from safety inspections over the past six years that models from Audi/VW, Saab, Vauxhall and Volvo are &bquo;clear leaders, showing an across-the-range application of thoughtful protective safety and design&equo;. 
 The single Mercedes tested was also &bquo;very good&equo;. 
 But it adds: &bquo;Six makers lag behind the mediocre majority &mdash; Citroen, Daihatsu, Hyundai, Skoda, Yugo and, by far the worst, Reliant with its Rialto.&equo; 
 The best small car was the five-door Vauxhall Nova 1.3L, while the best medium-sized car was the Volvo 360GLE. 
 The best large cars were the Audi 80E, the Saab 900, the VW Passat CL, and the Vauxhall Cavalier. 
 The best luxury car was the Saab 9000i. 
 Mike Bennett, Reliant Motor's marketing director, said: &bquo;We have no reason to believe the Rialto is less safe than any other lightweight vehicle.&equo; 
 Two die in tenement explosion 
 By MARK DOUGLAS HOME 
 A MAN and a woman died yesterday in a suspected gas explosion that destroyed a six-storey tenement block in the centre of Edinburgh, writes Mark Douglas Home. 
 Five other people &mdash; three of them women &mdash; were injured, including a man of 19 trapped for four hours. 
 Recue teams were planning to search the 50ft pile of rubble throughout the night and today. 
 Five people with addresses at the building had not been traced. 
 The woman victim was named as Nicola Marie Donnely, 21, a student of printing at Napier College in the city. 
 The dead man, aged 25 to 30, was not named. 
 Colin Cranston, deputy firemaster in the Lothian and Borders brigade, said late last night his team of 60 rescuers had uncovered two cellars where any survivors were likely to be. 
 There was no chance of survivors being found in other parts of the collapsed building. 
 &bquo;You have five storeys compressed into one. 
 Their chance would be diminishing as each hour goes by, but we have not reached the stage that we can confidently say there is nobody alive in that building.&equo; 
 The blast, at 7.25am, devastated the terraced building in Guthrie Street, causing all the internal floors and walls, and the entire back wall, to collapse. 
 The upper floors were private flats. 
 The ground floor and basement were the offices of an Edinburgh University student charity. 
 Rescue teams found four survivors soon after the explosion. 
 Two walked from the building, another was taken from a damaged building near by, and the fourth was found on top of the rubble underneath a bed. 
 Search operations had to be suspended temporarily at one stage while the roof was demolished because of the danger of it falling in. 
 A British Gas spokesman said investigations into the cause of the blast were continuing. 
 Police released a list of survivors: Henry Wyllie, 20, Helen Lawrie, 48, and Paula Gaunt, 28, were discharged from hospital after treatment; Dawn Howbridge, 19, and Martin Baptie, 19, were said to be satisfactory in hospital. 
 About 1,000 BP employees in Glasgow evacuated their offices for two hours yesterday after a pipe in the chilling plant of an air conditioning system broke loose, releasing gas into the building. 
 Speelman returns to battle 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 PLAY RESUMES today in the Pilkington Glass world chess championship semi-finals. 
 Jonathan Speelman will be grateful for yesterday's rest day, which gives him a chance to recover his equanimity after a depressing loss in the second game. 
 Speelman and Timman had agreed a draw on Tuesday night in their adjourned game from the first round. 
 Speelman with the white pieces has often been accused of having a rather wimpish opening repertoire, and on this occasion he gained nothing from the advantage of the first move. 
 Between moves 9 and 13, he adopted a convoluted plan that seemed only to tangle his own pieces. 
 He already stood worse when he overlooked Timman's clever 14th move, which forced the win of material. 
 Timman now leads 1 1/2 -1/. 
 The match is level, Karpov 1 Yusupov 1. 
 Safety at N-plant &bquo;breached&equo; 
 By TOM WILKIE, Science Editor 
 THE NUCLEAR installation inspectorate is to prosecute the Central Electricity Generating Board for two alleged breaches of safety regulations at the Dungeness B nuclear power station in Kent. 
 It is the first time the inspectorate has taken the board to court for an alleged lapse of safety. 
 In both cases the alleged safety violation concerns operators dropping nuclear components. 
 On 4 February this year, the station operators dropped a complete nuclear fuel assembly into the core of one of the reactors, putting the reactor out of commission. 
 It has still not been restarted. 
 The second alleged breach happened less than three weeks later where, as a result of actions by CEGB inspection team, a 2.5 tonne component was dropped 27 feet. 
 The inspectorate said the radiological consequences of both failures were negligible. 
 But the inspectorate is prosecuting to underline the importance that it attaches to nuclear workers following proper procedures. 
 The prosecution alleges that the CEGB is in breach of the Nuclear Installations Act 1965, which empowers the inspectorate to grant a licence to operators. 
 The inspectorate attaches mandatory conditions to the site licence - covering, for example, the need for maintenance to be carried out as specified in the maintenance instructions &mdash; and for inspections and tests also to be conducted in accordance with written procedures. 
 It is expected that the case will be heard at Folkestone Magistrates' Court in Kent on 16 November. 
 The maximum fine under the legislation is &pound;2,000 for each offence, although the magistrates may commit the cases for trial in the Crown Court which can impose an unlimited fine. 
 The prosecution over safety in an Advanced Gas-Cooled Reactor, reactors which form part of the electricity industry privatisation, will come as an extra embarrassment to the Government and will further dent City confidence in the value of the nuclear assets. 
 Ambulance disruption set to worsen 
 By TOM WILKIE, Science Editor 
 EMERGENCY ambulance services face serious deterioration from today as officers join the overtime ban amid calls to tighten industrial action. 
 Roger Poole, chief union negotiator, said there was a real risk of a major breakdown in the 999 service. 
 &bquo;Someone is going to get hurt. 
 That's bound to happen in a dispute like this,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Poole is to lead a delegation to Blackpool next week to see Kenneth Clarke, Secretary of State for Health, who will be attending the Tory conference. 
 The 3,500 ambulance control assistants and officers were due to start their action at midnight last night. 
 They are joining 19,000 ambulance crew members protesting against a 6.5 per cent pay offer. 
 Mr Poole said there was evidence that some ambulance workers in the shires had been breaching the ban at the request of managers. 
 &bquo;Now we're saying that there has to be a complete ban on overtime and that they should resist moral blackmail.&equo; 
 Obituary: Mark Dignam (CORRECTED) 
 By OSSIA TRILLING 
 Correction (published 10 October 1989) appended to this article. 
 MARK DIGNAM was one of England's foremost actors, both as a juvenile and as a character actor, ready to tackle anything going, from cameo to leading roles, an expert in the classics, above all Shakespeare, and a keen student of modern drama. 
 &bquo;I never went to drama school,&equo; he would say without a hint of regret, &bquo;but learnt my craft the hard way.&equo; 
 He entered the profession after an apprenticeship at the Jesuit college he attended in Sheffield, where his father, a salesman in steel, had moved from London with his young son. 
 Dignam used to joke about how his priestly teacher, a devotee of the classical drama, invariably cast him in the leading roles of Shakespeare's heroines, Portia, Juliet, and Ophelia among them. 
 He took lessons in elocution as an amateur actor from Rosalind Iden, Sir Donald Wolfit's wife and leading actress, at that time with the Sheffield Rep, which Dignam himself later joined. 
 Dignam must have had unusual stamina. 
 His entry in Who's Who in the Theatre is almost as long as Olivier's, if not longer. 
 He certainly enjoyed perfect health, helped, he claimed, by being a teetotaller and in later life a vegetarian. 
 He threw himself vigorously into the work in hand, and presented the aspect of one who did not know when to stop. 
 Up to his last days, he regularly walked his dogs, and was on the point of doing so on his usual route from his home &mdash; the oldest lived-in wooden house in London, built in 1483 &mdash; when he had his fatal fall. 
 All his adult life, Dignam had been one of the most involved defenders of the rights of actors. 
 He served intermittently on the Council of Equity and on its Executive Committee, from his election to both in 1941 until the day of his death. 
 In his eighties he was a recipient of his union's rarely given citation for &bquo;services to the acting profession&equo;. 
 He made his stage debut in 1930 in St Albans, his West End debut in Macbeth (as The Bleeding Sergeant) in 1932, and his New York debut, as Carson in Oscar Wilde, in 1938. 
 He had cut his teeth on Shakespeare with Ben Greet in 1931 and went on to enlarge his Shakespearian repertoire throughout the rest of his life. 
 I first saw him in a supporting role at the Croydon Rep in 1936, where another young actor, seven years his junior, by the name of William Devlin, who dared to tackle King Lear at about the same time. 
 Dignam then enrolled in Michael McOwan's company at the Westminster, appearing in Ibsen, Chekhov, O'Neill, Turgenev, Hamlet (the Ghost and the First Player), skilfully differentiating his performances without ever falling into idle routine. 
 For McOwan he played Justin O'Connell in Waste in 1937, the same Granville-Barker play to which he returned 48 years later, as Russell Blackborough, with the Royal Shakespeare Company. 
 He was in the Lilian Baylis 1937 season at the Old Vic and returned to the Westminster for Pygmalion, Richard III, and more O'Neill, including a memorable portrayal of the old Ephraim Cabot in Desire Under The Elms in 1940. 
 After four years in the Royal Artillery, Dignam was invalided out of the army and went straight to the Arts Theatre, where he was a delightfully tongue-in-cheek Shavian Angel and a foxy Claudius, proving Stanislavsky's adage, as Agrippa in the Anthony Quayle/Edith Evans Antony and Cleopatra, that there are &bquo;no small parts&equo;. 
 He went to the Edinburgh 1947 Festival in more Shakespeare. 
 Dignam's career blossomed in no uncertain manner. 
 At the Old Vic seasons at the New Theatre (now the Albery), he was the tetchy Cauchon in Saint Joan and Claudius with the company at Elsinore in 1950. 
 After more exposure in the West End, he spent three years at the Shakespeare Memorial Theatre, playing 12 large Shakespeare roles with distinction. 
 In 1969 he was Polonius in the Roundhouse, prior-to-Broadway, Hamlet, before returning to the RSC in 1972 and making his National Theatre debut in 1974. 
 From then until 1980 he commuted between the two, never disappointing his admirers, from Cardinal Bellarmin in Galileo (1980) to Perchikhin in The Philistines (1986). 
 He played numerous cameo roles both on the large and the small screen: in The Charge of the Light Brigade and Hamlet for the cinema and in Hess, Disraeli and Suez for television. 
 Nothing was too daunting for him and each new part was dispatched with the same intelligence and mental and bodily concentration. 
 CORRECTION Margaret Wolfit writes to correct an error in this obituary. 
 She says: &bquo;Rosalind Iden was not (to my knowledge) at Sheffield Repertory Company. 
 It was my mother Chris Castor, a fine actress, who was leading lady there and gave Mar Dignam lessons in elocution. 
 She had trained under Kate Rorke at the Guildhall, where she won the silver medal for elocution. 
 POP / The Who face up to a new generation: Giles Smith anticipates the return of Daltrey, Townshend and Entwistle 
 By GILES SMITH 
 THE WHO will be 25 years old next month, and not one of the band looks a day over 50. 
 Actually, not one of its members is a day over 50 (although all of them are coming close) but you might reasonably have expected age to leave Daltrey, Townshend, and Entwistle looking worse than well-travelled. 
 When they weren't trashing their equipment (something which kept them occupied deep into the Seventies), they were trashing each other. 
 Townshend is most famous for beating his guitar against speaker stacks, but it is also worth remembering that, on stage at The Ricky Tick Club, Windsor, in May 1966, he attempted the same stunt against the head of Keith Moon. 
 For his part, Moon managed to fry a sizeable portion of Townshend's hair by misjudging a flash powder explosion in his drum kit during the making of an American TV Special. 
 The on-stage arguments and bust-ups practically became a feature of the show, with Daltrey almost permanently poised to quit, but somehow hanging on. 
 And when they weren't trashing each other, they were trashing themselves. 
 Moon died in 1978, after an overdose of the prescribed drug he was taking to ease himself out of alcoholism; Townshend had his own dark periods of excess; even Entwistle, the quiet, static one, felt inclined to release a solo album entitled Smash Your Head Against The Wall. 
 Daltrey has always seemed the keenest to reform The Who for live shows (they split up officially in 1983), and he has finally got his way: these British dates follow an American tour. 
 Accusations of cynical pension-planning inevitably follow, as do questions about whether this is the sort of thing that grown men should be up to. 
 But if your repertoire includes standards like Won't Get Fooled Again, Substitute, and My Generation, it must be galling to be made to justify your desire to go out and play them. 
 SELECTED THE SUGARCUBES Inspired bohemians from Reykjavik, determinedly evading the clutches of the major record companies. 
 Tonight Newcastle Mayfair; Sat Glasgow Barrowlands; Mon Edinburgh Usher Hall; Tue Nottingham Rock City. 
 LENNY HENRY Benefit concert on behalf of Sickle Cell Anaemia Research. 
 Henry will run through a few soul favourites, backed by the Womack &amp; Womack Band. 
 Numerous scheduled guests include Aswad, and Karen Wheeler from Soul II Soul. 
 Fri London Brixton Academy. 
 VAN MORRISON The sombre balladeer, currently on form which you might almost describe as chirpy. 
 His band includes Georgie Fame on organ, and saxophonist Pee Wee Ellis, in a combination rarely known to disappoint. 
 Fri Leeds University; Sat Birmingham Hummingbird; Sun Bristol Studio; Mon-Wed London Town &amp; Country. 
 THE MIGHTY LEMON DROPS Their new LP, Laughter, marries an adventurously large guitar sound to some pop tunes of equal ambition. 
 Live, the mix seems likely to work well. 
 Fri Leeds Polytechnic; Sat Newcastle University; Tue Manchester Ritz; Wed Leicester University. 
 Tonight Sheffield University; Fri Newcastle Polytechnic; Sat Leeds University; Sun Norwich UEA; Mon Cambridge Corn Exchange. 
 Fri London Africa Centre. 
 Sun London Purcell Room. 
 Tonight Bristol Bierkeller; Fri Hereford Park Hall; Sat Leeds West Indian Centre; Tue Newcastle Riverside Club. 
 OPERA / The magical voice of the Flute: Joan Rodgers explains her role in The Magic Flute to Mark Pappenheim 
 By MARK PAPPENHEIM 
 Mozart is my whole life at the moment,&equo; says soprano Joan Rodgers. 
 &bquo;I keep telling myself that it will stand me in good stead when I'm about 40 and doing my first Isolde!&equo; 
 But she's not really complaining: Mozart launched her international career at the 1982 Aix Festival when at short notice, and at only 25, she took on the role of Pamina in The Magic Flute. 
 She's since sung Pamina, Zerlina and Despina under Barenboim in Paris and, before the axe fell on the conductor's brief reign at the Bastille, was to have done the three Da Ponte pieces with him and Patrice Chereau. 
 Concert work fills the blanks in her diary left by the Bastille debacle. 
 She sang Susanna earlier this summer in Simon Rattle's period Figaro for Glyndebourne (due to be seen on BBC TV before Christmas) and is now back at the Coliseum as Pamina in Nicholas Hytner's luminously hieroglyphic Magic Flute. 
 Rodgers has little difficulty reading between the lines of Hytner's stylish staging, which apes the hairpin role-reversals of Mozart's convoluted Masonic fable by itself, neatly reversing the racial and sexual stereotypes of the original. 
 Here we have a black prince and a white &bquo;blackamoor&equo;, a male hero but a female lead. 
 &bquo;It's clear that Pamina is just as much on trial as Pamino. 
 Even more perhaps. 
 After all, he's been told what's going on, she hasn't &mdash; and is almost driven to suicide by his mysterious silence,&equo; she explains. 
 In fact, it's Pamina that really grows in this production, from her first encounter with Monostatos ('a real pantomime villain'), through the cataclysmic change in her relationship with her mother, the Queen of the Night, from blind devotion to ultimate aversion. 
 &bquo;She starts as a naive young girl and ends as a grown woman, and quite a strong one too,&equo; Rodgers adds proudly. 
 And when this Pamina finally enters Sarastro's all-male Brotherhood of Man, it's clear she's really won her place. 
 As a final gesture, Tamino removes the hard-won Symbol of the Sun from his own neck and places it round Pamina's: &bquo;It's a breakthrough &mdash; a new order breaking the mould of the past.&equo; 
 TICKET OFFER English National Opera, in association with Ticketmaster, is offering Independent readers a 20 per cent reduction on its Stalls, Dress Circle and Upper Circle seats (&pound;8.80 to &pound;26.40) for the performance of Mozart's Magic Flute on Wednesday 18 October (7.30pm). 
 In addition, readers will receive a complementary glass of Taittinger champagne at the interval. 
 To book, call Ticketmaster on 01-379 4444 and mention The Independent offer before Thursday 12 October. 
 English National Opera, St Martin's Lane WC2. 
 MUSIC &amp; OPERA / Selected concerts and productions in the week ahead, including Norwich Festival, City of Birmingham Touring Opera; ticket offers 
 By MARK PAPPENHEIM 
 NORWICH FESTIVAL Swedish trumpet virtuoso Hakan Hardenbeger plays Jolivet's Concerto, British organist David Titterington plays Poulenc's, Richard Hickox conducts the City of London Sinfonia. 
 Plus Ravel (Tombeau de Couperin), Bizet (Symphony in C) 7.30pm St Andrew's Hall &pound;3-&pound;12 but half-price to Independent readers on presentation of this page at the Box Office (0603-618499) SATURDAY BBC Philharmonic Brahms (Symphony No3) and Wagner (Prelude and Liebstod) frame Schoenberg's Violin Concerto 7.30pm RFH &pound;3.50-&pound;15 but Independent readers can get 2 tickets for the price of 1 on presentation of this page at the Box Office Echoes of Venice 17th-century cantatas and motets by Rossi, Legrenzi, Stradella and Carisio sung by the Baroque Consort of Singers 8pm St Mary's, Putney Bridge SW15 &pound;4/concs &pound;2 RPO Nicholas Cleobury conducts Mendelssohn (Fingal's Cave), Handel (Water Music), Rachmaninov (Piano Concerto No2, soloist Piers Lane), Beethoven (Pastoral) 8pm Barbican &pound;7-&pound;15 Emma Kirkby with Anthony Rooley. 
 Dowland lute songs 7.30pm Wigmore &pound;5-&pound;10 Rendezous Canadian Music Festival Concert Acousmatique introduced by Claude Schryer 5pm PR &pound;3. 
 Chilingirian Quartet with oboist Lawrence Cherney and soprano Ingrid Attrot: Tippett (Quartet No2), Harry Freedman (Short Story), Cherney (In the Stillness of the Summer Wind), R. Murray Schafer (Beauty and the Beast) 7.45pm QEH &pound;3-&pound;6. 
 Gregory Levin's Medicine Wheel ('a shaman journey into the electric present'), plus John Oliver (El Reposo del Fuego), Micheline Coulombe-Saint Marcoux (Miroirs), DX7 player Sergio Barroso (La Fiesta) 8pm PR 32.50-&pound;5 READING Andrew Litton conducts Bournemouth Symphony Orchestra in Mozart's Sinfonia Concertante and Mahler's Symphony No5 7.30pm Hexagon (0734-591591) &pound;6-&pound;15 SUNDAY Seta Tanyel The rising Armenian star of the keyboard joins Rafael Fruhbeck de Burgos and the LSO for Beethoven's Emperor Concerto, plus Mahler (Symphony No1) 7.30pm Barbican &pound;4.50-&pound;20 Immortal Diamond Gerard Manley Hopkins, poet and priest, celebrated in poetry and song. 
 7pm Wigmore Hall &pound;4-&pound;7 Pinchas Zukerman The American violinist's only London recital this season. 
 Beethoven (Sonata Op12 No3), Schumann (Romances Op94, Sonata Op105 No1), Stravinsky (Suite Italienne) 4pm Barbican &pound;5-&pound;12.50 Bach Vespers Cantata 38 (Aus tiefer Not), plus Vivaldi (Double Violin Concerto) in context of Lutheran service 7pm St Anne's, Gresham St, The City NORWICH FESTIVAL Dorothy Tutin joins the Endymion Ensemble for Saint- Saens's Carnival of the Animals and Poulenc's Babar the Elephant, plus Ibert, Milhaud 3pm St Andrew's Hall &pound;2-&pound;8. l TUESDAY Verdi Requiem ECO and Tallis Chamber Choir with soloists Jo Ann Pickens, Sarah Walker, Jeffrey Talbot, Gwynne Howell 7.30pm Royal Naval College Chapel, King William Walk, Greenwich SE10 &pound;5.50-&pound;9 (317 8687) Olli Mustonen The brilliant young Finnish pianist-composer joins fellow Finn Esa-Pekka Salonen and the Philharmonia for a Grand Gala in aid of the Council for the Protection of Rural England: Ravel's breezy G major Piano Concerto is framed by aptly Green pieces by Vaughan Williams (Greensleeves Fantasia) and Stravinsky (Le Sacre du Printemps) 7.30pm RFH &pound;18 incl donation; &pound;35-&pound;125 incl reception and private view of Legacy exhibition (12 photographers' views of Britain's countryside) NORWICH FESTIVAL The Field of Cloth of Gold: A musical celebration of the 1520 meeting between Henry VIII and Francois I of France, played on period instruments by Musica Antiqua of London 7.30pm Cathedral &pound;2.50-&pound;7.50 (0603-618499) LES PARISIENNES Pianist Diana Ambache and her Ambache Chamber Orchestra offer musical portraits of four femmes de Paris &mdash; two of them composers, two of them inspirations for the compositions of others. 
 Emilie Candeille, opera singer, grande tragedienne and composeress, is represented by the first performance in 199 years of her Piano Concerto in D, Op2. 
 Louise Farrenc, who numbered Schumann among her fans, is remembered by her Nonet for strings and wind of 1849, while the hapless Marie Antoinette is immortalised in the nickname of her favourite symphony, Haydn's No85, La Reine de France. 
 Finally, the masculine sounding dedicatee of Mozart's Piano Concerto No9, dubbed the Jeunehomme, stands revealed as a certain Mlle Jeunehomme, virtuoso pianist 7.30pm St John's Smith Sq &pound;5-&pound;11/concs &pound;5 WEDNESDAY11 The Creation Period Orchestra, the Age of Enlightenment: Haydn's Handelian oratorio 7.30pm QEH &pound;5-&pound;15 THOMAS ALLEN Second recital this week (after Blackheath on Thursday 5) by the vibrant Geordie baritone. 
 Here it's English song by Britten, Butterworth, Quilter and Vaughan Williams. 
 With Geoffrey Parsons (piano) 8pm Royal Opera House, Covent Garden (240 1066) &pound;1.50-&pound;15 ADDRESSES AND BOOKING Barbican Centre, Silk Street EC2 (638 8891) South Bank Centre (Royal Festival Hall, Queen Elizabeth Hall, Purcell Room), South Bank SE1 (928 8800) St John's, Smith Square SW1 (222 1061) Wigmore Hall, Wigmore Street W1 (935 2141) OPERA CITY OF BIRMINGHAM TOURING OPERA &bquo;Ghanashyam &mdash; A Broken Branch&equo; CBTO's most adventurous project so far unites 16 of India's leading classical performers with nine British-based Asian artists in the premiere performances of Pandit Ravi Shankar's new musical theatre piece, a spectacular marriage of Indian classical music, song and dance (Kathak, Bharatanatyam and Kathakali) set in an idyllic early 20th-century India and exploring the destructive effects of drink and drugs upon a village dancer, played by Kathak wizard Durga Lal. 
 Crawley 7.45pm Fri The Hawth. 
 Farnham 8pm 12 Oct Maltings. 
 DANCE / Louise Levene with details of Rambert's national tour plus nationwide booking details 
 By LOUISE LEVENE 
 LONDON Anthony d'Offay Gallery (499 4100) Michael Clark Heterospective. 
 Small- space performance by this most trendy of dancers. 
 Dress up. 
 Only 50 seats per performance for a &pound;23 donation to the Michael Clark Foundation which finances his company 14-23 Oct. 
 Ealing Town Hall (579-2424 ext 55057) Common Ground Dance Theatre A Stranger Disintegrates &mdash; exploration of urban isolation by deaf and hearing dancers tonight. 
 BASILDON New Towngate Theatre (0268-532 632) Second Stride Heaven Ablaze in His Breast rehashed Coppelia based on Hoffmann's &bquo;The Sandman&equo; about a man's dangerous obsession with a mechanical doll to Sat. 
 GLASGOW Tramway (041-227 5511) Anne Teresa de Keersmaeker Mikrokosmos cult Belgian choreographer with four women performing to Gyorgy Ligeti and Bartok played by the Dutch Mondrian Quartet Sat &amp; Sun. 
 Football Round-Up: Thomas eases the doubts 
 By NEIL MORTON 
 ON A night of hat-tricks in the Littlewoods Cup last night, Michael Thomas made a powerful case to be considered as an England understudy for the Polish expedition should Bryan Robson suffer a relapse, writes Neil Morton. 
 The midfielder struck a superb second-half treble as Arsenal pummelled Plymouth 6-1 at Home Park. 
 Thomas's contribution could not have been more timely, Tommy Tynan having equalised an own goal by David Byrne. 
 Sheffield Wednesday, curiously, were the most prolific scorers, but only one goal ahead of Luton, finalists for the past two seasons, who defeated Third Division Mansfield 7-2 (11-5 on aggregate). 
 Steve Whitton and Dalian Atkinson were Wednesday's discoverers of the lost art; Luton's hero was their &pound;900,000 Danish acquisition, Lars Elstrup, who scored three following his double in the first leg. 
 In the only giant-killing acts, Tranmere, top of the Third, defeated Ipswich, struggling in the Second, with a Chris Malkin goal (2-0 overall) while Exeter ensured that the Fourth will have at least one representative in the third round. 
 After overcoming Blackburn 3-0 at home in the first leg, due largely to an injury to Rovers' goalkeeper Terry Gennoe, they were beaten 2-1 last night but prevailed on aggregate. 
 A 119th-minute goal by Tony Cascarino enabled Millwall to scramble through against Stoke. 
 Cascarino's decider came with the game heading for a shoot-out. 
 Teddy Sheringham had levelled the aggregate score (43). 
 Norwich preserved their unblemished away record, winning 2-0 at Rotherham thanks to Dale Gordon and Robert Fleck. 
 Racing: Cordoba shouts the odds 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 JUST possibly Cordoba (3.10) may prove to be the biggest talking horse since Mister Ed, the supernag of American television fame. 
 More probably, however, Cordoba is yet another potential champion from Michael Stoute's Newmarket production line, an opinion the son of El Gran Senor can underline by galloping off with today's Middle Park Stakes at Newmarket, writes John Karter. 
 Well before Cordoba made his debut over today's course two months ago, his name was being whispered behind many a well-respected hand as the one to be on for next year's 2000 Guineas. 
 And having been backed for the classic at long odds before his Newmarket introduction, Cordoba became clear favourite for the 2000 after treating his six opponents like seaside donkeys. 
 Stoute has stated that Cordoba's Guineas odds are absurdly low, but there is no doubt that he holds the colt in extremely high regard. 
 On actual racecourse achievement, Rock City is head and shoulders above Cordoba and the rest of today's field, having won Royal Ascot's Coventry Stakes and the Gimcrack Stakes at York. 
 However, Rock City looked a shadow of the brilliant juvenile who dominated those events when a well-beaten fourth behind the French colt Machiavellian at Longchamp. 
 He was apparently found to be running a temperature, but after a long season of competing in the best company, he may be past his best. 
 Willie Carson, Rock City's rider, has a significant ride to start of the afternoon when he partners Nashwan's half-brother, Mukddaam (1.30), on his first racecourse appearance, which has been delayed by injury and hard ground. 
 Mukddaam easily disposed of his more experienced stable companion, Marienski, in a racecourse gallop at Newbury, and as the latter ran creditably in last Saturday's Royal Lodge Stakes, Mukddaam clearly shares at least some of Nashwan's ability. 
 Carson is not without a chance on Murango later in the afternoon, but preference is for Petite Rosanna (next best 3.40), for whom the booking of Steve Cauthen looks significant. 
 Petite Rosanna lost a shoe when fancied for a big handicap at Newbury last time. 
 Cauthen could have a major chance on Spritsail if that horse's poor run at Ascot last week could be ignored. 
 However, it may pay to take a chance with SESAME (nap 2.35), who has been running creditably in top class events and could oblige at attractive odds. 
 Racing: Certain pride for Elsworth 
 By JOHN KARTER, Racing Correspondent 
 DAVID ELSWORTH will have a lot more to occupy his thoughts this winter than a certain grey steeplechaser. 
 Desert Orchid's trainer can fill the gaps between the great horse's latest achievements by dreaming of his first Classic success with Dead Certain, who became clear favourite for the fillies' Classic with a courageous victory in yesterday's Cheveley Park Stakes at Newmarket. 
 &bquo;You've got to do something in the close season when there's no jumping,&equo; Elsworth joked, making light of a triumph that clearly thrilled him enormously. 
 And if it seemed surprising to reflect that the supremely versatile Hampshire trainer has not yet struck in our Classic races, it was even more incredible to learn from the man himself that Dead Certain's victory in the richest two-year-olds race ever run in this country was his first success in a group one event. 
 And glory in the 1,000 Guineas may well be a lot more than just a warming winter thought because Dead Certain beat as competitive a field as there has been for a juvenile filly's race for many years. 
 Always up with the pace, she responded instantly when Cash Asmussen asked her to repel the challenges of the favourite, Chimes Of Freedom, and Line Of Thunder. 
 Those who follow cash of the other sort were chasing fool's gold. 
 The market signals proved totally wrong as Dead Certain drifted out ominously in the betting and Chimes Of Freedom was backed as if defeat was not even a remote possibility. 
 Money cascaded on to Henry Cecil's filly, including one individual bet of &pound;50,000 to &pound;55,000, but in the end she was even edged out of second place by Line Of Thunder. 
 The reason for the apparent lack of confidence was clearly the fact that Elsworth had suspended operations for some while because of coughing in his yard and had not had a winner for almost six weeks. 
 Dead Certain had been as badly affected as any, but Elsworth simply would not run a horse of that class in such a race unless he believed it was capable of giving of its best. 
 &bquo;I think she had done enough at the end and it was beginning to hurt,&equo; Elsworth said. 
 That was more a reflection on Dead Certain's ring rustiness than her stamina and Asmussen said: &bquo;She's a very good filly and I'm sure she'll stay the Guineas mile because she's got such a lovely relaxed temperament.&equo; 
 Dead Certain's win yet again brought home the fact that there is life after the Maktoums. 
 Toby Marten, Dead Certain's owner, paid only 5,800 guineas for her and even after stumping up &pound;10,000 to supplement her for yesterday's race, he is still well over six figures in the plus in prize money, not to mention Dead Certain's enormous intrinsic value. 
 William Hill made Dead Certain their 12-1 Guineas favourite but Corals offers only 8-1. 
 William Hill price In The Groove, another of Elsworth's fillies, at 20-1. 
 In The Groove, who runs at Phoenix Park on Saturday, has not achieved nearly as much as Dead Certain, but Elsworth rates them on a par. 
 Corals cut Cacoethes from 6-1 to 5-1 co-favourite with Aliysa and Young Mother for Sunday's Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe after it was confirmed that Steve Cauthen will ride Guy Harwood's colt. 
 Ten horses were withdrawn from the Longchamp race at yesterday's forfeit stage, including Khalid Abdullah's Assatis, which means that Pat Eddery is almost certain to ride the owner's other runner, French Glory. 
 Legal Case's connections were the only ones to pay the &pound;30,000 supplementary fee. 
 Racing: Ratings added to the service 
 By JOHN KARTER, Racing Correspondent 
 THE RACING service of The Independent has been improved with the introduction of individual ratings to the form guide. 
 The horse with the highest rating in each race is deemed to have the best chance on form, though other influences will be discussed in the guide. 
 In theory, a horse with a rating two points higher than his rivals is considered to be 2lb &mdash; the equivalent of a length over a mile and a half - superior. 
 Each day's race cards will indicate which meetings are to be shown live in betting shops by Satellite Information Services (SIS). 
 In addition, where necessary there will be notification of horses &bquo;out of the handicap&equo;, and who are therefore at a disadvantage. 
 These horses have a Jockey Club official handicap rating that merits carrying a weight lower than the minimum weight allotted for a race. 
 Other innovations include a comprehensive presentation of results from the previous day's principal meeting, featuring the breeding of winners, the successful trainer and owner, extended distances, and details of the first six finishers. 
 Every Monday, there will be an in-depth statistical look at the performances of leading trainers and jockeys, with particular reference to the stables and riders in form. 
 Television channels' tunnel vision: Rumbles of discontent with teasing highlights surround the Football League's deal with ITV. 
 Patrick Barclay reports 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY 
 THE Football League's new relationship with ITV has brought clubs a lot of money, irregularly distributed. 
 It has brought the viewer expanded coverage, irregularly spread; although the season began on 19 August, the first live match will not be broadcast until 29 October. 
 But David Dein, the Arsenal vice-chairman martyred for his part in the deal, insists that it is working &bquo;eminently satisfactorily&equo;. 
 Dein lost his place on the League management committee because it was felt that the interests of the so-called &bquo;Big Five&equo; clubs, including Arsenal, had been pushed too hard. 
 The then League president, Everton's Philip Carter, went too. 
 A year on, Dein is unrepentant. 
 He hears the rumbles of discontent &mdash; but points to concurrent rises in viewing figures and attendances. 
 &bquo;In any case,&equo; he says, &bquo;the world is changing. 
 Television can no longer be considered an intrusion into football. 
 The game is going to be TV-driven in the future, and rightly so when the worldwide trend is towards seated stadiums with reduced capacities.&equo; 
 Football is, of course, already a television sport in France, where the satellite station Canal Plus is noted for its quality of production &mdash; and the football industry for the size of its wallet. 
 Little Monaco, with their English Third Division crowds, could easily afford to tempt Glenn Hoddle from Tottenham; Marseille, who paid &pound;4.5m for Chris Waddle, were said to have earned that and more from television alone in the previous year. 
 Spurs would be lucky to receive &pound;1m from ITV this season. 
 So ITV is driving a comparatively modest engine. 
 But its skill at the wheel remains a matter of legitimate debate while the audience is temporarily neglected. 
 Piecemeal highlights are all very well, but viewers tend to be creatures of habit and, at present, a short burst of goals every Saturday night is just a tease; an uninitiated visitor would never guess that football was the national game. 
 Within ITV's ranks, there is concern that last season's gains have been wasted. 
 The overlord Greg Dyke, having paid a minimum of &pound;11m a year for exclusive rights to the League (at the current rate of inflation, the four-year, index-linked bill could soar over &pound;50m), hit his audience target of eight million when Manchester United beat Liverpool thrillingly on New Year's Day. 
 Then came Arsenal's unforgettable finale at Anfield in May, watched by nearly 12 million people (more than the BBC got for the FA Cup final). 
 &bquo;The viewers were hungry,&equo; one member of staff said. 
 &bquo;We could have re-established ourselves as the football channel. 
 But, when the League re-started, we gave the public nothing.&equo; 
 Trevor East, the new producer of The Match, explains the decision to wait for late autumn: &bquo;People are reluctant to watch televised football or anything else on a sunny afternoon. 
 Ratings dip right across the board. 
 In any case, we have only 18 matches live and need to have some week-by-week continuity, building towards the climax. 
 The deal doesn't buy us a match every week.&equo; 
 So why not a proper highlights package on Saturday night, or non-live Sundays as some regions are already trying? 
 &bquo;It depends on ratings for the short Saturday-night slot. 
 At the moment, they are not encouraging.&equo; 
 The consumers would appreciate some stability. 
 Perhaps more variety, too, although enthusiasts' assertions that not everyone is obsessed by the &bquo;Big Five&equo; are countered by East who, as a football nut and a director of Derby until he moved into his current post, knows all the arguments. 
 &bquo;We're not a public service,&equo; he says, &bquo;and we won't attract viewers by going to half-empty stadiums. 
 They want to share in big-match atmosphere.&equo; 
 For the clubs, as ever, the issue is money, most of which goes to the First Division. 
 Even those who never appear receive &pound;200,000 a year. 
 But this is not enough for the likes of Coventry, who are prominent among the complainers. 
 Millwall take a different view. 
 Their policy is to get in among the big clubs on merit, thus forcing television's hand. 
 Naturally, East warms to this. 
 &bquo;Clubs will get on the box,&equo; he says, &bquo;if they are doing well and at home to one of the big boys. 
 That's when they fill the terraces.&equo; 
 The inbuilt bias towards the big clubs has undoubtedly fuelled inflation in the transfer market; one has only to look at Manchester United, who raked in nearly &pound;1m from television last season. 
 But transfer money is not lost to the game &mdash; it circulates, by and large &mdash; and clubs have used their new wealth in different ways; Dein says it has helped Arsenal to develop their ground. 
 &bquo;The deal has been very good for football,&equo; he says, &bquo;and I believe that television is going to be accepted as a very important tool in the game's administration. 
 After Lord Justice Taylor's report, a lot of the bigger grounds have reduced capacities. 
 Ours is down to 49,000 &mdash; and that is still the largest in the League. 
 So there are going to be more lock-outs. 
 Television can meet the excess demand.&equo; 
 Enticing marriage with no promises: Neil Wilson on sport's need to balance the benefits and blights of TV exposure 
 By NEIL WILSON 
 NO BRITISH sport owes more to television than athletics. 
 You only have to look at the balance sheet its treasurer John Lister will present to its annual meeting in December, a million pounds sitting on reserve. 
 At that meeting he will be able to announce to clubs that ITV has agreed to pay more than &pound;7m over the next four years, an extension of a contract in which it paid &pound;10.5m over five years. 
 The debt goes deeper than money. 
 Television, both BBC's coverage for 20 years and ITV's for the past five, not only attracted lucrative sponsorships but developed a greater interest among the young. 
 The Pascoes and Fosters on the box fired the imaginations of the Coes and Crams and they in their turn the Jacksons and Backleys. 
 &bquo;Prime exposure, that's the key benefit to any sport on television, and the presentation of a sport in a positive way,&equo; said Alan Pascoe, athlete turned TV commentator who is chairman of the sport's marketing agents. 
 &bquo;Many sports are very envious of athletics.&equo; 
 So where is the catch? 
 Does a marriage of convenience between sport and television come with a promise to love, honour and obey? 
 &bquo;Any risks are far outweighed by the benefits,&equo; Pascoe argues. 
 &bquo;A sport just has to be a bit flexible.&equo; 
 Athletics arranges its annual fixtures in consultation with television. 
 No point in fixing dates when television's cameras are tied up elsewhere. 
 Similar co-operation follows in the scheduling of a meeting's main events. 
 Nothing must clash with a commercial break or run into the news. 
 Occasionally athletes are kept waiting at the start for a minute or so until television is ready. 
 It is a small price, Pascoe believes, and one which sport should accept as reasonable. 
 &bquo;The discipline television imposes can be helpful,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There's not many sports that can't learn about presentation from television.&equo; 
 A sport, like a new spouse, can be so infatuated with its glamourous partner that it loses its head. 
 Basketball in Britain did when Channel 4 offered to screen a game each week. 
 Suddenly sponsors appeared from everywhere, the sport thought it was Christmas and expanded out of control. 
 Now Channel 4 has gone and the sport is back where it was six years ago. 
 Some predict bowls will be the next to suffer. 
 &bquo;It is the sports which can get it wrong,&equo; Pascoe warned. 
 &bquo;They must always be careful when they adjust and react to television that they don't change the nature of their sport. 
 But the dictation and domination some predicted for athletics hasn't happened.&equo; 
 A sport's first concern, Pascoe says, should be its own development and that means presenting itself in the best possible way. 
 &bquo;They should not see television as a panacea for all financial ills.&equo; 
 As Jonathan Martin, the BBC head of sport, put it: &bquo;It's not just about having the biggest cheque on the table. 
 It's what television does with your sport in terms of scheduling and presentation that matters.&equo; 
 Commonwealth Games: Cost plan devised by AAA 
 By NEIL WILSON 
 SCOTTISH, Welsh and Northern Irish athletes will be able to prepare for next January's Commonwealth Games in Auckland at training camps in Australia in spite of the financial constraints which have imposed limits on the size of their teams. 
 The Amateur Athletic Association, the English body which manages the financial affairs of British athletics, is increasing its annual donation to the other three countries by &pound;20,000. 
 It is intended to cover the extra costs of sending athletes to the southern hemisphere immediately after Christmas to train in warmer weather. 
 The first &pound;10,000 has been shared out already, and the rest will be paid in the next half financial year. 
 John Lister, the Welsh treasurer of the AAA/BAAB, promises that the payments will continue annually. 
 &bquo;When the British Amateur Athletic Board was in financial crisis three years ago, we had to cut the grant to the Welsh, Scots and Irish,&equo; Lister said. 
 &bquo;Now we can afford to restore it, and by doing it immediately it gives their athletes the same advantages England's will have.&equo; 
 The four home countries' teams have been invited to a pre-Games warm-up meeting in Sydney, where the Kenyans and Canadians will also compete. 
 But without television coverage, the promoters could not afford to meet the costs, and the Scots, Welsh and Irish looked like missing the opportunity. 
 Tennis: Becker tells of refuge on the East side 
 From JOHN ROBERTS in Stuttgart 
 BORIS BECKER spoke here yesterday of how he tried to find the perfect antidote to New York by taking a week's holiday in East Germany after winning the United States Open last month. 
 &bquo;It was as bad as when I won Wimbledon in 1985,&equo; the 21-year-old multi-millionaire said of the response to this journey to the hamlet home, 50 miles south of East Berlin, of the grandmother of his girlfriend, Karen Schultz. 
 &bquo;There were only about 10 houses in the place, but there were so many people, you couldn't believe it. 
 We arrived at the little house in the evening and already there were a few people there. 
 The next day was frightening. 
 A couple of hundred people came, and all of them seemed to stay overnight. 
 I enjoyed myself. 
 I couldn't do much, but my mind was free and clear. 
 The trip was a good experience.&equo; 
 Having watched television documentaries about life in East Germany, Becker was keen to see for himself for the first time. 
 &bquo;What shocked me was that one wall could make such a difference,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It was hard to believe the change you could see by moving just a couple of kilometres out of West Germany, one of the richest countries in the world.&equo; 
 As a further 11,000 refugees were arriving yesterday in the hope of sharing this prosperity before the back door from Czechoslovakia was closed again, Becker added: &bquo;I am not surprised that they want to come. 
 I am only surprised that, suddenly, it's so many.&equo; 
 For Becker, a sporting life with capitalism has returned to normal as he mulls over details before signing a commitment to the mega-buck Association of Tennis Professionals Tour, which starts in January. 
 He is here playing in the Stuttgart Classic. 
 The East Germans have enough to think about without troubling themselves about tennis, but it is odd they do not have a single international player of note, bearing in mind the success of Czechoslovakia and the involvement of other Eastern bloc countries. 
 &bquo;I can only guess at the reason,&equo; Becker said. 
 &bquo;Tennis came back to the Olympics for the first time in Seoul, and maybe now that it is recognised again as an Olympic sport, it will become more important in East Germany. 
 In the end, they will have players.&equo; 
 Players who have had serious injury problems to contend with this year have used the &dollar;350,000 (&pound;212,000) Stuttgart event as part convalescence. 
 Miloslav Mecir, whose season has been handicapped by back trouble, assured himself of a place in the semi-finals along with Becker with a 6-2, 6-1 victory against Austria's Thomas Muster yesterday. 
 John McEnroe joined Mecir and Becker by defeating Henri Leconte 7-5, 2-6, 6-4, and Ivan Lendl's 6-4, 6-4 victory against Carl-Uwe Steeb put Leconte out of the tournament. 
 Tennis: Durie's brief dream turns to grim reality: Our Correspondent reports from Tokyo 
 From JOHN ROBERTS in Stuttgart 
 THE LONG and winding road that Jo Durie's career has followed over the past 10 years, took another nasty twist yesterday when she missed the chance to keep Britain in the Federation Cup. 
 With Clare Wood having lost the opening rubber of their second-round encounter against Austria to Judith Wiesner in straight sets, Durie needed to upset the form book. 
 For half an hour or so she had Barbara Paulus, ranked 21st to Durie's 102nd, chasing shadows as she won the first set 6-2. 
 &bquo;Jo played that set like a dream,&equo; said the team captain, Ann Jones. 
 Unfortunately, Durie woke up and subsequently allowed Paulus to take command from the baseline. 
 Once the Austrian had levelled the match it became evident that Durie was on shaky ground. 
 Paulus could sense it too as she moved in for the kill to claim a 2-6, 6-4, 6-3 victory. 
 &bquo;When I win a first set like that, I panic.&equo; 
 Durie said. 
 &bquo;It's because I haven't been winning for a while and I am desperate. 
 It's difficult to get matches under your belt when you're like that. 
 Winning has to become a habit.&equo; 
 At the age of 29, Durie must be wondering how much longer she has left to get hooked on that habit which she toyed with briefly six years ago when she reached the lofty heights of the world's top five. 
 Any form of a comeback could be thwarted by Durie's dismal world ranking. 
 Because of a succession of injuries and poor results she now stands at 102nd, her lowest-ever position. 
 It is a ranking that is likely to mean a spell in the qualifying competitions of the world's tournaments. 
 There was a morsel of consolation for the British team of Durie and Anne Hobbs before they left for home however, when they won the doubles contest against Petra Ritter and Paulus 2-6, 7-6, 6-3, saving three match points in the process. 
 The most strenuous victory of the day was claimed by the Spaniard, Arantxa Sanchez Vicario who survived several nerve-racking moments before beating Brenda Schultz, of the Netherlands, 2-6, 6-4, 10-8. 
 Sanchez's victory earned Spain, the second seeds, a quarter-final confrontation with the Soviet Union. 
 At the top end of the draw, the United States swept to a 3-0 win over Denmark and will next face Austria. 
 The most intriguing quarter-final will pit Czechoslovakia against Steffi Graf's West Germany. 
 Squash: Maclean finds the key to pick Umar's lock 
 From RICHARD EATON in Kuala Lumpur 
 BRITAIN delivered its third significant blow in two days to the world champions, Pakistan, when Mark Maclean put the seventh-seeded Umar Hayat Khan out of the World Open here yesterday, and became the first Scotsman ever to reach the quarter-finals. 
 The London-born, Cardiff-based man, from Edinburgh, has always been hard to pin down. 
 Yesterday, he produced his second extraordinary escape act in succession by coming from behind to win 10-15, 9-15, 15-13, 15-12, 15-10, against an opponent who has been in both of the last two world title-winning teams. 
 Maclean also had been two games down, and had had to play two match points, before surviving on Tuesday against England's promising 17-year-old, Simon Parke. 
 The suspicion exists that Maclean picks locks with a bent pin as a hobby. 
 He was 9-13 down in the third game this time, when he somehow slipped free. 
 &bquo;I thought I was out,&equo; Maclean said, &bquo;then I hit a couple of shots out of my arse, and I was in.&equo; 
 These &bquo;couple of shots&equo; were, in fact, four winners, which were immediately aided by a penalty point and abetted by a change in fortunes in refereeing decisions. 
 Maclean also concentrated on getting the ball past the talented Umar and denying him further chances to hit crisp drives into the nicks and towards difficult angles. 
 It earned him a quarter-final today with Jahangir Khan the title-holder, from Pakistan. 
 The former title-holder, Jansher Khan, also from Pakistan, plays Bryan Beeson, who became the second Briton to reach the last eight by overcoming Jason Nicolle, 15-7, 15-13, 15-6 in a tussle of English giant-killers. 
 On Tuesday, both beat members of the Pakistan team who defend the world title next week, in Singapore. 
 Was Brett upset to have beaten his brother? 
 &bquo;I would rather it hadn't been him, but he's done it plenty of times to me,&equo; was the answer. 
 Cricket: Subba Row to retire next year 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 RAMAN SUBBA ROW, the chairman of the Test and County Cricket Board since 1985, last night announced his intended retirement next year. 
 He will thus vacate possibly the most influential post in English domestic cricket when the game is at a watershed. 
 In his statement, Subba Row, who is 57 years old, stressed that he believes that five years in office is sufficient, and that negotiating the International Cricket Conference agreement on South Africa, announced in January, was quite enough to be remembered by. 
 Subba Row, also the chairman of Surrey and a former England and Northamptonshire batsman, will remain a powerful voice but clearly wishes for someone else to take the responsibility for the hazards to come. 
 In order to prevent a drain of young English cricketers to South Africa during the winter, the TCCB has to provide a suitably well-rewarded alternative and it is in this area that Subba Row's successor will need to shine. 
 The advent of satellite television and the imminent breaking of what has been a BBC monopoly of cricket offers opportunties of expanding TCCB income. 
 Other controversial topics during the next year include a restructuring of the county programme, the state of pitches, the height and durability of the seam and a continuing inquest into the inability of the 17 county clubs to produce Test-class players. 
 A public relations executive, Subba Row was a skilful diplomat accustomed to getting his own way and his methods did not always appeal to some of the county clubs or to the elder statesmen of MCC. 
 What history will say of his tenure of office is that he had very difficult decisions to make in awkward circumstances and while England's international team suffered an unimaginable decline most of the 17 first-class counties, his prime concern, flourished more than might have been expected. 
 Baseball: Oakland take lead on Stewart's arm 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 THE OAKLAND Athletics came back to win the first game of the best-of-seven American League championship series with a 7-3 victory over the Toronto Blue Jays, on Tuesday. 
 Toronto's starting pitcher, Dave Steib, took a 3-2 lead into the sixth inning, but Mark McGwire hit a lead-off home run to tie the game. 
 In the same inning, Carney Lansford grounded to shortstop, in what appeared to be an inning-ending double-play with the bases loaded. 
 But a hard-sliding Rickey Henderson forced Jays second baseman, Nelson Liriano, into throwing past first base, allowing two runs. 
 The Athletics added two more runs in the eighth inning on a wild pitch and a single. 
 Oakland's Dave Henderson scored the A's first run with a homer in the second inning and they scored their second on a single by Dave Parker. 
 Oakland's starting pitcher, Dave Stewart, recovered from a shaky start to allow just five hits over eight innings, before giving way to relief pitcher, Dennis Eckersley. 
 Toronto had scored on a sacrifice fly and a single in the second inning and on a home run by Ernie Whitt in the fourth inning. 
 Athletics: Thompson in doubt for Auckland 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 DALEY THOMPSON is doubtful for the Commonwealth Games in Auckland, in January, after undergoing an operation on his left knee, in Zurich last week. 
 Thompson, in an interview on BBC Television's Sportsnight programme, says he is neither pessimistic nor optimistic about his prospects for the Games but is convinced he can still be an athletics force for the next four or five years. 
 He said last night: &bquo;I've had a spot of bother for the past four or five years with my knee so I had these X-rays done and they found a bone growth about the size of a pea. 
 &bquo;They also found that my kneecap was not quite straight so they moved it over. 
 There were also floating bits of cartilage running round the knee. 
 They told me that in four or five years, it could get worse and would get arthritic. 
 So that's why I had it done. 
 &bquo;They told me that as long as I did not rush back too quickly, I should have another four or five years. 
 I'm not necessarily out of the Commonwealth Games. 
 I shall know when I'm a fit man. 
 &bquo;If I'm not there, I will not worry. 
 I shall be happy for the fellow who takes my place.&equo; 
 Asked about politics intruding in the Games, Thompson said: &bquo;The Games are always vulnerable. 
 But as a competitor, you do not think about politics and you just hope everyone will be there.&equo; 
 He was far more forthright on the omission of Steve Cram. 
 &bquo;It's bad news about Cram,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I think it is bad management. 
 I feel very strongly that a man like Cram, who has served his country very well in the past and won a host of medals, deserves more loyalty. 
 &bquo;The people who do the selecting know very little about the sport. 
 They do not want to select. 
 They do not want to be in the position of having to make decisions. 
 &bquo;Steve Cram and people like him should be there. 
 He is the first or second greatest miler in the last 10 years.&equo; 
 Cricket: Yardley's golden age of graft 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 NORMAN YARDLEY died yesterday, aged 74, three months after suffering a stroke; he will be mourned and missed by cricketers everywhere, writes Derek Hodgson. 
 Yardley was a golden boy pre-war who achieved almost every prize life and sport had to offer except, probably, the two he craved most: recovering the Ashes from Australia and taking Yorkshire to the County Championship. 
 As a right-hand bat and useful seamer, he captained St Peter's, York, when hardly out of short trousers, won his Blue as a freshman at Cambridge and, in turn, captained his school, university, county and country. 
 From then his career was hard graft: succeeding Brian Sellers as Yorkshire's captain he had to rebuild the side which, although talented, never managed more than a shared title; he won his England place on merit before succeeding Wally Hammond as captain when he had to face Don Bradman's Australia. 
 He accepted disappointment and defeat with dignity. 
 After retirement he became a respected commentator, chairman of selectors and eventually president of Yorkshire (1981-4) until, saddened by the internal strife, he resigned from an office in which he took great pride. 
 Yardley was proud that he was one of the few bowlers who could claim to have dismissed Bradman three times in Tests. 
 Drugs in Sport: Counsel on attack 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 ROBERT ARMSTRONG, the senior counsel at the Canadian Federal Inquiry into drug abuse in sport, wound up its hearings in Toronto by saying that the International Amateur Athletic Federation had failed to tackle the problem of drugs in athletics. 
 &bquo;There is a moral crisis in sport, not only in Canada but on a worldwide scale,&equo; he said. 
 The inquiry was set up after Ben Johnson was disqualified at last year's Olympics. 
 Last month, following Johnson's admissions at the inquiry that he had taken drugs and not failed drug tests, the IAAF decided to strip him of his world records retrospectively and enacted legislation which would punish any athlete who passed a drug test but subsequently admitted he was an offender. 
 &bquo;It may do no more than further entrench the conspiracy of silence,&equo; Armstrong said. 
 &bquo;You may wish to ask yourself whether there really has to date been a desire to address the drug problem in sport with firm conviction.&equo; 
 Justice Charles Dubin now has the task of ploughing through 14,500 pages of evidence from the inquiry's 119 witnesses before making known his findings, probably in January. 
 Meanwhile, Mel Levine, a United States Congressman, is introducing a Bill in Washington today which will put trading in 24 types of anabolic steroids, used to enhance muscle growth, under the Controlled Substances Act. 
 Golf: Olazabal returns 
 From NORMAN DABRELL in Stuttgart 
 A SPANIARD defends his German Masters title this week, after being stung into winning last year when he was left out of the Suntory World Matchplay Championship, while an Australian plays here having sacrificed a lucrative place in this year's matchplay event, writes Norman Dabrell from Stuttgart. 
 Jose-Maria Olazabal starts the defence of his title today in illustrious company, teeing off with Bernhard Langer and Mark Calcavecchia, looking to pick up a &pound;55,000 first prize. 
 With Severiano Ballesteros, Nick Faldo, Ian Woosnam and several leading Americans also in the field, Olazabal does not have the incentive of trying to gain a place in next week's World Matchplay at Wentworth: he has already been invited to play in the event this year. 
 The Australian, Craig Parry, misses Wentworth, but by his own volition. 
 Parry has turned down an offer to play in the World Matchplay and with it, an automatic &pound;12,500 reward, and has also decided to pull out of a couple of rich Japanese tournaments, so that he can play again next week in the BMW International. 
 &bquo;I feel there is more prestige in winning the order of merit,&equo; Parry said. 
 &bquo;I want to play on the US Tour eventually, too, and the Americans don't care how much money you have won. 
 But they would be impressed by you winning the order of merit &mdash; especially in Ryder Cup year.&equo; 
 Equestrianism: Smith makes most of Picnic 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY at Wembley 
 STEVEN SMITH'S perseverance with the brilliant but wayward Brook Street Picnic paid off last night at the Horse of the Year Show, when he won the &pound;4,000 first prize for the Leading Show Jumper of the Year title. 
 Formerly partnered by Nick Skelton, Picnic had proved to possess a distinctly awkward streak. 
 But he answered all the difficult questions that Harvey Smith's younger son asked of him last night to defeat a flying round from Philip Heffer on Viewpoint. 
 Emma-Jane Mac filled third place on Everest Oyster with the only other clear round of the jump-off. 
 Jos Lansink's first visit to The Horse of the Year Show could reward him with a Jaguar car, if he can maintain the form shown on the last three days. 
 When he won yesterday's NM Financial International, the Dutchman was left as the only rider who is still in with a chance of winning this special prize. 
 Known as the Everest Challenge, the car is offered to any rider who can jump two clear rounds in four specified contests and then win Saturday night's Grand Prix. 
 It had seemed an impossible target until yesterday, when Lansink produced his third double clear round in the specified series. 
 Now the Dutchman's goal has been reduced to two clear rounds in this evening's Modern Alarms Cup and victory in the Grand Prix. 
 &bquo;For sure I'd like to win the car,&equo; said Lansink, who finished third behind the Whitaker brothers in August's European Championships on Optiebeurs Felix. 
 He had the Jaguar prize firmly in his sights when opting for a steady clear round in Tuesday night's Rover Classic, instead of attempting a time which might have made it more difficult for Nick Skelton to win on Burmah Serenade. 
 Yesterday Lansink, 28, relied on the eight-year-old stallion, Libero. 
 First to go in the two-horse jump-off, he was able to claim his first ever Wembley victory after Michael Whitaker had 12 faults on another stallion, Next Didi. 
 Whitaker may well have parted with a horse of remarkable talent four years ago when he sold U2 to the Edwards family in Shropshire. 
 Now aged seven, this Irish-bred son of King of Diamonds was ridden by Carl Edwards to become overall winner of the three-part National Grade A Championship. 
 Equestrianism: Action to curb horse abuse 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 THE International Equestrian Federation is taking action to combat both physical abuse of horses and drug misuse to protect the reputation of the sport, writes Genevieve Murphy. 
 The federation's president, The Princess Royal, said yesterday that a new medication control programme would be based at a laboratory in Newmarket and that there would be substantially increased stewarding, possibly assisted by the installation of video cameras. 
 &bquo;A small minority of competitors are very much in danger of spoiling the good image of equestrian sport,&equo; she said. 
 In future, offenders are likely to be punished with &bquo;a short, sharp ban&equo; rather than a fine. 
 The Princess appeared to be at pains to avoid sensationalism as she declined to specify the abuses that the federation is aiming to stamp out. 
 However, there was the tacit admission of drug abuse in the tightened medication programme and a passing reference to the practice of &bquo;hyper-sensitisation.&equo; 
 The latter is designed to encourage the horse to avoid hitting fences by applying an irritant to its legs. 
 &bquo;We have started research into ways of detecting that type of abuse,&equo; the Princess said. 
 The forbidden practice of rapping, whereby the horse's legs are hit with a hand-held pole while it jumps a schooling fence, was not mentioned by name. 
 But the additional security, to be introduced at all international shows, is clearly aimed at stamping out that method of encouraging horses to jump clean &mdash; as well as reducing the possibilty of them being nobbled. 
 Two years ago, the Princess said that show jumping was &bquo;in serious danger of becoming a second-rate circus.&equo; 
 That threat, she said, was the reason why interested parties had come together to work for an improvement. 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 PAT CASH, the former Wimbledon champion out of competition for six months after surgery on a ruptured Achilles tendon, plans to make his comeback at the Hopman Cup in Perth over Christmas. 
 Sport in Short: Table Tennis 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Swimming 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Student Sports 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 THE ORGANISERS of the World Student Games to be held in Sheffield in 1991 intend to foot the bill for the Games, which will have to be staged for the first time without direct financial help from the host government, by raising &pound;18m through sponsorship. 
 They hope to attract eight to 10 corporate sponsors with worldwide rights to put the Games' logo on products, sponsors of the five purpose-built stadia which are now under construction and local firms. 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Snooker 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 SCOTLAND took the Amateur Home International Championship for the first time with an 11-7 victory over the Republic of Ireland at Prestatyn yesterday. 
 Sport in Short: Sailing 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Rugby Union 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Ice Skating 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 SUZANNE OTTERSON, the 15-year-old Scottish junior champion who was making her senior debut, gave a flowing performance to finish fourth in the short programme and move up to fifth place overall with the free skating to come. 
 Sport in Short: Ice Hockey 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 ALEXANDER MOGILNY, the Soviet forward who defected during the world championships in Stockholm, is among the Soviet contingent appearing in the NHL, which begins its 1989-90 season today, for the first time in the League's 73-year history. 
 Mogilny is playing for the Buffalo Sabres, while other Soviets include the New Jersey Devils' Viacheslav Fetisov, the former national captain, and the Vancouver Canucks' forward pair of Vladimir Krutov and Igor Larionov. 
 Sport in Short: Gymnastics 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Football 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Cricket 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 DAVE McAULEY has been given the go-ahead by a British Boxing Board doctor to resume full training after arm and foot injuries for his IBF flyweight title defence against Dodie Penalosa, of the Philippines, which the IBF insists must take place by 7 December. 
 Sport in Short: Bowls 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 JOHN BELL, the 1984 world championship fours gold medallist, has withdrawn from England's Commonwealth Games team for personal reasons. 
 His place at No. 3 goes to Gary Harrington. 
 Sport in Short: Basketball 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Baseball 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Badminton 
 Sport Page 37 
 Rugby Union: Oswald spurs Pontypool assault 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 Pontypool.. 34 Swansea..... 6 AT 37, and with more than 500 club games, 41 caps, and three British Lions tours behind him, Graham Price should be basking in the glory of one of Welsh rugby's greatest careers. 
 But old habits die hard, especially those fashioned in the Pontypool front row, and the easy life has been postponed for yet another season. 
 This term, though, there is a special reason for the archetypal tight-head cornerstone of the Pontypool pack to prop on &mdash; the All Blacks. 
 While the rest of Wales quakes in anticipation of next week's invasion by the world champions, Price is merely looking forward to another tussle with the ultimate rugby enemy. 
 Ten times he went into Test battle with them, winning once in 1977 in a Lions' jersey, and his experience and example will be crucial when the revamped, and increasingly successful, Gwent side meet the tourists in 13 days time. 
 It will not merely be his insight into the All Blacks' tactics and mentality which will prove valuable. 
 The Bay of Plenty No. 8, Dean Oswald, will offer a more contemporary view. 
 His influence in stemming the Swansea flow could not be overstated and he now looks certain to face his fellow countrymen in two weeks' time. 
 After Gerald Williams had caught Pontypool on the hop with a 16th minute try, converted by Mark Wyatt, the Kiwi import changed the whole course of events. 
 It was his pick-up and feed from a scrum which sent David Wright in for the first of his tries and then the No. 8 charged over from a similar situation to grab the lead on the stroke of half-time. 
 Once in the lead there was no stopping the home side as they reinforced their gathering momentum with five second-half tries. 
 Football: United divided in a search for dignity: Derek Hodgson reports on the story behind Knighton's impact on Old Trafford and football 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 THE Michael Knighton Story, already sold to a tabloid, began publicly as recently as 18 August when it became known that he was buying the controlling interest in Manchester United from Martin Edwards. 
 Knighton, Derbyshire-born and a professional for a year with Coventry City, was a teacher until 1984 when he took up property dealing. 
 He was largely unknown to football when last June he was introduced to Edwards, the chairman and majority shareholder of United. 
 In the ensuing month he persuaded Edwards to sell, accepting the stipulation that Edwards should retain his &pound;80,000-a-year job as chief executive for three years. 
 The terms were staggering to anyone naive enough to think football was only a game. 
 On the morning of 18 August The Independent, along with other media, reported that Edwards was prepared to sell for &pound;20m. 
 The new season was two days away and Alex Ferguson, a manager trying to compensate for a previous disappointing campaign, had spent &pound;2.5m on two midfielders, Mike Phelan and Neil Webb. 
 The following afternoon the sale was announced at Old Trafford and the name of the new chairman revealed. 
 Knighton, a small man with a ready smile, crisp, cool and articulate, flanked by PR men, made a good initial impression and left only one small but nagging doubt. 
 In answer to my question as to the source of his income he replied: &bquo;I have been extremely fortunate. 
 You could say the secret is location, location, location.&equo; 
 That one small doubt became a huge question mark two days later when, before the opening home game with Arsenal, Knighton took the field in a United playing strip (having refused the previous day to be photographed holding a United shirt) and juggled, headed and kicked a football in front of a at first incredulous and then delighted Stretford End. 
 There is nothing illegal nor immoral in a club chairman's demonstration of ball skills but the contrast, in a day, between the image of a shy, reclusive, multi-millionaire property tycoon and that of a terrace tearaway was too sudden to digest. 
 Within days rumours began to circulate that Knighton would have difficulty in raising the &pound;10m he needed to buy out Edwards, the &pound;10m reserved to buy out other shareholders and the &pound;10m pledged to the rebuilding of the Stretford End. 
 It also emerged that United's new No. 1 fan had tried to buy Bolton Wanderers in 1988. 
 One tabloid, threatened since with a writ, went as far as to say that he would not be able to find such a sum. 
 In mid-September the rumours reached a climax after two named backers withdrew their support. 
 Knighton remained ummoved as the money rolled out, Ferguson paying more than &pound;4m for Gary Pallister, Paul Ince and Danny Wallace. 
 Indeed Knighton seemed to have re-established control and credibility when David Murray, the wealthy chairman of Rangers, announced his support &bquo;and advice&equo;. 
 Then came yesterday's news that Knighton was reportedly negotiating a sale, including a &pound;6m profit and a three-year contract with the club for himself, with one of three groups: the United directors Amer Midani and Nigel Burrows, the media tycoon Eddie Shah, and the former estate agent and local radio entrepreneur (and Blackpool FC chairman) Owen Oyston. 
 Midani, the wealthy Lebanese who had always believed that he had first option should Edwards ever decide to sell, after trying to buy the club himself, insisted more than once: &bquo;United must not be caused embarassment,&equo; and seemed to be the one participant in what became an increasingly shabby affair who was conscious that great dignity was at stake. 
 To have the affairs of a club of such majesty as Manchester United conducted in a hole and corner manner has sickened more than many of their vast, worldwide following. 
 How much the shenanigans in the boardroom have affected the team's performance on the field is hard to say but those performances, even allowing for another sad catalogue of injuries, have been inconsistent at the least. 
 Fewer than 27,000 were at Old Trafford on Tuesday night to see the sequel to a thrilling first leg of a Littlewoods Cup-tie against Second Division Portsmouth. 
 Even five years ago an attendance of less than 35,000 would have been thought surprising. 
 It was symbolic of United's plight that Sir Matt Busby, nominally the club president, sat all alone, smoking his pipe, in the directors' box. 
 Basketball: Royals are waved aside 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 Hemel Royals.. 60 Reykjavik..... 64 (Reykjavik win 118-105 on agg) KODAK HEMEL ROYALS followed Manchester Giants out of European competition last night when they lost to Reykjavik of Iceland in the first round of the Korac Cup, writes Duncan Hooper. 
 Like the Finnish club who eliminated Giants from the Cup Winners Cup on Tuesday, Reykjavik followed the fundamental principles of playing aggressive defence, making simple passes and taking open shots. 
 But such simple tactics seemed beyond the inexperienced Hemel team, who were repeatedly caught out by American Jonathan Bow's eye for the easy basket. 
 Having started the match eight points down from the first leg, Hemel spent the first half apparently doing everything they could to double the deficit. 
 They almost succeeded, so that by a combination of close range misses, poor handling and half-hearted rebounding they trailed 33-27 at the break. 
 Hemel's Darin Schubring, who caused a two-hour delay in last week's first leg when he demolished the backboard, looked less dangerous on the rare occasions he had the ball. 
 The second half opened with Hemel threatening a stunning transformation as they outscored their opponents 9-2 to go one point ahead on the night and seven down overall. 
 But the effort proved too much to sustain and Reykjavik scored the next 13 points to put the issue beyond doubt. 
 Football: Nayim is the root of Southend's downfall 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY 
 Southend United.... 3 Tottenham Hotspur.. 2 (aet; score at 90 min 3-2; agg 3-3; Tottenham win on away goals) TOTTENHAM ended last night playing party tricks to waste time at Roots Hall, but it had taken them nearly two hours to establish a semblance of control over Southend in a throbbing, snarling, extraordinarily eventful Littlewoods Cup second round, second leg. 
 Having overcome the dismissal of Paul Stewart in the 49th minute, Spurs were forced into extra time by Gary Bennett's second goal. 
 Ultimately it was Nayim's audacious away goal that ruled, but only in the closing minutes had the Londoners enjoyed a moment's respite from the pumped-up Fourth Division team, who had Roy McDonough sent off for a reckless tackle near the end. 
 The contrast in styles could hardly have been more stark. 
 Right away Southend revealed their tactics: long, hanging balls played behind Spurs' back line. 
 And right away they worked, five minutes of chaos in Terry Venables's rearguard ending with Dave Martin heading home a corner to bring the sides level on aggregate. 
 Spurs clearly felt the loss of their big centre-back Guy Butters, who had reported sick on the coach journey to Essex. 
 The sheer fury of Southend's running kept Spurs under pressure and in the 41st minute Gary Mabbutt, newly cautioned for bringing down the impressive David Crown, gave the ball to him. 
 Crown squared from the byline for Bennett to shoot gleefully into the net. 
 But it was always an open contest, with Spurs' determinedly creative football making chances, and the home lead lasted only two minutes, Gary Lineker setting up Paul Allen. 
 Stewart's departure, after an incident that left Paul Roberts holding his face, did not seem to affect Spurs unduly. 
 Indeed their confidence soared with Nayim's exposition of mental and physical agility in the 55th minute. 
 Closely marked, he suddenly hooked the ball over his head and ran free to slip the ball between Paul Sansome's legs. 
 By now Spurs' defence looked more solid. 
 They had shuffled at half-time, moving Steve Sedgley back from midfield and Pat van den Hauwe to left-back. 
 But they could not quell Crown, who got his head to a free kick in the 68th minute, nor Bennett, who pounced. 
 Each side in turn went close to dispensing with extra time, Crown hitting a post then Paul Gascoigne having a chip turned on to the bar. 
 But Spurs lasted longer, the sparkling Nayim being denied another goal after a colleague was spotted offside while he completed an intricate run. 
 Manchester City erased the memory of last season's FA Cup third-round defeat against Brentford. 
 The Third Division side, holding a 2-1 advantage from the first leg of their Littlewoods Cup tie, were well placed at 1-1 before Trevor Morley struck twice in as many minutes and David Oldfield added another to wrap up City's 5-3 aggregate win. 
 Football: Drinkell lifts spirit level 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 Coventry City.. 3 Grimsby Town... 0 (Coventry win 4-3 on agg) GRIMSBY played for 87 minutes of this Littlewoods Cup tie with 10 men, and their prospects of defending the two-goal lead they brought to Highfield Road disappeared with Tony Rees, who was sent off for a coward's foul on Greg Downs. 
 Kevin Drinkell, Coventry's record signing from Rangers, ushered the club with whom he began his career towards the exit with a debut goal of which dreams are made. 
 Kevin MacDonald settled it with an even better one, drilled in from handsome distance. 
 Both sides were fired up &mdash; too much so &mdash; in some cases &mdash; and a spiteful start brought warnings for David Speedie and Keith Alexander before the third-minute incident which saw Rees dismissed for stamping on Downs with the full-back prostrate and helpless. 
 A man short, the Fourth Division side held their more illustrious opponents at bay with no great difficulty until midway through the first half, and the crowds had fallen into an apprehensive silence when Drinkell revived their spirits. 
 The newcomer could scarcely have opened his account in more spectacular fashion, scoring with an overhead kick from 10 yards after Speedie had nodded on a cross from Trevor Peake. 
 It was a goal of the highest class, reflecting the progress the 29-year-old striker has made in the five years since he left Blundell Park to earn fame and fortune with Norwich City and Rangers. 
 Speedie should have brought the aggregate level after 25 minutes, but leant back as he met a lay-off by Cyrille Regis, and his shot ballooned over the bar. 
 He is a better finisher than that, of course, and amends were duly made in the 43rd minute when he brought it to 2-0 on the night and 3-3 overall by meeting David Smith's low centre from the left with a 12-yard volley of stunning velocity. 
 Understandably, given their numerical disadvantage, Grimsby made little headway in attack, although Alexander, at 6ft 4in, was of a nuisance value against a defence deprived by injury of Brian Kilcline's aerial authority. 
 It was Alexander, formerly of Barnet, who demanded the only save Steve Ogrizovic was required to make &mdash; a low shot from the edge of the area forcing the man-mountain goalkeeper to go down with a motion usually greeted with cries of &bquo;timber&equo;. 
 Regis and Gary Bannister were both denied at close range before MacDonald spared us extra time with a rising 25-yarder which found the top left corner of Steve Sherwood's net. 
 American Football: Shell is the history man 
 By MATTHEW TENCH 
 ART SHELL'S appointment as the new head coach of the Los Angeles Raiders makes him the the first black in that position in modern NFL history, but the club's owner, Al Davis, immediately played down the importance of the move. 
 &bquo;It will only really be meaningful and historic if he is a great success,&equo; Davis said soon after firing the existing head coach Mike Shanahan. 
 Shell, 42, said: &bquo;It is an historical event and I understand the significance of it, but the main thing is I know who I am and I'm proud of it. 
 But I'm also a Raider and I don't believe the colour of my skin entered into this decision.&equo; 
 Shell was an outstanding offensive tackle during his 15 years with the Raiders until his retirement in 1982, when he became an assistant coach with the club. 
 The only other black to be a head coach in the NFL was Fritz Pollard, who led the now-defunct Hammond Pros from 1923 to 1925. 
 Civil rights organisations have long criticised the league for not having a black head coach despite the fact that many of its greatest players have been black. 
 Baseball has had four black managers since Jackie Robinson broke the sport's racial barrier in 1947. 
 Two of them &mdash; Frank Robinson of Baltimore and Cito Gaston of Toronto had their teams contending for the American League East title when the regular season reached its climax last weekend. 
 The sport's most prominent black is Bill White, president of the National League. 
 Shell has yet to discuss a contract with Davis, but said: &bquo;I have no problem with that. 
 When I was a player, I'd go into his office and we'd talk contract for five minutes about other things for 30 minutes.&equo; 
 Shanahan took over the Raiders in February last year having previously been the offensive co-ordinator with the Denver Broncos. 
 He guided them to a respectable 8-8 record last season, but with a cluster of outstanding players on the club's roster there was a heavy weight of expectation for the campaign which began four weeks ago &mdash; notably from Davis himself. 
 In those circumstances the Raiders' record of three defeats in four games proved unacceptable. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't admit a mistake even if I made one,&equo; Davis said. 
 &bquo;This is not done in anyway to downgrade anyone else. 
 &bquo;When I hired Michael, I thought our organisation needed a fresh implementation of ideas to go along with what we were doing. 
 I felt what was happening was we were going not in the direction of addition, but of total change. 
 &bquo;I'm sensitive to my head coach, it's the toughest job in America, possibly including the President of the United States. 
 You are dealing with the lives of people and under the microscope every day.&equo; 
 Football: Knighton seeks help to rescue his United deal 
 By FRANK KANE 
 MICHAEL KNIGHTON has been offering Manchester United to a circle of prominent businessmen in the North-west in an effort to salvage his &pound;20m takeover of the club, it emerged yesterday. 
 He has been in contact with Eddy Shah, the former national newspaper proprietor; Owen Oyston, who owns Manchester's Piccadilly Radio and Blackpool football club; and Amer Midani, the Lebanese-born director who is the second largest shareholder on the United board. 
 Shah said he wrote to Knighton when his offer to buy out the shareholding of United's chief executive, Martin Edwards, was first made public, and received a phone call last Friday from Knighton, who asked him if he wanted to participate in the deal. 
 Shah declined, but said he would be willing to help finance it for a fee. 
 Shah said that he was later offered Edwards's 51 per cent holding, which Knighton has agreed to buy for around &pound;10m, but only on payment of a &pound;6m premium. 
 Shah made a counter offer, which expired last night, with a &pound;1m premium. 
 The former Today owner said he had seen documentation from Scottish financial institutions which put Knighton's personal net worth at &bquo;around &pound;3m&equo;, and added: &bquo;I think he should now step aside and let somebody in who has the interests of the club at heart.&equo; 
 A confidant of Owen Oyston, the Lancashire businessman who owns the Miss World beauty competition business, said that Knighton and Oyston met at Manchester City's Maine Road ground last Saturday. 
 &bquo;A proposition was put to Owen, and he is considering it,&equo; the source said. 
 Meetings between the two men lasted into Saturday night and continued at a religious service on Sunday. 
 Oyston's position is complicated by his involvment in Blackpool. 
 Football League regulations impose limitations on an individual's ownership of shares in more than one club. 
 However, it was suggested that he could overcome that hurdle by signing the Blackpool involvement over to his wife. 
 &bquo;Owen would want to be a significant force at United. 
 He wants to be the real power there, rather than a minority,&equo; the aide said. 
 It is believed that Knighton has also had talks with Midani, at which he offered him control of the club, with Knighton himself staying on as vice-chairman. 
 Knighton told the Manchester Evening News: &bquo;There has been a whole lot of speculation and a lot of misinformation. 
 There is no question of me not being involved in a United deal. 
 At this time I do not intend relinquishing the deal. 
 I shall be staggered if I am not involved with the club at the end of this month. 
 I shall have a lot to say when the time comes.&equo; 
 Despite his insistence that the deal is on schedule, it now looks certain that the offer as it currently stands will not proceed. 
 A close associate of Knighton said that one option being considered was to sell on part of his Isle of Man holding company, M K Trafford, through which the offer is being made. 
 The same source estimated Knighton's asset backing at as much as &pound;25m, mainly in the form of property in the north of England and Scotland. 
 He is believed to own around 40 properties there and in the Isle of Man, as well as a large private art collection which could be worth &pound;1m. 
 Knighton has promised to post a formal offer document to shareholders by 11 October, but he could run into problems with the City Panel on Takeovers and Mergers, which is likely to require details of his financial backing. 
 This would normally be given in the form of a letter of authentication from a reputable bank. 
 There is also uncertainty surrounding the role of David Murray, the Rangers football club chairman, who has acted as a middle man in the negotiations but who has denied he has any financial interest in the takeover. 
 Knighton has hardly been out of the news since announcing his intention to buy United on 18 August, the day before the Football League season began. 
 The following day he introduced himself to the Old Trafford crowd by appearing in playing gear and juggling with the ball before United's game against the champions Arsenal. 
 Rugby Union: Andrew gives French lesson 
 From STEVE BALE at Parc des Princes 
 France.......... 27 Home Unions XV.. 29 THE LIONS' claws have not been drawn by the two months they have had apart since Australia. 
 The 11 tourists, with a lot of help from the four friends who made up last night's team, gave an astounding display to inflict on France their first defeat here for seven years. 
 Their makeshift pack performed heroics, and the backs found the spirit of adventure whose absence was so often criticised Down Under. 
 Its product was two tries by Gavin Hastings, who totalled 22 points, and one by Rob Andrew. 
 What made it more extraordinary was that everything had conspired against them, from the Home Unions committee's refusal to grant them official Lions status right through to the kick-off. 
 The Lions &mdash; well, they were wearing those familiar red shirts &mdash; scored a magnificent try only 64 seconds into the game. 
 Each member of the back row handled in a drive off a scrum and when the ball came back Andrew looped round Jeremy Guscott to score at the posts. 
 This was augmented by Hastings's conversion and two penalties, and only now, with more than a quarter of the match gone, did France pull themselves together and begin to pull back the Lions' lead. 
 Didier Camberabero kicked a penalty and converted a characteristic try by Serge Blanco. 
 But as soon as Blanco had dummied past a static defence Lions countered with their second try, in first-half injury time. 
 This time Damien Cronin kept going a move that seemed about to die and Hastings just made the line near the corner. 
 This dispirited the French at the moment their fortunes were improving, and their problems were exacerbated when Hastings added his third penalty and his second try in the first 10 minutes of the second half. 
 Again the try came from a concerted attack involving forwards and backs, Guscott and Brendan Mullin barely managing to squeeze the last two passes away. 
 France conjured a breathtaking try on the counter-attack, by the new flanker Philippe Benetton, which Camberabero converted and after Andrew had dropped a goal produced a furious finale in which Camberabero scored two penalties and a converted try. 
 The Lions were thankful that Hastings landed his fourth penalty. 
 Rugby League: Widnes enter dreamland 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 Widnes............ 30 Canberra Raiders.. 18 FOR 20 minutes at Old Trafford last night, it looked as if Graham Lowe might be proved right. 
 British Rugby League, the former Wigan coach had said, was living in dreamland if it thought its standards had risen to match those of Australia. 
 The Foster's World Club Challenge, attended by 30,786, proved, however, two things other than that the competition deserves to continue: the best of Britain can live with the best of Australia; and Widnes are a team of immense character. 
 The opening minutes, however, were ominous. 
 Widnes were stopped in their tracks by the ferocity of the Australian tackling, while Canberra gained yardage relentlessly, barging through the defensive line at will and utilising the width with effortless passes. 
 The first try came after a period of sustained pressure, when Mal Meninga had the strength to force over from close range. 
 The second arrived only two minutes later, and again Meninga was involved, this time with a forceful run up the right wing before crisp passing allowed Chris O'Sullivan a clear path to the posts. 
 Once the English champions found their way into the Canberra half, 27 minutes into the game, they made their first attack count. 
 Tony Myler made the initial breakthrough, then Joe Grima's surge was finished in the left corner by Paul Hulme. 
 Jonathan Davies could not manage the touchline kick, but was successful from a similar position five minutes before the interval, when inspired play by Derek Pyke and Philip McKenzie presented Martin Offiah with a try with virtually his first touch of the ball. 
 So Canberra turned round with a 12-0 lead cut to 12-10, knowing they were not going to get everything their own way. 
 Any relief Widnes might have felt at the non-appearance of the injured Meninga after half-time evaporated when Myler departed with a head wound a minute after the restart. 
 In the 45th minute, the French referee sent Daley to the sin bin for his recklessly high challenge on Davies, allowing the Welshman's touchdown in the right corner to stand. 
 Ahead for the first time, Widnes scored two tries in Daley's absence, Offiah claiming a second, after an astute pass by Grima, then finding huge spaces in a disoriented defence to give Richard Eyres sight of the line. 
 Daley's return prevented a further score until five minutes from time, when Widnes went the length of the pitch when Barry Dowd broke to give Darren Wright a try. 
 Walters scored a try on a last-minute consolation raid for Canberra. 
 Football: Graham wings in to wound Chelsea 
 By JONATHAN FOSTER 
 Scarborough.. 3 Chelsea...... 2 (Scarborough win 4-3 on agg) NOT SINCE Charles Laughton has Scarborough produced better theatre than the thunderous denouement which barged Chelsea off the Littlewoods Cup stage at Seamer Road last night. 
 Mathematics if not logic equated the two-goal lead Chelsea had established on the hour with a third-round place for the First Division side after the two clubs had drawn 1-1 at Stamford Bridge. 
 But Scarborough had been an urgent Fourth Division yard and a sturdy tackle better from the opening minutes of the second leg, when Dave Beasant had needed to stretch twice to low drives. 
 And from the wings of obscurity Tommy Graham emerged in the 67th minute to meet Martin Russell's cross with a header that summoned an onslaught. 
 Graham, the 31-year-old brother of Arthur, was one of four veterans last night of Scarborough's rise from the Conference: one of those latent talents who has lain mostly latent. 
 Graham relished the opportunity to upstage Chelsea and found in the talented Russell the width to dominate the game from midfield. 
 So Chelsea had more reason than alliteration to fear a third successive failure to reach the third round. 
 What Scunthorpe managed last season Scarborough achieved despite the disappointment of seeing one of their most sustained periods of pressure relieved with the Steve Clarke goal which gave Chelsea the lead. 
 The defender scored with a 25-yard drive after 53 minutes, his long run one solution to Chelsea's midfield indifference. 
 And it was with a certain indifference that, six minutes later, Chelsea hoisted a long ball under which Kerry Dixon loitered. 
 Not for the first time, Kevin Blackwell chose to sprint rashly from his goal; both he and Dixon were beaten by the bounce, and Kevin Wilson outstripped his marker to score. 
 But Graham and Russell, if anything more composed, made them defend that advantage, and the Chelsea defence responded with a disorder to which only Ken Monkou was an exception. 
 After 70 minutes, Paul Robinson, a tall, long-necked forward, stubbed Scarborough's second from close range. 
 Blackwell was immediately inspired to a fine save, and, in the 73rd minute, the ball was played forward quickly. 
 Clarke seemed momentarily to have the legs of Steve Norris, but as the Scarborough forward edged ahead Clarke used his arm to restrain him. 
 Russell converted the penalty, Beasant (and Chelsea) going completely the wrong way. 
 Football Round-Up: Thomas quick to do the trick 
 By CAMERON KELLEHER 
 ON a night of close finishes in Littlewoods Cup second round second leg matches, away goals ensured safe passages for West Bromwich Albion and Crystal Palace. 
 A John Thomas hat-trick enabled Albion to take the aggregate score to six apiece with a 5-3 win at Bradford, while Palace won 3-2 having lost 2-1 in the first leg of their clash with second division basement dwellers, Leicester City. 
 The Welsh international Dean Saunders also got in on the hat-trick act as Derby County overturned a 2-1 deficit against Cambridge United with a 5-0 victory to leave them 6-2 overall winners. 
 Not to be outdone, Liverpool defender Steve Staunton capably filled the striking boots of Ian Rush for the second half, scoring all three goals in their 3-0 win over Wigan for an 8-2 aggregate result. 
 Terry Gibson was on target twice to help Wimbledon eclipse Port Vale 3-0 for a 5-1 win on aggregate. 
 LITTLEWOODS CUP Third-round draw: Tranmere Rovers v Millwall; Everton v Luton Town; Aston Villa v West Ham United; Middlesbrough v Wimbledon; Sunderland v Bournemouth; Crystal Palace v Nottingham Forest; Manchester United v Tottenham Hotspur; Newcastle United v West Bromwich Albion; Southampton v Charlton Athletic; Manchester City v Norwich City; Derby v Sheffield Wednesday; Exeter City v Blackpool; Arsenal v Liverpool; Swindon v Bolton Wanderers; Queen's Park Rangers v Coventry City; Oldham Athletic v Scarborough. 
 Ties to be played week beginning 23 October. 
 The Football League's attempts to bring their 14-month search for a chief executive to an early conclusion by choosing between Gordon Taylor of the Professional Footballers' Association and Arthur Sandford, chief executive of Nottinghamshire county council, look destined to fail. 
 The League's management committee has decided to invite the two candidates it agreed upon on Monday for interview, but the head-hunting process which has caused so much vexation is threatening the ultimate embarrassment. 
 Both men are unhappy about the maladroit way the matter has been handled, and are in the mood to refuse to be interviewed. 
 Sandford, a lawyer before becoming the youngest chief executive in local government, was upset when his name was leaked to the press, and Taylor is incensed to find himself suddenly only a contender for a job to which he was appointed in August. 
 Bryan Robson was yesterday officially added to the England squad for the World Cup qualifying game with Poland in Chorzow next Wednesday. 
 Boxing: Mason's seventh heaven: Ken Jones reports from the Royal Albert Hall 
 By KEN JONES 
 A CONSIDERABLE future opened up for Gary Mason here last night when he knocked out Tyrell Biggs as the bell rang to end the seventh round. 
 By then both men were heavy-legged and Mason's inexperience at this level of boxing looked like becoming a decisive factor until he closed in and sent the American down with a short right to the temple and then a following left hook. 
 Biggs rolled over on to his back and remained motionless for more than two minutes after referee Larry O'Connell had completed the count. 
 If not a thoroughly convincing victory it further establishes Mason in the heavyweight division and his career will now take definite shape. 
 Nevertheless he will be required to introduce more variety into his boxing and before the end came there were once again serious doubts about his stamina. 
 The most obvious manifestation of this came when he remained almost immobile in the centre of the ring while Biggs picked him off with jabs from long range. 
 But Biggs also ran out of steam as the contest progressed towards the later rounds although he managed to conceal this inadequacy from the British champion. 
 A delighted Mason could not be sure which punch ended Biggs's interest in the proceedings and no one could be sure about the outcome as the bell approached. 
 Before a demoralising defeat when challenging Mike Tyson for the world heavyweight championship two years ago Biggs would have probably been too dangerous a proposition for Mason but something has gone from him since then and he was unable to fulfil bold pre-fight assertions. 
 Both men took heavy blows and by withstanding the best of the American's punches Mason at least emphasised that he has a strong enough chin. 
 It was not a contest to excite the audience and there must have been some anxiety in Mason's corner as it approached a critical stage. 
 Mason was ahead but Biggs for a while looked the stronger man and employed his superior technique to suggest that Mason might be running into trouble. 
 He took four of six rounds and yet without ever making his supporters believe that a decisive victory was on the cards. 
 Despite being out-jabbed, the British champion kept boring forward and when he got inside, taking punches in order to do so, he landed some solid right hooks to the head and the body. 
 There was never much conviction in the way Biggs fought, his attitude more that of a man boxing from memory rather than one attempting to resurrect a shattered career, and Mason was never persuaded that genuine peril might result from exchanges in the middle of the ring. 
 The manner of Biggs's defeat was to say the least surprising and on this evidence Mason has still a long way to go before he can think of himself as a genuine contender for the world championship. 
 Rugby League: Grainey grasps the reins at beleaguered Salford 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 TOMMY GRAINEY was appointed caretaker coach at Salford yesterday, in the wake of Kevin Ashcroft's unexpected resignation. 
 Grainey, formerly assistant to Ashcroft at the Willows, will select the side for the home match against Leigh on Saturday, doubtless with reservations about his first match in charge being televised live. 
 Salford intend to advertise for a full-time successor to the First Division's longest serving coach. 
 Ashcroft, who took over at Salford when Alex Murphy left in 1980, has had two spells at the Willows, broken by a couple of seasons at Warrington between 1982 and 1984. 
 A close working relationship with John Wilkinson, the club chairman, developed over the last five years, and Ashcroft's position was considered one of the First Division's safest. 
 What unseated the 45-year-old coach, who volunteered his resignation and left &bquo;the best of friends with everyone&equo;, was Salford's worst start to a season for years. 
 The club have twice narrowly avoided relegation in the last three years, and survived last season only because of a bright start, but have yet to pick up a point in the present campaign after playing five league games. 
 &bquo;We had six good seasons under Kevin but I suppose his departure had to happen,&equo; Wilkinson said. 
 &bquo;It's been a hard start and results have not been right. 
 The club have to come first.&equo; 
 Only Barrow keep Salford off the bottom of the table, and while the Cumbrians already appear resigned to relegation, the Mancunians, who have spent considerable sums on rugby union internationals such as Adrian Hadley and Peter Williams in recent seasons, had their sights set higher. 
 Just 12 months ago, Salford were contesting a Lancashire Cup final against Wigan, but whoever succeeds Ashcroft will be given a more familiar brief, simply to avoid the drop. 
 Ashcroft's efforts in recent seasons have been worthy of Houdini, but this year, if Sheffield Eagles continue to confound their doubters, Salford could have the strongest claim on the spare relegation place. 
 Nicky Kiss, the Wigan hooker, is out of tonight's Lancashire Cup semi-final at Oldham with a trapped nerve in his back. 
 Oldham, unsurprisingly, named the same side as the one who won at St Helens in the last round. 
 Football: Wolves are tamed by Villa 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 STEVE BULL, the striker England feel they can do without, again emphasised the power that has set him poles apart from other strikers, at Molineux last night. 
 But Bull's eighth goal of the season was Wolves' only reward for their territorial dominance, and Aston Villa squeezed into the third round by virtue of the early goal Derek Mountfield had added to their first-leg advantage. 
 Bull's reply prompted a hurricane finish by the Second Division side after a period in which Villa looked to have weathered the storm. 
 In the last minute, Bernie Gallacher, the Villa full-back, denied Wolves the chance of extra time when he headed Shane Westley's header from under the bar. 
 Wolves have now failed to progress beyond the second round since they won the then League Cup in 1980. 
 If the result was not one for Graham Turner to celebrate on the third anniversary of his takeover at Wolves, the manner of their performance should certainly cheer him on his 42nd birthday today. 
 It took Wolves 15 seconds to bring a Black Country barrage from the stands with their first, booming aerial &bquo;pass&equo; for Bull to pursue; a further 30 seconds for Villa to concede a corner; and two minutes for Nigel Spink to be forced into a sprawling save by Mark Venus. 
 A pass from Venus sounds like the definitive long-ball game, and Villa's central defenders, Paul McGrath and Mountfield, did well to defend a series of attacks that came out of the night sky. 
 Villa took the lead in the 15th minute against the run of play. 
 Barely 60 seconds after Spink had saved Bull's header at full stretch, Wolves were caught ball-watching by Gordon Cowans's curling free-kick. 
 Mountfield, prising himself away momentarily from the Tipton Terror, met the ball at the far post to score the kind of goal that was his trademark at Everton. 
 Bull's equaliser, though it took an hour to arrive, might also have been stamped &bquo;copyright&equo;. 
 Nigel Vaughan's cross from the left tempted Spink to leave his goal, but Bull ignored the on-rushing keeper and headed the ball into an empty goal from 12 yards. 
 Football: Robson and Pearce join the party 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 BRYAN ROBSON was yesterday officially added to the England squad for the World Cup qualifying game with Poland in Chorzow next Wednesday. 
 Robson, who came through Manchester United's Littlewoods Cup tie with Portsmouth at Old Trafford on Tuesday without problems, will join up with the England party tonight at their team hotel. 
 Now fully recovered from a hairline crack of the shin, Robson spoke to the England manager, Bobby Robson, this morning to tell him that he had suffered no reaction from the Portsmouth game and was fit and well for the Polish trip. 
 Bryan Robson said yesterday: &bquo;I'm feeling great. 
 When I was injured in the first match with Portsmouth at Fratton Park I didn't expect to be playing again in a fortnight. 
 I had a second X-ray on my injury last week and it showed that the crack had healed. 
 I was surprised when the doctors said the injury had gone.&equo; 
 The England captain, who missed the World Cup match with Sweden in Stockholm last month because of bruised ribs, was happy with his performance against Portsmouth, saying: &bquo;I was pleased to get through the 90 minutes. 
 I was involved in some fairly strong tackling and didn't feel a thing. 
 Now I have another week to get my fitness up to the right level.&equo; 
 Bobby Robson said: &bquo;I spoke to Bryan and he declared himself fit and willing to join up with the party. 
 That was just the news I was hoping for. 
 &bquo;It is a real bonus after I fully expected him to be unavailable for the Poland match. 
 I'm looking forward to the match and to seeing him training. 
 &bquo;It really has been an amazing recovery and I understand he gave an outstanding performance in his comeback match.&equo; 
 Bobby Robson received further encouragement when Stuart Pearce, the Nottingham Forest captain reported fit after taking part in the 3-3 Littlewoods draw at Huddersfield. 
 Forest prevailed after extra time on the away-goals rule. 
 Pearce, who was suffering from an ankle injury, came through unscathed and will be joining the England party at Burnham Beeches, Buckinhamshire, today. 
 David Seaman, the Queen's Park Rangers goalkeeper and Peter Shilton's international deputy, has also recovered from injury so the only England doubt now is John Barnes, the Liverpool winger who pulled a hamstring in training. 
 Barnes still has a week to recover, but Liverpool's manager, Kenny Dalglish, is making no predictions. 
 &bquo;We shall have to wait and see but Bobby Robson will be the first to hear,&equo; Dalglish said. 
 England require just one more point to ensure their place for the World Cup finals in Italy next summer and Robson said: &bquo;Everybody knows the importance of the game. 
 It's important that we don't lose but we won't be going there for a draw.&equo; 
 FIFA has designated next Wednesday's World Cup tie between the Republic of Ireland and Northern Ireland in Dublin as a &bquo;high risk&equo; match. 
 The Football Association of Ireland said last night that it was unhappy with FIFA's decision. 
 Joe Delaney, the FAI's security officer, said: &bquo;FIFA have known for long enough when and where this match would be played and the background to it. 
 Yet when we played in Belfast, that was not considered high-risk. 
 We are surprised FIFA have waited until now to make their high-risk ruling, particularly as Northern Ireland cannot now qualify for the World Cup finals.&equo; 
 Rugby Union: Orrell in search of a repeat victory 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 ORRELL, the North's only representatives in the Courage First Division, who are anxiously looking for their first League win of the season, can take some comfort from the news that Les Cusworth will not be around to torment them when Leicester visit Edge Hall Road on Saturday week. 
 Cusworth, England's former stand-off who still turns it on for the Tigers, leaves for a fortnight's holiday next week. 
 Orrell, though, may feel that they could have coped with Cusworth after causing one of last season's League upsets by winning 27-15 at Welford Road. 
 In order to build up for the trip to Orrell, Cusworth is omitted from the Leicester side to face Coventry at home this weekend. 
 His place will be taken by Jez Harris in one of three changes from the team beaten at Llanelli, Alan Warwood coming into the centre for the local county captain, Kevin McDonald, and Malcolm Foulkes-Arnold replacing Alex Gissing in the second row. 
 Paul Dodge, once the hard centre amongst England's backs, is recovering from a pulled hamstring and expects to make the Orrell trip, but there are still doubts about the fitness of John Wells, the England B flanker whose hamstring problems may keep him out for two more weeks. 
 Down in the South-West, Simon Halliday has been elevated to the captaincy in the build-up to the December divisionals. 
 The Bath and England centre will assume the role in a warm-up game against Cornwall, last season's beaten County Championship finalists, at Exeter on 31 October. 
 The South-West &mdash; whose Bath-Bristol-Gloucester resources have appeared in the past to resemble rugby's equivalent of the Bermuda Triangle &mdash; are set on improving their disappointing Divisional Championship record, and their success against Leinster in Dublin last week was seen as a first step in the right direction. 
 While Halliday takes on a new role, David Irwin is just happy to return to the scene. 
 Irwin, the centre whose back injury ruled him out of Ireland's tour of North America, plays his first game for four months when Instonians take on Malone this weekend. 
 Irwin has also been selected as captain to face Connacht in Galway on Saturday week by Ulster, who tackle the All Blacks in Belfast on 21 November, three days after the Dublin international. 
 There is mixed news concerning two of England's leading hookers &mdash; Brian Moore and Steve Brain. 
 Moore, who has been resting since the Lions tour, plays his first game of the season for Nottingham, at Northampton on Saturday. 
 Brain, the Rugby captain, is out for a minimum of three weeks with a dislocated collarbone. 
 Derek Quinnell, a Lions selector last season in spite of being ditched by Wales as an assistant coach after that traumatic tour of New Zealand two years ago, is back in the Welsh Rugby Union framework as a selector for the Welsh under-20 squad. 
 BMA accuses Clarke of reneging on drug pledge 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 RELATIONS between the British Medical Association and Kenneth Clarke, the Secretary of State for Health, reached a fresh low last night, as doctors' leaders accused him of appearing to renege on promises that patients' drugs would not be cash-limited under the Government's National Health Service plans. 
 Mr Clarke retorted that the BMA was being &bquo;absurd&equo; in trying to reopen the issue. 
 The new row follows talks last week at which Mr Clarke said that the &bquo;firm&equo; drug budgets to be given to regional health authorities and family practitioner committees would not operate, as the BMA feared, as cash limits. 
 A joint statement to that effect was issued afterwards. 
 But the next day Mr Clarke insisted that nothing had in fact changed from the NHS White Paper because it had not talked of cash limits, only of firm budgets. 
 What had changed, he said, was that the association had finally accepted his assurance that patients would get all the drugs they needed under the new system. 
 Yesterday Dr John Marks, the chairman of the association's council, said the crucial phrase lay in a working paper accompanying the White Paper which said there would be legislation &bquo;to require&equo; authorities to keep to their drug budgets. 
 The BMA's understanding when it left last Wednesday's talks, he said, was that that no longer applied. 
 Mr Clarke, however, had since said nothing had changed. 
 &bquo;If there is to be legislation for health authorities to keep to drug budgets, then cash limits must apply,&equo; Dr Marks said. 
 Dr Ian Field, the association's secretary, said it was prepared to accept there had been a misunderstanding. 
 But Mr Clarke's statements since the meeting &bquo;give the impression that he reneged on his promise to us. 
 We just don't know whether his assurances stand or not. 
 He gives us the assurance one day and the very next day seems to retract or contradict it.&equo; 
 If the legislation did contain a requirement for authorities to keep to drug budgets, &bquo;we shall be shouting &bquo;foul&equo; loud and clear,&equo; Dr Field said. 
 Mr Clarke said last night: &bquo;What I said after the meeting was exactly what I said at the meeting and exactly the same as I have been saying since the White Paper was published. 
 &bquo;I told the BMA at our meeting that I was not changing my ground, and after my explanation of the position they accepted my assurance.&equo; 
 No objection had been raised at the time, he said, and &bquo;it is absurd that they should start to quibble a week later and try to reopen the issue&equo;. 
 Sotheby's lent Bond 15m pounds to buy &bquo;Irises&equo;: Australian entrepreneur hopes to pay off debt to auctioneers by selling important Manet painting 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN, Art Market Correspondent 
 THE WORLD'S highest auction price for a work of art, the &pound;30.2m paid for Van Gogh's Irises, was achieved after the auctioneers, Sotheby's, had advanced half the money to Alan Bond, the Australian entrepreneur, it was revealed yesterday. 
 Michael Cross, speaking on behalf of Mr Bond, who bought the picture at Sotheby's in 1987, confirmed to The Independent that &bquo;Sotheby's approached us and offered us a loan facility against the picture.&equo; 
 The loan covered 50 per cent of the purchase price, he said, and the amount outstanding was now &bquo;significantly less than 50 per cent&equo;. 
 Mr Cross is managing director of Dallhold Investments, Mr Bond's private holding company through which he owns shares in Bond Corporation, Bond International Gold and other companies, as well as an extensive art collection. 
 &bquo;There is not a default. 
 We have met the terms of the loan,&equo; Mr Cross said, answering widespread speculation that Mr Bond, whose commercial empire is troubled, had been forced to hand over the painting to Sotheby's for resale. 
 Mr Cross also denied that Mr Bond was trying to sell the painting himself. 
 The sale of Irises was the first important test of the art market's resilience to Black Monday, the stock market crash of 19 October 1987. 
 The record price caused a revolution in market sentiment. 
 Many sales had been left with high unsold percentages over the previous two weeks, though some had been successful. 
 The sale of Irises sparked a boom which has still not run out of steam. 
 Sotheby's would not comment on their approach to Mr Bond yesterday. 
 They would not confirm the loan &mdash; on the ground that they never comment on arrangements with clients. 
 &bquo;All loans that we have outstanding would appear in the balance sheet under the loan portfolio,&equo; a spokeswoman said, but she would not confirm that this item currently includes the Bond loan. 
 She denied that the company's approach to Mr Bond had artificially inflated the price. 
 &bquo;The decline of 19 October had no noticeable affect on the art market,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;It was followed by a number of record-breaking sales such as jewellery, American paintings and silver. 
 The Impressionist sale, which contained the Irises, was very successful all through. 
 There were several bidders around the &dollar;40m level.&equo; 
 The identity of the under-bidder has never been revealed. 
 Sotheby's stated categorically yesterday that the under-bidder had no association with the company. 
 John Payson, who sent the picture for sale at Sotheby's, said yesterday that the bidding had gone well past his minimum. 
 &bquo;Our reserve was way below the sale price. 
 I started breathing hard some &dollar;15m before that.&equo; 
 He said he had been paid for the picture, but admitted that &bquo;in order to entice bidders&equo; he had agreed with Sotheby's that payment would be spread over three instalments. 
 Mr Bond is hoping to pay off his outstanding debt to Sotheby's through the sale of an important painting by Manet, La Promenade, a study of a woman in black, in New York in November. 
 Sotheby's have estimated its value at &dollar;10m-&dollar;14m, but this may be on the low side to ensure a sale. 
 &bquo;This is one that Alan has had for a long period of time,&equo; Mr Cross said. 
 &bquo;He wishes to capitalise on its appreciation and to use the funds for reducing or completely repaying the debt.&equo; 
 An exhibition including the Irises and six other Impressionist works has travelled round the capital cities of Austrlia over the past two and a half months, ending in Perth. 
 The Irises was left on show for an extra fortnight but removed last week for security reasons, according to Mr Cross. 
 It is now in the private gallery on the fifty-first floor of the Bond Tower in Perth. 
 There has been a flurry of colourful rumours over the sale of Irises in the past ten days. 
 According to one, Sotheby's had foreclosed and were seeking to sell the painting themselves in Switzerland at a price around &dollar;35m, a substantial reduction on the auction price &mdash; a private sale being preferred to the public ignominy of auction. 
 According to a second story, Mr Bond had offloaded his entire collection on a Japanese businessman closely associated with the Hong Kong Shanghai Bank, Mr Bond's principal backers. 
 The Bond collection contains 350 paintings, most of them Australian of the Impressionist and Post-Impressionist vintage, Mr Cross said. 
 Exodus spreads to heart of East Berlin 
 From STEVE CRAWSHAW in East Berlin and PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 AS THOUSANDS of East German refugees began leaving Prague in special trains last night bound for the West, the dramatic struggle for emigration reached the streets of the East German capital itself. 
 Berlin police sealed off access to the US Embassy after 18 sought refuge there, and arrested at least 12 more who tried to enter. 
 The 18 later left the building after being assured they would be considered for emigration. 
 The escapers' sense of urgency was intensified by Tuesday's decision by East Germany to end visa-free travel to Czechoslovakia. 
 An unknown number of East Germans were believed to have entered the West German mission in East Berlin, which was officially closed to the public, and others to have gone to the West German Embassy in Sofia, Bulgaria. 
 In Dresden, East Germany, some 3,000 police seized the local railway station, kicking and clubbing crowds. 
 Other stretches of railway track were sealed off. 
 The actions were taken to prevent thousands more emigrants jumping on to a series of trains bound for the West, which last night began carrying out 11,000 East Germans who had found sanctuary in Prague. 
 The first of the 10 special East German Reichsbahn trains finally left Prague at 5.30 local time, almost 24 hours late, reflecting the difficulties encountered by the East Germans in clearing the tracks. 
 West German officials said they understood the trains would be sealed from the inside, and would take roundabout routes to evade jumpers-on. 
 Another 500 East Germans came out through Hungary in the 24 hours to yesterday morning, bringing the total who have left since Hungary opened its borders on 11 September to 26,500. 
 Dozens more East Germans have been going to the West German Embassy in Warsaw, where by yesterday evening more than 400 had collected. 
 Some of them had swum the border rivers, the Oder or the Neisse, despite the knowledge that more than a dozen had drowned. 
 The Polish government has promised not to send them home, but no deal has been reached for their resettlement. 
 Arrivals spoke of arrests by East German patrols on the border. 
 The West German newspaper Bild Zeitung cited East Berlin sources as saying 3,000 people had been imprisoned for attempted &bquo;flight from the Republic&equo;. 
 East German opposition leaders said the atmosphere was becoming explosive, and appealed to the public to avoid violence during East Germany's fortieth anniversary celebrations at the end of the week, which President Mikhail Gorbachev is due to attend. 
 One non-Communist politician, Winfield Wolk, said he feared &bquo;things could happen like in China&equo;, where Mr Gorbachev's arrival in May provoked a hunger-strike on Tiananmen Square. 
 On the verge of tears, Mr Wolk went on television to appeal to people to refrain from taking to the streets, and urged them instead to keep a lit candle in their window. 
 Neues Deutschland, the GDR party daily, displayed a declaration by Erich Honecker, the country's leader, that &bquo;the existence of the Socialist German Democratic Republic is good fortune for our people, and for the peoples of Europe&equo;. 
 US &bquo;missed the chance&equo; to get rid of Noriega 
 From CHRIS MCGREAL in Panama City 
 GENERAL Manuel Antonio Noriega yesterday accused the US of planning and supporting Tuesday's failed coup to topple Panama's resilient military leader. 
 But Washington said that while it had prior knowledge of the plot hatched by three disaffected officers, it did not actively back it. 
 The US was yesterday sheltering on its bases at least two participants in the coup attempt who were among the few to escape death or capture. 
 A speculative report in the daily Critica said Major Moises Giroldi, the head of the elite Urraca battalion who spearheaded the coup attempt, had been killed in the dawn attack on the Defence Forces Headquarters. 
 The failure of the second coup attempt against General Noriega in less than two years has disappointed and enraged some Panamanians who felt the US missed a golden opportunity to use its troops to dispose of the general, indicted by the Americans on drug-smuggling charges last year. 
 Military sources said the key flaw was the plotters' mistaken belief that General Noriega was in the barracks as the rebels attacked. 
 They had planned to hold him hostage to secure the resignation of the strongly pro-Noriega General Staff. 
 Without him, they were unable to consolidate the uprising and were trapped by loyal troops. 
 The situation was further confused because the rebels were led by Major Giroldi, whose battalion is charged with guarding the barracks and who presumably should have known whether the general was inside. 
 Many of the coup participants surrendered to General Noriega personally, and more than 200 soldiers who backed the uprising were arrested after nearly five hours of fighting. 
 General Noriega went on television to say he had been aware of the rebels' plans for about three weeks. 
 His hand-picked President, Francisco Rodriguez, said the government had &bquo;all kinds of proof&equo; that Washington was behind the coup attempt. 
 He said US soldiers had sealed off roads leading to the Panama Canal before the coup attempt, and that US aircraft had circled the combat areas. 
 The US Southern Command called the accusations ridiculous, declaring: &bquo;We had nothing to do with the coup.&equo; 
 The White House admitted it had known of the plot for days and had not discouraged the rebels. 
 The US military source said while there were no promises of specific US military help, it was made clear the rebels would be welcome to send the general to stand trial in the US. 
 Many of the ordinary Panamanians who gave the general such a stinging defeat in May's annulled elections were astonished that the US allowed the coup to collapse when it had 12,000 troops stationed around the canal. 
 Yet US officials were dismayed that there was only one short-lived public demonstration in support of the rebels. 
 The pro-Noriega Press, the only newspapers permitted to publish, gloated over the general's suppression of the coup. 
 But the rebellion was further evidence of a military divided. 
 The rebel officers had been passed over for promotion as General Noriega strengthened his control of the military's two key policy-making bodies, the General Staff and the Strategic Military Council. 
 Strike curb in essential services is postponed 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT, Labour Editor 
 THE GOVERNMENT has postponed any attempt to curb industrial action in essential services and make unions legally liable for unofficial action. 
 Margaret Thatcher had sought to have new laws on the statute book this autumn, but the Government is now more likely to publish a consultative Green Paper towards the end of the year. 
 No final decision has been made on whether there will be legislation, but it would be unlikely to be tabled before next autumn, according to Department of Employment sources. 
 Norman Fowler, the Secretary of State for Employment, may announce the Green Paper at next week's Conservative conference in Blackpool. 
 Whitehall officials have encountered difficulties in deciding which essential services to include. 
 The favoured strategy so far has been to introduce a cooling-off period before industrial action could be taken. 
 Mrs Thatcher has been advised that a complete ban on strikes is not a practical proposition and may entail a high degree of political risk. 
 The Government, however, is likely to press ahead with legislation this autumn which will tighten up the law on secondary action. 
 The new statute will stop trade unionists trying to persuade workers in unconnected companies to take sympathy action. 
 The new Employment Act will also make it unlawful for organisations to refuse to employ a job applicant on the grounds that he or she is not a union member. 
 The plan to make unions responsible for unofficial action arose out of the strikes in the summer on the London Underground, where an informal group of drivers and guards led a long series of stoppages over pay. 
 Opponents of the Government have criticised the policy because it makes unions responsible for disruption which they have not organised and in some cases may oppose. 
 Labour Party leaders, meanwhile, saw their plan for new industrial laws overwhelmingly endorsed at the party conference in Brighton. 
 Some important planks of the policy have yet to be clarified, however. 
 The party has not decided what would constitute a legitimate trade dispute under the law and precisely what forms of secondary action would be sanctioned. 
 Michael Meacher, the shadow Secretary of State for Employment, said that such definitions would have to wait until the party formed a government and the details were worked out between ministers and officials. 
 &bquo;We cannot be expected to draft legislation at this stage,&equo; he said. 
 The Government is likely to snatch at this vagueness in an attempt to discredit the new image of moderation Labour is keen to promote. 
 Mr Meacher said the exact form of a new tribunal system for trying industrial cases had to be worked out within the next three to six months. 
 Delegates approved a policy which would seek to give workers the freedom to organise effective industrial action. 
 Employees would be given the right to belong to a union and to take industrial action, and strikers would be protected from dismissal. 
 Under the legal framework employers would also be prevented from winning interim injunctions to stop disruption backed by lawful ballots. 
 This clause was introduced following the abortive national docks strike this summer. 
 Despite the TUC's call for complete immunity in tort for unions, under a Labour government there would be no return to the pre-1979 position where unions arguably enjoyed a privileged position. 
 Any controversy over the new legal framework would give ammunition to Mr Meacher's critics within the party. 
 Labour's employment spokesman was blamed for much of the confusion which arose at the TUC on the issue. 
 ROCK / Definite articles: LLoyd Bradley on The The at the Town &amp; Country 
 By LLOYD BRADLEY 
 UP UNTIL Mind Bomb it was easy to see why Matt Johnson had never toured The The during its 10-year life span: the group was never more than a shifting collection of session players and &bquo;guests&equo;, songs so devoted to doom and gloom limited audiences to Exit members, the lunacy of the extended format Infected video implied visions far beyond the confines of the stage, and an inflated sense of his own worth would have made the risk of failure too great. 
 But the new album changed all that, with gutsy, chart-orientated pop music, spiced by thought-provoking lyrics. 
 Built around this album, The The at the Town &amp; Country provided as near perfect a late-Eighties rock show as anyone could want. 
 The PA was the same system The Eurythmics used at Wembley and offered clarity and balance. 
 Ex-Smiths guitarist Johnny Marr worked perfectly with Johnson, adding both inspired flights of fancy and substance to the rhythms. 
 Drums and bass were as solid as they come and the keyboards filled in any gaps. 
 While concert performance cannot reproduce all the subtleties of a recording, the band was drilled to precision and communicated the necessary edge with solid strength. 
 After a two-handed version of &bquo;Beat(en) Generation&equo; (Marr and Johnson) &mdash; its natural swagger becoming almost music-hall syncopation &mdash; they dipped into the four-album back catalogue with aplomb. 
 &bquo;Out Of The Blue&equo; was fractured in the extreme, &bquo;Heartland&equo; became a loose-limbed skank, and Marr more than proved his worth on &bquo;Violence of Truth&equo;. 
 Good as the concert was, it was rather too middle of the road for a tour titled &bquo;The The vs The World&equo; and, sadly for fans of the more paranoid earlier work, Johnson's attempts to darken the proceedings ended up looking silly. 
 By not uttering a word to the audience, then keeping the stage shrouded in smoke, lit only from the back in lurid purple, orange and red, and reducing the band to shadowy figures looming out of a fog, he put so much distance between them and anybody past the regulation front-of-stage pogoers that attention easily wandered. 
 And the over-use of an extra microphone, giving his voice the qualities of a US TV cop with a bull horn, made many of the lyrics unintelligible, removing the thrust of his carefully-penned portraits of despair. 
 Under the weight of such cliches, The The were about as dangerous as the average heavy metal band. 
 Still, the level of maturity achieved in the studio, combined with the musical excellence on stage, suggests these irritations may still be ironed out. 
 INTERVIEW / Academician in peril: John Cale, Velvet Underground graduate, has just written an orchestral suite. 
 Martin Aston met him 
 By MARTIN ASTON 
 NICO, PATTI SMITH, The Stooges, Jonathan Richman, La Monte Young, John Cage, Nick Drake, Eno, Squeeze, Happy Mondays &mdash; John Cale's CV is studded with the most intriguing of collaborations; he has traversed more ground and confused more expectations than the average musician has a right to. 
 The fields of classical music, the avant-garde, pop, rock and ambient music have all felt Cale's impact, and he has has zig-zagged between careers as a producer and A&amp;R man and a composer of film soundtracks. 
 But Cale is always likely to be best remembered for his work alongside Lou Reed in the The Velvet Underground. 
 &bquo;I still kind of don't believe it,&equo; Cale mumbles into his sleeve, although modesty is not one of his foremost traits; frankness, bravery and literacy are. 
 Nearly two decades after his first solo album, and four years since his last, Cale has signed to the Opal company (run by his old friend Brian Eno) who have just released Words for the Dying, the bulk of which is Cale's first extended classical work, The Falklands Suite. 
 &bquo;I figured I'd better get started before I ended up like Brahms or something,&equo; he deadpans in a voice that betrays his Welsh origins (he was born in 1942 in Garnant) rather than the last 25 years living in New York. 
 The 30-minute score for orchestra and boy's choir completes more than one personal circle. 
 The suite's core is a setting of four Dylan Thomas poems while the work as a whole finally makes good young Cale's music lessons, when he diligently mastered the viola as well as the high church organ. 
 But on escaping from Wales to study music at Goldsmith's College in London under the auspices of Aaron Copland, Cale decided that &bquo;the best thing for a classical musician in London at that time was to get involved in avant-garde. 
 I didn't know The Rolling Stones had started playing just down by the river.&equo; 
 Regular correspondence with the revered minimalist La Monte Young introduced him to the Dadaist movement Fluxus, but by the time he had won a Leonard Bernstein scholarship to the Berkshire School of Music in Massachusetts, &bquo;I felt I'd run my course as far as the avant-garde was concerned&equo;. 
 The dream ticket to America led to Lou Reed's primitive melodies and documentary realism, not John Cage. 
 Not that that prevented Cale from screaming at a potted plant sitting on his piano, or suddenly demolishing a table beside his stool with an axe in mid-performance. 
 &bquo;A lot of the things I did were done for shock value. 
 But when I joined the Velvet Underground, then it became a little bit more subliminal. 
 Something I always liked about Lou's lyrics was their unstated threat.&equo; 
 The post-Velvets solo albums dealt with the experimental, from Vintage Violence's California-light pop and rock mix and Church of Anthrax's systems music collaboration with Terry Riley, to The Academy in Peril's sombre classical brew and Paris 1919's lavish romanticism. 
 The trio of mid-Seventies snarl-toothed rock albums, Fear, Slow Dazzle and Helen of Troy were the best-received work of his career. 
 Cale became famous for violent demonstrations on stage; there were plenty of screams, stage props, a green surgeon's outfit, the odd tooth-spitting, the beheaded (but long dead) chicken episode which lost him half his band, the time he wore the Cambridge Rapist's mask&hellip; 
 The classical piece Cale always claimed was in him never emerged, mainly because the showman in him wouldn't let it go: &bquo;there was just so much chaos going on, in my personal and creative life, that I couldn't finish&hellip; 
 As the shows progressed, it got more outlandish.&equo; 
 What frustrated his old fans was that when he went it more or less alone, as on 1982's masterfully stark and turbulent Music For A New Society, Cale produced what he also regards as his best album, &bquo;because all the old pain was right there.&equo; 
 The four year hiatus has been a good old-fashioned period of reappraisal; he's learnt to become a good father, he says, while the composing has flourished. 
 His ballet music Sanctus and Carnival and self-explanatory Four Sketches For String Quartet have been performed, he supervised the film soundtrack for Jonathan Demme's Something Wild, and a Canadian documentary on the Falklands has already used Cale's score. 
 The choir came via Llandaff Cathedral Choir School, but (through Opal's Moscow connections) the Orchestra of Symphonic and Popular Music of Gostelradio recorded the suite. 
 After premiering in Amsterdam in 1987, Cale dropped its piano and pedal steel parts &mdash; &bquo;the cabaret aspect&equo; &mdash; because, &bquo;the Soviets played it better than I'd ever imagined, with so much passion. 
 They dug out every inch of expression.&equo; 
 Cale also had misgivings about setting Thomas's poems to music, &bquo;because they sound really beautiful and I didn't know whether I could take something with so much noise in them, so much built-in jazz, and maintain it.&equo; 
 Out of nine poems he set to music, Cale eventually chose four, &bquo;that seemed to hang together, especially &bquo;Lie Still, Sleep Becalmed&equo;. 
 It all became a kind of tribute to the Falklands which was going on at the time of writing. 
 We'd get to one poem four or five days into the war, or after The Belgrano or Sir Galahad, and then you have &bquo;Lie Still&equo;&hellip; which is sombre, like a tribute, and then the others, like &bquo;Do Not Go Gentle Into That Good Night&equo;, which started off as a camp throwaway as a tango; but the poems put together with an orchestra gives them much more depth.&equo; 
 Besides two short piano pieces from Sanctus, Words For The Dying also includes the luminous The Soul of Carmen Miranda, one of three spontaneous and highly promising recordings with Eno that will set the tone for the next album, &bquo;a rock'n'roll record I can be happy with because the percussion won't hit me over the head.&equo; 
 Projects with long-term Dylan sidekick Bob Nuewirth, Ralph Steadman (a theatrical version of &bquo;The Big I Am&equo; book) and contributions to William Burrough's new album are all underway, but the collaboration with Lou Reed is the one most people will be waiting for. 
 Songs For &bquo;Drella, their 14-song tribute to mentor Andy Warhol, who subsidised The Velvet Underground, will be performed at the Brooklyn Academy of Music Festival in November before the pair enter the studio. 
 Cale talks solemnly about unfinished business, &bquo;in terms of the arrangements that we worked so hard on on that first Velvet Unferground album. 
 I don't think Lou remembers how hard we worked, but it was every weekend for 18 months, going over and over these songs until we had all these dismembered arrangements we became famous for. 
 There's going to be a real tug-of-war: &bquo;here comes the past, and is it going to take over?&equo;. 
 But we'll see.&equo; 
 RECORDS / Girls next door 
 By JIM WHITE 
 KYLIE MINOGUE Enjoy Yourself (PWL Records HF9) According to a poll in the magazine Just 17, Kylie Minogue is the person most young girls in Britain would like to be. 
 Two million of them bought her first album (and probably bought all the tracks when they were released as singles as well) thus, in a self-fulfilling arc, making her very rich indeed, and even more enviable. 
 A sensible choice as a young girl's role model, she appears to be so attainable; nothing particularly talented, beautiful or clever about her, just a pleasant-looking girl-next-door who won the pools when she met Stock, Aitken and Waterman. 
 In her second album, which takes a sensibly modest manifesto for its title, the mix is as before; you will hear all the tracks over the next few months if you follow the charts. 
 The songs exhibit change of pace, from disco shake to waltz, but it is difficult to marry the lyrics to the rhythm at which they are sung. 
 This poetic sentence for instance, should it be quick or slow? 
 &bquo;You can't keep me hangin' on / Now the magic's gone&equo;. 
 A trick question: as it happens it appears on a sort of in-between track. 
 This is pop music without guts, without pattern or consistent thought, sung by a voice as thin and weedy, if the sleeve photo is to be believed, as the performer's own physique. 
 No parent in Britain should be remotely alarmed if their daughters are Kylie fans. 
 Which is probably the most offensive thing about her. 
 LIZA MINNELLI Results (Epic EPC 4655111) After toying with Dusty Springfield, the Pet Shop Boys have linked up with another old trouper and produced a scorching collection. 
 &bquo;I want you now / I won't take no for an answer,&equo; runs the first line, and who are we to object? 
 Liza sings it to reverberate round the Albert Hall and the final syllable has more tone and depth than Kylie manages in a whole album. 
 Despite the up-front vocals, it is really a Pet Shop Boys record, all but three of the tracks are their compositions. 
 The exceptions are Stephen Sondheim's &bquo;Losing My Mind&equo;, which was a Top 10 single, the old Motown number &bquo;Love Pains&equo; and, rather curiously, Tanita Tikaram's &bquo;Twist In My Sobriety&equo;, presumably reprised as a nod to Liza's unhappy past acquaintance with the bottle. 
 Even on these, though, the Tennant and Lowe arrangement replaces the lush Nelson Riddle-style orchestral arrangements she is used to with something called &bquo;Fairlight Programming&equo;. 
 The lyrics, too, have a recognisable touch of PSB cynicism, but are perfectly tailored to Liza's strengths: &bquo;I love you, you pay my rent,&equo; she sings on a number you could just imagine undermining the foundations at Caesar's Palace, Las Vegas. 
 JULIA FORDHAM Porcelain (Circa 10) &bquo;You make me feel vulnerable and totally exposed,&equo; is not a lyric you would expect from Kylie Minogue, or even Liza Minnelli. 
 The British public appears to have an increasing appetite for the work of sensitive female singer-songwriters telling us about their tangled emotional lives, and Julia Fordham is the latest high-flier to fulfill the need. 
 The album's title is a rather self-conscious reference to her delicate frame of mind, and if you are of more robust taste the cover portrait of a blonde with an impossibly white complexion climbing up the wall will indicate that you should explore no further. 
 But if you are in mellow frame of mind, there is plenty here to be commended: a good voice, pleasant melodies, clever arrangements and, in among the depression, some light touches of humour: &bquo;I cried the Solent, the Tyne, the Severn and the Rhine, The Thames and The Seine over again'. 
 But, throughout it all, it is hard not to be reminded of the debt owed, yet again, to Carole King. 
 THE KINKS UK Jive (London Records 8281651) Unlike his chums, Pete Townshend and Keith Richards, Ray Davies has remained so prolific that another Kinks album isn't an event, it's another Kinks album. 
 This one, like all the others, shows that Ray has kept his eyes open. 
 There's an ecological number sung in typically spacey fashion &bquo;The world's spinning round, like a looney balloon&equo;; there's an anti-Thatcher song summarising the Prime Minister's lack of sensitivity in the one charge that she doesn't like rock n roll; and, proving that they are probably the only pop band ready for the single European market, there is an EC tribute: &bquo;Down All The Days (to 1992)&equo;. 
 In this, the line &bquo;Bon soir my little senorita, c'est magnifique / Au revoir, my little frauline baby, it's so tragique,&equo;, would qualify Ray, if all else failed, as a script-writer for &bquo;Allo &bquo;Allo. 
 ROCK / Wicked French dressing: Absurd, brilliant performance from French Pogues: Les Negresses Vertes &mdash; Town &amp; Country Club 
 By GILES SMITH 
 SHORTLY before the show began, four carpets were winched down behind the drums to form a backdrop. 
 They matched the rugs draped over the equipment on stage, so you appeared to be looking into a stall at a bazaar. 
 With the lights dimmed, a solo accordion played a brief, preliminary waltz. 
 Then somebody let the livestock loose. 
 If Les Negresses Vertes tend to jostle on the stage like animals being herded down a narrow street, it is partly because there are so many of them (11, when all the strays are rounded up), but also because, even as the show begins, several key members appear to be too drunk to be capable of motion in a straight line. 
 This might sound like irresponsibility, but, given how the performance pans out, you could also read it as professional commitment; the longer the show goes on, the more the drink goes down and, in a remarkable contradiction of physics, the tighter the playing becomes. 
 In fact, midway through the first song, only the size of the band dissuaded you from buying a round to speed up the process. 
 You only had to compare the opening version of Zobi la Mouche (lumpy drums and shuddering halts) with the neatly turned performance eventually wheeled out as an encore, to realise how this is a machine which runs the better for being well-oiled. 
 Les Negresses put on, above all, a comic performance where timing is at a premium. 
 The humour inheres not just in the daffy selection of cultural allusions (their native French accordion, some flamenco guitar, a few African horns) but also in the way they take stiff, formal tempi (waltzes and tangos) and mockingly squeeze them for their stateliness. 
 It also comes naturally to them to include any musical form with a sharp sense of its own absurdity; ska, for instance (there are touches of Madness here) or a hyperactive brand of rhythm and blues (they become almost a French Blues Brothers on Marcelle Ratafia). 
 And with all of these forms, unless the delivery is precise, the comic energy simply drains away. 
 Consequently things only started to get funny around four songs in, just as the band began bringing the stops off cleanly and ending in the same places. 
 At this point the stunt that was being pulled off in the music found its visual equivalent rising to meet it. 
 Helno, the singer, is possibly the worst dressed man in rock. 
 The yellow nylon shirt with the frothy frill amounts to an offence against taste bordering on the criminal, yet it somehow works to offset his complexion (pale blue) and the ensemble enables him to come on like a chat-show host from Hell &mdash; vast smiles and arms flung out in gestures of mock formality. 
 He was the worse for wear in another sense, come the end of the evening. 
 Misty-eyed when he first appeared he looked practically fog-bound during the closing numbers. 
 His voice, though, was getting stronger every minute, which might have been why he alone dispensed with the formality of leaving the stage between encores. 
 Like so much of the show, it gave a touching twist to the common run of things; it was as if he couldn't bear to see us go. 
 TELEVISION / Being beastly to beasts 
 By KEVIN JACKSON 
 PASSIONS run high when the subject of animal rights is raised; so high that the warring factions can be at odds even over ownership of key metaphors in the argument. 
 &bquo;Unnecessary suffering?&equo;, last night's Natural Concern programme (BBC 2), began with shots of the cuddly toys and cartoons with which modern children are sold the lie that &bquo;animals are whimsical, endearing extensions of ourselves&equo;: the emotions which lead people to stick up for animals, that is, can be branded as essentially childish. 
 On the other hand, a pro-rights clergyman suggested that it is our traditional despotic treatment of the non-human creation which has been truly infantile, and that it is only in this century that we have begun to grow up a little. 
 The programme scrupulously refused to attribute full maturity to either faction, dwelling on the bestial acts committed by animal rights terrorists -the Bristol University bombing and so on &mdash; as well as on the vile surgical mutilations which had provoked them, and Ian Breach's presentation script was both deft and literate; a model guide through these complex issues. 
 But the very process of putting pictures to the argument tended to weight the case in favour of the critter lobby. 
 It's easy to sway the emotions by showing monkeys with their brains cut open, genetically stunted pigs or smoking beagles, less so to drag on someone suffering from a vile disease and say &bquo;this person will die unless we keep on chopping up small furry creatures.&equo; 
 (Indeed, the anti-vivisectionists were allowed a small but notable coup on this score: Sue Crowshaw, badly disabled by rheumatoid arthritis, made a moving speech denying scientists the right to claim they were experimenting on her behalf.) 
 Evidently wise to this fact, vivisectionists refused the Natural Concern team access to all their experiments save for some brain operations on rats. 
 It seems a fair bet that Joe Public finds it as hard to feel sorry for rodents as Winston Smith did, and though these lobotomised specimens were of the cuter white kind, it was possibly to watch this sequence without feeling many qualms. 
 The emotional complexity of the debate was deepened by the fact that neither side had the monopoly of logic or charm: Dr Colin Blakemore, though known as &bquo;Dr Frankenstein' to the yellow press for having experimented on animals&equo; eyes, seemed reasonable, persuasive and put-upon; Douglas Hogg, MP, also on the vivisectionist side, was quite startlingly and pointlessly rude. 
 Perhaps the most resonant phrases in the whole debate came from the pro-rights organiser who suggested that future centuries would come to regard our attitude to animals with the same horrified disbelief we now feel for the periods which practised slavery. 
 In fact, the whole programme had an unsually philosophical undercurrent (quoting, for example, philosopher Mary Midgeley) &mdash; so much so that it sometimes seemed less like a current affairs report than an enquiry into a fundamental shift in Western attitudes to nature. 
 All in all, very far from kid's stuff. 
 DANCE / A burden of gravity: Judith Mackrell on The Joel Hall Dancers at the Shaw Theatre and Altynai Asylnuratova in La Bayadere 
 By JUDITH MACKRELL 
 JAZZ DANCE has caught on slowly in this country, and most of what we see is attendant on musicals, cabaret acts or pop videos. 
 There are few choreographers who try to develop its raw appeal &mdash; its punch, slink and sex -into independent dance. 
 So Joel Hall, whose Chicago-based company is currently touring an evening of jazz-derived choreography, might have proved a useful model. 
 But, disappointingly, Hall seems less interested in mining the rich idioms of the form (lindy-hop, tap, Broadway and disco) than in trying to smooth out its vernacular with the classy accents of ballet and modern dance. 
 In works like Compassion (set to Albinoni's Adagio for Strings) and Now You See It, Now You Don't (a solemn confused piece dedicated to the homeless) Hall abandons the drive and sass of works like Nightwalker for emotional and sociological uplift. 
 We are clued into Artistic seriousness by an arabesque or a beaten jump, into Moral seriousness by a hungry contraction or protracted lift. 
 And the weakness of these works is not just that Hall cannot integrate &bquo;arty&equo; steps into jazz without them looking like destitute cliches, it is that his dancers are not adequately trained to look comfortable in mainstream styles. 
 Watching one of them wobble through a developpe in glazed desperation or another sickle his foot in an over-extended arabesque, you feel how cruelly Hall's ambitions tax his company. 
 Yet the same dancers can look confident and articulate when they are performing a style that suits them. 
 In Nightwalker, set to a medley of Duke Ellington, Hall shows that he can dovetail a strong variety of jazz elements without looking derivative, and the men in particular pounce on his choreography with eagerness and panache. 
 With their coiled energy, jumps, louche shoulder work, insinuating hips and limber backs, they look like real dancers. 
 And Hall himself, long and loose, with his body articulated into a thousand joints, shows how naturally this style comes to him. 
 If the programme had continued in the vein of Nightwalker, it would have been highly recommendable but after three examples of Hall in earnest, I felt bludgeoned into beating a retreat. 
 Seeing a great performer dancing true to her native style is part of Altynai Asylnuratova's astonishing impact in La Bayadere. 
 Although the Royal Ballet has acquired a certain Russian expansiveness for this production, Kirov-trained Asylnuratova simply recasts the ballet with the fierce lucidity of her movement. 
 The plot's dramatic excesses, which can be comically absurd, take on a brief reality as she dances. 
 Other Nikiyas &mdash; Durante or Guillem &mdash; may for instance assume a charming Oriental fluidity in their arms, but only Asylnuratova's urgency and amplitude of gesture can convey the destructive extremes of Nikiya's nature. 
 Only she can phrase her movement so that its rhythm speaks so legibly of high spirits or despair. 
 And if Asylnuratova does not possess the imperturbable technique of a Guillem, the expressiveness of her dancing is matched by so mobile and luminous a face that everyone else on stage looks slightly blank. 
 Everyone, that is, except 20-year-old Darcey Bussell, who, as the rich fleshpot's daughter Ganzatti, stands up to Asylnuratova's presence with a staggering authority. 
 She paces dangerously around the stage claiming everything in sight, including Solor, with the naive greed of a woman indulged since childhood. 
 Technically she still has some rough edges &mdash; a peremptoriness in her phrasing, an uncertain control over her own force - but the full easy strength of her dancing and the scale of her projection promise important things to come. 
 THEATRE / Lovers and gamblers: Jeffrey Wainwright reviews Romeo and Juliet 
 By JEFFREY WAINWRIGHT 
 THE ACTORS march on to the stage of the New Victoria in Newcastle-under-Lyme as an Italian town band, with Chorus in a red hat and sash beating the bass drum. 
 It is an immediate, positive image which embodies the character of this production, and indeed of the long tradition at Peter Cheeseman's Vics Old and New. 
 As an image within the action of the play, however, it is soon shattered, as the Montague-Capulet brawling begins. 
 Anny Evason's atmospheric evocation of the Piazza del Erbe, with its salamis, live chickens, fruit barrow and cafe tables, is spectacularly wrecked as the young bloods go to it in the first of Terry King's convincing fights. 
 The period chosen by director Bob Eaton and his designer is late nineteenth century, enabling a potent combination of bourgeois respectability and tight-trousered machismo brought to town from the stiletto world of Cavalleria rusticana. 
 As the stags go play they sustain this tone, especially in the humourless hauteur of Graham Fellows's excellent Tybalt. 
 His foil, Mercutio, is given both lightness and intelligence by Paul McCleary, poring over a table to evoke the tiny fairyland of Queen Mab before shaping the speech outwards as she roams abroad. 
 Romeo has none of his friend's worldliness, and one of Timothy Welton's best moments in the part is the animal way he leans and pushes at Richard Hague's Benvolio in trying to do dying Tybalt further hurt; another is his early gaucheness approaching Juliet. 
 While the best thing about the lovers is the way they convey adolescent awkwardness towards each other, their sexual excitement is less marked and both underplay the eloquence of their ecstatic speeches. 
 Frances Fielding (as Juliet) finds her way through the conceits of Shakespeare's early verse style intelligibly, and though her voice modulates little from a high, anxious note, her portrayal of Juliet's final loneliness is still affecting. 
 A welcome novelty in this production is the inventive presentation of Friar Laurence. 
 Edward York makes him more of a Friar Larry, Romeo's dishevelled contemporary, one of the lads who has unaccountably found himself a Franciscan. 
 Though this means Romeo's assumption that the Friar knows nought of love seem misplaced, it does at least make his rash engagement with the lovers more comprehensible. 
 It is Mr York who bangs the drum in John Kirkpatrick's apparently authentic, and certainly suitable band music. 
 The whole cast performs with similar versatility. 
 If this is not a production that scales the utmost heights of passion, it is one that is thoroughly realised by a team well worthy of the traditions of the house. 
 MUSIC / Flamboyant fantasy: Philharmonia / Salonen &mdash; City Hall, Newcastle 
 By WADHAM SUTTON 
 BALAKIREV'S Oriental fantasy Islamey exists in several versions &mdash; the composer's original, for piano solo, and at least two orchestral transcriptions, one by Lyapunov (a pupil of both Balakirev and Tchaikovsky), the other by the Italian Alfredo Casella. 
 The piano version is a tour de force demanding the prodigious technique of a Brendel or a Cherkassky. 
 The transcriptions are no less taxing, with virtuoso writing for all the orchestra. 
 In Newcastle on Tuesday, the challenges of Lyapunov's scoring were met magnificently by the Philharmonia under the young Finnish conducter Esa-Pekka Salonen. 
 The leader's chair was occupied by the familiar and welcome figure of Bradley Creswick, who recently moved to the Philharmonia from the Newcastle-based Northern Sinfonia. 
 Islamey is a dangerous work with which to start a concert, the agitato semi-quavers of the opening bars requiring considerable precision from an orchestra which has not had time to warm up. 
 The Philharmonia carried it off well. 
 The frantic whirl of the outer sections framed a warm and full-blooded Andantino with some clear woodwind playing, while the well-handled lowering of dynamic in the final pages permitted an exhilarating ascent to Lyapunov's noisy ending. 
 Islamey was followed by a rather quirky performance of Beethoven's Third Piano Concerto, in which the soloist was the 22-year-old Olli Mustonen, a compatriot of the conductor. 
 Comparisons are sometimes drawn between this work and Mozart's great K491 Concerto in the same key, which Beethoven is known to have played and admired. 
 The similarities, however, are mostly in matters of device (the piano arpeggios in the first movement Coda, for example, and the six-eight ending of the Rondo, tragic in Mozart, brilliant in Beethoven). 
 Mozart's heroic brand of oratory is very different from Beethoven's much more robust variety. 
 Mr Mustonen is a young man of flamboyant gesture, and his constant rolling body movements, even when he was not actually playing, soon became irritating. 
 In his hands the concerto was over-dramatic, his tendency in the louder passages to attack the keys from some height with a hard pecking action, and to shorten the staccato and overdo the sforzandi, being foreign to Beethoven's style. 
 Even in the central Largo, for the most part sensitively played, he risked a quite unidiomatic accelerando which, miraculously, the orchestra paralleled. 
 Mozart would not have survived the treatment. 
 Somehow Beethoven did, though it was not, one feels, a reading he would have approved. 
 The concert finished with Stravinsky's Rite of Spring. 
 The story of its ill-fated Paris premiere in 1913, which provoked fighting in the audience, is well known. 
 As it has become familiar over the years, the constant discord and the rhythmic complexities have ceased to shock. 
 Tuesday's performance was outstanding, vivid and of surpassing clarity. 
 The orchestra was in stunning form. 
 As for the conductor, Mr Salonen is making the going just now. 
 On this showing, it is easy to see why. 
 MUSIC / Guiding hands: Gothic Voices &mdash; Wigmore Hall 
 By TESS KNIGHTON 
 IT SEEMS that even in its own time the thirteenth-century motet was considered by many to be a sophisticated, subtle genre, only likely to appeal to the literati. 
 That these generally complex, polytextual pieces can today appeal to an almost capacity house at the Wigmore Hall is largely due to two factors: the superb singing of Gothic Voices, and the ability of their director, Christopher Page, to unlock the musical secrets of the past. 
 Over the years, Page has established himself as a medieval raconteur, delighting his audience with tales of, say, thirteenth-century Paris; but anecdotes aside, he has also been refining the presentation and programming so that, almost without realising it, his audiences learn a good deal about the often totally unfamiliar music being performed. 
 This concert, part of the Early Music Centre Festival, was one of the most overtly educative so far, with even, at one point, an illustrated guide to composing a motet in five easy stages. 
 Yet there is nothing condescendingly didactic in Page's manner, nor anything textbookish about Gothic Voices' performance. 
 Beyond this, what might appear just to be a way of illustrating how motets were put together &mdash; singing the two or three different, often highly contrasted melodies individually before putting them together as a polyphonic, multi-texted whole &mdash; may equally well represent a valid reflection of the manner in which they were originally performed. 
 More often than not, each melodic line stands perfectly well by itself, and hearing it thus at least lends something of the sense of familiarity and recognition that the thirteenth-century literati might have enjoyed if they attempted to disentangle aurally the separate strands of the motet. 
 The members of Gothic Voices (on this occasion five, of whom two were singing with the group for the first time) sing these melodies &mdash; often complex and wide-ranging &mdash; as if they really love them; sensitive to the ebb and flow of the text, they nurture unexpected melodic twists, always allowing the structure to unfold and mould. 
 Of the purely monophonic items included in the programme, Can vei la lauzeta mover was movingly performed by Leigh Nixon, while Rogers Covey-Crump brought out perfectly the sophistications of the courtly love-song Autres que je ne seuill fas. 
 Page's choice of motets illustrated how the different texts could be closely interrelated &mdash; as in Par un matinct l'autrier / He bergier / He sire / Eius, which could be summarised as &bquo;aspects of pastoral love&equo; &mdash; or how each might furnish a satirical commentary on the other &mdash; as in Ypocrite pseudopontifices / O quam sancta / Et gaudebit, with its antithetical opinions of the high clergy. 
 In the former, the emotional trefoil &mdash; disdain, envy, indignation &mdash; might have been more decisively distinguished, though, it is true, the melodies themselves were not so clearly differentiated. 
 The contrast, however, between the patter song of invective against the ecclesiastical hierarchy and the dignified paean to that estate was exploited to the full. 
 The Early Music Centre Festival continues at the Wigmore Hall this evening (Friday 6 October) with the Gabrieli Consort and Players, and on Saturday (7 October) with Emma Kirkby and Anthony Rooley. 
 LEP disappoints with half-time 9.5m pounds 
 By HUGH SHARPE 
 SHARES of LEP, the freight-forwarding and security monitoring company, were marked down 15p to 150p yesterday when its half-time figures failed to meet some market expectations. 
 The company's co-brokers, Hoare Govett, had hoped for &pound;12m before tax; in the event the figure was &pound;9.54m, still 89 per cent up on the corresponding period's &pound;5.04m. 
 Hoare said last night it now expected to be trimming its full year forecast back from the &pound;30m pencilled in so far. 
 Other brokers expect between &pound;29m and &pound;31m. 
 Around 50 per cent of half-time profits were contributed by National Guardian Corporation, the US security monitoring business where LEP increased its stake last year from 40 per cent to 100 per cent via a &pound;50m shares exchange deal. 
 NGC's physical security arm has now been sold for &dollar;20m. 
 For a write-off of &pound;471,000, the company has pulled out of freight-forwarding from all but one South American country, Venezuela, because of the problems of repatriating earnings and coping with hyper-inflation. 
 John Read, the chairman, said that Profit Freight Systems, the company's 59 per cent owned US arm, lost &pound;1.5m after running into a price battle with a competitor. 
 PFS expects to be back in the black for the full year. 
 Prem, LEP's new testing equipment for the Aids virus, is now on the market and should make a &bquo;useful contribution&equo; to profits this year. 
 The interim dividend is up from 1.45p to 1.75p. 
 Earnings per share rose 65 per cent to 5.6p. 
 The company's gearing is 90 per cent. 
 Borrowings largely relate to NGC, which had &pound;80m of debt at the time of takeover and which finances its rapid growth from cash flow. 
 The half-year interest bill was up 77 per cent at &pound;8.5m. 
 United Scientific blasts Meggitt bid 
 By HUGH SHARPE 
 United Scientific Holdings wheeled out one of its Scorpion tanks to blast an unwelcome &pound;102m takeover from Meggitt. 
 Its defence document posted yesterday claims the bid has no industrial logic and undervalues USH whose share price closed at 152p compared with Meggitt's 134p a share offer and 151p partial cash alternaive. 
 Galliford reports a 30% improvement 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 GALLIFORD, the construction company, boosted full year returns by 30 per cent on the back of a full one-point increase in pre-tax profits margins to slightly more than 5 per cent. 
 Group pre-tax profits to 30 June increased from &pound;7.11m to &pound;9.22m on turnover ahead just 3 per cent to &pound;181m. 
 Housebuilding profits rose from &pound;1.6m to &pound;3m although the company warned that the division's returns would fall this year. 
 George Marsh, managing director, said that housebuilding was now &bquo;bumping along the bottom&equo;. 
 Galliford completed 150 houses in East Anglia, with the average sale price increasing from &pound;42,000 to &pound;56,000. 
 The greater part of group sales are in commercial construction and civil engineering, and Galliford hopes to take advantage of increased infrastructure spending in the next deacde, particularly on water and road projects. 
 CRH, the Irish-based international building materials group, has acquired two Dutch companies for Ir &pound;11.7m (&pound;10m). 
 The move strengthens CRH's retailing operations in the Netherlands and will lift its annual clay brick production in that country above 50 million. 
 New trust aims to halt trend 
 By ALISON EADIE 
 IVORY &amp; SIME, the Edinburgh fund manager, has launched a new investment trust which it hopes will arrest the trend towards institutional ownership of investment trusts and switch back to individual ownership. 
 The Optimum Income Trust, which will give an income return of 8.5 per cent, is to be marketed to financial intermediaries as well as stockbrokers. 
 It will have a minimum size of &pound;27.5m and a maximum of &pound;67.5m, depending on the level of take-up. 
 The trust is designed to meet the terms of qualification for Personal Equity Plans, the opportunities created by the segregation of husband and wife taxation next April and the needs of the private investor and his independent financial adviser. 
 It will invest about 80 per cent of its funds in blue chip UK equities. 
 It aims to achieve a high level of income for ordinary shareholders as well as providing capital growth. 
 A minimum 17.32 million ordinary shares have been underwritten by S G Warburg, the merchant bank, and a further 25.2 million are available for subscription. 
 Zero dividend preference shares are also being issued in a ratio of 37 for every 63 ordinary shares. 
 They will qualify for capital growth but no income. 
 Photo-Me beats forecasts with 15m pounds 
 By HUGH SHARPE 
 PHOTO-ME International, the world's biggest photo-booths operator, yesterday announced slightly better than expected full year results. 
 Pre-tax profits advanced by 35 per cent to &pound;15.23m on turnover up by 23 per cent to &pound;94.46m. 
 The dividend total is doubled to 6p through a final payment of 4.8p, covered comfortably by earnings per share of 28.34p up from 19.72p. 
 Photo-Me's shares gained 5p to 560p. 
 Terence Chute, the chairman, explained that over the past year the company has invested over &pound;11m in revenue producing equipment, with existing operations being upgraded and new subsidiaries launched. 
 He added that the group is well-placed to make acquisitions. 
 Photo-Me's identity card venture is still at an embryonic stage, accounting for only 2 &frac12%; of turnover. 
 The company hopes to win business from Football Association clubs to produce membership cards for supporters. 
 Managing director David Miller said that the ID interests could tie in nicely with the photo-booth business. 
 &bquo;Most of us use the booths at one time or another, and they are the obvious place to go if you need a picture for your identity card.&equo; 
 The company is splitting its 5p nominal shares into units of 2&frac12;p to increase their marketability. 
 More than 75 per cent of the equity is in the hands of professional investors, many of them through Swiss nominee names. 
 Microfilm buys in US 
 By HUGH SHARPE 
 MICROFILM Reprographics, the microfilming company, is paying &dollar;5.3m for the micrographic division of American Management Systems of Washington. 
 The division's business is in microfilming computer output and laser printing. 
 Its profits before tax for the current year to 31 December are forecast at &dollar;900,000 on turnover of &dollar;6.5m. 
 A placing of 970,000 new Microfilm shares at 420p a share will be used to fund the acquisition, which follows the purchase of US microfilmer, CMC, for &pound;11.9m in September last year. 
 Microfilm also announced full year results yesterday showing a 50 per cent increase in pre-tax profits to &pound;6m on turnover up from &pound;15m to &pound;24.2m. 
 Richard Hayman of merchant bank Morgan Grenfell said the rise in turnover reflected the inclusion of CMC. 
 He added that CMC boosted profits by about &pound;1.3m. 
 News in brief 
 By HUGH SHARPE 
 TSW-TELEVISION South West reported taxable profits of &pound;3.19m for the year to 31 July, compared with &pound;3m in the previous year. 
 Earnings per share were a shade higher at 8.54p (8.43p). 
 A final dividend of 3p increases the total payout by 1p to 4.15p. 
 Purchases and disposals TYNE Tees TV is buying the Television Centre in Newcastle upon Tyne from Tritel, a subsidiary of Mecca, for &pound;4m cash. 
 James Finlay improves profits 
 Business and City Page 26 
 Abtrust New Dawn to raise 18.9m pounds 
 By ALISON EADIE 
 ABTRUST New Dawn Investment Trust, which specialises in the developing markets of the Far East, is raising &pound;18.9m net through a conditional placing and offer to shareholders. 
 The offer is on the basis of one new share for one old at 128p per share. 
 In addition a series B warrant will be issued with every five new shares. 
 The cash raising exercise comes just five months after the &pound;15m launch of the trust by Aberdeen Fund Managers via a placing at 100p per share. 
 Hugh Young, fund manager, admitted that with the benefit of hindsight the original launch was not large enough. 
 The original money was quickly invested and there has since been a stream of rights issues, particularly from companies in Thailand where the fund is 37.8 per cent invested. 
 The Indonesian market has also opened up to foreign investment allowing up to 49 per cent of any listed company or new issue to be bought by foreigners compared with only 11 companies being open to foreign investment previously. 
 Mr Young said he has had to sell stock he would prefer to keep in order to take advantage of new opportunities. 
 The Indonesian stock market, where 6.9 per cent of funds are invested, has risen 53 per cent since Abtrust New Dawn was launched and the Thai stock market 30 per cent. 
 The trust has appreciated 60 per cent in value since its launch. 
 It second largest area of investment is Taiwan (17.2 per cent) and third is South Korea (16.3 per cent). 
 Institutional shareholders have agreed to subscribe for 35.8 per cent of the offer. 
 Mr Young said that now the trust had its core holdings, the second tranche of money would be invested more slowly with some held back for new opportunities. 
 Armchair Investor: Betterware 
 By ALISON EADIE 
 WOE betide a small company in an unfashionable sector. 
 If few analysts follow it, the general tide of the market will wash the company away, even if it is countercyclical. 
 Thus shares in Betterware Consumer Products dropped 12p to 180p yesterday as the market knocked the retail sector for six in the wake of the interest rate hike. 
 How many of the sellers understood that Betterware is a beneficiary of high interest rates? 
 The company is based on a novel concept of direct selling, which involves representatives knocking on doors with catalogues and selling household goods on the back of it. 
 When times are hard, more people apply to be representatives and Betterware expands its distribution base. 
 This is done at little cost as representatives are paid on a commission basis. 
 Also the company has net cash of around &pound;2.5m, and so enjoys extra income with higher interest rates. 
 The market reaction was even more bizarre considering Betterware reported an increase in first-half pre-tax profits of 52 per cent to &pound;1.12m. 
 Earnings followed to 7.31p and the interim dividend is to be 2.15p (1.8p). 
 Acquisitions Geeco and Concept Housewares are being integrated, and Betterware is selling the SABCo factory in East Kilbride for about two-and-a-half times purchase price. 
 Assuming profits of &pound;2.9m this year, the shares are on a prospective multiple of under 10 and are good value. 
 Keep buying. 
 Market Report: Fragile Footsie plunges to a ten-week low 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 SHARES shuddered yesterday as interest rates were increased by one percentage point. 
 At one time the broadly-based FT-SE share index plunged 42 points. 
 It closed 30.5 points down at 2,281.6, its lowest level for ten weeks. 
 Datastream calculated that &pound;6.85bn was wiped from share values. 
 A combination of bargain hunting, a firm Wall Street opening and the clear reluctance of building societies to rush to increase mortgages helped the market stagger off the floor. 
 But the undertone was exceedingly fragile, with many traders prepared to bank on the FT-SE falling below 2,200 points in the next few weeks unless the 15 per cent rates do turn out to be just a short-lived shock. 
 Consumer and building stocks were the major casualties. 
 Stores, already bombed out, suffered some humiliating falls with the Next profits downturn merely emphasising the deepening problems of the high street. 
 Hard-pressed Dixons fell 7p to 134p and Kingfisher 15p to 310p. 
 Among breweries Allied-Lyons tumbled 8p to 514p, and on the building pitch Barratt Developments lost 9p to 173p. 
 But it was not all gloom. 
 Nomura, the Japanese owned securities house, remains bullish. 
 Strategist Nicholas Knight believes that on a two-year view shares are a buy. 
 &bquo;The rise in base rates does not unduly threaten the shape of the economy and the market going into 1990-91&equo;, he said. 
 And it was not all deep depression yesterday, with the likes of Boots and Morgan Grenfell in fine form. 
 Boots' progress was accompanied by a variety of stories as in often busy trading the shares gained 9p to 294p. 
 Talk of more profit upgradings and lucrative sales of bits and pieces of Ward White Group went the rounds. 
 But the favourite, if unlikely, yarn was the sale of its less-than-inspiring pharmaceutical division, which recently disclosed an apparent flop by its much-vaunted heart drug Manoplax. 
 Fisons, active lately, was the suspected buyer. 
 The shares edged ahead 1p to 333p. 
 Morgan Grenfell jumped 30p to 399p. 
 At one time the shares hit 416p. 
 They started the week at 336p. 
 The rumoured sale of Willis Faber's 20.5 per cent holding again excited the market. 
 Willis said it had not &bquo;adjusted&equo; its stake and had &bquo;talked to no one about it&equo;. 
 Morgan declared: &bquo;No discussions with any third party are in progress.&equo; 
 Rumours that the Willis stake was about to change hands ahead of a bid have fuelled the progress. 
 A variety of Continentals have been named as possible buyers. 
 The latest favourite is Credit Suisse. 
 Jaguar had a a hectic session, with one market maker briefly quoting 1,200p after seemingly misunderstanding a transatlantic message. 
 The shares hit 750p and closed 36p higher at 669p. 
 The hovering presence of Ford and General Motors remained the most significant influence. 
 Rumours that a Continental predator lurked also lingered. 
 The share advance came against more poor trading news, with Jaguar's US sales down 19.1 per cent last month. 
 Polly Peck, the international trading group, edged ahead 4p to 330p. 
 Shares of its Hong Kong subsidiary were suspended, and after the market closed it was announced that Polly may buy the 30 per cent of the company it does not already own. 
 Cadbury Schweppes fell 6p to 396p as 25 analysts trudged around its Bourneville plant. 
 Lep Group, the transport business which is attracting increasing US investment, fell 16p to 149p after it announced interim profits of &pound;9.5m against &pound;5m. 
 Georgina Philippou, at stockbroker Marshall &amp; Co, is looking for more than &pound;30m (&pound;18.5m) for the year. 
 Union Discount, the discount house, was unchanged at 555p. 
 Ubiquitous New Zealand investor Sir Ron Brierley has lifted his shareholding by 175,000 shares to 25.4 per cent. 
 Savoy Hotel bucked the downward pull with the &bquo;A&equo; shares climbing 10p to 873p. 
 Amstrad, following extensive option trading with more than 3,200 contracts, was at one time down 5.5p at 57p. 
 The shares closed at 61p. 
 Ferranti was unchanged at 57.5p following a meeting with institutional shareholders. 
 Newcomer Partridge, an antique dealer, reached 137p from a 130p placing. 
 Tullow Oil slipped 0.5p to 17.5p as it moved to the USM. 
 Nearly &pound;7bn was wiped off share values following the increase in interest rates. 
 The FT-SE 100 index plunged 42 points at one stage before closing at 2,281.6, down 30.5. 
 The narrower FT 30 lost 24 points on the day to 1,866.2. 
 Gilt-edged stocks increased by around an &pound;1/8 Marks &amp; Spencer retreated with the rest of the high street pack. 
 Mark Husson and Nick Bubb at Morgan Stanley are worried about a sales drop-off in the second quarter and difficulties at the Brooks Brothers US operation. 
 They have cut this year's profit forecast by &pound;18m to &pound;570m. 
 Next year's hope is now &pound;620m against &pound;660m. 
 The shares lost 6p to 192p. 
 The EMAP publishing group continues to pursue Builder Group, which produces business journals. 
 Yesterday it emerged that EMAP had lifted its stake to 10.3 per cent, buying a further 200,000 shares. 
 Builder shares, which came to the stock market last summer at 125p, rose 3p to 251p. 
 Many suspect EMAP sees the 147-year-old company as a long-term bid target. 
 View from City Road: Past continues to haunt Next 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 NEXT'S problems on the high street are rooted in uncontrolled expansion and poor merchandising. 
 This was the main message behind a worse than expected slump in interim pre-tax profits from &pound;30.9m to &pound;16.2m and the likelihood of a full year pre-tax loss, after incurring exceptional costs estimated at a cool &pound;50m, to &pound;55m. 
 The inadequacies of Next's inherited high street formulae have been cruelly exposed by the slowdown in consumer spending, reflected in a slump in profits at Next Retail from &pound;7.6m to just &pound;1.7m. 
 It is also disappointing to see that home shopping, in the shape of Grattan, has failed to recover from the travails of last year's postal strike and turned in a fall in profits from &pound;14.3m to &pound;8.6m. 
 And even in an area which is working well, Next Directory, the company failed to capitalise on strong demand, which lifted sales by 49 per cent, because it did not hold enough stock. 
 On the high street a sales rise at Next Retail of just 3.6 per cent compared with an increase in trading space of 17.6 per cent speaks volumes about Next's unbalanced expansion. 
 David Jones, chief executive, is acting in a determined way to remedy the ills of the past and will reverse some of George Davies' more grandiose schemes. 
 Next the Jewellers, which lost between &pound;1m and &pound;2m in this half, is in the process of being sold to its management. 
 &bquo;Many many millions of pounds&equo; have been lost by small stand-alone outlets and Next's 15 large stores operating from over 10,000sq ft. 
 Most small outlets will be closed and the large stores reduced in size with perhaps four closures leaving Next as a medium-sized specialist retailer operating from 3,000sq ft to 4,000sq ft stores. 
 Provisions against redundancies and the write-off of fixtures and fittings is one element in the &pound;50m-&pound;55m bill for exceptional costs. 
 The rest is to cover the costs of moving to the &pound;46m centralised home shopping warehouse at Listerhills, Bradford. 
 But all the remedial measures will not produce benefits for some time, in the case of remerchandising a year at least. 
 Trading remains tough with like for like sales down 2.5 per cent since 1 August at Next Retail. 
 Grattan is only 5 per cent ahead which looks a poor defence against wage costs rising by 8 per cent and high street occupancy costs by 20 per cent. 
 Pre-tax profits of &pound;30m to &pound;40m point to a p/e of over 15 at 104p, down 21p, which is less support than a yield of 9.5 per cent if the final holds. 
 View from City Road: Beware the Bambi factor 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 BENEATH the hype, Mickey Mouse, the Magic Kingdom and the publicity that has led to more than 100,000 people already enquiring about Eurodisney shares in the UK alone, there remains a disconcerting truth about this international share offer. 
 The shares, priced at FFr72 (707p) yesterday, represent a risky investment that even on the company's own projections will not give a decent return for another 10 years. 
 For a comparison, think of Eurotunnel, although Eurodisney is above ground, on budget and only two-and-a-half years from expected completion. 
 The assumptions made in the prospectus are mind-boggling. 
 More than 11 million people are expected through the doors at the Paris site in year one (1992), rising to more than 16 million by its peak. 
 A second park, the theme of which Disney has not yet decided, is projected to welcome eight million in its first year (1996). 
 This would make them respectively the first and fifth most popular tourist arractions in the world, with the ones in between being the three existing Disney theme parks. 
 Furthermore, Disney is assuming 60 per cent of these visitors will come from France, which mean 26 per cent of the company's population will visit Eurodisney each year. 
 These visitors are projected to spend more than Ffr 9bn a year by 1996. 
 At 707p a share, which is higher than the top end of the range indicated in the pathfinder prospectus, Eurodisney offers an average return of 13.3 per cent, compared to more than 17 per cent for Eurotunnel when it was floated. 
 This is pretty low for a speculative investment and assumes the company is capitalised at 12.5 times earnings in the year to 31 March 2017. 
 A combination of a six month construction over-run and attendance of only 10 million cuts the return to 12 per cent. 
 Eurodisney and its advisers, SG Warburg, can feel confident that the issue will go well because of the interest already shown in France, where half the &pound;607m of shares will be issued. 
 They have fired this interest by spending &pound;44m on the issue, aiming it primarily at the retail investor when one might expect an issue of this sort to be more suitable for institutions. 
 As with a privatisation, small investors may be tempted by short term profits and, like Eurotunnel, the issue is a hostage to many variables. 
 Treat with caution. 
 View from City Road: Boiling under Jaguar's bonnet 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 THE RISE in the Jaguar share price yesterday owes much to the no smoke without fire school of investment analysis. 
 Despite the carnage elsewhere, the shares ended the day 36p better at 669p and had been much higher. 
 However, there is a danger that the smoke could be little more than a pungent sign of burning fingers. 
 The transatlantic gossip of a bid battle for Jaguar between Ford and General Motors looks optimistic. 
 Much of the frantic activity in the share register can be attributed to the arbitrageurs rather than the titans of the motor industry. 
 The simple fact is that Ford cannot begin to exercise its stated intention of building a significant stake in Jaguar for another two weeks. 
 General Motors, it seems, has not yet applied for the necessary US permision to conduct a similar exercise. 
 There is also the small matter of the Government's golden share which can block a hostile bid for Jaguar and does not expire until the end of next year. 
 For investors to expect battle to commence given these circumstances is ambitious. 
 A more likely scenario is that GM and Ford will vie for a strategic yet friendly investment in Jaguar. 
 That would certainly suit the Jaguar management's book and has less potential for political embarrassment than an unruly hostile bid. 
 However, it will not provide the bumper take-out price implied by the recent performance of the Jaguar share price, offering instead some guidance as to what it might be in the future. 
 With Jaguar revealing more misery in the US where September sales were down 19.1 per cent year on the year, the company needs the takeover interest to keep its share price alive. 
 Column Eight: Donald in, but Mickey ducks out 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 It seems the French got the better part of the deal when the Eurodisney share price was announced in the City yesterday with all the overkill we have come to expect from the Americans. 
 While the crowds at the Broadgate arena were treated to a medley of Disney hits, including &bquo;Zip-a-dee-doo-dah&equo; and &bquo;Whistle While You Work&equo;, the obligatory Disney characters were wheeled out hand in hand with the company's key executives. 
 Frank Wells, president of the Walt Disney company, arrived with Minnie Mouse, and Jim Cora, executive vice president of Eurodisney, with Donald Duck. 
 But where was Mickey Mouse? 
 Alas, he was detained in Paris where he was revealing the price to the French, accompanied by Pluto and Scrooge McDuck. 
 Forced to convene yet another extraordinary meeting by sacked directors trying to get back on the board, Amalgamated Financial Investments has sent out a suitably apologetic letter to shareholders. 
 It explains that the meeting will be held on 20 November, 15 minutes after the agm. 
 The letter notes that the time and date have been chosen inter alia to &bquo;minimise further unnecessary costs to our company.&equo; 
 The meeting will be held at Claridge's. 
 Charterhouse Tilney, the agency broker, continues to pick off the City's rising stars with consumate ease. 
 Yesterday it secured the services of Rob Crookall, a salesman known in the market as Wunderkind. 
 His resignation was winging its way to Sheppards yesterday afternoon. 
 It has been a rough week down at Eurotunnel as you might imagine. 
 Following lengthy pleadings with the bank manager, there has also been the delicate matter of explaining rampant construction costs to incredulous shareholders. 
 Just how rough can be judged by the fact that Annabel Salmon, Eurotunnel's official spokeswoman, yesterday called off her engagements on the grounds that she has lost her voice. 
 Another spotty youth has hacked his way into the shadowy world of US defence. 
 The 15-year-old computer boffin from New York has been charged with juvenile deliquency after he broke into the computer system of Grumman, the US defence contractor. 
 The precocious meddler actually managed to gain access to a computer used by Grumman to handle military customers including the Pentagon, police said. 
 Grumman said he was caught because his entry was picked up by its own computers. 
 Even so, it was not sure how many times he had tried it. 
 LVMH adds 30m pounds to Guinness' 246m pounds 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 GUINNESS is on the look-out for more deals along the lines of its link-up with Louis Vuitton Moet Hennessy, the French luxury goods and drinks group in which Guinness has a 24 per cent stake. 
 LVMH added &pound;30m to the &pound;246m pre-tax profits Guinness announced yesterday for the period to 30 June, when only a 16 per cent stake was accounted for. 
 City analysts are forecasting that its contribution could be as much as &pound;80m for the full year. 
 Anthony Tennant, the Guinness chairman, said: &bquo;The synergistic benfits of our deal with LVMH are already coming through strongly, without all the costs and upset of a contested bid. 
 We would be happy to do more ventures involving cross-shareholdings, especially in Europe.&equo; 
 The half year result was a 34 per cent rise over last time, and at the higher end of City estimates. 
 The interest charge, at &pound;35m against &pound;24m, was lower than many had expected. 
 Mr Tennant explained that this was partly because payments for the LVMH shares had been delayed, but added: &bquo;We are not really exposed to UK interest rates. 
 Most of our debt is in the form of US dollars or French francs, where rates are a good deal lower.&equo; 
 Interest cover is eight times. 
 The French connection was also a factor behind the growth in the fastest growing areas of Guinness's business, the Far East, where the two companies have joint distribution agreements. 
 Profits from that area rose from &pound;34m to &pound;53m. 
 Mr Tennant said that Japan, where import tax rates were lowered in favour of foreign companies, was buoyant. 
 He was also confident that Korea would soon liberalise its domestic market. 
 North America was more problematic, with profits down from &pound;56m to &pound;53m. 
 This was because of de-stocking and running down of high volume, low margin brands, and a change of year end at the Schenley offshoot last time. 
 He expected the full year contribution to be unchanged from &pound;143m. 
 European profits rose from &pound;30m to &pound;42m. 
 Spirits accounted for 74 per cent of profits at &pound;209m, with brewing adding &pound;39m. 
 There is now full time working at all the operational distilleries for the first time in eight years. 
 On earnings of 17.9p against 13.5p, the interim dividend is 4.4p (3.5p). 
 The shares went against the market to add 4p at 572p. 
 Littler to head clearing committee 
 By JOHN MOORE, Assistant City Editor 
 SIR GEOFFREY LITTLER, a former Treasury official and currently a director of NatWest Investment Bank, has been asked by the International Stock Exchange to head a committee which will develop proposals for a clearing house in securities. 
 The move follows the announcement in July by the International Stock Exchange that it intended to set up a clearing house to handle existing and projected settlement services in London. 
 It would be a joint venture, the exchange indicated, with the exchange perhaps owning 40 per cent with the remainder controlled by 20 or more institutions, such as banks, registrars, securities houses and large financial institutions as well as some listed companies. 
 Other members of the Littler committee named yesterday are Jonathan Agnew of the British Merchant Bankers Association; Martin Cruttenden of Lloyds Registrars; Ian Cormack of Citicorp; Pen Kent of the Bank of England; William Legge-Bourke of the International Stock Exchange; Andrew Palmer of Associated British Investors; Herschel Post of the International Stock Exchange; and Alex Tweedie of the Committee of London and Scottish Bankers. 
 Andrew Hugh Smith, chairman of the exchange, said he believed that the clearing house &bquo;will involve market users more directly in the development of settlement systems and so enable the UK to achieve the rapid development of a paperless settlement, payments and registration system for domestic equities. 
 It will also facilitate important future developments such as cross-border settlements.&equo; 
 Sir Geoffrey intends to call a meeting of the committee early next week. 
 Strong &amp; Fisher slips 
 By JOHN MOORE, Assistant City Editor 
 SHARES in Strong &amp; Fisher slumped 33p to 181p after the fashion leather group reported a sharp decline in full-year profits stemming from tough market conditions and labour shortages. 
 Taxable profits fell from &pound;7.81m to &pound;1.17m in the year to 30 June on group sales down about &pound;20m to &pound;91m. 
 Earnings dived from 32.7p to 8.8p per share, but the final dividend of 8.3p improved the total to 12.3p (12p). 
 The decline was attributed to &bquo;very soft prices&equo; for finished clothing leather in the second half, which eroded profit margins. 
 Difficult market conditions were exacerbated when Korean tanners entered the UK and New Zealand raw material markets, driving up prices. 
 In addition the company suffered from the introduction of mechanical skin strippers into many UK abattoirs, which interfered with the quality of output. 
 Hot summer was healthy for Etam 
 By TERENCE WILKINSON, Assistant City Editor 
 ETAM, the fashion retailer, saw its profits before property income rise by 10.3 per cent to &pound;6.3m in the six months to 12 August. 
 But, despite this resilient performance, its share price dropped 14p to 192p on fears of a renewed slump in high street spending. 
 Etam sales, up 32 per cent to &pound;84.3m on an increase in trading space of 29 per cent, appeared to benefit from the hot summer weather and its low-priced fashion for younger women seemed not to suffer greatly from the effects of higher mortgages. 
 Pre-tax profits showed a more modest 2.5 per cent increase to &pound;6.3m in the absence of last time's &pound;409,000 of property profits, and after a slightly higher tax charge earnings per share were almost unchanged at 6.22p. 
 But the half-time dividend is up 15 per cent to 1.95p. 
 The warm weather which helped Etam in the summer has proved to be a disadvantage in the run-up to autumn trading and the chairman, Alan Howard, says the group has been trading slightly below budgeted levels. 
 But like-for-like sales in real terms are nevertheless holding steady. 
 The group's Snob subsidiary is steadily raising its sales per square foot and management has made a breakthrough at the previously troubled Peter Brown menswear acquisition, which has performed markedly better since June. 
 Physical expansion is set to continue in the remainder of the current year with 20 trading outlets, representing 100,000 sq ft on top of the existing 694,500, due to open. 
 British Steel in 330m pound deal 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 BRITISH STEEL yesterday snapped up the country's biggest steel stockholding company in a &pound;330m deal which gives it control of 20 per cent of the UK market and turns two Lancashire businessmen into millionaires many times over. 
 In its first major acquisition since privatisation a year ago British Steel is buying C Walker and Sons, of Blackburn. 
 The &pound;330m cash being paid makes this the biggest sale ever of a family-owned company. 
 Sir Robert Scholey, the chairman of British Steel, conceded yesterday that the move was largely a defensive one to prevent the business falling into the hands of an overseas predator. 
 Walker is British Steel's largest single customer, accounting for about 7 per cent of its total output of 13.1 million tonnes. 
 C Walker and Sons was founded in Blackburn 30 years ago by two brothers, Jack and Fred Walker, with a few thousand pounds of capital and has grown from a business with a turnover of under &pound;100,000 in the late 1950s to a &pound;620m concern with 3,400 employees in the UK and Ireland and profits last year of &pound;48.4m. 
 Following the sale Jack Walker, now a consultant to the company, will retire permanently to his Channel Islands home to run his small aviation business. 
 Fred Walker, who still lives locally, will also retire as chairman. 
 Their interests in the company are held in a family trust. 
 The deal, which needs the approval of the Office of Fair Trading and the European Commission, will give British Steel control over 35 per cent of the UK stockholding industry and 5 per cent of the European Community stockholding market. 
 Stockholders account for 60 per cent of the 20 million tonnes of steel sold in the UK each year. 
 British Steel already held 15 per cent of the stockholder market through its own service centres operation. 
 Walker, which bought out GKN's steel stockholding interests two years ago, has a market share of 20 per cent. 
 Sir Robert said British Steel would now &bquo;rest content&equo; at the combined figure of 35 per cent. 
 The acquisition of Walker will put British Steel on a par with its rivals in Germany and France which control up to 70 per cent of the stockholding outlets through which their steel is sold to industrial customers. 
 Sir Robert pledged that Walker would continue to operate as an autonomous business and ruled out closures in its network of distribution centres. 
 BT cuts prices 8% in rivalry with Mercury 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 (First Edition) BRITISH Telecommunications is to cut prices on some transatlantic services in the face of fierce competition from Mercury Communications. 
 The cuts, of about 8 per cent, are on BT's digital private circuits and come into effect on 1 January 1990. 
 But they leave BT more expensive than its rival. 
 Tony Booth, managing director of British Telecom International, said: &bquo;Competition is becoming cut-throat in the transatlantic services. 
 We have decided on the cuts as a result of strong competition from Mercury, whose prices until now have been around 20 per cent lower than ours.&equo; 
 He believes that quality of service will allow BT to fight back without further reductions. 
 Although Mercury has made little impact in local telephone services, it has begun to make an impact on BT's operations in long-distance and overseas links. 
 Private circuits, based on dedicated lines for large corporate customers, are increasingly important as a revenue stream for BT. 
 Mr Booth said that BTI is concentrating more and more on multinational customers. 
 The final hurdle in the race to become West Germany's second cellular radio operator was reached yesterday when 10 consortia, including many British companies, submitted the last part of their bids. 
 BT, which is bidding in a consortium including Daimler-Benz, says that the investment in setting up the network would be &pound;850m. 
 But it said that Germany's cellular subscriber base could soar to three million by the year 2000, compared with 150,000 today. 
 Other UK companies in the bidding include Racal, Cable and Wireless, and Securicor. 
 McCaw of the US, in which BT has a 22 per cent stake, is involved in a separate bid. 
 Economic Outlook: Raising the stakes with bank base rates 
 By SARAH HOGG 
 It is a golden political rule for Chancellors that they must ensure a pre-election boom and should never waste one post-election. 
 Nigel Lawson may have won his prime minister the 1987 election, but it has become ever more clear that he let his boom run on too long and too strong thereafter. 
 He was not, of course, alone in this. 
 Worldwide, the economy has continued to come on stronger than almost anyone forecast, which is why European central bankers agreed to throw another brick at it yesterday. 
 The policy stakes have been raised; but nowhere more so than in Britain, which will be the luckiest to avoid a (pre-election) recession. 
 Since the stock market crash at the end of that year, policy has however been dogged by an excessive fear of recession, and it would have compounded this mistake to have failed to raise British base rates to 15 per cent this week. 
 But Mr Lawson has now succeeded in doubling rates since the spring of last year; we are into the second half of this parliament; and there can be no certainty that this is the top of the ladder. 
 The Government's immediate choice this week was hardly calculated to appeal to the prime minister. 
 Either the Chancellor could raise interest rates ahead of the Germans, which would demonstrate the &bquo;national sovereignty&equo; in monetary matters on which Mrs Thatcher sets such store. 
 But it would leave the Government exposed to the full force of house-buyers' fury, with no international excuse for forcing an increase in mortgage rates that would probably have occurred anyway. 
 Or he could follow the Germans, who have duly provided him with an excuse for higher base rates at next week's party conference &mdash; but have also made it abundantly clear that the Bundesbank is the dominant monetary authority in Europe, and our much-vaunted independence is so much poppy-cock. 
 Pound peg The second option was obviously the more attractive, for it pegged this latest rise to 15 per cent base rates firmly on the exchange rate. 
 The Government could not risk the pound by allowing the return on mark (and franc) assets to rise relative to the return on sterling assets. 
 Since Mr Lawson has long been in favour of a stable exchange rate &mdash; and since industry has enthusiastically supported him, by expressing its enthusiasm for membership of the European Monetary System &mdash; it is ill-placed to argue against an increase in base rates at a time when sterling was threatening to fall below three marks, although the Confederation of British Industry has predictably grumbled that the rise was unnecessary. 
 It could hardly complain it was unexpected. 
 A weak exchange rate transmits inflation, and the Chancellor has made it abundantly clear his present priority is to get inflation down. 
 But that is not the whole story. 
 After all, Mr Lawson has taken pride in the fact that recorded inflation is coming down, which makes it difficult to explain to &mdash; say &mdash; the Tory party conference why interest rates have to follow the Germans up. 
 The obvious proximate cause was last week's trade figures, and these spell serious trouble for the Chancellor. 
 It is indeed true that balance of payments deficits can be sustained for longer than they could a generation ago; we would have never got this far without a much worse sterling crisis if that were not the case. 
 The most damaging feature of the August figures, however, is that they showed no sign, after a year and a half of severe monetary tightening, that the worst was over. 
 From which it is possible to draw one of three conclusions. 
 One is that Mr Lawson has not yet succeeded in getting a handle on domestic demand, and the signs of success this summer were misleading. 
 The second &mdash; Mr Lawson's line -that demand is indeed slowing down, but that it takes a long time to affect the balance of payments. 
 The third is that will have singularly little effect, because of industry's narrow base and uncompetitiveness, revealing our dependence on the deus ex machina of North Sea oil. 
 A very great deal hangs, of course, on the difference between the second and third answers. 
 We are only just beginning to see the first stirrings of a new debate on industry's competitiveness. 
 But it is the first possible answer that presents the immediate worry. 
 It is one thing to ask whether Mr Lawson's chosen strategy of maintaining a &bquo;firm&equo; exchange rate and slowing the growth of demand will produce good long-term results. 
 It is another to ask whether he has even begun to succeed in his short-term struggle to stop the rot. 
 Trading forecasts On this there does not, at least, seem to have been a great internal dispute. 
 After the last rise in base rates, all sources of advice to the Chancellor do seem to have taken the view through the summer that the squeeze was working. 
 The Chancellor might be forced to raise rates again if sterling took a nosedive, but he did not need to sit with his finger on the trigger. 
 Sterling strengthened, and the Chancellor did not cut rates; but nor was he under pressure to raise them. 
 As the CBI figures showed increasing anxiety about future orders, there was more fear that the deceleration might be too abrupt. 
 The inflation figures, and even pay settlements, have been less awful than might have been expected. 
 And there are two views of the money numbers, even among monetarists. 
 It was not only the trade figures that have reversed this view, but they clearly affected the markets most. 
 Admittedly, they are sufficiently erratic to give point to the Treasury's plea not to place too much weight on each month's figures. 
 But this plea has worn a bit thin. 
 A cumulative succession of nasty surprises has dealt a further destructive blow to an advantage Mr Lawson has enjoyed for so many years that he may have come to taken it for granted: the effect on expectations of confident and respected official forecasting. 
 For all the Chancellor's efforts to tell us things will come right in time, it will take real, hard evidence that the deficit is coming down to protect Mr Lawson from the bitter mercies of the markets. 
 Guilty plea made in US defence scandal 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 THE brother-in-law of James Guerin, the US industrialist accused of defrauding Ferranti of more than &pound;150m, pleaded guilty in US court yesterday to two counts of bribery in America's WedTech defence scandal. 
 Carl Jacobson faces up to 10 years in prison for relaying bribery money to the US navy official responsible for awarding lucrative contracts to WedTech, a New York contractor, and United Chemcon, a Lancaster, Pennsylvania company associated with Mr Guerin's International Signal and Control Corp. 
 Mr Guerin is suspected of misrepresenting dozens of contracts during the sale of his company to Ferranti in 1988. 
 Mr Jacobson admitted to conveying &dollar;120,000 from Jimmy Christian, the black president of United Chemcon, to Richard Ramirez, the US navy official responsible for granting contracts to black and Hispanic businesses. 
 At Mr Ramirez's request he also transmitted &dollar;60,000 from WedTech to a company controlled by the official after he left the government. 
 &bquo;He said it wouldn't be a problem,&equo; Mr Jacobson said. 
 &bquo;As it turned out, it was.&equo; 
 As part of his plea agreement with the government, Mr Jacobson is cooperating with the continuing investigation into defence industry corruption. 
 The WedTech scandal has also resulted in the convictions of a number of US politicians and military contractors. 
 Mr Jacobson refused to answer any questions following the hearing, except to say he hasn't seen his brother-in-law. 
 Mr Guerin has not been seen since the scandal broke, and has been communicating with the authorities through his lawyer in Philadelphia. 
 Donald Trump puts American Airlines into play 
 From LARRY BLACK in New York 
 THE UPHEAVAL in the US airline industry continued yesterday, with property developer Donald Trump announcing an unsolicited &dollar;7bn bid for American Airlines, the country's largest carrier. 
 The flamboyant Mr Trump, who earlier this year bought part of strike-bound Eastern Airlines, is offering &dollar;120 a share for American, a large premium over its &dollar;83 opening on Thursday. 
 The stock of American's Dallas-based parent, AMR Corp, jumped sharply on the news, but there is considerable scepticism on Wall Street over Mr Trump's intentions. 
 The airline's management, in a brief statement, reiterated its intention to remain independent. 
 Meanwhile, prospects for a &dollar;6.8bn purchase of the US' second-largest airline, United, sank further on word that the airline's machinists union is refusing to participate in an employee buyout scheme. 
 The deal, which would give British Airways a 15 per cent share in United, is already threatened by new US government restrictions on foreign ownership of American carriers. 
 Mr Trump, who has a penchant for naming his many buildings, hotels and casinos after himself, purchased what is now the Trump Shuttle from Eastern's parent company, Texas Air Corp, in April for &dollar;365m. 
 Mr Trump would not reveal details of his financing for the proposed purchase which comes at a time of growing concern among US regulators over the heavy debt loads the carriers are acquiring. 
 Analysts suggested Mr Trump, aware of long-standing takeover talk surrounding American, was simply putting the airline &bquo;into play&equo; in hopes of reaping stock-trading profits. 
 The price he is offering is fair, based on operating profits without liquidiating the airline, said analyst Louis Marckesano of Philadelphia's Janney Scott Montgomery. 
 &bquo;But the question here is &bquo;Is this for real?&equo; 
 American, other analysts noted, has had several months to prepare contingencies for a hostile takeover attempt, and probably has a restructuring deal of its own waiting in the wings. 
 Foreign participation in such a scheme is unlikely, given the apparent opposition of Washington, and the fact that American chairman Robert Crandall is an outspoken critic of such an arrangement. 
 Lufthansa is a likely partner, should American change its mind, suggests Mr Marckesano. 
 Last week, the US Transportation Secretary, Samuel Skinner, ordered KLM, the Dutch flag carrier, to reduce its equity involvement in the recent buyout of Northwest Airlines, the fourth largest US carrier, by Los Angeles businessman Al Checchi. 
 KLM's share of the &dollar;3.65bn buyout is considerably smaller than BA's &dollar;750m participation in United, but some analysts have suggested regulators might be swayed by the fact that the airline's staff will control the company. 
 The United machinists complain the scheme leaves the airline with too much debt. 
 In testimony before a US congressional committee earlier this week, the machinists' union said the takeover was based on a &bquo;ludicrous&equo; business plan, and threatened an extended campaign to block the deal. 
 KLM, meanwhile, is expected to maintain a reduced involvement in Northwest, &bquo;keeping its foot in the door&equo;, one analyst suggested, until US policy of foreign ownership becomes more clear. 
 Mr Checchi, for his part, said yesterday that he does not intend to seek a new partner to replace the &dollar;225m shortfall, but will instead repay KLM out of operating profits -a move analysts said would further endebt the airline. 
 Business and City Summary 
 From LARRY BLACK in New York 
 Hoylake withdraws action: Hoylake has withdrawn its court action against the insurance commissioners in nine US states, challenging their right to review its bid for BAT Industries. 
 It acted at the request of Axa Midi, which has reaffirmed its agreement to buy BAT's subsidiary, Farmers, should Hoylake win. 
 Disney at 707p: The Eurodisney share issue, which is being made in six European countries, has been priced at Fr72 (707p) and will raise &pound;607m, giving investors 49 per cent of the project. 
 View from City Road, page 25 Polly buys in: Shares in Polly Peck Far East have been suspended ahead of a general offer by majority shareholder Polly Peck International for the remaining equity. 
 Steel purchase: British Steel has made its first major acquisition since privatisation, buying private group C Walker &amp; Sons, of Blackburn, for &pound;330m. 
 Page 25 New dawn for Abtrust: Abtrust New Dawn Investment Trust is raising &pound;18.9m through a placing and offer which it will invest in developing markets in the Far East. 
 Page 26 Moet sparkle for Guinness: Louis Vuitton Moet Hennessy, in which Guinness has a 24 per cent stake, contributed &pound;30m to Guinness's &pound;264m half year pre-tax profits. 
 Page 25 Defence group defends: United Scientific Holdings said the Meggitt bid had no industrial logic and undervalued USH. 
 Page 26 Next tumbles: Next's pre-tax profits nearly halved to &pound;16.2m at the halfway stage as it revealed problems rooted in overexpansion and poor merchandising. 
 View from City Road, page 25 Telecom price cut: British Telecom is to cut prices on some transatlantic calls by up to 8 per cent in response to competition. 
 Markets tumble: The FT-SE 100 index fell 30.5 points to 2,281.6 as a reaction to the 1 per cent increase in base rates. 
 It was 42 points off at its nadir. 
 Market report, page 25 Accountancy merger: Coopers &amp; Lybrand's Dutch practice is to merge with Deloitte Dijker Van Dien of the Netherlands. 
 The move follows Wednesday's announcement of a merger between Coopers and Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells in the United Kingdom. 
 Jaguar leaps: Jaguar shares jumped 36p to 669p, having reached a high of 750p, on the suspicion of US stakebuilding. 
 View from City Road, page 25 Galliford margins rise: A percentage point rise in margins helped construction group Galliford boost half year profits by 30 per cent. 
 Page 25 Car sales down: Some 171,730 cars were sold in September, a 10 per cent decline on a year ago and the first fall since April 1987. 
 This page Etam bucks trend: Etam showed there was still growth in the high street, increasing half year profits net of property by 10.3 per cent to &pound;6.3m. 
 Page 25 World Markets New York: In mixed trading the Dow Jones average struggled to hold recently won high ground. 
 By the close it was up 2.47 points at 2,773.56. 
 Tokyo: Index-linked buying just before the close drove prices up and enabled the Nikkei average to end with a gain of 140.19 points at 35,522.99. 
 Singapore: Prices closed narrowly mixed in moderate trade. 
 The Straits Times index was 3.28 points easier at 1,404.98. 
 Sydney: Shares finished marginally weaker but off their lows, with the All Ordinaries index down 3.1 points at 1,772.5. 
 Bombay: An official denial of moves to end price controls on steel triggered nervous long liquidation across the board. 
 Johannesburg: Interest was minimal and the market closed weaker, with the general index 19 points down at 2,710. 
 Paris: The CAC-40 index climbed 9.37 points to 1,918.41 in a robust response to increases in European interest rates. 
 Frankfurt: Cautious trading ahead of the Bundesbank's interest rate announcement took the DAX index 2.94 points higher to 1,616.21. 
 Madrid: The construction sector showed the biggest losses as the index slipped 1.31 to 323.31. 
 Stockholm: Dealers welcomed the rise in other countries' interest rates as it closes the gap with Sweden's own high rates, which are unchanged. 
 The market index eased 0.06 per cent. 
 Germany gives Europe the lead: As banks raise UK interest rates to 15%, the highest level since 1981, building societies are set to follow 
 By MICHAEL PREST 
 INTEREST rates obediently rose accross Europe yesterday after the Bundesbank, the West German central bank, increased its lending rates by one percentage point and its counterparts participated in a co-ordinated attempt to suppress the dollar and maintain exchange rate parities within the European Monetary System. 
 As soon as the Bundesbank announced at 2pm that its discount rate would go up to 6 per cent and its Lombard emergency funding rate to 8 per cent, the Bank of England pushed up the base lending rate of British banks to 15 per cent, the highest for eight years. 
 But the carefully prepared general rise in European interest rates immediately prompted concern that it represented German worries about domestic inflation and the ability of the Bundesbank to persuade other countries to follow its policy, rather than an expression of the determination of the Group of Seven, the leading industrial nations, to control the dollar. 
 Neither the US nor Japan raised its rates. 
 But the European increases, although anticipated for a while, depressed stock markets. 
 In London the FT-SE 100 index fell 30.5 points to close at 2,281.6. 
 The index has fallen by about 5 per cent over the past month. 
 Money market rates strengthened, however. 
 The key three-month interbank sterling rate rose by 3 16 per cent to 1415 16 -147 8 per cent. 
 On the London International Financial Futures Exchange the December short sterling interest rate contract collapsed to 85.25 just after the interest rate rise before closing at 85.37, down 0.23. 
 The interest rate rises did appear to succeed in depressing the dollar. 
 In London the Deutschemark closed 0.97 pfennings higher against the American currency at DM1.8845. 
 The yen gained Y1.35 to trade at Y142.25 to the dollar and sterling rose by 0.57 cents to &dollar;1.6102. 
 Of the 12 members of the European Community only Greece, Italy, Portugal and Spain did not raise interest rates. 
 The Bank of France pushed up its intervention rate by 0.75 per cent to 9.5 per cent and its five-to 10-day repurchase rate rose by the same amount to 10.25 per cent. 
 The Netherlands, Belgium, Denmark and the Irish Republic increased interest rates by one percentage point. 
 Italy did not raise rates because they were considered high enough already and its inflation has been falling. 
 Like Spain, Italy did not want to raise interest rates and put further upward pressure on its currency within the EMS. 
 But, outside the EC, Switzerland and Austria also raised their rates. 
 The Swiss discount rate rose half a percentage point to 6 per cent. 
 These widespread changes underlined the power of the Bundesbank and its currency. 
 In a statement the German central bank said the rises were intended to &bquo;prevent an overheating of the economy and to avoid the danger of seeing prices and costs rising&equo;. 
 Germany has become increasingly concerned about the danger of importing inflation through an undervalued currency despite a massive balance of payments surplus, particularly within the EC. 
 The German authorities are also worried about the impact of tax changes next year. 
 It was the fourth rise in German interest rates this year and the first time for several years that they have risen by a full percentage point. 
 7.5% inflation predicted by end of year 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 INFLATION is widely expected to accelerate towards 7.5 per cent late this year after yesterday's one point increase to 15 per cent in base rates made higher mortgage interest rates inevitable. 
 Some City economists warned that there was a risk inflation may rise even further because of the impact of higher mortgage rates on wage claims in the forthcoming pay bargaining season. 
 Mortgage rate increases are likely to take effect in November and thus reverse a widely expected fall in inflation for this month. 
 Inflation in August, the latest month for which figures are available, was 7.3 per cent, and it is forecast to be unchanged when September figures are released next Friday. 
 But in October, the rate is expected to slow to around 63 4 per cent because a mortgage rate rise in October 1988 drops out of the annual comparison. 
 City economists predicted that building societies could lift their mortgage rates as much as 1.5 per cent &mdash; to 15 per cent on average &mdash; although initial indications from the societies pointed to a rise of no more than 1.25 per cent. 
 Because housing is given a weighting of 17.5 per cent in the retail price index, an increase of this order is likely to add 0.4 and 0.5 points to the inflation rate in November, assuming there are no other pressures on prices that month. 
 Most economists believe that the tighter squeeze on the economy would now lead to a more rapid deceleration in inflation in the first half of next year than had been expected before yesterday's base rate increase. 
 But some warned that the impact of higher mortgage rates on wage negotiations risked increased pressure on prices in the months ahead. 
 Glenn Davies, chief economist with Credit Lyonnais Securities, a French securities firm, said higher mortgage rates &bquo;will push inflation up towards 8 per cent by the end of the year. 
 What does that do to wage claims?&equo; 
 Negotiators for 33,000 manual workers at Ford Motor Company yesterday put in a bid for a &bquo;substantial rise&equo; &mdash; thought to be at least 10 per cent. 
 The Ford talks are expected to have a significant impact on pay talks throughout manufacturing industry in the next six months. 
 They are likely to influence, for instance, the negotiations between leaders of 2 million engineering workers and the Engineering Employers Federation. 
 Engineering workers are also asking for a &bquo;substantial rise&equo; in pay. 
 Official figures out yesterday indicated that British consumers saved at the lowest rate for 31 years while living standards actually declined 0.6 per cent between the first and second quarters of the year. 
 Savings as percentage of total personal disposable income fell to 3.2 per cent in the second quarter from 5.2 per cent in the first three months, the lowest ratio since 1958. 
 Angry response from business and union leaders 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 BUSINESS and union leaders yesterday reacted angrily to the latest base rate rise, warning it would force up inflation, undermine industry's confidence and put jobs and investment at risk. 
 Sir Trevor Holdsworth, president of the Confederation of British Industry, described the rise as &bquo;unnecessary and unthinking&equo;. 
 More businesses would defer decisions on investment and the rise in interest rates would reverse the downward trend in inflation, he told a Bristol press conference. 
 &bquo;It looks like a short-term reaction to a short-term situation, partially sparked off by the ridiculous reaction to the August trade figures,&equo; Sir Trevor added. 
 Meanwhile John Edmonds, general secretary of Britain's general union the GMB, claimed the rate rise would throw 250,000 people out of work. 
 &bquo;This will mean a miserable winter for house owners but a disastrous one for a quarter of a million working people. 
 Economists have told me this could be the final push that will consign up to 250,000 people to the scrap heap.&equo; 
 The base rate rise is also certain to hit sales of new cars, which fell in September for the first time in 18 months, according to new figures released yesterday. 
 Car sales had been the one area of consumer spending undented by the Chancellor's high interest rates strategy. 
 But motor industry executives now expect the decline in sales that showed through last month to accelerate in the remainder of the year. 
 Sales last month, at 171,730, were 10 per cent down on September 1988 &mdash; the first time there has been a month on month decline since April 1987, according to the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders. 
 Simon Foster, director of the SMMT, said he expected sales in the final quarter of the year to be below those in the last three months of 1988. 
 &bquo;The Government's monetary policy has already lowered demand for other consumer goods. 
 The motor industry is still buoyant but cannot remain immune from the trends in the rest of the economy.&equo; 
 Despite the fall in September sales, the figures produced by the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders show that total sales in the first nine months, at 1,919,338, are still 5 per cent up on the same period last year. 
 Estate agents put on brave face 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 THE BIG residential property lenders and estate agents were showing fortitude in the face of the inevitable after yesterday's base rate rise. 
 The most optimistic forecast severely reduced activity in residential property; others expected static house sales until the end of the year. 
 A serious reverse in house prices is a universal fear. 
 Joe Bradley of Prudential Residential Property Services said the move was &bquo;not in any way the end of the private property market. 
 House prices have been adjusting downwards in the South-east for over a year. 
 They are 10 to 15 per cent lower and asking prices now are more realistic.&equo; 
 Mr Bradley forecasts wage settlements running at 8 or 9 per cent. 
 From this, he argues, property prices can only benefit. 
 The Abbey National was less sanguine: &bquo;This could effectively put a seal on the property market to the end of the year,&equo; said a spokesman. 
 &bquo;There can be no collapse in the property market because sellers have a real reluctance to sell if they can't make last year's prices. 
 Properties will stick rather than prices fall.&equo; 
 Barclays Bank said that the market was &bquo;static and may even worsen. 
 Vendors who need to sell may be forced to discount prices to get their properties away&equo;. 
 Homeowners are cushioned from rise 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 HOME LOAN borrowers have been partially cushioned from the full effect of the doubling of base rates in the last 18 months. 
 The two key protective factors are the highly competitive nature of the mortgage market and the preponderance of mortgage budget schemes which are altered just once a year to cater for interest rate fluctuations. 
 Lenders' keenness to write business has seen mortgage rates sink below base rates. 
 Many building societies have pared this down yet further by offering &bquo;loss-leader&equo; discounts on standard loan rates to attract new business. 
 Roughly half the leading building societies' borrowers repay on budget schemes. 
 They will pay nothing more now, but will have the delayed interest on at least two mortgage rate rises to account for when the new yearly rates are fixed early in 1990. 
 The anticipated increase in rates to 14.75 per cent would mean a hike of 95p per thousand pounds borrowed without the benefit of income tax relief. 
 The monthly bill for a repayment loan of &pound;100,000 would cost &pound;1,117.73, an increase of more than 8 per cent after tax relief. 
 A loan of &pound;30,000 would add more than 7 per cent to a monthly &pound;298.22. 
 The figures are all the more startling when compared with mortgage bills of 18 months ago, when base rates hit a low of 7.5 per cent. 
 Assuming a standard loan rate of 14.75 per cent, a typical &pound;60,000 repayment mortgage would cost &pound;669.77 per month. 
 This represents an increase of &pound;188.63 per month, 39 per cent more than in May 1988. 
 Share prices tumble 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 LONDON share prices tumbled in the wake of the interest rate rise with &pound;6.85bn wiped off the stock market's value. 
 The FT-SE 100 share index was down 42 points at one stage but recovered in later trading to end the day down 30.5 points at 2,281.6. 
 Share prices that had remained nervously stable during the morning fell dramatically once interest rates began to rise. 
 However, much of the fall was due to share prices being marked down rather than a flood of selling and trading volume at just under 500 million shares was little above normal levels. 
 The stores and building sectors were among the hardest hit as traders anticipated a continuing squeeze in the high street and on house prices. 
 Some analysts were gloomily looking to the FT-SE 100 index to fall below the 2,200 level if the 15 per cent base rate is maintained for any length of time. 
 But the bearish view was not universally held and Nicholas Knight, the UK equities strategist at Nomura, said: &bquo;The market may go lower but the time to buy is now. 
 The bad news is now largely behind, the good news is to come.&equo; 
 Mortgage lenders' reaction is divided 
 By PATRICK HOSKING 
 MORTGAGE lenders were divided yesterday on how they would respond to the base rate hike, but a 1.25 per cent increase in ordinary mortgage rates to 14.75 per cent seemed the most common reaction, probably from 1 November, writes Patrick Hosking. 
 Lenders fell into two camps, depending on how much they fear a further drying up of already moribund mortgage demand. 
 Abbey National predicted an increase of between 1 and 1.5 per cent. 
 The Woolwich hoped to confine the rise to 1 per cent. 
 But the gloom deepened during the afternoon as more of the big societies said an increase was inevitable. 
 By evening the largest society, the Halifax, had dropped an earlier hope it might be able to resist the rise. 
 Banks are expected to follow with similar increases. 
 Wholesale-financed lenders, already charging 14.75 per cent, will face pressure to raise their rates close to 16 per cent. 
 However, National Home Loans said it was &bquo;virtually certain' it could hold out against a rise until Christmas. 
 The rate increase is doubly painful for societies with large loss-making estate agency chains. 
 Commodities: Coffee 
 By PATRICK HOSKING 
 DELEGATES to the International Coffee Organisation meeting in London said they expected to begin drawing up a framework within which economic clauses could eventually be reintroduced into the agreement. 
 Prices steadied and ended the day largely unchanged after November traded down to &pound;677 a tonne, the lowest for 14 years. 
 Cocoa was also weak and oil futures slipped after the International Energy Agency estimated Opec's September output at 22.3 million barrels per day. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Thatcher's early days on the seat of power: &bquo;Margaret, Daughter of Beatrice&equo; &mdash; Leo Abse: Jonathan Cape, 12.95 pounds 
 By AUBERON WAUGH 
 IN A LONG apologia for having had the temerity to undertake a psycho-biography of Mrs Thatcher, Leo Abse denies that his book is a personal attack on her, but agrees that it may have some admonitory function in warning people not to acquiesce too readily in the disposition of someone who would appear, on his argument, to be gravely unbalanced. 
 His justification for the necessary invasion of privacy is the familiar - and thoroughly respectable &mdash; plea that politics should and must be personalised. 
 Politics has very little to do with issues; it is all to do with the personal vanities and ambitions of politicians. 
 Or so he says at the beginning of his book. 
 By the end, with an extended sermon on the emptiness of individualist ethics, he is pleading for a return to the benevolence in public affairs which Thatcher cannot supply by nature of having been denied her mother's breast, given the wrong sort of potty training, etc. 
 There are two objections to this sort of psycho-biography. 
 The first lies in the extent to which all evidence adduced depends on guesswork. 
 Abse has not put Thatcher on the analyst's couch, and does not pretend to have done so. 
 Everything is taken from previously published material. 
 The only really solid piece of evidence is the fact that Thatcher made no mention of her mother in her Who's Who entry. 
 She also referred to her mother in a slightly dismissive way in the course of two reported interviews. 
 There is no direct evidence on the breast or the potty. 
 &bquo;When Thatcher was on the pot, it is my belief she was peremptorily required by her mother and grandmother to do her duty,&equo; writes Abse, and proceeds to build a gigantic edifice on the assumption: &bquo;A mother who is peremptory when the child wants satisfaction at the breast, is the same severe mother who denies her child the pride in her own first creation, her faeces,&equo; he explains. 
 Abse is most emphatic that mothers should congratulate children on their first excretions, and praise the resulting faeces. 
 In this, I think he is out of date. 
 Really bloody-minded children, I have been told &mdash; the MPs of the future, perhaps &mdash; deduce from all this lavish praise that the faeces are something worth keeping, and refuse to perform on that basis. 
 But this does not stop Abse constructing an elaborate thesis based on Thatcher's &bquo;sphincter morality&equo;, for which her mother, Beatrice, should really take the blame: &bquo;Thatcher succeeded in initiating the electorate into a new form of gambling: her personal need to end the earlier constraints which she had endured, outlawing the joys of shitting and coprophilia, drove her to open the doors of the Stock Exchange, and end its exclusivity.&equo; 
 This would seem a benign effect of Thatcher's bad potty training, except that Abse has a bee in his bonnet against gambling. 
 The second real objection to this form of psycho-biography is that as soon as Freud is quoted as gospel, the whole argument descends into music hall burlesque for everybody but dedicated Freudians. 
 &bquo;The aetiology of the urge to gamble lies in joyless masturbation and early, still-unresolved bisexuality,&equo; proclaims Abse, after Freud. 
 Most intelligent people who have not accepted Freudian indoctrination will ask him to tell that to the Marines. 
 Where Thatcher is plainly an ambitious woman, Freud reveals that the source of human ambition is urethral eroticism: the pleasure accompanying the function of urinating. 
 Her affection for the Bomb is explained by the fact that it is energy-charged and penis-shaped. 
 All of which is quite funny for a bit, but becomes boring because it is obviously such rubbish. 
 What is particularly boring about it is that all the arguments are circular. 
 Having observed Thatcher's boorish behaviour, Abse comments: &bquo;Such a jealous and ruthless super-ego can only have been formed by a prohibiting mother who is brusque and prematurely insists upon early toilet training.&equo; 
 From that possibility, he goes on to blame bad potty-training for all her character defects. 
 Which is a great pity, because if one cuts out all the Freudian claptrap, Abse has produced a brilliant character analysis of the Prime Minister, and of the whole Thatcher phenomenon, which succeeded in scaring the wits out of me. 
 It is enough to attribute the rage with which she invests every issue to primal narcissism, the rage provoked by any threat of helplessness. 
 We can observe that she is happy only when she is furious, and do not need to have it suggested that her earlier nickname of &bquo;Thatcher Milk-Snatcher&equo; derived from her own breast-deprivation, which denies her all happiness and allows her &bquo;only the sadistic triumphs of tawdry political and military victories.&equo; 
 It is a useful thought that Thatcher's main feelings may be those of control, triumph and contempt. 
 It is not useful to insist that these are the result of potty-training. 
 But I am prepared to accept that her delusions of grandeur are a form of psychosis connected with ageing and that her refusal to consider retirement springs from an awareness that it is she, not the country, who is in danger of falling to bits is she desists from hyper-activity. 
 Abse's book is full of long digressions &mdash; on gambling, Ulster, pornography, spies (among whom he counts the acquitted MP Will Owen), Welsh devolution, Woodrow Wyatt, Enoch Powell and Keith Joseph, Welsh devolution, the &bquo;wondrous possibilities&equo; of in vitro fertilisation, the horrors of a Conservative Chief Rabbinate, the security services. 
 Some may find this tedious, but I enjoyed them all. 
 Abse is an intelligent, well-informed man and a good writer, when he can be weaned from his Freudian claptrap and its related jargon. 
 His main thesis, that Thatcher's defective personality and failing judgement, allied to a fierce determination to survive, supported by ruthless henchmen, make her a danger to the country, may well stand up. 
 He makes little of the Gibraltar shootings, which first convinced me she was unreliable. 
 But it will be enough for many people that the Poll Tax will cost her the next general election. 
 Something needs to be done. 
 Abse puts his faith in Heseltine, whom I have never been able to take seriously as a politician. 
 Perhaps we should all start trying, since he is the only one who has dared raise his standard against her. 
 I wonder how he performed on the potty? 
 It is time we were told. 
 The week Labour's left was routed 
 By PETER KELLNER 
 MORE than anything else, this week's Labour Party conference should kill off a ritual that has been acted out over the years in a hundred radio and television studios. 
 The ritual went like this: Whenever Labour made news &mdash; at a conference, during a policy dispute, before a tense meeting of the National Executive Committee &mdash; politicians and commentators would be sat in front of a microphone and asked: &bquo;Will the left defeat the leadership?&equo; 
 Like most people responding to this question, I would reply along the following lines: &bquo;No. 
 Neil Kinnock has more complete control over the party than any leader since Attlee. 
 The left is in a small minority in every bit of the party that matters &mdash; the executive, the Shadow Cabinet, the party conference. 
 But the left still has enough supporters in the unions and the constituencies to make a lot of noise and win some votes. 
 To that extent, it still is a force to be reckoned with.&equo; 
 No longer. 
 This week the left lost its residual power to rock Mr Kinnock's sleek new social democratic boat. 
 Ken Livingstone's ejection from the executive was merely the most public manifestation of a profound shift in Labour's internal ecology. 
 For understandable reasons, neither side is prepared to proclaim the change too loudly: the left hates admitting defeat, while the right does not want to offend too many loyal party members by appearing triumphalist. 
 But it is hard to fit the evidence to any other conclusion. 
 The left used to have two ways to amplify its voice at the party conference. 
 The first was through the block votes of sympathetic unions. 
 The second was through elections to the constituency section of the executive. 
 There were some issues on which the left was always trounced &mdash; over the Militant Tendency, for example. 
 On other issues, such as nuclear weapons, it could construct a broad enough coalition to determine party policy (or, at the very least, limit Mr Kinnock's room for manoeuvre). 
 Now, for the first time since the early Seventies the left has no power to tether the leadership on anything significant. 
 As late as last year a narrow conference majority wanted to hold the party to unilateral nuclear disarmament. 
 This week, 60 per cent voted for multilateralism. 
 That vote was predicted, so the occasion lacked drama. 
 The announcement of the executive election results minutes later was altogether more dramatic. 
 Constituency delegates decide seven of the 29 places. 
 During the late Seventies and early Eighties, all, or almost all of these places went to the fortunate members of the left's slate. 
 Every so often, someone would buck the trend: in 1982 Mr Kinnock was dropped from the slate, but kept his place. 
 Generally, however, the best way to become one of the seven constituency representatives on the executive was to win the approval of those who set the slate. 
 It now looks as if membership of the slate is rapidly becoming a disadvantage. 
 Mr Livingstone's vote was down 30 per cent compared with last year; but all other left-wing candidates lost votes, too. 
 Their overall support was down by almost 20 per cent. 
 Prominent critics of the left, by contrast, saw their votes rise: Robin Cook by 18 per cent, Bryan Gould by 12 per cent, Gerald Kaufman by 11 per cent. 
 John Prescott, who did not stand last year, leaped to third place above both Tony Benn and Dennis Skinner, who used to come first and second. 
 What happened this week was a sharp acceleration of a process that started in the mid-Eighties. 
 In 1983, when Mr Kinnock was elected leader, candidates on the left's slate won 74 per cent of constituency votes. 
 Last year they still commanded a majority &mdash; 54 per cent. 
 This year their vote fell to 45 per cent. 
 Only three of their candidates were elected. 
 The left's slide is not over. 
 Individual members are increasingly being balloted for the executive. 
 The more ballots spread, the worse the left performs. 
 If some of Labour's rising stars, such as Tony Blair and Gordon Brown, stand for election, even Mr Benn's place could be in jeopardy. 
 It is possible that within two or three years the left wing will not have a single executive member it can truly call its own in the constituency section. 
 The disintegration of the left's main power-base will have far-reaching consequences. 
 The first is that it will be harder for the Tories to portray Labour as a party gripped by extremism. 
 That charge has been wrong-headed for some years; nevertheless, it has been sustained by enough left-wing activity to feed Conservative propaganda. 
 The second consequence is that ambitious left-of-centre politicians no longer need to genuflect to the far left to advance their career. 
 Future Neil Kinnocks &mdash; or David Blunketts or Michael Meachers or even Ken Livingstones &mdash; will find that their best strategy in their early years in national politics will be to act and speak in a way that appeals to ordinary television-watching, newspaper-reading Labour Party members, rather than to the left's hyperactivists. 
 In other words, ambitious Labour politicians will have to apply the same skills that win national elections to internal party contests. 
 Third, Labour can now proceed to dismantle the block votes of the trade unions confident that these are no longer needed to keep the party sane. 
 For some years leading Labour politicians have offered two separate justifications for the block vote &mdash; one in public, the other in private. 
 Their public defence is that the system brought together the industrial and political arms of the labour movement: abandon the block vote and you betray Labour's parentage. 
 Privately, however, many leading Labour MPs admit that this is a specious argument. 
 Instead they have used block votes like bulbs of garlic &mdash; to keep away the vampires of the left. 
 Now it is clear that by extending one-member-one-vote to the choice of constituency delegates, Labour can safely inject democracy into the party conference without fearing nasty side-effects. 
 The fourth consequence of the humbling of the left is potentially the most important. 
 Too often the leadership's victories over the left have had an unsavoury, pyrrhic quality. 
 Administrative means &mdash; like the block vote - have been used to solve political problems. 
 Debates over important issues, from nuclear weapons to public ownership, have been settled by manipulation rather than persuasion. 
 Few of Labour's keenest supporters could accuse either the right or the left within the party of approaching fresh issues with an open mind. 
 Loyalty to leader or faction has generally taken precedence over original thought. 
 That can now change &mdash; indeed, if the block vote goes, it will have to change. 
 Reason and persuasion will become the currency of Labour Party policy-making. 
 Yesterday's debate about electoral reform could provide the model. 
 The issues cross left-right divisions, and have therefore escaped the usual deadening control of faction-politics. 
 For once, both sides want to win over waverers; and if Labour scraps the block vote, there is a fair chance that eventually the merits of the arguments will determine the policy Labour chooses. 
 It will be a novel and healthy way for Labour to enter the 1990s. 
 World View: The virtues of old history: Lawrence Freedman argues that the key to coping with the future lies in past events 
 By LAWRENCE FREEDMAN 
 The news from California of the death of history now turns out to have been exaggerated. 
 Contrary to Dr Francis Fukuyama's analysis, published in The Independent on September 20 and 21, ideological conflict is not the sole motor of history, and even if it were, this rich seam of dispute has yet to be fully exhausted. 
 That this now seems to be generally agreed is a relief to historians, who otherwise faced mass redundancy. 
 At most they would have remained as caretakers of the museum pieces of the past, reminding the young in this brave new, smug, boring, consensual world of the bad old days when people felt deeply about big issues and the future was uncertain. 
 In practice history is being created this moment at a dizzying pace. 
 Europe is emerging from a period when basic political relationships had congealed. 
 Things have become much more fluid. 
 As Soviet order is relaxed in Eastern Europe, nations which had been kept in their place are reasserting their identities and rediscovering old aspirations. 
 This has an unavoidable knock-on effect on Western Europe, as evidenced by the revival of the &bquo;German question&equo;, and it will eventually lead to Washington reappraising its security interests. 
 All this new history makes old history even more important. 
 It can help us explain why the entrenched and the familiar can suddenly appear conditional and temporary, and inject meaning into those long-forgotten disputes which are bubbling to the surface, especially within the Soviet bloc. 
 It provides the stock of examples and analogies which politicians can plunder to justify policies for a novel and complex situation. 
 History orients us to the present. 
 But history can also play tricks on us. 
 There is a gap between the studies of the historians, continually re-interpreting the past, and the more general set of remembrances drawn upon in public debate. 
 Here the link with evidence may be tenuous, with the result that national myths are bolstered and well-known but inappropriate events from our past cited in support of current policy. 
 The need to avoid bad history is the reason the debate over the teaching of history in schools is so important: what is the proper balance between traditional concerns with royalty and battles as against the need to understand the great political movements of our time and the social and economic conditions which spawned them? 
 Between a focus on Britain and a broad appreciation of the world of which it is but a part? 
 There is a particular problem with contemporary history. 
 Schools have shown increasing interest in it, helped by such excellent organisations as the Institute for Contemporary British History, but there is limited room in the curriculum for the twentieth century, let alone for the period from when the text books end and memory begins. 
 Attitudes to the recent past are largely shaped by experience and the nature and extent of these experiences vary. 
 This is very much a generational problem. 
 Consider, for example, the new students who this week begin courses at universities and polytechnics. 
 Because of the limited recruitment and early retirements in recent years, most of their teachers will come from what is loosely known as the &bquo;Sixties generation&equo;. 
 That is, their memories may just go back to Suez, they can remember where they were when Kennedy was assassinated and their formative political years were dominated by the Wilson government at home and the Vietnam war abroad. 
 The new students, however, were born when Heath was Prime Minister and negotiating entry into what was then the Common Market. 
 They cannot remember when Britain was not part of the European Community or when there were not &bquo;troubles&equo; in Northern Ireland. 
 They were toddlers at the time of Watergate, not yet 10 when Mrs Thatcher came to power, Nato decided to introduce cruise and Pershing missiles and the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan. 
 They were but 11 at the time of the Falklands War and turning 14 as Gorbachev entered the Kremlin. 
 Teachers and students alike are governed, by and large, by people born during the inter-war years, when the Spanish Civil War and appeasement were the great issues. 
 This is a generation for whom the war years remain vivid and the Empire had real meaning. 
 Casual references by our political leaders to what seems to them to be the quite recent past can be lost on a young audience. 
 The new students are also new voters. 
 It is a matter of politics as much as education whether they grasp the flow of history and understand how events flow into one another. 
 If they are to be discerning consumers of political rhetoric they need not only to recognise the references but also to treat with suspicion attempts to make points through the mere mention of Suez or Munich. 
 These events are too often used as nuggets quarried from the record and displayed for our current instruction. 
 But their details are often still controversial and their meaning can only be appreciated by placing them in context. 
 An awareness of old history encourages caution when it is appropriated for a contemporary cause. 
 We are familiar enough with the role of historical myth in Northern Ireland or in the Arab-Israeli dispute. 
 Now it is becoming a powerful factor in the new, frenzied politics of Eastern Europe. 
 A dramatic example of this is the publicity given to the secret annexes to the 1939 Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact. 
 These demonstrate the basis upon which Stalin seized Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania and so undermine the legitimacy of continued Soviet rule. 
 Another example comes with Auschwitz, the Nazi concentration camp in Poland. 
 At its peak some 12,000 innocents were gassed there each day. 
 The majority of victims were Jews but they were not alone &mdash; as many as 4,000 gypsies may have been killed there in one session. 
 It is a relevant example because it involves one of the most searing of twentieth-century experiences, replete with both personal and broader political consequences, and it has recently been in the news. 
 The full horror of Hitler's &bquo;final solution&equo; is generally appreciated, although some, such as Mr David Irving, still attempt to deny its magnitude. 
 However, even those who do not doubt the terrible things that happened can still squabble about their meaning. 
 For example, in 1984 10 Carmelite nuns gained the support of the Archdiocese of Krakow to establish a convent just outside the walls of Auschwitz but in 1987 a number of leading Polish Catholics accepted that this was offensive to Jews and that the convent should be relocated. 
 Earlier this year Cardinal Glemp repudiated this agreement but he has now been prevailed upon to honour it. 
 The most disturbing aspect of this incident was the evidence it provided of a residual antisemitism in Poland, disproportionate to the residue of a once-great Jewish community. 
 Unwittingly perhaps, Cardinal Glemp reflected this when he enjoined Jews not to speak from &bquo;the position of a people raised above all others&equo; and added, in a classic restatement of the myth of Jewish omnipotence: &bquo;Your power is in the mass media, at your immediate disposal in many countries. 
 Do not use it to spread anti-Polonism.&equo; 
 To understand why Jews should be bothered by Catholics praying at this site it is necessary to go back to the role played by the Catholic Church in fomenting antisemitism, the passivity of the Pope during the war while the exterminations were underway and even the suspicions caused by the reception of Austrian President Kurt Waldheim, with his dubious war record, by the present Pope, John Paul II (from Poland). 
 To understand why Jews should be so possessive about a collective tragedy which touched many others, it is necessary to remember that this was mass murder specifically designed for Jews in which others were caught. 
 Cardinal Glemp was persuaded to recant in meetings with British Jews who, to their credit and in contrast to many of their American compatriots, took the route of quiet persuasion rather than shrill denunciation. 
 Afterwards the Cardinal accepted that he had not appreciated the strong feelings of Jews on this issue and that he now hoped to find out more about the Shoah (the Hebrew word for the Holocaust). 
 This might seem naive but it is all too possible. 
 Before the war the Jewish and Gentile communities lived in ignorance of each other and since the war state censorship has failed to allow a full discussion of past antisemitism (which persisted in some ugly incidents after the war). 
 One of the tasks for the Solidarity government is to ensure that a revival in the Polish spirit does not preclude an honest appreciation of the nation's history. 
 It is encouraging that an exhibition on Polish-Jewish life has opened in Krakow. 
 Equally, Jews may come to recognise how Poles feel that the suffering faced by the nation as a whole in the war was overshadowed by the Holocaust. 
 When old nationalisms come to the surface, having been suppressed for decades, it can be in a pure and dangerous form. 
 The few remaining Jews in Eastern Europe are being allowed a greater degree of freedom, but so are antisemites. 
 The rise of ethnic violence throughout the Eastern bloc is unfortunately the other side of the coin to self-determination. 
 History provides us with no guide as to how all this will work out, but it does remind us of the need for sensitivity when dealing with powerful social forces. 
 If post cold-war Europe is not to be violent and conflictual then the sources of rivalry and mistrust need to be addressed head-on. 
 If its post cold-war generation is not to be continually confused by unexpected developments then they will need to come to terms with the dynamics of change. 
 This is not the time to talk of the end of history &mdash; more a time for some good history lessons. 
 Leading Article: Some backyards have to suffer 
 By LAWRENCE FREEDMAN 
 CHRIS PATTEN, the Secretary of State for the Environment, summed up the house-building dilemma when delivering his (provisionally negative) judgement on the proposed building of Foxley Wood, a &bquo;new settlement&equo; on the borders of Berkshire and Hampshire. 
 &bquo;How,&equo; he asked, &bquo;do we provide the houses we need without destroying the places we love?&equo; 
 In essence, his answer was: by adhering to the planning system and leaving land allocation decisions to local authorities. 
 The regional plan for the South-east proposes that some 57,000 new homes should be provided each year. 
 Each county is told how many it should contribute, and is expected to conform to its &bquo;structure plan&equo;, proposing where such development should take place: within existing towns or villages, on their fringes, or on green-field sites. 
 The Foxley Wood project from Consortium Developments which Mr Patten's predecessor said he was &bquo;minded&equo; to allow was for 4,800 new houses in a large shallow quarry and conifer plantation. 
 This private proposal from a grouping of 10 of Britain's biggest house-builders did not form part of the structure plan for north-east Hampshire, and was opposed by the county council as well as local residents. 
 In giving his provisional &bquo;No&equo;, Mr Patten said: &bquo;Only if Hampshire County Council and the districts address the issue of distribution (of new houses) together, and take account of opinion at the local level, are we likely to reach solutions which both meet the housing requirement and satisfy local environmental concerns.&equo; 
 At first blush, that sentiment looks both unimpeachably democratic and commendably &bquo;green&equo;. 
 In reality, it underestimates the not-in-my-backyard factor (who is going to say: &bquo;Yes, please build your new town here?&equo;) and the temptation for county and district councils to avoid hard decisions which might benefit the county or region as a whole, at the certain cost of arousing fierce local opposition. 
 Had that principle ruled post-war planning, there would have been no new towns. 
 Some strategic direction is essential, as successive governments have recognised. 
 Equally, had county councils shown greater vision, more smaller settlements would have been built, and there would have been less urban sprawl, less despoliation of county towns, and fewer hideous spec-building estates on the fringes of attractive old villages. 
 Mr Patten partly concedes this point in recognising that new settlements can offer &bquo;exciting opportunities for imaginative, high-quality design&equo;. 
 Ironically, they are unlikely to arise on sites zoned by local authorities for housing development: such zoning can raise the price of land to as much as 40 per cent of the cost of a house. 
 The developers' profit margin is thus squeezed to a point where they cannot (should they, uncharacteristically, be so minded) spend enough on quality and design. 
 It would be regrettable if Mr Patten's new advice blocked the development of well-planned, quality private settlements on affordable sites. 
 Local residents will almost always oppose such development. 
 Yet an estimated 600,000 homes will be needed in the South-east by the turn of the century. 
 To achieve that target without endless sprawl, local interests will have to be hurt from time to time. 
 Letter: The real cause of terror in Broadwater Farm 
 From COMMANDER DAVID STEVENS 
 Sir: Shaun Waterman and Millard Scott (letter, 5 October) claim that the police operation on Friday criminalised and terrorised the Broadwater Farm Estate. 
 It is the vicious downward spiral of drug abuse, drug dealing and violence that terrorises inner city estates, not the police action to free the vast majority of law-abiding residents from a menace caused by a tiny minority. 
 It is the action of that tiny minority, day in, day out, which terrifies residents and corrupts the lives of young children who learn to accept this behaviour as normal. 
 Halting that activity was the objective of the exercise, not the capture of an enormous haul of drugs. 
 We have made that clear from the start, and we have also made clear that we are more than happy with the results. 
 The Metropolitan Police will not hesitate to take firm action to free communities from this tiny minority. 
 It will act as it did last Friday, with determination and sensitivity. 
 It will do all it can to reassure residents, to accept and prove accountability, to demonstrate openness, and to return communities to a quality of life which others enjoy and which all deserve. 
 However, I should add, it is with regret that we have to take such drastic intervention, a course which could so easily be avoided through co-ordination and commitment by other agencies close at hand. 
 This operation was carried out as the only possible way of dealing with the menace of the drug dealers. 
 The timing was determined by the known peak level of their activity, and by nothing else. 
 To talk of dawn raids in the circumstances is palpable nonsense. 
 The methods of the operation were absolutely necessary to gather evidence necessary for the courts, and were decided after full consultation with the Crown Prosecution Service. 
 The needs of the course of justice prevent me from elaborating further now. 
 From their letter, Mr Scott and Mr Waterman would have people believe that they alone will &bquo;pick up the pieces&equo;. 
 My officers have been bravely patrolling that estate, on behalf of the community which we serve, and will continue to do so. 
 They made it clear to all their colleagues who took part in that operation, and to the Press and observers at the briefing, that they will be supporting the community today, tomorrow and thereafter. 
 I am not aware of who elected Mr Scott and Mr Waterman. 
 What I do know is that it is disgraceful and defamatory to label as stooges the people from the Borough Community Relations Council who gave up a day's work to act as observers, and who have made it clear that they would have reported whatever they had seen, good or bad for police. 
 This is equally true for the Press. 
 If local agencies had chosen to co-operate with police in combating the drugs problem, we would have been delighted. 
 Without denying the great efforts made by the local council and others to improve the estate, it is they who chose not to co-operate with police, not the other way round. 
 For example, Haringey has still not taken its place within the Community Consultative Group set up after Lord Scarman's report on the disorders of 1981. 
 It is our wish, as ever, to build better relationships with these agencies, and develop levels of mutual confidence to a point where the flow of information would be much greater than it has been. 
 I note the allegations made by Mr Waterman and Mr Scott. 
 As I made clear to my officers at that briefing, I expected &mdash; and received &mdash; the very highest standards of policing, sensitivity and courtesy. 
 I stated that I would not hesitate to condemn and punish unacceptable behaviour; equally, I would issue praise. 
 We will investigate every complaint thoroughly. 
 However, I reject the disgraceful and unproven allegation of &bquo;weekly cases of harassment and malpractice&equo; &mdash; it has no basis in fact. 
 Leading Article: Mugabe's lapse of judgement 
 From COMMANDER DAVID STEVENS 
 THE Vice-Chancellor of the University of Zimbabwe, Walter Kamba, has ordered the indefinite closure of the institution after discussions with President Mugabe and members of his cabinet. 
 The decision followed demonstrations on the university's main campus. 
 Arthur Mutambara, president of the student council, who is in hospital as a result of injuries allegedly gained by jumping from a window, is to be charged under the Orwellian-sounding Law and Order Maintenance Act as a result of a statement he issued blaming the government for acts of &bquo;state terrorism&equo;. 
 Earlier, Mr Mutambara had accused the regime of &bquo;neo-fascism, comparable only to that of South Africa&equo;, adding that the university was &bquo;the last island of democracy&equo; in the country. 
 This summer the government decided to make life difficult for Edgar Tekere and his newly-formed opposition Zimbabwe Unity Party (ZUP) which was contesting a by-election in Harare. 
 The seat had become vacant as a result of the suicide of a senior offical of the ruling Zanu (PF) party who had been condemned by a commission of inquiry for profiting from a racket involving the unlawful resale of officially purchased vehicles. 
 Mr Tekere's organisation was refused permission to hold rallies, his officers were detained and newspapers were forbidden to carry ZUP advertisements. 
 Finally, according to The Independent correspondent, writing in July, the vote was &bquo;rigged&equo; to ensure Mr Tekere's defeat. 
 Earlier in the year, emergency powers inherited from the Smith regime were employed to break a strike in the telecommunications industry, although the government claimed that the laws were maintained to deal with armed incursions from Mozambique and South Africa. 
 The thread which runs through these sorry tales is that they are all examples of irrational over-reaction by a government which is, by the standards of the region, honest, able and secure. 
 Unlike some of his neighbours, President Mugabe is in a position to take a relaxed attitude to dissent. 
 He has no reason to fear the imminent collapse either of his administration or his country. 
 The student demonstrations against corruption occurred because of illegalities exposed as a result of his high standards of probity. 
 They could have been contained. 
 Equally, an electoral victory by Mr Tekere would have presented no particular problems to an administration whose members dominate Parliament. 
 And success by striking civil servants, seeking an improvement in pay, would not have imposed an intolerable strain on the state. 
 President Mugabe took office in the aftermath of a civil war in which both sides had behaved with appalling brutality. 
 Even so, he accepted that the maintenance of large landholdings, run predominantly by whites who had supported Ian Smith, was crucial to the economic well-being of his nation. 
 Although he suppressed tribal dissent ruthlessly, he subsequently attempted -with some generosity &mdash; to incorporate representatives of minority tribes into the governance of the state. 
 He has abandoned much of his Marxist baggage and, so far, set his face against the creation of a formal one-party state. 
 It is precisely because Mr Mugabe's record is, in context, more than respectable, that the current repressive mood demonstrated by his government is disappointing. 
 Open season on the great and the good 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 HAVE you noticed the new fashion for psychoanalysing our leaders? 
 We're used to being told dark secrets about dead artists, but suddenly it's open season on twentieth century public figures. 
 In the last few days alone there have been probing books about Mrs Thatcher and Winston Churchill which told us a great deal about the murky depths of the authors. 
 Only the tip of the iceberg, I'm afraid, so here is a brief guide to books due out later this month. 
 Why Prince Charles Does It, by Reg Guttering. 
 Dr Guttering is consultant psychologist to the Royal Institute of British Architects, where he has studied Prince Charles's compulsion to attack contemporary architects. 
 Prince Charles, he says, hates being recognised in public and has transferred these emotions to buildings. 
 Consequently he cannot approve of any building that wants to draw attention to itself. 
 Absorbing. 
 Why Jeffrey Archer Does It, by Professor Norman Zeitung. 
 Professor Zeitung has delved into Jeffrey Archer's childhood to explain why he writes the way he does, and comes up with an extraordinary finding &mdash; Jeffrey Archer never had a childhood! 
 This explains, says the professor, why all Archer's characters seem never to have been through the growing-up process. 
 Gripping. 
 Why The Duchess of York Does It, by Flight Commander Rod Ordnung. 
 Ordnung, consultant psychologist to the Fleet Air Arm, sets out to understand why a perfectly normal red-blooded Sloane should suffer from the terrifying desire to write stories about helicopters that can speak. 
 His theory? 
 That she does it for the money, which symbolises affection, emotional security and personal achievement. 
 Spiffing. 
 Why the Prince of Wales is Sick, Sick, Sick, by Reg Guttering. 
 Another of Dr Guttering's reasoned analyses of Prince Charles's architectural tastes, in which the author suggests that after a childhood spent in some of the most vile Victorian mansions in the country, it is not surprising if the prince is minus the odd nut and bolt. 
 Adhesive. 
 Why I Do It, by Dr Anthony Clare. 
 What possesses a grown man to pretend he is sitting in a psychiatrist's chair on radio and ask celebrities questions in a lilting Irish accent about their mummies and daddies? 
 Why do they answer him? 
 And wouldn't it be easier to get their mummies and daddies on the programme to answer the questions? 
 Dr Clare does not address any of these problems directly, but tells us a lot about his childhood, which seems to have been quite nice, unless he is trying to hide something shameful. 
 Enchanting. 
 Why They Do It, by Jackboot Colophon. 
 Dr Colophon, consultant psychologist to the Press Council, examines why so many consultant psychologists seem impelled to spill the dirt on people like Prince Charles, Mrs Thatcher and Ian Botham. 
 He concludes that they are suffering from fame displacement reversal syndrome, and hints that he had a pretty bloody awful childhood himself. 
 Riveting. 
 Westland, The Little Helicopter, by Michael Heseltine. 
 A charming children's story in which a small helicopter takes on the biggest financial brains in Europe and the USA, and loses badly. 
 In an impressive dream sequence, Westland traces the source of this business inadequacy to his helicopter childhood and wakes up screaming. 
 Compulsive. 
 Oh God, Why Do I Keep Writing These Dreadful Attacks on the Prince of Wales? 
 What's Wrong With Me? 
 And Why Can't I Stop? by Reg Guttering. 
 A cool look at how Richard Rogers's ideas spring from the outside drainpipes of his youth. 
 Tedious beyond belief. 
 Daddy, We Hardly Knew You, by Rupert Murdoch, Clive James and Germaine Greer. 
 A serious inquiry into the theory that almost all Australians had no fathers and have been searching for a father figure ever since, only to find it in their own persons, with resultant confusion. 
 Fascinating. 
 Churchill and the Black Dog, by Dr Heinz Riba. 
 A delightful children's tale about Churchill and his grumpy black dog. 
 &bquo;Come on, let's go and bomb Dresden!&equo; said Churchill. 
 &bquo;That should be fun.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what you said when we invaded Gallipoli,&equo; grumbled Black Dog. 
 &bquo;That didn't turn out to be much fun.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh come, you old spoilsport,&equo; cried Churchill. 
 &bquo;Last over the coastline's a cissy!&equo; 
 Letter: Media obsession with strikes 
 From MICHAEL MEACHER, MP 
 Sir: Your leading article (4 October) is without doubt the most vitriolic piece of anti-trade union bigotry I have read in a serious newspaper for some considerable time. 
 It takes as fact that employers, judges and Tory legislators can do no wrong, and so it is hardly surprising that it finds nothing to be said in favour of trade unions. 
 I do not recognise in your description of an employer &bquo;frivolously testing his rights to its limits&equo; the port employers or British Rail, which both this summer deliberately set out to overturn a majority strike ballot by manipulating the legal process. 
 Nor do I recognise the judges who can discriminate between frivolous and genuine employers in the Appeal Court ruling that dock strikes might have been illegal for the past 40 years. 
 Least of all do I recognise the fairness and balance of the current Tory legislation which you claim. 
 More to the point, however, the public does not recognise this either. 
 Opinion polls now show that employers are blamed for Britain's economic problems and union are more popular than at any time in their history. 
 Finally, it is not Labour and the trade unions who are obsessed with strikes but the media. 
 Speaker after speaker at the Conference voiced the reluctance of workers to take strike action and our commitment to finding other ways of resolving disputes. 
 You may choose not to report this, but you should have the honesty to report Labour's policy accurately. 
 Letter: Divided families 
 From MS JO TUNNARD 
 Sir: Sue Wells' poignant article about adoption (Living, 2 October) captures the heartbreak felt by so many other parents living in Britain today. 
 Each year we advise some 800 families with children in care. 
 One of their main concerns is that their children or grandchildren are to be placed for adoption with no continuing contact with family members, including brothers and sisters. 
 Adoption is pursued as an option for an increasing number of children in care. 
 Unlike Sue's daughter most of these children concerned are not adopted at birth. 
 Some local authorities still operate policy guidelines that recommend that children should stay in care for under two years; at that stage, they should either be back home or adopted. 
 Many of these children are prepared and placed for adoption with strangers, and part of the package is that they will no longer see or be in contact with relatives who have remained in touch during their stay in care. 
 The Government proposes to implement a major review of adoption law in the New Year. 
 We hope that part of its brief will be to research the views of children, relatives and adopters who have been involved in both open and more traditional adoptions. 
 We hope that the review will also invite individual submissions through your pages and other media avenues. 
 Letter: Cul-de-Thatcher 
 From MR MICHAEL HINTON 
 Sir: The residents of this once tranquil village have been bickering for years about the best way to deal with increasing traffic. 
 Thatchergate has given us an idea. 
 Letter: Cul-de-Thatcher 
 From MR DAVID W. HARVEY 
 Sir: Had today's date been 1 April many readers like myself would have nodded with quiet pleasure at your splendid little follow-up about Thatchergate (4 October). 
 Now, however, I wonder if the absurd story is true. 
 If so, it is a sad but illuminating irony. 
 Not so long ago this humble little eighteenth-century precinct provided an amiable short-cut between St James's Park and Whitehall. 
 Seemingly lesser residents of Number 10 found no difficulty in living with this arrangement. 
 While we have to accept that some people have had a good go at blowing up the present inhabitant, would it not be simpler for her to emulate a previous incumbent and move up the road to Admiralty House? 
 It allows the idle trappings of, albeit post-imperial, grandeur; would suit the French much better; ease the lot of the luckless sentinels and, who knows, even simplify the job of security. 
 Letter: TV sponsorship 
 From MR MELVYN BRAGG 
 Sir: Your report (Media, 27 September) was uncharacteristically inaccurate. 
 You say that 01 for London has approval from the IBA to look for sponsorship whereas The South Bank Show does not. 
 This is not the case. 
 Earlier this year the IBA suggested that arts programmes, local and national, could consider sponsorship and many are doing so. 
 David Glencross at the IBA and myself have been in full contact about this. 
 You speak about my &bquo;plea for sponsorship&equo;. 
 There is no plea. 
 Greg Dyke and I decided to explore the possibility of sponsorship, which could well be of great value in London Weekend Television's long-term future. 
 There is no question that LWT can afford to, and wants to, continue its support for The South Bank Show. 
 Letter: Escalating problem 
 From MRS BARBARA TIDMAN 
 Sir: Can nothing be done to stop these wildcat strikes by escalators on the Underground? 
 I do not know how they communicate with each other, but their organisation is formidable. 
 No sooner does one learn to avoid one station than another goes on the blink. 
 No prior warning can be given to travellers as it is obvious that the public address system has been infiltrated and now issues an even worse form of gobbledygook than hitherto. 
 Some say the escalators are controlled by the cones which march up and down the M1, but I find this fanciful. 
 Letter: Questions of faith 
 From MS SUSAN MENDUS 
 Sir: I am sorry that John Torode (3 October) found the Salman Rushdie seminar &bquo;dispiriting&equo;, and even more sorry that he perceives in it the birth of a &bquo;dangerously illiberal orthodoxy&equo;. 
 The real danger lies in dividing the protagonists into &bquo;goodies&equo; and &bquo;baddies&equo; and insisting that battle be joined between the forces of light (liberals like Mr Torode) and the forces of darkness (fundamentalists like Shabir Akhtar). 
 If the Rushdie affair teaches us anything, it is that liberals and fundamentalists alike should inspect their principles in a spirit of critical self-examination. 
 Certainly censorship should not be allowed to masquerade as virtuous compromise, but nor should commitment to free speech go unexamined. 
 As Mr Torode points out, our liberal forefathers insisted on the importance of testing faiths by submitting them to discussion. 
 Liberal commitment to free speech must also be tested in this way, lest it become an unthinking orthodoxy &mdash; a mere article of faith. 
 To submit the free speech principle to such a test is not an argument for book-banning. 
 It is a plea for consistency. 
 If we demand that the faiths of others be tested, how can we refuse to test our own? 
 Letter: Unborn children 
 From MRS JOAN M. CROUCH 
 Sir: It seems clear from Sarah Helm's report that members of SPUC and the Parliamentary Pro-Life Group, are determined to use the debates on the forthcoming Embryo Research Bill as though embryo experimentation and abortion can be considered together. 
 They might pause to reflect that there are those already born who have an equally strong right to life as an unborn child, and for whom embryo experimentation may give some hope of cure or relief. 
 The experience of watching my late husband's 16-year fight against the degenerative effects of Parkinson's disease (one of those conditions which might one day benefit from embryo research) causes me to write this letter in the hope that all who take part in the debates will recognise and confound these tactics of the anti-abortion pressure groups, quite rightly described by the British Pregnancy Advisory Service as &bquo;an attempt to hijack government legislation&equo;. 
 Letter: Unborn children 
 From MS THERESA CROSHAW 
 Sir: Did Sarah Helm (3 October) attend the same Society for Protection of Unborn Children (SPUC) conference as I did? 
 I heard nothing from students about a baby with alleged dog's ears but plenty about biochemical investigations and possible treatments of Down's syndrome from Professor Jerome Lejeune. 
 I should have thought Professor Lejeune's research and clinical findings on prevention of deterioration in Down's children by administration of folic acid or thyroxine in appropriate cases to be particularly newsworthy. 
 Was it overlooked because it demonstrates that insights into genetic disorders can be gained without use of human embryos? 
 It is also curious that, in describing the conference folder, Ms Helm omitted to mention the documented evidence it contained on failure rates, perinatal mortality, incidence of spina bifida and heart defects associated with invitro-fertilisation. 
 These data came, not from what Dame Mary Donaldson (letter, 3 October) chose to call &bquo;emotional, uninformed and often inaccurate outbursts&equo; of the Pro-Life lobby, but from publications of IVF teams, the Director of Australia'a National Perinatal Statistics Unit and the Commonwealth Department of Community Services and Health. 
 Lest anyone object to non-British sources, I should add that Dame Mary, in her foreword to the Interim Licensing Authority's Fourth Report (1989), wrote of &bquo;known obstetric and paediatric hazards&equo; of multiple birth, saying &bquo;we are very worried over the 1987 figures&equo; associated with IVF and GIFT. 
 Why should SPUC's concern for the conceptus be deemed any less legitimate? 
 Letter: Eye accuse 
 From MR DAVID CASH 
 Sir: Yesterday, to illustrate your news item on the Sonia Sutcliffe libel appeal, you published a photograph showing our proprietor Peter Cook, Editor Ian Hislop and myself &mdash; who you captioned as Private Eye's legal adviser. 
 I consider this a monstrous libel and gross slur on my reputation and it has caused grave distress and embarrassment to me and is of course highly defamatory. 
 I require a full and unqualified retraction and substantial damages, ie, &pound;50 to Bananaballs. 
 Letter: In a glass darkly 
 From MR DAVID HAMILTON EDDY 
 Sir: Jonathan Glancey (Architecture; &bquo;Invisible buildings that reflect nothing&equo;, 4 October) does well to remind us of the spreading disease of the mirrored glass building. 
 As Mr Glancey points out, there is much modern building that we may describe as passively mediocre, &bquo;half-hearted Post-Modern&equo;. 
 Mirrored glass is actively, indeed aggressively, mediocre. 
 What you see is what you get &mdash; just an image of yourself. 
 As with those mirrored sunglasses, nothing conveys hostility so well. 
 Letter: King and country 
 From MR HENRY ROE 
 Sir: Apropos the return home of the body of old King Nicholas of Montenegro ('Communists allow burial of Montenegro's last king', 2 October): King Alexander of Yugoslavia was his grandson, not his son-in-law. 
 The son-in-law was King Peter of Serbia, an optimist who translated John Stuart Mill's On Liberty into Serbian. 
 Alexander assumed the throne of Montenegro in 1918 when the French government, in league with the Serbian, refused to allow the old man to go back to Montenegro after his wartime exile in France. 
 Island killings 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Minister to quit 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Rebels give up 
 From MR HENRY ROE 
 BOGOTA (Reuter) &mdash; Colombia's M-19 guerrillas have agreed to lay down their arms and form a political party, taking two steps envisaged by a peace accord signed with the government. 
 Savimbi offer 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Bush operation 
 From MR HENRY ROE 
 WASHINGTON (Reuter) &mdash; President Bush will undergo minor surgery today to remove a small growth from the middle finger of his right hand. 
 Elephants die 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Standards lower 
 From MR HENRY ROE 
 SYDNEY (AFP) &mdash; Civil Aviation Authority officers accused the Australian government of lowering safety standards in an attempt to maintain a domestic air service during the seven-week-old pilots&equo; strike. 
 Ransom paid 
 From MR HENRY ROE 
 RIO DE JANEIRO (AP) &mdash; Luis Sales, head of a Brazilian advertising agency, was freed unharmed after being held by kidnappers for two months. 
 His family is believed to have paid a ransom of up to &dollar;1m. 
 Sailor jailed 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Cocaine haul 
 By MARC CHAMPION 
 WASHINGTON &mdash; Federal agents seized nine tons of cocaine at a house near the Mexican border and six tons from a ship off the Yucatan peninsula yesterday, writes Marc Champion. 
 Moon eclipsed 
 By MARC CHAMPION 
 SEOUL (AP) &mdash; The Rev Moon Ik Hwan, 71, who made an unauthorised trip to North Korea in March to discuss reunification, was sentenced to 10 years in prison for aiding an enemy power. 
 Leader acquitted 
 By MARC CHAMPION 
 MASERU (UPI) &mdash; The chief magistrate in Lesotho ruled that the killing last December of a student by Lesotho's ruler, Major General Metsing Lekhanya, was justifiable homicide. 
 General Lekhanya said he shot the man in an attempt to rescue a woman in distress. 
 Sri Lanka deaths 
 By MARC CHAMPION 
 COLOMBO (Reuter) &mdash; Eighteen young Sinhalese men were beheaded or shot dead and their naked bodies placed around a pond at Peradeniya University, Kandy, in apparent retaliation for the killing of the university's assistant registrar. 
 Embassy attack 
 By MARC CHAMPION 
 SAN SALVADOR (UPI) &mdash; A band of human rights activists, apparently armed with hand grenades, stormed the Costa Rican Embassy and took several people hostage in an attempt to draw international attention to human rights abuses. 
 Blockade goes on 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 MOSCOW &mdash; Azerbaijan is showing no sign of bowing to Moscow and calling off its month-old rail blockade of Armenia, despite a Supreme Soviet decree empowering the government to send in troops to get trains moving, writes Rupert Cornwell. 
 For the six days up to and including Wednesday, no trains had reached Armenia from Azerbaijan. 
 Strike ends 
 By SARAH LAMBERT 
 PARIS &mdash; The wave of strikes that has gripped France for a month showed some signs of abating yesterday as prison officers agreed to go back to work, writes Sarah Lambert. 
 But &mdash; to the government's continued chagrin &mdash; striking tax workers marched through Paris yesterday, and at the Peugeot factories in eastern France the employment ministry has appointed an official conciliator in a last-ditch attempt to bring the unions and management to the negotiating table. 
 Estonians retreat in voting row 
 By SARAH LAMBERT 
 MOSCOW (Reuter) &mdash; The Estonian parliament has suspended clauses in the local election law which had deprived thousands of immigrant Russians of the vote. 
 All those with permanent residence in the republic are to be allowed to vote in a 10 December poll. 
 The law provoked a wave of strikes by immigrant Russian workers after it was passed in August. 
 It was also rejected by the Presidium of the Supreme Soviet in Moscow as contravening the Soviet constitution. 
 Shut campus a sign of wider rifts in Zimbabwe 
 From KARL MAIER in Harare 
 STUDENTS carrying their luggage and books queued solemnly as they waited for lifts home yesterday morning, a day after the University of Zimbabwe had been shut down indefinitely. 
 It was the latest example of the increasing conflict between President Robert Mugabe's government and voices of opposition. 
 The unprecedented closure, following a day of violence on Wednesday between students throwing stones and riot police firing tear-gas grenades, drew expressions of shock from church officials and union leaders. 
 It came just three weeks before the students were due to sit their examinations. 
 The registration of students and all grants and loans have been suspended. 
 &bquo;The authorities responsible have developed so much uncertainty in themselves that they cannot even show tolerance and rationality in dealing with our children,&equo; the Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions (ZCTU) said. 
 It accused the government of engaging in &bquo;the naked use of brute state force and the suppression of individual rights.&equo; 
 Four bishops representing the Catholic Church and the Zimbabwe Council of Churches yesterday met the university's Vice-Chancellor, Walter Kamba, to urge that the campus be reopened and to learn the fate of the estimated 40 students arrested following the protests. 
 They hoped to arrange a meeting with Mr Mugabe, who in his capacity as Chancellor of the university was believed to have taken the decision to close the campus. 
 A police spokesman said yesterday that the Student Representative Council's president, Arthur Mutambara, and its secretary, Enock Chikweche, whose arrests early on Wednesday prompted the violence, could face charges of organising an &bquo;illegal meeting&equo;. 
 The student leaders had written a statement accusing the government of practising &bquo;state terrorism&equo; and comparing it unfavourably with the white minority rulers of South Africa. 
 The document was a riposte to the government's refusal to permit a campus commemoration on 29 September of the first big student protests against corruption a year ago. 
 It led to a cabinet decision on Tuesday to arrest Mr Mutambara and Mr Chikweche under Zimbabwe's 24-year-old emergency powers regulations, which were inherited from Ian Smith's Rhodesia. 
 Soon after police arrived to carry out the order, violence spread, as students smashed and set fire to Mr Kamba's Mercedes car, and police responded with tear gas and baton charges. 
 The university was the birthplace of the first serious protests against reports of increasing corruption in Mr Mugabe's nine-year-old administration, when students clashed with riot police. 
 Since then, the &bquo;Willowgate&equo; scandal over the illegal sale of cars has brought down five cabinet ministers, one of whom committed suicide. 
 A former adviser to Mr Mugabe, Edgar Tekere, has formed a new opposition party, the Zimbabwe Unity Movement, and the government, armed with the emergency powers, has suppressed a number of strikes. 
 The ZCTU warned the government yesterday that &bquo;its attempts to suppress the growing disenchantment of the masses&hellip; will certainly plunge the whole society into complete turmoil sooner rather than later&equo;. 
 Rumours of releases preoccupy S Africa 
 From JOHN CARLIN in Johannesburg 
 IN THE relative absence of pressing political news, the South African press has returned to predicting the release of famous political prisoners. 
 The idea of an imminent release for Nelson Mandela has been dropped. 
 The new word is that South Africa's second most famous prisoner, Walter Sisulu, will be out soon. 
 One day, if only by the laws of probability, the rumours will be proved right. 
 The word here &mdash; many talk but few are willing to be quoted &mdash; is that Nelson Mandela will be the last to go, and that he is working closely with the government in arranging a timetable for the releases. 
 Those on the list are: Mr Sisulu, sentenced with Mr Mandela to life imprisonment in the &bquo;Rivonia Trial&equo; of 1964; four other Rivonia triallists - Raymond Mhlaba, Elias Motsoaledi, Andrew Mlangeni, Ahmed Kathrada, Wilton Mkwayi and the oldest of them all, 80-year-old Oscar Mpheta, a trade union leader who has been behind bars since 1980, and whose whose sentence runs out next year. 
 His son Themba, who is studying at Liverpool University, said yesterday on the telephone that his family had been reliably informed that he and Mr Sisulu would be out this month. 
 According to sources close to Mr Mandela himself, the first two men out will be Wilton Mkwayi and Elias Motsoaledi, a very influential member of the ANC old guard with positions of leadership both in the union movement and in the ANC's military wing, Umkhonto we Sizwe. 
 Money is being raised at the moment to provide houses for those who come out first. 
 Mr de Klerk's main criterion, as far as one can tell, in deciding who is released first is to attempt to minimise the chances of mass political gatherings giving way to violence and, the great nightmare, loss of government control. 
 This is why Mr Mandela will not come out first, why the initial idea will be to test the waters with the lesser-known prisoners. 
 Which would suggest that it might be rash to release Mr Sisulu, who has been secretary general of the ANC since 1949, at this stage. 
 Abu Nidal link to Wybran murder 
 From ROBERT FISK in west Beirut 
 A GROUP claiming to represent Abu Nidal's Palestinian assassination organisation claimed yesterday that it had murdered a leader of the Jewish community in Belgium because he was &bquo;one of the main leaders of Israel's Mossad secret service&equo;. 
 Dr Joseph Wybran, the head of the Belgian Auschwitz Committee, who had campaigned for the removal of an order of Carmelite nuns from a convent just outside the perimeter of the former Birkenau extermination camp, was shot in the head outside Brussels University Hospital on Wednesday. 
 A typewritten statement in Arabic delivered to a Western news agency in west Beirut said that the &bquo;soldiers of justice&equo; &mdash; a name previously used by Abu Nidal's organisation when it kidnapped the Belgian doctor, Jan Cools, in southern Lebanon last year &mdash; had &bquo;executed the death sentence&equo; against Dr Wybran, adding that this was done to encourage the Palestinian intifada uprising against Israeli rule in the West Bank and Gaza strip. 
 Given the propensity of Abu Nidal (whose real name is Sabri el-Banna) to embarrass the Palestine Liberation Organisation's chairman, Yasser Arafat, the statement - which was not typed on Abu Nidal's &bquo;Fatah Revolutionary Council&equo; notepaper - appeared to be timed to coincide with the attampts of the Egyptian President, Hosni Mubarak, to involve the Israelis in talks with pro-PLO Palestinians. 
 The statement said that Dr Wybran's murder had been perpetrated &bquo;in support of the Muslim Palestinian people&hellip; and in response to the generation of &bquo;the children of the stone&equo; '. 
 The killing, it said, was also carried out &bquo;in response to the crime of assassination of the martyr, Neman Refat&equo;. 
 It did not clarify who Neman Refat was. 
 The murder was also revenge, the statement went on, for &bquo;the suspicious calls for co-existence and normalisation of relations with the entity of the Israeli enemy&equo; &mdash; a clear reference to President Mubarak's desire to talk to the Israelis about a Palestinian state. 
 Israel defers decision on Egypt's talks proposal 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Jerusalem 
 ISRAEL'S inner cabinet yesterday deferred a decision on whether to accept Egypt's invitation to convene Israeli and Palestinian delegations for talks designed to lead to a resolution of the dispute in the occupied territories. 
 The inner cabinet is to meet again today. 
 The aim of the Egyptian proposal was modest: to hold preliminary discussions on conditions for elections among Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza Strip for a team to negotiate arrangements during an interim stage. 
 This could last several years and might eventually lead to more talks to determine the final status of the occupied territories. 
 Labour ministers presented their resolution to accept the Egyptian proposals. 
 The Israeli Foreign Minister, Moshe Arens, of Likud, who had just returned from America, detailed the proposal of the US Secretary of State, James Baker, for three-way consultations on the composition of the Palestinian delegation. 
 The debate has again underlined the paralysis of a government made up of two parties which hold such opposing views on the resolution of the the occupied-territories question. 
 The inner cabinet meeting had been billed as being vital for the search for a settlement in the region and the future of the national-unity government. 
 Many in the US were keenly awaiting the outcome: Mr Baker had made several statements expressing Washington's desire for Israel to reach an agreement with the Palestinians on elections. 
 Two of the most influential US newspapers called for decisions. 
 &bquo;This is a great opportunity here &mdash; and the Israelis should seize it,&equo; The Washington Post said. 
 The New York Times recommended &bquo;gentle persuasion&equo; on Likud to make Yitzhak Shamir, the Prime Minister, budge. 
 Government officials habitually deny US ability to pressurise Israel. 
 &bquo;They are shrewd enough to appreciate that the appearance of pressure from outside is counter-productive in Israel,&equo; one official said. 
 But that pressure might not be quite so counter-productive. 
 That is the most obvious explanation for the apparent keenness of Mr Arens and Mr Shamir to consider Washington's proposal that Israel, the US and Egypt should hold consultations on the composition of any Palestinian delegation for talks with Israel. 
 It appears Mr Shamir, as with his original peace initiative, is keen to get the Americans off his back by showing willing. 
 It is well established that any Palestinian delegates must be acceptable to all parties: if this were not already the case, the Palestinian delegation would be made up of PLO members. 
 The composition of any Palestinian delegation remains one of two crucial issues at the heart of Likud's opposition to the 10 points put forward by President Mubarak of Egypt and devised as clarifications of Israel's own initiative. 
 More particularly, the question is over the association the delegates have with the PLO. 
 There is a government consensus that rejects talks with the PLO or the establishment of a Palestinian state. 
 However, Labour ministers accept that Palestinian delegates must inevitably be authorised by the PLO and they see these delegates as a channel to the PLO. 
 The nationalist camp in Likud argues that such contrivances will lead eventually to dialogue with the PLO and to the establishment of a Palestinian state. 
 Likud seeks an alternative to the PLO. 
 It refuses to consider the participation of outside Palestinians, whether US professors of Palestinian origin, or deported West Bankers. 
 Likud has consistently argued that it wants to deal only with local inhabitants of what it calls Judea and Samaria (the West Bank and Gaza). 
 &bquo;Once you accept outside Palestinians, you validate the concept of their right of return to their former homes in what is now Israel,&equo; a Likud source said. 
 Likud sources are confident the disagreements over how to respond to the Mubarak proposals will not break up the government. 
 &bquo;It's in no one's interests to have a government crisis. 
 The US doesn't want one for three reasons. 
 First, it will postpone any movement towards a peace process. 
 Second, because if there were elections in Israel, there would be no guarantee that a more flexible Labour government would get in. 
 Thirdly, because they regard the elections as basically a viable process. 
 So President Bush is anxious not to have a crisis. 
 The Egyptians are anxious too: that's why Foreign Minister Abdel Meguid is coming here. 
 And Shimon Peres is eager to avoid a showdown which may lead to his ouster as leader of the Labour Party.&equo; 
 Much now depends on how active a role the US is prepared to play to chivvy Israel along to respond to the Egyptian proposals. 
 Buthelezi steps into Commonwealth flurry 
 By JOHN BULLOCH, Diplomatic Editor 
 THE ZULU leader, Mangosuthu Buthelezi, held talks with Margaret Thatcher in Downing Street yesterday as the Prime Minister prepared to withstand attacks over her southern Africa policy at the Commonwealth Heads of Government conference in Kuala Lumpur later this month. 
 It was also announced yesterday that Britain was giving &pound;500,000 to the Urban Foundation in South Africa, a private group backed by South African businesses, to help finance homes for low-income black families. 
 At the same time, William Waldegrave, the Minister of State at the Foreign Office, met a delegation from the Southern Africa Coalition, an umbrella organisation linking all anti-apartheid groups. 
 Chief Buthelezi, one of the few black leaders inside South Africa who has been consistent in opposing sanctions, will address a fringe meeting at the Conservative conference in Blackpool next Tuesday. 
 What has become a round of South African diplomacy in London began earlier this year when FW de Klerk visited London as President-in-waiting. 
 Another official visitor was Barend du Plessis, the Finance Minister, while Helen Suzman, the best known of all the critics of the system in South Africa, met the Prime Minister a week ago. 
 Other callers have included Albertina Sisulu, wife of the jailed ANC veteran, Walter, representatives of the United Democratic Front and a leader of one of the nominally independent homelands. 
 Then, at the beginning of this week, the ANC and a group of South African academics and businessmen chose London as the scene of the latest in the series of black-white encounters which have become a regular feature of South African political life, while Mrs Thatcher gave interviews to four leading black journalists. 
 The support given to the Urban Foundation showed British recognition of the acute shortage of housing for blacks in South Africa's urban areas, a move welcomed by Nthato Motlana, chairman of Soweto's civic association. 
 Whitehall officials said there was no planned campaign behind all the activity linking London and Johannesburg. 
 &bquo;A number of invitations have been outstanding for some time, and people just chose to take them up at this stage,&equo; one said. 
 At the same time, it was accepted that all the talks, petitions, donations and arguments had been brought about by the imminence of the Commonwealth Conference, where the Secretary-General, Sonny Ramphal, has warned that Britain may find itself in a minority of one over South Africa. 
 Mrs Thatcher has made it clear that Britain remains as adamantly opposed as ever to sanctions and has no intention of joining in new measures against South Africa. 
 The latest argument deployed in Whitehall yesterday was not only that sanctions hurt the worst-off sections of the South African community &mdash; the ones they are designed to help &mdash; but that financial measures against South Africa might induce the country to default on its international commitments. 
 Mrs Thatcher has emphasised that to avoid the troubles which have afflicted other African countries, a majority-ruled South Africa must be based on a sound economy. 
 The British line has been that there is a huge difference between the image of Britain accepted in South Africa and the reality. 
 Officials said that President de Klerk was severely shaken by his meetings with Mrs Thatcher and Sir Geoffrey Howe, then Foreign Secretary. 
 &bquo;There seems to be an idea in South Africa that Britain will protect the country in the Security Council and fight against the imposition of sanctions. 
 That may be true in general, but the other side of the coin is that Britain expects change in return, and puts on tremendous pressure to get that change,&equo; one official said. 
 Commonwealth countries take the view that it is the limited sanctions so far applied which have done much to bring about the new climate represented by the de Klerk administration, and believe a turn of the screw would effect more change. 
 It is because Britain will resist that idea in Malaysia that Whitehall is so anxious to build up a record of consultation, commitment and sympathy towards the majority in South Africa. 
 Peking scorns the God King's Nobel prize 
 From ANDREW HIGGINS in Peking 
 SHORT of selecting a dead student, the Nobel Prize Committee could hardly have made a choice more calculated to embarrass and enrage the Chinese leadership. 
 By awarding the Dalai Lama the Nobel Peace Prize, it has strengthened what is the one real threat to Peking's rule of Tibet, the one source of dissent that cannot be silenced by guns: the international prestige of Tibet's exiled &bquo;God King&equo;. 
 Officials in Peking last night refused to comment on the award. 
 But the Chinese embassy in Oslo, where the prize is awarded, reacted with accusations that it was meddling in China's internal affairs, the stock response to any foreign commentary deemed hostile to China's rule of Tibet. 
 For years, China has used a combination of strong arm diplomacy and shrill rhetoric to try to deny the Dalai Lama international recognition as a legitimate representative of Tibet's aspirations as something other than a part of China. 
 The tactics have largely worked. 
 Most governments, including that of Britain, have shied away from receiving the Dalai Lama as a political as well as spritual leader. 
 But with the Dalai Lama, who fled to India in 1959 after a failed uprising against Chinese rule, now honoured with a Nobel Peace Prize not merely for his religious work but for &bquo;his struggle for the liberation of Tibet&equo;, China's efforts to keep him and his cause in quarantine will be all the more difficult. 
 The award also challenges China's long-held view that Tibetans sheltering abroad are no more than terrorists bent on disrupting the &bquo;unity of the motherland&equo;. 
 For Peking, Tibet has been an inseparable part of China since the 13th century, although direct control was not established until 1950, when the People's Liberation Army invaded the region after the revolution. 
 China therefore regards any challenge to its sovereignty over Tibet as intolerable interference and any threat from inside Tibet as treason. 
 In Peking's eyes, the Nobel Peace Prize could not have come at a worse time. 
 With China's international reputation already badly tarnished by its bloody suppression of protesters in Tiananmen Square, the Nobel Committee decision focuses attention on the use of equally brutal, though largely ignored, methods to silence opposition in the Himalayas. 
 It was in Tibet, after an outbreak of separatist rioting in March, the 30th anniversary of the 1959 revolt, that Peking first tested the use of martial law and indiscriminate gunfire. 
 They worked. 
 Troops continue to patrol the streets of Lhasa and police continue to make arrests &mdash; as they do in Peking. 
 The embarrassing parallels between the party's response to discontent in Peking and Lhasa also embrace rhetoric and ideology. 
 Tibet has been the testing ground for China's propaganda organs. 
 When it came to explain why millions of ordinary people had joined in student-led unrest in the capital, the Communist Party resorted to the line already used to explain away outbursts of discontent in Tibet &mdash; the masses were deceived and manipulated by a &bquo;tiny handful&equo; of &bquo;evil-doers, ruffians and counter-revolutionaries&equo;. 
 While the award of the Nobel Prize will, if anything, only strengthen Peking's resolve over Tibet, it challenges Peking to honour what it says is its readiness to open dialogue with the Dalai Lama. 
 China has so far refused to give any clear response to an offer he made last year to open talks on the basis of new proposals. 
 In what was seen as an important concession to China and condemned by more militant Tibetans as a sell-out, the Dalai Lama effectively acknowledged China's overall sovereignty and suggested that Tibet become a self-governing region in association with China, a relationship that would leave Peking in control of both foreign policy and defence. 
 Apparently caught off guard by the proposals, Peking threw up a host of pre-conditions and challenged the Dalai Lama's &bquo;sincerity&equo;. 
 The oubreak of violence in March and China's subsequent military crackdown in Tibet seem to have extinguished even the faintest hopes of a negotiated settlement in the near future. 
 As China's reaction to Western sanctions over the events in Tiananmen has shown, further international pressure on the Dalai Lama's behalf may only reinforce Peking's siege mentality and strengthen its conviction that the West is conspiring to undermine socialism in China. 
 China's new rulers boosted by Deng 
 By ANDREW HIGGINS 
 PEKING &mdash; Having dumped two heirs apparent in under three years, Deng Xiaoping yesterday moved to buttress the shaky position of yet another set of hand-picked successors by announcing that they, not he, were now running China. 
 Speaking to Yasser Arafat, the Palestine Liberation Organisation leader, who is visiting China, Mr Deng announced that the Prime Minister, Li Peng, and the head of the Communist Party, Jiang Zemin, were &bquo;now in charge&equo; writes Andrew Higgins. 
 &bquo;If there is anything you want to talk about, just talk to them,&equo; Mr Deng, China's paramount leader, told his guest. 
 His remarks follow a media campaign to build up the prestige of Mr Jiang, who was party boss in Shanghai before moving to Peking to replace his disgraced predecessor, Zhao Ziyang. 
 Mr Deng has repeatedly promised to retire in recent years, but yesterday was the first time he had reissued the pledge since the Tiananmen Square massacre and a shake-up of the party leadership. 
 Precedent, however, suggests that his comments will offer only cold comfort to Mr Jiang and Mr Li. 
 None of Mao's or Mr Deng's heirs has survived long enough to assume fully their designated role as successor. 
 Disinformation reigns on the Cambodian front 
 From TERRY MCCARTHY in Bangkok 
 THAILAND'S Foreign Ministry yesterday suffered a public relations fiasco when it failed to produce five Vietnamese soldiers it claimed had been captured inside Cambodia after Hanoi's much-publicised troop withdrawal from Cambodia last week. 
 Thailand claims the Vietnamese withdrawal was not genuine, and on Monday a Foreign Ministry spokesman, Prachyadavi Tavedikul, said reporters would be shown five Vietnamese in Cambodian Army uniforms who had been taken prisoner by Khmer Rouge resistance guerrillas after Hanoi's withdrawal deadline of 26 September. 
 About 30 journalists turned up at the Thai border village of Pong Nam Ron, about 200 miles east of Bangkok, yesterday morning, but were told by the local Thai military commander that he knew of no Vietnamese prisoners. 
 &bquo;As far as I know, no Vietnamese have been captured since 26 September,&equo; said Marine Colonel Chumphon Chotiyothin. 
 This propaganda flop is only the latest in a stream of disinformation and contradictory statements emanating from Cambodia since the Vietnamese said they were finally withdrawing all their troops from the country. 
 Reports of military gains by the Cambodian resistance have almost certainly been exaggerated in the last week, and estimations by the Thai and Chinese military intelligence agencies of the number of Vietnamese troops supposedly left behind in Cambodia appear little more than fanciful. 
 The non-communist Khmer People's National Liberation Front (KPNLF) said earlier this week it had captured 24 Phnom Penh government positions on Route 69 in the north-west of the country. 
 But military analysts in Bangkok pointed out that casualty figures are low, many of the positions along the sparsely-populated Route 69 are little more than bamboo huts sheltering two or three soldiers, and no big towns have been threatened. 
 Phnom Penh government troops in some small outposts appear to have simply surrendered when they realised they were outnumbered, said a Western intelligence source in Bangkok. 
 &bquo;The KPNLF is anxious to put on a show of force at a time when the US Congress is debating future aid to the non-communist resistance factions.&equo; 
 There has also been some hasty back-pedalling over the fate of the Cambodian border town of Pailin. 
 Thai military sources had been predicting the imminent fall of Pailin, saying that the Khmer Rouge were bombarding the town with up to 1,000 shells a day. 
 But reporters who visited Pailin last week found the area quiet, and saw little evidence of artillery damage to the town. 
 &bquo;Tibet faces elimination&equo; 
 From TERRY MCCARTHY in Bangkok 
 NEWPORT BEACH (Reuter) &mdash; The Dalai Lama, on a visit to California, said after winning the Nobel Peace Prize yesterday: &bquo;Tibetans today are facing the real possibility of elimination as a people and a nation.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;The Chinese students have given me great hope for the future of China and Tibet. 
 I feel that their movement follows the tradition of Mahatma Gandhi which has deeply inspired me ever since I was a small boy. 
 &bquo;I hope and pray that the decision to give me the Nobel Peace Prize will encourage all those who pursue the cause of peace to do so in a renewed spirit of optimism and strength.&equo; 
 &bquo;Russians must have an honest rouble&equo; 
 By JOHN LICHFIELD 
 WASHINGTON &mdash; The Soviet Union risked an &bquo;inflationary disintegration&equo; of its economic reforms unless it moved rapidly to a convertible rouble backed by gold, according to Wayne Angell, a governor of the US Federal Reserve, writes John Lichfield. 
 &bquo;It is my belief that, without an honest money, Soviet citizens cannot be expected to respond to the reforms, as they do not have a meaningful incentive,&equo; said Mr Angell. 
 &bquo;A gold-backed rouble would be seen as an honest money at home and would immediately trade as a convertible currency internationally.&equo; 
 The call for a Soviet gold standard was made in an interview between Mr Angell and a representative of the Soviet central bank, Gosbank. 
 It was echoed this week by the US Secretary of State, James Baker. 
 The subject is expected to be on the agenda when the chairman of the Federal Reserve Board, Alan Greenspan, becomes the first US central bank chief to visit Moscow this weekend. 
 The interview, in Moscow last month, is to be published in Izvestia. 
 Extracts appeared yesterday in The Wall Street Journal. 
 &bquo;I have offered a prediction to several officials of the Soviet government that, on the present slow course, the reforms run a very high risk of being set back by a general collapse of confidence in the rouble &mdash; an inflationary disintegration,&equo; Mr Angell said. 
 A convertible rouble was the essential foundation-stone for perestroika, Mr Angell said. 
 &bquo;You cannot address the apparent ills of the Soviet economy without first introducing a monetary standard of value.&equo; 
 The Gosbank official said Mr Angell was advocating a policy for the Soviet Union which the US abandoned with the collapse of the Bretton Woods agreement in 1971. 
 Mr Angell responded that it would not be feasible for Moscow to leap from the present unconvertible rouble to the complex Western system of floating exchange rates, or to a dollar or yen-backed rouble. 
 On the other hand, Moscow was one of the world's largest holders of gold bullion. 
 Around the World 
 By BRUCE PALLING 
 No respite for leftist cows IT IS not just the peasants who are revolting in Romania &mdash; the few remaining kulaks are also playing up. 
 They have raised the ire of President Ceausescu by letting their cattle die of old age or starvation both because fodder is extremely scarce and the miserable prices offered by the state. 
 According to exile sources in Vienna, cows are now being treated like Romanian women &mdash; ie, subjected to a monthly gynaecological examination just to make sure their fertility is not being interfered with because population increases are the order of the day. 
 In Ceausescu's Romania, making your cow miscarry is a crime subject to imprisonment. 
 Habsburg dynasty Dr Otto von Habsburg, son of the last King-Emperor of Hungary, has politely turned down an offer to stand in next month's Hungarian presidential election as the candidate of the Smallholders party. 
 The 76-year-old Euro-MP, who currently lives in West Germany, said he would of course not rule out a run some time in the future but for the moment he feels he can do more to promote his country in the European parliament. 
 &bquo;Mr&equo; Habsburg may not have a throne to sit on, he does have a leg to stand on. 
 Although the Hungarians chased the hapless Habsburgs out of town more than 70 years ago, in the confusing Fifties, the comrades were too preoccupied jailing and executing social deviants to strip the pretender of his nationality. 
 Libya-Venice axis Venetian politicians have decided against accepting a Libyan offer to annex their city to prevent it from sinking any further into either the sea or debt. 
 Jana, the official Libyan news agency, had earlier claimed that Libyan control would be a'logical and historical' move because of the considerable early Arab links with the city. 
 Jana contended that the Phoenician empire was Arab and therefore Venice was once part of a Pan-Arab civilisation, not to mention the other claim that many Venetians have Arab roots from ninth-century traders. 
 Venetian historians promptly discounted the claim, although Italian writer, Alberto Ongaro, thought that the move could have a positive effect after all. 
 &bquo;Let's hope that the prospect of becoming Libyan citizens will frighten Venetians into swiftly solving the problems that Gaddafi wants to take over.&equo; 
 First or steerage? 
 There is something a little distasteful about the head of the biggest international refugee organisation preferring to travel first class to solve the problems of the worlds dispossessed. 
 However, Jean-Pierre Hocke, the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, is hardly the first person in the job to prefer the pointy end of a jumbo jet. 
 The real problem is that he is Swiss and not Danish. 
 The previous incumbent, Poul Hartling &mdash; a former Danish Prime Minister &mdash; was provided with a special fund inside the &bquo;education budget&equo; by the Danish government for him to upgrade himself on his international travels. 
 However, a shocked Danish bureaucrat blew the whistle on Mr Hocke as that &bquo;refugee education fund&equo; was only supposed to be for Mr Hartling and not any old non- Danish High Commissioner. 
 Mr Hartling's predecessor, Prince Sadruddin Aga Khan, avoided such pitfalls by simply chartering private jets and paying for them out of his not inconsiderable private coffers. 
 Turning new page From the beginning of next year, two of the lesser-known journals of the Central Committeee of the Soviet Communist Party, with the titles of Political Education and Agitator will cease to exist. 
 Instead, they will be replaced with a magazine with a less strident and more caring title - Dialog. 
 Rebels &bquo;would not hand over general&equo; 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Washington 
 IN THE dying hours of Tuesday's Panamanian coup, rebel officers refused a &bquo;face-to-face&equo; request from a US military officer to hand over General Noriega for trial in America, the US Defence Secretary, Dick Cheney, said yesterday. 
 Shortly afterwards the rebels asked for US troops to help them to defend the routes to the military headquarters they had seized. 
 The US gave no answer to their request, said Mr Cheney. 
 He said Washington decided against helping the rebels because they refused to hand over General Noriega and because the US doubted their democratic good faith. 
 The coup was not to restore democracy, he said, but a &bquo;power struggle within the Panamanian Defence Force&equo;. 
 Other US government sources said both the rebels and the US army Southern Command, based in Panama, had been startled by the swift recovery of the pro-Noriega forces on Tuesday. 
 The &bquo;loyal&equo; forces air-lifted a company of troops to an air-strip near the military headquarters held by the rebels. 
 Their arrival swung on to General Noriega's side a battalion which had previously declined to commit itself. 
 Earlier, Mr Cheney appeared on television to rebut criticism of the Bush administration's actions &mdash; or inactions &mdash; during the coup. 
 He confirmed that General Noriega was briefly in the hands of the rebels but said the US had no time to make use of this fact. 
 &bquo;It wasn't until late in the coup activities that it became clear that the coup plotters did, in fact, have him,&equo; Mr Cheney said. 
 &bquo;Shortly after that the coup collapsed.&equo; 
 When approached &bquo;face to face&equo; by a senior US officer, two rebel officers said they wanted General Noriega to retire within Panama, rather than face drug trafficking charges in the US. 
 Although Washington was notified of the rebellion last weekend, Mr Cheney said there was &bquo;considerable reason&equo; to be cautious. 
 US doubts were redoubled by news that the coup was to be led by Major Giraldi, a close associate of the Panamanian military dictator. 
 &bquo;There was the possibility that it was an effort to draw the US into some kind of an embarrassing incident,&equo; Mr Cheney said. 
 The incident has become deeply embarrassing for the Bush administration, precisely because of its caution. 
 Criticism of the White House by both Democrats and Republicans grew yesterday. 
 Comparisons were made with the Reagan administration's more robust attitude during the Grenada invasion and Libya bombing raid in 1984 and 1986. 
 Democratic Congressman Dave McCurdy said &bquo;there is a resurgence of the wimp factor&equo; and Republican Congressman William Broomfield said: &bquo;We blew it&hellip; 
 It's a major setback for our foreign policy.&equo; 
 Other politicians complained that the failed coup had exposed the unaccustomed weakness of US intelligence and undercover activities in Latin America. 
 Panama cracks down on opposition 
 From CHRIS MCGREAL in Panama City 
 PARAMILITARY police fired shots and sealed off Panama's opposition headquarters yesterday, locking former presidential candidate Guillermo Endara inside for two hours after opposition leaders held a press conference to deny involvement in prior knowledge of Tuesday's failed coup attempt. 
 Minutes earlier, General Noriega, the military dictator, urged supporters at a rally to &bquo;defeat the indecisive ones&equo; &mdash; presumably a reference to dissent within the military after the second failed rebellion against him in less than two years. 
 Mr Endara, looking drawn from a 16-day-hunger strike in protest at the government refusal to recognise his victory in May's annulled election, was unharmed but two aides at the Liberal Party office, which serves as the opposition coalition headquarters, were arrested. 
 The incident appeared to be part of the continuing harassment of the opposition, similar to the brief arrest of the Christian Democrat leader, Ricardo Arias Calderon, earlier this week. 
 But it was the challenge from within the Panamanian Defence Force (PDF) that most concerned General Noriega yesterday. 
 The PDF issued a &bquo;war communique&equo; saying three senior officers, including the head of military intelligence, were among 37 arrested after the coup attempt. 
 Ten soldiers were killed, including the coup leader, Major Moises Giroldi Vega. 
 The list of dead and detained suggested that the conspiracy against the general ran wider than initially thought. 
 But at the same time it showed that there remained a solid contingent of the defence force loyal to General Noriega, who is wanted in the US on drug-trafficking charges. 
 The Defence Force's account raised doubts about the circumstances of the deaths of some of the rebels. 
 Only officers and NCOs were among those listed as killed, whereas dozens of lower ranking soldiers were involved in the fighting. 
 The US Senator Jesse Helms said in Washington yesterday he had reports from Panama that General Noriega had personally shot dead Major Giroldi, the commander of the &bquo;Urraca&equo; company charged with defending the Defence Force headquarters from where the uprising was launched. 
 US defence officials could not confirm the claim. 
 General Noriega detained two of the five colonels on his General Staff, both until now thought to have been loyal senior officers. 
 Colonel Guillermo Wong headed G-2 military intelligence, the General's post until he took control of the Defence Force. 
 Colonel Julio Ow Young was in charge of military administration. 
 The Chief of the Combined Staff, Lieutenant-Colonel Armando Palacios Gondola and the head of the Navy, Jose Sanchez, were also among those accused of participating in the rebellion. 
 The dead officers were drawn from a number of battalions, revealing that the coup attempt was not confined solely to rebels within the &bquo;Urraca&equo; company. 
 Those killed included Edgardo Sandoval, the leader of the Dobermann riot squad who signed the communique demanding General Noriega's resignation, and three officers from the elite 2,000 Battalion. 
 Military sources said some those arrested may not have direct knowledge of the coup. 
 They suggested Colonel Wong may have been detained because, as head of military intelligence, he failed to uncover the plot. 
 Sources also pointed to the swift response of troops loyal to General Noriega, especially the 7th Infantry, as evidence that he can still count on important parts of the military to back him up. 
 Nevertheless the implications of senior and middle-ranking officers drawn from an array of army units suggests that the General is less secure than he is prepared to admit. 
 General Noriega tried to isolate opposition within the military after a similar coup attempt last year by promoting loyal officers to the important Strategic Military Council and General Staff, and retiring those thought to be less enthusiastic in their support of him. 
 But the promotions appear not only to have brought resentment among officers who were passed over but also failed to overcome unrest at hardship caused by US sanctions. 
 While officers within General Noriega's inner circle continued to benefit from their various illicit businesses, the majority of the military has not been paid in three weeks. 
 Mr Arias, the Christian Democrat leader, said yesterday: &bquo;Noriega and the defence force are at their weakest moment. 
 This illustrates that the regime is profoundly divided against itself.&equo; 
 Mr Endara said he planned to continue his hunger strike to support a civil disobedience campaign to press General Noriega to step down. 
 &bquo;Praise The Lord&equo; Bakker found guilty on all counts 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 JIM BAKKER, the fallen televangelist, was convicted yesterday of swindling followers of his Praise The Lord ministry out of more than &dollar;150m (&pound;90m) and syphoning off part of the money to fund his extravagant lifestyle. 
 Mr Bakker and his wife, Tammy Faye, took the news calmly in the courtroom, although the 24 counts of fraud and conspiracy carry a maximum penalty of 120 years in prison and a &dollar;5m fine. 
 Mr Bakker was released on bail pending his sentencing, on 24 October. 
 He appeared briefly outside the courthouse in Charlotte, North Carolina. 
 &bquo;At this moment my faith is still in God&hellip; 
 I went into the courtroom innocent of the charges against me, and I am still innocent,&equo; he said. 
 Mrs Bakker sang, in chorus with her supporters, &bquo;On Christ the solid rock I stand/ All other ground is sinking sand&equo;. 
 She then added &bquo;It isn't over until it's over&equo;, confirming that her husband intends to appeal against the decision. 
 The case against Mr Bakker revolved around one central charge, that he defrauded PTL's followers of &dollar;158m by deliberately overselling time shares in the hotel at PTL's &bquo;Heritage USA&equo; Christian theme park. 
 In exchange for &dollar;1,000, each &bquo;partner&equo; was promised a three-night stay at the hotel every year for the rest of their lives. 
 Mr Bakker sold more than twice as many shares as &bquo;Heritage USA&equo; could accommodate. 
 Mr Bakker also took &dollar;3.7m of that money for his own use. 
 With it he decked Tammy Faye in expensive jewellery. 
 He bought four estates, and a string of cars, including Rolls Royces and three Mercedes. 
 Mr Bakker is the fourth PTL official to be convicted in connection with the scandal, which began after it was revealed that he had an affair with a former church secretary, Jessica Hahn, using PTL funds to pay her hush money afterwards. 
 Of the other three former executives, one was sentenced to eight years in prison and the other two to 18 years. 
 The jury deliberated for only 10 hours before convicting Mr Bakker on all charges. 
 The foreman, Ricky Hill, said afterwards that the only problem they had was in deciding exactly when Mr Bakker began the pattern of fraud. 
 &bquo;I kept looking for something that would tell me (the PTL managers) kept it from Bakker himself&hellip; but it never came.&equo; 
 Mr Hill said Mr Bakker displayed some of the persuasive powers in the courtroom that he had used to raise money on television. 
 &bquo;He kind of mesmerised you,&equo; said Mr Hill. 
 &bquo;Most honest man in US&equo; accused of lying 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 DAN RATHER, the CBS News anchorman, once regarded as the most trusted person in America, has yet to answer charges that he aired faked battle footage and false news accounts of the war in Afghanistan in the mid-1980s. 
 Despite a curt denial by the President of CBS News, David Burke, that the company knowingly broadcast faked combat film, Mr Rather's reputation for being the soul of integrity in the increasingly make-believe world of American television news has been damaged. 
 A 12-line, three sentence denial of the charges made by the tabloid New York Post, failed to satisfy Mr Rather's critics, who had been promised a &bquo;point-by-point&equo; rebuttal of the accusations. 
 To add to Mr Rather's discomfort, the BBC's Foreign News Editor, John Simpson, told the Post that he had rejected the same piece of film, narrated by Mr Rather, as false when CBS News offered it to the BBC in August 1987. 
 The report later won an award. 
 Mr Simpson said that he rejected the footage, which purported to depict &bquo;the greatest single-day defeat for Soviet troops since World War II&equo;, as untrustworthy after reviewing it frame by frame. 
 &bquo;There wasn't a single dead body. 
 If we'd seen loads and loads of Soviet bodies, we would have felt it was true. 
 It simply had no feeling of reality,&equo; he said. 
 Essentially the Post charged that in a 1984 report, Mike Hoover, a freelance news cameraman with a reputation for providing theatrical footage, recreated scenes of Afghan rebels sabotaging electricity pylons &mdash; days after the real action had taken place. 
 The paper also said CBS identified refugees walking on the Pakistani border as Afghans evacuating villages following fighting, identified a Pakistani jet as a Soviet fighter and used film stolen from another cameraman. 
 Thousands reach the West and more follow 
 From EDWARD STEEN in Prague and PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 THE EXODUS from East Europe continued unabated yesterday, with thousands leaving and many would-be emigres defying attempts by the Communist authorities to prevent their crossing into Czechoslovakia, from where most refugees are fleeing to the West. 
 The last of eight special trains bringing 7,600 refugees from the West German embassy in Prague arrived to a warm welcome in Bavaria, while a train with more than 600 East Germans left Warsaw, also bound for West Germany. 
 It was delayed because extra carriages had to be found for the unexpectedly large number of emigres. 
 About 100 emerged from the embassy and another 500 from holiday homes on the outskirts of Warsaw, where they had been temporarily housed. 
 Dozens more East Germans appear to be crossing into Czechoslovakia, despite East Berlin's ending of visa-free travel across the border. 
 Between 200 and 300 East Germans were yesterday camped in the mudbath which was once the majestic garden of the West German mission. 
 There were a lot of policemen in surrounding streets and in the park adjoining the embassy from which the refugees have clambered into the grounds. 
 Some refugees in the embassy gardens said they had been there for days, but had not boarded the sealed refugee trains travelling through East Germany to Bavaria. 
 &bquo;We came here to register, then we'll go home,&equo; said a man from Halle. 
 A woman said: &bquo;I'm going back too and then I'll return with my four children.&equo; 
 Both said they had decided not to put their families through the ordeal of the embassy occupation and appeared to believe the assurance of Wolfgang Vogel, special envoy of Erich Honecker, the East German leader, that they would all be allowed to leave for the West with their dependents within six months. 
 Miroslav Pavel, the Czechoslovak Foreign Ministry spokesman, denied yesterday that Prague had insisted on the closure of the border with East Germany. 
 Various ideas had been suggested to the two Germanies to try to resolve the problem. 
 He declined to give any official view on the situation except to say: &bquo;Any Marxist must say it's a good thing that nobody has been hurt and we should give thanks to the police.&equo; 
 Jan Urban, a former spokesman for the Charter 77 rights group and co-ordinator of a joint East European information service, was among numerous Czechoslovaks who befriended the refugees. 
 He said the debacle had been very important in Czechoslovakia: it had shown that &bquo;people can make a difference&equo;. 
 Living in a totalitarian system, he said, &bquo;you are taught all the time that it's unbreakable. 
 It has no weaknesses, it's impossible to fight.&equo; 
 But in less than a year Poland and Hungary had proved otherwise &bquo;and now you have the strongest of the strong, the East Germans, jumping out like water from a bucket with a hole in it. 
 It's very clear to anybody that the system is cracking.&equo; 
 The determination of the refugees, despite the freezing and insanitary conditions, had opened people's eyes. 
 In East Berlin yesterday officials turned away many would-be visitors from the West and gave warnings to opposition leaders in an attempt to avert demonstrations during the 40th anniversary celebrations today and tomorrow. 
 The head of the West German mission in the city, Franz Bertele, protested against the semi-closure of the seven crossings in the Berlin Wall. 
 Many Western visitors with day visas were refused entry. 
 Werner Kratschull, a pastor and dissident, said he had been told that East Berlin would crack down on the opposition &bquo;in the Chinese manner&equo; if there was trouble. 
 Barbel Bohley, a founder of the New Forum reform group, said on West German television that &bquo;one has the feeling that it only needs a spark for everything to blow up here&equo;. 
 A group of East German trade unionists complained yesterday to the main trade union federation that the official media dismissed or ignored &bquo;fundamental political problems that are upsetting the workers&equo;. 
 And a new Dresden reform group, Initiative for Democratic Renewal, published an open letter to President Gorbachev, saying their leaders' rigidity was destabilising the country, and urging him to press them to reform. 
 But East Germany's old guard was defiant. 
 &bquo;We do not need any lessons in human rights and socialist democracy,&equo; said the Prime Minister, Willi Stoph, in Berlin. 
 Czechoslovakia's opposition acquired a colourful new facet yesterday, when a group calling itself The Ladybirds launched its manifesto. 
 The founder, Ladybird 1 (membership involves abandoning one's name), introduced nine demands. 
 He thought the first would be the most popular: all power to the STB (the secret police). 
 Other demands included replacement of the currency by ration coupons, extension of military service from two years to 10, compulsory uniforms for all citizens and penalties for looking gloomy. 
 Cry freedom, as sealed trains reach the West 
 By PATRICIA CLOUGH 
 BONN &mdash; &bquo;Freedom! 
 Freedom!&equo; shouted men, women and children, hugging each other ecstatically as they poured out of the trains. 
 &bquo;We've done it!&equo; 
 This was not the climax to a corny B-film. 
 It was Europe on 5 October 1989, where a vast human drama which could provide scenes for a thousand films is in progress, writes Patricia Clough. 
 Seventy-two years ago, the Germans shipped Lenin in a sealed train, like a dangerous bacillus, from Switzerland to Petrograd to make a revolution. 
 Now East Germans are shipping their own people in sealed trains through their own country to the West, and police fight back thousands who block the tracks and want to jump on board. 
 Hundreds gather on the platforms at Hof station, Bavaria, holding sheets of paper with names aloft on sticks, anxiously scanning the faces of the crowds pouring out of the trains, just as Germans did when millions fled before the advancing Russians or the avenging Poles and Czechs at the end of the war. 
 Loved ones from whom they have become separated, relatives who have disappeared &mdash; have they managed to get out or are they in some jail? 
 Many arrivals rush to the telephone. 
 &bquo;We are here in Hof. 
 Frank was arrested as he tried to cross into Czechoslovakia.&equo; 
 'The Czechs shot at us.&equo; 
 Six-year-old Robert, clutching a small brown teddy bear, will remember how he missed school to go on a sudden &bquo;holiday&equo;. 
 &bquo;We told him it was a holiday in case he blabbed at the border,&equo; his parents explained. 
 Only amid the mud and chaos of the West German embassy in Prague did they try to explain where they were going. 
 He still does not quite understand. 
 Civil-defence workers serving hot soup from their mobile kitchens on Hof station have tears streaming down their faces. 
 They are used to all sorts of emergencies, but there has never been anything like this: their own people, prepared to face appalling hardships, possible arrest or even death to get out, arriving exhausted but so happy to be free. 
 &bquo;Unless your country has been divided too, you just cannot imagine what we feel like,&equo; says a middle-aged secretary. 
 Far to the East, a young man emerges dripping from the river Neisse on the border between East Germany and Poland. 
 He has swum across, although he knows that more than a dozen escapers have drowned there in recent weeks and East German border guards are patrolling. 
 A Polish farmer fits him out with a complete set of dry clothes and sends him on to the West German embassy in Warsaw. 
 Three children, aged between four and seven, scream as uniformed East Berlin police drag them and their mother off and push them into a lorry as they stand outside the US embassy in East Berlin, hoping desperately to get inside. 
 One day, West German diplomats from Budapest, Prague or East Berlin will relate how they did business in cafes and restaurants because refugees were crammed like sardines on mattresses in their offices and the corridors. 
 Then there is the story of the man who, as a young law student, fled across the border from the East and now, some 40 years later, has woven the deal which brought another 15,000, many of them the age he was then, to the West. 
 He flew to Prague to convince the embassy refugees it was not a trap. 
 Their delirious joy at his announcement, said Hans-Dietrich Genscher, the West German Foreign Minister, was the most moving moment of his life. 
 Only the canny Mr Genscher, who knew the East Germans' minds, could have thought of letting the regime save face by &bquo;expelling&equo; their own people across their own territory. 
 But millions of Germans will not forget the voice of Winfried Wolk, a leader of the hitherto tame East German Christian Democrat party, almost breaking as he warned over Western television on Wednesday night that East Germany's ferment could end like that in China. 
 Out of the USSR: Evil is out of the closet as Moscow copies the West 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 MOSCOW &mdash; Quite possibly, it is the event of the week here. 
 Forget about the thrills (and more numerous spills) of the great parliamentary debate on strikes, and most certainly forget the dreary speech of the Prime Minister, Nikolai Ryzhkov, on the utopia of the &bquo;socialist market economy&equo;. 
 Much more important, the interior ministry has let it be known that it is dropping its draconian controls on the use of photocopying machines. 
 We Westerners may take them for granted as part of the furniture of any self-respecting office and available to all on every high street. 
 Not so in the Soviet Union, where some 60,000 are reckoned to be installed. 
 In the companies and enterprises fortunate enough to possess one, access to these necessary but &mdash; so it seems &mdash; fundamentally evil items is limited to a favoured and closely monitored few. 
 The machines are kept in small locked rooms. 
 Every document that goes through them is recorded. 
 Each copy is numbered and registered. 
 To make sure the rules are observed, and that photocopiers do not fall into &bquo;undesirable&equo; hands, 1,000 inspectors attached to the second section of the ministry's Chief Directorate for the Maintenance of Public Order have been patrolling the nation. 
 The official pretext for such precautions has been the need to prevent illicit production of passes, travel documents or pornography. 
 The true reason, of course, is a secretive state's ancestral suspicion of its own citizens, and its desire for absolute control of information. 
 The cost in terms of technological advance and the dissemination of fresh and stimulating ideas, is incalculable but colossal. 
 That the restrictions are at last to be lifted in part reflects universal acknowledgement that terror of the communications revolution has been a prime contributor to the technological backwardness of the country. 
 Above all, though, glasnost and greater contact with the West have brought about a fait accompli. 
 Like it or not, high-tech communications have arrived in the Soviet Union, and the King Canutes of the interior ministry have become an absurdity. 
 The bridgehead has been the small Western community, which now has the use of a state-of-the-art office services joint venture to be found at 50 Gorky Street in central Moscow, as well as &bquo;Reprotsentr&equo;, in which Rank Xerox is a partner. 
 This latter has the inestimable advantage for Soviet citizens of accepting roubles. 
 In truth, however, humble photocopying has been overtaken by the wonders of the fax and personal computers complete with printers. 
 Whatever the price of these latter (up to 20 times their cost in the West) and reinforced customs procedures for their import, they are finding their way in. 
 The controls in any case are surely doomed to fail. 
 The government has admitted it is seven to 10 years behind the West in PC technology. 
 Earlier this year it spent &dollar;1bn (&pound;620m) on ordering 300,000 personal computers from West Germany. 
 Go to any demonstration worthy of the name these days, and you are swamped by offers to buy from an intimidating array of news sheets, statements or appeals published by informal associations. 
 Even 18 months ago, the material would most probably have been in the form of near-illegible carbon copies of an original laboriously produced on a manual typewriter &mdash; devices which until recently had to be registered with the authorities. 
 Now they are run off computers by the crisply-produced hundred. 
 Then there is the facsimile machine. 
 No self-respecting republican popular front is without one. 
 A month or two ago I was on the phone to the Baltic, to obtain some bloodcurdlingly seditious statement from the local nationalists. 
 &bquo;Fine,&equo; came the reply. 
 &bquo;What's your fax number?&equo; 
 Sheepishly I had to admit that I did not yet have one. 
 Mercifully, a colleague upstairs did. 
 In a few minutes, six pages of Russian text had travelled from Riga to Moscow. 
 Rather more officially, Radio Moscow has started to sell a faxed information service of its own, using leased Japanese equipment. 
 So the interior ministry is about to haul up the white flag. 
 In communications, too, the Soviet Union has realised it must modernise or die, whatever the risk. 
 Beyond the slightest doubt the new technology is helping reshape politics here far more dramatically than pious talk of the &bquo;socialist market economy&equo;. 
 The old fears of Russia's autocratic, ultra-centralised state were surely right. 
 Today, though, it is too late. 
 Hungary's old guard attacks reformers: &bquo;Stone Age&equo; conservatives are set to clash with &bquo;monetarists&equo; at the party congress starting today, Imre Karacs writes from Budapest 
 From IMRE KARACS in Budapest 
 AS DELEGATES were preparing for the congress of the ruling Hungarian Socialist Workers' Party which begins today, two of the most conservative factions yesterday issued an open challenge to the party's reformist leadership. 
 &bquo;The socialist order is in danger in Hungary because internal and external reactionary forces have launched a counter-offensive aimed at restoring capitalism,&equo; warned the manifesto of the party's &bquo;Marxist Unity Platform&equo; which was read out at a mass rally in a Budapest stadium. 
 &bquo;In full awareness of our responsibility, we reject the policies of the present leadership which are diverting our country from the socialist path and leading it into catastrophe.&equo; 
 At another rally in Budapest, the &bquo;Unity Platform&equo; led by the former hardline ideologist, Janos Berecz, was stressing &bquo;Bolshevik values&equo; and condemning the &bquo;monetarist policies&equo; of the government. 
 But the reformists have not kept completely silent. 
 Yesterday's government daily, Magyar Hirlap, carried extensive interviews with two of their leaders, Imre Pozsgay and the Prime Minister, Miklos Nemeth. 
 In the continuing war of words between reformers and hardliners, Mr Nemeth conjured up the best insult of the day when he referred to his opponents as &bquo;Stone Age conservatives&equo;. 
 With such an inauspicious start to the congress which is meant to be a demonstration of unity, the organisers have had to take precautions. 
 Three halls have been hired, just in case the split which nearly everyone expects occurs. 
 The event also breaks with past practices in other respects. 
 There will be no representative of any foreign communist party at the event, not even Moscow's man, because they have not been invited. 
 And no time limit has been set for the congress, simply because no one knows how long it will last and how it will end. 
 All the indications are that the outcome will not be the crushing reformist victory Mr Pozsgay has been predicting. 
 The reformist politician has already been forced to make compromises in the new party programme he has drafted, and has even had to put up with seeing the dreaded word &bquo;Marxism&equo; inserted into the version he will be proposing to the delegates today. 
 Less than a week ago, he said that this congress would strip the party of its ideology and change its name, but it now looks likely that he will have to settle for the second half of the forecast. 
 Polls taken among party members indicate an even split. 
 In the Budapest district of Zuglo, 47 per cent of party members said they supported the reformers, while the conservative groups of Mr Berecz and Robert Ribanszki, who have agreed a tacit alliance, obtained 33 per cent and 19 per cent respectively. 
 Zuglo, a mish-mash of high-rise estates, factories and prosperous suburbia, is the archetypal &bquo;average district&equo; which usually reflects national opinion. 
 But while the verdict of party members there was inconclusive, more than 80 per cent of them supported moves to abolish the present hierarchical structure which distinguishes communist parties from their Western counterparts. 
 An overwhelming majority were also in favour of the mixed economy, suggesting that the reformers are opposed not because of their policies, but because of their image. 
 The most sensitive issue facing congress delegates is the future of the party after next year's elections. 
 Mr Pozsgay wants the party to leave the factories and to allow managers to manage. 
 But the party's only contact with its members is the workplace, and after the elections they will be their only source of power. 
 For similar reasons, conservatives are also reluctant to disband the discredited Workers' Guard. 
 Delors implies EC might be widened 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Brussels 
 JACQUES DELORS, President of the European Commission, told West Germany that its hopes for reunification would best be served by working for a more federal Community, implying that this might one day embrace East Germany. 
 He also hinted that a conference expected next year to amend the EC treaty to achieve monetary union should be used for a more fundemental rewriting of the EC constitution. 
 Mr Delors is expected to develop the theme when he gives a speech to the College of Europe in Bruges in 10 days. 
 His remarks, made last night in Bonn to cabinet ministers and public servants, will enrage Margaret Thatcher and enliven the Europe debate in the Tory party. 
 Officials close to Mr Delors said he was convinced the pace of change in Eastern Europe had made the need for a more federal EC all the more urgent. 
 In his speech, he said the Twelve were providing a model of democratic co-operation and freedom that East European countries could follow. 
 Although he hinted, without saying it explicitly, that German reunification could mean East Germany becoming part of the EC, he argued that this depended on the Twelve prospering and developing. 
 &bquo;We will not achieve this without institutional changes. 
 We must reflect on this now. 
 The creation of an economic and monetary union is, in fact, at the heart of economic integration and of political integration.&equo; 
 That would mean overcoming shortcomings in the democratic answerability of the EC institutions by making the the Commission &bquo;more strong and more effective&equo;. 
 The Commission is planning a last-ditch battle to defend tax proposals which it considers essential for completion of the 1992 internal market programme. 
 Aspects of its scheme to align indirect tax rates and scrap border checks face a concerted attack from national treasury officials, who have drafted a paper for consideration at a meeting of finance ministers on Monday. 
 Soviet threat &bquo;eased by troop reductions&equo; 
 By MARK URBAN, Defence Correspondent 
 THE IDEA that the Warsaw Pact would be able to mount a surprise attack on Nato will shortly be &bquo;barely plausible&equo; because of the unilateral troop cuts started nine months ago by the Kremlin, according to experts at the London-based International Institute for Strategic Studies. 
 John Cross, speaking at a press conference to mark the publication yesterday of The Military Balance 1989-90, the institute's authoritative annual survey of world armed forces, said that the cuts under way in the Warsaw Pact &bquo;do tend to support Soviet claims of new thinking&equo;. 
 Conservative Western military analysts have expressed scepticism about Soviet statements that they are removing from their armed forces both the capability and the doctrine of a large-scale attack on western Europe. 
 Francois Heisbourg, the institute's director, said that growing tensions between different members of the Warsaw Pact are undermining its ability to act as an alliance. 
 Although the east European states individually retain strong bi-lateral links with Moscow, he said, the differing attitudes to reform mean that &bquo;there is clearly a group of countries who are no longer in alliance with another group&equo;. 
 The director said that it would take between one and two weeks for the Soviet Union to send the forces it is currently pulling out, back into eastern Europe. 
 This would increase the warning time of any possible surprise attack. 
 Figures in this year's Military Balance have not been revised to take account of the reductions of 500,000 troops and 10,000 tanks announced by Mikhail Gorbachev at the United Nations last December. 
 Experts at the institute say that this year's figures, which include 6,700 more Warsaw Pact tanks than were previously thought to exist, mark the high tide of eastern bloc military might. 
 Court Circular 
 By MARK URBAN, Defence Correspondent 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 5 October: The Princess Royal, President, Riding for the Disabled Association, this morning visited the Abingdon Group at Lower Lodge Riding Centre, Charley Bassett Road, Longworth, and was received on arrival by Colonel Robert Heywood-Lonsdale (Vice Lord-Lieutenant of Oxfordshire). 
 Her Royal Highness this afternoon attended the Annual General Meeting of the National Association of Victim Support Schemes at Central Hall, Westminster, and was received by the Lord Mayor of Westminster (Councillor Simon Mabey) and the Archbishop of Canterbury. 
 Afterwards The Princess Royal, President, Royal Yachting Association, attended a Racing Rules Committee Meeting (Chairman, Mrs Mary Peral) at the Royal Thames Yacht Club, 60 Knightsbridge, London SW1. 
 Mrs Richard Carew Pole was in attendance. 
 Subsequently His Royal Highness, President, Scottish Business in the Community, visited the Dundee Enterprise Trust and the Whitfield Estate, and afterwards attended a ScotBic conference in the Angus Hotel, Dundee. 
 His Royal Highness travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 The Prince of Wales, Patron, The Renaissance Theatre Company, attended the Premiere of Henry V at the Odeon Cinema, Leicester Square, London WC2. 
 Mr Guy Salter was in attendance. 
 Mrs Max Pike was in attendance. 
 5 October: The Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon, Patron of the Friends of St John's Smith Square, was present this evening at a Concert given by Dame Joan Sutherland and Mr Richard Bonynge in aid of St John's Organ Appeal. 
 The Lady Glenconner was in attendance. 
 YORK HOUSE 5 October: The Duchess of Kent, as Patron of the Norfolk and Norwich Triennial Festival, this morning visited the Sainsbury Centre for Visual Arts, University of East Anglia, and this evening attended the Opening Concert of the French Festival at St Andrew's Hall, Norwich. 
 Her Royal Highness, who travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight, was attended by Miss Sarah Partridge. 
 THATCHED HOUSE LODGE 5 October: Princess Alexandra, attended by Lady Mary Mumford, left Royal Air Force Benson this morning in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight to visit the Caribbean Dependent Territories of Montserrat and the British Virgin Islands in the wake of the destruction caused by Hurricane Hugo. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Princess of Wales visits the OUTSET employment scheme for disabled people at the Globe Town Neighbourhood Centre, 62 Roman Road, London E2. 
 Prince Edward, Chairman of The Duke of Edinburgh's Award Special Projects Group, visits Edinburgh, Stirling and Glasgow. 
 The Princess Royal visits Avon; as President, The Missions to Seamen, visits the Avonmouth International Seafarers&equo; Centre at Gloucester Road, Avonmouth, Bristol; as Patron, The Home Farm Trust, visits The Home Farm Trust's Registered Office at Merchants House, North Wapping Road, Bristol; as President, The Save the Children Fund, attends a reception with employees of Halifax Property Services, receives a cheque for the Fund and officially opens Halifax Property Services' Headquarters building at Great Weston Business Park, Yate, Bristol; as Patron, The Butler Trust, visits HM Prison Leyhill, Wotton under Edge, Avon; and, this evening, as President, The Save the Children Fund, attends a reception in celebration of the Fund's 70th Anniversary at Chavenage House, Tetbury, Gloucestershire. 
 Princess Margaret attends a Service at the Church of St Philip and St James, Up Hatherley, Cheltenham, during the Parish Preaching Mission. 
 The Duchess of Gloucester, Colonel-in-Chief, Royal Army Educational Corps, attends the Officers' Annual Dinner at Eltham Palace, London SE9. 
 Obituary: Graham Chapman 
 By JOHN CLEESE 
 GRAHAM CHAPMAN and I wrote together almost full time between 1966 and 1973, writes John Cleese, while producing sketches for The Frost Report, The 1948 Show and Monty Python, as well as several film scripts none of which made their way intact to the silver screen. 
 As a writing partner he had two rare gifts: the ability to get us unstuck with some inspired off-the-wall conceit when I was enmeshed in very on-the-wall musings; and in addition, the priceless talent of knowing whether something was funny or not. 
 I noticed this early and relied on it shamelessly. 
 In fact the Cheese Shot Skit &mdash; my all-time favourite &mdash; owes its life to him. 
 Every dozen or so cheeses I'd sigh and say &bquo;Gra, is this really funny?&equo; and he'd puff on his pipe calmly and say, &bquo;Yes, get on with it.&equo; 
 I wished he'd had the same confidence in front of audiences because he was probably the most talented actor of us all. 
 But he found the Python TV recordings a terrible strain, and some of his drinking was an attempt to dampen that fear. 
 After he gave up the booze at Christmas 1977 &mdash; for good - he gave us his splendid Brian which is as clever and well-judged a piece of comic acting as you'll see. 
 Of course, he'd given up medicine to pursue comedy, but he was absolutely at his best when caring for others. 
 He looked after the entire film unit practically single-handed while we were filming in Tunisia and I was reminded of this again in recent months when we visited him in hospital. 
 I think he was just as keen to look after us then, and his optimism, cheerfulness and absolute lack of self-pity made me, for one, feel very very small. 
 We all bought his optimism, of course. 
 We wanted to. 
 But his elder brother John thinks that he knew better what the score was than he ever let on. 
 That his bravery was ended so abruptly and unexpectedly seems very cruel. 
 Obituary: Graham Chapman 
 By ALAN RAFFERTY 
 IF, in the Forties and Fifties, a traditional training course for British comedians would start with the period of apprenticeship in ENSA and be followed by a stint filling in the gaps between trippers at the Windmill Theatre, these days a university degree (from Cambridge, ideally) has increasingly become a requisite for any successful career in stage, films or television humour. 
 Graham Chapman, who died on the eve of the twentieth anniversary of his first appearance in the show which made his reputation, travelled along (and to a certain extent pioneered) that now orthodox route to celebrity. 
 Chapman studied medicine at Cambridge and, on graduating, even briefly practised it; of more significance, however, in the light of his subsequent career, was a meeting with John Cleese, with whom he was to write and perform numerous sketches, most notably for David Frost. 
 Eventually they joined forces with other graduates sharing the same skewed sense of humour, Michael Palin, Terry Jones, Eric Idle and an American-born cartoonist and graphic artist, Terry Gilliam; and on Sunday 5 October 1969 (incongruously enough, in a scheduling slot which had always been rigorously reserved for programmes of a religious cast) the very first episode of Monty Python's Flying Circus was broadcast. 
 With its demented self-referentiality, its abrupt and dreamlike transpositions of settings and the head-spinning ease with which each sketch would dovetail into its successor, Monty Python soon became a cult show, albeit achieving viewing figures to rival those of the cosiest and most conventional sitcom; and its peculiar brand of humour, which contrived to be both anarchically delirious and quintessentially British, transferred without strain to the cinema, as witness And Now for Something Completely Different (a portmanteau film of the best-known TV sketches), Monty Python and the Holy Grail, Jabberwocky, The Life of Brian, The Meaning of Life and, released only last week, Erik the Viking. 
 These, along with other, related ventures, made the members of the Python team all variously rich &mdash; with the sole exception of Chapman. 
 His alcoholism apparently alienated his former writing partner; his admirable disinclination to offer any public denial of his homosexuality may have compromised his potential as a solo performer; and he battled for several years with the throat cancer which finally killed him. 
 Nor can one omit, as an important contributing factor in his decline, the humiliating failure of his own attempts to write and direct a feature film, Yellowbeard, even after some drastic and, by Chapman's own account, disastrous re-editing by the studio. 
 It is equally possible, however, that Chapman's problem as a performer, within a collective context in which the success of each individual seemed virtually guaranteed, related to an inherent incompatibility between the innovation of the Monty Python group and his own comedic style. 
 The Pythons' inspiration (of the films in particular) can be traced back, via the immediate influence of the Goon Show, along a line leading directly to Lewis Carroll and the whole English tradition of nonsense, parody and the mock-epic. 
 But the distinguishing feature of those films (even if they cannot quite be credited with inventing the conceit) was what might be called their sense of the inverted anachronism. 
 The humour of anachronism has always existed, of course. 
 But, in a film like The Life of Brian, the characters were not played, as one might expect, as superficially representative figures of the period turned into figures of fun by the odd verbal or gestural modernism. 
 Instead, they constituted a set of twentieth-century British comedy stereotypes (the harassed working-class housewife and mother, the truculent, bloody-minded shop steward, the jovial pillar of the labour exchange) somehow transplanted into a biblical setting -as, respectively, Virgin Mary, militant Early Christian and willing good-humoured martyr. 
 Yet what such a comic ploy demands is, precisely, performers capable of representing stereotypes; and, whatever the evidence to the contrary, that is where the true talent of the Pythonites lay. 
 Throughout the show's history, for instance, Cleese was the very image of pompous, impatient rectitude. 
 Whatever the different roles assigned, Palin invariably personified a sweatily ingratiating Milquetoast; and so forth. 
 Only Chapman lacked any easily identifiable and stereotypical presence (his cantankerous military type, who would interrupt the more outrageous sketches with a testy &bquo;this is silly!&equo;, might just as well, or even better, have been played by Cleese). 
 It was he who tended most to be swallowed up by the show's overall style and it was therefore he who became in a sense ultimately dispensable. 
 Obituary: Professor G. W. Keeton 
 By GEORG SCHWARZENBERGER 
 IN OUR TIME, abounding in specialists and experts in midget fields, George W. Keeton had some of the qualities of a rare survivor from a distant age. 
 His ebullient personality is a vivid reminder of the polymath of past times. 
 The scope of Keeton's knowledge encompassed Assyrian Law and the Comparative Law of Trusts, the Norman Conquest and Chinese marriage customs, as well as Development of Extraterritoriality in China. 
 This first major work of his (1928) came swiftly to be recognised as a masterpiece here and abroad and secured for Keeton an early Cambridge LLD. 
 Yet his venture on The Moscow Trial (1932) during the appeasement period met as much scornful disapproval as, conversely, his Passing of Parliament (1952) from Clement Attlee downwards. 
 That, in a later work of extensive and original research into little-known source material, carried out in partnership with his wife Marian, Keeton should have something to say in favour of Lord Chancellor Jeffreys, brought him little joy from quarters whose traditional schoolboy images he chose to query. 
 So it would be possible to go on: anybody who wishes to do so will find plenty of relevant material in the conscientious bibliography by Sultana Saeed in Law Justice and Equity: essays in tribute to GW Keeton (1967). 
 The closest comparison with another polymath in our time that, in spite of personal and other differences, comes to mind is with Arnold Toynbee. 
 The common denominator is less the substratum of overlapping spheres of knowledge than intuitive awareness and, even more so, shared condemnation from disdainful detractors. 
 To leave the presentation of Keeton on the polymath level would be as arbitrary as concentration on some of his disparate relaxations; boat-building, cookery or football. 
 What would be missing would be Keeton as a powerful and innovative planner and organiser. 
 More than once he was sadly mistaken and duly disappointed with the human material at hand; nonetheless, he succeeded in transforming an almost dormant pre-1939 Law School at University College, London, into a flourishing and internationally leading Law Faculty. 
 After his retirement, he similarly developed a Law Department in the technologically-orientated Brunel University. 
 He also helped to encourage, from 1938 onwards at University College, London, less than enthusiastically welcomed efforts to teach International Law and Relations on interdisciplinary levels. 
 Similarly, he used his connections with the promotion of adult education in the Workers' Educational Association (WEA) and the Extra-Mural Department of London University to establish a joint and full-time crash course for a Diploma in International Affairs in the London Institution of World Affairs, of which he was the president until his death. 
 The significance of this was to give a much-needed niche for future leaders of the Third World in the years after 1945 to prepare themselves for their daunting task. 
 Unpredictably it is Cambridge that may claim to have played a major part in his developments. 
 In admitting a highly promising but less than conformist Sheffield Grammar School boy to Gonville and Caius College, the university placed Keeton under the tutorship of one of the most astute and world-wise masters in the Law. 
 Arnold (later Lord) McNair recognised the potential of his pupil, but felt uneasy. 
 After graduating, Keeton felt that the available fellowship should fall to him. 
 McNair's response was uncompromising; that he should apply for, and prove himself in, a newly established Readership in Law and Politics at Hong Kong University. 
 Keeton spent three years there before returning to Cambridge, where he established himself as a private tutor to Law students, while he waited to be invited to fill a vacancy for a legal appointment in the Foreign Office. 
 Again, McNair's response was unequivocal. 
 He used his influence to favour a contemporary of Keeton's, of comparable mettle, but more predictable in terms of the expectations of a liberal-conservative establishment. 
 While McNair excluded Cambridge, he gave Keeton generous support elsewhere. 
 This turned out to be, first, Manchester's and, subsequently, London's gain. 
 Keeton's Case for an International University (1941) and unswerving interest in legal education and the future of the legal profession in England (University of Cincinatti Law Review, vol 25, 1956) deserve to be mentioned as facets of a wider concern. 
 This has been recognised for some time, perhaps most articulately in France, as one of the attainments to be expected from a top-class academic teacher and researcher, with an outstanding ability in accurate communication with the men (and women) in the street: haute popularisation. 
 Obituary: Norman Yardley 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 NORMAN YARDLEY was an extraordinarily gifted games player who rose to become captain of Yorkshire and England, later becoming a regular BBC commentator and chairman of selectors. 
 He personified the pre-war amateur at his peak, a kindly engaging man who was well placed to have been a major influence in the game had he been of a more forceful character. 
 He captained St Peter's, York, at cricket, rugby and squash, won cricket (all four years) and hockey Blues at Cambridge and was six times the North of England squash champion. 
 His reputation as a right-hand batsman, a strong on-side player, and deceptive medium-pace bowler was such that he was early earmarked for advancement by both his county and country, being twelfth man twice for England in 1938, appearing as Hammond's vice-captain in the 1946-47 tour of Australia before succeeding to the England captaincy in 1947, then succeeding Brian Sellers as Yorkshire's captain the following year. 
 He was 32, at his peak as a cricketer, but life then brought him a series of disappointments. 
 For England he had to compete against Bradman and the mighty 1948 Australians while the West Indies, in 1950, stunned cricket by producing, from nowhere, two world-class spinners in Ramadhin and Valentine. 
 Yorkshire, too, despite having many talented players and one great one in Hutton, were unable to reclaim their pre-war supremacy and Yardley's best was to share the championship with Middlesex in 1949. 
 Yardley bore all these setbacks with great dignity, afflicted as he was from time to time by a form of lumbago that almost certainly hastened his retirement. 
 Wardle, Appleyard, Close, Lowson, Trueman and Illingworth entered cricket in Yardley's reign and all had great respect for his tactical ingenuity and his benevolent, Gower-style leadership although they were to be critical later. 
 Don Mosey, then with The Daily Mail, summed up Yardley's captaincy: (He) had been introduced to Yorkshire cricket in the mid-Thirties when the side, individually and collectively, would have died for the cause. 
 He had picked up the pieces after the war and it must have come as a total shock to someone with his background to find players in his side who rocked the boat. 
 JM Kilburn, a close observer as cricket correspondent of the Yorkshire Post, wrote: In his view the game should be played earnestly, sensibly and with unfailing goodwill. 
 He assumed the same outlook in those with whom he played. 
 If they fell below his standard he was disappointed, but not censorious. 
 Yardley's personal contribution was not small: he finished with 18,173 runs at an average of 31, scored 27 centuries, took 279 wickets and 320 catches, despite losing five summers to the war and being wounded, with the Green Howards, in the Western Desert. 
 He played in 20 Test matches and his post-war service to Yorkshire included three years as Club president, a position he vacated sadly when he found his calls for moderation went unheeded at the height of the Boycott controversy. 
 Yardley, a second- or third-change bowler throughout his career, was rightly proud to be one of the very few who could claim to have dismissed Bradman thrice in Test matches. 
 He was, wrote one of the hard-bitten professionals who served under him &bquo;too much of a gentleman&equo;, which is not a common criticism nowadays. 
 Obituary: Ferdinand Marcos 
 By JAMES HAMILTON-PATERSON 
 IN THEIR respective obituary and report (29 September), Andrew Horvat and James Fenton produced a picture of the late President Marcos which was too simply one of a celebrated political monster who got his come-uppance, writes James Hamilton-Paterson. 
 The truth, as always, is more complex and uneasy. 
 It is unfashionable to point out that for most of his two decades in office Marcos enjoyed considerable grass-roots favour. 
 Whatever his increasingly evident misdeeds, he remains to many Filipinos a man of the people. 
 According to them, he was sassy, sharp, matalino; a fundamentally decent man undone by a scheming and treacherous woman. 
 It helped that they believed in his faked war record and legends such as that the religious leader Gregorio Aglipay inserted a slither of wood into Marcos's back before the Bataan campaign in 1942, allegedly giving him magic powers. 
 Other tyrants have astutely combined populism and magic: one thinks of Papa Doc and Idi Amin. 
 Nor is it fashionable to admit that even monsters have their uses. 
 In the village I have known for the last 10 years, they openly regret that things were better under Marcos. 
 They support Cory Aquino; but the barefoot health workers' small supply of free drugs has been curtailed by her administration. 
 Marcos had arranged the hand-out as a PR gesture he could easily afford, since he largely owned the pharmaceutical companies. 
 But, for all the wrong reasons, he did some good at barangay level. 
 Aquino's economic cutbacks, imposed on her for all the right reasons, have caused considerable suffering. 
 Unfortunately, countries deserve their rulers. 
 Marcos was thoroughly Filipino. 
 What his countrymen did not deserve was being prevented from ousting him after his second term of office. 
 What happened then, with the carefully engineered declaration of martial law in 1972, exposed the real power behind the dictator. 
 This was, of course, the United States. 
 Marcos was a prime beneficiary of Washington's egregious &bquo;hold-the-nose&equo; policy, the brand of realpolitik which, since the Second World War, has buoyed up so many of the world's most grotesque regimes. 
 The Americans wanted their Philippines bases; all that was needed was Marcos's ritual invoking of the Red Menace to make everything possible. 
 If there is shame in this story, it is less that the Marcoses finally stood revealed as nobodies and as thieves on the grandest scale, and far more in the wasted opportunities. 
 In 1965, Marcos had the Filipinos and the US State Department solidly behind him, while international aid agencies were beating a path to his door. 
 From that moment he could have transformed his country. 
 In the event, he beggared it. 
 Right from the first, the CIA and American diplomats knew all about the corruption, the misgovernment, the croneyism, the human rights violations, the ballot-rigging. 
 George Bush's infamous toast to Marcos ('We love your adherence to democratic principles') said it all. 
 If Marcos was cynical, he was no more so than the American foreign policy which kept him in power and in clover for 20 years. 
 Anniversaries 
 By JAMES HAMILTON-PATERSON 
 On this day: Captain Cook landed in New Zealand, 1769; the Polar Star and Boston Daily Advertiser newspaper was first issued, US 1796; the Rainhill trials of railway locomotives began, 1829; the Mormons in Utah renounced bigamy, 1890; Sir Henry Wood began Promenade Concerts at the Queen's Hall, London, 1895; Manchester University was opened, 1903; Austria annexed Bosnia and Herzegovina, 1908; 243 people died when the US freighter Ticonderoga was sunk by a German U-boat, 1918; the Jazz Singer, the first feature-length talking film, began showing in New York, 1927; Chiang Kai-shek became president of China, 1928; the first production of the musical show Nymph Errant was presented, London, 1933; the Berlin airlift ended, 1949. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 20 
 Wills 
 By JAMES HAMILTON-PATERSON 
 Mr William Henry Hunt, of Winestead, North Humberside, left estate valued at &pound;101,443 net. 
 He left his entire estate (and the option to purchase a freehold property in Patrington) to the RNIB. 
 Law Report: Parents must act reasonably in opposing adoption: Re L (a minor) &mdash; Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Balcombe and Mr Justice Harman), 25 August 1989 
 By YING HUI TAN, Barrister 
 When considering whether a parent was unreasonably withholding consent to a child's adoption, the test was not whether the court agreed with the parent's reasons for withholding consent but whether a reasonable parent would withhold consent in the circumstances of the case. 
 The Court of Appeal dismissed a mother's appeal from an order of Judge Wroath in the Portsmouth County Court on 11 May 1989 that a girl should be adopted and that the parents' consents to the adoption be dispensed with on the ground that they were unreasonably withheld. 
 The child was born in January 1984 and lived with her parents until 1986 when, on suspicion of sexual abuse, she was taken into care and placed with foster parents. 
 The local authority decided that it would not be possible to rehabilitate the child with her natural parents and that her welfare required that her future lay elsewhere. 
 The mother had not had access to her since January 1987. 
 In 1988 the foster parents gave notice of their application to adopt the child. 
 By section 16 of the Adoption Act 1976, an adoption order should not be made unless the parties agree or the court was satisfied that making of the adoption order should be dispensed with on, inter alia, the ground that the parent was withholding agreement unreasonably. 
 The mother had had three children who were living with her. 
 Her position had improved but was not totally settled. 
 Although the mother accepted that the child's immediate future lay with her foster parents and there was no immediate prospect that she could have her back, she wanted to keep the door open and therefore she refused her consent to the adoption. 
 She said that adoption should be postponed and that custodianship would be sufficient. 
 The judge held that the child's welfare required that she be adopted by the foster parents with whom she had lived for three of her five years, and that the parents were withholding agreement unreasonably. 
 He was satisfied the reasons which the mother advanced against adoption were not ones a reasonable mother would advance in the circumstances and were not reasonable reasons and that a reasonable woman in her position would give her consent. 
 The mother appealed. 
 Paul McCormick (Anderton &amp; Co, Portsmouth) for the mother; Barry Coulter (Sherwin Oliver, Portsmouth) for the foster parents. 
 LORD JUSTICE BALCOMBE said that the point of substance in the case was whether the mother's consent was unreasonably withheld. 
 The leading authority was the House of Lords case of Re W (1971) AC 682 where it was held that when dealing with the question of withholding consent, the test was reasonableness, not culpability or indifference, and although the child's welfare per se was not the test, it was relevant. 
 Lord Hailsham of St Marylebone, LC, said that the question was whether a parental veto came within the band of possible reasonable decisions and not whether it was right or mistaken and that there was a band of decisions within which the court should seek to replace the individual's judgment with his own. 
 Those tests presented the court with a difficulty. 
 It was very difficult for a court to say what a reasonable mother would have done in circumstances which were almost hypothetical. 
 Applying those tests, first you did not substitute your own decision for that of the parent. 
 There was a band of decisions and you had to say that the parent's decision was outside the band of reasonableness. 
 Second, the welfare of the child was important in the sense that the reasonably parent, however anguishing the decision might be, would put his or her own child's welfare right in the forefront of the decision. 
 Any judge faced with cases of this type found it very difficult because whatever the decision, somebody was going to be grievously hurt. 
 The welfare of the child was the first consideration and other tests had to be applied. 
 But no judge was unsympathetic to the dilemma in which a natural mother found herself. 
 Mr McCormick submitted that if any one of the mother's reasons was possibly valid then it could not be said that the mother's refusal to consent was outside the reasonable band. 
 The judge clearly adopted the right test &mdash; was this mother's decision in the circumstances of the case within the bank of what a reasonable mother would do &mdash; and he was entitled to say &bquo;No, it was not&equo;. 
 As said in Re W, the Court of Appeal should not intefere unless satisfied that he was wrong in law. 
 Further the test set out in Hitchcock v WB and FEB (1952) 2 QB 561 had been replaced by the test in Re W which set out all that any judge needed to do in making a decision. 
 Judge Wroath applied the right test in deciding whether or not the mother was unreasonably withholding her consent. 
 He came to a decision to which on the evidence before him he was entitled to come, and it was not a decision with which the court could properly interfere. 
 Law Report: Jury should not have known of co-defendant's guilty plea: Regina v Mattison &mdash; Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) (Lord Justice Mustill, Mr Justice Nolan and Mr Justice Saville), 5 October 1989 
 By YING HUI TAN, Barrister 
 Where a defendant was charged with committing an act of gross indecency with a co-defendant who had pleaded guilty to a charge of gross indecency with the appellant, evidence of the co-defendant's plea of guilty, although relevant, should have been excluded from the jury, since such evidence would have an adverse effect on the fairness of the proceedings against the defendant as the jury was likely to treat it as going to prove the defendant's guilt. 
 The Court of Appeal allowed the appellant's appeal against conviction of committing an act of gross indecency. 
 The appellant, Norman Mattison, was charged with committing an act of gross indecency with his co-defendant. 
 The co-defendant pleaded guilty to a charge of committing an act of gross indecency with the appellant. 
 The Crown's case was that the men were found by the police in a public lavatory behaving indecently towards each other. 
 The appellant pleaded not guilty. 
 His case was that he had been using the public lavatory for proper purposes when the the police burst into his cubicle and arrested him, and that he had had no contact of any kind with the co-defendant. 
 The trial judge admitted in evidence under section 74 of the Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 the co-defendant's plea of guilty. 
 In his summing up the judge said that the co-defendant's plea of guilty was not the issue and the jury knew of it to make the background accurate. 
 After retiring the jury returned with a notice asking whether the co-defendant was charged with gross indecency with the appellant only. 
 The trial judge directed that the answer was yes. 
 The appellant was convicted and now appealed. 
 Judith Nutt (Registrar of Criminal Appeals) for the appellant; Hugh Allardyce (CPS, Croydon) for the Crown. 
 MR JUSTICE SAVILLE, giving the judgment of the court, said the appellant did not suggest that the co-defendant's committing of an act of gross indecency with the appellant was not relevant to the question whether, at the same time and place, the appellant was committing a like act with the co-defendant. 
 The appellant appealed on the ground that the co-defendant's plea of guilty should have been excluded by the trial judge in the exercise of his discretion under section 78(1) of the 1984 Act. 
 Mrs Nutt submitted that it would be difficult, if not impossible, for the appellant to try and set about to prove that the co-defendant had not committed an act of gross indecency with him, that he was in effect deprived of any opportunity of cross-examining or otherwise challenging the co-defendant and that to admit the evidence would be simply to render the proceedings against the appellant wholly unfair. 
 It was clear beyond doubt that the jury were not treating the guilty plea as merely making the background accurate: but, on the contrary, after the judge's direction in reply to their question, must have treated it as going to proof of the guilt of the appellant. 
 The likelihood that that would happen should have been appreciated from the outset: if A committed an act of gross indecency with B, it was a strong inference that the converse was also true in the absence of special circumstances to indicate otherwise. 
 There was nothing to suggest that had the evidence been excluded that result would necessarily have been the same. 
 Accordingly, the appeal was allowed. 
 City prepares defences against influx of gypsies 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 YORK IS preparing to repel a band of gypsies who have been travelling to the city for centuries. 
 The city's council has decided that it no longer wants an unlimited number of gypsies or travellers, many of whom are using illegal pitches, descending on the city. 
 The authority has worked out a scheme which may well be copied around the country by councils faced with an increasing number of travellers. 
 The council has agreed to spend more than &pound;22,000 to block access routes to some 13 sites around York that the gypsies are using. 
 Concrete pillars and barriers will be erected to prevent them moving caravans on to the land. 
 Legal moves are also being made against the gypsies. 
 The Assistant Recorder for York, Jacqueline Davies, has granted an order for committal against &bquo;persons unknown&equo; who can be identified by &bquo;unlawful occupation&equo; of land in York. 
 The area named in the court order has been used by gypsies but is earmarked for a new &pound;125m business park. 
 Theoretically, any gypsy using the land in future could be in breach of the order and face imprisonment. 
 York has traditionally been a favourite halting spot for gypsies. 
 However, many travellers have set up more fixed camps around the city, which does not have an official site. 
 Under the Caravan Sites Act of 1968 all local authorities are required to find sites for gypsies &bquo;residing in or resorting to&equo; their own area. 
 But many authorities have either not been able to find suitable sites or have not complied with the ruling. 
 Recently residents of some of the smarter areas around York and in Harrogate, have objected strongly to the influx of gypsy caravans. 
 Protest petitions have attracted thousands of signatures. 
 Aware of the strength of public feeling, the council, which is trying to promote York to southern companies as a relocation area, put up restrictive height barriers at some of its open car parks forcing the travellers to move on to council land elsewhere. 
 Trevor Phillips, the council's director of environmental services, said: &bquo;We have to demonstrate to the public that we are doing something about this problem. 
 &bquo;We accept that some of the gypsies, the traditional travellers, do not want to be settled and wish to remain mobile. 
 But the problem we have here has to be dealt with.&equo; 
 York does not have a permanent site for travellers although one is planned. 
 The gypsies say they need a site for up to 40 caravans but there is continuing opposition to such a plan. 
 Consultants are looking at various sites and will report to the council in November. 
 Mr Phillips said: &bquo;We have 13 areas in and around the city that travelling people have started to use. 
 We do have traditional travelling people but we also have a lot of people these days who are dropping out of society and who do not want to stay put anywhere.&equo; 
 Hughie Smith, president of the National Gypsy Council, a body set up to fight for the rights of gypsies, said: &bquo;The point is that York does have hundreds of acres of land. 
 There are areas that are perfectly acceptable to the travelling people who use York. 
 There is no reason why York could not provide a site like other neighbouring authorities. 
 &bquo;It is not a function of a district council, which York is, to provide accommodation so they have an eviction policy for gypsies. 
 The quicker a site is provided the better it will be for everyone&hellip; 
 It is not the fault of the gypsies this is happening but short-sighted legislation.&equo; 
 International Bar Association Conference: Special tax to cover costs of legal aid urged 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A SPECIAL tax or a levy on lawyers should be used to pay for legal aid work, it was suggested yesterday. 
 The public could be charged a tax specifically to pay for publicly funded legal services, in the same way as the National Health Service, Stephen Gilchrist, a London solicitor, told the International Bar Association conference in Strasbourg. 
 &bquo;In the same way as a working person and a taxpayer makes a specific contribution to the upkeep of the national health system, so could a specific premium or tax be levied to support publicly funded legal services,&equo; he said. 
 Replacing the present legal aid system &mdash; which costs the Treasury about &pound;410m a year &mdash; with a specific tax would protect public legal services from spending constraints which had prevented legal aid from being extended. 
 Mr Gilchrist said the second alternative would be to impose a levy &mdash; linked to profits &mdash; on lawyers who did only privately paid work, to subsidise those who did legal aid work. 
 The idea was radical, but if lawyers accepted the principle of access to justice, acceptance by the legal fraternity was not unthinkable, Mr Gilchrist said. 
 A supplementary legal aid scheme started five years ago in Hong Kong was helping personal injury litigants in the middle income trap, the conference heard. 
 Patrick Moss, director of legal aid in Hong Kong, said that under the scheme, a successful litigant paid between 10 and 12 per cent of his damages to a central fund which financed other cases. 
 The scheme was now financially viable, and the last instalment of a private start-up loan of substantially less than &pound;1m was about to be repaid. 
 &bquo;Although the number of applications is small, there is little doubt that the scheme fulfils a need for those most deserving of assistance,&equo; Mr Moss said. 
 The British law reform group, Justice, proposed a similar scheme for the UK more than 10 years ago, but it never found favour with the Government. 
 A trial scheme to test the viability of the proposal was called for at last weekend's Bar conference. 
 International Bar Association conference: Price-rise warning over package tour proposal 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES 
 HOLIDAYMAKERS could face average price rises of 10 per cent if a proposed EC directive aimed at increasing consumer protection is implemented, the Director of the Association of British Travel Agents warned yesterday, writes Patricia Wynn Davies. 
 The average &pound;350 package tour would jump by 10 per cent, with more exotic trips likely to incur larger increases, Sidney Perez told the conference. 
 The draft EC package-holiday directive could make tour operators or travel agents responsible for personal injury claims and losses as well as tour accommodation and facilities. 
 They would be liable for &bquo;any deficiency&equo; &mdash; including those of third parties -in goods or services provided in connection with the package, and any contract clause limiting liability would be void. 
 &bquo;This will mean absolute no-fault unlimited liability for any eventuality,&equo; Mr Perez said. 
 &bquo;We believe much of what is proposed is uninsurable and the rest will be very expensive.&equo; 
 He predicts, however, that the proposal would be opposed by most member states when it comes before the Council of Ministers. 
 The conference was also told about an invention which could curb kidnapping and the illicit sale of Third World babies for adoption. 
 Biotab, developed by the British inventor Leighton Evans, involves taking palm-prints of the baby and its mother on a film which is then attached to an identity card. 
 The device costs just a few pence and is ready for commercial production. 
 Higgs determined to return to Cleveland: Nicholas Timmins talks to the doctor facing an uncertain future after a child sex abuse controversy 
 By NICHOALS TIMMINS 
 MORE THAN two years after the word Cleveland became synonymous with child sexual abuse, Dr Marietta Higgs remains clear about what she wants to do - go back there, and in time go back to work dealing with child abuse there. 
 &bquo;That is what I would like to do when the time is right.&equo; 
 She recognises that after the furore of two years ago any return would have to be &bquo;graded&equo;. 
 She would have to start working only with the new-born in the new neo-natal unit at Middlesbrough General Hospital which she was initially recruited to run as part of her job. 
 But &bquo;at some point in the future&equo;, she wants to become again what she is trained to be &mdash; a general paediatrician, work that would inevitably involve dealing with child abuse. 
 &bquo;Because of all that's happened,&equo; she says, such a move would have to come one step at a time. 
 &bquo;All I am asking, is to be treated in exactly the same way as Dr Wyatt&equo;. 
 Right now she is not being. 
 For of all those peppered by the shotgun blast of criticism that came out of the Cleveland inquiry, where in little more than three months 121 children were diagnosed as actual or possible victims of child sexual abuse, only Dr Higgs still does not know her future and faces effective dismissal. 
 Dr Geoffrey Wyatt, the paediatrician who was her &bquo;partner in crime&equo; to those who cannot believe they were even remotely right, still works in Middlesbrough, though not on child abuse. 
 The two police surgeons who so bitterly opposed them and who scarcely emerged from the inquiry untarnished, work on, while Sue Richardson, Cleveland's child abuse adviser, still works in the county, but with abused adults. 
 Dr Higgs is the only one left for those who believe someone must be seen to pay for the Cleveland controversy. 
 Her employers, the Northern regional health authority, want to prevent her returning there, to end her secondment as a neo-natologist in Newcastle-upon-Tyne, and for the foreseeable future prevent her working in child abuse. 
 They will, they say, try to find her another post as a neo-natologist in the region, but cannot guarantee her one. 
 On 16 October Dr Higgs is due in the Court of Appeal, attempting to stop the authority acting without a full disciplinary hearing. 
 Her frustration over the chaos that became the Cleveland controversy is palpable. 
 For the layman, the question that matters is was she right? 
 Could that many children, in one small part of England, really have been sexually abused? 
 It is a question that cannot be answered. 
 For the diagnosis of child sexual abuse is, she says, a process. 
 A child may &bquo;disclose&equo; abuse; a paediatrician may spot signs that indicate it; abnormal behaviour may alert a social worker, teacher, GP or health visitor to the possibility. 
 But answering the question of whether abuse has taken place takes time and the involvement of many people other than doctors. 
 Time Cleveland did not provide. 
 Amid angry parents, contradictory medical opinion over whether the signs were consistent with sexual abuse, a huge caseload, Stuart Bell, MP, and a baying media, children were lost to follow-up and not fully assessed. 
 The inquiry report did not even attempt to answer the question &bquo;how many of the children were abused?&equo; 
 But Dr Higgs defends her role. 
 Of the 82 &bquo;index&equo; children &mdash; those brought in by social workers or others with suspicion of abuse, or those where the paediatricians saw signs they believed consistent with abuse &mdash; 86 per cent, she says, fall into the Department of Health guidelines, issued since Cleveland, as having medical signs which should raise the question of sexual abuse. 
 The figure would be even higher, she adds, if the guidelines included children who live in a home where an adult has been convicted of a sexual offence with children. 
 Someone, she says, has to start the process. 
 &bquo;If you are asking whether I am still confident about the children in which I raised the concern to begin that process, the answer is &bquo;yes&equo;. 
 Whether or not the ultimate diagnosis is correct in every one or not, the answer is I don't know because many children didn't go through the process that was needed. 
 &bquo;But the grounds on which I raised the concern are still valid. 
 I've not seen anything since then to make me doubt that.&equo; 
 How those concerns are managed is another question. 
 &bquo;We can all learn from that. 
 I can go through the case notes and say maybe that parent could have been helped better, this child helped more.&equo; 
 Mistakes were made. 
 Links between the doctors, police, social workers and others did not work well. 
 Better arrangements now exist, in Cleveland and elsewhere. 
 &bquo;I don't think there's anyone now who thinks we've got it right, but we are all struggling to do that.&equo; 
 In addition, she maintains, Cleveland was not that exceptional. 
 More than 2,700 children went through the paediatrics department at Middlesbrough General in the five months she was there. 
 The cases came in a rush, in part because social services started referring a backlog of children because there was someone at the hospital prepared to diagnose, she says, and because Dr Wyatt started asking whether sexual abuse might be the problem in cases which had failed to respond to previous treatment. 
 But she maintains that as a percentage of all children seen over the five months, the numbers in which they first raised the question of possible abuse were little larger than those found in a recent survey by the NSPCC in a dozen areas of England. 
 &bquo;The figures we found are not significantly different to those anywhere else where people are looking for the problem.&equo; 
 What did boost the numbers was that once the question was raised they also looked for, and found, possible sexual abuse in siblings. 
 &bquo;Not everyone does that.&equo; 
 Good has come out of it all, she says. 
 At the beginning, she was very isolated. 
 Colleagues believed Cleveland would lead to the issue being &bquo;swept under the carpet&equo;. 
 That has not happened. 
 Many more adults are now prepared to admit to abuse as a child. 
 She has had hundreds of letters from adults sexually abused as children saying &bquo;keep going, that they wished someone had diagnosed it in their childhood and describing the trauma they still suffer as adults even though to the outside world they are perfectly normal, respectable people. 
 I had one from an 80-year-old woman who had carried the secret all her life&equo;. 
 New services for adult survivors of sexual abuse have been set up. 
 &bquo;All that's been good. 
 I'm not sure it is the same for children yet.&equo; 
 She says the crucial issue is not in how many cases was she right or wrong, but are doctors allowed to raise a cause for concern? 
 &bquo;Is it safe to do that, knowing one outcome may be that at the end of the process we exclude sexual abuse? 
 &bquo;We have to ask why this is such a horrendous issue to raise.&equo; 
 Society, she says, may need to change its attitude to the perpetrators, from a climate where they are seen as &bquo;monsters&equo; faced with imprisonment to one where they can admit what has happened. 
 She asks how it can be made easier for abusers, who suffer a compulsive behavioural disorder, to say &bquo;doctor I've got this problem and I need help?&equo;. 
 But can she really believe it is possible to go back to Cleveland over whose dead bodies she will return? 
 &bquo;At present anyone who deals with sexual abuse is going to come across people over whose dead bodies they are going to continue to work,&equo; she says. 
 Whatever the media reporting, she claims, Cleveland was not hostile to her. 
 &bquo;When it was all over the papers I feared that when I went shopping people would abuse me, spit at me. 
 It didn't happen.&equo; 
 All through the furore, the numbers attending the hospital's paediatric department did not drop, she says. 
 She met no open hostility. 
 Of the few poisonous letters she received, none came from Cleveland. 
 She would &bquo;have to make a very special effort&equo; to build the links with other professionals &mdash; GPs, the police, consultants and others on which she had barely had time to start in the five months she was there. 
 There are times when something happens to raise an issue high in the public consciousness &mdash; as Cleveland did child sex abuse &mdash; but the person responsible pays the price. 
 Does she fear that is her? 
 &bquo;I hope not. 
 I think I have already paid a certain amount. 
 I think it has got to stop because apart from anything else it has knock-on consequences for other paediatricians over how strong they are going to feel in dealing with this problem. 
 &bquo;At the moment, with me sitting in my position, it is easy to say &bquo;well, I'm not sure, I'm not going to begin the process of investigation here&equo;.' 
 As a mother, she says she sees the parents' point of view. 
 &bquo;I look at the mothers to whom I am going to have say it and I say &bquo;bloody hell, if I was in her shoes how would I feel, what would I do?&equo; 
 &bquo;I hope I know how I would behave, but you don't know until it happens to you. 
 But you also have to think on behalf of the child. 
 If I was a child being sexually abused, would I want it stopped, would I want someone to notice? 
 From the hundreds of letters I have received from adult survivors the message is quite clear: they wish that someone in their childhood had stopped it.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Victory for Kinnock as demands for PR are firmly rejected 
 By JUDY JONES 
 NEIL KINNOCK won a decisive victory yesterday when his party rejected demands to embrace proportional representation by a three-to-one majority. 
 Conference delegates endorsed their leader's determined stand after Roy Hattersley, Labour's deputy leader, warned that for the party to concede demands for PR would be &bquo;an act of historic folly&equo;. 
 He insisted: &bquo;The inevitable result of proportional representation is coalition government. 
 I do not believe that at the end of a week in which we have honed a new policy we are going to even contemplate bargaining that away in smoke-filled rooms with Paddy Ashdown, David Owen, or anyone else.&equo; 
 Post-election pacts were the inevitable consequence of PR. 
 &bquo;We would never have a Labour government able to carry out a Labour programme &mdash; even when that programme had won far more votes than any of the other parties.&equo; 
 Although Labour accepted that a second chamber to replace the Lords could be elected by a method other than the present first-past-the-post system, that chamber did not make or break governments. 
 &bquo;It is in the House of Commons that governments must build their majorities. 
 For the House of Commons, proportional reprentation would in consequence be a reduction, not an extension of democracy.&equo; 
 However, Jeff Rooker, MP for Birmingham Perry Barr and a prominent advocate of PR, said the House of Commons would continue to be &bquo;largely, middle class, white, and male dominated&equo; without a new system. 
 &bquo;You cannot be satisfied with a system which means votes do not have equal value and where, unless you live in a marginal constituency elections pass you by on the other side. 
 You cannot be satisfied when our fellow citizens are saddled with an electoral system which leads to elective dictatoriship, and the corruption of parliamentary law-making processes. 
 And all on the basis of 42 per cent of the vote. 
 &bquo;Electoral reform cannot be held in reserve in case things go wrong. 
 It would be unprincipled, and undemocratic to take that view.&equo; 
 Gavin Laird, general secretary of the AEU engineering union, said PR would be the remaining burning issue within the party in the run-up to the next election. 
 &bquo;The NEC report on this issue is a sham. 
 There was no debate on the national executive, merely an expression of prejudice and fear of change. 
 How can this party stifle debate on such a crucial issue? 
 How can this party join with the Tories to defend the status quo?&equo; 
 Sheila Cunningham, of Norfolk North, said the present system was unfair and perpetuated the elective dictatorship which had developed in the 1980s. 
 Both the Tories and Labour had 46 per cent of the vote in the 1955 general election, yet Conservatives were elected with a majority of 55. 
 But many speakers saw the issue as a damaging diversion from Labour's efforts to win the next election. 
 Alan Duncan, of the GMB, said: &bquo;It is absolutely irresponsible to waste the next year on a debate of no interest or concern to the people we represent.&equo; 
 He was supported by Alun Michael, MP for Cardiff South, who argued that for Labour to take the issue seriously would be a gift to the party's opponents. 
 &bquo;PR involves voting for the least worst, and we want the best for the country as a whole. 
 Just as we are on the way out of the desert, it would be plain daft to turn back because someone thinks they have seen a hazy mirage on the horizon.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Variations on the PR theme: Colin Hughes describes the main systems of proportional representation in use abroad 
 By COLIN HUGHES 
 Apart from First-past-the-post, the main majority systems are the Second Ballot (used in French parliamentary elections), and the Alternative Vote (used in Australia). 
 All three use single-member constituencies and therefore have the common drawback that substantial minorities are not necessarily represented. 
 With the Second Ballot the winning candidate must poll more than half the votes to be elected at the first ballot. 
 Where no candidate polls more than half of the votes, a run-off ballot is held a week later between the leading candidates. 
 The second ballot is final, and the candidate with the most votes is elected, whether he or she wins more than half the votes or not. 
 Under the Alternative Vote voters mark their ballot papers in order of preference &mdash; first preference with a figure &bquo;1&equo;, second with a figure &bquo;2&equo;, and so on. 
 If no candidate wins more than half the first preference votes, the candidate with the fewest first preference votes is excluded, and his or her votes are transferred to the remaining candidates, according to the voters' second preferences. 
 That process is repeated until one candidate clears 50 per cent. 
 Proportional systems elect several candidates in multi-member constituencies, giving due weight to minority votes. 
 The Party List requires voters to support parties, rather than individuals. 
 Each party puts forward a list of candidates for election in multi-member constituencies, which can often be geographically very large: Rome, for example, has 53 MPs. 
 The votes cast for each party are counted and the seats are allocated according to the proportion of votes each party receives &mdash; so a party polling 30 per cent of the votes would take 30 per cent of the seats. 
 In some countries (Israel, Portugal and Spain) seats are filled by candidates according to the order in which they are nominated by the party. 
 In others (Belgium, Finland, Italy and Switzerland) voters are able to vote for candidates within the list, as well as casting a vote for the party. 
 The Single Transferable Vote gives voters a free choice of candidates in multi-member constituencies &mdash; but the number of members is limited to between three and eight. 
 Each voter has one vote which transfers according to preference. 
 Voters therefore list candidates according to preference, as with the alternative vote &mdash; but their vote transfers according to a different principle. 
 Candidates are elected according to a quota: in a four-member constituency, for example, the quota would be one-fifth of the votes, plus one. 
 Once a candidate has enough votes to fufill a quota, other votes for that candidate are transferred to their second preferences, and so on. 
 Voters can therefore express clear preferences for individuals within or across party boundaries. 
 The hybrid West German Additional Member System combines first-past-the-post with the party list. 
 Each voter has two votes &mdash; one is used to elect half of the Bundestag seats in single member constituencies, and the other is apportioned proportionally to party lists across each region (in effect, treating the region as a party list multi-member constituency). 
 The Labour Party Conference: Opt-out hospitals would be returned to NHS 
 By JUDY JONES 
 LABOUR will restore to NHS control any hospital that opts to become a self-governing trust under the Government's controversial health service changes, the party's social services spokesman said yesterday. 
 Robin Cook told delegates that tax concessions for private medical insurance would also be abolished and charges for eye tests scrapped. 
 Mr Cook also repeated demands for arbitration to settle the ambulance staff pay dispute. 
 There could only be one reason why Kenneth Clarke, the Secretary of State for Health, was refusing to accept binding arbitration in the dispute. 
 &bquo;He knows he could not find an independent panel anywhere in Britain which would accept it is right to make an offer which is less than the rate of inflation to people who work in a service which is already underpaid and understaffed.&equo; 
 Steve Gazzard, who appeared in his ambulanceman's uniform, won a standing ovation after he told delegates: &bquo;Mrs Thatcher and her ministers are extremely quick to exploit photo-opportunities when disasters occur. 
 Here in Brighton not so long ago, she and members of her Cabinet experienced at first hand all the skills, courage and dedication of my colleagues. 
 I challenge the Government to repay their debt to Brighton ambulance staff by agreeing to go to arbitration.&equo; 
 While the police had been offered a rise of 9.25 per cent, ambulance staff, who earned only &pound;10,000 after qualification, were being offered 6.5 per cent. 
 For too long it had been treated as a Cinderella service. 
 Lorraine Monk, of Kingston-upon-Thames, said Labour would have to do far more than merely reverse NHS cuts. 
 Party leaders should consider taking the major drug companies into public ownership so that their products were developed on the basis of need rather than profit. 
 David Blunkett, replying for the national executive, persuaded delegates from Kingston-upon-Thames not to press the motion calling for a commitment to sack all the health authority chairmen and senior managers appointed by the present administration. 
 &bquo;We cannot commit ourselves to sacking senior managers who have simply been doing their jobs. 
 Labour will expect all staff in the civil service, and publicly-owned industries to carry out each policy irrespective of their point of view.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Old songs and some new lyrics 
 By JOHN PIENAAR 
 LABOUR'S hard-left crammed into their Campaign Group meeting. 
 It was hot, and everyone was very cross by the time Tim Peacock from Broxtowe summed up the general consensus: &bquo;We've been stuffed,&equo; writes John Pienaar. 
 One by one, Tony Benn, Eric Heffer, Audrey Wise and the formidable Joan Maynard &mdash; dubbed &bquo;Stalin's granny&equo; by the ungallant right &mdash; blazed away at the mood of meek obeisance abroad in Brighton. 
 &bquo;I was a shop steward at Cammell Laird,&equo; reminisced Eric. 
 &bquo;When I was sacked the workers stopped work &mdash; they didn't have a bloody ballot.&equo; 
 But no-one denied that times had changed. 
 For all the earthy language and talk of struggles to come, it sounded more like community singing in a bomb-shelter than a call to arms. 
 Some things never change at a Labour conference. 
 The expensive seafront hotels still heave each night with political and trade union cameraderie; though, tellingly, the Grand Hotel once ran out of Perrier water. 
 The odd Militant supporter appears at the conference rostrum and is easy to spot. 
 They always. 
 Punctuate their slogans. 
 In the wrong places. 
 But, the odd unscripted upset aside, the chairmen and chairwomen find it hard to keep up with torrential voting in favour of the leadership line. 
 Bryan Gould, Labour's trade and industry spokesman, yesterday posed for photographers with a Co-op credit card the size of a tea tray: &bquo;There are middle class Labour supporters&hellip; no, it won't contribute to the credit boom&hellip; change your credit card and help Labour win.&equo; 
 His morning photo-call clashed with a coffee-table press conference by Norman Buchan, the left-wing MP for Paisley South. 
 Mr Buchan is also a conoisseur of socialist folk-singing: he made it clear that he would find it hard to set the policy review to traditional music: &bquo;I am a primeval socialist.&equo; 
 Behind him was Stuart Bell, MP for Middlesbrough and a strategic thinker of the right. 
 He arrived at the conference hall after having a Campaign Group leaflet thrust into his hand. 
 It was a demand for his own deselection. 
 As he told the story, he did not seem too worried. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Poll tax protest fails to sway delegates 
 By JOHN PIENAAR 
 A SCOTTISH woman tore up her poll tax payment book at the conference rostrum yesterday as the row within the party over non-payment policy continued. 
 Christine McVicar, Glasgow Shettleston CLP, said she would not pay the tax, but failed to win conference support for a motion committing the party to a campaign of non-payment. 
 David Blunkett, Labour's local government spokesman, said: &bquo;Does anyone really believe in their heart of hearts that this Government under this Prime Minister is going to abandon the poll tax, return to the rates, because people don't pay and public services are under threat? 
 If you believe it, you are naive, and if you don't you are dishonest in arguing for a non-payment campaign.&equo; 
 Mr Blunkett said the party was refining an alternative which would be fair between people and between areas. 
 &bquo;Above all, our proposal will be based upon ability to pay. 
 If there are more in a household earning good money, they will pay more. 
 If there is someone living alone, who is retired and their income drops, they will pay less.&equo; 
 Ms McVicar said 3.9 million payment books had been issued in Scotland, but even the &bquo;official doctored figures&equo; showed that 700,000 people had not paid. 
 Challenging Labour councillors to join the non-payment campaign and &bquo;fight Thatcher&equo;, she said: &bquo;The poll tax is designed to impoverish our class. 
 Such unjust laws deserve to be broken.&equo; 
 Kathy Wilson, Liverpool Riverside CLP, said income support claimants would lose &pound;25 a year from the tax. 
 &bquo;I have never broken the law, but I will stand with my class, my community, my councillors and my MPs on this issue.&equo; 
 But Garfield Davies, general secretary of the shop workers' union USDAW, said non-payment campaigners were giving false hope to the vulnerable. 
 &bquo;They persuade the poor and the low paid to play this game &mdash; leaving them exposed to massive fines and levies,&equo; Mr Davies said. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Gay anger at NEC over age of consent 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 LESBIAN and gay delegates yesterday vented their anger at an attempt by the Labour leadership to abandon past conference calls to reduce the age of consent for homosexual acts from 21 to 16. 
 The National Executive Committee was warned that watering down the party's commitment to sexual equality in the policy review, out of a fear of losing votes, could backfire. 
 Peter Purton, an executive member of the Labour Campaign for Lesbian and Gay Rights, said the party was losing lesbian and gay votes &bquo;in droves&equo;. 
 &bquo;Hard on the heels of the policy review came the hunting hounds of the SLD and Green Party scraping up votes in bucket loads&equo;. 
 The Social Democrats passed a motion at their conference in Brighton last month calling for a common age of consent at 16. 
 Yesterday a card vote was called on a composite motion from Birmingham Selly Oak Constituency Labour Party demanding the same, but the result will not be announced until today. 
 Debbie Epstein, moving the controversial composite, said &bquo;full equality&equo; had been supported by Labour conferences in 1985, 1986, and 1988. 
 Last year it received a clear 84 per cent majority and then the Campaign was then asked to submit a draft statement to the policy review. 
 &bquo;Imagine our anger, and the anger of all lesbians and gays when we heard that the NEC, led by Roy Hattersley, had voted to exclude the commitment for an equal age of consent of 16 for gay men,&equo; she said. 
 Furthermore, &bquo;full equality&equo; had been replaced by &bquo;greater equality&equo;. 
 Jo Richardson, though replying on behalf of the NEC, pointedly distanced herself from its stand. 
 &bquo;I have been instructed by the NEC to recommend opposition,&equo; she said to some laughter. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Conference quotes 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 &bquo;Point of information. 
 The chair called a &bquo;cuddly&equo; man. 
 Am I not cuddly enough to be called?&equo; &mdash; Irate woman delegate. 
 &bquo;After years of having gentlemen call us &bquo;duck&equo; and &bquo;darling&equo;, surely we can call one of them &bquo;cuddly&equo; without being offensive.&equo; 
 &mdash; Gwyneth Dunwoody MP, chairing the democracy debate. 
 &bquo;I have been called many things by my political opponents, but I have just been given the kiss of death.&equo; 
 &mdash; The &bquo;cuddly man&equo;, Geoff Dixon, delegate from Old Bexley and Sidcup. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Motion rejected 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 The conference voted by 4,592,000 votes to 1,443,000 to reject a motion advocating the setting up of a working party to consider options for electoral reform. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Policy review documents approved 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 The conference yesterday approved the Consumers and the Community review report, which proposes: A Department of Consumer Affairs; Special funding to create local, regional and national consumers' groups; Quality and standards controls in local government, and the health and education services; A Quality Commission to replace the Audit Commission, an Education Standards Council, and a Health Quality Commission; &bquo;Go local&equo; health services, increased preventive medicine, and regular health check-ups; Records of achievement for pupils, a flexible national curriculum, a home/school partnership agreements, and a national schools award. 
 It also approved the Democracy and the Individual review, proposing: To replace the House of Lords with an elected second chamber; Devolved assemblies for Scotland, Wales, and the regions of England; Unification of Ireland only by consent of the majority in the North; A Freedom of Information Act; A Ministry for Women; A Department of Legal Administration to run the courts; Extend legal aid; A statutory duty on local councils to provide integrated child care services for the under-fives; A Children's Commissioner to act as an ombudsman on childrens' rights; Firm opposition to reform of the voting system for the House of Commons. 
 Viewpoint: Union law policy remains unclear 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT, Labour Editor 
 AS THE Labour leadership congratulates itself on a virtually unprecedented exhibition of unity and moderation, they should be aware that knives are being sharpened at Conservative Central Office. 
 The object of the attentions of Tory apparatchiks &mdash; and ministers &mdash; is the new policy on employment law, moderate and sensible as it may seem. 
 Bluntly, the Shadow Cabinet and unions need to get their fingers out &mdash; with some expedition &mdash; to set the limits of the proposed legal framework. 
 True, the conference ignored the call for complete immunity in tort which the TUC passed to the conference. 
 Under the resolution overwhelmingly passed by Labour delegates, unions would be subject to fines and there would no such immunity from civil action if they acted illegally. 
 Strikes without ballots, for instance, would not enjoy the protection of the law. 
 There has, however, been a confusing flurry of paper involved in the evolution of the policy. 
 First there was the broad statement of intent in the policy review document and then there was the controversial TUC composite resolution &mdash; an incompetently constructed mosaic of competing interests. 
 Last Friday came a statement of &bquo;clarification&equo; issued by the party and the unions and finally there was the debate and another statement by Michael Meacher, Labour's employment spokesman. 
 There has been nothing remotely resembling intellectual coherence. 
 Basically, the clarification needs clarification. 
 Within the next few months, for instance, the party and unions should set the level of fines that recalcitrant unions would incur. 
 Mr Meacher should also spell out his plans for limits on picket lines. 
 It is not sufficient to tell the conference that there will be no return to mass picketing. 
 Most important, he will have to explain how far sympathy action should be allowed and precisely what would constitute a lawful trade dispute. 
 Would it be lawful for instance, for workers to refuse to handle imports from South Africa; would meat porters be allowed to take action in support of nurses. 
 The first would demonstrably be a political strike and the second would hardly be a trade dispute. 
 The key phrase used by Mr Meacher is that there should be a &bquo;genuine interest&equo; involved before industrial action was within the law. 
 Jimmy Knapp, leader of the National Union of Railwaymen, argues that his members who took action in support of the miners during the coal strike had a genuine interest in the fight to keep pits open: fewer mines mean fewer coal trains. 
 Setting limits to action will not be easy for Labour. 
 If workers hold a democratic vote to go on strike for whatever reason, it ill becomes a Labour government to legislate to make it unlawful. 
 But that, according to Mr Meacher, is what they will have to do. 
 Within the next few months &mdash; and long before the next election &mdash; they will have to settle these questions or see the spectre of the Winter of Discontent raised to haunt them by gleeful Conservative politicians. 
 It simply is not enough for Mr Meacher to say that such details will be worked out after the next general election by Labour ministers and Whitehall officials. 
 Mr Meacher intends within the next three to six months to work out precisely what form of specialist industrial relations courts a future Labour government intends to set up. 
 Difficult as it may be, he should attempt to settle more delicate issues. 
 If Mr Meacher is not the man to bang the heads of union leaders together, then surely Mr Kinnock is. 
 Celebration in Colour flower festival in St Albans 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT, Labour Editor 
 Visitors admire some of more than 200 floral displays yesterday at the opening of the Celebration in Colour flower festival at St Albans Cathedral in Hertfordshire. 
 All furniture had to be removed from the nave to make room for the flowers. 
 The festival, which ends on Sunday, also includes displays of embroidery and tapestries  
 Art Market: Historical footnotes put value on clocks 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 What apparently made all the difference to the price was that the clock came from a historic house, Cassiobury Park, and that it is illustrated in an important book on the craftsman &mdash; Thomas Tompion, His Life and Work by R W Symonds. 
 Collectors love to be able to show friends the book with their own clock illustrated in it. 
 A monthgoing longcase clock of about 1710 by Daniel Delander also profited from a good footnote, selling for &pound;104,500 (estimate &pound;45,000-&pound;55,000) although the case which was originally ebonised is now painted blue. 
 The key thing appeared to be that Delander had fitted it with double wheel or duplex escapement &mdash; and it could be the first of the rare group of his clocks that include the feature. 
 He obviously changed the clock around &mdash; there are many filled in holes in the front &mdash; which implies it was a pioneering, experimental piece. 
 The other high price in the sale was &pound;88,000 (&pound;15,000-&pound;20,000) for a rare George II carved mahogany combination angle barometer, thermometer and mirror &mdash; a real curiosity in a handsome carved frame. 
 The sale made &pound;943,000 with 13 per cent unsold. 
 Renaissance medals, portraits of famous or infamous figures carefully realised in bronze, made an unlooked for advance in price at Sotheby's coin and medal sale. 
 Medical check on crack use urged 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 SENIOR POLICE officers have called on the Home Office to co-ordinate a more accurate system of detecting how many people are using crack, the cocaine-based drug, by gathering information from doctors and hospitals. 
 Such a move would mean a fundamental change in how information is gathered and acted upon. 
 Drugs squad officers want doctors and hospitals to pass on information about any traces of crack found in patients during emergency treatments. 
 No patients would be identified and the information would be confidentially passed to the British Medical Association and then on to the Home Office. 
 Police say the only barometer being used to measure crack usage is the number of arrests made. 
 There is some dispute about the level of abuse in this country. 
 The latest figures from the Home Office show that the largest of the 60 seizures of the drug made up to the end of June this year was 40 grammes in Nottingham. 
 The rest has been on average just over one gramme. 
 But police believe these figures disguise actual use. 
 David Owen, Chief Constable of North Wales, who also heads a senior crime committee, told the Association of Chief Police Officers' conference in Lancashire yesterday that there was genuine concern about the use of crack. 
 Mr Owen met the Home Secretary, Douglas Hurd, on 20 September and suggested that senior officials within the Department of Health, the social services and various community bodies should meet to discuss the problem. 
 &bquo;We are concerned and the scenario for us is not a particularly good one. 
 We do have cause for concern but it is not a problem which can be solved by law enforcement alone. 
 We need to work together with all agencies concerned about community care,&equo; he said. 
 He believes there is now a need for a more precise method of monitoring crack abuse nationally, similar to the Dawn (Drug Awareness Warning Network) method, used in the United States, which compiles statistics through information taken from hospitals. 
 &bquo;Private Eye&equo; must wait for decision over libel retrial 
 By JAMES DALRYMPLE 
 THE MAGAZINE Private Eye will have to wait two to three weeks to find out whether it has won a retrial on libel damages of &pound;600,000 awarded against it to Sonia Sutcliffe, wife of the Yorkshire Ripper. 
 Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, sitting with Lord Justices Nourse and Russell, yesterday reserved their judgment after Private Eye had rejected an offer from Mrs Sutcliffe to allow the Court of Appeal to set the amount of damages. 
 In his final arguments in the three-day hearing, Gavin Lightman QC, for the magazine, said that if a retrial was ordered it intended to subpeona the editor of the Mail on Sunday, Stewart Steven, and two senior journalists from the company in an effort to discover the truth behind a &pound;25,000 payment to Mrs Sutcliffe. 
 Mr Lightman claimed that if the jury which had awarded the &pound;600,000 had known that Mrs Sutcliffe was not adverse to taking money for her story, the outcome could have been different. 
 He said evidence of private conversations between journalists of Associated Newspapers about the secret deal, and of Mrs Sutcliffe's deliberate concealment of The Mail on Sunday's actions, could throw &bquo;completely new light&equo; on the case. 
 He agreed accounts of the alleged &bquo;roundabout&equo; payment were based on hearsay, but added: &bquo;The journalists will be questioned about what they knew and even journalists will tell the truth when they are called.&equo; 
 Earlier, Geoffrey Shaw, for Mrs Sutcliffe, said she would be willing to accept whatever damages figure the court substituted for the &pound;600,000 award. 
 He said: &bquo;If&hellip; the court's inclination at the end of the day is to interfere with the &pound;600,000 award of damages, then she, for her part &mdash; although she does not fear a retrial and again does not relish it - would be willing to accept whatever your lordships should decide is the right figure.&equo; 
 After a brief adjournment, and huddled conversations with Ian Hislop, editor of Private Eye, Mr Lightman rejected the offer. 
 He said that at the original trial, the magazine had no idea &pound;25,000 had been paid to Mrs Sutcliffe by Mail on Sunday reporter Barbara Jones - and nor had the jury. 
 He argued that if a jury had the benefit of &bquo;this further evidence&equo; it &bquo;might take a very different view&equo; of Mrs Sutcliffe's attitude to deals with the Press. 
 &bquo;Suddenly the light is thrown,&equo; Mr Lightman said, &bquo;and the matter can take a very different complexion&equo;. 
 &bquo;The magazine's primary concern is the size of the damages award,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;A retrial on this issue is absolutely vital. 
 If this award stands there is precious little scope in this country for any investigative journalism, and that sort of investigative and critical journalism is an essential feature of an informed democracy. 
 &bquo;There must be inevitable mistakes made in any such journalism and a lacunae will appear in regard to evidence, and indeed trials will go wrong. 
 But damages awards like Mrs Sutcliffe's would put out of business all but the biggest media moguls. 
 This kind of award would create not merely fear, but despair.&equo; 
 After the hearing, Dave Cash, Private Eye's managing director, said if the retrial was refused the magazine could well go under. 
 Mr Hislop said a fund to raise money from readers stood at about &pound;100,000. 
 Computer users prepare for an attack of viruses 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 (First Edition) COMPUTER experts fear &bquo;virus hysteria&equo; as Friday the 13th, a date beloved of perpetrators of computer viruses, approaches. 
 Several viruses are expected to be launched on computer users next week, including Datacrime 2, which can wipe information from computer hard discs. 
 The virus is also thought to have started in The Netherlands in March and to have surfaced in the US and UK. 
 But, according to Peter Sommer, a computer forensics expert, a hard disc &bquo;is more likely to be wiped out by glitches in the electricity supply&equo;. 
 He said computer networks would not be affected and copies of information should be made on floppy discs. 
 Infected programmes activate the virus when started up and it looks for other programmes to infect. 
 Experts say on 12 October it will wipe out the hard disc of any machine it has entered. 
 Computers can catch it by using floppy discs holding infected programmes, or from programmes copied off an electronic bulletin board, which is where it was probably first planted. 
 The date is said to have been chosen to thwart those taking precautions by adjusting computer clocks, which trigger the virus, to avoid the notorious date. 
 Other viruses, say some experts, might be triggered on 14 October for that reason. 
 Aircraft carrrier HMS Invincible first ship to be fitted with Goalkeeper short-range weapons system 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 The Goalkeeper short-range weapons system being fired during test trials aboard HMS Invincible. 
 The aircraft carrier is the first ship to be fitted with the gun, believed to be the most accurate, reliable and sophisticated close range anti-missile system in the world. 
 Warning on funding as enrolment at polys rises by 47% 
 By NGAIO CREQUER, Education Correspondent 
 ENROLMENT of full-time students in English polytechnics has increased by 47 per cent over the last eight years, compared with a rise of only 3 per cent in universities, Her Majesty's Inspectors said yesterday. 
 The huge expansion had been achieved without a reduction in quality, the inspectors said, but they warned that the polytechnics were seriously underfunded. 
 Buildings had deteriorated steadily, and there was a serious lack of equipment. 
 &bquo;Good teaching cannot be sustained indefinitely in inadequate and underequipped accommodation.&equo; 
 In 1988 more than 60 per cent of polytechnic buildings had &bquo;shortcomings in important areas&equo;. 
 Nearly half the science departments had deficiencies in equipment. 
 &bquo;In some cases the lack of up-to-date equipment which reflects modern industrial practice is impairing the students&equo; experience.&equo; 
 The report, which looks at all 29 English polytechnics, said there is a need for substantial investment in new capital equipment in most. 
 &bquo;Much of that which is in use is obsolete and expensive to maintain.&equo; 
 Half the polytechnics have poor computing provision. 
 A lot of accommodation was unsuitable for its purpose. 
 There were not enough classrooms and staff had to work in overcrowded conditions. 
 The polytechnics, faced with the problem of increasing access or maintaining the level of money spent on each student, had made access their priority. 
 The universities had taken the opposite view. 
 The report will be seized upon by ministers who argue that a further expansion in student numbers can be achieved by higher education becoming more efficient. 
 The contrary view is that a huge capital investment will have to be made soon to maintain buildings and provide equipment. 
 Polytechnic directors yesterday called for more government funding. 
 Students should not be expected to learn in &bquo;cowsheds&equo;, they said. 
 The rise in student numbers in polytechnics has not been matched by an increase in teaching staff. 
 Class sizes have risen, and between 1981-2 and 1985-6 expenditure per full-time equivalent student fell in real terms from &pound;3,800 to &pound;3,150. 
 Over the same period university expenditure, where more research is undertaken, was fairly constant at about &pound;5,200 per student. 
 The inspectors said the quality of courses was often better in polytechnics than in colleges. 
 The HMI does not inspect universities, except teacher training departments, by invitation. 
 There is some &bquo;outstanding teaching in most subjects in most institutions, but as a proportion of the total teaching effort the amount is comparatively limited&equo;. 
 The great majority of teaching is at least satisfactory, but 10-20 per cent is less than satisfactory &bquo;in some important respects&equo;. 
 Where teaching was unsatisfactory this was because of an over-dependence on formal lectures. 
 There was some &bquo;spoon-feeding&equo; in lectures, seminars and practical work, lecturers failed to identify or correct poor work, and assessment placed too much emphasis on the ability to recall factual information. 
 Monty Python star dies on eve of 20th anniversary 
 By DAVID LISTER, Arts Correspondent 
 IT WAS, said Monty Python member Terry Jones yesterday of the death of his colleague Graham Chapman the worst case of party pooping he have ever come across. 
 Chapman had died of cancer on Wednesday on the eve of the twentieth anniversary celebration of the first Monty Python show. 
 It was not the first time the 48-year-old comedian and doctor had pooped the party. 
 In 1967 Chapman, who had cultivated a conventional image with his ubiquitous tweed jacket and pipe, by his own later admission stunned a party attended by his friends and future Python colleagues by coming out as a homosexual. 
 John Cleese and Eric Idle who had both been at Cambridge with him had had no idea. 
 Chapman said later that Cleese, his writing partner at Cambridge and afterwards on the Frost, Marty Feldman and At Last the 1948 shows, &bquo;was still in a state of shock&equo;. 
 After the last Python show in 1974 Chapman pooped the party again. 
 While the others went on to further success he fought and eventually won a battle against alcoholism, but his writing partnership with Cleese did not survive it, and, at his own choice, he was not a member of the Python film company Prominent Features. 
 The sometimes uneasy relations between Chapman and the rest of the team received a boost recently when they filmed an introduction to a twentieth anniversary special to be screened later this year. 
 All assumed then and indeed until two days ago that Chapman was recovering from his illness. 
 Cleese and Michael Palin were with him when he died. 
 The painfully early death of someone who was part of a youth cult normally prompts obituaries for that cult. 
 But in the case of Python that could not be more inappropriate. 
 Books, records and films continue to sell well. 
 The original shows were last year sold to MTV in the US. 
 Only Chapman really failed to capitalise on Python's success. 
 Cleese's successes are well known. 
 Palin, among many film triumphs, co-starred with Cleese in A Fish Called Wanda; Eric Idle has also been consistently on screen. 
 Terry Jones has moved into film direction, as has Terry Gilliam, the show's animator. 
 The Python mixture of surrealism and Oxbridge set texts &mdash; a &bquo;summarising Proust&equo; competition in a municipal baths; phoning Sartre's wife &bquo;Is John Paul free?&equo; 'He's been asking himself that for years' &mdash; is as familiar as the silly walks, deceased parrot and other images that have gained cult status. 
 But if Chapman's death is to provoke any analysis it might be to ask whether the Pythons achieved their original aim of breaking the mould of English television comedy, doing away with the studio applause, the guest star, the musical interlude, even on occasion the punchline. 
 That ambition has only been partially fulfilled. 
 John Lloyd, producer of Not The Nine O'Clock News, Spitting Image and Blackadder, says that for his generation of university students 20 years ago Python was the seminal programme. 
 The first Not the Nine O' Clock News series had a sketch about Python worshippers but that team, while itself worshipping Python, went out of its way not to be derivative, eschewing silly voices, dressing in drag and what they later realised to be a misogynist trait in Python. 
 &bquo;In some ways,&equo; he said yesterday, &bquo;Python does look very old-fashioned now, yet when I arranged a compilation of all 45 shows for the BBC I found that we had on the Not The Nine O&equo; Clock News unintentionally pinched a number of things, putting the signature in the middle of the programme, parodying famous TV interviews. 
 It impresses itself upon you subliminally. 
 &bquo;But the irony of a mould-breaking programme like Python is that it is a dead-end, a spoiler for the rest of us. 
 Because it is so bizarre it is not possible to go down a very new route of comedy without appearing derivative. 
 And as not everyone can be a mould-breaker there are still a lot of traditional comedy shows on television.&equo; 
 Indeed, the formula for the majority of comedy on television remains as it was before a ragged man struggled along the seashore, collapsed and panted seemingly with his last breath: &bquo;It's&hellip;&equo; 
 Peer &bquo;was sure Yugoslavs would be well treated&equo; 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 LORD ALDINGTON told a High Court jury yesterday he remembered making inquiries to ensure that thousands of Yugoslavs repatriated by the British at the end of the Second World War would be properly treated. 
 He was continuing evidence in a libel action against Count Nikolai Tolstoy, the historian, and Nigel Watts, a Tunbridge Wells property developer, who circulated a pamphlet in 1987 describing him as responsible for repatriating 70,000 Russian Cossacks and Yugoslavs to be massacred by the communists in 1945. 
 The defendants say the accusations are true. 
 In evidence earlier this week Lord Aldington, 75, formerly Brigadier Toby Lowe, said the first he had heard that the men, women and children sent back from the British-occupied zone of Austria had been tortured and massacred was from Count Tolstoy in 1979. 
 He said yesterday: &bquo;I'm sure I had been making inquiries (in 1945) about what would happen to people who we sent back. 
 I have in my memory a feeling that we had satisfied ourselves that international law would be obeyed.&equo; 
 He referred to two documents where the Yugoslavs gave undertakings about treatment of repatriated citizens. 
 Lord Aldington was asked why the Yugoslavs had not been told their destination before repatriation. 
 &bquo;We did not wish to create conditions which led to possible violence.&equo; 
 This would have meant extra guards were needed on the camps, and would have forced the British soliders to use force. 
 He also told the court he had been acting in accordance with an order from Allied Forces Headquarters on 14 May 1945. 
 That said: &bquo;All Russians to be handed over to Soviet forces and all surrendered Yugoslav nationals serving in German forces to be handed over to Yugoslav forces.&equo; 
 Asked whether he had screened the Yugoslavs before they were sent back, he said there had been no requirement under the order. 
 He was asked why he had repatriated the women and children &bquo;camp followers&equo; with the captured troops. 
 He said that had been a concession to them to allow families to stay together. 
 &bquo;I assume that we thought that these dependants would wish to accompany their soldiers and that the soldiers would wish to have them with them. 
 It was a concession, not an extra burden.&equo; 
 But he did not order the return of other civilians, he said. 
 At the time, he and his commanding officers were more concerned with preparing to fight Tito's partisans, Lord Aldington added. 
 In May 1945 Yugoslav partisans had been spreading through Allied-occupied Austria, trying to annexe much of it to their own country. 
 The British Eighth Army's V Corps, where he was a staff officer, had been giving top priority to Operation Beehive, preparing a strategy to fight the Yugoslavs if necessary. 
 He said it had been vital to keep Operation Beehive secret from the Soviets and the Yugoslavs, so many people within V Corps had not known about it. 
 Fears of global trade battles 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 THE THESIS that liberal democracies will be the prevailing political form of the future may be premature, a conference of planners and leading industrialists was told yesterday. 
 John Roper, of the Royal Institute of International Affairs, warned that economic failure combined with growing nationalistic fervour in some East European and Third World countries could lead instead to the emergence of extremely right-wing, authoritarian regimes. 
 He told the conference &mdash; which is considering future world political, economic, social, scientific and environmental trends &mdash; that with the relative decline in the economic importance of the United States and the diminishing military threat posed by the Soviet Union, the new civil super powers of the 1990s were likely to be Japan and Western Europe. 
 While the Cold War evaporated as Mikhail Gorbachev, the Soviet leader, realised that there was little point in the USSR being a military giant if it remained an &bquo;economic pygmy&equo;, the world would not, Mr Roper said, necessarily become a safer place. 
 The growth of Islam, and regional tensions in the Middle East and parts of Asia would have an impact on the northern industrialised world. 
 &bquo;The issues of drugs, terrorism and global environmental challenges will fill any gap that the end of the Cold War might have created,&equo; he said. 
 Dr Barry Bosworth, senior fellow at The Brooking Institution, Washington DC, warned that the decline in the US's global economic hegemony, would lead to increased conflict between the major industrialised nations over trading issues and international financial relations. 
 In future the responsibility for preserving a stable international economic system would rest with &bquo;a committee&equo; of the major industrial nations. 
 However, while the growth of the international financial system would seem to imply the need for increasingly centralised decision-making, individual countries were unlikely to be willing to relinquish the freedom to conduct their own economic affairs for the sake of the greater international good. 
 The US's foreign trade deficit was likely to continue for the forseeable future, he said. 
 But there was no reason why this imbalance could not be sustained indefinitely. 
 North America, Dr Bosworth, said was on a &bquo;consumption binge&equo; but it could continue to live off its assets. 
 With real assets worth &dollar;15 trillion it was a very rich country. 
 It was currently financing its deficit by selling off &dollar;150bn worth of assets a year to other countries and by borrowing money from Japan and Europe. 
 While America currently lacked the political will to tackle its trade deficit, there was increasing talk of ending free-trade access to its vast domestic market. 
 In the past the US had tended to trade off economic advantages for political gains, but in future it would become much more single-minded about its own economic interests, he predicted. 
 National Trust to restore Uppark House after blaze 
 By JACK O'SULLIVAN 
 UPPARK HOUSE in West Sussex, one of Britain's finest seventeenth-century houses, which was virtually gutted by fire in August, is to be restored, the National Trust announced yesterday. 
 The work could take 10 years and will be the trust's biggest single building conservation project. 
 Many ornate plaster ceilings will have to be recreated, wallpapers reproduced, silk hangings rewoven and the staircase rebuilt. 
 Angus Stirling, the National Trust's director-general, said: &bquo;Far more of Uppark and its contents survive than has been lost. 
 There is a real phoenix, not a false one, to be raised from the ashes.&equo; 
 The ground floor has largely survived beneath the rubble, including 95 per cent of the contents such as furniture, paintings, books and china, the trust says. 
 Carved and gilded ornament, chimney pieces, floor boards, the saloon chandelier, window shutters and the dining room carpet have survived. 
 The basement is virtually intact. 
 Uppark will first be made weatherproof and opened to the public for six days in November before restoration work begins. 
 One alternative option had been to preserve the house as a burnt-out ruin. 
 This was rejected on the grounds that there was nowhere else to put the rescued artifacts, many of which were designed for the house. 
 Branson sets his sights on crossing Pacific by balloon 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 RICHARD BRANSON, head of the Virgin entertainment and airline empire, will make his next assault on the record books in November when he tries to cross the Pacific in a hot air balloon. 
 The balloon, twice the height of Nelson's Column and the width of the Albert Hall in London, is the largest yet built. 
 It will ride the jet stream between the troposphere and stratosphere at speeds of up to 320 kilometres per hour (200mph) and will carry atmospheric experiments for the Japanese meteorological agency. 
 The 10,000km journey, which is being supported by Virgin and the Japanese pharmaceuticals firm, Otsuka, will begin in south Japan and should end just off the Californian coast, or in open countryside near Los Angeles. 
 While Mr Branson and his colleague, Per Lindstrand, hope to use the flight to get into the record books. 
 Japanese meteorologists want to take advantage of it to examine the levels in the jet stream of freon gas, one of the chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) which contribute to the depletion of the earth's ozone layer. 
 The project will also donate funds to Cambridge University, which is carrying out a study into ways of protecting the flora and fauna of the Indonesian rain forests. 
 Diabetics benefit from insulin-cell transplant 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 DOCTORS in Canada have pioneered an operation to transplant insulin-producing cells into the livers of diabetic patients. 
 More than six months after surgery the two patients involved have &bquo;significantly&equo; reduced their insulin injections, according to a report in New Scientist. 
 Transplanted cells are taken from the pancreas of a donor. 
 Several transplants have been tried before, but this is the first time they have continued to function for a long period, according to the researchers at the University of Alberta, in Edmonton. 
 Insulin regulates the uptake of sugar from the blood by all the body cells and tissues. 
 In diabetics, the insulin-producing cells produce only small amounts of the hormone. 
 As a result, diabetics suffer from very high levels of sugar in their blood. 
 They are at an increased risk of a stroke, heart disease, kidney failure and blindness and nerve disorders. 
 Insulin injections allow the majority to live a normal life but the control over blood sugar is not as efficient as the body's own mechanism. 
 The recent introduction of genetically engineered insulin has lead to some problems for diabetics who have changed from animal-derived insulin. 
 Researchers say the grafting of pancreatic cells may eventually free many from daily injections. 
 Transplants of the whole pancreas have been successful for some severely ill patients, however, they need to take powerful drugs for life to stop rejection of the organ. 
 Transplants of small groups of cells require less drug treatment and the risk of rejection is much reduced, according to the report. 
 Researchers in Oxford have found the first evidence of a genetic cause for unexplained mental retardation in children. 
 A minor abnormality in the chromosomes which control development has been found in a brother and sister, both of whom were mentally retarded, according to a report in tomorrow's edition of The Lancet. 
 The chromosomes carry genes which contain all the genetic information needed to control development. 
 If they are abnormal, the information is no longer correct and various physical and mental problems develop. 
 About 3 in 1,000 people suffer from moderate or severe mental retardation. 
 In about half of those cases there is no apparent cause, according to the report. 
 Jeanette Lamb, a research team member at the Institute of Molecular Medicine, John Radcliffe Hospital, Oxford, said: &bquo;We have found a cause for mental retardation that may account for a large proportion of the unexplained cases.&equo; 
 Rape case report 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 The Crown Prosecution Service is to prepare a report on the case of a man cleared of raping a 16-year-old girl because his alleged victim was not considered mentally capable of giving evidence. 
 The report, to Michael Harvey, head of the CPS in East Anglia, will include a transcript of legal discussions. 
 &bquo;Sun&equo; standards 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 The Sun newspaper is to set up a service called &bquo;Hard Views&equo; aimed at &bquo;cleaning up and improving the standards of journalism in television&equo;. 
 It is asking readers to say if they have been misrepresented in a programme, to &bquo;expose the tricks and deception used by TV to deliberately mislead people&equo;. 
 Patient improves 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 Aisling Barnett, 35, who underwent an emergency liver transplant, at King's College Hospital, London, regained consciousness after 72 hours. 
 Her husband, Colin, said: &bquo;She's in discomfort but she's doing really well.&equo; 
 Westland jobs go 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 A further 420 jobs, are to go at Westland, the Somerset helicopter maker, in its high-technology division. 
 The latest redundancies, 345 at Yeovil and 75 at its Bournemouth plant, bring to nearly 3,000 the jobs lost since its rescue in 1986. 
 Children killed 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 Three children died and their mother Sharon Outlaw, 27, was injured in a fire at their home in Helensburgh, Strathclyde. 
 Acid house curbs 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 The Government is urgently to review powers available for councils to control acid house parties, Virginia Bottomley, the Environment Minister, told chairmen of local authority associations. 
 Search ends 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 Police in Edinburgh were satisfied no more bodies are buried in the ruins of the six-storey tenement building destroyed in an explosion on Wednesday morning which killed a man and a woman. 
 They said everyone living in the building was accounted for. 
 Investigators for British Gas Scotland said tests had revealed that a section of nearby gas main was not gas tight. 
 Two Kurds injured in fire 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 Two Kurds were injured, one seriously, in a fire inside their locked room at Harmondsworth detention centre near Heathrow airport a day after they were told their application for political asylum in Britain had failed. 
 The Home Office could not confirm reports that the two men set fire to themselves. 
 One was taken to Stoke Mandeville Hospital, Buckinghamshire, suffering from 30 per cent burns. 
 The other went to Mount Vernon Hospital, Hillingdon. 
 LWT criticised for &bquo;golden handcuffs&equo; share scheme 
 By MAGGIE BROWN, Media Editor 
 LONDON WEEKEND TELEVISION is facing difficulties over its &bquo;golden handcuffs&equo; share scheme designed to lock 40 top managers and programme-makers into their jobs. 
 It is arousing controversy within both LWT and ITV as independent television companies prepare for the fight to hold on to their franchises. 
 Under the scheme, the top 40 staff will pay about &pound;3.3m for a five per cent share stake in LWT. 
 If the company wins its franchise back in 1992, and then trebles its share price by mid 1993, their stake will expand to 15 per cent. 
 But those who participate have to sign a non-competition deal preventing them from leaving to work with a rival consortium. 
 It appeared last night that some of the staff entitled to 10 to 15 per cent of the shares might not take them up, but all the key board members will, thus ensuring the success of the scheme. 
 One programme department head is believed to have rejected it. 
 The proportion of shares expected to go to Christopher Bland, chairman of LWT Holdings and architect of the scheme, is also being questioned, both within the City and the company. 
 Details will not be fixed until the final scheme, part of a major capital reorganisation of the company, is published, within the next two weeks. 
 But reports that he is taking a quarter of the &pound;3.3m portion of shares were firmly denied yesterday. 
 Richard Dunn, chairman of the ITV Association and managing director of Thames Television, said: &bquo;It is sending out the wrong signals. 
 The managers appear to be enriching themselves.&equo; 
 The scheme is being widely debated within television because it sets a precedent for other companies. 
 The 40 executives are divided into an inner group of 15, who will buy three- quarters of the shares, and an outer group of 25, who divide up the remaining quarter. 
 The outer group includes the heads of programming departments. 
 Mr Dunn, who is currently devising an incentive plan for Thames Television, said he believed ITV had to motivate and retain the services of all its staff, but that schemes should be devised to spread profit sharing and share ownership company wide. 
 He added that special incentives should perhaps apply to the top 10 managers, whose performances will be crucial in retaining the franchise. 
 Mr Bland said last night: &bquo;Our scheme is designed to ensure that LWT is in a position to make and broadcast programmes at the weekend from 1993 onwards.&equo; 
 Barry Cox, LWT communications director, said that the company was unable to comment or discuss the scheme before publication. 
 ITV has been thrown into disarray because the current franchises have been extended for three years while the Government introduces a new free market framework. 
 They have to re-apply and pay, by competitive tender, for franchises which they have held for many years. 
 This switch is expected to put a premium on the top handful of managers, who have track records in arranging programming for television stations. 
 These people will be highly attractive to would-be new entrants, who are expected to head-hunt them. 
 Ford unions want double-figure rise and cut in hours 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT, Labour Editor 
 ONE of the most important wage claims in the pay round was submitted yesterday when leaders of Ford's 33,000 manual workers called for a double figure increase. 
 Management were told at the ritual claim submission in London that Ford workers at the 21 plants wanted to be the best paid in the motor industry. 
 Unions would accept a two-year deal provided there was an &bquo;inflation plus&equo; element in the second year. 
 A central part of the claim was a reduction in the working week from 39 hours to 35, to coincide with a similar demand by the leaders of two million engineering workers who are conducting strike ballots at key sites. 
 The eventual settlement will form a target for other workers and the Government will be anxious that the traditionally independent company will keep the award nearer the inflation rate, currently 7.3 per cent. 
 Union leaders, however, were already invoking probable mortgage rises as a reason for an increase in excess of 10 per cent. 
 Jack Adams, the unions' chief negotiator, said they would be seeking to ensure production staff were paid the same as those doing similar jobs at Jaguar &mdash; in which Ford recently took a stake &mdash; who were earning up to &pound;34 a week more. 
 Next month the present two-year deal runs out. 
 In 1987-88 they received 7 per cent and in 1988-89, 8.9 per cent (or the rate of inflation plus 2.5 per cent). 
 In the 31-page submission, the profitability of Ford is adduced as one of the main reasons for the claim for a &bquo;substantial&equo; rise. 
 Mr Adams pointed out that the profits of Ford of Britain had risen for the third year running to a record &pound;673m and he calculated a further increase to &pound;710m was likely this year. 
 It was the most profitable car company in Britain and earned the highest margins of any Ford plant in Europe. 
 The largest section of blue-collar workers, those on grade three, are presently paid &pound;215.31 basic plus an attendance supplement of &pound;8.49. 
 Line workers get an additional &pound;3.55. 
 Part of the submission concentrates on &bquo;social aspects&equo; of the claim including an inflation-proofed pension scheme, paternity leave and removal of the &bquo;clocking on&equo; system. 
 John Hougham, Ford's personnel director, refused to comment yesterday but agreed to reply to unions on 26 October. 
 Negotiations are likely to last into next month. 
 A company request that the normally prolonged negotiations be &bquo;concertina-ed&equo; into a week-long brain storming session has been rejected. 
 On Wednesday leaders of 12,000 white-collar workers at Ford put in a similar claim plus a call for low interest mortgages and a car leasing scheme. 
 The Ford Pay claim coincides with negotiations at Vauxhall where leaders of the 9,000 manual workers have turned down a two-year offer giving 9.1 per cent in the first year and inflation plus &pound;3 in the second. 
 Further talks are scheduled for 16 October. 
 Ministers claim &bquo;progress&equo; on UDR 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correspondent 
 BRITISH and Irish ministers last night ended eight hours of talks in London about the reform of the Ulster Defence Regiment without reaching agreement but claiming progress had been made. 
 Peter Brooke, the Secretary of State for Northern Ireland, said no major changes would be made to the UDR, in spite of the demands from the Irish government for a thorough review of its role. 
 However, Gerry Collins, the Irish minister for foreign affairs, later made it clear that progress had been made and he reaffirmed his Government's commitment to the Anglo-Irish agreement. 
 He firmly denied that he had emerged from the meeting empty handed. 
 Mr Collins told The Independent: &bquo;These are long standing, difficult, complex, sensitive issues relating to security, which have to do with the preservation of life or acts which result in the deaths of innocent people. 
 We can never walk away without resolving problems which have such importance. 
 We would be reneging on our total commitment and our obligations to the Anglo-Irish agreement. 
 That we will not do.&equo; 
 The Irish urged the British Government to withdraw the UDR from operations in all sensitive areas in Northern Ireland, which the British will not concede. 
 That comes after growing Irish annoyance at the continued failure of the British to ensure that the RUC accompanies the UDR on all its operations. 
 The British Government has promised tighter vetting of recruits to the UDR. 
 But the Irish ministers will be under pressure to obtain greater concessions. 
 Yesterday's meeting resumed talks broken off after eight hours in Dublin last month. 
 The failure to reach accord, and the spate of security leaks, intensified speculation that the Anglo-Irish agreement was under threat. 
 Mr Brooke said yesterday it was now stronger than before. 
 The two sides agreed to hold a further meeting soon which is expected to produce firm proposals for resolving some of the Irish concerns on security. 
 The names and addresses of senior judges in the Irish Republic, together with a document which purports to come from the office of the Chief of Staff of the Irish Army, surfaced yesterday as the latest in the series of security leaks, writes David McKittrick. 
 The material was sent to RTE, the Irish broadcasting service in Dublin and to the Newsletter, the Belfast Protestant newspaper. 
 It was marked &bquo;UVF&equo; - the illegal Ulster Volunteer Force. 
 Government meets costs of &bquo;Spycatcher&equo; bookseller 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 A BOOKSELLER who sold thousands of copies of the banned book Spycatcher was awarded &pound;1,725 legal costs in the High Court yesterday after the Attorney General dropped contempt proceedings against him. 
 The case arose out of a letter sent by the Attorney General in the summer of 1988 to booksellers handling Spycatcher warning them they were in contempt of court, because an injunction had been obtained to stop publication of extracts of the book in several national newspapers. 
 All but a handful of booksellers agreed to sign a written undertaking not to sell the book, but Peter Marsh, 45, who owns Bilbo's in Bath, decided to take on the Government. 
 He said: &bquo;I was outraged they thought they could tell a bookseller what to do. 
 The big traders were so supine, they just caved in after one letter.&equo; 
 He said that only a couple of other booksellers in the country had been brave enough to ignore the letters. 
 The Government initiated proceedings against Mr Marsh in September last year, but after a lengthy delay while he unsuccessfully tried to obtain legal aid, the case was dropped because it was judged to be &bquo;no longer in the public interest&equo;. 
 The case against two other booksellers was also being dropped. 
 Mr Marsh was so incensed by the attempted prosecution that he took out a summons to obtain his costs, and yesterday at a brief hearing in the High Court the Attorney General agreed to pay his costs and not to take any further action on the matter. 
 Mr Marsh said: &bquo;I am happy that they have got egg on their face. 
 I have taken a stand for freedom against tyranny. 
 They could have sent me to prison for two years but that would have been political suicide.&equo; 
 The European Commission of Human Rights will rule today on whether a complaint by The Sunday Times, The Observer, and The Guardian that the UK broke freedom of expression guarantees during the Spycatcher affair can go ahead. 
 Speelman matches Timman's aggression 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 CHESS fans at Sadler's Wells for the Pilkington Glass World Championship semi-finals witnessed remarkable play yesterday with a draw in the Timman-Speelman game and Karpov set to win against Yusupov. 
 Timman started the game very aggressively. 
 Speelman responded with a vigorous counter-attack and the game dissolved into massive complications. 
 When Speelman seemed to be getting the better of it, Timman suddenly sacrificed two pieces to expose his opponent's king. 
 Speelman had to give up his queen to avoid being mated, but by that time he had so many pieces for it that he was still able to draw comfortably. 
 Timman leads in the match by 2-1. 
 The Yusupov-Karpov game was even more exciting, if full of inaccuracies. 
 Yusupov had prepared an unusual opening variation: taking only six minutes over the first 14 moves, while Karpov used almost an hour. 
 But things went Karpov's way when he found a move that had clearly been overlooked by Yusupov's analysts. 
 At move 40, Karpov seemed to have only a small advantage. 
 But by move 50 he seemed to have lost the thread of the game completely and his position was considerably worse. 
 Then it was Yusupov's turn to wilt under the strain. 
 Karpov bamboozled his opponent with a string of unexpected moves. 
 At move 59 Yusupov blundered. 
 The game was adjourned at move 60, but Yusupov's position now looks hopeless. 
 The game is scheduled to be resumed today. 
 Clarke &bquo;to blame for ambulance dispute&equo; 
 By ANDY GLINIECKI 
 AN AMBULANCE workers' union leader yesterday accused Kenneth Clarke, the Secretary of State for Health, of intransigence, as union officials prepared for today's meeting at Acas. 
 Roger Poole, the staff's chief negotiator, and a senior Nupe official, said: &bquo;Kenneth Clarke's refusal to talk proves conclusively who is responsible for the continuation of the dispute. 
 Mr Clarke knows how serious this dispute is but he is prepared to risk people's lives rather than talk.&equo; 
 He warned that if anyone was hurt in the dispute the minister would be &bquo;faced with calls for his resignation&equo;. 
 Mr Poole said there were signs that the Army was being put on standby to intervene in the three-week-old dispute. 
 He had received reports that army ambulances were being &bquo;spruced up&equo; at a Gloucestershire army depot. 
 But an army spokesman denied that it had been asked to prepare to intervene. 
 Union officials were due to meet the arbitration service, Acas, this morning for a briefing session. 
 They say they will abandon the dispute over the Government's refusal to raise a 6.5 per cent offer if both sides agree to binding arbitration. 
 During a debate on the dispute at the Labour Party Conference in Brighton yesterday, Steve Gazzard, an ambulance worker, said that by allowing arbitration, ministers would then &bquo;repay their debt&equo; to ambulancemen called in after the bombing during the Tory party conference which was held in the town in 1984. 
 Salesman led police to pregnant woman's body 
 By DAVID THOMAS 
 A SALESMAN turned detective and led police to the bloodstained body of the pregnant wife Marie Wilks, the M50 murder trial heard yesterday. 
 William Farrell had seen a Renault 25 car parked beside a crash barrier as he drove past. 
 When he heard of the disappearance of Mrs Wilks, 22, he drove back down the motorway and noted the marker post number where he saw the car. 
 Then he took two detectives to the Queenshill Bridge over the river Severn, Shrewsbury Crown Court was told on the third day of the trial. 
 Mr Farrell, of Ross-on-Wye, Hereford and Worcester, showed them where he saw the car parked and pointed out a skid mark on the hard shoulder. 
 &bquo;All three of us looked down the embankment and it became apparent there was a body there,&equo; he said. 
 Mackay is urged to clarify view on rights of audience 
 By ANDY GLINIECKI 
 Lord Mackay of Clashfern, the Lord Chancellor, was last night urged to clarify the government position on who should be allowed rights of audience in the higher courts. 
 Lord Alexander of Weedon QC, chairman of the Society of Conservative Lawyers, told the annual dinner of the Bar Association of Commerce, Finance and Industry that the Government should accept judges' views. 
 He said there was a danger acrimony created by the Green Papers would lead to a &bquo;legacy of distrust between the Government, judiciary and the profession&equo;. 
 He said the White Paper failed to indicate the Government's attitude to the judges' response to the Green Papers. 
 Judges indicated advocates in higher courts should be independent and not bound to partners practising in other areas or involved in preparing cases. 
 Advocacy should become their predominant activity. 
 Law: Why we must tame the state Leviathan: Greater use of judicial review would help people fight bad decisions by public bodies, Anthony Lester says 
 By ANTHONY LESTER 
 WHEN I began practice at the Bar 25 years ago, phrases such as &bquo;judicial review of administrative action&equo;, &bquo;public law&equo;, or &bquo;fundamental human rights and freedoms&equo; sounded strange to English judges and lawyers. 
 They described apparently alien, un-English ideas, taken from Continental or United States systems. 
 Successive generations of politicians, civil servants, judges and philosophers reared on a meagre intellectual diet of pragmatic utilitarianism and positivism had firmly rejected these ideas as a basis for ensuring constitutional government and citizens' rights. 
 For them, written constitutions, Bills of Rights, and a special system of administrative law regulating relations between government and the governed were exotic, inedible fruits of the American and French Revolutions. 
 According to the conventional British wisdom of the middle of the century, our flexible unwritten constitution, our democratic Parliament, the sense of fair play of our permanent civil service, and our vigorous and vigilant free Press were safer and more effective guarantees of personal freedom than a Continental or American-style &bquo;government of judges&equo;. 
 A quarter of a century later, the conventional wisdom of British mandarins looks complacent, self-serving, ill-informed, and outmoded &mdash; especially in the light of the many serious breaches by the United Kingdom of the European Convention on Human Rights. 
 The powers of British central government are greater than those enjoyed by any other democratic country of comparable size. 
 Between elections, a government with a sufficient parliamentary majority obedient to its will is absolute and omnipotent. 
 Because it is not subject to the paramount law of a written constitution, it can make or unmake any law as it chooses. 
 It can legislate arbitrarily to deprive groups of citizens of their basic rights or freedoms, to enlarge its own powers at the expense of local government, to weaken the ability of the media to inform the public, or to sap judicial independence. 
 It can do all these things without the possibility of legal challenge in our courts. 
 The common abuses of public power are not abuses by the sovereign parliament itself. 
 The more usual examples arise from the misuse by public officials of the powers delegated by Parliament to central or local government, or to the many other bodies exercising administrative powers. 
 Judicial review is the process by which the courts decide whether public bodies have acted within or beyond those powers. 
 When judges perform this essential constitutional role, their task is not to usurp the administrator's functions, nor to stultify good government by imposing legalistic requirements upon him. 
 The court's job is to ensure that the administrator has acted within the rule of law, and has not infringed civil rights and freedoms. 
 But there are significant handicaps facing the individual who wishes to apply for judicial review of the lawfulness of a public body's decision. 
 In the first place, unlike normal litigation between private parties, the applicant has to obtain the court's leave at the outset. 
 This gives the courts a useful power to separate the wheat from the chaff among the pending cases. 
 So long as there is a full right of appeal against a refusal of leave &mdash; a right which the present Government sought, at one stage, to abolish &mdash; this handicap is acceptable, even though it places public authorities in a more privileged position than the ordinary litigant. 
 A less acceptable handicap is the special rule that the application for judicial review must normally be made within only three months from the decision complained of. 
 It is in the public interest for challenges to the exercise of public powers to be made promptly, so that the administration and citizens alike know what the law is. 
 But it is unjust that the individual's right of access to the courts should be restricted solely on the ground that there has been delay in making the application. 
 As the Law Commission recommended in 1976, the test should be whether the granting of relief to an applicant who has delayed would cause substantial prejudice or hardship to any person or would be detrimental to good administration. 
 What is wholly unacceptable is the denial of justice to the great majority of citizens who are not poor enough to qualify for legal aid but not rich enough to risk the costs of litigating an important public law issue in the High Court, the Court of Appeal, and perhaps the House of Lords. 
 Successive governments have refused to implement the recommendation of the Evershed Committee in 1953 that the costs of going to law over issues of general public importance should be paid out of public funds. 
 As a result, many who are genuinely aggrieved by apparently unlawful decisions by government bodies and public officials are effectively denied access to justice. 
 The number of applications for judicial review has none the less increased significantly over the past decade. 
 The process is now used in all kinds of contexts: immigration, prisoners' rights, homelessness, the closure of hospitals or schools, access to local government information and, increasingly, commercial cases with a public law dimension. 
 The decisions of Margaret Thatcher's ministers are struck down by the courts as often as were those of the Wilson or Callaghan administrations. 
 Ministers and senior civil servants are not amused. 
 Recently, senior Whitehall officials considered whether it would be feasible to curb judicial review. 
 After discreet soundings, they prudently abandoned the idea, which would have involved a major encroachment upon judicial independence. 
 The danger is not that the courts will intervene too much, but too little. 
 With a burgeoning caseload, too few judges, and increasing delays the courts may be tempted to block the further development of the law and to cut back on the advances already made. 
 The recent High Court decision in the Rose Theatre case indicates a restrictive approach to what is a &bquo;sufficient interest&equo; to permit an application for judicial review. 
 If that approach prevails in the higher courts, it will amount to a major reverse, making it more difficult for the ordinary citizen to complain of unlawful action by a public authority. 
 In the Lonrho case, the Law Lords in effect decided that the Secretary of State had no duty to give reasons for his decision not to refer the takeover of Harrods by the Al-Fayeds to the Monopolies and Mergers Commission. 
 The law requires public authorities to be rational in making decisions. 
 In the absence of reasons, the citizen cannot know whether a decision has been rationally, and hence lawfully made. 
 Every independent committee of experts which has considered the subject has recognised the need to require public authorities to give reasons (the current position in Australia, Israel and the United States, as well as under European Community law). 
 It is regrettable that the House of Lords has not taken a similarly progressive approach. 
 This is not to undervalue the change in judicial thinking which has come about in the last 30 years. 
 From the First World War until the mid-Sixties, administrative &mdash; or &bquo;public&equo; &mdash; law scarcely existed beyond the pioneering textbooks of Stanley de Smith and Sir William Wade QC. 
 For 50 years, English judges had been unwilling to nullify government decisions. 
 In spite of the inexorable increase in the powers of the modern state, the judiciary had remained subservient: as executive-minded as the executive. 
 It had been a dark age for administrative justice. 
 Ministers and civil servants were naturally content to let the judges remain asleep. 
 Fortunately, they woke up. 
 Under the leadership of Lord Denning and Lord Reid, old common law principles of natural justice were given new content and value. 
 The judgments in notorious cases which had decided that there could be unfettered administrative discretion were repudiated. 
 Archaic restrictions on legal remedies were eliminated. 
 Understandably, the courts are more willing to review a decision because of the way in which it has been reached than because of its actual merits, or lack of them. 
 To hold that a procedure is unfair involves a less apparent interference with the administration than to hold that the actual decision was unreasonable. 
 But our system is defective because it lacks coherent principles for reviewing the substance of decisions. 
 A decision will not be held to be unlawful because it is &bquo;unreasonable&equo; in the ordinary, non-legal sense. 
 Whether a decision is so unreasonable as to be unlawful depends, in Lord Diplock's words, on whether it is &bquo;so outrageous in its defiance of logic or of accepted moral standards that no sensible person who has applied his mind to the question to be decided could have arrived at it&equo;. 
 A test which requires the judge to ask if the decision-maker has taken leave of his senses is too strict and is scarcely judicial. 
 The European Court of Human Rights and the European Court of Justice (and the Supreme Courts of Canada, India and the United States) apply more sophisticated and properly judicial standards when reviewing the merits of a decision. 
 They consider whether the aims of the decision-maker conflict with basic rights and freedoms, such as the right to equality, to liberty or to freedom of speech. 
 They also consider whether the means used are reasonably proportionate to the aims pursued: in European parlance, &bquo;the principle of proportionality&equo;. 
 It is this gap between &bquo;reasonableness&equo;, in the English legal sense, and &bquo;proportionality&equo; in the European sense, which leaves the United Kingdom particularly vulnerable before the European Court of Human Rights. 
 Again and again, the European Court has noted the narrowness of the English test for reviewing the merits of official decisions, and has gone on to find a breach of the convention by the UK. 
 Two appeals are pending against the High Court's failure to adopt proportionality as the appropriate standard for review. 
 In one case, Dr Colman, a registered medical practitioner was prevented by the Code of Conduct of the General Medical Council, from advertising the nature and availability of his practice in local newspapers. 
 Dr Colman argues that a blanket ban on all advertising is disproportionate to the council's legitimate aims. 
 The court said that to import proportionality would &bquo;create a monster that could quickly get out of control and cause widespread disruption of the many administrative processes that might attract its application&equo;. 
 In the second case, journalists are challenging the Government's ban on the broadcasting of words spoken by Sinn Fein supporters. 
 They argue that the ban is a disproportionate response to the mischief which the Home Secretary seeks to control, and is in breach of the right to free expression guaranteed by the European Human Rights Convention. 
 Once again, the Divisional Court refused to apply the criteria used by the European Court of Human Rights. 
 Whatever the outcome of those particular appeals (in which I should declare my professional interest as representative of both Dr Colman and the journalists) it seems inevitable that English courts, indirectly influenced by Europe, will eventually develop coherent constitutional and legal principles to review the substance of administrative decisions. 
 The principle of proportionality &mdash; do not use a sledgehammer to crack a nut &mdash; is straightforward logic. 
 And in the absence of a modern British Bill of Rights, the European Convention provides a convenient source of Lord Diplock's &bquo;accepted moral standards&equo; where fundamental rights and freedoms are at stake. 
 In this way we will move towards a fully developed system of public law which will better serve the interests of the state as well as of the citizen. 
 Law: The other side of the crime: Pat Healy on 10 years of progress by Victim Support, a national charity which has helped 1.5 million people 
 By PAT HEALY 
 VICTIM SUPPORT has come a long way from the six-month experiment set up 10 years ago by a group of concerned professionals in Bristol. 
 Now it is a national charity employing 20 people centrally and administering the work of 400 co-ordinators employed around the country. 
 Since the national association was formed, 1.5 million people have been referred to Victim Support. 
 Yesterday the Princess Royal addressed its tenth birthday meeting, attended by representatives of the Home Office, the police, and the probation service. 
 The organisation took root because the originators of the experiment were shocked at how little the victims of crimes knew about getting assistance, says Helen Reeves, director of Victim Support. 
 This included compensation, legal advice, financial and housing help, or even simply somebody to talk to. 
 That is still the case, says Ms Reeves. 
 &bquo;Ten years on, I am quite sure that the biggest issue we have uncovered is the issue of neglect,&equo; Ms Reeves says. 
 &bquo;Crime is bad enough. 
 But when you have to face up to the fact that no one wants to know and people are more interested in the apprehension and sentencing of the offender, that for many people is even worse than the original crime.&equo; 
 Not only are victims denied immediate help, they are subsequently kept in the dark by the police and courts about what is going on. 
 Unless they are called as witnesses, victims are often not told when a case is coming to court. 
 &bquo;There are tons of leaflets for offenders, but nothing for the witness or the ordinary member of the public,&equo; says Ms Reeves. 
 A former probation officer, she blames the way professionals are trained to see the criminal as the main concern, with justice for the victim &mdash; if thought about at all &mdash; regarded as an optional extra. 
 So victims feel isolated and ignored and find it difficult to talk about their experiences. 
 Their reactions can range from anger to irrational guilt, fear and embarrassment. 
 Their families and friends seldom know how to respond. 
 &bquo;People tend to ask how much they lost and whether or not they were insured. 
 But it doesn't seem to be an acceptable idea that something like burglary or a street crime can cause quite severe emotional disturbance.&equo; 
 The worse the violence, the less people want to talk about it. 
 Families where there has been a murder find that people are more reluctant to talk to them than if they had suffered an ordinary bereavement &mdash; sometimes even crossing the street to avoid them. 
 Victim Support's trained volunteers offer an immediate response when people are still in a state of shock, giving encouragement, support and information. 
 The organisation's original intention was to refer victims to another professional agency like social services, but that has proved impossible. 
 Ms Reeves explains: &bquo;With each of the really serious cases &mdash; rape, murder, racial harassment &mdash; there simply isn't anyone to refer people on to. 
 So we've had to do a lot of work ourselves, including researching carefully that we are doing something worthwhile.&equo; 
 This research influences the way volunteers work with victims but it is also passed on by Victim Support to other organisations that might find it useful: it provides an input into every police training course in Britain, and that has led to a potential new area of work. 
 Former police officers now doing security jobs in shops, banks and offices have begun to ask Victim Support to provide help for employees who have become victims of crime through robberies or other incidents at the workplace. 
 Next year, Victim Support will be publishing reports on projects covering child victims of crime, families of murder victims, racial harassment and high crime areas. 
 In January, it will launch a new court service, based on seven Crown courts in England, designed to establish the needs of victims and witnesses attending court. 
 The organisation is also considering how it should respond to increasing requests for help with victims of domestic violence. 
 &bquo;One of the biggest jobs we have got to do is to pass on what we have learned to the professions,&equo; says Ms Reeves. 
 &bquo;That certainly means lawyers, judges and magistrates, but also doctors and nurses, employers and school teachers. 
 I don't see the support of victims of crime as a separate service provided by a small specialist agency but as something which should be much more widely accepted like sickness or bereavement, so that people can get a more sensitive and understanding response from their employers, neighbours, doctors and so on.&equo; 
 Law: Always take along a friend to sue: Litigation can pay off even in the unlikeliest circumstances. 
 Stephen Gold explains 
 By STEPHEN GOLD 
 WHEN things go wrong you can sue more often than you may think. 
 Money may not have changed hands. 
 Someone may have even done you a favour. 
 It doesn't matter. 
 As long as you can show that they owed you a legal duty to be careful and have been negligent, damages could come your way. 
 There are a number of points to bear in mind. 
 Take up references before giving credit, lending money, letting in tenants, taking on staff. 
 Ask banks, building societies, former landlords, present and past employers. 
 If you rely to your detriment on a misleading reference which was given negligently, you should be able to sue the referee. 
 The subject of a bad reference can sue the referee for libel but has to show the referee was up to no good: spite, ill-will or some improper motive will do. 
 Take along a prosperous adviser on all shopping sprees, demonstrate a high degree of trust and strong reliance in what they say and you may have unexpected protection should the seller go out of business and the goods fall to pieces. 
 A 26-year-old woman accountant who knew nothing about the mechanical side of vehicles asked her more knowledgeable friend to find a car for her. 
 She stipulated that it must never have been involved in an accident. 
 The friend found one at a garage. 
 Although he failed to check it had been accident-free, he assured the lady that this was the case. 
 She bought it. 
 It had been in an accident and it was worthless. 
 In May last year the Court of Appeal upheld a judgment against the friend for more than &pound;5,500 damages for negligence because he had owed the accountant a duty of care. 
 Your conservatory collapses as a result of negligence of the professionals who were engaged by the previous owner to put it up. 
 You can sue the professionals &mdash; builders, architects, surveyors or engineers &mdash; by courtesy of the Defective Premises Act 1972, despite the fact that you never had a contract with them yourself. 
 There are strict time limits: generally, six years from when damage first occurred; where the damage was initially &bquo;latent&equo; you are given longer &mdash; three years from when you could have discovered it, with a longstop of 15 years. 
 It may also be possible to claim damages against a local authority for negligently failing to ensure that construction work complied with the relevant building regulations. 
 A solicitor fails to draw up a will within a reasonable time for a client who subsequently dies. 
 You lose the gift which the will would have made. 
 You can sue the solicitor for what you would have collected, had he done his job properly, because the law reckons he owed you, as well as his client, a duty of care. 
 When you want to borrow on a mortgage, the prospective lenders will have the property valued at your expense. 
 There is no contract between you and the valuer. 
 But if the valuer is negligent and you buy the property relying on his report, you may still be able to sue him for damages. 
 This is what the House of Lords decided in two cases last April in spite of an attempt to get the valuers off the hook by a disclaimer which said: &bquo;I accept that the valuer does not warrant anything stated in his report as being accurate&hellip; 
 &bquo;Alas, disclaimers may work if, for example, the property being valued is industrial or an expensive house. 
 Disclaimers may also be used by referees and others to rob you of a claim for damages. 
 Whoever attempts to hide behind a disclaimer must prove it is fair and reasonable to do so. 
 But a disclaimer can never take away your rights under the Defective Premises Act 1972 for the collapsing conservatory or prevent anyone being sued for negligence which has caused death or injury. 
 Have we yet reached the point at which we would be awarded damages against the Meteorological Office because we went camping on the day of an unforecast hurricane? 
 Or after we followed the duff advice of a legal journalist in a newspaper? 
 Mercifully, we doubt it! 
 CONFERENCES / Blackpool receives a blue rinse: Conservative Party highlights selected by Lesley Abdela 
 By LESLEY ABDELA 
 10,000 representatives, press and lobbyists will proceed to Blackpool for next week's Conservative conference which begins on Monday. 
 Since their poor vote in the June Euro-elections, the Conservatives have lagged well behind Labour in the polls. 
 Poll Tax, the Environment, the fate of the health service and the ITV licences sale will be some of the high profile issues on the agenda. 
 Shoals of bustling, professional lobbyists will be in Blackpool to make their voices heard. 
 These professional persuaders will spend an estimated two million pounds to bend the ears of the governing party. 
 Visitors are welcome to the fringe meetings at venues outside the Winter Gardens and Imperial Hotel. 
 The latter are open to pass holders only. 
 Events (below) in the Winter Gardens, unless otherwise stated. 
 JOLLIES The social life is a traditional ingredient of Conservative Party conferences &mdash; balls, receptions and parties abound, from a Lancashire hot-pot reception to Stinging Nettle And Fool's Parsley &mdash; an &bquo;Organic Revue&equo; with sketch by Conservative wit, Hornchurch MP Robin Squire, on winners and losers in the recent Cabinet reshuffle. 
 Info on &bquo;Stinging&equo;: 01-976 5711. 
 INNOVATION A creche from The Party of the Family. 
 For the first time there will be a creche for children of representatives at the Conservative conference. 
 Free. 
 Sponsored and operated by the World of Children Organisation. 
 CONFERENCE HOTSPOTS CHILDCARE Childcare Crisis Fringe meeting with John Patten MP. 
 The Leader of the Ministerial Group on Women leads discussion on the lack of affordable quality childcare available to working parents. 
 Pressure is mounting for tax allowances on childcare. 
 Organised by National Childcare Association, National Out of School Alliance, National Childcare Campaign, Childcare Now, Working Mother's Association, Gingerbread, Workplace Nurseries and Pre-School Playgroups Association. 
 Queen's Theatre Monday 5.30pm. 
 CENTRAL OFFICE An Assessment Of Central Office Performance Charter Movement &bquo;To whom does Central Office Account? 
 Is it too much the fief of the Leader?&equo; 
 The Conservative Party is the only major Party in British politics where the Party Chair, Vice Chair and Treasurer are appointed by the Leader. 
 Could be lively. 
 Expect lots of coded speeches. 
 Carlton Hotel Tuesday 5.30pm. 
 PARTY POLICY Debate on Policy and Organisation Motion 854 on behalf of Harwich Conservative Association proposed by Elizabeth Rex. 
 Chance for grass-roots to criticise presentation of health service policy, community charges, and the Party's June European election campaign. 
 Reply Speaker: Rt Hon Kenneth Baker MP. 
 Friday morning. 
 South Africa: International Freedom Foundation (UK). 
 Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi, George Gardner MP. 
 Tuesday 1pm Pembroke Hotel. 
 Europe Sir Leon Brittan, European Commissioner. 
 Bow Group. 
 Thursday 7pm Pembroke Hotel. 
 ENVIRONMENT 153 motions on the Environment and Planning have been submitted. 
 The main Environment debate (Wednesday) has been extended to two hours. 
 Our Environment &mdash; A Safe and Clean Future. 
 Virginia Bottomley MP, Parliamentary Under-Secretary for the Environment. 
 Conservative Women's National Committee. 
 Tuesday 12.45pm Blackpool Parish Church. 
 TORY REFORM GROUP TRG meetings are the traditional shop-window where aspiring Party Leaders display their wares: A Fourth Term &mdash; Why Re-elect the Tories? 
 Michael Heseltine MP. 
 Tuesday 1pm Grand Theatre. 
 East-West Relations Hon William Waldegrave MP. 
 Wednesday 1pm Grand Theatre. 
 HEALTH Health debate. 
 A sturdy 62 motions on Health have been submitted by Constituency Associations. 
 Reply speaker: Rt Hon Kenneth Clarke QC MP, Secretary of State for Health. 
 Tuesday 2.20pm. 
 Facing The Future &mdash; Health Care In The &bquo;90's Royal College of Nursing. 
 Christine Hancock, General Secretary of the RCN. 
 Rosalynde Lowe, Deputy General Secretary of the Health Visitors Association, Baroness Cox (herself a qualified nurse). 
 Thursday 12.45pm St John's Church, Cedar Square. 
 A Drug Free Environment Peter Lloyd MP, Junior Home Office Minister. 
 Conservative Women's National Committee. 
 Thursday lunch-time Cliffs Hotel. 
 WEDNESDAY Morning: Social Security and Pensions; Environment and Planning. 
 Afternoon: Law and Order; Education; Local Government and Community Charge. 
 NEW BOOKS Rt Hon John Biffen MP will be signing his new &bquo;everything you wanted to know about the proceedings of the House of Commons&equo; Guide. 
 Thursday afternoon CPC bookstall Julian Critchley MP The Palace Of Varieties has shot straight into the best-seller list. 
 Rt Hon Kenneth Baker MP Faber Book of English History in Verse, now in paperback. 
 A Tory Seer: Writings of TE Utley. 
 Edited by Simon Heffer of The Telegraph and Charles Moore of The Spectator. 
 Launch at The Spectator Party Thursday 10pm Imperial Hotel. 
 Press/passholders only. 
 Film News 
 By LESLEY ABDELA 
 London doesn't have a corner on film festivals: in Newcastle, the twelfth Tyneside Film Festival begins tomorrow &mdash; with free tickets for Independent readers. 
 The opening film, at 8.00, is Kenneth Branagh's much-hyped, much-praised Henry V. Between this, and the closing gala on 15 October (the equally hyped and praised new Peter Greenaway film The Cook, the Thief, his Wife and her Lover), the varied programme features previews of Jim Jarmusch's Mystery Train (Sun, 8.45); the spicey, very black high-school comedy Heathers (Tues, 6.15); and Bert Rigby, You're a Fool (Wed, 7.00), a comedy about musical comedies, starring Robert Lindsay. 
 Other highlights include mini-seasons of new Spanish cinema (for the fourth time at the Tyneside) and &bquo;blaxploitation&equo; films; plus a small Fellini retrospective. 
 We have two pairs of free tickets for the following screenings: The Rachel Papers, based on the novel by Martin Amis (Mon, 9.00); Scenes from the Class Struggle in Beverly Hills (Tues, 8.30), a farce about sexual imbroglio among the smart set of Bel Air, by Paul Bartel, the director of Eating Raoul; My Left Foot (Wed, 9.00), starring Daniel Day Lewis as disabled Irish writer Christy Brown; New York Stories (Thur, 8.30), the eagerly-awaited compendium film with vignettes by Scorsese, Coppola and Woody Allen; more tales from Manhattan in James Ivory's adaptation of Tama Janowitz's novel Slaves of New York (Fri, 8.30); Great Balls of Fire (next Sat, 8.45), in which Dennis Quaid pounds the ivories as Jerry Lee Lewis; and the closing gala of Greenaway's The Cook&hellip; (next Sun, 8.00). 
 To claim your goodies, you need to arrive at the box office after 10.00am on the date of the film you want to see, bearing a copy of that day's Independent. 
 More details from the Tyneside Cinema, 10 Pilgrim Street, Newcastle Upon Tyne (091-232 8289). 
 For dedicated Trekkies, this Sunday sees an unmissable event: the screening of all five Star Trek films, including the latest one, Star Trek V: The Final Frontier, directed by no less an authority than Captain James T. Kirk (William Shatner). 
 Lift-off is at 11.00am with Star Trek &mdash; the Movie, followed by Parts II, III IV and V; the programme will end at around 10.00. 
 Tickets for the whole event are on sale, price &pound;10.00, from the box-office of the Empire Leicester Square, and we have pairs of free tickets for the first five readers to arrive at the cinema on Sunday morning bearing a copy of The Independent. 
 If you can't make this date, Star Trek V opens on 20 Oct. 
 FILM / Wired 
 By LESLEY ABDELA 
 Though subtitled &bquo;the laughs and times of John Belushi&equo;, this ill-starred biopic is woefully short on the former component. 
 The story begins in a morgue, with Belushi (honourably played by Michael Chiklis), dead from drugs at 33, hopping off the slab to review his life with a guardian angel (Ray Sharkey). 
 This ill-advised conceit casts a pall on the piece from the outset, and it doesn't help that the skits (rewritten and reconstructed for copyright reasons) are crushingly unfunny. 
 But the trouble, you feel, lies with Belushi. 
 It may be that his gifts lay in the thrill and risk of live performance, losing their savour in aspic; or, more likely, that his genius was always overrated. 
 FILM / Play Me Something 
 By LESLEY ABDELA 
 In a small airport on a Hebridean island, a group of passengers await their plane. 
 A dapper stranger (John Berger) hoves into view and launches into a long, rather tedious yarn about two Italian peasants who meet at a Communist Party dance. 
 Timothy Neat directs tricksily, mixing colour and black-and-white, 35mm, 16mm and still photography, narrated and direct action; the aim is to reflect on different ways of telling stories. 
 But its insights rarely exceed the banal. 
 FILM / K-9 
 By LESLEY ABDELA 
 Yet another pair of mismatched cops, with the disposable novelty of one of them being a dog (James Belushi has the supporting role). 
 This tends to restrict opportunities for verbal sparring, and, with the mangy dialogue and Belushi's lack of manic spin, it seems the mutt has all the best lines. 
 This dog-eared plot premise will shortly resurface in Turner &amp; Hooch. 
 FILM / Henry V 
 By LESLEY ABDELA 
 It's astonishing that Shakespeare's Henry V should become, except at a time of national emergency, a resonant figure. 
 He has so few doubts, and his objectives are so suspect. 
 The England he represents is not so much irrelevant as antithetical to any modern image of Britain. 
 Nevertheless, Kenneth Branagh, actor, director and entrepreneur, has saddled up the old warhorse and given it new colours. 
 The film appears to query the notion of heroism in its battle scenes, muddy, bloody, in marked contrast to the sunny patriotism of Laurence Olivier's wartime version. 
 But it's ultimately about winning: Henry V offers Branagh, better than any other play in the repertoire, what might be called a yuppie dynamic, a mythology of success and entrepreneurial self-definition. 
 FILM / Cookie 
 By LESLEY ABDELA 
 This &bquo;mob comedy&equo; is an especial disappointment, for the credentials look promising on paper: it's directed by Susan Seidelman (Desperately Seeking Susan) and co-written by Nora Ephron (Silkwood, Heartburn). 
 The cast, too, is strong, but Emily Lloyd (Wish You Were Here), issued with a thick Brooklyn accent, is charmless in the Madonna role, as Peter Falk's sassy, streetwise daughter. 
 Dianne Wiest has her moments, though, as a fluffy gangster's moll with claws of steel. 
 FILM / Ariel 
 By LESLEY ABDELA 
 This is the first of Finnish director Aki Kaurismaki's films to open here, but not the last: two more are lining up for release in the next six months. 
 It betokens a substantial talent. 
 In it, a miner who has been made redundant heads south to Helsinki and falls in love. 
 Dispensing with longueurs (the film runs 74 minutes, B-movie length), Kaurismaki traces the man's unsuccessful search for work and inevitable lapse into petty crime with clipped, deadpan comedy. 
 The cool narrative economy and unforced style recall early Fassbinder. 
 And, while none of the industrial townscapes could be described as pretty, he has a terrific eye. 
 FILM / A-Z of films for the capital: The programme of the 33rd London Film Festival was announced this week: We give complete details and Owen Slot picks out some of the highlights 
 By OWEN SLOT 
 In the space of sixteen days from 10 November, the London Film Festival will show some 170 films. 
 Such a huge number might appear to be excessive but Sheila Whitaker, the Festival Director, assures film-goers that the quality never wavers. 
 &bquo;While there are good films, they should be screened,&equo; she says, describing the festival as an &bquo;embarrassment of riches&equo;. 
 Top of the bill is a run of London premieres in Leicester Square cinemas beginning with Parenthood, a comedy with Steve Martin. 
 Other highlights include Field Of Dreams, another American baseball movie, this time starring Kevin Costner; A Dry White Season, Marlon Brando's long-awaited comeback; Last Exit To Brooklyn, a portrait of city low-life, based on the controversial banned novel and directed by Uli Edel of Christiane F fame; a good selection of American independent cinema and new films from Africa, Asia and Latin America. 
 The annual &bquo;Thames Silent&equo; features the classic Harold Lloyd comedy, Safety Last. 
 Thu 9, Fri 10 7.45 Dominion Safety Last Classic Harold Lloyd vehicle, with new score by Carl Davis, who will conduct Live Cinema Orchestra. 
 Fri 10 8.00 Empire Parenthood Ron Howard's comedy with Steve Martin as a beleaguered father. 
 Sat 11 10.30am NFT2 Making of a Legend: Gone With The Wind David Hinton's behind the scenes look at &bquo;the moviest of all movies&equo;; 10.45am NFT1 The Music Teacher Belgian portrait of a distinguished opera singer; 1.00 NFT1 Fellow Traveller Philip Saville's intriguing picture of two Hollywood friends victimised under MacCarthyism; 1.15 NFT2 Journeys Inland Documentary on the Swiss; 3.30 NFT1 Icicle Thief Italian parody on the confusion between films and commercials; 3.45 NFT2 Malpractice Australian account of medical malpractice; 6.15 NFT1 The Woman From Rose Hill Alain Tanner's examination of Swiss mores; 6.30 NFT2 Where The Sun Beats Joaquim Pinto's restrained dissection of a Portuguese land-owning family; 7.45 Dominion Safety Last See above; 8.45 NFT1 Too Beautiful For You! 
 Gerard Depardieu in unorthodox love triangle; 8.45 NFT2 James Baldwin: The Price Of The Ticket Karen Thorsen's tribute to the black writer; 8.30 MOMI Motorist/3 Cars Auto-culture. 
 Sat 25 11.00am NFT1 Waller's Last Walk Christian Wagner's elegiac treatment of an eldery railway inspector's life; 10.45am NFT2 In Fading Light Gripping docu-drama on the dying North Shields fishing industry; 11.00am Curzon West End Romuald and Juliette Coline Serreau's comedy about an affair between an exec and his black cleaner; 11.00am Screen on Green Island Paul Cox's elegant three-hander; 2.15 NFT1 Guardian/AIP Seminar; 1.15 NFT2 Martha Jellneck Kai Wessell's story of an old woman's relationship with her meals-on-wheels deliverer; 3.15 NFT2 I Am Living Portrait of contemporary Indian women; 4.30 NFT1 The Thief of Bagdad Restored version of Korda's sumptuous Arabian Knights fantasy; 5.45 NFT2 I Went to The Dance Documentary by Les Blank on the Cajun music of Louisiana; 7.30 LFMC Programme 7: Interior Monologues; 9.00 NFT1 The Kill-Off Maggie Greenwald's look at a sleazy East Coast seaside resort; 8.30 NFT2 Oranges Are Not the Only Fruit Beeban Kidron's interpretation of Jeanette Winterson's autobiographical first novel, with Geraldine McEwan; 8.45 MOMI Smoking Mirror Funereal British comedy, with Beatie Edney; 11.15 Rio Chicken and Duck Talk See above. 
 Football: League facing chief failure 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 THE Football League's attempts to bring their 14-month search for a chief executive to an early conclusion by choosing between Gordon Taylor of the Professional Footballers' Association and Arthur Sandford, chief executive of Nottinghamshire county council, look destined to fail. 
 The League's management committee has decided to invite the two candidates it agreed upon on Monday for interview, but the head-hunting process which has caused so much vexation is threatening the ultimate embarrassment. 
 Both men are unhappy about the maladroit way the matter has been handled, and are in the mood to refuse to be interviewed. 
 Sandford, a lawyer before becoming the youngest chief executive in local government, was upset when his name was leaked to the press, and Taylor is incensed to find himself suddenly only a contender for a job to which he was appointed by the League's president, Bill Fox, in August. 
 &bquo;I did not ask for the job &mdash; it was offered to me,&equo; Taylor said. 
 &bquo;I am not willing to be interviewed only to be compared with the chief executive of some Midlands council. 
 In August I had a job, now I am on a shortlist. 
 Perhaps in another month or so I will find I am one among 50 runners for the job.&equo; 
 Three First Division members of the management committee John Smith of Liverpool, Aston Villa's Doug Ellis and Robert Chase of Norwich City &mdash; are known to favour Sandford as a new broom from outside football. 
 The rest of the committee support Taylor, and are suspicious of the motives of the men they have dubbed &bquo;the gang of three&equo;. 
 They believe an outsider, untouched by the game's traditions, would be more receptive to the blandishments of the Super Leaguers. 
 The management committee is also to beef up the criteria to be met by new members of the League. 
 The intention is to close the loophole which allowed Maidstone United to be admitted to the Fourth Division without a home of their own. 
 Their ground-sharing scheme with non-League Dartford would not be acceptable under the proposed changes. 
 Bill Fox and Michael Sinclair of York, who represent the associate members of the lower divisions on the management committee, are to meet officers of the GM Vauxhall Conference next Thursday to outline the League's new requirements. 
 Rugby League: Harmon is kept off list 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 (First Edition) WARRINGTON have turned down a transfer request from Neil Harmon, their 21-year-old prop forward. 
 Harmon asked for a move after losing his first-team place to Bob Jackson, an Australian in his second spell at Wilderspool, but Oldham and St Helens will be among teams disappointed to learn that Warrington do not intend to list him. 
 Eric Latham, the new chairman of St Helens, has promised money will be found to sign new players. 
 &bquo;We have the nucleus of a good team, but money will be available to buy the right players,&equo; he said. 
 Latham, aged 57, succeeds Joe Pickavance, who stepped down from the Knowsley Road chair a week ago for health reasons. 
 Hull, who picked up their first win of the season against Leeds on Sunday, will take an unchanged side to unbeaten Warrington on Sunday, with the Australian Test forward, Noel Cleal, again appearing at centre. 
 Peter Williams, the Salford centre, has been told that the shoulder injury which has kept him out for much of this season will need at least another week to heal. 
 Tony Myler, the Widnes stand-off who was injured in the World Club Challenge against Canberra, is doubtful for Sunday's rather more prosaic fixture at Sheffield Eagles. 
 Dean Bell will captain his side, Wigan, against his country, New Zealand, on Sunday, knowing he is playing for a Test place. 
 Bell opted out of the tour, but declared himself available for internationals, and can expect extra attention on Sunday from the Kiwi centres. 
 &bquo;I'm available for Test selection, but that doesn't mean I'll necessarily be picked,&equo; the former Kiwi World Cup captain said. 
 &bquo;New Zealand will regard their match against Wigan as a &bquo;fourth Test&equo;. 
 They are bound to put out their strongest side.&equo; 
 Football: Edwards takes legal action against Knighton 
 By FRANK KANE and DEREK HODGSON 
 MICHAEL KNIGHTON'S faltering attempt to take over Manchester United looked in deep trouble last night after Martin Edwards, United's controlling shareholder, began legal procedings against 37-year-old Knighton for alleged breach of confidentiality. 
 Edwards agreed last month to sell his stake of 51 per cent of the company's shares to Knighton for &pound;10m, but that deal would be scuppered if a court rules in favour of Edwards. 
 His lawyers yesterday applied to the Manchester High Court for an injunction to halt the use of confidential information. 
 The hearing has been adjourned until next week. 
 Edwards declined to comment after a lengthy board meeting at Old Trafford, but it is believed the information in question related to players' contracts and salaries, as well as other financial information about the club. 
 Last night, United announced that Edwards was taking leading counsels' advice as to the validity of his agreement with Knighton. 
 Knighton has been in contact with several businessmen from the Manchester area in attempts to get wider backing for his &pound;20m bid, which has hit financial snags. 
 One of them, Eddy Shah, the former national newspaper owner, said he was no longer interested in a deal with Knighton, but another, Owen Oyston, a local radio-station owner and property entrepreneur, applied to the Football League for permission to obtain a financial interest in United. 
 That could mean another football club gets involved in the United wheeler-dealing. 
 Oyston is also chairman and owner of Blackpool Football Club, and is seeking the permission of the League to waive their rule that no one may hold more than 10 per cent of a club if he has a financial interest in another. 
 He said: &bquo;I have been involved in detailed talks with Michael Knighton for several days. 
 I have made it absolutely clear from the outset that I would not in any circumstances give up my family's present interest in Blackpool FC. 
 He fully understood my commitment, our discussions have taken place with that clearly understood. 
 &bquo;I have also discussed the situation with the Football League and put the full facts to them and they have given me clear advice. 
 &bquo;I have spoken to Mr Knighton this morning and we are discussing a formula which will enable me to give financial support to Manchester United.&equo; 
 Friends of Oyston believe this would involve the transfer of his controlling stake in Blackpool to his wife Vicky. 
 Knighton is publicly sticking to the line that his offer will proceed, and that a package is being put together, but he admitted yesterday: &bquo;Time is getting short.&equo; 
 Close friends said last night that he was worried about the apparent legal bust-up with Edwards. 
 Knighton was consulting his lawyers in Scotland. 
 The in-fighting on the United board has reached an intense pitch, with several incumbent directors jockeying for position as the Knighton deal looks increasingly likely to fail. 
 Amer Midani, the Lebanese-born businessman and United director who has a 15 per cent stake, seems to be in the strongest position to take over if Knighton's bid falls through. 
 In Manchester, there was open speculation that Bobby Charlton, probably the most famous player in United's history and also a director, was being lined up to take over the chairmanship after a Midani bid. 
 Midani has the support of another director, Nigel Burrows, who has been outspoken in his criticism of Knighton and the chaos at the club. 
 The Manchester Evening News published details of a document claimed to be the financial presentation made on behalf of Knighton to secure a loan from the Bank of Scotland. 
 It shows Knighton's worth as between &pound;3.2m and &pound;12.4m, with the main asset the St David's Preparatory School in Huddersfield, with a value of &pound;2m to &pound;5m. 
 There is also an art collection, currently being valued by art auctioneers Christie's, with a reported value of between &pound;450,000 and &pound;1.5m. 
 In Edinburgh, sources in the financial community said the reason Knighton is having trouble raising the cash for a bid is that the assets are &bquo;Illiquid&equo; -they could not be easily sold for cash. 
 &bquo;It would take months to sell off all that lot, especially the way the market is now,&equo; a merchant banker said. 
 The offer of a loan of &pound;20m to complete the United deal was also conditional on Knighton submitting a full statement of his assets and liabilities and full audited accounts from his companies. 
 His friends have also suggested that he would be willing to sell on a stake in MK Trafford Holdings, the Isle of Man-based company through which the bid is being made, in order to raise cash for the deal. 
 In London, the City Panel of Takeovers and Mergers said it was following the situation. 
 While the possibility of a court injunction did not in itself upset the takeover schedule, the panel would still expect a formal takeover document. 
 Football: Ajax thrown out of Europe 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY, Football Correspondent 
 AJAX have joined all English clubs in exile from European competition. 
 The Dutch club, who won the Champions' Cup three times in the early Seventies, were banned yesterday for at least two years as a result of crowd trouble that caused the abandonment of their UEFA Cup match against Austria Vienna in Amsterdam nine days ago. 
 The second leg was in extra time when the Austrians took a 2-1 lead on aggregate. 
 Within minutes, the Austrian goalkeeper, Franz Wohlfahrt, was being pelted with missiles, including 5ft iron bars torn from the perimeter fence, one of which appeared to hit him on the back. 
 The Swiss referee, Bruno Galler, had little choice but to call the teams off. 
 Five people were later arrested. 
 A UEFA disciplinary commission met yesterday to consider reports from Galler and the official match observer. 
 It was decided that Ajax should forfeit the tie and thereafter be excluded from European competition for the next two seasons for which they qualify. 
 The club's chairman, Michael Van Praag, who was not invited into the hearing, said that Ajax would accept the forfeit but appeal against the ban in Geneva next Friday. 
 He said: &bquo;We have very good arguments to prove that we cannot be held responsible for the actions of a few people who did not know what they were doing. 
 Security was more than 100 per cent. 
 There was a body check of every spectator.&equo; 
 All of that may be so. 
 But once the principle is established that clubs, however innocent, can be punished to protect the public or players, it is no longer a matter of pure justice. 
 UEFA is unlikely to reduce a punishment apparently designed to make the Dutch authorities, civil as well as sporting, take hooliganism as seriously as the British have been obliged to. 
 Of course the Amsterdam incident was less grave than the Heysel disaster, which cost 39 lives and caused all English clubs to be suspended indefinitely. 
 But, as Galler said, the iron bars were &bquo;life-threatening&equo;. 
 Hooliganism involving Dutch supporters has become so frequent as to suggest that another blanket ban of a nation's clubs might be necessary. 
 This is the first time UEFA has banned a Dutch club, but two years ago the national team were ordered to replay a European Championship qualifying match behind closed doors after Cyprus's goalkeeper had been struck by a firework. 
 Only last month the FA took Government advice to withdraw England from a planned friendly in Rotterdam in December. 
 Meanwhile riots continue to scar the Dutch League; one match was abandoned recently in Rotterdam. 
 The Ajax case emphasises the danger to players, especially goalkeepers. 
 Two years ago there was a similar, arguably worse, incident in Madrid when Real supporters threw sharp metal rods from behind a goal at the Bernabeu, narrowly missing Bayern Munich's keeper, Jean-Marie Pfaff. 
 He could have been killed. 
 Real's punishment was to play subsequent matches behind closed doors. 
 Perhaps the Austria Vienna spokesman, Peter Mueller, had this in mind when he said yesterday: &bquo;Compared with previous UEFA decisions in similar cases, Ajax's punishment is very harsh.&equo; 
 It opens the possibility, if there are repetitions, of the further denuding of European competition; five former champions of the continent &mdash; Liverpool, Aston Villa, Nottingham Forest, Manchester United and Ajax &mdash; are now banned. 
 But who can blame UEFA, post-Heysel, for coming down on the side of life and limb before either is lost? 
 Ice Skating: Suzanne Otterson at the Skate Electric UK International at Richmond 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY, Football Correspondent 
 Suzanne Otterson, 15, shows her free style at the Skate Electric UK International at Richmond last night. 
 Otterson finished seventh behind the American Tonia Kwiatkowski  
 Football: Barnes on hold 
 By HENRY WINTER 
 JOHN BARNES, the England winger struggling with a hamstring injury, stayed in Liverpool yesterday as Bobby Robson's squad met up in Buckinghamshire to fine-tune their final plans for next Wednesday's World Cup qualifying game in Poland. 
 Robson, who will contact Kenny Dalglish today for an update on Barnes, said: &bquo;Kenny has phoned me a couple of times and has told me that Barnes has done some training this week. 
 Kenny is non-committal, but I'm quite hopeful.&equo; 
 Barnes is not the only worry for Robson. 
 Barnes's club-mate Steve McMahon has a problem with his ankle and the forceful midfielder joined the Tottenham pair of Gary Lineker (knee) and Paul Gascoigne (calf) in the trip to Fred Street's physio bench yesterday. 
 Like Robson, Andy Roxburgh, the Scotland coach, has injury concerns, principally over his gifted midfielder, Paul McStay, who is troubled by groin and hamstring strains. 
 One Scotsman looking forward to Rome is David Will, who will take over from Harry Cavan as vice-president of FIFA when the Irishman retires during the World Cup next June. 
 Two strikers left Northampton Town yesterday, Tony Adcock joining Bradford City for &pound;190,000 and Paul Culpin moving to Peterborough United for &pound;40,000. 
 Brendan Ormsby's transfer from Leeds United to Cardiff City was called off yesterday after the defender decided he did not want to play in the Third Division. 
 Motor Racing: Verdict on Mansell &bquo;too harsh&equo; 
 By MAURICE HAMILTON 
 NIGEL MANSELL last night emerged the moral victor in his battle with the International Automobile Federation (FIA) even though an appeal court in Paris had not rescinded the decision to ban the Englishman from last Sunday's Spanish Grand Prix. 
 But the three-man tribunal of legal experts from France, Greece and The Netherlands did admit that the punishment had been too harsh and that there were mitigating circumstances. 
 A brief statement by the FIA said that there would be no decision until an appeal filed by Ferrari in a Portuguese civil court against a &dollar;50,000 fine &mdash; but not the ban &mdash; had been heard. 
 The FIA tribunal wished to consider the matter further and a final decision is not expected until the end of the month at the earliest. 
 In the meantime, the ban and the fine remain. 
 Mansell said last night that he was relieved. 
 &bquo;At least there is justice,&equo; he said after flying back to his home on the Isle of Man. 
 &bquo;Obviously, I don't want to say any more until we have the final verdict.&equo; 
 Mansell was penalised for failing to stop during the Portuguese Grand Prix and he threatened to quit if FISA, the sport's governing body, did not remove the ban. 
 Now that the Spanish race has been and gone, it is a matter of clearing Mansell's name and it would seem that the evidence offered gave the court food for thought. 
 The Englishman arrived at the FIA headquarters in Place de la Concorde yesterday morning accompanied by his manager, Mike Francis, the Ferrari team manager, Cesare Fiorio, the team's lawyer, Henry Peter, and a representative of the Italian Automobile Federation, Fabrizio Serena. 
 Ferrari also brought along Giacomo Modugno, an Italian Olympic Committee medical commission member who, as an eye specialist, was prepared to give evidence about Mansell's difficulty in seeing the flag signal ordering him to stop. 
 Modugno said it would have been almost impossible for Mansell to see the flag while following closely behind the McLaren-Honda of Ayrton Senna. 
 Mansell was shown the black flag three times after being disqualified for reversing his Ferrari after overshooting his pit during a scheduled stop to change tyres. 
 He and Senna then collided, putting both drivers out of the race. 
 Ferrari argued that proper procedures had not been followed in Portugal and that Mansell had been unable to hear the instructions on his radio as he travelled at 170 mph past the pits. 
 When the latest decision became known last night, Peter said that it was encouraging for Mansell, the Ferrari lawyer pointing out that this was the first time that the FIA had not confirmed a decision. 
 &bquo;I have the impression that, for the FIA, the penalty is too heavy for the supposed offence,&equo; Peter said. 
 If the tribunal upholds the appeal, then last Sunday's race, won by Senna, would be annulled. 
 That would automatically rule Senna out of the championship, even if he wins the final two races in Japan and Australia and the title would go to his team-mate, Alain Prost. 
 For that reason, the result of the appeal may not be made known until after the last race on 5 November. 
 And if it meant that Senna were to lose the championship, then the legal ramifications would be far-reaching. 
 Equestrianism: Turi has a Vital victory 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY at Wembley 
 JOE TURI defied a difficult draw &mdash; first to go in an eight-horse jump-off - to win yesterday evening's Modern Alarms Cup at The Horse of the Year Show on Country Classics Vital. 
 John Whitaker came closest to him, just 0.8 of a second behind on Next Milton, with David Broome a whisker behind on Queensway Lannegan. 
 &bquo;I thought I'd be beaten,&equo; Turi said, &bquo;but I began to realise I'd chosen the right route by not cutting inside fences. 
 It meant that we could keep moving forward and keep our rhythm.&equo; 
 The former Hungarian trick-rider, who has had some nostalgic moments watching members of his old troupe performing here this week, was also helped by the cautious approach of some of his opponents. 
 John Whitaker was anxious to qualify for tonight's Next International Masters and the Dutch rider, Jos Lansink, had an even more obvious reason for abandoning speed in favour of accuracy when jumping a slow clear round to be be fourth on Optiebeurs Felix. 
 Lansink is the only rider who has jumped double clear rounds in the first four contests designated for the Everest Challenge. 
 If he wins tomorrow's Grand Prix, he will be rewarded with a Jaguar car. 
 Only nine horses contested last night's Puissance but, though the big red wall at 6ft 11in was short of record height, it reached a sporting climax. 
 Both Tim Stockdale, on Supermarket, and Michael Whitaker, on Next Didi, cleared the wall at that height at the second attempt and chose to divide the honours. 
 Rugby League: Halifax draw satisfaction 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 Halifax............ 16 Bradford Northern.. 16 HALIFAX have maintained an impressive following since their relegation, so a full house for their Yorkshire Cup semi-final last night was no surprise. 
 An air of anticipation was less familiar, but Halifax exceeded all expectations by mounting a thrilling recovery, coming back from 16-4 down to earn a replay. 
 Had John Dorahy not rashly attempted a dropped goal on the first tackle in the closing stages, the Second Division side might have found themselves in the final. 
 With three of last season's Halifax dissidents representing Bradford, and the famously short-fused Brendan Hill facing his former club, a small corner of Calderdale was positively incandescent. 
 The opening quarter contained several meaty exchanges between the forwards which only the referee, Gerry Kershaw, appeared unaware of but tempers remained mercifully in check. 
 Les Holliday, with some intelligent distribution and accurate touch finding, established a measure of early control for the home side, who took the lead through Wilf George, after David Holmes had worked diligently to set up the chance. 
 Northern's larger, faster pack made ever greater inroads. 
 David Hobbs kicked a penalty after Kelvin Skerrett was illegally halted, then when Skerrett was held on the line, Karl Fairbank and Hobbs kept the ball alive for Steve McGowan to give the visitors a 6-4 interval lead. 
 Hill was substituted in the 55th minute, too late to prevent Halifax going further behind. 
 Holmes lost a scrum on his own 25, and before the defence could regroup Paul Medley, another player returning to Thrum Hall, stepped out of three tackles to score by the posts. 
 With Skerrett and his impressive front-row partner John Hamer now breaking almost unopposed, Bradford looked safe when Ian Wilkinson scored a third try. 
 But Anderson, consistently Halifax's best attacker, pulled one back for the home side 10 minutes from time, and two minutes later put Steve Smith joyously into the right corner, Dorahy equalising from the touchline. 
 WIGAN, the trophy holders, lost 19-18 to Oldham, of the Second Division, in the semi-finals of the Lancashire Cup. 
 Oldham won with a 35-yard goal from Gary Hyde with four minutes remaining. 
 Rugby Union: Sunday must be special 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 THIS MONTH Rugby Special returns to our screens. 
 The programme should have been broadcast for most of last month as well. 
 Rugby supporters, who are as much licence-payers as are aficionados of ballroom dancing, have, I think, been short-changed. 
 Up to last year it would have been justifiable not to show rugby until October. 
 Apart from some of the traditional Anglo-Welsh fixtures, such as Harlequins v Llanelli at Twickenham (played this year at Stradey Park), the calendar contained little that was required watching. 
 Other hallowed encounters which I enjoyed, such as London Irish v Bedford, were for diversion merely. 
 This year things have changed. 
 Two league Saturdays have already come and gone. 
 For myself, middle-aged and of a generally conservative disposition, I regret these changes, in particular the depreciation of the Anglo-Welsh occasions: not only because there are fewer of them but also because the clubs now tend to field their second XVs. 
 Nevertheless, I recognise this as sentimentality. 
 The rugby season proper now begins in September. 
 The BBC cameras should have been there, with the high priest Chris Rea and his acolyte Nigel Starmer-Smith in attendance. 
 We should have been shown excerpts from Wasps v Leicester and Gloucester v Bath, not to mention Neath v Bath; though the niggly Harlequins v Wasps match would have put the indulgent enthusiasm even of Starmer-Smith under some strain. 
 In fact we will be shown extracts from Gloucester v Bath once the programme gets going: but that is not quite the same thing. 
 The explanation for the delayed start is that the Rugby Union and the BBC agreed not to make Rugby Special overlap with Sunday Grandstand. 
 But why, in that case, could not some rugby have been shown on the Grandstand programme? 
 One sub-explanation is that there were not enough cameras and technicians to go round; though, as I say, the Gloucester v Bath match was recorded. 
 Next season the RU and the BBC must serve the fans better. 
 Having said this, I go on to welcome the show. 
 Last season it improved by, I should say, 50 per cent. 
 There is still no clarity about what sort of programme it is meant to be: but, to begin with, this is no bad thing. 
 Two or three seasons ago it concentrated on excerpts (including at least two showings a season of the dreaded encounter between Hawick v Gala). 
 These were followed or interspersed by a windswept Starmer-Smith standing on the touchline, microphone in hand, sporting a selection from his extensive wardrobe of scarves and neckties, and promising delights which were sure to come next week but which had unaccountably failed to materialise this week. 
 Last season the programme diversified. 
 There was a surrealist episode involved a gnarled coach, an attractive young woman who was trying to be a hooker (rugby variety) and a small boy who wanted to be a scrum-half. 
 There is certainly room for a programme on coaching and basic skills, but Rugby Special is not it. 
 There is room on the programme for a short weekly or monthly item on the laws and their interpretation. 
 Referees should be used more often. 
 TV commentators often assert confidently that a try has been awarded after a tackle just short of the line because the player's &bquo;momentum&equo; took him over. 
 Yet this is nowhere mentioned in the laws. 
 What the programme should do now, however, is concentrate more on the politics of rugby: both the internal politics of the game itself (which are omnipresent) and the politics of the game in relation to the outside world. 
 This demands a studio on a Sunday rather than a rainy, muddy field on a Saturday. 
 It also demands interviewers, of the calibre not perhaps of Brian Walden or Sir Robin Day but, say, of the Dimbleby brothers. 
 Ian Robertson and Rea are both of them knowledgeable and accomplished enough to make their living in political and current affairs television, if they wanted to. 
 Instead they devote their talents to sport, especially rugby. 
 They ought to be examining and cross-examining Dudley Wood, Clive Rowlands, Rhys Williams and Terry Vaux. 
 Their abilities are being not exactly wasted, but certainly under-used. 
 One thing I regret: the jettisoning of the original signature tune. 
 It was silly but it was catchy, and children loved it, which is always the sign of a good tune. 
 Bring it back. 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Table Tennis 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Speedway 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Shooting 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Rugby League 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Motor Cycling 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 THE Auto Cycle Council of Australia has threatened legal action over plans to move the Australian Grand Prix from Phillip Island to Sydney. 
 The ACCA refuses to sanction the event at any other location, and Sydney, despite claiming rights to stage the race for the next four years, has yet to build a Grand Prix circuit. 
 Sport in Short: Judo 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Ice Skating 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 SWEDEN is to prevent entries to its two European Tour events from players who play on this winter's Sunshine Tour in South Africa. 
 Sport in Short: Football 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 MARCO VAN BASTEN, in his first appearance since a cartilage operation last month, scored a first-half hat trick as AC Milan beat Pro Patria 6-0 in a friendly last night. 
 ZENITH DATA SYSTEMS CUP First-round draw: Northern section: Sheffield United v Wolverhampton Wanderers; Leeds United v Blackburn Rovers; Sunderland v Port Vale. 
 Southern section: Coventry City v Wimbledon; Oxford United v Luton Town. 
 Ties to be played week beginning 6 November. 
 Second-round draw: Northern section: Sheffield Wednesday v Sheffield United or Wolverhampton Wanderers; Stoke City v Bradford City; Hull City v Aston Villa; Newcastle United v Oldham Athletic; Barnsley v Leeds United or Blackburn Rovers; West Bromwich Albion v Derby County; Middlesbrough v Sunderland or Port Vale; Nottingham Forest v Manchester City. 
 Southern section: Swindon Town v Millwall; West Ham United v Plymouth Argyle; Ipswich Town v Watford; Crystal Palace v Oxford United or Luton Town; Portsmouth v Coventry City or Wimbledon; Norwich City v Brighton and Hove Albion; AFC Bournemouth v Chelsea; Charlton Athletic v Leicester City. 
 Ties to be played week beginning 29 November. 
 Sport in Short: Equestrianism 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Cycling 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Cricket 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 PETER SUCH, the 25-year-old off-spinner, has been released by Leicestershire and may join Essex. 
 TREVOR HOHNS, the Queensland leg-spinner and member of Australia's Ashes-winning side this summer, is to retire. 
 Hohns, aged 35, made his state debut in 1972, and played in seven Test matches. 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Basketball 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Baseball 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Badminton 
 Sport Page 31 
 Boxing: Mason's apprenticeship in yearning and learning: Lawless looks to future after his quick-witted student passes test: Ken Jones reports on the dreams and doubts that follow another successful step by an amiable giant 
 By KEN JONES 
 FROM the moment that Gary Mason announced his amiable presence at a gymnasium in London's East End yesterday it was pleasingly evident that few fighters have been less inclined to flinch from the truth. 
 The truth as observed at the Royal Albert Hall on Wednesday is that it would be exceedingly foolish for admirers to think of Mason as better than a developing apprentice in a punishing trade. 
 This has sensibly not escaped the British heavyweight champion; so for all the understandable excitement felt when knocking out Tyrell Biggs in the seventh round, by far the most important of 32 consecutive victories he has achieved since turning professional in 1984, he was not reluctant to focus on the flaws. 
 &bquo;I'm still learning this business,&equo; he said. 
 Mason occupied two spaces on a tier of seats normally reserved for visitors to his manager's gymnasium above the Royal Oak, a grimy Victorian watering hole in Canning Town. 
 He wore a luridly decorated black tracksuit and a broad smile. 
 &bquo;Did anyone speak to Biggs after the fight?&equo; he asked. 
 The question centred on whatever impressions the American had gained from a discouraging experience, another failed attempt to resurrect a career that was seriously undermined by the beating he took from Mike Tyson two years ago. 
 Biggs is of the opinion that Mason would be unlikely to survive more than a couple of rounds against the world heavyweight champion and at this stage it would be unwise to even think of him as a genuine contender. 
 &bquo;I would like Gary to have another fight this year (there is a Wembley date available) and we are looking at people in a similar class to Biggs,&equo; Terry Lawless said. 
 In time Lawless may be confronted by an obvious dilemma, the possibility that his two heavyweights, Mason and Frank Bruno, will be tempted into profitable confrontation, the suggestion being that they could come together some time next summer. 
 Lawless prefers to concentrate on further shaping Mason's career, encouraged by his quick-witted responses to tuition and the enthusiasm that has developed from greater recognition. 
 Mason weighed in at 17st 103 4 lb for Biggs, heavier by 10lb than ever before, and attributes this to a groin injury sustained when turning out in a charity football match. 
 &bquo;I wasn't able to train properly,&equo; he said. 
 Certainly by the middle of Wednesday's contest Mason appeared once again to have a stamina problem and unlike Biggs, who was also suffering, he did not have the experience to conceal his distress. 
 &bquo;Americans know so much more about that,&equo; Lawless added. 
 &bquo;They don't show it when they are hurt or tired and Gary couldn't believe how little Biggs had got left.&equo; 
 If this explained Mason's reluctance to pressure Biggs in the middle rounds, thereby allowing the American to pepper him with jabs, it cannot obscure the possibility that the British heavyweight will always experience difficulty if required to take on a long contest. 
 But he withstood some solid blows and finally saw off Biggs with a right to the temple as the bell sounded to end the seventh round. 
 The memory of it revitalised a bonny smile but he was aware that there had been some anxiety in his corner. 
 Rugby Union: Lions run the new revolution: Steve Bale on the death of an inferiority complex 
 By STEVE BALE 
 WHATEVER the home unions committee may care to think, the team who performed with great distinction in Paris are Lions to a man &mdash; and if the powers-that-be will not grant them the honour with a large &bquo;L&equo; they can hardly begrudge it with a small one. 
 To the rebirth of British Isles forward play in Australia has now been added the regeneration of back play as well. 
 The Lions had squeezed in two light training sessions amounting to little more than two hours before beating France 29-27 on Wednesday night in a game as grand as its occasion. 
 Despite this minimal preparation, and regular changes of personnel over the past fortnight, they achieved a wholly implausible blend of skill, aggression and indomitable spirit. 
 As no rugby country has won at Parc des Princes since England did so in 1982 (remember Colin Smart and the after-shave?), this result was a revolution of sorts &mdash; which was fitting as the match and its prolonged preliminaries were designed to mark the bicentenary of the French Revolution. 
 &bquo;It's a big psychological stepping stone,&equo; Ian McGeechan, the coach, said. 
 &bquo;The players now need have no inferiority complex about playing here.&equo; 
 Rob Andrew, his captain, added: &bquo;Not one player in that team had won in Paris, and now we know that France are vulnerable when you keep running at them.&equo; 
 Gavin Hastings, whose 22 points included two tries, and Andrew, who scored the Lions' other points with a try and drop goal, were only the most obvious beneficiaries of this unlikely success. 
 Fluid running of a sort seldom seen Down Under was one pleasant surprise &mdash; but then every member of Wednesday's back division was on that tour. 
 More remarkable was the way a makeshift pack, with only one Lions Test player and three other tourists, shaped up. 
 That they had any cohesion at all was impressive and when they also succeeded in driving through the heart of the French forwards an improbable victory became at least possible. 
 None of the non-tourists looked out of place. 
 But it helped that the one Test forward was Paul Ackford who, still less than a year into his international career, is a phenomenon, consistently winning his own line-out ball, securing kick-offs and loose possession, and cover-tackling more in the manner of a flanker than a lock. 
 At 31 going on 32, he is a model of a modern tight forward. 
 Tight forwards have been Jacques Fouroux's obsession since France were shattered by New Zealand in the 1987 World Cup final. 
 With his emphasis on the scrum and close-quarter exchanges, the French coach wants even his loose forwards to be tight, and the new generation he introduced against the Lions looked inadequate. 
 This will probably mean the return of some of his old lags when Australia play Tests in Strasbourg and Lille next month. 
 This will not, however, guarantee beating the Wallabies, since few of Wednesday's more experienced players looked much better. 
 As ever, Serge Blanco was impossibly dynamic and Philippe Sella was an occasional threat. 
 But others wilted under the physical pressure: Laurent Rodriguez, &bquo;the Lion of Dax&equo;, was one example, reduced to a harmless pussy cat by David Egerton and the rest. 
 For this and other achievements they deserved the recognition as Lions officially denied them &mdash; just as the whole Lions tour party had deserved to be invited to Paris. 
 There were something like 41 officials but only 21 players from the home unions at Parc des Princes. 
 If that suggests an odd set of priorities in what is still quaintly called a players' game, at least the 21 wore the familiar red jersey with the famous crest, white shorts and blue and green socks. 
 That makes them Lions as well as lions. 
 Rugby League: Canberra's capital gain 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 CANBERRA RAIDERS flew home via Honolulu last night with their pride dented but their bank balance improved by &pound;60,000, the amount both they and Widnes cleared from the World Club Challenge match. 
 On financial grounds alone the event was a resounding success, and after two thrilling encounters in the last two years the public appetite here is established beyond doubt. 
 The future of the fixture depends on the commitment of the Australians, however, and after two consecutive defeats, the enthusiasm for the World Club Challenge Down Under is more difficult to gauge. 
 A sign which went up on the Raiders' dressing-room door after the match, advising that only Australian media personnel were welcome, bore witness to the visitors' touchiness about defeat, though at least they did not follow Manly's example and grumble about the referee. 
 Just as well, since they chose him. 
 Already there are suggestions from Australia that the Raiders' post-Grand Final party lasted all the way to Manchester, in other words that their preparation for the game was not as dedicated as it might have been. 
 This is almost certainly not the case and does Canberra a grave disservice, though it does illustrate one of the problems behind the fixture. 
 Wherever the game is played, and the possibility of alternate years in Manchester and Sydney will be discussed in the coming weeks, one team will always go into the match having just become champions, while the other will be at the start of their first defence. 
 Canberra arrived at Old Trafford at the end of a hard season, and their tiredness, inevitably compounded by travel fatigue, dictated their match plan. 
 &bquo;We decided in advance to hit Widnes hard in the opening quarter to build up a platform,&equo; Tim Sheens, their coach, said. 
 &bquo;We were all too aware that exhaustion would be a problem in the second half.&equo; 
 Kevin Tamati has been appointed coach at Salford. 
 The former Warrington and New Zealand Test forward succeeds Kevin Ashcroft, who resigned two days ago. 
 He takes charge for the match against Leigh on Saturday when Tony Rampling, an Australian forward, will make his debut for the club, who have lost all five matches so far. 
 Rugby Union: WRU's strong lead 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 THE South African Rugby Board could lose one of its hitherto staunchest allies when the Welsh Rugby Union's 203 member clubs convene for tonight's special general meeting at the Port Talbot Civic Hall. 
 When they met under similar circumstances five years ago, to debate the same contentious issue, of whether or not to maintain playing links with South Africa, there was overwhelming support for the Springboks. 
 Then, as now, the vote was taken against a background of anti-apartheid pressure, especially from local councils, but without the intrigue which surrounded the recent centenary tour to the Republic. 
 Six Welsh officials and 10 players made the trip, many changing their mind at the last minute. 
 The post-tour inquest led to the WRU secretary, David East, and the president, Clive Rowlands, walking out of a general committee meeting. 
 East resigned, Rowlands returned, but not until the junior vice-president, Rhys Williams, had tendered his resignation. 
 Once the bickering and backbiting, which also led to Terry Vaux and Gwilym Treharne standing down from their posts as the Welsh representatives on the International Rugby Board, had died down, the general committee resolved to consult the clubs again over links with the Republic. 
 The main difference of tonight's meeting, compared to the one held in 1984, is that the Union lead is strong and definite. 
 The motion which has been put to the clubs, and backed by an emotive letter from the president, will be proposed by senior life member Ken Harris. 
 It reads: &bquo;For as long as any rugby player living in the Republic of South Africa is the victim of racial discrimination under the laws of that country neither the WRU, nor any of its member clubs, will become involved in any matches organised under the authority of the SARB. 
 Nor will the Union, nor any of its member clubs, permit teams under the jurisdiction of the SARB to play in Wales.&equo; 
 Wang, the computer company, has stopped its sponsorship of the Leinster senior league competition in protest at the Irish RFU's links with the South African Rugby Board's centenary celebrations this summer. 
 Malachy Smith, managing director of Wang in Ireland and a former player, said: &bquo;We discontinued our South African operation more than than seven years ago and have no ties with that country.&equo; 
 Jean Braendlin, the Toulon prop, was yesterday banned for a year by the French Rugby Federation for kicking a grounded opponent on Saturday. 
 Judo: Stewart in Belgrade campaign 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 (First Edition) THREE Olympic medal winners will head Britain's challenge for honours at the World Judo Championships in Belgrade from 10 to 15 October. 
 Dennis Stewart, the light-heavyweight bronze medallist in Seoul, leads the men's team, who also include the heavyweight silver medallist, Elvis Gordon, and the middleweight bronze medallist, Densign White. 
 Karen Briggs, a triple world champion before a broken leg interrupted her progress, also travels with the 14-strong team. 
 Sharon Rendle and Diane Bell, who struck gold in the demonstration judo event in South Korea, will defend their world titles. 
 The women also include the former world champion Ann Hughes, who is attempting to recapture the lightweight crown. 
 Baseball: Bay city strollers 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 THE CHANCES of a Bay Area World Series improved late on Wednesday night when the San Francisco Giants and Oakland Athletics notched up impressive play-off victories over the Chicago Cubs and Toronto Blue Jays. 
 Will Clark, the Giants first baseman who narrowly missed the 1989 batting championship with an average of .333, drove in six runs with two homers - one a grand slam &mdash; as San Francisco routed the Cubs 11-3 in the first game of the best-of-seven National League championship series at Wrigley Field. 
 Rickey Henderson's nerveless brilliance between the bases helped the Athletics beat the Blue Jays 6-3 in Oakland and earn a 2-0 lead in the American League play-off series. 
 Henderson, traded this season from the New York Yankees, stole a post-season record four bases (in one game) and scored two runs. 
 If the Californian clubs progress it would be the first World Series &mdash; which starts on 14 October &mdash; between the two cities facing each other across San Francisco Bay. 
 Screensport, the satellite television service, announced yesterday that it would be showing each of the World Series matches live. 
 Netball: Parkes hopeful 
 By LIZ ROUND 
 JESSLYN PARKES, the England goalkeeper, will be hoping to guide her new team, Middlesex, to a winning start when the new season of English county league matches opens tomorrow, writes Liz Round. 
 Parkes transferred from league champions Birmingham to newly promoted Middlesex during the summer, and she and former England captain Sue Keal should form a formidable partnership. 
 Middlesex, Second Division champions last year, take on Hertfordshire away from home. 
 Despite Parkes's defection, Birmingham are expected to win their opening match away to Hampshire North, who finished sixth in the league last year. 
 Essex Metropolitan versus Bedfordshire should be a very close match &mdash; Essex were runners-up to Birmingham last year and have a strong, experienced side. 
 Bedfordshire finished fifth last season but now boast a squad of talented young players, including the England vice-captain, Kendra Lowe, and Vicky Cox. 
 Surrey, who finished third last year, are expected to win their home match against Cheshire, the other promoted side. 
 Surrey are led by England's captain, Sheila Edwards, and also feature the England combination of Alison Keyte and Sandra Fairweather. 
 Viewers are victors in battle of the broadcasters: Michael Sheridan in Rome on sport's pre-eminent place on Italian screens 
 From MICHAEL SHERIDAN in Rome 
 THE deregulation of television in Italy has brought viewers more sport, more often than perhaps in any other European country but it has caused a tremendous row among the broadcasters and the political power groups who back their various causes. 
 The average Italian urban viewer, without satellite or cable, can receive up to 20 stations on his home set. 
 There are the three channels of the state network, RAI, funded by licence fee and advertising. 
 Then there are five major private networks, Canale 5, Capodistria, Rete 4, Italia 1 and Telemontecarlo. 
 Beyond these lies an archipelago of small regional or city broadcasters which range from dubious one-studio enterprises in the Sicilian hinterland to smartly presented local stations in the cities. 
 It all seems to offer a breathtaking array of choice yet in practice the schedules too often present the same glum menu of badly dubbed westerns, trivial game shows, long and justly forgotten Neapolitan comedies of the 1960s or windy discussion programmes. 
 But when it comes to sport, all bets are off. 
 Italians fully expect to watch skiing from Australia at 5 o'clock in the morning and would be surprised not to follow the Japanese Formula One Grand Prix live. 
 The range of sports programmes, live and packaged, is extraordinary, while the videotape market is booming. 
 No boxing match seems too trivial for live coverage, basketball and volleyball draw vast audiences, Formula One racing grips the nation and there is an inexhaustible appetite for football, to the extent that Saturday night English soccer is a major viewing habit. 
 Thus battle has been joined between RAI and the private channels for an audience which Italian advertisers regard as pre-eminently desirable. 
 According to Giulio Malgara, president of Auditel, which monitors viewing habits, &bquo;sport is the perfect medium for publicity. 
 It guarantees record viewing figures in Italy, more than films or variety shows. 
 Plus the fact that advertising at a sport event appears entirely natural&equo;. 
 The result, of course, is that while RAI presents basketball or football with an advertising ratio not unlike British commercial television, the private networks are forever interrupting events to inform viewers that the penalty was brought to you by the Galbani Salami company or that Nigel Mansell's dash from pole position is nothing but a gift from the state oil conglomerate. 
 Although the sport and television market appears to be a free-for-all to delight the most Darwinist of entrepreneurs, a scrutiny of those top five private networks soon reveals that four of them are in the hands of a holding firm called Finvest, which is itself the broadcasting vehicle of the Socialist-leaning businessman Silvio Berlusconi. 
 For good measure, he also owns Milan football club. 
 Italians think of the state system much as Britons used to regard &bquo;Auntie&equo; and not for nothing is it known as &bquo;Mamma RAI&equo;. 
 But Mamma, in television terms at least, is no longer a sacred institution. 
 Between Berlusconi and RAI it is now open warfare. 
 Italian league football matches are not televised live, although this does not prevent RAI radio and television from broadcasting a pyrotechnic package of live audio reports from the grounds on a Sunday. 
 (Next time you are on holiday in Italy, do not wonder why half the male population is out for its Sunday afternoon post-pasta stroll with a transistor clutched to one ear from which blares an urgent voice. 
 The Pope has not died. 
 It is merely the football programme.) 
 With no chance of live football league coverage the fight is on for European Cup matches and other internationals. 
 Finvest's men have been making the bidding against RAI harder and harder by the season and now they are fighting on a match-by-match basis. 
 RAI protests that this amounts to a colossal waste of money since it previously acquired Eurovision rights for nothing more than the duty of reciprocal access to material from Italy. 
 But the pickings could be huge: the audience for RAI's recorded Italian Sunday football in the United States and Canada may be as high as 50 million, while down in Latin America they hunger for footage of Maradona at almost any price. 
 Berlusconi, unabashed by his own creation of what amounts to a duopoly, bangs the drum of the free market against RAI, claiming that the licence payers' money is being squandered to break down unwanted competition. 
 The Director-General, Biagio Agnes (like all RAI executives a political party appointee), has angrily accused the Berlusconi camp of &bquo;dragging in even the authorities of the state and seizing every opportunity to attack the public broadcasting service with statements of such arrogance that they betray weakness and sheer lack of class despite (Berlusconi's) economic power and much-vaunted influential friendships&equo;. 
 &bquo;Empty words,&equo; barked back the entrepreneur. 
 &bquo;I've denounced facts which are there for all to see in the RAI accounts, and the public prosecutors are looking into some of them. 
 We'll see who's in the right.&equo; 
 While the outcome of the battle between public and private is far off, there is no doubt that during the phase of conflict the viewer is the winner. 
 According to Auditel's Malgara, everyone should be happy. 
 &bquo;The battle between RAI and Finvest for the football? 
 It's great for everyone: the clubs, the sponsors and the spectators. 
 And as for ad spots during the games, they're there all right, but they're part of life, accepted, they don't annoy anyone.&equo; 
 Football: &bquo;Jacki&equo; is proving to be a video nicety: Celtic's Polish import sounds the alarm bells for England as that crucial World Cup encounter in Chorzow beckons: David Livingstone reports on the Scottish liberation of a footballer who has enlivened the Parkhead terraces 
 By DAVID LIVINGSTONE 
 THERE are more glamorous places than Glasgow in which to be liberated, but Dariusz Dziekanowski has no complaints. 
 It is true that this outstanding product of Polish football might have chosen to celebrate his freedom in Italy or West Germany, but instead he left Legia Warsaw for Celtic. 
 In doing so, he achieved something of the economic uplift associated with a move to the West, with little of the attendant culture shock, a fact which Glasgow can take as a kick in the groin or a pat on the back. 
 That such a prolific goalscorer should choose a club renowned for their attacking play demonstrates the practical considerations which influenced his decision. 
 His development as a personality and player in his three months with Celtic were illustrated during last week's glorious exit from the European Cup Winners' Cup. 
 His four wonderful, but ultimately futile, goals against Partizan Belgrade must have had the World Cup alarm bells ringing in England. 
 &bquo;Jacki&equo;, as he is known affectionately in Scotland, will lead Poland's attack against England in Chorzow on Wednesday, and, having already given Terry Butcher an anxious time in the Old Firm match in August, he can approach next week's game without the pressure of having something to prove. 
 When &bquo;Jacki&equo; came to Glasgow, he grasped quickly what was expected. 
 He found himself in a city in turmoil, where traditional values had been overturned by Maurice Johnston's decision to dump Celtic for Rangers. 
 If being responsible for eradicating any sense of loss at Parkhead troubled &bquo;Jacki&equo;, it did not show. 
 &bquo;I never had any worries about him,&equo; Billy McNeill, the Celtic manager, said. 
 &bquo;He's an intelligent lad with a nice personality. 
 The people around him have been very receptive, although I must confess to an anxious moment when he was first being introduced to the players. 
 The lads were having lunch at the time and when &bquo;Jacki&equo; leaned over to shake hands with Peter Grant, his tie fell into a bowl of soup. 
 &bquo;Everyone started laughing and I was concerned that &bquo;Jacki&equo; might feel alienated but he immediately started laughing himself and I knew I'd signed a character who'd get on fine in Scotland.&equo; 
 McNeill signed &bquo;Jacki&equo; for &pound;650,000, largely on the strength of personal recommendation and video evidence, but it was hardly a shot in the dark. 
 At 27 years old, and having won 52 international caps, &bquo;Jacki&equo; had earned recognition around the world and, more importantly, the permission of the Polish authorities to move abroad. 
 His career started at 15 when he signed for, Polonia Warsaw. 
 A year later, he switched to Gwardia Warsaw where he made sufficient impact to attract the attention of Widzew Lodz. 
 Having lost their captain, Zbigniew Boniek, arguably the greatest of Polish footballers, to Juventus, Widzew saw Dziekanowski as a replacement and so, at 21, &bquo;Jacki&equo; was transferred in 1984 for 21m zlotys, a record between Polish clubs, amounting at that time to some &pound;200,000. 
 He assumed the Boniek role with authority, a fact which perhaps explains his lack of concern at having eventually to replace Johnston. 
 At international level, his career also developed rapidly but, having been promoted heavily in advance of the 1986 World Cup, he was forced to face major disappointments. 
 &bquo;Mexico was terrible for us,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I prefer to forget about it completely, especially the defeat by England when Gary Lineker scored three goals.&equo; 
 Having failed to shine in Mexico, &bquo;Jacki&equo; saw his plans evaporating. 
 His own form suffered at home, largely because of the poor standing of Widzew, and with Polish clubs finding success hard to come by in European competitions, the profile of individual players was dropping. 
 Salvation for Dziekanowski came with a transfer in 1987 to Legia Warsaw, a bigger club who, incidentally, enjoy sponsorship from the Polish Defence Department. 
 As a result, &bquo;Jacki&equo;, who by this time was keen to move abroad, was delighted to hear in 1988 of serious interest from Pescara of Italy. 
 To his horror, Legia &mdash; obviously inspired by American television &mdash; decided to make him the &dollar;6m man, a fee which inevitably frightened off even the wealthy Italians. 
 &bquo;The people who manage clubs in Poland are not very good businessmen,&equo; 'Jacki' said, with masterly understatement. 
 Eighteen months later, the player showed that this criticism could not be levelled against him. 
 The West German clubs, Eintracht Frankfurt and Bayer Leverkusen, both wanted him, but &bquo;Jacki&equo; had done his homework. 
 &bquo;I discovered,&equo; he said, &bquo;that in Germany other Polish players were not always paid what their contracts stated and that is no good. 
 When I heard Celtic were interested, I decided Scotland would be much better for me.&equo; 
 So far he has no regrets. 
 He lives, for the moment, in a city hotel, but with a three-year contract, he is planning to buy a house. 
 &bquo;Perhaps in Bearsden or Newton Mearns,&equo; he said, struggling to pronounce the names of two expensive Glasgow suburbs and yet making a better job of it than BBC newsreaders. 
 In reciprocation, Glaswegians roll the name Dziekanowski off the end of their tongues with ease, happy to acknowledge his impact on the city and keen to extend the warmest of welcomes. 
 What happens to &bquo;Jacki&equo; at the end of his contract is unclear, but uncertainty has become an occupational hazard. 
 &bquo;I don't know what I'll do eventually,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I studied for five years at the Physical Education Academy, so I could go back to Poland and be a school teacher. 
 Maybe I could open clothes shops in Poland, who knows? 
 The problem in Poland is that life is very difficult for most people. 
 Ninety per cent are very poor and 10 per cent are very rich.&equo; 
 Reminded that he would be going back as one of the 10 per cent, &bquo;Jacki&equo; let go one of the handsome smiles which have made him so popular, but he qualified that by underlining the discomfort he might feel in that situation. 
 With so many difficult decisions to be made, &bquo;Jacki&equo; is happier than most players to accept his manager's warning not to look further ahead than the next game. 
 That match, for &bquo;Jacki&equo;, is, of course, against England, and he believes it is time for a reversal of recent results between the two countries. 
 Never one for extravagant predictions, however, &bquo;Jacki&equo; summed up Poland's chances in two words. 
 &bquo;No bad,&equo; he said, with his new Glasgow twang. 
 No one should forget he said the same thing before Celtic played Partizan. 
 Football: Non-League Notebook: Kelly's eye for fist and chips 
 By &bquo;PARK AVENUE&equo; 
 IT WAS once said of Peter Shilton, by a frustrated forward who had failed to beat him in a one-on-one situation, that &bquo;he just spreads his arms and fills up the whole bloody goal&equo;. 
 Strikers in the Staffordshire Senior League are currently facing a weighty problem of similar proportions. 
 Sid Kelly, who minds the net for table-topping Eccleshall, is believed to tip the scales at around 20 stones. 
 The roly-poly goalie makes heads turn on away grounds when he runs out, and some of his diving stops have been measured on the Richter Scale, but his performances invariably win respect from opponents and spectators. 
 Eccleshall, from a scenic village north-west of the county town, are more accustomed to propping up the league than heading it. 
 Last Saturday, however, with Sid on-song between the sticks, they held Stafford Rangers' second string to a 0-0 draw and have yet to lose. 
 Kelly trains as hard as the rest of the squad at a sports centre in nearby Stone, but according to the team's joint manager, Ken Roberts, he has been known to polish off three Chinese take-aways afterwards. 
 &bquo;We have now got him down,&equo; Roberts said triumphantly, &bquo;to 10 pints and a bucket of chips.&equo; 
 For those who fancy an afternoon off the unbeaten track, Eccleshall visit Eastwood Hanley in the Potteries tomorrow. 
 Over in Nottinghamshire, Hucknall Town are marking their elevation to the Central Midlands League by producing a programme that would put many full-time clubs to shame. 
 Hucknall will not be at full strength, though, when they visit Pickering in Yorkshire in the FA Vase tomorrow &mdash; and closer scrutiny of their Talk of the Town explains why. 
 &bquo;Mail from the Notts FA disciplinary gurus is blocking the letter-box at the moment,&equo; an over-candid editorial says. 
 &bquo;Gary Shepherd, dismissed after only two minutes of our opening game at Stanton, has been suspended for 21 days&hellip; 
 Phil Towle (sic), early-bather against Boston FC, was also set to get 21 days&hellip; 
 Ian Hannah is likely to receive a much heavier punishment after his fifth sending-off in three years at Bradford.&equo; 
 In the edition for the visit of Grimsby Borough, Towle is the featured player in what one fanzine has dubbed the &bquo;Dire Straits and lager guide&equo;. 
 In it, the Hucknall left-back reveals himself to be a chip off the Sid Kelly block: &bquo;favourite food &mdash; 32oz steak-with-everything&equo;. 
 Further food for thought: Cohen Griffith, the winger Kettering signed for &pound;3,000 from Leicester United last season, has joined Cardiff for 20 times that amount; the GM Vauxhall Conference leaders Darlington will defend a 10-match unbeaten start, the best in the competition's 10 years, tomorrow at Enfield; and Dunstable have withdrawn from the FA Cup following the 38th-minute abandonment of the tie with Staines when what was left of their team walked off after the dismissal of three colleagues. 
 And they call Staines &bquo;unsightly&equo;&hellip; 
 Ice Hockey: Devils in baptism of fire 
 By STEVE PINDER 
 WITH the season's curtain-raiser, the Norwich Union Cup, now only of interest to three teams (Cardiff Devils and Durham Wasps meet to decide who faces Murrayfield Racers in December's final), attention switches to the Heineken Premier and First Divisions which start tomorrow. 
 Devils, new to the Premier Division, look capable of beating anyone. 
 In their imports, Steve Moria and Doug McEwan, they have two of the country's finest forwards, and they also have Stephen and Ian Cooper on their books and have signed Chris Newton from Peterborough to back up Jeff Smith in goal. 
 The Devils face a baptism of fire in the Premier Division, with games at Ayr and Murrayfield. 
 Rocky Saganiuk, the Ayr coach, took his team to the Heineken Championship at Wembley in April, but they won only three of their six Norwich Union Cup games. 
 Racers, once the top team in Britain, will want a flying start to the season to reassert themselves. 
 They have three new imports, with Martin McKay to back up their veteran minder, Moray Hanson and Chris Kelland icing as a re-classified import. 
 The other Premier team in the reckoning are Solihull Barons, whose new import, Tim Krug, has strengthened a previously suspect defence, while Jere Gillis and Jeff Larmer form a formidable duo up front. 
 They too travel to Scotland, playing Fife Flyers who have had their worst start for years. 
 And watch Humberside, fresh to the First Division, who scored 134 goals in their eight Autumn Trophy games. 
 Tennis: Lendl is left in the clear by Becker's withdrawal 
 From JOHN ROBERTS in Stuttgart 
 BORIS BECKER disappointed his West German supporters for the second consecutive year when a knee injury forced him to withdraw from the Stuttgart Classic here yesterday. 
 The Wimbledon and United States Open champion, who will also miss next week's grand prix tournament in Sydney and is unlikely to be fit for Tokyo the following week, has now lost any chance of overhauling Ivan Lendl as world No. 1 before the end of the year. 
 At least on this occasion, Becker had played his way through to the semi-finals of the eight-man exhibition event, organised by his manager, Ion Tiriac, before pulling out. 
 Last November he arrived on crutches on the opening day with his left foot in plaster, having chipped an ankle bone. 
 &bquo;Probably I started too early after Flushing Meadow,&equo; Becker said yesterday, before visiting his doctor in Munich. 
 Tiriac reacted with typical eloquence: &bquo;It's my tournament. 
 In one chair I'm the promoter, in another chair I'm Boris's manager and in another chair I'm his friend. 
 From any of these positions I would be crazy to make him play with the left knee inflamed the way it is.&equo; 
 Alberto Mancini, of Argentina, takes his place against Lendl in the semi-finals, which also features Miloslav Mecir against the local Carl-Uwe Steeb. 
 Last night Lendl had little difficulty in defeating John McEnroe 6-4, 6-4 at the conclusion of the round robin phase. 
 A degree of surprise was expressed when McEnroe showed up here after a knee injury had forced his withdrawal from last month's grand prix event in San Francisco. 
 &bquo;It's tendinitis, basically; nothing real serious, it just hurts,&equo; he reassured us. 
 McEnroe's autumn slog through Europe, which will include a trip to Wembley for next month's Silk Cut Championships, is designed for one purpose: &bquo;I'm trying to get myself prepared for the Masters, hopefully to do well. 
 It would have extra meaning for me, being the last one in New York.&equo; 
 Ah, yes. 
 While Europe in general, and West Germany in particular, rejoice at the removal of the grand prix finals from Madison Square Garden to Frankfurt's Festhalle next year under the banner of the Association of Tennis Professionals, others are already rummaging through fond memories. 
 In McEnroe's case, the Garden was the scene of his last triumph of major significance. 
 He ended 1984, acknowledged as his greatest year, as the world No. 1. 
 In January 1985, before he was supplanted at the top by Lendl, the New Yorker defeated the stern Czechoslovak in straight sets in the Masters final. 
 At 30, McEnroe is beginning to incline towards nostalgia, even though he leaves himself with little time to indulge in the luxury. 
 When he leaves here, he faces four tournaments &mdash; Antwerp, Toulouse, Paris and Wembley &mdash; in five weeks to tune up for the Masters on 27 November. 
 Tennis: Evert waives her goodbye 
 From Our Correspondent in Tokyo 
 IF ONE was to pose the question, when is a retirement not a retirement, Chris Evert might have the answer. 
 Last month, the 34-year-old American waved a fond farewell to the big-time, at the US Open, in New York. 
 Yesterday, in Tokyo, she indicated that she may be around for a little while longer than expected. 
 Evert is not feeling comfortable with what she describes as the &bquo;finality&equo; of the decision, although she does agree with it in principle. 
 So, to that end, she intends to keep the door ajar. 
 &bquo;What I said last month was that the US Open was my final Grand Slam tournament. 
 But if I want to play the odd tournament here and there, I will. 
 I am still playing well and still enjoying it, so why not?&equo; she said. 
 Evert added: &bquo;I'm not going to say that I stake my life on the fact that I'm never going to play another tournament. 
 But I would be surprised if I did after this year, although, at this stage, I am still playing well enough and I am enjoying it enough so that if I want to play another tournament, I can.&equo; 
 Evert also revealed that she has added a week of exhibition matches against Martina Navratilova to her schedule, which will be played in Asia, in April. 
 Although Evert had the day off from the Federation Cup yesterday, her presence was still felt, particularly by the Australian team, who surprisingly defeated Bulgaria 2-1. 
 Prior to the match, Evert had told the Australian captain, Wendy Turnbull, to tell her No. 1 player, Anne Minter, &bquo;that if she can beat me as she did in Toronto (in August), then she can beat Manuela Maleeva&equo;. 
 Evert's prediction was spot-on as Minter grabbed a thrilling 6-3, 2-6, 6-4 victory that saved Australia's bacon after Liz Smylie had lost the opening singles rubber 6-2, 6-1 to Katerina Maleeva. 
 Those two results left the outcome of the quarter-final tie hinging on the doubles, in which Smylie was joined by Janine Thompson against Team Maleeva. 
 Not suprisingly, it was a nerve-racking finale but eventually the more experienced Australians triumphed 5-7, 6-4, 6-0, to carry their country into the semi-finals for the first time in four years. 
 Their opponents tomorrow will be Spain, the second seeds, who overwhelmed the Soviet Union in the two singles matches to reach the last four. 
 Hockey: England aim for action replay 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 THREE years ago to the day, England last did battle with Argentina at Willesden in their second game in the World Cup. 
 The result was a 2-1 win for England, who went on to take the silver medal, losing in an exciting final to Australia. 
 Argentina finished in sixth place. 
 Today at Kenilworth Road, Luton, Argentina will again provide the opposition for England in the Four Nations Lada Classic. 
 Australia and The Netherlands complete the programme. 
 Although the Argentinians are noted for their defensive play, they have several attractive players, with the experienced Alejandro Siri likely to be the key performer. 
 But watch out for the one-handed play of the gifted Gabriel Minadeo and the goalkeeping feats of the high-kicking Emanuel Roggero. 
 The South Americans have come from a five-nation tournament in Hamburg, where they beat Spain 2-1 and lost to Australia 3-2. 
 Tomorrow, England play the Dutch and on Sunday, Australia. 
 England's women play the Soviet Union tomorrow and again on Sunday. 
 They have been forced to make two late changes. 
 Jill Atkin and Gill Brown have withdrawn, with Sutton Coldfield's Mandy Pickles and Slough's Sue Chandler coming in as replacements. 
 Their captain Sandy Lister, who was a doubtful starter at the beginning of the week, has recovered from a bout of tonsillitis and will play. 
 Squash: Call for fairer sex to play fair 
 From RICHARD EATON in Kuala Lumpur 
 JAHANGIR KHAN and Mark Maclean both criticised women officials after their quarter-final in the World Open Championships here yesterday in which the world champion from Pakistan beat the Scottish No. 1 15-11, 15-11, 15-12. 
 Maclean was docked a penalty point for dissent in the second game by the Australian referee, Chris Sinclair, the only woman officiating at this level of the men's game. 
 Afterwards, Maclean said: &bquo;I have a nightmare every time I see a woman up there in the chair. 
 &bquo;There was one decision that showed a total lack of understanding of the game. 
 And she didn't give me a chance to explain my case at all.&equo; 
 Jahangir agreed with Maclean. 
 &bquo;I don't think women should be refereeing men's matches,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They don't realise the speed of the men players or what they can do with the ball. 
 And all I can do when there is a woman referee is to accept her. 
 Men can still realise what women do, but it is difficult for women to understand how the men play.&equo; 
 Jahangir's coach, Rahmat Khan, explained: &bquo;Pakistani players find it very difficult to tell a woman off. 
 They have too much respect for them.&equo; 
 Sinclair, prevented by tournament rules from speaking to the press, was defended by the tournament referee, Christopher Foo. 
 &bquo;She is a qualified international referee and although the players are entitled to their opinions, I think they might say something different in the morning,&equo; Foo said. 
 A further defence came from Tony Swift, chairman of the International Federation rules committee: &bquo;We don't think of it as a woman up there &mdash; as far as we are concerned it is a person,&equo; he said. 
 Racing: Cordoba founders on Cove 
 By JOHN KARTER in Newmarket 
 THE GREAT Cordoba bubble burst with the impact of an exploding bomb as Sheikh Mohammed's heavily hyped colt trailed in third behind the 20-1 outsider, Balla Cove, in yesterday's Middle Park Stakes at Newmarket. 
 By contrast, another tall reputation had looked fully justified at the start of the afternoon when Nashwan's half-brother Mukddaam, survived a stewards' inquiry after beating 18 rivals convincingly on his racecourse debut to become favourite for the Derby at 16-1 with William Hill. 
 Before the Middle Park, bookmakers had taken fortunes on Cordoba for next year's 2,000 Guineas. 
 Hills cut him from 10-1 to 6-1, prompting their representative, Don Payne, to comment: &bquo;You expect big market moves before races like this, but I've never seen anything on this scale.&equo; 
 Asked how much his firm had laid Cordoba to lose, Payne replied tellingly &bquo;enough&equo;. 
 Cordoba had clearly cried enough a good two furlongs from the finish as first Batzushka and then Balla Cove set a furious pace which resulted in a time that equalled the course record by a two-year-old over six furlongs. 
 Just when we expected to see Cordoba produce an extra gear as Walter Swinburn got to work with the whip, the son of El Gran Senor capitulated and it was Balla Cove who produced extra reserves to hold the late thrust of Rock City. 
 Ron Boss, Balla Cove's trainer, was saddling his second successive winner of the race, having sent out Mon Tresor last year. 
 However, Boss's joy was tempered by the fact that Balla Cove was sold to two Americans earlier this week and is to be sent to the United States to be trained by Ron MacAnally, who prepared the great John Henry. 
 The French colt, Machiavellian, now heads the market for the 2,000 Guineas at between 7-1 and 10-1, with Be My Chief, who has twice beaten Balla Cove, disputing second favouritism with Mukddaam at around 12-1. 
 Mukddaam marginally interfered with the favourite, Mazag, but drew away to win in the style of a horse with a big future. 
 Dick Hern would not be drawn into comparisons with Nashwan at the same stage of his career, but on yesterday's evidence Hamdan Al Maktoum could well have a natural successor to his great champion. 
 &bquo;I'm relieved to have got a run into Mukddaam,&equo; Hern said. 
 &bquo;But I'll have to see how he comes out of the race before deciding if he'll race again this season.&equo; 
 Steve Cauthen, who rode Balla Cove, had earlier taken the other feature race on the card, the Godolphin Stakes, on Spritsail &mdash; a victory that should have been the subject of a stewards' inquiry. 
 Spritsail had started odds-on for a race at Ascot a week ago, but trailed in a well-beaten last of four behind Tralos. 
 Yesterday he was favourite again at 2-1 and won impressively. 
 The only reason that Henry Cecil, Spritsail's trainer, could give for that poor Ascot run was that the ground there was loose, but the official going was good to firm at Ascot, the same as yesterday's. 
 The stewards should at least have inquired into Spritsail's dramatic resurgence as a public-relations exercise. 
 Lord Howard de Walden, a former Senior Steward of the Jockey Club, whose wife owns Spritsail, joked afterwards: &bquo;The price was wrong at Ascot.&equo; 
 It is a fair bet that a good many punters were not amused. 
 Racing: Nisky to pass revision test 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 THE MISSING link reappears at Goodwood this afternoon in the shape of Ile De Nisky (2.45), the horse who represents the prime piece of evidence in the argument over the comparative merits of Nashwan and Old Vic, writes John Karter. 
 The fact that the English and Irish Derby winners will never meet on the track does not stop the followers of the dynamic duo hammering home their cases. 
 And if the form book is to be believed, Nashwan is clearly No. 1 because Ile De Nisky finished seven and a half lengths behind him at Epsom, but got a length nearer to Old Vic at The Curragh. 
 What that also shows is that Ile De Nisky is a very useful performer in his own right and he should take today's Foundation Stakes in his stride before having another crack at Nashwan in Newmarket's Champion Stakes later this month. 
 Originally, Geoff Huffer, Ile De Nisky's trainer, felt his colt was immature and was going to give him just one more run before putting him away for an ambitious campaign next year. 
 However, after a discussion with Pat Eddery, it was felt that Ile De Nisky had not truly stayed the mile and a half, hence the revised programme. 
 Ile De Nisky should win, but neither Monastery nor Muhbubh will be pushovers. 
 Markofdistinction (3.50), who got even closer to Nashwan when fourth in the 2,000 Guineas, was beaten at Doncaster by what is probably an outstanding horse in Nashwan's stable companion Gold Seam and should find compensation in the Supreme Stakes. 
 Harry Thomson Jones, the trainer of Muhbubh, has struck a gold seam himself, saddling eight winners from 19 runners in the past fortnight. 
 He could surprise a few better-fancied candidates in Newmarket's Somerville Tattersall Stakes with ABS (nap 3.10), who was an impressive winner at Leicester. 
 Message Pad and Qui Danzig have the better form, but as a son of the supremely successful Nureyev, Abs may have more scope for improvement. 
 Clive Brittain, who is quietly confident of a major showing from Top Class in Sunday's Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe, should also maintain an excellent recent run by completing a double with Sloe Berry (2.05), who was inched out at Ascot last week, and Charmer (2.35), who looks better class than the opposition. 
 Finally, Superoo (next best 4.10), who was controversially withdrawn before the start at Ascot on Saturday, should find swift compensation. 
 Racing: Phoenix rising to challenge: Mark Popham on the excess of riches on offer to racegoers this weekend 
 By MARK POPHAM 
 IT USED to be an easy decision, and still is for many racing fans &mdash; the first weekend in October is the time to visit Paris. 
 Such is the pulling power of Europe's richest race, the Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe, that up to 10,000 Britons will make the journey this weekend, making a considerable impact in a total crowd of 35,000. 
 Until last year, Longchamp was the only place to be, but now Phoenix Park in Dublin, where the Cartier Million will be staged for the second time tomorrow, provides a tempting alternative. 
 The Million, with IR &pound;1m in prize money, is the world's richest two-year-old race and challenges the Arc for offering the biggest prize in Europe. 
 Amazingly, the Million, which is restricted to the 250 yearlings sold at the Goffs Million sale the year before, will continue to clash with the Arc weekend because the sales it is tied to take place the week after. 
 So the prospect of a proper European Festival that would cover last Saturday's British Festival of Racing at Ascot and this weekend's races in France, Ireland and Newmarket, and which could rival America's Breeders' Cup day which has &dollar;10m in prize money, is likely to remain a dream even after 1992. 
 French racecourses, without bookmakers and with an undemonstrative crowd that tend to think of horses in terms of their number on the Pari-Mutuel rather than their name, can seem strange places to Britons. 
 Phoenix Park, at the top end of the biggest park in any European city, is altogether more atmospheric, with Tudor-style buildings, bookmakers who are just as happy to take and pay out in sterling as in punts, and bands and clowns to provide extra entertainment. 
 Racing and Ireland go together &mdash; it is said there are as many horses as people (three and a half million) &mdash; and racecourse crowds are extremely knowledgeable about the sport. 
 In an effort to create more atmosphere at Longchamp, Horse Racing Abroad, the chief transporter of Britons to French tracks, has its own grandstands, bars (stocking drinks the British are used to), restaurants and betting facilities at the course to make its clients feel at home. 
 And with the Arc such an established part of the racing scene, Paris will be bursting with Britons this weekend, with just a few hundred going on a punting pilgrimage to Dublin. 
 Tense East Germany awaits Gorbachev 
 From STEVE CRAWSHAW in East Berlin 
 EAST GERMANY battened down the hatches yesterday on the eve of Mikhail Gorbachev's arrival in its capital, Berlin, for the fortieth anniversary of the country's creation. 
 The border from West into East Berlin was closed for part of the day. 
 No explanation was given to those who were turned back, other than the Foreign Ministry's declaration that this was a &bquo;sovereign decision&equo;. 
 In Dresden, witnesses reported violent clashes between police and would-be emigrants desperate to board trains to the West. 
 Police used water-cannon and truncheons against the crowds. 
 East German television, by contrast, focused on ponderous wreath-layings and other ceremonial events in advance of the official birthday, which falls tomorrow. 
 The front pages of official newspapers have been filled with tales of glorious national triumphs, offset by with a smattering of gloom from the West &mdash; unemployment in the US, drugs in Britain, and so on. 
 But despite all the authorities' attempts to pretend that all goes well, the birthday celebrations are moving forward in the shadow of a public mood of national crisis, dramatised by the tens of thousands of East Germans struggling to flee to the West in recent weeks. 
 Their millions of compatriots follow the details on West German television, day by day, while the domestic media have confined their reports to abuse against the authorities in Bonn, and sometimes against those who have left. 
 &bquo;We should weep no tears for them,&equo; one commentator said. 
 Ordinary people talk constantly of the continuing exodus. 
 Opposition groups grow bolder. 
 Crowds have demonstrated in growing numbers in recent weeks - up to 20,000 in Leipzig on Monday night, chanting &bquo;Gorby! 
 Gorby!&equo; in the largest protest since the suppressed workers' uprising of 1953. 
 Many East Germans say that, though they themselves do not want to leave, there is almost universal resentment at the official lies and the unbending attitudes of the authorities, who, by cancelling visa-free travel to Czechoslovakia this week, made it even more difficult to escape what one person called &bquo;our cage&equo;. 
 East Germany's first organised opposition group, New Forum, its aims far from radical by comparison with those now being voiced in Poland and Hungary, was established last month even as the mass exodus began. 
 Jens Reich, one of its founders, said yesterday: &bquo;There is much anger that the reality and the portrayed image are so different&hellip; 
 . I think we have been silent too long, we've tolerated too much for too long.&equo; 
 He said that support for the opposition was growing, but many were still afraid &mdash; not surprisingly, as opposition leaders have already had officially-inspired warnings that, when the weekend's official jubilation is over, there could be a new clampdown. 
 The hopes of many East Germans now rest with Mr Gorbachev. 
 And yet he seems unlikely to bring them much comfort. 
 Pravda, the official Soviet newspaper, has positioned itself unambiguously on the side of the East German government's authority. 
 And if the Soviet leader kept silent in Peking in May, as hundreds of thousands shouted his name during the demonstrations at Tiananmen, he seems the more likely to say nothing which might inflame passions so comparatively close to home. 
 Winfried Wolk, leader of the East German Christian Democrat party, an ally of the government but a critic of the anniversary celebration, warned against confrontation. 
 Do not go out on the streets, he begged his compatriots &mdash; instead, put a lighted candle in the window for reform. 
 Game warden &bquo;most likely murderer of Julie Ward&equo; 
 From STEVE CRAWSHAW in East Berlin 
 SIMON MAKALLA, chief game warden of the Masai Mara game reserve in Kenya, was named in court yesterday as the man most likely to have murdered Julie Ward. 
 Byron Georgiadis, counsel for the dead Englishwoman's family, making his closing submissions to the inquest in Nairobi, said: &bquo;He had the mobility and authority to drive around the reserve after dark and an intimate knowledge of the area &mdash; his kingdom.&equo; 
 That should have prompted the police to question him closely, but they never did. 
 &bquo;Mr Makallah had a charmed life. 
 He should have been the principal suspect.&equo; 
 Miss Ward's charred and severed remains were found in a remote part of the game park last September six miles from her abandoned Suzuki vehicle. 
 Mr Georgiadis said much of Mr Makallah's evidence to the inquest had been lies &mdash; particularly details on three important issues: Mr Makallah claimed he could not drive, yet other witnesses claimed to have been driven by him; he denied telling a camp site proprietor that Miss Ward was definitely not killed by wild animals; and he covered up how he knew her jeep did not have four-wheel drive. 
 Mr Georgiadis said: &bquo;This murder has nothing to do with poachers, Ugandans, Somalians, Tanzanians or little green men from Mars&hellip; 
 The key to it is with Simon Makallah, who lied to us on three occasions.&equo; 
 The evidence at the inquest had vindicated the struggle by the dead woman's father, John Ward, to make the authorities accept she had been murdered. 
 Any other explanations were bizarre, Mr Georgiadis said. 
 &bquo;The police will have you believe that on the night of 12 September, after consuming half a tin of pilchards, she decided life was not worth living and hacked off her left leg with a non-existent sharp instrument. 
 Then she lopped off her head and finally decided to douse her mortal remains with petrol and set fire to herself.&equo; 
 Labour turns down move towards electoral reform 
 By COLIN HUGHES, Political Correspondent 
 THE LABOUR conference voted by a 3-1 majority yesterday to reject moves to commit the party to changing the voting system at parliamentary elections. 
 The strength of opposition to calls for a working party to consider the options for electoral reform delighted the party leadership. 
 During the debate Roy Hattersley, the deputy leader, argued that it would be &bquo;historic folly&equo; for Labour to back proportional representation; inevitable coalitions would mean that &bquo;we would never again have a Labour government that was able to carry out a Labour programme&equo;. 
 But advocates of PR said afterwards that the issue would not go away: Labour has yet to decide its preferred method of electing its proposed regional assemblies and its replacement for the House of Lords. 
 Jeff Rooker, the MP for Birmingham Perry Barr, who retired from Labour's front bench last year partly to campaign for PR, said: &bquo;A lot more people went away from this conference convinced of the merits of the argument than is shown in the vote.&equo; 
 Gavin Laird, the general secretary of the Amalgamated Engineering Union, said that it was the last &bquo;burning issue&equo; Labour needed to resolve before the next election. 
 Mr Hattersley said during the debate that he and Neil Kinnock were more determined than ever to resist pressure for Labour to back PR, because voters would suspect that the party lacked confidence in its ability to win under the present system. 
 Mr Hattersley, however, looks set for defeat in a vote over reducing the age of homosexual consent from 21 to 16. 
 Voting will not be announced until this morning &mdash; but gay campaigners were cheered by delegates when they protested that the party's policy review had replaced a commitment to &bquo;full equality&equo; for gays with &bquo;greater equality&equo;. 
 Base rates hit eight-year high: Rise to 15% will lead to increase in mortgage payments, lenders say 
 By PETER TORDAY and PATRICK HOSKING 
 MORTGAGE borrowers face an increase of at least 7 per cent in their monthly bills after a widely-feared 1-point rise in base lending rates yesterday. 
 The Bank of England was forced to signal an increase in base rates to 15 per cent &mdash; the highest for eight years &mdash; after the Bundesbank lifted its own key rates by a full point to clamp down on West German inflation. 
 The Bank was tipped off by the West Germans shortly before the decision was announced, and evidently decided it would have to follow suit or risk a damaging run on the pound. 
 Because of West Germany's dominant economic position in Europe, nine European countries, including Britain, felt obliged to lift their rates. 
 After the Bank's signal to the money markets at about 2pm yesterday, Barclays Bank announced an increase in its base rate, and was quickly followed by the other clearing banks. 
 As a result of the increase, some banks and building societies said they expected to raise mortgage rates by between 1 and 1.5 per cent, probably from 1 November. 
 But they are likely to delay formal announcements until mid-October. 
 The increase is almost bound to have a further depressing effect on the housing market. 
 Although average prices across the country are rising moderately from their levels of a year ago, in the South-east they have slid by 10 to 15 per cent in the past 12 months. 
 The increase in rates initially sent London share prices tumbling. 
 The FT-SE 100 index of leading shares lost 42.0 points within an hour of the announcement. 
 But by the close, it had recovered slightly to finish 30.5 points lower at 2281.6. 
 The pound, which has been under intense selling pressure for most of the past seven trading days, rallied 2.4 pfennigs to close in London at DM3.0342. 
 It also finished firmer against the dollar, rising 0.57 cents to &dollar;1.6102. 
 The Bank of England is thought to have spent between &dollar;2bn and &dollar;3bn defending sterling against the heavy selling which developed 10 days ago after the August trade figures were released. 
 These revealed a deficit of &pound;2bn in trade in goods and services &mdash; the third worst on record. 
 City economists welcomed the decision to raise rates and defend the pound's value, which they expect to subdue inflation more effectively. 
 But before that happens, inflation is expected to accelerate towards 7.5 per cent late this year because of the impact of higher mortgage rates on the retail price index. 
 There was also concern that a renewed upturn in inflation could inflame wage claims in the forthcoming pay round. 
 Abbey National said a rise of between 1 and 1.5 per cent in early November was inevitable. 
 The Leeds Permanent building society expected to increase rates by at least 1.25 per cent. 
 By yesterday evening the largest lender, the Halifax, which held out a glimmer of hope earlier in the day that it could stick with its 13.5 per cent rate, acknowleged a rise was inevitable. 
 The impact will not immediately be felt by the millions of borrowers on semi-fixed mortgages, whose rates are changed only once a year. 
 Eighty per cent of Halifax borrowers are on such &bquo;budget&equo; schemes. 
 Although yesterday's increase in rates intensified fears that the economy could come perilously close to recession next year, the instant judgement of most economists was that the worst would be avoided. 
 Ian Harwood, chief UK economist of Warburg Securities, said: &bquo;I'm not convinced that consumer confidence or business confidence is going to take a dramatic knock. 
 The economy has been so strong in the last few years it's going to take a lot to bring it down.&equo; 
 This week, reductions in National Insurance contributions worth &pound;2.8bn over the next 12 months go into effect. 
 The cuts, equivalent to a 2p reduction in the basic rate of income tax, are expected to replenish some of the consumers' depleted ammunition. 
 However, there were lingering fears yesterday that Nigel Lawson might yet be forced to raise rates even higher if another run on the pound develops because of poor trade figures. 
 Days Like These 
 By IAN IRVINE 
 4 October, 1941 LORAN HURNSCOT writes in her diary: &bquo;Mist and cold, after yesterday's Indian summer. 
 It was one of the perfect days &mdash; the high tide of this present time. 
 I went out for a walk, then picked blackberries on Periton Hill, in that far clump at the edge of the downs. 
 For a long time I sat out on the crumbling turf, with the blue distances below, and warm sun lying over this lovely autumn land. 
 And suddenly I was swept out of myself &mdash; knowing, knowing, knowing. 
 Feeling the love of God burning through creation, and an ecstasy of bliss pouring through my spirit. 
 I'm ashamed to put it down in these halting words. 
 For it was ecstasy &mdash; that indissoluble mingling of fire and light that the mystics know. 
 There was a scalding sun in my breast &mdash; the &bquo;kingdom of God within' &mdash; that rushed out to that All-Beauty, its weak rays met those encompassing ones and the bliss of heaven filled me.&equo; 
 6 October, 1835 FELIX MENDELSSOHN writes to his family from Leipzig: &bquo;The day after I accompanied the Hensels to Delitzsch, Chopin arrived here; he would not stay more than a day, and so we spent it together entirely, and played music. 
 I must confess, my dear Fanny (his sister), that I found your judgement of him was inadequate; perhaps, too, he may not have been in the mood for playing when you heard him, which is probably often the case; but I was again enchanted by his playing, and I am convinced that if you, and Father too, had heard some of his best things in the way he played them to me, you would say the same. 
 His manner of playing the piano has something so basically individual about it, and at the same time so masterly, that he may really be described as the perfect virtuoso.&equo; 
 7 October, 1814 JOHN WILSON CROKER to the Secretary of the Wellington Fund: &bquo;I quite agree with the Committee in its predilection for a pillar. 
 I was one of the pillarists in the Nelson case and only wish our column had been one of more magnificent dimensions. 
 Great height is the cheapest way and one of the most certain of achieving sublimity. 
 Ten thousand pounds will build you the highest column in the world, and will produce an astonishing effect; fifty thousand pounds would not serve to erect an arch, and when it was erected you would have doubted which, it or the Royal Exchange, was the more magnificent object; therefore I exhort you to keep to the columnar form. 
 Whatever you do at least be sure to make it stupendously high; let it be of all columns in the world the most lofty.&equo; 
 THEATRE / Lonely parts club: Mark Steyn reflects on one-man shows, including John Sessions's &bquo;Napoleon&equo; and Edward Petherbridge's &bquo;Muse&equo; 
 By MARK STEYN 
 THE SET is a luxuriously-upholstered leather chair alongside a small mahogany table, on which rest a glass of water and a handsomely-tooled volume. 
 The distinguished thespian wanders on, picks up the book and begins to read a letter from Wilfred Owen to Siegfried Sassoon or, perhaps, David Owen to Vidal Sassoon. 
 Faced with an actor reading, as Alan Bates did for much of his one-man show at Edinburgh this year, you're tempted to conclude that he's a little under-rehearsed. 
 In fact, it's part of a shrewdly calculated subtext. 
 &bquo;Look at me,&equo; he's saying. 
 &bquo;I'm not just a monkey dancing to the organ-grinder's tune. 
 I'm the sort of fellow who, after a hard day slogging away at the National Theatre, goes home and dips into a much-treasured, well-thumbed copy of Pope or Pepys. 
 If you &mdash; the audience &mdash; came round to my place, this is the sort of evening we'd have.&equo; 
 In image terms, the one-man show is a dramatised version of a colour supplement &bquo;Room Of My Own/Life In A Day&equo; feature. 
 The most favoured option is to pick a well-known name and either anthologise him or produce what is now grandly referred to as a biodrama. 
 As most actors are looking for someone they'll be happy to hang around with for years to come, they tend to choose subjects they like and approve of. 
 Peter Barkworth ends his Sassoon evenings by waving triumphantly a battered copy of the memoirs; even with a more controversial figure such as Lillian Hellman, Frances de la Tour only accepted because she felt sympathetic and compatible. 
 Few performers would be entirely happy touring the country as, say, Oswald Mosley, although it might make for a more interesting evening dramatically. 
 Most of the literary superstars have already been snapped up: Alec McCowen's done Kipling, Emlyn Williams Dickens, Michael Pennington Chekhov, Robbie Coltrane Dr Johnson and currently in the West End Leo McKern is playing Boswell. 
 If he finds the right character, the actor effectively claims the role for life. 
 For the Broadway run of Edmund Kean, Ben Kingsley was paid &dollar;12,500 per week. 
 His Equity-required understudy received &dollar;800 per &mdash; without having to learn a line. 
 The producer sent him the script, in case he was curious, but assured him there was no question of him appearing on stage in the role. 
 Had Kingsley been ill, the performance would have been cancelled. 
 The play's the thing, but, in a one-man show, the actor is the play: not Ben Kingsley in Edmund Kean, but Ben Kingsley as Edmund Kean or even, as those ultra-butch radio commercials put it, Ben Kingsley IS Edmund Kean. 
 We are there to attend not a play but a performance. 
 You can see why this appeals to actors. 
 Of the greatest player of her day, Jane Austen wrote only that &bquo;We were quite satisfied with Mr. Kean,&equo; &mdash; which may not look so good splashed across the marquee but which is all many of the experts demand: as far as Miss Austen is concerned, he didn't get in the way of the drama. 
 If we're honest, most of us reviewers prefer to engage in a dialogue with the author and director, addressing concepts of political theatre rather than the actor's little trick of twitching his left ear. 
 So, we bang on about the play and the staging and the big themes, and, if there's any space left, then, as the chairman of Critics' Forum wearily intones, &bquo;I suppose we ought to say something about the performances.&equo; 
 In his own solo, Edward Petherbridge quotes James Agate's comparison of actors with puppets: &bquo;Punch and Judy have no understanding of their show.&equo; 
 What better way for the hired hand to disprove the notion than to dispense with writers and stagers entirely? 
 So, the star compiles and writes the evening, and calls in a fellow thesp to direct: Petherbridge's The Eight O'Clock Muse is staged by Peter Barkworth, John Sessions's Napoleon &mdash; The American Story by Kenneth Branagh (a promising young actor, in case you hadn't heard). 
 In both these shows, there's an odd sense of being in some sort of parallel universe: it all looks the same, but the power structure has been weirdly distorted. 
 Petherbridge mentions Chekhov and Shakespeare, but, for him, theatre is something made by performance not writing. 
 &bquo;That's character,&equo; he says, after doing a few undulations. 
 &bquo;Truly it is.&equo; 
 Sessions's show endorses Petherbridge's point as forcefully as possible, reminding us that, in 20th century drama, the big stars have always been bigger than the big roles. 
 Mention Abe Lincoln and most of us visualise Raymond Massey. 
 True, he went to a lot of trouble to make his performance as authentic as possible ('he won't be satisfied till he's assassinated,&equo; friends used to say), but in the end what we see is still Massey, not Lincoln. 
 Telling the story of Napoleon through impressions of Marlon Brando, Phil Silvers, Diane Keaton, Gregory Peck and dozens more, Sessions simultaneously mocks and celebrates such overpowering casting: &bquo;Robespierre is no Henry Fonda. 
 He is Lee J Cobb through and through.&equo; 
 Where Sessions's military history is filtered through Hollywood, Petherbridge for his &bquo;pop-up guide to the theatrical imagination&equo; seems to have taken Ronnie Corbett's rambling monologues as his model. 
 As it happens, he paces himself much better than Corbett and other stand-up comics, and in his own sober way milks the material ruthlessly. 
 &bquo;Sorry to mention a critic's name so early on in the proceedings. 
 (LAUGH) But it is a dead one. 
 (BIGGER LAUGH) And not currently writing, either. 
 (HOUSE COLLAPSES)&equo; 'Edward, it's all in the timing,&equo; Cicily Courtneidge once told him, &bquo;so do your bit faster and then I'll come on.&equo; 
 This could have been just the usual self-indulgent actor's reminiscences. 
 Instead, Petherbridge has created a charming eccentric shambles, demonstrating the movement exercises of a 19th century Professor of Stage Deportment and Declamation, speaking Shakespeare while spinning plates and splashing the wilder shores of directorial ambition: &bquo;One can't,&equo; he purrs with delight, &bquo;walk across the stage without bumping into several concepts.&equo; 
 It's a practical guide to theatre, which subtly extends the eunuchs-in-the-harem sneer about critics to directors and authors. 
 In the end, only actors can do it. 
 Unfortunately, Petherbridge rather undermines this theory by reciting his own atrociously-rhymed poem. 
 Shakespeare had his moments, after all. 
 If the one-man show is as close to &bquo;actors&equo; theatre' as we'll ever get, perhaps it's just as well. 
 &bquo;Conflict is the essence of drama,&equo; Petherbridge concedes, &bquo;which is difficult in a one-man show.&equo; 
 He and Sessions, in their different ways, have found entertaining, imaginative substitutes, but, elsewhere, you're all too aware of what's missing. 
 Alan Bates's Muse Of Fire, for example, could have been compiled by a computer: its selection of all the biggest blazes in world literature lacks any sense of dramatic propulsion, a shapeless cabaret-set without music. 
 Bates gets by because his theme is so universal that practically all the heavyweights have something to say on it. 
 Doubtless, Muse Of Earth and Muse Of Wind will prove equally lucrative sequels. 
 But even carefully built evenings cannot avoid the whiff of compilation. 
 Whenever anybody reads a letter on stage, I'm reminded of one of those Radio 4 features where Martin Jarvis corresponds with Anna Massey, or vice-versa. 
 It's all very agreeable, and all terribly undramatic. 
 Even when a playwright has been drafted in, you can still see the joins. 
 Patrick Edgeworth's Boswell For The Defence has a plot of sorts &mdash; the barrister's defence of Mary Broad, an escapee from the penal colony at Sydney Cove &mdash; but, in the end, the form defeats any narrative thrust. 
 Unable to show his client or the Home Secretary or any of the other protagonists, Edgeworth is left with Boswell alone in his lodgings and is obliged to spin out the evening with the great man's reflections on extraneous matters - principally the size of his member and a certain actress's &bquo;snow-white boobies of the most generous proportions&equo;. 
 Leo McKern has some fun answering frequent calls of nature and waving a huge condom around, but he's doing no more or less than passing the time until the phoney climax of the First Act curtain, by which time you're aware that as a play Boswell is a fraud. 
 &bquo;Will delight fans of Boswell and Rumpole alike,&equo; claims one critic, but it's McKern's TV incarnation which is the draw, and such audience involvement as exists is not with Edgeworth's text but with the actor's genial clowning. 
 There's nothing necessarily wrong with that. 
 Actors, after all, are routinely ill-served by playwrights. 
 The last time he was at the Phoenix, in Simon Gray's The Common Pursuit, John Sessions was lost in a soggy, unsympathetic part, while co-stars like Rik Mayall and Stephen Fry hogged all the limelight; he seemed a non-entity. 
 Now, without help from anybody else, he fills the stage. 
 Napoleon has graduated from the fringe circuit to the West End because, despite the size of the cast, it is, in every other sense, a big show. 
 That's a point not always appreciated by those who think solos belong down the local community centre. 
 When Louis Benjamin was looking for a stopgap for Drury Lane between 42nd Street's closure and Miss Saigon's opening, the only production which could fill London's biggest theatre was Dame Edna's one-woman show: one Australian housewife outdrew the huge casts of the big-budget musicals. 
 Impressive as it is, however, Dame Edna's show is no more or less than a star vehicle. 
 In that respect, Willy Russell has accomplished a considerably trickier feat than Dame Edna: his Shirley Valentine is a one-woman show in which the show is more important than the one woman. 
 In both London and New York, the play has survived the departure of Pauline Collins, justifying for once the usually pretentious term of monodrama. 
 Even though the cast has been inevitably expanded for the new film, dramatically Shirley could have stood on her own. 
 It's a reminder that, occasionally, an author can have narrative drive and conflict within the confines of a single character. 
 Producers may favour one-man shows for economic reasons, but that doesn't in itself mean that the audience is being short-changed. 
 TELEVISION / Boxing far too clever: Mark Lawson in the ring 
 By MARK LAWSON 
 THE obituaries for Philip Larkin included an account of his attendance at an amateur boxing match in Hull. 
 It was a bout of poor quality and the writer is supposed to have murmured: &bquo;Only connect.&equo; 
 This tension between the cerebral and the visceral was usefully explored in Kim Evans' film for Omnibus (BBC 1) about the connections between two professions where the work, though very different, is done with the hands. 
 It is a widely held prejudice that the closest boxing gets to Art is that the guy who holds the towels at ringside might just be called that. 
 &bquo;Art In The Ring&equo; was a film about why so many writers are drawn to the sport. 
 Nobody pretended that it was other than a one-way process. 
 A number of poets like boxing but, on the other side, only Muhammed Ali has ever liked verse. 
 Vernon Scannell, an English poet and (spectator) pugilist observed that boxers were &bquo;not primarily men of words.&equo; 
 To put it more brutally, there is no other sport in which the participants are so habitually semi-literate. 
 Of the literati in their thrall, Budd Schulberg emerged as the writer who told you most about the bouts. 
 His was a rolling, jabbing prose, with an undertow of weariness; the best stuff on the subject somehow steals the speeds of the sport. 
 Mailer does that too but both his fight reports and his contributions to the film were proxy autobiography. 
 More than any other novelist, Mailer has narrowed the lines between writing and fighting. 
 Every publication or public appearance is a demarcation dispute. 
 When Mailer claims that &bquo;When the heavyweights become champions, they develop inner lives&hellip; like Dostoevsky, Joyce, Faulkner, Proust. 
 .. &bquo;, the really interesting reflection is why so many of the big American writers crave the inner life of Sonny Liston. 
 Whatever Mailer says, more great heavyweights have their roots in crime and punishment than in Crime and Punishment. 
 Equally, Mailer's reflections on the similarities between the condition of the writer and of the boxer ('There is a support system but you are alone&hellip; &bquo;) led you to a parallel which the programme tactfully left unstated. 
 After that great 1000-page bout with Gary Gilmore in 1979, Mailer has been displaying the typewriter equivalent of punchdrunkness. 
 Thursday's The Late Show (BBC 2) was presented by Cynthia Rose, to whom someone should speak about her big, swinging earrings. 
 Medically, they will surely pull her ears to destruction, which is her own problem, but, televisually, they pull the viewer's eyes to distraction, which is ours. 
 Also, the late Graham Chapman might have had a tribute more fitting to his debunking spirit than a discussion in which the presenter appeared to say the words &bquo;epiphany-oriented.&equo; 
 These moans apart, The Late Show long ago clinched the case for its existence and this edition also included a thoughtful report by David Walker on the bidding for television interviews with ministers. 
 Kenneth Baker, when at Education, was fingered as the smartest manipulator of his position and opposition in a programme. 
 So all the more thanks for Question Time (BBC 1), showing simultaneously on the other side, in which Mr Baker had no choice but to sit opposite Arthur Scargill and John Smith, all marshalled impartially by Peter Sissons, controversially and expensively replacing Sir Robin Day. 
 Regrettably, the new presenter is settling down slowly. 
 The moment when he playfully slapped the wrist of Baroness Seear, saying &bquo;No! 
 No! 
 No!&equo;, looked more like a presenter in search of a Day-like persona than one in control of the show. 
 Significantly, it got a laugh but didn't shut the lady up. 
 THEATRE / French without leers: Paul Taylor on &bquo;Paris Match&equo; at the Garrick Theatre 
 By PAUL TAYLOR 
 WATCHING Paris Match is like tucking into a plate of meringues and discovering that they are all Styrofoam fakes. 
 It also offers the spectacle (increasingly common this season) of crack British acting talent hurling itself down a lucrative drain. 
 Admittedly, Jean Poiret's congealed froth of a farce is a cut above the spurious Frankie and Johnny in the Clair de Lune and Exclusive, the most radically merit-free play in town, if not history. 
 But it still gives you a pang to see performers of the calibre of Stephen Moore, Sian Phillips and Sheila Steafel trapped voluntarily in a vehicle heading nowhere. 
 The trouble with Paris Match begins with its premise. 
 It is Easter weekend in Paris and, while his wife is away, middle-aged Jacques (Stephen Moore) brings home Julie, a sexy little bimbo played by Leslie Ash in a mini-skirt that is no broader than a cummerbund. 
 Re-enter (naturally) wife Claire (Sian Phillips). 
 To give the farcical complications a kick-start, Poiret asks us to believe that a man, finding himself in this predicament, would try to pass the bimbo off as his daughter from a former marriage, and that the girl, required to account for her surprise visit, would blurt out that she was pregnant. 
 This dodge would not be completely incredible, of course, if the participants were dense or desperate enough, but in Christopher Renshaw's production, they seem to be neither, and particularly not the latter. 
 Throughout, the atmosphere is too casual, and in addition to a grave lack of frantic drivenness, there is a marked absence of the erotic. 
 After all, the situation bulges with seedy potential: a man about to have sex with a girl young enough to be his daughter is suddenly forced to pose as her father. 
 Farce likes to tinker with such taboos. 
 But, although Jacques claims that it is massively frustrating to watch Julie tripping round the flat half-naked and not be able to touch her, Mr Moore fails to project the necessary dashed and deviant desire. 
 Looking more like a bewildered Old English sheepdog than a thwarted child-molester, he throws himself around the place, lying on his back and waggling his feet in the air, as if by an excess of physical effort he could make up for the thinness of the script. 
 Modelling a succession of gasp-provoking Balmain outfits, Sian Phillips maintains a nice, self-amused poise as his wife. 
 But the play, because it wants its bread buttered on both sides, keeps its options open until the end on the issue of whether she is genuinely taken in by her husband's lie or whether her insistence that the girl stay the weekend, her broody concern for the future of the fictitious baby, and marriage-broking on behalf of Julie are just ways of stoking up Jacques's embarrassment. 
 To my mind, the excellent Ms Phillips would be able to give a much funnier performance if she were allowed to let us in on the truth from the outset. 
 There are other incidental delights. 
 Sheila Steafel, in particular, turns in a sharp cameo as the girl's vulgar, port-tippling mother, a disaster area in fake leopard-skin and stacked heels, whose irruption into the proceedings powerfully increases the confusion. 
 Twice, though, Poiret gives a hostage to fortune by invoking the name of Feydeau. 
 &bquo;The most difficult thing in a situation like this,&equo; says Jacques, &bquo;is to find words that haven't been used already in a Feydeau farce,&equo; as though imitating Feydeau's words and situations was something that any fool could do. 
 Paris Match richly demonstrates the error of that view. 
 MUSIC / In praise of cheapness: Producer David Pountney argues that modern composers should not despise the idea of entertainment 
 By DAVID POUNTNEY 
 TO DENY the spirit of opera would mean to deny the development of the human spirit; indeed of human thought'. 
 This is one of many gems to be found in Janacek's Uncollected Essays on Music. 
 Janacek writes words as he writes music &mdash; the two were for him virtually indivisible, and in these abrupt, epigrammatic paragraphs, sometimes brutally down to earth, sometimes fanciful, you can hear him talking &mdash; often shouting in your ear. 
 Words like these are something to hang onto when people ask &bquo;Why is opera fashionable now?&equo; 
 Of course there are the ephemeral reasons &mdash; the admen's discovery of opera's blend of corny emotion with glamour and spectacle; the unpredictable cravings of yuppy culture snackers. 
 But the tide runs deeper than that, and it is surely at one with the desire to reassert the place of the human figure at the heart of all forms of creative life. 
 &bquo;What is more useful in art, to be bound up with mankind and the world, or to be wary of it?&equo; 
 Opera was rejected in the 60s because modernism found its dependence on human emotions embarrassing and messy, and because it seemed politically inept &mdash; a medium housed in monuments to the establishment and inadequate for the expression of political ideologies. 
 Yet political feeling, rather than ideology, is at the heart of all great opera. 
 Opera is too clumsy for ideology &mdash; it has no time for its sub-clauses and selective hatreds. 
 But its massed forces instinctively address the unspoken areas of emotional politics that are in the long run more fundamental. 
 And it illumines too the politics of personal relations: the vital fabric of social life that exists in the silence between people &mdash; exactly that space which is filled by music: &bquo;As the person talked to me in a conventional conversation, I knew, I heard that, inside himself, the person perhaps wept.&equo; 
 Opera is the communal act of listening to this silent voice from inside: it is not surprising that so many people are hungry for the experience it awakens. 
 The result of this hunger could simply be that opera houses survive the dog days of Thatcherism with full houses for Carmen etc., or it could be the creation of new works that express and mirror the social and political needs of our culture in opera's emotive language. 
 But are there composers ready to seize this chance? 
 Many composers now crave the chance to write operas, but will they acknowledge the duty to communicate with the audience? 
 There has always been a sense in which music is a secret, arcane, almost Cabbalistic, art. 
 But this introspective isolation, now compounded in so many cases by the fact that universities are the only institutions able to support a composer's existence, perpetuates the sense that the only right path for a serious composer is the romantic path of high seriousness and absolute individual integrity. 
 Robert Saxton, in these pages, recently denied that there was any longer a problem with contemporary music, and instead lectured the audience about paying closer attention. 
 He did not mention that one definition of a composer's talent is that he can write music that compels an audience's attention. 
 If the Orphic myth defines the power of music, it is because Orpheus compelled an entirely hostile audience to listen to him. 
 Mr Saxton also dismissed the idea of music as &bquo;entertainment&equo;. 
 ENO, I am glad to say, is proud to be dismissed by him to the purgatory reserved for this despicable activity, and more than 450,000 people pass through our doors each year to prove it. 
 If a composer remembers to keep this audience entertained, think what he can say to them all at the same time. 
 An entertained audience is actually there and listening: a bored one has usually gone to dinner. 
 Rehearsing Kurt Weill's Street Scene, I am in daily contact with a composer who was not embarrassed to entertain, nor to adapt his vision to the audience. 
 When he arrived in America, Weill did not automatically expect New York ears to take to the music of the Berlin avant-garde in which he had played so prominent a part: instead he set himself the task of learning to write music with an American accent. 
 Weill correctly perceived that the voice of the American nation was to be found in the musical, but as this form commanded no intellectual respect, the musical establishment has ever since accused him of selling out politically as well as musically. 
 In fact Weill's American years represent a serious struggle to find a way of addressing his lifelong political concerns in a popular language that spoke directly to the American public. 
 Street Scene is the climax of this quest, an opera that speaks with the accents of Broadway, but which holds up a typically critical and compassionate mirror to the face of his adopted city. 
 It is also a vindication of the lesson Weill, though one of Berlin's most intellectual musicians, had taken from his mentor: &bquo;My teacher Busoni, at the end of his life, hammered into me one basic truth which he had arrived at after 50 years pure aestheticism &mdash; the fear of triviality is the greatest handicap for the modern artist, it is the main reason why &bquo;modern&equo; music got more and more removed from reality.&equo; 
 Being trivial is not the whole answer, but it has its place. 
 Janacek's contemporary Krenek wrote a jazz opera called Jonny Spielt Auf. 
 For Janacek, this deserved only contempt: &bquo;Today's opera&hellip; 
 Look, here is street art! 
 The street makes art, Jonny Spielt Auf makes good box office. 
 What a desert, my dear sir, what a desert!&equo; 
 But wasn't this kind of work the best that Krenek could do? 
 It was topical, entertaining and ephemeral &mdash; so ephemeral that it has survived long after Krenek's excruciatingly boring serious works are forgotten. 
 Like most works that over-reach themselves by striving for unattainable seriousness they are probably simply bad. 
 On the other hand, intelligently entertaining and communicative works provide a background from which works of genius can emerge. 
 As Weill reminds us: &bquo;Good light music is appreciated as being more valuable than bad serious music.&equo; 
 Independent readers, with their heroic sponsorship of The Garden Venture, have already been part of the quest for a new operatic voice. 
 ENO too is launching a new Opera Studio &mdash; placing special emphasis on the collaboration between writer and composer (and are also desperately seeking a sponsor!). 
 Both these vital seed-beds must be clear about their objectives. 
 They cannot expect to affect the development of a genius like Janacek. 
 But that realisation should not be a disappointment: rather it liberates us from the job of creating masterpieces, and gives us a much more achievable task. 
 That is quite simply to reduce by say 25 per cent the amount of time the eager opera audience wishes to spend listening to famous old works about famous old people and places, and instead increase the amount of time it wishes to spend listening to new works about ordinary people now. 
 This is an exercise in persuasion, and requires composers who will focus their art on the simple and fundamental act of communication with their enthusiastic but tired, inattentive, restless, distracted and easily bored fellow human beings who none the less long to hear themselves in a not necessarily flattering mirror of music. 
 Our society needs to be given the chance to hear its own heartbeat in its own music &mdash; for pleasure first, then also for knowledge and understanding. 
 Langston Hughes, the black poet Weill chose to write the lyrics for Street Scene, puts it pithily: Cheap little rhymes A cheap little tune Are sometimes as dangerous As a sliver of the moon. 
 A cheap little tune To cheap little rhymes Can cut a man's Throat sometimes. 
 MUSIC / Canada ducks: Allegri String Quartet &mdash; Queen Elizabeth Hall 
 By ADRIAN JACK 
 THE CANADIAN series on the South Bank this week has had a somewhat diluted flavour. 
 Wednesday's concert at the Queen Elizabeth Hall featured the Canadian clarinettist, James Campbell, and the viola-player Rivka Golani, who is based in Toronto. 
 The other players were British. 
 Only three of the five works in the programme could be described as Canadian, and the whole evening left an impression it would be kind to call elusive. 
 It opened with a piece for clarinet and tape by Gregory Levin (born 1943), typical of its time (1975) in its title, Crossroads, and correspondingly anonymous in its taste for weaving of atonal melodic threads. 
 Mr Campbell played it well. 
 He was then joined by the Allegri String Quartet in the Clarinet Quintet by Sir Arthur Bliss. 
 He wrote this long four-movement piece in 1931 for the clarinettist of the day, Frederick Thurston, but might have had in mind his predecessor by 40 years, Richard Muhlfeld, so mellifluously Brahmsian is the style of writing. 
 The Allegri sounded a bit under-nourished against Mr Campbell's easy delivery, particularly in the second movement, which should have had more force, though if one expects a bracing scherzo-like piece at this point, Bliss surely over-wrote it, producing instead the effect of a finale. 
 Miss Golani had only one piece to play &mdash; as one of three irreconcilable characters in Michael Colgrass's Strangers. 
 She livened things up considerably, but then she had the most interesting part &mdash; by turns urgent, sinister and weird, against the clarinet's rather bland melodiousness and the pianist's all-purpose provision of harmony and counterpoint. 
 John York was neat and a little too tactful at the keyboard. 
 Why ever did this easy-on-the-ear but over-long piece get the 1986 Jules Leger Prize for Canadian Chamber Music? 
 Silly question. 
 Eclecticism rules these days, and traditional patterns may be thrown together with all the flair for ill-assortment of current Top-Shop fashions. 
 Which brings us to the next item, the String Quartet No 1 by Srul Irving Glick (born 1934). 
 The exotic folklore-ism towards which Colgrass's piece had eventually groped its way was here unleashed in all its succulence and schmaltz. 
 Real yearning for the old country. 
 The Allegri must have loved playing it. 
 There were only two movements, and the first was a lot more striking than the second, which tended to lose energy with time-filling sequences. 
 Prokofiev, in the final piece of the evening, showed what to do with that kind of thing: his Overture on Hebrew themes, written in 1919 for a group pretending to raise funds for a conservatory in Jerusalem but in fact trying to feed themselves, just sets the tunes in a concise sonata form, and preserves all their humour and charm with hardly a suspicion of the composer intruding. 
 MUSIC / The new deal: BBCSO / Knussen &mdash; Royal Festival Hall 
 By ROBERT MAYCOCK 
 THE GHOST of Charles Ives, still shouting &bquo;stand up and use your ears like a man&equo;, must have stalked the corridors when the opening programme of the BBC Symphony Orchestra's season was under construction. 
 Varese as well as Ives, and an Elliott Carter premiere &mdash; not much feminine sensibility there, though it all made for a classic Oliver Knussen pile-up of Americana, topped out with a violin concerto by Marc Neikrug that Pinchas Zukerman had brought to London for the first time. 
 Then again, it was relatively approachable Carter. 
 This particular novelty was the third short orchestral piece to appear in the last few years, written, like the second, at Knussen's prompting, and it rounded off a performance of all three as a suite, titled Three Occasions for Orchestra. 
 This suite now runs as a broadly balanced progression from fast to slow to fast again, or from the brilliant, epigrammatic and many-layered &mdash; A Celebration of Some 100 x 150 Notes &mdash; to the increasingly linear. 
 In fact the second piece, Remembrance, maintains its ritualistic continuity more through the long-held lines in the background than in the sombre broken utterances of the solo trombone. 
 But the BBC-commissioned Anniversary keeps up an exhilarating flow of counterpoint, flung around from one instrument to another, rich in incident and in side issues but, for all the pace, radiating a quiet air of serenity and sureness. 
 Taken together the pieces offer points of contact with a formidably quick mind that may suggest ways into the longer and more forbidding time-spans of Carter's major works. 
 To that extent they ought to have wide circulation, except that they depend on the kind of painstaking preparation that Knussen had given them &mdash; the music sounded taught and nurtured rather than merely rehearsed. 
 Varese's Arcana needs equal pains if its enormous forces are to operate with clarity. 
 Fourteen percussionists here had a stage of their own, stretching around half of the choir seats, and the average decibel count from the brass was well up in proportion. 
 The concern, though, was always with where the music was going and which of its layers were propelling it, so that the occasional sudden stillnesses became a real opening-up of another dimension in the music's workings and vision, not just a refuelling stop for the orchestra. 
 Thrills with thought: this astonishing piece is necessarily a rare event, and it would be a shame if so astute a performance went unrevived. 
 Ives's Three Places in New England also had a philosophical, meditative character, rather than a passionate or temperamental one. 
 The march tunes heaped up with proper brashness and a wild final acceleration, but the collage until then kept a rare sense of harmonic direction. 
 Neikrug's concerto was a tenderer flower, not at home in this strong company. 
 The music was well-made, sometimes boldly scored, and it produced attractive gestures from the start which glisteningly sampled ideas above a deep held bass. 
 Without sounding exactly like anything else, however, its sum total was more a collection of echoes than a consistent voice. 
 By the time the timpani signalled a perky rapprochement of the Chichester Psalms and the Young Person's Guide, having long ago left Berg behind, there was every reason to be grateful for the consistent vigour of the solo writing and to admire Zukerman's unstinted flair in putting it across. 
 MUSIC / Unholy row: CBSO / Rattle &mdash; Birmingham 
 By JAN SMACZNY 
 THE MOST appealing moment in Mark-Anthony Turnage's engagingly chatty introduction to Three Screaming Popes, his Feeney commission premiere for the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra at the Birmingham Town Hall, came with a stated desire that his music should be accessible to an audience. 
 Well, the Popes, in terrifying orchestral sonorities, certainly screamed and the new composition was, indeed, accessible to the audience. 
 This substantial, 15-minute orchestral movement was inspired by three paintings of Innocent X by Francis Bacon, themselves based on Velasquez. 
 Taking a lead from the artist, Turnage subjected his original material, some Spanish dances, to techniques of submersion and distortion. 
 The result is layers away from the original. 
 Far from being a harmless slice of programme music, Popes is a remarkably positive statement. 
 If at times the surface gives an eclectic impression, the outline of the whole is marvellously clear. 
 Sonorities constantly change and occasionally reach a thrilling pitch of tension with the composer forcing his wind and brass towards their natural upper limit. 
 Perhaps the most genuine tribute to the composer was that, despite the difficulty of the work, the orchestra went about their task with evident relish. 
 Turnage has produced a work which is attractive, disturbing and memorable: an impressive curtain-raiser to a three-year association with the CBSO from which more works are destined to flow. 
 The decision to interpose Stravinsky's Suite No 1 for Small Orchestra as a kind of buffer zone between Beethoven's Leonora No 3 and the Turnage was little short of inspired. 
 The Stravinsky was a welcome up-beat to the new work and it drew a veil over a performance of the overture which apart from a cracking final Presto was emminently forgettable. 
 Brahms' Fourth Symphony, now something of a hardy annual with Rattle and the CBSO, provided the conclusion. 
 Scrutinising this familiar object revealed some untidy details in the first movement: the performers have not quite solved the problem of what must be one of the cruellest openings for an orchestra ever devised. 
 Apart from a notable solo in the Finale, the flute section these days seems to prefer crescendos to decrescendos. 
 But, carping apart, Rattle's performance of the Brahms remains one of the most bracing and intelligent anywhere. 
 OPERA / Czech mates: Welsh National Opera &mdash; Cardiff New Theatre 
 By STEPHEN WALSH 
 WHEN IT was new, Rudolf Noelte's Bartered Bride for Welsh National Opera offered a notably austere view of Smetanesque comedy, with its single, dominating barn set (Jan Schlubach), its complete avoidance of condescension and slapstick and its severely geometrical stage placings. 
 Seven years on, much of this character survives in Mike Ashman's revival: it remains one of the least pantomimic of Brides (though the circus, with brilliant tightrope dancing by Brenda Larenty, is a startling exception). 
 But the impression is untidier, less focused and &mdash; some will say &mdash; more exuberant. 
 Ashman seems to make more whimsical use of the device of exit up-stage, re-entry stage right (whether the idea is Ashman's or Noelte's, its use in duets where one knows the exiting character has a line to sing almost at once, soon becomes irritating). 
 Above all, this is a less regimented show than Noelte made it; the chorus work is scrappy, and sometimes looks under-rehearsed, with much School-of-Sadlers-Wells handshaking and glass-waving. 
 Though one thinks of The Bartered Bride (among other things) as a cataract of marvellous vocal melody, it is rarely well performed in Britain, mainly because of our lack of really deep-chested lyric tenors of the type that can making singing Czechs such enthralling neighbours. 
 This problem is very much in evidence in Cardiff. 
 Ryland Davies is a fluent and musically amiable Jenik, but he is plainly not at home in the long and crucial stretches of middle-to-low register that Smetana throws at him; and the same is true of David Owen's otherwise rather stylish Vasek. 
 In fact, the only male singer in the cast able to convince that his part might have been written for him is Stafford Dean, who gives a beautifully focused and intelligent Kecal, somewhat constrained, though, by the context. 
 Much nearer to the intense spirit of the original staging is Christine Bunning's Marenka, taking her tone from the opening duet with Jenik, which can so easily project the character as a social and emotional misfit. 
 Something vulnerable in her manner brings out an element of sadism in the way the long final act teases her endurance; but it also makes the denouement extremely touching, and the part lies well for a voice that has managed Janacek's Capture as well as Verdi's Violetta. 
 When all is said and done, The Bartered Bride is rarely less than enchanting. 
 But this revival will enchant still more when Sir Charles Mackerras has tidied up stage-pit ensemble, and refined some aspects of the orchestral sound. 
 However, lively detail is no substitute for an integrated texture of the sort we have come to expect from the WNO chorus and orchestra. 
 RECORDS / Marital infidelities 
 By MISHA DONAT 
 THE NINETEENTH century could never reconcile itself to Cosi fan tutte, that most consistently inspired of great operas. 
 Beethoven, whose own opera of marital fidelity was heavily influenced by its music, regarded it as immoral -a reaction at least healthier than that of most commentators, who dismissed its plot as merely frivolous, and unworthy of Mozart. 
 As for Mozart himself, who had married the sister of the woman he loved, the subject of Cosi must surely have given him food for thought. 
 The opera's subtitle is &bquo;The School for Loves&equo;; and during the course of this dangerous experiment in human emotions, in which the two sisters unwittingly find themselves seduced by each other's lover, all four central protagonists learn something about themselves. 
 Nor can there be much doubt that the experience is more painful for the men than the duped women. 
 James Levine's new recording takes the opera very seriously indeed: it is a Cosi without, perhaps, a great deal of fun, but one with considerable insight. 
 Every single word of recitative is included (with a spasmodic fortepiano accompaniment that takes some getting used to), and all six characters are delineated with exceptional vividness. 
 In this opera of ensembles there is, however, a price to pay for such fierce individualization: the beauty of Mozart's blended vocal writing is sometimes sacrificed, and there is little sense of joint wonderment as each new turn of events is unfolded. 
 (Mozart's characteristic sotto voce seems in any case not to be in James Levine's vocabulary.) 
 The cast is first-rate. 
 Kiri Te Kanawa's Fiordiligi and Thomas Hampson's Guglielmo give particular pleasure throughout. 
 Only Ferruccio Furlanetto's consistently aggressive rendering of the cynical bachelor Don Alfonso becomes an irritant. 
 The recording is generally good, though the orchestra sounds curiously recessed in the concluding pages of the Act I finale. 
 There are, too, a few ensemble lapses that should have been corrected. 
 If in Cosi it is the women who are put upon, then in L'Italiana in Algeri it is the eponymous heroine who wears the trousers &mdash; or so, at least, it ought to be. 
 Alas, Agnes Baltsa is hopelessly miscast in DG's new recording of Rossini's frothiest comic opera. 
 Her lack of authority is helped neither by a recorded balance that places her too far from the microphone throughout, nor by Claudio Abbado's propensity for extremes of tempo. 
 With this vital flaw, and with Ruggero Raimondi also failing to make much of an impact as the comically menacing Bey, the performance never gets off the ground. 
 There is more to enjoy in Decca's Barber of Seville &mdash; particularly Cecilia Bartoli's fresh and delightful performance as Rosina. 
 However, William Matteuzzi's Almaviva is so weak that it requires a considerable stretch of the imagination to picture her preferring the young Count to the lecherous old Dr Bartolo; and although the late Giuseppe Patane conducts the score with obvious affection, he has little flare for dramatic pacing. 
 On an altogether higher level &mdash; indeed, among the finest opera recordings to appear in recent months &mdash; is John Eliot Gardiner's new version of Rossini's penultimate opera, Le Comte Ory. 
 It is not difficult to understand why Berlioz was such an admirer of this opulently scored work. 
 As a comic opera, it is very much sui generis: all the recitatives are furnished with orchestral accompaniment, and the music is both continuous and strongly unified. 
 The plot is more than faintly ludicrous but the music is Rossini at his most inspired &mdash; even when one suspects that he is writing with tongue in cheek. 
 The Act II trio, in which the labyrinth of disguises reaches a peak of intricacy, is one of his most sensual pieces. 
 The Philips recording, although made in the studio, is based on stagings at the Lyons Opera last year. 
 It offers a reminder of what can be achieved without recourse to star names or the Vienna Philharmonic. 
 Bookshop Window 
 By MISHA DONAT 
 IF THIS WAS HAPPINESS by Barbara Leaming, Weidenfeld &amp; Nicolson &pound;14.95 Barbara Leaming wrote a biography of Orson Welles almost as fat as its subject. 
 This is a suitably slimmer volume on one of his wives, Rita Hayworth. 
 She was a professional dancer at 12; her father partnered her on stage and, according to this book, did far worse to her off it. 
 Screen-tested four years later, she did something nasty to her hairline in the interests of personal sultriness, and was soon starring with Fred Astaire in You'll Never Get Rich and You Were Never Lovelier. 
 She proved both wrong, getting richer and lovelier by the hour. 
 This led her into masterpieces like Gilda and The Lady from Shanghai, plus a fistful of failed marriages. 
 Ms Leaming tells it all with vim, though the gossip turns her on far more than the movies: &bquo;Aly practised an Eastern art of love known as Imsak, which allowed him to exercise indefinite control&hellip;&equo; 
 With a bit more Imsak, this could have been a great book. 
 POETS AT WORK, ed. 
 George Plimpton, Penguin &pound;6.99 So far we have had eight collections of interviews from The Paris Review. 
 Now the editors have picked out some plums to make up a poets' special - from Eliot and Auden, through Allen Ginsberg ('I think it was about the same time that I was having these Blake visions') to John Ashbery and the delightful Elizabeth Bishop. 
 Although some of the questions are dippy, the volume is an inimitable record of poetic opinions and conversational habits. 
 Where else could you learn that Pound threw Robert Frost over his head in a restaurant? 
 BOOK REVIEW / A buried treasury of wicked wits: Claire Tomalin on surprising riches in a book which traces the ancestry of women's poetry. 
 &bquo;Eighteenth Century Women Poets&equo; &mdash; Ed. 
 Roger Lonsdale: Oxford, 20 pounds 
 By CLAIRE TOMALIN 
 IN 1730 or thereabouts Hetty, the naughty sister of John and Charles Wesley, wrote some verses on the subject of marriage. 
 They ended with lines which leave the reader in no doubt as to her view of the condition: That wretch, if such a wretch there be Who hopes for happiness from thee, May search successfully as well For truth in whores and ease in hell. 
 Hetty, the child of a clergyman and one of 19 siblings, had been taught, as a child, to cry softly for fear of being beaten; &bquo;by which means,&equo; she wrote, &bquo;the family usually lived in as much quietness as if there had not been a child among them.&equo; 
 Hetty could read Greek by the age of eight; not surprisingly perhaps, she was in full rebellion by her twenties. 
 She refused to marry the first husband proposed by her father, and ran away more than once with lovers of her own choosing; when she came home pregnant she was sold off with a dowry to a plumber called William Wright. 
 The couple had little in common, and her children died in infancy, one after another, a loss she attributed to the lead works Wright ran on their premises. 
 She was described as elegant, with great refinement of manners, and beautiful in her youth; later she had &bquo;the appearance of being brokenhearted&equo;. 
 Although her satire on wedlock was not published for more than a century after her death, its composition elicited an immediate rebuke from her brother Samuel, who admonished her thus: Repent, renounce all wicked wit:&hellip; 
 So may the world your flights forget, And God forgive, and Willy pardon. 
 Willy, thus bracketed with the Almighty, was of course her husband. 
 We, however, may think that Hetty's wicked wit was the best thing about her. 
 This fascinating story is one of many such in Roger Lonsdale's anthology of Eighteenth-Century Women Poets, not just a marvellous piece of scholarship but as richly entertaining and original a book as I have come across for some time. 
 Out of the dust of the Bodleian, Dr Lonsdale has resurrected more than a hundred witty women and set them glistening and pulsing with life and spirits before us; and through their fresh and often subversive eyes, the Augustan age seems much closer than it did. 
 How many women poets of the eighteenth century can most of us name? 
 I was stuck after Anne, Countess of Winchilsea, Lady Mary Wortley Montagu, Joanna Baillie, Mrs Barbauld and Helen Maria Williams. 
 Lonsdale's ladies are by no means all aristocrats or the daughters of schoolmasters and clergymen; they include washerwomen, milkwomen and servant girls; the disreputable and the priggish, the contented spinster and the erring Duchess; loving wives, bluestockings, governesses, actresses and invalids are all represented. 
 Their biographies contain material for a dozen books. 
 The number of women poets swelled through the century, not least because they learnt they could speak to one another in this way. 
 The discontents and aspirations of each individual woman found an answering voice; joined together, they became a chorus of inspiration for feminism. 
 They were helped by provincial publishers who saw money in the subscription system and the growing market of women readers. 
 Some were encouraged by Richardson, and by Dr Johnson, a fervent believer in the abilities of women. 
 Many of the poems naturally have feminist themes &mdash; complaints about lack of formal education, domestic duties and brutish husbands: &bquo;Wife and servant are the same / But only differ in the name&equo;. 
 One bold woman, Miss W-, takes on Swift. 
 Her answer to the Dean's famous poem on Celia's dressing room &bquo;is not recommended to readers of a nervous disposition (ed)&equo;; in parts it is more disgusting than the original. 
 It is also devastating. 
 &bquo;Of course the poetry's no good,&equo; grumbled a friend to whom I was praising this volume. 
 He has not read it yet, but in any case he is wrong. 
 There may be no single poem in it to equal Pope's Eloisa to Abelard (1717), Gray's Elegy (1751) or Coleridge's Frost at Midnight (1798); but one of Lonsdale's intentions is to encourage us to extend our definition of what constitutes poetry. 
 As in his earlier anthology, The New Oxford Book of Eighteenth Century Verse (1984), he sets out &bquo;to question some of the deeply ingrained preconceptions about what it was possible to feel, think, and write in the eighteenth century&equo;. 
 The most striking vein he mines is that of conversational and epistolatory poems; they run through the century, offering character sketches, rural and city scenes, drawing-room and marital exchanges. 
 One of the finest, by one of the finest poets, the Cumbrian Susanna Blamire, is &bquo;Wey, Ned, Man&equo;, recording a conversation she overheard about Tom Paine's &bquo;Reets o'Man&equo;. 
 Lonsdale also includes Blamire's enchanting epistle, written to friends and describing a day which included doctoring the local children with her own medicines. 
 She apologises for her simplicity, giving a busy woman's reason: &bquo;Tis true I write in shortened measure, Because I scrawl but at my leisure; For why? &mdash; sublimity of style Takes up a most prodigious while&hellip; 
 Blamire also wrote songs and lyrics of great beauty, including the well known &bquo;And ye shall walk in silk attire&equo;. 
 The century also delivered a few gorgeous formal feminine odes: the Countess of Winchilsea's address &bquo;To Spleen&equo; and Henrietta O'Neill's &bquo;Ode to the Poppy&equo;, with its almost Keatsian languor. 
 Lonsdale finds that, as the century progressed, increasing refinement of taste led to a loss of the informality, humour and immediacy that he prizes most; and it was precisely the strained and highflown verse that was eclipsed by the success of Lyrical Ballads. 
 &bquo;Ladies&equo; verse' became a phrase of scorn; anthologies ceased to include any, readers forgot its existence, and Elizabeth Barrett Browning was able to complain that she had no poetic grandmothers. 
 Feminists will want to thank Lonsdale for restoring Mrs Browning's poetic ancestors, but not feminists alone. 
 Historians will find rich material, and so will the general reader prepared to browse and surrender to the many different idioms, rhythms and personalities revealed here. 
 A review of this length can only touch on its range. 
 The book has more than one useful index, notes and an informative introduction. 
 For a taste of the verses see the paragraph (left) from Elizabeth Hands: a servant has published a poem on the biblical story of the rape of Tamar, and here imagines the conversation in the drawing room about it. 
 Like so many of Lonsdale's ladies she is surprising; yet she speaks to us with a directness that wipes out the centuries. 
 &bquo;Lonsdale's ladies are by no means all aristocrats.&equo; 
 The actress Sarah Siddons by John Downman, 1787. 
 From &bquo;The National Portrait Gallery Collection&equo; (NPG, &pound;14.95) a lavish selection of paintings with useful historical essays. 
 Quotation from: On the Supposition of an Advertisement Appearing in a Morning Paper, Poems by a Serving Maid having been Published (1789) by Elizabeth Hands. 
 &bquo;You've read it, I find,&equo; says Miss Harriot Anderson; &bquo;Pray, sir, is it anything like Sir Charles Grandison?&equo; 
 &bquo;How you talk,&equo; says Miss Belle, &bquo;how should such a girl write A novel, or anything else that's polite? 
 You'll know better in time, Miss.&equo; 
 &mdash; She was but fifteen: Her mamma was confused &mdash; with a little chagrin, Says, &bquo;Where's your attention, child? 
 Did not you hear Miss Rhymer say that it was poems, my dear?&equo; 
 Says Sir Timothy Turtle, &bquo;My daughters ne'er look In anything else but a cookery-book: The properest study for women designed.&equo; 
 BOOK REVIEW / Thanks to the Universe: &bquo;The Temple of my Familiar&equo; &mdash; Alice Walker: The Women's Press, 12.95 pounds 
 By JILL NEVILLE 
 &bquo;A ROMANCE of the last 500,000 years&equo; is how Alice Walker describes her latest novel. 
 It is tricked out with a handsome jacket and contains the standard acknowledgements, including the author's thanks to the Universe for her participation in Existence. 
 Fatal signs of weakness in American women's fiction, these earnest references to &bquo;cheerful support&equo;, &bquo;gracefulness and skill&equo;, &bquo;sensitive criticism&equo; and &bquo;inspiring example&equo; are no doubt useful as emotional blackmail to inveigle the reader into the moist sisterhood of approval. 
 Alas, this book need all the blackmail it can get, for it cannot stand up by itself to disinterested scrutiny. 
 Almost everything is wrong with it, in particular the tone, which is enormously soppy: hard to credit from the author of The Color Purple. 
 Most modern black writing (read largely by white readers) constitutes a Literature of Blame, and it is certainly our turn to bow the neck and bear the blows. 
 Once more we have the horrors of the slave-trade: the vicious overseer; the destroyed African communities; the black women endlessly raped, their backbones scraping along the ground, their smothered screams. 
 But, with its lack of paradox, its sonorous and sentimental prose, The Temple of My Familiar reads like one enormous gospel-chant of reassurance for blacks, devoid somehow of truth. 
 In fact it something called the &bquo;Gospel According to Shug&equo;, which is meant to be taken seriously: &bquo;HELPED are those who love the lesbian, the gay and the straight, as they love the sun, the moon and the stars. 
 None of their children, nor any of their ancestors, nor any parts of themselves, shall be hidden from them.&equo; 
 Walker retells the history of the world from the black perspective with a series of symbolic vignettes. 
 These &bquo;fireside&equo; monologues emerge from an assortment of inter-related characters and jump back through time to poor white Adam, (Nature's mistake). 
 Old Miss Lissie not only remembers her previous lives, but changes physically when she does so. 
 Hence photographs of herself taken by a lover look like lots of different women. 
 Readers who believe in reincarnation will probably not find all this such tough going. 
 (Sometimes the discussion of rebirth sounds like Shirley Maclean's writings on &bquo;channelling&equo;, though one suspects it is not meant to.) 
 But it would also be helpful to believe in some paradisal previous age of matriarchy and goddess-worship, to believe in astrology and to believe in the rightneousness of each feminist reflex. 
 There is one scene in which the straight-guy Suwelo refuses to push a cart to the shops, he would rather go by car; pushing a cart makes him feel un-manned. 
 His wife Fanny is appalled by this unreconstructed maleness which is called a &bquo;little murder&equo;. 
 Fanny is mystical and tends to go away on her own, so Suwelo has an affair with Carlotta, who wears three-inch heels. 
 Carlotta is just comforting herself. 
 Her husband, the all-wise singer Arveyda (named after a bar of soap) has run off with his mother-in-law (a terrific story, this, and well-told). 
 But they all end up happily together in orgasmic reconciliation. 
 In contrast to the melodramatic historical memoirs there is a poignant moment when Suwelo faces the memory of his parents, who were killed in a car accident. 
 Often the wonderful natural natural story-teller in Walker breaks through the marshmallow and has us on the edge of the chair, but finally and lamentably this is a failure. 
 It would be insulting to someone of Walker's stature to pretend otherwise. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Tales of true suffering in Eritrea: &bquo;Towards Asmara&equo; &mdash; Thomas Keneally: Hodder &amp; Stoughton, 12.95 pounds 
 By JEREMY BROOKS 
 WE HAVE become used to seeing Thomas Keneally centre his novels on well-researched historical events, from the charge of Joan of Arc (in the extraordinary Blood Red, Sister Rose of 1974) through the convict settlement of Australia, the American civil war and the negotiations that ended World War I to his Booker Prize-winner, Schindler's Ark, set in Poland at the height of the holocaust, an unforgettable and moving book. 
 In his new novel, Towards Asmara, Keneally is writing about the present; or, more accurately, about a historical event that is not yet over. 
 Eritrea's struggle for its independence from Ethiopia has gone on, first against Haile Selassie and then against the Soviet-backed Mengistu regime, since 1952, when the UN feebly handed over control of its Trust Territory to Addis Ababa. 
 The suffering and the slaughter have been almost unbelievable. 
 It is a largely forgotten war in which, as Soviet enthusiasm has waned, and Mengistu has been deposed, the Eritreans have increasingly gained the upper hand. 
 As I write there are a few small, unexcited newspaper reports about the progress of peace talks taking place, under the aegis of ex-President Jimmy Carter, in Atlanta, Georgia. 
 The Eritreans are described, as usual, as &bquo;the rebels&equo;. 
 It is not possible to review this novel without such a background sketch, however flimsy. 
 The narrator of the book, Darcy, a lawyer-turned-journalist in flight from a failed marriage, is inspired by a thinly-disguised Bob Geldof figure to question his ignorance about these matters. 
 He makes contacts with Eritrean representatives in London, and then the professional lure of a scoop brings him, bumpily, to the front line in the mountains, with Asmara, the capital, only a 100 miles away. 
 Keneally himself, researching the book, trod this same hazardous path in 1987, and one may suppose that much of what Darcy describes, Keneally saw, that much of what Darcy feels, Keneally experienced. 
 But it is into the mouth of one of Darcy's travelling companions that the heart of Keneally's emotional response to the Eritreans is put. 
 This is an elderly Englishwoman who has &bquo;inherited&equo; from an aunt her engagement with &bquo;the struggle against the mutilation of girl children&equo;, or female circumcision. 
 She is the widow of a life peer but is referred to throughout as &bquo;Lady Julie&equo; &mdash; the author indulging here in a little Pom-teasing. 
 Lady Julie observes, as Darcy has been observing with increasing awe, the extraordinarily civilised behaviour of the Eritreans; their exemplary treatment of prisoners ('We will insult you with our compassion'); their well-organised aid programmes; their balanced egalitarianism and their passion for educating their children even under the most appallingly adverse conditions. 
 Finally she is forced into exclaiming, with almost bewildered amazement: &bquo;These people are it! 
 The link! 
 A new level of moral being!&equo; 
 You may think this is way over the top, but by the time he gets there the reader, if he believes (as I do) in Keneally's veracity, will have experienced the same emotion. 
 Darcy focuses his own feelings on an Eritrean woman, a &bquo;splendid bureaucrat&equo; now based in Frankfurt but currently visiting the front line to renew her networks of information, and dreams hazily of a future sexual relationship with her until he discovers that she had once undergone, at the hands of the Dergue, such stomach-churning extremes of physical torture that &bquo;my distance from such a height of anguish disqualified me.&equo; 
 Of course it would. 
 It is such universal perceptions as those of Darcy and Lady Julie that mark out Keneally as a major novelist. 
 One might, as I usually do with one of his novels, quarrel mildly about his formal devices; but that would be an irrelevant vanity. 
 He makes the world stand up and speak to one. 
 You can't niggle about detail after that. 
 Recommended Books 
 By JEREMY BROOKS 
 A New Path to the Waterfall by Raymond Carver, Collins Harvill &pound;11. 
 A moving collection of poems by the late American storyteller, with an important introduction by his widow. 
 Reviewed by Hugo Barnacle, 23 September. 
 London Fields by Martin Amis, Cape &pound;11.95. 
 A typically startling, ambitious novel of murder and other threats. 
 Reviewed by Wendy Steiner, 23 September. 
 The Trick of It by Michael Frayn, Viking &pound;11.95. 
 A novel about novel-writing, which handles its tricky subject with a light touch. 
 Reviewed by Mark Lawson, 23 September. 
 Europe, Europe by Hans Magnus Enzensberger, Hutchinson &pound;14.95. 
 A lively tour of continental culture, seeking for signs of unity and predicting a grim future. 
 Reviewed by Anthony Burgess, 30 September. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Sisson: poet and commuter analyst: C J Fox welcomes the scorn and vigour shown by the memoirs of C H Sisson: &bquo;On the Look-Out&equo; &mdash; C H Sisson: Carcanet, 14.95 pounds 
 By C J FOX 
 C H SISSON &mdash; poet, translator, novelist, critic, polemicist, former Whitehall mandarin and the candidate who should have won Oxford's Chair of Poetry &mdash; has finally unveiled his life's story, most of it told, with typical unconventionality, backwards. 
 It begins in 1964 and works back to the author's birth. 
 &bquo;If anything can be concluded from this book, it is that I was born,&equo; writes Sisson after touching on that event, which occurred 75 years ago in a building since occupied by the Bristol Rovers Supporters Club. 
 The author notwithstanding, many conclusions can be drawn from this steel-trap of a book; about Berlin in Thirties turmoil, for example, as observed by a keen-eyed young loner from Bristol. 
 Certainly it can be concluded that the circumstances of Sisson's early life fuelled his salutary hatreds and helped form the outsider's perspective which now makes him a scourge of the age's insidious orthodoxies. 
 So it's with added comprehension that a reader of On the Look-Out can approach the taut ferocity of Sisson's early poems and the sombreness of those more recent, the jarring plainness of his Divine Comedy and other such translations, the savagery of his two gaunt novels, and the war against fashion-induced mediocrity waged by Sisson the literary critic. 
 More comprehensible too are his Seventies revolt (fatal to his Whitehall career) against the trendy refurbishment of the Civil Service and his scorn for Official Culture and for further dilution of the Anglicanism he cherishes. 
 Sisson's background, as now revealed, was the stark world of an artisan family stuck in down-at-heel Bristol. 
 &bquo;The whole country was hostile&hellip; its shabbiness I took for granted,&equo; Sisson recalls about his school-age surroundings. 
 &bquo;I must have gone to and fro in great concentration of spirit, always anxious to get on.&equo; 
 The &bquo;concentration of the spirit&equo; enabled this solitary youth to achieve a prodigious amount of literary self-education. 
 He thus arrived at his city's University in the Depression, well primed for encounters there with the suspect notions of Eliot, Pound and T E Hulme. 
 But Bristol wasn't Oxbridge, which compounded his sense of alienation from the left-wingery of those high-flying Young Gentlemen, Auden, Spender &amp; Co. 
 Still, Sisson managed a &bquo;Herr Issyvoo&equo; sting of his own in the Nazified Berlin of 1934 and watched ideological street-squads slanging one another in Paris the next year. 
 The German sights in particular &mdash; torchlit orgies of Nazi triumph, Hitler ranting in Stuttgart, storm-troopers stamping out the last flickers of academic freedom in Freiburg &mdash; showed him what lay in store for Europe and are vividly recounted here. 
 Though he took his professional plunge into the Ministry of Labour soon afterwards, Sisson also began writing, taking the outsider's route by contributing to obscure journals of the heterodoxy. 
 His subsequent Wartime lot was equally offbeat though hardly agreeable, contending against boredom and filth along the northern marches of India. 
 Re-immersion in the Ministry followed this prolonged servility, but a breakthrough came with the Fifties publication of An Asiatic Romance, a satirical fantasy explosively pointing up bureaucracy's absurdity and irrelevance in a world reduced to violence and cannibalism. 
 By 1960, Sisson was a top Civil Servant ('civil to everyone, and servant to the devil') and had published a treatise called The Spirit of British Administration, memorable for its irony as well as its broad view of the subject. 
 (Of Pontius Pilate: &bquo;The steps he took to still a particular local clamour were more or less what the service required, and he washed his hands with a civilised regret.&equo;) 
 The collections of his poetry began to appear, notably a searing logbook of life as a commuting careerist, The London Zoo. 
 The floodgates were now open and it is from here that the reverse sequence of On the Look-Out commences. 
 This &bquo;partial autobiography&equo; bristles satirically. 
 Manchester, for instance, is deemed &bquo;one of those disgraces by which the human race advertises the squalor and turpitude of its mind.&equo; 
 Of parish-pump politics in his old suburban nesting place, Sevenoaks: &bquo;While everyone would pretend that a solution was what was wanted when there was a problem, in fact what most people wanted was trouble&hellip; 
 The fatal addiction of the human race to trouble is something which, even at 50, has not ceased to amaze me.&equo; 
 The technique of reverse narrative is nothing new for Sisson. 
 His novel, Christopher Homm, took its forlorn hero from septuagenarian death back to his doom-shrouded entry into life. 
 On the Look-Out derives extra momentum from this eccentric procedure. 
 But Sisson, in addition to bringing his story up to date with a final chapter, interjects halfway through a lengthy segment on his war. 
 With its subject-matter mainly the crushing ennui of that experience, this section hampers the flow of the overall narrative somewhat, despite the crispness of its recollections. 
 Much more telling as a crystallization of the Wartime ordeal is &bquo;In the Raj&equo;, included in that lynchpin volume of Carcanet's big Sisson list, the 1984 Collected Poems. 
 But as if to prove his powers of condensation in the autobiography, Sisson exercises remarkable reticence on matters of personal and family sentiment. 
 Yet throughout he brandishes a fearless and confident individuality of judgement. 
 There is exhilaration to be had from his fresh vistas, vigorous assertions as they are of a truly independent mind. 
 BOOK REVIEW / The cause without a rebel: &bquo;The Pale Companion&equo; &mdash; Andrew Motion: Viking, 11.95 pounds 
 By MARTIN PACEY 
 IT WAS unfair of Auden to suggest, in his &bquo;Letter to Lord Byron&equo;, that a poet's &bquo;sense of other people's very hazy&equo;. 
 But the vaporous presences that float through this slender and anaemic first novel by a notable poet would appear to support the claim. 
 The book &mdash; which opens a projected sequence of novels that will cover the period from 1968 to the present day &mdash; aims to explore what the blurb describes as &bquo;the painful transition from youth to adulthood&equo;. 
 This, of course, is a popular subject: it seems particularly attractive to the poet-turned-novelist because of the scope it offers for the tremulously sensitive probing of feelings. 
 Sensitivity, though, is not enough. 
 What Andrew Motion presents us with here is a static and humourless mood-piece filled with over-elaborate imagery. 
 The hero, Francis Mayne, is suffering from the adolescent's emotional confusion and acute self-consciousness. 
 He finds it hard to communicate with people, not least his separated parents. 
 His father is a faceless figure: a retired brigadier, reserved and taciturn. 
 His mother, by contrast, is the most vividly realised character in the book: nervy, flirtatious and selfish, already on her third husband, she thinks primarily of her appearance, even when visiting her dying daughter, Francis's twin. 
 The first half of the novel is dominated by the girl's death from leukaemia. 
 There is a refreshing simplicity and tenderness in Motion's account of the way Francis nurses her, but she herself is too sketchily drawn for the episode to carry much weight. 
 Meanwhile, at his public school, Francis is conducting a love-affair with an older pupil named Keith Ogilvie. 
 He is finally rejected by the devious, arrogant Keith, who informs him that he is &bquo;obsolete&equo; because he does not &bquo;know how to make things happen&equo;. 
 His response to this rejection is as flat as his reaction to the massive demonstration which Keith has earlier persuaded him to join against the Vietnam War. 
 This violent event, described at length in hysterically colourful terms, is the only piece of history to be woven convincingly into the plot. 
 Other broad hints as to the date are inserted with a comical lack of subtlety: &bquo;My God, darling, have you heard?&equo; exclaims Francis's mother one day as she greets him, &bquo;Czechoslovakia. 
 It's been invaded.&equo; 
 Motion will have to do better than this if he seriously intends his series of novels to capture the feel of a period. 
 But the book's principal defect remains the vacuity of its protagonist. 
 In his eagerness to depict the cloudy psychology of an adolescent, Motion has forgotten to give the boy a personality. 
 He has, however, given him a psychotic compulsion to formulate fanciful similes. 
 Hardly a page goes by without the hapless Francis noticing something which reminds him, improbably, of something else. 
 Sometimes he is reminded of several things. 
 One moment an avenue of chestnut trees looks &bquo;like a child's drawing of ghosts&equo;; the next it appears &bquo;frightening but derelict, like extinguished chandeliers&equo;; and finally the chestnuts &bquo;prance at him, holding up their gleaming branches like hysterics.&equo; 
 Such writing rapidly palls, and I hope that in the novels to come, Motion can curb his reckless passion for it. 
 BOOK REVIEW / The tooth and the socket: &bquo;The Bellarosa Connection&equo; &mdash; Saul Bellow: Penguin, 3.50 pounds 
 By ANTHONY QUINN 
 A TITLE like The Bellarosa Connection tends to imply two things: first, that the book will be a jacket-straining 600 pages; and second, that its author will be Robert Ludlum. 
 Neither is the case. 
 Saul Bellow's new novella, his second in six months, is a mean 100 pages. 
 Coming from a writer whose reputation is built on large, expansive, improvisatory novels, these two miniatures seem a bit of an anomaly, or maybe just a diversion. 
 A Theft was exhilarating, but it faded very quickly; this new one, too, suffers a slight anticlimactic wobble at its turning point. 
 The story is recounted by the unnamed founder of the Mnemosyne Institute in Philadelphia, an elderly widower who has recently retired after making his millions as instructor to &bquo;executives, politicians and members of the defense establishment&equo;. 
 His theme is memory, a faculty with which he has been prodigiously blessed, though his origins as &bquo;the child of Russian Jews from New Jersey&equo; are held rather as a noble refusal to forget. 
 This same impulse leads him to recall the life of Harry Fonstein, a distant friend who miraculously escaped the Nazi holocaust, thanks to an underground operation masterminded by the Broadway impresario Billy Rose, or &bquo;Bella Rosa&equo; as his name sounds when whispered in excitable Italian. 
 Having arrived in New York via Cuba, the immigrant Fonstein seeks out Rose in order to express an entirely natural gratitude, but is shunned at every turn. 
 His letters are sent back, and when he tries to approach Rose in a restaurant he is ignored, then ejected. 
 The narrator identifies a larger issue behind this slight: it is the conflict between two kinds of Jewishness, between the embattled, coarse-grained immigrant from Europe and the wordly, go-ahead American, who rates business acumen and individual assertion over the value of community ties. 
 Billy is a thoroughly American creation, a Broadway mogul, dandy and gossip columnist with a &bquo;bug-like tropism for publicity&equo;. 
 His bloated self-aggrandisement is punctured, however, by the formidable intervention of Harry's &bquo;tiger wife&equo;. 
 Sorella, an enormous woman who brings out Bellow's near-parental tenderness for physical peculiarity. 
 Her obesity also represents a spiritual condition extended into bodily metaphor: hers is an immensity of soul. 
 Confronting Billy with his unworthy behaviour towards her husband, she exposes this &bquo;legend&equo; as a cheap fake. 
 When Sorella recounts this face-off, it's also intended as a moment of recognition, an anagnorisis, for the narrator. 
 Yet her candour and self-knowledge &mdash; &bquo;I am built like a Mack truck. 
 My flesh is boundless&equo; - hardly qualify as a testament to a &bquo;major force of personality&equo;. 
 Does Bellow think we should be amazed? 
 These insights look rather small when set next to his previous books of revelations. 
 If there has been a diminution in the voltage, however, there are compensating pleasures of wit. 
 Even the minor characterisations in this book bristle with prickly detail; the narrator's unloved Aunt Mildred &bquo;had a powdered look, like her own strudel&equo;; Wolfe, one of Billy's ghost-writers, &bquo;builds up his reputation as a weirdo nihilist. 
 He wants to become the Thomas Mann of science fiction&equo;. 
 This dry contempt strolls out even when its target is invisible: the narrator telephones the Fonsteins' house years after they have lost contact and is answered by a young man, on whom he forms an immediate image &mdash; &bquo;a thick head of hair, a beer paunch, a T-shirt with a logo or slogan. 
 Act Up was a popular one.&equo; 
 The conversation which follows is the last in the book, and the weakest, too, a stagey means of imparting some crucial news for Bellow to fulminate against all that is rotten and cynical in American youth. 
 It's passionately felt, for sure, but perhaps not adequately dramatised. 
 When that news hits him, the narrator seems to crumble, even though a premonitory dream the night before has readied him for the shock. 
 Shadows have lengthened stealthily in the course of The Bellarosa Connection, gathering for what Martin Amis described in later Bellow as &bquo;last things, leave-taking, and final lucidities&equo;, and at the close there is a quietly affecting image of the narrator setting down his story, alone. 
 &bquo;At times I feel like a socket that remembers its tooth&equo;, he writes, trying to retain some sense of the world even as he prepares to leave it. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Alpine village idioms: &bquo;Once in Europa&equo; &mdash; John Berger: Granta Books, 10.95 pounds 
 By HUGO BARNACLE 
 THIS STRONG collection of stories is the second in a trilogy about the peasants of the French Alps, where John Berger lives. 
 He produces the stories at a craftsmanlike rate, no more than one a year, so it is some time since the appearance of the first volume, Pig Earth. 
 The cover photograph shows Berger gone native, in dark suit, stiff collar and homburg hat, for all the world like a French shepherd (a berger, in fact) on his way to a wedding. 
 &bquo;In our village, as in many villages in the world at that time, there was a souvenir shop,&equo; one story goes. 
 &bquo;You could buy there skiers in glass bottles&hellip; clockwork marmots, goat horns&hellip; sunglasses, imitation butter-churns, my books.&equo; 
 It is part of Berger's purpose that he be seen as a village artisan. 
 Pig Earth dealt with the traditional pattern of Savoyard life. 
 This book is set against the breakdown of the pattern in recent times, the next will concentrate on peasants who have moved to the city. 
 But the stories have a universal appeal simply as stories, and it is good that the underlying programme seldom obtrudes as badly as in the gift-shop passage above, where the helpful aside about tourism affecting rural culture worldwide strikes a primary-school note. 
 The gift-shop used to be a farmhouse, one of several owned by the skinflint farmer Boris who made his fortune by never paying bills. 
 The house now belongs to a buxom blonde from Lyon, wife of a driving instructor. 
 When Boris began sleeping with her, villagers who wondered what would happen if the husband found out were told by wiser villagers: &bquo;If you'd lived in a big town you'd know that the husband knows.&equo; 
 Boris showered the woman with presents, eventually including the house which was what she (and her husband) really wanted. 
 Realising that she had not loved him, Boris then starved himself to death. 
 Berger sets this story up by saying: &bquo;Sometimes to refute a single sentence it is necessary to tell a life story&equo;: one villager mistakenly claims that &bquo;Boris died like one of his own sheep, neglected and starving&equo;, whereas the admittedly ill-tended flock was in fact killed by lightning. 
 Here Berger's roundabout, local-storyteller manner seems laboured. 
 It works better in another piece, beginning: &bquo;If every event which occurred could be given a name, there would be no need for stories.&equo; 
 A young girl discovers that the old shepherd across the valley, her only friend, is passionately in love with her. 
 Disturbed, she at once falls for a kind, handsome Italian woodcutter, becomes pregnant and elopes. 
 Years later, in Bergamo, she still teaches the old shepherd's phrases to her talking blue-rock thrush. 
 As Berger asks, what was the old man's relation to the girl's baby? 
 Not quite the godfather. 
 There is indeed a certain nameless truth to this one. 
 It is a pity that Berger inserts passages told by the girl, which do not fit. 
 In contrast the title story is narrated entirely by the heroine, and from mid-air too. 
 Her son has taken her up in his hang-glider (can you carry two on a hang-glider?), and she recalls her life and loves as she sails over the old family farm and the nearby manganese factory where it all happened. 
 Berger impersonates her to a fault, both in the superb egotism of female love &mdash; &bquo;It is painful for us to judge the man we've taken, for he's already ours, like a son&equo; &mdash; and in the certitudes of peasant thinking: &bquo;I will tell you which men deserve our respect&hellip; 
 The rest are pigshit.&equo; 
 The best stories, though, are perhaps the first, about a middle-aged bachelor farming alone after his mother dies, and the last, about a member of the village brass band picking up a woman on a bus trip to Venice. 
 These are the most simply told, and they have a nicely judged lack of any obvious point. 
 Berger's writing is wonderfully clear: once the book is opened it just reads itself out. 
 Toil, weather, human character and the quirks of animals are all graphically rendered, as well as the way in which newly-lifted potatoes glow &bquo;like children's shoulders after a day in the sun&equo;, or in which the voice of a once-active young man now crippled by an accident becomes &bquo;far-away, like a priest's voice at the altar&equo;. 
 Whether as social document or as fiction the completed trilogy could be, if fashion permits, a minor classic. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By HUGO BARNACLE 
 Chevron surge: BP declined to comment on speculation it is buying Chevron shares, which analysts said were continuing a recent surge following rumours the oil company may restructure. 
 They said speculation focused on BP because it has expressed interest in refining and marketing in the western US. 
 Dollar firm: The dollar ended the week on a firm note. 
 Sterling closed little changed in moderate trading. 
 This page Business failures: Business failures soared by more than a third in the second half of this year. 
 This page and View from City Road, Page 21 Smith sale: WH Smith has sold its 86.5 per cent stake in WH Smith Canada for C&dollar;54m (&pound;28.3m) to concentrate on expansion in the US. 
 Page 21 Eagle changes: Three directors of Eagle Trust have resigned and three more been appointed. 
 Page 21 Sea Containers deadline: Temple Holdings, the joint vehicle of Tiphook and Stena Holding, is extending the deadline for its &dollar;63 a share cash offer for Sea Containers until midnight New York City time on 3 November. 
 Improved ratings: Scottish Television reported pre-tax profits up 29 per cent to &pound;3m. 
 The figures were better than expected. 
 Page 21 Latin debt: Venezuela has paid more than &dollar;900m in overdue interest on its public sector debt owed to commercial banks, according to Chase Manhattan. 
 The payment brings the country up to date on four months of overdue interest on the debt. 
 Jaguar talks: Jaguar and General Motors were thrashing out a deal to protect the luxury car maker from rival US motor giant Ford. 
 GM is expected to take a key stake in Jaguar in return for substantial investment. 
 The shares jumped 62p to 731p. 
 This page and View from City Road, Page 21 Dalgety stake: Como International, owned jointly by Elf Aquataine and Robert Holmes a Court, has reduced its holding below the 5 per cent level requiring disclosure. 
 Mortgage rate up: Business Mortgages Bank, part of Nykredit of Denmark, has increased its mortgage lending base rate by 1 point to 15.5 per cent from 5 October. 
 Higher credit: The Finance Houses Association has warned that instalment credit will cost more following the rise in base rates. 
 World Markets New York: Lower interest rate hopes helped the Dow Jones Average to reach new high ground. 
 By the close it was up 11.96 points at 2,785.52. 
 Tokyo: Investors catching European interest rate jitters drove the Nikkei average down 313.64 points to 35,209.35. 
 Hong Kong: Receding concern about the situation in China was reflected in the market's continuing strength, the Hang Seng index posting its fourth successive gain at 2,826.21, up 23.04. 
 Singapore: Shares closed firmer across the board in active trade, with the Straits Times index 8.17 points higher at 1,413.15. 
 Sydney: Directionless trading brought little change, the All Ordinaries index ending just 0.7 ahead at 1,773.2 &mdash; but 37.4 points better on the week. 
 Bombay: Heavy institutional buying signalled a rebound from the losses of the past three days. 
 Johannesburg: Pressure on gold shares due to a weaker bullion price sparked a broad market decline. 
 The general index fell 43 points to 2,668. 
 Zurich: The index rose 4.5 points to 1,194.3 on selective local and foreign buying. 
 Milan: Shares ended weaker but above their lows, with the MIB seven points off at 1,164. 
 Nicosia: The Cisco index closed at a new high of 185.6, a gain of 2.1 points on the week. 
 Jaguar and GM work on deal to thwart Ford 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 JAGUAR and General Motors were last night locked in crucial talks over a deal which would safeguard the luxury car maker from being taken over by the rival US motor giant Ford. 
 This would involve GM taking a key stake in Jaguar and making a substantial investment to help to ensure its independence. 
 GM, the world's largest car maker, is understood to be planning to take an initial 15 per cent shareholding in Jaguar, rising to 29.9 per cent immediately the Government's golden share in Jaguar expires in January 1991. 
 At the same time as building up the 15 per cent stake, GM would make a big cash injection into Jaguar &mdash; perhaps as much as &pound;200m &mdash; to help the Coventry-based firm to fend off Ford, which has already announced it plans to take a 15 per cent holding as a prelude to a full takeover bid. 
 Jaguar's shares soared again on the stock market, closing 62p up at 731p &mdash; valuing the company at &pound;1.323bn. 
 As an estimated 5.5 million Jaguar shares changed hands, Ford confirmed that it had been granted early approval by US regulatory authorities to begin building its stake, immediately prompting speculation that it had entered the market. 
 Under US anti-laws Ford was not due for clearance to buy more than &dollar;15m of Jaguar stock until 18 October. 
 The hike in Jaguar's share price since Ford announced its intentions will have a crucial bearing on whether it can put together a defensive deal with GM. 
 Since the beginning of this week Jaguar's shares have risen by 161p &mdash; increasing its stock market value by nearly &pound;300m. 
 Last night's meeting, involving banking advisers for both GM and Jaguar, was to examine whether GM was prepared to bid at the inflated share price. 
 Reliable sources have confirmed that GM is &bquo;leading the pack&equo; of international car companies with which Jaguar is in discussions. 
 A deal is expected to be put together and announced within the next two weeks. 
 Two or three European car makers &mdash; possibly including Peugeot of France - are still understood to be discussing alternative rescue packages with Jaguar. 
 One option for GM would be for the American company to convert its cash investment into equity through an issue of new shares after the Government's veto on takeover expires. 
 Jaguar has the ability to issue up to 40 million new shares &mdash; more than enough to take GM's stake up to 29.9 per cent &mdash; though such a move would require the approval of Jaguar shareholders. 
 Jaguar, which was privatised in 1984 with a stock market value of &pound;283m, is understood to have sounded ministers' views on the proposals being examined. 
 The Government has made it clear that it may not use its power of veto, which protects Jaguar from takeover until the end of next year by limiting individual investors to a 15 per cent holding. 
 However, it is thought unlikely that Jaguar would ask the Government for the limit to be raised early in order to allow its preferred partner to build a stake of more than 15 per cent before January, 1991. 
 It is felt that if the Government did lift the veto, it would be obliged to allow any company to bid for Jaguar. 
 Sterling fails to make progress 
 By PETER TORDAY and COLIN BROWN 
 STERLING failed to make further headway yesterday following Thursday's one point rise in base rates but the dollar strengthened despite expectations that US interest rates may soon ease. 
 The US currency appeared to shrug off the impact of Thursday's round of European interest rate increases led by the Bundesbank, and central bank intervention yesterday, chiefly because of expectations of strong demand for the dollar from the Far East. 
 Sterling was meanwhile little changed in moderate trading, but there was little sign that confidence in the currency had been fully restored. 
 In London, the pound gave up early gains to end unchanged at DM3.0335 and it closed at &dollar;1.6080, 0.22 cents weaker. 
 After opening firmer, the dollar lost ground on expectations of an imminent easing of monetary policy by the US Federal Reserve but strong demand pushed it 0.80 pfennigs higher at DM1.8925. 
 It was little changed at Y142.00. 
 London share prices closed slightly lower, recouping early losses which sent the FT-SE 100 Index of leading shares 31.7 points down on fears of recession. 
 By the close, the index was just 4.5 points down at 2,277.1. 
 The Chancellor, Nigel Lawson, insisted yesterday that the economy was unlikely to slip into recession because of higher base rates as long as UK companies controlled their costs. 
 Speaking to BBC Radio Mr Lawson said: &bquo;If they keep a firm grip on their costs and can maintain and indeed increase their share of world markets &mdash; both the British and overseas markets &mdash; there will certainly be no recession at all.&equo; 
 Tory MPs said last night that the increase in interest rates would intensify the pressure on the Prime Minister to allow the Chancellor to go ahead with Britain's membership of the European Monetary System. 
 Sir Fred Catherwood, a senior Tory member of the European Parliament, said the Prime Minister's insistence that Britain should join when the time is right had become &bquo;a bit of a joke&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;It demonstrates we don't have any sovereignty over our money. 
 .. The Bundesbank puts up its rate by 1 per cent and the Chancellor is forced to put up his rate by 1 per cent straight ahead of the Tory Party conference. 
 He can't do anything else. 
 It's the last thing in the world he wants to do. 
 It's much better to join the European monetary union and do things through them. 
 It's worked for every other country. 
 It could work for us.&equo; 
 The Bundesbank's monetary dominance in Europe was underscored yesterday in a speech by its president, Karl Otto Pohl. 
 He indicated that the central bank wanted to revalue the mark but the most important EMS countries ruled that out. 
 As a result, he said, &bquo;in all practical terms, they are behaving as though we already had a currency union, which is defined as a zone of fixed exchange rates and free movement of capital.&equo; 
 The desire to hold their currencies unchanged against the mark led most West European countries to follow an increase in German rates on Thursday. 
 Mr Lawson denied he had acted as if sterling was a full member of the EMS, but his decision to hold the pound above DM3 with higher base rates was seen by several analysts as just that. 
 Concern continued yesterday that the Chancellor might not be able to guarantee that 15 per cent base rates were the peak if sterling came under pressure again. 
 Economists worry that even higher rates would make a prolonged recession much more likely than at present. 
 Commenting on the prospects, Jim O'Neill, international economist with Swiss Bank Corp, said: &bquo;They've got a stay of execution between now and the next set of trade figures.&equo; 
 September figures are released on 24 October. 
 Meanwhile US figures indicated yesterday that the US economy may be weakening, lifting hopes of a Fed easing. 
 Excluding workers returning from a strike, the number of new jobs grew by 134,000 in September, well below expectations, while job growth in August was revised down sharply. 
 Warning on insolvencies 
 By JASON NISSE 
 BUSINESS failures are expected to rise by over a third this year according to figures produced by the credit insurer Trade Indemnity, and are now running at their highest rate since 1985, writes Jason Nisse. 
 The private group, which insures invoices and financing arrangements, recorded 1,220 falures in the first half of this year, but indications so far show that at least 2,000 more failures will be recorded by the end of the year. 
 This compares with just 2,146 in 1988. 
 The rate of failures has been declining through the 1980s and the last time it was running at these levels was 1984, when 3,924 businesses failed. 
 Italy's 1.5bn dollar Eurobond is largest issue to date 
 By JASON NISSE 
 ITALY yesterday announced a &dollar;1.5bn (&pound;935m) issue of fixed-rate Eurobonds, the largest such deal to date. 
 The bonds carry a five-year maturity and will be priced on Tuesday to produce a yield of 0.42-0.44 per cent above the five-year US Treasury yield. 
 Morgan Stanley and Nomura International are arranging the deal and have assembled a group of 10 international banks to underwrite and sell the bonds in the Euromarkets. 
 One of the 10 said initial investor response was &bquo;fairly positive&equo;. 
 The issue is using the increasingly popular &bquo;fixed price&equo; US-style system for underwriting and offering Eurobonds. 
 Banks participating in the deal agree to sell bonds only at, or above, the stated issue price until such time as Morgan Stanley considers appropriate. 
 Traditionally, such discipline has not been imposed on Eurobond issues. 
 Two weeks ago the World Bank launched a &dollar;1.5bn global bond issue which was partly sold in the Euromarket and partly in the US domestic market. 
 Ivory Coast crop dispute pushes up cocoa prices 
 By MICHAEL PREST, Resources Correspondent 
 THIS year's machinations over disposal of the Ivory Coast's cocoa crop indirectly pushed up prices on the London Futures &amp; Options Exchange yesterday as dealers scrambled to obtain cocoa to deliver against a substantial long position controlled by Philipp Brothers, the big American commodity trading group. 
 Attention concentrated on the December London Fox contract, which rose by &pound;21 a tonne to &pound;753. 
 At one stage the contract traded up to &pound;757. 
 The rise bucked the trend, caused by over-supply and stagnant demand, which has depressed cocoa prices to their lowest in real terms in half a century. 
 The net uncovered December position &mdash; the amount traders are committed to buy &mdash; is around 28,000 lots, roughly three times the normal monthly total. 
 A lot is 10 tonnes. 
 At present prices, the exposure is worth more than &pound;210m. 
 The company most committed to deliver cocoa to the market is Sucres et Denrees, the French commodity trading house. 
 Sucden and Phibro contracted this year to buy 500,000 tonnes of cocoa from the Ivory Coast, the world's biggest producer. 
 But it is generally thought in the trade that the agreement has been abrogated by the Ivory Coast. 
 Earlier this week the London Fox sought to defuse the danger of companies being unable to meet their commitments by increasing margins &mdash; the amount necessary to preserve the value of collateral with a broker. 
 From 16 October, margins on the December London Fox contract will be &pound;200 a tonne, rising to &pound;350 on 30 October, &pound;500 on 13 November, &pound;600 on 27 November, and the full value of the contract on 5 December. 
 The exchange assumed that 150,000 tonnes of cocoa must be bought for delivery to the holders of long positions. 
 The biggest long, Phibro, is said by traders to need cocoa to meet commitments in the physical markets. 
 But traders thought that the full 280,000 tonnes might be delivered, squeezing prices acutely. 
 In that event, smaller operators stretched to meet margin calls might suffer. 
 Since the London Fox is anxious to preserve the integrity of the market, it may take other measures, such as extending delivery times, to relieve pressure on shorts. 
 Trusthouse sells Skyway Hotel for 35m pounds 
 By MICHAEL PREST, Resources Correspondent 
 TRUSTHOUSE Forte has sold the Skyway Hotel at Heathrow Airport to Edwardian Hotels, the privately owned London group, for &pound;35m. 
 Trusthouse has three other hotels at the airport, the Post House, the Ariel and the Excelsior. 
 A 250-bedroom extension to the Excelsior will increase total capacity to 1,576 rooms not counting Skyway's 450 rooms. 
 Trusthouse said it was well represented at the airport. 
 &bquo;The opportunity to sell occurred and the price was a good one,&equo; said a spokesman. 
 Edwardian plans to upgrade the 30-year-old Skyway from 3-star to 4-star deluxe, spending &pound;15m on top of the purchase price. 
 It has seven other hotels in central London with 1,100 rooms. 
 AMP states Pearl offer is generous 
 By ALISON EADIE 
 AUSTRALIAN Mutual Provident, the Australian insurance company bidding &pound;1.1bn for Pearl Group, yesterday reiterated that its 605p per share cash offer was generous and fully valued the company. 
 The shares, however, rose 6p to 648p, indicating that the market continues to expect either a higher offer or the intervention of a white knight, possibly from continental Europe. 
 The bid is being resisted by Pearl Group, whose chairman, Einion Holland, has described the offer as &bquo;derisory, unacceptable and totally inadequate&equo;. 
 AMP's offer document published yesterday claims that the share price has been inflated by speculation and the offer should be judged against the price of 394p per share prevailing before AMP raised its stake in Pearl to 18 per cent last June. 
 Pearl's low dividend yield is cited as evidence. 
 If Pearl yielded the 5.39 per cent average for the life insurance sector, its shares would trade at 408p. 
 The document also asserts that Pearl's market position in new annual premiums for UK life and pensions business fell from third in 1978 to 15th by 1988. 
 It claims that in the five years to the end of 1988 Pearl's new annual premium business rose by an average of 3.7 per cent a year against a UK market average of 13 per cent a year. 
 &bquo;Misleading&equo; MTS notice is criticised 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 THE Takeover Panel yesterday rapped Meat Trade Suppliers, the Smithfield sausage casings company, and its financial advisers Lloyds Merchant Bank, for sending a &bquo;seriously misleading&equo; circular to its shareholders, writes Alexandra Jackson. 
 Control of MTS is being contested by Twigrealm, a company backed by the South African meat trader Freddy Hirsch and the British property entrepreneur Stephen Wingate, and by Alpha Gamma, the property group. 
 Alpha Gamma's offer of 372p per share for 57 per cent of the group is backed by Meat Trade's board unlike Twigrealm's offer of 350p for the whole company. 
 A MTS family stake of 25 per cent has been pledged to Twigrealm. 
 The Panel's ruling refers to a document sent to shareholders on October 5 in which the Twigrealm offer was incorrectly valued at 314p a share. 
 The panel has asked MTS to send a correction to its shareholders. 
 The board of MTS does not accept every detail of the Panel's criticism and will be writing to shareholders with further information. 
 The extraordinary general meeting which was due to take place on 10 October has been rescheduled to 17 October. 
 Market Report: Interest rate blues meet some resistance 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 THE unlikely combination of Jaguar, Saatchi &amp; Saatchi and Scottish &amp; Newcastle Breweries helped the stock market resist the worst excesses of bank rate blues yesterday. 
 In early trading the broadly based FT-SE share index was down 31.7 points and seemed intent on reaching 2,200 points in double quick time. 
 Then at least two programme trades, one a buy and sell mix and the other a buy exercise, steadied the market. 
 With stories swirling and strengthening about a clutch of leading shares and Wall Street striding to new peaks, the index was down only 4.1 points at the close. 
 Jaguar, with not a black flag in sight, roared 62p higher to 731p in hectic turnover. 
 Saatchi, another busily traded share, jumped 40p to 340p. 
 A variety of stories flowed. 
 They included Swiss and US bids, managment buyouts and the sale of part of the group. 
 S&amp;N, not for the first time, enjoyed a heady ferment as, once again, the market was gripped by the story that the Elders' 23.7 per cent shareholding had found a new home. 
 Elders, the Australian group, has been ordered to cut its stake to at least 9.9 per cent by June. 
 It is expected to sell its entire shareholding. 
 BSN, the sprawling French group with interests spreading from food and beer to packaging, has emerged as the new favourite for the Scottish stake. 
 It was rumoured to have paid 450p a share. 
 The excitement was enough to push Scottish 19p higher at one time. 
 The shares closed 14p stronger at 375p. 
 Considering the interest rate blows, the market turned in a resilient performance. 
 Trading, never heavy, was at least well up to the post-crash average although there was little sign of institutional support. 
 BTR was another stock to attract attention. 
 The shares jumped 15p to 662p. 
 Kohlberg Kravis Roberts has declared its intention of buying up to 15 per cent and is thought to be quietly picking up stock. 
 Some were convinced it was in the market again yesterday. 
 There are suggestions it has at least a 2.5 per cent shareholding. 
 Boots, after its strong run on Thursday, ran into the inevitable profit taking, falling 6p to 288p. 
 The group, following the Ward White Group acquisition, has borrowings of nearly &pound;600m which makes it particularly sensitive to the interest rate increase. 
 There are also suggestions that the sale of WWG's US Whitlock car accessories group will take longer than expected and will not realise the price Boots had hoped. 
 Asda, the stores group, suffered the fate of a fading bid stock, falling 5p to 174p. 
 The discomfort was compounded by a profits downgrading by County NatWest WoodMac. 
 It now expects profits of &pound;225m against earlier hopes of &pound;243m. 
 The following year's prediction has been slashed from &pound;314m to &pound;270m. 
 Ferranti, helped by option influences, rose 1.5p to 59p. 
 ADT, benefiting from a US investment road show, gained 6p to 206p. 
 Guinness, reflecting its strong profits performance, jumped 25p to 597p. 
 But cider maker HP Bulmer, perceived as an interest rate casualty, fell 10p to 172p. 
 BAT Industries improved 17.5p to 850.5p on Hoylake's expression of continuing interest. 
 James Neill, the garden tools firm that suffered a sharp trading downturn, rose 12p to 197p. 
 Ross Consumer soared 131p to 177p as Roger Shute of the BM construction group and friends moved in. 
 Doctus rose 11p to 127p, making a two day 17p gain. 
 ANZ McCaughan's Alastair Irvine expects dramatic profit progress from &pound;1.8m to &pound;8.4m in the year just ended and then to &pound;12m this year. 
 The company is involved in management consultancy, marketing and promotion. 
 It acquired the Prospective Group, the old Pineapple business, earlier this year. 
 European Leisure, the fast growing discotheque group, held at 100p as Irish sources indicated Nazmu Virani's Control Securities had sold 1.5 million shares to institutions. 
 Control has almost doubled its money. 
 It acquired the shares when it sold a London property to EL last year. 
 Rechem, the waste dispoal group, had another difficult session, falling 45p to 560p. 
 The shares have come down from 795p since the toxic waste issue blew up. 
 Equities recovered from a sharp early setback yesterday. 
 The FT-SE share index was down 31.7 points before setting out on a steady recovery, closing 4.1 points down at 2,277.5. 
 The FT 30 share index finished 8.4 points lower at 1,857.8. 
 Government stocks improved by up to &pound;&frac38;. 
 AMI Healthcare, at 395p, has a potential takeover price of up to 550p, Smith New Court believes. 
 The company is controlled by a US group that is up for sale and has said it wants to sell AMI. 
 Bupa and Sun Alliance are regarded as likely buyers. 
 Smith New Court expects AMI's profits to have reached &pound;20.5m in the year just ended with &pound;24.5m likely this year. 
 Cupid's sights are being realigned from the Third Market to the USM and the company is aiming to add more strings to its bow through a placing of 660,000 shares at 125p each, raising &pound;825,000. 
 Shares in the manufacturer of bridal wear and nursery products, which only made its debut on the Third Market a year ago via a placing at 100p, stand at 136p. 
 Column Eight: The RBS tailors its image 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 The Royal Bank of Scotland has probably guaranteed itself a future recruitment crisis with the introduction of a range of designer wear for staff. 
 Bob Maiden, the managing director, said the range was a response to &bquo;the many requests from staff for something to wear which can be identified with the bank&equo;. 
 Three top designers were approached at an undisclosed cost. 
 The result is a range by Paul Costelloe which RBS hopes will lead to a &bquo;harmonious look&equo; among the staff. 
 So if you are in a hurry to cash your cheque you can always ask: &bquo;Is that a Paul Costelloe number you are wearing?&equo; 
 You might get served quickly. 
 You might get a clip round the ear. 
 For an autobiography which purports to tell us the real story behind the sacking of George Davies from the Next empire which he founded, What Next is on the naive side. 
 But the book, published next Thursday by Century Hutchinson, does contain some intriguing insights into the career of &bquo;the retail revolution&equo;. 
 Not least among them is a picture of young Davies in football kit, posing for a picture with the England Schoolboys Under 18 team. 
 The caption alongside notes that George Davies, aged 19, is in the front row on the far right. 
 Indignant over suggestions that the Prime Minister has replaced his Jaguar with a Rover, Nigel Lawson can at least draw comfort from the fact that he is a wanted man in the City. 
 The Abbey National is the latest company to target the Chancellor as the man it most wants to replace Sir Campbell Adamson when he eventually retires as chairman. 
 Whether Mr Lawson will accept remains to be seen. 
 Incidentally, the Treasury said that the Chancellor had not lost his Jag as well as Dorneywood, his country home. 
 It was merely in for repairs, said a spokesman. 
 However, he added, like all ministers, the Chancellor would be moving to a more environment-friendly machine in the fullness of time. 
 Those who follow this sort of thing will tell you that yesterday's recapitalisation of Ross Consumer Electronics was only a matter of time. 
 Financial problems aside, the company had already received the kiss of death in that, two years ago, the Department of Trade and Industry chose to feature it as a prime example of the Enterprise Initiative. 
 Ross duly appeared in a multi-million pound advertising campaign and the rest, as they say, is history. 
 View from City Road: Jaguar stretched to its limit 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 ONCE again Jaguar shares defied the laws of gravity yesterday with a 62p gain to 731p. 
 The shares started the week at 570p and turnover has been considerable. 
 However, there is still a lingering doubt about the justification for such a rise. 
 Although both General Motors and Ford would like to forge a liason with Jaguar, that interest does not translate automatically into a 28 per cent increase in the share price in a week. 
 In some ways the share price performance has made a deal with one of the US car giants less likely since the numbers have changed quite dramatically. 
 It would make some sense for friends of the Ford camp to push the Jaguar shares upwards simply to make a link with GM more difficult. 
 However, there is a danger for shareholders that they will become trapped in the power play between the two US giants. 
 Jaguar has attractions for both. 
 But there are also attractions for them in ensuring that neither company links with Jaguar. 
 A stalemate would make sure that neither Ford nor GM could benefit from Jaguar's expertise in the luxury car market but it will not be particularly attractive for investors. 
 That stalemate might provide a private sector equivalent of the Government's golden share. 
 However, it would also deprive the company of a welcome capital injection and would leave Jaguar shareholders facing a much lower share price than they currently enjoy. 
 The picture is further clouded by the stance the Government will take. 
 It may not be inclined to withdraw its golden share so the earliest shareholders would be able to capitalise on US interest in Jaguar is 1991. 
 And shareholders should not underestimate the determination of the Jaguar management to preserve its independence. 
 With the golden share intact, the company is under no immediate pressure to negotiate with the likes of GM and Ford and is likely to press for the most advantageous terms available. 
 That is why talks with GM are rumoured to have been more extensive than those with Ford, which appears to have adopted a more aggressive stance. 
 The picture may become clearer next week but with the Jaguar share price at this level, shareholders should now take some profits. 
 They may lose out on some limited upside but will also avoid exposure to the considerable risk of the US negotiations breaking down. 
 View from City Road: Rumours blur Saatchi picture 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 THE market appears to have lost its patience with Saatchi &amp; Saatchi's proposed disposal of its management consultancy business. 
 Little hard news has come out of the world's biggest advertising group since it put the division on the block. 
 Fed up with the snail-like pace, the market yesterday began to entertain the possibility that the group itself may now be on the block. 
 Yesterday's sharp rise in Saatchi's shares, up 40p to 340p in a falling market, was spurred by a flood of rumours. 
 The day began with talk that South Eastern Asset Management, a Tennessee-based fund manager, had been adding to its 10.3 per cent shareholding. 
 This was quickly followed by a spate of bid rumours, the most sensational of which was that Adia, the big Swiss-based recruitment consultant, was about to launch a takeover bid. 
 By lunchtime the tongues were really wagging and talk of LBOs, MBOs, an imminent sale of the management consultancy business as well as a bid featuring Bob Jacobi, formerly head of Ted Bates (the US advertising agency Saatchi took over after a bitter battle three years ago) were all fuelling the share price. 
 The obvious temptation is to dismiss yesterday's events as an old fashioned share ramp, but there is a niggling feeling that something more substantial is going on behind the scenes. 
 Trading in the company's shares was hectic and the 3.5 million Saatchi shares that changed hands by closing time is too high for a simple ramp. 
 Ironically, the message of all this activity is that the market is intensely worried about Saatchi's prospects. 
 And with good reason: the signs are that Saatchi is finding it difficult to sell the management consultancy division alone. 
 Moreover, the absence of any firm information about the progress it is making with the disposal has added to the belief that the &pound;300m estimated price tag for the management division was too optimistic. 
 In some quarters the combined value is now put at about &pound;225m. 
 If this scenario is correct, Saatchi could be heading for problems next year. 
 Saddled with a high level of cash outflow and a policy of high dividend payouts, the company may be forced to either sell other non-management consultancy businesses or make redundancies. 
 Although the uncertainty helped Saatchi shares yesterday, it is just as likely to cause movements in the other direction until the picture becomes clearer. 
 View from City Road: Receivership a growth industry 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 COMPANY failures are a classic lagged indicator of the health of the British economy. 
 From the point when the Government's high interest rate policies start taking effect to the point when companies start calling in the receiver, there tends to be quite a delay &mdash; liquidity problems do not suddenly emerge unless something dramatically goes wrong. 
 That is why figures produced by credit insurer Trade Indemnity, showing the rate of business failures soaring by more than a third in the second half of this year, are so worrying. 
 The declining trend from the troubled days of the early 1980s has been reversed, and if the rate of increase continues into 1990 the next decade will look rather bleak. 
 Back in 1984 Trade Indemnity, which reckons it records around a fifth of all the business failures in the UK, noted 3,924 failures. 
 This declined until it was only 2,146 last year. 
 In the first half of 1989 the total was 1,220 and indications are that more than 2,000 companies will suffer liquidity problems in the second half. 
 Worst hit, no one will be suprised to hear, are the textile and building trades. 
 In the first half 170 textile companies recorded problems compared with 112 in the whole of 1988. 
 Corresponding figures in building and construction are 320, up from 315 last year. 
 The other worrying trend is that the companies getting into difficulty are tending to be larger. 
 The increase noted is too significant to be attributable to inflation. 
 This all adds up to a bleak picture for corporate UK. 
 The fastest growing industry seems to be receivership and, alas, you cannot buy shares in Cork Gulley. 
 Company News in Brief 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 ARCOLECTRIC'S shares tumbled 20p to 113p on a fall in half year pre-tax profits from &pound;320,000 to &pound;128,000. 
 Sales for the period to 30 June were slightly higher at &pound;5.2m against &pound;5.08m in the comparable period. 
 Delays in delivery of machinery hit production. 
 Earnings per share dipped to 1.92p from 4.79p, but the interim dividend was increased from 0.44p to 0.48p. 
 TULLOW Oil, which joined the Unlisted Securities Market on Thursday, yesterday announced pre-tax profits of Ir &pound;41,000 for the six months to 30 June, against &pound;18,000 last time. 
 Earnings per share were 0.05p (0.03p). 
 The company said proven reserves were worth Ir20p per share. 
 SINGAPORE Para Rubber reported lower profits before tax of &pound;148,000 for the six months to 30 June, compared with &pound;212,000 previously. 
 Earnings per share were down at 0.81p against 1.05p. 
 The profits fall was blamed on wet weather in the early part of year. 
 BOOKER has merged Kingswood Chemists, its chain of retail pharmacies, with GK Chemists, a retail pharmacy business owned by Gus Kiamtia and his family. 
 The merged business, Kingswood-GK, will be 60 per cent owned by Booker and 40 per cent by the Kiamtia family. 
 It will be the fourth largest pharmacy chain in the UK with 153 outlets. 
 New Eagle Trust chief shakes up boardroom 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 DAVID James, who took over as chairman of Eagle Trust less than two weeks ago, yesterday stamped his mark on the troubled Midlands mini-conglomerate, appointing three new directors and securing the resignations of three others, two of whom were supporters of deposed chairman Malcolm Stockdale. 
 The new directors are Peter Churchill, 59, a barrister who specialises in corporate law, Peter Ryan, the chairman of Elga Group and a former director of conglomerate Thomas Tilling, now owned by BTR, and Brian Smith, who was group managing director of Rank Organisation until 1983. 
 Mr Churchill will have an executive role as director of legal affairs, a particularly useful role considering the Serious Fraud Squad and the West Midlands Police are investigating Eagle, and will temporarily assume the role of company secretary. 
 The other two will be non-executives. 
 The three resignations were signalled when Mr James took control. 
 Norman Ricketts, who was only appointed to the Eagle board by Mr Stockdale last month, is relinquishing his non-executive role, as is Hamish Jansen, who has been with the group since formation and was a strong supporter of Mr Stockdale. 
 Sidney Samuelson, the chairman of lighting hire group Samuelson which was taken over by Eagle in 1987, is also resigning though he will retain his position at Samuelson. 
 However, it is understood that Mr Smith, despite his non-executive position on the Eagle board, will take an active role in the running of Samuelson. 
 With the appointments the board retains a quorum, and Mr James is looking for two more members for the team. 
 Eagle currently has no finance director, and a person to fill this position is being actively sought. 
 In the meantime Mr James will be asking accountants Coopers &amp; Lybrand to provide the necessary support in this area. 
 Mr James will also be inviting a representative of the shareholders onto the board. 
 He hopes the person will be nominated in conjunction with the Investors Protection Committee. 
 WH Smith sells its Canadian interests 
 By TERENCE WILKINSON, Assistant City Editor 
 WH SMITH, the retail and distribution group, is pulling out of Canada after 40 years to concentrate on expanding its US operations. 
 The UK group has sold its 86.5 per cent stake in WH Smith Canada to Federal Industries Consumer Group for C&dollar;54m (&pound;28.3m). 
 Apart from WH Smith bookshops, the disposal includes 61 Celebration card and stationery shops and 12 Paperchase outlets. 
 Unlike other UK retailers in the Canadian market &mdash; Boots came out last year and Marks &amp; Spencer has been struggling to break even &mdash; WH Smith has shown profits growth. 
 In the year to 3 June pre-tax profits were C&dollar;6.5m (&pound;3.2m), which implies that WH Smith is selling out on a premium multiple of 18 times Canadian earnings. 
 One reason for the sale is that when WH Smith bought the Canadian Classic bookshops chain in 1985, doubling its outlets, it made an agreement with the Canadian government to reduce its holding in WH Smith Canada to 51 per cent by 1990. 
 Although this seemed a good idea at the time, current strategy at WH Smith is to have full control, as in the buying up of 100 per cent of Molinaire, the TV services company, in July. 
 While the Canadian business has been profitable, WH Smith believes the returns being obtained on &pound;75m of sales from 200 outlets are not comparable with the returns that can be obtained in other markets and did not justify the future investment necessary to develop the chain. 
 Profit fall hits Hi-Tec shares 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 SHARES in Hi-Tec, the sports shoe maker, dropped 7p yesterday to 105p on the announcement of a pre-tax profits fall from &pound;4.1m to &pound;3.1m for the interim period to 31 July. 
 Hi-Tec Sports is the UK market leader in sports shoes but trading profit margins were reduced by nearly four percentage points to 10 per cent on turnover of &pound;36.84m, up from &pound;32.93m. 
 Mario Aresti, finance director, said the erosion in margins was due equally to increased production costs and attempts to maintain volume sales. 
 Strong local currencies in the Taiwan and Korea production centres pushed up costs and attempts to take advantage of a cheaper environment in China were dashed by events following the Tiananmen Square demonstrations in Peking. 
 The company said that it did not see an improvement for the second half. 
 Increased sales in North America and Europe reduced the proportion of sales in the UK from three quarters to two thirds of the total. 
 Hi-Tec hopes North America, which lifted sales and profits by 20 per cent, and Europe will account for half of group turnover by early 1991. 
 In August Hi-Tec bought a Dutch sports clothing company Beheermaatschappij Copex in a profit-related deal worth up to &pound;7.7m. 
 The company said it was the first step towards a broadening of its geographic and product base which would reduce dependency on the UK and on shoes. 
 Earnings per share for the first half were reduced to 5.47p, against 7.83p last time, but the interim dividend has been held at 1.5p. 
 Ross Electronics sees value soar 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 THE market value of Ross Consumer Electronics, the troubled hi-fi and audio manufacturer, quadrupled yesterday when a new management team led by Roger Shute, the chairman of construction machinery company BM Group, moved in. 
 Tied in with the management charges, the company launched a four-for-five deep discount rights issue to raise &pound;1.2m and recapitalise Ross. 
 The group's shares opened at 46p, valuing the company at just over &pound;2m, and soared through the day to close at 177p. 
 The rise, with the rights issue priced at 23p, pushed Ross' market value above &pound;8m. 
 It currently has assets of less than &pound;2m and in the year to last March made a pre-tax loss of &pound;716,000. 
 Mr Shute is assuming the chairmanship of Ross from Ross Marks, the company's 37-year-old founder, who will remain as chairman of the consumer electronics operations and a director of the group. 
 Noel Hayes, a stockbroker who in his time has been a building analyst and up until the beginnig of this year was head of sales at Citicorp-Scrimgeour Vickers, becomes chief executive and Sam Oxford, the former chairman of Magnet &amp; Southerns, joins as a non-executive director. 
 Paul Owens, the recently appointed finance director, is retained, though two other directors, Laura Marks and Alfred Davis, are resigning. 
 The plan is to turn Ross, which is being renamed Ross Group, into a mini-conglomerate. 
 The consumer electronics side, which grew on the back of making headphones and more recently expanded into hi-fis, radios and televisions, is to be retained, and the new management has plans to move into warehousing and distribution. 
 The new team is also changing the year end from March to December. 
 In the nine months period it is hoped Ross will break even and the market is predicting the company will move into profit in 1990. 
 Mr Shute has had an impressive track record with BM, which he was appointed to when it was controlled by Beazer and which has thrived while Beazer's fortunes wained until Beazer severed the connections earlier this year. 
 Laird Group offloads its bus business 
 By TERENCE WILKINSON 
 LAIRD Group's MCW Metrobus range of double-decker buses has been acquired in a joint venture between Optare, the Leeds-based bus bodybuilder, and Daf of Holland, writes Terence Wilkinson. 
 The sale, for a sum not thought to be material, marks the final dismemberment of Metro-Cammell Weymann, the vehicles business which unbeknown to Laird lost &pound;50m over several years. 
 MCW cabs and coaches have already been sold. 
 A redesigned version of the Metrobus will be supplied to both UK and international markets with chassis being built by Daf in Eindhoven and bodies by Optare in Leeds. 
 During its six-year life the Metrobus has established a significant position in the UK double-decker market, capturing about 30 per cent of all sales in each year between 1983 and 1986 and earning the reputation of a mobile road block among motorists in the congested capital since a driver-only policy was introduced by London Transport. 
 Bett Brothers, the property, housing and leisure group, has ceased operations at Bett Trucks having failed to find a main distributor for Leyland Daf, its franchiser. 
 Scottish TV results beat predictions 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 SCOTTISH Television reported better than expected figures in the half year to end June despite a &pound;2.3m charge to cover the cost of voluntary redundancies and early retirement. 
 The shares bucked the market trend, rising one penny to 491p. 
 Pre-tax profits increased 29 per cent to &pound;3m on turnover up from &pound;39.8m to &pound;49.3m. 
 The interim dividend was raised from 3.75p to 5p. 
 Sir Campbell Fraser, Scottish Television's chairman, warned that higher interest rates were already making themselves felt with advertising revenues being squeezed. 
 Although Sir Campbell did not expect the strong sales growth of the first half to continue, he anticipated satisfactory results for the full year. 
 The uncertain outlook for consumer spending has encouraged City analysts to trim their profit forecasts from around &pound;11m to nearer &pound;10m. 
 The results also included an extraordinary credit of &pound;4m net of tax from Scottish Television's disposal of its investment in Independent Television Publications. 
 The Week in Review: Business and City 
 By ALISON EADIE 
 THE week's news was dominated by Chancellor Nigel Lawson's failed attempt to stave off a rise in bank base rates. 
 The fight was finally lost on Thursday after the Bundesbank lifted its key interest rates by a full point to clamp down on West German inflation. 
 The rise to 15 per cent &mdash; the highest for eight years &mdash; will inevitably force mortgage rates higher. 
 The Abbey National, now a bank, and the Leeds Permanent and the Halifax building societies were quick to break the bad news to already hard-pressed homeowners by stating that mortgage rates will probably have to rise by around 1.25 points to 14.75 per cent. 
 Mr Lawson admitted that the interest rate rise was extremely &bquo;embarrassing, awkward and uncomfortable&equo;, coming as it did on the eve of the Conservative Party Conference. 
 However, the worst may not be over for the embattled Chancellor. 
 He admitted that a further increase could be necessary. 
 Shares and sterling went down as interest rates went up. 
 The FT-SE 100 index fell to its nadir yesterday morning at 2,254.0, down 45.4 from its opening level on Monday. 
 Sterling, which came under intense selling pressure on continued reaction to August's dire trade figures, fell to a low against the German mark at DM3.0081 on Wednesday. 
 It regained some bounce to end the week nudging DM3.0400. 
 Life will get even tougher for those whom everyone loves to hate &mdash; estate agents. 
 The big chains admitted that house sales could dry up between now and Christmas, as vendors refuse to accept drastic price cuts. 
 The end of the housing boom was reflected in news of more losses and branch closures among estate agents. 
 The Halifax estate agency revealed a &pound;14.5m loss in the six months to the end of July. 
 The Leeds Permanent admitted it would be indulging in some &bquo;selective pruning&equo; of its agency branches. 
 Someone who most certainly will not be having trouble keeping up with his mortgage repayments is Lord Hanson, chairman of the industrial conglomerate Hanson. 
 A league table published by Charterhouse, the merchant bank, showed Lord Hanson was Britain's highest-paid director of a public company, earning &pound;1.239m last year. 
 Sir Ralph Halpern of Burton Group and John Gunn of British and Commonwealth were not so fortunate. 
 They suffered 25 per cent performance-related pay cuts, dropping to &pound;996,000 and &pound;740,700 respectively. 
 Also suffering was Sir Derek Alun-Jones, chairman of Ferranti International Signal, the troubled electronics company. 
 Trustees representing substantial Ferranti family interests wrote to Sir Derek asking for the board to be replaced or supplemented by new directors. 
 Sir Derek, however, sat tight, believing that he should not be blamed for the &pound;215m fraud perpetrated against the company. 
 The fraud by International Signal and Control, the American defence company which Ferranti bought two years ago, was not revealed in the audit carried out when Ferranti made the acquisition. 
 Ferranti this week received the report it commissioned from accountants Coopers &amp; Lybrand on the alleged fraud. 
 Depending on the contents, the report could provide Ferranti with ammunition for legal action against those who advised it during the ISC purchase. 
 The report will also be handed to the Serious Fraud Office. 
 Despite the gaping hole in the company's accounts, Ferranti shares returned from their suspension at 73&frac12;p to trade at higher than expected levels between 55p and 59p. 
 On Tuesday, the day of their return, some 115 million shares traded, representing 15 per cent of the company's stock. 
 Bid hopes buoyed the price with British Aerospace and Daimler Benz the market's frontrunners. 
 BAe refused to confirm or deny any interest. 
 The normally grey and staid world of accountancy was enlivened this week by a certain skittishness on the part of Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells. 
 After jilting Touche Ross, with which it had planned a worldwide merger, it married its UK practice with the UK practice of Coopers &amp; Lybrand. 
 The new firm will be the largest in the UK with a fee income of more than &pound;143m. 
 Eurotunnel shares fell sharply following revelations of spiralling costs. 
 Admission of a &pound;2bn cost overrun has sent Eurotunnel back to the banks to plead for fresh financing. 
 The banks have given Eurotunnel until the end of the year to come up with an agreed costing for completion of the Channel Tunnel. 
 As the Transport Secretary, Cecil Parkinson, ruled out any Government help, Eurotunnel shares fell to a low of 550p, down 145p on the week. 
 There was no respite for the beleaguered retail sector. 
 Even before the hike in base rates, Sears, the Selfridges, British Shoe Corporation and Olympus retailing group, was bemoaning the effect of high interest rates on consumer expenditure. 
 Its pre-tax profits slumped 10 per cent to &pound;91.7m in the half year to the end of July. 
 Next also produced a much worse than expected slump in interim profits to &pound;16.2m from &pound;30.9m previously. 
 Its problems are compounded by the legacy of expansion under former chairman George Davies and the Davies empire is now being dismantled. 
 European Markets: Equities lose the earnings edge to cash 
 By EDI COHEN 
 MOST MARKETS, but especially Paris, weakened initially with the news of the widely expected interest rate rises but rebounded later. 
 There was relief that the rise was out of the way and substantial enough to keep further advance at bay. 
 Analysts believe that Thursday's increases have opened the way for more gains in most markets, particularly Germany, the Netherlands and Switzerland. 
 Although earnings prospects all over Europe are still excellent the balance has now been slightly tipped away from the equity markets. 
 Rates at the current 7.5 to 8 per cent make cash a much better alternative than it was before. 
 Higher European interest rates were hardly the main concern of investors in Oslo, home of Europe's second-best performing market this year. 
 Norwegian investors were surprised on Thursday by the suspension of the shares of Den norske Creditbank (DnC) and Bergen Bank on the news of a proposed merger between the two to form Norway's largest bank. 
 The other interesting news was Norsk Hydro's announcement that it planned to buy DnC's 9 per cent stake in Saga Petroleum. 
 Reactions to the merger have been decidedly mixed in Oslo. 
 On the negative side it is difficult to see the advantage for Bergen Bank, which is getting mixed up with one of the most troublesome members of the already unfortunate Norwegian banking sector, where 1989 loss estimates of NKr1.6bn have been announced. 
 A more positive view of the merger is that consolidation in the fragmented Norwegian banking sector is a necessity and balance sheets need to be strengthened. 
 DnC's worse-than-expected results are indicators that the Norwegian banking sector, if perhaps on the road to recovery, is not all well yet. 
 Norwegian banks were severely hit by the 1986 oil price fall. 
 On top of that the 1987 stock market crash and a steep domestic increase in interest rates nearly nearly put paid to some of them &mdash; including DnC. 
 The fact that the loan losses of the banks remain heavy will force the Norwegian government to agree to the merger which otherwise might not square with its normally tough monopoly considerations. 
 Next year's outlook for the banks is expected to be less cloudy. 
 Interest rates have come down again and loan losses are expected to improve. 
 Although the Oslo Bourse has paused for a moment to digest the DnC/Bergen news the market has been hugely active and is currently one of the best performers in the world. 
 The index has risen by over 60 per cent while turnover is much higher than the Swedish market, with its much larger market capitalisation. 
 Foreigners have been piling in. 
 According to some surveys among clients, UK investors are heavily overweighted in the market. 
 Although a similar performance next year would be difficult, the valuation of the market is modest and analysts believe that Oslo will keep outperforming other European markets for the time being. 
 Norway's brilliant market has been based on a clear cut recovery situation after the trough of 1986. 
 Then, a successful austerity package was introduced. 
 Presently, growth forecasts are strong and inflation falling. 
 Also, the pressure on interest rates has been down and the balance of trade has shifted into surplus. 
 The major sectors witnessing recovery have been the shipping and the natural resources sectors. 
 Another boost to the market has been the removal of turnover tax at the beginning of this year, which tripled volumes. 
 The political situation, if by no means settled has at least become clearer. 
 A relaxing thought for investors is the fact that no matter which government will be in power no major economic changes are likely. 
 Washington Comment: Time to end the fiscal follies: Bailey Morris examines the United States' deficit reduction law 
 By BAILEY MORRIS 
 GRAMM-Rudman-Hollings, the US deficit reduction law, is arguably the worst piece of legislation passed by Congress in the past decade. 
 This heretical view is beginning to gain support. 
 Even one of the authors, Senator Ernest Hollings of South Carolina, says now that he &bquo;wants a divorce&equo;. 
 At its best, Gramm-Rudman-Hollings is a game of how to master a moving target. 
 At its worst, it represents a total breakdown of the US budget process. 
 The implications of this are chilling in an era marked by growing, destabilising imbalances among the world's largest industrial economies. 
 Politics not fiscal discipline clearly rules the US roost and in no month is this more obvious than in October, the start of the new 1990 fiscal year. 
 The US deficit is rising dramatically, not falling, as the law dictated, to zero by fiscal 1991. 
 Even now, as Congress struggles with the legislation to meet this year's deadline, it is clear that another target will not be met. 
 The original legislation passed in 1985 stipulated that the deficit must be reduced to &dollar;36bn in the 1990 fiscal year which began on 1 October. 
 This was amended to &dollar;100bn in a 1987 revision of the law, and now the Congressional Budget Office, which keeps track of such things, tells us that this too will be overshot, resulting in a deficit estimated at &dollar;117.8bn. 
 It is the same old story. 
 The 1989 deficit is estimated at &dollar;161.4bn, well above the &dollar;136bn target required under the 1987 revision and the &dollar;72bn target contained in the original legislation. 
 The 1988 experience was no different. 
 The actual deficit was &dollar;155.1bn, a sharp contrast to the revised target of &dollar;144bn and the original target of &dollar;108bn. 
 Suffice it to say, without getting into the tortured complexities of the US budget process, that everyone is fiddling with the numbers. 
 The administration is an adept player and so is Congress. 
 Richard Darman, the numbers whizz who directs the White House Budget Office, may be the all-time grand master. 
 It was his decision, for example, to shift a military pay day to 29 September, one of the last days of fiscal 1989, from 1 October, the beginning of fiscal 1990. 
 A similar accounting device was used to shift the cost of US farm support. 
 The exercise shaved off &dollar;4bn from the 1990 target, but it raised the 1989 deficit by an equal amount. 
 The point is that past deficits do not matter to serious players of the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings game. 
 The trick is to meet the target projected for the current fiscal year and to do this by 15 October. 
 This is the date that by law the government must review the budget process to determine whether enough progress has been made in reducing the deficit to avoid automatic spending cuts. 
 It has become an art to both beat the target projections and the cuts without offending important political constituencies. 
 Gramm-Rudman-Hollings is a classic shell game or, in the words of a veteran congressional official, &bquo;one of the greatest evasion schemes ever invented&equo;. 
 It is significant that the much-dreaded automatic spending cuts have never occurred. 
 If a problem becomes too complex, or too costly in this context, it is simply declared &bquo;off budget&equo;, much as the Bush administration declared the &dollar;100bn bailout of the savings and loan industry &bquo;off budget&equo;. 
 But the huge surpluses in the US Social Security system are counted to finance the deficit. 
 Never mind that even Mr Darman warns that future generations will find only IOUs. 
 The serious business of taking the tough decisions necessary to agree on a budget that both puts the deficit on a downward path and meets the government's priorities has virtually disappeared. 
 Some of the best government programmes fall by the way for lack of a strong political constituency. 
 This is the primary reason that US foreign aid programmes have died since the passage of Gramm-Rudman-Hollings. 
 The hard choices are simply not being made. 
 Indeed, the law has become a convenient shield for politicians. 
 &bquo;We cannot do it because Gramm-Rudman-Hollings will not let us&equo; has become a familiar refrain. 
 It is only now, almost five years after the fact, that the US press corps and America's allies are beginning to see Gramm-Rudman-Hollings for the hoax that it is. 
 Last year, at the annual meetings of the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund, it was generally agreed that the US deficit was less of a threat because it was on a downward path. 
 But the Group of Seven is beginning to worry. 
 There are similar internal domestic rumblings. 
 The debate is likely to boil over later this month when the US Congress must again pass legislation to raise the debt ceiling. 
 This has become an annual embarrassing exercise. 
 There is a movement afoot to draft legislation that would repeal the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings law. 
 But this is not likely to occur. 
 The best that can be hoped is that the Senate and the House will agree on amendments to the law which will remove the gimmicks and inject more discipline into the process. 
 The deficit is rising and it is time, to use a phrase coined by the Wall Street Journal, to end these &bquo;fiscal follies&equo;. 
 New steel mandate 
 By BAILEY MORRIS 
 THE European Commission was yesterday given a mandate to negotiate with the United States over renewing access to its steel market, French diplomats said. 
 Under a 1985 accord between the United States and other steel-producing countries that lapsed on 30 September, EC firms are limited to 6.74 per cent of the US market. 
 According to Commission sources, the US negotiators have recently offered the EC 7 per cent of the market in a new agreement to run for two and a half years. 
 Motoring: A lead-free lover's guide to used cars: Drivers with a tight budget and an environmental conscience can buy second-hand without losing principles, says James Ruppert 
 By JAMES RUPPERT 
 FROM this month, all new cars submitted for British type approval, the test which allows them to be legally sold in the UK, must be able to run on lead-free petrol. 
 As a result of this rule, and many carefully orchestrated publicity campaigns, the motor industry's image has now changed from polluter to pal of the earth. 
 If you can afford an environmentally friendly G-registered runabout, then the flora, fauna and children of the British Isles will have a lot to thank you for. 
 But if you have a tight budget and a conscience, running older cars on lead-free fuel becomes a much more complicated issue. 
 Without the presence of a lead compound, an engine's valve seats go unprotected. 
 This leads to premature wear and plumes of blue smoke spewing from the exhaust. 
 The only effective remedy is to install hardened valve seats or a replacement cylinder head, both expensive options. 
 Less costly, but not entirely satisfactory, is the practice of making every fourth tankful leaded petrol, which protects the valve seats but rather defeats the object. 
 Alternatively there are several chemical additives on the market which aim to provide a substitute for lead, although the case for these products has yet to be proved. 
 However, many cars built within the last few years have hardened valve seats, or alloy cylinder heads that need little (simply a retune) or no modification to use unleaded petrol. 
 Finding out which cars can and which cannot is not difficult. 
 Esso filling stations have a free booklet listing most models produced since 1980, as does the charity Clear (01-387 4970), with more detail available in the Unleaded Petrol Guide (Autodale, &pound;2.99). 
 Looking at those lists provides interesting reading and bears out the used-car trade's view that having a lead-only car could prove to be a liability. 
 It is not as if four-star leaded fuel is going to be phased out tomorrow, but more and more buyers are asking: &bquo;Does it take unleaded?&equo; 
 What is certain is that the pre-1989 Austin/MG range, all Skodas, Yugos and quite a few Lancias do not, which does not help already depressed resale prices. 
 A 1985 Lancia Y10 (lead only) sells for around &pound;2,000 whereas the similar Fiat Uno 55 from the same year, converted to run on unleaded, is worth around &pound;500 more. 
 A lead-only second-hand car is now worth about 10 per cent less than an unleaded equivalent. 
 In years to come the percentage difference is likely to be much larger. 
 Even so, exotica such as lead-only Porsche 911s and Ferraris are unlikely to be part of this trend, so no bargains there I'm afraid. 
 More impressive are the Japanese manufacturers whose cars dating from the early Eighties can run on unleaded without adjustment. 
 Find a 1980 Toyota Corolla or 1982 Nissan Sunny that has not succumbed to rust, and you can buy with confidence. 
 On the home front, most Fords and Vauxhalls from at least the mid-Eighties can use unleaded. 
 If the &bquo;greenness&equo; of going unleaded still seems a bit of a grey area, it is possible to switch to diesel without a shadow of environmental doubt. 
 Diesel always has been lead-free and the only adjustments you need to make are mental ones, because diesel-powered cars are no longer slow, smelly or noisy. 
 They also return more miles to the gallon than their petrol equivalents, although service intervals are shorter. 
 But after the publicity on unleaded fuel there has been increased interest in used diesel power. 
 But remember that these cars accrue, and can withstand, significantly higher mileages than petrol cars, 50-90,000 being the norm. 
 The tradition for diesel cars is far better established on the Continent and that is where the best buys come from. 
 Perhaps the most successful maker is Peugeot, with a complete range of cars from the small 205 &mdash; around &pound;3,000 for a 90,000-mile 1985 car &mdash; to the legendary 504 estate, about &pound;2,000 for a 1982 example. 
 The Germans are also fairly accomplished manufacturers, although a five-door 1980 Golf with a six-figure mileage will still cost &pound;1,500. 
 Prestige comes in the shape of a Mercedes with the 240D or &bquo;Stuttgart Taxi&equo;, commanding &pound;7,000 but returning unfailing reliability. 
 Even if lead levels in the atmosphere do not bother you, I am sure you will find the fact that unleaded petrol is 15p cheaper, and that diesel fuel boosts mpg by at least a third, most interesting. 
 Motoring: Miles of smiles as the diesel comes of age: Brett Fraser on the Citroen AX, which offers fuel economy without much sacrifice in performance to drivers willing to turn away from the petrol engine 
 By BRETT FRASER 
 BACK IN the bad old days, drivers of diesel cars were the social outcasts of the motoring world. 
 At filling stations they were banished to the far-flung corners of the forecourt, away from the well-lit protection of covered petrol pumps, to battle 32-tonners for a turn at the diesel pump. 
 That was not the end of their woe. 
 Until recently, diesel cars were slow and very noisy, the theory being that this was the price you had to pay for economy. 
 There was a social stigma attached to diesel car ownership, too. 
 People thought perhaps you needed to save money &mdash; after all, that was the only reason for buying a diesel car, wasn't it? 
 What few realised was that diesels were more costly than their petrol-engine counterparts, and that the break-even point (when the fuel savings outweighed the price difference) didn't occur until very large mileages had been covered. 
 Those who sold their diesels after 50,000 miles or so might just as well have bought a petrol vehicle. 
 At least that was the case in Britain, where the gap between petrol and diesel fuel prices has always been small. 
 On the Continent, governments have actively encouraged the use of diesel-powered vehicles as a way of stretching resources. 
 Not only is diesel much less expensive at the pumps, especially in France and Italy, but purchase tax on diesel-powered cars is reduced. 
 Travel the roads of Italy, and petrol-engine cars appear to be in the minority. 
 Even the Italians' up-market makers, Alfa and Lancia, have diesel models. 
 In Germany, diesel sales are in sharp decline after the Greens pointed an ill-informed finger at the visibly dirty exhausts of diesels and cried &bquo;polluter&equo;. 
 In fact, diesels are cleaner in many ways than petrol engines in their emissions. 
 German manufacturers such as Mercedes-Benz and Volkswagen are so convinced of the diesel engine's future importance, they are developing &bquo;clean-burn&equo; units and fitting catalytic converters to the exhaust systems. 
 Currently the French PSA Group, which comprises Citroen and Peugeot, produces the best diesel cars. 
 &bquo;Best&equo; means a combination of economy, speed, low noise, general refinement and pleasure to drive. 
 Judged by these criteria, the little Citroen AX diesel is the best of a good bunch. 
 The AX is the smallest of the Citroen range and is available in three-and five-door versions. 
 Computers were used extensively during the car's development, in a successful attempt to make the AX 220lb lighter than the class average. 
 The significance is the boost it gives to the AX's performance, particularly in the context of the diesel. 
 Here is a diesel-engine car which will out-gun many of its petrol-engine rivals. 
 It comes close to shaming some of its own stable-mates, too, and they are among the swiftest in their class. 
 Top speed for this diesel is 96mph, and it spurts to 60mph in just 13.2 seconds. 
 Most un-diesel-like. 
 On the road, the biggest difference you notice with the diesel is the need to change up a gear slightly earlier than in a petrol car. 
 This is not a hardship, as the AX is blessed with one of the lightest and quickest gear changes around. 
 The diesel never feels slovenly and can be hurried along snaking back roads with the sort of haste which soon makes you forget that derv, not four-star (or unleaded), goes into its fuel tank. 
 Another way the AX deceives is by the noise it makes, or rather the lack of it. 
 Once, all diesels sounded like taxis all the time. 
 The baby Citroen tends to give the game away only when started from cold. 
 At 70mph it is hard to tell what fuels the car, and only at idle, windows down, does the noise start to irritate. 
 Even then, it is not so bad as to give you taxi syndrome. 
 Other noises do infiltrate the cabin &mdash; the wind, the odd bump and thump from the suspension, and the constant rattle and clunk from the cabin fittings. 
 Citroen makes some fine cars, but it tends not to make them very well. 
 The plastic the French company uses for its interior trimmings is not of high quality and looks brittle and cheap, and in most places it sounds not to be screwed as tightly down as the designers originally intended. 
 Look into a cavernous gap down the right side of the dashboard and there are wires on display &mdash; beyond them, daylight. 
 For a light car, the AX rides surprisingly well, soaking up most road surface horrors with dignified composure. 
 Rough roads, however, of the sort council repair crews seem so keen to create, ruffle it slightly and cause it to slap its tyres on the road in protest. 
 Anyone who thinks owning a diesel spells the end of driving fun, should park their backside in the AX's comfortable, supportive driver's seat and go for a quick ride. 
 It carries a bit more weight in its nose (diesel engines are heavier than petrol) but the derv-sipping AX is just as agile as its petroleum cousins. 
 Light, accurate steering allows you to place the car precisely in a bend, and although there is a fair amount of body roll, once you've chosen your cornering line not even bumps half-way through will deflect the faithful AX from its path. 
 If you go into a corner too fast the tyres will lose their adhesion, but in the AX it is safe to take your foot off the throttle and let the car snap itself back into line. 
 Try that on several cars in the Escort-class, and you will sometimes watch the back of the car overtake the front. 
 The worst that happens when you overcook things in the AX is that the nose runs gently wide. 
 And what is the fuel economy like? 
 Well, for a start, ignore the preposterous and irrelevant figures achieved on the recent RAC-supervised &bquo;economy run&equo;. 
 Unless you drive everywhere at less than 40mph and never sit in traffic jams, the record-breaking 112mpg is as achievable as drying flowers underwater. 
 Nevertheless, watching the AX's fuel gauge fall to empty is a long and tedious vigil. 
 In ordinary conditions &mdash; a mix of blatting down the motorway, pootling down country roads, and getting stuck in London's slow-motion hours (when the rest of the country apparently rushes), fuel consumption in the mid-sixties is almost guaranteed. 
 With care, and clear roads, that figure should greatly improve. 
 Even when driven with the utmost contempt for economy, it is difficult to drop below 50mpg. 
 What is nice about the AX diesel is that you can smile smugly about the miles you are effortlessly squeezing from every gallon, in the knowledge you have sacrificed little along the way. 
 No longer does the diesel driver need to feel disadvantaged. 
 Second to the sporting GT model, the diesel, in either of its two trim levels, is the most desirable of the AX range. 
 For that to be true, the diesel must have come of age. 
 Motoring: The soaring triumph of the exotic Stag: Blow all your savings on a rare classic convertible which has just started to show a major rise in value, says Roger Bell 
 By ROGER BELL 
 PSST! 
 Shares a bit shaky? 
 Bored by your savings passbook? 
 Then now is the time to invest in a Triumph Stag &mdash; but keep it to yourself. 
 There are not that many good ones about. 
 Convertible prices always tend to dip in the autumn, particularly after a balmy summer, but the advice to buy has little to do with cyclic depression. 
 Stags are appreciating. 
 In the crazy world of classic cars, where old Ferraris and Aston Martins fetch silly money, and Jaguar E-types have gone through the roof, the rise and rise of these exotics over the past two or three years has lifted values down the line. 
 If Austin Rover's Leyland forebears had made a better job of the Stag in the first place, values would probably have risen before. 
 As it is, the car's great attraction as a luxury convertible has always been overshadowed by its reputation for poor reliability. 
 Not for nothing was it dubbed the &bquo;Triumph Snag&equo;. 
 Today's Stagisti, guided by the mechanical tragedies that befell their hapless predecessors, know that preventive maintenance is the key to dependability. 
 Achieve that &mdash; and it is achievable, though my own car, currently without an engine, is not yet there &mdash; and the Stag's attractions are nothing short of seductive. 
 Much was expected of this Anglo-Italian four-place convertible, high on creature comforts as well as style, when it was introduced almost 20 years ago. 
 Triumph aimed to build 12,000 Stags a year. 
 In the event, it produced fewer than 26,000 in its seven years of manufacturing life, between 1970 and 1977. 
 Depressed production, costly for Leyland at the time, is good news for investors now because it has endowed the Stag with scarcity appeal. 
 It goes without saying that rare cars are more coveted than common ones &mdash; and rare convertibles are of blue-chip status. 
 Scarcity value apart, the Stag is made of the right stuff by classic yardsticks. 
 It has style (Michelotti's), a luxurious, timber-encrusted cabin (with hard and soft headgear), six speeds to play with (four, plus two overdrive on the manual, though many Stags had three-speed automatic transmission) and a burbling V8 engine that can be found in no other car. 
 In its day, fully independent suspension (like that of the Triumph 2000 saloon) and lavish equipment that included power-assisted steering were also assets. 
 Ironically, the Stag's reputation as an expensive liability is rooted in the three-litre, 145-horsepower engine &mdash; effectively two four-cylinder Dolomite/Saab 99 units siamesed to a common crankshaft &mdash; that is germane to the car's appeal. 
 Overheating and loose valvegear chains, both of which can abruptly extinguish all mechanical life, are its (avoidable) weaknesses. 
 With the wisdom of hindsight, it is easy to see now that the Stag's troublesome V8, designed and inadequately developed in-house by Triumph before it merged with Leyland, should have been ditched and replaced by Rover's proven ex-Buick 3.5-litre V8 (still used by Land-Rover, Morgan, TVR and others) that was already on the shelf. 
 In the interests of dependability, many Stags have subsequently been converted to Rover V8 power, gaining in reliability (and quite possibly in performance) what they lose in originality and nose heaviness. 
 A Rover-engine Stag may well be a better car than one with Triumph power, but as a hybrid it will never be so valuable. 
 Ford V6 conversions are intrinsically even less desirable &mdash; though worth considering as a cheap and reliable engine. 
 Many Stags have undergone reversion transplants in the quest for originality. 
 To buy a Stag just for its investment potential is to deny yourself the sort of al fresco luxury that most people can only dream about in a new car. 
 Jaguar's classy convertibles start at &pound;41,200, albeit with V12 power. 
 What is more, the current XJS ragtop is structurally inferior to the cabriolet (with Stag-like superstructure) that preceded it. 
 Other classy convertibles come from Mercedes-Benz, Porsche and Aston Martin, whose Volante, listed at &pound;120,000, is said to be changing hands at over &pound;200,000. 
 Even the best Stags &mdash; and the best are very good indeed - are cheap by comparison. 
 Here is stylish, tousled-hair motoring without the discomfort. 
 Here is a car to be savoured at your leisure, on high days and holidays, but above all on sunny days. 
 I enjoy my Stag most when it is loafing along in overdrive (the DIY box has longer legs than the automatic), exhaust burbling as only a twin-pipe V8 can burble. 
 When there is nothing above your head but the bracing T-bar &mdash; fitted as much to provide body rigidity as to anticipate US safety regulations that did not materialise &mdash; so much the better. 
 From February 1973, all Stags were sold with both hood (which stows neatly in a lidded well behind the back seats) and hardtop (which required two pairs of strong arms to manipulate). 
 So heavy and cumbersome is the hardtop, which fails to turn the Stag into a refined fixed-head coupe because of atrocious wind whoosh, that many have succumbed to rust while lying neglected in the garden, incubating snails. 
 The Stag is not a sports car, nor is it especially fast: any modern GTi hatchback will comfortably outpace it in a sprint from rest to 60mph. 
 What the Stag has which most modern cars do not is the endearing ability to amble quickly, to lope effortlessly, reeling in the miles without really trying. 
 That, to me, is its strongest suit. 
 Despite the intoxicating exhaust noise, the Stag is not dynamically exciting. 
 Far from it. 
 The engine's lovely, lugging delivery (it is not all bad, you see) serves as an antidote to frenetic driving. 
 Whereas most modern performance cars encourage aggression through their virulence, the Stag suppresses it while getting there just as quickly. 
 Anyone who is not relaxed and glowing with a sense of well-being at the wheel of a good Stag should keep their money in the building society. 
 Age and mileage have little to do with values any more. 
 Condition is what counts. 
 A concours Mk 1 will fetch much more than a ropy Mk 2, perhaps six years (and maybe 100,000 miles) its junior. 
 Triumph did develop the Stag a little, but not enough to make the last of the series significantly better than the first. 
 Most of the changes were cosmetic, anyway. 
 Prices today range from under &pound;1,000 (bangers for breaking or total restoration) to over &pound;15,000. 
 Unblemished freaks, still in showroom condition (or else expensively restored to it) have been known to sell for even more. 
 Expect to pay &pound;4,000 for a serviceable car, &pound;6,000 for one of quality (rust-free body, sound engine), &pound;10,000 or more for outstanding examples. 
 Spares, by the way, are plentiful and relatively cheap (Rimmers and SOC Ltd are major suppliers) and membership of the active Stag Owner's Club is strongly recommended. 
 Auctions: Dazzling riches of the Orient 
 By ROGER BELL 
 IT IS Asian Week at Sotheby's and Christie's. 
 They are mixing Islamic art from the Middle East with Indian and South-East Asian. 
 The sales combine items of charm at fairly accessible prices with some rare treasures aimed at big-time collectors. 
 Homely Persian pottery of the twelfth to thirteenth century combines animal and bird images with sinuous plant motifs and marks the beginning of lustre wares; they are mostly priced in the &pound;500 to &pound;1,000 range and rate high on charm. 
 The Iznik pottery from Turkey dating from the fifteenth and sixteenth century explodes with colour on more sophisticated white grounds; Iznik is now highly sought after by Turkish yuppies and prices run from &pound;2,000 or so to &pound;15,000. 
 Both houses combine elegant early metalwares (twelfth/thirteenth century), bronze vessels with silver inlay &mdash; which are expensive &mdash; with nineteenth- century imitations, more flashy but in the mid-hundreds. 
 There are plenty of Indian miniatures, colourful and charming evocations of princely courts, priced in hundreds or low thousands. 
 Stone figures chipped off the war-torn temples of Cambodia are more expensive; a striking Khmer figure will cost &pound;20,000 or more. 
 There are also outstanding bits of Indian stone monuments, with gods and goddesses sensuously entwined in spiritual embrace; they start with the Gandhara grey schist carvings of the third/fourth century. 
 Glasgow: Clocks and scientific instruments, Wednesday 11am. 
 Market Harborough: Ceramics, glass, toys, silver, musical instruments and artworks, Tuesday 10am. 
 Prints, watercolours, oil paintings, furniture and architectural effects, Tuesday 1.30pm. 
 Gildings, Roman Way (0858 410414). 
 Finds: Old firm friends: John Windsor on a fight to save corporate archives from the bin 
 By JOHN WINDSOR 
 COMPANY records &mdash; boring-sounding but the ultimate in historical memorabilia -have slipped through the fingers of British private collectors by the skipload. 
 Only a sophisticated handful of collectors seek company minute books, ledgers and subject files to add historical depth to displayable hardware such as insurance firemarks or automobilia. 
 It has fallen to salaried professionals in universities, public record offices, the Business Archives Council, corporate bodies themselves &mdash; and the &bquo;vanity press&equo; &mdash; to salvage and conserve the tons of old papers explaining the historical context of what tumbled off the production line. 
 As the heritage boom gathers pace, made-to-measure company and family biographies have become big business. 
 For &dollar;27,000 (&pound;16,800), the San Francisco vanity publisher The Sharper Image offers 225-page hardbound corporate histories in limited editions of 100, for use &bquo;as a public relations tool&equo;. 
 The London publisher Henry Melland offers corporate biographies for &pound;5,000-&pound;50,000, and lists among past and present clients BP and British Steel. 
 A new British company, Living Memories, will produce an illustrated album of company or family biography for a typical price of &pound;500 for a family, &pound;2,000 for a company. 
 Most sophisticated of all, Terry Gourvish, director of the London School of Economics' business history unit, charges up to &pound;150,000 for a three to four-year company history project employing two full-time researchers. 
 No vanity here: the result is a warts-and-all publication intended as salutary reading during management training. 
 Rowntree and Glaxo are at present under his scrutiny. 
 Such in-depth research is what Sunday-morning collecting should evolve into but seldom does. 
 One of the few collectors dedicated enough to go for the company context is Peter Card, whose collection of 400 old bicycle lamps is without equal. 
 As honorary archivist for Lucas, the motor components group, he begged the company to let him be custodian of the earliest archives - including Lucas family albums &mdash; when, during company restructuring two years ago, the entire archive went to the British Motor Industry Heritage Trust. 
 Company archives are not that difficult to find. 
 They tend to be the first victims of clean-sweep company shake-ups and takeovers. 
 Expanding City firms hire skips to empty old papers out of basements and attics. 
 I paid a Hackney second-hand dealer &pound;100 a few years ago for seven black plastic bags of documents dating back to the seventeenth century &mdash; the contents of tin trunks removed from the basement of a firm of solicitors. 
 They include the entire records, with a letters file, charting the heat-and- history of the London-based Egyptian Dredging Company, 1885-1938. 
 There is also a complete and intimate record of the acrimonious relationship which developed between the Norwich Union Insurance Company and the founding manager of its London office in Edwardian times. 
 Besides an at times emotional correspondence, the manager's bills for dinners, cigars and ladies' hats, and a vellum wallet full of used cheques are all intact, providing a documentary cameo of the life and times of an Edwardian financial rake. 
 The thought of such treasures disappearing into private collections brings a sigh to Serena Kelly, secretary-general of the Business Archives Council. 
 She has never had to compete with private collectors for company archives and hopes she never has to. 
 As the Council's only full-time worker, she runs a one-woman intelligence operation, making friends with company archivists and hob-nobbing with big liquidators such as the London accountants Cork, Gully and Grant, Thornton, who allow her access to their warehouses of seized goods. 
 She relies heavily on tip-offs, in turn alerting county and metropolitan records offices about historic company records due for release by liquidators. 
 Two years ago, she and John Orbell, archivist of Baring Brothers and chairman of the Council's Liquidations and Rescue Support Group, were tipped off by a friendly Extel employee about the news agency's imminent takeover by United Newspapers. 
 The voluminous Extel archives, giving a unique insight into Victorian journalists' news-gathering methods (and expenses claims) are now in London's Guildhall Library awaiting a researcher. 
 We accompanied Pamela Scott-Wexo, a director of Living Memories, on a visit to one of her clients, the Royal Star and Garter Home for disabled servicemen at Richmond, Surrey, to see what her research would turn up. 
 One resident, Jim Goodson, aged 105, who enlisted in the Army in 1902 at the age of 17, remembered being one of the first to be issued with a khaki uniform, an improvement on the red tunics which the Boers picked off so easily. 
 She will include such memories in the home's 75th anniversary volume. 
 Collecting: You're never alone with a print: Edward Lucie-Smith reports on why the modern multiple image is making a big impact in the blue-chip art market 
 By EDWARD LUCIE-SMITH 
 Many column inches have recently been devoted to the boom in classic modern and contemporary painting. 
 Very little has been said about the boom in modern prints. 
 In some ways this boom is even more extraordinary, because it represents not only a new taste but a subtly different attitude towards works of art. 
 Peter Osborne of the Berkeley Square Gallery in London, which specialises in material of this kind, explained some of the rules of the print market. 
 &bquo;A print of the right kind is not simply something that is worth money. 
 It is more like actual currency. 
 The reason is that while it may be in limited supply, it isn't unique. 
 When other, identical examples exist, it is easy to establish what the value should be. 
 It is also much easier to create a market situation which will see to it that the value goes up.&equo; 
 Not every print, or every print-maker, is suitable for the purpose, however. 
 The blue-chip market is confined to a very limited number of names. 
 There are certain artists of the old Ecole de Paris: Matisse, Picasso, Miro, Chagall, Rouault. 
 There are certain contemporary American artists: Jasper Johns, Frank Stella, Jim Dine, Sam Francis. 
 There are also two British artists: Henry Moore and David Hockney. 
 What are the rules of admission to the pantheon? 
 First, the artist has to be a &bquo;major name&equo;. 
 Second, he has to be a prolific print-maker, and the prints themselves, though perhaps individually rare, must collectively be in reasonably good supply. 
 Third, the prints must form an integral part of the artist's career &mdash; that is, our appreciation of his achievement as a whole would be incomplete without some knowledge of his activity in this field. 
 All of these are fairly obvious. 
 But there are two other, less obvious laws as well. 
 Prints, to be valuable, must be good impressions on good quality paper. 
 Edvard Munch, whom many art historians would describe as one of the greatest print-makers of the century, fails to qualify as &bquo;blue-chip&equo;, despite occasional high prices at auction, because he often used poor quality paper and the impressions are not always of the best quality. 
 The final qualification is that a print-maker, to reach the very top of the tree, must be known and appreciated by the Japanese. 
 The Berkeley Square Gallery, for example, maintains a second outlet in Tokyo, as a vital part of its operations. 
 Japanese collectors find it easy to appreciate prints, because works on paper are very much part of their own cultural heritage. 
 They do not make the distinction between an image on canvas or panel and one on paper which seems so obvious &mdash; indeed axiomatic &mdash; to Europeans. 
 They are aware of the fact that some of the greatest of their own artists &mdash; Hokusai, for instance, and Hiroshige &mdash; made print-making a primary creating medium. 
 Japanese collectors also value the psychological security offered by the multiple image &mdash; to like exactly what other collectors like seems to them a good and reassuring thing. 
 The way the market in prints moves is very much governed by developments in Japanese taste. 
 &bquo;The first generation of collectors was very conservative,&equo; said Mr Osborne. 
 &bquo;They tended to like what was soft-edged and pretty.&equo; 
 As a result of this, certain big Renoir prints are expensive &mdash; over &pound;20,000 for the kind of lithograph which looks like a chalk drawing. 
 This makes a striking contrast with Manet, whose prints, though rare, are modest in scale and not found in signed, numbered editions. 
 The Berkeley Square Gallery has an example of his Infanta Margarita (After Velazquez) for only &pound;1,250. 
 But now a new generation of Japanese collectors is coming into the market and their taste is for much stronger, more colourful things, such as prints by Miro. 
 Something they have not developed a liking for yet is prints by the German Expressionists and their successors, the artists of the Neue Sachlichkeit such as Beckmann and Grosz. 
 Occasionally, they take a liking to a European or American artist who is not really an absolutely major name internationally. 
 An example is the American Carol Summers, who makes superb, coloured woodcuts. 
 What they appreciate here is the closeness to their own tradition &mdash; Hokusai's prints are coloured woodcuts, too &mdash; and superb quality. 
 How much do real blue-chip prints tend to cost? 
 This is fairly easy to answer, but only with the proviso that a given conjunction of circumstances will set prices spiralling upward again. 
 A recent major commercial show of Miro's work, for example, took all his prices to a new high. 
 A big coloured image, such as the aptly named Le Samourai, will now cost &pound;25,000. 
 Spectacular coloured Chagalls bring even more &mdash; up to &pound;45,000. 
 So do major prints by Sam Francis (who lived and worked for a while in Japan). 
 The benchmark here is over &pound;50,000. 
 Matisse and Picasso, who form the backbone of the market in &bquo;classic modern&equo; prints, bring sums which depend both on the actual rarity of the image and its attractiveness. 
 A beautiful odalisque by Matisse, such as Torso with a Jug, typical of the work he did in the 1920s and 1930s, will bring &pound;35,000 or more. 
 Images from Picasso's eternally popular Vollard Suite, which dates from the early 1930s, bring between &pound;8,000 and &pound;12,000 plus &mdash; but these, though easy to like because of their smooth neo-classical style, are not coloured and were published in a fairly big edition. 
 The established artist who is currently rising most rapidly in price is Hockney. 
 Images from the mid-1970s &mdash; large prints of swimming pools, vases of flowers and interiors (all nice, neutral subjects) were till recently anchored at around &pound;15,000. 
 In recent months they have begun to tear loose from this platform. 
 Today, &pound;20,000 might be a good guess for an especially attractive image and Mr Osborne predicts that the price will soon be nearer to &pound;30,000. 
 Obviously a good choice for collectors who like their blue-chips gilded. 
 But what about the long-term future? 
 One problem is that there do not seem to be many potentially blue-chip names in the pipeline, ready to join what is now a severely restricted group. 
 The Neo-Expressionists mostly seem too dour to qualify &mdash; and most do not make prints on a sufficiently regular basis. 
 One answer seems to be that the market will take another look at Impressionist prints, and those by the Nabis, both of which are beginning to seem undervalued, in comparison with what was produced by their successors. 
 You can get a fine Bonnard print for &pound;2,500; a Pissarro for less than &pound;7,000. 
 Signac, who continued his activity as a print-maker into the period after the First World War, uses the graphic medium superbly. 
 A tip-top specimen costs &pound;10,000. 
 Even Cezanne's rare prints are starting to look a bit undervalued, in terms of the way in which the market as a whole is performing. 
 Move over Hockney, Uncle Paul is behind you. 
 If this is the way things go, there would be a certain art-historical justice in it. 
 Leading Article: Hopes of better times deferred 
 By EDWARD LUCIE-SMITH 
 THERE is a certain symmetry in the evolution of the fortunes of the two major political parties in the past week. 
 At its conference in Brighton, the Labour Party showed that it is on the way to becoming an electable party. 
 The best hope of it actually achieving power would be a prolonged demonstration by the Conservative Government that it cannot run the economy competently. 
 Thursday's raising of base interest rates to 15 per cent in the wake of the Bundesbank, although unavoidable, has embarrassingly reinforced that impression. 
 Coming on top of a worryingly high inflation rate and a sequence of record-breaking trade deficits, Labour will be working hard to demonstrate that ordinary people are paying dearly for mistakes which the once super-abundantly confident Chancellor has made in economic management. 
 The latest interest rate rise will also cause some genuine anger at next week's Conservative Party conference in Blackpool, since it hits both mortgage-holders and entrepreneurs. 
 Mr Lawson will be hard pressed to convince delegates with his perpetual refrain: that all is under control and better times are not far ahead. 
 For Labour, it has been a good week. 
 At last it has achieved a respectable measure of unity at most levels of the party. 
 For once attention could be focused not on its divisions, but on its policies. 
 Some of these remained conveniently imprecise; but in his keynote speech, Neil Kinnock sketched an angle of attack with high potential appeal to the large floating centre of the British electorate. 
 In language which sounded convincingly like a social democrat's, he indicated that Labour would concentrate investment on the new commanding heights of the modern economy &mdash; education and training &mdash; and on technical research and the transport system. 
 With that emphasis, Labour could hope to appeal strongly to a wide spectrum of the middle classes, from parents who are desperately worried about their children's schooling to commuters fed up with the run-down public transport services and clogged roads. 
 Their votes will be vital if seats long since lost to the Conservatives are to be regained. 
 The irony is, however, that the economic crisis which might clinch their switch to Labour at the next election &mdash; with continuing balance-of-payments problems, punishing interest rates, a sinking pound, inflation and recession &mdash; would by definition preclude the heavy public investment required to implement the Kinnock programme. 
 It must be said, however, that this is a nightmare scenario which the Government does not subscribe to. 
 Ministers are, significantly, confident that an upturn can be achieved in good time before the next election. 
 Relations between the Prime Minister and Nigel Lawson may still be strained (she blames him for the present difficulties). 
 But there is no division over what needs to be done, or any question of ditching Mr Lawson. 
 Interest rates will have to remain painfully high for some months, and departmental spending will be made to stay within the current planning totals: even the big-spending ministers recognise they are involved in bidding against each other, rather than against the Treasury. 
 The Conservative case is that the present economic situation does not amount to a crisis. 
 The balance-of-payments deficit is not as bad as it looks, partly because it stems from private sector choices rather than public sector profligacy, and is thus inherently less inflationary as individuals cannot resort to the printing press to ease the burden of their debt; and partly because much of it may be imaginary, since the figures omit the &bquo;balancing item&equo; of unrecorded net receipts from overseas assets. 
 On this analysis, the economy remains fundamentally sound. 
 The most critical period will be this winter's round of wage negotiations. 
 If it can be weathered without undue damage, interest rates should fall sharply in the latter half of next year. 
 The Government's accumulated fiscal surpluses will then be available both to revive an economy which has had the excess heat taken out of it during 1989/90 and to restore its electoral fortunes. 
 The danger for the Government is that it may all come just a bit too late to expunge the memories of our current travails and of too long a period of neglect for the supply-side of the economy to respond. 
 In such circumstances, the new Kinnock approach &mdash; as long as he can show that it is not irredeemably inflationary &mdash; might appear quite attractive to people who would not otherwise have considered voting Labour. 
 Quote Unquote 
 By EDWARD LUCIE-SMITH 
 THE days must go when they can wake up a judge at dead of night, give him a drop of brandy, show him a headline in The Sun, and get him to sign an injunction. 
 Ron Todd on anti-strike laws. 
 During the period we were watching, we counted between 2,200 and 2,300 going into the launderette. 
 Only 217 took in washing. 
 Chief Supt Richard Stacey on surveillance at Broadwater Farm The curse of drug addiction, which hovers like a dark cloud over entire nations, is surely one of the most serious menaces to freedom in our time. 
 Pope John Paul. 
 I refuse to stand by and do nothing. 
 Abe Nathan, Middle East peace campaigner, jailed for six months in Israel for meeting Yasser Arafat The existence of the Socialist German Democratic Republic is good fortune for our people, and for the peoples of Europe. 
 Erich Honecker. 
 Who wants to celebrate on 7 October (fortieth anniversary of the GDR)? resident of East Berlin The successful are always tempted to regard their success as a sort of blessing or reward for righteousness. 
 This can lead to judgements being made about the unsuccessful, the unemployed, the poor and the unintelligent which are both uncharitable and untrue. 
 Archbishop of Canterbury. 
 With that skirt, you could see everything she had. 
 She was advertising for sex. 
 Ray Diamond, foreman of jury in Miami which cleared a man of rape. 
 I cannot give you a firm promise that this is the turning point. 
 Nigel Lawson after raising the base lending rate to 15 per cent. 
 There will be an orange lily growing there next year. 
 Rev Ian Paisley at the roadside where he answered a call of nature. 
 I am not Lord Longford in drag. 
 The Princess Royal on her prison visits. 
 It looks like a scene set from Beau Geste or one of those biblical epics. 
 We are the extras. 
 Dennis Skinner on Labour's conference rostrum 
 Profile: The stirrer in communism's kitchen: Imre Pozsgay, Hungarian reformer 
 By EDWARD LUCIE-SMITH 
 He has Hungary's second highest academic title in Marxist philosophy, has spent half his life teaching and disseminating the official ideology, and is one of the leaders of the Hungarian Socialist Workers Party, which calls itself the &bquo;vanguard of the working class&equo;. 
 But the enthusiasm which burned inside Imre Pozsgay when he joined the party at the age of 17 has been extinguished by the bitter experiences of the past 40 years. 
 He now describes communism as an &bquo;abstract concept&equo; and is this weekend busily exorcising the ghosts of Marx, Lenin and Stalin from his party, which opened its congress yesterday in Budapest. 
 Mr Pozsgay has become what all religions fear most &mdash; a renegade. 
 Born 56 years ago into a moderately well-to-do family in the village of Konyi in southern Hungary, Mr Pozsgay had no personal motivation to espouse revolution, unlike many of his contemporaries who were driven to the party by abject poverty. 
 He was one of the army of young idealists who believed that &bquo;scientific socialism&equo; held all the answers for their war-ravaged country. 
 &bquo;We shall overturn the whole world by tomorrow,&equo; they chanted with earnest conviction. 
 This they very nearly achieved. 
 By the time Mr Pozsgay joined up in 1950, the communists had strangled all other parties and executed many &bquo;class traitors&equo; within their own ranks. 
 But for Mr Pozsgay and his fellow thinkers, the end always justified the means. 
 To strengthen his beliefs, Mr Pozsgay enrolled at Budapest's Lenin Institute to study history and Marxism-Leninism. 
 He was a final-year student there when he went down to the provincial town of Kecskemet to earn some pocket money by delivering lectures. 
 The date was October 1956 and in Budapest anti-communist demonstrators and the Hungarian army were clashing with Soviet tanks. 
 Mr Pozsgay did not rush back. 
 By consequence of his inaction, he is the only leading communist of his generation today to be completely untainted by the 1956 uprising and its aftermath. 
 At the end of his studies, Mr Pozsgay was sent back in 1957 to Kecskemet, to become director of the county party committee's Marxism-Leninism evening school. 
 In 1965, at the age of 32, he became an apparatchik, first as a department head of the county party committee and then, in 1968, its secretary. 
 This was the year of the first wave of reforms in Hungary, when thinking communists were beginning to realise that something had gone awfully wrong. 
 Economic decentralisation was coupled with political liberalisation, and regional party bosses were allowed to experiment. 
 Mr Pozsgay's contribution was his support for &bquo;populist&equo; writers who drew their inspiration from rural Hungary and championed &bquo;national values&equo;. 
 Their concern for the Hungarian minority in Romania at a time when relations between Budapest and Bucharest were excellent frequently landed them in trouble with the authorities. 
 This period marks the beginning of his life-long friendship with a group of writers and intellectuals who now dominate one strand of Hungary's political life. 
 From Kecskemet, his path led to the party headquarters in Budapest. 
 Gyorgy Aczel, the liberal-minded ideology chief, spotted the talented regional boss and took him under his wings. 
 In 1970, Mr Pozsgay joined the Agitprop department &mdash; the party's watchdog on ideological purity and the media. 
 A year later he moved again, to become deputy editor of the party's turgid theoretical review, Tarsadalmi Szemle. 
 Whatever Mr Pozsgay thought of the hardline backlash which began around 1973, he kept it to himself. 
 There is no point in looking for any improvement in the journal while he was second in command &mdash; there was none. 
 Mr Pozsgay kept rising. 
 In 1975, at the peak of the conservative onslaught, he was appointed deputy minister of culture, and a year later was put in charge of the ministry. 
 The Pozsgay era there was as unremarkable in Hungary's cultural life as his tenure at the party review had been. 
 His literary proteges were allowed to publish more and the film industry also prospered. 
 But there was a limit to what Mr Aczel, the party's ideologist, could tolerate and the gradual thaw was frequently punctuated with repressive measures against those who fell out of line. 
 Nevertheless, Mr Pozsgay did at least emerge from his six-year stint at the head of the ministry as a man who deserved credit for trying. 
 Though he was clearly the more liberal half of the Aczel-Pozsgay tandem, he lost his job because of personal differences with his boss and not, as he claimed, for political reasons. 
 Mr Pozsgay was simply fed up with playing second fiddle, a characteristic that was to re-emerge later. 
 The &bquo;impertinent Pozsgay&equo;, as party leader Janos Kadar called him, was made boss of the party's powerless umbrella body, the Patriotic People's Front, in 1982. 
 As head of this embodiment of pluralism in a one-party state, his job was to ensure the communists got the required 99 per cent vote at elections and to maintain some semblance of a dialogue with people in the grey area between loyalty and opposition. 
 But then the unthinkable happened. 
 Mr Pozsgay, the soft-spoken intellectual who had loyally served the party all his life, rebelled. 
 Instead of submitting his organisation to the will of party bureaucrats, he turned it into his own power-base and started bombarding the party with his own initiatives. 
 He used ceremonial occasions to launch scathing attacks on conservatives and took on the role of the spokesman of all Hungarians, inside and outside the country. 
 In the forest of intellectual midgets with whom Janos Kadar surrounded himself, Imre Pozsgay, the powerful orator, became a star. 
 Reformists, closet-reformists and non-party intellectuals gathered in his home, feeding him their ideas and plotting against hardliners. 
 In 1987, the conspiracy stepped out of his living room into the limelight with the founding of the Hungarian Democratic Forum, now the largest opposition party. 
 The Forum's programme, which Mr Pozsgay helped to publicise, very closely resembled his own ideas: democracy, an autonomous society, freedom of expression, a proper constitutional order and radical economic reforms. 
 Other people and think-tanks had come up with a similar recipe before and never had much impact. 
 What they lacked was Mr Pozsgay's eloquence, access to the media and the ability to relate these lofty ideas to the man and woman in the street. 
 This is where Mr Pozsgay's training as the people's spokesman became useful. 
 By linking Hungarian national aspirations, in a language reminiscent of the country's greatest writers, to the general yearning for democracy, he struck a chord. 
 By the time Kadar realised what was happening, it was too late. 
 At a party conference in May last year, Kadar was replaced by Karoly Grosz and Mr Pozsgay was swept into the Politburo on the crest of the reformist wave. 
 But the comings-and-goings at the Pozsgay household did not stop. 
 He and his friends were already planning to oust the new boss and seize the party. 
 There are many people in Hungary nursing stab wounds in the back who can testify to Mr Pozsgay's first-class conspiratorial skills, but few have caught him wielding the knife. 
 Lacking the stomach for open combat, Mr Pozsgay unleashes terror on his opponents by proxy, when they least suspect it. 
 When one quiet weekend this February Mr Grosz left the country on a short trip to Switzerland, little did he know what would await him on his return. 
 For on that Saturday Mr Pozsgay organised a radio interview to tell the world that a party committee working under him had come to the conclusion that 1956 had been a popular uprising, thus ensuring that the terms of reference in Hungarian politics would never be the same again. 
 A hastily convened Central Committee meeting fudged the question of 1956, but not before Mr Pozsgay extracted the greatest concession possible: the green light to the multi-party system. 
 By then the Pozsgay bulldozer was rolling ahead at full speed. 
 Reform circles were springing up all over the country, calling for Mr Grosz's dismissal. 
 True to style, Mr Pozsgay claimed only to be a sympathiser of the movement and not its instigator. 
 All these schemings take a lot of energy, and Mr Pozsgay has plenty. 
 He darts around the country in the same blue pin-stripe suit, delivering variations of the same speech. 
 He frequently gives interviews, and has got television performances down to a fine art. 
 His boyish smile and double chin are now instantly recognised by Hungarian and &mdash; increasingly &mdash; by foreign viewers. 
 In his spare time he reads social science journals and contemporary Hungarian literature, or cooks for his family or friends. 
 His spicy fisherman's soup is legendary. 
 Mr Pozsgay has been written off many times. 
 A television commentator once said he stood no chance of becoming Hungary's leader because he was too fat. 
 Well, a little thing like that should not be allowed to stand in the way of such a great man, so Mr Pozsgay now spends one hour a week in the gym. 
 He has one great ambition: to be leader of a democratic Hungary. 
 Even six months ago, that seemed an impossible dream, but now, who knows? 
 If the final hurdle of this party congress is cleared, Hungary will be on the threshold of multi-party democracy. 
 The other half of his ambition has never been in doubt. 
 Mr Pozsgay's popularity ensures that if he stands, no one will defeat him in the presidential election. 
 He feels no need to conceal his personal ambition. 
 Deep down, he is convinced that he is the best thing that has happened to his country since the invention of goulash. 
 He may well be right. 
 Whatever the future holds for him, Mr Pozsgay has already ensured that his name will for ever be written in Hungarian history books. 
 Closed world of the potato harvest 
 By DUFF HART-DAVIS 
 ON FARM after farm around us the potato harvest is coming in &mdash; but the lifting of spuds is not what it used to be. 
 Gone are the days when women and children scrabbled along the furrows in the wake of a plough or simple digger collecting the fruits of the earth by hand. 
 Now the job is done by vast machines, which, with their great bulk and ponderous gait, resemble elephants travelling in reverse, the chute for the reject stalks hanging at the back like a canvas trunk. 
 To observe modern methods, come aboard this red monster, which, if new, would cost about &pound;25,000. 
 One tractor pulls it, another keeps a trailer moving alongside to receive the crop. 
 The farmer and his younger son are the drivers. 
 The crew of the harvester consists of five men, one woman and a sure-footed terrier called Benson. 
 We humans stand facing each other, three and three, high in the body of the machine. 
 Were it an elephant, our feet would be in its midriff, our heads just under its rib-cage. 
 Instead of ribs, the machine has a canvas roof to shield us from the weather, and although one can peer out through slits here and there, the effect is of travelling in a closed world, like an outsize gypsy wagon. 
 Overhead is a communication cord, as in a train. 
 A tug on it sounds a buzzer in the driver's cab and brings him to a halt. 
 Here we go, then, at a good half-mile an hour. 
 Far down below us, out of sight, a scoop burrows through the earth, lifting a single drill at a time. 
 This autumn the ground is so dry that most of the earth falls away through the gaps in the conveyor-belts, but the digger cannot distinguish between potatoes, stones and potato-sized clods of mud, and the whole lot are delivered aloft, along two belts made of metal rods. 
 At the back of the machine, on our level, an ingenious device separates out most of the stones: a circular rubber pad revolves below brushes, which are stiff enough to sweep the potatoes off into their special channel, but not rigid enough to dislodge the stones until later. 
 The idea works well, but it is not infallible. 
 This is where we humans come in. 
 As soon as the monster is in motion, twin tides of spuds and stones come pouring along the two channels, potatoes on one side, rocks on the other. 
 But in the potato channel are lumps of earth and a few stones masquerading as vegetable, and in the stone channel a few potatoes pretending to be mineral. 
 The noise is formidable, for the rocks clatter and bang away down a steel chute that dumps them back on the ground. 
 Our job is to sort everything out: to snatch the rocks and clods from the potato channel, and whip rogue spuds from among the stones. 
 The job demands intense concentration; even with six pairs of hands grabbing, the flow is almost too fast to be dealt with precisely. 
 At the end of each drill, as the tractor turns, the flood dwindles, the noise dies away, and we get a break. 
 The relaxed atmosphere breeds bantering conversation. 
 In the old days it needed a team of 20 women to do the equivalent job &mdash; and even then they did it less than half as fast. 
 &bquo;Couldn't get &bquo;em now,&equo; says the farmer's wife scornfully. 
 &bquo;They don't want to know. 
 If you do get somebody, one day of it about kills her.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; says my neighbour, who sports a white linen cap. 
 &bquo;And the rest of &bquo;em tell you where to go.&equo; 
 We are rolling again. 
 The noise builds up to a shattering roar. 
 Gossip is impossible now. 
 Go for the clods, spot the rocks. 
 Lurching along in this enclosed space, one loses all sense of direction. 
 The field is on a slope, so that there is a difference between going up and going down &mdash; but that is all. 
 These potatoes are round and white, a new Dutch strain, being grown in Britain for the first time this year. 
 They have been bred specially for chipping: they are not good for boiling because they tend to explode, but they cook fast and &mdash; hideous thought &mdash; absorb fat quickly. 
 The small ones will be kept back for seed, and anything damaged by worms or excavation will become cattle fodder; but all the rest go for chips. 
 Towards the bottom of the field the stones lie thicker. 
 An absolute torrent of them comes pouring through and down the junk-chute. 
 &bquo;Bring your wheelbarrow!&equo; yells the man in the white cap merrily. 
 &bquo;You can have a few of they.&equo; 
 The volume passing grows too great to be sorted properly. 
 &bquo;Stop him!&equo; somebody yells. 
 The man opposite me yanks the communication cord, and we lurch to a halt. 
 AS WE turn, discussion falls on the possibility of getting rid of the stones. 
 They could, in theory, be collected in another trailer and taken away, instead of being put back on the field. 
 But if you did that (the farmer's elder son reckons), the plough would simply bite deeper next time round, and bring another few hundred thousand to the surface. 
 Back at the top of the hill, the trailer alongside is full. 
 Eight tons of spuds: how many chips will that make? 
 How much salt and vinegar will this one load take down with it? 
 Better not think about it. 
 If things continue to go well, the day's work will produce three times that amount. 
 But now it is one o'clock, and I, being only a volunteer, can step down for lunch without loss of face. 
 The rest will do a nine-hour day &mdash; after which, I imagine, they will be seeing potatoes in their sleep and grabbing at phantom clods of earth for half the night. 
 Compared with that heavyweight operation, our own domestic harvest seems small beer. 
 Yet in the garden digging proceeds amid no mean excitement, for this year we have grown, for the first time, that exotic variety, the pink fir apple. 
 It must be admitted that these potatoes look obscene. 
 There is no other word for them. 
 Pink (as their name suggests), elongated, covered with nobbles and excrescences, they might be anatomical specimens: barely mentionable organs, far gone with some disgusting disease. 
 There is something of the artichoke in their irregularity, something of the pork sausage in their shape and colour. 
 Their appearance deceives. 
 One of their advantages is that they are an early potato which comes to maturity in autumn. 
 Even now they do not need peeling: a wash is enough. 
 Yet easily their greatest asset is their flavour: they have a marvellous, meaty texture and more taste than any other spud I know. 
 Hot with butter, cold with mayonnaise, they are excellent at any meal. 
 When Sainsbury's introduced them into their supermarkets two years ago, people hit them hard. 
 Pink fir apples became, in the words of a spokesman, &bquo;one of our most popular speciality lines&equo;. 
 This week they went on sale again, at the ludicrous price of 92p for a 608-gramme punnet, or about 70p a pound. 
 Now I have a dire suspicion that pink fir apples are being kept down artificially, that a cartel is operating. 
 One hears odd whispers to the effect that the production of seed is limited, and that only a few growers are allowed to handle them. 
 The secret &mdash; which I now divulge &mdash; is that they are dead easy to grow. 
 There is no mystique about their cultivation. 
 Put them in the ground, and up they come. 
 So I urge anyone with a garden to visit Sainsbury's, keep back a few potatoes at the end of the season, before Christmas store them carefully and plant them in the spring. 
 If you do that, 92p should give you not a punnet but a bucketful. 
 My Week: Conjuring tricks with a sewing basket 
 By WILLIAM DONALDSON 
 The spectacle last week of 400 officers in riot gear running round the Broadwater Farm Estate and finding little or nothing in the way of drugs reminded me of Sir Robert Mark's definition of a good police force as one which employed fewer criminals than it caught. 
 He went on to say that the Met failed in this respect, and it is certainly the case that in the late Sixties some policemen would have taken the evidence with them, later, with a conjuror's flourish, producing sackfuls of cannabis from behind the furniture with cries of &bquo;Hullo John! 
 What have we here?&equo; 
 Times change, I suppose &mdash; which is not to admit that fat generalisations about the Sixties, Seventies or Eighties are less problematic than statements about any other logical fiction, be it the nation, a salad, the MCC or whatever. 
 The activities of politicians, pop stars and policemen notwithstanding, life for most people is much the same, obviously, whatever decade it is &mdash; more or less endurable if you are young, that is, and quite the opposite if you are not. 
 Thus, when my boy Charlie says, &bquo;What were the Sixties like, Daddy?&equo; 
 I always reply, &bquo;It's the Sixties for you now, dear, so you get out there and make a wally of yourself&equo; &mdash; and he has never let me down in that respect, I am glad to say. 
 Even the fact that disappointed old toss-pots &mdash; unable to grapple with the idea that people once enjoyed themselves without getting drunk, vomiting and hitting one another &mdash; still react to the Sixties, as a notion, with comical indignation has never convinced me that there was anything special about that time. 
 Now I'm not so sure. 
 In the past week I have seen an exhibition of photographs by Lewis Morley &mdash; billed as &bquo;Photographer of the Sixties&equo; &mdash; at the National Portrait Gallery and I have reviewed elsewhere Paparazzo!, a collection of pavement snaps, taken during the Thatcher years, more or less, by someone called Richard Young. 
 The contrast between the images is quite extraordinary. 
 Morley's subjects were delightful, talented young people, clearly, who got on with the job and threatened no one. 
 Young's victims, on the other hand - silly old men and odd little tarts on their way home from Tramp and Langans -looked utterly mad, their faces contorted with rage and disappointment. 
 What are they on, I kept asking myself, booze or cocaine? 
 It must be booze, I think. 
 Cocaine is a very nasty drug, causing people to talk too much and to stay up too late, but it does not, in my experience, make you violent. 
 All these people want to do is hit someone before the lights go out. 
 It was not like that in the Sixties. 
 In the Sixties people worked hard and behaved themselves &mdash; except the police, of course. 
 Excluded, naturally, from the better parties, some of them would attempt to get on terms with their social superiors by bursting in with a search warrant in one hand and evidence in another, which they would produce from nowhere like cabaret artists plucking doves out of the air. 
 When they did this to me I was quite startled, in spite of Sir Robert's warning. 
 It happened during one of Mrs Mouse's musical evenings. 
 One minute a well-behaved group of us &mdash; writers, intellectuals and so forth &mdash; were contentedly watching Zelda Plum dancing with the chinchilla on her head while Ken the Australian Horse Player offered odds ('Six to four the rat,&equo; he used to say, I do not know why, and on this particular evening the rat escaped and tripped up Robin Fox, London's most distinguished theatrical agent, who fell on top of Wales's friend, the actress Susan George) and the next a squad of hooligans were pushing people around and conjuring a piece of pot from Mrs Mouse's sewing basket. 
 I had to laugh, was still laughing an hour later while being finger-printed in the nick. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; I said to the arresting officer, whom I will call Mr Pilcher, because that was his name. 
 &bquo;You know that I know that wasn't my piece of stuff. 
 What's your game?&equo; 
 &bquo;Actually,&equo; he said, &bquo;I was looking for something else.&equo; 
 &bquo;In that case,&equo; I said, &bquo;why didn't you bring it with you?&equo; 
 Which I still think was quite quick in the circumstances. 
 &bquo;Don't be like that,&equo; said Mr Pilcher, and he then gave me to understand that for an unspecified weekly consideration I could purchase his protection, allowing me and Mrs Mouse to continue with our musical evenings without their being gate-crashed by him and his colleagues. 
 Finally, he showed me off the premises with the injunction, accompanied by a theatrical wink, that I should get straight on to him if I ever had any bother. 
 I was never able to take him up on this kindness, alas, since he and half the drugs squad were themselves arrested a few days later. 
 He got four years and later emigrated to Australia, whereas I was fined &pound;30 and am welcome on Wogan, except that I am not. 
 I was banned, however, not because I am a convicted criminal, I think &mdash; like the unfortunate Simon Hayward &mdash; but because I wanted to wear a false nose out of consideration for the feeling of my associate, Mark Chapman, who, as I explained last week, has just had an inch and a half lopped off his. 
 I have no idea what Sir Robert Mark is up to. 
 In America: The crack in the anti-drug facade 
 By KEITH BOTSFORD 
 This week, Jefferson Morley, the Washington editor of the Nation, wrote in the New Republic about his experience, one night, of smoking a couple of &dollar;25 rocks of crack, an experience he justified with the following words: &bquo;I wouldn't argue that you have to smoke crack to understand the war on drugs&hellip; (nor) that crack isn't hazardous or that anyone should try it. 
 Having been through the experience, though, may facilitate a certain realism about the conflict in question.&equo; 
 Realism? 
 In the same week in which President Bush appeared on national television brandishing &dollar;3,200 worth of cocaine (coercively obtained from a dealer who was dragged a block or two nearer the White House) to raise the air-time mileage he earns on drugs, it did not take long for outrage to be expressed. 
 Correspondence was mountainously adverse. 
 Anti- drugs tsar (suppressor of those latter-day boyars, the drug lords) William Bennett thundered before Congress that the New Republic's article was &bquo;not very helpful&equo;. 
 To say that &bquo;if all you have in life is bad choices, crack may not be the most unpleasant of them is irresponsible to an astonishing degree&equo;. 
 Nor was he alone. 
 On CNN's chat show, Morley was accused of peddling &bquo;garbage&equo;, of &bquo;disgraceful journalism&equo; and worse. 
 Morley's article was, in fact, largely descriptive. 
 It described the high that ensues from smoking crack ('Crack is both spacey and intense') and the downs that follow; it told his readers how he bought it and what the morning after was like. 
 One night trying it. 
 He lived to tell the tale. 
 Was Morley wrong to try the stuff? 
 Reporters have tried smack, they've spent voluntary weeks in jail or among lepers, on the same principle that Orwell worked in Paris as a plongeur. 
 It's called learning about life. 
 Where Morley offends the gangbusters is in saying that crack doesn't invariably kill or addict, and that, if what you need is a change of mind, it can be fun while it lasts. 
 As the New Republic succinctly put it, &bquo;Kids tempted by crack don't need the New Republic to tell them the drug isn't invariably fatal.&equo; 
 Unfortunately, Morley contradicted the government's message &mdash; a form of Nancy Reagan-like intellectual reductionism: just say no. 
 He highlighted a classic phrase by Peter Jennings, ABC's anchor-man wrinkle-brow: &bquo;Using it even once can make a person crave cocaine for as long as they (sic) live.&equo; 
 Yeah? 
 Do all pleasurable experiences produce life-long addiction? 
 A good Richebourg gives a better buzz than inferior plonk, but there are constraints to the pleasure principle: economic, moral, social, physical. 
 &bquo;Just say no&equo; doesn't say much, no more than it means much to say to a slave, &bquo;Enjoy your slavery&equo; or to the poor, &bquo;Shut up and accept your lot.&equo; 
 Alas, every lie told about drugs simply reinforces the potential crack-head's conviction that the government line is garbage. 
 Governments should educate, not lie; to lie is to diminish the efforts of propaganda that, based on truth, shows signs of succeeding. 
 Even in an era of Aids there is a difference between saying &bquo;There is no safe sex&equo; and saying that unsafe sex is a form of Russian roulette. 
 Ultimately only peers or experiment can effectively deny the wish to try a drug. 
 As with all drugs, even aspirin, it is generally abuse, not use, that kills. 
 It was what Morley's reportage implied that aroused such ire, especially the bit about bad choices, and crack perhaps not being the worst of them. 
 Morley's hypothesis obviously worried the anti-drug establishment. 
 &bquo;What if there were a drug,&equo; he asks, &bquo;that could induce feelings of upper middle-classness?&equo; 
 Such a drug, he suggests, would be not unlike crack, and the poor shmucks who weren't UMC would love it, while those who'd worked so hard for their privileges would despise the short-cut: you're either UMC or you aren't, simulacra won't do. 
 Death is a potent dissuader, to the promiscuous as to the drug abuser, but the least-educated and the most-deprived have less to live for. 
 In Morley's words, &bquo;The drug can make sick sense to demoralised people.&equo; 
 When we suffer unbearable pain, we too anaesthetise. 
 For us, that is all right; our pain is physical. 
 For them, crack is wrong, because the pain is generalised and life, not physical pain, is what they cannot face. 
 Enter the Puritan Ethic. 
 In much of this there is the deepest kind of hypocrisy. 
 The vast majority of us don't do crack. 
 We get our highs from other forms of self-gratification. 
 The poor get theirs in ways of which we disapprove: consider nineteenth-century attitudes to working-class drinking. 
 The New Republic controversy is about prohibition: of the use of drugs which, though extended to all, essentially affect only the few; and now an attempted prohibition of the very discussion of the issues involved. 
 Morley's &bquo;sin&equo; was to acknowledge the short-term attraction of crack and to seek to explain, from his own experience, how the drug might alleviate social alienation. 
 That latter fact is as true for drink and cigarettes as for any one of a dozen &bquo;mood-altering&equo; drugs. 
 In his zeal, Bennett and his allies are asserting that the pleasure is so obvious (otherwise people wouldn't use crack) that it should not be mentioned; and that crack is so dangerous its pleasures should be suppressed lest others follow Morley's example. 
 Thus is the reporter put in a classic double bind. 
 Hush, not in front of the cameras 
 By ANTHONY HOWARD 
 Almost the first political article I had published was one called &bquo;The Goldfish Bowl Mentality&equo;. 
 Written as a result of attending a Labour Party conference, it was the product of shock at what then seemed to me the amount of time and energy politicians and journalists spent chasing each other's tails on such occasions. 
 It was very much a brash young man's piece &mdash; I was 24 when I wrote it. 
 When I came across it the other day, I was slightly embarrassed. 
 The fact, though, that I discovered it not in any yellowing vanity book of my own but among the vast volumes of newspaper clippings maintained by Dick Crossman was marginally encouraging. 
 That meant, or so I like to flatter myself, that it must have struck some chord with at least one practising politician. 
 If it did, it was not perhaps all that surprising. 
 One of Crossman's cardinal convictions was that Britain was run not as a democracy but as an oligarchy &mdash; and that view of his was perhaps partially reflected in my own youthful outburst against the essentially incestuous relationship between politicians and journalists that I thought I had discovered even within the people's party. 
 Probably, in those days, I was a bit of an ideological innocent &mdash; shamingly, I even singled out for praise the ostentatiously populist action of one member of the national executive. 
 Her name was Bessie Braddock and she had publicly refused that year to stay in the headquarters hotel, insisting on going to a boarding house instead. 
 Yet the central thrust of what I was trying to say still strikes me as having some validity. 
 There is a sense in which there is a secret, collusive relationship between politics and the media which the outside world rarely glimpses. 
 Curiously, I have become even more strongly persuaded of that since I began dabbling in the making of political television programmes. 
 Here the degree of complicity is, and perhaps has to be, far higher than the viewer ever suspects. 
 The best analogy is probably with the methods of the legal profession. 
 In the preparations for any civil trial, potential witnesses give written statements to solicitors of one side or the other beginning with that revealing phrase &bquo;I, so-and-so of such-and-such an address, will say&hellip;&equo; 
 Much the same procedure, shorn of its formality (and often of its reliability, too) is followed in the early stages of making a political programme for the box. 
 There is nothing wrong with that &mdash; in fact, without such precautions it would be hard to get a coherent programme together at all. 
 But the end result still runs the risk of leaving the viewer with a totally false impression. 
 Part of the trick of a successful television documentary is to make each comment delivered within it sound spontaneous: they are rarely anything of the sort. 
 The likelihood, indeed, is that they would have been repeated and rehearsed many times ('now that's a very good point you're making there &mdash; I wonder if you could conceivably contrive to put it a little more precisely'). 
 I am not seeking to suggest that there is anything sinister about such a process. 
 But it is surely silly to deny that it has thrown politicians and television journalists together in an association that remains totally invisible to the public. 
 In fact, thanks largely to Sir Robin Day &mdash; &bquo;the Grand Inquisitor&equo;, as he calls himself in the title of his new book &mdash; the impression that the average viewer probably has of politics on television is that it is predominantly adversarial. 
 That may still be true of the set-piece studio interview &mdash; though even there the prior indication of &bquo;lines of questioning&equo; is by no means unknown (and the viewer would probably be astonished at the general closeness of the atmosphere that prevails in the green room afterwards). 
 Of course, television is a performing trade &mdash; and the very element of show business involved for both the interrogator and the victim was bound to have its effect on what Lord Beaverbrook used to proclaim as &bquo;the armed frontier&equo; between politics and journalism. 
 Like a lot of Lord Beaverbrook's phrases, that was probably more colourful than accurate &mdash; but if such a frontier ever existed then the imperatives of current affairs television have certainly modified and adjusted it. 
 The layman's reaction is probably &bquo;and a good thing, too&equo;. 
 Who, after all, is in favour of conflict for its own sake? 
 But the dilemma, at least for the television journalist, is not quite as simple as that. 
 The one position he or she should avoid is of being a kind of co-conspirator with the politician against the legitimate interests of the audience and that, it has seemed to me lately, is an increasingly easy trap to fall into. 
 Perhaps I should explain. 
 For more weeks than I care to remember I have been working on a Panorama programme designed to look at the future of the Tory Party, even beyond Thatcherism. 
 The experience has taught me a lot, not least about Margaret Thatcher's single achievement in changing the class contours of British politics. 
 But another lesson I have learnt has been a good deal more unsettling. 
 In ridding the Tory Party of its old aristocratic embrace, the Prime Minister has entirely failed &mdash; or perhaps has not even tried &mdash; to banish oligarchic mores that went with its former upper-crust outlook. 
 Time and again the Conservative politicians we approached would talk in private frankly and openly about the problems they foresaw for their party. 
 Wire them up with microphones and start the camera rolling, however, and all candour vanished. 
 We were immediately back into the ambience of the nursery where, if anything even vaguely indiscreet was in danger of being said, it would instantly be muffled by the warning whisper: &bquo;Hush, not in front of the children&equo;. 
 No doubt I shall be briskly told that there is nothing new about that &mdash; and, of course, there is not. 
 Generations of lobby journalists at Westminster have had to tussle with the challenge of reconciling the remarks Tory politicians are prepared to make off the record with the ringing declarations of total loyalty and conformity they deliver in public. 
 (The Labour Party, to be fair, has never observed quite the same double standards when it comes to private and public speech). 
 The difference, and the difficulty, for the television reporter is that he inevitably becomes a partner in this process of suppression. 
 Any television documentary is entirely dependent on what its participants are prepared to say on camera &mdash; the winks and nudges of written journalism can have very little place in it. 
 In that sense, if in no other, I have felt these past weeks rather like a dentist. 
 Getting a Tory to say what he believes &mdash; and, to make it worse, what he knows you know he believes &mdash; is about as daunting as drawing teeth. 
 Perhaps the only mistake I made all those years ago was not realising what an anti-democratic medium television would prove to be. 
 Letter: Conservative economic record 
 From Professor MEGHNAD DESAI 
 Sir: As the Conservative Party gathers for its annual conference, it would be appropriate to ask the question which must be on everyone's mind. 
 Can we trust them with the nation's economy? 
 Since the war, each time the Conservative Party has come into power it has extolled the virtues of the market. 
 The specific policies and rhetoric have been different as the occasion demanded. 
 It has had three chances to cure the structural problems of the UK &mdash; abolition of rationing and freeing the interest mechanism from the Dalton experience in the 1950s, the Selsden Man competition and credit control in the 1970s, and the deregulation and monetarism of the 1980s. 
 There has been a promise that prosperity will be permanent. 
 In the course of these policies, one or the other restrictive practice has been singled out as the root cause of our ills &mdash; resale price maintenance, clearing banks' cartel, trade unions &mdash; the cry has been for their removal. 
 The result has been the same each time. 
 After a boom, inflation has gone up and there has been a disastrous showing on the balance of payments. 
 Maudling, Barber and now Lawson &mdash; the consistency of the disastrous outcome is hard to equal. 
 The only difference is that in the 1950s and the 1980s the Conservatives had more than 10 years to cure the ills of the economy while in the 1970s they had but four. 
 The structural problems of the economy remain &mdash; inadequate saving, uncompetitive industry and insufficient investment in human capital. 
 After all the boasts of supply-side miracles under one slogan or another from 1951 to 1989, the British economy remains sick. 
 The size of the trade deficit towards the end of each episode of Conservative government is a sure sign of this. 
 The issue is a simple one of economic competence. 
 The evidence is one of gross lack of it. 
 Letter: Mugabe over-reacting to student &bquo;threat&equo; 
 From Mrs DORIS LESSING 
 Sir: I have just returned from five weeks in Zimbabwe, mostly at village level, and your leading article (6 October) was right. 
 Mugabe is over-reacting to the &bquo;threat&equo; of the students' rebellion as the symptom of great disunity. 
 I did not once hear Zanu (PF) mentioned outside Harare. 
 People seem to take the party for granted, as they now do the unity accord, which they were talking gratefully about in November last. 
 What they discussed is policies and personalities &mdash; is he, is she, a good administrator, a good person. 
 No one said a word about Edgar Tekere until I asked. 
 The replies were versions of, &bquo;He is a brave man for talking out about corruption, but he is too unstable to make a leader,&equo; and &bquo;We village people are all stupid, we know that, but we don't want another war.&equo; 
 These are shrewd, calm, humorous, balanced people and Mugabe is luckier than he seems to know. 
 It is generally agreed that he has mishandled the students, who have been threatened, bullied, fired on with tear-gas grenades; and now the university is closed which means that these cynical and angry students are all over the country spreading disillusion. 
 Mugabe exhorts them to remember the sacrifices made in the war for the sake of Zimbabwe, but young people are seldom interested in a previous generation's sacrifices &mdash; as he could have learned from history. 
 People say: &bquo;Students are by definition idealistic and impatient &mdash; would Mugabe really want them to be any different? 
 He should have talked to them as reasonable people, not shouted at them.&equo; 
 Letter: European security and a reunited Germany 
 From Mr DAVID HABAKKUK 
 Sir: One may or may not share Christopher Hill's apprehensions about the destabilising potential of German reunification (letter, 4 October). 
 But can we be so confident that it can be stopped? 
 The &bquo;half-way house&equo; of a reformed GDR is very attractive. 
 But the initial effect of economic reforms there could very well be, as in the USSR, to worsen economic conditions, and thus to make more people want to leave. 
 Could a reforming East Berlin government then maintain a shoot-to-kill policy on the Wall? 
 Or are we expecting Bonn to recognise East German citizenship? 
 If East Germans have the freedom to choose, can we really be confident that they would prefer to face the difficulties of establishing a capitalist economy and democratic system on their own? 
 Might they not think it more sensible to throw in their lot with their fellow Germans west of the Elbe, who know as much about running a liberal capitalist society as anybody, and have abundant reserves of capital, not to speak of generous welfare benefits? 
 Today a main thrust of Moscow's security policy is to eliminate the possibility of crises escalating; pressing economic priorities push it towards cutting defence spending and integrating with the world economy. 
 Military intervention in Germany would be a disaster for the Russians, so it is no longer clear that the threat of this will continue to be a bar to German self-determination. 
 If we make ourselves the bar, if we suggest that self-determination is the right of every people on earth but the Germans, we risk creating resentments in Germany which could be quite as destabilising to the European order as reunification. 
 We cannot take it for granted any longer that the division of Germany is sustainable; in consequence, the whole European security order may be unstable. 
 Taking into account that over the past year changes in Europe have proceeded vastly faster than almost everyone predicted, it is imperative that we start thinking now about what a new &bquo;European security order&equo;, without vast Soviet and American armies on German soil, might look like. 
 Letter: Urban housing 
 From Councillor SIMON RANDALL 
 Sir: Chris Patten's new draft guidance on planning for housing and his rejection of a new town in Hampshire are both very encouraging. 
 The Government is rightly giving more responsibility to local authorities for planning and decision making, while still providing the necessary framework. 
 The London Boroughs Association firmly believes that much more housing is needed, but that it must be provided in the right locations. 
 With increasing concern for the environment, the need to recycle urban land becomes even stronger. 
 London expects to provide 31 per cent of the additional dwellings needed in the South-east between 1991 and 2001. 
 Mr Patten's decision and guidance are a clear boost to planning, local government decision making, and the environment. 
 Letter: Doctored fees 
 From Dr HAROLD EDWARDS 
 Sir: The doctor's plate offering two grades of medical advice (letter, 4 October) goes back to the end of the nineteenth century. 
 In 1933, I saw a notice in a doctor's shop window stating &bquo;Examinations one shilling and sixpence; with stethoscope two shillings&equo;. 
 Letter: Dialect and poverty 
 From Mr DAVID KNIGHT 
 Sir: I must take issue with Janet Daley's article on a supposed connection between poverty and language (4 October). 
 She suggests that the offending Geordie dialect &bquo;might equally well have been Liverpool or Sheffield&equo; - could it not also have been from Norfolk, Suffolk or Dorset? 
 Throughout Britain there is a wide range of rich and varied dialects which enhance our cultural diversity. 
 She holds up the American education system as an answer to the supposed link between language and class mobility. 
 Anyone who has heard the dialect of the Bronx, New Orleans or Albuquerque will be able to affirm the failure of those techniques. 
 We should not aim at levels of US poverty as goals for our society. 
 I am saddened that the article uses the spurious connection between dialect and poverty as a means of attacking English teaching in this country. 
 Those of us who have worked within the education system, in social priority areas, since the Sixties, can assure Janet Daley that these children have not been abandoned to a type of educational apartheid. 
 It is views such as those expressed in the article which are the foundations of all forms of apartheid. 
 Letter: Schools evidence 
 From Mr CLYDE CHITTY 
 Sir: Where is the evidence for Terry Coleman's vicious and stupid remark (5 October) that one of the results of the Labour Party's abolition of the grammar schools is the presence of &bquo;incoherently illiterate&equo; younger delegates at this year's Brighton Labour Party conference? 
 Apart from any other considerations, it was, in fact, during Margaret Thatcher's period as Education Secretary (1970-74) that more schools became comprehensive than at any other time either before or since. 
 It really is about time that journalists stopped mouthing the myths of modern-day Thatcherism. 
 There are many reasons why, sadly, too many of our youngsters still leave school without the skills of literacy and numeracy, but comprehensive reorganisation is not one of them. 
 Free Speech 3: No cause for panic over risks on site 
 By JOHN RIMINGTON 
 Director General since 1984 of the government-funded Health &amp; Safety Executive responsible for industrial safety and inspectorates. 
 Nobody with the job of managing the nation's principal safety agency could be complacent. 
 As industrial processes become more complex, the energy applied to them greater, substances and compounds more subtle and control processes more remote, the potential for serious accidents increases. 
 So does the vulnerability of people at work, or moving through the transport networks, or living near large industrial plants. 
 But are we becoming too worried? 
 Does the recent rash of serious accidents affecting people jammed together in small spaces mean that Britain has become the glass jaw, as well as, allegedly, the dirty man of Europe? 
 Let us put the record into perspective. 
 Every year in Britain about 5,000 people die on the roads. 
 About the same number are killed at home. 
 More than 600 people are murdered. 
 Rather fewer are killed at work, a low figure by international comparisons, though the number of those whose lives are abridged by industrially contracted ill-health is not known or included. 
 Yet the applied energy, constant movement of people, heavy loads and handling of what are sometimes the most dangerous substances imaginable make many industrial environments intrinsically dangerous. 
 A reasonable question might be, why is the safety record so comparatively good? 
 Do not mistake me. 
 The general record on accidents at work deteriorated between 1981 and 1986; the improvement since then is not enough. 
 No one could think that improvement is not necessary to safety, especially in quarrying, construction, diving or works transport. 
 But things could be a great deal worse. 
 What has happened in the past half century, apart from the advance of technology, has been the erection of a firm framework of regulation, the appearance of specific safety technologies, such as industrial hygiene, and the advance of the idea that safety can and must be managed. 
 About 800 plants are scheduled in the UK as presenting serious hazards. 
 There are more than 40 nuclear reactors and 22,000km of gas pipeline passing through built-up areas. 
 The Siberian pipeline disaster, Chernobyl and Bhopal illustrate the potential risks. 
 But the continuous scrutiny demanded and enforced by regulation of the high-risk cases and (for nuclear reactors) the designs of these installations are considerable forces on the side of safety. 
 One day there will be a serious industrial accident; there are occasional near misses and worse; but it usually takes a good measure of folly, inattention and misfortune to overwhelm good plant and a safe system. 
 Relatively few members of the public have been killed in Britain by industrial accidents in recent years. 
 People expect risks they did not ask for and cannot control to be much lower -by 10 or 100 times &mdash; than those which they run willingly. 
 People may smoke, drive at 80 miles an hour through fog on a motorway, go in for hang-gliding or rock climbing at the weekends. 
 Yet they see nothing inconsistent with objecting to a well-engineered nuclear waste disposal plant which is clearly necessary to dispose safely of irradiated material already created; or to properly regulated high-combustion chemical waste disposal plants that are the only alternative (unless we get rid of the chemical industry) to toxic wastes being dumped surreptitiously in some field or on some beach. 
 In a democracy we are entitled to choose not to die for someone else's benefit or profit. 
 The high general standards applied to industrial safety affect expectations. 
 But we do need to remember the great cost of exercising our right to have double standards and also to ask ourselves whether expenditure to make us extremely safe from one form of risk may not sometimes make us more vulnerable to others. 
 After the Midlands air crash, I asked Eddy Ryder, the Chief Nuclear Inspector, what safety lessons he drew. 
 He said: &bquo;If it had been us, we'd have demanded 10 engines.&equo; 
 After a pause for calculation, he added: &bquo;And then I'd have tethered it to the ground.&equo; 
 In fact, we know that if we get into a confined space with the intention of defying gravity we are running a risk and have decided to tolerate it. 
 In short our national standards are high and we can largely choose what they should be. 
 But it takes resolute, technologically aware safety management and regulation to maintain them. 
 Where people are crowded together, particularly when public order is in question; where hazardous materials are being moved; where traditional industrial disciplines and organisation are breaking down, as in parts of the construction industry, there is real reason for anxiety. 
 In serious hazard regulation, too, the stakes are high and the so-called &bquo;human factor&equo; in accident causation is an issue. 
 But there is no kind of crisis going on, except perhaps in the environmental or ecological area and in our own minds when we try to secure for ourselves what we cannot have: namely a zero risk. 
 Free Speech 2: Safety sacrificed at the altar of profit 
 By JAMES TYE 
 Director-General of the British Safety Council since 1968 and author of several books on safety, he is a leading authority on accident prevention. 
 During the last 23 years I have looked at thousands of so-called accidents in many countries. 
 I cannot remember a single one where the risks which gave rise to the accident could not have been measured and prevented with effective safety training, management commitment and &mdash; above all - sufficient funds. 
 It saddens me that, while most annual reports say &bquo;&hellip; we will do our utmost to preserve our most important asset: the skills contained in our workforce&equo;, when I visit the workplace I see the tell-tale signs of accidents in the making &mdash; blocked exits, unguarded machines, untrained work people. 
 Go to any firm and ask to see their written safety policy &mdash; legally required under Section 2 (3) of the Health and Safety at Work Act 1974 &mdash; and those without a single word on paper will make their excuses (and this includes nearly every UK Football Club). 
 This year, in its Plan of Work for 1989-90 and Beyond, the Government's Health and Safety Commission identified management failure as the main cause of accidents at work. 
 It was four years since the last Plan of Work was published &mdash; an indication, surely, of how low on the Government's list of priorities is the place of safety at work. 
 The &bquo;enterprise culture&equo;, the opening up of markets and the need to survive competition all place businesses under great pressure. 
 The scale and pace of technological change mean that the public as well as employees are crucially at risk. 
 It is of course the string of public transport disasters that has brought such a widespread public reaction &mdash; six in three years, with 193 lives lost on Herald of Free Enterprise at Zeebrugge; 31 deaths in the Kings Cross Underground fire; 35 deaths at the Clapham rail crash; 270 lost in the Lockerbie bomb blast; 47 claimed in the M1 air crash and most recently, 51 in the River Thames from the Marchioness. 
 When the chairman of the inquiry into the King's Cross Underground fire made his report he was strongly critical of London Underground's management (the two top men quit hours before the report was published): &bquo;An inward looking approach fostered by the organisation's narrow horizons undoubtedly led to a dangerous, blinkered self-sufficiency which included a general unwillingness to take advice or accept criticism from outside bodies.&equo; 
 In short, safety warnings were ignored and cutting costs came first. 
 The disaster at sea which took the lives of 165 oilmen is still the subject of inquiry. 
 However, the Interim Technical Report on the Piper Alpha explosion, published last October, raised the strong possibility that the incoming shift were unaware that a vital valve had been removed. 
 Why are safety standards in the UK inadequate? 
 Because it is the manufacturers who make the standards, with little or no input from the users or consumers. 
 This means that only the 20,000 readers of British Standards Institution publications hear about them: so much for public comment. 
 Remember &mdash; profit before safety. 
 It was only my individual objection which stopped an unsatisfactory standard for smoke masks being introduced 10 years ago. 
 Now a perfectly good internal sprinkler system has been developed which for &pound;500,000 could be fitted to an aircraft and would put fires out within 10 seconds. 
 It is not being fitted because of the cost: but in the meantime talks about the &pound;25 smoke mask are proceeding. 
 Any debate on the conflict between safety and cost cannot overlook the Government's unwillingness to provide adequate funds for its health and safety at work agencies. 
 The fight put up by the Health and Safety Commission to get more money saw niggardly extra funding at the end of the last year. 
 According to the commission chief: &bquo;We have always said very forcefully that more inspectors will be the prime claim.&equo; 
 The inspectors, through their union, say they are underfunded and understaffed (to which I would add the problem of incredibly low morale). 
 Regrettably, too many inadequately trained, ignorant and uncaring managers in too many workplaces believe they can beat the cost of unsafe practices and systems and take a chance on the consequences. 
 With a visit from a Government safety inspector likely only once in five years, the safety/cost conflict is all too easily settled by sacrificing safety to the god of profit. 
 Criminally negligent directors in the UK are not sent to prison as in other countries &mdash; the worst that can happen is a fine &mdash; and even that can be insured against and paid by the company. 
 As long as health and safety at work is seen as an optional extra more so-called &bquo;Acts of God&equo; are in the making, and more workers and members of the public will pay the price. 
 Is safety being sacrificed for profit? 
 Of course it is &mdash; at work, on the road, in the air, at recreation, in the home. 
 In the UK in the year to come, Joe Public will continue to pay the price (perhaps with his life) until he is a better citizen and stands up and protests enough about it. 
 Free Speech 1: Danger: men at work: This week: Are Britain's safety standards good enough? 
 By ANGELA LAMBERT 
 WE ALL have a schizophrenic attitude towards safety. 
 On the one hand we know that drinking, smoking, driving and overwork involve risks to our health, and we apparently accept them. 
 Yet we expect the much smaller risks incurred when travelling by train or air or sea to be non-existent, and express outrage and condemnation when accidents happen, Angela Lambert writes. 
 It is largely a matter of cost. 
 We could all fly to Paris in perfect safety if we were prepared to pay &pound;1,000 for a ticket, since we would then travel with the same cast-iron safety precautions as do heads of state. 
 But in paying fares amounting to a tenth of that, we incur &mdash; and do implicitly accept &mdash; a low level of risk. 
 The recent series of disasters from The Herald of Free Enterprise onwards, has led us to believe that Britain is particularly unsafe. 
 Certainly our industrial safety inspectorate is nowhere near large enough, and there are blackspots &mdash; such as construction &mdash; where the casualty rate is far too high. 
 Nevertheless, as the table shows, we rank among the safest countries in the world. 
 Food: The test of a true boar: British gourmets could soon go the whole hog, writes Henrietta Green 
 By HENRIETTA GREEN 
 WILD BOAR once roamed the fields and forests of Britain. 
 They were the sport of rich noblemen who hunted and ate them with terrific enthusiasm &mdash; until there were none. 
 Now there are plans afoot to reintroduce them to Britain on a grand scale for the &bquo;gourmet&equo; market. 
 Not as wild boar running free and doing untold damage to the countryside, as in Italy, France and Germany; but as farmed wild boar which should ease your mind, even if it causes the farmers untold headaches. 
 Thus it was, last Friday, that the inaugural meeting of the British Wild Boar Association took place. 
 It was held, appropriately, on the first day of Michaelmas when, in medieval times, pigs were traditionally turned out into the woods to fatten up on acorns. 
 It got off to a hairy start with several heated discussions about what a wild boar is. 
 Does &bquo;wild&equo; mean how it is kept? 
 Can it be farmed intensively or should it only be reared extensively? 
 Does the name cover only pure-bred wild boars or can it include a cross, bred with a domestic pig? 
 If crosses are to be allowed, what percentage of cross is acceptable? 
 And just because it looks like a wild boar with the striped marking or &bquo;agouti&equo; (long snout, straight tail and small pointy ears), can it be accepted as such without a genetic test? 
 Pretty technical stuff this, with enough contentious issues to make every boar farmer's hair curl. 
 As Robert Spencer Bernard, barrister and part-time farmer of wild boar for several years on his Buckinghamshire estate, said: &bquo;A tiger is a tiger whether you see it in the London Zoo or in the Indian forests, but with a wild boar the argument isn't so simple.&equo; 
 We had been herded together to discuss this and other issues by Dr Derek Booth, animal geneticist and scientist. 
 Easily recognised by his boar's head tie, his enthusiasm and appetite was first whetted when he met the &bquo;iron-age&equo; pig several years ago. 
 A cross between a wild boar and Tamworth pig, it was bred for a BBC TV series in an attempt to recreate animals from that era. 
 Dr Booth was admittedly &bquo;horrified by the amount of fat it carried&equo; and it was not until he saw wild boar in a wild life park in France that he realised the opportunities. 
 Clearly Sam Weller had also seen the light. 
 A self-proclaimed poineer and the &bquo;first man to go the whole hog&equo; with his business, the Wild Boar Company, he was all for setting the strictest standards of breeds, offering a product aimed at the &bquo;luxury end&equo; of the market. 
 &bquo;Cross breeds do produce some excellent pork, but it's not wild boar and it shouldn't be sold as such.&equo; 
 He believes that even when farmed, wild boar must be genetically pure and reared in conditions which approximate the wild as closely as possible. 
 An animal's environment, the food it eats, the rigours of its existence and its genetic make-up may all affect the taste and texture of its flesh. 
 &bquo;But what we don't know,&equo; Sam Weller told me, &bquo;is the relevant importance of those factors&equo;. 
 Research was then produced by Jeff Woods from the Institute of Food Research which backed up part of Sam Weller's argument. 
 A cross-bred boar was reared and fed indoors in a pen, under identical conditions to a domestic pig, and the meats from the two carcasses tasted exactly the same. 
 Clearly environment and diet do determine the taste. 
 When kept outside and left to roam, eating a varied diet and developing plenty of muscle, boars will taste different from the domestic pig. 
 But what no one seemed prepared or able to tell was to what extent the purity of breed influences the taste of boar. 
 As one cynical farmer whispered knowingly, &bquo;If they're not careful, they'll price themselves right out of the market with their boring pure-bred boars. 
 That'll leave it wide open for the supermarket boys to market a &bquo;free-range acorn-fed pork&equo; &mdash; an intensively bred pig, fattened up in woods in half the time and costing well under an eighth of the price.&equo; 
 Not a bad idea, but if the British Wild Boar Association, already bristling with problems, is to combat that threat it must sort out its standards. 
 If you do manage to buy wild boar, I suggest you try making hamburgers. 
 This recipe is adapted from Patricia Lousada's satisfying Game Cookery (John Murray, &pound;15.95). 
 It reminds me of eating wild boar in Tuscany where fennel seed is traditionally added to give an edge to the flavour. 
 Wild Boar Hamburgers Ingredients: 450g (1lb) lean boar meat from shoulder or loin 50g (2oz) fresh boar or pork back fat 3tbs breadcrumbs 2tbs fresh cream 2tbs fennel seed 1 &frac12; tsp fine sea salt Freshly ground black pepper Small pinch ground cloves and nutmeg Preparation: Mince the meat and fat and mix in the remaining ingredients, or mix all the ingredients together in a food processor. 
 Shape the mixture into smallish hamburgers in the palm of your hands and, turning them once, grill them for about 5-7 minutes depending on how rare you like the meat. 
 Recipe: Filling formulas for filo 
 By LINDA SUE PARK 
 READER submissions for filo pastry recipes were a trickle rather than a torrent. 
 Postmarks were for the most part no further north than the Midlands. 
 But filo pastry is available in the North, because this week's winning recipe comes from Newcastle upon Tyne. 
 The quality of the recipes was such that it was difficult to choose which to publish. 
 Several readers like the combination of filo and fish or seafood &mdash; prawns, salmon, trout. 
 P Taylor from Chester recommends a filling of courgettes and pine nuts from the excellent Greens Cook Book (Bantam, &pound;12.95). 
 Frances Craig from Middlesex sends a formula for a classic apple strudel, learnt when she was a washer-up in a German Gasthof. 
 But the winning recipe is for the filo fruit baskets, below, sent in by Margaret Crisell from Newcastle which wins her a bottle of 1987 Torres Milmanda wine from Pendes, Spain. 
 Savoury filo recipes next week; then we want the best recipe for game-bird stuffings. 
 Breadcrumb recipes are welcome but why not stretch to bulgur, rice, millet? 
 The prize is a bottle of Matusalem Oloroso sherry. 
 Send your suggestions, with source if not original, to Recipe/Weekend Section, The Independent, 40 City Road, London EC1Y 2DB. 
 Filo Fruit Baskets serves 4 Ingredients: filo pastry, cut into 5in squares 2oz butter, melted &frac14; pint double cream, whipped 2tbs Greek yoghurt &frac14; tsp ground ginger 2-4 pieces crystallised ginger, finely chopped 1tbs soft brown sugar Seasonal fruits, cut into small dice Preparation: Butter the outsides of four upturned ramekins. 
 Drape four or five squares of filo, each in a slightly different position, over each ramekin, brushing layers with melted butter. 
 Bake at 180C/ 350F/gas 4 for 20 minutes, until crisp and golden. 
 Cool, remove pastry and turn right side up. 
 Immediately before serving, fill with fruit and top with cream mixed with yoghurt and the gingers. 
 Food: Ping, unload, zap and refuel 
 By KEITH BOTSFORD 
 SOME 18 months ago I wrote about my own incompetence with and dislike for the microwave oven. 
 Now I have found out why. 
 My ideas about food are definitely passe. 
 A recent survey in the Wall Street Journal, America's only readable paper, has shown that the microwave is the nation's favourite household appliance, second only to the smoke alarm in terms of its importance to the American lifestyle. 
 The microwave, says the Journal, is &bquo;the embodiment of Eighties-style individualism, turning each family member into a chef. 
 Gone is the sanctity of the family meal. 
 Irretrievably altered is the role of Mom, the nurturer&equo;. 
 The present pattern is an ultra-sound bite, one for each member of the family, or a six-pack for guests if such people still exist. 
 Kids in shorts can stick My Own Meal, Kids Kitchen and Kid Cuisine (all from Campbells) in the little box, turn the knob, wait briefly, unload, zap down their food and get back to the major business of life, the latest video. 
 The loveliest remarks on this phenomenon come from the corporate convenience food conveyancers. 
 Consider Joel Weiner, a senior vice-president in the Kraft division (you know it, it makes the world's worst cheese) of Philip Morris. 
 Weiner says that in the Eighties we've gone past the &bquo;grazing&equo; stage, in which we picked at this and that all day long, to &bquo;refuelling&equo;: the pit-stop in which we shovel food in our mouths as fast as we can. 
 If speed is of the essence &mdash; and all marketing surveys say it is &mdash; then the microwave is the manufacturers' version of the licence to print money. 
 Time is money and, after money, time is what the masses crave most. 
 Ergo, the manufacturers no longer dare market food that takes more than 10 minutes to prepare. 
 In my own lifetime, the changes have accelerated. 
 I grew up in a house where the smells of preparation and cooking began, below stairs, not long after I rose. 
 In my youth the time required to prepare a meal, even a simple one, was usually two hours. 
 By the Seventies this had been cut down, thanks to the pressure cooker, hotter ovens and the first electric gadgets, to an hour. 
 Ten years ago, surveys showed people were willing to put in a half-hour in the kitchen. 
 It's 10 minutes today: less than a cat puts in on a bird. 
 Nor is it just time that is in question. 
 Convenience means just that. 
 Many people today are too lazy even to open a tin. 
 Tomorrow's meal, like an astronaut's dinner, comes in a plastic bag. 
 But that is not all. 
 Mona Doyle, president of Consumer Network Inc in Philadelphia which studies our food habits, has a philosophical point of some interest. 
 She thinks the microwave &bquo;has changed our perceptions of time, much as telephones changed them at the turn of the century&equo;. 
 Her proof is in the restaurant trade: &bquo;Even fast food restaurants (do) not seem fast, because at home you don't have to wait in line.&equo; 
 You know how it is with these developments. 
 We get genetically (and culinarily) imprinted with them. 
 You used to walk to the store; now you ride. 
 You used to shop daily, now it's weekly. 
 Fresh has become frozen. 
 Kitchen travail was for reward; now you get gratification without labour. 
 Roles were defined: mother in the kitchen, father owlishly awaiting his dinner, kids scrubbing their hands. 
 Now there is to be the universal democracy of the microwave. 
 Father wants tandoori duck, mother something green, the kids go for nachos except for studious Cecil, who wants Raymond Blanc in a package. 
 The schedule advances only on when the microwave is free. 
 Conversation at table is as superfluous as a sermon in church; all is still but for the ping of the latest microwave masterpiece. 
 Campbells' Richard Nelson has it right. 
 Today's kids &bquo;are being imprinted with the microwave, not the stove&equo;. 
 The hearth as metaphor is dead. 
 But the Journal also comes up with some curious contradictions: 36 per cent blame the microwave for poorer flavour, 20 per cent think it makes food soggy. 
 The Journal's final lament is to the grilled cheese sandwich or the croque monsieur. 
 Once a golden brown staple, crisp on the outside and creamy within, it has gone the way of all flesh. 
 But in this rather frightening vision of the present and future, so have all the things I learnt to care about in eating: flavour, texture, invention, subtlety, companionship &mdash; and leisure, which marks the end of the working day and the use of time, not its gobbling. 
 Food: Sad decline of a fishy business: Customers are deserting Billingsgate market to buy direct from the ports, says Deirdre McQuillan 
 By DEIRDRE MCQUILLAN 
 I do like to be able to pick a fish up by its head,&equo; William Black said, waving a sea bass in rigor mortis at me, before going on to inspect its gills. 
 He makes a bleary-eyed and disorientating living between Rungis, the wholesale fish market on the south side of Paris, and London, where he supplies fish to restaurants such as Tante Claire, Alistair Little and Suntory. 
 His is just one example of the new enterprises supplying fish to shops or restaurants that cut out Billingsgate market; for they also cut out the 25 per cent or so that trading through the market adds to the cost of fish. 
 Independent fishmongers often buy directly from the ports using Billingsgate, the central wholesale market for shops and restaurants across the whole of southern England, as a back-up. 
 &bquo;If they don't get their finger out, they will lose almost all their business to the direct trade,&equo; is Jim Moran's succinct analysis of the market's future. 
 From a family of fish merchants, he has served on Billingsgate committees and all but despairs of &bquo;them ever getting on with the real business of selling fish&equo;. 
 He estimates that the market handles only 50 per cent of the trade in fresh fish in southern England. 
 Mr Moran added to that decline when his Billingsgate-based merchant business, R W Larkin, opened a swanky new fishmonger in London's King's Road to which fish is delivered from port agents around Britain, and also from Boulogne. 
 &bquo;As wholesalers we felt that Billingsgate was not offering us the facilities we needed,&equo; he explains. 
 &bquo;We still trade from there, but in order to thrive we have had to look at better ways of selling.&equo; 
 The shop has two aims. 
 One is to see if adventurous buying, lavish displays and good service (which includes opening until 7pm and for a half-day on Sunday) will galvanise the public. 
 The other is to provide a more convenient location for restaurant customers. 
 &bquo;Chefs don't want to get up at six in the morning to go to Docklands,&equo; Mr Moran says. 
 Although it seems that the South is recovering its appetite for fresh fish, with restaurants buying about 30 per cent of the fish sold in the area, there is no doubt that there has been a positive nosedive in the demand for fresh fish in Britain as whole. 
 Sales have fallen by as much as 60 per cent in the last 40 years. 
 As a result, fishmongers have disappeared: their numbers dropped from 9,000 in 1971 to 3,000 in 1981. 
 A recent report on fish retailing, compiled by the market research company Keynote, records the number of wet fish shops in the south of England having declined by 60 per cent in 27 years. 
 Since the days when oysters were as everyday a dish as hamburgers are now, we have reached a point where each person eats only an average of 1.2oz of fresh fish a week. 
 Billingsgate has presided over this decline with all the grace of an oligarchy that sees its power declining. 
 It has stuck to an antiquated way of operating that harks back to the days of guild power, and has refused to countenance criticism. 
 Transport arrangements within the market are strictly regulated. 
 Porters must be hired to move any amount of fish, however small, and minders paid to look after customers' trucks. 
 No prices are written down and there is no competitive bidding. 
 All a buyer gets to see are the sample boxes opened on the trading floor, on the strength of which he negotiates with the merchant. 
 This is how markets operate the world over, but distrust of Billingsgate's dealing seems to be a problem. 
 Nicholas Roe, a writer who used to be a fishmonger, says: &bquo;I seemed to spend more time sending fish back than selling it. 
 I had to move further and further back down the line to the boats.&equo; 
 Horror stories abound: of the rogue's law that prevented any port agent who sold directly to fishmongers from ever trading with a Billingsgate merchant again; of the nepotism that determined who could have a stand in the market; and of prices that varied according to who you were and whether you had a good introduction. 
 These stories are commonplace, although those involved are wary of going on record. 
 On trips organised for food writers, public perfidy is a popular lament. 
 The shopper, so the refrain goes, doesn't know how to cook fresh fish, can't cope with bones, won't pay a fair price and will only be persuaded to buy the traditional species. 
 The traditional fishmonger wasn't up to much either, apparently, selling the same varieties of fish to the same ageing customers. 
 Now it is the turn of Billingsgate to feel anxious, although according to Lou Hart, chairman of the London Fish Merchants' Association, Billingsgate has nothing to fear: &bquo;We offer an unrivalled service. 
 No one else has the range of fish. 
 &bquo;The porterage system is antiquated but it works efficiently. 
 If we could think of a better system we would introduce it. 
 &bquo;Customers are coming back to Billingsgate because they know what they are getting. 
 Problems with short weights are being tackled and if fish has been on the market overnight, the person buying it is aware. 
 &bquo;Contrary to what people think, we are well prepared for 1992. 
 We are going to be ahead of any market in Europe.&equo; 
 Traipsing around after William Black through the cold, wet trading floors of Rungis, however, it was immediately apparent that the size of the Paris operation and the variety of fish dwarfed London. 
 Refrigerated juggernauts from all over Europe wait outside the doors. 
 He explained that on the Continent it is taken for granted that fish caught on a line by small boats should command a premium for the careful handling that preserves both flavour and texture. 
 &bquo;British fishermen are beginning to use lines rather than nets, but they are selling to the Continent because they'd be daft not to. 
 &bquo;It must sometimes be the case that I bring British fish back to London, but it will probably be in better condition than if it had been bought there as foreign agents insist on good transport and packing.&equo; 
 We stopped at one of his regular suppliers and cadged a few sea urchins, then the knife to eat them with. 
 &bquo;Fish is such wonderful stuff, so perishable and so delicate,&equo; enthuses Mr Black, waving at the glorious display of shellfish all around us. 
 &bquo;It is not treated by the trade in Britain with anything like the respect it is given in France. 
 &bquo;In the fish business, 1992 has already arrived. 
 There is one market across Europe and the prices the Germans and Italians will pay are even surprising the French. 
 They will pay whatever it takes to get Scots crayfish and Dublin Bay prawns into the shops and restaurants in beautiful condition, when no one back home can be bothered. 
 That is why I prefer to work from here.&equo; 
 As an example, he opened a case of red mullet &mdash; the fashionable restaurant fish of the moment &mdash; which he had just bought. 
 &bquo;Now this is packed in three-kilo boxes, filled properly with ice of just the right size. 
 Large lumps bruise the skin. 
 The mullet have been carefully interleaved in the box, rather than shoved in. 
 &bquo;If I bought red mullet in England, I would probably get a two-stone cardboard box. 
 Two stone is really too large to handle carefully and as for cardboard and ice &mdash; well, you can imagine. 
 The quality of the ice and the arrangement of the fish would be far more haphazard and so, by the time the fish are delivered, their stomachs will have split.&equo; 
 Alex Griffiths, Marks &amp; Spencer's fish executive, was surprised at the idea that the company might have even contemplated using Billingsgate when it began selling fresh fish nationally four years ago. 
 &bquo;I go to the market regularly to see what is happening,&equo; he says, &bquo;but our entire trading policy is based on building relations with suppliers. 
 Our suppliers buy direct from the ports, prepare and pack the fish for us and then we have it on the shelves within 24 hours. 
 We stipulate temperature and handling at every stage. 
 Going though another stage would mean a loss of control.&equo; 
 With restaurants, supermarkets, wholesalers, single fishmongers and foreign buyers all scrabbling for the best fish, the implications for Billingsgate are clear. 
 In the opinion of Tim Lucas, a director of the wholesale company Simson: &bquo;Billingsgate is, shall we say, a little tired. 
 There has been such a growth in direct dealing that fish is only getting sent to Billingsgate when no one else wants it.&equo; 
 But Jim Moran believes Billingsgate has already found its niche. 
 &bquo;Billingsgate is a good place for cheap fish,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;There is a need for fish that has been on the market a couple of days. 
 It is not the image which people like you want to know about, but it is true. 
 The British like cheap food.&equo; 
 Nicholas Roe concluded our conversation rather surprisingly by saying: &bquo;Billingsgate is a really tough environment, you work long hours and grow old quickly. 
 You shouldn't be too hard on it.&equo; 
 It seems all the more of a waste if those long, cold hours only result in stale fish. 
 Drink: Desire in search of a name: Do the French have the &bquo;mot juste&equo; to describe the desire for a reviving drink? 
 In the first of a monthly series, Michael Jackson hunts in vain 
 By MICHAEL JACKSON 
 THANK God it's Saturday. 
 I know that today is Saturday because already I am thirsty for a dry, hoppy pint of bitter at the end of the afternoon: an aperitif to sharpen my appetite for this evening's Indian meal. 
 How did you feel as you came to the end of your working week yesterday afternoon? 
 Boy, I had a thirst. 
 We say we are thirsty when we mean that we fancy a glass of wine, a pint of beer, a gin and tonic or a shot of whisky &mdash; the pleasure of naming our poison &mdash; at the end of a busy day or tiresome week. 
 That is not thirst. 
 To enjoy it, we do not need to be dry: just in need of a restorative or relaxant, or maybe a focus for a social moment or brief encounter. 
 We call it &bquo;thirst&equo; in lieu of a more accurate description. 
 No, not more accurate: &bquo;thirst&equo; is not accurate at all as a description for this apparently indescribable condition. 
 It is a desire millions of us know and share, yet for which we have no name. 
 This desire that cannot find its name (though it would dare speak it, if it could) is pleasurable. 
 It is as enjoyable as feeling gently hungry or amorous. 
 No, not amorous: randy &mdash; we have a word for that. 
 Any of these conditions is pleasurable so long as there is a good likelihood of satisfaction in reasonably short order. 
 Let puritans and pessimists damn, disapprove or dismiss these appetites; that is their loss. 
 Those of us who enjoy them need only a name for each condition, so that we may discuss them in expectation and in recollection. 
 Come to think of it, neither hunger nor randiness hits quite the spot. 
 Peckishness and lust, perhaps? 
 Or does that sound like a firm of country solicitors? 
 This is to digress. 
 What of this thirst that can be satisfied by an unquenching drink? 
 Wine is not quenching, but no less in demand for that. 
 Try to quench your thirst with a light, fresh white and you will drink enough to put you on your back. 
 Beer is, quite rightly, Britain's favourite Friday night drink. 
 It can momentarily blunt a thirst, but not altogether cut it. 
 The nearest to being quenching is the &bquo;white&equo; beer of Berlin. 
 Anything with even a modest smack of hops dries the palate ready for the next one. 
 So, of course, does alcohol itself. 
 It may for a moment seem to quench but it dehydrates, as purportedly healthy abstainers are forever telling me. 
 To quench is more than to refresh although our lying, lascivious eyes tell us the two are the same. 
 Does any drink look more quenching than one of those Italian or French patent aperitifs, swirling in a refractive pink or russet oiliness, clothing the melting ice: a Campari, Dubonnet, Lillet or (too rare in this country) a Picon? 
 Are they quenching? 
 No, refreshing. 
 In Strasburg, they have been known to lace beer with Picon, thereby ruining both drinks (as Queen Victoria reputedly did with claret and malt whisky), but still the result is not especially quenching. 
 Perhaps a shimmering dry Martini cocktail (minimum dilution, stirred, not shaken; and served straight up) looks even more refreshing, though its effect is that of a silver mallet. 
 In the right place (possibly New York, but San Francisco is better), the Martini is the ultimate &bquo;Thank God it's Friday&equo; drink. 
 The requirement for such pleasures is a matter of time and place, and it does not have to be Friday, Berlin or Strasburg, New York or San Francisco. 
 Not feeling thirsty, but fancying a drink, has a world of moments. 
 Some Frenchmen start the day with a coffee and calvados. 
 The people of Munich call their version of Weissbier &bquo;breakfast beer&equo; and have it with a pair of coddled veal sausages. 
 New Orleans favours a mid-morning milk punch, or its own variation on the gin fizz. 
 If the moment is before a lunch on the plane, it really ought to be a Bloody Mary. 
 If it is at an elegant dinner table, there is a choice between a fino sherry (or a manzanilla) or champagne. 
 None of these requires anything even approaching a thirst. 
 Do we really &bquo;wash down&equo; a good meal with claret? 
 Port is immediately suggested by Stilton; cognac by coffee. 
 I do not fully appreciate the experience of an American late-night movie without a bourbon, or a book at bedtime without a single malt. 
 These are not moments of thirst&hellip; but nor are they causes of drunkenness (unless one tries to pack all such experiences into one day). 
 We do not drink because we are thirsty. 
 Nor, if we are in civilised cast of mind, because we wish to become drunk. 
 A friend of mine says that her body tells her, without being asked, the season of the year. 
 At the end of summer, her body stops wanting gin and tonics and suddenly desires whisky. 
 If it were only a matter of alcohol, would a body care? 
 People will nevertheless say that the desire is for nothing more than alcohol. 
 So why not a pill or an injection? 
 Because there would be no colour, no ritual, no time and place, no glorious variety. 
 Worst of all, there would be no aroma, taste, texture or finish. 
 These are sensuous pleasures at their most enjoyable when we ritualise them, but how do we feel when we desire them? 
 We, who have so many words in our language, have none for this. 
 But then, do the French, Spanish or Italians have a word for it? 
 Perhaps they do; maybe I have not being paying attention; too busy with the eau-de-vie, anis or grappa. 
 Do the Greeks have a word for it? 
 Could we borrow, beg or invent one? 
 Answers in a bottle, please. 
 If you are feeling &mdash; for lack of a better word -thirsty, let's meet again next month. 
 Same time, same place? 
 It will be my turn to get them in, I think. 
 Food and Drink Update: Menu for number 10 
 By MICHAEL JACKSON 
 THE silly question is an essential ingredient to most competitions. 
 In the case of the last round of the Young Cook of Britain competition, to be judged on 17 October, regional finalists were asked which famous person they would like to cook for. 
 Julia Noon, aged 12, of St Anne's on Sea, Lancashire, took the politic and patriotic route and wrote to 10 Downing Street to find out the Prime Minister's favourite foods. 
 She received a reply within four days. 
 Food and Drink Update: Seriously Spanish 
 By MICHAEL JACKSON 
 AS CHEAP and ersatz tapas bars continue to pop up on London street corners, it is easy to overlook serious Spanish food. 
 Benat Arroyabe, a young chef from San Sebastian, proved a notable exception during the last year by producing food of great elegance and flavour (witness capiscums filled with fresh cod and parsley sauce) in the Basque-oriented Guernica restaurant at 21a Foley Street, London W1 (01-580 0623). 
 Jose Ramon, a new chef who arrived at the Guernica two months ago, will hopefully maintain these high standards. 
 Another breeze from the Basque country, this one long-awaited, will be felt in the cookery world from 12 October with the publication of Maria Jose Sevilla's Life and Food in the Basque Country (Weidenfeld &amp; Nicolson, &pound;12.95). 
 The author, a co-founder of the information department promoting Spanish food in Britain, has refrained from the greasy chorizo and rough rioja marketing rush. 
 Instead, she has spent the last two years working on a book chronicling Basque life through its kitchens and markets. 
 Food and Drink Update: Small beginnings 
 By MICHAEL JACKSON 
 THE restaurant industry has two things in common with the film industry: the high failure rate among its small businesses and the abundance of &bquo;how to&equo; wisdom. 
 The message behind &bquo;How to open and operate a small restaurant&equo; &mdash; a series of six lectures in Chester organised by Leith's School of Food and Wine &mdash; may well be chapter and verse on &bquo;how not to&equo;. 
 The lecturer, Martin Wood, counts equally successful those students of the courses he has given since 1984, at Leith's School of Food and Wine in London, who subsequently decided not to open restaurants. 
 Mr Wood's own experience in the restaurant business spans 20 years. 
 Numbering among those of his students who have opened restaurants is Sian Sutherland-Dodd, whose London restaurant, Sutherlands, was named 1989 Soho Newcomer of the Year by The Good Food Guide. 
 &bquo;The course is good because it makes you think about things like how to lay out a kitchen,&equo; Ms Sutherland-Dodd says. 
 She recommends as essential, however, working in someone else's restaurant first, as she did in Nick Lander's L'Escargot. 
 Martin Wood's course begins on 1 November, running six consecutive Wednesdays at the Greenbank Centre, Eaton Road, Chester, Cheshire, from 6.30pm. 
 Fee &pound;175. 
 Drink: October wine rack 
 By ANTHONY ROSE 
 AS WE reported at the beginning of September, an increase in the fixed price agreed each year between Champagne's growers and merchants seemed inevitable, putting further pressure on prices that are already affected by rising demand. 
 Sure enough, due to prospects this year of a vintage declaration and an estimated shortfall of supply over demand (although the latest estimated harvest figure has gone up from 250 to 274 million bottles), the price per kilo of grapes was fixed at 26.77 French francs, a 13.78 per cent increase over last year. 
 Among the champagne houses that have already increased their prices to the wine trade are Moet et Chandon (9.6 per cent), Laurent Perrier (4.9 per cent), Bollinger (about 3 per cent) and Lanson (about 4 per cent). 
 The following companies are planning further increases in the new year as well: Mumm (about 4 per cent) and Heidsieck Monopole (about 4 per cent). 
 Those holding their prices, at least until the new year, include Veuve Clicquot and Perrier-Jouet. 
 Even where price increases have taken place, retailers with good stocks may be able to cushion the blow for a while. 
 But with Christmas not that far off, some forward champagne planning is definitely in order. 
 An impressive new range comes from Thresher's five new Wine Rack stores (four in London, one in Gerrards Cross) which, with a 12.5 per cent case discount, aim to offer the cheapest champagne prices in the high street. 
 Two of the best-value offers in the Wine Rack are the attractive Bricourt Carte Noire (&pound;9.99 bottle/ &pound;8.74 case bottle) and Charles Heidsieck 1982, a classy, golden vintage champagne (&pound;12.99 bottle/ &pound;11.37 case bottle). 
 Also worth seeking out is Victoria Wine's new 1983 vintage champagne with its classic &bquo;biscuity&equo; character (&pound;11.99) as is Waitrose's rich, winy 1983 Extra Dry vintage fizz (&pound;10.50). 
 And now for something completely different: cheap and cheerful claret. 
 Two good examples from Victoria Wine are its house claret, juicy and a touch almondy, a good buy at &pound;2.89; and Baron Rocheau 1988, &pound;2.49, which is soft, a touch green and stalky, but still good value. 
 Also from selected Victoria Wine stores is a sauternes in half-bottles with all the creamy, nutty complexity you might expect from a more elevated chateau, a snip at &pound;2.99. 
 Going Out to Eat and Drink: Days of pie and mash: Susan Ellicott tucks into plates of British tradition 
 By SUSAN ELLICOTT 
 ONE PIE, one mash. 
 One pie, two mash. 
 Two pie, one mash. 
 Two pie, two mash. 
 The menu at Manze's, in London's Tower Bridge Road, by Bermondsey Antiques Market, may not be extensive but at &pound;1.20 for one pie, one mash - sloshed with parsley sauce &mdash; there is little reason for customers to argue. 
 &bquo;Well, there is a choice,&equo; says Graham Poole, whose grandfather started the shop in 1895. 
 &bquo;They can take it or leave it.&equo; 
 This is a no-nonsense restaurant full of regulars: a child on Dad's shoulders; teenagers in Day-Glo shorts who skateboard away afterwards; workmen in overalls; weary shoppers with bulky carrier bags stopping off before getting the bus home. 
 The lunch hour is like a time warp &mdash; give or take a few price increases. 
 The walls are covered with original cream and emerald tiles. 
 Without the restaurant's 10 grey and white marble tables, wooden pew-like seats and two whirring overhead fans, the interior would have the atmosphere of a beautiful &mdash; and meticulously clean &mdash; Victorian public convenience. 
 &bquo;The hardest thing is keeping it looking the same,&equo; says Mr Poole, &bquo;mainly because of modern health and safety regulations.&equo; 
 He winces as he recounts how builders recently suggested he replace the &bquo;M. Manze&equo; above the door &mdash; in gold-leaf on glass &mdash; with a plastic sign. 
 Someone else quoted him &pound;30 to replace a broken fan. 
 Imagining his grandfather turning in his grave at the very thought, he paid &pound;120 to repair the old one. 
 Generations of customers will thank him. 
 Many remember eating jellied eels &mdash; still on the menu, along with eels and mash &mdash; with their parents. 
 And the restaurant is often crowded with aficionados getting their fix of nostalgia. 
 A novice struggling through one of Manze's pies &mdash; crisp golden pastry on top and soggy pastry below &mdash; is quickly spotted and given a cursory instruction in the art of pie-eating by a Bermondsey-born professional. 
 &bquo;You don't look like you're enjoying that. 
 That's because you didn't put vinegar on it. 
 You sprinkle it on and then cut the pie into pieces.&equo; 
 But why the soft pastry? 
 &bquo;Why do Beefeaters wear those silly hats and hang around the Tower of London? 
 It's tradition, isn't it?&equo; says Dennis Thompson, an ambulance driver who eats at Manze's at least three times a week. 
 He mops his brow as he demolishes a double helping of pie, salty mash and pale green gravy. 
 &bquo;At home you can never get the gravy like they do here,&equo; confides one elderly woman. 
 &bquo;They use the water from the jellied eels.&equo; 
 Mr Poole, however, is not giving away any secrets. 
 He is none too pleased that one of the waitresses has let on that the pies are made with two different pastries. 
 Outsiders are not invited into the basement kitchen. 
 &bquo;We've always used the same recipe,&equo; he says. 
 Scotch beef comes from Smithfield Market, fresh each day, boned and minced. 
 The vinegar &mdash; one plain and one with chilli &mdash; comes in whisky bottles. 
 Two gallons are used daily. 
 Salt and pepper sit on the tables in old jam-jars: &bquo;The biggest containers possible and they still get nicked,&equo; says Mr Poole. 
 On Saturdays, hungry customers queue along the pavement beneath Manze's green awning that is sandwiched between a dry-cleaner's and a men's clothing store. 
 The smell of stewed eels streams from a steaming vat into the busy street. 
 Even the late Roy Orbison has eaten pie and mash here. 
 He turned up unannounced one day, during a break from a television appearance, with a minder who wanted to give him a taste of real working-class London. 
 A youthful &bquo;Big O&equo; smiles from a signed photograph among the plastic bottles behind the counter. 
 &bquo;The trouble is,&equo; says Mr Poole, &bquo;people say now, &bquo;How long before he died did he come here?&equo; 
 ' Manze's, 87 Tower Bridge Road, London SE1 (01-407 2985). 
 Open Mon 11am-2pm, Tues-Thur from 10.30am, Fri-Sat 10am-2.30pm. 
 Going Out to Eat and Drink: Old delis at the centre of the soul system: Delicatessens are the culinary outposts of our European immigrants. 
 Ellen Galford joins the queues in Scotland to buy heritage over the counter 
 By ELLEN GALFORD 
 FOR immigrant communities &mdash; Italians, Jews, and others who have the passion for good, simple food bred into their souls &mdash; a traditional delicatessen is the centre of the universe. 
 The name of the old homeland may have been wiped off the map, the native Tuscan village may have mutated into Chiantishire, but in London's Soho or downtown Manhattan, in Glasgow or in East Coast America's polyglot suburbs, these are the places where history &mdash; private and collective &mdash; is still alive. 
 Originally, the deli was an antidote to culture shock, where all the salt, sweet, hot, sharp, garlicky flavours of home could be conjured up between two pieces of bread. 
 Meals were eaten on shop premises &mdash; noisy, welcoming outposts of the mother country. 
 To post-war generations, the deli has become a way to stay connected, through the taste buds with their roots. 
 Scotland's Italian immigrants have been the most generous and benevolent of culinary missionaries. 
 Their contributions to the serious arts of fish-frying and ice-cream making are well documented; they have allayed indigenous suspicion about garlic; and, in Glasgow and Edinburgh, they have established two of the country's finest delicatessens. 
 In Glasgow, Fazzi Brothers' Caffe-Bar, adjoining the Cambridge Street branch of the family's 70-year-old delicatessen business, fits in nicely with the Glaswegian notion of la dolce vita: sparky but unhurried conversation, compulsive people-watching, searching critiques of the nearby Sauchiehall Street shoe shops, and comparative study of each other's purchases, all washed down with copious amounts of coffee and a plate of voluptuous cakes. 
 In the morning, breakfasts may be classic continental with fresh fruit juice and Italian-style croissants and pastries, or savoury treats such as focaccia &mdash; slabs of rich bread dough baked with herbs and olive oil. 
 The beans for the house coffee are roasted fresh every day in the Fazzis' other premises in Clyde Street. 
 By some mysterious alchemy it seems possible to drink two or more cups of the mellow cappuccino or caffe crema without suffering the jangle of caffeine overload. 
 The espresso, in small cups, is dark and serious and packs a more powerful punch. 
 Italian-style cold drinks, such as iced coffee granita or a zingy blend of fresh fruit juices and grenadine, are also worth exploring. 
 For a more serious snack, aficionados make time to study the delicatessen counter before ordering. 
 Any of the meats, cheeses, marinated vegetables or salads on sale can be made into a custom-designed sandwich. 
 The charcuterie, with seasonal variations, includes about two dozen different Italian salamis and sausages, Parma ham and the more delicately flavoured San Daniele. 
 Look out also for such exotica as malegato, an aromatic Italian equivalent of traditional Scots black pudding. 
 At lunch hours things get busy as customers queue up for the small range of soft pasta dishes and such daily specials as vegetable lasagne or a spicy Italian-sausage casserole &mdash; all moderately priced and consistently good. 
 For those with a sweet tooth (few Glaswegians are without one), the gateaux are suitably elaborate. 
 As Fazzi Brothers is to Glasgow and the west of Scotland, the magisterial Italian food and wine merchant Valvona and Crolla is to Edinburgh and the east. 
 Here, unfortunately, no restaurant area is yet available to allow customers to eat what they buy where they buy it, but the time spent waiting for a takeaway sandwich will be an invaluable education in Italian food. 
 The shop, established in 1934 and now run by the founder's grandsons, is undoubtedly one of the most important delicatessens in the country, vast in its range of goods and uncompromising in its quality. 
 Outside, it is easy to miss: the narrow shopfront is identified only by the Italian flags hanging overhead. 
 Inside, customers thread their way between stacks of every imaginable pasta, pickles and condiments, flasks of vintage olive oils, stacks of imported biscuits, panforte and panettone. 
 Service is at a counter backed by one of Britain's most comprehensive collections of serious Italian wines: more than 500 different varieties are on offer. 
 To the novice first impressions may be chaotic, but the temptation to turn away and come back at some quieter time should be resisted. 
 There are few, if any, quieter times. 
 Here again, all the glories of the delicatessen counter &mdash; marinated artichokes, sun-dried tomatoes in virgin olive oil, seafood salads and the rich home-made pesto &mdash; are available in sandwich form. 
 Those wanting to voyage further than comparatively familiar delicacies such as coppa, pancetta or fennel-flavoured salami, should look upwards. 
 At certain times of the year, hanging from the ceiling amid the festoons of dried sausages, cheeses, onions and garlic, will be a haunch of wild boar. 
 When manager Victor Contini judges that the moment is right, the haunch is brought down to be skinned, boned, cured and thinly sliced like Parma ham. 
 At &pound;5 per quarter, this rarity is not exactly a budget snack, but with a focaccia still warm from the oven and accompanied by a few herb-steeped olives, it could be the most extraordinary sandwich you ever eat. 
 Going Out to Eat and Drink: More scope for cross-cultural encounters 
 By ELLEN GALFORD 
 LONDON UNCLE Ian's Deli-Diner has got things determinedly backwards. 
 Old World trappings of the Jewish corner shop have been forsaken in favour of the glaring lights, imitation bentwood chairs and lurid indoor awnings of a suburban American fast-food parlour. 
 Yet portions cling to the style of days gone by, when a salt beef sandwich might have been the single meal of the day. 
 The manic tone behind this two-year-old north London deli, however, is timeless. 
 Uncle Ian is fond of jokes and posters. 
 A meal eaten in his deli is likely to be spent reading the likes of &bquo;Your spouse found out you're having an affair? 
 Well, have Uncle Ian cater it!!!&equo; 
 Experienced Temple Fortune locals seem to prefer to peer away from the posters at the television set perched atop the soft drinks cooler. 
 Mostly timeless, too, is the kosher-style deli menu: salt beef on rye with mustard; chopped liver; pastrami and salad; chicken soup &bquo;with everything&equo;; and the odd interloper, like peanut butter and cream cheese. 
 (Emily Green) Uncle Ian's Deli-Diner, 1105 Finchley Road, Temple Fortune, NW11 (01-458 3493). 
 Open 9am-11.30pm daily, except 4pm closing Fridays. 
 Like all good delis, La Galicia in Clapham is a family concern, run by Gloria Ricot with help from her twin sister Clara. 
 After 12 years of growing success with the shop, Gloria opened a wine/tapas bar on the premises in May this year. 
 With stocks consisting largely of wines from Navarra and Rioja, the place now has the unusual advantage of both on- and off-licences for alcohol. 
 The salty, fishy odour of baccala (dried salt cod) hits you at the door, and there is a good selection of Spanish pork products, not forgetting chorizo sausage and serrano ham. 
 There are eight varieties of olives, bulk and bottled, including a Californian one stuffed with jalapeno; olive oil, most famously Carbonell whose comely wench pictured on the labels must be the emblem of Spanish olive oil in British imaginations, comes in gallon tins rather than fancy little bottles. 
 A wide range of deCecco pasta, among the best of the dried brands, jostles for space on the shelves next to pretty tin boxes of turron, Spanish almond nougat. 
 In the compact bar space at the back of the store you can perch on a stool and eat tapas, sandwiches or a hot meal, washed down with cappuccino or Spanish beer. 
 The Ricots make paella almost every day by popular demand; the Saturday special is churros (fried twisted dough) and a hot cup of chocolate for &pound;1. 
 (Linda Sue Park) La Galicia, 148 Clapham Manor Street, SW4 (01-622 0599). 
 Open 9am-7.30pm Mon-Sat. 
 MANCHESTER Laps has been an institution for almost 60 years. 
 Many a Jewish courtship has got off to a somewhat greasy start over pickled brisket sandwiches and chips on fine evenings outside the deli. 
 The less pubescent diner can cast a detached eye on this ritual from six Formica-topped tables inside the tiny deli-restaurant. 
 Although Laps has now passed out of the benign hands of David and Lotte Lapidus, who ran it for some 50 years, the tradition lives on as does the style of cuisine, best described by the Yiddish word hamisch. 
 Nothing fancy and lots of it. 
 Pickled brisket and chopped and fried fish are the specialities, although at times Laps bizarrely mixes the Eastern European tradition with that of south Lancashire. 
 There can be few other places in the world where you can wash down a chopped herring sandwich with a glass of hot Vimto. 
 (Martin Kelner) Lapidus, 21 Bury Old Road, Prestwich (061 740 3095). 
 Open Tues-Thur 5.30pm-11pm; Sun 11.30am-3pm. 
 Food: Feast of indelicate edibles: Chaim Bermant hankers for herrings 
 By CHAIM BERMANT 
 DELICATESSEN, as the name suggests, means delicate edibles, but delicate these edibles are not. 
 They assault the sense, savage the palate, ravage one's innards and announce themselves in loud, pungent terms so that one gets wind of them long before one catches sight of them. 
 But I love them. 
 Basically they are titbits and are designed to excite the appetite rather than assuage it. 
 As food they are meant principally for the non-hungry, the non-domesticated, those who can just summon the energies to open a tin of pate de foie gras or unwind a rollmop. 
 I was born in what is now Russia, and when I came to Scotland shortly before the war the small Jewish grocery shops in the Gorbals district of Glasgow were my main link with home. 
 I still remember their names: Ixe's, Fogels, Ettingers, Callendars. 
 And their wares: huge, steaming loaves of black Russian bread, glossy bagels, crispy pretzels, cinnamon cakes, long, crudely circumcised phallic rolls of salami, pickled gherkins and &mdash; their hallmark - open barrels of salt herrings. 
 I only had to shut my eyes and inhale and I was back in Russia. 
 To me delicatessen means herring, 1,001 varieties of herring, but I did not always regard them as such if only because I virtually lived on them. 
 The herring was to the Eastern European Jew what potatoes were to the Irish, which is surprising, for the herring is a salt-water fish and in Russia and Poland one rarely got a glimpse of the sea. 
 But Jews know a good thing when they taste it and alighted on the herring because it was inexpensive, piquant, nutritious and versatile. 
 The herring was never quite considered a member of the fish family. 
 The carp and pike, which were found locally, were kitted out with lavish trimmings and served on the Sabbath and at festivals. 
 The humble herring was treated as crude workaday fare, and in our household we might have pickled herring on Sunday, soused herring on Monday, herrings in sour cream on Tuesday, schmaltz herring on Wednesday, and herrings fried in matzo meal on Thursday. 
 When we moved to Scotland I discovered the greatest delicacy of all &mdash; the smoked herring, or kipper. 
 I am sure the warm affinities between Scots and Jews arise out of appreciation of herrings. 
 I also came upon a mysterious animal I had not seen before: much larger than the herring, redder and infinitely more expensive. 
 They called it smoked salmon and I immediately concluded it was some sort of rich man's herring. 
 The Gorbals is no more and neither are the small Jewish grocery shops. 
 One is hard pressed even to find them in London. 
 Instead one has delicatessens which are more brightly lit and infinitely more hygienic than the small corner shops I have known, but with their fridges and freezers and extraction fans they have tamed their wares and robbed them of their pungency. 
 One's sense of smell, always deeply involved in the joy of the delicatessen, has been rendered virtually redundant. 
 But more than that, all the goods, and especially the innumerable varieties of herring, have gone upmarket. 
 If salmon is still the rich man's herring, one can no longer think of herrings as the poor man's salmon for they have become so expensive that one buys them by the troy ounce. 
 All of which shows that one man's staple is another man's delicatessen or, rather, that the necessities of one generation can become the luxuries of the next. 
 Reporter jailed 
 Foreign News Page 10 
 Nepal avalanche 
 Foreign News Page 10 
 Chilean protest 
 Foreign News Page 10 
 Peres to Moscow 
 Foreign News Page 10 
 Disident freed 
 By CHAIM BERMANT 
 PRAGUE (Reuter) &mdash; Czechoslovak authorities have released a human rights activist, Miroslav Kusy, who was held on charges of subversion. 
 Bush to see PM 
 Foreign News Page 10 
 Stepping down 
 Foreign News Page 10 
 No federal case 
 By CHAIM BERMANT 
 WASHINGTON (AP) &mdash; President Bush, making light of surgery to remove a cyst from his right middle finger, said it was no &bquo;federal case&equo; and promised to show off his scar afterward. 
 In the hot seat 
 By CHAIM BERMANT 
 BOGOTA (Reuter) &mdash; Roberto Salazar Manrique, an economist, was named as Colombia's new justice minister, replacing Monica de Greiff who resigned after repeated death threats by drug traffickers. 
 Mr Salazar is the ninth justice minister since August 1986. 
 Mining ban 
 By CHAIM BERMANT 
 SYDNEY (Reuter) &mdash; The government has decided to ban mining in most of the Kakadu wilderness park, where the film Crocodile Dundee was shot. 
 Harare arrest 
 By KARL MAIER 
 HARARE &mdash; Plainclothes policemen detained a Zimbabwean labour leader, Morgan Tsvangirai, as part of a crackdown on opponents of President Robert Mugabe's government, writes Karl Maier. 
 Mr Tsvangirai's detention came a day after his Zimbabwe Congress of Trade Unions denounced the government's closure of the University of Zimbabwe and accused it of unleashing &bquo;brutal state force&equo; against opponents. 
 Siege ends 
 By KARL MAIER 
 SAN SALVADOR (Reuter) &mdash; One of two occupations of embassies in San Salvador ended when human rights activists freed 13 hostages they had held for a day at the Costa Rican Embassy and left. 
 The occupation of the Mexican by leftist guerrillas continued. 
 Murder claim 
 By KARL MAIER 
 BRUSSELS (AP) &mdash; An unknown group called &bquo;Young Palestine, Proud and Free&equo;, in a letter to Belgian newspapers yesterday, said it had killed Joseph Wybran, a leading Belgian Jew. 
 The claim came as 1,000 people attended a funeral service for Mr Wybran. 
 LDP pick Kaifu 
 By KARL MAIER 
 TOKYO (Reuter) &mdash; The Liberal Democratic Party, struggling to win back voters alienated by scandals and a sales tax, yesterday chose the Prime Minister, Toshiki Kaifu, to lead it into the next general election. 
 Ratification of the appointment is expected on 31 October. 
 Plan rejected 
 By CHARLES RICHARDS 
 JERUSALEM &mdash; Likud ministers yesterday blocked a proposal by the Labour coalition partners to accept Egyptian ideas for convening Palestinian-Israeli talks. 
 The inner cabinet was split along party lines six to six, but tied votes are taken as votes against, writes Charles Richards. 
 Bitter medicine for Poles 
 By CHARLES RICHARDS 
 WARSAW (Reuter) &mdash; The Polish Finance Minister, Leszek Balcerowicz, offered Poles a harsh dose of economic austerity yesterday, but said no relief from soaring prices and food queues could be expected for at least a year. 
 He said the Solidarity-led government had been given a chance to implement a &bquo;total change&equo; from Poland's communist system to a free-market economy. 
 &bquo;But this chance was given to us in extremely bad conditions.&equo; 
 Poland must cut spending, free prices, tighten tax discipline, cut state subsidies and wage indexation and limit pay increases. 
 Mr Balcerowicz said his policies would bring unemployment to between 10 and 20 per cent. 
 East Berlin keeps Westerners out 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 &bquo;NO DAY-VISAS TODAY!&equo; 
 Phalanxes of East German border guards barred the way to Westerners trying to use the crossing-points in the Berlin Wall as East Germany's Communist leaders began celebrating their 40-year rule over an increasingly restive population. 
 Protests by hundreds of Dutch, Scandinavian, West German and British people fell on deaf ears as they were turned away. 
 Only business travellers and returning East Germans were allowed through. 
 At Friedrichstrasse station, where many Westerners arrive on the Stadtbahn, the city railway, long queues formed. 
 &bquo;I fixed up months ago to meet my parents in East Berlin today and took some holiday for it,&equo; fumed one man. 
 Many West Berlin pensioners, who had set off to visit relatives and friends in the East, looked scared. 
 That generation knows only too well what political tension can mean. 
 There were Poles returning home after selling rucksacks full of sausages, butter, Polish vodka and cigarettes on West Berlin's black market. 
 &bquo;This can't go on much longer,&equo; the Poles hopefully assured the Germans. 
 The flight of East Germans from their country continued yesterday, despite restrictions on travel to Czechoslovakia and other neighbouring countries. 
 No sooner had a special train, carrying 633 people who had taken refuge at the West German embassy in Warsaw, arrived in Hanover yesterday than at least 200 more refugees turned up on the embassy doorstep. 
 Another 1,800 emigres came out across the Austro-Hungarian border in the 48 hours ending yesterday morning. 
 The West German embassy in Prague, where thousands of people had taken refuge, is now surrounded by Czechoslovak police, who check the identities of all comers and have sent away numerous would-be refugees. 
 Film of the riots in Dresden on Wednesday have reached the West, with evidence that they were more violent than first thought. 
 A West Berlin radio station said a young man was killed &mdash; it was not known how &mdash; and that another lost both legs when hit by a train. 
 He been with people who had lain on the tracks to try to stop the special trains bringing out 7,600 refugees from Prague and climb on board. 
 About 10,000 people were believed to have been involved in the clashes, in which police, army units and factory militias armed with water-cannon and truncheons clashed with crowds hurling cobblestones and shouting &bquo;We want to get out.&equo; 
 Many people are believed to have been seriously injured. 
 Several police vehicles were burned or wrecked, windows were smashed and public buildings were damaged. 
 More demonstrations and clashes, although less violent, followed on Thursday night, while in Magdeburg, police broke up a silent march of some 500 people through the city following a prayer meeting in the cathedral. 
 Church sources said four people were injured and 100 to 200 were taken away by the police. 
 East Germany's workers' militias, which have 400,000 members, are standing by all over the country to help to clamp down in case of trouble. 
 Police and security-service patrols have been stepped up. 
 The mobilisation of the militias has been accompanied by letters in the press, supposedly from members, calling for tough action against &bquo;subversive provocation&equo; and vowing to &bquo;stop these counter-revolutionary actions for once and for all - with weapons if need be&equo;. 
 The militias, or &bquo;combat groups of the working-class&equo;, are armed units set up within factories, agricultural co-operatives, big organisations or institutions. 
 They are supposed to crush politicial uprisings, act as a kind of home guard in times of war and to guard buildings. 
 East Germans find consensus only in boredom: Edward Steen, in East Berlin for the 40th anniversary celebrations, reflects on how illusions have been shattered and triumphal propaganda now has a hollow ring 
 From EDWARD STEEN in East Berlin 
 LIKE BEAUTY, tawdriness is in the eye of the beholder, and on their country's 40th birthday East Germans tend to see it through the cruelly unblinking eyes of thoroughly Westernised consumers. 
 &bquo;My relatives used to come over and say: &bquo;There's nothing in the shops&equo;, and I thought it was ridiculous, because there was plenty,&equo; a 47-year-old lathe operator from Dresden told me yesterday. 
 He was on a train taking him home from a visit to his sister in Vienna. 
 &bquo;When I was allowed to go West again after 20 years, two years ago, I couldn't believe how it had been transformed. 
 I came back and saw it was true: there is nothing in the shops.&equo; 
 The postwar generation, unschooled in the brutality of hardships of war and reconstruction, compares its lot with that of West Germans, with double their standard of living, rather than with their neighbours to the East, to whom the mountains of sausages and pigs' trotters in butchers' shops would seem like a dream come true. 
 Forty years on, there is, at best, a consensus of boredom with the virulent attacks against allegedly renascent fascism, and the endlessly invoked Achievements. 
 Yesterday, Achievements marched up and down the grey columns of the party paper Neues Deutschland with more than usual determination. 
 The solid education system, full if unexciting shops, the fact that East Germany is socialism's only economic miracle, ranking among the world's top 10 industrial countries &mdash; it all bores people unspeakably, as much as those triumphal lists of foreign dignitaries attending today's ceremonies, and the constant reminder that 135 countries recognise the 1945 Soviet occupation zone as a second German state. 
 But so do many of the opposition groups here, entertaining a touching if economically illiterate faith in a third way which would involve neither reunification nor a return to capitalism. 
 But the haemorrhage of people since travel was eased in the past few years, and the mass exodus of the past weeks suggest they are in a minority. 
 The German Democratic Republic arose as a retaliation to the Western Allies' decision to create a German Federal Republic in the Western occupation zone in May 1949. 
 The GDR line is that Britain and the US were responsible for this &bquo;collaboration with monopoly capital&hellip; without any democratic authorisation&equo;. 
 The chance of &bquo;uniform anti-fascist and democratic development&equo; in a unified country had been thrown away. 
 East Germany's slender claim to legitimacy rests above all on the fraudulent implication that it is the good non-Nazi, never-Nazi Germany, any Nazi-supporters having joined the four million renegades whose Westward migration almost drained East Germany dry before the Wall went up on 13 August 1961. 
 The GDR's acceptance as a real country has been the function of the Cold War, a piece of make-believe reflecting tacit agreement by both blocs that the German Question is best put on hold. 
 West Germany's willingness in the early Seventies in effect to bribe East Berlin &mdash; by about DM4bn (&pound;1.32bn) a year &mdash; to treat its citizens more decently has cemented the division. 
 This has given the East Germans the best standard of living in East Europe. 
 But freer travel to the West, which is one of the benefits Bonn extracted, also increased disgruntlement with things at home. 
 An important factor in the crisis is the awakening realisation among West Germans that they have been tricked into pretending this peculiar arrangement of subsidising their compatriots' oppressors was normal. 
 The once-numerous Western apologists for the GDR have fallen silent, or stridently demand reforms. 
 Pope urges freedom for Church in Ukraine 
 From MICHAEL SHERIDAN in Rome 
 THE VATICAN is to step up pressure on Mikhail Gorbachev with a demand by the Pope for the legalisation of the Ukranian Catholic Church, church sources said yesterday. 
 The church, which had been in communion with Rome since 1596, was forcibly merged with the Russian Orthodox church by Stalin in 1948. 
 Pope John Paul's outspoken words on behalf of a church which he deems to have been &bquo;driven into the catacombs&equo; reflect a worried assessment by the Secretariat of State, the Vatican's Foreign Office, that Mr Gorbachev's authority may come under increasing threat and that the Church should therefore exploit Soviet liberalisation for all it is worth. 
 According to these sources, the Pope and the Secretariat of State intend to push for a firm public commitment to legalisation by Mr Gorbachev when he visits Italy and the Vatican at the end of November. 
 They say the decision to step up overt pressure came quickly after the Vatican learned from Italian Foreign Ministry officials that Mr Gorbachev's visit was being curtailed to less than three full days. 
 On Thursday, the Pope spoke forcibly to an audience of Ukrainian Catholic bishops, recalling that the native branch of their church had been &bquo;driven into the catacombs, suffering the martyrdom of her bishops and priests, deportations, arrests and the closures of churches and monasteries&equo;. 
 &bquo;The cries of these Catholics reach Rome with ever-increasing urgency,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The campaign of hostility and accusations against this church and her priests does not help reforms, but hinders them. 
 Without the legalisation of the Ukranian community, the process of democratisation will never be complete.&equo; 
 The Pope spoke these words, which allow the Soviet leader a suitable period for reflection, before travelling to Asia yesterday on a 10-day visit. 
 The trip begins at a Eucharistic Congress in Seoul intended to put the seal on the Catholic Church's extraordinary progress in Korea, where the number of believers has grown from a post-war 200,000 to more than 2.5 million, and is increasing by 10 per cent each year. 
 Then there is a potentially controversial stop in the former Portuguese colony of East Timor, which has a majority Catholic population. 
 The Vatican has never officially recognised Indonesia's annexation of the territory, but it is privately conceded that the Papal visit constitutes de facto recognition of the status quo. 
 Greek coalition resigns after launching clean-up 
 From PETER THOMPSON in Athens 
 GREECE'S three-month-old government will resign today, opening the way for fresh elections, probably on 5 November. 
 When the right-wing New Democracy party and the Communist-dominated coalition of the left agreed after inconclusive elections in June to support a temporary administration headed by the conservative backbencher, Tzannis Tzannetakis, its mission was strictly defined: to clean up the scandals that unseated Andreas Papandreou and his socialist (Pasok) government; and &bquo;to restore the prestige and normal functioning of democratic institutions&equo;. 
 After the summer's inquiries, MPs decided to commit Mr Papandreou and a handful of ex-colleagues for trial on charges of ordering telephone tapping and accepting bribes. 
 This momentous decision &mdash; it is the first time a former Greek prime minister has been indicted by parliament &mdash; was complemented by measures the left coalition in particular regards as vital to prevent abuse of power by single-party governments in future. 
 The Tzannetakis administration left state broadcasting free to report objectively. 
 It reformed the judicial system, buttressing its independence, and introduced parliamentary scrutiny of important public sector contracts and appointments. 
 It also completed the long task of national reconciliation, burying by example the myth which dates from the 1946-49 Civil War, that right and left can never co-operate. 
 Mr Tzannetakis, who has won public affection for his unassuming style, said this week that no single-party government could have achieved these things &mdash; the broader consensus was what was needed. 
 However, there are few signs, after this constructive interlude, that Greek politics will avoid reverting to their familiar rancour and polarisation. 
 Mr Papandreou's Pasok, embittered and demoralised, remains unable to evolve from unreconstructed popularism and anti-right rhetoric. 
 New Democracy, led by Constantine Mitsotakis, has shown that its undertaking to rid the bureaucracy of party domination means merely replacing Pasok stalwarts in key state posts with its own loyal time-servers. 
 The left coalition appears more committed to moderation and compromise, yet it is unlikely to be rewarded with the electorate's gratitude. 
 Its senior partner, the Communist Party, has not carried all its followers with it this summer, and last month had to purge the entire leadership of its youth movement (KNE). 
 Shocked by the formation of the left coalition last year, the KNE was downright hostile to its supporting a government in alliance with the right. 
 The big question now is whether Mr Mitsotakis will win an overall majority next month. 
 In June he fell just short, with 44 per cent of the vote and 145 seats out of 300. 
 Some observers argue that the assassination last month of Mr Mitsotakis' son-in-law, Paul Bakoyannis MP, and the dignity and courage shown by Mr Mitsotakis then, may tip the balance in New Democracy's favour. 
 Mr Papandreou will do everything he can to thwart New Democracy. 
 He has wooed back respected figures who had quit Pasok, and enticed one former conservative minister, Yannis Boutos, to join him. 
 His proposal of limited electoral co-operation with the left, while not encouraged, has not been completely rebuffed. 
 There may be bad blood between the two party leaderships but, given a hung parliament next month, they will need each other. 
 Reformists take hold of Prague congress 
 From IMRE KARACS in Budapest 
 HUNGARY'S ruling Socialist Workers Party took a big step yesterday towards the complete abandonment of Communism when its president, Rezso Nyers, sketched out the contours of a new socialist movement capable of contesting next year's free elections, the first in Eastern Europe for 40 years. 
 &bquo;The historic role of the Hungarian Socialist Workers Party has come to an end,&equo; Mr Nyers said, in a speech opening the party's congress. 
 &bquo;We now need a new party, one that is the heir and not a mere continuation of the present one. 
 I believe the new party cannot be a communist party.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;Communism is not on the agenda today as a social formation.&equo; 
 Mr Nyers was speaking shortly after a long procedural wrangle on the method of electing the new leadership. 
 This debate, as well as a straw poll taken in the morning, confirmed that the reformers, though short of an absolute majority, now have the upper hand. 
 With 464 delegates out of the total of 1,276, they are by far the largest bloc. 
 The numbers are important, because the new party's leadership will be elected from lists submitted by the various factions on an all-or-nothing principle. 
 If the reformists emerge as the largest group, they will sweep the board. 
 In the first vote of the day, they ensured that Central Committee members and regional party secretaries not elected as delegates were allowed to attend the congress only as observers. 
 The confidence displayed by reformers such as Mr Nyers and Imre Pozsgay, who introduced the new party's programme, was in sharp contrast to the air of resignation in the conservative rows. 
 Karoly Grosz, the outgoing general secretary, cut a lonely figure as he bowed out, dropping hints that in future he would be taking a back seat in politics. 
 Mr Grosz was the only senior politician yesterday with the courage to stand up for Communism in front of a hostile audience. 
 As a parting shot, he even attacked reformists for &bquo;resorting to Stalinist tactics&equo; and admitted to having &bquo;differences of philosophy and outlook with Comrade Poszgay&equo;. 
 But Mr Poszgay's radical programme looked safe last night. 
 His proposal that a new socialist party should rise from the ashes of the present one was hardly disputed. 
 The programme's emphasis on a mixed economy also met little resistance. 
 Democracy is, of course, a tedious process, and the first concrete results of the congress are not likely to emerge before tomorrow. 
 Having discarded Communism, the delegates will have the difficult job of deciding what to erect in its place. 
 Less than seven per cent of the delegates are manual workers, and even if the word &bquo;worker&equo; is dropped from the title, the Thatcherite economics will be hard to reconcile with the remaining word &bquo;socialist&equo;. 
 Readers lose their faith in Soviet press 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 GLASNOST, it would seem, has lost its charm &mdash; or more accurately perhaps, the Soviet people have realised that man cannot live by words alone. 
 After two years of explosive circulation growth, Soviet newspapers are being deserted by their subscribers in droves. 
 The bulk of sales of dailies and periodicals here is not at the news stands, but via annual subscriptions which normally have to be renewed by 1 October. 
 But the threatened drop in readership for 1990 is now so great that the the authorities have extended the date by a month. 
 In many cases, this form of guaranteed sales is running at barely half that of 1989, when the boom was such that the government was forced to drop limits on subscriptions, which it claimed were forced upon it by lack of newsprint. 
 By mid-September, according to figures released yesterday, subscriptions to Izvestia, the government daily, which now sells close to 11 million copies, were only 61 per cent of the level 12 months before. 
 For Trud, the union paper which claims the largest daily sale of close to 20 million, the figure is 54 per cent. 
 Both liberal and conservative publications have been hit. 
 The most dismal performance is by Pravda, the official party paper, of whose regular readers only 36 per cent had renewed their subscriptions. 
 But even Ogonyok, considered the most chic and sought-after of the progressive press, is running at only 50 per cent of 1989 levels. 
 Perhaps, as officials contend, faces will be saved by a last-minute rush to meet the new deadline. 
 More probably, however, even the final figures will show large declines &mdash; the most telling possible proof of how the exhilaration of being able to read almost anything has been replaced by disillusion at being able to buy almost nothing. 
 Vyacheslav Antonov, a senior official of the central press agency, Soyuzpechat, claimed yesterday that readers were merely becoming more discerning, after having snapped up everything on offer in the initial heady flush of press freedom. 
 If anything, the papers are growing yet more adventurous, and they are certainly not expensive, at between three and five kopecks (pence) a copy. 
 More probably, the mass desertion is another sign of how the people have lost faith in perestroika and its unfulfilled promises. 
 TRAINS moved vital supplies into Soviet Armenia yesterday, ending a blockade of more than a month by workers in neighbouring Azerbaijan, Reuter reports. 
 Tass news agency said hundreds of wagons rolled in to the southern Soviet republic bordering Turkey, three days after the Soviet parliament authorised the army to take over the railways. 
 Tass said the trains passed between Armenia and Azerbaijan, where workers have blockaded railways to press the Armenians to drop claims to the disputed territory of Nagorny-Karabakh. 
 The Week in Review: Foreign News 
 By FIONA LENEY 
 IT HAS been a week of mixed fortunes for the some of the world's more repressive regimes. 
 The exodus of East Germans continued: 18,000 streamed into West Germany before their country took belated action to plug the last hole in its borders by requiring visas for all future trips to Czechoslovakia. 
 East Germany's leader, Erich Honecker, did his best to pretend he had cured the malaise by expelling &bquo;anti-social elements, who have a bad attitude to work and also to normal living conditions&equo;. 
 His purge has been West Germany's much-needed transfusion, as its 26,500 new citizens bring with them precious skills. 
 Although East Germany managed to staunch the flow on the eve of its 40th birthday, observers said it was still in danger of bleeding slowly to death, or of suffering convulsions brought on by repression on its streets. 
 Police beat back would-be emigrants as they tried to join sealed trains carrying their countrymen to the West, or sought refuge in the US embassy in East Berlin. 
 China's elderly leaders had salt liberally rubbed into their wounds by the Nobel Foundation, which awarded the Peace Prize to the Dalai Lama. 
 The Peace Committee cited not only his religious work but his &bquo;struggle for the liberation of Tibet&equo;. 
 The parallels between the methods used to suppress unrest in Lhasa and those used to put down the student-led demonstrations in Peking made the award a double indictment of China's human-rights record. 
 The Chinese lashed out at the Nobel Prize Committee for meddling in China's affairs and &bquo;hurting the Chinese people's feelings&equo;. 
 For Panama's General Noriega, the week could have ended with far more than hurt feelings, after junior officers mounted a coup against him. 
 But troops loyal to the general foiled the attempt and he emerged with his customary grin and triumphal air-punching. 
 The rebels had managed to seize the military headquarters and briefly take &bquo;Pineapple Face&equo; hostage. 
 But they refused to hand him over to the US for trial and the coup crumbled when American troops stationed in Panama retaliated by ignoring their pleas for help against loyal troops. 
 In the recriminations that followed the botched coup, pro- and anti-Noriega factions attacked the White House. 
 The first accused Washington of backing the failed coup; the second, complaining of the Bush &bquo;wimp factor&equo;, said the United States had not done enough. 
 Denials of CIA involvement rang hollow in Washington, where the extent of the President's obsession with ousting General Noriega is common knowledge. 
 Tension between the Soviet republics of Armenia and Azerbaijan over administration of the bitterly-disputed region of Nagorny Karabakh threatened to erupt into full-scale confrontation. 
 The Azeris continued to block rail links with Armenia. 
 The Soviet parliament approved special measures allowing the military to take over the railways to get supplies through, but the army held off, apparently reluctant to trigger fresh protests. 
 Soviet newspapers said it was impossible even for convoys with a military escort to enter Nagorny Karabakh and compared the situation with Afghanistan. 
 President Corazon Aquino of the Philippines stood by her decision to forbid the return of Ferdinand Marcos's body for burial, saying his corpse still had a &bquo;malignant power&equo; which could be used by his followers to seize power. 
 The Marcos camp then applied to the Philippine Supreme Court to reverse the ban. 
 President Aquino said she would abide by the court's decision. 
 Show business has traditionally intruded on American news programmes, but it went a little far last week in the trial of the fallen televangelist, Jim Bakker. 
 Bakker was convicted of swindling followers of his Praise the Lord ministry out of more than &dollar;150m (&pound;90m), some of which he used as hush money for his mistress, Jessica Hahn. 
 After the verdict his wife sang, in chorus with her supporters in the courtroom: &bquo;On Christ the solid rock I stand/ All other ground is sinking sand&equo;. 
 Plans are reportedly afoot for a new soap called &bquo;Ministry&equo;. 
 Even worse, Dan Rather, the CBS news anchorman once considered America's most trusted person, failed to answer accusations that he had aired fake battle footage and false news accounts of the Afghan war. 
 The charges were backed up by the BBC's Foreign News Editor, John Simpson, who said the film &bquo;had no feeling of reality&equo;. 
 Seems you can't trust anyone nowadays. 
 Moscow and Kabul avoid UN flare-up 
 From LEONARD DOYLE in New York and AHMED RASHID in Lahore 
 THE SOVIET UNION and Pakistan remain bitterly divided as to how the conflict in Afghanistan should be resolved, despite having agreed on the wording for a United Nations resolution in the hope of avoiding a public row at the General Assembly, diplomats said yesterday. 
 Far from suggesting that the two sides were moving towards a new spirit of co-operation, the diplomats said they were a long way from calling for a ceasefire. 
 The resolution, drafted by the Islamic Conference group of countries, calls for &bquo;a comprehensive political solution&equo; and a &bquo;cessation of hostilities&equo; but contains no initiatives of substance, diplomats said. 
 At Moscow's insistance the resolution includes a call for an end to the fighting between the mujahedin and the Kabul government, but the appeal for a ceasefire is made in the context of a broad political settlement being reached, the diplomats stressed. 
 The resolution will be adopted by acclamation. 
 In spite of a spate of speculative press reports, Soviet-Pakistan co-operation at the United Nations does not change Pakistan's unconditional support for the mujahedin and Soviet support for the Kabul regime. 
 Although the resolution appeals to the UN Secretary General, Javier Perez de Cuellar, to &bquo;encourage and facilitate&equo; a comprehensive political settlement on the basis of the Geneva Accords (which his Special Representative, Diego Cordovez, negotiated to cover the withdrawal of the Soviet army in January), he has so far hesitated to begin a new round of peace talks between the warring Afghan parties. 
 None the less, the consensus in the General Assembly will give Mr Perez de Cuellar scope to carry on behind-the-scenes negotiations with all sides in the conflict, to agree to a UN peace plan. 
 Western and Pakistani diplomatic sources said the UN secretariat hoped to bring together the six countries directly involved in the conflict &mdash; the US, the Soviet Union, China, Pakistan, Iran and Saudi Arabia &mdash; to accept the broad terms for a dialogue among the rival Afghan groups. 
 The main stumbling block to this was the US, which is committed to the overthrow of the Kabul regime by the mujahedin. 
 Last week, Mr Perez de Cuellar called for a &bquo;structured&equo; Afghan delegation representing all the Afghan factions to meet and organise an intra-Afghan dialogue. 
 He hopes to encourage President Najibullah to allow prominent Afghans in Kabul who do not belong to the ruling People's Democratic Party (PDPA) to represent the regime in this delegation. 
 But there has been no sign from Kabul that President Najibullah is at all in favour of the proposal. 
 India's royals get a taste for democracy: Once-mighty Maharajahs are still making their influence felt in an election battle for a pivotal seat, Tony Allen-Mills writes from Bharatpur 
 From TONY ALLEN-MILLS in Bharatpur 
 WHEN the Indian princes were at the height of their outrageous fortune, the Maharajah of Bharatpur had 24 Rolls-Royces in his garage. 
 He kept tiger and cheetah cubs as house pets and was famous for slaughtering ducks. 
 Fortune duly gave way to forfeit; the cars were sold, the duck marsh was turned into a bird sanctuary and the only tigers left in Bharatpur are stuffed. 
 Yet almost 30 years after Indira Gandhi stripped the princes of their titles, the ex-Maharajah of Bharatpur continues to exert a regal influence over the affairs of his former state. 
 As India's leading political parties shift into gear for the forthcoming general election campaign, no fewer than three of the ex-Maharajah's once-royal relatives are jostling for the right to contest the Bharatpur seat. 
 The scramble for aristocratic advancement in this mixed constituency of prosperous urban merchants, ambitious Jat farmers and the inevitable hordes of illiterate villagers reflects a striking fact of political life in the royal Indian state of Rajasthan. 
 For all their cruel, corrupt and reckless vices, the Maharajahs were worshipped as gods by tens of thousands of their subjects. 
 They may have lost their feudal rights and their privy purses, but in many of these formerly-gilded princedoms there remains a powerful bond between ex-rulers and ex-ruled. 
 Several former Maharajahs or their relatives have entered Parliament as elected MPs. 
 In princely strongholds such as Jaipur, Udaipur, Jodhpur and Bharatpur, politicians of both ruling and opposition parties have been busily courting aristocratic support this year. 
 &bquo;The influence of the Maharajahs is probably not as great as they would like to think,&equo; observed a veteran republican in Bharatpur. 
 &bquo;But it is certainly important enough not to be ignored.&equo; 
 In Bharatpur, the competition between Rajiv Gandhi's ruling Congress (I) party and the assorted forces of the anti-Congress opposition is so finely poised, and the pool of royal admirers so deep, that three prominent relatives of Maharajah Brijendra Singh have slipped into a democratic version of an old autocratic vice: the royal family feud. 
 The sitting Bharatpur MP, K. Natwar Singh, is the grandson of the brother of a former Maharajah's wife. 
 Although he is a senior and successful Congress (I) figure, and is Minister of State for External Affairs, Mr Singh is being challenged for the ruling party's nomination by the present Maharajah's son, Vishwendra Singh. 
 An energetic and ambitious figure who was recently elected chairman of the local council, Vishwendra Singh has threatened to run independently if he is not selected. 
 Adding fuel to the fire is Deepa Kaur, the daughter of Rajah Man Singh, the Maharajah's late brother. 
 Behind Miss Kaur's prospective candidacy for the opposition Janata Dal party lies a family tragedy. 
 Her father was an eccentric, outspoken critic of the government, who was killed by police in 1985. 
 Enraged when supporters of a visiting Congress (I) chief minister tore down one of his family's red and yellow standards, the Rajah rammed the visitor's helicopter with his Jeep. 
 Police were sent to arrest him on a charge of attempted murder, but in the ensuing melee the Rajah was shot dead. 
 The death of the Rajah tainted the family's relationship with Natwar Singh and the Congress (I) party, and helped propel Miss Kaur into the opposition ranks. 
 Politicians on both sides in Bharatpur agree that if she is chosen as the Janata Dal candidate, she is certain to benefit from a sympathy vote, particularly in the nearby town of Deeg, where the Rajah died close to the extravagant summer palace formerly used by the family during monsoon months. 
 For the ordinary civilian politicians of Bharatpur, these complex family questions are tending to obscure what is looming as a tense election battle in a pivotal seat that both sides badly need to win. 
 The anti-Congress opposition won Bharatpur in 1967, lost it in 1971, won it again in 1977 and lost it again in 1980. 
 The seat is one of several in Rajasthan which the Janata Dal cannot afford to lose if the combined opposition forces are to oust Mr Gandhi from power. 
 Hoti Lal Parishar, the veteran chairman of the local Congress (I) committee, admits to some bemusement at the complications caused by Vishwendra Singh's challenge to the sitting MP. 
 &bquo;There is no reason why Mr Natwar Singh should leave, but we have some internal difficulties,&equo; he confessed. 
 &bquo;Some leaders are urging Vishwendra Singh to claim the ticket.&equo; 
 He added somewhat forlornly: &bquo;The Maharajahs are always arguing over very little things.&equo; 
 Mr Parishar is robustly confident that Congress (I) will regain the seat in any event. 
 That view is inevitably contested by Ram Kishen, 73, a socialist who won Bharatpur for the opposition in 1977, and who is a contender along with Miss Kaur for selection as candidate this year. 
 Mr Kishen prudently praised his royal rival, but he felt her appeal would be limited to Deeg and other rural areas where admiration for the ex-ruling family remains strong. 
 His own support, he asserted, was wider. 
 He agreed that without a friendly settlement of the candidate question and a unified opposition campaign, the Janata Dal could not hope to win. 
 Whoever ends up fighting the election, Mr Kishen suggested, royal parentage will not matter as much to Bharatpur voters as the government's abysmal record on rural development, inflation and corruption and its failure to fulfil promises made during the 1984 campaign. 
 Burmese hijackers free all hostages 
 From DENISE YOUNG of Reuters 
 U-TAPAO, Thailand &mdash; Hostages held by two students who hijacked a Burmese plane to Thailand were allowed to leave the plane one-by-one early this morning after an eight-hour drama, a Thai military official said. 
 The 50 passengers and crew were being let off the plane by the hijackers, who were armed with hand grenades, at intervals of seven minutes, the official added. 
 The first, wearing a traditional Burmese longyi, or sarong, and carrying an umbrella and a briefcase, was thoroughly searched by Thai security forces when he came down the plane steps. 
 Thai Deputy Prime Minister, Thienchai Sirisamphan, who held three rounds of negotiations with the hijackers, told reporters all the passengers were Burmese. 
 The domestic Burmese flight was hijacked shortly after taking off from Mergui in southern Burma, bound for Rangoon. 
 They had threatened to blow up the plane unless their demands for the release of political prisoners were met, but the deadline of 6pm passed without incident. 
 They demanded that the military government in Burma free all political prisoners, order troops back to barracks and lift an overnight curfew across the country. 
 Rangoon radio said the airliner was 20 minutes into its flight when it was taken over by what it called &bquo;terrorists disguised as passengers&equo;. 
 Thousands of Burmese students were rounded up, hundreds were killed and others fled after the military took power last September to crush a national uprising for democracy. 
 Foreign travel is restricted by the government, which has pursued an isolationist course for a generation. 
 Bonn may sell two submarines to Israelis 
 From CAROL BERGER in Cairo 
 WEST GERMAN companies, despite the country's long-term ban on selling weapons to the Middle East, are considering the sale of two advanced submarines to Israel, using an American firm as a go-between in the transaction. 
 Egyptian officials, who scrupulously monitor parity with Israel on weapons procurement programmes financed by Washington, are making enquiries in Bonn to determine whether the proposed sale will go ahead. 
 Contract discussions have been under way since early this year, according to West German sources. 
 But no one associated with the pending &dollar;500m (&pound;312m) sale would say whether the West German government has yet indicated its final approval. 
 The sale of the submarines to Israel would be technically in violation of strict West German export laws which prohibit military sales to zones of conflict. 
 On paper, however, the vessels would be on the order of the United States, enabling Israel to receive American financing and circumventing West German export restrictions. 
 An Egyptian military spokesman said the government had received no official notification of the reported negotiations on the sale, but is interested in obtaining further confirmation. 
 Egypt is the only Arab country to have signed a peace agreement with Israel. 
 Since the signing of the 1979 peace treaty, the US has sought to keep the military assistance component of its large foreign aid programme to Egypt and Israel on roughly equal terms. 
 Informed sources say that a sub-contract between an American company and the West Germans was signed in the US in mid-September. 
 Under the terms of the agreement, a consortium of the West German firms Howaldstwerke-Deutscheswerft (HDW) and Thyssen Nordsewerke is to supply two diesel-powered submarines to the US. 
 The sources said they understood the contract holder will be the US-based Ingalls Shipbuilding, a subsidiary of the defence conglomerate Litton Industries. 
 Ingalls has produced no submarines for more than 20 years. 
 A spokesman for the consortium lead firm, HDW in Kiel, confirmed that the contract for the two 1,550-tonne diesel-powered submarines had been signed. 
 Hans Saeger, the HDW submarine sales manager, expressed caution about the deal, saying that approval from the West German government was still being sought. 
 All German military exports must be approved by the Federal Security Council. 
 &bquo;In such a phase, where final decisions have not been taken, nobody can say anything is for sure,&equo; Mr Saeger said. 
 Robert Knapp, a spokesman for Litton Industries in the US, said: &bquo;We are not providing the submarines. 
 We will have a very minor role in that programme. 
 Ingalls will provide some contract support, but we will not be involved in the programme management, the engineering, material procurement or production.&equo; 
 On the West German law prohibiting military sales to zones of conflict, he said: &bquo;If such a law exists, it had no influence at all on our contractual relationship. 
 Our work with Israel is based purely on business considerations. 
 The submarine work is actually part of a much larger contract that we have with Israel to build three Corvettes for them, worth &dollar;300m (&pound;187m), at the Ingalls yards in Mississippi. 
 That sale is being made through the US government's foreign military sales programme. 
 I believe that means the US government has a role in its funding and in the contractual arrangements for the sale.&equo; 
 The West German vessel is considered the world's most sophisticated conventionally powered submarine, both in combat efficiency and &bquo;sustainability&equo; or battery storage capacity. 
 This enables underwater operation for long periods of time. 
 It is also well-suited for navigation in shallow seas. 
 The Dolphin-class submarine is considered a versatile platform for espionage activities, including violation of territorial lines, sensor laying, monitoring of underwater communications, interruption of communication signals and photography. 
 One Western military source said Israel's plans to acquire the submarines would &bquo;give impetus&equo; to Egyptian efforts to upgrade its anti-submarine capability. 
 Egypt's ageing fleet of 12 submarines is mostly composed of Chinese and Soviet-made Romeo-class vessels. 
 Egypt has requested financing for expensive refurbishment and modernisation from the United States, which provides some &dollar;1.6bn in military aid annually. 
 The US firm Tacoma Boat is in line to update two of the Egyptian navy's submarines with American components and financing. 
 The navy has also expressed its intention to purchase two derelict British-made Oberon submarines from the Immingham-based firm of Seaforth. 
 The two submarines were acquired by Seaforth through a Royal Navy disposal sale. 
 The 1960s vintage subs would require substantial refitting. 
 Two Swiss Red Cross workers kidnapped in Sidon 
 From CAROL BERGER in Cairo 
 A Muslim militiaman searches the boot of a car in Sidon yesterday after gunmen in the city kidnapped two Swiss Red Cross workers. 
 The abduction brings to 19 the number of Westerners missing and believed kidnapped in Lebanon  
 Red Cross officials seized in Lebanon 
 From ROBERT FISK in Beirut 
 ALLEGATIONS that the Swiss government failed to pay kidnappers for the release of an abducted Red Cross official in Sidon last year may lie behind the seizure yesterday of two more Swiss delegates of the International Red Cross. 
 The two men, Emmanuel Christen and Elio Erriquez, were kidnapped by two masked gunmen only 300 yards from the Ein Helweh Palestinian camp, where the Red Cross runs an artificial limb centre. 
 Other Red Cross workers saw Mr Christen standing with his hands in the air, holding in one of them an artificial limb, before the gunmen took him away. 
 But the latest abductions may also be a deliberate attempt to embarrass the Palestine Liberation Organisation which controls most of the Palestinian areas of Sidon. 
 Abu Nidal's Palestinian extremist group, which maintains a close association with the Shia Muslim Hizbollah holding most of the Western hostages in Lebanon, is the most likely culprit. 
 A presumed member of Hizbollah, Ali Mohamed Hariri, is in prison in Switzerland for the murder of a Frenchman on board an Air Afrique airliner during a hijack attempt which ended in Geneva in July 1987 &mdash; and Hariri's release is said here to have been part of the price which the Swiss government secretly agreed to pay for the release of Peter Winkler, the Red Cross official who was freed in Sidon 10 months ago. 
 Several Red Cross officials believed that the Swiss government had foolishly offered to trade Hariri for Mr Winkler and had then reneged on its promise. 
 The return of the kidnapping plague to Lebanon &mdash; albeit to Sidon, an area which lies outside the control of the Syrian army &mdash; has grave implications. 
 After Mr Winkler was released last December, the 31 Swiss Red Cross delegates were withdrawn from the country. 
 Unless the two men kidnapped yesterday are speedily released, it will be difficult for Michel Dufour, the chief ICRC delegate in Lebanon, to avoid taking the same decision once again. 
 The abductions have served to emphasise not only the anarchical state of Sidon itself, which has been the scene of five recent inter-Palestinian assassinations, but the vast Palestinian guerrilla presence in the city. 
 Up to 10,000 armed Palestinians live in Sidon and the surrounding hills, and the PLO is bound to be accused by its enemies of involvement in the kidnappings at the very moment when President Mubarak of Egypt is trying to involve PLO supporters in peace talks with Israel. 
 Only a day earlier, another pro-Palestinian group calling itself the &bquo;soldiers of justice&equo; - believed to be from Abu Nidal's organisation &mdash; had claimed responsibility in Beirut for the murder of the Belgian Jewish leader, Joseph Wybron. 
 Bush tripped up by Panama plot 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Washington 
 A MUDDLED response and ambivalent attitudes in the Bush administration contributed to the failure of Tuesday's Panamanian coup, US officials now concede. 
 Despite official denials, it appears the US did agree to play a limited, and deniable, role in the rebellion. 
 US officials place most of the blame for the debacle on half-cock rebel tactics, and a lack of adequate advance consultation with Washington. 
 But the White House Chief of Staff, John Sununu, has started an inquiry into the administration's performance in one of its first efforts in foreign policy crisis management. 
 The administration's enemies, both on the Democratic left and the Republican right, were still circling yesterday hoping to draw political blood. 
 In a speech to the Senate on Thursday night, Senator Jesse Helms compared the US performance to that of &bquo;the keystone cops&equo;. 
 President Bush defended his administration's cautious response, saying he had seen no facts since Tuesday which &bquo;would have made me make a different decision&equo;. 
 But the official version of events has already changed several times. 
 Three days after the coup, the provisional picture which has emerged from carefully phrased official clarifications, and unofficial leaks, is that the Bush administration did not initiate the rebellion but knew about it at least two days in advance and had promised, or at least hinted at, limited support. 
 It appears the US policy was to assist the coup if it appeared likely to succeed; but to back away as soon as it seemed doomed to fail. 
 According to The Wall Street Journal, Washington first heard about the coup plans from the wife of the rebel leader, Major Moises Giroldi, nearly three weeks ago. 
 Marlin Fitzwater, the White House spokesman, insisted yesterday that Mrs Giroldi first contacted US officials on Sunday night. 
 But Mr Fitzwater did confirm that US officials had spoken directly to her husband, something previously denied. 
 US officials say privately that Washington promised the rebels that American troops would block two key roads leading to the headquarters of the Panamanian Defence Forces (PDF). 
 The Defence Secretary, Dick Cheney, said yesterday that no formal pledge was given to the rebels but US troops were moved into place on both roads on Tuesday morning, ready to intervene if Washington decided that they should. 
 Military experts suggested yesterday that the US was hoping its troops would be attacked by the pro-Noriega forces, allowing Washington to claim that it was attacked first and forced to intervene. 
 In the event, the &bquo;loyal&equo; battallions took both the rebels and the US troops by surprise by using other roads, and possibly short-hop airlifts, to attack the rebels at army headquarters. 
 The coup leaders belatedly asked for additional US help. 
 Washington had still to respond when the coup petered out. 
 One theory is that the US was at a loss to know how to deal with the rebels becuase it had, indeed, been plotting a Panamanian coup, but not this coup. 
 Larry Birns, director of the Council on Hemispheric Affairs, quoting US government sources, said &bquo;the United States was conspiring with a different and more senior group of conspirators&equo;. 
 He said that Colonel Guillermo Wong, arrested by General Noriega after the rebellion failed, was part of the US plot, but not part of Tuesday's abortive coup. 
 This version of events is denied by the White House. 
 Another subject on which intense confusion remains is whether or not the US was ever offered a chance to apprehend General Noriega (wanted in Florida on drugs charges). 
 Senator Jesse Helms, the arch-conservative North Carolinian Republican, says he was told by the CIA, as well as sources within Panama, that the rebels did offer to surrender General Noriega to the US. 
 White House officials insist this is a misunderstanding; US interest in the coup evaporated rapidly when the rebels made it clear that they would not hand over Noriega. 
 Officials admit that the administration response was muddled but blame poor intelligence-gathering in Panama. 
 &bquo;This is our first blood-letting, if you will, our first real-time crisis operation,&equo; said an official. 
 Noriega threatens to fight &bquo;enemies within' 
 From CHRIS MCGREAL in Panama City 
 PANAMA'S military government yesterday stepped up its verbal assault against enemies at home and abroad after putting down a coup led by some of the country's most senior officers. 
 General Manuel Noriega's Justice and Interior Minister, Olmedo Mirando, said in an interview that he was going to &bquo;get rid of our enemies within the administration&equo;. 
 He went on: &bquo;They are a fifth column, and we cannot permit that. 
 We are going to change the law to allow us to get rid of people. 
 I do not want to say that we are going to get rid of everyone, only those who are our enemies. 
 People cannot be protected by the law when they are conspiring against the government.&equo; 
 Mr Mirando said that a government council had already overturned a law protecting diplomatic service personnel from dismissal. 
 On Thursday night more than 30 paramilitary thugs and soldiers ransacked the opposition coalition headquarters, where Guillermo Endara, the winner of May's annulled presidential election, was in the 16th day of a hunger strike. 
 Troops fired teargas and shots as they smashed their way in, beat reporters with rubber hoses and steel bars, confiscated camera equipment and stripped journalists of hundreds of dollars at gunpoint. 
 Yesterday Mr Endara, who had apparently been allowed to escape, took refuge in the Papal Nuncio's home. 
 &bquo;This hunger-striking buffoon sneaks out to eat so he can be well fed when he takes over the presidency, but he is screwed,&equo; General Noriega said of his opponent. 
 The military leader saved some of his most scathing remarks for the White House, which he said faced another &bquo;Bay of Pigs&equo;. 
 The 12,000 American troops in Panama remained on the highest state of alert and largely confined to their bases. 
 The crisis, ironically enough, coincided with the US military's &bquo;Hispanic Awareness Month&equo;. 
 Panamanian public opinion has shifted from disbelief to bitterness at the failure of the US to back the abortive coup. 
 Businessmen who support General Noriega have offered a &dollar;250,000 (&pound;156,000) reward for the assassination of six of the general's enemies, according to a letter published yesterday in a pro-government newspaper, AP reports. 
 The threats, presented as a letter from unnamed businessmen to a columnist of the Critica daily, could not immediately be confirmed. 
 Angola ceasefire &bquo;ready to sign&equo; 
 From PETER PRINGLE in Washington 
 SOME GENTLE arm-twisting from President Bush appeared yesterday to have persuaded the Angolan rebel leader, Jonas Savimbi, to accept a resumption of a ceasefire in the Angolan civil war, and to re-open the peace process with the Soviet-backed government in Luanda. 
 Zaire's President, Mobutu Sese Seko, said a ceasefire accord between the Angolan government and Mr Savimbi was ready to be signed. 
 &bquo;The ceasefire text is ready,&equo; Mr Mobutu told a news conference. 
 &bquo;It remains just to sign it. 
 When I return to my country I will start a discussion between the two parties.&equo; 
 Mr Mobutu said on Thursday he believed he could produce an agreement this month, after Mr Savimbi had had a week of talks with US officials, including 30 minutes with President Bush, and agreed to accept Mr Mobutu as mediator between his Unita guerrilla organisation and the Luanda government. 
 In two sessions, one with Mr Mobutu on Wednesday, and another with Mr Savimbi on Thursday, Mr Bush apparently persuaded both leaders to drop earlier disagreements and resume the negotiations to end Angola's 14-year civil war. 
 In making his diplomatic push, Mr Bush agreed to continue US support for Unita, which has been receiving a covert aid programme of between &dollar;40-&dollar;50m (&pound;25-&pound;30m) a year. 
 He also apparently succeeded in persuading Mr Mobutu to resume delivery of these military supplies to Unita through Zaire. 
 Mr Mobutu had cut the supply route after a dispute with Mr Savimbi. 
 The Angolan guerrillas refused to attend an 18 September meeting in Zaire to discuss the peace process, which started with a ceasefire last June. 
 But that ceasefire fell apart after Mr Savimbi learned that Mr Mobutu and seven other African leaders felt the Unita leader should go into &bquo;temporary and voluntary&equo; exile and integrate his Unita movement into Angola's single party Marxist-Leninist system. 
 Unita has been proposing a ceasefire followed by an interim coalition government and winner-take-all free elections. 
 The US supports Mr Savimbi's position. 
 A White House statement noted the United States' 'longstanding support for a ceasefire and face-to-face negotiations, and, ultimately free and fair elections'. 
 Mr Savimbi says he has no intention of going into exile, or of integrating his forces. 
 &bquo;Why are we going to surrender? 
 What is this reason?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;When we are strong why should we say we are going into exile, running away? 
 I am leaving behind my people who have fought a 14-year resistance; that would not be accepted. 
 That would not be reasonable.&equo; 
 Mr Savimbi said yesterday that he would meet Mr Mobutu &bquo;very soon&equo;, but set no specific date. 
 Menace in the air at capital's drug trial 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 AT one o'clock in the morning a petrol bomb shattered the window in Kathy Sellers' front room, shooting flames across the floor and up the curtains. 
 Ms Sellers was not at home. 
 She was under police custody waiting to continue her testimony against the man alleged to be Washington's most powerful drug lord, Rayful Edmond III. 
 Mr Edmond and 10 others are accused of running an extended &bquo;crew&equo; of drug dealers who controlled up to 40 per cent of the city's cocaine trade. 
 Security has been tight at the court, but there has been one threat against a juror, a bomb threat against the judge and now the firebombing directed at a key witness. 
 Mr Edmond has the dubious honour of being tried by the District of Columbia's first anonymous jury. 
 The courtroom itself was specially constructed with an inch-thick wall of bullet-proof glass to separate the principals in the case from reporters and spectators. 
 Last week Judge Charles Richey attempted to bar the public from the proceedings as a further security measure, but he was overruled by a higher court. 
 The Edmond family is reported to have been running crime rings, in a small way, for generations. 
 But since Rayful's father started him off in the business with a packet of cocaine from New York, prosecutors allege that Mr Edmond has built up a vast business concern, generating sales of up to &dollar;2m (&pound;1.25m) a week. 
 Police have linked the crew to 30 murders; Mr Edmond is charged with three. 
 &bquo;It resembled the structure of traditional organised crime, of La Cosa Nostra,&equo; said the prosecuting attorney Jay Stephens. 
 But the &bquo;godfather&equo; in this case is only 24 years old. 
 He allegedly became Washington's &bquo;Mr Big&equo; by finding a steady supplier in Los Angeles who could provide drugs in almost unlimited quantities. 
 Yesterday the jury donned headphones to begin listening to four months worth of FBI wiretaps of the Edmond headquarters. 
 The trial, in which 200 witnesses are due to testify, is expected to last another six weeks. 
 De Klerk to meet Tutu and Boesak 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 JOHANNESBURG (Reuter) &mdash; President FW de Klerk said yesterday that he would meet anti-apartheid churchmen &mdash; including Archbishop Desmond Tutu &mdash; next Wednesday, the first sign that he will live up to election promises of entering into talks with recognised black leaders. 
 The president of the World Alliance of Reformed Churches, Allan Boesak, and Frank Chikane, the secretary-general of the South African Council of Churches, will also attend the Pretoria meeting. 
 Archbishop Tutu said in a statement that he had asked to see the President in an effort to spell out what the white minority government must do to resolve South Africa's political crisis. 
 &bquo;Church leaders are convinced that (Mr de Klerk) does not appreciate the far-reaching nature of the steps he must take to get negotiations off the ground,&equo; the archbishop said. 
 &bquo;Negotiations which exclude the legitimate leaders of our people, which the government appears to be contemplating, will intensify, not resolve, our country's crisis.&equo; 
 He described himself and his colleagues as facilitators who would try to help create the climate for negotiations. 
 In a significant concession to the black union movement, the government yesterday granted permission for International Labour Day &mdash; 1 May &mdash; to be celebrated as a public holiday. 
 In the Garden Update: Prize fruit and veg 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 PRIZES will be awarded for the best carnations and bonsai at the Royal Horticultural Society's show in Greycoat Street, London SW1, to be held this Tuesday (11am-7pm, admission &pound;2.50) and Wednesday (10am-5pm, admission &pound;1.50). 
 There will also be displays of autumn fruit and vegetables. 
 In the Garden Update: Growing classes 
 Weekend Garden Page 43 
 In the Garden Update: Weekend work 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 SECATEURS are likely to be the tool most in demand now. 
 The summer's sprawl begins to be oppressive at this stage in the year and trigger fingers are itching to snip back overgrown mallows, clear out the mildewing foliage of golden rod and reduce the overpowering bulk of bullyboy ground cover. 
 Keep away from jasmine, already thick in flower bud, and clematis, however untidy. 
 Buddleias, although messy, should not be cut back until spring. 
 Dead, ragged heads of the climbing hydrangea can be removed, cutting where the stem joins the main branch. 
 Virginia creeper needs to be clipped back from windows and hauled out of gutters. 
 Mulching is a pleasant activity for October. 
 It can be done in spring too, but there are usually more pressing jobs then. 
 Shrubs such as hydrangea particularly relish rich rations. 
 It is a good time to plant hardy shrubs too. 
 Clematis so bristles with brittle green shoots in spring that planting then is an anxiety rather than a pleasure. 
 Runner beans and French beans have now given up completely and can be cleared off vegetable plots. 
 Globe artichokes are sprouting new leaves and may need protection from frost in cold areas. 
 Summer bedding is looking tired and should be removed so that the ground can be cleaned and fed ready for spring bulbs or wallflowers. 
 In the Garden: Planning to beat a leafy retreat at home: In the first of a series for novice gardeners, Anna Pavord stresses the value of careful forethought 
 By ANNA PAVORD 
 PLANTS should come a long way down the list of priorities for the novice gardener. 
 There are many things to think about before even the first tentative daffodil bulb is sunk into the ground. 
 The first and most important question to mull over as you gaze at your patch is: What is this garden for? 
 If you start writing down some of the responses to that question, you will find you have along the way acquired a ragbag of elements that will have an important bearing on the design. 
 If there are small children in the equation, there will need to be a flat, soft area where they can fall off swings and climbing frames. 
 If you like hanging out washing rather than drying it in the bowels of an expensive machine, you will need to tuck away a line and make a dry path to get to and from it. 
 Some novice gardeners may not want to do much actual gardening at all, but conversely, do not want to look out every day over a scene of threadbare grass and rotting fence. 
 Their ideal garden will look good and demand little attention. 
 If you are a dedicated sun-worshipper, you need to mark out the part of the garden where the sun lingers longest. 
 It may not be the part nearest the house, though this is where sitting out areas always tend to be made. 
 You may, even as a novice, care so passionately about plants that all you want is the maximum space to grow them in. 
 Raised beds built down an unpromising alley could provide extra gardening space. 
 Privacy is an important consideration. 
 A first time garden is usually small and certainly the typical one I am imagining for this series is no more than 40ft x 20ft and surrounded on all sides by other houses. 
 Privacy is a ticklish business where close neighbours are concerned. 
 To throw up an impenetrable Berlin Wall between you and them could be tactless. 
 Trellis is a useful compromise and you can always pretend it was forced on you by the speed of growth of your climbing rose. 
 Aesthetes among the novices will by now be thoroughly irritable and complaining that gardens should have as much to do with the soul as with the necessity or not of a washing line or a barbecue pit. 
 So they should, and when the list of necessities is securely written down, you can ask the second question: How do I want this garden to feel? 
 This question produces as varied a response as the first. 
 Some urban gardeners, as short of space inside as they are out, want their gardens to be extensions of their homes, with a great deal of hard paving, good furniture and lighting. 
 The garden for them should feel like an extra sitting room, gnat-ridden perhaps, damp occasionally, but an important overflow of living space. 
 Closet countrysiders may want to pretend their patch is actually a corner of some Sussex meadow and picture it swagged with honeysuckle and waving with ox-eye daisies and scabious. 
 This is a difficult trick to bring off with suburban trains hurtling by on one side and lorries grinding through their gears on the other. 
 A leafy retreat is an excellent goal for a small town garden, but it is best made acknowledging the urban setting, using un-wild plants such as bamboo, acanthus, fig, vine, alchemilla, euphorbia, wisteria. 
 While you are working through this process, take note of the features in the garden that you would like to keep. 
 On a new estate, there may be nothing. 
 In an old garden, there may be a fruit tree, or a good bulwark of evergreen laurel or box that, tidied up, could add a dash of venerability to the new garden that will emerge around it. 
 If you do not know what a tree or shrub is, exercise clemency and give it a year's grace to demonstrate its worth before you turn it over to the axeman. 
 The mood of the garden will dictate its eventual style. 
 It may be clipped classical, random cottage, modern high-tech, or some intensely personal vision of Byzantium, that no one has ever imagined before, but which exists in your head and wants to get out. 
 Do not let anybody, particularly gardening writers, tread on your dreams. 
 All this thinking and doodling will have done nothing physically to change the view outside the window, but it is a vital part of the gardening process. 
 Before you can make, you have to know what it is you are making. 
 In the Garden: Drawing the line at great design: Anna Pavord delves into a book that reveals the gardens architects have imagined could accompany their creations 
 By ANNA PAVORD 
 THE drawings of the Royal Institute of British Architects form one of the less well-known collections in London. 
 Architectural historians have already raided it to good effect, notably Mark Girouard for his book on the sixteenth-century architect Robert Smythson and Jill Lever, the curator of the collection, for the book she wrote with Margaret Richardson, The Art of the Architect. 
 Jane Brown is the latest to emerge triumphant from the RIBA library in Portman Square with The Art and Architecture of English Gardens (Weidenfeld &amp; Nicolson, &pound;40). 
 She looks at the collection with a view to its bearing on garden history. 
 Her book is not a comprehensive history of English garden design, but a much chancier, though equally delightful narrative depending for its emphasis on what happened to find its way into the collection. 
 These quirks of fate, combined with Jane Brown's own enthusiasms (she is the author of a fine book on the Lutyens-Jekyll partnership) have resulted in a narrative in which the gardens of the Arts and Crafts movement, a relatively short period between 1890-1914, get twice the space of the gardens of either the eighteenth or the nineteenth century. 
 This is fine by me. 
 The talented crew of Voysey, Newton, Baillie Scott, who created the beautifully put together houses of that period, evidently also had the gift of persuasively selling their ideas. 
 Who could have resisted Charles Voysey's design for Oakhurst, Ropes Lane, Fernhurst in Sussex? 
 A pool of blue scillas lies to the left of an entrance through yew hedges. 
 The house is softened by sprawls of climbing roses. 
 Hollyhocks and wallflowers tower over the gaily filled flower border. 
 His client, Mrs Chester, sensibly did not resist and the house was built in 1901. 
 Oliver Hill's plan (1913) for the paving of the water garden at Moor Close, Binfield, Berkshire, shows staggering attention to detail. 
 Red tile set on edge was to be used for the centrepiece, Portland stone for the surround, brown pebble paving for an infill, blue and white pebbles to make a star design, white marble for the path through the pergola. 
 The plan, beautifully drawn and lettered, as are all the plans of this period, is particularly poignant. 
 No architect gardeners came this way again. 
 The story told in Jane Brown's book does not end with the Arts and Crafts movement, however. 
 It continues with the relatively little known work of the Modern Movement, curtailed by the war, through the idealistic beginnings of the Span housing estates in the mid-Fifties, to Sir Geoffrey Jellicoe's plan, now being executed, for the Moody Botanic Gardens at Galveston, Texas. 
 Sixteen drawings for this massive project form the book's final chapter &bquo;Towards the 21st Century&equo;. 
 After this chronological march through the archives, Jane Brown devotes the second part of her weighty book to the delightfully rich seam of garden buildings and ornament designed over the last 400 years. 
 Here is Sir Jeffry Wyatville's design for a Swiss Cottage to be built at the Duke of Bedford's rural retreat, Endsleigh, Devon. 
 The &bquo;bijou rustic pavilion&equo; as he describes it, still survives and has recently been restored by the Landmark Trust. 
 Here too is Lutyens's design for a fowl house, a wooden building perched on staddle stones with lantern and a thatched roof, a residence to please the most demanding chicken. 
 Architectural drawings may seem dry fodder to provide the stuff of an exciting book. 
 Jane Brown's gift is to vault the divide that has unfortunately grown up between architects and the rest of us and bring their drawings alive in the most agreeable and informative way. 
 One does not always agree with her. 
 She commends Barry for &bquo;his ability to build well and to last&equo;, but Barry's work at Kingston Lacey in Dorset and elsewhere was outrageously shoddy. 
 She credits the Crystal Palace built by Joseph Paxton for the Great Exhibition in 1851 as the inspiration for later conservatories and &bquo;the whole future of growing plants indoors&equo;. 
 The revolution in glasshouses had surely started rather earlier than that with the radical design built in 1820 by W&amp;D Bailey of Holborn for Lady Rolle at Bicton in Devon. 
 But these are quibbles, and in no way detract from Jane Brown's achievement. 
 This is a fascinating book. 
 Court Circular 
 By ANNA PAVORD 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 6 October: Brigadier RW Morris (Representative Honorary Colonel of the Royal Australian Army Ordnance Corps) and Mrs Morris had the honour of being received by The Queen. 
 The Duke of Edinburgh was represented by the Countess Mountbatten of Burma at the Memorial Service for Marjorie, Countess of Brecknock, which was held in the Guards Chapel, today. 
 The Duke of Edinburgh was represented by Mr Peter Coni at the Memorial Service for Mr Thomas Keller which was held in St Peter's Church, Zurich, this afternoon. 
 6 October: The Duke of York, Trustee, this evening attended the 10th Anniversary Dinner of the Friends of Lakefield College School at the Cavalry and Guards Club, Piccadilly, London W1. 
 6 October: The Prince Edward, Chairman of The Duke of Edinburgh's Award Special Projects Group, this evening attended receptions in Edinburgh at the New Club and at the Dominion Cinema. 
 His Royal Highness was received on arrival by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for the City of Edinburgh (Mrs Eleanor McLaughlin, the Right Hon the Lord Provost) and was attended by Major William McLean. 
 6 October: The Princess Royal today visited Avon, and was received on arrival by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Avon (Sir John Wills Bt). 
 Her Royal Highness, Patron, The Home Farm Trust, visited the Home Farm Trust's Registered Office, Merchants House North, Wapping Road, Bristol. 
 The Princess, President of the Missions to Seamen, then visited the Avonmouth International Seafarers' Centre, Gloucester Road, Avonmouth. 
 In the afternoon Her Royal Highness, Patron of The Butler Trust, visited HM Prison Leyhill, Wotton under Edge. 
 Afterwards The Princess, President of the Save the Children Fund, attended a reception with employees of Halifax Property Services, and opened their Headquarters building at Great Weston Business Park, Yate, Bristol. 
 This evening The Princess Royal, President of the Save the Children Fund, attended a reception at Chavenage House, Tetbury, in celebration of the Fund's 70th Anniversary, and was received on arrival by Colonel David Lowsley-Williams (Deputy Lieutenant of Gloucestershire). 
 Mrs Richard Carew Pole was in attendance. 
 The Princess Royal, President, Federation Equestre Internationale, was represented by Mr Rene Ziegler (Director, Federation Equestre Internationale) at the Memorial Service for Mr Thomas Keller (President of the International Rowing Federation and GAISF Honorary President) which was held in St Peter's Church, Zurich, this afternoon. 
 KENSINGTON PALACE 6 October: The Prince of Wales, President, Business in the Community, held a meeting with members of Business in the Community which was followed by a luncheon at the Palace of Holyroodhouse. 
 His Royal Highness, attended by Mr Guy Salter, travelled in the Royal Train. 
 6 October: The Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon this afternoon visited Up Hatherley, Cheltenham, and was received on arrival at Staverton Airport by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Gloucestershire (Colonel Martin Gibbs). 
 Her Royal Highness was present at a Service at the Church of St Philip and St James during the Parish Preaching Mission. 
 The Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon who travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight, was attended by Mrs Jane Stevens. 
 6 October: The Duchess of Gloucester, Colonel-in-Chief, The Royal Army Educational Corps, this evening attended the Officers' Annual Dinner at Eltham Palace, London SE9. 
 Mrs Howard Page and Major Nicholas Barne were in attendance. 
 Princess Alice, Duchess of Gloucester, was represented by Major Nicholas Barne at the Memorial Service for Marjorie, Countess of Brecknock, which was held in the Guards Chapel today. 
 The Duke and Duchess of Kent were represented by Captain the Honourable Christopher Knollys at the Memorial Service for Marjorie, Countess of Brecknock which was held in the Guards Chapel, today. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Princess Royal, Patron, The British Nutrition Foundation, today visits the Foundation's Conference for Teachers of Nutrition at Exeter Court Hotel, Kenford, Exeter, Devon; as President, The Save the Children Fund, visits the Save the Children Fund Shop, 17 Paris Street, Exeter, Devon; and, as President, the British Academy of Film and Television Arts, attends and presents the Annual Tribute Award at the Odeon, Leicester Square, London W1. 
 Princess Margaret, Patron of the Halle Concerts Society, tomorrow attends a performance by the Halle Orchestra at Henbury Hall, Macclesfield. 
 The Duke of Gloucester, President, British Consultants Bureau, tomorrow accompanies a mission to Portugal. 
 Faith and Reason: We know only that God is a mystery: In the fourth article in our series on the mutability of God, Herbert McCabe OP argues that neither change nor stasis are applicable to God's &bquo;human&equo; suffering 
 By HERBERT MCCABE OP 
 THE MUDDLES all come from thinking you could have a better idea of God or a worse one or any idea of God at all. 
 In Jewish, Christian and Islamic tradition the word &bquo;God&equo; is used for God not because its meaning is thought to correspond to the nature of God, but simply as a convenient label for the ultimate, altogether incomprehensible mystery because of which things exist instead of there not being anything at all. 
 This is not, of course, the only or the first or the commonest use of the word; we have borrowed it from people who believe in gods. 
 In our tradition we think it appropriate, and indeed urgent, to ask the vertiginous question about Creation: &bquo;Why is there anything instead of nothing?&equo; 
 If it is sensible to ask this question it has an answer &mdash; even though we have not the faintest idea what that answer is &mdash; we simply label it &bquo;God&equo;. 
 What are called &bquo;proofs for the existence of God&equo; are not attempts to show that there must be a divine kind of thing (we have no concept of a divine kind of thing), they just seek to show that if and when all other questions were answered we would still be left with this mystery: and this is what we shall call &bquo;God&equo;. 
 We know of innumerable kinds of things that could not possibly be the answer to our question; we know, then, what God is not, but nothing at all of what God is. 
 We know some things about what God does, for once we recognise that there is this mystery we recognise that all that is is God's doing &mdash; though we have no understanding of what it is for God to &bquo;do&equo;. 
 Faith, moreover, means that we are sure that God speaks to us. 
 In hearing that word we recognise yet more astounding things that God does &mdash; like summoning us to share in the mystery of his own life. 
 Yet more astonishingly we learn that the word of God is made flesh and is one of us and that God himself is tortured to death and that through our suffering and death we can share in God's suffering and thereby, in some utterly incomprehensible way, in his life. 
 It is this sharing in the suffering of God that is so convincingly and magnificently expressed in Margaret Spufford's recent book, Celebration. 
 It is, however, central to the Christian tradition that the suffering of God is the human suffering of the cross. 
 It is historical and of our world. 
 The suffering of God is not incomprehensible &mdash; except in the weaker sense that all human life is incomprehensible by contrast, say, with crystals or tides. 
 The suffering of God is not eternal and infinite; it is human and limited and the same kind of suffering as that of Auschwitz or of cerebral meningitis. 
 We can at least begin to understand the human life and affection and anger and doubts and suffering and death of God in a way that we could not possibly begin to understand what it means for him to be God. 
 The muddled thinking that makes us claim at least some vague idea of what God is leads us disastrously to thinking that if we say God cannot be one kind of thing we must be saying he is the other. 
 But if we (rightly) say that God has to be unchangeable we do not mean he is static any more than if we say &bquo;The Equator&equo; is not the name of a poison we mean that it is safe to eat it. 
 Neither change nor stasis, in any sense we could possibly understand, can have any application to whatever it is we label &bquo;God&equo;. 
 If we were to use the word &bquo;God&equo; to mean something subject to change we would have ceased to use it in the Jewish-Christian-Islamic sense to refer to the mystery of Creation. 
 What we spoke of would be a part of, an inhabitant of, the changing inter-acting universe and not the source of all meaning and being. 
 Of course there are, and ought to be, a thousand images of God in which we represent him as changing his mind, forgetting, being angry, being him, doing all kinds of creaturely things; our language of worship, of gratitude for existence, has to be full of such metaphors and images; we must take these metaphors seriously, but if we take them literally, if we mistake these images for God, we are idolaters. 
 The genius of the Council of Chalcedon, in saying that Jesus is one person in both divine and human natures, was that it denied that the incarnation implied anything about the nature of God (the meaning of &bquo;God&equo;), asserting simply that God, the mystery of Creation, is become a human being &mdash; not a divine kind of human being but a human kind of human being. 
 It is the mystery of Creation, the God of all Jews not some new &bquo;Christian&equo; God, the God who is not a god but the mystery at the centre of all being who transcends all beings, He who Is, that hung in torment from the cross and died. 
 In the mainstream Christian tradition it is the human suffering of God (of God, not some limited, changeable, process-god) that redeems our agonised world. 
 It is not, however, precisely by suffering as such that this redemption is brought about. 
 (I am about to re-read Celebration to see whether Dr Spufford ever really suggests any such thing.) 
 We are saved through the loving obedience of Jesus which is not just a mental state but is expressed and only could be expressed in bodily pain and death. 
 The world is redeemed because of the sanctity of this man Jesus, because of the love for his Father and for his sisters and brothers which made him totally accept his mission from the Father. 
 He was sent to be, commanded to be, the first completely human being, the first to be wholly at one with the human race, to be, therefore, wholly at risk from us, to be the victim, the scapegoat on whom we could project our guilt and our fear of being human, of being loved. 
 His willingness to accept violation and destruction at our hands out of love for us the loving obedience to his Father is the darkness of the aboriginal prayer, the prayer that makes sense of any other prayer, the mystery of hope at the heart of hopelessness that Dr Spufford refers to in the death of Robert Aske. 
 This is the inarticulate prayer that is answered (we read in Philippians) in the resurrection, the redemption of all human suffering, of all mortality. 
 The prayer of Jesus from the heart of the suffering world is not something in the mind, it is his accepted bodily agony and it is by being given the grace to accept our material weakness and pain and finally our death in union with him that we too can pray. 
 That is why the prayer of the Church as such, the Eucharistic meal which expresses and celebrates joyfully the community of the Church and the ultimate unity of humankind is the sacrament of bodily suffering, of the sacrificial death of Christ at our hands. 
 It is the sign of our redeemed and forgiven sin in being the sacrament of our unity in love. 
 For it was on the night he was betrayed that he took bread and broke it and said: &bquo;This is my body for you&equo;. 
 Obituary: Witold Rowicki 
 By RICHARD BERNAS 
 ONE OF the finest conductors of his generation, Witold Rowicki had the good fortune to play a central role in his country's musical reconstruction after the Second World War. 
 In 1945 the newly formed Communist government appointed him head of music for Polish radio, based in the southern city of Katowice. 
 There Rowicki created the Polish Radio Symphony Orchestra, building it from scratch and directing it for the next five years. 
 He then moved on to Warsaw where he undertook an even more arduous task, that of reconstructing the Warsaw Philharmonic and supervising the rebuilding of its concert hall from the musical and acoustic standpoint. 
 At the inauguration of the hall in 1955, Rowicki's orchestra was officially renamed the National Philharmonic. 
 With the exception of three years in the mid-Fifties, Rowicki continued as its artistic director and principal conductor until 1977. 
 For a short period from 1952 to 1954 he was Professor of Conducting at the Warsaw Conservatoire. 
 From 1965 to 1970 Rowiecki also served as musical director of the Theatr Wielki, Warsaw's huge opera and ballet theatre, and presided over the opening performance of the reconstructed building in 1965, conducting Moniuszko's Straszny Dwor (' The Haunted House', a characteristically Polish mix of folklore and Bellinian melody). 
 But the exigencies of operatic life did not really appeal to one of his perfectionist standards. 
 He preferred touring with his orchestra and, increasingly, guest conducting abroad. 
 In London he appeared with the Philharmonia, RPO and LSO (with whom he recorded all the Dvorak symphonies), and he also worked with the Vienna Philharmonic, Cleveland Orchestra and Orchestre de Paris. 
 It is as an advocate of twentieth-century music that Rowicki may best be remembered. 
 Building on the Warsaw Philharmonic's pre-war advocacy of such Polish composers as Szymanowski (of whose Third Symphony and ballet Harnasie he made particularly strong recordings), Rowicki moulded the orchestra into a responsive vehicle for an exceptionally talented native generation: collaborations with Penderecki, Gorecki, Lutoslawski and a dozen other composers were a regular feature of the National Philharmonic's concert season and not just confined to the Warsaw Autumn festival of contemporary music. 
 Rowicki's early training reflected this. 
 Although he took his diploma from the Krakow Conservatoire in violin, he studied composition there as well and a number of works, including a symphony (1957) and a concerto for orchestra (1976) to his credit. 
 Of his study visits to pre-war Vienna, his strongest memories were not of virtuosos but of composers conducting, notably Richard Strauss directing his operas and Anton Webern the symphonies of Mahler. 
 As with Hermann Scherchen and Hans Rosbaud in Germany, contemporary music was nothing unusual, but rather an integral part of his repertoire. 
 In rehearsal Rowicki's method was one of a patient but relentless taskmaster. 
 He never rehearsed the performance, but rather the technique of the music, leaving his emotional response to the inspiration of the concert and expecting a well-prepared orchestra to be entirely responsive to this. 
 Working with an ensemble he had built in a hall whose construction he had supervised, he could afford to be as relaxed as he wished, and also as demanding. 
 Rehearsals for important premieres, such as the first Polish performance of Shostakovich's Fourteenth Symphony at an inaugural concert of the Warsaw Autumn, could take many weeks. 
 I remember a short, rhythmically complex passage patiently unpicked and reconstituted over half an hour. 
 After what seemed its thirty-fifth repetition, Rowicki put down his baton, looked up and spoke to the ceiling in a low-pitched, conversational tone: &bquo;Everyone can now play this correctly except Mr X&equo; (the fourth inside desk cellist). 
 The ceiling obviously had a word with Mr X, who was note perfect the next day. 
 Appointments 
 Gazette Page 18 
 Anniversaries 
 By RICHARD BERNAS 
 On this day: the Battle of Lepanto was fought, 1571; The Independent was first published, 1986. 
 Today is the Feast Day of St Artaldus or Arthaud, St Helan of Cornwall, St Justina of Padua, St Mark, pope, and St Osyth. 
 On this day: King's College, London, was opened, 1831; Charles Nessler first used a permanent waving machine on a woman's hair, 1905; Britain's tallest building, the Post Office Tower in London, opened, 1965; Britain's first legal commercial radio station, LBC, started transmitting, 1973. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 18 
 Obituary: Jacques Doniol-Valcroze (CORRECTED) 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 Correction (published 9 October 1989) incorporated into this article. 
 AS A FILM-MAKER, Jacques Doniol-Valcroze was only a minor member of the nouvelle vague but by virtue of being &mdash; with Andre Bazin &mdash; the founder and editor of Cahiers du Cinema he was one of the driving forces behind the movement. 
 He had already edited several popular movie magazines, but it was because of Bazin's reputation as a theoretician that this new one, more highbrow, attracted from its first publication in 1951 a group of young, enthusiastic and iconoclastic critics. 
 By the middle of the decade, they had formulated their auteur theory, which gave a new gloss to film studies. 
 They claimed that the director was the sole author of his films, and that the more strongly his personality and preoccupations were found in them, the greater he was. 
 With the exception of Hitchcock, whom they worshipped, they had little time for accepted and acclaimed directors, finding more value in the more commercial movies of, for instance, Howard Hawks and Raoul Walsh. 
 With a vigour amounting to tactlessness they put dissension and argument into film debate, too long overshadowed by blind acceptance of yesteryear's taste. 
 It took as long again for their theories to be discredited, despite the fact that almost none of their Hollywood idols would agree that they were the sole auteur of the films they made; while the greatest weakness of their belief was that the most flawed work by one of their preferred film-makers was of more interest than a major piece by one of those they did not rate. 
 Years later one of Cahiers' most influential critics, Jean-Luc Godard, admitted that none of them had really believed in the theory, but had used it to draw attention to themselves. 
 Along with Francois Truffaut, Claude Chabrol and other contributors, he became a director himself, and the brilliance of their early work was one of the reasons their views became so firmly enshrined. 
 Both as critics and film-makers their creed was so consistent as to encourage producers to contact any of their colleagues, and after the international success of such films as A Bout de Souffle, Hiroshima Mon Amour and Les Quatre Cents Coups, Doniol-Valcroze was able to make his feature debut in 1960 with L'Eau a la Bouche. 
 It was, alas, only too derivative, but given its auteur's antecedents everyone was prepared to give him a second chance. 
 Like his peers, he had already &mdash; since 1955 &mdash; been making shorts: unlike the most celebrated of them, he was to prove only moderately talented. 
 Indeed, only the first of the seven features Doniol-Valcroze made was shown publicly in this country. 
 He also published a novel, acted in movies and assisted on the screen plays of others; but he did not direct again after 1974, perhaps because a much-anticipated family saga, La Maison des Bories, reveals many of the faults of those film-makers swept away by the nouvelle vague, and none of the movement's freshness. 
 This last quality was, however, manifest in his second (and best) film, Le Coeur Battant (1961), a witty and enchanting comedy about a couple in a small seaside resort &mdash; she (Francoise Brion) waiting for her lover to arrive and he (Jean-Louis Trintignant) gradually falling in love with her but refusing to admit it even to himself. 
 With the possible exception of Louis Malle, none of that generation of French movie-makers was too happy with more grandiose material: sitting through some of Doniol-Valcroze's later films, one longed more and more for the simplicity of that one. 
 Council inquiry 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 (First Edition) Two senior council officers were suspended on full pay pending an inquiry into a chain of consultancy companies they set up on public health, waste management, food hygiene and urban renewal. 
 Frank Reynolds, 57, head of Birmingham City Council's health department and his deputy, Keith Hunter, face disciplinary proceedings. 
 Benefit cash 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 Spending on cash benefits for long-term sick and disabled people now totals &pound;7.3bn, a 90 per cent increase in real terms since 1978-79, Nicholas Scott, Minister for the Disabled, said. 
 Heart first 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 A 43-year-old man underwent the first heart transplant operation at the London Hospital, Whitechapel. 
 The operation was performed by a surgical team led by Mr Alan Wood. 
 MP to retire 
 Home News Page 2 
 Man dies in blast 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 An investigation is under way into an gas explosion at a block of flats in Dagenham, east London, in which a man died. 
 Police said that although the explosion was not thought to have been an accident no one was being sought. 
 Party conference 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 Plans to prevent acid house parties in the South-east were drawn up at a meeting of senior police officers and council leaders. 
 Policemen from Kent, Sussex, and London met representatives from every council in Kent in Sevenoaks. 
 Short measures 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 Only one out of 208 pints served in 104 pubs, clubs and restaurants in Birmingham came up to a full measure, trading standards officers disclosed. 
 Investigators said 170 complaints were made resulting in 39 prosecutions. 
 Met Office move 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 The Meteorological Office, at Bracknell, Berkshire, is to become an executive agency in April 1990 under the Government's Next Steps Initiative, Michael Neubert, Minister for Defence Procurement, said. 
 Hostage pledge 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 John Major, the Foreign Secretary, promised to keep the Lebanon hostages &bquo;high on the public agenda&equo; after attending a memorial service for the mother of the missing British journalist John McCarthy. 
 Mr Major and a number of diplomats joined the Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Robert Runcie, and Mr McCarthy's family and friends at the service for Sheila McCarthy, 66, who died in July. 
 Warning on health food 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 A food supplement sold in health food stores could cause kidney damage, the Department of Health warned. 
 Tests on products containing germanium showed there was a risk. 
 The products were supposed to speed up blood-flow to make people feel more alert. 
 The department said: &bquo;We have no evidence to show that germanium has any nutritional value or is beneficial.&equo; 
 Accused &bquo;told to use M50&equo; 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 The father of the man accused of the M50 murder told a jury yesterday he advised his son to use the motorway on the day that pregnant housewife Marie Wilks vanished. 
 Edward Browning, a night club bouncer, called at his father's home shortly before setting off for Scotland. 
 He says he travelled north by going across the Severn Bridge on to the M4. 
 Shrewsbury Crown Court heard that the two men discussed no other topics and Browning, 36, left. 
 The trial continues on Monday. 
 Ambulance service inquiry into deaths 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT, Labour Editor 
 THE LONDON Ambulance service, hardest hit by the national overtime ban, is to investigate two deaths last week which may have been caused by staff shortages. 
 Leaders of ambulance crews argue that their industrial action, in protest at a 6.5 per cent pay offer, has exposed the lack of personnel which may have been responsible for the deaths. 
 The fatalities were in the London area and involved collapses. 
 Both involved a delay of about an hour, and in the second case an officer was forced to go in a staff car to attend the patient. 
 A London Ambulance Service spokesman said: &bquo;We are aware of the two cases where people died and they are being investigated to discover what happened.&equo; 
 Stuart Barber, the National Union of Public Employees' ambulance official for London, said: &bquo;The work-to-rule has exposed the chronic staffing problems in the London Ambulance Service where there are over 160 vacancies.&equo; 
 Ambulance crews have been warned by their unions to keep a dossier of all delays because of the risk of litigation and possible disciplinary action. 
 Meanwhile, representatives of management have agreed to meet officials of Acas, the conciliation service, next week &mdash; possibly on Tuesday. 
 Managers will be responding to points made to Acas officials yesterday at a briefing session involving union officers. 
 A Department of Health spokesman said, however, there was little immediate hope that the dispute, now in its third week, would be resolved. 
 At the Conservative Party conference in Blackpool next week, ministers will face a persistent, vociferous and potentially embarrassing lobby by ambulance union representatives. 
 Roger Poole, and other leaders of the overtime ban, have vowed to do whatever they can to force a face-to-face confrontation with Kenneth Clarke, Secretary of State for Health, who has refused to countenance a meeting. 
 &bquo;We shall go to the conference anyway and if necessary catch him in his pyjamas in his hotel room,&equo; Mr Poole said. 
 Emergency services could face additional problems over the next few days - the first weekend that ambulance officers have been involved in the action. 
 Nuns end their hen house occupation 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT, Labour Editor 
 Six nuns from the Our Lady of the Passion monastery at Daventry end their hen house occupation to prevent the slaughter of 5,000 hens thought to be infected with salmonella. 
 The nuns say there is insufficient evidence that the chickens carry the virus. 
 Ministers prepare to attack &bquo;myth&equo; of new Labour image 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correspondent 
 A TWO-PRONGED counter-offensive is to be launched next week against Labour at the Conservative Party conference by Cabinet ministers, with a series of announcements and an attempt to explode the &bquo;myth&equo; of Labour's new image. 
 Ministers will also be seeking to lift sagging Tory morale, by offering assurances on a range of issues, which promise to make this one of the most difficult annual conferences the party leadership has faced since Margaret Thatcher came to office. 
 While the Labour conference was taking place the Prime Minister had a trial run with the televising of Parliament. 
 Commons sources confirmed that on Thursday Mrs Thatcher stood at the despatch box with a television monitor nearby to see how she appeared on television in the chamber. 
 Her advisers are expected to groom her in adapting her Commons performances at Prime Minister's question time to television coverage. 
 The same day ministerial aides met to co-ordinate the attack on Labour. 
 One source said: &bquo;Our blood is up. 
 We are angry at the way Labour is being presented and we are going to go for them.&equo; 
 Underlining government irritation with the success of Labour's presentation, some aides privately are complaining, for the first time in many years, about Labour bias in the Press. 
 Chris Patten, Secretary of State for the Environment, will lead the Government's fight-back, by announcing a compromise over the poll tax to allay Conservative grassroots concern about the effects of the &bquo;safety net&equo; under which Tory areas subsidise Labour-dominated inner cities. 
 Mr Patten will also outline the forthcoming &bquo;green Bill&equo;, underlining the Government's commitment to environmental protection in the wake of his decision to reject a proposal for a new town at Foxley Wood, Hampshire. 
 Norman Fowler, Secretary of State for Employment, is planning to couple announcements about further trade union legislation in the next session of Parliament with an attack on Labour's plans for restoring rights to trade unions, including the right to carry out a form of secondary, &bquo;sympathy' action. 
 Party leaders aim to lift sagging morale by attacking Labour's successful conference week as a public relations exercise masterminded by Peter Mandelson, the party's director of campaigns and communications. 
 Ministers will insist that, despite the image management, the party remains dominated by the left. 
 Nicholas Ridley, Secretary of State for Trade and Industry, will open the attack on Neil Kinnock, the Labour leader today with a warning that the party could revert to its left-wing image, if it were elected. 
 Kenneth Clarke, Secretary of State for Health, will offer reassurances on the changes to the National Health Service, with a strong defence of the policies for allowing hospitals to opt out, establishing an internal market and giving GPs practice budgets. 
 Michael Heseltine, the former Secretary of State for Defence, is the voters' favourite to succeed Mrs Thatcher, according to an opinion poll published in The Daily Telegraph today. 
 Mrs Thatcher will deliver a major speech on the environment to the United Nations General Assembly, when she visits New York next month. 
 It will be her first speech to the assembly for four years. 
 Engineering firms to quash levy collection 
 By HELEN HAGUE, Labour Correspondent 
 ENGINEERING employers are mounting a tactical offensive to cripple the union selective strike campaign aimed at winning an industry-wide hours cut for two million workers. 
 The strategy, outlined in an internal document from the Engineering Employers Federation, centres on quashing workplace collection of a voluntary levy to fund the strikes. 
 The disclosure comes as Rolls-Royce, one of four blue-chip companies selected for strike ballots at key sites in two weeks, said there would be lay-offs and redundancies among its 37,000 workforce if action goes ahead. 
 Nearly 5,000 Rolls-Royce workers at Glasgow and Coventry are among 24,000 who will vote on whether to strike, so spearheading the campaign to cut the working week from 39 hours to 35. 
 Other companies in the front line are British Aerospace, Smiths Industries and NEI. 
 The leaked federation document, from Ian Hughes, its director in Yorkshire and Humberside, shows the employers' strategy as agreed by the federation management board three weeks ago. 
 In a letter to chief executives, he reports there was a unanimous view that the success of the Confederation of Shipbuilding and Engineering Unions' campaign, and its ability to sustain industrial action &bquo;will depend significantly on the success of the levy&equo;. 
 Therefore &bquo;all federated companies have a duty to see that the collection of the fund is made as difficult as possible for the CSEU&equo;. 
 The voluntary levy has raised &pound;2m so far and unions have pledged a further &pound;7m to enable payouts of at least &pound;100 a week to be made to those called out on strike. 
 Last night, Roger Lyons, assistant general secretary of the white-collar union MSF, accused the federation of &bquo;sending out secret missives to chief executives instructing them to sabotage a democratically-determined voluntary levy&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;The letter suggests the employers have got a spy network in place, indicating they are in a state of war with their own workers. 
 This displays an attitude that the employers are not interested in a constructive settlement.&equo; 
 Rolls-Royce wrote personally to all its employees yesterday claiming that either a strike or a cut to a 35-hour week would be &bquo;disastrous&equo; for the company. 
 Treasury rejects appeal for more CTC funds 
 By NGAIO CREQUER and HELEN HAGUE 
 THE TREASURY is refusing to fund a further phase of the city technology colleges. 
 Plans for the creation of 20 CTCs by 1990 were announced by Kenneth Baker, the then Secretary of State for Education and Science, at the Conservative Party conference in October 1986. 
 They were to be a new form of secondary school &mdash; &bquo;beacons of excellence&equo; &mdash; funded mainly by industry, and would concentrate on science and technology. 
 But the Government has been severely embarrassed by the burgeoning cost of the programme. 
 Mr Baker had said that industrial sponsors would pay &bquo;all or a substantial part&equo; of the capital costs. 
 The lack of sponsors has meant the taxpayer has had to foot more of the bill. 
 The Department of Education and Science said yesterday that the Government had spent &pound;19.7m on CTCs and there was a further planned expenditure over the next three years of &pound;106.2m. 
 So far industry had contributed &pound;44m. 
 Sir Cyril Taylor, the Government's adviser on CTCs, who had earlier been successful in persuading Mr Baker to commit more government funds to the 20 schools, had been hoping to get more money for a new round of schools. 
 But sources have confirmed that this has been ruled out by the Treasury in the current round of public expenditure talks. 
 But yesterday, Susan Fey, of the CTC Trust, said, &bquo;We were only ever given a target of 20. 
 We have never been to Treasury to ask for funds for more than 20. 
 Of course there have been discussions between the Trust and civil servants but nothing has gone to PESC (the expenditure talks).&equo; 
 Although Sir Cyril had spoken in January 1988 about &bquo;hundreds&equo; of CTCs, these would be funded by local education authorities. 
 Jack Straw, Labour's shadow education secretary said yesterday at the Labour Party conference that the news to abandon further CTCs marked &bquo;the death of an expensive corrupt fiasco, which has already cost the taxpayer millions&equo;. 
 &bquo;But so rotten has the policy proved that not even a &bquo;taxpayer bail-out&equo; could save it. 
 Indeed even Britain's blue chip businesses boycotted the scheme despite being put under intense personal and political pressure,&equo; he added. 
 Mr Straw said this involved &bquo;veiled threats if they did not cough up and clear promises of honours if they did&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;What is so appalling is that millions of pounds which should have been invested in children's education has been squandered in pursuit of electoral advantage.&equo; 
 He will renew calls on the public accounts committee to conduct a full investigation into &bquo;this disgraceful waste of the funds so vital to the education of our children&equo;. 
 He is also writing to John McGregor, the Education Secretary, urging him not only to abandon the idea of additional CTCs but to hand over those in the pipeline to local authorities. 
 Prisoner in lice case wins again 
 By NGAIO CREQUER and HELEN HAGUE 
 A CONVICTED mass murderer has, for the second time, bloodied the nose, metaphorically speaking, of Malcolm Rifkind, the Secretary of State for Scotland, by successfully pursuing a claim for damages. 
 Thomas Campbell was yesterday awarded &pound;4,000 damages by the Edinburgh Court of Session, following a three-day hearing into a claim that he was beaten and stamped upon in his cell by prison officers. 
 Campbell, serving a minimum of 20 years for six murders during the so-called Glasgow ice cream war, last month accepted &pound;250 damages after discovering his hospital bed in Petershead Prison, north-east Scotland, was infested with lice. 
 In pursuit of the action Campbell had caught about 80 of the creatures on a piece of sticky tape and then forwarded them to a zoologist. 
 Yesterday, the Court ruled that Campbell, 36, sustained injuries as a result of the unlawful actions of prison officers. 
 He suffered a ruptured bowel. 
 His earlier successful damages claim arose when he was in the prison's hospital wing convalescing after abdominal surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary as a result of the beating. 
 Law-abiding island hit by crime of the century 
 By MARK DOUGLAS HOME, Scottish Correspondent 
 IN THE closing years of the twentieth century, the wind-swept island of Foula, 20 miles west of the main Shetland group, has reported its first recorded case of vandalism. 
 This remote crofting community, where sheep outnumber people by 30 to one, has had a law-abiding past. 
 No one can remember precisely when the last crime was committed, but it could have been in the early 1900s. 
 One Shetland policeman said yesterday: &bquo;It has not been a regular occurrence by any means. 
 It could be 80 years. 
 But our records don't go back far enough for that. 
 The previous crime was supposed to have been an assault.&equo; 
 The latest addition to Foula's sparse crime statistics was the sort of incident that nobody would pay much regard to elsewhere. 
 A broken-down Land Rover parked by the roadside had its windows broken and its instrument panel smashed. 
 Constables Stephen Mardon, from Scalloway, and Alex Forbes, from Lerwick, flew from the main island to investigate, hitching a lift aboard an eight-seater plane on charter to British Telecom. 
 It was their first visit to Foula, and they seem to have been well received. 
 &bquo;People were very friendly and we were invited in for a number of cups of tea during our stay,&equo; PC Mardon said. 
 Their day of inquiries led to a charge being laid against a resident of the island. 
 Along with the island's hydro-electric scheme &mdash; bringing power to some houses for the first time &mdash; and the harbour improvements, the incident will probably go down in Shetland annals as another stage in Foula's modernisation. 
 Right to buy for the old to be extended 
 By MARK DOUGLAS HOME, Scottish Correspondent 
 ELDERLY council tenants living in easily-accessible housing will gain the right to buy for the first time, under a government amendment to be tabled in the House of Lords on Monday. 
 If the change to the Local Government and Housing Bill goes through, it will remove the power of local authorities to refuse to sell such homes to right-to-buy applicants. 
 This right has been used by councils to prevent 6,169 old people buying their council homes since January 1987 when the rule came into force as a result of a government defeat in the Lords. 
 Under the previous legislation the Secretary of State had the discretion to turn down applications but exercised it only 519 times in the space of five years. 
 Age Concern said: &bquo;If local authorities&equo; precious stock of properties suitable for elderly people begins to be sold off, the consequences for the majority of elderly tenants in ordinary housing could be very serious indeed.&equo; 
 Research centre plans rejected 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 THE GOVERNMENT'S advisers on scientific research have rejected proposals for a &pound;50m national clinical research centre, which medical experts say is needed urgently. 
 The Advisory Board for the Research Councils acknowledged the need for a boost to clinical research, but rejected the Medical Research Council's proposals for a new centre linking basic laboratory research to clinical research in a hospital setting and postgraduate education. 
 The board outlined its views in a letter to the Secretary of State for Education and Science. 
 Britain's clinical research is widely acknowledged to be in very bad shape. 
 The existing centre at Northwick Park in north-west London, has not developed its research in collaboration with hospital work, as once hoped, and is to be phased out. 
 Rejecting the idea of a new national centre will hamper efforts to put laboratory work to practical effect and will mean that medical postgraduates do not develop the appropriate training in new biological techniques, according to an MRC source. 
 The board favours a more &bquo;cost-effective&equo; approach that involves strengthening several existing regional centres and enhancing clinical research at the Royal Postgraduate Medical School at Hammersmith, west London. 
 The reduced proposals that the MRC is now being forced to put together will mean that some areas of research must be dropped. 
 They will render impossible the broad, multi-disciplinary approach to research and teaching that the MRC wanted. 
 &bquo;There is a unity about the whole thing which needs to be practised in a single centre,&equo; the MRC source said. 
 &bquo;But the political reality is that we will have to reshape the whole proposal.&equo; 
 Man &bquo;used cucumber to rob building societies of 9,205 pounds&equo; 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 A ROBBER tricked building society cashiers into handing over thousands of pounds by pretending a cucumber was a gun, an Old Bailey court was told yesterday. 
 Ernest Coveley, 36, escaped with &pound;9,205 from building societies in London during a two-month period. 
 His total haul from the robberies was &pound;12,418. 
 Staff were hoodwinked into thinking the cucumber, wrapped in a black bin-liner, was a sawn-off shotgun, Michael Warren, for the prosecution, said. 
 Armed flying squad officers ambushed Mr Coveley, who was still carrying the wrapped cucumber, at his home in Bethnal Green, east London, on 4 July. 
 He admitted eight robberies between May and July and asked for two others and six attempted robberies to be taken into consideration. 
 He also admitted using the cucumber and an iron bar to frighten staff. 
 But he denied possessing the vegetable and the iron bar as imitation firearms. 
 Mr Justice Jowitt adjourned sentence for social inquiry and psychiatric reports. 
 Yugoslav fear &bquo;no surprise&equo;, peer tells trial 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 LORD ALDINGTON told the High Court yesterday he was not surprised that tens of thousands of Yugoslavs, many of whom had fought on the German side, feared repatriation at the end of the war. 
 The former Conservative minister and company chairman was being cross-examined at the end of the first week of his libel action against historian Count Nikolai Tolstoy and property developer Nigel Watts, who circulated a pamphlet in 1987 saying the peer was responsible for repatriating 70,000 Cossacks and Yugoslavs to be massacred by the communists in 1945. 
 Richard Rampton QC, for Count Tolstoy, cross-examining Lord Aldington, said: &bquo;These people were in mortal fear of being returned to their homes.&equo; 
 Lord Aldington replied: &bquo;That's what you tell me. 
 I'm not surprised they were.&equo; 
 Mr Rampton suggested if Lord Aldington had not known what would happen to the Yugoslavs, he was the only person in his corps who did not. 
 Mr Rampton read out a military report which said that parts of Austria under the Tito forces, to whom the Yugoslavs were to be repatriated, were being ruled by terror. 
 Lord Aldington said: &bquo;If you're suggesting I knew they were behaving badly, then I did. 
 But I didn't think it would extend to massacring.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you know that those Yugoslavians who came into your hands had very good reasons to fear for terror?&equo; 
 Mr Rampton asked. 
 &bquo;I was told they had contributed to the terror almost as much as the terror was used against them,&equo; Lord Aldington said. 
 &bquo;Those working with the Germans were no less guilty of the most horrible brutality than the Titoists.&equo; 
 Mr Rampton asked: &bquo;Suppose you had somebody in your hands who had behaved badly&hellip; is it in those circumstances right to hand him back to somebody who would treat him with equal brutality?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's right to hand him back to the government of the country to which he belongs in the expectation that he will be properly treated and if he has committed a war crime he would be tried accordingly,&equo; Lord Aldington replied. 
 &bquo;It most certainly is my view that what was done with these people was a political decision, a decision of high command.&equo; 
 Mr Rampton asked Lord Aldington why he had ordered on 17 May 1945 that the Yugoslavs not be told where they were going, and whether they had been falsely told they were going to Italy. 
 Lord Aldington insisted they had not been lied to, but they would not have got into the trucks if they had known they were going to Yugoslavia. 
 In evidence earlier this week Lord Aldington, 75, formerly Brigadier Toby Lowe, who was chief of staff to General Sir Charles Keightley, commander of the British Army's V Corps in Allied occupied Austria, said he had not known until 1979 what had happened happened to the Yugoslavs when they were handed over to the forces of Marshall Tito. 
 The case continues on Monday. 
 Heavyweights in battle for British vegetable honours 
 By RICHARD NORTH 
 THERE WERE pumpkins the size of bean bags and groups of onions which would have made fair roofs for Byzantine churches. 
 And carrots which looked like impacted wisdom teeth crossed with a fantasy of Edgar Allan Poe's. 
 One carrot resembled a tower in Gaudi's cathedral in Barcelona. 
 This was the giant vegetable competition run by the British National Pumpkin Society, itself an offshoot of the World Pumpkin Confederation, based in the United States. 
 On Monday, the results of 22 national competitions will be phoned to New York to find the heaviest pumpkin in the world. 
 Bernard Lavery is the doyen of the home-grown British giant vegetable world, and he organised yesterday's event at Alton Towers, the Midlands pleasure park which attracts two and a half million visitors a year. 
 Not many of them were in evidence yesterday, when the first proper snap of autumn was in the air. 
 There were plenty of pumpkins at about the British record weight of 444lbs, or about a third the weight of a hatchback car, into which not one of them could have fitted. 
 Mr Lavery, however, weighed his champion in at 710lbs, 39lbs over the world record. 
 &bquo;I fed mine this year with Algoflash, which is a seaweed-based formulation - organic &mdash; from France,&equo; Mr Lavery said. 
 He farms half an acre of a friend's land in Mid-Glamorgan. 
 Last year, he fed his giants on lager from the firm whose products reach where other beers can't. 
 &bquo;But I find that Algoflash reaches places even the lager couldn't&equo; 
 The tricks to giantism sound very simple. 
 Mr Lavery, who had entered giant celery, onion, radish (about the size of a young elephant's tusk) and leek (about the size of a young palm tree) and cabbages, explained how the latter's immense size was achieved. 
 &bquo;I noticed a freak red cabbage with side-shoots coming from the leaves, and crossed it with a freak green cabbage. 
 The result is a giant cabbage with four heads.&equo; 
 Opinion is sharply divided on the edibility of the results. 
 One woman who grows some big vegetables, but is normally more interested in quality, said that on no account would she touch one of the big pumpkins. 
 &bquo;They've been forced, haven't they? 
 They must be stuffed with nitrogen and God knows what.&equo; 
 Others swore they tasted fine, if only you could find an army of friends to devour them with. 
 Mr Lavery said his would be delicious, and that you can't over-fertilise a pumpkin, or it wilts. 
 &bquo;They just collapse,&equo; he said, leaning against his winning pumpkin, which looked like something run up for a stage set. 
 It showed no sign of collapsing. 
 Geoff Kirby, of the National Society of Allotment and Leisure Gardeners, who is based near Coventry, gave a cautious welcome to the giantists. 
 &bquo;It's a bit of fun, and if it appeals to the young people, that's a good thing. 
 We've noticed a fall in the demand for allotments.&equo; 
 Brian Davies, also from near Coventry, had entered some immense pumpkins and marrows, but seemed mournful. 
 &bquo;I normally enter village shows. 
 Today, I've put in a runner bean &mdash; it must be all of twenty inches long &mdash; but I don't grow them specially. 
 If I see one that looks like it's growing good, I might give it some extra feed and talk to it a bit.&equo; 
 But otherwise, he swears by the old tradition of a load of farmyard muck. 
 He sounded as though he disapproved of exotic plant feeds and the new variety of vegetative showmanship. 
 Unfortunately, there were no giant bean stalks on show yesterday. 
 But then Alton Towers prides itself on not being a theme park. 
 It leaves all that fairy-tale nonsense to Disney. 
 Clarke denies that &bquo;firm&equo; drug budgets will restrict doctors 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 HEALTH AUTHORITIES will be expected to adhere to the &bquo;firm&equo; budgets they are to be given for patients' drugs, Kenneth Clarke, Secretary of State for Health, said yesterday. 
 But the budgets will not be cash limits and GPs will remain free to prescribe all the drugs their patients need, he insisted. 
 Mr Clarke, however, would not say whether &mdash; as seems likely &mdash; the legislation putting the Government's plans into effect will &bquo;require&equo; regional health authorities and family practitioner committees to keep to their drug budgets. 
 &bquo;We are still drafting, and exactly what goes into the legislation has not been settled,&equo; he said. 
 The British Medical Association has said that if the legislation does require authorities to keep to drug budgets, the association will see that as a cash limit and cry &bquo;foul&equo; after accepting assurances from Mr Clarke last week that budgets would not operate as cash limits. 
 Mr Clarke, speaking in Southport at the annual conference of the Society of Family Practitioner Committees, insisted that what was planned would not be a cash limit for drugs. 
 &bquo;What we will expect the regions to do is adhere to the firm budgets by doing their job properly,&equo; he said. 
 That would involve monitoring the &bquo;indicative&equo; budgets which are to be given to GPs to ensure that there is no wasteful or excessive prescribing. 
 &bquo;But we cannot give them cash limits because we have no idea how bad the weather is going to be in the winter or what particular type of &bquo;flu might be coming along. 
 &bquo;We have no idea what wonder drug Boots or Wellcome might suddenly produce during the year, and we cannot stop and should not stop doctors prescribing all the drugs that their particular patients&equo; need.&equo; 
 That was why, he said, the NHS White Paper did not use the words &bquo;cash limits&equo;. 
 When it was being drawn up &bquo;we agreed we couldn't have a cash limit and we never said there would be a cash limit&equo;. 
 It was his critics, Mr Clarke said, who had confused themselves by saying there would be one. 
 He wished that the BMA would now stop &bquo;quibbling&equo; and accept the assurance that it had accepted last week that patients will get all the drugs they need, he added. 
 David Mellor, Minister for Health, yesterday told representatives from major voluntary groups that the chronically sick and disabled stood to gain more than any others from the proposed health service reforms. 
 &bquo;The fears that I have heard expressed about the possible negative impact on these groups are totally groundless,&equo; he said. 
 It was of prime importance that &bquo;money follows the patient&equo;, ending the present haphazard funding of patients across district boundaries. 
 &bquo;What that means is that NHS hospitals will be resourced according to the number of patients they treat. 
 The establishment of a clear link between work done and resources obtained is absolutely crucial to the future of the NHS&hellip; 
 &bquo;This will particularly help those chronically ill patients who have to travel out of their home districts to specialist treatment centres.&equo; 
 The minister also said that there would be no financial or budgetary disadvantage whatsoever to any GP who had to treat a large number of chronically ill patients. 
 Mr Mellor dismissed the suggestion that self-governing hospitals would focus on acute specialities, to the detriment of the chronically ill. 
 &bquo;District health authorities will be under a duty to ensure that demands for both acute and community health care are adequately met, and their performance in discharging this vital function will be monitored.&equo; 
 Karpov discovers fear is the key to winning ways 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 IN THE Pilkington Glass World Chess Championship semi-finals at Sadler's Wells, the former world champion, Anatoly Karpov, has taken a 2-1 lead after his opponent, Artur Yusupov, resigned the adjourned third game of their match yesterday. 
 In the other semi-final, Jan Timman leads Jonathan Speelman, also by 2-1. 
 The last two games show that Yusupov still has to overcome his fear of Karpov. 
 From two very good, perhaps even winning, positions, he has scored only half a point. 
 In the third game, he outplayed Karpov in the late middlegame and early ending, and then made a fatal blunder after almost six hours' play. 
 The scene as the game was adjourned on Thursday night told the whole story: Yusupov, head buried in hands, glumly contemplated the ruins of his previously wonderful position; Karpov stood impassively behind his own chair, surveying the battleground with quiet authority. 
 But it is Jan Timman who has gained the attention of the Dutch. 
 The Netherlands' chess tradition dates back to 1935 when Dr Euwe won the world championship. 
 Since then, chess has been followed with the fanatical devotion usually associated with the major physical sports. 
 The only problem is that the Dutch have not really been very good at the game since Dr Euwe retired. 
 Now, with Jan Timman as their first genuine world title contender for 50 years, Dutch chess journalists almost outnumber the English at Sadler's Wells. 
 Last Tuesday, when the start of this match coincided with the end of a major international event (won by Garry Kasparov) in The Netherlands, one national paper devoted most of a page to chess coverage. 
 Their investigative chess journalism is also evidently of high calibre. 
 Herman Eetgerink, writing in Algemeen Dagblad, has revealed an interest in the match in very high places. 
 He reports a supposed telephone conversation between Margaret Thatcher and the Dutch Prime Minister, Ruud Lubbers, with Mrs Thatcher doing all the talking and demanding that Mr Lubbers help with her problems. 
 &bquo;&hellip; that damned Kinnock and his vile socialists in Brighton&hellip; behind in the polls&hellip; we need a champion, Ruud, get my drift?&hellip; your Timman takes a dive, or else!&equo; 
 At the start of the Pilkington Glass Semi-finals, Mrs Thatcher did send a welcoming letter to the grandmasters: &bquo;I wish all the players every success but I must send my particular good wishes to Jon Speelman.&equo; 
 Only with this Dutch report has the extent of her potential support become apparent. 
 UK on brink of revolution in telephone technology 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 Computer technology built on to telephone exchanges will allow subscribers to have the same number wherever they are in the country, automatically reject unwanted calls and bar calls to &bquo;chat-lines&equo; or other unwanted services. 
 It will enable the telephone to take messages, storing them at the exchange for &bquo;reading back&equo; when required. 
 Eventually, in conjunction with television, it could allow the telephone to be used for &bquo;tele-shopping&equo;, or for selecting a film from huge databases which could be the electronic video stores of the future. 
 The key to the telephone revolution is a development which can link telephone exchanges to computers running a widely-used software system called UNIX. 
 A British company called GPT, which makes many of the digital telephone exchanges used by BT, Mercury and others, has devised a way of upgrading its System X exchanges to link to UNIX machines so that anyone can write the software to run on them. 
 It is this extra software which will enhance the intelligence of the telephone networks and allow them to provide special services rather than simple telephony. 
 The more intelligent networks will be able to recognise codes, keyed in at the telephone and will store much more data than is possible today. 
 How quickly the services will be on offer depends on BT, Mercury and the operators of mobile radio networks. 
 But GPT believes that demand will be so high that the services will be well established by the middle of the next decade. 
 Fears for the future of rare game bird 
 By MARK DOUGLAS HOME, Scottish Correspondent 
 CONSERVATIONISTS are concerned about the decline in the Scottish population of capercaillie, a bird of the old pine woods and the largest member of the grouse family. 
 The capercaillie, one of Britain's most spectacular game birds, is prized by European trophy hunters. 
 But as it has retreated towards its heartland in the Tay, Dee and Spey valleys, most sporting estates have imposed a voluntary moratorium on shooting. 
 Roy Dennis, North of Scotland officer for the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, said there could be as few as 2,000 left in the highlands, an 80 per cent decline in the past 15 years. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't say it was the last ditch for the capercaillie. 
 But it is concerning.&equo; 
 Poor breeding in wet, cold springs; clear-felling of Scots pine forests; the proliferation of dense sitka spruce plantations; and over-shooting have all been suggested as contributing to the capercaillie's retreat. 
 Robert Moss, the leading British expert on capercaillie, believes that habitat destruction and modern forestry practices played an important role. 
 &bquo;The future of the capercaillie will depend on how good a habitat we provide for them in our new forests,&equo; he said. 
 The bird's retreat has led the Forestry Commission to modify three of its forests to make them more welcoming to capercaillie. 
 This has involved thinning trees, opening up glades around mature Scots pines and planting juniper and blackberries. 
 The experiment was prompted by a survey of the commission's forests in northern Scotland. 
 Assisted by the RSPB, the commission circulated questionnaires among its rangers in Highland and Grampian regions. 
 The results showed that capercaillie had vanished from 12 of the 56 forests which had held them for 20 years, and numbers had declined in nearly all the other forests. 
 The commission has sponsored the Institute of Terrestrial Ecology (ITE) at Banchory, near Aberdeen, to examine how modern forests can be made capercaillie-friendly. 
 Capercaillie in Scotland have already come back from near extinction once. 
 They died out in the eighteenth century as a result of deforestation and hunting. 
 The species was successfully re-established in Perthshire with birds from Sweden in the 1830s. 
 By the turn of this century they were plentiful in Scotland, eventually becoming so numerous that commercial foresters regarded them as vermin because of their liking for pine buds and needles (a trait which, according to gourmets, makes them taste strongly of turpentine). 
 Their last population peak was 1974. 
 Since then there has been a long decline. 
 Popularity of police to be tested by survey 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 POLICE forces throughout the country are taking part in a survey to discover how effective, efficient and popular the police are. 
 Police constables, station sergeants, inspectors and some higher ranks are all being asked to take part in the review, while the public in selected towns are to be asked questions about the police and whether the people's needs are being met. 
 The results of the survey, which will include a national poll, will be known to senior police officers in the next few weeks, but will not be made public until early in the new year. 
 Peter Wright, chief constable of South Yorkshire, and outgoing president of the association, revealed details of the survey on the final day of its conference in Preston, Lancashire. 
 Mr Wright, whose own force faced criticism after the Hillsborough disaster, said there was a need for police forces to discover whether or not their perception of their work matched that of the public's need. 
 The Metropolitan Police are co-ordinating the survey and six other forces, Avon and Somerset, Devon and Cornwall, Northumbria, North Wales, Sussex and South Yorkshire, are looking at specific police roles. 
 John Dellow, deputy commissioner of the Metropolitan Police, has been elected the new president of the Association of Chief Police Officers. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Neil Kinnock takes time away from the platform limelight 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 Neil Kinnock takes time away from the platform limelight yesterday, disappearing backstage before the Labour conference ended with the party in a buoyant mood  
 The Labour Party Conference: Gay rights group wins support over age of consent 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 THE LABOUR leadership suffered an embarrassing rebuff when lesbian and gay rights activists won a conference endorsement of their demand for cutting the age of homosexual consent from 21 to 16. 
 Fearing it would lose general election votes, party leaders avoided any reference to a common age of consent in the policy review and replaced a commitment to &bquo;full equality&equo; for gays with &bquo;greater equality&equo;. 
 But the Labour Campaign for Lesbian and Gay Rights argued in a debate on Thursday that back-tracking was costing gay support &bquo;in droves&equo;. 
 Roy Hattersley, deputy party leader, was blamed for the change in policy which has been approved at three previous conferences. 
 To cheers, it was announced yesterday morning that a composite motion reaffirming full equality and 16 years as the age of homosexual consent had been carried by 3,702,000 votes to 2,317,000. 
 Unions supporting the motion included the transport workers, shop workers and public employees. 
 Peter Purton, an executive member of the lesbian and gay rights campaign, said now the idea of a common age of consent had been supported for a fourth time, he hope that the leadership would finally accept the commitment and ensure it went into the manifesto. 
 &bquo;We hope the leadership will have learnt their lesson this time. 
 &bquo;It is only if you pretend and try to sweep it under the carpet that you get a bigoted response,&equo; Mr Purton added after the vote. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Trade unions face cut in power over making of policy 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN and JUDY JONES 
 THE LABOUR PARTY took the first step yesterday towards diminishing the power of the trade unions in its policy-making procedures. 
 In the Brighton conference's closing session, delegates called on the party's national executive to bring forward proposals next year to give a bigger say to local party members, women, ethnic minorities, councillors and MEPs. 
 Larry Whitty, the party's general secretary, admitted Labour's current procedures were &bquo;unsatisfactory, unfair, archaic and need changing&equo;. 
 The NEC believed that there had to be changes and had already begun wide-ranging consultations. 
 But though the intention will be to curb the power of union leaders wielding hundreds of thousands of block votes, Mr Whitty emphasised that Labour would remain a trade union-based party. 
 A composite motion demanding the straightforward abolition of the block vote was defeated on a show of hands. 
 He said there was &bquo;inexorable pressure&equo; for Labour to change its methods of representation. 
 They were out of line with the procedures of most socialist parties in Europe and the growing democracy within the trade union movement. 
 &bquo;It is time for the party as a whole to take a step back and look at the way in which its democracy is being carried out,&equo; he told the conference. 
 Millions of trade unionists could not simply be represented by the casting of a block vote once a year. 
 Demands for the NEC to draw up proposals for widening the party franchise were led by John Edmonds, general secretary of the GMB. 
 He argued that Labour policy-making, though democratic in concept, was defective in practice. 
 He urged the party to move towards a &bquo;one member, one vote&equo; system of decision-making. 
 &bquo;Whenever I am asked about the block vote by GMB members, they find the explanation baffling. 
 They cannot accept that I should cast votes on their behalf without first asking each of them what they think. 
 I agree with them. 
 &bquo;That is no way to make policy in a party of government. 
 The trade unions should retain influence, but surrender control.&equo; 
 In a modern party, the national executive committee should launch the policy-making procedure, and the conference should have the final say. 
 He called the existing policy-making system as one &bquo;designed for the 1920s which is wilting under the television lights of the 1980s&equo;. 
 He said they should not try to camouflage the block vote &mdash; &bquo;we should not try to paint a smile on the face of the monster&equo;. 
 Keith Gordon, of Conwy, attacked those within the party who were &bquo;clinging to masonic unionism&equo;. 
 In the 50 seats that Labour needed to capture at the next election, people would continue to view the party with suspicion &bquo;until we display democracy in our organisation&equo;. 
 However, some delegates feared ordinary members would have even less influence on policy formation if the conference voting system was altered. 
 Graham Till, of Derby North, saw the GMB move as a &bquo;silken noose&equo; that would tighten around the party's neck. 
 This week's conference had been superfluous since Sunday's vote to prevent amendments to the policy review documents, he said. 
 All that was left was a media exercise staged by Peter Mandelson, the party's director of communications. 
 In future, Labour conferences would be &bquo;good television&equo; but little else. 
 &bquo;Maybe the party will be able to get some money out of it and we will be able to prostitute ourselves a little bit more. 
 Socialism is not something you can tinker with, not something you can stop.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Block voting reform may be linked to membership drive: Possible block vote reforms all leave trade unions with a powerful voice. 
 Colin Hughes looks at the options 
 By COLIN HUGHES 
 ALL OF the options being considered for block vote reform leave the trade unions with either a majority or a veto. 
 But the proposal most likely to win the leadership's backing is the one which carries the potential for most substantially diminishing trade union power. 
 At present the unions wield 89 per cent of the conference vote in blocks, with the constituency parties taking 10 per cent, and the small socialist society affiliates less than 1 per cent. 
 The favoured alternative is to base the share of vote on the value of membership fees by which unions and constituency parties respectively affiliate. 
 The main attraction of that method is that it can be loaded in favour of constituencies, to give them a heavy incentive to recruit more members. 
 The leadership is determined that reform of the block vote should be inextricably tied to the party's mass membership drive, and to the extension of one member, one vote democracy. 
 That approach can be devised in numerous ways to produce different results. 
 The most radical is to give one vote to each constituency party for its first 500 members, and an additional vote for every 250 extra members. 
 Trade unions would have one vote for every 3,000 affiliated members. 
 On existing membership figures that would give constituency parties 26 per cent of the vote, and the unions 74 per cent. 
 But if individual membership doubled &mdash; in line with Labour's 1991 campaign target &mdash; the proportions would shift dramatically: union voting strength would then be reduced to 55 per cent, with constituency parties having a 45 per cent share. 
 There are two other main options. 
 The party could create an electoral college, simply giving the trade unions and constituencies set proportions. 
 The national executive's consultation paper suggests a trade union/constituency party split of 70/30. 
 One variation on that would be to increase the constituency share according to the national increase in membership &mdash; so constituencies would have 30 per cent of the vote on a membership of 300,000 (as now) but would get an extra 1 per cent of the vote for every 30,000 increase in national membership. 
 Then if membership doubled, the balance would move to 60/40 in the unions' favour. 
 That could be further varied by including MPs as a section of the electoral college. 
 The final option is splitting the party into two houses &mdash; the unions with half the vote on one side and constituency parties on the other. 
 Any proposal would have to achieve a majority in both houses. 
 Although that would reduce the union block vote more drastically than other options, it would also give both sides a veto. 
 The national executive's consultation paper further warns that it would leave the party looking divided every time the two houses failed to agree. 
 The executive's consultation paper &mdash; written by Larry Whitty, party general secretary &mdash; also advocates redesigning policy-making machinery along the lines of European socialist parties. 
 The &bquo;rolling programme&equo; approach would mean creating an enlarged and more representative executive, fed by policy commissions of up to 100 members. 
 They would take policy reports to conference in one year, have party consultation and debate during the year, with voting and amendments in the subsequent year. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Buoyancy hides fear of failure 
 By JOHN PIENAAR 
 IF THIS WEEK'S striking display of Labour unity was more show than substance, there was no sign of it among the party's &bquo;other ranks&equo; as they dispersed in buoyant mood from Brighton. 
 All around the conference centre, the message was the same from all but the largely isolated activists of the hard-left: differences on the detail of Neil Kinnock's policy review took second place to its status as Labour's only route-map to political power. 
 Dread of failure, as much as positive enthusiasm for Labour's change of direction, was a driving motivation for offering the most appealing face possible at the next election. 
 Constituency Labour Party and trade union delegates seized eagerly on the common feeling that the Conservatives economic and political trials, and the disarray of the centre parties, were at last combining to open a window of opportunity. 
 Thursday's hike in interest rates had served only to heighten that conviction. 
 Ron Waugh, a 38-year-old glassworker and delegate from St Helens North CLP was resigned to a &bquo;period of healing&equo; on the hard-left. 
 &bquo;People here don't know that the policy review is already outdated. 
 We need to do more work at grass-roots level &mdash; possibly, we have been a bit lazy in that respect.&equo; 
 But that view was the exception. 
 Eileen Dunning, 33, from Glasgow Central CLP laid heavy emphasis on the common yearning to haul Labour back from the wilderness. 
 &bquo;There has been so much despair among the lot of us that seeing the party back in government again seemed so remote. 
 Despite my criticisms of the way the policy was carried out &mdash; there was not enough consultation - it gives us a real basis to work on. 
 &bquo;The left will always have their heroes. 
 But there is almost something sad about it &mdash; we are talking about people who have become politically impotent.&equo; 
 That urgency, she added, was even greater in the party's Scottish heartland, where Labour knows that anything but a convincing election challenge could allow the Scottish National Party rapidly to mobilise a bandwagon of anti-Conservative protest. 
 A knot of delegates from the transport workers union were determined to press next year for nuclear unilateralism and union immunities wider than those envisaged in the policy review. 
 Michael Tappin, 42, a politics lecturer at Keele University and delegate from the local CLP, believed 80 per cent of the party were in accord with the review. 
 The political shift at the top was now widely reflected, he said. 
 Edward Boden, 50, who is a transport worker and secretary of Newcastle under Lyme CLP, celebrated the return of the &bquo;old Labour Party&equo;. 
 He said: &bquo;The ideas have been fed from the top down, but from the bottom up they have been accepted. 
 &bquo;The mood of this conference has been that there is a light at the end of the 10-year tunnel &mdash; we are a party again.&equo; 
 The Labour Party Conference: Labour &bquo;needs help&equo; 
 By JOHN PIENAAR 
 Labour would not win the next general election on its own and should accept electoral reform, David Owen, SDP leader, told a Plymouth meeting. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Conference quotes 
 By JOHN PIENAAR 
 &bquo;We used to have to promise to do things to get elected, and now we have to promise not to.&equo; 
 &mdash; David Blunkett, in the Red Review. 
 &bquo;Current conference procedures are unsatisfactory, unfair, archaic and need changing.&equo; 
 &mdash; Larry Whitty, the party's general secretary. 
 &bquo;This conference must sound the death knell of the block vote. 
 The trade unions should retain influence, but we must surrender control.&equo; 
 &mdash; John Edmonds, GMB. 
 &bquo;We want to put behind us these tawdry, shabby years of the 1980s&equo; materialism, the salmonella, listeria society of Thatcher.&equo; 
 &mdash; Dennis Skinner. 
 The Labour Party Conference: Delegates' final day decisions 
 By JOHN PIENAAR 
 The conference yesterday: Condemned privatisation of security at Ministry of Defence establishments. 
 Instructed the NEC to prepare a blueprint for widening the party franchise and streamlining annual conference procedures, reporting back to next year's conference. 
 Rejected appeals to commit the next Labour government to introducing a Bill of Rights. 
 Supported reducing the age of consent for homosexual acts to 16. 
 Pressure on services forecast in &bquo;ageing UK&equo; 
 By NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 WESTERN nations will have older and dwindling populations as they enter the next century, and their fluctuating birth rates will also pose problems, a conference on future trends heard yesterday. 
 But the populations of poorer countries will continue to rise rapidly. 
 The growing number of elderly will put strains on pensions, social security and health services in developed countries, Geoffrey Hobbs, a senior planner with ICI, told the &bquo;Exploring the Future&equo; conference in London. 
 Ever-changing bulges and deficits in different age groups &mdash; such as the shortage of school-leavers which Britain is about to experience &mdash; will present problems and opportunities for businesses, Mr Hobbs said. 
 One of the most important factors for governments and forecasters will be how much money young and middle-aged people save for their old age while they are earning. 
 Almost all developed countries, including Britain, have a fertility rate of less than 2.1 children per woman &mdash; the level needed to sustain the population, Mr Hobbs told the conference, organised by the Royal Institute of International Affairs and the Strategic Planning Society. 
 In Britain the median age will rise from 36 years now to 41 in 2020. 
 West Germany and Japan will be older, the United States slightly younger. 
 The &bquo;young&equo; elderly of the future &mdash; active, many of them relatively affluent and in their sixties &mdash; will become an important and powerful group of consumers, Mr Hobbs said. 
 The old elderly &mdash; frail, and mainly widows &mdash; will also provide growing business opportunities in converting houses to meet their needs and health care. 
 Fluctuating birth rates will present their own challenges. 
 The US will probably benefit from a doubling of middle-aged people aged 45 to 54 over the next 20 years because of the baby boom of the late 1950s. 
 Meanwhile, the number of young adults in West Germany will decline dramatically. 
 The number of teenagers there is expected to fall by 45 per cent between 1980 and 2000. 
 The influx of young refugees from East Germany will help to offset this. 
 In the developing nations, populations will continue to rise, according to United Nations forecasts. 
 But this growth rate should begin to decline around the turn of the century. 
 At its peak it will add 90 million people to the world each year, roughly equivalent to the population of Mexico. 
 Growth rates in the countries of sub-Saharan Africa will be the slowest to fall off, and by 2020 Nigeria is likely to become the world's fourth most populous country with 350 million people. 
 On present trends, Mexico City's population will expand to 26 million by the end of the century, retaining its place as the world's biggest mega-city. 
 Its people will equal the entire population of Canada. 
 Comic's funeral 
 By NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 Graham Chapman, the comedian who died on Wednesday, will be cremated next Friday at Vinters Park Crematorium, near Maidstone, Kent. 
 Chemical leak at school 
 By NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 Nine pupils and two teachers were treated in hospital after being overcome by noxious fumes in a classroom at Lancaster Boys' School, Leicester. 
 Environmental health officers are investigating. 
 Five policemen were taken to hospital after a lorry overturned while carrying canisters of the chemical phenylacetonitrile near Scotswood Bridge, Newcastle upon Tyne. 
 Terrorists &bquo;cannot be Catholics&equo; 
 By NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 IRA terrorists could not also be members of the Catholic Church, the Bishop of Down and Connor, Dr Cahal Daly, told mourners at a Northern Ireland funeral yesterday. 
 He said: &bquo;Membership of the IRA and voluntary participation&hellip; with its so-called &bquo;military operations&equo; is most gravely sinful'. 
 This was not an opinion, simply the Catholic moral teaching, he said at the funeral of Henry Babbington, shot dead on Wednesday by IRA men who mistook him for a loyalist terrorist. 
 Aspiring astronauts set to take space test 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 SIXTEEN aspiring astronauts will next week undergo a series of trials to test their endurance in space. 
 Their ability to withstand high G-forces, extreme disorientation and lack of oxygen will be key factors in deciding who is to travel to the Soviet space station Mir. 
 The would-be astronauts will be spun in a giant centrifuge to simulate the experience of rocket lift-off and re-entry, and sealed inside altitude chambers to experience the lack of oxygen at 16,500 feet. 
 But perhaps most severe of all are tests for susceptibility to motion sickness: they will be blindfolded, and have to move their heads and upper parts of the body back and forth or up and down; and they will be pushed back and forward on a track every five seconds for 20 minutes. 
 The 14 men and two women will begin this next phase of tests on Monday at the Royal Air Force Institute of Aviation Medicine at Farnborough. 
 Group Captain Glaister, a professor of aviation medicine who is involved in the testing, said at Farnborough yesterday: &bquo;We will inquire upon the symptoms of increasing sickness, so that they can stop before they actually have to use a paper bag.&equo; 
 The most severe tests have already been carried out on a man and a woman, unconnected with the project, last week. 
 The &pound;16m British Juno mission to send an astronaut to Mir is fast reaching the point where the final candidate and a backup will be chosen and sent to Moscow's Star City for 18 months of training with Soviet cosmonauts. 
 Hopes that a woman would make it to the last hurdle are receding as the Soviets have made it clear they would like the two candidates to be of the same sex. 
 The rigours of testing do not end next week as eight people, chosen by the Soviets and the British, will be taken to a Soviet hospital for further tests, the nature of which is as yet unclear. 
 According to Air Vice Marshall Peter Howard, who is in charge of selecting the astronaut, the Soviets can choose four &bquo;finalists&equo; but the British then decide on the two people who will leave for Moscow at the beginning of December. 
 &bquo;We the British have undisputed and unchallenged choice of the final two. 
 Then they have five days to sell the dog, make arrangements for the wife and kids and set off for Moscow's Star City,&equo; he said. 
 The Soviets, however, seem happy for families to stay at Star City for the whole 18 months. 
 It is not yet known, however, who will end up paying for the Juno project, currently being supported by the London-based Moscow Narodny Bank. 
 ITV and Scottish Television have a contract for TV coverage, but the project needs to attract at least &pound;15m in sponsorship and advertising of various kinds. 
 Details of the science experiments which the astronaut will carry out may be revealed in the next week or two, Professor Heinz Wolff, of Brunel University, said. 
 Sixteen experiments have recently been presented to Soviet scientists in Moscow, he said. 
 The Soviets are particularly interested in growing protein crystals which could help to develop drugs to tackle diseases including Aids. 
 Computer hacking may be outlawed 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 THE LAW COMMISSION's report on computer hacking is to be published on Tuesday, two months earlier than planned and in time to allow ministers to put proposals for legislation into the Queen's Speech, should they so wish, writes Mary Fagan. 
 Experts are divided over whether the commission will urge specific new legislation making hacking a crime, or opt for changes in existing laws to cope with certain types of computer crime. 
 For example, some lawyers say the law of deception must be adjusted to include deception of machines rather than just people. 
 This could lead to prosecution of people who illicitly use passwords and codes to get access to forbidden parts of a system. 
 There may also be a need for changes to criminal damage laws to cover viruses and logic bombs which can corrupt and destroy computer data. 
 At the moment, under English law, data is not property, and damage or theft has to relate to the medium on which it is stored. 
 But the main area of controversy is whether simply obtaining unauthorised access to a computer should be a crime. 
 Emma Nicholson, Conservative MP for Devon West and Torridge, has lobbied that it should be, and for prison sentences of up to 10 years for culprits. 
 The Confederation of British Industry also wants hacking outlawed, but the Data Protection Registrar is adamant that hacking per se should not be a crime. 
 The Week in Review: Home News 
 By DAVID LISTER 
 NEIL KINNOCK, in his speech to the Labour Party conference, dealt with waste disposal methods in Sweden and the increase in the rodent population in Thatcher's Britain. 
 As not a single local party had discussed either of these issues, not a single delegate took umbrage and Mr Kinnock received a Tory-style standing ovation. 
 The Labour leader said that in her supposed splendid isolation from Europe, Margaret Thatcher showed she was from the Greta Garbo school of diplomacy. 
 Nigel Lawson enrolled in the Clark Gable &bquo;Frankly, I don't give a damn&equo; school when he fell foul of his own party over a rise in interest rates just before the Tory conference. 
 The Archbishop of Canterbury, a graduate of the John Wayne memorial diplomatic academy, spoke out against the emergence in Britain of a &bquo;Pharisee&equo; society of self-interest and intolerance. 
 He said: &bquo;The successful are always tempted to regard their success as a sort of blessing or reward for righteousness. 
 This can lead to judgements being made about the unsuccessful, the unemployed, the poor and the unintelligent, which are both uncharitable and untrue.&equo; 
 Placing himself in an illustrious line of critics he pointed out that the Pharisees did not escape the sharp edge of Jesus's tongue for their &bquo;self righteousness&equo; and &bquo;judgemental&equo; attitudes. 
 Most parents eschew diplomacy completely when dealing with their children, and opt for the Jimmy Cagney approach. 
 New research showed that as many as two-thirds of babies are smacked before the age of one, 83 per cent of mothers of four-year-olds believe in smacking, and 18 per cent of children were still being smacked by their 11th birthday. 
 Christopher Brown, director of the NSPCC, said: &bquo;How can you listen to children if you are hung up on smacking them?&equo; 
 Which assumes that the latter is an alternative to the former, rather than a consequence. 
 The Second World War intruded into the week's events. 
 A group of MPs protested that it was &bquo;totally unacceptable&equo; for the Second World War to be omitted from the national curriculum for 7 to 14-year-olds. 
 They concluded: &bquo;We regard the omission as totally unacceptable; without logic; educationally insupportable; and offensive to all those who fought in or suffered from the Nazis.&equo; 
 Walter Kent, the 72-year-old American composer of the wartime song White Cliffs of Dover, came to Britain for his first glimpse of the aforesaid cliffs. 
 He saw many seagulls but not a single bluebird, and could not be persuaded to approach the edge to have his picture taken. 
 After the opening of his much acclaimed film of Henry V, Kenneth Branagh said he was worried that his high media profile could lead to a &bquo;Branagh backlash&equo;, and that people might get &bquo;bored rigid&equo; reading about him. 
 Doomed valley yields store of historic treasure 
 By DAVID KEYS, Archaeology Correspondent 
 ARCHAEOLOGISTS in Devon are recording the 5,000-year history of a valley which is about to be flooded to form one of Britain's largest reservoirs. 
 Investigations in the area &mdash; part of the valley of the river Wolf, north-west of Dartmoor &mdash; have revealed evidence of human activity dating from neolithic times. 
 But the most important aspect of the project has been the excavation of domestic buildings built between the fifteenth and nineteenth centuries. 
 For the first time, archaeologists have been able to study in detail the techniques used by post-medieval builders to construct the typical &bquo;cob&equo; houses for which the West Country is famous. 
 Building in cob &mdash; mud, straw and cow dung &mdash; is no longer practised. 
 The tradition, which goes back at least 2,500 years, continued until the early part of this century. 
 Although cob walls contain no stone, apart from the footings, they are remarkably resilient. 
 Tens of thousands of traditional mud-built cob buildings are still in use throughout Devon and Cornwall. 
 In the early nineteenth century, the area &mdash; whose most celebrated son was the Rev Sabine Baring-Gould, composer of the hymn &bquo;Onward Christian Soldiers&equo; &mdash; supported at least 100 people. 
 It had its own brickworks, cloth mill and farms, and was largely self-sufficient. 
 However, by the 1970s the population had dwindled to less than 20, and the last inhabitant moved out three years ago, after the land was bought by South West Water. 
 Over the past two years, archaeologists have excavated the remains of a medieval village &mdash; including its corn and cloth mills &mdash; as well as four farm sites, and three buildings constructed of cob. 
 The last house in the valley &mdash; West Wortha &mdash; will be demolished within the next four weeks, but archaeological work will continue even as the water level starts to rise. 
 The excavation &mdash; directed by Peter Stead of Exeter Museum &mdash; has been funded jointly by English Heritage and South West Water to the tune of &pound;250,000. 
 Items so far recovered include prehistoric flint instruments, medieval pottery, a seventeenth-century water wheel, eighteenth-century clay ovens for scalding Devonshire cream, and nineteenth-century cider presses and apple crushers. 
 A permanent exhibition on the history of the valley is to be established near the dam in the early 1990s. 
 The flooding process, which begins next week, is expected to be complete by 1991. 
 A &pound;16.1m dam will hold back a 2.6-mile-long artificial lake to be known as the Roadford Reservoir. 
 The dam itself &mdash; 45 miles west of Exeter and completed two months ago &mdash; is 430 metres across and 40 metres high. 
 SNP sets tone for election campaign 
 By MARK DOUGLAS HOME, Scottish Correspondent 
 THE SCOTTISH National Party yesterday signalled its strategy for the 1990 regional council elections and the next general election by accusing Labour of swallowing &bquo;Thatcher values&equo;. 
 Launching its autumn campaign in Edinburgh, the party revealed that the twin themes of independence in Europe and &bquo;fighting for Scotland better than Labour ever can or will&equo; would form its &bquo;springboard to victory&equo;. 
 The SNP's national executive comittee meets this weekend to discuss election policy. 
 Nationalists claim growing popularity for their flagship policy of independence in Europe. 
 But the SNP is only too aware that most of its dormant support lies within Labour's Scottish ranks and that its electoral fortunes are constrained by Labour's dominance north of the Border. 
 In the latest Scottish opinion polls the SNP was trailing behind the Conservatives and Labour. 
 But Labour's lead over the SNP was 30 percentage points, a far cry from the four-point gap which separated them in January, in the wake of the nationalist victory at the Govan by-election. 
 The SNP is also launching a recruitment drive but its attacks on Labour seem likely to cause most controversy. 
 Michael Russell, the party's vice-convener for publicity, accused Labour of selling out on all the promises it made to Scottish voters at the last election. 
 Labour had &bquo;actively collaborated&equo; in trying to impose the poll tax. 
 The party had even colluded with the Tories to attempt to thwart SNP assaults on &bquo;Thatcher's right to ruin Scotland&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;Labour may have thrown in the towel, but the SNP will continue to lead the fight to defeat the poll tax and to rid our nation of the nuclear menace.&equo; 
 Court will hear Press appeal over &bquo;Spycatcher&equo; 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 THE EUROPEAN Commission of Human Rights gave its permission yesterday for three newspapers to pursue a claim that the UK broke freedom of expression guarantees during the Spycatcher affair. 
 The Guardian, The Observer and The Sunday Times are seeking a ruling that temporary injunctions handed down by a 3-2 House of Lords majority in 1987, banning publication of details from the memoirs of an ex-MI5 officer, Peter Wright, were unnecessary prior restraints on free speech that breached Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights. 
 Andrew Neil, editor of The Sunday Times, welcomed the commission's decision and said his newspaper would certainly pursue the case to the bitter end. 
 The ruling in Strasbourg yesterday that the complaints are admissible clears the way for a future hearing before the European Court of Human Rights in up to two years' time. 
 In the meantime, the commission will consider the merits of the case with a view to bringing about a private, &bquo;friendly&equo; settlement with the Government. 
 Failing that, the case will be referred to the court by the commission, or by the Government, or be decided by a committee of ministers. 
 &bquo;We hope the Government will agree to an amicable settlement but it will mean a big climbdown for them because we're not going to give way on the principle,&equo; Mr Neil said. 
 &bquo;Our understanding is that if it does go to court, the hearing will be next year.&equo; 
 Peter Preston, editor of The Guardian, said his newspaper's main aim was to get the European court to rule that it was wrong for the Government to use injunctions to prevent publication of such material, on the questions of principle and cost. 
 As soon as an injunction was sought, newspapers faced large legal bills, he said. 
 The Guardian and The Observer published details of the contents of the book in April 1986 and The Sunday Times published the first of a series of extracts in July 1987. 
 The Government was represented at a hearing before the commission on Thursday by the Attorney General, Sir Patrick Mayhew QC. 
 It argues that the injunctions were necessary in the public interest to prevent the concept of the security service's confidentiality being destroyed pending full argument at trial. 
 The affair provoked a deep division of views when the case reached the Law Lords in July 1987. 
 Lord Templeman said that sweeping aside the public interest factor without any trial would have &bquo;established a &bquo;charter for traitors&equo; to publish on the most massive scale in England whatever they had managed to publish abroad'. 
 But in a dissenting judgement, Lord Bridge described the injunctions as a massive encroachment on freedom of speech. 
 They were finally lifted in a second House of Lords ruling in October last year. 
 Call for ivory trade ban tops conference agenda 
 By NICK CATER 
 THE FATE of the elephant will be decided by delegates at a conference on endangered species next week. 
 Eugene Lapointe, head of the world's wildlife trade monitoring body, hopes to find a compromise between those African nations calling for a total ban on ivory trading and those arguing for trade to be controlled. 
 The 103 nations which are parties to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) meet in Lausanne, Switzerland, from Monday. 
 Tanzania's proposal, which is backed by Kenya, Somalia and The Gambia, has divided delegates. 
 Southern African countries, including Zimbabwe, Botswana and South Africa, will fight any ban, and, if it achieves the required two-thirds majority, have declared they will register a CITES &bquo;reservation&equo; to allow elephant tusk sales to continue. 
 Mr Lapointe is cautious. 
 &bquo;I want the emotion taken out of this debate. 
 It may be impossible to stop the trade in ivory, so a compromise must be found,&equo; he said. 
 At present, trade in African ivory worth millions of dollars is allowed by CITES, under a system of quotas, with tusk markings and shipment papers designed to catch out sales of poached tusks. 
 The quota system, which critics claim permits poached ivory to enter legal trade, was set up as African elephant numbers fell from an estimated 1.3 million in 1979 to about 600,000 today. 
 The dispute arises because poaching and habitat destruction has vastly reduced elephant herds in central and eastern Africa, but wildlife management further south has meant rising populations, which are regularly culled to raise foreign exchange. 
 Conservationists condemn as near-bribery the fact that the CITES' ivory trade monitoring unit is financed by a &dollar;140,000 (&pound;86,950) levy on the trade. 
 Mr Lapointe says CITES needs at least &dollar;4m (&pound;2.4m) to enlarge the role of the Convention and to bring in more money to support its policing work. 
 &bquo;One suggestion is to develop our expertise in species management and to support countries establishing systems for the sustainable exploitation of wildlife.&equo; 
 The Convention could examine key traded species, carry out the necessary scientific studies and create management plans which would ensure the protection of the species while allowing a profitable legal trade. 
 Mr Lapointe hopes to begin in Bolivia, where poaching threatens the caiman crocodile. 
 Neither the Bolivian government, nor its people benefit from the trade. 
 &bquo;Yet with the right kind of controls, and the development of proper management for the species, the caiman could be conserved and still create income for local people and foreign exchange for the government.&equo; 
 Encouraging more trade is an anathema to the pure protectionists, dismissed by some observers as &bquo;bunny huggers&equo;. 
 They and other green groups will be among 350 observers at the biggest CITES meeting yet held. 
 Family left Sellafield house after dogs died 
 By NICK CATER 
 THE DEATH of two pet dogs from cancer was one of the factors which convinced a family they had to leave their home near the Sellafield nuclear processing plant in Cumbria, a High Court judge was told yesterday. 
 Christine Merlin also told Mr Justice Gatehouse that the fertility of her breeding geese diminished and goslings hatched with abnormalities such as &bquo;heads on the wrong way round and wings in peculiar positions&equo;. 
 Mrs Merlin and her husband Christopher say radioactive contamination was behind their decision to sell the house, Mountain Ash, Ravenglass, six miles from Sellafield, which fetched only &pound;35,000 &mdash; little more than it cost 11 years earlier. 
 The couple are suing British Nuclear Fuels for about &pound;150,000 compensation. 
 BNFL is contesting the case, claiming the levels of radioactivity were harmless and that the decision to sell was purely financial. 
 Mrs Merlin, now of Grass Gars Farm, Broughton in Furness, Cumbria, said she became concerned about the safety of the house before her husband who was &bquo;completely besotted&equo; by Mountain Ash. 
 She told him of her unhappiness, but she knew that, because of his love of the house, it would be difficult to convince him to move. 
 Their financial situation would not have been enough to drive them away. 
 A schoolmasterly exposition of the law: Andrew Brown sat in on a High Court trial &mdash; and was transported back to the strangely mingled fears and absurdities of a prep-school 
 By ANDREW BROWN 
 THE LAW COURTS in the Strand pronounce a terrible judgment on the visitor as soon as he enters: school, they say, really was a preparation for life. 
 Why, this is Dotheboys Hall, nor are we out of it. 
 The architecture is that of a thousand prep-schools; just as at a boarding school, authority seems at the same time ludicrous, arbitrary, and deadly serious. 
 The eccentricities of the judges have the same stupefying unfunniness &mdash; however witty &mdash; as those of a schoolteacher. 
 The courtrooms themselves are much smaller than one would imagine, from the size of the issues dealt with in them, while the great hall of the courts, which would, in a palace, be impressive, has red benches all around its edges, on which hurried sandwich lunches are consumed, the wrappers stuffed into ashtrays afterwards. 
 The majesty of the law does not derive from pomp, but from fear. 
 In libel trials the threat is of bankruptcy, rather than prison: the action brought by Lord Aldington against Nigel Watts and Count Nikolai Tolstoy is expected to last around three months, and could ruin at least one side. 
 Private Eye will probably close if it loses its appeal against the award of &pound;600,000 to Sonia Sutcliffe, which was also heard last week. 
 Knowing all this, the surprise is the lack of drama as these trials progress. 
 A libel trial is in large parts intensely soporific, if you are not on the receiving end. 
 The wood panelling echoes slightly; Lord Aldington's counsel, Charles Gray QC, has a voice like a bumble-bee: a moment's inattention and his even, well-modulated and comforting tones seem to embark on an erratic, heavy flight around the room. 
 &bquo;Have you violated, grossly or otherwise, the laws of war and of humanity?&equo; he asks his client. 
 &bquo;Certainly not,&equo; Lord Aldington replies. 
 The careful, thorough examination continues: each charge in the pamphlet complained of is brought out and evenly dismissed. 
 &bquo;Do you have the blood of 70,000 men, women and children on your hands?&equo; &mdash; &bquo;Certainly not.&equo; 
 The hot-air hand-drier was almost certainly invented by lawyers: instead of the quick, rough efficiency of a towel, you must stand there miming the washing of hands over and over again until the soap has been extracted from every last crevice. 
 This is very much the way in which the law approaches the extraction of the truth, and it is different both from the vivid imprecision of ordinary life and the intimacy of a police interrogation. 
 Above all, the questions to be decided in a libel case stand at a curious tangent to the stories that lead up to them. 
 Tom Bowden fell over in his bathroom, drunk, in 1975 and crushed his throat and died, Mr Gray told the court. 
 He left a widow and three children. 
 The insurance company did not pay out because he had failed to mention when renewing his policy that he had been seriously ill. 
 The nature of the illness is disputed: the company thought it was alcoholism; the widow believes not. 
 A partner in her firm of solicitors knew Lord Aldington, who was then the chairman of Sun Alliance Insurance, which handled the case; and asked him to look at it. 
 He decided that the company was justified and that the nature of the disease was irrelevant. 
 Mrs Bowden's brother is Nigel Watts, who in 1984 took up the campaign against the insurance company, which had lain dormant since 1978. 
 After repeated telephone calls to Lord Aldington at home &mdash; as many as 28 in one weekend &mdash; had failed to change his mind, Mr Watts learnt of Count Tolstoy's theories. 
 Count Tolstoy provided much of the information for the pamphlet at issue, of which Mr Watts circulated 10,000 copies. 
 Among the recipients were the teachers and pupils of Winchester College, of which Lord Aldington was Warden. 
 The general allegations in it had been made before: Harry Phibbs had a moment of fame for calling the late Earl of Stockton &bquo;a war criminal&equo; on the strength of Count Tolstoy's theories, but he got away with it. 
 This time, the lights went up on the slipper-fight. 
 Lord Aldington sued first Mr Watts, and then Count Tolstoy. 
 He has told the court that he has spent the best part of the last two and a half years preparing for this joust. 
 There are several unusual things about this libel trial. 
 Most of the recent causes celebres in the libel courts have involved journalists on one side or another. 
 Frequently they have involved celebrities, who are thought, because they have fame and money, to have commensurately vulnerable reputations. 
 Lord Aldington does not fit this pattern at all. 
 He has been enormously successful, but in a quiet world. 
 One of the youngest brigadiers in the British Army; deputy chairman of the Conservative Party; chairman of a major insurance company; Warden of Winchester College &mdash; these are all solid achievements, but it is safe to guess that until this trial started most people had never heard of him. 
 When he gives evidence, sitting for the most part on two cushions, he leans forwards attentively like a headmaster, and with something of the same terrifying effect. 
 What a curious and deep shaft into English society is opened by the reflection that when reputations and perhaps a million pounds in costs alone are at stake, we revert to the patterns of upper-class education. 
 Critical Review of the Week: Theatre 
 By ANDREW BROWN 
 Jean Poiret, the author of La Cage Aux Folles, came to the West End this week with Paris Match. 
 Sian Phillips, Stephen Moore and Lesley Ash did their best, but to little avail. 
 &bquo;They awarded me a seat behind a pillar for this French farce, but foolishly I moved to a place where I had a full view of the stage. 
 I say foolishly because (it) grows worse the more you see of it&hellip; 
 Miss Phillips's performance is really a series of inappropriate costumes by Pierre Balmain and the actress wafts around in a lilac voile morning trouser suit, a black cocktail number, dresses up to resemble a wasp and dresses down in a riot of patchwork heliotrope, orange, purple, blue and green. 
 It is as if her costumes were the reasons for her being there. 
 Perhaps they were.&equo; 
 Nicholas De Jongh, The Guardian. 
 &bquo;In the course of a long and misspent career, I have probably seen less amusing comedies than this but, if so, I cannot at present call any of them to mind.&equo; 
 Charles Osborne, Daily Telegraph. 
 &bquo;Those of my colleagues and fellow theatregoers who constantly compare British theatre unfavourably with the depth, vitality and style of of the European stage should cop a load of this.&equo; 
 Martin Hoyle, FT. 
 Critical Review of the Week: Film 
 By ANDREW BROWN 
 Could the Kenneth Branagh backlash be beginning? 
 Critical response to the actor-director's hugely-hyped Henry V was distinctly mixed. 
 &bquo;Saddest disappointment is Branagh himself (who) proves a curiously anodyne screen presence. 
 Blond-mopped and doughty-featured, he resembles &mdash; Nature's fault not his, but one magnified on screen &mdash; a schoolboy who has eaten too many buns during the tuck-box break. 
 Shorn of Oliver's physical charisma and reserves of sullen, glowing mystery, Branagh tries to compensate with a pugnacious modernism. 
 But all one feels is a talented adjunct desperately grabbing at officer status.&equo; 
 Nigel Andrews, Financial Times. 
 &bquo;In terms of performance the film is praiseworthy, with a consistent, naturalistic, undeclamatory style that still respects the poetry&hellip; 
 Kenneth Branagh's own performance &mdash; correct, passionless, all intelligence - will be entirely a matter of taste.&equo; 
 David Robinson, The Times. 
 &bquo;This Henry V is an achievement of some character and resource, warts and all. 
 It deserves anybody's attention.&equo; 
 Derek Malcolm, The Guardian. 
 &bquo;Henry V offers (Branagh), better than any other play in the repertoire, what might be called a yuppie dynamic, a mythology of success and self-definition rather than of struggle&hellip; 
 It is fair to say that the real chemistry is not between actor and part, but between the idea of the star as entrepreneur and the idea of the king as a self-made man.&equo; 
 Adam Mars-Jones, The Independent. 
 The best thing about Wired was Michael Chiklis's touching and convincing performance in the central role of John Belushi. 
 Otherwise, there seemed little to commend it. 
 &bquo;The filmic device of a discarnate Belushi reviewing his life allows the dead performer (and Hollywood collectively) a right of reply; unfortunately it also makes the film ludicrous.&equo; 
 Hugo Davenport, Daily Telegraph. 
 &bquo;Better than it might be. 
 Michael Chiklis is an astounding Belushi lookalike, and an act-alike to match&hellip; 
 The movie's only enemy &mdash; but a major one &mdash; is its dialogue, oscillating between the pompous and the purple.&equo; 
 Nigel Andrews, Financial Times. 
 &bquo;Wired purports to be about America not just Belushi, but this is trite stuff about decadence in Tinseltown; what it has to say about the nation is nugatory.&equo; 
 Sheila Johnston, The Independent. 
 The week's oddity was Ariel, a Finnish road movie directed by Aki Kaurismaki. 
 &bquo;The week's pleasant surprise&hellip; 
 Dark, comic and determinedly un-moralistic, Ariel is a minor-key delight.&equo; 
 Nigel Andrews, Financial Times. 
 &bquo;The film is pretty short, but makes everything count and, while proving extremely entertaining, never lets go of its main point, which is to illuminate, with some sympathy, the underbelly of Scandinavian and particularly Finnish life.&equo; 
 Derek Malcolm, The Guardian. 
 EVENTS / Conkering heroes take on the world 
 By SIOBHAN DOLAN and OWEN SLOT 
 The conker fraternity prepares for the highlight of its sporting year on Sunday with the World Championships at Ashton; it includes entries from the USA and Greece. 
 Nurturing the conkers to peak fitness rests with the Ashton Conker Club who ensure the nuts are not overly toughened or injected with illegal substances. 
 A World Championship conker must be exactly a week old, any less and it is too soft and if it lies any longer, the inside shrivels up. 
 Thousands are graded for size, shape and consistency and then strung on leather bootlaces. 
 All that remains for the entrants is to polish the conkers, Dennis Lillee style. 
 Tips for budding conker conquerors (like those above) include aiming for the the top (the weakest part) of your opponent's conker with the periphery of your own. 
 The swing is also crucial. 
 One enthusiast has constructed a gallows-like contraption in order to perfect his technique. 
 Overswing and you could snag (entangle with the string of your opponent's conker) &mdash; three snags and you're disqualified. 
 A good eye is essential as illustrated by the Mexican who practised for only 10 minutes before becoming King Conker, and the first overseas winner, in 1976. 
 This year the British contingent looks set to retain the title (won by a Devon man, Will Cox last year) unless the late Russian entry (a red hot favourite with some observers) proves a dark horse with his chestnut. 
 BOURNEMOUTH Golden Oldies Hockey Festival International event for the over 35s with teams from Fiji, New Zealand, Canada and West Germany bullying off for supremacy in the week long tournament. 
 To 14 Oct. 
 Bournemouth Sports Club, Chapel Gate, Hurn, Dorset (details 0684-293175). 
 Sat, Civic reception, Sun play begins at 2pm. 
 BRISTOL Amnesty International Film Week &bquo;89 A week of screenings, debate and discussion to raise awareness of the the organisation's work. 
 Includes Death Penalty Debate (Sat 7) to follow screening of much acclaimed The Thin Blue Line. 
 Watershed Media Centre, Bristol (0272-276444). 
 To 14 Oct. 
 BUXTON 4th International Kite Fly For Peace Up, up and away as kite flyers world wide unite in their quest for peace. 
 Participants are invited to bring kites or make one in the on-site kite workshop. 
 Buxton Girls Lower School, Peveril Rd (details 0298-814543). 
 Sun, 1.30-5pm. 
 Free admission. 
 GATESHEAD Family Sculpture Day 1989 Mammoth effort to build circus in just one day with old wood and pieces of string. 
 Professional sculptors on hand to help advise. 
 Wear old clothes and bring a hammer. 
 The Grove, Saltwell Park, Gateshead (details on 091-477 3478). 
 Sun, 11am-5pm. 
 Dagarti African music and dance with evocative displays of the history and landscapes of the Commonwealth. 
 Commonwealth Institute, Kensington High St, London W8 6NQ (01-603 4535). 
 Sun, 2.30pm. 
 London To Brighton Road Running Race The chimes of Big Ben mark the start of this race which follows A23 to Horley, then B2036 to Pycombe where it rejoins A23 to Brighton. 
 Big Ben Clock Tower, Palace Of Westminster, London SW1 (details 01-247 0371). 
 Sun, 7am; free for spectators. 
 SOUTH TYNEDALE Railway Diesel Day Chance to get all steamed up at unique collection of classic British industrial engines including &bquo;Tiny Tim&equo; and &bquo;The Wickham Trolley&equo;. 
 Opportunity to view non-operational equipment under restoration. 
 South Tynedale Railway, Alston Station (details 0452 304546). 
 Sun. 
 FRIDAY LEEDS Film Festival Two weeks of varied film with a horror weekend (14/15 Oct), a George Romero retrospective with a screening of his new film Monkey Shines, various seminars, and two exhibitions, The Man Who Shot Garbo and 30 Years of Cuban Cinema. 
 To 28 Oct. 
 Box office and details (0532-462453). 
 Chess Commentary 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON 
 After a nervous start to the Pilkington Glass World Championship Semi-finals, the Timman-Speelman match exploded into violence in Thursday's third round. 
 The diagram shows the position after White's 42nd move. 
 With two rooks and a bishop for the queen, Speelman has a nominal material advantage, but there are still threats to his king. 
 Shares escape new crash but face uncertain future 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 IF THE rise in bank base rates is bad news for homebuyers &mdash; now facing the inevitability of a hike of at least 1 per cent in the mortgage rate &mdash; it is not exactly good news for investors either. 
 Many were just beginning to see shares and unit trusts &mdash; bought two years ago before the crash of 1987 &mdash; regain those levels. 
 This week was a setback. 
 The FT-SE 100 index of leading shares dropped 42 points to 2,270 on the announcement of the base rate increase to 15 per cent, but rallied and closed on Thursday only 30.5 points off at 2,281.6. 
 And the outlook for investors is not bright, according to Brian Tora, of stockbroker James Capel. 
 &bquo;The basic problem is that everything has been pushed out, and we can't see the light at the end of the tunnel, which is bad for shares. 
 &bquo;There is no certainty that the Chancellor will be able to hold base rates at 15 per cent. 
 The trade gap looks appalling and it may take some time before we see a significant drop in consumer spending. 
 If we stick with 15 per cent rates until the Budget, the prospects for positive growth in the economy do not look too good.&equo; 
 The August trade gap was &pound;2bn, the third worst on record. 
 &bquo;A few more trade figures like that and we will see the market fall further.&equo; 
 The last time base rates hit 15 per cent was in 1981 but, as Mr Tora points out, &bquo;in real terms this is the highest the base rate has ever been. 
 Inflation was running at 11 per cent in 1981, but it's only around 8 per cent today. 
 Unless something happens swiftly, the market is going to be uncertain for some time.&equo; 
 So how far is the market likely to fall, and should unit trust and investors in shares consider selling? 
 &bquo;I would be surprised if it doesn't test 2,200,&equo; says Mr Tora, a view shared by others. 
 &bquo;I would not be surprised to see Footsie (FT-SE 100 index) off another 50 points,&equo; says Fred Carr of fund manager Capel-Cure Myers. 
 Chris Tracey, investment director at fund manager Save &amp; Prosper, is even more pessimistic. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't be surprised to see the Footsie at around 2,000 to 2,100.&equo; 
 However, nobody is predicting a repetition of the crash of 1987. 
 &bquo;America is doing very well, there is a lot of liquidity in the market &mdash; and what might happen to the market if Hoylake succeeds in its bid for BAT?&equo; asks Mr Tora. 
 What happens to share prices in the US inevitably affects prices in the UK. 
 In addition, fund managers such as the big pension funds have a constant flow of cash from employee and employer contributions which has to be invested somewhere, and they are currently sitting on a pile of money on deposit. 
 &bquo;The excess of investible funds over the supply of securities looks set to remain for at least another financial year. 
 This may not help the market go up, but it could well ensure that any setback is only modest,&equo; says Mr Tora. 
 And if Hoylake wins its takeover battle for BAT, he believes that other companies will embark on the acquisitions trail, giving the market a boost. 
 &bquo;We have heard a lot about Salomon Brothers&equo; multi-billion pound war chest for acquisitions.&equo; 
 Some sectors of the market, however, will take longer to recover than others. 
 The high street shops will feel the draught most keenly. 
 Homeowners will have less money to spend in their pockets after making higher mortgage repayments and will be even less inclined to borrow at today's high rates. 
 While nobody is recommending investors to indulge in wholesale selling of shares and unit trusts, equally nobody is suggesting a massive buying spree either. 
 &bquo;Interest rates are in the driving seat for the time being and it is still too early to buy,&equo; says Mr Tora. 
 &bquo;The scene does not seem right for a 1987 style crash, but the more cautious will be dusting off the chartist's recommendations to see which shares can still be sold.&equo; 
 Time bomb ticking away under &bquo;budget&equo; borrowers: As the base rate rises 1 per cent both homeowners and investors look set for troubled times ahead 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 BRITAIN'S 7.6 million homebuyers face another rise in mortgage repayments following this week's one per cent hike in bank base rates to 15 per cent. 
 This is its highest level for eight years and will result in an increase of at least one per cent on home loan rates, possibly more. 
 The average borrower with a &pound;30,000 25 year loan will see monthly repayments rise from &pound;278 a month to &pound;298 if the mortgage rate goes to 14.75 per cent as expected. 
 But many borrowers &mdash; nearly 3 million on &bquo;budget&equo; repayment schemes &mdash; won't feel the draught immediately because their monthly repayments are adjusted just once a year. 
 While annual adjustments are popular with lenders, they can create unexpected problems for borrowers who fail to make financial provision for the higher repayments. 
 More important, buyers with 95 per cent loans who may have seen the price of their property slide in recent months could end up with a debt greater than the value of the property. 
 More than 80 per cent of the Halifax's borrowers pay their mortgages on an annually adjusted basis, which is the society's standard practice. 
 These budget or fixed payment schemes are good for lenders. 
 The mortgage rates may fluctuate, but the administration and the repayments remain the same until the time comes to adjust. 
 But are budget schemes good for borrowers? 
 The Halifax argues that borrowers benefit from certainty, but does concede that some people &mdash; who will not pay any more if rates do rise, until next April &mdash; may be seduced into &bquo;a feeling of false prosperity&equo;. 
 When the Halifax last readjusted, it had to accommodate a rise in mortgage rate in 1988 from 10.3 to 13.5 per cent. 
 The average rise was &pound;55 per month, but some borrowers were hit hard. 
 &bquo;We only get complaints when rates move down,&equo; says the Bradford &amp; Bingley. 
 &bquo;Borrowers can pay more when rates move up, but they must come to a branch to make a specific request to do so.&equo; 
 The Cheltenham &amp; Gloucester's approach is typical of the big lenders' attitude to budget schemes. 
 Its own scheme was implemented three and a half years ago, and now 85 per cent of its 250,000 borrowers pay this way. 
 The Leeds Permanent has converted 90 per cent of it members to fixed payments since last year. 
 Not everyone loves budget schemes. 
 The Woolwich insists that it has no plans to introduce them, while the Abbey National believes that fluctuating payments &bquo;show their value in weeks like the one we've just had&equo;. 
 &bquo;The short term benefit of certainty in household budgeting can be more than offset by a nasty shock when the rate is revised,&equo; said the Abbey, which adds that its research reveals no demand for budget schemes. 
 The National &amp; Provincial's experience contradicts this. 
 The society implemented its scheme &bquo;in response to strong consumer demand&equo;. 
 There are three important potential effects of the growth of fixed payment mortgages. 
 First is the drastic effects for the borrower who fails to save up ahead of a re-adjustment when rates rise three or four times in a year. 
 The new monthly payment will accommodate not just the backlog but also the new, expensive rates. 
 Some fear that big rises could precipitate mass defaults next year. 
 This year's adjustment saw some Halifax borrowers experience a sudden rise in mothly payments of &bquo;more than 30 per cent in many cases&equo;. 
 The Bradford &amp; Bingley had a similar experience. 
 &bquo;We treated hardship cases sympathetically, and we feel they have almost all been honourably resolved on both sides. 
 There's no doubt that to operate these schemes you have to be a sensitive lender.&equo; 
 Some commentators feel that budget schemes blunt the effectiveness of interest rates as an economic tool. 
 Britain still has the highest debt to income ratio in Europe and the appetite for credit may not be blunted until the review date comes and with it the monetary day of doom. 
 The &bquo;feeling of false prosperity&equo; may help to fuel demand and inflation. 
 Third is the special tax position of budget scheme borrowers. 
 Income tax relief will fluctuate as levels of interest fluctuate. 
 Borrowers who underpay tax if interest rates rise must give any unpaid interest to the Revenue in the subsequent 12 months. 
 What budget borrowers can expect for next year will depend on when their review date falls. 
 The Halifax and C&amp;G expect to have just one rise to cope with. 
 Others, who caught the February increase in mortgage rates, will be giving their borrowers an unpleasant start to the new year. 
 The Midland launches banking by telephone 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 INSOMNIACS bored with counting sheep can now organise their financial affairs at any time of the day or night, seven days a week with the launch of Firstdirect, Midland Bank's telephone banking service. 
 Customers can call Firstdirect at any time of the day or night at local call rates and be immediately connected to a banking representative who will carry out instructions on the computer. 
 The range of services offered includes cheque and savings accounts, personal loans, mortgages, insurance, bill payment and travel services. 
 &bquo;Because it has no branches, Firstdirect can offer attractive rates of interest on both savings and borrowing,&equo; claims Midland. 
 All cheque account customers will be given an automatic guaranteed overdraft facility, and an all-in-one &pound;100 cheque guarantee, cash machine and Switch debit card. 
 Cash can be withdrawn from the usual Midland Bank, NatWest, and TSB machines. 
 News Round-Up: Investors' safety net 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 AFTER being ill-served for many years by the investment industry, the small investor at last has a choice of funds which follow share indices. 
 If there is not quite an embarrassment of riches, there is enough to make the small investor blush at the choice. 
 The latest vehicle to track the UK market comes from Skandia Life. 
 Skandia's Performance Bond guarantees the return of 95 per cent of capital invested, plus 100 per cent of any increase in the FT-SE 100 index at November 1994. 
 Getting in costs 5 per cent of the amount invested. 
 News Round-Up: A preference for plastic 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 MOST of us prefer to pay for things with plastic rather than paper. 
 According to a Midland Bank survey published this week, only 10 per cent of those questioned said they preferred to use a cheque rather than an electronic debit card. 
 The main perceived benefit was the lack of need to carry cash or cheques. 
 Meanwhile, Barclays has announced plans to more than double its network of wipe-through machines. 
 Its PDQ terminals can read Visa, Access, American Express and Diner's Club cards as well as some store and fuel cards. 
 If Barclays application to join the Switch network &mdash; started by Midland and Royal Bank of Scotland &mdash; is successful the electronic direct debit network will expand by at least 30,000 terminals over the next year and a half. 
 News Round-Up: More PEPs take a bow 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 THE MARCH to popular capitalism proceeds apace. 
 After last week's Revenue announcement that more than &pound;1bn had beep taken by Personal Equity Plans, two new PEPs have been launched this week by stockbrokers Credit Suisse Buckmaster &amp; Moore and life insurance giant Norwich Union. 
 Both offer a choice of direct equity investment and unit trust investment up to the maximum &pound;2,400. 
 Minimum investment for the Norwich Union PEP is &pound;500 into unit trusts or &pound;1,200 into shares. 
 Charges are 6 per cent initially and 1 per cent annually for unit trusts, 5 per cent plus VAT initally and 1 per cent, again plus VAT, annually for shares. 
 News Round-Up: Investing in the Far East 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 &bquo;YOU don't need to outperform the market to make spectacular returns in South-east Asia,&equo; says Jonathan Custance Baker, of James Capel Unit Trust Management, introducing yet another entrant to the index fund market. 
 Just over 18 per cent of the Tiger Index Fund will follow each of the DTI approved markets such as Hong Kong, Singapore and Malaysia and half this percentage will go into others. 
 News Round-Up: Winning loans from Lloyds 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 TAKE OUT a personal loan now and you will have landed yourself with a debt which is, at the most charitable interpretation, expensive. 
 Some might say that typical annual percentage rates of around 24 per cent are crippling. 
 But anyone taking out a loan from Lloyds Bank between Monday and 31 December may win one of five first prizes worth &pound;7,500 each, 20 smaller ones valued at &pound;1,600, or an Olympus camera. 
 The minimum loan is &pound;500, spread over as long as five years. 
 The APR is 23.8 per cent. 
 News Round-Up: Teddy Bear protection 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 MONEY, of course, is no substitute for the loss of life or limb. 
 But it does help. 
 Norwich Union's child insurance policy, the &bquo;Teddy Bear&equo; contract, costs an annual &pound;25 per child. 
 The new scale of payouts makes somewhat grisly reading. 
 It will provide &pound;75,000 for the loss of one or both eyes, hands or feet. 
 Permanent disablement from any profession or occupation entitles a claimant to &pound;100,000, while loss of hearing in both ears is compensated by &pound;30,000. 
 The policy caters for children from three to 18 years of age or when they start work, whichever is the sooner. 
 News Round-Up: Teenage pregnancy 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 THE MYTH that teenage girls become pregnant to qualify for a council house or flat, has finally been exploded. 
 A survey, Young Single Mothers Today, by One Parent Families, &bquo;shows that teenage pregnancy results from a complex set of circumstances and motivations, of which housing is only a minor factor, if considered at all,&equo; explains Sue Slipman, of One Parent Families. 
 News Round-Up: Young savers 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 THE ABBEY National has started an Action Savers Club for children. 
 Young members receive a pennant, a plastic identity card and a comic. 
 The comic is somewhat idealised. 
 It carries edifying tales of four children and a dog finding an old shed and doing it up as a clubhouse. 
 Not an estate agent, a valuer, a lawyer or a property slump in sight. 
 To open an account, children need just &pound;1. 
 There are no notice restrictions on access. 
 News Round-Up: New rate for savers 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 NORWICH &amp; Peterborough Building Society is offering 10.75 per cent net of basic rate tax, fixed for six months. 
 Minimum investment is &pound;5,000 with a maximum of &pound;250,000. 
 Only one deposit may be made and up to &pound;300 a day withdrawn in cash from branches. 
 Larger amounts may be withdrawn by cheque. 
 The pros and cons of fixed rate offers 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 NOT QUITE all hope is lost in this week's interest rate misery. 
 With loan rates virtually certain to move up over the next month to around 14.75 per cent, a line of credit fixed at 12.95 per cent suddenly seems rather attractive. 
 The desirability of the loan is enhanced by the dangerous charm of deferred interest payments. 
 Borrowers can chose to repay with 3 or 5 per cent pared off their monthly repayments. 
 Simon Tyler, of Chase de Vere, says that by taking the 5 per cent deferment &bquo;borrowers can take out a loan for &pound;84,000 and it will cost what a &pound;50,000 repayment would with the Halifax&equo;. 
 The danger, of course, lies in the fact that the deferred interest payments will be rolled up into the capital debt. 
 As long as house prices rise this will present no problem. 
 But if the market is still stagnant or even falling the prospects are worrying &mdash; a higher debt and a lower property value. 
 It is possible to switch out of the loan if interest rates fall, but this will cost a penalty equivalent to one month's interest payments. 
 The Cheltenham &amp; Gloucester has produced a &pound;50m fixed rate loan priced at 13.25 until the end of 1991. 
 The penalty for early redemption is three months' interest. 
 The C &amp; G has &pound;50m to lend which it calls &bquo;a very limited issue&equo;. 
 Chase de Vere (01 930 7242) have a credit line of just &pound;5m. 
 Another entrant to the market is Prolific Life, which is offering short-term loans pitched at 12.45 per cent for a standard loan and 12.95 per cent for the self-certified loan. 
 The loans are fixed until April 1990 to get over what was at the beginning of the week &bquo;the current period of uncertainty&equo; and has now become a gloomy fact. 
 Prolific say that intermediaries do not like the more usual two-to five-year period for fixed rate loans, as these lock borrowers out when interest rates fall. 
 If rates do fall about the time of the next Budget these loans appear to offer reasonable value. 
 However Prolific's strategy seems absurdly short-term. 
 With a typical conveyancing transaction taking at least two months, thanks to the archaic system of conveyancing prevalent in England and Wales, borrowers will be lucky to have the benefit of the fixed rates for more than three months. 
 News Round-Up: High interest cheque account 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 TYNDALL, the fund manager, has released a high interest cheque account aimed at the upper end of the market. 
 Minimum investment is &pound;1,000, and net interest rates are good for cheque accounts at 10.25 per cent for balances below &pound;10,000 and 10.44 per cent above that figure. 
 The account comes with a &pound;100 cheque guarantee card, standing orders, direct debits and free personal accident insurance worth up to twice the outstanding balance on the account. 
 The High Interest Money Account is available both offshore &mdash; through Tyndall's Isle of Man subsidiary &mdash; and onshore through its Bristol office. 
 Offshore accounts offer gross interest. 
 Covering yourself against the expense of going to law: Sue Fieldman describes schemes that insure a policyholder against the risk of legal expenses 
 By SUE FIELDMAN 
 FREE legal protection insurance is on offer to all new and existing Bank of Scotland Premier Visa cardholders from this week. 
 Bank of Scotland has joined forces with the legal insurer Allianz Legal Protection to provide legal fees cover. 
 The plan, known as Lawclub, provides protection up to &pound;50,000 a claim. 
 However, Lawclub is not the panacea for all the legal bills of the affluent Premier Visa cardholders. 
 They have to earn &pound;20,000 a year to qualify for the charge card. 
 You only get cover for the cost of legal fees if you have problems with consumer goods and services bought with the card. 
 If you bought your car with cash you have to foot your own legal bills. 
 There is also cover for legal fees for personal injury suffered in an accident. 
 However, the pursuit of an accident claim as a car driver is excluded. 
 The advantage, with Lawclub &mdash; and all other legal fees insurance &mdash; is the free 24-hour telephone helpline. 
 If you need a legal eagle at midnight, there is one perched at the end of the telephone ready to answer questions on everything from probate to personal accidents, divorce to drink-driving. 
 Furthermore, legal fees insurance undoubtedly gives you legal muscle if you become embroiled in a courtroom battle. 
 Derek Bluston, of the solicitors Malkin Janners, says: &bquo;To get involved in litigation you either have to be very rich or very poor. 
 &bquo;Most people are in between, and this is the niche that should be filled by insurance.&equo; 
 However, legal expenses insurance generally tends to be full of small print and exclusions. 
 The insurers will not cover disputes that arose before the policy was taken out and will not meet legal costs incurred without their approval. 
 Furthermore, the insurers are judge and jury rolled into one &mdash; if they do not think that your case has a reasonable chance of success they will not indemnify you. 
 However, the insurance usually covers not only the insured, but also the pursuit of legal claims by other members of the family. 
 Janet Pressley, of the Legal Protection Group, legal insurers, says: &bquo;In one case our client, his family and their dog were crossing the road, reached a traffic island and the dog went completely berserk &mdash; screaming, writhing and foaming at the mouth. 
 &bquo;Our client touched the ground on the island while he tried to control the dog and received a very strong electric shock. 
 &bquo;It was then that he realised that the whole island was alive. 
 The dog had received a massive electric shock, his children also received shocks and his wife, in trying to comfort the dog, received a nasty bite to her hand. 
 &bquo;Eventually the council concerned made an offer of &pound;1,000 in compensation, but counsel's opinion is that damages in the region of &pound;5,000 are appropriate. 
 A writ for damages has been issued.&equo; 
 There are two basic types of legal expenses policy available for individuals. 
 Cheap add-on policies, such as the supplements to your motor insurance policy, cover legal fees for &bquo;uninsured loss recovery&equo;. 
 These include pursuing a claim for policy excess, car hire charges and loss of the use of one's vehicle. 
 Premiums vary, but typically range from &pound;8 to &pound;10 a year. 
 Add-on policies are also sold as supplements to household insurance. 
 They typically provide cover for consumer disputes, personal injuries and employment matters. 
 The premium is again relatively cheap, depending on the extent of cover, and varies from about &pound;3 to &pound;10. 
 This type of cover is on offer from Allianz, Legal Protection Group, DAS, IRPC and Hambro Legal Protection. 
 There are also more expensive stand-alone policies. 
 But some insurers do not offer this wider cover. 
 The reason for their non-availability will not surprise anyone who has dealings with an insurance company &mdash; the policies apparently attract people who make claims. 
 Brian Knight, of Hambro Legal Protection, says: &bquo;We do not offer a stand-alone policy to the public. 
 Basically our belief is that it is not possible to make a profit. 
 While it (profit) is a nasty word we are all here for one reason. 
 &bquo;Stand-alone policies are bought by people who are going to use them. 
 It is far better to provide low-priced cover which you can add on.&equo; 
 DAS no longer markets its stand-alone policy. 
 &bquo;The experience we had was that the only people who bought it more or less were the people who used it,&equo; says a spokesman. 
 &bquo;You do not get a good spread of risk and it kept putting the premiums up. 
 But we do expect to reintroduce a contract next year.&equo; 
 Allianz, Legal Protection and IRPC offer stand-alone policies. 
 Typically, they cover consumer disputes, personal injury claims, employment matters and inheritance problems. 
 Property disputes are included, but conveyancing costs are not covered. 
 Legal Protection is the only company that provides cover for divorce costs. 
 It is not available in the first year of the policy and in the second year only &pound;250 &mdash; about two hours' worth for a top London matrimonial lawyer -will be met for each party. 
 From year three the maximum is &pound;500. 
 Legal Protection also provides cover for a flat owner in a block of more than four flats to pursue a claim against a freeholder. 
 Allianz and IRPC do not cover divorce or flat disputes. 
 However, Allianz does have a &pound;50,000 limit for every claim. 
 The premium for Allianz's Personal Law Plan is &pound;68 a year by direct debit. 
 IRPC's Personal Legal Assistance Plan costs &pound;70 a year, although it is shortly to rise to &pound;80. 
 There is a &pound;25,000 limit of indemnity per claim, but IRPC excludes one of the biggest areas for disputes &mdash; major building works. 
 Society fined for loan adverts 
 By SUE FIELDMAN 
 WITH THIS week's hike in interest rates, homebuyers should be more careful than ever about advertisements for mortgages with seemingly low rates of interest. 
 Last week, Cheltenham &amp; Gloucester Building Society was prosecuted at Exeter for breaches of the Consumer Credit Act in connection with its mortgage advertising. 
 The case was brought by Devon's trading standards officers. 
 C &amp; G was prosecuted for advertising displayed in branch windows at Exeter and Okehampton. 
 Ken Ellis, county trading standards officer for Devon, said: &bquo;C &amp; G was convicted on three charges of giving more prominence to a flat rate charge rather than the annual percentage rate, and three charges of not including an example in those advertisements. 
 &bquo;There was a fine of &pound;3,000 for these six offences. 
 C &amp; G was also convicted of omitting an invitation to ask for further details in two further advertisements. 
 C &amp; G was fined &pound;250 on each of those offences. 
 The total fines were &pound;3,500 and C &amp; G also had to pay &pound;356 in costs.&equo; 
 A spokeswoman for C &amp; G said: &bquo;We were prosecuted for a technical infringement as the APRs on our posters were not printed boldly enough. 
 &bquo;We are amazed to be prosecuted when currently there are many brokers, other mortgage advertisers, and major building companies who are running ads contrary to the Act which do not mention APR at all, and they are getting away with it. 
 &bquo;C &amp; G, like any building society, is an easy target for trading standards officers compared to other smaller, less well known lenders. 
 It makes a good example for them.&equo; 
 If one big building society can fall foul of the rules, then you can not assume that any lender will get its advertising right. 
 Always check that the interest rate quoted is the annual percentage rate (APR). 
 It is the only true yardstick for comparing different mortgages. 
 &bquo;In an advertisement for a mortgage which contains interest rates, then the APR must be more prominent than any other rate,&equo; said Mr Ellis. 
 The advertisement must also contain an example of the details of payment and the total cost. 
 &bquo;If it does not contain interest rates, then it must include an invitation for readers to get full written details of the terms.&equo; 
 In the C &amp; G advertisements an interest rate of 12.75 per cent, which was the annual flat rate, was more prominent than the APR of 13.7 per cent. 
 However, the worst culprits are those advertisements offering deferred rates. 
 &bquo;A deferred rate mortgage is one where the mortgage is charged all the time at the normal APR, but the consumer only pays at a reduced rate during the early years,&equo; Mr Ellis explained. 
 &bquo;Unpaid interest is added to the balance, so the consumer ends up paying more when payments revert to normal. 
 Anyone who advertises the deferred rate may only do so provided that the APR is more prominent, and they explain all the terms.&equo; 
 In February next year, further changes to mortgage advertsing will be introduced. 
 A spokesman for the Department of Trade and Industry said: &bquo;The changes are generally to make the advertisements clearer and easier to understand. 
 The advertisements must also specify that the loan is secured on the home. 
 Foreign currency mortgages must specify that repayment is affected by fluctuations in exchange rates.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, if you see any advertisements that are misleading, contact your local trading standards officers. 
 Property: Cottage charms 
 By SUE FIELDMAN 
 THE reputed birthplace of Bob Fitzsimmons, world heavyweight boxing champion in 1897, is one of the 100 or more properties to be auctioned by the Bristol and West between 18-20 October. 
 The house (right) at 61 Wendron Street in Helston, Cornwall, has a guide price of &pound;55,000-&pound;70,000 and a blue plaque in honour of Fitzsimmons. 
 It will be auctioned at the Alverton Manor Hotel, Truro, on 19 October, at 3pm. 
 Ferryman's Cottage (left), at Noss Mayo in South Devon, is to be auctioned on its own by Strutt &amp; Parker (0392 215631) on 26 October. 
 The two-bedroom cottage needs refurbishment but it is in a superb location, in the middle of woodland owned by the National Trust and overlooking the River Yealm. 
 The guide price is &pound;150,000. 
 Property: Forward Planning: Making Proposals: Influencing the decision-makers: Allison Flight fills in the background to a planning application 
 By ALLISON FLIGHT 
 THE planning system is designed around the idea that people should have a say in what happens to their immediate surroundings. 
 But how do you find out about whether a planning application has been made in the first place? 
 Whether you are proposing or opposing an application, what is the best way to influence the decision that is eventually made? 
 Finding out about an application: Under section 28 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1971 the planning authority &mdash; usually the local council &mdash; is supposed to advertise certain planning applications in the local newspaper. 
 The proposals covered are development in a conservation area, works to a listed building or which affect the setting of a conservation area or a listed building, and developments in Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty. 
 The planning authority also has to advertise locally any proposals involving large buildings (those more than 20 metres high), or any &bquo;unneighbourly uses&equo; &mdash; such as a casino, scrap yard, cemetery or slaughterhouse &mdash; and put up a notice on the site itself. 
 Some local authorities publish a list of all their new planning applications in the local paper. 
 Often they circulate these lists to local conservation and amenity groups, residents' associations and subscribers. 
 Ring the local planning authority to find out. 
 When the council receives a planning application it often consults people who might be affected such as neighbours, other residents and community groups. 
 The consultation process usually takes the form of a letter describing the application and inviting you to come and look at a copy of the application and any drawings submitted with it. 
 There is no legal obligation on the council to carry out any specific consultation process. 
 However, if the authority concerned has a code of practice dealing with consultation and fails to carry it out, the Local Government Ombudsman may find the authority guilty of &bquo;maladministration&equo;. 
 The planning department of a local council keeps all current planning applications on a register which is available to the public. 
 As a result of recent changes in the copyright laws, if you cannot see the application at the council's offices then you can ask the planning department to send you a copy of the application and the drawings. 
 But this can be expensive, so find out first. 
 If there is a particular site for which you want to be kept informed of any future development, you can ask the planning department to tell you if it receives an application affecting it. 
 How to comment on a proposal: When you make observations on a planning application you should only comment on planning grounds. 
 This will exclude many issues which are probably important to you personally, such as the fact that a development will reduce the value of your property or spoil your view. 
 The council will take a number of factors into account when making up its mind whether to give a development the go-ahead. 
 These will include: Does the scheme comply with the policies contained in its local plan? 
 Is the proposed use compatible with the surrounding area? 
 Will there be enough parking provision and will the development cause traffic problems once it is complete? 
 The design of the building, particularly its bulk and size. 
 Any loss of daylight or sunlight to adjoining properties. 
 These matters will be looked at before a firm decision is taken. 
 The council can negotiate with the applicant in advance to ask for changes to the scheme and these can result in new drawings being submitted. 
 Be careful: if you were asked by the council to comment on the original application, it may only inform you of these new drawings if you specifically ask. 
 If you are particularly worried about a proposal, it may be possible to make an appointment with the appropriate planning officer for a meeting, either in the council offices or on site, so you can explain your objections in person. 
 The planning officer is an employee of the council who handles the application up to the point when it is put to the planning committee, made up of elected councillors, for a decision. 
 He or she will usually make a recommendation to the committee about what its decision should be, but it does not have to follow this advice. 
 There is a set time allowed for the council to receive comments on an application. 
 This varies but it will be stated in the consultation letter. 
 If you have not had time to object, contact the planning officer and ask for extra time. 
 He may agree, and he is often the one who decides what issues will be dealt with and when. 
 The committee may only meet once a month. 
 All comments should be in writing and these letters are made available to the public when the case is decided. 
 If the council receives a large number of letters about a development, this will give it an idea of the strength of feeling involved and it is much better than a petition. 
 Many councillors take the view that it is easy to drum up names for a petition although you may have more impact if, say, the petition is restricted to immediate neighbours of the development. 
 Nevertheless, just because a lot of objections are received does not automatically mean an application will be refused. 
 If the development is large or controversial, it may be worth forming an action group to give local opposition a focus. 
 If you are applying for planning permission yourself, include a letter stating the planning merits of your proposal and also any personal circumstances you think are relevant &mdash; for example, that you are building an extension for an elderly relative. 
 If you think your application will be unpopular (such as a mini-cab office or a bed and breakfast hostel), you can ask the council for a &bquo;personal&equo; or &bquo;limited period&equo; planning permission, so the council can review the situation at a later date. 
 How the planning committee makes up its mind. 
 When the council has considered all the factors involved, the case will either be decided by the chief planning officer under delegated powers (if it is a minor or uncontroversial issue) or it will be decided by the elected councillors at the planning committee meeting. 
 To influence the decision in your favour, contact the planning department to find out whether an application is to be heard at committee or dealt with under delegated powers. 
 If the case is going to committee you are able to see the agenda and relevant background papers three working days in advance of the meeting, which will be held in public. 
 This right is given to members of the public under the Access to Information Act 1985. 
 If there is an application you feel strongly about, find out the names of the councillors on the planning committee from the planning department or &bquo;members&equo; secretariat' of the council. 
 Write a letter stating your objections or support for the application and send a copy to every member as well as the chief planning officer. 
 Contact your ward councillor and try to interest him or her &mdash; even if they are not on the committee they may be able to influence the councillors who will take the decision. 
 They may also be able to tell you some of the preferences of those councillors, which can make a big difference to how you lobby them. 
 The actual meeting will be open to the public. 
 Sometimes a limited number of people will be allowed to address the councillors for or against a proposal at the meeting. 
 This is fixed in advance. 
 Often there is a limit on numbers and it works on a first-come-first-served basis. 
 Talk to the planning officer beforehand. 
 Whether an application is dealt with by the council in committee or under delegated powers, you should receive a letter stating the outcome of the case if you submitted comments. 
 Property Update: Priory status 
 By ALLISON FLIGHT 
 ONE of Norfolk's oldest houses, a twelfth-century converted priory at Horsham St Faith, five miles outside Norwich, has come up for sale through the Prudential (0603 761600) for &pound;350,000 The house's rarity is reflected in its Grade I listed status. 
 There are only about 550 Grade I listed properties in Norfolk, more than 400 of which are churches. 
 The 10-roomed priory was converted into a house in Tudor times, and has medieval wall paintings, including a larger-than-life size crucifixion scene and a 30-ft long series of paintings dealing with the priory's foundation, thought to be among the finest in Europe. 
 Property Update: Tenants' protection 
 By ALLISON FLIGHT 
 SHELTER has called for urgent legislation to protect people buying their homes on &bquo;rental purchase&equo; &mdash; a form of credit. 
 In a report, Rental Purchase: The Case for Change, the housing pressure group says that people buying properties on rental purchase schemes &mdash; common in the north of England for cheaper property &mdash; should be protected as if they were assured tenants under the Housing Act 1988, and landlords should be responsible for all repairs. 
 Property Update: Skye's the limit 
 By ALLISON FLIGHT 
 THREE small estates and three separate cottages on the beautiful Knoydart peninsula opposite the Isle of Skye, for sale through Frank &amp; Rutley (031 225 7105), will appeal to lovers of the wilds of Scotland. 
 Prices for the cottages start at &pound;35,000 and for the estates at &pound;85,000. 
 All the properties overlook the sea and there is a small village nearby; the harbour has a pier with a regular ferry service too and from Mallaig. 
 Nevertheless the peninsula is remote &mdash; there are deep sea lochs on either side, Loch Nevis (meaning Heaven) to the south has a mild protected climate, Loch Hourn (meaning Hell) to the north is far less hospitable. 
 Property Update: Sheltered slump 
 By ALLISON FLIGHT 
 SALES of sheltered housing units are falling because older people cannot find buyers to purchase their existing properties. 
 The Retirement Care Group, a company which specialises in managing retirement schemes, estimates that more than 4,000 sheltered properties are on the market and that builders have cut their original forecast of 12,000 units built this year back to about 8,000 as a result. 
 Property Update: Grape chance 
 By ALLISON FLIGHT 
 AN unusual opportunity has come up to buy an English vineyard. 
 Three Corners Vineyard (below) at Woodnesborough near Sandwich, in Kent, produced nearly three tons of Siegerrebe, Ortega and Reichensteiner grapes this year. 
 It is up for sale because its owner, Lieutentant-Colonel Charles Galbraith, plans to retire. 
 Property Update: Chimney sweeps 
 By ALLISON FLIGHT 
 FOR those baffled by a smoky or cracking chimney, a new free booklet may be able to offer some help. 
 It has been produced by CICO, the chimney linings service, and describes how a chimney works, the typical problems it will suffer from and then offers various solutions. 
 Property Update: Small works 
 By ALLISON FLIGHT 
 IF you are contemplating home improvements, it is worth using a builder covered by the Building Employers Confederation's guarantee scheme for small works. 
 The BEC has just doubled the amounts covered by its scheme. 
 Protection where the BEC builder is employed by the customer (known as a standard contract) is being increased from projects worth &pound;500-&pound;40,000 to those worth &pound;500-&pound;100,000. 
 If the builder is employed by an architect or contractor working for a client (known as a supervised contract) the upper limit for cover is being increased to &pound;125,000. 
 Property Update: Witty ad winner 
 By ALLISON FLIGHT 
 THIS week's winner of our Witty Ad of the Week competition, Mrs Terry Jones, has concocted a fine recipe for selling her London flat. 
 The resulting dish, which appears on page 49, sounds filling rather than delicious, and should in no circumstances be flipped. 
 Mrs Jones wins a free three-week insertion for her advertisement, plus a bottle of champagne. 
 The competition runs for another two weeks, so time is running out if you have a house or flat to sell and want to enter. 
 Property: Houses that are going, going, gone: Fed up with trying to sell, more people are auctioning their home instead. 
 Andrew Bibby reports 
 By ANDREW BIBBY 
 IN THE small Devon town of South Molton, Julie Widlake is waiting with anticipation for Friday 20 October. 
 She and her boyfriend have had their future planned for some time: they want to start farming in a nearby village, where they also intend to build a bungalow. 
 First, they have to sell their present house, a two-bedroom cottage in the centre of the town. 
 As is the case almost everywhere else, the market in Devon is depressed and selling has not been easy. 
 So instead of waiting indefinitely for a buyer, they have decided to try selling their house by auction. 
 It comes under the hammer at 2.15pm on the 20th, at the Barnstaple Motel. 
 &bquo;We accept that we might not get very much for it, but on the other hand we could get more,&equo; says Julie Widlake. 
 &bquo;We've been waiting to move for a long time, and we need the money to build the new house.&equo; 
 Their South Molton cottage (guide price &pound;44,000-&pound;46,000) is one of more than 20 lots to be put up for sale at the Barnstaple auction by Bristol and West Property Services, and one of more than a hundred which the building society subsidiary will be auctioning in eight West Country venues over a three-day period. 
 Bristol and West claims these auctions will help to bring some action to an otherwise slow market, and says it was overwhelmed by the response from people wanting to sell in this way. 
 Auctions certainly speed up the house-buying process. 
 Once the hammer has fallen, the successful bidder for a house must exchange contracts immediately and pay a deposit. 
 Completion normally takes place four to eight weeks later and there is no opportunity for second thoughts. 
 As the Bristol and West explains, if a bidder does not sign the contract, the auctioneer can sign on their behalf. 
 &bquo;From the vendor's point of view, the house is actually sold once a successful bid is made,&equo; says Graham Harrison, director of Bristol and West Property Services. 
 &bquo;Many people have suffered from sales falling through and from house-buying chains, and some of our vendors feel that now's as good a time as any to sell.&equo; 
 From the purchasers' point of view, auctions can also be attractive &mdash; if slightly nerve-racking as you wait for bidding to start for the house of your dreams. 
 The problem is that normally potential purchasers have to incur the expense of undertaking surveys and arranging mortgage finance, without any idea whether they will be able to afford the final selling price. 
 Not surprisingly, several estate agents report difficulties at the moment in attracting enough serious bidders. 
 &bquo;With an auction, you've got to be certain that at least two buyers are there who can commit themselves, and the difficulty is that buyers who can proceed are few and far between,&equo; said David Phillip, a director of Yorkshire estate agents Dacre Son and Hartley. 
 Bristol and West hopes that by arranging collective auctions it will be able to overcome this problem. 
 It is also guaranteeing mortgages at 1 per cent below the normal interest rate, for endowment or pension-linked policies, on several of the houses up for sale, an interesting and innovative service for would-be bidders (mortgage surveys will already have been undertaken for these houses). 
 The building society will be staffing a mortgage desk at each auction, and says buyers could arrange finance there and then, subject of course to proof of income and status. 
 Obviously, however, Bristol and West hopes to hear from interested people in advance &mdash; if only so it can gauge the likely demand for each property before the auction starts. 
 &bquo;We're trying to smooth the path for purchasers, and streamline the system,&equo; says Graham Harrison, pointing out that live telephone bidding will also be available for those unable to attend. 
 Holiday homes and commercial property have been included among the lots to be auctioned. 
 Although collective property auctions take place regularly in London (often primarily for investors rather than house-hunters), in country areas the more typical auction will be just for one house, and as likely as not will take place in a nearby pub or village hall. 
 In fact, country auctions are often the nearest many villages get to live theatre. 
 &bquo;The locals come for the entertainment, and to see who's buying into their village,&equo; observed one auction-goer. 
 Pub landlords are usually only too happy to provide free accommodation. 
 &bquo;It's very exciting and gets the adrenalin going,&equo; says David Phillip, whose firm usually undertakes auctions in the Otley area. 
 Only certain types of property normally come to auction, however. 
 Traditionally, country cottages and houses which have unusual or unique features or are in need of a lot of renovation may be auctioned, if only because valuation is likely to be difficult. 
 Sometimes, too, houses have to be sold by auction to satisfy the legal requirements of trustees or executors (auctions provide adequate proof that the property has been sold at the going market value, and protect trustees from future claims of negligence). 
 Less happily, but for the same reason, repossessed houses are often auctioned. 
 Anyone considering selling by auction needs to be aware that the costs involved will be higher. 
 Advertising costs and any expenses incurred in hiring premises are normally passed on by the estate agents to the vendor, whether or not the auction results in a sale. 
 In addition, agents may charge slightly more commission than usual for a successful sale. 
 In Bristol and West's forthcoming auctions, a set fee of &pound;375 plus VAT will be charged to everyone entering property to sell, with its usual agent's commission (about 2 per cent plus VAT) charged on top when sales are made. 
 &bquo;We accept that we could lose the money we've paid to go to auction, but that's a risk we're prepared to take,&equo; says Julie Widlake. 
 The secret of a successful outcome depends partly on setting the right reserve price, a task the auctioneer undertakes in conjunction with the seller. 
 Normally, the reserve is set only days or hours before the auction, when the agents will already have a good indication of how much interest has been shown. 
 Too high a reserve price can mean no sale, and disappointment all round. 
 &bquo;You need to understand what your clients&equo; expectations are beforehand,&equo; says Graham Harrison of Bristol and West. 
 Agents and their clients may also have the dilemma of deciding whether to accept any offers made prior to the auction. 
 Inevitably they do not always get it right. 
 Peter Crowther, managing director of a Leeds business centre, recently bought two semi-detached stone cottages in Bramhope, on the outskirts of Leeds, at an auction in the village pub. 
 His successful bid was for &pound;190,000 although he had made a higher prior offer which had been turned down. 
 On the other hand, sometimes the drama of the auction and the competition between bidders can have the opposite effect. 
 Another recent auction in Leeds saw a run-down stone farmhouse without water or other amenities finally fall under the hammer for &pound;330,500. 
 &bquo;Success is by no means guaranteed at auction,&equo; says Graham Harrison. 
 &bquo;In a tough market you need to get the programme right, the price right and have a little bit of luck.&equo; 
 Bristol and West Property Services (0272 294271) has produced a brochure covering all eight West Country auctions. 
 Racing: Prix de L'Arc de Triomphe: Britain's faith in Class value: Europe's richest race brings another opportunity for Britain's most fearless trainer to tilt at a top prize. 
 John Karter examines Clive Brittain's ambitious aims for Top Class and runs the rule over his Arc rivals 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 FOLLOWERS of Clive Brittain are once again marvelling at bookmakers' largesse over their assessment of tomorrow's Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe. 
 The Newmarket trainer runs Top Class in the Longchamp spectacular and the faithful backing Brittain will expect to be laughing all the way to the bank as they help themselves to the generous 40-1 on offer. 
 Like many in the sport, the men who make the odds view the bold Brittain as racing's version of Don Quixote. 
 What the cynics overlook, however, is that when Brittain tilts at windmills, it is the windmills that frequently come off second best. 
 Perhaps Brittain has been the chief contributor to his reputation by running horses in events in which they appear out of their depth. 
 However, he has bagged an enviable collection of major prizes, including two Classics, the 1,000 Guineas and St Leger. 
 Those who have cottoned on to the streak of genius in Brittain's seemingly eccentric modus operandi have struck a rich vein of gold as the stable's horses are often priced a good deal longer than they should be. 
 Helping punters outwit the bookies is something that gives Brittain real pleasure and he recalls with pride how an acquaintance made an exceptionally nice profit when the trainer's Terimon took second place to Nashwan in this year's Derby. 
 At odds of 500-1, Terimon became the longest-priced horse ever to be placed in the Epsom Classic. 
 &bquo;A man I know who works in a tailor's shop in London backed Terimon in a forecast with Nashwan at 2,000-1,&equo; Brittain explains. 
 &bquo;He won enough to set himself up in his own business, so if you see a &bquo;Terimon Cafe&equo; on the outskirts of London you'll know how it got the name.&equo; 
 Brittain categorically denies that he is merely &bquo;having a go&equo; when he flies in the face of the form book. 
 &bquo;I think a lot more about it than people realise,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;And I never run a horse unless I think it's got a real chance.&equo; 
 Rarely on the defensive when questioned about his charges &mdash; unlike so many of his tight-lipped contemporaries &mdash; his attacking policy has reaped a particularly golden harvest overseas. 
 Boldly going where no man has gone before has brought Brittain success on an unprecedented scale. 
 His victories with Pebbles in the Breeders' Cup Turf and Jupiter Island in the Japan Cup &mdash; the only successes by a Briton in the events &mdash; were superb feats, but perhaps even more laudable was his achievement in saddling Bold Arrangement to take second in the Kentucky Derby, a unique venture the know-alls told him was not even worth attempting. 
 By comparison to what Top Class undertook earlier this year, the trip to Paris will seem like a canter up the road. 
 In March he provided Brittain with another sizeable slice of foreign currency by finishing second in Australia's Tancred International. 
 The fact that he travels well is not the only thing in Top Class's favour, as Brittain explains. 
 &bquo;Like so many of High Top's stock, Top Class is developing late. 
 He's fit and ready to run for his life. 
 It's the race of his life and he should get the result of his life.&equo; 
 Top Class ran a fine Arc trial when third to Nashwan and Cacoethes in Ascot's King George VI and Queen Elizabeth Stakes, the same position filled by Tony Bin last year before he went on to win the Arc. 
 Brittain believes that Top Class would have caused Nashwan and Cacoethes a lot more problems had he not gone to the front so early. 
 &bquo;I've told Michael Roberts to come a lot later this time,&equo; Brittain says.&equo; 
 That will take some nerve from the South African jockey, whose final flourish on Mtoto last year failed so narrowly. 
 Racing is often cruelly unfair, however, and while Top Class looks marvellous each-way value, Brittain's dreams of victory could be wrecked by Golden Pheasant, a horse he trained in the early part of the season. 
 A disagreement with Golden Pheasant's American owner over the sale of the colt after he had finished second to Old Vic in the Chester Vase, led to Brittain asking her to remove all her horses. 
 Golden Pheasant was sold to a Californian millionaire, Bruce McNall, despite Brittain offering to buy the horse himself. 
 Now in the care of a young Englishman, Jonathan Pease, at Chantilly, Golden Pheasant inflicted Nashwan's only defeat when he took the Prix Niel over the Arc course and distance three weeks ago and, being lightly raced, he looks capable of improvement. 
 French Glory, who deprived Nashwan of second in the Niel, has the assistance of Pat Eddery, who will be trying for a record fifth Arc win. 
 Khalid Abdullah's colt must be respected, as must the French filly Young Mother, winner of the Prix Vermeille over the Arc course and Brittain's fancy. 
 Before the Arc, Luca Cumani's Statoblest may maintain the successful run of raiders in the Prix de l'Abbaye, in which there are five other British runners. 
 The British also make a strong challenge for the other big prizes at Longchamp, with Light Of Morn in today's Prix Dollar and Dancing Tribute in tomorrow's Prix de l'Opera our best chances. 
 Judo: White remains the stylist in a world of brute force: Philip Nicksan meets a fighter on the mat after throwing his weight around on behalf of the British judo team 
 By PHILIP NICKSAN 
 EVER since Neil Adams retired, Densign White has been the spokesman and leader of the British men's judo squad. 
 This is partly because he has become the man most likely to win medals in the top competitions abroad &mdash; including the World Championships in Belgrade which start on Tuesday &mdash; notwithstanding his curiously fragile physique. 
 Far from the rugged nature of most combat sportsmen, he has been sidelined by injuries only too often during his career, though, in his eight-year period as Britain's top middleweight, he has won two European silver medals, a world bronze medal, and two Olympic fifth places. 
 His captaincy is partly due to his quiet, controlled manner and a confidence and authority that unnerves his opponents &mdash; on and off the competition mat. 
 Last month he was hauled before the management committee of the British Judo Association to explain a series of criticisms he had made in The Independent after the poor British results at the European Championships in Helsinki last May. 
 He stands by what he said, and, sadly, many of his criticisms are still valid: the team have still not bought a video camera despite a large injection of cash from the Sports Council and no one could say that the preparation training for the world championships &mdash; one weekend in the Kendal Judo Club &mdash; has been anything but derisory. 
 White duly came down to London from his home in Wolverhampton &mdash; he is the senior member of a remarkable quartet of Elvis Gordon, Dennis Stewart and the banned Kerrith Brown who have all won medals at world level, yet all train in the back room of an Edwardian bath house. 
 White faced the official carpeting, defused the attacks with a firm but polite dignity, and went off to catch the next train unaffected by the experience. 
 He went straight back on to the mat to work with his judo partner of a decade and more, Brown. 
 Characteristically, he refuses to make any secret of his work with Brown, whose Olympic drugs ban has one more year to run; nor, in loyal fashion, does he have any doubts that Brown will return to competition and go straight to the top. 
 &bquo;There isn't a man in Britain who would be able to touch him at lightweight or light middleweight,&equo; he said. 
 Brown has been important to White because he provides the top-level training practice that has been so lacking in the build-up to this world championships. 
 Ten years ago, they toured the domestic junior competitions as gangly, gawky youths, winning most of them, and riding the knocks with humour. 
 White was a stylist then, and remains so. 
 He is the only middleweight to have beaten Austria's double Olympic champion, Peter Seisenbacher twice - and convincingly too. 
 When in peak condition, White is one of the most stylish throwers in a game which only too easily breaks down into brutishness. 
 His range alone is impressive: he can spring into a left uchimata (inner thigh throw) then twist right into a seoi-nage (shoulder throw) and still retain sufficient balance to produce a sparkling footsweep which will send his opponent crashing to the ground. 
 Even on a bad day he is worth watching, for a few seconds of his lightning, elegant attacks eclipses an evening of mauling aggression. 
 &bquo;Judo has always been a technical sport for me &mdash; it must be the most complex of any in the Olympic Games,&equo; White said. 
 Sadly, there are no points for style in judo competitions. 
 To win, you must throw your opponent, ideally on his back; or dispose of him on the ground with an armlock, strangle or 30 second hold. 
 It is a tough uncompromising business, and one where a man like White seems curiously out of place. 
 Not so. 
 &bquo;If I don't go on the mat for a few days, I get withdrawal symptoms,&equo; he confesses. 
 He shrugs off his legacy of injuries &mdash; a fractured bone in his back, ripped Achilles tendons, the deep bruise on his face which he picked up on the way to winning a bronze medal in Poland. 
 That was four weeks ago but it is still evident. 
 There is scarcely a useful middleweight in the world whom he has not beaten with the one exception of the world champion, Fabien Canu of France. 
 Twice, White lost European finals to him;, on the last occasion, in 1988, he lost on a rather harsh penalty, but knew that at last he had the measure of the Frenchman. 
 White is not making any rash predictions for this coming affair. 
 &bquo;My main fault in the last few years, is being too laid back. 
 I didn't get thrown very often, but that is no good if you still don't win a medal at the end of the day. 
 &bquo;Now, I have decided to fight in a more open style. 
 I am getting thrown a little more, but I feel stronger and better with a lot more aggression.&equo; 
 He declines to comment on the chances of the rest of the team, saying only that all have lacked the intensive training, with a sojourn in Japan, which they really needed. 
 &bquo;British men's judo is not in a very good state,&equo; he said, more with honesty than pessimism. 
 &bquo;I don't feel there are any young players coming through to threaten my position which is not good for me. 
 &bquo;But we will all go and make the best of a bad situation. 
 We are not a rubbish team, but frankly any medal will be a bonus.&equo; 
 Basketball: Glorious Celtics take the honours 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 BRACKNELL Tigers and Livingston are Britain's survivors in Europe following their wins in the Champions Cup on Thursday night, but the week's honours went to Oldham Broadway Celtics, who made a glorious exit from the Korac Cup with a 98-91 win over Monaco in France. 
 Oldham trailed 91-85 with one minute and 50 seconds to play in their first-round, second-leg tie, but outscored the wealthy French 13-0 to win 98-91. 
 They lost 203-186 on aggregate, and on the long cost-saving coach drive back to Lancashire the players had ample time to contrast their status with that of Monaco. 
 Prince Rainier finances most of his team's annual budget of &pound;800,000. 
 His opposite number in Oldham, the mayor of the metropolitan borough council, had the best value this week, however, after the authority topped up Celtics' annual budget of &pound;35,000 to finance short-term contracts for two extra players, Dip Donaldson and George Branch. 
 Both will play tomorrow at Gateshead for the defending National League champions, who cannot afford too many more domestic slips following their opening-day defeat at unbeaten Brixton. 
 Oldham's task at Gateshead may have been eased by the Tynesiders' dismissal earlier this week of their American guard, Darryl Thomas. 
 In the Champions Cup, Bracknell and Livingston now face the two most powerful teams in Europe. 
 Livingston play title-holders Jugoplastika Split, of Yugoslavia, while Bracknell face the 1987 and 1988 champions, Philips Milan. 
 Bracknell defeated Keflavik 106-91 in Iceland on Thursday for a 250-196 aggregate win, and are at home to Milan in the first leg on Thursday 26 October. 
 The Week in Review: Sport 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 SUNDAY: Mark Calcavecchia's single-stroke win over Japan's Hajime Meshiai at St Andrews secures the Dunhill Cup and a measure of Ryder Cup consolation for the United States. 
 There is some consolation, too, for Formula One world champion, Ayrton Senna, for last week's crunch with Nigel Mansell in Portugal. 
 He takes first place in the Spanish Grand Prix at Jerez, although Alain Prost comes third to keep him on course for Senna's title. 
 MONDAY: With the qualifying match against Poland imminent, England's World Cup aspirations are raised when Bryan Robson, out with a fracture in his leg for 10 days, is unexpectedly named in Manchester United's squad for Tuesday's Littlewoods Cup tie against Portsmouth. 
 Nashwan, his trainer, Dick Hern, announces, will not be racing in Sunday's Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe at Longchamp, the scene of his only defeat. 
 TUESDAY: Robson comes through unscathed against Portsmouth, as United go through on aggregate. 
 Steve Whitton scores four goals and Dalian Atkinson three as Sheffield Wednesday increase their goalscoring record this season by 500 per cent, beating Aldershot 8-0 in their tie. 
 Third Division leaders Tranmere knock out Ipswich Town of the Second. 
 There is a minor triumph for British tennis when Jo Durie, Clare Wood and Anne Hobbs beat Indonesia 3-0 in the first round of the Federation Cup in Tokyo. 
 WEDNESDAY: Success is brief for Durie, Wood and Hobbs when they are knocked out 2-1 by Austria. 
 It emerges that Michael Knighton, the man who would be Manchester United chairman, is seeking help to salvage his attempted &pound;20m takeover. 
 Eddy Shah, the former national newspaper proprietor, is one of his contacts. 
 In the Littlewoods Cup, Scarborough, two goals down to Chelsea, score three times in seven minutes to go through 4-3 on aggregate. 
 A bright future &mdash; or at least a possible meeting with Mike Tyson &mdash; beckons for British heavyweight champion Gary Mason after he knocks out Tyrell Biggs in the seventh round of their Albert Hall bout. 
 THURSDAY: As the Old Trafford soap opera unfolds, Martin Edwards, United's chief executive, begins legal proceedings against Knighton for alleged breach of confidentiality in their dealings. 
 Ajax join English clubs in European exile, as UEFA bans the club for the next two years they qualify for Europe, as punishment for the previous week's crowd trouble, when the Austria Vienna goalkeeper was felled by a metal spike. 
 FRIDAY: The good news of Robson's call-up to the England squad is tempered by the withdrawal of Liverpool's John Barnes with a hamstring injury. 
 Knighton is reported to be ready to abandon his takeover bid. 
 Rugby League: Whitehead &bquo;off lightly&equo; 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 CRAIG WHITEHEAD, a Nottingham City forward, was yesterday banned for eight matches for the elbow tackle which smashed Jason Ramshaw's jaw, nose and cheekbone, and also may face a private prosecution on behalf of the 20-year-old Halifax player. 
 Halifax are considering legal redress after dismissing Whitehead's sentence, lengthy by normal standards, as &bquo;extraordinarily lenient&equo;. 
 &bquo;We were looking for 12 matches or even 16,&equo; David Brook, the club president, said. 
 &bquo;The League saw a video which clearly showed the elbow raised in an unprovoked attack on an inexperienced and defenceless opponent. 
 Anywhere other than a rugby pitch it would have been common assault. 
 Ramshaw is in a terrible mess, he will not play again this year, and he deserves better protection.&equo; 
 Brook's concern was compounded when Dick Fairbank, a Halifax forward dismissed in the same match for a transgression described by his president as &bquo;mere retaliatory fisticuffs&equo;, received a five-match ban. 
 &bquo;Either Fairbank's punishment is disproportionate, or Whitehead got off lightly,&equo; Brook said. 
 &bquo;The League appear to be saying that the difference between scrapping and cynical wounding is just three matches.&equo; 
 The other club to fall foul of the disciplinary committee yesterday was St Helens, who travel to Wakefield tomorrow without Roy Haggerty and Stuart Evans, both banned for four matches. 
 They were dismissed against Oldham last week, Evans in the final minute of a 36-6 defeat, after missing the start of the season through injury. 
 Evans, like Haggerty, is not in the Saints side for his cerebral contribution, though there was evidence against New Zealand last week that the giant prop is at last gaining an understanding of his league potential. 
 The Kiwi tour continues at Wigan, where after the Oldham upset, the home side need a confidence booster almost as badly as the visitors, whose efforts so far have been disjointed. 
 Jonathan Davies, almost disjointed in a literal sense in the act of try-scoring on Wednesday, will get a run in his favoured stand-off position if Tony Myler misses the new world champions' next challenge, Sheffield Eagles at Bramall Lane. 
 This afternoon, Kevin Tamati, last seen demonstrating an ability to talk fellow television commentators into submission, finds himself the object of Granada's broadcast as his new charges look for first points from Leigh. 
 Tamati has taken on a lot but life from here should not be dull for Salford's long-suffering support. 
 Hockey: Ealing's chance 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 EALING can take advantage of England squad calls and move to the top of the Typhoo Women's National League today as two games involving teams with three or more players in the squad have been postponed, writes Bill Colwill. 
 England play the Soviet Union at Luton and Leicester's game at Sutton Coldfield was an early postponement. 
 Slough's home match with Clifton has also being called off following Sue Chandler's call to the colours. 
 Slough already had Karen Brown and Kate Parker, their captain, on duty at Luton. 
 With Slough absent, Ealing should take over the leadership when they travel to Ottery St Mary to play Exmouth. 
 The Devon side went down only 2-1 at Leicester last week, but Ealing are a different proposition. 
 Sports Diary: Rugby Union: Andrew says it with flowers 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 THE FRENCH love to lay on the style and their over-the-top preliminaries - world's biggest scrum, Un Show Laser &mdash; to this week's Bicentenary match against the Lions in Paris gave the evening a sense of occasion which the rugby itself also justified. 
 But the pomp and splendour did not go down so well with Craig Chalmers. 
 The Scottish stand-off, who was among the Lions replacements, was forced to parade, bouquet in hand, from behind one set of posts to the red carpet on the half-wayline as chaperone to Mireille Mathieu, the French songstress who had just rendered all three verses of the Marseillaise (with the chorus repeated each time). 
 The anthem, flower-presentation, long walk and interminable announcements all took place after the teams had taken the field, where they were forced to kick their heels in a neat line for nearly a quarter of an hour during which the chanteuse and the French Army choir six times exhorted the crowd: &bquo;To Arms!&equo;. 
 Mireille eventually met Rob Andrew, the Lions captain, and he too ended up with a bouquet, which he was still wondering how to dispose of as his players began to line up. 
 Andrew did most horribly revenge. 
 The game afoot, he vented his embarrassment by scoring the Lions' first try after 64 seconds. 
 Cry God for Rob. 
 Sports Diary: Football: Disguised price rise for Stoke programme 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 THE POTTERY kilns adorning Stoke's programme for the derby with Port Vale - &bquo;Special Edition, &pound;1&equo; &mdash; looked a nice local touch. 
 They were actually there to obscure the original price of 80p&hellip; no wonder The Oatcake fanzine sold well at 30p. 
 We trust Vale chairman Bill Bell enjoyed his pen portrait. 
 &bquo;Dedicated to making Vale No. 1 team in the Potteries, Bill also wants to find the Lost City of Atlantis, be first man to walk the Channel, and skateboard up Everest.&equo; 
 Sports Diary: Quotes of the Week 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 I am not touting the club around. 
 Michael Knighton, on Manchester United. 
 We have now got him down to 10 pints and a bucket of chips. 
 Ken Roberts, Eccleshall manager, on dietary habits of 20st goalkeeper Sid Kelly. 
 I've told my son that I am going to get him a forged passport that will get him into the opposition penalty area. 
 Brian Clough, on striker Nigel. 
 I did not ask for the job, it was offered to me. 
 I am not willing to be interviewed only to be compared with the chief executive of some Midlands council. 
 Gordon Taylor, candidate for Football League's chief executive. 
 We have to accept this is showbiz now, not a sport. 
 John Watson, on punishment imposed on Nigel Mansell. 
 People said I was too old in 1985, but I had confidence in my own ability. 
 I still have, but now my legs aren't quite as young as I feel. 
 John Ferguson, Canberra Raiders wing, recalling &bquo;85 RL cup final when playing for Wigan. 
 Favourite food: 32oz steak-with-everything. 
 Hucknall Town FC programme feature on left-back Phil Towle. 
 It will take a little time for me to forget the hurt and the disappointment&hellip; 
 I am not sorry I undertook the captaincy again &mdash; I genuinely wanted to do it successfully. 
 I am just sorry it has all ended in this way. 
 David Gower. 
 Even a repeat of Hawaii Five-O will get more viewers than most sport. 
 Derek Brandon, of sports producers Grandslam. 
 Anybody who swears allegiance to United must share the same sense of dismay at what has happened, and what is still going on &mdash; for me, it's almost a sense of revulsion. 
 No more shabby deals. 
 Pat Crerand, on Manchester United. 
 Sports Diary: Football: Crystal Palace's Lifeline winner 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 LOOKS thrilled to bits, doesn't he? 
 Maybe Crystal Palace's Lifeline winner had no need of &pound;1,000, or there's something unpleasant in that handshake. 
 Perhaps he wanted second prize; not Jim Rosenthal's Book of Banal Alliteration, but two tickets to the US and &pound;300 in cash. 
 Was third prize a round-the-world trip plus &pound;500? 
 Sports Diary: Lookalike: Muriel Gray / Monica Seles 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 THE MONICKER'S different but Monica's very much alike, claims Steve Tivey, from Wellingborough, after watching Muriel Gray, ScotNat television presenter, and Monica Seles, expat tennis pretender. 
 &bquo;Or could they be, in any way, related?&equo; 
 Sports Diary: Football: Statue of liberties 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 NOT many football clubs have had 27 martyrs on their books and beaten Real Madrid. 
 The Jesuit College of St Alban, an English seminary in Valladolid, this month celebrates the 400th anniversary of its foundation, the programme including Mass in Westminster Cathedral but, sadly, no return of the 1907 fixture with Real which the college won, though the result seems to have been lost in some priest-hole of history. 
 St Alban's never had a player capped, though many of their lads have gone on to be decapitated, especially in internationals. 
 The club mascot, a statue of Our Lady Vulnerata (the wounded Maradona?) was hacked about in 1589 by some (Lord) Essex supporters on their way back from Cadiz, but still stands in the chapel, a focus of prayer. 
 Perhaps Manchester United should borrow it. 
 Sports Diary: Football: Millwall quivers 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 &bquo;FORGET your worries, take up archery&equo;, advised an item in a programme last week. 
 &bquo;Archery is a great tonic &mdash; quiet, non-polluting and you get your ammo back!&equo; 
 This last attraction may have special appeal to the article's audience, since it was published in the Millwall programme, raising the spectre of the League's most feared supporters tooled-up on the terraces, humming the William Tell theme instead of &bquo;No one likes us.&equo; 
 Millwall's achievements are now chronicled in the Far East. 
 Erith? 
 No, Bangkok, from where a Lions fan on a business trip (!) reported a &bquo;Millwall Unfashionable But Dangerous&equo; headline in The Nation. 
 &bquo;I've been a Lions fan for about 15 years and it's great to see the look on the tourists&equo; faces when I walk around Bangkok in my &bquo;No One Likes Us We Don't Care&equo; T-shirt,&equo; wrote Mr Barrett. 
 Sports Diary: Tennis: Chris Evert's latest bulletin on whether she intends to retire 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 FORTHRIGHT and unambiguous, that Chris Evert. 
 Take her latest bulletin on whether she intends to retire, issued from Japan, where she is playing in the Federation Cup. 
 &bquo;I'm not going to say that I stake my life on the fact that I'm never going to play another tournament. 
 But I would be surprised if I did after this year, although, at this stage, I am still playing well enough and I am enjoying it enough so that if I want to play another tournament, I can.&equo; 
 That should stop the gossip. 
 Football: Toshack confronts his Real test: Shankly's protege carries the Liverpool creed to Madrid in a relentless pursuit of the European Cup: Patrick Barclay on the British manager putting the nice on ice in the hotbed of Spanish football 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY 
 THEY SAY nice guys finish second, in which case John Toshack must have every chance of winning the Spanish championship for Real Madrid. 
 Though it is rare to find consensus among footballers and the media, few on either side had a good, or even printable, word for Toshack in Wales while he was marching Swansea to the top of the hill and down again. 
 In the Basque country, too, his successes as manager of Real Sociedad were somewhat grudgingly accepted; locals contrasted his surly manner with Howard Kendall's affability along the coast at Bilbao. 
 Well, I take as I find, and can only say that I was happy to do Toshack a favour a few years back when a friend, an international fixer with contacts in Portuguese football, rang to ask if anyone might be available to Sporting Lisbon. 
 Toshack was out of work at the time, so I passed on the offer. 
 Some days later the telephone rang. 
 It was Toshack, in Lisbon, gushing with gratitude as he rustled his contract. 
 He has not looked back since. 
 Perhaps we shall renew our acquaintance in Barcelona tonight, where Real Madrid have their first major test under his management. 
 I fear not, though. 
 Last week Toshack, back in character, directed inquiries to an agent in England, who firmly pointed out that his client was exclusively tied to The Sun. 
 Such style! 
 And such a change from that of Leo Beenhakker, the urbane Dutchman from whom Toshack took over at the Bernabeu last summer. 
 But then managers are not paid to be nice. 
 Toshack has a two-year contract worth &pound;600,000 (figure courtesy of The Sun) and an awful lot to do if he is to see it out. 
 Real have won the championship in each of the last four seasons, so that is almost taken for granted; his job is to win the European Cup, which the club last lifted in 1966. 
 Three times in succession they have fallen in the semi-finals, and Beenhakker's departure became a formality when they were thrashed 5-0 by Milan at San Siro last season. 
 Now the clubs are to meet again, in circumstances that could scarcely be more favourable to Toshack. 
 The European champions, who host the first leg in 11 days' time, have lost Ruud Gullit and Marco Van Basten and are struggling for form. 
 So are Barcelona under Johan Cruyff, as if participating in a benign conspiracy: two good results for Real and the Toshack era takes off. 
 Thus far his press has been ambivalent. 
 The general opinion is that Real are tighter in defence, but less interesting and inventive. 
 As one observer put it after goalless draws with Castellon and Mallorca: &bquo;Under Beenhakker, the little teams were slaughtered.&equo; 
 Beenhakker, in his more candid moments, went close to admitting that senior players were in charge at the Bernabeu. 
 Toshack has wasted no time in putting his stamp on the side, moving the West German midfielder Bernd Schuster to libero, Michel from the right flank to central midfield, and giving the striker Emilio Butragueno a slightly withdrawn role. 
 And those with their ears to the dressing-room wall have yet to report rumbles. 
 Toshack has taken pains to play down the hard-man image he brought from San Sebastian, swearing that the extra training ordered after the poor performance at Castellon was not a punishment. 
 While Real are unbeaten, the relative honeymoon will continue for a man whom the late Bill Shankly, with characteristic caution, once said was destined to become &bquo;the top manager in the game&equo;. 
 Toshack's admiration for Shankly, who signed him for Liverpool from Cardiff in 1970, is unquestionably deep: still the overwhelming influence on his career. 
 As a centre-forward, tall and crafty, he formed one of the great Anfield partnerships with Kevin Keegan. 
 As a manager, initially player-manager, at Swansea, he leant heavily on former Liverpool club-mates: Tommy Smith, Ian Callaghan, Ray Kennedy, Phil Boersma, Alan Waddle and Colin Irwin all went to the Vetch Field. 
 But there was more to it than that as Swansea soared from Fourth Division to First with only a season's rest. 
 The club have never had a better side. 
 With Leighton James on the wing and Bob Latchford up front, they finished sixth in the League in 1982. 
 It was early in that season that Shankly died. 
 Liverpool's next match was at home to Swansea, and shortly before kick-off the mourning Toshack appeared before the Kop in his old red No. 10 shirt. 
 There were later rumours that the gesture, however sincere, cost Toshack the Liverpool management when Bob Paisley retired; he had certainly seen Swansea as his apprenticeship. 
 The truth is that some members of the Liverpool board had misgivings about the way Swansea were run and wondered if Toshack might have picked up bad habits. 
 Perhaps they were too cautious. 
 But, sure enough, when Swansea's money ran out, so did the players. 
 Relegation followed, and the hopelessly over-stretched club were sliding back towards the Fourth Division when Toshack resigned in 1984. 
 He made a brief, unsuccessful return, but his future was overseas: Lisbon first, and then San Sebastian, where the club's policy of using only Basque players (recently broken by the arrival of John Aldridge from Liverpool) limited his use of the cheque book. 
 Only those with short memories would subscribe to the notion that he guided a hick club to new heights &mdash; Real Sociedad were twice Spanish champions in the early Eighties &mdash; but his record was more than respectable. 
 They won the King's Cup in 1987, and the next year finished second to Real Madrid in the League. 
 Few were surprised when the champions turned to him. 
 The Liverpool connection remains hard to break. 
 &bquo;Everything I've achieved has been due to what I learned there,&equo; he said upon arriving at the Bernabeu. 
 &bquo;Being made manager of Real Madrid, I hope, projects the name of Liverpool Football Club more than ever. 
 Yes, I'm laughing at that because I know Kenny Dalglish will laugh when he reads it. 
 Bill Shankly will be laughing somewhere up there as well. 
 Because when one laughs we all laugh. 
 When one cries we all cry. 
 That's why we are what we are.&equo; 
 Well, he has always had a way with words. 
 He even had a book of &bquo;poetry&equo; published during his playing career. 
 It was called Gosh It's Tosh and, gosh, it was. 
 A sample: We're coming in to land at Speke My legs are feeling very weak We've just returned from Barcelona And now I'm going for a sauna Toshack is of Scottish descent, and there is certainly a bit of McGonagall in there, though not the best bit. 
 But the man is no fool. 
 He has kept his day job. 
 He has proved himself as a coach, and any doubts harboured at Anfield about his judgement have long since been swept away. 
 If Dalglish ever left, Toshack would be a powerful candidate to take over. 
 Let Madrid and a mission near-impossible bring what it may; he has friends where he wants them. 
 Tennis: Letter from West Germany: Becker boom beckons the masters 
 By JOHN ROBERTS 
 MENTION big-time tennis venues round here and folk let you prattle on about Wimbledon, Roland Garros, Flushing Meadow and Flinders Park and then press a few claims of their own. 
 How could we possibly overlook the Schleyer Halle, the Festhalle, the Rothenbaum and the Rochusclub? 
 The West German boom, which started with Boris Becker's success at Wimbledon four years ago and was echoed by the prodigious achievements of Steffi Graf in winning the Grand Slam and Olympic gold last year, is developing into a national industry. 
 This year Becker and Graf, who were born six miles apart in small towns near Heidelberg, cornered the major prizes at both Wimbledon and the US Open. 
 In December, Stuttgart will host the Davis Cup final, in which the West Germans will defend the trophy they won for the first time by defeating Sweden in Gothenburg, and in the coming three years Frankfurt will stage the ATP Tour World Championship, which will supersede the Nabisco Masters in New York. 
 Here in Stuttgart today we shall see the final of an unofficial mini-Masters, the masters having taken a lucrative detour away from the pressures of the circuit. 
 Ion Tiriac, Becker's manager, devised the show last year as a maverick tournament to demonstrate that he deserved an opportunity to promote a fully fledged grand prix event. 
 His wish has been granted. 
 In February, the Stuttgart Classic takes its place along with Hamburg as one of the &dollar;1m (&pound;625,000) stops on the ATP Tour, adding to a growing list of reasons why West Germany is rapidly becoming the focal point of world tennis. 
 The ATP Tour Championship next year offers a prize of &dollar;2m to be divided between the top eight players in the rankings. 
 A private West German television company, SAT 1, will pay more than &dollar;5.2m per year to broadcast the tournament and other ATP events in Germany, and the mayor of Frankfurt, Dr Volker Hauff, has promised to &bquo;showcase&equo; the event with a week of concerts, exhibitions and international symposiums. 
 Tiriac is still miffed that the ATP final did not come to Stuttgart: &bquo;The ATP told me to join the auction, but I am too good to have to do that.&equo; 
 He expresses scepticism about Frankfurt's boast of being able to fill their stadium for every session: &bquo;I don't think they will get 9,000 every day, but I would have achieved that here, where we have developed an audience for the game. 
 Frankfurt is not a traditional tennis city. 
 It is not like Hamburg, where they have had a tournament for a hundred years and people would go out and watch tennis at 7 am, even in the freezing cold.&equo; 
 Tiriac is also concerned that the Germans are beginning to take their success for granted. 
 &bquo;Imagine what it would mean to Britain if you had a player in Manchester and a player in Liverpool who won Wimbledon and the US Open,&equo; he said, boggling the mind. 
 &bquo;In Germany they are becoming blase. 
 They expect it. 
 Becker and Graf won Wimbledon and the US Open and did not get their pictures on the front cover of any non-tennis magazines here.&equo; 
 Becker's photograph was in the German newspapers yesterday, accompanied by lamentations about his physical condition after a knee injury had caused him to abandon the Classic on Thursday. 
 They were not taking the hero for granted, but missing him madly and praying that he would be fit to return for the Davis Cup. 
 The feeling was mutual. 
 &bquo;The Davis Cup is definitely the biggest highlight of the rest of the year for me,&equo; Becker said. 
 &bquo;The Masters is important also, but if I have to choose I would prefer the Davis Cup to be the next big thing to win.&equo; 
 This time last year Becker still carried the label of a one-surface player, two Wimbledon triumphs being the sole major achievements on his record. 
 Since then he has won the Masters, inspired his country to their first Davis Cup victory and added the US Open to a third Wimbledon title. 
 &bquo;It astonishes me, to be quite honest,&equo; he said, showing that it is not all swagger on the courts over here. 
 Tennis: Graf is upset by nervous second 
 From Our Correspondent in Tokyo 
 FOR THE first time in three years Steffi Graf was yesterday reminded what it feels like to leave a tournament a quarter-final loser when West Germany were beaten 2-1 by Czechoslovakia in the Federation Cup here. 
 Clearly Graf was not amused by the experience as she quickly booked herself on the next flight home leaving her team-mates behind without telling them. 
 The world No. 1 gave the tie her best, however, but even that was not enough to make up for the shortcomings of her second in command, Claudia Kohde- Kilsch. 
 The latter player, once a top-10 performer but now languishing at No. 31 after a series of injuries and a great loss of confidence, was a bag of nerves. 
 First, she lost the opening singles match 6-3, 6-3 to Jana Novotna then she dithered far too often in the deciding doubles after Graf had, as expected, levelled the score by crushing Helena Sukova 6-2, 6-1 in the other singles match. 
 To call Graf and Kohde-Kilsch a team on this showing is a misnomer. 
 They were in total disarray from the start. 
 Indeed, the only good thing about their confrontation against Sukova and Novotna is that it took just 50 minutes to complete, with the established Czech combination sweeping to a 6-2, 6-2 victory and a place in the semi-finals against the United States. 
 It was a lesson not lost on Klaus Hofsaess, the West German team captain, who said: &bquo;It is absolutely necessary that Steffi plays doubles three or four times a year with a German player.&equo; 
 At the moment Graf spends most of her time partnering Gabriela Sabatini. 
 Indeed, this week was the first time that Graf had joined up with Kohde-Kilsch since the Olympics. 
 &bquo;If she is not prepared to play with another German player sometimes on the circuit then the German team has no chance in the future to win the Cup,&equo; Hofsaess added. 
 Fishing Lines: Bated breath leads to web of intrigue 
 By KEITH ELLIOTT 
 PREVIOUSLY uncatchable fish are being suckered into grabbing baits and flies attached to a new &bquo;invisible&equo; line. 
 Out of water, Krystom Multistrand looks like a length of string. 
 In water, it splits like a spider's web into gossamer strands while retaining its basic strength. 
 Many anglers are hailing it as the most significant advance in fishing tackle during the past 20 years and Dave Chilton, the man who has popularised its use, believes that the line, made from the world's strongest man-made fibre (Lancia uses it to strengthen the internal bodywork of its cars), may revolutionise all branches of the sport. 
 In many parts of the world, fish are still being caught by bow and arrow and it was a bowstring which first put Chilton, a Bolton lorry driver, on to the potential of the high-performance polyethylene fibres. 
 He had been experimenting with dental floss, which was multi-stranded but then broke when rubbed against rocks or weeds. 
 &bquo;I was delivering to industry and kept a constant look-out for a suitable material. 
 Then someone tipped me off about a US material used for bow and kite strings.&equo; 
 But bow strings are highly waxed and far from suitable for fishing line. 
 Chilton and his wife scraped together &pound;250 and persuaded the manufacturer to produce an unwaxed batch. 
 The results exceeded his wildest hopes. 
 As soon as the line came in contact with water, the fibres separated. 
 Instead of one strand as thick as string, there were dozens of fibres three times thinner than a human hair. 
 A fish will often reject a bait because the line's weight makes a maggot chunk of bread or artificial fly move unnaturally. 
 A fish can also see or sense the presence of a line. 
 With Krystom, it is an entirely different matter. 
 &bquo;The fish don't seem to associate it with danger because of the very fine diameter of each strand, but also because of its weightlessness and extreme softness. 
 Initially, Chilton has only been able to persuade the makers to turn out spools of line with a 70lb breaking strain, strong enough to tow a boat. 
 Even that wasn't an easy job. 
 &bquo;Their marketing people had already said that the product had no future in angling,&equo; Chilton said. 
 Now he is churning out line with a 15lb breaking strain and it is proving so popular that he has now got rid of the old banger he had been driving around in for years and bought his first executive saloon. 
 Krystom cannot be used in the same way as traditional nylon line. 
 Because of its softness and weightlessness, it is best in lengths up to a yard long. 
 This means that at the moment it is being used closest to the hook, where presentation and visibility are vital factors and, because it is so different to nylon, many users have problems knotting it. 
 &bquo;It requires a totally different technique,&equo; Chilton said. 
 Krystom's main impact so far has been in catching carp, the Independent readers of the fish world. 
 It has brought outstanding success on waters where anglers were quite happy to catch a single fish in the course of a whole season's fishing. 
 Enlightened dry-fly anglers, too, have already been taking some tremendous catches with it and it will surely prove devastating for dapping, the earliest form of fly fishing, a method still used extensively in Ireland at certain times of year. 
 Krystom, and its inevitable rivals, is not an instant route to success. 
 &bquo;It is not simply a matter of buying a spool and catching millions of fish,&equo; Chilton said, &bquo;but the more skilful and forward-thinking anglers are developing its use all the time. 
 &bquo;I'm just pleased I had the idea and that anglers with a lot more skill than me are showing what can be done with it,&equo; he said modestly. 
 The former lorry driver is now busy exporting Krystom throughout Europe and his only regret is that he no longer has time to go fishing. 
 Racing: Free to go for Guineas 
 By KEITH ELLIOTT 
 FREE AT LAST entered 1,000 Guineas calculations after her victory in the Somerville Tattersall Stakes at rain-soaked Newmarket yesterday. 
 Gerald Leigh's filly, who is quoted at 25-1 for the Classic, was recording her third successive win. 
 &bquo;Her dam, Brocade, preferred cut in the ground, but Free At Last likes it fast. 
 She won't run again this season, and will take her chance in the Guineas next spring,&equo; said Guy Harwood, the filly's trainer. 
 Tony Clark struck the front on Free At Last with a quarter of a mile to cover, and his mount held off Qui Danzig by a neck. 
 Racing: Cumani's Career to take the low road to success 
 By HYPERION (CHRIS CORRIGAN) 
 LUCA CUMANI, who built his reputation on success in big handicaps, complicates a cavalry charge of a Cambridgeshire Handicap at Newmarket today by saddling Shellac and Splendid Career, the two best-backed runners in the race. 
 Neither horse will have the benefit of their usual riding partners as Cumani's stable-jockey, Ray Cochrane, last night gave up his weekend rides as he was in pain from the shoulder injury sustained in the Doncaster pile-up three weeks ago. 
 So Lanfranco Dettori takes over from Cochrane on Cullinan at Phoenix Park today and on Legal Case and Statoblest at Longchamp tomorrow. 
 Choosing between Shellac and Splendid Career is made more difficult by the draw, as both colts will run up the stands rails from low numbers. 
 This could prove a significant advantage over their chief rivals &mdash; Blue Orca, Hard As Iron and Red Paddy, who are all drawn high on the far rails. 
 Last year's winner, Quinlan Terry, would not have beaten the second horse, the subsequent Group One race winner Ile De Chypre, had that rival not been drawn on the far side. 
 The heaviest betting this year has been for Shellac, a six-length winner from Sudden Victory at Ayr last time out, but the deciding factor is that Dettori originally chose to ride SPLENDID CAREER (nap 3.35), who may have been unlucky when beaten at Newbury by yesterday's Goodwood winner Monastery. 
 Some high-class fillies contest the Group Two Sun Chariot Stakes, including Tessla (3.00), who was winter favourite for the Oaks but has yet to win this season. 
 Her sire is Glint Of Gold, so she should not mind the rain that has eased the Newmarket going. 
 The rain should also help the chances of Pinctada (next best 5.10), for whom Rod Simpson has booked Willie Ryan, and Stoneythorpewonder (4.40). 
 The draw could also be decisive in the Cartier Million, run on the dog-leg straight at Phoenix Park, and Cumani has again been fortunate with Cullinan (4.0), drawn 16 of 20. 
 He may have the measure of the John Gosden-trained Anshan, running from stall 15. 
 Fitness should be crucial at Chepstow, the jumping season's first televised meeting. 
 Following horses with a run under their belt may be the best advice for armchair punters retreating from an unprofitable Flat campaign. 
 Gavin Pritchard-Gordon's Peer Prince (3.10) has already won twice this season and could make that advantage tell over Josh Gifford's Zamil. 
 Over fences, Marshlander (2.35) takes a big step up in class after a hat-trick of recent victories. 
 But this front-runner has always battled with gameness and gets plenty of weight from Midnight Madness, a previous winner of this race. 
 Toby Balding gives Folk Dance (2.0) his seasonal debut over the sticks, but this gelding had a pipe-opener when finishing ninth on the Flat at Sandown last month. 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Sport in Short: Table Tennis 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Sport in Short: Rugby League 
 By HYPERION (CHRIS CORRIGAN) 
 LEEDS are to play their Stones Bitter Championship game against Warrington at Headingley on Thursday, 2 November. 
 The game has been brought forward from 5 November because Headingley has been chosen to stage the John Smiths Yorkshire Cup final on that date. 
 DARRYL PITT, the 23-year-old centre from Brisbane who arrived in England on Thursday, has signed for joint Second Division leaders Fulham. 
 Pitt, who played for the Valleys club in Australia, will make his Fulham debut at Whitehaven tomorrow. 
 Sport in Short: Motor Racing 
 By HYPERION (CHRIS CORRIGAN) 
 THE ORGANISERS of the Portuguese Grand Prix, who fined Nigel Mansell &dollar;50,000 for allegedly breaking the rules during the race at Estoril on 24 September, said yesterday that their case concerned only the motor racing authorities and is not a civil action as previously thought. 
 Mansell's appeal, which involves only the fine and not his subsequent ban from the Spanish Grand Prix, will be heard on 18 October. 
 Sport in Short: Ice Hockey 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Sport in Short: Hockey 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Sport in Short: Football 
 By HYPERION (CHRIS CORRIGAN) 
 MARK ROBSON, the winger signed by Tottenham from Exeter for &pound;50,000 in July 1987, has signed for Watford on a month's loan with a view to a permanent transfer. 
 Cardiff City have signed Leigh Barnard, the Swindon midfield player, for &pound;25,000, while Bury have borrowed Gary Kelly, the Newcastle goalkeeper, also for a month. 
 Sport in Short: Equestrianism 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Sport in Short: Commonwealth Games 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 By HYPERION (CHRIS CORRIGAN) 
 MICHAEL WATSON'S World Boxing Association world middleweight title challenge against the Jamaican, Mike McCallum, has been brought forward to 29 November and switched to Alexandra Palace. 
 The same promoter, Barry Hearn, is to stage Jim McDonnell's World Boxing Council world super-featherweight title fight with Azumah Nelson of Ghana at the Royal Albert Hall on 5 November. 
 Sport in Short: Basketball 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Sport in Short: Baseball 
 By HYPERION (CHRIS CORRIGAN) 
 THE Chicago Cubs scored six runs in the first inning as they beat the San Francisco Giants 9-5 at Wrigley Field on Thursday to level the National League championship series at 1-1. 
 The Giants' starting pitcher, Rick Reuschel, was driven from the game after only 18 pitches as the Cubs' lead-off man, Jerome Walton, had two first-inning hits and Mark Grace three hits and four runs batted in. 
 The series moves to Candlestick Park tonight for the first of three games on the West Coast. 
 Sport in Short: Badminton 
 Weekend Sport Page 63 
 Motor Racing: FIA find road free 
 By MAURICE HAMILTON 
 (First Edition) THE ORGANISERS of the Portuguese Grand Prix, who fined Nigel Mansell and Ferrari &dollar;50,000 for allegedly breaking the rules during their race at Estoril on 24 September, said yesterday that their case concerned only the motor racing authorities and was not a civil action, as previously reported. 
 The Portuguese officials said they would hear the appeal on 18 October and confirmed the appeal only involved the fine and not the ban, which actually took effect at the Spanish Grand Prix last Sunday. 
 This will clear the way for the International Automobile Federation (FIA) to reach a conclusion on Mansell's appeal against his exclusion from the Grand Prix at Jerez. 
 The FIA court of appeal did not make a final decision in Paris on Thursday after a three-hour hearing to consider Mansell's evidence. 
 The three-man tribunal did allow, however, that the exclusion appeared to be too harsh for the alleged crime. 
 Rugby Union: NZ undercurrent running at Stradey 
 By STEVE BALE 
 RUGBY at Stradey Park when Neath are the visitors is as red-raw as Llanelli's scarlet jerseys. 
 It is an acquired taste for sensitive palates but a lot of hungry people are only too happy to tuck in. 
 For this afternoon's rematch of the Welsh Cup finalists &mdash; Neath won that one 14-13 before 58,000 people at the Arms Park &mdash; Stradey has an upper limit of 18,700 and, if last season's equivalent is anything to go by, every available space may be needed. 
 That exhilarating game, which Llanelli won 27-21, attracted 20,000 to Stradey even though the official limit was some 5,000 fewer. 
 Since then safety work has pushed up that capacity and when the (New Zealand) All Blacks play there in three weeks it will be helped to 21,000 by a temporary stand erected over the Tanner Bank wall on the outfield of the adjacent cricket field, adding 2,300 spectators who need not be counted in the official figure. 
 The Welsh All Blacks, too, have an imminent engagement with their NZ counterparts, three days before the tourists play the Scarlets, and for both sides today's game is vital preparation. 
 These are the best teams in Wales and as such given the best chance &mdash; better, for sure, than Wales &mdash; of upsetting the New Zealanders. 
 Llanelli field seven internationals, Neath six, and both are well enough endowed to relegate a recently capped player &mdash; Carwyn Davies and Rowland Phillips &mdash; to the bench. 
 Neath's outside-half Paul Williams, who scored 268 points last season, is out for a fortnight with a rib injury and replaced by Jason Ball, who is the son of the club coach, Glen, and was once on Arsenal's books. 
 If Williams's injury drags on to threaten his participation against the All Blacks, Neath will be allowed to recall Adrian Davies from Cambridge University. 
 Lloyd Isaac, the outstanding reserve hooker to Kevin Phillips, is a longer-term casualty; a knee injury against Bath last Saturday required surgery and he will not be involved against New Zealand or for two months afterwards. 
 England, meanwhile, has another of the non-league, partly Anglo-Welsh club days which &mdash; with occasional exceptions such as Bath's visit to Neath &mdash; have been rendered peripheral by the coming of Courage. 
 There is also the diversion of a county programme in the North and West, where the competition still has more than passing meaning. 
 A Swansea visit to Twickenham would once have been a highlight of Harlequins' season but an almost-empty HQ will be an eerie sort of place this afternoon and we may rest assured that the Quins players already have their attention on next Saturday's First Division visit to Bedford. 
 The All Whites, incidentally, have their own All Black date in a fortnight. 
 Quins need Paul Ackford fit to face Bedford far more than they do today. 
 He picked up a groin injury during his heroic performance in Lions colours in France and, with exhaustion probably exacerbating his condition, he makes way for David Thresher in the second row. 
 The prop Andy Mullins, like Ackford and Thresher an England squad member, is another absentee, with a twisted ankle. 
 Brian Moore, the Lions hooker, makes his first appearance of the season - having rested since the tour of Australia &mdash; for Nottingham at Northampton. 
 Moore's England props, Paul Rendall and Jeff Probyn, belatedly return for Wasps, at home to Blackheath, after being left out of the first two First Division games. 
 Oxford begin the build-up to their Varsity defence with a bigger overseas influence than they had even last season. 
 Ian Williams (Australia) and David Kirk (New Zealand) have gone, but the freshmen who face University College Cork include two US internationals, Gary Hein and Don James, Toshiyoki Hayashi of Japan, and two South Africans, David Curtis and Willem de Klerk. 
 Football: Team News 
 By STEVE BALE 
 Blackburn v Middlesbrough Undefeated Blackburn name full-back Sulley, who has had a trapped thigh nerve. 
 Boro's captain Tony Mowbray has a foot injury, so Coleman, a &pound;400,000 buy from Mansfield, starts for the first time. 
 Bradford City v Brighton Adcock, City's &pound;190,000 striker from Northampton, makes his debut. 
 Left-back Chapman, who has missed three matches with a twisted ankle, is in Brighton's squad, and Curbishley makes his 400th League appearance. 
 Hull v Swindon Hull, without a win, hope to have Whitehurst back in attack. 
 Galvin, Swindon's Irish winger, has recovered from injury, while Parkin returns to defence for the suspended Gittens. 
 Ipswich v Newcastle Ipswich's ex-Norwich winger Donowa makes his full League debut for his home-town team. 
 Newcastle restore 10-goal Quinn, unfit for the Littlewoods win over Reading. 
 Brazil, a scorer as substitute at Hull and in midweek, keeps his place at Kristensen's expense. 
 Oldham v Barnsley Dobbin, the Barnsley midfielder carried off at Blackpool in midweek, has made a good recovery from a knee injury and may play. 
 Oxford v Portsmouth The home side have dropped Greenall, so Evans, a New Zealand international and Oxford University student, will partner Slatter in central defence. 
 They face Gilligan, Portsmouth's new &pound;215,000 striker from Cardiff. 
 Plymouth v Stoke Plymouth are unchanged &mdash; despite the 6-1 home defeat by Arsenal in midweek. 
 Stoke, still searching for a League win, recall &pound;250,000 front-man Biggins, fit after knee surgery. 
 Port Vale v Leicester The 1,000th competitive fixture at Vale Park. 
 The Burslem side await fitness reports on Glover, Porter, Jeffers and their captain, Earle, though forward Cross is ready to return. 
 For Leicester, the bottom club, teenager Kitson is likely to retain his place in attack. 
 Sunderland v Bournemouth Sunderland will be unchanged if Gates (toe injury) and MacPhail (stomach upset) pass fitness tests. 
 Watford v WBA Hodges (ankle) and Wilkinson (knee) are doubtful for Watford. 
 Injury-hit Albion &mdash; 12 players unavailable &mdash; hope to have winger Ford back and include Barham, the former Norwich and England player who is on trial at the Hawthorns, much-travelled reserve-team coach Allardyce, plus teenagers Foster and Whitehouse. 
 West Ham v Leeds West Ham, who give fitness tests to Parkes, Gale and Ward, have added Strodder and restored cup-tied newcomer Foster to their 16. 
 Jones, substituted in three consecutive games by Leeds, makes his first London appearance since leaving Wimbledon. 
 Fairclough, a scoring substitute in the Littlewoods Cup defeat by Oldham, returns at centre-half. 
 The match is an all-ticket sell-out. 
 Wolves v Sheffield Utd Bull and Mutch are reunited up front for Wolves, the former having recovered from concussion sustained in scoring against Villa, when Mutch was absent with a groin strain. 
 United, the unbeaten leaders, are unchanged. 
 Brentford mark their centenary at home to Bristol City&hellip; 
 Bristol Rovers (second in the Third) make their first change this season against Fulham (fourth) because of Alexander's suspension, with striker Sealy set to face one of his old clubs&hellip; 
 Cardiff's goalkeeper Wood has broken two bones in his right hand, so Ward, who began the season with Droylsden, deputises at Huddersfield&hellip; 
 Fourth Division leaders Southend may face Scarborough without Bennett, who broke his nose in a two-goal display against Tottenham. 
 Football: Tough test for MacLeod's men 
 By DON LINDSAY 
 SCOTLAND'S national bard, Robert Burns, awarded Ayr the epithet of a town populated by &bquo;honest men and bonnie lasses&equo;. 
 As a gentleman of sincerity Ally MacLeod, now enjoying his third spell as manager of Ayr United, has few equals in the world of football. 
 MacLeod has toughened up the side during a close season which saw the club turn full-time following a flirtation with relegation last year. 
 One of the former Scotland manager's old teams, Airdrie, visit Somerset Park today &mdash; on a day when the Premier Division clubs have no matches as Scotland play on Wednesday &mdash; lying third in the First Division and keen to maintain form which has helped them overcome an uncertain beginning. 
 As if to celebrate the move into their brand-new all-seater stadium, St Johnstone have advanced to the leadership of the division. 
 Astutely managed by Alex Totten, the former Rangers coach, the Perth men have their recent signings from Dundee United and Hearts, Harry Curran and Allan Moore, looking to increase an already impressive striking rate against Morton at McDiarmid Park this afternoon. 
 Sandwiched between Saints and Airdrie are those mercurial inhabitants of Maryhill, Partick Thistle. 
 The Jags have unearthed a highly unusual talent in Chic Charnley, a forward with a feel for the unexpected, but he will face a physical examination against Falkirk, who have already had three players sent off in one match this season. 
 Cricket: England to enjoy a one-day stand in India: Martin Johnson finds grounds for confidence as England's touring party leave for the limited-over thrash on the sub-continent 
 By MARTIN JOHNSON 
 THE FIRST of England's three winter tour parties leaves Heathrow this afternoon, bound for Delhi and a six-nation one-day jamboree described as the Nehru Trophy. 
 As (on the evidence of last summer at any rate) there is no one to match them in the art of swishing across the line and bowling not to take wickets, England are probably favourites to win it. 
 In terms of preparation for the New Year Test series in the West Indies it is a bit like getting ready for an army assault course by taking the dog for a walk around the block. 
 However, with 12 of the 14-man squad destined for the Caribbean, it does offer the opportunity of forging (under the new triumvirate of Graham Gooch, Allan Lamb and Micky Stewart) the kind of unity that will be essential when the flak is flying at the Queen's Park Oval and Sabina Park. 
 There is also the chance of picking up a not inconsiderable amount of loot. 
 The winners, for example, will collect only around &pound;5,000 less than the &pound;30,000 total prize money that was on offer for the sub-continent's 1987 World Cup, which is doubtless why Australia and the West Indies were eventually persuaded to join the party after originally blowing it a loud raspberry. 
 As is the case with most tournaments of this kind, there has to be a peg to hang it on, and this one is to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the birth of Jawaharlal Nehru. 
 It could just as well have been the 20th birthday of the Eden Gardens tea urn, and as far as the Indian government is concerned, there is nothing like an international cricket tournament for persuading the electorate that, with polling day just around the corner, Rajiv is the boy to vote for. 
 The proliferation of one-day cricket &mdash; there were 227 limited-over internationals played between the last two World Cups &mdash; is a reflection of modern-day audience demand, and, overseas anyway, is what brings in the cash. 
 Even in a country like India, Test cricket no longer generates massive appeal, and on the last full tour there &mdash; by the West Indies &mdash; a 12-match international programme was split 8-4 in favour of the instant thrill. 
 It is, of course, mere coincidence that Gooch's passage to India is considerably smoother for World Cups and Nehru Trophies than for a full England Test tour. 
 Could it be, so to speak, that all cricket will be one-day one day? 
 Heaven forbid, but the urge to shoehorn into the calendar as much of it as possible continues unabated, leading at times to brain-numbing events such as the three-match Pakistan versus England knockabout immediately after the World Cup &mdash; which was a bit like lighting the cigar after a five-course a la carte dinner, then having the waiter arrive with a tureen of porridge. 
 As for the Nehru, England's first match is on 15 October, while India and Pakistan do not get under way until the 22nd. 
 The reason for this is that the sub-continent's representatives will still be competing for a one-day pot in Sharjah until the 20th. 
 However, while returning home with the Cup might not quite be an occasion for breaking out the ticker tape and launching into an orgy of street parties, it would be nice to see England do well, and there is no reason why they should not. 
 They might have mislaid the formula for operating over five days &mdash; December 1986 is the last time England beat anyone of any consequence when asked to bat and bowl for longer than 55 overs &mdash; but there is no getting away from their ability to play the negative stuff as well as anyone else. 
 They will go, for example, into their final qualifying match against the West Indies in Gwalior on 27 October with the record of having beaten them in nine of their previous 10 one-day meetings. 
 With the usual premium on daylight, which in the sub-continent disappears like a power cut, there will not be much of a gap between the breakfast gong and pavilion bell, and heavy over-rate fines have been written into the regulations. 
 West Indies have answered speculation about Viv Richards's health by naming him captain for the Champions' Trophy tournament in Sharjah and the Nehru tournament in India. 
 Golf: Embarrassment of choice after Faldo's harvest 
 From NORMAN DABELL in Stuttgart 
 IT IS apt that much of this German Masters course is set amid fruit trees, because the tournament leader Nick Faldo was talking cherries yesterday. 
 After harvesting six strokes in the second round with a 66 to be nine under for the tournament, Faldo digressed on US Tour players coming over to find pickings in European Tour events &mdash; particularly pertinent as his nearest challenger is the American, Payne Stewart. 
 Asked if he thought Americans would now want to play more in Europe, Faldo demurred on their behalf. 
 The US Masters champion said: &bquo;To be the best in the world you've got to play around the world, but I don't expect to see Americans playing over here. 
 And Deane Beman (the US Tour commissioner) doesn't want us to cherry-pick on their tour.&equo; 
 This was a topical point as Faldo is currently &bquo;up in the air&equo; on whether he will play in the American Nabisco Grand Prix or the last European event, the Volvo Masters. 
 Faldo will want to defend his Volvo Masters title if he wins here because he could then still clinch the European Order of Merit. 
 However, the Nabisco first prize is &pound;280,000, whereas the Volvo top purse is only &pound;66,000, although that could be doubled if he is also the order of merit winner. 
 Here Faldo's latest swing &mdash; which makes him stand taller &mdash; made his short game easy. 
 Three birdie putts were from three feet and one from only a foot. 
 He also had an eagle putt from six feet. 
 Stewart's 67 left him a stroke ahead of his playing partner Rodger Davies and two in front of the overnight leader, Bernhard Langer. 
 The defending champion Jose-Maria Olazabal, five places above Faldo in the order of merit, ended with an eagle to be a shot behind Langer. 
 He is five under with Keith Waters. 
 Seve Ballesteros followed up yesterday's quadruple-bogey seven by plummeting out of bounds at the par-three 15th and out of the tournament with two 75s, six over par. 
 Squash: Jahangir beaten by Dittmar 
 From RICHARD EATON in Kuala Lumpur 
 JAHANGIR KHAN'S attempt to extend his record of world titles to seven ended in exhaustion, annoyance and a surprise semi-final defeat in the World Open here yesterday. 
 His conqueror, by 15-9, 12-15, 15-9, 8-15, 15-13 was Australia's Chris Dittmar and his tiredness was also partly caused by the extra pounds of weight that have been expanding around his middle in recent months. 
 Jahangir's irritation was with the refereeing which, he reckoned, had hindered him throughout the tournament and yesterday he said it &bquo;made it hard for me to catch up a couple of points&equo;. 
 But Jahangir admitted Dittmar had never played better. 
 It was the red-haired left-hander's first win over the squash legend, the first time he had played a match lasting an hour and 50 minutes at this level and won, and the first time he can ever have gambled so audaciously as he did at 13-13 in the final game. 
 Dittmar, incredibly, tried a backhand volley return of serve into the side-wall nick. 
 &bquo;It was the most ridiculous shot selection I have probably ever made,&equo; he admitted. 
 &bquo;If I had missed it, it might have destroyed me.&equo; 
 But instead the ball whipped unplayablly along the floor and in another moment the man from Adelaide was celebrating with a grim, pale smile one of the biggest upsets of recent years. 
 Jahangir's defeat will increase speculation that the man who once went more than 500 matches unbeaten, may sometime next year retire. 
 He was fatigued even before the start of the fourth game when he was late back on to court. 
 He then gained some extra seconds of recuperation by tying up his laces. 
 The Pakistani fought with characteristic courage, but was unable to utilise his fearsome steamrolling style, except in bursts. 
 Well before the end his shirt was hanging like cling-film, his hair separating into rats' tails, and his body movements winding down. 
 Dittmar's wife, Lyan, was in tears at the end, but the Australian was mostly impervious to emotion, already concentrating, as he said, on today's final against the other great Pakistani Khan, Jansher, the 1987 world champion. 
 Cycling: Fignon's positive drug test 
 From RICHARD EATON in Kuala Lumpur 
 LAURENT FIGNON, the double Tour de France winner, failed a dope test after a race in The Netherlands last month, the president of the French Cycling Federation, Francois Alaphilippe, confirmed last night. 
 Fignon, who won the Tour de France in 1983 and 1984, and finished just eight seconds behind Greg Lemond this year, failed the test after his team, Super U, placed second in the Grand Prix de la Liberation in Eindhoven on 17 September. 
 Alaphilippe did not name the drug involved, but a Dutch newspaper claimed that the test had revealed traces of amphetamines. 
 &bquo;Fignon was informed in time to have a second test done,&equo; Alaphilippe said. 
 He said the cyclist was &bquo;very shocked&equo; that he tested positive. 
 Fignon said in a statement that he had asked for a second test at a different laboratory but his request had been turned down. 
 He faces a one-month cautionary suspension during which he would be allowed to race. 
 The Frenchman, who protested his innocence when he failed a drug test after winning the Tour of Wallonia in 1987, is one of a number of leading riders to have failed a test, including Pedro Delgado, the Spaniard who was allowed to complete and win the Tour de France last year after a test revealed a substance banned by the International Olympic Committee but not by the International Cycling Union. 
 Football: Robson's tact is strained by Barnes blow 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 BOBBY ROBSON tried his best to be diplomatic, but his face is too expressive to play that game, and the fight to conceal his true feelings was well and truly lost. 
 The England manager was surprised and disappointed by Liverpool's decision to withdraw John Barnes from Wednesday's decisive World Cup qualifier in Poland &mdash; and it showed. 
 Barnes has been suffering from a hamstring strain, but he was able to train on Thursday and yesterday, and Robson had expected him to be fit for Chorzow, where a point will be enough to take England to Italy as winners of Group Two. 
 The manager thought his lunchtime call to Anfield was no more than a formality. 
 He was confident that Barnes would have trained without discomfort before being dispatched to join the squad at their Buckinghamshire headquarters. 
 Instead, Robson replaced the receiver after the briefest of exchanges with Kenny Dalglish, and announced: &bquo;Barnes is out. 
 Kenny told me he trained this morning, but was still feeling the injury, and that there was no point in him coming. 
 I am very disappointed. 
 I was always optimistic and thought he would come through.&equo; 
 Robson looked upset. 
 Was he unhappy about Liverpool's decision? 
 &bquo;We have got another 48 hours before we leave and John could have had treatment here, but Liverpool are ruling him out. 
 It is very unfortunate because we want all our best players for such an important match, but I am not going to embroider it. 
 That is up to you.&equo; 
 The implication was that when it came to embroidery, the stitching up had been done on Merseyside, if Barnes had been fit enough to train for the last two days. 
 Had Liverpool been playing Arsenal next Wednesday would Dalglish have ruled him out a full five days before the game? 
 In an era when pre-match fitness tests are commonplace, surely not? 
 Robson decided against summoning a replacement, explaining: &bquo;With Chris Waddle, David Rocastle and Steve Hodge here, we have the best players of Barnes's type with us already.&equo; 
 Waddle will be the one to benefit from Barnes's absence. 
 The two wingers were, in the manager's words, &bquo;brilliant against Poland at Wembley&equo;, but tactical considerations had already precluded their selection in tandem next week. 
 Robson is anxious not to fall into the trap which ensnared Alf Ramsey in 1973, when England sought a draw in Poland with a team packed with defenders and lost 2-0, but sensible precautions will be taken. 
 Until yesterday, these would have seen Barnes deployed on one flank with Rocastle's defensive awareness earning him a ninth cap at Waddle's expense on the other. 
 The loss of Barnes has brought Waddle a reprieve, and a switch to the left to accommodate Rocastle on the right. 
 Robson, who watched Rocastle last Saturday, said: &bquo;He has made a good start to the season. 
 When he got on as a substitute against Sweden he was first class; in Albania he was one of our best players.&equo; 
 Steve McMahon, who is to deputise in midfield for the injured Neil Webb, missed England's workout at Bisham Abbey yesterday along with Gary Stevens, Tony Adams, Paul Gascoigne and Gary Lineker, but their injuries are slight. 
 Polish police said yesterday that they had called in army commandos to help control English fans. 
 A spokesman said 1,500 police and commandos would escort the fans when they arrived in Poland. 
 Paul Ince of Manchester United has pulled out of the England Under-21 squad for Tuesday's European Championship match in Poland with an ankle injury. 
 Steve Sedgley of Tottenham and United's Lee Sharpe have also withdrawn. 
 David White and Andy Hinchcliffe of Manchester City and Ipswich's Jason Dozzell have been called in. 
 Fulham defender Jeff Hopkins has been recalled to the Welsh squad for the World Cup qualifier against The Netherlands as a replacement for Kevin Ratcliffe. 
 Tony Norman, the Sunderland keeper, also withdrew after suffering a reaction to a hand operation. 
 Paul McStay and Jim Bett, who have been doubtful with injuries, yesterday reported fit for Scotland's World Cup qualifying match against France on Wednesday. 
 Hockey: Kerly's trick 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 England...... 5 Argentina.... 0 SEAN KERLY scored three times in England's workmanlike victory in their opening game in the Lada Classic at Kenilworth Road, Luton, last night against Argentina. 
 Nick Thompson, with his first goal for England in the 17th minute after a good move down the right by Steve Batchelor, started England off. 
 Within a minute Kerly had latched himself on to a Robert Clift free hit to score his first goal. 
 In the 28th minute Potter scored from a penalty stroke. 
 Kerly, exchanging with his captain Richard Leman, slotted in No. 4 in the 48th minute and completed his hat-trick in the last minute after Thompson had set him up. 
 Earlier, Australia overcame The Netherlands 2-1. 
 Football: Midani set to buy out Knighton 
 By FRANK KANE 
 MICHAEL KNIGHTON will this weekend contact Manchester United's chairman Martin Edwards to seek a way out of the financial and legal impasse caused by his &pound;20m bid for the club. 
 Knighton is ready to offer the Manchester United boss a new deal on the 50.6 per cent shareholding which he sought to buy from Edwards for &pound;10m, and which is now the subject of a damaging legal wrangle in the High Court. 
 It is likely that the outcome of the talks, after a suitable period to allow the club to recover, will be a new takeover bid for the club, made by the Lebanese-born businessman and United director, Amer Midani. 
 Midani, said to be a member of one of the richest families in the world, would install one of United's favourite sons, Bobby Charlton, as chairman. 
 Speaking from the offices of his Manchester travel business yesterday, Charlton would only comment: &bquo;There is a legal case pending, and it is a very, very dicey situation. 
 Until all that has died down, I will only say that the only thing I'm bothered about is the well-being of the club. 
 I will not speculate on anything that would upset things.&equo; 
 Knighton declined to comment ahead of the talks with Edwards, but it seems he is keen at all costs to avoid a court case. 
 A friend of Knighton said: &bquo;It is very unlikely he would go to court. 
 I imagine they will sort it out between them.&equo; 
 The appointment of Charlton would be seen in Manchester as the perfect solution to the damaging public wrangling that has made the club a public farce over recent weeks. 
 Apart from his family riches, Midani is a wealthy man in his own right, with interests in property and leisure developments in the United Kingdom and Spain. 
 He has a 15 per cent stake in United's shares. 
 A financier in the Manchester broking community said yesterday: &bquo;It is more than a possibility that he will make an offer to get Knighton out of his hole.&equo; 
 Speculation was rife in the city that the Edwards-Knighton talks would agree to tear up their disputed agreement. 
 It has been suggested that the club would pay Knighton &pound;1m as compensation, which would then be added to the price-tag Midani would put on the Edwards stake. 
 The going rate for Edwards's 50 per cent has risen rapidly since the affair began in August with Knighton's &pound;10m offer. 
 Last weekend it was offered to Eddy Shah, the former national newspaper proprietor, for &pound;16m. 
 Midani would be able to afford at least that, and a general offer would be cheaper for him to fund because of his existing stake. 
 He would also be expected to pay a premium to put an end to the chaos. 
 Other players could still enter the contest, but it is increasingly unlikely that any would be acceptable to the United board. 
 Robert Maxwell, the Daily Mirror publisher who once offered to buy Edwards's shares, was rumoured yesterday to be still interested, but his family's interest in other football League clubs &mdash; Derby and Oxford &mdash; would face problems from the Football League's limitations on club ownership. 
 These were underlined yesterday by the League's decision to bar Owen Oyston, the radio station owner who has said he would be willing to back Knighton's offer, from an interest in United. 
 Oyston, along with his wife, Vicky, has a controlling stake in Blackpool football club. 
 A League statement later spelt out that &bquo;League Regulation 86 quite unequivocally prohibits an individual, a member of his family or any other associate including a nominee from holding more than 10 per cent of the shares in more than one League club&equo;. 
 The statement also expressed &bquo;grave concern about the recent uncertainty&equo; surrounding Manchester United and Blackpool and hoped the matters would be &bquo;brought to an early conclusion&equo;. 
 Shah is also out of the United running. 
 &bquo;I am not interested,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I am a Spurs supporter and my kids would never forgive me.&equo; 
 There is also speculation as to why Edwards initially accepted an offer of &pound;10m, which subsequently turned out to be way below the market price. 
 Football: Manchester's resources stretched 
 By FRANK KANE 
 (First Edition) MANCHESTER police will be at full stretch for the next round of the Littlewoods Cup &mdash; because of the demands of television. 
 The two Manchester clubs have been drawn at home and the police originally wanted one to play on Tuesday, 24 October, and the other 24 hours later. 
 United's match against Tottenham is scheduled for television highlights on the Wednesday, so the League suggested that City play Norwich on the Tuesday. 
 However, City have a live televised match against Aston Villa at Maine Road on Sunday, 22 October, and they were unhappy about playing two games in three days. 
 It has now been decided that both clubs will play on the Wednesday with 7.45 kick-offs. 
 Oldham, policed by the same force, are also at home on that night, against Scarborough. 
 Meanwhile, Nottingham Forest yesterday unveiled plans to make the City ground the leading stadium in the Midlands over the next five years. 
 They are likely to develop the Trent End and/or the Bridgford Road End, the only uncovered part of the ground. 
 Maurice Roworth, the Forest chairman, said: &bquo;We have a duty to our supporters and the team to provide a ground worthy of the success the club has had. 
 Work would already have started on improving what we already believe to be one of the country's most modern and safe grounds. 
 &bquo;But we cannot do anything until we know what will be expected of football clubs in the future in terms of all-seater grounds or any other issues. 
 Until we get the full implications of the Taylor Report and discover what happens over the identity-card issue, we will have to sit tight. 
 But feasibility studies have been carried out and we should be in a position to act when we know what is expected.&equo; 
 Forest also announced a pre-tax loss of &pound;7,000 for last year. 
 Ron Atkinson, the Sheffield Wednesday manager, yesterday promised the shareholders' AGM that the team will not be relegated and will climb from the bottom of the First Division by Christmas. 
 Joe Ashton, a Labour MP, narrowly failed to gain election to the Wednesday board. 
 The Welsh FA have signed a sponsorship deal with Welsh Brewers Ltd which could net them more than &pound;100,000 over the next three years. 
 The 105-year-old Welsh Cup will be renamed The Allbright Bitter Welsh Cup. 
 Rugby Union: Welsh sever SA links 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 WELSH RUGBY was united for the first time in the last few stormy months when the 203 member clubs of the Welsh Rugby Union decided to sever playing links with South Africa last night. 
 In becoming the first country to shun the Springboks, the Welsh not only turned about face from their decision of five years ago, but also brought the advent of a professional rugby circus in the Republic that bit closer. 
 At the Union's special general meeting, held at the Civic Hall in Port Talbot, delegates voted 276-113 in favour of a strongly-worded WRU motion proposing a complete cut-off of playing links with South Africa. 
 &bquo;I think this should be the end of it. 
 I certainly left the meeting feeling that way,&equo; Clive Rowlands, the president of the WRU, said. 
 &bquo;We left the meeting united. 
 The clubs have looked at the situation and felt it was time to change. 
 We gave the whole matter a fair airing on everything involved in South Africa and that's why the result is as such. 
 It's all right to build bridges with South Africa, but if bridges are falling down in Wales something must be done about it.&equo; 
 Although Rowlands, who resigned his presidency for seven days in the bloody aftermath of this summer's centenary tour to South Africa, was happy to lay the issue to rest last night, the debris of the affair is still apparent throughout Welsh rugby. 
 The secretary, David East, is now a figure of the distant past following his decision to resign his post over the way 10 Welsh players were recruited for the celebratory tour, and the Union still have to find a candidate to replace Rhys Williams as the junior vice-president. 
 The vote will be seen as a victory for the local authorities, who put so much pressure on the clubs, and many of the delegates were relieved that the vote had taken away the threat of possible punitive action from their local councils. 
 &bquo;It takes all the pressure off us and we can now start to play rugby again,&equo; a representative from Ebbw Vale, whose ground is owned by the local authority, said. 
 What the repercussions will be in South Africa &mdash; where the ageing president, Danie Craven, has threatened to support rebel tours &mdash; only time will tell. 
 Craven has said that Welsh players will still be chased by South Africa in spite of this vote, but the WRU is confident that they have shut off the avenue to the Republic. 
 Last night's resolution from the WRU committee read: &bquo;For as long as any rugby player living in the Republic of South Africa is the victim of racial discrimination under the laws of that country, neither the WRU nor any of its member clubs will become involved in any matches organised under the authority of the SA Rugby Board. 
 Nor will the Union nor any of its member clubs permit teams under the jurisdiction to play in Wales.&equo; 
 Equestrianism: Whitaker's Milton in paradise 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 JOHN WHITAKER scooped his sponsor's pool at the Horse of the Year Show for the second time running on the spring-heeled Next Milton, when winning last night's Next International Masters, writes Genevieve Murphy. 
 He collected his winner-takes-all prize of &pound;27,000 after a dramatic finish. 
 After clearing the five fences in the fifth round, Whitaker had an agonising wait. 
 Nick Skelton, on Burmah Serenade, and Germany's Franke Sloothaak, on Walzerkoenig, could have taken the prize, for the rider clearing the highest course, but each made one error. 
 Michael Whitaker survived one drastic moment with Next Tees Hanauer to snatch the Everest Championship from the sponsor's stable. 
 Whitaker's partner slipped while turning tight into the penultimate fence, but the horse managed to jump clear and win from Emma-Jane Mac on Everest Oyster. 
 Tennis: Becker names his six of the best 
 From JOHN ROBERTS in Stuttgart 
 TOWARDS the end of a week of stocktaking at the Stuttgart Classic, in which some of the world's leading male players have expressed mixed feelings about the way professional tennis is moving into the next decade, Boris Becker was asked to name his player of the 1980s. 
 The West German shook his head. 
 &bquo;I name Borg, Connors, Lendl, McEnroe, Wilander and myself,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;In 10 years things change so much, and it is difficult to name one player. 
 Five years ago nobody knew Boris Becker.&equo; 
 Bjorn Borg vacated the courts long ago, and though the 37-year-old Jimmy Connors will continue to swing his racket with gusto when the new Association of Tennis Professionals Tour gets underway in January, Lendl, Wilander and McEnroe remain to test the 21-year-old Becker as he endeavours to convince the rankings computer that he is the top man. 
 Lendl, the current No. 1 and the winner of more than &dollar;14m in official prize-money, guaranteed himself another &dollar;60,000 at least last night by defeating Argentina's Alberto Mancini, 6-2, 6-3, to reach the final of this exhibition event. 
 He has surprised Becker by announcing that he will forgo the French Open next June in order to prepare for Wimbledon, the one major championship to have eluded him. 
 &bquo;He's put too much unnecessary pressure on himself,&equo; Becker said. 
 &bquo;If I was him I would probably skip the French, but I wouldn't talk about it so far ahead.&equo; 
 Lendl smiled and countered: &bquo;It would be laughable if I didn't say it because it's obvious that Wimbledon is my main goal &mdash; to pretend otherwise would be wrong.&equo; 
 In today's final he plays Miloslav Mecir a 6-3, 6-4 winner against Stuttgart's Carl Uwe Steeb. 
 Wilander was No. 1 a year ago. 
 He has since lost the Australian, French and US Open championships. 
 Becker, who expects to encounter the 25-year-old Swede in the Davis Cup final here in December, cannot understand why he has drifted so long. 
 &bquo;I am very surprised about Mats. 
 I thought he would get it back together.&equo; 
 Fashion: Fable, cable and fishermen's yarns: Vinny Lee on warm and woolly traditional chunky sweaters 
 By VINNY LEE 
 SAILING around the coast of England searching for shoals of fish, Gerorge Trowark, a Cornish fisherman born in 1877, must have visited dozens of ports and harbours. 
 At each stop he noted down the shapes and stitch work of other traditional working men's jumpers. 
 From the Morecambe Cockler's Pullover to the Romney Marsh Smock and Norfolk Fenman's Weskit to Thames Docker's Jacket, each intricate knit and pearl motif was documented. 
 Trowark himself would most likely have been found under the thick cable-knit cover of his Cornish Knit Frock. 
 Trowark joined his father Jelbert and brother Jago on the fishing boats of Newlyn and in time learnt to knit &mdash; a craft popular among fishermen of the day as a way of passing time on long voyages. 
 Although a skilled fisherman, George Trowark became renowned as a knitter and over many years and many voyages he accumulated detailed notes of designs and patterns. 
 These notes have provided knitwear designer Martin Storey with much of the information and inspiration for his new George Trowark range, a new collection of chunky man-sized jumpers. 
 The 12 sweater designs in the new Trowark collection are hand-knitted or quality machine-knitted and hand finished in cotton, linen or wool yarns. 
 Colours are muted &mdash; black, blue or natural &mdash; the dyed colours mature and look softer with wear. 
 Indigo-dyed blue jumpers are stonewashed to give a worn look, but the stonewashing also creates an interesting highlight effect on the raised knitted details. 
 The dye tends to stay darker around the patterns and creates an outline on the stitch-work, including the discreet GT initials worked into the hems of the jumpers. 
 Trowark style is large, enveloping and extremely cosy with an almost indestructible quality &mdash; one five-year-old jumper seen by The Independent is only just beginning to look &bquo;broken in&equo; after years of frequent machine washing and hard wear. 
 Only medium and large sizes are made in these real men's jumpers, but the large linen shirt makes a wonderful tunic for a woman of average size and will probably keep her knees nice and warm. 
 The designer, Martin Storey, of Artwork, the man credited with the discovery of Trowark's manuscripts, may be spinning a good yarn about their origins, but the jumpers are genuinely a fine mix of fable and cable. 
 Trowark knitwear is sold in sensible big brown cardboard boxes with a &bquo;handwritten&equo; manuscript copy of the legend of the Cornishman. 
 Hand-knitted jumpers cost from &pound;160, machine-knitted from &pound;70. 
 Chunky woollen gilet waistcoat with velvet buttons and shawl collar, &pound;95, available in mulberry, olive or brown. 
 Cream cropped wide-necked Aran cable sweater, &pound;205. 
 Black and white thick chenille cropped sweater, &pound;293. 
 Black chenille thick sweater with colourful tulip motif, &pound;396. 
 Chunky Aran turtleneck sweater, &pound;90, both available in navy, light blue, brown, red, tobacco, green or lime. 
 Chunky short cropped sweater, &pound;112. 
 Ribbed roll neck sweater, &pound;99. 
 Long chunky cardigan, &pound;125, all available in beige, black or grey. 
 Chunky flecked roll neck sweater, &pound;99, in black or grey with white flecks. 
 Marks &amp; Spencer, Marble Arch, London W1 and selected branches. 
 Black and white patterned handknitted chunky sweater, &pound;19.99. 
 Aran cable woollen cardigan with ethnic embroidery, &pound;42.99. 
 Cotton Aran chunky knit sweater with embroidered flowers, &pound;32.99. 
 Navy woollen bolero cardigan with large paisley wool embroidery, &pound;42.99. 
 Russian floral woollen sweater, available in black or cream, &pound;325. 
 Chunky long length bobble sweater, &pound;269, in a variety of colours. 
 Russian bolero woollen sweater, &pound;115, in assorted colours. 
 Thick Fairisle long woollen sweater, &pound;312, available in black, red or cream. 
 Chunky navy woollen sweater with zip-up front, &pound;147. 
 Cream cropped thick woollen sweater with black flowers, &pound;133. 
 Black thick sweater with cream flowers, &pound;156. 
 Gold, black and brown patterned chunky knit cardigan, &pound;135. 
 Jigsaw, 14 James Street, London W1 and branches nationwide. 
 All over cabled sweater, &pound;49, available in cream, mustard, navy or dark green. 
 Crew neck Aran cardigan, &pound;49, in orange, navy, rose or cream. 
 Cabled zip cardigan, &pound;54, in leaf green, mustard, dark green or navy. 
 Design: Crossed lines over the toytown tram: City transport could soon be back on the right track, says Jonathan Glancey 
 By JONATHAN GLANCEY 
 MODERN trams, as most continental Europeans know, neither shake nor rattle, nor do they roll. 
 Sleek, solidly built, gentle on the environment, they are often an ideal form of city transport. 
 They also exert a fascination very much of their own as they slither round circuses and brush through old city gates, flashing arcs of lightning as they switch tracks on winter nights. 
 Single-car, articulated or double-decker, trams are one of the most reliable and enduring forms of public transport invented. 
 The orange-liveried &bquo;1500&equo; series trams in Milan, for example, date from 1927. 
 Eventually they will be replaced, but more than 60 years on they run with the rhythmic reliability of a Swiss watch. 
 They are as much a part of Milan as La Scala or the Galleria Vittore Emmanuele. 
 Last month it was announced that Britain will get its first new-wave trams in 1991. 
 Destined to run in Manchester, they will relieve traffic congestion and help to reduce the levels of carbon monoxide in the city centre, outlying suburbs and satellite towns of Bury, Altrincham, Salford, Oldham and Rochdale. 
 In Britain, with the main exception of Blackpool (not forgetting the single-deckers of the Isle of Man and Llandudno), trams had been largely relegated to the history books. 
 Otherwise, the best place to see working trams has been the tram museum at Crich in Derbyshire or else in old British Transport Commission films and Ealing comedies. 
 Trams disappeared from most British cities in the 1950s. 
 London's venerable red and cream double-deckers rumbled along the Thames embankment for the last time in 1952. 
 Somehow the image of the tall, thin, mournful double-deck tram with its wooden body, slatted wooden seats and growling electric motor has stuck in the British mind. 
 Trams, it was believed until surprisingly recently, are old-fashioned. 
 They had something to do with fish and chips wrapped in newspaper, men in hats, National Health specs, smog and powdered egg. 
 They held up the bright new diesel buses and, even worse, blocked the progress of private motorists in bulbous Austins and lumpen Humbers in canyon-like city thoroughfares. 
 They picked up power from a spider's web of unsightly overhead wires. 
 They were inflexible in operation, draughty, and mobile reminders of TB epidemics with the enamelled &bquo;Do Not Spit&equo; signs screwed to their bulkheads. 
 But the modern tram could hardly be more different. 
 It plays a key role in keeping city streets on the move and is even the object of the best modern designers' desire. 
 In Milan, for example, the commission to design the new generation of &bquo;Jumbo&equo; trams, which went into service in 1979, was one that leading Italian architects and designers fought over. 
 After all, the Jumbo, a handsome and imposing articulated unit designed by architect, engineer and critic Klaus Giovanni Koenig, will be seen on the streets of Milan for the next half-century. 
 Spotlessly clean and popular, the Jumbo is a long-term advertisement for Koenig's design skills. 
 The modern tram is a green machine. 
 Assuming the power station at the end of the line burns cleanly, the tram is virtually pollution free. 
 Standing at traffic lights a Koenig-designed Jumbo is, save for the chatter inside, completely silent. 
 The overhead wires are so slight that you have to look hard to see them. 
 Powers of acceleration and braking are remarkable, the latter far greater than any car. 
 But sadly, there is no indication that the GMA consortium which will design, operate and maintain the first of the new generation British trams in Manchester will share the looks of their Milanese counterparts. 
 Artists' impressions show a tram that has more in common with the flat-faced, characterless light trains of the toy-like Docklands Light Railway. 
 There is still time for GMA (GEC, Mowlem, Amec and Greater Manchester Buses) to consider employing an inspired architect or industrial designer. 
 After all, Mancunians and visitors to the Manchester conurbation are going to have to look at these mechanical millipedes for well into the twenty-first century. 
 Now that buses are no longer designed to enhance the streets they serve, Manchester has a chance to make a fresh start with its trams. 
 Manchester is not alone. 
 Other British towns, Croydon and Southampton among them, are also considering modern tramways. 
 These are all referred to as &bquo;supertram&equo; networks, the implication being that the new-generation tram is an altogether more dynamic form of transport than its pre-war predecessors. 
 What it really means is that the new trams are a hybrid between street car and lightweight suburban train. 
 Although they will slip through the city centre serving the essential parts &mdash; shopping malls, leisure centres, theme parks, amusement arcades and museums &mdash; the Manchester supertrams will also head out of town on a mix of reserved track and existing railway lines. 
 The supertram is, in effect, a low-cost replacement for British Rail's ageing fleet of suburban diesel multiple-unit trains, those rasping diesels which change gear to the accompaniment of voluminous clouds of acrid black exhaust fumes and the blessing of train spotters. 
 They will perform some of the same functions, but they will not be an exact replacement for traditional trams. 
 And although the supertram concept will spread through major cities during the next decade, Blackpool will still be alone in its use of traditional double-deckers. 
 Keeping the fabric of history: Taking care of old clothes requires more than just mothballs, writes Jo Levin 
 By JO LEVIN 
 HOARDING clothes has long been a British vice. 
 The current exhibition of Indian dress at Liberty (Regent Street, London W1, until October 21) shows many a garment bought by an Empire wife and stored in a trunk, along with christening dress, lace collars and evening gowns. 
 These surviving pieces of history need care if they are not to deteriorate. 
 So will the new wedding dress. 
 The craft of caring for clothes vanished with the ladies' maid and the most common modern method of storage &mdash; hanging them, shrouded in plastic, on a wire coathanger &mdash; is less than ideal. 
 Items of value, real or sentimental, are worth the trouble of proper storage. 
 Lynda Hillyer, head of textile conservation at the Victoria and Albert Museum in London, is concerned with the care of fragile and valuable textiles from the time of Tutankhamun. 
 But the basic rules she recommends apply to all. 
 Keep textiles out of light, which both fades dyes and supplies the energy to begin the process of breaking the fibres down, as with the shredded silk curtains of many a National Trust mansion. 
 Pack, swathe and support garments with acid-free tissue paper. 
 Normal tissue paper, like most paper, contains acid which encourages fading and decay, including the gradual yellowing of white fabrics, a process which may be seen after only a few years. 
 Acidic conditions are particularly bad for cellulose, so cotton and linen fabrics are especially at risk. 
 Wood &mdash; in a drawer, wardrobe or chest &mdash; may also be acidic: line all drawers and storage compartments with acid-free tissue. 
 Fragile and heavy garments are best stored flat on a dust-free shelf or, ideally, in an acid-free cardboard box. 
 Insert sausage-shaped rolls of acid-free tissue paper in folds, so that they do not become permanent &mdash; caused, as a microscope would show, by fibres cracking. 
 Use pads of acid-free tissue paper to bulk out shoes. 
 If using hangers, pad them to about three times the usual extent with acid-free tissue or with polyester wadding covered with white cotton (which can also be used to pad out the shoulders and shapes of packed costumes). 
 Foam padding, often used on coat hangers, is not ideal. 
 Make sure the whole shoulder area is supported &mdash; the hanger should fit its breadth. 
 If a dress is heavy, support the skirt separately with tapes. 
 Use cotton dust-covers &mdash; white &mdash; and wash them every few months. 
 Dust is abrasive and may contain metallic particles. 
 Of course everything to be stored must first be clean. 
 Do not store clothes in plastic, which will attract dust and, if there is any moisture in the air, encourage the growth of mould. 
 Check the clothes every few months, or moths and mould may flourish unhindered. 
 Wrap mothballs in muslin and do not let them touch the textiles. 
 Specialist private dry cleaning of antique textiles: Bernard Dore works for the National Trust and national museums as well as dealers. 
 Write or telephone before visiting: 0304 373684, 271 Sandown Road, Deal, Kent. 
 Conservation cleaning is an expensive process and prices vary wildly, though it is worthwhile for a valuable or fragile article: Mr Dore will give an estimate in advance. 
 The conservation unit of the Museums and Galleries Commission has a register of private conservators including specialists in textiles. 
 The unit checks references on all conservators, and has a leaflet on how to choose the right restorer: write to 7 St James's Square, London SW1Y 4JU. 
 Compare and date your own textiles with those at the Victoria and Albert Museum's Textile Galleries, from room 96 to 101, which include samples from ancient Egyptian times to the present century, and with the museum's Dress Collection. 
 Style Update: Reams recycled 
 By VINNY LEE 
 PAPERSAVE is the first commercial stationer and paper merchant in Scotland to deal exclusively in recycled paper products. 
 Dismissing the myth that recycled paper is sub-standard, Papersave is offering finishes as fine as watermarked business papers, and in many cases prices are cheaper than for &bquo;virgin' paper. 
 Papersave sells recycled paper for everything from quality stationery, to paper for printing, duplicators, computers, note-pads, kitchen and toilet rolls. 
 Coloured, textured as well as plain, the paper comes primarily from British sources, quite a lot is Scottish and smaller amounts are imported from Germany and America. 
 Toilet rolls 84p for pack of two, basic writing papers from &pound;9 for 500 sheets, quality watermarked paper from &pound;10 for 500 sheets, envelopes, standard &pound;26 for box of 1,000 (can be split) and quality from &pound;27 for 500. 
 Style Update: Plate class 
 By VINNY LEE 
 MARYSE BOXER designs simple but beautiful tableware and has just added &bquo;Dorado&equo;, with simple gold leaf decoration to her collection. 
 Ms Boxer's philosophy is that china should be flexible, &bquo;getting away from the 50-piece matching bridal set&equo;. 
 She advocates building up place settings &bquo;with separate yet related pieces that can be combined according to mood, time of day and style of meal&equo;. 
 The popular &bquo;Form and Colour&equo; range comes in eight colours and four shapes - round, square, oblong and Lotus (six scalloped-edged petals). 
 But the new &bquo;Dorado&equo; in cream, black and orange with single gold line edge or concentric gold circles, offers scope for a richer, more formal look. 
 The range is available from Joseph, Sloane Street, London SW1 and One, Princes Street, Glasgow. 
 Pin-stripes and inter-city stitches 
 By VINNY LEE 
 THE twentieth-century equivalent of the fishing knitter George Trowark (see left) could well be management consultant Jeremy Young who also knits as he travels, writes Vinny Lee. 
 &bquo;I knitted my way across the Atlantic,&equo; he reveals. 
 &bquo;On a flight to New York I sat in my Club Class seat and knitted almost continuously for the seven-hour flight. 
 The air hostesses inquired what I was making and a man passing in the aisle quite genuinely complimented me on my work.&equo; 
 Mr Young started knitting 10 years ago. 
 &bquo;A girlfriend made me a wonderful big, bright red jumper which I liked so much that I asked her to knit me another. 
 Her reply was &bquo;knit it yourself&equo; &mdash; so I did. 
 She taught me the basics: casting-on, how to knit and pearl, and I set to work. 
 &bquo;Travelling on the train to and from Folkestone and London over a period of months I knitted a bright pink jumper. 
 Sitting in the compartment in my dark city suit, working away at the bright knitting caused a lot of second glances from passers-by, but usually ensured I kept the compartment to myself. 
 &bquo;In the beginning knitting was a challenge; now it is therapeutic and satisfying. 
 I have reached a stage where I can watch television, as long as the programme doesn't require too much attention, and knit at the same time.&equo; 
 Mr Young does not have much time for fancy patterns with three dimensional &bquo;fiddly&equo; bits. 
 He likes to knit quickly. 
 &bquo;I use chunky wool and big needles so that results are achieved rapidly. 
 I love bright colours and knit most of the jumpers as presents. 
 Friends like to be given something you've taken time and trouble to make for them.&equo; 
 Apart from jumpers he has knitted a jacket, scarves, a three-foot banana (which became a cushion) and numerous ties. 
 &bquo;Moss stitch is best for ties otherwise they tend to curl up at the edges and look like a drain pipe.&equo; 
 Has knitting been detrimental to his career? 
 Mr Young thinks not. 
 When working for Reuters, a colleague revealed that their boss had been impressed by his hobby. 
 &bquo;Apparently he liked his staff to have character,&equo; says Mr Young. 
 And is there anywhere he has not knitted? 
 &bquo;Yes, in the pub.&equo; 
 Angry Tories round on Lawson 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS and COLIN BROWN 
 NIGEL LAWSON conceded last night that the hike in interest rates was extremely &bquo;awkward&equo;, &bquo;uncomfortable&equo; and &bquo;embarrassing&equo; so close to next week's Conservative Party conference. 
 But the Chancellor said in a series of television and radio interviews that he did not believe in &bquo;trying to play silly games, political games&equo; &mdash; and he would not rule out a further increase if it became necessary. 
 Mr Lawson said he had always played straight with people, which was why the Government was so respected, &bquo;even if it is not always loved by all the people&equo;. 
 Rank-and-file party representatives, when they debate the economy in Blackpool next Thursday, are bound to reflect the strong reaction of high-level mortgage holders in the Conservative heartlands of the South. 
 Mr Lawson, who has never found it easy to win the affection of the party conference, now faces the trickiest political test of his career in attempting to avert unseemly attacks on his competence from the Conservative grassroots. 
 Tory MPs were last night angry about the rise in interest rates and expressed fears that a further rise might be necessary. 
 But ministerial aides said it was better to get the increase out of the way this week, rather than have it happen during the conference. 
 Party leaders will be making efforts to ensure that Mr Lawson is not openly attacked at the conference. 
 Although the terms of the motion to be debated are supportive of government economic policy, a significant number of constituencies have criticised over-reliance on interest rates as an instrument of economic regulation. 
 Ministers are also determined to use the Tory conference to counter-attack Labour's successful conference week and lift the Conservatives' sagging spirits. 
 Neil Kinnock said last night that the rise in interest rates was &bquo;a shattering blow both to households right across Britain and also to industries, and it's even worse because it's a blow that has been gathering ever since the first day that this Government decided its one and only economic policy would be a reliance on interest rates&equo;. 
 But Mr Lawson refused to rule out what John Smith, Labour's Treasury spokesman, described as &bquo;the unthinkable&equo; &mdash; a further increase. 
 The Chancellor said on BBC television: &bquo;I can't give a firm promise that this is the turning point, that they won't go up any higher. 
 But I would very much hope that it won't be necessary for interest rates to go up any higher than necessary.&equo; 
 He accepted that mortgage-holders would face difficulty, but said it was necessary to curb borrowing, and mortgages accounted for 85 per cent of household borrowing. 
 Mr Smith said: &bquo;This is the price of Mr Lawson's economic mismanagement and complacency.&equo; 
 Labour, he said, would curb borrowing through credit controls. 
 Michael Latham, an executive member of the 1922 Committee of Tory MPs and a former director of the Housebuilders' Federation, condemned the rise as unnecessary and warned it could lead to a recession. 
 He said: &bquo;This is an extraordinary decision. 
 This rise will send some industries, especially construction, spinning into deep recession and will force up unemployment.&equo; 
 &bquo;Independent&equo; sales 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS and COLIN BROWN 
 The Independent, which celebrates its third birthday today, achieved a record circulation in September of 419,000 copies a day. 
 That unaudited figure compares with a previous peak of 413,000 last March. 
 The comparable figure for September 1988 was 397,000. 
 Recruits for Sunday paper 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS and COLIN BROWN 
 Two of Britain's best-known journalists are to join The Independent on Sunday, which is to begin publishing on 28 January next year. 
 Neal Ascherson, the award-winning writer, will be a columnist on the new newspaper. 
 He leaves the Observer, where he is an associate editor. 
 Blake Morrison will be literary editor; he also leaves the Observer, where he held the same position. 
 The appointment of other leading journalists will be announced over the next few weeks. 
 Nuns' thin black line repels chicken-killers 
 By LIZ HUNT 
 SHORTLY AFTER 8am yesterday six elderly nuns slipped from their living quarters at the Our Lady of the Passion Monastery near Daventry, Northants, and made their way to the hen-house. 
 &bquo;You've heard of the thin red line; we are the thin black one,&equo; said one before disappearing inside. 
 They were prepared for an unyielding defence of their two flocks of 10,000 battery hens against the Ministry of Agriculture and the 10 burly ex-miners who form the ministry's chicken-killing squad, ever-ready to wring a feathered neck. 
 A little after 8.30am, Chris Williamson, a ministry veterinary officer, arrived. 
 He had come to supervise the slaughter of one of the nuns' flocks which had been found to be infected with Salmonella typhimurium. 
 The hen-house door remained firmly shut. 
 Mr Williamson was reduced to fruitless trips between the car and the telephone. 
 The mobile slaughter unit came, saw, and was repulsed. 
 Miriam Warburton, a divisional veterinary officer, arrived, and was in turn refused entry to the hen-house. 
 The nuns claim that they were exploiting a loophole in the Zoonoses Order 1989, which allows the slaughter of any infected flocks. 
 It might permit the slaughter, but it did not permit entry of Ministry of Agriculture officials, the nuns said. 
 Mother Catherine, the mother superior, a spritely 85-year-old American, said there had never been a case of food poisoning associated with eggs from the monastery, which had kept flocks for 20 years. 
 &bquo;We eat eggs all the time; we'd be the first to be affected.&equo; 
 She said there was no direct evidence linking their eggs with an isolated case of food poisoning that had occurred nearby in Bedworth in June, which was due to Salmonella enteriditis, not typhimurium. 
 There was &bquo;vague information&equo; that the person concerned might have eaten an egg which may have come from the monastery, Mother Catherine said. 
 &bquo;If we thought for one moment that the health of the public was at risk we'd stop selling eggs.&equo; 
 Last night, a ministry official delivered a notice to the monastery, stating that officers intended to return this morning to carry out the order to slaughter the birds. 
 Mother Catherine said the nuns' action had highlighted the plight of egg producers in the wake of the salmonella controversy. 
 Gorbachev on Berlin tightrope: Encouragement for reform in the East coupled with warning to the West to respect post-war borders 
 From STEVE CRAWSHAW in East Berlin 
 IN ONE of his most difficult balancing acts to date, Mikhail Gorbachev, who arrived in East Berlin yesterday, urged the hard-line East German leadership to discuss economic and political reform with &bquo;all groups in society&equo;, while warning West Germany against any attempt to realign post-war borders in Europe. 
 In a speech marking the country's fortieth birthday, which is today, he said East Germany, like all countries, had problems stemming from the reform movement elsewhere in the East bloc and that these difficulties &bquo;required thought&equo;. 
 It seems unlikely that the East German leaders feel much threatened by his tone. 
 If anything, they may be relieved to have got off so lightly, given that East Germany's aversion to a local brand of perestroika and glasnost has long been clear. 
 &bquo;We do not doubt that the (East German Communist Party) is able through co-operation with all forces in society to find answers to all those questions which arise through the development of the republic and which interest its citizens,&equo; he told the huge audience gathered in the Palace of the Republic. 
 Mr Gorbachev then warned against &bquo;voices&hellip; being raised in West Germany demanding the re-establishment of Germany under its 1937 borders&equo;. 
 He said he did not &bquo;idealise&equo; the European order, &bquo;but until now, it is precisely the recognition of post-war realities that ensures peace in Europe. 
 Today we are being repeatedly asked to take steps to eliminate this division,&equo; such as breaking down the Berlin Wall, he said. 
 Arriving in East Berlin at the height of the country's most serious political crisis for more than three decades, Mr Gorbachev had earlier in the day, in a brief encounter with enthusiastic East Berliners, spoken of the need &bquo;not to panic &mdash; that's the most important thing&equo;. 
 &bquo;We're staying!&equo; shouted one man in the crowd that greeted the Soviet leader when he laid a wreath at the Eternal Flame. 
 There were scattered cries of &bquo;Gorby! 
 Gorby!&equo; which became louder and more prolonged when he emerged from the war memorial. 
 Several thousand people, including many wearing the blue shirts of the official Free German Youth, were waiting to see Mr Gorbachev on his first &bquo;meet-the-people&equo; detour of the day. 
 In an impromptu press conference outside, Mr Gorbachev said: &bquo;If states don't react to impulses of the times, they are in danger.&equo; 
 He then delivered a heavy hint of the need for reform: &bquo;We know the Germans, we've known them for a long time. 
 They look at problems, and change.&equo; 
 The truth is that the East German leadership has so far shown all too few signs of wanting to change. 
 Erich Honecker, the country's 77-year-old leader, continued only to talk of the need for &bquo;the further development of socialism&equo;, in his speech in the Palace of the Republic. 
 &bquo;We will solve our problems ourselves, with socialist means. 
 Proposals intended to weaken socialism will not blossom here,&equo; he told the audience. 
 But the optimistic platitudes are sounding more hollow than ever before. 
 It is not just a matter of the tens of thousands who have streamed out of the country in recent weeks, via Budapest, Prague and Warsaw. 
 The opposition at home is growing ever stronger. 
 Every night the Gethsemane Church is packed with mostly young East Germans who come to light candles in protest at the regime's refusal to accept reform. 
 Several thousand have signed a petition demanding more change. 
 Last night, another church &mdash; the Church of the Saviour &mdash; was packed for what was described as &bquo;a workshop&equo;, entitled &bquo;East Germany's Future: What Now?&equo; 
 The theme of many of the leaflets plastered over church walls is the same: &bquo;The police state methods must change.&equo; 
 The East German authorities do not seem to agree. 
 In East Berlin, members of Stati, the secret police, were much in evidence at and near yesterday's church meetings. 
 More ominously, a &bquo;reader's letter&equo; in a Leipzig paper yesterday spoke of &bquo;counter-revolutionary&equo; actions. 
 The letter in the Leipziger Volkszeitung called for the use of &bquo;weapons, if need be&equo;. 
 If that really is the way the authorities are now thinking &mdash; and &bquo;readers&equo; letters' have long been notoriously close to official thinking in East Germany &mdash; then the government could find it is courting unprecedented disaster. 
 When talking of what is much discussed in East Berlin as &bquo;the China solution&equo;, an elderly woman at the Church of the Saviour expressed a widely-held view when she declared: &bquo;The authorities just couldn't do it. 
 Then things would get even worse.&equo; 
 I speak for Britain, Kinnock says 
 By COLIN HUGHES, Political Correspondent 
 NEIL KINNOCK yesterday declared himself fit to be Prime Minister, by claiming in an end-of-conference message that he now speaks for the British people. 
 The Labour leader told an ITN interviewer that he felt fit to govern partly because he loved his country. 
 But he added: &bquo;That's not enough by itself. 
 I'm fit to be Prime Minister because I truly represent the people of this country &mdash; their hopes for economic success and social justice, and their aspirations, because I'm from them. 
 I'm not detached, remote, in the way this government certainly has become.&equo; 
 He went on: &bquo;I know that I'm tough. 
 I know that I can see objectives and drive after them. 
 I think that kind of tenacity is required too. 
 I've got it.&equo; 
 Kenneth Baker, the Conservative Party chairman, has made it clear that he intends mounting an attack on the Labour leader's personal qualities. 
 But Mr Kinnock dismissed the Tory tactic as &bquo;pathetic&equo;, and predicted that the Tory conference next week would be a gathering of marionettes. 
 &bquo;The British people will say to themselves: &bquo;Well here's a government that's got a majority of 100, they've been in office for 10 years, they've had all these opportunities, and at the end of 10 years all they can think of to do is to make individual attacks on the Leader of the Opposition.&equo; 
 ' Mr Kinnock's confidence was bolstered by an NOP survey in last night's London Evening Standard, which gave his party a 9-point lead over the Conservatives (46 per cent to 37). 
 The same poll found that his satisfaction rating with voters now runs at 48 per cent, compared with 39 per cent for Margaret Thatcher. 
 Mr Kinnock said that this week's conference had been a landmark for his party. 
 &bquo;It's not just that the objectives have been achieved, of getting the policy reviews endorsed, and conducting ourselves in a way that will attract the British people. 
 But it's been done because people wanted it to happen, not because it's been imposed upon them.&equo; 
 Labour will now enter a phase of trying to popularise its reviewed policies, while refining details in some areas. 
 The successful delivery of the party's policy review this week was capped when the conference agreed yesterday to the next major change Mr Kinnock intends to carry through: a diminution in the overwhelming dominance of the union block vote. 
 He is also keen to press on with modernising the party's policy-making machinery, a process which took a jump forward yesterday when delegates approved an executive consultation paper on the block vote and reform of the conference. 
 Consultation will be completed in February. 
 Some rule changes may be voted on next year, though extensive change is not likely before 1991. 
 The move towards greater equality between the unions and individual party members will &bquo;evolve&equo; over time, according to party officials, an indication that Mr Kinnock would prefer the union vote to shrink gradually as the party's membership rises. 
 But the Labour leader will move faster on indicating his preferred options for increasing the size of the national executive and making it more representative. 
 As delegates left Brighton in self-proclaimed unity and amity, party officials reflected that the week had been, electorally, the most effective Labour conference since the early 1960s. 
 It is certainly the first time since Mrs Thatcher was elected in 1979 that Labour has ended its conference with the Conservatives on the defensive. 
 Labour has doubled its lead over the Conservatives to 6 per cent in the past month, according to a poll of polls conducted for the BBC programme Newsnight. 
 Rebels &bquo;shot dead after Panama coup attempt&equo; 
 From CHRIS MCGREAL in Panama City 
 MOST OF the rebel officers who led this week's abortive coup in Panama were shot after their rebellion failed, not killed during the fighting, as the military contends, according to a senior source who was permitted to see the bodies. 
 The source added yesterday that there were 14 bodies and not 10, as the government claimed. 
 Another witness had earlier reported seeing four hooded and shackled men under arrest at the military section of the airport during the coup, but there was no way of identifying them. 
 The source said the families of the victims were not allowed to view the bodies or bury them. 
 They appeared to have suffered only one or two shots to the head, not to the rest of the body, as might be expected in a gun battle. 
 He said the killings had shaken some members of Panama's Defence Force, but that in the aftermath of the uprising, when suspicion of complicity ran wide, no one was prepared to plead for the lives of the coup plotters. 
 General Manuel Noriega, the man they failed to overthrow, is now turning his wrath to civilian opponents, saying he intends to present emergency legislation to purge the bureaucracy of &bquo;treasonous&equo; government employees who tacitly backed the uprising. 
 He called on civil servants loyal to him to denounce subversive colleagues. 
 Those who did not were also traitors, who would be replaced with his supporters. 
 One source said the general was closely scrutinising the list of telephone calls of support he received from senior officials during the coup to see who called, and whether it was before the rebellion was known to have failed. 
 Julie Ward inquest told &bquo;no evidence of murder&equo; 
 From ROBERTA MULLINEAUX in Nairobi 
 THE JULIE WARD inquest ended yesterday with counsel for the Kenyan state still maintaining she might have committed suicide or been killed by animals. 
 &bquo;We do not have evidence of murder,&equo; Alex Etyang concluded. 
 Joseph Mango, the chief magistrate who has heard evidence from 38 witnesses since the hearing began in August, reserved his verdict until 27 October. 
 Byron Georgiadis, counsel for the dead woman's father, has insisted she was murdered. 
 The charred and severed remains of Miss Ward, 28, were found a year ago in the Masai Mara game reserve in Kenya, in an out-of-the-way spot, six miles from her abandoned vehicle. 
 Mr Etyang said: &bquo;It was death by misadventure. 
 We do not have evidence of murder.&equo; 
 He questioned the evidence given by Professor Austin Gresham, a Home Office pathologist and Professor of Morbid Anatomy at Cambridge University, who conducted a second post-mortem examination on Miss Ward's remains after they had been flown to Britain by her father, John Ward. 
 Mr Etyang said: &bquo;Professor Gresham may be an eminent pathologist in the UK, but he is a human being &mdash; could he have made a mistake? 
 Just because he is a professor of medicine at Cambridge does not make his findings unquestionable. 
 He admitted he has no experience of animal bites. 
 He does not know what a hyena can do to a human body.&equo; 
 In his evidence Professor Gresham had said he had experience of bites by dogs and foxes, and had studied wild animal injuries in books. 
 In his opinion there was no doubt that Miss Ward's head had been cut off with a single blow from a sharp instrument. 
 Mr Etyang said the evidence making the game reserve's head warden, Simon Makallah, the man most likely to have murdered Miss Ward was just speculation. 
 He suggested instead that perhaps one of the two white men to see her alive last may have had something to do with her death. 
 Neither man arrived in Kenya to attend the inquest. 
 In earlier evidence the court heard that both the detective in charge of the investigation, Superintendent Muchuri Wanjau, and the dead woman's father had cleared of blame Stephen Watson, an English safari leader, and an Australian marine biologist, Glen Burns. 
 Outside the courtroom, Mr Ward said: &bquo;I have considerable qualms about what the verdict will be. 
 The Kenyans have gone to enormous trouble to make this not a murder.&equo; 
 An Irish poet not going gentle into that good night: Peter Dunn tells the bizarre tale of how family feuding, jealousy and assorted shenanigans has left Patrick Kavanagh with two graves 
 By PETER DUNN 
 Civil war has broken out among the poets of Ireland, which is why Patrick Kavanagh, bohemian and rural bard, now has two graves in Inniskeen, the County Monaghan village where he was born 85 years ago. 
 Father Peter McGuinness, the parish priest and a man of gentle understatement, says this is going to be very confusing for tourists who want to pay homage to Inniskeen's most famous son. 
 The conflict, in which men of letters are now burying each other in eloquent abuse, is over the possession of Kavanagh's soul and the legacy of his poems. 
 Ownership of the copyright to Kavanagh's work, a virulent family side-issue, could be resolved in the High Court this autumn. 
 The emotional dust over Kavanagh's two graves could, as Father McGuinness is the first to admit, take much longer to settle. 
 The first is in the village's neat cemetery, where fields run up to a distant hedgerow and a sign by the gate says &bquo;Fast Food Service&equo;. 
 Kavanagh was buried there in the family plot after his death in 1967. 
 Signs point the way along a twisting path towards the site but give no warning of what is to come. 
 Apart from a pile of fading wreaths and evidence of recent digging, the grave of Ireland's most revered poet, spoken of today in the same bated breath as W. B. Yeats, is unmarked. 
 The second grave is behind a roadside fence in the garden of the poet's pebble-dashed birth-place in Mucker a mile away. 
 It has the wooden cross and deck of old stepping stones which, until six weeks ago, identified Kavanagh's final berth in Inniskeen. 
 A notice, its spelling primly corrected, hangs on the fence and says: &bquo;This was the arrangement on the grave of Patrick Kavanagh from 1967 to 19th August 1989 when the grave was forcibly opened and the arrangement scattered. 
 These flag-stones and other memorabilia were salvaged from the detritus and are preserved here.&equo; 
 Both the Mucker shrine and its indignant notice are the work of Kavanagh's younger brother, Dr Peter Kavanagh, now 73, one-time Professor of Poetry at Wisconsin University, who has spent the past 25 years in New York promoting and publishing Patrick's work. 
 Dr Kavanagh's monumental landscaping is visible evidence of the tumultuous row which took place around Patrick's other grave in August when 100 members of Dublin's literary set turned up at Inniskeen to bury the poet's widow Katherine. 
 The funeral was delayed for three hours after members of Katherine's family complained that the wrong grave had been opened for the ceremony. 
 Katherine, a niece of the Irish patriot Kevin Barry who was shot by the English in 1916, married Patrick six months before his death in Dublin from lung cancer. 
 The two had lived together on and off in London for 10 years. 
 Katherine, a book-keeper who shared Patrick's passion for horse-racing, adored the poet who was 20 years her senior. 
 &bquo;There goes all I will know of God in life,&equo; she once said of him. 
 Her last wish, to be buried in her husband's grave, was vociferously opposed by Dr Kavanagh, who had neither known of the relationship nor been invited to the wedding. 
 He said after the funeral that his brother's marriage had been a shot-gun affair never consummated. 
 His clumsy rage scandalised Dublin's academe. 
 Its members saw it as further evidence of his obsession for being Patrick's Sacred Keeper, the title of the biography he wrote on the poet in 1979. 
 Kavanagh's book makes no mention of Katherine's name. 
 She has even been snipped out of a photograph taken after her wedding. 
 Dr Kavanagh, who wears a beret above fierce eyebrows and is known in New York as Frankie the Mechanic because he fixes the neighbours' cars, is on permanent red alert over his brother's reputation. 
 He complained once about Kavanagh's poems being read on Irish radio in a vulgar Monaghan accent; he saw his brother as a poetic giant among Dublin's envious literary pygmies who filled the helpless bard with whiskey and made him the instrument of their Communist-homosexual conspiracies. 
 &bquo;The situation is this,&equo; Dr Kavanagh said last week. 
 &bquo;The resentment against my brother was like Galileo said: &bquo;There's no hatred like the hatred of ignorance against intellectual belief.&equo; 
 Great poets speak from a position of morality, of authority and that's the one thing these people can't abide. 
 The hugger-mugger that's going on today concerns the same anti-morality. 
 I chose the moral ground and don't care about the results. 
 &bquo;When some of these smart Alecs in 1974 put up a venomous plaque to my brother in Soho, outside the Plough tavern in Museum Street, I went over there, in the winter, and tore it down. 
 It was jeering at him, saying &bquo;Patrick Kavanagh Pissed Here&equo;. 
 They'd done it in Gaelic to cover up the vulgarity. 
 Very crude people. 
 I couldn't allow that kind of thing, otherwise we slip into barbarism. 
 &bquo;It's not me that didn't recognise the marriage. 
 Patrick himself made a statement to my sister which I've got on tape, saying he'd been discarded by the woman he married. 
 There's a lot of politics involved. 
 It's very hard to explain, but these people are all on the extreme left and were seeking a poet to give them some sort of standing. 
 As for homosexuals, as Pilate said, &bquo;You've said it.&equo; 
 (Dr Kavanagh is inclined to scatter quotations and leave them to the imgination.) 
 I don't think I'm prepared to make a public statement, but I think you're very close to the truth there. 
 &bquo;I wasn't even told about the wedding because he was largely under pressure, in a corner d'you see. 
 He'd no place to live and they'd ganged up on him. 
 You probably know that the person who introduced Patrick to this woman was the head of the Communist Party in Ireland.&equo; 
 Peter Fallon, owner of the Gallery Press and Katherine's literary agent, says of Dr Kavanagh: &bquo;Because he'd devoted certain energies to Patrick, he acted as if the man were entirely his. 
 Then suddenly into the picture came a woman Patrick clearly loved enough to marry. 
 Peter's an extraordinarily cranky man with a venom that became directed towards Katherine. 
 &bquo;I read the letters between him and his brother and it became clear he couldn't even buy petrol on the New Jersey turnpike without writing to the petrol company about being over-charged. 
 People do live in a certain fear of him and anxiety about how he'll respond to anything done up there in Inniskeen. 
 &bquo;I do think in the last couple of months he's gone too far. 
 He's committed a libellous slander, based on heresay, making the most obscene remarks about Katherine and the marriage not being consummated. 
 Basically people are sick of him. 
 The community of Inniskeen, including his surviving sister, is bored with his carry on.&equo; 
 In the circumstances, no member of Katherine's funeral cortege was particularly surprised that there was trouble at the graveside, though they were relieved Dr Kavanagh had stayed away, the line from New York to Inniskeen quivering with warnings that opening Patrick's grave would be regarded as desecration. 
 There are two perceptions of what actually happened in the village that day. 
 One of them, drawn from metropolitan Dublin, laced the scandal with a smile and simply blamed the Svengalian influence of Dr Kavanagh; the other, more parochial, gives the impression of a little country funeral spinning quietly but inexorably out of control. 
 Peter &bquo;Penny&equo; Murphy, a local farmer who acts as curator of the birthplace when Dr Kavanagh is in America, is like a man savouring a dream. 
 &bquo;When Katherine died, no one contacted me whatsoever except Peter Kavanagh in America,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;He told me there was no one to go in that plot except Mary, who's the surviving sister. 
 Katherine's remains were coming on the Saturday and on the Friday I slipped up to the cemetery and saw the grave diggers digging Mary's grave. 
 &bquo;I said to the grave digger, in conversation with him, &bquo;Look, are you in the right plot?&equo; and his answer was the priest told him to dig the grave opposite Patrick's but when he came along he'd seen there was already a burial there, who was the sister Annie, but had seen this vacant plot next door, so he had dug the vacant one. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; I said, &bquo;I think there'll be trouble about this, but if that's the position, carry on.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then the remains arrived next day and the sister Mary, who is 89 and on a walking aid, objected to her grave being dug and being used by Katherine at that stage. 
 She accused me of instructing them to dig the wrong grave, which I didn't and I immediately defended myself and said: &bquo;Mary, I did not. 
 I had nothing whatever to do with it.&equo; 
 In fact I pointed that out to the grave-diggers, but they were already 4ft 6ins down at the time. 
 &bquo;What I'd like you to know is that when it was all over and Peter was back from America, the grave-diggers were down here on their bended knees begging him for forgiveness because they knew it was a nasty business and said had they known at the time they'd have had nothing to do with it.&equo; 
 Katherine Kavanagh's lawyer, John Jay, a Joycean figure with a handsome beard, was among the mourners from Dublin. 
 &bquo;God help you, it's the most exciting thing which has happened there since the man was buried,&equo; he told me in his comfortably-scuffed office in Dublin. 
 &bquo;They seemed convinced a whole lot of people had come up from the big city to show off, to be grandees, which was far from the truth. 
 &bquo;When the cortege arrived a grave ear-marked, I think, for one of the Kavanagh sisters had been opened two doors down from Patrick's, which at this stage had a wooden crucifix made and erected by Peter and crazy pavings which I gather were stepping stones from a stream on the homestead and mentioned in one of the poems. 
 &bquo;I was standing by the graveside and one of the Kavanagh sisters had said to Helen Moloney, Katherine's sister: &bquo;It's perfectly all right to use Patrick's grave. 
 We own the plot. 
 Peter doesn't&equo; And it was at this stage that someone else said, &bquo;But Peter wouldn't like it,&equo; and some little woman, who I'd thought until that moment was a nun, said, &bquo;Oh, fuck Big Petie.&equo; 
 &bquo;Katherine's sister, a pleasant, sensible woman, said to the priest, &bquo;This is the wrong grave,&equo; and the priest said, &bquo;That's the grave I was told to open,&equo; at which stage he started the funeral service and Helen said &bquo;Stop! 
 This can't go on. 
 You're burying her in the wrong grave.&equo; 
 Whereupon I produced the will out of my pocket, because I tend to take wills to funerals, and said, &bquo;Perhaps this will refresh your memory.&equo; 
 &bquo;The priest didn't seem terribly concerned, being a pragmatic man. 
 He said we couldn't ask the grave-diggers to dig another grave. 
 We said, &bquo;We'll take our jackets off and do it.&equo; 
 He said, &bquo;You couldn't do that. 
 There'll be union trouble.&equo; 
 Then the priest said, &bquo;But the grave-digger isn't well.&equo; 
 He certainly fought a stout rearguard action. 
 When the sister was summoned up and said it was her grave had been dug, he realised there was nothing more he could do and the whole thing was adjourned to the community centre for a couple of hours while big men with shovels rather grudgingly got to work.&equo; 
 John Montague, the Cork poet, who was also at the funeral, later described the shenanigans as &bquo;a brutal Irish business, and anti-woman&equo;. 
 He says he once told Peter he had &bquo;the ignorance of his brother without the excuse of his genius&equo;. 
 The fact remains, however, that the poet probably has more friends now, 20 years after his death, than when he lived in poverty in Dublin and London during the forties and fifties. 
 A big-shouldered, coarse-tongued drinking man, thumbs looped in his braces, black-shirted to save the washing, he was often derided as a rough country boy, the son of a rural cobbler. 
 &bquo;The literati had never seen one of them things before,&equo; Montague says today. 
 &bquo;They were writing about the country, but they weren't from it. 
 So here was this extremely awkward young man who'd actually ploughed, had worked with horses, owned 40 acres and was anxious to write. 
 They were amused by him for a while but he didn't keep his place. 
 He didn't think they were very good and said so. 
 He wrote Paddy, published in Cyril Connelly's Horizon about 1946, and let them all have it, which meant he'd even less chance of getting a job after that. 
 &bquo;The place that did give him a job was the Irish Catholic paper The Standard, which had a very funny editor who just liked to drink most of the day and was amused by Patrick and hired him as film critic. 
 After 10 years he worked for The Farmers Journal. 
 He was always trying. 
 &bquo;It's perfectly clear that Peter made a spiritual takeover bid for his brother. 
 He seems to think he has the moral right to usurp him, completely ignoring the woman who nurtured him through his last worst year. 
 &bquo;The truth is that Patrick was partly terrified of Peter, who came up behind him and thought he knew better what he should do. 
 Patrick was a bully, a Hibernian savage, an ex-heavyweight champion of Trinity who struck people.&equo; 
 The scuffling over Patrick's soul may soon move to a more prosaic level, that of his modest estate and, in particular, the Irish copyright to his writings. 
 Dr Kavanagh, Patrick's Sacred Keeper, has already published The Complete Poems, first in America and then, in 1984, in Ireland through the Goldsmith Press, whose proprietor is the Kildare poet Desmond Egan. 
 Dr Kavanagh sold his brother's papers, including letters from Katherine to Patrick, to University College, Dublin, three years ago for &pound;100,000. 
 Royalties remain a dynamic issue in the wake of the great funeral fiasco. 
 In July, a few weeks before she died, Katherine started High Court proceedings against Mr Egan and his publishing house for breach of copyright. 
 Her will has directed that the income from Patrick's work, estimated at &pound;10,000 a year, should be used to support a middle-aged poet, to be chosen by the estate's trustees. 
 Apart from that, Peter Fallon, her agent and proprietor of the Gallery Press, says there are plans, approved by the estate, to republish Kavanagh &bquo;to correct the many errors that appear in many published books&equo;. 
 Desmond Egan, an ebullient man known in the enemy camp as Desperate Ego, is confident that he and Dr Kavanagh will win the day. 
 &bquo;A lot of people fell around the place laughing when they heard about the middle-aged poet bit,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;I certainly did. 
 One's sense of the ridiculous should not abandon one, even at this moment. 
 &bquo;Peter Kavanagh supported Patrick for 40 years. 
 He's devoted his life to the cause and if Patrick came back there's no question as to who he'd want to control the show, because it was he that called Peter &bquo;The Sacred Keeper of My Sacred Conscience&equo;. 
 We're not in any doubt that morally we've all the rights and we believe we're going to prove it. 
 There's a fellow called Peter Fallon who's behind this thing. 
 I've been told he paid the widow money. 
 There will be a few people, beginning with Mr Fallon, looking for their own McGoolies when this is over.&equo; 
 John Jay is equally certain that the court action will be won. 
 &bquo;Copyright should theoretically have belonged to Katherine and now to the estate,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;Peter keeps uttering things over the years saying copyright has been given to him, that there was a letter, a document, but they've never been produced.&equo; 
 Dr Kavanagh, who is a director of the Goldsmith Press, promises to be in Dublin to fight his Sacred Keeper's corner in court. 
 &bquo;Ultimately I couldn't care less what happens,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;It's outside my control. 
 Mrs Kavanagh's claim cannot be, because I've spent 25 years editing, arranging and completing his work. 
 There's no other authority outside of me. 
 I'm never defeated. 
 One can never be defeated if one stands on a matter of morality.&equo; 
 Dr Kavanagh's views are not shared by many villagers of Inniskeen, whose placid good manners have been affronted by the churchyard barnies and people trundling grave-stones from one side of the parish to the other. 
 Father McGuinness has decided, for the time being at least, to keep his profile low. 
 &bquo;Sometimes you're just as well in the wings for a while,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;I don't want to be a dictator over the whole thing, to tell them what to do. 
 Peter's not going to live for ever. 
 I think that the stones will go back one day. 
 I knew there wasn't any point in asking him to return them at this stage. 
 He's got a long memory and can be rather spiteful. 
 &bquo;Apart from that, he's a good enough man, a nice man to talk to. 
 When he comes here he always visits the children in the school. 
 But he seems to have this antagonism towards the local people. 
 He feels they don't appreciate Patrick, who was not really likeable because he drank rather too much and insulted people and all sorts of things. 
 &bquo;And people were afraid of him of course. 
 He was rather ignorant sometimes. 
 He would look at people and they normally would walk on the other side of the street. 
 The Irish were always afraid of the local bard, that he might record their names in some of his work.&equo; 
 Departures: Cautionary tale for enterprising readers 
 By PETER DUNN 
 PERHAPS the Independent Traveller ought to carry some sort of warning: &bquo;Reading this section can change your life.&equo; 
 It certainly did for Simon Turner, who read a feature on these pages a year ago written by Godfrey Hodgson on his travels around the Michelin &bquo;Red Rocker&equo; hotels in the region around Toulouse in south-west France. 
 Mr Turner was a chartered surveyor who worked for Hamptons estate agents, but had realised that he &bquo;patently wasn't suited to selling houses&equo;. 
 He confesses that at the age of 40 he had reached &bquo;the proverbial midlife crisis&equo; and was searching for a different way of life. 
 &bquo;I had holidayed several times in France and was toying with the idea of buying a house there, but with no definite plan in mind. 
 I had already received details of properties in several regions of France, including the Toulouse area, when I providentially read your article, &bquo;At the sign of the Red Rocker&equo;, the catalyst being the mention of a cheap flight to Toulouse from Heathrow for &pound;116 return.&equo; 
 He immediately booked a flight to Toulouse, saw a house 35 miles north-west of Toulouse in a small hamlet and realised it was ideal as a home as well as an auberge. 
 &bquo;I discussed the matter with my wife and signed a contract straight away &mdash; without my wife seeing the house. 
 I then left Hamptons and spent two months at the Berlitz School of Language in London.&equo; 
 Mr Turner his wife and three daughters aged eight, six and four moved to France in April and his auberge opened in July. 
 The three children are now attending the local village school. 
 &bquo;Despite various teething problems we are very happy in our new life,&equo; said Mr Turner. 
 &bquo;The auberge is an attractive nineteenth-century house standing in a secluded garden of about one acre with glorious views towards the Pyrenees. 
 Guests have the use of the spacious ground-floor living room with direct access to the large south-facing terrace. 
 There are also swings and a games room for the children.&equo; 
 There are three rooms available: one double, one single and a family room. 
 Bed and breakfast prices are around &pound;10 per person for adults, &pound;5 for children (aged four to 12), children under four are free. 
 Evening meals on request at &pound;5 per person. 
 Mid-life crisis readers are duly warned. 
 Departures: Record billing 
 By PETER DUNN 
 MR E G HARRIS of Harold Wood in Essex is claiming a Guinness Book of Records entry for an overcharge on his bill during a trip to Bayeux in Normandy last month. 
 After a meal for four at Les Quatre Saisons restaurant, he was presented with a bill for Fr 1,887, around &pound;180. 
 When he later took the trouble to add up the bill he discovered that the actual cost was Fr 1,481, around &pound;140: an overcharge of &pound;40. 
 He recovered this money the following day. 
 How many people take the trouble to check their hotel or restaurant bills these days? 
 Perhaps there are others who have been overcharged by more than &pound;40 for a meal. 
 Departures: Fares that care 
 By PETER DUNN 
 NORTH-SOUTH Travel (0245 492882) in Chelmsford is perhaps Britain's first environment-friendly travel agency. 
 Non-Abta and non-Iata, it refuses to sell the traditional sun-and-sand Mediterranean package: instead it offers cheap air fares to &bquo;responsive travellers&equo;. 
 All its profits are covenanted to third world charities: since November 1986 it has contributed &pound;33,500 to organisations such as Unicef, a Tibetan children's home, Oxfam, Church Relief in Uganda and others. 
 According to the agency's director, Roger Millman, who is also director of the Centre for the Advancement of Responsive Travel, the aim is to encourage those travel alternatives &bquo;which do not adversely alter the natives&equo;. 
 Wild isle of the strange and absolute: Alison Lurie followed Flaubert, Colette and Sarah Bernhardt to find drama and mythology on Belle-Ile, off the coast of Brittany 
 By ALISON LURIE 
 At the siege of Belle-Isle I was there all the while; All the while, all the while, At the siege of Belle-Isle Until last month these lines were only a nursery-rhyme to me, accompanied in my memory by a crude illustration of a tower by the sea and square-rigged warship balancing on humped waves. 
 I thought of the place as an imaginary island, a sort of French Never Never Land. 
 But there is a real Belle-Ile in the Atlantic about eight miles off the coast of southern Brittany: a mysterious, beautiful, isolated island shaped like a fish swimming north-west, edged with black cliffs and coves of pale-brown sugar-sand. 
 Just off its shore stand giant rocks carved into strange jagged patterns by the sea. 
 The place has always attracted writers and artists and lovers of strange and dramatic scenery. 
 Colette went there at 21. 
 While her unpleasant husband shut himself in his room and wrote letters, she explored the island with Paul Masson and for the first time in her life &bquo;tasted and touched the salt, the sand, the seaweed, the odorous soft bed of the receding sea, the dripping fish&equo;. 
 The sea-gravel seemed to her to be composed of &bquo;shattered rubies tinted with mauve&equo;. 
 Flaubert describes Belle-Ile at length in Par les Champs et par les Greves; Courbet, Monet, and Matisse lived and painted there. 
 Later, Andre Breton, Salvador Dali, and other surrealists stayed and worked in a now-destroyed hotel on its wild western shore, the famed Cote Sauvage. 
 I reached Belle-Ile by ferry from the peninsula of Quiberon, after a seven-hour drive in 27-degree heat from the Paris airport that nothing on earth would induce me to repeat &mdash; though my two companions, one British and one French, conversed enthusiastically on opera, European politics, and structural anthropology. 
 (A better alternative might be to travel by rail or plane to L'Orient, 30 miles west, and rent a car.) 
 As a result of the journey, however, I can report that French motorway food is greatly superior to American. 
 We were offered fresh do-it-yourself salads, good local cheeses, strawberry tart and chocolate mousse. 
 The souvenirs on sale, though, were of intriguing awfulness; my favourite was a plastic female head enclosing a dried and shrivelled bouquet &mdash; a dead-metaphor version of the French custom of naming women after flowers, perhaps. 
 Quiberon is just south of the village of Carnac, where mile-long alleys of menhirs, or standing-stones, erected in prehistoric times, wade through fields of tall rose-beige grass. 
 It is a crowded tourist centre, heavy on souvenir shops and jokey exploitation of local sights; the cafe opposite the ferry landing was advertising a giant hamburger called Le Menhir. 
 Belle-Ile, however, seems to belong to a past era of modest and amateur tourism. 
 Le Palais, where the ferry docks, is an agreeable, unspoilt little town of ancient houses and cobbled squares. 
 It is dominated by the imposing Citadelle de Vauban, constructed in 1549 to defend the island against invaders. 
 The citadel's rough, sheer pale-brown outer walls and ramparts resemble a giant sandcastle built on the edge of the sea. 
 It is now a museum of military history, but was once full of armed men and artillery. 
 The siege commemorated in my nursery rhyme took place in 1761: an English fleet cut off supplies to the citadel, and after 38 days the garrison surrendered. 
 Until about 20 years ago the citadel still served as barracks and prison, and seems to have been thought suitable for confining revolutionaries. 
 Placide Touiss ant-L'Ouverture, son of the liberator of Haiti, was imprisoned there, and so was, more recently, Messali Hadj, the Algerian nationalist. 
 After the political disturbances of 1848, Karl Marx, with other radicals, spent time in an internment camp on the island. 
 In the summer the ferry also runs from Quiberon to the little fishing port of Sauzon, which is almost postcard-pretty from a distance but given satisfying reality in close-up by the sounds and smells of its trade and the stacks of water-roughened lobster traps and water-soaked nets and floats. 
 On the jetty near the little lighthouse is a remarkably good restaurant. 
 We sat on its terrace overlooking the harbour, watching the sky blush rose-red and devouring plum oysters, crabs, and langoustines caught that same day &mdash; and the first snails I have ever had that did not taste like bits of black rubber boot fried in garlic and olive oil. 
 The Atlantic coast of Belle-Ile is known as the Cote Sauvage, and in most places is sufficiently savage to deter any invader. 
 In the nineteenth century the actress Sarah Bernhardt, &bquo;attracted by the Absolute,&equo; as one guidebook puts it, built a chateau high on the cliff near its northernmost end, the Pointe des Poulains (Foals' Point), where the offshore rocks are said to resemble young horses galloping in the swaying navy-blue sea. 
 Her house is in ruins now, covered with flowering weeds and inhabited only by seagulls. 
 While we were on the beach below another tourist tried to climb up to the ruin; but a flock of dive-bombing gulls, screaming histrionically, drove him off. 
 hree kilometres south of the Point des Poulains is a spectacular sea-level cave, the Grotte de l'Apothicairerie. 
 Its name comes from the cormorants' nests which in the past were ranged in rows along shelves in the wet black rock, like jars in a chemist's shop. 
 Now only the sea thunders rhythmically through the grotto, flinging up fans of salty spray. 
 Further along the coast is the most amazing sight of all, the Aiguilles (needles) de Port-Coton: a chain of huge, spiky dark rocks that emerge from the sea like the petrified remains of some prehistoric monster. 
 The waves around these rocks churn up a salty froth that is said to resemble cotton-wool, though to me it seemed more like the foaming spit of an angry sea-serpent. 
 After touring the Cote Sauvage we had a perfect lunch in a crep erie: galettes &mdash; whole-wheat crepes made from sarazin (black wheat) &mdash; filled with ham or melted cheese and accompanied by foaming mugs of Breton cider; then crisp lacy brown crepes with sugar and jam or chocolate sauce, which bore no resemblance to the limp pancakes served under that name in America. 
 As the afternoon temperature rose our thoughts turned to the beaches. 
 There are many on the quieter north shore or Cote du Dedans, all beautiful and uncrowded. 
 The best-known is Les Grands Sables, over a mile long and backed by cliffs where the gorse-bushes were explosions of butter-yellow fireworks. 
 On the Cote Sauvage is Port-Donant, where the surf is exciting and sometimes dangerous. 
 It is popular with summer bathers, but at other times the water is cold and the fine sand dotted with jellyfish like complicated hot-weather dishes: semi-transparent yellow-streaked boeuf en daube and deep magenta grape aspic. 
 The central part of the island seemed at first to belong to another and less dramatic world. 
 We passed gently rolling pastures where fat sheep and cows grazed, empty dusty roads edged with white convolvulus and daisies, and fields of grain rippling in the soft wind like beige velvet stroked by an invisible hand. 
 But even here there were signs that we were not far from the sea or from strange phenomena. 
 The cypress es on the heights had grey wind-contorted branches and trunks, mimicking the twisted layers of rock by the ocean; and at a distance the whitewashed farmhouses, with their triangular gable ends, looked like fleets of sailboats moored beyond the farthest field. 
 Standing in the fields in the centre of the island were two tall stone menhirs, known locally as Jean and Jeanne. 
 According to legend they were young lovers whom the druids forbade to marry. 
 When they disobeyed they were transformed into pillars of rock and placed where they could see each other but never meet. 
 Once every 100 years they resume their human shapes and renew their embraces; anyone who sees them then is turned to stone. 
 Flaubert, who visited the island in 1847, got lost in these deserted, deceptively placid fields, of which he wrote: &bquo;One would have said that all those who owned them profited from them but did not like them.&equo; 
 He preferred the shore, where the long vistas of rocks with their thick coverings of seaweed appeared to him as the heads of &bquo;black phantoms emerging from the underworld,&equo; and the grottos were full of strange brilliantly coloured rocks and polished white beds of gravel which seemed about &bquo;to receive the water-nymph when she emerged from the waves&equo;. 
 Like Flaubert, I left Belle-Ile hoping to return &mdash; and hoping, too, that the island's isolation and the occasional fogs that cover it would discourage too many other tourists. 
 Alison Lurie is Professor of Children's Literature at Cornell University, New York. 
 Her latest book The Truth about Lorin Jones (Abacus, &pound;3.99) has just been published in paperback. 
 Alison Lurie's next book Don't Tell the Grown-ups, on children's literature, will be published next year by Bloomsbury. 
 FACT FILE Flights: Brit Air (01-499 9511) offers daily direct services from Gatwick to Brest and Rennes; a special weekend fare to both destinations costs &pound;99 return (travel out Friday, return Sunday or travel out Saturday and return Monday). 
 Normal economy return is &pound;262. 
 Ferry: Brittany Ferries (0752 221321) has a daily service from Plymouth to Roscoff, crossing time six hours. 
 A five-day bargain return for car and two adults costs &pound;84. 
 Berths from &pound;9 per person. 
 No service 23 December 1989 to 20 January 1990; one sailing a week on the route from November to February. 
 Brittany Ferries also has a daily crossing from Portsmouth to St Malo: crossing time about nine hours. 
 Bargain five-day return fare for two adults in a car from &pound;84. 
 Berths from &pound;10.50 per person. 
 No service from mid-November to mid-February. 
 Car hire: Seven days hire with Hertz (01-679 1799) under its Europe on Wheels programme costs from &pound;216, including unlimited mileage and all extras. 
 Skiing: A Swiss role on the slide: Chris Gill asks why few British skiers choose the cantons 
 By CHRIS GILL 
 THOSE who care about such things are at present locked in combat over the issue of whether the greatest number of British skiers go to Austria (which traditionally enjoys the distinction) or to France (which is the flavour of the decade). 
 Both, according to the latest figures conjured out of a hat by the French, have just over 35 per cent of the market. 
 Of much more interest to Alp-watchers is the performance of the other great Alpine skiing nations. 
 The French reckon that Italy now gets 7 per cent of our custom and, more surprisingly, that Switzerland gets only 5 per cent. 
 Once upon a time, this might have been 95 per cent. 
 This is partly a consequence of simple arithmetic. 
 Switzerland has lots of Alps, but they are now less densely equipped with skiers' dormitories than those of France and Austria. 
 Many of the big names of Swiss skiing have fewer than 10,000 beds; the total for Val d'Isere/Tignes approaches 50,000. 
 But it is more a consequence of the view we have of Switzerland and of Swiss skiing. 
 A dominant factor is the idea that Switzerland is expensive. 
 It is not entirely without foundation: holidaying on the cheap in such places as super-smart St Moritz, Zermatt and Gstaad is next to impossible, whatever the tourist offices there might say. 
 But it is not expensive when you compare like with like &mdash; that is, when you compare French with Swiss. 
 Of course, if you squeeze yourself and your mates into a &bquo;compact&equo; studio and live on bread and cheese, you can live more cheaply in France than in a Swiss hotel. 
 But in the important area of mountain lunches, for example, my experiences (and the distilled findings of those who report to The Good Skiing Guide on such matters) point to parity between France and Switzerland, with Austria and Italy providing worthwhile savings. 
 It remains true that Switzerland is not a place for &bquo;convenience&equo; skiing in the way that France is. 
 Ski areas tend to be as fragmented now as they were 20 or 30 years ago. 
 In some cases this may be attributable to the Swiss tendency to conserve (money, not nature); in others, the terrain makes links between areas impracticable or unnecessary. 
 Zermatt, for example, is a resort where many skiers must have wished for better links. 
 In Davos and St Moritz, the areas are so widely spread and rewarding individually that the idea of linking them scarcely arises. 
 One resort seizing the bull by the horns is little old Adelboden, which for 1991 is building a big new gondola to link two of its smaller ski areas to its major one. 
 Whatever its weaknesses, Switzerland always has a couple of aces up the sleeve. 
 The first is that there are no Alps like the Swiss Alps. 
 The French, Italian and Austrian Alps have their spectacles, but they are not presented so conveniently for the the idle downhill skier (or even non-skier) as the great set-pieces of the Swiss. 
 The second ace is the country's near-monopoly of traditional traffic-free villages &mdash; or what pass for traffic-free villages in these days of electric taxis and buses. 
 It is from these villages and their ski areas that the most impressive mountain scenery is to be seen. 
 The famous trio of Eiger, Monch and Jungfrau loom over the pistes of tiny British-dominated Wengen, and are seen to even better advantage from even tinier Murren (the one resort which genuinely is traffic-free). 
 Money-dominated Zermatt is synonymous with the unreal pyramid of the Matterhorn (which is unrecognisably ordinary when seen from Italian Cervinia, next door). 
 The peaks surrounding glacier-dominated Saas Fee may be less distinguished, but the ice-falls of the Feegletscher hanging over the village are in their way just as striking. 
 Of course, we must not forget that these are ski resorts. 
 Wengen's skiing is extensive, but for piste skiers is mostly easy; Murren is very limited, with one spectacular descent from the famous Schilthorn; Zermatt has something for everyone and lots for experts, but to reach its full potential needs better snow than it often receives; Saas Fee has an excellent glacier, but again needs abundant snow to provide much more than that &mdash; in particular, to satisfy better skiers. 
 But the quality and quantity of the skiing to be done in these places is almost a secondary consideration. 
 Perhaps that explains why most British skiers aren't inclined to go to Switzerland &mdash; and why a minority wouldn't dream of going anywhere else. 
 Skiing Update: Runway enterprise 
 By CHRIS GILL 
 EXETER-BASED InStyle Holidays (0392 70131) has displayed enterprise in flying from little-used airports in Britain to little-used airports in the Alps, using small propeller aircraft. 
 Their six resorts in France are served by flights from Plymouth, Exeter and London City to Chambery, their three resorts in Austria from Exeter and Bristol to Innsbruck. 
 Skiing Update: Letters, pray 
 By CHRIS GILL 
 OVER coming weeks, this page will cover subjects on which we'd like to hear from readers. 
 First, ski-guiding &mdash; now widely offered by tour operators. 
 Is it the valuable service it's made out to be? 
 Then, skiing with young children. 
 If you've done it, what lessons could you pass to those who have not? 
 Finally, chalet holidays, and in particular upmarket ones: are they worth the extra cost? 
 Write to Chris Gill, The Old Forge, Norton St Philip, Bath BA3 6LW. 
 The most stimulating letter on each topic wins The Good Skiing Guide. 
 Skiing Update: French lesson 
 By CHRIS GILL 
 IT IS always worth timing visits to the French Alps to avoid French school holidays. 
 This season, according to Chamonix tourist office, the peak period will be 14-25 February, when schools in two of the three national zones will have broken up. 
 The churches built on wool: Angela Lambert enjoys the riches at the heart of East Anglia 
 By ANGELA LAMBERT 
 UNTIL six or seven years ago, outsiders associated East Anglia with fens, flatness and the vanished Edwardian nannies of Frinton. 
 Its old churches, green fields and long beaches were cherished by the inhabitants of Essex, Suffolk, Norfolk and Cambridgeshire, but not yet on the tourist agenda. 
 Today, I was told, villagers living around the great wool churches of Lavenham and Long Melford have to bar their doors and ignore the knocking of tourists, who take them for antique shops and offer to buy their furniture. 
 The tourists are right. 
 East Anglia on a sunny weekend is a place of matchless beauty. 
 Its villages look too good to be true. 
 Lavenham and Long Melford, for example, have no telegraph poles, to preserve the timeless air that pervades them. 
 Yet you only have to read Ronald Blythe's Akenfield to realise that these picturesque, half-timbered cottages, often painted the characteristic Essex pink (pale salmon), ochre or spring-leaf green, are more prosperous now than ever in the &bquo;real&equo; past. 
 Many are still elaborately decorated with pargeting, an ornate, patterned plasterwork practised in this area since the early thirteenth century. 
 Most of East Anglia's prosperity today is due to City commuters, the second-homes market and tourism. 
 The ideal hotel from which to explore is Dedham Hall, set among tall trees in the Vale of Dedham, looking directly across towards Dedham church on one side and Flatford Mill on the other: both painted by Constable. 
 The hotel lies in five acres of fields and garden, and the Slingos, who own it, make the most of their beautiful surroundings by running painting courses for about &pound;200 a week (including breakfast and dinner), or &pound;90 for a long weekend. 
 These are so popular that you will need to book at least a couple of months in advance. 
 The other great joy of Dedham Hall is the food. 
 The Slingos have their own vegetable garden, chickens, ducks, sheep and cows. 
 Everything is home-grown, home-made and fresh: it tastes like forgotten food. 
 If Dedham Hall is fully booked &mdash; and it may well be &mdash; try the best bed-and-breakfast we have ever found, just a few miles away at the Old Vicarage, Higham, near Colchester. 
 It is a rambling Tudor house run by John and Margaret Parker, whose breakfast room and drawing room look out over a wonderful walled garden, beyond which fields of grazing cows stretch down to the river. 
 Another hotel that would make a good starting point for a weekend &mdash; or longer &mdash; in East Anglia is the Black Lion at Long Melford. 
 It changed hands recently and is now run by Stephen and Janet Errington. 
 After dinner there, when the moon was full and low and deep orange, we walked up the road from the hotel to Long Melford church. 
 Its vast walls of flint and glass and Gothic tracery were brilliantly floodlit and the churchyard cat, sleek and black as tar, greeted us querulously and led us right round the church and through the gravestones at the back, glimmering and pale in the moonlight. 
 We were quite alone and the great church, the size of a cathedral, was unearthly in its floodlit, moonlit beauty. 
 Long Melford is one of the wool churches that commemorate the wealth of East Anglia in the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries. 
 Another is at Lavenham, 10 minutes' drive up the road. 
 Just inside the front porch, a handwritten book is prefaced with the words &bquo;This book has been compiled that something, more than their mere names, may be known of the Lavenham men who gave their lives for their country in the Great War.&equo; 
 This is followed by 50 or so names, each with a description. 
 The much-thumbed book is deeply moving, and sets the tone for a walk round this glorious building, which has seen the christenings, marriages and burials of the folk of the village for more than 600 years. 
 East Anglia is exceptionally rich in churches and cathedrals. 
 There are several splendid houses near Long Melford that would make for a gentle afternoon's potter through the rooms and possessions of the rich of a few centuries ago. 
 The loveliest, to my mind, is Melford Hall, whose charming, octagonal Jacobean gatehouse is reached along an avenue of clipped yew trees and, with its high windows flooding the octagon with light, is my fantasy of the ideal study. 
 Lavenham is often called the finest medieval village in England. 
 It is an image of the world we have lost, its gently sloping streets converging upon the market place. 
 Here stand the early sixteenth-century timbered Guildhall, now a museum to 700 years of the cloth industry. 
 Next to it is The Little Hall, dating from the fourteenth century, with its floorboards gleaming with the patina of age, low-beamed ceilings and a tiny, unruly, charming walled garden. 
 Precisely next door to this is a restaurant called The Great House. 
 Here, in the cool, pretty setting of the dining room that was once Stephen Spender's, you will be served an exquisite three-course lunch for &pound;9.50, &pound;6 for children. 
 The wine list is small but perfectly chosen. 
 The service is impeccable. 
 East Anglia has bookshops filled with titles like 101 Things For A Boy To Do&hellip; 
 Constable landscapes&hellip; 
 Gainsborough's house&hellip; to say nothing of huge grey sweeps of empty beach from which, at Aldeburgh, you can buy goggle-eyed skate direct from the fishing boats as they come out of the water. 
 It has Colchester oysters. 
 It has Ely Cathedral, its great green windows casting a translucent light across the Lady Chapel. 
 With all this, small wonder it also has tourists. 
 Sore pedal push to the pagodas: A mountain bike is the perfect way to explore the byways of Nepal, says David Reed 
 By DAVID REED 
 THE FIRST thing to do in Kathmandu is dump your bags and hire a bike. 
 A bicycle is to the medieval streets of Nepal what a convertible is to a California freeway: appropriate technology. 
 Until recently, Nepal knew only one brand, the Hero, a clunky steel one-speeder. 
 Now, Kathmandu has discovered mountain bikes. 
 They're everywhere, not just in the capital but exploring crannies where no other form of transport will go. 
 A mountain bike is the perfect touring vehicle for Nepal's roads, which in recent years have deteriorated badly. 
 After this summer's monsoon, the Kathmandu-Pokhara highway (the country's most popular tourist route) probably looks like a donkey track. 
 A serious petrol shortage is only making things worse &mdash; bus travel, crowded at the best of times, is now cruel and inhumane. 
 I joined a group going to Nagarkot, a hilltop resort on the rim of the Kathmandu valley. 
 Organised by Kathmandu's only cycle tour operator, the trip wasn't too long or demanding, and was designed to introduce Nepalese culture, history and (in theory, anyway) Himalayan views at the top. 
 We were a group of eight Australians and Americans, led by a former Atlanta debutante named Frances Higgins. 
 She'd come to Nepal with a back-pack three years earlier and ended up marrying the US embassy dentist. 
 After a ritual distribution of chocolate and biscuits &mdash; they came in handy later &mdash; we wheeled out of the Kathmandu Guest House and into the demolition derby of old Kathmandu. 
 Pedestrians were the main hazard, but rickshaws, curio sellers, money-changers and the odd sacred cow also had to be manoeuvred around. 
 And the bumps. 
 I quickly found that mountain bikes don't particularly spare you the bumps. 
 We pedalled eastwards, first past the new Royal Palace &mdash; a weird, menacing building with bats hanging in the trees like handbags &mdash; and on to the great domed stupa, or Buddhist monument, of Bodnath. 
 It was Buddha's birthday. 
 An army of beggars and lepers had turned out, each crouched behind a cloth heaped with rice grains and coins. 
 For pilgrims, the ritual prostrations and prayer-wheel-spinning were out of the question, because beggars blocked the shrine. 
 Once out of Kathmandu we started getting long stares from villagers, laying out spring wheat on the road to be threshed by passing cars and carts. 
 I felt pretty silly wearing a plastic walnut shell on my head. 
 The flashy gear turned you, however unwillingly, into a sort of pied piper of Western materialism. 
 We stopped in Thimi, a village obscurely famous for a type of papier mache mask. 
 An instant crowd formed, mostly children. 
 Two or three pairs of hands roamed sensuously over the alloy frame, tentatively flexing the brakes and fiddling with the gear shift. 
 &bquo;How much you pay for this?&equo; asked a lad in a Michael Jackson T-shirt, hopefully. 
 I didn't buy any masks, but I was tempted by the matching two-foot-high figurines of King Birendra and Queen Aishwarya. 
 The King is said to be a reincarnation of the Hindu god Vishnu. 
 Ten miles from Kathmandu we pulled into Bhaktapur, the best preserved of the three ancient cities of the valley. 
 The tall brick houses would have looked like Victorian mansions, except for the pagoda roofs and the intricate wood lattices in place of glass window panes. 
 The alleys between them were dark and damp, rich with the smell of onions hung from the eaves. 
 To park the bikes we had to strike a deal with the children in the main square. 
 They wanted a few rupees as protection money &mdash; a common arrangement. 
 We lunched in a cafe overlooking a five-tiered pagoda temple, tall and slender like a square bullet. 
 After Bhaktapur, the real biking began. 
 As the land rose, the rectangular paddy fields gave way to thin terraces that carved the valley into steps; here and there an irrigated paddy glistened in a green crescent. 
 The road angled towards the rim of the valley, climbing 2,000 feet in eight relentless miles. 
 The grade was manageable in the lowest of 18 gears, but it was like riding an exercise cycle in a sauna. 
 The weather was fiendishly sticky, what they call the &bquo;pre-monsoon&equo;. 
 Clouds rose in thin columns up the mountain sides, grey upon grey, and started smudging out the valley. 
 The hilltop we were aiming for looked like an angry volcano. 
 I asked Ms Higgins what the difference was between the monsoon and the pre-monsoon. 
 &bquo;Oh, &bquo;bout two weeks,&equo; she said from behind her Ray-Ban sunglasses. 
 We climbed into the clouds and a cooling drizzle began to fall. 
 I noticed I could see my breath. 
 We kept spiralling up towards a high point on the ridge, and when we reached it there was a lodge, perched improbably like a ski-lift station. 
 Next to it was a bamboo out-building with a big sign saying: &bquo;The Restaurant at the End of the Universe&equo;. 
 We sat there drinking hot chocolate and watching the clouds scrape raggedly past. 
 They seemed to be breaking up, and to the west a different valley - the one we would descend into the next day &mdash; was filling with a luminous gold haze. 
 But to the north, where the main Himalayan chain should have loomed, the curtain never parted, and it was the same story in the morning. 
 &bquo;Y'all should see this place in the fall,&equo; Ms Higgins apologised. 
 I'd seen the Himalayas in the autumn, so I was able to imagine them. 
 On my previous visit, at dawn, the range had floated eerily above a sea of fog. 
 At sunset the slabbish, orange peaks had appeared like ghosts out of the clouds and then, in less time than it took to wind on a camera, swirled away again. 
 Sore bottoms on saddles, we pointed our fat tyres down the steep track. 
 The descent was nerve-racking and it reminded me of the slow, queasy way light planes come in to land in Himalayan valleys. 
 At the first sign we came to, women were bashing wheat sheaves against rocks and men squatted in the dust playing a game with pebbles. 
 We were back in the sultry heat of the valley. 
 FACT FILE Flights: Royal Nepal Airlines has begun direct flights from London to Kathmandu: return fares cost &pound;520 through Babin Travel (01-383 4314). 
 An alternative is Pakistan Airlines via Karachi. 
 Mountain bike operators: Himalayan Mountain Bikes, located in the courtyard of the Kathmandu Guest House, runs trips all over Nepal from 1 to 13 days, with costs ranging from &dollar;20 to &dollar;1,940; the Nagarkot trip costs &dollar;80. 
 Price includes everything &mdash; equipment, food, hotel or tent and, on longer trips, an escort vehicle. 
 Overnights can be arranged in Kathmandu, but longer trips should be booked by writing to the company at PO Box 2769, Kathmandu, Nepal. 
 Mountain bikes can be hired for &dollar;8 a day from America Nepal Mountain Bike Rental, south of the Old Vienna Inn in Kathmandu. 
 Books: A Guide to Trekking in Nepal by Stephen Bezruchka, The Mountaineers, &pound;8.95. 
 David Reed is also writing a guide to Nepal. 
 Health: Hepatitis (gamma globulin), typhoid and Japanese encephalitis jabs are recommended; malaria pills may be advisable for lowland areas. 
 Visas: 14-day visas, extendable to one month, available on entry at the airport; for longer stays, apply in advance to the Royal Nepalese Embassy, 12a Kensington Palace Gardens W8, London (01-229 1594). 
 Trekking permits are necessary only for off-road trips in certain areas. 
 Maps: The Schneider map of the Kathmandu Valley is invaluable; outside the valley, the Nelles map of Nepal should be taken with a pinch of salt. 
 Trekking maps sold in Nepal may prove useful. 
 Tavel Update: Travel Top Ten 
 By DAVID REED 
 ACCORDING to figures from the English Tourist Board, the following historic places attracted the most (ticket-paying) visitors in 1988. 
 Tavel Update: Neat Noel 
 By DAVID REED 
 A THREE-NIGHT Christmas holiday in Rouen, France, at the Hotel de Dieppe costs &pound;119 per person &mdash; including a six-course dinner on Christmas Eve -in a ferry-inclusive package offered by P &amp; O European Ferries (0705 772233). 
 The winter Short Trips to the Continent brochure also offers pre-Christmas shopping trips from Portsmouth to Le Havre, or Cherbourg, from &pound;50 return for a car and four passengers. 
 Tavel Update: Credit caution 
 By DAVID REED 
 IF YOU buy air tickets by telephone, be very careful about giving your credit card number. 
 David Rundle of Slough rang a London agency, seeking a return seat-only deal to Athens. 
 The agent was able to offer a ticket and quoted a fare of &pound;153. 
 &bquo;I said I was very interested and gave my credit card number as requested.&equo; 
 The agent told Mr Rundle that she had to check his &bquo;card rating&equo; and put him on hold &mdash; to the accompaniment of taped music. 
 &bquo;This played for at least 10 minutes and finished and the phone went dead. 
 I rang again and the agent said she thought I'd put the phone down.&equo; 
 He said that he hadn't, and he was put on hold again &mdash; and again the phone went dead. 
 &bquo;By this time I had waited about 15 minutes hanging on the phone and the clerk had not confirmed any booking.&equo; 
 His patience exhausted, he called another agent and booked a dearer ticket. 
 He was surprised to receive shortly afterwards an invoice from the first agency informing him that his Visa account had been debited for &pound;153 for tickets he didn't know he had bought. 
 The second agency had warned him he was entering into a contract by giving his credit card number. 
 He demanded a refund from the first agents but they refused, arguing that because he had given them his credit card number he had entered into a contract. 
 Mr Rundle took his case to Save &amp; Prosper who issued his Visa card. 
 On investigation, they discovered that the first agency had failed to get proper authorisation from Visa for the transaction. 
 According to Ian Lindsey, a director of Save &amp; Prosper, if the agency had obtained authorisation there is &bquo;no way&equo; Mr Rundle could have received a refund. 
 &bquo;Never, ever give out your card number until you have reached agreement,&equo; Mr Lindsey said. 
 Medieval bridge-builders to tourists: Hilly Janes found Bruges full of foreign hordes and historical haunts 
 By HILLY JANES 
 The first thing the lady in the hotel pointed out when she showed us our room overlooking the canal was an electric mosquito killer. 
 &bquo;Infested with tourists and mosquitoes&equo; &mdash; the verdict of some friends who had spent a weekend in &bquo;the Venice of the North&equo; earlier in the summer flashed through my mind. 
 Fortunately, in the cooler weather of late September, the scarlet geraniums in the window-boxes were still in bloom, but the mosquitoes seemed to have wilted. 
 Not so the human swarm. 
 If you perceive yourself as a traveller rather than a tourist, read no further. 
 If walking down streets teeming with non-residents induces mild panic, or if it strikes you as undignified to whizz around a museum in 10 minutes, because entry is part of the combination ticket you have bought from the tourist office, then forget Bruges. 
 You would be better spending a weekend in Antwerp, about 15 miles to the east, less well preserved architecturally but with more comprehensive museums and galleries, and much more the feel of a &bquo;real&equo; town. 
 Almost entirely surrounded by a circle of water that formed part of the original fortifications, and still linked to its neighbours and the port of Zeebrugge about eight miles away by canals, Bruges' attraction is that its medieval architecture is remarkably intact. 
 Cobbled streets with gabled houses are criss-crossed by a network of tree-lined waterways linked by more than 50 arched bridges (which is how the city got is name). 
 A trip in a motorised open punt, with stripy red and white umbrellas at hand as shelter from the Belgian drizzle, is an enjoyable way to find your bearings, and at &pound;2 for half an hour, offers a quick fix of what exactly hooks all these tourists. 
 As the boat chugs under the low arched bridges, the driver catalogues in Dutch, French, German and English the exhibits in this living museum. 
 There is St John's Hospital, the first in Europe, built in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries, although founded much earlier, and still in use until the 1970s; the Beguinage, a religious foundation for women that dates back to the twelfth century, now a convent; the thirteenth-to fifteenth-century Church of our Lady, with a 350ft tower; the Stadhuis, a magnificent Gothic town hall dating from 1376-1420. 
 The Blue Guide lists almost 20 museums, churches and galleries within a circular area about half a mile across. 
 The contents of these buildings are no less spectacular than their exteriors. 
 The St John's Hospital allows a glimpse of early health care, with mock-ups to show how the patients were housed in rows of wooden cots, and cared for by nuns and friars. 
 Displays of early surgical instruments give a chilling glimpse of the pain the sick must have endured before anaesthetic was invented. 
 The hospital's fifteenth-century chapel houses a small collection of works by Hans Memling: exquisite, jewel-like portraits and interpretations of biblical scenes and Christian legends, as vivid as when he painted them 500 years ago. 
 In the chapel at the Beguinage, you can listen to the nuns chanting their prayers wearing the white headresses and black robes of the original beguines. 
 The Church of our Lady has a Michelangelo sculpture of the Madonna; the Gothic hall in the Stadhuis is crowned by a magnificent wooden vaulted ceiling. 
 Elsewhere there are Breughels; walls covered with Delft tiles; a medieval belfry with 366 steps from which you can gaze down on the town's steep, red tiled roofs; holy blood brought back from the crusades. 
 You begin to feel dizzy with history. 
 Of course, the well-groomed head of modern Bruges pops up all over the place to remind you that this is not really a medieval theme park at all. 
 On Saturday morning, we watched outside the Stadhuis, where couples still marry in the Gothic hall. 
 Limousines drew up to disgorge a wedding party; women in elegant outfits topped with splendid hats were a fanfare for a bride who stepped out of an old white Daimler, tanned beneath her white silk. 
 Very bourgeois, but that is probably what Bruges has always been. 
 The patrons of all this art were merchants in the thirteenth century, who profited from cloth manufacture. 
 From the fourteenth to fifteenth centuries, Bruges was the chief market of the powerful Hanseatic trading league. 
 At the end of the fifteenth century, one enterprising family realised there was money to be made from all the foreign merchants, and turned their house into sort of prototype stock exchange. 
 The family name, Beurze, explains the origins of the name for similar operations all over the Continent. 
 Their house is now a bank. 
 Nowadays the bourgeoisie is more likely to patronise the city's luxurious food and clothes shops, all housed in the medieval streets. 
 The oldest tavern is the Vlissinghe, of which mention was first made in 1552, but there are hundreds of little bars and cafes, many of them housed in olde-worlde buildings that have the Americans squealing with delight. 
 Plenty have terraces from which to watch the world go by accompanied by a hot waffle or a glass of beer. 
 There were once 40 breweries in Bruges, and although now there are only two, the choice of Belgian beers is still enormous. 
 One cafe lists 300. 
 My rich, dark Trappist practically knocked me for six at lunchtime, while a deep red cherry beer, Kriek, tasted like alcoholic cough mixture. 
 For more substantial meals there are plenty of bigger cafes and restaurants offering set-price menus. 
 The north side of the market square, the Markt, is lined with them, and for about &pound;6 you can have three basic courses. 
 For a little more many include fish treats such as half a dozen oysters in season; waterzooi, fish cooked in a light stock and served with leeks and carrots; a fillet of turbot or chunks of eel in a green herb sauce. 
 An enormous bowl of mussels cooked in a delicious liquor with celery, onion, parsley and plenty of black pepper can be had for about &pound;4. 
 The open air fish market does brisk business every morning except Sunday and Monday and is well worth a visit for its display of fresh and smoked specialities, as well as a huge range of shellfish. 
 It is best not to leave eating too late. 
 Bruges goes to bed early and can hardly be said to be throbbing with night-life. 
 Last weekend the highlights were marionettes miming to Die Fledermaus at the puppet theatre and a country music festival. 
 We did try a night cap in a &bquo;classical music pub&equo; but as it was in the underground of a shopping arcade, and the clientele seemed more interested in chomping through their steak and chips than appreciating Karajan's version of the Emperor Concerto, we just had the one. 
 Once fully saturated with culture, food, drink or any combination of the three, it is possible to escape the tourist honeypots, which are mostly in the centre and south of town. 
 To the north the streets are quieter, and by following the canals &mdash; a smelly exercise in high summer, no doubt &mdash; or simply the end of your nose, Bruges can be appreciated on a more domestic scale. 
 The flat-fronted facades are often decorated with intricate brickwork, and even modern restorations seem to be strictly controlled in a style that combines discreet Post-Modern twiddly with forms and colours that are in the spirit of the original. 
 There are few cars here, though lots of bicycles, very few dogs and almost no dog mess (even the horse-drawn buggies for tourist joyrides have built-in pooper scoopers). 
 Best of all, there are hardly any other tourists. 
 Accommodation: The Bruges tourist office produces a comprehensive guide. 
 Independent travel: Bruges is four hours from Victoria by train via Dover and the 90 minute jetfoil to Ostend. 
 Alternatively you can fly to Brussels or Antwerp and take the train to Bruges. 
 Eating Out: Plenty of places in all price ranges &mdash; just look at the menu displayed and take your pick. 
 Serious eaters look at the red Michelin Benelux guide, which lists about 25 restaurants in the centre, a handful of which have one star. 
 Appetites should be matched by pockets, as here you are entering &pound;30-a-head-plus territory. 
 Markets: Apart from the fish market, there is a general market every Saturday morning on T'Zand, on the west side of town, and every Wednesday on the Burg, in the centre. 
 A flea market along the Dijver, one of the main canals, takes place on Saturday and Sunday from March to October but looks like a real tourist trap. 
 Books: Blue Guide to Belgium and Luxembourg (Black/Norton, &pound;11.95), good for historical sights; Brugge Inside Out available locally for about &pound;4 is useful for more down-to-earth matters. 
 Useful information: From October to March the Tourist Information Office in the Burg (44 86 86) is open Mon-Sat 9.30am-12.45pm and 2am-5.45pm, closed Sundays. 
 It sells combination tickets to four museums for about &pound;3. 
 Agenda Brugge is a useful free guide to what's on each month. 
 Ostend Ferries: P&amp;O European Ferries (0304 203388) has up to six sailings a day in each direction from Dover to Ostend, crossing time four hours; a 60-hour return for a 4.5 metre car and two adults costs from &pound;50 to &pound;89 depending on sailing. 
 Zeebrugge Ferries: North Sea Ferries (0482 77177) has a daily sailing from Hull to Zeebrugge: crossing time 14 hours. 
 Short break fares including one night's hotel accommodation in Bruges, cost from &pound;78 per person &mdash; cars extra. 
 P&amp;O European Ferries (0304 203388) has five sailings a day in each direction from Dover to Zeebrugge: crossing time four and a half hours. 
 A 60-hour return for a 4.5 metre car and two adults costs from &pound;50 to &pound;89, depending on sailing. 
 P&amp;O has two sailings a day from Felixstowe to Zeebrugge, crossing time five and a half hours. 
 A 60-hour return for a car and two adults costs from &pound;55 to &pound;94. 
 Dunkirk Ferries: Sally (0843 595522) operates five sailings a day from Ramsgate to Dunkirk: crossing time is two hours, 30 minutes. 
 A 60-hour return for a 4.5 metre car and two adults costs from &pound;47 to &pound;84, depending on day and time of travel. 
 Market: The town market takes place on Wednesday and Saturday in the place Jean Bart. 
 Hypermarket: The best is Auchan on the RN1, en route to the Sally ferry terminal. 
 It accepts Visa cards. 
 DANCE / Court in a trap: Judith Mackrell reviews Ashley Page's Piano at The Royal Opera House 
 By JUDITH MACKRELL 
 ONE of the great achievements of Ashley Page's new ballet, Piano, is its creation of an elusive but powerful atmosphere that completely over-rides its lack of plot. 
 Without over-stating the case Piano recalls some of Ashton's work in the rich allusiveness of its world, mysteriously intimating other ballets, other stages and other lives. 
 The ballet is set to Beethoven's First Piano Concerto and Page and his designer, Howard Hodgkin, have responded to the &bquo;formality and intimacy&equo; that they find in the score by conjuring a kind of post-modern Court. 
 Hodgkin's magnificent swathes of green and blue paint suggest towering columns and arches, and as sections of the set rise during the ballet two grand staircases are revealed on either side of the stage. 
 That certain entrances evoke the descent of a Prince or ruling couple is no accident either. 
 For Page has deliberately divided his dancers into the traditional hierarchy of principles, soloists and corps, and in so doing reminds us of all the great courts of 19th century ballets. 
 The time and place for this palace is not fixed, though &mdash; the women's hats and swirling frocks remind us both of Dior and Watteau, the men are in chic, futuristic black chiffon. 
 And this shifting between the past and almost- present is equally felt in the choreography &mdash; it contains some of the cleanest, most authoritative classical dance Page has produced while simultaneously suggesting modern bodies and modern mores in the way the dancers loll negligently on the floor or challenge each other's strength. 
 On first viewing, the movement is too enjoyably dense to take in fully &mdash; in old Page-style the head, torso and arms work in radical counterpoints to the legs, but their opposition is much less clamorous and wilful than before. 
 Where the eye often used to be bruised by hectic entrances and exits, Page now keeps his dancers on the stage, shifting them around in complex patterns or gathering them up in long architectural phrases. 
 Above all there is a new humanity in the work. 
 When a head whips round to complete a phrase, it is also a man seeking out his lover; when two dancers incline their faces together, it is in playful talk. 
 The one flaw is Page's abiding fondness for clever-clever partner work &mdash; his determination to find new means of supporting bodies, new ingenuities in the way the dancers intersect. 
 Certain duets thus feel like tortuous workshop explorations, with manoeuvres hard to do and awkward to watch, and it is these moments where Page seems to come adrift from the music. 
 The dancers, however, get an obvious and infectious thrill out of performing Piano, and apart from its minor longeurs, it is an equally fresh and exhilarating experience for the audience. 
 On Friday night Piano faced stiff choreographic competition from Rubies, Requiem and Robbins's Other Dances, danced by Sylvie Guillem and Laurent Hilaire. 
 Their interpretation lacked soul, the dying fall of nostalgia and the abandon of passion being supplanted by a more relaxed air of complicity. 
 But at the same time they looked sublimely elegant. 
 The precision of Hilaire's placing was constantly astonishing and in an air-borne rond de jambe Guillem's long lean line was as breathtaking as I've seen it. 
 Some of the dancing in Requiem was way below this standard yet the ballet still came across as one of MacMillan's most monumental works. 
 Its tableaux of suffering and benediction are on a scale that easily matches Faure's score and its concluding lifts are exquisite &mdash; the women floating high above the men like angels breast-stroking through paradise. 
 ROCK / For Pete's sake: Still crazy after all these beers: The Who &mdash; Birmingham NEC 
 By JIM WHITE 
 WHILE The Stones appealed to the students, and the Beatles to the girls and their mums, The Who were always the lads' band. 
 As representatives of the ranks of the great unfashionable made their way to their seats weighed down by crates of lager, it was clear, at the band's first British appearance for seven years, that paunches may come and full heads of hair may go, but times don't change. 
 The first thing the lads noted when the stage lights came up was that the previewers' obituaries for Pete Townshend are about as wide of the mark as a Birmingham City attack. 
 Dressed in beard and pigtails, black Armani suit and spanking new blue jogging shoes, Pete looked mean, lean and young by book editing standards. 
 His tinnitus did not, as we had been led to believe, oblige him to spend the concert inside a perspex box; he leapt across the stage, knees at 90-degree angles, for much of its three hour span. 
 True, some of the filling-in was performed by a young guitarist in patched jeans, whose contribution was generously acknowledged, but Pete has no trouble playing the guitar. 
 And, most importantly for the lads, judging by the roar which greeted its first appearance, he can still windmill his right arm. 
 Indeed during the finale, at the rate his arm whirled over his Fender strings, it looked as though he had caught the tail end of Hurricane Hugo during their US tour. 
 Roger Daltrey, all Shirley Temple curls and inflated biceps, swung his microphone dutifully and John Entwistle, in a tatty spiv's blouson and shock of white hair, stood characteristically immobile, but it was Townshend who looked most chirpy. 
 He was delighted, he told us, to be back in England and, most particularly, Birmingham. 
 (Big cheer.) 
 &bquo;You awight?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;As soon as we've had some valium, we'll be awight too.&equo; 
 All of Who life was here, the progression from R'n'B ('I'm a Man') through pop ('I Can See For Miles') and pretension ('The Overture' from Tommy) to Dinosaur Rock ('Sister Disco'). 
 At least a third of it could have been cheerfuly excised: the highlights from Tommy, for instance, merely served to show how few there were; and there was a serious lapse of taste in resurrecting their &bquo;Laughing Gnome&equo;, &bquo;Boris the Spider&equo; (presumably performed to give nice John Entwistle his turn in the spotlight). 
 But, against a huge backcloth of mod images, bold arrows and No Entry signs and Union Jacks, beautifully executed songs like &bquo;Can't Explain', &bquo;Substitute&equo; and &bquo;Magic Bus&equo; served to remind us how innovative a songwriter Townshend could be. 
 The three best moments of his career were, appropriately, the concert highlights: &bquo;Won't Get Fooled Again', &bquo;5.15&equo; and, despite the easy jokes, &bquo;My Generation&equo;, whose lyrics still have some pertinence even when sung by a 45 year old. 
 By the encore the chubby middle-aged chap in front of me, like many in the hall, had lost all touch with decorum, and, during &bquo;Summertime Blues&equo; was standing on his seat, windmilling his arms over the strings of his air guitar. 
 No doubt he will be booking for the 30th Anniversary Tour in 1994. 
 THEATRE / Storm in a tea-house: Yukio Ninagawa's productions merge western approaches with eastern ritual. 
 Sarah Hemming met him 
 By SARAH HEMMING 
 SIX o'clock on a Friday night and, in the Lyttleton foyer, groups of people cluster noisily round the bar; others, waiting for companions, finger books in the bookshop. 
 But no-one gives a second glance to a frail Japanese man, who stands, cupping his hand over a cigarette, looking a little lost amid the general traffic. 
 Offstage Yukio Ninagawa and his 100-strong company seemto melt into the background. 
 At the National the only clues to their presence are the dozens of shoes neatly paired around a huge makeshift dressing room and the scarlet signs in Japanese on every backstage door. 
 Onstage, though, it is a different matter. 
 So far Britain has hosted three of Ninagawa's productions of western classics &mdash; Medea, Macbeth and The Tempest. 
 Each of them combined eastern ritual with western realism. 
 In his Macbeth, the Scottish warlord became a Samurai warrior in 16th century Japan, bludgeoning his way to power beneath a cherry tree that rained white blossom down on him. 
 Medea, first performed at the Edinburgh Festival in the outdoor courtyard of the Old College, ended with Medea in a chariot on the college roof, battered by the howling wind and rain. 
 The audience, transported with her, sat open-mouthed, oblivious to the rain pouring down their necks. 
 This time, though, Ninagawa has brought over a Japanese classic. 
 Suicide For Love is adapted by Matsuyo Akimoto from three plays by the 17th century writer Chikamatsu Monzaemon and Ninagawa's production involves 73 actors, a swirling snow storm and a river on stage &mdash; the company, with true Japanese courtesy, provide plastic macs for the first two rows of spectators. 
 Ninagawa explained: &bquo;We have done classic tragedy with new eyes &mdash; now we have to do Japanese classics with new eyes.&equo; 
 Ninagawa is now in his fifties. 
 Dressed in faded black cords, a black pullover and black trainers, he carries no sign of his international status except a double-faced watch giving both Tokyo and London time. 
 Curled up on his armchair, thin as a wood shaving, he looks far too slight to carry this immense spectacle. 
 Yet there is a tense energy about him &mdash; and it was precisely this that struck Tadao Nakane, when he discovered Ninagawa directing angry underground productions in the early Seventies. 
 Nakane, then a producer for the renowned Coho company, was desperate to stage radical Shakespeare in Japan, where productions tended to be absurd, academic affairs. 
 He got Ninagawa to join him and they have since produced an extraordinary row of classics, welding the individual psychological realism of European theatre to the formality of Kabuki theatre. 
 Ninagawa feels that this may be easier for a Japanese director. 
 &bquo;The Tempest, for instance, has many local European elements and many universal ones. 
 We were able to respond by making a play within a play, setting it on a remote Japanese island and doing a Noh play. 
 For an English director it might be very difficult to imagine getting it out of the traditional setting.&equo; 
 Conversely, Ninagawa had trouble applying the combination of eastern and western styles to a traditional Japanese piece: &bquo;It is much more difficult to bring realism into stylization than the other way round. 
 It is a constant battle to stop actors slipping into style &mdash; my stomach aches all the time!&equo; 
 The Chikamatsu dramas on which Suicide For Love is based were originally puppet plays. 
 Their subject matter, though &mdash; suicides committed by ordinary people under economic pressure &mdash; was of contemporary urgency, based on reports Chikamatsu read in the papers. 
 Nowadays they are usually performed in an ossified Kabuki style and for Ninagawa the task was to throw all this off and recover their original spirits. 
 His production opens with a darkened stage, lit only by a spotlight on a tiny, fragile rod puppet. 
 Suddenly, behind her, the stage explodes into life -50 people milling about in the bawdy chaos of a red light area. 
 It is a characteristic Ninagawa coup &mdash; spectacular, yet suggesting the vulnerability of human nature. 
 At the technical run-through it looks perfect. 
 But Ninagawa stops the action every few minutes to make tiny adjustments. 
 This is where he comes alive, slithering lizard-like over the Lyttleton seats to issue instructions in a voice that brooks no argument. 
 The impression is of final polishing after many months of gradual rehearsal. 
 In fact, Ninagawa takes just one month to direct a production and rehearses only five hours a day. 
 He admits that he is a hard task master, on himself and his cast. 
 &bquo;Actors say working with me is far more exhausting than with other directors,&equo; he says, grinning. 
 &bquo;I tell them that acting is the burning of life &mdash; and the inner conflict lasts for a month&hellip;&equo; 
 They are expected to come word perfect and to research their part, however tiny. 
 In the crowd scenes every character has a history &mdash; the chaotic spontaneity is deceptive, and improvisation is out. 
 &bquo;He attacks every actor,&equo; says Nakane, chuckling. 
 &bquo;They have to walk along a very narrow ridge with a valley on each side: one side Stanislavski and the other stylization. 
 I remember it was very difficult for Arashi, who played Medea. 
 Every day Ninagawa tried to destroy Arashi's Kabuki education and every day Arashi ended up crying, saying &bquo;If it continues like this I shall die.&equo; 
 'Die then'. 
 Ninagawa would say.&equo; 
 Yet, Nakane adds, actors queue up to work with him and audiences flood to his shows. 
 Ninagawa points out that his style, combining East and West, ritual and freedom, in many ways mirrors life in Japan: &bquo;I get up and listen to Bach on my compact disc and have Japanese rice for breakfast.&equo; 
 But, more importantly, his productions' stark expression of human vanity perhaps touches a pressurized Japanese audience. 
 &bquo;I feel there are too many people who cast no doubt on today's prosperous Japan. 
 Japan is twisted and warped.&equo; 
 For his next production in Britain he hopes to work with British actors at the National on a contemporary Japanese piece. 
 But is there another classic he would love to tackle? 
 Ninagawa, still coiled on his chair, gazes at the ceiling. 
 &bquo;King Lear&equo;, he says, finally. 
 &bquo;While I still have the energy.&equo; 
 Suicide for Love has eight performances at the Lyttleton between 9th and 14th October (Box Office: 01 928 2252). 
 TELEVISION / Certified excellence: Mark Lawson on Ashcroft's second childhood 
 By MARK LAWSON 
 HEAVY with prizes from Venice, She's Been Away (BBC1) was, superficially, one of those pieces in which a major star offers what might be called a Complex Simpleton performance. 
 Reigning in their verbal and facial expressiveness to play a character so damaged that a big speech is possible (if at all) only at the end, they subsequently receive an award from a jury awed that they were clever enough to play so dumb. 
 Peggy Ashcroft duly got her gong for playing Lilian, 50 years in the bin, but She's Been Away was considerably more than a kind of Rain Woman; a vehicle for acting technique. 
 The tough, unsettling, adult script confirmed Stephen Poliakoff's status, alongside Potter, Rosenthal and Griffiths, as a major small-screen author. 
 Poliakoff had his first playwrighting success at the age of 19 but he has always been, to put it gently, a more grown-up dramatist than many of the pack of hairy, scary stage writers whose careers coincide with his. 
 This script began with Aunt Lilian's release from the shabby asylum in which she had been held for decades. 
 The ward had been closed by cuts but Poliakoff was only subliminally concerned with the politics of this. 
 What animated the screenplay was the question of exactly how other members of Lilian's family, past and present, had escaped similar restraint. 
 The incarcerated aunt lodged, on her release, with her nephew Hugh (James Fox) and his wife Harriet (Geraldine James). 
 Hugh was a City prig of exemplary emotional repression. 
 His faintly dazed demeanour was perhaps attributable to having fathered Dominic, a monstrous kind of pre-yuppy who, when Lilian demonstrates her unfamiliarity with domestic appliances, lisps: &bquo;Daddy, are we insured for any damage she does?&equo; 
 This was a small performance of emetic perfection by young Jackson Kyle. 
 If the Greens ever form a government, they should use him in the commercials advocating population control. 
 Comic leavening though Dominic was, he also fitted the script's careful patterning of parent-child relationships. 
 Lilian was in her second childhood and Harriet was expecting her second child, which she secretly despised. 
 Both women were treated as infants by Hugh, while Harriet was forced to play stern mother to her husband's aunt. 
 (If the film had a serious weakness, it was that there was too much Naughty Little Sister stuff for Lilian in supermarkets and car parks.) 
 Another childhood &mdash; Lilian's first, vouchsafed in flashback &mdash; was revealed to be the key to her incarceration. 
 Her adolescent rebellion, seemingly involving immoderate sex and the moderate occult, was clearly supposed to be viewed as a stand against the social codes of her English middle-class tribe. 
 Back in society five decades on, Lilian joined (or perhaps led) Harriet in another such break-out, involving the trashing of a Jag and a hotel. 
 Appropriately for what was a non-communication, middle-class-prison piece, Sir Peter Hall, an infrequent visitor to this medium, adopted the look of those Losey-Pinter films of the Sixties; the domestic made menacing. 
 Hall's most obvious technical reflex was the use of Lilian's viewpoint to establish her childish fear of our everyday: a tree, a plane, traffic. 
 This extended a nice Martian strain in the script, examining how Hampstead life might look to a spectator who had missed the first two acts. 
 The main performances were significant for their denial of sentimentality. 
 A cute crone part can be as wearisome as a cute kid one but Ashcroft held an edge of menace, a tension about how much of Lilian's mental absence was pretence. 
 Produced by Kenith Trodd, She's Been Away was a distinctive achievement to match Poliakoff's and Ashcroft's Caught On A Train nearly a decade ago. 
 In a Don Featherstone South Bank Show (LWT) of high quality and unusual form, the novelist Thomas Keneally recreated in 1989 a research trip through Eritrea which he made in 1987 while gestating his new book Towards Asmara. 
 It is fascinating to speculate on the reactions of the Eritreans to the spectacle of a man asking to have again the same conversations and introductions, this time with four or five other men holding cameras, lights and recorders. 
 To what extend would they understand the western methods of book promotion? 
 There need, however, be no PR qualms about this documentary. 
 The new Keneally treats the unlovely, unpluggable subject of the politics of famine, and Feather stone, far from hyping Towards Asmara, made a detailed case for the book. 
 In the same way as Keneally is using fiction to bring a forgotten conflict to an audience which might shrink from it as fact, the arts programme admitted material &mdash; reportage and politics &mdash; which it usually would not. 
 A football match with a one-legged goalkeeper and all of the crowd bearing arms was one of many memorable scenes. 
 THEATRE / Contra flow: Michael Church reviews the RSC's Kissing The Pope at The Almeida 
 By MICHAEL CHURCH 
 IF THERE is one political lesson which recent events have underlined in Africa, South East Asia and Latin America, it is that peasant armies waging guerilla wars all end up committing the same sort of brutalities, whatever the flag they fight under. 
 Marxist ideology was no better guarantee of Vietcong decency 20 years ago than it now is for Swapo; nor has it preserved the Sandinistas from endemic corruption in their civil war against the American-backed Contras. 
 In Nick Darke's Kissing the Pope, however, the Sandinistas are given unequivocal white-hat status: a visit to Nicaragua apparently convinced him and his director Roger Michell that that unhappy land was &bquo;one of the world's few areas of moral black and white&equo;. 
 So his Contras behave like homicidal lager-louts, and his Sandinistas like palely scrupulous members of the SDP. 
 The production is cowboys and Indians first and last, with a buddy-movie section in between. 
 The audience file in to discover three actors sitting ragged and disconsolate under the eye of a fourth who is reading the Bible and shouting &bquo;Shut up!&equo; at intervals. 
 After 10 minutes of this the action begins: a jungle-skirmish in the wings, then an interrogation, with the Contras jeering and their victims rigid with fear. 
 There follows an atrocity off-stage, an American military adviser (Edward Peel) watching with horribly convincing sexual excitement. 
 Then come some ear-splitting explosions (don't sit near the entrance) after which most on stage are dead. 
 This is the cue for the survivors &mdash; a young Contra (Mark Hadfield) and his prisoner (Christian Dixon) &mdash; to embark on an odyssey in the course of which the psychological balance of power gradually shifts. 
 Hadfield's violence- crazed adolescent is a brilliant feat of characterization, to which Dixon's peasant youth offers a sweetly endearing foil. 
 Finally they are ambushed and taken prisoner by the enemy (the former lager-louts risen from the dead and now wearing masks); Hadfield goes catatonic with terror, and is solicitously carried off to re-education in the jungle. 
 The first laugh of the evening came with the phrase &bquo;non-aligned countries like Nato&equo;; the second with the observation that killing for the first time is &bquo;like sex&equo;: Darke's audience of true believers was easily pleased. 
 Back to back with Howard Brenton's HID, this simplistic piece of agit-prop suggests that the RSC's Almeida season will have decidedly limited appeal. 
 MUSIC / Leaving early: Anthony Payne reviews Ileana Cotrubas's farewell recital at Covent Garden 
 By ANTHONY PAYNE 
 AT WHAT point in his or her career should a singer decide to quit the stage and concert platform? 
 It is certainly not unknown for artists to sing on until well past their best and to put considerable strain on even their most sympathetic listeners, expecting them to weigh charm of manner and artistic experience against failing vocal powers. 
 Ileana Cotrubas is not of that ilk, and many of her devotees must have been shocked when it was disclosed last weekend that her Covent Garden recital with Geoffrey Parsons on Thursday evening was to be her farewell British appearance. 
 Here was a lady who at the age of 50 had certainly decided to quit while she was ahead, and her moving and musically thoughtful recital confirmed it. 
 It was a mark of her artistic intelligence and independence that she did not choose to dish up a pot-pourri of well tried favourites for the occasion, drawing attention to herself rather than the music. 
 True, in a first half devoted to the song repertory she allowed herself a Wolf group which included Mein Liebster ist so Klein and Ich hab' in Penna. 
 But she effortlessly avoided that exasperating coyness with which some seek to engage their audience, and the group also included the angelic Wir haben beide lange Zeit with whose chiming repetitions she wove an enchanting spell. 
 To frame this more familiar fare, she presented songs by Enesco and Marx, bringing to them the skill of a dramatic singer without ever overstepping the bounds of intimate communion required by the genre. 
 Enesco is a major force in twentieth century music whose almost total neglect at present is quite astonishing, and if his little Poemes de Clement Marot show a limited aspect of his art, they still breathed an engaging wit and charm in Miss Cotrubas's heart-warming performance. 
 No less devotion was brought to four songs by Joseph Marx, and although the rather overheated style of Nocturne elicited a few smiles (Parsons performing prodigies in representing the burgeoning June night) there was a touching ecstasy in Hat dich die Liebe beruhrt which was delivered absolutely from the heart. 
 It could perhaps be said that Miss Cotrubas came truly into her own with the operatic excerpts that provided the second half of her programme. 
 Actually, she opened with Mozart's scena Misera, dove son which tested her somewhat at the top of the stave, but there followed arias from Manon, Don Pasquale and La Forza del Destino which she gave with commanding conviction, variety and characterisation. 
 Towards the close there was the feeling that she was forcing a little at the top, and that the middle voice was tiring. 
 But as she responded to the audience's affectionate plaudits with both Mimi's and Violetta's farewells it was the natural sweetness and dramatic presence of this fine artist that carried the day. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By ANTHONY PAYNE 
 Today: September producer prices (UK). 
 French finance minister to propose European Community savings tax in Paris. 
 EC finance ministers meet in Luxembourg to consider VAT harmonisation and investment income taxation. 
 Tuesday: EC internal market ministers meet in Luxembourg. 
 Wednesday: Nobel prize for economics to be announced in Stockholm. 
 Confederation of British Industry monthly meeting to consider the economy and European monetary union. 
 Nicholas Brady, the US Treasury Secretary, speaks in Washington on the consequences of low US savings rate. 
 Thursday: Liffe allowed to sell its contracts in the United States from today. 
 Friday: UK retail price index (September). 
 US producer prices (September). 
 Commodities: AFBD problem: to be or not to be 
 By MICHAEL PREST 
 KEITH GAUNT is no Pericles. 
 But when the citizens of the Association of Futures Brokers and Dealers cast their stones into the pot last week and elected the managing director of Amalgamated Metal Trading on to their council with the biggest number of votes, they elevated the nearest that divided body has seen to a populist. 
 The AFBD is divided for two reasons. 
 First, despite a brave attempt to encourage candidates to stand at last week's annual general meeting, the council remains grossly under-represented. 
 Neither the very big and important financial futures business, which accounts for about 155 of the AFBD's 400 members, nor the equally important oil market, is represented by the nine elected council members. 
 By sharp and crucial contrast, the metals trade, which accounts for a fraction of the AFBD's membership and income, is directly represented by at least three members &mdash; the triumphant Mr Gaunt, Phillip Robinson from Metallgesellschaft, and Francis Holford from Rudolf Wolff. 
 The AFBD has not been treated with the seriousness it deserves by bodies as powerful as the London International Financial Futures Exchange. 
 Moreover, the association suffers from a very Periclean problem: you cannot force people to vote in a self-regulatory organisation. 
 Allowing for 120 proxy votes and some 50 people at the AGM, less than half the AFBD membership bothered to register their opinion. 
 So the rules were changed last week to permit co-option of individual members. 
 One consequence of this weakness of self-regulation is the other reason for division within the AFBD. 
 A relatively small group of members, characterised as the Commodity Traders Group, has ensured that relations with the United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission occupy more public airtime than the leaders of the AFBD would like. 
 Mr Gaunt has been the most vocal of this band, and his election was his reward. 
 The warning to the AFBD is direct: &bquo;I don't see myself being tied to an AFBD board position on the CFTC issue. 
 I'm not looking to work at the CFTC issue within the AFBD. 
 I'm going to talk as Keith Gaunt, who has a mandate.&equo; 
 In this political sense, Mr Gaunt is a populist. 
 The mandate, it seems, extends to discussing directly with Andrea Corcoran, the engaging lawyer whose unfortunate task it has been to negotiate on the CFTC's behalf, a solution to the intricate questions of extra-territoriality and segregation of clients' funds on the London Metal Exchange. 
 This threat Ms Corcoran can survive. 
 But can the AFBD survive? 
 The lofty official view is that the agitators in favour of an entirely fresh deal &mdash; or preferably none at all &mdash; with the CFTC command little support among the membership and distract the association from grappling with real issues such as Globex, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange's putative electronic trading system. 
 For his part, Mr Gaunt claims that 38 of the 50 members who have signed the exemption order saving them from the full rigour of the CFTC's rules say they do not like the agreement. 
 Most, however, will probably tolerate it. 
 In any case, rescinding the deal will be very hard and was virtually ruled out at the annual meeting by Christopher Sharples, the AFBD's chairman. 
 Still, in this sense, there are divisions. 
 The unfair element is that the AFBD has been obliged to extricate itself from a CFTC hole largely dug by the Securities and Investments Board and imperfectly filled in by the Department of Trade and Industry. 
 There is a sovereignty issue, and the question of adapting rules to an odd but bona fide market such as the LME cannot be swept aside. 
 However, the vexed CFTC issue is resolved &mdash; and the AFBD last week was the lucky recipient of yet another draft solution from the commission &mdash; the traumas of the past six months have posed again the question of the association's independence. 
 Phillip Thorpe, the AFBD's chief executive, felt obliged to circulate to his staff a denial of reports that a merger with The Securities Association was in the offing. 
 But co-operation over matters such as a futures rulebook and joint compliance have indicated the economies of scale possible in combining with the TSA's 1,000 members. 
 Faced with the possibility of their contributions to the AFBD doubling to &pound;8m a year, members may find a merger less undignified after all. 
 It would be ironic indeed if the AFBD's new populist hastened the downfall of his Athens. 
 International Capital Markets: Banks lose money in Eurobond battle 
 By DAVID FRANKS 
 OLD HABITS are dying hard in the Eurobond market where two months have now elapsed since leading banks implemented a radical change in the way they organise the selling of new issues to investors. 
 The habit into which the banks had slipped, and which their fresh approach to the business was designed to cure, was quite simple: losing money. 
 The largest fixed-rate offering ever witnessed in the Eurobond market, a &dollar;1.5bn five-year deal announced on Friday for Italy, which used the new money-making formula, provides disturbing evidence however that excessive competition, born of over-capacity, could yet ruin the latest attempts at restoring profitability to the market. 
 The new system for arranging Eurobond issues is derived from the way new issues have been done in the US for many years. 
 Bonds are underwritten and sold to investors by a small group of banks in return for a fee from the issuer. 
 The banks agree not to sell bonds below the issue price until the arranger of the issue is satisfied that the bulk of the deal has been sold, after which, members of the group are free to sell at whatever prices they wish. 
 This contrasts with the traditional Eurobond new issue system: banks in the underwriting group can sell below the issue price from the outset. 
 This they frequently do, eating into, and more often devouring, the commissions they receive from the issuer. 
 At the root of the problems with the old system was cut-throat competition. 
 Not, however, the old story of too many banks chasing too little commission income; compared to most markets, conventional Eurobond commissions are very generous. 
 No, the problem was banks were giving away their commissions to investors as inducements to buy expensively-priced bonds, the result of new issues arranged by banks desperate to maintain market share. 
 The US-style new issue system has much lower commissions than its Eurobond counterpart. 
 But under the US system, banks stand a much greater chance of actually retaining them. 
 On a five-year conventional Eurobond, fees might be 1.25 per cent of the total issue amount, yet banks would be lucky to see one eighth per cent (and that on a good deal) once discounts had been allowed to buyers of the bonds. 
 On a similar US-style deal, commissions might be only 0.325 per cent but most of that should end up with the banks. 
 Which brings us to the blockbusting Italy issue arranged by Morgan Stanley, the US investment bank which put together the first US-style issue in Europe with an offering for New Zealand in August. 
 Bankers had expected that the fees for the Italy deal would be the standard 0.325 per cent. 
 According to reliable sources, however, Italy is paying only 0.25 per cent to its underwriters. 
 Bankers close to the deal say that Morgan Stanley was forced reluctantly to accept a lower commission structure because Italy was being offered this by other banks competing for the business. 
 The fear now is that banks will start to compete by driving commission rates lower and lower until they are prepared to arrange issues at break-even or worse. 
 And this would vindicate those who believe that the market's ills are not going to be solved by tinkering with new issue processes, but rather by a drastic cutback in the overheads &mdash; ie, sacking people &mdash; being carried by the industry. 
 Major UK slowdown forecast 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 THE BRITISH economy is on the brink of a &bquo;major slowdown&equo; in the fourth quarter as the Government's high interest rate policy produces a dramatic downturn in business confidence, the latest Dun and Bradstreet survey of UK business says. 
 The survey was conducted before base rates rose to 15 per cent, and Dun and Bradstreet suggest that its findings might have been even bleaker had the poll been taken after the move. 
 The poll discloses a decline in selling prices for the second successive quarter, indicating that inflation is expected to fall. 
 But, at the same time, the steepest decline in Dun and Bradstreet's &bquo;optimism index&equo; since quarterly surveys began in the fourth quarter of 1987 points to a sharp slowdown in economic activity. 
 Keith Williams, managing director of Dun and Bradstreet UK, said: &bquo;High interest rates and the present value of the pound look like escalating the slowdown in the economy.&equo; 
 The survey, of 1,000 chief executives in large and medium-sized companies, points to significant declines in optimism over sales, new orders and profits. 
 And companies expecting to shed workers have matched those likely to continue hiring, which suggests no growth in employment in the final quarter. 
 Employment opportunities in manufacturing, in particular, are likely to decline. 
 Moreover, business failures are expected to continue rising, especially among small firms. 
 Other highlights of the survey suggest that the construction industry is stagnating and that there has been a steep fall in new orders, declining sales and lower selling prices. 
 And manufacturers report a big drop in new orders. 
 For the first time since they began the surveys, Dun and Bradstreet report a negative outlook for the profits of retailers, which indicates a gloomy outlook for consumer spending in the run-up to Christmas. 
 Unlike previous polls, the latest survey shows the service sector joining the downward trend with significant declines in optimism for profits and employment. 
 On a brighter note, the survey indicates that the North-South divide is continuing to narrow. 
 Optimism remains relatively higher in the North than in the southern part of the country. 
 The survey's findings underline the concern of several City economists that the economy was already slowing down rapidly as base rates were lifted. 
 The Government is also understood to be divided over whether the increase in base rates will provoke a recession. 
 However, the Treasury which in the past several weeks has been preparing economic forecasts for inclusion in the November autumn statement seems almost certain to revise down its estimates for economic growth next year. 
 It is understood that the Bank of England backed higher rates to protect the pound but was less convinced that they needed to be raised to cool down the economy any further. 
 Treasury officials emphasised that Nigel Lawson, the Chancellor, has never promised a &bquo;soft landing&equo; in which inflation abates but growth continues moderately. 
 However, some in the Treasury are understood to have been recommending a base rate increase for some weeks on the grounds that there was insufficient evidence that the economy had cooled. 
 Although it is by no means the universal view, some City analysts believe the increase in rates makes a short-lived recession inevitable next year. 
 And they believe that what makes the current situation precarious is the continuing uncertainty over the outlook for sterling. 
 September trade figures, due on 24 October, are thought critical for sterling's fortunes. 
 Economists believe a sizeable narrowing from the &pound;2bn current account shortfall for August would shore up sterling and ensure that interest rates rise no higher. 
 BAe-Thomson may bid for Ferranti 
 By JEREMY WARNER 
 A JOINT takeover proposal from British Aerospace and Thomson-CSF of France is one of a number of bid options which the board of Ferranti International, the troubled electronics group, will consider this week, writes Jeremy Warner. 
 Company sources said yesterday that British Aerospace and Thomson, who are believed to be negotiating a joint proposal, had not yet put anything to Ferranti which counted as a firm offer. 
 &bquo;It is only one of a number of options which include proposals from British, US and Continental companies,&equo; the source said. 
 GEC, Ferranti's main British rival in radar, is also keen to mount a takeover bid but would encounter fierce Ministry of Defence opposition on the grounds that it would damage competition in electronics procurement. 
 The Ferranti source said: &bquo;Lord Weinstock (GEC's managing director) would like to be in the position where he was able to say to the Ministry of Defence, &bquo;Look, I am the only person who can rescue Ferranti from collapse.&equo; 
 But the fact of the matter is he is not. 
 There are lots of people who want to take us over.&equo; 
 One option believed to be under consideration by GEC would be to form its own partnership with British Aerospace, but MoD sources say this would be unlikely to overcome its fundamental objections to GEC's involvement. 
 Unions said yesterday that there would be a threat to thousands of jobs if either GEC or Thomson were allowed to gain a foothold at Ferranti because of the overlap in radar interests. 
 Roger Lyon, assistant general secretary of the Manufacturing Science and Finance union, said he would demand that Ferranti should discuss all takeover plans with the workforce first. 
 Mr Lyon is due to meet Ferranti's chairman, Sir Derek Alun-Jones, after tomorrow's reconvened annual meeting. 
 Mr Lyon believes he will be able to discover Thomson's plans because of an agreement giving his union the right to discuss any relevant employment or investment matter with senior managers. 
 Former adviser leads attempted TCS buyout 
 By PATRICK HOSKING, Banking Correspondent 
 AN INDEPENDENT consultant who advised the Government on privatising The Crown Suppliers, the procurement agency, is now leading a buyout team bidding for the bulk of the business. 
 Bob Ethrington, a director of Coopers &amp; Lybrand Associates, is heading a group of TCS managers and staff planning to bid for the core business, the product supply and services division. 
 There is no suggestion of any impropriety by Mr Ethrington. 
 However, his membership of the team could prove an embarrassment to the Government, which is subsidising his bid attempt. 
 Mr Ethrington has provisional financial backing from the trade union bank Unity Trust to make a bid via an employee share ownership plan. 
 He previously conducted two studies on behalf of the Government into TCS. 
 The first, more than two years ago, considered the feasibility of privatisation and followed reports from the Treasury and the Central Purchasing Unit which came out against wholesale privatisation. 
 The second was a report on restructuring the business in the run-up to privatisation. 
 This was completed in September 1988. 
 Eight months later, in May 1989, Mr Ethrington joined the management buyout team, which had been formed a year earlier. 
 Coopers &amp; Lybrand worked on the first study in conjunction with Samuel Montagu, the merchant bank which is handling the sale on behalf of the Government. 
 Mr Ethrington denied there was any potential conflict of interest. 
 &bquo;There is absolutely no question of (our receiving) favoured status in the sale process,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;This has been done in a very formal and proper way.&equo; 
 On the question of whether as adviser he had been privy to confidential information, he said: &bquo;Any (management) buyout is party to information other buyers won't have.&equo; 
 The Department of the Environment commented: &bquo;We see no conflict of interest. 
 Mr Ethrington had no association with the management buyout team when he was advising the Government. 
 Neither he nor anyone else in Coopers &amp; Lybrand is now advising the Government on matters relating to the privatisation of TCS.&equo; 
 Mr Ethrington's partners in the buyout team are Jim Cousins, the TCS finance director, and John Cross, procurement director. 
 Christopher Chope, the environment minister, disclosed in May that the Government was prepared to contribute to the professional advice costs of management buyout teams to a maximum of &pound;132,000. 
 NI changes take effect 
 By PATRICK HOSKING, Banking Correspondent 
 MORE than 19 million employees will pay &pound;3 a week less in national insurance contributions and more than two million pensioners will be able to work without reducing their state pension entitlement following changes which came into force this month. 
 Reforms of national insurance and the abolition of the pensioners' earnings rule will effect most of the working population, claims the Treasury in this month's Economic Progress Report. 
 The measures, designed to boost the supply side of the economy, were announced in this year's Budget. 
 Increases in earnings just above the old NIC &bquo;steps&equo; (&pound;75 and &pound;115) will no longer be wiped out by higher contributions. 
 The rate at the lower earnings limit of &pound;43 a week is reduced from 5 to 2 per cent. 
 Earnings between &pound;43 and &pound;325 a week &mdash; the upper earnings limit &mdash; will now attract the uniform 9 per cent. 
 The Treasury estimates that abolition of the pensioners' earnings rule could cost &pound;565m by 1991, to be met out of reserves. 
 But extra tax revenue from working pensioners could claw back &pound;130m. 
 French set to reject Deloitte merger 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 THE PROPOSED international merger between Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells and Touche Ross is likely to be holed below the waterline this week when the French arm of Deloitte pulls out of the agreement. 
 The French firm is expected to follow the example of Deloitte UK by joining forces with Coopers &amp; Lybrand instead. 
 But unlike Deloitte UK, which declined to join the proposed Deloitte Ross Tohmatsu (DRT), the French practice has already signed up. 
 Sources within Coopers say that a change of mind will be announced this week. 
 The move will come as a shattering blow to the US-backed DRT initiative. 
 It will leave it so far with merger agreements in just the US and Japan. 
 Coopers, on the other hand, now has merger agreements with Deloitte UK, Deloitte Dijker van Dien of the Netherlands and now France. 
 With DRT still holding two of the most important countries, the complete disintegration of Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells International is now assured. 
 A fierce battle is now on for the constituent firms across Europe, the Pacific basin and Canada. 
 Sources within Coopers suggest that Deloitte in Australia will shortly announce it is to side with Coopers, and the firm is confident that the Canadians will follow suit. 
 The position in Canada is critical. 
 Both Coopers and Touche are neck and neck in the market place with the Canadian firm, Deloitte Samson, just a fraction behind. 
 If the Deloitte firm joins with Coopers, Touche Ross, as a representitive of DRT, will be at a huge disadvantage and the gloabl aspiriations of DRT will be utterly wrecked. 
 If that happens, the logic behind the Deloitte strategy will have disappeared and some in the profession are predicting that Deloitte US may have to admit defeat and reconsider its position. 
 Of all the proposed mega-mergers this year, the only success has been that of Ernst &amp; Young, which merged all its significant practices expect for Canada. 
 Radio sounds like music to City ears: Changes afoot in the world of radio have made the City sit up. 
 Deregulation could make it an exciting prospect, as Mary Fagan reports 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 AFTER years of playing the cinderella of the media world, the potential of radio is at last gaining recognition. 
 Shares in the quoted radio stocks in 1988 outperformed the market by 100 per cent, and since March 1987, the sector's market value has soared from &pound;33m to over &pound;400m. 
 All the signs are that radio is an exciting prospect &mdash; the forthcoming deregulation of the industry with associated changes in costs, and an expected boom in advertising revenues, is finally making the City take notice. 
 The potential for an advertising bonanza has come under the spotlight with the advent of &bquo;splitting frequencies&equo; such as that undertaken by London's LBC last week. 
 Splitting frequencies &mdash; transmitting different programmes on FM and AM &mdash; could effectively double listening hours and provides two highly targeted audiences for advertising in a catchment area. 
 In LBC's case, for example, the LBC Crown FM is going for the upmarket listener, while the medium wave service, London Talkback Radio, is pitching for the tabloid market and the dedicated followers of phone-ins. 
 Capital Radio, the other UK giant of the independents, has already split its frequencies, and before long all nine quoted independent stations are expected do so, albeit not always around the clock. 
 To date, radio has trailed badly in the UK advertising stakes, taking just 2 per cent of total expenditure. 
 But the trend is changing. 
 Stockbroker Hoare Govett believes that radio could increase its share by 5 per cent by 1995. 
 But advertising is itself extremely volatile and profits could take a dive as easily as they could soar. 
 At Barclays de Zoete Wedd, whose report on the sector is due out this week, analyst Jane Anscombe points out that there are currently some worries on the advertising revenue front, and that some television people have seen a bit of pressure. 
 In spite of that, she believes: &bquo;These times seem a good opportunity for long-term investors to get hold of stock.&equo; 
 The Broadcasting Bill, due next month, is expected to spark a radical reshaping of radio in the UK, broadly along the lines envisaged in the Government's 1987 Green Paper &bquo;Radio: Choices and Opportunities&equo;. 
 Today, the radio industry is dominated by two regulatory authorities, the BBC and the Independent Broadcasting Authority. 
 Unlike the BBC radio stations, which are funded by the television licence fee, the independents depend almost entirely for their revenues on advertising, which they can broadcast for nine minutes in an hour. 
 They rely for their existence on franchises awarded by the IBA, and pay a primary rental fee each year in return for the use of the IBA transmitters. 
 The Government's thirst for more competition, less regulation and more consumer choice is expected to result in three new national commercial radio networks (two of which will push the BBC out of some of its existing frequencies) as well as a plethora of local and &bquo;community&equo; stations. 
 Unlike the national services, which are likely to go out to competitive tender, these local and community services are expected to be awarded on the basis of their planned services and financial viability. 
 The result could be many hundreds of independents in the UK by the end of the next decade. 
 In about a year's time, the IBA will be no longer, and the regulation of radio passes to the Radio Authority. 
 From then, licencees will be responsible for their own transmitters, either owning or leasing them. 
 But the cost structure of the industry is also set to change. 
 The main costs to the independent stations have been the IBA primary rental for transmission facilities, secondary rental as a tax on net profits, and copyright. 
 In future, the primary rental will be abolished, and the new costs of maintaining their own transmission systems plus paying for the licence are expected to be considerably less expensive. 
 But because currently larger stations effectively subsidise the transmission costs of smaller ones, the big stations will benefit most. 
 More widespread benefits are likely from the passing away of secondary rental, which will finally disappear with the advent of the Radio Authority. 
 Less than glamorous, perhaps, but with lighter regulation and the prospect of consolidation on a regional level, the independent radio business is no longer the ugly duckling of the media world. 
 Economic Outlook: Sweet and sour conference specials 
 By SARAH HOGG 
 Ask yourself which politician you would rather be this fortnight, Chris Patten or Nigel Lawson, and the answer is easy: John Smith. 
 Labour's party conference was, for its shadow Chancellor, wonderfully enhanced by the sufferings of the real one. 
 Being Labour's money man is never easy, even when the party is still in opposition and you are as persuasive as Mr Smith. 
 But for once, the regular Labour conference task of reminding the party the public purse is not bottomless was put in the shade by the two looming Tory conference tasks of presenting the poll tax &mdash; and 15 per cent base rates. 
 The first of these is basically more difficult; but Mr Patten has the advantage of novelty, the sheen of possible succession to Mrs Thatcher, a way with green words and blue audiences. 
 He is wresting more money out of the Treasury to dilute the poll tax. 
 But it is far from clear yet how much. 
 As for the hoped-for recasting of the &bquo;community charge&equo;, nothing short of transferring education to central government &mdash; which is simply not going to happen before the next election &mdash; can reduce it to a politically painless level. 
 Well, Mr Patten will do his best to make a silk purse out of a sow's ear, and the audience will know it was not his idea. 
 Nor, of course, was it Mr Lawson's. 
 After a year in which the Treasury's forecasting failures (notably that very large trade deficit) have been rather obvious, it is only fair to recall that it did presciently point out just about every awkward little detail of the poll tax, from its automatic upward impact on inflation to the folly of providing local authorities with a golden opportunity to raise more tax while blaming the Government. 
 Mr Lawson did, however, play his part in taking the Prime Minister to that peak of economic success from which the poll tax plan was launched. 
 It was born in that self-confident time when other changes she had doggedly forced past party muttering had been rewarded by a step-change in productivity and relatively low inflation. 
 Would she &mdash; could she &mdash; have driven the idea of the community charge through in today's less confident political and economic circumstances? 
 Plenty to explain Circumstances which, of course, will fall to Mr Lawson to explain this week. 
 A decision is always easier to defend than vacillation, so &mdash; provided he is spared a second &mdash; the Chancellor can at least be glad that the base rate hike happened last week. 
 Having blamed it on the Bundesbank, he can go on to talk about other things &mdash; such as sex and tax, perhaps. 
 Britain's savers and pensioners are just beginning to wake up to the possibilities of independent taxation of husbands and wives. 
 One unremarked consequence for both sexes, for example, is that since wives' allowances can henceforth be set against investment income, there will be more non-taxpayers among bank and building society depositors &mdash; and the composite rate of tax on their yield will then be reduced for everybody. 
 Mr Lawson can dress all this up macroeconomically as a timely &bquo;budget for savings&equo;. 
 For a current account deficit on the balance of payments reflects a shortage of national savings, in relation to investment. 
 He has hitherto fought shy (apart from a few marginal incentives) of trying to increase total savings through the tax system. 
 But he is a sufficiently good opportunist to put a strategic gloss on something he is going to do anyway. 
 A Tory conference probably has more than its due share of savers. 
 It will still contain plenty of business and mortgage borrowers to kick up a stink about base rates. 
 At the moment, the economic evidence is sufficiently ambiguous to support the view that higher rates were needed domestically, not just to steady the pound. 
 But a conflict between objectives &mdash; as we saw early in 1988 &mdash; may re-emerge the moment it is clear the economy is really slowing. 
 Then the trade deficit will make it hard to lower interest rates without undermining sterling, while at the same time reinforcing industry's demands for cheaper money to help it compete. 
 Reaction to the latest rise makes it clear that everyone is watching out for another eruption of internal discord on the exchange rate between Sir Alan Walters in Downing Street, and Mr Lawson in the Treasury. 
 Ripe time Assuming Mr Lawson has achieved a respectable fall in inflation, the time then really would be &bquo;ripe&equo; for full membership of the European Monetary System, since this would tend to drive interest rates down while holding up the pound. 
 Out of the question? 
 Well, perhaps only the new Foreign Secretary could sell it to Mrs Thatcher, and he will have his own notions of ripe time. 
 But some quite surprising right-wing converts to the idea seem to be popping out of the woodwork, attracted by Mr Lawson's mistitled idea of &bquo;competing currencies&equo;. 
 What this really means is a fixed exchange rate system without capital controls. 
 In such a system, big companies could choose which currency to do business in, especially if national taxes are reformed to encourage choice. 
 Then high-inflation EC members would have to get their act together, or lose reserves and revenue. 
 Hey presto, economic convergence and monetary union - without a European central bank. 
 All this actually amounts to, however, is the existing EMS (once so resisted by those converts), after capital controls are finally gone, as long planned for next year. 
 For it is coming to be understood that their departure will force the pace towards total fixity of exchange rates in the EMS. 
 But that means not so much competing currencies as one Euro-currency with various national names. 
 This would inevitably require European central bankers to work closely together, while the structure of the system would eventually have to be formalised. 
 Well, what's in a name? 
 If different people see the process differently, never mind. 
 If competing ideas all point in the same direction, the politicians follow. 
 It will not be long before every party conference is treated to its spokesman's version of European monetary union, along with motherhood, apple pie &mdash; and, no doubt, local government finance. 
 GM buffs up its British credentials: Michael Harrison on Jaguar's preferred ally in its fight to stay independent 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON 
 THE attentions of General Motors, the world's largest car manufacturer, can be hard to resist &mdash; something Jaguar may very soon discover as GM and its US rival, Ford, slug it out for the hand of the embattled luxury car maker. 
 In 80 years, GM has grown into the most powerful industrial conglomerate in the United States, and one of the biggest multi-national companies in the world. 
 Its size is simply awesome. 
 Last year GM's turnover was &dollar;123.6bn (&pound;77bn) &mdash; comfortably more than the gross domestic product of a good few developing countries. 
 It employs 766,000 people and last year sold 8.1 million cars and trucks &mdash; three times more than the entire British market consumed. 
 It is nearly 10 times the size of the UK's biggest industrial conglomerate, British Aerospace including its Rover car subsidiary, and dwarfs even the mighty Japanese motor manufacturers Toyota and Nissan. 
 The founding of GM in September 1908 was, however, a little publicised event. 
 In its first year of operation it made 25,000 cars and trucks. 
 Today its tentacles spread from motor manufacture to aerospace, defence, computing and railways. 
 It has more than 200 plants in 30 states and 122 cities in the US, and manufacturing or distribution operations in 33 other countries worldwide. 
 For a good part of the 1980s, GM languished in the doldrums &mdash; burdened by a a top-heavy bureaucracy, losing market share to Japanese and domestic rivals, and saddled with a reputation as the biggest but highest-cost and least efficient US car maker. 
 In 1986 its profits plunged from &dollar;4bn to &dollar;2.9bn &mdash; largely as a result of a &dollar;1.3bn restructuring programme. 
 Critics of its lumbering style of management &mdash; notably the flamboyant and dissident board member H. Ross Perot &mdash; were having a field day. 
 In a memorable phrase Mr Perot suggested that what GM needed was &bquo;the capitalist equivalent of Mao's cultural revolution&equo;. 
 The man who has achieved that &mdash; and has record profits of &dollar;4.8bn in 1988 to prove it &mdash; is the GM chairman Roger Smith, hardly a charismatic revolutionary, but rather the quintessential GM company man down to his sober suits and clean-cut features. 
 The resurrection has not been without pain, however. 
 Since 1986 GM has slimmed its workforce by 111,000 and &bquo;indefinitely idled&equo; a number of its US plants &mdash; GM's euphemsism for closure. 
 But it has paid dividends. 
 On Friday, GM announced that its share of the US car and truck market for the 1989 model year ended September 30 was 35.2 per cent &mdash; up from 34.7 per cent in 1988 &mdash; and that it has outsold Ford by 1.7 million vehicles and Chrysler, the third biggest American car maker, by 3.4 million vehicles. 
 No company is an island, however. 
 Not even one the size of GM, which has enthusiastically joined in the scramble to forge alliances and co-operative deals with other motor manufacturers worldwide. 
 Last week, it announced an unprecedented pact with its rival Chrysler to manufacture jointly transmissions and other drive-line components for each other's van and car ranges. 
 But the process of collaboration had started earlier. 
 In February 1984, GM and Toyota formed a joint venture to produce a new small car, the Chevrolet Nova. 
 Eight months later, GM completed a merger with the computer services company Electronic Data Systems in a bid to improve computer services throughout the GM empire. 
 In the same year GM launched the Saturn passenger car division. 
 In 1985 GM expanded into aerospace technology with the &dollar;5bn acquisition of Hughes Aircraft &mdash; a diversification which has been copied by Daimler-Benz in its takoever of MBB and, in reverse, by BAe with its purchase of the Rover car group. 
 GM, in common with other Western car manufacturers, perversely views the Japanese automotive industry as both the great collaborator and the great threat in equal measure. 
 This schizophrenic attitude is amply illustrated. 
 On the one hand, GM has joined forces with Toyota in car production and with the Japanese van manufacturer Isuzu, to which it sold a 40 per cent stake in its Bedford van plant in the UK and with which it is now investing &pound;70m to produce a new four-wheel drive vehicle for the European market. 
 On the other it has made no bones of the need for concerted action on the part of European car makers &mdash; of which it counts itself one &mdash; and European governments to counter the threat of growing Japanese car imports into the Continental market. 
 At the Geneva motor show earlier this year, the president of GM Europe, Robert Eaton, articulated this most clearly when he warned it was vital to make &bquo;substantial progress&equo; towards improving productivity and presenting a united political front against Japanese import penetration. 
 Failure to do so, he warned, would mean surrendering 25 per cent of the European car market to Japanese companies by the mid-1990s. 
 The cause for GM's concern is plain when one realises that its West European operations have emerged as the biggest profit earners in the entire group, accounting for some 37.3 per cent of net income in the last two years but for only 14.6 per cent of group turnover. 
 Not least among its star performers has been the British arm, Vauxhall, which last year achieved record net profits of &pound;152m and record car sales. 
 As well as being profitable and actually paying a dividend back to Detroit for the first time in years, Vauxhall is an important part of the GM empire for political reasons. 
 GM has sold off its UK truck operations and reduced its holding in the Bedford van plant. 
 It was badly scarred by the ill-fated attempt to acquire Leyland Vehicles and Land Rover, and only in recent times has it begun to reverse its image in Britain as little more than a screwdriver assembler of cars. 
 At one stage, Whitehall officials seriously considered stripping Vauxhall of its classification as a UK car company, so high was the imported content of &bquo;British-built&equo; Vauxhalls. 
 Since then local sourcing of components has improved markedly, as has the proportion of Vauxhall-Opel's UK sales which derive from its UK car plants as opposed to those on the Continent. 
 In 1986 GM acquired a controlling interest in the British sports car maker Lotus, and also employs thousands in its UK car parts division, AC Delco. 
 If it is to succeed in partnering Jaguar, then it is important for GM to be seen as a &bquo;good citizen&equo; of the UK. 
 The difficulty remains that, in this respect at least, Ford still has the superior credentials. 
 Third Market: Unit to add new interest 
 By NEIL THAPAR 
 UNIT GROUP, which obtained the distinction of being the first company to float on the Third Market, is about to make an important diversification into the engineering sector. 
 The company, which is one of the leading manufacturers of timber pallets in the UK, is thought to be planning the acquisition of a components manufacturer for about &pound;700,000. 
 The target is believed to be a privately-owned Surrey business which is a supplier of most aluminimum products to the aerospace and defence sectors. 
 Although there appears to be little synergy between Unit's existing business and engineering, the group believes it can introduce better management systems in the target company. 
 Unit has already built up valuable experience in engineering by setting up its own production line for the pallets business with in-house expertise. 
 It aims to capitalise on that experience by creating a second plank for the group in the engineering field. 
 It is likely that Unit will want to acquire more engineering interests to tie in with the Surrey business. 
 Unit is expected to finance the deal with a combination of cash and shares, which last week closed 1p lower at 145p, valuing the company at about &pound;8m. 
 Meanwhile, demand for Unit's pallets continues to be strong, although it remains to be seen what impact the slowdown in the economy will have on its prospects. 
 However, BWD Rensburg, the broker, is looking for pre-tax profits of about &pound;1.2m in the year ending 31 March against &pound;1.04m reported for last year. 
 Although earnings slipped from 8.1p to 17.6p last year due to a much higher tax charge, they are expected to improve to about 20.3p a share in the current year. 
 Next year could also see Unit's graduation from the third tier to the main market. 
 The company has a large number of Business Expansion Scheme investors who backed the company before it was on the Third Market. 
 It does not want to move up until the tax rules for BES investments have been fulfilled in January. 
 Square Mile: Stock Exchange hurries ahead on clearing house 
 By JOHN MOORE 
 BY THE end of this month the International Stock Exchange will have a clearer idea of the problems ahead of it in its establishment of a clearing house for the settlement of share deals. 
 Sir Geoffrey Littler, a former senior Treasury official and a director of NatWest Investment Bank, together witha group of eight City worthies, will have reported back to another committee established by the Exchange giving an interim assessment of the issues involved. 
 Last week, Andrew Hugh Smith, chairman of the Exchange, announced the appointment of Sir Geoffrey Littler as head of the Clearing House Formation Committee, which is charged with developing the proposals for the new settlement system. 
 The Exchange intends that the new clearing house will be jointly owned. 
 The Exchange will hold around 40 per cent of the shares in the new body with 20 or more groups &mdash; such as banks, registrars, securities houses and large financial institutions as well as some listed companies &mdash; holding the remainder. 
 As yet nothing is concrete and, following Sir Geoffrey's study, that initial concept may well change. 
 The terms of reference of Sir Geoffrey's committee indicate that the Exchange is determined that all aspects of the creation of a clearing house are fully explored. 
 A priority for the committee will be to establish the categories of organisation to which participation in the ownership of the clearing house would be extended, and the requirements that such an arrangement would be expected to fulfil. 
 The committee will also be considering whether there should be representation for groups not involved in ownership. 
 Mr Hugh Smith is committed to the principle of allowing users of the stock market more participation in the provision of services. 
 In its original thinking for the clearing house scheme, announced last July, the Exchange intended that a management agreement will exist between the clearing house and itself for the use of the Exchange's existing and projected settlement services. 
 An eventual transfer of the settlement services to the new clearing house was not ruled out. 
 Sir Geoffrey and his committee will be attempting to define the relationship between the clearing house and the Exchange and the financial arrangements for the provision of services. 
 His committee will be considering the regulatory requirements of the Financial Services Act for the new Exchange. 
 Under the act, the new clearing house will have to achieve &bquo;recognised&equo; status and adhere to the existing regulatory regime in the City. 
 More generally, Sir Geoffrey has been charged with proposing arrangements which will ensure that the business direction of the clearing house will be consistent with the maintenance and promotion of an effective central securities market in the UK. 
 What has given impetus to the establishment of the clearing house is the Exchange's fear that its centralised securities market is in danger of fragmenting. 
 The provision of efficient services and the involvement of users of the stock market is seen as a vital way in which to hold the market together. 
 Sir Geoffrey is also required to examine the basis on which share deals which are carried on outside the Exchange can be handled by the new clearing house. 
 His committee starts work next week. 
 The Exchange hoped originally that the new clearing house would be in operation by March next year. 
 At the moment, no date for its formation has been set but Sir Geoffrey has been asked to make specific recommendations &bquo;as soon as possible&equo;. 
 Threat to insurers AS THE &pound;1.1bn takeover bid by Australian Mutual Provident, Australia's largest life insurer, gets underway for the Pearl Group, a new survey suggests that perhaps the Australians should have made a bid for a building society. 
 The survey, prepared by the giant reinsurance group Swiss Re, shows that building societies pose a growing threat to insurance companies. 
 In it, 1,500 individuals were asked: &bquo;If you were to buy life assurance, which of the following methods, if any, would you choose &mdash; from a salesman in your own home, from a broker in his office, by post (either from a newspaper advertisement or from a mailshot), from a bank, or from a building society.&equo; 
 The responses indicated that 28 per cent would prefer to buy through a building society; 27 per cent said they would buy from a salesman in their own home. 
 Only 2 per cent would choose to buy a policy through the post, while 26 per cent opted for the broker route. 
 Those who would prefer to use a bank amounted to 22 per cent. 
 The fascinating feature of the survey is the marked change of sentiment towards methods of buying life cover in the last year. 
 A year ago 37 per cent of individuals indicated that would prefer to buy through a salesman, while 20 per cent preferred building societies. 
 Banks appear to be growing in popularity: a year ago only 17 per cent would have bought life cover through a bank. 
 According to Swiss Re, the banks and building societies continue to be very strong in the 15-24 age group. 
 The findings indicate why groups such as the Pearl are finding it heavy going in their core business activity. 
 The Pearl has a 6,500-strong sales force which collects insurance premiums and arranges policies by the simple expedient of house-to-house calls. 
 The Australian group bidding for Pearl argues that the UK market's proportion of individual life and pension business attributable to this method of business has fallen from 25 per cent to 7 per cent. 
 The Pearl has been making strenuous efforts to change its business direction, but the Australians clearly see the possibilities offered by the British group's large distribution network to market its own products. 
 View from Paris: Postal reform not easy to deliver 
 By SARAH LAMBERT 
 THE FRENCH government is standing firm against a wave of strikes by tax collectors, Peugeot workers, nurses and transport workers that threaten to paralyse certain sectors of the economy. 
 The strong tactics have paid off in the case of the prison officers, who went back to work last week, but there is increasing concern on how to deal with the tax collectors. 
 The unrest stems from their demand for higher salaries and better working conditions and has brought the day-to-day operations at the ministry of finance to a virtual standstill. 
 In the south of France hundreds of house sales have been held up because there is no one available to process the tax-related paperwork involved. 
 Given this background, the minister of posts, telecommunications and space, Paul Quiles, was treading on eggshells when he met the unions this week for the second in a series of talks concerning the reform of the country's post office, the PTT. 
 France, Denmark and Luxembourg are the only European countries not to have deregulated their post and telecommunications industry. 
 As a result the country is losing market share and is ill-prepared to fight the European competition come 1992 and the single European market. 
 The EC ministers have been told that if they cannot agree voluntarily on measures to ensure the harmonisation of the telecommunications industy some time early next year the European Commission will force them to do so. 
 The hurdle of post office reform has brought down French ministers of state before now, notably Pierre Lelong, who held the posts and telecommunications portfolio in Jacques Chirac's government but was forced to resign after a long and bitter strike in 1974. 
 Notwithstanding, Mr Quiles commissioned a report into strategies for reform and its controversial recommendations, made public at the beginning of last month, immediately drew the wrath of the unions. 
 The report recommends splitting the PTT in two with separate managements, one responsible for the post, the other for telecommunications. 
 The 450,000 employees, 300,000 of whom work in the postal service, are unhappy. 
 In the 1970s the government of Valery Giscard D'Estaing made a huge investment in the French telecommunications industry, giving it one of the most modern infrastructures in the world. 
 The rates it charges for its services are, however, set by the ministry of finance. 
 While 85 per cent of telephone users are reportedly satisfied with the service they receive, commercial clients are not. 
 The use of telex machines increased 7 per cent in the year 1987-88 and the demand for fax machines will outstrip that this year. 
 Many large companies doing business with the US and Asia can save as much as 20 per cent on their communications costs by routing traffic through London. 
 With the developments in fibre optics and the explosion in the use of services such as transcontinental video conferences, the competition can only get stiffer. 
 The post is, meanwhile, losing out to electronic &bquo;mail&equo; systems and a lengthy postal strike last year served only to hammer another nail in the coffin. 
 Delivery services such as DHL have captured 65 per cent of the post office's traditional market. 
 The post office has a monopoly only on the delivery of letters and parcels weighing less than a kilogram &mdash; a decling trade and one that now represents only 40 per cent of total earnings although attempts to stop the drift by creating, for example, specialised services for direct marketing have been very successful. 
 The post office's financial viability rests on its investment product, the good old post office savings book. 
 But, while it attracts 14 per cent of all personal savings, it barely ranks as a force in France's wider investment market. 
 However, the development of specially-tailored funds and financial products to compete with those offered by banks is beginning to get under way and there is a potentially lucrative link-up with the big assurance companies based on the post office's huge client base. 
 None of this is of any comfort to the unions, who are very strongly represented within the PTT and have been united in their rejection of the proposed reforms. 
 They fear that having separated post and telecommunications, France Telecom will receive the lion's share of the budget and may ultimately be privatised altogether. 
 The most vociferously opposed union maintains that all the problems could be solved were the government to remove the PTT from the financial tutelage of the finance ministry and give it an independent budget. 
 Since this would require a constitutional change it is not likely to recruit many supporters, but the unions have some powerful government supporters on their side. 
 They oppose the proposed changes for political reasons, believing that they form part of the task the prime minister, Michel Rocard, has set himself to reform public sector industry &mdash; reforms that many to the left of Mr Rocard believe to be inherently unsocialist. 
 The astute Mr Quiles has made a promising start. 
 The initial talks with the unions dealt with grievances such as working conditions and pay, sweetened with the promise of Fr100m to fund immediate improvements &mdash; to help provide cheaper accommodation for Paris workers, for example. 
 However, the unions have made it clear that they refuse even to discuss the proposed reforms and are not afraid to call their men out on strike. 
 Mr Rocard is frightened that, without reform, the PTT risks the same fate as France's now moribund iron and steel industry. 
 Mr Quiles is probably more concerned to hold on to his job. 
 An expert at crisis management: Mr Morton's penchant for rows is one of his hallmarks: Jeremy Warner looks at the man entrusted with the spadework of the tunnel project 
 By JEREMY WARNER 
 &bquo;ALASTAIR MORTON is terrific at crisis management, but he is no good when it comes to running a settled organisation,&equo; says one of those who has been left, somewhat bruised, along the wayside of Mr Morton's whirlwind career. 
 If this is a correct analysis Mr Morton must have found his metier at Eurotunnel, where he is one of two chairmen. 
 Yet questions are now being asked about whether his combative and aggressive style is really appropriate for Eurotunnel's latest debacle. 
 Mr Morton was headhunted by Eurotunnel from a minor financial services group, Guinness Peat, in Febuary 1987 specifically to deal with another such crisis. 
 Then the group's efforts to raise &pound;750m from the Equity Three share placing looked like foundering. 
 Without the new share capital, the banks wouldn't put up the &pound;5bn syndicated loan which was to provide the bulk of the tunnel's finance. 
 Most observers agree that Mr Morton did a spectacular job in reversing the project's fortunes. 
 With new advisers, he managed to change investment sentiment. 
 A series of presentational coups followed his appointment. 
 He renegotiated the agreement over tunnel usage by the railways and succeeded in presenting it as a breakthrough. 
 And he made a number of management changes which reinforced the impression that Eurotunnel had become a company capable of acting in the best interests of bankers and shareholders and standing up to the demands of the Anglo-French contracting consortium. 
 Yet, despite numerous rows with the contractors, he has failed so far to tinker with the construction contract to any meaningful degree. 
 It is this contract, which Mr Morton inherited when he joined Eurotunnel, that lies at the heart of present difficulties. 
 Mr Morton needs to bring the contractors down from their revised cost forecast of &pound;7.5bn. 
 He also needs to cap the new price so that it is prevented from rising further over the remaining four years of construction if he is to convince bankers that they should continue to support Eurotunnel. 
 It should be a situation perfectly suited to Mr Morton's Rottweiler style of management. 
 Some bankers, however, are beginning to have doubts about the way he bulldozes through his business aims. 
 One admits to getting a little fed up with Mr Morton's tendency to gloss over Eurotunnel's problems, insisting that almost whatever happens it will all come right in the end. 
 Mr Morton has always had a powerful ally in the shape of the Bank of England. 
 Both David Walker, now at the Securities and Investments Board, and Kit McMahon, now chairman of Midland Bank, are friends. 
 In 1982 they called on Mr Morton to help rescue Guinness Peat, which was close to collapse. 
 Despite some well publicised rows with Lord Kissin, the group's founder, and a high turnover of senior executives, he succeeded in turning the company round. 
 Mr Morton's penchant for rows is one of his hallmarks. 
 His most notable was with the merchant banker Sir Philip Shelbourne. 
 Mr Morton was running the British National Oil Corporation when Mrs Thatcher took power in 1979. 
 She brought in Sir Philip to oversee the dismantling of BNOC and the privatisation of its successor Britoil. 
 Within a week of his arrival Mr Morton, always an interventionist in his economics, was gone. 
 Mr Morton was born in South Africa, the son of a Scottish oil executive who had married into a local Afrikaner family. 
 He has worked for South African companies and first came to this country on a De Beers scholarship to Oxford. 
 But his views are strongly against the regime of his birthplace. 
 In his business style he bears many of the characteristics of an immigrant - including an overbearing, sometimes ruthless, desire to succeed. 
 The immigrant in him also makes him a bad delegater, say former colleagues. 
 He acquired his interventionist leaning at Harold Wilson's Industrial Reorganisation Corporation, where he was recognised as an up-and-coming young manager by Lord Kearton, the charismatic chairman of Courtaulds. 
 Mr Morton has long been rumoured as a possible successor to Sir Bob Reid at British Rail. 
 But, even if he wanted the job, his politics would probably rule him out. 
 He is strongly SDP, or at least was until its virtual demise. 
 Mr Morton, who has made many speeches on the need for an integrated and planned transport policy, would in any case be unlikely to relish the job of breaking up the rail network. 
 Ward arrested in US over Guinness affair 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Assistant Business Editor 
 THE US Department of Justice has agreed to back the Serious Fraud Office's efforts to have Washington lawyer Thomas Ward extradited to Britain to face charges in connection with the Guinness affair. 
 Mr Ward was arrested by the FBI in Washington on Thursday and charged with Theft Act offences relating to the &pound;5.2m he secretly received from Guinness through an obscure offshore nominee company in May 1986. 
 Mr Ward, a senior partner of the Washington law firm of Ward, Lazarus, Grow &amp; Cihlar, is the eighth person to face criminal proceedings in relation to the Guinness affair. 
 The Washington attorney was a close friend and adviser to Guinness's former chairman, Ernest Saunders, and has been a major target of the SFO's investigation of the corporate scandal. 
 He is alleged to have been a key figure in virtually all aspects of the Guinness affair. 
 Mr Ward refused to comment on his arrest when contacted at his Maryland home yesterday. 
 &bquo;We do not comment on anything. 
 How's the weather there in London? 
 It's glorious here&equo;, he said. 
 Many of the crimes with which others caught up in the Guinness affair are charged are not covered by the extradition treaty with the US. 
 As a consequence it is possible to extradite Mr Ward on only one of the offences allegedly committed by him &mdash; the alleged theft of the &pound;5.2m. 
 Theft is covered by the treaty but other offences which crop up in the Guinness case, such as common law conspiracy to rig the market and breaches of the Companies Act, do not. 
 Mr Ward has claimed that the &pound;5.2m was a legitimate payment for &bquo;valuable services&equo; to Guinness during the Distillers takeover. 
 However, the British civil courts have ruled that the payment was unlawful and that the money was at all times the property of Guinness. 
 Mr Ward has consistently refused to be interviewed by the British authorities investigating the Guinness affair. 
 It is thought certain that Mr Ward will fight extradition proceedings, which as a result could take up to two years to bring to a conclusion. 
 The extradition will add a further complication to the Guinness criminal trial. 
 Mr Saunders has already been charged with the theft of the &pound;5.2m, raising the possibility that this part of his trial may have to be delayed until Mr Ward is extradited. 
 Eagle acts to stop 227,000 pounds cheque 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 DAVID JAMES, the recently-appointed chairman of Eagle Trust which is under investigation by the Serious Fraud Squad and the West Midlands Police, has made attempts to freeze payments totalling &pound;227,000 authorised by the previous chairman Malcolm Stockdale to John Carway, a Dublin-based financier with a record of drugs and fraud offences. 
 Mr Stockdale, who resigned as chairman of Eagle Trust two weeks ago, paid Mr Carway to locate assets purportedly owned by Eagle. 
 Mr Stockdale had taken control of Eagle Trust in the wake of the resignation and subsequent departure from the country of John Ferriday, and had discovered that &pound;13.7m of funds could not be accounted for. 
 These included a shareholding in Laforza Automobiles, the US car manufacturer in which Eagle had invested &dollar;17.9m (&pound;11m). 
 It was Mr Carway who discovered that the holding in Laforza's parent company, the Jersey-registered AIUK, was only under option to Eagle, not directly owned by it. 
 In 1985 Mr Carway was given two suspended sentences, one in the UK for possession of cannabis, and another in Ireland for cheque fraud. 
 &bquo;There is nobody I do business with that does not know of my convictions,&equo; Mr Carway told The Independent. 
 &bquo;It's part of my life that is passed and there is no point in hiding it.&equo; 
 Mr Stockdale, however, said he did not know of Mr Carway's record, despite having a long business relationship with him. 
 It was Mr Carway who introduced Mr Stockdale to Iroquois Brands, the US-listed company Mr Stockdale used to buy into Eagle ealier this year. 
 Mr Stockdale authorised the &pound;227,000 payment as part of a package just before he resigned. 
 This included &pound;329,000 to Iroquois, covering fees over the four-and-a-half months that he chaired Eagle, &pound;33,000 to Iroquois' lawyer and two blank cheques for &pound;250,000 presented to Richard Smith and Clive Whiley, who had just been sacked as directors of Eagle. 
 The payments to the former directors were later stopped. 
 WPP settles for 7m dollars in Lord Geller action 
 By NEIL THAPAR, City Reporter 
 WPP IS to be paid &dollar;7m (&pound;4.3m) in an out-of-court settlement of its long-running legal battle against former executives of its Lord Geller subsidiary who left to form a rival agency with backing from Young &amp; Rubicam, the US advertising giant. 
 In an agreement reached last Friday, Lord Einstein O'Neill &amp; Partners, the new agency, will pay WPP &dollar;7m in cash, settling all claims and counter-claims. 
 &bquo;The settlement does not suggest admission of wrongdoing by any of the parties and is intended to avoid the expense and distraction that would accompany continued litigation,&equo; the four said a joint statement last night. 
 However, the outcome will be interpreted as a considerable victory for WPP in its attempt to stop the movement of staff and advertising clients from its subsidiary to the rival shop. 
 The legal battle began shortly after WPP acquired J. Walter Thompson, the Madison Square agency, for &dollar;544m in July 1987. 
 The takeover sparked off the defection of key executives from Lord Geller, a J W T subsidiary. 
 At the time, Lord Geller was handling a number of important accounts, including a &dollar;130m advertising contract from IBM. 
 The dispute was seen as an important test case in the advertising industry over the issue of staff and client defections. 
 The former executives have also dropped counter-claims against WPP involving bonus and retirement benefits and another &dollar;5m in &bquo;golden parachute&equo; payments. 
 The settlement will not affect WPP profits. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Fish, chips and zeal: &bquo;Against the Tide: Diaries 1973-76&equo; &mdash; Tony Benn: Hutchinson, 20 pounds 
 By RUTH DUDLEY EDWARDS 
 &bquo;MY OFFICIALS looked sick&hellip; but somehow I have seen a shaft of light; I know clearly why I am there. 
 I am there to look after our people, and what good people they are.&equo; 
 Thus Tony Benn, in June 1975 and three months into his tenure as Secretary of State for Industry, summed up what this volume is all about &mdash; his vain attempt to persuade government and Civil Service to implement Labour Party policy and bring about an irreversible shift of power and wealth to the working class. 
 And how he tried &mdash; speeding from study group to policy committee, from National Executive Committee to Cabinet, from office to platform, spraying out speeches, press releases and lengthy papers reminding his colleagues of what had been said in their manifesto. 
 At every turn he met bewilderment, cynicism or hostility he found difficult to understand. 
 Night in, night out he sat at home in his basement office dictating his account of the day, and seeking to record and explain for posterity what was going wrong. 
 Like other officials, his Permanent Secretary, Sir Anthony Part, is unhelpful &mdash; because &bquo;the Civil Service is defending the class interests of owners and professional people&equo;. 
 Working-class ministerial colleagues see socialism as &bquo;people like them getting to the top, not actually changing the top, just getting there&equo;. 
 Michael Foot is &bquo;an elitist parliamentarian&equo;, Barbara Castle is &bquo;politically greedy&equo;, Denis Healey &bquo;wobbles about according to which way the wind is blowing&equo;. 
 And above all there is Harold Wilson, &bquo;piggy-eyed&equo;, deceitful and contemptible. 
 (Benn is as vicious about the appearance of only one other person &mdash; the &bquo;stubby, dull, ageing&equo; Princess Margaret.) 
 Never does it occur to him that there might be good reason to dispute his proposals. 
 In some ways this is a heart-rending book, for there is no doubting Benn's single-minded commitment to his adopted class. 
 He is horrified by the contemptuous way in which fat Establishment cats speak of workers and it is particularly unfortunate that his enthusiastic support for co-operatives should have foundered because he backed dodgy horses. 
 Where he becomes ridiculous is in his desperate ambition to be part of the working class, striking a rather pathetic figure as he sits in his ministerial office with his trade union banner behind his head. 
 Eagerly he announces that he joined in &bquo;a marvellous Christmas drink with the canteen staff at the Department&equo;. 
 Along with his intensely loyal family he struggles hard to achieve downward mobility. 
 In his prejudiced but occasionally interesting Labour and the Benn Factor (Macdonald &pound;12.95), Michael Cocks recalls Benn on the train after a party conference wandering up and down the carriage saying: &bquo;Has anybody seen a pair of National Health Service glasses?&equo; 
 Cocks also describes how Denis Healey, in excellent form after winning the deputy leadership in 1981, spotted his beaten opponent in a fish and chip cafe and roared through the window: &bquo;Joined the plebs then?&equo; 
 Benn would not have seen the joke. 
 The comic dimension of a line like &bquo;Caroline and I went to Lockets for the husbands&equo; and wives' left-wing dinner' will have passed him by; he is as earnest as he is sanctimonious. 
 With his loyal advisers Francis Cripps and Frances Morrell by his side, he beavers away with unremitting zeal even when his beloved industrial policy is snatched away and he is banished to the Department of Energy. 
 But despite enthusiasm and hard work, disappointment and disillusion are the main reward. 
 Ms Morrell attempts damage limitation by telling her boss to keep his mouth shut and not rock the boat, but on he goes collecting more enemies and being let down by erstwhile friends. 
 And all of this is inevitable, for Utopians are ill at ease at the sharp end of politics. 
 Benn is too much a product of his comfortable and intensely high-minded background to be able to understand why the common man (let alone the common politician) has more vulgar aspirations than plain living and high thinking. 
 Yet whatever Benn's shortcomings, he deserves high praise for the service he has performed for recent political history. 
 His diaries may be partisan but they are honest, thoughtful and unsanitised. 
 They make up an archive of incalculable value. 
 Historians should be carrying him shoulder-high. 
 It's not who you know: Tom Arnold on the new gap between the Establishment and the Tory party 
 By TOM ARNOLD 
 THAT familiar phenomenon, the mid-term protest vote, should not be allowed to obscure an equally dramatic long-term change. 
 The Establishment has lost its heartland in the Conservative Party. 
 The emergence of a competitive society of equals was once only a dream. 
 Within this party, however, there has been a real move in that direction. 
 A short time ago, it would have been difficult to imagine that the Conservative Party in Parliament would be in open revolt against bishops of the Church of England. 
 A common feeling among Tory MPs is that on matters such as the resurrection of Christ, on which the Bishops should be certain, they are full of doubt; but on matters such as the precise level of the public sector borrowing requirement, they are vociferous in their certainty. 
 Few would have predicted that a radical, reforming Lord Chancellor would begin an assault on the restrictive practices of barristers. 
 In the old days the subtle relationships which constituted the Establishment at work would have prevented any such developments taking place. 
 Henry Fairlie wrote: &bquo;The exercise of power in Britain (more specifically, in England) cannot be understood unless it is recognised that it is exercised socially.&equo; 
 Fairlie, who is widely credited with inventing the phrase &bquo;the Establishment&equo; during the Burgess and Maclean revelations in September 1955, alleged that the two diplomats had been protected by such an Establishment. 
 In today's Conservative Party, &bquo;knowing all the right people&equo; does not ensure that doors will be opened. 
 Quite the reverse. 
 It may be a hindrance, for the new method of recruitment to the Conservative Central Office approved list of parliamentary candidates places no emphasis on social connections, and tries to assess a candidate's practical and political potential. 
 Individuals are now more important than institutions. 
 The Conservative parliamentary selection board meets three or four times a year. 
 Over a two-day period on each occasion, nearly 50 applicants are assessed for their suitability as future candidates and MPs. 
 At the 28th such board meeting, in February 1989, the age of those present ranged from 26 to 49, with an average age of 37. 
 They included lawyers, bankers, chartered surveyors, company directors, a market researcher, an engineer, a journalist, a charity appeals officer, a student, an actor and four computer managers. 
 There were eight women (not enough in my opinion; we are going to recruit more). 
 Half of the applicants passed, including five of the women. 
 What, then, does the board seek to examine? 
 Broadly speaking, the assessors, divided into MPs, industrialists, and senior party volunteers do not mark a score card; their task is to build up a profile of the applicants' intellectual and practical potential. 
 In other words, are they leaders? 
 Could they weld a Conservative Association together, lead it into an election campaign, and, if successful, represent the constituency in the House of Commons? 
 Are they well-rounded individuals who can cope with the stresses and strains of public life, domestic pressures, and constant travelling? 
 The Conservative Party is not looking for experts, but it is looking for men and women who have a good working knowledge of contemporary politics and a proven track record of experience in the party, and who above all know their own minds. 
 We might, for instance, ask them: &bquo;The local education authority, which is Conservative-controlled, wants to close a popular primary school in a run-down urban area in your constituency because of falling rolls; there is high unemployment. 
 Parents, teachers, and local clergy are campaigning to have the decision reversed. 
 They say the nearest alternative school is too far away and has a poor reputation. 
 Would you defend the decision?&equo; 
 Those who do well are the men and women who can articulate a sense of their own values, and who convey conviction. 
 Since May 1980, nearly 1,250 applicants have been to the board. 
 Few of them, in Henry Fairlie's phrase, have &bquo;known all the right people&equo;. 
 Many have been councillors, schooled in the hard practicalities of the town hall. 
 Their understanding of political power is formal and explicit, not mysterious and implicit. 
 They prefer conscious, open decisions to veiled influence. 
 The power of the Establishment came not from the fact that a few dozen people imposed their will on the rest of us, but from the fact that for a long time we felt it right that the opinions of such people should have respectful attention paid to them. 
 They thought they knew better, and they were, in turn, thought to know better. 
 As far as the Conservative Party is concerned, the current method of recruitment to the candidate list has released a great deal of pent-up energy and ability. 
 Thatcherites, and the Prime Minister herself, believe in a meritocracy of talent &mdash; and that talent is changing the face of the Conservative Party. 
 Creating money to buy trouble with 
 By WILLIAM REES-MOGG 
 NIGEL LAWSON'S fatal mistake was to abandon targeted monetarism in his Mansion House speech in the autumn of 1985. 
 A standard monetarist prediction of that decision would have been that it would produce two years of boom, followed by growing inflation and balance of payments deficit. 
 That is exactly what has happened. 
 Tim Congdon, at any rate, forecast it correctly. 
 The monetarism which Nigel Lawson abandoned was not perfect. 
 I am not myself an advocate of the Friedmanite arithmetical standard for money, but of the older and stronger rule of gold convertibility, the gold standard. 
 Yet a chancellor transgresses Professor Friedman's rule at his peril. 
 The money supply, measured by a broad definition, should only be allowed to increase at a stable and gradual rate, in line with the growth of the economy's productive capacity. 
 That is the rate of monetary growth which is compatible with avoiding inflation. 
 That rule was accepted by the Conservative Party in opposition before 1979, and Nigel Lawson, as a junior Treasury Minister, helped to develop the targeting of M3, the money supply measure, which was the backbone of the counter-inflationary policy of Mrs Thatcher's first administration. 
 There is no doubt about his commitment, or the Prime Minister's, to that policy. 
 It was painful, but it was successful. 
 Inflation was brought down to below 5 per cent, the balance of payments remained healthy and productivity improved rapidly. 
 That was the Thatcherite miracle of the early 1980s. 
 The price was that much redundant labour was squeezed out of industry, and unemployment rose to above three million. 
 Since the 1985 Mansion House speech broad money has ceased to be targeted. 
 However, it has continued to be reported, though M3 has been dropped. 
 M4, the best measure we have, has risen at an annual rate of around 18 per cent, and even this year it has continued to rise at that rate. 
 Unbelievably, M4 was allowed to rise at a rate of 17.7 per cent in the most recent six-month period. 
 Over a four-year period, 18 per cent compound approximately doubles, and Britain's broad money supply has approximately doubled since that fatal Mansion House speech. 
 This increase in the money supply has been disproportionate to that in any other West European or North American country. 
 During these four years twice as much sterling has been brought into existence. 
 What has this monetary expansion financed? 
 In the first place it financed a boom, helping to win the last election. 
 Around a fifth of the increase was taken up in greater activity, which resulted in a sharp fall in unemployment. 
 Something like a third of the increase has been taken up in higher prices, with the prices of some capital goods, such as houses, actually doubling. 
 Third, it financed a massive increase in British imports, and a critical deterioration in the British balance of payments. 
 Just less than half the money created went down that drain. 
 We created the money to buy trouble. 
 This is precisely what the Conservatives were elected to avoid. 
 The repudiation of the monetarist doctrines which were the heart of Thatcherite economics is the cause of 15 per cent base rates, and Labour's surge in the polls. 
 The Chancellor has not responded to the crisis with a monetarist policy, but with a severe interest rate policy, which has halted the housing market and depressed some consumer demands. 
 Yet he has allowed the excess creation of credit to continue, and has not used the obvious policy of overfunding to mop up the excess money supply. 
 The result has been that sterling has become very expensive to borrow, but there is still far too much of it, and the supply is still increasing too fast. 
 The Labour Party's solution is to advocate credit controls. 
 That does address itself to a real evil, the grossly excessive creation of credit, but not in the best way. 
 Credit controls have been tried in the past in Britain, and proved arbitrary and ineffective. 
 The other and lesser mistake has been the Government's failure to agree on a policy towards the European Monetary System. 
 Nigel Lawson rightly wanted to join the exchange rate mechanism two years ago &mdash; as did Sir Geoffrey Howe. 
 The Prime Minister rejected that, and refused to participate in the creation of a European Central Bank. 
 The result has been a shambles. 
 We are now plainly operating on a Deutschmark standard, and the rise in British base rate to 15 per cent was dictated by the rise in German rates. 
 We are therefore behaving as though we were fixed in the European Monetary System. 
 Yet, as the Financial Times observes, we are getting &bquo;none of the advantages&equo;. 
 I share some of the Prime Minister's suspicion of a European Central Bank. 
 Europe has a perfectly good central bank already &mdash; the Bundesbank. 
 The Germans are more to be trusted with maintaining the value of European money than would be a Central Bank with votes for inflationary countries like Greece, Britain or Italy. 
 Until the Bank of England has the independence of the Bundesbank, it will remain an ineffective protection against inflation. 
 I do not therefore mind leaving these matters in the safe hands of the Germans, just as many nations before 1914 were content to leave them in the safe hands of the British. 
 But if we are to be fixed to the Deutschmark, that should be an agreed and acknowledged policy. 
 It is absurd to disagree about whether we should be fixed to the Deutschmark or not, while behaving as if we were. 
 There is now no easy way out of the economic problems which face Britain. 
 Even with the best economic policy it will take two years from this point to go through the unavoidable stages of deflation and recession to reach the start of recovery. 
 The past two years have only seen the start of the process, and in terms of M4 the process has not been started at all. 
 With current policies the Conservatives will not win the next election; even with better policies they might not win it. 
 The first step must be to restore coherence and confidence to the central direction of economic policy. 
 That would require three decisions: the restoration of targeting of M4, the use of government funding to control the quantity of money, and immediate British entry to the exchange rate mechanism of the EMS. 
 The shibboleth of the DM3 standard should not stand in the way of entry at a realistic level, which would probably be at around DM2.80 to the pound. 
 During the period of entry, interest rates may have to be kept at the present emergency level, but it is an emergency level, a punishment for past sins of credit creation and lax management. 
 It is not an acceptable long-term rate, because of the damage it does to industry and homeowners. 
 There is no need for Nigel Lawson to resign, although he and the Prime Minister share responsibility for a disastrous lapse from Thatcherite principles. 
 He is still the best equipped Chancellor on the Conservative front bench; she is still the best Thatcherite Prime Minister we have. 
 But they must announce a new and solid policy. 
 They are both tough and principled politicians. 
 That makes them effective when the policies are right; but to run a stable economy one needs not only strong character but the right ideas. 
 What we have, we hold: The decision not to build in Foxley Wood leaves vital questions of planning policy unanswered. 
 Paul Barker offers a cure for the South-east's Nimby tendencies 
 By PAUL BARKER 
 It is the blueing, not the greening, of the countryside. 
 The decision last week by Chris Patten, the Secretary of State for the Environment, to reject the scheme for a small new town among the gravel pits and conifers of north-east Hampshire is pure politics. 
 The Conservative Party is trying to get its green credentials in order, as witness Mr Patten's emollient interview with Brian Walden on ITV yesterday. 
 For anxious Conservative MPs in the Home Counties, the Foxley Wood decision is a signal that the Government is listening to them. 
 It is, however, not just a little local difficulty. 
 It is an important signal that short-term politics matter more than the longer-run question of how to house the next generation. 
 The priority has been to buy off the ex-brigadiers of Hampshire. 
 In one of his last acts as environment secretary, Nicholas Ridley scrapped a similar scheme in Oxfordshire, at Stone Bassett. 
 The local MP happened to be Michael Heseltine, who knows a thing or two about campaigning. 
 But just where are the proliferating households of south-east England supposed to go? 
 On Sunday Mr Patten was vague about this. 
 A responsible green policy would not defend every blade of grass. 
 People are as important as buttercups. 
 The trick is to keep as many buttercups as you can while giving people a pleasant place to live in. 
 At the moment, the cheery assumption is that wasteland can be found somewhere within existing cities for housing to be built on. 
 The snag is, as London Docklands developers have found, these are not always the houses that people want. 
 There is a paternalistic assumption lurking here, which reminds me of that which led to the disastrous council housing estates of the Sixties and early Seventies. 
 Those estates were not where We would like to live: but they were all right for Them. 
 Similarly, We would like to have a bit of grass around the house and a nice view. 
 But, for Them, an in-fill town house will be just fine. 
 If they can find one at a price they can afford&hellip; 
 Tightly packed urban living is, indeed, fine &mdash; if that is what you want. 
 As a rule, those who can afford it seem increasingly to temper the urban living of the weekday with a touch of rural life at the weekend. 
 But those people who &mdash; unlike Chris Patten or Nicholas Ridley &mdash; can only afford one house would like a flavour of the country on their own doorstep. 
 It is no use wringing hands and regretting this preference. 
 It is a long English tradition, which is not going to change. 
 Every Englishwoman and her husband wants a garden. 
 The only sensible question is how to meet this demand in a way that does not wreck the countryside. 
 Foxley Wood and Stone Bassett &mdash; neither of which, incidentally, was in the Green Belt &mdash; were a reasonable stab at answering this. 
 They were private developers' schemes, yet the Town and Country Planning Association &mdash; which tends the flame of Ebenezer Howard's garden city ideals &mdash; endorsed them. 
 The point is that, unless you have such focuses for new building, you are left with only two alternatives: to force all new building back on to those urban wastelands; or else to let new housing grow, like fat around a middle-aged belly, on the outskirts of existing villages and country towns. 
 In practice, as Chris Patten seems to acknowledge, it means the latter option. 
 Without new towns of some sort, we shall not protect the countryside; we shall ruin it. 
 Inevitably, we are talking about the South-east, which is where the development pressure is. 
 That is where the jobs are. 
 It is the South-east that needs new settlements, if we are not to end up with a town-and-country muesli of interest to no one. 
 I would like to think that the Foxley Wood and Stone Bassett decisions might mark a positive turning point. 
 Until now, under this Government, everything has been left to the hazards of private development and the initiative of county councils. 
 But the not-in-my-backyard arguments are hard to resist at local level. 
 Three private new town schemes have now been rejected. 
 This is the catch in Chris Patten's weekend declaration of trust in local authorities. 
 The only one that is going ahead is in the Fens, north of Cambridge, at Westmere. 
 Here there is a great deal of open space, no longer necessary for agriculture, and Cambridgeshire County Council was in favour. 
 I doubt if any more private-enterprise new towns will now be proposed. 
 One of these days a new co-ordinating authority will have to be created to resolve the Nimby tendencies of the South-east. 
 Until then, only the Government &mdash; which means the Department of the Environment &mdash; can fill this role. 
 Chris Patten &mdash; the cuddly man succeeding the spiky man &mdash; has begun ominously. 
 Alongside his Foxley Wood decision he published new planning guidance which tilted the general balance against giving permission for house-building. 
 Another dose of blue for the countryside. 
 What we have, we hold. 
 Conservatism at its best is about letting people &mdash; within broad bounds &mdash; do what they want and live how they want. 
 (This is why, in the media, it has always been Tory governments that have created new radio or television channels, whether Radio Clyde, Granada Television, London Jazz Radio, or Channel Four.) 
 I only hope that, once he has calmed the panic among his Home Counties political colleagues, Chris Patten has more of a strategy up his sleeve. 
 If London is not to implode and if people are not to be paternalistically forced to live the way they do not want to live, new towns will have to be publicly designated. 
 It is the only way to give both people and the countryside a breathing space. 
 There will be about two million more people in England in the year 2001 than in 1986. 
 London and the South-east will have to absorb 900,000 extra households over the same span of years. 
 These are the Environment Secretary's own figures. 
 If you let your eye rove over the map, it is pretty obvious that one of the new towns should be near the Channel Tunnel and another near the new Stansted Airport. 
 The pressures will build up there inexorably. 
 That will help the north-east and south-east conduits of growth outwards from London. 
 To the north-west, there is of course Milton Keynes. 
 Huge tracts of this city of 137,000 are not yet built. 
 Chris Patten could reasonably say to house-builders: Go to MK. 
 But how, after the Foxley Wood decision, is the pressure going to be eased to London's south-west, along and around the M4 and M3 motorways? 
 Fuelled by defence spending, this is the electronics boom area. 
 Unemployment is nil. 
 Should the only answer be to tack more and more suburbs on to the edge of Reading and more &bquo;executive housing&equo; on to the fringes of Berkshire or Hampshire villages? 
 Is our imagination at such a low ebb? 
 I have many reservations about Prince Charles's scheme at Dorchester. 
 It is too far-flung, anyway, to help much with this specific problem. 
 But at least he is having a go. 
 He could not do it if he were not the landlord, although in general you cannot, in the late twentieth century, expect high-minded landlords to do your planning for you. 
 Nor on present evidence can you leave it to the internecine politics of the county councils around London, with occasional injections of national politics. 
 Planning got a bad name through trying to do too much. 
 It is worth looking closely at Milton Keynes to see that planning need not, any more, mean trying to design every dot and comma of people's lives. 
 Where planning is not purely negative (which it has to be sometimes), it should set out to enable people to live decent lives. 
 Right now, we seem to be ready to cripple lives and curb them &mdash; creating houses we shall regret and preferring town cramming to town planning. 
 The collapse of London &mdash; like the report of the death of Mark Twain &mdash; is much exaggerated. 
 Many of its difficulties will not be solved either by John Prescott's ideas for greater rail and bus use, or by Cecil Parkinson's new and wider motorways. 
 The only answer is to spread the people and the jobs thinner &mdash; so that fewer travellers, bringing their cars and their litter - journey into it or through it. 
 This is not an argument that should only concern South-easterners. 
 Love it or hate it, the South-east does contain 30 per cent of the population of the United Kingdom. 
 It is the engine that drives the economy. 
 It is in everyone's interest, North, South, East and West, that London is not throttled and that those who live in the South-east &mdash; on modest means &mdash; can have a decent life. 
 If the regions revive, the revival will be powered from the South-east. 
 If the South-east sinks, they will go down the plug with it. 
 Unroll that map of England, Mr Patten. 
 A green and pleasant London goes hand-in-hand with a green and pleasant England. 
 London is not the way it is through sheer inertia and accident. 
 In its day it built the world's first by-pass and dug the world's first underground railway. 
 It invented the suburb &mdash; the most successful invention in the history of human habitation. 
 It is time to match again that degree of ingenuity. 
 This will not be done just by saying No to things. 
 It means deciding where, when and why to say Yes. 
 Leading Article: Gorbachev's German Question 
 By PAUL BARKER 
 MIKHAIL Gorbachev presents himself as the saviour of socialism. 
 These days, however, when he visits some outpost of that crumbling creed, he must look like its undertaker. 
 In Havana in April, Fidel Castro politely told him to mind his own business. 
 A month later his arrival in Peking gave moral succour to the &bquo;counter-revolutionaries&equo; of Tiananmen Square. 
 Now it has happened again. 
 His obligatory attendance of the 40th birthday party of East Germany has helped to leave that self-advertised &bquo;pillar of European stability&equo; and &bquo;trustiest of friends of the Soviet Union&equo; looking more unstable than at any time since the Red Army moved in to suppress the uprising of 17 June 1953. 
 This time the stakes are higher than ever: the very future of Moscow's most important military ally. 
 However dramatic the events of these days in East Berlin, Dresden and Leipzig &mdash; not to mention sundry West German embassies in the Eastern bloc &mdash; East Germany will not disappear tomorrow. 
 But with stunning clarity they demonstrate again how the great reformer has unleashed forces which he and his country no longer control, and which now are playing on the German Question itself, the issue which lies at the very heart of today's European order. 
 Nato may fret over the soul of West Germany. 
 But such worries are nothing compared to the dilemma facing the Kremlin as the waves of perestroika lap at one of the last fortresses of communist orthodoxy. 
 To permit things to proceed as they are is to invite further mass emigration, further disorder, and deeper isolation of East Germany among its increasingly notional &bquo;fraternal socialist allies&equo;. 
 Yet the advent of out-and-out reformers in East Berlin would represent an even greater threat for Moscow. 
 Unlike Poland or Hungary, East Germany has no nationalism upon which to fall back, as the dogmas of nearly half a century evaporate. 
 Ideology is the only rationale for the existence of the &bquo;first workers&equo; state on German soil'. 
 Remove Marxism &mdash; as the Hungarians have done this weekend &mdash; and the pressures to pull down the artificial barriers with the other freer, richer, and more appealing Germany, would become irresistible. 
 What price the pact then? 
 This weekend Mr Gorbachev has walked the finest diplomatic tightrope. 
 Unmistakably, though, he has come down on the side of the demonstrators and against Erich Honecker, the East German leader. 
 &bquo;When you fall behind, you are punished by life,&equo; was the remark to his host, relayed to the world by Gennady Gerasimov, the Soviet spokesman. 
 Beyond such verbal subversion there is little Mr Gorbachev can do. 
 The only way of squaring the circle to Moscow's satisfaction would be to send in troops. 
 But the interventionist Brezhnev doctrine, in any case not conceived as an instrument of liberalisation, has been abandoned. 
 East Germany's future, as Mr Gorbachev never tires of reminding us, can be settled only by East Germany itself. 
 He may have concluded that Mr Honecker is a lost cause, but sooner or later (and probably sooner) he will leave the stage. 
 If the regime is to be saved, his successor will have no choice but to make changes. 
 The Kremlin's only option now is to pull every available string to find a miracle-worker, a man capable both of reform and of limiting the consequences of reform. 
 Mr Gorbachev's future, as well as that of East Germany, ride upon the outcome. 
 Leading Article: The freedom to party 
 By PAUL BARKER 
 WE HAVE been here before. 
 The delights of all-night dancing parties with weird lights on the walls were discovered by white bohemian crowds in California in the Sixties, when they were called acid tests, and had a quasi-religious significance. 
 It is difficult to deal sensibly with the craze unless we remember that it is the latest in a series of recognisably similar phenomena, which the law has had difficulty in regulating: the early &bquo;happenings&equo;, influenced by LSD; the &bquo;blues parties&equo;, which were the last to hit the headlines; the continuing &bquo;northern soul&equo; craze, and no doubt others which even the participants have long since forgotten. 
 The fashionable dress varies, as do the fashionable drugs, but there are always at least two problems for society to deal with: the fact that these events are associated with the consumption of illegal and often dangerous drugs; and the noise they make. 
 Some acid house parties can be heard miles away across the countryside: the inhabitants of normally quiet villages deserve protection. 
 So, too, do those people in towns who have the misfortune to live near the wrong warehouse. 
 Douglas Hurd's announcement on Friday that he will try to tighten up the law relating to the licensing of these parties should certainly address itself to that aspect of the problem. 
 If noise pollution is made a more clearly identifiable criminal offence, this will prove one of the rare occasions on which hard cases have generated a much-needed law. 
 As a general principle, hasty legislation does more harm than good. 
 None the less, there are some aspects to the present acid house craze which distinguish it from its predecessors and which need attention. 
 The first is the amounts of money to be made in the business. 
 While the fashion lasts, these are considerable: figures of &pound;200,000 to &pound;300,000 in profit for one well-organised party are being bandied about, and do not seem to be greatly exaggerated. 
 Such sums could prove attractive to all sorts of unsavoury characters, including those who might have money to launder. 
 With bad luck, the phenomenon could even develop into the sort of cash-cow that speakeasies became for organised crime in the United States under Prohibition. 
 The emergence of bellicose private security forces enforcing order at these parties is an allied worry. 
 The second cause for concern is the sheer length of time for which the parties seem to continue. 
 Perhaps this is a reflection of the increasing health of the young and affluent, who are prepared to try to dance for 24 hours; be that as it may, it multiplies the offence to outsiders. 
 But none of these problems is unique to acid house: the Notting Hill Carnival continues for three days, attracts vast crowds, involves large-scale drug consumption, and is stupefyingly noisy. 
 So is the annual CND pop festival at Glastonbury. 
 Yet these, by a process of negotiation and experience, have been regulated and brought within the compass of what is socially acceptable without the passage of unnecessary laws such as the &bquo;anti-hippy&equo; sections of the Public Order Act. 
 Regulation should not attempt to suppress the phenomenon altogether, but ensure, with appropriate penalties for failure, that acid house parties &mdash; and whatever succeeds them &mdash; cause minimal disturbance to the non-dancing majority, and that they do not become occasions of profit for professional criminals. 
 A higher degree of espionage 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 &bquo;FIFTY million freshmen can't be wrong,&equo; thought Boris. 
 It was the first day of the new university year. 
 Most second-year students had not returned yet; they were still struggling back from cycling holidays in Iran. 
 Most of the third-year students had been back for a month already, desperately trying to catch up with their second-year work. 
 But all the first-year students had arrived together on the first day of term and sought out the one fixed event in the university calendar, the Freshmen's Fayre. 
 Boris had got back two months early to organise it. 
 But then, he was a sixth- or seventh-year student. 
 Nobody was quite sure how many degrees he had started and not finished, not even Boris, but he had been at the place so long he could remember when they used to spell it Freshmen's Fair. 
 It was Ronnie, one of the junior lecturers. 
 Boris could remember him coming. 
 Only the older dons predated Boris. 
 &bquo;I don't need to join any of your lonely hearts clubs,&equo; said Ronnie. 
 &bquo;A young lecturer is meant to be able to get friends without paying for them.&equo; 
 &bquo;They're not dating agencies,&equo; said Boris, shocked. 
 &bquo;They're ways of recycling first-year money directly into third-year pockets &mdash; from students who don't know how to spend it to those who really need it. 
 Anyway, I've got to go in and snoop around a bit. 
 I'm worried about the English Literature Society's threat to burn Dame Iris Murdoch in effigy.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's wrong with that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing. 
 I'm just afraid they might forget.&equo; 
 As he wandered round, Boris saw all the old stalwarts. 
 The Tobacco Society ('Unable to hand roll ciggies? 
 We'll teach you in complete confidence'), the Jazz Society ('There will be a small written examination before we let you know if you can join') and the French Society ('Amusez-vous bien et attrapez cirrhose du foie avec la Frenchsoc! '). 
 There were the bank recruitment stands ('If you give us all your money, we will let you queue in our bank when we're open, and outside when we're not! ') and the MI5 stall ('Ever thought about Intelligence? 
 You could do worse&hellip; '). 
 The MI5 stall? 
 Boris couldn't believe his eyes. 
 MI5 had never asked for permission to have a stall. 
 He had never granted it. 
 It must be some kind of joke. 
 &bquo;How are things going, lads?&equo; he said casually, wandering over to the stand. 
 &bquo;Anyone joined yet?&equo; 
 &bquo;We don't answer questions like that, Boris.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, how about this one? 
 How do you happen to have a stall when the organisers didn't give you permission?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, we rented this space from the Poetry Society. 
 We persuaded them we needed it more than they did.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right, here's another. 
 Who the bloody hell are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Exactly who we say we are,&equo; said the man, looking surprised. 
 &bquo;MI5 has decided to recruit openly in future. 
 Hadn't you read? 
 All this old-style word-in-your-ear, casual approach stuff wasn't getting anywhere, so we're going out in the market place to get the right people.&equo; 
 &bquo;And recruiting first-year students?&equo; 
 &bquo;Planting the seed, Boris, planting the seed. 
 Care to join yourself?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, we know all about you,&equo; said the man. 
 &bquo;We know how much money from the Freshmen's Fayre has found its way into your bank account over the years. 
 We know who's been organising acid house parties for the past year. 
 We know who's been supplying the drugs to them. 
 We even know about you and Ronnie's wife. 
 Intelligence is our business, don't forget.&equo; 
 &bquo;What are you going to do about it?&equo; said Boris faintly. 
 &bquo;We like the way you organise things,&equo; said the man pleasantly. 
 &bquo;Shame to see such talent wasted. 
 Why not join us?&equo; 
 &bquo;You'd be in trouble, I'm sorry to say.&equo; 
 &bquo;This is blackmail.&equo; 
 Letter: The Dalai Lama's Nobel Prize 
 From Lord ENNALS 
 Sir: The announcement of the award of the Nobel Peace Prize to the Dalai Lama is not only wonderful news for Tibetans throughout the world and for those who admire this selfless leader of the Tibetan people. 
 It will also be widely welcomed by all who believe in self-determination for these proud people, who have suffered Chinese oppression for nearly 40 years. 
 From my visit to Lhasa last year, I am very much aware of the implications for the Tibetan people of Chinese colonialism and its policy of apartheid. 
 As your article (6 October) says, the award challenges Peking to honour what it says is its willingness to open a dialogue with the Dalai Lama. 
 Their condemnation of the award is not a good omen. 
 The award is also a challenge to Her Majesty's Government. 
 For how long can Mrs Thatcher continue to recognise China's present position, in spite of martial law in Lhasa and a series of brutal attacks on peaceful demonstrations by Chinese troops, in that HMG recognises the Chinese occupation of Tibet? 
 When the Dalai Lama came to Britain in April 1988, he was snubbed by the Government. 
 On the Prime Minister's orders, no minister or civil servant was allowed to meet him. 
 That sort of response is no longer acceptable. 
 The Dalai Lama should be congratulated on the great honour which is to be bestowed on him, and the Prime Minister or the Foreign Secretary should make it clear that he will be warmly welcomed when next he is able to visit London. 
 This week's Conservative Party Conference in Blackpool would be a very appropriate time for such a statement by Mrs Thatcher. 
 I know there are many Conservative MPs who would welcome this. 
 Letter: Repression of Sudanese unions 
 From Mr KEN GILL and others 
 Sir: We write to express our deep concern and profound fears over the continued detention of scores of prominent trade union leaders and activists in the Sudan and the banning of all union activity. 
 Recently 55 more trade unionists have been arrested, yet those who were detained immediately after the 30 June coup have been neither interrogated, charged nor given an explanation of the reason why they are being held. 
 Those held are imprisoned throughout the Sudan including in the main prison in Khartoum North, &bquo;Kober&equo;. 
 There is little reason to doubt that they are being incarcerated because of their trade union membership. 
 Immediately after it came to power, the junta led by General Omar Hassan el Beshir dissolved all trade unions, closed their headquarters and confiscated their property. 
 Since then it has started to dismiss work leaders and trade union activists. 
 The suppression of trade union and democratic rights by the military authorities is reflected in their attempt to impose a new trade union law in the absence of leaders, thus violating international conventions and agreements, including the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, to which Sudan is a signatory. 
 Now the Union of Sudanese Trade Unions has issued an international call for support. 
 We appeal, therefore, to public opinion, and trade unionists in particular, to denounce these repressive measures, condemn the violations of democratic and trade union rights by the authorities and demand the immediate release of all detainees and a halt to mass dismissals and arrest without trial. 
 Letter: Lawson's blunt instrument 
 From Mr DAVID F. HEATHFIELD 
 Sir: The Chancellor's policy of fighting inflation with exceptionally high real interest rates is at variance with the government's economic philosophy in two significant ways. 
 First, interest rates are not to be left to market forces and free competition. 
 Unlike other prices (and wages), interest rates are to be politically determined. 
 Second, whereas the government's social policy extols the virtues of targeting benefits and subsidies to where they will do most good, there is no parallel targeting to ensure that interest rate policy will bear only on those aspects of the economy which increase inflationary pressure. 
 The need for state interference in this market springs from the fact that it is no longer the state but the commercial banks which generate the bulk of our money supply. 
 They do so by creating credit. 
 The sovereign's power to debase the currency has passed to the commercial banks and so has the seigniorage which once accrued to the state. 
 Profit-seeking banks in competition with each other are, quite reasonably, keen to issue as much interest-bearing credit as possible. 
 They cannot be expected to consider the inflationary consequences of their commercial activities. 
 Unlike the sovereign, who simply minted more coin, the banks have first to persuade us to take up the credit they wish to create. 
 In other words, they have to persuade someone to borrow from them before they can &bquo;issue&equo; new money. 
 By imposing a very high cost of borrowing, the Chancellor hopes to reduce our willingness to accept any more bank credit and thereby limit credit creation by the banks. 
 This is a very blunt instrument. 
 The only kind of credit which is inflationary is that which is newly created by the commercial banks (and similar deposit-taking institutions). 
 Existing credit and other (non-bank) credit is not only non-inflationary, but beneficial. 
 By imposing a high cost on all credit, the Chancellor is failing to target newly-created bank credit and the costs of this failure are enormous. 
 The increasing number of mortgage repossessions, the increasing interest costs to the UK manufacturing sector, the distortion of the foreign exchange market, the wage demands induced as workers seek to maintain their living standards and the large, gratuitous redistribution of income from debtors to creditors result in painful and often irreversible dislocations. 
 Letter: Libel damages 
 From Sir KENNETH DOVER 
 Sir: The suggestion of Mr Varcoe-Cocks (letter, 5 October) that if I win damages for libel and give them to charity I &bquo;cannot be said to have been compensated in any way&equo; is extraordinary. 
 I find it hard to think of any more splendid compensation than conferment of the power to transfer a very large sum of money from a newspaper which I dislike and despise to an organisation or institution which I love and admire. 
 Letter: Libel damages 
 From Mr ANDREW BLUNDY 
 Sir: Mr Stephen Campbell (letters, 5 October) asks if he is alone in thinking that personal injury awards should be increased in relation to libel awards rather than the other way round. 
 The answer is that, while he is not alone, he has misunderstood the purpose of civil awards of damages. 
 The purpose of the civil law is to compensate; it is the function of the criminal law to punish. 
 The most likely explanation for the recent record levels of libel awards is that juries have confused these two functions, and part of the blame must lie with judges for having failed adequately to explain to juries the purpose of their damages award. 
 Perhaps it is too much to hope that the Court of Appeal (in their forthcoming judgment in the Sutcliffe case) will give definitive guidance on what should be included in the judge's summing up in a libel trial. 
 Letter: Invitation list 
 From Professor BHIKU PAREKH 
 Sir: In his report on the seminar on the Rushdie affair organised jointly by the Commission for Racial Equality and the Policy Studies Institute (3 October), John Torode says that the proceedings were dominated by &bquo;pragmatist liberals&equo; &mdash; those who believe in restricting freedom of speech in order to protect the religious sensibilities of fundamentalists. 
 But there was no such domination. 
 Two of the five papers presented at the seminar disapproved of such censorship. 
 The participants represented a wide variety of views and tended on the whole to disapprove of state-imposed censorship. 
 Mr Torode says he was told that those supporting the Government's views on blasphemy were excluded. 
 He was misinformed. 
 Although he was unable to accept, John Patten, Minister of State at the Home Office, was invited to open the seminar. 
 Two senior research officers at the Home Office were also invited, and one of them made an excellent contribution. 
 Mr Torode's sources are also wrong in saying Fay Weldon and her allies were not invited because they held racist attitudes. 
 In a seminar limited to 40 participants, not everyone's favourites can be included; however, Harold Pinter, whom Mr Torode surprisingly regards as Ms Weldon's ally, was invited, not only to participate but also to chair a session. 
 Angela Carter too was invited. 
 Stuart Weir, who has courageously stood by Rushdie, was there, and so were such men and women of impeccable liberal credentials as James Cornford, Sara Maitland and Ben Whitaker. 
 The CRE organised a series of three seminars in order to bring together people of very different points of view and evolve a broad consensus on some of the large issues raised by the Rushdie affair. 
 The results so far have been encouraging. 
 They have shown that the gap between the different communities is smaller than Mr Torode would have us believe, and it is bridgeable. 
 Letter: A-road architecture 
 From Councillor SALLY POWELL 
 Sir: While agreeing with much of what Jonathan Glancey say in his article on &bquo;A-road&equo; architecture (4 October), I think he misses the point when he says that no one cares about it. 
 The impressions given by Mr Glancey is that these buildings somehow just appear from nowhere, with no one even noticing; he says that they are &bquo;anonymous&equo;, even &bquo;invisible&equo;. 
 In reality, of course, they are the result of a long chain of conscious decision making. 
 They are the product of a specific brief by land owners or developers, detailed &bquo;design&equo; by architects within that brief and approval by the local authority. 
 It is no accident that these three processes combine to produce buildings that reflect the values of those involved. 
 The combination of commercial patronage, large-scale corporate architectural firms and those local authorities which hold materialistic values produces the kind of architecture described in Mr Glancey's article. 
 Local people (who do notice and do care) are virtually powerless to intervene against such a combination. 
 Hammersmith Road is a good illustration of this process at work. 
 There was colossal opposition to these developments at the planning stage, but local people's views were generally ignored by the Tory administration of the day, who basically held the same values as the developers and permitted the schemes. 
 If the worst examples of A-road architecture are produced by a combination of developer, architect and local authority all holding the same materialistic values, the reverse is also true. 
 While any one of these groups can individually try to alter the design of a building, each can only achieve a little on their own. 
 When all three, however, start from a different point &mdash; caring about the environment and the quality of life - buildings such as Ralph Erskine's design for Ake Larson and Enator become feasible. 
 Mr Glancey is inaccurate when he says that the London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham rejected an &bquo;inspired scheme&equo; by Terry Farrell for the reconstruction of Hammersmith Broadway. 
 Quite the reverse. 
 The Labour administration approved the scheme wholeheartedly in 1986, and used it at a public inquiry to try to oppose the imposition of more A-road architecture on the site approved by the previous Tory administration. 
 The Secretary of State, however, &bquo;knew best&equo; and overruled his inspector who had supported the borough's view. 
 A-road architecture does not glide in silently overnight and park itself along our urban highways. 
 It results from and reflects power, patronage and politics in our society &mdash; and it is detested by those who must live for decades in its shadow. 
 Letter: Margaret Regina 
 From Mrs S. L. ALLCOCK 
 Sir: Following the report on the &bquo;regal&equo; gates to be erected at the end of Downing street ('Psychiatrists explore hidden meaning of Thatchergate plan', 4 October), your readers may be interested in a recent instance when Mrs Thatcher was equated with the Queen. 
 Two weeks ago in Yugoslavia, we stayed overnight in a private house offering bed and breakfast accommodation. 
 Owing to the extremely high inflation there, prices are often quoted in Deutschmarks. 
 My husband did not have enough marks to pay the bill, so he offered to pay the equivalent amount in Sterling. 
 The landlady looked suspiciously at the notes he proffered and asked if they were Belgian currency. 
 When he insisted that they were pounds, she looked more closely and then exclaimed: &bquo;Of course they're British &mdash; they've got a picture of Mrs Thatcher on them!&equo; 
 Letter: Social balance 
 From The Rev JIM WELLINGTON 
 Sir: Canon Oestreicher (letter, 5 October) would appear to have allowed political prejudice to cloud impartial judgement. 
 Dr Runcie, he writes, &bquo;is calling for a social market economy&equo;, the implication being that such a marriage between free market principles for wealth creation and collective provision for social needs does not exist in this country. 
 How can this implication be justified when the last decade has witnessed a real growth in public spending, particularly on health and society security, coupled with an increase in overall taxation? 
 Judged on the facts, rather than the political rhetoric of both left and right, the present Government deserves neither the undying praise of the supporters of laissez-faire nor the unremitting invective of collectivists. 
 Letter: Fees and taxes 
 From Professor MALCOLM GRANT 
 Sir: Terry Coleman reports (5 October) the speech by Andrew Neil at a Fabian fringe meeting, in which he described the BBC licence fee as a poll tax and suggested that it was indistinguishable from the community charge. 
 A similar comparison was made by the Minister (Michael Howard MP) when defending the poll tax in the House on 18 April 1988. 
 It is entirely fallacious. 
 There are two fundamental differences between the two. 
 First, the licence fee is voluntary: nobody is forced to buy the BBC's product. 
 Payment of the community charge is compulsory, which is why it is more accurately characterised as a tax than a charge. 
 Second, for those who do choose to have a BBC licence, the fee is payable per household (like the existing system of domestic rating), not per head (or &bquo;poll&equo;) of the adult population. 
 The only common feature is that the level of each is fixed, and bears no relationship to the means of the payer. 
 Letter: Electoral reform 
 From Mr KIERAN SEALE 
 Sir: Roy Hattersley says that he is against electoral reform as it would stop the Labour Party winning an overall majority. 
 Besides, he says, the Democrats and the Greens only support it because of self interest. 
 I wonder if there is some contradiction here. 
 The party's just begun for Democrats in New Jersey: New Jersey used to be the butt of TV comics. 
 Now, in an election year, Leonard Doyle writes, it is finding new respect 
 By LEONARD DOYLE 
 THE MAN with the bulbous nose and large gold pinky ring was determined to have his photograph taken with Congressman Jim Florio. 
 Elbowing his way through the crowd at the &bquo;colonial streetfair&equo; inside the Loews Glenpointe Hotel, he said that having paid &dollar;500 to get in, he wasn't about to leave without being photographed with the next governor of New Jersey. 
 Candidate Florio and his blonde wife, Lucinda, had no choice but to pose with the property developer from the Jersey waterfront before moving on past three mediocre belly-dancers, a man (on stilts) dressed up as Abraham Lincoln and an actor dressed up as Rip Van Winkle. 
 The Florios worked the room with ease and self-confidence and by the time they had reached the podium an aide to the candidate was saying that almost a million dollars had already been raised for the Democratic campaign. 
 On the platform, Mr Florio asked the party faithful not to become too complacent. 
 &bquo;To quote the famous American philosopher Yogi Berra (of baseball fame),&equo; he said, &bquo;It ain't over till it's over.&equo; 
 With less than a month left before the 7 November election and opinion polls showing that he leads his Republican opponent, Congressman Jim Courter, by between 14 and 23 points, the race for governor of New Jersey is attracting intense national interest. 
 Traditionally a Democratic state, New Jersey has been under broad Republican control since Ronald Reagan defeated Jimmy Carter in 1980 and Governor Thomas Kean narrowly defeated Mr Florio in 1981. 
 Thanks to an economic boom which started in the Reagan era, New Jersey has started to shed its hackneyed image as the home of toxic dumps and second-class citizens. 
 Once looked upon as a valley of humility between two mountains of conceit &mdash; New York City and Philadelphia &mdash; the Garden State now has a much sharper image to present to the world. 
 This year, with the Democrats poised to win the state, the national leadership is looking to see whether the same tactics can be used to turn back the tide on the Republicans nationwide. 
 Mr Florio's formula has been to embrace those Republican policies which brought economic growth to the state during the Reagan years, while sharply attacking the Republicans' conservative stand on social and environmental issues. 
 He contends that economic prosperity has given the voters the opportunity to choose on issues like abortion and the environment. 
 To a large extent, the election has been fought on the airwaves, with both candidates delivering television advertisements attacking each other. 
 Because New Jersey does not have its own television station, or even a state newspaper, the candidates have bought expensive air time on the New York City-based stations and in Mr Florio's case, they seem to be working. 
 The Republicans placed an advertisement making a link between Mr Florio and the Mafia, which the Democrats have countered with ads referring to Mr Courter as a liar and showing his nose getting longer &mdash; Pinocchio-style - as he speaks. 
 The Republican advertisement shows Angelo Errichett, the Mayor of Camden &mdash; which is in Mr Florio's district &mdash; being dragged off to jail after his conviction for corruption. 
 &bquo;Joisey&equo; is still the butt of jokes made by New York sophisticates, but its political leaders, like the outgoing Governor Kean, now have national stature and have taken the lead in forming social policy for the rest of America on welfare reform, school financing, public housing and care of the environment. 
 Almost a million new jobs have come to the state since 1990, many in pharmaceuticals and electronics, making up for the 1,000 jobs a month which have been lost in mature heavy industries. 
 The state has a population of 7.6 million, making it the most densely populated in the union. 
 Bush gave approval for a plan to hold Noriega 
 From PETER PRINGLE in Washington 
 AS THE post-mortem into the failed coup in Panama continued yesterday, it emerged that President Bush had approved an order to the US commander in the Canal Zone to remove General Manuel Noriega using covert forces, but the coup fizzled out before the order could be executed. 
 The debate is now focused on what the United States will do next time, if anything, to fulfil its declared policy of getting rid of General Noriega and avoid an image of timidity and indecisiveness when the chance comes. 
 In a television interview, James Baker, the Secretary of State, said the Panama commander, General Maxwell Thurman, had been sent an order last Tuesday morning, the day of the coup, requiring him to seize General Noriega if there were an opportunity to do so &bquo;without risking American life and without open military involvement, then he was free to go ahead&equo;. 
 The order was, in effect, an authorisation to plan a seizure, not to carry it out. 
 General Thurman still had to receive a final green light from the president once he had worked out a plan. 
 By early Tuesday afternoon, however, pro-Noriega forces had arrived at the military command headquarters, where General Noriega was apparently being held, and the rebels surrendered. 
 The &bquo;fog of war&equo; &mdash; a phrase used by several administration officials to explain the confusion in the Panamanian command post &mdash; had prevented any clear view that an attempt to seize General Noreiga would succeed. 
 As the details of the US involvement are revealed, the administration is coming under fire from normally dovish Democrats on Capitol Hill for not acting swiftly and decisively enough to take advantage of the opportunity to end General Noriega's rule. 
 In their defence, administration officials reply that if they had used more force &mdash; for example, to block a third road used by Noriega's reinforcements -there would have been an unacceptable risk to American troops and Panamanian civilians. 
 &bquo;You do not commit American lives on somebody else's time frame, somebody else's plan and somebody else's schedule,&equo; said Mr Baker. 
 But he said that does not mean the administration has ruled out the use of force in future efforts to oust the general. 
 As far as the administration is concerned, the debate over what to do next is governed to a large extent by what the American people say they are prepared to sacrifice to force General Noriega to retire or return to the United States to answer drug trafficking charges. 
 The polls show that about 70 per cent of American troops do not want to risk the lives of American troops to achieve such goals. 
 On the other hand, the administration is also fighting the return of the president's &bquo;wimp&equo; image, which is being revived by the criticism from Capitol Hill. 
 Argentina: Menem attacked on amnesty decision 
 By COLIN HARDING 
 PRESIDENT Carlos Menem's decision to pardon more than 200 military officers accused of human rights abuses, together with the members of the junta responsible for the conduct of the Falklands war in 1982, has been attacked by human rights campaigners and political opponents. 
 Rene de Epelbaum, a leader of the Mothers of the Plaza de Mayo, said the pardon &bquo;mocks justice&hellip; 
 It is a real moral aberration that leaves at liberty those who violated human dignity and those who rose up against the constitutional order.&equo; 
 Facundo Suarez Lastra of the opposition Radical party said: &bquo;Menem has betrayed the people and his own mandate.&equo; 
 More than 100,000 human rights supporters staged a rally last month to urge President Menem not to issue a pardon. 
 But he insisted it was the best way to banish the bitterness of the recent past. 
 &bquo;I know there will be those who are unhappy&hellip; but I am also convinced that millions of Argentines are applauding this measure,&equo; he said at the weekend. 
 Included in the pardon were General Leopoldo Galtieri, the former army commander and president, and 38 other officers who faced trial over the disappearance and presumed execution of almost 9,000 people during the 1976-83 military regime. 
 General Galtieri was also pardoned for misconduct of the Falklands war, along with his fellow junta members, Admiral Jorge Anaya and the air force chief, Brigadier Basilio Lami Dozo. 
 More than 160 officers who rebelled against President Menem's predecessor, Raul Alfonsin, were also pardoned, notably Lieutenant-Colonel Aldo Rico and Colonel Mohamed Ali Seineldin, who led revolts in 1987 and 1988. 
 Pardons went also to 64 left-wing guerrillas, but not to Mario Firmenich, founder of the Peronist guerrilla group, Montoneros, who is serving 30 years for murder. 
 FMLN guerillas in San Salvador 
 By COLIN HARDING 
 Wounded FMLN guerrillas in San Salvador board a plane, believed to be bound for Chile, after they were evacuated from the Mexican Embassy, which they occupied to demand safe passage  
 Drug lords' offer 
 By COLIN HARDING 
 BOGOTA (Reuter) &mdash; The Colombian government said it had rejected an offer last year from drug traffickers to give up the drug trade in exchange for not being extradited to the US, and firmly ruled out any dialogue with the traffickers. 
 Supplies stopped 
 By COLIN HARDING 
 MOSCOW (AP) &mdash; Azerbaijani rail workers defied a ban on transport strikes and again stemmed the flow of supplies into Armenia. 
 Reports conflicted on how much of the desperately needed food, fuel and building supplies were reaching Armenia. 
 &bquo;Our drivers are striking and demanding guarantees of their safety,&equo; after gunfire and stone attacks on several trains in Armenia, an Azerbaijani activist said. 
 Nuns still there 
 By COLIN HARDING 
 WARSAW (Reuter) &mdash; Carmelite nuns denied a report that they had moved out of a convent at the former Nazi death camp of Auschwitz which has caused a row between Roman Catholics and Jews. 
 &bquo;All 14 of us are still here. 
 We are waiting just as you are, as the whole world is waiting,&equo; a spokeswoman at the convent said. 
 Pope's Korea trip 
 By COLIN HARDING 
 SEOUL (AFP) &mdash; Pope John Paul II urged South Korea to work for the reunification of the Korean Peninsula peacefully and told the President, Roh Tae Woo, that the division symbolised suffering. 
 He told some 600,000 people at a mass that he wanted to visit China, where millions of Catholics are believed to belong to an underground Church. 
 Greek elections appear imminent 
 By PETER THOMPSON 
 ATHENS &mdash; Greece's interim government, headed by the conservative New Democracy backbencher, Tzannis Tzannetakis, resigned after three months in office, writes Peter Thompson. 
 Mr Tzannetakis was asked to stay on until the appointment of a caretaker administration under a senior law officer later this week, to hold new elections on 5 November. 
 The President must offer the three main party leaders in turn a three-day mandate to try to form another government based on the present parliament. 
 This is a formality, however, since two parties &mdash; New Democracy and the Communist-dominated Coalition of the Left &mdash; have refused to use their mandate. 
 Andreas Papandreou, leader of the socialists (Pasok) and former prime minister, is unlikely to win the support he would need &mdash; ruling out any course other than immediate elections. 
 Latvians vote for statehood 
 By PETER THOMPSON 
 RIGA (Reuter) &mdash; Latvia's mass Popular Front movement yesterday approved an ambitious plan for independent statehood in the biggest challenge so far to Moscow from the restive Baltic republics. 
 The 1,152 voting delegates to the Front's second congress approved a carefully worded programme for transition to a free, multi-party state. 
 &bquo;We now have the backbone of the programme,&equo; said a Front spokesman. 
 &bquo;We are still speaking about a transition period, and our most important tasks is to shorten that transition&equo;. 
 Other delegates said they would take economic and political measures to achieve their final aim, including forming independent economic ties with other Soviet republics. 
 Out of Angola: Market socialism on the edge of a rubbish dump 
 By KARL MAIER 
 LUANDA &mdash; A small crowd rocks with laughter as a uniformed soldier, his eyes nearly closed in a drunken Saturday afternoon stupor, writhes body to body in a snake-like dance with a plump young woman in a tight blue dress. 
 Smoke from a row of barbecues mixes with the dust of perhaps 15,000 people shuffling along the wooden stalls to shop for meat, antibiotics, the latest fashions, even, it is said, used cars. 
 There is plenty of ice-cold beer, soft drinks and grilled chicken sandwiches. 
 There would be nothing particularly remarkable about this scene in most African countries, where open air markets are an age-old tradition. 
 But Rock Santeiro, which takes its name from a steamy Brazilian TV soap opera that delighted viewers throughout Portugal's former African colonies, sits on a rubbish dump on the northern edge of Luanda, the capital of Angola. 
 And in Angola, ruled since independence in 1975 by the Marxist Popular Movement for the Liberation of Angola (MPLA), such free markets are illegal, officially anyway. 
 Many visitors to Luanda leave with the image of a dead city, where large glass windows in state-run shops reveal mostly empty shelves, where sewage too often runs through the streets &mdash; there's a cholera epidemic now &mdash; where the state has had to hire a private firm which imported Filipino lorry drivers to clean up a decade's worth of rubbish. 
 (They have not yet succeeded.) 
 The 14-year-old civil war between the government and Jonas Savimbi's Unita rebels has brought about the collapse of the oil-rich Angolan economy, the story goes, and turned Luanda, once called the Rio de Janeiro of Africa, into one of the continent's dirtiest capitals. 
 The &bquo;programmes&equo; put together for visits organised by President Jose Eduardo dos Santos' government rarely include stops at the &bquo;Candonga&equo;, or parallel market, whose high prices have fostered such names as Tira Bikini (take off your underwear) or Cala Boca (shut up). 
 But ask state workers where they buy their new outfits, be it of traditional African cloth or stylish jeans, and the answer is likely to be Rock Santeiro. 
 Nice clothes can also be had at the dollar stores run by the Cubans and the Bulgarians, whose recent low price sales have angered Angolan higher-ups. 
 There is an invisible frontier just a mile or so on the road north out of Luanda, but it is more of a feeling than anything else. 
 The run-down villas and cement footpaths give way to dusty tracks and wooden shacks. 
 Portuguese, spoken officially, fades into Kikongo, Kibundu and other African languages which finally all mix together into Angolan slang. 
 A young girl selling sugar doughnuts on a street corner is symbolic of the threshold, where one of Angola's economies, the official, meets the other, the parallel. 
 Her freshly baked treat goes for 100 Kwanzas, about &pound;2 at the legal exchange rate but just two pence on the open market. 
 The Angolan government, increasingly looking to free market policies to revive the economy, last month joined the International Monetary Fund in Washington, and says, as it has for the past three years, that a devaluation of the Kwanza and the lifting of controls on many goods is imminent. 
 Markets like Rock Santeiro did it long ago. 
 The huge difference between the official and parallel market prices makes a nightmare out of the monthly shopping budget. 
 A modest pile of six or seven tomatoes costs about &pound;10 or ten pence depending on your calculation, while a pound of meat easily wipes out a month's salary. 
 But salaries are largely irrelevant in Angola, because there is so much money and so few things to buy. 
 Most families rely on income earned outside their job. 
 For many, the scramble for enough cash to afford the free market prices inevitably leads back to the state shops, and specifically to beer. 
 The government ration card system allows an urban family to buy a case of imported beer for about 400 Kwanza. 
 They can be sold immediately on the open market for 24,000 Kwanza, the equivalent of a month's salary for a middle level civil servant. 
 One engineer uses his truck as an illegal taxi, known as a &bquo;proceso 500,&equo; and earns 80,000 Kwanza, To stem the flow of MPLA party workers, state employees, and professionals to the private sector and foreign aid groups, the government introduced a system of cards, lettered A, B or C, which provide bearers with privileged access to imported goods. 
 The special cards are expected to be phased out once the long-anticipated economic reforms begin. 
 But until they do, for state and party functionaries, the cards remain the ABC of Angolan socialism. 
 Curbs sought on laundering: World experts meet today to find ways to hit drug traffickers where it hurts &mdash; in their pockets, writes John Eisenhammer. 
 By JOHN EISENHAMMER 
 FAR FROM the drama of special agents in helicopters swooping over remote Colombian mountainsides, experts from the world's richest countries meet in Paris today to improve what many consider to be the most effective means of combating the drugs trade &mdash; hitting the traffickers' pockets. 
 The illicit drugs industry has a turnover of some &pound;200bn annually. 
 The economies of the poor producing countries, such as Colombia or Pakistan, are too small to absorb such sums. 
 So they have to find their way into the international financial system, where they can be given a veneer of legality. 
 The business of turning &bquo;hot&equo; money into legitimate tender is as old as crime itself, but it is only in recent years, largely because of the explosion of the drugs trade, that money laundering has become such a huge business. 
 &bquo;A few years ago few officials spoke about it,&equo; says Professor Lutz Krauskopf, the president of the Swiss committee on special legislation on money laundering. 
 &bquo;It has become the number one crime in Europe.&equo; 
 Professor Krauskopf will be Switzerland's legal expert at the Paris conference, called by the seven richest industrial nations at their summit in June. 
 They decided that, in addition to the traditional, and largely vain, efforts to curb drug production, there is an urgent need to step up the offensive from the other end of the drugs trail. 
 &bquo;Fighting the money launderers is the most effective means we have,&equo; says a senior British specialist. 
 &bquo;The confiscation of proceeds from drugs crimes makes it difficult for traffickers to salt away their funds, do time and come out to the high life.&equo; 
 Once a sizeable sum has been accumulated from street deals, this illegal cash has somehow to be &bquo;made legal&equo; by slipping it into the banking system. 
 In countries where deposits above a certain amount have to be authorised, such as those over &dollar;10,000 (&pound;6,250) in the United States, this entails a team of flunkeys making numerous lower deposits which are then switched around at will. 
 Alternatively, a courier will smuggle often millions of pounds at a time to a country where banking secrecy offers greater protection. 
 With their teams of lawyers, accountants and company agents, and able to transfer money at the push of a computer button, the launderers dodge through the maze of the different countries' jurisdictions creating a trail so complex that investigators, never mind the banks, find it almost impossible to spot what is going on. 
 The British government led the way in Europe with its tough Drug Trafficking Offences Act in 1986. 
 This gave wide investigative powers, and made possible the seizing, freezing and confiscation of assets. 
 On conviction, the court has to set a value on the drug assets earned during the previous six years, and a confiscation order. 
 In a reversal of normal legal practice, this money is assumed to have been illegally earned, unless the trafficker can prove otherwise. 
 &bquo;But the nature of the drugs trade, and financial markets, is such that one country alone can do little,&equo; says Detective Chief Inspector Gus Jones of Scotland Yard's National Drugs Intelligence Unit. 
 &bquo;The only agreement that is really working is the one with the Americans, and that was signed 18 months ago. 
 The whole process takes so long. 
 But until the international co-operation is there, with similar powers, and sufficient resources, it's very difficult.&equo; 
 This will be one of the main tasks facing the Paris meeting. 
 EC split on how to collect VAT 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Brussels 
 IT IS about as impenetrable as any dispute in the European Community can get, but it threatens either to seriously weaken the edifice of &bquo;Project 1992&equo; or at least to bury businessmen under a landslide of new paperwork. 
 At issue is one small, but key part of the European Commission's plan for an alignment of Value Added Tax (VAT) and Excise rates in the 12 member states, which it considers essential if frontier checks on traders are to be abolished after 1992. 
 The area of dispute, which promises to occupy all of a meeting of EC finance ministers in Luxembourg today, is over the Commission's proposal that the current system of exporting goods free of VAT be abandoned and that after 1992 the tax should be levied in the country of origin before export. 
 Such a change would entail the creation of a clearing house, presumably in Brussels, whose job would be to reapportion VAT receipts to ensure that revenue is accrued as now in the country of consumption rather than production. 
 The member states have, however, come out in almost unanimous opposition to such a change, arguing, in a paper prepared for today's meeting by national treasury officials, that it is too cumbersome and bureaucratic (although an unwillingness to cede fiscal control to Brussels is probably more relevant). 
 The counter-proposal is that zero-rating of exports should remain, but that traders would be obliged to list every item exported for spot-inspection by customs officers. 
 This, it argues, would minimise the risk of fraud that open borders would generate. 
 Without border checks, traders may be tempted to claim exemption from VAT on goods ostensibly destined for export but which, in fact, never leave the country or are reimported. 
 At a meeting of the European Commission last week, the Commissioner for tax, France's Christiane Scrivener, shocked her colleagues by suggesting that the member states' case may prove overwhelming or at least that the system as first proposed should be put back until 1995. 
 Thus the sacrosanct date of 1992 would be effectively abandoned. 
 Mrs Scrivener was sharply rebuked, not least by the Commission President, Jacques Delors, and she has been instructed to stand firm against the governments' proposal today and tell ministers to think again. 
 In the view of most Brussels officials, the alternative of making traders list every item bought and sold across borders would be intolerable and undermine the purpose of 1992, which is to make trading between EC countries as simple as possible. 
 The Commission calculates, moreover, that the job of cross-checking between the customs departments of each member state into the validity of traders' declarations would mean an exchange in electronic mail between them of about 20,000 million characters a year. 
 Even with that level of scrutiny, there could be little hope of containing fraud, which is already a serious drain on the EC's coffers and on its reputation. 
 Babangida blocks new political groups 
 By CAMERON DUODU 
 PRESIDENT Ibrahim Babangida of Nigeria has blocked the creation of 13 new political parties. 
 He surprised the nation with the announcement, made in a radio and television broadcast on Saturday night, that his government has refused registration to any of the 13 political associations that applied for it. 
 The president said that the military government itself would organise and finance two parties under a new &bquo;grass roots democratic two-party system&equo;. 
 The two parties created by the government will be called the Social Democratic Party and the National Republican Convention. 
 They would give equal rights and opportunities to all qualified Nigerians to participate in the political process in the run-up to when the military hands over to civilian rule in 1992, the President said. 
 His move appeared certain to inflame passions in a country noted for the frequently intemperate attitude of its people towards party politics. 
 A great deal of money and time had been spent by the 13 political associations in their efforts to win approval from the government-appointed National Electoral Commission (NEC). 
 The Commission had in fact drawn up a short list of six associations, from which the government was expected to select two groups. 
 But the NEC said that all the associations had performed poorly in relation to the criteria it had set for them. 
 They had made exaggerated claims about their membership size, among other shortcomings, the NEC said. 
 Yet it was able to produce a score sheet which showed that out of a possible score of 100, the Peoples Solidarity Party came first with 43.90, followed by the Nigerian National Congress (42.62), the Peoples Front of Nigeria (41.20) and the Liberal Convention (34.08). 
 The Nigerian Labour Party and the Republican Party of Nigeria came bottom with 17 points apiece. 
 Publication of these results had raised an expectation that the two associations which showed the most promise would be accepted for registration. 
 After that it was supposed that the others would merge with them. 
 It came as a shock when President Babangida said the associations were rooted in &bquo;ethnic and religious bigotry&equo; and that all of them would be dissolved forthwith. 
 The government would refund registration fees to the associations, the President said. 
 He warned that authorities would not hesitate to take decisive action against any groups or individuals that contemplated a disturbance of the peace. 
 Hussein hints at more freedom 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Amman 
 KING HUSSEIN of Jordan has promised a parliament with real powers after elections on 8 November, the first for 22 years. 
 But he warned against the exploitation of religion for extremist political ends. 
 &bquo;The next parliament will not serve merely as a forum for making political statements but rather as a national institute in which we will all take part in formulating the country's policies,&equo; he said on television before leaving on a three-nation tour as part of Middle East peace efforts. 
 &bquo;In the coming stage, we will not suffice ourselves with mere slogans but we will embark on objective and responsible dialogue.&equo; 
 He gave no specific indication of what powers the parliament would have, and he sounded a cautionary note on the abuse of power. 
 &bquo;Both voters and candidates in the coming parliamentary elections in Jordan shoulder a grave responsibility and should therefore seek a true democratic rule based on the tenets of the constitution, avoiding rashness and extremism.&equo; 
 Using religion for political ends, as in Lebanon, had no place in Jordan, he said. 
 It was a stiff, headmasterly performance, appropriate to the handing down from the palace of the kingly rules by which the democratic experiment was to be played. 
 But then, as he pointed out, national experience was limited. 
 No one under the age of 41 has any experience of voting in elections. 
 He explained that elections and the resumption of parliamentary life, suspended after Israel's seizure of the West Bank from Jordanian rule in 1967, were the logical outcome of his decision on 31 July 1988 to sever legal and administrative ties with the West Bank. 
 He made no direct reference to the disturbances in April against the government's economic policies. 
 Instead he summoned up the perennial fears on the East Bank of Israeli destabilisation and denounced what he said were Zionist plots to make Jordan a substitute homeland for the Palestinians. 
 Yesterday, King Hussein arrived in Italy at the start of his foreign trip, during which he will discuss Middle East problems and economic assistance to Jordan. 
 Apart from Italy and Canada, he will also visit Britain. 
 Prisoners of Conscience: Leftists jailed as Pope arrives - Bambang Subono and Isti Nugroho 
 By CAROLINE MOOREHEAD 
 AS THE Pope begins his visit to Indonesia, two young men from Gajah Mada University in Yogyakarta on Java are beginning long prison sentences for subversion. 
 Bambang Subono, a student of political science, and Isti Nugroho, who works in the physics and chemistry laboratory, are charged with spreading leftist ideas and feelings of hostility and dissension in society, and with distributing communist literature and discussing communism at meetings. 
 The announcement of their sentences &mdash; seven and eight years respectively - has precipitated a series of clashes between students and members of the security forces, who were said to have used bayonets. 
 Curbs on free speech &mdash; the banning of books, revocation of newspaper licences and persecution of writers who criticise the government &mdash; is a normal feature of Indonesian political life. 
 Since 1965, when the Communist party of Indonesia was blamed for an attempted coup and banned, and hundreds of thousands of communists were killed or sent to prison, the legal instrument most often used to curb political offences has been the Anti-Subversion Law. 
 The trial of Mr Subono and Mr Nugroho was the first time in many years that the law was used to try &bquo;leftists&equo; rather than Muslim activists. 
 The two men were arrested at a time of increasing student political activism, and a renewed government offensive against the supposed communist threat. 
 The two men were held in military custody, incommunicado, for some time and are believed to have been ill-treated. 
 Visitors report seeing Mr Nugroho covered in bruises and unable to speak. 
 Accounts of their trial suggest that it took the form of a political witch-hunt, with the intention of intimidating other critics of the government. 
 Spanish bishops call for anti-ETA vote 
 From TIM MCGIRK in Madrid 
 CATHOLIC BISHOPS stepped into the Spanish political arena at the weekend by warning Basques not to vote in this month's elections for Herri Batasuna, the legal arm of ETA, the Basque terrorist group. 
 The bishops' caution came after 2,500 Basques marched through San Sebastian on Saturday protesting against ETA's killing of a police officer, Jose Angel Alvarez, father of six. 
 The bishops claimed that a vote for Herri Batasuna in the 29 October general election was &bquo;incompatible with one's moral and Christian conscience&equo;. 
 Opinion polls taken before the bishops' caution show Herri Batasuna &mdash; some of whose candidates are serving long prison sentences for terrorism - winning up to five seats in Cortes, the Spanish parliament. 
 The bishops'intrusion into bloody Basque politics has maddened many priests, according to Inaki Esnaola, a radical lawyer who is Herri Batasuna's candidate for Guipuzcoa province. 
 Mr Esnaola claimed that 200 Basque clergymen publicly support Herri Batasuna's call for greater independence from Madrid and an amnesty for nearly 500 ETA terrorists in jail or exile. 
 But the bishops' warning may harm Herri Batasuna and sober up the many Basques who have persuaded themselves that ETA terrorists are a kind of latter day Knights Templar, wielding car bombs and Uzzis for greater Basque liberty. 
 During the Franco days, the Basque church was the only bastion of dissent against a regime which denied the Basques their ancient language, self-expression, and even prohibited parents from giving their children traditional names like Inaki and Arantxa. 
 A number of ETA's early leaders were once Jesuit seminary students. 
 The terrorist band they formed has, over the past 15 years, claimed more than 550 lives. 
 The Basque troubles are seen by most Spaniards as so tangled that they do not blame the current Socialist government of Felipe Gonzalez for failing to end the strife. 
 A recent poll by El Pais predicts the Socialists will be swept into a third term of office on 29 October by an absolute majority. 
 Mr Gonzalez's party is expected to win 41 percent of the vote, with the conservative Popular Party a distant second at 23 per cent. 
 The poll also shows that the communist-led Leftist Unity party &mdash; capitalising on the high jobless rate and union unrest &mdash; is expected to nearly double its vote from 4.6 percent to 8.7 percent, replacing Adolfo Suarez's centrist party as the third most powerful force in Spanish politics. 
 Ambition spoils French right aim of &bquo;one big party&equo; 
 From PATRICK MARNHAM in Paris 
 MICHEL ROCARD'S Socialist government faces a vote of no confidence today which it is bound to win. 
 The motion has been tabled by the Gaullist Rassemblement pour la Republique (RPR), but neither the liberal Union pour la Democratie Francaise (UDF) nor the centrist Union Democratique du Centre (UDC) will support them. 
 This further sign of disunity among the opposition comes just as the former president, Valery Giscard d'Estaing, who is also the leader of the UDF, has called for a fusion of the seven parties of the centre-right into &bquo;one big party of the centre-right by the beginning of 1992&equo;. 
 Last week the first practical steps towards such a union were taken when leaders of the RPR, UDF and UDC met and agreed to form a tactical group to work out the most effective means of opposing the government. 
 The first decision of this tactical group was not to table a motion of no confidence during the debate on the bill which sets this year's level of defence spending. 
 But within two days the RPR had broken the initial agreement. 
 The agreement had been drawn up by Bernard Pons, the head of the RPR's parliamentary group, but it was opposed by the former prime minister, Jacques Chirac, who is the founder and president of the RPR. 
 Mr Chirac explained that by tradition defence bills are based on a cross-party consensus. 
 Since the socialist government has said that it intends to pass this year's defence bill anyway, it was the duty of the opposition to move a vote of no confidence. 
 Mr Giscard d'Estaing said last week: &bquo;France already has its left-wing governing party. 
 We are still waiting for its opponent on the centre-right. 
 To be effective, a political message should be very simple. 
 Yet the opposition's message is exactly the reverse.&equo; 
 But the real obstacle to any formal union of the centre and right opposition parties is that each of them is formed around the personality and ambitions of an individual politician who considers himself to be papabile or presidentiable. 
 At the moment Mr Chirac, Mr Giscard d'Estaing, Pierre Mehaignerie of the Centre des Democrates Sociaux (CDS) and Giscard's former heir apparent in the UDF, Francois Leotard of the Partie Republicain (PR) all have hopes of the presidency of the republic; hopes which are entirely based on their positions as party or faction leaders. 
 Turin court refuses to try Fiat chiefs 
 From MICHAEL SHERIDAN in Rome 
 A COURT in Turin, the home of Italy's Fiat group, declined at the weekend to try Fiat's chief executive and three senior managers on charges of violating workers' safety statutes, citing fears of an unspecified &bquo;threat to public order&equo;. 
 The decision was greeted by a chorus of outrage from trade unionists, Green party activists and Communist party leaders. 
 The Fiat group is viewed by business as the pre-eminent example of the Italian industrial renaissance. 
 But it is regarded by the Left as a paramount case of arrogant power and political influence above the law. 
 Fiat's defence lawyers hailed the court's move as a sensible conclusion which would leave it to the court of appeal to determine whether the four defendants should be tried in another city. 
 They said the case was prejudiced by a campaign by the Communist party to mount a political attack on Fiat. 
 The decision is likely to postpone a hearing on the charges for many months and it is now thought that the case could eventually be heard in Milan instead of Turin. 
 Armed paramilitary police placed central Turin under a virtual state of siege for the hearing on Saturday morning. 
 It was a show of force which appeared somewhat out of proportion to the 200 or so trade unionists who turned up outside the court. 
 Mr Romiti, the ruthlessly effective chief executive who was their main target, did not present himself in court. 
 After consultations in chambers, the court determined that on a technicality, it was not competent to hear the case. 
 It said that fears for public order would make a hearing undesirable. 
 However, both the Turin police headquarters and the anti-terrorist squad said they knew of no particular cause for alarm and that only normal security measures had been taken. 
 A leading Turin Communist, Diego Novelli, who was mayor of the city for a decade, said: &bquo;We've carried out trials here of the Red Brigades, of (the terrorist group) Prima Linea and of the most dangerous Mafia clans. 
 It seems incredible that we are not able to carry out this one.&equo; 
 Winter arrives in Germany 
 From MICHAEL SHERIDAN in Rome 
 Winter arrived in some parts of West Germany just 15 days after autumn officially began and some areas in the Black Forest and the Alps recorded freezing temperatures and snowfalls 
 The World This Week 
 By COLIN HARDING 
 EUROPEAN COMMUNITY finance ministers meet in Brussels today to seek a way out of the impasse over harmonisation of VAT and excise duty rates which, if unresolved, could make the 1992 single market unworkable. 
 The Commission's proposals have met with virtually unanimous opposition from the 12 member countries, and the commissioner in charge, Christiane Scrivener, has the unenviable task of persuading them to change their minds. 
 On Saturday EC foreign ministers assemble in a chateau near Chartres for an informal weekend during which they will discuss, among other things, the co-ordination of Community policy towards eastern Europe. 
 The 1959 Antarctic Treaty's 15th consultative conference opens in Paris today, to review the accord, which expires in 1991. 
 The 39 signatories will be discussing what to do about growing pressures for development of the continent's resources. 
 They will also be examining the Antarctic Minerals Convention, signed in May 1988, which would have permitted controlled mining and oil exploration. 
 Australia has changed its mind and vetoed the agreement, to the annoyance of the US, the Soviet Union and Japan. 
 Pope John Paul continues his eastern tour this week, arriving in Indonesia today from South Korea. 
 President Suharto has urged his country's five million Catholics to give the Pope a restrained welcome, as befits a tiny minority in the world's most populous Muslim country. 
 The papal itinerary is expected to include the former Portuguese colony of East Timor, annexed by Indonesia in 1976, which has a predominantly Catholic population. 
 The Pope goes on to Mauritius on Saturday. 
 The seventh conference of the 102-nation Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species, which opens in Lausanne today, promises some lively debates, particularly on orchids and ivory. 
 The secretary-general of Cites, Eugene Lapointe, expects the conference to reach a compromise on the ivory trade, stopping short of the total ban opposed by some African countries. 
 As for the flowers, the Dutch delegation will be calling for a total ban on trade in some rare slipper orchids, which they say face extinction in 10 years unless something drastic is done. 
 The presidents of seven Latin American contries (Peru, Argentina, Uruguay, Brazil, Venezuela, Colombia and Mexico) gather on Wednesday in Ica, an oasis in the desert south of Lima, for two days of talks focusing on the foreign debt and drug trafficking. 
 Panama's President Francisco Rodriguez should have been there, too (it is a Group of Eight meeting, after all), but his country is in the doghouse because of the controversial behaviour of his boss, General Manuel Noriega. 
 President Alan Garcia will take the opportunity to host a mini-summit on drug policy with the leaders of the other two big cocaine-producing countries, Virgilio Barco of Colombia and Jaime Paz Zamora of Bolivia. 
 Security will be tight: Peru's Maoist guerrillas, Sendero Luminoso, expressed their disapproval of the whole business by setting off a number of bombs in Ica last week and murdering the wife of the rector of the local university. 
 The Norwegian parliament reassembles on Wednesday, and on Friday the Prime Minister, Gro Harlem Brundtland, and her cabinet will present their resignations, to forestall a vote of no confidence. 
 Jan P. Syse, the Conservative Party leader, will then put together a centre-right coalition government. 
 Space shuttle Atlantis is due to be launched from Cape Canaveral, Florida, on Thursday. 
 The main job for its five-man crew will be to send the nuclear-powered Galileo space probe on its way to Jupiter, where it should arrive in 1995. 
 The Chinese Vice-Premier, Wu Xueqian, arrives in India on Thursday for talks with the Prime Minister, Rajiv Gandhi, and Indian ministers. 
 Mr Wu is the most senior Chinese official to visit India since June 1981. 
 The main item on the agenda will be reduction of troop numbers along the two countries' common border. 
 The Governor of Hong Kong, Sir David Wilson, arrives in Washington on Saturday for a week-long visit, to meet members of the administration and congressional leaders. 
 The problem of what to do with the 55,000 Vietnamese boat people in Hong Kong detention centres will figure prominently in the talks. 
 Sir David feels there is no alternative to some form of forced repatriation, while the US is resolutely opposed to such a solution. 
 There is a big batch of Nobel prize announcements coming up this week: medicine today, economics on Wednesday and physics and chemistry on Thursday, all in Stockholm. 
 The Queen begins a state visit to Malaysia on Saturday, and will open the Commonwealth Heads of Government meeting on the following Tuesday. 
 Her visit sets the seal on the improved relations between Britain and Malaysia, following a period of extreme coolness. 
 East Germany's protesters face violence of state 
 From STEVE CRAWSHAW in East Berlin 
 THE HARDLINE leadership in East Germany is today under greater pressure than ever following the weekend demonstrations in East Berlin &mdash; the biggest show of social unrest in the East German capital since the doomed workers' uprising of June 1953. 
 The protests, which were overwhelmingly peaceful except for persistent violence by uniformed and plainclothes police, began late on Saturday afternoon, and the ironies were plentiful. 
 Even as they began, the chief Soviet spokesman, Gennady Gerasimov, was insisting that change was necessary: &bquo;Those who delay will be punished by life itself.&equo; 
 Mikhail Gorbachev avoided touching sensitive nerves during his Berlin visit, though he, too, hinted at the need for change. 
 The crowds who gathered on Alexanderplatz and then moved off on a winding trail through East Berlin were in any case convinced he was their man. 
 &bquo;Gorby! 
 Gorby!&equo; was a persistent cry of the demonstrators, who at one stage numbered more than 5,000. 
 Police sealed off central East Berlin and tried to disperse the crowds. 
 The crowds in turn shouted &bquo;no violence!&equo; and put their hands above their heads, as if daring the Volkspolizei, the people's police, and the plainclothes men, the Stasis, to beat them. 
 &bquo;Who do you want to protect?&equo; they asked, and: &bquo;We are the people.&equo; 
 The plainclothed Stasis &mdash; mostly dull-faced youths in windcheaters &mdash; formed snatch squads and, with uniformed colleagues, kicked and beat demonstrators. 
 On at least one occasion, demonstrators were pinned against the wall to make it easier to assault them. 
 Busloads of Stasis were disgorged into the crowd. 
 Many arrests were made. 
 The timing of the demonstration, on the very day of the 40th anniversary of the founding of the East German state, gained an inescapable symbolism. 
 At one point, the official, irrelevant, birthday fireworks lit up the marching protesters, to the accompaniment of deafening explosions. 
 Some sang a mocking version of Happy Birthday. 
 One old man hauled into a police van declared: &bquo;They've invited us to the birthday celebrations, don't you see!&equo; 
 The marchers chanted to those watching from balconies: &bquo;Come down into the streets!&equo; 
 Some on the balconies waved, some came down, to cheers. 
 People at ground floor windows offered soft drinks. 
 When the marchers passed the city's overhead railway, two trains hooted in solidarity, to the crowd's delight. 
 There were calls for political detainees to be freed and chants in support of the new opposition group, New Forum. 
 Another call &mdash; sometimes from those who had just sung the Internationale &mdash; was: &bquo;Freedom &mdash; the West!&equo; 
 Eric Honecker, the country's ageing and inflexible leader, must know that Saturday night's demonstrations seem certain to be but a foretaste of what is to come. 
 For the moment, the ever more active opposition remains dominated by intellectuals; it has hardly succeeded in joining hands with the workers. 
 If that happens &mdash; as it did in Poland after 1976, paving the way for Solidarity's triumph in 1980 &mdash; then the regime's days will seem numbered. 
 Bonn speaks of &bquo;deep dismay&equo; over clashes 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 THE WEST GERMAN government yesterday expressed &bquo;great concern and deep dismay&equo; at police violence against East Germans demonstrating for reform at the weekend. 
 It urged the East German leadership to respond to demands for freedom &bquo;not with the police but with understanding and open-mindedness&equo;. 
 The &bquo;oppressive&equo; police violence, arrests and the jamming of a West Berlin radio station had thrown &bquo;further heavy shadows&equo; over East Germany's 40th anniversary, the deputy government spokesman, Dieter Vogel, said. 
 At the same time West German leaders renewed their pressure on the East German regime to follow Mikhail Gorbachev's advice and bring in glasnost and perestroika. 
 They again offered strong economic backing for reforms. 
 Dorothea Wilms, minister for intra-German affairs, and Oscar Lafontaine, Social Democrat prime minister of the Saarland ventured to hope that there would soon be changes in East Germany despite the fact that its leader, had not shown the slightest inclination to budge during the 40th anniversary celebrations and talks with the Soviet president. 
 Hundreds of Western tourists were again turned away at crossing points in the Berlin Wall yesterday as East Berlin remained sealed off to all but those with regular visas for the fourth day running. 
 The authorities evidently feared that Westerners would reinforce protest demonstrators in the city. 
 A large and angry group of people hurled beer bottles and cans at East German border guards at the Checkpoint Charlie crossing point on Saturday and tore down parts of a newly metal fence in protest. 
 No-one was hurt but one man was detained by West German police for identification. 
 The flow of East German refugees swelled during the 24 hours to Sunday morning from the normal 500-600 to 1,184, bringing the number who have taken that route since Hungary opened its borders on 11 September to 35,000. 
 A further 300 have taken refuge with the West German embassy in Warsaw and, although the East German-Czechoslovak border is virtually sealed off and the West German embassy in Prague is surrounded by police who turn would-be refugees away, 30 more have managed to get inside the building. 
 Rudolf Seiters, head of the West German chancellery, who played a big role in the deals to ship more than 14,000 from Warsaw and Prague to the West in special trains, said he was confident a solution will be found for them too. 
 Earlier, Mr Vogel said Mr Honecker's speech on Saturday must have disappointed reformists in East Germany. 
 &bquo;One could discern no forward-looking political thinking, nor any willingness even to contemplate reform.&equo; 
 President Gorbachev, he said, had &bquo;spoken clear words very cautiously. 
 Whether the (East German Communist) leadership will draw the consequences remains to be seen.&equo; 
 Mr Seiters said Mr Honecker's speech was an &bquo;oppressive contrast&equo; to the challenge posed him by the recent exodus and the upsurge of demands in East Germany for reform. 
 East Germany must change course it if it is to stop the haemorrhage of its own people, he said, and renewed Bonn's offer of financial assistance for reforms. 
 Volker Ruhe, secretary-general of the ruling Christian Democrat party, said West German aid should include projects to improve East Germany's consumer goods industries and to develop its environment technology. 
 West Germany's opposition Social Democrats yesterday cautiously welcomed the formation of an East German Social Democrat party, the first actual political party to emerge from the present ferment for reform. 
 The caution was prompted by a desire not to seem anxious to dominate the fledgeling party. 
 &bquo;It is not for us to steer these people or act on their behalf&equo;, said the SPD spokesman Eduard Heussen. 
 &bquo;But we declare our solidarity with them.&equo; 
 The Social Democrat party, banned by the Nazis in 1933, returned to life for only one year after the war in what was then the Soviet-occupied zone of Germany. 
 In 1946 it was forcibly merged with the Communist Party into what was, and is, called the Socialist Unity Party (SED). 
 The Social Democrats found themselves without influence inside a hard-line Stalinist party. 
 East Berlin prays for deliverance from evil 
 From EDWARD STEEN in East Berlin 
 AROUND the dire brick pile which is Gethsemane Church lurk malevolent-looking plainclothes policemen dressed in uniform windcheaters. 
 By the door, in the middle of the working class district of Prenzlauer Berg, a mess of candles flutter. 
 This is the church which has been the centre of opposition in East Berlin for the past few weeks. 
 There is a vast hand-painted banner strung across the aisle demanding freedom for those arrested. 
 The sermon yesterday was truly politically charged. 
 But this remains a deeply spiritual place, in the crisp, sober Lutheran mode. 
 Pastor Berndt Albani began his sermon: &bquo;How will it continue, today and in the next days? 
 The sun has chased away the shadows of the night, but what, when it is night again?&equo; 
 His theme was Christ's defiance of the Pharisees and his view that the sabbath was made for man, not man for the sabbath. 
 The Pharisees, said the young, prematurely grey-haired pastor, had been &bquo;prisoners of their own system, they walled themselves in&equo;. 
 They had come to expect nothing from a disenfranchised people except violence and anarchy. 
 Christ, he said, had openly defied &bquo;the unholy alliance of the keepers of tradition and the power apparat&equo;. 
 His teaching was a challenge to Christians, more radical than it seemed: &bquo;The state is there for man, not the other way round, the socialist order is there for man, not the other way round.&equo; 
 For the first and only time, the audience applauded. 
 Pastor Albani urged his congregation to follow Christ's way of non-violence: &bquo;We must try not to be another lot of historical victors&hellip; hold to God's word and love your neighbour as yourself.&equo; 
 The congregation &mdash; perhaps 400 people, from outrageous punks to young women with babies &mdash; prayed with him &bquo;to free us from the temptation of power, the temptation of violence &mdash; remove us from the barriers of ideology.&equo; 
 He finished the service by announcing tersely that some of the large number of people jailed during the night had been released. 
 There were no figures. 
 Later in the day security forces stormed a candlelight protest march, beating young people who called for peaceful change. 
 Security police snatched away members of the 1,000-strong march and beat them about the head with truncheons as the crowd chanted &bquo;No violence&equo; and &bquo;We're staying here&equo;. 
 When the police and security forces ordered the protesters to leave a wide street near the Gethsemane Church they drowned out the order by chanting &bquo;We are the people! 
 We are the people!&equo; 
 Security forces surrounded the area and ordered the 3,000 people gathered at the church to leave. 
 Many but not all did. 
 Fundamentalists and reformers haggle in Budapest 
 From IMRE KARACS in Budapest 
 SUFFERING from hangovers after their intoxicating victory on Saturday night, Hungarian reformers and their temporary allies were split last night on the question of where the new Socialist Party should pick up the pieces, as a marginal hardline faction announced the foundation of the Hungarian Communist Party. 
 Members of the Reform Alliance and the Peoples Democracy Platform emerged from separate caucus meetings unable to decide what should be changed in the manifesto drafted by Imre Pozsgay. 
 Many reformers also complained that the new party's founding document, adopted on Saturday by an 80 per cent majority, did not go far enough. 
 They had wanted an outright victory leading to the expulsion of all &bquo;fundamentalists&equo;, whereas the document allows everyone to join the new party. 
 &bquo;Everyone appears to be a reformist,&equo; Peter Medgyessy, the deputy prime minister, said bitterly. 
 Because of the &bquo;unconvincing nature&equo; of the compromise, he could not make up his mind whether he should apply for membership. 
 Having failed to sanction expulsions, reformers were trying to drive out their opponents by personal insults, directed mostly at Karoly Grosz, the General Secretary, and Janos Berecz, the former conservative ideology chief. 
 Mr Grosz said that he would remain &bquo;active in the movement&equo; but would not be standing for any elected post. 
 He was one of the 159 delegates out of 1,202 who voted on Saturday against the name change. 
 Mr Berecz, on the other hand, has still not given up his seemingly futile struggle, and has been plaguing the congress with constant interruptions. 
 He even managed to delay the founding declarations on Saturday, despite being whistled and booed from the hall. 
 Last night, he told Hungarian television, that he would go with the majority of party members, and leave the party if the majority so decided. 
 The Peoples Democracy Platform, the reformers' ally, wants to avoid a major split at all costs and are trying desperately to prevent a purge. 
 They are also accusing Mr Pozsgay's supporters of trying to go too far too fast, and of constantly raising the stakes. 
 The Reform Alliance announced that on top of the agreed agenda, they wanted congress to make a decision on four issues. 
 These are the establishment of an ethical committee which would weed out corrupt party officials, the disbanding of the notorious workers guard, a declaration that the new party would hand back to the nation a substantial chunk of the old party loot, and a resolution calling on all parties, including their own, to withdraw from workplaces. 
 If they succeed, they will give up the last vestiges of the party state and refute the criticisms that they are only interested in the power and money accumulated by the Communists over the past 40 years, without accepting any blame for their actions. 
 This, however, will not be tolerated even by those who call themselves the centre, and a major split will become unavoidable. 
 So far, only a lunatic fringe, led by Roland Antoniewicz, a Polish-born admirer of the North Korean dictator, Kim Il-Sung, have joined the new Communist Party. 
 As delegates continued their debate over the new manifesto and statutes late into the night, the arithmetic in the hall began to show a slight drop in the reformist support, while numbers of the popular democracy platform doubled to more than 200. 
 That leaves about 500 delegates who are still undecided, and whose views have so far been ignored. 
 At the leadership elections expected today, it is their votes that will determine the outcome. 
 Hungary drops the &bquo;workers&equo;: Imre Karacs in Budapest looks at what a change of name and newspaper means for the Hungarian Socialist Workers Party 
 By IMRE KARACS 
 DESIGNER SOCIALISM arrived in Hungary at 17 minutes past eight on Saturday night, when delegates to the ruling Hungarian Socialist Workers' Party congress voted overwhelmingly to drop &bquo;Workers&equo; from their title. 
 As the strains of the national anthem filled the hall, the editors of the party's daily, Nepszabadsag, pulled out of the drawer a new, redesigned front page. 
 The masthead still carried the same title, meaning &bquo;People's Freedom&equo; but the phrase &bquo;Workers of the world unite&equo; had been dropped. 
 Naturally, the words &bquo;Central daily of the Hungarian Social Workers&equo; Party' also had to give way to a much simpler phrase: &bquo;Socialist Daily&equo;. 
 At a news conference on Saturday night, the party's spokesmen indicated that many other symbols would also have to be replaced before the coming presidential and parliamentary elections. 
 The red star would probably be replaced by a red rose, the huge portrait of Lenin at headquarters might be taken down. 
 But the declaration issued by the congress left no doubt that the decision was intended to be more than a mere facelift: &bquo;The present concept of socialism, the Stalinist system, has exhausted all its social, economic, political and moral reserves, and has proved unsuitable for keeping pace with global developments. 
 Thus the history of the HSWP as a state party has come to an end.&equo; 
 To sidestep any arguments about who should inherit the party's vast fortunes if a split occurs, the delegates declared themselves to be the legal heirs of the HSWP, whilst dissociating themselves from the old party's &bquo;crimes, false and mistaken principles and methods&equo;. 
 The founding document states that members of the old party will not automatically receive their new cards. 
 They will all have to apply and sign the HSP's statutes and programme. 
 Local cells of the new party will be formed by 10 November, but what happens to the rest of the apparat is at the moment anybody's guess. 
 Hungarian radio, always trying to be even-handed in the new climate of pluralism, introduced the HSP as the &bquo;old-new party&equo; in yesterday's bulletin. 
 Ordinary Hungarians were also sceptical of events at Budapest's Novotel Hotel where the congress is being held. 
 Saturday's name change was the sixth this century, and the previous alterations did not necessarily lead to a radical renewal. 
 The name discarded at the weekend was invented during the 1956 uprising as a gesture of total break with the Stalinist past. 
 The HSWP's leadership then proceeded to liquidate, with the help of Soviet tanks, the &bquo;opportunists and revisionists&equo; within its ranks, including Imre Nagy, the Prime Minister. 
 But as workers were busily removing the offending logo from the congress hall yesterday, there were many signs that the change this time would be more than superficial. 
 As a panicked organiser confided on the first day: &bquo;There is complete chaos here, everyone is allowed to speak.&equo; 
 The delegates have also been allowed, for the first time in a communist party's history since Stalin, to set up factions. 
 The substantive work has consequently shifted from the party headquarters, where all decisions used to be made, to the conference hall and the corridors. 
 Deals between the two biggest factions, the Reform Alliance and the People's Democracy Platform, are struck in the open, in the congress hall buffets. 
 Coups are plotted in small groups huddled around a faction leader and strategies decided at fringe meetings. 
 It is rather like a Labour Party conference, without the block vote. 
 Here every delegate vote counts equally, and they are increasingly waking up to the power of the voting card. 
 On Saturday, a deal struck by the leaders of the reformers and the People's Democracy Platform was thrown out by the Reform Alliance's nearly 500 members. 
 &bquo;Now it is they who are trying to manipulate us,&equo; one reformist said in disgust as he was leaving a caucus meeting. 
 The fact that manipulation was possible even in the almost unadulterated democracy of the congress came as a great surprise to most delegates. 
 But the leaderships of the main factions consist almost entirely of sociologists and political scientists, all of whom have had to read Macchiavelli at one stage of their careers. 
 The compromise founding declaration which was approved on Saturday contains a line many Western socialist parties would be proud of: &bquo;The party wishes to contribute to the building of a social market economy based on mixed ownership.&equo; 
 True to form, the argument has already begun on what &bquo;social market economy&equo; means. 
 Britain is blamed by China for HK fears 
 From ANDREW HIGGINS in Peking 
 CONDEMNING Britain for its &bquo;irresponsible actions&equo; and &bquo;erroneous stand&equo; on Hong Kong, China yesterday blamed London for the crisis of confidence that has gripped the colony since the military assault on Tiananmen Square four months ago. 
 Emigration, perhaps the best gauge of public unease, has increased sharply since the 4 June massacre, an event that shocked millions of ordinary Hong Kong residents usually uninterested in politics. 
 In sharp contrast to Britain's refusal to publicly apportion blame for waning faith in the colony's future, China's representative to the Joint Liason Group on Hong Kong, Ke Zaishuo, suggested that Britain, not China's trigger-happy army, was alone responsible. 
 &bquo;The British side has unshirkable responsiblity for the present problem of confidence in Hong Kong,&equo; said Ambassador Ke in an interview with the official New China News Agency. 
 The unusually strong words follow a meeting of the Joint Liason Group in London late last month. 
 The session, postponed at Britain's request after the Peking bloodshed, was the first since hardline leaders triumphed in Peking in June. 
 &bquo;Because of the British side's sticking to its erroneous stand, the two sides were divided on some major issues of principle,&equo; said Ambassador Ke. 
 He admitted that some people in Hong Kong had been alarmed by reports of carnage in Peking but said this was only because they &bquo;misunderstood&equo; or had been misled by the &bquo;false reporting and even rumour of some news media&equo;. 
 Court Circular 
 From ANDREW HIGGINS in Peking 
 His Royal Highness afterwards presented The Duke of Edinburgh's Awards at St Pius's Secondary School and gave an interview to BBC Radio Scotland. 
 The Prince Edward visited Callendar Park and was received by Captain William Forbes (Vice-Lord-Lieutenant of Falkirk) and later visited Stirling Castle, Strathallan Games Park and subsequently attended a dinner at the Forum Hotel, Glasgow. 
 His Royal Highness, attended by Major William McLean, returned to London in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 7 October: The Princess Royal, Patron, British Nutrition Foundation, attended the British Nutrition Foundation's Conference for Teachers of Nutrition at Exeter Court Hotel, Kenford, and was received on arrival by Lieutenant Commander JA Holdsworth (Vice-Lord-Lieutenant of Devon). 
 Afterwards Her Royal Highness, President of Save The Children Fund, visited the Save the Children Fund Shop, Paris Street, Exeter. 
 The Princess Royal, attended by Mrs Richard Carew Pole, travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 Her Royal Highness, President, The British Academy of Film and Television Arts, this evening attended the Julie Andrews Tribute Award at the Odeon, Leicester Square, London. 
 The Hon Mrs Louloudis was in attendance. 
 8 October: The Queen and The Duke of Edinburgh left Heathrow Airport, London this afternoon in a British Airways Tristar for Singapore and Malaysia. 
 Her Majesty and His Royal Highness were received upon arrival at the Airport by the Earl of Airlie (Lord Chamberlain). 
 The following were present and took leave of The Queen and The Duke of Edinburgh: Field Marshal the Lord Bramall (Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant of Greater London), Mrs Mary Seet-Cheng (Acting High Commissioner for Singapore), Dato AW Omardin (Acting High Commissioner for Malaysia), the Lord King of Wartnaby (Chairman, British Airways), Sir Norman Payne (Chairman, British Airports Authority Plc) and Mr Alan Proctor (Managing Director, Heathrow Airport). 
 The following are in attendance: The Lady Farnham, Mrs John Dugdale, the Right Hon Sir William Heseltine, Rear-Admiral Sir Paul Greening, Sir Robert Fellowes, Mr Robin Janvrin, Surgeon Captain Norman Blacklock, RN, Air Commodore the Hon Timothy Elworthy Lieutenant-Colonel Blair Stewart-Wilson and Mr Brian McGrath. 
 By command of The Queen, the Lord Reay (Lord in Waiting) was present at Royal Air Force Northolt this afternoon upon the departure of The Duke of Gloucester for Portugal and bade farewell to His Royal Highness on behalf of Her Majesty. 
 Mrs John Dugdale has succeeded the Lady Susan Hussey as Lady-in-Waiting to The Queen. 
 KENSINGTON PALACE 8 October: The Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon, Patron of the Halle Concerts Society, was present this evening at a Performance by the Halle Orchestra of Benjamin Britten's War Requiem held at the Free Trade Hall, Manchester. 
 Her Royal Highness was received on arrival by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Greater Manchester (Colonel John Timmins). 
 Mrs Jane Stevens was in attendance. 
 8 October: The Duke of Gloucester as President of the British Consultants Bureau left Royal Air Force Northolt this afternoon to visit Portugal in an aircraft of No 32 Squadron, Royal Air Force. 
 Upon arrival at RAF Northolt, His Royal Highness was received on arrival by Manuel Corte-Real (Representative for the Portugese Ambassador) and Mr Peter Smith (Representative for the Department of Trade and Industy). 
 Major Nicholas Barne was in attendance. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Queen and The Duke of Edinburgh visit Singapore. 
 The Princess Royal attends a lunch at the Enmore Hotel, Kirn, Dunoon, Argyllshire; as President, Riding for the Disabled Association, attends a Show given by the Dunoon and Cowal branch of the Association at Dunoon; attends a sheep show at the European Sheep and Wool Centre, Lochgoilhead, Argyllshire; and opens the Drimsynie Holiday Village. 
 Princess Margaret, as Patron, visits the Northern Ballet Theatre in Manchester. 
 The Duchess of Kent attended the launch of Tears and Smiles: the hospice handbook by Martyn Lewis, at BT Tower, London W1. 
 Obituary: Bette Davis 
 By GILBERT ADAIR 
 THE VERY first line of Edward Albee's Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? - &bquo;What a dump!&equo; &mdash; is spoken by the play's feminine protagonist in a parody of the classic Bette Davis manner: an (imaginary) cigarette held imperiously at eye-level, eyes blazing like the headlamps of an automobile, bee-sting lips enunciating each word (including the &bquo;a&equo;) for absolutely maximum effect, almost as if they had been snipped out of a newspaper headline by a writer of anonymous letters. 
 Paradoxically, though, when one sees the film from which this line was borrowed, a gloriously overheated melodrama by King Vidor entitled Beyond the Forest (1949), one is rather startled to hear Davis deliver it with a quite unstudied, unfussy brusqueness and without any of the intonational posturing that Albee has attributed to her. 
 Yet, in a sense, the dramatist was right and the actress wrong. 
 As a star, Bette Davis was of the type commonly designated &bquo;inimitable&equo;, which tends to mean (as it did in her case) that she eventually became the butt of countless imitators; and these imitators merely accentuated symptoms of self-parody that were already detectable in her own screen presence. 
 Though she was a performer of indisputable talent, one was none the less left with a nagging impression that overarching each of her individual characteristics was another role, one she played to the hilt: that of the grande dame, the First Lady of the American cinema, the Duse of the double-feature. 
 At her worst &mdash; which is to say, when her performances, all crust and no bread, seemed little more than a rash of mannerisms &mdash; she could strike one as impossibly tic-ridden and implausible. 
 At her considerable best &mdash; when her physical angularity, her fluttery, melodramatic flounces and her inclination to treat the most unpretentious line of dialogue as a conversation-stopper were tempered either by a real affinity with the role in question or else by a witty, self-deprecating sense of her own absurdity in it &mdash; she remained one of the most consistently spell-binding of Hollywood stars. 
 Before the phrase became fashionable, Davis was, on-screen, the epitome of the castrating female, her appeal as a cinematic icon being thus largely confined to the feminine (and, by a probably logical extension, homosexual) portion of her audience. 
 She excelled in playing ruthlessly calculating bitch-goddesses, clawing their way to wealth, security and power: eg as Mildred, the sluttish Cockney waitress who enslaves sensitive Leslie Howard in John Cromwell's adaptation of Somerset Maugham's Of Human Bondage (1934), the role in which she made her reputation; as Jezebel, flouting the decorous conventions of the antebellum South in William Wyler's 1938 melodrama of that name; and as the indefatigably scheming Regina, one of her most memorable creations, in Wyler's 1941 film version of Lillian Hellman's The Little Foxes. 
 And though, once she hit her formidable histrionic stride, it was possible to feel that a little of Bette Davis went a long way, her excesses were surely preferable to the homogenised blandness of those mass-produced Hollywood sirens of whom a lot went a very little way indeed. 
 Such stoutly-defended independence of character was no less typical of her off-screen conduct. 
 When Warner Bros, the company with which she had signed an exclusive long-term contract, squandered her potential during the Thirties in a series of amusing but, for her, unfulfilling potboilers (eg Fashions of 1934, The Big Shakedown, Jimmy the Gent, Fog over Frisco), she took the unprecedented step of departing for England, where she could continue working outside of American jurisdiction. 
 Then, when Warners sued her for breach of contract, she reluctantly agreed to return to the studio corral while making certain that the trade press was fully apprised of her frustration. 
 As it happened, the gamble paid off handsomely. 
 The studio almost immediately cast her in a cycle of prestigious (if often meretricious) &bquo;women's pictures&equo;, including Edmund Goulding's Dark Victory (1939), which had her, in its famous climactic scene, walk upstairs to die in solitude with all the dignified serenity of an elephant trundling off to its ancestral graveyard; Michael Curtiz's The Private Lives of Elizabeth and Essex (also 1939), in which she flaunted the Virgin Queen's (and her own) baldness as the ultimate emblem of great, self-abasing character acting; and, of course, Irving Rapper's sudsy, multi-Kleenex tearjerker Now, Voyager (1942), in which her repressed, plain-Jane spinster blossoms overnight into chic, radiant, cigarette-tapping womanhood. 
 Of this last film the Argentinian fabulist Jorge Luis Borges laconically wrote: &bquo;The vigorous message of Now, Voyager is: When Bette Davis is disfigured, she is less beautiful.&equo; 
 In the late Forties, just as her career was sinking to its lowest ebb, and an English critic commented of her notorious egomania that &bquo;only bad films are good enough for her&equo;, she returned in triumph with one of her most brilliant performances, as the ageing but feisty actress Margo Channing who, to her emotional and professional cost, learns All About Eve (directed by Joseph L. Mankiewicz, 1950). 
 And a decade later, when the term &bquo;has-been&equo; seemed almost an understatement, she not only gratefully accepted but gleefully flung herself into the high camp, Low Gothic shenanigans of Robert Aldrich's Whatever Happened to Baby Jane? (1962), in which, with a gloating relish that neither her baby-doll fright wig nor her impenetrable pancake make-up could conceal, she set about tormenting her immemorial screen rival and alter ego (or egoist), Joan Crawford. 
 In a career spanning half a century Davis appeared in numerous major films but practically no great ones, a distinction that, in truth, may have been irrelevant to an actress for whom the role, rather than the film encompassing it, was primordial. 
 Yet, of the several factors distinguishing the cinema from other art forms, not the least significant is the amazing durability of its ephemera. 
 And if a work as trite, foolish and offensive to women as Now, Voyager should, after 40 years, remain as watchable today as on its initial release, when equally feeble plays and novels from the same period have vanished into a limbo of neglect from which they can never be retrieved, it is a tribute less to the very questionable &bquo;artistry&equo; of its writer and director than to the enduring fascination of its leading actress. 
 Bette Davis was charisma incarnate. 
 Obituary: Milton Goldman 
 By DEREK GRANGER 
 MILTON GOLDMAN was probably the world's most famous theatrical agent. 
 He had the most stars on his books, he had the most friends and he gave the most renowned New York parties. 
 In a notoriously tough profession he had the most deservedly celebrated career. 
 If Norman Rockwell had ever painted an American theatre agent the result would have been a portrait of Milton. 
 With his burly, four-square stance, his ruddy colouring, his handsome strong-featured face, he radiated energy, warmth and good nature. 
 The strong rich voice and the ready deep-throated laugh completed the impression of almost invincible benevolence. 
 Milton Goldman had been an actors' agent for nearly 40 years. 
 By the time he became vice-president of International Creative Management, one of the largest talent agencies in the world, he represented not only a host of illustrious American stars &mdash; Helen Hayes, Mary Martin, Arlene Dahl, Maureen Stapleton, Ruth Gordon, Carol Channing, Lillian Gish &mdash; but most of the leading actors of the British theatre, including Laurence Olivier, Ralph Richardson, John Gielgud, Rex Harrison, Peggy Ashcroft, Albert Finney and Vanessa Redgrave. 
 In the early Sixties, on my first visit to America, I was introduced to Milton by Coral Browne. 
 &bquo;You don't realise what I'm giving you,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;This is the key of New York.&equo; 
 Typically, one call to Milton would inevitably elicit the immediate response, &bquo;Where are you? 
 We're having a party. 
 Come on over.&equo; 
 In his Sutton Place apartment overlooking the East River, with ships' lights nosing past the windows and the walls hung with a splendidly eerie collection of Magritte paintings, there was a permanent welcome on the mat. 
 There you could meet the likes of Orson Welles, Norman Mailer, Lillian Hellman, Virgil Thomson, Martha Graham, Ethel Merman, and Anita Loos &mdash; as well as almost every star in American showbusiness. 
 With his partner of 38 years, the lawyer Arnold Weissberger (who died in 1981) Milton had created a genuine New World salon. 
 From Monday to Thursday every week Milton and Arnold were at home to friends from 5pm to theatre time. 
 Some evenings it would be a small group of half-a-dozen close friends, on red-letter nights a gathering of 100 or more to greet a visiting celebrity. 
 For such occasions Milton had perfected an immaculate form of rapid-fire introduction in which he would give his guests both their potted biographies and list of credits. 
 Only occasionally, in the heat of the party, did this formula go amiss as when he blithely introduced Robert Morley (playwright, actor, racanteur and wit) to his own son Sheridan. 
 For years 45 Sutton Place became a meeting place and home-from-home for the entire British colony in New York &mdash; a place where British actors, writers and directors, great and small, knew that they had not only a constant refuge but a friendly shoulder to lean on and a sympathetic ear. 
 The kindness was unbounded. 
 Milton would get you theatre tickets, special hotel rates, restaurant reservations and still wonder if you needed anything more. 
 His friends used him shamelessly. 
 You didn't have to be a client or a famous face to be on the receiving end. 
 The obscure and the struggling got just the same treatment. 
 Rather than use his apartment as an extension of the office, Milton did things the other way round. 
 The salon was continued during daylight hours at the ICM building in an atmosphere which succeeded in being simultaneously both frenetic and relaxed and in which a mood of party time was seldom absent. 
 While Milton grappled with two telephones hung from a sort of yoke around his neck and into which he alternately spoke in a staccato mixture of best Variety showbiz-patter, friends, clients and droppers-in gathered to laugh and gossip in his office while Milton imperviously went on with his wheeling and dealing. 
 Offers of hospitality were engagingly pre-emptory. 
 &bquo;You're coming to the theatre tonight. 
 I'm taking Hermione Gingold. 
 Your date's a wonderful new actress. 
 Odd name. 
 Meryl Streep.&equo; 
 And Miss Streep duly arrived on her bicycle which she chained confidently to the theatre railings. 
 A call for lunch could come at noon. 
 &bquo;Be at the Four Seasons at one. 
 It's Rex Harrison and Mrs Bing Crosby. 
 Wrap up, it's going to snow.&equo; 
 Every summer, for the month of July, the Goldman caravanserai would come to rest in London, where Milton would refresh his contacts, burnish new friendships and influence even more people. 
 Against the onslaught of that pounding geniality English reserve melted. 
 In the old days, with Arnold Weissberger, most of London's theatre and social worlds were bidden to a suite at the Savoy overlooking the Thames. 
 Latterly it was to a flat in Eaton Square where the army of friends, constantly replenished, continued to gather. 
 For Milton Goldman was truly one of those people who, for their friends, make the world go round. 
 Nothing was too much trouble, no call left unanswered. 
 Bringing people together, tirelessly fixing up dates and appointments, putting in just the right word at the crucial moment, helping to forge new partnerships, Milton conducted both his life and his business with an extraordinary degree of caring. 
 Not long ago at the theatre in New York he stood beaming with understandably possessive pride between Jacqueline Onassis and Edna O'Brien. 
 Early the next morning he would probably be back in his office thinking of ways to help an unsuccessful actor. 
 He will leave a huge gap in the theatrical life of Broadway; for his friends in England, New York and the London summer can never seem quite the same again. 
 Obituary: Professor Michael Akehurst 
 By CHRISTINA LYON 
 MICHAEL AKEHURST was amongthe leading international lawyers of his generation. 
 A legal scholar of considerable merit, he was a very private man, difficult to get to know and to describe. 
 After a distinguished student career at Emmanuel College, Cambridge, he went on to study at the University of Paris under Suzanne Bastid. 
 The work he did for his Doctorat de l'Universite, awarded with the citation &bquo;bien&equo; in 1965, formed the basis for his first book, The Law Governing Employment in International Organisations (1967), which remains a source much used by courts and tribunals including the Hague International Court of Justice. 
 Akehurst was early in understanding the importance of administrative and employment law in international organisations and, although others have carried this work forward, his contribution during the 1960s can properly be regarded as pioneering. 
 He was awarded the Diploma of the Hague Academy of International Law in 1965 and his experience of the practice of international law with the United Nations Relief Works Agency (Unrwa) in Beirut, with the Hague Unification Conference and with the European Commission marked him out as exceptional. 
 His work, in his British Yearbook of International Law articles on customs, reprisals and jurisdiction, and &bquo;Intervention in World Politics&equo; are described by fellow international lawyers as classic. 
 The article &bquo;Jurisdiction in International Law&equo; is one of the most widely cited, and is extensively relied upon, most recently before the court of the European Community in the landmark Wood Pulp case. 
 In 1982 the House of Commons Foreign Affairs Committee asked him to write a paper on the Falklands, which was considered a most notable contribution to the debate in this area. 
 Akehurst's passion for the subject of international law led him to embark on the writing of what became a standard student textbook, A Modern Introduction to International Law. 
 This demanded skills radically different from those displayed in his earlier highly specialised work. 
 Now in its sixth edition in English it is used extensively throughout the world, but has also been translated into Spanish, Portuguese and Japanese. 
 To write a really successful &bquo;introduction&equo; to a subject like modern international law, demands a quite unusually catholic and thorough knowledge and experience of the whole subject. 
 As a fellow international lawyer has put it, Akehurst is one of the few who succeeded. 
 Although entitled an &bquo;introduction&equo;, the work had an authority all of its own and was often quoted. 
 His dedication to the subject was complete and he continued to write and give high quality papers at various conferences. 
 His first academic appointment was as a lecturer in law at Manchester University. 
 He was in the Department of Law at the Keele University for nearly 20 years and the university was his home. 
 Although a private man and somewhat of a loner, he worked tirelessly for the department both in a teaching and administrative capacity. 
 His love of international law he communicated to his students both at an undergraduate and a postgraduate level. 
 Keele University acknowledged Michael Akehurst's position as one of the foremost international lawyers of his time by awarding him a personal chair in February 1989. 
 Obituary: Patricia Cockburn 
 By RICHARD INGRAMS 
 PATRICIA COCKBURN was the widow of the journalist Claud Cockburn and a remarkable and resourceful woman, an intrepid traveller, an inspired gardener and latterly a creator of shell paintings. 
 She was born in County Cork in 1914, the youngest of the six children of Major JB Arbuthnot and his wife Olive Blake. 
 Her father, who served in the Brigade of Guards, was the original Beachcomber columnist on the Daily Express and also guarded Sir Roger Casement when he was a prisoner in the Tower. 
 Patricia enjoyed the kind of Anglo-Irish childhood so well described by her lifelong friend Molly Keane. 
 She had no formal education at all and was brought up by her paternal grandmother at Myrtle Grove, Youghal, which had been the home of Sir Walter Raleigh when he was the Governor of Ireland. 
 &bquo;As a child,&equo; Claud wrote, &bquo;Patricia hunted half the day and in the evenings, supine on a board for reasons of deportment, lay drinking Madeira wine and reading The Golden Bough.&equo; 
 Her family was well off and at the age of 18 she was presented as a debutante. 
 Shortly afterwards she married Arthur Byron, a Lloyd's underwriter and cousin of the travel writer Robert Byron. 
 With him she rode across the Rockies and made two expeditions, in the Far East and Africa, on behalf of the Royal Geographical Society, to study tribal languages. 
 As a result of a visit to Ruthenia in 1939 on behalf of the Evening Standard during which she was briefly imprisoned, she met and married the then notorious journalist Claud Cockburn who was at that time producing his one-man newsletter The Week. 
 Her family was appalled and her father told her she would never be allowed into the Royal Enclosure at Ascot again. 
 Certainly her marriage involved financial sacrifice and for the rest of her life she was almost always short of money. 
 In 1947 Claud decided to make a complete break with his past and they settled near her family home in Youghal in a derelict Georgian mansion belonging to an American policeman which they rented for &pound;150 a year. 
 Claud however found it increasingly hard to earn because of his Communist past and it was left to Patricia to keep the various wolves from the door. 
 For a time she became a pony-dealer, buying horses from tinkers and selling them on to English buyers. 
 Then in 1965, inspired by an eighteenth-century folio which she discovered in Leixlip Castle she revived the art of making pictures (usually floral designs) from different shells mounted on a black velvet background. 
 Encouraged by the Irish artist Norah McGuinness, she exhibited her work with great success in Dublin, London and New York. 
 She published two books: The Years of The Week (1968), an account of Claud's periodical, and a memoir, Figure of Eight (1985). 
 Her three sons Alexander, Andrew and Patrick all became successful journalists. 
 Obituary: Supt Mhoira Robertson 
 By PC MICHAEL B. S. CASEY 
 I DO NOT feel, writes PC Michael B. S. Casey, that Mhoira Robertson would have been happy with an obituary (by Joan Burnie, 3 October) that was used as a platform to criticise her colleagues (antiastunomologists &mdash; thank you, Anthony Burgess) and the male species in general: &bquo;and Scottish policemen do not like women much at all.&equo; 
 This particular police officer does and wants Superintendent Mhoira Robertson to be remembered for a glittering career and not a weary struggle as recorded by Joan Burnie. 
 Mhoira was and is a symbol to WPCs throughout the country that the ladder can be scaled. 
 Go into the CID, the Identification Branch, the Women and Child Unit and ask the women police officers about the influence of Mhoira Robertson. 
 In the end she proved, and many women police officers are proving, that it is now the men who are holding on to their apron strings. 
 Obituaries 
 By PC MICHAEL B. S. CASEY 
 HJ (Mudi) Stieger, aircraft designer, died Brough East Yorkshire 1 October aged 87. 
 He developed the monospar system of wing construction in 1927 and also founded the Gloster Aircraft Company, General Aircraft and the Monspar Company. 
 Darlington Hoopes, politician, died Sinking Spring Pennsylvania 25 September aged 93. 
 A leader of the US socialist party, he twice ran unsuccessfully for President, in 1952 and 1956. 
 Arnold Johnson, American Communist leader, died New York City 26 September aged 84. 
 A leader of the US Communist Party in New York from the late 1940s, he was imprisoned in 1953 for two years for violating the Smith Act, which made it a crime to advocate the violent overthrow of the Government. 
 August J. Busch Jr, brewer, died St Louis 29 September aged 90. 
 Head of the Anheuser-Busch brewery for 28 years and owner of the St Louis Cardinals since 1953. 
 Geoffrey Sumner, actor, died Alderney 29 September aged 80. 
 Best known for his portrayal of Major Upshot-Bagley in the television series The Army Game. 
 Anniversaries 
 By PC MICHAEL B. S. CASEY 
 On this day: Louis XII, King of France, married Mary Tudor, sister of Henry VIII, 1514; the first Luddite riots against the introduction of machinery for spinning cotton started, Manchester 1779; Hobart, Tasmania, was founded, 1804; the Universal Postal Union was founded, Rome 1875; the first petrol-driven motor bus began operating in London, 1899; the Labour government fell, 1924; King Alexander of Yugoslavia and Louis Barthou, French foreign minister, were assassinated by a Croatian terrorist, Marseilles 1934; the first London production of the musical show Porgy and Bess was presented, 1952; the breathalyzer test came into force in Britain, 1967. 
 Today is the Feast Day of Saints Andronicus and Athanasia, St Demetrius of Alexandria, St Denis or Dionysius of Paris, St Dionysius the Areopagite, Saints Eleutherius and Rusticus, St Ghislain or Gislenus, St Louis Bertrand, St John Leonardi, St Publia and St Savin. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 19 
 Obituary: Jacques Doniol-Valcroze: Correction 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 A transmission error resulted in a misspelling throughout Saturday's obituary by David Shipman. 
 The name of the subject should have read Jacques Doniol-Valcroze. 
 (Erroneous spelling: Jacques Doniol-Volcroze). 
 Law Report: Case Summaries (CORRECTED) 
 By DAVID SHIPMAN 
 Correction (published 11 October 1989) incorporated into this article. 
 The following notes of judgments were prepared by the reporters of the All England Law Reports. 
 Immigration R v Immigration Appeal Tribunal, Ex parte Khalid Hussain; CA (Lloyd, Glidewell, Stuart-Smith LJJ); 5 Oct 1989 Under r 18 of the Immigration Appeals Procedure Rules 1972, the decision of an immigration appeal tribunal considering whether or not to hear oral evidence to determine whether there were compassionate reasons for a person convicted of murder to be given entry clearance was a matter of discretion and could only be attacked on Wednesbury principles or other recognised rules. 
 S Kadri QC and Harjit Grewal (Penmans, Coventry) for the applicant; John Laws (Treasury Solicitor) for the tribunal. 
 R v Secretary of State for Home Department, Ex parte Kuku; CA (Woolf, Nicholls and Staughton LJJ); 28 Sept 1989 It is highly desirable that foreign nationals to whom r 10 of the Statement of Changes in Immigration Rules HC 169 applies should not only by warned by the Home Office of the necessity under s 3(4) of the Immigration Act 1971 of obtaining a visa if seeking re-entry to the UK after a short visit abroad, but that that warning should take the form of a document attached to the foreign national's passport, so there is no question of any misapprehension. 
 Ismael Kumi (Iqbal &amp; Co) for the applicant; David Pannick (Treasury Solicitor) for the Home Secretary. 
 Magistrates' court R v Holyhead Justices, Ex parte Rowlands; QBD (Mann LJ, Waterhouse J); 31 Aug 1989 An objection to witness statements tendered by the prosecution being admitted in evidence should be made according to the procedure in s 102 of the Magistrates' Courts Act 1980. 
 A request that prosecution witnesses be tendered for examination was not tantamount to an objection under s 102. 
 Objection should not be objection by implication or common usage. 
 Objection within section 102(2) (d) was unqualified, and need not be buttressed by a promise to make a submission of &bquo;no case to answer&equo;. 
 Paul Bogan (R Gordon Roberts &amp; Laurie, Llangefni) for the applicant; Rowena Goode (CPS, North Wales) for the prosecution. 
 Planning Ward v Secretary of State for the Environment; CA (Woolf, Nicholls, Staughton LJJ); 25 Sept 1989 A private garden was capable of being an &bquo;open space&equo; and something that should be taken into account when deciding whether a development proposed to be carried out in a conservation area would preserve or enhance the area within s 277 of the Town and Country Planning Act 1971, as substituted, and of Circular No 8 of 1987 issued by the Secretary of State. 
 Anthony Smith QC and Nadia Sharif (Marron Dodds &amp; Waite) for the appellant; Robert Jay (Treasury Solicitor) for the Secretary of State; Michael Rich QC and Timothy Mould (Shoosmith &amp; Harrison) for the developer. 
 Practice Richard Ashworth and ors v Berkeley-Walbrook Ltd; CA (Russell, Stuart-Smith LJJ); 27 Sept 1989 As a general rule, where a counterclaim could properly be relied on as a set-off and where it arose out of the same subject matter as the claim, the counterclaiming defendant ought not to be required to give security for costs of that counterclaim unless there were exceptional circumstances. 
 Robert Leonard (Bischoff &amp; Co) for the defendant; Jonathan Marks (Collins Stone &amp; Co) for the plaintiff. 
 Sentencing R v Barney; CA (Crim Div) (Bingham LJ, Ognall, McKinnon JJ); 3 Oct 1989 A judge was in error in implying that, had a defendant been in a position to pay compensation to his victim, he might have received a shorter sentence than that in fact imposed. 
 It must never be thought that a convicted criminal can buy his way out of imprisonment. 
 The significance of an offer of compensation is that it may be taken as a token of the defendant's remorse, and that it redresses the private loss of the victim, and to that extent and no other it plays a part in the sentencing exercise. 
 It must be clearly recognised that compensation orders are otherwise wholly independent of that exercise. 
 Timothy Coombes (Registrar of Criminal Appeals) for the appellant. 
 R v Stanley; CA (Crim Div) (Bingham LJ, Ognall, McKinnon JJ); 2 Oct 1989 Where a judge has it in mind to make a compensation order but the possibility has not been raised by counsel, it is the judge's duty to raise the matter of his own motion so that it may be properly and fairly ventilated. 
 Such an order should be made only where there is evidence of the defendant's ability to pay. 
 JV Machin (Registrar of Criminal Appeals) for the appellant. 
 Service of documents Lex Service plc v Johns; CA (Glidewell, Balcombe LJJ); 22 Aug 1989 The evidence of the defendant that he had not received documents sent by a recorded delivery service and apparently received by some other person was not contrary evidence for the purpose of contradicting the statutory provision for deemed service under s 7 of the Interpretation Act 1978. 
 To prove contrary evidence it was necessary to have either positive proof that the document was returned to the sender or, if sent by recorded delivery, that there was no acknowledgement of receipt, or if there was evidence of the document having been received by some person, there was proof that the person was not the intended recipient and that he had not brought the document to the notice of the person required to be served. 
 In the absence of such proof service must be deemed to have been properly effected. 
 Contemporary Art Market: East and West meet in magical interiors 
 By EDWARD LUCIE-SMITH 
 MOST OF Setsuko's paintings were sold by Friday lunchtime &mdash; and the show at the Lefevre Gallery only opened on Thursday. 
 Her gouache paintings on paper depict unpeopled interiors and flowers with a Japanese sense of colour and design, but their intriguing magic derives from the marriage of East and West. 
 The chairs and tables, shopping baskets, watering cans and tablecloths are Western, as are the flowers. 
 They have been arranged in a Western home by the Japanese wife of Balthus, the great French painter. 
 Balthus, who is 81, married Setsuko, now 47, in 1967. 
 She began to paint after the birth of her first child in 1973. 
 The Lefevre show, which moves on to Tokyo in November, is Setsuko's fourth exhibition. 
 While her husband's work is seen as one of the landmarks in Western painting of the twentieth century, she has retained her own identity, working with the exquisite finesse of the best, traditional Japanese painters. 
 There are just hints of Balthus's influence in her interiors; enough to add a piquancy to a supremely-decorative style. 
 Her work would be a pleasure to live with at any price and the &pound;9,000 to &pound;13,000 range seems modest compared with much of the contemporary art on offer in London. 
 Anthony Caro's prices are 10 times higher &mdash; but then he is the founding father of British avant-garde sculpture and does much of his work in the US where prices are higher. 
 A major exhibition of his 1980s sculpture is split between Annely Juda Fine Art and the Knoedler Gallery. 
 The Knoedler pieces are evocations in welded metal of the balance of forms in some of the most famous Western paintings, Manet's Dejeuner sur l'herbe and the Descent from the Cross as interpreted by Rubens and Rembrandt. 
 The powerful balance of these figure compositions is highlighted when they are transposed into tubes and sheets of metal. 
 They are priced between &dollar;150,000 (Manet) and &dollar;180,000 (Rembrandt). 
 Annely Juda has used the gallery's three floors to divide the exhibits into three distinct groups. 
 The ground floor has big architectural metal sculptures, dominated by the Elephant Palace whose abstract form in shiny brass echoes the monumental mass of an elephant and scores the top price at &dollar;250,000. 
 The first floor contains paper sculptures &mdash; he has used torn, cut, folded and painted paper to form provocative jumbles contained in plexiglass cases; these abstract explorations of texture and form, which closely parallel his metal pieces, are attractively priced at &dollar;10,000. 
 It is clearly harder work to produce smaller images in metal; the contorted metal forms in the third-floor gallery, mostly two to three foot high, cost between &dollar;40,000 and &dollar;60,000. 
 Fischer Fine Art is showing Elisabeth Frink, the grande dame of British sculpture. 
 She represents a wholly different tradition in twentieth-century sculpture to Caro. 
 Where he is abstract and geometric, she is figurative and expressionist. 
 The show is dominated by more than life-size naked bronze men inspired by the majestic Hellenistic bronze warriors rescued from the sea off southern Italy in the 1970s. 
 Their heavy, menacing bodies, roughly finished and coloured with acid cost &pound;50,000. 
 Other works start at &pound;2,500 and include drawings, small animal bronzes, paper cut-outs and massive plaster heads. 
 Teachers urged to boycott appraisal schemes in schools 
 By PETER WILBY, Education Editor 
 TEACHERS' UNIONS are advising their members to boycott appraisal schemes set up by schools and local authorities. 
 They fear that such schemes could lead to disciplinary action against sub-standard teachers and to the beginnings of a merit pay system. 
 Their advice follows a decision by John MacGregor, Secretary of State for Education, to delay proposals for a national appraisal scheme, run by local authorities under strict guidelines. 
 The scheme, drawn up after pilot projects by a steering group under Duncan Graham, chairman of the National Curriculum Council, had the support of all the teachers' and heads' unions as well as the local authority employers. 
 It was designed to focus appraisal on teachers' needs for in-service training and other forms of support. 
 The steering group strongly opposed &bquo;standard checklists of performance&equo;. 
 Mr MacGregor said that he would delay introducing the scheme because of the demands made on teachers by other educational reforms. 
 But, he added, appraisal had great potential to improve standards, and regulations requiring local authorities to introduce it would be brought forward eventually. 
 In the meantime, he suggested local authorities and individual schools might introduce their own schemes. 
 The unions suspect that Mr MacGregor is trying to introduce appraisal on the cheap. 
 Mr Graham's recommendations would involve the employment of the equivalent of an extra 1,828 full-time teachers and a total cost of &pound;36m-&pound;40m or 0.5 per cent of the annual teacher salary bill. 
 The unions also fear that Mr MacGregor wants to link appraisal more closely to teachers' salary levels, thus creating a merit pay system. 
 In a speech announcing his decisions, he said he wanted &bquo;a wider debate&equo; on some points. 
 He also suggested that school governors with commercial or industrial experience might be particularly interested in introducing appraisal schemes. 
 In a letter to members, the Assistant Masters and Mistresses Association warns against schemes &bquo;with no guarantee of adequate resources; which may blur the process of professional development with the identification of alleged weaknesses for disciplinary purposes; and which may be used as a crude and inequitable process for relating salary rates to arbitrarily judged levels of performance&equo;. 
 The National Union of Teachers says that all school appraisal schemes - including existing ones &mdash; should be boycotted and local authority schemes supported only if they follow all the recommendations of the steering group. 
 Making all children learn a foreign language will do nothing to help Britain commercially, Sir Alfred Sherman, a former adviser to the Prime Minister, says today. 
 Writing in Language Matters, a newsletter issued by the Associated Examining Board, Sir Alfred argues: &bquo;English is now the world language. 
 Anyone born with English as his or her native language does not need other languages...&equo; 
 Spanish, Portuguese, Arabic and Japanese are the most useful languages, Sir Alfred says, because they &bquo;have a wide catchment area containing many decision-makers who may not have a command of English&equo;. 
 Radioactive risks from Sellafield &bquo;not fully shown&equo; 
 By TOM WILKIE, Science Editor 
 RADIOACTIVE contamination from the Sellafield reprocessing plant extends much further than official surveys suggest, according to a report published by Friends of the Earth today. 
 Patrick Green, the environment group's radiation consultant, says: &bquo;There is extensive contamination along 6 kilometres of the River Esk in Cumbria, which is not discussed in official reports published by the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. 
 They do not monitor in the area &mdash; which suggests that they don't think it is a major exposure route. 
 Our evidence suggests the contrary.&equo; 
 If there is undetected contamination in the Esk, then it seems likely that other areas of the west coast are also contaminated without showing up in official statistics, Mr Green says. 
 He believes that the ministry and British Nuclear Fuels have not sampled the area extensively because the contamination was not predicted by the official models of how radioactive material moves in the environment. 
 The levels detected upstream in the Friends of the Earth study are broadly comparable to those measured by the ministry in samples nearer the coast - where official models would predict a higher amount of radioactivity. 
 According to the study, some of the readings exceed levels set by the National Radiological Protection Board for environmental contamination. 
 This does not mean that anyone has necessarily suffered a dose of radiation exceeding safety limits. 
 Doses received by local people would depend on the amount of time they spent near areas of higher radioactivity, and on whether any of the radioactivity passed through the food chain. 
 Nonetheless, the National Radiological Protection Board recommends that when radiation levels approach its &bquo;generalised derived limits&equo;, the authorities should investigate both the sources of radiation and the way of life of people in the locality to check that they are not being exposed to excessive amounts. 
 Friends of the Earth claim one particular radioactive chemical, ruthenium, is present to an extent that is 50 times higher than the generalised derived limits. 
 However, the Ministry of Agriculture reported a similar level of ruthenium in a soil sample taken in 1987, apparently without any comment being raised at the time. 
 A spokeswoman for the ministry said that it had seen a draft of the report earlier in the year and had felt that it had made &bquo;inappropriate use&equo; of the generalised derived limits. 
 &bquo;We have monitored in the area and there is no hazard to health,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;We shall look forward to seeing the report and if there is new data that warrants investigation.&equo; 
 &bquo;Telegraph&equo; to cut jobs and move to 7-day rotas 
 By MAGGIE BROWN, Media Editor 
 THE DAILY TELEGRAPH is due to announce today plans to integrate staff into a seven-days-a-week publishing operation. 
 The plan is expected to involve about 40 redundancies &mdash; mainly sub-editors - as management believes the company is overstaffed when compared with new newspapers. 
 The aim is to put all employees on standard five-day-week contracts, compared with the mixture of four-day weeks, nine-day fortnights and five-day weeks which staff currently work. 
 Almost everyone will work for the group, rather than a specific title. 
 &bquo;We have to confront vast, very powerful baronies, one at a time. 
 It is very painful,&equo; one manager said. 
 Sales of The Sunday Telegraph are trailing The Sunday Times, and Observer and facing new competition from The Sunday Correspondent. 
 &bquo;You can't treble your staff to compete, so we have to throw the resources of The Daily Telegraph behind it,&equo; an executive said. 
 The new editor of The Sunday Telegraph, Trevor Grove, was appointed because he is one of Max Hastings's closest colleagues, and can mobilise these resources. 
 The company's plans indicate the way in which newspapers, having modernised printing methods, are looking closely at editorial costs. 
 The Telegraph's management believes that when it moved to Docklands, more than two years ago, it failed to modernise fully journalistic work practices, and did not realise how new technology could be used to reduce the number of editing jobs. 
 Safety drive launched by nuclear inspectors 
 By TOM WILKIE 
 NUCLEAR SAFETY inspectors have formed an international &bquo;trade association&equo; in an effort to raise standards of nuclear safety regulation throughout the world, writes Tom Wilkie. 
 The idea is the personal initiative of Eddy Ryder, HM Chief Inspector of Nuclear Installations, who has now persuaded the Vienna-based UN organisation, the International Atomic Energy Agency, to co-ordinate the arrangements. 
 The first formal meeting of top nuclear safety regulators is expected to take place in December. 
 Although he is little known in Britain, Mr Ryder appears to be developing into an influential international figure in the regulation of nuclear safety. 
 He is chairman of the IAEA's Nuclear Safety Advisory Group, which gives him a pivotal role in co-ordinating the safety policies of all countries that have nuclear installations. 
 The new project, which has been launched quietly and without fuss, mirrors a much more highly-publicised initiative &mdash; the World Association of Nuclear Operators &mdash; promoted some months ago by Lord Marshall, chairman of the Central Electricity Generating Board. 
 WANO brings together the owners and operators of nuclear power stations and reprocessing plants. 
 According to Mr Ryder, the nuclear inspectors decided to get together to swap information and to identify &bquo;good practice&equo; that might be codified into formal guidance notes. 
 He does not see formal codes of practice as the real outcome of the new project, however. 
 The key outcome will be to bring &bquo;peer pressure&equo; to bear to improve the general level of nuclear safety. 
 Boy's Own adventurer keeps faith with the past: Wilfred Thesiger, explorer, talks to Richard North about his lifelong search for diversity 
 By RICHARD NORTH 
 WILFRED THESIGER is exactly the kind of person television companies like to make films about. 
 After all, he is one of the last survivors of a disappearing people; he belongs to a tribe whose main characteristic is that its members do not own a television set. 
 So it is that tomorrow, ITV will screen a profile of the man who spent the first eight years of his life in Abyssinia (now Ethiopia) and graduated to serious eccentricity via an English prep school (where he was beaten), Eton (where he learned to box) and finally Oxford (where he was a boxing blue and acquired the dramatically-bent nose which for six decades has lent drama to what would in any case have been a distinguished face). 
 Mr Thesiger, who will be eighty next summer, arrived in London last week. 
 In his London flat there is only an old Roberts radio his mother owned until she died in 1973, aged more than ninety. 
 He now spends most of his time in Northern Kenya, where the Moran (tribesmen) still cling to tradition, just. 
 As a very young child he witnessed scenes which equalled anything from the imagination of Rider Haggard. 
 He saw Ras Tafari &mdash; later Haile Selassie - return from a great battle which was the beginning of a long road to Emperorship. 
 This was an Africa of gold and robes, and a bloodiness which reminded the boy Thesiger of The Iliad. 
 Mr Thesiger hates machines and modernity. 
 He says he knew from the start that they would spread conformity. 
 Camels, mules, tribesmen he can master. 
 Briefly with the SAS in the Second World War, he distinguished himself by being wholly ignorant of whether a wheel nut was to be undone clockwise or not. 
 Diversity is what he has sought all his life. 
 But seeing it was never enough. 
 &bquo;I had to be a part of it&equo;, he says. 
 Thus he was a supernumerary stoker on a tramp steamer (how Thesiger hated appearing before the ambassador in Constantinople in his flannels when His Excellency cabled the boat with an invitation). 
 He also gutted fish on a trawler in the north Atlantic. 
 His explorations took him into deserts and marshes. 
 He never went alone. 
 Everything depended on a group of people, loyal to him in harsh places. 
 &bquo;We starved,&equo; he says simply, of a camel ride across the Empty Quarter of Saudi Arabia. 
 &bquo;We had to draw straws for the food we had.&equo; 
 He claims a simple quality for his companions in these crazy adventures, and in the Bedu whom he admires most of all. 
 &bquo;They had nobility.&equo; 
 Asked if any tribes he admires would allow the kind of eccentricity the English tribe had allowed him, he said &bquo;I had never thought of that&equo;. 
 He now lives in three homes in Kenya: they belong to people who think of themselves, he says, as his sons. 
 His dog-leg patrimony (his uncle was Lord Chelmsford) has enabled him to support himself and to help some others. 
 His books must sell, but he does not think of himself as an author. 
 Walking briskly towards Sloane Square to get some lunch at his club, he said: &bquo;In Kenya, I like to sit in a car and watch the world go by. 
 I don't want to do that in the King's Road.&equo; 
 He is a man in thrall to the gaudy, tattered pageant of Africa. 
 He was wearing a dark suit and tie when we met. 
 He looked like a very good old headmaster, or a decently obscure peer of the realm. 
 He knows that he wandered in places which had never seen a plane, a car, or a radio. 
 And he did nothing in his life of exploration to introduce any of them to the places he saw. 
 To that extent, he can claim to have been an innocent traveller. 
 &bquo;Imagine being able to radio to base. 
 I should have hated that.&equo; 
 Whitehall Watch: Social security plans hold key to wider success: Peter Hennessy examines Next Steps' showpiece 
 By PETER HENNESSY 
 AS SENIOR Civil Servants go, Nick Montagu, 45 and an Under-Secretary and principal establishments officer at the Department of Social Security, has one of the biggest burdens in the business on his shoulders. 
 Managing a staff of 80,000-plus is tough enough. 
 But, added to that, the success of the most substantial Civil Service reform this century largely depends on Mr Montagu and his colleagues. 
 If the great social security businesses can be turned into successful, free-standing executive agencies, the problem will have been cracked &mdash; the Next Steps reforms will have worked where so many attempts at change faltered. 
 Mr Montagu is quite open about it: &bquo;We're the showpiece. 
 It mustn't fail. 
 .. Next Steps almost stands or falls by us. 
 If we succeed in the biggest executive operation, we can succeed with almost any operation.&equo; 
 &bquo;The biggest executive operation,&equo; as Mr Montagu puts it, is the benefits system, the largest single employer in the Civil Service (70,000 staff) and distributor of the largest single chunk of public expenditure (about &pound;50bn). 
 But for Mr Montagu, his colleague, Bob Brown, and his team in the department's Agency, Systems and Planning Division, it is one of a series of new creations. 
 The first and smallest, the 600-strong Resettlement Agency, got off the ground last June. 
 Next April, the Information Technology Services Agency, headquartered in Lytham St Anne's, Lancashire, will be launched with its staff of 3,000 and its job of keeping the whole benefits system electronically live. 
 At the same time, a new Contributions Unit, which may or may not develop into a full-blown agency, will be spun out of the existing DSS central capacity in Longbenton, Newcastle (with people stationed in every benefit office in the land and a total staff of 7,000). 
 A year later, the hoped-for jewel in the Next Steps crown, the Benefits Agency, will be up and away with its headquarters in a place still to be determined. 
 In the next few weeks advertisements will appear for a chief executive who, if all goes to plan, will have a year to run themselves in and have a real say in building the new institution. 
 The headship of the Benefits Agency will rank with the chief executive's post on the National Health Service as the most demanding management job in Britain. 
 It is a place where a great reputation can be won or an existing one extinguished. 
 Few appointments made by the Civil Service Commission in recent years will be so crucial, not just to the efficient running of the welfare state, but to the progress of the most significant Civil Service reform this century. 
 If I were on the pay side in the Treasury, I would be prepared to permit maximum flexibility on the salary and conditions offered to the successful applicant. 
 Pay flexibility is a main preoccupation of Mr Montagu and Mr Brown in the planning stage. 
 It is relatively easy to operate such a system where trading is involved and many are in specialist grades as in Her Majesty's Stationery Office, the up-and-running agency with the most sophisticated pay arrangements so far. 
 Offering it to armies of administrative assistants doing non-commercial jobs in the great clerical factories underpinning the benefits system and in a nation-wide network of local offices, is another matter. 
 They are looking at job-weighting, concepts of &bquo;stewardship&equo; and performance measurement in the knowledge that greater flexibility in pay (and recruitment) will be crucial factors in escaping from what Mr Montagu calls &bquo;the rigidities that have bedevilled us in the past&equo;. 
 The feasibility study prepared by Stephen Hickey, an assistant secretary, which provided the agency blueprint for the DSS, was unequivocal about the key asset in the operation &mdash; &bquo;people will represent the prime resource of any social security agency&equo; &mdash; and blunt in saying &bquo;morale in some areas is low&hellip; virtually no local office staff were happy to admit working for social security&equo;. 
 Mr Montagu and Mr Brown believe getting staff not to fear the agency process as a bringer of cuts or worse conditions, but as a way of improving both and service to the customer, is the crucial task facing ministers and senior officials between now and spring 1991. 
 Much was happening to disrupt life before the agency idea &mdash; the &pound;2bn rolling programme to make social security operations fully computerised; plans to move work out of London. 
 &bquo;Time is so short&equo;, Mr Montagu said. 
 &bquo;We have got to get around the local offices and listen to what they're saying.&equo; 
 A great deal is riding on those words and what they produce. 
 Arts events &bquo;the domain of Britain's privileged&equo; 
 By DAVID LISTER, Arts Correspondent 
 GOING to the theatre, concerts and art galleries remains largely the privilege of the well-off and well-educated, and of more women than men, research shows. 
 A year-long survey of the habits of 24,000 adults in England, Wales and Scotland has found that people with an annual household income of &pound;20,000 or more have considerably higher levels of attendance than those in lower income groups. 
 It was very high for people who took their full-time education beyond the age of 18, and higher among women than men for all art forms except jazz and art galleries. 
 The information, collected for the Arts Council by the British Market Research Bureau, shows that in an average period of four weeks during 1988-89, 6 per cent of the adult population went to the theatre, 4 per cent to an art gallery, 2 per cent to classical music and 1 per cent to jazz. 
 Over a three-month period, opera attracted 1 per cent of the population but ballet and contemporary dance fewer than 1 per cent. 
 Of the 24,058 people interviewed, 37.7 per cent of women attended arts events and 33.1 per cent of men. 
 Above the &pound;20,000 income threshold, more than half of those interviewed go to arts events. 
 Fewer than 30 per cent of those earning up to &pound;8,000 go, and fewer than 40 per cent of those earning up to &pound;15,000. 
 Nearly 55 per cent of people who have been in higher education had been to the theatre in the survey period, but fewer than 19 per cent of those who left school at 16. 
 For art galleries the figures are 50 per cent and 16 per cent, for classical music 32 per cent and 8 per cent. 
 Arts Council officers are understood to be considering changing the practice of handing out separate information about the arts to the different political party conferences. 
 As reported in some editions of The Independent last week, the Arts Council leaflet aimed at this week's Conservative Party conference differs starkly from the one handed out to Labour delegates in Brighton last week. 
 The leaflet earmarked for the Tories will stress the earning potential of the arts, its management and marketing skills, and the usefulness of sponsorship. 
 The leaflet given to Labour activists mentions none of these things, concentrating on how many ordinary people go to arts events. 
 In a memorable set of class assumptions, the Labour leaflet looks at how many people go to opera, jazz and West End theatres, while in the message to Tories only opera remains. 
 Neil Kinnock appears to have failed to convince the Arts Council that his party now has a wide constituency covering large sections of the middle classes, and might have business contacts. 
 The Labour leaflet compared the numbers going to the Royal Shakespeare Company with attendances at Wembley Stadium, Aida with the Ideal Home Exhibition, and ballet, somewhat incongruously, with Rugby Union. 
 And, without a hint of irony, under the heading &bquo;All kinds of people enjoy the arts&equo;, it says that 3.1 million News of the World readers go to the theatre, and 1,157,000 Sun readers attend art galleries or exhibitions. 
 Study shows big fall in number of people entitled to legal aid 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 THE NUMBER of people entitled to civil legal aid has fallen by more than 14 million since 1979, according to research published today. 
 The findings confirm earlier estimates of a large drop in eligibility and will fuel renewed calls for the legal aid means test to be thoroughly reviewed. 
 Compared with 10 years ago, when it was estimated that at least 70 per cent of two-parent households with two children came within the scheme, less than half of two-parent families now qualify, according to the author of the study, Michael Murphy, a statistician at the London School of Economics. 
 Claimants under the scheme receive advice or representation free or subject to a contribution linked to disposable income. 
 But legal aid experts argue that low income and capital limits are denying access to justice to increasing numbers of people who cannot afford to pay privately. 
 Mr Murphy's analysis of available earnings and spending data, including the Department of Employment's most recent Family Expenditure Survey, is revealed in today's Legal Action. 
 The analysis concludes that 1 million households and more than 2&frac12; million people have dropped out of the legal aid net in the two years since Lord Mackay of Clashfern became Lord Chancellor. 
 Over the last decade, the upper disposable income limit rose by about 50 per cent, but earnings rose by 135 per cent and prices by 93 per cent. 
 Mr Murphy's findings are borne out by new evidence of a decline in the use of legal aid. 
 Figures for the year ended 31 March 1989, due to be published at the end of the year, show an overall 8 per cent drop in the use of the &bquo;green form&equo; initial advice and assistance scheme, as compared with an overall increase the previous year of 10 per cent. 
 &bquo;Green form&equo; advice for consumer problems was 16 per cent down on the previous year. 
 Help with employment disputes fell by 14 per cent, with debt, immigration and housing matters showing falls of 13, 9 and 8 per cent respectively. 
 Like previous studies, Mr Murphy's analysis uses conservative assumptions and legal aid experts say the problem could be much more serious. 
 Mr Murphy says eligibility levels which took account of variations between households and actual, rather than assumed, figures for tax and housing, could be definitively assessed by further analysis of detailed Family Expenditure Survey statistics at the cost of only a few thousand pounds. 
 Lord Mackay has treated claims that eligibility has substantially fallen as speculative. 
 But there is now tacit acceptance at the Lord Chancellor's department that the subject must be investigated. 
 &bquo;Over the last couple of months we have begun a preliminary look at the statistics with a view to doing our own calculations. 
 The Family Expenditure Surveys will be a part of the exercise,&equo; a spokeswoman said. 
 But she added: &bquo;Numbers are one thing, effects are another. 
 The scheme was intended for people of poor or moderate means. 
 We will need to discover who is really being stopped from going ahead with legal action, or whether people are making choices between legal action or re-mortgaging their house, a holiday, a car or otherwise freeing money which is tied up.&equo; 
 Viewpoint: Clear approach to policy on trade union law: Michael Meacher, Labour's employment spokesman, replies to a Viewpoint article by Barrie Clement, Labour Editor, which considered the party's position on trade union law 
 By MICHAEL MEACHER 
 READING Barrie Clement's diatribe (6 October) under the heading &bquo;Union law policy remains unclear&equo;, I wondered if he had attended the same Labour Party Conference as I did. 
 The party now has a clearer, more comprehensive and more explicit statement covering the whole range of industrial relations policy than in the past. 
 It is a firm and robust statement which we believe will command a very high degree of public support as being balanced, fair and even-handed. 
 In addition, the unions unanimously support it. 
 That gives us a far stronger base from which to campaign on trade union law than we have had before. 
 While blithely ignoring this fact, all Mr Clement will say is that &bquo;bluntly, the Shadow Cabinet and unions need to get their fingers out &mdash; with some expedition &mdash; to set the limits of the proposed legal framework&equo;. 
 It seems to have escaped him that we already have. 
 He claims there has been &bquo;a confusing flurry of paper involved in the evolution of policy&equo; &mdash; first the policy review document, then the TUC composite resolution, then the Meacher-Haigh clarifying statement 10 days ago on legal protections for unions, and then the conference debate, including my speech. 
 He then draws the breathtaking conclusion that &bquo;there has been nothing resembling intellectual coherence&equo;. 
 One has to ask, has he read them? 
 Can he point to one iota of inconsistency or lack of intellectual coherence between the policy review, the clarifying statement, and my speech? 
 It simply doesn't exist, and significantly he produces no evidence. 
 Mr Clement then says, presumably as a joke, that the clarification needs clarification. 
 And what reason does he give for thinking that? 
 That &bquo;the party and unions should set the level of fines that recalcitrant unions would incur&equo;. 
 So it all comes down, two years before the election, to stating the level of fines. 
 He seems to have missed my statement three weeks ago that fines would be &bquo;deterrent, sufficient to secure compliance with the law&equo;. 
 He then argues that &bquo;it is not sufficient (for me) to tell the conference that there will be no return to mass picketing&equo;. 
 Actually, I never mentioned picketing, mass picketing or otherwise, in my speech, but let that pass. 
 In fact, we have repeatedly said that we would retain the current Code of Practice on peaceful picketing which limits the number of pickets. 
 Next Mr Clement asks some questions about sympathy action, as though the answers were uncertain. 
 In fact, they are obvious. 
 &bquo;Would it be lawful for workers to refuse to handle imports from South Africa?&equo; 
 Answer, no. 
 &bquo;Would meat porters be allowed to take action in support of nurses?&equo; 
 Answer, no. 
 He queries our criterion of &bquo;having a genuine interest in the outcome of a dispute&equo; as a measure of connectedness in sympathy action. 
 He asked me that same question at the conference but, like Pontius Pilate, has not stayed to report my answer. 
 I told him we were simply adapting the phrase from the social security regulations, where for years it has worked perfectly satisfactorily in deciding whether or not a worker should get benefit if he is laid off at another workplace from the one where a dispute is taking place. 
 He does not, under section 19 of the 1975 Act, &bquo;unless he proves that he is not directly interested in the dispute&equo;. 
 Rather than asking generalised questions about applicability in a vacuum, this criterion, once the exact local circumstances are known, has proved readily workable, as I told Mr Clement. 
 Finally he argues the need &bquo;to bang the heads of union leaders together&equo; to resolve these issues. 
 Is he really blind to the fact that we have already done precisely that, and that is why an unprecedented consensus now exists on every aspect of the policy? 
 Building society plan for &bquo;school-term&equo; jobs 
 By HELEN HAGUE, Labour Correspondent 
 A MAJOR BUILDING society is introducing a &bquo;school-term&equo; employment scheme for parents who wish to take school holidays off work to look after their children. 
 The Alliance and Leicester initiative is among measures to stem staff turnover now being explored by finance sector companies as the labour market tightens. 
 It is being piloted in Hove, Sussex, and Oadby, Leicestershire, where the society has its administrative offices, and is open to employees with children aged between five and 14. 
 A company spokesman said last night the programme was part of a company-wide strategy to broaden its recruitment net. 
 &bquo;It is intended to enable parents to dovetail their career and family commitments and thereby to ease recruitment problems which are already being felt in all areas of commerce as a result of the steadily falling number of school leavers and graduates.&equo; 
 Jobs under the new scheme will command a salary in proportion to time worked. 
 Successful applicants will be able to build up entitlement to normal benefits such as concessionary mortgages. 
 Employees who opt for the scheme will be expected to revert to their former employment contract once their children reach 14. 
 The shortage of women solicitors and the difficulty in persuading many to return after having children is prompting the Law Society to consider setting up a creche for employees of firms in central London. 
 A meeting will be held tomorrow to assess demand. 
 Video workshop held at National Museum of Photography, Film and Television 
 By HELEN HAGUE, Labour Correspondent 
 A video image of Dale Kunzler, 10, from Todmorden, West Yorkshire, is projected upside down on a screen behind him during a video workshop at the &bquo;Let's Make A Film&equo; Festival held at the National Museum of Photography, Film and Television in Bradford at the weekend. 
 About 1,500 young people attended the event. 
 Anxiety grows over integrity of statistics 
 By ROSIE WATERHOUSE 
 CALLS FOR an independent body to monitor the Government's use of statistics followed two recent cases which attracted widespread criticism, but some academics have long been concerned about the independence of British official statistics. 
 The Prime Minister's decision to refuse funding for a survey of sexual behaviour to further research about the spread of Aids, and a new way of counting people in the poorest category of the population which reduced the number by one million, caused controversy. 
 However, Sir Claus Moser, former head of the Government Statistical Service (GSS), and Sir David Cox, a former president of the Royal Statistical Society (RSS), identify the turning point in the history of British official statistics as a White Paper in 1981 entitled Government Statistical Services. 
 In two and a half pages there were seven references to efficiency, five to value for money, four to economies and two each to savings and cost effectiveness. 
 Integrity, validity and reliability merited one mention each and objectivity got two. 
 Based on the Rayner Review, by Sir Derek (now Lord) Rayner, chairman of Marks and Spencer, the White Paper signalled a 25 per cent cut in the GSS and the Central Statistical Office (CSO) which then employed 540 professional statisticians and about 8,500 other staff at a cost of &pound;100m. 
 It also resulted in fundamental changes to the principles on which they operated. 
 The CSO, which passed from the control of the Cabinet Office to the Treasury earlier this year, prepares the National Accounts and many other economic statistics. 
 Its director is also head of the GSS and as such has considerable influence over statistics throughout Whitehall. 
 According to Sir Claus, who ran the services from 1967 to 1978: &bquo;Before the Rayner Review the purpose of the government statistical services was to serve several masters, first and foremost &mdash; and this was never in doubt - the Government; but also industry, academics the public, indeed the whole nation&hellip; 
 &bquo;What worries me most is the effect of the cuts following Rayner on the overall accuracy of government statistics.&equo; 
 The Rayner Review stated: &bquo;Particular attention needs to be paid to all information collected or costs incurred primarily to meet demands outside central government&hellip; in general there is no more reason for govermment to act as universal provider in the statistical field than in any other. 
 Information should not be collected primarily for publication. 
 It should be collected primarily because government needs it for its own businesses.&equo; 
 Sir David, who is a widely respected, moderate voice, has become increasingly concerned about the reputation and integrity of British official statistics. 
 &bquo;It is not just statistics that are involved, it is also research and information generally,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Informed public discussion of potentially controversial issues is being inhibited.&equo; 
 The fact that the RSS is even considering a proposal for an independent watchdog is interpreted by academics and scientists as highly significant, as the organisation typically projects a reserved and conservative image. 
 Until now, at least publicly, the society has played down the level of anxiety; it has resisted taking any action that could be seen as anti-government. 
 Privately, a number of distinguished members have decided that measures are needed because of a growing perception, nationally and internationally, that the integrity of official statistics was being eroded. 
 &bquo;The fact that there is concern, is itself cause for concern,&equo; Sir Claus said. 
 Recent causes for concern had related both to frequent revisions of figures as well as to integrity issues. 
 &bquo;Revisions of the National Accounts and balance of payments figures have caused worry. 
 One cause of this many be the cuts in basic information collected following the Rayner reforms.&equo; 
 Sir Claus pointed out that allegations of political interference in statistics are not new, and revealed that he twice threatened to resign over attempts to change or suppress reports under Labour governments. 
 He said: &bquo;I don't know of any government that has actually falsified figures. 
 But there are different grades of interference. 
 There is non-publication or limited circulation of figures. 
 Then there is changing definitions or the method of collection of statistics in such a way that something misleading is produced. 
 &bquo;At present I worry most about the unemployment statistics, the poverty data and any suggestions of tampering with the Retail Price Index.&equo; 
 He said he had wanted to see a national statistics council to act as a protective agency 10 years ago. 
 Such an organisation should be chaired by the RSS with representatives from government, industry and other sectors of the community. 
 Researchers allege figures &bquo;politically manipulated&equo; 
 By ROSIE WATERHOUSE 
 The Independent has interviewed pressure groups and independent researchers who do work commissioned by various government departments. 
 Their allegations include political manipulation of statistics, selective and misleading use of figures, failure to collect information which reflects badly on the Government's record, and constraints on research. 
 Here are some examples: Unemployment The 29th change affecting unemployment figures since 1979 was quietly introduced last July when 26,000 redundant miners were &bquo;relieved of the requirement&equo; to sign on, according to documents leaked from the Department of Employment. 
 Because they are now paid by the Department of Energy, they have been removed from the jobless totals. 
 The Unemployment Unit, a pressure group which calculates the unemployment figure as if the changes had not been made, claims it is 2,325,100 compared with the Government's figure of 1,751,000. 
 A recent Bank of England report for analysts concluded: &bquo;The sharper fall in unemployment than rise in employment has been due to the introduction of the Restart interviews and stricter availability-for-work tests. 
 Thus the Restart variable has, since 1986, contributed about 750,000 to the fall in unemployment.&equo; 
 Restart is aimed at the long-term unemployed and involves interviews with the employment department. 
 Those may or may not lead to training or jobs but once a person registers for an interview they are taken off the jobless total. 
 According to the Unemployment Unit's calculations including them takes the jobless total to more than three million. 
 Economy Nigel Lawson, Chancellor of the Exchequer, sparked a political dispute by proposing mortgage interest payments should no longer be included in the Retail Price Index (RPI), a move that would lower the apparent inflation rate. 
 No decision has been taken but he argues few countries include them, that they obscure the underlying trend and mean tightened monetary policy produces an illusory rise in monetary inflation. 
 Neil Kinnock, the Labour Party leader, told the Commons that any RPI not including mortgage interest payments would be &bquo;fraudulent&equo;. 
 NHS At the Conservative Party Conference in 1986, Norman Fowler, then Secretary of State for Health, was loudly cheered on producing a long computer printout of 380 new &bquo;large hospital schemes&equo; costing &pound;3bn, which he unrolled over the rostrum for the benefit of photographers from newspapers which had criticised the Tories' record on the NHS. 
 The list was so long because he counted every programme over &pound;1m &mdash; the previous definition was over &pound;5m &mdash; and included such projects as a car park at Medway Hospital in Kent. 
 Poverty Research by the Institute of Fiscal Studies (IFS) published last week showed the Department of Social Security has removed more than one million people from the poorest category of the population &mdash; having an income less than half the average wage, by changing the way figures are calculated. 
 Now it is assumed all in a household have an equal share of the total income. 
 Under the old method a pensioner, for example, or unemployed teenager, sharing a house with the family was assumed to have a separate, and often lower, income. 
 The Commons Social Services committee asked unsuccessfully for both sets of figures to be produced. 
 The IFS report Counting People With Low Incomes said that refusal &bquo;does nothing to allay fears that the changes were for political rather than bona fide methodological reasons&equo;. 
 Margaret Thatcher caused an uproar when she claimed 88 per cent of claimants would be better off after changes to social security benefits introduced in April 1988. 
 The Government's Social Security Advisory Committee chairman said 38 per cent would gain, 19 per cent would be unaffected and 43 per cent would lose out in real terms, taking inflation into account. 
 Ministers claimed &bquo;in cash terms&equo; 88 per cent would gain &mdash; but took no account of inflation. 
 Soon after Mrs Thatcher came to power in 1979 she disbanded the Royal Commission on the Distribution of Income and Wealth, set up as a permanent body by the Labour government in 1974 to report periodically on changes in distribution trends. 
 Hostels Researchers at The Policy Studies Institute were commissioned by the then Department of Health and Social Security to study the extent to which hostels for the needy provided care as well as accommodation and food, to enable the department to decide if, how, and by whom they should be funded. 
 Its report published in July last year, The Cost of Care in Hostels, concluded: &bquo;Even hostels offering relatively low care were still offering some care, and had to spend more than could be explained simply in terms of the costs of accommodation.&equo; 
 On the same day the DHSS published a consultation paper proposing changes which would deprive many of income. 
 The report called Help with Hostel Charges, Proposals for Change cited the PSI study and stated: &bquo;Many hostels provided little or no care to their residents. 
 Where care is provided, it is far more often in the form of advice than of assistance with physical care. 
 This is because the primary aim of most hostels is to meet a housing need.&equo; 
 Surveys into Aids fail to survive government veto 
 By ROSIE WATERHOUSE 
 THE LATEST controversy over political interference in research surfaced when a Sunday newspaper reported that the Prime Minister had personally pulled the plug on Department of Health funding for a survey of sexual habits to help scientists to predict the spread of Aids. 
 A pilot scheme involving 2,000 people had been successful and &pound;500,000 for a further survey of 20,000 people had been promised by the Health Education Authority and the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC). 
 The Department of Health had been expected to approve another &pound;250,000 when the story that it would refuse was leaked, apparently from Downing Street. 
 Researchers from the Imperial College of Science, Technology and Medicine in London, and an independent company, Social and Community Planning Research, which were to have carried out the survey, had not been informed officially. 
 But worse news came last week when the authority and the ESRC unexpectedly withdrew promises of funds. 
 The department had written to the ESRC: &bquo;In all the circumstances it is not appropriate for the Government to support it&hellip; and, more generally, it would not be appropriate for the Government to sponsor the survey.&equo; 
 The research council was forced to conclude it was being told not to help. 
 It was constrained by a clause in financial arrangements agreed two years ago between all five research councils and the Government whereby in exchange for more flexibility in approving most research grants, they relinquished independence in sponsoring some key research. 
 The councils had effectively agreed to a ministerial veto in sensitive areas including &bquo;matters liable significantly to involve ministers including highly contentious and politically sensitive matters of moment&equo;. 
 The Independent has discovered that another important survey of sexual behaviour connected with Aids research, commissioned by the health department, was prevented from being published. 
 The British Market Research Bureau had examined how the sexual habits of homosexuals had changed between 1986 and 1989. 
 Its paper was to be presented to a Market Research Society seminar last March when, with three days' notice, the health department instructed the authors to withdraw it. 
 It was cut out of conference papers and replaced with a notice slipped into the file saying: &bquo;The proposed paper on the Aids monitor has unfortunately had to be withdrawn, since it has not been possible to synchronise the publication with the Health Education Authority's own report on the 1988 data, expected in the near future.&equo; 
 The paper has still not been published. 
 Fears that the Government was putting constraints on research it commissions were fuelled when, last year, the then DHSS inserted a new clause in its contract with outside researchers. 
 It said: &bquo;Any publication of research material, or of the results of research, or of matters arising from such material or results, is subject to the prior consent of the Secretary of State, which consent shall not be unreasonably withheld.&equo; 
 Linked rail network &bquo;can bring Euro-megalopolis&equo; 
 By RICHARD NORTH 
 &bquo;ONLY A few small seas and rather larger mountain ranges stand in the way of the completion of a Euro-megalopolis which spreads from Glasgow to Milan&equo;, according to Terence Bendixson, a transport researcher. 
 A network of high-speed pan-European rail services could help to reduce road traffic jams within the Continent and ease pollution, he says in a report, Transport in the Nineties, the Shaping of Europe, for the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors, which meets in Paris this Thursday and Friday. 
 He wants a high speed railway with national companies owning the track but undertakings such as a privatised British Rail bidding for track-time to run services across Europe. 
 It would be likely to cost &pound;60bn. 
 &bquo;Unless the costs of traffic congestion can be reduced there is a danger that Europe's competitiveness in international markets will suffer,&equo; he says. 
 Other schemes for reducing congestion were &bquo;pay-as-you-drive&equo; road tolls, electronic signs on motorways warning of delays and in-car programmes plotting quickest routes. 
 The report points out that 70 million people live in the banana-shaped industrial complex which stretches from Britain to Italy. 
 Mr Bendixson quotes the work of Roger Brunet, a French geographer, who says a new &bquo;boulevard of the sun&equo; will open up on an east-west axis, from Barcelona to the Adriatic, hugging the north Mediterranean coast. 
 Mr Brunet notes that countries in the sun see migration northward towards, say Catalonia or the Po valley, while the countries of drizzle see migration towards their southern sectors. 
 This is the pull of incomes for poor people, and of sea, sun and snow for the rich. 
 Cars spread pollution, and scatter development along roads. 
 Aircraft are more polluting, probably, than is generally realised &mdash; therefore, enter the train. 
 Mr Bendixson quotes Professor Alain Bonnafous: &bquo;&hellip; the TGV should be seen as a low-flying Airbus. 
 It has little influence on places along the route, but a powerful one on those at the ends of it.&equo; 
 Mr Bendixson hopes that tunnelling under the Channel, the Oresund (between Sweden and Denmark), and under the Alps and Pyrenees, will bring new life to old cities, while preserving good countryside. 
 Drugs counsellor beaten to death 
 By RICHARD NORTH 
 POLICE are hunting the killer of a drugs centre counsellor who was found battered to death at her office in Worcester. 
 The body of Elizabeth Page-Alucard, 41, was found on Saturday by her boyfriend, Peter Hook, 25, after he had reported her missing to the police. 
 The couple lived together in the village of Bramsford, about five miles from Worcester. 
 A post-mortem examination showed Mrs Page-Alucard died from a fracture of the thyroid bone in her neck and head injuries. 
 Chief Supt David Foster said there was no indication of a sexual attack and police were still searching for a murder weapon. 
 There were signs of a struggle in the office, run by the charity Turning Point, but he added: &bquo;The motive for this killing is unclear.&equo; 
 He said there did not appear to have been a break-in. 
 There was no formal appointments system at the centre and people with drugs problems could just &bquo;drop in&equo; to talk to counsellors. 
 A spokesman for Turning Point said that Mrs Page-Alucard had worked for the the charity for three years and was a very experienced and valuable worker. 
 Les Rudd, chief executive, said: &bquo;Turning Point, like any other organisation that deals with the general public, has a range of policies to ensure staff safety and minimise risks at work. 
 &bquo;It is routine procedure that there needs to be more than one staff member on the premises when a project is open to the public. 
 This procedure obviously was not followed in this case and Turning Point is looking into what happened.&equo; 
 Compromise sought over move to ban ivory trade 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 EFFORTS TO reach a compromise over a move to ban all trade in ivory were under way last night as delegates gathered for the conference of the world's wildlife monitoring organisation. 
 Representatives from 103 countries which are parties to the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (Cites) are still deeply split, but alternative proposals are being canvassed to prevent a confrontation. 
 A Tanzanian proposal for an ivory trade ban is officially the only formal resolution tabled so far, Jean-Patrick Le Duc, a Cites spokesman, said. 
 The resolution would move the African elephant and its &bquo;products&equo; from a listing on the Cites appendix II &mdash; which allows regulated trade and a quota system for African nations &mdash; to Appendix I, where all trade is banned. 
 The proposal comes after a decade in which the number of elephants in Africa has declined from 1.3 million to barely 600,000. 
 Tanzania, Kenya and other east and central African nations have been particularly affected. 
 Southern African countries, particularly Zimbabwe, whose elephant herd numbers are rising, allowing them to make valuable foreign exchange from culling the animals, have already announced that they will not accept a Cites ban. 
 If Tanzania's ban fails to secure the required two-thirds majority, the Cites secretariat is ready to propose a range of measures to tighten control on the trade. 
 This could include providing for zero quotas on all African nations &mdash; or selectively reducing quotas to help stop poached ivory slipping into legal trade. 
 Cites officials maintain that a complete ban will not work and suggest strengthening the present control system through a variety of measures: controls on worked ivory; regulation of domestic manufacturing and retail industries; the registration of dealers; and greater trade analysis and monitoring. 
 This would require far greater funding by the parties to Cites for an investigations and ivory unit. 
 Acid roadblock 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 Police turned back hundreds of cars heading into Kent for a suspected acid house party in the Chatham area. 
 It was the second time in 24 hours that they had acted to stop a party in the county. 
 Marine reunion 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 Hundreds of graduates of the Royal Marines School of Music at Deal gathered for their annual reunion service two weeks after 10 bandsmen were killed by an IRA bomb. 
 Gas caused blast 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 British Gas has confirmed that a gas escape from a fractured main was the likely cause of an explosion which demolished an Edinburgh tenement, killing two people. 
 The gas probably reached the Guthrie Street building along a sewer. 
 Wall reselected 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 Pat Wall, the left-wing Labour MP for Bradford North, was reselected as candidate for the next general election after challenges from Mohammed Riaz, a city councillor, and a union official, Gerry Sutcliffe. 
 Police in accident 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 Robert Heslop, 70, of Tanfield Lea, Stanley, Co Durham, died from head injuries after being in an accident with a police car on Saturday night while crossing a road. 
 Liver setback 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 Aisling Barnett, who had a liver transplant after a television appeal for a donor, was on a ventilator machine at King's College Hospital, London, after developing an infection. 
 Students face jail 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 A group of 14 Irish student leaders face jail sentences for contempt today after ignoring a Dublin High Court injunction obtained by the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children barring publication of information on abortion services in Britain. 
 It is seeking to have the order made permanent. 
 70 rescued from North Sea rig 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 Seventy people working for Penrod Drilling Company were rescued by helicopter from a gas drilling rig in the North Sea yesterday after a leak on a platform near by. 
 Last night experts were trying to find the cause of the leak, in an out-of-service well at Conoco's Vulcan field, 40 miles north-east of Great Yarmouth, Norfolk. 
 No relief on poll tax for MPs 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 Sir Geoffrey Howe, leader of the House of Commons, last night denied MPs would be exempt from paying poll tax on second homes &mdash; but agreed they would be able to reclaim the full cost from allowances. 
 MPs are allowed to claim all costs of living away from home, whether hotel accommodation or the full charge of running a private flat in the capital. 
 70 rescued from 
 Labour lead over Tories confirmed by latest poll 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Correspondent 
 THE LATEST opinion poll, a comprehensive survey of 10,000 voters carried out for the Press Association news agency, last night gave Labour an eight-point lead over the Conservatives. 
 The poll, by ICM Research in 341 British constituencies between 26 September and last Monday, put Labour at 45 per cent; Conservatives, 37; Greens, 8; Social and Liberal Democrats, 4; Social Democrats, 3; Scottish Nationalists, 2; and Plaid Cymru, 1. 
 Although suggestions of a Labour government are premature with an election possibly two years off, Kenneth Baker, Conservative Party chairman, yesterday accepted his party was in some difficulties. 
 It was his job to turn difficulties into opportunities, he said. 
 In interviews throughout the day, he and cabinet colleagues made statements which suggested the softening-up process had begun &mdash; with representatives at this week's party conference in their sights. 
 Replying to common criticism that Margaret Thatcher tended to be a one-woman band, Mr Baker said on BBC television's On the Record: &bquo;I think there will be a growing amount of Cabinet discussion. 
 But I start that by saying there was already a considerable amount of Cabinet discussion.&equo; 
 Nevertheless, he appeared to suggest Mrs Thatcher &bquo;may well have been&equo; open to the charge of stifling dissent in the past. 
 Mr Baker also conceded &bquo;there will be in the 1990s inescapable areas of expenditure where there has got to be increases, for example, in caring for the elderly&equo;. 
 As for government mistakes, he said: &bquo;I think that as a consequence of the Stock Exchange crash in 1987, when the richest countries in the world all decided collectively to avoid a 1930s-type recession, and collectively there was an expansionist policy followed across the world and the tap marked &bquo;money&equo; was turned on, perhaps that tap was left on too long; not only in our country but in other countries as well.&equo; 
 Such concessions will be seen by many critics as timely. 
 John Biffen, former Leader of the Commons, said in yesterday's Observer: &bquo;The conference theme is &bquo;the Right Team&equo;. 
 It is a welcome emphasis upon collective leadership&hellip; 
 If there is a changing mood in British politics favouring moderation I suspect the Conservative Party&hellip; is about to react to it.&equo; 
 But Mrs Thatcher has shown her ability to temper her style in the past, meeting public criticism, only to reassert herself when interest rates and taxes fall, and popularity rises once more. 
 The Press Association poll puts Mrs Thatcher top of the league among main party leaders for toughness (82 per cent), competence (53), and arrogance (55). 
 Neil Kinnock scored most for being down-to-earth (41 per cent) and was also considered more trustworthy than Mrs Thatcher &mdash; scoring 26 per cent to the Prime Minister's 21 per cent. 
 Mr Kinnock would be in Downing Street with an overall majority of 28 seats if there were a general election tomorrow, according to a Mori aggregate poll in The Times, which surveyed more than 7,500 people over three months. 
 The figures are: Labour, 45 per cent; Conservatives, 38; Greens, 7; SLD, 5; SDP, 4; others, 1 
 New rules &bquo;will remove 50,000 from jobless total&equo; 
 By HELEN HAGUE, Labour Correspondent 
 CONTROVERSIAL regulations come into force today requiring people out of work for more than 13 weeks to accept low-paid jobs or risk losing their benefit. 
 The Government expects the new &bquo;actively seeking work&equo; provisions of the Social Security Act to remove up to 50,000 people from the unemployment register, saving &pound;100m a year. 
 However, a draft report by a secret ministerial advisory group reviewing &bquo;persistent unemployment&equo; suggests further measures to bring down the jobless tally could be in the pipeline. 
 The Department of Employment document, prepared in March for the Secretary's Strategy Group (SSG) maps out &bquo;possible future strategies&equo; for dealing with the problem of long-term unemployment. 
 The politically-sensitive option of &bquo;increased pressure to join Employment Training&equo; &mdash; the Government's scheme for the long-term unemployed &mdash; is canvassed. 
 By designating the programme an approved training scheme, claimant advisers could &bquo;use it selectively to apply sanctions to unco-operative claimants in areas where training might be useful&equo;. 
 But it says this could lead to &bquo;presentational difficulties&equo; given ministerial assurances that the &bquo;actively seeking work&equo; condition would not affect ET because it was voluntary. 
 However, though this &bquo;looks unlikely to be politically feasible in the short-term it may be an issue for next year when ET is fully established&equo;. 
 The document, leaked to the Unemployment Unit, also suggests that making Restart courses for the unemployed &bquo;compulsory for certain groups could help the service deal with more poorly-motivated clients&equo;. 
 It could also &bquo;justify a bid for some limited additional resources&equo; from central government. 
 The paper admits that employment is the destination of &bquo;only a minority&equo; of those who leave the unemployment register after two years. 
 &bquo;The main cause of the projected reduction of the group over the PES (Public Expenditure Survey) period will be reduced inflows to long-term unemployment rather than the (slightly) reduced outflows.&equo; 
 Michael Meacher, Labour's employment spokesman, last night said: &bquo;The formula is not just another in the long line of bureaucratic barriers which prevent the unemployed claiming benefit. 
 It is a return to the 1930s idea that people out of work had to humble themselves to be given benefit they were entitled to. 
 Now a rise in unemployment looks certain to follow the latest rise in interest rates, we can expect to see &bquo;actively seeking work&equo; enforced with even greater severity and bias.&equo; 
 RUC officer dies in car bomb incident 
 By HELEN HAGUE, Labour Correspondent 
 The damaged car in which a senior RUC officer, Supt Alwyn Harris, (right) died yesterday when a bomb exploded under it. 
 Mr Harris, 51, and his wife were setting out for church in Lisburn, Co Antrim. 
 She escaped serious injury. 
 He was the third high-ranking RUC officer to be murdered in Northern Ireland this year  
 Kurd refused asylum dies after fire 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 A KURDISH refugee who set fire to himself after being told his application for political asylum in Britain had failed has died, intensifying criticism of the Home Office's handling of the Kurds' plight, writes Mike Prestage. 
 The death of Shio Tyiven, 26, in Mount Vernon Hospital, Hillingdon, west London, yesterday will further focus attention on efforts by more than 3,000 Alevi Kurds to avoid being returned to Turkey, where they fear persecution. 
 Mr Tyiven and Dogan Arslan started a fire inside their locked room at Harmondsworth detention centre, near Heathrow airport, last Thursday. 
 Mr Arslan is in Stoke Mandeville Hospital, Buckinghamshire, with 30 per cent burns. 
 Sherif Xemgin, for the Kurdish Workers' Association &mdash; a group to which Mr Tyiven belonged &mdash; said the death showed the fear that gripped refugees. 
 &bquo;The Home Office takes the attitude these people are here for economic reasons; you don't go this far for &pound;25 a week income support payments. 
 People are determined not to return to Turkey.&equo; 
 The association hoped the death would bring a softening of Home Office attitudes towards Kurds seeking asylum. 
 But Mr Xemgin said: &bquo;I would like to think his death would bring changes, but somehow I doubt it.&equo; 
 The Home Office said 100 applications for political asylum from Kurds were handled each week in accordance with United Nations guidelines. 
 Dutch &bquo;salmonella eggs&equo; allowed on the market 
 By LIZ HUNT 
 DUTCH eggs known to be infected with salmonella were allowed to go on sale in Britain without a public health warning being issued, it was confirmed yesterday. 
 The Ministry of Agriculture said eggs taken from consignments imported last month, showed evidence of salmonella contamination. 
 Salmonella has been found in four other consignments &mdash; mainly from Holland &mdash; since April. 
 No warnings were issued to consumers because earlier advice from the Department of Health about the dangers of salmonella and the importance of cooking eggs thoroughly, was felt to be sufficient, the ministry said. 
 About 3 per cent of eggs sold in the UK are imported, the majority from France and Holland. 
 Sixty eggs are removed from each consignment &mdash; about 300,000 eggs &mdash; and tested for salmonella. 
 Results are not known for at least four days, and to prevent the eggs going off the consignments are allowed through. 
 It is impossible to recall contaminated eggs as they are distributed to packing stations around the country, where they are packed under British brand names. 
 A ministry spokeswoman said the testing was &bquo;not intended to stop the eggs going onto the market&equo;. 
 It was to help discover which EC states had a salmonella problem and to improve controls throughout the EC. 
 She emphasised that only a small proportion of the 30 million eggs eaten daily in the UK would be affected. 
 The ministry would be writing to its Dutch counterpart. 
 Under EC regulations contaminated eggs cannot be banned from the UK nor can eggs be labelled as &bquo;imported&equo;. 
 The United Kingdom Egg Producers and Retailers Association said the ministry's testing was &bquo;purely cosmetic&equo;. 
 British egg production had decreased because of constraints imposed on it by the ministry. 
 The shortfall was being met by imported eggs from countries where there was no testing or compulsory slaughter of infected flocks. 
 Nuns fight to save flock of hens 
 By LIZ HUNT 
 THE Northamptonshire nuns who are trying to save 5,000 chickens are to take legal action against the Ministry of Agriculture's decision to slaughter their flock. 
 Lawyers acting for the 14 nuns are due to see a judge in chambers today to ask for a judicial review which would effectively prevent ministry officials carrying out the slaughter at Our Lady of the Passion Monastery near Daventry. 
 . Earlier this month traces of Salmonella typhimurium were found in swabs taken from the hen house. 
 Under the Zoonoses Order 1989, the ministry can slaughter any infected flock. 
 The Mother Superior, Mother Catherine, 82, said there had never been a case of food poisoning associated with eggs from the monastery. 
 Sale of the eggs is their only source of income, and they are confident they can prove there is no risk to public health. 
 The nuns say they are &bquo;battle weary&equo; but determined to continue their fight. 
 &bquo;Someone had to make a stand for the egg producers,&equo; Mother Catherine said. 
 &bquo;They were being steam-rollered. 
 Evil is done because the good, too often, stay quiet.&equo; 
 They are being backed by the United Kingdom Egg Producers and Retailers Association which says their plight has highlighted the problems being faced by thousands of small egg producers after publicity over salmonella infection. 
 The association has launched a fighting fund and hopes to raise &pound;50,000 to help the nuns establish another business, making Belgian chocolates. 
 The ministry yesterday confirmed that it intended to slaughter the birds. 
 &bquo;We will exercise our duty in the interests of public health,&equo; a spokesman said. 
 Health officials to meet Acas for ambulance talks 
 By HELEN HAGUE 
 FRESH ATTEMPTS to break the ambulance pay dispute deadlock are expected to coincide tomorrow with a health service union lobby of the Conservative Party conference as it opens in Blackpool, writes Helen Hague. 
 Department of Health officials have agreed to meet the conciliation service, Acas. 
 But they are resisting pressure to refer the disputed 6.5 per cent pay rise to independent binding arbitration. 
 The department emphasised last night that it had agreed to meet Acas in its advisory capacity. 
 Both sides are under mounting public pressure to settle the three-week dispute. 
 About 3,500 ambulance officers and control room staff joined the crews' ban on overtime last week. 
 The unions hope to embarrass Kenneth Clarke, Secretary of State for Health, with tomorrow's lobby and believe that many Tories at the conference back their call for an increased offer. 
 The war of words intensified last week when Mr Clarke accused the unions of using patients as &bquo;fodder for pay claims&equo;. 
 Roger Poole, union chief negotiatior, described Mr Clarke's letter as &bquo;totally and utterly appalling&equo;. 
 Over the weekend only a third of ambulance crews were working in London, where the dispute is taking the biggest toll because of staff shortages. 
 Heart attack risk &bquo;greater in short men&equo; 
 By LIZ HUNT 
 SHORT men are twice as likely as tall men to have heart attacks in middle age, according to a new study by the British Heart Foundation, writes Liz Hunt. 
 More than 7,000 men from all over Britain took part in the eight-year study. 
 Of the 1,533 men under 5ft 6ins, 118 of them suffered a heart attack compared with only 62 of the 1,533 men who were over 5ft 10ins. 
 The shorter men were more at risk because they had less efficient lung function compared with the taller men, according to the researchers at The Royal Free Hospital, north London. 
 They tended to have smaller lungs, but other causes may be involved. 
 Writing in the International Journal of Epidemiology, the researchers said: &bquo;It is possible that lung function like height is a marker of the effects of growth and development of childhood environmental factors such as nutrition and infection.&equo; 
 The shorter men also had slightly higher blood pressure and higher blood cholesterol levels than the taller men. 
 They also tended to be heavier smokers, the study found. 
 The researchers said that their findings should be an &bquo;added incentive&equo; to short men to maintain a healthy lifestyle. 
 Late counter-attack saves day for Karpov 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 AFTER the weekend's play in the Pilkington Glass World Chess Championship semi-finals, Anatoly Karpov and Jan Timman have maintained their leads, despite some unconvincing play from all four contestants. 
 No one could quite understand what Karpov was trying to do in Saturday's game against Artur Yusupov. 
 With the white pieces, he seemed intent on avoiding any continuation that might give him an advantage, playing into total equality, then drifting into an inferior position and time-trouble. 
 With one minute for five moves, however, he seemed to wake up, launching a counter-attack which forced a draw. 
 On Sunday, Yusupov claimed a time-out (each player is allowed one such postponement), so the score remains at Karpov 2&frac12; Yusupov 1&frac12;. 
 While Karpov was taking the difficult road to a draw, Speelman and Timman were trying hard to beat each other. 
 Jon Speelman, unusually for him, opened 1. 
 e4 and equally unusually achieved what looked like a considerable advantage from the opening. 
 Timman unleashed some tactics and the watching grandmasters switched their allegiance. 
 In a difficult endgame, however, inaccuracies by the Dutch grandmaster let Speelman seize the initiative again. 
 The game was adjourned after 63 moves, with Speelman trying to win with rook and bishop against rook and pawn. 
 This is a theoretical draw, but Timman may have to suffer several hours of torture before he can claim the half-point. 
 The game resumes today. 
 Despite being one game behind, Speelman seems to have recovered from his hesitant start to the match. 
 After the encouragement of emerging with the advantage after a complex struggle in the fourth game, he began Sunday's game in uncompromising style, playing the reputedly risky Dutch defence. 
 Timman advanced, creating problems for Speelman with a pawn thrust deep into his opponent's position, splitting Black's forces. 
 Speelman, however, defended patiently, before surrounding and taking the pawn. 
 After 43 moves, he was a pawn up, but Timman's pressure provided ample compensation and the players, somewhat surprisingly, agreed a draw. 
 Timman leads 21 2 &mdash; 11 2 with one game unfinished. 
 70 rescued after North Sea gas leak 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 (First Edition) SEVENTY people were rescued from a gas drilling rig in the North Sea yesterday after a leak on a platform near by. 
 Last night experts were trying to find the cause of the leak, in an out-of-service well at Conoco's Vulcan field, 40 miles north-east of Great Yarmouth, Norfolk. 
 The 70 men, employees of the Penrod Drilling Company, were safely transferred from the Penrod 92 rig to the nearby Britoil Loggs platform by helicopter, Conoco said. 
 The rig was working in the &bquo;V&equo; Field complex of gas fields opened in September 1988. 
 Conoca said: &bquo;A leak has developed inside one well of the unmanned platform and gas is leaking up to the surface. 
 The crew of a drilling rig have been evacuated.&equo; 
 The company added that a standby boat was keeping an eye on the situation. 
 Conoco was trying to find out the cause of the leak, before it could decide how to stop it. 
 It added: &bquo;We are very pleased that the procedures have worked and people have come out of this safely with no casualties.&equo; 
 The &bquo;V&equo; Field complex Vulcan, North Valiant, South Valiant and Vanguard comprises nine manned and robot platforms, linked by bridges. 
 Kisses from a glamorous old trouper: Shirley Bassey tells Jim White of her determination to survive in an era when showbiz is run by yuppies 
 By JIM WHITE 
 HANDS coquettishly on hips, like a girl in the playground sneering at her friends, Shirley Bassey is defining her raison d'etre. 
 &bquo;EastEnders, Coronation Street, Emmerdale Farm. 
 Who's interested? 
 I don't want the kitchen sink. 
 Give me Dallas and Dynasty. 
 I want glamour.&equo; 
 The setting is the tea-room of the Ritz and the dress is slinky &mdash; a tight black jersey number, split at the side to allow a long, black-stockinged leg to be flourished with full drama. 
 &bquo;I want escapism. 
 I want Showbiz.&equo; 
 Everybody knows who Shirley Bassey is. 
 They may never have heard one of her records, but when Joe Longthorne, or any of those impressionists who have made a career perfecting the quiver of her lip, does his Shirley Bassey everyone knows who he means. 
 The two elderly Americans who squeezed past her chair ('Hey Harry, have you signed the bill? ') knew who she was. 
 Even the waiters were excited, and they've seen everyone &mdash; Clement Freud had just vacated the table next door. 
 Shirley knows that everybody knows who she is. 
 &bquo;They are sitting in the lobby of my hotel now, waiting for me. 
 And that frightens me. 
 Not physically, I don't think they want to hurt me, but your life is not your own.&equo; 
 She wears big dark glasses and insists on sitting with her back to the throng, coincidentally facing the mirror. 
 But when the time comes to leave, she can't help going in a showbiz way, negotiating the steps of the Ritz in her towering leopard-skin stilettos like she's on the set of a Busby Berkeley musical. 
 We may be a grandmother, but we can still walk across the tea-room with a girlish flick of the bottom. 
 Britain's most successful entertainer ('I'm not a pop singer, I hate that word. 
 I'm, I'm, I'm&hellip; an Entertainer') was born in Tiger Bay, Cardiff, some time before the war, the seventh child of a mother from northern England and a father from Nigeria. 
 At the time, in a cosmopolitan place, racism was not on the agenda. 
 &bquo;The odd kid at school would call me names, but not for long, boy. 
 There was a fighter at the time called Joe &bquo;Kid&equo; Bassey and people used to think we were related. 
 And there was prejudice once when I went for a job. 
 They made out I wasn't any good at arithmetic, which I wasn't, but that wasn't the reason. 
 It was the colour of my skin. 
 But it was not enough to give me a complex, not as it would have been in America. 
 I was glad I was born in Wales.&equo; 
 It was only when she went to America, headlining for the first time, that she came across the curious racial classification with which music there is compartmentalised. 
 &bquo;When I opened in Vegas and I sang &bquo;Goldfinger&equo;, they all said, &bquo;Why is this black girl singing a white girl's song?&equo; 
 They had never seen me so they thought I was white. 
 They said I had a white voice. 
 I never thought of that. 
 I thought I just had a voice.&equo; 
 Her voice was first noticed in choirs in her home town. 
 It was not long before she had left home and was on the road. 
 Living first in Switzerland and now in Spain, she only really sees Britain when she is here to work. 
 This early departure, she thinks, explains the lack of attachment she has for home, for her Welshness. 
 She doesn't go dewy-eyed when the Marbella orchestra strikes up &bquo;Land of my Fathers&equo;. 
 &bquo;I'd like to be able to say yes I do, but I left so long ago. 
 I'm not really Welsh by blood and I don't speak the language. 
 I love to play Cardiff though, I'm at my very best there.&equo; 
 One thing she does go dewy-eyed about, however, is the old show business days. 
 The constituency to which she appeals, the family audience aged from eight to 80 seeking a big-production glamour night out, has contracted. 
 For this she blames the record companies, run by yuppies with no feel for showbiz. 
 &bquo;It's all gone downhill. 
 It's all geared to the kids, the teenyboppers. 
 Nobody's thinking that there are middle-aged people, grannies and mums and 20 to 30-year-olds who want to be entertained. 
 Fortunately I still have an audience, otherwise I would be redundant, I would be a pensioner. 
 A 29-year-old pensioner.&equo; 
 Except for Sting and George Michael ('wonderful voice, writes great songs'), she has little time for most modern pop. 
 &bquo;On television they are miming. 
 And these kids spend money on it. 
 Are they aware that they are miming? 
 Which for me, an old trouper, is fraudulent.&equo; 
 Particularly, she has little time for a group called Yello, the Swiss electro-band with whom she collaborated on a single last year, much in the way Liza Minelli and the Pet Shop Boys or Gene Pitney and Marc Almond have. 
 Sadly, it was not as successful a partnership as these others. 
 &bquo;I loved the song, and I think it should have been a hit, but there again the record company did nothing to promote it. 
 The video was too contemporary. 
 It should have been very sophisticated. 
 I mean people saw it and said, &bquo;That's not Shirley Bassey.&equo; 
 Shirley Bassey is glamour, sophistication, sex. 
 But they (Yello) didn't want that, and they were in on everything. 
 They wouldn't let me plug it by myself.&equo; 
 Pop may have disappointed, but she has no ambition to move into a more refined orbit. 
 &bquo;No. 
 Why disappoint yourself? 
 I am a singer. 
 I would like to do something classical but I can't. 
 It's too late to train. 
 I was once introduced to Sir somebody, David Webb I think, who was in charge of the Opera House. 
 &bquo;God, I see you as a Carmen,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If only you could sing opera.&equo; 
 And madam in all innocence said, &bquo;Well why can't I do Carmen?&equo; 
 And he said, &bquo;The key is not your key.&equo; 
 'Well couldn't we change the key?&equo; 
 And the man had a mouthful of champagne and I thought he was going to have a heart attack.&equo; 
 It was an innocent remark, because for her act songs are tailored to her range. 
 &bquo;I hear a song and I tell my musical director what tempo I want it in, and how it's going to end. 
 The ending is very important. 
 The Bassey end.&equo; 
 She had been rehearsing a new song on the way to the Ritz, but didn't know who wrote it. 
 &bquo;I don't know, all I know is Johnny Mathis did it, and it's a lovely song. 
 It doesn't matter who wrote it, I like it.&equo; 
 Frank Sinatra always mentions the writer when he introduces a song, but it is not through generosity, she believes. 
 &bquo;Well, Americans do that. 
 They mention everyone who's had anything to do with the song. 
 It's to rest the voice, you know. 
 Americans love to talk. 
 I just want to get on and do it. 
 You notice how few songs they do. 
 I mean my act is all songs, songs, songs.&equo; 
 Then, after Earl Grey tea and cucumber sandwiches and no holding back on the cake and scones, the perfectly maintained Bassey chassis repaired to the Ritz's dining room for a photo session. 
 It was a wonderful performance, a feast of perfectly choreographed poses and pouts. 
 &bquo;I think I was a stripper in my previous life, or will be in the next,&equo; she said, curling her leg round an opulent red curtain. 
 &bquo;I'd love to take my clothes off on stage. 
 Everyone goes on about Cher's dresses, showing her navel. 
 I was wearing dresses that showed more than she ever would dare, before she was born. 
 Or perhaps not before she was born.&equo; 
 At the end, the photographer kissed her on both cheeks. 
 &bquo;I've wanted to do that all my life,&equo; he said. 
 As she left, I shook her hand. 
 &bquo;Have a kiss. 
 Don't let the photographer get all the perks.&equo; 
 Shirley Bassey's 20-date British tour culminates in an appearance at Wembley Arena on 4 November accompanied by the London Symphony Orchestra. 
 Muddling along with Stalinism: Marlies Menge visits an East Berlin family which has not joined the exodus to the West 
 By MARLIES MENGE 
 THE SCHRODERS live on the fourth floor of a house in East Berlin. 
 On the last flight of steps to their flat they have stuck posters on the wall, mostly landscapes: a colourful picture of Provence, an advertisement for southern Sweden, the Caucasus mountains, St Mark's Square in Venice. 
 The posters are intended to cheer up the staircase, which is in urgent need of renovation. 
 Elke Schroder opens the door for me. 
 She is 37 years old, a teacher. 
 She invites me into the living room, pours me a coffee, sits down beside me, slips her shoes off and groans about the working day she has just been through. 
 Two of her colleagues have gone to the West in the past three months. 
 The others have to cover their work. 
 &bquo;And of course the children ask why everyone is going. 
 In my class four pupils were missing after the holidays. 
 What should we tell the children? 
 They are no longer content to swallow the cheap arguments our politicians and newspapers offer.&equo; 
 Had she, then, not thought of going to West Germany? 
 &bquo;Obviously I think about it, every East German has at some time thought about it, or still does. 
 But no, I like my work, and there are many unemployed teachers over there. 
 And we have no relatives there, so we cannot even travel to West Germany to see uncles and aunts. 
 On the other hand, when you see thousands climbing over the embassy railings as if the Devil were at their heels, you think you must be stupid to stay.&equo; 
 Eight-year-old Claudia hears the last sentence. 
 She is on the floor playing with the family dachshund. 
 &bquo;Could he come with us to the West?&equo; she asks. 
 &bquo;No, you are probably not allowed to leave the country with dogs,&equo; her mother says. 
 &bquo;Then I'll stay here,&equo; decides Claudia. 
 Seventeen-year-old Fabian comes home. 
 An argument develops between mother and son about a rock concert which Fabian desperately wants to go to. 
 His mother would rather he studied. 
 Fabian is studying at secondary school for the abitur or school-leaving certificate (equivalent to English A-levels), and also learning to be a construction worker. 
 To study for the abitur is a privilege in East Germany. 
 Usually only two out of 10 classes get that far. 
 Two others are taking the path chosen by Fabian. 
 After the exam he will study at the building academy to become a building engineer like his father. 
 He had wanted to be a vet, but all his plans had come to nothing. 
 Fabian grumbles: &bquo;Ah, why didn't I just go to Hungary as well&hellip; 
 &bquo;Going to Hungary has become a synonym for going to the West. 
 He slams the door behind him. 
 A few minutes later music drones from his room. 
 The Schroders are lucky with their flat, four fine big light rooms, kitchen and bathroom, for 100 marks rent a month. 
 They had swapped it for a modern flat in a concrete skyscraper. 
 They had gas heating installed, and claimed most of the cost back from the communal housing authorities. 
 Father and son did the painting. 
 &bquo;What's keeping Jochen?&equo; asks Elke. 
 &bquo;He only wanted to go to the out-patients. 
 He had a splinter in his nail that had become inflamed.&equo; 
 Jochen, two years older than his wife, came in quite late. 
 He had had to wait four hours in the out-patients department, he said. 
 Only one doctor was there, three had left the country. 
 If this goes on any longer, he was going too, the doctor had told him. 
 This just wouldn't work, Jochen said. 
 Something had to happen eventually. 
 Never had the commitment of those who wanted to stay been as strong as now. 
 At his workplace a list for the &bquo;New Forum&equo; campaign was going round. 
 Jochen had signed it. 
 &bquo;We cannot keep muddling along like this forever. 
 Everywhere Stalinism is being reformed and openly discussed, in Hungary, Poland, the Soviet Union. 
 Only we are behaving as if it's nothing to do with us and that only the West is to blame for the thousands who turn their back on us.&equo; 
 Elke has laid the table for the evening meal and fried the eggs. 
 The family sits down to eat. 
 Elke says she has tried once more in vain to buy a decent pullover for Fabian and tells how unfriendly the saleswoman in the shop was. 
 She could well understand how women in particular wanted to get away to the West where daily life was so much more convenient. 
 For the daily chores fell mainly on the shoulders of the women: shopping, running around to find particular things. 
 Jochen and Elke warn Fabian not to go out on the streets on 7 October for the 40th anniversary of the formation of East Germany, and for God's sake not to demonstrate. 
 That the state would certainly not allow. 
 Otherwise he could forget his abitur and his studies. 
 The anniversary was to be celebrated with a torchlit procession, military parade and fireworks. 
 For weeks the newspapers had been full of stories about it, with, over and over again, people describing how well they lived in this country, how much they loved their homeland, how they did everything to strengthen East German socialism &mdash; as if there were not several thousand people leaving the country in a panic at the time. 
 &bquo;I think of it as a stuffy old family that wants to celebrate the birthday of an aged aunt. 
 Everyone has it impressed upon them that on the day there will be no discussion of any problem. 
 Everyone has to join in the charade: ah, what a good family we are! 
 And when a problem cannot be brushed aside, then a scapegoat must be found. 
 In our case it's the reform groups, and of course the bad, bad West.&equo; 
 The author is East Germany correspondent of Die Zeit. 
 The interview took place before this weekend's demonstrations. 
 Four men on an upturned boat 
 By DAVID BARBER 
 IT WILL probably be a month before the results of an official inquiry are published and sceptics silenced, but experts in New Zealand are already calling the voyage of the Rose-Noelle one of the most remarkable stories ever told of survival at sea. 
 Doubts remain about the saga of four men who spent 118 days drifting atop their upturned trimaran after it had been flipped by a huge wave before being washed up on an island near Auckland. 
 Investigators, astounded that the four could survive such an ordeal in the southern hemisphere winter, are puzzled by a number of details. 
 But there is nothing to support the theory that the crew made up the story, and no apparent motive for them to do so. 
 The craft's owner-skipper, John Glennie, a lifelong seafarer who survived a previous shipwreck, shrugs it off. 
 &bquo;There are always sceptics. 
 They are people who never do anything, who never go sailing or climb mountains.&equo; 
 Captain Mel Bowen, a Ministry of Transport investigator, seems to have made up his mind after interviewing Mr Glennie and the three others. 
 &bquo;Suspicion will be laid to rest by fact rather than hearsay and rumour.&equo; 
 The facts as related by the Rose-Noelle's crew are that the 41-foot trimaran left Picton, on New Zealand's South Island, for Tonga on 1 June and capsized in a storm about 125 miles off the North Island on 4 June. 
 The boat drifted in a north- west semi-circle, covering at least 1,000 nautical miles, until hitting Great Barrier Island, north of Auckland, on 30 September. 
 The crew said they had survived on the upturned hull, sleeping huddled together in a compartment the size of a double bed. 
 Scepticism arose with the first television interviews. 
 The four, who had trimmed each other's hair, did not fit the popular image of castaways, and their mental state appeared sound. 
 Flames of doubt were fanned by the crew's insistence that they had activated the emergency radio beacon for a week, though it was not picked up. 
 In addition, the last radio reports purportedly from the Rose-Noelle had been received on 6 and 9 June &mdash; days after its capsize &mdash; the latter giving its position as near the Kermadec islands, en route to Tonga and 620 miles north of Auckland. 
 This prompted a fruitless air search at the end of June when the yacht had not reached Tonga. 
 Another mystery is how the yacht drifted north-west when prevailing conditions would normally have sent it towards South America. 
 The Rose-Noelle was well-equipped as Mr Glennie had set off to start a new life cruising the South Pacific. 
 The crew salvaged some food and had a barbecue on which they grilled fish and birds using timber from the boat. 
 Rice and crates of soft drinks survived the capsize and a system was rigged up to collect rainwater. 
 The fish and fruit diet sustained them well, though a doctor diagnosed Mr Glennie, who lost 22lb, as being malnourished, and he showed reporters folds of skin hanging off his buttocks. 
 Captain Bowen said it was possible commercial aircraft did not pick up a signal from the emergency beacon, and the radio messages could have been confused with another vessel. 
 Meteorologists have confirmed that, for the first time in years, the prevailing winter winds were easterly, and a navy hydrographer said the surface area of the submerged craft would have been enough to act as a sail and counter the current. 
 The final stroke of luck was a strong north-easterly which sprung up to wash them ashore on Great Barrier Island. 
 &bquo;We needed a miracle, and we got one,&equo; said Mr Glennie, whose yacht, valued at about &pound;87,000 and uninsured, represented everything he owned. 
 &bquo;And I never doubted we would.&equo; 
 Investigators are feeding weather and tide charts into a computer to trace the voyage. 
 Mr Glennie and crewman Rick Hellriegel wrote diaries during the trip. 
 They would have been invaluable to the inquiry &mdash; and to the crew, as book and movie offers pour in &mdash; but were lost when the wreck was smashed to pieces on the island's rocks. 
 It is apparent that the voyage provoked conflict which the four are reluctant to talk about. 
 Mr Hellriegel says he does not care if he never sees Mr Glennie again. 
 Another crewman, Jim Nalepka, recalls bitter arguments over half a biscuit and confesses to having thoughts about slitting the throat of one of his friends. 
 Four months at the mercy of the weather taught Mr Glennie to enjoy the moment. 
 &bquo;I was free and in a way I was happy.&equo; 
 But the others found his apparent calm hard to take. 
 &bquo;All they wanted was to get home. 
 They thought there was something wrong with me. 
 We all changed. 
 I know I'm new, and I've lost everything. 
 Now I have nothing, I am free.&equo; 
 After the deluge, life goes on for trout 
 By MICHAEL SMITH 
 AFTER such a long hot summer, with rivers running dry, it's difficult to imagine what a good flood looks like. 
 But &mdash; very soon &mdash; sluggish trickles over riverbed pebbles will be transformed by heavy rain in a matter of hours into dangerous raging torrents. 
 What happens to a river's aquatic life when the deluge strikes? 
 The answer, it seems, is that next to nothing is known about it. 
 Paul Giller and Helena Twomey, of the Department of Zoology at University College, Cork, have been awarded a grant by the British Ecological Society to try to find out what damage this water-based equivalent of a hurricane can do, and how quickly river life returns to normal. 
 Some of their early findings are very surprising. 
 What they have done is to look in detail at the impact of two severe floods which hit the little Araglin river in Co Cork in August 1986 and how it has recovered since. 
 The Araglin &mdash; a stony, soft-water, trout river &mdash; was chosen because of a welter of data on its fish and invertebrate populations collected well before the flooding. 
 What they found was that the river bottom invertebrates which spend their larval stages among the gravel and pebbles on the riverbed plummeted in numbers immediately after the inundation. 
 They dropped from between 4,000 and 9,000 per square metre of riverbed &mdash; a natural variation according to time of year &mdash; to about 500 per square metre. 
 Two years later their numbers were still no higher than 2,000 per square metre. 
 The species richness of this invertebrate community also fell by half &mdash; 69 species were recorded prior to flooding &mdash; and had not recovered after two years. 
 Among the groups of invertebrates worst affected were those that prey on others, the grazers on plants such as algae, and the so-called detritus collectors. 
 But the big surprise was what happened to the Araglin's brown trout population. 
 They were hardly affected by the deluge, even though their diet consists very largely of the very riverbed invertebrates which were so badly affected. 
 Only the few three-year-old trout in the river and the salmon disappeared temporarily &mdash; but were back again within three months. 
 Giller and Twomey suggest that the fish coped perfectly well with the floods because the Araglin river anyway has an over-abundance of invertebrate food. 
 So a catastrophic drop to 5 per cent of its pre-deluge invertebrate quantities still provided them with three square meals a day. 
 Gut analysis did not suggest, either, that the trout changed diet after the flood depleted the aquatic invertebrates, to consume more terrestrial flies dropping on to the river's surface. 
 But what is not clear is why such an excess of water-living invertebrates &mdash; if this is the explanation &mdash; does not support a larger population of fish (and water birds such as Dippers and Grey Wagtails) in the first place. 
 With so few studies of the impact of severe floods on river life, knowing how typical the response of the Araglin is could be anybody's guess. 
 Giller and Twomey reason that their river seemed more severely affected than the very few others ever studied. 
 Perhaps, they argue, it is because it suffered two sudden floods in quick succession at a time of year &mdash; summer &mdash; when the invertebrate populations are least adapted to cope. 
 Whatever the answer, do not fall into the trap of imagining that the impact of a flood in one of this year's drought-ridden rivers will pass as quickly as the time it takes for the river to &bquo;look&equo; normal again. 
 If your home got hit by a tornado it wouldn't recover quickly either. 
 A feast fit for a prawn: Revolutionary food capsules may lead to bigger and better harvests of shellfish. 
 Ted Nield reports 
 By TED NIELD 
 PRAWNS are not small fry. 
 According to the Shellfish Association of Great Britain, they are our most popular seafood. 
 Four out of every five restaurants serve them, and our import bill reached &pound;100m in 1987. 
 Britons now chomp their way through more than 27,000 tonnes a year &mdash; about half a kilo for every man, woman and child. 
 Dr Eric Edwards of the Shellfish Association says: &bquo;Customer reaction is that they are stylish and upmarket.&equo; 
 Demand in Europe and North America continues to rise by 4 per cent a year - despite the fact that natural sources are already overfished. 
 For this reason, prawn farming thrives in South and Central America, Taiwan, China, Japan, Indonesia, the Philippines and Thailand, where tropical species grow very quickly, giving two or three crops per year. 
 From a modest 1,000 tonnes a year in the early 1970s, the world's prawn farms are expected to produce 440,000 tonnes by 1990. 
 But while rising demand, high prices and fast growth provide the stimulus, the prawn's life-cycle presents many problems for the would-be farmer. 
 A team of scientists from the distinctly untropical environment of the University College of North Wales in Bangor has solved some of these problems by designing food fit for a prawn to eat. 
 But this tale of commercial enterprise by academics has, ironically, rebounded on them. 
 Peneaeus monodon, the Asian prawn, spends much of its life in coastal waters, migrating at maturity to deeper water for spawning. 
 Here the female may produce 800,000 eggs which hatch within 36 hours into larvae. 
 The larvae undergo a complex cycle of 12 stages in almost as many days, making their way back inshore as they reach their adult form. 
 Traditionally, prawn farmers have trapped these young adults (or &bquo;post-larvae&equo; as they are called) and put them into ponds. 
 But with this method, supplies are unreliable. 
 Ideally, farmers would like to grow the larvae from eggs, and so a new industry &mdash; prawn hatcheries &mdash; has grown up to meet the demand. 
 There are more than 1,500 hatcheries in Taiwan alone. 
 Hatchery owners then face the problem of getting supplies of the right feedstuffs for their metamorphosing crop. 
 During the larval cycle, prawns change their diet dramatically, from plant plankton to animal plankton and finally to the creatures which live in the sediment. 
 In the past, hatcheries have had to rely on live feed, which is as unreliable and expensive to harvest from nature as it is to grow artificially. 
 Clearly, some form of artificial feed was needed. 
 However, throwing organic matter into water feeds the bacteria as well as the prawns, which are quite fussy about who shares their environment. 
 So the problem was to create a feed which came in particles of the right size (five millionths of a metre across), could be freeze-dried, would not foul the water, dissolve or feed the bugs. 
 Until it was developed, prawn hatcheries would remain at the mercy of factors beyond their control. 
 The North Wales scientists came up with the solution. 
 A team led by Dr David Jones, of Bangor's renowned School of Ocean Sciences, designed a revolutionary new feed, using a process called microencapsulation which puts a thin, digestible membrane around each tiny food particle. 
 &bquo;It's exactly the same, essentially, as making nylon,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;To do that, you take a lot of identical molecules called amines and join them together to form a chain. 
 To make nylon thread, you dissolve the amines in a liquid. 
 Then you take an acid chloride, and dissolve it in another liquid which won't mix with the first one. 
 &bquo;When you put the two together, the cross-linking reaction occurs, and all the amine molecules at the interface of the two liquids join together in a polymer. 
 By drawing the polymer off, new cross-links are formed and you go on drawing the thread until all the constituents are used up. 
 &bquo;Now if, instead of having a single interface between the two liquids, you emulsify the two (like oil and vinegar in French dressing) the reaction occurs over the surface of each suspended droplet, creating a capsule.&equo; 
 Originally, the team mixed prawn nutrients with amines, thinking that they would be needed to form the capsule. 
 But it soon became obvious that the proteins of the nutrient contained the correct chemical groups, and that the food molecules themselves were polymerizing and creating the capsule membrane. 
 &bquo;Haemoglobin, chicken egg and many other natural proteins are rich in the important chemical groups, and these cross-link without any problem at all. 
 We have now been able to remove all non-nutrients from the mixture &mdash; which is lucky because amines are actually very toxic.&equo; 
 After their initial breakthrough, the team still had much to do before the process became commercially viable. 
 The first membranes they made were far too thin and would not survive transfer into air, let alone freeze-drying. 
 &bquo;Once we had solved the thickness problem, it became a commercial possibility,&equo; says Dr Jones, &bquo;and Mars &mdash; the people who make the chocolate bars &mdash; became interested. 
 Eventually we got together to devise the patents and scale up the process.&equo; 
 A subsidiary company, Frippak Feeds, was set up in Batley, West Yorkshire to manufacture the feed &mdash; the only one which can be used exclusively, without the need for supplements. 
 Developing the diet has had great scientific spin-offs. 
 &bquo;It's amazing that a multi-million pound industry was built on an animal nobody knew anything about,&equo; Dr Jones says. 
 &bquo;We have 50 years of data on the chicken or the pig. 
 We know exactly how to change their feed day by day to produce optimum growth. 
 None of this had been done for the prawn. 
 &bquo;Through refining our feed, by leaving things out and seeing what happens, we have been able to define the dietary requirements of the prawn throughout its development. 
 We've learnt about its physiology and how it changes to keep pace with the larva's changing eating habits. 
 &bquo;We know how fast food moves through its gut, how much energy it takes to make one post-larval prawn from the day it hatches, and so on. 
 We've learnt an enormous amount because the microcapsule is such an ideal tool for simplifying and controlling food intake.&equo; 
 Dr Jones and his team are now extending their work to other species, and to the post-larval stage, which leads to the ultimate product &mdash; the prawn on the end of your fork. 
 And expertise gained has enabled the university to launch a new MSc course in shellfish biology, fisheries and culture &mdash; due to take its first students in the coming academic year. 
 &bquo;The commercial aspects are very good, of course &mdash; though I still find the teaching and research spin-offs the most exciting part of it all,&equo; says Dr Jones. 
 But, he admits, one would not have happened without the other. 
 It is tempting to see this tale as a classic example of how academic work can stimulate opportunity, create wealth, and enrich both research and teaching. 
 But Dr Jones's involvement with industry has led him into difficulties &mdash; which lend a critical edge to the parable. 
 &bquo;Frippak support our work generously,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;But they are understandably reluctant to pay for research students, because they will probably go off and join the competition. 
 But I had to get research students from somewhere, so I asked the research councils to fund them, in the usual way, by submitting research proposals. 
 &bquo;That didn't work either. 
 The project's got alpha ratings, but the council saw the industrial involvement and said &bquo;Go to industry &mdash; we're short of money&equo;. 
 &bquo;It's a real Catch 22 situation. 
 Once you get working with industry, there's a feeling that industry must pay for everything. 
 But I don't see why they should be asked to shoot themselves in the foot by paying to train a competitor's workforce, and neither do they!&equo; 
 The end result is that Dr Jones takes on overseas researchers. 
 &bquo;That's fine as far as I am concerned&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;They don't cost British industry or taxpayers a thing, but of course they take all their expertise abroad. 
 &bquo;Whatever the Government's idea is, I don't think that's it, somehow.&equo; 
 Seeking an ethical watchdog for the genetic scientists 
 By TOM WILKIE 
 IN A RARE display of consensus last week, industry, consumers' organisations and the environmental movement called for a national committee to examine the social and ethical implications of biotechnology and genetic engineering of plants and animals, Tom Wilkie writes. 
 The proposal came at a meeting organised by the National Consumer's Council, a representative body established by statute in 1975. 
 Ann Foster, the council's food policy adviser, said: &bquo;There should be the equivalent of a Warnock Committee to look at aspects of genetic manipulation other than simply matters of safety.&equo; 
 The Committee of Inquiry into Human Fertilisation and Embryology was set up in July 1982 under the chairmanship of Dame Mary Warnock to investigate in vitro fertilisation and human genetic research. 
 Ms Foster put forward the idea of a similar investigation for plant and animal biotechnology because she was troubled by the unnecessary secrecy and seeming insensitivity of government departments to issues other than the narrow technical one of safety. 
 She stressed that such an investigation would not hinder progress or hold up commerical companies, but would further public acceptance of the technology and so foster developments. 
 The suggestion was supported both by companies involved in biotechnology and by environmental groups. 
 The NCC meeting provided an unprecedented forum for all sides &mdash; representatives of consumer interests, environmental groups such as the Green Alliance, and commercial firms such as ICI &mdash; to come together to discuss the implications of the new biotechnology. 
 They exhibited a surprising degree of consensus and common interest throughout the meeting. 
 The only persistent jarring note came from civil servants responsible for framing safety regulations and administering the various safety committees. 
 As if they were stuck in the 1950s, the civil servants could see no way in which consumer, environmentalist or the broader public interest could be represented. 
 In stark contrast, industry seems almost eager to put all its cards on the table. 
 Keith Pike, a manager of ICI Seeds, told the meeting that &bquo;industry likes to know where it stands. 
 We are investing millions in these technologies and we want to know what are the rules of the game before we take the risk of bringing a product to the marketplace.&equo; 
 Mr Pike welcomed the idea of a general Warnock-style committee on the ethical aspects of the technology. 
 But he opposed any suggestion that representatives of the environmental movement might sit on the technical committees set up to decide on the safety of any release of genetically manipulated organisms into the environment. 
 ICI is in the vanguard of genetic engineering. 
 Its scientists have snipped through the genes of tomato plants to produce a version that will ripen and develop full flavour without going soft and spoiling in transit between the grower and supermarket shelves. 
 If its research is successful, it should mean the end of mass-produced tomatoes that are tasteless because they are picked before they are fully ripe to prevent wastage during handling. 
 If the product is approved, genetically engineered tomatoes could be on the supermarket shelves by 1993. 
 Slow progress in the war on diabetes: Nicholas Russell says investigative research may beat flashy technology 
 By NICHOLAS RUSSELL 
 ONE IN 50 Britons suffers from sugar diabetes and, despite 100 years of scientific study, we still do not know how it is caused. 
 It is unlikely that further knowledge will improve treatment, but it may allow prevention of the disease, at least in a proportion of cases. 
 Normal individuals maintain the concentration of blood sugar at a constant level by their own insulin, which causes cells in muscle, liver and fatty tissue &mdash; target cells &mdash; to take up excess circulating sugar and store it. 
 The diabetic is unable to regulate sugar in this way. 
 In theory there are two distinct versions of the disease. 
 Either no insulin is produced (Type 1 diabetes) or the muscle, liver and fat cells fail to respond to insulin (Type 2). 
 In practice the distinction is not so clear-cut. 
 When insulin was isolated at the Toronto Medical School in 1922, a far-sighted decision by an executive of the Eli Lilly Company ensured the dominance of his firm in commercial production. 
 With astonishing speed, in the era before regulation of new drugs, Lilly developed systems for extracting pork and beef insulin from slaughterhouse offal. 
 Effective therapy has therefore been available for more than 60 years. 
 There are defects, the most obvious being the inconvenience of daily injections, the relatively crude control they provide (sometimes resulting in coma) and long-term damage to organs, including eyes and kidneys. 
 Some of these are unavoidable, others are said to result from the use of animal insulin, which differs slightly in structure from human insulin. 
 In the 1970s, genetic engineering made it possible to clone human insulin genes in micro-organisms which secreted insulin with the same structure as natural human material. 
 Two systems for engineering a &bquo;human&equo; insulin were developed and most patients have been switched to these engineered products. 
 But doubts surround the long-term benefits. 
 There is alarm at the subtle changes in reaction to the new insulin, which seems to give less warning of the danger of erratic sugar control. 
 The new techniques were used to &bquo;improve&equo; existing therapy, while fundamental research into the causes of diabetes has only recently begun to yield important results. 
 Three papers published recently in Science move us a little closer to understanding the basis of the disease, which turns out to be highly complex. 
 Most diabetes is the Type 2 form, in which the patient still generates insulin, but the body's target cells fail to respond to it. 
 Detailed biochemical work has shown that target cells carry an insulin receptor molecule on their surfaces, which reacts with insulin molecules in the surrounding body fluids. 
 A series of complex activation steps then occurs which changes the state of the target cells. 
 One consequence is the appearance of sugar-transporting molecules which bring sugar in from the surroundings. 
 Diabetics may develop errors at any stage in this process, making their cells resistant to insulin stimulation. 
 Therapeutically, this resistance can often be overcome by insulin injections. 
 The increase in concentration of insulin seems to force a response from the slow or faulty system. 
 Two of the papers in Science came from Japan and reported on individuals suffering from Type A syndrome, a rare variant of Type 2 diabetes. 
 In both cases it seems that the problem lay in the transmission of the activation signal across the target cell membrane, once insulin has bound to the surface receptor. 
 The activation molecule is an enzyme called &bquo;tyrosine kinase&equo; and in both individuals this molecule was not functioning properly because they had inherited a faulty kinase gene. 
 But the faults in the genes and the resultant proteins were different in each case: one producing an enzyme molecule with large structural changes, the other having a single amino acid change at a critical part of the molecule. 
 The third paper, from the US, reports work with rats given diabetes experimentally with the drug streptozotocin. 
 Analysis of cells from these rats showed that drug action had interfered with the expression of genes for some of the proteins designed to move sugar into muscle and fat cells, exactly the target tissues which must be stimulated by insulin if they are to take up excess sugar. 
 This provides circumstantial evidence that some cases of human Type 2 diabetes result from a similar failure. 
 Working out the whole story will be a long, difficult process of unravelling the pathways of insulin action in cells. 
 By contrast, genetically-engineered &bquo;human&equo; insulin is flashy stuff, a rapid application of advanced molecular genetics to modify a therapeutic product. 
 But this modification may be more of a public relations coup than a genuine therapeutic improvement. 
 In the long run the technological hare may be outrun by the investigative tortoise. 
 Parallel lines to the future: Britain is among the front runners as tomorrow's supercomputers take shape, says Greg Wilson 
 By GREG WILSON 
 FROM desk-top micros to the largest mainframes, conventional computers are built around a single processor and a single store of memory. 
 This architecture was adopted because it was simple to build, fitted the theoretical preconceptions of early computer scientists, and seemed to offer the greatest reliability. 
 At a seminar hosted by the Edinburgh Concurrent Supercomputer Project last month, researchers and vendors could finally say with confidence that supercomputing in the 1990s and beyond will be done by parallel computers. 
 There are fundamental limits to how fast a conventional computer can go. 
 Data cannot be moved from the processor to the memory and back faster than a certain speed, which limits the performance of the computer as a whole. 
 Another limitation is the extent to which components can be shrunk before quantum effects decrease their reliability. 
 Faced with these problems, computer scientists began in the mid 1970s to experiment with using many processors in a single machine to work in parallel on a single problem. 
 The advantage of this approach is that it can be scaled up to build computers of any size and speed. 
 There are practical difficulties with parallel computers. 
 For one thing, builders had to solve the problems of making processors communicate with one another quickly and reliably. 
 More important was the software &mdash; how should a parallel computer be programmed? 
 Would it be possible to re-use old programs written for conventional machines, or would users have to start from scratch and throw away their existing investment in software? 
 While some manufacturers advocated the latter, a more popular approach has been to build computers out of conventional processors so that many current programs and, more importantly, programming concepts, can be recycled. 
 There are now manufacturers world-wide pursuing variations on this approach, building everything from high-powered graphics work stations for computer-aided design and advertising, like soon-to-merge American firms Ardent and Stellar, through to Teradata, another American company which has sold several hundred of its parallel database machines, to Britain's Meiko Scientific, manufacturer of the Computing Surface. 
 Meiko was set up in 1985 by members of the group which developed the transputer chip for Inmos. 
 The transputer contains a processor, memory, and communications links on a single chip, which makes it an ideal building block for multi-processor computers. 
 More importantly, the transputer allows modular supercomputers to be built. 
 When users want to improve the performance of their machine, they do not have to throw it away and buy a newer model. 
 Instead, they can buy more processors and add them to the existing machine. 
 The success of this approach can be judged by Meiko's growth. 
 From six members, the company has grown in less than four years to a staff of more than 90, and a base of more than 200 installed systems. 
 Only 27 per cent of these are in academia; the rest have gone to research (20 per cent), the military (23 per cent), the financial sector (11 per cent), and direct industrial use (19 per cent). 
 Still owned by its employees, Meiko has broken into the American and Japanese supercomputer markets, and now has offices across the US and in Europe. 
 The largest of its Computing Surface machines is at the University of Edinburgh. 
 Faced with the loss of their previous high-performance computer in 1987, the university got backing from the Science and Engineering Research Council and the Department of Trade and Industry to purchase a large Computing Surface to serve both as a research vehicle and a flagship site for Meiko. 
 The Edinburgh Concurrent Supercomputer Project (ECSP), under Professor David Wallace, now has the largest parallel computer in Europe, with 400 processors which can perform 400 million arithmetical calculations a second. 
 The example of the installation at Edinburgh has led to several million dollars' worth of business which, according to Meiko, would have been much harder to obtain without a such a proof of cost-effectiveness. 
 What this power has meant to the scientific and industrial users involved in the ECSP was made apparent during the project's second annual seminar last month. 
 Applications ranging from molecular sequencing (an important tool in bio-engineering) to modelling oil reservoirs, image processing and high-energy physics were described. 
 Modern science is critically dependent on high-performance computing; studies of the world's changing climate, structural engineering, and medical imaging simply could not have progressed to their present state without access to the sort of computing power that can only be provided by parallel machines. 
 Much funding for the ECSP has been raised from industry. 
 Major industrial partners, like Shell, Hewlett-Packard, and Meiko itself have contributed both money and equipment to help the project to the point where it can offer a reliable multi-user service to people from all over the UK. 
 In exchange, ECSP has developed a pool of software and made these available to its sponsors. 
 The keynote speaker at the seminar, Dr Paul Messina of the California Institute of Technology, emphasised that such developments are an international phenomenon. 
 His group has been involved in parallel computing since the early 1980s; software produced at CalTech has become a de facto standard for the various &bquo;hypercube&equo; machines manufactured in the United States. 
 He pointed out that every major supercomputer manufacturer, including such giants in the conventional supercomputer market as Cray, were now building multi-processor machines in order to stay competitive. 
 Parallel computing has matured so much that users and manufacturers are beginning to discuss standardisation. 
 Until now, each parallel computer has been so different that users had to re-write applications every time they changed machines. 
 Now that CalTech's operating environment is being marketed commercially by Parasoft under the name Express, and with Meiko's introduction of a machine-independent programming system called CS Tools, a single, uniform environment is becoming increasingly likely. 
 The emergence of such standards, and the ability to re-use programs written in conventional languages, should bring down the last barriers to wide acceptance of parallel computing. 
 Football: Muir inspires Tranmere 
 By DEREK WALLIS 
 Tranmere Rovers.... 3 Leyton Orient...... 0 TRANMERE ROVERS, who in recent years have survived a threat of extinction as well as only just preserving League membership, reinforced their position as Third Division leaders by overcoming Leyton Orient, thereby stretching the margin to four points. 
 The customary gallery of managers and scouts assembled to watch on a night when a chill, blustery wind made the measurement of passes difficult with the result that the match and Rovers in particular took time to warm up - until the 20th minute. 
 A cute backheeled pass by Ian Muir set John Morrissey free on Rovers' right. 
 Despite the wind, the cross that followed was so accurate and inviting that Chris Malkin was able to rise to the ball and head it out of the reach of the sprawling Paul Heald to register his 10th goal of the season. 
 Orient, like Rovers promoted from the Fourth Division last May, made few telling incursions into the penalty area where they lacked the pace of the home team's Malkin and Morrissey, though their approach work was neat enough. 
 Muir's nimble footwork merited a second Rovers goal at the start of the second half but Heald's save prevented it. 
 Not for long, however, because in the 53rd minute Muir was able to swivel in reaching a cross by Tony Thomas before driving in his 10th goal of the season. 
 As the match progressed Rovers became more assured largely due to the midfield influence of Jimmy Harvey who played passes unhurriedly but with increasing effect. 
 Eight minutes from time Muir sealed the points by scoring from Malkin's cross. 
 Rugby Union: Shelford aims to talk money on NZ tour 
 By ROBERT COLE and BARRIE FAIRALL 
 BRITISH officials and players will be keeping a close eye on developments when New Zealand arrive for their 13-match tour of Wales and Ireland tomorrow after hearing that Wayne Shelford, the All Blacks captain, is charging &pound;500 for each personal appearance during the visit. 
 &bquo;There will be a few candidates for doing the same thing in this part of the world if he gets away with it,&equo; one Welsh international said, &bquo;and I for one will be very interested to see how it develops. 
 Things like this shouldn't really surprise people because we have been telling them about what has been going on Down Under for years.&equo; 
 Shelford's services are being sold to rugby clubs in England and Wales by marketing agents and, according to the Cardiff link in the sponsorship chain, he is available for almost any kind of promotional activity. 
 Shelford, part of Mark McCormack's International Management Group which handles the interests of many of the world's top sporting celebrities, has bypassed the laws on amateurism by working for a company whose main activity is the promotion of the All Blacks captain. 
 As his personal agent points out: &bquo;The promotion of Wayne Shelford is now Wayne Shelford's full-time employment.&equo; 
 The game's amateur principles, increasingly under threat, received another jolt with allegations that Brian Moore had been offered over &pound;25,000 to play in South Africa. 
 The England hooker, who has already said that he would have accepted only the usual expenses had he undertaken this summer's tour of the Republic marking the South African Rugby Board's centenary, has now been quoted as saying that &bquo;remuneration was mentioned.&equo; 
 Dudley Wood, the Rugby Football Union's secretary, said yesterday: &bquo;I spoke to Brian Moore a little while ago because there was a story that he had been offered money, although the amount wasn't specified. 
 Moore refused to confirm or deny whether it was true. 
 &bquo;I think what we do know is this. 
 At the time when there were doubts about whether or not the tour would go ahead, after the first invitations were largely turned down, numerous stories started to circulate that there would be money available and that sponsors were in the country looking for players. 
 In the end, they did get some players and I have said I am pretty satisfied that the England players who went didn't go for money. 
 But I am in no doubt that if players had not been forthcoming the next chapter in the SA book &mdash; not the SARB's &mdash; would have been to offer money. 
 That is the situation. 
 Whether Moore was actually offered money or not I have no idea.&equo; 
 Wood and the RFU are adamant that the game should remain amateur, while in South Africa it appears that contingency plans are already afoot to buy the Springboks out of isolation. 
 Now Ronnie Dawson, Ireland's representative on the International Rugby Board, is pushing for a full investigation over claims that players were paid to undertake the trip to the Republic. 
 David Young, the Lions prop, has recovered from his hamstring strain in time to be included in the Cardiff side to tackle the All Blacks on Saturday. 
 The news concerning Ieuan Evans, another Welsh international, is much grimmer though. 
 He has no chance of facing the tourists after suffering his fourth shoulder dislocation in Llanelli's narrow home win over Neath and has been warned by doctors that unless he has a second operation he may never play again. 
 Another troublesome shoulder, that belonging to Dean Richards, will be X-rayed within the next 10 days to determine whether the Leicester No. 8 has any chance of playing for England against Fiji on 4 November. 
 Racing: House masters the Arc 
 By JOHN KARTER, Racing Correspondent 
 MICHAEL KINANE, the champion jockey of Ireland, completed the most sensational 24 hours of his career when he took the Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe on the British-trained 19-1 outsider, Carroll House, at Longchamp yesterday, but he had to endure the longest 20 minutes of his life before he could be sure the victory was his. 
 Kinane, aged 30, rode the Irish filly The Caretaker to win Europe's most valuable prize for two-year-olds, the Cartier Million, in Dublin on Saturday, but almost as soon as he had passed the post to complete his lucrative double on Carroll House, who is trained by Michael Jarvis at Newmarket, the klaxon sounded ominously to indicate a stewards' inquiry. 
 This was followed swiftly by the news that Alain Lequeux, the rider of the runner-up, Behera, had lodged an objection against the winner for interference a furlong and a half from the finish of an exceptionally rough race. 
 There were long faces among the British contingent as study of the replay showed Carroll House deviating from a straight line. 
 With the tension reaching boiling point, it was finally announced that the French officials had allowed the result to stand and they had to be applauded for a sporting decision. 
 The head-on film showed Carroll House had rolled to his right, inhibiting the French-trained Behera, though not actually making contact, and the verdict could have gone either way. 
 Behera's owner, the Aga Khan, whose other filly, Aliysa, finished 10th, left it to Lequeux to object. 
 &bquo;I did not see any interference,&equo; he said. 
 Kinane, who was having his first Arc ride, said: &bquo;I had quickened past Behera when Carroll House hung across and it didn't affect the result. 
 It would have been an injustice if they had taken it away from me.&equo; 
 There was an almost equally dramatic sequel to the race when Carroll House, who is known to be a highly strung individual, lashed out several times as he was returning and almost caught well-wishers patting his quarters. 
 In so doing, Carroll House sustained a 10-inch gash to a hind leg as he caught a rail. 
 As for the race itself, Kinane added that he knew he would win some way from home and had enjoyed a trouble-free run throughout. 
 However, many of the jockeys described it as one of the roughest races they had ridden in. 
 Steve Cauthen, who finished 16th of the 19 runners on one of the leading English hopes, Cacoethes, said: &bquo;I was hampered continually and had no sort of run.&equo; 
 Lanfranco Dettori, the talented 18-year-old who was eighth on another English runner, Legal Case, confirmed Cauthen's view. 
 &bquo;I was bumped on to the rail six or seven times and I think I would have been in the first four but for that,&equo; he said. 
 Although Carroll House started at long odds, he was well supported by the 15,000-strong British contingent, who also profited from the victories of two other English runners, Salsabil and Silver Fling, during the afternoon. 
 The reason for the increased confidence behind the mud-loving Carroll House was the overnight deluge that had softened the ground. 
 Jarvis, 51, who is the son of a jump jockey, has been training for 21 years and Carroll House's victory was by far his most important. 
 He has enjoyed notable success abroad, and this year won the Derby Italiano for Carroll House's Italian owner, Antonio Balzarini, with Prorutori. 
 Carroll House was the second Italian-owned winner of the Arc in the two years it has been sponsored by the Italian hotel chain Ciga. 
 Furthermore, last year's winner, Tony Bin, was also ridden by an Irishman, John Reid. 
 Football: England's desire to settle debt 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 ENGLAND fly out to Poland today confident of securing the draw that will be sufficient to take them to the World Cup finals, stirred but not shaken by a warning from Bobby Moore. 
 On a similar mission to Chor- zow in 1973, Alf Ramsey sought security with five defenders, but Moore, put through his own goal, presented Lubanski with a second and the Poles won 2-0. 
 The old debt has been nagging away these last 16 years, and Moore made a point last week of reminding Bobby Robson of the hostile reception England can expect on Wednesday. 
 Robson said yesterday: &bquo;Bobby told me the atmosphere got to certain players last time. 
 It built to a crescendo and unnerved them. 
 It must have been something out of the ordinary because even a player of his vast experience was affected by it. 
 &bquo;The record shows that not too many teams win in Poland. 
 We are anticipating a hard match, and that is one of the reasons why I am so pleased to have Bryan (Robson) back. 
 We are going to need our toughness.&equo; 
 The Swedes' 3-1 victory over Albania yesterday left Robson mildly disappointed but England still had control of Group Two, he said. 
 &bquo;I was hoping the Swedes would draw and drop a point, but we are still in a strong position. 
 Like us, they have eight points with one game to play, but our goal difference is plus 10 to their four. 
 Their final match is also in Poland.&equo; 
 The loss of Steve Hodge with hamstring trouble 24 hours after the withdrawal of John Barnes, has left England short of cover on the flanks, but Robson again decided against summoning a replacement. 
 Tony Dorigo, the Chelsea full-back, will now understudy all positions along the team's left side, with Paul Gascoigne covering for David Rocastle on the right. 
 England's Under-21 squad for tomorrow's match against Poland contains six changes from the original 16. 
 The latest casualties are the Bristol Rovers goalkeeper, Nigel Martyn, plus strikers Stuart Slater (West Ham) and Jason Dozzell (Ipswich). 
 The latter pair have been replaced by Sheffield United's Brian Deane and Gary Owers of Sunderland. 
 Rangers' Richard Gough and Maurice Johnston will fill vital roles in Scotland's World Cup qualifying match against France in Paris on Wednesday. 
 Andy Roxburgh, the Scotland coach, said their consistency during the campaign made their return to the side essential after both missed last month's defeat by Yugoslavia because of injury. 
 Football: Knighton bid stands 
 By FRANK KANE 
 AFTER a weekend of hard talking between Michael Knighton and Martin Edwards, the Manchester United chairman, the 37-year-old property developer's advisers were publicly sticking to the line last night that his &pound;20m take-over bid for the club was ready to proceed. 
 Meetings were still going on in Manchester in a last-minute attempt to avoid today's scheduled hearing in the High Court. 
 The weekend talks stalled on United's inability to agree the price for Knighton's withdrawal from the take-over. 
 Edwards has alleged that Knighton breached the terms of a confidentiality clause in his agreement to sell his controlling stake in United for &pound;10m. 
 Eddy Shah, the former national newspaper owner, has submitted a sworn affidavit that Knighton showed him confidential financial details of the club when he offered to sell the Edwards's shares on for a &pound;6m profit. 
 In London, a spokesman for Knighton said the offer document for the take-over was ready to be sent to shareholders on Wednesday. 
 &bquo;The cash is in place, and the bankers are supporting him.&equo; 
 He added that the document would name only one backer for the bid &mdash; Knighton himself. 
 Rugby Union: Kiwis in Lowe's shadow 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 Wigan&hellip;.. 24 New Zealand. 
 . 14 Life must be very agreeable for Graham Lowe at the moment. 
 Comfortably installed at Manly, with five months to wait until the new Australian season, the coach's reputation is enhanced with every sight of his former charges. 
 Both Wigan and New Zealand are living in Lowe's shadow and, on the evidence of this scrappy affair at Central Park yesterday, struggling to find the light. 
 John Monie, Wigan's new Australian replacement, received the first raised eyebrows since his arrival this week when his side tumbled out of the Lancashire Cup, a trophy practically screwed to the Central Park sideboard during Lowe's three-year reign. 
 Further quizzical glances were invited when he left out Mark Preston yesterday, preferring half-fit wings in Joe Lydon and Henderson Gill, but Wigan muddled through, their job made easier by the tourists lacklustre performance. 
 Charitable observers put the Kiwis' opening defeat at St Helens last week down to nerves or initial rustiness. 
 Now, with just one win in three matches, a close-run thing against Castleford reserves, opinions are hardening. 
 The 1989 Kiwis do not look a patch on their predecessors. 
 If they are to give Great Britain a game at Old Trafford on Saturday week, Tony Gordon, Lowe's successor as New Zealand coach, may have to swallow his pride and call up the likes of Emosi Koloto, Joe Grima and Tony Iro, who appear to have blighted their international chances by making their reputations in England. 
 The Widnes forwards especially would give the Kiwis some punch; the present pack is simply unable to dominate. 
 Defence must be Gordon's main worry, however, as at times yesterday, notably when Shaun Edwards found an ocean of space to lay on a try for Andy Platt, the tourists fell short of decent club standards. 
 Joe Lydon, Ged Byrne and Les Davidson scored Wigan's other tries, isolated moments of meaning in a game of little pattern. 
 New Zealand had their moments, too, but the tourists were never in the game. 
 Gordon and Monie shared a smile and a drink after the game, but only Lowe, 12,000 miles away, was laughing. 
 Snooker: Rulers under attack 
 By JANICE HALE 
 CIRCULATION of documents apparently intended for board members and senior executives of the World Professional Billiards and Snooker Association has fuelled speculation that the professional game's governing body has &bquo;wasted the golden years of snooker and not planned properly for the future.&equo; 
 The charge, made by Ian Doyle, who manages seven players including Stephen Hendry, is fully supported by Barry Hearn, whose eight management clients include Steve Davis. 
 Doyle and Hearn, former directors of the WPBSA, were in possession of the documents in Glasgow three weeks ago when they met John Virgo, the WPBSA's chairman, at an informal meeting. 
 Subsequently, Hearn has been threatened with an injunction, while a letter from the WPBSA's solicitors awaits Doyle on his return from holiday. 
 Doyle voiced his criticisms at a board meeting in Stoke 10 days ago. 
 Among his concerns was the level of admitted losses sustained on the WPBSA's overseas ranking tournaments. 
 These amounted to &pound;120,000 in last November's Canadian Masters and, under its partnership arrangement for overseas events with Mark McCormack's International Management Group, &pound;100,000 from last February's European Open in Deauville and what seems certain to be a substantial sum from August's Hong Kong Open. 
 Non-tournament expenditure is also felt to be excessive in some areas. 
 The WPBSA's constitution does not permit player-directors to be paid, but the board voted itself a 50 pence per mile travelling allowance in 1984 and doubled it to &pound;1 per mile this year. 
 Some consider the level of their entertaining to be over-lavish. 
 Hearn and Doyle, whose players won over 70 per cent of the prize money on the WPBSA circuit last year, would rather see greater efficiency and cost effectiveness. 
 Golf: Langer delivers the goods 
 From NORMAN DABELL in Stuttgart 
 BERNHARD LANGER, the co-organiser of the German Masters, had the enviable task of presenting himself with the &pound;55,000 winner's cheque here yesterday. 
 Langer, with a final round of 68, pipped Joe Maria Olazabal and one of the Americans in Stuttgart for the week, Payne Stewart, who finished joint second, one stroke adrift. 
 That important stroke was the result of Olazabal and Stewart narrowly missing birdie putts on the 18th which would have resulted in a play-off. 
 Stewart closed with a 71, Olazabal a 69. 
 After starting the day a stroke behind Stewart, the USPGA champion, Langer overhauled him over the seventh, eighth and ninth holes. 
 Stewart bogeyed the seventh and eighth, the downhill par-three which had dumped Seve Ballesteros out of the tournament, while Langer birdied the ninth. 
 Stewart and Olazabal came back at him over the back nine but, unlike in the Lancome Trophy when Eduardo Romero chipped in to deny him his second tour victory this year, this time the West German was not to be disappointed. 
 Even a nervous pull into the greenside bunker with his third shot at the par-five 18th, which was to open the door for Stewart and Olazabal, could not prevent it being Langer's day. 
 There was a good return for another American. 
 Fred Couples eagled the last to share fourth place with Brett Ogle. 
 Derrick Cooper went past a Nick Faldo who found his new swing was not as successful over the last two rounds. 
 Faldo tied at six under with Stephen Bennett and veteran Bernard Gallacher. 
 Olazabal's finish hauled him to the top of the European order of merit. 
 Squash: Jansher faces loss of prize 
 From RICHARD EATON in Kuala Lumpur 
 JANSHER KHAN, who won back the world title here on Saturday, is in danger of losing some or all of his &dollar;15,000 (&pound;9,500) prize money this week, for failing to make more than a brief appearance at the official dinner afterwards. 
 One of those who wants the young Pakistani punished is none other than the man he so narrowly beat 10-15, 6-15, 15-4, 15-11, 15-10 in the final, Chris Dittmar. 
 The world No. 3 from Australia also happens to be the president of the International Squash Players Association and he said: &bquo;Jansher was only at the dinner 15 minutes and this is a poor showing. 
 We lose a lot of credibility when this happens. 
 We have to do something about it.&equo; 
 Those actions could hit Jansher hard if, as seems possible, the Malaysian Squash Rackets Association decides to send the world champion's prize money to the ISPA to do with as it thinks fit. 
 It is part of the players' contracts that all the semi-finalists must turn up to the function after the World Open title. 
 Much may depend on how Jansher defends himself. 
 &bquo;I was sick after the final,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I had a headache and also an injured back after falling on court. 
 So I came to the dinner for 20 minutes and sat with the sponsors. 
 But I slept almost all the next day.&equo; 
 Dittmar's remarks cannot in any way be attributed to sour grapes. 
 He cannot possibly have played better despite tiring in the second half of a patchy but exciting final. 
 On Friday he played the match of his life to beat the defending champion, Jahangir Khan, in five games, and at 6-0 up in the final game on Saturday he was not far from becoming the first player to beat both Khans in the same tournament. 
 Dittmar is now likely to face either Jansher or Jahangir again in the world team championships which start in Singapore today. 
 Rugby Union: Stephens adds Scarlet colour: Welshmen waiting for tourists find hope in rehearsals as Llanelli and Swansea prosper, but others offer cannon-fodder 
 By STEVE BALE 
 First the good news &mdash; with the All Blacks almost on our doorstep, there are parts of Welsh rugby which live on even after the mass suicide, on and off the field, of the past seven weeks. 
 Llanelli and Neath, to name but two, are in such vibrant health that they may present the tourists with a respectable challenge. 
 Wales, meaning the suffering Welsh public, desperately needed the comfort of Saturday's epic encounter before a Stradey Park gathering fit for the occasion to remind themselves of the level of attainment of which their game is still capable. 
 Llanelli's 14-12 win was also a reminder of what used to be. 
 Stradey was the ground where New Zealand last lost in Wales, on 31 October 1972, the day the pubs ran dry. 
 Since then defeat by New Zealand of Wales, which was bearable because it tended to be close and hard-fought, has become despair, which is unbearable. 
 Three All Black thrashings have been a cross Welsh rugby has had to bear alone, as in the same period, since June 1987, this is three times more than any other home country has had to bear. 
 Wales would once have relished the opportunity; in present, straitened circumstances, it is desperately unfair. 
 Lucky England and Scotland: there is, as Wales know and Ireland are about to find out, simply no chance to rebuild when New Zealand are your regular opposition. 
 Unlucky Wales: they are widely thought to have a worse chance against the tourists than either Neath or Llanelli. 
 This may, however, turn out to be hokum and Saturday's Stradey celebration probably provided an imperfect guide to the two clubs' chances, other than to reveal that here at least there is no chance of capitulation. 
 Given the way things have gone lately, that in itself is cause for mild celebration. 
 A Wag, that ubiquitous turner of phrases, said: &bquo;At least Welsh club rugby is in a healthy state.&equo; 
 The only thing was that he said it after Bridgend had beaten Wales a week earlier. 
 But at Stradey, at the rematch of last season's Cup finalists, Mr Wag's dictum was borne out again. 
 This was cold comfort for the Welsh coach, John Ryan, who by a neat irony was at Twickenham (watching Harlequins v Swansea). 
 Ieuan Evans's shoulder let him down on his comeback, possibly ruling the Lions wing out for this season, and Neath's lock prospect Gareth Llewelyn also limped out of contention for a Test place with a knee injury. 
 As they had in losing to Bath on the day Wales lost to Bridgend, Neath conceded a first-half deficit which proved too much for them to turn over. 
 For this they could blame their own indiscipline as much as Llanelli's eagerness to take advantage of it. 
 There was Scarlet inspiration, too. 
 Colin Stephens's sprint for his try again showed a Wales stand-off in the making &mdash; although his coach, Gareth Jenkins, for the umpteenth time, counselled caution: &bquo;We are all expecting too much of Colin. 
 People should start looking at him in another year or 18 months.&equo; 
 Llanelli's second try, a disarmingly easy one by Steve Bowling on the blind side of a scrum-five, was of more modest proportions and if Jeff Bird had kicked more than one of the six chances he had the conclusion would by half-time have been foregone. 
 In a sense Neath would have deserved it. 
 There is a steady current of physicality in their play which sometimes spills over into outright violence. 
 This can intimidate lesser opposition but, as they perhaps now realise, Llanelli's mettle is made of stronger stuff than others'. 
 Neath conceded some asinine penalties and, on a broader point of policy, their obsession with keeping the game moving by taking tap penalties instead of letting Paul Thorburn accumulate points is laudable but liable to cost them such a tight game as this. 
 In the end Kevin Phillips, their captain, called on Thorburn and he landed a penalty in first-half injury time. 
 After the interval a clever try by Chris Bridges, whose dummy to Mark Jones sent the whole defence the wrong way, followed by Thorburn's conversion and second penalty put Neath ahead. 
 Two minutes later Bird was forsaken and Stephens given the onerous task of kicking the winning penalty for Llanelli, a task achieved with ludicrous ease by a 20-year-old who this time last year was understudying Jonathan Davies (remember him?). 
 It was an unworthily prosaic culmination of a momentous occasion in which, for once, the good in Welsh rugby was exposed for public consumption. 
 But it may soon be forgotten, because now comes the bad news: the All Blacks arrive tomorrow. 
 Llanelli: Tries Stephens, Bowling; Penalties Bird, Stephens. 
 Neath: Try Bridges; Conversion Thorburn; Penalties Thorburn 2. 
 Rugby Union: Johnston wraps up recovery 
 By BILL LEITH 
 Selkirk&hellip;. 16 Boroughmuir.. 9 EVEN with three replacements permissible it is not always possible to cover the loss of a key player, as Boroughmuir discovered when suffering their third defeat in four years at the hands of Selkirk, this time by a 16-9 margin. 
 The game was barely 10 minutes old when Peter Wright, an immensely strong Sport Page 31 prop, limped off with knee-ligament damage. 
 Kenny Wilson moved up and Henry Edwards came on to the flank and the disruptions partially explained why Boroughmuir were unable to generate forward momentum. 
 Sometimes, too, the return of even a class player such as Sean Lineen can actually have an inhibiting effect for there was an unmistakable tendency either to channel everything through the Scotland centre or else turn the ball back inside. 
 The tackling of Selkirk's back row/midfield triangle was a revelation and Graham Marshall took the opportunity to issue a reminder with Scotland's team to face Fiji being named in midweek. 
 Turning round 3-9 behind, Selkirk suddenly recognised that again they had the beating of the title favourites, their match winner, Ian Ballantyne, having come into the side at short notice. 
 Ballantyne scored a try which cancelled out a strike by Mike Debusk then sent in Keith Johnston for a second. 
 Still bankrupt in rugby terms are champions Kelso &mdash; denied clearance for Steve Autogavaeia, one of two recruits from New Zealand &mdash; and Hawick. 
 Three successive defeats, the latest at Stirling, mean Hawick's worst League start. 
 Amid talk of rebuilding and reorganising resources it appears suitable material is in short supply. 
 Significantly, Melrose and Jed-Forest, border rivals who began developing local youth talent years ago, are today among four unbeaten teams setting the title pace. 
 Selkirk: Tries Ballantyne, Johnston; Conversion Nichol; Penalties Ballantyne, Nichol. 
 Boroughmuir: Try Debusk; Conversion Walker; Penalty: Walker. 
 Rugby Union: Clement and Jones rise above ugliness 
 By HUGH BATESON 
 Harlequins... 14 Swansea&hellip;.. 21 DO NOT believe everything that has been written about the parlous state of Anglo-Welsh matches now that the English clubs are diverted by the league. 
 The confrontations are alive &mdash; and most definitely kicking &mdash; and are as combative, irritable and downright ugly as ever. 
 Time will tell whether Swansea's grim win at an echoing Twickenham was an omen that the international in February will be fought out in the Cardiff fashion of last year or whether it was just these 80 minutes which had the mark of the beast upon them. 
 Swansea deserved to win because, hard though they tried to disguise it, they actually were the better side, and in Robert Jones and the accomplished Tony Clement, they had half-backs capable of rising above the long grass slicked by rain and the inevitable slippery ball. 
 But Jones is a snappy player in every sense, and set the tone for an afternoon of petulant silliness with a Gatting-like finger-wagging retort to one of Keith Griffiths's decisions. 
 The dominant theme of a whistle-stop second half was of Swansea driving towards Harlequins' line, a shrill blast for a penalty, followed immediately by an even shriller one and Griffiths pacing out a generous 10 metres to silence the Welsh invective. 
 Craig Luxton, a New Zealand-born scrum-half on the England periphery, rubbed salt into the self-inflicted wounds with a series of tap-penalties and darting thrusts, one of which led to a 90-metre break-out and a second try for Gavin Thompson &mdash; one of the game's few high points. 
 Another was the sight of Stuart Parfitt lancing through Harlequins's midfield for Swansea's lone try. 
 The lowest point &mdash; and there were many vying for the honour &mdash; came when Richard Langhorn, Quins' lanky No. 8, went off, head bloodied, after just 14 minutes, the victim of &mdash; at best &mdash; a misguided boot. 
 Slicker though Swansea were, Harlequins gained more than enough possession through their dominance at the line-out and the innumerable penalties to have expected more from the game &mdash; certainly New Zealand's All Blacks will drive a far harder bargain when they play Swansea on 21 October. 
 But, even allowing for the conditions, Luxton and David Pears were never much better than a lumbering link. 
 It does not help your cause much, either, if you give the ball away close to the opposition's line four times in as many minutes. 
 At least one memory of class will abide, though. 
 The &bquo;whump&equo; of Clement's boot as it strikes the ball is as different a noise from an ordinary punter as Domingo is from Kylie. 
 His prodigious distance can turn defence into instant attack, and his drop goal at the end was a perfect sighter for February. 
 Rugby Union: Black clouds on Cardiff's horizon 
 By JIM HILL 
 Newport. 
 . 16 Cardiff. 
 . 29 IN the modest setting of Rodney Parade, Cardiff's final rehearsal before taking on New Zealand could be judged a comfortable domestic success. 
 But, in the broader terms of next Saturday's tour opener at the Arms Park, it surely failed to convince a single soul that Cardiff will be anything other than cannon-fodder for the All Blacks. 
 And what that implies for Newport's chances against the world champions in a month's time, when the tourists will be properly attuned, hardly bears thinking about. 
 Cardiff, whose rucking and mauling remains sub-standard, at least possess a pair of half-backs with the wit and ability to make best use of the ball they do get. 
 David Evans, the stand-off who plays centre for Wales, and Andrew Booth, his scrum-half partner, virtually sealed the result in the second half simply by appreciating what the Newport pair, David Phillips and Nigel Callard, had failed to grasp in the first &mdash; that kicking downwind is as good a way as any of gaining huge chunks of ground to keep the pressure on. 
 The simple difference in rugby intellect plus a glaring weakness in Newport's defensive cover allowed Cardiff to improve a 12-9 interval deficit with four second-half tries. 
 The best Newport had to offer was a solid front row, the line-out jumping of their veteran lock, David Waters, and a passion which, in the case of 19-year-old No. 8 Ian McKim, needs restraining. 
 McKim, a Wales youth player last season and new to some of the more unwelcome machinations of senior rugby, lost his temper so totally after a brush with the Cardiff prop Jeff Whitefoot that he even lashed out at Newport's skipper, Glen George, who was trying to cool him down. 
 McKim, however, claimed severe provocation. 
 He alleged that Whitefoot had literally spat in his eye. 
 McKim said: &bquo;I can take a punch or a kick but to be spat at for no reason is disgusting. 
 People like Jeff Whitefoot who is so experienced should be trying to encourage young players like myself but this makes me feel like packing it in.&equo; 
 Rugby Union: Liley's remake of a chart-topping record 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 Leicester. 
 . 35 Coventry&hellip; 6 SO far as the ratings are concerned, Leicester's Lethal Weapon 2 is in the process of becoming a smash hit. 
 For Trusty Dusty Hare read Long John Liley, a rapidly emerging full-back who has let his boots do the talking whilst notching up the season's fastest century. 
 No one can deny that Hare's act is a hard one to follow, which is why judgment should perhaps be reserved until the newcomer faces up to some of the winter's more demanding tasks. 
 Liley, though, is making his points &mdash; 107 of them so far &mdash; and leaving all senior players in his wake. 
 Hare, the world's greatest accumulator who retired after the Pilkington Cup Final in April, signed off with a club record total of 438 points last season. 
 Liley, with a try, five penalties and two conversions at Welford Road on Saturday, is already ahead of Hare at an equivalent stage in the Leicester programme. 
 It would be a marvellous feat if the 22-year-old swimming pool attendant from Wakefield was to supercede Hare at the first attempt. 
 &bquo;I'm a different player,&equo; he said, illustrated by the fact that he kicks goals with either foot. 
 But the thinning thatch and predatory excursions into the line bear the Hare hallmarks. 
 Against a Coventry side in no fit state to make much of a fist of it, Liley was away like the wind midway through the second half on a 45-yard run for the second of Leicester's four tries. 
 It was well taken, like the rest of his scoring chances on a wet, grey afternoon. 
 For Coventry, the issues had become clouded even before setting foot in the Tigers lair. 
 Their coach broke down and they arrived after begging a lift from a passing Transit van and car. 
 Simon Wright, their No. 8, was lost along the way which meant that Andy Roda, normally a prop, played on the flank. 
 The sorry plight of an ailing club continued with the news that a supporters' coach had been involved in a crash and that only 12 youngsters could be rounded up to take on Leicester in a youth match. 
 Sorry times, indeed, for Coventry, whose Midland rivals are streets ahead in strength in depth. 
 Simon Povoas, for example, proved himself an excellent deputy to the injured Dean Richards at No. 8 and the Tigers ticked along despite the absence also of Les Cusworth, Paul Dodge and John Wells. 
 Rugby Union: Irish amble after scramble 
 By STUART ALEXANDER 
 London Irish. 
 . 13 Bristol. 
 ... 21 AT London Scottish the role of providing rugby opportunities to Scots in London is still important, but in times of league realism, racial purity has had to give way to the expediency of also running a successful 1st XV. 
 A couple of miles down the road at London Irish they still want to hold on to the Irish connection, even if that leads to qualification by reading The Irish Times. 
 So there is a constant return to the roots, and with it an entirely local focus on winning places in the Inter-Provincial sides back home, including Ulster. 
 That is laudable, but Scottish can field Lions, internationals and &bquo;B&equo; internationals and yet are in the Third Division. 
 They have chosen no-frills rugby as the way back up. 
 Irish need to think along the same lines. 
 Against a Bristol side content to cruise through experimenting with back-row moves and threequarter combinations, Irish too often fumbled and scrambled. 
 Had they stung Bristol into raising a game dampened by unremitting drizzle they might have suffered more. 
 Even so, at the end, Irish were a enjoying a romp to hearten supporters who love nothing more than spirit and graft. 
 They had also caused Bristol much discomfort and penalties in the line but Ian Aitcheson, the recruit from Waterloo, barely made amends with a drop goal and a conversion for not only three penalties missed in four minutes, but a couple of passes which made everybody wince and defence pulse rates surge. 
 There were some highlights from Bristol, some back-row charges, a 50-yard passing movement which saw Doug Woodman scoring the first of his two tries, and Paul Collings making a solo break for the third. 
 Football: Rostron repays the loan: Phil Shaw reports on a surprising afternoon of Bull and void at Molineux 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 THERE have been few moments, if any, in the century-long history of Sheffield football rivalry when a goal by a Wednesday player has set United followers dancing with delight. 
 Wilf Rostron, a left-back on loan from Hillsborough, carved a niche in Bramall Lane folklore by nullifying another event no one could recall having happened before &mdash; Steve Bull disowning a goal. 
 But after Dave Bassett's side had clung to the 2-1 lead provided by John Gannon's opening strike of the season, the only first that actually mattered was United's position in the Second Division. 
 The Sheffield 2,000 bellowed &bquo;The Red Flag&equo; with Skinneresque gusto, though whether their team can keep flying high must be doubtful. 
 The quality, apart from the pace and shooting of Tony Agana and Ian Bryson's crosses and trickery, is not apparent. 
 The same was said about Bassett's Wimbledon, of course, and for a promoted team to take an unbeaten record and three-point lead into the season's eighth week is an achievement in itself. 
 United's game plan, with few refinements, is that which took them up behind Wolves in May: long balls from the back, incessant hustling in midfield, nine men behind the ball when the opposition have it. 
 Pretty it isn't. 
 Wolves play a similar style, and at times one yearned for someone to set the ball rolling&hellip; literally. 
 Nigel Vaughan did a passable impersonation of Liam Brady and Peter Reid for 35 minutes, but once he tired the home attacks lost any semblance of variety. 
 Bassett felt his centre-backs had struggled against the power and industry of Bull and Andy Mutch, yet it was superior defensive organisation which gave United victory against the run of play. 
 They had fallen behind when Simon Tracey, not for the last time, missed a corner and right-back Colin Hill poked Shane Westley's header into his own net. 
 From our (disad) vantage point 50 yards from the touchline, it looked like Bull's goal (well he was within two yards). 
 His muted celebrations told the real story. 
 Westley's arrival from Southend means Wolves have a bull in defence too. 
 He was booked for a wild foul on Carl Bradshaw, so there was an element of justice when his clearance found Rostron and the Owl-in-exile advanced to equalise with a cross-shot that may have been more cross than shot. 
 Out of the blue, you could say. 
 The same failure to push out of defence quickly and as a unit when clearing their lines, which gives the goalkeeper a clearer view and often wins an offside decision, helped Gannon score a well-taken winner, also from outside the penalty area. 
 Wolves huffed and puffed, but they could not blow Tracey's house down again. 
 Four strikers on the pitch had amassed 161 goals between them since the start of last season. 
 Not one scored. 
 Both Bassett's full-backs managed to without necessarily meaning it. 
 United to go up again? 
 Clearly, stranger things have happened. 
 Wolverhampton Wanderers: Kendall; Bellamy, Venus, Streete, Westley, Vaughan, Chard, Gooding, Bull, Mutch, Dennison. 
 Substitutes not used: Downing, Paskin. 
 Football: Hard times at Hartlepool: Jonathan Foster on a club struggling to escape from pervasive depression 
 By JONATHAN FOSTER 
 THEY take the lead with a fine goal, concede two sloppy ones, and then the captain gets sent off for throwing a punch not even redeemed by the infliction of injury. 
 So what do they do next? 
 Play smart football and win, 3-2 against Scunthorpe, one of the favourites for promotion. 
 All this, and Hartlepool United are still at the bottom of the Fourth Division. 
 A period of &bquo;decline interrupted only by slump&equo; has settled on the town from the incorporation in 1877 of West Hartlepool, an economic historian's analysis which could have doubled on Saturday as programme notes at the Victoria Ground. 
 One of the few genuinely dockland clubs, they won the 1905 FA Amateur Cup as West Hartlepool, then achieved nothing more until they won promotion to the Third. 
 They came straight back down in 1969, and on a record 14 occasions have owed continued League status to the old block vote system of re-election. 
 It cannot save them now, as Roland Boyes, the vice-chairman and a local Labour MP, knows. 
 Boyes claims there has been a policy review at Pool under the chairmanship of John Smart. 
 &bquo;Our debts are now manageable,&equo; Boyes said. 
 &bquo;But I am a bit disappointed that while we've been appealing for new directors nobody from the town has come forward.&equo; 
 Perhaps they cannot see potential at a ground shorn of its wooden stands and surrounded by deprivation. 
 Even Ralph Ward Jackson, the autocratic railway boss who built West Hartlepool as a pile of self-aggrandisement, stares from his statue straight back toward Darlington, the town that lost its League team last season. 
 But Darlington have flourished since; they paid Hartlepool &pound;40,000 for Andy Toman and on Saturday broke the Conference record for an unbeaten start to the season. 
 By contrast, Smart and his Hartlepool directors have endured verbal and physical intimidation, plus the destruction of a takeover offer Boyes described as &bquo;mischievous&equo;. 
 Meanwhile, the team were turning decline into a slump. 
 They ran out on Saturday to a cautious welcome from a crowd of 1,823 (the best this season and lowest of the day) a week after losing to Doncaster: it was not so much that Doncaster had scored their first away goals of the season, rather that they got six without reply. 
 Ironically, it was Doncaster's defeat at Torquay that kept Hartlepool at the bottom. 
 Rob McKinnon had been the only Hartlepool player not pilloried in that game, and the 23-year-old left-back was the most impressive player again. 
 Bob Moncur, the Hartlepool manager, has also encouraged others of less talent to play the game on the ground, and stiffened the midfield by giving John Trewick, the former Birmingham City player, a debut. 
 It helped to give Hartlepool the lead, with the move begun in their own area and completed by Paul Baker's firm header on Paul Dalton's cross. 
 They were guilty of lax marking as Scunthorpe took the lead from two crosses aimed without challenge, and weakened by Baker's sending off in the 36th minute, a pathetic flourish of petulance. 
 McKinnon, though, kept attacking, predictably winning a penalty. 
 It inspired Dalton to some excellent dribbling amid some expansive moves, one run and loop back of his providing the winner. 
 Moncur conceded that his team could be better organised when they do not have the ball, but he should be congratulated for encouraging their skills. 
 &bquo;Healthful Hartlepool&equo; the town used to advertise, &bquo;The Most Bracing Sea Air In The Kingdom&equo;. 
 Maybe the wind has changed at the Victoria Ground. 
 Football: Milan caned by Abel 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY 
 SUDDENLY, the course of history seemed to change: penalties, a subject that had always clouded Barcelona's relationship with Real Madrid, now fell upon the Catalans like gentle rain. 
 The Nou Camp support had begun Saturday evening waving white handkerchiefs at the Basque in black, expressing the customary suspicion that referees feel indebted to Madrid. 
 At the end they were celebrating his manifestly even-handed eccentricities, and a 3-1 victory that halted, at least temporarily, speculation about the future of Johan Cruyff. 
 The Dutchman had needed to win. 
 Three early-season defeats away from home had started a buzz that he was on his way, even prepared for a terminal handshake; under the somewhat defensive provisions of his contract as manager, which might have been designed by the American alimony lawyer Marvin Mitchelson, it would have cost Barcelona more than &pound;1m. 
 Indeed, if one did not know Cruyff better, one might have mistaken for gloom the mood in which he unsmilingly accepted his reprieve. 
 &bquo;The problems,&equo; he told the assembled media, &bquo;were all down to you. 
 It was not us who talked of crisis. 
 Perhaps now we will hear no more of that and the other waffle.&equo; 
 John Toshack, a little surprised by Real's vulnerability towards the end, spoke of questionable decisions and a tendency towards &bquo;strange results&equo; at this stage of the season. 
 Barcelona are only two points behind Real and, as long as they stay in contention for the Spanish championship, an obsession last satisfied under Terry Venables in 1985, the club will have no need to calculate the cost of a pay-off. 
 Even Barcelona would be pushed to meet it at present. 
 Since guiding his team to the European Cup-Winners' Cup five months ago, Cruyff has taken his spending to &pound;15m in a year. 
 His tactics have been ridiculed, principally on grounds of inflexibility. 
 For the greatest player of the total-football era to face such an accusation may seem strange, but the long-serving Carrasco said upon leaving Barcelona for France: &bquo;he wants static players in fixed positions&hellip; players who do exactly what he tells them and nothing else. 
 As a manager Cruyff demands something he would never have accepted as a player. 
 He's a dictator.&equo; 
 It is also said that he leaves the defence undermanned, but neither charge was proved on Saturday as Barcelona rode adversity in an absorbing match that emphasised, as one knew it would, how hurried and imprecise so much of the British game has become and how necessary it is that we cherish such exceptions as Liverpool, Norwich and Nottingham Forest if the art is not essentially to be driven out. 
 The notion that British spectators would be bored by a regular diet of &bquo;continental&equo; football (whatever that means: &bquo;patient&equo;, I suppose) once again appeared fatuous as play flowed from end to end without too much of the cynical tackling that used to ruin the Spanish game. 
 Bernd Schuster, the German whom Toshack uses as sweeper, committed the one foul that made the heart sink as Michael Laudrup, in glittering form, was brought down. 
 If a yellow card scantily punished that, Schuster was to make full payment in the last minute when he earned another caution by childishly wasting time and was sent off: an unusual, but justifiable decision. 
 All in all, Toshack said, it had been a &bquo;negative&equo; night for Real. 
 Emilio Butragueno, who twisted an ankle in earning the first of three penalties, may not be fit for the European Cup first leg in Milan next week. 
 Barcelona had already been refused a penalty, but they soon drew level through Julio Salinas, the deceptively inelegant striker who has taken Gary Lineker's reluctant ill-fitted role on the right wing and, on Saturday, made such a good job of it that he might have had a hat-trick but for Francisco Buyo's reflexes. 
 Real, less cavalier than under Leo Beenhakker, tried to consolidate and break; but the offside flag abused them and the initiative remained with Barcelona, who went ahead after Eusebio was judged to have been tripped inside the area. 
 Ronald Koeman converted that penalty, then another gloriously won by Julio Salinas when, tiring of the professional duty to let seconds tick away near the corner flag, he burst clear of his attendant, evaded one challenge along the byline, and fell under a second. 
 Game, set and match. 
 But the tournament? 
 Can Toshack yet emerge triumphant? 
 &bquo;I sometimes wonder&equo; he said, &bquo;how some of the team will react after winning four successive championships.&equo; 
 His changes, designed to tighten the defence for another tilt at the European Cup, has not pleased all critics and he knows his twin requirement is about as tough as football can provide. 
 &bquo;Of course it was always going to be difficult,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You know that when you sign a two-year agreement here you might not be able to see it out. 
 But this is the most famous club in the world. 
 What are we in the job for if not for challenges like this? 
 Whatever it brings, one day my son can turn round and say &bquo;My dad managed Real Madrid&equo;. 
 Basically that sort of thing is what it's all about.&equo; 
 Football: Koeman raises a buzz in Barcelona 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY 
 ONLY Genoa scored more than one goal in Italy yesterday, but no one was carping in Cremona, writes Phil Shaw. 
 The local club, Cremonese, won for the first time since gaining promotion - and their victims were the European Cup holders, Milan. 
 Marco van Basten returned after injury for Milan, but the less-celebrated Abel Dezotti won the match (10 min). 
 Diego Maradona, who has twice missed penalties this season, scored from the spot (55) to earn leaders Napoli a draw at Roma, who led through Antonio Comi (11). 
 Internazionale had to come from behind to draw with Bari, while Sampdoria beat Verona with a goal by GianLuca Vialli (16). 
 Genoa, 2-0 up at Udinese, were pegged to 2-2 before Carlos Aguilera netted twice in the last 10 minutes. 
 &bquo;Football&equo; hooliganism is becoming increasingly commonplace in Eastern Europe. 
 Nine Yugoslav policemen were injured when Dynamo Zagreb fans rioted at Borac Banja Luka. 
 Sparta Prague have been banned by UEFA from playing their next European Cup match at home because of attacks on Turkish fans during a game against Fenerbahce. 
 The Czechs must stage their home leg against CFKA Sofia on 18 October 200 miles from the capital. 
 Gregori Martin, of Malta's Sliema Wanderers, was suspended from UEFA competitions until 1995 for assaulting the referee in a tie against Nentori Tirana. 
 The acceptable face of striking was seen in the League of Ireland yesterday, when Galway ('We're going to Derry to attack') kept their word &mdash; and lost 9-1. 
 Football: Mehew blazes own trail: Guy Hodgson finds the blase blending with the blatant at Twerton Park 
 By GUY HODGSON 
 THE WHIFF of intrigue was in the air at Twerton Park. 
 Trevor Francis, the Queen's Park Rangers manager, sat a few feet away from Malmo's Bobby Houghton, other shadier characters scouting for the wealth blended happily into the background. 
 More conspicuous, and producing a pungent pong of his own, was Jimmy Hill. 
 The Fulham chairman ignored the no-smoking signs around him in the predominantly wooden stand and puffed at his pipe throughout. 
 Comments from the crowd went unheeded. 
 Even a quiet word in the boardroom at half-time &mdash; &bquo;I thought someone was playing a joke,&equo; Hill pleaded &mdash; failed to douse his passion for lighting up, and the BBC's voice of football reason contravened the ground regulations for 90 minutes. 
 As for the match, Rovers conspired to throw a smokescreen of their own around their abilities until they emerged starkly with two clever goals inside three minutes early in the second half to scuttle their scoreless fellow Third Division promotion hopefuls. 
 First Paul Nixon showed intelligence when he ignored an opportunity to shoot and pulled the ball back instead for the better-placed David Mehew to score and then, two minutes later, Mehew combined with Devon White before sending over a cross that Gary Penrice, a yard out, accepted with relish. 
 Mehew's contribution probably surprised the scouts, who were almost certainly in Bath to watch Penrice and Nigel Martyn, but it is a fair reflection of his part in pushing Rovers into second place. 
 A prodigious runner, Mehew's pace and fitness give Rovers the appearance of playing 4-4-2 and 4-3-3 at the same time and his willingness to get into the penalty area has brought him four goals already this season. 
 It has also produced satisfaction for his manager, Gerry Francis, who rescued Mehew from Bath City's reserves two years ago. 
 Francis also plucked Penrice and Martyn from non-League football and is getting almost blase by the attention his players attract from the bigger clubs. 
 Football: Advertisement for small beer: Joe Lovejoy reports on a game which failed to quench the purists' thirsts 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 AS AN advertisement for Second Division football, it was pure Jim Dunk. 
 On television, the lugubrious Jim advises us that the Canadian lager he is paid to promote is horrible stuff, and should be avoided. 
 This spiteful scrap warranted a similar warning. 
 Trevor Brooking, that most mild-mannered of radio reporters was heard to utter the word &bquo;awful&equo; on air. 
 When he says something is awful, rest assured it is. 
 Howard Wilkinson is rebuilding Leeds in the image of the kick-and-rush monster he created at Sheffield Wednesday. 
 Worse still, the new Leeds are as sly and provocative as Don Revie's sides, with none of the skills which made them the Liverpool of the Seventies. 
 It must be added that they were the better team, had the outstanding individual in Gordon Strachan and deserved the victory procured by a touch of finesse which could have Vinny Jones drummed out of the cloggers' union. 
 What does all this tell us about West Ham? 
 That they are going from bad to worse. 
 Successive home defeats, this one by a single goal, have seen them plummet from second to 10th, and their next two games are away to the leaders, Sheffield United, and at home to second-placed Sunderland. 
 Not much comfort there. 
 Lou Macari's attempts to wed a club steeped in sophistication to the long-ball game have brought him unpopularity in the dressing-room which will soon spread to the terraces if results do not improve. 
 Brooking, Devonshire or Dickens would have rendered useless Leeds's tedious offside trap by the simple expedient of running through from deep with the ball. 
 Now, West Ham have no one with the wit to surmount such obstacles. 
 Leeds broke out of their defensive cocoon midway through the first half for Jones to win the match by meeting Mike Whitlow's centre from the left at the near post and flicking it across Phil Parkes into the opposite corner. 
 Why, we enquired of Wilkinson, had his team found it necessary to pass the ball back so often &mdash; even from the half-way line? 
 &bquo;Maybe they can't pass it forward,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Maybe it's like diving, and the degree of difficulty is too great for them to pass it forward.&equo; 
 Had Wilkinson enjoyed the match? 
 &bquo;I don't enjoy watching my own team. 
 I never have done.&equo; 
 He is not alone. 
 Football: Scottish Round-Up: Killie lifted by Watters 
 By DON LINDSAY 
 AN extraordinary annual general meeting of the shareholders of Kilmarnock Football Club will tonight be asked to choose between two rival bids for control of one of Scottish football's giants in decline. 
 At least those present will have the comforting knowledge that they will be voting on the future of a team which has just ascended the summit of the Scottish Second Division, although that must be considered more of a Ben Nevis than an Everest of the football world. 
 For that step up Killie must thank their most prolific scorer Willie Watters, whose goal disposed of Montrose at Links Park. 
 Tonight's AGM will weigh up the relative merits of two businessmen, John Kerr and Robert Fleeting, to assume control at Rugby Park. 
 Fleeting has twice already suffered rejections from the present board of directors amid allegations of sectarianism. 
 Fleeting is a Roman Catholic. 
 On the other side, it is widely believed that Kerr's ambitions are backed by money belonging to Jack Gillespie, a director of Rangers. 
 The plot, should there be such a thing, thickens as Fleeting has consistently put more cash on the table than his opponent. 
 On the other side of Ayrshire, Ally MacLeod discovered how painfully short his Ayr United side are of becoming genuine challengers for promotion out of the First Division. 
 Airdrie, managed by that most travelled of forwards, Jimmy Bone, showed far too much physical prowess for MacLeod's men at Somerset Park, and a 3-1 win maintains the Broomfield challenge at the head of the division. 
 The top two, St Johnstone and Partick Thistle, maintained their unbeaten records although Saints dropped their first home point this season to Morton at McDiarmid Park. 
 A late equaliser by Rowan Alexander gave the Greenock side the point after Grant Jenkins's goal had put the Perth team ahead at half-time. 
 Thistle made sure they kept up the pressure on Alex Totten's men by defeating Falkirk at Fir Hill, with Alan Dinnie scoring the winner. 
 Racing: Braiswick brings era to a close: Richard Edmondson on the last victory for a racing dynasty before it becomes absorbed by the Maktoum empire 
 By RICHARD EDMONDSON 
 A DYNASTY disappeared the moment Braiswick crossed the line a glorious winner of the Sun Chariot Stakes on Saturday. 
 The filly provided a fitting final parading of the chocolate and gold colours of the White Lodge Stud as she waltzed seven lengths clear of eight tired rivals. 
 The White Lodge officially becomes another part of the eastern block of property around Newmarket this week, when the Maktoum family takes control of the stud administered by the Moller brothers since the war until the death of Eric last July. 
 Animals that have carried their distinctive braided silks in the past include Most Welcome, Red Glow and Teenoso, the 1983 Derby winner. 
 Geoff Wragg, the trainer of those colts, said: &bquo;It's the end of an era and it's nice to go out on a high. 
 The colours won't be seen again and they may end up in a museum.&equo; 
 Braiswick herself will be on view in the future, most immediately a week on Sunday at Woodbine, Toronto, on the same card as Old Vic, and, like the dual Derby winner, she seems certain to be sporting the maroon and white colours of Sheikh Mohammed. 
 The beaten favourite in Braiswick's race was Mamaluna, whose jockey, Greville Starkey, later announced he would be retiring at the end of the season to take up a post with the Newmarket trainer Michael Stoute. 
 &bquo;Greville will be joining our team, but we have yet to discuss his role,&equo; Stoute said. 
 If the Sun Chariot emphasised the spreading cloak of Arab domination, then the Cambridgeshire proved there is still a place for the smaller owner when Jeremy Glover sent out Rambo's Hall, the only horse to have won for him this season, to gain an equally facile success. 
 The Worksop trainer was one of the few who missed seeing the gelding, bought with another yearling for &pound;3,250, pull six lengths clear. 
 Glover was making his way back from the start, where he had coaxed the temperamental Rambo's Hall into his stall, and his swelling excitement as he listened to a radio commentary was confined in a swaying Land Rover. 
 &bquo;I was jumping up and down in my seat as I heard the end of the race,&equo; he said. 
 The winner may now become Glover's first runner in a Group race. 
 His mission had been planned two years ago when he worked well with stablemate Balthus, the 1987 Cambridgeshire winner, and Glover promises he has something else in the yard to continue the trend in two years. 
 For the successful jockey, Dean McKeown, it was some compensation for the dismal performance of 2,000 Guineas hope Message Pad on Friday. 
 McKeown has not given up on the north's hope for next year's Classic, who was found to have a temperature after finishing last in the Somerville Tattersall Stakes. 
 &bquo;He's got a real motor, but that day the engine fell out,&equo; said the jockey. 
 &bquo;But he's still the best horse I've ever ridden.&equo; 
 Another of the better northern horses, Jimmy FitzGerald's Sapience, got a taste of future assignments when he had to plough through two miles of softening ground in the Jockey Club Cup. 
 FitzGerald aims to make his St Leger runner-up one of the classier recruits to the jumping game next winter. 
 Sapience's conqueror on Saturday, Weld, should see a little more of the sun, as he will be have a Cup campaign next season. 
 Racing: For the Notebook 
 By RICHARD EDMONDSON 
 A weekly list of horses to follow BATZUSHKA: Set a blistering pace before capitulating on the final climb in Newmarket's Middle Park Stakes won by Balla Cove. 
 A return to five furlongs should see him back on the winning path. 
 (Mrs L Piggott). 
 DAME ELUSIVE: Did not have the best of runs in the race won by Valville at Newmarket. 
 By the time she got through the winner had flown, but she finished full of running. 
 (H Collingridge). 
 LASSIA: Finished fast on her debut over six furlongs in the Newmarket maiden won by Roman Walk. 
 Will go closein similar company, especially if she is stepped up in distance. 
 (H Cecil). 
 MAZAG: Became the meat in a sandwich between Mukddaam and Soy Roberto at Newmarket and lost all chance of winning. 
 Heavily backed in what was probably a hot race, he should soon recoup the losses. 
 (M Stoute). 
 Racing: Silver jubilee for Balding 
 By RICHARD EDMONDSON 
 SILVER FLING reserved the finest moment of a 19-race career for her last race when she won the Prix De l'Abbaye de Longchamp yesterday, writes Richard Edmondson. 
 John Matthias brought the filly with a customary late surge to get up on the line to beat Zadracarta, the Canadian challenger, a head. 
 Nabeel Dancer, trained by Alex Scott and ridden by Pat Eddery, was a further head back in third. 
 The victory maintained the monopoly of British and Irish-trained horses, who have now exported this prize for the last 11 years. 
 George Strawbridge, the American owner, will now retire Silver Fling, who paid 3-1 on the Pari-mutuel, to the paddocks in England. 
 Ian Balding, the winning trainer who sent out Mill Reef to win the Arc in 1971, said: &bquo;If ever a horse deserves to win a Group One race it is Silver Fling. 
 She is such a marvellous filly. 
 &bquo;I was very pleased when it rained, as Silver Fling is best really at five and a half furlongs, and the easier ground made it more of a test&equo;. 
 A British filly at the other end of her career earlier captured another prize for the visitors. 
 Salsabil, a 13-2 shot, took command of the Prix Marcel Boussac a furlong from home before being driven clear by Wille Carson. 
 For John Dunlop, the successful trainer, it was a second win in the juvenile event in three years following the victory of Ashayer in 1987. 
 &bquo;Salsabil has the ideal temperament and is very easy to train,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;She is very much like Ashayer, but might have a little more speed.&equo; 
 The bookmakers clearly believe Salsabil has the speed to win the 1,000 Guineas, William Hill putting her in at 16-1 for the Newmarket Classic. 
 Carroll House apart, there was little else to cheer the British challengers, with the failure of Luca Cumani's Kefaah in the Prix du Rond-Point providing perhaps the biggest disappointment. 
 That race went to Golden Opinion, the middle leg of a treble for Cash Asmussen, the American who completed a five-timer the previous day. 
 Asmussen had clearly removed the memory of Polish Precedent's humiliation at the hands of Zilzal last Saturday from his mind, and is looking forward to tackling Michael Stoute's colt again in the Breeders' Cup Mile at Gulfstream Park next month. 
 &bquo;Golden Opinion is pretty sensational, and Zilzal had better put his tennis shoes on in Florida &mdash; he'll need them,&equo; was the volley from the French champion jockey. 
 Cycling: Kelly's sore point 
 By RICHARD EDMONDSON 
 (First Edition) IRELAND's Sean Kelly, who finished seventh in the Paris-Tours race on Saturday to win the inaugural World Cup, has criticised the system by which points are allocated in the series. 
 Kelly said: &bquo;It's not right that the end of year events are worth more than the early season classics just because the interest has got to be maintained to the finish.&equo; 
 The winner of the famous Paris-Roubaix event in April, Jean-Marie Wampers of Belgium, collected only 12 points to Dutchman Jelle Nijdam's 16 for victory in the modest Paris-Tours race. 
 The 12-race World Cup ends with the Tour of Lombardy in Italy next Saturday but, with a 17-point lead over Denmark's Rolf Sorensen, Kelly is assured of the title as victory in Lombardy is worth 16 points. 
 Sport in Short: Volleyball 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Rugby League 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Rallying 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Orienteering 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Netball 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Motor Racing 
 By RICHARD EDMONDSON 
 DAVID BRABHAM took his Ralt Spiess VW to victory in the penultimate round of the British Formula Three championship at Silverstone yesterday in a race shortened by four laps after a four-car pile up on the first lap. 
 With the championship leader, Scotland's Allan McNish, only six seconds behind in second place, the Australian must finish either first, or second plus the fastest lap, in the final round at Thruxton next week to have any hope of the championship. 
 Sport in Short: Lacrosse 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Ice Hockey 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Football 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Cycling 
 By RICHARD EDMONDSON 
 IRELAND's Sean Kelly, who finished seventh in the Paris-Tours race on Saturday to win the inaugural World Cup, has criticised the system by which points are allocated in the series. 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 By RICHARD EDMONDSON 
 JUAN MOLINA, of Puerto Rico, won the IBF junior lightweight title by stopping Tony Lopez, the American holder fighting in his home town, Sacramento, in the 10th round of a scheduled 12-round bout. 
 The referee stopped the contest when Molina was hitting a badly battered Lopez at will, prompting supporters to pelt the ring with beer cups. 
 Sport in Short: Baseball 
 By RICHARD EDMONDSON 
 JOSE CANSECO'S 484ft third-inning home run in the fourth game of the American League Championship play-off series helped Oakland Athletics to a 6-5 victory against Toronto Blue Jays. 
 Oakland now lead 3-1 in the best-of-seven series. 
 In the National League play-offs, Robby Thompson hit a two-run home run in the seventh inning to give the San Francisco Giants a 5-4 victory over the Chicago Cubs, leaving put them 2-1 ahead. 
 Sport in Short: Badminton 
 Sport Page 28 
 Sport in Short: Athletics 
 Sport Page 28 
 Tennis: Lendl debates call to the net 
 From JOHN ROBERTS in Stuttgart 
 IVAN LENDL stresses that he has no intention of becoming &bquo;a kamikaze&equo;, even though the world No. 1 proposed to take sleeping tablets while travelling to Sydney to rejoin the grand prix circuit this week. 
 The other flights Lendl has in mind are the erratic ones which transport him on their excursions to the net in his long quest to win the Wimbledon title. 
 His dilemma continues to be one of deciding whether to attack or to stay back, and to discover how to execute a charge successfully. 
 After announcing a determination to play serve-and-volley, whatever the event, the ultimate professional then proceeded to work chiefly from the baseline for five sets to defeat that whimsical artist Miloslav Mecir in the final of the Stuttgart Classic exhibition tournament here on Saturday. 
 The raiding of Wimbledon, Lendl explained, was not going to be a suicide mission: &bquo;Against some players you feel more confident moving to the net than against others. 
 Mecir is one of those whose shots you can't read.&equo; 
 This is not surprising, as the Olympic champion is almost dyslexic about his own strokes, frequently following deceptive approaches or cunningly angled winners with elementary blunders. 
 Mecir does not need reminding about this inconsistency. 
 &bquo;I sometimes play half of a match good and half of a match bad, or not so good, and I have a feeling it gives opponents the chance to come back,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;When you are always trying to make your best shots you sometimes miss. 
 In a long match like this it is really difficult to play your best for three and a half hours.&equo; 
 Lendl's concern that Mecir's shrewder shots would pass him in mid-court made for a characteristic back-court performance and a 6-4, 4-6, 4-6, 6-1, 6-4 victory for a &dollar;100,000 (&pound;62,500) prize. 
 While it would be a mistake to regard such matches too seriously when they lack the edge of grand prix conditions, Lendl's tactical reticence was interesting. 
 Mecir could not envisage his fellow Czechoslovak changing a successful routine. 
 &bquo;I have seen him play a little bit more to the net than normally, but I would say that he has much more confidence staying back and playing long rallies. 
 He's got a very good serve, but the percentage of points he makes from the baseline is better than with the volley. 
 You have to play what it is most effective. 
 A lot depends on your opponent and the surface, but his volley is not one of the best.&equo; 
 Two factors preoccupy Lendl in this respect. 
 He knows that he must improve his footwork for the grass courts, and he is also concerned that the head of his racket, which is smaller than most manufactured nowadays, may put his volleying at a disadvantage. 
 New prototypes have so far failed to satisfy him. 
 How much of this is psychological is difficult to judge. 
 Mecir, a &bquo;touch&equo; player, and one of the last tour professionals to forsake a wooden racket in the name of technology, advocates caution: &bquo;It depends on your confidence. 
 Some rackets are better for some shots, some are better for others. 
 It is best just to find a racket that suits your game. 
 It is no use having a racket for volleying if it doesn't help other parts of your game.&equo; 
 Mecir, whose world ranking has dropped to 26 chiefly as a result of back injuries, ought to add a good deal of craft to the Silk Cut Championships at Wembley next month. 
 His moments of inspiration did much to elevate the Stuttgart event, a relaxed affair apart from the odd obligatory outburst. 
 During the final, Lendl ordered the removal of a wandering cameraman who was distracting him: a novel instance of someone chasing television away from tennis faster than the BBC. 
 Hockey: Ealing steal up to top 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 EALING went to the top of the Women's Typhoo National League with a comfortable 3-0 win away to Exmouth at Ottery St Mary, writes Bill Colwill. 
 Mandy Langridge, the England Under-21 striker, scored twice with Jane Jagger getting the third as Ealing took advantage of the idleness enforced on Slough and Sutton Coldfield because of the international matches.. 
 Val Robinson, who first played for England back in 1966, was named player of the match in Great Harwood's 1-1 draw at Orpington. 
 The Lancashire side took the lead in the ninth minute through Kath Jackson with Orpington's Helen Morgan equalizing 10 minutes into the second half. 
 Pat Mawdsley gave Hightown an early lead in their game against Chelmsford with Lyn Bollington putting the visitors on terms. 
 Jackie Crook put Hightown back in front and Tina Cullen put them further ahead in the 46th minute. 
 But Brenda Howe and Bollington scored in the closing minutes to give Chemsford their first league point. 
 The Pizza Express London league got off to an early start this year with a shortened programme. 
 Surbiton, last year's runners-up to St Albans, who achieved National League status, had a 3-0 victory against Maidenhead with goals from David Francis, Ian Jolly and Gareth Notton. 
 England have been drawn in the same pool as Pakistan, the host nation, for next February's World Cup in Lahore. 
 They have avoided their tormentors of late, The Netherlands, but will have to play West Germany, the Olympic silver medallists. 
 Hockey: Taylor a pillar between posts 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 England&hellip;&hellip;&hellip; 0 Australia&hellip;&hellip;.. 0 STEVE TAYLOR probably established himself as the rightful successor to his more famous namesake, Ian, when he gave an outstanding performance of goalkeeping in England's final game in the Lada Classic at Luton yesterday - a goalless draw with the world champions. 
 The result was enough, however, to give Australia the trophy. 
 Following their disappointing performance against the Dutch on Saturday when they lost 5-1, England made a number of changes, including dropping captain Richard Leman and introducing a young right-wing triangle of Chris Mayer, Russell Garcia and Rob Hill. 
 It was Mayer who gave the experienced Michael York a torrid afternoon and created a string of opportunities with penetrating crosses. 
 Only sound keeping by Lachlan Dreher in the Australian goal and poor finishing denied England a victory they fully deserved. 
 With both sides lacking penetration at 10 penalty corners, the deadlock remained unbroken in spite of the presence of two of the game's outstanding centre-halves, Australia's Warren Birmingham and England's Jon Potter. 
 In the other men's game yesterday, a goal for each side within a minute, seven minutes from the end, concluded a highly entertaining 3-3 draw between The Netherlands and Argentina. 
 England's women gave a disappointing display in their second match against the Soviets at Luton, losing 2-1. 
 They won Saturday's game 1-0, Vickey Dixon scoring from a penalty stroke. 
 A similar strike from Dixon yesterday brought England's consolation goal (61min). 
 Tennis: Evert plays the lead 
 From Our Correspondent in Tokyo 
 IT SEEMS that these days Martina Navratilova needs all the inspiration she can get. 
 Normally it comes from what she likes to call her coterie of friends and advisers. 
 Yesterday it was Chris Evert, normally her rival, who provided the impetus. 
 Navratilova had watched in awe as Evert opened up the rain-delayed Federation Cup semi-final between the United States and Czechoslovakia to set her team on the way to a 2-0 victory. 
 Evert was supposed to struggle against the hard-hitting Jana Novotna, who has risen to 12th in the world rankings. 
 The 34-year-old American was obviously not troubled by the predictions, however, as she confidently dispatched Novotna 6-2, 6-3 in little more than an hour. 
 Evert's victory left Navratilova knowing that victory over Helena Sukova, the Czech No. 1, would secure the United States a place in the final for the 18th time in 27 years. 
 But the eight-time Wimbledon champion lost the first set as the Czechoslovak brought her down with her huge serve and she looked a bag of nerves. 
 Sukova made her work extremely hard before she was able to celebrate a 4-6, 6-1, 6-4 victory. 
 &bquo;I was very relieved to dig myself out of it,&equo; Navratilova added. 
 &bquo;I was nervous and Chris's performance definitely helped me.&equo; 
 Rugby League Round-Up: Eagles end Widnes' run 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 SHEFFIELD EAGLES were doubtless declaring themselves unofficial world club champions last night &mdash; and it was not the Stones Bitter talking. 
 Widnes, who had won the official version in thrilling style against Canberra Raiders before more than 30,000 fans at Old Trafford four days earlier, went down 31-6 to the Eagles, a team formed only five years ago and without a permanent home. 
 It was the champions' first defeat since losing to Hull in the First Division at the start of April &mdash; a run of 13 successive victories. 
 Jeff Hardy led the Sheffield spree with two tries; the others came from Bruce McGuire, Warren Smiles and Sonny Nickle, with Mark Aston kicking five goals. 
 The Eagles' manager, Gary Hetherington, said afterwards: &bquo;It was a tremendous performance and a great day for us. 
 What made it more significant was that over 7,000 Sheffield fans were following us.&equo; 
 A year ago, the Eagles were drawing three-figure crowds to Owlerton greyhound stadium. 
 The only sad note for the newly promoted club was the injury to their 17-year-old full-back David Mycoe, who was carried off 10 minutes from time with a suspected broken leg. 
 The match, staged at Sheffield United's ground, drew the day's best League attendance of 8,000. 
 Remarkably, three of the top five gates were in the Second Division &mdash; at Halifax, Hull KR and Ryedale York, where 5,000 watched the inaugural game at the club's swish new stadium in the suburbs. 
 Warrington, the First Division leaders, lost their 100 per cent record with a 12-12 home draw against Hull, who pulled level with 75th-minute penalty by winger Paul Eastwood. 
 Bottom-placed Barrow came from 14-0 down after 10 minutes to level 24-24 at Bradford but finished as badly as they had started, leaking a further 12 points in the final 14 minutes. 
 Barrow are the only club still without a point. 
 Chris Burton, a Featherstone substitute, was sent off after 32 minutes for a high tackle on Craig Izzard, and visitors Leeds went on to win 22-20. 
 Leeds were again without their six-figure signing from Hull, Lee Crooks, and the Great Britain forward's mysterious absences are likely to lead shortly to a parting of the ways. 
 Sailing: Smith ups his crew 
 By STUART ALEXANDER 
 WITH just the smallest of the 23 starters in the Whitbread Round the World Race, the 51-foot La Poste, due last into Punta del Este, Uruguay, at midnight tonight, crews are preparing for the second leg, writes Stuart Alexander. 
 There are also some changes afoot. 
 Lawrie Smith, skipper of the leading British maxi, Rothmans, is to increase the size of the crew from 13 to 16 for the voyage to Fremantle in Australia. 
 The 13 on the first leg stay with the boat, Smith said, and they will be joined by David Powys, who has been with the project from the beginning. 
 The two others will be named this weekend after the boat has undergone repairs. 
 Tracy Edwards, the British skipper of the Jordanian-sponsored all-women crew on Maiden, was delighted to finish 20th (18th on handicap) at midday on Saturday. 
 Equestrianism: Compensation for Sloothaak 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 FRANKE SLOOTHAAK'S fortunes changed abruptly when he won the Everest Grand Prix, the closing contest of The Horse of the Year Show at Wembley, for the second year in succession. 
 The German had intended to ride his Olympic gold medal partner, Walzerkoenig, on Saturday night until a few hours earlier when it was discovered that the horse's off-foreleg was inexplicably swollen. 
 &bquo;I was having a bad week then,&equo; Sloothaak said. 
 Two days earlier his puissance horse, Leonardo, had cracked a bone in his off-fore fetlock which had to be put in plaster. 
 On Friday night Walzerkoenig had dislodged the lowest rail on the triple bar in the final round of the Next International Masters, which cost Sloothaak &pound;28,000. 
 But Argonaut, brought in as a substitute for Walzerkoenig, ended the German's week on a happier note with some powerful jumping and nimble turning. 
 He beat Liz Edgar on Everest Rapier, who had the only other clear round of the jump-off. 
 Sloothaak had some fraught viewing before his prize was safe. 
 Emma-Jane Mac, in marvellous form throughout the week, looked as though she might beat his time until Everest Oyster stopped at the penultimate fence. 
 It was there, too, that John Whitaker's challenge ended when Next Milton made his first mistake of the show. 
 The Dutchman Jos Lansink, the only rider left with a chance of meeting the conditions for the first Everest Challenge (which had required him to jump double clear rounds in four specified contests), would have collected a Jaguar car if he had won the Grand Prix. 
 His do-or-die bid failed when Optiebeurs Felix refused after a desperately close turn into the second fence. 
 Mac, who gained her fourth win of the week with Everest Gringo on Saturday afternoon, was chosen earlier that day for the British team that will compete on the American Fall Circuit which begins later this month. 
 Basketball: Boyd on the boil 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 CHARLES BOYD took his points haul to 131 in four games as he led Brixton Topcats, the pacesetters in the National League First Division, to a 115-86 win over Corby Fliers. 
 Boyd, a 6ft 5in American in his first English season, has been top-scorer for Brixton in every game &mdash; although on Saturday he shared the honour with his team-mate, Jody John, each scoring 33 points. 
 Brixton, who have won all four of their matches, are followed by two more unbeaten teams, Kodak Hemel Royals and Worthing Bears, who have three wins each. 
 Hemel recovered from their woeful midweek performance against Reykjavik in the European Korac Cup to win 89-75 at Stevenage Falcons, for whom Renaldo Lawrence was top scorer with 36 points. 
 Hemel's Daron Hoges, so ineffective in midweek, also scored 36 points and was supported by Darin Schubring, his fellow 6ft 10in American, with 21. 
 Worthing, the league champions two seasons ago, had a 110-101 victory over the Birmingham Bullets, who are severely under strength after losing Stuart Ruckledge to glandular fever and the American Kevin Brown, who arrived at Heathrow last week without a valid work permit. 
 Judo: IJF's president problem 
 By PHILIP NICKSAN 
 ALLEGATIONS of gross misappropriation of funds belonging to the sport by the former president of the International Judo Federation were made at the biannual congress yesterday while the man himself lay in a nearby hospital apparently suffering from a heart attack, writes Philip Nicksan from Belgrade. 
 The problems arose over the two-year presidency of the Argentinian, Sarkis Kaloghlian, who was dismissed from his position in July after financial irregularities in the IJF's Miami bank account. 
 Kaloghlian surprisingly appeared at the congress this weekend in an attempt to regain his seat. 
 After his own area, the Pan-American Union, had failed to support him, he claimed to suffer a heart attack in the middle of the meeting and was taken to a local hospital. 
 Yesterday, having recovered sufficiently to return to his hotel, he attempted to withdraw from international judo by offering his resignation. 
 He added that this was on condition that he would withdraw claims for defamation of character made against the IJF if the IJF would agree not to take any legal action against him in the future. 
 This was rejected by the full IJF congress. 
 &bquo;We did not accept his resignation because we felt he had already been dismissed in the summer,&equo; Lawrie Hargrave said. 
 &bquo;In any case we want to continue the investigation and if necessary will take the matter up with the appropriate authorities.&equo; 
 East Berlin protesters beaten up by police 
 From EDWARD STEEN in East Berlin 
 AT LEAST 10 people were arrested as up to 2,000 demonstrators began a sit-down protest last night in Schonhauser Allee, in the centre of East Berlin. 
 Large numbers of soldiers and police were brought in to seal off the entire area. 
 In another part of the city, near the Gethsemane church in the run-down Prenzlauer Berg district, police attacked a candlelit procession by about 1,000 young people, beating them about the head with truncheons, as the crowd chanted &bquo;no violence&equo;. 
 Fears were growing last night that the enforced departure of almost all foreign journalists from East Germany by midnight would signal the beginning of a sharp crackdown on all dissent. 
 The fifth decade of the German Democratic Republic had dawned with many hundreds of its citizens behind bars after the brutal suppression of demonstrations throughout the country which continued late into Saturday night. 
 The West German government expressed its concern at the police violence against protesters on Saturday, and political leaders in Bonn urged East Germany to bring in political and economic reforms. 
 East Berlin remained virtually sealed off for the fourth successive day yesterday, but in Poland a further 300 East Germans took refuge with the West German embassy in Warsaw. 
 In East Berlin alone, the state's fortieth anniversary on Saturday was marked by 7,000 protesters marching through the city chanting &bquo;Gorby&equo;, &bquo;We're not afraid&equo; and &bquo;We're staying here&equo;. 
 But the worst trouble was in Dresden. 
 At least 2,000 people pelted security forces with cobblestones during the fourth consecutive night of often bloody fracas. 
 The unusual violence was blamed by Lutheran church sources here on the frustration of a trainload of young people prevented from crossing the now-closed border to Czechoslovakia, and the chance of clambering into the West German Embassy in Prague. 
 Yesterday an edgy calm reigned in the capital for most of the day. 
 Uniformed Volkspolizei and hordes of plainclothes Stasis, state security men, almost outnumbered ordinary Berliners on the central Alexanderplatz, where Saturday's march began. 
 In side-streets, special Stasi units and paddy-wagons waited at the ready. 
 Checkpoint Charlie was reinforced to stop any possible charge of demonstrators from West Berlin; tourists and all but accredited journalists were refused entry. 
 In Leipzig small groups of protesters again gathered yesterday outside the Nikolaikirche in the centre of the town, where water-cannon were used against demonstrators on Saturday night. 
 No one is clear where the situation can now lead; they are only aware that the blanket of fear is suddenly not so suffocating any more. 
 After the failed June 1953 uprising, crushed by Soviet tanks, &bquo;people shut their eyes and looked away&equo;, said Heiko, a 19-year-old factory worker, after a packed service in the Gethsemane church, in recent weeks a centre of opposition. 
 &bquo;Now there's a certain unity.&equo; 
 Last week six opposition organisations, including the largest, New Forum, agreed &bquo;to examine mutual political activity&equo; and demanded free, secret elections under UN auspices. 
 Yesterday the formation of an East German Social Democrat party was announced. 
 The ominous atmosphere in East Berlin contrasts sharply with the anodyne official picture presented by the GDR media. 
 It is of a more than usually splendid birthday party, of jolly music, beer and sausages, goose-stepping, displays of rocket transporters and President Gorbachev saying (without mentioning his loaded off-the-cuff remarks, or those by his spokesman, Gennady Gerasimov) all the right things about West German revanchism. 
 Birthday demonstrations; Opposition church service; West German reaction, page 10 Those who stay behind, page 18 Leading article, page 20  
 Berlin Philharmonic opts for amiable Abbado 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 THE 120 musicians of the great Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra shut themselves up in a secret conclave yesterday and elected a conductor who is almost the exact opposite of the late Herbert von Karajan: the Italian Claudio Abbado. 
 Abbado, 56, who is already said to have inherited the mantle of Toscanini, was chosen out of a large field which included such names as Lorin Maazel, Bernard Haitink, Seiji Ozawa, Daniel Barenboim and Zubin Mehta. 
 He was doubtless selected because he not only commands a vast classical repertoire, essential for one of the world's great orchestras, but has also worked hard to popularise modern music. 
 There seemed to be an element of &bquo;never again' in the choice of a man whose whole personality and way of working are in dramatic contrast to the distant, dictatorial von Karajan, who died on 16 July. 
 The orchestra, extremely democratically-run and independent-minded, was bruised, strained and a little anxious about its standards after clashes with the great maestro, who at the same time had spent less and less time with it. 
 In a first round of voting during the summer, and then during their closed-doors assembly at a secret spot in Berlin yesterday, the musicians came out in favour of a likeable man who has worked well with all kinds of orchestras, and who is diplomatic rather than autocratic. 
 While von Karajan created his own personality cult &mdash; which added greatly to the orchestra's prestige and earnings &mdash; Abbado is modest, unassuming and hates publicity. 
 Von Karajan had been a member of the Nazi party, and saw no reason publicly to mourn musicians who had been persecuted; Abbado by contrast is a left-winger whose mother was imprisoned by the Nazis for hiding a Jewish child. 
 Curiously, Abbado is succeeding the man who gave him his first big break. 
 In 1965 von Karajan spotted his talent and invited him to conduct the Vienna Philharmonic at his Salzburg Festival. 
 He then rose rapidly to become chief conductor at La Scala, Milan, and later became musical director of the London Symphony Orchestra and, for the past three years, of the Vienna State Opera. 
 Tory leaders hope to sell softer image 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 MINISTERS HAVE opened a concerted campaign to sell a softer government image in a belated attempt to pre-empt rank-and-file revolt at this week's Conservative conference in Blackpool. 
 Kenneth Baker, the party chairman, said yesterday that Cabinet ministers would play a stronger role in government than they had done over the last decade, and there would have to be public spending increases in the 1990s to pay for an improved quality of life. 
 He also said Nigel Lawson, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, had made a mistake when he pumped too much money into the economy after the 1987 stock market crash. 
 Those three points are bound to be read as concessions to public opinion, given a series of weekend polls putting Labour as far as 11 points ahead of the Conservatives. 
 Last week's successful Labour conference, which coincided with the 1-point increase in interest rates, will have further dented Margaret Thatcher's confidence in the run-up to Blackpool. 
 But the ultimate test of government credibility will be taken after this week's conference, when backbench Conservative dissidents decide whether to put up a &bquo;stalking horse&equo; challenger to Margaret Thatcher's leadership of the party next month. 
 Some senior party sources believe that a &bquo;kamikaze&equo; candidate could attract as many as 70 votes from disaffected MPs &mdash; paving the way for a fully-fledged contest next year. 
 An Observer/Harris poll said yesterday that 58 per cent of its sample thought Mrs Thatcher should retire before the next election, including 15 per cent of Conservative voters. 
 On the economic front, the latest Dun and Bradstreet survey of UK business, carried out before last week's increase in interest rates to 15 per cent, warned that the British economy was on the brink of a &bquo;major slowdown&equo; as high-interest policies produced a dramatic downturn in confidence. 
 Moves to monitor use of statistics by Government 
 By ROSIE WATERHOUSE 
 THE ROYAL Statistical Society is to consider setting up an independent council to monitor the Government's use of statistics and research in a climate of growing concern about political interference. 
 The society also decided, at a council meeting last week, to compile, over the next three months, a dossier of cases of alleged misuse by government departments and ministers, to establish whether there is evidence to back up anecdotal claims that the integrity of government statistics is being undermined. 
 Miron Straf, the director of the Committee on National Statistics in Washington, which monitors and reviews US government statistics, is to be invited to address the Royal Statistical Society (RSS) on how his organisation operates and how a similar group could be established in Britain. 
 The decisions follow two recent cases over which the Government was widely criticised &mdash; the Prime Minister's refusal to fund a survey of sexual behaviour to further research about the spread of Aids, and a report by the Institute of Fiscal Studies which showed that the Government's new way of counting people in the poorest category of the population had reduced the number by 1 million. 
 The Government has long been accused by politicians and academics of repeatedly changing the way the unemployment figures are counted to reduce the total. 
 Earlier this year there were calls for a public inquiry into the Government's use of statistics and constraints on research, from the social statistics section of the RSS, from the Association of Social Research Organisations and from the Social Research Association. 
 This followed the publication of a book called Facing the Figures, by the Radical Statistics Health Group, and a television documentary, in the series &bquo;Dispatches&equo;, which said the Government was &bquo;cooking the books&equo; and misleading the public over issues such as unemployment, poverty and the health service. 
 The idea for a national committee to act as an independent watchdog has been proposed behind the scenes by Sir David Cox, one of the world's most eminent statisticians. 
 Now Warden of Nuffield College, Oxford, he is a former president of the RSS and last year chaired a government committee on the spread of Aids. 
 Backing is being sought from influential colleagues including Sir John Kingman, Vice-Chancellor of Bristol University, who was president of the RSS until earlier this year, and Professor Peter Moore, former principal of the London Business School, the current RSS president. 
 Neither was prepared to discuss the plans with The Independent. 
 Sir David is assured of the support of Sir Claus Moser, newly-elected President of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, Warden of Wadham College, Oxford, and a former head of the Government Statistical Service from 1967 to 1978. 
 Sir Claus said last night: &bquo;In official statistics and research, nothing is more important than integrity. 
 Once the public start questioning the integrity of government statistics, they are questioning the integrity of the Government itself.&equo; 
 28 UDR men arrested in collusion inquiry: IRA prison escape attempt foiled in Belfast as bomb kills officer 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK, Ireland Correspondent 
 POLICE ARRESTED 28 members of the Ulster Defence Regiment in an unprecedented series of swoops in and around Belfast yesterday. 
 More arrests are expected in other areas of Northern Ireland as investigations continue into collusion between security force personnel and loyalist paramilitary groups. 
 Last night police said that four of those arrested would appear in court this morning charged under the Firearms Act. 
 Others would be the subject of reports to the Director of Public Prosecutions and the authorities. 
 Some of those arrested were released last night, but most were believed to be still in custody at RUC interrogation centres in Belfast and Armagh, held under the Prevention of Terrorism Act, the Official Secrets Act and common law. 
 In other incidents, an RUC superintendent died in a bombing and a major IRA prison escape attempt was foiled in Belfast. 
 Supt Alwyn Harris, 51, was killed yesterday morning when an IRA boobytrap bomb exploded underneath his car as he drove with his wife to church. 
 His wife escaped with her life and was treated for shock. 
 The murder was widely condemned. 
 Mr Harris, a sub-divisional commander based in the Co Down area, was on sick leave following a heart attack. 
 The prison break-out attempt took place at Crumlin Road jail in Belfast on Saturday, but failed after police discovered a large bomb nearby. 
 Another bomb, together with a quantity of ammunition, was later discovered inside the prison as a large-scale search operation was launched. 
 The bomb contained 4lb of Semtex. 
 A series of hijackings and bomb hoaxes in the west of the city was apparently designed to act as a diversion as a mass escape was made. 
 Four men from west Belfast were arrested close to the jail. 
 The wave of arrests of UDR men took place yesterday morning as part of the investigation into security force collusion. 
 The inquiry is headed by John Stevens, the Deputy Chief Constable of Cambridgeshire. 
 The move is unprecedented: a substantial number of security force members have in the past been charged and convicted of terrorist-type offences, but never before has such a number been picked up for questioning at one time. 
 According to security sources, a UDR man recently charged with serious terrorist offences has made a series of detailed statements to police naming other members of the regiment as being involved in illegal activities. 
 His information may form the basis of some of the arrests. 
 A statement from the Stevens team said a number of photo-montages and some ammunition had been found during searches of the homes of UDR members. 
 The operation was directed by the team backed by 300 RUC officers. 
 The move follows the recent series of leaks to the media demonstrating that loyalist terrorists had access to confidential security force files and photographs on suspected republican activists. 
 The scale of the exercise will be seen as confirming suspicions that the number of security force personnel involved in collusion is substantial. 
 The UDR, which is predominantly Protestant, has traditionally been regarded with distrust by many nationalists. 
 Suspicions will now be increased that the regiment has been penetrated by a network of loyalist paramilitary supporters and sympathisers. 
 The arrests will have several political effects. 
 The authorities may contend that they demonstrate their determination to find extremists in the ranks. 
 On the other hand, it will be argued that the large number of arrests points to a malaise of such dimensions that it cannot completely be dealt with by a police investigation and that a wider inquiry is called for. 
 Political reactions within Northern Ireland differed yesterday. 
 Peter Robinson, the Democratic Unionist Party's deputy leader, described the arrests as a publicity stunt designed to appease the UDR's critics. 
 The Unionist MP Ken Maginnis, a former UDR member, said: &bquo;What I hope is not happening is that people who &mdash; as I would have had in my time &mdash; had montages for lawful and necessary purposes will be made scapegoats.&equo; 
 The SDLP's deputy leader, Seamus Mallon, said: &bquo;The question is &mdash; is this for the optics or is it for real?&equo; 
 RADIO / No laughing matter 
 By ROBERT HANKS 
 COMEDIANS are supposed to work better with an audience. 
 Not always though: witness the strange, sad case of Arnold Brown and Company (Radio 4, Saturday), a series which slips neatly into the BBC tradition of vaguely funny cabaret. 
 Much of Arnold Brown's strength as a stand-up comedian lies in his eyebrows, a pair of fat black, hyperactive caterpillars. 
 On radio, metaphorically shorn of them, he is also shorn of that strength. 
 More seriously, his understated, meditative style is lost: the impression is that his timing is fine, the audience's is all wrong: &bquo;I was talking to someone at a party the other night&hellip; he happened to mention that he was reading Virginia Woolf's letters. 
 I gave him a real dressing-down.&equo; 
 This is not a particularly good joke, but it was delivered neatly. 
 Not a snigger to suggest that anybody in the audience even knew this was a joke. 
 &bquo;The cheek,&equo; Brown added. 
 (Silence.) 
 &bquo;The absolute cheek.&equo; 
 (Lone snigger.) 
 &bquo;Reading somebody else's mail.&equo; 
 (Audience catches on: laughter. 
 But not very loud.) 
 The effect of this is, curiously for a man who claims to have been ejected from the Library Theatre in Manchester for being overdue with his punchlines, to slow things down. 
 Brown isn't a man with a big punch; it's those telling body-blows that sap your opponent, plus some sly head-butts in the clinch. 
 Put him in the ring with an audience that you can't see, and he seems to be delivering butterfly-taps. 
 The Law Game (Radio 2, Tuesday) also has an audience response problem, perhaps because the format is tired; after all, it is in its fourteenth series. 
 The way it works is this: Shaw Taylor introduces three short scenes in which actors have rows, go to industrial tribunals, issue death threats and so forth. 
 If necessary, Shaw then adds details (who sued whom), and a panel of celebrities is asked who won and why, or who got sent down and for how long. 
 The Law Game suffers uniquely by its audience: you know that they are there, because they applaud at the beginning. 
 But after that, every joke belly-flops into silence. 
 Well, almost every joke: when celebrity panellist Duggie Brown said &bquo;backside&equo;, how they roared! 
 The flatness is a shame, because this is a public service: you can glean from the programme an idea both of how irrational the law can be, and of how flimsy most people's understanding of it is. 
 I had meant to give a detailed critique of the interaction between performers and studio audience in You Asked For It (Tuesday, Radio 4), a comedy improvisation game produced by the &bquo;Cardiff Comedy Explosion&equo; and introduced by a shy man called Luke Sorba. 
 After 10 minutes of this week's edition I was too embarrassed to go on listening. 
 It is really very dull. 
 That comedians work better with an audience is also one of the more convincing justifications for democracy. 
 Peter Hennessy is conducting a brief series of interviews with ex-prime ministers, on the theme of Premiership (Radio 3, Wednesday). 
 This week, he put a good case for regarding Alec Douglas-Home, Lord Home of the Hirsel, as one of the most under-rated comedians of the last 30 years. 
 Lord Home belied his reputation for laziness &mdash; the commonly-held view of the elder statesman, as the British prototype for Ronald Reagan, didn't hold water: up and working at 6.30 every morning, even if he did spend uncommon amounts of time in trout streams. 
 It was a great shock to him, though, after years in the House of Lords, to encounter once more the bear-garden of the Commons: he was unprepared for the shock of the sheer weight of noise from the opposition benches (which were more crowded in those days). 
 But what undermined him in office, and made him worth hearing out of it, was his surprise at becoming Prime Minister in the first place &mdash; Rab Butler shared that &mdash; so that, he agreed, he never quite suppressed a sense of the absurdity of his position. 
 There's a case for bringing back those old style Tory values. 
 TYPOGRAPHY / The writing on the wall: Tanya Harrod looks at the importance of lettering, in the light of a new exhibition at Portsmouth 
 By TANYA HARROD 
 WHEN IT comes to lettering, everyone is a bit of an expert; most of us intuitively respond to the message of a particular typeface. 
 Edward Johnston's 1915 sanserif lettering for the Underground still strikes an efficient modern note amidst the dirt and gloom. 
 Similarly the Faber book-jackets, designed by Berthold Wolpe in the 1960s employing his own typeface Albertus, convey a sense of literary energy and creativity. 
 So do the Gollancz wrappers of the 1930s and beyond with an audacious mixture of typefaces printed on glaring yellow paper. 
 And at the moment you are reading a typeface called Dutch, a sharper version of Times New Roman. 
 Twentieth-century artists as diverse as Klee, Miro, Jackson Pollock and Mark Tobey, inspired by the apparent freedom of Oriental calligraphy, have invented new alphabets and made abstract art with letter shapes. 
 The neo-Romantic poet and painter David Jones drew on an eclectic range of writing styles to create a whole series of semi-private painted inscriptions. 
 Artists like these, however, whose influence on lettering has been a liberating one, are not to be found in The Spirit of the Letter at Portsmouth City Museum and Art Gallery. 
 This is essentially a crafts-and design-based exhibition that does not attempt to give a European or transatlantic overview. 
 Still, while it does not pretend to be comprehensive, The Spirit of the Letter manages to provoke many questions about the protean and varied role of lettering, from typography to bravura calligraphy, public inscriptions to computer-generated letter forms. 
 Calligraphy &mdash; which literally translates as &bquo;beautiful writing&equo; &mdash; bears the same relationship to typography as post and lintel architecture does to the classical orders. 
 Purists would argue that type cannot be intelligently designed unless the creator understands the calligraphic origin of the thin and broad parts of most typefaces. 
 Certainly Johnston, Wolpe and Eric Gill, the authors of some of the finest modern typefaces, possessed considerable writing or inscriptional skills. 
 On the other hand, Stanley Morison, responsible for the typographical identity of The Times in the 1930s, was not an adroit penman &mdash; he simply had an unerring eye for good typefaces and strong composition. 
 The same might be said of Neville Brody whose typography for The Face owes more to computer-operated typesetting than to calligraphy. 
 Unaccountably, he is absent from this exhibition. 
 The Spirit of the Letter pays a good deal of attention to the vellum / scribe / fine penmanship side of the lettering question. 
 But the mainstream of calligraphy used to be a movement that firmly set modernism aside and as a result virtually vanished as a serious art school discipline after the 1960s. 
 This is a pity. 
 The problem is as much to do with content as with form. 
 Whose words deserve expensive risk-taking with black inks, gold leaf and vellum? 
 At Portsmouth, Lily Lee creatively amplifies a passage from Machiavelli's The Prince, inscribing a chilling statement in a bold agitated hand. 
 But many calligraphers inhabit a gentler world and are happy to embellish prettily texts of staggering banality. 
 Arguably this problem of content lies at the heart of the whole lettering question. 
 It is an abstract art, which we none the less consume as readers rather than as connoisseurs of pure form. 
 And when it comes to content, the key public commission since the war must be the eight New Testament inscriptions in Basil Spence's Coventry Cathedral. 
 Whatever else may be said about the Cathedral's architecture and its glass and its sculpture, no one would dispute the success of Ralph Beyer's contributions, known as The Tablets of the Word and cut in Hollington stone on a grand scale. 
 Beyer's background is cosmopolitan and his sources have always been varied &mdash; German expressionist typography, the early Christian inscriptions in the catacombs, the art of David Jones. 
 The texts themselves are inspirational, but Beyer's lettering style for this commission, which treated each letter as a piece of incised sculpture in its own right, greatly adds to their declamatory power. 
 Are we likely to see anything on the scale of the Coventry commission again? 
 This was clearly a response to the devastation of war but in general the public commissions that have provided work for our artist craftsmen and women since then have tended to be bland and factual. 
 In that sense the talents of such fine letter-cutters as David and Richard Kindersley, Bryant Fedden, Sara More, Tom Perkins, Alec Peever, David Holgate, Michael Harvey and many others are being under-used. 
 It is partly up to them to break free of their role as craftsmen and craftswomen working to order and to surprise us, as Ralph Beyer consistently does, with lapidary writing that operates as a literary form with a sculptural presence. 
 The career of the Scottish artist Ian Hamilton Finlay demonstrates what can happen when secular public inscriptions go beyond the formulaic. 
 He has elevated inscriptions to a new seriousness because the wording of his own work is not bland and ranges from the delphic to the painfully controversial. 
 The public inscription, like public sculpture, is in a tricky political position today. 
 The way forward may be a modest one. 
 &bquo;Poetry on the Underground&equo;, that much-loved project developed by the London College of Printing, suggests the realistic possibilities for uplifting collective reading. 
 In these days of decline in public provision, these little posters are perhaps the best we can hope for. 
 The Spirit of the Letter: A Celebration of Lettering and Calligraphy in Britain Today continues at the Portsmouth City Museum and Art Gallery until 12 November and then tours nationally. 
 THEATRE / Contrary to nature: Randall Stevenson on John Pope's production of Macbeth at the Citizens' Theatre in Glasgow 
 By JOHN POPE 
 UNNATURAL troubles, in John Pope's extraordinary production, dominate the stage long before any unnatural deeds by Macbeth himself. 
 Hecate immediately warns the audience, in a speech displaced to the opening, that it is confronted by a chaotic world in which Scotland does not even stand where it did. 
 Some Armageddon has wiped away landscape and locale, leaving only a hurricane-stricken desolation, blasted by a huge wind-machine on the stage. 
 Nature, we learn, has long since sickened and died. 
 The &bquo;leafy screens&equo; of Birnam Wood are merely sets of plastic riot-shields. 
 The only traces of bladed corn are machine-produced, a flickering film projected onstage showing sunshine, harvest and children, blotted out by Macbeth's huge shadow on the screen. 
 Description of Dunsinane as a pleasant seat, of sweet and nimble air, is made laughable by a set entirely walled in antiseptic silver foil, lit by fluorescent tubes and peopled by actors swathed in chemical- yellow protective clothing, carrying gas-masks. 
 The astonishingly monochrome, synthetic quality of the set is modified only occasionally by the saturating splashes of blood-sachets, perfunctorily punctured over the bodies of the slain. 
 Such a comprehensively de-natured environment is, ironically, most nearly escaped through Macbeth's most unnatural deed. 
 Murder of Duncan briefly shocks him back into some half-remembered humane responses, though these quickly dwindle again in renewed surfeits of horror. 
 Elsewhere, even such fragile respite is rare, the production deleting all possibilities of redemption or relief. 
 The porter's speech disappears, for example; and Malcolm is at least as ugly and graceless as the tyrant he replaces. 
 The supernatural is as numbed as the natural: equipped with microphone headsets and miniature televisions, the witches are played as suave technocrats, moving among humanity with invisible malice, sometimes doubling as murderers. 
 Only in the language &mdash; spoken with clarity throughout, especially by Simon Tyrrell as Macbeth, and Peter Granger-Taylor as Ross &mdash; does any slight consolation remain. 
 Across ashen, unredeemable scenes, Shakespeare's words resound with redoubled force and humanity; they sound almost ironic, in their fruitless reaching towards the images and emotions which have drained away from a soulless, monochrome universe. 
 There are times when this universe seems excessively, even arbitrarily, bleak. 
 Like Peter Brook's Endgame-inspired King Lear in the Sixties, this Macbeth takes the risk of narrowing the play's potential dramatic range in order to create a particular emphasis. 
 Limited scope exists for actors to develop individual characters: there is little room, in particular, to explore tensions between the sympathy and horror that Macbeth's conflicts can elicit in an audience. 
 Any loss in emotional or dramatic range, however, is generally compensated for by the fearsome intensity of the vision that results, and the compelling stylishness with which it is communicated. 
 Moving, like the witches, with confident, implacable force, the Citizens' creates a Macbeth machine to assault a Scottish audience's expectations of this most familiar of Shakespeare's plays, leaving it, by the end, thoroughly drained and disturbed. 
 MUSIC / Marriage of true minds: The Marriage of Figaro - Theatre Royal, Glasgow 
 By WILMA PATERSON 
 AFTER THE considerable controversy following Di Trevis's production of The Merry Widow, Scottish Opera's current Marriage of Figaro, which opened at the Theatre Royal in Glasgow on Thursday, is unlikely to cause offence or rouse strong passions. 
 Lynn Binstock's direction (the original version was by John Cox) was unprovocative, almost workmanlike, and the production one in which the music and the characterisation were of paramount importance &mdash; I certainly discovered fresh beauties and subtleties in the score, which was carefully conducted and nicely paced by a youthful Justin Brown. 
 Designer John Byrne is probably better known for his stage plays and quirky graphics than for his stage sets, and his work generally has a sardonic and ironic quality eminently suited to Figaro. 
 Oddly enough, these characteristics were almost wholly lacking in his cleverly designed sets, which were, none the less, imaginative and alluring, and still perfectly in keeping with this lyrical production. 
 The Countess's bedroom, a sumptuous penthouse in warm, mellow terracotta tones, made a pleasing backdrop to Susanna and Figaro's charming costumes of palest khaki and cream, while the garden of Act Four was a ravishing grotto of drooping, glittering foliage. 
 Only the odd prop &mdash; a portrait or an eloquent statue &mdash; and a touch of the grotesque in an otherwise comely chorus, suggested an idiosyncratic personality. 
 A tale of female cunning and male oppression, sexual intrigue and jealousy, of true love and forgiveness, the political undertones of the original Beaumarchais play are forgotten, but the social and sexual implications of the Da Ponte libretto are still completely relevant and were accentuated in this production by some sensitive casting. 
 Singing was uniformly excellent. 
 Jason Howard was very human and charming as Figaro, suitably ironic too, and well matched by a youthful, fetching and amply-toned Susanna (Rosa Mannion). 
 The Count and Countess both looked and sounded good, though Stephen Page's portrayal of a habitual seducer was less than convincing. 
 Mozart's perception and understanding of the female psyche is especially illuminating in this piece and Jane Leslie MacKenzie's sad and tense characterisation of the Countess was extremely plausible, if lacking in the real sense of fun which the lady must have had in order to be drawn into the intrigues in the first place. 
 Clare Shearer, looking rather too much like the Principal Boy of the pantomime, gave an attractive performance as Cherubino &mdash; not quite as breathless and impetuous as I would have liked from this juvenile Don Giovanni &mdash; but it is very difficult to get used to hearing the immortal Non so piu cosa son sung in translation. 
 It is Scottish Opera policy to present their operas in English, and while this can make lengthy recitatives comprehensible to those of us whose Italian is less than fluent, I can see no other advantage. 
 But there was nothing jarring in Michael Irwin's English version. 
 Stock buffo characters Marcellina and Bartolo (Ann Howard and David Gwynne) added lightness and comedy to what could be described as a serious interpretation of The Marriage of Figaro, not as effervescent as some would have liked but thoroughly convincing just the same &mdash; and one in which the complex ensemble were particularly memorable. 
 The Marriage of Figaro can be seen in Glasgow on 19 and 21 October 19 on 5 and 7 December, with performances in Edinburgh, Newcastle, Aberdeen and Inverness in November. 
 MUSIC / Twisted tales: La Finta Giardiniera &mdash; Grand Theatre, Leeds 
 By JULIAN RUSHTON 
 EVEN WITH half a dozen arias omitted, the Opera North production of Mozart's La Finta Giardiniera makes a long evening, three and a half hours including interval. 
 That it never seems boring is due first, of course, to the richness of the youthful Mozart's music; but given the fantastical convolutions of the story even that might not be enough. 
 It is the high quality of musical performance, as well as the staging, which somehow make what might have been a curiosity into an entertaining and disturbing theatrical experience. 
 The production was first given at the Theatre Royal in York, yet it transfers very well to the larger auditorium of the Grand. 
 The expanses of green still dominate the set, the lighting gains in intensity, and this time the scene-change during Act Two was mercifully quite quiet. 
 The violence done to Tom Cairns's inventive set, like the aftermath of an explosion, is an apt symbol of the turmoil in the characters' brains. 
 Tim Albery's production takes this weird eighteenth-century fantasy of nobles, bourgeois, and servants, all of whom finally settle for marrying their own class, and instils it with Fuselian surrealism. 
 The result is a genuine triumph, thanks to a troupe of singers, the same cast as at York, willing to give their best in attitudes ranging from completely recumbent to perilous perching on ladder or chaise-longue; dragging themselves around on all fours and wrapping themselves in curtains; and generally behaving as though the entire cast (not just the noble lovers, as in the script) is ripe for the psychiatrist's couch. 
 In the title role, Anne Dawson remained passive until error and madness set in near the end; then she sang with increased energy, and spun her lines with great beauty. 
 Mozart wrote the part of Ramiro for a castrato, perhaps expecting greater power than Katherine Steffan conveyed, at least until the final aria when this previously rational character loses his cool. 
 With the exception of Paul Nilon's delightfully zany Count Belfiore, the principal roles were in some danger of being upstaged by the slightly lesser ones (Nilon is not to blame if it remains incredible that any woman, let alone two, should fall in love with such a bizarre creature). 
 Linda Kitchen excelled as the housekeeper who fails to marry her master, Peter Savidge as the dogged servant of the heroine who finally gets his girl. 
 Nigel Robson, tall and pompous, became wonderfully enraged as the Mayor; while Juliet Booth, ill on the first night at York but now displaying her fine voice and musicianship to the full, mixed honey and gall as the spoiled and fickle Arminda. 
 The singers received buoyant if occasionally untidy support from a classically sized and seated orchestra under that excellent Mozartian Alan Hacker. 
 Deutsche Bank in UK launch 
 By JULIAN RUSHTON 
 DEUTSCHE BANK, the giant German banking group, will today make a move into the British fund management market, launching Deutsche Bank Capital Management (UK), an institutional fund manager. 
 The move follows the expansion of Deutsche Bank's unit trsut operation, DWS, into the UK in April. 
 DBCM is an offshoot of Deutsche Bank Capital Management International, founded in 1983 to offer fund management primarily to international companies with operations in West Germany. 
 It is headed by a Britain, Bill Richards, who was formerly a director of Sun Life, and has offices in New York and Tokyo. 
 Currently the parent has around &dollar;3bn of funds under management, 70 per cent of which is invested in West Germany. 
 Outlook: Timing more at fault than policy 
 By JULIAN RUSHTON 
 There was a hint of panic in the air yesterday, as though the markets suddenly realised that the grapeshot fired by the authorities last week might be heading in their direction. 
 Weekend talk of policy rifts at the highest level and of impending recession, and a perception that the Government is most reluctant to raise interest rates again, caused sterling to collapse to its lowest against the Deutschemark since the celebrated events of March last year. 
 These concerns in turn took their toll of equities, which in any case are increasingly being supported by institutional cashflow rather than expectations of company profits. 
 In the circumstances factory gate prices, which could be interpreted as showing that demand had hardly relaxed, and input prices which underlined the inflationary danger posed by a weaker pound deepened the gloom Yet it was mainly the timing, not the policy, which was to blame. 
 Trying to plug the hole in the dyke with reserves and then appearing to react to, instead of pre-empting, a widely-anticipated rise in German interest rates, left the impression that the authorities were tailing behind events. 
 This sense of a loss of control has demoralised the markets more than any other factor. 
 In two short years the Government has seemed to lose its grip, and that disturbs financial markets. 
 The evidence of deep concern, if not panic, was the universal reaction to go short of sterling and equities yesterday, and interest rate futures gave little sign of a remission. 
 Yet the markets may have over-reacted even more than usual. 
 Evidence of a rift between the Prime Minister and the Chancellor, such as precipitated last year's Deutschemark crisis, is pretty sparse. 
 The timing question aside, there appears to have been basic agreement between Mrs Thatcher and Mr Lawson on the need to defend sterling. 
 Whether interest rates or intervention were the chosen instru ment, and in what combination, was probably a secondary question. 
 As it happens, intervention might at least have tided the Government through the Conservative Party conference had the Bundesbank not intervened. 
 In March last year, moroever, the German currency was weaker than it is now. 
 So an exchange rate of fewer than DM3 to the pound today might not be so inconsistent in market terms. 
 In policy terms, however, it does nothing to diminish fears of another interest rate rise. 
 The risk is that the markets are perilously close to ensuring that the grapeshot comes straight up Lombard Street in a self-fulfilling prophecy. 
 Outlook: Ferranti's catch-22 
 By JULIAN RUSHTON 
 Solutions to the Ferranti crisis are not going to be easy to find despite the way in which the company has been inundated with offers of help. 
 Three alternatives face Sir Derek Alun-Jones, Ferranti's beleaguered chairman, all fraught with difficulties. 
 The first &mdash; a rights issue &mdash; looks unrealistic. 
 With Ferranti needing to raise a minimum of &pound;150m in new equity, the issue would have to be on the basis of one for two. 
 Ferranti is looking increasingly isolated in the UK defence electronics scene and it is difficult to see the institutions tolerating such an exercise or forgiving lightly the management for the International Signal and Control takeover. 
 Sir Derek's preference is to bring in some friendly Continental company such as Daimler-Benz of West Germany as a substantial minority shareholder, leaving Ferranti with a share quote and at least a semblance of independence. 
 But it would be equally difficult for the institutions to countenance such an outcome. 
 They would rather mount their own bid. 
 This leaves only one realistic option a full scale takeover. 
 But anyone who launches a bid for Ferranti will want to be sure there are no more black holes lurking in the company's books. 
 And many of the potential suitors for Ferranti face complex and in some cases insurmountable government objections. 
 British Aerospace, the lead British contender, may have the backing of the Department of Trade and Industry but it is almost certain to face fierce opposition from the Ministry of Defence. 
 A further problem is that a BAe takeover would strengthen German objections to Ferranti winning the radar contract for the European Fighter Aircraft since it would mean BAe gaining a disproportionately large share of the total project. 
 Thomson CSF of France is also big in radar. 
 One thing is certain. 
 Not much would be served at this stage by ousting Sir Derek Alun-Jones as chairman, as some shareholders would like. 
 Though Sir Derek must ultimately carry management responsibility for the mess ISC has got the company into, it would prove difficult to find someone better to sort it out if only because any newcomer would have to spend so long in getting to grips with the problems. 
 Outlook: The EC spirit of compromise 
 By JULIAN RUSHTON 
 After last month's stormy meeting in Luxembourg, when EC member nations could not agree on a common approach to takeover regulation and supervision, John Redwood, the new junior minister at the DTI, will propose a compromise when the ministers gather tomorrow. 
 The problem was that the EC is split between the smaller countries which want the Commission to review a takeover when combined turnover of the two companies involved exceeds Ecu2bn (about &pound;1.4bn); and the larger ones, like the UK, France and Germany, who think a Ecu5bn threshold is sufficient. 
 The reasons for the split are understandable. 
 Denmark, Belgium and the Irish Republic want to protect their domestic industry from foreign predators, and regard the EC as their protector. 
 The bigger nations, for their part, have already developed systems of takeover supervision, and do not want to be encumbered with another layer of M&amp;A bureaucracy. 
 The compromise works neatly. 
 The smaller members, who would normally be defending a bid, will be able to surrender jurisdiction to the EC on any bid above the Ecu2bn threshold; the larger ones will still adhere to the Ecu5bn limit. 
 The formula seems a good halfway house, and has the saving grace that it avoids another row by commanding EC unanimity. 
 The position of the UK merger authorities, the OFT and the MMC, as arbiter of most domestic takeovers would remain almost unchanged. 
 European mega-bids would fall under EC review in current circumstances anyway. 
 Two potentially problematic areas remain. 
 The German authorities want, in certain sensitive sectors such as defence and electronics, to retain a final sanction over mergers, which would work against the spirit of a single Euromerger policy. 
 The French, for their part, are promoting the idea of a &bquo;Euro-champion&equo; to take on the US and Japanese world leaders. 
 This would require that, in certain cases, a merger should be allowed even when it gives a combined share of more than 25 per cent of the European market. 
 These two issues will test the EC's new found spirit of compromise. 
 Pearl under siege in insurance revolution: This insurer may have done too little too late to preserve its independence 
 By JOHN MOORE 
 FOR THE last 10 years or so the British insurance community has attracted an enormous amount of takeover activity. 
 In the late 1970s British insurance brokers were takeover targets of their larger rivals in the United States. 
 Then, in the 1980s, overseas financial groups have had large British insurance companies within their sights, which has led to aggressively fought takeovers. 
 The wave of acquisitions has been prompted by expansionist desires among the overseas financial groups, which see opportunities to increase market share and provide themselves, in the case of the acquisition of insurance companies, with new marketing and product design arms. 
 In some cases, overseas groups have just taken speculative shareholdings in British insurance companies in the hope that their interest may flush out other buyers. 
 The latest, and the largest of the takeovers came last week with the offer of &pound;1.1bn by Australian Mutual Provident, Australia's largest life insurance company, for Pearl Group, a leading British life insurer. 
 Why Australian Mutual Provident wants the Pearl, which is fighting the bid, is not entirely clear to the City. 
 All City insurance analysts believe that in any event Australian Mutual will not get the Pearl for the 605p per share bid that it has made. 
 Pearl's share price stands at 648p as hopes mount in the market that the Australian's interest will flush out a more determined bidder which will offer more. 
 Pearl has the unenviable reputation of being one of the more sleepy members within a sector not noted for a dynamic approach. 
 Founded in 1864, the group has maintained its image as a typical home service company, with a mixture of ordinary and industrial branch life business and general insurance business sold through a field force of up to 6,500 individuals, second only in terms of size to the Prudential's of more than 12,000. 
 As a home service company, or so called &bquo;industrial&equo; life insurer, it has specialised in arranging policies and collecting premiums on a door-to-door basis, with its sales force collecting small amounts of money on comparatively small life insurance policies. 
 These policies have, in many cases, been taken out by individuals on low incomes merely to provide for the cost of funeral expenses. 
 But regulatory and structural upheavals in the City ahead of and after the &bquo;big bang&equo; in the British securities markets of 1986 have sparked a revolution within the life insurance industry that the Pearl has often found difficult to keep up with. 
 Other life insurers sought to increase their distribution networks, either increasing their branches or their personnel in a variety of ways in order to market their products in increasingly competitive environments. 
 The mighty Prudential and other life insurers bought chains of estate agencies. 
 The Pearl did not. 
 The Pearl's decision not to buy estate agencies, with hindsight, may look smart in the wake of the collapse of the housing market but it was failing to take advantage of other changes. 
 Other life insurers were forging closer links with building societies, who were choosing, under the new regulatory regime, to market the products of only one life insurance company, in accordance with new regulatory requirements. 
 While the Legal &amp; General established marketing outlets with 19 building societies, the Pearl only established a mortgage facility arrangement with the Alliance &amp; Leicester. 
 Standard Life, Norwich Union and Friends Provident forged &bquo;tied&equo; links with, respectively, the Halifax, Leeds Permanent and Abbey National, three of the largest building societies in the country. 
 Now building societies are the preferred choice of many customers for purchasing life insurance. 
 Management of the Pearl is led by Eionion Holland, the executive chairman, and Nigel Proddow, the chief general manager, who have 36 years of experience each with the Pearl. 
 Both actuaries have tried to turn the Pearl in other directions, taking advantage of the personal pensions boom, and developing the group's general insurance business, which suffered a rough ride in the early 1970s before they took charge of the group six years ago. 
 Their efforts may be too little too late to ensure that the Pearl maintains its independence. 
 But whether Pearl's new masters will be AMP is another matter. 
 Collapsed bank depositors get first payout 
 From TONY FARAGHER in the Isle of Man 
 SOME 4,000 depositors who lost &pound;42m in one of Britain's biggest bank crashes are to receive their first interim payment following an &pound;11.7m judgment against fugitive city financier Jim Raper in the Manx Chancery Court yesterday. 
 Barrister David Ashton, acting for the liquidators of the Isle of Man Savings and Investment Bank, told the court that good news was on the way for the mostly small depositors, many of whom lost their life savings when the Douglas-based bank collapsed seven years ago. 
 &bquo;There is no reason now why there should not be an interim payment made to the unsecured creditors,&equo; he said. 
 The Savings and Investment Bank, said to be owned by property developer Victor Gray, closed its doors in July 1982 having given massive loan facilities. 
 One of these was said to be a &pound;5m loan to Raper's master company, the Hong Kong and Netherlands based Gasco Group. 
 This was given nine months before the bank collapsed and financed Gasco's takeover of Cornish tin mining company St Piran. 
 When the bank went into liquidation repayment was demanded and Raper immediately started a &pound;15m action for damages, saying it was being called in earlier than agreed. 
 A long-running legal wrangle ensued with Gasco assets ultimately being frozen and a court undertaking secured from St Piran not to reduce its UK assets below &pound;7m, sufficient to cover the SIB claim. 
 This undertaking was given to the High Court in London but in March last year Vice Chancellor Sir Nicolas Browne-Wilkinson found Raper and the man described as his &bquo;sidekick&equo;, Douglas Allen, guilty of the &bquo;most deliberate and serious&equo; contempts. 
 Both were accused of aiding and abetting the transfer abroad of &pound;2.6m of St Piran assets in breach of the undertaking. 
 Raper was jailed for two years and Allen for six months, Sir Nicolas saying it was one of the most serious contempts he had ever come across. 
 Mr Ashton told yesterday's hearing that neither man had served a day of his sentence as both had been out of the jurisdiction. 
 Raper's last known address was Quezon City in the Philippines though he is now thought to be in Switzerland. 
 His clients had pressed ahead with the claim against his companies and Mr Ashton told the Manx judge, John Corrin, that the matter had been settled out of court and Raper was prepared to admit judgment for &pound;11.7m, which would be paid into a firm of local advocates. 
 This, he said, would clear the way for an interim repayment to the depositors, and although there were some small administration problems, he saw no reason why this should not be done in the &bquo;near future&equo;. 
 He said that although Raper and his &bquo;henchman&equo;, Allen, had unlawfully exported large sums of money out of the UK's jurisdiction, by the terms of the agreement the bank liquidators would take no voluntary part in any subsequent proceedings relating to the contempt charges. 
 After the judgment, Mr Ashton was approached by a group of irate depositors and questioned about the return of their money. 
 He told them that around &pound;10m of the lost cash had been recovered and a payment of this would be made. 
 Brokers &bquo;unable to meet VAT deadline&equo; 
 By CLARE DOBIE, Deputy City Editor 
 CONCERN is growing that a number of stockbrokers will be unable to meet a January deadline for VAT changes which are expected to reduce the cost of share dealing. 
 The changes follow the adoption in July this year of the Eighteenth EC directive. 
 H M Customs and Excise confirmed yesterday that they had to be implemented by 1 January 1990. 
 The changes should reduce investors's costs because VAT will no longer be payable on commissions paid to stockbrokers. 
 They also affect management fees paid to unit trust managers. 
 Though a draft directive has been circulating since 1984 it passed its final stages rapidly. 
 The International Stock Exchange has called for more time to implement the changes but so far it has had little success. 
 Andrew Ball, of Spicers &amp; Oppenheim, accountants to the Stock Exchange, said yesterday: &bquo;1 January is impossible and there will be widespread default.&equo; 
 Stockbrokers and unit trust managers have to decide how much of the VAT saving they can pass on to investors. 
 While they will no longer have to charge investors VAT at 15 per cent, they will no longer be entitled to recover the VAT they spend on services bought in. 
 This reduces the benefit of the change to investors. 
 This suggests the net saving may be nearer 10 per cent. 
 Paul Masters of BZW, the stockbroking arm of Barclays Bank, said it was too early to say what reductions in commission rates would be possible. 
 As well as deciding on new commission rates, firms will have to make extensive changes to their computer systems. 
 Commodities 
 By CLARE DOBIE, Deputy City Editor 
 STERLING hung like a pall over commodity markets which have been growing more gloomy for their own reasons in recent months. 
 But copper, the major London Metal Exchange contract still to be denominated in pounds, did benefit. 
 Cash LME copper jumped by &pound;54.50 a tonne, helped by persistent buying in New York and concern about political pressure to close the Ok Tedi mine in Papua New Guinea. 
 A fall of 1,400 tonnes in LME copper stocks, to 102,875 tonnes, also supported the market. 
 Coffee, however, enjoyed no such support. 
 The inconclusive end to a fortnight's talks at the International Coffee Organisation further depressed the market. 
 On the London Fox the January contract collapsed to &pound;636 a tonne, its lowest since the great Brazilian frost of 1975. 
 The contract later recovered, but signs that producers are selling coffee to maintain market share and income are likely to push prices down further. 
 Accross the London Fox floor, cocoa remained dominated by strong positions in the December contract. 
 Cocoa for delivery that month traded at a premium of &pound;36 a tonne to March, the next contract month, about &pound;10 a tonne more than on Friday. 
 Technology: Radio paging about to go international 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 RADIO paging across the world is becoming a reality with the introduction of &bquo;frequency agile&equo; pagers which can listen in to the frequencies used by different countries. 
 Like most radio services, paging is limited by the regulatory authorities' allocation of frequencies, which tend to differ from country to country. 
 But British Telecom Mobile Communications is introducing a transatlantic paging service based on frequency-hopping technology &mdash; the first on which the same pager can used in either the UK or the US. 
 The service is being launched through Metrocast, the US operation in which BT has an 80 per cent stake. 
 Metrocast already needs frequency-agile paging to cope with the fragmented US market, and this is now being extended for British businessmen who travel to the States. 
 The pagers are alphanumeric &mdash; they relay information in the form of words and numbers to a tiny scrolling screen on the pager. 
 Calls made to the BT bureau in Ealing, west London, will be passed on as usual, taking into account the traveller's schedule and the different time zones he or she encounters along the way. 
 For anyone who travels regularly to the US, the Metrocast service covering more than 100 cities will cost &pound;45 a month plus an initial fee of &pound;30. 
 Less frequent travellers can have a transatlantic pager for &pound;48 a week or &pound;144 a month. 
 From January next year a cross-border paging service will be operated covering the UK, Italy, France and Germany, with the British end operated by the Euromessage consortium. 
 Euromessage, which includes BT, Air Call, Radal Vodapage, Millicom, InterCity and Digital, has been awarded the UK licence to operate on a particular UHF singled out for the service. 
 Because all four countries have agreed on one frequency, the &bquo;agile&equo; pagers are not needed. 
 From 1993 a more sophisticated European operation called Ermes &mdash; European Radio Messaging System &mdash; will be introduced. 
 But by then paging will be in the thick of furious competition in mobile communications. 
 Digital cordless telephone services &mdash; telepoint &mdash; are about to start in the UK, and low cost personal communications networks are due to begin in 1992 or 1993. 
 Telepoint offers one-way telephone services and PCN is expected to be like an affordable cellular radio, so the need for paging seems dubious. 
 But, according to Jerry Mooney, group marketing director for BT paging, the cinderella of the mobile communications business still has a bright future. 
 Pagers are expected to be incorporated into telepoint telephones, offsetting the disadvantage of being able to make only outgoing calls. 
 Incorporated in PCN handsets, pagers would have the advantage of consuming very little power and would allow the power-hungry PCN telephone to be switched off most of the time. 
 Psion, the UK manufacturer of handheld and laptop computers, has also announced plans to incorporate pagers into computers. 
 One thing which could give pagers a new lease of life is miniaturisation. 
 The Japanese are developing pagers the size of credit cards which could arrive in this country as early as next year. 
 Technology: European boost for the British Technology Group 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 THE BRITISH Technology Group, the UK's technology transfer organisation, is branching out into Europe, patenting and licensing technology from researchers throughout the Continent. 
 With the possibility of privatisation looming, the BTG has been making strenuous efforts to become an international organisation. 
 Now the European Institute of Technology &mdash; an industrial organisation founded by IBM Europe, AT&amp;T, Enichem, Montedison and Philips &mdash; has asked it to handle the intellectual property rights for the scientific projects it supports in European institutions. 
 The EIT was set up last year to help fund university research which could help underpin the technological base of Europe's industry. 
 The scheme began with 35 projects funded to the tune of Ecu10,000 each to put forward more detailed proposals. 
 Now about a dozen or so of those are to go ahead with funds of up to Ecu250,000 a year for three years. 
 The problem with industry-funded research has always been sorting out the intellectual property rights. 
 The EIT's policy is to hold the patents for products and processes accruing from its funding and to allow members to licence them. 
 Royalties are to be distributed between the EIT and the research scientists. 
 With the institute opening its doors to many more companies and introducing ways for smaller firms to take part, the issue could become complex. 
 The British Technology Group will be responsible for all patenting and for handling licensing of any technologies which the member companies do not want. 
 An important role will be deciding what a fair rate of return for the academics should be in any given project. 
 According to the EIT, funds for research should rise to Ecu5m next year. 
 The annual subscription for large companies is still Ecu200,000, but companies with sales of up to Ecu8bn can pay Ecu100,000 a year. 
 The deal is a boost for the BTG, the future of which has been in the balance since the middle of last year. 
 A Coopers &amp; Lybrand report to the Government on the possibilities of privatisation was delivered in summer 1988, but since then the group has had little indication of what its fate might be. 
 Technology: Scoring for the boss in extra time 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 EMPLOYERS gain almost two hours a week on average from early-bird employees, and only 30 per cent of employees contribute no extra time at all, according to a report by the mobile communications group Phonepoint. 
 Traffic problems are the single biggest reason why people are late for work, says the report, accounting for one-third of late arrivals, with oversleeping and bus or tube problems accounting for 16 per cent and 9 per cent respectively. 
 Workers under 35 years are the worst oversleepers, but overall women are more likely to be late than men, the survey found. 
 Women are also more likely to leave work earlier, although only 15 per cent of people surveyed would admit to leaving early at all. 
 To be sure of punctuality, firms should employ more people in the over-55 age group, in which three-quarters of businessmen claim to be early almost every day. 
 Businessmen and women in the North-west and Midlands are more likely to be early than their counterparts in London despite the fact that traffic is apparently not a significantly bigger problem. 
 FKB moves into US medical promotions 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 THE ACQUISITIVE sales promotion company FKB Group has broken into the lucrative US medical promotions market with the &dollar;41m (&pound;26m) acquisition of a specialist marketing company. 
 FKB has bought Audio Visual Medical Marketing Inc and its associated companies Pharmaceutical Services International and Data Medical Communications, collectively known as AVMD. 
 A key element of the deal means that all senior AVMD staff, including senior partner Jan Robinson, have signed five-year contracts to stay with the group. 
 FKB is paying for the US group through an initial &dollar;3.5m in new shares, with a further &dollar;19m funded through loan notes realisable in January. 
 Future payments totalling &dollar;18.5m will depend on average post-tax profits over the next four years. 
 AVMD made &dollar;846,000 pre-tax in 1988 and is warranted as having net assets of at least &dollar;1.15m. 
 Duncan Bain, FKB's joint group chief executive, said: &bquo;This acquisition will not dilute earnings even in the short term. 
 &bquo;We expect it to contribute 4.5 per cent of profits, and we base that on our expected group performance of 20 per cent organic growth a year.&equo; 
 FKB, the UK's largest independent sales promotion company, has over the past 15 months made half a dozen US acquisitions. 
 Mr Bain, who is in charge of the US operations, said: &bquo;We didn't have any presence in the specialist medical markets, and pharmaceuticals is a fast-growing business with an ageing Western population and greater choice of drugs to be marketed. 
 It should not be affected by recession. 
 &bquo;Any company which has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on developing and testing a drug is not going to wait before bringing it out.&equo; 
 AVMD helps in this marketing operation and has most of the major US drugs firms on its client list. 
 Mr Bain hopes FKB's other US companies can pick up business from the non-drugs operations of those clients. 
 Savage forced to cut nearly 200 staff 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 SAVAGE GROUP, the USM quoted DIY retail chain, has dismissed almost 200 of its 1,000 UK staff in the face of a slump that cut earnings per share by a third. 
 Sales almost doubled from &pound;61.9m to &pound;120m for the year to 30 June, but operating margins fell sharply and pre-tax profits rose just five per cent to &pound;7.29m. 
 Last-quarter UK sales were hard hit by high interest rates eating into disposable income, a slower housing market, and a fall-off in DIY interest caused by the hot weather. 
 This year's first quarter sales are still below those of last year in the UK, says David Stephens, Savage's financial director, and there is no sign of a pick-up. 
 in the market. 
 &bquo;July and August are normally quiet, but this year has been exceptional and the latest interest rate rise won't help,&equo; he said. 
 Savage's interest charges are up from &pound;900,000 to almost &pound;2.4m, and gearing was around 90 per cent of shareholders' funds. 
 The UK accounts for almost half group turnover, and the European operations, mainly France and Germany &bquo;are not suffering in the same way as the UK,&equo; Mr Stephens said. 
 Company News in Brief 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 W B INDUSTRIES, the fully listed spring manufacturer, is funding three acquisitions and reducing its debt with a &pound;5.75m two-for-five rights issue. 
 It is buying Elson and Robbins, a seat spring maker, for &pound;4.1m cash and &pound;820,000 in new shares. 
 Elson and Robbins had a turnover of &pound;15.5m in the year to 31 December compared to WB's &pound;3.6m. 
 W B shares were suspended at 75p yesterday. 
 DOWTY GROUP, the high technology electronics to engineering company, has paid &dollar;12m (&pound;7.5m) in shares for Palmer Chenard Industries, of New Hampshire, USA. 
 HEYWOOD WILLIAMS, the aluminium and plastics company, has bought Gloster Plastics, window frame makers, for &pound;2.8m, which could increase to &pound;4.7m depending on profits. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 ICI disposal: Imperial Chemical Industries has sold its US over-the-counter drugs business in a &dollar;450m (&pound;285m) deal with Johnson &amp; Johnson-Merck Consumer Pharmaceuticals, which also gives it the rights to Merck's Elavil anti-depressant drug. 
 View from City Road, page 29 James Neill suspended: Shares in James Neill, the Sheffield engineer, were suspended at 202p, valuing the company at &pound;140.2m, prompting speculation that an agreed bid will be launched today. 
 Page 29 Broking concern: Concern is growing that a number of stockbrokers will be unable to meet a January deadline for VAT changes which are expected to reduce the cost of share dealing. 
 Page 27 TIP leaps 40 per cent: Pre-tax profits at TIP Europe, the trailer rental company, rose 40 per cent from &pound;9m to &pound;12.6m in the year to July as the fleet grew from 10,000 to 18,000 vehicles. 
 Page 29 Compromise on mergers: The junior industry minister, John Redwood, is to propose a way out of the row over European mergers policy when he meets EC ministers in Luxembourg today. 
 Outlook, 27 Savage cuts: Savage Group, the USM-quoted do-it-yourself retail chain, dismissed almost 200 of its 1,000 UK staff in the face of a slump that cut earnings by a third. 
 Page 30 Cluff glitters: Rising gold production pushed Cluff Resources' pre-tax profits for the half year to 30 June up ninefold to &pound;790,000 and strengthened the possibility that the group could pay a maiden dividend this year. 
 Page 29 Lowndes board strengthened: Lowndes Queensway, the troubled furniture and carpets retailer which recently completed a &pound;18.5m refinancing, has appointed two heavyweight non-executive directors. 
 Page 29 Sterling slumps: The pound posted its steepest one-day fall in more than three years, sinking almost six pfennigs in a few hours to close at DM2.9737. 
 Recovery by Mrs Fields: Shares in Mrs Fields, the troubled US bakery and cookie retailer, rose more than 20 per cent from their 12-month low of 19p to 23p after it announced much reduced trading losses. 
 Page 29 US purchase for FKB: Acquisitive sales promotion company FKB Group has broken into the lucrative US medical promotions market with the &dollar;41m (&pound;26m) acquisition of a specialist marketing company. 
 Page 30 Manx payouts: Some 4,000 depositors who lost &pound;42m in one of Britain's biggest bank crashes are to receive their first interim payment following an &pound;11.7m judgment against City financier Jim Raper in the Manx Chancery Court yesterday. 
 Page 27 Buoyant Borland: Borland International said it expected second quarter results to beat analysts' expectations after buoyant sales of Paradox, the US software company's database product. 
 Page 29 World Markets New York: The Columbus holiday and Yom Kippur hit trading, and in low turnover the Dow Jones Industrial Average slipped before rallying to close 5.89 points higher at 2,791.41. 
 Tokyo: Fuelled by the dollar's decline against the yen, the Nikkei average recovered 167 points of Friday's heavy losses to close at 35,376.35. 
 Singapore: After touching another post-crash high at midday, the Straits Times index fell back to close 0.37 lower at 1,420.18. 
 Bombay: Heavy institutional demand to start the new account took prices broadly higher, but a rise in contango charges prompted private investors to sell. 
 Frankfurt: The DAX index rose 14.69 points to end at 1,658.12, within 20 points of the record high set last month. 
 Zurich: The stable dollar and Wall Street's firm Friday close stimulated early trading. 
 The index added 2.2 points to 1,196.5. 
 Milan: Shares rebounded from Friday's losses but ended below the day's highs, with the MIB 0.43 per cent higher at 1,169. 
 Brussels: Prices tumbled on the last day of the forward account Oslo: Caution ahead of the 1990 budget clipped 3.83 points off the index to 527.08. 
 Stockholm: Strong gains by engineer Alfa-Laval helped the index to a 0.06 per cent rise. 
 Analysts predict rates will stay put 
 By CLARE DOBIE, Deputy City Editor 
 THE City is braced for further nervous trading in both currencies and shares this week but most analysts expect interest rates to stay at 15 per cent despite yesterday's slump in the value of the pound. 
 As the pound slid through the important benchmark of DM3 to close at DM2.9737 and lost ground against the dollar, most analysts agreed that the Chancellor would resist a further hike in interest rates at least for the duration of the Conservative Party conference, and possibly for some weeks to come. 
 A typical comment came from Bob Semple of County NatWest, the stockbroking arm of National Westminster. 
 &bquo;I don't think interest rates will go up again. 
 The Chancellor has no option but to sit and wait,&equo; he said. 
 But others were less sanguine. 
 Richard Kersley of BZW, the Barclays Bank offshoot, said the Chancellor would not only have to increase interest rates but would also have to make other changes. 
 These could include promising to join the European Monetary System and mopping up liquidity by, for example, special banking deposit rates. 
 The outlook for sterling is clouded by confusion about whether the Chancellor has set a new floor for the pound. 
 This uncertainty was behind much of yesterday's fall against the mark. 
 Some brokers suggested the floor had shifted to DM2.95 but others thought the pound would have to fall still further, possibly to DM2.90, before the Chancellor would react. 
 The full extent of the weakness in sterling may only become apparent today when trading in the US returns to normal levels after a holiday yesterday. 
 Analysts were divided over the prospects for share prices as the widely based FT-SE 100 index lost a further 30.5 points to close at 2,247.0. 
 Most thought there would be further falls this week. 
 Phillips &amp; Drew, the broking house, has stuck to its forecast that the FT-SE index will be 2,350 at the year end. 
 But BZW remains more pessimistic, believing the FT-SE index would have to fall to 2,200 before it started to look attractive to investors. 
 Traders are anxiously waiting for further cues from the Conservatives at Blackpool and the next set of economic statistics. 
 The retail price index for September is due on Friday when US figures for producer prices are also expected. 
 Later there will be a Confederation of British Industry quarterly survey. 
 Market expectations are for little change upwards in the RPI from the latest figure of 7.3 per cent. 
 Housing market blues until 1992 
 By GAIL COUNSELL, Property Correspondent 
 HIGH interest rates mean the housing market looks set to stay depressed until 1992. 
 Until recently most analysts had expected house prices to begin to recover in early 1991. 
 While prices were forcast to fall by about 10 per cent on average next year, a slow decline in interest rates over the next 12 months was seen as prompting a resurgence the following spring. 
 But the worsening base rate environment, which yesterday forced the Halifax, the UK's largest building society, to increase its mortgage rate by one percentage point to 14.5 per cent, seems certain to delay that process. 
 &bquo;I think the housing market is bound to be psychologically affected,&equo; said Gary Marsh, head of research for the Halifax. 
 &bquo;Our view is the recovery will probably now be delayed to the end of 1991.&equo; 
 House prices have already begun to fall across the country with the most recent statistics showing the Midlands and the North joining London and the South-east. 
 Prices in some areas have dropped by between 10 and 20 per cent this year and the number of sales has been half last year's. 
 The Halifax's monthly index shows prices fell by 0.3 per cent during August, compared with a peak in July last year of 4.3 per cent. 
 Union leaders warn of massive job losses 
 By HELEN HAGUE, Labour Correspondent 
 THE RISE in interest rates could cost thousands of jobs across the economy &mdash; with the retail, service and construction sectors hardest hit, union leaders and industrialists warned yesterday. 
 Last week, John Edmonds, general secretary of the GMB general union, predicted that high interest rates could kill around 250,000 jobs in the service sector. 
 Yesterday, the union claimed the first jobs casualty of the base rate rise &mdash; the Automobile Association's announcement of 500 job losses, in the wake of the company's decision to pull out of the air package holiday business. 
 The company said it was &bquo;pointless to continue to compete in the overcrowded, heavily discounted and ultimately unprofitable air package holidays business&equo;. 
 The travel industry expects more cutbacks as holidays are sacrificed to meet the mounting cost of household bills. 
 The CBI fears that the interest and consequent mortgage rate rise will feed through to higher wage claims. 
 Its latest forecast, issued in August, found that order books had already fallen behind &bquo;normal&equo; levels. 
 As the forecast assumed interest rates would peak at 14 per cent it has already been eclipsed by events. 
 Even from that base, the CBI predicted that unemployment would rise to 1.72 million in the last quarter of this year to 1.83 million in the last quarter of 1990. 
 Revised forecasts &mdash; expected in November &mdash; are likely to be more pessimistic. 
 Imported food lifts raw material costs 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 MANUFACTURING industry's raw material costs jumped 1 per cent last month due mainly to higher prices for imported food for the processing industry. 
 The increase, which followed a 0.2 per cent decline in August, took the index for materials and fuel purchased by industry to 104.6, 1985=100, after adjustment for seasonal influences, to stand a provisional 5.3 per cent above a year earlier. 
 The rise was principally due to higher prices of imported food processing material, underlining City concern over the inflationary impact of a weakening pound. 
 Prices of other imported materials also increased during the month. 
 Meanwhile prices at the factory gate increased 0.4 per cent in September, the same as in August, lifting the index to 120.0, 1985=100, which was 5 per cent above a year earlier. 
 Excluding prices of food, drink and tobacco, regarded as a more reliable guide to the underlying trend, factory gate prices rose 0.5 per cent during September and were 5.5 per cent higher than a year earlier. 
 City economists also worried that factory gate price inflation was proving difficult to curb. 
 In spite of high interest rates, price inflation at the factory gate has varied from 4.8-5.2 per cent during the past seven months with little indication that it is set to slip below the range. 
 Several analysts said this was evidence of continued strong demand in the economy. 
 Receiver goes into shopfitter Sharp 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 SHARP &amp; LAW, the Bradford-based shopfitter, has called in Cork Gully as administrative receiver following a demand from Barclays Bank for about &pound;18m of outstanding loans. 
 The receiver has gone in at only the parent company, and Sharp yesterday made it clear that seven of its 15 operating subsidiaries were going concerns. 
 Indeed the company is close to raising up to &pound;30m from the sale of three operations &mdash; Baxter Fell Northfleet, Internal Partition Systems and the French shopfitter, S N Giblin Lavault. 
 Accountants Ernst &amp; Young, which is handling the sale, said negotiations were at an advanced stage. 
 Sharp, which is quoted on the USM, had its shares suspended at 42p last week. 
 Earlier this year it was forced to restate its 1987 profits from &pound;1.2m to &pound;410,000 after an investigation by Ernst &amp; Young discovered errors in the valuations of contracts at Sharp's main business in Bradford. 
 These problems meant 1988 profits were only &pound;1.06m, compared to expectations of over &pound;4m, and in June the company warned that profits for this year would be below expectations. 
 Brian Considine, Sharp's chairman, said the 1989 figures would be affected by management problems at the Bradford operation, troubles in the retail sector and high interest rates. 
 Tunnel revenue forecasts fail to allay cost fears 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 EUROTUNNEL confirmed yesterday that Channel tunnel revenues are not forecast to rise in the early years of operation to offset the &pound;2.2bn rise in the cost of the project to &pound;7bn. 
 The news sent the Anglo-French group's share price plunging a further 40p to close at 528p. 
 According to the latest traffic forecasts in the consortium's interim report projected revenue in 1993, the year the tunnel opens, will be just under &pound;580m &mdash; the same figure as forecast last year. 
 Eurotunnel's traffic consultants have, however, increased their forecasts of long-term revenue. 
 They believe that revenue will reach &pound;820m a year in 2003 and &pound;997m in 2013 &mdash; respectively 6.7 per cent and 8 per cent higher than forecast last year. 
 Despite the gloomy initial traffic forecasts, Alastair Morton, the British co-chairman of Eurotunnel, rejected suggestions that fares would be forced up, saying they would be competitive with ferry and air fares. 
 Mr Morton described weekend press reports of a serious rift between Eurotunnel and Transmanche Link, the consortium of British and French construction firms building the tunnel, as &bquo;the Batman school of journalism&equo;. 
 &bquo;There is no row or brawl going on,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;What there is is a strong difference of commercial opinion.&equo; 
 However, it is clear the two sides are far from agreement on the extra &pound;382m TML claims the tunnel terminals and fixed equipment will cost, which Mr Morton described as &bquo;manifestly absurd&equo;. 
 He refused to be drawn on what would happen if the two failed to reach agreement in time to get the banks' support for an extra &pound;1bn-&pound;1.2bn of finance next year. 
 Without a satisfactory agreement the banks could refuse to lend more money on top of the &pound;6bn in total committed to the project and demand that Eurotunnel be replaced. 
 Mr Morton, said he was &bquo;pretty confident&equo; that would not happen. 
 If a deal was hammered out with the banks, an accompanying rights issue to raise up to &pound;400m from existing private shareholders was likely next spring. 
 Ferranti shareholders to meet chairman today 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Assistant Business Editor 
 FERRANTI International shareholders meet today amid indications that there will be no solution to the company's problems until Christmas at the earliest. 
 Sir Derek Alun-Jones, Ferranti's chairman, is expected to postpone the annual meeting for a second time so that revised accounts can be prepared to include the effect of the &pound;185m International Signal and Control fraud. 
 Sir Derek will resist pressure from some shareholders to resign in the belief that this is largely a minority view. 
 A spokesman for Ferranti said Sir Derek had no reason to fear a shareholders' revolt and there were no indications that there would be one. 
 The company's advisers, Baring Brothers, believe that nothing would be served by making Sir Derek a scapegoat at this stage. 
 They believe that any newcomer would take months to come to grips with what has gone wrong at Ferranti and would as a consequence be worse placed to negotiate a rescue for the group. 
 Sir Derek is expected to give further details of the progress of negotiations at today's shareholders' meeting. 
 Potential suitors are believed to be holding off from making outright bids for fear that there may be further black holes in Ferranti's balance sheet. 
 They also want to assess more fully the damage that the debacle might have done to long-term customer confidence in Ferranti. 
 Institutional shareholders have told Sir Derek they would not be prepared to tolerate the introduction of a large minority shareholder on favourable terms. 
 Such a solution would only dilute their interest in the company. 
 They have also ruled out any possibility of supporting a rights issue. 
 British Aerospace, possibly in partnership with Thomson CSF of France, has emerged as the leading British contender to mount a bid but could face Ministry of Defence objections. 
 The MoD is keen to preserve Ferranti as an independent force in defence electronics. 
 It feels unduly reliant on GEC and BAe for its procurement needs and does not wish to see this reinforced. 
 Fines plan to combat power cuts 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Assistant Business Editor 
 THE ABILITY of the electricity industry to keep the lights burning once it is privatised was thrown into confusion yesterday. 
 It emerged that the Government is being forced to alter arrangements for protecting security of supply and impose fines on distribution companies that allow power cuts. 
 The changes in the system were disclosed in a letter to employees of National Power, one of the two big generating companies being created in the sell-off, from its chairman, Lord Marshall. 
 Under the present system the Central Electricity Generating Board is charged with ensuring there is enough power station capacity to meet demand. 
 When the industry is sold off this obligation will be transferred to privately- owned distribution companies. 
 However, Lord Marshall's letter says that because of the Government's commitment to introduce competition into electricity supply as quickly as possible &bquo;alternative arrangements for protecting the security of supply&equo; would need to be made, involving a &bquo;capacity deficiency scheme&equo;. 
 Tony Blair, Labour's energy spokesman, last night described Lord Marshall's letter as &bquo;deeply disturbing&equo; and called on John Wakeham, Secretary of State for Energy, for an explanation. 
 A Department of Energy spokesman said: &bquo;Hopefully this should not lead to power cuts in most cases because distributors ought to be able to get supplies from other area boards.&equo; 
 GM may build plant for Jaguar 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON 
 GENERAL MOTORS of the US may build new facilities in the UK to support a major increase in Jaguar production as part of its plan to take a 30 per cent stake in the luxury car maker. 
 This emerged yesterday as the two companies finally confirmed they were discussing a deal to thwart the rival US car giant Ford, which intends to build a 15 per cent stake in Jaguar in preparation for a full bid. 
 In a joint statement issued after the stock market had closed, the two companies said they were examining &bquo;certain manufacturing, marketing and other commercial joint venture arrangements&equo; as part of which GM is &bquo;considering taking a minority interest&equo;. 
 Earlier in the day Jaguar shares had fallen back to close 46p down at 685p as speculators cashed in their stock for large profits. 
 There were also rumours that Ford had now taken its stake up to the maximum 15 per cent allowed under the golden share held in Jaguar by the Government since its privatisation in 1984. 
 Ford later said that the Jaguar-GM talks had not affected its own plans &bquo;Today's announcement does not affect our view in any way, and we still plan to acquire up to a 15 per cent holding in Jaguar,&equo; said a Ford spokesman in Detroit. 
 GM's plan is to take a 15 per cent stake in the Coventry-based car maker rising to 29.9 per cent immediately the golden share expires at the end of next year. 
 A variety of options for building the stake are being examined including an issue of new shares in return for GM injecting between &pound;200m and &pound;600m. 
 Alternatively, GM may opt for a mix of new shares and shares bought in the market. 
 Part of the strategy of GM, the world's biggest car maker, will be to increase Jaguar's output of 50,000 cars a year by two or threefold and launch new models into the executive market. 
 This may involve an expansion of Jaguar's main Coventry plant, the building of a new greenfield site or possibly utilisation of spare capacity at the Luton and Ellesmere Port factories of GM's British subsidiary Vauxhall. 
 Another possibility being mentioned was that GM could begin Jaguar production in the US &mdash; the company's biggest market. 
 This would help protect Jaguar from fluctuations in the dollar-sterling exchange rate &mdash; the principal factor behind the collapse in its pre-tax profits in the first half of the year to &pound;1.2m. 
 Last night Ford declined to comment on the long-awaited Jaguar/GM statement although the company is expected to respond shortly. 
 Ford, however, has made it clear that it wants ultimate majority control of Jaguar &mdash; something which the company's board, led by chairman Sir John Egan, is resisting fiercely. 
 Armchair Investor: Brixton Estate 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON 
 PROPERTY stocks and high interest rates are not thought to be a good combination. 
 But the security and long-term attractions of many of the investor/developers, as opposed to the property traders which hold on to little of what they develop, makes many of the downgradings a nonsense. 
 Majors, such as Land Securities and MEPC, have been hit severely and unjustly and Brixton Estate, a favourite in Armchair Investor, has lost a quarter of its value since this column recommended investors take profits at the end of August. 
 At 194p, down 7p yesterday, the shares stand at a discount of 37.5 per cent to the net asset value expected for the end of this year. 
 Brixton is in a particularly strong position. 
 Its portfolio is split 60:40 between industrial properties and offices. 
 Many of the offices are in the West End of London, where rentals are still growing, and there are quite a few rent reviews coming up in the next few months. 
 The industrial property is even more secure. 
 There is a shortage of industrial sites in the South-east of England and rentals are now coming up after lagging behind offices and housing through the late 1980s. 
 Although Brixton has &pound;180m of borrowings, all but a small proportion of this is borrowed at fixed rates so it does not suffer from higher interest rates. 
 And as a final plus point, Brixton has no retail property. 
 Take advantage of current weakness and buy Brixton for the medium to long term. 
 Market Report: Interest rate fears spread despondency 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 FEARS that interest rates will be forced even higher demoralised the stock market yesterday. 
 In nervous trading the broadly based FT-SE share index slumped 30.5 points to 2,247.0, wiping, Datastream calculated, &pound;6.5bn from share values. 
 Government stocks fell by more than &pound;1. 
 The market is at its lowest level since July. 
 It was only a month ago that the index hit a post crash high of 2,423.9. 
 Many observers believe it will fall to below 2,200 points even if the anti-inflation policy works and the 15 per cent base rate level is held. 
 But, if sterling's performance against the US dollar and West German mark is anything to go by, the worry of 16 per cent base rates will continue. 
 Any further increase could push Footsie, which started the year at 1,782.8, below 2,000. 
 Trading yesterday was modest, reflecting the Yom Kippur Jewish holiday. 
 Turnover, according to SEAQ, was 425.8 million shares. 
 Stores had another miserable day. 
 Beers, building and properties were other sectors which suffered acute discomfort. 
 Many of the old takeover favourites were also hard hit as speculators moved to take their profits. 
 Dalgety fell 11p to 413p. 
 Como International, the Robert Holmes a Court / Elf Aquataine company, has lowered its stake to below 5 per cent. 
 Jaguar plunged 46p to 685p as General Motors confirmed it is in talks that could result in it taking a minority stake. 
 Mr Holmes a Court is thought to have taken advantage of the share's rapid progress, selling his 2 per cent stake. 
 Ferranti, after touching 61p, closed just 0.5p higher at 59.5p. 
 British Aerospace, one of the likely bidders, fell 16p to 604p. 
 Eurotunnel's sad retreat continued. 
 The interim report left the shares 40p down at 528p. 
 Joint chairman Alastair Morton is due to make an investment presentation at the Victoria headquarters of Salomon Brothers this morning. 
 Saatchi &amp; Saatchi, the communications group, was one to shine through the gloom. 
 Continuing speculation about a bid helped the shares improve a further 9.5p to 349.5p. 
 At one time they hit 356p. 
 An array of stories are bemusing the market. 
 Adia, the Swiss group, is said to be keen to buy chunks of Saatchi. 
 An Italian bidder, with US support, is rumoured to lurk. 
 Southeastern Asset Management, a US group, was said to be on the verge of selling on its 10 per cent stake. 
 There was also some excitement on the oil pitch, with a number of old stories given another whirl. 
 Burmah was in demand, climbing 18p to 619p, a considerable performance on such a depressing day. 
 Rumours of transatlantic bids persistently hover over Burmah but it seemed to be the suspected presence of SHV, the big Dutch group, that fuelled the price. 
 SHV, which has 43 per cent of Calor Group, was thought to be buying Burmah. 
 One idea is that SHV wants to sell its Calor stake to Burmah and, as part of the deal, take a 15 per cent interest in Burmah. 
 But Premier Consolidated Oilfields could also be entangled. 
 Burmah has just under 30 per cent, which could be sold on to SHV, or another party. 
 Overall oils were among the best performing shares with the sector's defensive qualities in the present uncertain atmosphere drawing support. 
 Guinness was the best performing drink share as analysts stretched their year's forecast higher after last week's interims. 
 Some now expect &pound;673m against &pound;521m. 
 Bass fell 16p to 908p. 
 Nigel Popham at CIBC Grenfell &amp; Colegrave says the shares are undervalued. 
 He expects profits to dip this year from the estimated &pound;580m in the year just ended but reach &pound;645m next year. 
 Armstrong Equipment, resisting a bid from Caparo, fell 1p to 185p. 
 Possible white knight JH Fenner lifted its stake to 5.6 per cent. 
 Five Oaks Investments, the property group, edged forward another 3p to 83p. 
 London Securities now has 13.6 per cent. 
 British &amp; Commonwealth, the financial group, was another to resist the retreat. 
 The shares gained 4p to 139p on management buyout stories. 
 Newcomer Reg Vardy, a motor dealer, closed at 92p against a 90p placing price. 
 The stock market was a depressed area again yesterday. 
 At one time the FT-SE share index was down 34.9 points. 
 It closed 30.5 points lower at 2,247.0. 
 The FT 30 share index finished 34.9 points down at 1,822.9. 
 Government stocks were also weak, falling by up to &pound;1. 
 Mount Charlotte Investments, the hotel group, offers the opportunity to invest in a stockbroker. 
 It has a 13.1 per cent stake in Peel Hunt. 
 Robert Peel, MCI's chief executive, has 5.2 per cent. 
 Peel Hunt, where a leading light is Charles Peel, Robert's brother, will collect a &pound;200,000 fee in connection with MCI's &pound;151m rights issue. 
 MCI shares held at 77p. 
 Speculation is increasing that Continental, the West German tyre maker, will be forced to bid for Kwik-Fit, the tyres and exhausts business. 
 Since building up a 10 per cent stake Continental has tried to arrange trading pacts. 
 But so far Kwik-Fit's chairman, Tom Farmer, has, it appears, shown little inclination to meet the German wishes. 
 Kwik-Fit slippd 1p to 143p. 
 View from City Road: Eurotunnel must dig up facts 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 ALASTAIR MORTON, Eurotunnel's co-chairman, was keen yesterday to stress that his upbeat presentation of the Channel link's interim financial progress report should not be interpreted as an arrogant dismissal of the clear underlying problems. 
 His approach may not be arrogant but neither is it justified. 
 The time is fast approaching where both the stock market and Eurotunnel's bankers require something a little more concrete than vague reassurances that it will be all right on the night. 
 There was little in the report to offer investors any incentive to assess the company more favouarbly. 
 In London the shares lost a further 40p to close at 528p and it was a similar story in Paris. 
 The shares have more than halved in value since the summer high of 1,172p. 
 Eurotunnel's prospects will only become apparent once the delicate negotiations with the banks and contractors have been completed. 
 And it would be dangerous to underestimate the seriousness of those talks. 
 The banks can technically pull the plug on Eurotunnel. 
 The common view is that this is unthinkable and politically unacceptable. 
 But some bankers have an acute awareness of where their loyalties lie and the idea of winding Eurotunnel up and continuing the project with a new management company may have its attractions. 
 It would ensure that the tunnel was completed and would give the banks much more direct access to the project and its long-term rewards. 
 The only losers would be the shareholders but they always knew this was a high-risk project. 
 The negotiations with the banks are complicated by the discussions with the contractors. 
 Although Eurotunnel's attitude to Trans Manche Link, the contractors' consortium, was more conciliatory yesterday than has been the case, there are still important differences to be settled. 
 The contractors are rightly concerned that they should not be forced to pick up the bill for problems which are not of their making. 
 The next few months will be crucial in determining Eurotunnel's future as the nominated manager of the Channel link. 
 It may be tempting to regard today's share price as a buying opportunity but it is a temptation which should be avoided given the uncertainties and high risk which the company still attracts. 
 View from City Road: ICI deal makes strategic sense 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 IMPERIAL Chemical Industries seems to have struck a surprisingly good &dollar;450m (&pound;285m) deal with Johnson &amp; Johnson and Merck in swapping its US over-the counter pharmaceutical business for the rights to an established anti-depressant drug and a substantial, if as yet unquantified, cash sum. 
 In strategic terms the move makes plenty of sense. 
 Because of the need for marketing economies of scale there is no point in being a small player, which ICI is, in the OTC market. 
 If further proof were needed it is the formation of the joint Johnson &amp; Johnson-Merck Consumer Pharmaceuticals Co itself. 
 Even if ICI's presence in the US OTC market with its well-known Mylanta and Mylanta II antacids is relatively modest it can still get a good price for these products. 
 The company is coy about revealing the profits from its US OTC products. 
 But it is notable enough that the deal is worth 3.6 times the annual &dollar;125m sales value of these products. 
 If they made a profit margin of 15 per cent to 20 per cent then the the value of the deal, which includes the rights to Merck's Elavil anti-depressant, is equivalent to 18 times pre-tax profits. 
 The latest move comes at a time when ICI's &pound;1.2bn a year pharmaceutical division, which accounts for around a fifth of group trading profits, is set to emerge from a relatively fallow period. 
 Since 1985 profits growth in the division has been restricted to an average of less than 5 per cent a year and as 40 per cent of revenues come from the US the one third fall in the dollar over the period obviously affected the outcome as have rising R&amp;D costs. 
 But ICI's top drug Tenormin, the beta-blocker, has also run into competition from rival cardiovascular products such as ACE-inhibitors and calcium antagonists and growing generic competition as Tenormin has gradually come off-patent. 
 New products are, however, in the offing as Zoladex for prostate cancer and the intravenous anaesthetic Diprivan are soon to be launched in the key US market. 
 By acquiring the rights to Merck's Elival, ICI will gain expertise in marketing drugs for the central nervous system to support its own products in that area which are currently being developed. 
 But fears of a bulk chemical downturn and worries about the dollar overshadow the ICI share price which at 1,175p sells on less than 8 times 1989 earnings. 
 View from City Road: Ivory &amp; Sime's wildcard 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 NIGEL LAWSON has been testing Ivory &amp; Sime's sense of humour. 
 As the fund manager launched a campaign to sell its &bquo;optimum income trust&equo; &mdash; a new variation on an old theme, the split trust &mdash; the authorities were orchestrating a base rate rise and the stock market is now providing stark illustration of how equities and climbing interest rates do not mix. 
 The outlook is as menacing as ever, the sort of uncertainty which puts excitement into investment markets and pacemakers into investors. 
 But the Ivory &amp; Sime trust caters for both the faint-hearted and those happy to embrace risk in the hope of greater rewards. 
 The &pound;65m trust is divided into ordinary shares, paying quarterly dividends, and &bquo;zero dividend&equo; preference shares. 
 Holders of the prefs will forego dividends in return for 13.7 per cent compound growth over the trust's seven years, thereby allowing the managers to increase dividends to ordinary shareholders who will hold two-thirds of the capital. 
 They can expect an income return of 8.5 per cent in the first year. 
 To do this, and to be able to return to all shareholders the full 100p value of their initial investment, the managers must achieve compound growth of 6.8 per cent &mdash; a modest target given their plan to invest 80 per cent of the fund in UK blue-chip companies and the fact that the top 20 Footsie stocks last year accounted for 40 per cent of the total income of the FT-all share index. 
 Returns above this will go to the risk-takers &mdash; holders of the ordinary shares. 
 An added wildcard is the attraction for PEPs. 
 Because of a loophole in the legislation &mdash; which some believe will be closed soon &mdash; &pound;4,800 can be invested in this trust, double the usual maximum. 
 With the associated tax break, the promised returns could gross up into handsome rewards. 
 Column Eight: Change of course for Burke's 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 The grand old name of Burke's Peerage could soon appear on some rather surprising household items. 
 The company which owns the worldwide franchise of the name and trademark is planning an expansion phase &mdash; in the best possible taste, of course &mdash; and is hoping to get into the pockets of a few well-heeled outside investors. 
 A discreet notice has appeared in the latest newsletter of the Local Investment Networking Company, an organisation which matches rich private investors with needy entrepreneurs. 
 Brooks Marketing, which owns the Burke's franchise, is offering about 10 per cent of its equity in return for &pound;150,000. 
 The aim, says the blurb, is to develop other publishing and ancestor-tracing businesses. 
 The company's publishing director, Harold Brooks-Baker, was busy yesterday fielding inquiries about Marina Ogilvy, the pregnant daughter of Princess Alexandra. 
 However, he did disclose that the money will be used to finance biographies of royals and politicians like Prince Albert and Lloyd George. 
 He also hopes to exploit the Burke's name by reproducing it on the labels of clarets, burgundies and champagnes. 
 There are distant plans for a Burke's range of repro furniture and wallpaper. 
 The activities of its centuries-old rival Debrett's, which uses its once exclusive name to sell smoked salmon, begin to sound comparatively tasteful. 
 The Takeover Panel has carpeted one of its own. 
 Last Friday, Meat Trade Suppliers was taken to task for &bquo;seriously misleading&equo; shareholders over a hostile offer. 
 The Panel must be hoping that this will be an end to the matter. 
 Campbell Allan, a director and substantial shareholder of the sausage casings company, also sits on the Panel's appeals committee. 
 While on the subject of meat, we can tell you that the competition to find the best-made sausages in the UK gets under way this Sunday with the defending champion reported to be in sizzling form. 
 George McCartney, a butcher from Northern Ireland, has won the Meat Trades Journal Champion of Champions competition for the past two years. 
 The title is reckoned to be worth an extra 50,000lbs in sales, so competition will be hot. 
 Breakfast begins at 8.30am at Butchers' Hall in the City. 
 The latest edition of The Building Societies' Gazette contains some courageous predictions. 
 In particular the thoughts of Dick Howard, a bond market specialist with ANZ McCaughan, the stockbroker, are worthy of further examination. 
 &bquo;Base lending rates will fall to 12 per cent by the end of this year,&equo; he prophesies. 
 Agreed bid likely after James Neill suspended 
 By CLARE DOBIE, Deputy City Editor 
 SHARES in James Neill, the Sheffield engineer, were suspended yesterday at 202p, valuing the company at &pound;140.2m, prompting speculation that an agreed bid will be launched today. 
 The shares were suspended at the company's request after James Wilkes, the beer mat maker also based in Sheffield, sold its 9.6 per cent stake in Neill. 
 According to Stephen Hinchliffe, Wilkes' chairman, it sold the shares for &bquo;substantially more than 202p&equo;. 
 This suggests that any bid would be pitched well above the suspension price. 
 The stake was sold to a single buyer through Warburg Securities. 
 Neill declined to comment on the sale or the suspension. 
 The company, which owns Spear &amp; Jackson, the garden tools manufacturer, has been the subject of recurrent speculation for months, and it was fuelled last month when Neill announced a fall in pre-tax profits from &pound;2.71m to just &pound;28,000 in the first half. 
 Industry sources suggested that Williams Holdings, the conglomerate, or Triplex Lloyd, the foundries and building components company which owns 1.6 per cent of Neill, might be planning a bid. 
 Williams declined to comment but Triplex ruled itself out. 
 Jim Doel, the chief executive, said he had failed to find out what was going on. 
 &bquo;We don't understand why they are so bashful,&equo; he added. 
 There was also a suggestion that the bidder may be a financial buyer, looking at the company as an investment rather than an addition to existing operations. 
 James Neill has attracted the unwelcome attentions of several predators in the past, including Suter, the conglomerate run by David Abell, and BM Group, run by Roger Shute. 
 Suter's dealings in Neill and other companies are the subject of a Department of Trade and Industry inquiry. 
 The company recently valued its brand names, which as well as Spear &amp; Jackson include Eclipse hacksaws, in readiness for a hostile takeover. 
 It has not disclosed how much it thought these brands were worth. 
 Despite worse than expected profits reported last month, Neill's shares lost only 6p to 191p as bid speculation limited the fall. 
 Mr Hinchliffe promised that Wilkes would reveal today how large a profit it had made on its shareholding in Neill. 
 Reduced losses put spice in Mrs Fields 
 By JERRY CONNOLLY 
 SHARES in Mrs Fields, the troubled US bakery and cookie retailer, rose more than 20 per cent from their 12-month low of 19p to 23p yesterday after it announced much reduced trading losses. 
 The shares were helped by the prospect of a resumed dividend payments next year following a recovery in trading performance, the company said. 
 It last paid a dividend in 1987. 
 Losses before tax have been cut to &dollar;1.3m (&pound;800,000) for the six months to 30 June, compared with &dollar;15.1m in the same period last year, on sales up 14 per cent at &dollar;60.2m. 
 The company said: &bquo;The traditionally stronger second half has started well and it is anticipated cash flow for the full year will exceed capital requirements.&equo; 
 The improvement could allow some repayment of its long-term debt which has grown from &pound;12.7m in 1986 to almost &dollar;69m at the end of last year. 
 In that period, however, it slipped from a pre-tax profit of &dollar;17.14m to a loss of &dollar;18.5m. 
 Radical reshaping of the group's operations away from retail outlets and into bakery operations led to write-offs last year, but this time there were no below-the-line expenses for store closures. 
 &bquo;As an indication of continuing trading improvement, if current trends are maintained, it is the intention of the board to resume dividends with a payment next June,&equo; the company said. 
 Corporate overheads in the first half were cut from &dollar;8m to &dollar;7.7m, and total operating income rose from &dollar;13.3m to &pound;16.2m. 
 However, interest payments rose from &dollar;2.5m to &dollar;4.2m while plant losses also rose sharply, up from &dollar;349,000 to &dollar;1.13m. 
 The loss per share has fallen from 10 cents a share to 1 cent, but it was the renewed promise of a dividend that helped the shares beat the market trend yesterday. 
 Most of Mrs Fields' operations are in the United States. 
 It was launched in Britain on the USM in 1986 at 140p a share. 
 The price had soared to 250p before crashing last year. 
 Cluff interims increase ninefold 
 By MICHAEL PREST, Resources Correspondent 
 RISING gold production pushed Cluff Resources' pre-tax profits for the half year to 30 June up ninefold to &pound;790,000 and strengthened the possibility that the mining and oil group could pay a maiden dividend this year. 
 Emboldened by earnings per share jumping from 0.13p to 1.12p, Algy Cluff, the company's chairman said: &bquo;It's certainly our intention to pay a dividend&equo;. 
 The bulk of Cluff's turnover, which rose from &pound;1.88m to &pound;6.8m, was generated by gold mining in Zimbabwe. 
 The company produced 29,224 ounces of gold at an average grade of between 2.5 and 2.8 grammes per tonne, and says it is on course to mine 70,000 ounces during the whole of 1989. 
 Mr Cluff said that the Royal Family Mine at Filabusi had exceeded its planned production by 12.5 per cent. 
 Exploration is under way to determine whether the life of the mine can be extended beyond the spring of 1990. 
 The ore-treatment plant at the Freda/Rebecca mine is running ahead of design capacity, treating an average of 2,800 tonnes of ore a day in August. 
 Drilling will establish whether reserves of 1m ounces can be increased. 
 Cluff is also pushing ahead with its Fetish gold mine in Ghana, where borehole results, albeit tentative, indicated high grades. 
 The company should receive about 9,000 ounces of gold next year from its 50 per cent share of the Transaccion mine in Spain. 
 Mr Cluff said that the interest payments, which were &pound;605,000 in the first half, on the &pound;7.7m loan for developing the Zimbabwe properties, should diminish as cashflow from gold production reduces the principal. 
 Two added to Lowndes board 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 LOWNDES Queensway, the troubled furniture and carpets retailer which recently completed a &pound;18.5m refinancing, has appointed two heavyweight non-executive directors. 
 They are Norman Ireland, chairman of Bowater and former finance director of BTR, and Brian McGillivray, chairman of the photocopier distribution group Erskine House. 
 The appointments are the first non-executives taken on by Lowndes since its highly leveraged takeover of Harris Queensway last year. 
 The resignation of Bryan Portman, corporate finance director, earlier this year had slimmed the company's board down to three &mdash; James Gulliver, chairman, Eddie Dayan, managing director, and David Tibble, finance director. 
 Though both new directors are accountants with a wealth of experience, the appointments did not stop the shares falling 1&frac14;p to a new low of 16&frac12;p. 
 Lowndes is expected to show a &pound;17m pre-tax first half loss this week. 
 Acquisitions help TIP's 40% advance 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 The number of TIP's vehicles increased from 10,000 to 18,000. 
 Four acquisitions totalling &pound;50m, led by the &pound;29.5m purchase of Yorkshire-based CSL in January, accounted for a third of the growth in the fleet. 
 Strongest organic growth came on the Continent, where profits rose by 150 per cent in France and 70 per cent in West Germany. 
 Of 30 new branches opened, 16 were in mainland Europe. 
 Jim Cleary, chairman, said: &bquo;We prosper in uncertainty. 
 European harmonisation and the Channel tunnel make leasing trailers more attractive.&equo; 
 TIP has branched out into eight related areas ranging from tanker rental to truck leasing. 
 Following the purchase of a Finnish company, it has landed its first contract with the Soviet Union. 
 Earnings growth, diluted by the issue of shares for acquisitions, was just 2.9 per cent to 14.1p. 
 Stephen Clapham, an analyst at Hoare Govett, said: &bquo;It will take time to cut costs in the acquisitions, but they look sensible on an 18-month basis.&equo; 
 Borland sales buoyant 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 BORLAND International said yesterday it expected its second-quarter results to beat analysts' expectations after buoyant sales of Paradox, the US software company's database product. 
 Alan Henricks, chief financial officer of the USM-quoted Borland, said Paradox performed well against a weak product from its main rival. 
 Borland also announced it had won shareholder approval for its reincorporation in Delaware, a preliminary to the company seeking a US listing, probably on NASDAQ. 
 The reincorporation included a five-to-one share consolidation. 
 Leading Article: Massage is bad for the figures 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 THE longer one party stays in power, the greater the danger that it will find ways of falsifying its record. 
 In yesterday's Independent, growing concern was reported about the integrity of official statistics. 
 There have, for example, been 29 changes in the method of computing the unemployment figures since the present Government came to power, so that the total number of people out of work has fallen by a far greater amount in appearance than in reality. 
 Two disadvantages result. 
 The first is that insofar as people continue to believe the figures, the Government derives an unfair advantage. 
 The second is that official statistics become less and less use as a basis for rational debate, let alone for good decisions. 
 Argument may continue about the extent of poverty or the balance of payments, but the very facts to which each side appeals are in dispute. 
 The Government may object that the figures will never be perfect. 
 This is, however, no reason to avoid making them as reliable as possible. 
 The honorary secretary of the Royal Statistical Society denies in a letter published on this page today that there are plans to set up an independent council to monitor the Government's use of statistics, but such a development would be desirable. 
 Politicians of all parties resort to dubious statistical assertions. 
 At the Conservative Party Conference in 1986, Norman Fowler, then Secretary of State for Health, produced a computer printout of 380 new &bquo;large hospital schemes&equo;: the list was so long because he had counted every programme over &pound;1m, whereas schemes had previously had to cost over &pound;5m in order to qualify. 
 At present, a minister who abuses statistics in this way has only to fear the counter-assertions of the Opposition, no less self-interested. 
 One argument to which the Government has no right to resort is that statistics do not matter. 
 It is obvious that good economic indicators no more ensure good economic management than accurate instruments on the dashboard of a car ensure safe driving. 
 But since ministers, including the Prime Minister, are so fond of using statistics for the purposes of debate, they cannot be allowed to make the contradictory claim that these figures are irrelevant. 
 The Government is, moreover, committed to markets, which cannot work well without reliable information, and are severely damaged by misleading data. 
 Even without the distortions introduced by politicans, the standard of British economic statistics is lamentable. 
 In a White Paper of 1981, Sir Derek (now Lord) Rayner declared that the collection of official statistics should be cost-effective, and should meet the needs of central government, not the rest of the nation. 
 But here as elsewhere, though the emphasis on cost and utility was helpful in curbing bureaucratic empire-builders, it failed to provide a full definition of the public service which should be provided. 
 Advanced societies are distinguished from backward ones by, among many other features, the reliability of the information which can be obtained about them. 
 Some of that information has to be gathered by disinterested investigators, not by politicians or pressure groups intent on proving points. 
 After 10 years, this administration still fails to understand how government and markets complement each other. 
 Leading Article: Regulating the market in ivory 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 THREE months ago President Daniel arap Moi of Kenya took part in a media event staged in the Nairobi National Park to demonstrate his country's distaste for the ivory trade. 
 He doused with petrol and inflammable glue 12 tonnes of illegally poached elephant tusks, worth almost &pound;2m. 
 They were then ceremonially burned. 
 The gesture was a symbolic expression of the abhorrence felt by growing numbers of people at the threat to the future of the African elephant posed by a particularly bloody trade and will have gained widespread support. 
 But the destruction of the tusks from 1,800 slaughtered animals was, at a more mundane level, an example of gesture politics. 
 Had the government of Kenya sold the confiscated tusks on the open market, the money generated could have been used to encourage systematic conservation. 
 This week in Lausanne, at the conference of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species, Kenya, supported by the governments of Gambia, Somalia and Tanzania, is indulging in a similar exercise in political theatre. 
 These nations are demanding an end to all trade in ivory. 
 Opposition to any ban comes from South Africa, Zimbabwe and Botswana, which want the international regulatory agency to build on the present system of licensing and quotas. 
 The southern African states have the right of the argument for two reasons, both severely practical. 
 First, it would be as unrealistic to impose a world-wide ban on ivory as it would be to attempt to outlaw, say, tobacco or alcohol. 
 Demand would merely be driven underground, prices would rise and the potential profits available to criminal syndicates &mdash; and to corrupt politicians and government officials &mdash; would rise accordingly. 
 Second, criminalising the entire ivory trade would impose a financial penalty on those nations such as South Africa, Botswana and Zimbabwe which have developed relatively effective conservation policies. 
 These countries are able to practise open trading because their elephant herds are now big enough to demand regular culling. 
 Killing would continue even if an effective ban on ivory sales were to be introduced. 
 Part of the the profit from the present, legitimate sales of tusks is used to meet the costs of the conservation programmes. 
 Part is earmarked for transfer to the impoverished peasant farmers living in the areas concerned. 
 As a result, villagers in the three southern African states are coming to regard herds of elephants which will be legally culled as a source of legitimate profit. 
 They thus have a vested interest in their conservation. 
 In the past these same villagers were more inclined to slaughter elephants in the hope of criminal gain from unlicensed traders. 
 Kenya's new director of wildlife, Richard Leakey, was quoted recently as saying that government neglect had &bquo;permitted the poachers to have our parks to themselves as private hunting blocks with their vehicles, modern weapons and chain saws&equo;. 
 The objective of the Lausanne conference should be to encourage Kenya and its allies to emulate the conditions pertaining in the Kruger and Hwange national parks, where culling has become a necessity born out of successful conservation, rather than to encourage policies which could turn them into the run-down disaster zones Mr Leakey described. 
 A soothing seasonal checklist 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 I FIND a lot of anxiety among people about the dividing lines between the seasons of the year, or what the French call pre-Mistral tension. 
 When does summer end and autumn begin? 
 Was summer longer than usual this year to fit in six Test matches against the Australians? 
 Was autumn further delayed to allow six party conferences one after the other? 
 What part of the year are we in now, for heaven's sake? 
 Well, relax. 
 There is a totally painless way of establishing whether summer is really over, and that is to fill in the following checklist of autumnal signs as they occur. 
 When you've ticked every box, autumn is here. 
 OK? 
 Right, let's go. 
 It is a sign that autumn is approaching when&hellip; 
 You stop leaving doors open behind you as you come into the house. 
 - You start thinking about a coat. 
 - You think you're buying three pounds of onions in the shops, get home and find you're actually carrying a bag of the new season's hyacinth bulbs. 
 - Stationers start overflowing with 1990 calendars, bearing pictures of thatched kittens. - After yet another new TV series, you start regretting all the rude things you said about the summer repeats. 
 - You start getting this strange maternal urge to bring in everything from the garden overnight. 
 - You have a brilliant idea for a Christmas present for somebody. 
 - British Rail issue a new timetable and you have a nasty suspicion that they have juggled it around so that they have deleted a few trains and cut out that convenient late night one, and you look for your old timetable to check but it has gone with the wind. 
 - You start noticing your friends arguing about whether the clocks go backwards or forwards in October. 
 - You find postal charges mysteriously a penny higher than you thought they were, so you buy a sheet of 1p stamps to upgrade all the old ones you have left, and then you find you haven't got any old ones left, only this big sheet of 1p stamps. 
 - You notice teams of British Rail gardeners and foresters chopping, cutting and burning the vegetation growing alongside railway lines like East German border guards improving their arc of fire and wonder idly what they do the rest of the year. 
 - The only cricket stories in the newspapers are suddenly about winter tours of places you didn't even know played cricket. 
 - You start forgetting where you went on holiday this summer. 
 - The banks start promising to look after you much better than ever before, and to shower you with presents. 
 But they will only do this, it turns out, if you're 19 and just going to college. 
 - Buses in the morning and afternoon are suddenly full of children, traffic jams are caused by cars containing family groups and signs appear in tobacconists' shops: &bquo;Sorry, No More Than One Schoolchild In Here At A Time, Put Your Arms Up and Stand Against The Wall To Be Searched When Requested. 
 Thank You'-You are about to deflate the small plastic paddling pool in the garden in which no infant has paddled for a month until you realise that it is now full of strange vegetation and even stranger swimming insects and you decide to keep it as a nature reserve. 
 - You notice that the section of your local supermarket which has stocked picnic and barbecue material since the birth of time has suddenly disappeared and been replaced by a new section stocking wrapping paper, crackers and tinsel decorations. 
 - A letter appears in a national newspaper expressing disbelief that the writer has already spotted the first penny-for-the-guy collector/Christmas tree/artificial snow sprayed on shop window/Valentine cards on sale. 
 - People start using the curious phrase &bquo;Indian Summer&equo; if the sun stays out for more than 10 minutes at a time. 
 - Your summer clothes go into hibernation in cupboards, wardrobes, dry cleaners', cloakrooms, hat-stands, boots of cars, other people's houses, restaurant vestibules, backs of chairs in disused rooms and many other places from which they will eventually creep, crumpled and dishevelled, in six months' time. 
 - Somebody says: &bquo;Oh God, do we really have to spend Christmas day this year with&hellip;? '- 
 Letter: The vital question on higher education funding 
 From Professor MARTIN HARRIS 
 Sir: The ongoing debate about the suggestion by the Committee of Vice-Chancellors and Principals (CVCP) that universities must identify the full costs of their undergraduate programmes and should examine various ways in which these costs might be met seems to me to have largely missed the main point at issue. 
 Government, employers and educators alike are now convinced that higher education should be expanded radically during the next decade, to include perhaps twice as high a proportion of school leavers and others than has traditionally been the case in the UK. 
 The question is how this expansion can be paid for, given that the new Secretary of State has said quite candidly that his present view is that higher education cannot expect a higher share of public spending than it currently receives. 
 In this situation, universities have three choices. 
 One is to say that substantial expansion is simply not possible, given planned expenditure levels. 
 This would in many ways be the easiest option for us to follow &mdash; the status quo can always be defended but would clearly disappoint the legitimate aspirations of ever more young men and women to participate in higher education and, just as serious, fail to provide the educated and skilled workforce which the country so manifestly needs. 
 A second apparent option would be to take more students without additonal funding. 
 The result of this on any significant scale would inevitably be a decline in the quality of the education we provide, and consequently of the graduates we produce. 
 And the issue is not simply that of deteriorating staff-student ratios, which has attracted so much attention, but at least as much a question of capital investment. 
 In my own university, for instance, the number of first year students of biology that we have been able to accept this year has been entirely constrained not by the quality of our applicants but the physical size of our teaching laboratories. 
 Who will pay for their extension? 
 And, given the much valued British tradition of attending a university or polytechnic away from home, who will fund the additional sleeping accommodation for students, the absence of which has attracted so much adverse publicity this week? 
 Questions such as these have to be faced urgently if the university system is to expand as we all wish it to. 
 So, if turning away qualified candidates, on the one hand, and significant loss of quality, on the other hand, are to be avoided, that leaves only the third option, namely the funded expansion of our higher education provision. 
 What the vice-chancellors are asking, very simply, is where the necessary additional funds are to come from. 
 This is far too broad a question for us to seek to answer on our own, even if we wished to, affecting as it does everyone who hopes to enter higher education, their parents and their future employers; but it is imperative that the debate should be joined. 
 There are those who believe passionately that one only appreciates what one has paid for oneself, while there are others who believe, like your higher education correspondent Ngaio Crequer, that the public funding of higher education has served a whole generation well and should be allowed to continue to do so in future. 
 A key issue which must be addressed in this debate is not what most favours the sons and daughters of those families already committed to higher education, important though this is, but rather which funding system will most likely encourage first-generation entrants to higher education from social groups not hitherto persuaded to participate, because it is only from these groups that the necessary growth of an education and trained population can actually come. 
 This is the question which vice-chancellors have sought to raise &mdash; and this is the question to which society must, as a matter of urgency, respond. 
 Letter: Smart thinking on public transport 
 From Dr IAN BASNETT 
 Sir: I was interested to read Terence Bendixson's article (5 October) on directly charging for road use. 
 Putting to one side the other inequities associated with such a system should it be introduced, I hope due consideration would be given to the problems of the disabled. 
 Many disabled, (partly because of their disability and partly as a result of the inadequacy of public transport), are completely dependent on private or other vehicles to get out at all. 
 Unless those wholly or almost wholly unable to travel any distance without a vehicle (bearing in mind the current state of the pavements) were exempt from such a charge, it would amount to gross discrimination against an already disenfranchised group. 
 Letter: Smart thinking on public transport 
 From Mr CHRIS BUSHELL 
 Sir: For real dramatic effect, your article on road pricing by Terence Bendixson (Focus, 5 October) should have been published alongside that of John Lichfield reporting from Los Angeles the day before. 
 The experience of Los Angeles, which is the largest developed city in the world without any form of rail transport, should be a terrible warning to politicians who ignore or dismiss the crying need for improvements to our own public transport networks. 
 Here in London and the South-east, we already have metro and commuter railways which carry over 1,300 million passengers a year. 
 On London Transport alone, over 1,900 million annual journeys are made on buses and tubes. 
 Yet we suffer ever-growing road congestion, the amelioration of which most thinking people now agree cannot be achieved merely by building more roads. 
 Certainly we need road space for those who must drive, but there are many drivers who would willingly change (or revert) to public transport given some inducement &mdash; like services that are more frequent, more reliable and more widely available, or a further disincentive to the scandal of non-essential company cars that make commuting free of charge to their users. 
 We must make public transport once again the &bquo;smart&equo; way to travel. 
 To give Londoners the range and quality of rail services enjoyed by Parisians will cost a great deal of money, but this money will have to be spent if our public transport is not to slip once again on to the mad downhill spiral of reduced investment, reduced service, reduced passengers, reduced investment and so on. 
 This way only leads to the nightmare of Los Angeles. 
 Fortunately for us, and unlike Los Angeles, we already have the basis of a high-quality rail system &mdash; the huge network of lines laid down by our Victorian forefathers, many of which remain grossly under-utilised in a rapid transit context. 
 Coupled with desperately needed new construction, such as the cross-rail proposals, these existing routes could be made to really work for us at a fraction of the cost of new road-building, and with minimal land encroachment, pollution or disturbance to the environment. 
 Labour's &bquo;radical&equo; plans are to be welcomed for the vision they bring of the kind of urban public transport that is more or less taken for granted in western Europe. 
 In the race to present the &bquo;greenest&equo; image in advance of the next election, the present government may find it prudent to revise its view that Britain cannot afford such luxuries. 
 Letter: Official statistics 
 From Professor B. W. SILVERMAN 
 Sir: The Royal Statistical Society indeed has a keen interest in government statistics ('Moves to monitor use of statistics by Government', 9 October) and is planning an open discussion meeting in December, introduced by the head of the Government Statistical Service, on the topic of public confidence in official statistics. 
 However there are no plans at present to set up an independent council to monitor the Government's use of statistics. 
 Letter: Illogical verdict 
 From Dr BLAIR H. SMITH 
 Sir: I refer to the dropping of charges against the man accused of raping a mentally handicapped girl on the grounds she was not of fit mind to answer questions and give evidence (4 October). 
 As he was found guilty of having intercourse with a girl of under 16 years of age, logic surely draws the conclusion that if she is unable to testify in court, she is unable to give informed consent to sexual intercourse; in other words that the grounds on which the charge was dropped should have been the grounds on which rape was proven. 
 Letter: Arts leaflets 
 From Mr LUKE RITTNER 
 Sir: Your report (9 October) stated that the Arts Council had prepared two leaflets for separate distribution at the Conservative and Labour Party conferences. 
 This is not so. 
 In fact, we have published three leaflets, dealing respectively with the arts and the quality of life, the earnings of arts organisations and attendances at arts events. 
 All three were distributed throughout the Labour Party conference last week in Brighton and all three are available this week in Blackpool. 
 Letter: Good buildings but no good streets 
 From Mr ROGER JAMES 
 Sir: I agree with Jonathan Glancey when he says, in your welcome new Architecture page, that &bquo;the British public needs&hellip; to be shown what a city street such as Hammersmith Road could become if built by the best architects and developers&equo;. 
 But where is there such a street? 
 I remember as a young man walking up and down the main street of the 1951 South Bank Exhibition for the sheer pleasure of it, and thinking how marvellous it would be if every town could have a street like this. 
 But is was not to be. 
 There are good modern buildings but no good modern streets. 
 Letter: Psychological addiction to crack 
 From Mr J. D. ASHCROFT 
 Sir: Keith Botsford's column (7 October) highlights the need for clear information about and reporting of the approaching crack epidemic. 
 In the mid-1980s, I was addicted for nearly a year to &bquo;free-basing&equo; cocaine, which is no different in any way from what is now called crack. 
 It has been quite common in London for nearly 10 years. 
 &bquo;Free-basers&equo; make their own crack, rather than buying ready-washed &bquo;rocks&equo;. 
 Seizures of crack are quite irrelevant in gauging the growth of cocaine smoking (as opposed to &bquo;snorting&equo;), since a baser buys ordinary powder-form cocaine. 
 As I know from my own experience, crack, or free-base, is highly addictive, but in a psychological rather than a physical way. 
 Once the motivation to stop arises, it is not so difficult to kick the habit. 
 In other words, the habit is by no means incurable. 
 Further, crack is not &bquo;instantly&equo; addictive; it takes, usually, a few weeks of regular sessions to produce addictive tendencies. 
 The addiction is to the &bquo;rush&equo; &mdash; an experience of great pleasure which lasts a relatively short time. 
 In my own case, the motivation to stop free-basing followed the realisation that what crack promises in the rush is never delivered. 
 With increasing use, it leads to emotional instability and feelings of paranoia. 
 It is also a hideously expensive habit. 
 I would rarely spend less than &pound;200 a night, and often more. 
 As the pleasurable feelings which first fuelled my psychological addiction decreased and began to turn sour, it became easier to give up the habit, something which would not be possible with a physically addictive drug such as heroin. 
 If the craving returned, I could cope by contemplating it for an hour or two, until it went away. 
 Crack is a dangerous drug because it is initially very addictive and because of its enormous financial cost. 
 But it is probably relatively easy to give up compared to heroin. 
 In trying to educate people against using it, I would emphasise not its dangers but the fact that ultimately it is a complete waste of time and money. 
 Letter: Late-night news 
 From Mr TOBY ENGLISH 
 Sir: Your expansion is a terrible thing. 
 You should have been more kind to your loyal readers. 
 It is now 10.30pm and I have still not finished today's Independent. 
 What will happen when you publish on Sundays as well, I dread to think. 
 Letter: Adoptive parents 
 From Mr NICHOLAS BAKER, MP 
 Sir: In her article ('The child as a piece of disposable property', 2 October), Sue Wells argues for a change in adoption law so as to bring it nearer an open adoption system, whereby adopted children remain in contact with birth parents. 
 This argument, based apparently upon the particular circumstances of a young woman in New Zealand whose daughter was unfortunate enough to grow up in care, itself an unusual experience, is dangerous and partial stuff. 
 Adoption agencies in Britain take the greatest trouble to see that children are placed where they will enjoy a strong family background. 
 It is the security of that family background which is the basic need of any child. 
 In order to provide it, adoptive parents themselves need the security of knowing that they alone have the joy and responsibility of bringing up the child. 
 Constant tugs of war between birth and adoptive parents would destroy the stability of the most rational child, who is presently adequately protected by the right to see birth parents at the age of 18 when the necessary information is available. 
 The changes proposed by your correspondent, as well as by Polly Toynbee in her book Lost Children, could well add to the increasing number of children in our society who lack a strong family background provided by two married parents. 
 Letter: Uppark treasures 
 From Mr ROBIN MILLER 
 Sir: The extraordinary circumstances which led to Uppark being preserved, virtually unchanged, since the early nineteenth century are well known. 
 What seems to have been forgotten is the role played by my relation, Meg Meade-Fetherstonhaugh in bringing this Sleeping Beauty to life for our generation to enjoy until its tragic destruction. 
 When Meg arrived at Uppark as its first chatelaine in many a year she found all the original fabrics in place, but hanging, through neglect, &bquo;like grey seaweed&equo;. 
 She was advised to throw the whole lot away. 
 She refused. 
 She knew she had inherited something unique; she did not know how to save it; she found out; and she did it, down to the last chair cover. 
 I believe it was a woman from the Savonnerie company who taught Meg how to make the herbal soap which restored not only the colour of the fabrics but also their texture, how to stretch the fabrics on rollers of scrim, 30ft long, and how to repair the fabrics with 100 wax threads to the inch. 
 One can only imagine the time, the patience, the dedication, the sheer labour. 
 And when everything at Uppark was complete she continued to use her skills and the workforce she had trained to save other fabrics. 
 Other houses have treasures. 
 It was the &bquo;small&equo; things at Uppark that Meg saved and cherished that made it what it so uniquely was &mdash; the chair covers, the blankets Prinny pulled up to the portly royal chin, the original wallpapers in the attics where this quiet, remarkable woman worked to such effect. 
 Like the colour of the great shades in the saloon, they cannot be replaced or even exactly reproduced. 
 For that reason, I feel Meg would have opted for Anna Pavord's scheme. 
 The liberal Inquisition: Shabbir Akhtar says freedom of speech should not override society's other values 
 By SHABBIR AKHTAR 
 ONE might forgive John Torode ('Illiberal liberalism', 3 October) for thinking that the intolerance of liberals who make loud professions of tolerance is preferable to the intolerance of Muslims who do not. 
 But pardonable errors are errors nonetheless. 
 Meditating on the Anglo-Rushdie tragedy, he &bquo;long(s) for the protection of a written constitution like that of the US&hellip; which elevates freedom of expression above freedom to hide from intellectual challenge, or even vulgar verbal abuse.&equo; 
 He warns us against being seduced by &bquo;a new and&hellip; illiberal &bquo;liberal&equo; orthodoxy' designed to accommodate demands for a law protecting Islamic sensitivities. 
 In his defence of Rushdie's right to publish, Mr Torode argues we should be allowed to &bquo;shock and insult and to ridicule as a way of testing the faith of our forefathers&equo;. 
 We should not ban Voltaire's Candide, Tom Paine's Age of Reason, Bertrand Russell's Why I am not a Christian, Scorsese's The Last Temptation of Christ, or Monty Python's The Life of Brian. 
 But if we are to understand people's anxieties and hopes, we cannot ignore their sensitivities. 
 Even if a Rushdie-like attitudemay occasionally be necessary in the face of entrenched orthodoxy, iconoclasm need not lapse into abuse. 
 A scepticism reverent in tone may be revolutionary in content. 
 The works Mr Torode would refuse to censor differ in status. 
 Russell's critique of Christianity is not obscene. 
 Its tone is playful and frivolous but it makes some valid criticisms. 
 Paine's Age of Reason is iconoclastic but its central thesis is not reducible to a parody of the Christian faith. 
 A few of its witticisms are unnecessarily provocative and should be censored. 
 Voltaire's work is, arguably, offensive but one should err on the side of allowing it to be available. 
 The Last Temptation of Christ is disturbing but discerning. 
 It does not suggest that Christ was irredeemably wicked but merely that, in his humanity, he experienced temptation. 
 If the scenes of homosexuality were less explicit, there would be a powerful case for allowing its broadcast. 
 The Life of Brian, like Rushdie's The Satanic Verses, should be removed from public knowledge. 
 Neither teaches the ignorant nor disturbs the orthodox in the right way. 
 Both are parodies of seminal religious figures with vast and enduring ideological legacies. 
 Such works demean religious believers and hold up their convictions to contempt. 
 In a multicultural society, we must not allow our idolatry of art and literature to obscure issues of immense social and political significance. 
 Art should identify and condemn injustice and evil, but it can never properly be used to humiliate those, living or dead, who are among the best of our species. 
 Both Muslims and their liberal opponents should now shun the dramatic dogmaticism of former days and ask themselves: is freedom of speech a negotiable value? 
 Is it a contestable concept? 
 Does the secular clergy have the right to canonise freedom of speech as an absolute value overriding all others? 
 Does the Muslim minority here have the right to demand legislative changes to protect the dignity of its members? 
 Mr Torode is fanatical in his responses. 
 If he wants to &bquo;elevate freedom of expression above freedom to hide from intellectual challenge, or even vulgar verbal abuse&equo;, then why should Muslims not elevate the obligation to defend Muhammad's honour above the liberal desire to prostitute his reputation? 
 Is Mr Torode's liberalism any less an absolute ideological position than the Islamic fundamentalism of his opponents? 
 Such attitudes create a deadlock. 
 The opponents, then, regrettably, tend to move into the sphere of physical power. 
 Muslims soberly recognise that, in a world addicted to the logic of coercion, it is, sadly, sometimes necessary to be militant in the defence of one's persuasion. 
 In the end, John Torode's attitudes bring into question the very purpose of law. 
 Most liberals have thought that we, unfortunately, needed the firm yoke of the law to ensure that the interests of weaker individuals and groups were not substantially harmed by the irresponsible attitudes and actions of the more powerful. 
 If the new liberals have their way, the law cannot be credited even with such a modest achievement. 
 The final irony is that the kind of liberalism John Torode wants is itself illiberal. 
 There can be nothing but hubris in a position that substitutes one moral absolutism for another while pretending to offer humility. 
 The liberal Inquisition is no doubt set to continue. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Including it all in: &bquo;A Scott Berg&equo; &mdash; Sam Goldwin: Hamish Hamilton, 16.95 pounds 
 By ROBIN BUSS 
 IN AUGUST 1962, Sam Goldwyn packed the Beverly Hilton to celebrate his 80th birthday. 
 President Kennedy sent a telegram, Richard Nixon praised &bquo;one of those who began with nothing but his own ability, and achieved greatness on just that&equo;. 
 Jimmy Durante sang &bquo;Inka Dinka Doo&equo;. 
 The best estimates, in fact, put his age that August at a month or so past 83. 
 Goldwyn did not conceal his origins, but would sometimes embroider on them. 
 His East European Jewish background &mdash; he was born Schmuel Gelbfisz, in Warsaw &mdash; and the instinct that first led him into pictures, make him typical of the men who created Hollywood: Louis B Mayer, Adolph Zukor, Carl Laemmle, William Fox and the Warners. 
 But his path differed from theirs in one important respect. 
 In the early 1920s, when the industry was increasingly the preserve of the studios, Goldwyn found himself an outsider, an independent producer in competition with the majors. 
 This left him exposed but, at the same time, free from many of the studio constraints. 
 As a result, some aspects of Hollywood history are magnified in the ups and downs of his career. 
 The pursuit and creation of stars, for example, occupies a large part of the story that A Scott Berg has to tell: Goldwyn was constantly trying to sign up the human properties who would ensure the success of his pictures. 
 &bquo;Crude&equo; and &bquo;loud&equo;, according to Eugene Zukor (in an industry where these traits had to be marked to draw comment), he was in frequent conflict with his collaborators. 
 He made enemies and friends, gambled, pursued women, married, remarried, produced good films and bad, and survived to become an American legend. 
 It should be impossible to write a boring book about Goldwyn, but Berg comes close. 
 The twists and turns of Goldwyn's life can become tedious, since he was so often fighting the same battles; and the extent of his involvement in the industry means that Berg continually digresses to enlarge on some aspect of movie history, or introduces us to other personalities as they appear. 
 No one, in this cast of hundreds, has just a walk-on part: a role in just one Goldwyn film entitles us to the full biography of Frances Farmer, from winning a teenage essay competition to her eventual confinement in an asylum. 
 When Berg describes the Goldwyns moving house, moreover, to 1800 Camino Palmero or 1200 Laurel Lane, you could probably find your way round the properties blindfold on his description. 
 Yet from this trivial and exhaustive research, a portrait of Goldwyn does start to emerge &mdash; indulgent, yet credible and sometimes touching &mdash; until, at length, it triumphs over the irrelevant details, the plot summaries, and the occasional errors of fact. 
 It is the portrait of a brash, insensitive but privately vulnerable man, who suffered from being portrayed as the comic perpetrator of &bquo;Goldwynisms&equo;: &bquo;the public stayed away in droves&equo;, &bquo;include me out&equo;, and many more, many apocryphal. 
 He could be mean to those who worked for him and generous to those to whom he owed nothing. 
 A boon to Western Union, he conducted business by wire, in effusive capitals. 
 His second marriage, to Frances Howard, lasted nearly 50 years. 
 It seems to have been based on real understanding, but little real intimacy. 
 Goldwyn considered himself physically unappealing and Frances retained a lifelong devotion to George Cukor, who was homosexual. 
 Berg implies that they settled for a stable relationship, Frances acting the perfect Hollywood wife and ultimately finding consolation in religion, while Sam's unspent emotions were burned off in work. 
 During the night after The Best Years of Our Lives scooped the Oscars, she came downstairs to find him sitting alone, with an award in each hand, sobbing. 
 If this was the summit of his career, his finest moment was his maverick statement opposing the House Committee on Un-American Activities. 
 Otherwise, Goldwyn remained chiefly a facilitator and a financier, and Berg is unable to support any more substantial claim for him, or to resolve the ambiguities in the producer's role. 
 Goldwyn tried to stamp his own notions of quality and Americanism on his pictures, but he did so as a tycoon, in competition with writers, directors and stars. 
 A picture that is grim, not lurid 
 By PETER JENKINS 
 BLACKPOOL: A bit of a cheer went up when the news came through last week in Brighton of the Government's humiliation at the hands of the Bundesbank. 
 From the leadership, the word quickly went out: bad news is not good news, no triumphalism. 
 But Labour leaders were purring like pussies all the same; as they saw it, the 15 per cent lending rate made necessary by a &pound;20bn trade deficit virtually endorsed their analysis of Britain's economic weakness. 
 The razing of manufacture by a too-high exchange rate, the abdication of government from the promotion of industry, and the dissipation of the oil revenues on tax cuts was resulting in the nemesis of Thatcherism. 
 It is an appealing diagnosis for a party eager once more for power. 
 But is it true? 
 I write as a gloomy chronicler of Britain's relative economic decline struck by the inherent improbability of reversing a century's trend in a mere decade. 
 Today the word &bquo;decline&equo; is once more on senior ministerial lips and, from outside the Cabinet, Michael Heseltine draws new attention to the urgency of arresting it. 
 The deep-grained uncompetitiveness of the British economy, most notably its persistent failure to produce a sufficient supply of needed skills, has to be part of the explanation of such a trade imbalance. 
 The Government insists that the trade deficit is the result primarily of excess demand; it is man-made or &mdash; as Number 10 would put it &mdash; Lawson-made. 
 The charge is that he allowed domestic inflation to get out of control and messed around with the exchange rate when he should have been applying the monetarist remedy. 
 But if inflation could be brought quickly down again, the balance of payments would look after itself. 
 For, says Mr Lawson, a trade deficit is not in itself a problem if the world is happy to finance it. 
 Other trends in the economy, investment for example, are encouraging, and productivity has been rapid by British standards. 
 The cultural changes of the Thatcher years &mdash; supply-side improvements in management, shopfloor relations and the spirit of acquisitiveness &mdash; have resulted in a strong underlying improvement in Britain's economic performance, which the world recognises if the Labour Party does not. 
 I rehearse these arguments not in an attempt to settle them but for the purpose of casting doubt upon the thesis that the performance of the economy is at the crux of the Government's difficulties. 
 If Mr Lawson now drives the economy into deep recession or, alternatively, inflation is let rip, the Government would almost certainly perish at the polls. 
 But its predicament is not yet as lurid as that. 
 Even if things go fairly badly it is not certain that voters would turn to Labour as economic saviour. 
 Economic management has never been Labour's strong point. 
 The opinion polls continue to score the Conservatives well ahead on this count. 
 For the moment, high interest rates have eroded people's economic confidence in the future but the trends in savings and consumer spending scarcely suggest a lack of economic buoyancy after seven years of real income growth. 
 Even at this awkward moment, I doubt that the performance of the economy alone, or even chiefly, will lose the Conservatives the next election. 
 Preaching economic death and disaster may not be Labour's best tactic. 
 In a lecture he delivered on the fringe of last year's Conservative Party conference, Mr Lawson said: &bquo;While economic failure will most certainly drive a government out of office, economic success alone will not ensure that it retains office.&equo; 
 He must wish he had rather more economic success to report this year, but the thought remains valid. 
 If ministers spend this week in Blackpool trying to paint the Labour Party red again &mdash; as Kenneth Baker seems to intend &mdash; they will have missed the point and further demeaned themselves in the eyes of the public. 
 The Labour Party comes to the fore when the distribution of resources comes to the top of the agenda. 
 While people look to the Tories to make money, they look to Labour to spend it to more social purpose. 
 The indictment now levelled against the Government is that the years of Thatcherite prosperity have been matched by a deterioration in public services and the environment. 
 Mrs Thatcher's only answer, people have been encouraged to believe, is to privatise everything that moves. 
 This public backlash against the shoddy, callous and spivvy aspects of Mrs Thatcher's administration does not derive from the sense of chronic economic crisis which infected the politics of the 1970s but, rather, is born of prosperity. 
 Prolonged prosperity is as likely as prolonged adversity to engender the mood that it is time for a change. 
 Today people are wondering why a country which, according to Mr Lawson not long ago, was experiencing an &bquo;economic miracle&equo;, has been reduced to such public squalor &mdash; dirty, violent, congested and broken down, prone even to third-world disasters? 
 Economic difficulties are foreclosing on Mr Lawson at an awkward moment for the Government. 
 The rumours which upset markets yesterday of a renewed difference of opinion between the Downing Street neighbours appear this time to be without substance. 
 But exchange rate troubles draw attention to the unresolved argument between Mrs Thatcher and her Chancellor (backed by Sir Geoffrey Howe) about subjecting the pound to the formal discipline of the European Monetary System. 
 The Bundesbank has made mock of Mrs Thatcher's &bquo;when the time is right&equo; position. 
 This arcane dispute contributes to the electorally damaging impression that the Prime Minister is willing to hammer the country on the anvil of her dogmatism. 
 Meanwhile, declining confidence in the pound, and perhaps in the &bquo;Thatcher Revolution,&equo; is severely constraining ministers at a time when &mdash; as a formidable faction in the Cabinet has recognised &mdash; the Government needs to give a higher priority to the quality of life if it is not to be swept aside in the 1990s. 
 The enthusiast in the wings: Michael Heseltine tempered his Tory loyalty with some cautious ambition when he spoke to Anthony Bevins 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS 
 If Margaret Thatcher stands down before the next election, as most voters appear to believe she should, Michael Heseltine is the popular choice to succeed her as Conservative leader, according to the opinion polls. 
 But, following the Labour Party's transformation, he will be under pressure to explain how his beliefs differ from those of Neil Kinnock. 
 Faced with renewed attention from the Press and public, Mr Heseltine, although naturally shy, is soon overwhelmed by the instinct to advertise his political wares. 
 Referring to his decision to resign from the Cabinet over the Westland affair in January 1986, he says: &bquo;I made a statement that day making it clear that I was going to continue in active politics in any role the Conservative Party wanted. 
 &bquo;In a sense I'm a market-led politician. 
 It is a valuable thing to remember that you can never succeed in public life further than your friends will let you. 
 You've got no way to say, &bquo;I'm going to make a takeover bid,&equo; or &bquo;I'm going to appoint myself,&equo; or whatever.&equo; 
 At Brighton last week, Mr Kinnock spoke about the need for greater investment in education and training, research and development, science and transport, the need for a beefed-up Department of Trade and Industry. 
 On the face of it, a reflection of Mr Heseltine's own views. 
 He says of Mr Kinnock's call: &bquo;I think it is a huge tribute to those of us who have spoken for the Conservative Party on industrial matters, and have had some personal experience in creating a small business and building it up to some size. 
 It is a great tribute that the Labour Party, having done so much to destroy the climate in which industry is successful, is now having to listen to what we're saying. 
 &bquo;But it's not Kinnock; it's Mr Gorbachev; the world has come on to our ground and I find that a source of strength, because at least we know that we're talking about the capitalist system.&equo; 
 He then goes on to criticise Labour for suggesting that priority spending on education and training can help overcome the difficulties of the balance of payments deficit &mdash; because such investment programmes take generations to work through the system. 
 &bquo;So we're talking about the next century.&equo; 
 And what of this century, including, more pertinently, the last decade under Mrs Thatcher? 
 &bquo;I think this government&hellip; in terms of industrial support policies, has made gigantic strides. 
 Take education: it has made gigantic strides against bitter opposition to reform the system, to raise standards, to monitor the results and to draw industry closer to the academic and the educational world.&equo; 
 But when asked whether those strides had been adequate, Mr Heseltine says: &bquo;We have not set our sights on achieving the standards of the world's best. 
 We have to do it.&equo; 
 Thus, his view on the Government's education record is: good effort, but must do better. 
 The same applies to research and development and investment generally. 
 &bquo;The uncomfortable problem Britain faces is to recognise its capacity to consume and not to invest. 
 The public debate about political priorities focuses far too much on what we can do for today's consumption and far too little about what we invest in the future. 
 Research and development should be taking a bigger priority in our public expenditure and within the private sector than it is even now.&equo; 
 But there are other differences between the government frontbench and the man in the wings. 
 On poll tax, he says with due modesty: &bquo;There is nothing attractive in politics about the language of &bquo;I told you so.&equo; 
 ' He told the Conservative Party that it would be an unpopular tax when he first opposed the idea &mdash; successfully &mdash; as Secretary of State for the Environment in the early Eighties. 
 He then spoke out against the legislation, from the backbenches, when it was introduced in the Commons. 
 &bquo;I made one speech on the subject and I've not referred to it since, and there seems no purpose in doing so.&equo; 
 Why not? 
 &bquo;In the end, I'm a Conservative. 
 In the end, I don't believe the poll tax justifies a vote against this Government in a general election. 
 In the end, I want the Tories to win and I will do nothing to prejudice that position.&equo; 
 And what of that other political sore, the proposed health service changes? 
 &bquo;I go back to my opening view. 
 We are a high-consumption society and we have got to conserve the national resource and make sure that every part of it is effectively used. 
 And so if one of my colleagues sets out on a reform designed to get better value for money and a more effective health service, I'm going to support him. 
 I will support the legislation.&equo; 
 But he then adds: &bquo;I would say just this: that having got the legislation it would be wise to proceed by exemplar, by experiment, by demonstration of success rather than trying to do a root and branch revolutionary approach. 
 It is such a complicated thing to try and do, you do need the support of the medical profession and of the managers of the health service and of the public, and you'll get it more effectively if they can see by example what you're trying to do comprehensively.&equo; 
 At which point I asked Mr Heseltine what he was up to. 
 What was his game? 
 He supported the Government, he was loyal, but there too often appeared shades of difference which set him apart as a challenger. 
 He said that cabinets and parties were coalitions; groups of people with a common philosophy, providing &bquo;a starting point in most discussions which enables them to work their way by dialogue through to agreement&equo;. 
 Inside Cabinet, he had played that role, with the required public discretion, to argue the case for council house sales, industrial competition, and the inner cities policy. 
 Now, an outsider, he was arguing his own beliefs, within the Conservative framework, from the public platforms of Westminster and beyond. 
 That was all very well, but agreement by dialogue did not match the public perception of Mrs Thatcher's Government. 
 Mr Heseltine says: &bquo;The media are very good at sensing a mood and then exaggerating it. 
 I think that basically the 1980s were very rough and there were some very difficult times and in order to persuade the country to change, and impose change where it was resisted, and to carry it through, required both will and language characteristic of that challenge and Mrs Thatcher has been associated with that.&equo; 
 He goes on to argue that the reality is different from the rhetoric. 
 As an example he cites Europe; his political passion &mdash; just as it would appear to be Mrs Thatcher's bete noir. 
 &bquo;This government has taken Britain into Europe further and more irrevocably than any previous government. 
 The Macmillan government applied to join, the Heath government signed the treaty as it was, but at that stage basically the nation states retained the veto process which had been injected by de Gaulle into the original treaty. 
 &bquo;It was Mrs Thatcher who signed the Single European Act, which is the biggest transfer of sovereignty undertaken in any period of our history. 
 From that moment on, we were committed to a process that required majority voting, to which we were subject. 
 The conclusions from that are of profound consequence. 
 &bquo;The precise scale you can't quantify, but I can give you the parameters. 
 When Jacques Delors said that within 10 years, 80 per cent of the decisions affecting the industrial economic and commercial matters would be taken in Brussels, Lord Young argued with him and said it would be 50 per cent. 
 I am not in the business of arguing with either. 
 50 per cent taken by Brussels? 
 That's not to me consistent with a view that we have remained detached and apart and able to take whatever decisions we like regardless of our partners.&equo; 
 Then right at the end of the interview, he comes back to the fundamental question about himself &mdash; what is on offer. 
 He says: &bquo;There are great forces at work, and they've already embraced us in a world market, they're sweeping us towards a European destiny. 
 They are forces which are spreading wealth faster than at any time in human history and in one's political approach I think you either are an enthusiast anxious to embrace the forces that are at work or you are a sceptic, perhaps inclined to resist them, hoping that you can frustrate them. 
 &bquo;Now I am by nature an enthusiast. 
 I've no idea whether Europe is going to work, no one has, and I can think of huge historical reasons why it won't. 
 But I know this; if it is going to work, there is no argument that denies Britain a place at the leading edge of what is happening. 
 &bquo;Obviously, by background and experience I'm wholly committed to the benefits of the capitalist system. 
 But I'm a Tory. 
 And I believe that with the privileges that come to those who benefit most from the capitalist system there are obligations, and so the combination of that latter thought makes me want to do something about the inner cities, plus a revulsion at waste and hopelessness and dereliction and concern which is self-evident in some of these older towns and cities. 
 &bquo;So, given that I have a political opportunity, I tend to become an enthusiast harnessing the forces that are at work, trying to get the best out of them, trying to use them for the political purposes that I believe in. 
 There's a role for people like that. 
 But in a political party, there's a role for the sceptic. 
 Because the enthusiast must be constrained, the sceptic must be led. 
 And the excitement of democracy, of being a member of a cabinet or whatever, is to see how these forces inter-relate.&equo; 
 Khmer Rouge: Hidden strengths and forced marches 
 By TERRY MCCARTHY 
 THE STRENGTH of the Khmer Rouge guerrilla army is, according to its commander-in-chief, Son Sen, &bquo;a military secret&equo;. 
 Western intelligence estimates range between 20,000 and 35,000 armed men. 
 The Vietnamese say 17,000. 
 There are 68,000 refugees in Khmer Rouge-controlled camps inside Thailand, according to the United Nations border relief operation. 
 But aid officials estimate that there are between 50,000 and 100,000 refugees living in military camps hidden along the border and to which international organisations have no access. 
 Many of these refugees are used as porters to bring supplies into Cambodia for the Khmer Rouge troops. 
 The military command structure of the Khmer Rouge is tight at the top and loose at the bottom. 
 Besides Son Sen, the two most senior commanders are Pol Pot and Ta Mok. 
 Under them are battlefield commanders, most of whom operate under code names such as Korn, Siab, Chan, Sok. 
 Khmer Rouge divisions and regiments have no set size, and their strength depends largely on the proficiency of the commander. 
 Each commander has general orders, but is allowed considerable independence in day-to-day decisions. 
 Their operations are monitored by three small mobile commands which move around inside Cambodia, keeping radio contact with each other and with the base camps along the Thai border. 
 In the field, the guerrillas rely mainly on AK47 automatic rifles, B40 and B41 rocket-propelled grenade launchers, hand grenades and 82mm mortars, which can all be carried easily by men moving on foot through the jungle. 
 In the military camps along the Thai border, the Khmer Rouge also has some heavy artillery, including 130mm guns which have a range of up to 15 miles and some armoured vehicles, rumoured to include a number of tanks. 
 Most recently, it has acquired HN-5A infra-red guided anti-aircraft missiles, which are Chinese copies of the Soviet SAM 7 missiles and described by one military analyst as a cheap version of the Stingers used by the resistance in Afghanistan. 
 These missiles have so far not been used because the Phnom Penh airforce has not yet deployed its Soviet helicopters and recently acquired MIG 21 jets in combat. 
 Inside Cambodia, the Khmer Rouge strongholds are mostly in the western and southern provinces, and to a lesser extent, in the north. 
 The guerrillas operate from the Phnom Malai mountains in Battambang, the Cardamom mountain chain that runs through Pursat, Kompong Speu and Koh Kong, and the Elephant mountains in Kampot. 
 Recently there have been reports of a concentration of Khmer Rouge forces in Kompong Speu, where the mountains come within 30 miles of Phnom Penh. 
 The Khmer Rouge also comes down from the north through Preah Vihear to Kompong Thom, Kratie and Kompong Cham. 
 Pol Pot's shadowy cabinet 
 By TERRY MCCARTHY 
 ONE OF the key strengths of the Khmer Rouge is the continuity of leadership. 
 Today, it is fighting the same war, with the same leaders, as 20 years ago. 
 When Hun Sen, himself a former Khmer Rouge commander who fled to Vietnam, gives his list of eight Khmer Rouge leaders whom he absolutely refuses to include in any political deal, it is the same people who studied together in Paris in the 1950s, fought in the jungles from 1967, captured Phnom Penh in 1975, led the government of Democratic Kampuchea from 1975, and fled to Thailand in 1979 after the Vietnamese invasion. 
 Pol Pot was born in 1928 and educated in Phnom Penh before going to Paris to study electronics. 
 He returned to Cambodia in 1953, joined the Kampuchean Communist Party, and quickly worked his way to the top. 
 When Phnom Penh fell to the Khmer Rouge in 1975 he was head of the party, and known as &bquo;Brother Number One&equo;. 
 He was ultimately responsible for the emptying of the city, the forced labour in the countryside, the persecution of anyone judged to have been tainted by foreign influences, and the bloody purges of Khmer Rouge cadres suspected of being &bquo;Vietnamese traitors&equo;. 
 Today he lives in the Eastern Thai town of Trat and, although officially retired, is still regarded as the overall leader of the Khmer Rouge. 
 All major decisions, either on the international diplomatic front or on military strategy inside Cambodia, are referred to him. 
 Ieng Sary, 59, studied with Pol Pot in Paris, and returned to Cambodia in 1957. 
 He became deputy prime minister and minister for foreign affairs after 1975, and was known as &bquo;Brother Number Two&equo;. 
 He is thought to be Pol Pot's effective deputy. 
 Son Sen, 59, has a degree in philosophy from the Sorbonne. 
 In the fight for Phnom Penh, he was chief of staff of the Khmer Rouge forces, and was made defence minister in the 1975 government. 
 Today he is commander in chief of the Khmer Rouge guerrilla army. 
 Khieu Samphan, 58, has a doctorate in economics from the University of Paris, and after returning to Cambodia set up a left-wing newspaper and served in Sihanouk's parliament before fleeing to join the Khmer Rouge in the bush in 1967. 
 He was head of the state presidium under Pol Pot, and after the Vietnamese invasion became the official head of the Khmer Rouge. 
 He leads Khmer Rouge delegations at international conferences, and has been promoted as the moderate face of the Khmer Rouge. 
 Ieng Thairith is married to Ieng Sary, and has a degree in English Literature. 
 She was minister for social action in the Pol Pot era and is regarded as one of the main theoreticians of the party. 
 Her sister, Khieu Ponnary, is married to Pol Pot, and was influential in the 1975 government, but is now understood to be confined to hospital because of mental illness. 
 Ta Mok, 62, does not belong to the Paris-educated clique. 
 One of the most brutal of the Khmer Rouge commanders, he is known as the &bquo;Butcher of Kampuchea&equo; for the killings he ordered in the south-west from 1975 to 1978. 
 He is now one of the most senior battlefield commanders. 
 Nuon Chia was educated in Thailand, and is regarded as the main ideologue of the Khmer Rouge. 
 In 1960 he was more senior in the Communist Party than Pol Pot, and in 1976 briefly replaced him as prime minister. 
 Ke Pauk was in charge of the central zone of Cambodia under Pol Pot, and carried out the purges of Khmer Rouge cadres in the Eastern zone in 1977 and 1978 which forced many to flee to Vietnam, including Hun Sen and Heng Samrin, currently Prime Minister and President of the Phnom Penh government. 
 He is still in charge of military operations in the same zone, centred on Kompong Thom province. 
 Thiounn Prasith, not on Hun Sen's list, is the Khmer Rouge's top diplomat. 
 Grandson of a former palace minister in Cambodia under the French, Thiounn Prasith studied with Ieng Sary in Paris and was adviser on foreign policy from 1975-78. 
 He is now ambassador to the United Nations in New York for the Coalition Government of Democratic Kampuchea. 
 Khmer Rouge: A feared and secret army of &bquo;patriots&equo; 
 By BY TERRY McCARTHY 
 THE Khmer Rouge values secrecy. 
 On the international front, its diplomats are tight-lipped and difficult to approach. 
 Its military camps along the Thai border are closed to aid organisations and journalists. 
 Inside Cambodia, the Khmer Rouge usually appears at night, without warning. 
 Khmer Rouge guerrillas move around the countryside in small groups of five to 10. 
 Their black pyjama uniform of the Seventies has been exchanged for grey-green jackets and trousers, but they still wear the krama, the chequered cotton scarves common to all Cambodian peasants. 
 They enter villages, round everyone up, and criticise those who support the Phomn Penh government for being &bquo;lackies&equo; of the Vietnamese. 
 The Khmer Rouge propaganda also highlights the growing corruption among official party leaders and businessmen in the towns, the lack of economic improvement in the villages. 
 In the western provinces they have been distributing leaflets, many carrying the warning: Pros tvoeu chi, neari tvoeu pouch &mdash; &bquo;We will make the men into fertiliser, and keep the women for reproduction&equo; &mdash; to deter collaboration with the government. 
 Sometimes they take people away from the village for re-education, or for recruitment into their army. 
 They rarely meet opposition from the village militia, who have no training and not enough ammunition to put up a fight even if they wanted to. 
 In many villages, Khmer Rouge informers warn them if government troops are in the area. 
 The guerrillas are well disciplined, and intent on winning villagers over to their cause. 
 Despite their spartan, isolated lifestyle, there are no stories of women being raped or wanton violence against civilians. 
 When they need food, they will often pay for it in gold or hard currency, although villagers rarely admit this to the local authorities, preferring to say that their rice was stolen. 
 In rural areas, the Khmer Rouge is not universally despised, as the government in Phnom Penh maintains. 
 Unlike townspeople and those &bquo;polluted&equo; by foreign influences, the peasants were not targeted for persecution under the Pol Pot regime. 
 For many, the worst memories of that era are of food shortages because of the disruption to the agricultural system. 
 It is among the merchants and civil servants that fear of the Khmer Rouge is highest. 
 One night in July, a large number of Khmer Rouge entered the town of Muong, on Route 5 between Pursat and Battambang. 
 According to a shopkeeper, they went through the market forcing merchants at gunpoint to hand over money and gold. 
 &bquo;As patriots, we think we have some Cambodians to support us,&equo; said Khmer Rouge leader Khieu Samphan in an interview in Paris in August. 
 The extent of active support for the Khmer Rouge in the countryside is impossible to judge, but interviews with peasants in the provinces of Battambang, Pursat, Takeo and Kampot, in the west and south of Cambodia, indicate widespread passive support allowing the guerrillas to move around and gather food. 
 A district army commander in a small outpost 10 miles west of Kampot town admitted last month that the mines his troops had planted at the foot of the mountains were designed only partly to defend their position. 
 &bquo;They are also to stop the people having relations with the Khmer Rouge in the mountains,&equo; he said. 
 When they fight, the Khmer Rouge show their real mettle. 
 the Vietnamese soldiers were terrified of them. 
 The Khmer Rouge had no mercy for any Vietnamese they took prisoner, and many Vietnamese soldiers preferred to kill themselves rather than be captured. 
 &bquo;I thought I would use a grenade&equo;, said Vu Van Hau, a 22-year-old Vietnamese soldier who served for three years in Kompong Cham and Kompong Thom provinces, before returning to his native Ho Chi Minh City as part of the September withdrawal. 
 Hau knew what the Khmer Rouge could do. 
 In July he was one of 80 troops attacked by about 400 Khmer Rouge in Kompong Thom. 
 The Vietnamese withdrew, but not before Hau saw two of his friends shot. 
 &bquo;In the afternoon we returned to collect the bodies. 
 Two had their limbs cut off, including one of my friends. 
 The Khmer Rouge had used hammers to smash their skulls.&equo; 
 It is not just their passionate hatred of the Vietnamese that has kept the Khmer Rouge together in the malarial jungles for 10 years. 
 Many of the soldiers have families held hostage in the refugee camps along the Thai border, but so do the two other, much less effective, resistance factions. 
 The loyalty and discipline of the Khmer Rouge troops springs from something much deeper &mdash; the pride of the warrior in being able to survive in the forest, fighting against foreign enemies. 
 The harsh discipline imposed on them enhances their morale. 
 &bquo;I was proud of myself as a soldier,&equo; said Loy Im, a 32-year-old former Khmer Rouge commander who had deserted to rejoin his family after 17 years in the jungle. 
 He commanded 90 men from a jungle camp close to Route 10, from Battambang to Pailin. 
 &bquo;We slept in hammocks attached to trees, but there were not enough mosquito nets to go round. 
 We also had anti-malaria pills, but not enough. 
 If people got seriously ill, we had to carry them back (to Thai border camps) in hammocks.&equo; 
 The Khmer Rouge paid him no wages, but sometimes the porters carrying rice and ammunition supplies from the Thai border would also bring cigarettes and rice wine. 
 Food was always short, and they were forced to eat roots and fruits from the forest, and kill deer and birds. 
 Once a month his commander, Nam, would visit and update his orders. 
 Otherwise, he was totally responsible for his men, and for planning ambushes on Vietnamese or Phnom Penh forces along the road. 
 Although a deserter, his estimation of the Khmer Rouge was still high: &bquo;The Khmer Rouge can survive in the jungle for ever&equo;. 
 Preparing to return to power: The Khmer Rouge, whose atrocities of the mid-Seventies have become notorious, is increasingly likely to form part of any new government in Cambodia. 
 On this page Terry McCarthy looks at the organisation's roots, aims, strength, support and supposedly revised methods 
 By TERRY MCCARTHY 
 THE Khmer Rouge. 
 Visions of skulls in the rice fields of Cambodia, torture, starvation, death. 
 The Western view of the Khmer Rouge has been encapsulated in the title of David Puttnam's film The Killing Fields. 
 Few would argue with the proposition that it should never be allowed to return to power. 
 But the blank horror over Khmer Rouge atrocities between 1975 and 1978 has created a blind spot about its strength in Cambodia, and the growing likelihood that it will return to power, either on its own or with the other Cambodian opposition factions. 
 The Kampuchean Communist Party, first called the Khmer Rouge by Prince Sihanouk, has existed under the same leadership since the 1950s, has deep roots in Cambodia, and is not about to disappear. 
 It is &bquo;a sociological phenomenon of Cambodia&equo; says Vandy Kaon, a dissident intellectual in Phnom Penh. 
 It is a product of a dark, brutal side of Cambodian society that lives in fear of racial extinction at the hands of the neighbouring Vietnamese and Thais. 
 Its dream of recreating the glories of the Khmer empire that 1,000 years ago stretched from northern Malaysia to southern Vietnam may be an illusion. 
 But it is a powerful illusion, and attracts support from some of the best brains Cambodia has produced. 
 In public, the Khmer Rouge leaders have a quiet dignity. 
 But it is the dignity of the funeral parlour, tempered by the knowledge that they have killed many people for their dream. 
 They have pursued this dream so fiercely that they cannot afford to admit any self-doubt. 
 &bquo;The Khmer Rouge wants to protect Cambodia, but no one has harmed Cambodia as it has done,&equo; says an aid worker. 
 What makes the Khmer Rouge so strong is its vision for Cambodia, which is pure, radically nationalistic and free of the corruption, petty power struggles and personal jealousies that bedevil the other two resistance factions and the Hun Sen government in Phnom Penh. 
 Lon Nol, the country's leader in the early Seventies, sold out to the Americans, said the Khmer Rouge. 
 Hun Sen sold out to the Vietnamese, and is now selling out to Thai businessmen as well, it says. 
 Only the Khmer Rouge will fight to preserve Cambodia for Cambodians. 
 It is actively supported by a small part of the population, and tacitly tolerated by many more, out of either fear or a simple desire not to be involved in a political battle. 
 The Khmer Rouge has infiltrated the towns, and is said to have secret sympathisers at very high levels in the Phnom Penh government. 
 Time is on its side. 
 It no longer has the Vietnamese army to worry about, and can now operate in large parts of the countryside with little interference from Phnom Penh government troops. 
 Since the Vietnamese withdrawal, the two non-communist resistance factions - the Khmer Peoples National Liberation Front (KPNLF) and the Sihanoukists - have mounted a big offensive with an even bigger publicity campaign to boost their credibility. 
 The Khmer Rouge has done nothing, because it has no need to prove anything. 
 Its arms supplies from China are assured. 
 Speculation that its soldiers would attack the town of Pailin on the Thai border has died down, as it became clear that to hold Pailin would be more of a liability than an asset. 
 It would tie down a lot of troops and would also give Phnom Penh the opportunity to raise international alarm at the spectre of the return of the Khmer Rouge. 
 Vietnam has not ruled out the possibility of its army returning to Cambodia if requested by Phnom Penh. 
 The Khmer Rouge does not want to rock the boat, having waited patiently for more than a decade for the Vietnamese to leave. 
 The Paris conference was a success for the Khmer Rouge. 
 There was no international recognition of the Hun Sen government, no agreement on the cessation of foreign military aid, and Prince Sihanouk did not do a deal with Hun Sen cutting out the Khmer Rouge. 
 &bquo;Prince Sihanouk knows well that the problem is not the Hun Sen government, but the Khmer Rouge. 
 This is why he does not cut them off,&equo; said an aide to the Prince in Bangkok last week. 
 Of the three Cambodian resistance factions, the Khmer Rouge is by far the best organised. 
 In Paris, its diplomats proved to be the most methodical, hardest working and best co-ordinated of all the Cambodians. 
 The Coalition Government of Democratic Kampuchea (CGDK), made up of the Khmer Rouge, the Sihanoukists and the KPNLF, is recognised by the United Nations. 
 It has nine permanent diplomatic missions abroad. 
 Eight of the missions have Khmer Rouge ambassadors, effectively giving the Khmer Rouge its own foreign ministry. 
 All the CGDK declarations, including Prince Sihanouk's recent five-point peace plan, are written by the Khmer Rouge, and simply presented to Sihanouk and the KPNLF leader, Son Sann, to sign. 
 Along the Thai border, the Khmer Rouge leaders can function with impunity, courtesy of the Thai Army which has supported them as its most effective weapon against Vietnam, Thailand's largest security concern. 
 Inside Cambodia, Khmer Rouge guerrillas do not appear to be planning any big offensives against the towns. 
 Their strategy seems to be widespread but low- level guerrilla warfare to discredit and destabilise the Phnom Penh government. 
 At the same same they are using propaganda and terror to boost their position in the countryside. 
 The calculation is that increased pressure on Hun Sen will force him back to the negotiating table, ready to make the dreaded concession: the inclusion of the Khmer Rouge in a political settlement. 
 The main supporters of the Khmer Rouge are the Chinese, who kept advisers in Phnom Penh throughout the Pol Pot era, and now supply the guerrillas with arms and money. 
 The Chinese want to put pressure on Vietnam, and Peking has made clear that it will continue sending arms until the Vietnamese-installed government of Hun Sen agrees to some form of power-sharing that includes the Khmer Rouge. 
 The Khmer Rouge says it has changed, and now supports a free market economy and a multi-party system. 
 Given the conviction of Khmer Rouge members that they are the only people who can save Cambodia, few observers believe their commitment to multi-partyism would last for long. 
 But if they return as part of negotiated settlement, they will at least be constrained by a large international presence of peace-keepers and aid organisations, which was not the case in 1975. 
 The Khmer Rouge is aware of the tightrope it has to tread, both with the West and with Vietnam. 
 Its goals are long-term. 
 &bquo;We need international support, particularly from Western countries. 
 Therefore we cannot return to the politics of 1975 to 1978,&equo; said the Khmer Rouge leader Khieu Samphan, in Paris. 
 &bquo;We need a liberal economy and a liberal democracy. 
 This is the basis for national unity. 
 Why is this indispensable? 
 Because Vietnam is still there at our door, ready to return at any occasion.&equo; 
 Treaty ban will not stop America from making nerve gas 
 From PETER PRINGLE in Washington 
 THE United States will continue to make new nerve gas weapons after the conclusion of a global treaty banning them takes effect, according to a hitherto secret administration policy review. 
 The move takes the glitter off President Bush's call at the United Nation's last month for immediate steps to &bquo;halt and reverse&equo; the worldwide threat of chemical weapons, and indicates that Mr Bush's commitment to a poison gas ban is not so &bquo;extraordinarily strong&equo; as he and his advisors have declared. 
 The secret decision to continue producing the new generation of so-called &bquo;binary&equo; nerve gas weapons would also seem to preclude a Bush-inspired bilateral agreement between the United States and the Soviet Union to start reducing their arsenals of chemical weapons before the new global treaty is concluded. 
 After the President's UN speech on 25 September, the chief Soviet arms control adviser, Viktor Karpov, made it clear that Moscow would not join in making such reductions unless the US first ended its production of the new &bquo;binary&equo; weapons. 
 The new US position would also require redrafting the new global treaty banning production and stockpiling of chemical weapons being negotiated by 40 nations in Geneva. 
 At present, the treaty would require that production acitivities be halted immediately and the chemical plants rendered &bquo;inoperable&equo; within three months. 
 The United States is about to seek changes to allow continued production, according to officials quoted in the Washington Post. 
 Critics of the decision by the Bush administration said yesterday that continuing US production was destabilising because it encouraged countries capable of producing chemical weapons to begin developing new production lines immediately. 
 This would put them among the countries allowed to continue production after the new treaty comes into force. 
 &bquo;Once these countries have actually made substantial investments in a chemical arsenal, what guarantees do we have that they will eventually be willing to throw it away?&equo; asked Elisa Harris, a chemical weapons at the Brookings Institution. 
 The secret decision to continue production was teken by the President after several options had been presented to him by the Pentagon and the State Department. 
 Pentagon hardliners, who have opposed a chemical weapons ban on the grounds that it could not be verified adequately, suggested the idea of seeking continued production of the new &bquo;binary&equo; weapons during the 10 years it would take to eliminate all arsenals. 
 The new binaries are claimed by their advocates to be safer than the older &bquo;unitary&equo; weapons because they use two chemical components that only become lethal when combined during the firing of the weapon. 
 The French have also favoured a continued production clause so that they would be able to develop new binaries during the 10-year period. 
 Mr Bush accepted the Pentagon proposal even though he told the United Nations that he believed &bquo;we can achieve the level of verification that gives us confidence to go forward with this ban&equo;. 
 Also at the United Nations, the President called on the Soviet Union to reduce its stocks immediately to 20 per cent of the current US arsenal, which is unofficial estimated to be 30,000 tons. 
 The Russians have said they have 50,000 tons. 
 But such a bilateral arrangement is now in jeopardy. 
 because of the Soviet condition that the US cease production of its binary weapons. 
 Administration officials argue that Mr Bush's speech at the United Nations was in fact a turning point in the US efforts to ban the prodictoion of chemical weapons because it created an atmosphere in which the Geneva negotiations are likley to be accelerated. 
 Other countries were looking to the United States to take a firm leadership role, said one official. 
 Professor Matthew Meselson, a chemical weapons expert at Harvard, said the administration &bquo;wants to have its cake and eat it, too. 
 It's backward thinking to put the global ban at risk&hellip; simply to save a rather controversial binary programme&equo;. 
 Bus bomb kills seven in Colombia 
 From PETER PRINGLE in Washington 
 A policeman in Bogota surveys the body bags of some of the seven people who died when an explosion destroyed a bus. 
 Police do not believe it was the work of Colombian drug lords Photograph (omitted): 
 Street life kills Brazil's children: Richard House in Sao Paulo finds runaways suffering brutality at the hands of criminals, death squads and the police 
 From RICHARD HOUSE 
 FOURTEEN-year-old Manoel Jorge Santos had no idea of the perils awaiting him in Sao Paulo when he fled from a broken home and brawling stepfather, trudging 50 miles to the city's cathedral square in search of a new life. 
 &bquo;You've got to be careful: they cause lots of trouble,&equo; said Manoel, glancing nervously at the groups of patrolling military police and the slate-grey truck used to cart away vagrant minors who spend their days here sniffing glue, bathing in fountains, picking pockets and sleeping rough. 
 Street children like Manoel now fear more than temporary incarceration at Febem, the Dickensian state orphanage that has long been a synonym for alienation and violence. 
 They fear torture, sexual brutality and death at the hands of organised death squads allegedly paid by tradesmen to &bquo;clean up&equo; the streets. 
 In Rio de Janeiro, dead street children have been found trussed in barbed wire, with their eyes gouged out, and even decapitated with a chainsaw. 
 One small corpse found recently in a fashionable district bore the warning: &bquo;I kill all those who don't go to school.&equo; 
 Three years ago a Sao Paulo solicitor was applauded as he kicked a young would-be pickpocket to death. 
 He was never charged. 
 &bquo;The violence against street children is now far more barbarous than anything inflicted on political prisoners during the worst phase of the military dictatorship,&equo; said Benedicto Rodrigues dos Santos, of the National Street Children's Movement, a welfare organisation that has documented the violent deaths of 1,397 street children since 1984. 
 &bquo;The children are caught by police, imprisoned with common criminals, tortured and made to sign confessions. 
 The girls also suffer sexual exploitation by police. 
 Often they're made to pay for their release and so must steal to get this money,&equo; said Mr Santos. 
 The data compiled by the Childrens' Movement and IBASE, an independent institute, show a street child dies from stabbing, strangulation, beating or gunshots every two days in Brazil and claims that 82 children have been murdered by death squads this year. 
 Mr Santos blames &bquo;paramilitary groups and violent military policemen working for sectors of the business community interested in increasing profits by cleaning up the streets.&equo; 
 But he admits it is almost impossible to prove their involvement. 
 He says evidence is systematically suppressed by the authorities. 
 Offending policemen frequently receive no more than a dishonourable discharge, and may resume killing in plain clothes, Mr Santos said, while some adolescents &mdash; who under Brazilian law are not criminally responsible - are also employed to kill other children. 
 These charges have mobilised the government: the Justice Minister has ordered an investigation by regional security officials, and Congress plans an inquiry. 
 Police officers insist that most of the killings are drug-related, especially in Rio, where minors are employed as delivery boys and armed lookouts by traffickers. 
 But last weekend two adolescent courting couples were murdered in Novo Fribourgo because they witnessed the killing by military police of a youth considered to be tarnishing the town's image. 
 For thousands of children who spend their days locked up in the shanty towns while their parents work, the streets offer freedom and escape from domestic violence as well as a springboard to prostitution or petty crime. 
 A decade of economic stagnation has forced families to turn schoolchildren into breadwinners. 
 Of Brazil's 58 million children and adolescents, almost a fifth work full-time as delivery boys, rural workers, shoe-shiners or gatherers of waste paper. 
 Marta Silva Campos, municipal welfare secretary for Sao Paulo's left-wing city administration, calculates that there are almost two million children living in such poverty that the streets offer an alternative. 
 &bquo;People are paranoid &mdash; they just want to keep the problem under control so they don't get robbed by juvenile delinquents,&equo; she said. 
 Funabem, the federal child welfare agency, calculates there are seven million street children across Brazil. 
 Ms Campos is highly critical of the Sao Paulo state government's high-profile child care policies, which claim to have saved at least 100,000 children. 
 &bquo;The first problem is to stop adults being afraid of children. 
 By educating children that a large part of society would like to see behind bars, we are breaking down important taboos,&equo; said Alda Marco Antonio, state welfare secretary. 
 But despite the return to democracy, she admits humanitarian attitudes are unchanged:: &bquo;This is an outdated, prejudiced and repressive society.&equo; 
 FBI advertises for Russian spies 
 From LEONARD DOYLE in New York 
 THE FBI HAS taken out advertisements in a Russian-language newspaper in New York in an effort to entice spies and counterintelligence agents living among Soviet emigres in the United States to defect. 
 The advertisements appeared in Novoye Russkoye at the weekend, causing a buzz of excitement in the Soviet expatriate enclave of Brighton Beach, also known as Little Odessa. 
 Some 150,000 Jews, Armenians and ethnic Germans have come to the US since 1975, and 80,000 more are expected over the next year. 
 Many Russian exiles have long suspected that spies had been planted in their midst by the KGB, and for some the advertisements confirmed their darkest fears. 
 The FBI &mdash; which handles counterintelligence matters &mdash; is trying to turn the influx of Soviet emigres to its advantage, however, and, according to The New York Times, the agency hopes to reap a potential intelligence bonanza once double agents have been weeded out. 
 The agency's unorthodox approach and a solemn promise that &bquo;replies will be kept in the strictest confidence&equo; caused some mirth among exiles. 
 The ad says that &bquo;many emigres have found themselves in a position to assist the FBI in its counterintelligence mission&equo;. 
 &bquo;Some of you are emigres who, for one reason or another, have direct knowledge of KGB methods or operations in the USSR or abroad, but particularly in the United States. 
 Potential defectors are asked to call Manhattan (212) 553-2700 and ask for the counterintelligence section at extension 3037.&equo; 
 Defectors have found difficulty making contact with FBI agents, although the agency is listed in the telephone book. 
 Apparently many emigres are unaware that phone books, almost impossible to acquire in the Soviet Union, are freely available in the US. 
 Novelist leads as presidential race begins in Peru 
 From SIMON STRONG in Lima 
 MARIO VARGAS LLOSA, the novelist, was comfortably ahead in the opinion polls as the deadline for the registration of candidates in the Peruvian presidential elections passed yesterday. 
 Mr Vargas has achieved his lead despite the offence caused to some of the crustier elements of his right-wing allies, the Popular Alliance and the Popular Christian Party by a television advertisement that presented a monkey dressed as a state bureaucrat. 
 &bquo;And they say they care about those below&equo;, said the commentary, as the monkey urinated against a wall. 
 Doubts about Mr Vargas' taste were also raised by the sight of near-naked women dancing to celebrate his second anniversary in politics. 
 Mr Vargas, whose group is called the Liberty Movement, needs to win more than half of the votes next 8 April to secure the presidency. 
 He would introduce sweeping, neo-liberal reforms, including an extensive privatisation programme, within a framework of ideas promoted by a Peruvian economist, Hernando de Soto, whose work has been hailed by President Bush as a blue-print for the developing world. 
 If he fails to gain an outright majority the Marxist former mayor of Lima, Alfonso Barrantes, might win the second round. 
 Mr Barrantes, 61, bowed out of the 1985 presidential elections after coming second in the first ballot. 
 He launched his campaign on Saturday with a promise to protect the public sector and to jail those caught stealing from the state. 
 Superficially, little has changed. 
 Left and right struggle over familiar territory and all sides &mdash; including the ruling Apra candidate, Luis Alva, - vow to root out corruption. 
 But the figure lurking behind all three is Mr de Soto. 
 And against all three are the guerrilla groups, the Shining Path and the smaller Tupac Amaru Revolutionary Movement. 
 Mr de Soto's think-tank, the Institute of Liberty and Democracy, has highlighted how massive urban emigration has undermined a government system that revolves around private and state monopolies. 
 He claims it has forced migrants to live outside formal society. 
 His plans to grant land titles to shanty-town dwellers were effectively launched into the Apra-dominated Congress by the &bquo;reformist&equo; left. 
 His comprehensive law to cut bureaucratic red tape was similarly backed. 
 Both initiatives have the active support of President Garcia. 
 Mr de Soto's early association with Mr Vargas' alliance, the Democratic Front, has cooled because of the economist's suspicion that the novelist is being compromised by his allies. 
 Among these are powerful businessmen with little interest in a genuinely free market. 
 The municipal and new regional elections on 12 November will be the Front's first test. 
 The elections will be boycotted by Shining Path, who have already stepped up assassinations, caused several candidates to resign and raised fears that, in many parts of Peru, democratic elections will simply be a pipe dream. 
 Somalia is disintegrating into anarchy: Richard Dowden last week became the first outsider to visit the parts of Somalia controlled by anti-government guerrillas. 
 He describes a country ravaged by tribal warfare and seemingly doomed to become the African continent's next tragedy 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 THERE are only 19 people left in Zeila &mdash; mostly old men sheltering from the glaring sun in the wreckage of this ancient port. 
 They and starving cats are the only living things surviving among the shattered buildings and corrugated iron shacks. 
 The only building unscathed is the green and white tomb of Ibrahim Ahmed Ben Omar, who died 750 years ago. 
 The British-built hospital (1939) stands empty, doors ripped off and windows smashed. 
 A pile of grimy bed-linen lies in what was once a ward. 
 Embedded in the sand outside is a broken microscope. 
 The Zeila Fishing Community Training Centre, built by a United Nations fund, has been looted, every removable part of its generator has gone and its floors are littered with excrement and papers from upturned cupboards. 
 The half-finished Save the Children Fund clinic is abandoned. 
 Nearby, two rusting medieval cannons lie half-buried in the sand. 
 Their modern equivalents, two 120mm mortars, stand nearby, pointing out to sea. 
 Their crews are prostrate in the shade, trying to escape the excruciating, oven heat. 
 This small town fell to the guerrillas of the Somali National Movement after fierce fighting in May this year. 
 By June, the whole of northern Somalia was in their hands, with the exception of Hargeisa, the regional capital, and four garrison towns. 
 In the south, rebels from another group are pressing the government of President Siad Barre, who now has little authority beyond the capital. 
 The rebel movements are almost exclusively tribal &mdash; as is the rump of government. 
 Fighting has been accompanied by massacres of civilians from the &bquo;wrong&equo; tribe. 
 A recent US State Department report on human rights in Somalia said that, at a conservative estimate, 5,000 unarmed Issaqs had been murdered by the Somali armed forces between May 1988 and March this year. 
 Hundreds of thousands of Somalis have fled from their homes, some to refugee camps in Ethiopia, others to revert to their ancestral nomadic existence in Somalia's empty semi-deserts. 
 The Somali government has armed refugees from Ethiopia to help fight the rebels; deserters from the army are also roaming the desert. 
 Somalia is disintegrating into anarchy. 
 Last week SNM guerrillas took me into Somalia from Djibouti, a crossing made on foot by night, dodging police and army patrols. 
 The Djibouti government wants to avoid involvement in its neighbour's civil war, but most Djiboutians support their Issaq Somali cousins. 
 Although there are between 30,000 and 50,000 Somalis squatting in the tiny littoral state of Djibouti, its government does not grant them refugee status and deports any Somalis - guerrillas or refugees &mdash; it catches crossing the border. 
 According to many local people, the police hold refugees without food or water for a few days, then turn them loose in the desert near the Somali or Ethiopian borders - too far for them to walk back. 
 As I recrossed into Djibouti, villagers sympathetic to the SNM, or just wanting money, hid me from the patrols. 
 In one village, suddenly raided by the army at 2am, villagers made me lie on the ground and threw a blanket over me, telling the soldiers I was an old woman, too sick to move. 
 The SNM is a ragged band of fighters with little political ideology beyond the expulsion of President Barre's forces from northern Somalia and the overthrow of his 20-year-old government. 
 It is almost entirely made up of Issaq people, the clan of northern, formerly British, Somalia. 
 The movement seems to have substantial sums of money, but I saw no sign of material support. 
 All the weapons and uniforms appeared to have been captured. 
 It lives off the local people, eating the camels of roaming nomads, who appeared to offer them willingly. 
 When I asked Ali Ahmed Yonis, the local guerrilla commander, how many fighters the SNM had, he replied simply: &bquo;I don't know. 
 All Issaqs are SNM fighters.&equo; 
 The Issaqs have cause to hate the Mogadishu government. 
 In Djibouti I met 13 of them, once the leading professionals of Hargeisa; doctors, teachers, businessmen and civil servants. 
 Ten years ago they formed themselves into the Hargeisa Group to lobby the government for a better deal for the north. 
 For that they were detained and tortured for four months in 1981. 
 After a brief show trial they were put in solitary confinement in appalling conditions until March this year. 
 Some still bear the marks of their torture, but they appeared remarkably calm and unembittered by their suffering. 
 The civil war in the north began in earnest in May last year, when hundreds of SNM fighters poured across the Ethiopian border and attacked Hargeisa and Buroa. 
 They nearly captured Hargeisa, and the government forces reacted by rounding up all influential Issaqs in the town and executing them. 
 The SNM withdrew and is now laying siege to Hargeisa and four other garrisons in the region. 
 Commander Ali said SNM ambushes had prevented supplies reaching them and he was confident that Boroma would soon fall. 
 It is bitterly ironic that Somalia, the only nation in Africa with one ethnic group, one culture, one language and one religion should be the most deeply divided of the continent's 52 fractious countries. 
 The landscape seems to belong to some bare planet closer to the sun than earth, and the passions of its people match that glaring heat. 
 Somalis have a just reputation as fierce, uncompromising fighters. 
 When the Princess Royal visited the region on behalf of the Save the Children Fund last year, the local people danced for her. 
 One of the dances consisted of a mimed battle between two men. 
 It ended with one man symbolically castrating the other and dancing before the Princess waving his &bquo;prize&equo;. 
 But the viciousness of Somalia's civil war is far outweighed by the suffering of its refugees. 
 Almost 350,000 fled to Ethiopia in May last year when the fighting flared. 
 They were mostly from Hargeisa, townspeople with a reasonable standard of living. 
 Many of those who arrived in Ethiopia were healthy, and with money and possessions. 
 Due to the incompetence of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in Ethiopia, their condition rapidly deteriorated. 
 They were not properly cared for, and by May this year there was widespread malnutrition in the camps &mdash; despite the fact that the UNHCR provided for an assumed 600,000 refugees, almost double the true number. 
 The distribution of food, water and shelter was chaotic. 
 Some refugees managed to obtain extra ration cards, and at the Harshin and Hartishek camps food repeatedly ran out before everyone had received their ration. 
 There were several riots, and local Ethiopian troops opened fire more than once to quell the angry refugees. 
 The Save the Children Fund, which was working in the camps, made a report which exposed the scandal of the Ethiopian camps. 
 In June, after heated talks with the UNHCR, conditions began to improve. 
 The aid agencies working there decided not to publicise the report, which has since been backed up by an internal report by Robert Ash, a senior UNHCR official. 
 However inadequate its facilities, Ethiopia remains the only neighbour which accepts Somali refugees. 
 The UNHCR is too weak to press the governments of Kenya or Djibouti into accepting and caring for them. 
 Last week the BBC reported that Kenyan police at Liboi, on the border with Somalia, were forcibly returning refugees from Somalia who arrived three weeks ago. 
 Two had already died of starvation and young children were reported to be very weak from lack of food. 
 Those who resisted repatriation were arrested and jailed. 
 But Somalia's refugees may have suffered a less appalling fate than the hundreds of thousands of Ethiopian refugees in Somalia, who have existed in desolate camps for nearly 10 years. 
 These camps have been attacked by both government forces and the SNM, with at least 241 refugees killed. 
 The UNHCR has been forced to abandon them, and no one knows what has become of their inhabitants. 
 Dumped in waterless barren regions near the Somali Ethiopian border, they could not survive long without the food and water supplies brought in by lorry. 
 They may become another African horror story, reported long after anyone is able to do anything about it. 
 Siad Barre will celebrate &mdash; if that is the right word &mdash; 20 years in power on 21 October. 
 The old man's power, built on a mixture of skilful manipulation and ruthless repression, has waned. 
 Some say he is now no more than mayor of Mogadishu, retaining only the loyalty of his own Marehan clan and other Darode tribes. 
 The Ogadeni tribe, once the backbone of his army, has deserted him: its members have formed the Somali Patriotic Movement. 
 Even the Hawieh, the majority in the capital and usually politically docile, have begun their own movement, the Somali Union Congress. 
 The United States, formerly President Barre's close ally, has abandoned him. 
 Having secured a regional detente with the Soviet Union, the Americans no longer need the base facility at Berbera on the coast of the Gulf of Aden. 
 Only the Italians, the former colonisers of southern Somalia, are continuing to give aid to Mogadishu. 
 But the question is no longer whether President Barre will survive. 
 The question is: what will replace him? 
 The Somali nation has broken down into its tribes and there is little trust between them. 
 The removal of the Barre regime may be the end of a tyranny; it could also be the begining of a tribal war the horrors of which we have so far only glimpsed. 
 One day last week we stopped in a deserted village and the guerrillas led me to where lunch was being prepared. 
 Lunch was a camel. 
 Its hindquarters squatted comfortably on the ground but the rest of it, from its fifth vertebra, was missing. 
 The lopped neck and head lay a few feet away, and starving cats licked the blood-soaked earth. 
 In between men with machetes hacked and chopped in a welter of gore. 
 It is my abiding image of Somalia. 
 Sick system 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 First Edition (AP) &mdash; The World Health Organisation said Bulgaria's ethnic Turks have not received equal access to or equal use of the public health system 
 Aquino annoyed 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 First Edition MANILA (Reuter) &mdash; President Aquino, admitting that the death of Ferdinand Marcos had sparked a wave of sympathy for the late dictator, urged Filipinos to stop weeping for the man who had &bquo;laughed all the way to the bank.&equo; 
 Pope appeal 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 First Edition JAKARTA (Reuter) &mdash; Pope John Paul, who makes a controversial visit to the disputed territory of East Timor this week, told Indonesia's government that human rights and self-determination must be respected. 
 He paid tribute to the way the country had forged national unity. 
 But in a speech to President Suharto and ministers he added: &bquo;At times nations are tempted to disregard fundamental human rights in a misguided search for political unity based on military or economic power alone. 
 But such unity can easily be dissolved.&equo; 
 Briton held 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 David Ormerod, a geology lecturer at the Open University, has been held in Oradea, Romania, for the past three days, after being picked up at the main crossing point into Hungary. 
 Dr Ormerod, who was on a working holiday in the Carpathians, is to be tried on charges of attempting to smuggle a Romanian citizen out of the country. 
 Sign of hope 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 BEIRUT (AP) &mdash; The American University of Beirut, once the most celebrated centre of higher education in the Middle East, reopened after a six-month closure caused by fighting between Syrian and Christian forces. 
 Car bomb case 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 MADRID (Reuter) &mdash; Two Basque separatists went on trial charged with a car bomb attack which killed 21 Barcelona shoppers in June 1987. 
 The prosecution has requested 950-year jail sentences each for Josefa Mercedes Ernaga and Domingo Troitino. 
 Killer Angela 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Dollar hunt 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 BELGRADE (Reuter) &mdash; The Yugoslav Prime Minister, Ante Markovic, leaving behind an economic crisis with inflation running at almost 1,200 per cent, flew to the US to ask for &dollar;1bn to back up his reform programme. 
 Hijackers' trial 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 BANGKOK (AP) &mdash; Two Burmese students who hijacked a plane to demand democracy in their military-ruled country will be tried in Thailand but not sent back home. 
 30-year itch 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 SINGAPORE (Reuter) &mdash; The Prime Minister of Singapore, Lee Kuan Yew, confirmed in an interview with the BBC that he would step down and hand over power to his deputy, Goh Chok Tong, by the end of next year. 
 Mr Lee, 66, leader of the ruling People's Action Party, has held the office since 1959 when Singapore became a self-governing state. 
 Japan to pay 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 NICOSIA (Reuter) &mdash; The Japanese firm, Mitsui, has undertaken to pay Iran almost &dollar;1bn (&pound;625m) in compensation for ending its role in a joint petrochemical complex, Iran's Irna news agency said. 
 Bomb charge 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 STOCKHOLM (Reuter) &mdash; A prosecutor formally charged four men of Palestinian origin with a series of terrorist bombings against various US and Israeli offices in Copenhagen and Stockholm between 1985 and 1986. 
 But he denied newspaper reports that the men had been involved in last December's bombing of a Pan Am jet which exploded above the Scottish village of Lockerbie with the loss of 270 lives. 
 More elections 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 ATHENS (AP) &mdash; Greeks faced the prospect of new general elections next month after party leaders failed to form a government. 
 The former Prime Minister, Andreas Papandreou, rebuffed in his attempt to convince leftist forces to join his socialist camp in a coalition government, returned an exploratory three-day mandate to President Christos Sartzetakis. 
 Galileo launch challenged 
 By MARK CHAMPION 
 WASHINGTON &mdash; Countdown to liftoff has begun for the space shuttle Atlantis and the Jupiter-bound spacecraft it is carrying. 
 But a Washington court could stop the launch today, if it agrees with anti-nuclear activists that the space probe's plutonium generators are unsafe, writes Mark Champion. 
 In the first-ever legal challenge to a space launch, a coalition of anti-nuclear groups charge that Galileo's generators could rain radioactive waste all over eastern Florida if the shuttle were to explode during takeoff. 
 Italy pulls out of Nato ship plan 
 By MARK CHAMPION 
 THE HAGUE (AFP) &mdash; Following the lead of Britain and France, Italy will pull out of Nato's &dollar;13bn (&pound;8bn) project to build a frigate for the 1990s, according to the Dutch Defence Secretary. 
 Jan van Houwelingen said Italy would not participate in the Nato plan to build a new anti-aircraft frigate for the fleets of eight allied powers. 
 He told the Dutch parliament that those countries still wanting to participate would meet shortly to decide whether to pursue the programme. 
 Kohl pleads for reform for the sake of European stability 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 CHANCELLOR Kohl yesterday appealed again to East Germany's unbending leaders to introduce reforms as anxiety grew here that the situation in East Germany could hurtle out of control. 
 &bquo;Internal peace and stability cannot be guaranteed by force and by denying the people a voice,&equo; he said. 
 As he spoke, details continued to pour in of demonstrations and police brutality matched only by the harshly-suppressed 1953 uprising. 
 Caught unprepared by East Germany's explosion of discontent, West Germans fear that the regime's stubbornness could provoke a revolt and bring chaos to the country, threatening the stability of Europe and pose immense problems &mdash; including the question of German reunification &mdash; which they and their neighbours are not ready to face. 
 &bquo;We don't want to stabilise the existing regime but we don't want a destabilisation which could lead to incalculable risks,&equo; said a close aide of the Chancellor. 
 Chancellor Kohl has promised generous aid to support reforms in East Germany. 
 This should be taken as a message both to the Western allies and the Soviet Union that West Germany's first concern is the gradual, well-disciplined reform of East German society, not the country's destruction and its absorption into West Germany. 
 Nor does the Chancellor demand free elections for East Germans immediately, his aides say, but would first like to see them be given greater personal freedom and basic human rights. 
 The West Germans have found themselves sharing virtually identical interests with East Germany's own superpower, the Soviet Union. 
 Chancellor Kohl has been in contact with President Gorbachev since the refugee exodus began in August. 
 Although the details have not been disclosed, the Soviet Union played a key role in convincing the East Germans to let refugees holed up in West German embassies leave for the West. 
 The Chancellor has evidently made it clear to Moscow that West Germany respects East Germany's existence as a separate state, that it does not want to alter the present military set-up of Nato and the Warsaw Pact, and that although it aims to overcome the division of Europe, this does not also apply to the political division of Germany &mdash; at least for the foreseeable future. 
 The Soviet Union, for its part, let it be known that if serious trouble did break out in East Germany Soviet troops would not move in, as they did to quell the 1953 revolt &mdash; so long as the West did not interfere either. 
 Bonn is now hoping that Mr Gorbachev's publicly cautious, but presumably privately firm pressure on the East German leaders to reform will produce results and doing their best to reinforce it. 
 WARSAW &mdash; About 100 East Germans have been arriving daily at the West German embassy In Warsaw, hoping to join the 1,436 who have gained passage to the West via Poland since 30 September, AFP reports. 
 A total of 110,184 refugees arrived in West Germany between January and September, according to the West German Ministry for Inter-German Relations. 
 Honecker sees parallel with unrest in Peking 
 From EDWARD STEEN in West Berlin 
 THE East German leader, Erich Honecker, yesterday compared unrest in his country to China's pro-democracy uprising earlier this year, and said that any attempt to undermine communism in East Germany would be doomed to failure. 
 The official ADN news agency said that Mr Honecker told the visiting Chinese Deputy Prime Minister, Yao Yilin: &bquo;Any attempt by imperialism to destabilise socialist construction, and slander its achievements, is now and in the future nothing more than Don Quixote's futile charge against the steadily turning sails of a windmill.&equo; 
 &bquo;The two agreed there was evidence of a particularly aggressive anti-socialist action by imperialist class opponents with the aim of reversing socialist development,&equo; ADN added. 
 &bquo;In this respect there is a fundamental lesson to be learnt from the counter-revolutionary unrest in Peking and the present campaign against the GDR and other socialist states.&equo; 
 East Germany, together with Czechoslovakia and Bulgaria, condoned the Peking government's actions in June, when hundreds of people were killed in the crushing of the pro-democracy movement. 
 The party newspaper, Neues Deutschland, splashed yesterday on a story headlined: &bquo;The Development Of The German Democratic Republic Will Be The Work Of The Whole People In Future, Too.&equo; 
 Apart from a page 9 reference to hooligans in Neues Deutschland, only the youth paper, Junge Welt, referred to the unprecedented protests over the weekend, which saw tens of thousands of young East Germans on the streets, and an estimated 1,000 still in jail in East Berlin alone. 
 Junge Welt printed a photograph of some demonstrators. 
 The most high-level discontent appeared in an extraordinary open letter to the same paper, the organ of the Free German Youth (SDJ). 
 The president of the Writer's Association, Hermann Kant, a central committee member, said the exodus of almost 50,000 refugees could not be blamed on the &bquo;wicked class enemy&equo; in West Germany: &bquo;A defeat is a defeat even if it comes on the eve of a glorious celebration.&equo; 
 He attacked the smug &bquo;self glorification&equo; of the official press, the &bquo;pervasive bossiness&equo; of the system, and said that social understanding was imperative &bquo;through criticism and self-criticism &mdash; openly, not bleating, but by being hard and patient.&equo; 
 After protests by the Western Allies about the infringement of the Four Powers agreement, West Berliners were moving again through the Friedrichstrasse crossing yesterday. 
 But only a trickle of tourists passed through Checkpoint Charlie. 
 The more determined Australian backpackers turned up again repeatedly all through the day. 
 Too late to find an E German Gorbachev 
 From EDWARD STEEN 
 WEST BERLIN &mdash; East Berlin yesterday began jamming the cheeky private radio station 100,6 broadcasting from the Western half of the city. 
 A more eloquent statement of unrealism would be hard to devise, writes Edward Steen. 
 The would-be island, now with hermetically sealed borders and excluding all but a few tourists, is full of noises. 
 They are faithfully relayed by West German television to the 16.5 million population, and range from the shouts of &bquo;freedom&equo; and the sound of Stasi truncheons hitting skulls to the even more ominous noises from abroad. 
 Bonn can plainly not afford the political price of continuing to shore up the German Democratic Republic with billions of Deutsche Marks unless in return for genuine reform. 
 Back in Moscow after the grinding 40th anniversary celebrations in East Berlin, President Gorbachev made plain on Soviet television that Erich Honecker's Socialist Unity Party of Germany (SED) could sink or learn to swim. 
 Last week the Soviet embassy in East Berlin even signalled it would not intervene if unrest became uncontrollable. 
 The long search for an East German Gorbachev is looking more and more irrelevant. 
 It is probably now too late, but the subject continues to provoke speculation. 
 Hans Modrow, Party leader in Dresden, is supposed to be a reformist, but there is no evidence for this. 
 Another, more exotic, suggestion is Markus Wolf, the retired spy chief, if only because he sounds rather human and writes books. 
 The pundits dip haphazardly into the lucky dip. 
 What about Gunter Schabowski, First Secretary of The East Berlin Party, who always seems to be in Moscow? 
 Egon Krenz, 48, a hard-drinking hard-liner and nominally number two, responsible for youths, is now written off, having no friends in the Soviet Union or anywhere else. 
 But no one knows, and perhaps there is nothing to know. 
 President Gorbachev claimed on Soviet television to have found many supporters of perestroika in SED. 
 That could be true. 
 The disgruntlement among its two million members is almost palpable. 
 The 22-man Politburo jealously guards power. 
 It is entirely dominated by old comrades of 77-year-old Erich Honecker from the days when, after 1945, he built his powerbase. 
 All in Mr Honecker's image, tough and second rate, they are not inclined to give up the hunting lodges and chauffeurs they feel are their due. 
 With luck, an &bquo;easeful death&equo; will intervene before that day comes. 
 Eight of them are over 70. 
 To speculate about possible good communists in the GDR is also to ignore the central fact about the country, which is that it is not one. 
 Increasingly referred to by its citizens as &bquo;the Zone&equo;, as it had been when it was merely the Soviet occupation zone, it has achieved no genuine separate identity or legitimacy. 
 On the economic front, the near-heroic attempt to make a centralised economy work has produced, with Bonn's support, a real success story. 
 But it is sliding ever backwards in relation to the West. 
 Reform will bring chaos a la russe, according to the leading West German expert on the GDR economy, Doris Cornelsen: &bquo;But without reforms disaster looms anyway. 
 The GDR's choice is between dealing with chaos quickly and overcoming it or putting it off. 
 Then it will be worse.&equo; 
 But even improbably swift, prudent action, does not solve the problem of the GDR's lack of any other reason for existence except a Socialism few now want. 
 Reform is not just a sensible course which could, with some pain, lead to a better life for everyone, as in Hungary. 
 Reform would in effect mean the end of the state. 
 Mr Gorbachev pleased his grinning hosts in East Berlin when he politely remarked that whatever affected the future of the GDR would be decided in Berlin. 
 In truth, Berlin is perhaps the least important player in the game. 
 Soviet workers win a qualified right to strike 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 IN A HISTORIC legislative debut, the new Soviet parliament last night gave final and overwhelming approval to a comprehensive law on labour disputes, admitting the right of workers to strike but outlawing stoppages in various key sectors of the national economy. 
 The measure is not only the first full-scale law passed by the Supreme Soviet in its new incarnation as a professional legislature. 
 It is also an unprecedented legal recognition here of a problem the very existence of which was for many decades denied by a Communist state claiming to be founded upon the interests of the working class. 
 The big moment came shortly before 7pm after more than two days of debate in the full parliament and much scrutiny and no few amendments in committee. 
 When the result &mdash; 373 votes for, 12 against &mdash; flashed up on the black and green computer screens at either end of the chamber, the assembled deputies gave themselves a short, self-congratulatory round of applause. 
 The law itself will take over from the emergency anti-strike provisions voted through amid no little confusion six days ago. 
 It effectively bans strikes in transport, including rail, air and underground services, in the fuel, energy and defence industries, and in other sectors where a halt in production could have &bquo;serious and dangerous consequences&equo;. 
 Strikes for political motives are also forbidden. 
 Even where they are allowed, strikes will still not be easy. 
 They are conceived of as a last resort when all else fails, including a mandatory three-day cooling-off period and a further five days while a &bquo;conciliation commission&equo; will attempt to produce agreement between the parties. 
 Even then, a strike can go ahead only with the backing, secured in open or secret ballot, of a majority of the work force. 
 Picketing and other intimidation will be illegal, and men involved in a stoppage will not be paid for its duration. 
 However, in an important concession, the legislation permits disputes to be handled not only by official trades unions and works councils but by &bquo;any other organ&equo; so empowered by the work collective. 
 This amounts to de facto recognition of the unofficial strike committees which emerged as a real power during last summer's disruption in the Siberian and Ukrainian coalfields. 
 Meanwhile, in the current strike which really matters, Azerbaijan's month-long unofficial rail blockade of Armenia and Nagorny Karabakh, the situation remains confused. 
 According to the Tass news agency, 37 trains got through over the weekend, partly as a result of &bquo;serious measures&equo; by the authorities. 
 That last phrase would seem to indicate employment of the military to ensure safe and regular transit over Azerbaijan, through which 85 per cent of the rail freight reaching Armenia must pass. 
 But at a rally in Baku on Sunday, the Azerbaijani Popular Front, prime mover in the blockade, indicated it was continuing its campaign, which is aimed at forcing Armenia to drop its demand for reunification with Nagorny Karabakh. 
 Estonia gets ready for a three-letter miracle: Rupert Cornwell traces the Baltic republic's rapid move to remarkable degree of economic and political autonomy 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 REIN OTSASON, at least, has no doubts. 
 &bquo;By 1 January, we will be ready,&equo; says Estonia's Deputy Prime Minister in his office in the elegant pink government building, atop the hill dominating the spires and steep-sloping rooftops of the old Hanseatic heart of Estonia's capital. 
 If anyone may speak with confidence, it is Mr Otsason. 
 He more than anyone is the inventor of IME. 
 In Estonian, the acronym stands for Ise-Majandav Eesti: &bquo;an economically independent Estonia&equo;. 
 Only 18 months ago, it was little more than a dream, the brainchild of himself and a few radical economists, blending Mr Gorbachev's plans for economic decentralisation with crystallising Estonian nationalism. 
 Today, almost incredibly, it stands less than three months from take-off. 
 This May, IME became a law of the Estonian parliament. 
 Far more astounding, the plan for the republic to switch to full economic self-management on 1 January 1990 was approved by the full Supreme Soviet in Moscow on 27 July. 
 Thus, perhaps without realising the implications, the Soviet parliament gave the go-ahead for the most revolutionary experiment here since Lenin's New Economic Policy of the 1920s: for a massive delegation of powers from the centre, permitting a single republic to create its own market-oriented economy, with its own budget, and to redraw economic rules which basically Stalin's. 
 And not just any republic. 
 Nowhere can economic autonomy be separated from political autonomy, and least of all in the Soviet Baltic states, where separatism stalks every debate. 
 This devolution will take place amid bitter conflict over local electoral and citizenship laws, and an explosive argument over the very legality of the incorporation of Estonia into the Soviet Union in 1940. 
 Last week, the Estonian Parliament compromised on both fronts &mdash; but only at the price of jeopardising the alliance between nationalists and the republic's Communist Party which has hitherto allowed Estonia so nimbly to sidestep a decisive confrontation with Moscow. 
 It is against this background, and that of desperate economic crisis in the entire Soviet Union, that IME is supposed to proceed. 
 In fact, the present mess, whatever its practical implications for the myriad administrative changes required to implement the Estonian experiment, merely increases the impetus for reform. 
 For the separatists, IME offers escape from the system &mdash; political as well as economic &mdash; which has imprisoned their nation for half a century. 
 Those of more moderate cut, such as Mr Otsason and the official party leadership, maintain that the Estonian model is the Soviet Union's only hope of salvation. 
 &bquo;Our programme is the only one that can get the country as a whole out of its crisis,&equo; he argues. 
 &bquo;It will make everyone concerned to spend less and earn more. 
 Right now, in order to improve our standard of living, we have to ask Moscow for more. 
 In future we'll be asking for less.&equo; 
 But it will be a long time before that system is fully installed. 
 No fewer than 20 legislative acts will be required, says Mr Otsason. 
 Those providing for a separate republican budget, a revamped tax system, and autonomy for companies registered in Estonia, have been drawn up. 
 Others though are not, and will be even more controversial. 
 Their subjects range from property and land (in contrast to the country-wide bill about to be discussed in the Moscow Supreme Soviet, Estonia will explicitly recognise private ownership) to migration and &mdash; most delicate of all &mdash; currency and finance. 
 The blueprint approved in May foresees an Estonian central bank controlling a local banking system, the local money supply and credit market. 
 It would be empowered to conduct its own relations with foreign central banks. 
 Most crucially, it would have the right to issue an Estonian currency, probably named after the kron which served during the 20 years of independence between the wars. 
 &bquo;We do not want economic war with Russia,&equo; Mr Otsason stresses. 
 Yet there could be no more symbolic act of defiance than a currency with a separate exchange rate against the rouble. 
 A finance bill looks unlikely before next summer and even then, a re-appearance of the kron seems improbable. 
 But before that there are other hurdles: how to reach agreement with a jealous central bureaucracy over control of &bquo;union&equo; factories on Estonian soil, vital to the central plan. 
 What about defence industry plants? 
 Other issues touch sensitive local nerves. 
 The laws on migration and land could easily upset the 30 per cent Russian component of the population. 
 Quietly, Estonia is also exploring the possibility of trading directly with other republics. 
 IME happens to be the Estonian word for &bquo;miracle&equo; &mdash; exactly what is required, you could be forgiven for feeling, if today's designs are to become reality. 
 Hungarian party heads off split 
 From IMRE KARACS in Budapest 
 HUNGARIAN reformers narrowly averted a fatal split last night just two days after the birth of their new Socialist Party when they elected a compromise leadership. 
 Imre Pozsgay's Reform Alliance managed to secure 14 seats on the new presidium, while Reszo Nyers, the moderate president re-elected last night by an 80 per cent majority, won the 11 remaining seats on the party's top body. 
 The compromise list was put together after long hours of high drama when Mr Pozsgay, a minister of state and the leading reformer, and two of his close allies threatened to walk out. 
 Mr Pozsgay, Mr Nemeth and Gyula Horn, the Foreign Minister, had been dissatisfied with Mr Nyers' compromising stance, and his support for party cells in workplaces. 
 Nevertheless, the three would-be breakaways said after the vote that they were &bquo;satisfied&equo; with the composition of the new leadership, despite the big sacrifices they had to make. 
 Two leaders of the Reform Circle movement, Csaba Tabajdi and Ferenc Gazso, are missing from the new line-up, while the People's Democracy Platform, the reformists' left-wing allies, seemed to have got more than their share of the leading places. 
 Another source of future friction lies in the failure of the congress to elevate Mr Pozsgay above other presidium members, some of whom had never been elected to a top party position. 
 Mr Pozsgay will have his chance of greater glory in the presidential elections scheduled for next month, but his ambitious young colleague, Mr Nemeth, will have no such consolation. 
 His high profile in recent months and obvious bid for the party presidency have amounted to nothing. 
 The new party's founding documents condemned &bquo;policy mistakes&equo; in Hungary's recent history, and outlined &bquo;remedies&equo; for the future. 
 The main &bquo;mistakes&equo; were: the Communist Party's forcible suppression of opposition in 1948 to establish a political dictatorship in Hungary; the Stalinist era's &bquo;unrealistic pace of military preparation, ill-conceived industrialisation and the forced collectivisation&equo;; Stalinist &bquo;harassment of millions of people, the mass violation of rights and intimidation&equo;; the violent Soviet suppression of the 1956 Hungarian revolt, which is now now officially defined as a popular uprising; and the party's inability from the mid-1970s to continue the decentralisation of economic reforms launched in 1968. 
 The proposed &bquo;remedies&equo; included: a multi-party political system; a government answerable to an elected parliament, not to one political party; use of referenda as a form of direct democracy; autonomous local governments; the creation of the office of state president; an independent judiciary; an end to censorship; a supreme auditing office to inspect state finances; constitutional guarantees to defend the rights of ethnic and religious minorities; and a welfare state, founded on a market-based economy. 
 The big question now is whether Communist MPs, most of whom come from the old school, will apply for membership of the new party. 
 If they do not, the party could lose its majority in parliament, precipitating a government crisis. 
 MPs will start debating these issues on the 17 of this month, two weeks before members of the old party have to make up their minds about whether they want to join the new ship. 
 Latvians seek independence 
 From IMRE KARACS in Budapest 
 RIGA (AP) &mdash; Members of the Latvian nationalist movement, the People's Front, have raised their demand from achieving local autonomy to outright independence from the Soviet Union. 
 Delegates at the second annual congress of the movement voted overwhelmingly early yesterday to approve a programme designed to build an independent economy and social structure in Latvia before the republic secedes at an unspecified date. 
 Only one of the 1,074 delegates voted against the proposal. 
 As the congress came to a close, Janis Aboltins, vice-chairman of the Latvian state planning commission, said the call for independence could create problems in negotiating more econonic freedom from the Kremlin. 
 &bquo;There is a direct link between the political situation and economic negotiations,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The more radical the slogans, the more difficult it is for us the day after in the corridors of power in Moscow.&equo; 
 Around the World 
 By BRUCE PALLING 
 Law and order in Uganda IT IS more than a decade since Kampala was one of the world's danger capitals, when Uganda was under the sway of Idi Amin, the murderous clown now in exile in the Middle East. 
 Even though the country is now relatively peaceful, British diplomats still enjoy the protection of British Royal Military Police equipped with the latest in machine pistols and bullet-proof vehicles. 
 The only other posts with such security are Lebanon and El Salvador. 
 All the more embarrassing, then, that the residence of the High Commissioner, Sir Derek March, was recently burgled and thoroughly looted, despite a British policeman being on duty at the time. 
 As though this were not enough, a gang of Ugandan footpads then raided the homes of the newly-arrived British police training mission and made off with their video machines &mdash; plus their training tapes for the local police on how to prevent burglaries. 
 Cedric goes home Mystery surrounds the recent recall to New York of Cedric Thornberry, the Northern Ireland-born bon vivant and occasional spokesman for the United Nations in Namibia. 
 Officially it is for &bquo;consultations&equo; but the usual reliable sources say it follows a series of death threats by white bigots who were displeased when he said the South African-controlled Koevoet paramilitary forces were &bquo;on a turkey shoot&equo; against Swapo guerrillas. 
 He also offended cost-conscious UN bureaucrats by purchasing a large mansion in Windhoek; a spokesman in New York described it as showing a &bquo;lack of judgement&equo;. 
 He still has many supporters, though, among the Western press, who considered him to be one of the few UN bureaucrats with a habit of telling the truth. 
 Marcos fairy tale A touching story has reached me from the Manila Times of how Ferdinand Marcos had planned to bequeath more than &pound;2.5bn in gold to his beloved people, but fell ill before he could sign the will. 
 Even more amazing, he is alleged to have told confidants before he died last month that, far from being the spoils of two decades of looting the Treasury, he had found the 400 tons of bullion just after the war in a northern province of the Philippines. 
 He claimed it was the fabled treaure, buried in 1945, of the Japanese General Tomoyuki Yamashita. 
 Marcos, it is said, tried to set up a foundation last year to launder - sorry, deposit &mdash; the funds to benefit Filipinos, minus a 10 per cent cut for his greedy relatives and 10 per cent for the Vatican. 
 The Philippines government, still searching for the estimated &pound;6.5bn that the Marcos family squirreled away, is unimpressed with this fairy tale. 
 Stuff of nightmares No one expects the life of a Peruvian gold prospector to be easy, but I doubt if many would expect to die from the bite of a rabid vampire bat. 
 This, unfortunately, has been the fate of 14 gold panners in the town of Puerto Maldonado, deep in the Peruvian jungle. 
 The vampiros, which have wingspans of more than three feet, swoop into their thatch huts late at night and attach themselves to the sleeping miners' heads, necks and feet. 
 One Peruvian veteran recalled that the worst thing about the vampiros is that, because they are such brilliant surgeons, they can make their incisions without even waking the victim. 
 The head of Lima's anti-rabies clinic said the bats normally feasted on animals but, in their rabid state, they probably didn't know any better. 
 He added that attempts were being made to snare them by hanging nets between trees. 
 Meanwhile, priests are trying to persuade the survivors that the bat attacks were not the work of evil spirits. 
 VAT row sparks fears for single market by 1992 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Luxembourg 
 THERE WERE fears last night that the first substantial cracks had opened in the facade of the European Community's &bquo;Project 1992&equo; after finance ministers appeared to concede that the deadline for creating a truly seamless marketplace for traders cannot be met. 
 In an attempt to overcome a two-year-old impasse over European Commission proposals for an alignment of national rates of Value Added Tax (VAT) and Excise rates by 1993, the ministers agreed to abandon key provisions for revising VAT collection arrangements. 
 These asked for an end to the current system of zero-rating goods bound for export to other EC states in favour of levying VAT on all taxable goods sold, regardless of where in the Community they are to be sold. 
 Thus, in tax terms at least, the 12 EC states would become one. 
 The Commission argues that switching from zero-rating to tax-paid exports would provide the only way of scrapping checks on traders at borders without inviting fraud on a massive scale. 
 It also suggests that this is vital if traders are to be convinced that trading across frontiers is no more strange than doing business with the shopkeeper next door. 
 Yesterday, however, the ministers endorsed a counter-proposal prepared by senior treasury officials, which asks that the current zero-rating mechanisms are maintained &bquo;for a limited period&equo;, on the grounds that too little time is left to adapt to a new system. 
 The governments' main complaint is that for the Commission's plan to work, a special clearing house would have to be set up to reapportion VAT revenue levied in the country of export which would be owing to that of import - where the product would be consumed. 
 National officials answer the Commission fears of fraud by proposing a system of double-checking on traders, whereby they would be obliged to list every item exported and imported for spot-checking. 
 The Commission thinks this would would present businessmen with new paperwork perhaps more burdensome than border checks themselves. 
 France's Finance Minister, Pierre Beregevoy, insisted a step had been taken towards eliminating fiscal frontiers. 
 When pressed, he almost conceded that something of the original philosophy of the 1992 programme may have been lost. 
 &bquo;Rather than seeing total disagreement, I would prefer to have a good compromise,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I would rather make pragmatic progress than theoretical progress.&equo; 
 Britain's junior Treasury Minister, Peter Lilley, also defended the new tactics. 
 &bquo;We can't faff around forever,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The UK was not alone in thinking that the original proposal was too rigid and paid insufficient regard to market forces.&equo; 
 The EC Commissioner now responsible for tax, France's Christiane Scrivener, shuffled out of the meeting unusually declining to speak to journalists. 
 Last week, she outraged her Commission colleagues by suggesting that the government's paper, which has unanimous backing, might prove irresistible. 
 It may not be long before her view is upheld. 
 Any decision on taxation has to be taken by the member states unanimously and there now seems little hope that the Commission can deflect them from the course they set out upon yesterday. 
 Perhaps more grave, however, is the fact that still more contentious aspects of the plan are also still unresolved, notably the extent to which governments can be persuaded to approximate their highly divergent rates of VAT Excise duties. 
 Three countries &mdash; Denmark, Ireland and Belgium &mdash; meanwhile indicated yesterday that they remain opposed to another key element, which forsees the abolition of all limits on tax-paid goods that can be carried across borders by private travellers. 
 These governments fear a vast loss of revenue to the low-rate neighbour countries if these limits &mdash; so-called &bquo;travellers&equo; allowances' &mdash; are abandoned. 
 However, if they are maintained &mdash; and car boots still have to be checked for goods that may exceed the allowances in worth &mdash; then the whole dream of a frontier-free Community will be lost. 
 US cancer experts win Nobel prize 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Luxembourg 
 STOCKHOLM (AP) &mdash; The US cancer researchers Michael Bishop and Harold Varmus won the Nobel Prize for medicine yesterday, for helping to explain how malignant tumours begin. 
 The 50-member Nobel Assembly of the Karolinska Institute, Sweden's largest and oldest medical university, awarded the researchers the prize &bquo;for their discovery of the cellular origin of retroviral oncogenes&equo;. 
 Oncogenes control normal growth cells and their division. 
 The researchers showed cancer develops when the function of oncogenes is disturbed and cells grow without control, the Karolinska Institute said. 
 Dr Bishop, 53, and Dr Varmus, 49, work at the University of California School of Medicine in San Francisco, at the Department of Microbiology and Immunology. 
 Dr Varmus said he learned of the prize in an early morning call to his home from a radio reporter. 
 &bquo;I didn't know if it was false alarm or they got my name confused,&equo; he said. 
 Dr Varmus said winning the Nobel Prize was not in his mind when he and Dr Bishop published their research. 
 &bquo;I didn't go to work thinking about the Nobel Prize. 
 I go to work thinking about the next experiment,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Obviously, in the last few years when you look back and see that it had an impact in the field, then it becomes a possibility.&equo; 
 Dr Bishop said he was &bquo;stunned&equo; by the news. 
 At a news conference later yesterday he declined to speculate about a cancer cure. 
 &bquo;That's an imponderable at the moment,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Certainly we have a better image of what's wrong with the cancer cell at the moment.&equo; 
 In France meanwhile, Dominique Stehelin, a director of research for the National Centre for Scientific Research at the Pasteur Institute in Lille, said he should have shared in the prize. 
 Dr Stehelin said he worked for Dr Bishop and Dr Varmus in their San Francisco laboratory between 1972 and 1975, and was the principal signer of the first article in the scientific magazine Nature, in 1976, that said a cancer virus was causing cancer by means of a gene it had captured from normal cells. 
 Dr Bishop and Dr Varmus called Dr Stehelin's work &bquo;crucial&equo; to their research, but referred questions about the prize to the Nobel committee. 
 &bquo;We didn't nominate each other,&equo; Dr Varmus said. 
 The regulation and growth of cells was much more complicated than originally believed, and so far more than 40 different types of oncogenes have been discovered in experiments using retroviruses, said the assembly citation. 
 It said viruses or chemical substances, such as those found in tobacco smoke, can disrupt this growth-control mechanism. 
 Gosta Gahrton, a member of the Nobel Assembly, said the clinical application of the discovery was still being explored, but he predicted that &bquo;an enormous field will be opened. 
 We now have the possibility to analyse the cause of cancer in a much more precise way, because we now know that the cause of cancer is within ourselves&equo;. 
 Professor Gahrton said the research had facilitated the diagnosis of some types of cancer, including leukemia. 
 Based on the breakthrough, researchers were working to develop new medicines that would specifically target certain kinds of cancer. 
 France takes a green lead on Antarctica's fate 
 From SARAH LAMBERT in Paris 
 THE FUTURE of Antarctica turns on the outcome of an international conference which Michel Rocard, the French Prime Minister, opened yesterday with a speech that set the tone for what will be a fiercely political debate. 
 In urging delegates to &bquo;work on a comprehensive regime for protecting the Antarctic which, in my view, should take the form of a &bquo;nature reserve&equo;, ' Mr Rocard threw his weight firmly behind the environmentalists who believe the commercial exploitation of the mineral reserves of &bquo;the world's last true wilderness&equo; must be stopped. 
 &bquo;It is no longer enough merely to acknowledge the facts&hellip; and to hope that science will solve by itself the problems that it is creating. 
 The time has come for the politicians to face up to their responsibilities,&equo; Mr Rocard said. 
 For the delegates to the 15th meeting of parties to the Antarctic Treaty, the main topic of discussion over the next 10 days will be the status of an agreement &mdash; the Convention on the Regulation of Antarctic Mineral Resource Activities &mdash; which collapsed in the summer after the French and Australian governments decided, in consultation with each other, to withdraw their support. 
 Their action effectively scuppered six years of negotiations, since all decisions taken by the 22 signatories to the 1959 Washington Treaty &mdash; the framework for the political and environmental protection of Antarctica - must be unanimous. 
 Ranged against the French, the Australians and their Belgian and Italian supporters are the US, New Zealand, Japan and the UK, which believe that exploitation of Antarctica is inevitable and that to ensure the environment is properly protected, it is vital that commercial activities be legally regulated. 
 The latter camp took heart yesterday from Mr Rocard's insistence that any decision must be based on a consensus, but realise that they have a tough fight ahead persuading others of the logic of their arguments. 
 Greenpeace, the World Wildlife Fund, the Cousteau Foundation and other organisations have been very successful in mobilising public opinion in favour of designating Antarctica a &bquo;World Park&equo;, outlawing commercial exploitation of mineral resources, and limiting scientific research and tourism to better protect the region's flora and fauna. 
 While their representatives in Paris doubt the conference delegates will discard the Minerals Convention, they are confident that they, for the moment, occupy the moral high ground. 
 Hole in ozone layer over Antartica getting bigger 
 By DAVID BARBER 
 WELLINGTON &mdash; The hole in the ozone layer over Antarctica threatens to be bigger than ever this year, according to New Zealand scientists, writes David Barber. 
 It is already as big as the previous record in 1987, when half the ozone over the Antarctic disappeared between late September and late November. 
 &bquo;This means a colossal amount of ozone has disappeared in the last few weeks,&equo; Bill Jeffries, New Zealand's Minister in charge of the Meteorological Service, said yesterday. 
 Scientists had thought weather patterns would reduce the size of the hole over the next few years. 
 He said there was already 10 per cent more chlorine &mdash; which mainly comes from chlorofluorocarbons chemicals (CFCs) in aerosol sprays and refrigeration equipment and is the main cause of the ozone hole &mdash; in the stratosphere than two years ago. 
 China hits at Hong Kong by blocking repatriation 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 CHINA used a seven-year-old immigration agreement with Hong Kong yesterday to show its annoyance over the colony's support for the Peking democracy movement. 
 It was a further example of Peking's present heavy-handed approach towards Hong Kong, and stemmed from the colonial government's decision not to return swimmer Yang Yang to China last week, but to allow him to leave for asylum in the United States. 
 China refused to accept back 71 people who entered Hong Kong illegally and accused the colony of reneging on a 1982 agreement on immigration policy. 
 Normally the &bquo;illegals&equo; are handed back to China on the border almost daily, but Peking now says it will check each case, a move expected to slow repatriation to a trickle and put further pressure on the Territory's detention centres, which are already overflowing with Vietnamese boat people. 
 More than 12,000 Chinese &bquo;illegals&equo; have flooded across Hong Kong's border this year. 
 Peking had warned that &bquo;Hong Kong would be held responsible for all consequences of the (Yang Yang) affair&equo; by allowing the swimmer, a supporter of the student-led democracy movement, to seek asylum in America. 
 The latest move comes a day after Ke Zaishuo, the senior Peking representative to the Joint Liaison Group &mdash; the Anglo-Chinese body overseeing Hong Kong's return to mainland sovereignty in 1997 &mdash; blamed Britain for the crisis of confidence in the territory after the Chinese army assault on Tiananmen Square. 
 Mr Ke said Whitehall had &bquo;connived&equo; with a &bquo;handful&equo; of Hong Kong people who attempted to sabotage and overthrow the Chinese government. 
 He used the same language as that employed by the Chinese government to explain away the unrest that the democracy movement unleashed in May and June &mdash; namely that it was the work of a &bquo;handful of evil-doers&equo;. 
 Martin Lee, an outspoken campaigner for democracy in Hong Kong before it is handed over, said: &bquo;China has declared war on the people of Hong Kong. 
 This (comment) just goes to show that either the Chinese leadership is totally insensitive to the feelings here or they don't care what happens anymore.&equo; 
 The Foreign Office dismissed the conspiracy allegation. 
 &bquo;There is no evidence that Hong Kong is used as a base for activities against the Chinese government,&equo; a spokesman said. 
 Hong Kong's main political groups yesterday reached final agreement on the pace of future democratic reforms, raising the prospect of further acrimony between Britain and China. 
 The agreement, between conservatives, moderates and liberals, calls for 40 per cent of the legislature to be directly elected by 1997, and 60 per cent by 2001. 
 Peking has so far agreed to only a quarter of legislators being directly elected by 1997, and has condemned supporters of a full democracy. 
 Six hanged in Sierra Leone for coup plot 
 From Our Correspondent in Freetown 
 SIX MEN, including a former vice-president convicted of treason and murder in the 1987 coup attempt in Sierra Leone, have been hanged at Pademba Road prison in Freetown. 
 The executions began at midnight on Saturday and were completed six and a half hours later. 
 Instead of being buried at Rokupa cemetery, as is the normal custom with state criminals, the six were buried elsewhere at state expense. 
 Unlike other occasions, no bodies were displayed. 
 The state-run Sierra Leone broadcasting service and newspapers confirmed the executions, and reports from Freetown suggested there was widespread shock that President Joseph Momoh had chosen not to exercise his prerogative of mercy. 
 The coup attempt in March 1987 was foiled when explosives, army uniforms, arms, a rocket launcher and Sierra Leone currency were found in a raid by security officers in a house in Freetown. 
 Police of the Special Security Division came under fire, and one was killed. 
 The plotters, led by Gabriel &bquo;GMT&equo; Kai Kai, a former police officer, were arrested. 
 Police also arrested Francis Minnah, then First Vice-President, who was accused of being behind the coup attempt. 
 Like the others, Mr Minnah was of the Mende tribe, and an associate of the previous president, Dr Siaka Stevens. 
 His election campaigns were notorious for their cruelty &mdash; he often made sure that those who did not vote for him would never vote again &mdash; but the depth of his involvement has never been clear. 
 After a four-and-a-half-month trial and several appeals, four of the 16 accused were released. 
 The six condemned to death, with another six who were sentenced to life imprisonment, went to the Supreme Court, whose five judges unanimously dismissed their appeals. 
 Their sentences were confirmed on 29 September. 
 &bquo;The Committee of the Prerogative of Mercy considered all the sentences and advised the President accordingly,&equo; the authorities announced. 
 President Momoh has rarely made such a controversial decision. 
 That he didso, even after appeals for clemency from abroad, including Britain and France, apparently indicates his concern at the threat posed by the abortive coup, and may presage further measures to demonstrate a firm hand. 
 The hanged men were Gabriel Mohammed Tennyson, Francis Misheck Minnah, Prince Kai Kai, Joseph John Harding, Daniel Suleiman Kai Kai and Conrad Innis. 
 The six sentenced to life imprisonment are David Abu Samu, Francis Massaquoi, Amara Alieu Tarawalie, Joseph Abiodun Williams, Hassan Morlai Conteh and Harunda Vandi Jimmy. 
 Pope meets President Suharto in Indonesia 
 From Our Correspondent in Freetown 
 Photograph (omitted): Pope John Paul talks to Indonesia's President Suharto at the Freedom Palace in Jakarta yesterday. 
 The Pope will visit four other cities during his five-day visit to the country 
 Fashion takes great leap backwards 
 From ANDREW HIGGINS in Peking 
 FORGET WHAT they might think in Paris and Milan: China's fashion commissars have decreed what is and is not stylish. 
 The boiler suit is back. 
 The colours to watch: revolutionary red, proletarian blue and grey. 
 In keeping with its drive to restore socialist purity and combat &bquo;counter-revolution&equo;, China yesterday unveiled a &bquo;new socialist look&equo; for the next spring and summer season. 
 According to Zhu Bingchen, director of the China Garment Research and Design Centre, &bquo;four types of garments will be trendy&equo;. 
 Inspired by their octogenarian leaders' nostalgia, fashion designers are promising a return to the austere clothing of the 1950s, now hailed as the high-water mark of the revolutionary tradition of &bquo;bitter struggle and hard living&equo;. 
 Such garments, Mr Zhu insists, will recall this golden age of Chinese socialism when people &bquo;worked hard and were always in high spirits&equo;. 
 Eschewing the Western suit and tie and flamboyant clothes from Hong Kong, the new line features the standard Mao suit and what the official New China News Agency describes as &bquo;Lenin's small V-neck look&equo;. 
 Central planners uncomfortable with the confusion and uncertainty of the market-place will also be pleased to learn that the consumer will have little say in what he wears: &bquo;Various shades of red, blue and grey will be in favour,&equo; the agency announced. 
 A second line of clothing is less dreary and perhaps slightly more attuned to what people might actually want to wear. 
 But it too carries a heavy moral message. 
 Patterned on what athletes will be wearing to the 11th Asian Games in Peking next year, it includes sportswear, jackets and close-fitting suits: &bquo;The vigorous clothes will help build the atmosphere of the Asian Games and encourage people to get more exercise to promote health,&equo; the agency predicted. 
 A third theme will be nature, or as Mr Zhu put it, &bquo;people's desire for tranquility, harmony and purity&equo;. 
 Finally, next year's fashions make a token nod in the direction of China's open door policy by including &bquo;elegant foreign fashions&equo;. 
 There will be little room, however, for more daring creations from the now reviled capitalist West. 
 According to Mr Zhu, the foreign inspiration will be limited to &bquo;subdued and relaxed fashion with lace trim&equo;. 
 If previous attempts to dictate dress are anything to go by, sartorial discipline may hold in the Politburo, but the decree will have little immediate impact in the street. 
 The last great campaign to revise social style &mdash; the so-called anti-spiritual pollution drive six years ago - petered out after only a few months when even the party leadership acknowledged it had more important things to worry about than enforcing short hair and dreary clothes. 
 Pretoria gives way over Namibia poll 
 From LEONARD DOYLE in New York 
 A BLATANT attempt by South Africa to dictate the terms of next month's elections in Namibia has been reversed after months of tough negotiations with the United Nations. 
 Both sides have agreed on a new electoral law which guarantees secret balloting and an immediate count. 
 There is still disagreement on how long the UN military forces (Untag) and other UN monitors should remain in Namibia after the elections. 
 South Africa has said it expects the UN to reduce its 4,000-strong military presence once the poll is over and a Constituent Assembly has been elected to draft a new constitution. 
 But the UN is under pressure from church groups and from Swapo and other parties to keep a strong military presence beyond the six-month deadline the Security Council has decreed. 
 South African forces in Namibia have been cut from the 40,000 there on 1 April, at the beginning of the independence plan, to a token 1,500. 
 But a report to the Security Council by the UN Secretary-General, Javier Perez de Cuellar, makes clear that the many former members of the defence forces, as well as counter-insurgency units &mdash; the notorious Koevoet in particular - though officially demobilised, are still on South Africa's payroll. 
 Mr Perez de Cuellar described South Africa's attempt to interfere with the elections as &bquo;highly problematical&equo;, and announced new procedures for the vote, over four days beginning on 7 November. 
 South Africa's Administrator-General, Louis Pienaar, had proposed that all ballots be cast in numbered envelopes, which could be traced after the elections, and that the count should be conducted in the capital, Windhoek, over as long as five weeks. 
 He also wanted voters to have the right to cast their ballots anywhere in Namibia, rather than in towns and villages where voters can be recognised, and to keep the tallymen from Namibia's political parties away from the polling stations and from places where votes would be counted. 
 The procedures were agreed after acrimonious discussion with South Africa's UN Ambassador, Jeremy Shearar, and with Mr Pienaar in Namibia. 
 There will be numbered envelopes, but standard sealed ballot boxes. 
 All voters' hands will be dyed with indelible ink, and both the vote and the count will be conducted locally. 
 WINDHOEK &mdash; Namibian campaign violence could end the independence process, Mr Pienaar said yesterday, AFP reports. 
 Mr Pienaar's spokesman said: &bquo;The Administrator-General is very disturbed that with the evidence at our disposal we realise that a situation could be building up which could lead to the ultimate defeat of the aims and objectives of Resolution 435.&equo; 
 Court Circular 
 From LEONARD DOYLE in New York 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 9 October: The Queen was represented by Major John Henderson at the Memorial Service for Colonel the Hon Sir Gordon Palmer which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, this afternoon. 
 The Duke of Edinburgh was represented by Marshal of the Royal Air Force Sir John Grandy. 
 The Duke and Duchess of York was represented by Major William McLean. 
 The Princess Royal was represented by Lieutenant-Colonel Peter Gibbs. 
 9 October: The Princess Royal this morning arrived at Glasgow Airport and was received on arrival by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Renfrewshire (Major JDM Crichton Maitland). 
 Her Royal Highness subsequently arrived at Enmore Hotel, Kirn, and was received by Colonel RM Campbell-Preston (Vice Lord-Lieutenant for Argyll and Bute). 
 The Princess Royal, President, Riding for the Disabled Association, later attended a show given by the Dunoon and Cowal Branch of the Association at Dunnon. 
 Afterwards Her Royal Highness attended the European Sheep and Wool Centre, Lochgoilhead and opened the Drimsynie Holiday Village, Lochgoilhead. 
 The Princess Royal, attended by Mrs Timothy Holderness-Roddam, travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 CLARENCE HOUSE 9 October: Queen Elizabeth The Queen Mother was represented by Sir Martin Gilliat at the Memorial Service for Colonel the Hon Sir Gordon Palmer which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle this afternoon. 
 Miss Alexandra Loyd and Lieutenant-Commander Patrick Jephson RN were in attendance. 
 The Princess of Wales attended the Memorial Service for Colonel the Hon Sir Gordon Palmer which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, this afternoon. 
 The Prince of Wales was represented by Mr Gerald Ward. 
 9 October: The Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon, Patron of The Northern Ballet Theatre, this morning visited the Company at their Studios in Zion Crescent, Hulme, Manchester. 
 Her Royal Highness, who travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight, was attended by Mrs Jane Stevens. 
 The Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon was represented by the Hon Mrs Wills at the Memorial Service for Colonel the Hon Sir Gordon Palmer which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, this afternoon. 
 9 October: Princess Alice, Duchess of Gloucester and The Duke and Duchess of Gloucester were represented by Lieutenant-Colonel Sir Simon Bland at the Memorial Service for Colonel the Hon Sir Gordon Palmer which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, this afternoon. 
 YORK HOUSE 9 October: The Duchess of Kent this morning attended the launch of Tears and Smiles &mdash; The Hospice Handbook by Martyn Lewis at British Telecom Tower, London W1. 
 Her Royal Highness was attended by Miss Sarah Partridge. 
 The Duke and Duchess of Kent were represented by Mr Andrew Palmer at the Memorial Service for Colonel the Hon Sir Gordon Palmer which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, this afternoon. 
 THATCHED HOUSE LODGE 9 October: Princess Alexandra, attended by Lady Mary Mumford, arrived at Heathrow Airport this afternoon in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight upon the conclusion of the visit to Monserrat and the British Virgin Islands. 
 Her Royal Highness was represented by Sir Angus Ogilvy at the Memorial Service for Colonel the Hon Sir Gordon Palmer which was held in St George's Chapel, Windsor Castle, this afternoon. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Princess of Wales, Patron, RELATE, attends the premiere of Shirley Valentine at the Empire, Leicester Square, London WC2. 
 The Duchess of York, President of Action Research for the Crippled Child, visits the Duncan Guthrie Institute at the Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Glasgow; and this afternoon, as Patron of Museums Year 1989, opens the Customs and Excise Museum and Exhibition at Custom House, Greenock, Glasgow. 
 Prince Edward attends a performance of Buddy in aid of the Sharon Allen Leukaemia Trust at the Victoria Palace Theatre, London SW1. 
 The Princess Royal visits the Elizabeth Foundation, Southwick Hill Road, Cosham; attends the Centenary Service of Thanksgiving at St Mary's Church, Portsea, Portsmouth; opens Whitbread Brewery's new depot at Hedge End, Southampton; opens the hostel at Sparsholt College, Winchester; this evening, as President, The Save the Children Fund, attends a Save the Children Fund Industry and Commerce Group Reception at Buckingham Palace for Patrons of the 70th Anniversary Training Appeal; and, as President, Engineers for Disaster Relief, attends a Dinner at the Institution of Civil Engineers, Great George Street, London SW1. 
 The Duchess of Gloucester, Patron, Asthma Research Council, opens the Allergy and Allied Respiratory Disorders Department at Guy's Hospital, London SE1. 
 The Duke and The Duchess of Kent attend a Gala in aid of the CPRE at the Royal Festival Hall, London SE1. 
 The ballerina Lydia Lopokova, pencil on card, 1919, by Pablo Picasso, which has been acquired by the Fitzwilliam Museum, in Cambridge. 
 By JOANNA GIBBON 
 The ballerina Lydia Lopokova, pencil on card, 1919, by Pablo Picasso, which has been acquired by the Fitzwilliam Museum, in Cambridge. 
 This is one of three drawings of Lopokova by Picasso, the latter having come to London for the first time to work on designs and sets for Massine's Le Tricorne, writes Joanna Gibbon. 
 Picasso also made a series of studies of Lopokova and Massine in the can-can for Massine's Boutique Fantasque. 
 The painter's interest in ballet was stimulated by his affair with one of Diaghilev's dancers, Olga Koklova, whom he later married. 
 Lydia Lopokova (1891-1981) studied ballet at the Imperial Ballet School in St Petersburg, joined the Diaghilev Company in 1910 and remained with it until it was disbanded in 1929. 
 She was renowned for her character dancing, appearing in a production of The Sleeping Princess in 1921 as both Aurora and the Lilac Fairy. 
 With her husband, Maynard Keynes, she founded the Cambridge Arts Theatre in 1936. 
 The Fitzwilliam Museum bought the study, which is now on display, with help from the National Art Collections Fund, and a regional purchase grant from the Museums and Galleries Commission (administered by the Victoria &amp; Albert Museum). 
 Appointments 
 Gazette Page 20 
 Anniversaries 
 By JOANNA GIBBON 
 On this day: Lucius Plancus founded Lyons, 43 BC; rioters burnt down Nottingham Castle, 1831; Henry Morton Stanley met Dr Livingstone, Ujiji 1871; the Savoy Theatre opened with a performance of Patience by Gilbert and Sullivan, London 1881; Gershwin's Porgy and Bess opened in New York City, 1935; Tristan da Cunha islanders were evacuated following a volcanic eruption, 1961; the XVIIIth Olympic Games opened in Tokyo, 1964; Fiji became independent, 1970; Sir John Betjeman became Poet Laureate, 1972; Spiro Agnew resigned as US Vice-President after being fined &dollar;10,000 for income tax evasion, 1973; in the General Election, Labour was returned with an overall majority of three, 1974. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 20 
 Obituary: Edmund Osmanczyk 
 By JAN CIECHANOWSKI 
 EDMUND OSMANCZYK was a versatile and accomplished author, journalist, parliamentarian and encyclopaedist who had a lifelong and unquenchable interest in international affairs. 
 He spent most of his professional life outside his native Poland, working as a foreign and diplomatic correspondent for the Polish media. 
 He worked in Europe, the USSR and North and Latin America and covered such important events as the storming of Berlin by the Russians and Poles in 1945, the Potsdam Conference, the Nuremberg Trials and many post-war Summit Conferences. 
 He was, par excellence, both Pole and European, looking forward eagerly to the day of the creation of a united Europe &mdash; to him the &bquo;motherland of motherlands&equo; &mdash; free from the control of or undue influence from the two super powers. 
 Born in 1913 in Silesia, the descendant of a Turkish soldier who had settled in Poland after being captured by the Poles at the Siege of Vienna in 1683, he was educated at a Gymnasium in Warsaw and at the Universities of Warsaw, Berlin and Bordeaux, where he studied history and journalism. 
 During the war he served in the Home Army, working for the clandestine radio show, and took part in the Warsaw rising of 1944, which he later described as &bquo;the most tragic of all Polish insurrections&equo;. 
 In January 1945 he was arrested in Krakow by the Gestapo but managed to escape from the transport taking him to a concentration camp. 
 Soon after the liberation of Poland he joined the Polish regular army as a war correspondent and eventually entered Berlin with the First Polish Infantry Division. 
 From the publication, in 1946, of his book The Affairs of the Poles Osmanczyk's constant call was for Polish-German reconciliation as one of the essential steps towards the creation of a new, permanently conflict-free Europe. 
 He rightly felt that in the age of nuclear weapons any future war in Europe would be an act of suicide and so from 1956 he appealed repeatedly for an improvement in East-West relations and for super-power disengagement in the continent's central heartland. 
 He also strove staunchly to strengthen relations between the Poles living in Poland and those scattered abroad in the 13-million-strong Polish diaspora &mdash; links which had been almost destroyed during the Cold War period by Communist authorities, oblivious to their potential value to both sides. 
 Throughout the Seventies and Eighties &mdash; following his final return from postings abroad to work in Poland &mdash; he was a determined champion of human and civic rights for all his fellow citizens, regardless of political or religious affiliations, and an untiring advocate of political and economic reform. 
 A long-standing independent member of the Polish Parliament &mdash; the Sejm &mdash; he often used this position as a platform from which to criticise the Government and the ruling Party. 
 He fought for the introduction of a free press, the right of everyone to travel freely, a sound convertible currency and the right to existence of a Polish opposition. 
 He knew that these were the essential ingredients of political and economic stability in Poland and that two of them &mdash; political opposition and a free press &mdash; were the only real guarantees against Government abuse of power. 
 He was energetic in the struggle for Solidarity and finished his parliamentary career as a Solidarity-sponsored senator (for his native Silesia) in the newly re-established Senate to which he was elected last summer. 
 Osmanczyk wrote a number of useful and influential works, in Polish, Spanish and English, on Polish and international affairs. 
 The most important of these was his thousand-page Encyclopaedia of the United Nations and International Agreements, published in Philadelphia in 1985, of which he produced editions in all three languages. 
 He was justifiably proud of this splendid work which he rightly considered to be his main literary achievement. 
 At the time of his death he had just completed a second, much fuller edition, to be published in 1990. 
 Obituary: Aubrey Boomer 
 By CHRISTOPHER PLUMRIDGE 
 AUBREY BOOMER was the last surviving member of the Great Britain and Ireland Ryder Cup team which contested the first match against the Americans in 1927. 
 The son of a professor, Boomer became interested in golf when he watched the six-times Open Champion Harry Vardon, whose birthplace he shared, playing in Jersey during the First World War. 
 Boomer chose to pursue his career in France and he and his brother, Percy, became the professionals at the fashionable St Cloud club, just outside Paris. 
 Golf on the Continent in the 1920s was very much a pastime for the rich, whereas in Britain professionals were employed by clubs as low-paid servants: across the Channel they were regarded as the social equals of the members they served, by virtue of their skill at the game. 
 Aubrey Boomer's tournament career was also confined to the Continent, where he was extremely successful, winning the French Open a record five times between 1921 and 1931, the Belgian Open twice, the Dutch Open twice and the Italian Open once. 
 He challenged for the Open Championship on one occasion, in 1927 at St Andrews, when he was unfortunate enough to run into Bobby Jones at his best. 
 The American set a new record aggregate of 285 and Boomer shared second place, six strokes behind. 
 Boomer was a handsome man with a great deal of charm and became the favourite professional of the rich who visited Paris, playing with such luminaries as Sir Philip Sassoon, who rewarded Boomer by having suits made up for him from Savile Row. 
 This kind of treatment caused resentment among the petty-minded officialdom which ran the British professional game, and when Boomer was chosen for the 1927 Ryder Cup team he was picked up at Cherbourg en route to America and made to wear what every Frenchman was supposed to wear &mdash; a beret. 
 The crossing took almost a week and those team members who were not seasick practised hitting shots on board, timing their swings with the roll of the ship. 
 On arrival at Worcester, Massachusetts, for the match, the earth was still moving for the British side and they lost nine-and-a-half to two-and-a-half, with Boomer winning his foursomes in partnership with his friend Archie Compston, but losing his single. 
 Boomer was selected again for the 1929 match, which took place at Moortown, Leeds, and was made vice-captain under George Duncan. 
 He played his part in a famous British victory, winning his single, having lost in the foursome. 
 This was to be Boomer's last appearance in the Ryder Cup, although he was still quite clearly a good enough player to hold his own against the best of the Americans. 
 The British penchant for shooting themselves in the foot emerged again when officials decided that professionals who resided and worked outside Britain were ineligible to play, although they qualified by birth. 
 This move was based purely on jealousy, as professionals on the Continent enjoyed a far higher standard of living than their British-based counterparts. 
 The rule also affected Henry Cotton, who took up the post at Royal Waterloo, Belgium, in 1933 and thus missed two Ryder Cup matches when he was at the peak of his powers. 
 Aubrey Boomer also held the post at Royal Waterloo and subsequently moved to the Royal Golf Club de Belgique at Ravenstein. 
 He was due to attend this year's Ryder Cup match at The Belfry, but illness prevented him. 
 His death means that the American Gene Sarazen is the only survivor of that first Ryder Cup match 62 years ago. 
 Obituary: Professor Bernard Harris 
 By JOHN ROE 
 BERNARD HARRIS, formerly Professor of English at York University, was a gentle and gentlemanly scholar of the school of Allardyce Nicoll, his Stratford mentor, a type which is sadly disappearing as universities enter a tougher phase. 
 A Renaissance scholar with a strong emphasis on English drama, he was active on the Board of Shakespeare Survey, to which he contributed articles on Elizabethan satire while co-editing with John Russell Brown the early volumes of the influential Stratford-upon-Avon Studies. 
 Harris was born at Henley-upon-Avon, but the family soon moved to Birmingham, where he was later to become associated with the Shakespeare Institute. 
 He took his BA at Birmingham in 1948, and followed this with an MA (on James Shirley) in 1952. 
 Nicoll appointed him a fellow of the Shakespeare Institute in 1953. 
 Harris came to York in 1963 as the first lecturer appointed to the English Department by the founding professor Philip Brockbank. 
 They quickly recruited others and soon established a formidable department which based its teaching on a principle of direct engagement with the student. 
 Harris rose to the position of full professor at York in 1971. 
 His literary interests were remarkably wide and his expertise ranged from Anglo-Irish writing to Silver Age Latin epigrammatists; but he published mainly on seventeenth-century comic or satirical dramatists, as his editions of Marston's Malcontent and Vanbrugh's Relapse testify. 
 His own wit was ruefully amiable. 
 Once when we were both contributing to The Year's Work in English Studies (he on Renaissance drama), I met him in the library and expressed anxiety about the deadline. 
 &bquo;I've missed it too,&equo; he said reassuringly; then, more reassuringly, &bquo;but I'm unrepentant.&equo; 
 True to the York principle his commitment was entirely to the person, sometimes causing exasperation to administrators. 
 An undergraduate met by chance on the campus walkway might be treated to one of his brilliant, spontaneous tutorials, the kind normally only dreamt about, while a group of colleagues over whose meeting he was to preside gazed at an empty chair. 
 Conducting a graduate seminar on the unpromising topic of textual variants he would hold the room spellbound for two hours by his unforced erudition. 
 He was the possessor of learning which he shared unselfishly with his students, making them feel it was just as much theirs as his. 
 More of his scholarship should have found its way into print, but persistent illness, latterly reinforced by family tragedy, cruelly intervened and compelled his early retirement. 
 Yet if his ideas and perceptions did not always reach the page, they undoubtedly entered the minds and imaginations of the many lucky enough to converse with him. 
 Obituary: Rollo Silver 
 By RUARI MCLEAN 
 Rollo Silver, librarian and printing historian, born New York 1909, married Alice Gindin, died Boston 20 September 1989. 
 For this, he had an odd background. 
 Born in 1909 in New York City to parents who were members of the Ethical Society, he went to a school run by the Society where, under distinguished teachers, he ended up with little knowledge of even how to write correctly. 
 Never mind: he taught himself and entered Brown University, Rhode Island, a Baptist foundation. 
 When he wrote a letter to the college newspaper criticising the compulsory chapels and boring sermons, he was expelled. 
 But when someone wrote letters on his behalf to The New York Times he was quickly reinstated by the university president, and graduated in 1931. 
 During the Depression Silver sold china and glass in Fifth Avenue, worked a petrol pump, and sold cigarettes wholesale; but all this time he was collecting Walt Whitman; he also studied for a Master's degree in English at Boston University, which he was awarded in 1941. 
 Then in 1941 America entered the war. 
 When the US army discovered that Silver had been engaged in research work (on Whitman) he was put to personally testing the durability of uniforms, in sub-zero and boiling temperatures, artificial rain storms in laboratories and real tropical conditions in Florida: he soon became an assistant director of this project and stayed there for two years. 
 Then, in pursuance of his interest in Whitman and others, he decided to study to become a librarian. 
 In 1953 he became Assistant Professor and in 1957 Professor of Library Science at Simmons College in Boston, where he remained until 1965. 
 One of his students at Simmons was the daughter of Frank Francis, Director of the British Museum, and this led to close contacts with the printing and publishing world in Britain. 
 From 1957 Rollo and his wife Alice came to London every year, where he was elected an honorary member of the Double Crown Club (whom he addressed, on WA Dwiggins) and the Wynkyn de Worde Society. 
 Friendships made in this country were warmly reciprocated by the Silvers in their beautiful old house in Mt Vernon Street in Boston, where they lived an elegant and &bquo;simple&equo; life: they never owned a car, and never cooked in their kitchen; all meals except breakfast were eaten in restaurants. 
 Rollo loved being taken to the gilt and plush ambience of Rules in Covent Garden, to which his riposte was Lock-Obers in Boston, which he protested was not so good. 
 Rollo Silver was old-fashioned in the best of ways, and a warm friend of the book world. 
 Correction: Obituary: Mark Dignam 
 By MARGARET WOLFIT 
 MAY I correct a mistake in Ossia Trilling's Obituary of Mark Dignam (5 October)? writes Margaret Wolfit. 
 Rosalind Iden was not (to my knowledge) at Sheffield Repertory Company. 
 It was my mother Chris Castor, a fine actress, who was leading lady there and gave Mark Dignam lessons in elocution. 
 She had trained under Kate Rorke at the Guildhall, where she won the silver medal for elocution. 
 Obituary: Albert Geldard 
 By MARGARET WOLFIT 
 Albert Geldard, footballer, died Bury, Lancashire aged 75. 
 He shared (with Ken Roberts of Wrexham) the distinction of being the youngest Football League player when he appeared for Bradford Park Avenue against Millwall 60 years ago aged 15 years, 158 days. 
 Later won four England caps. 
 Obituary: Canon Hugh Pickles 
 By GERALD HOWAT 
 HUGH PICKLES was one of life's enthusiasts and eccentrics. 
 Cricket, he claimed, was his second religion, but his first won him the loyalty and affection of generations, whether the staff and pupils of Worksop College, of which he was chaplain, or his parishioners at Blewbury in Oxfordshire, of which he was vicar from 1964 until his death, five days before he was due to retire. 
 His canonry was not of Oxford but of Kobe, of the Anglican Church in Japan, but it was the Oxford Diocesan Clergy Cricket side which he captained and ran for 25 years. 
 Three weeks before his death he received the Church Times Cup when Oxford beat Rochester in the Final. 
 Only a year earlier he had performed his last hat-trick. 
 His skills as a coach (the England player Philip Sharpe was one of his discoveries), his knowledge of players, his presence at cricket's great occasions and his ability to entice the great and the famous to play for his occasional XIs combined to make him, in his own way, one of the game's celebrities. 
 Health Update: Impure cheek 
 By OLIVIA TIMBS 
 WEDDINGS may be hazardous for guests, according to an anonymous report in The Lancet. 
 The author considers the risks of kissing the bride at the reception and argues that the vogue for &bquo;continental&equo; kissing means the risk of contracting a bug from a fellow guest, via the bride's cheek, is considerable. 
 The author suggests you should either make sure you are near the front of the receiving line &bquo;or, before applying the lips, wipe the bride's cheeks gently with a dilute solution of hypochlorite&equo;. 
 From personal experience, the greater hazard may be for the bride. 
 After a reception for nearly 150 guests, my right cheek was red and raw: a result of male guests who had failed to have an afternoon shave. 
 Health Update: Anxious patients 
 By OLIVIA TIMBS 
 PEOPLE suffering from terminal cancer are understandably depressed and anxious during their treatment. 
 However, Sheila Payne, from the Department of Psychology, University of Exeter, has discovered that women being treated for breast or ovarian cancer were much more anxious half-way through their treatment than they had been at the beginning. 
 Sheila Payne suggests a number of reasons for this: the side effects of the drugs become more distressing; patients are aware that they will have to go through further courses of similar treatment and feel gloomy at the prospect; and they receive less support from health professionals than at the start. 
 Sheila Payne argues in Counselling Psychology that women would benefit from attention throughout their treatment &mdash; not just at the beginning. 
 Health Update: Dishwasher warning 
 By OLIVIA TIMBS 
 AUTOMATIC dishwasher detergents are an unrecognised hazard to children. 
 They work by creating a powerful alkaline solution which dislodges fats. 
 They are highly caustic and can cause terrible injuries to the throat and stomach if they are accidentally swallowed. 
 A report from Australia on children who had swallowed dishwasher detergent revealed that nearly half had been given the wrong advice and made to vomit. 
 This can cause even more damage to the throat if the lining is already damaged. 
 Medical advice should be sought as quickly as possible. 
 A commentator in The Lancet argues that detergents should be sold in child-resistant containers. 
 Parents should be aware that sludge left behind in the dispenser is highly concentrated and dangerous. 
 Health: The choice that allowed a life for Sophie: Pregnant at 37, Belinda Whiting decided against screening. 
 She explains why to Eileen Herzberg 
 By EILEEN HERZBERG 
 BELINDA WHITING gave birth to Sophie, a baby with Down's syndrome, 18 months ago. 
 Although Belinda was 37, she decided against amniocentesis or any other test to detect chromosomal abnormalities. 
 She wanted her baby, did not want to run the risk of a miscarriage and would not have considered an abortion. 
 &bquo;I don't understand how people can abort a wanted child. 
 How we can legally do away with children like Sophie,&equo; Belinda explains. 
 &bquo;It seems a terrible arrogance to abort a baby because you believe it isn't good enough.&equo; 
 Belinda had made a conscious decision to have a baby and felt that it was important to keep healthy by eating well and exercising during her pregnancy. 
 &bquo;I felt I was doing everything I could to nourish and protect the baby and I was so sure about the rightness of it all that I didn't want a scan. 
 I didn't want any intervention. 
 &bquo;I knew that whatever I was producing, I was meant to have: that somehow we had chosen each other. 
 Throughout the pregnancy, I sensed there was nothing wrong with the baby; that it was very strong, healthy and right.&equo; 
 But despite all the careful preparation, the birth turned out to be difficult and traumatic and Sophie was finally born with the help of forceps. 
 Belinda says: &bquo;I remember looking at her clearly for the first time, searching for that visual connection with my family or her father's, some genetic connection to identify myself with her, but seeing instead that otherness &mdash; the look of a stranger. 
 &bquo;From the eyes, the ears, the shape of the head, we knew immediately. 
 My heart sank and numbness took over. 
 I kept thinking: &bquo;This isn't real. 
 Tomorrow I shall wake up from the dream.&equo; 
 ' The initial shock was distressing, but after a night's sleep, nature's chemistry had wrought its miracle and Belinda fell completely in love with her daughter. 
 &bquo;I felt high for about four days, not thinking about anything but caring for her.&equo; 
 As an anxious new father, Belinda's partner, Jem, read everything he could find about Down's syndrome because he wanted to know what he could expect from the future. 
 For Belinda, looking after Sophie was the only way she knew how to deal with the shock. 
 &bquo;I couldn't bear to think of the future, of what would happen to her when we got old, if we got ill, when we died, or worse &mdash; whether she would only live a few years,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;At moments it seemed overwhelming.&equo; 
 Wrapped up in the everyday business of looking after her newborn baby, Belinda felt fine: she could cope for a few days. 
 Then she would explode with grief and anger. 
 &bquo;What seemed so hard at the beginning was the limitation that calling her Down's and handicapped would have on her new life. 
 Nothing could be done to alter what felt like a sentence.&equo; 
 With no escape route, Belinda was forced to take a long, hard look at herself, re-evaluating expectations for herself as well as Sophie. 
 Forced to face up to her own fears and failed expectations, it was as if Belinda had to deal with two babies: one was the theoretical idea of a baby with Down's syndrome, the other was Sophie herself. 
 She says: &bquo;Experiencing the reality of this very wonderful little human being makes a mockery of any disappointment that could have been felt in her. 
 She has been a delight from the beginning, not only to us, but to all the friends and relatives who have met her. 
 She gives out so much and has so much to teach us.&equo; 
 Coming to terms with the idea that Sophie is different, Belinda finds making comparisons with so-called normal children increasingly meaningless: &bquo;There is nothing abnormal about Sophie. 
 She is different, yes, but we see that difference as a uniqueness peculiar to her. 
 She has her own purpose and we are very proud to have her in our lives to love.&equo; 
 Like so many women of her age, Belinda wanted her baby very much and felt that it was a miracle when she became pregnant. 
 Because of her age, she had a one in 180 chance of carrying a baby with Down's, yet she was not unusual in deciding against having an amniocentesis. 
 Half the women whose age &mdash; 36 plus &mdash; puts them at relatively high risk of carrying a Down's syndrome child, also refuse amniocentesis. 
 Either they do not want to run the risk of miscarriage (about one in 100-200) which the procedure entails; or they would not want a termination even if the baby was found to be disabled. 
 Few people would wish to deny a woman's right to know whether the baby she is carrying is disabled, and to decide &mdash; with counselling if needed - whether she wants to have it. 
 But what seems to be in question is the right to choose otherwise &mdash; to refuse the procedures used to detect abnormality. 
 Many doctors assume that if Down's is spotted, termination is the only &bquo;sensible&equo; thing to do, what all women will want. 
 Describing a new screening programme to detect Down's in the foetus at a London hospital, the British Medical Journal (8 October 1988) claims that it could &bquo;detect 60 per cent of affected pregnancies&hellip; and could reduce the number of children born with Down's syndrome in the United Kingdom from about 900 a year to about 350 a year&equo;. 
 This assumes that all the women who are found to be carrying a child with Down's syndrome will want to terminate their pregnancies. 
 Will children with Down's syndrome become an endangered species? 
 Should doctors always be so keen to offer abortion as the only solution to women who are in the first throes of disappointment and depression at the news that their baby is not genetically perfect? 
 Dawn Winterhalder was 32 and expecting her fourth child when she developed hydramnios &mdash; excess fluid in the womb &mdash; and her gynaecologist became seriously concerned about the baby's health. 
 She was 22 weeks pregnant when doctors discovered that her baby had Down's. 
 Dawn recalls: &bquo;The consultant assumed I would terminate the pregnancy. 
 He suggested abortion two or three times and made it very clear that he thought I was making a mistake. 
 He said it was a devastating mental handicap: &bquo;You'll find her a terrible burden on your life and your family. 
 Are you sure you are making the right decision?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fortunately I was strong, but had I been weak, I might have given in. 
 I think it's very sad, to have a terribly negative view put to you when you are in a vulnerable situation. 
 &bquo;Now we've got Rebecca she's a delight. 
 We expect little and get a lot. 
 I really don't see a handicap as a handicap, I just enjoy Becky for who she is and what she is.&equo; 
 Odds against a Down's syndrome baby The risk of having a Down's syndrome baby: if you are 25 is one in 1,500; if you are 30 is one in 800; if you are 35 is one in 300; if you are 40 is one in 100; if you are 45 is one in 30. 
 Health: Happiness is born-again hugging: Simon Denison joins a rebirthing weekend and weeps with two hundred apprentices in loving relationships 
 By SIMON DENISON 
 THE LOVING Relationships Training began to the sound of Albinoni's Adagio. 
 Two hundred people were milling about the room; 20 or 30 of them were hugging each other in greeting. 
 &bquo;Do these people know each other?&equo; 
 I asked someone, shaking his hand. 
 &bquo;No, but they've done this before&equo; he replied, with a huge smile. 
 &bquo;You'll see, we do a lot of hugging this weekend.&equo; 
 He was right. 
 At the end of the training &mdash; a weekend seminar on the philosophy of Rebirthing &mdash; all 200 were in each other's arms, many crying with happiness. 
 An elderly English lady, with a tendency to pre-war propriety, who told me on the Friday that she was afraid it would all be &bquo;another load of pretentious American rubbish&equo;, said on Sunday that she had learned to open up for the first time in her life. 
 What on earth had happened? 
 Loving Relationships Training (LRT) sounds like &bquo;How to Find a Man and Keep Him&equo; women's magazine advice. 
 But at &pound;320 for the weekend, it is more expensive. 
 On a superficial level, there are similarities. 
 The weekend is a training in how to find and nurture the right sort of relationships with friends, parents, business, money, and especially sexual partners. 
 Rebirthing is a form of group psychotherapy, teaching participants how to eliminate the hang-ups that cause conflict and pain in our dealings with each other. 
 Developed in the Sixties in the United States by Sondra Ray, rebirthing has grown increasingly popular. 
 Thousands of people in Britain visit rebirthers every year. 
 At the start, we introduced ourselves: most were creative people or professionals, aged between 25 and 35. 
 About half said they were in stable relationships. 
 Less than a quarter claimed to be (or looked) miserable or confused. 
 Rebirthing, we were told, offered a superabundance of all good things with no sacrifice whatsoever. 
 You can have it all, we were told; even eternal life was promised. 
 The central tenet of rebirthing is that thought is creative and that our beliefs about ourselves are self-fulfilling: according to the trainers, a &bquo;beautiful&equo; American couple called Peter and Meg Kane, if we can think positively about ourselves and get rid of negative thoughts, we can eliminate our insecurities. 
 So if a man who has had an adolescent incestuous relationship with his mother now feels guilty about having close relationships with women, he is told that there is nothing wrong in loving women. 
 He must then affirm this, over and over again, until he begins to believe it. 
 There is nothing new about this. 
 According to Jenny Cousins, a psychologist and practising psychotherapist, teaching people to think themselves out of negative and erroneous beliefs about themselves is a standard psycho- therapeutic practice. 
 &bquo;It is absolutely as effective as anti-depressant drugs, if not more so.&equo; 
 The LRT method of shaking off destructive beliefs about ourselves brought with it an astonishing sense of joy. 
 Everyone had to admit what rebirthers call their &bquo;personal lie&equo; and affirm that the opposite &mdash; their &bquo;eternal law&equo; -was true. 
 People milled about the room, shaking hands, saying things like: &bquo;Hello, I'm Jane, and I have a right to be alive.&equo; 
 'Oh, that's great. 
 My name's Jonathan, and I am good enough.&equo; 
 Tears of happiness and laughter were pouring down everybody's cheeks. 
 One danger is that for some people everything might happen too quickly at a Loving Relationships Training weekend. 
 They might regress too far too soon, and there is no follow-up for LRT &bquo;graduates&equo;. 
 Neither is there any screening of precariously unstable people, who might be unable to cope with what comes up. 
 The weekend lost its appeal for me when it came to the fundamental rebirthing philosophy. 
 Traditional psychology from Freud onwards has held that what happens in the earliest years of childhood can affect our later perceptions of ourselves. 
 But the rebirthers take this further. 
 If a boy is born &bquo;breech&equo;, or bottom first, for instance, he may later believe that he does things the wrong way round; or because such births are painful for the mothers, he may decide that he hurts women. 
 A girl born with the umbilical cord twisted round her neck may feel that she always gets herself tied up in things. 
 Because beliefs about ourselves are self-fulfilling, these people will continue to find themselves in situations in which they can prove themselves right. 
 &bquo;It may sound plausible, but is it correct?&equo; asks Charlie Lewis, an academic psychologist at Reading University. 
 &bquo;I doubt whether babies have the software to be able to map these experiences on to their memory.&equo; 
 Rebirthing psychology also verges on the absurd in its extension of the idea that thought is creative. 
 To a rebirther, thought is always creative. 
 And the reverse is also true: namely that all events are created (only) by thought. 
 So if someone is mugged, raped, or injured, it is because he or she believed it would happen. 
 The rebirthers believe that positive thoughts can have similar effects. 
 The biggest nonsense is the belief that we can be physically immortal, if only we believe it. 
 &bquo;The only reason we die is that we think death is inevitable. 
 It is the greatest negative thought in the world,&equo; said the Kanes. 
 The centrepiece of the weekend was a &bquo;group rebirthing&equo;. 
 Lying in rows on the floor, we breathed deeply without pause, the idea being that we can cleanse our bodies of negative thoughts and that some, by actually reliving the experience of their birth, can release their first hang-ups. 
 Orthodox medical explanations of the process are less dramatic. 
 &bquo;If you breathe in and out like that you will definitely hyperventilate,&equo; says Jenny Cousins. 
 &bquo;It could be dangerous.&equo; 
 The lights were dimmed and the process started. 
 Breathing with the others, my heart began to beat very fast, and soon my fingertips were tingling.; eventually my whole body was filled by trembling. 
 The loud sound of 200 people breathing hard was soon punctuated by a woman beginning to sob, then howl. 
 Others started to join in. 
 Sometimes there were cries of pain, shouts of &bquo;I can't breathe&equo;, but mostly a loud and continuous din of sobbing from at least half the people in the room. 
 As each person began to cry, a rebirther helped to calm them down. 
 Eventually the room grew quiet. 
 Afterwards many people said this experience had been traumatic but positive. 
 One girl said that she had been unable to breathe, and was only able to do so when she covered her face with a pillow. 
 Then she had remembered her birth. 
 She was in the birth canal, her head and ears were covered, she was at peace. 
 Then a whoosh, and she was out in the painful, bright light. 
 A man said he had breathed for ages and felt nothing. 
 Then he was touched on the head by a rebirther and broke down into uncontrollable sobs. 
 &bquo;I realised for the first time that I have never been wanted: it really was such a revelation. 
 But now, it sounds crazy but I have never felt so happy.&equo; 
 He was not alone in feeling this way. 
 Many others were laughing and crying and hugging each other. 
 I wept too. 
 Was all this emotion merely suggestibility to the day's teaching? 
 Or a reaction to an atmosphere charged by 100 people's grief? 
 Or is there more to breathing than we understand? 
 Some people seemed genuinely changed by the weekend: they learned that they really could give or receive love. 
 For others it provided a safe environment in which they could recognise the insecurities that were messing up their lives. 
 Nobody I spoke to regretted the money they had spent. 
 Time will show whether the training has long-term benefits &mdash; or whether it merely creates LRT junkies, capable of happiness only in an environment unnaturally charged with emotion and hooked on an expensive promise of love and everlasting life. 
 Knock profit 
 By SIMON DENISON 
 A multi-million pound airport built in a remote part of Ireland has trebled profits to &pound;138,000. 
 Passenger numbers at Knock Airport, built near a Marian shrine four years ago, are expected to double by the end of 1989. 
 Jail challenge 
 By SIMON DENISON 
 Jens Soering, the West German awaiting extradition from the UK to face a murder trial in the US, is to challenge his continuing detention in a British prison at a High Court hearing this month. 
 In July the European Court of Human Rights in Strasbourg ruled that Britain could not extradite Mr Soering to answer a capital charge of murder because he might face &bquo;death row&equo;. 
 Hearing delayed 
 By SIMON DENISON 
 The High Court in Dublin adjourned until today an application by the Society for the Protection of the Unborn Child for a permanent ban on Irish student union leaders distributing information on abortion facilities in Britain and a related contempt hearing. 
 Gas leak sealed 
 By SIMON DENISON 
 A gas leak on an unmanned North Sea platform which led to the evacuation of 70 workers from a nearby drilling rig was successfully sealed. 
 Workers will not be allowed back on the out-of-service Vulcan II well in Conoco's Vulcan field until the area is completely clear of gas. 
 Moves to improve safety on North Sea rigs were announced by Peter Morrison, the Energy Minister. 
 Discussion documents have been issued, aimed at better protection against fire and explosion. 
 Whitehall &bquo;brain drain' warning 
 By SIMON DENISON 
 Whitehall faces the prospect of a new &bquo;brain drain' following a 6.5 per cent pay increase for senior civil servants, union leaders said. 
 Representatives said the rise left 22,000 professionals with salaries between 11 per cent and 24 per cent behind colleagues in the private sector. 
 &bquo;Good talent is being lost, particularly in the science and engineering areas,&equo; said a spokesman for the Institution of Professionals, Managers and Specialists. 
 Engineers warned of lay-offs 
 By SIMON DENISON 
 Engineering union leaders believe employers could respond to selective strike action by using mass lay-offs. 
 The unions are balloting 24,000 members in four companies next week on an indefinite strike. 
 The unions' joint strategy committee agreed to raise strike pay from &pound;100 to &pound;125 a week plus top-ups from individual unions but confirmed that those laid off or locked out will not qualify for payments. 
 Alex Ferry, general secreatry of the Conferderation of Shipbuilding and Engineering Unions, said there was a distinct possibilty companies would use mass lay-offs. 
 Release of Kurds &bquo;not connected to suicide&equo; 
 By ANDY GLINIECKI and NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 THE HOME OFFICE yesterday released 25 more Kurds seeking political asylum in Britain from detention centres but denied it was bowing to pressure after the death of a detainee who set fire to himself last week. 
 A spokesman said the seven Kurds released from Haslar detention centre, near Gosport, Hampshire, and all 18 from Gloucester Prison were given temporary admission &bquo;for as long as it takes to assess their cases&equo;. 
 The death at the weekend of Siho Iyiguven, who threw himself on a burning mattress at Harmondsworth detention centre, near Heathrow, was followed yesterday with further suicide threats by detainees who barricaded themselves into their dormitory. 
 There was also a mass picket by supporters outside the Home Office. 
 But the Home Office said last night that the latest releases, after interviews carried out as part of a review of each case, were unconnected with recent events. 
 Kurdish detainees at Harmondsworth were released after last week's fire, which also left one man seriously injured. 
 There are still at least 20 Kurds detained at Haslar. 
 Immigration officials will be conducting interviews over the next few days. 
 Several hundred Kurds picketed the Home Office in protest at the continuing detentions and the deportations back to Turkey where they are said to face oppression and torture. 
 Meanwhile, a High Court judge warned of a serious problem because of a log-jam of refugee cases as he gave leave for two of them to seek judicial review of Home Office decisions to refuse them asylum. 
 &bquo;Clearly the Kurds, one way or another, are going to present an enormous problem to the courts very shortly, as they are at the moment to the Home Office,&equo; Mr Justice Schiemann said. 
 He said some of the cases should be dealt with soon so that the principles for deciding who should be granted asylum &bquo;can emerge and be tested on appeal&equo;. 
 The Home Office is deciding who is a genuine refugee and who should be deported out of 3,500 Kurds who arrived in May and June, before a visa requirement was introduced. 
 Most are living in north London, on income support and with help from Kurdish groups. 
 But about 200 have spent some time in detention, some for more than four months. 
 The Home Office says it has assessed only 560 of the total influx. 
 Seventy have been given refugee status and 240 have been allowed to stay for a year after which their cases will be reviewed. 
 Asylum has been refused for 150, and 35 of these have already been deported. 
 A further 45 cases are likely to go to judicial review. 
 At this rate, it will be about six months before all the Kurds know their fate. 
 In today's preliminary hearings at the High Court a 36-year-old farmer and 25-year-old X-ray technician both claim a right to asylum under the 1951 United Nations Convention Relating to Refugee Status on the ground that they have a well-founded fear of persecution if they are deported. 
 Their cases will be heard early next month. 
 The Home Office believes many are economic refugees. 
 Officials point out that more than 230 have decided to return to Turkey voluntarily. 
 Alf Dubs, the former Labour MP who is director of the British Refugee Council, said: &bquo;I'm sure they're not all genuine refugees. 
 But what we argue is that all should have the right to put their case for asylum fairly and properly, and reasonably quickly.&equo; 
 Yesterday The Independent spoke to three Kurdish men picketing the Home Office who all said they had suffered torture and imprisonment in Turkey and were frightened to return. 
 All were known sympathisers of the Kurdish independence movement or communist groups. 
 They said they had come to Britain because they did not need a visa and because they thought it was a free country. 
 They had all left wives and children behind. 
 They said they had to pay heavy bribes to get passports to leave Turkey. 
 Speaking through an interpreter, Ahmed, 31, said: &bquo;I'm very worried about my wife and children. 
 I can't bring them here although I'd like to, and I can't be with them safely. 
 I'm here for some time, not forever. 
 I don't know what will happen.&equo; 
 Heseltine joins NHS critics 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 MICHAEL HESELTINE, the public's favourite to succeed Margaret Thatcher, has issued a direct challenge to the pace and style of government policy. 
 In an interview with The Independent, he aligns himself with critics of the proposed timetable of change in the National Health Service, and he questions the Prime Minister's &bquo;sceptical&equo; approach to the European Community. 
 With representatives arriving in Blackpool for today's opening session of the most critical of Conservative conferences for many years, the former Cabinet minister finds himself the focal point for public and party disaffection with Mrs Thatcher. 
 The opinion polls identify Mr Heseltine as the favoured successor to the Tory leadership, and he said in television and radio interviews yesterday that he would accept the &bquo;huge honour&equo; if it came his way. 
 But he emphasised that he would not put himself up as a challenger to Mrs Thatcher. 
 &bquo;Let us be frank about it,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There is no contest. 
 There is no vacancy. 
 In my view, Mrs Thatcher will lead the Conservatives into the next election and win it. 
 &bquo;One must recognise that these polls take place, but also carefully remember that a decision about any vacancy that takes place is taken by my colleagues in the House of Commons, and not the general public.&equo; 
 Mr Heseltine also defended Nigel Lawson's decision to put interest rates up to 15 per cent, and hoped the Chancellor would be given a courteous reception when he addressed conference on Thursday. 
 But in his interview with The Independent, Mr Heseltine staked out the areas of difference between himself and his front-bench colleagues. 
 On the NHS changes, he said he would support the legislation because it was designed to make the service more effective and efficient. 
 But he then sided with many professional and political critics of the Government's plans, saying: &bquo;Having got the legislation, it would be wise to proceed by&hellip; demonstration of success rather than trying a root-and-branch revolutionary approach. 
 &bquo;It is such a complicated thing to try and do, you do need the support of the medical profession and of the managers of the Health Service, and of the public, and you'll get it more effectively if they can see by example what you're trying to do comprehensively.&equo; 
 As for the Government's style, Mr Heseltine suggested that much of its tough &bquo;rhetoric&equo; was empty, because the hostile words did not match the actions. 
 Citing the EC example, he said: &bquo;It was Mrs Thatcher who signed the Single European Act, which is the biggest transfer of sovereignty which this government has ever undertaken in any period of our history.&equo; 
 Health plans &bquo;may cost Tories 1.5m votes&equo; 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 THE GOVERNMENT'S plans for the NHS could cost the Tories 1.5 million votes at the next general election, Robin Cook, Labour's health spokesman, claimed yesterday. 
 An opinion poll conducted by MORI for the Labour Party shows that 12 per cent of Conservative voters would be fairly or very likely to switch parties if the Government goes ahead with its plans, Mr Cook said. 
 &bquo;That would mean the Conservatives losing over 1.5 million voters at the next election and many marginal seats would go with them.&equo; 
 Almost 80 per cent of Tory voters say they are unlikely to change parties if the NHS plans go ahead, but 70 per cent believe the proposals are likely to lead to privatisation of the NHS, with 62 per cent seeing the changes leading to worse standards of care and treatment. 
 Labour is to split the front-bench job of shadowing health and social security, mirroring the Government's division of the DHSS portfolio last year. 
 Mr Cook said he hoped to retain responsibility for health matters. 
 Wide support for impartial check on official statistics 
 By ROSIE WATERHOUSE 
 CALLS for an independent body to monitor political interference in government statistics, reported in The Independent yesterday, have received widespread backing. 
 Economists, the statistics profession, trade unions and Opposition politicians all pledged support for the idea of a national council which is being promoted by eminent statisticians and considered by the Royal Statistical Society. 
 &bquo;Anything that improves the accuracy and quality of government statistics would be welcomed by the economic profession,&equo; Kevin Darlington, a UK economist with City analysists Phillips and Drew, said. 
 &bquo;The figures the Government's Central Statistical Office (CSO) produce are neither timely nor accurate. 
 Statistics are the life blood of both the Government and economists, as chief end-users. 
 &bquo;The amount of confidence end-users have in the figures has been seriously dented after last year's performance. 
 In December they had three different interpretations of the Gross Domestic Product, which is one of the most important figures for macro-economists. 
 The press notice showed different things &mdash; that output was growing, that it was standing still and that it was falling. 
 &bquo;It is an alarming position when the CSO are the monopoly producers of the macro-economic statistics which are used to formulate policy and steer the economy. 
 Their performance has been very poor. 
 &bquo;Bill Martin, chief UK economist at Phillips and Drew, has already spoken of the need for an independent watchdog to &bquo;protect the interests of non-Treasury use of economic data&equo;. 
 Barry Quirke, chairman of the Institute of Statisticians, said: &bquo;We would be very keen to support any initiative to set up an independent committee, so long as it has teeth. 
 We are concerned about the profession's reputation.&equo; 
 John Ellis, general secretary of the Civil and Public Services Association, which has members employed by the Government's statistical services, said: &bquo;Anything that improves the quality of statistics, which this country is very good at getting wrong, particularly on transport and the economy, would be to the benefit of the whole country.&equo; 
 Yesterday, it emerged that members of his union and the National Union of Civil and Public Servants who work in the government's Business Statistics Office in Newport, Gwent, expressed worries that their work could be &bquo;prostituted&equo; and &bquo;manipulated&equo; by politicians after the CSO was moved from the control of the Cabinet Office to the Treasury. 
 But Margaret Thatcher wrote to Paul Flynn, their MP, in July saying: &bquo;The concerns you express are without foundation. 
 The Government regards the integrity, quality and relevance of official statistics as vital for the conduct of the economy.&equo; 
 Last night Michael Meacher, Labour employment spokesman, called for the all-party Treasury and Civil Service Select Committee to examine the accuracy of government statistics and political use of them. 
 A spokesman for the CSO said: &bquo;The Government Statistical Service has a high reputation for integrity, objectivity and honesty. 
 It is our business to collect, compile and publish figures. 
 We are not responsible for what politicians and others do with them.&equo; 
 &bquo;IRA photos&equo; security tightened last year 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK 
 A CLAMPDOWN on the circulation of photographs of IRA suspects among members of the security forces was brought into operation secretly last year, official sources in Belfast said yesterday, writes David McKittrick. 
 Before the change, they were given photographs of republicans to take with them on patrols. 
 Since then, however, standard procedure has been for patrols to study photographs, names and addresses of suspects before leaving security force bases. 
 Official sources were yesterday unable to explain why the restrictions had been brought in, including whether they had been designed to reduce the risk of leaks to loyalists of the type recently coming to light. 
 The sources said almost all the documents which had turned up appeared to have gone missing before the 1988 change. 
 RUC documents sent to The Independent last month were dated June 1988. 
 The information from official sources serves to confirm what loyalist paramilitaries said in August &mdash; that a partial clampdown had taken place about a year ago. 
 Loyalists said this had reduced the flow of photographs to them. 
 The IRA yesterday shot dead a Protestant, claiming he had links with the illegal Ulster Volunteer Force (UVF). 
 Thomas Gibson, 28, died in his car at Kilrea, Co Londonderry. 
 The UVF denied he had any connection with it. 
 Four members of the Ulster Defence Regiment &mdash; among 28 arrested on Sunday - appeared in court in Belfast charged with possessing ammunition under suspicious circumstances. 
 All were remanded on bail. 
 Timman and Speelman agree fourth game draw 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK 
 YESTERDAY'S play in the Pilkington Glass World Chess Championship semi-finals at Sadler's Wells in London yesterday, was restricted to completing the adjourned fourth game of the Timman-Speelman match. 
 This ended in a draw after 116 moves. 
 Timman now leads 3-2 overall. 
 When Jan Timman and Jonathan Speelman shook hands on a draw in the fifth game of their match on Sunday night, it was perhaps the most surprising move of the event so far. 
 Speelman had won a pawn at move 29, so his position looked far superior. 
 But then Timman attacked and by move 40, the question was whether Speelman could survive. 
 Timman's 42nd move looked like a winning combination (42&hellip; 
 Qxb6 loses to 43. 
 Qxe5+). 
 but after Speelman's reply the position was unclear again. 
 Shop celebrates 75th anniversary 
 By DAVID MCKITTRICK 
 Phillip Whittemore, manager of Grouts &mdash; the drapery shop in Palmers Green, north London &mdash; taking money from the &bquo;railway&equo; cashtill which moves cash around along wires. 
 Above him is a clock which stopped 50 years ago and has not been wound since. 
 The shop, celebrating its 75th anniversary, specialises in traditional underwear  
 Nuns claim ministry changed eggs story 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 THE NUNS in Northamptonshire who are battling to save their 5,000 chickens from slaughter said yesterday that the Ministry of Agriculture had changed its story over the type of salmonella responsible for the outbreak of food poisoning which led to the flock being tested. 
 The nuns, from the Our Lady of the Passion Monastery in Daventry, had been told that the food poisoning in nearby Bedworth had been caused by Salmonella enteriditis. 
 Tests on one of the two flocks at the monastery were positive for Salmonella typhimurium. 
 Later Ministry of Agriculture officials told the nuns that this was a mistake and that the food poisoning was due to Salmonella typhimurium. 
 A spokesman for the ministry confirmed that an outbreak of food poisoning in Bedworth in July had been traced back to the monastery. 
 It affected four people &mdash; three from one family &mdash; and was caused by Salmonella typhimurium in eggs purchased from a stall at Bedworth Market. 
 The eggs are reported to have come from the monastery. 
 Sister Jane Anne, one of the monastery's 14 nuns, said that they found the ministry's statement &bquo;very strange&equo;. 
 &bquo;They say that it was a mistake that we had been told that the outbreak was due to Salmonella enteriditis,&equo; she said. 
 The nuns have acted to prevent the slaughter of the flock because they believed that their eggs have never been associated with an outbreak of food poisoning, she added. 
 Sister Jane Anne said that they would continue their fight: &bquo;We don't want to give up until there has been a fair hearing.&equo; 
 Lawyers acting on their behalf are seeking a judicial review. 
 This would stop the slaughter of the flock until there had been a full hearing in the High Court, according to Mr Richard North, an environmental health officer and technical adviser to the United Kingdom Egg Producers' Association, which is backing the nuns. 
 The ministry said that it intended to go ahead with the slaughter of the flock &bquo;as soon as possible&equo;. 
 John Gummer, Secretary of State for Agriculture, said: &bquo;We cannot have a situation in which the consumer does not have absolute confidence in British eggs. 
 This action is to protect the consumer and the producer.&equo; 
 His officials were talking last night to the nuns' lawyers. 
 Last week six of the nuns locked themselves in a hen house and refused access to a ministry vet who was to supervise the slaughter of the hens by 10 ex-aminers. 
 Andy Oatley, chairman of the association, said that a court hearing would be a &bquo;watershed&equo; for small egg producers. 
 The British egg industry had been made a scapegoat for food poisoning by the Government. 
 Between 60 and 70 per cent of eggs came from the &bquo;independents&equo; such as the nuns who kept up to 10,000 birds. 
 They had been hardest hit by new legislation which required regular testing of the flocks and their compulsory slaughter if salmonella was found. 
 It cost about &pound;14,000 to restock; compensation was inadequate and hundreds had gone out of business, Mr Oatley said. 
 Evidence of salmonella in chickens or in the hen house did not mean that the eggs were infected to levels that could cause food poisoning, he said. 
 &bquo;We suggested to the ministry a long time ago that they should find a flock with salmonella and test the eggs for salmonella. 
 They refuse to do this. 
 There have been no scientific studies to determine whether the eggs themselves are infected.&equo; 
 He added that in Sweden salmonella had been eradicated from poultry by vaccination but cases of food poisoning were still increasing. 
 Mr Oatley pointed out that because small producers were going out of business, up to 10 per cent of eggs consumed in Britain were being imported. 
 Earlier this week the Ministry of Agriculture confirmed that Dutch eggs known to be infected with salmonella had been allowed on sale in the UK. 
 Aldington denies &bquo;subterfuge&equo; over war repatriation 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 LORD ALDINGTON was asked to explain yesterday why he had removed the word &bquo;subterfuge&equo; from a speech at his old school explaining his part in the repatriation and subsequent death of tens of thousands of Yugoslavs at the end of the Second World War. 
 The former brigadier Toby Low was continuing his evidence in his action for damages over accusations that he repatriated 70,000 Yugoslavs and Cossacks from Allied-occupied Austria in 1945, knowing they faced almost certain death. 
 He was accused in a pamphlet, written by the historian Count Nikolai Tolstoy and circulated by Nigel Watts, a property developer, of deceiving the Yugoslavs by letting them believe they were going to Italy. 
 Richard Rampton QC, read out a draft of a speech which Lord Aldington gave in March 1985 to the pupils of Winchester College where he was Warden. 
 It said: &bquo;I'm much criticised for part of a written order under my signature which includes a sentence that the Yugoslavian nationals were not to be told their destination. 
 The purpose of it, I guess, was to reduce to the minimum the need for our British soldiers to use force with the Yugoslavians. 
 Subterfuge was thought to be better than violence.&equo; 
 Mr Rampton said the text showed that &bquo;subterfuge&equo; had been crossed out and the word &bquo;silence&equo; substituted. 
 Lord Aldington, 75, said: &bquo;I think I dictated &bquo;silence&equo; and my secretary might have typed &bquo;subterfuge&equo;.' 
 Mr Rampton protested that the two words were very different. 
 He asked Lord Aldington: &bquo;Subterfuge was your first thought was is not?&equo; 
 It was important because subterfuge meant deception, and he had denied deceiving the Yugoslavs. 
 Lord Aldington denied it had been his first thought: &bquo;Silence is the right word.&equo; 
 He had been ordered not to tell the Yugoslavs where they were going. 
 Lord Aldington was asked what he knew about the Yugoslavs who had been repatriated by the British Eight Army's V Corps while he was chief of staff to its commander, General Sir Charles Keightley. 
 He said he had thought they had all been fighting on the German side because they had all been under a German commander when surrendering. 
 &bquo;These people had been fighting against their own country, against Marshal Tito who had been recognised as an ally by the British Government,&equo; Lord Aldington said. 
 He was asked if he had known about the attrocities committed under Stalin in the 1930s, and whether he would have liked to be returned to the Soviet Union labelled traitor at the end of the war. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't have liked to be returned to Britain at the end of the war labelled &bquo;traitor&equo;,' he said. 
 Conservancy council in buy-out fight with farmer 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 A PUBLIC inquiry today could make legal history as the Nature Conservancy Council attempts for the first time to purchase compulsorily a farmer's land to protect a rich wildlife habitat. 
 Eighteen acres of meadowland, part of the Somerset Levels, is at stake. 
 For five years &mdash; and at a cost of at least &pound;150,000 &mdash; the council has tried unsuccessfully to reach agreement with Mervyn Sweet, of Chapel Farm, to protect the meadows. 
 The Levels form one of England's last cultivated wetlands, flooding every winter. 
 Modern drainage and farming techniques make cultivation possible, but with the agreement of local farmers this has not been done and the water level is artificially maintained to protect the wildlife that has developed. 
 Other farmers have signed management agreements and accepted annual payments of between &pound;30 and &pound;70 per acre not to use modern farming techniques on the land. 
 Mr Sweet does not want to farm the site, but dig it up for the valuable peat underneath. 
 To leave it alone he wants &pound;300 an acre compensation - even though there is no planning permission for peat extraction and little chance of getting it. 
 The land, part of Westhay Moor, near Wedmore, a 100-acre Site of Special Scientific Interest, has not been managed, and all attempts to reach agreement or use legal powers have so far failed. 
 Mr Sweet has already lost planning applications, High Court hearings and a Crown Court prosecution, yet still fights on. 
 He said: &bquo;Everything will come out in evidence. 
 I am only trying to mind my own business and I don't know whether I can prevent the compulsory purchase order.&equo; 
 Win or lose at Glastonbury Town Hall, the inquiry will not be the end of the council's dealings with Mr Sweet. 
 He has put in an application to build a restaurant and car park on some of his remaining land. 
 Police in hunt for athletes who hurdled closed level-crossing 
 By PHIL REEVES 
 POLICE are aiming to track down 30 athletes who hurdled over closed barriers at a railway level-crossing moments before a train hurtled through. 
 It happened shortly after 500 athletes set off on the Rowntree Athletic Club's 10-mile road race at the weekend. 
 When the runners, who included several international competitors, arrived at the crossing at Strensall, near York, they found a single policeman calling them to a halt. 
 His orders were obeyed by more than 450 competitors but about 30 &mdash; they were apparently reluctant to lose their position at the head of the race - steeplechased over the two closed barriers and carried on running. 
 Shortly afterwards a Liverpool to Scarborough train thundered through. 
 Sergeant Terry Lawton, of British Transport Police, said yesterday: &bquo;The train was approaching and if all 450 runners had hurdled the barriers and any had fallen, there could have been a mass slaughter on the line.&equo; 
 The policeman on crossing duty had taken the 30 runners' numbers: &bquo;We are checking numbers with race officials who were also near the crossing and the runners involved will be interviewed with a view to prosecution,&equo; Sergeant Lawton said. 
 Race officials claim the start of the run had been delayed 20 minutes to avoid the train but the race was running 10 minutes ahead of schedule. 
 Dr Peter McDaid, from Tyneside, won the race. 
 John Lenihan, an Eire international, came second. 
 Afterwards Dr McDaid said: &bquo;I couldn't see any train. 
 I was 20 yards ahead and I could not afford to let Lenihan catch up.&equo; 
 The Crown Prosecution Service will decide whether or not the 30 runners should be prosecuted for trespassing on the railway. 
 &bquo;Telegraph&equo; staff strike over new hours plan 
 By MAGGIE BROWN, Media Editor 
 DAILY TELEGRAPH journalists yesterday began an immediate 36-hour strike, in protest at a package of compulsory redundancies and the introduction of contracts featuring a flexible five-day week requiring staff to work Saturdays and Sundays. 
 They were able to respond swiftly because they already have a secret ballot strike mandate over an ongoing pay dispute. 
 The union also voted for a further strike ballot on the new contracts. 
 Last night a management spokeswoman said a skeleton staff was working and would produce a newspaper. 
 One journalist said: &bquo;Staff are foaming at the mouth. 
 They believe there will be an awful lot of weekend working.&equo; 
 The journalists' reaction appeared to take management by surprise. 
 They were last night handing back their new contracts and refusing to sign them. 
 The newspaper group plans to shed 33 jobs, about 25 of them through compulsory redundancy, leaving it with 400 staff to service the Daily and Sunday Telegraph. 
 Journalists were told they would receive pay rises of between &pound;1,500 and &pound;6,000 to adopt the terms, backed-dated to September if signed quickly. 
 Average pay for journalists on the paper, excluding the editor, is &pound;29,000. 
 But it is the wording of the new contracts which appears to have prompted the strike. 
 They say the nature and demands of the job &bquo;may necessitate you working at times other than your normal hours of the week&equo;. 
 Andrew Knight, chief executive and editor-in-chief of the group, said the word &bquo;may&equo; was used to denote the flexibility required. 
 The seven-day strategy was designed to throw the resources of The Daily Telegraph behind the weaker Sunday Telegraph. 
 Minister grants new poll tax exemptions 
 By MAGGIE BROWN, Media Editor 
 WEALTHY property owners may escape paying poll tax on their second homes under plans announced by the Government yesterday. 
 And about 50,000 young people in further education or who are still at school would also be exempt from the community charge, David Hunt, Minister of State at the Department of the Environment, said. 
 For second home owners, it will be up to local authorities to use their discretion in setting a lower rate of charge for certain properties. 
 At present, a council has to set the same standard charge for all unoccupied second homes. 
 The new rule allows them to either reduce it or to make no charge. 
 The proposed change will be written into the Local Government Housing Bill. 
 Mr Hunt said of the changes in the poll tax rules for teenagers: &bquo;A new wider exemption will apply to all young adults under the age of 20 for so long as they are still at school or in full-time further &mdash; though not higher -education.&equo; 
 Special community charge rules already apply to students in higher education at universities and polytechnics. 
 Tory unease over the poll tax will surface at the party conference tomorrow when delegates will call for government cash to fund the &bquo;safety net&equo;. 
 That net is aimed at forcing people in low-spending Conservative boroughs to subsidise voters in mainly high-spending Labour areas. 
 Senior Conservative MPs have already protested about the move and called on the Government to foot the &pound;650m bill or risk losing key marginal seats at the next general election. 
 Government legal service seeks bright new image 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 THE ATTORNEY GENERAL, Sir Patrick Mayhew QC, embarked on a campaign yesterday to rid the government legal service of its dull image with the launch of a recruitment brochure and training scheme aimed at attracting the best graduates. 
 Adopting techniques long employed by the solicitors' profession, the brochure sets out personal accounts of government legal work by serving lawyers. 
 Sir Patrick said the brochure had a dual aim: to show potential recruits that government legal work was responsible and worthwhile; and to dispel the notion that the service was for lawyers who had not made it in other parts of the profession. 
 The brochure will be used in a forthcoming drive to fill 40 vacancies across a number of government departments, and as a recruitment aid on planned &bquo;milk round&equo; sessions at universities and polytechnics. 
 The new training scheme will be targeted at a limited number of high-calibre graduates. 
 Twenty intending solicitors or barristers are being sought immediately for articles or pupillage, at starting salaries of &pound;12,672. 
 Sponsorship through professional exams will also be available. 
 The Crown Prosecution Service will &bquo;continue the fight&equo; to get at least limited rights of audience in the Crown Court for its lawyers once the new advisory committee for legal education and conduct is set up under the Government's White Paper plans for the legal profession, Fiona King, a recruitment specialist at the service said yesterday. 
 The service is short of 369 lawyers, but it has received 517 inquiries about its own articled clerk and pupillage scheme launched in May. 
 Twenty-three trainee lawyers are already in post, with 175 about to be interviewed. 
 Primary schools &bquo;must devote more time to science&equo; 
 By PETER WILBY, Education Editor 
 PRIMARY SCHOOL science has improved over the past decade but still suffers from poorly-trained teachers, inadequate space and equipment and bad organisation, a report from Her Majesty's Inspectors said yesterday. 
 Schools will have to give &bquo;substantially more time&equo; to science to meet the requirements of the national curriculum, the inspectors added. 
 John MacGregor, Secretary of State for Education, yesterday said &bquo;the report shows we are better placed for a major advance than some have suggested&equo;. 
 The report draws mainly on visits to 300 primary schools from 1982-86; since then shorter visits to 80 schools have shown &bquo;further improvements at an increasing pace&equo;. 
 There was a big improvement on the late 1970s when science had barely a toe-hold in most schools and standards were generally poor. 
 But time spent on science was still inadequate. 
 Some classes gave as little as half an hour a week to science and, on average, it took only 5 per cent of the timetable. 
 There was little improvement in the teaching of scientific skills such as making and testing hypotheses and designing experiments. 
 Work was good or better in only a third of classes; in a fifth, it was poor. 
 In about half, much of the work was insufficiently demanding, particularly for older and more able children. 
 For example, conditions necessary for seeds to germinate were often studied in much the same way by successive age groups. 
 Fewer than a fifth of the schools kept records of pupils' achievements in science. 
 In a quarter of the schools, &bquo;work was constrained by limited space and by a lack of other facilities such as a water supply&equo;. 
 Two-thirds of schools had apparatus ranging from adequate to generous. 
 But in a minority &bquo;access to resources was unsatisfactory: apparatus was hidden in cupboards, stored haphazardly, scattered, or kept in rooms used for other purposes for much of the day&equo;. 
 Most primary teachers had had little or no science in their initial training. 
 Though more schools had appointed teachers with responsibility for science, only one in seven classes received specialist teaching. 
 And the specialists' impact on other classes was limited &bquo;because they rarely have sufficient time to work alongside their colleagues&equo;. 
 Countries split over ivory ban 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 LOBBYING over a proposal to ban all trade in ivory divided the conference of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) when it opened yesterday. 
 Arguments over the Tanzanian resolution could lead to the resignation of the secretary-general of CITES, Eugene Lapointe. 
 Mr Lapointe and his secretariat are facing a mounting barrage of accusations, most of them linking the secretariat's allegedly biased lobbying against the ban with the money being given by Far East wildlife traders to the organisation's ivory monitoring unit. 
 The British-based Environmental Investigation Agency says in a brochure, A system of extention, that &bquo;the scale of abuse of the responsibilities entrusted to the secretariat of the parties (CITES 103 member nations) has become so widespread, and the extensive manipulations to prevent a ban on the ivory trade so obvious and desperate, that there is no longer any doubt about the ivory trade's grip on major decisions being taken by the secretariat&equo;. 
 The agency adds: &bquo;Determined to reduce the influence of conservationist non-governmental organisations on CITES and its partners, Lapointe has delivered CITES on a silver platter to the poachers and smugglers.&equo; 
 The agency's allegations have not been supported by other major conservation groups, although Buff Bohlen, a World Wide Fund for Nature official, said he was concerned over what he believed was money from business trading in illegally poached ivory going to support the secretariat's work. 
 The fund had acted as a conduit for the money from ivory trade associations in Japan for one year, but this was stopped by Mr Lapointe, Mr Bohlen said, because he wanted the money to go directly to the secretariat. 
 Over four years, &dollar;600,000 has gone into the ivory unit, of which about &dollar;200,000 was from Japanese and Hong Kong ivory trade associations, with the rest coming from governments and conservation groups. 
 Mr Lapointe defends the use of ivory money saying that he has managed to bring in funds from such sources at the direction of government members of CITES. 
 He adds that it is not in the traders' interests for the elephants to die out. 
 He also denies that his staff overstepped the mark in lobbying, saying he has a responsibility to explain all the options for the trade in addition to a full ban. 
 CITES, which is run on a budget of less than &dollar;3m a year, is facing a financial crisis. 
 Prince Bernhard of The Netherlands, the founder president of the World Wide Fund for Nature, told the conference: &bquo;CITES will retain credibility in my view, by making decisions based on scientific evidence, not political or commercial expedience nor emotion, and by its secretariat at all times maintaining objectivity and impartiality. 
 Parties to CITES must give the secretariat the finances with which to do its job and not oblige it to raise its own funds in ways which lead to question and criticism.&equo; 
 Tanzania, backed by Kenya, Somalia and the Gambia, is urging a ban on the ivory trade because elephant numbers in east and central Africa are falling as a result of poaching. 
 In the past 10 years, elephant numbers in Africa have fallen from more than 1.2 million to about 600,000. 
 Southern African states, such as Zimbabwe, Botswana and South Africa, have already declared their opposition to a ban, as their stocks of elephants are rising, allowing profitable culling for ivory, meat and leather. 
 A compromise with far tighter controls over the CITES-monitored quota system is likely to be agreed before the end of the conference in two weeks' time. 
 British breakthrough in speech-wise computers 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 BRITAIN has broken a vital barrier in developing computers that recognise continuous speech rather than needing a keyboard to type in information. 
 The computers can recognise thousands of words and, unlike older systems, do not have to be trained laboriously for each word. 
 The technology has brought Britain to the forefront of speech recognition in nine months &mdash; thanks to a team of three researchers, Dr Roger Moore, of the Royal Signals and Radar Establishment, says. 
 The advance has proved highly accurate in recognising continuously spoken airborne reconnaissance reports for the Royal Air Force. 
 Until now reconnaisance pilots, because their hands and eyes are fully occupied, have had to remember what they see and compile reports later. 
 The computer has to recognise not only words, but when speech begins and ends. 
 It must differentiate between background noise, words, and breathing. 
 According to Dr Moore, speech recognition could be an important feature of future aircraft and it is believed to be under consideration for the European Fighter Aircraft. 
 The same technology will allow machines to be controlled by voice command in the dark or where the operator's hands are full. 
 Similar work in the United States, he says, has taken a multi-million dollar, five-year programme to achieve. 
 Now establishment scientists are looking for someone interested in using the achievement in the civil sector. 
 Early speech recognition systems relied on converting words in a given vocabulary into a pattern stored in the computer and comparing each spoken word to see if it matched. 
 It was crude, slow, and could not cope with variations in speech. 
 Some later work focused on modelling variations in speech patterns, but the computers still could be used by only one person who &bquo;trained&equo; by saying each word five or 10 times. 
 According to Dr Moore, that is unrealistic if computers are to be able to recognise thousands of words. 
 The establishment's scientists use models based on sub-units of words &mdash; about 40 sounds which are the building blocks of the English language. 
 The result is a system that has the potential to recognise every word in the language. 
 To date, each system uses models of sounds uttered by one person, but could be developed to cope with anyone speaking in one language or accent. 
 Coroner links 14 deaths to psychiatric unit 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 FORTY-THREE per cent of the suicides and probable suicides in south Devon this year were people recently released from the controversial Edith Morgan psychiatric unit at Torbay Hospital, a coroner has disclosed. 
 Hamish Turner gave the figure in an unprecedented statement when opening an inquest into the death of Debra Tosio, 30, a Shaldon shop assistant found at the bottom of 70ft cliffs at Berry Head, Brixham, last week. 
 She was found dead hours after walking out of the unit in a suicidal state after her family had been told it was secure. 
 She apparently left through an unlocked door. 
 Yesterday the Torbay coroner said 14 out of 32 suicides this year had recently been released from the unit, which he has criticised on several occasions since it replaced more secure psychiatric hospitals that have been closed by the area health authority. 
 He has called a seminar in nine days to discuss &bquo;The Urge For Self Destruction&equo;. 
 It will be attended by leading doctors. 
 Clamping proves to be parking deterrent 
 By ANDY GLINIECKI 
 WHEELCLAMPING of cars is deterring drivers from parking on yellow lines and illegally parking in residents' bays, according to a new report. 
 Published by the research arm of the Department of Transport, the report comes shortly after the London borough of Hammersmith and Fulham announced it would be introducing the scheme later this month. 
 So far no local authorities outside London have approached the department about the implementation of wheelclamping. 
 Surveys of parking habits by the deparment's Transport and Road Research Laboratory carried out before and after wheelclamping was extended to the areas of St John's Wood and Pimlico in London in spring 1987, show that parking on yellow lines declined by 31 and 17 per cent respectively. 
 Both areas experienced a 50 per cent reduction in illegal parking in residents' bays. 
 In St John's Wood illegal parking-time in each bay fell per day from 77 minutes to 40 and in Pimlico, from 48 minutes to 24. 
 The percentage of time that meters were occupied during the penalty period fell from 19 to 5 per cent in Pimlico with an increase in &bquo;meter-feeding&equo;. 
 But in St John's Wood there was a dramatic rise in the time parked in penalty &mdash; from 8 to 28 per cent. 
 The changes in parking behaviour in St John's Wood are similar to those observed in the period after wheelclamping was introduced in central London in 1982. 
 In the original clamping area the decline in parking on yellow lines was 40 per cent. 
 Pimlico was shown to be comparatively resistant to clamping, as were Mayfair, Soho and Knightsbridge, all of them part of the original clamping area. 
 Areas covered by wheelclamping include the City of London, most of Westminster and Kensington and Chelsea, and the southern half of Camden. 
 Police hunt woman over IRA bombing of Deal barracks 
 By JACK O'SULLIVAN 
 AN ARTIST'S impression was released yesterday of a young blonde woman believed to be a fourth member of the IRA unit which bombed the Royal Marine barracks at Deal, Kent, on 22 September. 
 The drawing and new evidence about cars suspected of having been used by the bombers, has prompted police to call 1,500 Deal residents for further interviews later this week with 50 officers at a church hall. 
 The woman was picked up by taxi in the afternoon of 6 September from the suspected IRA safe house beside the barracks at 17 Campbell Road. 
 She was driven for 20 minutes to the Eastern docks, Dover. 
 From there she could have travelled to France or Belgium but it is not known whether she boarded a ferry. 
 She did not indicate her destination. 
 Police described her as aged about 21, between 5ft 4in and 5ft 5in tall, of medium build, wearing a light, fairly baggy trenchcoat. 
 She had collar-length, straight, ash-blonde hair, parted on one side and spoke with a southern Irish accent. 
 Other witnesses have described seeing such a woman near the house. 
 Ten days ago police released drawings of two male suspects. 
 Sightings have been reported from as far as France and the Netherlands. 
 Police say evidence suggests there was a third man, although descriptions are confused. 
 Detective Superintendent Owen Taylor, who is leading the inquiry team, said yesterday that three people were spotted in an E-registration, black Nissan Micra car, near allotments close to the barracks at 8.15pm on 21 September, which was 12 hours before the bombing in which 10 bandsmen died. 
 They had the car lights switched off for a while. 
 Witnesses have also identified an old light brown Mark 2 Ford Cortina under repair on Station Road, Walmer, two miles from the barracks, on 2 September. 
 This evidence fits statements from Dennis Johnson, who had arranged to meet the suspected bombers around midday at 17 Campbell Road to hand over the keys to the holiday home. 
 When they did not arrive, a man calling himself Richards rang and said: &bquo;Sorry I am late, Mr Johnson. 
 The car has broken down and my two mates have taken it to a local garage to get it fixed.&equo; 
 Police say that at about 11am a man reported at the Green Garage service station that his car had broken down nearby. 
 A mechanic went to the car and saw two men beside it and a young woman inside. 
 Police have still to trace where the suspected bombers went between leaving Campbell Road on 16 September and the bombing six days later. 
 They have ruled out Deal as the site of a second safe house and inquiries are now focused on Dover and Kent villages. 
 Spanish Riding School of Vienna prepare for London performances 
 By JACK O'SULLIVAN 
 Grooms from the Spanish Riding School of Vienna unloading a Lipizzaner stallion at Wembley Arena, London, where the school will stage six performances, starting on Thursday, demonstrating the classical art of riding as practised at the Imperial Court of Vienna. 
 The performances will feature the school's 25 best stallions  
 Art Market: Porcelain inkwell fetches 13,200 pounds 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 AN INKWELL was bought by the Victoria and Albert museum for &pound;13,200 (estimate &pound;4,000-&pound;6,000) at Christie's yesterday. 
 It was made at the Bow porcelain factory around 1758 but its most valuable feature was the signature Ja Welsh on the footrim. 
 James Welsh and his wife are recorded as decorating porcelain at Chelsea in 1750; by the summer of 1754 they had moved to Bow. 
 But nothing was hitherto known of their work. 
 The inkwell is the first signed piece to be discovered. 
 Welsh has painted a loose bouquet, scattered flowers and a dragonfly around the sides, while the shoulder is painted with quills, dividers, rulers, a mathematical manuscript and a geometrical equation. 
 It should become a key in attributing other work to his hand. 
 There was keen competition for the finer pieces in Christie's sale of British ceramics. 
 An early (1745-49) Chelsea teapot, the sides moulded in imitation of acanthus leaves and painted with sprigs of flowers and insects reached &pound;24,200 (estimate &pound;15,000-&pound;20,000). 
 Determined collectors bid two lots through the roof. 
 First to get the treatment was a rare Staffordshire saltglaze oval soup tureen, cover and stand painted with flowers, butterflies and insects. 
 Jonathan Horne secured it for his client after a long battle at &pound;31,900 (estimate &pound;5,000-&pound;8,000). 
 At weekend sales in New York and Paris prices for post-war French artists soared to new heights. 
 In Paris an abstract patchwork of colours by Serge Poliakoff, Composition -1966, set an auction record for the artist at Fr3.6m (&pound;360,000). 
 In the same Charbonneaux auction, a chair made by Dubuffet from irregular-shaped coloured chunks secured Fr2m (&pound;200,000). 
 Water authority to be sued over officer's illness 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 A POLICE federation is to sue its local water authority in an attempt to win compensation for an officer who became ill after saving a man from drowning in a polluted river. 
 Malcolm Beavers, a former inspector, has now retired on a police pension after contracting an infection when he dived into a polluted stretch of the River Aire at Selby, North Yorkshire. 
 Mr Beavers, 37, a married man with two children, won a bravery award for the rescue but is suffering from viral fatigue syndrome which strikes at the nervous system and brain. 
 David Murfin, the chairman of North Yorkshire Police Federation, said: &bquo;It's a tragic waste of talent. 
 What happened to Malcolm Beavers has upset a lot of policemen.&equo; 
 Yorkshire Water has declined to comment but is believed to be refusing to accept liability. 
 Oil giant Shell UK appeared in court at Birkenhead, Merseyside yesterday charged with polluting the River Mersey in the first major case brought by the new pollution watchdog, the National Rivers Authority. 
 The case was adjourned until 6 November for committal proceedings. 
 Shell is charged with polluting the River Mersey by allowing crude oil to enter the river at Bromborough, Wirral, on 19 August &mdash; contrary to the Control of Pollution Act of 1974 &mdash; from a fractured pipeline from Birkenhead's Tranmere Oil Terminal to Shell's Stanlow refinery at Ellesmere Port. 
 A massive clean-up programme followed and the long-term environmental effects of the leak are still being assessed. 
 An investigation was launched yesterday after one of the West Country's best game-fishing rivers was hit by a second major pollution incident in seven weeks. 
 The National Rivers Authority confirmed that &bquo;hundreds if not thousands&equo; of salmon, sea trout and brown trout had died in a two-mile stretch of the River Erme at Ivybridge, south Devon. 
 John Hancock, county pollution officer, said the latest incident involved &bquo;a toxic discharge of some sort&equo;. 
 Samples had been taken and investigations were centred on a local factory. 
 On 22 August, 2,000 fish were killed when chlorinated water from a council swimming pool leaked into the river. 
 More than &pound;120,000 has been paid in compensation to victims of another poisoned water accident in the West Country. 
 South West Water said 477 claims worth &pound;123,644 had been settled, with 318 more still outstanding. 
 Supplies to 20,000 people were poisoned in Cornwall when a relief delivery driver accidentally pumped 20 tonnes of aluminium sulphate into the wrong tank at the Lowermoor treatment plant near Camelford on 6 July 1988. 
 Pipe museum closes 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 Anthony Irving inside the House of Pipes he founded at Bramber, in West Sussex, which closed yesterday after more than 16 years because of his ill-health. 
 Among the hundred most popular museums in Britain, it was visited by more than 900,000 people. 
 The 40,000 exhibits, covering 1,500 years, may go on display again in Yorkshire  
 50m pound computerised theft highlights debate on hacking 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 A MAJOR financial institution in Britain has been the victim of a &pound;50m computerised theft in which the money was sent around the world in electronic parcels. 
 Det Supt Don Randall, of the City of London Police fraud squad, says the police recovered the money and 25 people are facing prosecution in four countries. 
 In an interview with Channel 4's Dispatches programme, to be shown tomorrow, Mr Randall says that co-operation between law enforcement agencies in the United States, the Far East and Europe has resulted in &bquo;arrests and prosecution&equo;. 
 However, he said yesterday that it was important to distinguish between a crime in which computers were used as a tool, and computer fraud, which involved manipulating or corrupting a mainframe, which was still relatively uncommon. 
 &bquo;There is very little computer fraud as such, but almost any fraud has now got an electronic aspect,&equo; he said. 
 The programme will also reveal that Barclays, one of the few major financial organisations willing to talk openly about computer crime, spends &pound;20m every year on computer security. 
 Trevor Nicholas, head of Barclay's computer operations, says that the bank has been the victim of attempts to move funds to accounts in other parts of the world, but that as far as it knows, they have been thwarted. 
 The largest attempt was about &pound;900,000, Mr Nicholas says. 
 Barclays has specialists on computer security, hacking and computer viruses &mdash; programmes which replicate themselves and can cause enormous damage. 
 Although the bank has software that can spot 200 different viruses, there are always new ones against which there is no defence. 
 The problem of computer-related crime will be highlighted today in the Law Commission's report on Computer Misuse. 
 The report will spark the next round in the debate over whether hacking should be outlawed. 
 Mr Randall said: &bquo;In general terms, we do see room for hacking to be made a criminal offence.&equo; 
 Some legal experts, and Eric Howe, the Data Protection Registrar, are concerned about the prospect of outlawing hacking per se. 
 Mr Howe says the targets for legislation should be hacking for personal gain, the gain of someone else, or to cause damage. 
 The Law Commission is also expected to deal with the legal issues surrounding computer viruses. 
 Two barristers, Alistair Kelman and Owen Keane, say in the latest Information Security Guide that the battle against viruses is being lost because of their ability to reappear in new strains which are immune to known antidotes. 
 Personal computers are too fragile to cope with viruses and must be replaced with sophisticated systems which are resilient to viruses in the first place. 
 The barristers warn that viruses can be perpetrated inadvertently by computer maintenance engineers and software companies. 
 They divide viruses into the &bquo;mostly harmless&equo; which display messages, &bquo;fatal distraction&equo; which mean to display messages but accidentally cause loss of data or crash the computer, and &bquo;information terrorist&equo; which are designed to do harm. 
 But they warn that any virus is undesirable even if not destructive. 
 Law Report: Limits allowed on doctor's use of deputising service: Regina v Secretary of State for Health, Ex parte Spencer. 
 Queen's Bench Divisional Court &mdash; (Lord Justice Watkins and Mr Justice Hutchison), 9 October 1989 
 By YING HUI TAN, Barrister 
 A doctor's primary duty to provide his patients with personal treatment limits his right to provide treatment by arrangement with a deputising service. 
 Accordingly, having regard to maintaining the doctor's primary duty, a Family Practitioners' Committee is entitled to impose conditions limiting the number of visits per 1,000 patients which might be made by the deputising service, so as to prevent excessive use being made of a deputising service. 
 The FPC's power to limit the use of deputising services is not confined to conditions which bear on the service's capacity to provide an adequate service. 
 The Divisional Court dismissed a general medical practitioner's application for judicial review of the Health Secretary's decision that Coventry Family Practitioners' Committee acted within its powers and duties in imposing a condition on the doctor's use of the BMA/Air Call Deputising Service. 
 Schedule 1 to the National Health Service (General Medical and Pharmaceutical Services) Regulations 1974, as amended, includes doctors' terms of service. 
 By paragraph 16: &bquo;(1) Subject to sub-paragraphs (2) and (3) a doctor shall give treatment personally. 
 (2)&hellip; a doctor shall be under no obligation to give treatment personally if such reasonable steps as are appropriate are taken to ensure continuity of treatment, and treatment may be given &mdash; (a) by another doctor acting as a deputy&hellip; (b) if it is treatment which it is clinically reasonable in the circumstances to delegate, by a person whom the doctor had authorised and who is competent to carry out such treatment.&equo; 
 By paragraph 19: (1) Before entering into arrangements with a deputising service&hellip; a doctor shall obtain the consent of the committee. 
 In giving such consent, the committee may also impose such conditions as it considers necessary or expedient to ensure the adequacy of such arrangements.&equo; 
 By circular HC(FP)84 2, the Department of Health and Social Security gave guidance to FPCs in exercising their functions in paragraph 19 and referred to limitations on the use of services, such as a limit on calls. 
 On Dr Spencer's application to the FPC for consent to use the deputising service, the committee agreed to renew consent subject to the condition which involved a limit of 15 calls per thousand patients per month. 
 Dr Spencer appealed to the Secretary of State for Health who dismissed the appeal. 
 Francis Ferris QC and Michael Briggs (Hempsons) for Dr Spencer; John Laws (Treasury Solicitor) for the Secretary of State for Health. 
 MR JUSTICE HUTCHISON said that the applicant was in effect asking the court to declare unlawful the FPC's use of paragraph 19 provisions in order to put in place a policy for limiting the use of deputising services, save where the power to limit was used for the purpose of keeping the deputising services going properly. 
 Mr Ferris submitted that the obligation to give personal treatment was very substantially cut down in cases falling within sub-paragraph (2) and that a doctor was entitled to make arrangements for the entirety of his practice to be conducted by some other doctor. 
 He submitted that paragraph 19 was to be construed without regard to paragraph 16(1). 
 Mr Laws submitted that (1) the expectation was that the doctor would in general provide for his patients a full-time service. 
 The fundamental provision was in paragraph 16(1). 
 Paragraph 19 was merely ancillary to paragraph 16. (2) If the FPC did not impose limitations it would be facilitating the frustration of the doctor's paragraph 16 duties. 
 (3) The draftsman could never have intended to permit a doctor to lawfully sub-contract all his work. 
 (4) Reasonable limits had to be placed on the use of deputies to enable the doctor to fulfil his fundamental obligation of giving treatment personally. 
 (5) While the words &bquo;adequacy of such arrangements&equo; in paragraph 19 included the concept that the commercial organisation should be efficiently run and provide cover by adequately qualified doctors, their correct interpretation was adequacy in the sense of its compatability with the continuance of the basic obligations of a doctor to his patients. 
 Mr Laws contended that paragraph 16(2) did limit the doctor's right to provide treatment by another deputy; that it was legitimate for the FPC to take into account the doctor's reasonable needs for time off duty for relaxation and rest, the advantages of continuity of patient care and the paragraph 16 obligation to give personal treatment. 
 He submitted that it was quite clear that the FPC reached a considered decision as what it found to be the proper level of use of the deputising service consistently with maintaining the doctor's primary responsibility and as regards the need to maintain the standards of the deputising service efficiently and consistently with that obligation. 
 His Lordship concluded without hesitation that Mr Laws' arguments were to be preferred. 
 It was wholly unrealistic to construe paragraph 19 without regard to paragraph 16. 
 The terms of service had to be construed as a whole. 
 The primary obligation was plainly to provide personal treatment, though that obligation was subject to limited qualifications. 
 His Lordship could not accept that a sensible construction of paragraph 19 involved that, provided only the commercial deputising service was large and efficient enough, the FPC was in practice obliged to give its consent even though it knew that the doctor in question intended to delegate his entire practice to such an organisation. 
 Any sensible construction of the terms of service involved that paragraph 19 must be read in the light of, and subject to, the obligation imposed by paragraph 16. 
 The challenge to the Secretary of State for Health's decision, which was also effectively a challenge of the FPC's decision and the circular, was misconceived. 
 Slate quarries given a new lease of life 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 A GROWING demand for slate roofs has breathed new life into traditional slate quarrying in north Wales and given a fillip to villages that for centuries have relied on the industry for jobs. 
 While other Welsh industries, particularly coal mining and steel production, have declined, devastating the villages that grew up to service them. 
 The soaring market for roof slates, helped by a return to traditional architecture and materials, has come just in time. 
 The village of Bethesda, four miles from Bangor, has grown cheek-by-jowl with its slate quarry over two centuries. 
 Penrhyn is now the largest quarry in the world, and 30,000 tonnes of rock a week are gouged out of the Carneddi mountains &mdash; 6 per cent of the world's slate output. 
 Yet five years ago, the quarry faced closure. 
 Employment was down to 150, from a pre-Second World War high of 3,000, and two rival quarries in neighbouring valleys had succumbed to the depression. 
 Now Penrhyn, operated by Alfred McAlpine, has seen profits and production increase fourfold in five years, and 400 are employed. 
 A training scheme enables young people to learn the old skills. 
 But Penrhyn's success has met a mixed reception. 
 Over the years, quarrying generally has had a bad record for pay and conditions, and Penrhyn has a particularly infamous past. 
 It was there in 1903 that quarrymen went on strike for three and a half years, surviving on subsistence farming. 
 Such times are not easily forgotten. 
 Since then, there has been a history of militancy and while McAlpine's has brought dramatic improvements in wages and conditions, it has also imported English managers, resented in this staunchly Welsh-speaking region. 
 Quarrymen stopping for a pint in the King's Head public house on their way home took a stoical view of the quarry's recent success. 
 &bquo;It pays well and has brought valuable jobs, but if the demand for slate drops they will close us down without a second thought,&equo; one said. 
 Talk was of a minor disciplinary measure by management that might lead to industrial action. 
 A worker said: &bquo;The industry has changed a lot and is now highly-mechanised, and we work continental shifts, but some things don't change. 
 What the management has to learn is that we can't be mucked about.&equo; 
 Today's quarry owner has to take account of the environmental issues his predecessor could safely ignore. 
 The boundaries for the Snowdonia National Park run round the edge of Penrhyn, which covers six square miles. 
 Quarries down the road at Ffestiniog are within the National Park, and expansion plans must be carefully thought out. 
 Geoff Drake, managing director at Penrhyn, said: &bquo;We are aware of our responsibilities, and tipping is now below ground level to avoid creating an eyesore. 
 The quarry has been here 200 years and is part of the landscape, rather than a blot on it.&equo; 
 Certainly the galleries where the slate is blasted, which go down 1,500ft in giant steps, have a dramatic quality of their own. 
 They cannot be seen from the village, but are visible from Anglesey across the Menai Strait. 
 Mr Drake said: &bquo;We are seeking to redress some of the ills of our predecessors. 
 The quarry had a bad reputation, but we are trying to get involved in the local community and are improving the image of quarrying.&equo; 
 He added that &pound;10m had been invested in equipment and there was a commitment to the future; growing export markets, particularly in Japan, were being exploited and the quarry would be Bethesda's main employer for some time. 
 Study shows 100,000 young people run away each year 
 By PHIL REEVES 
 NEARLY 100,000 young people go missing in Britain each year, many of whom are lured into prostitution in fear of their lives by &bquo;the unscrupulous and powerful&equo;, according to a study into the country's first safe house for young runaways. 
 The young people arrive on the streets penniless and homeless and turn to prostitution to support themselves, the report says. 
 Once involved in prostitution, they often find it hard to give up. 
 Some fall victim to pimps, others are preyed upon by men who hang around main-line railway stations, waiting for runaways to arrive. 
 &bquo;Young people's bodies are still a saleable commodity in Britain in the 1980s,&equo; the study concludes. 
 The report is based on information from 532 young people admitted over two years to the Central London Teenage Project, Britain's first &bquo;safe house&equo; for runaways. 
 The house, which has 10 beds, is at a secret address and is funded mainly by the Children's Society, a charity. 
 Most were aged between 14 and 16, but some were as young as seven. 
 Of the 532 &mdash; members of all social classes and from all over the country &mdash; 24 girls and 13 boys said they had been involved in prostitution at some time. 
 Only 39 per cent had been reported missing to the police. 
 Cathy Newman, author of the report, which is based on the project's first two years of operation, from 1985-87, said: &bquo;Many of those involved in prostitution, particularly females, were the victims of physical abuse from the pimps they worked with. 
 Several girls had been badly beaten and threatened by these men and forced to return to return to the streets for fear of their lives.&equo; 
 One girl at the safe house said she was beaten up by two other girls trying to persuade her to &bquo;go on the game&equo;. 
 In another case, a pimp repeatedly followed a girl to her house in an attempt to force her back on to the streets. 
 About a third of those interviewed said they had run away because of &bquo;problems at home&equo;. 
 A similar number ran away after being placed in local authority care. 
 Many spoke of being unable to get on with parents, often a step-parent, leading to constant arguments or violence. 
 Ninety-eight (18 per cent) said they had been sexually abused at some time, including 82 girls &mdash; the victims of rape, incest, sexual assault or prostitution. 
 Seventeen girls said they were sexually abused by more than one person. 
 The report, which the Children's Society says is the first detailed study of runaway youngsters, calls for a national centralised system for collecting statistics on missing juveniles. 
 It says that about 98,000 young people go missing annually, sometimes only for a short period. 
 But this is a &bquo;conservative&equo; estimate, as not every police force collates figures on missing juveniles. 
 &bquo;It is alarming that in the annual reports of chief constables the number of stray dogs is always recorded but not the number of missing children,&equo; Ms Newman writes. 
 She calls for a national policy for dealing with runaway children, and more government funding. 
 Young people should have the right of independent counselling, and should not be held in police cells. 
 An independent complaints procedure should be established for youngsters in care, she says. 
 Frank Field, Labour chairman of the Commons Social Services Select Committee, said a common thread was that many of the youngsters came from broken homes. 
 &bquo;We have a divorce law which allows marriages to be broken up after less time than the run of an average HP agreement,&equo; Mr Field said. 
 Dark Age cemetery reveals &bquo;Barra's people&equo; 
 By DAVID KEYS, Archaeology Correspondent 
 THE REMAINS of the shields and spears of five Dark Age warriors together with the jewellery of at least eight of their womenfolk have been unearthed near Cambridge. 
 Excavations, nine miles south-west of the city, have revealed the rich graves of a pagan Anglian cemetery in use between 550 and 630AD. 
 For much of that period the area was probably part of one of many statelets beyond the western edge of the early kingdom of East Anglia. 
 The cemetery, which probably contains at least 300 Dark Age graves, may have been used by the inhabitants of a statelet possibly known as the Barringas - &bquo;the people of Barra&equo;. 
 This can be deduced from the surviving local parish name of Barrington which, when translated from Anglo Saxon, means &bquo;the village of Barra's people&equo;. 
 Barra was probably the fifth or sixth-century founder of the statelet. 
 Archaeologists have found 28 skeletons, six iron spearheads, five iron shield bosses, 18 iron knives, 12 decorated bronze brooches some of which are gilded, six pairs of bronze wrist and clothes clasps, two spindle whorls -one ceramic and one of glass &mdash; one bone comb, two pots and 90 beads. 
 Most of the beads are of amber, probably imported from the Baltic, but some are multi-coloured in blue, yellow and red glass. 
 The cemetery, which contains graves of men, women and children, covers about 15,000 square yards. 
 Less than 10 per cent has been excavated. 
 The remaining graves, probably about 280 &mdash; filled with up to 1,000 more weapons and jewellery items &mdash; will be excavated only if finance for future digs becomes available. 
 It is estimated that the cost of completing the excavation and related research will be about &pound;40,000. 
 However, if excavations do not take place the cemetery and its treasures are likely to be destroyed by ploughing within a few years. 
 It is not known whether all the material will be permanently exhibited, because South Cambridgeshire District is one of the few local authorities in Britain not to have a local museum. 
 The cemetery has been excavated, mostly over the past fortnight, by a team directed by Tim Malim, of Cambridgeshire County Council. 
 &bquo;This particularly rich pagan cemetery still contains skeletons and grave goods in good condition and will provide us with a wealth of information on the health and culture of the sixth-century inhabitants of Cambridgeshire,&equo; Mr Malim said. 
 Foreign student raped at knifepoint on campus 
 By DAVID KEYS, Archaeology Correspondent 
 A FOREIGN student was raped at knifepoint just hours after she arrived in Britain to start the new term. 
 The 21-year-old was spending her first night at Sussex University, near Brighton, when she was woken at about 4am by a man who turned on the bedroom light, held a knife to her throat and raped her, before escaping through the open window by which he had entered. 
 Sussex police have warned other female students on the campus to be on their guard after the attack on Sunday. 
 Det Insp Brian Welfare, of Sussex CID, said that he had met the university's residential advisers to alert them to the risk to other students. 
 &bquo;It's obviously a possibility that this man could strike again,&equo; he said. 
 The rapist, believed to be aged 20 to 22 years, was described as lean but muscular and about 5ft 8in tall. 
 He was clean-shaven with straight blond hair and angular features. 
 He wore dark trousers with a light cotton shirt. 
 &bquo;Clever&equo; calculators pose problem for exam boards 
 By BY SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 FEARS are mounting that increasingly sophisticated electronic calculators could give some pupils an unfair advantage in GCSE and Advanced level exams. 
 The pace of technological change is such that the latest generation of machines is now capable of drawing graphs, working out algebraic formulae, correcting spelling mistakes and communicating with computers outside the examination room. 
 The Scottish Examination Board is so concerned about the advent of the &bquo;clever&equo; calculator that it has redrafted its regulations to schools for maths exams. 
 In future, while candidates will be allowed to use advanced calculators, they will be forbidden from storing information in the memories of such machines or from using calculators that can be linked by aerial to computers outside the examination room. 
 While recognising that there are educational advantages in using such machines, the board is anxious to prevent candidates with advanced calculators from having an unfair advantage over contemporaries with less sophisticated machines. 
 Colin Vickerman, secretary of the Joint Matriculation Board, said: &bquo;It is a continuing problem which all the boards are having to keep a fairly close watch on. 
 Things that take up no more space than a cigarette packet can now have vast amounts of data in them. 
 The state of the art is quite incredible.&equo; 
 Machines which once cost &pound;400 to &pound;500 as prototypes are now available for &pound;3 to &pound;4. 
 While there was no evidence of widespread abuse of calculators in the examination room, the boards, he said, were attempting to anticipate possible problems. 
 Dick Whittaker, deputy secretary of the JMB, said that there were now calculators available which, for example, offered computerised foreign language dictionaries and others which provided a complete guide to fossil groups in palaeontology. 
 Specialised computing functions were not just confined to scientific and mathematical calculators. 
 The Scottish Examination Board says that word processors/ calculators which correct spelling mistakes are posing &bquo;some problems&equo;. 
 Candidates using them for project or course work may have an advantage if spelling is one of the skills being tested. 
 The board is preparing notes of guidance to schools about how and when such calculators should be used. 
 Whereas in the past the boards would say that advanced calculators could be used without additional calculating programmes or memory banks, such programmes and data banks are incorporated in the latest generation of machines as a matter of course. 
 The problem, Mr Vickerman said, was to ensure that while all students were able to use technology appropriate to their subjects, some examination candidates should not be disadvantaged by having less advanced calculators than others. 
 There was a need, he said, to specify the maximum allowable functions that a calculator used in an exam could be capable of. 
 There might even be a case for a standardised calculator to be used in all A, AS and GCSE examinations nationally. 
 Extradition case 
 By BY SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 A man on the run from Crumlin Road prison, Belfast, was ordered to be extradited from the Irish Republic. 
 Justice Desmond Windle ordered at Dublin District Court that Anthony Gerard Sloan, 35, from Summerville Drive, Belfast, who is serving 20 years for possession of an M-60 machine gun, be handed over to the RUC at the Co Louth border. 
 Sloan has 15 days to appeal. 
 Fish fingers &bquo;overpriced&equo; 
 By BY SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 Fish fingers cost, on a fish-per-pound basis, as much as fresh salmon, researchers said. 
 Most brands analysed by The Food Magazine were less than half fish. 
 The rest was batter and up to 10-20 per cent extra water, the magazine said. 
 Happy Shopper fish fingers contained 49 per cent fish; Findus cod fillet fingers 40 per cent; Findus Crostinos cod fillet 42 per cents; Birds Eye Value fish fingers 45 per cent and Birds Eye cod in wholemeal 44 per cent. 
 At less than 50 per cent fish per portion, fish in this form could cost more than &pound;6 per pound. 
 Call for blasphemy law change 
 By BY SIMON MIDGLEY, Education Reporter 
 One person in three would like blasphemy scrapped as an offence &mdash; but an equal proportion want it extended to cover all religions, not just Christianity, according to a survey published yesterday. 
 Of the 1,792 people over the age of 15 questioned by Public Attitude Survey, 7 per cent believed the law should be the exclusive preserve of Christianity. 
 Most atheists were in favour of abolishing blasphemy while nearly all Muslims wanted it to cover Islam. 
 Women, Roman Catholics and older people preferred the retention of existing laws. 
 Housing crisis forces young to leave dale 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 WENSLEYDALE, better known for its cheese than its housing problems, is facing a serious shortage of houses which is forcing young people to move away from one of the most picturesque parts of the Yorkshire Dales, according to a survey published this week. 
 Some 4,690 Wensleydale households took part in the survey which shows that nearly 10 per cent of local residents need immediate additional accommodation or will do so shortly. 
 The survey for the Wensleydale Housing Forum was conducted by Lancashire Polytechnic and funded jointly by the Yorkshire Dales National Park and Richmondshire District Council with help from the Sanctuary Housing Association and local businesses. 
 The findings, which will be published on Friday, follow concern voiced nationally by the Association of County Councils and other organisations at the plight of young people being forced to leave their home villages for lack of affordable accommodation. 
 The housing forum in Wensleydale was set up to assess the severity of the problem. 
 It hopes the findings of the survey will provide ammunition to press for government funding as well as policy changes to encourage housing associations or similar schemes to help local people. 
 The survey shows that 861 people needed various types of accommodation. 
 It also reveals that 18.9 per cent of households, 434 in all, are made up of people who have retired to the Dales and of these some 54 per cent previously lived outside Yorkshire. 
 Many local people also expressed concern at the number of holiday cottages and second homes in Wensleydale. 
 The survey also highlights the fears of many elderly people about the contraction of local services. 
 One suggestion put forward is that there should be a programme of starter homes, perhaps provided through housing associations. 
 Nigel Watson, chairman of the housing forum, said: &bquo;The survey confirms our fears that there is a problem and it is one which is getting worse as more young people are being forced to leave the dale.&equo; 
 The forum would now use the information to &bquo;press for changes in legislation to enable more money and resources to be directed at the problem, while at the same time doing all we can to enable local people to find local solutions&equo;. 
 Sacked teacher awarded 12,000 pounds 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 A TEACHER who was sacked because some of his lessons were said to be too sexually explicit has won &pound;12,000 compensation for unfair dismissal. 
 The ruling came after a 10-day industrial tribunal hearing at which Robert Nicholson, 58, challenged Birmingham Education Authority's decision to dismiss him. 
 The authority had also accused him of encouraging homosexuality in his religious education lessons. 
 The tribunal was told that Mr Nicholson had shown a vibrator to a class of teenage boys, and also invited pupils to chalk four-letter words on the blackboard and to shout-out &bquo;the F-word&equo; and other swear words. 
 Mr Nicholson said his intention was to make the pupils realise that he could not be shocked. 
 After they had used swear words once in class, he argued, they would never use them again. 
 After being dismissed from his post as head of religious education at King's Norton Boys' School in December 1988, Mr Nicholson began a fight for compensation. 
 His stand was vindicated by the tribunal chairman, John McMillan, who criticised the actions of Birmingham Education Authority. 
 Mr McMillan said: &bquo;They have been guilty of what we would not expect from professional people in the late twentieth century. 
 &bquo;They have seen a phenomenon they believe to be smoke, and with nothing but their personal opinion to guide them, they have promptly pronounced its origins as fire.&equo; 
 He also criticised the authority's principal witness, Diana Harrap, a senior schools adviser. 
 &bquo;Her reports were at the best misleading and at worst untrue reports,&equo; Mr McMillan said. 
 &bquo;Mrs Harrap has a secret and furtive approach to sex education.&equo; 
 Mr Nicholson, of Russell Road, Hall Green, Birmingham, was awarded &pound;12,436 in compensation. 
 He is not seeking re-instatement. 
 After the hearing he said: &bquo;I am so pleased that my character and reputation has been cleared. 
 That is the most important thing.&equo; 
 Police find van owned by murder victim 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 POLICE have found the van belonging to a murdered social worker half-a-mile from the drugs centre where her battered body was found. 
 Detectives said they discovered Elizabeth Page-Alucard's old black Mini van in the car park of an empty DIY warehouse. 
 They immediately started a hunt for any witnesses who may have seen the vehicle during its last journey. 
 A team was also carrying out checks on all 250 addicts registered with the Turning Point drugs centre in Worcester, where the body of Mrs Page-Alucard, aged 41, was found at the weekend. 
 She was reported missing by her boyfriend, Peter Hook, 25, who discovered her body with the help of an official from Turning Point, the drugs advisory charity for which she had worked as a counsellor for three years. 
 Mrs Page-Alucard had apparently been murdered while she was working alone at the centre. 
 Police discovered the Mini van in the warehouse in the nearby City Walls Road while carrying out a systematic search of the whole city. 
 &bquo;The movements of the van form a vital part of our investigation,&equo; Chief Superintendent David Foster, the head of Worcester police, said. 
 &bquo;It seems that it was taken from the car park next to her office but abandoned almost immediately. 
 &bquo;We urgently appeal to anybody who may have seen it during the 48 hours in which it was missing to contact us.&equo; 
 Forensic scientists were examining the vehicle yesterday. 
 Detectives said Mrs Page-Alucard may have been murdered as early as Friday morning, more than 24 hours before her body was discovered. 
 Mr Foster said she was last seen alive at 10.30am on Friday by five people who were registered with the centre. 
 PERFORMANCE ART / The art of performance: Dalya Alberge talks to a newly installed Derek Jarman&hellip; 
 By DALYA ALBERGE 
 &bquo;THEY'RE the forces of evil. 
 The enemy. 
 The scum, the destroyers of British society. 
 A positive evil,&equo; fumed Derek Jarman. 
 The British film director was letting off steam over the tabloid press, citing in harshly-clipped tones the names of the accused. 
 His is a fury fanned by insensitive press coverage of homosexuality and the Aids epidemic; the director best known for films like Caravaggio has leapt at the opportunity of reacting against &bquo;licensed queer bashing&equo;. 
 His plan of attack: an installation for the Glasgow Live Art Festival. 
 Go to the Third Eye Centre tomorrow, and you'll find bed mattresses bolted to the wall, tarred and feathered, and covered in discarded clothes. 
 But the most eye-catching feature will be a bed with two naked men. 
 Last week, Jarman hadn't quite decided whether they were to talk to the audience or simply sleep through the exhibition's four-day run &mdash; &bquo;although they'll be allowed to get up for a pee and lunch,&equo; he added generously. 
 By piercing hundreds of news-cuttings with barbed-wire, Jarman intends his most wounding attack on the tabloids' attitude to homosexuality. 
 The cuttings date back to the beginning of the 1980s: &bquo;If you read these stories day by day, you simply don't realise how many there are. 
 Brought together, the whole view becomes very black. 
 I've also included the particularly unpleasant articles &mdash; sheer malevolence &mdash; written by Jehova's Witnesses. 
 And I'll incorporate crucifixes &mdash; tarred and feathered. 
 I might even have a go at Muslim fundamentalists and have a copy of the Satanic Verses there.&equo; 
 But this is not an attempt to be controversial for the sake of it. 
 Some will no doubt accuse Jarman of shock tactics along Warhol lines, but Jarman has reinforced the view that performance and installation art are at their strongest when addressing social or political issues. 
 &bquo;I have never thought of anything I undertook as provocative. 
 My work came out of the social situation within which I found myself&hellip;&equo; 
 Although Jarman is an avid painter (he exhibited at the ICA in 1984), he did not feel that that medium could extend beyond &bquo;one person's thing&equo;. 
 In a symbolic embrace of victims of suffering, he is making it a participation installation, inviting the public to bring along their own press cuttings and photos of loved ones to attach to the barbed-wire: &bquo;That way, it's like the Berlin wall where people leave messages. 
 We're living behind Clause 28. 
 And I'm giving a voice to the hundreds of people who don't have a voice. 
 It's an incredible responsibility, but I was blessed with a chance to do these things.&equo; 
 It just so happens that Berlin has expressed interest in a loan show. 
 By substituting tar (like a thick black oil) for paint, he intends to prompt thoughts about tar as both preservative and something more sinister &mdash; a symbolic tarring and feathering of Britain's homosexuals. 
 &bquo;While the Danes have just legalised marriage between gay couples, the British have not progressed beyond the Oscar Wilde trial. 
 Gays are still segregated. 
 When, for example, gay films are shown on Channel 4, they're in a different slot. 
 ..&equo; He smarts at media references to Aids as a &bquo;gay plague&equo;. 
 Nowhere is this more plainly spelt out than in the &bquo;programme notes&equo; accompanying the show. 
 &bquo;This is the tip of the iceberg. 
 Being HIV positive, I notice these things.&equo; 
 The installation is at the Live Art festival at the Glasgow Third Eye Centre. 
 Jarman discusses his film-making on Thurs 12 Oct, 6pm; and his painting/installation on Sun 15 Oct, 2pm. 
 Going Out to Galleries: Dalya Alberge selects some of the artists and installations selected for the National Review of Live Art 
 By DALYA ALBERGE 
 BEER tipped on a member of the audience is not everyone's idea of art, let alone a joke. 
 But it was part of a performance by one of the contenders for the Ninth National Review of Live Art. 
 Needless to say, that &bquo;artist&equo; was not selected by Nikki Milican &mdash; the festival's director &mdash; who attended hundreds of events up and down the country. 
 &bquo;I saw some appalling things. 
 It's extraordinary that you still find performers assaulting the audience, commenting on &bquo;anarchy and art&equo;. 
 That's so tired and boring.&equo; 
 Nineteen artists offer installations and performance art. 
 These range from purely aesthetic pieces like Kristel Collison's tape-slide essay on light, to strongly political works like Anne Seagrave's videos on Northern Ireland. 
 And Gary Stevens's performance piece, using toys and animals, is a witty play on ideas of confused identity. 
 But for unconscious humour, the festival catalogue wins the award. 
 On an untitled piece by Richard Downes and Thomas Roper, it reads &bquo;Two performers interact with each other using two heavy concrete curves as a channel for their communication.&equo; 
 Some football hooligans will be familiar with this one. 
 Nikki Milican jumps to their defence: &bquo;It's impossible to talk about performance art and not sound pretentious. 
 But as audiences will find out, we don't have to make apologies for the art. 
 The work proves strong enough.&equo; 
 The National Review of Live Art runs from 11 to 15 October. 
 A selection of the festival artists appears below. 
 (For full details of performances, talks, workshops, contact the Third Eye Centre, 346-354 Sauchiehall St Glasgow (041-332 7521). 
 Lindsay John Wojna! 
 (War!), an &bquo;installation dance&equo; from the West Indian-born visual artist-dancer; and The Bowl, an improvised comic/tragic duet which he promises will be &bquo;minimal, gentle, humorous, elegant and profoundly touching.&equo; 
 His work &mdash; reported as visually stunning &mdash; is influenced by both Japan and East Europe. 
 Richard Layzell Dancing on the Mountain, a new, humorous performance piece in which this seasoned performance-artist choreographs a range of characters. 
 His one-man show takes us through states of mind and body. 
 In the 1970s, he improvised on single props in a room; today, his work is more structured, more theatrical. 
 Gary Stevens Animal &mdash; a new piece inspired by the &bquo;comic, animal-like persona of Stan Laurel&equo;, says Stevens somewhat enigmatically &mdash; will be premiered by a new group of artists and performers. 
 Images and effigies of animals and people observed with bemused curiosity. 
 Characters are apparently motiveless, compulsive liars, who shy from eye contact. 
 It's a strange piece, but a humorous one. 
 Anne Seagrave Video works by this Brighton College of Art graduate. 
 Strong political statements commenting on Ireland where she has lived for the past two years. 
 Richard Downes and Thomas Roper A dialogue-free performance combining movement and sculptural elements. 
 Two heavy concrete curves are their channel of communication&hellip; 
 &bquo;A continuous exploration of the material and of their relationship to each other.&equo; 
 It's a &bquo;sculptural&equo; piece, in which the performers' bodies become a continuation of the sculptural pieces. 
 Alison Inkpen Sometimes you can't hear the Screaming &mdash; an installation about the waste of human energy, both physical and emotional. 
 The performance revolves round rows of hissingly-hot pressure cookers, which are brought to the point of pressure; suspended above them are boxes of ice, with nails and bits and pieces, which drop on to the pressure cooker lids as the ice melts. 
 It's a &bquo;sound-visual sculpture&equo;. 
 Sebastiane Installation/performance about the artist's relationship with his father. 
 An atmospheric piece, revolving round a white shrine to his father, complete with icons and religious objects. 
 Fast Food Zoo 33&frac13; RPM &mdash; a piece of &bquo;physical and visual theatre&equo; &mdash; looks at role, definition and relevance of the individual to revolutions &mdash; both political and sexual. 
 Performers are five recent graduates of Bristol University, who felt revolutions were topical in the light of the bicentennial of the French Revolution and events in China. 
 The performance is dance, rather than scripted theatre, without dialogue apart from the soundtrack. 
 &bquo;It's more of a movement piece, with art being created with slides and other material,&equo; says Dean Byfield, one of the performers. 
 Brian Hand An installation of slide, video, found objects, text and image &mdash; all used to &bquo;explore origins, coincidences and inter-relationships between concepts and phenomena &bquo;normally&equo; not felt to be related within Irish history.&equo; 
 Mark Hudson Out of the strong came forth the sweetness Not so much an installation as a duration piece created with treacle and sugar cubes. 
 Thematic ingredients are wide-ranging &mdash; issues of race, class, dietary control, patriotism and patronage of the arts. 
 Mineo Aayamuguchi An important video artist, whose work is concerned with aesthetics rather than issues. 
 The latest work, Phosphor, is an exploration of the relationship &bquo;between the human eye and its ability to make sense of colour, shape and light.&equo; 
 Random sounds are produced by banging together various objects and computers. 
 Daniel Reeves A fusion of performance and installation. 
 Smothering Dreams, like most of his work, is about the Vietnam War &mdash; the myths, the realities. 
 &bquo;It's a great privilege to have Reeves,&equo; enthuses Nikki Milican. 
 &bquo;He's such an important video artist worldwide, known particularly well in the United States where he has won numerous awards.&equo; 
 Mehdi Moghadassi If past performances are anything to go by, this should be quite a disturbing work. 
 Believing that an artist has to suffer to make his statement, he puts himself through dangerous sequences like cutting off his breathing. 
 Can be unnerving. 
 Kristel Collison A gentle tape-slide work that uses the surfaces of a room's walls to play with light and shadow. 
 PICTURE CHOICE / A sublimely sensual state of limbo: Choreographer Ashley Page selects Painting by the Surrealist, Miro 
 By ASHLEY PAGE 
 Painting, 1927, by Joan Miro, the Spanish painter regarded as the greatest of all Surrealist abstract artists. 
 He once said that &bquo;form is never something abstract; it is a always a sign of something. 
 It is always a man, a bird, or something else&equo;. 
 Tate Gallery Millbank SW1 (821 1212) Mon-Sat 10am-5.50pm, Sun 2-5.50pm. 
 Copyright: ADAGP, Paris/DACS, London, 1989 The first thing that I feel when I look at Miro's Painting is a sense of sublime calm. 
 The beautiful blue groundwash is so sensuously placid and dreamlike (almost aquatic), and the simple but elegant forms and lines animate the scene, producing in me a state of quiet limbo. 
 I prefer to retain my initial response to this as an abstract work, although I realise that Miro and his fellow Surrealists were strongly opposed to the abstract movement. 
 He was influenced by the leading French poets of his time: images seem drawn from Apollinaire's play, Les Mamelles de Tiresias, including the large white form dominating the left of the canvas which, according to Miro, is a horse. 
 Should we just enjoy the things that touch us in a painting or should it spur us on to learn more? 
 I know that I will continue to get great pleasure from simply looking at this beautiful image. 
 Going Out to Galleries: OPENINGS / Erotic fantasy comes to the ICA while Pre-Raphaelites gather in the North East&hellip; 
 By ASHLEY PAGE 
 OPENINGS LONDON AIR GALLERY Dave Mulholland, a Newcastle-born artist who has worked in locations as diverse as New York and Durham, and has organised community mural projects in London and the North-east, has his first solo exhibition at the Air Gallery in Islington, writes Paul Dunn. 
 He describes his work - which includes oils, watercolours and ink as well as sculptures in plaster and wood &mdash; as &bquo;dramatic and moody&equo; with a subjective approach to its main themes of people and landscapes. 
 &bquo;The show will not have a thematic finished look but will show a potential to move in several directions,&equo; he says. 
 6 &amp; 8 Roseberry Avenue London EC1. 
 Tuesday 10 October to Saturday 14. 
 ALPINE GALLERY An auction of contemporary art: a percentage of proceeds goes to ARK, the environmental organisation. 
 Also, a show of figurative work by Robert Plisnier, in his first public show. 
 On view from today; auction takes place, tomorrow 6pm. 
 Exhibition from Thurs-Sat. 74 South Audley St W1 Full details 629 2280/821 9401. 
 HEIM GALLERY Masterpieces from Tabley House &mdash; an important collection of British art that includes Turner and Lawrence. 
 The pictures were assembled during the 1900s by Sir John Leicester, a close friend of George IV who went on the Grand Tour but who, unlike many of his contemporaries, remained faithful to living British artists. 
 He was later made Lord de Tabley, in recognition of his arts patronage. 
 Tabley House is the 3,000-acre estate near Knutsford, which he inherited in 1770 at the age of eight. 
 In 1818, he opened a gallery in Mayfair, showing British paintings, watercolours and sculptures; in 1823, he offered ten major oil paintings by Turner to the nation &mdash; to start a national gallery of modern British art. 
 The offer was turned down by the then philistine government (history repeats itself?) and the collection returned to Tabley House. 
 59 Jermyn St St James's SW1 From 12 Oct, to 21 Nov Mon-Fri 10am-6pm. 
 INSTITUTE OF CONTEMPORARY ARTS Surrealism and erotic fantasy are recurring themes in a retrospective on Meret Oppenheim, the German-Swiss artist, who for a time was a model and follower of Man Ray. 
 But the conflict between the grotesque and the melancholy never obscures humour: Surrealist objects like a tea-cup made useless by fur; and a pair of white shoes, presented on a platter with heels bound like the legs of a roast chicken in frilly paper. 
 The Mall SW1 (930 0495). 
 From 13 Oct, to 3 Dec. 
 MICHAELSON &amp; ORIENT At a gallery specialising in ceramics, a show devoted to the distinguished British ceramicist, Henry Pim. 
 In his most recent work, he has moved away from elaborate vessels and on to rough-textured jigsaw-like pieces &mdash; the ceramicist's equivalent of collage. 
 318 Portobello Rd W10 (969 4119) From 11 Oct, to 4 Nov. 
 SMITH'S GALLERIES Start saving for the Contemporary Art Society Market, the Cash and Carry Art &mdash; the Sainsbury's-sponsored event &mdash; which returns at the end of the month to Covent Garden. 
 It is a chance to select from over 100 artists, and 1,000 paintings, drawings and sculptures at prices from &pound;100 to &pound;1,000. 
 Purchases can be taken away immmediately. 
 If the previous five markets are anything to go by, works will be grabbed from the walls and plinths while organisers rush to replace them with other works. 
 Last year, 767 works were sold to 410 people in four days. 
 This time, it runs an extra day and there will be more sculpture. 
 25 Neal St WC2 (Details: 821 5323) From Tuesday 31 Oct, to 4 Nov. 
 NEWCASTLE-UPON-TYNE LAING ART GALLERY Pre-Raphaelites: Painters and Patrons in the North East. 
 An exhibition that brings together (for the first time in over a century) the Pre-Raphaelites' paintings, sculpture and decorative arts that decorated the houses of the region's Victorian industrialists and entrepreneurs. 
 It shows how wealth, created through shipbuilding, iron, lead and armaments manufacture, was redirected towards cultural development. 
 Among exhibits are Isabella and the Pot of Basil, 1867 &mdash; one of William Holman Hunt's most important paintings, illustrating Keats's poem. 
 Includes a set-piece display recreating the interior of one of the patron's private houses &mdash; complete with pictures by Rossetti and Burne-Jones. (091-232 7734) From 14 Oct, to 15 Jan Tues-Fri 10am-5.30pm, Sat 10am-4.30pm, Sun 2.30-5.30pm; &pound;1 (40p concs). 
 PLYMOUTH MUSEUM &amp; ART GALLERY The last self-portrait by Sir Joshua Reynolds -regarded by many as his finest &mdash; is among a small group of 17th and 18th-century paintings loaned from the Royal Collection at Windsor Castle. 
 Reynolds also appears as the central figure in Zoffany's group portrait of all 36 founder members of the Royal Academy, of which he was first President. 
 Zoffany, George III's favourite artist, is represented by his detailed portrait of King George III, Queen Charlotte and their six eldest children. 
 Drake Circus (0752-668000) From 14 Oct, to 13 May 1990. 
 STIRLING SMITH ART GALLERY The Smith Biennial &mdash; open show for artists living in Scotland. 
 This year, new work by 20 artists includes sculptures, paintings, installations, drawings. 
 No restrictions were made on entries, but positive encouragement was given to artists &bquo;working in new ways&equo;. 
 The final selection was made after studio visits. 
 Artists include Louise and Jane Wilson, who comment on their relationship as twins through a photographic-sculptural work &mdash; their identical degree show at Dundee and Newcastle. 
 Dumbarton Rd (0786-71917) From 13 Oct, 26 Nov. 
 PICCADILLY CIRCUS It may be wise to keep your eyes on the traffic, but when you've reached the island, look up to the Spectacolor board above the corner of Haymarket and Coventry Street. 
 You'll see Circus Diver by Tina Keane - one of the latest artists commissioned by Artangel, an organisation which specialises in promoting public art in &bquo;high visibility territory&equo;. 
 Tina Keane, an experimental artist whose materials are film and video, explores ideas about female identity and beauty. 
 Every four minutes daily between 8am and midnight. 
 To 31 Oct. 
 VICTORIA AND ALBERT MUSEUM The Art of Design: Edward Bawden, an artist who began his career studying calligraphy and went on to master the art of book illustration, printmaking, poster design, advertising. 
 His technical command of artistic processes never obscured his sense of humour. 
 Henry Cole Wing Exhibition Rd SW7 (938 8361) To 29 Oct Mon-Thurs, Sat 10am-5pm, Sun 2.30-5pm. 
 WADDINGTON GALLERIES David Inshaw, the Staffordshire artist, still turns to the landscape as his main source of inspiration. 
 But the presence of man is always evident, whether in prehistoric mounds or stone circles. 
 12 Cork St (437 8611) To 28 Oct. 
 SOUTHAMPTON City Art Gallery 100 Years of Russian Art &mdash; transferred from the Barbican and Oxford. 
 The first major show to examine the development of Russian art over the last century. 
 Includes works by Chagall, Malevich, Rodchenko and Popova &mdash; all lent by private collectors. 
 (0703-832769) To 12 Nov. 
 Competition results: Monty Python, Lords and Commons Cricket 
 By ASHLEY PAGE 
 Asked to name the title of the first episode of Monty Python's Flying Circus on BBCTV, only three readers correctly answered &bquo;Whither Canada&equo;; many more correctly completed the Lumberjack Song verse as &bquo;he puts on women's clothing and hangs around in bars&equo;. 
 Congratulations, and sets of Just The Words to J Howard, Birmingham; S Bryant, London W13; M Walker, Wirral. 
 Nearly-right prizes to T Jenks, London W14 and M Flett, Edinburgh. 
 The answer to our Lords And Commons Cricket Competition is as follows: the three England Captains to have played for the LCC are Lord Harris, Sir Stanley Jackson MP and Lord Tennyson. 
 Mrs M Brett from Norfolk receives a copy of Ian Orr-Ewing's Celebration Of Lords And Commons Cricket. 
 COMEDY / Tristan Davies on a free speech benefit with no expletives deleted: The four letter offensive 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 Outside the comfy confines of Saturday night television, comedians &mdash; from Bernard Manning to Bob Monkhouse &mdash; are a pretty vulgar lot. 
 And the language, like the seating, is worst in fringe comedy clubs. 
 Where Cannon &amp; Ball have made &bquo;Rock on, Tommy&equo; their trademark, and Jim Davidson is known as &bquo;Nick Nick&equo;, there is a comic on the &bquo;alternative&equo; circuit known simply as &bquo;Two Fingers&equo; Soan, and another, Malcolm Hardee, who goes by the catchphrase &bquo;F**k it&equo;. 
 Those four little letters could cost Hardee more than the walkouts he has grown used to. 
 On Sunday night at London's Red Rose Cabaret, run by Ivor Dembina (erstwhile member of Comic Abuse), a benefit going by the name of F**k was held for cabaret performance poet Joolz. 
 Attilla The Stockbroker, a suitably offensive looking poet-comedian, took to the stage to tell an unusually large Sunday night crowd why they were there. 
 &bquo;Joolz, myself and New Model Army were playing an anti-fascist gig in Leeds Town Centre. 
 Joolz was cautioned by the police for swearing at a heckler who swore at her. 
 I was told that if I swore my performance would be stopped.&equo; 
 Joolz was fined &pound;100 for contravening the Public Order Act. 
 Top of the Red Rose bill was Gerry Sadowitz, a comedian who, if he played Leeds Town Centre, could expect, at &pound;100 per F-word, to lose close to quarter of a million in the course of a routine. 
 Perhaps heeding the catchphrase of his manager, Malcom Hardee, he failed to show. 
 Those who came included the food-obsessed Jo Brand ('I thought it was a &bquo;Fork benefit&equo;); Marks Thomas and Miwurdz; Michael Redmond; The Comedy Store Players; and Mark Steel ('I know it's not trendy to say so any more but I just hate the police. 
 They're just so sarcastic. 
 Sarcasm must be part of the course at Hendon'). 
 Only Arnold Brown ran slightly against the grain. 
 &bquo;I don't think it's very intelligent to swear,&equo; said Brown, squinting in an atmosphere thicker with smoke than obscenity. 
 &bquo;There's a time and a place for it. 
 If I was walking down a street and some scaffolding fell on my head I wouldn't say &bquo;oh dear&equo;.' 
 He even showed some sympathy for the police. 
 &bquo;The Left always say police are bastards&hellip; until their video is stolen&hellip;&equo; 
 He places an air-phone to his ear &bquo;Can you send a bastard round please&hellip;&equo; 
 The money raised by the benefit is being put into a defence fund, pending Joolz's appeal against the fine. 
 &bquo;The money's not important, but the implications are mind-boggling,&equo; Atilla reminded us, &bquo;&hellip; that if you say anything more offensive than &bquo;Crystal Palace&equo; in your performance then you are liable to get nicked.&equo; 
 A selection of the best live comedy around the country in the week ahead 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 Archaos The Last Show On Earth as envisaged by this French circus troupe is a mixture of Mad Max, The Great Rock'n'Roll Swindle and Billy Smart. 
 Fine strong-man/trapeze element, brilliant trick biker, ridiculous clowns, sublime running gags, over-hyped, under-used chainsaws, expensive tickets (&pound;8) but a great night out. 
 Big Top, Clapham Common, SW4 (498 1528) Tue-Sun 8.30pm (Sat mat 3pm) To 27 Oct. 
 Flying Pickets Veterans of the alternative circuit, a capella one-and-a-bit hit wonders who have put their signatures to show themes (remember the accompaniment to the floating condoms in Porterhouse Blue?), here with a show of sketch-like songs loosely based on the theme of &bquo;work&equo;. 
 Different. 
 Theatre Royal, Gerry Raffles Square, E15 (534 0310) 8pm To 14 Oct. 
 Perrier Pick of the Fringe The provocative South African satirist Peter Dirk Uys (9.30pm to 14 Oct) plus the surreal, but this year more accessible cabaret/theatre duo The Front Lawn (11.15 12-14 Oct only) in the last week of the Edinburgh Festival Perrier panel's choice of the fringe. 
 Donmar Warehouse, Earlham Street, WC2 (240 8230). 
 Hot Club Not only are the Paris Studio recordings free (for those who are prompt), you have the added novelty of watching comedy on the radio. 
 This recording for a R4 comedy show has Arthur Smith, Josie Lawrence, Richard Vranch and Ronnie Golden behind the mikes. 
 Paris Studios, Lower Regent Street, SW1. 
 Doors 7.15, no admission after 7.25pm. 
 FRIDAY Alex Langdon is the fourteen-year-old son of satirical scriptwriter John (Punch Newsrevue, and Rory Bremner gag writer) who delivered some of his father's best lines at this year's Edinburgh Festival. 
 Brave though he is in facing adult audiences, the result is a bit of a cringe. 
 With Al &amp; George (see Today), and the agreeably laid-back Irish comedian Sean Hughes. 
 Old White Horse, Brixton Road (487 3440) 9pm. 
 Chris Luby by day is a customs and excise inspector, by night a Human Aeroplane. 
 He warms up with the march-past of the Brigade of Guards, before wheeling out his spitfire, moving on to jet fighters and finishing, if he's in a good mood, with dogfights and acrobatics. 
 Despite his airforce fatigues (he has a pilot's licence) and handlebar moustache (he is a cult on the military base circuit) his feet never leave the ground: but close your eyes and you'd never know it. 
 A real novelty. 
 With Jenny Lecoat, Tracy Brothers, The Two Marks, Owen O'Neal and compere Tony Morewood. 
 Jongleurs, The Cornet, 49 Lavender Gardens, SW11 (780 1151) 9.30pm. 
 Also Sat. 
 SATURDAY Nick Hancock Hugely enjoyable blast-off comedian who, like some smirking, behind-the-sheds schoolboy takes a list of his pet hates out of his pocket, lays them out and talks you through them one by one. 
 His bald routine is tear-inducing, and, in a show devoid of malice, there are few hairy moments. 
 With Simon Bligh, Ronnie Golden, Lynn Thomas, Mark Westwood, and compere Maria Callous. 
 Red Rose Club, 129 Seven Sisters Road, N7 (263 7265). 
 The Panic Brothers Although the patter of the camp, grey-haired one between songs can irritate, his tenor combined with the falsetto of the otherwise silent, red-haired, red-faced one produces a pleasing pastiche of the Everlys. 
 With Lee Cornes, Alan Davies, Doon and compere Ivor Dembina. 
 South of Deptford, 51 Woolwich New Road, SE18 (317 8687) 8.30pm. 
 BLACKPOOL Jim Davidson A truly blue comic for Tory Party conference week. 
 Anything after his terrible sitcom Home James has got to be an improvement, hasn't it? 
 Opera House, Suns to 29 Oct 8pm, 0253-27786. 
 BOURNEMOUTH Russ Abbot Silly wigs, voices and costumes from the man who once rocked the charts with &bquo;Oh What An Atmosphere&equo;. 
 Pavilion Today-Sat. 
 BRIGHTON Mark Steel is a comic who should be returned to at irregular intervals: see him too often (and he is all over London) and you tire of his south London patter, but go back to his schoolroom lesson after a break from the circuit, or see him off his home patch and you'll enjoy an exercise bookful of character face-pulling, energetic storytelling and witty, like-it-is observations. 
 With Jungr &amp; Parker and compere Pete McCarthy. 
 The Concorde, off Palace Pier. 
 Thur 9pm. 
 LIVERPOOL Chris Lynham His party piece is placing a banger between his cheeks and setting it off. 
 With Sean Hughes and Auntie. 
 Trader Jacks, 21 Berry Street. 
 Thur 9pm. 
 NORWICH In between screenings of such classic nasties as Teeth of Death, The Belly Film and Die Baby Die, comedians John Erwin and Geoff Green will be expected to gag (comically speaking) and the Norwich Women's Soul Choir to sing. 
 Malcolm Hardee will be there &bquo;to ensure the smooth running of this Big Night Out&equo; say the management, who may not be aware that the presence of Martin &bquo;Two Fingers Soan&equo; on the bill may lead to an impromptu, and far from smooth reunion of the two's infamous Greatest Show on Legs. 
 Norwich Arts Centre, Reeve's Yard, St Benedict's St (0603-660352) Sat 8pm. 
 Special Edition The special edition of the title is a kind of newspaper, entirely filled by a one-man, sound-off column penned by Simon Fanshawe about the media and its presentation of news and current affairs. 
 Excellent. 
 The Drill Hall Arts Centre, 16 Chenies Street, WC1 (637 8270) from 14 November. 
 Sport in Short: Volleyball 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 MONICA SELES, the Yugoslav who has withdrawn from the Midland Bank Championships at Brighton later this month, is to be contacted by tournament organisers hoping for a change of heart. 
 Sport in Short: Table Tennis 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Swimming 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Speedway 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Snooker 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 JAMES WATTANA, 19, from Thailand, has broken the world table clearance record with a time of 3min 45sec in Brussels. 
 Sport in Short: Rugby Union 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Ice Hockey 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Hockey 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 NATIONWIDE ANGLIA CUP First round:: Camberley v RAOC; Spencer v Blackheath; Staines v Horsham; Eastcote v Lensbury; Hampstead v National West Bank; Gerrards Cross v Old Edwardians; Enfield v Hayes; Aylesbury v High Wycombe; Old Tauntonians v Tulse Hill; City of Portsmouth v Sunbury; Winchester v Wokingham; Goan v Cheam; Fareham v Trojans; Oxted v Tunbridge Wells; Beckenham v Bicester; Mid Surrey v Old Merchant Taylors; Purley v Witney; Oxford Hawks v Tonbridge; Old Kingstonians v Bognor; Midland Bank v Mid Sussex; Marden Russetts v Wellington College; Tilehurst v Crawley; Blueharts v Harleston Magpies; Pelicans v Westcliff; Old Southendians v Ipswich; West Herts v Bedford; Ipswich &amp; Suffolf v Bury St Edmunds; Cambridge Nomads v St Neot's; Colchester v Norwich Grasshoppers; Letchworth v Long Sutton; Chelmsford v RAF; Leighton Buzzard v Wisbech; Appleby Frodingham v Bishop's Stortford; Olton &amp; West Warwick v GEC Coventry; Barford Tigers v South Nottingham; Bloxwich v Belper; Shrewsbury v Northampton Stains; Handsworth Eagles v Pickwick; Gyymfit v Khalsa (Warks); John Player v Derwent; Wombourne v Kidderminster; Lichfield v Worcester Norton; Edgbaston v Leicester Westleigh; Hightown Northern v Liverpool Sefton; Durham University v Harrogate; Tynemouth v Ben Rhydding; Bowden v Mancehster; Timperley v Chorlton; Carlisle v Preston; Ramgharia v Adel; Swalwell v Aderley Edge; Bacchanalians (IOM) v Stockton; Sheffield v Seaton Carew; Formby v Bradford; Sheffield Bankers v Brooklands; Jersey v Bath; Firebrands v Gloucester City or Cheltenham; Westbury v East Devon; Newquay v Marlborough; Exeter Crickets v Plymouth; RN Portsmouth Comm v Bournemouth &amp; West Hants; Bristol v Leominster; Swindon v Yatton. 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 GREAT BRITAIN and Ireland won the women's world amateur team betterball championship by one stroke in 72-hole event at Sao Fernando, near Sao Paulo, Brazil. 
 Helen Dobson, the 18-year-old British matchplay and strokeplay champion from Skegness, and Elaine Farquharson, the 21-year-old from Aberdeen had a two-under-par final round of 69 for a six-under total of 278. 
 Sport in Short: Football 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 YOUNG BOYS of Berne have dismissed their Swedish coach, Tord Grip, because of poor results. 
 Pal Csernai, a Hungarian in charge of Bayern Munich when they won the Bundesliga in 1980 and &bquo;81, takes over until the end of the season. 
 Sport in Short: Cycling 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 JANIE EICKHOFF won the women's tempo and points races on Sunday to lead the United States to a surprise victory in the three-day World Invitational, at California State University. 
 PAUL SHERWEN, manager of the Raleigh-Banana professional team, is to attend a disciplinary hearing in Stoke-on-Trent to explain the behaviour of his team. 
 Sherwen, the former Tour de France rider and British champion, faces a charge of &bquo;conduct prejudicial to the good order of the sport&equo; after Raleigh's absence from two domestic races in September &mdash; allegedly without permission &mdash; when the team competed on the Continent instead. 
 Sport in Short: Cycle Speedway 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Cricket 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 IMRAN KHAN, the Pakistan captain, has called for an overhaul of Pakistan cricket to combat what he describes as widespread &bquo;nepotism and favouritism&equo;. 
 NOTTINGHAMSHIRE are searching for financial backers for an extension to the new &pound;500,000 William Clarke stand, at Trent Bridge. 
 Work on the stand has already begun and the club are hoping to extend the plans to include seven executive boxes and a press box. 
 THE Test and County Cricket Board has announced two changes to the itinerary for New Zealand's tour to Britain next season. 
 The one-day MCC v New Zealand match will be played on Monday, 7 May, instead of Tuesday, 8 May, and the two matches between Somerset and New Zealand, on 16 and 17 May, have been converted into a three-day match on 16 to 18 May. 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 By TRISTAN DAVIES 
 GLENN McCRORY, the 25-year-old British cruiserweight who defends his IBF title against the South African Siza Makhatini in Middlesbrough on 21 October, said yesterday that his long-term target is still to challenge Mike Tyson, who he used to spar with. 
 &bquo;I fulfilled a childhood dream when I became champion in June, but Tyson is the ultimate dream.&equo; 
 McCrory said. 
 Sport in Short: Basketball 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Baseball 
 Sport Page 37 
 Allan Lamb and an ox 
 Sport Page 37 
 Cricket: Inquest looks for a victim: Derek Hodgson examines the problems facing today's gathering of the Headingley hierarchy 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 NOT for almost five years has it been thought necessary to preview a meeting of the General Committee of the Yorkshire County Cricket Club but today, at 5.30pm at Headingley, the 22 members will gather knowing that once again they wil be under intense scrutiny by the media. 
 In short, Yorkshire, the club with 31 Championships, are in crisis again. 
 The first reason for the meeting is that it is 21 years ago since the last title was won. 
 The second is that Yorkshire finished 1989 four points from the bottom with a one-day record almost as poor; it seems there has been no improvement, nor is one in sight. 
 That recent moment of glory, the Benson and Hedges Cup win at Lord's in 1987, can now be seen to have been illusory. 
 Today's meeting, which the club's bete noire, Geoffrey Boycott, is not expected to attend in his capacity as the member for Wakefield, is an inquest into last summer. 
 There will be no conclusions today because, says chairman Brian Walsh, &bquo;the committee felt it necessary to find time for a full discussion on cricket outside of the agenda planned for the next scheduled meeting on 26 October.&equo; 
 The decisions will be voted upon at the later date. 
 There is much to talk about. 
 The captain, Phil Carrick, last month put the cat among the pigeons, or his head upon the block (depending upon each Yorkshireman's point of view on his county's cricket, without which no Tyke is properly dressed) by writing a letter, with his players' support, in which he advocated the abandonment of the holy writ, the birth qualification. 
 Carrick suggested that a maximum of three outside players should be recruited &mdash; one an overseas professional &mdash; to strengthen the team immediately. 
 &bquo;No&equo; thundered the vast majority of every poll conducted by newspapers, radio and television, members and public alike. 
 Carrick's argument, that of the man who earns his living playing the game, would make sense anywhere but in the Ridings: without the addition of a West Indian fast bowler and the option of adding two more experienced outside players, says Carrick, the chances of his youngish team ever winning trophies and thus making money, are severely limited. 
 Without incentives, goes the argument, the drift of talented young players towards more successful counties, with open doors, will accelerate. 
 His supporters, including some in the Yorkshire media, point out the difficulty in attracting sponsorship to an unsuccessful team and a slow decline in the membership figures. 
 For most of this century Yorkshire have boasted the highest membership outside MCC; Lancashire now lead them by more than 2,000. 
 So what is to be done? 
 The first target tonight will be Brian Close, the former Yorkshire and England captain and now chairman of the cricket sub-committee, on which he is supported by such luminaries as Bob Appleyard, Phil Sharpe, Bryan Stott and Bob Platt, all ex-players. 
 They will have to answer for the team's performances and can expect to be closely questioned on how often they saw those performances. 
 Close has an insurance business to run, an excuse that will be accepted. 
 He will find it less easy to defend his involvement with a cricket call-line service last summer, a job that some will say kept him from his Yorkshire priority. 
 There will be criticism that team discipline off the field is wanting, a complaint that has surfaced with reasonable regularity since before Lord Hawke's time. 
 The difference is, it will be quickly pointed out, is that Hawke's teams were winners. 
 There has been some fairly loose and wide-ranging sniping about inept leadership (Carrick) and incompetence (the committee). 
 Everyone agrees that something will have to be seen to be done before the next annual general meeting in February. 
 But what can be done? 
 Recruiting outsiders is a dead duck for the moment; another five years of failure and the time may yet come. 
 Bringing home the exiles is a possible option (James Whitaker, Bill Athey, Steven Rhodes) but players of this class will not be lured back easily, for the reasons above. 
 Changing the captain must be a strong possibility, not least because Carrick himself looked a little weary of wearing the crown of thorns. 
 The dressing room needs a sense of a new direction: Martyn Moxon is the official vice-captain. 
 He has experience of leadership at all levels, as has his possible successor Ashley Metcalfe. 
 The other alternative is to promote Neil Hartley, Ray Illingwoth's choice as a future captain five years ago, from the second team. 
 If Moxon, still young in captaincy terms, were to be given the job there would be a strong argument in favour of a team manager and as Illingworth, perhaps wisely, has rejected one offer to return (from Leicestershire) Yorkshire might look at another native son who has, from all accounts, done an excellent job in his first year of managment at Somerset, Jack Birkenshaw. 
 Another possible candidate is MCC's highly successful head coach, Don Wilson. 
 There will also be talk of a return by Boycott, who has always been open in admitting that he would like to be either cricket chairman or team manager. 
 His weakness is that he has only four or five votes on the committee and his intermittent appearances and lack of involvement in either the Headingley School or the Bradford Academy will count against him, all past prejudices apart. 
 The key figure tonight will be Dennis Brian Close. 
 He still has sufficient force, passion and reputation to get his way if he puts his case forcefully enough and yesterday he spent some time in conclave with Carrick, Neil Hartley and coach Doug Padgett. 
 But even Close cannot answer the crucial question. 
 A survey by Don Mosey, helped by the Yorkshire Cricket Association, three years ago revealed that there were 1,798 clubs in organised cricket leagues in the county. 
 Assuming that each club fields only two teams they will represent almost 40,000 players. 
 So why is it, for almost the first time in 150 years, Yorkshire cannot contribute a single regular member to the England team? 
 Not just Yorkshire but all England needs to know. 
 Cricket: Stewart feels the heat 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 MICKY STEWART, the England manager, gave his son, Alec, a gruelling introduction to cricket on the Indian sub-continent when he put the Surrey wicketkeeper-batsmen &mdash; along with the rest of the 14-man England squad - through a three-and-a-half hour training session in temperatures of up to 100F at the National Stadium in Delhi yesterday. 
 &bquo;Just a short sprint leaves you struggling for breath,&equo; said the younger Stewart, on his first tour with England. 
 &bquo;Can you imagine what it's like when it's really hot out here?&equo; 
 England, who have arranged two practice games against local sides later this week, play their first match in the six-team Nehru Trophy against Sri Lanka on Sunday. 
 Australia, India, Pakistan and the West Indies complete the line-up for the one-day competition. 
 Baseball: Henderson steals show to leave Toronto in tatters: Richard Weekes reports on a weekend which saw the Oakland Athletics reach baseball's World Series 
 By RICHARD WEEKES 
 BEFORE the Oakland Athletics began their American League Championship series against the Toronto Blue Jays it was said that the team had a crucial flaw: when their celebrated home-run hitters were not peppering the upper decks, the A's supposedly found it tough to manufacture runs base by base with base hits, steals and sacrifice flies. 
 After Rickey Henderson had finished with the Blue Jays on Sunday &mdash; in a 4-3 victory &mdash; to take the A's through to their second World Series in a row, that analysis looked a trifle dumb. 
 The Oakland left fielder, a unanimous choice as the series' most valuable player, put on a display of aggressive running between the bases that had Toronto in tatters. 
 His total of eight stolen bases in the A's 4-1 series victory was a post-season record, he scored eight runs in total and even managed a couple of homers himself in Saturday's 6-5 win in the SkyDome. 
 In all he was involved in 11 of Oakland's 26 runs over the series. 
 &bquo;This was the Rickey Henderson Show,&equo; Dave Parker, the Athletics' pitcher and designated hitter, said. 
 &bquo;I've been involved in a few of these things but I've never seen anyone bring it up to the level he did &mdash; he turned it up a few notches.&equo; 
 Henderson did get a little help from his friends, in particular a massive 484ft third-inning home run from Jose Canseco on Saturday that came within 13 rows of hitting the roof of the SkyDome but dropped instead into the hands of a surprised Toronto fan. 
 And there was some nerveless relief pitching from Dennis Eckersley to secure the final out on Sunday after the Blue Jays had briefly rekindled hopes of a miracle by reducing the deficit to 4-3 with two runs in the ninth inning of game five. 
 Parker, Oakland's starting pitcher, had gone a full eight innings before George Bell finally broke his hit-left streak by depositing the ball over the left-field fence. 
 Eckersley then took over, conceded another run when Tony Fernandez scored on a sacrifice fly but stayed cool enough to strike out Junior Felix and end the game. 
 &bquo;We had our chances,&equo; Bell said. 
 &bquo;We just couldn't come out with the key hits. 
 That's the way it is. 
 If you start thinking about this game it will drive you crazy.&equo; 
 While the Blue Jays licked their wounds, the Athletics began the celebrations prior to hosting the first two games of the World Series at the Coliseum next weekend. 
 Last night the Giants, their neighbours from across the San Francisco Bay, sealed the National League championship series against the Chicago Cubs, winning 3-2 to complete a 4-1 victory and take their first pennant for 27 years. 
 The odds had turned towards the Giants on Sunday after a 6-4 win at Candlestick Park. 
 Matt Williams seized on some poor Cubs pitching to drive in four of the Giants runs and Will Clark lifting his series batting average to .625 when he reached base on three of his four at-bats. 
 Yesterday, Clark improved his average with a tie-breaking, two-run single in the eighth inning &mdash; and a record 13th hit of the series &mdash; to give him a .650 average in the play-offs. 
 Rallying: Auriol flies off the track in Tuscany 
 By RICHARD WEEKES 
 LANCIA'S new 16-valve Integrale had a disastrous debut at the San Remo Rally yesterday. 
 Didier Auriol, the French driver, drove off the road in Tuscany and wrote off his new car in the fifth special stage, while Massimo Biasion, the Italian world champion, suffered a puncture in the next special stage. 
 Lancia still ended the first day in the lead, but Alessandro Fiorio's Integrale was one of the old-style standard versions that have dominated the world championship for the past two years. 
 Before the setbacks, the new Lancias had passed their tests with flying colours. 
 Auriol and Biasion tore through the first four special stages to take a commanding lead. 
 But the Frenchman fell victim during the first off-road stage turning his car over several times. 
 He climbed out leaving the car upended on its roof. 
 Biasion's puncture cost him two minutes and he ended the day two minutes and six seconds behind Fiorio. 
 Tennis: Reissen to pursue Evert 
 From Our Correspondent in Tokyo 
 WITH all the youngsters now invading the tennis world, it was somewhat ironic, perhaps even worrying, that Chris Evert turned out to be the heroine of the 27th Federation Cup, in Tokyo, which ended yesterday with a predictable victory for the United States. 
 Arantxa Sanchez Vicario, 17, made a late charge into the hearts of the fans by putting the frighteners on Martina Navratilova, to race through the first set 6-0, in just 25 minutes, cracking winners at every opportunity. 
 But as Navratilova, although looking somewhat shaky, recovered to win the next two sets 6-3, 6-4, to complete the victory over Spain, there was no stealing Evert's thunder. 
 The 34-year-old American survived the week without dropping a set. 
 She was again impressive yesterday as she dispatched Conchita Martinez, another 17-year-old, who is ranked 10th in the world, 6-3, 6-2. 
 It was the sort of match Evert has grown to hate. 
 It was full of long baseline rallies that sap the concentration and the patience. 
 Somehow, though, Evert remained razor sharp throughout the 78-minute examination, and for good reason. 
 &bquo;I came here at the beginning of the week thinking that this was my last tournament for the year, maybe forever,&equo; Evert said. 
 &bquo;What better note to end it on than to win in a team situation and when you are playing for your country? 
 If this is it, I am sure I am going out on the highest note possible.&equo; 
 Whether Evert has, in fact, bowed out from the sport she has graced for two decades remains to been seen. 
 Today, she has hot-footed it to Kyushu, on Japan's southern-most tip, to play an exhibition against Navratilova. 
 It is one of many planned between now and April. 
 Indeed, should Marty Reissen, the US captain, get his way, Evert could return to his line-up for next year's Federation Cup, which will played in Atlanta, in July. 
 &bquo;I will be asking all the team to play again and that includes Chris. 
 She is definitely an asset and she played superbly here, she was terrific,&equo; he said. 
 Volleyball: England discontent 
 By MIKE SPENCER 
 THE ENGLISH Volleyball Association will this weekend move to quash discontent in England's senior men's squad, concerning the development of a Great Britain team, writes Mike Spencer. 
 The Sports Council recently awarded &pound;200,000 towards the development of a British men's team, with the aim of qualifying for the Olympics. 
 Although a shortlist of five candidates for the position of coach has been prepared, Jefferson Williams, coach of the England men's team, said yesterday his squad were &bquo;annoyed&equo; at the lack of information from the EVA. 
 &bquo;If they think they can set up a squad at three months&equo; notice, they're sadly mistaken. 
 If they treat the players like second-class citizens, then I'm not sure they'll get the support. 
 But it's not too late to change things,&equo; he said. 
 In the Royal Bank English League, at the weekend, men's champions Malory defeated Reebok Liverpool City in four sets, and they have a match in hand over joint leaders, Polonia and Staffordshire Moorlands, who are both still unbeaten. 
 Judo: Corner of a foreign mat for Britain 
 From PHILIP NICKSAN in Belgrade 
 THE JAPANESE are taking these world championships seriously. 
 Yesterday, on the eve of the event, the squad were supposed to share the training hall with the British team, but there was no room for Karen Briggs, Elvis Gordon and the rest. 
 In addition to the 14 Japanese competitors, there were 17 training partners and coaches for the men and 11 for the women &mdash; and most were past Olympic or world champions. 
 The loss of face suffered in Seoul, where the Japanese men won just one gold medal, is set to be corrected. 
 The British team looked quite forlorn in comparison by the time the fighters got on the mat, the Japanese conceding them a small corner. 
 There were no extra training partners. 
 Heavyweight Gordon had his team manager, Arthur Mapp, to throw around; likewise, Sharon Lee, the Birmingham heavyweight, had the women's team manager, Roy Inman. 
 The quality in the British corner included Briggs, showing the speed which is one of her greatest assets, as she attempts to regain the world bantamweight title lost two years ago. 
 Double world light-middleweight champion, Diane Bell, showed no sign of the back injury that had sidelined her for the past month. 
 Inman, however, was cautious. 
 &bquo;Now that women's judo is on the main Olympic agenda in Barcelona, the competition has become much tougher,&equo; he said. 
 He pointed over to the Japanese side. 
 &bquo;They are now capable of taking two or three titles, though two years ago, they were not really a threat.&equo; 
 The pressure is on him because Britain has taken at least one world title in the women's event since the competition began in 1980. 
 &bquo;I don't think our record will be broken,&equo; he said. 
 Ice Hockey: Devils find work for keen hands 
 By STEVE PINDER 
 CARDIFF DEVILS opened their Heineken Premier career by winning three points in Scotland. 
 Ayr Raiders were the first stop and the second period saw Devils take a 4-1 lead. 
 Tommy Searle and Danny Shea replied for the home team only to see another Cooper, Ian, make it 5-3. 
 A power-play goal by Searle half-way through the second period made it 5-4 and with so many minutes left on the clock, a decisive result looked certain. 
 But despite end-to-end play, it was Searle's third goal with 10 minutes still left that tied the game. 
 The following day at Murrayfield Racers was a different story as Devils out-shot (40 to 24), out-thought and outplayed the Scots. 
 Steve Moria's hat-trick gave Cardiff a 3-1 lead and despite the first period ending 3-3, the other two were about Racers receiving a harsh lesson in ice hockey as Moria (with three more), John Lawless, and Ian Cooper sealed an 8-3 win. 
 The weekend's other draw was in the First, between the upstarts and the fallen mighty. 
 Streatham Redskins travelled to rampant newcomers Humberside Seahawks with Josef Lukac back from injury to join his Czech international brother Vincet on the import line. 
 After five minutes, Streatham were 2-0 up, after 18, 4-2 down. 
 The Lukac brothers spearheaded a second-period revival to take their team to 8-6 at the end of the second but Hawks managed to take the final period 3-1 and tie the game 9-9. 
 Boxing: Lewis' heavyweight thoughts: Nick Halling on the British-born fighter who is boxing clever on his way to a possible title challenge to Mike Tyson 
 By NICHOLAS HALLING 
 SOCRATES and Plato may be unlikely corner men for an aspiring heavyweight champion, but Lennox Lewis, the man reluctantly carrying the tag of the next Frank Bruno, is a lover of philosophy, and admits to being &bquo;one of those deep-thinking kind of guys&equo;. 
 It really should not come as a surprise to find Lewis, who continues his professional career tonight against Bradford's Steve Garber at Hull City Hall, owning up to such an unexpected hobby. 
 Since winning the super-heavyweight gold at last year's Olympics, the London-born but Canadian-raised fighter has shown himself to be anything but another pugilistic stereotype. 
 After Seoul, many of the sport's biggest promoters, including Bob Arum and Don King, vied for his signature. 
 Expected to take his considerable talents south of the border, Lewis confounded everyone by choosing instead to cross the Atlantic and return to the country of his birth. 
 &bquo;I wanted to be different,&equo; he admitted. 
 &bquo;There's nothing special about being a heavyweight or having an Olympic gold medal in the United States. 
 There was more of an opportunity for me to stand out over here, particularly as there is no real heavyweight contender on the British scene since Bruno lost to Tyson.&equo; 
 He also felt a keen sense of returning to his roots. 
 Lewis grew up in Forest Gate in east London, where he remembers causing problems at school ('I wasn't a hooligan or anything like that, but I was pretty rough') and following West Ham. 
 Had he stayed in the East End, he may have drifted into delinquency; instead, his mother sent for him when he was 12 to start a new life in Canada. 
 There was, of course, another motivating factor: that most basic and powerful philosophy of all, the pursuit of wealth. 
 His manager, Londoner Frank Maloney, offered Lewis a financial package which proved irresistible. 
 &bquo;Britain's always wanted a heavyweight champion, and I believe Lennox is the only man capable of giving us one,&equo; Maloney said. 
 Lewis certainly possesses the physical attributes for the task in hand. 
 He turned 23 last month, and his 6ft 5in, 16st 11lb frame carries no excess weight. 
 In his third professional contest two weeks ago, against the veteran Welshman Andy Gerrard, Lewis displayed patience, mobility, a punishing left jab, and the power of his punching. 
 Gerrard was unhinged in the fourth round by a double-fisted barrage to the head. 
 Ultimately, however, the biggest barrier to Lewis's goal of becoming Britain's first world heavyweight champion this century may be his own personality. 
 Although both he and his advisers stress that he has a killer instinct ('I change when I'm in the ring'), Lewis is articulate, intelligent, and good company. 
 &bquo;He's a super guy, the kind of person you'd like your sister to go out with,&equo; one of his handlers said. 
 There cannot be many who would say the same of Tyson. 
 Rugby Union: Black knights move on the Welsh pawns: Steve Bale predicts more of the same as rugby union's champions, New Zealand, arrive on their tour today 
 By STEVE BALE 
 IF THERE had been unity, it would have been simple enough: in purely rugby terms the All Blacks are unbeatable, by Wales at any rate, so only a surge of hwyl, a tide of emotion, could hope to stop them. 
 But even the presupposition is wrong. 
 There has been no unity; in fact, the Welsh Rugby Union has set an atrocious example of disunity, and the national side caught the mood. 
 When Wales lost to Bridgend 10 days ago, home supporters, who would now like nothing better than a Test-match miracle at the Arms Park on 4 November, taunted the beaten team with chants of &bquo;Easy&equo;. 
 The 30 New Zealand supermen &mdash; they are only human actually, but they have something like divine status in their own land &mdash; fly into Heathrow at lunchtime today for a 13-match tour which next month moves on to Ireland. 
 It is already being said that if Wales keep them below 30 points it will be a moral victory. 
 This is a devastating commentary on the state of a relationship that was among the greatest &mdash; some would argue the greatest &mdash; in international rugby. 
 Remember that it took New Zealand four attempts before they finally beat Wales in Cardiff, in 1963 (they won in Swansea in 1924). 
 In bygone days the Arms Park had an almost mystical quality for them. 
 Times have changed dramatically for the worse in Wales, a condition brought on as much as anything by the masochistic fixture-making which has brought about so much contact between the countries since the Welsh were blacked out in the 1987 World Cup semi-final. 
 Welsh rugby needed last year's tour, with its half-century hammerings, as much as it needs the All Blacks here now. 
 That Alex Wyllie, the grizzled New Zealand coach, regards this as the All Blacks' most important tour since the Cup is a tribute not to the Welsh but to the necessity of bringing through the next generation of players. 
 It threatens the worst for John Ryan, Wyllie's Welsh counterpart, for whom 15 short months in charge have been an eternity. 
 Defeatist it may seem, but it would be dishonest to predict other than that his tribulations will continue. 
 If he sees a gleam of light, it is in the clubs &mdash; some of them anyway &mdash; who tackle the tourists before they play Wales. 
 &bquo;Whatever state we appear to be in, the players will be raising their game,&equo; Ryan said. 
 &bquo;I'm sure the All Blacks expect six games against Welsh clubs culminating in an international at the Arms Park to be a hard tour. 
 In any case, 100 Welsh players having the opportunity to take on the world champions and learn from them will do a lot of good for Welsh rugby.&equo; 
 Ryan is trying to keep a long-term perspective since his appointment as Welsh coach runs to the end of the next World Cup, in the autumn of 1991. 
 But all the plans in the world will mean nothing if Wales take another battering. 
 Everything has conspired towards this gloomy conclusion. 
 The WRU was riven, by the league issue, even before the divisive South African centenary celebrations &mdash; which distracted Ryan, his players and the Welsh public from their main business, trying to do the impossible against the All Blacks. 
 And then there were the games with Newbridge (won unconvincingly) and Bridgend (lost disastrously). 
 &bquo;Those weekends gave us more problems than they solved,&equo; Ryan conceded. 
 &bquo;But they were a justifiable attempt to redress the balance: the All Blacks have recently had five Test matches, whereas we haven't played together since March. 
 &bquo;Whether it was the right decision, only history will tell. 
 If I'd had control over everything I would have had a full Wales tour in the summer and then we wouldn't have needed to have the practice games, but as it is we are giving them the advantage and I wanted to try to do something about that.&equo; 
 Ryan may console himself with an unlikely piece of New Zealand rugby history. 
 In 1924, the All Blacks undertook internal matches against Auckland and Manawatu as preparation for a European tour and promptly lost 14-3 to Auckland, who in those days were nothing like the force they are now. 
 &bquo;This is the weakest team New Zealand has ever had,&equo; one former All Black, George Tyler, inveighed in the New Zealand Herald. 
 &bquo;It is weak in the scrums, weak in defence and lacking in pace. 
 It is doubtful if the material is there for a first-class combination.&equo; 
 As this sounds vaguely similar to some of the insults being thrown at Ryan's side, all hope is not lost. 
 Those All Blacks went on to win every one of 30 tour games, including Tests against Ireland, Wales, England and France, and were arguably the finest ever to visit these shores. 
 Rugby Union: New Zealand newcomers already on the rampage 
 By NICK CAIN 
 British Columbia.............. 3 New Zealand.................. 48 AS THE All Blacks touch down at Heathrow today there is nothing but cold comfort for John Ryan, the Welsh coach, with the news of their heavy defeat of British Columbia at the Swangard Stadium here en route to their United Kingdom tour. 
 The game, played as a centrepiece to celebrate the BC centenary, provided the All Blacks with a useful opportunity to blood many of their new players. 
 The result was an emphatic seven-try victory over a courageous side who, over the past few months in their own colours and in their other incarnation as the Canadian national team, have overwhelmed Japan and the United States and been pipped by Wales and Ireland (minus their Lions) after surrendering leads late on. 
 That this win was achieved by an All Black team featuring only six first-choice Test players &mdash; Gallagher, Kirwan, Stanley, Deans, McDowell and Gary Whetton &mdash; is conclusive evidence of the great strength-in-depth of this touring party. 
 The New Zealanders continue to strive for new Everests in rugby achievement and their coach, Alex Wyllie, has already thrown down the gauntlet by stating: &bquo;If we lose a single game we will consider the tour a failure.&equo; 
 On the evidence available from their thorough training sessions and the way they brushed aside the challenge from a truly competitive outfit here, it is hard to see these All Blacks returning home as &bquo;failures&equo;. 
 The All Blacks are searching for perfection on the pitch and the physical strength and skill of their forwards leaves you with the sense that they are not far from attaining that dream. 
 The British Columbians, despite dogged persistence, could not cope with a pack in which eight men worked as one and where possession once obtained was so powerfully and cunningly retained. 
 The hallmark of Wyllie's All Blacks is the ability to drive the ball forward repeatedly at close quarters, sucking in the defence before opening up and ruthlessly exploit any gaps. 
 Against BC the gaps duly materialised and Joe Stanley, Va'Aiga Tuigamala &mdash; a pocket-battleship of a wing &mdash; Walter Little, Bruce Deans and Zinzan Brooke crossed for tries. 
 John Gallagher, meanwhile, proved a more than useful stand-in for Grant Fox in the goal-kicking role, missing the sticks just once. 
 Wyllie's verdict was a typically gruff Kiwi understatement: &bquo;There was nothing wrong with it.&equo; 
 He then added ominously: &bquo;In fact, it was a good score judging by the other teams who passed through here recently. 
 But we've still got plenty to work on and we won't get into the real tour rhythm until next Saturday.&equo; 
 Cardiff be warned. 
 Schools Rugby: Wellington backs hold the key 
 By NICK CAIN 
 WELLINGTON COLLEGE seem certain to have another good season, their latest victory being against St Edward's, Oxford, 17-3, writes Our Correspondent. 
 St Edward's were powerful up front but the Berkshire side's backs held the key, their tries being scored by Dominic Cannon, James Wyke and Matthew Scott, with Richard Butland kicking a conversion and a drop goal. 
 Their master-in-charge, John Martin, was very impressed with St Paul's, who had previously beaten Wellington 8-4, and St Paul's must have enjoyed their weekend victory against Whitgift, when they won 36-0. 
 Llandovery College must regard their third consecutive triumph at the Midland Schools invitation tournament, at Walsall RFC, as the high spot of a successful start to the season. 
 They beat Friary Grange, Lichfield 28-3, Sponne School, Northampton 26-6, and Queen Mary's, Walsall 36-11, before overcoming Old Swinford Hospital School, from Stourbridge, 15-3 in the final. 
 Their new player, Quentin Butt, was impressive at fly-half. 
 Last weekend Llandovery added a notable scalp to their belt with an away victory at Muirfield, 15-20. 
 Among unbeaten schools, Monmouth have been going particularly well, with victories against Wycliffe College, 16-12, Bristol GS, 14-6 and Bromsgrove, 7-4. 
 They have speedy backs and a strong, mobile back row, in which their No. 8 and captain, Jamie Lewis, is outstanding. 
 Their latest victory, at the weekend, was a hard-fought away win against Plymouth, 10-12. 
 Following their defeat of Ampleforth, Mount St Mary's beat a successful Leeds GS side 39-3, suggesting that they are among the strongest school sides in the country. 
 American Football: Big Bears mugged by Buccaneers 
 By JON MARGOLIS 
 THE big boys were expecting an easy day on Sunday. 
 The undefeated Chicago Bears, who beat the powerful Philadelphia Eagles last week, had to deal only with the paltry Tampa Bay Buccaneers, who had been crushed the week before. 
 The 3-1 Cleveland Browns, fresh from their hard-fought win over Denver, were facing the even weaker Miami Dolphins. 
 There must have been something in the Florida air in addition to vitamin C. One of the passes from Vinny Testaverde, the Tampa Bay quarterback, went through the hands of his intended receiver right in front of the goal-line, and into the hands of a team-mate, Mark Carrier, for a touchdown. 
 Then there was the bad snap from center on an extra-point attempt. 
 Unable to kick the point, the Bucs ran the ball in. 
 Chicago showed enough life early in the second half to get within seven points of the Bucs, but ended up scoring only 35 points to Tampa Bay's 42, the most points scored against the Bears since 1981. 
 In Miami, the best Cleveland could do after the regulation 60 minutes was a 10-10 tie. 
 They lost in overtime to a field goal by Pete Stoyanovich, Miami's rookie kicker. 
 Then there was that other division leader in the American Conference, the Buffalo Bills, who figured to have a picnic in Indianapolis. 
 Instead they had a disaster. 
 They fumbled away the game, 37-14, to the Colts, and lost quarterback Jim Kelly for perhaps four weeks with a shoulder separation. 
 The other big losers of the day were the Houston Oilers, who had already lost games they should have won. 
 But lose to the Patriots? 
 &bquo;Ayyeh&equo;, as they say in New England. 
 It would be a bit of an exaggeration to say that little Doug Flutie out-quarterbacked Houston's big Warren Moon. 
 But Flutie's team did win the game. 
 Elsewhere, there was some normality. 
 In a competitive match-up, the Eagles knocked the New York Giants out of the unbeaten ranks, leaving the Los Angeles Rams, who had little trouble with the Atlanta Falcons, with the League's only perfect record. 
 The Dallas Cowboys, who were beaten by Green Bay, and the Detroit Lions, who lost to the Minnesota Vikings, remain without a win. 
 The Washington Redskins had more trouble than they should have with the injury-ridden Phoenix Cardinals before winning by two points while San Francisco relied on one of those Joe Montana come-from-behind specials to overcome New Orleans 24-20. 
 Racing: Sangster calls time at Manton 
 By JOHN KARTER, Racing Correspondent 
 THE SHADOW of the Maktoums looms larger than ever over British racing after confirmation yesterday that Robert Sangster is to sell Manton, his multi-million pound training establishment in Wiltshire. 
 In an official statement put out yesterday, Sangster said cryptically: &bquo;It is a sad decision, but it no longer makes any sense keeping the place and having to stay in the local pub when we visit.&equo; 
 Speaking from their Isle of Man home where they live as tax exiles, Sangster's wife, Susan, firmly denied that the sale of Manton was a result of her husband's reduced stature in the bloodstock world. 
 &bquo;It is simply that for tax reasons we cannot stay overnight at Manton,&equo; Mrs Sangster explained. 
 &bquo;And if we can't fully enjoy the place there's not much point in keeping it. 
 But Robert is as fully committed to the world of bloodstock as ever.&equo; 
 Despite what Mrs Sangster says, the jettisoning of the Sangster flagship will be seen as further evidence of her husband falling behind in racing's power game, in which it is no longer enough just to be a run-of-the-mill millionaire. 
 Furthermore, there will inevitably be speculation that the Maktoum family, who now dominate racing and breeding in this country to an extent that many find unacceptable, will add Manton to their bejewelled chain of racing assets. 
 Only last week, Sheikh Mohammed added the White Lodge and Beech House Studs in Newmarket, and the dynasty of priceless mares and racehorses established by the Moller family, to the family's prodigious portfolio. 
 The Sheikh has a string of horses at Manton under the care of the present incumbent, Barry Hills, who leases the facilities from Sangster. 
 Hills took over at Manton at the end of 1986 after Sangster sacked Michael Dickinson. 
 The great dream had turned sour when Dickinson, the former champion National Hunt trainer, failed to produce the required results in his first season as Sangster's private trainer at the refurbished establishment. 
 Sangster is reputed to have spent &pound;8m on the historic stable, which is possibly the most lavishly equipped in Europe. 
 The asking price now is rumoured to be in the region of &pound;15m. 
 Last month it was announced that the Maktoums are to purchase a property especially for Major Dick Hern, who trains the Derby winner, Nashwan, for Hamdan Al Maktoum. 
 Hern's lease of the royal stables at West Ilsley in Berkshire is to cease next year. 
 It is possible, however, that the Maktoums may snap up Manton for Hern. 
 Hills's lease at Manton also terminates at the end of next year, and he could return to his original yard in Lambourn which he still owns and where his son John trains. 
 Sangster intends to continue sending him horses. 
 Last year Sangster sold his Vernons Pools empire for &pound;90m in order to concentrate on his bloodstock interests. 
 In the late Seventies and early Eighties he took racehorse ownership and breeding into a new dimension by applying business principles to what was originally a pastime. 
 Sangster joined forces with the legendary Irish trainer Vincent O'Brien, and they virtually cornered the market in the stock of the great stallion Northern Dancer as well as successfully syndicating stallions such as The Minstrel and Alleged. 
 To maintain his operation, Sangster needed a regular flow of Classic winners, but this dried up when the Maktoums arrived on the international scene with their limitless spending power. 
 Sangster has also fared badly through his involvement with Classic Thoroughbreds, a more recent venture. 
 The horses trained by O'Brien for this public company have not fulfilled expectations and the shares have fallen from an issue price of 30p to 17p. 
 Ironically, the sale of Manton comes at a time when Sangster's fortunes on the track are looking up. 
 His filly Silk Slippers became one of the favourites for next year's Oaks after winning at Ascot recently and he also owns a share in The Caretaker, who won Saturday's Cartier Million. 
 Things cannot all be black, however. 
 Sangster recently purchased a 10-acre property in the South of France, apparently to concentrate on his golf. 
 If he is a loser, who needs to be a winner. 
 Racing: Carroll could aim at Japan 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 THE GASH sustained by Carroll House after he proved himself a cut above the rest of Europe in Sunday's Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe looked a lot less serious than had been feared when Britain's new equine hero was examined on his return to Newmarket yesterday, writes John Karter. 
 Michael Jarvis, Carroll House's trainer, went straight from Paris to Ireland for the bloodstock sales, but Jim Hiner, his secretary, said yesterday: &bquo;The vet has confirmed that the cut is only superficial.&equo; 
 Carroll House lashed out at well-wishers and photographers who crowded round him as he was led back after winning and struck a rail with his hind leg. 
 The four-year-old has always been highly strung and Hiner added: &bquo;He got so worked up that the French vets couldn't examine him.&equo; 
 Jarvis will not decide on Carroll House's future until he gets back from Ireland later this week. 
 If the horse recovers well from his Longchamp experience he could head for the Japan Cup, for which he was entered yesterday. 
 Meanwhile, four weeks after the St Leger was abandoned because of subsidence of the track, the future of Doncaster racecourse is under debate. 
 Local Tories plan to lobby Colin Moynihan, the Minister for Sport, at this week's Conservative Party conference to allege that the course in being mismanaged by the local Labour council. 
 Peter Davis, leader of a delegation from the local Conservative Association, said yesterday: &bquo;We feel the racecourse would benefit by being taken out of local authority hands.&equo; 
 The delegation are to submit evidence as to why the course should be privatised in the interests of racing. 
 It was confirmed yesterday that the meeting scheduled for Doncaster on 27 October is to be transferred to Carlisle. 
 The following day's card has been switched to Newcastle. 
 Doncaster's final meeting of the year (10 and 11 November) could go to Thirsk. 
 Celtic Chief will be out of action for a year while he recovers from a leg injury sustained in last season's Champion Hurdle. 
 The six-year-old is now trained by John McConnochie following the retirement of Mercy Rimell. 
 Knighton back on course with take-over 
 By FRANK KANE 
 WITH ONLY 48 hours to come up with the cash, Michael Knighton's &pound;20m take-over bid for Manchester United is back on course following a High Court ruling that gives him leave to put together a funding package. 
 After a day of legal drama mixed with financial farce, he was last night &bquo;working on two or three options&equo;, according to an associate, &bquo;before deciding which one he's going to run with&equo;. 
 Friends of Knighton believe he is close to putting together a deal which would see at least some of the shares resold within four months of a take-over. 
 &bquo;The problem is that Knighton wants to sit in the chairman's seat, at least for a while,&equo; one confidant said. 
 Earlier, Mr Justice Judge had ruled in the Manchester High Court that the terms of a temporary injunction be lifted, allowing him to show financial details of the club to his advisers. 
 The suit had been brought by Martin Edwards, the United chairman and controlling shareholder, who has agreed to sell his 50.6 per cent holding to Knighton for &pound;10m. 
 The Court adjourned the matter until Thursday, &bquo;but it is hoped by both parties that by then the current uncertainty and speculation concerning the future of Manchester will have been resolved&equo;. 
 Under the terms of Knighton's original contract with Edwards, he set midnight tomorrow as the deadline for posting a formal offer to shareholders. 
 If he does not do so, Edwards will be able to sell his stake to the highest bidder. 
 Peter Cole, a solicitor acting for Edwards, said after yesterday's hearing: &bquo;I think the ball is essentially in Knighton's court.&equo; 
 But the uncertainty over Knighton's ability to raise the cash continued with a bizarre denial from his financial adviser, stockbroking firm Laing &amp; Cruickshank, that they had guaranteed the deal to Edwards. 
 Following reports in Manchester that the firm had confirmed to Edwards's satisfaction that Knighton had the &pound;10m to buy his stake and a further &pound;10m to make a formal offer for the rest of the shares, Laing &amp; Cruickshank said: &bquo;It is completely untrue that we have given an assurance to anyone. 
 The verification process is going on, but we cannot say whether it's going to be completed by any particular time. 
 That depends on his assets and whether they meet Stock Exchange requirements.&equo; 
 Yesterday's developments are bound to anger further the rest of the United board, and fans. 
 In particular Amer Midani, the United director who has a 15 per cent holding and who is believed to be waiting to buy Edwards's stake. 
 He is backed by another director, Nigel Burrows, and has indicated that he would install Bobby Charlton as chairman if he wins control of the club. 
 There is also the role of Robert Maxwell, the newspaper publisher whose Daily Mirror has been strongly critical of Knighton. 
 Maxwell once tried unsuccessfully &mdash; to buy United. 
 The court hearing, which lasted 23 minutes and took place in chambers, was told by Edwards that a report prepared by Knighton's accountants &mdash; believed to show confidential details about players' salaries and contracts, as well as other sensitive financial information &mdash; had &bquo;come into the possession of at least one outsider&equo;. 
 This is believed to be Eddy Shah, the media entrepreneur who has claimed he was offered the Edwards shares for &pound;16m. 
 Tony Meo and Eddie Sinclair take up centre stage during yesterday's third-round matches in the grand prix snooker event being held at The Hexagon in Reading 
 By FRANK KANE 
 Tony Meo and Eddie Sinclair take up centre stage during yesterday's third-round matches in the grand prix snooker event being held at The Hexagon in Reading  
 Football: Robson has a case for the defence 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY 
 ENGLAND flew to Poland yesterday with reliance placed in a defence that, like Bobby Robson, has shown a talent for confounding the critics. 
 Robson's team have yet to concede a goal in their five World Cup qualifying matches and one more clean sheet when the whistle blows on the last, in Chorzow tomorrow evening, will put them in the finals. 
 This has become almost par for the course in English qualifying campaigns under Robson: they were breached only once in reaching the last European Championship finals. 
 Yet there is persistent critical doubt about a defence which, upon meeting European opponents of the highest class &mdash; West Germany, The Netherlands, The Soviet Union &mdash; tends to show equal consistency in letting in three goals per match. 
 In such situations, Peter Shilton's frame cannot cover a whole multitude of sins. 
 But with England's great goalkeeper still betraying no signs of his 40 years, except a finely honed judgement that causes the target to shrink before advancing strikers, hopes are high that Poland can be shut out and the points secured that will see England safely through to Italy. 
 The Poles did not look much of a side at all when they lost 3-0 at Wembley in June and, although they have improved since under new management, there is nothing in their results to suggest that they have recovered the standard of the team that put Sir Alf Ramsey's England out of the World Cup in 1973. 
 Then, England lost 2-0 in Chorzow, Bobby Moore inadvertently scoring one goal and letting Wlodimierz Lubanski through for the other. 
 But the Poles had an outstanding side then &mdash; not only featuring Lubanski but Deyna, Lato, Gadocha, Gorgon and the goalkeeper, Jan Tomaszewski, who was to defy a barrage of attack in London. 
 They went on to finish third in the finals in West Germany. 
 Now, their main hopes rest on the striker Dariusz Dziekanowski, a deep disappointment to his countrymen when Poland lost to Gary Lineker's hat-trick in Monterey in 1986 but lately revived by a transfer to Celtic, for whom he vainly scored four goals in that extraordinary roller-coaster of a European tie against Partizan Belgrade at Parkhead 13 days ago. 
 Dziekanowski did not play at Wembley last summer &mdash; he was suspended after walking out on his then club Legia Warsaw &mdash; but clearly he is in the mood to test the English defenders whom Bobby Robson has been casting as his unsung heroes. 
 The new Polish manager, Andrzej Strejau, has said he noted faults in Terry Butcher's game during the goalless draw in Sweden last month. 
 But England feel that the pace of Des Walker, the great gain of last season's unbeaten sequence, should close any gaps. 
 Again, however, a lot may depend on the covering play of the full-backs, Gary Stevens and Stuart Pearce, upon which England's flat back-four system places great responsibility. 
 Robson insists that he will not play for a draw. 
 Such an approach, he says, is against the instincts of English players. 
 They feel they are creative enough to win, even without the injured John Barnes, whose place on the left flank will go to Chris Waddle with David Rocastle coming in on the right and Steve McMahon and Bryan Robson taking the middle. 
 Waddle has made an excellent start to his new career in France, where he is the major single investment in Marseille's campaign for domestic and European success. 
 He has lost half a stone since his move from Tottenham, partly, he thinks, because French players do not have the English habit of sinking a few post-match lagers. 
 &bquo;He looks fitter, sleeker, and better,&equo; Robson said, &bquo;and we just hope he can score a goal for us from the wing. 
 He's certainly looking sharp enough to do that.&equo; 
 Football: Knocks for Roxburgh 
 From DON LINDSAY in Paris 
 TROUBLE, according to the proverb, comes in threes. 
 Certainly Andy Roxburgh, the Scotland coach, must believe so after arriving here for Wednesday's crucial World Cup qualifying match against France carrying a trio of injured players. 
 Roxburgh revealed the doubtful candidates for the game as the midfielders Gordon Strachan and Jim Bett, and Brian McClair, who fills an auxiliary role for his country. 
 Strachan took what the coach described as &bquo;a whack on the thigh&equo; in Leeds United's win over West Ham on Saturday. 
 Bett has problems with a painful toe, and McClair strained a hamstring during a training session on Sunday. 
 There is particular concern over the knocks to the midfield pair. 
 &bquo;We did not bring them here to sit in the stand,&equo; Roxburgh said, although he would not commit himself as to whether either was considered a starter against the French. 
 &bquo;That is still open for discussion,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;At this stage we will have to wait and see what state they are in before we make a decision.&equo; 
 Scotland require just one point against Michel Platini's men to qualify for next summer's finals in Italy. 
 &bquo;We are more than capable of getting a draw. 
 I think France could be badly affected if we open the scoring.&equo; 
 The man most likely to cause problems for the French is Maurice Johnston, the striker who joined Rangers from Nantes during the summer. 
 Johnston is the only member of Roxburgh's squad to have played at the Parc des Princes, the venue for the match. 
 &bquo;I think he's very important because of that fact, and also as he knows the French set-up and the way they play. 
 In this situation, they'll be worried about him,&equo; Roxburgh said. 
 Johnston is confident of making an impact on the game and felt the size of the crowd would also be a vital factor with 10,000 Scots fans expected to attend. 
 &bquo;It will be more like a home game for us than France as they have only sold about 20,000 tickets,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The last time I played there, for Nantes, there was very little atmosphere, and on Wednesday the Scots fans will be right behind us. 
 I am firmly convinced we will be celebrating on the way home to Glasgow.&equo; 
 A special security fence will be built well away from Parc des Princes stadium to prevent any Scottish fans planning to turn up without tickets from reaching the stadium. 
 Football: Wales to face Van Basten 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 WALES'S World Cup qualifying tie against The Netherlands tomorrow, deprived of three main attractions by the suspension of Ian Rush and Mark Hughes and injury to Ruud Gullit, recovered some of its box-office potential yesterday with the news that Marco van Basten had been added to the Dutch squad. 
 Van Basten, the Milan striker whose goals were largely responsible for his country's victory in the European Championship finals last year, has recovered from a knee operation on 1 September and played on Sunday in his club's defeat at Cremona. 
 &bquo;I thought I did well,&equo; the European Footballer of the Year said yesterday. 
 &bquo;I felt good, though perhaps I'm not at my best yet.&equo; 
 A win at Wrexham would take Thys Libregts's side to the top of Group Four and virtually guarantee their place in the World Cup finals in Italy next summer. 
 Terry Yorath, the Wales manager, is delaying his selection until he has checked on the fitness of Barry Horne, the Southampton midfielder, who has had a knee injury. 
 He confirmed that Derby's Dean Saunders will lead the attack. 
 Yorath said yesterday: &bquo;We know we won't be going to Italy. 
 But the team that plays the Dutch is playing for the future &mdash; for the 1992 European finals.&equo; 
 Algeria will be going to the finals if they beat Egypt in Cairo next Sunday, but without the national team's coach, Kamel Lemoui. 
 He resigned after Sunday's 0-0 home draw with Egypt. 
 Norwich City yesterday confirmed that they have received an enquiry from the FA of Ireland about the availability of the club's central defender Andy Linighan. 
 The Hartlepool-born Linighan qualifies for the Republic by virtue of a family connection. 
 The Chelsea manager Bobby Campbell is considering an offer for Bradford City's 24-year-old central defender Lee Sinnott. 
 Albert Geldard, who gained an FA Cup-winners' medal with Everton in 1933 and won four England caps, has died in a Bury hospital, aged 75. 
 Geldard, a winger, holds the record, with Ken Roberts of Wrexham, for being the youngest player to appear in the League. 
 He played for Bradford Park Avenue against Millwall in the Second Division 60 years ago at the age of 15 years, 158 days. 
 Squash: Jansher has cash complaint 
 From RICHARD EATON in Singapore 
 JANSHER KHAN, who regained the world title on Saturday, has criticised tournament organisers for withholding his &dollar;15,000 (&pound;9,500) prize money because he left an official dinner in Kuala Lumpur after only 15 minutes. 
 The 20-year-old Pakistani said: &bquo;They have no right to do this. 
 I was told that I would be given the money when I got to Singapore. 
 Now I find that I am not given it.&equo; 
 Jansher also complained about the treatment of Pakistani players. 
 Jansher has been rebuffed in the past by the president of the Players' Association, Chris Dittmar, for demanding too much of tournament organisers. 
 Dittmar does agree with Jansher, however, that not paying prize money may set an unfortunate precedent. 
 Nevertheless, the Australian is still likely to preside over the punishment of the opponent who beat him in the World Open final. 
 He has already been told the prize money will be forwarded to his association. 
 Moreover, Dittmar takes a very dim view of Jansher's behaviour, because it has occurred before. 
 &bquo;Jansher was warned by the players&equo; chairman, Phil Whitlock, for not turning up to the official function at the Singapore Open last month. 
 That's what makes this so serious,&equo; he said. 
 The aggravation did not seem to upset Jansher yesterday as he conceded only a single point to Frank Ellis as the title holders, Pakistan, started the world team championships here yesterday with a 3-0 win over Scotland. 
 England also began with a 3-0 win, against Finland. 
 However, Del Harris, the No. 1, returning to action after a month out, had to work hard to avoid going the full distance with Sami Elopuro before winning 9-5, 9-2, 2-9, 9-7. 
 Rugby Union: Quins complain to Swansea over &bquo;kick&equo; 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 HARLEQUINS have confirmed that they will be following up Saturday's incident in the match with Swansea at Twickenham &mdash; when one of their players was apparently kicked in the head &mdash; with an official letter of complaint to the Welsh club. 
 This is currently being drafted by Colin Herridge, the club's secretary, who said: &bquo;Deliberate foul play cannot be condoned.&equo; 
 Early in the encounter, Herridge and other spectators said they saw Swansea's flanker Ian Davies kick Richard Langhorn and the Quins' No. 8 later had stitches inserted in a head wound. 
 Roger Blyth, chairman of the Swansea selectors who was one of Saturday's touch judges, said: &bquo;I didn't see the incident but it's quite obvious that the bloke was cut from contact with a boot. 
 It's only dirty play if there is intent there. 
 Until we get the letter we won't be able to do anything, but we will speak to the people concerned.&equo; 
 With Sandy Sanders &mdash; a former Harlequin and this season's president of the Rugby Football Union &mdash; keen to eradicate violence in the game, this latest incident is particularly upsetting. 
 Just a fortnight previously on a black day for rugby, Gareth Chilcott, the Bath and England prop, was sent off at Gloucester for punching and, in another league match, two Richmond forwards were badly injured in the game with Rugby at the Athletic Ground. 
 Richmond have since sought help from Middlesex in pursuing the issue while Chilcott, dismissed for the fourth time in his career with Bath, awaits the result of tonight's meeting of the Somerset Disciplinary Committee. 
 Finlay Calder, the Lions captain, is unavailable for Scotland's international against Fiji on 28 October. 
 Calder, who had been expected to win his 22nd consecutive cap, feels he is short of fitness having spent September fulfilling a number of engagements in the aftermath of the tour. 
 &bquo;A burst knee muscle also set me back by about three weeks,&equo; he said, adding that the Fiji match would be an ideal opportunity to blood another flanker in front of a home crowd. 
 &bquo;I would, though, very much like to go to New Zealand with Scotland at the end of the season.&equo; 
 Brian Smith, this season's Oxford University captain who is looking to become a dual international by adding Irish caps to the six he has won already for Australia, plays against some of his former Wallaby team-mates on Sunday at Iffley Road. 
 Smith, born Down Under but with Irish grandparents, leads Oxford against a World XV in a match to raise funds for GOAL, an Irish-based international charity which provides financial assistance to the Third World. 
 Included in the Australian contingent for Sunday's match are Simon Poidevin, who leads the side, Bill Calcraft and Enrique Rodriguez, the prop who turned out for Argentina before emigrating and playing for Australia. 
 Smith went on Ireland's recent tour of North America and the stand-off is now hoping to gain selection for Leinster in a push for a place in the Irish side to face the All Blacks next month. 
 Phil Matthews, of Ireland, has pulled out of the Barbarians side to play Newport this evening. 
 Noel Mannion, another Irish international, and the Orrell lock Bob Kimmins have also withdrawn. 
 Matthews is replaced at flanker by the former Wales captain, David Pickering, while the Bath lock John Morrison comes in for Kimmins. 
 Mannion's replacement will be Owain Williams of Bridgend. 
 Demonstrators fill streets of Leipzig 
 From STEVE CRAWSHAW in Leipzig 
 TENS OF THOUSANDS of East Germans &mdash; perhaps as many as 50,000 &mdash; streamed through Leipzig last night, calling for the legalisation of the New Forum opposition group. 
 It was almost certainly the largest protest the German Democratic Republic has seen. 
 There had been widespread fears of police violence, and water cannon had already been used against demonstrators on Saturday. 
 Leipzigers feared live ammunition could be used. 
 In one sidestreet alone there were 16 trucks full of the so-called &bquo;workers&equo; militias' on standby. 
 But the demonstration took place peacefully. 
 The march began after several thousand people had filled four churches to overflowing in the centre of Leipzig, for a special service of &bquo;prayers for peace&equo;. 
 The local bishop, Johannes Hempel, spoke in all four churches, and called on the state to open a dialogue with the protesters. 
 By the time the church meetings ended, the Nikolaikirche Square and the surrounding streets were already full to overflowing with the crowds who had failed to gain entry into any of the churches. 
 The Nikolaikirche, with 2,000 seats, was full one and a half hours before the church meeting began. 
 The crowds in the church, where protest meetings began to gain momentum last month, applauded the bishop. 
 Then, outside, in an indication of just one of the unusual qualities of the growing East German opposition, they chanted &bquo;Gorby, Gorby&equo; and sang the &bquo;Internationale&equo;. 
 The huge crowd proceeded from outside the church to fill the largest square in the city, Karl Marx Square. 
 The multitude then filed past the Opera House and down towards the central station. 
 It seemed that the police, in Leipzig at least, had lost their enthusiasm for beating up citizens pressing for change. 
 One elderly man said: &bquo;We were all very frightened of what the police would do, but they behaved sensibly.&equo; 
 But another demonstrator said the softly-softly tactics have a disadvantage for the regime. 
 &bquo;People will be less frightened. 
 And more and more will come out on the streets.&equo; 
 A message from a local party leader was broadcast on Karl Marx Square, calling for dialogue with all groups. 
 If that offer is serious, it will mark a radical change in policy. 
 Many Germans express scepticism about how amenable to reform the hardline regime can be. 
 Last night however, crowds gathered round the workers' militia standing by their trucks, trying to include them &mdash; sometimes successfully &mdash; in conversations about the need for change. 
 Pin-headed aliens invade Russia &mdash; official 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 NIGHT LIFE in Voronezh, a dour city of 850,000 people in the great Russian heartlands, is definitely looking up. 
 Once the best you could hope for was a 50-year-old prima ballerina who sometimes starred at the local opera house. 
 If you go there after dark now, you may see UFOs and small-headed hominoids 12 feet tall. 
 We have this from no less an authority than Tass. 
 As deadpan as in its more accustomed role of relaying verbatim endless speeches by Mikhail Gorbachev, the official Soviet news agency reported yesterday on a town terrorised by &bquo;at least three&equo; visitations from outer space &mdash; and vouched for by eminent local scientists, no less. 
 But the tale is best told in Tass's sober prose. 
 &bquo;A large shining ball or disc was seen hovering above the park. 
 Then it landed, a hatch opened and one, two or three creatures similar to humans and a small robot came out. 
 The aliens were three to four metres (10-13ft) tall, but with very small heads. 
 They walked near the ball or disc and then disappeared inside. 
 Onlookers were overwhelmed by a fear lasting several days. 
 Many also claimed to have seen a banana-shaped object in the sky, and a characteristic illuminated sign.&equo; 
 Confirmation of this astounding occurrence &mdash; which must banish any churlish suggestion that the affair is to be put down to Russia's eternal obsession with the supernatural &mdash; was provided by Genrikh Silanov, head of the Voronezh Geophysical Laboratory. 
 His account to Tass follows. 
 &bquo;We identified the site by means of biolocation. 
 We detected a circle 20 metres across. 
 Four dents, each 4-5 centimetres deep and with a diameter of 14-16cm, were clearly visible. 
 They are situated at the four points of a rhombus. 
 We also found two mysterious pieces of rock. 
 At first glance these looked like sandstone of a deep-red colour. 
 However, mineralogical analysis showed that the substance cannot be found on Earth. 
 But additional tests are needed to reach a more definite conclusion.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, one odd coincidence must be noted: the &bquo;banana-shaped object and characteristic illuminated sign&equo; were apparently similarly described by an American journal, Saga. 
 But, as Tass concluded: &bquo;It is unlikely that residents of Voronezh could have read the magazine.&equo; 
 PC accused of raping woman in patrol car 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 A YOUNG mother yesterday told an Old Bailey jury that she was raped by a policeman on the front seat of his patrol car. 
 After agreeing to give her a lift home from a discotheque, PC Peter Anderson was said to have stopped his Metro car on a deserted allotment, and threatened the 18-year-old woman by pushing his truncheon under her chin. 
 PC Anderson, a 40-year-old officer with 20 years' experience, warned her not to report the incident, saying he knew where to find her and could arrest her for soliciting, the court was told. 
 The woman, now 20, said she began to feel &bquo;wary&equo; when the officer turned off the main road to her home, saying he knew a short-cut. 
 He stopped the car, reached over into the back seat and grabbed his truncheon, putting it under her throat and rubbing her legs. 
 She told the jury: &bquo;I said to him, &bquo;You are a married man,&equo; but he tried to get on top of me. 
 I tried to push him off, but he was too forceful.&equo; 
 She said that after he raped her, he forced part of his hand into her, causing pain, and threatened to use the truncheon. 
 &bquo;I begged him not to and he stopped.&equo; 
 The woman made no complaint to the police for five days. 
 Questioned about why she had not sought help immediately after the alleged attack, she said: &bquo;I had just been raped by a policeman, and I did not trust no police after that.&equo; 
 PC Anderson, who was based at Surbiton police station, has denied raping the woman in Kingston, south-west London, on 4 April last year. 
 Godfrey Carey, for the prosecution, said PC Anderson admitted that sexual intercourse took place, but claimed the woman was a willing partner &bquo;and indeed egged him on. 
 He says it was one of the best sexual experiences he has ever had.&equo; 
 When questioned PC Anderson allegedly told police: &bquo;I have had personal problems. 
 I have split with my mistress today, my wife gave me an ultimatum &mdash; and now this. 
 I never raped anybody. 
 A more willing partner you couldn't wish for.&equo; 
 Mr Carey told the jury it would have to decide whether the woman had made a &bquo;wicked and false allegation&equo; against a serving police officer or whether the officer had gone to the &bquo;very depths of the pit of deceit&equo; by claiming the woman, less than half his age, had encouraged and enjoyed sexual intercourse with him. 
 The court heard the woman had approached PC Anderson as he sat in his car. 
 She said she asked for a lift for herself and a male friend as a joke. 
 He dropped the friend off, then drove to the allotment. 
 Fears of crisis as pound plunges: Collapse of confidence leads to 6bn pound drop in share values 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 THE POUND yesterday posted its steepest one-day fall in more than three years, sinking almost 6 pfennigs within a few hours. 
 There are now worries in the City that the plunge in sterling could flare up into a full-blown crisis and, in the last resort, force the Government to raise interest rates even higher. 
 Sterling closed at DM2.9737, its weakest finish against the West German currency since 4 March last year. 
 London share prices also fell sharply. 
 The FT-SE 100 Index slumped 34.9 points at one stage before ending 30.5 points down at 2247.0, which wiped &pound;6.54bn off share values. 
 Fears in the financial markets that government policy towards the pound was in disarray also drove down the currency 3.05 cents against the dollar to &dollar;1.5775. 
 Reports in weekend newspapers of a rift between Margaret Thatcher and Nigel Lawson over the recent rise in interest rates and the value of sterling also contributed to the fall. 
 The sudden collapse in sterling came despite last week's 1-point rise in base rates to 15 per cent, intended to defuse the selling pressure and reinforce the Government's battle against inflation. 
 The Bank of England stepped into the currency markets three times yesterday morning, selling dollars and buying pounds. 
 The intervention was modest and trading was thin because US markets were largely closed for a holiday. 
 Trading was comparatively light in both currency and equity markets, but the collapse in confidence seemed widespread. 
 There were reports of sterling sales from all around the world and also by major British companies. 
 Government sources yesterday denied the reported rift between the Prime Minister and the Chancellor. 
 They also played down the role of Sir Alan Walters, the Prime Minister's personal economic adviser, in the critical decisions to intervene heavily in the past two weeks and raise interest rates to protect the pound last Thursday. 
 Sir Alan has in the past written about his deep misgivings over intervention and has recently let it be known in the City that he believes the economy is at last showing signs of pronounced slowdown, a view not fully shared by the Treasury. 
 The Chancellor had the Prime Minister's support, according to government sources, in intervening to the tune of &dollar;2bn to &dollar;3bn to shore up the pound after pressure intensified following the news two weeks ago of a &pound;2bn current account deficit in August &mdash; the third worst on record. 
 It is also understood that the Treasury by then was concluding that an interest rate increase would be needed to ensure a clampdown on inflation. 
 The sources also said that intervention in the currency markets was not expressly aimed at averting an increase in interest rates. 
 One senior source said: &bquo;Clearly if there had been a fundamental disagreement (between the Prime Minister and the Chancellor) then the Government wouldn't have raised interest rates.&equo; 
 Despite yesterday's slump in the pound, most analysts believed the Government would be extremely reluctant to raise interest rates again. 
 The Treasury stressed yesterday that, despite the pound's fall, the increase in rates meant that overall monetary policy had been tightened. 
 Ian Harwood, chief UK economist at Warburg Securities, said: &bquo;I don't think anybody seriously thinks interest rates are going to rise any further.&equo; 
 Financial markets are apprehensive that the trade deficit has still not turned the corner and a poor figure could shake sterling again. 
 Another rise in interest rates would make recession much more likely without necessarily ensuring a rapid easing of inflation. 
 Partly as a result, there was growing market speculation yesterday that the Prime Minister might reconsider her strong objections to sterling's membership of the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System. 
 Although there is disagreement in the City over whether recession is inevitable, there were warnings yesterday that high rates could reduce package holiday bookings by as much as 40 per cent next summer &mdash; something that would help to narrow the current account deficit. 
 Halifax 1 per cent rise sets mortgage rate benchmark 
 By PATRICK HOSKING, Banking Correspondent 
 THE HALIFAX, Britain's biggest building society, yesterday attempted to stem a wholesale move to 15 per cent mortgage rates by announcing a comparatively modest 1-point hike in its own lending rate to 14.5 per cent. 
 The announcement, hastily brought forward from the middle of the month, was designed to forestall other lenders from following the Yorkshire Building Society, which lifted its rate to 15 per cent at the weekend. 
 The benchmark now set by the Halifax is certain to influence how other societies respond to last week's 1-point increase in bank base rates to 15 per cent. 
 There are fears that large mortgage rate hikes could tip the already stagnant housing and mortgage market into deep and long-lasting recession. 
 A Halifax spokesman said: &bquo;Hopefully this will give the lead to other building societies to restrict their increases to 1 per cent.&equo; 
 Virtually all mortgage lenders plan to lift their interest rates. 
 Most aim to bring in the increase from 1 November. 
 However, they are split on how high to raise their rates, now around 13.5 per cent. 
 The Leeds Permanent and Abbey National want to go up by 1.25 points or more. 
 The Woolwich and Cheltenham &amp; Gloucester societies believe they can live with a 1-point rise or less. 
 The Halifax increase takes effect from 1 November, but four-fifths of the society's 1.6 million borrowers are on semi-fixed mortgages and will not face any changes to their monthly payments until 1 April next year. 
 The Halifax lifted its interest rates for savers by 0.75 of a point. 
 More societies are expected to announce mortgage rate increases during the Conservative Party conference this week. 
 The Leeds Permanent said yesterday it would announce an increase of at least 1.25 points &bquo;within a day or two&equo;. 
 Derek Roberts, chief executive of the Yorkshire, said he believed societies which raised their rates by only 1 point would be forced to increase them again to attract savers. 
 Mortgage rates are already at their highest since November 1981. 
 In real terms, after adjusting for inflation and taking account of the diminishing impact of tax relief, they are at record levels. 
 Societies privately admit that they would have to respond with still higher mortgage rates if the Government raises base rates again to prop up sterling. 
 Borrowers with companies financed by the wholesale money markets are already paying rates of about 14.75 per cent. 
 They face new rates of up to 16 per cent. 
 The Conservatives in Blackpool: Upbeat Thatcher supports Lawson 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correspondent 
 THE PRIME Minister gave her support to Nigel Lawson last night over his decision to raise interest rates to 15 per cent. 
 She told Conservative agents at a private dinner in Blackpool: &bquo;The interest rate rise was necessary and this government always does what is necessary and always has.&equo; 
 Margaret Thatcher also set the tone for the conference with a deliberately upbeat message. 
 She said: &bquo;The economy is stronger than ever. 
 Living standards are higher than ever. 
 One has only to look at the new jobs created and investment. 
 It is a totally different situation now from the one the Government inherited.&equo; 
 Her remarks could ease the way for Mr Lawson's speech to the conference on Thursday. 
 Kenneth Baker, the Conservative Party chairman, last night said the Chancellor would defend his use of high interest rates to reduce inflation and reinforce the Tories as the party of sound money. 
 Mr Baker failed to end speculation about opposition from Sir Alan Walters, the Prime Minister's economic adviser, to last week's 1-point increase. 
 But the party chairman insisted in a BBC interview that the Cabinet was united. 
 Last night, Mr Baker dismissed questions about the possibility that interest rates could be raised again and refused to be drawn on whether the pound's dip below DM3 on the exchange markets during the day signalled a change in policy. 
 Mr Baker made it clear that the leadership was determined to use the conference &mdash; under the slogan &bquo;The right team for Britain's future&equo; &mdash; to lift the flagging morale of supporters and raise the party in the opinion polls. 
 He said he would &bquo;come out fighting&equo; &mdash; a style not normally associated with annual Conservative conferences. 
 The conference which begins today is one of the most difficult for the Tories since Mrs Thatcher came to power. 
 The party leadership faces unrest over the poll tax, water and electricity privatisation and the changes to the health service, in addition to rising mortgage rates, which are damaging Tory support. 
 Mr Baker said Mr Lawson's speech would be &bquo;well received&equo; because the party would understand the problems the Government was facing. 
 &bquo;He took a difficult decision last week to increase interest rates. 
 It's unpopular &mdash; I don't disguise that from anybody &mdash; and it is harmful and painful to people paying mortgages. 
 I accept that. 
 &bquo;But then it was the right decision for the longer term, to bring down inflation. 
 We have got to reinforce the fact that we are the party of sound money.&equo; 
 Party managers are hoping that by delivering a positive message and creating an upbeat mood, they can avoid too much unrest surfacing during the debate on the economy. 
 Mr Baker said: &bquo;There is no black cloud over me. 
 I am not downhearted. 
 We are behind in the opinion polls. 
 So what? 
 We have been behind before.&equo; 
 On the horns of the Bull Ring dilemma: The people of Birmingham should be allowed to vote on the future development of their city, Jonathan Glancey believes 
 By JONATHAN GLANCEY 
 BIRMINGHAM'S infamous and exhausted retail hub, the Bull Ring, just 25 years old, has been placed on architecture's death row. 
 There will be no stay of execution and few mourners for this spoiled concrete child of the Sixties. 
 Old before its time, the Bull Ring has been accused of the systematic rape of the second city. 
 It also stands accused of murdering the much-loved area around the old Bull Ring market that had grown up in piecemeal fashion over the 800 years since Birmingham was granted a market charter in 1150. 
 This had survived the worst the Luftwaffe could do, but was no match for &bquo;comprehensive redevelopment&equo;. 
 The Bull Ring, completed by Laing Developments in 1964, rammed together four levels of shopping, a market hall, a multi-storey car park, an office block, a bus station and a banqueting suite all in one vast complex. 
 Snaking between its constituent parts was the controversial and overwhelming city ring road designed by the successive and all-powerful city engineers, Herbert Manzoni and Neville Borg. 
 The most militant fan of Sixties architecture would be hard pressed to support a last-minute appeal for the Bull Ring, although crocodile tears will be shed over the probable demolition of the Rotunda, a monumental steel and glass phallus, that, in the absence of a sky-piercing cathedral, acts as the city's one instantly recognisable focal point. 
 But what is going to replace the Bull Ring? 
 Given the stupendous costs involved, should the city be looking to powerful private developers working with big firms of commercial architects to take the lead and replace like with like, albeit in a more acceptable architectural garb? 
 Or should development be given over to a broad church of interest groups and realised by a catholic mix of architects working in a number of complementary styles? 
 The debate in Birmingham has reached something like fever pitch, now that the city council is faced with two rival development schemes. 
 On the one side is the developer, London &amp; Edinburgh Trust (LET) and its architects, Chapman Taylor Partners. 
 On the other is the pressure group, Birmingham for People, championed by local architect Joe Holyoak. 
 LET is in a strong position. 
 It has owned the leasehold of the Bull Ring and surrounding sites since 1985. 
 As LET's partner in charge of the Bull Ring project, John Newman, says: &bquo;We don't have to develop the Bull Ring. 
 We could just sit back and collect rents from an ever-decreasing number of tenants. 
 Instead, we're willing to take the risk and give Birmingham the retail centre it deserves and needs if it is not to be completely undermined by rival out-of- town attractions.&equo; 
 The LET scheme is, in outline at least, straightforward. 
 It envisages replacing the Bull Ring development with a vast new shopping complex, almost free from the graffiti-sprayed subways that have characterised central Birmingham since the mid-Sixties. 
 Shoppers approaching what LET have named The Galleries from New Street and High Street will be channeled along a brand new street flanked by granite and stone-clad pseudo-Classical shops and offices, entering the new mall under a vast glazed dome, second in diameter only to that of St Paul's Cathedral. 
 From this generous lobby, looked down on by diners perched high in the dome's galleries, shoppers will be able to pass either directly down to the open-air market in the shadow of old St Martin's church, explore the curving three-storey shopping halls or snack in a galaxy of glitzy cafes. 
 The attractions of LET's scheme are easy for city councillors to appreciate. 
 The Galleries will act as a one million sq ft magnet to six million shoppers, not just from Birmingham, but from the entire West Midlands conurbation and beyond. 
 Birmingham is well served by public transport, while its frequently denigrated ring road system allows traffic to flow at a remarkably fast pace (17.5mph in rush hours compared to central London's 9 or 10mph). 
 Parking for 3,500 cars, either underground or else in a well disguised Post-Modern palazzo, will encourage shoppers to steer away from rival retail developments in surrounding Solihull, Leamington Spa and Kidderminster, along with the out-of-town Sandwell Mall and Merry Hill Centre. 
 The Galleries will bridge the snarling ring road, which will be buried in decorous tunnels. 
 Rodney Karen, the affable architect in charge of the design of The Galleries, guarantees that they will have a truly urban character. 
 This will not be theme park shopping, Karen insists, nor will The Galleries be closed at night. 
 They will form a integral part of the city, opening up new pedestrian routes, while upgrading existing ones. 
 But Joe Holyoak and the Birmingham for People group believe The Galleries will simply repeat the mistakes made in the early Sixties, but on an even bigger scale. 
 Holyoak's attack, published in a recent issue of The Architects' Journal, is based on two premises. 
 First he takes the city council to task for presenting the LET scheme as a fait accompli, criticising it for &bquo;accepting without question LET's objective of redevelopment in the form of 500-metre-long, inward-looking building&equo;. 
 Holyoak gleefully points out that architect Tony Ridell, of Chapman Taylor Partners, has, rather unfortunately, described The Galleries as &bquo;a huge aircraft carrier settled on the streetscape of the city&equo;. 
 Second, Holyoak attacks the monumentality of The Galleries which, in his words &bquo;is the latest in the big developers&equo; move to privatise city centres &mdash; to eat up public space and reshape it as internalised, homogenised, security-patrolled private space'. 
 Instead, Holyoak proposes a People's Plan for the Bull Ring. 
 This consists of a return to traditional principles of town planning, of conventional streets, markets and shops. 
 The People's Plan includes houses, which the LET scheme expressly discounts. 
 &bquo;A healthy city,&equo; says Holyoak, &bquo;needs a diversity of uses as well as diversity of design.&equo; 
 But, more than that, the People's Plan is an attempt to allow for incremental growth and change. 
 &bquo;Its development,&equo; says Holyoak, &bquo;would not necessitate the great cataclysm of demolition; the plan is designed so that parts of it can be built independently in phases.&equo; 
 Holyoak has another trump card up his sleeve. 
 &bquo;The removal of through traffic, pedestrianisation, new public spaces, new mixed uses, living in the city, environmental quality, removal of subways: all these aspects of the Peoples&equo; Plan are city council policies contained in the City Centre Strategy published in 1987.&equo; 
 Holyoak believes that the council has been bamboozled into adopting LET's monolithic scheme which has had outline planning permission for the last year. 
 &bquo;If,&equo; he says, &bquo;the city council grants full planning permission for The Galleries in the next few weeks, it will not simply be shooting itself in the foot but blowing off its entire leg.&equo; 
 John Newman of LET is unrepentant. 
 &bquo;Holyoak talks about building houses in the centre of Birmingham. 
 But who wants to live there? 
 Would you? 
 I think he's lost in a Victorian vision of Britain.&equo; 
 But what about using a variety of architects and splitting the scheme into a number of smaller related parts? 
 Newman explains that LET works with big practices of commercial architects because time and time again they come up with the goods, on budget, on time and with none of the tantrums of the prima donna. 
 LET's experience of working with &bquo;name&equo; architects has not been very fruitful. 
 &bquo;Chapman Taylor on the other hand,&equo; says Newman, &bquo;understand exactly what the retailer wants.&equo; 
 Chapman Taylor architect Rodney Karen thinks Holyoak's scheme is a case of &bquo;fiddling while Rome burns&equo;. 
 He warns: &bquo;Birmingham has to compete with outlying attractions. 
 At the moment all the centre offers is anxiety. 
 I see The Galleries as a focal point, a powerful force aiding the city, a proper part of the centre designed to enhance its life and character.&equo; 
 But what sort of character? 
 Whether Birmingham city council should push ahead with the LET scheme or stop to consider Holyoak's counterblast must turn on what sort of centre the city wants. 
 Does Birmingham want a centre where people live and work, or a shopping complex that draws in people who live and sleep at the end of the bus routes? 
 Do they want to plan for organic change or reap the fruit of a retail giant that might, no matter what the quality of the architecture, be redundant in another 25 years? 
 It is difficult not to sympathise with the People for Birmingham's scheme. 
 It might be quixotic, it might be full of contradictions and loopholes (how will the traffic flow if the ring road is downgraded as Holyoak plans? why save the Rotunda, when trying to recreate a traditional city centre?), but it does recognise that a city centre works best when it is the sum of a number of interrelated parts. 
 The people of Birmingham ought to be allowed to vote on this all-important issue. 
 Are they, and do they want to be, urbanites or suburbanites? 
 Both Joe Holyoak and his rivals really ought to know. 
 A prayer for the brick cathedral facing St Paul's: Bankside Power Station is a masterpiece worth preserving, Gavin Stamp argues 
 By GAVIN STAMP 
 FROM the top of the dome of St Paul's Cathedral the view is no longer dominated by City church steeples but by an intrusive cacophony of drab, characterless Sixties boxes. 
 One building stands out in this dispiriting panorama of post-war mediocrity: a dark powerful mass of brickwork with a tall central tower that stands right across the Thames from Wren's dome. 
 This is not an office block, nor a church &mdash; although its sublime form might suggest that its architect was adept at designing cathedrals. 
 It is, in fact, the now redundant oil-fired electric power station that sits on Bankside next to the site of Sam Wanamaker's new Globe Theatre. 
 Bankside Power Station should never have been built. 
 Its architect had spent the war years with fellow Royal Academicians planning the orderly and spacious London of the future, free of smoke and industry. 
 But, when asked in 1947 to replace an old dirty power station that had been on the site since 1891, he soon forgot such idealism and, like any architect, was glad to have the job. 
 The project was controversial and the power station was only permitted providing the smoke was clean and the building did not challenge the visual dominance of St Paul's. 
 So the single chimney rose only to 325ft, some 45ft below the height of the cross above the cathedral. 
 The irony is that had the tower been higher and had the teak &bquo;scrubbers&equo; been less efficient, the smoke would have gone straight up into the air. 
 As it was, the &bquo;smokeless shimmer of vapour&equo; was so cooled by cleaning that it drifted across the river to cause mischief with the leadwork on Wren's great dome. 
 Bankside Power Station should not have been built. 
 But, as it was built, it should not now be demolished. 
 That is because it is a magnificent structure, the supreme architectural expression of the heroic, monumental phase of power station design and the creation of a great architect. 
 Bankside was the work of Sir Giles Gilbert Scott, OM, the architect of Liverpool's Anglican Cathedral, the rebuilt House of Commons and some of the last vital products of the Gothic Revival. 
 He was a designer of extraordinary versatility, being responsible for the standard &bquo;traditional&equo; red telephone kiosk, Waterloo Bridge and several power stations. 
 Bankside represents the fullest realisation of his industrial aesthetic. 
 Scott's first venture into this unlikely field of design was at Battersea where, in 1930, he was wheeled in as a famous knighted architect by the London Power Company to try to make acceptable the coal-fired monster power station to which the residents of Chelsea and Westminster were taking strong exception. 
 This was a brilliant move. 
 Scott was so successful in styling the building in fine brickwork with &bquo;jazz-modern&equo; fluting (as John Betjeman called it) that, when the Battersea &bquo;A&equo; station was opened in 1934 it was widely acclaimed as a supremely successful modern treatment of a building type that seemed quintessentially twentieth century. 
 When, in 1939, The Architects' Journal conducted a survey to find what were considered the best modern buildings in Britain, Battersea was placed second &mdash; and was the favourite of such unlikely celebrities as Sir Kenneth Clark, Rebecca West and Charles Laughton. 
 Scott was so pleased with the style he had evolved at Battersea, a treatment that humanised industrial forms without denying their function, that he also used it on the Guinness Factory at Park Royal, west London. 
 At Battersea, Scott could not alter the basic design of the building and he much disliked the &bquo;upturned table&equo; appearance created by the four corner chimneys. 
 At Bankside, however, he was able to persuade the engineers, Mott, Hay &amp; Anderson, to gather all the flues into a single &bquo;slender tower or campanile&equo;. 
 As a result, he was able to create a symmetrical, monumental composition of great power. 
 As at all his power stations, Scott faced the building in a fine Worcestershire brick that has weathered to a lovely pinky-brown. 
 But there is nothing homely about the general effect. 
 Vast overlapping planes of brickwork are modelled with careful set-backs and subtle bands of detail. 
 The result is an expression of the monumental aesthetic of the early twentieth century, with strong American overtones. 
 When the campanile is seen from a distance, it seems to belong to some strange Expressionist church one has not noticed before. 
 Not for nothing were such power stations described as &bquo;brick cathedrals&equo;; Bankside is the finest manifestation of this tradition. 
 Now it is redundant. 
 Smoke shimmers no longer from the tall tower. 
 But Bankside is nevertheless a sound structure which, like the best mills of the Industrial Revolution, is well worth preserving and is perfectly capable of adaptation for a new commercial use. 
 Such re-use is, of course, much encouraged by a building being listed, something which, until recently, was not possible with architecture of so recent a date. 
 Two years ago, however, the Department of the Environment at last began the listing of post-war buildings in England that were more than 30 years old. 
 Bracken House, the former home of the Financial Times, became the first candidate and English Heritage then submitted some 70 recommendations to the Department of the Environment; these included Bankside. 
 This, however, was too much for the Government and, using the excuse that public opinion was not yet ready to accept the protection of many unpopular modern buildings, Lord Caithness, the Minister of State for the Environment, arbitrarily whittled down English Heritage's list to 18 buildings - excluding Bankside &mdash; although it represented a more traditional approach in the Fifties to the now-unfashionable Modern Movement. 
 However, Caithness himself stated that this first selection was &bquo;in no way a definitive list&hellip; 
 I have no doubt that others will be added. 
 The important thing is that the Thirty Year Rule is in force and that we can respond to developing perceptions of our times.&equo; 
 Earlier this year, in my capacity as chairman of the Thirties Society, I asked Caithness's successor, Virginia Bottomley, to reconsider English Heritage's recommendation of Bankside for listing. 
 My argument was that, as Michael Heseltine had so boldly listed Battersea Power Station in 1980, it was illogical not to protect a much finer and more complete industrial work by the same architect. 
 Furthermore, the listing of Battersea had ensured the building's survival for conversion to a new use &mdash; in that case, as an entertainment centre which the Prime Minister herself had praised and inaugurated. 
 After two months' silence, I was informed that ministers stood by their decision. 
 I wrote back asking the reasons for this, pointing out that, if any large modern power station deserved to be listed, it was Bankside. 
 I have received no satisfactory reply. 
 Of course, I know perfectly well why the Department of the Environment declines to list it. 
 Listed building procedures might impede the full commercial realisation of the site when the electricity industry is privatised. 
 Furthermore, British Rail has its eyes on the Bankside site for bringing up the spoil from the tunnel for Channel traffic which it is, so absurdly, driving under the middle of London at astronomical cost. 
 Listing, in theory, is an objective assessment of architectural or historical importance which does not necessarily prevent demolition. 
 In the case of Bankside Power Station, the ultimate &bquo;temple of power&equo; and a masterpiece of industrial architecture by a major twentieth-century British architect, our historic building system is being perverted for purely political reasons. 
 Architecture Update: Sites and scenes 
 By GAVIN STAMP 
 THE BBC 2 Building Sites series (Wednesdays, 10.20pm) takes viewers on a tour of Janet Street-Porter's gingerbread-style house in London's Smithfield. 
 Ms Street-Porter does the talking, while her architect, the clever Piers Gough, seems unnaturally quiet. 
 This cannot be said of the colourful house, which turns out to be as likeable as its architect. 
 Less likeable is a thoroughly daft idea by Rochdale Council to purchase compulsorily weavers' cottages in Clegg, Lancashire. 
 Theme Park Britons, (tonight, Channel 4, 9.15pm) details the council's plan to oust local residents and turn Clegg into a &bquo;multi-century themed village&equo;. 
 The living, working residents will be replaced by dummies &bquo;re-enacting scenes from working life&equo;. 
 Architecture Update: Views from Leeds 
 By GAVIN STAMP 
 PROFESSOR Peter Smith believes that &bquo;reasoned architectural criticism has given way to inflammatory metaphor&equo;. 
 Tomorrow he delivers a lecture Beyond the Rhetoric: a cool look at architectural judgement as the first in a series by new professors at Leeds Polytechnic. 
 Lecture begins 5.30pm, Brunswick Building lecture theatre, Merrion Way, Leeds. 
 Tickets from Lynda McStay (0532) 463231. 
 Architecture Update: All the way from the Bank 
 By GAVIN STAMP 
 THE WORK of Ron Herron, an architect whose career spans the now unfashionable Hayward Gallery and Queen Elizabeth Hall on London's South Bank, the heady days of Sixties pop architecture, to his recent computer-generated designs, is on exhibition in London until 21 October. 
 Herron's pop collages should not be missed, nor should the opportunity to be guided by computers through his latest projects. 
 &bquo;Sets + Things&equo; is at the Heinz Gallery, Portman Square, London W1, Mondays to Fridays 11am to 5pm; Saturdays 10am to 1pm. 
 Television / Rising to the Cajun 
 By SABINE DURRANT 
 ALONG A long, wide highway, palm-trees swaying, sun glinting on distant windscreens, cruised a low, sleek convertible Corvette. 
 It could have been the opening sequence of any off-beat, low-budget American cop series, but closer attention to the soundtrack ('Green Onions' would be an unusual choice for Florida Felony) gave it away. 
 This you realised, the moment the driver turned to give the camera a typically vague, rumbustious salute, was the first programme in Floyd's American Pie (BBC 2). 
 Keith Floyd, the housewife's galloping choice and tippling gourmet extraordinaire, has said goodbye to the roues of Provence, the stews of West Cork and embarked upon, as he so professionally put it, &bquo;the BBC maxi-break of a lifetime&equo;. 
 While American grub generally has little of the yearning deliciousness of French cuisine, New Orleans, Floyd's first port of call, has certain obvious attractions. 
 Huge concoctions of gumbo and jambalaya, crawfish pie and Andouille sausage, against a backdrop of swamps and snakes, street-cars and Creole Queens, suit the postcard, throw-it-all-in format of this particular culinary genre, and life in the Big Easy clearly made Floyd feel at home. 
 He toyed with raccoon meat, alligator fat and &bquo;trinity&equo; (green peppers, onions and celery) in a shack on the bayou, stirred steaming okra stew in K-Paul's Louisiana Kitchen, and concocted a vast, suppurating cauldron of seafood gumbo (crab, oysters, shrimps, sausages, seafood boudin, mudbugs, salted pork) in the New Orleans Cookery School. 
 Throughout, his banter came as thick and fast as softshelled crab, only halting as he paused to take a slurp from his Dixie Beer or to wipe the steam off the camera lens. 
 The programme's frenetic shuffling of history lesson, Holiday &bquo;89 and Fanny Craddock at times seemed irritatingly brash. 
 But Floyd's air of mock humility, constant stream of self-reflexive comments ('Quick cut away; lots and lots of minutes have gone by now&equo;) and bossy remarks to the cameraman were as refreshing as ever. 
 &bquo;If you want the exact quantities, buy my book,&equo; he said at one point, one eye in the direction of the BBC publicity department, before adding, as the other swivelled down towards his drink, &bquo;if I can be bothered to write it.&equo; 
 Energy is not a quality one could easily accuse Wilfred Thesiger, &bquo;The Last Explorer&equo;, of lacking, as last night's Viewpoint &bquo;89 (Central) showed. 
 Now in his eightieth year, Thesiger looked back on a life travelling in the Sudan, Arabia, Afghanistan, Morocco, East Africa and &bquo;Eth&hellip; 
 Abyssinia, as I insist on calling it&equo;. 
 Milky blue eyes disappearing behind bushy eyebrows, Thesiger told interviewer Julian Pettifer of the dignity, pure morality and barbaric splendour he had found in civilizations since destroyed by &bquo;the drab uniformity of the modern world&equo;. 
 Oddly, though, his public school / Oxbridge language ('Bloody Italians') seemed unaffected by life in strange, savage worlds. 
 A young Abyssinian, returning to camp with a victim's testicle hanging from his belt, he compared to &bquo;a deserving young Etonian who has just got his colours for cricket.&equo; 
 Jazz Diary 
 By CHRIS PARKER 
 Legend is an overworked term in jazz: it can describe a figure like Eubie Blake, who died at 100 after a lifetime's achievement, or those who died young, their promise unfulfilled, like everyone from Jimmy Blanton to Charlie Parker. 
 But the word fits singer and composer Slim Gaillard, whose extraordinary life is to be celebrated in a four-part Arena series, Slim Gaillard's Civilisation. 
 Born in Cuba to a German-Jewish father and a black mother &mdash; &bquo;I was sort of kosher, but swinging&equo; &mdash; he cut sugar-cane in his youth before joining his father, a ship's steward, on his travels, only to be accidentally left behind on Crete at 12: &bquo;I had to sit down for a minute &mdash; almost cried.&equo; 
 From there, at 16, he moved via Lebanon to Detroit, where he worked in a beauty shop and a car factory before helping the notorious Purple Gang smuggle alcohol from Canada in a hearse. 
 He also freelanced, collecting bodies from alleys for medical students. 
 All this was before he became a jazz legend, writing such hits as &bquo;Flat Foot Floogie&equo; and appearing in films like Hellzapoppin. 
 After the war he set Hollywood alight with his invented language, Vout, and played with Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie. 
 He has been idolised by fictional characters from Dean Moriarty in Kerouac's On the Road to Barley in Le Carre's The Russia House, and he is one of only two people looked up to by Miles Davis. 
 Now, he is living in the UK: &bquo;I like the weather here and the people are friendly &mdash; no revolvers.&equo; 
 Slim Gaillard's Civilisation begins on 22 October on BBC 2 GIVEN the renewed popular interest in bebop, it might be supposed that drummer Max Roach, who came to prominence playing it, would take a pragmatic view of two movies which helped that resurgence: the Charlie Parker film Bird and Round Midnight, loosely based on the life of the pianist Bud Powell. 
 But his reservations outweigh his praise: &bquo;They may have done some good in creating interest in two people who've made major innovations in twentieth-century music, but they've also given a negative impression: that the people involved in this music have serious flaws in their personalities. 
 This obscures the fact that many major contributors &mdash; Duke Ellington, Count Basie, Dizzy Gillespie &mdash; are the total opposite; it also ignores the fact that the freak depicted in Bird is not the Charlie Parker I knew and worked with at all.&equo; 
 More generally, Roach has reservations about the direction the music took after bebop &mdash; &bquo;There was a change-over: it went into dance and party music, functioning as an entertaining vehicle rather than an intellectual, enlightening thing&equo; &mdash; and he sees the effects of this slackening of purpose in the playing of a number of later-1980s musicians. 
 Roach is a busy man: as well as continuing work with his quartet (currently touring the UK), his double quartet, a percussion ensemble known as M'Boom and a forthcoming collaboration on a play about the Harlem Renaissance, he's also involved with New York rappers in a project called From Bebop to Hiphop and Then There's Max. 
 Many jazz-players, often to the detriment of their later careers, rise to prominence through a single performance or achievement and find themselves saddled with an epithet expressing public expectations. 
 An example of this typecasting has been US alto-saxophonist Lee Konitz, customarily referred to as &bquo;Doyen of the Cool School&equo;. 
 Not that he resents this: &bquo;Categories are essential for describing phenomena and I'm a phenomenon of some kind. 
 I've always tried to play as intensely as I can. 
 I'm not a high-energy person, though.&equo; 
 Anyone who has seen a recent Konitz performance won't argue with this; taste, attention to tonal delicacy and a striving after melodic inventiveness are his hallmarks. 
 Indeed, in the interval of a gig on his 1986 UK tour, a disgruntled punter was heard to remark: &bquo;If I'd wanted something this cerebral on a Friday night, I'd &bquo;ve stayed at home and read Proust.&equo; 
 Konitz acknowledges that there is some basis in his history for this view: he and his 1950s musical guru, the pianist Lennie Tristano, in a sense set themselves up as a (white) alternative school to bebop: &bquo;Tristano was keen to prove that whites could play jazz, though Charlie Parker, Lester Young and Louis Armstrong were his heroes. 
 Tristano's was an improvised music, and part of its quality was that it wasn't as flashy and virtuosic as bebop. 
 We made the first free-jazz record, with no plan, just improvised. 
 It had its effect: Ornette Coleman heard it.&equo; 
 These days Konitz plays everything from standards to samba &mdash; he's recently recorded a wonderfully relaxed album with Brazilian accompanists, Lee Konitz in Rio &mdash; and he's shortly to tour the UK. 
 For details, see tomorrow's Listings. 
 THEATRE / Sublime to ridiculous: Kemp on the Ninagawa Company's Suicide for Love at the National 
 By PETER KEMP 
 AT THE start of Yukio Ninagawa's Suicide for Love, a geisha puppet &mdash; picked out from pitch darkness by a spotlight &mdash; is manipulated through a series of formalised attitudes. 
 Then, as lanterns start to glow on wooden balconies and red gleams fall through slatted screens, the stage gradually brightens to reveal a gaudy, tumultuous crowd in the pleasure district of seventeenth-century Osaka. 
 Visually resplendent &mdash; like everything in this production &mdash; it's an effect that also makes vividly manifest the play's twin concerns of control and unruliness. 
 For Suicide for Love &mdash; a synthesis by Matsuyo Akimoto of works by the seventeenth-century dramatist Monzaemon Chikamatsu &mdash; depicts a world in which individual impulses are kept in place by fierce restraints. 
 Shutting in all the characters of this drama is a society of unyielding rigidity. 
 Reminders of this are visible even in the decor of the red-light quarter. 
 People riotously reel around here, fighting, fondling, tittering, clowning. 
 But penning in this raucous melee are buildings that seem all shutters and grids. 
 Lolling behind a screen of vertical bars, girls in a brothel resemble animals in a cage. 
 Demarcated as the one zone where people are allowed some liberty, the pleasure district is in itself testimony to a stringently regulated society. 
 And, even amid its licensed disorderly streets, ceremonial and ritual can hold sway &mdash; as is displayed by the stately procession through the teeming revellers of a stoop-kneed, silk-swathed geisha and her entourage. 
 Her face a rice-white mask of impassivity above the elaborately arranged draperies of her kimono, she looks more objet d'art than human being. 
 What most strikes you about this elegantly swaddled creature is that she seems encumbered by the costume of her role. 
 Likewise, aesthetically lacquered trappings dramatically impede the movements of the drama's main characters. 
 Taking two contrasting stories of thwarted aspirations from Chikamatsu, Akimoto's play juxtaposes &mdash; to evoke the atmosphere of popular melodrama - high-flown sentiment and down-to-earth sense. 
 While one tale is all doomed romantic passion, the other portrays an unglamorous urge to stay alive. 
 The heroic plot has Chubei, an ardent, sensitive youth, falling in love with Umegawa, a courtesan chance brings his way. 
 A further accident &mdash; stumbling over a coffer of government funds in his care &mdash; fatally scatters temptation before him. 
 Stealing the money, Chubei is able to buy Umegawa from the clutches of a wealthier rival. 
 Abetting him in this is his childhood friend Yohei, a woebegone young husband much harassed by a matronly dragon of a mother-in-law. 
 The broad comedy he brings into the drama is, like the operatic emotions of the romantic plot, performed with masterly finesse. 
 As not only Chubei and Umegawa but also Yohei and his wife find themselves under sentence of death from the Shoguns' inexorable laws, both couples make a suicide pact. 
 In Yohei's case, this collapses into a craven botch &mdash; hilariously acted by Ryo Amamiya &mdash; in which he more or less accidentally dispatches his wife but can't bring himself to take the plunge and throw himself into the river as promised. 
 While this interlude spoofs the love-suicide convention, though, Chubei's story spectacularly dramatises it. 
 In a thrilling climactic scene during a howling blizzard in the mountains, he and Umegawa do kill themselves. 
 With macabre gracefulness, she is strangled with a crimson scarf. 
 When Chubei slashes his neck, a thread of scarlet spurts out. 
 With its splashes of red standing out from the swirling whiteness of the snowstorm, this tableau combines the decorative and the dramatic in a manner reminiscent of the finest Japanese prints. 
 And throughout the evening, making you almost afraid to blink in case you miss anything, Ninagawa fills the stage with a constantly shifting sequence of such pictures &mdash; including a magnificent riverside landscape with clumps of reeds bleached by the light of an enormous moon. 
 The plash of flowing water is authentically audible throughout this scene. 
 And, everywhere in the production, there is deployment of carefully-chosen sound effects. 
 The most noticeable of them is a throbbingly emotional ballad -as if from some oriental Tom Jones &mdash; which intermittently wells out to remind you of the popular nature of the love dramas you are witnessing. 
 But what most impresses you about this phenomenal piece of theatre is less its class affiliations than its national attributes: a drama of mutinous impulses crushed by an authoritarian social system is given consummate rendering by a cast who very triumphantly unite energy and discipline. 
 THEATRE / Bowling without spin: Macbeth &mdash; Redgrave, Farnham 
 By ALEX RENTON 
 THE MOST remarkable thing about Graham Watkins's Macbeth is that it only has two women. 
 You suspect, though, that featuring male witches is a reaction to economic demands rather than any sort of radical reinterpretation in this, the Redgrave's first Shakespeare in many years. 
 But it works well enough. 
 Just about everything works well enough in this competent but hardly inspiring production. 
 It seems that Watkins's energies have gone into making sure he has got the details right at the expense of analysis. 
 Details are indeed slavishly attended to: at the &bquo;cry of women&equo; you hear a light offstage wailing; when the owl shrieks after Duncan's death, we get a &bquo;tu-whit-tu-whoo&equo;. 
 These are acceptable, but the witch who, at &bquo;by the pricking of my thumbs&equo;, held up his thumbs and twiddled them for us all to check out was excessive. 
 Macbeth, short and severely to the point, is not a play onto which you can get much spin, but what we are given here is a treatment devoid of ambiguity. 
 Even an A-level student might want a little more in the way of interpretation. 
 But at the Redgrave you sit back and watch an unarguable Macbeth unroll. 
 James Bolam takes the lead, and he makes a fair job of it. 
 He is not a Macbeth who seems particularly hag-ridden, by wife or witches, nor grotesquely ambitious. 
 Until the final scenes Bolam's Macbeth is a placid, middle-management man who may reckon he has been unfairly passed over for promotion. 
 Many of his speeches are given in the quiet, confidential way he might explain his predicament in the pub. 
 It is hard not to sympathise with his desire to knock off managing director Duncan, a hammy, cantankerous old fool in Kevin Stoney's playing. 
 Susan Jameson makes a similarly polite and suburban Lady Macbeth. 
 For excitement you have got to look elsewhere: David Lancaster's music has cracked brass blowing doom-laden fanfares, and Clare Southern's costumes are samurai studded quilts, suitably grubby for a Stone Age Scotland. 
 The English, by contrast, sport pristine chainmail. 
 Some characters live up to their dress: Peter Craze's pig-tailed Banquo, earthy and violent, and Stephen Hattersley's no-nonsense Macduff are a welcome contrast to Bolam's King. 
 The pace picks up towards the end: Bolam's hair goes awry, and for the first time a sense of desperation enters his acting. 
 But generally this is a straight Macbeth with the morality all in order: nothing fancy, and precious little to dwell upon afterwards. 
 MUSIC / Tedium in one key: Tess Knighton on The Sixteen at Broadcasting House 
 By TESS KNIGHTON 
 THE IBERIAN Baroque is waiting to be rediscovered; with Antonio Teixeira's 20-voiced setting of the Te Deum The Sixteen uncovered a Portuguese corner of a vast, but largely forgotten or ignored, musical tapestry. 
 By the eighteenth century, the music of the Iberian Peninsula, so long dominated by North European developments, had a decidedly Italianate weave: Scarlattian, even occasionally Vivaldian threads run through the texture. 
 Yet this piece has much that is freshly inventive and original, even if these were epithets that, alas, did not readily spring to mind with regard to the performance it received. 
 The Te Deum was never the most popular text amongst composers of the pre-Baroque, but in the eighteenth century it enjoyed a new, though rather limited, vogue: from Purcell and Handel to Haydn, festive settings with large and colourful forces became the norm. 
 Teixeira's contribution to the genre was first performed in 1728, just after he had return to Portugal from Rome, and it reveals Italian influence in its polychorality (it is scored for five &bquo;choirs&equo; of four voices each) and the florid, operatic nature of the solo snippets. 
 The question is whether The Sixteen, having revived this work, could breathe life into their performance. 
 A church setting would undoubtedly have been more atmospheric than the shocking pink of the BBC Concert Hall, but then listeners to the broadcast will only need to worry about aural aesthetics. 
 There were one or two things that may concern them (the scratchy sound of the orchestra for one), though nothing that should deter them from tuning in, for the singing was generally fine, with particularly good contributions from the basses (Michael George and Peter Harvey), the soprano Nancy Argenta, the tenor Andrew Murgatroyd, the &bquo;cantor&equo; Nicholas Robertson and the choir itself, here expanded, of course, to The Twenty. 
 It happens in the musical world that conductors sometimes rely on their performers to do their work for them; it is currently happening rather too often in the field of &bquo;early music&equo;. 
 This disturbing fact passes mostly unremarked, partly because the repertory is often unfamiliar, but partly, too, because the role of the conductor in pre-nineteenth-century music can be a source of embarrassment. 
 Be that as it may, this work, heavily reliant on repetition and never straying far from the home key, cried out for someone to nurture its more lyrical passages, to shake its often delightful phrases, to exploit its contrasts; in short, for a far more imaginative approach than that brought by Harry Christophers. 
 DANCE / Scatty, logical humour: Judith Mackrell reviews the Groupe Emile Dubois at the Queen Elizabeth Hall, opening this year's Dance Umbrella 
 By JUDITH MACKRELL 
 THIS YEAR'S enthusiastically Francophile Dance Umbrella opened with one of the most prestigious of the French new-wave companies &mdash; Jean-Claude Gallotta's Groupe Emile Dubois. 
 Gallotta's whimsical approach receives heavy support in his own country. 
 But on Monday night the audience at the Queen Elizabeth Hall appeared neatly divided &mdash; between those who were willing to prolong the applause indefinitely and those who either disappeared discreetly halfway through or scarpered quickly at the end. 
 Gallotta's Mammame is true to a very French type, with its scatty logic, its mix of dance, gesture and slapstick and its ability to polarise opinion between &bquo;joyously unconfined choreography&equo; and &bquo;mildly diverting tosh&equo;. 
 By the end of 90 minutes I was close to the tosh school, but still buoyed up by the work's genuine pleasures; the unflagging force of its energy, the wit of its timing and the comic unlikeliness of some of its performers. 
 The women admittedly conform to standard dancerly mould, and it is an awkwardness in the piece that little of its clowning comes from them. 
 But the men look, refreshingly, as if they have spent years away from the studio mirror. 
 There is a tragic buffoon with bald pate and flowing hair; a short, bespectacled man entering a grey and paunchy middle age; and Gallotta himself, who patters manically around the stage, fixing the dancers with an unfocused glare, while waving his arms and muttering instructions down a microphone. 
 When Gallotta works up steam he has the dancers going through some startlingly slick paces &mdash; polished dance routines, split-second falls and lifts and a brisk formation crawl. 
 But this adroitness is constantly fighting against a humanly disruptive counterpoint. 
 During a jazzy quartet for the women, the company's shambling clown is dangerously over-excited by one dancer's leggy prowess, attempting to nuzzle up against her or to initiate a wildly mismatched pas de deux. 
 At one point, half the company are banging rhythmically on a table like kids at a tea party. 
 At another, the women wrap themselves in blankets and line up pitifully like a group of refugees. 
 But in a piece where every idea is disposable, very little turns out to be memorable. 
 What ought to be exciting about Mammame is the unpredictability with which an image or a movement switches into something new. 
 Yet too often its lawlessness feels like an empty romp. 
 For all its tension between unison and bedlam, its freedom to use any kind of gesture or step, you are rarely exhilarated by a sense of newly-discovered movement. 
 Few of Gallotta's ideas are developed rigorously enough to see all their possibilities, and too many degenerate into rituals for marking time. 
 It is good to see the French contingent at the Umbrella. 
 But I have yet to be convinced (as some publicity suggests) that the centre of the dance universe is now located in France. 
 THEATRE / A spark of Greek fire: The Trojan Women - Liverpool Everyman 
 By JEFFREY WAINWRIGHT 
 THE FULL resonance of this production may not be felt until next May. 
 By that time the Everyman's new artistic director, John Doyle, and his permanent company will have worked their way through an ambitious and unusually schematic programme culminating in two works of twentieth-century apocalypse: a Solzhenitsyn piece from the Gulag, and the Chernobyl play Sarcophagus. 
 But they begin at the beginning, with three works derived from the Greeks; the first is Euripides's dramatised cantata of desolation, The Trojan Women. 
 The scene is Troy immediately after its fall. 
 King Priam's widow Hecuba and other women await their fate from the victorious Greeks. 
 In four episodes Cassandra, Andromache, Helen and, most affectingly, Andromache's small son Astyranax, are remorselessly accounted for. 
 The corralled women are emphatically at male disposal, though the contradictory figure of Helen is twisted into the torque of human hatreds by hands from both sides of the sexual divide. 
 On stage, Euripides's plainness is both promising and exposing. 
 The promise, of imaginative setting, is very well taken up here by Elizabeth Ascroft's designs. 
 She presents us with a glistening floor bordered by a number of bells hanging from long ropes, each lit from above to produce its own pool of light. 
 As the action proper begins, Poseidon and Athene rush a white curtain round the perimeter of the auditorium. 
 The actors take up this hieratic style, and achieve considerable physical stillness, exemplified by the profile of Irma Inniss's Helen. 
 Their exposure is extreme. 
 Nicholas Monu's Poseidon seizes the attention at the beginning, but the scale of the speeches one actor after another must face is daunting. 
 They are permitted no naturalistic embellishment, but given that choice the stylisation should be taken further. 
 For instance, Maria Gough as Cassandra brings great energy and commitment but has a modern prettiness where the implacability of the classical mask might have made her more awesome and compelling. 
 Similarly, having chosen to use a large Chorus, John Doyle has not developed their ritual of voice and movement far enough. 
 To go further in these directions would also require more boldly gestural language than Philip Vellacott's plausible, if prosaic translation provides. 
 This is altogether a bold and uncompromising enterprise. 
 But, although it tries, it fails to persuade us that with Greek drama we are not secular theatre-goers but communicants in a religious mystery. 
 Commodities 
 By JEFFREY WAINWRIGHT 
 GOLD was slightly easier yesterday, ending in London at &dollar;362.00/&dollar;362.50 an ounce after the dollar surged following comments by Alan Greenspan, the Federal Reserve chairman, which implied the US would keep interest rates firm. 
 It was joined by silver and platinum, both of which also slipped back. 
 On the LME, copper attracted most of the attention, trading up to &pound;1,900 per tonne during second ring afternoon dealings, its highest level since late August when sterling values hit an all-time high of &pound;1,932. 
 Armchair Investor: Crest Nicholson 
 By JEFFREY WAINWRIGHT 
 THE latest interest rate rise put the dampners on the housebuilding sector. 
 The housing market is the worst seen for 25 years, and a 15 per cent base rate and rising mortgage rates cannot help. 
 The downgradings in the sector may be justified on some housebuilders, but others look severely undervalued at current levels. 
 Prime among these is Wilson Bowden, the Leicestershire-based housebuilder which increased profits despite a 25 per cent fall in house sales. 
 The group is strongest in the resilient Midlands and a land bank stretching five years is good security. 
 At 212&frac12; p, down 111 2 p yesterday, the shares are on five times earnings assuming pre-tax profits of &pound;43m this year. 
 Westbury Homes, the Cheltenham-based group, also has a long land bank, but its main market, the West country, is relatively weak. 
 It needed some land sales to achieve pre-tax profits of &pound;36.2m for the year to February. 
 This total is achievable this year, putting the shares at 196p, down 2p yesterday, on a very cheap multiple of 4.4. 
 Crest Nicholson is the exception, not having much of a land bank and relying on its skills in land buying. 
 Like the well regarded YJ Lowell, Crest is interested in urban regeneration, and a large development in Swindon should start contributing to profits next year. 
 Profits for the year that ends this month should reach &pound;42m pre-tax, putting the shares at 179p, down 5p yesterday, on 5.9 times earnings. 
 All these shares should be bought and tucked away for when interest rates ease. 
 Column Eight: Mobil slips up over pound 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 The prize for the most unfortunate advertisement this year must go to Mobil, the oil major, for yesterday's offering in the Financial Times. 
 xo Keen to trumpet its part in the future of offshore energy, the company went back 25 years. 
 &bquo;Mods and rockers fought on the beach at Clacton; John Steed and Emma Peel joined forces against evil as The Avengers; West Ham froze out Preston North End to win the FA Cup; Treasury officials defended the pound by borrowing &pound;1,080m. 
 And Britain announced the first licence awards for North Sea Oil and Gas&equo;. 
 So far, so good. 
 But the ad continued: &bquo;Times change, occasionally for the better&hellip; 
 Today, the pound is holding its own.&equo; 
 And this after the Treaury has spent roughly &dollar;3bn defending sterling in the last 10 days, probably to no avail. 
 Gerrard &amp; National, the venerable City discount house, is not easily swayed from its time-honoured customs. 
 Neither, it seems, does it believe in new- fangled technology. 
 As guests sat down to lunch in the company's magnificent dining room earlier this week, the fellow with his back to the window was asked if there was too much of a draught. 
 There was, so the waiters were dispatched at once. 
 They returned with a huge roll of green baize which was then gently placed on top of the groaning air conditioner. 
 Gordon Dunlop, the former director and chief financial officer of British Airways, has turned his interest towards the Lloyd's insurance market. 
 He is running for a place on its ruling council in the forthcoming elections. 
 If elected, Mr Dunlop, who is also a past chief executive of Commercial Union, says he would question whether the services offered by Lloyd's are efficient and cost effective. 
 He also has reservations about the market's accounting procedures. 
 It may seem tame stuff after helping out in the privatising of British Airways. 
 However, previous attempts to change those procedures at Lloyd's have usually presented more problems than privatising the water authorities. 
 Having flatly denied that he has any intention of going to British Rail, Sir David Plastow, chairman of Vickers, yesterday announced that he has installed a &bquo;safety valve&equo; guaranteeing that he will not be solely responsible should his company hit the slippery slope. 
 He has granted his lieutenants carte blanche to rebel should his performance &bquo;go crook&equo;, to use his phrase. 
 They have been formally invited to ring Dick Lloyd, the deputy chairman, to vent their spleen. 
 View from City Road: Paying over the pop for cellular 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 McCAW'S revised offer for just over 50 per cent of LIN Broadcasting is cleverly structured. 
 It is more attractive to LIN shareholders, who will retain an interest in their company, and reduces the exposure to the risk that the US cellular radio market bubble will burst for British Telecom, which has a 22 per cent stake in McCaw. 
 BT's role in the new offer is hidden but doubtless significant. 
 By bidding for half rather than all of LIN there should be no need for McCaw to seek additional funding from BT since its cash resources and existing lines of credit should cover the cost. 
 And by deferring for five years the right to purchase the balance of LIN's shares BT is protected against a downturn in cellular company prices. 
 That downturn remains a real risk in an industry where the true commercial prospects have still to be established. 
 Although the &bquo;price per pop&equo;, the measurement used to value US cellular businesses, has risen steadily it is far from certain that the trend will continue. 
 The terms of the revised McCaw offer value LIN at &dollar;293 per pop, which is the highest yet recorded. 
 But it is also an inflated price since it represents a healthy premium for control of the last really big established national player in the US cellular market. 
 The price also reflects the ominous presence of BellSouth which has tabled a rival offer for LIN. 
 While BT can be pleased that it bought into McCaw at a much lower price than today's going rate and that it will be difficult for other overseas companies to enter the US domestic market, it will be some time before its investment begins to yield a return. 
 There is still no guarantee that McCaw, even with LIN, can achieve the penetration rates necessary to make cellular radio commercially viable. 
 For the time being all BT is buying is a concept. 
 The danger for UK investors is that they will be lured into thinking that the inflated prices paid in the US translate into an undervaluation of British cellular operators. 
 It is a dangerous assumption. 
 The British and European cellular markets are very different from that in the US. 
 The position is further clouded by the curious share structure of Racal Telecom where most of the free floating shares are US held. 
 The US investors' enthusiasm for cellular radio, therefore, has a strong bearing on Racal Telecom's price performance. 
 The cellular business remains complex and uncertain and investors should continue to view it with a healthly degree of caution. 
 View from City Road: Murdoch loses Midas touch 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 RUPERT Murdoch's profit warning will not lead Australian and US shareholders to desert News Corporation the way they have dumped Alan Bond, but it must be rather worrying. 
 Suddenly, there is just the slightest hint that Mr Murdoch is losing the magic touch, and for many investment banks and financial institutions around the world that magic touch was the main reason for backing him. 
 The news was not entirely unexpected. 
 In August, announcing profits of A&dollar;496m net for 1988/89, he said that in future losses on Sky TV in the UK would be charged directly against the profit and loss account. 
 In the worst possible case, that would slice A&dollar;250m off the result for this year, and nobody could have expected him to make up that sort of ground. 
 But other problems have arisen which will make 1990 a difficult year even when Sky is taken into account. 
 The first is the world economic situation, which hits him in two ways. 
 First, he has enormous debts totalling &dollar;7.9bn at the last year end, which are an obvious burden in a period of rising interest rates, even higher in Australia than the UK. 
 Second, there is the knock-on effect to the advertising market in the UK and Australia, which is looking weaker than it has for a long time. 
 Not everything is black. 
 Mr Murdoch can draw some comfort from the fact that News' own interest rates are 70 per cent fixed at long-term rates, and it looks as though he will narrowly avoid joining the A&dollar;1bn interest payers list at next year end. 
 Cash flow from Wapping, and from the Fox TV business in the US, will continue at around twice interest payments, and debts will be within the agreed limits. 
 But there is little leeway for anything to go wrong. 
 Sky may do better than most people think, but it will not turn into another Fox, breaking even in its second year. 
 The launch of BSB, still scheduled for next spring, will be the true test of the Sky formula, while an advertising downturn would take away some of the very good margin the UK papers enjoy, especially The Sunday Times which is operating in an increasingly competitive Sunday market. 
 The Murdoch image has also taken a knock with the failure of Media Partners, when investors proved unwilling to back his management style. 
 News Corp must be hoping that the sins of the son are not visited on the father. 
 View from City Road: Water holds hidden perils 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 THE Government's efforts to ensure that all 10 water authorities are successfully floated on the Stock Exchange in December are becoming more than a little disingenuous. 
 The impression given by the marketing campaign is that you are being invited to invest in a single entity &mdash; the British water industry &mdash; and that there will be attractive perks for those who do. 
 This is not the case. 
 In fact you are being invited to invest in 10 separate companies each with different characteristics and ambitions. 
 The perks are specifically designed to encourage people to invest in their local water authority despite the fact that it is patently obvious that some are not going to be as attractive as others. 
 In other words, if you live in the North-west but believe Yorkshire to be a fundamentally more attractive investment, you are being cheated. 
 Meanwhile the individual authorities are gagged from revealing anything meaningful about their business or aims and it is doubtful that the prospectuses, when they are published, will be any more illuminating. 
 The Government's aim is to make the authorities all appear the same in investment terms. 
 The effect of this is that nobody, some City professionals included, really knows much about any of them. 
 The growing number of people registering their interest in investing are being driven by the greed factor alone. 
 They know little about what they are being asked to invest in, but they do believe that the Government's determination to make the privatisation succeed will ensure that the water authorities are presented as a steal. 
 In an uncertain market and given the water flotation is already something of a lottery, that is a dangerous attitude to take. 
 Market Report: Burmah bucks trend on day of gloom and doom 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 BURMAH, the oil group which nearly came to grief in the 1970s stock market crash, was one of the few shares to resist Barclays de Zoete Wedd's gloomy forecast on shares. 
 In occasionally active trading it closed 16p higher at 635p after touching 648p. 
 In two days, when the market has been in ragged retreat, the shares have climbed 34p. 
 Although many oil experts are taking a more bullish view of the sector, the Burmah performance indicates corporate activity. 
 SHV, the powerful Dutch group which has aready made its presence felt in the UK oil industry, is known to have approaching 5 per cent of the capital. 
 There is continuing speculation it wants Burmah to buy Calor Group, where it has 43 per cent. 
 The SHV objective is to end up with a significant stake in Burmah, perhaps as much as 29.9 per cent. 
 The rest of the market was under the BZW whip. 
 Consultant Peter Thompson destroyed a hesitant rally when he forecast the FT-SE share index ending the month at 2,100 or 2,200 points and sinking to 1,800 next year. 
 At one time the FT-SE was riding 17.2 points higher. 
 But gradually confidence weakened. 
 And once Mr Thompson's views became known in mid-afternoon the market collapsed &mdash; with the index swinging from a 14.2-point gain to close 28.2 points down at 2,218.8. 
 The index is at its lowest since July. 
 It has lost 58.7 points in two days and 93.3 points since the Chancellor, Nigel Lawson, hoisted interest rates to 15 per cent on Thursday. 
 With sterling again weak against the dollar and mark, fears continue to grip the market that the Chancellor will be forced to move base rates to 16 per cent. 
 Comments by Alan Greenspan, Federal Reserve Board chairman, were another unsettling influence. 
 But while sterling remains weak exporters should prosper &mdash; although the market would not acknowledge such a fact yesterday. 
 Not all securities houses agree with BZW. 
 For example, Citicorp Scrimgeour Vickers is still looking for the index to end the year between 2,300 and 2,400. 
 Insurance shares produced some excitement. 
 Royal Insurance Holdings continued to ignore the drip of the John Spalvin share sales, gaining at one time 20p. 
 The shares closed up 9p at 469p. 
 A Continental bid was rumoured. 
 Sun Life Assurance lost much of an early gain but managed to close 10p higher at 1,123p. 
 Union Assurance de Paris, which has 19.2 per cent, is said to be talking to Sun's other big shareholder, the South African controlled Trans-Atlantic Holdings. 
 If UAP can buy the Trans-Atlantic stake, it would be obliged to bid for the rest of the capital. 
 Trans-Atlantic, which has experienced a stormy relationship with the Sun board, would demand a fancy price. 
 Saatchi &amp; Saatchi lost some of its exuberance, falling 17.5p to 332p. 
 Recent activity is explained by a 1 per cent shareholding, built by Fininvest, a Milan-based media group run by Silvo Berlusconi. 
 Guinness, at one time 22p higher on talk that LVMH was buying, closed 6.5p to the good at 608.5p. 
 Scottish &amp; Newcastle Breweries lost an early gain to close 5p lower at 367p. 
 Kwik-Fit, the tyres and exhausts gorup, was another to lose an early gain, closing 3p down at 140p. 
 Another round of talks with 10 per cent shareholder Continental have been futile. 
 Continental is expected to try and increase its stake &mdash; or bid. 
 Jaguar retreated 32p to 653p with stories flowing that Ford had given up its pursuit and planned to buy 50 per cent of the Swedish Saab group. 
 Ferranti fell 4.5p to 55p on the British Aerospace/Thomson-CSF interest. 
 James Neill closed at 269p on the agreed bid. 
 The shares were suspended on Monday at 202p. 
 Guinness Mahon, the merchant bank, rose 1.5p to 147p. 
 The second slice of the The Bank of Yokohama's &bquo;excess&equo; stake has been placed. 
 The Japanese bank cut its shareholding to 61 per cent. 
 Ford Sellar Morris, the property group, slipped 1p to 140p. 
 It has sold another &pound;28m of assets and has now pulled in &pound;70m from disposals since it took over the Brookmount property group in August. 
 The inflow will reduce gearing. 
 A hesitant rally in share prices was undermined by another poor performance by sterling and a bearish market outlook from brokers BZW. 
 A 17.2 gain in the FT-SE 100 index turned into a 28.4 fall to 2,218.8 by the close. 
 The FT 30 eased 26.2 points to 1,796.7. 
 Gilts lost around &pound;3/4 Goal Petroleum was among the oils to improve, up 1p to 85p. 
 Nomura says the group is &bquo;poised for a rapid recovery&equo;. 
 Analysts Alan Marshall and Christine Baker are impressed by the 20-well drilling programme for next year. 
 The shares are selling on a 25 per cent discount to assets and &bquo;there is virtually no downside risk but at least 25 per cent upside potential&equo;. 
 ADT, the security systems and car auctions group, has spent &pound;74m building a 4.2 per cent stake in BAA, the old British Airports Authority, up 2p at 337p. 
 It has also returned to auctioneer Christies International, lifting its stake back to 5.7 per cent. 
 Christies fell 7p to 310p. 
 Canada's Laidlaw Transportation has a near-30 per cent ADT holding. 
 Company News 
 Business and City Page 29 
 Patricof takes control at Neill with 78m pound bid 
 By CLARE DOBIE, Deputy City Editor 
 JAMES Neill, the 100-year-old Sheffield engineering company, lost its independence yesterday in just two hours after MMG Patricof, the fund manager, launched a cash bid valuing the company at &pound;78m. 
 A buy-in fund managed by Patricof, a 12-year-old firm based in Chicago, London and Paris, announced the bid, after securing the support of Neill's directors, at 10.00 am. 
 By noon Patricof had acquired control of more than 50 per cent of the company. 
 James Neill shares, which were suspended at 202p on Monday, closed at 269p against Patricof's 280p offer. 
 The Patricof team met Hugh Neill, the chairman, in August and has been planning the bid since then. 
 It decided to launch the bid sooner than planned after Neill announced a sharp drop in interim profits from &pound;2.71m to just &pound;28,000 before tax last month. 
 Mr Neill, whose grandfather founded the company, said: &bquo;I am sorry that in the future I will not have any shares in the company that bears my surname.&equo; 
 But he was more interested in seeing the Neill name being carried forward. 
 Patricof plans to operate Neill as an independent company. 
 Ronald Cohen, Patricof's chairman, said: &bquo;Our strategy is expansion based. 
 It is not shrinking the business.&equo; 
 Mr Cohen will become chairman of Neill and two Patricof appointees will join the board as executive directors. 
 They are Ian Fisher, formerly of Bain &amp; Co, management consultants, and Paul Bristow, formerly finance director of London International. 
 Mr Cohen said these men will &bquo;support&equo; the existing management. 
 But it is not clear whether Peter Bullock, the chief executive of Neill, will be staying. 
 Patricof, which manages funds for a number of UK institutions including Eagle Star and Standard Life, hopes to float the company on the stock market in five years. 
 Mr Cohen suggested the company might then be worth &pound;500m. 
 Patricof plans to invest further sums in Neill allowing it to make acquisitions on the Continent. 
 Mr Fisher said Neill had perhaps taken too many initiatives at once in the past year. 
 Mr Cohen said there was &bquo;great scope for building up a British-based group hand tools business over the next few years.&equo; 
 Grampian hives off its sales team 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 GRAMPIAN Television, the Independent Television contractor in the North of Scotland, is to have its advertising airtime sold by Television Media Marketing, the sales company set up by Welsh franchise holder HTV Group. 
 The deal was won by TVMM against strong competition from Scottish Televison, which used to be part of the same organisation as Grampian. 
 It is part of a growing trend for television contractors to hive off their advertising sales. 
 Most of Grampian's sales staff will be taken on by TVMM, and the group expects to make savings through increased usage of resources such as research, computers and office space. 
 All the television company's sales teams are based in London, where 90 per cent of the advertising comes from. 
 Earlier this year Central and Anglia teamed up in a jointly owned group, Television Sales &amp; Marketing Services, which has now won contracts to sell time for Border TV and the cable channel Discovery. 
 The Independent Broadcasting Authority has said that groups can team up as long as they have no more than 25 per cent of the total independent television advertising market. 
 TVMM will have just under 8 per cent and Charles Romaine, the sales director of HTV, said TVMM would be willing to take on any other groups to bring that total closer to 25 per cent. 
 Top of the list would be Television South-West, the West Country contractor, although Mr Romaine said that discussions had yet to be opened. 
 Worries have been expressed within the industry about the trend towards amalgamating sales teams. 
 The advertising market is tough at the moment, total sales fell in real terms in both August and September and no growth is expected in the run up to Christmas, and some contractors believe that combining sales staff could cost them dearly in the battle for market share. 
 Slump in building hits Walter Lawrence 
 By GAIL COUNSELL, Property Correspondent 
 WALTER Lawrence yesterday became the latest housebuilder to release sharply lower profit figures. 
 In the six months ended 30 June pre-tax profits fell from &pound;7m to just &pound;5.1m, and earnings per share dropped 36 per cent to 6p. 
 The shares lost 25p to 104p on the results. 
 The interim dividend is held at 2p. 
 Lower volumes were primarily to blame. 
 Sales &mdash; mostly of properties in the North-west of England, so far one of the more resilient areas in the slump - fell by more than a third, from 502 homes to 316. 
 Property price inflation lifted turnover and operating profits, but costs also increased steeply, with interest charges leaping from &pound;1.236m to &pound;3.94m, reducing the pre-tax result. 
 Brian Pritchard, chairman, insisted that all was not gloom and doom, pointing to the success of West Venture Development, the group's Southern Californian subsidiary, which this year is expected to double its output to about 500 homes. 
 Around 242 homes were sold by the company in the first half of this year. 
 West Venture was acquired in March 1988 but only began to make significant sales this year. 
 Mr Pritchard, said results had so far been good, and it was well placed to achieve excellent full year figures. 
 He hoped it would help shelter the group against the UK downturn in housebuilding. 
 Setback for Britannia Security 
 By PAUL DURMAN, City Reporter 
 A HEFTY &pound;4.85m interest charge helped cut full year pre-tax profits at Britannia Security by 4 per cent to &pound;9.6m. 
 Yesterday's poor figures to 30 June were expected after the fire alarm and data storage group warned two weeks ago that it was unlikely to beat last year's &pound;10m. 
 As Britannia's shares dropped 8p to 125p, one analyst placed a break-up value of 180p a share on the company. 
 Besides the interest charge, up from &pound;1.6m, Britannia also suffered from delays in introducing reliable products at Actron, the electronic tagging company, reorganisation costs at Britannia Fire and underperformance at Sentrymatic Britannia. 
 In the US, Leahy Business Archives suffered a loss in revenue when major customers decided to destroy obsolete records. 
 Britannia is expected to sell Leahy. 
 The UK data management business, which contributed &pound;751,000 to pre-tax profits, was sold in June. 
 This &pound;14.38m disposal produced a &pound;4.8m extraordinary profit. 
 A &pound;1m loss on the sale of a quoted investment left an extraordinary credit of &pound;3.79m. 
 Anthony Record, Britannia's chairman, said Actron had overcome its problems and was performing well. 
 The Swiss-based firm is regarded as having have high potential, since there is only one other manufacturer of anti-shoplifting electronic tagging equipment. 
 Mr Record said Britannia had net debts of &pound;40m and gearing of 110 per cent. 
 The rise in interest rates was particularly damaging because of the money borrowed to buy Mather &amp; Platt Alarms last October. 
 Laurentian Holding to get new chief executive 
 By PAUL DURMAN, City Reporter 
 PAUL SEYMOUR, formerly Michael Hepher's right-hand man at Abbey Life, is leaving to be chief executive of Laurentian Holding Company, the financial services group headed by Lord Marsh, former Labour minister and British Railways Board chairman. 
 Since the formation of Lloyds Abbey Life at the beginning of the year, Mr Seymour has been the company's deputy chairman as well as group director Europe for Abbey Life. 
 Until Lloyds Abbey Life has found a replacement for Mr Seymour, Stephen Maran, finance director, will have responsibility for Abbey Life (Ireland) and Gary Jones, sales and marketing director, will look after continental Europe, which includes the German subsidiary. 
 London &amp; Manchester, the life insurance group, yesterday announced a 15 per cent increase in its interim dividend to 3.795p and warned that its profits would be hit by reduced turnover margins on its mortgage lending and estate agency business. 
 NMW posts return to profitability 
 By NEIL THAPAR 
 NMW Computers, the computer bureau which specialises in settlement systems for the City, has returned to the black with pre-tax profits of &pound;48,000 in the half year to 30 June, writes Neil Thapar. 
 This compared with a &pound;428,000 loss in the corresponding period last year. 
 The company slipped into the red after the stock market crash of October 1987 led to sharply lower share trading. 
 The crash also happened just as NMW was expanding into other markets. 
 As a result it slipped into a loss of &pound;1.33m in 1988 against a &pound;1.71m taxable profit in 1987. 
 Since then NMW has carried out a heavy rationalisation programme and the return to profits has come despite a fall in turnover from &pound;5.92m to &pound;4.66m. 
 NMW, however, is cautious about the second half. 
 &bquo;It should be borne in mind that seasonal variations in stock market activity ususally result in lower turnover in the second half. 
 Therefore, further progress is required to maintain profits and return the company to its previous levels of profitability,&equo; it said yesterday. 
 BM shares rise as profits climb 78 percent 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 ROGER Shute, whose takeover of the helm of Ross Consumer Electronics last Friday quadrupled that company's share price, excited the market again yesterday by reporting sharply higher profits for BM Group, the industrial holding group where he is chairman and chief executive. 
 Pre-tax profits rose 78 per cent to &pound;15.8m in the year to 30 June and pushed BM shares up 15p to 508p. 
 Turnover rose 62 per cent from &pound;120m to &pound;193m, with sales of construction equipment accounting for more than half at &pound;106m. 
 The &pound;14.3m acquisition of Austoft Holdings last April enlarged the distribution network in Australasia and the US. 
 Overseas earnings accounted for 9 per cent of the total last year and could reach 30 per cent this year. 
 SEP, the French company acquired last October, will form the basis of expansion into Spain and Portugal. 
 There will be no more European purchases this year. 
 Millwall oversubscribed 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 THE OFFER for sale of five million shares at 20p each in Millwall Holdings, which owns London's Millwall Football Club, has been one-third oversubscribed. 
 The company has received applications for 6.615 million shares. 
 &bquo;The response has been fantastic particularly from Millwall supporters, many of whom brought their applications into The Den (home of the football club),&equo; said the chairman, Reg Burr. 
 More than 2,750 people applied for shares, the majority being Millwall supporters. 
 Mr Burr said many had applied for between 500 and 1,000 shares. 
 Applications for 15,000 shares or fewer will be granted in full. 
 Bids for more will be scaled down to 17,000 shares. 
 The company has placed another 20 million shares with institutions. 
 Dealings begin on Monday. 
 Alexandra lifts profits by 19 percent 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 ALEXANDRA Workwear, the maker and supplier of boiler suits and nursing uniforms, increased pre-tax profits by 19 per cent to &pound;3.7m in the 28 weeks to 12 August. 
 John Prior, chairman, said that profits and sales &mdash; up &pound;4.7m to &pound;31m &mdash; increased despite economic problems. 
 Earnings per share were 7.31p, up from 6.11p, and the interim dividend was 1.6p against 1.33p last time. 
 The shares rose 1p to 205p on the results before closing 2p lower in a falling market. 
 OutlooK: Fear of technical bear trap grows 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 As traders fall over themselves to dump the pound, the wise grow wary that a bear trap may await them further down the line. 
 Yesterday afternoon the New York markets opened for the first time since Friday night and saw that sterling had weakened about 9 pfennigs since then. 
 The immediate reaction of the American markets was to intensify European selling pressure &mdash; briefly pushing the pound through the critical chart point of DM2.95 despite fairly determined intervention from the Bank of England. 
 A technical bear trap may indeed lie ahead, perhaps before the pound sinks to DM2.90. 
 If history is any guide, the Bank of England could force overnight money rates up into the 20 to 30 per cent range and ram home the message with aggressive buying of pounds. 
 That would make it extremely painful to have gone short of sterling in the past few days. 
 Yet, however great the pain, the effect of a technical tactic may fail to have a lasting impact in such a bear market. 
 Still, it would probably be futile to look for another increase in base rates immediately, if at all. 
 There is speculation that the Government is working to the rule that for every 4 per cent depreciation of the pound, there would be a 1 point rise in base rates to maintain the tightness of monetary policy. 
 On those grounds, a 4 per cent decline since the last base rate increase, last week, would mean trigger points of around DM2.90 and &dollar;1.54. 
 But does the Government dare risk another increase? 
 Quite apart from the political fallout, there is the nagging worry that the economy may already be on the brink of recession. 
 Certainly that is what yesterday's steep sell-off in the equity markets may suggest. 
 Unfortunately, another crutch for sterling was kicked away yesterday when a speech by Alan Greenspan, chairman of the United States Federal Reserve, reinforced the impression that US interest rates are unlikely to soften soon. 
 The dollar strengthened as a result and had the temporary effect of relieving pressure on sterling against the mark. 
 But that is not expected to last. 
 In the absence of a concrete policy towards the pound, the best that the Government can hope for is to ride out the crisis until the next set of trade figures, due on 24 October. 
 There are predictions that the deficit could narrow significantly, which would undoubtedly provide support for sterling. 
 But two weeks is a long time when the markets believe that the Government has no clear policy. 
 And there is little confidence that Nigel Lawson's speech tomorrow will alter the outlook fundamentally. 
 Outlook: Liffe climbs out of the pit 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 In announcing yesterday that its Automated Pit Trading system will start on 30 November, the London International Financial Futures Exchange inserted the final element in a cautious but promising strategy for intergrating electronic trading and open outcry, and setting the pace for exchange reform in London. 
 APT is the last building block in a set of systems &mdash; blessed with the contrived name LIFFEforce &mdash; which will allow exchange members and their clients fast and competitive access to the markets, enabling them to track and record their positions and settle them on the same day. 
 APT is impressive, not least because it comes nearer than any rival to retaining essential qualities of open outcry, a feat unmatched by American exchanges which profess the greatest attachment to traditional trading. 
 The advantages to Liffe are clear. 
 Clients will be able to trade electronically out of hours, initially between 4.30pm and 6pm, and probably from 7am next year. 
 This 11-hour day, longer than that of any other exchange, will give Liffe a crucial edge in the increasingly competitive European arena. 
 Launching APT at the end of November with the Euromark futures contract will reinforce the point. 
 Liffe is also likely to steal a march on Globex, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange's electronic trading system now the victim of the ancient rivalry with the Chicago Board of Trade. 
 So far, however, Liffe has taken the modest route of allowing access to APT through any authorised carrier, such as Telerate, with whom agreement was announced yesterday. 
 The open approach contrasts favourably with Chicago's exclusivity. 
 The question now is whether this openness, of which the common access protocol Tramp is a crucial component, will set the standard for cooperation between London's fragmented futures and options exchanges. 
 Outlook: Accounting for Europe 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 That the European Commission should toy with imposing a set of uniform accounting rules is viewed in London with abject horror. 
 There is fear that such rules will be over-bureaucratic, while demanding less financial disclosure than the UK requires. 
 Instead, the UK accountancy bodies would rather see the Commission adopt the guidelines of the International Accounting Standards Committee (IASC), which has been working progressively towards the international harmonisation of the rules by which companies report. 
 But there is a problem. 
 The Commission sees the IASC as a private club. 
 It is for this reason the UK accountancy bodies have put forward the idea of a European accounting standards body in the hope of persuading Brussels to toe the IASC line. 
 The argument is tricky. 
 Given a free hand, the Commission could put the development of international accounting standards back 15 years. 
 But having lobbied for state backing in the policing of financial reports in the UK, the accountancy bodies cannot argue the same should not apply in Europe. 
 The solution would appear simple. 
 The Commission should be encouraged to develop and police European accounting standards. 
 But it might do well to look very carefully at the IASC's work. 
 Sooner, rather than later, Europe will be forced to bring the standard of its financial reporting in line with the rest of the world, not least the US. 
 Vickers, the engineer and defence group, has confirmed the appointment of Sir Colin Chandler, 50, as managing director-elect. 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 Vickers, the engineer and defence group, has confirmed the appointment of Sir Colin Chandler, 50, as managing director-elect. 
 Sir Colin is the former head of export services at the Ministry of Defence, having been seconded in 1985 from British Aerospace  
 Pressure mounts as Bond shares slide to 10-year low 
 From TERESA POOLE 
 BOND CORPORATION shares slid to a 10-year low yesterday as pressure intensified on the beleaguered Australian group. 
 At one stage the company was valued at just A&dollar;97.3m (&pound;49.1m). 
 Yesterday was the deadline for Bond Corp's 58 per cent owned subsidiary, Bell Resources, to pay &dollar;24m to Corona Corporation, the Canadian gold group, to satisfy an option agreement under which Bell Resources was due to purchase a 7 per cent stake in Bond International Gold from Corona. 
 Bell Resources would not comment on whether the payment had been made or whether the BIG shares had been sold on to another party. 
 Meanwhile, the slide in Bond Corp shares prompted the Australian Stock Exchange to suspend short-selling in the shares. 
 This is required when a company's value falls below A&dollar;100m. 
 Although there was no specific new item of bad news yesterday, there is now a growing perception in the market that the Bond group is faced with insurmountable difficulties. 
 The most crucial is the possible suspension on 23 October of Bond Corp shares if the company fails to report preliminary full-year results, which are already 10 days overdue. 
 After touching 23 cents, Bond Corp shares closed at 25 cents, down 4 cents on the day and compared with A&dollar;1.78 at the beginning of the year. 
 Other Bond group companies also suffered. 
 Bell Group, 75 per cent owned by Bond Corp, lost 8 cents to 30 cents and Bell Resources lost 5 cents to 95 cents. 
 The exchange will decide today whether to restore short-selling in Bond Corp. 
 Bond Corp would not comment on the situation. 
 Michael Cross, executive director of Alan Bond's private company Dallhold Investments, which controls BIG, was in New York where BIG is quoted. 
 Under Corona's put option agreement, Bell Resources was due to pay &dollar;7.25 a share for the Corona stake, well below the present market price. 
 This means that Bell Resources could meet the option demand by selling the BIG shares in the market. 
 But any premature sale could thwart Dallhold's hopes of attracting an outside party to purchase both the 7 per cent stake and a big slice of Dallhold's 58 per cent BIG holding, releasing a profit for Bell Resources and a much-needed cash injection for Dallhold. 
 Bond is already facing a series of &bquo;crunch&equo; days over the next two weeks: 18 October: This is the deadline by which Bond Corp planned to issue the &bquo;Part A&equo; document for its bid for Bell Resources, the first stage of the proposed A&dollar;2.5bn Australian brewing joint venture with Lion Nathan, the New Zealand brewer. 
 Bond Corp has already said this deadline may be delayed if the regulatory authorities insist that full Bond Corp accounts are included in the document. 
 The brewing deal is central to Bond Corp's restructuring and is the key to shifting about A&dollar;3bn of debt off the balance sheet. 
 20 October: The Western Australian State Government Insurance Commission hopes to announce the successful tenderer for its 19.7 per cent stake in Bell Group. 
 If the SGIC sells this holding, Bond Corp faces paying out more than A&dollar;160m under an indemnity agreement entered into when it and the SGIC bought out Robert Holmes a Court's Bell Group stake last year. 
 The indemnity is likely to be subject to legal action between the parties. 
 23 October: Shares in Bond Corp and Bell Group are likely to be suspended if the companies have not published their preliminary profit and loss statements by this date. 
 31 October: This is the deadline for Bond Corp to produce the keenly awaited full audited accounts for the company. 
 Why US carmakers are looking for European partners: Larry Black explains an unexpected effect of US restrictions on imports of Japanese cars 
 By LARRY BLACK 
 BLOODY-MINDED rivalry between America's two biggest car makers explains at least some of their renewed interest in European producers like Jaguar and Saab, say Wall Street analysts. 
 But, ironically, the longer-term explanation lies in the restrictions Washington has maintained on Japanese car imports for almost a decade. 
 General Motors and Ford both expect to lose money on car manufacturing this quarter for the first time since the 1982 recession, largely as a result of overcapacity in the market. 
 In response to the import quotas, Japanese manufacturers have been rapidly expanding production in the US. 
 But the quotas limited imports by number of vehicles rather than sales, encouraging the Japanese to develop luxury cars that earn higher per-unit profits. 
 Following the success of Honda's upmarket Acura line, this autumn Toyota is introducing the Lexus and Nissan the Infiniti, both with expensive advertising campaigns. 
 Both cars will retail at roughly &dollar;40,000, challenging a market currently dominated by European luxury imports. 
 The Big Three US carmakers, who controlled more than 85 per cent of the luxury market 10 years ago, saw their share drop to below 50 per cent last year. 
 While their manoeuvring with Jaguar is in part defensive &mdash; ensuring that the other does not win control of the British car maker &mdash; both Ford and GM were &bquo;clearly anxious to improve their slumping image in this market&equo;, he said. 
 Jaguar, which dropped its prices in North America last year, now sells into the market the Lexus and the Infiniti are targeting. 
 Jaguar sold 21,000 cars in the US last year, well shy of the 82,000 sold by Mercedes-Benz and the 72,500 of its German rival BMW. 
 Saab similarly sells relatively few cars in the US, though its numbers have been rising dramatically. 
 But analysts say better distribution and marketing by either GM or Ford could exploit these valued brand names far more extensively. 
 Their own luxury marques, GM's Cadillac and Ford's Lincoln, appeal to an older and shrinking share of the domestic US market, notes analyst Gerry Paul, of New York's Sanford Bernstein brokerage. 
 &bquo;They need to add some panache to this line of products,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Many Americans who drive luxury European imports simply wouldn't be seen in a Cadillac or Lincoln.&equo; 
 Both GM and Ford have tried to introduce high-priced European models of their own without much success. 
 Ford imports the Merkur, a line of cars made by its West German subsidiary, while GM fabricates the body of its Cadillac Allante in Italy. 
 The purchase of an interest in either Jaguar or Saab would extend another trend by the two Detroit carmakers which has seen both buy a number of small motor engineering firms in Europe in recent years to acquire technology. 
 In Britain, GM has used Lotus to develop a new engine for its Corvette sports car. 
 Rover new 200 series gets off to 400m pounds start 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 ROVER today launches a new 200 series model, backed by a &pound;400m investment and vital to the company's attempt to maintain its resurgence as a profitable manufacturer of niche market cars. 
 The new five-door car, which is aimed at a middle sector of the market dominated by the VW Golf, Vauxhall Astra and Fiat Tipo, is one of Rover's most important launches this decade. 
 The &pound;400m investment in the new Longbridge-built car represents one of the biggest single spending programmes in Rover's history, involving new production lines, paint and body shops and engines. 
 Rover has invested &pound;200m on just the development of the all-aluminium K-series engine, which will power three of the four versions of the new 200. 
 The car also represents the second full-scale collaboration between Rover and its Japanese partner Honda, which has shared design and development costs. 
 Honda's version of the 200 &mdash; to be known as the Concerto &mdash; will be built under contract at Longbridge in Birmingham by Rover at an initial rate of 40,000 a year. 
 Honda will also assemble Rover-badged 200s in Japan. 
 Aimed at young families, small business users and aspiring professionals, the car is the first new model to emerge from Rover since the 800 series in 1986. 
 The Rover 200, priced between &pound;8,775 and &pound;10,940, will make its public debut at next week's Motorfair in London. 
 The launch comes at a time when Rover's share of the record UK car market is slipping. 
 The Rover chairman, Sir Graham Day, argues, however, that the model mix being put through its Longbridge and Cowley plants is increasing profits. 
 The Rover 200 will be joined in the showrooms next month by the first new Land Rover model for 20 years, the Discovery, aimed at the sector of the four-wheel drive market dominated by Japanese manufacturers. 
 Earlier this week Rover also announced it is to introduce a new sports coupe model in 1992 &mdash; the first sports car to be built by the company since production of the TR7 ended in 1981. 
 The new car will be a coupe version of the Rover 800 executive car and will be styled on the CCV concept car which Rover designed three years ago. 
 Sales will initially be limited to the US, although Rover may launch the car in other markets, including the UK. 
 Lloyd's members leave in droves 
 By JOHN MOORE, Assistant City Editor 
 RESIGNATIONS of underwriting members from the Lloyd's insurance market could top 2,000 by the end of this year, a new record in the number of departures from the market. 
 Currently, resignations of the underwriting members, the wealthy individuals who back the market with their private wealth which allows it to function, are running at 1,900. 
 That compares with total departures last year of 1,750. 
 Moreover, the number of new members seeking to join could be significantly lower than last year. 
 So far 500 individuals are seeking to become members, compared with the 970 who joined last year, and the 2,572 who joined in 1987. 
 If a net 1,400-1,500 underwriting members leave the market, Lloyd's total membership will be reduced from its record high point of 33,532 at the beginning of last year to just over 30,000. 
 During last year 1,750 members resigned compared with 489 a year earlier. 
 Last year's 970 new entrants were the smallest number of new members to come forward since 1980. 
 Lloyd's officials have stressed that the departures are taking place among members who do not have large investment commitments at Lloyd's. 
 In September, when Lloyd's announced record profits of &pound;650m for its market's last completed trading period, Murray Lawrence, Lloyd's chairman, said that the financial capacity to accept insurance business next year would be the same as this year's &pound;11bn. 
 He admitted that this financial capacity would be provided by fewer underwriting members. 
 Many professionals within the Lloyd's market welcome the current crop of departures as there is an excess of financial capacity within the market at a time when business is not growing at the same rate as the available capacity. 
 Lloyd's has been under-utilising its financial resources for some time. 
 Lloyd's argues that many members who are leaving are those with limited resources who joined the market during a period of rapid expansion in the 1970s. 
 Sky losses bring warning of News Corp downturn 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 NEWS CORPORATION is set for a fall in profits this year, mainly because of the haemorrhage of cash caused by losses on Sky Television, its satellite TV station. 
 Rupert Murdoch told the annual meeting in Adelaide: &bquo;This may well be the first year in some years when our earnings do not show their customary increase.&equo; 
 The effect of the Sky losses will look even more dramatic after a change in accounting policy which takes them directly out of the profit and loss account. 
 After Sky losses of up to A&dollar;250m (&pound;126.3m), analysts are forecasting net profits for the year to June 1990 of about A&dollar;370m, which compares with a reported A&dollar;464m for 1989, excluding foreign exchange dealings. 
 The profit downturn will also reflect the world economic outlook. 
 &bquo;We are entering, at the very least, softer economic conditions in Australia and Britain,&equo; Mr Murdoch said. 
 &bquo;We see it in our advertising revenue&hellip; 
 So far this year our revenues are ahead and still healthy, but they are not what we expected. 
 Clearly some deterioration has set in.&equo; 
 He said that Sky &bquo;is our largest risk undertaking, perhaps ever. 
 Certainly it is this year. 
 We have taken various risks looking back over the years, like Wapping. 
 &bquo;But Sky is a major risk which has grown largely because of the activities of the competition, which have forced up the price of the product infinitely higher than we expected or was necessary. 
 But that's life.&equo; 
 Sky's main rival, British Satellite Broadcasting, is due to launch next spring. 
 There are also problems with 20th Century Fox, the US film group News Corp owns. 
 &bquo;Quite frankly, we are having a bad year,&equo; Mr Murdoch said. 
 &bquo;We have not made enough films in the last 12 months. 
 We had to fix some management problems.&equo; 
 An improvement is not expected until next summer. 
 The newspaper war in Melbourne, where three Sunday titles were launched in August, also affected profits. 
 Mr Murdoch also told the meeting that plans for Media Partners International, the investment vehicle, had been &bquo;put on hold&equo;. 
 There was some good news from the US television station Fox Broadcasting, where advertising revenue is up by 150 per cent, and from sales of Sky receiving dishes. 
 These had risen by 70,000 in the month from mid-August, and Mr Murdoch said the group was likely to reach the target of one million homes by 1 February 1990. 
 News Corporation shares shed 55 cents to close at A&dollar;15.9, while in London the shares of the News International subsidiary fell 21p to 352p. 
 Building societies ripe for takeover: Speculation is rife in the building society industry. 
 Patrick Hosking reports 
 By PATRICK HOSKING 
 WHISPERS of a takeover of a British building society have been circulating in the City since the spring when the Abbey National won the overwhelming backing of its savers and borrowers to convert itself into a bank. 
 So far not one deal has materialised. 
 But the whispers in recent weeks have got louder. 
 Numerous societies including the Cheltenham &amp; Gloucester, National &amp; Provincial, Norwich &amp; Peterborough and Birmingham Midshires have been in the frame as possible targets. 
 The list of suggested buyers is almost limitless -ranging from Royal Trust of Canada to National Australia Bank and from Credit Lyonnais to the Pru. 
 Ben Thompson-McCausland, managing director of National &amp; Provincial, believes a lot of the speculation about bid approaches is overdone. 
 &bquo;We're not getting approaches. 
 We're really not. 
 And we're not aware of anyone else getting them. 
 There are merchant bankers who find it convenient to stir up apprehension with a view to drumming up business for themselves.&equo; 
 One highly placed source says &bquo;deliberate disinformation&equo; is being put about, creating &bquo;a South Sea Bubble&equo; of speculation. 
 With the housing and mortgage market depressed and competition in retail banking intensifying, the appeal of buying a building society is if anything diminishing. 
 Equally, however, there are respected industry commentators who are certain that the first agreed takeover of a building society is just around the corner. 
 According to John Wriglesworth, analyst with UBS-Phillips &amp; Drew: &bquo;Just as 1989 was the year of the Abbey National flotation, 1990 will be the year of the building society takeover. 
 &bquo;An agreed takeover is the most sensible option for many of the medium-sized societies,&equo; by which he means those ranked 4th to 35th. 
 &bquo;They're too big to be niche players and too small to be low-cost producers.&equo; 
 Geoff Cooper, director of the Spicers Consulting Group, which is advising several societies on how to construct defences to hostile takeover offers, says a bid within the next 18 months is extremely likely. 
 &bquo;We've been involved with a number of societies who have been approached by potential predators.&equo; 
 He predicts that bidders, including insurance companies and investment management groups, will form strategic alliances with societies, initially using the branch networks to sell their own financial services, and later agreeing full mergers. 
 &bquo;Building societies are being approached almost daily with offers of this kind,&equo; he claims. 
 John Franklin, director of corporate finance at the merchant bank Morgan Grenfell, whose clients include both societies and prospective bidders, is convinced a bid for a society is on the way: &bquo;The first merger will see the light of day early next year.&equo; 
 Any bid would probably be with the blessing of the society's management. 
 But some societies fear hostile bids &mdash; a subject on the agenda at the Building Societies Association council meeting tomorrow. 
 Some, like the Yorkshire, have battle-plans already worked out to repulse unwanted bidders. 
 The size and direction of the Abbey vote on conversion strongly suggests societies would succeed in meeting the more stringent voting criteria required for takeover. 
 Moreover, the saving and borrowing members of a society stand to make much bigger gains in the case of takeover than the &pound;150 or so of free shares offered in the Abbey flotation. 
 Farmers back in court 
 By PATRICK HOSKING 
 LOS ANGELES (Reuter) &mdash; Farmers Group of insurance companies, the California subsidiary of BAT Industries, yesterday said it has filed a motion in Los Angeles County Superior Court to stay a recently imposed state freeze on automobile insurance rates. 
 Farmers, the second largest car insurer in the state, had previously sought a 5.9 per cent increase to offset projected losses of about &dollar;100m on high-risk drivers. 
 But State insurance commissioner Roxani Gillespie imposed a six-month freeze on all car insurance rates on October 2. 
 Cities may block MBB bid 
 By PATRICK HOSKING 
 HAMBURG (AFP) &mdash; Two West German city governments with a stake in Messerschmitt-Bolkow-Blohm, the aviation company, have said they will not approve its merger with Daimler-Benz under the current plan. 
 The authorities in Hamburg and Bremen said on Monday that the merger plan does not take sufficient account of the interests of the north of the country, particularly in terms of employment. 
 The two cities indirectly hold more than 17 per cent and 10 per cent of MBB which could be enough to stop the merger, observers said. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By PATRICK HOSKING 
 Saatchi approach: Southeastern Asset Management, which owns 10.2 per cent of Saatchi &amp; Saatchi, said one or more parties had approached it about a possible restructuring of the advertising group. 
 It said it may discuss such transactions, which would not involve a change in control, with the management. 
 LIN bid: US-based McCaw Communications, which is 22 per cent owned by British Telecom, launched a revised &dollar;2.9bn bid for LIN Broadcasting, the cellular radio and TV stations group. 
 This page and View from City Road, page 29 Wills factory bought: A consortium including developer Skillion and Peter Earl's Tranwood Group, has bought the WD &amp; HO Wills tobacco factory at Bedminster, Bristol, which covers 10 acres in the city. 
 Savings rates raised: The Yorkshire, the first building society to increase mortgage rates after last week's base rate rise, announced 0.75-1.5 per cent hikes in its savings rates and a top rate of 12.75 per cent. 
 New Visa boss: Jacques Kosciusko, general manager of retail banking at Credit Lyonnais, is to head the Europe, Middle East and Africa division of Visa International, the credit card network, from early next year. 
 Bond plunge: Shares in Bond Corporation slid to a 10-year low at one point valuing the beleaguered Australian group at less than &pound;50m. 
 Page 27 News warning: Losses at Sky Television will produce a fall in profits at Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation this year. 
 Page 27 and View from City Road, page 29 Bank steps in: The Bank of England again stepped in to the currency markets to prop up sterling, taking its interventionist spending since the trade figures a fortnight ago to an estimated &dollar;3-&dollar;4bn. 
 This page and Outlook, page 27 Investor fears: Institutional investors fear share prices have further to fall than yesterday's 28.2 point drop in the FT-SE 100 index. 
 This page and Outlook, page 27 Ferranti action: Ferranti International is planning legal action against some intermediaries in the &bquo;phantom&equo; arms contracts which have brought it close to collapse. 
 Page 26 New Rover: Rover today launches a new 200 series model &mdash; a key product in its strategy to make niche market cars. 
 It is investing &pound;400m in the project. 
 Page 27 Millwall oversubscribed: The offer for sale of shares in Millwall Holdings, the football club, was taken up by 2,750 people, mainly supporters. 
 Page 29 Pathe sold: British Pathe News Library, the film newsreel archive, was acquired for &dollar;16m by the mini-conglomerate Parkfield Group. 
 Page 26 James Neill sold: MMG Patricof, the fund manager, successfully took over the Sheffield engineering company James Neill after launching a &pound;78m cash bid. 
 World Markets New York: Shares see-sawed in moderate trading. 
 By the close profit-takers had the upper hand and the Dow Jones Industrial average was down 6.08 points at 2,785.33. 
 Hong Kong: Strong institutional and overseas buying after a morning decline drove the Hang Seng index up 17.83 to 2,844.04. 
 Singapore: The Straits Times index inched up 0.73 of a point to 1,420.91 in moderate trading. 
 Sydney: Concern about the performance of News Corporation following a warning by Rupert Murdoch helped to pull the All Ordinaries index down 17.5 points to 1,755.8, the day's low. 
 Paris: Intense speculative interest in merchant bank Paribas was the feature of a session in which the CAC-40 index posted a record 1,961.74, up 19.2. 
 Zurich: Shares closed slightly weaker in moderate trade. 
 Milan: In position squaring ahead of today's expiry of options the MIB slipped three points to 1,166. 
 Madrid: Uncertainty ahead of Friday's inflation data brought a 0.79 fall in the index to 322.32. 
 Brussels: Renewed confidence on the first day of the new forward account enabled shares to close firmer in heavy trading. 
 Stockholm: Sharp gains in Volvo and Ericsson shares dominated a moderate session in which prices generally fell back from early advances. 
 Volvo has refused to comment on reports of merger talks with Renault. 
 Water perks intended to ensure maximum take-up 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Assistant Business Editor 
 SHARES in the water industry are to be made &bquo;as attractive as possible to as many people as possible&equo;, the Government's advisers on water privatisation said yesterday after announcing a series of perks for investors which go beyond anything seen in previous privatisations. 
 Gerry Grimstone, a director of Schroders, the Government's merchant bank for the water flotations, claimed that the response so far had been extremely encouraging, with interest spread broadly across the country and &bquo;no signs of an investor strike&equo; in any of the regions. 
 City analysts are convinced that the Government will price shares extremely favourably to ensure success, with the average dividend yield among the 10 authorities a little under 8 per cent. 
 Incentives were announced yesterday which analysts agreed ought to guarantee a very high level of retail demand for the shares. 
 Customers will be able to opt for discounts worth &pound;20 for every &pound;250 invested up to a maximum investment of &pound;3,750 or for bonus shares on the basis of one for every 10 bought. 
 The value of the discounts works out at about 8 per cent of the sum invested. 
 For British Telecom and British Gas, where the perks took the form of discounts on quarterly bills, they were worth only 6.9 per cent and 7.4 per cent respectively. 
 Labour condemned the incentives as &bquo;another effort to ensure that the sale is not a flop&equo;. 
 Anne Taylor, Labour's water spokeswoman, said: &bquo;No one will be very impressed with discounts on something they already own. 
 People want high quality service, and that's what money should be spent on &mdash; not on expensive public relations and giving shares away free.&equo; 
 The Goverment is spreading the incentive net wider than in previous privatisations. 
 Every member of a household down to the youngest child will be eligible for perks, whereas for British Telecom and British Gas they were limited to one set per metered outlet. 
 This may account for the relatively high level of interest being expressed in the issue. 
 With two months to go, more than 2.5 million people are said to have pre-registered, more than invested in either British Telecom or British Gas. 
 Bonus shares will also be available for non-customers, but on a less favourable basis of one for 20 up to a maximum investment of &pound;7,500. 
 Mr Grimstone stressed that the perks would only be available to those who registered their interest in advance, with the cut-off date likely to be some time in mid-November. 
 The Government's research showed that many of those who were interested in investing were still not aware of the importance of pre-registering. 
 Water authority prospectuses will carry a &bquo;health warning&equo; about the Opposition's stated intention of bringing the industry back into public ownership. 
 Bryan Gould, Labour's trade and industry spokesman, has said that the industry may be renationalised at a lower price than it is sold for. 
 More share price falls expected 
 By CLARE DOBIE in London and LARRY BLACK in New York 
 LARGE investors expect London share prices to fall still further, some by as much as 20 per cent, after yesterday's sharp drop on the stock market. 
 As the widely-based FT-SE 100 index dropped 28.2 points to close at 2,218.8, pension fund managers and other institutional investors spoke of their fears of further falls. 
 A spokesman for Phillips &amp; Drew Fund Management, one of the largest fund managers in the City, said recent movements looked like the start of a downturn. 
 &bquo;In a bear market you normally expect shares to drop 15 to 25 per cent over 18 months. 
 It would not surprise us to see something like this over the next few months.&equo; 
 Mike Payne, of Legal &amp; General, the insurance company, said the market was unsure whether the Chancellor, Nigel Lawson, was in control. 
 If Mr Lawson was, he might be happy to see the pound fall to ease the burden on companies. 
 But the danger was that the pound would fall further than planned, said Mr Payne. 
 If the Chancellor was not in control the pound could go into free fall, leading to much higher interest rates, Mr Payne went on. 
 &bquo;I've got a nasty feeling he may need to jack up interest rates further, but possibly not for very long.&equo; 
 The fall in London, most of which took place in the afternoon, was triggered by a combination of factors. 
 These included a pessimistic forecast from BZW, the stockbroking arm of Barclays Bank. 
 In the BZW forecast, Peter Thomson said the FT-SE index should be back to 2,100-2,200 by the end of this month and would at best hold its own next year but more likely fall to 1,800, where it started this year. 
 Mr Thomson also said the Government's aims of controlling inflation would put pressure on company profits and make a share prices surge in the winter/spring unlikely. 
 These views reinforce BZW's well-publicised caution on the market, which is not fully shared by other leading houses. 
 The fall was not helped by remarks made in Moscow by Alan Greenspan, chairman of the US Federal Reserve, who said it might be counterproductive to give great importance to short-term stabilisation of domestic financial or foreign exchange markets. 
 Though there was some selling yesterday, volume was not heavy. 
 Some large investors stood on the sidelines, happy to have moved money out of UK companies earlier in the year to overseas markets. 
 Most fund managers believed it was too early to say when they would consider buying London shares again. 
 Wall Street, however, experienced an unusually quiet day, with stock markets drifting slightly lower despite the strong dollar and firm credit markets. 
 Investment strategists said the decline was attributable to profit-taking after six days of climbing prices, which brought the Dow Jones Industrial average up by more than 100 points. 
 Prices were lower across the board, with nearly all blue-chip stocks losing ground. 
 &bquo;Eventually, traders want to cash in their chips,&equo; said Hildegard Zagorski, market analyst with Prudential-Bache Securities in New York. 
 &bquo;It isn't a real sell-off.&equo; 
 Airline stocks, which have been surging for months on a series of high-stakes takeovers, declined after one potential target, US Air, declared lower than expected earnings. 
 American Airlines, which last week received an unsolicited buyout offer from developer Donald Trump, fell several dollars as scepticism about the bid widened. 
 Delta Airlines, the only other major US carrier not in play, also fell about a dollar. 
 The three major US car makers saw their stock prices decline after analysts predicted quarterly losses on their North American businesses for the first time since the 1982 recession. 
 But European car makers fortunes were mixed. 
 Volvo's over-the-counter US shares jumped more than &dollar;5 on word of a merger with Renault, while Jaguar &mdash; the object of a run-up since Ford hinted at takeover plans two weeks ago &mdash; fell nearly a dollar on word that rival General Motors will take only a minority share in the British car maker. 
 Bank fails to halt sterling's slide 
 By PETER TORDAY 
 STERLING succumbed to heavy worldwide selling again yesterday despite sizeable intervention in the foreign exchange markets by the Bank of England to break the fall, writes Peter Torday. 
 In London, sterling closed 2 pfennigs down at DM2.9537 and was 1.9 cents lower at &dollar;1.5585. 
 The Bank stepped into the markets early yesterday to steady a bout of selling in the European markets. 
 It sold dollars at &dollar;1.5715 and German marks at DM2.96. 
 The Bank repeated its intervention just as the New York markets opened during the European lunchtime to signal that it did not want the American markets, closed since Friday night, to push the pound down further. 
 But the Bank was later forced to continue its intervention. 
 It sold dollars and European currency units for pounds in a determined fashion to counter heavy selling, which briefly pushed the pound down below DM2.95 for the first time since August 1987. 
 Market estimates for yesterday's intervention put the Bank's purchases of pounds as high as &dollar;500m, and there were indications that the authorities may have intervened to a similar extent the day before, when sterling fell almost 6 pfennigs. 
 That suggests the Bank has spent &dollar;3bn-&dollar;4bn of its foreign exchange and gold reserves, worth &dollar;42bn when the latest official figures were released last Tuesday, since the &pound;2bn current account deficit for August was disclosed on 26 September. 
 The Bank supported the pound the day the trade figures were released and its support grew through that week, culminating in heavy intervention on Thursday and Friday. 
 Last week started quietly, but on Tuesday fresh pressure developed as speculation mounted that the West German Bundesbank was set to raise its key interest rates. 
 Last Wednesday the Bank was believed to have spent as much as &dollar;1bn. 
 The 1-point rise in base rates last Thursday bought 1&frac12; days of calm to the currency markets. 
 EC mergers plan bogged down again 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Luxembourg 
 EUROPEAN Community trade ministers meeting in Luxembourg last night seemed set to fail in an attempt to make any new progress towards a common mergers policy, giving final right of veto on large-scale mergers to Brussels. 
 The failure of yesterday's meeting to achieve even a preliminary compromise makes the prospect of a final agreement before the end of this year highly unlikely. 
 The 15-year-old proposal aims to give the European Commission exclusive jurisdiction over the largest industrial mergers involving companies from more than one EC state. 
 However, governments have for a long time been divided over how large a merger must be before it passes out of national hands to Brussels. 
 Britain, France and West Germany have argued for a joint world turnover threshold of &pound;3.5bn, while the majority want it set lower at &pound;1.4bn. 
 Last night ministers continued to look at a compromise prepared by the EC commissioner Sir Leon Brittan, incorporating a Dutch-led formula where the higher level would be the norm but governments would have the option of asking Brussels to intervene for mergers breaking &pound;1.4bn. 
 Ferranti plans to sue contract intermediaries 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Assistant Business Editor 
 FERRANTI International is planning legal action against a series of obscure European registered companies which acted as intermediaries in the &bquo;phantom&equo; arms contracts that have brought the UK defence contractor to the brink of collapse. 
 Lawyers acting for Ferranti concede that there is no chance of getting back the full &pound;215m which the company is being forced to write off as a result of the International Signal and Control fraud. 
 However, they believe there could be some hope of recovering lines of credit which were extended by International Signal and Control to a number of European intermediaries. 
 It emerged yesterday that, from the moment Ferranti acquired International Signal and Control two years ago, executives were put on alert about the suspect contracts because, unusually, they involved the granting of credit on open account to sub-contractors and intermediaries. 
 Ferranti's senior management was extremely unhappy about the arrangements, but at that stage took the view that they amounted merely to a credit risk rather than a fraud. 
 Ferranti carried on with the contracts because it did not want to give the purported customers an excuse not to pay back the credit. 
 It has now emerged that the fraud was carried out by using the credit to pay back money to International Signal and Control as if it was the customer making stage payments on the contract. 
 In a separate development, British Aerospace and Thomson CSF of France confirmed they were considering making a joint offer for Ferranti. 
 If successful, it would be their intention to maintain Ferranti's position as a leading UK defence contractor and to share operational responsibility for Ferranti's businesses with overall management vested in British Aerospace. 
 The two companies said the Ministry of Defence had been supportive of their approach and they did not anticipate any regulatory problems. 
 However, neither would contemplate any direct involvement without &bquo;an appropriate period of due diligence&equo;. 
 British Aerospace said its advisers would have to take a detailed look at Ferranti's books to satisfy themselves that there were no further problems before the company could proceed. 
 Ferranti will be sending British Aerospace and other interested parties prepared to sign a confidentiality clause a detailed information pack on the company's present state of affairs. 
 Two private shareholders called on Sir Derek Alun-Jones, Ferranti's chairman, to resign at the company's reconvened annual meeting yesterday. 
 However, Sir John Hoskyns, a non-executive director, defended Sir Derek. 
 The board had considered the chairman's position seriously, he said, and decided &bquo;it would have been a very foolish thing to ask him to step down&equo;. 
 There had been no suggestion from the company's bankers or major institutional shareholders to date that he should do so. 
 The composition of the board would be reconsidered when the situation had been sorted out. 
 McCaw offers 2.9bn dollars for LIN 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 MCCAW Communications, the US cellular radio company in which British Telecom has a 20 per cent stake, has launched a revised &dollar;2.9bn bid for LIN Broadcasting. 
 McCaw is offering &dollar;125 per share for 22 million shares. 
 The bid price is equivalent to &dollar;293 &bquo;per pop&equo; &mdash; the way in which cellular radio licences are valued in the US, based on the population of a catchment area. 
 This makes it the highest price offered so far in the rush for licences. 
 A previous bid of &dollar;110m per share was due to expire on Friday, and faced strong opposition in the form of a proposed merger between the cellular radio operations of LIN and BellSouth. 
 The &dollar;2.9bn renewed bid by McCaw would leave 26 million shares in LIN outstanding. 
 It has been designed to lure shareholders by allowing them to keep a stake in LIN, and by offering a private fair market guarantee. 
 Under the guarantee, McCaw will buy the remaining LIN shares in five years at an agreed private market price or will put the entire LIN company up for sale. 
 The renewed bid for LIN further complicates the battle for supremacy in the US cellular radio market and in particular for the prized New York licence, currently owned by LIN and Metromedia. 
 McCaw last week agreed to pay &dollar;1.9bn for Metromedia's half of the licence, but that deal in turn hinged on whether LIN took up its right of first refusal on Metromedia's stake. 
 If the new McCaw/LIN deal succeeds it would bring McCaw's stake in LIN Broadcasting to 50.3 per cent. 
 The Metromedia interests in New York would subsequently be sold to LIN at no profit to McCaw, bringing an entire New York licence under one roof. 
 Nynex of the US holds the second New York cellular radio licence. 
 McCaw believes it needs LIN, which also has substantial cellular radio interests in Los Angeles, Dallas, Houston and Philadelphia, to build a national cellular radio service in the fragmented US market. 
 BT, which bought its stake in McCaw in June for &dollar;1.3bn, said that it would not have to invest further to support the current McCaw bids. 
 Barry Romeril, BT's finance director, said: &bquo;This deal will make McCaw manifestly pre-eminent in the US cellular business, the only one able to offer a full national service. 
 Once LIN has gone there is not much left on the open market. 
 BT would be the only foreign company to get a significant stake in this market.&equo; 
 Pathe library sold for 16m dollars 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 BRITISH Pathe News Library, the film newsreel archive which chronicled world events of the last 100 years, has been acquired for &dollar;16m by Parkfield Group, the mini conglomerate. 
 Pathe, epitomised by its crowing cockerel and mildly patronising commentaries, stopped producing newsreels in 1970 after 75 years' coverage of world events because of the decline of the film industry and a change in cinema audience tastes. 
 But the library occupies an important position in British cinema history and includes unrivalled coverage of events, spanning Queen Victoria's diamond jubilee, the Wright brothers' flight, the world wars and the onset of the space age. 
 Its footage is mainly licensed world-wide to film makers for inclusion in features and documentaries. 
 Chris Davies, a Parkfield director, said the library makes a profit of &bquo;a few hundred thousand pounds annually&equo; but its potential is &bquo;enormous&equo;. 
 Pathe's library is being sold by Weintraub Entertainments, a Los Angeles and London film and concert business. 
 All the fun of the fair: Jim White takes a fresher look at the company a student might be keeping 
 By JIM WHITE 
 A COUPLE of years ago, a rumour swept Oxford that the National Front was to have a stall at the Freshers' Fair. 
 A posse of huge anti-fascists from Ruskin, the workers' college, disguised themselves as undergraduates and infiltrated the Examination Schools building where the event is traditionally held. 
 Once inside, however, they found that the only remotely fascistic stand was one occupied by a pimply youth from the Wagner Society. 
 He spent an uncomfortable day surrounded by burly miners threatening to smash his Dansette with baseball bats every time he put on another part from the &bquo;Ring Cycle&equo;. 
 At this year's fair, Wagner's fans had wisely absented themselves. 
 But the CV Society was there. 
 Under the banner &bquo;The Unhackable Hierarchy &mdash; Bullshit is our Business&equo;, they were selling presidencies at &pound;4 each. 
 &bquo;Employers look not simply for participation in social societies, but for those who attain officer status&equo; read a framed commendation on their stand, typed on the headed notepaper of a firm of City solicitors. 
 That it was signed by a partner called Hugh Jarse would lead the wary to conclude that the CV Society was as adept at pinching stationery as at extracting money out of fun-loving freshers: after only an hour it had sold four presidencies, six other posts and had about 40 names on a list headed &bquo;I'm interested in your society but don't want to cough up any money at the moment&equo;. 
 Like the desert after a flash flood, Freshers' Fair is decorated by societies which bloom for just a day. 
 Take the Singles' Society, which seemed to exist solely so that its smartly dressed president could chat up pretty girls; or the Alice Society: &bquo;You didn't sign up for that did you,&equo; said one newcomer to his friend as they left. 
 &bquo;You're so bloody gullible.&equo; 
 Others have been in existence for years, yet seem to hold out little hope of attracting new recruits. 
 A stall hung with a poster picturing smiling folk-dancers and the legend &bquo;Do you think Hungary is likethat? 
 No!&equo; was unmanned. 
 Next door, two elderly ladies from the Esperanto Society smiled more in hope than expectation at every preterpasanto &mdash; or passer-by, as you or I might say. 
 London's South Bank Poly, unlike its longer-established cousin, had opened its doors to outside organisations. 
 Freshers were obliged to run a gauntlet of computer software, insurance and Student Railcard salesmen and a host of banks seeking their overdrafts, before reaching the union societies' billeted in the sports hall. 
 Here were sporting clubs and the Conservative Association run by two youths in heavy metal tour T-shirts. 
 There was also, inexplicably, a mountain of Pot Noodle cartons in one corner, just next to a leaflet on the wall reading &bquo;Anarchist Society &mdash; no need to join'. 
 At Oxford, not only could you join the anarchists, you could debate the class struggle with a shambolic figure in a wispy beard and a &bquo;No Entry&equo; sticker pasted to his flies. 
 He was buried under subversive literature between the Gardening Society (whose president sat framed by snaps of himself communing with plants) and the Women's Group, unhappily eyeing the occupant of the Rocky Horror Society stand, who, dressed in regulation suspenders and holed stockings, was doing roaring business. 
 Dressing up was a constant theme: soldiers in the outdoor adventurists' room (which also housed the Scout and Guide Association), men in deer-stalkers behind the Sherlock Holmes counter and countless Arthurian knights, Gilbert and Sullivan pirates and American footballers. 
 Two men with cans of Guinness strapped to their baseball caps wore yellow T-shirts emblazoned with the logo of the Leprechaun Society. 
 On closer inspection this turned out to be the L'Chaim Society, a Jewish good-time gang which presumably also has a stout approach to Judaism. 
 At South Bank Poly the commercial pressures came from outsiders. 
 At Oxford they were provided by the students. 
 The Investment Society, for instance, offered members &bquo;trips to City institutions, talks from investment professionals and advice on making the most of your grant&equo;. 
 &bquo;Don't wait until your third year to learn about careers in the City&equo;, ran a flier pinned to the stall. 
 Hard by, the persistent salesmen from the Union Society (membership &pound;70), offered a green plastic folder crammed with professional-looking information sheets. 
 But the Union is not faring as well as it might think. 
 Its president had a bleeper attached to her belt. 
 Her South Bank Poly counterpart had a mobile phone. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Up the Shining Path: &bquo;The Vision of Elena Silves&equo; &mdash; Nicholas Shakespeare: Collins Harvill, 11.95 pounds 
 By ANTHONY QUINN 
 WHEN Saul Bellow wrote of America as the place where the &bquo;modern action&equo; is, he might as well have included the whole continent: Central and South America, with their chaotic flux of civil wars, bloody massacres, assassinations, coups and putsches, are about as modern as the action gets. 
 Small comfort for those languishing in the prisons or holed up in the hills, one suspects, but their toils have been translated into the stuff of great writing &mdash; Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Mario Vargas Llosa and Graham Greene have, in different ways, picked over the moral and political wreckage of Latin America, and you feel it needs writers of their calibre to make sense of it. 
 The influence of all three is perceptible in Nicholas Shakespeare's first novel, though it is not so much the magical flights of Marquez as Greene's Catholic mysticism which I found the most intriguing. 
 Tiny hints of The Power and The Glory and the later brilliance of The Honorary Consul flicker here and there, but the event pivotal to Shakespeare's novel also recalls - perhaps unconsciously &mdash; the miracle at the close of The End of the Affair. 
 It turns out that The Vision of Elena Silves operates on a more secular footing, but its meditation on the transcendence of human love over the coercions of church and state is a quietly compelling achievement. 
 The plot is a simple one, despite the author's shuffling of time sequences between 1965 and 1986. 
 Gabriel is a student revolutionary of Chinese extraction living in Belen, a town in the jungle of the Amazon Valley. 
 Having read Schiller, Conrad and Bakunin by the age of 12, he is now moved to join the Sendero Luminoso (Shining Path) terrorists, but finds his ideological ardour diverted when he meets Elena Silves, a bewitching girl of 17 and a devout Catholic. 
 They fall in love, but before they can consummate it Elena has a vision of the Virgin Mary, which throws the local authorities into a tailspin. 
 Having performed a healing miracle, she is packed off to a remote convent. 
 Gabriel becomes a Senderista and ends up in prison, from which he finally escapes to go in search of Elena. 
 This story is framed by the ramblings and reminiscences of three old men who hang out in the town square, acting as a comic chorus to the action and sketching in the historical background. 
 It is not one of the book's better strokes, since their discourse makes the opening stages drag a little. 
 Once Elena experiences her vision, however, Shakespeare hits his stride. 
 He neatly unfolds two opposing wings of a Catholic authority now required to pass judgement on the event. 
 On one side is the spineless Bishop Barrantes, representing the worst aspects of the Church's mugwumpery and corruption; on the other is Father Maby, confidant of Elena and friend to the poor and displaced in his jungle retreat; his work is less glamorous than the revolutionary's, but his wisdom and gentleness make him the unexpected hero of the novel. 
 Through him Gabriel learns the true nature of Elena's vision, which points to the sovereignty of love amid the warring clamour of Catholicism and Communism. 
 The book has the weight of research behind it, though this has been unobtrusively stitched into the narrative. 
 The shadowy figure of Abimael Guzman, subject of an essay Shakespeare wrote for Granta last year, surfaces here as Presidente Ezequiel, while the ritualistic savagery of Peru is detailed in some brief, shocking images. 
 Here, for example, is how Elena's ancestors dealt with an enemy: &bquo;They would eat his tongue for wisdom, his heart for courage, and for fertility make their women chew his genitals&equo; (not difficult to imagine who gets the worst of that deal). 
 Back in the present, enemies of the guerrillas' 'new democracy' have their feet and heads hacked off and crudely sewn back on &mdash; the wrong way round. 
 Such violent grotesquerie is seen as one more consequence of political madness. 
 The Vision of Elena Silves, despite its rather cautious prose style, is in the end a quite moving story of individuals swallowed up by dogma's greedy maw. 
 The &bquo;modern action&equo; of Peruvian politics exacts a heavy price, and Shakespeare has given us a very plausible sense of the people &mdash; lovers, priests, guerrillas, soldiers &mdash; who have to pay it. 
 Ambiguity that is intolerable 
 By PETER JENKINS 
 BLACKPOOL: Conservatives are meeting here with the pound sliding around their ears. 
 The markets have exposed the fatal flaw of Margaret Thatcher's government. 
 This is not the fallacy (although some allege it to be so) of Nigel Lawson's exchange rate policy, nor the fallacy (which others allege) of the money supply policy which Mrs Thatcher would prefer, but the fallacy of supposing government can be conducted successfully on the basis of ambiguous vacillation. 
 Ambiguity concerning exchange rate policy offers markets the opportunities for the kind of one-way bets speculators like best. 
 They believe they have such an opportunity at the moment and no one here dares say where the pound may stand against the Deutschmark when the Chancellor rises to speak tomorrow. 
 Look what has happened in the last few days. 
 On Thursday Mr Lawson, his hand forced by the Bundesbank, raised the minimum lending rate from 14 to 15 per cent. 
 Since then financial markets concluded they have three good reasons for betting on a devaluation of the pound against the DM. 
 First, that interest rates are as high as they can go politically, certainly while the party conference is in session. 
 Second, because the president of the Bundesbank, Karl Otto Pohl, has said publicly that the DM needs revaluing against the currencies of high-inflation countries, of which Britain is the leader. 
 Third, because there is reason to suspect that the Prime Minister herself might prefer a devaluation to further expensive and, probably, futile attempts to &bquo;buck the markets&equo; by penalising her heartland constituency of home owners. 
 On this last point it is not necessary to authenticate gossip about renewed disagreement between Mr Lawson and the Prime Minister's own personal economic adviser, Sir Alan Walters, or of new rifts between the Prime Minister herself and the Chancellor. 
 They are probably false. 
 In the run up to the Conservative Party conference it is hardly surprising if Mrs Thatcher swallowed her intellectual objections to intervention and backed the Chancellor's expensive efforts to defend the pound in the hope of avoiding or postponing a further increase in interest rates. 
 Mr Lawson is not solely to blame for the uncertainty and muddle. 
 Whether or not they were promoted to the level of policy disagreement, everyone knows precisely what differences of opinion exist between Number 10 and Number 11. 
 That in itself is a destabilising factor. 
 No amount of holding hands, kissing in public, or mingling of blood is going to persuade speculators that Mrs Thatcher and Mr Lawson are at one when they are not. 
 Markets have learned to judge when one approach becomes incompatible with the other, as was the case in May last year when Mrs Thatcher effectively vetoed further attempts by Mr Lawson to hold the pound below DM3. 
 Today, markets have judged that Mr Lawson's endeavours to hold the pound at above DM3 had reached their limit &mdash; or hers. 
 That gave them their one-way bet. 
 The markets have correctly judged where the strongest political pressures lie. 
 The monetarist line is the populist line and to prove it, Sir Rhodes Boyson was peddling it around the Winter Gardens yesterday. 
 Mortgages hit family incomes more directly and forcibly than paying more for the Volkswagen or Sony video recorder which would be among the potentially inflationary effects of devaluation. 
 The mood of the conference is plainly hostile to higher interest rates and in favour of letting the pound float where it will in best Thatcherite, free-market fashion. 
 Some conference representatives may have been influenced by a fiercely polemical front page editorial in yesterday's Daily Mail. 
 It denounced Mr Lawson as &bquo;This bankrupt Chancellor&equo; and called for his dismissal. 
 Instead of his high interest rate policy, the pound should be allowed to fall but then, the Mail added, Britain should join the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System. 
 But this last is precisely what Mr Lawson has long wanted to do and the Prime Minister absolutely forbidden. 
 When Sir Geoffrey Howe last summer tried insisting that she name a date for next year she refused and later sacked him from the Foreign Office. 
 Mrs Thatcher's veto against putting the pound in the ERM has obliged Mr Lawson to set interest rates higher than would have been otherwise necessary to sustain sterling and, some economists think, to beat inflation. 
 If recession and rising unemployment are now the results, she must share the blame. 
 In a clear display of leadership from the fringe yesterday, Michael Heseltine put forward his own radical strategy for industrial and social regeneration based on policies of sound money. 
 On the last point he said &bquo;a formal relationship with the DM would signal the long-term determination to accept the discipline that our counter-inflationary policy needs. 
 Outside but shadowing the DM, we deny ourselves the support of the system at times of currency fluctuation. 
 We could accept a lower parity as part of a decision to join because it would be coupled with the disciplines of the exchange rate mechanism.&equo; 
 Otherwise, he argued, to devalue would be to sanction the inflationary wage-increases which had vitiated so much of Britain's post-war economic history. 
 If coherence of this kind could be brought to the conduct of government policy, the prospects for the economy remain far from forlorn. 
 But whether a monetarist or exchange rate policy is preferred it ought to be clear that the country can no longer endure an ambiguous mix of the two. 
 Mrs Thatcher should do either as the Mail demands and replace Mr Lawson with a Chancellor of whose policies she can wholeheartedly approve or, as Mr Heseltine urges, lift her veto against the only course which could give credibility to an exchange rate policy. 
 Either would be preferable to continuing to try to muddle through with neither. 
 More than a little private problem: On the eve of Nigel Lawson's key address to the Conservative conference, Roger Bootle says the Chancellor must take the balance of payments deficit more seriously, and Nicholas Faith argues that the Tories have failed the entrepreneur 
 By ROGER BOOTLE 
 The author is chief UK economist with the investment bank Midland Montagu. 
 The Chancellor makes his speech tomorrow in Blackpool in the midst of an economic crisis. 
 If a single economic statistic can be blamed for the recent slide towards panic it is the balance of payments figures. 
 The latest batch, showing a deficit of &pound;2bn for the month of August, were the last straw. 
 Now the Conservative Party, the markets and the country at large all desperately seek reassurance. 
 What none of these groups would find reassuring is a repeat of the old Lawson line that the deficit does not matter. 
 The Chancellor has defended this line with a variety of arguments. 
 Perhaps the most appealing has been the idea that the deficit is really not as large as the official figures suggest (because of gross inadequacies in the data). 
 Nevertheless it is not consoling. 
 For however inaccurate the figures are, their inaccuracies cannot have increased sufficiently to explain the sharply deteriorating trend of the balance of payments over the last few years. 
 In fact the Central Statistical Office's view is that the published deficit overstates the real level by no more than &pound;2bn or &pound;3bn. 
 Our current account deficit is now so large that it can be reduced by a mere &pound;2bn or &pound;3bn and still be huge. 
 Of all the arguments the Chancellor deploys, the most powerful is the contention that the deficit does not matter because it does not represent borrowing by the public sector &mdash; in effect the deficit is all in the private sector. 
 Accordingly, he has argued, it should be of concern only to those involved in the respective private sector transactions. 
 If only the markets and the media would get over their obsession with the current account numbers then the Government too could forget about them. 
 This argument derives from an idea with a distinguished academic pedigree. 
 The reasoning is simple. 
 If a country has a current account deficit, then collectively it is spending more on things produced abroad than it is earning from abroad. 
 This gap must be financed by borrowing or selling assets. 
 If we divide the domestic economy into two sectors, public and private, then the deficit must correspond to a financial deficit by one or both of these sectors. 
 In the UK at present, the public sector is in substantial budget surplus, (ie the excess of tax receipts over government spending). 
 Accordingly, the current account deficit must reflect net borrowing (and asset sales) by the private sector. 
 Whether the money has been borrowed for investment or for consumption, both borrower and lender have made a judgement about the viability of the project and its returns. 
 Why should the extent of this activity be of concern to the public authorities? 
 After all, in every other aspect of economic behaviour we now espouse a liberal philosophy. 
 Why not in this aspect also? 
 The main problem with this argument is the consequence of a current account deficit for the exchange rate. 
 Take Britain's case with a deficit running at about &pound;20bn a year. 
 This will mean &pound;20bn-worth of sterling coming on to the market to buy foreign currency. 
 To prevent this from depressing the exchange rate, &pound;20bn of extra capital inflow has to be forthcoming. 
 For a while this may happen easily, not least in circumstances when interest rates are very high. 
 But without high rates, or when foreign investors become worried about the short-term prospects for the currency, these inflows will not be readily forthcoming at current exchange rates. 
 Accordingly the exchange rate will fall until they are forthcoming. 
 Now granted that current account deficits bring downward pressure on a currency, should this be a source of concern for the authorites? 
 It need not be if the authorities do not acknowledge a responsibility for control of inflation or if they believe that exchange rates (just like changes in wage rates, or indirect taxes) do not influence inflation but rather have their effect on relative prices. 
 Accordingly, they can be ignored by monetary authorities seeking to control the overall price level. 
 Inflation is determined by money supply growth. 
 This is the position apparently held by various government ministers in the period 1979-81, when sterling was allowed to soar. 
 Something like it still seems to be believed by some economists close to Mrs Thatcher. 
 Yet this is most definitely not Mr Lawson's position. 
 He believes that the exchange rate is relevant to the control of inflation and indeed has gone to great lengths to show it, including raising interest rates in an attempt to stop the pound from falling. 
 Accordingly, it follows that he should be concerned about the current account deficit as a matter of public policy. 
 In eight years Britain has moved from a current account surplus of 2.5 per cent of GDP to a deficit of 4 per cent of GDP. 
 This turnaround of the external accounts has made the domestic performance of the ecomomy look decidedly better than it has been. 
 It has enabled living standards to be higher and inflation lower than they would have been if the existing current account position had been maintained. 
 But now that the patience of the exchange markets is exhausted and Mr Lawson finds he is unable to raise base rates any more, the chickens are coming home to roost. 
 The surpising thing is not that this is happening now, but rather that it was staved off for so long. 
 He seems to have made the mistake of believing his own propaganda. 
 If you had told any of Britain's hard-pressed post-war chancellors that they could expand the economy vigorously and turn round the external accounts by 6.5 per cent of GDP without adverse consequences, would they not have jumped at the chance? 
 As for the comparison with regions within the country which do not have balance of payments accounts, the balance of payments is a record of transactions between areas with genuine informational content even in these examples. 
 Where areas have their own separate currencies, the forces revealed in the accounts have a vital bearing on the prospects for exchange rates; where there are not separate currencies these same forces have a bearing on the prospects for the real economy, including unemployment. 
 For a separate currency area like the UK, a weak balance of payments may amount to the basis for a depreciating currency. 
 For an area within a currency block, like north-east England, it may amount to a tendency towards high unemployment. 
 If much of this information disappears after 1992 (with the demise of customs barriers), the problem to which it relates will not. 
 The suggestion that it will is like the idea that we can deal with inflation by ceasing to collect data on the price level. 
 The Chancellor should be wary of the argument that the deficit does not matter because it is in the private sector. 
 Given his concern with the exchange rate, the argument does not stand up to analysis. 
 The truth of the matter is that the current account deficit is a touchstone for the success of the Thatcher revolution. 
 As the deficit developed, it enabled the fruits of that revolution to seem greater to consumers than they really were. 
 How quickly the deficit falls without resort to recession will tell us how effective the revolution has been in transforming Britain's producers. 
 Mr Lawson is in danger of striking the market as complacent about the current account deficit. 
 It would be far better to admit the problem openly and set about tackling it. 
 Such a frank appraisal would elicit sympathy from the markets and the British people alike. 
 If Mr Lawson could bring himself to go a stage further, admit some mistakes and consider other policies to use in combination with high interest rates, he might even win their support. 
 If only the Prime Minister were a Thatcherite 
 By NICHOLAS FAITH 
 THE LATEST rise in interest rates finally quashes the foolish delusion that Margaret Thatcher's economic policies were designed to help the entrepreneurial classes, for they need low, stable sources of credit. 
 In fact, her target audience has always been the unenterprising middle- classes, in big private companies as much as in the public sector, looking for security in the form of a home, a pensionable job and a company car. 
 She has taken care not to touch any of these totally unentrepreneurial perks. 
 Mrs Thatcher's priorities were set before she became party leader. 
 Her most notable contribution to the 1974 election campaign was the promise that the interest rate on mortgages would be limited to 9.5 per cent, and she has never been unfaithful to her mystical attachment to the concept of home-ownership. 
 Ironically, it is precisely this religious fervour which has landed her Government in the present mess: not so much mortgage tax relief (which is limited) as the failure to tax the unlimited capital gains available from selling the prime family residence. 
 The sums involved are enormous: 70 per cent of the total growth in the nation's wealth since 1979 has been due to the rise in value of the housing stock. 
 Over the past few years the bourgeoisie has taken probably &pound;10bn of completely untaxed, totally unearned capital profit from selling their houses. 
 These gains, usually lavished on travel abroad, foreign cars and luxuries, are the single biggest cause of our balance of payments deficit. 
 Moreover the hitherto unstoppable rise in property value has formed an apparently solid base for the credit spiral which so bedevils government economic policy. 
 Politically, her pro-home bias was perfectly sensible. 
 Entrepreneurs, by their nature, are relatively thin on the ground &mdash; and an ungrateful lot not given to remembering those who helped them on the first, shaky steps on the ladder. 
 Moreover, since Michael Heseltine's departure, there is no one in Mrs Thatcher's Cabinet to remind her of the nature of Entrepreneurial Man. 
 When he stalked out he left her with a motley crew mostly of accountants and lawyers. 
 This group of professionals has not even bothered to ease the biggest problem facing entrepreneurs &mdash; apart from the unavailability of cheap finance &mdash; which is the lack of cash flow that results from customers not paying bills on time. 
 These delays cost small businesses well over &pound;1bn a year but Mrs Thatcher's Government has not followed our EC partners in providing for automatic charging of interest on overdue bills, a step recommended 10 years ago by the Law Commission. 
 This lack of cash flow does not worry the typical Thatcherite so-called &bquo;entrepreneur&equo;, who is not really a risk-taker. 
 He is a partner in a service business or professional partnership: estate agencies, solicitors, surveyors or accountants' practices. 
 Agents for other people's money, they do not venture their own capital, and their firms are not truly entrepreneurial ventures. 
 They do not make the sort of sacrifice &mdash; the second mortgage, the move to a smaller house, the seven-day weeks, the abandonment of any thought of holidays for years on end -required of those starting up new commercial or, above all, industrial businesses. 
 You can tell her priorities from a glance at the obituary columns. 
 Every day half a dozen or so old ladies leave a million pounds or more, generally widows whose major asset was a decent house in the South-east. 
 But these unearned gains concern only the older generation. 
 Houses are no longer the gold-plated investment they have been since the war. 
 The British bourgeoisie is going to have to look elsewhere for capital appreciation. 
 They may actually have to take risks: all the fault of Mrs Thatcher, but not because she was too interested in the entrepreneurs; quite the contrary, because she over-egged the pudding for the house-owning classes. 
 Leading Article: High time for monetary union 
 By NICHOLAS FAITH 
 THERE is no excuse for further delay. 
 Britain should enter the Exchange Rate Mechanism of the European Monetary System immediately. 
 The case for taking this step has long been powerful, and is now overwhelming. 
 The Chancellor of the Exchequer, Nigel Lawson, said he had one weapon with which to beat inflation: the interest rate. 
 That weapon has been shown by events to be inadequate. 
 The rate has been raised quite high enough to deal with overheating in the domestic economy. 
 Mr Lawson is right to argue that, given time, this desirable objective will be achieved. 
 But if anything, the rate may already be too high, bringing with it the danger that it will not only remove excess demand, but push the economy into recession. 
 A base rate of 15 per cent is perilously close to monetary overkill, let alone the still higher rates which might be needed to appease the rapacious gods of the foreign exchange markets. 
 It follows that the interest rate can no longer be used to defend sterling. 
 The maintenance of a firm currency has an important part in the battle against inflation, but if pursued uniquely by means of offering foreign holders of sterling an ever-increasing interest rate premium, the result will be severe damage to the British economy and the Tories' chances of re-election. 
 This elementary drawback has long been foreseen, as has the means of avoiding it. 
 Instead of being obliged, indefinitely, to keep British interest rates higher than domestic conditions warrant, we can join the ERM. 
 The pound would then no longer be an isolated currency, to which greater risk attaches, necessitating a premium rate of return to induce people to hold it. 
 The Government's official position, dictated by the Prime Minister, has been that Britain will join the ERM when &bquo;the time is ripe&equo;. 
 Because this phrase has been understood to mean, as far as Margaret Thatcher is concerned, &bquo;over my dead body&equo;, an announcement that the time is now ripe would be interpreted as a climbdown. 
 So it would be, but even the Prime Minister ought to see that it is the least bad course open to her. 
 When West Germany raised its interest rate last week, Britain was forced immediately to follow suit. 
 The economic sovereignty which Mrs Thatcher claims to defend is a chimera. 
 This so called sovereignty amounts to a choice between a continued run on the pound and an interest-rate-induced slump. 
 The refusal to join the ERM is harming the nation, as narrow-minded nationalism generally does. 
 The refusal also makes the Government incapable of carrying conviction in its overall economic policy. 
 So long as a fissure is known to exist between the Prime Minister and the Chancellor about the ERM, the task of convincing the financial markets that policy is in safe hands will be made infinitely more difficult. 
 The achievements of the past 10 years will be jeopardised not only by the present bout of inflation, but even more by a general loss of confidence in the Government's ability to deal with it. 
 The rate of inflation would be less high if Britain was already subject to the discipline of the ERM. 
 An announcement now, by the Chancellor, that he has instructed the Governor of the Bank of England to start negotiations on entry with his European counterparts, would transform the situation. 
 Leading Article: Private gifts for public arts 
 By NICHOLAS FAITH 
 ACCORDING to Peter Palumbo, chairman of the Arts Council, in the United States 90 per cent of the arts are funded by individual donors. 
 In Britain, the balance between public and private sector funding is five to one and individual rather than corporate benefactions form a &bquo;negligible&equo; element of the private sector. 
 Many people have made substantial personal fortunes in the past few years, Mr Palumbo writes in the council's annual report, and having inherited the mantle of the great patrons of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, they should acknowledge their responsibilities by returning a portion of their good fortune to the community. 
 Mr Palumbo's central point is sound, his argumentation less so. 
 For a start, much of that earlier patronage was for the benefit of the patrons and not of the public. 
 Great collections were formed primarily for personal enjoyment. 
 Only in the nineteenth century did some of them find their way into the new museums. 
 If Lord Chandos commissioned operas from Handel, it was not for the public's enjoyment. 
 Many of the great fortunes in this country are still in the hands of the landed aristocracy who tend to be preoccupied with maintaining their great estates and country houses, no doubt feeling that opening them to the public is in itself a form of patronage. 
 Old, or unearned, money tends to be neither acquisitive nor outward-going, whereas new money tends to be both. 
 In the United States there is more new money, the social structure is different, and the tax regime encourages private giving. 
 Nonetheless, there have latterly been some notable donations from individuals in Britain: like the Sainsbury brothers' new wing for the National Gallery and the Clore Foundation's for the Tate; Terence Conran's &pound;7m for the establishment of the Design Museum in Docklands, and Paul Hamlyn's cheap weeks for children at the Royal Opera House. 
 To tap the wealth of the highly salaried, American-style tax incentives are needed. 
 An American giving to a non-profit-making organisation can deduct such donations from taxable income. 
 So a company chairman earning &dollar;750,000 a year and giving &dollar;250,000 to the local orchestra would pay tax on only &dollar;500,000. 
 The sole equivalent here is the modest &bquo;give as you earn&equo; scheme, with up to &pound;480 a year deductable from taxable salary if donated to a registered charity. 
 Tax advantages are not the only factor making donations to the arts so popular among rich Americans. 
 In state capitals, the standard of museums and of the performing arts is a source of pride, and helping to raise those standards confers prestige and social cachet. 
 In Britain, the old tradition of private patronage in the great provincial cities is reviving &mdash; but not fast enough. 
 More needs to be done to popularise the arts as a focal attraction of regional life. 
 Substantial state funding of major artistic enterprises will continue to be required if their standards are to be maintained. 
 Corporate funding, which rose to around &pound;30m last year, has its part to play, irritating though it is when executives parade as great patrons while giving away their shareholders' money. 
 Private donations are unequivocally good. 
 They should be encouraged by the tax system and give from a desire to share or spread pleasure rather than a sense of guilt or duty. 
 A world beyond our Ken 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 STAGGERINGLY, an unknown Shakespeare play has been unearthed in a small computer in The Independent. 
 This is its first publication anywhere. 
 The History of King Kenneth I The court. 
 Enter King Kenneth I, with lords, including Earl Wapping, the Duke of Fleet Street and the Lord of the Isle of Dogs. 
 King: How now, my noble lords, good morrow! 
 You bring us news of what the public prints Think fit to say upon our royal performance? 
 Lords: We do, my lord. 
 We have this morning's here, Chock full of column inches on yourself. 
 King: Then tell me what the inky-fingered crew Have new concocted to admire, or damn, in me. 
 Am I today the &bquo;Young man in a hurry&equo;? 
 Or is it time for &bquo;Gilded Ken&equo; again? 
 Lord Wapping: My Lord, tis none of these today, I fear&hellip; 
 King: Your name, old man? 
 King: Then stand not so, dear Wapping, when you speak, All stiff and formal as you were a judge Preparing to send a murderer to the scaffold. 
 Relax! 
 Let go your hands! 
 Put on a smile! 
 This is a young man's court from this day on We'll bid old ways and styles of talk begone! 
 Wapping: My Lord, this is the way I always stand And have stood so for 60 years or more. 
 I cannot change it now, tis far too late. 
 King: I beg thy pardon, Wapping. 
 I find in me A strange compulsion to direct all men E'en to the way they stand and walk or move. 
 Sometimes I stop a total stranger in the street And say to him: Let's do that one more time, But this time walk past slower, with a limp, Or smiling to yourself, as one gone mad. 
 Think you this strange? 
 Wapping: I cannot say, my Lord. 
 King: And just as well. 
 So, tell me then what sport The hacks of Fleet Street have with me today. 
 Isle of Dogs: They talk today of your new book, Beginning, And seem uncertain whether to praise or blame. 
 King: It grieves me, sir. 
 We actor kings, you know, We Shers and Simon Callows, write our books About ourselves for one good single reason. 
 Knowst what it is? 
 Wapping: For vanity? 
 Wapping: To make sure Melvyn Bragg cannot Write posthumously on your life and times? 
 King: I like your jest, but no. 
 Tis to ensure By being author of a hardback book, That we are handled by a book reviewer To make a change from endless drama critics. 
 Wapping: How very interesting, my Lord. 
 And now With your consent, we'll go about our tasks. 
 King: So, farewell, Wapping, faithful Fleet Street too, And Lord of the Isle of Dogs, adieu to you. 
 Exeunt lords, severally. 
 Enter to him Emma, his Queen. 
 King: But see where yonder Emma comes to me, In such a light as blinds the eye to tears, The which casts shadows o'er her lovely face And totally muck up the shot, I fear. 
 Put out the light! 
 And do the take again! 
 Emma: My Lord, I have not time to waste on that - I have an interview with Vogue ere midday strikes. 
 But tell me who those men were, walking out. 
 King: Press barons, moguls, mediamen, that's all. 
 Emma: Sweet Kenneth, do not trust these gentlemen! 
 They smile and nod like flowers in the sun, But come a nasty squall or shower from the West, And they will squeal and shout, and say of you, We never liked young Kenneth much before And now this change of climate proves us right. 
 Emma bursts into tears, and does it very well. 
 Letter: Monetarism and the &bquo;Thatcherite miracle&equo; that never happened 
 From Dr CHARLES BEAN 
 Sir: William Rees-Mogg ('Creating money to buy trouble with', 9 October) writes that &bquo;to run a stable economy one needs&hellip; the right ideas&equo;. 
 I agree. 
 Unfortunately, his advocacy of a broad money target coupled with entry into the EMS ignores recent evidence and rests on doubtful economics. 
 The following table gives the average rate of growth of narrow money (NIB M1) and broad money (M3) over selected periods together with the annual inflation rate at the end of each period.  
 Broad money was dropped as a target because it gave completely misleading signals during the 1979-81 recession. 
 Furthermore, a variety of indicators, including capacity utilisation and vacancies, have been giving clear signs of inflationary pressure in the economy for some time. 
 Why just look at broad money? 
 The Government would be well advised to choose to direct its monetary policy either towards domestic monetary conditions or to the exchange rate. 
 Either will do, but the present confusion has only added to uncertainty in the financial markets. 
 Targeting both the money supply and the exchange rate would be daft since the Government has only one effective instrument available, the level of interest rates. 
 Overfunding is not a way out of this box, because at the end of the day this too works via interest rates. 
 Perhaps Lord Rees-Mogg should stick to picking European mastersingers? 
 Letter: Monetarism and the &bquo;Thatcherite miracle&equo; that never happened 
 From Professor WYNNE GODLEY 
 Sir: In his article &bquo;Creating money to buy trouble with&equo; (9 October), William Rees-Mogg puts forward the surprising view that the early 1980s constitututed a &bquo;Thatcherite miracle&equo;. 
 This, he contends, was achieved by the targeting of M3, the money supply measure, which was the backbone of the counter inflationary policy of Mrs Thatcher's first administration&hellip; 
 It was painful but it was successful. 
 Inflation was brought down to below 5 per cent, the balance of payments remained healthy and productivity improved rapidly. 
 But M3 was not successfully targeted in the early Thatcher years. 
 For instance, in the Financial Statement and Budget Report for 1980/81 the target range for the four years 1980/81-1983/84 averaged 5.5-9.5 per cent per annum; according to Economic Trends (Annual Supplement 1989), the outrun was 13 per cent &mdash; about double the centre of the targeted range. 
 Almost all the subsequent targets were exceeded until the attempt at control was abandoned. 
 And over the whole six-year period 1979-85 the average growth of M3 was 13 per cent, which happens to be exactly the same as it was between 1965 and 1973, the period analysed by William Rees-Mogg in his famous article in The Times (13 June 1976), &bquo;How a 9.4 per cent excess money supply gave Britain 9.4 per cent inflation&equo;, which denounced the conduct of economic policy in the early Seventies. 
 As M3 grew so fast in the early Eighties, its performance can hardly explain the reduction in inflation, which I believe to have been caused by very high and rising unemployment together with a very large and destructive appreciation in sterling. 
 Moreover it is not true that &bquo;the balance of payments remained healthy&equo;. 
 The current account surplus in 1985 was more than entirely accounted for by oil, which had improved from a deficit of about &pound;700m in 1979 to a surplus of &pound;8bn in 1985. 
 The underlying trend of the balance of payments was extremely adverse; although the average growth of total output was only just over 1 per cent (slower than in any six-year period previous to Thatcher), the current account excluding oil moved from a small surplus in 1979 to a deficit of &pound;5bn in 1985. 
 It is true that productivity in manufacturing (though not in the economy as a whole) grew rapidly, though no faster than in the six-year periods ending 1969 or 1973. 
 But there is no merit in improved productivity without any other sign of improved performance. 
 And of this there was little. 
 Manufacturing output and investment in 1985 were both far below their 1979 levels absolutely. 
 And the ability of manufacturing industry to compete in world markets (defined to include our own) had deteriorated markedly; exports of manufactures rose 2 per cent on average whereas imports rose by 6 per cent. 
 Taking everything together, I strongly suggest that the idea that an economic miracle took place in the first six Thatcher years is a very dangerous myth. 
 Letter: Concern over statistics 
 From Mr B. A. J. QUIRKE 
 Sir: The Institute of Statisticians' role over the last 40 years has been to promote and protect the professional integrity of statisticians not only in this country but in the many others covered by our membership ('Wide support for impartial check on official statistics', 10 October). 
 After the Rayner Report in 1981, we were party to discussions with Sir John Boreham, the then Head of the Government Statistical Service, and others with a view to setting up a National Statistics Council. 
 These discussions failed through the basic problem of lack of resources to fund the operations of such an organisation. 
 The Institute of Statisticians continues to be deeply concerned with both the provision of adequate statistical information and the monitoring of potential misuse, be it by political parties, television, radio and the Press or any other vested interest group which might benefit from such misuse. 
 Our concern certainly includes official statistics such as the retail price index and unemployment figures, but is cognisant of similar dangers associated with clinical trials testing, opinion polls, advertising claims, etc. 
 This institute believes that some form of National Statistics Council has a role to play but with the following provisos: 1. 
 It should be genuinely independent of all vested interest; 2. 
 It should be properly representative of all the sectors at risk; 3. 
 It should be adequately funded. 
 Letter: Campus &bquo;Kremlin' 
 From Mr GAVIN COULTHARD 
 Sir: As a former student at the then University of Rhodesia, I was appalled at the decision of the Zimbabwe government to close down the university. 
 During the UDI (Unilateral Declaration of Independence) years there was little love lost between the Smith regime and the university &mdash; indeed it was often referred to as &bquo;the Kremlin on the hill&equo;. 
 At no time, however, did they use such draconian measures to stifle dissent. 
 On 28 July 1971 the Rhodesia Herald published a letter from me in response to a vitriolic attack by a Rhodesia Front Party MP: When Mr Irvine claims that the university campus is both a hotbed of evil living and orientated to the &bquo;unpractical arts&equo; subjects, did he visualise arts and social science students abandoning their studies in history, sociology and political science to take up carpentry and plumbing? 
 These students would then, no doubt, be accused of depriving immigrants of their sole source of livelihood. 
 Sadly events have turned full circle and those who defended the university then must do so again. 
 Letter: Gallery view 
 From Ms PHILIPPA TOOMEY 
 Sir: When it comes to supporting the arts, very little seems to have changed since George Farquhar in his Discourse on Comedy described his audience in 1702 as: a pit full of City gentlemen, a gallery full of cits, a hundred ladies of court education and about 200 footmen of nice morality. 
 It could be, of course, that these are the only people interested in the arts and it is a waste of time trying to increase the proportion of the modern equivalent of the footman of nice morality. 
 I write as a cit in the gallery. 
 Letter: All-night licences for &bquo;Acid House&equo; parties 
 From Mr TONY COLSTON-HAYTER 
 Sir: Your leading article &bquo;The freedom to party&equo; (9 October) made a number of valid points. 
 We as organisers of all-night dancing parties would welcome the reasonable regulation of parties. 
 We are not criminals &mdash; we are a legal tax-paying enterprise which organises, up until now, perfectly legal, private, dance music warehouse parties. 
 The idea that so-called &bquo;acid parties&equo; are a dangerous drug crazed youth cult is a sensationalist fantasy of the gutter press. 
 We would welcome a system of licensing which allowed private clubs to apply for all-night music and dance licensing in suitable venues. 
 Local authorities, fire officers and the police would inspect the venue for safety and suitability (we already fulfill all safety conditions). 
 We would then organise the party along the lines of other large events such as pop concerts or sports meetings, in co-operation with the police. 
 The crux of the problem is the duration of the event. 
 The massive popularity of our parties is partly due to the fact that we offer all-night dancing, this proves the need for a facility to obtain all-night licences for one-off events. 
 This would solve the problem of fly-by-night organisers. 
 By all means outlaw unsafe parties, but the Government must consider how to allow properly organised events to take place. 
 If the Government introduces blanket laws to prevent all-night parties it will be making an ominous step towards removing the right to freedom of association. 
 A government committed to freedom should reconsider. 
 Letter: Time for Dr Higgs to return to her work 
 From Dr GEOFFREY WYATT 
 Sir: Following your interview with Dr Marietta Higgs (6 October) I write to support her case to be allowed to return to work in Cleveland. 
 I do so because I believe she has been made a scapegoat for what happened. 
 In turn, that may be damaging child health care in the county. 
 Dr Higgs always appeared the most likely scapegoat for what happened in Cleveland in 1987. 
 She had been in the post for only seven months when the inquiry started, had little public or professional support, and there was unlikely to be any backlash to her being blamed. 
 Yet since 1987, the level of child sexual abuse diagnosed in Cleveland has been shown to be no higher than elsewhere in the country, and an increasing number of people locally take the view that she should be treated in the same way as myself &mdash; allowed to return to work as a paediatrician in Cleveland, but restricted from working in child abuse for the time being. 
 That would allay concerns about public confidence in the paediatric services at Middlesbrough General Hospital. 
 To blame an individual doctor for making a diagnosis of child sexual abuse because adults find anal abuse difficult to understand and accept has serious implications. 
 Fear of public criticism may well be intimidating some doctors, making them less inclined to consider the diagnosis. 
 Children may be denied the possibility of such abuse being detected. 
 The political will to deal with the issue is reduced, affecting the resources available. 
 And the wider community is denied the opportunity to deal with the issue compassionately. 
 The publicity Cleveland attracted understandably disturbed many people here. 
 They found thinking about child sexual abuse emotionally distasteful. 
 Aspects of the &bquo;crisis&equo;, such as the separation of children from their family homes, worried and frightened them, and the possibility that the doctors were wrong brought welcome relief from the pain of child sexual abuse and precipitated denial and anger in the community. 
 Two years on, Cleveland should be allowed to move from anger and denial to acceptance and compassion &mdash; for the sake of children and the people abusing them, both of whom need effective help. 
 Without open debate and education, the local community cannot move to the clearer understanding of the nature of child sexual abuse that is necessary for professionals to receive the help and support they need from the public. 
 Professionals alone cannot tackle this difficult and distressing subject. 
 It has to be a shared responsibility. 
 Scapegoating an individual prevents the debate and delays community understanding. 
 While Dr Higgs is excluded from Cleveland, other doctors in Cleveland cannot discount the same thing happening to them. 
 They may as a result lack the confidence to raise a concern about child sexual abuse despite government advice following the inquiry that the possibility should be considered in the differential diagnosis of many physical conditions. 
 Thus while Dr Higgs continues her exile, both public and professional issues here remain unresolved. 
 Lord Justice Butler-Sloss in her concluding remarks on Dr Higgs's role stated that &bquo;She alone did not create the crisis. 
 She was one among many professionals and shares with others the responsibility for what happened. 
 To place it all upon her is to distort reality, and an unjust over-simplification of the complex issues which arose in Cleveland.&equo; 
 The scapegoating of Dr Higgs is not justified. 
 If she returned to share her burden as the &bquo;Cleveland scapegoat&equo; we could all make progress with this very serious issue of child health. 
 Letter: Redundant chapels 
 From Mr ALAN BEITH, MP 
 Sir: Clive Fewins's article (Weekend, 7 October) rightly praised the excellent work of the Redundant Churches Fund, but it should also serve as a reminder that there is still no Redundant Chapels Fund to conserve some of the best examples of Non-Conformist buildings, many of which are in imminent danger of demolition or drastic alteration. 
 The one Non-Conformist chapel referred to in the article has been saved because it subsequently became a parish church and thus qualified for the fund. 
 The root of the problem is that there is no Non-Conformist equivalent of the church commissioners who, as well as contributing in large measure to Church of England clergy stipends, share with the state the responsibility for providing the Redundant Churches Fund. 
 There is no way the non-established denominations can be expected to make a comparable contribution, and the Government must therefore take a larger role in providing some mechanism for preserving some of the notable places of worship which, as well as being delightful buildings, are an important testimony to our religious and social history. 
 Letter: Fitting tribute 
 From Mr STEPHEN BINGHAM 
 Sir: The recent death of your food correspondent, Jeremy Round, was a cause of great sadness not only for his family and friends but also to the many thousands of readers who regularly enjoyed his articles. 
 World Family was greatly touched, therefore, when Mr Round's family requested that donations in lieu of floral tributes should be sent to us, to assist our work with children in less developed countries. 
 Readers may be interested to know that the money given will go towards nutritional programmes in one of the poorest areas of Cairo. 
 May we, through your newspaper, thank all those who contributed; the Cairo project seems to us a most fitting tribute to a fine young writer. 
 Letter: Street credibility 
 From Mr F. J. GRIFFITH 
 Sir: It would appear that the Prime Minster is overlooking a perfect opportunity to put her theories into practice &mdash; why not assign the security arrangements at Downing Street to a private security firm? 
 Panama coup plotters died &bquo;in Noriega bloodbath&equo; 
 From DAVID ADAMS in Panama 
 &bquo;NORIEGA just exploded and the conspirators died where they stood.&equo; 
 Diplomatic and military sources, after speaking with people who were trapped inside General Manuel Noriega's military headquarters during last week's coup attempt, say a bloodbath took place when the plot leaders surrendered. 
 In the days following the attempt, sources said that some of those detained also were killed. 
 There are further reports of torture of rebels and the persecution of their families. 
 As the bodies of victims of the fighting are buried, there is growing alarm over the scale of the killing both during and after the battle. 
 According to evidence drawn from diplomats, military analysts and family members of the dead and detained, it appears that as many as 24 people were killed and 100 injured. 
 Some of those detained may have been tortured. 
 The government is still sticking to its account, which names 10 dead and a further 37 detained. 
 But so far only four men have been buried and no autopsy results have been disclosed. 
 &bquo;Where are the bodies?&equo; asked a European diplomat who monitors military affairs. 
 Yesterday, one of the detained rebels, Captain Nicasio Lorenzo, was buried. 
 Government reports assert that Captain Lorenzo hanged himself in his cell. 
 Family members at his funeral said they do not believe official accounts. 
 &bquo;We know who is doing the killing,&equo; said one. 
 Captain Lorenzo is the first member of General Noriega's inner military circle, known as the Strategic Military Council (CEM), known to have died. 
 Another two CEM members are reported as detained. 
 The coup leader, Major Moises Giraldi, was buried on Monday beside three other rebel graves. 
 Only close family members attended the service, some of whom say that his body showed signs of torture. 
 As they wept around his coffin, one relative who said she had dressed the body, said: &bquo;It looked as though he had been tortured.&equo; 
 She said that, in addition to several gunshot wounds, Giraldi had fractures of the skull, ribs and one leg. 
 During the service, one relative collapsed after shouting: &bquo;They will pay for this.&equo; 
 Reports are growing of continued division within General Noriega's Panama Defence Forces. 
 Sources say the brutal way in which the coup leaders have been dealt with has caused a dramatic loss of morale within the army. 
 &bquo;Before Noriega had to worry about the gringos,&equo; said one diplomat. 
 &bquo;Now he's watching his own people.&equo; 
 US troops in Panama remain on the highest state of alert. 
 A curfew imposed by the government is still in effect, although it seems directed more at confining soldiers and policemen to their barracks than at keeping civilians off the streets. 
 A draconian set of &bquo;emergency war laws&equo; is being drawn up. 
 The package of 16 measures is likely to be presented shortly. 
 The measures are expected to include new financial and tax laws, a revision of the military and penal codes and restrictions on freedom of movement and transport. 
 Regulations have also been discussed regarding the suspension and dismissal of public employees who do not express loyalty to General Noriega. 
 Abortion debate moves to fore in US state polls 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Washington 
 THE FLORIDA state legislature began a special session yesterday devoted entirely to abortion law. 
 Earlier this week, the first television debate in a fascinating and closely-fought Virginia gubernatorial race was dominated by the arguments for a woman's right to choose and a foetus's right to life. 
 When the Supreme Court decided in July to weaken the nationwide constitutional right to abortion granted in 1973, political pundits predicted a flurry of abortion-restricting legislation and political blood-letting at state level. 
 They also predicted abortion would overwhelm all other issues in a series of gubernatorial elections this autumn and in the state legislative and US Congressional elections next year. 
 The pundits have proved half right. 
 The Supreme Court's July ruling admitted for the first time in 16 years the right of individual states to restrict abortions during the first six months of pregnancy. 
 The decision has generated sheafs of proposed new abortion legislation, pro and anti, at state level. 
 It has possibly become the dominant issue in several state races but has also produced a more compromising approach to the abortion issue. 
 The Supreme Court decision instantly awakened the large silent majority in favour of basic abortion rights. 
 Since the early 1980s, the Pro Life lobby had made all the political running, especially in the Republican Party where candidates at local and national level, including George Bush, were forced to amend their views to fit the new conservative orthodoxy. 
 The political re-awakening of the Pro-Choice lobby has made it electorally essential for Republicans to abandon the simplistic Pro-life slogans of the Reagan years. 
 Take, for instance, the recent experience of three conservative Republicans. 
 The day after the July ruling in the Supreme Court, Bob Martinez, Governor of Florida, promised a special session of the state legislature to push through abortion-restricting laws. 
 When he saw the extent of the Pro-Choice backlash against the Court decision, he temporised. 
 The Pro Lifers insisted, and he called this week's special session. 
 It is predicted the Democratic majority in the legislature in Tallahassee will block his proposals, giving a valuable psychological victory to the pro-choicers. 
 Meanwhile, Marshall Coleman is making his second attempt to become governor of Virginia. 
 He won the Republican nomination this year largely because he persuaded conservative voters that he favoured &bquo;life&equo; more than his two principle opponents. 
 Come July and the Supreme Court decision, Mr Coleman found Virginia voters were two to one in favour of the retention of a broad right to abortion. 
 His Democratic opponent, Doug Wilder, hoping on 7 November to become the first black governor of a US state, has been forcing him to back-pedal since. 
 The two went into yesterday's television debate dead even in the polls. 
 Mr Coleman promised he would not push for legislation which would severely restrict abortion in Virginia. 
 For New Jersey, the Republican candidate in the November gubernatorial elections, Congressman Jim Courter, has been a prominent and powerful campaigner against abortion in the US House of Representatives. 
 He has stated that, as Governor of New Jersey, he would not push for legislation to restrict abortion drastically. 
 He has challenged his Democratic opponent in electorally more productive areas, such as public funding for abortions. 
 Political commentators suggest that the political migration of such prominent Republicans has a positive side. 
 The US abortion debate, long entrenched in the absolute positions of the opposing activist camps, is moving toward the more moderate that reflect the broad plains of US public opinion. 
 The Supreme Court is expected to weaken further the nationwide constitutional protection for abortion early next year. 
 Most states can be expected modestly to regulate access to abortion, rather than radically restrict it. 
 Kluge crowned king of America's wealthy 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 THE TITLE of America's wealthiest person bestowed each year by Forbes magazine has passed to John Kluge, a media baron from Virginia less known for his billions than his wife's passion for the British royal family. 
 Forbes's 1989 list of the 400 wealthiest people in the United States estimates Mr Kluge's net worth at &dollar;5.2bn (&pound;3.3bn), much of which he realised in a sale of six television stations to a fellow media mogul, Rupert Murdoch. 
 Mr Kluge displaced the long-time title holder, Sam Walton, only because Mr Walton chose last year to divide a &dollar;9bn Wal-Mart stores fortune among his children. 
 In world-wide rankings Mr Kluge comes ninth, behind six Japanese billionaires, the richest of whom is weighs in at &dollar;15bn. 
 The passion of Mr Kluge's third wife, Patricia, for the royal family has periodically thrust her 75-year-old husband into the public eye. 
 Mrs Kluge, 40, has pursued the royal family relentlessly, to the point of buying a 75,000-acre estate next to Balmoral Castle. 
 But her cause was badly damaged in 1985, the day before she was to sit next to the Prince of Wales at a dinner in Florida, when it was revealed that she posed as a nude model in magazines and appeared in pornographic films in the late 1960s. 
 Mr Kluge also appears to suffer from anglophilia. 
 His Virginia estate includes an 850-acre game reserve, where Mr Kluge last year advertised an &bquo;authentic British shoot&equo;. 
 The shoot was waylaid by litigation, however, after Mr Kluge's Irish and British gamekeepers were convicted of killing hundreds of protected hawks and owls &mdash; and some of the neighbours' dogs &mdash; in an authentic effort to keep the game alive for the pleasure of the guests. 
 Mr Kluge built a communications conglomerate, Metromedia Inc, from scratch. 
 It included radio and television stations, paging devices, mobile telephones, Orion Pictures and the Harlem Globetrotters. 
 When he sold his stations in 1985, he got &dollar;2bn &mdash; 15 times the cash flow of the stations, rather than the usual multiple of nine to 11. 
 Amnesty hits at Colombian army killings 
 By ISABEL HILTON 
 KILLINGS of unarmed civilians in Colombia by sectors of the armed forces have reached unprecedented levels, according to a report by Amnesty International published today, writes Isabel Hilton. 
 The report argues that the drug crisis should not be allowed to obscure a pattern of gross human rights violations committed by members of the armed forces, often working in collusion with alleged drug traffickers, and paramilitary groups acting on their orders. 
 In the past year-and-a-half, 2,500 Colombians have been killed by such groups and a further 250 have disappeared after being detained by security forces, according to Amnesty. 
 The killings are part of a campaign of intimidation and elimination of supporters of the political opposition. 
 The report says that recent judicial investigations in Colombia have established that political killings have been planned and organised by army officers and carried out by irregular groups operating on behalf of the armed forces. 
 The victims have included priests, human rights workers and members of the judiciary investigating human rights abuses. 
 In one of several examples in recent months of mass killings, the report says, 43 people, including three children, were massacred in the gold-mining town of Segovia in November 1988. 
 The report says that court investigations established that the security forces were directly responsible for the massacre, which was believed to be directed against supporters of the left-wing party, the Patriotic Union. 
 The judge investigating the case has also received death threats. 
 Burmese release spy chief 
 From TERRY MCCARTHY in Bangkok 
 THE BURMESE government has released a disgraced former intelligence chief, but is continuing to arrest civilians in a growing &bquo;terror campaign&equo;, according to diplomats in Rangoon. 
 Criticism of alleged &bquo;foreign interference&equo; by Western embassies and news organisations in Burmese affairs has also been stepped up by the military. 
 Brigadier-General Tin Oo was unexpectedly released from Insein jail last week, after nearly seven years. 
 He was head of the Military Intelligence Service (MIS) until his fall from grace in 1983, when it was thought that Ne Win, Burma's autocratic ruler since 1962, perceived him as a threat to his leadership. 
 The MIS, with its vast network of informers, was designed by General Ne Win to consolidate his hold on power. 
 Diplomats think that by releasing General Tin Oo now, General Ne Win may be trying to counter the growing power of the MIS head, Khin Nyunt. 
 The military government, officially called the State Law and Order Restoration Committee, has promised to hold elections by May. 
 But diplomats say that with many opposition politicians in jail and the continuing arrests, few Burmese expect the elections to affect the military's control of the country. 
 The regime has done little to reassure people. 
 &bquo;Democratic activities can be carried out, but it should not be forgotten that the Tatmadaw (army) is the life of the nation,&equo; warned a slogan in the government-run Working People's Daily. 
 Arrests are being made nightly. 
 Many people are taken away hooded and chained and are interrogated for several days before being released. 
 One woman who was kept in solitary confinement for three days said: &bquo;The whole idea is to worry people.&equo; 
 An envoy said: &bquo;It is ironic that the two most important people in the country are completely removed from the population.&equo; 
 He was referring to the opposition leader, Aung San Suu Kyi, whose home on Inya lake, northern Rangoon, is surrounded by troops to enforce her house-arrest and General Ne Win, whose residence on the other side of the lake is also surrounded by troops and who rarely ventures out. 
 Aung San Suu Kyi, the leader of the National League for Democracy, has been under house-arrest since July. 
 She is becoming Burma's most famous non-person, much to the anger of the military, who were hoping she would fade away as a political force. 
 The regime is also trying to minimise contact between Burmese and foreign diplomats, whom they accuse of interference. 
 Foreign publications have been criticised for alleged one-sided reporting and their correspondents have been denied visas. 
 Myth and menace merge in India's poll campaign: Tony Allen-Mills writes from Uttar Pradesh on a Hindu-Muslim row over a mosque that could influence the general election later this year 
 By TONY ALLEN-MILLS 
 AT THE end of the Treta, or Second Age, Dasaratha, the childless king of the Solar race, performed the Aswa-medha sacrifice of horses and begged the gods to grant him a son. 
 It was a time of great alarm in the Hindu heavens, for Ravana, the Rakshasa king of Lanka, had obtained terrible powers and was threatening the world. 
 Vishnu, the second god of the Hindu triad, resolved to return to earth in human form. 
 Dasaratha's wish was granted and, in the sacred Solar capital of Ayodhya, the divine baby Rama was born as Vishnu's seventh incarnation on Earth. 
 So began a glorious episode in Hindu legend, leading not only to Ravana's defeat at Rama's hands, but, centuries later, to problems for the secular forces ruling modern India. 
 Ayodhya, a placid centre of worship on the Ghaghara river in eastern Uttar Pradesh, has become the focus of a religious and political wrangle that could influence India's general election this year. 
 Both government and opposition are grappling with the awkward consequences of an upsurge of religious tension inspired by militant Hindu claims to a disused Muslim mosque on a site believed to have been Lord Rama's birthplace. 
 Ayodhya's Babri mosque was built on the ruins of an old Hindu temple during the Moghul invasions of the late 16th century. 
 Four hundred years later, after the British division of the sub-continent and the Muslim exodus to Pakistan, the mosque fell into disuse. 
 After years of frustrated attempts to regain control of the site, Hindu extremists brought the issue to an explosive head this year by threatening to tear down the crumbling mosque and build a temple devoted to Lord Rama. 
 The dispute has been referred to the Uttar Pradesh high court and the government recently secured a tentative promise from Hindu militants that the mosque would not be harmed pending a ruling. 
 But tension remains high and bricks for the new Hindu temple, each inscribed with Lord Rama's name, are being baked and blessed at ceremonies around the country. 
 Irrespective of the court proceedings, Hindu activists have chosen 9 November to lay the foundation-stone of the new Ram Janmabhoomi temple less than 100 yards from the mosque's front gate. 
 The threat to the sanctity of the Babri mosque has infuriated India's Muslim minority. 
 Abdullah Bukhari, imam of the Jama mosque in New Delhi, threatened earlier this year to retaliate to any assault in Ayodhya by ordering Muslims &bquo;to attack, to crown the downtrodden with victory; to destroy the tyrant&equo;. 
 A group of radical Muslim youths has formed a &bquo;demolition squad&equo; which has pledged to build an even bigger mosque in place of the Babri. 
 As myth and menace merge, there have been clashes in several towns: in neighbouring Faizabad, five Muslims and one Hindu were killed. 
 The dispute is worrying the Congress (I) Party of Rajiv Gandhi, the Prime Minister, who faces a strong challenge from Hindu fundamentalists in the election. 
 These parties accuse Mr Gandhi of pampering India's minorities at the Hindu majority's expense. 
 In recent months their flagrantly communal slogans ('Say it with pride &mdash; I am a Hindu') have propelled them to significant gains in municipal and other elections. 
 The controversy is also seriously embarrassing leaders of India's mainstream opposition alliance. 
 It is generally agreed that opposition success in the election will depend on a unified challenge to Congress, especially in the densely-populated Hindi-speaking states of the north. 
 Secular parties like the Janata Dal, led by a former Congress cabinet minister, VP Singh, are hoping to come to an election agreement with the powerful pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), to ensure that the opposition vote is not split. 
 But the Communists, Socialists and other secular groups in the opposition alliance appear increasingly disheartened both by the narrow religious chauvinism of the BJP and by its open links with even more extreme Hindu groups like the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and the Vishwa Hindu Parishad, which is spearheading the Ayodhya campaign. 
 Last week leaders of four left-wing parties accused the BJP of &bquo;spreading communal poison&equo; and urged the Janata Dal not to deal with it. 
 The opposition's difficulties have enabled Mr Gandhi to retrieve ground lost to the BJP. 
 He has been busily sowing further discord by congratulating the leftist parties for their stand while damning the BJP for their destructive policies. 
 The Congress-run state government in Uttar Pradesh has also moved to defuse Muslim ire by formally endorsing Urdu, spoken by most Muslims, as the official second language in the state. 
 Despite government efforts to strike a compromise enabling both mosque and temple to stand side-by-side in Ayodhya, the threat of a communal eruption remains. 
 Before this year, Ayodhya, a community of 30,000 Hindus and 2,000 Muslims, had never witnessed a religious clash. 
 &bquo;Dingo case&equo; duo claim 2.6m pounds 
 By TONY ALLEN-MILLS 
 DARWIN (AFP) &mdash; Lindy and Michael Chamberlain, the couple wrongly convicted of the murder of their baby in the &bquo;dingo case&equo;, are seeking dollars A5.38m (&pound;2.6m) compensation for nine years of hardship and legal costs, officials said yesterday. 
 Their nine-week-old daughter, Azaria, disappeared in August 1980, when the family was on a camping holiday near Ayers Rock. 
 The Northern Territory Attorney-General, Daryl Manzie, told the parliament in Darwin yesterday that he was denying the Chamberlains' request for confidentiality because the claim for legal expenses was almost double the figure given in a submission last year. 
 In 1982 Mrs Chamberlain was sentenced to life imprisonment for murder, while her husband was convicted as an accessory and given a suspended 18-month jail term. 
 Mrs Chamberlain, who insisted that a dingo had killed the baby, was released after three-and-a-half years in jail. 
 In September last year the couple's convictions were quashed. 
 Migrants row raises tension between China and Hong Kong 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 CHINA increased its patrols along the border with Hong Kong yesterday in an apparent effort to prevent an exodus of its people into the colony following a dispute over immigration procedures. 
 The dispute was triggered by Hong Kong's decision to allow the top Chinese swimmer, Yang Yang, who had sought political asylum in the West, to travel to the US last week. 
 However, the dispute reflects more the growing mistrust between the two sides rather than an argument over visas and numbers. 
 Hong Kong officials said negotiations with China to end the dispute were continuing and that the colony's border guards were in a state of &bquo;high alert&equo; in preparation for a possible influx. 
 Police sources said China had doubled its patrol on the border. 
 An official from the New China News Agency office, China's de facto embassy in Hong Kong, said no progress had been made in the negotiations and that an early solution was not expected. 
 He said Hong Kong must show its &bquo;sincerity&equo; before the dispute could be resolved. 
 On Sunday China refused to accept back from Hong Kong a group of 71 Chinese illegal immigrants, saying it was in retaliation for allowing Mr Yang, a pro-democracy activist, to leave for asylum in the US. 
 It subsequently accused Hong Kong of breaking a 1982 agreement on immigration and said it would handle returns on a case-by-case basis. 
 Already 206 Chinese are waiting to be repatriated. 
 Up to 100 Chinese a day have previously been repatriated. 
 Yesterday the Governor of Hong Kong, Sir David Wilson, said he was &bquo;concerned at the action the Chinese have taken&equo;, but argued that the decision to allow Mr Yang to travel to the West had not breached the 1982 agreement. 
 Sir David said: &bquo;In handling the Yang Yang case, which was a very difficult case because it was used by various groups for propaganda purposes, we have not in any way gone against the 1982 understanding.&equo; 
 The disagreement follows China's recent assertion that Britain was responsible for the crisis of confidence in Hong Kong and that Whitehall had &bquo;connived&equo; with locals who were attempting to overthrow the Chinese government. 
 Hong Kong's relations with China have grown increasingly sour in the wake of Peking's crack-down on the student-led pro-democracy movement in June. 
 China is angry over Hong Kong people's support for the democracy movement and some see the border dispute as an attempt by Peking to press the government to take action against the Hong Kong Alliance, a political group that has provided financial support to China's democracy movement. 
 Community leaders say China's latest act of &bquo;bloody-mindedness&equo; will further undermine Hong Kong's confidence. 
 Sir David will strive to bolster confidence today, when he gives his annual address at the opening of the new session of the Legislative Council. 
 He is expected to announce the construction of an airport costing &pound;640m, a project that will be hailed as evidence of Britain's confidence in Hong Kong's post-1997 future. 
 But he will probably avoid restating Britain's position that it is mainly China's responsibility to restore Hong Kong's confidence, and will instead urge locals to build the territory as a separate but valuable part of the &bquo;one country, two systems&equo; model under which it is to return to China. 
 Following Britain's recent dispute with China over the stationing of People's Liberation Army troops in Hong Kong after 1997, Whitehall has been at pains to keep its distance from the immigration row. 
 But Hong Kong people are keen that Britain should maintain a tough stance in its dealings with Peking. 
 Out of France: Crime news? 
 Just cherchez la femme&hellip; 
 By PATRICK MARNHAM 
 PARIS &mdash; The other day the window of the police station was open and an angry male voice could be heard shouting: &bquo;But you have to sign the statement, Madame.&equo; 
 Then there was a banging noise as of a large, hairy fist striking a desk. 
 Afterwards, nothing. 
 Silence. 
 No stifled sobs. 
 Just silence. 
 One was left to imagine the scene being played out inside the commissariat and the events which had led up to this incident. 
 Women are making such progress in the world of French crime that they sometimes seem to be monopolising the police report headlines. 
 Over in Nancy, Simone Weber, the so-called &bquo;Devil of Nancy&equo;, is now the undisputed record-holder for imprisonment on remand. 
 Next month she will have been locked up for 4 years without being charged or tried, while an examining magistrate struggles to assemble enough evidence to convict her of murdering first her husband and then her boyfriend. 
 The magistrate has two problems. 
 As far as the husband goes, he has the corpse but no clear evidence of murder. 
 With the boyfriend there is evidence that Mrs Weber killed him and chopped him up with a chain saw, but there is no corpse. 
 This week Mrs Weber's lawyers lodged the 18th application for her release on bail, and received the 18th refusal. 
 Then there is Christine Villemin, whose 4-year-old son Gregory was found near the village in the Vosges where he lived, floating in a river with his hands tied behind his back. 
 That too was four years ago. 
 First Mrs Villemin's husband's cousin, Bernard Laroche, was charged with the murder. 
 Then the examining magistrate changed his mind, released Mr Laroche and charged Mrs Villemin with killing her own son. 
 Then her husband Jean-Marie went round to Mr Laroche's house and shot him dead. 
 So then Jean-Marie was charged with his murder. 
 Then the original examining magistrate was dismissed from the case for making such a muddle of it. 
 Four years after the murder of &bquo;little Gregory&equo; his successor is still pondering the whole business, and until he makes up his mind Mrs Villemin cannot finally be cleared of all suspicion, and her husband cannot be tried for shooting Mr Laroche. 
 Mrs Villemin is the wife of a peasant farmer. 
 Mrs Weber is also from an unprivileged background. 
 These two women who have never been tried have become two of the stars of the French press's Chamber of Horrors. 
 They are now joined by a very different woman, Marie-Elisabeth Cons-Boutboul, who was charged on Monday with being an accessory to the murder of her son-in-law, who was found shot dead in the hallway of his Paris apartment block in 1985. 
 The case is made slightly untoward by the fact that both Mrs Cons-Boutboul and her former son-in-law were at one time barristers. 
 The prosecution's case against Mrs Cons-Boutboul is simple. 
 She is the mother of Darie Boutboul, celebrated as one of the leading female jockeys in France. 
 It is a fact that her son-in-law, the barrister Jacques Perrot, was in the process of divorcing her daughter. 
 He was trying to get custody of their only child. 
 In order to hamper his wife's objections to his custody application, Mr Perrot apparently tried to blackmail his mother-in-law. 
 He had a means of doing this since she was at the time in danger of being disbarred after allegations that she had defrauded a Catholic charity active in Africa. 
 Mrs Cons-Boutboul, it is said, therefore decided to have Mr Perrot bumped off. 
 She hired a hit-man from Le Havre called Bruno Dassac, once a member of the Zemour gang, and paid him about &pound;14,000 to do the job. 
 Mr Dassac, in his turn, was found shot dead with a bullet through his head last year. 
 Mrs Cons-Boutboul denies any connection with either murder. 
 But she also denied knowing Dassac, and the police subsequently discovered that she had had numerous telephone conversations with him and paid him large sums of money under a false name through a Swiss bank account. 
 Guilty or innocent, Mrs Cons-Boutboul, like Mrs Villemin and Mrs Weber, gives the impression of being an extremely tough nut. 
 Mrs Villemin had no difficulty in seeing off her first examining magistrate. 
 Mrs Weber has so far undergone 200 hours of questioning, and is admitting nothing. 
 No doubt all three ladies will have participated in many scenes such as the one recently overheard through the open window of the commissariat. 
 Chirac declares war on the car 
 From SARAH LAMBERT in Paris 
 PARIS is suffocating. 
 Like most large cities, it can no longer cope with the traffic that blocks the city centre almost all day and the Mayor of Paris, Jaques Chirac, presented a plan to the city fathers yesterday to restore the capital to its residents. 
 But the residents are the problem, or rather the lack of them. 
 People are leaving Paris at the rate of some 20,000 a year, chased out by soaring property prices and the shortage of rental accommodation &mdash; especially of flats big enough for a family. 
 The flight to the suburbs accelerates every year. 
 For every person who leaves Paris, two move to the suburbs; the Ile de France now has a population of some 10 million, most of whom work in the capital. 
 So, every day, some 3 million cars flood Paris and the peripherique &mdash; the ring-road built to by-pass the city centre &mdash; is often at a standstill in rush-hour. 
 The authorities have been grappling with the problem for a decade, but still the cars choke the cobbled streets. 
 Mr Chirac is tackling the effect rather than the cause of the problem. 
 His scheme involves eliminating 100,000 parking places and installing 15,000 parking-meters. 
 He has also ordered a crackdown on parking offences. 
 Some 65,000 cars a day are illegally parked and anyone unlucky enough to get caught in future could lose their driving licence for a time. 
 But the plan envisages the creation of 5,000 parking places a year and any new apartment block will have to provide more parking spaces than flats. 
 Of Paris's 950 miles of road, 200 miles carry 80 per cent of the traffic. 
 An underground toll road beneath the peripherique would ease congestion in the south and enable the creation of extra bus routes through the city centre. 
 The heart of Paris, around the Louvre and the Hotel de Ville, would be entirely reorganised with pedestrian zones, one-way systems and extra bus routes. 
 Once the huge car park near the Louvre is finished in 1991, tourist coaches will be banned from the centre. 
 Parisians remain unconvinced that the project will be approved, especially since it is not the only idea on the drawing board. 
 A private consortium has financial backing for a scheme to build an entire underground toll-road system. 
 Traffic would be directed through a double-decker tunnel 30ft in diameter sunk between 90 feet and 150 feet below ground. 
 Thirty exit points would take no more room than the entrance to a multi-storey car park and the tunnel would carry one three-lane &bquo;layer&equo; of cars travelling in one direction and a bottom &bquo;layer&equo; travelling in the other. 
 The Laser project, as it is known, has its supporters in the government though Mr Chirac is not one of them. 
 The political dimension makes any long-term transport project hard to carry out. 
 Responsibility for Paris's traffic problem falls upon the Interior Ministry and the Police department, not on the mayor &mdash; which Mr Chirac complains is &bquo;anachronistic&equo;. 
 Court orders UK to let back an armada 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Luxembourg 
 BRITAIN HAS been instructed by the European Community to suspend immediately key provisions of the 1988 Merchant Shipping Act, designed to repel a 100- strong armada of Spanish vessels fishing in United Kingdom waters. 
 In an urgent ruling yesterday, the European Court of Justice in Luxembourg ordered the government immediately to repeal specific clauses of the act which relate to the Spanish presence, on the grounds that they illegally discriminate against foreigners. 
 The provisions were incorporated in the act to prevent Spanish trawlers joining the UK shipping register and freely exploiting the fishing quotas which have been allocated to Britain each year since 1983 under the Common Fisheries Policy. 
 The effect of the act, which came into force in April this year, was to exclude almost 100 boats operated by Spanish owners, mostly in waters off the south-west coast of Britain. 
 Ireland has also taken action to expel the boats. 
 However, yesterday's ruling means that only about 10 of those boats will be able to resume operations immediately. 
 The court was considering only a limited application by the European Commission for the suspension of parts of the act considered to be most at odds with EC non-discrimination laws. 
 These stipulated that any person operating in British waters must not only be resident in Britain but should also be a British citizen and that the ship should be British-owned. 
 Both requirements will have to be repealed pending full court actions already under way in Luxembourg and London. 
 British officials sought to play down the significance of yesterday's move. 
 &bquo;Clearly we regret the court's ruling,&equo; one said. 
 &bquo;But the number of ships affected will be small and we underline the need for the Commission to find a long-term solution.&equo; 
 Baker invites Israel and Egypt to talks 
 From PAUL TAYLOR of Reuters 
 JERUSALEM &mdash; The US Secretary of State, James Baker, has invited the Israeli and Egyptian foreign ministers to Washington in an attempt to break a stalemate in the Middle East peace process. 
 But Israel has complicated US mediation efforts by demanding a veto over Palestinian representatives to peace talks. 
 Mr Baker proposed a meeting with Israel's Foreign Minister, Moshe Arens, and his Egyptian counterpart, Esmat Abdel-Maguid, after Israeli leaders last Friday rejected Egypt's invitation to meet a Palestinian delegation in Cairo. 
 &bquo;The problem is that Israel wants to choose both teams on the football field,&equo; a diplomat said. 
 Sources said Egypt, co-ordinating its actions with the Palestine Liberation Organisation (PLO), could not accept an Israeli veto. 
 Egypt has drafted a list of potential Palestinian delegates composed of PLO supporters from the occupied territories and deportees who are senior PLO activists. 
 President Hosni Mubarak has said any delegation would have to have PLO blessing. 
 Western diplomats in Cairo said yesterday that Washington had asked Egypt to persuade the PLO to accept the exclusion of Palestinians from outside the Israeli-occupied territories in such a delegation, but they felt that neither the PLO nor Egypt was likely to accept this. 
 In Jerusalem, a foreign ministry spokesman said: &bquo;One of our basic principles is that Israel will not agree to any move that will bring direct or indirect contact with the PLO.&equo; 
 He said this did not amount to a demand for a right of veto: &bquo;The principle we stick to is that the PLO will be totally out of the picture.&equo; 
 Sources close to the Prime Minister, Yitzhak Shamir, said while he welcomed greater US involvement, he had misgivings about the wording of Mr Baker's proposals, presented orally, because they did not ensure a clear-cut Israeli veto power. 
 Diplomats said Washington was reluctant to offer any formula in writing because this would mean taking sides. 
 Israel was also said to be determined that the agenda for a meeting with Palestinians be restricted to agreeing details of the conduct of elections in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. 
 Israel proposed in May that Palestinians in the occupied territories hold elections to choose delegates to discuss interim self-rule with Israel. 
 The Defence Minister, Yitzhak Rabin, whose Labour Party forced last Friday's inner cabinet vote on the Egyptian proposal, dismissed talk of a deadlock: &bquo;I have time and patience and I am not pessimistic,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Rabin said he favoured allowing some deportees to join the Palestinian delegation, but he ruled out the two deportees on the reported Egyptian list because they were PLO officials. 
 Captain Henrick Kurt Carlsen waves from the Flying Enterprise, which he refused to leave for seven days in 1951 as it foundered in the Channel after a storm. 
 From PAUL TAYLOR of Reuters 
 Captain Henrick Kurt Carlsen waves from the Flying Enterprise, which he refused to leave for seven days in 1951 as it foundered in the Channel after a storm. 
 His determination to prevent the vessel from being claimed for salvage earned him a bravery award from the US Congress. 
 He died on Saturday at the age of 75  
 Aliens in full 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 MOSCOW &mdash; Further details emerged yesterday of the reported visitation of alien beings to the Soviet city of Voronezh, writes Rupert Cornwell. 
 The newspaper Sovyetsyaka Kultura quoted Voronezh residents as saying that between 23-29 September they had repeatedly seen UFOs &mdash; including a three-eyed humanoid, a robot and a raygun which makes mere earthlings disappear. 
 The newspaper's local correspondent admitted that &bquo;it is hard to believe what happened, but there's no doubt that something did&equo;. 
 Bogota bombs 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 BOGOTA (Reuter) &mdash; Suspected drug traffickers set off 12 bombs, injuring 35 people, in the latest round of violence here linked to the country's cocaine war, authorities said. 
 In Medellin, two employees of the El Espectador newspaper were shot dead by gunmen. 
 Expulsion call 
 By SIMON STRONG 
 LIMA &mdash; Peru is to propose the expulsion of Panama from the so-called group of Eight at the third summit of Latin American presidents beginning today because of the refusal of its military dictator, General Antonio Noriega, to institute democracy, writes Simon Strong. 
 Strike mounts 
 By PATRICK MARNHAM 
 PARIS &mdash; French customs officers along the entire length of the Pyrenees announced yesterday that they were joining the 19-week-old strike by the country's tax collectors and would be closing the border to commercial traffic, writes Patrick Marnham. 
 Defendant faints 
 By PATRICK MARNHAM 
 ANKARA (Reuter) &mdash; A Turkish schoolboy who had scratched the word &bquo;Marxism&equo; on his desk fainted when he was cleared of spreading communist propaganda, after spending a year in prison and psychiatric hospitals. 
 The state prosecutor had demanded Melih Calayoglu be sent to jail for at least five years. 
 Greek poll 
 By PETER THOMPSON 
 ATHENS &mdash; The Greek President, Christos Sartzetakis, is today expected to name the Supreme Court President, Yannis Grivas, as Premier of a caretaker government until elections on 5 November, writes Peter Thompson. 
 Despite talks with party leaders yesterday, Mr Sartzetakis failed to find a way out of the impasse created by the resignation on Saturday of a conservative-communist coalition government which was formed in July. 
 Galileo fears 
 By PETER THOMPSON 
 WASHINGTON (Reuter, AP) &mdash; Opponents of NASA's plan to launch 48 pounds of plutonium in the power pack of the Galileo space probe, said it could cause a nuclear accident worse than Chernobyl. 
 Galileo is scheduled to be launched tomorrow on the space shuttle Atlantis, but opponents went to court yesterday in an attempt to stop it. 
 At the same time, NASA reported an engine problem that could ground the shuttle launch. 
 Troops order 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 MOSCOW &mdash; The Supreme Soviet voted the government an extension of its powers to send in troops if necessary, to restore order to the railways of Transcaucasia, thrown into chaos by Azerbaijan's blockade of neighbouring Armenia, writes Rupert Cornwell. 
 Fears of fresh fighting between the now entirely separated Armenian and Azeri communities within Nagorny Karabakh itself have been heightened by discovery of an arms cache hidden aboard an Armenian helicopter, which landed on Sunday in a football stadium in the Armenian-controlled section of the enclave. 
 Mujahedin barrage kills 23 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 ISLAMABAD (UPI, Reuter) &mdash; Mujahedin guerrillas fired five rockets at Kabul yesterday, killing 23 people at a bus stop, Radio Kabul reported. 
 The barrage was the most devastating in a series of recent rocket attacks on Kabul by the Western-backed mujahedin. 
 The New York Times reported that Soviet military advisers wearing Afghan army uniforms were supervising and firing Scud missiles on behalf of the Kabul government at mujahedin positions, possibly in violation of the Geneva accords. 
 The newspaper quoted a confidential US government document that said &bquo;all functions connected with the security, transportation, storage and launch of the Soviet-supplied Scuds were handled by Soviet advisers&equo;. 
 Nusrat Bhutto, Pakistan's deputy prime minister who is leading its delegation to the UN General Assembly, said in New York that Moscow had agreed to talk to the mujahedin on the establishment of an interim government in Kabul that would involve the present Soviet-backed administration. 
 Local officials press Honecker for reform 
 From EDWARD STEEN in West Berlin 
 WHILE the East German leadership yesterday remained defiantly committed to another Tiananmen Square if need be, local party officials increasingly called for openness and dialogue with the opposition. 
 The confused evidence suggests they are acting on their own initiative, not on directives from East Berlin to play for time. 
 In Dresden, long known for a softer line than elsewhere, the Mayor, Wolfgang Berghofer, announced after talks with 20 church and New Forum opposition activists that he was willing to discuss their nine-point proposal, and release anyone arrested who was not accused of violence within 24 hours. 
 The proposal deals with basic demands such as freedom of travel and of the press. 
 Although Mr Berghofer reportedly said he was &bquo;not competent&equo; to negotiate legalising the banned New Forum group, he said he too wanted &bquo;elections to be elections again'. 
 Also in Dresden, police yesterday released 500 protesters held after the past week's unrest. 
 In East Berlin, the well-known opposition figure, Pastor Rainer Eppelmann, said the talks set an example for the whole country, and called for a two-week period of calm on the streets. 
 But church leaders denied a West German radio report that the Church had struck a deal with the authorities to stop the demonstrations. 
 News of the Dresden talks was announced to some 20,000 people packing churches there, and was broadcast on the city tannoy system in Leipzig on Monday afternoon. 
 It is thought to have helped calm tension. 
 Church sources in Leipzig were delighted by the extraordinary joint declaration of three local party secretaries and the city's director of music, Kurt Masur. 
 It read in part: &bquo;We all need a free exchange of views about how Socialism is to be continued in this country.&equo; 
 Newspapers, apart from the party paper Neues Deutschland, began to drop the pretence that the troubles were not the main concern throughout the country. 
 The Union, organ of the puppet Christian Democratic Union Party, even admitted giving a one-sided picture of them. 
 It was not right, it said, to criminalise &bquo;the unrest, worries and questions which drove thousands of Dresdeners on to the streets&equo;. 
 The usually ultra-orthodox organ of the Free German Youth (FDJ), which on Monday attacked &bquo;pervasive bossiness&equo; by the President of the Writers' Union, Herrman Kant, quoted a sermon in the opposition centre, Leipzig's church. 
 It ridiculed those who still thought the Berlin Wall was &bquo;a piece of benevolence&equo;. 
 People had been waiting for years for freedom &bquo;and they've now had enough&equo;. 
 It is all in stark contrast to the two pages Neues Deutschland devoted to feting the &bquo;fundamental lesson&equo; to be learned from China, and showing demonstrators to be vicious thugs. 
 One group was quoted as ranting at a young police woman: &bquo;We're going to cut your belly open. 
 We'll remember your face.&equo; 
 As in previous attacks on the protesters, the real agents provocateurs are said to be the Western media egging on the rabble. 
 Curbs fail to halt flood of refugees 
 By PATRICIA CLOUGH 
 BONN &mdash; As the net of restrictions which prevents East Germans leaving their country grows tighter, the flow of refugees through the few remaining gaps continues steadily, writes Patricia Clough. 
 Another 479 people crossed the Hungarian border into Austria in the 24 hours ending Tuesday morning while the number who have taken refuge in the West German embassy in Warsaw is now around 500. 
 Another 30 are in the embassy in Prague. 
 It looks as if roughly 130,000 East Germans have emigrated, illegally or legally, to the West this year. 
 By the end of September, the number was 110,184, of whom 71,355 came with full permission of the authorities. 
 Since then, about 13,000 who took refuge in the Prague and Warsaw embassies have been transported to the West while 450 to 1,200 have been crossing daily through Hungary. 
 Most of the refugees who arrived after Hungary opened its border with Austria on 11 September, and aboard the special trains last week, have been taken to reception camps where they are given West German citizenship papers and DM200 (&pound;66). 
 Many quickly join relatives or friends living here, while the rest go to transitional camps set up by the Land governments. 
 There they wait until they have found housing and jobs. 
 Meanwhile they have all the benefits of West German social security &mdash; unemployment pay, health insurance and so on. 
 Jobs, government officials say, are much less of a problem than is housing. 
 E German clerics strive for peaceful change: Patricia Clough in Bonn examines the intermediary role played by the Protestant Church during the exodus to the West 
 By PATRICIA CLOUGH 
 IF EAST GERMANY finally sets out on the path to reform without further bloodshed and repression, it will be largely thanks to the efforts of the Protestant church. 
 Church leaders have been tirelessly urging the country's leaders to find out why thousands have been fleeing and pleading with would-be refugees to stay and work for change. 
 They have been protecting dissident groups and appealing for non-violence. 
 Prayer meetings in the great barn-like churches of East Berlin, Dresden, Leipzig and other cities have been the focus of protest, drawing many thousands of people until no more could squeeze in and the crowds spilled into the streets. 
 Often these were the starting points of big demonstrations which were broken up by the police. 
 East Berlin church leaders, for instance, issued &bquo;Four Urgent Pleas&equo; on Monday night &mdash; the first being an appeal to East Germans &bquo;from now on to exercise freedom of speech fearlessly, so that the discussion of our future can begin.&equo; 
 The second plea was to the regime for &bquo;clear and convincing steps&equo; towards putting the country on a just, democratic and socialist course. 
 Police and security forces were urged to exercise the &bquo;greatest possible restraint&equo; in face of the &bquo;impatience of critical citizens&equo; and reformists were begged not to take part in unauthorised demonstrations. 
 Individual pastors have helped to found some of the numerous opposition groups while bishops have intervened to put an end to confrontations between the police and reformers. 
 While the Protestant church, like the Polish Catholic church, has played an important role in the efforts for reform, the nature and situations of the two churches could hardly be more different. 
 While the Polish church has always been a vital element in the Poles' national identity, neither the Protestant nor the Catholic churches in Germany &mdash; much less East Germany &mdash; have ever had this function. 
 And while the Polish church is conservative and traditionalist, the Union of Evangelical Churches in the German Democratic Republic is composed of radical churches founded by the great Reformation leaders, Luther, Calvin and Zwingli. 
 There is now little difference between them: they focus on the Bible, on preaching and on the importance of the individual conscience. 
 (The much smaller East German Catholic church is conservative and less active in political life, but has also recently urged reforms.) 
 The union or Bund is composed of eight regional churches, each run on relatively democratic lines with synods and councils in which lay members play a prominent part. 
 Women pastors have long been regarded as something quite normal. 
 The root of the East German church's involvement lies in the agonising sense of guilt and self-accusation among many clergy during and after the Second World War for not having spoken out against the Nazis in time. 
 With heroic individual exceptions, both the Protestant and Catholic churches supported Hitler and, in East Germany in particular, were determined that such a thing should never happen again. 
 During the harsh, repressive years after the war, life was extremely difficult as the Communist regime actively preached atheism and railed against outdated &bquo;superstitions&equo;. 
 With Ostpolitik and acceptance of the division of Germany in the late Sixties the church removed one of the worst bones of contention by leaving the pan-German Evangelical Church. 
 It formed the Bund and committed itself to a critical modus vivendi with the state by declaring itself to be a &bquo;church within socialism&equo;. 
 Members still suffer for their faith, for instance, by being denied university education or worthwhile jobs. 
 Both the church and the Communist Party ban dual membership. 
 No one, including the church itself, knows how many members it has. 
 The most common estimate is between 3.5 million and 4 million, with the Catholic church at around 1 million out of a population of almost 17 million. 
 But the regime allows the church itself considerable freedom, perhaps as a kind of safety valve. 
 Its leaders and pastors have long been the only people who can say what they think; its press, although censored, is freer than the state media and its synods and congresses are the only places where people can openly discuss the problems in the country. 
 Adversity breeds a special kind of Christian and it has remarkable members who devote their lives to helping, for instance, people abandoned by the state, such as punks, conscientious objectors or would-be emigrants. 
 The church is not a political opposition &mdash; its present, more vocal, leaders would be happy with a freer, more democratic and humane form of socialism. 
 But it believes it must take its message into all areas of life, to press causes, such an end to official silence on environmental problems, an investigation into glaring election fraud and above all an honest look at why so many are leaving. 
 Bankers agree on cure for Soviet economic ills 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 SEPARATED BY just a few miles in distance and a few hours in time, the West's most powerful central banker and the Soviet prime minister were yesterday at one: immediate and full scale price reform would only confront the Soviet Union with runaway inflation. 
 This notable agreement between men who might be supposed to represent the opposite poles of economic ideology came on a day when Prime Minister Nikolai Ryzhkov disclosed grim new evidence of wage inflation here, and Dr Alan Greenspan, the visiting chairman of the US Federal Reserve Board, wound up three days of discussions with Soviet ministers, bankers and economists. 
 The similarity of their views &mdash; if only on that one key point &mdash; is a measure of how the superpower thaw is extending from arms control to economic matters as well. 
 It testifies both to a new realism in Moscow's approach to the country's profound economic crisis, and acknowledgement by the Western financial community that red-blooded free market therapy cannot alone provide the answer. 
 Naturally, the emphases were different. 
 Addressing the Supreme Soviet during a debate on emergency price curbs, Mr Ryzhkov was far blunter than a man accustomed to the velvety circumlocutions and understatements, second nature to Western central bankers. 
 Over the third quarter of this year, he told parliament, output by Soviet industry had risen at a rate of one per cent while wages were soaring at an annual pace of 15 per cent. 
 &bquo;We are not against pay rises, but people have got to sensible,&equo; he said, defending the three per cent ceiling on pay rises which has just come into force here. 
 Mr Ryzhkov made plain the government would steer a middle course between the two extreme strategies on offer &mdash; unbridled market economics and a return to the discredited command economy of the Stalin and Brezhnev eras, buttressed in the current emergency by a broad price freeze. 
 &bquo;Neither course is acceptable,&equo; he said. 
 Blanket price controls would destroy the very basis of economic reform, but reliance on market mechanisms alone would unleash a price explosion. 
 &bquo;Now we argue whether inflation is three, four or five per cent. 
 If we fall back on market laws in our present position, this figure could multiply tens of times.&equo; 
 Instead, the government intends to resist pressure from the unions for a freeze, and separate suggestions for a generalised rationing system. 
 Its preference is for measures to &bquo;stabilise the consumer market&equo;, which would include strict controls on various key commodities. 
 Detailed proposals are likely later this month. 
 Dr Greenspan made his comments at a press conference after meetings with officials including Leonid Abalkin, the deputy prime minister in charge of economic reform, the state bank chairman (and his notional Soviet opposite number) Viktor Gerashchenko and Valentin Pavlov, the finance minister. 
 He is not the first Federal Reserve chairman to visit Moscow, but never can one have been paid as much attention. 
 Diplomatic throughout, Dr Greenspan insisted that he was no expert on the Soviet economy, and had not come to offer instant solutions. 
 Central banker to the core, he would not entertain the notion of crisis. 
 &bquo;I did not get the impression they were reaching out for help, there was not a general mood of crisis.&equo; 
 Had he met anyone to be considered a socialist, he was asked. 
 There was a long pause and then a smile: &bquo;I assume I did.&equo; 
 Britain warns against faith in &bquo;liberal Tsars&equo; 
 By JOHN BULLOCH, Diplomatic Editor 
 WILLIAM WALDEGRAVE, Minister of State at the Foreign Office, called yesterday for the improvement in human rights in the Soviet Union to be codified into law. 
 They should not depend on the personal commitment of one leader, he said. 
 &bquo;There have been liberal Tsars before.&equo; 
 Speaking at an Amnesty International meeting in Blackpool, Mr Waldegrave said that up to a few years ago the Soviet Union's record was appalling and its policy unyielding. 
 But today things were changing, with Mikhail Gorbachev trying to renew Soviet society and create a better life for the people. 
 Yesterday, the Soviet Union blamed Britain for the cancellation of a visit by a human rights delegation, saying British officials insisted on sending Mr Michael Bourdeaux of Keston College &mdash; someone they knew would not be given a Soviet visa. 
 Earlier, Mr Waldegrave had said that &bquo;We could not, of course, allow the Russians arbitrarily to exclude an expert in a key area of human rights from our delegation&hellip; 
 I hope the decision will be reversed; if not, it could prove a poor omen for the way in which the Soviet authorities will approach the 1991 Human Rights conference in Moscow.&equo; 
 However, Mr Waldegrave did concede that many abuses were ending, and the human rights provisions of the Helsinki agreement had become a useful yardstick to measure Soviet behaviour. 
 Jewish emigration continued to increase, and this year 33,000 people had left the Soviet Union, nearly double the figure for the whole of 1988. 
 Of that number, 6,776 left in August, the highest monthly total so far. 
 Yet the Soviet authorities had not fulfilled their commitment made during the recent Vienna conference to resolve all outstanding cases within six months. 
 Mr Waldegrave said Britain was continuing to press Moscow over long-term &bquo;refusenik&equo; cases, and had achieved a reasonable response, with more than 70 per cent of cases raised being resolved. 
 But many had not been settled, and Britain had a list of 50 names it had presented to the Soviet authorities. 
 Mr Gorbachev had said there were no longer prisoners convicted for political or religious beliefs, and most prisoners of conscience known to the West had been released. 
 But a number of citizens remained in prison or labour camps on the flimsiest of pretexts, and the West would continue to press their cases, Mr Waldegrave said. 
 Budapest apparatchiks contemplate the dole 
 From IMRE KARACS in Budapest 
 THE GOLD lettering on the socialist-realist facade of the White House overlooking the Danube was still there yesterday morning as hundreds of bureaucrats showed up for work. 
 But the building no longer belonged to the Hungarian Socialist Workers' Party, and the apparatchiks, once the backbone of the party state, were contemplating the possibility of unemployment for the first time in their lives. 
 In the middle of the night, the ruling party's congress wound up its work with a resolution to hand back to the state all superfluous assets. 
 Though it failed to define the new Socialist Party's financial needs, the party's holiday homes, hotels and hunting lodges were obvious targets for re-nationalisation. 
 &bquo;I cannot see how they are going to pay all of us from membership dues,&equo; an embittered party bureaucrat said at headquarters, adding that most of them would have to be given six months' notice. 
 Congress was not able to address that question because the delegates ran out of time. 
 But they rushed through another resolution surrendering control of the 60,000-strong Workers' Guard to the government. 
 Ferenc Glatz, the Minister of Culture, told The Independent that the government, at its meeting on Sunday, had already decided to disband the old party's private army. 
 A formal announcement will be made in Parliament by the end of the month. 
 &bquo;This party now has a programme and will have an internal structure of which any West European socialist party would be proud,&equo; Imre Pozsgay, the party's candidate for next month's presidential candidate, said. 
 He denied that any hardliners would be expelled, expressing the hope that &bquo;they will decide to join a party which still clings to the idea of the dictatorship of the proletariat&equo;. 
 Last night, reformers were still waiting for their wish to be fulfilled. 
 While a lunatic fringe was organising a new party, leading conservatives such as Karoly Grosz, the outgoing General Secretary, and Janos Berecz, the former ideologist, were refusing to reveal their intentions. 
 Mr Berecz said he still considered himself a member of the old party and refused to recognise the new one &mdash; despite voting for its establishment &mdash; but did not rule out the possibility of seeking admission to it. 
 He is bound to realise he can hurt the reformists most by joining them. 
 The dilemma facing Hungary's allies is even more serious. 
 Congress delegates waited in vain for the congratulatory telegram from Moscow when the new party was formed. 
 In May last year, Mr Gorbachev's cable arrived several minutes before Karoly Grosz's election to the leadership was announced. 
 This time, the new name deserved no greetings. 
 Two days later, when Rezso Nyers was elected president, he received Mr Gorbachev's personal greetings. 
 Conspicuously absent from the telegram were any of the customary &bquo;fraternal&equo; formulas. 
 But whatever reservations Moscow may have about the latest changes in Budapest, Mr Gorbachev must be aware that the old party would have been annihilated in next year's elections. 
 Mr Nyers and his reformists now stand a very good chance of becoming the biggest party in the new parliament. 
 In one of his congress speeches, Mr Nyers drew the curious analogy with the collapse of the Fourth Republic in France, and &bquo;democracy&equo; by General de Gaulle. 
 The Hungarian Socialist Party, he said, now faces the even greater task of creating democracy in a country run dictatorially for decades, in full awareness of the possibility of being devoured by its creation. 
 Militias submit to power of the flower 
 By STEVE CRAWSHAW, East Europe Editor 
 AS 70,000 East Germans streamed through Leipzig on Monday night in the largest demonstration the German Democratic Republic has ever seen, a few marchers approached the line of the workers' militia units, on standby in a side-street there. 
 A young woman put a flower into the buttonhole of one of the militia. 
 He recoiled in apparent disgust. 
 But his colleague received the flower gracefully. 
 And then a series of extraordinary dialogues began between the woman and the militia, and with groups of demonstrators who clustered round the militias, all along the street. 
 They chatted, almost amicably, about the need for change. 
 Just an hour or so earlier, many demonstrators had been worried by rumours that the workers' militia might open fire on the crowds. 
 There was a climate of fear after anonymous tip-offs claiming that live weapons would be used. 
 In the event, the authorities refrained from violence. 
 So far, so good. 
 All credit to the authorities in Leipzig who made a clear decision not to intervene. 
 The local party leadership even broadcast messages, applauded by the marchers, calling for dialogue. 
 Until then, almost every demonstration had been broken up. 
 But the moral for the East German leadership is worrying. 
 If 70,000 dared to go on the streets feeling they might be beaten up or worse, how many might demonstrate if that fear is removed? 
 Most provocative of all is how unprovocative are the slogans. 
 The truth is that a whiff of counter-revolution is hard to find &mdash; dismaying though that may be for party propagandists. 
 In one window of the Nikolaikirche with the burning candles and the flowers for those arrested, was a slogan demanding: &bquo;All power to the people &mdash; for a democratic, more human socialism.&equo; 
 Even the churchmen, closely tied to the opposition, stress they do not wish to be seen as &bquo;anti-Communist&equo;. 
 Among many demonstrators, with their calls for &bquo;Freedom!&equo; and &bquo;We stay here!&equo;, there remains an attachment to some aspects of life in East Germany: perhaps best described as socialism with a very small s. 
 Popular attitudes in the German Democratic Republic remain full of contradictions, however. 
 Some may indeed dream of a united Germany: few believe it is politic to speak or even think of such a thing. 
 Those bold enough to put their heads above the parapet &mdash; still by no means the majority &mdash; feel that to make demands even for basic freedoms is radical, in the present climate. 
 If the calls for change are allowed to build up peacefully in Leipzig, then there will clearly be an escalation in the number of those who press for change. 
 But if the authorities return to violent methods resentment will grow even more, and could explode violently. 
 There would be little chance of continuing to see flowers in militias' buttonholes. 
 Court Circular 
 By STEVE CRAWSHAW, East Europe Editor 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 10 October: The Duchess of York, President of Action Research for the Crippled Child, this morning visited the Duncan Guthrie Institute at the Royal Hospital for Sick Children, Glasgow. 
 Her Royal Highness was received by The Right Honourable The Lord Provost of Glasgow (Mrs Susan Baird). 
 Afterwards, The Duchess of York, Patron of Museums Year 1989, opened the Customs and Excise Museum and Exhibition at HM Customs and Excise Custom House, Greenock, and was received by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Renfrewshire (Major JDM Crichton Maitland). 
 Her Royal Highness travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight and was attended by Mrs Harry Cotterell. 
 10 October: The Prince Edward this evening attended a gala performance of Buddy at the Victoria Palace Theatre, London, in aid of the Sharon Allen Leukaemia Trust. 
 Major William McLean was in attendance. 
 10 October: The Princess Royal this morning visited Hampshire and was received on arrival by Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Hampshire (Lieutenant-Colonel Sir James Scott Bt). 
 Her Royal Highness visited The Elizabeth Foundation, Southwick, Portsmouth. 
 In the afternoon Her Royal Highness opened Whitbread Brewery's new depot at Hedge End, Southampton. 
 Afterwards The Princess Royal opened the new hostel development at Sparsholt College, Sparsholt, Winchester. 
 Her Royal Highness travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 In the evening The Princess Royal, President, The Save the Children Fund, attended the Industry and Commerce Group Reception at Buckingham Palace for Patrons of the 70th Anniversary Training Appeal. 
 Subsequently The Princess Royal, President, REDR &mdash; Engineers for Disaster Relief, attended the Vice-Presidents Dinner at the Institution of Civil Engineers, Great George Street, London. 
 Her Royal Highness was attended by Mrs Malcolm Wallace. 
 Mrs George West, Lieutenant-Commander Patrick Jephson RN and Mr Richard Arbiter were in attendance. 
 10 October: The Duchess of Gloucester, Patron of Asthma Research Council, today opened the Department of Allergy and Allied Respiratory Disorders at Guy's Hospital, London SE1. 
 Mrs Michael Wigley was in attendance. 
 YORK HOUSE 10 October: The Duke of Kent, President of the Royal National Lifeboat Institution, this afternoon received the Duke of Atholl upon relinquishing his appointment as Chairman. 
 The Duke and Duchess of Kent this evening attended a Gala Evening in aid of the Council for the Protection of Rural England at the Royal Festival Hall. 
 Their Royal Highnesses were attended by Mr Andrew Palmer and Mrs Alan Henderson. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Princess of Wales, Patron, The Natural History Museum, attends the launch of the Natural History Museum Development Trust at the Natural History Museum, Cromwell Road, London SW7. 
 The Princess Royal, Patron, College of Occupational Therapists, opens the College's new headquarters, Information &amp; Study Centre at 6-8 Marshalsea Road, London SE1; opens the Young Designers' Centre, The Design Council, 28 Haymarket, London SW1; visits the Headquarters of The Special Escort Group at their Barnes Headquarters, London SW13; and, this evening, attends a Banquet at the Guildhall given by the Worshipful Company of Framework Knitters to celebrate the 400th anniversary of the invention of the knitting frame by William Lee. 
 Princess Margaret, President of the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children, opens the Hertfordshire Child Protection Team's Unit, Hemel Hempstead. 
 The Duchess of Gloucester, as Patron, visits the offices of Counsel and Care for the Elderly, at 16 Bonny Street, London NW1. 
 The Duchess of Kent attends a Thanksgiving Service to mark the 150th Anniversary of the foundation of the West of England School for Children with Little or No Sight in Exeter Cathedral. 
 Obituary: Daan Van Der Meulen 
 By ARTHUR IRVINE 
 DAAN VAN DER MEULEN is best known in English-speaking circles as the first reliable explorer of the Wadi Hadhramaut in South Africa, a little-known, wild region, riven by tribal feuds, hardly explored, and fraught with danger for the outsider; though he himself would probably have liked to be remembered equally for his services in the Dutch colonial administration in Sumatra. 
 Van Der Meulen was an austere, patriarchal figure, deeply imbued with the rigidly Calvinist outlook he had acquired from his father, a schoolmaster in a small village near the German frontier. 
 At an early age he developed a desire for foreign travel and it was the Dutch East Indies which first attracted him. 
 He grew up in an age when the youth of the Netherlands were preoccupied with the tales of oppression and corruption in the colonial service revealed some 50 years earlier by the writings of ED Dekker (writing as &bquo;Multatuli&equo;). 
 Moved to rectify this situation, he abandoned plans of working in the missionary field, and offered his services to the Netherlands Indies civil service. 
 His first posting in 1915 took him to the Toba Batak country in Northern Sumatra in time to witness the Muslim Acehnese rising against their Christian rulers; an event which made him appreciate the approaching crisis of Islam as a focus for nationalism, and impressed upon him the urgent need for Muslim-Christian accommodation. 
 Further postings gave him experience of Muslims and heathens in Central Sumatra, and he finally became Resident Adviser to the Netherlands East India government at Batavia (1945-48). 
 Throughout Van Der Meulen's long career, his primary concern was that of peaceful co-existence and co-operation in a region where a Muslim majority had to live in close proximity to large communities of Christians and pagans. 
 He viewed the establishment of mutual recognition and trust as a prerequisite for the future prosperity of the region and was largely responsible for its realisation with the creation of the non-Islamic Republic of Indonesia. 
 The Dutch administration had long seen the need for consular representation in Jedda, the port of Mecca, where the security, health and transport of large numbers of Indonesian pilgrims could be supervised by the Batavian authorities. 
 In 1923 Van Der Meulen applied for the post of consul there and was selected for a three-year training in Arabic and Islam by the great Leiden Arabist, Snouck Hurgronje. 
 His studies in Leiden proved congenial to him and he developed a love for Arabia and Islam, which he felt provided a solid background for his Calvinist faith. 
 His arrival in Jedda in 1926 coincided with the expulsion of the Hashemites from the Hijaz and their replacement by the strict Wahhabis under King Ibn Saud. 
 He thus witnessed the birth of Saudi Arabia and could observe its growth and development at a crucial period in its history. 
 By the time he left in 1931 it was clear to him that there was a need for the Dutch to establish trading and cultural links not only with Saudi Arabia but with the Yemen and Hadhramaut, and most of his subsequent career in Arabia was devoted to this end. 
 Van Der Meulen's austere but charming character was to stand him in good stead with the Saudis. 
 He developed good relations, often deep friendships, with prominent figures of the time, including Ibn Saud, who frequently sought his advice and from whom Van Der Meulen was able to obtain a number of concessions for the Dutch. 
 This last relationship is poignantly chronicled in his Faces in Shem (1961). 
 Van Der Meulen's reputation as an explorer was founded in 1931 when, at the close of his first posting to Jedda, he was commissioned by the Dutch Ministry for Foreign Affairs to explore the mysterious Wadi Hadhramaut. 
 The Dutch interest there was inspired by the presence in the East Indies of large numbers of Hadhramis who had emigrated there to make their fortunes. 
 Accompanied by his close friend the German geographer Hermann von Wissmann, he set out from the port of Mukalla and visited the cities of Shibam, Saywun and Tarim, closely studying the society and minutely describing the topography, geology, flora and fauna of the valley. 
 His account of the journey, Hadhramaut, some of its mysteries unveiled (1931), immediately became a landmark in the description of Arabia. 
 A further exploration with von Wissmann in 1939 took him from Aden, through the almost unknown highlands to the north-east as far as the Wadi Jirdan and on into Hadhramaut, the results appearing in his Aden to the Hadhramaut (1947). 
 Van Der Meulen has been characterised as a good explorer rather than as a great one. 
 There is some truth in this. 
 His vision was direct, concrete and simple and he recorded faithfully the accidents of every-day life. 
 He possessed the true explorer's curiosity but did not bring to his journeys his own creative touch. 
 As a diplomat and administrator he really belonged to the Imperialist age before the discovery of oil and could be rather paternalistic in his attitudes. 
 He was prepared to vindicate the bombing of South Arabian villages by the RAF as necessary for the pacification of the country. 
 He also had a high opinion of British travellers and officials but felt that they were not dedicated, or good examples of Christian virtues; they had not been chosen for their moral worth and were likely to be judged by Muslims in that light. 
 His 1939 journey took place at a time when anti-British sentiments were beginning to reach Hadhramaut from Cairo and there was increasing criticism of the privileges of sayyid rulers. 
 Van Der Meulen realised that change had to come but he was surely saddened by the way it happened. 
 Obituary: Ian Scott-Kilvert 
 By ARTHUR FOSS 
 IAN SCOTT-KILVERT, writer, editor, translator and Director of the British Council's Department of Publications and Recorded Sound from 1962 to 1967, devoted his considerable energies to an unusually wide range of interests, which he pursued with quiet determination and unswerving loyalty. 
 His war service after Cambridge, where he was an exhibitioner at Gonville and Caius College and gained a first in English, pointed the way to his future career. 
 His duties with the Friends' Ambulance Unit in the Western Desert reinforced a desire to give service. 
 Later joining the intelligence corps, his attachment to Special Operations Executive in German-occupied north-west Greece and afterwards with the British Information Service in Athens gave him an abiding affection for and an understanding of the Hellenic scene. 
 His achievements were considerable. 
 While at the British Council, which he joined in 1946, he was responsible for the recording of Shakespeare's plays, under the direction of George Rylands. 
 He was also general editor of an important series of pamphlets, &bquo;Writers and Their Works&equo;, each containing an essay on an author and an extended checklist of his or her work (those for John Webster and AE Housman he wrote himself); Scribner's, the New York publishers, later collected these in eight volumes. 
 He also became one of the small group of scholars who translated from the classics for Penguin Books, for which he contributed versions of Plutarch, Polybius and Dio Cassius. 
 Scott-Kilvert showed his affection for Greece by serving for many years on the council and executive committee of the Anglo-Hellenic League, in due course becoming honorary secretary. 
 He was one of the three judges of the league's annual &pound;1,000 Runciman Award for a book about Greece. 
 Greece also stimulated his interest in Byron, first aroused while at school in Harrow. 
 He was responsible for the British Council's highly successful Byron exhibition in Athens in 1974, a timely reminder of the long-standing friendship between the two countries. 
 He later became joint chairman of the UK Byron Society and joint president of the International Byron Society; in this capacity he chaired international Byron symposia in Cambridge and Athens, on one occasion conducting members in the footsteps of Byron's Childe Harold to Epirus, into which he had parachuted in summer 1944. 
 He also composed dramatic entertainment for the society in London. 
 Scott-Kilvert's other interests included membership of the European-Atlantic Group, becoming a committee member in 1984 and an executive editor of its Journal. 
 He was a Fellow of the Royal Society of Literature: his last few weeks before his death from cancer, which he fought uncomplainingly and with great courage, were spent in devising an entertainment, &bquo;The French Revolution through British Eyes&equo;, for the RSL. 
 Two years ago he became chairman of the Wednesday Club, at which writers, publishers and others of note meet fortnightly for luncheon. 
 This, together with his membership of the Athenaeum and the Beefsteak show how much he was liked and respected. 
 Quiet and modest in manner, speaking with an occasional stutter, his initiative, absolute reliability and willingness to help in the humblest duties endeared him to his many friends, not only in the literary world. 
 He had gained a half-Blue for athletics at Cambridge, was a member of the MCC and played tennis regularly at Hurlingham until stricken by illness. 
 Obituary: The Rev Hugh Bishop 
 By ALAN WEBSTER 
 HUGH BISHOP was one of the most significant Anglicans of his generation. 
 As a Mirfield monk his strong profile, cassocked figure and deep resonant voice had power among universities, schools and parishes. 
 After a crisis in his life in 1974, his ministry in Leeds and London led women and men, archbishops and students to his home, meeting an increasingly gentle, humane and wise priest, who might greet his visitors in an apron preparing the meal. 
 Some of Hugh Bishop's confidence came from being a countryman from a secure Shropshire home, safe among those &bquo;blue remembered hills&equo;. 
 History at Oxford and theological training at Cuddesdon increased his assurance. 
 In his earlier years he could counsel priests to celibacy and doubters to Catholic dogma with almost papal infallibility, untroubled by a fiance's feelings or a questioner's uncertainties. 
 As a retreat conductor, preacher and speaker for religious communities in the Assembly and the Synod he had few rivals. 
 The shocks of ministry changed him. 
 In early years as a curate at Workington, the cruelties of the means test for taxation shook him into protest. 
 After capture at Tobruk as a chaplain he listened as well as lectured and poured himself out as father, brother and friend, empathising with the religious difficulties of his fellow prisoners which gnawed away at the rigid Anglo-Catholicism of more sheltered days. 
 Easter Day 1945 found him in the darkness of a cattle truck in a German railway tunnel; there was a true resurrection moment when prisoners were allowed out in to the sunshine and flowers of the railway cutting. 
 On demob Bishop returned to the Community, holding a series of offices and attracting many fresh novices. 
 Visiting his brethren in Southern Rhodesia he attacked apartheid in a sermon in Salisbury Cathedral so directly that he was deported and declared an &bquo;undesirable visitor&equo; by the UDI regime. 
 This incident sharpened his radical catholicism. 
 He had already accepted the need for reunion of churches in South India and agreed with Archbishop Michael Ramsey's view that risks should be taken for the sake of Gospel. 
 So he supported reunion with Methodists and believed that it was Canute-like to oppose the ordination of women. 
 In his theology &mdash; largely spoken: all his four books were printed addresses -he had begun to experience what John Hick describes as a &bquo;Copernican revolution&equo;. 
 Always committed to God, the sacrament and prayer, he became agnostic about much else. 
 For him Mirfield felt claustrophobic, a position no longer consonant with his role as Superior. 
 After much consultation with the Archbishop and with his approval he resigned in 1974 to continue his ministry first in Leeds and afterwards in London living with a friend, Dr Robert Towler. 
 Bishop's change in theological position and his abandonment of monastic life both caused sorrow to his community. 
 He had the weakness of dramatising his position. 
 He could hurt those who cared most about him &mdash; his parents when he became a monk and Mirfield when he followed his resignation with a national television account of what was personal and private. 
 His discovery of a new freedom both theological and psychological was not easy for him to articulate though his widely circulated letter Ad Amicos revealed his absolute devotion to the search for God. 
 Hundreds of friends found Hugh Bishop a supportive fellow pilgrim on their own spiritual journeys. 
 In particular women discovered they were treated with rare attention and understanding. 
 His power to help the perplexed, and his liberating refusal of over-definition in religion, gave him an authority more profound than he had exercised even when he was Superior. 
 Anniversaries 
 By ALAN WEBSTER 
 On this day: the Order of the Bath was constituted, 1399; Pope Leo X conferred the title &bquo;Defender of the Faith&equo; on Henry VIII, 1521; Peter the Great became Tsar of Russia, 1669; the Chicago Fire ended, having almost completely destroyed the city at a cost of &dollar;196m, 1871; the Anglo-Boer War started, 1899; Czechoslovakia became an independent republic, 1918; inflation overtook German currency, with the mark dropping to an exchange rate of 10,000m to the pound, 1923; fighting broke out in China between the Nationalists under Chiang Kai-shek and the Communists under Mao Tse-tung, 1945; Pope John XXIII opened the second Vatican Ecumenical Council, 1963. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 34 
 Obituary: Patricia Cockburn 
 By JAMES PETTIFER 
 IN THE EDWARDIAN world in which Patricia Cockburn grew up, writes James Pettifer (further to the Obituary by Richard Ingrams, 9 October), there were rational certainties: the family bank, as an Arbuthnot; the Empire, as a source of employment and, in the case of the grandparents, huge wealth from China; and within the Empire, the natural world, as something to be explored, revered, loved. 
 Only the last survived a long complicated life as a passion, and led to her single-handed revival of the eighteenth-century art of shell pictures, an obsessive pursuit of Irish aristocratic ladies in the time of Sheridan and Goldsmith. 
 She had early ambitions to be a marine biologist, and always claimed that lack of formal educational opportunity prevented her. 
 Whether that was the whole story no one will ever know. 
 To many of her friends she seemed more a mystic than a likely scientist, despite her encyclopaedic knowledge of natural history; a woman with religious respect for and understanding of the environment, an ecologist long before the term was widely known. 
 But most of all, she belonged in her native landscape, around Youghal and later Ardmore. 
 A small figure wrapped in an old duffel coat and woolly hat, she accompanied her Collie dog along the great open beach at Ardmore, in solitary contact with the Atlantic. 
 Like Euripides she believed the sea could cure the ills of man. 
 But her wider life was anything but solitary. 
 Immensely learned about all aspects of modern Irish life, she knew almost everybody and was known to them. 
 Perhaps the number of thinly-disguised character studies in modern fiction, from Molly Keane to Emma Tennant, are a better tribute to her than anything else, not all of them flattering, it must be said. 
 She was an excellent shrewd local politician and a comfort to her at the end of her life was the defeat of the atrocious plans of the Merrell Dow Chemical Company to build a plant near her beloved River Blackwater, the last campaign in which she played an active part. 
 Deeply kind and warm-hearted, despite her somewhat formidable exterior and a conversational style which could tend towards the monologue, she remained a generous radical to the end, one of the few of her generation who integrated the immense energy and self-confidence of the Ascendancy families into modern Irish life. 
 She will be missed as much in the tiny village halls in County Waterford, where she was active in the Irish Country Women's Association, as in fashionable dining rooms in Cape Cod or London. 
 Obituary: Mark Dignam 
 By GILES GORDON 
 OSSIA TRILLING's obituary of Mark Dignam (5 October) mentions that the actor played a dozen major Shakespeare parts at Stratford in the late 1950s, writes Giles Gordon. 
 They included the most sinister, malevolent Claudius I've seen, drenched like Satan in Motley's red costume, to Michael Redgrave's last Hamlet. 
 The star, not inclined to be bored by his own performance, gave a slightly different interpretation every time, keeping the rest of the cast on its toes. 
 Dignam, in the role second largest to Redgrave's, coped magnificently in the two performances I saw. 
 Never a star perhaps but stars, on the boards, come and go. 
 Character actors and second leads, like Dignam, tend to stay, not seduced by celluloid. 
 Down the decades, I never saw Dignam give a performance that wasn't true to his classical text. 
 When he was in a production the overall power was somehow raised. 
 He belonged more to the Gielgud tradition than the Olivier. 
 Nothing inadequate about his physical acting but his voice was his asset, the driest, most pungent of sherries at the command, so often, of Shakespeare's verse, utterly lacking the fruitiness and histrionics of so many over-tired classical actors of his generation. 
 His performances were ever at the service of the text, and invariably characters were created. 
 I never felt: &bquo;Oh, so old Dignam's playing Claudius&equo; (or whomever); always: &bquo;I wonder what Dignam will make of Claudius?&equo; 
 A year or so back I found myself sitting next to him, bearded in his old age and wearing plus fours, overall resembling a successful if slightly barmy countryman, at a ghastly new play at the Almeida. 
 His concentration throughout was total, and at the end he clapped vigorously. 
 He was one of those relatively few actors &mdash; Ian McKellen and Simon Callow are others &mdash; who somehow boost the confidence of regular theatregoers by taking the opportunity of a free evening to watch fellow actors at work. 
 At Riverside Studios during the interval of a play in Russian, I was chatting about anything other than the play to the Guardian's critic, Michael Billington, when Mark Dignam approached Billington and, most courteously and with a touch of a bow, said: &bquo;Mr Billington, I look forward to reading you tomorrow and seeing what I think of the play.&equo; 
 Clearly a man who understood and relished his profession. 
 Obituary: Carlo Dapporto 
 By GILES GORDON 
 Carlo Dapporto, Italian comic actor, died Rome 1 October aged 88. 
 He was known in Italy as the &bquo;King of the Joke&equo; and had his greatest critical success in Ettore Scola's film La Famiglia. 
 Shortage of nurses &bquo;could grow worse&equo; 
 By GILES GORDON 
 First Edition THE STAFF shortage crisis in nursing could go from bad to worse as industry, the United States and Australia take their pick of recruits, it was claimed yesterday. 
 Brenda Baxter, chairwoman of the National Association of Theatre Nurses, said: &bquo;There have always been unfilled vacancies in this speciality. 
 What is new is that we have moved from too few qualified nurses coming to work in the operating theatres, to not enough people entering nursing. 
 &bquo;The profession as a whole is in crisis as nursing is now in direct competition with business, industry and other professions to attract personnel into its ranks.&equo; 
 She told 1,000 representatives at the association's 25th annual congress in Harrogate, North Yorkshire, that the nursing shortage was being experienced by the rest of the Western world with the subsequent drain of qualified theatre nurses going to the US, Australia and anywhere else offering a better deal. 
 &bquo;All of this suggests that things could go from bad to worse,&equo; Miss Baxter said. 
 Parents who abuse their children have often been abused themselves, Dr Hans Steiner, consultant paediatrician and senior lecturer in child health at Newcastle University, told the congress. 
 &bquo;I am now surprised if the parent involved has not got such a history.&equo; 
 He said professionals dealing with the problem had to &bquo;break the circle&equo; of abuse. 
 Raiders find getaway car driven by PC 
 By GILES GORDON 
 First Edition TWO MEN who fled after bungling a raid on a shop jumped into a getaway car only to find a policeman at the wheel. 
 Constable Dale Buckingham had just collected the car from the scene of the raid, in Bristol, and was taking it to his police station when he saw two men he suspected of being involved in the raid, and stopped. 
 According to a report in yesterday's Newsbeat, the Avon and Somerset Police newspaper, the men recognised the car and jumped in, congratulating the driver on avoiding the police. 
 It was only when PC Buckingham called for assistance on his personal radio that they realised what was happening. 
 They attacked him, but he was able to hold them off until help arrived. 
 Correction: Case Summaries: Lex Services plc v Johns 
 Home News Page 10 
 Law Report: Tribunal's decision on road verges cannot be re-litigated: Crown Estate Commissioners v Dorset County Council &mdash; Chancery Division (Mr Justice Millett), 6 October 1989 
 By YING HUI TAN, Barrister 
 The decision of an inferior tribunal with a limited jurisdiction and a limited function to perform is capable of creating an estoppel for all purposes, subject to the principles that it cannot conclusively determine the limits of its own jurisdiction and that a public official cannot be debarred from performing his statutory duty. 
 Mr Justice Millett held that, by reason of the decision of the Chief Commons Commissioner on 17 March 1977, the plaintiffs were estopped from asserting as against the defendant council (other than in proceedings concerned with the registrability of certain grass road verges within the Royal Manor of Portland under the Commons Registration Act 1965, in respect of which the plaintiffs accept that this issue had been finally determined) that the road verges were not part of the highway. 
 In 1968, the road verges, with other land, were provisionally registered by the council, acting as registration authority, in the register of common land. 
 In 1969, various rights of common were registered. 
 The council as highway authority lodged an objection to the registration of the road verges on the ground that they formed part of the highway. 
 After a hearing in 1976, the Chief Commons Commissioner found that the road verges were part of the highway, and so did not fall within the definition of &bquo;common land&equo; in section 22(1) of the Act. 
 The registration, excluding the road verges from the register, became final in 1977. 
 The council had recently authorised an adjoining owner to construct and pave an access way over part of the road verge. 
 The plaintiffs claimed that certain grass verges were part of the manorial lands of the manor and wished to re-litigate the question of whether the road verges were part of the highway. 
 John Mummery (Farrer &amp; Co) for the plaintiffs; Sheila Cameron QC, and Frank Hinks (County Solicitor) for the council. 
 MR JUSTICE MILLETT said that the particular question was whether a decision of a commons commissioner that certain land was not registrable as common land because it formed part of a highway was capable of giving rise to an estoppel per rem judicatam so as to preclude the landowner from afterwards asserting, in proceedings unconnected with the register, that the land in question did not form part of a highway. 
 It raised the more general and important question whether the determination of a statutory tribunal with a limited jurisdiction could give rise to issue estoppel at all, or only to cause of action estoppel; in other words, whether it could give rise to an estoppel for all purposes or only for the limited purpose for which the jurisdiction to make the determination was conferred. 
 The council contended that the plaintiffs were estopped from asserting that the road verges did not form part of the highway by the decision of the Chief Commons Commissioner. 
 Res judicata was a special form of estoppel. 
 It gave effect to the policy of the law that the parties to a judicial decision should not afterwards be allowed to re-litigate the same question, even though the decision might be wrong. 
 If it was wrong, it must be challenged by way of appeal or not at all. 
 As between themselves, the parties were bound by the decision, and might neither re-litigate the same cause of action nor reopen any issue which was an essential part of the decision: cause of action estoppel and issue estoppel respectively. 
 The plaintiff accepted they were precluded from re-litigating whether the road verges were registrable under the Act, by the commisioner's decision, which they conceded gave rise to cause of action estoppel, but said the requirements of issue estoppel were lacking. 
 The requirements of issue estoppel were summarised in The Sennar (No 2) (1985) 1 WLR 490, 499. 
 The plaintiffs contended that the commissioner was not a court of competent jurisdiction, and that the issue before him of whether the entries in the register were validly made was not the same as the issue in the action, which was whether the road verges formed part of the highway. 
 They submitted that the commissioner had no jurisdiction to adjudicate on the status of the road verges generally or otherwise than for the limited purpose of deciding what entries should be contained in the register. 
 The plaintiffs had cited highway, tax and rating cases in support of the limited jurisdiction principle. 
 The leading highway authority, R v Hutchings (1881) 6 QBD 300, where the justices were held to have no jurisdiction, did not help the plaintiffs. 
 The rules developed in taxation and rating cases could not be applied more generally. 
 They were sui generis, and were to be justified by considerations of policy. 
 The supposed principle did not exist. 
 The whole doctrine of res judicata was based on considerations of judicial policy, was of great importance but was not paramount. 
 It must yield to the principles that a tribunal of limited jurisdiction could not be permitted conclusively to determine the limits of its own jurisdiction and that a public official could not be debarred from performing his statutory duty. 
 Subject to those two safegaurds there was no reason why the decision of an inferior tribunal with a limited jurisdiction and a strictly limited function to perform should not be capable of creating an issue estoppel. 
 All the requirements of issue estoppel were satisfied in the present case. 
 The commissioner had statutory jurisdiction to decide whether the road verges should be registered as common land. 
 For that purpose he had to determine whether they formed part of a highway. 
 He, therefore, had jurisdiction to determine that question also. 
 But it was not a jurisdictional question, for his jurisdiction to decide it did not depend on the correctness of the answer he gave. 
 Farmer sees financial sense in going green 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 HILL FARM, in the heart of south Somerset, is about to undergo a revolution that will be watched with interest by neighbours and from further afield. 
 It is thought to be the largest British dairy farm to go green, and the conversion &mdash; for deeply held environmental reasons &mdash; is backed by sound economic logic. 
 Oliver and Vanessa Dowding are not amateurs living the good life on a smallholding. 
 From the dairy yard where Friesian cows wait to be milked, fields stretch a mile and a half to a distant hill. 
 There is a second dairy yard at the far side of the farm, near the village of Shepton Montague. 
 The 920-acre mixed dairy and arable holding employs five full-time staff, as well as two students gaining work experience. 
 Three generations of Dowdings have run the farm and used herbicides, pesticides and the best the agro-chemical producers could come up with to get the maximum yields. 
 But no more. 
 The spraying machine in the yard will become a museum piece as pesticides are outlawed. 
 Mr Dowding is a leading official in the local National Farmers' Union and is aware of the risks involved in throwing away the drugs and chemicals. 
 However, he believes the increased market for green products, and the premium price people are willing to pay, makes the conversion commercially viable &mdash; and will help farmers to break the stranglehold of the powerful agrochemical companies. 
 He said: &bquo;If you look in any of the farming magazines, the majority of the full-page ads are from drug companies. 
 They have a tremendous hold on the industry, and the pressure is on to use more and more chemicals to get better and better yields. 
 It's a treadmill that is hard to get off.&equo; 
 Though he expects lower cereal crop yields after he completes the conversion, there is a saving of &pound;70 an acre in the cost of pesticides and herbicides. 
 The higher price being paid for environmentally sound produce also means that, despite the smaller crop, his income will stay much the same. 
 Extra can also be earned on milk produced from &bquo;green&equo; cows; customers pay 10p a pint more in the shop. 
 He said the conversion would take three years and the pitfalls were unknown. 
 &bquo;It is a risk, but it's something I have wanted to do for some time and I believe it is feasible. 
 We are determined to make it work &mdash; the last thing I want is to be a laughing stock among local farmers if I fail.&equo; 
 He said the way drug, chemical and fertiliser companies and supermarket chains were manipulating the public's opinions and buying habits and dictating to farmers was &bquo;frightening&equo;. 
 An example he cites of the way drugs are pervading the industry is the experiment with BST hormone which is being injected into cows, including animals on farms in Somerset, to improve milk yields. 
 In spite of fears about the use of the hormone, the names of the farms taking part in the trials are kept secret, and their milk is fed into the public supply. 
 &bquo;This use of drugs to help nature along is worrying. 
 The attitude of the companies is such that I want nothing to do with them; I like to think we will survive without ruining the lives of the animals and destroying the land.&equo; 
 Running a farm on green lines will mean much more planning ahead and developing such techniques as homeopathic treatment for sick cows, though as a last resort medication will be given. 
 &bquo;If we can prove this works,&equo; Mr Dowding said, &bquo;I am sure there are a lot of other farmers who want to give it a try and are just waiting. 
 Hopefully, our experience will be of use to them.&equo; 
 Berlin conductor 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 Alun Francis was appointed principal conductor of the Berlin Symphony Orchestra. 
 Bomb blocks road 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 A suspected Second World War bomb found in road works near the A2 exit of the M25 between Dartford and Swanley in Kent closed both roads for several hours last night, leading to a 25-mile traffic jam at one point. 
 Sentence cut 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 Malcolm Conway Graham, 41, a Kent residential social worker jailed for five years for having unlawful sex with two teenage girls in his care, was cleared in respect of one girl. 
 The Court of Appeal decision left him with a two-year term to complete. 
 1m pounds drugs haul 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 Eight people were being questioned by police after 250 kilos of cannabis worth &pound;1m was found concealed in a consignment of cabbages which arrived in Birmingham from Holland. 
 UDR men's bail curbs are lifted 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 Four members of the Ulster Defence Regiment arrested and charged with arms offences were granted unrestricted bail by the High Court in Belfast yesterday. 
 The men were among 28 UDR members arrested during police raids on Sunday in the inquiry into alleged security leaks. 
 Darryl Chapman, 29, is accused of possessing three rifle magazines, and the other three &mdash; Leslie Wheeler, 24, Robert Thompson, 25, and William Casement, 31 &mdash; face charges of possessing ammunition. 
 On Monday the men were each granted bail on condition that they remained in military custody. 
 But Lord Justice MacDermott did not impose any conditions when he released them on their own bail of &pound;100. 
 Rich should give more to the arts, Palumbo says 
 By DAVID LISTER, Arts Correspondent 
 WEALTHY businessmen who have benefited from low tax rates should do more to subsidise the arts, the chairman of the Arts Council said yesterday. 
 Peter Palumbo also hinted that, in the current squeeze, public money might have to be limited to centres of excellence and innovation. 
 Introducing the Arts Council's annual report, Mr Palumbo, a highly successful property developer, pointed out that the public sector gave five times as much as the private sector in Britain, whereas in the United States 90 per cent of the arts were funded by private donations. 
 &bquo;It is that sort of tradition I shall be seeking to foster, albeit in lower percentage terms,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The fact is that many people have made substantial personal fortunes in the last few years, and with encouragement and the lowest income tax rate for 50 years, I believe they will be prepared to acknowledge their privileged position and return to the community a portion of their good fortune. 
 Like it or not, they have inherited the mantle of the great patrons of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, and it is a responsibility that they can hardly deny.&equo; 
 However, the trend appears to be going in the reverse direction. 
 The Association of Business Sponsorship of the Arts says many sponsors are uneasy that they are expected to replace, rather than supplement, government grant, and a fall in sponsorship is feared. 
 Mr Palumbo also suggested that grant money might be taken away from companies which failed to achieve a sufficiently high standard. 
 The Arts Council is holding a special meeting in November to discuss the funding crisis; it is thought that it might decide to cut the number of bodies receiving grant if more government money is not forthcoming. 
 Mr Palumbo said: &bquo;Excellence springs up in many places. 
 It is, however, essential. 
 I can see no justification in spending taxpayers&equo; money in order to celebrate the second-rate.&equo; 
 But he said he was committed to funding experimental art, &bquo;the equal of research and development in industry&equo;. 
 He also implied that the Arts Council might soon give greater emphasis to its former role as a policy body as well as a grant-giving organisation. 
 It existed to &bquo;speak for artists and art organisations, to offer them advice, to argue for them and to champion their interests in the media and to government whenever and wherever the need may arise&equo;. 
 Luke Rittner, secretary general of the Arts Council, said inflation had outstripped grant aid by 6 per cent, and &bquo;a failure by government to recognise this situation will be a cruel slap in the face to an arts world that has done so much to adapt to the market economy of the 1980s&equo;. 
 A &pound;5m development appeal launched yesterday by the Natural History Museum has already raised &pound;2.5m. 
 The appeal aims to raise the rest over the next five years through private sector support. 
 Gerald Ronson, co-chairman of the fundraising committee, said: &bquo;We have to use money from business because government funding is being cut back.&equo; 
 BP is providing &pound;1m of sponsorship. 
 US law rejected as model for seizing criminal assets 
 By TERRY KIRBY, Crime Correspondent 
 LAWS to confiscate the proceeds of organised crime in the United Kingdom should not follow the American pattern, according to a report on practises in both countries published yesterday. 
 The report, by Professor Michael Zander, of the London School of Economics, criticised United States legislation on the confiscation and forfeiture of assets as being too wide-ranging and open to abuse by prosecutors. 
 In the report for the Police Foundation, an independent research body, Professor Zander argues that the main US legislation, the Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organisations Act, is &bquo;fundamentally objectionable&equo; since it allows forfeiture without criminal conviction. 
 The criticisms will be studied closely by the Home Office, which has overseen an increase in British legislation aimed at the seizure of financial gains from crime, particularly drugs and terrorism. 
 While generally approving existing British legislation, Professor Zander cautioned against any extension of powers and points to the United States where, he said, mere suspicion could mean financial ruin for individuals and organisations while the law also allowed the seizure of all assets, not simply those related to a specific offence. 
 &bquo;The US law in this respect seems greatly excessive,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;To take away the profits of crime is one thing; to seize assets that have no connection with crime is another. 
 Forfeiture should be proportionate to the offence.&equo; 
 The professor believes the potential damage is so great there is a temptation for suspects to plea bargain. 
 Entirely innocent people might admit to lesser offences to avoid confiscation. 
 &bquo;The resulting scope for abuse of prosecutorial discretion is great,&equo; he adds. 
 The report also criticised US law for confusing juries, extending the scope of conspiracy charges, and having vague language and excessive penalties. 
 However, Professor Zander supported the American idea of using money and other assets seized in drugs inquiries to fund law enforcement operations. 
 The Home Office has ruled out specific allocation of seized funds to law enforcement bodies but is considering the possibility of a central pool for expensive police operations. 
 Laboratory seeks industrial cash 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 A LEADING government scientific research centre is selling its services to industry in an attempt to bolster its ailing finances. 
 Daresbury Laboratory, near Runcorn, Cheshire, has Europe's largest and Britain's only source of synchrotron radiation (SRS) &mdash; vital to the study of protein crystals and the development of drugs to combat diseases such as Aids. 
 The laboratory, one of four run by the Science and Engineering Research Council, has come under increasing financial pressure as its &pound;20m annual budget has fallen sharply in real terms. 
 Professor Alan Leadbetter, Daresbury's director, said its buying power had declined by 7 per cent per year over the last few years. 
 Selling science to industry was &bquo;necessary&equo;. 
 &bquo;We simply do not have enough money.&equo; 
 Earlier this year, the SERC said its laboratories should use 20 per cent of their resources to attract outside work. 
 But Professor Leadbetter also feels the laboratory has a duty to serve British industry, which, he said, lags behind Japan and the United States in the exploitation of advanced facilities such as the SRS. 
 Daresbury's work for industry, which amounts to only 5 per cent of its activities, could double within a year, Professor Leadbetter said. 
 Glaxo, the pharmaceutical company, has already announced a &pound;500,000 contract to use the SRS. 
 Some of the profits will be used to buy sophisticated instrumentation which Daresbury cannot afford. 
 Moves to set up statistics watchdog 
 By ROSIE WATERHOUSE 
 MOVES to set up a national watchdog to monitor the integrity and accuracy of government statistics gained momentum yesterday when plans were announced for a meeting to draw up firm proposals, writes Rosie Waterhouse. 
 The Statistics Users' Council is to hold a seminar of its member organisations, including the Confederation of British Industry; the Trades Union Congress; the Royal Economics Society; the Institute of Statisticians; the Royal Statistical Society, which is already considering an idea for a watchdog organisation; and the government Statistical Service. 
 A forum to establish guidelines for a national statistics council is being organised by Ian Maclean, secretary of the Statistics Users' Council. 
 University plans to double its students 
 By NGAIO CREQUER, Education Correspondent 
 THE University of Southampton announced plans yesterday to more than double its student numbers over the next 35 years by building an additional campus. 
 The university wants to expand from 6,800 students to 15,000 by 2030 and it is clear some private fee-paying would be instrumental in that expansion. 
 It has identified a 295-acre site of mainly coniferous woodland managed by the Forestry Commission, and is discussing acquisition with landowners and local authorities. 
 Professor Gordon Higginson, university vice-chancellor, said yesterday: &bquo;I am not assuming students would be fully-funded by government.&equo; 
 The professor said the idea of a two-year degree was under consideration. 
 He pointed to a &bquo;desperate need to educate the population better&equo; and said that in the first half of the Eighties the engineering workforce fell by a third and the number of graduates employed increased by half. 
 The additional campus, 2 &frac12; miles from the present site, would make Southampton one of Britain's largest universities. 
 College lecturers have voted overwhelmingly for a one-day strike and a total ban on flexible working over pay, the National Association of Teachers in Further and Higher Education announced yesterday. 
 Artery &bquo;drill&equo; brings hope for heart cases 
 By ROB STEPNEY 
 A NEW blood vessel &bquo;drill&equo; which can relieve blocked arteries supplying the heart has been used successfully for the first time by surgeons in Britain. 
 A man of 65, from Bristol, last week became the first British patient to benefit from the technique, known as rotational angioplasty. 
 His arteries were blocked with hard calcified deposits of cholesterol. 
 Conventional treatments, including surgery, had failed to improve the blood flow to the heart. 
 An oval drill head was attached to a flexible wire and threaded into a blood vessel in his leg. 
 Watched using X-rays, it was pushed through the main artery and into the small opening of the coronary arteries at the top of the heart. 
 The head bored through the blockages that were reducing the blood flow. 
 Such blockages cause pains known as angina, and in severe cases can lead to a heart attack. 
 The patient then underwent a treatment called balloon angioplasty in which a small rubber balloon was passed inside the artery and inflated, thus pushing the remaining cholesterol deposits back into the artery wall. 
 Dr Jonathan Crick, a consultant cardiologist at Bristol Royal Infirmary, and a consultant radiologist, Dr George Hartnell, tried the technique after hearing of its use in West Germany. 
 The Conservative Conference: Clarke urges Treasury Secretary to back NHS bid: Direct appeal to Lamont brings battle for additional health service funding into the public arena 
 By JUDY JONES and COLIN BROWN 
 KENNETH CLARKE, the Secretary of State for Health, yesterday took his battle for more money for the health service to the conference hall at the annual Conservative Party conference in Blackpool. 
 Mr Clarke made a direct appeal to Norman Lamont, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, to support his bid for between &pound;1-2bn extra for the NHS budget next year. 
 &bquo;Norman Lamont is a good friend of the NHS and I am sure &mdash; or I think I am sure &mdash; that he will prove it,&equo; Mr Clarke said. 
 Mr Lamont is engaged in a series of behind-the-scenes negotiations with the major spending ministers at the conference to reduce &pound;10bn in excess bids. 
 It is expected that the health budget for next year will be settled in the talks, but disputes over education and transport could go to an appeal to the Star Chamber of ministers chaired by Sir Geoffrey Howe. 
 In a robust speech, which won him a standing ovation, Mr Clarke denied suggestions that Government's plans to overhaul the NHS were a substitute for extra money for the service. 
 &bquo;Thatcherite Britain now spends more taxpayers&equo; money on our health than on our defence. 
 It was the last Labour government which spent more on defence than the NHS. 
 We are not proposing reform instead of spending more money on the NHS. 
 &bquo;We intend to reform as well as spending more money in order to get the most out of that money for the patients. 
 We are fully prepared to accept the cost of a high quality and expanding service. 
 Cost is not the enemy. 
 Waste is the enemy of a good service.&equo; 
 The Secretary of State further emphasised that the Government was not embarking on the privatisation of the NHS. 
 Private polls conducted for the Tory Party have shown concern among voters that the service, like water and electricity, is about to be sold off. 
 Mr Clarke told representatives: &bquo;We haven't any plans for privatisation. 
 We never have. 
 I regard the whole idea of privatising the NHS as quite daft - impossible in a universal service offering the full range of service to every citizen of all ages and states of health without any of them having to pay for their medical treatment.&equo; 
 He remained unchanged in his &bquo;unwavering and inflexible commitment&equo; to the principle of an NHS funded largely out of taxation, giving free medical treatment to everyone regardless of means. 
 &bquo;But we will and really must change the bureaucracy, the remoteness of management, the impersonal care for patients, the frustrations of the staff and the failure to maintain high standards everywhere that the present way of running the service causes far too often.&equo; 
 Regional variations in waiting times for operations, the excessive drugs prescribed by some doctors and other failings were often not the failing of a single individual. 
 &bquo;They are the fault of the old-fashioned way in which it is run. 
 It is our duty, if we care, to tackle the causes of these problems.&equo; 
 Mr Clarke won the approval of the conference for a strong attack on the BMA's campaign against the NHS changes. 
 Tory supporters also turned against the BMA and angrily disrupted a BMA fringe meeting shortly before the health debate. 
 The anger against the BMA was still present in the hall when Mr Clarke repeated his appeal to the British Medical Association to withdraw its campaign against the Government's health service White Paper Working for Patients. 
 &bquo;After eight months, I recently won an admission from the BMA that our proposals in the White Paper would not and could not cause any doctor to have to refuse any patient medicines which that patient would need. 
 They did not say sorry. 
 &bquo;They have not yet admitted that none of my proposals would force a patient to travel long distances for treatment against his or her will; that no doctor will have any new financial incentive to refuse elderly patients on to his list. 
 They still do not concede that we are doing nothing to force any GP to spend less time with his patients. 
 &bquo;They ought to because all those allegations are untrue as well.&equo; 
 Speakers in the health debate overwhelmingly supported the Government's blueprint for changing the NHS. 
 Paul Twyman, of North Thanet said: &bquo;The BMA are a trade union and they are entitled to stand up for their members&equo; interests, but they are not entitled to abuse their professional position by deliberately scaremongering and frightening elderly patients.&equo; 
 Sheila Scott, a state-registered nurse from Hendon, said the Government was right to try to make the NHS more cost-conscious. 
 &bquo;If it means treading over sensitive toes, so be it.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: A lone police officer on duty on Blackpool seafront yesterday as part of the increased security there for the Conservative Party conference 
 By JUDY JONES and COLIN BROWN 
 The Conservative Conference: A lone police officer on duty on Blackpool seafront yesterday as part of the increased security there for the Conservative Party conference 
 The Conservative Conference: Fowler prepares law to stamp out wildcat strikes 
 By COLIN HUGHES and STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 LEGISLATION TO curb wildcat strikes will be introduced during the coming parliamentary session, Norman Fowler, Secretary of State for Employment, announced yesterday. 
 He told the conference that he will today be publishing a consultative Green Paper to tackle what he called &bquo;the weapon of the militant &mdash; the tool of the wrecker&equo;. 
 Three out of four strikes are unofficial. 
 Afterwards he told reporters that the proposals would probably be incorporated in an industrial relations Bill which could be published either late this year or early next year. 
 The same Bill will ban the remaining forms of secondary action, and outlaw closed shop agreements altogether. 
 But Mr Fowler confirmed that the Government's attempt to find a way of preventing strikes in essential services has so far failed. 
 He told a press briefing that the issue remained under review, and emphasised that he hoped the legislation on unofficial strikes would help to prevent disruption of essential services. 
 His review of the law on unofficial action and strikes in essential services was launched during the early summer this year, when a sequence of strikes hit the railways and the London Underground. 
 The latter action was exclusively unofficial, and repudiated by the union, but it was widely known to be organised in secret by a small group of shop stewards. 
 Today's Green Paper is expected to contain two separate methods of enabling employers to take action in the civil courts against the organisers of unofficial strikes. 
 One will enable employers to take the union to court, where it would risk losing its immunities, if it fails to repudiate the action. 
 The other is likely to enable employees to dismiss strike organisers, where the union has repudiated the action. 
 In his conference speech Mr Fowler attacked Labour's reviewed industrial relations policy, saying it had one aim: to make strikes easier. 
 When Labour opposed sequestration of union assets it meant, &bquo;strike freely&equo;, when it said trade union immunities would be restored it meant &bquo;strike often&equo;, and when it approved of enabling secondary action it meant &bquo;strike anywhere&equo;. 
 He proclaimed the Government's success in reducing unemployment by 1.2 million since the last general election, with both youth and long-term unemployment falling. 
 &bquo;It has been the largest and longest sustained fall in unemployment in the history of this country.&equo; 
 But employment prospects would be limited if pay settlements were too high: labour costs had to be controlled, Mr Fowler warned. 
 Conference speakers repeatedly called for no let-up against the unions. 
 Chris Davis, managing director of a Liverpool manufacturing company, said not enough had yet been done to restrict union power. 
 &bquo;There are still nearly three million trade unionists in either pre or post-entry closed shops,&equo; Mr Davis said. 
 His own firm had been picketed for the last five months in a dispute over the use of new technology. 
 Don Stewart, a farmer from Boothferry, declared: &bquo;No more closed shops; no more trade union barons. 
 That is the road of future success for the Tory government.&equo; 
 Jacqui Lait, of the European Union of Women, attacked Labour's proposal for a minimum wage. 
 It would put thousands out of work and close business after business. 
 &bquo;That is the thorn on the red rose,&equo; she said. 
 Representatives also emphasised the need for more skill training. 
 Jenny Riley, a recruitment consultant and parliamentary candidate in Newcastle East in 1987, said there had to be &bquo;massive&equo; programmes of training and retraining. 
 Almost every business sector lacked specialist and well-qualified staff. 
 The Conservative Conference: Councils to face housing targets 
 By JUDY JONES 
 COUNCILS will be asked to set annual housing targets and explain any failure to meet them to their tenants under government proposals announced yesterday. 
 Michael Howard, Minister of State for Housing, hailed the move as a &bquo;clear enhancement of tenants&equo; rights', enabling people to judge how well local authorities ran housing. 
 &bquo;Tenants and community charge payers will have the evidence they need to condemn inefficiency,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Howard was responding to Tory grassroots demands for the Government to do more to relieve homelessness and allow councils to spend more of their own cash to provide homes. 
 Ministers will decide in January exactly how council performance should be measured and they want assessments to begin in April. 
 A consultation paper published yesterday suggested the proportion of rent collected, the amount of rent arrears, the number of empty properties and the average cost and waiting time for repairs must be included. 
 The minister also said a framework for securing the future of shared ownership schemes in rural areas, offering part-rent, part-purchase deals, had been agreed with the Housing Corporation. 
 During the housing debate, Kevin Johnston, from Eastbourne, East Sussex, was cheered as he said: &bquo;The homelessness problem is even more acute now than in 1985. 
 Quite clearly, to the shame of local and central government, the homelessness crisis has been allowed to get to such a level that I would describe it as a national disgrace.&equo; 
 Thousands of families were destined to a life of misery in cramped bed and breakfast accommodation. 
 Many had no privacy and were living in filthy conditions. 
 Fire safety standards were widely flouted. 
 More than 400,000 individuals were now classified as homeless and, in the second quarter of this year, some 33,000 people were placed in bed and breakfast accommodation. 
 &bquo;It takes away an individual's dignity and a family's self-respect. 
 It destroys hope for a better life. 
 But as a party and as a government we have a duty to encourage families to better themselves and discourage dependency.&equo; 
 Eileen Sandford, vice-chairman of Shrewsbury's housing committee, said the borough had a waiting list of more than 4,000. 
 &bquo;Soon we shall be reaching the bed and breakfast stage&hellip; but it is totally unsuitable for young and elderly people. 
 The situation embarrasses us in committee. 
 We face Labour's jibe that the Government holds all our revenue and that we can only save 20 per cent from our house sales.&equo; 
 Jean Burnham, from West Sussex, criticised the &bquo;smug&equo; Richmond Conservative Association's motion for debate, welcoming government initiatives to increase the supply of low-cost housing. 
 &bquo;We must be allowed to spend our capital receipts. 
 We do not want to be handing our paper profits back to the Government.&equo; 
 Mr Howard emphasised the Government's continuing commitment to its Green Belt policy. 
 &bquo;In the Thirties we established it. 
 In the Fifties we expanded it. 
 In the Eighties we have doubled it.&equo; 
 He cited the decision last week of Chris Patten, Secretary of State for the Environment, last week to turn down the housing development for Foxley Wood in Hampshire, adding: &bquo;We have repeatedly said that, wherever possible, decisions of this kind should be left to local people.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Wakeham puts faith in nuclear power 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 NUCLEAR power and more competition were offered to the Conservative conference yesterday as the Government's answer to protecting the environment and safeguarding the future of planet Earth. 
 Reaffirming the promise to privatise the electricity industry within the life of this Parliament, John Wakeham, Secretary of State for Energy, said competition between generating companies would be a massive incentive to use fuel more efficiently and keep costs down. 
 &bquo;For us, energy needn't cost the earth. 
 And it won't,&equo; he told the conference. 
 &bquo;Nuclear power is, without a doubt, the cleanest &mdash; and by any objective criteria &mdash; safest way of sustaining growth and protectingthe environment at the same time. 
 It is the only energy available in the quantity we need that doesn't damage our atmosphere. 
 And it is also the only source of power we know that will still be available when coal and gas supplies run out.&equo; 
 Several delegates expressed disappointment at the delay in the electricity privatisation timetable, but Mr Wakeham said he would make no apology. 
 It was the biggest privatisation ever. 
 The Government wanted to get it right and ensure genuine competition. 
 In the first criticism of Nigel Lawson from the floor, Rupert Blum, an energy economist from Leominster, argued that a base rate of 15 per cent, plus the lenders' mark up, meant energy conservation schemes simply did not pay. 
 He appealed to the Chancellor to &bquo;start fighting inflation with more flexible, more imaginative measures than ever rising interest rates&equo;. 
 The debate also brought demands for privatising the pits. 
 Trevor Evans, a mineworker and vice-chairman of Bolsover Conservatives, said that the ideal for the future must be a private coal mine and power station working together. 
 The privatised electricity industry should not rely on imported coal &bquo;dumped&equo; at artificially low prices, he said. 
 The Conservative Conference: Easy lie the locks that would bear the crown 
 By COLIN BROWN 
 MICHAEL HESELTINE yesterday eclipsed the conference with a sideshow at the Grand Theatre, a couple of hundred yards down the road from where the full conference was taking place. 
 The Cabinet outcast managed to upstage Kenneth Baker, the Conservative party chairman, who has been taking acting lessons from Kenneth Branagh. 
 The big question now is how soon the blond from Henley will eclipse the blonde from Finchley, who is said to be planning a speech which would make Joan of Arc sound hesitant. 
 Mr Baker adopted the Henry V model for his official morale-boosting speech from the conference platform. 
 He stiffened the sinews, jutted the jaw, summoned the Baker blood and delivered the &bquo;once more into the breach dear friends&equo; soliloquy with fiery passion. 
 The cherubic Baker face was fixed with a hardened lip for the tough bit on the economy, subtitled, I support Nigel and so should you. 
 People were asking whether the Government had got the economy right, Mr Baker said. 
 &bquo;Again, I say yes. 
 Nigel Lawson took a very courageous decision in the war against inflation. 
 He did not shrink from doing what was right.&equo; 
 The only problem with the Shakespeare text is that it is open to modern political misinterpretation. 
 When Mr Baker quoted Henry's words before Agincourt &mdash; &bquo;He which hath no stomach to this fight, let him depart&equo; &mdash; it was seen, not as an attack on Labour, but a slight on the Chancellor who had decamped from the conference for Blaby. 
 Throughout his performance, Mr Baker allowed a carefully oiled strand of hair to fall over his forehead, clearly an attempt to steal the crown from the famous golden locks which thrilled successive Tory conferences. 
 But the Heseltine mane has been tamed. 
 It is neatly trimmed and, though elaborately structured, never fell out of place. 
 Heseltine watchers could have wished for no clearer sign of his leadership intentions. 
 They settled down to a tour de force, delivered with the power of Concorde on full throttle. 
 The Grand is an intimate theatre setting. 
 But this was the conference speech for the big hall, delivered with the full range of Heseltine oratorical skills which used to bring the entire conference to its feet. 
 &bquo;He's beginning to sound just like Churchill,&equo; one admirer said softly. 
 The words roared over a row of Henley Heselteenies and reverberated in the gods. 
 This was the conference speech which the conference would never hear, but he tried. 
 When it was over, Robert Hughes, PPS to Ted Heath and dampish MP for Harrow West, put into words what everyone was thinking. 
 &bquo;A Conservative Cabinet without you is like Hamlet without the prince.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Tea room talk shows high interest in Lawson 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correspondent 
 HAD Nigel Lawson toured the tea bars at the Blackpool Winter Gardens yesterday, he would have found one topic on everyone's lips &mdash; increased interest rates. 
 Several grass-roots supporters want their concern about interest rates and higher mortgages to be brought out in the open tomorrow when Mr Lawson replies to the debate on the economy. 
 But the Chancellor would have drawn considerable heart for his important speech. 
 A straw-poll of representatives yesterday showed support for the Chancellor is remarkably resilient. 
 The vitriolic attack on Mr Lawson in the Daily Mail had few supporters. 
 &bquo;Who are you going to put in his place?&equo; many said when asked about the call for his sacking. 
 One party worker from a Midlands constituency said: &bquo;I don't mind how many kids he's got, but Cecil Parkinson is too lightweight to become Chancellor. 
 Nigel has got nerve. 
 This party likes nerve. 
 The Tory Party likes taking the medicine. 
 But it needs to know it is getting better.&equo; 
 Several indicated they would be looking to Mr Lawson to give the Tory voters a reason for enduring the pain of higher mortgages. 
 But the Chancellor may have a hard time explaining why the pound has to shadow the Deutschmark. 
 &bquo;It's the fault of the Bundesbank, or is it the Bundestag?&equo; one perplexed representative said. 
 Another problem which Mr Lawson will have to address is the generation gap with the new Tory voters, who have grown up with Thatcherism. 
 A party worker from Cheadle said: &bquo;I have a boy of 30. 
 He was 20 when the Thatcher government came to power. 
 He doesn't remember inflation at 27 per cent. 
 Our real problem is that people are now comparing our performance with our own record.&equo; 
 A young Tory activist from Preston said: &bquo;We are the victims of our own success. 
 People have got used to years of growth. 
 This crisis has a lot to do with press hype.&equo; 
 There is resentment that the rise in interest rates has not been explained properly. 
 A middle-aged woman from St Helens said: &bquo;Mr Lawson doesn't seem to bother trying to get it across, but then most Chancellors are like that. 
 Personally, I'd like to bring back Sir Geoffrey Howe. 
 He got the economy straight.&equo; 
 Another representative said: &bquo;It's not us. 
 But it's our children, who have mortgages. 
 I have brought them up to support the Conservatives, but they are saying they are not going to vote again next time.&equo; 
 Grass-roots workers recognise the problems being stored up for the general election. 
 &bquo;People in my patch don't like being unpopular,&equo; a worker from Manchester said. 
 &bquo;They keep saying, &bquo;Why are they doing this to us?&equo; 
 ' Another worker, who stood as a Conservative councillor, said she had encountered Mr Lawson at a reception last year and had been asked by the Chancellor why she had lost. 
 &bquo;I told him straight. 
 I said it was because of your bloody policies. 
 Why didn't you save up the bad news for after May 5? 
 He didn't like that.&equo; 
 At least one MP was taking some solace from the economic medicine. 
 &bquo;It's put the shits up the middle-classes and it will stop them spending, which is what we want,&equo; he said. 
 The Conservative Conference: Conference quotes 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correspondent 
 &bquo;As Londoners, desperately worried about the present route of the Channel tunnel, what do we say to those who think the Talis alternative is beneficial?&equo; &mdash; Chris Fraser, Peckham &bquo;Out of the huge crowd of demonstrators, a woman ran out and thrust a baby in my arms &mdash; then she vanished&equo; &mdash; Kenneth Clarke, Secretary of State for Health &bquo;Polluted rivers, filthy streets, bodies bedded-down in doorways are no advertisement for a prosperous or caring society&equo; - Michael Heseltine &bquo;We know that God has endowed her with that great quality of not fidgeting when it is necessary to come to grips with prickly nettles&hellip; 
 Mrs Thatcher epitomises that something extra in womanhood. 
 Mrs Thatcher enhances the meaning of womanhood&equo; &mdash; Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi, Chief Minister of the KwaZulu 
 The Conservative Conference: Immigrants leaflet causes row 
 By JUDY JONES 
 A TORY MP last night appeared to defend the circulation of an immigration leaflet by a right wing pressure group, depicting a wave of black figures falling from a dustbin on to a map of Britain, writes Judy Jones. 
 Tim Janman, MP for Thurrock, was asked for his view at the Monday Club fringe meeting, attended by about 40 people, that the leaflet had advertised. 
 He said: &bquo;If you look at the lack of immigration control in the past, then yes, in the Fifties, Sixties and Seventies Britain had become the dustbin of the world.&equo; 
 There was a need to offer voluntary repatriation to members of ethnic minorities settled in the UK, he said. 
 Earlier, David Hunt, Minister of State for Environment, denounced the Monday Club leaflet. 
 Holding up a copy at a One Nation Forum fringe meeting, he said: &bquo;We can do without that. 
 Let us get to the real matter in hand &mdash; how to develop our relationship with the ethnic minorities.&equo; 
 Mr Janman clashed at the Monday Club meeting with fellow Tory Mike Truman, who contested Ealing Southall for the party at the last election. 
 He said: &bquo;You are saying that all those people in my constituency &bquo;We don't want you. 
 We detest you so much we will bribe you to go away.&equo; 
 However, Mr Janman countered that ethnic minority groups did not wish to integrate with the indigenous population. 
 Today's debates: social security and pensions; environment and planning; law and order; education; and the poll tax and local government. 
 The Conservative Conference: Tories closer to standing in Ulster 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 THE RULING body of the Conservative Party yesterday gave way to rank-and-file pressure and moved a step nearer to sanctioning official party candidates in Northern Ireland. 
 At the close of unusually emotional debate, Sir Peter Lane, chairman of the National Union Executive Committee, agreed to recommend affiliation to the party of a model Conservative association set up in North Down. 
 Last November the executive committee turned down North Down's application. 
 But by an overwhelming majority on a show of hands vote, party representatives demanded it reconsider the decision at the earliest possible opportunity. 
 John Strafford of Beaconsfield was given a standing ovation after declaring that the people of Northern Ireland had &bquo;more than earned the right to be members of the Conservative Party&equo;. 
 One potential embarrassment for the Government in the move is strong opposition of the Ulster Tories to the Anglo-Irish agreement. 
 There were jeers when Stephanie McKenzie-Hill argued that the North Down association should be asked for a commitment to support the party manifesto, including the agreement. 
 Providing the National Union executive accepts Sir Peter's recommendation, the North Down Tories intend to field a candidate in the next general election. 
 There was delight among Ulster Tories, present as observers. 
 Laurence Kennedy, their chairman, hailed it as &bquo;a new start for Northern Ireland&equo;. 
 He acknowledged they were at odds with the Government over the agreement, but said the North Down association would support the party manifesto. 
 Moving the affiliation motion, Phil Gallie, Ayr constituency, was cheered when he discounted fears of a final break with the unionist parties. 
 &bquo;All United Kingdom citizens should have the opportunity to select on broad base policy option as opposed to narrow sectarian appeal,&equo; he declared. 
 Backing for Hong Kong over ivory stockpile 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 HONG KONG won British backing yesterday for a plan to continue trading from its stockpile of ivory, even if a world-wide ban is agreed by Cites, the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species. 
 Hong Kong has objected to the proposed ban because its stockpile of 670 tonnes &mdash; the tusks of up to 75,000 elephants &mdash; is worth &dollar;134m, while at least 3,000 jobs in the colony depend on the ivory carving industry. 
 Chris Folland, head of the British delegation to Cites, said yesterday: &bquo;All of Hong Kong's 670 tonnes were legally imported, in accordance with the provisions of Cites. 
 Hong Kong supports a ban on trade in new ivory, and we believe it now has a villain-proof system for its stocks. 
 &bquo;It is up to this meeting to decide what happens to those stocks, but we see no reason for Hong Kong to be penalised.&equo; 
 In a statement circulated to delegates yesterday &mdash; as the full debate on the proposed ban got under way &mdash; the Hong Kong government said that, while new ivory should be banned from trade, &bquo;properly controlled trading of legally-acquired and legally-held ivory should be allowed to continue&equo;. 
 Shaharyar Khan, Pakistan's High Commissioner in London, unfurling his country's flag outside the Commonwealth Institute, west London, yesterday 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 Shaharyar Khan, Pakistan's High Commissioner in London, unfurling his country's flag outside the Commonwealth Institute, west London, yesterday. 
 Pakistan rejoined the Commonwealth on 1 October, having left 17 years ago in protest at the recognition of the breakaway state of Bangladesh, formerly East Pakistan  
 Five years in prison proposed for hackers 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 COMPUTER hacking should be outlawed by three new criminal offences to curb the use of computers for serious crimes and maintain confidence in computer systems, the Law Commission recommended yesterday. 
 There should a widely-drawn &bquo;basic&equo; summary offence of unauthorised entry into a computer system, an aggravated offence of unauthorised entry with intent to commit or assist in serious crime, and a further serious offence of altering computer-held data or programs. 
 The two serious offences should carry maximum jail terms of five years. 
 It was not enough to patch up existing gaps in the criminal law, the commission said. 
 Announcing the recommendations, Lord Justice Beldam, its chairman, said hacking was &bquo;far from being a youthful prank&equo; and caused serious consequences. 
 The commission's final report, which contrasts with tentative suggestions 12 months ago, was welcomed by Nicholas Ridley, Secretary of State for Trade and Industry. 
 &bquo;The Government considers that legislation should be brought forward when a suitable opportunity arises,&equo; he said. 
 The Department of Trade is seeking further comments, which should be submitted as soon as possible. 
 The report represents a victory for the Confederation of British Industry and a lobby led by Emma Nicholson, Tory MP for Devon West and Torridge, which had campaigned for tough new laws. 
 The CBI endorsed the report yesterday. 
 The basic offence would cover amateur hackers who access systems for fun and would be intended to act as a general deterrent to all types of hacking. 
 Eric Howe, the Data Protection Registrar, had argued that the activities of the mischievous or curious should not be criminalised. 
 But the commission accepts that since the simple offence would cover deliberate foolishness which caused cost and inconvenience but which did not damage property or seek dishonest gain, the penalty should be modest and limited to a maximum of three months' imprisonment. 
 It will not carry police powers of arrest and search of premises. 
 The commission accepts that the basic offence might not lead to many convictions. 
 But Richard Buxton QC, a commissioner, said: &bquo;The introduction of a hierarchy of offences will convey the message that this conduct is no longer responsible or funny. 
 We expect that to have a substantial effect.&equo; 
 Big business was spending millions of pounds on security to deter simple unauthorised access. 
 The offence of hacking with intent to commit serious crime &mdash; including all serious forms of dishonesty, serious offences against the person and blackmail &mdash; would enable criminals to be apprehended earlier, he said. 
 The third offence would cover the use of worms, viruses, Trojan horses or logic bombs and include both attacks on particular computers and the putting into circulation of infected computer disks that eventually cause unauthorised alterations to computer material. 
 The current law of malicious damage produced far too erratic and uncertain results. 
 Special safeguards will apply to protect employees of system operators to ensure that those who are careless or negligent will not be accused of criminal offences. 
 The commission rejected submissions that Police and Criminal Evidence Act rules on the admissibility of computer print-outs in evidence are too strict. 
 Barrister warns of &bquo;blackmail charter&equo; 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 OUTLAWING basic computer hacking will amount to &bquo;a charter for blackmail&equo; and will drive innocent youngsters underground and into the hands of serious criminals, according to Alistair Kelman, a barrister who is an expert on computer law. 
 He said yesterday that young people who hack innocently and for fun will be more inclined to listen to approaches from potential evil doers. 
 &bquo;Having committed one offence and been given a criminal recordfor innocent hacking, they may feel that they might as well get in a bit deeper.&equo; 
 Mr Kelman believes that the net result of the Law Commission proposal will be to increase the risks to companies because hackers who often tell their &bquo;victims&equo; about their insecure systems will be afraid to do so. 
 It will also decrease the likelihood of catching hardened computer criminals by turning informers into criminals, and allow computer manufacturers to carry on selling insecure computers for applications where they should not be used. 
 Stephen Gold, who gained notoriety for his part in hacking into the Duke of Edinburgh's Prestel mailbox, said that the law would not be enforceable. 
 &bquo;No information will be obtained from hackers because they will be afraid of prosecution.&equo; 
 A more sinister problem was that of hackers being approached by serious criminals, he said. 
 &bquo;If I was approached by a terrorist to undermine the Bank of England, my immediate reaction would be to tell the police. 
 Now a hacker in that situation would have to think twice.&equo; 
 Mr Gold has been asked, in the past, to undertake various hacking acts, including a request from Stern, the West German magazine, to hack into the Princess of Wales's Barclaycard account. 
 Adding his voice to the outcry against outlawing simple unauthorised entry into computers, Budley Salterton (not his real name) warned: &bquo;It's not the catch-all they (the Law Commission) hope for. 
 It might put less determined hackers off, but it does not remove the challenge so it won't stop hacking.&equo; 
 The law could result in less security for business. 
 &bquo;A lot of hacking goes on inside companies by employees trying to find easier ways of doing their jobs. 
 This is often picked up by the programmers, who then make the system more secure.&equo; 
 The Confederation of British Industry rejected criticism that companies and manufacturers with poor security can hide behind the law. 
 If the recommendations became law, unauthorised entry to a computer through carelessness would technically be an offence, so there was more of an onus on companies to ensure that all employees knew exactly what they were authorised to do, a spokesman said. 
 However, Mr Kelman is convinced that a law against hacking for fun will hamper the investigation and prosecution of computer crime. 
 &bquo;My experience is that hackers are the world's innocents &mdash; they can so easily be manipulated,&equo; he said. 
 Shortly after the commission's report was made public, Alan Soloman, a computer virus expert, invited hackers, and those whose business it is to keep them out, to a tournament which will test the expertise of both sides. 
 Jury told of blood on car 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 A MAN accused of killing Marie Wilks arrived at a friend's house with a thick smudge of blood on his car the day after she disappeared, the M50 murder trial was told yesterday. 
 Kerry Evans said at Shrewsbury Crown Court that he asked Edward Browning about the blood, and was told that it must have come from an animal he had hit while driving to Scotland. 
 Mr Evans, of Inverurie, near Aberdeen, said that Mr Browning telephoned him from South Wales on the evening of 18 June last year to say he wanted to visit. 
 He noticed the blood on the mudguard of Mr Browning's Renault 25 the day after his arrival. 
 Mr Browning, 36, of Cwm-parc, Mid Glamorgan, denies murdering Mrs Wilks, 22, whose body was found below an embankment on the M50 near Tewkesbury. 
 Scottish solicitors' monopoly over conveyancing fees to be ended 
 By MARK DOUGLAS HOME, Scottish Correspondent 
 SCOTTISH solicitors' monopoly over charging fees for conveyancing is to be ended and their rights of audience extended to Scotland's supreme courts, the High Court and Court of Session. 
 The changes are two of the principle proposals contained in a government policy paper on the Scottish legal system published yesterday. 
 Malcolm Rifkind, Secretary of State for Scotland, described the move as a modernising exercise. 
 &bquo;We are removing some of the cobwebs on the fringes of the Scottish legal system.&equo; 
 However, Alistair Clark, president of the Law Society of Scotland, which represents 6,400 solicitors, criticised the decision to allow banks, building societies and other authorised practitioners who complied with a statutory code of conduct to charge for conveyancing. 
 The present system, involving solicitors who &bquo;put the interests of their clients first&equo;, was being replaced by &bquo;a free market which will be a free-for-all among a handful of powerful, profit-motivated instititutions serving the financial interests of their shareholders.&equo; 
 Alan Johnston QC, treasurer of the 250-strong Faculty of Advocates, said: &bquo;The disappearance of many small legal firms which rely on conveyancing income to underwrite the provision of other, non-profitable legal services will not be in the public interest.&equo; 
 The faculty also opposed the move to extend the rights of audience to suitably qualified solicitors, &bquo;not to protect a monopoly&equo;, but because it felt the administration of justice might suffer. 
 However, Mr Johnston was delighted by the Government's decision on lawyers' partnerships, a view not shared by the Law Society of Scotland. 
 The Government plans to remove the statutory barrier to the formation of partnerships between solicitors and non-solicitors. 
 However, the document adds: &bquo;Those who practise in the courts owe duties to the court in the interests of justice&equo;. 
 Thus, the professions might continue to regard rules limiting &bquo;forms of organisation among their members as necessary&equo;. 
 These would require the Secretary of State's approval. 
 But Mr Clark said this section of the policy document left &bquo;more questions unanswered than answered&equo;. 
 Those who practised in court would be protected from multi-discipline partnerships. 
 But what would that mean for a partnership of solicitors where some practised in court and others did not. 
 But the faculty welcomed the Government's view. 
 It had opposed partnerships of advocates, believing they would reduce choice and efficiency. 
 More companies impose curbs on smoking at work 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 SMOKING has become the main health concern of companies, with a sharp rise in the number introducing policies to control smoking at work, a conference on the issue was told yesterday. 
 But, as Action on Smoking and Health predicted that within a few years the majority of companies will have smoking policies, Roger Stubbs, deputy managing director of MORI, warned a confrontation is looming between &bquo;green consumers&equo; and &bquo;smoking civil libertarians&equo; who insist aggressively on their right to smoke in public places or at work. 
 A MORI survey of more than 100 personnel directors at the top 500 companies and financial institutions, shows four out of five have designated no-smoking areas. 
 Nearly a third have introduced restrictions, or further restrictions, on smoking in the past 12 months. 
 Two years ago, barely two-thirds of top businesses questioned had such policies. 
 Only one in seven has a complete ban, Mr Stubbs said. 
 Most have no-smoking areas or designated smoking rooms, but more than half the companies still without restrictions reported less tolerance for smokers. 
 Almost four out of five people now accept passive smoking is harmful, the MORI surveys show. 
 That, coupled with an estimated 50 million working days a year lost to smoking-related illness, means companies now list smoking as their main health concern for male employees and second most important, after VDU and computer worries, for women. 
 Mr Stubbs told the Bupa symposium: &bquo;The big anti-smoking battalions are in the ascendant. 
 Smoking in the workplace is becoming less and less acceptable. 
 Many smokers feel guilty about their habit and most would like to give up.&equo; 
 But there is, he said, &bquo;a hard core of vociferous and aggressive smokers&equo;. 
 &bquo;They are outraged at blanket smoking bans, in workplaces or aeroplanes, for example. 
 The green consumers are heading for a confrontation with the smoking civil libertarians.&equo; 
 Many of the latter were young, in their twenties, and included &bquo;yuppies&equo; in City and financial institutions who might not smoke a lot but took the attitude that they would smoke more at work if people pressured them over their habit. 
 Some companies which have introduced smoking restrictions have faced resignations over the issue, he said. 
 Twenty per cent of smokers in the MORI surveys deny passive smoking is harmful, and 10 per cent believe smoking does not cause fatal diseases. 
 &bquo;Views are polarising,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There are people who are &bquo;smokers and proud of it&equo; who are coming up against the trend that the rest of society wants to see.&equo; 
 The survey shows that more than half the companies which have smoking restrictions introduced them after pressure from the workforce, with a quarter having the issue raised through health and safety committees. 
 Mark Flanagan, of Ash, said companies were also concerned that passive smoking will fall within the Health and Safety at Work Act now it is a proven health risk. 
 Five years ago, he said, Ash could list only a handful of companies with smoking restrictions. 
 &bquo;Many&hellip; had a complete ban and had been no-smoking from the start because they perceived that smoking did not fit in with their ethos &mdash; Boots, for example, or the Body Shop.&equo; 
 At that time Ash was getting about 20 inquiries a month, mostly from employees, on how to introduce smoking polices. 
 &bquo;Now we get 200 a month, of which more than 100 are coming from employers who want to develop such policies&hellip; 
 Within a few years we will see the majority of UK companies having smoking policies.&equo; 
 There were no excuses now, he said, about it being difficult to do. 
 BP, ICL, IBM, Volvo, British Gas in Wales, British Telecom in the South-west, and a clutch of local authorities, many of which had led the way, had all shown it could be done, with Ford announcing its partial ban recently. 
 Central government departments, however, had been slower to react. 
 Ash, he said, did not advocate complete bans on smoking. 
 These should be considered only where designated smoking areas could not be provided. 
 &bquo;It should be done on the basis of the right of non-smokers to breathe smoke-free air, but wherever possible taking account of the needs of those who smoke.&equo; 
 Nicotine addicts' stairway to heaven 
 By NICHOLAS TIMMINS, Health Services Correspondent 
 SHEILA KEOGH and Carol Morrison are perched on the stairs outside their third floor office, lighting up again. 
 Six months on from ICL's decision to introduce a no smoking at work policy at its Reading office block, it is still possible to indulge in an on-site nicotine fix. 
 The policy has been applied nationwide at the company's 100 locations after a pioneering attitude survey at Reading, where 81 per cent of the workforce were found to be non-smokers. 
 In the city-centre block, there is a ground-floor coffee room with ashtrays, easy chairs and potted plants set aside for smokers. 
 But, despite its echoes of furtive schoolday puffs behind the bikesheds, Sheila and Carol prefer the stairwell. 
 &bquo;We can hear the phones, and it saves a trek downstairs,&equo; says Sheila, who has been smoking for 25 years. 
 Before workrooms were deemed no-smoking zones, the small admin room where the two work was known as &bquo;the gas chamber&equo; because of the fug generated by five smokers. 
 Now, though the office air is clean, the butt-crammed ashtray outside testifies that smoking is far from stubbed out. 
 Both women went to a &bquo;smoking cessation course&equo; the company laid on before the policy went on stream. 
 But they did not stick it out. 
 &bquo;It was good for those who were determined to give up &mdash; and a couple of people did. 
 But I don't think we had the right attitude,&equo; Sheila says. 
 Their fellow worker Paul Sinclair, a 20-a-day man, takes the stairwell option. 
 He cut down to five when the policy was introduced, but is back to pre-ban levels. 
 Cathy Wallis, a computer programmer, believes the policy has improved the quality of her working life and would definitely think twice about accepting a job where smoking was the norm. 
 She feels sorry for smokers &mdash; &bquo;Nowadays, I think it is looked on as a sort of disability&equo;. 
 The Reading attitude survey found 15 per cent of smokers &mdash; and 67 per cent of non-smokers &mdash; favoured a total ban. 
 Implementation has been left to local managers, who appear to have baulked at that option. 
 The &bquo;ghetto&equo; policy at Reading has posed no problems for life-time smoker Stan Peat, employed in security. 
 &bquo;If I want a cig I can come in the coffee room.&equo; 
 But, down the road at Bracknell, ICL plans to ban smoking throughout its new building. 
 Stubbing out his butt, Stan shudders at the prospect. 
 Bankers &bquo;have no debt-swap claim&equo; 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 FIVE BANKS, which could lose over &pound;100m if money market transactions by the London Borough of Hammersmith and Fulham are ruled unlawful, should not be allowed to appear at the hearing into their legality, the High Court was told yesterday. 
 Anthony Scrivener QC, for Hammersmith and Fulham, was presenting the council's case on the fifth day of a hearing in which the district auditor is seeking to have the transactions declared ultra vires, or beyond the local authority's legal powers. 
 Mr Scrivener said: &bquo;This court has no power to order repayment of ultra vires expenditure,&equo; and he commented on the presence of bank representatives, saying: &bquo;I have difficulty with them being here.&equo; 
 If the banks wanted to seek relief, they would have to do so through a separate case brought against the local authority, he added. 
 Although the banks will begin to present their arguments today, Mr Scrivener said: &bquo;This court is not concerned with private rights. 
 There is no justiciable issue between the auditor and the banks.&equo; 
 The two judges, Lord Justice Woolf and Mr Justice French, widened the scope of the hearing by ruling that arguments about the enforceability of the transactions could be presented. 
 With the council now agreeing with the district auditor about the unlawfulness of the deals, which at one time involved a notional &pound;6bn, the banks are the only parties arguing that the transactions should be enforced. 
 Mr Scrivener said that while the council did have the right to take out interest-rate swaps for debt management, other types of transaction were ultra vires. 
 However, he accepted that the council was &bquo;involved in an exercise of trading&equo; rather than attempting to manage its debt and that local authorities cannot be involved in trading activities without a specific power to do so. 
 If the transactions are found to be lawful and enforceable and interest rates remain high, the council stands to lose at least &pound;69.1 million - the estimated negative value of its portfolio in February. 
 Hurd urged to bring in laws on use of video &bquo;spy&equo; cameras 
 By PHIL REEVES 
 LAWS should be passed controlling the rapidly increasing use of video &bquo;spy&equo; cameras in public places, the National Council for Civil Liberties said today. 
 The pressure group has written to Douglas Hurd, the Home Secretary, warning of a &bquo;serious risk&equo; to civil liberties unless statutory regulations are introduced. 
 It says video surveillance is currently only subject to &bquo;vague and inadequate&equo; government guidelines. 
 Hundreds of thousands of small, sometimes hidden, cameras have been installed in the last decade, mainly to detect crime or monitor traffic. 
 Last year, about &pound;30m of closed-circuit television equipment was imported. 
 Video monitoring is widely used by local authorities, the police, companies and private security firms. 
 In some cases, cameras which produce high definition close-up pictures are linked to video recorders or to screens in police stations. 
 At present, the use of such systems is not covered by any statutory regulations. 
 Local authorities using video cameras determine their own controls. 
 Although some apply strict guidelines, others contract out their surveillance to private security companies. 
 In a research paper published today, Liberty &mdash; the logo used by the NCCL - warns that, without regulations, video surveillance could be used to harass groups who are considered a potential threat to public order, such as young people, ethnic minorities and political activists. 
 It warns that the spread of vast computer data banks means it will soon be possible to identify individuals walking along a street, whether or not they have committed a crime: &bquo;The new PNC2 police national computer will be capable of storing digitised photographs to which detectives will have instant access.&equo; 
 The paper states: &bquo;It is not implausible to foresee a situation in which central government exercises increasing control over the ordinary movements and activities of its citizens. 
 Big Brother could be watching. 
 . on every street corner, and democratic dissent could be inhibited.&equo; 
 It warns that recorded material could be used by blackmailers. 
 In addition, data could be passed to the police, private detectives or computer database holders. 
 Widespread surveillance threatens to alienate the public. 
 Liberty is proposing regulations, including a rule requiring anyone installing cameras to supply the authorities with valid reasons for doing so. 
 The laws should be backed up by an effective inspectorate, it states. 
 Video users should also have to give the number and location of their cameras, post public warning notices, and specify who is entitled to operate the system. 
 Private security firms using surveillance systems should be subject to inspections. 
 Liberty also suggests that video users should apply to their local authority for a licence, allowing objectors to register their opposition. 
 Video systems at football grounds should be regulated and individuals should have the right to see any recorded evidence used against them. 
 The group also condemns the Government for failing to carry out research into its effectiveness. 
 &bquo;Extravagant claims for its effectiveness are often based on anecdotal evidence,&equo; it says. 
 Nuns gain court reprieve for hens Court reprieves nuns' hen flock 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 FOURTEEN NUNS battling to save their flock of 5,000 chickens from slaughter have won a further reprieve. 
 Lawyers representing the nuns from the Our Lady of the Passion Monastery, Daventry, Northamptonshire, were yesterday granted a judicial review of the Ministry of Agriculture order to slaughter the chickens. 
 This followed a private hearing before Mr Justice Konrad Schiemann in London. 
 It is alleged that the flock is infected with Salmonella typhimurium. 
 The judicial review hearing will take place on Friday in the High Court when the full arguments will be presented, according to Dennis Cooper, who is representing the nuns. 
 In a written application for the review, lawyers said the decision to slaughter was made &bquo;despite a significant lack of evidence of a connection between the food poisoning outbreak in Bedworth and the monastery&equo;. 
 Ministry officials were also accused of giving conflicting evidence, leaving doubt as to the accuracy and reliability of reports of infection. 
 They had refused to supply details of alleged infection and this deprived the nuns of a chance to determine whether mistakes had been made, the lawyers said. 
 They said the failure to give full reasons for the intended slaughter and the absence of any factual basis for the action justified the High Court in blocking the order. 
 The ministry claims that an outbreak of food poisoning in July, at Bedworth, near Daventry, caused by Salmonella typhimurium was traced to the monastery. 
 However, the nuns said the ministry changed its account after initially telling them that Salmonella enteriditis was responsible. 
 Richard North, an environmental health officer advising the nuns, said last night that they were all &bquo;delighted&equo; with the outcome. 
 Mother Catherine, 82, the mother superior, will attend the hearing on Friday, he said. 
 Mr North is technical adviser to the United Kingdom Egg Producers' Association, which has launched an appeal to meet the nuns' legal costs. 
 A spokesman for the ministry said it would continue consultation with Mother Catherine, and would be studying the papers submitted by the lawyers. 
 &bquo;There is still a statutory obligation to slaughter the flock,&equo; he said. 
 UN protest over Kurd ignored 
 By NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 THE HOME OFFICE is pressing ahead with the deportation of a Kurdish refugee, in spite of protests from the United Nations High Commission for Refugees that his life could be in danger if he returns to Turkey. 
 A High Commission official has interviewed Selahattin Ozberk, 30, and a doctor who examined him said that he is potentially suicidal and has scars which appear to be from beatings in Turkey. 
 He is likely to be put on an aircraft in the next few days. 
 The commission said: &bquo;We feel he is a genuine political refugee who has reason to fear persecution. 
 The Government's decision to deport him is regrettable, but the matter is out of our hands.&equo; 
 The commission is effectively saying the Government has not followed the UN Convention for Refugees, under which anyone with a well-founded fear of persecution should be granted asylum. 
 Mr Ozberk is one of 18 Kurds still detained at the Haslar Centre for young offenders near Gosport, Hampshire, all of whom face deportation. 
 A further seven were released yesterday, and seven on Monday night. 
 His solicitor, Michael Hanley, said: &bquo;We expect a date for his deportation is imminent. 
 He says he has been beaten and kicked in his local police station in Turkey. 
 They want to know the whereabouts of his brother, who is a member of an illegal Kurdish independence organisation and in hiding. 
 His fear is that he will be tortured to extract information about his brother. 
 He doesn't think he'll be able to resist. 
 He broke down and cried when we talked to him about it.&equo; 
 Mr Ozberk, who has been refused leave for a judicial review, is left with no right of appeal &mdash; unless he first returns to Turkey, where his wife and three children live. 
 The Charter 87 campaign group for refugee rights wrote yesterday to Timothy Renton, Minister of State at the Home Office, pleading for a reprieve. 
 PC says he was handed &bquo;sex on plate&equo; 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 A UNIFORMED police constable accused of raping a young mother on the front seat of his patrol car claimed yesterday that she had handed him &bquo;sex on a plate&equo;. 
 Peter Anderson, 41, told an Old Bailey jury the woman, 18, suddenly became passionate and initiated intercourse. 
 But under cross-examination, he was accused of deliberately setting out to besmirch her character. 
 Mr Anderson had also claimed to investigating officers that the woman told him she had had three Aids tests and was taking a contraceptive pill. 
 Her doctor had told the jury she was not on the pill and knew of no tests. 
 Richard Carey, for the prosecution, said: &bquo;Your intention was to blacken the woman's character. 
 That is what you have been doing by lying about the many things you say took place.&equo; 
 Mr Carey added: &bquo;You were so keen to have your own way with her that you disregarded the fact that you could have made her pregnant.&equo; 
 Mr Anderson replied: &bquo;No, she said she was on the pill.&equo; 
 Mr Anderson, married with two sons and based at Surbiton, has denied raping the woman after agreeing to take her home from a discotheque last March. 
 He told the jury yesterday that he had never threatened her with his truncheon, but he had offered to use it as a sexual aid. 
 Mr Anderson said he had driven to the allotment after the woman suggested going somewhere quiet. 
 He knew of the spot because it was the habit of patrolling officers to stop &bquo;and have a glass of wine or a chat&equo;. 
 &bquo;Does that mean other police officers might have been there?, he was asked. 
 &bquo;Most definitely yes,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Anderson also admitted checking to see if the woman had a police record. 
 Asked why by the judge, he said it was because of fears about Aids. 
 Salmon cash 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 Salmon angling contributed &pound;50m to the Scottish economy last year and generated 3,400 jobs, according to a study for the Scottish Tourist Board and the Highlands and Islands Development Board. 
 The declining salmon netting industry contributed only &pound;3m. 
 Leisure complex 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 Councillors in Bromley, south-east London, gave outline planning permission for a multi-million pound sports and leisure complex on the historic Crystal Palace site. 
 The proposal, by Al Houda and Holiday Inns, includes a 150-bedroom hotel and multi-screen cinema. 
 Man questioned 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 Police were questioning a 30-year-old man in connection with the murder of Elizabeth Page-Alucard, 41, the counsellor who was found dead on Saturday at a drugs advisory centre in Worcester. 
 Arts agreement 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 Managers and unions at the South Bank arts complex in London agreed to reopen talks in their pay dispute. 
 A meeting of staff agreed to a concordat under which the unions will suspend industrial action and the management agrees not to terminate any contracts during the talks. 
 Ambulance talks 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 Management in the ambulance dispute told Acas, the conciliation service, that they had no intention of acceding to union demands. 
 Management leaders repeated their refusal to countenance arbitration over the 6.5 per cent offer. 
 Inquiry plea on collusion claim 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 A group of lawyers from Britain and Europe called for a judicial inquiry into allegations of collusion between loyalist paramilitaries and the security forces in Northern Ireland. 
 In a report today, the lawyers, including representatives of the National Council for Civil Liberties and the Haldane Society, criticise Douglas Hogg, the former Home Office minister, and the RUC for accusing some solicitors of holding IRA sympathies. 
 A loaded pistol and a small quantity of explosives were found in Belfast's Crumlin Road jail as a search continued after an IRA attempt to stage a breakout. 
 Police face discipline moves 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 Policemen standing yards from where 95 soccer fans died in the Hillsborough football stadium disaster were last night expecting disciplinary charges. 
 They are accused of failing to use their initiative and not opening emergency gates. 
 Some South Yorkshire policemen have already been served with discipline papers &mdash; an early notification of any complaint which might lead to a disciplinary hearing &mdash; by West Midlands officers investigating handling of the disaster. 
 Debate grows over whether time is ripe to join ERM: Falling pound puts Conservatives under pressure at Blackpool, from industry and the Press 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS and PETER TORDAY 
 THE RAW political pressure for an early decision to join the European exchange rate mechanism (ERM) was increased at Blackpool yesterday by a coincidental pincer movement headed by Michael Heseltine and the Daily Mail. 
 Entry has long been opposed by Margaret Thatcher and her No 10 economic adviser, Sir Alan Walters &mdash; resisting the overtures of Nigel Lawson and Sir Geoffrey Howe with the brick-wall response that the pound would enter &bquo;when the time is ripe&equo;. 
 But there was increased speculation on the Conservative Party conference fringe in Blackpool that an urgent decision on full membership of the European Monetary System (EMS) could get the Government off the economic and political hook of high interest rates, a falling pound, and massive Bank of England intervention in the markets. 
 Because of the market sensitivity of such a decision, ministers were refusing to respond to questions. 
 But one well-placed Cabinet source did say privately that he would not put money on it; there was no such thing as an easy answer to current problems; and that ERM entry would be tantamount to jumping from &bquo;the puddle and into the pond&equo;. 
 Speaking at a packed fringe meeting, however, Mr Heseltine urged quick action. 
 He said the Chancellor had had no choice but to put interest rates up last week. 
 But he then added: &bquo;I hope the Government will not delay further its clear commitment to join the full EMS. 
 &bquo;The full credibility of its strategy would then be enhanced. 
 A formal relationship with the Deutschmark would signal the long-term determination to accept the discipline that our counter-inflationary policy needs. 
 &bquo;Outside, but shadowing the Deutschmark, we deny ourselves the support of the system at times of currency fluctuation.&equo; 
 Commenting on the falling pound, he said: &bquo;We could accept a lower parity as part of a decision to join because it would be coupled with the disciplines of the exchange rate mechanism. 
 &bquo;To accept the lower parity without the disciplines would be to license the inflationary wage settlements that have characterised post-war Britain.&equo; 
 The challenge was underlined by yesterday's scathing front-page &bquo;Daily Mail Comment&equo; attack on the Chancellor, which concluded: &bquo;The pound should be allowed to fall. 
 Britain should then join the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System, which Mrs Thatcher keeps promising to do when the time is ripe.&equo; 
 Nevertheless, there are some senior Conservatives who subscribe to a long-standing conspiracy theory; that the time would come when such a sterling crisis would happen &mdash; and would force Mrs Thatcher toaccept the only alternative was ERM entry. 
 The economic and political debate over the merits of full EMS membership will now intensify. 
 It seems a highly attractive alternative to periodic sterling crises. 
 Proponents argue it would stabilise the pound and save Mr Lawson from resorting to the conventional answer to a currency crisis: a big emergency increase in interest rates. 
 Because Britain is already an EMS member, no legal changes are required for joining the exchange rate mechanism. 
 Mr Lawson would instruct Robin Leigh-Pemberton, Governor of the Bank of England, to begin secret negotiations with European central bank counterparts on the best exchange rate at which to enter. 
 In practice, that would have to be about the level at which sterling was trading in the foreign exchange markets. 
 If Britain chose a rate significantly above or below, currency market pressures could try to push the pound into line. 
 The decision to enter could be announced any time after completed negotiations and entry could take effect the next weekend, when markets are closed. 
 To become a full member, Britain would need to introduce several technical measures. 
 It would set a central rate for sterling against the European Currency Unit. 
 This is a hybrid of EC currencies increasingly traded on international capital markets and seen as a forerunner of a single European currency. 
 The Government would establish the limits within which sterling could trade above or below that central rate. 
 In practice, most member countries have set divergence limits of 2 &frac14; per cent either side of the central rate. 
 Italy and Spain negotiated divergence margins of 6 per cent. 
 It has been argued that Britain could adopt their position, but would eventually move to narrower trading margins. 
 To hold the pound within its margins the system requires a member country to intervene in the markets when its currency diverges 75 per cent of the way to its permitted fluctuation margins, either side of the central rate. 
 At the point of full divergence, Britain could call on other EMS central banks to hold the pound within its agreed trading limits. 
 It could also be obliged to change economic policies &mdash; such as raising or lowering interest rates and taxes &mdash; to reinforce intervention. 
 The advantage to Britain of ERM membership would be that, in addition to the Bank of England's &dollar;42bn of foreign currency reserves, the pound could be supported by other European central banks, such as the wealthy West German Bundesbank, making speculation against sterling a much riskier business. 
 More fundamentally, anchoring the pound to the ERM would, it is argued, link it to the successful anti-inflation policies of the Bundesbank, ensuring low inflation in Britain. 
 In turn that would reduce significantly interest rates in Britain. 
 Yet, in spite of repeated European calls for Britain to join the ERM, it is plain West Germany and France would not welcome British membership at present. 
 The tricky economic and political question is the exchange rate at which the pound would join the ERM. 
 The unspoken concern of West Germany and France is that if sterling joined the ERM at its present exchange rate, a devaluation might still be required in several months' time. 
 That would provoke a politically damaging general realignment of exchange rates within the system, which has managed without any changes since early 1987. 
 Opponents of membership, such as the Prime Minister, argue that whatever the right level of entry it is at least necessary to reduce inflation to the European average of roughly 3-4 per cent. 
 But in 1979, France joined with inflation of 10.4 per cent compared with 4 per cent in West Germany, a wider inflation differential than exists between Britain and Germany today. 
 The Government's dilemma is that sterling is falling because the financial markets no longer have faith in government policy towards the pound. 
 Mr Lawson has frequently ruled out supporting the pound by means other than interest rates. 
 But the stage has probably been reached where only a politically unacceptable increase in those rates would stabilise the currency. 
 But it is not only recession fears which drive down the pound. 
 Britain's current account deficit is likely to hit an unprecedented &pound;20bn this year. 
 Currency markets, however, take the view that the deficit is so large that only a lower exchange rate will help to speed up the adjustment. 
 Draw for Speelman after pawn blunder 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 JONATHAN SPEELMAN gave his supporters an anxious day in the sixth round of the Pilkington Glass World Chess Championship semi-finals yesterday. 
 One down against Jan Timman, with three left to play, he was looking for a solid advantage with the white pieces. 
 Instead a blunder in the opening left him a pawn down, on the verge of defeat. 
 Good technique in a Rook and pawn endgame, however, enabled him to salvage a draw. 
 While Timman played with impressive composure, Speelman seemed oddly distracted. 
 Quite apart from the blunder there was one moment near the end of the game when he was walking around on the stage of Sadler's Wells, unaware for a few minutes that it was his move. 
 Timman now leads by 3 &frac12; -2 &frac12;. 
 There was no play in the other semi-final yesterday, after Karpov's decision to take a time out; he leads Yusupov 2 &frac12; -1 &frac12;. 
 Both matches resume tomorrow after a rest day today. 
 Speelman was almost apologetic about his efforts to win the adjourned fourth game, with Rook and Bishop against Rook. 
 He had confidence in Timman's ability to hold this theoretically drawn endgame, but tested him for four hours on Monday before agreeing to share the point. 
 Here are the moves of the marathon fourth game. 
 &bquo;Mail&equo; joins anti-Lawson chorus (CORRECTED) 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS and MAGGIE BROWN 
 Correction (published 12 October 1989) appended to this article. 
 NIGEL LAWSON'S problems with the Tory conference were aggravated yesterday by a scathing front-page attack in the pro-Tory Daily Mail. 
 Under a banner headline, &bquo;This bankrupt Chancellor&equo;, and a cartoon of a tubby, bedraggled figure with empty pockets, the newspaper said he had betrayed the people, himself, his party and Prime Minister. 
 It said that he had reneged on his monetarist beliefs; that arrogance has been his undoing; and that his policy lay in ruins. 
 The article concluded: &bquo;The bankrupt Chancellor should go&hellip; 
 The right politician must be put in charge of the Treasury to bring the economy back to even keel, reduce the trade deficit and force both inflation and interest rates down in time for the next election. 
 &bquo;If the Government thinks this is a tall order, then the Daily Mail agrees with it. 
 But they got us into this mess, it's up to them to get us out of it. 
 If they fail, they will find themselves out of office.&equo; 
 The fact that the final article is likely to have been polished by Sir David English, the editor and long-standing friend of Margaret Thatcher, prompted speculation that the Number 10 knives were out for the Chancellor, and that his days might be numbered. 
 But when Sir David was asked whether Mr Lawson was being lined up as a scapegoat, he said: &bquo;These are problems of the economy and the Chancellor's handling of it. 
 You must not see all this as a Machiavellian plot. 
 It's a perfectly straightforward reaction to events.&equo; 
 Nevertheless, in the wake of last week's one-point hike in interest rates, Friday's Daily Mail commented that Mr Lawson had had little choice but to follow the West German increase. 
 &bquo;The Chancellor's time is evidently running out. 
 If his medicine is not visibly working soon, he will, like many of the unfortunate people who cannot afford their mortgage payment, have to be evicted from his comfortable home.&equo; 
 There was no hint then that the Mail was running on such a short fuse. 
 But Sir David said yesterday: &bquo;We've always had doubts about this policy, and the thing that now confirms our doubts is that it hasn't worked.&equo; 
 His instinctive editorial policy, and his mercurial reflection of reader moods, is a well-known feature of his journalistic style. 
 Asked whether yesterday's attack had been a case of spontaneous combustion, he said: &bquo;Look, it's a reaction that I put forward there on behalf of, as much as anything else, the readers of our newspaper. 
 We've certainly criticised this Chancellor, and we've certainly criticised Tory governments in the past.&equo; 
 Sir David, knighted in 1982, has swung his paper behind critical issues: it started campaigning on environmental issues a year ago just as the Conservatives switched tack. 
 Charles Wilson, editor of The Times, asked whether it was not damaging to devote so much space to the attack, said: &bquo;This conference should be discussing why this bankrupt policy isn't working. 
 He did have an alternative, he could have let the pound drop lower.&equo; 
 CORRECTION The statement attributed to Charles Wilson, editor of The Times, saying that Chancellor of the Exchequer should have let the pound drop lower, was in fact made by Sir David English, editor of the Daily Mail. 
 We apologise for the error. 
 Employers fear investment and jobs will be severely affected 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 INDUSTRY was divided last night on whether the economy was about to enter a damaging recession but there was general agreement that jobs and investment would be hit severely. 
 Ian Thompson, economic adviser to the Engineering Employers' Federation, which has 5,200 member firms, warned: &bquo;The basic message is that the UK economy is heading for recession, with reduction in investment, domestic demand and jobs.&equo; 
 The federation believes that 53,000 jobs in engineering will disappear next year &mdash; a fall of 2.5 per cent &mdash; with mechanical and electrical engineering and the car industry the worst affected. 
 Andrew Sentance, economics director at the Confederation of British Industry, said the economy was balanced on a knife-edge but it was not possible to say whether it was heading irretrievably for recession. 
 &bquo;There is no sense of crisis, of panic setting in among businesses yet, but if interest rates go up again it could be very detrimental,&equo; he said. 
 Nevertheless, the CBI, backed by the gloomiest forecast on output from its member firms in two-years, predicts that growth in investment will stagnate next year and unemployment will cease to fall. 
 &bquo;The levelling out of investment is worrying because it needs to grow so that UK industry can keep up with international competitors,&equo; Mr Sentance said. 
 ICI, Britain's second biggest exporter, said the fall in the value of the pound would make exports more competitive. 
 But it warned that the latest hike in interest rates could have serious repercussions for its UK customers by weakening demand. 
 Mr Thompson said that what marked out the drift to recession was that the service sector would be as badly hit as manufacturing at least, and possibly worse affected, unlike in the recession of 1981. 
 Healthy and rising exports would help balance out the squeeze in the domestic economy. 
 He said that the federation does not predict that any sector of engineering will increase employment next year, though it forecasts the civil aerospace industry will be least badly affected because of a backlog of orders and its high level of exports. 
 The CBI cautioned that the rise in mortgage rates would feed through into pressure for higher pay, raising the prospect of wage inflation and undermining businesses. 
 Its last detailed forecast, published before the latest increase in base rates, predicts unemployment rising to 1.72 million in the last quarter of this year. 
 Detective is suspended 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 A SECOND senior detective with a regional crime squad has been suspended after an internal inquiry into allowances irregularities. 
 The detective, whose name and rank have not been given, is a member of the Essex force and worked at the Brentwood office of the No 5 Regional Crime Squad, covering a large area of East Anglia and the South-east. 
 Two weeks ago, a detective inspector from the office was suspended as part of the inquiry by Chief Supt Peter Nevitt, a divisional commander in the force. 
 Essex police emphasised that the inquiry is separate from one into corruption at Brentwood. 
 PENSIONERS protesting outside Manchester's town hall where about 3,000 rallied yesterday at a Grey Power conference. 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 PENSIONERS protesting outside Manchester's town hall where about 3,000 rallied yesterday at a Grey Power conference. 
 They heard Jack Jones, the former transport workers' union leader, condemn British pensions as the worst in Europe and denounce means-testing for pensioners. 
 &bquo;It is time that Mr Lawson was targeted with all his friends. 
 Like Jim Larkin said in the First World War, &bquo;Hang the Kaiser and all his relatives&equo;,' he said. 
 Alf Morris, the Labour Party's spokesman for the disabled, promised that it would increase pensions above the rate of inflation. 
 VIDEO / Chilling case of child's play: A critical guide to films available for hire this month by Elkan Allan 
 By ELKAN ALLAN 
 Best of a full but not very dis tinguished rental month (the blockbusters are coming in November, leading with Rain Man, Roger Rabbit, Dangerous Liaisons and Mississippi Burning) is Parents (18 Vestron), which is simultaneously both scary and funny. 
 From the start of this modest but compelling chiller, you sense that the family, moving to suburban Indiana in 1958, has got a skewed and sinister undertow. 
 Just how black isn't fully apparent until about half-way through, when you discover that the glum little son (a brilliant performance by a child, Bryan Madorsky) of the happy couple (Randy Quaid and Mary Beth Hurt) has a great deal to be disturbed about. 
 To give away much more of first-time director Bob Balaban's plot would be a shame: sufficient to say that I was seriously put off meat and more cosily frightened than by any film since the original Halloween. 
 BEST OF THE REST The casting of Arnold Schwarzenegger and Danny De Vito as Twins (PG CIC) is funny in itself, and the comedy that Ivan Reitman (Ghostbusters) has fashioned for them is consistently inventive. 
 In its crazy way, it is more touching than the similar fraternal discovery in Rain Man. 
 Both Schwarzenegger as the nicest of guys and De Vito as a sneaky crook are surprisingly convincing and delightfully funny. 
 Dead Bang (18 Guild Home Video) marks a welcome comeback for John Frankenheimer in his Manchurian Candidate conspiracy mood. 
 Starting as a conventional thriller about a cop (Miami Vice's Don Johnson) with marital and drinking problems, it escalates excitingly. 
 Claims to be based on the real-life experiences of LAPD detective Jerry Beck. 
 Two goodies for the whole family: if Willow (PG RCA/Col 20 Oct) never quite manages to fulfill its own fantasies, it is nevertheless an impressive box of tricks. 
 In essence a simple sword-and-sorcery entertainment, it carries enough sophistication to keep adults as entertained as children. 
 A nice change for Joanne Whalley after Scandal. 
 And Danny, Champion Of The World (U Collins Home Video) is one of those occasional British children's films in the tradition of The Railway Children, where a horrid grown-up (here Robbie Coltrane with a moustache and slicked-back hair) is defeated by a kid (Samuel Irons) and his adult allies (notably real-life father Jeremy Irons). 
 The Dressmaker (15 MGM/UA Home Video) is an adaptation of Beryl Bainbridge's post-wartime novel about three women (Joan Plowright and Billie Whitelaw, turning in impeccable performances as sisters, and Jane Horrocks, holding her own as their ward) mixed up with American GIs. 
 Emotionally chilling and horribly convincing. 
 THE REST The return to low-budget film-making by the director of Halloween, John Carpenter, fails to generate anything like the same tension. 
 In They Live (18 Guild 26 Oct) the endless fist-fights are boring and the Orwellian tyrrannies familiar, to say the least. 
 The little-known cast is unlikely to become better known. 
 Something of the same quality of camp horror is to be found in The Blob (18 Braveworld 25 Oct), a remake of the 1958 B movie about a mysterious substance that eats people. 
 Remarkable special effects tend to get in the way of the story. 
 Madame Sousatzka (15 Virgin Video 20 Oct), is a sickly confection, turning Bernice Rubens's clear-eyed novel about a German refugee piano teacher and an 11-year-old Jewish prodigy into a star vehicle for Shirley MacLaine, now a Russian-American with a 14-year-old Indian pupil. 
 Messily directed by John Schlesinger, it fails to evoke admiration or sympathy for its characters. 
 A gallery of eccentric supports (including Twiggy and Peggy Ashcroft) cannot save it. 
 In 1969 (15 Entertainment in Video 25 Oct), Robert Downey Jnr and Kiefer Sutherland do well enough as heroic Vietnam War draft-dodgers. 
 Its heart is in the right place, the detail is right but the texture is wrong. 
 Lillian Gish, Bette Davis and Ann Sothern don't quite gel together in The Whales Of August (U Vestron 23 Oct). 
 Stubbornly a stage play and resisting all Lindsay Anderson's attempts at opening out, this study of old age is charming but static. 
 Stealing Home (15 Warner Home Video 13 Oct), one of a cycle of baseball stories, gets lost in a maze of flashbacks, as the self-regarding Mark Harmon returns home and scores home runs. 
 Jodie Foster, fresh from her triumphs in The Accused (released on video last month), is the only reason to bother, as with Five Corners (15 Pathe 13 Oct), where she is almost raped again and is carted about, unconscious, by a psychopath. 
 Punchline (PG RCA/Col 20 Oct) fails to convince that either Tom Hanks or Sally Field, who idolises but won't love him, are natural stand-up comedians, and the general standard of jokes is pretty thin all round. 
 However, Hanks's &bquo;Singin' In The Rain&equo; routine is brilliant. 
 Billy The Kid (15 Turner Home Entertainment 19 Oct), called on the titles &bquo;Gore Vidal's Billy The Kid&equo; because the novelist wrote the script, must be the twentieth remake of this particular story. 
 It has gone straight to video despite being promoted with a National Film Theatre lecture on 29 October. 
 Frankly, it is hard to see what Vidal has brought to the familiar myth, most recently remade as Young Guns. 
 In the name part, however, Val Kilmer is charismatic. 
 DOA (15 Buena Vista 12 Oct) is another remake, this time of a 1949 film noir, starting well as Dennis Quaid discovers he has been poisoned and will die within 24 hours: the initials stand for Dead On Arrival. 
 Unfortunately, it soon degenerates into an unconvincing whodunit. 
 Despite a large helping of hokum, Warlock (15 Medusa 18 Oct) makes the supernatural transition from 1691 to 1988 fairly successfully and with a touch or two of knowing humour. 
 To cast Julian Sands from A Room With A View and Richard E. Grant from How To Get Ahead In Advertising as a male witch and his pursuer shows a certain imagination, even if the whole affair is complete nonsense. 
 The only strength of Farewell To The King (PG Vestron 18 Oct), its exotic Borneo scenery, is lost on the small screen; the rest is mumbo-jumbo about leadership and how the egregious Nick Nolte achieved the position of chief to the savages. 
 Tequila Sunrise (Warner Home Video 13 Oct) is a dull thriller with the over-rated Mel Gibson and Kurt Russell as friendly enemies and Michelle Pfeiffer as an unconvincing restaurateuse. 
 The House On Carroll Street (PG Virgin Video PG) Kelly McGillis, blackballed by McCarthy, takes the job of reading to an elderly woman; across the garden is a dark old house whose mysterious goings-on intrigue her. 
 With the help of the unattractive Jeff Daniels as an FBI agent assigned to watch her, she solves the mystery, culminating in a sub-Hitchcockian chase over Grand Central Station's roof. 
 TICKET OFFER / Caught in the spider's web: From the Amnesty International Film Week in Bristol 
 By JAMES RAMPTON 
 THE Amnesty International Film Week &bquo;89 at the Watershed, Canons Rd, Bristol (0272-276444) presents a screening of Hector Babenco's gripping picture of life in a nameless Latin American jail, Kiss Of The Spiderwoman, with the Oscar-winning William Hurt (above) and Raul Julia, tonight at 6pm. 
 After the film, there will be a discussion on the &bquo;disappearances&equo;, the extra-judicial killings of individuals by the state in Latin America, chaired by Dawn Primorolo, Labour MP for Bristol South and Chilean expert. 
 The panel will include: The Observer's Latin American specialist Hugh O'Shaugnessy; Chilean refugee, Helia Lopez, whose brother-in-law joined the ranks of the &bquo;disappeared&equo; in 1973; and Andy McEntee, who is secretary of the Chilean Committee for Human Rights. 
 The Independent has five pairs of free tickets to offer for this stimulating event, available to the first five readers to present this page at the Watershed Box Office from 10am this morning. 
 INTERVIEW / The merchant's tale: Playwright Arnold Wesker tells Paul Arnott about the latest production of his jinxed Shylock 
 By PAUL ARNOTT 
 &bquo;If I had been able to run my own theatre, like Alan Ayckbourn or Neil Simon, I would definitely have directed all my plays myself. 
 I can't bear being dependent upon other people. 
 It has been the biggest frustration of my career.&equo; 
 So spoke Arnold Wesker at the Riverside Studios where, next week, he will take the unusual step of mounting eight rehearsed readings of his play, Shylock, formerly titled The Merchant, in a bid to raise enough interest from commercial backers to persuade them to mount a full production. 
 For Wesker, the fortunes of Shylock have been all too typical of a career plagued by bad luck which has left him with a sizeable canon of rarely performed work. 
 He is perfectly earnest when he says, &bquo;I feel that the people who run the big national companies are in my way. 
 They are the guardians of a door of a house that belongs to me. 
 I think it genuinely irresponsible that someone with my theatrical track-record has written a play about this internationally known theatrical figure yet it has only been seen by a few people.&equo; 
 The story of Shylock began with its premiere at the Royal Dramatic Theatre, Stockholm in 1976 from where it was picked up by Broadway producers for a full-scale run starring Zero Mostel. 
 However, on the pre-Broadway run in Philadelphia, Mostel fell ill and died after only one performance. 
 Thereafter the play received a few critically acclaimed performances in Birmingham but has otherwise been unperformed in this country. 
 An article in the Jewish Chronicle last year, in which Wesker wrote that all he wanted was enough money to give the play a chance to be seen in London led to a benefactor, who wishes to remain anonymous, phoning him up and offering to underwrite the venture to the tune of &pound;13,500. 
 Another &pound;7,000 followed and Wesker was ready to mount the readings. 
 To understand Wesker's determination to see Shylock produced it is salutary to consider his views about Shakespeare's The Merchant Of Venice. 
 &bquo;When I saw Dustin Hoffman in Peter Hall's production, which was strong and clean, I thought that the strength of the production showed up what an awful play it is. 
 Everyone is unpleasant. 
 Who are Lorenzo, Bassanio, Antonio? 
 None of these characters has any interesting or redeeming features. 
 The Jew is nothing more than a popular villain (bear in mind that Marlowe had just had a success with The Jew Of Malta). 
 The play was a brilliant pot-boiler which has been reinforcing the Jewish sterotype ever since. 
 Hoffman was good, but I think he'd be more interested in playing my Shylock.&equo; 
 Although Wesker expresses the utmost admiration for Shakespeare, he was determined to write an original work which would change people's perception and create a new Shylock. 
 Of Shakespeare he says, &bquo;Being a great poet the lines just tumbled out of him, and, like the whore an artist sometimes is, he distributes his favours to undeserving characters. 
 It is not an anti-semitic play. 
 Rather, its impact inflames anti-semitism.&equo; 
 Wesker might be accused of being somewhat subjective about the play, a charge that may be repeated as the producer of his own work. 
 &bquo;I think that this argument about objectivity is nonsense. 
 As the director I have the big advantage that I know all the melodies. 
 I do, however, keep giving the actors directions which belong to a five-week rehearsal period and then have to tell them to forget what I've just said. 
 It is difficult, to remember that what we are presenting here is an entertaining rehearsed reading rather than a full-scale production.&equo; 
 This is a very different Wesker to the public socialist, the man who has been a regular correspondent in newspaper letters pages on major public issues. 
 He is aware that what he is involved in now is nothing less than Thatcherite self-help. 
 He also confesses that, in short bursts, the role of theatrical entrepreneur excites him. 
 For this production he believes that he has found the Shylock to replace Zero Mostel. 
 Oded Teomi, one of Israel's leading actors was seen by Wesker in a one-man show. 
 &bquo;I think that he is an actor of international standing and if the production is taken up I want him to stay with it. 
 I like the idea of my shows making stars. 
 Joan Plowright was made by Roots and Frank Finlay by Chips With Everything.&equo; 
 Unfortunately, Wesker was struck by another (albeit minor) disaster: Teomi was not able to attend the first day of rehearsals because Wesker had forgotten, when writing his schedule, that it was also Yom Kippur. 
 &bquo;I blush, I blush.&equo; 
 1958 John Dexter produces Chicken Soup and Barley at the Belgrade, Coventry 1959 Dexter directs Roots. 
 1960 The Wesker Trilogy, The Kitchen, Chicken Soup and I'm Talking About Jerusalem open to great acclaim at the Royal Court. 
 Over 350,000 copies of the trilogy have been sold and the hardback is now in its fifth reprint. 
 1961-1970 Artistic director of Centre 42, a cultural movement for popularising the arts primarily through trade-union support. 
 1972 The Old Ones. 
 Controversial clash with the RSC begins over Wesker's play, The Journalists, which is cancelled after an actors' rebellion. 
 Financial settlement is only reached seven years later. 
 1975 Shylock, then known as The Merchant, is first produced. 
 Stage News 
 By PAUL ARNOTT 
 As the Conservative Party wends its way home from Blackpool next weekend, another conference will be warming up in London at the Almeida Theatre on 15 Oct entitled, Subsidy, Sponsorship Or What? 
 The subject under discussion is that old chestnut, public or private financing of the arts, but there is a particularly exciting line-up of speakers to chew the cud. 
 Terry Hands, retiring director of the RSC, will be facing up to Douglas Mason of the Adam Smith Institute, whose Expounding The Arts has been one of the most interesting discussion documents of recent years. 
 Thomas Sutcliffe, Arts Editor of The Independent, will be chairing the debate which will be thrown open to an audience including Ian McKellen, David Puttnam and Ned Sherrin. 
 John Sessions (above) will open the afternoon with a specially written piece on this contentious subject. 
 The debate begins at 3.00 and tickets are available from the Almeida box office on 01-359 4404. 
 Tickets are priced &pound;3.50, &pound;2.50 concs. 
 One man who could have a busy day on Sunday if he drops in on the above conference will be Michael Billington, the theatre critic of The Guardian. 
 Later that day, 15 Oct, at The Questors Theatre in Ealing, he will be the guest of honour at a fund-raising event for the Questors in which we are promised the opportunity to &bquo;find out what makes a critic, what are his prejudices and his preferences, and what are his fears and hopes for British (and world) theatre.&equo; 
 The evening begins at 7.45 and tickets, priced &pound;3, are available from the Questors, 01-567 5184. 
 London does not have a monopoly on chat this Sunday, however. 
 At the ever active Theatre Royal, Plymouth, there is a day-long workshop looking into the history of the musical. 
 The Art Of The Musical will be led by the artistic director, Roger Redfarn and will explore the contention that, although America is thought of as the home of the musical, the Brits have been busy in the Eighties conquering Broadway. 
 But are the new musicals any good? 
 Tickets are available from the Plymouth Theatre Royal on 0752-669595. 
 If you can't make it to Plymouth, you can check out their own latest musical production, Buddy, which is playing in preview at London's Victoria Place. 
 Buddy tickets 01-834 1317. 
 THEATRE / Paradise Now And Then &mdash; Drill Hall, WC1 
 By HELEN ROSE 
 Stonewalls, Judy Garland, Hair, Vietnam, the Summer of &bquo;69 &mdash; Noel Greig's retrospective on a particular period in Gay history loosely ties together snapshot scenes from the past with episodes from the present and links the whole with a curious blend of choral music which is part protest song, part hymn. 
 The play takes place on two sides of the Atlantic and deals with two sides of a story. 
 Why did a young black American idealist leave his British lover to fight the Vietnam war? 
 Greig explores the way in which people choose to remember the past through the reactions of the boy's sister (her angry rejection), the boy's lover (her confused sadness), and the impartial perspective of a young girl's view from 1989. 
 To be able to live fully in the here and now one must first learn how to honour the past, appears to be the message. 
 But it is buried in the indigestible and clumsy structure of Greig's play. 
 And really, it is surprising that a company such as Gay Sweatshop still finds a need to have a dyke in a dress suit and a queen in a fluffy frock bitching over a Judy Garland album. 
 Richard Coles (of The Communards) has written an insipid score and Paul Heritage's stilted direction is confined to a foursquare stage. 
 THEATRE / The Eight O'Clock News &mdash; Riverside, W6. 
 By LYDIA CONWAY 
 Like a best-man's speech, Edward Petherbridge's The Eight O'Clock News is an anecdotal monologue, often rambling, occasionally funny and inevitably far too long. 
 Offering us &bquo;the entire history of World Theatre&equo;, a kind of pop-up guide to the theatrical imagination, he artfully avoids dry chronology, beginning instead with the modern, virtuoso excesses of Simon Callow, reaching Shakespeare through Jane Austen's observations of Edmund Kean, and the Greeks via puppetry. 
 In illustrating Voice through a recording of Beerbohm Tree's lament over the body of Julius Caesar, or Walks and Exits as passed down to him by Esme Church, Petherbridge conjures up a strong, if erratic, sense of theatrical tradition. 
 It is, however, by drawing on his own past performances, from Aldwych farce to Newman Noggs, from Volpone to Vershinin, that he gives real substance to the evening. 
 Dressed in white tie, his delivery is conversational and informal, but, to sustain the illusion that he is making it all up as he goes along (it is in fact directed by Peter Barkworth), he launches into too many rambling sidetracks. 
 The result is neither comprehensive enough to inform nor selective enough to fully entertain. 
 Another danger to the ozone layer 
 By JANET DALEY 
 EVER since the new Booker shortlist failed to include some of this year's most frenetically over-promoted stars (thereby affording the rest of the authorial population a good smirk) the media have been publicly soul-searching about hype. 
 The arts community has always gone in for manic attention-seeking, of course -the oxygen of publicity (to borrow a phrase) being crucial to its survival. 
 Ironically, the proliferation of outlets for arts coverage &mdash; more quality newspapers, expanded review sections, late night television programmes, local radio chat shows &mdash; has brought not a wider, more varied selection of material but an ever more imitative and uniform one. 
 The Kenneth Branagh phenomenon is a cautionary tale but apart from the aren't-you-sick-of-him response, there has been little serious attention paid to the growing predictability of the media circus. 
 The official excuse for a sudden wave sweeping every column inch of coverage is that a genuine revelation has occurred. 
 By some spontaneous telepathic inspiration, the entire world has begun talking about the new genius in its midst. 
 The analogy is with instinctive mystery &mdash; an arcane communing which erupts suddenly at a mutually understood signal, like an entire species of bird becoming aware that it is time to mate. 
 But when all the arts journalists in London start fluffing up their tail feathers in unison, the effect is not so much of natural compulsion as of chummy conspiracy. 
 Perhaps conspiracy is too strong a word. 
 No raincoated figure skulks furtively in the shadowy corners of the Groucho club, hissing &bquo;Martin Amis is in. 
 Pass it on.&equo; 
 But the arts media circuit is nothing if not socially cohesive. 
 If everybody knows everybody else and they all go to the same parties, then there is bound to be a certain unanimity, if not in their judgements at least in their objects of attention. 
 This is an almost inevitable function of the clubby atmosphere of the media in what is, after all, a very small country. 
 I think it is an American character in one of Paul Theroux's short stories who says of England, &bquo;This isn't a country, it's an interesting room.&equo; 
 It also has something to do, I am sorry to say, with intellectual laziness. 
 If something or somebody seems to be all the go, it takes a determined editor to ignore it even if he thinks it wildly over-rated. 
 The incestuous atmosphere of media discourse is exacerbated too by British xenophobia. 
 A (probably correct) belief that anything foreign will be regarded as either irrelevant or incomprehensible tends to reinforce parochial cross-fertilisation. 
 What has become apparent is that the hype chorus has become counter-productive by its very volume. 
 There is an anarchic, bloody-minded streak in British public taste which likes to feel that it is striking out on its own with idiosyncratic preferences and non-conforming views. 
 All of the authoritative voices shrieking in concert that X is the greatest actor since Olivier or Y the best novelist since Dickens, are virtually guaranteed to cause the ordinary punter to mutter, &bquo;Oh, yeah?&equo; 
 Hence, the backlash to which so many poor devils have been exposed after a premature elevation to megastardom. 
 This is probably what accounts for the fact that being featured in one of those articles entitled &bquo;Faces to Watch in the New Year&equo;, or worse, &bquo;Who Will Be Who in the Coming Decade&equo; is almost inevitably a ticket to total oblivion. 
 It is not just artistic ephemera which suffer from metal fatigue in the heat of ubiquitous exposure. 
 Issues of life and death also ride the roller coaster in the same trivialising way. 
 When the current affairs machinery started to roll on the Aids issue, it quickly became apparent that this one had everything: public anxiety about health; the awakening of incipient guilt over sexual freedom and either compassion or vengefulness, depending on your sympathies, for the gay community. 
 Predictably, it shot to the top of the dinner party list of mandatory topics and was talked relentlessly into the ground on every conceivable broadcasting medium. 
 Never has so much explicit description of the mechanics of intercourse been rivetingly televised with such unimpeachable justification. 
 Six months or so of this produced not only a degree of understandable tedium -even the most terrifying things can become boring if lived with long enough &mdash; but what I would call an inverse effect. 
 Out of sheer perversity, the thinking human seems impelled to say something contrary to whatever received opinion has been yelling at him. 
 Hence, the spate of was-the-risk-exaggerated, debunking stories. 
 Aids is now on the downward trajectory of fashionable worries, barely able to keep its head above the surface of apathetic extinction. 
 Green concerns may well be about to travel the same route. 
 The greenhouse effect is deeply in danger of being Branaghed largely because of the mind-numbing saturation with which it is being covered. 
 It is only a matter of time before somebody decides to rubbish the whole global warming theory out of sheer desperation at finding a new angle. 
 With the consumer industry and media boffins jamming up behind one another to support the unquestionably fine ideals of conservation, one can only wish that they would ask themselves as they prepare to board one more rolling bandwagon whether they really have anything to add to what has already been said. 
 Sacrificed to the cause of poverty: Keith Joseph, whose &bquo;cycle of deprivation&equo; speech halted his political rise, talks to Mary Kenny about the problems of poor, young mothers 
 By MARY KENNY 
 &bquo;YOU WON'T ask me about abortion, will you?&equo; said Lord Joseph, apprehensively. 
 No, of course not, I replied, wondering why he had brought the subject up: why, too, was he so anxious to avoid it? 
 &bquo;Because I feel so complicated about it,&equo; he sighed. 
 &bquo;It's so awfully difficult &mdash; I'd be bound to get myself in a muddle trying to explain myself.&equo; 
 A characteristic Lord Joseph approach: honest, serious and keen to apologise for a complexity of thinking even before being quizzed. 
 In him, too, one sees an aspect of the Jewish secular conscience: anxious to think morally, but anxious, too, to do what is practical. 
 It would be inappropriate, however, to avoid the general subject of birth control, since it was this very question which ostensibly destroyed his ambition to lead the Conservative Party, and indeed, to be prime minister. 
 He was, in the early Seventies, spoken of as a possible future Tory leader. 
 And then, as Morrison Halcrow describes it in his new biography of Lord Joseph, Sir Keith (as he then was) made that celebrated 1974 speech which created such a storm. 
 &bquo;The balance of our population, our human stock, is threatened,&equo; he proclaimed. 
 &bquo;A high and rising proportion of children are being born to mothers least fitted to bring children into the world&hellip; 
 Some are of low intelligence, most of low educational attainment. 
 They are unlikely to be able to give children the stable emotional background, the consistent combination of love and firmness, which are more important than riches. 
 They are producing problem children&hellip; 
 Yet proposals to extend birth control facilities to these classes of people, particularly the young unmarried girls, the potential young unmarried mothers, evoke entirely understandable moral opposition. 
 But which is the lesser evil?&equo; 
 The reaction was an uproar: Sir Keith had managed to offend both the left and the right, as well as touching on two taboos in one theme: sex and class. 
 Barbara Castle, then social services minister, was outraged, as was the left in general, by his infelicitous use of key eugenic phrases such as &bquo;human stock&equo;, &bquo;low intelligence&equo; and &bquo;these classes&equo;. 
 But in apparently suggesting that armies of feckless teenagers should be supplied with free contraceptives, Sir Keith irked the right too, which has been traditionally critical of the notion of indulging the young with the means of sexual hedonism unhampered by restraints. 
 Yet, looking back today, it might seem that the reaction to that birth control speech was a little over-heated. 
 By and large, he was saying what most ordinary people think: that it is not a good idea for very young girls to embark on motherhood, especially if they are poor or a bit dim. 
 Maybe time does give it some perspective, he agrees, but he is determined to take the blame for the controversy it provoked. 
 &bquo;It was my own fault entirely. 
 It was a calamitous representation, by me, of a perfectly honourable and generally accepted proposition. 
 The reaction to that speech - and my reaction to that, the attempt to explain and apologise &mdash; put a firm stop to any hope I might have had that I might have been a candidate for leadership of the party.&equo; 
 Would he have liked to lead the Conservative Party? 
 &bquo;I was flattered by the idea. 
 It was the thought that I liked. 
 But it was absolutely clear to me then that I hadn't the political antennae, the political flair. 
 That speech, its reception, and my reaction, too, confronted me with what I had already suspected &mdash; that my candidacy was a fantasy.&equo; 
 The speech itself was passed by Conservative Central Office without any objection: it had been partly inspired by his close reading of the material supplied by the Child Poverty Action Group, and with his concern of the &bquo;cycle of deprivation&equo;, a phrase he popularised &mdash; or even, perhaps, coined. 
 He now wishes he had used the phrase &bquo;cycles of disadvantage&equo; instead, though it all comes to the same thing &mdash; when poverty is perpetuated through family patterns, generation after generation. 
 Lord Joseph has been interested in the causes of poverty for a long time: as a young man he joined the Howard League for Penal Reform as well as a Quaker group which busied itself about improving the social conditions of the poor. 
 Yet he claims to have been a late developer in many respects, a dreamy boy who grew up absorbed in cricket and poetry, still unaware, at Oxford in 1939, of anti-Semitism in Germany. 
 He was the only child of a rich, upper-class and cultivated Jewish family, distantly related to the Samuels, Lyons, Glucksteins. 
 Nigel Lawson's late wife, the beautiful Vanessa Salmon, was his cousin. 
 Lord Joseph's family was &bquo;minimally observant&equo; but &bquo;maximally acknowledging&equo; of Judaism, and his concern for poverty is, in a way, quintessentially Jewish, underpinned by a sense of charity and a belief that prosperity can be encouraged, as can his favourite condition, embourgeoisement. 
 Lord Joseph is now 71, in the House of Lords and out of the political fray. 
 His influence on Margaret Thatcher has been acknowledged &mdash; particularly his insistence that many problems associated with the quality of life come from low productivity and bad management. 
 &bquo;I retain a belief that by means of higher productivity and better crafted tax and welfare policies we could reduce poverty. 
 Of course, poverty itself is not that simple. 
 There are those who are poor because of circumstances beyond their control.&equo; 
 He is still, I suspect, most concerned with the problems of the &bquo;cycles of disadvantage&equo;, of poor young girls having babies too soon. 
 He reads, almost obsessively, the material published about the sources of family poverty, and the failure of the truly &bquo;disadvantaged&equo; to become embourgeoisee. 
 &bquo;There are some initiatives going on which interest me, whereby young women who had a child when they were adolescent, and although they love the child, regret very much that they were too young, too immature, and too unsupported to care for it effectively: it's being suggested that they should go into schools and talk to girls about the glories of motherhood at the right time, but begging them not to embark on it too young. 
 A baby is a joy, but it can be a stinking, leaking prison for a young lone mother.&equo; 
 The famous 1974 address still remains, in some respects, a benchmark of his thinking and of his central concern. 
 He was first drawn to the whole theme of cycles of disadvantage, he says, by some research which suggested that the mature and the middle classes use birth control more effectively than the young and the disadvantaged. 
 It is, however, a puzzle to me why this should be a surprise to anyone, or should even require exhaustive research. 
 Long before the Child Poverty Action Group was ever thought of, folks were singing &bquo;the rich get riches and the poor get children&equo;. 
 Long before Planned Parenthood observed that education, the development of other distractions such as television, or increased cultural activity reduced fertility, the Italians had a saying that &bquo;the conjugal bed is the poor man's opera&equo;. 
 Long before experts scratched their heads over the increase in teenage pregnancies, Shakespeare's Romeo and Juliet demonstrated the essential hotheadedness, spontaneity and damn-the-consequences timeframes of teenagers. 
 Why should anyone wonder that if the young and poor live in a culture of sexual freedom babies will ensue? 
 Lord Joseph shakes his head. 
 &bquo;In the past 50 years we've done a great deal of abolition. 
 We've abolished, largely, the concept of sin. 
 We've abolished, largely, the concept of hellfire. 
 We've tried to abolish destitution. 
 We've tried to abolish stigma. 
 When you actually abolish these things, you can't expect behaviour to be totally unchanged. 
 You can't imagine a political party saying we're going to bring back these things that have gone.&equo; 
 The best we can do today, says Lord Joseph, is warn young people, as much as possible, that poverty and teenage single parenting are inextricably linked. 
 Having sacrificed his career, in a way, for this mission, he talks as though he means to continue with it, of returning again and again to the theme that the stable family is the means of prosperity and, to some extent, happiness. 
 Being such an advocate of the family, it strikes a sad note, in his biography, that Lord Joseph's own four children are unmentioned, or that, after 30 years of marriage, he separated from his wife to become, in effect, a single parent himself. 
 Raise the kids, raise the money: Ann Roberts finds US schools have demanding standards for parents 
 By ANN ROBERTS 
 THE SUPERMARKETS are now full of pumpkins. 
 Every day the children worry about their Hallowe'en costumes for the school fancy dress parade. 
 A sharp note has come home informing me that the costume must be made by the child. 
 We all know what that means &mdash; it will take 10 times as long. 
 We also have to traipse round the neighbourhood on All Hallows Eve, calling on neighbours, who give our children sweets. 
 Newspapers and television implore us to slit all the candy open to ensure that it contains no foreign body. 
 The local hospital even sets up a Hallowe'en candy X-ray service. 
 The children have been back at school for only a month and already I am exhausted. 
 There have been fund-raising events, back-to-school meetings and enough notes sent home to make me wish I could employ a filing clerk. 
 I thought that I would have plenty of time to work once the children went back after the 10-week summer holiday. 
 But I reckoned without the Parent Teacher Association or American public holidays &mdash; today it is Yom Kippur and Columbus Day. 
 At my youngest child's public kindergarten, the equivalent of a British state school, the main event currently is a fun run. 
 It costs &dollar;15 for adults and &dollar;7 for children for the excitement of running not a few miles. 
 Why waste time and energy on sponsors when the runners are prepared to pay to suffer? 
 Of course, most &bquo;achieving&equo; American parents are in an almost permanent state of training. 
 But there is no escape for non-runners, who are required to sign up for light duties. 
 That takes care of Sunday. 
 We cannot refuse, because we are in awe of the formidable women running the PTA. 
 They have doctorates in education, and pace the halls in jogging suits. 
 Also this Sunday, our eight-year-old's school holds its Fall Festival. 
 There will be food, provided by the stalwart parents, plus games and pony rides. 
 Some hotshot parents cheat by calling in at the food store and ordering a gourmet prawn salad for 20 &mdash; at a cost of &dollar;60. 
 We parents also have the dubious pleasure of &bquo;getting acquainted&equo; while funds are earned for the school. 
 But as one parent said at the last gathering: &bquo;Why do we all have to be so matey?&equo; 
 Most of the mothers work. 
 They wear &bquo;power suits&equo;, attend &bquo;power lunches&equo; and cope magnificently. 
 Their children's lunch boxes are nutritionally correct. 
 They have a master calendar in the kitchen and they never forget anything. 
 Not for them the hollow reply, &bquo;What meeting?&equo; when a call is made to check that they are bringing something to the pot luck supper at school that very evening. 
 Perhaps you have got to do this stuff for a whole lifetime to be any good at it. 
 I know that in Beirut I simply took my child through the checkpoints and delivered her at the school gates. 
 Once a year I attended the school play. 
 In London, the Notting Hill Gate primary school did not encourage us to linger. 
 We were happy to run the school jumble sale, and the weekly book club meeting in the staff room, with parents and children talking about books, was a delight. 
 But this American fund raising business is just that - a business. 
 Every day brings a new request. 
 Tonight we must visit the classroom to &bquo;become acquainted with the teaching materials&equo; and generally appear involved. 
 Fathers are not excused, not even senatorial ones. 
 A buffet supper, provided inevitably by mothers, is considered a sufficient counter attraction to those on Capitol Hill. 
 We will be lucky to be out by 10pm. 
 Our 16-year-old daughter goes to an enormous high school with almost 2,000 pupils. 
 On back-to-school night all parents attend 15-minute orientation sessions with each teacher in every class. 
 Bells ring. 
 Loudspeakers admonish us to hurry to our next classroom (up three flights of stairs and along endless corridors). 
 The halls look like Dante's Circles, packed as they are with anxious parents grasping their child's schedules, trying not to be late for class. 
 We parents in America seem to be cowed a lot. 
 But the orders come down from above and we jump to it. 
 Private school or public, it makes no difference. 
 Funds must be raised and we are commanded to raise them. 
 This week's newsletter advises that a contribution of &dollar;40 per family will bring the PTA funds up to satisfactory level. 
 And this is a state school. 
 How many computers do they need, before enough is enough? 
 Some parents leap forward eagerly and some must be dragged to the battle lines. 
 But in the end we are all caught up. 
 Land of the Free? 
 A likely story. 
 Talk of the Trade: Antiques record 
 By ANN ROBERTS 
 THE first antiques &bquo;freesheet&equo; is claiming to have topped the circulation of every other antiques magazine just four months (and one issue) after its launch. 
 The World of Antiques is produced quarterly from a cottage in Somerset by Duncan and Jacki Phillips and distributed to everyone who visits antiques fairs around the country &mdash; estimated at 50,000 people every three months. 
 The top-selling magazines have a circulation of around 14,000. 
 Talk of the Trade: Technical hitch 
 By ANN ROBERTS 
 THERE are grumblings among BBC Television technical staff, whose objections to cramped studio conditions caused a two-week delay in the launch of the new Breakfast News. 
 When it was eventually launched last week, critics - including our own Mark Lawson &mdash; noticed a number of technical blips. 
 The next day a high-tech caption machine broke down.&equo; 
 Talk of the Trade: Disputed Record 
 By ANN ROBERTS 
 RUPERT MURDOCH's News International is furious that the Audit Bureau of Circulations has allowed Robert Maxwell's Daily Mirror to include the sales of its Scottish sister paper the Daily Record in calculating its circulation figures. 
 Together, the Mirror and Record sales amount to 3,900,000 &mdash; only 200,000 below The Sun. 
 The Mirror sells 3,200,000 on it own. 
 NI insists that the Mirror and the Record are separate newspapers with different editors and very little common content, even selling at different cover prices. 
 Talk of the Trade: Battle to rule the air waves 
 By ANN ROBERTS 
 THE fuse is lit for Britain's radio explosion. 
 Four of the extra 21 community stations are vying to be first on the air. 
 Manchester's Sunset Radio is aiming for 22 October, Haringey's LGR/WNK for 16 or 30 October. 
 Hounslow and Ealing's Sunrise Radio is set for early November, along with Bradford City Radio. 
 London Jazz Radio, winners of the lucrative London-wide FM frequency station, is looking for a February launch. 
 Another two London FM frequencies now being made available are likely to attract around 30 applications next month. 
 All of this favours the growth of radio programme suppliers. 
 Today sees the launch of The Unique Broadcasting Company, which aims to exploit openings for sponsored radio: Noel Edmonds is a key associate. 
 This is a lucrative business, since the price of sponsoring a series such as Nescafe's Network Pop Chart can approach &pound;500,000, while a one-hour programme reaching 70 per cent of independent local radio may cost around &pound;20,000, with three namechecks during the broadcast, and up to 10 in trailers. 
 Daily Telegraph: A decade of disappearing readers 
 By ANN ROBERTS 
 The Daily Telegraph has slipped into decline over the last 10 years, losing more than a million readers (3.59 million in 1980; 2.55 million 1989). 
 Sixty one per cent are over 45, compared with 56 per cent in 1986, when proprietor Conrad Black started to modernise the image. 
 New printing helped, but the strategy hasn't really worked. 
 Media: Guide to the world, the universe and decline 
 By MAGGIE BROWN 
 EIGHT months ago the conservative Daily Telegraph seemed a happy media parable of modern Britain. 
 A dozy, family-run business which faced bankruptcy in 1985, had been put to rights by the application of sound Thatcherite principles. 
 The group was set to make &pound;40m profit this year: a stock market flotation loomed. 
 The paper had worked hard at being modern, adding proper features and news analyses. 
 On Saturdays, it arrived with a stylish colour magazine, taken over from the Sunday Telegraph. 
 An influx of bright youngtalent was set to work under a dashing editor, Falklands hero Max Hastings, who occasionally took an independent, anti-government line. 
 Sustained advertising campaigns - &bquo;Your guide to the world, universe and everything'-tried to persuade yuppies and advertising agencies to view the paper in a new, chic light. 
 Yet, as the accompanying graph shows, The Daily Telegraph continued to lose readers. 
 The Sunday Telegraph behaved in a more quirky fashion, until shorn of its magazine a year ago. 
 They remain publications predominantly loved by the middle-aged, elderly and Conservative politicians. 
 But there has been enough good news to feed the belief that the strategy largely implemented by the Chief Executive and Editor-in-Chief, Andrew Knight, had borne fruit. 
 Even the industrial costs of over-ambitious Docklands works had been defrayed through a print sharing arrangement with the Express. 
 Then, on 22 March, the confident mood was poisoned. 
 Amid mounting rumours that the Sunday Telegraph was going to be abolished, Mr Knight announced that the editorial staff of the two titles would be pooled, under the editorship of Max Hastings. 
 The apparent aim was to strengthen the Sunday Telegraph, which with a circulation of 667,000 was nearly half a million copies behind the daily and facing a fight for its life. 
 But it was also a device to increase productivity: everyone was to work a five-day week. 
 A summer of mounting discontent began in April. 
 The first victim of a collapse in morale was the Sunday Telegraph: its former editor, Peregrine Worsthorne, sacked by Mr Knight over poached eggs at Claridges, was confined to organising its distinctive opinion pages. 
 Talented staff began to leave. 
 A working group which was debating ways of running a common staff, increasingly became dominated by the apparent overmanning of both papers. 
 By July, the relatively calm mood of The Daily Telegraph was badly infected with rumours that more than 100 redundancies were required in the staff of 440. 
 Andrew Knight says now that there was no target. 
 He wanted the same efficiency on the papers as on newly-founded ones. 
 Sub-editors, who work long evenings, currently do a four-day week, he says. 
 If they work five days, there would, in theory, be a 20 per cent increase in periods worked, therefore on paper you would need a fifth fewer people. 
 &bquo;At which point an editor would say, that is not how it works. 
 We went through a process of learning about each other's business&equo;. 
 His intellectual approach to the management of human resources seems to have made matters worse. 
 Meanwhile the paper imposed a 4 per cent pay deal, sweetened with merit money, an action which further inflamed feelings and led to industrial action and set Monday 9 October as the date when all would be revealed. 
 It was also to be Andrew Knight's last executive action: he is becoming a non- executive deputy chairman as Conrad Black, holding 80 per cent of the shares, assumes daily control. 
 In the event, the paper has declared 33 named redundancies. 
 Savings are modest. 
 Mr Knight hasn't costed them. 
 In the 1990s there is no room for the hard-won concessions of the 1970s &mdash; sabbaticals, fixed newspaper allowances and four-day weeks &mdash; which recognise the problems of stressful, anti-social hours. 
 But this week's 36-hour strike was provoked by the content of the new contract on which journalists are to be re-employed. 
 To quote: &bquo;The nature and demands may neccessitate you to work at times other than your normal hours. 
 Heads of Department may then permit you time off in lieu&equo;. 
 There are fears of family life going down the drain, as staff may get only two complete weekends off in seven. 
 The talk is of &bquo;bondage&equo; to the paper: under a highly restrictive contract. 
 So what began, apparently, as an attempt to strengthen the weakest paper of the group has convulsed the main profit-earner. 
 Whether this is the start of a deliberate confrontation, or the result of bad management of the kind which provoked BBC staff to strike this summer there is every sign that Mr Black wants his staff on a far tighter rein. 
 No-one expects a 36-hour strike to deter him. 
 Media: A new brand of screen sponsorship: Easing of broadcasting rules will let advertisers fund TV programmes. 
 Harvey Lee reports 
 By HOARVEY LEE 
 SPONSORSHIP has become the most hotly debated subject in television. 
 Hardly a week passes without a major conference &mdash; in the past seven days, one in London, another in Lisbon &mdash; where television companies, advertisers and sponsorship consultants, a new breed, come together to divine any slight shift in the regulatory tea leaves. 
 Until recently, company sponsorship of ITV or BBC programmes was strictly confined to events which would be taking place regardless of their being televised. 
 The Broadcasting Act, which governs ITV, limitsit to &bquo;doings, places, happenings and things&equo;. 
 This has meant sponsors could pay to stage an event, say the Trebor Mints Pure Strength Challenge, but not directly pay to make the television programme. 
 Now, under pressure from the ITV companies, the Independent Broadcasting Authority has relaxed its interpretation of the Act. 
 Both are now due to be replaced, the first by a lighter touch Independent Television Commission, the other by a new Broadcasting Bill that will be far more permissive. 
 Arts reviews, instructional programmes and the weather may now be directly sponsored. 
 Drama and situation comedy are likely to be next. 
 With government nudging and IBA winking, the ITV companies are leading what Channel 4 chief executive Michael Grade describes with alarm as a &bquo;cavalry charge&equo; towards sponsorship. 
 All the companies have a sponsorship executive, and the commercial network has a sponsorship committee. 
 Two examples of their efforts are already on screen: People and Pets is an animal advice series produced by Granada, &bquo;in association with Pedigree Chum&equo;. 
 But the national weather forecasts, sponsored by PowerGen, have caused the biggest storms. 
 Unveiling details of the &pound;1.7m deal, Ed WAllis, PowerGen's chief executive, candidly said he would expect some say in the way the weather was presented. 
 Mr Grade has been most vociferous. 
 &bquo;Sponsorship is the slippery slope towards the erosion of editorial independence.&equo; 
 But his further assertion that &bquo;it always ends in tears&equo; surprised many programme-makers, not least of all his own staff. 
 Channel 4 has if anything led the cavalry charge, pioneering direct sponsorship deals for minority sports such as American Football, Tour de France cycling and Sumo wrestling. 
 Current practice so far is based on the notion that some sponsorship is harmless. 
 There is little chance of advertisers influencing sport or performance art. 
 Sponsored Shakespeare is unlikely to feature Lady Macbeth holding a proprietary stain remover during her &bquo;damned spot&equo; soliloquy. 
 If Cornhill could influence the outcome of Test Cricket, it would have been its patriotic duty to have done so by now. 
 But Mr Robin Duval, chief television assistant at the IBA, the person who has been most closely involved in monitoring sponsorship, observes: &bquo;The widely canvassed notion that sponsors never seek to influence programmes simply does not hold up in my personal and direct experience.&equo; 
 The public and private faces of sponsors certainly differ. 
 Ed Wallis, of PowerGen, was the first to openly admit that having paid the piper, he would expect a choice of tune. 
 A stern note from the IBA advised him that if he had read the small print on his contract, he would have realised he had no right to. 
 But in a recent annual survey of 150 top UK advertisers, conducted by sponsorship consultants Granard Rowland, part of Saatchis, 50 per cent of marketing directors said they believed sponsors should influence programme content. 
 Robert Dodds, managing director of Broadcast Innovations, a sponsorship firm backed by two advertising agencies, told a conference last week: &bquo;There is an arrogant belief on the part of broadcasters that advertisers should support their output regardless of where the programme is scheduled. 
 If an advertiser doesn't insist on some scheduling guarantee for investing in a programme, he needs his head tested.&equo; 
 Yet with annual income from advertising topping &pound;1.3bn and a growth rate of 15 per cent, why should ITV need to bother with what at best will remain a marginal financial contribution? 
 Hugh Geach, head of programme support services at Television South, explains: &bquo;Everything the Government has done has been designed to open up television to market forces, to encourage new channels and competition for advertising. 
 Money will be spread more thinly and the companies may become more reluctant to fund minority appeal programmes, particularly big budget documentaries.&equo; 
 This was the fear behind Melvyn Bragg's initial plea for a millionaire to sponsor LWT's South Bank Show. 
 He insisted that it was a precautionary &bquo;belt and braces&equo; measure for tougher times ahead. 
 The swift intervention by his managing director, Brian Tesler, underlined the extreme sensitivity ITV feels on the subject. 
 Jon Marchant, Granada's sponsorship controller, was a principal negotiator on the PowerGen deal and is drawing up ITV's plan to put next year's World Cup sponsorship out to tender. 
 He says: &bquo;Production costs continue to soar. 
 High quality programmes need long-term commitment and funding. 
 Sponsorship can play a vital role in securing the future of high-quality television.&equo; 
 Some admit it already does. 
 Tim Brady, head of corporate sponsorship at Thames, the richest ITV company, pointed to The Concert, an overnight rock series, sponsored by McEwan's lager to the tune of &pound;50,000. 
 Mr Brady said: &bquo;Audiences at 1.15am are tiny and programmes at that time attract very little advertising revenue. 
 Without sponsorship, the series simply would not have been made.&equo; 
 Independent producers, from whom the Government expects both ITV and BBC to take one quarter of their programmes, regularly complain that the broadcasters, like building societies, are reluctant to advance the full cost of a project. 
 They see sponsorship as a useful top-up. 
 But this has already given rise to concern about hidden or back-door sponsorship. 
 The BBC was forced to drop an independently produced film for Arena on lorry drivers when it emerged that it was partly funded by a hauliers' association. 
 The film opened on a long lingering shot of sponsors' lorries. 
 The furore led to a revision of the BBC's sponsorship guidelines, though the formal position is quite clear. 
 Clause 12 of the Licence says: &bquo;The Corporation shall not send or emit any sponsored programme. 
 &bquo;The prohibition is total,&equo; warns the rulebook. 
 The BBC says it wants to encourage sponsored events which it can cover. 
 And sponsors claim that BBC producers are among the most persistent canvassers for their cash. 
 Advertisers also point out the hypocrisy of barring sponsored programmes when sports coverage is awash with branding. 
 Mr Marchant argues that to make sure sponsorship is transparent to viewers, as the new Broadcasting Bill will insist, sponsors should be given far more prominence than the present restrictions to discreet and static front and end credits on programmes. 
 He sees no harm in Pedigree Chum being mentioned as sponsors by the Pets and People presenters. 
 This and more already happens on satellite and cable channels, which are under the more lenient gaze of the Cable Authority. 
 EC legislation could well put a stop to this. 
 News and current affairs will remain a no-go zone for sponsors. 
 So there is little chance of our newsreaders breaking off, US-style, from a headline story to extol the virtues of a brand of paint, or even a national newspaper. 
 But the greatest danger could be that which is not shown, the commercial temptation for sponsors to play safe. 
 Duval agrees: &bquo;For me the real issue is programme choice, in the sense of what is actually scheduled. 
 I wonder now if Spitting Image or the The Singing Detective could ever be originated in any British system of the future substantially dependent on sponsorship? 
 In 1959, the producers of a US television drama about the Nuremberg war crimes trials were forced to delete the words &bquo;gas chamber&equo; from the soundtrack. 
 The sponsor was the American Gas Association. 
 So far, British sponsors have been discreet. 
 But how much longer will they remain so? 
 Rugby League: Willey takes Bradford helm 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 BRADFORD Northern have appointed Ron Willey, a veteran Sydney coach, to succeed Barry Seabourne, at Odsal. 
 Willey, credited with bringing Manly to pre-eminence before spells with Balmain, Norths, Souths and, most recently, Penrith, hopes to arrive in time for Sunday's Yorkshire Cup semi-final replay, against Halifax. 
 At 59, he will be the oldest coach in the First Division, but Willey can draw on a wealth of experience. 
 His Grand Final-winning Manly side of the early Seventies included not only Malcolm Reilly, now the Great Britain coach, but also Bobby Fulton, the leader of next year's Kangaroos. 
 His appointment on a two-year contract will disappoint David Hobbs, the caretaker who had applied for the job on a permanent basis, but Chris Caisley, the Odsal chairman, hinted yesterday that patience might bring a reward for the Northern captain. 
 &bquo;Ron is the right man for us at the moment,&equo; Caisley said. 
 &bquo;David has done a great job over the last few weeks but he still has playing ambitions. 
 Working closely with Ron Willey can only enhance his future coaching prospects.&equo; 
 Bradford's decision, together with Salford's installation of Kevin Tamati last week, means an unprecedented half of the first division clubs have overseas coaches. 
 Alex Murphy recently suggested this situation had arisen because of the sterility of the Australian game, but there are less complacent views. 
 Phil Larder, the national coaching director, accepts Sydney specialists can bring short-term benefit, but feels a new generation of English coaches is being held back. 
 &bquo;It is not axiomatic that overseas coaches are better than our own,&equo; Larder said. 
 &bquo;That might have been the case once, but now we produce perfectly good coaches ourselves, and I'm concerned the incentive will disappear if administrators continue to look only to Australia.&equo; 
 Football: Single-minded England come to the point 
 From PATRICK BARCLAY in Katowice 
 ONLY by breaking the habit of what seems a lifetime will England this evening jeopardise their hopes of reaching the World Cup in Italy next summer. 
 It is eight years since they lost a World Cup qualifying match, six years since they lost a qualifying match for either of the international competitions open to European countries. 
 A point in the Slaski Stadium would carry Bobby Robson's team into the finals, and few Poles doubt their chances. 
 With all Polish clubs eliminated from Europe the local mood is as grey as Silesia's industrial landscape. 
 England face a far less forbidding task than in 1973, when defeat on the same Chorzow ground by a gifted, combative Poland signalled the beginning of the end for Sir Alf Ramsey. 
 &bquo;Our football at the moment,&equo; as one sage put it, &bquo;is like our economy &mdash; failing to keep pace with changing conditions in the society around it.&equo; 
 In the shops it was possible to buy imported vodka, but not Polish; supply could not meet demand. 
 In football too, he said, production lines were faulty. 
 Never, indeed, has one seen such shoddy workmanship in a Polish team as that displayed at Wembley in June, when they lost 3-0, dismaying the folks back home. 
 Under the new management of Andrzeja Strejlaua, and with several team changes, they were said to have been much improved in narrowly losing a friendly in Spain last month. 
 Video evidence of the match is not available but England's attitude was summarised by the captain, Bryan Robson, who said: &bquo;We're not too bothered. 
 The main thing is to get our game right. 
 If we do, we will win.&equo; 
 Bobby Robson has made the three expected alterations to the team that began the 0-0 draw in Sweden last month. 
 The captain, absent with bruised ribs then, replaces his injured Manchester United colleague Neil Webb. 
 Chris Waddle moves from the right flank to the vacancy on the left caused by John Barnes's withdrawal and David Rocastle takes over on the right. 
 The balance of the side is just as Bobby Robson would have wished it; bearing in mind the need for midfield solidity, Rocastle would probably have played anyway. 
 The extraordinary episode of Bryan Robson and his quick-healing fracture has yet to be fully explained. 
 But Bobby Robson said last night that his fitness was in no doubt. 
 &bquo;We've nursed some players through training these last few days, but he's not one of them.&equo; 
 Assuming no relapse, Robson and Steve McMahon, who wore the captain's mantle so impressively in Stockholm, are capable of winning enough possession to prevent the defence from coming under sustained pressure. 
 McMahon had failed to convince the manager on his five previous appearances. 
 As he said yesterday: &bquo;Stockholm was make or break. 
 I had to show him I could be an international rather than just a squad player. 
 So I went out to play like I do for Liverpool.&equo; 
 Only poor Webb, still in plaster but determined to be back in the side in time for Italy, can feel discouraged by the way he brought it off. 
 The acting captain Terry Butcher, bloodied but unbowed, gave a particularly stirring performance that night and was ably complemented by Des Walker until the Nottingham Forest defender almost gave the match away with an aberrant pass back. 
 What England, yet to concede a goal as they go into their sixth and final group match, must avoid this evening is such an error in the early stages. 
 Then, Poland might just surprise themselves and a crowd expected to fill only a quarter of the 72,000-capacity stadium. 
 They are, after all, unburdened by expectation of success (to have a chance of qualifying, they must win all of their last three matches) and strengthened by the return of the Glasgow exile Dariusz Dziekanowski. 
 He will be supported up front by Hamburg's Jan Furtok and the tousle-haired Roman Kosecki, a lively substitute at Wembley who, like his captain, Dariusz Wdowczyk, will be hoping to impress British talent spotters. 
 England have Gary Lineker and Peter Beardsley and, surely, too much experience for Poland. 
 The main fear is that Captain Marvel, having turned into Captain Miracle, will be revealed as Captain Mortal; the sight of Robson limping off would be ominous. 
 But then England are not Manchester United, who crumbled at Portsmouth after he departed to have his fracture diagnosed. 
 They got a point without Robson in Stockholm. 
 They know the qualifying course as well as any team in Europe and, shortly before 7pm, should have earned themselves a toast in vodka, imported, of course. 
 ENGLAND'S PLACE ON THE ROAD TO ITALY ENGLAND need a point to ensure a place in the World Cup finals alongside Italy (the hosts), Argentina (holders), Yugoslavia (winners of European Group Five), Brazil and Uruguay (winners of their South American groups) and Costa Rica (from the Concacaf Group). 
 With nine points, they would be certain to qualify even if they are overtaken by Sweden. 
 If England lose they can still reach the finals as one of the best two second-placed teams in the three four-team European groups. 
 In such circumstances England's goal difference could give them an advantage over, say, Denmark in Group One or The Netherlands in Group Four, both of whom complete their fixtures next month. 
 Football: Rivals speechless on the eve of battle 
 From JOE LOVEJOY in Dublin 
 WHATEVER happened to the blarney? 
 Jack Charlton and Billy Bingham were spouting nothing but platitudes last night, leaving the Dublin public to count punts and what sounded suspiciously like chickens before the Republic of Ireland's historic World Cup tie against their northern neighbours at Lansdowne Road this afternoon. 
 Neither manager would give a clue as to his team, or discuss in depth a match which could see the Republic qualify for the finals for the first time. 
 Instead, the debate here focused on the bonuses Charlton's players will receive for getting to Italy (&pound;25,000 per man) and the Sports Minister's public criticism of Irish television for their decision not to screen the other tie in Group Six, between Hungary and Spain. 
 Victories for the Republic and Spain would settle the issue, with the Spaniards qualifying as group winners and Charlton's side advancing with them, as runners-up. 
 Frank Fahey, the Irish Minister for Sport, told RTE that the situation demanded that they broadcast Hungary v Spain, which kicks off at five o'clock &mdash; a suggestion which brought a mind-your-own-business response from their head of sport, Tim O'Connor. 
 O'Connor points out that demands for the game in Budapest is based on the dangerous presumption that the Republic will beat Northern Ireland &mdash; a result they have yet to achieve after three meetings. 
 The North's chances of qualifying perished with their 2-1 defeat at home to Hungary in June. 
 The Republic are unbeaten at home in their last 16 games, but if recent results point to only one winner, they know form can be a fickle friend when tribal passions are aroused. 
 Charlton confessed: &bquo;This one has been troubling me for some time. 
 The nearer it gets, the more worried I become.&equo; 
 His apprehensions are fuelled by a crop of injuries that may deprive him of Paul McGrath (hamstring), Kevin Moran (bruised back) and Steve Staunton (ankle). 
 John Aldridge has scored just one goal in 26 internationals and Tony Cascarino three in 16 appearances. 
 Did the Republic have a problem in attack? 
 &bquo;Not at all. 
 Next question.&equo; 
 Was there a contingency plan to cover the loss of McGrath, Moran and Staunton? 
 &bquo;No. 
 Next?&equo; 
 Charlton has no need to wax lyrical to talk up a crowd. 
 Interest here is such that the FA of Ireland could have sold three times the 46,000 tickets. 
 Rowing: Norrish offers to resign 
 By HUGH MATHESON 
 ALI NORRISH, the Oxford University Boat Club president, offered to resign last night after failing her first-year engineering examinations for the second time. 
 Norrish was elected last May to be the first woman president of the 150-year-old club. 
 &bquo;I'm deeply disappointed,&equo; she said last night, &bquo;but more for OUBC than myself.&equo; 
 She came to the university after steering the British women's coxed four in the final of the Olympics in Seoul. 
 She joined the Boat Race squad last January and quickly took over the Blue boat. 
 In the week before the race, she became embroiled in a controversy over the skill of her opponent, the American Leigh Weiss, who had also steered international women's crews but who was deemed not to know enough of the Boat Race course on London's tideway. 
 In the event, by the intervention of the umpire, Norrish was given enough room after two minutes to grasp the stream and she held on to her advantage with great skill until Oxford were clear and the race was won. 
 With no primus inter pares among the many oarsmen candidates for the presidency, Norrish, slightly against her will, was elected. 
 She confessed her doubts about combining the huge workload of president with her preliminary exams. 
 Her tutors at University College have allowed her a third attempt next year but have insisted she take a year out. 
 Martin Watts, of Oriel, this year's coxswain of Isis, the Oxford second crew, takes over as acting president. 
 He will have to call an election which will probably be contested by Richard Thorpe, the 1989 stroke, Calman McLennan, a fourth-year medical student, and Richard Hull, the post-graduate from Cambridge. 
 Football: Charlton criticises Edwards 
 By HUGH MATHESON 
 BOBBY CHARLTON, the former Manchester United and England forward, who is now a club director, made it clear yesterday that he would be willing to take over as chairman &bquo;if the right person asked me&equo;. 
 Charlton was critical of the way the proposed sale of Martin Edwards's majority shareholding to Michael Knighton for &pound;10m had been handled. 
 &bquo;It has been very disturbing and hurtful for me to see the way things have happened,&equo; Charlton said. 
 Talks were still going on between Knighton and his stockbrokers Laing &amp; Cruickshank last night to prepare an offer document before tonight's midnight deadline. 
 &bquo;Throughout all of this Manchester United has been kicked around like a football and the quicker this ends the better,&equo; Charlton said. 
 &bquo;The directors have been impotent because the deal was between Martin Edwards and Michael Knighton. 
 The board has tried to gather information about the bid, but we could not act until we knew who to act for or against. 
 &bquo;Perhaps Martin Edwards will admit that he has made a mistake selling to the person he has done and the way in which he has sold it. 
 With hindsight he may have acted differently. 
 &bquo;Certainly promises were made when Michael Knighton came to the club and doubts have now been cast on his ability to fulfil these, but if he does everything he has said who is to complain?&equo; 
 Football: Bull's double may be in vain 
 By HUGH MATHESON 
 Poland Under-21.. 1 England Under-21. 
 3 STEVE BULL scored twice as England finished their European Championship Under-21 qualifying campaign with a flourish in Jastrzebie Zdruj, but they are still likely to miss out on a quarter-final place for the first time since the competition began 13 years ago. 
 Sweden, who beat England last month, need only avoid a heavy defeat in Poland a fortnight today to head the group and qualify for the final stages. 
 England made an excellent start when Manchester City's Ian Brightwell headed them in front from a David Smith cross in the ninth minute. 
 Bull exploited hesitancy in the Polish defence when he headed in the second goal in the 36th minute, again from a Smith cross, after good work by David Batty. 
 Arsenal's Paul Merson almost made it three when he connected with a Bull cross a minute before the break, but goalkeeper Adam Mateysek reacted quickly to parry the ball for a corner. 
 England always looked dangerous and extended their lead in the 53rd minute when Merson opened up the Polish defence for Bull to slot in the third goal. 
 Piotr Prabucki scored a consolation in the 73rd minute when he sent an angled shot into the net off Digby's fingertips. 
 Football: Taylor's chief interest 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 GORDON TAYLOR, the players' union secretary, yesterday confirmed that he is still prepared to take up the post of chief executive of the Football League -despite a cold-shoulder from the League's management committee and the reluctance of the Professional Footballers' Association to release him. 
 &bquo;The League just don't seem able to sort it out,&equo; Taylor said yesterday. 
 &bquo;It was over two months ago that I was approached about the job, terms were agreed and I was a part of Bill Fox's presidential platform. 
 &bquo;It was voted on by the clubs but there has been no ratification of that by the management committee. 
 My people at the PFA feel that until the League get together and show there is a practical job for me to do, they don't see why they should let me go.&equo; 
 Walsall's move from Fellows Park to a new &pound;4m stadium has been postponed until the start of next season because the pitch will not be ready in time. 
 The FA has charged Dunstable with bringing the game into disrepute for their FA Cup qualifying round walk-off at Staines. 
 Dunstable had three players sent off, the rest left the field in protest and the match was called off and awarded to Staines. 
 Justin Fashanu, the former Norwich and Nottingham Forest striker, scored three and Clive Allen two in Manchester City's 5-0 home win against Notts County in a reserve match. 
 Fashanu is on trial with City after a knee injury. 
 Ruud Gullit flew back to Milan from Amsterdam yesterday to resume light training after a Brussels specialist confirmed he would not need further surgery on a nagging knee injury. 
 He will not train with his team-mates for five weeks. 
 Sport in Short: Windsurfing 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Speedway 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Snooker 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Rugby Union 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 WALES, the Soviet Union and West Germany are three new nations making their debut at the 15th Hong Kong Sevens, to be staged from 31 March to 1 April next year. 
 Sport in Short: Rallying 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Judo 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Football 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 WELSH CUP DRAW: Southern Section: Swansea v Merthyr Tydfil; Pembroke Borough v AFC Cardiff; Cardiff City v Newport or Brecon; Barry Town v Bath City; Sully or Maesteg Park v Worcester City; Ton Pentre v Port Talbot; Ammanford Town v Llanelli; Aberystwyth v Islwyn Ath or Cardiff Corries. 
 Northern Section: Hereford v Connagh's Quay Nomads; Porthmadog v Wrexham; Penycae v Caersws; Conway Utd or Bangor v Flint; Mostyn or Brymbo Steelworks v Colwyn Bay; Morda Utd v Kidderminster Harriers; Twyyn-Bryncrug v Lex X1; Chirk v Rhyl. 
 Ties to be played on or before 11 November. 
 Sport in Short: Cycling 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 LAURENT FIGNON said yesterday that his three-month suspension for failing a dope test was lenient. 
 &bquo;It doesn't encourage people to be too careful,&equo; he said. 
 ROLF GOELZ, West Germany's leading rider, dominated a four-man sprint to win the 214km Milan to Turin classic for the second successive year yesterday. 
 Sport in Short: Cricket 
 By PHIL SHAW 
 THE INDIAN Board of Control yesterday relaxed rules binding Indian cricketers during tours abroad. 
 Players would no longer be barred from playing in another country after a tour. 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Baseball 
 Sport Page 37 
 Sport in Short: Athletics 
 Sport Page 37 
 Rugby Union: Chilcott is forced to play a waiting game 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 GARETH CHILCOTT, the England prop who was sent off for the fourth time in his playing career with Bath when the champions suffered a League reversal at Gloucester last month, is still awaiting news of his punishment from the Somerset disciplinary committee. 
 The Chilcott case was due to be heard last night by the committee, which generally meets once a fortnight. 
 The trouble is that since Chilcott's dismissal for punching, players in the county have been on their best behaviour. 
 John Davidson, the secretary of the committee, explained: &bquo;We've got some fixed dates in the diary, but we don't always operate to those because it depends whether or not we've got enough cases.&equo; 
 Davidson added that Somerset has about four cases to hear next week which means that Chilcott is left kicking his heels for another seven days. 
 Meanwhile, the recipient in an alleged head-kicking incident at Twickenham last Saturday, plays on. 
 Richard Langhorn, the No. 8 whose stitches resulted in a letter of complaint to Swansea by Harlequins, has been passed fit to play for Quins in this weekend's First Division game at Bedford. 
 Another Harlequin, Everton Davis, has been seeking a second opinion on the knee injury that forced him out of last month's England training session. 
 The wing was also ruled out of the squad last year &mdash; by a groin injury which required surgery &mdash; and the surgeon's knife was poised again until a specialist diagnosed that an operation was not necessary. 
 Rugby Union: Shelford has work cut out 
 By STEVE BALE, Rugby Union Correspondent 
 THE All Blacks stepped off their plane at Heathrow yesterday straight into the arms of a waiting posse of officials set on saving Wayne Shelford and New Zealand rugby for amateurism. 
 The efforts of the home unions' committee appear to have worked &mdash; for now at least. 
 Shelford, the tour captain, will no longer be asking &pound;500 for personal appearances and is understood already to have set about &bquo;dismantling&equo; those that had been arranged. 
 &bquo;We have received categorical assurances that whatever has been reported about his earning money while he is here is not the case,&equo; Ronnie Dawson, the home unions chairman and Irish RU president, said. 
 Bob Weighill, the home unions secretary, added: &bquo;It is not normal for rugby union players to work while on tour.&equo; 
 What, then, is his work? 
 Shelford's full-time employment is the promotion of Wayne Shelford (through Mark McCormack's International Management Group). 
 At yesterday's welcoming press conference he declined to comment and instead confined his remarks to the job in hand: seven matches in Wales, five in Ireland and one (against the Barbarians) in England. 
 The problem has been deferred rather than resolved, as the pressure inexorably intensifies to relax rugby union's amateur regulations. 
 These are interpreted differently Down Under; to take two among many examples of the New Zealand way, back home Shelford promotes, unimpeded, a brand of baked beans (called Watties), and John Kir- wan, the wing, advertises bananas. 
 &bquo;We are still within the amateur regulations or we wouldn't be here,&equo; Grant Fox, the All Black outside-half, said yesterday. 
 &bquo;I believe players should be able to make money for making a speech or opening a supermarket. 
 Concessions must soon be made.&equo; 
 It is a view increasingly shared by players on this side of the Equator. 
 The tourists anticipate a harder time than recent evidence in Welsh and Irish rugby might have suggested to them. 
 &bquo;A lot has been said about how weak Welsh rugby is,&equo; the coach Alex Wyllie said. 
 &bquo;But no All Black team other than 1967 and 1924 has gone through unbeaten and we know very well we will have tough games against Wales and Ireland.&equo; 
 Shelford was in Wales last October to watch Neath beat Toulouse, a result which has led him to a conclusion similar to Wyllie's: &bquo;From the performance Neath put on that night, Welsh rugby is in pretty healthy hands.&equo; 
 The matches actually begin on the coastal belt in Cardiff on Saturday (the New Zealand team will be announced this morning), and the tour moves on to Pontypool next Wednesday. 
 By then Wyllie, the sole selector, hopes to have given all 30 players a game. 
 Rugby Union: Botha a ghost at the feast 
 By STEVE BALE 
 Newport..... 13 Barbarians.. 40 SO THE Welsh have not after all severed all links with South Africa. 
 Naas Botha, of all people, turned up at Rodney Parade last night to see the Barbarians' annual autumn get-together. 
 The Springbok stand-off is not about to be signed up in south Wales. 
 He is merely stopping over en route from the Republic to Italy, where he plays rugby for Rovigo. 
 But the company he has been keeping has been fascinating. 
 Brian Jones, secretary of the Merit Table organisation, which brings together Wales's 18 senior clubs, is putting him up. 
 Yesterday he and Botha lunched with Terry Vaux, the WRU committee man who resigned from the International Rugby Board as a result of the South African row. 
 The fare laid before Botha last night was hardly epicurean. 
 Newport have fallen on even harder times than last year, when the Barbarians beat them 60-18, and the Baa-Baas too scratched around for fluency. 
 Only occasionally was there any doubt that they would win, however, particularly as David Phillips, who took over the kicking on the early retirement of Brian Bolderson, kicked only one of four penalty chances for Newport. 
 The Barbarians countered with first-half tries by Jeremy Guscott and Owain Williams. 
 Guscott's, set up by a break by Brendan Mullin, was a felicitous product of the renewal of the Lions centre pairing who did so well in Paris last week. 
 The Black-and-Ambers' All Black date in three weeks has been looking more of a death sentence than an opportunity to breathe new live into an ailing club. 
 But last night they at least could not be faulted on their spirit. 
 Having taken the game to the Baa-Baas at the start of the second half they deserved their try by Damian Griffiths, although the revival was brief. 
 Within two minutes Mike Hall put Peter Dods in for the Barbarians' third try, and another four followed in a procession interrupted by one for Newport by John Thomas. 
 Phil John, John Morrison, Craig Chalmers and Williams completed the Baa-Baas' runaway, with Chalmers's six conversions from seven giving him 16 points from a productive night. 
 Botha, meanwhile, signed off with a few words of advice for the Welsh: &bquo;They are going berserk about nothing and it might be time for the WRU to concentrate on their own rugby.&equo; 
 Which is precisely what last Friday's anti-SA vote means they are now doing. 
 Newport: Tries Griffiths, Thomas; Conversion Callard; Penalty Phillips. 
 Barbarians: Tries Williams 2, Guscott, Dods, John, Morrison, Chalmers; Conversions Chalmers 6. 
 Rugby League: Warrington danger springs from Mackey 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 Warrington.. 28 Widnes....... 6 WIDNES appear to be still paying the price of becoming world champions. 
 Humbled at Sheffield Eagles on Sunday, in their first game after the defeat of Canberra Raiders, they failed to bounce back in the Lancashire Cup last night, losing to a disciplined Warrington side. 
 As at Sheffield, the margin of defeat was surprising. 
 Making an extraordinary number of handling errors and under-using the speed in their backs, Widnes were scarcely in the hunt. 
 At one stage in the game they were down to 11 men, but their shortcomings should not be allowed to detract from Warrington's impressively positive performance, the home side contributing much that was memorable in a thrilling and thunderously received encounter. 
 Warrington set out to contain Widnes in their own half and pressure them into mistakes, and met with early success on both counts. 
 A misunderstanding between Richard Eyres and Derek Pyke gave Rocky Turner his first penalty chance, and a second, from a similarly kickable position, arrived when David Hulme was forced to obstruct Mark Roskell. 
 Hulme transgressed even more unpardonably in the 14th minute, when his high tackle on Greg Mackey earned a spell in the sin-bin and allowed Turner a third goal, this time from the half-way line. 
 Mackey, an Australian scrum-half whose short contract Warrington are trying to turn into a long one, was a constant source of danger to Widnes, and provided the final pass to enable Mark Forster to score a try in Hulmes's absence. 
 Widnes were back to a full complement of players by the time Tony Thorniley scored Warrington's second, again from an inspired Mackey pass, but the visitors were powerless to prevent the centre reaching the line from 25 yards. 
 Worse, Barry Dowd, injured in attempting a final tackle, joined Eyres in the casualty room, as Widnes were forced to field both their inexperienced Welsh substitutes before half-time. 
 The Widnes tale of woe continued in the second half, when Tony Myler was unable to hold Pyke's pass and Turner intercepted to give Thorniley a second try. 
 Andy Currier was eventually able to provide consolation at the other end, but departed for the sin-bin 30 seconds later after a foul on Bob Jackson, accompanied by Paul Hulme, who questioned the referee's decision too vehemently. 
 Joe Ropati scored a final try for Warrington, with Turner adding a sixth goal. 
 Warrington now meet Oldham in the final on Saturday at St Helens. 
 Motor Racing: Spanish result to stand 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 THE RESULT of the Spanish Grand Prix will not be nullified, even if an appeal by Nigel Mansell on his exclusion from it is successful, the president of FISA, the sport's ruling body, said yesterday. 
 Jean-Marie Balestre confirmed the British driver's ban from the Jerez race for &bquo;a recognised, proven and established offence&equo; and ruled that his appeal could not affect this year's world championship. 
 Mansell has appealed against a one-race ban imposed by FISA for reversing in the pits during the Portuguese Grand Prix in Estoril on 24 September. 
 Balestre said Mansell had admitted and apologised for reversing. 
 The FISA president said the sanction against Mansell was for this breach of security rules and had nothing to do with his failure to stop after a black flag was waved at him three times. 
 Balestre criticised the media, Mansell and Ferrari and the International Automobile Federation's appeals tribunal for spreading confusion about the case. 
 He said the media had been impulsive in reporting the incident and that Mansell and Ferrari had appealed to two different bodies &mdash; the national motorsports tribunal in Portugal and FIA's international tribunal. 
 He said that the FIA tribunal had no right to rule on the case until a hearing in Portugal and should not have heard representation from Mansell and Ferrari at a hearing in Paris last Thursday. 
 The Portuguese hearing would go ahead on 18 October even though Ferrari had asked for it to be postponed, he said. 
 Any ruling in Mansell's favour could only affect the size of his &dollar;50,000 (&pound;31,500) fine, Balestre added. 
 Amateur Rugby League:: Yearning from the students 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 PLAYING rugby league can be addictive, according to Martyn Sadler, the chairman of the students' association, who reports that young people introduced to the game at university or college are no longer necessarily lost after graduation, writes Paul Wilson. 
 First to profit from this trend are Bradford's Dudley Hill, who, with five members of the English Students World Cup squad in their side, have made an explosive start in the BNFL national league, leading the first division with six wins from six matches at an average of almost 40 points per game. 
 Mick Keebles, the World Cup captain, heads the off-campus contingent, which also includes John Jenkins, a centre who briefly returned to rugby union with Waterloo on leaving Leeds Polytechnic, but decided it did not quite match the real thing. 
 There is more to Dudley Hill's startling success than graduate recruitment. 
 This season they are coached by Peter Roe, the former Bradford and Keighley centre, and have Paul Dennis, an ex-paratrooper as fitness conditioner. 
 From his universal nickname &mdash; Tenko &mdash; it will be surmised that Dennis demands more than a few laps of the pitch prior to a session in the pub. 
 Training for the new season began on 20 June, earlier than at many professional clubs, and even more astoundingly among amateurs, Dennis's players renounce mid-week alcohol. 
 Results have been rapid. 
 Huddersfield, Second Division professionals, were seen off in a pre-season friendly, and in the National League a succession of self-respecting clubs have been trounced. 
 Millom arrived undefeated but were routed 48-8. 
 Leigh Miners fancied themselves against the upstarts, but fell to a 35-12 home defeat. 
 Rugby Union: Goodway, Hobbs back for Britain 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 ANDY GOODWAY and David Hobbs, two former Oldham forwards, were yesterday rehabilitated at international level when Malcolm Reilly named a squad of 21 for the first Test against New Zealand on Saturday week. 
 Goodway, now of Wigan, disappointed Reilly deeply by withdrawing from last year's tour for personal reasons which seemed less than urgent, but the coach has sensibly decided against holding grudges. 
 After several public expressions of regret and an impressive start to the season, Goodway makes the party on the unanswerable grounds of form. 
 Hobbs, who last played for Great Britain in France in 1987, returns to international favour on the strength of the maturity he has displayed since taking over the captaincy at Bradford this season. 
 Kelvin Skerrett, another high-profile performer in the Northern pack, is one of three uncapped players. 
 In the backs there are no real surprises. 
 Andy Currier and Paul Newlove are the newcomers, scarcely unheralded, but Reilly has chosen a squad rather than a team because of injury doubts over Andy Gregory and Joe Lydon, and with the threat of suspension hanging over Shaun Edwards. 
 Thus while Deryck Fox can celebrate his first call-up since 1986, it is only with the knowledge that he will be discarded if Gregory is passed fit. 
 Those waiting to see whether Edwards or Tony Myler gets the stand-off shirt must likewise wait a little longer, and Reilly has also prevaricated over the choice between Alan Tait and Steve Hampson at full-back, though neither player is injured. 
 One notable absentee from the squad is Lee Crooks, once rated invaluable by Reilly, who appears to have come to a career crossroads. 
 The &pound;172,000 prop failed to appear for Leeds on Sunday, and yesterday confirmed his disenchantment at Headingley by asking for a move. 
 Salford yesterday announced the signing of David Fell, a 23-year-old centre from the Orrell rugby union club, on a &pound;40,000 contract. 
 Baseball: Clark caps Cubs' demise 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 WILL CLARK applied the coup de grace that extended the Chicago Cubs' post-season losing streak to 44 years and took the San Francisco Giants into the World Series against their neighbours the Oakland Athletics. 
 Stepping up to bat in the eighth inning of game five on Sunday with the scores tied 1-1, the Giants first baseman had trouble controlling the adrenalin, &bquo;but I took a deep breath and tried to focus on the point of release of the ball&equo;. 
 He hit a single that brought two runners home, and San Francisco held on to win 3-2 and take the National League title 4-1. 
 Clark, whose batting average for the series was an amazing. 
 650, won the most valuable player award for his play-off record of eight runs, two home runs and eight runs batted in. 
 &bquo;I want to stress I'm happy with the award but this is not a one-man team,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It has character, a great manager in Roger Craig and 24 guys who don't know how to quit.&equo; 
 Golf: Organisers accuse Faldo of &bquo;disloyalty&equo; 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 NICK FALDO was accused of &bquo;disloyalty&equo; yesterday after opting to miss his defence of the Volvo Masters title at Valderrama, Spain, later this month, and play in the Nabisco Championships in the United States instead. 
 Mel Pyatt, the Volvo spokesman said: &bquo;It is all very sad; loyalty seems to have gone by the board. 
 It is a shame that the players feel they can put sponsors to ransom like this and that they are bigger than the sport.&equo; 
 Faldo said at Wentworth yesterday that he made the decision because he feels he cannot now finish at the top of the European order of merit by playing in Spain. 
 &bquo;I realise the European Tour will not be too happy but I blame them anyway for the clash of dates,&equo; Faldo said. 
 The US Masters champion added: &bquo;I always try to defend a title but I have sweated my guts out in America this year to get where I am and I feel I am entitled to play. 
 It is a good tournament, a good field and a course where I have won before.&equo; 
 Another Ryder Cup player, Seve Ballesteros, is also torn between tournaments. 
 Despite protracted negotiations, the Spaniard will stick to his plans to play in a conflicting event in Japan instead of the World Cup in Spain in November. 
 Athletics: Whitbread chosen without a throw 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 THE England women's selectors have been able to include both Fatima Whitbread, the javelin world champion, and Tessa Sanderson, the Commonwealth champion, in the 48-strong team for January's Commonwealth Games in Auckland, despite neither woman throwing at the trials in August. 
 The use of qualifying standards meant the women had none of the awkward choices which confronted the men, also enabling them to bring in experienced campaigners like Christina Cahill (1,500 metres) and Wendy Sly (3,000m), despite both runners having had restricted summer seasons. 
 Meanwhile, Scottish athletes and officials yesterday angrily rejected as &bquo;useless&equo; an offer by the Scottish Commonwealth Games Council to extend the time limit to achieve the qualifying standards for New Zealand. 
 Announcing that Scottish companies and local authorities had raised more than &pound;230,000, George Hunter, the Games Council secretary, said that this would allow the time limit for achieving qualifying standards to be extended to the end of December. 
 &bquo;Not one person who has met the qualifying standard before the plane takes off for Auckland will be left behind,&equo; Hunter said. 
 But Brian Whittle, the leading 400 metres and 800 metres runner, was among those to dismiss the offer because of the lack of competitive opportunities between now and the new deadline. 
 Football: Charlton wins the green vote: Ken Jones on the simple yet successful philosophy that has made Jack Charlton the outsider a giant in terms of popularity 
 By KEN JONES 
 WHEN citizens of the Irish Republic bestow sainthood on Jack Charlton, thinking him to be perhaps the most significant figure in their sporting history, they are not merely responding to what he has already achieved with the national football team. 
 There is also the man. 
 That an English hero should become so popular on historically alien ground is a phenomenon best explained by Charlton's instinct for being nothing but himself, a characteristic that appeals mightily to the Celtic nature. 
 Last week while Bobby Robson was surrounded by players and coaches, knee-deep in the paranoia that appears to afflict the majority of football managers, Charlton was fishing in Ayrshire, not seeking relief from cumulative tension but simply enjoying life. 
 This may have strengthened an impression that occurs frequently to his critics, one of relentless eccentricity most manifest in forgetfulness. 
 What they ignore is Charlton's ability to dispense knowledge acquired when turning out in more than 600 matches for Leeds United and 35 in the England colours, his World Cup experience of great and possibly lasting importance to the Irish cause. 
 In Dublin today Charlton will send out the Republic against Northern Ireland in an attempt to take the points that would virtually ensure participation in the World Cup finals next summer in Italy, a feat guaranteed to consolidate his status as a modern Irish hero. 
 If anything the prospect of increased attention embarrasses Charlton. 
 &bquo;I don't need to be more famous,&equo; he said last week after returning to a charmingly comfortable home converted from farm buildings some 15 miles to the north-west of Newcastle. 
 A glistening 18lb salmon lay on a kitchen work-top and Charlton applied a sharp knife, gutting and then carving it into steaks. 
 He wore battle-dress green, slacks and sweater and his weather-beaten face glowed with satisfaction and well-being. 
 Later he spoke about references to him in a popular Sunday tabloid, scowling at the implication that his approach is essentially haphazard. 
 &bquo;It hurt me,&equo; he growled, &bquo;all that stuff about sitting on river banks and prowling moors instead of concentrating on the job, turning up late and being more interested in fishing and shooting than football. 
 They forget I took the job on the understanding that management of a national team can only be part-time employment. 
 What can you gain from sitting behind a desk making and waiting for telephone calls, going from game to game watching players you already know about?&equo; 
 The philosophy is devastatingly simple, Charlton recognising that he cannot hope to improve players technically in the short time available to him before matches. 
 &bquo;I don't want them to get bored with me or me with them. 
 There are rooms booked in the hotel if they want to take the opportunity of visiting relatives but I don't expect them in Dublin until two days before we play. 
 From then on they are with me. 
 Nothing complicated. 
 We sort out the free kicks and pay attention to specific tasks.&equo; 
 Under Charlton the Republic have made quite dramatic progress, reaching the finals of the European Championships in West Germany last year, his appointment undeniably responsible for an upsurge in potential after decades of comparatively anonymous endeavour. 
 As this has been achieved with a style of football that owes little to romantic idealism, Charlton is not in trouble-free waters although even his most vigorous detractors are now inclined to take a pragmatic stance, appeased by success and forced to accept his widespread popularity. 
 When it comes to the Republic's method Charlton is unrepentant. 
 &bquo;We are not playing kick and rush,&equo; he insisted when driving out to a friend's hotel in the Derwent Valley below Consett, pausing now and then to savour the uncluttered Durham landscape, his heart for ever in the North-east of England. 
 &bquo;I simply don't want the ball put at risk in areas where we are immediately vulnerable to counter-attacks and we must always be giving the opposition something to think about. 
 They should never feel comfortable or be familiar with the problems. 
 The team must never to be stretched and when we press forward that also means the goalkeeper. 
 &bquo;Liverpool have exploited that but it first came to me many years ago in a charity match at Newcastle. 
 For the fun of it Len Shackleton played in goal and of course he was full of tricks, shaping to punch or catch the ball on the edge of the penalty area and then controlling it on his chest, things like that. 
 But he was also occupying space behind the defenders, making it difficult for attackers to get in on passes.&equo; 
 None of the Republic players was more likely to come into conflict with Charlton's tactics than Liam Brady, who announced his retirement from international football after being substituted 10 minutes from half-time in a recent friendly against West Germany. 
 Charlton immediately came under fire, his decision to withdraw Brady from the fray seen to be cavalier and grossly insensitive. 
 &bquo;I am paid to win matches,&equo; Charlton said. 
 &bquo;I like Liam and have great respect for his ability and reputation but he wasn't doing what was expected and it was necessary to make a change.&equo; 
 Subsequent emollient correspondence has has healed the rift and Brady remains within Charlton's embrace, his vast experience still on tap and offered enthusiastically. 
 This did not come as a surprise. 
 What some of us have come to expect from Jack Charlton cannot always be adequately defined: obdurate, quick-tempered, argumentative but unfailingly loyal and never less than a man. 
 Football: Polish history a reminder of harsh lessons 
 By KEN JONES 
 IMAGES of Chorzow: bleak terrain, the coalfields of Silesia, a passionate audience, ferocious tackles, grim possibility. 
 The irresistible thing is to suggest that even the most resolute of England's footballers, ever mindful of the predicament that could result from defeat, are not entirely immune to what awaits them today in Poland. 
 History is set out in apparently discouraging detail. 
 &bquo;One of the most difficult matches we have ever been asked to play,&equo; confided Sir Alf Ramsey in June, 1973, his apprehension understandable despite being able to call upon the vast experience of Bobby Moore, Alan Ball and Martin Peters. 
 For Moore, on the occasion of his 105th appearance in England colours, it became a miserable exposure to the inevitability of decline, an uncharacteristic positional error enabling Lubanski to surge through for the second of Poland's two goals; the famed captain would play only three more times for his country, and not in the climax to the qualifying group, five months later at Wembley. 
 The end was in sight for a number of them that day in Chorzow: Alan Ball, sent off, unable to contain his frustration; Ramsey, the most successful of England's managers, sacked within a year. 
 An era crumbling. 
 There were other times in Silesia. 
 September, 1973: Poland versus Wales in England's qualifying group, a brutal confrontation, the late Trevor Hockey sent off, his manager Dave Bowen choking back obscenities. 
 Unable to build upon a draw against England at Wembley and a victory over Poland at home, Wales, defeated 3-0, were out of the World Cup. 
 It was in Silesia that a marvellous Tottenham Hotspur team, League champions and FA Cup winners in 1961, were first introduced to the hazards of European competition, their ambitions in disarray until Dave Mackay inspired a partial recovery that led to a 8-1 success in the return at White Hart Lane. 
 Only spirited defending of the highest order and considerable good fortune enabled Manchester United to progress beyond Silesia in 1968: despite losing 1-0 to Gornik, Sir Matt Busby's vision of winning the European Cup was still intact as the result of a two-goal advantage from the first leg. 
 So was it ever thus, history the source of ominous portent, further nourishing Bobby Robson's anxiety? 
 He can take heart from the events of 1966. 
 After wandering through Scandinavia, permutations completed, England came to Chorzow, the last match they would play before taking part in the World Cup. 
 Silence settled on the assembled company as Ramsey read out his team. 
 &bquo;&hellip; Hunt and&equo; pause for effect &bquo;Peters&equo;. 
 England defeated Poland 1-0, Roger Hunt the goalscorer and the tenacious manner of that victory persuaded us that the possibilities were immense; of that team, only Jimmy Greaves would be missing from the World Cup Final. 
 Cricket: Larkins given a one-day pass 
 By KEN JONES 
 WAYNE LARKINS, shunted into the sidings after the last of his six Test caps in 1981, has been recalled to the England team for their one-day match against a Railway XI in Delhi today. 
 For Larkins the game represents a chance to book his ticket for Sunday's Nehru Trophy opener against Sri Lanka. 
 The dashing 35-year-old Northamptonshire batsman was the personal choice of Graham Gooch for this winter's battles in India and the West Indies. 
 &bquo;It's good for the confidence to know that the captain wanted me,&equo; Larkins said. 
 &bquo;I have to admit I was surprised when my name was announced for both tours but, hopefully, I can take the chance with both hands.&equo; 
 Gooch launches the partnership today and will probably stick with it for Friday's second and final warm-up match against an Air India XI. 
 Larkins, like Gooch, was a member of the 1981-2 rebel tour to South Africa. 
 The nearest he has come to an England place since was three years ago when he broke a thumb within 24 hours of being selected to face India. 
 The Australians have cleared the all-rounder Steve Waugh for the trip to India despite a back injury which will prevent him from bowling in the tournament. 
 Australian Cricket Board manager Graham Halbish said doctors had ordered Waugh not to bowl for several months after diagnosing a stress fracture of his lower back &mdash; a legacy of the recent Ashes tour of England. 
 Waugh led the Ashes batting averages with 126.5 from eight Test innings including four unbeaten knocks, but bowled only sparingly in the series because of his back problem. 
 Zimbabwe and Sri Lanka will be making short unofficial tours of England next year, in addition to the official tours by New Zealand and India. 
 Tim Lamb, the TCCB cricket secretary, said: &bquo;The Board has agreed to host the additional tours in order to assist the development of cricket in Zimbabwe and Sri Lanka.&equo; 
 Judo: Ogawa shows his age 
 From PHILIP NICKSAN in Belgrade 
 HEAVYWEIGHTS, it is said, take a while to mature but tend to remain longer in the sport. 
 But in world judo at present, there is a group of young fighters all jockeying for the top positions &mdash; and in the first day of the World Championships here yesterday, they began to sort themselves out. 
 The man who headed the pack was Naoya Ogawa, 21, of Japan, who first came to prominence two years ago at the World Championships in Essen when he threw Britain's Elvis Gordon for ippon in the final of the open weight category. 
 This time, he appeared in the heavyweight division where he produced similar results, throwing his three opponents in the preliminary rounds for ippon (10 points). 
 In the final, Ogawa accounted for another talented youngster, the 23-year-old Cuban, Francesco Moreno, who had earlier defeated the European champion, Rafael Kubacki, of Poland. 
 Gordon, now 31, could not live in this company. 
 He was beaten by both Kubacki and Grigory Veritchev, the 1987 Soviet world champion, who both captured bronze medals. 
 Femgliah Gao, China's leading heavyweight, added another world title to her collection. 
 It was not as easy as usual, however, with West Germany's Regina Sigmund providing stiff opposition in the final. 
 Britain's Sharon Lee also faced Gao and succumbed to two knockdowns, but although she left the hall without a medal, two good wins, including a 20-second victory over Carole Scheid, of the United States, showed that she is capable of making an impact at world level. 
 Sailing: &bquo;Inadequate&equo; Soviet slips anchor in port 
 By STUART ALEXANDER 
 ALEXEI GRYSCHENKO, co-skipper of Fazisi, the Soviet yacht in the Whitbread Round the World Race, has gone missing in Uruguay. 
 After disappearing for 48 hours the matter has been reported to the police in Punta del Este and Montevideo. 
 Gryschenko, 42, from Kiev, had had grave doubts about doing the first leg of the race. 
 Although co-skipper, it was the American Skip Novak whose experience the Soviets had used to manage both the breakneck completion of the 82ft yacht and help to train the crew. 
 Having done three previous Whitbreads, including skippering Simon Le Bon's Drum, Novak's big boat and his ocean-racing experience far exceeded anything Gryschenko had come across. 
 The Russian felt inadequate, but was persuaded that not doing the leg would just put him further behind as the crew developed experience. 
 The police in Uruguay are also taking an interest in the French yacht Esprit de Liberte. 
 The project crew has yet to appear in Punta del Este, so the crew has no money to pay bills already incurred, and their passports have been left in France to be given Australian visas. 
 Skipper Patrick Tabarly, brother of Eric, was yesterday trying to enlist the help of the French Embassy in Montevideo in the hope of preventing his yacht being impounded should the bills remain unpaid. 
 On the swings and roundabouts of crew changes, Grant Dalton, skipper of the New Zealand ketch Fisher &amp; Paykel, issued a denial that Britain's Chris Law would be joining the crew, while Lawrie Smith, skipper of Rothmans, said that on 20 October he would announce that David Powys would boost the crew to 14, plus one or two others. 
 A new, hard-edged approach is expected from the joint services maxi-yacht, Satquote British Defender, in the second leg to Fremantle, Western Australia. 
 Taking over as skipper from the Army's Lt Col Frank Esson is the yacht's navigator, the Navy's Lt Commander, soon to be Commander, Colin Watkins, and the crew is being increased in size from 15 to 16. 
 The quiet-spoken Esson has paid the price of seeing Defender slip from being third at one stage of the first leg to ninth in Punta, leaving Watkins to attack a two days, 17 hours, 37 minutes and 25 seconds deficit to make up on the leader, the New Zealand ketch Steinlager, and a 30 hours, 54 minutes, 52 seconds on the other top British challenger, Rothmans. 
 The damage to the mast has been repaired and three Army officers, Garfield Smith, Nick Bate and Richard Nicholson, have joined the crew, Mandy Gallow and Tim Morris having made a scheduled return to duty. 
 CPO John Giblet is the extra man joining Watkins, who is a veteran of the 1973 race on Adventure, on the 7,600-mile leg where the yachts will play chicken with the 40-knot winds and high-rise seas of the Southern Ocean. 
 American Football: Shell's shock is a winning start 
 By STUART ALEXANDER 
 ART SHELL, the first black head coach in the modern NFL, recorded his first victory as the Los Angeles Raiders beat the New York Jets 14-7. 
 Shell, who succeeded Mike Shanahan last week, got off to a winning start thanks to the safety, Eddie Anderson, who returned an interception 87 yards for the winning touchdown early in the fourth quarter. 
 &bquo;In this organisation there is no black and white,&equo; Shell said. 
 &bquo;It was a great moment for us to win. 
 There's nothing like winning. 
 I was talking to Al Davis (the team's owner) and he said, &bquo;There's no pressure on you to do anything.&equo; 
 But I put that pressure on myself.&equo; 
 After a scoreless first half, the Raiders took the lead on their first possession of the second when Jay Schroeder's 73-yard pass found Mervyn Fernandez. 
 The Jets responded with a 97-yard drive which ended with a one-yard scoring run by Roger Vick. 
 The Jets mounted a final drive which was halted on the Los Angeles 15-yard line with nine seconds left to play. 
 &bquo;Those last two minutes felt like two hours,&equo; said Shell. 
 The victory ended a run of three successive defeats, and Shell showed himself to be a relatively undemonstrative head coach prepared to listen to the advice of his assistant coaches and players before calling the big plays. 
 Bo Jackson, the outstanding running-back who rushes for the Raiders when not playing baseball for the Kansas City Royals, returns to practice this week, but is unlikely to be ready for the Raiders game on Sunday&hellip; against the Kansas City Chiefs. 
 Rallying: Fiorio keeps his cool to extend lead 
 By STUART ALEXANDER 
 ALESSANDRO FIORIO, of Italy, despite being plagued by overheating problems in his Lancia Delta Integrale, extended his lead to more than half a minute during the second stage of the San Remo rally yesterday. 
 Fiorio stretched his 18-second margin over the second-placed Toyota of the Spaniard, Carlos Sainz, to 35sec with wins in the last three of the morning's six special stages. 
 Sainz's team-mate, the 1987 world champion, Juha Kankkunen, of Finland, hung on to third, but his overnight deficit increased to 2min 0.04sec. 
 Roads were turned to mud by days of rain and Fiorio had the additional hardship of a bubbling radiator to contend with. 
 The championship leader Massimo Biasion, of Italy, will retain his world title if he repeats his 1988 triumph in San Remo. 
 Biasion won the first three of the morning's special stages but then lost valuable seconds when he spun and lies fourth overall, two minutes behind Fiorio. 
 The rally ends tomorrow. 
 Squash: Parke emphasises his upward mobility 
 From RICHARD EATON in Singapore 
 SIMON PARKE became the youngest male player to represent England when at the age of 17 years and two months he helped his country to a second 3-0 victory in the World Team Championships here yesterday, this time against the hosts. 
 If anybody has what it takes, it is this long-legged, fair-haired fellow from Knaresborough. 
 The young Yorkshireman apparently has a good temperament and a complete all-round game. 
 To these qualities, he has been adding more and more flair within the past fortnight. 
 Anthony Chua will testify to the fact. 
 The Singaporean yesterday needed 11 attempts before he won a rally, and lost 15 points before he won one. 
 Chua is not a front-line player but Parke's 9-0, 9-5, 9-5 victory signalled the launching of a new &bquo;star&equo;. 
 To maintain the upward momentum, Parke must keep his ambitions high, yet keep his feet on the ground. 
 It is probable those legs will get even longer; Parke is 5ft 11in and growing. 
 Tall men rarely reach the top in squash. 
 However, Parke may soon be at the heels of Del Harris, the 20-year-old England No. 1 who had to battle hard for the second day in succession. 
 He was 5-3 down in the fourth game against Peter Hill before winning 9-1, 9-0, 2-9, 9-5 in a patchy, not to say puzzling, match. 
 Harris won the second game in exactly two minutes without losing a rally, then had trouble with his racket handles and his control. 
 Meanwhile Jansher Khan, the new world champion who had his &dollar;15,000 prize money withheld because he left the official dinner early, may have lost his chance of taking over as world No. 1. 
 The International Squash Players' Association said it will take action this week on the 20-year-old Pakistani, and the likelihood is a fine and a zero point score for the World Open. 
 If so, Jahangir Khan, his predecessor as champion, will stay at the top for the foreseeable future. 
 &bquo;We are absolutely disgusted with his behaviour,&equo; Roger Eady, the ISPA's executive director, said. 
 &bquo;It is something we can't tolerate. 
 It will affect his livelihood if it turns sponsors away. 
 They will find another activity where athletes are more receptive to their requirements.&equo; 
 Schools Football: Bolton fall to old-style virtue 
 By PHILIP JAMES 
 THE VIRTUES of good old-fashioned wing-play were underlined at Bolton where Hulme Grammar School, Oldham, beat their hosts 2-0. 
 Bolton, unbeaten before Saturday's match, fell behind in the opening minute when right-winger Ryan Hill drifted into the penalty area, met a cross from the left, and fired in from an acute angle. 
 After that, Hill, feeding off a series of well-weighted, accurate passes from Richard Smith in midfield, continued to torment the Bolton defence with a series of penetrative runs down the flank. 
 Midway through the second half, Hulme's second goal again originated on the wing. 
 Daniel Mellor's cross was headed in by Matthew Hunt from close range. 
 There is no doubt that the direct approach is still effective as well. 
 A fast and furious encounter between Aldenham and King Edward School, Witley, had yielded no goals when, with just minutes to go, Aldenham's Jason Clemow tried a long-range shot, the goalkeeper parried, and Kazeem Abimbola poked in the rebound. 
 Steve Morrell of King's School, Chester, hit a hat-trick against Repton but still finished on the losing side. 
 The match ended 5-3 in Repton's favour, thanks to two goals by Richard Basnett, and others from Jim McDonald, Jimmy Tipper and Robin Powell. 
 Eton and Lancing enjoyed rather less excitement as they fought out a dour 0-0 draw. 
 Lancing's master-in-charge, John Wilks, described the scoreline as &bquo;a perfect summing up of the match &mdash; dull&equo;. 
 Eton were in charge for most of the match, although Lancing squandered the best chance near the end. 
 The Northern Independent Schools trials were held at Bolton on Sunday, and a team was named for this Sunday's match against Cheshire. 
 Hulme Grammar were best-represented, with three players in the side. 
 At Eton, the Southern trialists were whittled down to a 16-man squad to face Essex at Forest on 5 November. 
 Three Brentwood boys were included. 
 Boxing: Hardy is quick to retain title 
 By PHILIP JAMES 
 BILLY HARDY retained the British bantamweight title against Brian Holmes in Sunderland last night, knocking out the Scottish challenger with an explosive assault in the first round. 
 The pair had met two years ago when Hardy scored a convincing 10-round win in a non-title bout. 
 But this time Hardy went straight on to the attack, putting Holmes on the canvas with a right over the top for an initial count of seven. 
 Seconds later, Hardy landed a stunning left to stagger Holmes again for another count before he finished off his third defence of his crown after two minutes 40 seconds of the round, with a barrage of punches that left referee Larry O'Connell delivering the full count. 
 Lennox Lewis, the British heavyweight, stormed to another thrilling victory when he knocked out Bradford's Steve Garber in one minute 30 seconds of the first round in Hull last night to record his fourth successive victory. 
 Like Hardy, Lewis started impressively, knocking Garber to the floor with two thundering rights to the chin inside a minute. 
 A packed City Hall did not have long to wait as Lewis roared in with several more stinging rights and left hooks and when Garber was floored for the second time he had no chance of beating the count. 
 Gary Stretch makes the first defence of his British light- middleweight championship against Rochdale's Derek Wormald at the London Arena tonight, knowing it could lead to a lucrative world title eliminator against Leicester's Chris Pyatt. 
 Stretch outpointed Gary Cooper for the vacant title more than 12 months ago. 
 Racing: Glover's rise from dark side 
 By SUE MONTGOMERY 
 THERE are times when life not only kicks you in the teeth, but follows up with the knee in the groin and the rabbit punch to the back of the neck as well. 
 That sort of assault makes it more difficult to get up. 
 But when you do, it's a sweet, sweet moment. 
 And on Saturday, in the rain at Newmarket, Jeremy Glover savoured it to the full. 
 He had just won the competitive Cambridgeshire Handicap for the second time in three years. 
 Glover has been training for only five years, and many a famous name has yet to come within spitting distance of the race, so the achievement was remarkable. 
 But the man's melon-sized grin as he scampered into the sodden winner's enclosure to welcome Rambo's Hall indicated more than that. 
 He had proved that he had not, after all, thrown away his how-to-train manual, despite the fact that only Rambo's Hall has won for him this season. 
 Glover's year began badly and went downhill from there. 
 Two weeks before the start of the Flat season he was in hospital having most of his bowel removed because of severe, life-threatening colitis. 
 Then his horses contracted a virus. 
 And the really crushing blow came when the owner of his star performer, Joveworth, removed the horse from the yard. 
 Six weeks later the grey won the Ayr Gold Cup for his new trainer. 
 &bquo;After Joveworth went I was really in two minds as to whether to pack it in. 
 It was Reg Hollinshead and Steve Norton who snapped me out of it. 
 They told me that this sort of thing happens, it's part of training, and to stick in there and show the buggers they were wrong.&equo; 
 Glover showed them, and if anyone had cared to look, the portents for Rambo's Hall's win were there. 
 On his previous outing, at Ayr, the four-year-old gave Sonilla 17lb and ran her to three-parts of a length, with Ned's Aura third. 
 Sonilla and Ned's Aura both won at Newmarket the day before the Cambridgeshire. 
 Glover grinned: &bquo;I ran him at Ayr just to freshen him up. 
 And I got on at 50-1 immediately after that race, and had a fair bet. 
 Winning that race was bloody brilliant.&equo; 
 Joveworth, incidentally, finished 25 lengths behind Rambo's Hall. 
 Glover, 45, and a former top-notch jump jockey, took up training relatively late in his racing career. 
 He retired as first jockey to Stan Mellor in 1977, after eight seasons in the top 10. 
 The likeable Glover, a most sympathetic horseman, trains at his own Pinewood Stables at Carburton, near Worksop, which sounds horrendously urban, but isn't. 
 The 36-box yard is set amidst 17,000 acres of glorious scenery in Clumber Park, owned by one of Glover's most loyal patrons, Lady Anne Bentinck. 
 It is entirely appropriate that racehorses should be trained in that setting, for Lady Anne's grandfather was the 6th Duke of Portland, owner of the legendary racehorse and sire St Simon. 
 The box where he lived as a stallion is still preserved on the estate. 
 The owners of Rambo's Hall, four businessmen, have stuck by Glover when those of lesser faith might not have done. 
 The trainer explained: &bquo;Three of them, Jeff Newton, Mick Dews and Barry Dixon, had a horse with me called The White Lion, who won a seller and I told them to let it go. 
 But the new bloke sent it back to me and it went on to win six races, and I felt so sick for the lads. 
 &bquo;After The White Lion won they gave me &pound;6,000 and told me to get them another, so I sold them three shares in Rambo's Hall &mdash; who I'd bought cheaply in a job lot as a yearling &mdash; for &pound;1,500 each. 
 Bud Booth, who I used to ride for, came in later. 
 Rambo's won first time, and now it looks like they've got a decent horse.&equo; 
 Glover is used to pain. 
 As a jockey, he broke everything &mdash; skull, neck, vertebrae, feet, kneecaps, collar bones &mdash; bar his legs. 
 But permanent illness is more difficult than injury. 
 He talks about his ileostomy (a permanent colostomy) with the lack of embarrassment that only someone who has been through it can. 
 He said: &bquo;I've always been a worrier, and apparently it's stress that makes the lining of the stomach and bowel come away. 
 I was on drugs, but they kept having to use stronger and stronger ones for the pain. 
 I only had about two inches of rectum left, and they said cancer was a possibility, so they just took it all out. 
 I had begun to feel that ill that I didn't care, but I was back riding out three lots three weeks after the op.&equo; 
 For much of this year, Glover's drawn face has matched his prematurely greying shock of hair. 
 But the Cambridgeshire result gives lie to the notion that nice guys can't win. 
 The oldest rookie is still punching to the line. 
 Racing: Roberts to get a run out of Money 
 By HYPERION 
 MICHAEL ROBERTS recorded his second consecutive century in this country when winning the last race on Power Shift at Folkestone yesterday and can take this season's total beyond 100 at York this afternoon, writes Hyperion. 
 Winning the three-year-old stayers' race on Star Lord (2.30) should not be a problem for Roberts but the price will be cramped. 
 Victory at better odds, however, could can come through Where's The Money (3.00), a lightly-raced three-year-old who will be fresher than most of her rivals. 
 Roberts excels on sprinters and the filly is well drawn. 
 The nine-race card at Haydock is strong on quantity but lacks runners of the class of Old Vic, the winner of the Whitebeam Maiden Stakes by six lengths last year who went on to take this year's Irish Derby and its French equivalent. 
 The same race is divided into two today, and the spoils should be split between Adding ((2.15), from the in-form stable of Guy Harwood, and Toucan (5.45), a Luca Cumani runner who finished well when third to stablemate Chirone at Yarmouth last month. 
 Also at Haydock, the 5lb claim of talented apprentice jockey Jimmy Fortune eases the burden on topweight NATIVE GEM (4.45) and this filly's consistency should be rewarded. 
 De Klerk gives order for Sisulu's release 
 From LAURINDA KEYS of Associated Press 
 PRESIDENT F W de Klerk last night announced the unconditional release of eight prominent political prisoners, notably Walter Sisulu, 77, former secretary-general of the African National Congress and the closest political associate and oldest friend of Nelson Mandela, with whom he was jailed for life in 1964. 
 The move is seen as presaging Mr Mandela's release, perhaps early next year. 
 In a politically bold move whose timing was widely interpreted as a favour to Margaret Thatcher with a week to go to the Commonwealth summit in Kuala Lumpur, Mr de Klerk said that the prisoners would be released as soon as prison formalities were dealt with. 
 &bquo;Most South Africans are tired of confrontation and wish to speak to one another about the road of prosperity and justice for all,&equo; he said in a nationally broadcast statement. 
 Mr de Klerk telephoned Mrs Thatcher at the Conservative conference in Blackpool to tell her of the decision before it was announced in South Africa. 
 Five of the eight prisoners due to be released were convicted of terrorism and sentenced for life in the famous Rivonia Trial of 1964. 
 They are Mr Sisulu, Andrew Mlangeni, Raymond Mhlaba, Ahmed Kathrada and Elias Motsoaledi, all of whom are more than 60 years old. 
 Also to be released is Wilton Mkwayi, who took over the overall command of the ANC's military wing, Umkhonto we Sizwe, after the others were jailed but was himself arrested and jailed for life in 1965. 
 Mr de Klerk also announced the release of Oscar Mpheta, a legendary figure in the black trade union movement who, at 80, is the country's oldest political prisoner. 
 Mr de Klerk said Mr Mandela was fully aware of the proposed releases, lending substance to the belief that the world's most famous political prisoner has played a decisive negotiating role with the government way beyond the political limitations normally placed on prisoners. 
 Mr de Klerk, who said Mr Mandela's release was &bquo;not on the agenda now&equo;, expressed the hope that the release of the prisoners would contribute to a spirit of reconciliation. 
 Of the eight prisoners, Mr Sisulu is the best known, second only to Mr Mandela in both symbolic and substantial political importance. 
 His &bquo;unconditional&equo; release, by which it is understood he will be able to operate freely in politics, represents a risk for Mr de Klerk, since it is clear Mr Sisulu will have a capacity to generate mass political gatherings, as well as give a revitalised direction to anti-apartheid politics. 
 Explosives found on Hampstead Heath 
 By TERRY KIRBY, Crime Correspondent 
 A LARGE QUANTITY of explosives and what detectives described as &bquo;terrorist paraphernalia&equo; was discovered yesterday in two bags dumped on Hampstead Heath, one of London's most popular parks. 
 Anti-Terrorist Squad detectives from Scotland Yard began an investigation. 
 The area was sealed off, sniffer dogs were called in to search for more explosives and the bags taken to the Metropolitan Police forensic science laboratory for examination. 
 Although there was no confirmation last night, it was being widely assumed that the explosives were Semtex and the discovery part of a pattern of similar finds and explosions in an IRA mainland campaign that has continued for more than a year. 
 The most recent explosion was the Deal bombing on 22 September in which 10 Royal Marines bandsmen were killed. 
 Commander George Churchill-Coleman, head of the Anti-Terrorist Squad, last night appealed for the public to be vigilant as a result of &bquo;this timely reminder&equo;. 
 He refused to give details of the type, quantity and condition of the explosive or identify the &bquo;terrorist paraphernalia&equo;, although it is possible this might include timing devices or detonators. 
 Scotland Yard added that it was a &bquo;significant find&equo;, which suggests there was a sizeable amount for forensic analysis, but said connections with other incidents was &bquo;mere speculation&equo;. 
 It is possible the discovery could be part of Middle Eastern terrorism &mdash; two months ago a terrorist was blown up by his own bomb in a London hotel in an incident later linked to the Satanic Verses affair. 
 The cache was discovered by a workman on the site of an old hospital about 50 yards from Spaniards Road, a main road running across the heath near areas used for car parking by visitors. 
 Detectives are working on the theory that the bags had been there for some time. 
 If the IRA is involved, they may have been dumped after the discovery of an IRA bomb factory in Clapham, south London, last December, in which 150lb of Semtex, arms and other equipment were discovered, with a list of 100 potential targets. 
 Subsequently, 22lb of Semtex was found dumped in water filter beds in Stoke Newington, north London, and then 25lb of Semtex and some firearms were found near Scarborough, North Yorkshire. 
 Detectives named two men sought in connection with Clapham as Patrick Sheehy and John Conaghty, who are believed to have been the core of a cell of about five or six. 
 The Conservatives in Blackpool: Lawson speaks from beyond the graveyard 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 NIGEL LAWSON went missing from Blackpool yesterday. 
 He had wanted to be alone while he wrote tomorrow's vital speech to the Conservative conference. 
 The only place peaceful enough in the midst of an economic crisis, it seemed, was his early Victorian former vicarage home at Stoney Stanton, in his constituency, two-and-a-half hours' drive away. 
 This also had the advantage of giving a signal to the money markets. 
 Staying in Blackpool to ride out the storm might have been unduly bullish, while retreating to London could have prompted undue alarm bells. 
 But just to be on the safe side Mrs Lawson was stationed in 11 Downing Street, giving her husband a convenient reason to visit the capital if circumstances took a sudden turn for the worse. 
 It was also suggested that should the Chancellor need to make urgent calls to the International Monetary Fund, his telephone at home was likely to be more secure than calls from a hotel in Blackpool surrounded by journalists. 
 The image Mr Lawson presented holed up in his home behind a securely locked gate was unfortunate, in view of the speculation over his political future. 
 The only way to view the Chancellor was by scrambling through the neighbouring graveyard and looking at the house across a row of tombstones. 
 In the middle of the morning a reporter climbed over the low fence into Mr Lawson's garden and rang his entry phone. 
 Mr Lawson's disembodied voice told him he was trespassing. 
 At 1.30pm a portly white-shirted figure looked anxiously through the downstairs front window at the growing assembly of reporters and photographers and disappeared. 
 An hour later the village bobby was let into the house by Mr Lawson, and shortly afterwards they emerged together for the Chancellor to give the message the world's money markets had been waiting for. 
 &bquo;I'm working on my speech,&equo; he said in a tired and slightly world-weary voice. 
 &bquo;If I pose for a photograph will you all go away and leave me to some peace and quiet?&equo; 
 &bquo;Can you tell us what you're planning to do about the fall..?&equo; 
 He went back inside without another word. 
 The policeman shepherded everybody away and padlocked the churchyard. 
 &bquo;He's one of my parishioners. 
 Leave him alone now,&equo; he said. 
 Pressure grows for rethink over EMS: Pound's slide raises speculation about UK move towards entering Exchange Rate Mechanism 
 By PETER TORDAY and MICHAEL PREST 
 PRESSURE on the Government to reconsider its strong opposition to full membership of the European Monetary System mounted yesterday after the authorities failed to arrest another slide in the pound. 
 Deepening concern over the Government's monetary policies and a gloomy stock market forecast compounded nervousness in financial markets by sending London share prices into rapid retreat yesterday. 
 The FT-SE 100 Index closed 28.2 points down at 2,218.8. 
 The Bank of England stepped into the currency markets three times as the pound continued its slide below 3 marks &mdash; once seen as a level which would attract critical support from the Government. 
 Selling pressure also sent sterling briefly below DM2.95 for the first time since August 1987. 
 By the London close, the pound was 2 pfennigs weaker at DM2.9537. 
 Against the dollar it lost 1.9 cents to finish at &dollar;1.5585. 
 So nervous were the markets that the disappearance of Nigel Lawson from the Conservative Party conference in Blackpool obliged the Treasury to issue a statement that he was writing his speech at home. 
 Sterling lost ground against the dollar after the US central bank, the Federal Reserve, signalled that it was not about to reduce its interest rates. 
 There had been considerable speculation and concern that it was about to do so. 
 Yesterday morning shares seemed to recover from Monday's collapse. 
 They had gained 14.2 points by early afternoon, but the market was thrown sharply into reverse by a forecast from a consultant to the stockbroker Barclays De Zoete Wedd that the market could fall to 2,100-2,200 by the end of the month and to 1,800 next year. 
 Since its post-crash peak a month ago, share prices have fallen by 8.5 per cent. 
 Sterling's dramatic weakness in recent days has reawakened speculation in financial markets that the Government will not be able for much longer to resist joining the Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) of the EMS, the system of semi-fixed exchange rates to which most members of the European Community belong. 
 Margaret Thatcher has personally opposed joining the ERM. 
 However, the widely-perceived reluctance of the Government to raise base rates again has encouraged expectations in financial markets that it is seeking alternative monetary policies. 
 Mr Lawson's speech to a City banquet at the Mansion House next week is seen as one occasion on which new policies -possibly even a step towards full EMS membership &mdash; could be outlined. 
 Gavyn Davies, chief UK economist in London for the US investment house Goldman Sachs, said: &bquo;If they joined the pound would spontaneously recover.&equo; 
 He added that the market gloom was caused by fears of recession. 
 But Professor Alan Budd, chief economic adviser to Barclays Bank, said of the Government's predicament: &bquo;In the short run there is nothing that can be done. 
 When the markets go against you there is nothing that can stop it until the market adjusts.&equo; 
 He added that the Government had &bquo;neither an exchange rate policy nor an interest rate policy&equo;. 
 Professor Budd's remarks echo a widespread belief in the City that the Government needs to develop a credible monetary strategy. 
 There is scepticism that a return to controlling the growth of broad money supply would work when many of the economic pressures on Britain are external. 
 The sense of instability in financial markets increased when Alan Greenspan, the chairman of the US Federal Reserve and one of the world's most powerful central bankers, appeared to criticise the international efforts to stabilise currencies recently agreed by the Group of Seven main industrial nations, which includes Britain. 
 Mr Greenspan said: &bquo;Great importance may be given to the short-run stabilisation of domestic financial markets or foreign exchange markets.&equo; 
 But he added: &bquo;Such considerations, however, may ultimately be counter-productive if they are allowed to obscure or cause long delays in achievement of price stability (zero inflation).&equo; 
 TELEVISION / Travel sickness 
 By MARK LAWSON 
 IS IT POSSIBLE to be too nice to be a television presenter? 
 Certainly, there is substantial observable and anecdotal evidence that, in the cases of many of our leading frontpersons, qualities other than modesty and friendliness rank highest among the energies they bring to their profession. 
 Charm is like Spam; you have to have something else with it. 
 You can be nice with a slight edge of cynicism like Ludovic Kennedy, Alan Whicker or Desmond Lynam but, in adult television at least, being pleasant about everything all the time is best left to constitutional monarchs. 
 So the main tension in Around The World In 80 Days (BBC 1), in which Michael Palin does a Phileas Fogg, is whether the famously amiable presenter will ever rise to a barbed remark. 
 Ladbroke's had a book open on whether he would get round inside the distance but the far spicier price would be odds against him in bawling out a porter in Bangkok. 
 Being rude about Palin feels like bombing Switzerland, but for the first time he seems, with this series, to be to post-Python what Paul McCartney was to post-Beatles. 
 His equable temperament would complement perfectly a tough production but this one kicked off soft. 
 Six hours of television began with Palin taking a phone-call at home ('The BBC? 
 Oh, yes? ') asking him whether he had ever thought of going round the world in 80 days. 
 It was a tense moment but, luckily, he said yes so the seven-part series was underway. 
 A useful rule of documentaries is that re-creations of scenes which occurred before filming always leave the viewer feeling cheated. 
 Curiously, Palin made a point in the commentary about how he wasn't pretending that he was on his own or that there were not gruff acolytes kneeling at his feet as he spoke. 
 Director Roger Mills even retained a quip from Alan Whicker (whom the presenter consulted) about a Bernard Levin series in which the pretence of solitude was attempted. 
 This was fine, but solid evidence will have to be provided that the scene in which Palin woke up on the Orient Express to the knock of brioches at the door was the real thing. 
 I expect the crew had tiptoed down very gently from the bunk above while he slept. 
 On the subject of rest, you twitched a bit when Palin was referring to feeling weary as early as the second day. 
 The script kept sending out these little signals ('It's only when there's land around that sea travel becomes really interesting') but it was possible to take them as evidence not of exhaustion but of apprehension about the project. 
 The nerves extended to the visuals. 
 Venice, God help us, was introduced by a shot of gondoliers. 
 But then the problem with a television tour of Europe is that it begins with the familiar. 
 We must hope it was a harbinger that the one riotously funny scene occurred at the end of the first episode, with Europe through. 
 The presenter had been advised confidently by Coutts before he left London that, should funds be required, he should telephone them with the code-word Jabberwocky. 
 Short of cash while just short of Cairo, Palin reached them from the ship. 
 &bquo;This is Jabberwocky&hellip; 
 Can you tell her it's Jabberwocky?&hellip; 
 Oh, it's Friday&hellip; 
 I see.&equo; 
 You suspected that in the deterioration of the arrangements lay the series' main hope of improvement. 
 Nice Work (BBC 2), in which factory meets fiction, continues to be the treat of the week. 
 David Lodge has adapted himself cleverly and economically, introducing the kind of tricks that actors can make work for you; like the way in which Vic the businessman uses choice lines from Robyn the lecturer in subsequent conversations. 
 The Christophers Parr and Menaul, producing and directing, have also thought through visually a literary script; from the astonishing Rothman's smog of the board-meeting scenes to the volley of sighs, nods and twitches - beautifully played by Warren Clarke and Haydn Gwynne &mdash; by which Robyn's gradual acceptance that executives also possess inner lives is signalled. 
 The only quibble is that the materials of Vic's erotic dream about Robyn - in which she splashes with nymphs in a pool before firing an arrow &mdash; are a bit literary. 
 His fantasy would more probably have been of Robyn as the first female, naked centre-forward for Birmingham City. 
 Sorry, Rummidge City. 
 THEATRE / A mingled yarn: Paul Taylor reviews All's Well that Ends Well at Stratford 
 By PAUL TAYLOR 
 THERE ARE moments in Barry Kyle's partly dismal, partly enchanting production of All's Well that Ends Well, that will come as a great comfort to anyone who is exceptionally slow-witted. 
 Just in case you fail to deduce, for example, that war is more a matter of narcissistic games-playing than of honour for the play's young soldiers, they helpfully tote around personal full-length mirrors in the court scenes. 
 Then, in a dream-like sequence at the end of the first half, they are seen raiding the nursery at Rossillion, where they proceed to plunge their swords into a defenceless rocking-horse. 
 Likewise, to give the fistula-suffering monarch (Hugh Ross) rather more than his fair share of Fisher King-like significance, he is made to stagger about in a stagy, enfeebled agony that could compete with Amfortas's travails in Parsifal. 
 This is, you will gather, a production that tends to deliver its messages by lorry. 
 But the crude over-emphases jostle with touches of true subtlety. 
 In the course of the drama, Gwen Watford's venerable Countess seems to get perceptibly older, whiter-haired and stiffer in the joints, as though her son's behaviour towards Helena and the news of his other derelictions has slackened her hold on life. 
 And, given that All's Well is a play in which mementoes of the past and symbols of family tradition (rings, secret medical cures) carry such a charge and play a crucial part in the plot. 
 It is especially moving in this production that Watford, painfully trying to disinherit her son from her affections, should feed his little toy soldiers and letters home to the smoky bonfire of autumn leaves on her estate. 
 One of the peculiarities of this problem comedy is that the main obstacle to the course of true love comes not, as is traditional, from the older generation but from the young hero, Bertram. 
 He has, you might suppose, some right on his side. 
 After all, why should he consent to be Helena's fairy-tale prize for curing the King, if he cannot love her? 
 But your ability to sympathise with him is powerfully lessened by the fact that this hero is also an immature prig and lying snob, whose principal objection to Helena is her social inferiority. 
 In an over-diagrammatic performance, Paul Venables suggests that, buried deep down, Bertram may harbour a secret affection for his enforced bride. 
 This, because he wants to cut a figure among the fighting lads and impress Parolles, he is forced twistedly to repress. 
 Having reduced Helena to tears by refusing her a kiss on his departure for the wars, he has, you notice, to check himself from an involuntary lunge forward to comfort her. 
 This hint of a potential for goodness in the hero helps give some human credibility to Helena's otherwise folkloric determination to re-entrap him via the bed trick. 
 At least the object of this man-hunt is not wholly worthless. 
 It is in the second half, when Helena becomes a quasi-symbolic force for life and renewal that Patricia Kerrigan's performance comes into its own. 
 As she orchestrates the substitution plot, she radiates a touchingly-willed but inspiring hopefulness. 
 Harriet Walter, in the last RSC All's Well, realistically signalled a pained disgust at the fresh flaws in Bertram which this scheme brings to light. 
 But Kerrigan has a keyed-up, visionary quality which, though it does not overlook these drawbacks, manages to see beyond them by an act of moral imagination to the purposed end. 
 There are fine performances, too, from Bruce Alexander as the wordy and worthless Parolles, his front of unfazable swagger clearly a very thin crust over awful insecurity. 
 Here, even the famous credo of uncrushability by a mere comic plot comes across as somewhat comically crushed. 
 Best of all, though, is Suzan Sylvester as Diana. 
 Appropriately for a drama in which the grossest crimes, though intended, turn out to be apparent rather than real, her chaffing in riddles of Bertram and the King in the final scene is a marvellous mix of the pointedly cutting and the teasingly playful. 
 It is a performance of real moral authority, lightly worn, and richly earns her the right to be the character who, like Paulina in The Winter's Tale, stage-manages the resurrection of the heroine &mdash; here literally pregnant with the future. 
 MUSIC / Rich contrasts: Rattle conducts Ravel and Mozart. 
 CBSO / Rattle &mdash; Birmingham 
 By JAN SMACZNY 
 THE ACOUSTIC of Birmingham Town Hall has never been kind to the mistier recesses of Debussy and Ravel. 
 In the first half of a concert which spanned the gamut from Expressionism to Impressionism, the hall's resonance favoured the spare lines of Webern's Op 6 while proving cruelly analytical in Ravel's Sheherazade. 
 Such imaginative concert planning deserves a more versatile acoustic, one which the Town Hall, for all its considerable virtues, does not possess. 
 Webern's Six Orchestral Pieces, still perceptibly Romantic even with the pruned wind band of 1928, emerged under Simon Rattle with enormous personality. 
 The funereal fourth piece despite some squelchy brass chords, had a true air of expectancy and generated a terrifying climax. 
 The brutal clarity which the acoustic bestowed on Ravel's Sheherazade stripped the work of atmosphere. 
 There was lots of marvellous playing with sensitive string sound and excellent wind solos, but the whole was too clear an image of Ravel's subtle settings. 
 The cycle might have been written for the celebrated dramatic powers of Maria Ewing. 
 Her performance, though full of poise and presence, was at a disadvantage in terms of balance. 
 Many vital stanzas were lost, although none could fail to mark the superbly engineered climax of the first song or the sensuous duet with the flute at the end of the second. 
 For those seated close to the orchestra, this performance was doubtless a treat; those up in the gallery were left frustratingly under-involved. 
 No such problems marred a fascinating interpretation of Richard Maunder's newish edition of Mozart's C minor Mass. 
 With the soloists placed above the orchestra, nearly every note was audible. 
 It is quite an achievement to upstage the assembled might of City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra and Rattle, not to mention Maria Ewing as second soprano, but this is precisely what Barbara Bonney, standing in for an indisposed Lillian Watson, did. 
 Her solos brought us some of the most memorable Mozart singing heard in years. 
 The contrast between her fine-boned line and Maria Ewing's post-classical, though undeniably exciting, view of her role in the Domine Deus was revelatory. 
 Pitting a slim-line orchestra against a jumbo choir might be hazardous with any body other than the CBSO Chorus. 
 In the fast passages the choir sang as one voice and did much to render some mannered readings of appoggiaturas and dynamics thrilling. 
 This performance was a rich mixture of styles: perhaps not one to put on record, but certainly not to be missed live. 
 MUSIC / Pinning it down: The Marriage of Figaro - Glyndebourne 
 By MICHAEL JOHN WHITE 
 REIGNING monarchs have a history of obtuse relationships with Mozart. 
 Joseph II will always be remembered for finding &bquo;too many notes&equo; in Die Entfuhrung; and our own Queen has an almost comparable claim on immortality if the story is to be believed that when asked to attend a performance of Figaro, she replied: &bquo;Is that the one about the pin?&equo; 
 It is, of course, the one about the pin. 
 And however silly it might sound to take so slight a fragment of the story, the possibility of doing so says perhaps as much about the richness of the opera as it does about the interests of the listener. 
 There are many, varied access routes into great art, as this year's Glyndebourne Figaro has shown. 
 In quick succession it has passed through three lives. 
 There was the original Peter Hall / Simon Rattle collaboration for the festival, remarkable for the introduction of authentic instruments to Glyndebourne. 
 Then there was a semi-staging for the Proms. 
 And now the production has been re-staged by Stephen Medcalf for the Glyndebourne tour with a new cast (some of the occupants of minor roles in the festival have been promoted: Alison Hagley's Barbarina is now Susanna), a different orchestra, the London Sinfonietta, and a new conductor, Sir Peter Maxwell Davies. 
 The acquisition of Sir Peter is, inescapably, the chief interest of this Figaro. 
 As a conductor he is, in a sense, a &bquo;new boy&equo;, accustomed to directing contemporary music but a late-starter in broader repertory. 
 This Figaro is the first time he has tackled an opera written by someone other than himself. 
 The result is very different from Rattle: the authentic instruments are gone; and the London Sinfonietta are not particularly experienced in playing Mozart. 
 But they are supremely experienced in the process of discovery, and when they do play older repertory they always do it with a sense of looking freshly at the notes, taking nothing for granted. 
 All the details in the Figaro are prominently placed, the product of obvious and careful thought. 
 There isn't the transparent profile of original instruments, but Davies has encouraged an approximation to it. 
 His speeds are not so driven as Rattle's, the energy level is lower; but there is a clearer sense of the cunning in the music. 
 The ensemble, sometimes a bit slack, worked especially beautifully in Act Two, where the singers were at their best: a strong, capable Figaro from Robert Poulton, a pleasingly unhaughty Countess in Elizabeth Gale, and a fine, well-focused Almaviva in Robert Hayward despite his dramatic reticence. 
 The restaging generally has less bite and less fluency than Hall's original &mdash; Susanna's humour is more truly peasant-like &mdash; but it feels warmer and more sympathetic. 
 Medcalf's pin pricks gently. 
 THEATRE / When the chattering stops: Heartbreak House - Cambridge Arts Theatre 
 By ADRIAN POOLE 
 A CAST LIST boasting characters called Hesione Hushabye and Lady Ariadne Utterword does not promise an evening of undertones. 
 Shaw's Heartbreak House pays homage to Chekhov, but it has nothing to learn from Joe Orton. 
 &bquo;Is this England, or is it a madhouse?&equo; cries someone. 
 No need to ask. 
 Nancy Meckler's production for Shared Experience makes this peculiarly English madhouse funny and frightening in almost all the right ways. 
 There is certainly a war on, but no one seems to notice the one going on outside. 
 Meckler makes a ghostly Tommy wander in and out of Captain Shotover's country villa, but Shaw's family of grotesques are far too absorbed in playing their power-games to pay any attention. 
 They fill the foreground with easily punctured fantasies and vicious cartoon banter. 
 The words &bquo;bloated capitalist&equo; take the literal shape of the mountainous Boss Mangan. 
 Women swoon at the sight of the moustache sported by Hesione's husband; later on this reluctant roue appears as an Arab sheikh. 
 In the sex-wars, the men mainly get the worst of things. 
 Two of the women turn Mangan into a blubbering infant, and a third polishes her nails with vigorous glee over the wallowing body of her sentimental admirer. 
 &bquo;Cry baby,&equo; Ariadne chortles. 
 This is all good rollicking fun, though never quite clean. 
 But it is when all the brittle, garrulous posturing gives way to something else that this production really shows its intelligence. 
 It is the moment that Shaw called, perilously, &bquo;heartbreak&equo;, but there is nothing sentimental about the pauses when the chattering stops. 
 Wisps of distant music, the creak of machinery, enigmatic shiftings of light, a spasm of slow-motion: first you realise that this house (in Dermot Hayes's cunningly flimsy set, a little Calvary of stunted, corroding masts) is haunted, then that it is doomed; and then, the real turn of the screw, that these people may really want to be doomed. 
 &bquo;Is there thunder in heaven?&equo; asks Hector Hushabye, vainly clutching for Jacobean grandeur. 
 We really can't see much future for a gang of derelicts like this &mdash; &bquo;rather a favourable specimen of what is best in our English culture&equo;, one character blithely insists &mdash; and they don't see any for themselves. 
 Shaw said that his method was founded upon music, and this extraordinary, teetering play needs the finest of ears to balance its tones and pace its switchback rhythms. 
 Shared Experience does it proud. 
 Inside Eye 
 By LIAM CARSON 
 Liam Carson, general manager / director of the Groucho Club, has worked in London restaurants for the last 15 years. 
 LUNCHTIME at the Groucho Club is never like this. 
 For a start Albert the Thief would not have made it through the membership committee. 
 He is the embodiment of a restaurateur's nightmare, someone who behaves grotesquely yet spends an awful lot of money. 
 Quelle horreur: many's the time I have found myself torn between throwing people like him out and putting up with them for the sake of the cash-till. 
 This decision would have been complicated by the fact that Albert is also the part-owner of La Hollandaise. 
 But, while he is of Le Patron Mange Ici school (which always used to be the sign of a good restaurant), I can't see that it would have been particularly good for business here. 
 His antics and those of his wife would have the environmental health officer round at the drop of a hat. 
 Fornication in the kitchen is surely not allowed under Section 37/3 of Westminster City Council Environmental Health Act&hellip; 
 Still, this orgy of food and sex would have suited the dear departed Peter Langan (with whom I worked for four years) very nicely. 
 The kitchens in La Hollandaise were undoubtedly going to serve decent grub. 
 I am sure I spotted Nico Ladenis preparing some divine demi-glace and Bohringer, the head chef, bore an uncanny resemblance to Michel Guerard, one of France's three-star Michelin men. 
 Chefs are not usually noted for their even-temper and calmess, however, and Bohringer's sleepy-eyed nature was at odds with this. 
 The entire kitchen (there must have been a brigade of 50 where one would expect more like 12), belongs to some turn-of-the-century grand Parisian establishment, but strangely there was only one washer-upper. 
 The food, fancy French, all mousses and coulis, stuffed this on a bed of that, is now rather dated &mdash; stuck in a late-Seventies time-warp. 
 Had Greenaway wished to depict the chic cuisine of the moment, he should have chosen &bquo;Cuisine de Terroir&equo; (food of the earth) &mdash; solid, gutsy, grandmother's cooking very far removed from the nouvelle fantasia we see here. 
 Full marks for the service, though: discreet and professional. 
 If you go and see this film I recommend that you don't eat first. 
 A couple of stiff drinks and a bowl of soup afterwards was about all I could cope with. 
 I felt strangely repelled at the thought of eating meat. 
 Peter Greenaway has advanced the vegetarian cause no end. 
 FILM / Architectural bellies: The Cook, The Thief, His Wife And Her Lover; Shirley Valentine 
 By ADAM MARS-JONES 
 BY NOW, the name of Peter Greenaway functions either as a reliable guarantee or a reliable warning. 
 With The Cook, The Thief, His Wife And Her Lover (18) he has made a few changes, but certain basic principles hold good: the look of everything is still turned into art history, and the meaning of everything is still turned into nothing, a nothing that sometimes seems despairing and sometimes only smug. 
 Greenaway's obsessively elaborating and allusive aesthetics have always been strangely at odds with his reductive philosophy, but the insistent paranoid patterns &mdash; lists, correspondences, arcane games &mdash; which in earlier films served to bind them together are much less in evidence in the new film. 
 There are still a few speeches in Greenaway's house-style of inert paradox and cod worldliness &mdash; notably a digression by the Cook (Richard Bohringer) about black food and the price structure of restaurant meals &mdash; but the story, for better or worse, stands relatively clear of verbiage. 
 The bulk of the action takes place in and around an impossibly stylish restaurant, divided into the four zones of car-park, kitchens, dining-room and lavatories. 
 The zones seem to be associated with different moods and eras, post-industrial apocalyptic for the car-park, medieval for the kitchens, belle epoque for the dining-room, and high-tech for the lavatories. 
 They are also rigorously colour-coded, so that when the Wife (Helen Mirren) walks into the lavatory from the dining-room, the camera keeping pace with her all the while, she is miraculously redressed in identical tacky Jean-Paul Gaultier clobber, but now in white and not red. 
 The constant tracking shots across the extraordinary sets provide the film's major pleasure. 
 Greenaway's camera, to chime with the story's intensive focus on eating, is fixed at stomach height for most of the film. 
 But though the camera may be at gut level, a cerebral decision has placed it there, and it is characteristic of Greenaway that he should stylise a major element of his film in this way. 
 For this most unspontaneous of artists, it is better to have a bad reason for something &mdash; a tenuous or cabbalistic reason &mdash; than to depend on chance, subjectivity and the moment. 
 Of course, only a sensibility that is accustomed to seeing food largely in still lifes can be surprised, as Greenaway seems to be, by the revelation that food, whether eaten or not, eventually by digestion or rot comes to look less good. 
 This is a particular case of a general rule about Greenaway's films: that only a person as obsessionally preoccupied with formal patterns as the director &mdash; and that is a tall order &mdash; can properly share his shock when death turns out not to be deterred by lists and games after all. 
 More moderate temperaments, to whom the patterning seemed a sort of death in the first place, are apt to remain stubbornly cheerful. 
 The plot of The Cook, The Thief, His Wife And Her Lover has a hand-me-down Jacobean tragedy feel to it, though it is usually only the language of those plays that remains exciting, not their storylines, and Greenaway is innocent of imitation there. 
 The character of the Thief is of unrelieved grossness and barbarity, and Michael Gambon turns in a resolutely one-dimensional performance. 
 Sometimes an actor makes an escape attempt in a Greenaway film (notably Brian Dennehy in Belly of an Architect) but Gambon is a model prisoner of his director. 
 Oddly enough, there is a point in the new film when Greenaway puts the formalism on a back-burner, and seems to remember that he has hired actors - people, that is, who are skilled at projecting emotions. 
 But by then it is too late. 
 Without fair warning he calls on Helen Mirren, hitherto muffled by the black flounces of his cosmology, to produce raw feeling, love even, loss and rage. 
 She must go to sleep next to her murdered lover, talking of breakfast, and she must then persuade the Cook to prepare the body for eating. 
 In these scenes, Greenaway's camera stops moving and his technique, alternating awkwardly between long shots and close-ups, seems ragged and inadequate. 
 The defence of formalism is always that it serves to control an excess of feeling, but here in the absence of formalism there is nothing but empty pathos, artificiality in its weak form. 
 In a recent interview, Greenaway said that he hated the idea of a shot in a film being only a preposition, linking what went before and after. 
 It is a revealing remark, because it shows that he doesn't think of himself as being in the business of constructing anything like sentences, though a film sequence is a sort of visual sentence, composed of standard elements inflected in an infinite variety of ways. 
 What writer, after all, would think of despising a part of speech for performing its indispensable task? 
 Greenaway rejects the conventional grammar of film, its reaction shots and implied points of view, but he replaces it not with his own idiom but with his slide library, though a film modelled on an art-historical lecture has no greater intrinsic claim to quality than one modelled on a promotional video, a newsreel or a travel brochure. 
 Shirley Valentine (15) is a film version, directed by Lewis Gilbert, of Willy Russell's one-woman show, first performed by, and now starring, Pauline Collins. 
 It is a piece with few reasons to be a film, and mercifully few pretensions to cinematic status. 
 If Peter Greenaway's camera is anything but a participating human representative, Gilbert's is nothing else, addressed, ogled, and even winked at by the heroine. 
 The story is of ersatz oppression and liberation, oppression by domesticity and chips in suburban Liverpool, liberation by sunshine and retsina on a Greek island holiday. 
 (They don't have winter in Greece, you know.) 
 Russell's screenplay is full of announced sympathy for ordinary people's lives, and actual condescension. 
 The ways for women to escape or understand their circumstances are systematically disparaged. 
 Marjorie (Joanna Lumley), for instance, whom Shirley envied for her academic prospects, ends up with only the freedom of high-class prostitution. 
 Shirley's best friend Jane (Alison Steadman), on the other hand, declares herself a feminist but is shown as merely paranoid and frustrated, cured of her analysis by a brisk holiday romance. 
 Only escapist fantasy is allowed any authenticity. 
 Still, Pauline Collins is genuinely charming, there are some perky one-liners, and if there was an Oscar for Best Crinkly Smile In A Supporting Role, Tom Conti would have it sewn up. 
 FILM / Dropping in the ocean: The Abyss, Young Einstein, Lola, Asterix and the Big Fight and Driving Me Crazy 
 By SHEILA JOHNSTON 
 WE ARE unlikely to learn many secrets of the soul when the Enterprise sallies forth next week in Star Trek V; but perhaps the underwater movie is more conducive to introspection than questing journeys into outer space. 
 Luc Besson's The Big Blue, for all its follies, had some lovely brooding moments, and The Abyss (12), the biggest and almost certainly best of the current American wave of subterranean movies, nurtures expressly metaphysical intentions: it is, says the producer Gale Anne Hurd, about &bquo;the abyss inside each of us&equo;. 
 It is directed by James Cameron, though, and so primarily a first-rate action picture. 
 Money may have disappeared down a black hole (the budget was &dollar;40m according to Hurd, though industry sources put it nearer &dollar;50m), but it has all been spent on spectacle, not marquee names: Ed Harris (from Jacknife) and Mary Elizabeth Mastroantonio star as an oil-rig foreman and the project engineer, both brought in to rescue a striken nuclear submarine. 
 The underwater sequences &mdash; which occupy most of the film &mdash; warrant the price of admission alone. 
 Shot in an eerie, aqueous light, the scenes in the submarine rig are fraught, cramped and dangerous, in the tradition of The Boat, the diving scenes &mdash; men swimming in slow-motion or submersibles, magically lit, gliding along like ancient chariots &mdash; are steeped in silent mystery. 
 As if it were not enough to battle the elements and their colleagues (the crew includes a freaked-out Naval officer with a nuclear warhead and an itchy finger), Harris and Mastroantonio are a husband and wife with marital troubles. 
 In the course of their mission, which takes each through a death and rebirth (Harris is required to plunge to the bowels of the earth, breathing a kind of oxygenated foetal fluid), they learn to love each other again. 
 Though these bits, unashamedly sentimental, met with laughter, it seemed most like a nervous release of the tension of the previous scenes. 
 But, in the most egregious error of judgement, the film, not content with human interest, ropes in aliens as well, arriving like a deus ex machina from the ocean bed, as though the characters were unable to face their darkest selves without prodding from a benign ET. 
 It is a silly, redundant device that eventually drowns the film in a surfeit of plot. 
 The famous photograph of the 72-year-old Albert Einstein sticking out his tongue at the camera inspired an Australian film-maker who (for reasons he may come to regret) has adopted the name of Yahoo Serious to make Young Einstein (PG), a mock-heroic biopic dedicated to &bquo;the genius rebel with a clowning sense of humour&equo;. 
 Probably Serious, who not only stars in the film, but directed, wrote, produced and edited it too, would not mind the description being applied to himself. 
 It begins as Einstein, the hick son of Tasmanian apple farmers, is prompted by a Newtonian falling fruit to discover gravity only 300 years apres la lettre. 
 Thence, he invents the theory of relativity as a means of putting bubbles into home-made beer; rock and roll; and (his country's major contribution to world culture) the surfboard. 
 The main joke, a cheerily philistine one, is to pitch Australia from the margins of Western thought into its centre. 
 The jokes are copious, hit-and-miss and very broad (the credits include a &bquo;collapsing dunny specialist&equo;): we're in Life of Brian territory, which may be more congenial here than in America, where the film failed to reproduce its massive success on home turf. 
 Jacques Demy's Lola (15), made in 1960, continues the little spate of revivals from the heyday of European cinema. 
 It plays with Godard's Une Femme est une Femme, made the following year, both graceful and romantic tributes to the MGM musical comedy, and to their vibrant stars, Anouk Amiee and Anna Karina. 
 Asterix, whose village was the last in Gaul to resist the invading Romans, was conceived in the Fifties with, no doubt, the Occupation still fresh in memory. 
 He has proved a durable fellow, though, inspiring 28 comic books to date and six animated features, the latest being Asterix and the Big Fight (U). 
 Gaul might be divided into three parts, but this film, imperfectly cobbled together from two separate stories, displays no such narrative neatness. 
 Many of the gags expire when extended beyond a comic-strip frame, and few of the clever puns which have secured Asterix an adult following, survive translation. 
 &bquo;The biggest mass art project in the history of the world&equo; was how the impresario Andre Heller modestly described his plan to stage Body and Soul, an extravaganza of black song and dance. 
 Nick Broomfield was hired to record the event. 
 It was a nightmare: early on, his budget dropped from dollars l6m to &pound;300,000, and his crew was reduced to two. 
 Driving Me Crazy mercilessly records the squalls, the vibrant performances and the inertia of the production team, who spend most of their time solemnly discussing what black music means to them and jockeying for pole position. 
 Broomfield gets under everyone's feet, but soldiers on and ends up with a revealing, funny film about the petty power plays and outsize egos of showbiz. 
 Rushes 
 By SHEILA JOHNSTON 
 Next week sees the release of Melancholia, a directorial debut by Andi Engel, who has until now been best known for his work as a film distributor. 
 Engel is German by birth but has lived in Britain for the last 20 years, and this mixed background has been reflected not only in Melancholia's plot but in its production history, as it has been co-financed by the British Film Institute and the Hamburg company Lichtblick. 
 It was a collaboration with some useful lessons for British companies. 
 According to Colin MacCabe, who produced the film for the BFI, two areas in particular proved unexpectedly tricky. 
 The first was the question of where and how the co-production funds could be spent. 
 Hamburg enjoys an extremely high level of film subsidy - approximately &pound;6 million a year, or three times the sum available in Britain. 
 This generosity is, it seems, partly due to regional rivalry. 
 Hamburg's local government had seen the results of generous film funding in Berlin: the city became attractive to film-makers, work came pouring in and attractive or interesting images of Berlin were sent around the world. 
 Hamburg's decision to follow suit looks like a shining opportunity for venturesome British outfits, but there are snags. 
 Subsidies are granted only on the agreement that a set percentage of any budget must be spent in Hamburg. 
 MacCabe and company had assumed that their location work would prove more than adequate to meet the quota, but then found that they were obliged to do all their processing and post-production work in Hamburg, too -a doubly inconvenient requirement since the local labs are not used to working nearly so quickly as their counterparts in London. 
 The second unexpected area of conflict came over the question of who was to be entitled to final cut on the film. 
 The German co-producers were shocked when they found that the contract for Melancholia gave this right to the BFI, since in Germany final cut is almost always given to the director. 
 After considerable wrangling, a compromise was reached: there would be a German version of the film which would be Engel's and a British version which would be the BFI's (though these &bquo;versions&equo; proved, in the event, to be identical). 
 As a producer, MacCabe is naturally enough dismayed by this pro-directorial bias: &bquo;If you look at what's been happening to British cinema over the last 10 years or so, then it's clear that it has tended to be production-led &mdash; names like Working Title, Palace Films or Zenith are as important as those of any individual director. 
 Good films come about when there are two centres of power &mdash; in other words, when there is the opportunity for some really good rows. 
 &bquo;But the German system appears to have no place for the producer &mdash; it's like a final, ridiculous culmination of the auteur theory, which insisted that movies are made by directors rather than producers &mdash; and so it has no room for that kind of creative argument.&equo; 
 If MacCabe's views on the value of a good row are right, then 1992 may offer some stranger cultural exchanges than expected: we may end up putting our mouths where their money is. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Laughter in the dark: &bquo;Wartime&equo; &mdash; Paul Fussell: Oxford, 15 pounds 
 By TIM BLANNING 
 FOR THE title of his last chapter Paul Fussell borrows Walt Whitman's prediction about the American Civil War, &bquo;The real war will never get in the books&equo;, and then comments: &bquo;Nor will the Second World War, and &bquo;books&equo; includes this one.&equo; 
 He is right, but this modest disclaimer is at odds with the confident tone he adopts in the rest of the book. 
 Nowhere in the previous 300-odd pages has he shown any doubts in his mission to give an account of the war fought by the Allies which balances all those previous versions &bquo;sanitized and romanticized almost beyond recognition by the sentimental, the loony patriotic, the ignorant and the bloodthirsty&equo;. 
 His technique is simple but effective; he looks at the war &bquo;from the bottom up&equo;. 
 He cares neither for the broad sweep of grand strategy nor for the narrow focus of specific campaigns, so he ignores both government archives and the memoirs of the great and the good. 
 What Fussell is looking for are the records of the little people, to discover what the war was like for them. 
 Perhaps not very surprisingly, it turns out to have been pure hell - brutality intensified by stupidity. 
 Typically, the first action he describes was a mistake: the bombing of Freiburg at the beginning of the war by a squadron of the Luftwaffe believing itself to be over Dijon. 
 That sets the tone for what follows, as blunder is piled on blunder. 
 &bquo;We made a major assault on German agriculture&equo; was the laconic comment of J K Galbraith on the notorious inability of bomber crews to drop their loads anywhere near their urban target. 
 Fussell records that German manufacturing output seemed to increase with every bomb dropped; he might have added Albert Speer's witty &mdash; and possibly accurate &mdash; comment that Allied bombing had actually improved productivity by destroying the bureaucracy's files. 
 Tales of squadrons bombing their own units are here in abundance. 
 Although much of this is very funny, the laughter is decidedly uneasy, for death is almost always present. 
 Fussell is a past master of gallows humour; but every now and then one can laugh without any sense of guilt, usually when senior officers are being mocked. 
 Anyone who has ever suffered at the hands of military pomposity will relish the story of General Patton inspecting a hospital in France and screaming abuse at a man for not coming to attention in his presence, only to be told &bquo;Run along, asshole. 
 I'm in the Merchant Marine.&equo; 
 Fussell clearly did suffer during his own military career. 
 His hatred of the army is shouted from every page, most loudly in a wonderful chapter on &bquo;Chickenshit&equo;, best defined as &bquo;sadistic pedantry&equo;. 
 He agrees with an unnamed British soldier that there were two wars being fought &mdash; against the designated enemy and against the army. 
 No wonder, then, that Fussell can find not a single redeeming feature of the war. 
 In the space of one page he describes it as &bquo;indescribably cruel and insane&hellip; savage, insensate, barely conceivable to the well-constructed imagination&equo;, &bquo;boring&equo; and &bquo;demoralizing&equo;. 
 This is not the first or last case of over-statement. 
 One's admiration for the brilliance of Fussell's writing cannot suppress doubts about the partiality of the picture he is drawing, with all its entertaining anecdotes and quotes. 
 He gives us two kinds: salty recollections, verses and songs of the rank-and-file (surely no previous volume from this august publisher has contained so many f-words and c-words); and more elegant expressions of disillusion from the intelligentsia. 
 There are plenty of both, more than enough to sustain an indictment of the war, but insufficient for an understanding of what it was all about. 
 It was concerned with more than the effing and blinding of other ranks or what Cyril Connolly published in Horizon. 
 When Fussell tells us that the war was &bquo;so devoid of ideological content that little could be said about its positive purposes that made political or intellectual sense&equo;, he shows that he has become the prisoner of his own limited sources, and also of an imagination limited by distaste for his subject. 
 By choosing to take at face value all the evidence pointing to the futility of the war, and ignoring all those who believed, with patent sincerity, that they were fighting for something worthwhile against something evil, he has taken cynicism to the point of naivety. 
 My Week: Meeting in Mukden 
 By CHARLOTTE BLACKER 
 THE late James Cameron, who roamed the globe, used to claim that his least favourite city was Mukden in Manchuria&hellip; until he went to Blackpool. 
 I know nothing about Mukden except that it and Blackpool are equally unlucky in their names. 
 But there is something infallibly depressing about Blackpool. 
 The fun is obligatory, that's the problem. 
 So when the wind blows and the rain descends, as it has this week, you are not only upskirted and damp, but you feel guilty too. 
 This is uncomfortably similar to the endemic guilt of constituency agents like me, since it's our role to believe that everything die Partei does at all times is absolutely right. 
 And of course it is. 
 Other sections of the Partei (except the government speakers) are allowed to express dissenting views. 
 They are even allowed to say we have, here and there, made a cock-up. 
 We agents, however, must represent anything with the air of a cock-up only as an opportunity to demonstrate the Partei's brilliance in extricating itself from it. 
 Thus, we are the only definable group in the Winter Gardens today who are actually looking forward to Nigel's speech. 
 PERHAPS we are the only definable group, except for the landladies, who look forward to conference at all, conference and elections being the only points in the calendar when our lives become primed with meaning. 
 We know now why God chose us to be agents and not lollipop persons or antique dealers. 
 This priming often has to last the entire remaining 51 weeks. 
 But when apparatchiks from Central Office, who have us acting as stewards (ie, usherettes) are often seen risking life and limb, SAS-style, in order to arrive at a doorway at the same time as a minister does, they are taking a serious risk with morale. 
 Last year, so piqued was I by this, that I plunged the outsize handbag of an excessively bossy senior stewardess from Central Office into a fire-bucket of water on the grounds that it could have contained an incendiary device. 
 This year I have paid for it. 
 I have been banished to a windy concrete corridor far from everywhere. 
 What primes us agents most is our own exclusive conference speech from the Leader. 
 This occurred on Monday night at a dinner at the Imperial Hotel. 
 When she sat down we rose in a body, convinced and as one. 
 This was an outstanding achievement, since we began the dinner (with Avocado aux Crevettes de Blackpool) unsettlingly divided: the organisers (Central Office again) had expanded the Top Table so ridiculously, in an attempt to flatter those who care about such things, that all of us who weren't on it were consumed with envy. 
 The Leader's message was that winning the next election depended not so much on her as on us. 
 Our collective noun is an Apprehension of Agents. 
 Conferencemanship is an inferior art form. 
 Not so much for the platform speakers, who have arrived, but for some of the floor speakers, who haven't and would like to. 
 I refer to would-be parliamentary candidates, Bordes-type aspirants with lunging bosoms and other improbable specimens, who seek to board the Candidates' List, and in due course may turn up before our selection committees. 
 These types hang around the Great in the hope of getting them to pull a string. 
 WE agents are Shepherds of the Faithful &mdash; the 5,000 or 6,000 who fill the hall, averaging a dozen per constituency. 
 We book them into the Seaview and the Esplanade and give them a comradely nosh-up at the Claremont. 
 They are much nicer people than the mass of politically inactive carpers would suppose. 
 The blue-rinsed dame and the bottle-nosed blimp are extinct species here. 
 And of those who would hang, it is less for retribution than to save the next victim. 
 (But it would be a mistake to bring it back &mdash; we are bound to hang some unfortunate youth who would later be proved innocent by Ludovic Kennedy.) 
 For now they sit like shareholders at the annual general meeting of a company whose profits have fallen on last year's. 
 What will they take home? 
 1. 
 Three or four sharply conflicting views about the suitability of Michael Heseltine for the leadership of the Partei should it ever become vacant again. 
 2. 
 Reassurance that it's safe to stick to the policy without losing the next election. 
 3. 
 A stick of Mukden rock. 
 The author is constituency agent for Kensington Conservative Association. 
 A task for the green-eyed boy 
 By PETER JENKINS 
 BLACKPOOL: The Prime Minister's speech-writer-in-chief, Chris Patten, had never himself addressed a Conservative Party conference. 
 He must have felt like Sir Norman Hartnell wondering what to wear for the Royal Enclosure at Ascot. 
 Never clash with the Queen: the same goes for any aspiring young member of Mrs Thatcher's Cabinet. 
 One of the &bquo;Blue Chips&equo;, regarded in her early days as little better than an Edward Heath Youth Movement, the new Secretary of State for the Environment is now her green-eyed boy. 
 Yesterday was his big chance. 
 Much was expected. 
 In tone and content Mr Patten's speech was of some significance, coming like a breath of damp air into the dry and brittle atmosphere of the Winter Garden. 
 In what has been a good year for poets at the conferences, with Neil Kinnock quoting both Frost and Shelley, and Kenneth Baker identifying with Henry V or Kenneth Branagh, Mr Patten chose Larkin's observation that, with honour gone, all we could now leave to our children was money. 
 Was this an ecumenical endorsement of the Archbishop of Canterbury on Thatcherism? 
 Surely not. 
 Burke was also invoked as a reminder that the cult of individualism is not the only, nor perhaps the chief, stream of the Tory tradition. 
 Burke, said Patten, had reminded us of our duties as trustees for the nation, of its traditions, its values and its riches. 
 A nation, he had written, was a partnership between the past, the present and the future. 
 Nothing snide or loaded here but enough to set a high Tory and paternalistic tone not often heard from the platform at recent Conservative conferences. 
 Appropriate too, because the sudden greening of British politics, the rediscovery of the quality of life (QOL, as it used to be known among Labour ministers on a previous incarnation) introduces a catalytic ingredient into the brew known as Thatcherism. 
 Environmental protection and wealth creation are in tension but not necessarily in conflict, and indeed there can be little hope of improving the quality of the environment without the resources to do so. 
 This has become the standard Tory party-point in which the Labour Party can be linked with the ecological disaster areas of the no-growth communist world. 
 But in no way can effective environmental policies be rendered compatible with the anti-statist, non-interventionist creed which has inspired a good deal of Thatcherite rhetoric. 
 Concern for the environment was certainly not among the Victorian virtues and the passing of laissez-faire and the coming of the welfare state could be written as a parable around the ideological battles which preceded the conquest of cholera through the construction of sewers at the public expense. 
 &bquo;It is for government to regulate on behalf of the community, to set the standards and the environmental goals,&equo; said Mr Patten emphatically. 
 &bquo;Planning,&equo; he later added, &bquo;is a form of regulation to enhance the quality of life.&equo; 
 Pattenism is not to be a continuation of Ridleyism: an important theme underlying the whole speech was that he intends not to err on the side of market forces at the expense of planning restrictions. 
 Regulate? 
 Deregulate is the British cry for the Europe of 1992. 
 Regulation is a nasty continental vice, what the European Commission does, what makes Jacques Delors run. 
 Here is an ostensible shift in the balance of the Government's approach, reflecting the new composition of the Cabinet but also, perhaps, the new constellation of electoral politics following the disintegration of the centre parties. 
 The centre ground of British politics is once more an open arena for two-party competition. 
 The centre ground is these days tinged with green. 
 How green is the Tory party? 
 In its heart, not very. 
 The Prime Minister's latest ambition is to close the ozone gap and save the world from the greenhouse effect. 
 We should wish her every success. 
 At home, on both wings of her Cabinet, are ministers who regard green politics as no more than the latest fad; the election will not be won by fighting on the beaches, in the air, and in the green belts, but once again in the pockets of the people, is their view. 
 QOL? 
 Yes, well, up to a point&hellip; 
 As for the rank-and-file, the conference gives the impression that green belt and suburban preoccupations dominate the concern for the future of the ecosphere, not-in-my-backyard as Nicholas Ridley dubbed the attitude, ever honest and inept. 
 And the green-eyed boy himself? 
 Identifying the environment as a major priority is one thing, doing something about it another. 
 The scope for action ranges from saving the world to cleaning up Clapham High Street. 
 Mr Patten scored well in the middle range, for example the town and country planning issues which most concern his own supporters. 
 He also ranged higher and spoke inspirationally of the &bquo;absolutely imperative task, to bring the whole world together in a cause which both touches and imperils our common humanity&equo;. 
 But when he got down to the streets where we live he said, &bquo;If people want a cleaner Britain, they can start with their own street and their own neighbourhood&equo;. 
 How I can make a start cleaning up Clapham High Street I would like to know. 
 It is used by vast numbers of people who do not live there but take lunch at its many bus stops. 
 Sometimes is almost ankle deep in filth and litter. 
 Mr Patten promises that the Government will &bquo;allow (sic) the public to take local authorities to court if they fall down on the job of keeping the streets clean. 
 But why should the citizen have to do this? 
 Should not the Government enforce the statutory responsibilities of local authorities? 
 Why do the police not enforce the law? 
 Cleaning up Britain does not require international action, involve huge public expenditure, or impair the efficiency of industry. 
 It is exactly the kind of thing a truly determined and environmentally conscious government could get on with and do. 
 Great seaside pretensions 
 By TERRY COLEMAN 
 To Blackpool, for the illuminations, and to hear three leaders&equo; speeches - those of Baker, Heseltine, and Howe. 
 Mrs Thatcher's own will come tomorrow. 
 &bquo;Like Disneyland,&equo; said the innocent, first-time Tory delegate with whom I shared a cab from the station. 
 No, I said. 
 There might be funfairs everywhere, but the real Disneyland was neither crumbling, nor swept by bitter winds off the Irish Sea, nor cursed by hotels that are really gimcrack boarding houses, nor served by superannuated London cabs displaying notices saying that if you're so drunk that you're sick inside, a cleaning fee of &pound;10 will be payable to the driver. 
 The survival of Blackpool as a resort proves vividly the stubbornly persistent poverty of expectation of the English. 
 But there are the illuminations, miles of them along the seafront, which people really do come to admire, driving slowly and reverently down the tatty Golden Mile. 
 And, for this week of the Conservative conference only, there are endless television lights in the foyer of that fortress called the Imperial Hotel. 
 The lights are always there so that Mrs Thatcher, at whatever hour, may choose to be seen on TV sweeping through saying nothing, thus demonstrating that she is Prime Minister and going busily about the nation's business. 
 And Blackpool does have, at the Winter Gardens, the most atmospheric party conference hall in England, a plush and gilded set for political dramatics. 
 There on the platform you see who's in, who's out, and at whom Mrs Thatcher smiles. 
 There and in its environs, this week, have been played out the shows of Kenneth Baker as Kenneth Branagh, Michael Heseltine as Alvin Stardust, and Geoffrey Howe as Geoffrey Howe. 
 The situation is grave because the bank interest rate is at 15 per cent. 
 It is not grave because there needn't be an election for two years and more. 
 It is all in order because the proceedings start with a service conducted by the Anglican rural dean, at which the reading is by a member of the Free Churches, and where prayers are said by a Jesuit. 
 It is all out of order because the preliminaries are a shambles. 
 Was this shambles a sign? 
 It is unusual. 
 The Tories are impeccable in their organisation. 
 But you get in nowhere without a pass, applications for which are vetted by the Special Branch, and this year hundreds of passes went missing and had to be queued for. 
 You waited outside in the street for up to two hours, and then, when you got to the box office, the passes were heaped in no known order, and Tory office girls scrabbled through piles of them as if digging for hidden bones. 
 When the passes were found, each was enclosed in an envelope with a first class frank and a recorded delivery sticker; the covering letter inside mine was dated 18 September. 
 Then the chains on some passes were too short to pass over the wearers' heads: they were getting longer chains in. 
 Then, the day before it was due to begin, they had already run out of conference handbooks. 
 I will remark that MCC, a cricket club efficient by long tradition, made a similarly chaotic cock-up with its match tickets at the beginning of last season &mdash; and look how that season turned out. 
 I sometimes think that only the professional politicians, the organisers and the hacks who cover these things year-in year-out have the vaguest idea what anything is about. 
 This year 1,073 motions have been put down, but only 18 of those will be debated, and, of those 18, only two will be chosen by the conference itself. 
 A typical motion will congratulate Her Majesty's Government on its policy, and call upon it to continue. 
 I call this a &bquo;congratulate, and call upon&equo; motion. 
 There is the occasional &bquo;congratulate, but call upon&equo; motion, but such deep dissent is rare. 
 The debates are processions of praise. 
 To many delegates their presence is a holiday and a reward. 
 The law and order debate is a traditional exception. 
 As the representative from Rochdale said yesterday afternoon, she knew most people in the hall would vote for the return of the death penalty, at which the applause was loud and sustained. 
 But that is a permitted indulgence. 
 And though the Tory woman's hat is a high art form now decayed and lost, as is that of the elegant crossing of Tory wives' legs on a platform far above, and though the party has become more catholic in the women it attracts, there is a still a discernible type of Tory woman. 
 Two of the female proposers of motions are married with four children each. 
 And one of this year's vice-presidents of the association is a farmer's daughter who became a farmer's wife who gave birth to three sons, and whose special interests include farming. 
 It will be seen, therefore, that whatever the state of the pound Mrs Thatcher is in no danger from the constituencies. 
 But the menace of the IRA is everywhere. 
 Mrs Thatcher's car is armour-plated, the platform party leaves in a tank-like bus, the town crawls with policemen, and all this vigilance costs &pound;1.1m. 
 The ratepayers are sick of paying 49 per cent of this bill. 
 But let me get to the various leaders' speeches. 
 Mrs Thatcher has a new party chairman, Mr Baker, who worked for Mr Heath, and in former days was a notorious wet. 
 He once said the Tory party was like a bird &mdash; with a left wing, a right wing, and its brains in the middle. 
 He is a man who has edited a book of satirical verse. 
 He has miraculously survived all this, and even being education secretary, but how would he measure up to being chairman, in a party where, in times of stress, to be party chairman is a greater thing than to be a secretary of state? 
 And the chairman also has to make a big speech on the first day. 
 He managed. 
 Now Mr Baker is a man of substance, who, as a backbencher in the year Mrs Thatcher came to power, said in the House that a backbencher trod a fine line between sycophancy and rebellion. 
 He is ambitious, but rebellion of any overt kind now appears to be out. 
 The Prime Minister, he said, had entrusted him with delivering her fourth election victory. 
 On the platform he made a movement of deference to her, with open hand held out. 
 She in return regarded him with what looked like admiration. 
 He would not fail her, he said. 
 The first election shots had been fired. 
 The polished Mr Baker, in defence of Mr Lawson's interest rates, even brought himself to shout, something for which the conference handbook, in its Suggestions to Speakers on page 46, says there is no need. 
 &bquo;Victory,&equo; he said. 
 He even descended to the realms of the unwise and hubristic Kenneth Branagh and declaimed some words of Henry V before Agincourt. 
 Everyone knows Mr Baker has edited the Faber Book of English History in Verse, and included some lines from Henry V, but even there he never got to that particular bit. 
 He which hath no stomach to this fight, let him depart. 
 At which, after an ovation, half the audience did depart to hear Michael Heseltine, whose idea of a fringe meeting is to hold it in the Grand Theatre, which is very grand, built 1906, seats 1,200, and where Alvin Stardust will head the bill in this year's pantomime. 
 Watched from above by proscenium cherubs, and in the spirit of One Nation first enunciated by Disraeli and all that, Michael Stardust held forth, he who walked out of the Cabinet and resigned. 
 He who also hopes for the leadership, but not yet, but still makes a speech fit for a leader. 
 Now this speech has been well reported, and 10 commentators will produce 10 glosses. 
 And, true, he hacked at Mr Lawson's trade deficit; but he also defended his rise in interest rates. 
 But above all, this was a loyal speech. 
 It had to be, because Tories destroy those whom they deem disloyal. 
 But this speech fairly shone with loyalty, way beyond the call of self-preservation. 
 Filthy streets, he said, bodies bent down in doorways, were no advertisement. 
 But that's the permissible Heseltine touch. 
 All this, I say, giving my gloss, can be read &mdash; and more particularly seen and heard, since Heseltine's manner and presence carry their own conviction &mdash; as the utterance of a man demonstrating that he has been in the wilderness longer than it is in anyone's interest. 
 &bquo;Make me an offer,&equo; he might have been saying. 
 And that is as acceptable an approach as a little touch of Harry at the conference. 
 Then we come to Sir Geoffrey Howe, the third contender. 
 He is a grey man in a grey suit. 
 He is Deputy Prime Minister, but yesterday sat on the very edge of the platform group. 
 He is not down to address the conference at all. 
 But he could and did hold a fringe meeting with the Bow Group, where he gave the becoming speech of a statesman. 
 He toured the world. 
 What Gromyko had said to him and what he had said to Shevardnadze. 
 How the miracle of the turn-round and recovery under Margaret Thatcher's leadership was rightly hailed as an inspiration worldwide. 
 How Mr Lawson was right, and had not only his sympathy but his support. 
 But, he said, they should never be seduced into thinking their policies had been so effective that there was no risk of relapse. 
 He was wary of triumphalism. 
 There was, he said, a triumphalist literature which celebrated the end of the struggle as we had known it. 
 He named Francis Fukuyama, an American, whose &bquo;End of History&equo; article might tempt one to think that the struggle was over and to put one's feet up, thinking that every alternative to economic liberalism, in recent times, had shown itself to be hopelessly flawed. 
 But it did not follow that we could now relax, least of all in Britain. 
 Here was the statesmanlike Howe. 
 Not a flourish. 
 Never a shout. 
 His great strength is that he looks a small-'c' conservative, with that appealing moderation which used to be thought Tory. 
 You could say that, somehow, he made the most convincing of the would-be-leaders' speeches. 
 Mrs Thatcher, though, is there, and triumphantly there, and will be triumphally acclaimed when she has her say tomorrow. 
 Leading Article: The return of Edmund Burke 
 By TERRY COLEMAN 
 &bquo;READ Edmund Burke.&equo; 
 With this advice the Secretary of State for the Environment, Christopher Patten, yesterday rebuked a Thatcherite who had urged the Conservative Party to put its faith in the free market. 
 The Thatcherite thought Mr Patten was wrong to oppose the building of a new town at Foxley Wood, in Hampshire. 
 Most of the conference firmly supported Mr Patten. 
 His predecessor, Nicholas Ridley, had favoured the building of Foxley Wood, but his approach to the environment was so unpopular that he was moved to another department. 
 The Prime Minister has far more sympathy for Mr Ridley's view than Mr Patten's. 
 She has failed, however, to convert her party. 
 In Blackpool, evidence mounts daily that the Conservative Party has rejected Thatcherism. 
 Speakers may still make respectful remarks about the market, but few want it to be free. 
 Michael Heseltine is among the eminent figures who have advocated greater government help for industry. 
 His advocacy is not surprising: he never abandoned the interventionism which was part of the conventional wisdom in the Sixties and Seventies. 
 But he evidently believes his chances of eventual succession to the leadership of the party are enhanced by his &bquo;pragmatic&equo; plea for intervention. 
 More strikingly, Sir Geoffrey Howe, a stalwart of the heroic period of Thatcherism in the early 1980s, when she as Prime Minister and he as Chancellor of the Exchequer defied almost the entire economic establishment, has started to lay greater stress on the Government's role in industry. 
 Sir Geoffrey spoke more cautiously than Mr Heseltine when he urged &bquo;the energetic use of existing agencies and resources, private and public sector alike, to give potentially fruitful initiatives a helping hand&equo;, and praised the work of the Welsh Development Agency. 
 In effect, however, he was letting it be known that Mr Heseltine would not be the only interventionist candidate for the leadership -nor the only one to feel more enthusiasm about Europe than Mrs Thatcher. 
 The rise of public concern about the environment has done most to hasten a realisation among Conservatives that Thatcherism has its limitations. 
 &bquo;First, our philosophy,&equo; Mr Patten said at the start of his speech yesterday. 
 He did not then make an appeal to Adam Smith, the intellectual inspiration behind Thatcherism, but went on: &bquo;The greatest of Tories, Edmund Burke, reminded us of our duties as trustees for the nation, as good stewards of its traditions, its values and its riches.&equo; 
 In this speech, Mr Patten confirmed himself as the leading exponent in the Cabinet of a traditional Toryism owing nothing to Mrs Thatcher. 
 Students of political philosophy are sometimes set the question: &bquo;Was Burke consistent?&equo; 
 They invariably get into difficulties trying to answer it, for Burke, unlike Adam Smith, was not a systematic thinker. 
 Therein lies the danger for the Tories in rediscovering him. 
 His sublime but discursive wisdom could be used to camouflage a headlong rush towards an easier life, one in which hard problems are fudged, not faced. 
 The arrangements announced yesterday to ease the introduction of the poll tax are symptomatic of a less rigorous approach. 
 In practice as well as in theory, Thatcherism is in the process of being abandoned. 
 Leading Article: De Klerk takes a necessary risk 
 By TERRY COLEMAN 
 PRESIDENT F W de Klerk's decision to release Walter Sisulu and seven other long-detainees is only his first step along the road of political reform in South Africa &mdash; but an important one. 
 Mr Sisulu, the former secretary-general of the African National Congress, may be less famous than Nelson Mandela, but he is equally formidable: if his family is included, even more so. 
 Mr de Klerk is taking a risk in releasing him unconditionally, a move which can be interpreted as a de facto unbanning of the ANC. 
 If Mr Sisulu senior (and his seven fellow detainees) are allowed to take part in political activities, his wife Albertina and their son Zwelakhe, a newspaper editor, cannot realistically continue to be restricted. 
 From his own continued but comfortable detention, Mr Mandela will be assessing the unconditionality of his colleagues' release. 
 He would evidently like to make the freeing of all political prisoners a pre-condition of his own release. 
 The latter, he said yesterday, is &bquo;not now on the agenda&equo;. 
 One of the many dangers for South Africa's evolution is that each move which President de Klerk makes will be discounted in advance by the opposition. 
 It was, at the least, bad psychology for Archbishop Desmond Tutu to belittle the release of this first batch of heavyweight political prisoners. 
 The same discounting may occur with the next moves, probably involving the lifting of the three-year-old state of emergency and the formal unbanning of political organisations. 
 As for eventual negotiations on political reform, the ANC has already partially pre-empted them by drafting its own programme, which was endorsed this summer by the Organisation of African Unity and leaders of non-aligned countries. 
 Further endorsement will be sought at the Commonwealth heads of government conference in Kuala Lumpur next week, and at the General Assembly of the United Nations. 
 Unexceptional though the proposals are, their widespread endorsement could have two unwelcome effects for Mr de Klerk: of internationalising negotiations for reform, and of marginalising other potentially important representatives of the black majority, like the Zulu leader Chief Buthelezi. 
 For Mrs Thatcher, the timing of President de Klerk's announcement in the week before the Commonwealth conference is helpful, though she would have had no difficulty in resisting pressure there for further sanctions. 
 For her and others who wish South Africa well, Mr de Klerk's bona fides remain unproven. 
 Is he genuinely anxious to give the black majority full political rights, or is he simply interested in the survival of Afrikanerdom? 
 The economy is crumbling, and the country's foreign debt is due to be rescheduled by next June. 
 From all quarters, and especially from the white business community, the message is the same: only with social justice can the country's economic potential be released. 
 Some remarkable men are now being freed after a quarter century in prison. 
 Their crime was to want to overthrow the apartheid state. 
 Their minor acts of sabotage &mdash; reminiscent of those of Welsh nationalists &mdash; caused no injuries, let alone deaths. 
 Their return to public life will increase the pressure for political reform. 
 It is a process which Mr de Klerk must accelerate, but which he will find hard to control. 
 Importance of being Kenneth 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 TODAY we conclude our extract from the hitherto totally unknown Shakespeare play. 
 King Kenneth I, Part II Confident young Kenneth is being warned by his wife, Queen Emma, that if he gets any more young and confident, people may gang up and say rotten things about him&hellip; 
 King: Publicity, they say, is never bad. 
 Tis better to be mocked than be ignored. 
 Together, dearest Emma, we can rise Above the petty heckling of our foes Tis all hot air, and hot air can be used To hoist aloft the balloon in which we soar! 
 Just turn your face a little to the right. 
 That's better; now you're much more in the light. 
 Emma: Publicity's a tiger which can turn and rend The man who thought it once to be his friend. 
 King: Sweet Emma, you remember far too well The jeers and cat-calls mingled with the praise When you did sing and dance for half an hour In your own TV show. 
 It was not bad at all&hellip; 
 Emma: Not bad at all!? 
 I thought you liked the show. 
 Emma: Too clever by half, Or so the critics said, week in, week out. 
 King: They say the same of me, and always will In England, where to excel is still a crime. 
 And yet if we are both &bquo;too clever by half&equo; 
 Then let us join our clever halves to make a whole! 
 Emma: You may be right. 
 Yet I do fear the worst. 
 King: I'll walk on unafraid! 
 Emma: Look both ways first. 
 Exit Queen Emma. 
 Kenneth takes several phone calls from his agent. 
 Then enter the ghost of Laurence Olivier. 
 King: What pale and ghastly apparition here Doth tear the eyeballs from my living sight? 
 Speak, if thou canst, and whilst thou'rt at it, Move one small pace this way to get in range. 
 This is a two-shot, not a bloody close-up. 
 Speak, speak, thou vision of hell! 
 Ghost: All right, all right! 
 Don't shout at me; it gives a ghost a fright I've only come to have a little chat I do not think we've met. 
 The name's Olivier&hellip; 
 King: Of course. 
 They still talk much of you today&hellip; 
 Ghost: Oh, do they now? 
 How very gratifying&hellip; 
 King: And endlessly contrast yourself and me. 
 Ghost: Well, Ken, dear boy, you somewhat asked for it, When you chose Henry V to film again, Drawing inevitable comparisons. 
 King: Comparisons with you are odorous. 
 Ghost: Oh, very droll, dear lad &mdash; you will go far. 
 But I have come to warn you that ahead Lie hazards that are little short of dread. 
 King: You mean the constant limelight and the gossip? 
 The crowd of critics waiting for a fall? 
 Ghost: Oh no &mdash; that's all great fun, I think, don't you? 
 King: Well then, the titles, slowing down the actor, Like silken chains around his neck and feet? 
 Ghost: Well, to be honest, I was never bored With being a knight, or, better still, a lord. 
 No, I was thinking of a far worse fate Which can o'ertake you when you're 28. 
 King: Which happens, as you know, to be my age. 
 Ghost: I know. 
 Learn, then, that on the stage The worst thing's not to be the newest Larry But to hear behind your back Tom, Dick or Harry Being greeted by the critics with &bquo;Hosanna! 
 Here comes the man to oust old Kenneth Branagh!&equo; 
 King: A young pretender to my crown you mean? 
 Ghost: Just so. 
 Think on't. 
 And now I leave the scene. 
 Thank God no more by me needs to be said. 
 Line-learning is so boring when you're dead. 
 Exit the ghost of Larry, leaving Kenneth looking pensive, as well he might. 
 For rest of story see daily Press&hellip; 
 Letter: Arts grants for ethnic minorities 
 From Mr FRED D'AGUIAR 
 Sir: Fiona Pith-Helmet must have had her hard hat pulled over her ears and eyes leaving only her mouth operational when she accused the Arts Council of inverted racism ('What about the special needs of a struggling poet without funds?&equo; by Fiona Pitt-Kethley; Living, 27 September). 
 Being wilfully deaf and blind these last 25 years, she would have missed the debates and riots which culminated in the Race Relations Acts and in institutions such as the Commission for Racial Equality. 
 With a head as hard as hers, she would have failed to register any number of missiles lobbed her way, such as the Scarman Report which followed the Brixton riots of 1981. 
 It is exactly the equality before the law, which Ms Pith-Helmet invests with so much trust, that has betrayed blacks and Asians in the courts, in their treatment at the hands of vicious and prejudiced police (that has resulted in the death of 10 blacks at the hands of police during the course of arrest and interrogation in the last 15 years), that allows black and Asian homes to be terrorised by racist thugs who can sprinkle liberally their British hospitality in the form of firebombs, beatings, excrement dumped on doors, and children bullied to the point of suicide and madness. 
 But this is reality, not the world of arts subsides and grants to which Ms Pith-Helmet aspires to belong. 
 Being deaf and blind, all this would have passed her by. 
 The notion of giving a helping hand to a new literature produced against these overwhelming odds would naturally appear to her to be anathema. 
 Two notable and deserving successes cited by her in no way disqualify the principle of special needs. 
 If anything, the rarity of such successes (disproportionately few in relation to the number of writers and artists) testifies to the crucial place of Arts Council grants for minorities in British society. 
 Letter: A way out for the elephants 
 From Mr DAVID COULSON 
 Sir: Your leading article on the ivory trade (10 October) was a bitter blow to all who have the interest of the African elephant at heart. 
 Far from indulging in political theatre as you suggested, Kenya and Tanzania, by campaigning for an international ivory trade ban, are fighting for their political life. 
 Both countries depend on wildlife-based tourism for their economic survival. 
 Both countries are being bled dry by the poachers who supply the ivory trade. 
 Both countries also enjoy the full support of Britain and the US &mdash; a point you chose to ignore. 
 The argument that a ban will drive ivory trading underground is plainly absurd, since up to 90 per cent of all ivory currently in trade has come from elephants illegally slaughtered by poachers. 
 Nor can an ivory ban be compared to attempts to stop trade in alcohol or tobacco. 
 Nobody ever got high on elephants' teeth. 
 Common sense cries out for a moratorium to allow the herds time to recover. 
 No one will suffer. 
 The southern African countries can salt away their ivory stocks in the bank until the day trade resumes, and watch them increase in value. 
 Since tusks continue to grow throughout an elephant's life, the amount of ivory carried by the herds will also increase. 
 Then, properly managed, perhaps using birth control instead of the crude culls practised by Zimbabwe and its friends, there is no reason why elephants should not go on producing &bquo;found&equo; ivory (tusks picked up after natural mortality) and tourist revenue for ever. 
 Surely it is time we stopped talking of elephants as if they were a commodity to be traded, like so many cans of paint, and accept them for what they are, ancient and splendid fellow inhabitants of the earth who share with us the joys of close kinship bonds and grieve when they are severed. 
 Letter: Secrecy in Tory selection process 
 From Mr ERIC CHALKER 
 Sir: The article by Tom Arnold (9 October), vice-chairman of the Conservative Party, takes much pride in the fact that social connections are, in his view, no longer a passport to becoming a Conservative candidate (9 October). 
 He offers Conservatives and the public at large a picture of equal opportunity for all. 
 Unfortunately, within the party, there is widespread distrust of the approved list of candidates and it is regarded as anything but fair. 
 The eminent weekend &bquo;assessors&equo; are no doubt most conscientious in their task and, despite the apparent absence of a &bquo;score card&equo;, come to their conclusions in inviolate objectivity, but that is not the whole of the process. 
 Before most aspirants get to a parliamentary selection board, they are vetted by one of the party's full-time professionals, who submits a secret report. 
 Other individual reports are also obtained (so does it really not matter whom you know?) and are added to each individual's file. 
 These files are secret of course. 
 It is the secrecy and lack of accountability that are the present system's greatest faults. 
 At no point is any aspect of the selection process subject to democratic scrutiny or approval. 
 Tom Arnold himself is appointed, not elected and, although he reports to a committee &bquo;representing&equo; the voluntary party, he is not accountable to that committee, nor is that committee elected by the constituency associations on whose behalf it is supposed to act (it does not even report to them). 
 Of course there are allegations of favouritism, affecting both getting on to the list and then getting &bquo;placed&equo; afterwards. 
 Social background may not matter much now (but until they publish the list we cannot judge this for ourselves), but the 100 per cent increase in party professionals getting on the list and getting elected to Parliament between 1979 and 1987 cannot, surely, be just coincidence? 
 So, too, do we hear and see frequent examples of the pressure to conform that is put upon those who have parliamentary ambitions. 
 When the path to achievement of ambition is a hidden process rather than an open competition, all are vulnerable to establishment pressures. 
 The old &bquo;establishment&equo; to which Tom Arnold refers may have gone, but a new one is in its place and he is a representative of it. 
 Letter: &bquo;Trojan&equo; arguments 
 From Mr PATRICK ROBERTSON 
 Sir: Contentious points are raised in your leading article, &bquo;High time for monetary union&equo; (11 October), not least the title, which itself implies an ideological support for &bquo;European union&equo; in favour of an analytical study of the forces at work in Europe. 
 It is a fallacy at the present moment to believe that there are any quick cures for our monetary difficulties, least of all joining the ERM (European exchange rate mechanism). 
 Membership of a system of exchange rate parities which are fixed would involve considerable intervention in the underlying economy to maintain that fixity. 
 We would be forced to invent more and more mechanisms to avoid the realignments which members of the ERM are bound to face. 
 In the long-term, this may be more damaging than a short-term run on the pound. 
 Predictable is the reference to our non-membership being the result of &bquo;narrow-minded nationalism&equo;, and this emotive point somewhat detracts from the overall objectivity of many who put forward cogent arguments for British membership of the ERM. 
 In this context, although Mr Lawson supports the ERM, he too would be, no doubt, a narrow-minded nationalist when faced with the prospect of European Monetary Union, as would increasing numbers of German economists who argue on the basis of economic research that EMU is not necessarily an attractive option. 
 It is a tragic fact that the European debate, which is the most complex and important issue facing the countries of this continent, should be treated in such a facile manner, with the Trojan horse of &bquo;nationalism&equo; and &bquo;sovereignty&equo; wheeled out every time better arguments do not prevail. 
 Europe has a destiny to fulfil, and in years to come it will become apparent that the best Europe is one which rejects interventionist mediocrity in favour of a European Community which will deliver the promise of a higher standard of living and political pre-eminence so justly deserved by all Europeans. 
 Letter: South-east shambles 
 From Mr ERIC GATES 
 Sir: Paul Barker's analysis of the shambles of planning policy in the South-east in the aftermath of Foxley Wood was most perceptive (9 October). 
 While the objectors to Foxley Wood &mdash; and to Tillingham and Stone Bassett before it &mdash; may be rejoicing, the decision leaves us with no solutions to the future growth of population and households in the region. 
 Here in Milton Keynes &mdash; one of the areas suggested by Paul Barker that developers should now direct their attention to &mdash; the Government's false starts, decisions and counter-decisions, do seem ludicrous. 
 We have the land and the right planning framework to create new communities that do offer the sorts of housing and living conditions that many people are looking for. 
 Many major housebuilders are already here, and large development opportunities of the size of Foxley Wood are being offered. 
 The difference is that they take place within an agreed plan and programme. 
 What is amazing, therefore, is that the agency that has the responsibility for this programme &mdash; Milton Keynes Development Corporation &mdash; has been largely wound down over the past few years and the remainder of it will cease to exist in 1992. 
 Along with many of the other development corporations, the skills and experience in creating new communities have been dispersed &mdash; a fact that always amazes foreign visitors who look on British new towns as one of the major achievements of post-war planning anywhere in the world. 
 So perhaps another note for Mr Patten's no doubt very full in-tray is to look again at the decision to close down the body responsible for developing Milton Keynes, and start a new government initiative to encourage more new settlements throughout the region, rather than leaving it to private consortia to chance their arms through a development control system which seems unable to accommodate new initiatives in planning. 
 Letter: Future of the National Fruit Collection 
 From BARONESS TRUMPINGTON 
 Sir: An article by Anna Pavord on the National Fruit Collection (Weekend, 30 September) described very clearly the issues involved in the future of the collection, and I am glad the message is finally getting across that the Ministry will be continuing to support it. 
 I would, however, question the accuracy of the sub-title to the article: it is not the case that the Government &bquo;will no longer fund horticultural research&equo;. 
 Public funding is being withdrawn from research and development which is of direct benefit to growers &mdash; like the evaluation of different varieties in the National Fruit Trials at Brogdale &mdash; but the Government will still be paying for a substantial amount of horticultural research at a number of centres spread across the country. 
 I would also like to reassure your readers that moving the National Fruit Collection, should this prove necessary, is unlikely to be the traumatic event that some people imagine. 
 The fruit trees would be moved in stages, over a period of years. 
 The parent trees would be retained for several years after the new trees had been planted at the new site, just so that they could be used as a reference for checking. 
 Great care would be taken during the whole operation, and there need be no fears that varieties could be incorrectly named or labels lost. 
 There is nothing new about this procedure; the National Fruit Collection has already been moved from Wisley to Brogdale. 
 No one disputes the satisfactory results of this earlier move. 
 The Government is as keen as anyone else to ensure that this fine collection of old and new varieties is maintained to a high standard. 
 Letter: The Runcie effect 
 From The Rt Hon Sir FREDERIC BENNETT 
 In this context one paragraph in the Archbishop's recent controversial article in The Director is surely enlightening: The successful are always tempted to regard their success as a sort of blessing or reward for righteousness. 
 This can lead to judgements being made about the unsuccessful, the unemployed, the poor and the unintelligent which are both uncharitable and untrue. 
 One can legitimately ask Dr Runcie what are the temptations facing those who are unsuccessful, in regard to their own failings and failures &mdash; indulgence in self-pity; trying to pass the buck; bitterness, even resentment. 
 Under such circumstances would he agree that judgements could be made (inter alia, by himself) about the successful, the employed, the better-off and the intelligent, which are both uncharitable and untrue? 
 Letter: Cynical comment 
 From Mr CHRISTOPHER LUCAS 
 Sir: Your otherwise sound leading article ('Private gifts for public arts', 11 October) shot itself hypocritically in the foot in its last paragraph by expressing irritation with corporate executives who &bquo;parade as great patrons while giving away their shareholders&equo; money'. 
 That comment under-estimates the growing interest which shareholders are beginning to take in the wider responsibilities of the companies they invest in (eg, support for arts, education, health, environment or indeed anything which contributes to an increase in the quality of life), and its cynicism can only alienate the executives whose involvement in their companies' patronage we so badly need to encourage and applaud. 
 Letter: Funding students 
 From Professor JOHN GRIFFITH 
 Sir: The letter from the vice-chancellor of Essex University (10 October) reflects the appalling compliance with government views which has been the policy of the Committee of Vice-Chancellors and Principals over the last decade. 
 The Secretary of State says no more money so that's that. 
 Don't be beastly to the Conservatives. 
 The letter says that the key issue is which funding system will most likely encourage first-generation entrants to higher education from social groups not hitherto persuaded to participate. 
 Is the writer seriously suggesting that changing from a system where fees are paid in full by the state to a system where they are paid wholly or partly by the student is likely to be encouraging? 
 Letter: Was Euripides's Apollo an ancient Green? 
 From Mr RALPH HILL 
 Sir: The earliest recorded Green? 
 In Euripides's play Orestes (408 BC), Apollo says The gods by means of Helen's loveliness embroiled Troy and Hellas, causing death thereby, that they might lighten Mother Earth of the outrage done her by man's excessive population. 
 Graduate Careers: The closing of the jobs gap between universities and polys: Unemployment rates for polytechnic graduates fell dramatically last year, Peter Wilby reports. 
 But the real test will be how they fare in an economic recession 
 By PETER WILBY 
 ARE EMPLOYERS looking more favourably on polytechnic graduates? 
 For years, unemployment rates among poly graduates, six months after finishing, have been higher than those among comparable university graduates. 
 There are various explanations. 
 One is that personnel officers, themselves often educated at universities, are simply prejudiced against the polys; another, which can be supported by reference to A-level qualifications, is that universities recruit a superior class of student. 
 A third view is that the proportion of students going into permanent employment is what really counts and, here, the polys at least hold their own. 
 The figures for 1988 graduates suggest that the polys are still poor relations. 
 In 19 out of the 24 subjects in the table (right), their graduates are more likely to be unemployed or to be in short-term employment only. 
 But there is some evidence that the gap is closing. 
 Overall, the poly graduate unemployment rate (excluding short-term employment) was down from 9.2 per cent to 6.9 per cent, bringing it closer than ever before to the university unemployment rate, which was 5.3 per cent in 1988. 
 Further, the table reveals 10 subjects where the university jobless rate (this time including short-term employment) has risen or stayed the same while the poly rate has fallen. 
 The reverse is true in only four subjects. 
 In 13 subjects, proportionately more poly than university graduates are going directly into permanent employment; in another four, there is no significant difference. 
 Before the polys uncork the champagne, it should be added that it is always dangerous to infer a trend from one year's figures. 
 This time last year, I was reporting that the gap between the two sectors of higher education was widening. 
 In eight subjects, poly unemployment rates had risen while university rates had fallen; the reverse was true in only three subjects. 
 In some areas (such as psychology), the figures bobble about for no apparent reason. 
 The real test for the polys will be what happens if the economy goes into recession, as it may next year, and unemployment rises again. 
 Will employers make their main cuts in recruitment of poly graduates? 
 If the polys are indeed achieving the parity of esteem they have long sought, their graduates' relative position during the next recession should prove better than it was during the early 1980s. 
 So what are the conclusions for prospective students, now completing the entry forms? 
 First, it must always be emphasised that long-term graduate unemployment is extremely rare. 
 Unemployment or short-term employment immediately after graduation is largely a reflection of the time that graduates take to find the right openings. 
 The rates should not be compared with those for, say, 16-year-old school-leavers; what we are really measuring is difficulty in finding a graduate-level job, not difficulty in finding a job of any sort. 
 Second, the subject you study is far more important than where you study it. 
 A sociology graduate, whether from a university or polytechnic, is 10 times more likely to be unemployed or in short-term employment than a building, pharmacy or civil engineering graduate. 
 There is no subject where attending a polytechnic increases the statistical likelihood of being unemployed by more than three or four times. 
 Choice of a particular university or polytechnic makes even less difference. 
 If you take the crude figures, the differences between universities look dramatic. 
 Over the three years, 1986-8, 7.3 per cent of Aston's graduates were unemployed or in temporary employment six months after graduation; at Sussex, 13.5 per cent. 
 Yet, according to calculations by the Committee of Vice-Chancellors and Principals, the two universities performed much as expected, given their subject mix. 
 The committee calculated, for each university, the unemployment rate expected if the fate of graduates in each subject had conformed to national averages. 
 It compared this expectation with the actual unemployment rate. 
 Unemployment was higher than expected by 3 per cent or more at Ulster (5.5), Liverpool and Queen Mary College, London (both 4.8), East Anglia (3.4) and Sheffield, Aberystwyth and the London School of Economics (all 3.2). 
 Other universities where unemployment was higher than expected included Stirling (2.8) and University College London (2.5). 
 Education: How politicking has split the vice-chancellors: The students' fees campaign has exposed differences between university leaders, Ngaio Crequer says 
 By NGAIO CREQUER 
 VICE-CHANCELLORS are not normally known for their speed of action and this is how it should be: universities are reflective, discursive communities. 
 But on the question of private tuition fees they are moving with remarkable alacrity. 
 Although the question of fees was billed at their recent Leeds meeting as only one of the options to be pursued in funding the doubling of student numbers, a political campaign to promote the acceptance of fees has quickly got underway. 
 A leaflet headed The Case for Charging Full Cost Fees, with the sub-heading Why this is felt to be necessary, has been dished out at the party political conferences. 
 It says vice-chancellors believe this Government, any government, will not fund expansion. 
 It quotes John MacGregor, Secretary of State for Education, in support, and John Smith, the Shadow Chancellor, as saying: &bquo;We cannot spend what we have not earned and we intend to earn it before we spend it.&equo; 
 It does not quote Jack Straw, the Labour education spokesman, who is opposed to private tuition fees. 
 It is nifty footwork. 
 What has not yet been made clear is that the vice-chancellors are seriously split over the issue and some are expressing grave misgivings over the direction being taken. 
 Dr Clark Brundin of Warwick University said: &bquo;We did not say at our meeting in Leeds &mdash; and this is where we have shot ourselves in the foot &mdash; that no government is going to meet the cost of higher education. 
 We did not accept that. 
 I have never accepted that. 
 &bquo;The really worrying thing is that higher education is being regarded as a commodity for sale rather than something that we should invest in. 
 We did not talk about &bquo;Robin Hood&equo; schemes, not at all. 
 We discussed how to identify the full costs of courses, and the mechanisms by which funding could flow, which could include funds through students, but we did not rule out all of this being government money. 
 &bquo;One of the things I thought we did agree was that we should not do the Government's dirty work for them. 
 Our job is to say what higher education costs. 
 It is not for us to make political decisions. 
 My job is to ensure my institution is adequately funded. 
 It is for government to say it will not fund us adequately, not for us to go round saying it rather like a lot of sheep. 
 &bquo;There are undoubtedly people around who would like to bounce things in that direction (towards fees).&equo; 
 Berrick Saul, vice-chancellor of York University, is also unhappy. 
 &bquo;A lot of people think it is the Secretary of State's problem to provide the funding. 
 It is not for us to say we are going to do it. 
 The impression has been created that we want to charge fees. 
 It has put us in the position of villains, whereas the Secretary of State is the villain because he will not pay. 
 &bquo;I do not see how you can expand access by any means other than the Government paying. 
 If you charge students, they will not come. 
 If you are going to double student numbers, then the extra students are going to come from lower-income families and they will need a full grant. 
 &bquo;We should be saying to the Secretary of State: &bquo;If you want fees say so, go to the electorate and ask them.&equo; 
 This is a political question and now is a good time to start pushing the Government.&equo; 
 Ken Edwards, vice-chancellor of Leicester University, voted against the proposal to investigate the fees option. 
 &bquo;This is a very serious question about the methods of funding the expansion of higher education and to say that we are seriously interested in the proposal that fees should be charged at full cost is not going to increase or widen access. 
 &bquo;We are in danger of taking a political decision. 
 The way it should be funded is a matter for governments to decide. 
 I do not see how expansion could happen without a substantial increase in government funding. 
 &bquo;Any other scheme could lead to great difficulties of inequality and make it harder to recruit from those groups we need to reach.&equo; 
 He said that a number of vice-chancellors see the fees scheme as a way of getting the Government off the universities' backs, giving them freedom from detailed control. 
 He is not persuaded that this would be the effect. 
 Lord Flowers, vice-chancellor of London University, says the vice-chancellers are prepared to discuss funding mechanisms with the Government, but must make the point that they will not accept under-funding of the universities. 
 Identifying the full cost of courses makes it clear to the voter where the funding gap is. 
 &bquo;I no longer want full government funding from a government that is going to be dictatorial as hell, which is not to say I would not prefer it under a government of a different kind.&equo; 
 The vice-chancellors committee wants to consult polytechnic directors and the Government about &bquo;how a full cost system might work&equo;, recognising that it will need help to ensure that any changes, if made, increase opportunities and avoid hardship. 
 Education Update: Poor recruiting by employers 
 By NGAIO CREQUER 
 POOR standards of schooling are a frequent employers' complaint. 
 But heads and teachers complain just as much about low standards among employers. 
 A survey of 140 heads, deputies and careers teachers by a marketing consultancy found that 54 per cent thought that businesses went about recruiting school-leavers &bquo;not very well&equo; or &bquo;very badly&equo;. 
 One head said: &bquo;Careers officers and pupils have to do all the work&hellip; 
 Most companies have a lackadaisical approach to recruitment &mdash; as if they're doing us a great favour.&equo; 
 Only 37 per cent agreed that employers handled applications efficiently and fairly against nearly 70 per cent who thought that universities and polytechnics did so. 
 &bquo;They take so long to get back to pupils,&equo; was one comment. 
 &bquo;Sometimes they don't answer at all unless nagged into it.&equo; 
 Another head said: &bquo;It's more than rude, it's disruptive.&equo; 
 Education Update: College for the over-50s 
 By NGAIO CREQUER 
 PEOPLE OVER 50 who have not previously had any further or higher education should be entitled to spend a year at college, with their fees and maintenance paid by the state, a new pamphlet argues. 
 Tom Schuller, senior lecturer in continuing education at Warwick University, says that this &bquo;third-age entitlement&equo; would enable the over-50s to switch careers, to continue working longer and to preserve their independence. 
 Costs would be limited by keeping the offer open only until 1995 and by using a means test. 
 Full entitlement to fees and maintenance could be offered to those on a basic income level; 25 per cent to those earning, say, &pound;12-&pound;15,000 a year, and nothing to those with higher incomes. 
 Mr Schuller argues that costs would be offset by the increased economic activity of older people and by the reduction in social dependency. 
 It costs the taxpayer &pound;130-&pound;165 a week to keep someone in a residential or nursing home, he says. 
 Education Viewpoint: Hands-off stance on teacher quality 
 By PETER WILBY 
 I CAN still remember the overpowering smell of alcohol on his breath. 
 As I passed the hall in a large comprehensive school, where notices proclaimed &bquo;Quiet please: examination in progress&equo;, the invigilator, a geography teacher, staggered out to engage me in slurred discussion of educational issues. 
 Since the man was in this incapable state most afternoons, the head rightly wanted to be rid of him. 
 It took three years, and the man was backed every inch of the way by his union. 
 Another head recently told me of a teacher who had been in the habit of twanging the sixth-form girls' bra straps. 
 After repeated complaints, the head attempted to lodge a final warning on his record. 
 This was unfair, the union protested. 
 The man had been trained in the 1950s when the &bquo;tactile&equo; approach to teaching was favoured. 
 He could not help touching the pupils; extensive re-training was required. 
 A system of teacher appraisal, of the sort proposed in a report from a national steering group last week, would not have helped in either of these cases. 
 First things first: schools still need a speedy mechanism for getting rid of those guilty of gross misconduct, negligence and incompetence. 
 Such teachers are a tiny minority; colleagues, parents and pupils know perfectly well who they are. 
 The steering group proposed &bquo;a biennial cycle&equo;, involving an initial appraiser/appraisee meeting, self-appraisal, collection of data, target setting, follow-up discussions and a formal review meeting. 
 You do not need all this to establish that a man is drunk or that there is mayhem when he is in charge of a class. 
 So appraisal has, or should have nothing to do with what the tabloid press likes to call &bquo;weeding out&equo;. 
 It is, nevertheless, fundamental to a sound education system. 
 The steering group's proposals may seem a touch elaborate but, for two reasons, appraisal in education is bound to be more complex than in other areas of life. 
 First, most companies devote resources to quality control and product testing. 
 Apart from crude measures of test and exam results, schools have no equivalent; appraisal of what happens in classrooms must include some of the quality-control functions. 
 Second, most other businesses have simple objectives; schools have a multiplicity of aims. 
 The decision by John MacGregor, the Secretary of State for Education, to delay introduction of a national appraisal scheme is therefore singularly perverse. 
 A ridiculously complicated national curriculum and assessment system; new budgetary arrangements; records of the time that pupils spend on different subjects &mdash; with all these and more, schools must press ahead without delay. 
 But, when there is a development that might improve the quality of teaching and learning in classrooms &mdash; and one, moreover, on which unions and employers are agreed &mdash; ministers suddenly recognise that schools are overloaded. 
 Or so they say. 
 I suspect that other considerations are in Mr MacGregor's mind: appraisal would require the equivalent of an extra 1,828 full-time teachers, according to the steering group, and a total cost of &pound;36-&pound;40m &mdash; or 0.5 per cent of the annual teachers' salary bill. 
 The national curriculum and its tests are also expensive: but appraisal does not somehow have the same political glamour as announcing that children must learn the facts about British history or correct grammar. 
 The biggest danger of Mr MacGregor's decision is that he perpetuates a system that fails to reward good classroom teaching. 
 At present, promotion decisions in teaching are based on evidence from bland references, stilted interviews and lists of in-service training courses attended. 
 Information on a teacher's classroom ability is almost entirely lacking. 
 In future, no doubt, interviewers will look at test scores attained by teachers' pupils and every school governing body will have a statistician capable of producing appropriate graphs. 
 Mr MacGregor will then have created the worst of all worlds. 
 Education: A broader base for the A-team: Hilary Wilce looks at the pressures for change in traditional sixth form studies and examinations 
 By HILARY WILCE 
 CAROL HAMMERTON is a sixth form pioneer. 
 She has just started at Luton Sixth Form College, in Bedfordshire, but she has picked a more varied menu than the traditional sixth form diet of three A-levels. 
 As well as A-level history and English, she is studying French and performing arts for AS (half an A) exams and psychology for GCSE. 
 &bquo;I wanted to be a primary teacher, and you have to teach so many different things at that level that it seemed better to study a broader range of subjects,&equo; she says. 
 Joanna Kemp, also at Luton, is taking A-level music and English, and AS-level courses in psychology, music and drama, not because she knows what she wants to do, but because she doesn't. 
 &bquo;There are so many different subjects, it seemed pointless narrowing myself down at this stage. 
 And they tell you that two AS-levels are equal to an A-level when it comes to applying for university places.&equo; 
 For years, people have been calling for sixth form studies to be broadened and updated, but now the pressures for change have become urgent. 
 For one thing, teaching and examination styles have changed dramatically lower down the school system. 
 &bquo;Our biggest problem with A-levels is that they have not been modified in the light of the GCSE,&equo; says Brian Howseman, principal of Luton Sixth Form College. 
 &bquo;In some areas we have had to put on special courses to prepare students for A-level.&equo; 
 Since the GCSE was introduced, Luton's intake of A-level students has risen. 
 It took in 400 last year, 500 this; other colleges and schools also report big increases. 
 The GCSE, which stresses individual initiative and competence, has boosted students' confidence and encouraged their interest in learning. 
 But the next exam on the educational ladder lays emphasis on what people know, rather than what they can do, and is seen primarily as a passport to university entry. 
 Many subjects are still examined by a single pass-or-fail hurdle at the end of a two-year course, and the failure rate is around 30 per cent. 
 &bquo;A-levels have a very high standard, but these standards are protected by failure,&equo; says Professor Alan Smithers, professor of education at Manchester University. 
 &bquo;Many spend two years in the sixth form and get nothing at all, and it is hard for people who get a low grade at A-level to realise they have actually done very well.&equo; 
 The A-level system is also creaking under pressures from above. 
 Universities and colleges are looking to expand their intakes, but are drawing on a shrinking population of 18-year-olds. 
 Increasingly, they are taking students with non A-level qualifications and finding that many of them perform superbly. 
 The glitter of A-levels in today's broader, more diverse, degree market is starting to tarnish, and is unlikely ever to be restored to its former glory. 
 A further problem with A-levels is the narrowness they impose on students. 
 Our high-flying 18-year-olds are superbly grounded in their specialist areas, compared to their counterparts in other Western countries, but we seem incapable of producing engineers with a fluent second language, or historians who understand information technology. 
 The Government's answer has been to introduce AS-levels, equivalent to half an A-level syllabus, designed to encourage sixth formers to take a broader range of subjects. 
 But parents and pupils are suspicious of the new exam, and the early indications are that, in many places, AS-levels are being mis-used as trial-run A-levels. 
 So the time is ripe for a major overhaul of the sixth form. 
 But A-levels are much admired for their depth and rigour. 
 Attempts to change the system &mdash; and there have been many &mdash; have always foundered on an unwillingness to abandon the gold standard of British education. 
 The latest, a Government-sponsored inquiry by Professor Gordon Higginson, vice-chancellor of Southampton University, concluded there were far too many A-level syllabuses, and that they were stuffed too full with information. 
 Students should take five tougher, leaner A-levels, he said. 
 The plan drew wide support from schools, universities and industry, but was turned down flat by the Department of Education, apparently on instructions from Downing Street. 
 However, the proposals, kicked out of the front door last year, are now coming in through the back. 
 This summer the Government accepted recommendations from its Secondary Examinations and Assessment Council to put A and AS-levels into a clear, common framework and to look to further ways of updating and broadening sixth form studies. 
 &bquo;They have in fact taken a big step towards our recommendations,&equo; says Professor Higginson. 
 &bquo;Many very significant aspects of our proposals are being implemented, like the need to set down a number of general principles, and to tighten up syllabuses.&equo; 
 In practice, many A-level syllabuses have already changed beyond recognition. 
 &bquo;The education system is very good at subverting things that are pushed onto it,&equo; says Brian Howseman. 
 &bquo;It has already found numerous ways of making changes at A-level acceptable. 
 There is a lot of teacher input into the examination boards, and all sorts of moves towards introducing more course work, and more practical elements into the syllabuses.&equo; 
 Barry Gore, head of economics and business studies at Luton, points out that all business studies candidates have to undertake an extended case study. 
 &bquo;A-levels now test a huge range of skills, not just knowledge. 
 There are practical assessments, orals and so on. 
 We've come a long, long way in just five years.&equo; 
 But they, and others, believe there is room to go much further. 
 John Millington, principal training adviser for the Engineering Industry Training Board, says employers would like to see the present system streamlined, with fewer syllabuses and more emphasis on assessing a wider range of skills. 
 But, he adds: &bquo;There is an enormous advantage in building change on to something that is already known and respected. 
 Far better to take what is, and bring in progressive changes, than to radically alter the whole thing.&equo; 
 Schools, too, see that change has to come. 
 &bquo;Only 11 per cent of the country's 18-year-olds pass three A-levels,&equo; says Michael Duffy, head of the King Edward VI School, in Morpeth, Northumberland. 
 &bquo;Schools have been dealing in failure too long, and with the demographic and consumer pressures the present system is simply no longer viable. 
 But in the short-term AS-levels are the only instrument we've got for change.&equo; 
 Like many others in education, he would like to see a structure that meets the needs of all 16-to 19-year-olds by bringing together the academic A-level syllabuses, with all the various vocational courses, into a common system. 
 This would allow students to build up their qualifications by taking a variety of units, or modules. 
 However, the practical problems of matching up hugely varying exams, at different levels, in a vast variety of subjects, while also paying due respect to the inevitable sectional interests and sensitivities, seem almost insurmountable. 
 But Professor Smithers argues: &bquo;It's perfectly possible, especially now we've got all the experiences of devising a national curriculum and of working out key stages and ways of testing them. 
 If people want it enough, they can do it.&equo; 
 Stuck fast in the mire: Ford's at Dagenham may now be in a state of terminal decline. 
 Michael Harrison, our Industrial Editor, contrasts its performance with that of its foreign counterparts 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 FORD'S ageing and ramshackle Dagenham site in Essex, once the jewel in the company's overseas operations, enters the 1990s with its very survival uncertain. 
 The plant now dubiously boasts the poorest levels of productivity, quality and working conditions of any Ford factory in Europe. 
 Unless it can effect a remarkable recovery, the factory may well disappear back into the bleak and sodden marshes of Essex from which it emerged nearly 60 years ago. 
 The evidence of Dagenham's predicament can be gauged from internal company documents which illustrate graphically the task confronting Ford and its workforce. 
 These show that it takes Dagenham nearly twice as long to produce a Sierra car as it does Ford's Genk plant in Belgium. 
 The picture is similar when Fiesta production is compared at Dagenham and Valencia. 
 The British plant takes 53 hours to turn out each car, the Spanish factory 30 hours. 
 Product quality at the Essex factory is also inferior, measured against any index, whether it be ratings out of 10, defects per vehicle or warranty costs on each car leaving the factory gate. 
 The Dagenham workforce would argue that there are good reasons why the ageing plant cannot match the performance of its modern Continental rivals. 
 However, the documents also show that Dagenham's car body and assembly operations are failing to meet even its own internal targets. 
 In 1988 the plant was scheduled to produce 992 cars a day. 
 It actually achieved 861 &mdash; a shortfall of 13 per cent. 
 The only consolation was that this was a slight improvement on 1987 when Dagenham fell 14 per cent short of target. 
 Dagenham, which is currently scheduled to produce 1,100 cars a day, is one of the few Ford plants in Europe where output is not planned to increase. 
 At Genk it will rise by 400 cars a day, at Halewood on Merseyside and at Valencia by 150, and at Cologne in West Germany by 50. 
 At Dagenham it will remain static. 
 With its 14,000 workers, Dagenham may still be the company's biggest centre of employment in the UK, it may have produced more than 10 million vehicles in the last 60 years and its name may be inseparable from Ford of Britain. 
 But unless quality and productivity can be improved in leaps and bounds by the early 1990s, then Dagenham is unlikely to have a future as a car production plant. 
 Executives at the Ford of Britain headquarters at Brentwood in Essex have undoubtedly already looked into the future and examined what would happen if car production were to end at Dagenham. 
 In Ford-speak, these are called &bquo;I wonder&equo; exercises. 
 The political ramifications of shutting Dagenham would be immense. 
 The omens, however, are not promising. 
 Ford has already announced that production of the Sierra &mdash; one of its most profitable and best-selling cars -will end at Dagenham next summer and be switched to Genk, leaving the Essex plant with only production of the new Fiesta. 
 Union observers believe that unless Dagenham can be transformed by 1994 into an efficient, viable plant then it will not be selected for another new model. 
 &bquo;When the decision was announced to end Sierra production it was tantamount to a five-year death sentence,&equo; one said. 
 The reasons why Dagenham performs so poorly are complex and partly historical. 
 The site was designed to be a mirror-image of Ford's main US plant. 
 When it opened in 1931, erected on 22,000 concrete piles to lift it clear of the water-sodden ground, it already sported its own blast furnace, foundry, jetty and power station. 
 Special trains were chartered to transport 2,000 employees and their families down to the gleaming new plant from Ford's Trafford Park factory in Manchester which was in the process of closing. 
 In its first year Dagenham produced 25,571 cars and trucks but as Ford's presence in the UK grew, extension after extension was tacked on to the plant to accomodate tractor and commercial vehicle production, new foundries, paint shops, furnaces and export packing plants. 
 By 1959, the 1.7-square mile site had become a small industrial town in its own right and production peaked at 470,000 cars, trucks and tractors. 
 In the early 1960s, all that began to change, however. 
 A new &pound;30m car plant opened at Halewood on Merseyside in 1963. 
 Production of tractors and trucks was transferred elsewhere and, much later, engine production was largely relocated to South Wales. 
 Ford was left with a huge, sprawling, under-used mess at Dagenham. 
 Yet, ironically, car production today is still being crammed into a pint pot. 
 Halewood produces only one car, the Escort/Orion range, against Dagenham's two models and yet it has 20,000 more square feet of storage space. 
 Similarly the production area at the Saarlouis plant in Germany, another single-model plant, is 10 per cent bigger than at Dagenham. 
 The result is that Dagenham is a cramped, unpleasant and inefficient place to work. 
 Lack of space, for instance, has prevented Ford from building locker facilities &mdash; meaning that some shop-floor workers still have to change their clothes at the side of the production line. 
 Nor is there enough space at the side of the production lines to stock components. 
 Thousands of boxes of parts arrive at the assembly line every week to be emptied and then simply discarded in a corner because Dagenham is not geared to what the modern motor industry calls &bquo;just-in-time&equo; delivery. 
 &bquo;The place is like a pigsty,&equo; said one union source. 
 The fact that Dagenham currently produces two cars makes the operation of the plant even more chaotic. 
 Nearly 7,000 different parts flood into Dagenham for assembly of the Sierra and Fiesta &mdash; 50 per cent more than at Halewood or Saarlouis. 
 Since 1984 Dagenham has had to cope with double the number of product changes at Halewood. 
 The senior management of Ford recognises and accepts all these shortcomings. 
 Its answer has been to reduce Dagenham to a single-product plant. 
 The solution the unions and workforce prefer is increased investment to overcome the numerous production bottlenecks at Dagenham. 
 In the next two to three years Ford intends to spend &pound;105m on the body and assembly lines at Dagenham, modernising the press shop and paint line, upgrading computer-aided facilities in the toolroom and streamlining the trim and final assembly lines. 
 As part of a &pound;60m investment programme, Ford also intends to begin production of a high-roof Fiesta van at Dagenham in 1991. 
 Output could eventually rise to 300 a day, making Dagenham the sole European source of the new van. 
 However, this is small beer set against the &pound;1.8bn Ford has earmarked for investment in the UK between 1988 and 1993. 
 Dagenham's problems need to be viewed not just in the context of Ford but of the European motor industry as a whole. 
 Between 1984 and 1988 Ford's share of the European new car market fell from 13 per cent to 11.5 per cent, to leave it trailing Fiat, Volkswagen and Peugeot. 
 Of equal concern, the steady encroachment of the Japanese car industry into Europe is gathering pace. 
 By the latter part of the next decade, Nissan, Toyota and Honda could be producing nearly one million vehicles in the UK alone, according to some industry analysts. 
 Dagenham cannot match other Ford plants right now but its performance will appear even less satisfactory against the Japanese. 
 Last year the 8,500 workers in body and assembly produced just under 200,000 cars. 
 In 1993 Nissan's factory at Washington, Tyne and Wear, will produce the same number of cars with a total workforce, including white-collar, managerial and support staff of 3,800. 
 Such vast advantages in costs and production are a source of great concern to Ford management. 
 Although the long-term outlook for car manufacture at Dagenham may be uncertain, engine production there is more secure. 
 Ford has invested &pound;157m to make Dagenham the sole European source for the new lean-burn 2-litre engine for the Sierra and Granada. 
 It also supplies all 1.6 and 1.8 diesel engines for Escorts, Orions and Fiestas as well as the 2.5 diesel engine for the Transit van, which is built in Southampton. 
 Dagenham produced a record number of engines last year. 
 However, if car assembly were to end then Dagenham's wheel plant might also disappear. 
 When Edward Grace, the Ford manager sent over to England in 1923 to find a production site, finally settled on Dagenham, paying &pound;167,695 for the acreage, the choice came as a surprise to some people given the geological conditions. 
 Six years later when Henry Ford's son, Edsel, cut the first sod of earth on site with a silver spade, the site looked barely more promising. 
 Indeed, Ford's own potted history of Dagenham records that &bquo;some experts said it was unworkable&equo;. 
 Dagenham's employees can only hope that Ford does not resurrect the phrase in the 1990s. 
 Sweet-talking greater output from car workers: Barrie Clement, Labour Editor, on a bid for more shopfloor commitment 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT, Labour Editor 
 IN THE words of Jimmy Airlie, a fiery Scotsman and a senior union negotiator at Ford, &bquo;you don't get owt for nowt&equo;. 
 In a fortnight's time, when the company replies to a call for a substantial increase in pay and a reduction in the working week, John Hougham, personnel director, will probably throw that philosophy back at him. 
 The company realises that it will probably have to pitch the offer at or near 10 per cent. 
 But Mr Hougham will also try to attach some productivity strings to the deal in an effort to close the gap with the Japanese. 
 Since the 1970s, working practices have changed out of all recognition. 
 And where once union leaders talked of struggle and solidarity, now they speak of profitability and competitiveness. 
 The pressure to change emerged out of the recession in the early 1980s and the increasing incursion of the Japanese into world markets with productivity levels light years ahead of European competitors. 
 Ford management chalked up its most significant coup over working practices in 1985 when 500 job titles were reduced to 58. 
 An attempt to emulate such progress in 1987 ended in almost three months of wildcat action followed by a damaging two-week official strike. 
 As part of the 1987 pay deal, Mr Hougham had sought to win agreement for the introduction of temporary workers to cope with seasonal variation in demand, the establishment of quality discussion groups and moves to have skilled men working on the production line. 
 Ford &mdash; and indeed the unions &mdash; badly misjudged the mood of the workforce. 
 It was, to use another of Mr Airlie's aphorisms, &bquo;a bridge too far&equo;. 
 Instead of a three-year deal the unions eventually signed a two-year agreement with a second year in which pay was increased by the inflation rate plus 2.5 per cent. 
 It gave the 33,000 manual workforce 8.9 per cent, which at the time was considerably higher than the &bquo;going rate&equo;. 
 This year management will also be looking for concessions on working practices. 
 The company's strategy, according to Professor Garel Rhys, the industry's guru, will be one of gradualism. 
 A &bquo;drip feed rather than a torrent&equo;, he says. 
 Management has decided that workers are still not ready to be pushed too far towards Japanese-style working methods, or as one assembly worker at Dagenham put it: &bquo;If they think I'm going to do physical jerks and sing the company song before I start my shift, they've got another think coming.&equo; 
 The company has signalled its keenness to sign another two-year deal, and unions have indicated they might be prepared to accede, as long as there is an &bquo;inflation-plus&equo; element in the second year. 
 Workers are only too aware that Ford of Britain's pre-tax profits doubled to more than &pound;673m in the last financial year and they feel they ought to share in its success. 
 No doubt the company will contend in negotiations that such a profit compared with the capital sums needed for investment is &bquo;peanuts&equo;. 
 Ford's employees are also wont to point out that their mortgage payments have rocketed over the past year and negotiations will take place against a background in which interest rates seem to be moving in one direction only. 
 An attempt by Dagenham shop stewards to win the approval of colleagues from other plants to a South-east weighting to cope with higher living costs in the area and ease problems over recruitment and retention was rejected. 
 So far the company has not registered any enthusiasm for such a payment either. 
 This year's talks come in the wake of a regeneration among unions and a feeling that industrial action &mdash; following the rail strikes early in the summer &mdash; can pay. 
 It would be simplistic and indeed inaccurate, however, to ascribe a single &bquo;mood&equo; to the workforce, although industrial relations are considered generally to be good as memories of last year's conflict dim. 
 Workers at Halewood, particularly in the engine plant, have co-operated with management to give a productivity record comparable with any in Europe. 
 No longer does the complex have the reputation as a hotbed of Merseyside militancy. 
 The company's satisfaction with labour relations at Bridgend in South Wales must also have been a factor in the decision to build a &pound;750m engine plant there. 
 Equally the problems at Dagenham may have influenced the decision to switch the Sierra away to Ford's Belgian plant at Genk even though the company's strategy is to concentrate a single model at each plant. 
 Union leaders were told recently that the Essex plant, which currently produces the Sierra and the Fiesta, was experiencing more stoppages than any of the company's plants in Europe and that quality levels were also the worst. 
 Most unrest at the plant takes the form of lightning stoppages of between 10 minutes and half an hour, often health and safety issues are cited as the cause or disciplinary matters. 
 Most of the stoppages have a negligible impact on output, but the cumulative effect, particularly in the body and assembly plants, is considerable. 
 Professor Rhys, of Cardiff Business School, points out that the Essex plant is in an area of low unemployment and that the same could not be said of the other big plants. 
 &bquo;The reality is that workers at Dagenham can get jobs elsewhere and their colleagues at Halewood can't,&equo; said Professor Rhys. 
 He believes that training is insufficient at the plant and that morale is at a low ebb, largely because of the working environment and the ageing equipment. 
 This has spawned and sustained a shop stewards' movement reminiscent of the 1970s. 
 The far left is also being blamed for taking advantage of grievances. 
 Steve Hart, of the Transport and General Workers Union at Dagenham, believes the degree of unrest can be exaggerated. 
 &bquo;There is a better atmosphere now than for many years &mdash; fewer stoppages, better relationships. 
 But we acknowledge that things aren't perfect and we are seeking to improve the situation.&equo; 
 The threat to the plant's existence is being taken seriously by the unions even though the management denies any intention to close it. 
 Senior union leaders acknowledge privately that they have to win a hearts-and-minds campaign among their members. 
 Mr Hart believes there should be a more structured approach to problem-solving as there is at the Halewood plant. 
 Efforts are being made to improve the relationship between frontline managers and shop stewards and to evolve a system for dealing with disputes as and when they occur. 
 Nationally, the company has been attempting to win a higher degree of commitment from the workforce. 
 One such attempt is the &pound;1.5m personal training and development scheme. 
 The programme offers evening classes in courses not related to the job and a range of health services. 
 The Employee Development and Assistance Programme, as it is called, is part of the campaign to win greater &bquo;employee involvement&equo;. 
 Having burned their fingers two years ago, senior Ford executives will continue to press for change, but preferably not at the expense of another strike. 
 Or to use another of Mr Airlie's sayings: &bquo;You catch more flies with honey than with vinegar&equo;. 
 End of the musical football manager: The megalomaniac conductor may finally have had his day, argues Fiona Maddocks 
 By FIONA MADDOCKS 
 AS THE dust settles on the surprising, but widely approved decision to appoint Claudio Abbado chief conductor of the Berlin Philharmonic Orchestra to replace Karajan, a new round of speculation is about to begin. 
 Will the Italian Abbado remain musical director of the Vienna State Opera where he has been for the past three years? 
 If not, who will replace him? 
 Will any of those disappointed Berlin front-runners stand a chance, and who would replace them in their respective jobs if they go? 
 With the traditional rivalry which exists between Berlin and Vienna, such a tournament would be especially enthralling for spectators of the international music chess board. 
 The reality, however, is probably more prosaic. 
 Abbado has yet to confirm the terms of his Berlin contract. 
 The likelihood is that after such a short time in Vienna, he will stay on there, if with reduced involvement. 
 Some have suggested that his appointment at Berlin was the result of a compromise by the orchestra, an attempt to secure someone as far removed from Karajan in character, musical and personal, as the world could offer. 
 Whether or not this is so, few would deny that Abbado is a sound choice, a man of few words who nevertheless commands great respect among orchestral players and is as highly praised for his Rossini as for his Mahler, his Mozart or his Brian Ferneyhough. 
 Is it not time, though, to ask whether all this heady ferment over a mere conductor &mdash; Abbado or any other &mdash; has not got out of hand? 
 To suggest, sotto voce, that we may be in danger of inflating the man (woman, rarely) way out of proportion to the job itself? 
 For most listeners today, it is true, concerts are attended, records purchased, orchestras identified by the name of the conductor. 
 In discussing any of these we revert to foolish solecisms: &bquo;Rattle's Stravinsky&equo; or &bquo;Karajan's Missa Solennis&equo;, or of &bquo;seeing Giulini conduct Verdi&equo;. 
 Strictly speaking, this last description is accurate. 
 The conductor's role, after all, is silent. 
 The audience sits mesmerised by his expressive choreography, watching each inflection of the hand or eyebrow. 
 We almost convince ourselves that the music is created not by the orchestra but by the tip of the baton itself, rich sounds oozing out like some exotic genie. 
 Yet not so long ago orchestras managed perfectly happily without this apparently indispensable Merlin. 
 Like football managers, conductors are a phenomenon of the modern age. 
 The job hardly existed until a century ago, when orchestral works began to require such large forces that composers - Berlioz, Wagner or Mahler &mdash; resorted to doing the job themselves to ensure a modicum of accuracy (Haydn and Mozart, with their smaller orchestras, had managed effectively by waving a hand from the keyboard). 
 The conductor's earliest origins, though, were humble, his duties confined to banging time loudly with a stick &mdash; a sort of dull musical beadle. 
 So lowly, indeed, was the job that it was long considered too insignificant to warrant a credit on the programme. 
 The late Hans Keller, the most peppery and venerable writer on music since George Bernard Shaw, dearly wished that this were still the case. 
 He dismissed conducting as a phoney profession, responsible for turning players into mindless dependents, powerless without the hypnotic beat of a little white stick in front of them. 
 ('You have to attain a high degree of musical stupidity in order to find watching the beat, or the conductor's inane face for that matter, easier for the purpose of knowing how or when to play than simply listening to the music,&equo; he argued.) 
 But in the twentieth century, conductors have replaced composers as the most influential people in musical life. 
 They determine repertoire, secure multi-million-pound recording contracts, hire and fire players. 
 Their whim can make or ruin a reputation. 
 Moreover, they interpret a piece of music and make it their own, even if they have never encountered the given orchestra until a few hours before. 
 Can any conductor, though, be said to have made the same impact on recent musical history as that made by Bach or Beethoven or Wagner in the past? 
 The short answer is no. 
 A more qualified response might be, yes, in various ways which collectively have shaped musical life as we know it. 
 The Berlin Philharmonic, founded in 1882, has grown up in tandem with the evolution of the star conductor. 
 Its most notable musical directors &mdash; Von Bulow, Richard Strauss (though primarily a composer), Nikisch, Furtwangler and Karajan &mdash; remain models on which subsequent conductors have based themselves. 
 Nikisch, for example, was among the first to perfect the technique (etiquette, mannerisms and devilish good looks included) of the &bquo;virtuoso conductor&equo;; Furtwangler established a new and enduring tradition which transformed orchestral playing out of all recognition. 
 Other great names have played their part: Toscanini, the god-like showman, worked hard to popularise repertoire; Mengelburg, with the Amsterdam Concertgebouw, proved a gifted orchestral trainer. 
 Some, like Klemperer, have brought a knowledge of composing to the podium. 
 Recently, composer-conductors like Pierre Boulez or Oliver Knussen have cajoled orchestras into playing better than they ever knew how, by extending their technique, especially in contemporary repertoire. 
 Less high in the popularity-winning stakes, but ultimately more important for posterity, are those who have acted as patrons &mdash; either playing new works (Klemperer, Boult) or commissioning them. 
 How many, for example, have heard of the Swiss-born conductor Paul Sacher? 
 Yet he alone has been responsible for bringing about some of the seminal works of this century, Bartok's Music for Strings, Percussion and Celesta among them. 
 Claudio Abbado already has a good record in many of these areas. 
 His instinctive methods, and his belief that the spontaneity of a performance, whatever went on in rehearsals, is of prime importance, keeps players on their toes. 
 His work with the youthful Chamber Orchestra of Europe confirms both a commitment to training and to performing new works. 
 Furthermore, his quiet, democratic manner gives no indication of harbouring an aspiring despot. 
 Nor would the Berlin Philharmonic welcome him if that were so. 
 Today, orchestral musicians wish to assert their identities again, to escape the thrall of the baton at last. 
 The conductor is now, without doubt, a permanent fixture in musical life. 
 But if players have their way, as they have in Berlin, the age of the megalomaniac conductor, the age of Karajan, may be over for ever. 
 Prague dissident goes into hiding 
 From EDWARD LUCAS in Brno, Czechoslovakia 
 ONE OF Czechoslovakia's most prominent dissidents, Stanislav Devaty, has gone underground rather than face an appeal hearing which could have confirmed a 20-month jail sentence. 
 Mr Devaty, a former spokesman for the Charter 77 rights group and an associate of the dissident playwright, Vaclav Havel, is, like Mr Havel, one of four organisers of the &bquo;Several Sentences&equo; petition for political reform and liberalisation, which more than 30,000 people have signed since its launch in June. 
 Mr Devaty is one of the few dissidents who do not come from a Prague-based intellectual background. 
 His practice of hunger-striking when detained has attracted international attention and the displeasure of the authorities, and led to his release from custody earlier this year. 
 Mr Devaty was sentenced in August to 20 months in jail on charges of incitement connected with the petition. 
 Following the trial, the official news agency said he had &bquo;mendaciously accused the socialist state&hellip; of violating constitutional laws and international agreements&equo;. 
 A bizarre aspect of the case is that Mr Devaty's &bquo;crimes&equo; include the apparently punishable offence of sending the authorities papers about their human rights abuses. 
 At yesterday's appeal hearing in Brno, a colleague of Mr Devaty, Jana Petrova, handed the judge a statement on his behalf which said that Mr Devaty did not regard his trial as just and would pursue his activities underground while the risk of punishment remained. 
 The judge postponed the hearing; Ms Petrova read the statement aloud outside the courtroom to cheers and applause from several dozen friends, including Vaclav Havel, who had attended the hearing with British and American diplomats and representatives of Amnesty International and the official Czechoslovak Committee on Human Rights. 
 Mr Havel was one of a handful of people who knew of Mr Devaty's decision in advance. 
 He told The Independent: &bquo;It's an experiment&hellip; and very respectable. 
 We shall see what will happen later&hellip; until now nobody has tried such a method.&equo; 
 Although the opposition has no experience of sheltering such a prominent figure underground, Mr Devaty's move appears to have caught by surprise not only his friends, but the country's creaky legal machinery, and it may be some time before his non-appearance prompts a full-scale police hunt for him. 
 The wife of the detained dissident, Sasha Vondra, said yesterday that she had had no news of her husband for three weeks. 
 Tax inspectors' strike may hold up Beaujolais 
 From PATRICK MARNHAM in Paris 
 A STRIKE by French tax officials for more pay is threatening early sales of this year's wine harvest, including the Beaujolais Nouveau. 
 The taxmen, who are among the most efficient and unpopular figures in France, have been engaged in various forms of industrial action for 19 weeks. 
 But only now are the effects becoming apparent. 
 Among innumerable other tasks they are responsible for stamping the lead or paper seals which enclose wine bottle corks. 
 Until these are stamped as &bquo;duty paid&equo; the wine cannot be sold. 
 Pre-Christmas sales of this year's vintage &mdash; wine known as nouveau or primeur &mdash; from many parts of France are due to start in November. 
 But an enormous backlog of untaxed cases of wine is building up in the producers' warehouses. 
 The strike has begun to affect almost every branch of commercial life. 
 Customs officers at many ports are refusing to pass commercial traffic. 
 On Tuesday union leaders claimed that every French customs post along the Spanish border was closing to all traffic except private cars. 
 But yesterday at the Hendaye border post, near Bayonne, lorries were passing freely without any form of control. 
 At Marseilles airport, one customs officer said: &bquo;You can bring in anything you like &mdash; including drugs or weapons. 
 We're taking a breather until further notice.&equo; 
 At Roissy airport, near Paris, the customs officers have refused to check cargo flights since last week. 
 The strike affects not just tax and customs officers but every branch of the state's financial service. 
 So jewellers cannot get their new stock hallmarked and 800,000 articles are now waiting to be examined before they can be put on sale. 
 Thousands of property deals are waiting to be completed because local tax offices are refusing to deal with the French equivalent of stamp duty. 
 The strikers have also extended their tactics. 
 They started by taking action that diminished goverment receipts. 
 They are now refusing to handle government payments as well. 
 This month five million government employees and pensioners, including soldiers, judges and diplomats, may not be paid. 
 Town halls will be unable to make payments on many of their contracts, and the hospital service is also threatened. 
 The tax inspectors, whose annual earnings are between &pound;7,150 and &pound;23,140, almost exactly the French civil service average, are demanding a steep increase in pay. 
 Their negotiators have refused to take part in further talks with departmental heads and yesterday Pierre Beregovoy, the Minister of Finance, gave in to their demands and agreed to a meeting with the leaders of the five unions involved. 
 Next week the strike is expected to spread to the Post Office. 
 East Germany admits concern over refugees 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 EAST GERMANY'S Communist leaders said last night they were prepared to discuss ways of improving life in their country. 
 But they flatly refused to relinquish their grip on power. 
 In a long statement read out on television after the evening news programme, the Politburo admitted for the first time that it was &bquo;not indifferent&equo; to the mass exodus of its people to West Germany. 
 &bquo;Together we want to shape our fatherland in such a way that the growing material and cultural needs of each person can better be met, according to his contribution,&equo; it said, and called for suggestions from the public. 
 &bquo;We are ready for discussion.&equo; 
 The issues, the Politburo said, would include better economic performance, &bquo;democratic togetherness&equo;, better goods, &bquo;life-oriented media&equo;, opportunities to travel and a healthy environment &mdash; all burning topics in East Germany. 
 It promised to present its &bquo;strategic concept for continuity and renewal&equo; at its next meeting at the end of the year and that it would all be thoroughly discussed at the party congress next May. 
 But it firmly rejected any idea of reforming the system, saying: &bquo;We are against suggestions and demonstrations which aim to lead people astray and change the constitutional basis of our state.&equo; 
 The party already had all the necessary channels for debate, it said, adding: &bquo;Socialism on German soil is not in question. 
 The people of the German Democratic Republic have opted for socialism forever.&equo; 
 The statement, entitled &bquo;Socialism needs everyone&equo;, followed a meeting of the 21 members of the Politburo, who also brought in numerous members of the lower-ranking Central Committee &mdash; a rare event which only occurs when urgent and important issues are at stake. 
 There was no confirmation of a news agency report that Erich Honecker, the East German leader, might resign. 
 Mr Honecker, 77 and still recovering from a gall-bladder operation, has so far flatly rejected all notions of change. 
 When asked by journalists recently about the refugee problem, he said, &bquo;What refugee problem?&equo; 
 Earlier, Kurt Hager, 77, the party's oldest and most authoritative hardline ideologue, said the first priorities were to involve the population in the solution to important social problems and to improve the government's information policy. 
 Obstacles which prevent young people from using their talents at home must be swept out of the way, he said. 
 Meanwhile, contradictory reactions by the authorities in various parts of East Germany continued, reinforcing the suspicion among experts in Bonn that the party leadership's authority is crumbling and it no longer has a firm grip on the situation. 
 While city leaders in Leipzig held talks with reformists, reports indicated that police in Halle had made a baton attack on about 3,000 people as they were leaving a church to march in silence round the town. 
 Many were clubbed to the ground and kicked. 
 Shortly after Gunter Krusche, a leading figure in the East Berlin Protestant church, said there were signs that the reformist New Forum would be granted legal status in several regions, police in East Berlin detained 15 members of the group and confiscated papers they were carrying. 
 The 15 were later released. 
 There was a telling indication that the police and other forces who have to impose Communist rule were not immune to the general discontent. 
 Wolfgang Rosch, the deputy commander of the Leipzig worker's militia, which had been out in force during recent demonstrations, admitted that members &bquo;had the same concerns as the people who were on the streets&equo;. 
 WARSAW &mdash; Poland announced yesterday that it had stopped sending home East Germans who cross the border illegally, seeking transfer to West Germany, Reuter reports. 
 Malgorzata Niezabitowska, the government spokeswoman, said the Foreign Minister, Krzysztof Skubiszewski, was opposed to expelling East Germans. 
 Mr Skubiszewski has said the problem of East Germans who come to Poland to seek transfer to West Germany should be resolved in a humanitarian way. 
 About 1,500 East Germans who managed to reach Bonn's embassy in Warsaw in the past few weeks have been sent to the West in two special trains. 
 More than 500 more East Germans have reached the Polish capital since the last train left. 
 Storms threaten mild Greek election climate 
 From PETER THOMPSON in Athens 
 THE CHIEF JUSTICE of Greece's Supreme Court, Yannis Grivas, was appointed by President Sartzetakis yesterday to head a caretaker government which will conduct fresh elections, probably on 5 November. 
 His government will be sworn in today. 
 After the election, Mr Grivas will preside over the special tribunals due to hear cases of corruption against the former prime minister, Andreas Papandreou, and several of his colleagues. 
 Despite agreement among party leaders that the elections should be held in &bquo;a mild climate,&equo; it looks like being a divisive contest. 
 This results from the strategy adopted by Mr Papandreou, whose eight years in office ended when his socialist Pasok party was defeated in an inconclusive election last June. 
 He rejected proposals for an all-party government, leaving his opponents on left and right to join forces in the house-cleaning needed after Pasok's rule. 
 Mr Papandreou paid lip service to the clean-up while condemning it as a political plot to end his career and destroy his party. 
 Preferring attack to defence, he refused to answer charges against him in Parliament, saying instead: &bquo;I accuse my accusers&equo;. 
 Now that MPs have committed him for trial for allegedly ordering telephone-tapping and accepting bribes, he describes the three months of coalition government as &bquo;a lamentable political parenthesis&equo;. 
 In June, the conservative New Democracy Party, headed by Mr Papandreou's long-standing opponent, Constantine Mitsotakis, won 44 per cent of the vote and 145 seats out of 300, Pasok 39 per cent and 125 seats, and the Communist-led coalition of the left, under Harilaos Florakis, 13 per cent and 28 seats. 
 Mr Mitsotakis, who stood aside for one of his backbenchers, Tzannis Tzannetakis, to form an interim government with the support of the left, is confident of gaining the extra 2-3 percentage points needed for an overall majority next month. 
 Mr Papandreou, in good voice despite his poor health, launched his election campaign this week with a rally of 75,000 Pasok loyalists at the Olympic Stadium in Athens. 
 Despite the charges against him, he does not anticipate many defections. 
 Voters have voiced complaints at the elections being held before the trials begin, and before Mr Papandreou has a chance to prove his innocence. 
 Pasok denied yesterday it was waging a battle on two fronts. 
 But this is precisely what Mr Papandreou is doing. 
 To compensate for votes lost on the right, he needs to attract Communists horrified by the summer's iconoclastic alliance, and has described the left-wing coalition as &bquo;a crutch for New Democracy, a spare part&equo;. 
 Le Pen enjoys day of embarrassment 
 By DAVID USBORNE 
 STRASBOURG &mdash; Jean-Marie Le Pen's European Right party has offended both Switzerland and Israel, brought the European Parliament to a standstill and embarrassed the British Conservatives in Blackpool, writes David Usborne. 
 The row erupted on Tuesday when it was discovered that, by a quirk of the rulebook, Mr Le Pen's neo-fascists would chair the assembly's permanent delegations to Switzerland and Israel. 
 Mortified, all the other political leaders voted to change the rules to exclude the far-right MEPs from their new posts, especially after it was discovered that Mr Le Pen's man for Israel was likely to be from West Germany's Republicans, led by an ex-SS officer, Franz Schonhuber. 
 Mr Le Pen launched a tirade of Nazi terminology, suggesting that his MEPs were being treated as Untermenschen. 
 When the ruling was announced yesterday, Bruno Gollnisch, a European Right MEP, shouted &bquo;Dictator, dictator&equo; at the Parliament's president, Enrique Baron, and called other MEPs &bquo;Gestapo men&equo;. 
 When officials tried to eject him, Mr Gollnisch tried to punch his neighbours. 
 The session was suspended in disarray for two hours. 
 Mr Gollnisch has been invited to speak at a Conservative fringe meeting in Blackpool, organised by Western Goals UK, a movement run by the former Tory MP, Sir Patrick Wall. 
 The letter of invitation said Mr Gollnisch would have &bquo;the perfect opportunity to show support for Mrs Thatcher's policy of protecting the identity and national sovereignty of all European nations&equo;. 
 Uranium-seller 
 By DAVID USBORNE 
 ATHENS (Reuter) &mdash; A Briton, named as Derek Smith, 49, was arrested in Greece for trying to sell 5.5lb of radioactive uranium to a nuclear research centre in the outskirts of Athens. 
 Sadeq &bquo;lost&equo; 
 By DAVID USBORNE 
 LONDON (Reuter) &mdash; The former Sudanese prime minister, Sadeq al-Mahdi, deposed in a military coup in July, was taken from Khartoum's Kober prison last weekend and has not been heard from since, his cousin said. 
 Soviet budget 
 By DAVID USBORNE 
 MOSCOW (Reuter) &mdash; A Soviet parliamentary committee rejected the government's proposed budget and economic plan for 1990 saying it did not go far enough in adapting the Soviet planned economy to competition and market forces. 
 Tass news agency reported that the committee on economic reform said the proposed budget had failed to meet &bquo;the critical character of our situation&equo;. 
 Britain balked 
 By LEONARD DOYLE 
 NEW YORK &mdash; A British effort to bring the international drug trade before the UN Security Council has been balked by Brazil and Algeria, who objected to Britain's plan to include the drug trade in its definition of threats to international peace and security. 
 Brundtland goes 
 By TONY SAMSTAG 
 OSLO &mdash; Gro Harlem Brundtland, Norway's minority Labour Prime Minister, is to resign tomorrow, writes Tony Samstag. 
 A new government, a centre-right coalition led by the mainstream Conservative Party, takes over formally on Monday. 
 Old guard rebels 
 By IMRE KARACS 
 BUDAPEST &mdash; The Hungarian Socialist Workers' Party, extinguished at the weekend by its congress, rose from the ashes yesterday in Budapest's communist heartland, the industrial district of Csepel, Imre Karacs writes. 
 Forty-three members of the old party set up an HSWP cell, and urged their comrades all over the country to do the same. 
 &bquo;Lax security&equo; 
 By PATRICK MARNHAM 
 PARIS &mdash; The pilot of the UTA DC10 which exploded over the Sahara desert on 19 September, killing all 171 people on board, had previously complained of lax security on the Libreville to Paris route, according to a report in Le Canard Enchaine, writes Patrick Marnham. 
 The paper quotes documents which suggest the pilot learnt that the French authorities had received several bomb threats against UTA's African flights which were not passed on to him. 
 The Ministry of the Interior and UTA have repeatedly denied that any bomb warnings were received. 
 The airline actually withdrew special security precautions shortly before the DC10 went down. 
 Norwegian wins Economics Prize 
 By PATRICK MARNHAM 
 STOCKHOLM (UPI, Reuter) &mdash; A Norwegian professor, Trygve Haavelmo, 78, described as a humble man who spends much of his time in seclusion at his mountain cottage, was awarded the 1989 Nobel Economics Prize for pioneering use of mathematical statistics to interpret economic data. 
 Meanwhile, France's Minister for Research and Technology urged the two US winners of the Nobel Medicine Prize to honour Dominique Stehelin, a Frenchman who took part in the award-winning cancer research at the University of California in the 1970s. 
 He has said bitterly that he was overlooked by the Nobel committee. 
 Armenian passions flare anew 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 MOSCOW &mdash; Nagorny Karabakh, already effectively partitioned between its feuding Armenian and Azerbaijani communities into two armed camps, was yesterday facing further turmoil after the shooting by troops of an Armenian demonstrator in the capital, Stepanakert, on Tuesday, Rupert Cornwell writes. 
 According to official accounts, Spartak Okopyan, 39, was shot when a column of soldiers returned fire after coming under attack as it patrolled Stepanakert, now exclusively populated by Armenians. 
 His death brings to at least 118 the number of those killed in Transcaucasia since Armenia's campaign for the return of a territory controlled by Azerbaijan began in February 1988. 
 This ominous escalation of tension has come amid reports that the rail blockade of Armenia and Nagorny Karabakh by Azerbaijan &mdash; partially lifted at least in recent days &mdash; has been re-imposed after fresh violence. 
 Last night the extent of the blockade remained confused. 
 But the shooting has once more raised Armenian passions to boiling point. 
 Hong Kong receives an injection 
 From KEVIN HAMLIN in Hong Kong 
 CHINA'S political turmoil has had a &bquo;traumatic&equo; effect on Hong Kong, but in announcing plans for a Bill of Rights and expenditure of HK&dollar;127bn (&pound;10.1bn) on a new international airport and port facilities, Sir David Wilson, the Governor, made a bold attempt yesterday to bolster the territory's confidence. 
 In an upbeat policy speech that marked the opening session of the Legislative Council, Sir David was at pains to show a government committed to building a future for the territory beyond the 1997 handover to China. 
 He referred to plans to develop social programmes and infrastructure projects as a &bquo;vision that I hope will sustain Hong Kong during the present period of uncertainty and give us all confidence in our ability to overcome whatever problems confront us&equo;. 
 The speech, billed as the most important address ever made by a Hong Kong governor, was mostly well received by community leaders, with criticisms focusing on its skimpy attention to important political issues. 
 Sir David did not comment on Britain and China's war of words over Hong Kong's future, or Hong Kong's recent differences with Peking over the Chinese swimmer, Yang Yang, who was allowed to leave Hong Kong for the United States. 
 The Governor urged China to take &bquo;action to restore confidence&equo; in Hong Kong, but gave greater emphasis to locals finding confidence within themselves. 
 He warned people against &bquo;becoming directly involved in China's domestic politics&equo;. 
 Peking was upset by Hong Kong's support for the pro-democracy movement. 
 Sir David acknowledged a demand for political reforms to be speeded up, but hedged on how far Britain would go in backing them. 
 He reiterated that Vietnamese boat people considered to be &bquo;economic migrants&equo; must be sent back to Vietnam, but did not say when. 
 He expressed hope that Britain's long-awaited scheme to grant some Hong Kong people the right to live in Britain would be &bquo;as generous as possible&equo;. 
 More positive was confirmation that draft legislation for a Bill of Rights should be ready by July 1990. 
 This will give effect in law to provisions of the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights. 
 The bill is aimed at preserving social and political freedoms and is welcomed by most people. 
 However, critics note that China does not obey human-rights guarantees contained in its own constitution. 
 The new airport, at Chek Lap Kok, off Lantau Island's west coast, will, with new port facilities and related infrastructure, be the territory's biggest-ever development. 
 The airport will be linked to Hong Kong by a high-speed railway and a six-lane highway. 
 Sir David said the private sector would be invited to participate in the project, and that the first of two runways should be open in early 1997. 
 While the airport is seen as a big confidence-boost for business, Sir David said little to reassure Hong Kong people. 
 &bquo;The question of how to resolve the fear which so many people have in Hong Kong was omitted,&equo; said Peter Harris, a political scientist. 
 &bquo;There was simply a hope that somehow in the future things would get better because of this enormous expenditure.&equo; 
 Jimmy McGregor, a member of the legislative council, said, &bquo;If we did not have to depend on China we would be looking at a most marvellous future.&equo; 
 Party unleashes assault on Zhao 
 From ANDREW HIGGINS in Peking 
 CHINA'S ousted Communist Party leader, Zhao Ziyang, has come under renewed attack in the official media, amid hints of a power struggle in the Chinese leadership. 
 The Peking Daily, organ of the city's ultra-conservative party organisation, accused the disgraced former leader of trying to turn the party into little more than a &bquo;social club&equo; shorn of power. 
 It accused Mr Zhao, who was sacked as party secretary in June, of encouraging the formation of independent workers' unions during student-led protests. 
 The critique, the first such assault on Mr Zhao's record in several weeks, focuses on the policy of allowing factory directors greater freedom to run their business without meddling from local party cadres. 
 The policy has been the cornerstone of China's efforts to revive state industry over the past five years. 
 Officially it remains in force, but an attack in the official press suggests hard-line ideologues want to criticise not only Mr Zhao but also the economic policies he helped to implement. 
 Mr Zhao's fate, and by association his legacy, have become a big bone of contention in the leadership. 
 He has already been stripped of all his posts, but hardliners had been pressing for a public trial on criminal charges, though this looks unlikely. 
 Complaining that the grass-roots party cadres had been excluded from decision-making, the Peking Daily called for new emphasis on the party's role in economic as well as political matters: &bquo;If the party only controls the party then it would no longer be a political class party but an amateur group for the masses, or a kind of club.&equo; 
 Despite the crackdown on student protesters, Chinese leaders have repeatedly ruled out any big change in economic reform or the open-door policy. 
 Pressure seems to be growing, however, from party conservatives for a review of such policies and a stronger campaign to root out suspected &bquo;counter-revolutionaries&equo; in the government and party apparatus. 
 Leading the attack is the Peking Municipal Party Committee, stacked with zealous ideologues who played a key role in suppressing the student movement. 
 Fearing that the crackdown after the Tiananmen Square assault may be softening, city authorities warned this week that &bquo;counter-revolutionary&equo; remnants would become a &bquo;time bomb&equo; unless &bquo;ferreted out&equo; with more vigour. 
 However, the Peking Youth News has reported that &bquo;many people&equo; are worried about the high incidence of wrongful arrest and torture by martial law forces and police. 
 De Klerk meets the reformist trinity 
 From JOHN CARLIN in Johannesburg 
 AT A MEETING in Pretoria yesterday which FW de Klerk said he hoped would prove a milestone in South African history, the President talked for three hours with the country's three most politically prominent church leaders, Archbishop Desmond Tutu, Dr Allan Boesak and Rev Frank Chikane. 
 Mr de Klerk described the meeting as &bquo;talks about talks,&equo; an important step before negotiations get under way between the government and black political leaders. 
 The churchmen were less buoyant, having presented Mr de Klerk with a memorandum in which they listed six steps he had to take &bquo;immediately&equo; before negotiations about the government's much-vaunted new political dispensation could start. 
 Archbishop Tutu said in a news conference after the meeting that he was concerned about Mr de Klerk's failure to give any specific undertakings. 
 However, no doubt mollified both by the President's dramatic decision on Tuesday to announce the release of eight long-term political prisoners and by the urbanity of his style, the archbishop did note that the talks had proceeded in &bquo;a far better atmosphere&equo; than previous encounters he has had with the government. 
 Appearing to agree in part with Mr de Klerk's assessment of the meeting, the churchmen said they saw their role as &bquo;facilitators to get negotiation going&equo;. 
 The six steps proposed by this celebrated trinity of black anti-apartheid leaders were: lifting the state of emergency; lifting political restrictions on individuals; releasing all those detained without trial; unbanning political organisations; releasing all political prisoners; reprieving all those sentenced to death. 
 In every detail, the proposals are exactly those made by the African National Congress in a document released in August in which they list the conditions necessary to create the climate for negotiations. 
 The British and the US governments have asked for similar concessions from Mr de Klerk.. 
 Mr Chikane, the secretary-general of the South African Council of Churches, said that unless the six points were met negotiations would be a non-starter. 
 Rather more positive, Archbishop Tutu said that, if Mr de Klerk responded positively to their initiative, they would respond in kind. 
 &bquo;We would be ready to say to our friends: &bquo;Put the sanctions programme on hold because it appears there is a commitment here which we can accept&hellip;&equo; 
 If these things happen we'll say to our people: &bquo;Give them a chance. 
 They are serious&equo;.' 
 Mr de Klerk, while failing to offer any firm assurances, did say in a press conference of his own that the government would look at &bquo;areas&equo; where the state of emergency might be lifted. 
 (There are strong suggestions that he might, for example, lift restrictions on press freedom.) 
 He pleaded that the time had come for government bona fides to be accepted at face value and reiterated, emphatically, that the fact that all South Africans should have the vote was no longer a point that required further discussion. 
 A family to make Pretoria tremble: Walter Sisulu will leave his cell to join a wife and son who have themselves been restricted, John Carlin writes from Johannesburg 
 From JOHN CARLIN in Johannesburg 
 WALTER SISULU will have cause in the coming days to reflect, perhaps not for the first time, that stone walls do not a prison make. 
 Upon his release after 26 years in jail he will discover that he is more free than either his wife, Albertina, or his journalist son, Zwelakhe, who are both &bquo;restricted&equo; by the authorities under the long-standing state of emergency. 
 Whereas Mr Sisulu's release will be &bquo;unconditional&equo;, according to President FW de Klerk, his wife and son are prohibited from participating in any kind of public political activity and they are allowed to move &mdash; unless special exemption is granted &mdash; only within the boundaries of the Johannesburg area. 
 Zwelakhe Sisulu, who was released last December after two years of detention without trial, must report to the police every day and be indoors after 6pm. 
 His older brother, Mlungisi, may not enter South Africa, as an exiled member of the African National Congress. 
 There is no black South African family more rebellious, more doggedly persistent in their political opposition to apartheid, than the Sisulus. 
 Walter Sisulu himself, who as secretary-general of the ANC was more senior even than Nelson Mandela when the two were jailed for life in 1964, served seven jail terms between 1953 and 1963. 
 He also underwent several periods of de facto house arrest and trial for treason between 1956 and 1961. 
 He was acquitted, but virtually denied any time for family or politics during those five years. 
 The upshot is that, since he married Albertina in 1944, they have spent rather more than 30 years of their 45 years of marriage apart. 
 In spite of consistent repression, they produced five children. 
 Faced with the classic choice facing revolutionaries between a quiet family life and the turbulence of the greater good, they opted for the latter. 
 After her husband's life sentence, Mrs Sisulu, 68, was detained without charge twice. 
 She was banned from politics between 1964 and 1981, and spent 10 of these years under house arrest. 
 During a fleeting unrestricted period in 1985 she was named co-president of the United Democratic Front, the mainstream anti-apartheid organisation inside South Africa. 
 Then she was swiftly &bquo;restricted&equo; again, a condition which has endured since. 
 Demonstrating the arbitrariness of the emergency regulations, she was granted a passport in June this year so that she could head a UDF delegation which met Margaret Thatcher and President Bush. 
 Her appeal to them was more from the heart than the head, stressing the pain of being black in South Africa more than the broader strategies to be pursued. 
 She is an articulate, brave and exceptionally sweet-natured and compassionate woman, a nurse by training, who has stolen the hearts of the people of Soweto, where she lives, in a manner that the more queenly Winnie Mandela has not. 
 In the 1940s, when she trained as a nurse in Johannesburg, she began a lasting friendship with Mr Mandela's first wife, Evelyn. 
 The two couples were very close. 
 Mr Sisulu, now 77, was six years older than Mr Mandela and became something of a mentor to him on his arrival in Johannesburg in 1941. 
 The two men were born in the same region, the Transkei, but whereas Mr Mandela was a distinguished personage of royal blood, Mr Sisulu came from an impoverished peasant family and engaged in politics as a consequence of his exposure to the daily indignities of life for blacks through his work in a dairy, a bakery, in mines and factories. 
 But Mr Mandela arrived in Johannesburg penniless, while Mr Sisulu was already in the ANC, gaining prominence through his work in the unions. 
 Mr Mandela sought out Mr Sisulu and was rewarded with a loan to buy a suit and money to start a degree course in law. 
 Mr Sisulu's generosity and warmth did not waver during his time in the maximum security prison of Robben Island, where other inmates deferred to him as a charismatic senior statesman of what has been called &bquo;the government-in-exile&equo;. 
 One trait that former &bquo;Robben Islanders&equo; recall is his remarkable, almost photographic, memory &mdash; a quality that served him well in his ascent through the ANC hierarchy. 
 Physically he is unusually sturdy and has not fallen prey to illness during his long confinement. 
 He is said, despite his years, to be fit, lucid and raring to re-enter the political fray. 
 As a close friend of the ANC president, Oliver Tambo &mdash; with Mr Mandela the three were seen as the organisation's ruling &bquo;troika&equo; &mdash; he is certain to become a leading force in South African politics. 
 It will be interesting to see whether Mr de Klerk has the courage to lift the state of emergency, unban the ANC and unleash against himself and his government the full might of the Sisulu family. 
 Welcome progress, but not enough 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN 
 IF President FW de Klerk was hoping to ease the pressure on his government by announcing the release of eight prominent prisoners on Tuesday, he must have been disappointed by the reaction. 
 It was, from Mrs Thatcher to the African National Congress, the same: a welcome move, but now get on with releasing Mr Mandela and negotiations, writes Richard Dowden. 
 Mrs Thatcher called the move &bquo;a major step in the right direction&hellip; we hope it will lead on to the release of Nelson Mandela and open the way for negotiations for a new constitution for South Africa&equo;. 
 In Washington, the State Department welcomed the move but hoped that it was the &bquo;first step in a process&equo;. 
 Its statement spelt out the process: the release of other political prisoners, the return of political exiles, the lifting of the state of emergency and other political restrictions, and negotiations on a peaceful transition to a non-racial and democratic South Africa. 
 These conditions are almost identical to those of the ANC contained in a document endorsed by the Organisation of African Unity in August. 
 A statement from the ANC's exile headquarters in Lusaka welcomed &bquo;with great joy&equo; the announcement of the releases but rejected Mr de Klerk's use of the word reconciliation. 
 &bquo;The ANC is not aware of any spirit of reconciliation,&equo; it said. 
 Nor did President de Klerk gain much by telling Mrs Thatcher and the Americans of his plan in advance. 
 The move caused some surprise in Whitehall, where the belief is that it would be damaging to Mr de Klerk if he were seen to be making reformist moves because of external pressure. 
 If he hoped to persuade Mrs Thatcher that the releases were a favour to her and should be rewarded by her support for lifting sanctions, he will be disappointed. 
 The firm message from Whitehall last night was that Mrs Thatcher was not going to the Commonwealth heads of government meeting in Kuala Lumpur next week to propose a reduction in sanctions, although she would not agree to an increase in the measures already in place. 
 Rivonia gave immortality to the men it jailed for life 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN, Africa Editor 
 HISTORY will judge whether the Rivonia treason trial, which began in 1963, did more damage to the African National Congress or to the South African government. 
 At the time it seemed as if the government had crushed the nationalist movement by locking up its leaders for life. 
 In fact it immortalised them and ensured that all future anti-apartheid movements would vow their allegiance to the heroes of Rivonia. 
 Nelson Mandela was already serving a five-year sentence for inciting a strike and leaving the country without travel documents when, on 12 July 1963, the police raided Lilliesleaf Farm at Rivonia, near Johannesburg. 
 The house was the underground headquarters of what became the military wing of the ANC, Umkhonto we Sizwe, Spear of the Nation. 
 At the time it was an embryonic sabotage unit. 
 Nine men were arrested, including the five now due to be released: Walter Sisulu, Raymond Mhlaba, Elias Motsoaledi, Andrew Mlangeni and Ahmed Kathrada. 
 The police also found Mr Mandela's diary, documenting his travels to raise support for armed rebellion, and hundreds of documents which betrayed the plans of Umkhonto. 
 Mr Mandela was brought from prison on Robben Island to join his colleagues, and the trial began on 9 October. 
 The prosecution's first attempt quickly collapsed. 
 It accused Mr Mandela of carrying out acts of sabotage on dates when he was in prison. 
 But as the judge quashed the indictment, the men were re-arrested in the dock and four other charges were brought: recruiting persons for training in sabotage and guerrilla warfare for the purpose of violent revolution, conspiring to aid foreign military units when they invaded the republic, furthering the aims of communism and soliciting and receiving funds for these purposes from several countries. 
 The defendants, caught between the need to demonstrate their innocence and to stand by their political commitment, opted to make a political defence. 
 They pleaded not guilty. 
 In a recent book on the trial (The World That Was Ours &mdash; The story of the Rivonia trial, by Hilda Bernstein, published by SAWriters.), 
 Hilda Bernstein, the wife of one of those on trial, wrote: &bquo;The Rivonia trial was a confrontation in which the opposing forces in South Africa appeared face to face; those who stood for apartheid&hellip; and those who opposed it. 
 The court was an ultimate court of morality: the issues were not the guilt or innocence of the accused but the guilt or innocence of those who opposed apartheid.&equo; 
 The defendants tried to prove that Umkhonto we Sizwe was not part of the ANC. 
 They denied that they had adopted a plan for guerrilla warfare and denied that the ANC was communist. 
 The state's case was based mainly on accusations of sabotage and planned sabotage, a case well supported by the evidence found at Rivonia. 
 Detailed plans for Operation Mayibuye, an outline for guerrilla warfare and foreign intervention, were revealed. 
 Mr Sisulu said that it was just a draft plan, which had not been adopted. 
 The prosecution alleged that the men had been responsible of 222 acts of terrorism which it then reduced to 193. 
 The defendants admitted 20, thereby conceding the government's main case. 
 The trial ground on through the long hot summer in Pretoria. 
 It drew to an end in April 1964 with Mr Mandela's four-hour speech from the dock, in which he defended the formation of Umkhonto we Sizwe and said he had done what he did for the ideal of a free and democratic society, &bquo;an ideal for which I am prepared to die&equo;. 
 The only question was whether they would indeed be executed. 
 Convicting eight of the nine, the judge said they had, in essence, been convicted of high treason, which usually carried the death penalty. 
 But he sentenced them to life imprisonment. 
 The New York Times called the men heroes, and The Times said &bquo;the verdict of history will be that the ultimate guilty party is the government in power...&equo; 
 Denis Goldberg was released in 1985 and Govan Mbeki in 1987. 
 Soon only one Rivonia man will remain in jail. 
 Out of the West: A prince is found in the quartet of ex-presidents 
 By PETER PRINGLE 
 WASHINGTON &mdash; Under normal circumstances, when the by-line Gerald R. Ford appears, I frankly don't bother to read it. 
 In my book, there is nothing this ex-president has done, or said, since leaving the White House which is worthy of attention &mdash; especially considering the many worthy things ex-presidents can do and say. 
 But yesterday was different. 
 Under Mr Ford's byline on the editorial page of The Washington Post was the headline &bquo;Poland: I Told You So&equo;. 
 Instantly, I knew the article would be irresistible: a glorious return to one of the most famous, and fatuous, lines ever uttered by a presidential candidate debating with his opponent. 
 The year was 1976; the date, 6 October; the place, San Francisco. 
 By pre-arrangement the debate was limited to foreign and defence matters, which Mr Ford considered his strong suit because he had been a congressman and a vice-president while his opponent, Jimmy Carter, had been a mere governor of Georgia and a peanut farmer. 
 A question was asked about American power. 
 Mr Carter droned on about the United States not being strong any more and being too afraid of the Russian bear and being out-traded and so on. 
 &bquo;I might say this in closing,&equo; he said, &bquo;&hellip; as far as foreign policy goes, Mr Kissinger (Mr Ford's secretary of state) has been the president of this country. 
 Mr Ford has shown an absence of leadership and an absence of grasp of what this country is and what it ought to be.&equo; 
 Mr Ford recalls in yesterday's article that his &bquo;slow-burn really reached lift-off&equo;. 
 When chided by his questioner about signing the Helsinki accords on human rights which, the questioner suggested, allowed the Russians to have dominance in eastern Europe, Mr Ford, as he put it, &bquo;pranced with both feet across the open mine field&equo;. 
 He declared: &bquo;There is no Soviet domination of eastern Europe, and there never will be under a Ford administration.&equo; 
 Like millions of Americans I was watching the debate on television and, like millions of Americans, I leapt out of my seat yelling something like: &bquo;I can't believe he said that&hellip; 
 Carter wins!&equo; 
 And he did win &mdash; not solely because of that statement, of course, but it helped the unknown Georgian enormously in the final stretch of the campaign. 
 No one has ever given a satisfactory explanation of why Mr Ford said what he said &mdash; and it has gone down in the history books as just another Ford pratfall. 
 Yesterday, in his rather large article, Mr Ford could have offered an explanation for the statement &mdash; for instance, had the CIA briefed him that eastern European communism was about to unravel? 
 To know the answer to that would have been really interesting. 
 It would also be comforting to learn that the agency's analysis was that far ahead. 
 But no. 
 Mr Ford writes only: &bquo;My mother taught me it was wrong to crow. 
 But former presidents, as well as small boys, know no greater joy than being able to say, &bquo;I told you so&equo;&hellip; 
 I come out pretty well as a prophet.&equo; 
 Taking this in the spirit in which it was written &mdash; as a joke &mdash; Mr Ford's self-deprecation is admirable, but his limited understanding of what his role as an ex-president could be is appalling. 
 When he is not on the golf course, he is making large sums as a company director. 
 That's about it. 
 Richard Nixon is no better. 
 He writes books and articles few people want to read. 
 And Ronald Reagan accepts &dollar;2m from the Japanese to give a single lecture. 
 The prince among the four ex-presidents turns out to be Jimmy Carter. 
 His rehabilitation &mdash; from the leader they could not wait to get rid of because he represented high taxes, inflation and military failure (over Iran), to the president everyone loves to cite as the model elder statesman -has been remarkable. 
 He is everywhere, doing good things from building houses for the poor, helping farmers in Africa raise better crops and fight disease, to monitoring Panamanian elections, which he declared a fraud before it was officially agreed, and generally promoting peace and justice around the world. 
 When he goes back home to his tiny home village of Plains, Georgia, he teaches Sunday school. 
 Mr Carter graciously attributes his return from the political wilderness to the fact that Mr Bush has been more interested in his advice than Mr Reagan ever was. 
 &bquo;Under Reagan, everything bad that happened was either my fault or Nixon's fault or Congress's fault or some foreigner's&hellip; 
 It's a totally different attitude (under Mr Bush).&equo; 
 Mr Carter's closer relationship with Mr Bush has got his smile back into the newspapers, but Mr Carter has never stopped believing he can help solve the world's problems. 
 He never needed any encouragement in these moral quests, and my guess is that the recent favourable publicity about him means we will be hearing a great deal more of the Preacher from Plains. 
 Syrian airman asks Israelis for asylum 
 By PETER PRINGLE 
 MEGIDDO, Israel (Reuter) &mdash; A Syrian air force major yesterday landed a Soviet-made MiG-23 fighter in Israel and an army statement said he requested political asylum, becoming the first Arab airman to do so in more than 20 years. 
 In Damascus, a Syrian official said the plane had made an emergency landing because of mechanical problems. 
 He said Syria had asked the International Red Cross to arrange the man's return. 
 Israeli military experts said the advanced version of the MiG-23, from the arsenal of Israel's most significant frontline enemy, would provide valuable data. 
 The pilot could also give vital information on Syria's air force. 
 Military sources named the pilot as Major Adel Bassem, 34, and said he was co-operating with his Israeli debriefers. 
 &bquo;It doesn't look like he came here to keep quiet,&equo; an army officer said. 
 Israeli planes made the jet land at an airstrip in the plain of Armageddon, used by crop-dusting planes, to ensure it was not booby-trapped. 
 Workers at the airfield said they offered the pilot water and greeted him in Arabic. 
 Military sources said the unarmed plane split off from another MiG during a training flight east of the Golan Heights. 
 Israeli sources said a second Syrian MiG-23 landed at the same time in Egypt, near Alexandria. 
 But Egypt denied the report. 
 UN team reports on Swapo detainees 
 From SUSAN BROWN in Windhoek 
 A UN MISSION has not yet found any detainees in Swapo refugee camps, prison camps, bases and other facilities in Angola and Zambia, the UN Special Representative for Namibia, Martti Ahtisaari, said yesterday. 
 In making public the findings so far of the Mission on Detainees in Angola and Zambia, Mr Ahtisaari said that the group would keep trying to find about 250 people reported to have been detained or missing. 
 &bquo;At the alleged places of detention,&equo; Mr Ahtisaari said, &bquo;the facilities were found to have been stripped of all valuable material and not to have been inhabited for several weeks at least.&equo; 
 As a result of interviews with local people, he said, the mission did not believe that any detainees were moved from prison camps &bquo;to another place prior to the mission's arrival&equo;. 
 The UN team spent three weeks visiting the camps in September. 
 It found that a number of them were &bquo;what could be described as pits&equo;, according to the Nigerian ambassador, BA Clark, who headed the team and who represents the United Nations Transition Assistance Group (Untag) in Angola. 
 He described the facilities as &bquo;bricks, cement or mud-lined holes in the ground without steps or, by now, roofs&equo;. 
 Before it left, the UN mission compiled information on 1,100 people who had been detained, were alleged to have been detained or who were said to be missing, back to 1977. 
 The information came from a variety of sources, including Swapo itself. 
 The mission then cross-checked the names with those of people repatriated to Namibia through the UN High Commissioner for Refugees programme, which has brought back 41,000 Namibians, including most Swapo guerrillas. 
 Mr Ahtisaari said that only 315 people were then found to be unaccounted for, because the mission's list contained duplications, vague identifications, names of people who have been released and repatriated, names of people never detained and some who have been reported dead. 
 But Mr Ahtisaari said that more recent checking, against the roll of Namibians who registered to vote in recent months, turned up 54 more names, and the mission expects to find that at least 20 others have been repatriated. 
 An anomaly in the report is that it lists 21 &bquo;locations of alleged detainees&equo; in Angola. 
 The team visited only 10. 
 But war was under way again in southern Angola, the team faced obvious difficulties and had to rely on information from the Angolan government. 
 It is still not clear whether the approximately 250 people still listed as missing include those whom ex-detainees say were still alive in May, or if they include the names of those last seen in 1984 or 1986. 
 Automatic cuts in US budget start next week 
 From JOHN LICHFIELD in Washington 
 THE FINANCES of the most powerful country in the world will jump the rails this weekend. 
 Senior congressional sources yesterday wrote off all hopes of agreeing a 1990 US budget before the 16 October deadline. 
 As a result, automatic cuts will fall next Monday on &dollar;16.2bn (&pound;10.1bn) of US spending plans, equally divided between defence and some domestic programmes. 
 Who cares? 
 In the short term, no one much. 
 But budgetary relations between the White House and Democratic leaders in Congress are now so strained that some officials warn that the whole process of long-term deficit reduction could be threatened. 
 The last time that automatic budget cuts, mandated by the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings deficit-cutting law, took effect was in October 1987. 
 Three days later the stock market crashed. 
 Members of Congress and administration officials ought, in theory, to be wringing their hands this week; most are shrugging their shoulders. 
 Wall Street has long been bored with the US budget deficit. 
 With fears of a US recession calmed, the conventional wisdom is that the deficit does not matter much any more. 
 In the short term, next week's budget crunch is more like a toy train crash rather than the real thing. 
 When the White House and Congress do reach a 1990 budget agreement (no one is willing to predict when) the spending cuts will be restored and the carriages lifted back on to the rails. 
 But some senior members of Congress in both parties remain concerned by recent developments in US budget politics. 
 They believe the Bush administration's promise of steady deficit erosion, in co-operation with Congress, is being more systematically derailed. 
 Democratic leaders in Congress have been wounded and baffled by the fight picked by President Bush over his promised cut in capital gains taxes. 
 The acceptance of the tax cut in the House last month, against the wishes of Democratic leaders, has used up much of the good will cautiously built up earlier in the year for a medium-term, bipartisan deficit-cutting campaign. 
 The White House yesterday spurned a conciliatory offer by Senate Democrats to unload the tax cut from an already overloaded 1990 budget cart with a pledge to return to pick it up later. 
 Democratic leaders say the fact that the White House remains determined to pursue the capital gains cut suggests that the administration has lost interest in a steady, bipartisan campaign to reduce the deficit. 
 In that case, they say, all bets are off for co-operation on the budget next year. 
 Republicans say Mr Bush's win on capital gains suggests that the White House might be able to put together a majority of its own for budget restraint, with or without the Democratic leaders. 
 But they concede this is likely to take the form, sooner or later, of a less demanding timetable of deficit cuts. 
 Under the existing Gramm-Rudman law, the deficit is due to shrink to zero by 1993. 
 One of the original sponsors of the act, Senator Phil Gramm of Texas, a Democrat turned Republican, will sponsor legislation later this month to extend the deadline for a balanced budget until the end of the century. 
 Does this matter? 
 As long as the economy continues to grow, the political risks for President Bush are minimal. 
 The deficit has been reducing as a percentage of GDP. 
 Admittedly, this has been achieved, in part, by the kind of chicanery and double book-keeping which would earn a jail sentence for the treasurer-secretary of a small glue factory. 
 But no one appears to care too much. 
 Conservatives have even learnt to love the deficit: it helps to resist any movement towards an increased government share in the economy. 
 Others point out, however, that the combination of high public deficits and budget restraint is already beginning to eat into necessary public and private investment in infrastructure, from roads to new technology. 
 Shuttle's foes given a second chance 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 A TECHNICAL failure on the space shuttle Atlantis has given anti-nuclear activists time to return to court for a second attempt to prevent the space craft's launch, which they believe risks raining radioactive material over Florida. 
 Atlantis was to carry the Galileo space probe on the first leg of a six-year voyage to Jupiter this afternoon. 
 But a fault in the computer controlling one of the engines has forced the National Aeronautics and Space Administration (Nasa) to delay the launch until at least Monday. 
 The dispute concerns two nuclear batteries, each containing 24.7 pounds of plutonium oxide to power Galileo's scientific instruments. 
 Critics argue that if the probe should explode on lift-off or veer off course and re-enter Earth's atmosphere, the batteries could be pulverised, dispersing 260,000 curies of radioactive waste &mdash; more than half as much as has been released in all nuclear tests. 
 Lenny Sinken, a lawyer for the Washington-based Christic Institute, wants the mission delayed for 18 months while Nasa studies alternative power sources or arranges for Galileo to leave Earth on an unmanned rocket, less prone to failure than the shuttle. 
 Nasa won the first round of the legal battle on Tuesday, when a federal judge refused to order the launch be postponed. 
 The mission's opponents said they would appeal. 
 Each side claims that its estimate of the chances of nuclear catastrophe is more accurate. 
 Nasa said that the chances of a repeat of the 1986 Challenger disaster were 1 in 78. 
 Other estimates begin at 1 in 25. 
 The odds against radioactive contamination, Nasa told the court, are 2,500 to 1. 
 The evidence is not conclusive. 
 Nuclear batteries have been used in 22 other US missions. 
 Three involved accidents. 
 Radioactive contamination occurred in one, in 1964, but Nasa says it was designed to &mdash; a policy which has been changed. 
 Nasa said the plutonium is in marshmallow-size nuggets, each encased in three layers of protective material and set in a ceramic honeycomb, in turn contained in a cylinder made of layers of metal and fibreglass &frac34; in thick. 
 &bquo;Nasa conducted tests on those canisters early on,&equo; said Mr Sinken. 
 &bquo;They detonated an explosive device next to one, and it disintegrated into so many pieces they couldn't find them all. 
 So they decided the test wasn't valid and used computer simulations instead, where they get to punch in all the assumptions.&equo; 
 The search goes back to Moscow for the truth about Wallenberg: This Sunday leaders of Sweden's Raoul Wallenberg Society arrive in Moscow for meetings with Soviet officials. 
 John Eisenhammer recalls the story of the Swedish diplomat who vanished into Stalin's Russia almost 45 years ago 
 By JOHN EISENHAMMER 
 ON A GRASS verge along Szilagyi Erzsebet avenue in Budapest stands a bronze figure flanked by blocks of granite, bearing the inscription: &bquo;While good fortune stands by your side, friends are plentiful. 
 But should grey clouds gather, you are alone to withstand the storm&equo;. 
 It took more than 40 years for that memorial to be raised, near the place where Raoul Wallenberg's car was found after his disappearance into Russian hands. 
 For 40 years in Hungary, his selfless and ultimately tragic struggle in 1944 to save Budapest's Jews from extermination was conveniently forgotten, as Moscow wanted. 
 Not until the Kremlin signalled that times had changed could life be breathed back into Wallenberg's heroism. 
 Only then could tributes be written and statues erected. 
 Even more importantly, as Mikhail Gorbachev gradually allows so many officially forgotten barbarisms from the Soviet Union's past to slide into the glare of public scrutiny, so the prospect grows of solving one of the post-war era's most persistent enigmas. 
 For a frenzied seven months in 1944, Raoul Wallenberg, special envoy of the neutral Swedish government at its embassy in Nazi-occupied Budapest, waged a perilous struggle on behalf of the city's Jews. 
 His adversary was SS Colonel Adolf Eichmann, chief administrator of Hitler's final solution. 
 Eichmann's challenge in Budapest was to liquidate the last substantial urban Jewish community in Nazi-dominated Europe, some 230,000 trapped people. 
 Often as many as five trains a day, each one packed with 4,000 Jews, trundled eastwards to Auschwitz. 
 Later Eichmann, faced with a lack of rail transport, began a programme of deportations by foot &mdash; &bquo;death marches&equo; along a 120-mile route from Budapest to the Austrian border at Hegyeshalom. 
 Ignoring attempts on his life, and constant threats, Wallenberg used every means possible to outwit the executioners, bribing Hungarian and German officials, threatening the Gestapo and issuing Swedish passports which, surprisingly, offered some protection in a period hardly renowned for respect for the law. 
 He began by giving official passports to Jews who could claim some vague connection with Sweden, and ended by thrusting, in defiance of the Gestapo, cyclostyled papers bearing his signature into the hands of anyone he could reach, in the cattle trucks in railway sidings or along the road as the tragic columns struggled by. 
 Gideon Hausner, the Israeli lawyer who prosecuted Eichmann in 1961, estimates that Wallenberg personally saved 30,000 Jews in Budapest. 
 Others claim that some 100,000 owe their lives to his efforts. 
 When the Red Army finally reached the outskirts of Budapest, Wallenberg went to discuss his operations with the commander. 
 Soon after arriving at Marshall Malinovsky's headquarters in Debrezcin on 17 January 1945, Wallenberg was handed over to the NKVD, the predecessor of the KGB, and disappeared. 
 It is assumed that he was arrested on suspicion of being an American spy. 
 Indeed, Wallenberg was sent to Budapest with the backing of the US government and the World Jewish Congress. 
 The years in Lubyanka prison in Moscow transformed Wallenberg into a hostage of the Cold War, and then into one of the many errors of the Stalinist period whose truth became too ghastly to reveal. 
 The official Soviet version of events was provided in 1957 by Andrei Gromyko, then Deputy Foreign Minister, who claimed that Wallenberg had died of a heart attack in prison in 1947, a date conveniently set before the end of the Stalin era. 
 Few were inclined to believe this version, a scepticism reinforced over the years by countless reports, some highly credible, of sightings of the Swede, in prisons, mental homes and labour camps. 
 Some believe he is still alive; he would be 77. 
 The Soviet Union edged closer to this when its delegate at the international human rights conference in Paris this summer said of Wallenberg: &bquo;His fate, like that of thousands of others, is unknown, as are the circumstances surrounding it&hellip; 
 Rumours floated in the West that he is alive are not true. 
 This was a dark period in our history. 
 We deeply regret the death of this noble person. 
 If we knew any more, we would let the world know. 
 We have thousands like him, people who passed into oblivion.&equo; 
 Those who have campaigned on behalf of Wallenberg find it hard to believe that, in a bureaucratic system like the Soviet Union's, a file on the missing Swede is not somewhere. 
 In August the Soviet ambassador in Stockholm, Boris Pankin, wrote that Moscow wanted to &bquo;turn the case of the search for Raoul Wallenberg into a mark of honour for his memory,&equo; but again claimed that the Swede had died under Stalin. 
 The ambassador said it was not surprising that many people refused to believe Wallenberg was dead, since the Soviet authorities initially denied he was in custody: &bquo;Who believes you if you have lied before?&equo; 
 For years it was left to the family and close associates to keep the search alive. 
 The Swedish government's intermittent diplomatic efforts to solve the mystery got nowhere, often bungled out of deference to the Soviet Union. 
 America, which supported Wallenberg's activities in Budapest, quietly forgot, while Israel did little to honour him and even less to secure his release. 
 At last, the single-minded resolve of the Wallenberg Association in Sweden, of Nina Lagergren, his half-sister, Sonja Sonnenfeld, the association's secretary, and Per Anger, who was first secretary in Budapest during Wallenberg's time, may be rewarded. 
 The meeting with Kremlin officials could mark another significant step by the Soviet leadership as it comes publicly to terms with the unpleasant truths of a hitherto denied past. 
 &bquo;He would be 77, have you seen him?&equo; 
 Rupert Cornwell looks at the predicament facing the Kremlin hosts this weekend 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 THE 26 August 1989 edition of Do i Posle Polinochi, the popular late-night television magazine was offering its usual mixture of chat and interviews when suddenly there was a pause. 
 A black and white photo of a young man appeared on the screen. 
 &bquo;This is a picture of the Swedish diplomat, Raoul Wallenberg, taken in the 1940s,&equo; ran a caption beneath. 
 &bquo;Today he would be 77, have you seen him?&equo; 
 That was it. 
 But the moment alone was enough to prove that the Soviet authorities are sincere in their efforts to resolve the riddle of a romantic, mythical figure who single-handedly saved the lives of tens of thousands of Jews in wartime Budapest before disappearing for ever, at the start of 1945, into the darkness of Stalin's Russia. 
 At the invitation of the Soviet government, and accompanied by no fewer than 25 Swedish journalists, members of Raul Wallenberg's family and the society which bears his name will meet, during their week-long visit to Moscow, representatives of the KGB and the Foreign Ministry, who have promised to submit to them all available material. 
 The only problem is that the Soviet side insists there is nothing new. 
 For over three decades, Moscow has stuck to the explanation it gave in 1957 to the then Swedish Prime Minister, Tage Erlander: that 10 years before, in July 1947, Raul Wallenberg had died in Lubyanka prison. 
 Diligent searching of the Lubyanka files had unearthed a memo signed by one Dr Smoltsov, chief of medical services at the prison, to General Viktor Abakumov, the Minister of State Security, under whose &bquo;special supervision&equo; Wallenberg was being held. 
 He had died in his cell, the memo claimed, &bquo;presumably of a heart attack&equo;. 
 On the orders of Abakumov the body was cremated without a post-mortem. 
 There, officially, the trail ends. 
 General Abakumov, by bitter irony himself a Jew, was shot on the orders of his rival, Lavrenti Beria, in 1951. 
 Dr Smoltsov's fate is unknown. 
 Stalin is dead, and so since this summer is Andrei Gromyko, who as Deputy Foreign Minister at the time of the 1957 note, might have been in a position to provide some elucidation. 
 In its absence, the Wallenberg enigma has persisted. 
 For 20 years after 1957, reports of &bquo;an old Swedish prisoner&equo; somewhere in the giant Soviet penal camp system would reach the West. 
 The instinctive secrecy of the Soviet Union, its propensity to lie, only fuelled the suspicions that the full truth had not been told. 
 Now the advent of Mr Gorbachev, and the departure of Mr Gromyko, have rekindled hopes that it will be. 
 If the 1957 explanation was false, the theory runs, then the subsequent loss of face would have been too great for a correction to be issued in Gromyko's lifetime. 
 And it is surely in keeping with the Kremlin's efforts to win trust abroad, to remove once and for all an issue which intrudes into every high-level encounter with Sweden. 
 Today no-one &mdash; with the possible exception of members of his family - seriously believes that Wallenberg is still alive somewhere in what is left of the Gulag Archipelago, four and a half years into perestroika. 
 The question is rather exactly when, where and how he died. 
 In the Soviet Union, unlike the West, Raoul Wallenberg is a little-known figure. 
 Maybe, however, someone's memory will have been nudged by that photo flashed on television screens six weeks ago. 
 In the meantime Andrei Sakharov, the human rights campaigner, has demanded a special investigation, independent of the government, to check the evidence and sift every rumour. 
 He himself paid two fruitless visits to the site of a camp near Torzhok, 200 miles north of Moscow, where as late as 1987 Wallenberg was said to have been held. 
 But no corroboration was forthcoming, either from local residents or from former camp officials. 
 More nagging is the suspicion that Wallenberg did not die of a heart attack at the age of 35, but was murdered or tortured to death. 
 The problem is the familiar one when trying to establish the exact fate of millions of Stalin's victims: detailed records of the security police, if they ever existed, have probably long since been destroyed. 
 Barco moves too late to break the drug barons 
 From SIMON FISHER in Bogota 
 ALMOST two months into Colombia's crackdown on the cocaine cartels, it is becoming increasingly clear that President Virgilio Barco has launched a war he cannot win. 
 Although President Barco is given credit for good intentions, the fear is that his move has come too late: by now, the money at stake is too big, the drug barons too firmly entrenched in Colombian society, and the state institutions too deeply compromised by too many years of complacency, if not complicity. 
 At the moment, the &bquo;war&equo; has become distilled to a hunt for Pablo Escobar and Gonzalo Rodriguez Gacha, two of the heads of the Medellin cartel. 
 The Ochoa family, whose patriarch freely gives interviews to the press on his family farm, seem to have been forgotten, as do the Rodriguez Orejuela brothers and Jose Santacruz, who lead the Cali cartel. 
 Rodriguez Gacha and Escobar are undoubtedly worthy of pursuit. 
 But the others are no prettier, and neither are the hundreds of hoods behind them waiting to take their gold-plated places. 
 Neither has been caught because both seem to have known of the swoops on their many hide-outs even before the authorities who conducted them. 
 This drug duo may have been singled out because their penchant for fine racehorses and private zoos, not to mention murder on a massive scale, made them the most public of the mafia bosses. 
 But some commentators believe that it may also be because, unlike other cartel kingpins, Escobar and Rodriguez Gacha are social upstarts who have clawed their way out of the gutter. 
 Colombia's ruling class maintains the conservative interests of its aristocratic lineage. 
 The clampdown has exposed the close links between landowners, the security forces and the cocaine cartels, who set up paramilitary squads to &bquo;clean out&equo; left-wing activists from rural areas such as the Magdalena Medio. 
 Politicians who have their power base in these areas, including several presidential candidates, are also implicated. 
 The drug barons have themselves become substantial land holders, effectively controlling several departments. 
 Amnesty International's report that this unholy alliance is responsible for at least 2,500 political killings in the past two years demonstrates that the Colombian authorities are more interested in waging a war on the left than on the drug cartels. 
 After 10 years, the cocaine trade has joined, and to some extent displaced, the traditional elite class. 
 The drug dollars have become an integral part of the economy. 
 The current offensive has provoked a sharp recession, with investment, construction, travel and commerce suffering badly. 
 Colombia does not have a consumption problem comparable to that of the US or Europe. 
 Consumption is relatively low, and the problem in Colombia is really one of politics and poverty. 
 For many ordinary Colombians, the drug traffickers have become heroes who fund social programmes and provide work, in a classic beans-and-bullets strategy. 
 They sought legitimacy and a political outlet to match their enormous economic power. 
 Until two months ago, they had achieved considerable success: the recent launch of a new political party, the National Restoration Movement (Morena), is credited to the cartels. 
 But after the assassination of the presidential candidate, Luis Carlos Galan, which triggered Mr Barco's clampdown, Morena was banned. 
 Secret talks with the government, which went on over a period of more than a year, were also broken off. 
 But many commentators believe that there are points of common interest between the government, the traffickers and the traditional ruling class, and that Mr Barco, a lame-duck president in the closing months of his administration, may no longer have the power within his own party to sustain his offensive. 
 One possible outcome of the current stalemate is that Colombia's next government will quietly accommodate with the traffickers, as did its predecessors, after the fuss has died down. 
 MONTERREY &mdash; Luis Cano, publisher of the Colombian daily, El Espectador, said yesterday that his newspaper would continue operations in Medellin despite threats from drug barons and the murder of two of its employees there, Reuter reports. 
 Presidential hopefuls confuse Brazil's voters 
 From RICHARD HOUSE in Brasilia 
 FIVE WEEKS before Brazil's first presidential elections in 29 years, an increasingly volatile political and economic situation favours a struggle between youthful candidates of the right and left. 
 For a month, more than 80 million voters have been bombarded with twice-daily doses of television broadcasts from 20 candidates. 
 Hours of lavishly-produced films have deployed mystical predictions, humorous pastiches of advertisements and evocations of Winston Churchill, all underscored by a vitriolic trade in insults between rivals. 
 The seven leading candidates have shunned firm manifesto proposals in favour of vague attacks on foreign creditors or elites who benefit from Brazil's crippling income disparities. 
 Those favouring taxation or recession have kept quiet. 
 But the broadcasts have confused voters &mdash; the number of don't-knows has risen to almost half &mdash; and produced complex movements in the far-from-reliable opinion polls, where four candidates are now closely bunched in second position behind a fast-flagging leader. 
 There has been an uncanny duplication of the pre-election economic chaos that Argentina experienced in May. 
 Brazilian monthly inflation has topped 36 per cent and the flight into gold and dollars has produced dramatic leaps in black-market rates. 
 Economists predict 50 per cent inflation by polling day. 
 As no outright winner is expected to emerge from 15 November's poll, a run- off will be held on 17 December between the two leading contenders. 
 The new president is not expected to take office until March 1990, or at best 1 January if Jose Sarney steps down from the presidency early. 
 This means Brazil will not have the rapid handover of power that saved Argentina from hyperinflation. 
 Brazil's latest political phenomenon, Fernando Collor de Mello, the governor of Alagoas state and a defector from the ruling PMDB, who founded his own party last year, astonished Brazil's political class by taking a dramatic early lead in the opinion polls. 
 He began the campaign with more support than all his rivals combined, but it has trickled through his fingers. 
 His 43 per cent support has shrunk to 32 per cent, according to the latest poll. 
 As the educated urban elite abandon Mr Collor, following a series of media exposes of his political record, he has relied on continued support from rural voters at rallies of up to 70,000. 
 But yesterday Mr Collor struck back by announcing a detailed Thatcherite economic plan to roll back the frontiers of the state. 
 &bquo;We must replace a state that's gigantic, inefficient and corrupt with one that's modern and austere,&equo; he said. 
 He promised a &bquo;shock of credibility&equo; to beat inflation. 
 Zelia Cardoso de Mello, his chief economic adviser, proposed to increase tax revenues by 25 per cent, reduce government spending by 10 per cent and raise &dollar;18bn (&pound;11.46bn) through privatisation programmes. 
 Mr Collor promised to reduce inflation to just 3 per cent a month within a year by using shock tactics similar to those of President Menem of Argentina. 
 He said this would be paid for by &bquo;speculators and those who have been living off the state like cannibals&equo;. 
 Polls show a surge in support to 12 per cent for the left-wing Workers' Party (PT), whose candidate, Luis Inacio &bquo;Lula&equo; da Silva, could supplant the main social democratic contender, Leonel Brizola, and emerge as Mr Collor's rival in the run-off. 
 The union-backed PT favours an immediate debt moratorium and statutory controls on company profits. 
 Mr Collor is pleased by this polarisation, which could drive defecting conservatives &mdash; fearful of radical socialist advances &mdash; back to his camp. 
 Drug summit call to Europeans 
 From SIMON STRONG in Lima 
 The US yesterday welcomed a proposal made by the presidents of Colombia, Peru and Bolivia that European nations should participate in a drugs summit with President Bush. 
 The interior ministers of Peru, Bolivia and Colombia and representatives of Spain, France and Italy are to meet in Madrid in two weeks' time to discuss drug trafficking. 
 The issue was expected to be high on the agenda at the summit of presidents of the so-called Group of Eight &mdash; Peru, Colombia, Mexico, Venezuela, Argentina, Brazil and Uruguay &mdash; which started in Ica yesterday. 
 Meeting in Ica on Tuesday, Presidents Alan Garcia of Peru, Jaime Paz Zamora of Bolivia and Virgilio Barco of Colombia said there was an increased global sense of &bquo;co-responsibility&equo; for the drugs trade. 
 They welcomed last month's initiative by Mr Bush and called for a summit with him within 90 days. 
 Mr Bush doubled international military and police aid to stamp out drugs. 
 Mr Bush's failure to acknowledge the need for financial compensation for the three main producer countries, Peru, Bolivia and Colombia, has been condemned by all three, but this criticism was conspicuously absent from their declaration. 
 It was believed they differed on how to deal with the US and that Mr Garcia had pushed for a stronger stance. 
 Mr Paz Zamora said Europe was being invited to the summit because it had &bquo;demonstrated a marked interest in dealing with the problem alongside other countries&equo;. 
 Court Circular 
 From SIMON STRONG in Lima 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 11 October: This morning The Princess Royal, Patron, College of Occupational Therapists, opened the College's new Headquarters, Information and Study Centre, at 6-8 Marshalsea Road, London, and was received on arrival by The Mayor of Southwark (Mr Tony Ritchie). 
 Afterwards Her Royal Highness opened the Young Designer's Centre, The Design Council, 28 Haymarket, London, and was received on arrival by The Lord Mayor of Westminster (Councillor Simon Mabey). 
 This afternoon The Princess Royal visited the Headquarters of the Special Escort Group at their Barnes Headquarters, St Ann's Road, London. 
 Afterwards The Princess Royal, President, The Save the Children Fund, chaired the tenth meeting of The Save the Children Fund Industry and Commerce Group at Buckingham Palace. 
 In the evening Her Royal Highness attended a Banquet at the Guildhall given by the Worshipful Company of Framework Knitters to celebrate the 400th Anniversary of the invention of the Knitting Frame by William Lee. 
 The Princess Royal was attended by Mrs Malcolm Wallace. 
 Miss Anne Beckwith-Smith was in attendance. 
 11 October: The Princess Margaret, Countess of Snowdon, President of the National Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Children, this afternoon opened &bquo;Treetops&equo;, the Society's Child Protection Team's Unit in Hemel Hempstead. 
 Her Royal Highness was received on arrival by Her Majesty's Deputy Lieutenant for Hertfordshire (Brigadier F. De Butts). 
 The Countess Alexander of Tunis was in attendance. 
 11 October: The Duchess of Gloucester, Patron of Counsel and Care for the Elderly, today visited the Counsel's new offices at 16 Bonny Street, London NW1. 
 Mrs Howard Page was in attendance. 
 YORK HOUSE 11 October: The Duke of Kent, Colonel-in-Chief of the Royal Regiment of Fusiliers, today received Lieutenant-Colonel GW Henderson on assuming command of the 2nd Battalion and Lieutenant Colonel JC Gunnell on relinquishing the appointment. 
 The Duchess of Kent this morning attended a Thanksgiving Service in Exeter Cathedral to mark the 150th Anniversary of the foundation of the West of England School for Children with Little or No Sight, and later opened St David's House. 
 Her Royal Highness this afternoon visited the Devon Guild of Craftsmen's Centre, Bovey Tracey, Devon. 
 Her Royal Highness, who travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight, was attended by Mrs Alan Henderson. 
 The Duchess of York, Patron of Museums Year 1989, opens the Food for Thought Gallery at the Science Museum, London SW7; and, this evening, attends the opening performance of the Spanish Riding School at the Wembley Arena, Middlesex. 
 Prince Edward attends the presentation of the Historical Association's Young Historians prizes on the First National History Day at the Imperial War Museum, London SE1. 
 The Princess Royal, President, Riding for the Disabled Association, attends the Council Meeting at Saddlers Hall, London EC2; as Chief Commandant, Women's Royal Naval Service, attends a luncheon on board HMS London in the Pool of London; and, as Chancellor, University of London, attends a reception and dinner at the Senate House, Malet Street, London WC1, on the occasion of Foundation Day 1989, and attends the Fundation Ceremony and Reception at the Institute of Education, Bedford Way, London WC1. 
 The Duchess of Gloucester, attends an Anglo-Danish Society Ball at The Savoy Hotel, Strand, London WC2. 
 The Duchess of Kent, as Patron of Age Concern, opens a new Day Centre in Hockley and Hawkwell, Essex. 
 Obituary: Charles McCall 
 By BERNARD DUNSTAN and CHARLOTTE HALLIDAY 
 CHARLES McCALL was a painter who worked all his life unaffected by fashion or the pressures of the art world. 
 He belonged to no movement but his attitude could be described, like that of many good British painters of the last 50 years, as being in the tradition of Vuillard and Sickert. 
 Coming between the poetic neo-romanticism of the war years and the potentially overwhelming influence of American abstraction, theirs was a quiet but genuinely felt and observed art which shows its strength by continuing to flourish in its unsensational way. 
 McCall was happiest working on a small intimate scale, dealing with the domestic interior and the urban scene. 
 He used a solid rich surface of paint and liked the simplified shapes produced by artificial lighting. 
 In his person he matched his art perfectly: he was distinguished in appearance, erect in bearing and with a certain unselfconscious, slightly old-fashioned, courtesy. 
 Apparently preferring silence to chatter, in company he would let the froth bubble around him yet then produce a wry, always shrewd, comment. 
 Likewise, though a loyal supporter of the societies of which he was a valued member, he managed to remain detached from any of the inevitable petty politics. 
 Charles McCall began life as a clerk to a firm of lawyers in Edinburgh, but in 1933 he won a scholarship to Edinburgh College of Art, where he studied under DM Sutherland and SJ Peploe. 
 He was made a Fellow in 1938. 
 In that same year he returned from studying on the Continent and began to exhibit work in the Royal Academy and with the New English and the London Group. 
 He had One Man shows at many London galleries including the Leicester Galleries and the Belgrave and in Manchester, Dublin, New York, Montreal and Winnipeg. 
 Though dogged by ill health in later years he was still able to work in his particularly single-minded way, largely because of the devotion of his wife Mitzi whom he met during the war, while serving with the Royal Engineers. 
 Throughout their married life she was a tremendous support, managing their everyday affairs, helping to organise his exhibitions on both sides of the Atlantic and allowing him the freedom &mdash; one might say the luxury &mdash; to paint without interruption. 
 Obituary: Penny Lernoux 
 By PETER HEBBLETHWAITE 
 THROUGHOUT the last 20 years Penny Lernoux was one of the best interpreters of Latin America to the United States. 
 Born in Los Angeles in 1940, she majored in journalism and Spanish studies at the University of Southern California. 
 She found her bearings conventionally enough by working for the US information office in Bogota, Colombia, and then in Rio di Janeiro where she acquired a lifelong love for Brazil. 
 She served the Copley News Service for a decade and then, married to a British businessman, Denis Nahum, settled in Bogota and became Latin American correspondent for The National Catholic Reporter. 
 These were exciting years for the Catholic Church in Latin America. 
 The Medellin Bishops' meeting in 1968 launched the movement known as &bquo;liberation theology&equo;. 
 A network of &bquo;base communities&equo; sprang up in response, and began to live the Gospel on the humblest level. 
 Lernoux's first book, Cry of the People (1980), was a superb piece of first-hand reporting about the way God appeared to have changed sides. 
 No longer the prop of an unjust social order, the God of the Magnificat was to be found on the side of the poor while the mighty trembled at the prospect of being toppled from their insecure thrones. 
 Lernoux became &bquo;the voice of those who had no voice&equo;. 
 It was not a voice North Americans were used to hearing. 
 Lernoux was partisan. 
 She wrote from the shanty-towns, not from air-conditioned hotel rooms. 
 Her next book, In God We Trust (1984), tackled the effect of international banking on Latin America and the debt problem. 
 Her last book, which appeared this spring, The People of God: the struggle for world Catholicism (1989), struck a more sombre note. 
 It also contained her unconscious valedictory: As a Catholic observer who has lived in the Third World for nearly 30 years, I have followed developments in the Church, at times with despair but mostly with optimism. 
 The hope that a new Church of the poor has given to the impoverished masses of this region is the most significant political development in the region in recent decades. 
 This Church has also given me new faith. 
 She now thought that the Church was under attack from a Vatican more concerned with power and control than with the good of the people. 
 Cardinal Paolo Evaristo Arns, Archbishop of Sao Paolo, was in Belgium at the time of her death and would have liked to have said her Requiem Mass. 
 She was, he said, &bquo;a great journalist&equo; &mdash; &bquo;We must recommit ourselves to the important mission to which Lernoux was devoted.&equo; 
 It is difficult to think of any comparable tribute from a cardinal to a journalist, still less to a woman. 
 It reminds us that there can be an invaluable &bquo;women's ministry&equo; well this side of the ordained priesthood. 
 The last cause she took up was that of Dom Pedro Casaldaliga, poet and bishop of a remote Amazonian diocese, unjustly pursued by the Vatican. 
 She began her last book with these lines of his: When you say law, I say God. 
 When you say peace, justice, love, I say God. 
 Obituary: Tony Hewitt-Jones 
 By LEWIS FOREMAN 
 TONY HEWITT-JONES was a versatile musician and a great character in Gloucestershire music. 
 Avuncular and sociable, he was a warm and friendly person who might be encountered conducting a Women's Institute choir, accompanying an audition at the piano, as a freelance organist or providing harpsichord continuo. 
 As a bass, his appearances in the choir at the Three Choirs Festivals found a singer who &bquo;could really get the bottom notes&equo;. 
 By the wider public he will be remembered as a composer whose style, founded in practical music-making, has an immediate appeal which rewards both performers and audiences. 
 He more or less started the Gloucester County Youth Orchestra, which he conducted for 13 years, as well as running the County Music Summer Schools. 
 These activities gave him an enduring influence in the development of young musicians. 
 He conducted the Cheltenham Bach Choir, the Stroud Choral Society and all manner of local choirs. 
 The anti-clash diary of regional events which he compiled was widely distributed. 
 Hewitt-Jones went up to Christ Church, Oxford, where he was a pupil of Bernard Rose (who later recorded his Magnificat, written for Magdalen). 
 Later he studied with Herbert Sumsion, and was made an Associate of the Royal College of Organists in 1957 when he was awarded the Limpus and Read prizes. 
 In 1969, he took six months' sabbatical leave to study with Nadia Boulanger in Paris. 
 The earliest music Hewitt-Jones acknowledged was a cello sonata written in 1951. 
 His many anthems and music for church performance include delightful settings of Psalm 150 and &bquo;Bring Unto the Lord O Ye Mighty&equo;. 
 One organist remarked to the present writer on the &bquo;marvellous&equo; Fanfare for organ, for which he also wrote a Sonata (1971). 
 Two of his best-known works, the unaccompanied setting of Donne's &bquo;At the Round Earths Imagin'd Corners&equo; and the Seven Sea Poems for soloist, chorus, oboe and strings, date from the mid-1950s, the latter making a strong impression during the 1968 City of London Festival. 
 The format of the traditional choral suite with soloist is also reflected in the light-hearted Good Company for baritone, chorus and orchestra (1964), and later in The Celestial City written for Adrian Beaumont and the Bristol Bach Choir in 1977. 
 Hewitt-Jones also wrote orchestral music, including a Sinfonietta for Strings (1959), concertos for oboe, for clarinet and for trumpet (1966, 1968, 1976), the first and last being works of considerable substance and worthwhile additions to somewhat restricted repertoires. 
 While not primarily a composer of chamber music, his substantial Piano Trio performed by the Joubert Trio in 1985, would appeal to a wide audience. 
 The majority of his music was written for particular occasions, for performers known to him or in memory of friends and colleagues. 
 Possibly the best known of these is the Mass of Reconciliation written for Coventry 25 years after the bombing (a service which appeared on disc), and his association with the Three Choirs Festival which included his Te Deum in 1962, his setting of &bquo;Let Us Now Praise Famous Men&equo; at the opening service in 1977, and the Benedicite (in memory of Cecil Adams) in 1986. 
 There is not space to enumerate all his works which arose from such associations, but The Battle of Tewkesbury for voices and instrumental ensemble for the 1971 Tewkesbury Festival and Henry Purcell for counter-tenor, clarino obbligato and strings for Alfred Deller and Stour Music (1971), the Jubilate for Charlton Kings Choral Society (1979), the Scherzo for piano and orchestra for Douglas Smith and the Cheltenham Sunday Players, the moving Concerto for trumpet and strings in memory of Bernard Brown (1976), and the Cantate Domino in memory of John Clough (1978) are all interesting examples that deserve to be heard again. 
 During the 1980s Hewitt-Jones suffered from depression, which inhibited composition, though he continued to produce new works. 
 For the last year of his life he suffered from myeloma, a form of bone cancer, and entered hospital for the last time in July where he made friends with another patient who, unfortunately, soon died. 
 This experience appeared to transform him and he threw himself into a great surge of composition, writing a Mass of Thanksgiving for unaccompanied choir filling 100 pages of manuscript, which he completed in 15 days, as well as other works, including a setting of Out of the Deep which is given its first performance by his choir at St Philip and St James, Cheltenham, at his funeral on today. 
 Obituary: Joe Crossman 
 By STEVE VOCE 
 Joseph Crossman, alto saxophonist and clarinettist, born London March 1905, died London 4 October 1989. 
 ODDLY enough, although he was for almost 50 years a pillar of the British dance band scene, by his own account Joe Crossman's only popular acclaim was given to him in the United States for his beautiful alto saxophone solo on Stanley Black's mid-Forties recording of Django Reinhardt's ballad &bquo;Nuages&equo;. 
 Aptly enough Crossman died after leaving the El Coda Club, while walking down Archer Street. 
 The club was a meeting place for musicians of his era, and Archer Street was for many years the centre of the British dance music business. 
 &bquo;He was never a progressive musician,&equo; recalls pianist Gerry Moore, who in contrast always was, &bquo;but he had the most beautiful tone. 
 I remember playing a concert with him at Portsmouth Town Hall, and he played one of the most moving versions of &bquo;Stardust&equo; that I ever heard. 
 During the Thirties when we were all in the big bands, I remember the really fiery jazz clarinet he used to play with us in the Bag O' Nails, just about the first jazz club in Britain.&equo; 
 Crossman joined Ambrose's Embassy Club Orchestra in 1926, some years before the band made its name as the finest jazz group in Europe. 
 In 1932 he left to join the Lew Stone Band which, like Ambrose, played &bquo;society&equo; clubs in London. 
 Although conventional, Crossman's technique, dazzling for the time, shines through many of Stone's records, notably &bquo;Tiger Rag&equo; from 1934, where it is obvious that the American clarinettist Jimmy Dorsey had had a strong influence on him. 
 Unlike most other musicians, he did not seem to have been impressed by Louis Armstrong's seminal appearance at the London Palladium in 1932. 
 &bquo;His actual presence gave me a shock,&equo; said Crossman then, &bquo;and I much regret to have to admit finding something barbaric in his violent stage mannerisms.&equo; 
 Crossman left Lew to work for Jack Hylton and then, two days after the Second World War began, rejoined Ambrose. 
 &bquo;Lew was a very communicative chap, who liked to discuss the musical arrangements with the boys in the band,&equo; he remembered. 
 &bquo;Ambrose was much more stringent, and a sense of discipline could be felt, which was reflected in the style of clip phrases and a tighter rhythmic background used in his band.&equo; 
 The Ambrose Orchestra played at the Mayfair Hotel until it was closed down by an unexploded bomb. 
 Forced to leave, Crossman played alongside Ted Heath in the Maurice Winnick Orchestra before touring France briefly for ENSA. 
 He then joined Harry Roy's band in 1940. 
 Roy was also a clarinettist, and when Joe soloed brilliantly on some of his records, the credit was given to Harry. 
 In October 1940 Joe was called into the RAF where he played in the band of Fighter Command with embryo jazz musicians like trumpeter Kenny Baker and reed player Aubrey Franks. 
 On his release he rejoined Harry Roy and later the novelty band Sid Milward And the Nitwits. 
 Working for &bquo;Geraldo's Navy&equo;, the group of bands put together by Geraldo to play in cruise liners, he became band master of the SS Caronia in the middle Fifties. 
 He continued to work until a few years ago and from then on passed much of his time in London. 
 He was most often to be found in that jazz Mecca, Dobell's Record Shop in Tower Street, where he was happy to reminisce about earlier times and to discuss who played what on the records from his heyday. 
 Anniversaries 
 By STEVE VOCE 
 On this day: Christopher Columbus discovered San Salvador, 1492; the first Morris Minor car designed by Alec Issigonis was produced at Cowley, 1948. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 27 
 Bridge 
 By ALAN HIRON 
 GREAT BRITAIN has had mixed fortunes in international competition this year. 
 Our Open team finished tenth in the European Championships in Turku &mdash; their lowest ever placing &mdash; while our Women's team (generally regarded as ante-post favourites) could manage only sixth place. 
 It was left to our Juniors, competing in the Second World Junior Bridge Championships in Nottingham, to salvage our national pride. 
 This they did handsomely, leading the Round Robin qualifying rounds, defeating France, who had been strongly tipped, in the semi-finals and Argentina in the finals. 
 This was a deal where Andy Robson, playing with John Pottage for Britain, did all the right things. 
 Well done, but no bidding system yet devised could have identified the absence of the nine of clubs. 
 If this card had been with either North or South the slam would have been a 75-per-cent chance. 
 As the cards lay, some inspiration was needed. 
 The opening lead of a small trump did not solve any problems and declarer set to work to eliminate hearts and draw trumps. 
 Then came the ace and king of spades and a low club from dummy. 
 East played low, the ten lost to the king and back came a low club. 
 As you can see, if West had led his last spade dummy would have been forced to ruff and successfully play the ace of clubs. 
 At least by leading a club he gave declarer a choice. 
 There were a number of clues available to Robson: if West had still held the guarded queen of clubs he would almost certainly have kept and exited with his last spade; if he had held both the king and queen of clubs he would have been equally likely to win the first club with the queen; and, from what had happened so far, it looked as though West had started with more clubs than his partner. 
 At any rate, declarer went up with dummy's ace to drop the queen and land his slam. 
 I will ask him some time what prompted his winning play but it has been known for players to forget matters like that after a week's hard work. 
 Obituary: Huynh Tan Phat 
 By ALAN HIRON 
 Huynh Tan Phat, Viet Cong political leader, died Ho Chi Minh City 1 October aged 76. 
 In 1964 he became secretary-general of the National Liberation Front &mdash; the political arm of the Viet Cong &mdash; and thus officially the top communist leader in southern Vietnam, although more power was held by senior leaders from the north. 
 Following the Communist victory over the pro-American regime in 1975, Phat was named president of the short-lived Republic of South Vietnam. 
 When the republic was merged with North Vietnam in 1976 he became deputy prime minister. 
 In 1982 he was given the ceremonial post of vice-president. 
 Law Report: Representative defendant cannot claim contribution &mdash; Choudhury v Hussain. 
 Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Slade, Lord Justice Neill and Lord Justice Ralph Gibson), 26 September 1989 
 By YING HUI TAN, Barrister 
 Order 5, rule 5 of the County Court Rules 1981 (SI No 1687 (L20)) does not give the court jurisdiction to make an order for contribution in favour of a purported representative defendant against a member of the class which he was said to represent. 
 The Court of Appeal allowed an appeal by the appellant, who was not named as a party to the action, against an order that he was liable to pay &pound;861 with costs. 
 The plaintiff claimed damages of &pound;2,000 for wrongful dismissal in 1983 from his employment as a community worker at the Islington Asian Centre. 
 The only defendant named was sued as &bquo;General Secretary of the Management Committee of the Islington Asian Centre, sued on his own behalf and on behalf of the members of the management committee&equo;. 
 The centre was an unincorporated association run by its management committee. 
 In 1986 the plaintiff was awarded damages. 
 The judge found that six members of the management committee, including the appellant and the defendant, resolved to dismiss the plaintiff. 
 In 1988 the plaintiff applied for a charging order on the defendant's house in respect of damages, interest and costs. 
 The defendant applied for an order that the five other members of the management committee, including the appellant, be joined under Order 5, rule 5 as persons responsible to pay damages and costs to the plaintiff. 
 Each of the six members of the management committee was ordered to pay the sum of &pound;861. 
 When the appellant received notice of the order, he applied for the order to be set aside on the grounds that he had no notice of the proceedings and had nothing to do with it. 
 His application was dismissed. 
 The appellant appealed on grounds, not raised below, that the judge had no power under Order 5, rule 5 to entertain an application by the defendant for enforcement against the appellant of the plaintiff's judgment against the defendant and that any claim by the defendant against the appellant was statute barred. 
 Alan Bayliss (Chas J Nicholls) for the appellant; Simon Croall (Timmis Desai) for the defendant; the plaintiff was not present or represented. 
 LORD JUSTICE RALPH GIBSON said that neither the plaintiff nor the defendant applied to the court at any time before judgment for an order under Order 5, rule 5(2) appointing the defendant to represent all or any of the members of the management committee. 
 From that fact considerable difficulty had arisen. 
 If either had applied promptly, the appellant would have brought into the action at an earlier stage and the defendant would, in all probability, have been forced to give consideration then to the making of a claim to contribution in respect of his liability, if proved, to the plaintiff. 
 His Lordship accepted Mr Bayliss's submission that Order 5, rule 5 did not give power to make an order for contribution in favour of a representative defendant against a member of the class which he was named as representing; and that the only power it gave was that of giving leave to a person, in whose favour a judgment or order had been given or made, to enforce the judgment or order against a person not a party to the proceedings who was bound by the judgment or order. 
 Paragraph 5 of the rule was directed not only at enforcement of a judgment in favour of a claimant who had obtained judgment in his favour but also at preventing, by means of the principle of res judicata, relitigation of the same case by a person who was properly represented by a claimant against whom judgment had been given dismissing the claim, whether that person tried to pursue his claim against a named defendant sued in his own right only, or against a named defendant sued both personally and as a representative of a class, or against a member of that class. 
 The rule dealt with persons who had &bquo;the same interest in any proceedings&equo;. 
 It made no express reference to proceedings between a named representative of a class and a member of that class who might well have sharply different interests, as betweeen themselves, as to the substance of the plaintiff's claim. 
 Paragraph 5 referred simply to enforcement of a judgment or order against a person who, under the rule, was bound by it. 
 It did not purport to enlarge the class of persons who might enforce the judgment or order and there was no basis for attributing any such intention or effect. 
 There was no reason to suppose that in proceedings under Order 5, rule 5, it was intended to enable a named representative defendant to claim against a member of the represented class without complying with the requirements of the county court rules. 
 Accordingly the county court judge had no power under Order 5, rule 5 to make the order by which, on the defendant's application, the appellant was ordered to pay &pound;861. 
 As to whether the defendant's claim was barred by section 10 of the Limitation Act 1980, the defendant's right to claim contribution accrued on the date when the plaintiff was given judgment: 6 February 1986. 
 The defendant did not commence proceedings against the appellant until 7 March 1988. 
 The claim to contribution, being commenced more than two years after the date of the judgment, was out of time. 
 The claim was plainly within section 1 of the Civil Liability (Contribution) Act 1978 and was therefore caught by section 10 of the 1980 Act. 
 For the reasons above, Order 5, rule 5 provided no alternative basis of claim. 
 Accordingly if the defendant had commenced proceedings in which the court would have had jurisdiction to order contribution against the appellant, the claim would have been statute barred. 
 It was not necessary for the court to decide the issues raised on the ground that the judge was wrong to treat the proceedings as properly constituted representative proceedings, although the vital importance of the making of an application under Order 5, rule 5(2) promptly and before judgment was observed. 
 High Court fight by nuns &bquo;will decide fate of egg industry&equo; 
 By LIZ HUNT, Medical Correspondent 
 THE FUTURE of the egg industry rests on tomorrow's judicial review in the High Court of the case of 14 Northamptonshire nuns fighting to save 5,000 chickens, egg producers said yesterday. 
 If the judge rules in favour of the nuns it will call into question the Zoonoses Order 1989, which allows the Ministry of Agriculture to slaughter an infected flock. 
 One legal source says the ministry could face claims from hundreds of egg producers whose flocks have been slaughtered. 
 To date, 669,532 laying birds from 59 flocks have been slaughtered. 
 If this is allowed to continue it means the destruction of the British egg industry, according to United Kingdom Egg Producers' Association, which represents around 80 per cent of producers. 
 The nuns from the Our Lady of Passion Monastery at Daventry are seeking to block an order to slaughter one of their flocks, which is allegedly infected with Salmonella typhimurium. 
 The fundamental issue behind the arguments that will be heard is that the nuns are not permitted to see the results of the Ministry of Agriculture tests confirming the presence of infection. 
 There is no right of appeal within the law. 
 Under the Testing of Poultry Order 1989, egg producers must test birds who are 18 weeks or older once every two months. 
 Swabs are taken from up to 60 birds and five dead birds must be sent to a ministry laboratory for testing, at the producer's expense. 
 If salmonella is found, the producer is informed, a Zoonoses Order is issued banning the sale or movement of eggs from the farm, and ministry officials carry out further tests on the flock and the environment. 
 If the tests prove positive the flock is slaughtered. 
 A Disinfection Order is also placed on the premises and further testing carried out to ensure that it is salmonella-free. 
 Compensation is paid to the producer, a total of &pound;524,008 so far, which works out at about 78p a bird and is far from adequate, according the egg producers' association. 
 &bquo;For many farmers it spells financial disaster and few of the smaller ones have recovered. 
 Hundreds have gone out of business,&equo; Andy Oatley, the association's chairman, said. 
 All the egg producers wanted was a &bquo;fair hearing&equo; and to establish a workable framework for testing flocks and protecting public health. 
 The nuns claim that their eggs have never been associated with an outbreak of food poisoning, and although salmonella is present in the environment it is not necessarily in the eggs. 
 Since eggs became the focus for the food poisoning scare, the association has called for the testing of the eggs themselves to establish infection. 
 The ministry does not do this and no studies have been carried out. 
 There are more than 2,000 strains of salmonella. 
 The best known &mdash; because of their association with eggs &mdash; are Salmonella enteriditis and Salmonella typhimurium, which is alleged to have infected the nun's flock. 
 Professor James Duguid, former professor of microbiology at Dundee University, said yesterday that if salmonella is found in swabs taken from the hen house or in the chickens, it does not follow that the eggs are infected to a level that can cause food poisoning. 
 &bquo;It has been assumed that the eggs are contaminated too but the evidence is weak,&equo; he said. 
 Viewpoint: Seeking a fair deal on salmonella policy: Richard North, an environmental health adviser, presents the small egg producer's view of slaughtering to beat salmonella 
 By RICHARD NORTH 
 SALMONELLA is everywhere &mdash; in farms, domestic houses, people, birds, including seagulls and starlings, and in every type of warm-blooded animal. 
 There is even a type found in snakes. 
 To seek to eliminate it from the environment is impossible; a fact acknowledged by the Minister for Agriculture and his advisers. 
 It is also unnecessary. 
 The organism is a marginal pathogen, not normally transmissible person-to-person. 
 For illness to occur, salmonellas usually require a growth medium such as prepared food and exposure to warm temperatures for a prolonged period, to allow multiplication to their 100,000 to 100,000,000 cells which constitute an infective dose. 
 Against that background, the minister seems intent on wiping out salmonella, but only in the egg-laying flocks. 
 His action has already caused the premature death of 700,000 birds with miserly compensation to owners. 
 At the current slaughtering rate, the UK egg industry will be wiped out within 10 years. 
 It is that alarming situation which egg producers wish to address and which the battling nuns have brought into public focus. 
 Politically aware, Mother Catherine, 82 and mother superior at the Our Lady of the Passion Monastery in Daventry, Northamptonshire, has made the running, fully conscious from the start of her publicity value. 
 She has offered her plight as an example of what is happening to many small producers. 
 Far from being used by the producers, it is her insistence that there is no absolute link between salmonella in birds and its presence in eggs that has attracted supporters to her cause. 
 Running one of the UK's most technically advanced husbandry schemes, Sister Gabriel, her flock manager, who is a graduate biologist, is also adamant about the absence of risk. 
 And risk there is not. 
 Ten months after Edwina Currie raised the alarm as a health ministry Under-Secretary of State, researchers have not been idle. 
 The egg industry, in the form of United Kingdom Egg Producers' Association (Ukepra), has submitted a definitive proof to the Richmond Committee, under the umbrella of the Secretary of State for Health, Kenneth Clarke, saying intact eggs, consumed immediately after breaking, cannot cause food poisoning. 
 Even in the rare instance that salmonella is found in an egg, a phenomenon known since at least 1913, numbers detected are low; usually fewer than 10 organisms. 
 And tests on naturally contaminated eggs show multiplication cannot occur in an intact egg, not even in the yolk. 
 Statistical studies, such as that published recently in the British Medical Journal, show that there is no association between the consumption of lightly boiled eggs and illness. 
 Yet where egg products exposed to the risk of contamination are involved, such as mayonnaise, the association is extraordinarily strong. 
 An examination of the &bquo;Currie 49&equo; outbreaks shows that, while 53 per cent of their 1,000 egg-associated cases in 1988 were related to the salmonella strain enteriditis, more than 60 per cent involved mayonnaise. 
 All that shows beyond reasonable doubt that eggs were not responsible for the increase in food poisoning, which has gone up 36 per cent this year, despite an overall 24 per cent drop in egg consumption and the 700,000 birds slaughtered. 
 Evidence from Sweden, where enteriditis has never been found in a poultry flock, shows food poisoning in humans exactly matches the UK profile and, in percentage terms, is running at a higher rate. 
 This evidence was available to the chief veterinary officer last December but never given to the Select Committee. 
 Small wonder, therefore, that egg producers feel they are not getting a fair deal. 
 They believe that the current slaughter policy is a political expedient designed to allow ministers to show that they are doing something to curb food poisoning. 
 The measures have little relevance to public health. 
 The race is now on to show that the Government is wrong before the last bird in the UK is slaughtered. 
 Even now it might be too late: imports are rushing in to replace the shortfall. 
 Bank gives 500,000 pounds to sponsor arts fringe 
 By DAVID LISTER, Arts Correspondent 
 A RECORD sponsorship deal of &pound;500,000 for fringe theatre, dance and music companies was announced yesterday. 
 Barclays Bank is making the grant over a three-year period to encourage independent companies. 
 Peter Leslie, the bank's deputy chairman, said that fringe theatre should be admired as &bquo;the product development sector of the theatre industry&equo;. 
 Under the sponsorship terms, money will be provided for eight new productions a year to be performed for limited seasons at the Royal Court in central London. 
 Entries are invited from groups representing cabaret, dance, mime and puppet shows. 
 Community projects, children's theatre and stage productions of ethnic benefit will also be considered. 
 Applications for Barclays New Stages, as the project is called, must be in by 31 January. 
 A report examining the structure of arts funding is likely to be laid before Parliament next Wednesday. 
 The report, by Richard Wilding, former head of the Office of Arts and Libraries, is likely to recommend merging some regional arts organisations. 
 The regional arts associations want to see more decentralisation, but Richard Luce, Minister for the Arts, said that when Mr Wilding undertook his inquiry at the start of the year he was unhappy about the accountability of some regional arts associations. 
 Mr Luce was urged yesterday by Mark Fisher, Labour arts spokesman, to reopen the books on next year's arts grant to avoid widespread closures and cuts. 
 Delivering the Drew lecture on &bquo;Government and the Arts&equo; at the Central London Polytechnic, Mr Fisher pointed out that when Mr Luce announced three-year funding for the arts in November 1987, he had said the figure could not be reviewed &bquo;unless the situation changes substantially in ways that cannot be foreseen today&equo;. 
 Since the rise in inflation, which had seriously eroded the three-year funding, was unforeseen, Mr Luce should honour that commitment. 
 To recover ground lost since April 1988 will require a 10 per cent increase, he added. 
 Protester arrested in clashes at tree vigil 
 By DAVID LISTER, Arts Correspondent 
 ONE MAN was arrested and scuffles broke out yesterday as protesters battled to save a line of beech trees from being felled. 
 Peace was restored after the demonstrators, police and council leaders at Stroud, Gloucestershire, agreed to let a court decide the fate of the trees. 
 The scuffles broke out when more than 60 protesters began tearing down a fence while it was being erected by council contractors around the trees on a strip of land at Stafford Park. 
 Further clashes were averted after Mike Snell, the district council engineer, gave an assurance that the trees would not come down until the issue was resolved in court. 
 He said the fencing was being put up to deter trespassers. 
 The protest campaign was sparked by a council decision earlier this year to fell the trees &mdash; 10 beech, one scots pine and one yew &mdash; to make way for a road improvement scheme said to be needed for a new supermarket. 
 Protesters rallied against the decision and built treehouses from which to direct operations and protect the trees. 
 As workmen moved in to put up fencing yesterday, more demonstrators joined a small group of protesters who had been on a 24-hour vigil at the site. 
 Ron Birch, the protest leader, said they would accept the fence for the time being but would step up their campaign to protect the trees from a surprise attack by council workmen. 
 Cost of tunnelling raises doubt over Channel rail route 
 By COLIN BROWN and ROSIE WATERHOUSE 
 THE &bquo;HORRENDOUS&equo; cost of tunnelling in south London has driven Cecil Parkinson, the Secretary of State for Transport, to consider seriously an alternative route for the high-speed rail link to the Channel tunnel. 
 Mr Parkinson is concerned that the cost over-runs of the tunnel, which rose last month by &pound;1bn to an estimated &pound;7bn, could be repeated in the building of the rail link from Folkestone to London. 
 The costs of the preferred British Rail route have risen from &pound;1.7bn to between &pound;3.5bn and &pound;4bn partly because of extra tunnelling insisted upon by ministers after protests in south London and Kent. 
 Mr Parkinson is coming under heavy pressure from competing private consortia to approve an alternative route to a new terminus at Stratford in east London, which they say would be cheaper than the British Rail scheme to Waterloo and King's Cross. 
 If Mr Parkinson agrees, BR would have to abandon the private Bill it is planning to introduce in Parliament next month, to build the link. 
 It could cause further delays to the scheme, which has been fiercely opposed in Kent. 
 It was emphasised yesterday that Mr Parkinson has yet to reach a decision. 
 But it was confirmed he is concerned that the cost of tunnelling through south London could be &bquo;horrendous&equo;. 
 At least two consortia are lobbying Mr Parkinson to accept the Stratford route. 
 They say it would be cheaper because it would avoid the difficult tunnelling terrain of waterlogged sand and gravel which has prevented the building of Tube lines to much of south London. 
 One consortium includes the bank Manufacturers Hanover, and Bechtel, both American companies, with the contractors Laing and Mowlem, and Warburg, the merchant bank. 
 The costs of its route are claimed to be about &pound;2.5bn. 
 Another group is led by Ove Arup, which was among the original six contenders to build and finance the link in partnership with British Rail. 
 They claim they dropped out because of the increasing costs and argue their route would only cost about &pound;1.7bn. 
 But BR sources said that their independent survey showed that one alternative, known as the Talis route, would be more expensive. 
 They also pointed out that the alternative would not &bquo;plug into&equo; the east coast rail lines from King's Cross unless an expensive underground link was built from Stratford into central London. 
 Newham council, whose east London borough includes Stratford, wants the terminus in Stratford to revive the run-down area. 
 It has published a feasibility study by consultants to persuade Mr Parkinson to change the route. 
 But the BR source warned that there would be environmental objections to the alternative route, which would have to cut across other parts of Kent and marshes in Essex. 
 Two consortia &mdash; one led by P &amp; O and the other by Trafalgar House &mdash; are still bidding for partnership with BR, which is due to announce its choice by the end of the month. 
 Rumours have been circulating that both groups and BR say the link is not financially viable without government funds. 
 Ministers remain anxious that the Government could be brought under pressure to provide public funds, even though the Channel Tunnel Act expressly forbids the Government from providing any finance for the tunnel or the infrastructure needed to serve it. 
 As recently as two weeks ago sources close to Mr Parkinson ruled out changing the route at this late stage, saying it would revive uncertainty, antagonise people who had escaped the BR route, and cause an unacceptable delay to legislation. 
 Mr Parkinson will give no hint of his decision in the transport debate at the Conservative party conference in Blackpool today. 
 HIV cases &bquo;rising at rate of five per day&equo; 
 By CELIA HALL, Medical Editor 
 CASES OF people infected with the Aids virus, HIV, are now increasing at a rate of almost five a day, according to the latest government figures. 
 But it is publicly acknowledged that these numbers, which represent people who have put themselves forward for testing, are underestimates. 
 The Department of Health also said the 88 new Aids cases reported last month was the highest increase for some time. 
 The known number of HIV positive cases was 11,218 at the end of September, 424 more than the cumulative total at the end of the previous quarter. 
 But it is believed that between 50,000 and 100,000 people in this country, who are free of symptoms are likely to be carrying the virus. 
 Experience shows that 80 per cent of HIV cases will go on to develop Aids, on average within eight years. 
 The number of cases of developed Aids is now more than 2,649. 
 David Mellor, the Health Minister, warned last night that while still small, a &bquo;reservoir&equo; of infected heterosexuals was now established. 
 &bquo;The steadily increasing incidence of new reports of Aids in injecting drug users and in people infected heterosexually has been maintained in the third quarter of this year. 
 The number of drug users with HIV infection and of people infected heterosexually, continues to grow,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Although these groups presently account for only 7 per cent of Aids cases in the UK they represent a reservoir from which the spread into the general heterosexual population can occur. 
 This is a particularly worrying possibility and I urge everyone, homosexuals, heterosexuals and drug abusers to remember the risks and dangers of HIV infection.&equo; 
 Michael Adler, Professor of Genito-Urinary Medicine at the Middlesex Hospital, London, said the figures illustrated that the problem was not going away. 
 &bquo;The figures are a movable feast, but they show how important it is for anonymised prevalence testing to get under way so we can get a true picture of infection in the population.&equo; 
 A selection of the 36 classic sports and competition cars that are expected to fetch several million pounds at a Brooks auction during the London Motorfair 
 By CELIA HALL, Medical Editor 
 A selection of the 36 classic sports and competition cars that are expected to fetch several million pounds at a Brooks auction during the London Motorfair at Earl's Court on 26 October. 
 In the foreground, Mark Beattie, of Brooks, climbs out of a Porsche Carrera. 
 Alongside are two Austin-Healeys and a replica Frazer Nash  
 Prescott questions &bquo;cosy relationship&equo; over safety 
 By ANDY GLINIECKI 
 THE INDEPENDENCE of the body appointed to oversee Channel tunnel safety was questioned yesterday by John Prescott, Labour's transport spokesman. 
 He has received a leaked internal memo which he said indicates a &bquo;cosy relationship&equo; has been established between Safety Authority and Eurotunnel, the Anglo-French consortium that will own and operate the tunnel. 
 The memo originates from Eurotunnel. 
 According to Mr Prescott it indicates that &bquo;urgent advice&equo; was sought from Eurotunnel by Robert Bailey, secretary of Safety Authority, a panel of independent experts, on questions of safety raised by the MP. 
 They concerned the key issue of whether passengers should be separated from their cars on trains using the tunnel. 
 Mr Prescott said that the Safety Authority ought to have been able to answer the questions without reference to Eurotunnel. 
 The questions, which Mr Prescott also raised with Cecil Parkinson, the Secretary of State for Transport, and the Health and Safety Executive, centre on the &pound;600m order for rolling stock made earlier this year, although the issue of whether passengers should stay with their cars or be segregated had not been resolved. 
 Mr Prescott wanted to know why the order had been made before the Safety Authority was satisfied with the non-segregation procedure; whether the design was &bquo;open ended&equo; and could be adapted to separate passengers from their cars; and whether, by acting before getting firm permission from the authority, the order had been made entirely at Eurotunnel's own risk. 
 At the time, Eurotunnel said the contracts had been placed on the assumption passengers would stay with cars, but that the rolling stock could be altered, if required, by the Safety Authority. 
 Separating passengers would add time to the tunnel journey and some observers believe it could destroy any time advantage over ferries, putting a question mark over Eurotunnel's entire operation. 
 The memo, dated 23 August, states: &bquo;Robert would like urgent advice on how best to answer these questions. 
 He is of the opinion that Mr Prescott has probably given wide broadcast of these questions.&equo; 
 Mr Prescott said yesterday: &bquo;For the authority not to have been able to answer these sorts of questions, without going to Eurotunnel at that late stage when rolling stock had already been ordered, is totally unacceptable.&equo; 
 He added that he would be raising the matter in Parliament when it reconvenes. 
 The Safety Authority said last night that Mr Bailey was a Department of Transport official, in addition to being secretary to the authority. 
 He had been acting in his departmental role, gathering information for Mr Parkinson, when he contacted Eurotunnel. 
 Genetic engineering curbs tightened 
 By TOM WILKIE, Science Editor 
 THE SAFETY of genetic engineering is to be controlled more tightly by the Health and Safety Executive under new regulations laid before Parliament yesterday. 
 About 330 laboratories and industrial plants are involved in genetic manipulation work in the UK. 
 The new rules place a statutory duty on anyone who wants to alter the genetic structure of living creatures in the laboratory &mdash; or to use such organisms after they have been genetically engineered &mdash; to notify the executive well in advance so that it can assess independently the safety of the proposed activity. 
 The executive has been policing the safety of genetic engineering since the mid-1970s, but parts of the system were voluntary agreements rather than legal requirements and some parts have been overtaken by developments in the technology. 
 Richard Clifton, chief administrator of the executive's medical division, said the voluntary arrangements had worked well, but &bquo;voluntary arrangements are not enough. 
 They will not reassure the public&equo;. 
 Each proposal to carry out genetic manipulation was assessed on a case-by-case basis by an Advisory Committee on Genetic Manipulation, which had representatives of trades unions and employers as well as expert scientists, he explained. 
 Mr Clifton paid particular tribute to the work of the trades union representatives on the advisory committee. 
 Because the membership was so widely based, the UK had succeeded in establishing an &bquo;open, sensible and pragmatic structure for safety regulation&equo;. 
 The new rules still fall short of the &bquo;positive consent system&equo; proposed by the European Commission and agreed by the Council of Ministers last month. 
 To fulfil the terms of the European Directive, still tighter rules are expected to follow from the &bquo;green&equo; Bill the Government is expected to introduce. 
 Judge cautions jury over rape evidence 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 THE JUDGE hearing the case of the uniformed policeman accused of rape said yesterday it was &bquo;dangerous&equo; to convict upon the evidence of the alleged victim alone. 
 Mr Justice Jowitt told the jury that previously it had been shown in cases of alleged sexual misconduct that women may be tempted to exaggerate or fabricate. 
 &bquo;I am not saying she has been subject to a temptation to exaggerate, but I merely remind you of those matters which can exist in relation to a woman's evidence.&equo; 
 He told the jurors they should look for corroboration of the 18-year-old woman's claim that she had been attacked in the officer's marked police car. 
 The only corroborative evidence, he suggested, was the bruising to her arm and legs, which could have been caused by the exertion of force. 
 The judge was summing up at the end of the Old Bailey trial of PC Peter Anderson, 41, based at Surbiton police station in Surrey, who is accused of raping the woman on 4 April last year. 
 He admits having sexual intercourse with her but denies rape, claiming she instigated the act. 
 The judge said that the officer was not on trial for being a &bquo;faithless husband, womanising in his motor car or for breaching police regulations&equo;. 
 Mr Anderson was married and had a mistress at the time of the alleged rape, the jury has been told. 
 The jurors only had to consider whether the woman had consented or not to the intercourse taking place. 
 The woman has alleged that after agreeing to give her a lift home from a discotheque, the officer drove her to a deserted allotment, threatened her by pushing his truncheon under her chin and then raped her. 
 She claimed he then forced his fingers into her, causing pain and threatened to insert his truncheon &mdash; only stopping after she begged him not to. 
 She said she did not report the rape because he had destroyed her faith in the police force. 
 Earlier, Jean Southworth QC, for Mr Anderson, suggested that the woman had been &bquo;hoisted by her own petard&equo;. 
 Miss Southworth said the woman had made up the story to friends and was then forced to go through with it, after complaints were made to the police. 
 She claimed her client, with both a wife and mistress, &bquo;was not sex-starved&equo;. 
 Godfrey Carey, for the prosecution, told the jury that the young woman had &bquo;only taken a lift from someone in whose hands you could not really expect to be more safe &mdash; an officer in uniform&equo;. 
 That man, who was old enough to be her father, had &bquo;completely destroyed her trust,&equo; he said. 
 Aldington &bquo;hardened heart&equo; over fate of Cossacks 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 LORD ALDINGTON told a High Court libel jury yesterday that he and other British Army personnel &bquo;hardened our hearts&equo; when obeying orders to repatriate about 40,000 Cossacks at the end of the Second World War. 
 The former Brigadier Toby Low said that he had known many of the Cossacks would be tried and executed as war criminals by the Soviets. 
 &bquo;I did not make a fuss about it. 
 I got on and did my job,&equo; he said. 
 The peer, who is suing over allegations that he is a war criminal, described himself as a &bquo;human being and a good Christian&equo;. 
 He told Mr Justice Michael Davies and the jury he did not expect the Cossacks to be massacred without trial &mdash; the fate of many thousands. 
 Lord Aldington, who lives at Knoll Farm, Aldington, Ashford, Kent, is claiming libel damages over allegations in a pamphlet that he arranged the repatriation of around 70,000 Cossacks and Yugoslavs, knowing they would be massacred on their return. 
 Count Nikolai Tolstoy, 53, a historian and author, of Court Close, Southmoore, Abingdon, Berkshire, and Nigel Watts, of The Old Courtyard, Church Road, Tunbridge Wells, Kent, deny libel. 
 They claim the pamphlet is true, although they contest Lord Aldington's interpretation of it. 
 Cross-examined by Richard Rampton QC, for Count Tolstoy, on the eighth day of the libel trial, Lord Aldington told the court that he now considered the interests of the Cossacks had not been given a sufficiently high priority by the British Army and the War Cabinet. 
 But the Cossacks had been fighting for the Germans and the British Army's main concern in Austria in May 1945 was to comply with the Yalta agreement ordering repatriation so that the Russians would honour a promise to return British prisoners of war. 
 Mr Watts circulated 10,000 copies of the pamphlet among staff and parents of pupils at Winchester College, to old boys, MPs, Aldington villagers and the Press in March and April 1987 in an attempt to force Lord Aldington's resignation as college warden. 
 Count Tolstoy provided much of the information. 
 Lord Aldington, 75 and a former deputy chairman of the Conservative Party, is an ex-chairman of the Sun Alliance Insurance Group. 
 He has told the jury that he is the victim of a campaign of harassment by Mr Watts, who was annoyed by the company's failure to &bquo;pay out&equo; on the death of his brother-in-law. 
 Law Society warns over wider role for solicitors 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 THE Lord Chancellor, Lord Mackay, should ensure that judges cannot thwart plans to give solicitors rights of audience in the higher courts in England and Wales by adopting the framework of Scottish proposals, the Law Society urged yesterday. 
 The White Paper on changes to the Scottish legal profession published yesterday by Malcolm Rifkind, the Secretary of State for Scotland, says that once trained, Scottish solicitors should have unrestricted rights of audience in the higher courts, with the standard of performance achieved in training as the sole test. 
 Any rule directly or indirectly restricting solicitors' freedom to undertake all the actions necessary for the preparation and presentation of cases will need the approval of both the Secretary of State and the Lord President of the Court of Session. 
 But in what the Law Society also interpreted yesterday as a clear shift in emphasis from the English proposals, the paper makes it clear that the role of the Lord President would be no different from the one he currently exercises when approving training and professional rules. 
 Under the English White Paper, rights of audience rules drawn up by the Law Society in conjunction with an advisory committee will be subject to the &bquo;concurrence&equo; of four senior judges. 
 The society fears that the Bar and judges will exert subtle pressure to build in &bquo;case separation&equo; requirements. 
 The Master of the Rolls, Lord Donaldson, one of the four, told barristers recently that the interests of justice might require preparation and presentation of criminal, matrimonial and judicial review cases to be in separate hands. 
 The suggestion could mean that barristers would retain much of their monopoly over advocacy in the higher courts. 
 In their response to Green Papers earlier this year, a majority of judges suggested standards of conduct and competence might decline if lawyers who took instructions directly from clients (solicitors) were also allowed to present cases in court. 
 Fine Italian goblet found in cesspit 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A fifteenth-century gilded goblet (below) made of the finest Venetian glass has been discovered in a medieval cesspit west of the Tower of London, writes David Keys. 
 Unearthed by archaeologists from the Museum of London, the 10-cm high goblet which is almost intact, probably belonged to an Italian merchant. 
 The glass is only one millimetre thick, and is pale amethyst in colour. 
 It is covered with gold leaf into which is etched a pattern of oak and bay leaves &mdash; and a medieval North Italian inscription, the surviving words of which suggest that it said: &bquo;In this little goblet one often acquires happiness&equo;. 
 The goblet, which has no known exact parallel, was probably made in Murano, an island near Venice. 
 Correction: &bquo;Mail&equo; joins anti-Lawson chorus 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A statement on page two of The Independent yesterday, attributed to Charles Wilson, editor of The Times, saying that the Chancellor of the Exchequer should have let the pound drop lower, was in fact made by Sir David English, editor of the Daily Mail. 
 We apologise for the error. 
 Farmer killed 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A murder investigation was launched in Lancashire last night after James Parkinson, a retired farmer aged 82, died after a savage assault at his Staining home, near Blackpool. 
 Liver donor 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A possible donor liver was found last night which could save the life of Linda Prime, two. 
 She was at Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge, for assessment after an organ was located following an appeal. 
 Police inquiry 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 The Police Complaints Authority is going to investigate three complaints against officers involved in the Hillsborough football disaster which killed 95 people last April. 
 Dental closure 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A campaign to prevent the closure of Edinburgh's dental school ended in failure when the Universities Funding Council announced its intention to phase out the school's grant from next autumn. 
 It is expected to close in five years. 
 Murder charge 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A man aged 30 from Stourbridge, West Midlands, will appear before Worcester magistrates today charged with the murder of Elizabeth Page-Alucard, 41, a drugs counsellor. 
 Deadline set in Marchioness case 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 Lawyers representing the 51 who died when the Marchioness pleasure boat sank after being in collision with a dredger on the Thames, have given the owners of the vessels until tomorrow evening to agree to pay full compensation - estimated at between &pound;6m and &pound;7m. 
 If they refuse, the lawyers say they will begin proceedings in the High Court for damages. 
 Damages for injured nurse 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 A former nurse, hurt on duty and unlikely to work again, was awarded &pound;157,500 by Newcastle Crown Court yesterday for a serious back injury. 
 Deborah Fitzsimmons, 30, was injured at Hexham General Hospital eight years ago. 
 She and a student nurse were lifting a six-foot patient out of bed. 
 Mr Justice Brooke ruled that Northumberland health authority should have specified that three staff were necessary. 
 &bquo;This has got massive implications because back injuries are the most common suffered by nurses,&equo; Nupe, the union supporting the case, said. 
 Soviet &bquo;threat&equo; to 3bn pounds anti-tank missile projects 
 By MARK URBAN, Defence Correspondent 
 BRITAIN'S plans for a new generation of anti-tank weapons, involving projects costing more than &pound;3bn, could be thrown into turmoil after the discovery of new armour on Soviet tanks. 
 Ministry of Defence sources say that two of the Army's three new anti-tank missiles will be ineffective against the frontal armour of new Soviet tanks. 
 Warsaw Pact tanks have been fitted in recent years with additional armour, designed to explode when hit by an anti-tank missile, so neutralising its effect. 
 This is called reactive armour. 
 The Army's new anti-tank weapons are being designed with &bquo;tandem warheads&equo;; the first explodes reactive armour and the second penetrates the shell of the tank. 
 Now it has emerged that Soviet tanks are being fitted with two or three layers of the reactive armour, which probably renders the tandem warhead ineffective. 
 Les Aspin, a member of the US Congress and chairman of the powerful Armed Services Committee, said he had a &bquo;nasty surprise&equo; when he saw Soviet tanks fitted with the multi-layer reactive armour during a visit to the Ukraine in August. 
 In the latest Jane's Defence Weekly, he says this discovery &bquo;can't be anything but bad news to forces planning to defend against these tanks with current anti-tank weapons&equo;. 
 The Army is taking delivery of LAW-80, a short range anti-tank weapon costing &pound;400m. 
 But it cannot penetrate the frontal armour of new Soviet tanks, MoD sources say. 
 Britain is collaborating with France and West Germany, in a project called Trigat, to develop medium and long range anti-tank missiles. 
 The cost to Britain is &pound;780m and &pound;1.85bn respectively. 
 Medium range Trigat has been designed with a tandem warhead and is due to enter service in the mid-1990s. 
 It will be ineffective against the multi-layer reactive armour, experts say. 
 Long range Trigat is being designed to make a diving attack on the roof of a tank, where the armour is normally at its weakest. 
 Explosive reactive armour, which is fitted in box-shaped panels, has been fixed to the turret roof of modern Soviet tanks. 
 The long range weapon is not due to enter service until the late 1990s and may be delayed while scientists attempt to modify the warhead to defeat the multi-layered Soviet armour. 
 Further delays could have a serious effects on Army plans to introduce a fleet of gunship anti-tank helicopters, for which the long range Trigat is intended to be the primary weapon. 
 The MoD may be forced to incur further costs by buying another anti-tank missile as an interim solution until the long range Trigat is ready. 
 Some officers familiar with the medium range Trigat project are sceptical that it can be modified to defeat the new armour. 
 They believe Britain should pull out of the project and find another weapon to fill the same role. 
 Reactive armour has hardly any effect on the solid, armour-piercing rounds fired from tank guns. 
 The new development may strengthen, therefore, the case of those who back the early replacement of the Army's Chieftain tank fleet. 
 Mines are also still effective against Soviet armour as it is difficult to fix reactive armour under armoured vehicles. 
 Russians sold on peaceful cartoons 
 By MARK URBAN, Defence Correspondent 
 TRAMPY, PC BOOT and Margot the ballet shoe are about to become cartoon heroes of children in the Soviet Union, after the biggest publishing deal between East and West. 
 Fifty million copies of The Shoe People by James Driscoll have been sold to the Soviet Union as part of a three-year, &pound;16m deal which includes televison rights. 
 The animated film of the stories will be the first Western cartoon series to appear on Russian television. 
 Mr Driscoll created the cartoon characters as bedtime stories for his children, Adam and Holly. 
 After the children grew up, the stories remained in a drawer until three years ago when Mr Driscoll, who owned a mail order business, decided to publish them. 
 When he had difficulties finding a publisher, he formed Storm Publishing in Stourbridge, West Midlands. 
 The Shoe People has since been televised in 52 countries and has spawned a multi-million pound empire. 
 Mr Driscoll hopes to float the company on the Stock Exchange in December. 
 The &pound;16m contract is the biggest joint publishing link between the East and the West, with the prospects of further millions from merchandising. 
 But the deal has even greater cultural significance, as The Shoe People has been given the official stamp of approval to become a major influence on millions of Russian children. 
 Mikhail Polyakov, the First Secretary of the Soviet Embassy in London, said yesterday: &bquo;We welcome any new trade links between our two countries. 
 But it is excellent this type of agreement will create the spirit of co-operation at the earliest possible age.&equo; 
 Mr Polyakov was speaking at the Soviet Embassy School, where Russian schoolchildren had a preview of the books that will be available in the Soviet Union from next month. 
 Nastya Gorohova, 7, liked the pictures of the people &bquo;because they are funny. 
 Margot the ballet shoe is my favourite&equo;. 
 Natasha Kossov, the children's English teacher, believed The Shoe People would be a big success in the Soviet Union. 
 &bquo;They are very colourful and amusing characters. 
 They also have a very good message, they teach children to be kind and honest. 
 It is very important for our children to see your cartoons, which are a good first message of what Western children watch.&equo; 
 Mr Driscoll said the Russians liked the television series and books because of their &bquo;innocence and non-violent message&equo;. 
 He made the Eastern breakthrough via his Yugoslav publishers, who thought the non-violent message would be well received by Russians. 
 After showing the books to the leading Moscow publishers Mezhdunarodanaya Kaniga a joint publishing company, Yunona, was formed and a three-year contract signed. 
 The venture has the full support of the State Committee of the USSR for Publishing, Printing and Book distribution. 
 Speelman's blunder leads him into trap 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 THE Pilkington Glass World Chess Championship semi-finals will resume this afternoon at Sadler's Wells after a rest day yesterday. 
 Karpov and Yusupov, each of whom has used his sole permitted time-out, will be playing their fifth game. 
 Karpov leads by 2&frac12;&ndash;1&frac12;. 
 Timman and Speelman, without time-outs, are now up to game number seven. 
 Speelman lags 3&frac12;&ndash;2&frac12;, needing to win one of the two remaining games to force the match into extra time. 
 After a blunder in the opening of the sixth game, Speelman may feel lucky to be still in the match. 
 The first 13 moves were identical to those of the fourth game, then Speelman varied, capturing a black bishop with a knight instead of his pawn. 
 The next three moves were also known to theory, but Speelman fell into a trap with his 17th move. 
 IRA may have hidden Semtex 
 By TERRY KIRBY 
 THE cache of Semtex explosive and suspected bomb making equipment discovered on Hampstead Heath in London may have been hidden by an IRA cell for a bombing attack, it emerged yesterday, writes Terry Kirby. 
 As forensic scientists began examining the explosives and &bquo;terrorist paraphernalia&equo; found in two holdalls 50 yards from a main road, it was being suggested the bags may have been hidden, rather than dumped, more recently than first thought &mdash; possibly within the past weeks. 
 It is understood the holdalls contained about 80lb of Semtex. 
 The &bquo;terrorist paraphernalia&equo; is believed to include bomb making equipment but not firearms. 
 The cache could provide valuable clues in the hunt for the IRA cell responsible for the explosion at Deal barracks, Kent, last month, which killed 10 men, and links with explosions at Army barracks at Mill Hill, north London, and Tern Hill, Shropshire. 
 It is possible the explosives were left over from the Deal attack. 
 The Semtex can be compared with fragments from those incidents and that found in the bomb factory at Clapham, south London, last December. 
 Recovered wrappers and other manufacturer's signs can be useful in establishing explosives' movements. 
 Explosives found in jail shoes 
 By TERRY KIRBY 
 EXPLOSIVES smuggled in the soles of training shoes were to be used in an attempted daylight breakout by more than a dozen IRA men in a top security prison, it emerged yesterday. 
 Balls of Semtex &mdash; slightly bigger than Maltesers but powerful enough to blast away doors &mdash; were found in the shoe heels, which had been hollowed out and then bonded together again, security sources disclosed. 
 So far, about 6lb of Semtex, a number of rounds of ammunition and a loaded pistol have been found at Crumlin Road jail, Belfast. 
 About 4lb of Semtex was discovered rolled up and primed in a prison lavatory. 
 When the authorities learned of the attempt by the IRA to free key men from east Tyrone and south Derry last Saturday, all 570 inmates of the jail were ordered to remove their socks and shoes. 
 Security chiefs believe that terrorists on the outside were planning to fire at &mdash; and bomb &mdash; two rear lookout towers as part of the escape plan. 
 At the same time, between 12 and 14 IRA men selected to make the escape attempt were apparently preparing to blast an inside gate with some of the smuggled Semtex. 
 But the plan was foiled after a 750lb bomb &mdash; not 500lb as earlier reported - was found in the bucket of a JCB digger on a building site, and four hijacked and unoccupied cars, with keys in the ignition and driving licences behind the sun visors, were found in a street near by. 
 Most of the 570 prisoners at Crumlin Road are loyalists and republicans who are on remand and awaiting trial. 
 They are entitled to three visits and three food parcels a week and are allowed their own clothes, with one pair of shoes &mdash; usually trainers &mdash; supplied by relatives. 
 Employers to get new powers against unofficial strikes 
 By HELEN HAGUE, Labour Correspondent 
 EMPLOYERS ARE to be given new powers to isolate union members who take part in unofficial strikes through selective sackings. 
 Under proposals outlined in a Green Paper yesterday, unions will have to repudiate unequivocally any wildcat stoppages organised by any of their officials &mdash; or risk sequestration. 
 They must disown the action through writing to all members who could be affected. 
 Unions could also seek to &bquo;adopt&equo; the action by organising a strike ballot. 
 But unions would be effectively debarred from holding a strike ballot in support of workers already sacked for taking part in unofficial strikes. 
 This course of action would expose them to the prospect of mounting fines and eventual seizure of assets. 
 The new measures are aimed at curbing unofficial action, which last year accounted for 40 per cent of the days lost through strikes. 
 They are likely to be included in a new employment Bill, alongside measures to make all secondary action unlawful and abolish the pre-entry closed shop. 
 The Government has shied away from forcing unions to discipline members who take part in unofficial action, and has put proposals to curb strikes in essential services on the back burner. 
 The moves to stem wildcat stoppages, condemned by unions and the Labour Party and the independent Industrial Society &mdash; are thought to be the first time ministers have sought to legislate against the individual. 
 Changes to current restrictions on selective sackings and rehiring form a key plank of planned legislation. 
 Those sacked for wildcat strikes would lose their right to appeal against unfair dismissal to an industrial tribunal. 
 Unveiling the Green Paper, Norman Fowler, the Secretary of State for Employment, said unofficial action cost jobs and undermined Britain's international competitiveness. 
 He cited recent strikes by railway workers, London Underground staff, North Sea oil workers and steel erectors in central London to bolster the case for legislation. 
 Michael Meacher, Labour's employment spokesman, later branded the proposed measures as &bquo;another example of uncalled for interference in industrial relations for party political reasons&equo;. 
 He said: &bquo;Union bashing is always the first refuge of this government when it wants to distract attention from its mishandling of the economy. 
 Banning unofficial action will put individual workers entirely at the mercy of unscrupulous employers who will be able to dismiss them selectively on the slightest pretext, without any right of appeal.&equo; 
 He added that two of the unofficial disputes named by Mr Fowler &mdash; North Sea workers and steel erectors &mdash; were staged in protest at unsafe working conditions. 
 Alistair Graham, director of the Industrial Society, said the proposals were &bquo;misguided and counter-productive&equo;. 
 &bquo;After 10 years of employment legislation focused on what unions and their members may not do, the Government would do better to spell out the positive rights it believes trade union members are entitled to at the workplace.&equo; 
 Norman Willis, the TUC general secretary, said the UN-based International Labour Organisation had already condemned the Government's employment laws. 
 &bquo;Where strikes do occur it is usually because of a serious problem at work. 
 The important thing is to solve those problems rather than trying to drive grievances underground by a further set of hasty legislation.&equo; 
 6bn pounds deals &bquo;valid if illegal&equo; 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 TRANSACTIONS on the money market worth &pound;6bn undertaken by Hammersmith and Fulham Council may have to be honoured, even if ruled unlawful, it was suggested in the High Court yesterday. 
 John Chadwick, QC, counsel for four of the banks which stand to lose millions of pounds should the deals be ruled void, said enforceability depends on how they might be judged unlawful. 
 If the court found the west London council had no powers to undertake them whatsoever, then &bquo;the banks&equo; private rights' to enforce the deals would go. 
 However, if it were merely the scale of the transactions that was unlawful or that payments had been made out of the wrong fund, it may be the council could be forced to honour the contracts. 
 Using the analogy of company law, Mr Chadwick said there were many examples where contracts had been entered into that were ultra vires from the company's point of view but enforceable by third parties. 
 That was the position of the banks in this case. 
 He was opening the case for the banks on the sixth day of the application by the district auditor to have the transactions ruled ultra vires &mdash; beyond the council's legal powers. 
 Five banks: Midland; Security Pacific National; Chemical Bank; Mitsubishi Finance International and Barclays have been joined as respondents and Mr Chadwick represents all but Barclays. 
 He pointed out that when the council was barred from making further payments on the transactions, it had made a profit. 
 &bquo;The appeals which Anthony Scrivener (counsel for Hammersmith) made to safeguard the interests of the ratepayers are difficult to reconcile with the position actually shown on the accounts.&equo; 
 The council has not had to raise funds to make those payments and unscrambling the transactions would, he said, lead to ratepayers losing out. 
 He added that the council, which accepts the transactions were unlawful, was not concerned with the two years of accounts (1987-88 and 1988-89) at issue in the case but was seeking to ensure its future position. 
 Woman died after taking &bquo;ecstasy&equo; at acid house party 
 By JACK O'SULLIVAN 
 AN ACID house fan died when she collapsed in a fit and suffered liver failure after taking a single &bquo;ecstasy&equo; tablet, an inquest was told yesterday. 
 Collette Margaret McCarthy, 21, a receptionist, never recovered consciousness and, despite a liver transplant, died on 16 August, 16 days after taking the amphetamine-based hallucinogen, Southwark Coroner's Court in south London was told. 
 After the hearing, Dr Bernard Portmann, a pathologist from King's College Hospital, where Ms McCarthy was treated, said the case was &bquo;highly unusual&equo;. 
 Liver failure was not normally associated with amphetamines, which could induce fits and coma, he said. 
 The death suggested a possible previously unrecognised side-effect of ecstasy. 
 He agreed with warnings from Sir Montague Levine, the coroner, that the amount of ecstasy needed to induce an hallucinogenic state was very close to the fatal dose. 
 During the hearing, Sir Montague said that people trying the drug for the first time were in particular danger. 
 &bquo;I could say without doubt that this lady would have been alive today if she had not taken drugs at that party.&equo; 
 Sir Montague returned a verdict of death due to &bquo;non-dependent abuse of drugs&equo;. 
 Dr Portmann told the court that the post-mortem examination indicated all the signs of intoxication with amphetamines. 
 Ms McCarthy's liver had small drops of fat in it, normally found in children suffering Reyes syndrome. 
 She might have had an unknown liver defect or the symptoms were induced by the drug. 
 Ms McCarthy was out for the evening with a friend, Stacey Gallacher, when they heard that acid house partygoers were meeting on Clapham Common. 
 They were driven to the party in Peckham at about midnight. 
 Ms Gallacher, 20, a hairdresser, told the court that there were about 500 people at the party in a warehouse or old school. 
 &bquo;Some guys approached us and gave us one (tablet) each.&equo; 
 They did not have to pay the usual &pound;20 a tablet and both took one. 
 About 3am Ms McCarthy became ill. 
 &bquo;We were both dancing and then she sort of fell over and went into a fit. 
 I held on to her and called for help.&equo; 
 Ms Gallacher said that Ms McCarthy had tried ecstasy once or twice before but had never had a fit. 
 Apart from the single ecstasy dose, she believed she had drunk only a glass of wine that night. 
 After the hearing Ms Gallacher said: &bquo;People who go to acid house parties are getting younger and younger. 
 If the parties were drug-free they would be fine, but as soon as you go in you get offered drugs.&equo; 
 Last March, an acid house partygoer in Surrey collapsed and died after taking two ecstasy tablets. 
 Air crashes lead disaster teams to review tactics 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 (First Edition) The first international conference to discuss openly air disaster contingency plans was told yesterday that the recent spate of major incidents, including the Lockerbie and Kegworth tragedies, has led to a review of emergency tactics. 
 The police, fire brigades, ambulance workers and rescue services, including the RAF and other military branches, are now working in far closer contact. 
 Plans cater for both an immediate accident and the long-term care of individuals who survive or are caught up in the disaster &mdash; including the rescuers. 
 More than 250 delegates from 19 countries are at the Cranfield international emergency management conference at Castle Donington, near Loughborough &mdash; not far from the scene of the Kegworth crash in January. 
 The Cranfield Institute of Technology is mainly engaged in post-graduate teaching and research and has a disaster preparedness centre at the Royal Military College of Science. 
 It is the first time aviation experts and the rescue services have held a joint conference on the importance of working together. 
 There is also a need for joint detailed pre-planning for disasters. 
 John Rolfe, conference chairman, said: &bquo;People within the industry have known for some time there is a need for such a gathering. 
 This is the largest and most comprehensive of its kind and does address the very real problems people have to cope with in the event of a major disaster.&equo; 
 The conference was told yesterday that police forces have introduced a new command structure. 
 Chief Supt Ian Herd, head of territorial operations within the Metropolitan Police, said that, given changes in technology and equipment, there had been a clear need to review policies which involve local emergency services responding to an incident and police co-ordinating operations. 
 The Government has announced it will appoint a civil emergencies adviser with a small team geared towards encouraging multi-disciplinary planning. 
 Mr Herd said police forces were using a new command structure with one senior officer, referred to as &bquo;gold&equo; overseeing strategy for any big operation. 
 A second senior ranking officer, codename &bquo;silver&equo;, would ensure the police response was implemented correctly and co-ordinated. 
 Finally &bquo;bronze&equo; officers would be responsible for post-disaster operations. 
 The conference also heard detailed evidence yesterday on the more disturbing, but necessary, work of body identification. 
 The conference heard that out of 732 post-mortem examinations &mdash; on victims of the Air India Boeing which crashed into the Atlantic near Cork, Zeebrugge, Piper Alpha, Lockerbie and Kegworth &mdash; 80.22 per cent of identifications had been through dentistry records. 
 The psychological consequences of an air disaster were discussed by Claire Marrison, of the Applied Psychology Unit at Cranfield Institute of Technology. 
 She said that, contrary to popular opinion, traumas caused by such a disaster were not short-lived. 
 Estate charges 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 (First Edition) Nine men arrested during a police raid on the Broadwater Farm housing estate in north London were remanded on bail by Haringey magistrates on charges ranging from assault to threatening behaviour and obstruction. 
 Birds in danger 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 More than a third of Britain's bird species need urgent protection, according to a report by the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds. 
 It lists more than 40 endangered species &mdash; including the golden eagle, bittern, red kite, corncrake, barn owl, nightjar and Dartford warbler. 
 Tube assault 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 Victoria Carrington, 23, of Northolt, west London, a convent-educated stockbroker who attacked a mother and daughter on an Underground train after they knocked into her newspaper was fined &pound;400 by Knightsbridge magistrates and ordered to pay &pound;600 compensation after being found guilty of assault. 
 Two jailed for cliff death plot 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 James Palmer, who bungled an attempt to push his neighbour over a cliff in Exmouth, Devon, was jailed yesterday by Bristol Crown Court for 10 years. 
 James Shaw was given five years for his part in a later plot to kill Stephen Brown by knocking him down with a car. 
 He was found guilty of conspiracy to murder but not guilty of attempted murder. 
 Palmer, 43, a painter, had earlier admitted attempted murder. 
 The jury was told the men were to be paid &pound;1,000 each with &pound;500 expenses by Mr Brown's wife to kill him. 
 M50 accused &bquo;seen with lost knife&equo; 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 A NIGHTCLUB bouncer accused of murdering Marie Wilks asked for a cloth to clean his car hours after her disappearance, then asked to keep the cloth, a court was told yesterday. 
 Irene Jaffray said at Shrewsbury Crown Court that Eddie Browning made the request to her when he arrived at the house she shared with Kerry Evans in Inverurie, Aberdeenshire. 
 He had travelled there from his home in Cwm-parc, Mid Glamorgan. 
 The jury was told earlier that after Mr Browning, 36, arrived at the house a thick smudge of blood was seen on his Renault 25. 
 The prosecution alleges that en route to Scotland, Mr Browning abducted and killed Mrs Wilks, 22, who was pregnant, after he saw her making an emergency phone call on the hard shoulder of the M50. 
 She was found with a knife wound in her neck. 
 Clare Evans, 18, of Barry, South Wales, told the jury that Mr Browning took a splinter out of her hand with a butterfly knife on 16 June last year, two days before he is alleged to have killed Mrs Wilks. 
 She was outside her father's social club at Pentre, South Glamorgan, where Mr Browning worked as a bouncer. 
 John Griffith Williams QC, for the defence, said: &bquo;I'm suggesting you saw the knife a week earlier.&equo; 
 Miss Evans replied: &bquo;I'm sure it was that date.&equo; 
 Anthony Palmer QC, for the prosecution, has alleged that Mr Browning told police he had &bquo;misplaced&equo; his knife about three weeks before the killing. 
 Canadian tribes people delivering petition to Canada House, London 
 By MALCOLM PITHERS, Northern Correspondent 
 Innu Indians Simon Michel and Mary-Ann Michel, delivering a petition to Canada House, London, yesterday, protesting at noise and pollution from low-flying Nato aircraft over the Labrador-Quebec peninsula which they say is threatening their survival by killing the animals they hunt. 
 The tribe is one of the last hunter-gatherer cultures in North America  
 Students win abortion case 
 From ALAN MURDOCH in Dublin 
 THE SOCIETY for the Protection of Unborn Children yesterday failed in its attempt to bar 14 Irish Republic students' union leaders from giving information on abortion facilities in Britain. 
 After a two-day hearing in the Dublin High Court, Miss Justice Carroll referred the matter to the European Court of Justice. 
 The society is appealing against the ruling to the Irish Supreme Court. 
 In a related case, four Trinity College Dublin student leaders were cleared of contempt after the society sought to have them jailed for alleged breaches of an earlier injunction restricting distribution of literature on abortion services. 
 Miss Justice Carroll said newspaper reports of the students' activities did not represent prima facie evidence of a breach. 
 She also refused an application by the society for sequestration of the funds and assets of Trinity Students' Union. 
 Mary Robinson SC (Senior Counsel), for the students, had said they claimed a right under European law to provide information on services available legally in another EC member state. 
 She asked the court to refer to the European Court the question of whether Article 59 of the EC Treaty could be taken as meaning that a member state could bar the giving of information in its territory about services in another member state that were illegal in the first country. 
 She also raised the question of whether such a bar obstructed the freedom to provide services under Articles 59 and 66 of the Treaty and Article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, guaranteeing the right to give and receive information. 
 James O'Reilly SC, for the society, said SPUC would prefer the students not to be jailed. 
 But he claimed they were well aware they were breaking the law and were prepared to face the consequences. 
 He argued there were provisions in the Single European Act which ensured that member states could not be obliged to accept abortion services if they did not wish to have them. 
 Insulin safety reviewed 
 From ALAN MURDOCH in Dublin 
 BRITAIN'S official drug safety committee is reviewing warnings to diabetics after deaths of patients taking insulin from human rather than animal sources. 
 The Committee on the Safety of Medicines wants to see if warnings issued this year are adequate, the Department of Health said last night. 
 The concern comes after a reported increase in deaths of diabetic patients, most relying on genetically engineered human insulin. 
 It is thought that form of insulin may not always give vital warnings of low blood sugar, such as hunger or sweating, and that patients may be at increased risk of slipping unawares into a coma. 
 Confirmation of the official safety review came after a n investigation by Channel Four television into the deaths of patients. 
 Those switching to human insulin were alerted this year to reduce the dose by 10 per cent, and the need for careful monitoring was emphasised. 
 The safety review is in consultation with the British Diabetic Association. 
 The Conservative Conference: Pensioners &bquo;caught in poverty traps&equo; 
 By JUDY JONES 
 THOUSANDS of pensioners have missed out on the prosperity brought about by Margaret Thatcher's administration and remain caught in &bquo;massive poverty traps&equo;, the conference was told yesterday. 
 Sid Cordle, of the Yorkshire Conservative Trade Unions, protested that the basic state pension of &pound;46.60 a week for a single person and &pound;69.80 for a couple was totally inadequate. 
 Despite the spread of private pensions, 75 per cent of pensioners lived on less than &pound;3,500 a year. 
 He said the Thatcher years would be seen as the time &bquo;in which existing pensioners missed out on the prosperity afforded to the great majority in this country. 
 Pensioners have not fared better than other groups and targetting has led to massive poverty traps&equo;. 
 Mr Cordle was applauded as he demanded the abolition of standing charges for pensioners on gas, electricity and telephone bills as a first step towards helping them. 
 However, Tony Newton, the Secretary of State for Social Security, defended the Government's record. 
 Benefits increases for the worst-off pensioners aged over 75, or disabled, had come into effect this week and the earnings rule restricting eligibility for pensions had been abolished. 
 &bquo;These measures have added nearly another &pound;600m a year to the support we give to those over retirement age. 
 There could be no more concrete evidence of our commitment to that group.&equo; 
 Mr Newton made no mention of the future of child benefit, which the Government has frozen for each of the last two years years at &pound;7.25 a week. 
 But he confirmed that the Government plans to changes the rules covering attendance allowances to increase the number of those terminally ill who can claim it. 
 At present, patients are prevented from receiving the benefit for the first six months of a terminal illness. 
 The conference heard an appeal from a wheelchair-bound representative to enable the disabled to run their lives more independently. 
 Jonathan Hastings-Day, vice-chairman of the Conservative Disability Group, said the disabled should be able to buy the services they need from privately run agencies: &bquo;I am sick to death of social workers sitting around having case conferences. 
 We must move away from local authorities&equo; services. 
 Schools are being given the chance to run themselves, and hospitals are being given that chance. 
 &bquo;Why the hell should disabled people not be given the chance to run things themselves?&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: MacGregor in plea for teachers not to strike 
 By JUDY JONES 
 TEACHERS were urged by John MacGregor, the Secretary of State for Education, yesterday not to disrupt classes with strikes next year in their pay campaign. 
 The &pound;600m earmarked for their salaries was 55 per cent more than the amount set aside this year, he said. 
 The teachers' public image had been badly damaged by the &bquo;posturings of a few&equo; in the strikes two years ago. 
 &bquo;It is important for their standing as a profession that such antics by the few are never repeated. 
 After all, teachers&equo; pay rose by only 6 per cent after inflation under Labour. 
 It has risen by 30 per cent in our period of office.&equo; 
 Mr MacGregor also defended the Government's plans to introduce top-up student loans next autumn. 
 The move would bring Britain into line with most developed countries. 
 &bquo;A broader base of funding has to be found if we are to achieve the increased access to higher education we seek.&equo; 
 The minister disappointed some supporters when he confirmed the Government had abandoned plans for legislation to curb the activities of the National Union of Students. 
 To include that issue in the forthcoming Student Loans Bill would make the measure hybrid and deny it any prospect of a swift passage through Parliament. 
 But he remained concerned over the claims of the NUS to speak behalf of individual students on political matters and the &bquo;no platform&equo; policies operated by certain local unions that challenged the principle of free speech. 
 Earlier, Alex Aitken, of the Conservative Collegiate Forum, was loudly applauded when he said it was &bquo;intolerable&equo; that taxpayers should have to fund the left-wing propaganda of the NUS. 
 &bquo;Unless the Government acts to free students from this sort of red fascism, then all the words of the Education Reform Act will have been in vain.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Howe echoes Heseltine in urging an &bquo;energetic&equo; boost for manufacturing 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 SIR GEOFFREY HOWE, the deputy prime minister, yesterday joined Michael Heseltine in urging &bquo;energetic&equo; action to bolster manufacturing industry. 
 In a conference fringe speech which appeared to set out his own personal manifesto, the Leader of the Commons also echoed Mr Heseltine's views on the need to take a more positive attitude to the European Community, and he called for a moderation of the Government's confrontational style. 
 But the most remarkable section of Sir Geoffrey's address to a meeting organised by the Conservative Bow Group &mdash; an influential Tory centre grouping &mdash; dealt with the trade deficit. 
 Michael Heseltine said on Tuesday that Nigel Lawson was wrong to dismiss the deficit as a minor matter &mdash; something which he said smacked of &bquo;socialist naivety&equo;. 
 Speaking as a minister, Sir Geoffrey was less robust, but his message was similar: although the deficit was &bquo;not all bad news&equo;, it did &bquo;identify that part of our economic performance and vitality which most needs to be strengthened&equo; &mdash; manufacturing industry. 
 &bquo;Manufacturing must be seen to matter,&equo; Sir Geoffrey said. 
 That did not mean Labour-style intervention, but he added: &bquo;I do visualise and urge the energetic use of existing agencies and resources, private and public sector alike, to give potentially fruitful initiatives a helping hand.&equo; 
 His text cited the success of the Welsh Development Agency and Scottish Enterprise, government-backed bodies, in pump-priming inward investment. 
 Mr Heseltine has long advocated an extension of such agencies to other British regions, and Sir Geoffrey's new-found support could signal Cabinet debate on industrial policy &mdash; an issue which has been omitted from this week's conference agenda. 
 Sir Geoffrey said Britain needed to adopt a less fearful and inhibited approach towards the EC; arguing that sustained economic recovery depended to a significant degree on an ability to shape Community policies. 
 &bquo;That means that for economic as well as for political reasons, we need to make certain that our power to influence Europe's future is as great as can be,&equo; he said. 
 But he added: &bquo;It is not evident that most of our partners often perceive us in the same constructive light as we see ourselves.&equo; 
 As for government style, Sir Geoffrey warned that in spite of Margaret Thatcher's revolution there was a pervading temptation for the country to revert to its &bquo;besetting sin&equo; of complacency. 
 Political persuasion was required to keep up the political momentum, and given the changing age profile of the electorate &mdash; many of whom had not been adults a decade ago &mdash; Sir Geoffrey warned: &bquo;We've got to choose the style to match the mood of Britain.&equo; 
 He said the Conservatives had to win a reputation for being &bquo;a listening party&equo;, showing a willingness, where necessary, &bquo;to reappraise&equo;. 
 The party had to show that it was good &bquo;not just at winning battles, but at winning arguments and friends&equo;. 
 Sir Geoffrey said that at Labour's Brighton conference last week, hope had been nurtured that the Thatcher generation of voters, &bquo;like youngsters offered a sickly-smelling cigarette at a party, will experiment as their elders did with the notion that Labour knows best. 
 &bquo;We must be sure that they are alive to the evidence here, no less than in the East, that socialism does not work.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Parents to pay for crimes of children 
 By JOHN PIENAAR 
 PARENTS who fail to prevent their children committing crimes are to face heavy financial penalties, under legal changes foreshadowed by Douglas Hurd, the Home Secretary, yesterday. 
 Courts will weigh parents' financial means in imposing fines and compensation, and they will be ordered to attend court hearings, he told the conference. 
 The measures to enforce &bquo;parental responsibility&equo; will be included in a wide-ranging criminal justice White Paper in the next parliamentary session. 
 Legislation is planned for 1990-91. 
 &bquo;The family is our first defence against crime,&equo; the minister said. 
 &bquo;For too long in this country we have pushed parental responsibility into the sidelines. 
 &bquo;But it is more important than anything else to bring parental responsibility back to the centre of the stage.&equo; 
 The law, he said, &bquo;should reinforce the principle that parents have a responsibility for the actions of their children.&equo; 
 The means-tests would be accompanied by powers to bind-over parents to prevent their children from offending and to &bquo;hit them in the pocket if they don't&equo;. 
 Mr Hurd's response to the debate on law and order, always a difficult test for Conservative Home Secretaries, was markedly well received and ended to a standing ovation. 
 Calls for the restoration of the death penalty were applauded loudly, but did not dominate the event as in past years. 
 The warmth of his reception stemmed in part from a pledge, based on recent spending negotiations with Norman Lamont, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, to increase uniformed police manpower by a further 1,100 next year. 
 Mr Hurd also outlined proposals to establish Home Office teams in areas at risk from the spread of the drugs crack and cocaine. 
 They would co-ordinate the work of government and council agencies, local businesses, churches and voluntary groups. 
 Nine would be set up in areas to be announced shortly. 
 And John Patten, the Home Office Minister of State told reporters later that a further 11 would follow. 
 On sentencing, the Home Secretary confirmed plans to publish detailed guidelines to courts. 
 &bquo;Our sentencing system has become muddled, and many of our fellow citizens lack the confidence which they should have in the decisions of our criminal courts. 
 Too often, people think that the sentence by a court is not proportionate to the crime committed and the sentence actually served is too different from the sentence passed.&equo; 
 Serious and violent offenders should receive &bquo;long stays&equo; in prison, and the parole authorities should &bquo;make the protection of the public their first and overriding prison concern.&equo; 
 During the debate, there were repeated calls for tougher sentencing and more resources to buttress law enforcement, tempered with praise for new powers to challenge &bquo;over lenient&equo; court decisions. 
 &bquo;For too long some judges have appeared to be out of touch,&equo; Edward Hess, of the Conservative Lawyers, said. 
 But some speakers emphasised the importance of crime prevention, community liaison and education. 
 Kevin McKenna, from Manchester Wythenshaw, said: &bquo;No industry has failed as comprehensively as the prison industry. 
 What we need are new ideas to prevent re-offending.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Patten sets state role as guardian of environment 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 CHRIS PATTEN, Secretary of State for the Environment, yesterday steered further away from the philosophy of his predecessor, Nicholas Ridley, and emphasised the need for state regulation to protect the countryside. 
 In a key speech to the Blackpool conference, Mr Patten announced the immediate withdrawal of proposals to relax planning controls over rural land use. 
 Conservationists had protested that Mr Ridley's plans for broadening economic activity on farmland could lead to a rash of theme parks, shopping developments and housing estates. 
 The Secretary of State paved the way for the greening of all Whitehall departments through a White Paper to be published next year and set a target on the recycling of household waste. 
 The aim should be to re-cycle half of the 18 million tonnes of domestic rubbish produced in Britain each year within the next 10 years. 
 &bquo;It's for government to regulate on behalf of the community, to set the standards and environmental goals,&equo; Mr Patten said &mdash; a statement that would have jarred on his predecessor, and, until recently, on the party faithful. 
 &bquo;We must harness market forces and the market place to prevent pollution, to change the sort of conduct that degrades the nation's resources, and to find the most efficient and effective ways of delivering environmental quality.&equo; 
 Planning was a form of regulation to enhance quality of life. 
 The environment debate showed conference representatives concerned about unsuitable housing development in the countryside, freeing derelict land in the cities, and litter. 
 One young representative, Colin Mason, a computer systems manager from Streatham, who branded environmental controls as &bquo;socialism by the back door&equo;, was gently advised by the Secretary of State to read the Tory philospher Edmund Burke. 
 Mr Mason had criticised Mr Patten's stand against the proposed new town at Foxley Wood, Hampshire. 
 &bquo;We must still trust the market at the end of the day. 
 I don't want restrictions; I don't want controls,&equo; Mr Mason said. 
 But Mr Patten told him good government should be founded on fact, not fantasy. 
 &bquo;The greatest of Tories, Edmund Burke, reminded us of our duties as trustees for the nation, as good stewards of its traditions, its values and its riches. 
 A nation, wrote Burke, is a partnership between the past, the present and the future. 
 So let there be no doubt. 
 Just as there is an overwhelming moral argument for prudent management of the economy, so there is an overwhelming ethical argument for prudent management of the environment.&equo; 
 Filling in more detail on the Environment Protection Bill for the coming session of Parliament, Mr Patten said the public would be given more access than ever before to information about industrial pollution and about how individual firms would be obliged to clean up their operations. 
 Fines for litter louts will go up from a maximum of &pound;400 to &pound;1,000. 
 Local authorities will have a duty to keep the streets clean, on pain of being taken to court by members of the public. 
 The Bill will also place a duty on councils to include re-cycling in their waste disposal plans. 
 Of the 18 million tonnes of household waste produced annually, only 2.7m tonnes is treated or re-used. 
 &bquo;We want industry to cut down on its own waste and make better use of other people's. 
 We should aim to re-cycle half our household waste within 10 years.&equo; 
 Turning to the White Paper, to be published before the next party conference, he said it would set out the Conservatives' agenda for the rest of this century. 
 Mr Patten said the Government wanted to tighten agreements already reached towards ending the depletion of stratospheric ozone. 
 &bquo;We intend to work just as creatively to negotiate a convention on climate change &mdash; a framework of action for the nations of the world. 
 We can then fit into the convention binding agreements on subjects like energy efficiency and forestry, as the science and the political will come into balance.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Government heeds warnings on poll tax 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 TORY councillors at Blackpool yesterday left the Government in little doubt about the need for the &pound;1.3bn package of concessions to ease the introduction of poll tax. 
 Shortly before David Hunt, Minister of State for the Environment, announced drastic changes in the &bquo;safety net&equo; arrangements to the conference, he was warned once again that poll tax payers in prudent council areas should not have to subsidise the profligate. 
 &bquo;Let the mud stick where it belongs,&equo; Peter Skolar, leader of the Conservative group on Labour-controlled Camden Council, said in the local government debate. 
 &bquo;Don't remove the accountability of Camden to their public, allowing them to blame all their ills on the Government.&equo; 
 The safety net is supposed to cushion the impact of the change from rates to poll tax next April. 
 But Mr Hunt told the conference that, instead of phasing the system out over four years, the cross-subsidy from gainers to high-spending areas which lose would be abolished after the first year. 
 &bquo;So the gainers will then get their gains in full. 
 The protection for losing authorities (for the following three years) will be paid for by the Exchequer,&equo; Mr Hunt said, answering a demand for central funding repeated in the debate. 
 The concession will save contributor areas a total of &pound;685m over the three years. 
 &bquo;We listened. 
 You were right, and we have acted,&equo; the minister said. 
 Typical of the complaints had been that of David Fletcher, a Wirral councillor, who said his constituents &bquo;objected most strongly to subsidising the extravagancies of hard-left councils like Liverpool&equo;. 
 Mr Hunt also announced a three-year transitional relief scheme for individuals &mdash; costing &pound;300m next year &mdash; to protect ratepayers who face the largest increases in the change. 
 It takes the total cost of the package for Britain to at least &pound;1.3bn. 
 &bquo;This new scheme will ensure that, where local authorities spend at a sensible level, no ratepayer or ratepaying couple anywhere in the country will be more than &pound;3 a week worse off when the community charge is introduced,&equo; he said. 
 Pensioners and the disabled would be singled out for special treatment, whether they paid rates or not. 
 Sufferers from Alzheimer's disease were to be exempt from the tax &mdash; a concession which opposition parties had fought for. 
 Clive Condie, of Hazel Grove, warned that the unpopularity of a system, under which his area subsidised high-spending neighbours like Labour Rochdale, could cost the Conservatives marginal seats like Hazel Grove. 
 &bquo;The community charge is brilliant. 
 But the arrangements for funding the safety net are not,&equo; Mr Condie said. 
 &bquo;It is wrong that residents of prudent spending areas should cross-subsidise the profligate.&equo; 
 Eric Pickles, leader of Bradford Council, cautioned that it took time to get budgets under control. 
 In some cases it was going to take years. 
 &bquo;We need to give decent people a chance to elect a sensible council.&equo; 
 Murdo Fraser, of Scotland Young Conservatives, urged the party to heed the lesson of Scotland where the poll tax was &bquo;universally reviled&equo; and the electoral position of the Tories &bquo;nothing short of disastrous&equo;. 
 Though he supported the poll tax, in operation in Scotland since April, party activists had not been equipped to fight for it. 
 They had not been given details of the legislation and so were unable to counter opposition scaremongering. 
 The Conservative Conference: Conference quotes 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 &bquo;It's 24-hour drinking here. 
 Why the hell do you think we come?&equo; &mdash; Blackpool woman representative queuing to enter the conference headquarters hotel in the small hours &bquo;I'm bound to say that when considering some examples of modern architecture I enthusiastically join those who say, &bquo;God bless the Prince of Wales&equo;.' 
 - Chris Patten &bquo;I have spoken four or five times at party conferences and people always laugh at everything I say. 
 And I'm trying to be serious today.&equo; 
 &mdash; Norman Hazell, Wakefield councillor &bquo;It is not wise to expect to have immediately all the material possessions you might covet. 
 It is rewarding to work and save over time to earn them.&equo; 
 &mdash; John MacGregor, Secretary of State for Education &bquo;Every Conservative candidate will be able to say on every voter's doorstep, &bquo;I can save you money&equo;. 
 And this means that every council in the country could be a Conservative council.&equo; 
 &mdash; David Hunt, Minister for Local Government Today the conference will debate economic policy and taxation, farming and food, defence, European Community and foreign affairs, transport, and Sunday trading. 
 The Conservative Conference: Hostile shadows loom over haven from reality 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 KENNETH BAKER'S brave vision of Agincourt is each day looking more like an avant-garde film version of the Little Big Horn. 
 In perfect keeping with the genre, the encircling savages turned up whooping yesterday in bizarre fancy dress. 
 Hostile forces seemed to be everywhere in Blackpool, emerging from the sea and even, in the case of Rowan Atkinson, from inside a television set. 
 As the Tory faithful trumpeted their green credibility in the Winter Gardens, Ann Taylor, the Labour environment spokeswoman, was on Blackpool beach amusing photographers and terrifying holidaymakers by paddling in the shallows in a white laboratory coat and protective wellingtons. 
 Specimen jar of sea water in hand, she cheerfully highlighted the embarrassing prospect of European Court prosecutions over the pollution of nearby pleasure beaches. 
 &bquo;We won't let them sit back and talk amongst themselves, as if everything in the garden is rosy,&equo; she explained earnestly. 
 &bquo;From now on, up to the election, it is one long campaign.&equo; 
 An attendant Labour press officer mumbled: &bquo;We're shameless aren't we?&equo; 
 He had been seen earlier dodging the massed constabulary around the Winter Gardens, thrusting Labour press releases into the hands of reporters queuing for their body searches and radar scans. 
 For the first time in memory, the conference press room telephones have been besieged by warlike members of the Shadow Cabinet, volunteering a stream of unsolicited scorn in advance of successive ministerial speeches. 
 Around the conference centre, the party rocks on with blithe disregard for the economic and political turbulence beyond. 
 Watching the happy, milling crowd at the conference, one Tory MP muttered: &bquo;It's a good tribal rite, but it doesn't have much to do with reality.&equo; 
 Even Sir Geoffrey Howe unwittingly contributed to the general impression, as he addressed the Bow Group from an Opera House stage set for a performance of Cats. 
 It was, he said, a &bquo;good time for us as Conservatives to think afresh about the direction of British politics; about where we have come from, what we are doing, and where the future is taking our nation and our party.&equo; 
 The deputy prime minister seemed oblivious throughout to the vivid backdrop of broken bicycle wheels and overflowing rubbish bins. 
 At another fringe-meeting, Rowan &bquo;Blackadder&equo; Atkinson led a measured onslaught against the Government's proposals for the future of broadcasting. 
 His own contribution was sober and only occasionally spiced with alternative wit. 
 There was no attempt to liken any Conservative minister, or downtrodden Chancellor, to Baldrick or anyone else. 
 But his mere appearance ensured a packed audience, eager for anything approaching intentional humour at their party conference. 
 In this respect, Kenneth Baker's jocular early reference to Labour's &bquo;Gould mine&equo; of political gaffes may conceivably have fallen a little short. 
 Only the organist in the conference hall seemed to be properly tuned-in, belting out a rendition of Bewitched, bothered and bewildered as the representatives filed in for their annual law and order debate. 
 Extra penny on stamps to raise &pound;1m for charity 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 CHRISTMAS STAMPS this year will offer people the chance to make a donation to a &pound;1m charity appeal. 
 Four charity stamps, covering inland destinations and the most popular overseas countries, each have an extra 1p added to their price. 
 Last Christmas the Post Office handled 1.5bn letters, cards and parcels; this year, from 1p per stamp, it aims to raise up to &pound;1m to help charities carrying out community projects. 
 The Post Office will absorb a &bquo;significant portion&equo; of the administrative and related costs involved, so 90 per cent of the money will go directly to charity. 
 It is also meeting the costs of the publicity and of the huge printing run of tens of millions of charity stamps. 
 This year's Christmas stamps, to be issued from 14 November, will feature Ely Cathedral, Cambridgeshire, which is celebrating its 800th anniversary. 
 They show different sections of the cathedral, including Romanesque arches, the central tower, and a stained glass window featuring a medieval peasant. 
 One non-charity Christmas stamp will be available, at 15p &mdash; the most popular price for Christmas cards &mdash; featuring four peasants framed by a row of Gothic arches. 
 Ordinary stamps will continue to be on sale at the normal price. 
 The money will be distributed by the Charities Aid Foundation, set up to co-ordinate the raising and distribution of funds to other charities. 
 Priority will go to emergency and crisis cases. 
 Pioneering projects breaking fresh ground could receive up to &pound;50,000. 
 Charities wanting to improve services will receive up to &pound;5,000. 
 Applicants from charities registered with the Charity Commissioners or those approved for charitable status by the Inland Revenue should send their name and address on a postcard to: Ann Derby, Post Office Charity Stamp Appeal, Charities Aid Foundation, 48 Pembury Road, Tonbridge, Kent TN9 2JD. 
 Art Market: Record price paid for Islamic casket 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 CHRISTIE'S SET an auction record for Islamic metalwork on Tuesday when it sold a silver inlaid brass casket for &pound;242,000. 
 The estimate had been between &pound;40,000 and &pound;60,000, but competition between the Khalili Galleries of London and an unnamed museum drove the price through the roof. 
 Elaborately inlaid medieval metalwork from the Middle East is rare enough, but the products of Jazira in Mesopotamia, where this casket was made, are especially rare. 
 The great metalworking centres of the time were in Mesopotamia, Iran and Egypt. 
 The best works of Jazira have an edge on the others. 
 The inlay depicts intricate little scenes, including a group playing backgammon and another group with a tray of drinks. 
 It covers the sides of the casket densely. 
 The rarest feature of the casket, however, is the combination lock; it is one of only five known on boxes from Jazira. 
 The impact of the big price appears to have spilled over into Sotheby's yesterday where a Timurid brass jug inlaid with gold and silver, dating from 1495-96, was bid to &pound;60,500 against an estimate of &pound;8,000 to &pound;12,000. 
 It was bought by a dealer from Kuwait. 
 Sotheby's Islamic sale was full of surprises. 
 The front runner was a 15in Syrian blue and white jar of about 1400, which sold for &pound;137,500 (estimate &pound;30,000-&pound;40,000) &mdash; again to Dr David Khalili of the Khalili Galleries. 
 He bought it on behalf of a private institution in Switzerland. 
 The decoration of the jar is lifted directly from Chinese porcelains of the fourteenth century which were highly prized in the Middle East at the time. 
 Iznik pottery of the sixteenth century was again in great demand. 
 Two prices were far out of line with Sotheby's predictions. 
 A dish, circa 1560, centred on a turquoise ground panel containing two lions, a deer, a hare and a bird, soared to &pound;82,500 (estimate &pound;5,000-&pound;8,000), selling to a private Swiss collector. 
 A single rectangular tile, circa 1575, decorated with a pattern of interlocking arabesques secured &pound;28,600 (estimate &pound;6,000-&pound;9,000). 
 Dealers emerged from the first day's sale of the Blackmer library gasping at the high prices. 
 The collection is devoted to books on Greece, Turkey, Egypt and the Levant; there are further sales today and tomorrow. 
 The top price was &pound;66,000 (estimate &pound;15,000-&pound;20,000) for an exquisitely illustrated account of a journey in Greece and Turkey, by Louis Dupre, published in 1825. 
 Dupre was a pupil of David, the towering genius of French neoclassical painting, and the views and costume studies echo his clarity of line and ornamental composition. 
 Entitled Voyage a Athenes et a Constantinople, it includes 40 finely hand coloured lithographed plates. 
 Self-defence murder case is dropped 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 A MURDER charge against a man who stabbed a burglar was dropped yesterday. 
 The Crown Prosecution Service announced at Tower Bridge Magistrates' Court that it was not continuing with a case against John Graham, 53, a lift engineer. 
 Mr Graham had said he stabbed Anthony Sweeny in self defence after catching him and another man breaking into a neighbour's flat in Bartram Road, Brockley, south London, on August bank holiday. 
 He said the two men attacked him with a tyre lever, hammer and a craft knife. 
 He struck back with a knife which fell in the struggle from his chest of drawers. 
 After his first court appearance he received dozens of letters of support from the public. 
 Michael Freeman, for Mr Graham, said: &bquo;It is plain that the evidence of self defence has guided them.&equo; 
 Mr Graham was &bquo;extremely relieved and grateful&equo; that the case had been dropped, he said. 
 When Mr Graham first appeared in court reporting restrictions were lifted and Lorna Burns, for the prosecution, described how police arrived at the flats to find a man with a scarf around his face lying unconscious on the first-floor landing with a stab wound in his chest. 
 On the next landing was Mr Graham, heavily covered in blood. 
 Asked by police what had happened, Mr Graham said: &bquo;He attacked me with a hammer and I stabbed him.&equo; 
 Miss Burns said: &bquo;He discovered the victim and another apparently burgling room six.&equo; 
 Christopher Voelcker, stipendiary magistrate, said: &bquo;Mr Graham's &pound;260 legal aid payment will be remitted to him in full.&equo; 
 Kenya road death facts refused 
 By JACK O'SULLIVAN 
 THE FOREIGN OFFICE is being asked to intervene with the Kenyan government over the death of a British teacher, killed while on his honeymoon when an army ambulance mounted a pavement in Nairobi. 
 The Kenyan authorities have failed to respond to inquiries by British police, via Interpol, about John Graham Garrod's death, Southwark Coroner's Court in south London, was told yesterday. 
 Sir Montague Levine, the coroner, said he took a very poor view of their attitude and would seek Foreign Office help to get more information. 
 He said the only details available, apart from a death certificate, had come from Mr Garrod's family. 
 &bquo;I view with very much concern the comments I have had to make in this inquest.&equo; 
 Sir Montague returned an open verdict on Mr Garrod, 35, who was revisiting the country where he had met his wife, Leanne, 30, and spent seven years teaching before returning to England last Christmas. 
 His family is suing the Kenyan government over his death from a fractured skull after the vehicle veered on to the wrong side of the road on 3 August, hitting the couple from behind. 
 Mrs Garrod suffered minor injuries. 
 The inquest heard that the driver ran off after the accident, in which a motorcyclist and a pedestrian were also injured. 
 Mr Garrod, who had been appointed head of geography at a Chesterfield school, was rushed to hospital by a passing motorist but never regained consciousness. 
 He was put on a life support machine, but died four days later. 
 Last-ditch attempts to stop deportation of Kurdish refugees 
 By NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 TWO Kurdish refugees will be deported this afternoon to Turkey &mdash; where they say they face persecution and torture &mdash; unless they win a last-minute reprieve. 
 They are among eight Kurds facing imminent deportation who have been moved from Haslar detention centre, near Gosport, to Winchester prison. 
 They are being kept in cells under close observation because of fears that they may become suicidal or stage a protest. 
 The Home Office wants to prevent any repetition of last week's incident when two Kurds facing deportation from Heathrow Airport set fire to their room at the nearby Harmondsworth Detention Centre. 
 One died and the other, Dogam Arslan, remains seriously ill with burns at Stoke Mandeville Hospital. 
 He has since been granted temporary leave to stay in Britain. 
 Ten Kurds who had been in detention were released from Haslar yesterday with permission to stay while their applications for political asylum are processed. 
 The United Nations High Commission for Refugees has said Selahattin Osberk, 30, who is due to be put on a flight to Istanbul today, should be granted refugee status and has a well-founded fear of persecution. 
 Yesterday Amnesty International sent an urgent letter to Timothy Renton, Minister of State at the Home Office, urging him to reconsider Mr Osberk's case. 
 He is in Blackpool at the Conservative Party Conference and has given no sign of a reprieve. 
 Michael Hanley, Mr Osberk's solicitor, says his client fears he will be tortured by Turkish police trying to trace his brother, a member of an illegal Kurdish independence organisation who is in hiding. 
 &bquo;There is medical evidence to show that he is suicidal and clinically depressed,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Hanley will go to the High Court this morning in the hope of winning a last-minute judicial review. 
 He has been refused one review already. 
 Another Kurd represented by Mr Hanley, Halil Guzel, is due to be deported on another flight to Istanbul this afternoon. 
 The UN has called on the Home Office to reconsider the &bquo;humanitarian aspects&equo; in his case, but has not said he deserves asylum. 
 About 3,500 Kurds came to Britain last May and June, before a visa requirement was hurried in to stem an influx. 
 Their applications for asylum are being processed gradually; most are still awaiting a decision. 
 If they are told the Home Office is &bquo;minded to refuse&equo; asylum they can apply for a judicial review. 
 But that can be granted only to a refugee who is seeking asylum on the ground that the Government might have administered a case improperly and not followed its own rules for processing refugees under a United Nations Convention. 
 The only way the ground for the deportation decision can be challenged is if the refugee returns to the country from which he fled and launches an appeal there. 
 The Kurds come mostly from Kahramanmaras in south-eastern Turkey, a poor region where there are communities of Arabs, Kurds and Turks. 
 They are young and middle-aged men, many with wives and children in Turkey, who say they have suffered repeated imprisonments, police beatings and torture because of their sympathies for communist and Kurdish independence groups. 
 DANCE / Louise Levene preview LCDT's autumn tour; plus listings 
 By LOUISE LEVENE 
 London Contemporary Dance Theatre have begun touring this autumn with their usual selection of excellently mixed bills. 
 They dance to an exciting variety of music by composers such as Boyce, Shostakovich, Britten and Philip Glass. 
 Two of the new pieces, To Comfort Ghosts and another tentatively titled New Dance are choreographed by LCDT's new artistic director Dan Wagoner. 
 Another new work Orfeo (pictured above) by Kim Brandstrup deals with the myth in the manner of a baroque opera and is set to the computerised harpsichord of Ian Dearden. 
 The perennially popular pastoral celebration Arden Court by Paul Taylor will be danced at four of the venues. 
 Plymouth, Coventry, Bristol, Leeds, Cardiff, London (see below for details). 
 The Place (387 0031) Laurie Booth Terminus Terminux to Sat; Compagnie Cre-Ange Noir Salle should be livelier and less self-indulgent than Emile Dubois' much-hyped and absurdly over-long opening to Dance Umbrella &bquo;89 17-18 Oct. 
 Royal Opera House, WC2 (240 1066) Royal Ballet Mixed Bill: Rubies, Other Dances (Sylvie Guillem happy and relaxed with her old partner from Paris Laurent Hilaire), Ashley Page's new Piano (opened to mixed reviews. 
 The conductor does Beethoven no favours and the ballet is a little long but is worth seeing), Requiem tonight, 27 Oct (when Sylvie Guillem dances Grand Pas Classique with Cope); La Bayadere Fri (Guillem, Bussell, Cope 13 Oct); Postal booking: Prince of the Pagodas. 7 Dec (Gala), 8, 11, 14, 15, 19, 20 Dec. 65 amphitheatre seats are sold from 10am on the day. 
 One per person. 
 OPERA / Finding the right tenor: Mark Pappenheim previews new Britten productions and a competition in memory of Peter Pears 
 By MARK PAPPENHEIM 
 Benjamin Britten overshadowed the whole of Britain's post-war operatic scene, from the revelatory first performance of Peter Grimes at Sadler's Wells in June 1945, to the desperately achieved premiere of Death in Venice, three years before his own death in 1976. 
 Throughout all his operatic output, one factor remained constant: the inspiration of Peter Pears as friend, lover and uniquely-voiced creator of all the tenor leads from Grimes to Aschenbach. 
 It was an artistic relationship that ultimately cost the composer his life as he repeatedly delayed vital heart surgery to complete the role that he knew would also be Pears's last. 
 Pears himself died in 1986, leaving a new generation of British tenors to emerge from beneath his shadow at a time when Britten's own work is undergoing vital reassessment and revival. 
 On Saturday, Stephen Lawless's new GTO staging of Death in Venice opens its tour at Glyndebourne with Robert Tear as Aschenbach, the only Pears part (bar Albert Herring) he has yet to sing. 
 Opera North has also just unveiled a new Britten staging: Peter Grimes, directed by Ronald Eyre and with John Treleaven as the visionary Suffolk fisherman. 
 It reaches Manchester on Wednesday, the same day that Philip Langridge opens at Covent Garden in Elijah Moshinsky's proto-Brechtian Grimes. 
 Meanwhile Imperial Opera are bravely burrowing further back in the Britten archives to stage the comic musical Paul Bunyan which Britten wrote with Auden during wartime exile in America (see listings, below, for performance details and for discount offer on the Royal Opera's Peter Grimes). 
 And this week has seen the launch of a new international singing competition in memory of Peter Pears. 
 Over 80 artists from some 14 nations entered for the new BP Peter Pears Award, each presenting a 22-minute programme representing their talents in opera, oratorio, baroque and 20th-century works; Britten was to be heard in most contestants' 20th-century selections. 
 Four finalists will go through to the closing contest on Sunday when James Lockhart and the ENO orchestra provide an operatic interlude while the jury is out for the final count. 
 Lord Harewood chairs the panel, which includes Covent Garden's current Valkyrie, Dame Gwyneth Jones, as well as Norman Bailey and Josephine Veasey. 
 My money's on Alastair Miles, currently stealing the show as Raimondo in WNO's Lucia. 
 Readers who want to hear who wins the Peter Pears Award First Prize of &pound;5000 can buy two tickets for the price of one in the stalls or dress circle (&pound;6-&pound;8.50) upon presentation of this page at the Sadler's Wells Box Office or by quoting this offer on 01-278 8916 Sun 6.30pm Sadler's Wells, Rosebery Ave EC1. 
 POP / Far Out sounds from Stourbridge: Giles Smith samples The Wonder Stuff and chooses the gigs of the week 
 By GILES SMITH 
 The Wonder Stuff come from Stourbridge, in the West Midlands, and have never been shy about saying so. 
 In fact, in interviews, a quick reference to the home town frequently serves them as well as a rhetorical trick: by declaring their provinciality, they can remind you just how surprised they are to be attracting so much attention all of a sudden. 
 You could hardly blame them, though, for feeling bewildered from time to time. 
 One minute they were pushing forward a couple of tentative singles on their own label (The Far Out Recording Company), the next they were being pressganged by Polydor and trailed across the press following the release of their debut album, The Eight Legged Groove Machine. 
 Q liked it. 
 So did Smash Hits. 
 It gave them something more than local interest to build on. 
 The follow-up, Hup, came out last week and runs along the same lines: some neatly-chopped guitar riffs float in a fashionably psychedelic haze, while the nasal disdain of Miles Hunt's voice rides a few tuneful melodies. 
 It's a simple arrangement and adapts straightforwardly to the stage. 
 As the tour will doubtless prove, what drives them crazy in Stourbridge holds good elsewhere. 
 JOE JACKSON Over from New York to give his first London performances for three years. 
 An 11-piece band will cover the ground between Look Sharp! and this year's excellent Blaze of Glory, passing several notable pop landmarks on the way. 
 THE MIGHTY LEMON DROPS A vast noise in the midst of which some bold melodies are attempting to box their way out. 
 Worth being ringside. 
 Fri, Sat London Dominion; Sun Birmingham Hummingbird. 
 FISH Fish has now slipped loose of progressive rockers Marillion, but the title of his forthcoming album (Vigil in a Wilderness of Mirrors) suggests he's still thinking on the grand scale. 
 Sun Dingwall Legends; Mon Elgin Town Hall; Tue Ullapool Village Hall. 
 THE TEMPTATIONS No longer with Kendrick and Ruffin up front. 
 But nevertheless, the tunes, the outfits, the lush harmonies, the synchronized dancing &mdash; irresistible. 
 Tonight London Hammersmith Odeon; Fri Nottingham Royal Concert Hall; Sat Newcastle City Hall; Sun Edinburgh Playhouse; Mon Liverpool Empire; Tue Manchester Apollo; Wed Wolverhampton Civic Hall. 
 Tonight London Royal Albert Hall; Sat Southampton Mayflower; Mon Birmingham Hippodrome. 
 THE SUGARCUBES The sound of independent Iceland. 
 Several members of the group are published poets. 
 JOE STRUMMER Last summer the former Clash singer set out on the fairly unequivocal &bquo;Rock Against The Rich&equo; tour, where he sounded pretty fed up about everything. 
 This time he is promoting a solo album. 
 And he still sounds pretty fed up about everything. 
 CHRISTY MOORE Costello, The Pogues, and U2 are among a hoard of artists quick to declare the Irish folk-singer's influence. 
 Tonight Leeds Irish Centre; Fri Liverpool Royal Court; Sun Newcastle Playhouse; Mon Manchester Free Trade Hall; Tue Birmingham Town Hall. 
 THE TOM ROBINSON BAND The original line-up, road-testing some new material for future release, while at the same time customising some of the old agit-pop anthems. 
 Fri Northampton Roadmenders Centre; Sat Manchester International; Wed Sheffield University. 
 GARY NUMAN All the hits are made available again on a live compilation, The Skin Mechanic. 
 Remarkable how long a nasal drone and a cheap synth can sustain a man. 
 Tonight London Dominion; Fri Oxford Apollo Theatre; Sat Sheffield City Hall; Sun Hull City Hall; Mon Manchester Apollo; Wed Bristol Colston Hall. 
 LOUDON WAINWRIGHT III Sly American songwriter, whose new album, Therapy, ponders the demands of fame: like having your picture alongside Frankie Vaughan's in the local launderette. 
 Tonight Southport Arts Centre; Sat Wolverhampton Wulfren Centre; Mon Brighton Zap Club; Wed Manchester International. 
 DAVID ESSEX Going all out for the Cliff Richard Award for persistent youthfulness. 
 He'll need a lot of breath for this lengthy stint, which heads off towards the new year. 
 There are only 45 David Essex gigs to Christmas. 
 Tonight Bradford Alhambra; Fri Hull City Hall; Sat Nottingham Royal Concert Hall; Sun Stratford Royal Shakespeare Theatre; Mon Bristol Colston Hall; Tue Northampton Derngate Centre; Wed Cardiff St David's Hall. 
 ROOTS &amp; WORLD MUSIC THE NORMAN COOK ROADSHOW The former Housemartin alongside The Real Sounds of Africa (suppliers of the Zimbabwean World Cup theme song), while, all around, graffiti artists spray and club DJs mix. 
 There are twenty seven people on the stage at any one time. 
 Sat Trent Polytechnic; Tue Birmingham Hummingbird; Wed Brighton Top Rank. 
 PAPA WEMBA A show built in Paris on musical foundations assembled in Zaire. 
 Much use made of the lokole, a percussion instrument employed to communicate between villages. 
 Tonight Liverpool Bluecoat; Fri Manchester International 2; Sat St Helens Citadel; Sun London Town &amp; Country. 
 LE RUE Cajun crazies, featuring some fairly forward fiddle-playing from leader, Pierre. 
 Fri London Royalty Theatre. 
 JAZZ / Pete Martin selects a fortnight of gigs, starting with Lionel Hampton 
 By PETE MARTIN 
 LIONEL HAMPTON One of the few remaining links with the classic era, Hamp played drums for Louis Armstrong as long ago as 1930; later in that decade his pulsating vibes gave Benny Goodman's great quartet much of its joie de vivre. 
 Since the Forties he has led his own big bands, noted for their driving swing on up-tempo numbers like &bquo;Flying Home&equo;, and for the leader's exuberant showmanship. 
 Sun 22 Lewisham Jazz Festival; Mon 23 Northampton Derngate; Wed 25 Canterbury Marlowe Theatre; Thur 26 Edinburgh Usher Hall; Fri 27 Glasgow City Halls; Sat 28 Cork Jazz Festival; Mon 30 Birmingham Alexandra Theatre; Tue 31 Bristol Colston Hall; Wed 1 Nov Cardiff St Davids Hall; Fri 3 Poole Arts Centre; Sat 4 London Dominion Theatre; Sun 5 Manchester Free Trade Hall; Mon 6 Sunderland Empire Theatre. 
 MIKE STERN/BOB BERG Stern's guitar and Berg's saxophone are currently best remembered for their contributions to Miles Davis' comeback bands. 
 But both played a great deal of different music before then, and have done so since. 
 Fri 20 Edinburgh Queens Hall; Sat 21 Leeds Trade Club; Sun 22 Town &amp; Country Club, Kentish Town, London NW5. 
 LEE KONITZ Over the years, Konitz has developed into one of the most fluent and intelligent of contemporary improvisers, his light yet husky alto sound the perfect vehicle for his incisive lines. 
 He resumes a remarkably productive partnership with pianist John Taylor, himself among the best around. 
 With Mick Hutton (bass) and Steve Arguelles (drums). 
 Fri 20 Mansfield Civic Centre (with the Cantamus Choir); Sat 21 Queen Elizabeth Hall, South Bank, London SE1; Sun 22 Dartington Arts Centre Great Hall; Mon 23 Bristol St Georges Church; Tue 24 Padiham Town Hall; Wed 25 Darlington Arts Centre, Vane Terrace; Thur 26 Aberystwyth Arts Centre; Fri 27 Brighton Concorde Club; Sat 28 Llantwit Major St Donats; Sun 29 Birmingham Midlands Arts Centre. 
 JOE HARRIOTT Memories of the great altoist are evoked by a quintet featuring three members of his band: trumpeter Shake Keane, bassist Coleridge Goode, and drummer Bobby Orr. 
 The pianist is Michael Garrick and altoist Martin Hathaway has the daunting task of following in Harriott's footsteps. 
 Fri Cheltenham Queen's Hotel; Sat Berkhamsted Civic Centre; Sun Birmingham Midlands Arts Centre; Wed Leeds College of Music; Thur 26 Northampton Arts Centre; Thur 2 Nov London, University College School; Sat 4 London, Pizza Express, Dean St, W1; Sun 5 Brentwood Monkey Club; Wed 8 Nottingham Old Vic; Sun 12 Newcastle Corner House; Fri 17 Brighton Concorde Club; Sat 25 Swindon Link Ctr. 
 ART BLAKEY The godfather marks his 70th birthday with a reunion band featuring past and present Messengers. 
 Jackie McLean, Benny Golson, Bobby Watson and Curtis Fuller are among those rumoured to be involved. 
 Fri 20 Aberdeen Alternative Festival. 
 Full details 0224-635 822. 
 Football: &bquo;Volatile&equo; Knighton pulls out of United deal 
 By DEREK HODGSON and FRANK KANE 
 MANCHESTER UNITED yesterday settled into an uneasy peace after a face-saving operation by which Martin Edwards and Michael Knighton mutually agreed to tear up the contract that would have sold the club to Knighton. 
 The 37-year-old property developer will in turn be given the chance to buy the 1,000 shares necessary to become a club director. 
 Officially what Knighton called &bquo;the vilification&equo; is over, the two men are friends and colleagues again. 
 Edwards, Manchester United's chief executive and major shareholder, was at pains to emphasise that Knighton had been in a position to complete the deal, but had not done so &bquo;in the interests of the club&equo; and had at no time sought compensation. 
 The idea that he should become a director came from Edwards. 
 Laing &amp; Cruickshank, Knighton's stockbrokers, confirmed that funds for the deal had been available. 
 &bquo;We received enough indications over the past few days that he could have gone through with it,&equo; a senior spokesman said. 
 Exactly why he chose not to proceed will be a matter for debate in financial and footballing circles for some time. 
 One merchant banker, who was privy to the late night talks on Tuesday that ended in yesterday's withdrawal, said: &bquo;He was very volatile.&equo; 
 Another reason, according to the same financier, was that &bquo;at least two of his backers were not acceptable to the United board, while the third was so murky it was not even clear who it was.&equo; 
 In the course of an acrid, 30-minute press conference, called at midday and starting at 3.42, both men implied that the deal could be resurrected at some time later: &bquo;I might consider selling my majority shareholding in the future,&equo; said Edwards, &bquo;but certainly not this season.&equo; 
 Knighton added: &bquo;If Martin does decide to sell some of his shares at some future date, he knows I will be there.&equo; 
 But he will think long and hard before he again takes on the United board. 
 The whole affair has cost him more than &pound;650,000 in fees for legal and financial advice, his spokesmen said last night. 
 As much as &pound;150,000 of that will go in fees and costs to Laing &amp; Cruickshank, who were taken on only last week. 
 There could be further fall-out from the financial authorities today. 
 The City Take-over Panel, which has to give its blessing to the ending of the contract, could take a dim view of the decision not to proceed with a formal bid. 
 Knighton, much paler than when the whole saga began, 56 days ago, never smiled through an acrimonious exchange of questions. 
 He and the club's solicitor and director, Maurice Watkins, sat either side of Edwards while on the flanks were placed two more lawyers, one representing Knighton's take-over firm, MK Trafford Holdings, and the other, United's merchant bank, Ansbacher. 
 Was the invitation from the Board to Knighton to become a director unanimous? 
 Watkins intervened: &bquo;It was a common agreement.&equo; 
 Was there a vote? 
 Edwards: &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Then it wasn't unanimous? 
 &bquo;It was a common agreement to be ratified at the next board meeting on 20 October&equo;. 
 Knighton's fiercest response came when he was asked about reported demands. 
 He denied angrily that he had ever sought compensation of up to &pound;1m &bquo;although this has been a very expensive operation&equo;, adding: &bquo;I could have proceeded had I been totally selfish for there were several options on the table, financially very attractive.&equo; 
 Edwards, looking strained and weary, stressed: &bquo;What United need most now is a period of stability&equo;. 
 No one present would have disputed that but the feeling was that all we had seen was the closing of one chapter of a story in which there is much more to come. 
 Amer Midani, the wealthy Lebanese businessman who sits on the United board, is still favourite to eventually take over the club, and to install Bobby Charlton as chairman. 
 Yesterday's denoument will also turn out to be good for Edwards, who will be able to sell his stake for a good deal more than the &pound;10m on offer. 
 &bquo;Mr Edwards did not get the best price he could have,&equo; a merchant banker said. 
 &bquo;Buying Manchester United would be like buying a Van Gogh &mdash; you just cannot put a value on it.&equo; 
 Football: Shilton's point duty shows the route to Italy 
 From PATRICK BARCLAY in Chorzow 
 Poland. 
 .0 England. 
 .0 A SECOND successive goalless draw saw England through to the World Cup finals here yesterday, when Poland practically burned themselves out in an often scintillating hour and yet fanned an ember in the last minute when Ryszard Tarasiewicz's shot struck Peter Shilton's crossbar. 
 Thus a suspect defence completed the qualifying programme of six matches without conceding a goal; they must be doing something right, although not for the first time their debt to Shilton was manifest. 
 As a relieved and slightly rueful Bryan Robson put it: &bquo;Shilts always complains that his worst night is when he has nothing to do. 
 We thought we'd give him some work this time.&equo; 
 Bobby Robson's delight at having guided his team to another major tourament was coupled with gratitude to the 40-year-old goalkeeper. 
 &bquo;He was incredible. 
 The Poles picked an attacking side and had us under siege for a while but Shilton made vital saves at vital times.&equo; 
 Sweden could still claim top place in Group Four, which would diminish England's hopes of being seeded in Italy next summer, but the Swedes must win here in a fortnight and on yesterday's evidence that could be difficult. 
 Poland did more than enough to win in every respect except finishing and must have regretted Dariusz Dziekanowski's failure to beat Shiton with a header after half an hour. 
 The veteran contributed his customary reassurance while Terry Butcher made important interventions and Robson and Steve McMahon toiled in midfield. 
 But it was not an impressive performance; indeed, recalling the swashbuckling victory in Yugoslavia that sent England to the European Championship, one questions whether any genuine progress has been made. 
 Still, in the art of qualification they have few equals. 
 How the likes of Poland, now incapable of reaching Italy, must envy the continuity and consistency established under Bobby Robson. 
 In June, the Poles came to Wembley and, dismally, lost 3-0. 
 Under new management, and with widespread team changes, they have certainly improved. 
 Shilton dived to turn behind a deflected drive from Robert Warzycha; and clawed away a devilishly unexpected chip from Piotr Czachowski. 
 But Shilton should not have been allowed to make his crucial save. 
 The Poles were building beautifully at times, and one example engineered by Japek Ziober and Janusz Nawrocki ended with Robert Warzycha curling over a perfect cross from Dziekanowski. 
 The Celtic striker, however, put his header too close to the keeper. 
 McMahon strove to retaliate but was denied by an advance by Jaroslaw Bako of which the maestro at the other end would have been proud. 
 Meanwhile, for all the tousled-haired trickery of Ziober and Roman Kosecki on the flanks, and the delicate midfield skills of Tarasiewicz, the Poles had a tendency to waste possession by shooting from ludicrous range. 
 At the begining of the second half England again had cause to be grateful as a marvellous five-man move graced by Tarasiewicz's stunning volleyed pass ended with Ziober drifting a benign shot over. 
 Poland needed a goal. 
 They had set themselves a pace that could not survive 90 minutes and, sure enough, began to sag. 
 A lapse in concentration invited England to move ahead when Robson was allowed to head a corner into the goalmouth. 
 Gary Lineker swung a foot, but missed. 
 England then funnelled back and the match died. 
 Its brief revival was sparked by Dziekanowski who fed Tarasiewicz and for once a long shot had Shilton in trouble. 
 It swerved, dipped and smacked the bar. 
 He said later: &bquo;I never thought it would go in.&equo; 
 He could be forgiven that. 
 Football: Southern comfort as Whelan leads way 
 From JOE LOVEJOY in Dublin 
 Republic of Ireland.. 3 Northern Ireland..... 0 THE celebrations were on the point of becoming a full-blown ceilidh when the score was corrected: Spain had not won 2-1 in Budapest, but the Hungarians had equalised eight minutes from time, and a bizarre set of circumstances could yet deny the Republic their first appearance in the World Cup finals. 
 Logic dictates that the Boys in Green will accompany the Spaniards to Italy next summer. 
 For them to miss out, they would have to lose their last qualifying tie, in Malta next month, while the Hungarians were winning by a handsome margin in Seville. 
 Nobody believes that is going to happen, least of all Jack Charlton, who says taking the Irish to the finals will give him as much satisfaction as he drew from winning the competition with England in 1966. 
 Billy Bingham, Northern Ireland's manager, believes the hurricane style blowing the Republic to the finals could take Italy by storm &mdash; if the isobars are favourable. 
 Bingham acknowledged that his southern neighbours deserved their first appearance in the finals after beating the North for the first time in four attempts. 
 &bquo;They blitzed us,&equo; was Bingham's verdict. 
 George Dunlop, of Linfield, preferred to Allen McKnight, held out for 42 minutes, but when Fort Dunlop came under siege, the defences were found wanting, and the only Irish-based player on the field was at fault for the important first goal. 
 Dunlop elected to punch a cross from Steve Staunton, but succeeded only in presenting the ball to Ronnie Whelan, who drilled it back past him from 18 yards. 
 Six minutes later Whelan, outstanding in a mother hen role, created the space for Kevin Sheedy to deliver an incisive cross. 
 Tony Cascarino dispatched it with a towering header, and that was that. 
 The North, outplayed in all departments, were never going to score twice against the meanest defence in Group Six (five clean sheets in succession) and a third Republic goal, a 20-yarder from Ray Houghton, served only to improve their useful goal difference. 
 Houghton and Whelan were the game's dominant influences, running the midfield despite the painful attentions of Norman Whiteside, but it is Cascarino's increasing effectiveness which is giving the Republic most satisfaction. 
 &bquo;His power and persistence will cause any team problems,&equo; Bingham said. 
 &bquo;He reminds me a lot of Billy Hamilton in that he's rangy and big and he gets in there on the end of crosses to do untold damage.&equo; 
 The punctured Dunlop will attest to that. 
 Football: Bosman polishes off Wales 
 From JOE LOVEJOY in Dublin 
 Wales............ 1 The Netherlands.. 2 EVEN without Ruud Gullit and with Marco van Basten on the bench, The Netherlands looked polished and stylishly effective in brushing aside Wales on their way to the the top of Group Four at Wrexham. 
 They now need only to beat Finland on 15 November to be sure of their place in Italy. 
 The European champions got off to the best possible start when the full-back Graeme Rutjes headed them into the lead after 12 minutes. 
 Wales had opened brightly, but were then caught out when Gavin Maguire gave away a free kick on the right. 
 Ronald Koeman swung the ball into the area and Rutjes headed firmly past Southall. 
 Wales did find the net in the 32nd minute through Malcolm Allen, but it counted for nothing because Dean Saunders had fouled Hans van Breukelen. 
 The Netherlands replaced Rijkaard with Johnny Bosman at half-time and resumed in irresistible fashion. 
 Koeman was involved everywhere and cracked in a 35-yard shot which cannoned back off the post after 48 minutes. 
 Three minutes later he brilliantly beat three men and found John Van &bquo;t Schip, whose low shot was deflected away by the desperate boot of Jeff Hopkins. 
 The game was put beyond any lingering doubt after 69 minutes when Van &bquo;t Schip crossed and Bosman headed home. 
 Mark Bowen's goal two minutes from the end brought some consolation to Wales. 
 Football: Sexton set for friendlies 
 From JOE LOVEJOY in Dublin 
 DAVE SEXTON, the England Under-21 manager, is prepared to search for friendly fixtures if his side fall out of the European Championships at the qualifying stage for the first time in 12 years. 
 Sexton's team registered an encouraging 3-1 win over Poland, in Jastrzebie Zdruj on Tuesday afternoon, to become joint leaders of Group Two with Sweden. 
 But the Swedes will qualify if they avoid a heavy defeat in their final game in Poland, on 24 October. 
 Sexton is eager to keep his side together and has already discussed with Football Association officials the prospects of arranging friendly fixtures. 
 He said: &bquo;We have never had to worry about fixing friendly matches before as we have always reached the quarter-final stage at least. 
 But if Sweden go through this time we will try to arrange extra games. 
 Most of the lads in the squad are still eligible to play at under-21 level and we don't want it to break up.&equo; 
 Steve Bull, one of the over-age players, scored twice in England's win, but Sexton was keen to point out it had been a team performance, with Manchester City's David White and Dave Smith, of Coventry, particularly effective. 
 Brian Talbot, the West Bromwich Albion player-manager, has pulled a muscle in his back and is struggling to be fit in time to face Wolves, at The Hawthorns on Sunday. 
 Frank van Hattum, the New Zealand international who appeared in the 1982 World Cup finals in Spain, is having a trial with Fourth Division Colchester. 
 Van Hattum has been capped more than 60 times for his country. 
 John Sheridan is in line to make his league debut for Nottingham Forest, at Coventry on Saturday. 
 The &pound;650,000 signing from Leeds could step into the first team if midfielder Steve Hodge fails to recover from the hamstring injury he suffered while training with England last weekend. 
 Forest's assistant manager, Ron Fenton, said: &bquo;Hodge looks very doubtful. 
 Hamstring injuries don't clear up overnight.&equo; 
 Sheridan, a Republic of Ireland international, has made just one first team appearance &mdash; against Third Division Huddersfield in the Littlewoods Cup &mdash; since his arrival at the City Ground during the summer. 
 Dunstable have cancelled the registration of Herbie Smith after the team's recent walk-off during an FA Cup tie at Staines. 
 After Smith and two other Dunstable players were sent off during the match, the rest of the team left the field. 
 George Shipley, the former Charlton midfield player who was released by Gillingham at the end of last season, has officially retired at the age of 30 on medical advice, after a series of knee operations. 
 Doug Bell, Shrewsbury Town's experienced midfield player, has agreed to join fellow Third Division club Birmingham City. 
 Bell, 30, was a member of the Aberdeen squad who won the European Cup-Winners' Cup in 1983 and is a former Scottish Under-21 international. 
 The fee will be decided by an independent tribunal. 
 Football: Three Greeks sent off 
 From JOE LOVEJOY in Dublin 
 YUGOSLAVIA, already qualified for the World Cup finals, maintained their unbeaten run in Group Five by beating Norway 1-0 last night, despite having only 10 men from the 13th minute. 
 It was a night of sendings off &mdash; Norway also had a man dismissed, shortly after Faruk Hadzibegic's decisive penalty. 
 There were four sendings-off, three of them Greek, as Bulgaria beat the visitors 4-0 in a Group One match at Varna. 
 In Budapest, Spain clinched qualification from Group Six when they drew 2-2 with Hungary. 
 Julio Salinas and Michel scored for the Spaniards, while both Hungary's goals came from Pinter. 
 Football: Leighton lapse costs Scots again 
 From DON LINDSAY in Paris 
 France.. 3 Scotland. 
 0 JUSTICE can be a forlorn friend in football, and so was the verdict against Scotland here last night. 
 Despite constructing one of their most positive displays for some time they lost to a French team who profited from the only genuine opportunities they created. 
 It now requires the Scots' nerve, and more importantly their defence, to hold firm against Norway at Hampden next month to earn the point still needed to qualify for the World Cup finals in Italy next summer. 
 The test is sure to prove an onerous one. 
 Andy Roxburgh's side was radically different from that which lost so decisively against Yugoslavia in Zagreb last month. 
 Richard Gough returned to fill a central defensive slot alongside Alex McLeish and Maurice Johnston resumed his relationship up front with his Rangers team-mate, Ally McCoist. 
 Significantly, Roxburgh decided to pay heed to the excellent club form of Gordon Strachan and the Leeds United man displayed an admirable combination of cockiness and sheer resolve on the right side of a midfield which contained the Celtic pair Roy Aitken and Paul McStay, and the former Parkhead workhorse, Murdo Macleod, who is now enjoying a renaissance in West Germany. 
 All Scotland's impressive technique and tactical shrewdness went for nought in the 26th minute, though, when they lost a depressingly poor goal. 
 It was particularly disappointing as the Scots had shown signs of a refreshing midfield arrogance which had been missing from many of their recent displays. 
 Jean-Marc Ferreri and Eric Cantona accumulated a series of short passes on the edge of the Scots' box and the ball broke to Didier Deschamps 10 yards from goal with Gough nowhere in sight. 
 Again, Jim Leighton's judgement was at fault as the little Nantes midfielder managed to steer a shot between the keeper and his near post. 
 It was the second time in successive World Cup ties that Leighton had let down his colleagues. 
 Of all those entitled to feel disappointed, no one less deserved such ill fortune than McStay. 
 There was real distinction about his elegant yet powerful performance, but further misery descended cruelly upon the Scots 18 minutes into the second half. 
 With an equaliser the priority, the Scots were caught embarrassingly exposed at the back by Ferreri's sweeping ball and Cantona found scoring a joyous simplicity. 
 The goal did a lot to temper France's discomfort at the dismissal of the centre-back Eric Di Meco for hacking down Johnston and incurring both the referee's displeasure and a second bookable offence. 
 Jean-Philippe Durand scored a third for France three minutes from time. 
 Referee: K Roeghlisberger (Switzerland). 
 Rugby Union: Seabrook distanced by rugby's divide: Steve Bale reports on growing alarm about the health of the game in the North 
 By STEVE BALE 
 WHERE it matters &mdash; on the field &mdash; the north of England does rather well, successfully managing widely dispersed resources and usually playing winning rugby. 
 Yet with the new season have come new strains which have opened up a fundamental debate about its future. 
 Its past is also well remembered. 
 Next month brings the 10th anniversary of the North's celebrated defeat of Graham Mourie's All Blacks. 
 Those players - Beaumont, Smith, Cotton, Uttley and the rest &mdash; became part of northern folklore and, more importantly, went on to form the hard core of the England team who won the Grand Slam in 1980. 
 As if in reminder, the new All Blacks have arrived this week, and for the North the contrast between 1979 and 1989 could hardly be greater. 
 Where there were eight northern Grand Slammers, England's first, 41-strong squad this season had only three &mdash; Dewi Morris, Wade Dooley and Bob Kimmins &mdash; from northern clubs. 
 In the more recent squad of 35 the figure was up to four after Sale's David Baldwin had been brought in as cover for Dooley. 
 Yet these same squads each had no fewer than 10 northern players attached to more southerly clubs. 
 It is rugby's version of the north-south divide, given further emphasis when last season's England captains Will Carling and Rob Andrew, who play for Harlequins and Wasps respectively, decided they had had enough of travelling and declared for London. 
 This is not &mdash; not yet &mdash; a crisis but it is a significant problem, reflected in the depressed state of northern club rugby, where Orrell carry the standard alone in the English First Division. 
 Thinly spread playing strength and rugby league are imposing pressures different from anything experienced elsewhere in the country. 
 Twickenham is a long way away and the message from the North is that the Rugby Football Union needs to plough more resources into its missionary work in the area. 
 Otherwise, in Lancashire and Yorkshire at least, rugby league will take over completely. 
 &bquo;We've found it increasingly difficult to attract youngsters into the game because of the success of, and publicity for, rugby league here,&equo; Des Seabrook, coach of Orrell and Lancashire, said. 
 Seabrook speaks with authority &mdash; he also coached the &bquo;79 North side. 
 &bquo;The teachers&equo; strike had a big effect on many of the schools playing union in this part of the country &mdash; and rugby league simply stepped in. 
 We've been telling the Rugby Union for years that we want help; what they're doing now is like shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted.&equo; 
 The RFU is recruiting youth development officers and, of the 11 so far appointed, eight are in the North. 
 But as Seabrook points out, rugby league already has the same sort of thing in every town. 
 &bquo;I'm very concerned and I just wish the Rugby Union were as concerned as I am,&equo; he said. 
 Seabrook believes the clubs' hands would be strengthened by a change of selection policy so that only those based in the North play for the North. 
 &bquo;If the players are to be given some incentive, they really have to get the North going as it was. 
 In 1979, with the single exception of Roger Uttley, they were lads from northern clubs. 
 &bquo;It would be hard on people like Peter Winterbottom but they have taken a decision to go to London and there's no room any more for sentiment.&equo; 
 Seabrook's opinion is not universally shared. 
 David Robinson, the North coach, accepts the principle but not, for now, the practice. 
 &bquo;We can't just cut off our nose to spite our face,&equo; he said. 
 Andrew also differs: &bquo;Those of us who play outside the North are just as much northerners.&equo; 
 But Andrew said this last April, after leading the North to victory over the US, and the sharply increased requirements &mdash; club, divisional and national - of a new season have rapidly changed his, and Carling's, mind. 
 &bquo;It's down to individual players,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If they're northern-born and bred and happen to live elsewhere, they should still have the opportunity to play for the North. 
 &bquo;But as much as I'd like to continue playing for the North, I suddenly thought there's more to life than sitting on the M1. 
 I look as if I've made an about-turn but in terms of simple logistics it's getting itself out of all proportion.&equo; 
 If others took the same decision it would spare the North selectors some uncomfortable choices. 
 But for Robinson the answer lies elsewhere. 
 &bquo;The club scene in the North isn't too healthy because the players are spread so thinly but there are still plenty of good ones about,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;To find this talent and bring it on, above all we need the county championship. 
 But the Rugby Union has seen fit to let it degenerate and from next season, when it's played at the same time as the divisional championship, it will be virtually kaput. 
 &bquo;The clubs have that much power over players it's as if they own them, and this isn't good for the game in the North. 
 If the county championship was still there as it used to be, then I could pick only northern-based players and in two or three years I'd have a very strong side.&equo; 
 Robinson, who was England B coach with Alan Davies until both were dumped in the summer, reluctantly accepts he is fighting a lost cause: &bquo;It isn't going to happen and the situation is beginning to get worrying. 
 The Rugby Union is oblivious to us; they mean well but they just don't realise what's going on up here.&equo; 
 Rugby Union: Cardiff first in firing line 
 By STEVE BALE 
 IT IS small consolation to Cardiff that they will be spared the full force of the All Blacks on Saturday. 
 Yesterday's initial tour selection is so strong as to make no difference. 
 There are 10 of the players who beat Australia in August, all but Mike Brewer having started each of New Zealand's five summer Tests. 
 Indeed Alex Wyllie, their coach, already expects to reselect his Test team en bloc: &bquo;There won't be changes as long as those players keep their form.&equo; 
 The rest of the party will therefore have to produce something exceptional to oust the well-established incumbents. 
 That in turn threatens the worst for the teams they face, Cardiff being the first to dip their toe in the water. 
 This is a suitable metaphor after the rain pouring from leaden skies which greeted the All Blacks to training yesterday. 
 It was just like home, really - and the tourists looked at home too, working with an urgency and precision which would put our domestic equivalents to shame. 
 Saturday's team reunites five of the Auckland backs who recently cut a swathe through NZ rugby. 
 Matthew Ridge, a full-back of Anglo-Armenian parentage and astonishing gifts, and centre Craig Innes are among those making their first impressions. 
 Otherwise Graeme Bachop, Bruce Deans's scrum-half understudy for Canterbury as well as New Zealand, the prop Ron Williams and beanpole lock Ian Jones are the &bquo;outsiders&equo; brought in. 
 The tour's prestige refereeing appointment, the Barbarians game at Twickenham on 25 November, has rightly gone to the world's best, Clive Norling. 
 The Welshman has also received his annual invitation to take the University match on 12 December. 
 French Barbarians have included Harlequins' England forwards, Paul Ackford and Peter Winterbottom, and the Springbok stand-off Naas Botha against Fiji in Bordeaux on Sunday week. 
 Eric Vergniol, an ex-rugby league international, is a provocative choice on the wing in a French Selection against the Fijians in Bergerac on Saturday. 
 Rugby Union: Young rekindles Waspish spirit 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 Wasps.................... 25 Loughborough University.. 17 THE FIRST priority for Wasps this week is to get back to winning ways in the League after their reversal at Harlequins. 
 Unbeaten Gloucester are their Courage visitors on Saturday and it was Loughborough, previously unbeaten until they met Quins, who stepped out at Sudbury last night. 
 Wasps can only wish then that this weekend's activities are as fruitful, the students putting on a brave show with two second-half tries from their dashing wing, Andy Parton, but Wasps &mdash; fielding only two of this season's first-teamers &mdash; winning with something to spare thanks largely to the goal-kicking of Paddy Young. 
 The referee's first task of a damp evening was to ask Wasps to change their jerseys in order to avoid confusion and they emerged with a far more waspish look about them in black-and-yellow hoops. 
 Stung by this delay, they drove the students back many a yard at the opening scrum. 
 This may have embarrassed Loughborough's Richard Wareham, the tight-head who played in the England Under-21 front row when they hammered Romania in Bucharest last May, and the youngsters continued to go backwards at a rate of knots in tight and loose. 
 Wasps soon moved ahead when twice catching their opponents offside, Young landing penalties from bang in front of the posts. 
 The best that Loughborough could manage was a penalty in reply from their full-back Chris Dossett after 18 minutes. 
 Moments later Loughborough lost their flanker John Hastings with a cut around the eye. 
 Wasps pressed on with another penalty from Young while the students' best hope of winning possession came from their 6ft 9in lock Derwin Jones. 
 But by the interval they had fallen further behind, Tom Hillier sprinting to the blind side and Ian Armstrong crossing for the try in support. 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 JIMMY CONNORS, who beat John McEnroe in a bitter final eight years ago, returns to Wembley next month, having been given a wild card for the tournament which begins on 7 November, when the 37-year-old faces McEnroe again. 
 ANDRE AGASSI, the second seed, was knocked out of the Hong Kong Open in the first round yesterday by Haiti's Ronald Agenor. 
 The world No. 5 from the United States claimed jet-lag had made him tired. 
 Sport in Short: Table Tennis 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Swimming 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Speedway 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Snooker 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 WILLIE THORNE reached the semi-finals of the Continental Airlines London Masters at the Cafe Royal with a 4-3 victory over Steve Davis. 
 Sport in Short: Rowing 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 DENIS OSWALD, of Switzerland, is to take over immediately as president of the International Rowing Federation (FISA) following the death of his compatriot Thomas Keller, who suffered a heart attack last month. 
 Sport in Short: Rallying 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Olympic Games 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 ISL, the international marketing agency which has the International Olympic Committee among its clients, is up for sale. 
 Members of the West German Dassler family, who own Adidas, the sports equipment company, have decided to sell their 51 percent holding in ISL. 
 Sport in Short: Judo 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 Middleweight (86 kg) Pool B, first round: D White (GB) bt S Freudenberg (WG) koka. 
 Second round: White bt G Vismara (It) decision. 
 Third round: White bt Nan Wang (Ch) yuko. 
 Pool B, final: B Spykers (Neth) bt White decision. 
 Third places: Lobenstein bt White yuko, Karger bt Freudenberg yuko. 
 Final: Canu bt Spykers decision. 
 Sport in Short: Ice Hockey 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Hockey 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Cycling 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Cricket 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 NOTTS CCC yesterday criticised the county council's refusal to support its ground improvements at Trent Bridge. 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: Badminton 
 Sport Page 39 
 Sport in Short: American Football 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 HERSCHEL WALKER, the Dallas Cowboys running back, is wanted by the Minnesota Vikings, who are thought to have offered running backs Darrin Nelson and Allen Rice, cornerback Carl Lee., two No. 1 draft picks and a No. 2 draft pick in exchange. 
 Rugby Union: Stanger earns his wing for Scotland 
 By BILL LEITH 
 THE BRIGHT new right-wing talent was acclaimed yesterday. 
 Not in the conference halls of Blackpool but at Murrayfield after Tony Stanger, the 21-year-old Hawick threequarter, had been included in Scotland's team for the opening international of the season, against Fiji, on 28 October. 
 Confirming Stanger's inclusion, the only new cap in a team to be captained by David Sole, Bob Munro, the selection chairman, said the player had grasped his opportunity on the summer trip to Japan. 
 &bquo;Although we were disappointed at losing to Japan the emergence of Tony Stanger plus Ian Corcoran, Cameron Glasgow and Adam Buchanan-Smith emphasises the value of touring,&equo; Munro said. 
 Finlay Calder, who has yet to regain full fitness, is replaced by Graham Marshall, a 6ft 3in specialist open-side flanker who also excelled in Japan. 
 His only previous taste of international rugby was as an interval replacement against the Wallabies last year. 
 United seek values of a visionary: Ken Jones reflects on a tarnished ideal as Old Trafford struggles for a new sense of stability 
 By KEN JONES 
 MANCHESTER UNITED supporters in middle-age and beyond no doubt heaved a great sigh of relief yesterday when something akin to reasonable order was restored at Old Trafford. 
 Theirs is not an ideal shared by a generation raised on crude manifestations of pop culture, most conspicuously in this case, a brash attempt to seize control of our most internationally famous football club. 
 The ideal grew out of one man's initiative and people who referred to Sir Matt Busby as a visionary did so without hesitation because, of all the titles bestowed upon him, none appeared to be more appropriate. 
 He remains synonymous with Manchester United which is more than will ever be said about the principal figures in that disturbing saga of boardroom intrigue which has been occupying our attention this season. 
 Now this may sound like fatuous bluster but suspicion of businessmen ought to be understandable in an era of commerce made squalid by stock-market muggings on a grand scale. 
 When the dust settled yesterday Michael Knighton, a thwarted professional footballer who has been elected to the Manchester United board, spoke bitterly of the vilification he claims to have endured since moving in on the club and Martin Edwards, the chief executive. 
 In my trade this is thought to be par for the course. 
 The point is that Knighton, for all the ludicrous exhibitionism with which he announced himself to the Stretford End, decided to withdraw, despite evidence that he could indeed finance the original deal. 
 Not that the incumbent emerges from all this with any credit. 
 Having agreed to sell his shares to Knighton, thereby relinquishing the control he inherited from his father, Martin Edwards remains, at least temporarily, in the chief executive's chair although his authority will not carry much conviction. 
 &bquo;The saga is at an end. 
 It is good news for the club and the fans,&equo; Edwards said yesterday. 
 &bquo;I believe Manchester United needs a period of stability. 
 The last thing we want at the moment is talk of selling.&equo; 
 Of course there is no reason why the takeover of a football club should arouse greater interest than controversial manoeuvres in any other area of commerical life but this ignores the status Manchester United have acquired so the negotiations were bound to provoke serious misgivings. 
 Further moves can be expected, if not from without then certainly within and anyone with a feel for football, particuarly as represented by Manchester United's history, will draw some comfort from the possibility that Bobby Charlton will eventually emerge as their figurehead. 
 Rugby League: Iro offers the only reasons to be cheerful 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 Bradford Northern.. 8 New Zealand....... 26 BRADFORD NORTHERN have been making an effort this season, and reasons to be cheerful at Odsal have included cheerleaders, improved results, increased gates, two men in the Great Britain rugby league squad, an Australian at half-back and a Welshman on the wing. 
 Unfortunately, only the cheerleaders were in evidence last night. 
 Involved in a Yorkshire Cup semi-final replay this Sunday, Bradford shamelessly fielded a second-string side, risking action from the League authorities and the possible loss of a fixture against Australia next year. 
 The loyal few who paid full price at the turnstiles deserved better, but the real losers were Sheffield Eagles, who wanted a tour game and would have used the opportunity much more imaginatively. 
 New Zealand, too, fielded a side below full strength, though that is their privilege, and an uninspired 80 minutes signified little, beyond underlining the value of Kevin Iro to whichever team he happens to be playing in. 
 Iro's direct running down the wing always looked the tourists' most promising mode of attack, and on the stroke of the interval, he muscled past three defenders to give the Kiwis a 10-4 half-time lead. 
 Bradford had opened the scoring through Graham Mackay, taking advantage of Morvin Edwards' defensive naivety, but conceded a try and the lead shortly afterwards by losing the ball in their own half and enabling Dean Clark to present Tony Kemp with a simple opportunity. 
 Iro squandered a couple of chances close to the line at the start of the second half, but held on to Clark's pass to make room for Edwards to score in the 50th minute, Phil Bancroft adding a touchline goal off the post. 
 The tourists had looked decidedly ordinary at times during the first half, but combined more fluently in the second to run up their most convincing victory to date, albeit a hollow one. 
 Clark scored a fourth try, Roger Simpson clinging ineffectually to his shirt, though the visitors' impetus was halted when Mark Elia was sent to the sin bin for a high tackle on David Cooper. 
 Mackay scored a last-minute try for Bradford. 
 More worrying for the Kiwis, however, was the departure of Adrian Shelford with what looked like a pulled muscle. 
 Shelford, with Iro, is one of the few players of undoubted world class the tourists presently possess, and his absence would seriously dent New Zealand's Test hopes. 
 Rugby League: Mackey joins Warrington's first violins 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 GREG MACKEY, Warrington's Australian scrum-half who came as a two-month stop-gap but has figured prominently in the club's unbeaten start, has agreed to spend the full season at Wilderspool, writes Paul Wilson. 
 Mackey, 27, is rebuilding his career after being sacked by Canterbury, his Sydney club, and will make his ninth appearance for Warrington in Saturday's Lancashire Cup final against Oldham. 
 &bquo;Six weeks ago I thought my whole career might be up, but I love it over here,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I was aware when I came that I was only Warrington's third choice, after Michael Hagan and Trevor Kissell, so I feel doubly lucky that things have gone so well.&equo; 
 In addition to orchestrating the defeat of Widnes in Tuesday's semi-final, Mackey was one of the players to receive the kind of attention which prompted Brian Johnson, his coach, to remind referees of their duties. 
 &bquo;Head tackles are supposed to warrant full dismissal,&equo; Johnson said. 
 &bquo;Referees now have no hesitation in sending off players for tripping, but often take a more lenient view of use of the elbow, which causes far more damage.&equo; 
 Salford, who turned down a Leeds approach for Ian Bragger, yesterday listed Steve Herbert for &pound;20,000, at his own request. 
 Paul O'Neill, a 21-year-old wing from Leigh Miners, has signed professional at the Willows, while Swinton announced the signing of Vince McCue, a 23-year-old centre from New Zealand. 
 Rugby League's disciplinary committee will consider a case against Castleford's Australian forward, Ron Gibbs, in Leeds next Thursday after Gibbs was cited by Hull for dangerous tackling, in their Stones Bitter Championship game last month. 
 The League's board of directors decided in Leeds last night that there was a case to answer. 
 Motor Racing: Ferrari attack Balestre 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 FERRARI yesterday criticised the International Motor Sports Federation (FISA) for not giving Nigel Mansell a fair hearing in the continuing row over sanctions against him following his disqualification at last month's Portuguese Grand Prix. 
 The Ferrari team were upset by FISA president Jean-Marie Balestre's statement on Tuesday that an appeal against the &dollar;50,000 fine imposed on Mansell would go ahead on 18 October, despite their request that it be postponed because the Japanese Grand Prix is on 22 October. 
 Ferrari spokesman Franco Liistro said: &bquo;It's the same vice again of the defendant not being given a hearing. 
 Mansell can't be in Portugal and Japan at the same time,&equo; he said. 
 Mansell received the fine and a one-race ban, which FISA applied to the Spanish Grand Prix, after he illegally reversed his Ferrari in the pits and failed to stop at a black disqualification flag, waved three times during the race in Estoril on 24 September. 
 Liistro would not comment on Balestre's announcement that FISA's World Motor Sport Council had confirmed that Mansell's ban from the Spanish Grand Prix would stand and agreed that the result of the race, won by Senna, would stand. 
 Ferrari and Mansell have appealed to the International Automobile Federation (FIA), an umbrella organisation which includes FISA, against the race ban. 
 The Italian team gave evidence to an FIA tribunal in Paris last Thursday. 
 The FIA tribunal postponed any decision, but Balestre said it had no right to rule on the case until after the Portuguese hearing and should not have heard representation. 
 &bquo;It's strange for Balestre to criticise a tribunal he created,&equo; Liistro said. 
 Balestre is president of FISA and FIA. 
 Mansell showed his personal well-being yesterday by shattering the lap record on Ferrari's home track at Fiorano as he tested his car for the two remaining world championship races in Japan and Australia, clipping nearly two seconds off the old record. 
 Bernie Ecclestone, the vice-president of FIA will go to Buenos Aires in March to start talks with Argentinian officials on resuming Formula One events &mdash; last held there in 1981. 
 Golf: Seve on a road that Jack built 
 From TIM GLOVER at Wentworth 
 LIKE the Burma Road itself, Seve Ballesteros was showing distinct signs of wear and tear after a long, hot season. 
 Manipulating a lump of putty from finger to finger, hand to hand, he looked as if he was auditioning for the lead role in The Caine Mutiny. 
 The air was thick with paranoia as the conversation turned to the perfidious question of appearance money. 
 Volvo, the European Tour's main benefactor, had accused the leading money winners of disloyalty by not committing themselves to the end-of-season showpiece, the Volvo Masters in Spain. 
 Despite the attraction of bonuses worth &pound;250,000 and a &pound;400,000 prize fund, it looks as if Masters Ballesteros, Nick Faldo, Sandy Lyle and Bernhard Langer will not play in Spain. 
 Yesterday Ballesteros, who is at Wentworth for the Suntory World Matchplay Championship, read one British newspaper and nearly choked over his cornflakes. 
 The story is that the Volvo Masters is not on his schedule because it will not pay him to appear. 
 Perish the thought. 
 &bquo;It is very sad,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;My reasons have nothing to do with appearance money. 
 I never negotiated with Volvo and I am in a different position to Nick Faldo and Sandy Lyle. 
 If I decided to play in it, it would not be because of &dollar;50,000 but because I felt better. 
 I can't remember feeling so tired.&equo; 
 Appearance money is officially frowned upon by the European Tour but the creases in the foreheads of the officers have not been discerned by the Spaniard. 
 He is the number one draw in the game, sponsors will almost bankrupt their companies to get him and he can afford to play the market. 
 &bquo;Appearance money is not a problem,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You people are the problem. 
 It is very simple. 
 When Jack Nicklaus plays in a golf tournament, do you think he is playing under the same conditions as everybody else? 
 Everybody keeps quiet but under the table he's making money. 
 This is how it is. 
 I think Jack is right.&equo; 
 For Jack read Seve. 
 Ballesteros's dilemma is not how much money to make but how much to reject. 
 After Wentworth he will play two tournaments in Japan which means he will also miss the World Cup in his home country. 
 &bquo;It is not true that I only play this game for money. 
 I always play for my country when I have a chance,&equo; Ballesteros, who last played for Spain in the World Cup in 1977, added. 
 Even so, he admits he has not rejected enough this year. 
 &bquo;My schedule has been wrong. 
 After all the strain of the Ryder Cup I feel even more tired. 
 I haven't taken more than a week off at a time and I need some rest.&equo; 
 The prospect of equalling Gary Player's record of five victories, and the fact that he has a bye into the second round on Friday, has enticed Ballesteros to make his 14th successive appearance in the World Matchplay. 
 The field is without the Open champion, the US Open champion and the US PGA champion but rumours that Mark McCormack was thinking of inviting another of his clients, Wayne Shelford, to tackle the Burma Road are exaggerated. 
 Cricket: Larkins back on the rails 
 From TIM GLOVER at Wentworth 
 THE OLD and the new combined successfully in Delhi yesterday as England claimed victory over The Railways. 
 Wayne Larkins, who last represented his country eight years ago, scored a century then Angus Fraser, playing his first one-day game for England, took four for 21. 
 It added up to an emphatic win by 137 runs, in the first of the tourists' warm-up matches before Sunday's opening Nehru Cup match against Sri Lanka. 
 Larkins, who made 103 before retiring to give his team-mates a bat, could not have wished for a better comeback, and with Robin Smith making a stylish 70, England made 263 for four from 50 overs. 
 Railways were unlikely to threaten that target but, just in case they harboured any ambitions to get close, Fraser removed three of their first four batsmen for 10 runs in the space of 22 deliveries. 
 He came back later to claim another victim and the hosts were dismissed for 126 with 5.2 overs remaining. 
 &bquo;It was a pleasing performance after just two days&equo; practice over here,&equo; Micky Stewart, the England manager, said. 
 &bquo;It gave everyone a good introduction as to what we can expect &mdash; the weather was hot and the pitch typically flat.&equo; 
 The only disappointment for the tourists was captain Graham Gooch's failure. 
 He fell for eight, bowled by 22-year-old welfare officer, Srinivasan. 
 At least Gooch had the consolation of getting out to the best of the home bowlers, and to a man who is coached by former Indian captain, Kapil Dev. 
 Allan Lamb, the England vice-captain presently on duty in India, has been reappointed captain of Northamptonshire for 1990. 
 The county have signed up four youngsters for next season, including two local 18-year-olds - all-rounder John Hughes and batsman Russell Warren &mdash; on summer contracts. 
 Terms also have been accepted by Paul Berry, a 21-year-old batsman from Manchester, and Rugby School's prolific runscorer, Richard Montgomerie. 
 Golf: Daunting deficit faces Douglas 
 By JOHN BOLTON at Stoke Poges 
 ALTHOUGH there are only four more tournaments to count towards the final Order of Merit, there will be no end-of-season relaxing for the professionals on the European women's Tour, who tee off in the Laing Charity Classic here today. 
 A tendon injury in her left hand makes last year's winner Marie-Laure de Lorenzi, from France, an absentee this week, while Alison Nicholas, the 1987 winner, who is at the qualifying school in America, is also missing. 
 With winnings of &pound;75,134 from 11 tournaments this year, De Lorenzi is almost assured of retaining her Order of Merit title. 
 She could conceivably be denied by Kitrina Douglas, the winner of this season's St Moritz Classic and European Masters, although even if she were to win each of the last four tournaments, she still might not make up the &pound;30,000 deficit on De Lorenzi. 
 Elsewhere there are other incentives at stake in the shape of &pound;10,000, &pound;6,500, &pound;3,500 and &pound;1,500 end-of-season bonuses for the top four in the final Order of Merit. 
 For the leading three there is the additional prize of a place in the Dinah Shore tournament, while the leading two will earn invitations to next year's US Women's Open Championship. 
 Not surprisingly a strong field has assembled for this last tournament of the year in Britain. 
 Laura Davies, whose aim at the beginning of the year was to win on both sides of the Atlantic, again attempts to complete the second leg of her target. 
 Having won the Lady Keystone Open in the United States, Davies, seemingly lacking inspiration, has not finished better than fourth in her seven European outings. 
 The biggest threat to Davies may well come from Scotland's Jane Connachan, never out of the top seven in her last five tournaments, and Trish Johnson, who finished third in the Italian Open two weeks ago. 
 Squash: Parke's benchmark of success 
 From RICHARD EATON in Singapore 
 SIMON PARKE, 17 on Tuesday and England's youngest ever international, helped his country to their third 3-0 victory, this time over The Netherlands, here yesterday, ensuring a place in the quarter-finals of the world team championships. 
 Such is Parke's improvement that England felt able to rest their No. 1, Del Harris. 
 Indeed they may well risk their pale-faced prodigy again in the match against Egypt today &mdash; even though this must be won if a vital quarter-final seeding place is to be secured. 
 Parke, who yesterday beat the Dutch champion, Erik van der Pluym, 3-9, 9-2, 9-3, 9-0 may continue in the team to allow the captain, Bryan Beeson a rest. 
 Beeson, who has been showing the strain of captaincy, secured his third carefully crafted win by beating the Dutch No. 1 Hans Frieling 9-2, 9-5, 7-9, 9-1. 
 Jason Nicolle also won in four games, against Raymond Schaffer, but had to fight back from a game and 6-7 down in the second, and his place in the sudden-death phase at the weekend could be under threat from Parke. 
 Meanwhile the Australians, who hope to deny Pakistan their fifth successive world title, have their worries. 
 Rodney Martin, who had 12 stitches inserted in his scalp after hitting his head on a street sign, yesterday lost the first two games before recovering to beat the Finnish No. 3 Marko Pulli. 
 No one can quite be sure whether he will be really ready for the expected showdown with world champion Jansher Khan, which is likely to decide Tuesday's final. 
 By contrast, Jansher conceded only four points to the capable Swedish champion Anders Wahlstedt. 
 Yesterday the International Squash Players Association confirmed it had received the &dollar;15,000 (&pound;9,400) withheld after Jansher's walkout from the World Open's official dinner. 
 The ISPA plans to pay him this money later in the week but is also to discipline him. 
 The most likely punishment is a modest fine and a zero points score on the computer for the World Open. 
 Boxing: Stretch takes the short cut to victory 
 From NICK HALLING at the London Arena 
 IN ONE of the quickest and most decisive finishes to a British title fight, the glamour boy of boxing, Gary Stretch, successfully defended his light middleweight championship with a first-round stoppage of Derek Wormald. 
 Stretch, making the first defence of a title he won more than a year ago when he out-pointed Gary Cooper, caught Wormald with a perfectly timed right hook to the chin. 
 Although he managed to beat the count, Wormald was in no position to defend himself and referee Dave Parris stopped the contest with 35 seconds remaining in the opening round. 
 The result was all the more remarkable as the champion has looked vulnerable in his last two contests. 
 Although a competent fighter, Stretch was not considered to be one of the game's bigger punchers. 
 The first clean punch of the fight was landed by Wormald, who caught the champion with a solid right to the jaw. 
 But Stretch, whose aftershave-commercial good looks and bright personality have helped make him one of British boxing's most marketable commodities, soon recovered, and began to take the fight to the challenger. 
 The end was as sudden as it was unexpected. 
 Though not the most powerful punch ever thrown, Stretch's right hook was delivered with perfect timing. 
 This victory may set Stretch up with a world-title elimination fight with Britain's other leading light middleweight, Chris Pyatt. 
 Pyatt, fighting on the same bill, was in equally devastating form ending the challenge of Wayne Harris of Guyana in the third round. 
 Despite conceding large advantages of height and reach, Pyatt went to work on Harris's body with solid shots to the solar plexus. 
 Pyatt has outstanding hand speed and he demonstrated it to full effect against an opponent who was clearly out of his depth. 
 Pyatt crashed in combinations at will in the third and a punishing left to the jaw broke the Guyanan's resistance, and referee Richard Davies rightly intervened. 
 Basketball: Ramsey's wonder of the bar 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 KEITH RAMSEY'S match-winning shot for Manchester Giants in the 105-104 victory over Sunderland 76ers on Tuesday night made him the toast of the Stretford Sports Centre, particularly as all of their supporters had been confined to the bar. 
 Less than four hours before the scheduled start, the local fire brigade refused to issue a safety licence for the arena. 
 The centre's system for emergency lighting runs from a generator, which would fail in the event of a fire cutting off main electricity, so the fire officer said spectators could not be allowed in. 
 As Sunderland were already on their journey, the Giants director Jeff Jones, who is also the coach, could not call off the game and decided against moving the match. 
 When Sunderland arrived their coach, Craig Lynch, agreed to play in the absence of spectators. 
 Of the arriving crowd of 800, some 150 stayed to watch on closed-circuit TV from the centre's bar. 
 Giants could not charge admission and after cancelling match sponsorship from a local computer company, they lost some &pound;2,500 on the evening's promotion. 
 Jones is hoping for an offer of compensation from the local authority and must now look forward with added enthusiasm to 1991, when Giants are scheduled to move into their own purpose-built, multi-sport arena. 
 Ramsey's winning shot guarantees Giants will qualify for the semi-finals with Southern group leaders Kingston and Bracknell. 
 The final spot is contested by Sunderland, Leicester and Derby. 
 Last night's NatWest Trophy Match between Leicester and Derby was abandoned when Leicester's 6ft 10in Scott Paterson smashed the backboard while dunking the ball in the pre-game warm up. 
 Snooker: The young Thai breaking new ground: JANICE HALE reports on the rapid rise of James Wattana, Asia's snooker &bquo;natural&equo; 
 By JANICE HALE 
 WATTANA Po Ob Orm is a 19-year-old Thai, self-taught and naturally talented, who is the best snooker player Asia has produced. 
 With his name Anglicised to James Wattana, he will play his first match in front of British television cameras in the fourth round of the Rothmans Grand Prix on Monday. 
 He started his first season on the professional circuit by winning 21 of his first 24 matches, reaching the final of the Asian Open in his native Bangkok in August, with three wins over top 10 players before losing to Stephen Hendry. 
 Yesterday Silvino Francisco became his victim for the second time. 
 In the fourth frame of their third-round match, Wattana was on course for a maximum but missed the 12th black with the rest after potting the first 12 reds and 11 blacks. 
 This new prodigy, already 36th on the provisional list after only three ranking events, started playing in his mother's snooker club when he was nine; at 13 he made his first century and at 16 his first 147. 
 On 24 occasions, he has taken 15 reds, 15 blacks and all the colours. 
 Competitively, snooker has until the last few years been confined to Britain and its old Commonwealth, but there have always been a few tables in the Far East, catering for the needs of expats. 
 The scene changed dramatically for two reasons. 
 Export sales of Pot Black immediately proved popular with Thai television viewers, and annual tours in the early Eighties by Steve Davis and the rest of Barry Hearn's merry men presented the game's superstars in the flesh. 
 Commercial clubs started to open and snooker now has an exceptionally high profile with Wattana a national hero, and Sportsman of the Year after winning the world amateur title in Sydney last November. 
 Wattana first came in contact with the Davises and Jimmy Whites of the snooker world when he was 16, the year that a Chester club owner, Harry Wau, was on holiday in Bangkok and introduced himself to local snooker officials. 
 The outcome was a year in Chester for the young Thai, learning to speak English and furthering his snooker education. 
 He made 165 centuries in 11 months, and reached the final of the British junior championship in which he lost to Barry Pinches, a teenager from Norwich whom he was to defeat in last year's world amateur final. 
 Leading 10-8 and within a frame of the title, Wattana had the sublime confidence of youth to go for the &dollar;100,000 jackpot prize on offer for a 147, choosing reds more suitable for continuing the red-black sequence than those which offered maximum certainty of winning the title-clinching frame. 
 He reached 96 with red-blacks anyway, more than enough to secure the title. 
 He is now based in Bradford, birthplace of his manager, Tom Moran, who moved in the Sixties first to Nigeria and then to Thailand as an engineer. 
 Moran helped another expat, Maurice Kerr, with the fledgling Thailand Association in the early Eighties and now takes Wattana's important career decisions on behalf of a six-man syndicate answerable to the association. 
 Already Wattana has contracts with Nestle and Thai Airways, but the commerce of the game scarcely impinges on his single-mindedness. 
 &bquo;So far as I can see, he only thinks about snooker, his girlfriend and pop music. 
 That's about it,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;Some people said that he'd have to change his style when he turned professional, but so far he's stuck to his natural game, and he hasn't done badly with it so far. 
 I think he can win a ranking event this season.&equo; 
 Cricket: Boycott walks out of meeting 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 GEOFFREY BOYCOTT'S credibility as a member of Yorkshire's general committee was dented further yesterday when he left the emergency meeting an hour before the end, writes Derek Hodgson. 
 Sid Fielden, an erstwhile ally and chairman of the county's public relations sub-committee said afterwards: &bquo;I find his conduct difficult to understand and impossible to explain.&equo; 
 The meeting had been called, in advance of the general monthly gathering, to investigate Yorkshire's dismal record last season and to discuss a suggestion by the captain, Phil Carrick, that players born outside the county be recruited. 
 A motion calling for the signing of an overseas professional was rejected unanimously; only three votes were recorded in favour, one presumably Boycott's, of signing players born outside the county. 
 The cricket chairman, Brian Close, after what was described as a &bquo;well-briefed&equo; report invited comments. 
 Boycott was asked for &bquo;constructive questions&equo; but according to the chairman Brian Walsh, &bquo;he had none or declined to ask any&equo; at which point the former England opener left. 
 At the end of the four and half hour inquest the cricket sub-committee was asked to re-define the role of captain and chief coach, to consider whether it required a team manger and ordered to report back on 28 November when, presumably, a decision will also be made on the captaincy for next season. 
 Close said he had found the meeting &bquo;very instructive&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;A few people had their eyes opened. 
 A lot of the points discussed had also been considered by the cricket committee and we shall now make a thorough investigation.&equo; 
 A memorial service for Norman Yardley, the former Yorkshire and England captain who died last week at 74, will be held in Sheffield Cathedral, at noon, on 26 October. 
 Judo: White's hopes fade out 
 From PHILIP NICKSAN in Belgrade 
 DENSIGN WHITE, Britain's leading men's hope for a medal in the world championships leaves Belgrade without any medal at all. 
 But he came so close. 
 He did not look particularly inspired at the start of the day, but survived to make the semi-final where he met his old rival, Ben Spijkers, of the Netherlands. 
 It was very much a revenge match for White &mdash; Spijkers had beaten him for a bronze in the Seoul Olympics, though then White was injured. 
 Now White was fit &mdash; but it made no difference. 
 In the intense, cagey and close match that followed, White put in more attacks, but perhaps Spijkers' attacks were more effective. 
 Chris Bowles, the British coach, was circumspect. 
 &bquo;It sometimes looked as if Densign was attacking under pressure,&equo; he said. 
 In the bronze medal fight against Axel Lobenstein, of East Germany, White appeared to start with more aggressive determination, but his attacks were way off target and he was thrown for a yuko (five points) as he got up off the ground. 
 Jane Morris, the 21-year-old light heavyweight from Kent, also lost in the bronze medal fight, to Weifung Wu, of China. 
 But no one could question her readiness and her courage. 
 She took a decision from Stefana Drzewiecka, of Poland, was strangled by the Frenchwoman, Aline Batailler, but then had two good wins in the repechage. 
 Dennis Stewart, the Olympic light-heavyweight bronze medal-winner, lost his first fight against Jens Geisler and was not given an opportunity for the repechage. 
 Rallying: Title within Biasion's reach 
 From PHILIP NICKSAN in Belgrade 
 MASSIMO BIASION, of Italy, won the brief third stage of the San Remo Rally yesterday to keep alive his hopes of a second successive world title. 
 Though the Lancia works driver lies third overall, with a repeat of his 1988 triumph at San Remo seeming beyond him when the event ends today, a place in the top three will secure his world crown two rallies before the end of the season. 
 Yesterday, he took his new 16-valve Delta Integrale around the bumpy, one-kilometre asphalt circuit at Genoa's Christopher Columbus airport in 1min 26sec, edging out Alessandro Fiorio, his team mate and compatriot, by one second. 
 Dario Cerrato was third to complete an Italian and Lancia sweep of the top three places. 
 It was the day's only special stage before the drivers regrouped in San Remo for a midnight start to the fourth and final stage. 
 Spanish Toyota driver Carlos Sainz, the overall leader since Tuesday, has a margin of one minute over Fiorio and 1 min 41 sec over Biasion. 
 Drugs in Sport: New test under attack 
 From PHILIP NICKSAN in Belgrade 
 THE International Weightlifting Federation, stung by a wave of positive drug tests, has introduced a controversial testing system which has not been approved by the Olympic movement. 
 &bquo;We are ready to adopt the steroid profile procedure,&equo; Tamas Ajan, the general secretary of the IWF, said. 
 &bquo;It would be a good idea if other sports followed.&equo; 
 Under the system, created by West Germany's Manfred Donike, the amount of steroids in an athlete's body can be detected not only at the time the test takes place, but several months beforehand, although the actual drug is not identified. 
 The procedure has not gained formal approval by the International Olympic Committee because it does not give conclusive proof of drug use. 
 Ajan said that athletes who tested positive under the technique would not be banned, instead a warning would be issued to the national weightlifting association involved. 
 The decision was bitterly attacked by Arnold Beckett, a member of the IOC medical commission, who said: &bquo;Warning someone is tantamount to saying &bquo;you took steroids&equo;. 
 These tests do not prove that. 
 All they show is that someone has a depressed steroid profile. 
 They don't show why.&equo; 
 Sailing: Soviet skipper found hanged in forest 
 By STUART ALEXANDER 
 ALEXEI GRYSCHENKO, the joint skipper of Fazisi, the Soviet entry in the Whitbread Round the World Race, was found dead yesterday, hanged in a forest a mile from Punta del Este, Uruguay, writes Stuart Alexander. 
 Gryschenko had been missing for more than two days. 
 Police immediately began an investigation, but foul play was not suspected. 
 Early reports suggested that a note was found in Gryschenko's pocket, though neither the police nor the Soviet Embassy in Montevideo would comment. 
 Gryschenko had been known to be unhappy about embarking on the first leg of the race. 
 Eventually, he decided to continue in the role of co-skipper with the American, Skip Novak. 
 There were doubts, however, that the Soviet would be on board for the second leg. 
 Gryschenko, from Kiev, married and with a child less than a year old, joined with all the team working long into the night at Hamble to prepare Fazisi's bare hull for the race. 
 They had to overcome engineering problems, a last-minute change of keel, and the withdrawal of their sponsor. 
 Nevertheless, the yacht did well on the first leg, finishing sixth. 
 No immediate statement was made on whether the death of Gryschenko would alter plans to continue when the race leaves Punta, bound for Fremantle, on 28 October. 
 Equestrianism: Smith's Picnic in America 
 By GENEVIEVE MURPHY 
 STEVEN SMITH'S new rapport with the unpredictable Brook Street Picnic will be put to the test later this month, when he begins the tour of shows in Washington, New York and Toronto on the North American Fall Circuit, writes Genevieve Murphy. 
 Smith had Picnic's full co-operation when winning last week's leading showjumper of the year title at Wembley, making a timely impression on the selectors who have chosen him for the British team. 
 He will be joined by his brother, Robert, Peter Charles and EmmaJane Mac, who won four contests at Wembley. 
 &bquo;I bought Picnic because Nick Skelton told me to, he knew I didn't have the biggest cash flow in the world,&equo; Steven Smith said of a horse whose awkward streak would have been reflected in the price. 
 Skelton will compete at Stuttgart while Smith is on his American tour with Picnic. 
 The German show, which offers substantial prize money, has attracted all four members of Britain's European Championship-winning team &mdash; Skelton, Joe Turi and the Whitaker brothers &mdash; as well as the reserve, David Broome. 
 Racing: Muddle concept gains ground: JOHN KARTER reports on plans for an all-weather race track coming to fruition 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 INSPIRATION may not spring readily from the prosaic-sounding north Midlands town of Southwell but it is the black stuff that dreams are made of in the eyes of Ron and Richard Muddle, the father and son team of racing entrepreneurs extraordinary. 
 Southwell, as well as Lingfield, has been chosen as a first venue for all-weather racing in this country. 
 The opening meeting on the new surface at the Nottinghamshire track is on 1 November, two days after Lingfield stage their historic fixture. 
 Coming second, particularly to a course they once owned, is not a little irksome to the amiable Richard Muddle, a former Flat jockey, who allied his vast international racing experience to his father's business acumen to bring a whole new concept of sound commercial practice to racecourse management in this country. 
 &bquo;We like to be first in everything,&equo; Richard says. 
 &bquo;We designed the all-weather track for Lingfield before we sold it, so they had everything set up for them. 
 &bquo;But we will have the first National Hunt racing on all-weather anywhere in the world at our first meeting (Lingfield's opening card is all Flat) and we are also staging the first trials at racing pace on the new surface (they take place on Sunday).&equo; 
 The type of track used at Southwell is an innovative Muddle &bquo;first&equo;. 
 Officially described as Fibresand (a composite of silica sand reinforced with rot-proof synthetic fibres), which is used widely for exercise gallops, the Southwell track is actually a mixture of Fibresand, rubber particles and polymer. 
 The building of a hotel and golf course as well as an extra 30 corporate hospitality boxes at Lingfield was the sort of commercial diversification that the Muddles see as a prerequisite to transforming racecourses into the nice little earners they should be. 
 &bquo;When we took Lingfield over it was losing &pound;50,000 a year and the year before we sold it to Leisure Investments, it made a profit of &pound;690,000,&equo; Muddle junior says. 
 He is justifiably proud of what he and his father achieved at Lingfield, not least the deal they struck with the redoubtable Cyril Stein of Ladbrokes when they bought the course from his company seven years ago. 
 &bquo;There was a year of negotiation before the deal was closed and we refused their persistent demands to increase our offer of &pound;750,000,&equo; Muddle says. 
 A year ago, the Muddles sold Lingfield to its present owners for &pound;7m. 
 Having cleaned up at Lingfield, the Muddles took a circuitous route to Southwell to follow their dream of building a new super track. 
 Their hopes of starting from scratch with a leisure complex incorporating a racecourse at Thurrock in Essex were dashed at a public inquiry two years ago. 
 Then, last year, their planned purchase of Nottingham racecourse fell through. 
 In the end they fell upon Southwell, and the earth has literally moved for them since they purchased it in March. 
 They are completely tearing up the whole site, including a new turf course as well as the all-weather, but Muddle'splans extend far beyond the obvious. 
 &bquo;There's a lot more to all-weather tracks than just racing,&equo; he says. 
 That is just as well, because, after the initial curiosity value, Muddle expects the attendance to fall to around 500. 
 Already he has schemes under way to make Southwell handsomely viable, however. 
 Besides building an 18-hole golf course, and charging trainers to exercise their horses on the track, he is instigating another new concept in this country by constructing American-style barns so that training can be done at the track as it is in the United States. 
 These will be sold or leased to trainers with living accommodation. 
 All this may seem quite enough to be going on with for ordinary mortals, but, amazingly, Muddle informs us &bquo;Southwell is just a guinea-pig for Telford&equo;. 
 The Muddles have acquired a site of undeveloped agricultural land west of Birmingham which is well served by motorways and which they believe is perfect for building the ultimate racecourse. 
 The opening is scheduled for 1 January, 1991, even though they have still to obtain planning permission and Jockey Club approval. 
 &bquo;We've learnt from our past mistakes in approaching Thurrock and Nottingham and we'll use the experience we gain from Southwell to the full at Telford to build something on a far grander scale,&equo; Muddle says confidently. 
 Theirs is the sort of Muddled thinking we could all use. 
 Racing: Pace on for Nashwan 
 By HYPERION (CHRIS CORRIGAN) 
 MICHELOZZO, winner of the St Leger by eight lengths, will take on Nashwan in the Champion Stakes at Newmarket a week on Saturday after being supplemented for &pound;10,000 yesterday. 
 Henry Cecil's colt proved himself a thorough stayer when running on strongly at the end of the 1 &frac34; miles of the St Leger on rain-softened ground at Ayr, but the Champion is run over half a mile less. 
 It will be the first time Michelozzo has tackled 1 &frac14; miles, but he did win over a distance of 1 mile and 50 yards at Nottingham in April. 
 Although his owner, Charles St George, obviously feels his colt has the necessary speed for Newmarket, he and trainer Henry Cecil will no doubt be hoping for a strong pace on 21 October. 
 That appears a certainty as Sheikh Hamdan Al Maktoum, Nashwan's owner, paid &pound;20,000 yesterday to supplement two horses for the race &mdash; Polemos and Wabil, to act as pacemakers for his Derby winner. 
 The Sheikh's brother Maktoum Al Maktoum has also supplemented his easy Ascot Festival Handicap winner Braashee. 
 Altogether, there are eight supplements for the &pound;200,000 race, taking the list of acceptors to 35. 
 Nashwan won the Eclipse Stakes over the Champion Stakes distance at Sandown in July but was disappointing in the Group Two Prix Niel at Longchamp on his latest outing, finishing third to subsequent Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe flop Golden Pheasant. 
 Sheikh Mohammed's Irish 2,000 Guineas and St James's Palace winner Shaadi is one of 10 horses declared for the Group One Prix de la Foret at Longchamp on Sunday. 
 The Michael Stoute-trained colt, who will retire to stud at the end of the season, is likely to be joined by Dick Hern's improving colt Gold Seam in the seven-furlong event. 
 The Conservatives in Blackpool: Heseltine attacks Chancellor for &bquo;naivety&equo; 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 AS THE pound continued to sink, moving below the symbolic DM2.95 figure on the foreign exchanges, and shares plummeted, Nigel Lawson yesterday went into retreat at his Leicestershire constituency home to draft tomorrow's make-or-break speech for the Conservative conference. 
 The Chancellor had left Blackpool late on Monday night, after addressing party agents, but conference jitters were so great that his unexpected disappearance prompted rumours that he had gone back to London for crisis talks. 
 Those rumours were quickly quashed by the Treasury, but there remained an underlying conference mood of expectation and anticipation; wondering how Mr Lawson would respond to party concern about the economy. 
 His acute political and personal crisis was increased by a direct attack from Michael Heseltine, who said the Chancellor's attempts to shrug off the trade deficit smacked of &bquo;socialist naivety&equo;. 
 Speaking to a conference fringe meeting, he warned: &bquo;Your empty words will come back to haunt you.&equo; 
 The former Cabinet minister joined the pro-Tory Daily Mail in urging an early decision on membership of the European Exchange Rate Mechanism, something which was ruled out by a senior Cabinet source as jumping &bquo;from the puddle into the pond&equo;. 
 As for last week's increase in interest rates, which he endorsed, Mr Heseltine said: &bquo;We must not let the medicine drag out, dissipating our economic strength and dispersing our political support.&equo; 
 And in a direct repudiation of the Chancellor's repeated statements, he said: &bquo;I beg our party not to argue that a deficit on overseas trade is of incidental importance, self-correcting, easily financed. 
 I don't believe a word of it.&equo; 
 Mr Heseltine then accused the Government of standing by while &bquo;our former pre-eminence as a manufacturing nation has been steadily eroded&equo;. 
 Industry had become an ideological battleground, caught in the left-right crossfire. 
 &bquo;Interest rates twice as high as those of our competitors choke off British investment. 
 Exchange rates held up artificially high by interest rates prejudice exports and encourage imports,&equo; he said. 
 Meanwhile, ministers rallied in a concerted effort to denounce rumours of a rift between Mr Lawson and Margaret Thatcher. 
 Cecil Parkinson, regarded as a potential successor to Mr Lawson at the Exchequer, said in a BBC television interview: &bquo;You heard the Prime Minister last night say very clearly and openly that she and the Chancellor are in total agreement and that she has every confidence in him. 
 &bquo;Now I would ask you to measure what she says against rumours and speculation. 
 She's spoken out very clearly and said that those rumours are baseless.&equo; 
 As for the Chancellor himself, Mr Parkinson said: &bquo;I think he has both the backbone and the brains and the determination to see us through this difficulty.&equo; 
 But yesterday's Daily Mail said, under the front-page headline &bquo;This Bankrupt Chancellor,&equo; that Mr Lawson had betrayed the people and his party; had reneged on monetarism; and should go. 
 Although conference representatives seemed muted in their applause for Kenneth Baker, the party chairman, when he defended water privatisation, they responded well to his support for Mr Lawson's increase in interest rates. 
 Mr Baker was applauded when he said: &bquo;He did not shrink from doing what was right&hellip; 
 Some people said he was going to postpone it until after our party conference. 
 Such an act would have been deceitful and irresponsible.&equo; 
 Viewpoint: Lawson suffers for Thatcher's hatred of EMS 
 By MATTHEW SYMONDS 
 RONALD REAGAN'S ability to escape blame for his frequent lapses from even basic competence earned him the nickname &bquo;the Teflon President&equo;. 
 Mr Reagan pulled off his political con-trick through a mixture of calculating charm and genuine niceness. 
 Margaret Thatcher is working hard to become a &bquo;Teflon Prime Minister&equo;. 
 But in her case the technique employed is a great deal less attractive &mdash; it is to blame everyone but herself when things are going wrong and to make scapegoats out of able colleagues. 
 When the Chancellor, Nigel Lawson, addresses the Tory party conference this morning, he will know that despite the appearance of support from the lady at his side, it she who is almost single-handedly responsible for the undermining of his policy and his prestige. 
 There is no reason to suppose that Mrs Thatcher took any pleasure from the Daily Mail's attempt to destroy her Chancellor earlier this week. 
 But it is she who has created an atmosphere in which it is possible for her most senior minister to be publicly rubbished while she escapes without blemish or stain. 
 It is one thing for dissident ministers to buck Cabinet responsibility and risk the sack. 
 It is another for the Prime Minister to distance herself from the policies of the government of which she is head. 
 Let us be clear about the causes of our present economic travail and where the blame lies. 
 The Chancellor is not without fault. 
 He made an error of judgement, albeit one which is understandable, when he pumped additional liquidity into the system following the stock market crash of October 1987. 
 He believed that recession was a more immediate enemy than inflation and acted accordingly. 
 He then compounded that error six months later when his undeclared policy of shadowing the German mark, at a time when sterling was in high demand, resulted in a reduction of interest rates unwarranted by domestic conditions. 
 Mr Lawson's mistake was that when formal monetary targeting broke down because of the impossibility of finding any measure of money which bore an accurate relationship with nominal demand, he thought that he could use the exchange rate as an informal target. 
 He hoped that the markets would see that he had tied sterling to the Deutschmark and that they would realise that this meant a commitment to achieving German-style price stability. 
 He also hoped that success would build an unanswerable case for membership of the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System, which he believed had become vital. 
 There were three fatal flaws to the Chancellor's strategy. 
 The first was that because the exchange rate target was not explicit it was ultimately not credible. 
 The second was that by shadowing the mark outside the ERM, sterling was denied the protection afforded by the combined reserves of the other member countries. 
 The third was that when Mrs Thatcher concluded that the way was being prepared for full membership of the EMS, she was able to destroy the shadowing strategy by loudly denying its existence. 
 Since the summer of last year we have been living with the consequences of Mrs Thatcher's unreasoned dislike of the ERM. 
 She repeatedly says that inflation is too high and that its reduction must be the Government's overriding priority. 
 She has the evidence of her own experience that the achievement of low inflation through monetary discipline is not something at which either the British Treasury or the Bank of England excels. 
 She would not dispute the fact that, by contrast, the Bundesbank is very good indeed at it, nor that since inflation-prone countries, such as France and Italy, joined the Deutschmark-dominated ERM their inflation rates have been forced down to German levels. 
 Yet a combination of gut anti-European prejudice and some strange part-ideological, part-mystical belief in a largely bogus economic sovereignty (witness the events of last week) prevents her from taking the one step which would give credibility to the fight against inflation. 
 The direct results of the Prime Minister's aversion to the EMS are: interest rates which are higher than is needed to take the heat out of the economy; an incipient sterling crisis; the prospect of recession; jittery financial markets waiting in vain for a clear signal about the direction of policy; poisoned relationships with some of her most senior colleagues and Tory MPs who increasingly fear that her arrogance and stubbornness will cost them their seats. 
 If the Government was serious about regaining the initiative it has so wretchedly lost, the Prime Minister would sanction the Chancellor to announce this morning that Britain is seeking to join the ERM at the earliest practical moment. 
 The effect would be as positive as it would be dramatic. 
 Government will spend 1bn pounds to smooth poll tax: Policy initiatives in advance of election reassure party rank and file 
 By COLIN HUGHES, COLIN BROWN and ANTHONY BEVINS 
 THE GOVERNMENT will spend more than &pound;1bn before the next general election to take the sting out of the poll tax. 
 More than half the extra money &mdash; announced at the Conservative Party conference yesterday by David Hunt, the local government minister &mdash; will be spent in 1991/2, the last full financial year before the election. 
 The announcement, coming alongside the announcement of a major &bquo;green&equo; White Paper next year, signalled a clear decision by the Prime Minister to smooth the rough edges of Tory image and policy in the pre-election period. 
 Conference representatives responded with evident relief. 
 The extra cash, however, will only partly soften the impact of the introduction of the poll tax next year. 
 It will provide little help to many Tories, particularly in London, who will be fighting local elections next May. 
 Sir Rhodes Boyson, the MP for Brent North, who has led the Tory backbench campaign to wring more funds from the Treasury, argued that more money should have been provided for next year. 
 But John Heddle, who chairs the Conservative parliamentary environment committee, was confident it would be enough to &bquo;buy off&equo; most of those Tory MPs, particularly in marginal seats in the North and North-west of England, who have been putting intense pressure on ministers. 
 Roy Thomason, Tory chairman of the Association of District Councils, said: &bquo;This is just what's needed.&equo; 
 He would be seeking assurances from ministers that administrative costs would be covered from central funds. 
 David Blunkett, Labour's local government spokesman, said the announcement meant that the Government had admitted defeat over the poll tax, and that the money was solely aimed at the next election. 
 Chris Patten, the Secretary of State for the Environment, later countered: &bquo;If the Labour Party are accusing us of an electoral bribe, it shows that they find it rather difficult to criticise us on any other grounds.&equo; 
 He added that the measures announced yesterday would be the last change to the Government's poll tax plans. 
 &bquo;These are the terms and conditions on which we will be introducing the community charge,&equo; he told a press conference at the Blackpool conference. 
 The Treasury has agreed, under pressure from the Cabinet last Thursday, to spend about &pound;1.3bn over the next four years in two separate ways. 
 The first &mdash; which will start in April next year, and run for three years &mdash; is a new system of transitional protection for those households that stand to lose most from the abolition of domestic rates. 
 From the outset, no individual or couple will lose more than &pound;3 a week from the changeover so long as their local council spends according to government assumptions. 
 Where the council &bquo;overspends&equo; government targets of an increase of no more than 8.3 per cent in spending next year, some poll tax payers may lose more. 
 The &pound;156-a-year cap on losses is expected to help 6 million people in the first year of the poll tax. 
 It will also be specially targeted at pensioners and disabled people who do not currently pay rates, a decision which will probably add 400,000 pensioners to the beneficiaries. 
 That protection for individual losers will cost &pound;300m next year, around &pound;200m the year after, and &pound;100m the year after that. 
 The other plank of the announcement is that, after the first year, better-off councils will no longer have to contribute to the &bquo;safety net&equo; originally designed to ease the impact on those areas of the country which are set to lose. 
 That will cost the Treasury &pound;400m in the second year of the poll tax, &pound;200m in the third, and &pound;85m in the fourth. 
 The package will be extended to Wales, and retrospectively to Scotland, where the poll tax is already in force. 
 On the eve of Nigel Lawson's make-or-break speech to the Tory conference in Blackpool, an opinion poll last night suggested that 68 per cent of the voters had little confidence in his management of the economy. 
 The Guardian/ICM poll, taken last week when interest rates went up to 15 per cent, also found that Labour had maintained its 10 per cent lead over the Conservatives. 
 Pressure on the pound lightened yesterday as financial markets decided to suspend judgement until they heard what the Chancellor had to say, a mood which was reflected among Conservative representatives. 
 Mr Lawson returned to Blackpool from his Leicestershire home yesterday, and he will reply to a debate on the economy at around noon today. 
 The party will want him to resolve concern about high interest rates and mortgages, the weaker pound and higher inflation. 
 John Biffen, the former Leader of the Commons and Chief Secretary to the Treasury, said yesterday he found government policy &bquo;confusing&equo;, and party nerves were not calmed by a fringe speech from Sir Geoffrey Howe, the deputy prime minister, which echoed some of Michael Heseltine's criticism on Tuesday of government policy and presentation. 
 The Conservative Conference: Patten launches Tories' green shift 
 By COLIN HUGHES, Political Correspondent 
 A REVIEW of all government policy affecting the environment was announced yesterday by Chris Patten, the Secretary of State for the Environment, in a Conservative Party conference speech that flagged a shift in the Government's ideological stance. 
 The review will lead to a &bquo;green&equo; White Paper, planned for publication next summer and likely to provide the kernel of the Tories' next general election manifesto. 
 It will move the Government away from its emphasis on unfettered market forces, towards the need for intervention and regulation to protect people's quality of life. 
 A Cabinet committee, expected to be chaired by the Prime Minister, will be set up soon to look at the broadest possible scope of environmental policy, taking in road traffic, housing, agriculture, the rural economy, energy, and industrial development, as well as the obvious &bquo;green&equo; areas of policy such as planning, waste disposal and pollution. 
 The committee will therefore include ministers from most of the main Whitehall departments. 
 A strong Treasury presence is certain, because methods of placing a cost on the environment will be one of the key questions to be decided by the review. 
 It will, for example, decide whether the Government wants to adopt the approach advocated by Professor David Pearce &mdash; Mr Patten's main outside adviser &mdash; of taxing polluters. 
 One possibility is that the Government will advocate a &bquo;carbon&equo; tax on the burning of fossil fuels &mdash; oil, gas and coal. 
 But ministers would almost certainly prefer such a &bquo;green&equo; tax, designed to limit planetary damage, to be introduced according to international agreements, rather than by Britain alone. 
 The main shift, however, is in the new emphasis the White Paper is bound to place on intervention and regulation, words that have been regarded as mostly unpalatable in Tory conference debates over the past decade. 
 Mr Patten said that, just as there was &bquo;an overwhelming moral argument for prudent management of the economy&equo;, so there was also &bquo;an ethical argument for prudent management of the environment&equo;. 
 He added later, with Margaret Thatcher applauding alongside, that it was &bquo;for government to regulate on behalf of the community&equo;. 
 Only one representative came to the podium to protest against the dilution of free-market principles. 
 Mr Patten spelled out his direction even more explicitly in a BBC radio interview, by linking his line to the Disraeli tradition of Toryism. 
 &bquo;The market isn't enough, and I don't think that Tories have ever believed the market is enough. 
 We've always believed that the market has to be regulated; that's what Disraeli and Peel were all about in the nineteenth century,&equo; he said. 
 Green campaigners welcomed the tone and direction of Mr Patten's conference speech. 
 Jean Lambert of the Green Party said it was &bquo;pace-setting&equo;, and added: &bquo;I wish him luck &mdash; though I am sceptical about his chances.&equo; 
 De Klerk gives Mandela and ANC a growing role: South Africa's white leader, who yesterday met black churchmen, is already deferring to Nelson Mandela, John Carlin writes 
 By JOHN CARLIN 
 NOW THAT President F W de Klerk has announced the release of eight of the nine most prominent political prisoners in South Africa, the question is when &mdash; not if &mdash; the ninth, Nelson Mandela, will be freed. 
 And it is looking increasingly as if the date will be as much Mr Mandela's own decision as the government's. 
 For the most remarkable thing to have emerged from Mr de Klerk's decision is the degree to which Mr Mandela and the exiled African National Congress have become participants in government decision-making. 
 He has acquired an autonomy and influence staggering even by the standards of a country where anomalies are institutionalised. 
 Indications of Mr Mandela's growing political stature in the eyes of the government have been accumulating for some time. 
 One paragraph in Mr de Klerk's statement on Tuesday announcing the release of Mr Mandela's old associate Walter Sisulu provided the final piece of the jigsaw. 
 &bquo;It is necessary to state,&equo; Mr de Klerk said, &bquo;that Mr Nelson Mandela is fully appraised of these proposed releases. 
 In fact, discussions were held with him and he considered yet again that his release is not now on the agenda.&equo; 
 Mr de Klerk, so eager to placate Margaret Thatcher and international opinion generally, was saying, between the lines: &bquo;Look, I know you're asking for Mandela's release. 
 But what can I do? 
 He doesn't want to go out yet.&equo; 
 Even if that is not the whole truth, &mdash; clearly, the government has a crucial say -Mr de Klerk has gone on record as recognising that Mr Mandela has leverage in government decisions. 
 The deference the government is showing him points to the recognition, finally, that Mr Mandela is the symbolic leader of the disenfranchised black majority, and that he is, accordingly, a key player. 
 By extension, so is the ANC, whose influence successive South African governments have attempted, frantically and quite without success, to wish away. 
 Mr Mandela, thus, has already begun on his own the negotiating process that Mr de Klerk's government claims to seek with black leaders. 
 Maybe without fully recognising it, the government has, in fact, started talking to the ANC &mdash; for if there is one thing Mr Mandela has made clear throughout his long incarceration, it is his unwavering allegiance to the movement, whose foremost leader he remains. 
 Mr Mandela's hand was discernible in the ANC negotiating proposal put out in August; in the successful campaign of mass protest before the 6 September white election; and in a silent scheme by some of the leaders of the black &bquo;homelands&equo; to flat-foot Mr de Klerk by publicly declaring that the country cannot be partitioned along racial and tribal lines. 
 The conclusion is irresistible that Mr Mandela is exploiting the government's growing dependence on him to extend his influence to the many black organisations whose adoptive leader he is. 
 Where there is possibly a meeting of minds between him and the government is in the desire not to release him into a political vacuum. 
 In the eyes of both, it would make sense not to have him roaming the country generating huge gatherings with a politically futile, and possibly violently anarchic, outcome. 
 Mr Mandela needs a ready-made negotiating structure in which he can play the decisive role that his authority requires. 
 Someone close to Mr Mandela described him yesterday as a chess player five moves ahead of anyone else in the game. 
 E German leaders set limit to reform 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 EAST GERMANY'S Communist leaders said last night they were prepared to discuss ways of improving life in their country. 
 But they flatly refused to relinquish their grip on power. 
 In a long statement read out on television after the evening news, the Politburo admitted for the first time that it was &bquo;not indifferent&equo; to the mass exodus of its people to West Germany. 
 It promised to discuss issues including better economic performance, &bquo;democratic togetherness&equo;, better goods, opportunities to travel and a healthy environment, but rejected any idea of reforming the system. 
 There was no confirmation of an agency report that Erich Honecker, the East German leader, might resign, although he has postponed a planned visit to Denmark. 
 Until now Mr Honecker has rejected any idea of change, but Kurt Hager, 77, East Germany's oldest and most authoritative Communist ideologue, said yesterday that the party's immediate task was to work out &bquo;a precise idea as to how to bring about a necessary renewal&equo;. 
 Further pressure came from Poland's announcement yesterday that it had stopped sending home East Germans who crossed the border illegally with the aim of reaching West Germany. 
 Teenagers happy at home 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 THE BRITISH teenager is happy at home and one in three do not want to leave the parental nest ever, according to a survey carried out by The Indy this week. 
 The weekly paper for the young and independent, published today, asked 500 12 to 15-year-olds how happy they were at home and 79 per cent said they did not want to leave before the age of 18. 
 This week's 20-page colour issue of The Indy also has a quiz for young people to test where their parents come on the embarrassment scale. 
 The paper also reports on the role of the police, talks to people who make a living out of trivia question machines and has an exclusive interview with Lenny Henry, in which he reveals his top jokes. 
 There are reviews of the latest films and the week's new records. 
 The Indy costs 40p and is available from all good newsagents this morning. 
 &bquo;The Independent&equo; wins awards 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 For the third year running The Independent has been named overall sport pages winner in the national daily newspapers category of the Linotype-Printing World newspaper design awards. 
 The newspaper was yesterday also named joint winner, with the Bucks Free Press, of the 1989 Allen Hutt award for the outstanding use of photography throughout the newspaper. 
 The Independent was the overall national newspaper winner in 1988 and 1987. 
 Oliver Gillie, deputy editor of The Independent Magazine and formerly medical editor of the newspaper, won a special award for the paper's health page, in yesterday's first presentation of the Caroline Walker awards, created in memory of the campaigning nutritionist who died last year. 
 Sleeve Notes 
 By GILES SMITH 
 THE LAST batches of refugees to slip loose over the Hungarian border before regulations tightened up again, included an East German thrash metal band. 
 They call themselves Rektum, and all signs suggest they enjoyed what you might call a safe passage. 
 Not surprisingly, in their rush they were disinclined to hump mounds of electrical equipment into the west with them, and would now find themselves without so much as a guitar string to their name, were it not for the warm-hearted generosity of the British thrash metal community. 
 The band came to rest in Bristol, where they are currently being housed by Shane, owner of the city's thrash record label, Manic Ears. 
 Last night a benefit concert was set to take place at the Bristol Bierkeller, featuring Extreme Noise Terror, perhaps Britain's foremost thrash band, now legendary for turning out songs which clock in at under one second. 
 Doctor and The Crippens were also scheduled to appear, as were Sore Throat, and the guest list seemed likely to be something of a hardcore Who's Who? &mdash; or at any rate, a hardcore Who's That? 
 Rektum will spend the money on reassembling their career in a less pressurised climate: up to now their recordings have only been available on bootleg cassettes, while their live performances have taken place exclusively underground. 
 FORBES, the American business magazine has published its table of top-earning show-business stars, which reveals that, for the second year running, Michael Jackson is the world's highest-paid entertainer. 
 Last year he took home something in the region of &dollar;60 million: this year he will have to find room under the bed for 65. 
 You would have thought this would be enough to keep him in bread and circus animals for the foreseeable future, but there are rumours that he intends to watch the money grow by buying out Jobete Music, publishers of the Motown catalogue &mdash; a snip at &dollar;175 million. 
 Jackson already owns the rights to most of The Beatles' songs and would, if successful, suddenly have shares in former label-mates Stevie Wonder and Diana Ross. 
 This is rather like growing up and buying your parents. 
 Meanwhile, Brian Wilson, the former Beach Boy, would be happy enough to get some of his own songs back. 
 His father sold off some copyrights in 1969 when, as Wilson's lawyers now claim, Brian could not be claimed to be of sound mind. 
 But then, in 1969, who could? 
 INTERVIEW / Message misunderstood: Singer and songwriter Joe Jackson, playing in London after a three-year absence, talks to Giles Smith 
 By GILES SMITH 
 IF THERE is one thing Joe Jackson particularly dislikes, it is being made a fuss of. 
 And if there is one thing that West London hotels particularly enjoy, it is making a fuss of Joe Jackson. 
 Which might go some small way towards explaining why this weekend's concerts are Jackson's first in London for three years. 
 It was the kind of hotel where detailed civilities attend even the most straightforward arrangements. 
 While Jackson, who had just returned from filming a television clip, was mildly bemoaning the pressure it had placed on him to be &bquo;incredibly entertaining for one minute&equo;, his press officer was engaged in ordering him a beer from room service. 
 Her hand cupped over the receiver, she began to relay the endless continental choices, in a list sounding like a Bavarian family tree. 
 You noticed a vaguely pained expression enter Jackson's eyes, as if he was wondering why nothing ever proved simple. 
 But then large portions of Jackson's years as a recording artist have been spent picking back through complications he had no intention of creating. 
 Take, for instance, his most famous song, &bquo;Is She Really Going Out With Him?&equo;. 
 Where Jackson had in mind a playful swipe at other people's romantic success, some of those other people read a venomous resentment. 
 &bquo;It was as if I had a vast chip on my shoulder. 
 That was supposed to be a funny song, and I can't understand how people couldn't see it. 
 You open a song with a line like &bquo;Pretty women out walking with gorillas down my street&equo; &mdash; well, what do you have to do?&equo; 
 Jackson may well have the spirit of punk to blame for the misunderstanding. 
 His first two albums (Look Sharp! and I'm The Man, released at either end of 1979) owed their sweaty energy to the push and shove of new wave. 
 Meanwhile Jackson himself, a gangly six foot four, with a hairline not so much receding as speeding flat out towards his neck, was easily slotted in with the other unlikely pop stars, taking their surly revenge on the conventional way of doing things. 
 Nevertheless there were features that set Jackson apart even then. 
 For one thing, very few punks could claim to have passed through the Royal College of Music on a piano scholarship, nor really to have worked on their musical discipline by backing bouzouki players in Greek restaurants, or a plethora of cabaret acts in The Playboy Club, Portsmouth. 
 In fact, while punk was at its phlegmy height in 1977, Jackson was employed as musical director for Opportunity Knocks winners, Coffee and Cream. 
 &bquo;I wanted to make a living out of music, any way I could. 
 I figured it was better than working in a factory. 
 And cabaret and pop are hardly on different planets.&equo; 
 In retrospect, it seems unsurprising that subsequent Jackson LPs should have found themselves weaving through a variety of musical styles. 
 Yet somehow it brought him more explaining to do. 
 &bquo;I get this image foisted on me &mdash; the musical chameleon, changing my style all the time. 
 People say that after my first two &bquo;punk&equo; albums, I did a &bquo;reggae&equo; album (Beat Crazy, 1980), and then a &bquo;swing&equo; album (Joe Jackson's Jumpin' Jive, 1981). 
 When I listen to a piece of music, my first questions have to do with whether it moves me, does it have anything unique to tell me, and questions about what style it's in are way down the list. 
 Critics seem to have it the other way round, so there's a lot of stuff talked about me using different styles, but there doesn't seem to be much said about whether it works, or whether it's done with taste, or whether the end result is worth having. 
 I think I've made different kinds of Joe Jackson albums. 
 There's a thread running through them, but you have to sit down and listen to them before that sinks in.&equo; 
 Jackson recently sat down and listened through his collected works, prior to making selections for the current live show, and found the thread wearing a little thin in places. 
 &bquo;Hearing the early stuff can be embarrassing, like discovering love letters you'd written when you were 15.&equo; 
 So the song &bquo;Sunday Papers&equo; has had to go ('I re-wrote the lyrics for the last tour - called it &bquo;Monday Papers&equo;. 
 There was nothing I could do for it this time'), but &bquo;Is She Really Going Out With Him?&equo;, formerly ditched, now finds itself reinstated, although apparently in a setting designed to tease out its reluctant humour once and for all. 
 If his own reactions to past work are subject to shifts, the response of fans bewilders him even more. 
 &bquo;I still find it amazing that intelligent-looking people will come up and say they think Look Sharp! is a good record. 
 But then people do have a thing about first albums.&equo; 
 Jackson is the first to admit that the numbers of people having a thing about some of the later material have taken a dip. 
 He had his largest commercial success in 1982 with Night and Day, directly following his emigration to New York. 
 The album pulled a few Manhattan fads (salsa, jazz, R&amp;B) into snappy pop figures and also revealed a newly flexible capacity in Jackson's voice; previously hard-edged and impatient, it could now sit comfortably on the grand slopes of a ballad like &bquo;Breaking Us In Two&equo;, a Top 20 hit in America. 
 Yet subsequent projects revealed an almost unerring instinct for commercial blackspots. 
 The album of music for the film Mike's Murder was left looking limp after John Barry had been hired, at the last minute, to replace sizeable parts of Jackson's score on the actual soundtrack. 
 Then there was the three-sided live LP, Big World (1986), during the recording of which the audience was asked to observe silence. 
 And the accounts department at A&amp;M probably stopped short of throwing a party when Jackson delivered the tapes for 1987's Will Power, an orchestral instrumental album. 
 ('I got called pretentious for that, but you have to watch the rock &bquo;n&equo; roll posing on MTV to see people really taking themselves seriously. ') 
 This year's Blaze of Glory featured in the region of an hour of strong tunes, eclectically arranged, and it is among these that the current live show centres. 
 &bquo;It's meant to be theatrical, by which I don't mean lasers and fireworks. 
 There are 11 people in the band, all dressed to project their own characters. 
 A Canadian reviewer said they looked like people I'd found at a bus-stop, which I was very flattered by.&equo; 
 It is, perhaps inevitably, some way from the limb-flinging Jackson performances of old, during which, twisting into the microphone, Jackson's body would appear to be making off in several directions at once. 
 &bquo;The idea then was to go completely beserk for an hour, but there's more to life than that. 
 Besides, if that's what people want, there will always be young bands with raging hormones ready to supply it.&equo; 
 These days, Jackson seems to be minding his energies more carefully, prepared, in at least one respect, to make a small fuss of himself. 
 The opening show was still days away, but he was valiantly avoiding cigarettes in the interests of his voice. 
 &bquo;I have a passion for Disque Bleu, and it doesn't do the singing much good. 
 &bquo;Actually, I've thought about giving up,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;The singing, that is. 
 So I can concentrate on smoking full time.&equo; 
 Joe Jackson appears at the Hammersmith Odeon tonight and tomorrow. 
 RECORDS / Around the world in a daze 
 By JIM WHITE 
 ERASURE Wild (Mute C Stumm 75) Vince Clarke is a one-man exception to the rule that manufactured, electronic pop lacks imagination. 
 First with Depeche Mode (who, despite his departure, remain the group exception), then Yazoo and now in Erasure, with Alison Moyet soundalike Andy Bell, his career is littered with fine, soulful tunes. 
 And this album continues that tradition, presenting a boggling variety of melody and pace, which, only once, on &bquo;You Surround Me&equo;, resorts to the awful &bquo;Oxygene'-style bubbling rumble which passes for rhythm in the world where the programmer is king. 
 There are guitars in here, a piano and even a harpsichord. 
 Either that, or Vince's computers are even better mimics than we thought. 
 The lyrics, strangely, seem more mechanical than the tunes. 
 &bquo;Piano Song&equo;, for instance, includes lines like &bquo;My vulnerability rushes up to me&equo; and &bquo;The deeper I delve into the conciousness of me and you&equo;, which sound as though they have been selected from a random computer-search for meaningful phrases in a dictionary of pretension. 
 But never mind. 
 From the jolly cod-flamenco romp of &bquo;La Gloria&equo;, to the &bquo;infinite complexities&equo; of the wonderful top ten hit &bquo;Drama&equo;, this album will keep you dancing and jogging, if not singing, all autumn long. 
 REAL SOUNDS OF AFRICA 7 Miles High (Big 1) One of the attractions of World Music, as identified by its advocates, is that it offers an antidote to the studio world of Erasure and their ilk. 
 Fresh, spontaneous, natural and not sung in an American accent, it is a proposition implicit in Real Sounds of Africa's very name. 
 But, if it is untainted purity you are looking for, go elsewhere. 
 This is very much the hybrid sound of Africa, and all the better for it. 
 Growing up in Zimbabwe the group were as likely to hear a record by The Beatles as they were one by a local performer. 
 Their distinctive sound grew from adapting rock forms and instruments, and, eventually, it was in the pubs and folk festivals of Britain that they began to achieve some sort of prominence, while back home the discos of Harare pulsated to the real sound of Whitney Houston. 
 The result of this cocktailing of influences is a vastly entertaining album, with lots of spritely guitars (ex-Housemartin Norman Cook was responsible for the mixing) and get-up-and-jig rhythm. 
 Perhaps it is only in some of the lyrics, which exhibit a kind of simple, home-spun philosophising strangely absent from an Erasure album, that Africa remains untainted. 
 Could you imagine John Lydon, for instance, admitting to the importance of the matriarch like this? 
 &bquo;When I was young my mama used to say &bquo;grow up and see how tough the world is&equo; ' and &bquo;I was unhappy at my mother's death/ I was unhappy at my father's death/&hellip; 
 I had no one left to give me advice&equo;. 
 But it is only in some of their lyrics that this cleanliness of vision appears. 
 One song reveals the damaging influence on their minds of their sojourn in London: &bquo;Soccer Fan&equo; is a peon of praise to Everton's midfield cruncher, Norman Whiteside. l CURIOSITY KILLED THE CAT Get Ahead (Mercury) You can tell that Curiosity Killed The Cat haven't been around for some time. 
 Firstly pictures of their lead singer, Ben Volpierre Pierrot, have stopped appearing in the front sections of Sunday newspaper supplements captioned by bad puns on his name, and secondly the single from this album is all about leaving messages on an answering machine. 
 Whatever enforced their absence for the last couple of years, it wasn't an extensive search for a new musical direction. 
 Second-hand soul, funky horns, wandering blues-style vocals, all derivative life is here. 
 The band, made up of sophisticated London rich boys, never really looked happy as teen heart-throbs. 
 So perhaps their disappearance was a brave bid to shake off that old image (two years is long enough to be forgotten in teen land) and appeal to a broader church. 
 Brave, but probably mistaken: even teen success is better than no success at all. 
 l IAN McCULLOCH Candleland (WEA UK: WX303C) Ian McCulloch was the most memorable thing about Echo And The Bunnymen, the Liverpool acid revivalists of the early Eighties (acid as in Syd Barrett, psychedelia and funny oily slides put over the spotlights, rather than mega-profitable discos in aircraft hangars and gate-crashing visits from the uniformed branch). 
 He was the one with the distant, distracted look and the voice which sounded as though it were the product of an experiment by Dr Timothy Leary. 
 All of these things can be found here, in an album which could well be a Bunnymen work, were it not for the absence of much of the pomposity to which they were inclined (though, unrepentant fans will note, not all of it judging by track titles like &bquo;The White Hotel&equo; and &bquo;Proud to Fall&equo;). 
 It is a consistent piece, full of melodies that quickly start to nag, expensive arrangements and above it all McCulloch's ingenuous, whispering, conspiratorial voice. 
 &bquo;Horse's Head&equo; (a Godfather of a track), &bquo;The Flickering Wall&equo; and the title track should provide acid fans with as big a fix as they will need until the next Wonder Stuff album. 
 l THE JESUS AND MARY CHAIN Automatic (WEA BYN 20) The Reid brothers' leather-clad thrashers were the most punk of post-punk groups. 
 Ill-disciplined in the hair, stage presence and amplifier feedback departments, their slouched, apparently indifferent performances were the most compelling thing since the demise of the Sex Pistols. 
 Sad to report, then, that they have been taken into the studio with this album and produced. 
 There are two or three strange things in there which, while hardly melodies, might qualify as tunes, several of them coming to satisfactory conclusions. 
 The speakers hardly whine and Jim Reid now sings with a US accent, rather than mumbling in a Scots one &mdash; it all sounds improbably adult-oriented. 
 Blindfolded and presented with this and a Def Leppard album, sensible money could be put on 80 per cent of those challenged failing to tell the two apart. 
 INTERVIEW / Littlechap at large: Songwriter and performer Anthony Newley talks to Mark Steyn about the return of Stop The World 
 By MARK STEYN 
 &bquo;DID YOU know,&equo; enquires Anthony Newley, by way of an ice-breaker, &bquo;that Leonard Rossiter died in this dressing-room? 
 I didn't know him, but I'm told he was a very nice man.&equo; 
 Perhaps it was Newley's ex-wife and Rossiter's Cinzano co-star, Joan Collins, who volunteered this judgement, for it's hard to find any other connection between a strictly domestic sitcom performer and one of the highest-earning acts in Vegas and Atlantic City. 
 Surveying the solitary chair and bare mattress, the missing lightbulbs round the mirror, you understand why for much of the time Newley keeps his eyes closed, picturing maybe the backstage steamrooms and personal barmen of American showbiz. 
 Dressing Room One, Lyric Theatre, who needs it? 
 &bquo;It's true,&equo; he says, &bquo;there comes a time in your life when comfort matters. 
 America is very comfortable &mdash; especially California, but we all know that in a lot of ways it's not culturally satisfying. 
 You could go mad there. 
 There are a lot of people who think Newley's very strange. 
 I think Newley's very strange.&equo; 
 He refers to himself in the third person quite frequently, almost as if his stage persona is a separate being. 
 If it is, it none the less dates back explicitly to 1961 when he played Littlechap, the Everyman figure who makes it big, in Stop The World &mdash; I Want To Get Off at the Queen's. 
 But if it's taken him 28 years to rediscover the show, the character's never left him: &bquo;All that Cockney toughness is just a cover for the inability to love,&equo; he says of Littlechap, but it could as easily apply to him ('I'm desperately childish. 
 One does not marry three women if one is an adult human being. '). 
 That's why he's never tired of singing the show's big ballad. 
 &bquo;I never had the hit with &bquo;What Kind Of Fool Am I?&equo; 
 Sammy Davis did. 
 But Newley sings it in a way that personalises it. 
 I sing it practically every night of my life, because, like bits of Hamlet, it's so obvious that the trick is to go against the lyric and stir in your listener the real sense of a man who cannot love. 
 In the arrangement in my act, the song floats on top of a piano sonata: it's the Brechtian thing of throwing responsibility for the sentiment to your audience.&equo; 
 Before Stop The World, Newley was a rock'n'roller, spoofing Elvis in the film Idle On Parade. 
 But the parody was mistaken for the real thing, and the songs made the charts. 
 Now, his songs are intended as the real thing, but widely assumed to be some sort of parody. 
 All those mannerisms &mdash; the splayed feet, the cupped hands, the exaggerated furrows of the brow, the strange vowel sounds -, surely he can't mean it? 
 &bquo;I wasn't aware of my effect,&equo; he insists. 
 &bquo;I was so inside the lyric, my body had a life of its own. 
 When I first saw myself imitated, I was in shock for days. 
 They made me look and sound like a freak: &bquo;Gonna build a mown-tine.&equo; 
 I swore I'd never take my hands out of my pockets again. 
 I may sing like Marcel Marceau, but it was never a style. 
 It's just the way I make my noise.&equo; 
 He's specialised in tortured individuals, spilling his guts on self-taunting lyrics like &bquo;The Man Who Makes You Laugh&equo;: go on, Mr Funny Man, entertain us. 
 The last time we met he was singing the number at a Friars' Club gala in New York and, for all the lofty intellectual disdain one feels obliged to muster at tuxedo circuit events, it was undeniably impressive to see him afterwards, the only British subject in the room, surrounded by Lauren Bacall, Lena Horne and Gwen Verdon. 
 &bquo;The respect of my peers has been desperately important.&equo; 
 He pauses. 
 &bquo;Perhaps too important.&equo; 
 He pauses again. 
 &bquo;The Man Who Makes You Laugh&equo; is an indulgence. 
 &bquo;Civilians&equo; don't really understand it, about the waiters in the deli and all that. 
 Maybe I should concentrate on pleasing the public more. 
 But why are you gifted? 
 Why do you create? 
 I'd love to be a record success again, but the last LP I made was so bloody personal it was ludicrous: you can't write songs about those you love, your children, and expect other people to buy them&hellip; 
 Perhaps this is all too heavy for you?&equo; 
 No, but the gloomy prognosis does Newley an injustice. 
 After all, at a time when the British musical was despised, he did write, direct and star in several notable exceptions to the rule &mdash; a sort of Kenneth Branagh of the early Sixties, except that Branagh's yet to take Broadway, doesn't compose music, and has never had a No 1 record. 
 &bquo;I'm basically a loner in a collaborative field, and I thought everything was possible,&equo; says Newley. 
 &bquo;I sometimes wonder what it would be like if Stop The World had had a proper director, who did it for a living. 
 But I was seduced by the thought that I could pull it off. 
 Jack of all trades&hellip; well, you know the rest of it.&equo; 
 His best work, including Stop The World, was written with Leslie Bricusse. 
 &bquo;Why did we stop? 
 Neither of us knows the answer. 
 Newley and Bricusse would both like to find another Newley and Bricusse, with somebody else &mdash; just to change the sheets. 
 You have mixed emotions about any collaboration &mdash; there's a lot of subjugation, a lot of domination.&equo; 
 He stops, creases his brows and stares with closed eyelids into the distance, as if wrestling with some new concept. 
 &bquo;Being gifted without discipline is a wasted gift. 
 I lack discipline. 
 Leslie brought form to my passion. 
 In print this won't look too good over breakfast, but I have to say there is more to this chapter of our being then we know. 
 I have probably been in a family relationship with Leslie in 12 previous lives.&equo; 
 The belief in relationships which outlast our present existence might explain why he's been more complacent than Bricusse about his time since the split. 
 &bquo;Leslie has always been disappointed in me because I didn't continue. 
 We wrote these extraordinary shows, and then I just put on a dinner-jacket, started singing and gave them up.&equo; 
 When he returned to the theatre in 1983 for Chaplin, it was an almighty flop. 
 &bquo;I had an open cheque on Broadway. 
 Amazing how we screwed it up. 
 But I'd stayed away too long, I'd forgotten everything. 
 My God, for 15 years I'd written nothing but a few songs.&equo; 
 If all this self-doubt is part of the act, it's a brilliant performance. 
 You begin to appreciate why Newley has become a rich and famous celebrity playing poor failed nobodies. 
 And, in the end, if much of the promise is still unfulfilled, in his own words, &bquo;I ain't done too bad. 
 There was nothing in my background to suggest I wouldn't be just another East End kid.&equo; 
 Then, at 14, he landed the Artful Dodger in Oliver Twist. 
 &bquo;Every day, I'd cycle from Clapton to King's Cross, take the train to Pinewood, then the bus to the studio to be directed by David Lean in scenes with Alec Guinness. 
 Then, every night I'd return to that street and live in one room with my mother. 
 Why wouldn't one want to stay in that world? 
 Why would one want to go back to Clapton?&equo; 
 Today, closer to Clapton (geographically) than he's been in a long while, Anthony Newley is relishing the chance to prove he's still up to a tough dramatic performance eight shows a week and, to follow, he has plans for a musicalised Richard III. 
 &bquo;I know there are any number of other musical versions and I'm not a Shakespearean actor, yet I feel comfortable with him. 
 You see, the musical theatre is overdressed at the moment. 
 I've nothing against aeroplanes landing on stage, but there should be a place for personal musicals, and frankly they're all I know how to write. 
 I've been on automatic pilot for 25 years. 
 But now my personal life has been&hellip; simplified, and I'm back two doors away from where it all started, maybe I've been offered a new beginning.&equo; 
 THEATRE / The wax and wane of property values: Singer &mdash; RSC, Stratford 
 By PETER KEMP 
 ONE OF Peter Flannery's earliest plays was called Savage Amusement. 
 Singer, his latest work, aims to provide this, along with lashings of fierce emotion. 
 Billed as &bquo;a modern Jacobean tragi-comedy&equo;, it seeks to graft the sickening thrills and sickened satire of seventeenth-century revenge plays onto a contemporary drama of cruelty and decadence. 
 Like its prototypes, it deals in grisly encounters between the evil and the wronged and trades in horror, black farce and exultantly appalled expose of the grossness, callousness and cynicism of the rich and powerful. 
 At its start, a chorus figure &mdash; played with chipper authority by Joe Melia - strolls on stage and talks about the importance of remembering. 
 He is in ARP uniform; sirens wail and searchlights flicker. 
 But the memory lane he points the audience down isn't one that starts in Britain. 
 Dragging open a curtain to reveal an advancing line of emaciated near-cadavers in filth-caked concentration camp uniforms, he takes you back to Auschwitz. 
 Here, as inmates with red-rimmed eyes and ash-grey faces barter items like a shirt or a spoon for half a bowl of soup, a nightmarish market economy is seen in operation. 
 Unable to cope with it any longer, one Polish Jew &mdash; Peter Singer &mdash; sinks despairingly down to die. 
 Kicking him back to his feet, his nephew Stefan galvanises an urge in him to survive and thrive, the progress of which the play charts over the next four decades. 
 The initial change in Singer from shuddering zombie to desperate fighter for life is only the first of several metamorphoses &mdash; all caught with bravura vividness in Antony Sher's phenomenally versatile performance. 
 Soon, for instance, he is seen cheekily jostling for prominence among refugees arriving at Southampton. 
 &bquo;I think you'll find that pushing to the front of the queue is rather frowned on,&equo; an official disdainfully informs him. 
 But, to the contrary, Singer finds that in much of post-war British life it is applauded and rewarded. 
 Dramatising this, Singer virtually splits into two plays. 
 The first half, modelled on the career of Peter Rachman, is a sequence of cartoon-strip-like scenes chronicling Singer's rise from homeless, oppressed refugee to exploitative property landlord. 
 Sarcastic cameos of barking Tory predators and their yelping spouses indicate his accomplices in this enterprise. 
 But also keeping him company is Stefan (endowed with intense integrity in a fine performance from Mick Ford). 
 A painter whose pictures record the atrocities of the past, he acts as his uncle's conscience and it is partly due to him that Singer &mdash; at the height of his spivvy, flashy success - throws himself into a Hampstead pond. 
 The play's second half offers a contrasting fable. 
 Ambiguous as to whether or not Singer drowned himself, it looks at an era &mdash; 1964 to 1979 &mdash; during which the spirit of rapacious capitalism he personified was at any rate submerged. 
 As a complement to a career based on forgetting the past, the play sketches out an alternative one based on remembering. 
 This takes &mdash; for the new avatar of Singer who features in this part of the play &mdash; two forms: first retribution (the hunting out of his Auschwitz guard), then compassion (the running of a soup kitchen for London's homeless). 
 The play during the latter interludes &mdash; humane warmth not being Flannery's forte &mdash; seems somewhat enfeebled. 
 But it flares to acrid life again with the explosion of a second property boom in the 1980s. 
 Dramatising the ugly repercussions of this, Flannery, with his rip-the-jugular satire, is sometimes carried to over-kill. 
 But many of his ironies stab home tellingly. 
 And, once again, his stage swarms with a gruesome crew of rapacious monsters, portrayed with that lurid neo-Jacobean ferocity so many present- day playwrights employ when putting Thatcherism under the arc-lights. 
 Terry Hands's direction whips all this along at a fast pace. 
 Performances of outstanding force and finesse from Sher and Ford ensure that, at the heart of the satiric bustle, there is always something emotionally moving. 
 MUSIC / Head for heights: Joan Sutherland 
 By WADHAM SUTTON 
 MANY musical celebrities visit Newcastle but it was a red-letter day on Wednesday, when the Tyne Theatre and Opera House was sold out for Joan Sutherland's first appearance in the city. 
 It hardly needs saying that Dame Joan is a virtuoso. 
 Few can deliver high notes of such ringing clarity or trills so impeccably controlled, and she has a chest register many contraltos would envy. 
 She was accompanied by the augmented Northern Sinfonia, conducted by Richard Bonynge, whose empathy with his wife's interpretations is legendary. 
 Dame Joan's first contribution was &bquo;Casta Diva&equo; from Bellini's Norma, a superb piece of bel canto which explains Chopin's admiration for this composer. 
 It was delivered movingly, with an accompaniment which breathed with the singer. 
 The same flair for characterisation and a rapport between voice and orchestra, were evident in Amalia's &bquo;Tu del mio Carlo al seno&equo; from Verdi's I Masnadieri. 
 This was the only opera Verdi wrote specifically for the London stage, and at the 1847 premiere Amalia's role was sung by Jenny Lind. 
 It says much for the sang-froid of the practised musician that, despite the intrusion of a bomb hoax, both Dame Joan and the orchestra resumed the published programme as if no interruption had occurred. 
 After the interval came &bquo;Non temete, milord&equo; from Auber's Fra Diabolo, the only piece of French music on the programme, albeit with an Italian text, and an important contribution to the field of opera comique. 
 With its sparkle, its risque connotations (the prudish Mendelssohn was outraged at an early performance) and its bustling accompaniment, deftly played, it was proof again of Dame Joan's versatility. 
 The orchestral items included an adequate account of Rossini's Semirimide Overture, and a polished performance of Mozart's Divertimento in D (K136). 
 But the Sinfonia excelled in a suite from Lehar's Merry Widow, music that would sit well in the Palm Court or the pier pavilion, but which merits the stylish performance it received. 
 The accompanying of the arias was exemplary. 
 Finally, the Mad Scene from Lucia di Lammermoor. 
 Donizetti's resources did not run to the excesses a more modern composer would have applied in depicting a tormented mind. 
 Yet the simplicity is telling. 
 Dame Joan gave a compelling performance, handling the coloratura apparently without effort, and rising superbly to the final altissimo E flat &mdash; a stratospheric note which she then repeated in the encore. 
 The obbligato flute part was sensitively played by David Haslam. 
 A standing ovation ensued. 
 Commodities: Gold 
 By WADHAM SUTTON 
 GOLD bullion closed up a dollar in London helped by a pause in the dollar's advance with an absence of fresh news. 
 Meanwhile, a report from Credit Suisse says China will step up gold sales to 100-120 tonnes this year, to help pay off its mounting foreign debts. 
 China produces about 60 tonnes of gold annually. 
 Armchair Investor: Evans Halshaw 
 By WADHAM SUTTON 
 IT IS IRONIC that at a time when the shares of motor traders are dropping like stones, the price at which dealerships change hands has remained steady. 
 Though the volume of cars sold has come off its peak, the damage caused to this market by high interest rates has been less marked than in, say, housing. 
 Evans Halshaw, which runs Britain's largest chain of Ford dealerships in addition to selling a broad range of other marques, yesterday added another marque to its portfolio when Toyota granted the group a franchise at Stavordale Garages in the Wirral, Cheshire, after Evans bought the operation for &pound;355,000 in cash. 
 Evans has been active in outlet trading. 
 In recent weeks it sold one Ford franchise for &pound;8m and bought another for &pound;6m. 
 This might seem curious, but Ford of Europe only allows dealers to have a maximum of eight franchises and Evans was at its limit. 
 Evans is convinced it ended up with a better dealer than it started with, and has &pound;2m of cash to play with. 
 Despite this the market treats Evans like a black sheep with a severe attack of Chancelloritus &mdash; the disease that afflicts any company that people think will be affected by the Chancellor's high interest rate policies. 
 This month Evans has had its second downgrading of the year. 
 The first came when the group reported what seemed to be rather minor problems at its parts side. 
 Evans should make pre-tax profits of &pound;12m this year, putting the shares at 223p on an earnings multiple of 6.1. 
 Far too cheap. 
 Market Report: Bid speculation puts some fizz into S &amp; N 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 SCOTTISH &amp; Newcastle Breweries starred again yesterday as the stock market was gripped by rumours that a mega takeover bid was imminent. 
 In often busy trading Scottish shares frothed up 20p to 389p with stories flowing that the French BSN foods and drinks group or the giant US brewer Anheuser-Busch was about to pounce. 
 The bid rumours, which also embraced other old takeover favourites such as Morgan Grenfell and Burmah, helped the market higher. 
 Chancellor Nigel Lawson's Tory conference speech had little impact. 
 The rush into speculative bid candidates was seen by some observers as further evidence of the fragility of the market. 
 &bquo;It is a day for speculative stocks. 
 Fundamental considerations, such as looking for stocks which will beneift from sterling's weakness, are out of the window,&equo; said one bemused dealer. 
 A series of profit downgradings were shrugged off. 
 One leading stockbroker cut estimates for a string of leaders. 
 Amstrad, the electronics group, came out badly with this year's forecast slashed from &pound;85m to &pound;50m. 
 Its shares fell 2p to 55p But it was Scottish and the rest of the takeover in-crowd, with new time buyers active, which dominated the day's trading. 
 The brewing group has been the subject of intense speculation for decades. 
 This year the excitement has centred on the 23.7 per cent shareholding which Elders, the Australian group, has to cut to 9.9 per cent. 
 It is widely assumed that Elders will not bother to hold on to any Scottish shares and its 23.7 per cent stake will be acquired and used as the springboard for a bid. 
 An offer within the next few days could also hinder the &pound;645m sale of Scottish's Thistle Hotels chain to Mount Charlotte Investments. 
 There is little doubt that in the Monopolies and Mergers Commission-inspired upheaval in the brewing industry Scottish represents the most obvious entry into the British beerage by an overseas group. 
 Another theory is that Scottish, in a pre-emptive move, is about to buy the brewing interests of Grand Metropolitan. 
 Merchant bank Morgan Grenfell rose 16p to 406p, with suggestions resurfacing that insurance broker Willis Faber had sold its 20.5 per cent holding to a Continental predator. 
 Burmah, in a firm oil section, remained in demand. 
 The market is convinced that the Dutch SHV group is adding to its near-5 per cent shareholding. 
 The shares rose 9p to 647p. 
 They have climbed 46p this week. 
 Conglomerate BET rose 4p to 260p as Normura forecast profits up nearly &pound;50m to &pound;320m and said the shares were oversold. 
 APV was little changed at 131p. 
 Angus Sibley, at CIBC Grenfell &amp; Colegrave, said: &bquo;With 80 per cent of sales to overseas customers, APV is an excellent hedge against sterling weakness.&equo; 
 Ferranti International rose 1.5p to 58p as Hoare Govett and others sought to pick up shares. 
 Hoare is acting for British Aerospace, which yesterday admitted it had a 1.7 per cent stake. 
 Tozer, Kemsley &amp; Millbourn, the garages group, edged ahead 2.5p to 132.5p. 
 Speculation continues that New Zealander Sir Ron Brierley is planning to sell his controlling stake, with takeover-threatened Unigate emerging as the most likely buyer. 
 Hogg Robinson, the travel group, was unchanged at 143p as Sir Ron's stake went to 12.7 per cent. 
 Jaguar recovered 27p to 663p on hopes of takeover developments in the next account. 
 BTR rose 7p to 437p with Kolhberg Kravis Roberts, which has filed notice of its intention to go to 15 per cent, reported to be buying. 
 Trafalgar House improved 13p to 349p. 
 Asda, the stores group, rose 4p to 163p. 
 The acquisition of the 61 Gateway stores was approved by shareholders. 
 Macarthy, the pharmaceutical wholesaler and retailer, surged 38p to 308p as stories of a West German bid were revived. 
 Saatchi &amp; Saatchi fell 3p to 344p following management changes and WCRS Group continued to attract speculative interest, up 25p to 304p. 
 ML Laboratories, expected to announce new drug developments soon, jumped 40p to 495p. 
 Shares bounced back yesterday although the rally carried little conviction. 
 The FT-SE share index closed near its best level at 2,237.8, up 19 points. 
 The FT 30 share index gained 20.4 to 1,817.7. 
 Government stocks were firm, scoring gains of &pound;1 8 in places. 
 Shares of Pennine Optical slipped 2p to 75p on the Third Market as the company paid &pound;1.6m for A-Z Dental, a false teeth maker. 
 Pennine, with a &pound;3.2m capitalisation, is raising &pound;2.2m through an open offer to shareholders on a two-for-three basis at 70p. 
 Stockbroker Charlton Seal Schaverien yesterday conditionally placed the new stock. 
 Shares of Harrisons &amp; Crosfield, the chemical, timber and plantation group, rose 2p to 158p yesterday. 
 Bob Carpenter at Kitcat &amp; Aitken believes they are undervalued and should be purchased for the 7 per cent dividend yield and the group's medium term potential. 
 He expects profits this year of &pound;135m and has pencilled in &pound;150m for next year. 
 View from City Road: Anxious times for the Panel 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 ON THE wall of a waiting room at the Takeover Panel hangs a &bquo;notice to advisers in contested bids&equo; anticipating the reaction of whichever side receives an adverse ruling. 
 It says: &bquo;Self-regulation as we know it will end if the executive rules against you.&equo; 
 The Panel's self-regulatory status is often under verbal threat from those on the receiving end of adverse rulings. 
 But now it faces a more serious threat. 
 While the rest of the City has had to relinquish self-regulation under the Financial Services Act, the Panel has continued as a non-statutory body. 
 Its independent status has been supported by many companies, merchant bankers, stockbrokers and lawyers. 
 That is not to say its decisions go unchallenged - witness the furore over Consolidated Gold Fields and Newgateway. 
 Lurking in the corridors of Brussels is a draft EC directive which could fundamentally change the way the Panel works. 
 There was a drafting meeting yesterday and discussions are under way in a Council of Ministers working group and various committees of the European Parliament. 
 The directive &mdash; which is quite separate from the proposals for vetting large takeovers from the point of view of competition &mdash; is in itself uncontroversial. 
 It requires member states to set rules on mandatory bids, providing information to shareholders and treating them equally. 
 All of this is already covered in the Takeover Code. 
 The problem is over who administers the rules. 
 EC regulations normally have to be implemented by statutory authorities, but the Panel has little statutory backing. 
 It wants the EC to make an exception in its case. 
 The Panel wants to be the competent authority and to be explicitly designated as such. 
 It believes this would prevent legal challenges to its status while retaining its flexibility to interpret the code according to changing circumstances. 
 Precedents are few and far between. 
 The Advertising Standards Authority provides the nearest model, but even this is not ideal for the Panel. 
 The ASA is not a competent authority &mdash; this status has been accorded to the Office of Fair Trading, which effectively delegates the task of monitoring misleading advertisements to the ASA. 
 A similar structure would not entirely satisfy the Panel. 
 Whether it can persuade the Government to dig in its heels over this issue looks very uncertain. 
 But the City should support its call. 
 View from City Road: LWT's schedule for a repeat 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 IMAGINE the reaction if, say, Ladbroke came to its shareholders and said: &bquo;The Government have decreed that we will have to rebid for our betting licence in 1992, and to put ourselves in a better position to win it we are taking on borrowings equal to our equity and giving our managers around 15 per cent of the company.&equo; 
 LWT revealed the details of a similar scheme yesterday and also let slip that its advertising revenue and market share were on the slide. 
 Yet its shares jumped 10 per cent, compounding the strength of the shares since the scheme was first mooted. 
 The plan is that a new company, soon to be renamed LWT (Holdings), will buy in all of LWT's shares, paying one new preferred share plus a package worth 130p made up of a special dividend of 60p, an associated tax credit of 20p and either loan notes or cash worth 50p. 
 In 1993 or 1994, these preferred shares will be swapped for ordinary shares. 
 Forty of LWT's managers will be allowed to subscribe for these at a price equal to LWT's share price today, minus 130p. 
 LWT's managers will end up with between 5 and 15 per cent of the new company depending on the performance in the interim, for which they will pay &pound;3m &mdash; &pound;700,000 in cash and &pound;2.3m in forgone share options. 
 To pay for all this LWT is turning &pound;50m of cash into &pound;72.5m of debt. 
 Its market capitalisation will fall from &pound;200m to &pound;70m, the size Christopher Bland, LWT chairman, thinks is ideal to bid for the franchise. 
 Mr Bland is banking on the ability of TV companies to generate cash. 
 Borrowings will fall immediately as the company releases advanced corporation tax reserves, and two-thirds should be paid by 1992. 
 But the spanner in these works could be falling advertising revenue. 
 The winter is going to be bleak for the TV companies as income from advertising falls off, and the New Year bleaker as they have to fork out a higher Government levy. 
 LWT, whose market share is under attack, may find it hard to maintain the 40 per cent return on capital that would make its share incentive scheme worthwhile to the managers. 
 LWT needs 75 per cent of its shareholders to approve the scheme, which does not seem too difficult now the plans have been moderated. 
 Shareholders will end up with a highly leveraged vehicle &mdash; which is fine if the group is going to thrive and win its franchise, but dangerous if either the group's stream of advertising revenue or its franchise is under threat. 
 View from City Road: Saatchi needs radical refocus 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 THE SAATCHI &amp; SAATCHI share price responds better these days to gossip and innuendo than it does to hard fact. 
 The announcement of a new senior management team was greeted with a 3p mark-down to 344p by a market that is much happier with rumours of bids and break-ups at the troubled communications group. 
 The fall in the shares also reflects the fact that the more Saatchi does to put its house in order, the less chance there will be of a third party doing the job instead. 
 The new appointments demonstrate a commitment by the Saatchi brothers to restore the company's fortunes and suggest they are a long way from turning their backs on the business they built. 
 It was not an easy decision to make but one that was helped by the undoubted pedigree of the new team. 
 However, the arrival of fresh management does not translate automatically into an immediate upturn in Saatchi's performance. 
 Its problems are too deep rooted and a more radical refocusing is required before it can return to its more traditional profits growth pattern. 
 But the arrival of Messrs Louis-Dreyfus and Scott will give the group an injection of basic management skills and strategy that has been missing of late. 
 The newcomers will be hoping that the unsettling bid talk will die down so they can set about the more urgent tasks that lie ahead. 
 Investors, who have seen life breathed into a share price that was destined for the doldrums this year, may have a different view. 
 They may prefer short term bid speculation to long term recovery but if Mr Louis-Dreyfus has his way, they will have to settle for the latter. 
 Column Eight: Giving your mortgage a service 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 The building society grapevine is buzzing with rumours of foreign predators queuing up to bid for a large British society. 
 The latest whisper surrounds Ford. 
 Yes, that's right, the car maker. 
 The American corporation refuses to comment, of course, but the notion is not quite as bizarre as it sounds. 
 Ford has a massive financial services division, with a &dollar;100.2bn balance sheet and net income last year of &dollar;691m. 
 More to the point, it is looking to expand its European credit operations which are comparatively small, but highly profitable. 
 In Britain, Ford Motor Credit has a banking licence, and has therefore already cleared the Bank of England's &bquo;fit and proper&equo; hurdle. 
 And doesn't the Bradford, Bingley &amp; Dagenham have a convincing ring to it? 
 Just a joke Mr Bingley. 
 Red faces all round at Chase Manhattan following a foray into London's docklands in search of new offices. 
 The leading US bank is leaving its City headquarters in Wolgate House. 
 And according to next week's edition of International Financing Review, a high powered scouting party was dispatched under the command of Willard Butcher, the chairman. 
 Alas, on boarding the Docklands Light Railway the party was confronted by an inspector only to find that they had purchased childrens' tickets by mistake. 
 It was either off the train or pay the fine. 
 They paid the fine. 
 Savoy Hotel directors evidently have an awesome regard for the talents of Willy Bauer, the celebrated manager who left them to supervise the links at Wentworth. 
 The company is buying three of the 40 &bquo;A&equo; units in the golf and country club in a deal worth roughly &pound;2.4m. 
 Payment has been satisfied by the issue of 274,914 Savoy &bquo;A&equo; shares. 
 Of course, the deal will also allow certain &bquo;selected&equo; Savoy clients to hack divots out of the championship course. 
 The company secretary of a very well known firm in Yeovil, Somerset (he prefers to remain anonymous) was yesterday spotted emptying the contents of the office's hole punchers. 
 Happily this is not a security crisis. 
 Purely an attempt to gather some confetti for a wedding in the town tomorrow. 
 Having stumped up &pound;250 to help sponsor a general practitioners' management meeting in Nottingham, the Royal Bank of Scotland saw fit to leave it at that. 
 Not so John Emmerson of the National Westminster's medical unit in London. 
 He travelled to the meeting for &bquo;observation purposes&equo; and cheerfully mopped up all the business. 
 A dejected David Mellor, of the Royal Bank, told the magazine Doctor: &bquo;I was led to believe it wasn't an appropriate venue for a bank representative.&equo; 
 Ferranti puts own man in charge at ISC 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Assistant Business Editor 
 FERRANTI moved yesterday to take full management control of its International Signal and Control subsidiary where a &pound;215m fraud has been discovered. 
 The UK defence contractor has been strongly criticised for allowing ISC, a highly secretive US arms manufacturer, too much independence since acquiring the company two years ago. 
 Albert Dodd, a long-standing Ferranti director, has been put in charge of ISC and its subsidiaries including Marquardt, EMP, Datacom, Cardion Electronics and Laben and Elmer in Italy, with a view to bringing about closer integration. 
 ISC used to be run as a state-within-a-state by James Guerin, its founder, until his forced departure from the group in May. 
 It is now under the wing of Joe Zilligen, ISC's finance director. 
 In a separate development, British Aerospace confirmed it had raised its stake in Ferranti to 1.7 per cent through the purchase of 5.72 million shares. 
 BAe's stockbroker, Hoare Govett, was in the market again yesterday but is not believed to have added significantly to the stake. 
 A huge volume of Ferranti shares has changed hands since they returned to trading just over a week ago and a number of other potential bidders are believed to have built up small stakes. 
 Ferranti continued with presentations yesterday to the group of more than 10 companies believed to have expressed an interest in bidding for the company or providing it with equity capital. 
 Mr Zilligen is to relinquish his posts as chairman of Ferranti International USA and chief executive officer of Ferranti Italia though he will remain a main board director and assist Mr Dodd at ISC's Lancaster headquarters in Pennsylvania. 
 Surprise has been expressed in some quarters that Mr Zilligen has been allowed to stay on the Ferranti board given his key role at ISC during the &pound;215m deception. 
 Other directors are understood to be satisfied that he was not implicated in the fraud and had no knowledge of it. 
 Since discovery of the deception, which involved the creation of non existent profits and stocks in the books through use of &bquo;phantom&equo; contracts, Mr Zilligen has given investigators every assistance in helping to get to the bottom of the debacle. 
 Company News in Brief 
 Business and City Page 23 
 AMI Healthcare in good shape 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 WITH the future ownership of its American parent still in the balance, AMI Healthcare, the British private hospital group, has announced an increase in pre-tax profits from &pound;15.8m to &pound;20.9m. 
 Sales in the year to August grew by 19 per cent to &pound;131m, while operating profits were up 17 per cent at &pound;22.1m. 
 Operating margins were squeezed from 17.2 to 16.9 per cent as the company had to increase wage rates in line with NHS rises. 
 A final dividend of 4p makes a total of 6p. 
 Earnings per share rose from 18p to 20.5p. 
 AMI is 65 per cent owned by American Healthcare International, the US group. 
 The parent company is subject of a &pound;1.3bn leveraged buyout from IMA, an investor group. 
 AMI Healthcare operates 13 acute care hospitals and four psychiatric hospitals in the UK. 
 It also has corporate health screening and medical diagnostic interests. 
 Acute care operations account for 93 per cent of sales and 94 per cent of profits. 
 AMI spent &pound;14m last year refurbishing existing facilities and acquiring new ones. 
 Strong cashflow allowed borrowings to fall. 
 Interest paid was down from &pound;3.1m to &pound;1.2m and gearing at the year-end was 9 per cent. 
 Dr Marvin Goldberg, chief executive, expects continued growth in private health care. 
 &bquo;Private companies are spending &pound;2.2bn a year on their employees&equo; health care, which is a tenth of the National Health Service budget of &pound;22bn,&equo; he said. 
 Occupancy of AMI's acute care hospitals averaged 63 per cent throughout the year. 
 Admissions rose by 6.4 per cent to 62,000, with the average stay falling from 4.6 to 4.4 days. 
 In an &pound;8m programme AMI is doubling the resources in its psychiatric division, which accounted for just under 5 per cent of group sales last year. 
 Rentaminster in court action against director 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 RENTAMINSTER, the third market company which supplies labour to the construction industry, has instituted court proceedings against Anthony Swales and dismissed him as a director of the company and its subsidary BES Construction Services. 
 The action follows detailed investigations carried out by the board last month. 
 The company and its solicitors, Jeffrey Green Russell, could not elaborate on the reasons for the action against Mr Swales as they said the matter was sub judice. 
 Rodney Toogood, chairman, said the matter was not material to the business. 
 It would not affect results in the period to the end of June or current trading, which was to budget. 
 Rentaminster joined the third market in August last year through sponsor Brewin Dolphin. 
 Earlier this year it acquired the sales training agency Sales Booster International for &pound;9.3m. 
 The placing and rights issue to fund the acquisition were undersubscribed, with 61.2 per cent of the rights issue taken up. 
 USH may cost extra 25m pounds 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 MEGGITT'S &pound;110m bid for United Scientific Holdings could cost a further &pound;25m, if the Singapore Securities Industry Council rules that Meggitt must buy out the 35 per cent minority in AVS, USH's Singapore subsidiary. 
 USH has approached the securities council for a ruling. 
 Ken Coates, managing director of Meggitt, dismissed the issue as &bquo;a diversion&equo;, but said the company had the cash. 
 By yesterday's first closing date Meggitt had acceptances of 7.2 per cent of the ordinary shares of USH, taking its total stake to 10.2 per cent, and 5.2 per cent of the preference shares. 
 Nu-Swift gets 219m pounds from buyout 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 NU-SWIFT GROUP has put the finishing touches to France's second biggest leveraged buyout, confirming yesterday the &pound;218.7m sale of an 88.5 per cent stake in Compagnie Centrale Sicli. 
 The buyer, Financiere Sicli, controlled by a group of investors including Bankers Trust and Wasserstein Perella, was formed especially for the acquisition. 
 Nu-Swift will repay &pound;65.3m to retain HP Cleaning, the US business maintenance group bought by Sicli last year, and will also subscribe for a 33 per cent interest in Financiere Sicli. 
 Confirmation of the deal, the terms of which were adjusted marginally for exchange rate movements since a letter of intent was signed in July, coincided with the release of Nu-Swift's interim figures revealing pre-tax profits of &pound;16.4m (&pound;15.5m) and earnings per share of 19.78p (18.73p). 
 Outlook: Lawson revives loan rate threat 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 Financial markets yesterday naively expected something, although they did not know what, from Nigel Lawson, the Chancellor of the Exchequer. 
 In the event, his speech was aimed primarily at reassuring Conservatives, and secondarily at mollifying markets. 
 But the disappointment was restrained, even if Mr Lawson left important questions such as joining the European exchange rate mechanism unanswered. 
 Sterling, helped conveniently by the Bank of England, was relatively steady, and equities closed 19 points up. 
 But there may have been more to the Chancellor's remarks than meet the eye. 
 Mr Lawson declared that the Conservatives &bquo;never have been and never will be the party of devaluation.&equo; 
 Anodyne though those remarks may seem, they revived the threat that the authorities were ready to take action to defend the pound. 
 And it cannot be ruled out that even higher interest rates - whatever the political consequences &mdash; would be used in the last resort. 
 Before Mr Lawson's speech the markets had decided that the Government was unwilling to contemplate another increase. 
 That may still be the case. 
 But the Chancellor yesterday replanted the seeds of worry, even though another interest rate rise would make the risk of recession unacceptably high. 
 So with the commitment to defending the pound restated, there was caution in the markets. 
 Mr Lawson's hints were supported by an increase in overnight rates in the money markets, where the Bank of England has not financed shortages in full. 
 That makes it painfully expensive to sell the pound short. 
 But Mr Lawson and the Bank may only have bought a week for sterling. 
 High hopes are riding on the Chancellor's annual speech on monetary policy at the Mansion House next Thursday. 
 If the markets are pressing for sterling's entry into the ERM, a negative message could invite a brutal reaction. 
 Outlook: Americans tilt playing field 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 By early next week each of the 400 members of the Association of Futures Brokers and Dealers, the self-regulatory organisation for com modities, should have received the latest proposal from the United States Commodity Futures Trading Commission for ending the wrangle over London firms doing business for American clients. 
 But even if the proposals prove sufficiently acceptable, important questions of principle will remain unresolved. 
 The proposal sets out in detail how profits made, but not realised, by American customers of British brokers dealing in this country can be guaranteed against the broker's financial failure. 
 Segregation of funds chiefly affects the London Metal Exchange, whose successful hybrid of futures and forward market has baffled the CFTC. 
 But many AFBD members are disturbed by the implication that they could be answerable in London to a foreign regulator. 
 The CFTC says that this latest offer is the last. 
 Given that the AFBD seems to agree, and that the deadline for acceptance is 14 November, the CFTC is in a strong position. 
 Only a mass revolt by AFBD members &mdash; which is unlikely - or legal action by particularly aggrieved firms, for example the Commodity Trad ers' Group, can prevent the great majority of those firms which wish to continue doing business with Americans from signing the commission's order exempting them from the full rigour of its rules. 
 The AFBD, and probably the LME, will dodge the issue by leaving members separately to decide whether to apply for exemption. 
 Leadership cannot be expected from those quarters. 
 Yet the principles remain. 
 The CFTC will have the right, with the acquiesence of the Government, to intervene in business conducted under a regulatory regime which any reasonable person would consider more than adequate. 
 The right, moreover, will extend to only one group of customers, Americans. 
 In other words, the agreement offers privileges of protection to one group not afforded to others. 
 This is a principle of extra-territoriality, and it is not clear what British firms in America receive in return. 
 For the Securities and Investments Board, which neogtiated the original sorry deal, and for the AFBD, the episode has been a baptism by fire. 
 It has underlined how tricky is the interpretation of the level playing field. 
 The hope must be that both bodies have emerged from the fire hardened in their dealings with other regulatory bodies on behalf of the City and the country. 
 Outlook: Maintaining an invisible record 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 Unless we do live in an age of miracles, it seems unavoidable that the current account deficit this year will be about &pound;20bn, an unenviable record. 
 But as Lord Limerick, chairman of the British Invisible Exports Council, points out in the council's latest annual report, British investors appear unusally skilled at building up, and generating earnings from, overseas portfolios. 
 The hopes of Nigel Lawson, Chancellor of the Exchequer, for financing the trade deficit are partly pinned on this ability. 
 In 1988 total net private sector invisible earnings were &pound;12.1bn. 
 Against that, the Government ran an invisible deficit of &pound;5.94bn, and the deficit on visible trade was &pound;20.8bn. 
 Britain's net foreign assets grew by &pound;4bn, and the total overseas portfolio produced income of &pound;5.9bn and capital gains of &pound;16.1bn. 
 On this basis, Britain was the world's biggest generator of invisible earnings, and has probably remained so this year. 
 But can the record be maintained? 
 Faced with poor trade figures for some time to come, it is an important question. 
 One concern must be the impact of tighter regulation in Britain on the City's ability to sell services and earn from them. 
 Up to a point, regulation may attract business by offering a more secure environment. 
 It is also premature to assume that the single European market means that rival continental financial centres will deliberately keep regulatory standards below London's. 
 The object of British policy must be to ensure genuine equivalence of standards and to control regulatory costs in London. 
 Office and shop redevelopment scheme planned for Spitalfields: The Spitalfields Development Group 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 THE Spitalfields Development Group, the consortium planning the redevelopment of the fruit and flower market in the City of London (above), has applied for planning permission for a radically revised 1.9 million sq ft scheme (below), involving 900,000 sq ft of flexible office space, 200,000 sq ft of retail units, residential and lesiure elements. 
 Two years ago the group won the go-ahead for a different scheme aimed at the banking and financial sectors, but the crash and oversupply in the City market forced a rethink. 
 Royal Assent for a Bill to move the market to North-east London is expected by the end of the year and the group hopes to complete the redevelopment by 1995  
 Water authorities that will make a splash: Jeremy Warner on investment in the floated water authorities 
 By JEREMY WARNER 
 STOCK broking analysts are about to start making choices about which of the 10 water authorities being floated in early December are worth investing in. 
 To ensure the successful flotation of all 10, the Government has attempted to gloss over differences and has reconstructed the authorities financially to make them seem equally attractive. 
 Stock broking firms that are involved in the issue or act for the authorities have been banned in the run up to flotation from issuing any research. 
 There appears to be only three front ranking firms not involved and therefore not covered by the ban &mdash; CL-Alexanders Laing &amp; Cruickshank, Citicorp Scrimgeour Vickers and Hoare Govett. 
 In private, however, all are making judgements about the relative merits of each of the authorities. 
 Thanks to the inherently leaky nature of the water industry, there is already a fair amount of information to go on. 
 The Labour Party recently publicised a series of financial projections for nine of the 10 authorities that not even the prospectuses will contain. 
 The documents appear to have been working papers that were used for setting price caps for the authorities. 
 These documents were later issued to bankers who are granting medium-term credit facilities to the authorities. 
 The fact that there were no projections for South West Water has fuelled speculation that this authority might be left out of the flotation process. 
 However, there appear to be less sinister reasons behind its absence from the leaked papers. 
 The Government has stuffed the authority so full of cash -it is being privatised with &pound;242m of cash in its balance sheet (equivalent to more than &pound;140 for every person in the region) &mdash; that it does not need any medium-term credit facilities. 
 Despite its cash mountain, South West is still generally seen, perhaps unfairly, as the least attractive of the authorities and privately the Government is worried about its flotation prospects. 
 The Camelford pollution incident, coupled with the bungled appointment of a new finance director, has contributed to an impression of management incompetence. 
 South West appointed the finance director only to have him vetoed by the Government on the grounds that he was caught up in a Department of Trade and Industry investigation. 
 South West also faces a beach clean-up programme, which worries some analysts. 
 Some of the water authorities are thought likely to attract predatory interest. 
 Golden shares will prevent the French water companies that have been investing in the British water industry from bidding outright for five years. 
 But they will be allowed to buy stakes of up to 15 per cent and after five years the barriers will come down. 
 Northumbrian, Wessex, Southern and Yorkshire are thought to be vulnerable. 
 Lyonnais des Eaux already owns the two big statutory water companies in Northumbrian's region and is bound to have ambitions for the region as a whole. 
 Wessex and Yorkshire are thought possible targets for Compagnie Generale des Eaux and Southern could eventually fall prey to Saur, which owns most of the private water companies in its area. 
 Citicorp Scrimgeour Vickers expects the water authorities to be floated on the stock market with dividend yields of between 6.5 per cent and 8.5 per cent. 
 The leaked financial projections show that the Government is giving the authorities substantial leaway for raising dividends in real terms over the next 10 years. 
 The documents indicate that shareholders can look forward to annual rises above the rate of inflation ranging from 3.2 per cent in the case of Severn Trent to 5.5 per cent for Northumbrian, North West and Yorkshire. 
 Thames Water, the biggest, has traditionally been thought the most attractive. 
 There are far more potential shareholder-customers in its region than elsewhere and there are greater potential profits from property disposals. 
 However, some analysts have expressed doubts about management continuity. 
 Lowndes Queensway loses 16.9m pounds halfway: Jason Nisse examines the problems which have dogged James Gulliver's company since last year's takeover 
 By JASON NISSE 
 JAMES GULLIVER, chairman of the troubled furniture and carpets retailer Lowndes Queensway, yesterday announced &bquo;with sadness&equo; a &pound;16.9m pre-tax loss for the six months to 30 July. 
 The loss was &pound;100,000 less than the group predicted when it launched an &pound;18.5m rights issue to refinance the group in August. 
 But otherwise the City found little cheer in the results. 
 Losses per share were 7.52p and the shares themselves slipped &frac12; p to 15 &frac12; p. 
 This compares with a rights issue price of 20p and a price of 102p last year when Lowndes took over Harris Queensway for &pound;450m. 
 Sales, on a like-for-like basis, were down nearly 10 per cent, with operating losses of &pound;5.2m. 
 Eddie Dayan, Lowndes' managing director, said it was too early to know how the latest round of interest rates would affect sales, but the company has put on hold its &pound;10m store refurbishment programme, which was three-quarters complete. 
 Interest charges on the group's &pound;180m of debt were &pound;11.7m. 
 Though &pound;80m of this was swapped into fixed rate money recently, this was still at what the company calls &bquo;usurious&equo; rates and only &pound;60m of this total was borrowed at interest rates significantly below the high levels of today. 
 The group made a provision of &pound;78m last year to cover stock writedowns, reorganisation costs and two outstanding legal actions. 
 In the half it used up &pound;21m of this provision, and the net cash outflow of the group was &pound;40m. 
 Since the year-end Lowndes has settled one of its actions, paying &pound;3m to to NFC, the former National Freight Consortium, to cover ending a distribution agreement signed before Lowndes took over Harris Queensway. 
 The company is not likely to make a profit either in the second half of this year or next year. 
 Most City analysts do not expect to see a dividend paid before 1992 and the less optimistic believe Lowndes will have to refinance itself again next year. 
 They point out that the group has a banking facility limit of &pound;190m, and though it does have &pound;10m more of properties to be sold it does not take much to push the Lowndes to this limit. 
 The company's poor performance has been brought about by adverse factors that have dogged Lowndes since it bought out Harris Queensway, which had grown fast in the early 1980s only to fall on more difficult times. 
 The former chairman, Sir Phil Harris, soon sold his shares and it was not long before the new company was running off the rails. 
 Lowndes found that management controls and stock levels were not as good as they had hoped. 
 Just as they were implementing changes to bring the company to heel the Chancellor started his process of attacking retail spending through higher interest rates. 
 This hit carpets and furniture retailing particularly hard, as did new furniture fire regulations brought in by the European Commission piecemeal. 
 UK is heading for &bquo;acquisitions deficit&equo; 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 THE UK is heading for a &bquo;balance of acquisitions deficit&equo; with continental Europe, according to statistics released yesterday by Acquisitions Monthly. 
 In the first nine months of 1989, British companies spent &pound;2.1bn on buying continental companies, up on the &pound;1.6bn recorded in the comparable period. 
 But this was less than the &pound;2.3bn that mainland European corporations spent on UK acquisitions. 
 The trend is further underlined by the relative size of the companies acquired. 
 Whereas British companies spent an average of &pound;7.6m per deal on their 278 acquisitions, continental takeovers averaged &pound;23m in 99 deals. 
 The figures highlight the debate over &bquo;reciprocity&equo; which arose out of the &pound;2.1bn takeover of Rowntree by Swiss group Nestle last year. 
 This deal has also figured in the European Council of Ministers' negotiations over a common mergers policy. 
 Philip Healey, Acquisitions Monthly editor, said UK companies do not go for smaller acquisitions out of choice. 
 &bquo;In most European countries, government obstacles, complex share structures and cross-shareholdings continue to make many large, and even medium-size companies impregnable to hostile takeovers.&equo; 
 French companies are the most active in buying UK ones. 
 They bought 21 UK groups for &pound;918m in the nine months, which compared with 62 deals worth &pound;382m by British companies in France. 
 The largest deal, however, was by a British company in The Netherlands, with Scottish &amp; Newcastle Breweries' acquisition of CentreParcs. 
 At &pound;518m, this was &pound;6m more valuable than the &pound;512m spent by Rhone Poulenc, the French industrial group, in acquiring RTZ chemicals. 
 The figures for European buying in the UK takes in &pound;270m for the buyout of the British Newspaper Printing Corporation by the Liechtenstein based Maxwell foundation. 
 France, Germany, The Netherlands and Spain proved to be the most popular for UK bidders. 
 &bquo;European acquisitions are now firmly on the board agenda for a growing number of UK company directors,&equo; said Mr Healey. 
 If the trend continues, 1989 will be the first year in which UK companies have made more acquisitions in continental Europe than in the US. 
 &bquo;The trend towards ever more ambitious takeover attempts looks certain to continue,&equo; Mr Healey concluded. 
 &bquo;If a vast conglomerate like BAT can come under attack, no-one is really immune from a bid approach.&equo; 
 Free market &bquo;needed for regulators&equo; 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 A DISPUTE over which American regulatory agency should control new financial products could be ended by the application of free market principals, according to Joseph Grundfest, a commissioner with the Securities and Exchange Commission. 
 New products should be allowed to trade freely in any market overseen only by the agency responsible for that market, he told the Chicago Commodities Law Institute yesterday. 
 This approach could end the long-running battle between the SEC and the Commodity Futures Trade Commission over which agency should be responsible for which new products. 
 The SEC and CFTC are fighting in the courts over which should regulate &bquo;stock-basket&equo; products, new financial instruments with a cash security and a futures contract. 
 &bquo;When the product trades in the futures market it can be regulated by the CFTC,&equo; suggested Mr Grundfest. 
 &bquo;When it trades in the securities markets it can be regulated by the SEC.&equo; 
 After-hours computerised futures trading will be operating in the US next year, possibly through a combination of systems being developed by the world's two largest futures exchanges, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange and the LIFFE. 
 Hambros launches interest hedge 
 By MICHAEL PREST, Resources Correspondent 
 HAMBROS BANK has launched an interest-rate fixing product which is likely to intensify competition in the market for hedging exposure to the fluctuating cost of money. 
 Called Simple Hedge for Interest Rate Exposure (Shire), the product allows companies to budget for interest from deposits or for servicing loans. 
 Shire enables a borrower to fix the maximum interest rate payable over an agreed period, and also gives the borrower the benefit of falls in the interest rate below a set level. 
 At the moment the product is restricted to interest rates and to medium or big corporate clients. 
 But Graham Steward, director of Hambros treasury and capital markets division, said that the principle could be extended to currencies and small companies, and perhaps even to individuals, for example to hedge mortgages. 
 Mr Steward said that the bank charges no fees or premiums for Shire. 
 It makes money from spreads on its hedging operations which fix the interest rate, and on attracting new clients. 
 The product had three elements. 
 The contract rate sets the maximum interest rate payable on an exposure. 
 If interest rates rise above the contract rate, Hambros meets the difference. 
 Customers can also take advantage of falling rates. 
 The exit rate is the agreed interest rate below which the contract rate is abandoned. 
 If rates fall below the exit rate, the customer pays the market rate plus the difference between the contract and exit rates. 
 Thus, if the contract rate were 14 per cent, the exit rate might be 13.65 per cent. 
 Should interest rates fall to 9 per cent, the customer would pay 9 per cent, plus 0.35 per cent, the difference between the contract and exit rates. 
 The third element is the duration of the hedge. 
 An agreement would normally embrace a number of interest rate renewal periods of three, six, nine or 12 months over a total of two years. 
 Hawker and GEC in 40m pounds deal 
 By MICHAEL PREST, Resources Correspondent 
 HAWKER SIDDELEY yesterday strengthened its position in the European electric motors business by agreeing to purchase GEC Alsthom's electromotors division in a deal worth between &pound;35m and &pound;40m. 
 The merger of the two operations will transform Hawker Siddeley into the UK's biggest supplier while giving it 10 per cent of the European market - putting it in third place behind the Swedish-Swiss combine Asea Brown Boveri and Siemens of West Germany. 
 The purchase follows Hawker Siddeley's acquisition earlier this year of a 49 per cent stake in Elco Elettromeccanica, an Italian maker of small electric motors, as part of a plan to strengthen its European presence. 
 Dr Alan Watkins, Hawker Siddeley's chief executive, said the deal with GEC Alsthom would re-inforce its position in the fiercely competitive UK market and enable it to achieve greater exports than the two companies had separately. 
 The company's existing electric motor business, Brook Crompton, and GEC Alsthom Electromotors will have combined sales of about &pound;150m. 
 The GEC Alsthom subsidiary employs 1,400 at three plants in Birmingham, Bradford and Newcastle-under-Lyme. 
 The merged company will supply motors for everything from heaters and hair dryers to large pieces of industrial plant such as powered conveyor belts. 
 The GEC Alsthom business, which has assets of about &pound;28m, specialises in the manufacture of industrial and fractional horsepower motors. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By MICHAEL PREST, Resources Correspondent 
 Steel compromise: European Community negotiators have reached a compromise with the United States over limits on Community steel exports, an EC spokesman said. 
 The new deal marginally increases the EC's market share from 6.68 to 7 per cent. 
 Any disputes must be settled by mutual consent. 
 Saatchi stands down: Maurice Saatchi is stepping aside as chief executive of Saatchi &amp; Saatchi, the advertising giant that he formed with his brother Charles. 
 Maurice Saatchi will remain as chairman. 
 This page, View from City Road, page 23 Abbey rise: Abbey National followed the Halifax Building Society by increasing its ordinary mortgage rate by 1 per cent to 14.5 per cent. 
 Page 20 Dealer proposals: Members of the Association of Futures, Brokers and Dealers will soon receive the latest proposal from the US Commodity Futures Trading Commission on London firms doing business for American clients. 
 Outlook, page 21 Bond remains with BSB: Alan Bond, the troubled Australian entrepreneur, is to pay the &pound;27.5m required to remain part of the consortium behind British Satellite Broadcasting, the UK rival to Rupert Murdoch's Sky Television. 
 Page 20 Ferranti move: Ferranti moved yesterday to strengthen its control of International Signal and Control, the subsidiary where a &pound;215m fraud is feared, by putting Albert Dodd, a long-standing Ferranti director in charge of ISC. 
 Page 23 Lawson silent: Nigel Lawson, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, made no mention of Britain joining the European Monetary System in his speech to the Conservative Party conference yesterday. 
 Despite the disappointment, sterling lost only 0.5 pfennings to close in London at DM2.9562. 
 This page and Outlook, page 21 Panel threat: A European Community directive, discussed in draft yesterday, threatens the current working of the City's Takeover Panel. 
 View from City Road, page 23 Sad Gulliver: James Gulliver, chairman of the troubled furniture and carpets retailer Harris Queensway, yesterday announced &bquo;with sadness&equo; an interim pre-tax loss of &pound;16.9m. 
 Page 21 Dispute solution: Application of &bquo;free market&equo; principles could end a protracted dispute over which American regulatory agency should control newly-developed financial products, said Joseph Grundfest, a US Securities and Exchange Commissioner. 
 Airline offer: The proposed takeover of American Airlines by Donald Trump is looking far-fetched following an offer by Texas businessman Robert Bass to help the carrier remain independent. 
 World Markets New York: Shares drifted and by the close the Dow Jones average was down 13.52 points at 2,759.84. 
 The market was apprehensive about today's producer prices figures. 
 Tokyo: The yen's continued fall after a discount rate rise led to the year's second biggest drop in the Nikkei average, which plunged 444.73 to 34,795.34. 
 Singapore: Still setting post-crash records, the Straits Times index added 2.87 to 1,431.85 on slightly lower turnover. 
 Sydney: Continuing negative fallout from News Corporation's slide dragged the All Ordinaries index down 17 points to 1,730.4. 
 Frankfurt: The market gained ground after two days of losses, with the DAX index climbing 8.73 points to 1,612.78. 
 Zurich: Shares closed steady after recovering early losses caused by rising interest rates. 
 Milan: The underlying tone remained weak as the MIB edged up one point to 1,174. 
 Brussels: Chemicals was the only sector to show resilience as prices were marked down in thin business. 
 The forward market index fell 73.25 to 6,589.07. 
 Oslo: The government's 1990 budget proposals had little effect, with the index slipping 2.39 to 515.81 in moderate trade. 
 Copenhagen: Shares eased as political uncertainty and an ailing bond market reduced trade. 
 Shake-up at Saatchi 
 By NEIL THAPAR, City Reporter 
 MAURICE SAATCHI, who with his brother Charles created Saatchi &amp; Saatchi, the world's biggest advertising group, is stepping down as chief executive. 
 The move is part of a sweeping re-think about the group's direction. 
 It comes at a time of growing fear that Saatchi &amp; Saatchi may become the subject of a takeover bid as a result of recent business problems. 
 Mr Saatchi will continue as chairman but is being replaced as chief executive by Robert Louis-Dreyfus, a French citizen and president and chief executive of IMS International, who yesterday pledged to restore the strength of Saatchi &amp; Saatchi's core business. 
 &bquo;My first job is to learn Saatchi's activities and to do a good job of selling the consulting businesses,&equo; he said, in a reference to the company's previously announced plans to sell its management consultancy arm. 
 &bquo;I would hardly be joining a group if I felt it was about to be taken over. 
 The problem with Saatchi is cost containment. 
 But advertising revenue is excellent and is winning major accounts.&equo; 
 Mr Louis-Dreyfus, who graduated from Harvard with an MBA, promised to tighten budgetary control throughout the group. 
 &bquo;There will not be any rights issues and my dream is that we can take a 20 per cent share in advertising markets abroad. 
 We hope to go back to our core business,&equo; he said. 
 Saatchi has appointed Charles Scott as group finance director. 
 Mr Scott worked alongside Mr Louis-Dreyfus for five years and is currently chief financial officer of IMS. 
 IMS, the world's second largest market research company was acquired by Dun &amp; Bradstreet for &dollar;1.7m last year. 
 It has produced a 25 per cent compound growth in earnings per share in the last five years. 
 Mr Saatchi has filled the twin role of chairman and chief executive for several years, but Mr Louis-Dreyfus's appointment is designed to bring in financial skills at a senior level at a time when the company's business has been under pressure. 
 The company said Mr Saatchi would now concentrate on the overall strategy of the business while Mr Louis-Dreyfus would be responsible for its profits growth. 
 Charles Saatchi is a director of the main board. 
 Market speculation that Saatchi &amp; Saatchi could be the target of a takeover bid has been intensified by South Eastern Asset Management, a Tennessee- based fund manager, which recently amassed a 10.3 per cent stake. 
 Although SAM has ruled out a bid, it might participate in a restructuring of the group. 
 Also this week, Fininvest, the Italian master company of Silvio Berlusconi, disclosed a 1 per cent stake in Saatchi's. 
 The disclosures have helped Saatchi's shares to a 50p rise in the past two weeks, but yesterday they fell 3p to 344p. 
 Musical chairs spark problems: Saatchi &amp; Saatchi 
 By NEIL THAPAR, City Reporter 
 THE APPOINTMENT of Robert Louis-Dreyfus as Saatchi's chief executive and Charles Scott as financial director comes after a prolonged period of musical chairs involving top management. 
 The company has experienced a number of high level departures in recent years and some argue that part of Saatchi's problems may be explained by a lack of continuity at senior levels. 
 The most dramatic defection from its board was that of Martin Sorrell, its former finance director, who left about three years ago to join WPP, a small industrial company, which he transformed into the world's second largest advertising group, principally with takeovers of J Walter Thompson and Ogilvy &amp; Mather, two of the leading US agencies. 
 Mr Sorrell was replaced by David Newlands, but he resigned from the company this spring, shortly before Saatchi shocked the stock market with a warning that group profits would be substantially below those in 1988. 
 The problems stem from a high cost structure and an ambitious move into management consultancy that has failed to live up to expectations. 
 The market is now expecting pre-tax profits to emerge at about &pound;70m this year, a far cry from the &pound;138m taxable profits reported in 1988. 
 Others who have come and gone include Anthony Simonds-Gooding, former chairman and chief executive of the communications division, who left in October 1987 and later joined British Satellite Broadcasting. 
 In 1986 the group recruited Victor Millar from accountants Arthur Andersen to head its consulting business. 
 But Mr Millar, who was instrumental in introducing new financial controls at the company and was forced to look after the communications side after Mr Simonds-Gooding's departure, has also gone. 
 Meanwhile, the decision to sell Saatchi's ailing business consultancy division has put additional strains on Saatchi management and a number of senior managers have had to be moved to new positions. 
 Although the two main architects of the group, brothers Maurice and Charles, are still very much in charge at the top, they are essentially ad men and not financial experts. 
 Lawson says do not expect EMS news 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 STERLING'S fortunes are riding on hopes that Nigel Lawson will provide a clear signal for the timing of Britain's full membership of the European Monetary System next Thursday despite his omission of the issue in yesterday's speech to the Conservative Party conference and a later denial that any announcement was pending. 
 The Chancellor provided no clue on whether any policy change was in prospect during his address, but when asked about joining the exchange rate mechanism of the EMS on the BBC's Newsnight programme he said: &bquo;I have no new announcement to make about that, neither today nor indeed at the Mansion House&equo; &mdash; referring to his annual speech on monetary policy and City issues at a banquet there next Thursday night. 
 Despite disappointment in the City, the pound had lost only 0.5 pfennigs by the close to finish in London at DM2.9562. 
 Nevertheless sterling swung between DM2.97 before the Chancellor began to speak, and fell to DM2.9450 after he had finished. 
 However, the wide trading range was partly due to the impact of a weakening dollar after speculation revived that the US Federal Reserve is loosening its grip on monetary policy. 
 Against the pound, the US currency ended 0.60 cents higher at &dollar;1.5510. 
 In the stock market, there was little reaction to the Chancellor's speech and the FT-SE 100 index climbed 19 points to a closing 2237.8. 
 Mr Lawson's reaffirmation of the Government's commitment to a strong pound coupled with discreet intervention by the Bank of England also helped to underpin sterling. 
 The Chancellor said the Conservative Party &bquo;never has been and never will be the party of devaluation&equo;, and underlined the &bquo;paramount need&equo; to fight inflation. 
 Until the Newsnight programme Mr Lawson had refused to be drawn on whether he would address the EMS issue. 
 But in France, Pierre Beregovoy, the Finance Minister, increased speculation that the British Government would have to make up its mind soon. 
 He said: &bquo;What is happening in Great Britain should perhaps show Mrs Thatcher and Chancellor Lawson that they should act more quickly than anticipated in terms of bringing the currency into the EMS.&equo; 
 But there was no indication that Mr Beregovoy, speaking at a business seminar, was suggesting that there were any negotiations for full British EMS membership. 
 However, it is understood that the Bundesbank might favour a much lower exchange rate &mdash; of around DM2.70 &mdash; for sterling's eventual entry into the mechanism. 
 Karl Otto Pohl, Bundesbank president, said last week that the West German central bank favoured a revaluation of the mark within the EMS to help to reduce international trade imbalances. 
 And he added: &bquo;An upward valuation of the mark, especially towards countries with high inflation, would also be a correct response to the problem of (West German trade) surpluses.&equo; 
 Britain has an annual trade deficit of around &pound;8bn with West Germany and Mr Pohl's comments could be relevant to Britain if the Government decided to join the exchange rate mechanism. 
 Bond to pay final 27.5m pounds to BSB 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 ALAN BOND, the troubled Australian entrepreneur, will pay the &pound;27.5m he must find to remain part of the consortium behind British Satellite Broadcasting, the UK rival to Rupert Murdoch's Sky Television. 
 A London spokesman for Mr Bond said yesterday: &bquo;He has intended all along to meet his commitment to BSB, and that is still the situation.&equo; 
 The deadline on the payment, which is the final tranche of a total Bond investment of more than &pound;154m, is early November, but it now looks as though the money could be paid over as early as next week. 
 That will be a considerable relief to Mr Bond, who could in certain circumstances have seen his entire 35 per cent stake in BSB placed with the other equity participants, which include Granada, Pearson, Reed International and Chargeurs of France. 
 However, it is not yet clear how he will finance the payment, which is believed to be in cash. 
 The rest of his BSB commitment is backed by bank guarantees. 
 The payment will remove another obstacle to BSB's goal of a spring launch for their five channel subscription TV system, which now depends on solving the technological difficulties involved in the set of chips that scramble and decode the satellite signal. 
 The main problem is understood to be integrating the software and the microchip decoder apparatus in the receiver. 
 The software is being developed by the US company General Instruments, which is working flat out on it at its plant in San Diego, California. 
 The chips themselves are being worked on by ITT, which has said the problems will be ironed out in the next few weeks. 
 According to sources close to BSB, the &bquo;squariel&equo; &mdash; the square, flat receiving dish &mdash; is no longer regarded as a problem. 
 Square receivers are in common use in Japan, and the BSB contract could go to a Japanese firm like Matsushita. 
 They are also manufactured by STC and Marconi. 
 A large-scale advertising campaign next month will offer a squariel and a three-month film channel subscription for &pound;10. 
 Once the technological problems are solved Lazard Brothers, the merchant bank advising BSB, will begin the second round of fund raising on the international capital markets. 
 It now regards &pound;500m as the minimum necessary to see BSB through the promotional expenditure of a launch and the purchase of programmes. 
 BSB is also committed to spending as much on producing new programmes as it is on buying from the BBC archives. 
 The money will be raised in a mixture of straightforward borrowing and long-term, high-interest bearing mezzanine finance &mdash; often referred to as junk bonds. 
 The existing equity holders may also be asked to participate in a further round of equity raising, for around 10 per cent of the total. 
 LWT gives details of share incentive plan 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 LWT (HOLDINGS), the parent of London Weekend Television, yesterday revealed the details of its plan to replace most of the company's equity with debt and give 40 top managers up to 15 per cent of the group's shares. 
 The company announced the scheme in August, and has had to weather a storm of objections from shareholders and managers. 
 Christopher Bland, the chairman, said the scheme would place LWT in an ideal position when it comes to rebidding for its Independent Television franchise in 1992. 
 He said he was confident that at least 85 per cent of LWT's shareholders, and all the managers, would support it. 
 The scheme offers one share in a newly created company plus 130p in dividends and cash or loan notes for each LWT ordinary share. 
 It is structured so that LWT's managers will end up with between 5 per cent and 15 per cent of the new company, depending on how well LWT performs in the meantime, which they will pay for in 1993-94 at today's prices. 
 Mr Bland said that if LWT manages to retain its franchise, the new shares will be worth three times as much as they are now. 
 The scheme will use up LWT's &pound;50m of cash and bring in &pound;72.5m of borrowings. 
 Mr Bland said that the cost of the borrowings was much lower than the cost of the group's equity, which he estimated at 20 per cent per annum. 
 LWT's shares jumped 22p to 223p on the news despite most City analysts being lukewarm about the scheme. 
 Government &bquo;responsible&equo; for rail link to Channel tunnel 
 From SARAH LAMBERT in Paris 
 THE MANAGING director of Eurotunnel, Tony Ridley, made it clear yesterday that the Government is ultimately responsible for the Channel tunnel rail link and has a duty to see the project completed successfully. 
 &bquo;I don't argue the pros and cons of public or private investment per se, but in view of the problems that have arisen it seems to me that if the Government has talked up the price by making rather loud commitments to potential voters, perhaps the Government should spend some of our money overcoming those problems,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Ridley added that he was talking in the context of the national good. 
 &bquo;The effect on the environment will now be far worse if it is not built.&equo; 
 The cost of the tunnel has risen by &pound;2.2bn to &pound;7bn &mdash; forcing Eurotunnel to return to its bankers for fresh loans. 
 At the same time the cost of the proposed high-speed rail link from London to the tunnel has risen nearly three-fold to &pound;3.5bn because of environmental safeguards demanded by the Government. 
 Ministers insisted that both projects should be financed by the private sector and the Channel Tunnel Act specifically prohibits the British Government from subsidising either the tunnel or transport infrastructure linked to it. 
 However, Mr Ridley told a Paris conference that &bquo;even in the private world there is a role for government to play&equo;. 
 In order to develop a coherent transport strategy to meet the challenge of increased demand in the 1990s the Government should either invest itself or encourage the private sector to do so. 
 He cited the Docklands Light Railway and the proposed light railway in Manchester as examples of successful co-operation in the public and private sectors. 
 The extent of government involvement in such projects should be judged on individual merit, he said. 
 The Government's insistence that the Channel tunnel rail link be privately-financed is being seen as the first stage in a longer term plan to privatise the entire British Rail network. 
 Mr Ridley would not be drawn on the thorny issue of rail privatisation other then to say that investment was urgently needed in Britain's rail and road links. 
 If this was stimulated by selling off BR, so much the better. 
 But he added: &bquo;If, however, it means that managers are so distracted discussing the process of privatisation that they have no time left to manage, then that would be a most unhappy state of affairs.&equo; 
 He was confident that the problems between Eurotunnel, Transmanche Link, the consortium of 10 construction companies building the tunnel, and its financiers would be overcome. 
 &bquo;If we believe the project is important for the well being of the economy then the money will be found. 
 It doesn't matter what the source is,&equo; he added. 
 Since TML had drafted in a new team, relations with Eurotunnel had improved significantly, Mr Ridley said. 
 He was generally dismissive of the idea that the two could merge because, he said, they existed to serve the interests of two very different sets of shareholders. 
 Abbey lifts mortgage rate to 14.5% 
 From SARAH LAMBERT in Paris 
 ABBEY NATIONAL yesterday announced a one-point rise in its ordinary mortage rate to 14.5 per cent. 
 The increase was a carbon copy of Halifax Building Society's increase on Monday and sets a firm benchmark which most other societies will now follow. 
 At the same time the Abbey raised its rate for borrowers of more than &pound;60,000 from 12.95 to 13.9 per cent. 
 Both new rates apply from 1 November. 
 Savings rates will rise by about 0.75 per cent. 
 Last weekend the Yorkshire Building Society announced a 1.5 per cent rise to 15 per cent in the wake of the one-point rise in base rates. 
 The smaller rises from the largest two mortgage lenders will deter other societies from following the Yorkshire's move. 
 The Leeds Permanent, which had hoped to raise its rate by at least 1.25 per cent, is now thought likely to restrict its increase to 1 per cent. 
 The Woolwich expects to announce an increase of &bquo;up to 1 per cent&equo; next week. 
 Letter: Mourning delivery 
 From Ms SARAH COHEN 
 Sir: I note the new unpriced first-class postage stamps are black. 
 Are they in mourning for the first-class service? 
 Leading Article: The weight of a victim's evidence 
 From Ms SARAH COHEN 
 AN OLD BAILEY jury yesterday found PC Peter Anderson guilty of rape. 
 He was sentenced to seven years imprisonment by Mr Justice Jowitt. 
 The penalty was imposed primarily as a result of evidence provided by the victim and in spite of the tenor of the earlier summing-up by the judge who had told the jury that it was dangerous to convict on the evidence of an alleged victim alone. 
 Moreover Mr Justice Jowitt had spoken of the temptation on the part of women to &bquo;exaggerate or fabricate&equo; when questions of sexual misconduct were involved. 
 He did not apparently find it necessary to explain the reasons for this sexist-sounding conclusion. 
 Last week, in contrast, a Florida jury cleared a vagrant accused of the rape of a 22-year-old woman who had been snatched from a Fort Lauderdale restaurant car park while wearing a white mini-skirt and, so the jury was informed, no underwear. 
 The foreman was quoted as saying that the woman in question had shown &bquo;everything she had&equo;. 
 She was &bquo;advertising for sex&equo; and therefore &bquo;deserved what she got&equo;. 
 Without going into the detail of the Old Bailey case, two general points emerge from it and from the Florida case. 
 They involve the authority to be given to the unsubstantiated evidence of a woman in a rape case and the question of her character, real or assumed. 
 On the former point yesterday's Old Bailey judgment says a lot about contemporary British social mores. 
 The accused, a 40-year-old police officer with a wife and a recently discarded mistress, claimed that the woman in question, to whom he had casually given a lift, offered him sex in return. 
 The victim said that the policeman had forced himself on her. 
 Counsel for the prosecution invited the jury to decide between the suggestion that the officer had &bquo;gone to the very depth of deceit&equo; by imposing his attention on the woman or whether she had made &bquo;a wicked and false allegation&equo;. 
 Given this stark choice, the jury decided that the policeman had been deceitful rather than that the woman had been &bquo;wicked and false&equo; in her evidence. 
 The Commissioner of the Metropolitan Police might care to ponder why it is that juries increasingly dismiss the sworn evidence of his officers in favour of those accusing them of gross impropriety. 
 More fundamental however, is the assumption that women who wear mini-skirts, accept lifts from strange men late at night or even offer casual sex in return for a ride, are therefore somehow inviting rape. 
 They are not, in the immortal phrase of the Florida juryman, &bquo;asking for it&equo;. 
 Provocative dress and casual promiscuity (which are by no means the same thing) may be abhorrent to juries in the southern states of America or to judges in this country. 
 But they do not constitute invitations to sexual assault, least of all by officers of the law. 
 It may be ill-advised of a young woman dressed in a titillating manner to accept lifts from a stranger, just as it would be foolish for the owner of an expensive motor car to leave his vehicle parked overnight in an ill-lit side-street. 
 Yet such lack of judgement does not justify the thief who breaks into the car and steals the radio or the hooligan who takes off on a joy ride. 
 Citizens going about their lawful occasion merit the support of the police and the courts, not their moral disapprobation. 
 Miles Kington: Around the M25 in Eighty Days 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 AT RONNIE SCOTT's Club last night I was chatting to some of the members, insofar as one could hear one's self talk above the noise of the musicians, when the subject of London transport came up. 
 Someone said London would seize up before Christmas. 
 Someone else said it had already seized up. 
 Nonsense, said I; it was still perfectly easy to get around London. 
 &bquo;In less than 80 days?&equo; said somebody. 
 There was laughter. 
 Before I knew where I was, I had been wagered a great deal of money that I could not do it, and shortly before midnight I was leaving the hallowed portals of Ronnie Scott's Club. 
 Ahead of me lay an historic mission: to circumnavigate London using hired transport, and return within 80 days. 
 I took a taxi home and went to sleep. 
 DAY TWO. 
 I have packed and bought my maps. 
 It should not be too hard. 
 I aim to get a bus to Heathrow, then circle south from there along the M25. 
 First of all, I must get to a bus stop that serves Heathrow, which means heading towards Kensington and the Bayswater Road. 
 From here, that means a short cab ride, and I phone a mini-cab firm whose card I find in one of my pockets, the Ace Express Super Silver Service. 
 DAY THREE. 
 The mini-cab phone finally answers. 
 A man says: &bquo;Hold on, I've just got in, be right with you&hellip; 
 &bquo;. After another 10 minutes he is with me. 
 &bquo;Right,&equo; he says, &bquo;a nice cup of tea, I was dying for that, what can I do for you?&equo;. 
 I explain. 
 No problem. 
 He rings off. 
 An hour later nobody has arrived. 
 I am reduced to sitting staring out of the window with nothing much to look at but a young man, presumably a salesman or political canvasser, patiently going from door to door down the street. 
 I am glad I don't have to work door-to-door. 
 My doorbell rings. 
 I rush downstairs with my luggage. 
 But it is only the young man. 
 &bquo;Whatever it is, I don't want it,&equo; I tell him. 
 &bquo;I'm just waiting for a cab.&equo; 
 &bquo;You must be the passenger I'm looking for,&equo; he says, studying a bit of paper. 
 &bquo;They didn't give me a house number.&equo; 
 Ten minutes later we're off. 
 Eight minutes later we're lost. 
 He hasn't got a map and has never been to Bayswater before. 
 On closer questioning, I find he has never driven a cab before; he is an economics student filling in for his brother. 
 His brother has never driven a cab before either; this was going to be his first day. 
 Philosophical question: can you actually fill in for someone who has never done the job? 
 &bquo;Why don't you take me back to my house and I'll try some other way?&equo; 
 I suggest. 
 &bquo;I think that is a very good idea,&equo; he agrees. 
 The return to my house is strained by the thought that he still has not the faintest idea where he is going. 
 Suddenly, I emit a cry of recognition. 
 Yes, after we had given up all intention of going there, we have arrived. 
 I pay him. 
 I await the bus. 
 It comes. 
 It is full of Americans. 
 So is the next. 
 But the third lets me on, and I am finally en route to Heathrow. 
 The bus stops again at the Kensington Hilton, a hotel so much on the edge of Kensington that had it been built 10 feet to the west, they should have called it the Shepherds Bush Hilton. 
 It is much frequented by aircraft crews and the sort of businessman who jogs instead of having breakfast, and you'd be lucky to meet anyone in there whose native language was English. 
 All this I learn from the bus driver who chats to me as we wait for the traffic ahead to move. 
 &bquo;Blimey,&equo; he says, as we find ourselves still sitting outside the Hilton after 20 minutes. 
 &bquo;I've never known it this bad. 
 Are you going to Terminal One?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 He gives me what the French call a curious regard and asks me to explain myself. 
 &bquo;I am going round London in 80 days,&equo; I say, &bquo;and intend to pick up a local bus at Heathrow&equo;. 
 &bquo;Then you can get out of my coach,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;This is for bona fide air travellers only.&equo; 
 DAY FOUR. 
 All day at home, planning a better route. 
 Still 76 days to go. 
 It must be possible. 
 More soon of this exciting saga, which is due to be turned into a TV epic or will be if we can fix up a deal with anyone. 
 Leading Article: A fracas which demeans Europe 
 By MILES KINGTON 
 THE European Community has the parliament it deserves. 
 As long as the latter enjoys only modest powers, the election of its members will not be taken with full seriousness. 
 Last June's vote led to the creationof a 17-strong block called the European Right, consisting of members of Jean-Marie Le Pen's National Front from France, the Republicans from West Germany (led by a former Waffen-SS officer, Franz Schonhuber), and a Belgian from the wilder shores of Flemish nationalism. 
 Given the appalling historical baggage which the European far right carries with it, it is not surprising that their inclusion in the Strasbourg assembly has begun to create serious difficulties. 
 The last two days' scenes of disarray, including some fisticuffs, caused by the exclusion of far-right MEPs from the leadership of two delegations to foreign parliaments, are demeaning to the European Parliament, and bode ill. 
 Under the assembly's system of apportioning positions on committees and on the 26 standing delegations to foreign parliaments, mathematical logic made it inevitable that far-right members would receive a few sensitive posts. 
 It was bad enough that a National Front MEP should emerge as chairman of the delegation to the Swiss parliament; worse still that one of Mr Schonhuber's men should be vice-chairman of the delegation to Israel's Knesset. 
 The trouble broke out when other party leaders voted to change the rules and thus enable delegation members to elect their chairmen (as committee members have long been able to do). 
 Before long West Germany's Bundestag may confront the same problem: the federal elections late next year could give the Republicans enough votes to achieve representation &mdash; and not necessarily at the expense of Hans-Dietrich Genscher's Free Democrats. 
 For the voice of resurgent German nationalism to enjoy such a platform would send shivers through continental Europe. 
 Even if Republican members could somehow be excluded from sensitive parliamentary posts, their presence would embarrass both the Bundestag and the Federal Republic as a whole. 
 The chief danger from the resurgence of the far right in Western Europe lies not in the likelihood of its achieving any real influence, but in the reactions to it of centre right parties. 
 The ambiguity of Jacques Chirac's attitude to the National Front helped destroy his bid for the Presidency last year, and with it the credibility of the opposition to President Mitterrand. 
 The leadership of Chancellor Helmut Kohl's Bavarian partners, the Christian Social Union, is now making a similar mistake. 
 Made jittery by the successes of the Republicans, the CSU is pandering to the far right by questioning the legitimacy of Germany's post-Second World War frontiers. 
 In Britain the 15 per cent scored by the Greens in last June's European elections had a salutary effect on both main parties. 
 But in West Germany, Republican successes pushed the centre-right government towards more illiberal policies. 
 In France, the Communist Party appeals to reactionary working-class prejudices almost as strenuously as does Mr Le Pen. 
 If European Parliament elections continue to be treated semi-frivolously, such extremists as Mr Le Pen will be over-represented in Strasbourg. 
 Letter: Statistical integrity 
 From Dr JANET LEWIS and Mr ROBERT MARKLESS 
 Sir: The Royal Statistical Society's concern ('Moves to monitor use of statistics by Government', 9 October) has long been shared by the social science community in this country. 
 Last year the Association of Learned Societies in the Social Sciences and the Association of Social Research Organisations set up the Social Science Forum (SSF) to campaign on issues that were affecting social scientists. 
 We launched a manifesto promoting positive aspects of our field, including a call for a clear statement of principle for the collection and use of official statistics. 
 Later this year we will be publishing a more comprehensive paper on this topic outlining what we feel needs to be done to ensure the integrity of official statistics, but in general we believe that there are three principles: 1. 
 Decisions about data collection should be determined by the need for an informed society as well as for the concerns of government; 2. 
 All statistics collected with public funds should be in the public domain; 3. 
 Britain should conform to international standards. 
 The SSF supports the call for the establishment of an independent body which would monitor the use of statistics by any government and would establish a set of acceptable principles for their collection and use. 
 We know from our informal discussions with politicians of all shades of opinion that we have a long way to go, but many have been sympathetic to our aims. 
 As more and more concerned organisations make their voice heard, the greater is our chance for a more informed society. 
 Letter: The goals of the universities are the crucial issue, not the cost 
 From Professor Sir GRAHAM HILLS 
 Sir: Shame on you, Ngaio Crequer, for deserting the cause of educational reform (5 October). 
 I expected better from someone half my age. 
 Just because you had the good fortune to pay nothing for your very expensive university education does little to justify a system of higher education which, at the same time, excluded 85 per cent of your age group from the privileged position you evidently enjoyed. 
 It really is not good enough for you to preen yourself in this way while Britain continues to suffer from the consequences of a largely uneducated workforce. 
 In effect, you are like all those in the lifeboat &mdash; cosy, complacent and unwilling to give up their privileged position. 
 You may not think that access cards for greater access are a good idea, but what are you proposing should be done to double the age-participation rate in this country? 
 If your only answer is to pour more money on the problem then I would direct your attention to the parlous condition of other more deserving sectors of our society. 
 If your answer is simply &bquo;lobbying harder for increased funds for higher education&equo;, then please look back over 10 or 15 years to see whether that is remotely likely to succeed. 
 Letter: The goals of the universities are the crucial issue, not the cost 
 From Dr MICHAEL COLLINS 
 Sir: In the debate about the funding of higher education, it is essential that the purpose of the universities and of the education that they provide should not be neglected. 
 It is one thing to demand efficiency and the just use of public resources; it is quite another to impose conditions where the universities cannot provide what the nation requires. 
 The nation should not need to accept lower levels of achievement among all its graduates in order to widen access to higher education. 
 A university education should be characterised by the fact that one &bquo;learns to learn&equo; rather than &bquo;learns by being taught&equo;. 
 It may be fashionable to decry Robbins &mdash; and many of the universities' problems stem from the rapid expansion of the 1960s which followed his report &mdash; but his pertinent description of the aims of higher education is no less valid today than when it was written. 
 To quote: It is the distinguishing characteristic of a healthy higher education that, even where it is concerned with practical techniques, it imparts them on a plane of generality that makes possible their application to many problems. 
 To achieve this necessarily takes time and it is thus the means and goals which we should examine today rather than the setting first of arbitrary (financial) parameters. 
 Some undergraduates seek simply to broaden their horizons and develop analytical skills; others wish to acquire a more specialised knowledge to be used in a subsequent career. 
 Why should both groups follow the same course? 
 And should we introduce a common core as in American universities? 
 As the educators of a larger student body, we should expect to ensure that arts graduates are numerate, scientists literate, and both fluent in a foreign language. 
 One option is to have &bquo;basic&equo; degree courses, followed by an extra year which would be taken by those wishing ultimately to pursue a career related to their chosen subject. 
 The teaching of specialist options is relatively expensive; this might enable universities to maintain intellectual standards at a lower unit cost for the majority of undergraduates while still serving those who need more advanced knowledge. 
 The debate should not, however, centre on cost, but should hinge on the ultimate benefit to the nation. 
 One assertion which has been made in support of student loans is that a student should be prepared to take a loan in respect of his or her enhanced earning capacity as a graduate. 
 But, if this argument is valid, then taxation ensures that the Government is itself a very substantial beneficiary. 
 Furthermore, graduates can be expected to make fewer demands on the public purse in later life. 
 The education of the nation is no less important than its defence. 
 The Universities Funding Council has an &bquo;unfettered right to provide advice (to the Secretary of State), whenever it wants, on any aspect of university education&equo;. 
 The vice-chancellors should enlist its support, but the universities must first have a clear view of what is needed in the future, and the model need not be uniform. 
 While it is a major function of universities to educate, this cannot be taken in isolation. 
 Robbins observed also that the world, not higher education alone, will suffer if ever they cease to regard (the advancement of knowledge) as one of their major functions. 
 This observation again is timeless, and the burden of education must never be such as to place this role at risk. 
 Letter: No room for fantasy 
 From Ms RUTH VALENTINE 
 Sir: Nicholas Baker's perception of adoption (letter, 10 October) perpetuates the destructive secrecy and denial that afflict all the people involved in traditional adoption practices. 
 The birth parents, adoptive parents and the child itself are at present all encouraged by the law, the professionals and common prejudice to deny the reality of their situation. 
 Under this pressure, all ordinary human ambivalence and doubt is outlawed: adopters become guilty or angry when the relationship does not proceed according to the fantasy or reality of ordinary parenting; children suppress their fantasies of an alternative life with birth parents &mdash; or hold on to that fantasy all the more tenaciously &mdash; and birth mothers, in particular, are pushed into a denial of their own experience and feelings. 
 Does Mr Baker really believe that such dishonesty and repression provide a &bquo;strong family background&equo;? 
 Adoption is hard, and everyone involved has disappointments, longings and anger that cannot easily be dealt with. 
 But the only way to start, and to prevent those neglected feelings souring the endeavour, is to be open and accepting of them. 
 A child's need to understand its situation is not going to destroy the new relationship: trying to live out the fantasy that this is exactly the same as a birth relationship may well do. 
 Letter: Channel link safety 
 From Mr A. B. MARTIN 
 Sir: I am surprised that Mr Prescott did not contact me to air his concerns on the independence of the Channel Tunnel Safety Authority (12 October). 
 As the article explains, Mr Bailey's inquiry was made on behalf of the Department of Transport which shares his services with the authority. 
 Neither I nor any other member of the Authority knew, or needed to know, that he had made the inquiry in question. 
 The Authority necessarily has a close relationship with Eurotunnel. 
 We have to examine and discuss in great detail its proposals for an immensely complex engineering project. 
 However, &bquo;cosy&equo; is not the word I or, I suspect, Eurotunnel would use to describe our relationship. 
 All that is of little consequence. 
 What is important is to tell your readers that the Safety Authority is quite independent of the influence of Eurotunnel and of the Government when it comes to the advice we give on safety standards of the tunnel and its railway system. 
 Our primary duty is to the travelling public. 
 We recognise this and we are determined to achieve a transport system which is as safe as it can be made while still remaining effective. 
 We have been given the status, resources and expertise to do so &mdash; on both sides of the Channel. 
 Letter: Of Pharisees and Philistines 
 From Rabbi Dr FRANK HELLNER 
 Sir: I fail to understand the somewhat confused parallel that the Ven William Paley (letter, 5 October) has sought to draw between the Pharisees and Jews on the one hand and the Philistines and Arabs on the other. 
 Permit me to set the record straight. 
 The Pharisees were Jews. 
 The Philistines, however, were a non-Semitic, Aegean, sea-faring people who settled along the coastal region of Canaan (not Palestine as he suggests) sometime in the twelfth century BC. 
 The term &bquo;Palestine&equo; was coined over 1,000 years later by the Romans who renamed the country after the ancient Philistines in an attempt to de-Judaise the Holy Land and expunge all Jewish references. 
 The Philistines have nothing to do with the Arabs, a Semitic people, who invaded the Holy Land from Arabia in the seventh century. 
 Letter: The freedom to question received wisdom 
 From Mr JOHN HYAMS 
 Sir: Shabbir Akhtar (10 October) himself makes what he might call a pardonable error in thinking that to liberals &mdash; genuine ones, not the compromisers so regretfully limned in John Torode's article (3 October) - freedom of speech is an absolute value. 
 Belief in its importance is in fact a consequence of the recognition that people, including priests, are fallible, so that the right to challenge their views is a necessary condition of arriving at valid opinions. 
 It is reinforced by the further recognition that what is now valid may well not be in the future, and that some people see earlier than others when changes in accepted opinions and values are needed. 
 These people are entitled to use ridicule as a weapon to provoke such folk as the sweetly unreasonable Mr Akhtar and the rest of us into wondering whether our beliefs, including our most deeply held convictions, are actually tenable. 
 Since our beliefs strongly influence our actions, getting them right is socially very important, and therefore the freedom to question received wisdom, especially in fields that affect the behaviour of large numbers of people is, indeed, in the liberal view, a hugely important means, if not a vital precondition, of ensuring that &bquo;the interests of weaker individuals and groups&equo; are not harmed by &bquo;the irresponsible attitudes and actions of the more powerful&equo;. 
 All that liberals cannot tolerate is pretension to infallibility. 
 Mr Akhtar's ex-cathedra statement that The Satanic Verses and The Life of Brian should be &bquo;removed from public knowledge&equo; because their particular mode of subversiveness is not, as he puts it, &bquo;right&equo; proves the regrettable gulf between religious fundamentalism and the requirements of a secular society like ours. 
 I suppose we have to be grateful that Mr Akhtar grudgingly refrains from asking us to ban the works of Voltaire, which seems a major concession from him. 
 One suspects he would not make it were Islam a majority religion in Britain. 
 Letter: Bull Ring plans 
 From Mr JOE HOLYOAK 
 Sir: Why on earth do architectural critics maintain the fiction that large collective schemes are the creation of individual architects? 
 Jonathan Glancey's article on the Bull Ring (11 October), while covering the issues excellently, and clearly sympathetic to our cause, misleads your readers in implying that the People's Plan is all my work. 
 The true significance of the People's Plan is that it is a model of democratic participation, challenging the authoritarianism of the developer's proposal. 
 It is by and for citizens, representing the real interests of the people of Birmingham. 
 Letter: Mysterious lines 
 From Mr CHRISTOPHER MORGAN 
 Sir: Thank you for the photograph (10 October) showing the &bquo;railway&equo; cash till at Grouts drapery shop in Palmers Green. 
 I was reminded of a similar mechanism at Evan Roberts department store which fascinated me as a boy in Cardiff during the early Fifties. 
 Dylan Thomas immortalised such machinery in Draper Mog Edwards' soliloquy in Under Milk Wood: I have come to take you away to my emporium on the hill, where the change hums on wires. 
 The allusion must mystify younger readers. 
 Letter: Theatrical survival 
 From Mr ROBERT BRECKMAN 
 Sir: In extolling the virtues of the one-man show, Mark Steyn (7 October) misses the real point of their popularity &mdash; cost. 
 With the theatre now under financial siege, these are the only shows now possible to make ends meet. 
 One only has to look at the diminishing casts in productions all over the country. 
 The proliferation of these diminutive shows will soon be in inverse proportion to the theatres still open to receive them. 
 Survival is now an art form. 
 Letter: Vote-losing courage 
 From Mr DAVID WOLFSON 
 Sir: The Chancellor's decision to raise interest rates yet higher has today been defended by Mr Baker, the Conservative Party chairman, as &bquo;courageous and right&equo;. 
 Might I remind Mr Baker of Sir Humphrey's wise advice to his minister? 
 A controversial decision may cost you votes, but a courageous decision will lose you the election. 
 Letter: Bottled water on the Tories' platform 
 From Mr LES FREEMAN 
 Sir: How sad that on the day details were announced of the incentives available to investors in water authorities the Government gave virtually a vote of no confidence in the industry's product. 
 Only polished bottles of water appeared before Mrs Thatcher and her colleagues on the platform when the Conservative Party conference opened in Blackpool. 
 It would have been cheaper &mdash; and certainly better PR &mdash; if speakers had been offered jugs of iced water, the liquid being supplied by North West Water. 
 Hasn't anyone told Mrs Thatcher that bottled water can cost a thousand times as much as water from the tap? 
 And surely her ministers have convinced her that tap water really is safe and wholesome to drink. 
 Lawson's luck meets its nemesis 
 By PETER KELLNER 
 MOST crises have three components. 
 What is remarkable about the present sterling crisis is that the Government &mdash; and for all practical purposes, that means the Prime Minister &mdash; has declined to tackle any of them. 
 The three components are political, tactical and strategic. 
 Each component raises a question needing a clear answer. 
 Who is in charge? 
 What immediate decision is needed? 
 What goal is being attempted? 
 Those issues all interact, of course; like those fiendish three-dimensional puzzles that children can often do more easily than adults, the pieces have to be put together simultaneously, or the whole thing falls apart. 
 But it is possible to dissect most crises and examine each component in turn. 
 In September 1976 when &mdash; as this week &mdash; Blackpool's Winter Gardens played host to a government in turmoil, James Callaghan and Denis Healey had to confront what became known as the IMF crisis. 
 From the outset, Prime Minister and Chancellor stood shoulder-to-shoulder. 
 They quickly extinguished any hopes, or fears, that anybody else in the Cabinet or the party would divert them. 
 That prevented a potentially violent political explosion. 
 Their tactical decision was equally clear: to borrow money from the International Monetary Fund. 
 And strategically, Mr Healey cut public spending and brought the domestic economy back into balance. 
 A similar analysis applies to April 1982, when Argentina invaded the Falklands. 
 Lord Carrington resigned as Foreign Secretary, pre-empting a distracting row about who was to blame, leaving the Prime Minister unambiguously in charge of policy. 
 An immediate tactical decision was taken to send the Task Force to the South Atlantic. 
 A clear objective was set and adhered to: recapture the islands. 
 The point of those brief excursions down memory lane is not to laud Mr Healey's public spending cuts or to justify war-war rather than jaw-jaw. 
 Both episodes offered alternative options. 
 What is hard to dispute, however, is that the Callaghan government in 1976 and the Thatcher government in 1982 managed dangerous crises with care and skill. 
 They tackled their political, tactical and strategic problems swiftly and directly; and, incidentally, their poll ratings rose strongly. 
 Contrast then with now. 
 Politically, it is impossible to tell who is in charge of economic policy. 
 For almost 18 months Margaret Thatcher and Nigel Lawson have been at loggerheads over sterling. 
 The consequence has been to diminish the credibility of both; for nobody can have any confidence that what either of them says one week will still be government policy the next. 
 In his speech yesterday to the Conservative Party conference, Mr Lawson did nothing to resolve the uncertainty. 
 He said: &bquo;I will continue to take whatever action is needed, however unpopular it may be, to keep our economy sound and strong.&equo; 
 That &bquo;continue'is especially rich. 
 It implies that the Prime Minister has permitted him the freedom &bquo;to take whatever action is needed&equo; in the past. 
 This is manifestly not the case. 
 Mr Lawson's words might have reassured the financial markets had he carried conviction as a man in complete charge of short-term economic policy; instead he sounded faintly ridiculous. 
 Few can have been surprised that the markets reacted by marking sterling down. 
 Political paralysis has prevented the evolution of either clear tactics or a coherent strategy. 
 The main tactical issue is when to join the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System. 
 There is a case for going in; there is a case for staying out; there is even a case for setting clear, robust conditions for when to go in. 
 Mrs Thatcher and Mr Lawson tell us that government policy is the last of these: Britain will become a full member of the EMS when France and Italy abolish exchange controls and when our inflation rate is similar to that of other EMS members. 
 It is a policy that has signally failed to persuade either the financial markets or the rest of the European Community, mainly because neither Mrs Thatcher nor Mr Lawson shows any serious sign of being persuaded by it. 
 They honour it in the manner of warring tribes observing a precarious truce, waiting nervously for hostilities to reopen. 
 At that moment the terms of the truce between the Downing Street neighbours will be conveniently forgotten. 
 It makes as much sense to bet on the survival of the Government's EMS policy as to look for tranquility in west Beirut. 
 To the failure of politics and tactics must be added the most serious shortcoming of all: the absence of a defensible strategy for lifting the British economy out of its present crisis. 
 This seems mainly to be because Mrs Thatcher and Mr Lawson &mdash; for once in agreement &mdash; refuse to admit the existence of the crisis. 
 Politicians are always at their most vulnerable when they believe their own propaganda. 
 In his speech yesterday Mr Lawson dismissed sterling's troubles as &bquo;turbulence&equo; of the kind that grown-ups like him, who have seen a thing or two over the years, expect from time to time. 
 He observed that the economy had expanded steadily since 1981, and repeated something that Kenneth Baker had said earlier in the week: that there was &bquo;no precedent for eight years of sustained growth&equo;. 
 That is nonsense. 
 The economy grew steadily for 11 years from 1946 until 1957, and then for 15 years from 1958 until 1973. 
 In peacetime, growth is the normal condition of the economy. 
 Besides, it is playing fast and loose with the statistics to take 1981 as the baseline for the Government's claims. 
 There are three reasons for this. 
 First, it omits the first two years of the Thatcher government's record, when output fell 3.5 per cent. 
 Second, no respectable economist derives a trend by comparing a trough year (1981) with a peak (1988): sensible figures can only be obtained by contrasting peak-with-peak or trough-with-trough. 
 Third, even growth rates obtained by comparing similar points in successive economic cycles must be treated with caution if the end-year shows a massive balance of payments deficit. 
 Any fool can boost spending by taking out an overdraft; no bank manager would deduce from such figures that the same growth could, or should, be extended indefinitely. 
 Mr Lawson boasts that between 1981 and 1988, Britain's growth rate of 3.5 per cent a year was the highest in Europe. 
 But if the full peak-to-peak period, 1979 to 1988, is counted, our average growth rate is just 2.1 per cent &mdash; the same as for the OECD countries as a whole. 
 If last year's consumer boom had not been allowed to boil over, our nine-year growth rate would have been below two per cent. 
 True, there have been some achievements. 
 Productivity in manufacturing has risen faster than in the past. 
 Some distortions in the tax system have been removed. 
 But the costs &mdash; to the poor, to the quality of public services, to the trade balance &mdash; have been considerable. 
 Now hubris has been succeeded by nemesis. 
 Mr Lawson's luck has run out. 
 He and Mrs Thatcher are having to face up to a crisis they have made worse by trying to deny it, and now they cannot agree on who should do what or how or why. 
 World View: So close yet still far apart: Timothy Garton Ash reflects on what it means when Germans start behaving like Poles, and Poles like Germans 
 By TIMOTHY GARTON ASH 
 What is the difference between Poles and Germans? 
 The Germans can make any system work. 
 The Poles can destroy any system. 
 Such humorous generalisations about &bquo;national character&equo; are, of course, deeply suspect, and will soon be banned by Unesco. 
 Yet in our bones we all know that there is such a thing as national character, even if only a fool or a racist would attempt to define its precise ingredients. 
 We all exclaim &bquo;how very French&equo;, &bquo;how marvellously Irish&equo; or &bquo;how ridiculously English&equo;, and we know what we mean. 
 In the same way there are qualities we recognise as quintessentially &bquo;Polish&equo; or &bquo;German&equo;. 
 And these qualities contrast. 
 It is hard to think of two other nations in Europe which are so close and yet, still, despite many noble efforts on both sides, so very far apart. 
 In the last month, however, our expectations have been disconcerted. 
 On the streets of Leipzig and Dresden Germans have begun &mdash; just begun &mdash; to behave like Poles. 
 In the economic ministries of the new Polish government, in workshops and backyards, Poles have begun &mdash; just begun &mdash; to behave like Germans. 
 Germans have stood up for freedom. 
 Poles have sat down for efficiency. 
 And the rest of Europe must cry: three cheers for both! 
 The crisis of the GDR is a novelty in the Eastern Europe of the 1980s. 
 For it is in essence a political crisis without an economic crisis. 
 In Poland, Hungary and the Soviet Union, the dramatic political developments were directly precipitated by economic crisis. 
 The story has then been one of the dynamic interaction of politics and economics, with political change affecting the economy &mdash; so far mainly for the worse &mdash; and economic crisis sharpening the political struggle. 
 In the GDR, by contrast, one cannot talk of &bquo;economic crisis&equo; in the sense that one can use that term for Poland, the Soviet Union, and even for Hungary. 
 True, real growth has been slowing. 
 The deferred tasks of modernisation are accumulating. 
 Shortages have got worse. 
 Relatively speaking, the West looks more attractive than ever. 
 But it was not economic distress that precipitated the present crisis. 
 Of course Western prosperity is one reason why East Germans want out. 
 But it is wrong and deeply offensive to suggest &mdash; as Robert Maxwell recently did after meeting with Erich Honecker &mdash; that this is the main reason they are fleeing. 
 We have hundreds of testimonies from escapees who left behind a nice flat, two cars, country cottages, yachts&hellip; 
 No, what they want is perfectly expressed in the simple banner held up during the Leipzig demonstrations: &bquo;Freiheit!!!&equo; 
 The East German crisis &mdash; or should one say simply the German crisis? &mdash; is thus essentially a political crisis, and the answers to it, if there are answers, must also be political. 
 The Polish crisis, by contrast, is now essentially economic. 
 For almost exactly nine years, from the late summer of 1980 to the late summer of 1989, Poland lived through a political crisis. 
 That political crisis both drove and was driven by the economic crisis: but again and again it emerged that the key lay in politics. 
 In attempting to influence political developments in Poland, the West was reduced to using precisely those instruments that the Bonn government (and Social Democratic opposition) is now belatedly attempting to apply to the GDR: first, a symbolic politics recognising the Church and opposition as partners no less important than the communist authorities who claim to be, but are not, identical with &bquo;the state&equo; and, second, the conditional offer of economic help (politely called &bquo;co-operation&equo;) as a goad to political change &mdash; neither pure &bquo;carrot&equo; nor simple &bquo;stick&equo;, but a carrot-cum-stick. 
 These are crude instruments. 
 But in such circumstances they are all we have. 
 Despite the chaotic and inconsistent way in which they were applied to Poland, they had, on balance, an ultimately positive effect. 
 In Poland today, however, we face a quite new situation. 
 The basic political crisis has, in effect, been resolved. 
 Government, Church and Solidarity are united in the person of the Prime Minister, Tadeusz Mazowiecki. 
 Of course there are endless inconsistencies, tensions and conflict. 
 Of course there is chaos. 
 Yet politically the new constellation arrived at by elections and negotiations over the past six months &mdash; a strong presidency held by Jaruzelski, a Solidarity-led &bquo;grand coalition&equo; government, a real parliament -is somehow working. 
 But while all this was being thrashed out, over six months, over nine years, the economy was getting worse, and worse, and worse. 
 The challenge to the West here is thus, &mdash; at the moment &mdash; primarily economic. 
 For the West, as for the Poles, there was a time for obstinate political defiance. 
 That time is past. 
 To adapt Edmund Burke: the age of chivalry is gone. 
 That of economists and calculators has succeeded; and the glory of Europe hangs in the balance. 
 Almost as soon as he was nominated, Mr Mazowiecki said &bquo;I am looking for my Ludwig Erhard&equo;. 
 The German model. 
 And just a few weeks ago the man he found, Deputy Prime Minister Leszek Balcerowicz electrified the finance ministers of the developed world with a seven-page plan to &bquo;transform the Polish economy into a market economy&equo;. 
 No one has tried to do this before. 
 No one knows whether it can be done. 
 How do you turn a clapped-out Lada into a Mercedes while driving down the motorway? 
 The wise men from Harvard fly in and tell you: &bquo;It will have to get worse before it gets better&equo;. 
 But the man in the street will say: how can it get worse? 
 And: why should it get better? 
 The idea of the &bquo;big plunge&equo; is that you rapidly create an economic environment in which producers will spontaneously respond to demand, and the change of profit. 
 But beside all the problems confronted by such strategies in, say, Latin America, there is a whole set of even more basic structural problems specific to a post-war East European &bquo;socialist&equo; economy: the lack of capital, real money or real banks. 
 And beside the basic structural problems there is a further set of problems connected with such an economy in crisis: energy shortages, or assembly-lines standing idle for want of one or two spare parts. 
 One can all too easily imagine a situation in which, within a few months, Poland will have the worst of all worlds: hyper-inflation and acute shortages and high unemployment, all at the same time. 
 According to Lech Walesa, one can also imagine people exploding in sheer desperation &mdash; tomorrow. 
 Faced with this unprecedented, unique and, above all, fearsomely complex challenge, the West is just beginning to come up with an unprecedented, unique, and also fearsomely complex response. 
 In the end it may be a Marshall Plan in scale, but not in kind. 
 Already in July, the Group of Seven (G7) top industrial nations asked the EC to co-ordinate the efforts of the 24 member nations of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) &mdash; a hitherto unheard-of construction. 
 Some food aid is already going in. 
 The European Investment Bank will make available up to Ecu 1bn (&pound;685m) for loans to Poland and Hungary &mdash; another first. 
 The traditional multilateral institutions, IMF and World Bank, are gearing up for a major contribution. 
 The British government has established a small fund for bringing the &bquo;know-how of pluralism&equo; to Poland: in management, accountancy, banking, local government, tourism and even (God help us) journalism. 
 As so often with British policy, it is the right thing, but not enough of it &mdash; although Nigel Lawson promised in Washington that we would do more. 
 The French have offered modest new credits. 
 The Americans have announced food-aid, know-how and investment support schemes, and &dollar;200m of credit which may go towards the &dollar;1bn &bquo;stabilisation loan&equo; requested by the Polish government. 
 Much of this is conditional on an IMF seal of approval. 
 Everyone is waiting for the Japanese. 
 Everything depends on everything else. 
 But in all this vast, slow, cacophonous orchestra, the most important single player is West Germany. 
 The Kohl government is profoundly aware of this responsibility. 
 Despite some domestic political resistance &mdash; from its own right-wing rather than the opposition &mdash; it is determined to produce a major &bquo;package&equo; for the Chancellor's visit to Poland later this year. 
 To its critics, it can argue that this is in the German interest in three ways. 
 In the short term, it will secure rights and recognition for the remaining German minority in Poland. 
 In the medium term, a success for the attempted transformation in Poland would be a very major encouragement for fundamental reform in the GDR. 
 In the long term, all West Germany's Western neighbours and partners would feel a great deal more relaxed about a coming-together of the two Germanies if her immediate neighbours to the East were capitalist democracies, themselves gradually integrating into a larger Western European community. 
 Thus in the short, medium and long term, to help Poland is to help Germany. 
 It is only a slight exaggeration to say that, at this extraordinary historical moment, the future of Poland depends on the Germans; the future of Europe depends on each behaving a little more like the other. 
 BOOK REVIEW / The gentleman who did the dirty work &mdash; &bquo;The Time of My Life: Denis Healey&equo; &mdash; Michael Joseph, 17.95 pounds 
 By JEREMY PAXMAN 
 DENIS Winston Healey is having a certain amount of characteristically mischievous fun with journalists at the moment, on the question of whether he will or will not stand at the next election. 
 Whatever his decision, this book of memoirs reads like his valedictory. 
 In the last decade, Denis Healey has developed from prop-forward bruiser to everybody's favourite uncle. 
 Mike Yarwood and the catchphrase &bquo;Silly Billy&equo; had a lot to do with it, but more important is the fact that the Labour Party now belongs to a younger generation. 
 How many people now remember his humiliation as chancellor of the Exchequer, turning back on a trip to Heathrow en route for a meeting of the International Monetary Fund in order that he could draft an application for a loan from the same organisation, then appearing in the Blackpool bear garden to be publicly abused? 
 A weaker person might have buckled under the strain, but Healey bounced back, and it is his considerable inner strength which gives this account of his life in politics its particular charm. 
 Recent years have seen a succession of second-rate political memoirs illuminated by the self-serving clarity of hindsight, stashed with dutiful acknowledgements to dreary constituency agents, padded out with hack accounts of official visits to one foreign country or another. 
 This is in another class altogether: literate, thoughtful, at times profound, and shot through with wit. 
 Edward Heath was a contemporary at Balliol, where Healey became a communist. 
 Healey recalls walking in the quad with him. 
 &bquo;I happened to mention that a mutual friend was going to Bibury with his girl for the weekend. 
 Teddy looked at me with horror. 
 &bquo;You don't mean to say they're sleeping together?&equo; he whispered. 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 I suppose so,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;Good heavens,&equo; said Teddy, &bquo;I can't imagine anyone in the Conservative Association doing that.&equo; 
 Heath's lack of imagination in this field,&equo; Healey observes, &bquo;was to have consequences for some of his cabinet ministers later on.&equo; 
 Healey is, of course, the man who likened an attack by Sir Geoffrey Howe to being savaged by a dead sheep, and his one-liners are terrific. 
 Harold Wilson had a &bquo;short-term opportunism, allied with a capacity for self-delusion which made Walter Mitty appear unimaginative.&equo; 
 Richard Crossman was &bquo;a heavyweight intellect with a lightweight judgement.&equo; 
 Roy Jenkins's appearance had &bquo;the sleek pomposity of Mr Podsnap.&equo; 
 And of the party in the Fifties: &bquo;the Great Debate in British socialism has so far consisted in one side talking nonsense and the other side keeping mum.&equo; 
 No one would accuse Mr Healey of retiring modesty. 
 Documents declassified under the 30-year rule tend to confirm the wisdom of his early years in politics. 
 Few mistakes are admitted to, and events which don't reflect well upon him, like the highly dramatic resignations of the Navy Minister and chief of Naval Staff in protest at his decision to scrap aircraft carriers, are dismissed in two illuminating sentences. 
 Quite how a man who could not bear to hurt a living thing after seeing the damage his childhood air-rifle did to a starling could serve as defence secretary is something of an enigma. 
 Yet this was not only his most effective period in office but also the job he enjoyed most. 
 The Suez debacle had been the great emblematic event for Healey, as for many others of his generation, vividly demonstrating the gulf between imperial pretence and potential. 
 His time in the Ministry of Defence was one of constant retrenchment &mdash; the withdrawal from East of Suez, the aircraft carrier decision, the scrapping first of the TSR2 aircraft project, to be replaced by American F111s, themselves then also cancelled. 
 Whatever the subsequent rationalisations, all decisions were forced upon him by shortage of cash. 
 Healey always seems a man at the receiving end, full of great ideas but with little or no room for manoeuvre. 
 As chancellor he inherited an economy with the skids under it after the Barber years. 
 Soon, inflation was running at 26 per cent and the trade unions were grasping for whatever wage awards they could. 
 His forecasting staff in the Treasury might have been better suited to dreaming up horoscopes, and at times officials seem to have been deliberately distorting figures for political ends. 
 In the circumstances, his failure to win the leadership of the party seems unsurprising. 
 He was a pragmatic loner from first to last, and by now had devised his own answer to the student chestnut &bquo;Who will do the dirty work under socialism?&equo;: 
 Denis Healey would. 
 His explanation for this defeat in the leadership elections - that some right-wing MPs voted for Michael Foot in order to justify their subsequent defection to the SDP &mdash; looks fanciful to say the least. 
 But his failure represents a great lost opportunity to have avoided both the damaging interlude of the SDP and the antics of the loony left which kept Labour out of the office for a decade. 
 He twice turned down the chance to become Secretary General of Nato, and the ideas on defence and deterrence outlined here compare favourably with much of the output of the Beltway Bandits and their fellow theorists in Paris or Moscow, save only that they are more readably expressed. 
 The prospectus for the Nineties with which his book concludes is a thoughtful text which could with benefit be read by anyone interested in foreign affairs. 
 The whole manuscript is illuminated by a genuinely cultured temperament. 
 His final, understated comments on the worthwhile qualities of a career in politics are as good an apologia for a much-derided trade as I have read recently. 
 He emerges as a man with a big heart and a clever mind who did the best he could in difficult circumstances. 
 Around the World 
 By BRUCE PALLING 
 Rupe roots for his mate Bob Rupert Murdoch has stirred up the possums in Australia, his former homeland, by praising his mate Bob Hawke, the Prime Minister, and dismissing Andrew Peacock, the opposition leader. 
 Although he traded in Australian citizenship for an American passport for business reasons, he still has a stranglehold on 60 per cent of Australia's main newspapers. 
 In a television interview given after appearing in Adelaide at the annual meeting of his parent company, News Corporation, he confessed to having &bquo;considerable sympathy&equo; for the way Bob was handling the economy. 
 Then, in a quick display of candour &mdash; or humour &mdash; he added: &bquo;I mean, I could argue one way or the other about that. 
 I'm not going to say something here which is going to commit my newspapers. 
 That's up to the editors.&equo; 
 Rock &bquo;n&equo; rail Some months before the troubles developed in East Germany, one of the world's more arcane organisations, the Ireland-German Democratic Friendship Society, announced plans to celebrate in Dublin the 40th birthday of their comrades' dictatorship in the East. 
 A couple of bands were hired several months ago to jolly up the celebrations, whose main participants appeared to be trade unionists who had been on free holidays to one of the last proletarian paradises. 
 One band was called &bquo;Imelda's Boyfriend&equo; and the other &bquo;The Train Now Leaving&equo;. 
 Strong words were exchanged with the latter band by the organisers, who demanded a quick piece of historical rewriting to expunge this accidental slur on the workers' state. 
 However, the rock group refused and the party went on, with no ill-effects on the tiny number of celebrators or the East German functionaries. 
 GDR is just a joke The ferment in East Germany is breeding a batch of jokes. 
 A little old lady, troubled by the unrest, goes to her local Communist Party secretary and asks: &bquo;Was socialism invented by politicians or scientists?&equo; 
 He replied: &bquo;Politicians, of course.&equo; 
 The old lady nodded wisely: &bquo;I thought so&hellip; scientists would have tried it out on rats first.&equo; 
 Erich Honecker dies and goes to Heaven, but St Peter bars the way: &bquo;Erich, you belong in Hell.&equo; 
 Honecker begs in vain, then finally asks: &bquo;Can I at least leave my luggage here for a bit?&equo; 
 St Peter reluctantly agrees. 
 Next day, a small but agitated devil knocks on the doors of Heaven. 
 &bquo;Have you come to pick up Honecker's luggage?&equo; 
 St Peter asks. 
 &bquo;No, I'm the first refugee from Hell.&equo; 
 Cuddly Saddam Iraq is not a country one normally sees being defended, so it is all the more intriguing to read a glowing account of this thuggish regime by Tony Marlow, the right-wing Tory MP for Northampton North. 
 Having recently returned from a &bquo;fact-finding mission&equo; organised by the &bquo;Gulf Centre for Strategic Studies&equo;, Mr Marlow attacks in the Gulf Report the &bquo;vociferous and unrepresentative minority that effects (sic) to believe that our way of life and system of government is the measure by which all other countries should be measured.&equo; 
 Rather than censure the dictatorship of President Saddam Hussein, Mr Marlow believes that its poor image is partly the fault of the British press. 
 &bquo;The press (and television) increasingly make their money (or secure their viewers) by providing entertainment.&equo; 
 As for British citizens falling foul of the regime, Mr Marlow believes that &bquo;No country can be expected to operate a differential system of justice in favour of foreigners&equo;, although he adds that benefits can accrue from the exercise of &bquo;justified clemency&equo;. 
 Daphne Parish, a British nurse, has been held incommunicado since last month for giving information on casualties caused by an explosion at an Iraqi missile plant in August. 
 Farzad Bazoft, the Observer's correspondent, was detained soon afterwards and also denied consular access. 
 These unfortunate people have more comprehension of the nastiness of the Saddam regime than the member for Northampton North, who gives &bquo;rugby spectator&equo; as one of his hobbies in Who's Who. 
 Cover-up claim as Indian press joins battle over Bofors 
 From TONY ALLEN-MILLS in New Delhi 
 AN INDIAN journalist yesterday accused his editor of suppressing information that might have helped to identify the recipients of millions of dollars in bribes allegedly paid to Indian officials by the Bofors armaments company, a scandal which has caused acute embarrassment to Rajiv Gandhi's government. 
 Narasimhan Ram, associate editor of The Hindu, a Madras-based daily, said at a press conference that it had been preparing to publish documents about the &pound;550m Bofors contract to supply the Indian army with 155mm howitzers. 
 On Tuesday The Hindu printed copies of supposedly secret Swedish government documents which purported to confirm that, despite denials in India and Sweden, Indian middlemen had received huge payoffs as part of the contract. 
 The Hindu report infuriated the opposition in parliament and there were renewed demands for the resignation of Mr Gandhi, who has repeatedly been accused of attempting to cover up the scandal. 
 The Hindu promised fresh disclosures the next day, but Wednesday's paper contained no more reports. 
 Mr Ram, whose family owns The Hindu, said yesterday that &bquo;internal sabotage&equo; had prevented the series from continuing. 
 He accused his editor, Govindan Kasturi, of &bquo;arbitrarily&equo; deciding to discontinue the expose, even though the paper had more documents in its possession. 
 Mr Ram hinted that Mr Kasturi had been got at by government officials. 
 Mr Ram said that in the interests of press freedom he was offering The Hindu's reports to rival newspapers. 
 At least two, the Statesman and the Indian Express, were expected to take up the story in their issues today. 
 All those involved were cagey about the contents of the reports. 
 However, for all the heat generated by the scandal, it appeared from this week's developments that the opposition is still far from identifying the &bquo;smoking bank account&equo; that would ruin Mr Gandhi's career. 
 While the press, led by The Hindu, has gone a long way to proving that Bofors handed out millions of dollars to Indian middlemen, the identity of the ultimate recipients of the money remains a mystery. 
 Allegations that Mr Gandhi or members of his family received large sums have often been heard on opposition hustings, but not a shred of evidence exists that his hands dipped anywhere near the till. 
 Without proof that money was paid into an account controlled by Mr Gandhi, there is little doubt that the Prime Minister will be able to continue resisting calls for his resignation. 
 But the steady drip of disclosures, which appears certain to continue right up to the general election later this year, could yet prove fatal to the Congress (I) Party's chances of remaining in power. 
 Mr Gandhi may not have been personally involved in the Bofors contract, but his government's clumsy efforts to keep the case under wraps have smacked of guilt, and the Prime Minister's &bquo;Mr Clean&equo; image of five years ago has all but been destroyed by the scandal. 
 Shared adversity unites old Communist enemies: Andrew Higgins, in Peking, examines why East Germany and China are blaming the West for their youth's disenchantment with communism 
 From ANDREW HIGGINS in Peking 
 &bquo;WARMLY congratulate the German Democratic Republic on its 40th anniversary,&equo; reads the latest exhortation to adorn the cheerless, half-empty lobby of the Peking Hotel, China's grandest monument to socialist hospitality at its dreary, dust-covered worst. 
 The Peking Hotel is not alone in its sympathy for Erich Honecker's regime. 
 United by a sense of shared adversity, party leaders in Peking and East Berlin have now forgotten their past quarrels to confront what both see as their common enemy &mdash; the forces of change sweeping the rest of the Communist world. 
 On one level the sudden and unexpected friendship thrives on little more than mutual back-scratching. 
 When most countries recoiled in horror at China's killing of unarmed protesters four months ago, East Berlin helped break China's isolation by offering support and congratulations. 
 Likewise, when China had trouble getting guests for its national day celebrations on 1 October, the 40th anniversary of Communist rule, East Germany was again glad to oblige, along with hardline stalwarts such as Cuba, North Korea, Czechoslovakia and three African countries: the Comoros, Kenya and Burundi. 
 In its zeal to relieve China's embarrassment at hosting a party with so few guests, East Berlin sent two senior officials &mdash; Egon Krenz, a member of the Politburo, and Wolfgang Rachfuss, a member of the Central Committee. 
 China was quick to repay the favour. 
 When East Germany celebrated its own equally joyless 40th birthday party last weekend, Peking sent a delegation led by Yao Yilin, a senior Politburo member and veteran central planner who appreciates a well-regimented society. 
 The Chinese press marked the occasion by scrupulously avoiding any mention of the one subject that has preoccupied the rest of the world's news media: why people keep leaving East Germany. 
 But the two countries share not only embarrassment but a common mission. 
 While China insists that its open-door policy remains intact and continues to encourage investment from the West, it has revived a vocabulary of ideological struggle almost identical to that used in East Germany. 
 Recent national day speeches in the two countries were almost interchangeable. 
 Jiang Zemin, the newly-appointed secretary-general of the Chinese Communist Party, and Mr Honecker, his East German counterpart, chose the same themes - the superiority and inevitable triumph of socialism, the need to strengthen the leadership of the party and the danger posed by pressure for rapid reform. 
 The leaders blamed the disenchantment of their young people on an international conspiracy by reactionary forces aimed at, according to Mr Honecker, &bquo;confusing people and sowing seeds of doubt in the power and advantages of socialism&equo;. 
 But if neither China nor East Germany is shy about attacking the West, both tread gingerly over the problem at the heart of their common predicament - what to do about their fellow socialists. 
 For all their bluster about foreign conspiracy, the foreigners who worry them most live not in the United States or Western Europe but in Hungary, Poland and the Soviet Union. 
 Both Peking and East Berlin have witnessed at first hand just how dangerous the forces unleashed by Mikhail Gorbachev can be. 
 It was a visit to Peking by the Soviet president in May that helped to bring more than a million demonstrators out on to the streets on two successive days, pushing China's student-led protest movement towards its tragic climax. 
 The Soviet leader has had a more modest, though not dissimilar effect on East Germany, where his presence last weekend became a focus for calls for change of the type so steadfastly refused by his hosts. 
 For hardline leaders in East Germany and China, the dilution of party authority in Hungary and Poland represents not reform but treason, a betrayal that threatens to undermine their own legitimacy. 
 Without absolutist faith in the right of the party to rule, East Germany would lose its sole raison d'etre. 
 The same faith provides China's leaders with their only explanation and justification for why they sent tanks to crush student protesters who had hurt no one and damaged nothing. 
 &bquo;History has proved and will continue to prove, that the socialist system has a strong historical vitality and is full of life,&equo; said Mr Jiang in his national day address. 
 &bquo;Seeing only the whirlpools and counter-currents but not the progress of the long river of history only reveals the observer's political short-sightedness.&equo; 
 Mr Honecker chose a different image to make the same point: attempts to destabilise socialism, he said, are like &bquo;the fruitless attacks by Don Quixote against windmills that continue to turn imperturbably.&equo; 
 Tibetan protest in New Delhi 
 From ANDREW HIGGINS in Peking 
 Tibetan refugees protest in front of the Chinese embassy in New Delhi against a visit to India by Wu Xueqian, a Chinese Vice-Premier attending talks about the Indo-Chinese border  
 Out of the USSR: The guard is not yet tired here 
 By RUPERT CORNWELL 
 MOSCOW &mdash; Once upon a time, in a previous journalistic incarnation, I worked at Westminster. 
 The first thing which struck me upon attending a House of Commons debate was how few MPs actually turned up to take part. 
 The second thing was that almost never did it matter since the whips ran the show. 
 Exactly 11 years later, I find myself doing the same job, this time in the Kremlin. 
 Riveted and astonished, I can report that in a palace whose previous tenants have included Ivan the Terrible and Stalin, parliamentary democracy is flourishing. 
 Only last June, when this first Supreme Soviet worthy of the name was elected from the Congress of People's Deputies, everyone predicted that it would be a pretty soft touch. 
 Many big-name radicals in the Congress had failed to win seats. 
 True, in a full-time legislature appearances at least would differ from its feeble predecessor. 
 But when push came to shove, we blase Western correspondents told each other, the government and the party would get their way. 
 Not so. 
 For one thing, the deputies turn up. 
 For the six full sessions every Monday and Tuesday so far, at least 400 of the 542 Supreme Soviet members have been present throughout the day. 
 On top of that, for the remaining three days each week, several of its 23 permanent commissions beaver away at the mountain of legislation that is being thrust before them. 
 About 20 major bills are promised this session. 
 Admittedly, some facilities leave much to be desired. 
 There is, for example, no Annie's Bar where we may gossip with the mighty over a vodka &mdash; although we do have access to a well-stocked cafeteria, where the waitresses are uncommonly polite. 
 But we can buttonhole anyone we please as they leave the chamber: a privilege akin to the London correspondents of Pravda or Izvestia being able to accost cabinet ministers in the members' lobby of the Commons. 
 That Soviet fondness for improvisation doubtless explains why the local equivalent of HMSO does a miserable job of providing us with copies of draft laws under discussion. 
 And on one occasion at least the deputies themselves had to pronounce on a crucial compromise resolution whose text had not even been distributed. 
 No daily Hansard is at hand, to get us out of a tight corner. 
 This old Westminster hand misses the joy of watching a backbench procedural expert destroy a day's business, if not a bill, with a point of order or a single wrecking amendment. 
 But these are early days. 
 Most important, we are witnessing constitutional history. 
 In just three weeks, the Supreme Soviet has become a real parliament, in the sense that every problem of national life feeds into it. 
 Lithuanians protest, Ukrainian mine leaders warn, Armenians walk out. 
 Already fascinating conflicts between legislature and executive (be it government or party apparatus) are taking shape: over the non-publication of a commission report on the Hitler-Stalin pact of 1939 and its consequences; over the Uzbek corruption affair and the alleged complicity of the Politburo conservative Yegor Ligachev; even, it would now seem, on the overriding issue of the 1990 plan and budget. 
 But everyone is on their best behaviour. 
 Such previously unimaginable impertinences must not only be done by the book: they must be seen to be too. 
 What is at stake in this novelty could scarcely be greater. 
 Should this well-behaved and well-intentioned parliament fail, then its failure will merely be infinitely depressing vindication of the theory that Russia &mdash; and a fortiori the Soviet Union &mdash; can only be ruled by a rod of iron. 
 All Soviet history points that way. 
 A parliament possessing real power is alien to the country's every tradition. 
 The last experiment, the post-revolutionary Constituent Assembly, lasted but 24 hours after it had tiresomely refused to recognize the authority of the Bolshevik government. 
 On 6 January, 1918, the soldiers &bquo;protecting&equo; its deliberations marched in to put an end to proceedings. 
 &bquo;The guard is tired,&equo; was the explanation offered by Anatoly Zhelesnyakov, commander of the intruding detachment. 
 His words are as familiar to Soviet schoolchilden as Cromwell's &bquo;In the name of God, go&equo; to the Long Parliament over 250 years earlier, is to us. 
 No one has yet suggested that Mikhail Gorbachev, or anyone else for that matter, should make himself Lord Protector. 
 But these are turbulent, unpredictable times. 
 The charms of limitless glasnost have already worn distinctly thin. 
 A Supreme Soviet of fine words and few deeds could quickly become just an irritant, a scapegoat for a &bquo;democratization&equo; which does not put goods in the shops. 
 Westminster, for all its failings, never faced that threat. 
 E Germans demand deeds, not words 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 GERMANS in East and West reacted with disappointment and scepticism yesterday to a promise by the East German leaders to talk about change. 
 &bquo;What good are hints when they do not say when, how and what will ever get better?&equo; one East Berliner asked Western journalists. 
 &bquo;After the events in Leipzig and other cities I would have expected more,&equo; said another. 
 &bquo;This declaration is not a blind bit of good to the workers who have to take over the jobs of those who have emigrated,&equo; and &bquo;Why do we have to wait till the next central committee meeting?&equo; were other grumbles. 
 Barbel Bohley, a co-founder of the reformist discussion group New Forum, said the promise by the Politburo was &bquo;only a verbal concession&equo; which would not have any effect on real life. 
 The most optimistic were East German Protestant leaders. 
 Manfred Stolpe, chairman of the Berlin-Brandenburg Church Consistory, admitted not all their dreams had come true but it was &bquo;a start to the process of dialogue&equo;. 
 The long statement, read out on East German television after the evening news, followed a crisis meeting of the 21-strong Politburo on the exodus of tens of thousands of East Germans and the mass protests last weekend. 
 The move in itself was sensational, but after close scrutiny top East Berlin-watchers in Bonn decided its contents were &bquo;not very promising&equo;. 
 The hardline leadership admitted for the first time it regretted the exodus, admitted there were problems and conceded it might be partly to blame. 
 &bquo;But the hints of such things as &bquo;travel opportunities&equo; and &bquo;media that are close to life&equo; are too vague and generic,&equo; one said. 
 The insistence that the discussion take place through established party channels and the refusal to contemplate changes to the present communist system meant real reforms are extremely unlikely, he added. 
 Otto Reinhold, an East German ideologue, reinforced this gloomy view by insisting: &bquo;We do not want reform for reform's sake, but changes which will help the further development of socialism&equo;. 
 The Politburo statement helped to strengthen suspicions that Erich Honecker's days as East Germany's leader are numbered. 
 Kurt Hager, the 77-year-old chief party ideologue who first indicated changes were on the way, insisted in Moscow yesterday: &bquo;The leadership is united and will remain so, even though people keep on trying to invent disputes.&equo; 
 Informed sources say neither the more realistically-minded East German leaders nor the Russians believe that any sensible changes can be brought about so long as Mr Honecker, 77, whose attitudes have become particularly rigid in recent months, is at the helm. 
 Not that he will necessarily go soon, but few think he will last longer than the party congress next May. 
 He is still frail after a gall bladder operation, and his health could be an excellent reason for his departure. 
 UN force due for Central America 
 From PETER JAMES SPIELMANN of Associated Press 
 NEW YORK &mdash; The UN Secretary-General, Javier Perez de Cuellar, plans to send a 625-member peacekeeping force to Central America in the first serious test of the regional peace agreement signed in August. 
 A draft copy of Mr Perez de Cuellar's report to the Security Council shows that the force would be a highly mobile border patrol, equipped with jeeps, helicopters and speedboats. 
 Its mission is to prevent any nation from mounting an attack on its neighbour, to verify that no rebel forces launch cross-border raids, and to halt any broadcasts by insurrectionary forces. 
 Canada, West Germany and Spain will provide personnel, and there will also be a Latin American contingent. 
 The Security Council must approve the force, to be called Onuca. 
 The presidents of El Salvador, Nicaragua, Honduras, Guatemala and Costa Rica wrote to Mr Perez de Cuellar in March, requesting the establishment of Onuca. 
 It would be the first major peacekeeping force deployed in the Western Hemisphere. 
 Onuca will have 260 military observers, 115 helicopter and aircrew, 50 naval personnel, 14 medical staff, about 104 UN administrative staff and 82 locally-recruited civilians. 
 It will have headquarters in Honduras, with a liaison office in each of the five Central American capitals and 31 &bquo;verification centres.&equo; 
 In practice, its mission will be to make sure the Contras in Honduras do not infiltrate Nicaragua, and to keep the Farabundo Marti Liberation Front (FMLN) guerrillas in El Salvador from seeking shelter in Honduras. 
 The US representative to the UN, Thomas Pickering, has stressed that Onuca should deal with the FMLN as well as the US-supported Contras. 
 Washington seems content to let the United Nations disband the Contras, but Mr Pickering and other US officials have been linking it to the disbanding of the FMLN, without explicitly making it a condition for Washington's cooperation. 
 Escobar pleads for talks after new arrest 
 From PETER JAMES SPIELMANN of Associated Press 
 BOGOTA (Agencies) &mdash; A leading member of the Medellin cocaine cartel who resorted to plastic surgery to avoid arrest has been captured and will face extradition to the United States, the Colombian authorities said yesterday. 
 Shortly after the announcement Pablo Escobar, the reputed leader of the cartel, the largest in the world, reiterated the drug barons' readiness to negotiate with the government in a letter to a Bogota newspaper. 
 The Administrative Security Department said Jose Abello Silva, indicted in the US in 1987 on drug charges, was arrested on Tuesday in a Bogota restaurant. 
 It said in a communique that he had undergone facial surgery to avoid detection. 
 Mr Abello was the fourth-ranking person in the Medellin cartel and the most important suspect arrested since Colombia began cracking down on the cocaine barons nearly two months ago, the department said. 
 Mr Escobar, in a letter to La Prensa, called for &bquo;direct dialogue to search for peace&equo;, with participation by government, opposition, judicial, church and journalism representatives. 
 He promised attacks by his cartel would cease if the government agreed to negotiate. 
 At least nine people have died in bomb attacks launched by the cartels since President Barco ordered the crackdown on the cocaine traffickers. 
 The group has also claimed responsibility for a string of murders of journalists and other civic leaders opposed to the cartels and in favour of Mr Barco's decree authorising the drug traffickers' extradition to the US. 
 Mr Escobar confirmed reports that he had been in contact with the government for over 12 months prior to the crackdown, ordered after the drug-related slayings of a presidential candidate and two other top officials. 
 On Wednesday, the Bogota newspaper El Espectador temporarily closed its Medellin office after cartel agents killed two of the newspaper's employees there and threatened to murder the bureau's remaining staff of 11. 
 An executive of the anti-drug crusading newspaper said officials would explore ways of improving office security. 
 Noriega tries to shore up crumbling power base 
 From DAVID ADAMS in Panama City 
 THE PANAMANIAN military chief, General Manuel Noriega, has turned to &bquo;people power&equo; as he strives to shore up his tottering regime in the wake of last week's failed coup attempt. 
 He has declared himself general co-ordinator of a new Parliament of Popular Power which, although it has no legislative authority, appears destined to take the place of the country's National Assembly, which was dissolved last month. 
 But new evidence is emerging that shows even greater military discontent with the general's rule than was previously thought. 
 The wife of Major Moises Giroldi, the dead coup leader, has identified other officers who were involved in the plot, but who are still believed to hold their posts. 
 Following her airlift to the United States with 40 other coup survivors and relatives, Edela de Giroldi said her husband was betrayed by fellow officers who deserted the coup plotters at the last minute. 
 She named Major Francisco Olechea, the head of Battalion 2000 &mdash; the unit which came to General Noriega's rescue during the coup &mdash; as one of the initial conspirators. 
 Major Olechea has not been detained since the coup. 
 &bquo;Everything was ready,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;But Olechea was playing a winner's game and he failed to come through because of his cowardice. 
 He committed treason.&equo; 
 Mrs Giroldi alleged that General Noriega personally killed her husband, &bquo;even though my husband was his trusted friend&equo;. 
 In a relaxed and confident address to the Parliament of Popular Power, General Noriega told more than 500 delegates that if he dies, his supporters should seize all government installations and continue a process of national liberation from US imperialism without him. 
 For the time being the parliament serves only as an advisory body of Noriega loyalists. 
 But the country's National Assembly, which was dissolved in September, shows no signs of being revived. 
 Panamanian opposition leaders say that the coup attempt has shown how General Noriega's own supporters are abandoning him. 
 &bquo;His very own people are rebelling against him,&equo; said an opposition spokesman, Luis Martinez. 
 &bquo;He cannot twist this into a fight for the liberation of Panamanians.&equo; 
 Gold rush comes to Russia 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL, in Moscow 
 GOLD HAS always been the ultimate store of value &mdash; and so it is proving here today. 
 With scarcely a consumer item worthy of the name to buy in the shops, and with a rouble in their pockets that loses value by the week, Soviet citizens are staging a gold rush. 
 Perhaps unsurprisingly, given that Western estimates place the Soviet Union as the world's second producer behind South Africa, gold jewellery and commemoratively minted gold coins have been always comparatively plentiful, though their export is forbidden. 
 In the last two months, however, jewellery shops have been taken by storm. 
 Moscow stores alone report sales of gold this year running at double those of last, while those of diamonds and silver have almost quadrupled. 
 Faced with a demand that could no longer be met, the Moscow city fathers 10 days ago limited purchases to one item per person. 
 But the queues continue &mdash; symbolising a gathering flight from money amid constant rumours that a currency reform is in the offing. 
 This would be aimed, the argument runs, at confiscating the ill-gotten gains of &bquo;speculators&equo; in the much-hated co-operative movement, and at eliminating a surplus currency overhang of up to 150bn roubles (&pound;150bn). 
 As must any government in similar circumstances, Moscow denies any such intention. 
 &bquo;I can say firmly and unambiguously &bquo;no&equo;, ' declared Leonid Abalkin, the Deputy Prime Minister in charge of economic reforms, when questioned on the subject by the government newspaper Izvestia. 
 But it has happened, most recently under Stalin in December 1947, when all cash in the possession of individuals above a maximum of 3,000 roubles was forcibly exchanged on a 10-for-one basis. 
 The method was harsh, but brought a 17 per cent drop in retail prices and an end to formal rationing. 
 Many trade union leaders and ordinary workers want a repeat dose to wipe out fortunes accumulated on the black market and through high-priced co-operatives of &bquo;rouble millionaires&equo;. 
 Currency reform was &bquo;essential&equo;, said a resolution adopted after a protest here last week of trade unionists from all over the Russian Federated Republic. 
 Simultaneously, calls are growing for the introduction of a new rouble backed by gold, akin to the Chervonets, a monetary unit brought in by Lenin in 1922 as part of his Economic Policy which permitted a measure of private enterprise. 
 Worth 10 ordinary roubles, the units could be exchanged for seven grams of gold. 
 This would have the merit of being convertible into hard currencies and enable the import of desperately needed consumer goods from the West, and it would help soak up excess ordinary roubles on the domestic market. 
 The Soviet Union certainly has the means. 
 Gold output is one of the few remaining state economic secrets. 
 Western analysts put annual production at between 250 and 350 tonnes, and total reserves at up to 2,000 tonnes &mdash; worth around &dollar;22bn at world prices. 
 Galtieri walks free as the generals seek vindication 
 By ISABEL HILTON, Latin America Editor 
 THE former president of Argentina and the man responsible for one of the most ill-organised military adventures in history, General Leopoldo Fortunato Galtieri, was freed yesterday under a presidential pardon from his comfortable confinement in a suburban military college in Buenos Aires. 
 General Galtieri's release underlines the fact that the Argentine armed forces may have learned nothing and forgotten nothing, but, by dint of constant pressure on Argentina's elected leaders, they have moved closer to their goal of rewriting history with themselves in the role of hero. 
 The question now is how much further they will push. 
 &bquo;The hardliners will not be satisfied with anything short of a total vindication of the Falklands and the &bquo;dirty war&equo;, ' said one Argentine military analyst. 
 Those demands were voiced repeatedly in the successive military rebellions that dogged President Alfonsin's administration as dissatisfied military officers refused to accept the judgements that civil society attempted to impose on their conduct in the dictatorship. 
 General Galtieri was acquitted on human rights charges but sentenced first by a military court, then, on appeal, by a civilian court on his conduct of the 1982 Falklands War. 
 He was accused under three main charges: that he launched the invasion with no plan to counter a British military reaction, that there was no co-ordination between the three branches of the armed forces and that Argentine forces were left without support as the British advanced. 
 His defence was to insist that he would do exactly the same again under the same circumstances. 
 His release is a victory for those elements in the armed forces who reject even their fellow officers' professional criticism of the Falklands campaign and argue that General Galtieri deserved a statue, not a prison sentence, for his actions. 
 President Menem last week explained the pardon, which embraced 280 people, including former leftist guerrillas as well as officers convicted of torture and murder, as necessary to heal the wounds in Argentine society. 
 His critics point out that the pardon has proved deeply unpopular and, to the extent that it is likely to encourage the armed forces to insist on a public vindication, could have the opposite effect. 
 Clashes disrupt peace moves in Western Sahara 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN, Africa Editor 
 THE WAR in the Western Sahara, dormant for 12 months after an informal ceasefire, has burst into life again with two attacks in the past five days by Polisario guerrillas on the Moroccan wall dividing the territory. 
 The Moroccans claim to have killed 101 Polisario guerrillas and lost 11 dead and 10 wounded in Wednesday's battle near the border with Mauritania. 
 Polisario claims to have killed 180 Moroccans and wounded 150. 
 It gave no figures for its own losses. 
 Last week Morocco claimed it had killed or wounded 80 Polisario guerrillas and had lost 14 soldiers, including a colonel, when Polisario attacked its defences near the Mauritanian border. 
 For the past 13 years Polisario, operating in jeeps across the semi-desert, has mounted surprise attacks on the huge sand wall which runs across the country. 
 Braving the minefields, guerrillas capture Moroccan soldiers and equipment and retire into the desert. 
 In February a ceasefire was established after King Hassan met Polisario leaders for the first time. 
 Meanwhile Algeria, Polisario's main backer, restored diplomatic relations with Morocco and signed a regional co-operation pact with Morocco, Mauritania and Tunisia. 
 The advantages of regional economic co-operation appeared to outweigh obligations of shared ideology. 
 Morocco claims the former Spanish colony as Moroccan territory. 
 Polisario, representing many of its inhabitants, claims it is an independent country. 
 Both sides have agreed in principle to a referendum on the future of the territory, and the United Nations has been trying to achieve agreement on its details but, despite concessions by Polisario, little progress has been made. 
 A follow-up meeting between the movement and the king never materialised, and after the two clashes on the border King Hassan has called off a second meeting. 
 &bquo;Hassan is not serious,&equo; said Malainine Sadik, a member of the political bureau of Polisario, in London this week. 
 &bquo;If he was he would sit down at the negotiating table with us.&equo; 
 This view was reflected by one observer in Rabat, who said: &bquo;He (King Hassan) has so clearly been playing for time. 
 I think the Algerians have been angry with him for some time and are prepared to let Polisario have a free hand.&equo; 
 Frustrated by the delay in the peace talks, Polisario has resumed fighting and claims to have occupied 10 miles of the Moroccan lines. 
 But without new supplies from Algeria it is doubtful whether it can sustain an offensive for long. 
 Joyful reunion may make South African history: Albertina Sisulu and Nelson Mandela talked of old times and new strategy, she told John Carlin at her home in Soweto 
 From JOHN CARLIN in Soweto 
 IT HAS been a tough quarter of a century for Albertina Sisulu. 
 Her husband Walter, former secretary-general of the African National Congress, has been behind bars. 
 She has endured house arrest, detentions without trial, continual harassment by the police and orders banning her from political activity, while, all the time, never shrinking from her duties of leadership in the thankless battle against apartheid. 
 Now, at last, at the age of 71, things are starting to come right. 
 Tuesday was the turning point, as well as a day of great joy. 
 Her husband, President FW de Klerk announced, was to be released. 
 More immediately delightful, she saw Nelson Mandela, an intimate friend of her youth, for the first time since he was sentenced to life imprisonment in 1964. 
 And all against the background of what appears to be a historic breakthrough in black South African politics as the cracks in the apartheid edifice widen and the government begins to lose its grip on the affairs of state. 
 Breathlessly, in an interview yesterday at her home in Soweto, she recounted the events. 
 &bquo;I flew down to Cape Town and at 9.30 we went &mdash; with my daughter, son-in-law and their two children &mdash; to Pollsmoor Prison to visit my husband. 
 We noticed that there was a lot of rushing around. 
 All the guards looked worried. 
 &bquo;I asked him: &bquo;What's going on? 
 Why all this movement?&equo; 'Man, I don't know,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;But one thing is that we have a meeting at 1pm at Nelson's cottage. 
 We're going to meet him&equo;.' 
 &bquo;We&equo; were the seven political prisoners at Pollsmoor &mdash; all senior ANC members &mdash; of the eight men whose release Mr de Klerk was to announce that night. 
 Further suggesting to Mrs Sisulu that she might afford to hope, to imagine that her husband might be freed, was a meeting that she and other leaders of the Mass Democratic Movement had scheduled with Mr Mandela at 6pm. 
 Ismail Ayob, Mr Mandela's lawyer, had phoned Mrs Sisulu, Cyril Ramaphosa, Murphy Morobe and Cassim Salojee &mdash; all MDM leaders &mdash; on Monday night to instruct them to be at Mr Mandela's prison house, also in the Cape Town area, at five on Tuesday afternoon. 
 &bquo;The last time I'd seen Nelson was in the courtroom in 1964,&equo; Mrs Sisulu said. 
 &bquo;We were so excited to meet, you can imagine! 
 We're almost the same age, I'm just a few months older. 
 And we're cousins, you know.&equo; 
 How did he look? 
 &bquo;Oh, he's quite fine. 
 He's lost a lot of weight, but he looks very fit. 
 A touch of TB always drains one.&equo; 
 She was referring to the illness which put him in hospital last year before he was moved out of Pollsmoor to his present quarters, formerly a prison warden's home. 
 &bquo;The house is posh, man, posh &mdash; so many rooms! 
 He's got a TV and a phone and a little library and a garden. 
 Man, if it was his own home, I'd say the man was really comfortable!&equo; 
 The four had supper with Mr Mandela. 
 &bquo;It was very nice food,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;We had steak, chips and all sorts of salads. 
 He's got a gentleman there who makes his meals for him and cleans the house. 
 &bquo;Over the meal he told us that he had discussed with the authorities what people would be released. 
 That's why he met the seven earlier in the afternoon. 
 He said the announcement would be made at eight that evening. 
 &bquo;Suddenly we realised it was eight o'clock and we rushed to the sitting room to put on the TV. 
 We listened and there it was: De Klerk's announcement. 
 &bquo;The men around me jumped around and shouted and shook my hand, and Nelson hugged me. 
 But I was just cool. 
 I couldn't believe it. 
 It took a while to sink in.&equo; 
 They were with Mr Mandela until 10pm, much of the time he and Mrs Sisulu simply recalling their old days together and recounting what they had done all these years. 
 The main dish, though, was the question of negotiations with the government. 
 &bquo;He was trying to explain to us how he feels about negotiations, how it was his feeling that in any country, even if there is war, there is time for negotiations. 
 He said that if the people were ready for negotiations, he wouldn't be against it. 
 But he said the people must be well educated on this and everything must be explained to them before any steps are taken. 
 &bquo;He said he had written a document which would explain everything &mdash; all his views on negotiations. 
 And this document will be distributed among the people, it will be made public. 
 He says it's very important that people know what negotiations are about.&equo; 
 What about her husband? 
 What were his political plans? 
 &bquo;First of all, be sure of one thing. 
 When he comes back we will celebrate: Oh! we are going to welcome him! 
 As far as what his political role will be, you know my husband is an ANC man &mdash; and he's not going to deny it. 
 He will stick to the ANC.&equo; 
 But would he resume his position of leadership? 
 &bquo;Oh yes, yes! 
 Some people might think they will be forgotten. 
 But the people have always said: &bquo;Release our leaders!&equo; 
 So, the leaders will be released to lead the people. 
 They will take their rightful places and we will follow them&hellip; 
 They must take advantage of their unconditional release and go on with the ANC. 
 We joined these organisations (the MDM, the United Democratic Front) because the ANC was banned. 
 Now we'll go home to our organisation, to the ANC.&equo; 
 And the government? 
 Didn't she think it was odd that they were taking such a risk? 
 &bquo;Oh, let them gamble!&equo; she chuckled. 
 &bquo;Let them gamble!&equo; 
 Why were they gambling? 
 Was it perhaps partly that Mr Mandela, did she get the feeling, was pulling strings, leading the government along? 
 &bquo;Nelson Mandela is twisting them around his little finger.&equo; 
 CAPE TOWN &mdash; Two South African riot police officers were acquitted yesterday of assault charges brought by a fellow policeman who said their unit had acted like wild dogs during protests around Cape Town, Reuter reports. 
 A court found Major Charles Brazelle and Lt David Roos not guilty of ordering their squads to use excessive violence against anti-apartheid protesters during riots before parliamentary elections last month. 
 But the court ruled it was clear that members of Lt Roos's patrol had beaten members of the public, and added it was astonishing that they had escaped punishment. 
 Lt Gregory Rockman, the Coloured (mixed-race) officer who brought the charges, said the verdict was ridiculous and provided patrols with a licence for beating. 
 Jordan embarks on an electoral road to uncertainty: In November Jordanians will vote in the country's first parliamentary elections in 22 years. 
 Charles Richards, in Maan, describes changing attitudes to the government 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Maan 
 THE CHARRED hulks of vehicles beside the highway on the approaches to Maan, 130 miles through the desert south from Amman, remain as mute but eloquent reminders of the limits of public tolerance of an unpopular government when no other expression of opinion is possible. 
 A newly constructed police encampment on the outskirts of the city underlines that the authorities are prepared for any eventuality. 
 It was in Maan that riots against price rises started in April. 
 The unrest, which killed 11 people, spread elswhere in the south, the traditional base for support for the Hashemite regime; first to al Hassaniyeh and al Tufeila, and then up to Kerak, Madaba and Salt. 
 In response, King Hussein removed his prime minister and childhood friend, Zeid ar-Rifai, and accelerated the announcement of parliamentary elections to be held on 8 November, the first for 22 years. 
 &bquo;If we had enough money there would be no need for elections,&equo; said a political commentator. 
 &bquo;The swiftness and depth of the economic shocks were key factors. 
 Jordan simply had to come to terms with political and economic imbalances.&equo; 
 But there is little civic pride in Maan that its actions should have set off the train of events. 
 Instead townspeople speak of Maan's glorious role in sparking another great rebellion, the Arab revolt against the Ottomans. 
 The Maan which Lawrence of Arabia knew was a way-station on the Hejaz railway taking pilgrims down to Mecca, and later was briefly capital of Transjordan before the Emir Abdullah, grandfather of King Hussein, moved with his tribal chiefs to Amman. 
 Whether from shame or fear of the all-pervasive Mukhabarat security police, people are reluctant to talk of the four civilians in Maan who were killed - they do not use the word &bquo;martyred&equo; as would Palestinians on the West Bank of the river &mdash; during the &bquo;sorrowful events&equo; as they are known in official parlance. 
 &bquo;The disturbances were spontaneous outpourings against bad management by the ex-government&equo; said Mahmoud Talhouni, known as Abu Ammar, a conservative politician, tribal leader and electoral candidate. 
 He emphasised that people distinguished between the ex-government and the King. 
 &bquo;When the King came recently, blood flowed in the streets from all the camels killed for him. 
 This was an expression of the real soul of this city.&equo; 
 Campaigning for the 80 parliamentary seats opens officially tomorow. 
 But already candidates have been holding informal sessions, enticing potential voters with great banquets of slaughtered sheep. 
 Mahmoud Talhouni says that since the last elections, television and communications have increased the electorate's awareness. 
 &bquo;People can see how across there Israeli politicians fight each other in parliament, and in Greece they bring to account a corrupt prime minister.&equo; 
 His comments reflect the uncertainity of an experiment where no one under the age of 42 has voted before. 
 Corruption and the mismanagement of the economy by the previous government are major issues. 
 A number of people associated with the excesses of the past have already fallen from grace. 
 Ahmed Shalabi, the Iraqi founder and head of Petra Bank, the country's third largest, has fled the country amid accusations of fraud and embezzlement. 
 The government has announced that culprits in the scandal will be tried by military court. 
 The prosecution could open a can of worms, since Mr Shalabai who has denied any wrongdoing had connections at every level. 
 Other prominent personalities to have departed the scene are Ali Ghandour, the Lebanese Shia head of the national airline, and Abdul Hadi Majali, the powerful police chief and scion of a powerful Kerak clan. 
 But bread-and-butter issues are alos important. 
 Maan, with no agriculture, commerce or industry, is especially hard-hit by the country's economic difficulties, including the halving of the value of the dinar, rising prices and more unemployment. 
 &bquo;The elections mean nothing&equo; said a local chemist. 
 &bquo;Nothing has changed. 
 What matters is that something should be done to give us jobs and money to live on. 
 If not there will be another explosion.&equo; 
 There are two explanations put forward for why the King has relaxed his grip on the government. 
 The first theory is that the move is a safety valve, to defuse popular resentment and a sense of alienation. 
 In future, government will be more accountable to an elected legislature. 
 State institutions will be reinforced. 
 Elections, however, are only the first step. 
 Political parties are still banned. 
 Candidates stand as individuals. 
 As for the future, much depends on how far the King is prepared to renounce constitutional prerogatives. 
 The experiment has gathered wide support, even from left-wing groups which in the past sought to overthrow the monarchy, but which now express support for constitutional reform. 
 The second hypothesis is more ominous. 
 This is that the King is showing signs of not having learnt the lesson of the past months. 
 He has travelled abroad at sensitive times. 
 He is used to ruling autocratically, as are his advisers. 
 There were disturbing hints of this attitude in his televised speech to the nation on Saturday evening. 
 He effectively cast his own vote against the Islamic trend by calling on his subjects not to vote for extremist religious ideologies &mdash; a move which could prove counter-productive. 
 For 36 years, he has survived through a sure-footed personal response to problems. 
 He may have reassured himself of the contnuing power of his charisma during recent tours of the south, where he was given a rapturous welcome. 
 But the jubilation in Kerak and Madaba may have led him to overestimate his popular support in the area where he has traditionally drawn his loyal troops. 
 There was grumbling that he may not have heard among tribesmen at al Hassaniyeh who are resentful at not being able to voice their grievances freely. 
 Eventually, he may feel parliament is expendable. 
 This could happen if 10 or 15 firebrands are elected, whether Islamic zealots or radical Palestinians, or if parliament plays an overly assertive and forceful role. 
 Were he to deflect the challenge by dissolving parliament, it would confirm he had not properly learnt the lessons of April's disturbances. 
 Fading star 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Maan 
 BUDAPEST (AP) &mdash; The light illuminating the huge red star atop Hungary's parliament was switched off and will be removed after the Communist Party's decision to disband. 
 Falling down 
 Foreign News Page 8 
 Manila calamity 
 Foreign News Page 8 
 Nagorny death 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Maan 
 MOSCOW (Reuter) &mdash; Soviet troops killed a second man in the disputed territory of Nagorny Karabakh and Azerbaijan extended its railway blockade of Armenia to neighbouring Georgia, Soviet newspapers said. 
 Greek caretaker 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Maan 
 ATHENS (UPI) &mdash; The Greek Chief Justice, Yannis Grivas, was sworn in as caretaker Prime Minister, with a 20-member cabinet of judges and retired army men, to take the country into general elections on 5 November. 
 President Christos Sartzetakis asked Mr Grivas to form a government after the main political parties would or could not do so. 
 Union reform 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Maan 
 CANBERRA (Reuter) &mdash; Australia's conservative opposition, led by Andrew Peacock, announced plans to curb trade unions, sell state assets and cut taxes, with a view to the general election a year ahead. 
 Indians to go 
 Foreign News Page 8 
 Inquiry call 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Maan 
 JERUSALEM (Reuter) &mdash; Britain's senior diplomat in the Israeli-occupied territories called for an inquiry into the killing by troops of an Arab youth. 
 Consul-General Ivan Callan, who visited the occupied West Bank town of Nablus, said a woman there told him she saw Nidal al-Habash, 21, shot after he raised his hands and then shot three more times on the ground. 
 &bquo;It seemed to be a credible account,&equo; Mr Callan said. 
 Pretender's trial 
 From CHARLES RICHARDS in Maan 
 BASTIA, Corsica (Reuter) &mdash; After 11 years of deliberations, a court has ordered the pretender to the Italian throne to stand trial for manslaughter in the shooting of a German youth. 
 Prince Victor Emmanuel of Savoy, 52, son of Italy's last king, will be tried in the Corsican capital Ajaccio. 
 The shooting happened after the prince went in search of a dinghy taken from his yacht. 
 Peking summons 
 By KEVIN HAMLIN 
 HONG KONG &mdash; Xu Jiatun, China's senior official in Hong Kong, was summoned to Peking for talks on the dispute between China and Hong Kong over the Chinese swimmer Yang Yang, who was allowed by Hong Kong to go to the US last week, writes Kevin Hamlin. 
 China retaliated by refusing to accept back illegal immigrants into Hong Kong. 
 Bug alert 
 By KEVIN HAMLIN 
 NEW YORK (AP) &mdash; Computer users around the world waited nervously to see whether warnings of a rogue &bquo;virus&equo; come true today. 
 Someone tampered with IBM systems by planting a dormant bug due to wipe out whole data banks as soon as the calendar hits Friday 13 October. 
 It has been detected in a dozen systems in the US and yesterday the Swiss government announced that 75 of its computers were infected. 
 Kremlin wars 
 By KEVIN HAMLIN 
 MOSCOW (Reuter) &mdash; A senior defence official acknowledged that Soviet combat forces fought for a decade in Vietnam and in other foreign wars over the past 40 years. 
 In what Western experts said was the first recognition of the extent of Kremlin military activity, Lieutenant-General Anatoly Sidorov listed Korea, Egypt, Syria, Angola and Ethiopia as other countries where Soviet troops fought. 
 Battles at Pope's sermon 
 By KEVIN HAMLIN 
 DILI (Reuter) &mdash; Pro-independence demonstrators fought with police during a Mass in East Timor for about 100,000 people at which the Pope told Indonesia to uphold human rights after &bquo;years of death and destruction&equo;. 
 The protesters waved banners in Portuguese reading &bquo;Pope, please save East Timor&equo; and yelled &bquo;Long Live Fretilin', the guerrilla movement seeking independence. 
 Vibrant atom-age timekeepers clock up a Nobel Prize 
 By TOM WILKIE, Science Correspondent 
 THE NOBEL Prize for physics has been awarded to three scientists who developed ultra-precise techniques that lie at the heart of modern atomic clocks. 
 Two US scientists have been awarded the chemistry prize for a discovery that has changed scientists&equo; views about the origin of life. 
 Norman Ramsey, 74, of Harvard University, shared the physics prize with Hans Dehmelt, a naturalised US citizen born in Germany in 1922, and Wolfgang Paul, 76, of the University of Bonn in West Germany. 
 In 1949, Professor Ramsey introduced a crucial refinement to previous work on atomic beams which allowed the frequency of atomic vibrations to be measured with unprecedented accuracy. 
 Scientists discovered the atom vibrates with more regularity than the earth turns on its axis. 
 So in 1967, the rotation of the earth was abandoned as the basic source of timekeeping. 
 The definition of a second has since officially been the time it takes a cesium atom to make 9,192,631,770 vibrations. 
 Professor Ramsey then went on, with other colleagues, to develop the hydrogen maser, which, with recent refinements, may be able to measure frequencies with a stability of one part in a billion billion. 
 That is the equivalent of a clock set running at the time of the dinosaurs having gained or lost less than a second by today. 
 Masers have allowed scientists to track the infinitesimally slow drift of the continents across the earth's surface and to check the predictions of Einstein's theory of relativity that gravity or acceleration will cause a clock to run slow. 
 In the 1950s, Professor Paul carried out the first experiments using a form of magnetic bottle &mdash; the &bquo;Paul trap&equo; &mdash; to isolate ionised atoms. 
 The work was further developed by Professor Dehmelt. 
 In the 1970s, at the University of Washington in Seattle, he succeeded in isolating a single electron and holding it in his trap for nearly 10 months before losing it. 
 Brian Petley, who is head of basic metrology at Britain's National Physical Laboratory, says the technique was so sensitive that Professor Dehmelt was able to measure the mass of the proton relative to the electron with an accuracy of one part in 100 million. 
 That is the equivalent of weighing a fully-laden oil supertanker so accurately that a contraband bottle of whisky in the captain's cabin would register on the scales. 
 Sidney Altman, 50, of Yale University, and Thomas Cech, 41, of University of Colorado, Boulder, shared the chemistry prize. 
 In the 1970s, the two were independently studying how the information necessary to specify living creatures, which is stored in the DNA molecule, was transcribed and its instructions expressed to make living cells. 
 DNA contains huge stretches of &bquo;junk&equo; information that have to be edited out. 
 This is done when the message, written in the DNA double helix, is transcribed into a related &bquo;messenger&equo; molecule, called RNA. 
 Everyone had thought that only special chemical scissors, strips of protein called enzymes, could snip out the junk. 
 The two scientists demonstrated that some RNA molecules could do the job directly. 
 &bquo;They deserve the award,&equo; said David Zimmern of the Laboratory of Molecular Biology at Cambridge. 
 &bquo;It was something that impressed a lot of people.&equo; 
 The discovery may also be important medically, Dr Zimmern suggested. 
 Some cases of Hepatitis B are complicated by a satellite virus known as the delta agent and its RNA has been shown to have this catayltic property. 
 Neo-fascists apologise for disruption in Strasbourg 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Strasbourg 
 AFTER 24 hours of disruption, the European Parliament recovered its poise last night when two members of its neo-fascist faction publicly apologised for violently interrupting proceedings on Wednesday. 
 Bruno Gollnisch of West Germany and Bernard Antony of France had resisted expulsion from the parliament chamber after protesting against a decision to exclude their party from leading official visits abroad. 
 The resulting fracas led to the suspension of proceedings for two hours on Wednesday and further rancorous debate yesterday. 
 Both members of Jean-Marie Le Pen's European Right party, the MEPs shouted insults at the President of the Parliament, Enrique Baron, when he announced the measure barring the far-right party from leading delegations to Israel and Switzerland. 
 Political leaders from across the assembly had resolved earlier in the week that an apparent lacuna in the rulebook which gave the neo-fascists the chairmanship and vice-chairmanship of the delegations should be filled so that the pair could be voted out of their posts. 
 There was unanimity among all but Mr Le Pen's members that the neo-fascists would be unsuitable to represent Strasbourg abroad, especially at the Knesset. 
 Glyn Ford, the leader of the British Labour group, was among those speaking out against Mr Le Pen's group. 
 &bquo;Ever since the elections they have been revealing themselves as the neo-Nazis that they really are,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Le Pen said his 17-member party was being persecuted and unjustly accused of racism and fascism. 
 Earlier, the leader of the Socialists, Jean-Pierre Cot, said Mr Le Pen had &bquo;improved his Nazi vocabulary&equo; by his alliance with the West German Republicans, led by ex-Waffen SS officer, Franz Schonhuber. 
 Mr Schonhuber also voiced anger, saying that &bquo;squadrons of former Waffen SS officers&equo; were now members of the Social Democratic party in West Germany. 
 &bquo;We are seeing a pilgrimage of hypocrisy,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Gollnisch had shouted &bquo;Dictator, dictator&equo; at Mr Baron on Wednesday and called other MEPs &bquo;Gestapo men&equo;. 
 When officials tried to eject him, he tried to punch his neighbours. 
 Mr Le Pen launched his own tirade of Nazi terminology, suggesting that his party members were being treated as Untermenschen. 
 In accepting the apology last night, Mr Baron said he considered the case closed. 
 Several members of the European Parliament, including Mr Cot, had called for the pair to be suspended for five days with financial penalties. 
 However, Mr Baron also ordered a review of the rules regarding disturbances in parliament sessions to ensure that tougher sanctions can be applied to members causing disruptions in future. 
 Exhibition of children's books at the Frankfurt Book Fair 
 From DAVID USBORNE in Strasbourg 
 A SPECIAL exhibition of books for children forms one of the centrepieces of the 41st annual Frankfurt Book Fair. 
 This year's five-day fair is the biggest so far, with 8,189 exhibitors from 93 countries; the organisers expect 220,000 visitors. 
 Britain &mdash; represented by 1,041 exhibitors &mdash; is the second-largest contingent after West Germany. 
 But business at the fair &mdash; the focal point of world publishing &mdash; has been described as quiet. 
 Works under discussion range from novels by Tom Wolfe to The Complete Book of Portable Power Tool Techniques. 
 At least one deal has been mooted which would allow European firms to publish simultaneously in several languages. 
 Well-oiled transfer of power in Norway 
 From TONY SAMSTAG in Oslo 
 OSLO &mdash; The leader of Norway's minority Labour government, Gro Harlem Brundtland, is not entirely without a sense of humour. 
 It is no accident that she chose Friday the 13th to resign, writes Tony Samstag. 
 A new government, a centre-right coalition led by the mainstream Conservative Party, takes over on Monday, with the Brundtland administration caretakers over the weekend. 
 It is an orderly transition, reinforcing the impression, as it is intended to, that the social-democratic ship of state is on course, its institutions well-oiled and in working order, even though last month's general election left the country with a hung Storting (parliament). 
 From Monday the world's third-richest nation (in per capita income terms), an important member of Nato and the second-largest oil producer in Europe, will be run by a fragile alliance of Conservatives, who won 22 per cent of the vote, the Centre Party, representing farmers' interests, who won 7 per cent, and the Christian Democrats, whose religious enthusiasts won 9 per cent. 
 The balance of power will be held by the Progress Party, an unpredictable all-purpose protest party. 
 Swede is cleared of murdering Palme 
 From MATS WIKLUND in Stockholm 
 THE MAN sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder of the Swedish prime minister, Olof Palme, was acquitted yesterday after the appeal court overturned the verdict against him. 
 The court announced that the charges against Christer Pettersson, a social outcast with a history of manslaughter and drugs offences, did not contain enough evidence for a guilty verdict. 
 As Mr Pettersson left Kronoberg remand centre with a police escort and his lawyer, Arne Liljeros, he declared: &bquo;I'm of course happy. 
 After all, I had imagined a future in Kumla security prison. 
 &bquo;I'm surprised. 
 I never really believed I would be acquitted, although I am innocent.&equo; 
 In July Mr Pettersson was convicted by a the crown court in a split decision where the majority, consisting of lay assessors, unanimously voted in favour of a life sentence. 
 The assessors based their decision almost entirely on the testimony of Lisbet Palme, who without hesitation pointed out Mr Pettersson as the man she saw standing near her and her dying husband. 
 Olof Palme was shot dead on a Stockholm street on 28 February 1986. 
 A second shot grazed Mrs Palme. 
 The text of the appeal court judgement, where trained judges form the majority, will not be made public until 2 November. 
 But it is safe to assume that the lack of technical evidence &mdash; no weapon connected to the murder has been found &mdash; and a valid motive will be cited. 
 Almost certainly, Mrs Palme's testimony will be put in doubt. 
 Mr Liljeros has maintained that too much time has passed to make it possible for Mrs Palme to point out her husband's murderer. 
 Mrs Palme was first confronted with Christer Pettersson in December 1988, more than two years after the death of Olof Palme. 
 An appeal to the Swedish Supreme Court is considered unlikely, so Christer Pettersson is to all practical purposes a free man. 
 How free is another matter. 
 There is already talk of changing his identity. 
 He could also expect record damages after being jailed for almost 10 months. 
 As for the hunt for Mr Palme's murderer, Swedish police officials have asserted that it will continue. 
 Aoun rejects deal and says war still on 
 By HARVEY MORRIS, Middle East Editor 
 LEBANON'S Christian leader, General Michel Aoun, last night denounced a draft peace agreement produced by the country's parliamentarians in the Saudi resort of Taif on the grounds that it did not set a timetable for the withdrawal of Syrian troops occupying the country since 1976. 
 The general's effective rejection of the peace charter, which has yet to be formally presented by the 31 Christian and 31 Muslim deputies gathered in Taif for the past two weeks, risks plunging Lebanon into a new cycle of the violence from which it temporarily escaped when the Arab League brokered a ceasefire on 23 September. 
 Speaking to Christian supporters in east Beirut, General Aoun reminded the deputies in Taif that &bquo;a war has erupted to liberate Lebanon and it is still on and it will continue until it achieves its goals&equo;. 
 The general, whose appointment as prime minister a year ago is disputed by a rival Muslim government in west Beirut, did not want Christian deputies to go to Taif in the first place. 
 In the face of their insistence and that of Arab League negotiators, he warned them not to settle for any deal which did not involve the withdrawal of 30,000 to 40,000 Syrian troops based in west Beirut and the hinterland. 
 In the event, the deal which has emerged in Taif has justified the general's fears of what he would regard as a sell-out of the Maronite cause. 
 A working group of senior parliamentarians broke the deadlock at the talks by endorsing a charter which would give equality in parliament to the majority Muslim population and transfer powers now enjoyed by the Maronite presidency to a cabinet headed by a Sunni Muslim. 
 The charter, if put into effect, would reform the unwritten national charter of 1943, which gave the Maronites political dominance of the multi-confessional state. 
 The new charter would more closely reflect the demographic predominance of the Muslims, a move which their leaders and their Syrian backers argue is long overdue. 
 But General Aoun insists no such reforms can be instituted until the withdrawal of Syrian troops, which Christian leaders invited into Lebanon in 1976 as a peacekeeping force. 
 &bquo;We can achieve such reforms on Lebanese soil once it is free of any conqueror imposing his will on it,&equo; the general said last night. 
 The tentative Taif agreement, on the other hand, sets no timetable for a total Syrian withdrawal and refers only to a pull-out from the Beirut area within two years. 
 The fear among many Muslim Lebanese, who might otherwise favour the departure of the Syrians, is that they would leave behind a power vacuum to be filled by warlords on both sides of the confessional divide. 
 Most of these consistently criticised the parliamentary peace efforts under way in Saudi Arabia. 
 The Druze leader, Walid Jumblatt, said in Amman yesterday that the Taif deal would not bring peace to Lebanon and that, although he did not intend to block it, he would not accept it either. 
 Mr Jumblatt's forces, together with the Syrians, were in the front line of the confrontation with Christian forces &mdash; General Aoun's &bquo;war of liberation&equo; - which began in March and lasted until the Arab League-sponsored ceasefire last month. 
 Ark Royal sheers off after battle of Lisbon 
 From TONY SMITH of Associated Press 
 LISBON &mdash; The British aircraft carrier Ark Royal cut short a five-day goodwill visit here yesterday as controversy flared between US and Portuguese officials over the arrest of 121 American and British sailors during an alleged street-fighting rampage. 
 The Ark Royal, which docked in Lisbon on Wednesday, prepared to return to Portsmouth four days early after shore leave was cancelled following the incident. 
 &bquo;We've decided to go. 
 The atmosphere is bad and British sailors could get caught up in the bad feeling if they went ashore,&equo; said the Ark Royal's captain, John Brigstocke. 
 &bquo;We're at pains to stress this isn't a protest, but we were here for rest and recreation,&equo; he said, &bquo;so if I can't send my men ashore; there's not much point in staying.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;There is no evidence of fighting between American and British sailors&hellip; and I am confident my men were not involved in any drunkenness, damage or trouble of any kind.&equo; 
 Lisbon police said about a third of the 121 sailors detained were British. 
 They said the sailors were detained after about 500 seamen brawled along Lisbon's dockside, besieging a police station, smashing windows in shops and bars and overturning cars. 
 They were later released after their commanders promised there would be no further incidents, said duty officer Paulino Cardoso. 
 But US embassy officials said preliminary interviews with most of the 142 injured US servicemen indicated they were wounded in clashes with police. 
 Mr Cardoso said the battling started after three black American seamen attacked a white US sailor at the Passport Bar in the gaudy, neon-lit Cais do Sodre area. 
 Fighting spread from bar to night-club along the narrow cobbled streets of the seedy riverside area as other sailors, including British seamen from the carrier, joined in and police were called in to keep the peace, he added. 
 US officials, however said there was no proof of fighting among sailors. 
 Police revised an earlier version that the clashes began between black US and white British sailors. 
 US and Portuguese officials were yesterday conducting separate investigations. 
 Court Circular 
 From TONY SMITH of Associated Press 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 12 October: His Excellency Senhor Luis Neto-Kiambata was received in audience by The Prince of Wales and The Prince Edward, Counsellors of State acting on behalf of The Queen, and presented the Letters of Recall of his predecessor and his own Letters of Credence as Ambassador Extraordinary and Plenipotentiary from the People's Republic of Angola to the Court of St James's. 
 His Excellency was accompanied by the following members of the Embassy, who had the honour of being presented to Their Royal Highnesses: Senhor Virgilio Marques de Faria (Counsellor), Senhor Emilio Sofia Rosa (Head of Protocol) and Senhor Mario Alfredo (Financial Attache). 
 Senhora Neto-Kiambata had the honour of being received by The Prince of Wales and The Prince Edward. 
 Sir Patrick Wright (Permanent Under Secretary of State for Foreign and Commonwealth Affairs), who had the honour of being received by Their Royal Highnesses, was present and the Gentlemen of the Household in Waiting were in attendance. 
 12 October: The Duchess of York, Patron of Museums Year 1989, this afternoon opened the Food for Thought Gallery at the Science Museum, London SW7. 
 Her Royal Highness was received by the Deputy Mayor of Kensington and Chelsea (Councillor Mrs Elizabeth Russell). 
 The Duchess of York this evening attended the opening performance by The Spanish Riding School of Vienna at Wembley Arena. 
 Her Royal Highness was received by The Austrian Ambassador (His Excellency Doctor Walter Magrutsch). 
 Mrs John Floyd was in attendance. 
 12 October: The Prince Edward this evening presented the Historical Association's Young Historian prizes on the First National History Day at the Imperial War Museum, London SE1. 
 Major William McLean was in attendance. 
 12 October: The Princess Royal, Colonel-in-Chief, The Royal Scots (The Royal Regiment), this morning received Lieutenant-Colonel Martin Gibson upon relinquishing his appointment as Commanding Officer of the 1st Battalion and Lieutenant-Colonel Iain Johnstone upon assuming the appointment. 
 Her Royal Highness, President, Riding for the Disabled Association, afterwards attended the Council Meeting at Saddlers' Hall, London. 
 In the afternoon, The Princess Royal, Chief Commandant, Women's Royal Naval Service, attended the WRNS 40th Anniversary luncheon on board HMS London in the Pool of London. 
 Afterwards Her Royal Highness, Colonel-in-Chief, The Worcester and Sherwood Foresters Regiment (29th/45th Foot), received Lieutenant-Colonel Richard Lees upon relinquishing his appointment as Commanding Officer of the 3rd Battalion and Lieutenant-Colonel Malcolm Peatfield upon assuming the appointment. 
 In the evening, The Princess Royal, Chancellor, University of London, attended a reception and dinner at the Senate House, Malet Street, London WC1, on the occasion of the Foundation Day 1989 followed by the Foundation Ceremony and reception at the Institute of Education, Bedford Way, London WC1, and was received on arrival by the Lord Flowers (Vice-Chancellor). 
 Mrs Malcolm Wallace was in attendance. 
 Mrs Michael Wigley was in attendance. 
 His Royal Highness was attended by Mr Andrew Palmer. 
 The Duchess of Kent, as Patron of Age Concern England, this morning opened the Hockley and Hawkwell Old People's Welfare Council Day Centre, Hockley, Essex. 
 Her Royal Highness, who travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight, was attended by Mrs Alan Henderson. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS Prince Edward attends an evening of greyhound racing at Kingsmead Stadium, Canterbury, in support of the Royal Marines School of Music Disaster Fund. 
 Princess Alice, Duchess of Gloucester, President, The Gardener's Royal Benevolent Society, attends a luncheon and subsequently a Council Meeting at Red Oaks (Home for Retired Gardeners), Henfield, on the occasion of the society's 150th Anniversary Year. 
 The Duke of Kent, Vice Chairman of the British Overseas Trade Board, visits Reckitt and Colman, Norwich, Norfolk. 
 Apple Pickers in a South-West Orchard, 1988 
 By JOANNA GIBBON 
 Apple Pickers in a South-West Orchard, 1988, a photograph by James Ravilious, which forms part of a touring exhibition called Orchards this autumn. 
 The exhibition is being organised by Common Ground, a charity, which was created in 1983 to promote new and imaginative approaches to prevent the destruction of the character and fabric of our countryside and towns, writes Joanna Gibbon. 
 The charity sets up projects, often connected with the arts, to persuade people to value their surroundings, regardless of whether they are unusual or not. 
 So far they have set up Parish Maps, New Milestones and recently Trees, Woods and the Green Man projects &mdash; the last being connected to the Orchards exhibition. 
 Common Ground is concerned about the decline in old orchards, which grow traditional varieties of fruit, provide habitats for bees, grazing for sheep, geese and pigs and create beautiful landscapes; their exhibition encourages people to grow their own fruit trees, and plant larger orchards for the community. 
 The exhibition's first venue is the Royal Albert Memorial Museum, Exeter; it runs from 28 October to 2 December, and then tours the south-west of England in 1990. 
 Common Ground urgently needs to raise &pound;7,000 to publish a small book and poster for the exhibition. 
 Appointments 
 By JOANNA GIBBON 
 Miss Elizabeth Neill Fisher, to be a Circuit Judge (Midland and Oxford Circuit). 
 Mr Richard Graeme Hawkins, to be a Circuit Judge (South Eastern Circuit). 
 Anniversaries 
 By JOANNA GIBBON 
 On this day: the arrest of the Templars for heresy took place in Paris, on the orders of Philip IV, 1307; Benedict Arnold was defeated at Lake Champlain, 1776; President George Washington laid the foundation stone of the White House, Washington 1792; British forces defeated the Americans at the Battle of Queenston Heights, 1812; Greenwich was adopted as the universal meridian at the Washington Conference, 1884; 41 people were killed during a German air-raid on London, 1915; Ankara became the new capital of Turkey, 1923; Italy declared war on Germany, 1943; the Allies liberated Athens, 1944; the first London production of the musical show The Pajama Game was presented, 1955. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 14 
 Obituary: David Anderson 
 By SIMBA MAKONI 
 David Alexander Anderson, public servant, born Bathgate Lothian 7 June 1920, EEC Delegate to Botswana, Lesotho and Swaziland 1975-78, Commonwealth Assistant Secretary General (Managing Director Commonwealth Fund for Technical Co-operation) 1978-83, married 1953 Mary Rammell (two daughters, and one daughter deceased), died Holton Buckinghamshire 9 October 1989. 
 DAVID ANDERSON was a life-long campaigner for African development and believed in the right, and the ability, of Africans to manage their own affairs. 
 Anderson was one of the few members of the British colonial administration who, remaining in Africa after British colonialism retreated, made a successful transition to serving the independent governments of the continent. 
 He worked closely, and made friends with, several leaders of English-speaking Africa and in more recent years had nurtured similar relationships in Angola and Mozambique. 
 Throughout his life he cultivated and maintained the confidence of his African colleagues, and his faithfulness and loyalty to the African cause were profound. 
 His love of Africa was paralleled by a deep and abiding loathing of racism, in general, and apartheid in particular. 
 Anderson spent most of his adult life in Africa. 
 He served in the Colonial Administrative Service of the Gold Coast from 1945 to 1957 and, from earliest days, was convinced of the urgent need to Africanise the civil service, in preparation for independence. 
 As Secretary to the Lidbury Commission on the Structure and Remuneration of the Ghana Civil Service (1950-51), and, as a member of the Working Party on Africanisation of the Civil Service (1952-53), Anderson helped lay the foundations for Ghana's civil service. 
 He subsequently worked closely with Ghana's first president, Kwame Nkrumah, on the country's Africanisation programme, becoming Establishment Secretary, and thus effectively in charge of the Civil Service from 1957 to 1961. 
 In the early 1960s Anderson moved to East Africa as Staff Development Advise to President Julius Nyerere of Tanzania (1961-64). 
 He was responsible for a major reform of Government administration, including a new public service act, which helped to facilitate the rapid localisation of the civil service. 
 He also put in place a long-term programme of staff development. 
 These reforms made a major contribution to the stability of independent Tanzania's administration. 
 From 1964 to 1967 he was adviser on the public service to President Jomo Kenyatta of Kenya. 
 In addition, he advised the newly independent Governments of Botswana, Zambia and Zimbabwe, and served on numerous commissions and enquiries across the continent, on public services matters. 
 As recently as last year, Anderson was asked by the Ugandan government to advise on the restructuring of the civil service there, following the turmoil of recent years. 
 The experience which Anderson gained while working directly for the newly independent governments of Africa made him uniquely well placed for his second career, in the field of development co-operation. 
 From 1967 to 1975 he was the Ford Foundation's representative in Nairobi, and was responsible for developing an innovative and highly influential programme to support the process of Africanisation. 
 He was an active supporter of national and regional institutes of public administration, and was a founding member of the African Association of Public Administration and Management (AAPAM), which links senior civil servants from many African countries. 
 In 1975 Anderson was appointed the first EEC delegate in Southern Africa, responsible for the EEC Commission's relations with Botswana, Lesotho and Swaziland. 
 In this capacity, he also established ties with the Government of Mozambique, and helped in the gradual process by which relations between Mozambique and the EEC were put on a more constructive basis. 
 Anderson's life in Africa ended in 1978, when he was appointed Managing Director of the Commonwealth Fund for Technical Co-operation (CFTC). 
 He applied his energies and experience to the Commonwealth countries and, with the support of the Commonwealth Secretary-General, Sonny Ramphal, had ample opportunity to continue his involvement in Southern Africa. 
 He was convinced of the need for, and the feasibility of, creating a regional economic grouping in Southern Africa. 
 He believed that the political commitment existed to ensure that the independent countries of the region would co-operate effectively to reduce their dependence on South Africa, and accelerate economic development; and that such a new grouping could influence decisively the way that offical development assistance was used in the region, and the course of development co-operation in general. 
 Anderson participated in the informal soundings on how best the idea might be given institutional and practical form. 
 His support for, and contribution to the process leading to the establishment of the Southern African Development Coordination Conference (SADCC), in 1980, was another manifestation of his commitment to the cause of African development. 
 He attended the early meetings of SADCC Ministers and Heads of State and Government, and continued to provide assistance to SADCC, until illness made this impossible. 
 David Anderson was a selfless public servant with an incisive analytical mind. 
 He gave, and demanded of others the highest standards of performance. 
 Although never a public figure, and always shunning the limelight, he was a man of great influence, an efficient administrator, a first-class draftsman and an eloquent communicator. 
 Obituary: Eric Ball 
 By ERIC WLISON 
 ERIC BALL will be remembered as perhaps the most significant contributor to the repertoire of the brass band. 
 In quantity as in quality his output may never find an equal. 
 Many of his original works, written as test-pieces for use in competitions, have become cornerstones of the repertoire; Resurgam (1950), Festival Music (1956) and Journey Into Freedom (1967) all find regular places on both the concert and contest stage. 
 As an arranger of other composers' music, Ball was a master craftsman who carried out his work with a respect for the original and an integrity rarely found today. 
 His greatest achievements in this field were undoubtedly the Enigma Variations of Elgar and four dances from Sir Arthur Bliss's ballet Checkmate, though even a short hymn setting was done to perfection. 
 As a musical architect, Ball excelled. 
 His sense of proportion and balance ensured that his music flowed no matter how the level of his inspiration varied. 
 As a developing pianist in his teens, he soaked himself in the music of Mozart, Beethoven and, most of all, Elgar, with whose musical language he found much affinity. 
 Given his deep-rooted Salvation Army connections, it came as no surprise when the 18-year-old Eric Ball found himself employed (not without some misgivings on his part) in their Music Editorial Department. 
 In 1926 he became a commissioned officer in the Salvation Army, a commission he resigned in 1944 when his interest in spiritual matters had developed beyond the bounds of Salvationism. 
 His contribution to the literature, both choral and instrumental, of the Salvation Army is vast. 
 Ball's estrangement from the Salvation Army was to be the secular brass band's gain. 
 Soon after the Second World War, in which he worked with ENSA (or &bquo;Every-Night-Something-Awful&equo;, as he called it), he came to work for the music publishing firm of R. Smith and Co Ltd and served as editor of British Bandsman (the brass band world's leading newspaper since 1887) for 15 years. 
 Here he invested the paper with some of the most wisely conceived editorial pieces in its long history and was a great Christian witness in the world of secular bands. 
 His success as a conductor of contesting bands was immediate, with victories at the National Brass Band Championships in 1946 (with Brighouse and Rastrick Band) and at the Belle Vue September Contest, Manchester, in 1948 and 1952, with the now-defunct Co-operative Workers Society (CWS) Manchester Band, being the highlights. 
 In time, he was welcomed back to the Salvation Army, who even arranged for a star bearing his name to be laid on Hollywood Boulevard alongside those of the great movie stars. 
 Dignified, modest, though not unaware of his charisma and influence, Eric was a serious man, yet with a twinkle in the eye and by no means narrow in his thinking. 
 Conscious that his gifts were God-given, he was a man of no material ambition. 
 His ideal was to attain to Christ, and to that goal he pressed forward. 
 Obituary: Ian McMillan 
 By A. M. JOHNSON 
 IAN McMILLAN entered medicine when his chosen speciality was developing rapidly, following wartime and post-war advances in anaesthesiology, diagnostic cardiology and other technologies. 
 A surgeon's son, he was educated at the Dragon School, Oxford, St Paul's School, London, Jesus College, Cambridge, and St Thomas's Hospital, where he qualified in 1946. 
 After junior appointments at St Thomas's and Great Ormond Street he entered the Royal Army Medical Corps for two years, during part of which time he investigated the dangers of hyperthermia in tank crews and how they might be overcome. 
 He then returned to St Thomas's and during nine years there and one in America, at the National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, Maryland, he saw cardiac and thoracic surgery from its beginnings and contributed notably to formulating its basic principles. 
 An apparatus that McMillan designed and built to show, with high-speed cinephotography, how normal and diseased heart valves move and the effects of surgery upon them, aided progress in valve surgery throughout the world. 
 His teaching film was a classic. 
 He helped too in the development of the cardiac defibrillator, without which cardiac surgery could not have progressed and which has saved countless lives. 
 With the Hammersmith team he took part in the evolution of the heart-lung machine and for some years the Melrose pump-oxygenator was the standard in Britain. 
 All this was continued and extended during his year in America. 
 McMillan gained surgical experience in these years and when, in 1959, he joined Paul Chin and Eric Machell, both pioneers themselves, at Southampton, they made steady progress in closed and open-heart surgery. 
 Experience grew with congenital heart disease too and the report (1959) of surgical correction of Fallot's tetralogy, a complex abnormality in very young children, was a landmark. 
 McMillan was an extremely hard worker but a certain fluidity in his perception of time made him sometimes an unpredictable colleague. 
 This quirk was, however, outweighed by his integrity and devotion to his patients. 
 McMillan travelled widely with Pete's Club, an international surgical club of which he was a founder member. 
 He established a Visiting Fellowship for surgeons in training at the Massachusetts General Hospital to come to the Southampton unit, with mutual benefit. 
 Following Chin's accidental death in 1960, it was not until 1972 that he was able to reduce and finally to leave cardiac work; and from then until his retirement in June 1987 he devoted himself to chest surgery at Southampton, Basingstoke and King Edward VII Hospital, Midhurst. 
 Obituary: Horace Alexander 
 By A. M. JOHNSON 
 Horace Alexander, lecturer, died Crossland Pennsylvania 7 October aged 100. 
 In 1928 he took leave of absence from a lectureship at a Quaker college in Birmingham to go to India. 
 There he met Mohandas K. Gandhi, and spent much of the next 20 years acting as a conciliatory intermediary between Gandhi's Congress Party and the British Government, latterly as a member of Gandhi's entourage. 
 Gandhi described him as &bquo;British in nationality but Indian in heart.&equo; 
 Bar examination results 
 By A. M. JOHNSON 
 The following have been awarded a Conditional Pass. 
 The section they have yet to pass is shown in brackets against their name. 
 The Council of Legal Education Trinity Bar Examination 1989 Additional Pass List The following candidate has been awarded a III been awarded a III Class Pass in the Bar Examination 6017 Andrews, JR (I) The Council of Legal Education Michaelmas Bar Examination 1989 Overseas Pass List The following candidates have passed an Individual Section to complete the Bar Examination. 
 Law Report: Divorce award recognised wife's contribution to wealth of family: Gojkovic v Gojkovic &mdash; Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Woolf, Lord Justice Russell and Lord Justice Butler-Sloss), 12 October 1989 
 By PAUL MAGRATH, Barrister 
 In assessing the financial relief to be awarded to the former wife of a millionaire after their divorce, pursuant to section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973 (as amended by section 3 of the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act 1984), the court should not calculate the wife's share solely by reference to her needs, but could take account also of any exceptional contribution she had made to the creation of the husband's wealth. 
 The Court of Appeal dismissed the husband's appeal from Mr Justice Ward who, on 17 February 1989, had ordered him to provide his former wife with a maisonette worth &pound;295,000 and a lump sum of &pound;1m. 
 Nicholas Wall QC and Judith Hughes (Hamlin Slowe) for the husband; Bruce Blair QC (Michael Freeman &amp; Co) for the wife. 
 LORD JUSTICE BUTLER-SLOSS said that the husband, who was a Yugoslav, arrived in England in 1966 at the age of 23 with a small sum of money in his pocket. 
 He worked his way up from kitchen porter, assistant cook, employment at a casino and by painting and decorating. 
 The wife also came from Yugoslavia to England in 1966 and took menial jobs in a hospital and as a waitress. 
 They met in 1968 and began to cohabit in 1969, although they did not marry until 1978. 
 The judge described their life together as a story of high achievement and glorious success, which had come through unrelenting hard work, unlimited self-sacrifice and absolute determination. 
 They started by working on a property while they were carrying on other employment, and then turning that property into hotel accommodation. 
 It was agreed that the wife was the chatelaine par excellence. 
 The husband's brothers became involved in enterprises with him, and their business expanded into other hotels and properties. 
 Other members of the family became involved in these businesses. 
 The wife spent her time running one of the hotels, while the husband and his brothers devoted their skills to property speculation with considerable success. 
 By the time of the divorce in 1986, the assets of the family were considerable. 
 The husband's share was &pound;4m but the wife's legal interest was very small. 
 The judge found the wife's contribution to be &bquo;exceptional by ordinary standards, if not exceptional as measured against the (husband's) contribution. 
 In terms of doing what is expected of them I find they performed equally.&equo; 
 The wife had played a unique role in the hotel business and had, the judge concluded, &bquo;earned a share of the assets that have been produced&equo;. 
 Following the divorce, the wife now desired to buy and run a small hotel. 
 For this she required the &pound;1m which was awarded her. 
 The husband agreed that the wife should have the maisonette, but appealed against the judge's award of a lump sum of &pound;1m on the grounds (1) that the judge was wrong in principle to make an award to enable the wife to buy a hotel; and (2) that in any case the amount was excessive. 
 It was argued for the husband that the wife should have been awarded a lump sum of &pound;532,000, calculated in accordance with the principles established in Preston v Prestion (1982) Fam 17 and Duxbury v Duxbury (1987) FLR 7, to provide sufficient income to satisfy the reasonable requirements of the former wife of a millionaire. 
 In both Preston and Duxbury, the Court of Appeal upheld the award of a lump sum, designed to provide the wife with a net income after tax of &pound;20,000 and &pound;28,000 respectively, without onsidering in any detail the level of income appropriate in such cases. 
 Moreover, her Ladyship did not read those cases as laying down an income bracket suitable for the needs of every former wife of a millionaire. 
 Although section 25, as re-enacted, no longer required the court to attempt to place the parties in the financial position they would have been in had the marriage not broken down, it did not, in her Ladyship's judgment, circumscribe the court's discretion so as to limit it to providing for the wife to become self-sufficient. 
 The new section 25A laid a responsibility upon the court to consider whether financial obligations should be terminated and to make orders designed to enable the spouse to adjust without due hardship to the termination of financial dependence on the other spouse. 
 A Duxbury calculation could not by itself provide the answer as to the sum to which the wife was entitled, though it produced a figure to which the judge was entitled to have regard in deciding what was the right answer. 
 Here, the judge found that the wife had made an exceptional contribution to the wealth generated during their relationship. 
 Her share was not to be calculated exclusively in relation to her needs. 
 If the wife's contribution was adequately taken into account by the figure offered by the husband, her desire, however strong, to have a greatly increased lump sum to enable her to run a hotel would not be reasonable. 
 But weight had to be given to the fact that this was a working wife with a recognised expertise in the managing of hotels. 
 A wife who was entitled to a lump sum on the &bquo;clean break&equo; principle was not obliged to deal with it in any particular fashion. 
 She was perfectly entitled to use it as working capital if that was the sum of money to which, taking into account her contribution and all other aspects of section 25, she was entitled. 
 But however great the wife's contribution, the order to her should not be out of proportion to the total assets and had to do justice between the parties. 
 The judge considered this aspect very carefully. 
 There was no suggestion that this order would be impossible for the husband to comply with or would cripple his business. 
 On joint assets of &pound;4m he would retain &pound;2.7m or so. 
 The award was not excessively generous. 
 The appeal should be dismissed. 
 Britain to hold first talks with Savimbi 
 By JOHN BULLOCH 
 IN A CHANGE of policy designed to help bring about a ceasefire in Angola, John Major, the Foreign Secretary, will today hold talks with Jonas Savimbi, the leader of the Unita rebels, writes John Bulloch. 
 Mr Savimbi is at the Conservative Party conference in Blackpool to address the Bow Group. 
 It will be the first time that the Unita leader has met a British minister, and only a few days ago the Angolan ambassador in London was assured by a Foreign Office official that there were no plans for such a meeting. 
 The Foreign Office view is that as the Angolan government has been in direct contact with Unita, there is no reason why other countries should not use their influence. 
 Mr Savimbi is to hold talks with President Mobutu of Zaire in France next week, and it is hoped that the meeting may result in a new ceasefire. 
 One of the difficulties is that the Angolan understanding of the agreement reached in June was that Mr Savimbi should not remain in Angola while elections are held, though he might return later. 
 Unita says that was not a condition. 
 The fact that the Foreign Secretary has decided to intervene would indicate that the US is prepared to take a strong line, and to use its influence to force Unita to accept the Angolan reading of the agreement. 
 Robert Hughes, the Labour MP and chairman of the Anti-Apartheid Movement, criticised the decision to see Mr Savimbi. 
 He said Unita was still blocking moves toward peace in Angola. 
 Viewpoint: Capitalising on high standards in egg industry: A group of nuns begin legal action today to prevent the slaughter of their chickens. 
 John Coles, chairman of the British Egg Industry Council, gives his views on the challenges facing the industry in the 1990s 
 By JOHN COLES 
 THE TIME has come for the egg industry to look forward to the 1990s. 
 After a disastrous year for British producers, they are now faced with a unique opportunity to capitalise on the benefits of an industry with the highest standards in the world. 
 The British Egg Industry Council (BEIC) fully supports the extensive legislation introduced this year to minimise the risk of salmonella and to re-establish consumer confidence in British eggs. 
 Every link in the egg production chain is now covered by stringent controls. 
 Nineteen different measures incorporate strict controls on feed suppliers, breeding and laying flocks. 
 All breeding and laying flocks have to be registered and are required to undertake extensive testing for salmonella at every stage of the hens' lives. 
 If salmonella is confirmed a flock has to be slaughtered and the laying house cleansed and disinfected. 
 Eggs laid by flocks in which salmonella is found cannot be sold for human consumption. 
 While supporting the principle of legislative measures to reduce the risk of salmonella, the BEIC has been actively lobbying the Government to ensure the British producers are not faced with an impossible burden. 
 We argued for &mdash; and won &mdash; amendments to testing procedures to reduce producers' costs without reducing the effectiveness of the measures. 
 We are continuing to lobby for full compensation for the commercial value of hens slaughtered and for equivalent testing legislation to be introduced throughout the European Community. 
 The measures introduced in the UK mean that, in the words John Gummer, the Minister for Agriculture: &bquo;The consumer can be confident that British eggs are protected by the most stringent safety regulations in the world. 
 We can eat British produced eggs with confidence.&equo; 
 The challenge now for the egg industry is to communicate this message to consumers; to look forward to the 1990s with confidence in the knowledge that its product is the best in the world &mdash; not to waste time and money on the constant examination of its collective navel and on cries of &bquo;not fair&equo;. 
 Assuming the Daventry nuns have been subject only to the same controls being applied to all other British egg producers, the protest by the United Kingdom Egg Producers' Association (Ukepra), the only organisation within the UK egg industry not represented among BEIC members, is potentially damaging both to egg consumers and to egg producers. 
 By entering &bquo;the race&hellip; to show that the Government is wrong&equo; Ukepra is clutching at straws and defying the accepted principle that marketing any product is all about listening to the demands of the consumer and satisfying those demands. 
 No matter how small the problem of salmonella within the British egg industry &mdash; and the BEIC has always maintained that any problem was minute and much smaller than last year's hysteria implied &mdash; the consumer has demanded that the problem be reduced to the absolute minimum possible. 
 The sort of cheap publicity gained by Ukepra over the past week will simply reinforce consumer concern about the integrity of the egg industry and the safety of its product. 
 Egg producers must recognise that they are competing in the sophisticated food industry of the late 1980s and that they have a responsibility to the consumer. 
 If the industry is not prepared to meet consumer demand, egg sales and hence egg producers will continue to suffer and the industry will remain in the Dark Ages. 
 Labour chief whip facing poll defeat 
 By COLIN HUGHES, Political Correspondent 
 LABOUR MPs are predicting extensive changes to the Shadow Cabinet over the next month, with the increasing prospect that the party's chief whip will be defeated in an election contest next week. 
 Derek Foster, who has held the Commons chief whip post for four years, is being challenged by Ron Davies, the MP for Caerphilly. 
 The best prediction of the vote &mdash; to be counted next Thursday at the first parliamentary Labour party meeting after the summer break &mdash; is that Mr Davies will just beat Mr Foster by a handful of votes. 
 Last year Mr Foster won 107 votes to Mr Davies's 65, with Jeff Rooker, MP for Perry Barr, polling 41. 
 This year Mr Rooker stayed out of the race, and has nominated Mr Davies who is expected to pick up most of his votes. 
 Mr Davies's canvassing over the party conference period has found 70 MPs solidly backing Mr Foster &mdash; including most of the hard-left Campaign Group. 
 But the rest of Mr Foster's vote looks soft, with many of the 1987 intake of Labour MPs switching their support to Mr Davies in protest at what they see as Mr Foster's lax disciplinary regime over the parliamentary party. 
 In his letter to Labour MPs, Mr Foster has asked for backing on the grounds that he has seen the parliamentary party through the dark years, and now wants to guide them through better times. 
 Mr Davies, by contrast, has pledged specific reforms to regulate Labour MPs' time more strictly, while helping them plan their time outside Parliament more confidently. 
 It is also seen as significant in the Davies camp that Neil Kinnock, the party leader, is remaining neutral in the contest. 
 After the election for the chief whip, Labour MPs will vote for the restyled Shadow Cabinet, the elections for which are being weighted to ensure a minimum representation of three women. 
 The Tribune group has sent out a list of candidates who are bidding to join its slate for the 18 Shadow Cabinet places. 
 Analysis suggests that all five Tribune women will make the slate. 
 One woman outside the Tribune group &mdash; Ann Taylor, an environment spokesperson &mdash; is likely to top the poll among the women. 
 But at least three, and maybe four of the women on the Tribune slate are also likely to be elected, taking the total of women on the Shadow Cabinet to four or five, compared with only one at present. 
 The Tribune women who are regarded as certain winners are Joan Lestor, who speaks on overseas aid, Jo Richardson, who speaks on women's issues, and Margaret Beckett, who speaks on social security. 
 The other two Tribunites are Clare Short &mdash; who won a strong vote last year &mdash; and Harriet Harman, health spokesperson, who is standing for the Shadow Cabinet for the first time. 
 The extent of unpredictable change makes it very hard for Mr Kinnock to plan his Shadow Cabinet reshuffle in advance of the election results. 
 Museum opens food safety &bquo;hotline&equo; 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 A TELEPHONE hotline on food safety, nutrition and diet will be opened today by the National Museum of Science and Industry. 
 The scheme &mdash; intended to let the public draw directly on scientific knowledge &mdash; has been partly prompted by recent panic over the contamination of food by listeria and salmonella, public concern about how to store and cook food, and issues such as food preservation through irradiation. 
 If the service, which is free apart from the cost of the phone call, proves successful, it may be supplemented by others dealing with information on areas of concern such as the environment. 
 The man behind the scheme is John Durant, Professor of Public Understanding of Science at Imperial College, London, and an assistant director of the museum. 
 He regards it as a way forward for the museum and a means of providing a window for many more people on Britain's scientific and technological expertise. 
 It will run initially for three months but may become permanent if it seems to fulfil a need. 
 &bquo;There is a great public demand for information on food and nutrition &mdash; and we are not here to sell a particular line,&equo; he said. 
 Although staff will be fully trained, they will be able to seek specialist advice to answer more complicated inquiries. 
 As areas of concern emerge, information packs will be made up and sent out, again free of charge. 
 &bquo;This is a way forward for the museum to offer a wider range of access points into the nation's science and technology,&equo; Professor Durant said. 
 The hotline scheme coincides with a new &pound;1.2m exhibition gallery at the museum, &bquo;Food for Thought&equo; which is intended to entertain and to instruct visitors about the past present and future of food, food industries, eating out, and food fashion &mdash; ranging from Lyons corner houses and Palm Court tea rooms in the 1920s and 1930s to the coffee bars of the Fifties and McDonalds fast-food outlets of the 1980s. 
 It will aim to explain the limits of scientific knowledge in any given area, and will be updated as issues change and facts emerge. 
 Jane Bywaters, who has been responsible for much of the exhibition, said: &bquo;We need to give people information so that they can make up their own minds about food and not be dictated to by the media and media events.&equo; 
 The gallery has its lighter side to arouse the interests of children &mdash; the &bquo;smellerama&equo; to test their sense of smell and relate it to certain types of food, the &bquo;food pyramid&equo; to test their ability to build a healthy diet, and an &bquo;aerobicycle&equo; which will demonstrate the amount of exertion required to burn off a given number of calories. 
 The telephone service, on (01) 938 8217, is open from 10am to 4pm, Monday to Friday, but closed on bank holidays. 
 The Conservative Conference: Sacrificial writers at work behind the scenes 
 By COLIN BROWN, Politcal Corrrespondent 
 &bquo;GREATER LOVE hath no man than that he lays down his jokes for his Prime Minister,&equo; a Cabinet minister said in Blackpool on hearing of the sacrifice made by Chris Patten, the Secretary of State for the Environment. 
 Mr Patten, a former Tory research officer and the brains in the Thatcher team, has been involved in the great behind-the-scenes task of the week at the Imperial Hotel, Blackpool. 
 Along with with Robin Harris, past director of Conservative research department, who is joining the Downing Street policy unit, John O'Sullivan, editor of the US National Review and Sir Ronald Millar, playwright, Mr Patten has been helping to write the Prime Minister's speech for today's keynote address. 
 But this year, Mr Patten had to make his own speech to the conference for the first time. 
 Shortly before he was due to deliver that speech on Wednesday &mdash; a Burkeian lecture on economic growth and greenery &mdash; he realised that he had put some of his best lines in the draft for the Prime Minister's speech. 
 He did the decent thing, and dropped them from his speech. 
 Insiders say he has transplanted a large tract of greenery into the leaderene's speech, which will dwell on her commitment to saving the world from global warming. 
 The speech-writing team, locked away in a suite at the Imperial Hotel, are said to have made faster progress this year than at previous conferences, despite the need to do some hefty redrafting to echo the Chancellor's assurances on the economy. 
 Mr Patten played Cinderella last night and cancelled a private engagement to carry on the polishing while Margaret went to the Blue Ball. 
 But the great behind-the-scenes event of the Blackpool conference has been the secret series of meetings between Norman Lamont, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, and spending ministers to whittle down their bids for spending next year. 
 Ministers are sworn to secrecy about the talks &mdash; known by aficionados as Pesc (public expenditure scrutiny committee) &mdash; but Kenneth Clarke, the Secretary of State for Health, broke ranks by mentioning them in his conference speech. 
 Mr Clarke unknowingly stole the thunder of Douglas Hurd, the Home Secretary, who had been intending to make a veiled public appeal for more cash for the police services in the law and order debate. 
 In the end, Mr Hurd had to make a joking reference to Mr Clarke's audacity. 
 Although Mr Lamont has been staying in the Imperial Hotel with the rest of the Cabinet, he has held most of the talks in more down-market hotels along the Promenade. 
 He has used a fast government car to shake off at least one photographer, but there is a more prosaic explanation for Mr Lamont's perambulations around Blackpool &mdash; his civil servants could not get through the security around the Imperial. 
 As the civil servants are not party members, they have not been issued with security passes. 
 Mr Lamont was therefore forced to go outside the hotel to meet them. 
 One Cabinet minister, however, is likely to have saved some money on his hotel bill to go towards his bid for next year. 
 John Gummer, the Minister of Agriculture, has been staying not at the Imperial, but at a modest B-&amp;-B at the back of the conference hall. 
 Mr Gummer has used the guest house for every Tory conference since his student days and he told friends that he has been rewarded for his continued custom with the best room in the house. 
 It is next to the showers. 
 Margaret Thatcher will address the final session of the conference. 
 There will be debates on drug abuse and on party publicity. 
 The Conservative Conference: Chancellor stands by interest rate strategy 
 By JUDY JONES 
 NIGEL LAWSON yesterday made clear his determination to keep interest rates as high as necessary to defeat inflation and provide a sound basis for continued economic prosperity. 
 The Chancellor of the Exchequer was given a two-minute standing ovation after he delivered an uncompromising defence of his policies and declared: &bquo;It is clear that the economy is already responding to the measures we have taken, and I have no doubt whatever that it will come right in good time. 
 There is no alternative and the policy will work.&equo; 
 Mr Lawson told the conference that the damage inflicted by high inflation would be far worse than that sustained by home owners and businesses through high interest rates. 
 Labour demands for the Government to impose credit controls instead of high interest rates to curb borrowing were &bquo;a cruel deception&equo; because they were unworkable. 
 &bquo;They would be child's play in the modern world to get around. 
 Nor is there any salvation in the rake's progress of perpetual devaluation. 
 All it does is to raise the price of things we buy from abroad. 
 And that means inflation. 
 &bquo;In the world in which we live there are bound to be periods of turbulence on the foreign exchange markets from time to time. 
 We have been through them before. 
 But the Conservative Party never has been, and never will be, the party of devaluation. 
 &bquo;The plain truth is there are no easy answers. 
 But I give you this pledge. 
 I will continue to take whatever action is needed, however unpopular it may be, to keep our economy sound and strong.&equo; 
 The Chancellor said the British people had responded to privatisation, trade union reform, deregulation and tax reform with a dynamism that had surprised the world. 
 &bquo;There is no precedent in living memory for the eight years of sustained growth and surging prosperity that Britain has enjoyed with this Conservative government. 
 It has been a rebirth &mdash; and all the more vigorous for being so long overdue. 
 &bquo;That vigour has been reinforced by something else: confidence, a belief in Britain's future.&equo; 
 The Government's most pressing task now was to see that inflation was brought down still further. 
 To achieve this, there would have to be a period during which growth slowed down, and with it the growth of imports. 
 &bquo;But there is no need whatever for this to mean recession, providing business and industry keep a firm control of their costs, including wage costs in particular. 
 &bquo;So when will interest rates come down again? 
 Just as soon as it is safe to do so but not before. 
 For we will take no risks with inflation. 
 There are too many forces we do not control &mdash; nor indeed seek to control. 
 A free country in a free world is always at risk from high winds and rough seas. 
 Calm waters only belong to stagnant pools, and there is nothing stagnant about the new Conservative Britain.&equo; 
 The rulers of Eastern Europe had been forced to recognise the failure of their system and that &bquo;socialism is economic poison&equo;. 
 &bquo;What will sustain the reformers of Eastern Europe is that great yearning for freedom that has started them off. 
 And it is significant that for many of them, the beacon of light is Britain &mdash; yes, Margaret Thatcher's Britain. 
 We showed that at least the British version of socialism could be reversed and that a nation could win back its prosperity and its pride.&equo; 
 The Chancellor won substantial backing from speakers in the economic debate. 
 However, Jacky Davis, who runs a business with her husband in North West Hampshire, sounded a dissenting note. 
 &bquo;My husband and I have just taken out a massive loan to finance the purchase of offices and manufacturing equipment. 
 With the latest rise in interest rates and speculation that more may be to come, that loan is becoming a millstone. 
 We must make savings to finance the extra cost of borrowing. 
 &bquo;We are happy to do this but it is a struggle to meet our debt. 
 I really cannot see how high interest rates which penalise investment&hellip; help in the fight against inflation.&equo; 
 She urged a two-tier system of interest rates, aimed specifically at curbing consumer borrowing. 
 Andrew Oxley, of Langbaurgh, said high inflation hit the less well off hardest. 
 Refering to the Archbishop of Canterbury's recent attack on &bquo;Pharisee&equo; values prevalent in Britain, he said: &bquo;It is hardly a Pharisee society which puts the interests of these groups at the top of its priorities. 
 If the effective choice is between higher mortgages and unemployment, which would you choose?&equo; 
 Andrew Crisp, from Winchester, said it was nonsense to suggest that the Government had abandoned the entrepreneur by raising the cost of borrowing. 
 &bquo;The rise in interest rates provides clear leadership, a challenge to be faced and overcome. 
 In my business, either I cut my costs or I find new business. 
 When interest rates start to fall again, then my business is stronger, with a greater competitive edge.&equo; 
 Peter Bassett, from Chelsea, said that the present economic difficulties bore no relation to that which pertained under the last Labour government when the country had to be bailed out by the International Monetary Fund. 
 &bquo;Now is the autumn of our discontent. 
 But life under Labour would be like a nuclear winter.&equo; 
 John Horam, of Fulham, a former Labour minister, believed the Chancellor was pursuing the right policies.&equo; 
 High interest rates are clearly necessary to clamp down demand and bring the money supply under control. 
 The CBI says the extra 1 per cent will drive us into recession. 
 Frankly that is drivel. 
 The basic health of the British economy is far better than ever it was.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Faithful display common purpose 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 THE TORY faithful crowded into the Empress Ballroom, the spear-carriers on the set of Nigel Lawson's epic production. 
 But they knew their role well and they delivered. 
 Only when the inevitable standing ovation was over, and their work was done in the conference hall, could they relax. 
 And here and there, a small private groan at the harshness of the Chancellor's economic message could be heard clearly. 
 &bquo;It is all right for us, it is the younger generation I feel sorry for,&equo; a Devonshire councillor told her companion. 
 &bquo;Mary didn't know whether she was going to stand up. 
 Her son has a small business, and he doesn't know if he will be able to carry on.&equo; 
 In another knot of constituency representatives, someone observed: &bquo;Mrs Thatcher did not clap him very hard, did she?&equo; 
 However, the debate and the reception accorded to Mr Lawson's speech was a striking demonstration of the Conservatives' capacity to close ranks: proof, if proof were needed, of their party's most formidable political resource. 
 As one Cabinet minister remarked, on the eve of yesterday's crucial debate: &bquo;This party is interested in power, above all else. 
 It knows how to behave.&equo; 
 The ornate hall, its balconies and aisles were crowded to overflowing. 
 As they rose to cheer the Chancellor, marching onto the platform with Margaret Thatcher again ostentatiously at his side, their common purpose was clear. 
 Speaker after speaker endorsed the anti-inflationary weapon of high interest rates. 
 Andrew Crisp from Winchester was applauded loudly for describing the rise in base rates as a sign of &bquo;clear leadership&equo;; and each reference to the central plank of Mr Lawson's strategy was a signal for a demonstration of approval. 
 It seemed to be genuine. 
 The speaker who complained at the burden on small businesses was clapped by just a handful. 
 For lengthy passages of the Chancellor's speech, while Mr Lawson addressed his wider audience in the City and the country at large, their on-cue responses seemed more mechanical than enthusiastic. 
 The acclaim was loudest, and most heartfelt, when Mr Lawson derided the inability of the Opposition to offer a convincing alternative formula. 
 Outside, Tory representatives were ambushed by camera crews and reporters, and nearly all strove to re-echo Mr Lawson's message in fulsome terms. 
 &bquo;It was brilliant and encouraging,&equo; Carol Jamieson, a trainee party agent from Leeds, said. 
 &bquo;He explained the whole situation well. 
 The Opposition has nothing to offer.&equo; 
 Tom Gower from Southport, though, seemed to have been as anxious for reassurance as he was to express solidarity. 
 &bquo;This party needed explanations,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;He gave them this morning. 
 We will be absolutely loyal to any minister as long as that minister explains the situation to us.&equo; 
 Backbench Tory MPs added their weight to the straining chorus of approval. 
 Privately, MPs with divided views on Mr Lawson's chosen course agreed that the Government was effectively boxed-in to its position, and now had to tough it out. 
 &bquo;Lawson's speech was quite good,&equo; one said. 
 &bquo;He said nothing, but what could he say? 
 We are tied to him anyway. 
 Either he gets it right or we all go up the Swanee.&equo; 
 Another said: &bquo;He is the best man we have got by far. 
 The sooner the Prime Minister and her horde of Americans get off his back the better.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Brittan urges entry to ERM 
 By COLIN HUGHES, Political Correspondent 
 BRITAIN should enter the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System as soon as the present turbulence in the foreign exchange markets has died away, Sir Leon Brittan, the European Commissioner, told a Bow Group fringe meeting last night. 
 Sir Leon added that the Government should also adopt a more active policy of support for progress towards European monetary union, with a central banking system, while resisting other forms of unnecessary economic union. 
 Similarly, he argued, Britain should seek to create a Social Charter of its own liking, rather than merely oppose the adoption of any social charter at all. 
 He advocated an approach of saying, &bquo;Yes, but&equo;, rather than &bquo;No, perhaps,&equo; in relation to the European Community. 
 For example, on the controversy over the removal of frontier controls, Britain's Commissioner proposed that controls should be replaced with police and Customs officer powers to check any traveller on suspicion of drugs or terrorist offences. 
 The Government has been resisting the removal of frontier controls because of anxieties about drugs and illicit arms traffickers. 
 On the EMS, Sir Leon said that the Government's primary criterion for entry -that of falling inflation &mdash; had already been met. 
 He strongly applauded the decision by Nigel Lawson, the Chancellor, to raise interest rates last week, and argued that a sharper rise of two percentage points might have been more immediately effective. 
 But he did not believe that Britain should wait until next summer's removal of capital and exchange controls throughout the Community before entering the exchange rate mechanism. 
 &bquo;I think we should join well before next summer, but I do not think&hellip; that the time to join is this week,&equo; Sir Leon said. 
 &bquo;You don't join the EMS at a time of turbulence in the foreign exchange markets. 
 You join something like that when there is a measure of stability.&equo; 
 Entry should not be a reaction to short-term problems, but a considered response to long-term needs. 
 &bquo;We should join after the turbulence in the foreign exchange markets has died down,&equo; Sir Leon said. 
 He believed that membership of the exchange rate mechanism would give greater certainty to business and industry, help the battle against inflation, and secure lower rates of interest. 
 The Conservative Conference: Food safety directorate to be set up 
 By JUDY JONES 
 A FOOD safety directorate is to be set up in the Ministry of Agriculture to co-ordinate research and monitoring and improve public awareness of food issues, Judy Jones writes. 
 John Gummer, Minister of Agriculture, told the conference it would bring together existing strands of work and report directly to David Maclean, the junior minister responsible for food. 
 &bquo;I shall also be reviewing the way we get independent advice, so that the public will be able to see absolutely clearly that I act on the best possible evidence, without fear or favour.&equo; 
 The formation of the directorate will be seen by critics of the Government's food policy as a tacit admission that its response to recent food scares has been muddled and sometimes too slow. 
 Mr Gummer rejected appeals from consumer groups and Opposition parties for a separate Ministry for Food that would act independently of farming interests. 
 &bquo;The farmer has just as great an interest in safe food as the customer. 
 If his customers are not fully satisfied, he won't sell his products.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Sunday trade reform issue put on ice 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 REFORM OF the law on Sunday trading was put on ice for at least another year yesterday despite a clear demand for liberalisation by rank-and-file Tories, writes Stephen Goodwin. 
 Timothy Renton, Minister of State at the Home Office, told the conference the Government would not push to legislate while neither shops nor shoppers could agree on a solution, pressure groups could not agree, and Parliament could find no consensus. 
 Mr Renton said he hoped, maybe by the next conference, to have found agreement. 
 But his emphasis on the opposition to options considered by the Home Office suggests there will be no Bill before a general election. 
 On a show of hands, representatives rejected a motion against any legislation incompatible with &bquo;the traditional character of Sunday&equo;. 
 Moving it, Joyce Simpson, Ilford South, said Sunday should be used &bquo;to rest from the stress of our galloping society&equo;. 
 But Jacqui Burns, Newham NW, said people would not be forced to shop on Sunday. 
 &bquo;If the shopkeeper wants to sell and I want buy, what business is it of anyone else?&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: King attacks Labour on defence 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 LABOUR'S new arms policy was condemned by Tom King yesterday as &bquo;an appalling shambles&equo; which would cripple Britain's conventional forces, scrub nuclear weapons and leave the country well and truly defenceless. 
 The Secretary of State for Defence roused his audience with a fierce attack on Labour over its Brighton conference decisions on defence and the appearance at a fringe meeting there of Gerry Adams, the Sinn Fein leader. 
 The country should recognise what some members of &bquo;the new model Labour party&equo; were like, Mr King said. 
 &bquo;They are the ones who invited Mr Adams to address them just 500 yards from the Grand Hotel which some of us have cause to remember; to address them less than two weeks after the time when, along the coast at Deal, 10 young musicians in the Royal Marines were foully murdered. 
 &bquo;He described that murder of unarmed musicians, at that meeting, as a &bquo;legitimate tactic&equo;, and what did those Labour Party members do? 
 They gave him a standing ovation.&equo; 
 To shouts of &bquo;shame&equo;, the Secretary of State went on: &bquo;Protest all you want Mr Kinnock, wave as many red roses as you want, those were members of your party that did that, and the country must never forget it.&equo; 
 He ridiculed the Labour conference endorsement of the policy review shift from unilateral nuclear disarmament as a fudge that failed. 
 It had been followed by a motion from Bruce Kent, chair of CND, to reduce Britain's defence spending to the European average of Nato countries. 
 That would mean a cut of &pound;5bn, Mr King said &mdash; roughly the same as the annual cost of the Royal Navy. 
 The Army and Royal Air Force each cost &pound;6bn. 
 &bquo;What shall they do? 
 You can do it by scrubbing the Navy. 
 Or share out the misery? 
 Halve our ships, ground the fighters that defend this country and disband half the regiments of the British Army as well.&equo; 
 The final twist was that Mr Kinnock was committed to negotiating away nuclear weapons at the earliest opportunity, Mr King added. 
 Likening Tony Benn to the Erich Honeker of the Labour Party, he said the left-wing MP got it right when, after the multilateralist vote, he commented: &bquo;Who will believe us on this? 
 Who will ever believe us on anything?&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Parkinson raises new doubts on BR sell-off 
 By COLIN BROWN and JUDY JONES 
 RENEWED doubts about the possibility of privatising British Rail were raised yesterday by Cecil Parkinson, Secretary of State for Transport. 
 After speaking at the conference, Mr Parkinson told journalists: &bquo;It (BR privatisation) has never been at the top of my agenda. 
 It was never going to happen before the next Parliament, if ever.&equo; 
 His remarks will disappoint many right-wing Tories who have been pushing hard for the Government to give a firm commitment to privatisation. 
 Studies on the options are still going on, and the Government's decision to increase BR's profit targets had been seen as part of the &bquo;fattening-up&equo; process. 
 Mr Parkinson also appeared to distance himself from the BR route for the Channel tunnel link through Kent, saying that it was &bquo;for Parliament to settle the way forward&equo;. 
 In the transport debate Mr Parkinson said more investment in Britain's railways would not solve the problem of congestion on the roads. 
 And he rejected the demands of environmentalists and opposition parties for measures to discourage car use in favour of public transport. 
 &bquo;People must be free to make choices not bludgeoned, bullied or bribed,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Parkinson told representatives: &bquo;Railways cannot deliver goods to Britain's high street shops. 
 They can't take children to the school door. 
 They cannot take people to the outpatients&equo; clinic&hellip; 
 Roads will continue to meet most of the needs of British people and businesses.&equo; 
 Mr Parkinson also announced approval for a new &pound;200m air traffic control centre to be built by the Civil Aviation Authority by the early 1990s. 
 &bquo;It will increase our handling capacity by 50 per cent. 
 People are fed up with airport delays.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Conference quotes 
 By COLIN BROWN and JUDY JONES 
 &bquo;The rise in interest rates provides clear leadership, a challenge to be faced and overcome.&equo; 
 &mdash; Andrew Crisp from Winchester, during economic policy debate &bquo;Any party that has Dennis Skinner as its chairman and Neil Kinnock as leader, badly needs a hero.&equo; 
 &mdash; Cecil Parkinson, Secretary of State for Transport &bquo;The Prime Minister was worried about my appointment. 
 She thought I might be too old. 
 Too staid. 
 Too well-known.&equo; 
 &mdash; John Major, Foreign Secretary &bquo;What will sustain the reformers of Eastern Europe is that great yearning for freedom that has started them off. 
 And it is significant that for many of them the beacon light is Britain &mdash; yes, Margaret Thatcher's Britain.&equo; 
 - Nigel Lawson, Chancellor of the Exchequer &bquo;Politicians are poor prophets, but the unlucky creatures have to try, because we are elected to look at least some distance ahead.&equo; 
 &mdash; Douglas Hurd, Home Secretary 
 The Conservative Conference: Major announces 25m pounds aid package for Hungary 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 JOHN MAJOR, the Foreign Secretary, yesterday announced the setting up of a &pound;25m aid fund for Hungary as he set before the conference what he called a &bquo;common sense&equo; approach for Conservatives in Europe. 
 With some Tory representatives still smarting over their humiliation in the European Parliament elections, Mr Major said it would be a terrible mistake for Conservatives to become defensive or defeatist about their role in the Community. 
 &bquo;It is our show. 
 The Community is carrying out our programme,&equo; he said. 
 Handing the credit to Margaret Thatcher, he said Britain had put the single market at the top of the EC agenda and put the torch to &bquo;a veritable bonfire of petty obstacles and niggling controls&equo;. 
 In restrained terms, Mr Major echoed the Prime Minister's distaste for the Commission's &bquo;grandiose&equo; social charter, a European central bank and a common currency. 
 &bquo;We can't accept those ideas, but there are other ideas to discuss and we will put them forward,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We Conservatives are realists. 
 We know that the best way to achieve our objective is for countries to work with their national traditions &mdash; not against them. 
 We want companies and workforces to come to their own arrangements. 
 &bquo;Above all, we want decisions to be taken by those who have to live with them.&equo; 
 Mr Major ranged beyond the EC and spoke of a feeling in the air of a better Europe to be built. 
 &bquo;A Europe more secure, more prosperous, more free. 
 &bquo;All Europe stands on a threshold &mdash; and we Europeans now have to make a choice. 
 We can turn our backs on the divisions of the past, and tear down the barriers that divide us. 
 Or we can cling to the old certainties &mdash; and go on as before.&equo; 
 The fund for Hungary mirrors that set up by Britain for Poland. 
 Worth &pound;25m over five years it is intended to help run elections, launch newspapers, form political parties and build businesses. 
 The hour-long debate on Europe brought criticism of the party's election campaign and of Edward Heath, the former prime minister. 
 Harriet Crawley, London Central Euro constituency, said the campaign had been negative and the advertising &bquo;dismal and downhearted&equo;. 
 &bquo;That gloom and doom cut no ice with Conservative voters. 
 They stayed away,&equo; she told representatives. 
 The party lost 13 seats in the European Parliament. 
 James Clappison, Yorkshire South, said Mr Heath's intervention in the campaign had not been a conspicuous success. 
 To loud applause, he said the message to Mr Heath from the grass-roots should be: &bquo;We all respect your vision and your achievements, but please remember that the overwhelming majority of Conservatives totally reject the idea of European union and a federal Europe.&equo; 
 Sally Illman, a student at Oxford University, had a message for Jacques Delors, President of the European Commission: &bquo;Hands off free-enterprise Britain'. 
 She said the British people wanted the opportunities of the single market, but they would not accept &bquo;nanny state meddling&equo;. 
 Riot police hit by back problems 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 RIOT policemen are suffering from bad backs caused by hours sitting in vans, according to a survey. 
 Avon and Somerset Police, concerned by the growing number of officers taking sick leave due to back trouble, discovered in the survey that 15 per cent of the ricked backs were caused or aggravated by sitting in police vans and personnel carriers. 
 Over one four-month period, 25 policemen were affected. 
 The problem is caused by the spartan nature of the seats in riot vans, and because police rarely get the chance to ease aching muscles with a stroll. 
 Police officers are to be taught how to minimise backache by sitting properly, and vans with more comfortable seats are being bought. 
 David Shattock, the Chief Constable of Avon, says in a report: &bquo;Vehicles currently being purchased have greatly improved seating. 
 These seats will hopefully not only prove more comfortable for my officers, but will also reduce the aggravation that poor seating can cause to backs. 
 In addition, an input in posture is to be made into the training of officers to educate them in ways of preventing back injury.&equo; 
 Ron Scriven, a spokesman for the Police Federation which represents police officers, said: &bquo;If the Avon and Somerset report is forwarded to us we will study it and consider circulating the 43 forces in England and Wales with its findings. 
 Then we can see if other forces are experiencing the same problems.&equo; 
 Vi Gillman, spokeswoman for the National Back Pain Association, said the problem was caused by the way seats were designed and the posture of the people sitting in them. 
 &bquo;Police officers may also be working in stressful conditions and stress plays a part in back pain,&equo; she said. 
 Horses preparing for parade in Cumbria 
 By MIKE PRESTAGE 
 Horses exercising on a walker at Rosthwaite Farm, Windermere, Cumbria, to make them supple for pulling the 160-year-old coach in the background. 
 It is to feature in a parade of coaches at Boroughbridge, North Yorkshire, in weekend celebrations commemorating the arrival of the market town's first mail coach 200 years ago  
 M50 murder victim &bquo;tried to staunch flow of blood&equo; 
 By DAVID THOMAS 
 THE motorway murder victim Marie Wilks used her Red Cross training to staunch the flow of blood from her jugular vein after being stabbed in the neck, a court was told yesterday. 
 But she lapsed into unconsciousness after being dumped down a 15ft embankment on the M50 where she suffered a series of blows, one of which broke her jaw, Dr Peter Acland, a Home Office pathologist, told Shrewsbury Crown Court. 
 Dr Acland said she became progressively weaker through blood loss and died within 10 minutes. 
 She had no defensive injuries and had not been sexually assaulted. 
 The absence of a blood trail from an emergency telephone was consistent with the 22-year-old pregnant housewife staunching her own blood, Dr Acland said. 
 He believed that she pressed a clenched fist against the 2in deep knife wound during the three-mile journey in her killer's car from the telephone to the embankment at Twyning, Gloucestershire. 
 The court was told that Mrs Wilks, of Warndon, Worcester, had trained for six years with the Red Cross. 
 She was on duty regularly at horse races and stock-car races. 
 Her instructor, Sally Sheffield, described her as a competent first-aider who did not panic. 
 She had detailed knowledge of how to deal with bleeding of all types. 
 Edward Browning, 36, a nightclub bouncer, of Cwm Parc, Treorchy, Mid Glamorgan, denies murdering her. 
 Tagging &bquo;first step to community jail&equo; 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 ELECTRONIC tagging of remand prisoners, seen as the first stage towards plans to introduce community-based punishments, was attacked by probation officers yesterday. 
 Tagging, house arrest, tracking offenders, curfews and other restrictive punishments being considered by the Government for its Criminal Justice White Paper, would be a &bquo;trip wire&equo; into custody for those who would not have been jailed, they warned. 
 Tougher non-custodial measures and centralisation of the Probation Service were the likely groundwork for privatisation of punishment in the community, John Roberts, chairman of the National Association of Probation Officers, said. 
 He warned that the private security companies, which would monitor the offender, would be the only ones to benefit. 
 Punishment in the community would not ease prison overcrowding, he said, unless some form of sentencing restrictions were introduced to ensure courts did not impose jail sentences for minor offences and infringements of parole or bail restrictions. 
 Home Office figures showed plans to lengthen the time before a prisoner became eligible for parole and to introduce longer parole periods would mean the prison poulation could expand by between 4,000 and 5,000. 
 &bquo;The proposed changes will not have the effects intended. 
 Instead of thousands of offenders, inhumanely contained in Victorian slums, we would have thousands of offenders being punished in the community and confined to their homes. 
 Punishment measures will be used instead of existing supervision&hellip; multiple orders will mean multiple demands, which in turn will lead to multiple breaches. 
 The prison population will again rise.&equo; 
 He told Napo's annual conference in Bridlington, Humberside: &bquo;Electronic surveillance, house arrest tracking, restrictive and punitive community supervision cannot be part of any real living community &mdash; they simply transfer the techniques of imprisonment into the world at large.&equo; 
 Wife's 1.3m pounds divorce settlement upheld 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 A hotelier was ordered yesterday to make a &pound;1.3m divorce settlement to his wife, a former waitress. 
 The Court of Appeal refused to cut the award made in February to Radojka Gojkovic, 49, in the Family Division of the High Court. 
 Her lawyers believed it was highest settlement made in an English divorce court. 
 Lord Justice Butler-Sloss said the award, &pound;1m cash and a London maisonette valued at &pound;295,000, was &bquo;not excessively generous&equo;. 
 Risto Gojkovic, 45, said to be worth &pound;4m, had argued that his wife should receive the maisonette and &pound;532,000. 
 But Lord Justice Butler Sloss, sitting with Lord Justices Woolf and Russell, ruled that Mrs Gojkovic had &bquo;earned her share&equo;. 
 Mrs Gojkovic, of Sloane Terrace, Belgravia, London, and her husband, of Eardley Crescent, Earls Court, west London, arrived separately in Britain from Yugoslavia in 1966, the court heard. 
 Mr Gojkovic, who was then 23, worked his way up from kitchen porter, assistant cook, casino worker, and painter and decorator. 
 Mrs Gojkovic took &bquo;menial positions&equo; in hospitals and as a waitress. 
 They met in 1968, lived together from 1969, married in 1978 and were divorced in 1987. 
 They had no children. 
 Lord Justice Butler-Sloss said that while still working for others, they bought a property and turned it into an hotel, with Mrs Gojkovic working hard alongside her husband. 
 &bquo;It is agreed that the wife was the chatelaine par excellence.&equo; 
 She refered to comments made in the High Court by Mr Justice Ward, who said of the Gojkovics' success: &bquo;This is a story of high achievement and, many would think, glorious success. 
 That success came through unrelenting hard work, unlimited self-sacrifice and absolute determination.&equo; 
 Mr Justice Ward had added that Mrs Gojkovic had &bquo;played a unique role&equo; in building up the hotel venture, which now included 13 hotels. 
 Mrs Gojkovic said later: &bquo;What I now want is to get a middle-of-the-range hotel to cater for the tourist trade in London&hellip; this is going to enable me to do this.&equo; 
 Trade ban aims to protect threatened species of orchids 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 THE INTERNATIONAL trade in threatened species of wild orchids is set to be banned, it was announced yesterday. 
 The ban is expected to be part of a series of new measures to tighten control of the illegal horticultural business which is worth billions of dollars a year. 
 The large numbers of wild orchids being traded threatens some species with extinction. 
 Plant experts at the meeting of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) have agreed that more than 80 species of &bquo;slipper&equo; orchids &mdash; the genus paphiopedilum from Asia and the genus thragmipedium from South America &mdash; should be listed on the CITES Appendix I, which bans all commercial trade. 
 The decision is expected to be endorsed by the full CITES meeting next week. 
 Concern over the trade in wild plants has been heightened by the activities of Henry Azadehdel, who was jailed in Britain this year for smuggling orchids taken from the wild and imported without the proper permits. 
 Up to 100,000 thousand wild orchids are exported every year from Asia, and many thousands more are imported into America from countries such as Peru. 
 The ban will have no effect on the sale of propagated hybrid orchids, and botanists hope it will encourage the horticultural industry to switch from wild specimens to greenhouse-grown plants. 
 Botanists yesterday welcomed the agreement by the CITES plants committee to press for a wild slipper orchid ban. 
 Grenville Lucas, of the Royal Botanical Gardens, Kew, said: &bquo;Weight for weight, rare plants may be more valuable than ivory. 
 This move will help us combat the traders putting many rare plants at risk.&equo; 
 In another action to conserve endangered plants, the Netherlands &mdash; the world's centre for the plants trade &mdash; is to second one of its leading botanists to the CITES secretariat to improve the campaign to enforce tighter controls. 
 Dr Ger Van Vliet, scientific director of the Botanical Gardens in Lieden, said his tasks in the next three years would be to make customs officials more aware of endangered plants, reducing the illegal trade, and help countries supplying wild plants to sell correctly propagated specimens. 
 However, Mr van Vliet is at the centre of a disagreement within CITES over how to best protect snowdrops &mdash; the genus galathus &mdash; another plant worth millions in the trade, which is being endangered by sales of wild stocks. 
 The vast majority of snowdrop bulbs on the world market have been picked from the wild in Turkey. 
 Turkey exports up to 50 million bulbs a year with the majority passing through the Netherlands. 
 Rarer species of snowdrops are being indiscriminately harvested along with the more common ones. 
 The Dutch horticultural business is resisting proposals for snowdrops to be listed on CITES Appendix II, which would bring greater regulation and monitoring of the trade, a move backed by the plants committee with the exception of Mr van Vliet. 
 The traders say that the main species they import &mdash; galathus elwesii &mdash; is not endangered. 
 They have offered as an alternative to a formal listing, a system of self-regulation. 
 This would include cultivation of sample bulbs by Kew and Dutch Botanical Gardens to check if rarer species are being collected. 
 A final decision on the trade in snowdrops will be made next week. 
 CITES is also expected to back a British proposal for Appendix II listing of Turkish exports of winter daffodils. 
 Victoria Chipeto, Zimbabwe's Minister for Wildlife, yesterday defended her country's intention to continue selling ivory by culling its herds of 52,000 elephants. 
 She said the trade in ivory was a problem for Africa and the decision on it could not be made by &bquo;people outside with their emotional campaigns&equo;. 
 Peer denies requesting repatriation by force 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 LORD ALDINGTON denied in the High Court yesterday that he was responsible for seeking permission from higher command to use force to repatriate unwilling Cossacks from Austria only days after General Dwight Eisenhower, Supreme Allied Commander, offered to arrange their peaceful evacuation in May 1945. 
 General Eisenhower's offer to accept 150,000 surrendered German personnel, including 45,000 Cossacks, into the US-controlled zone was made on 19 May after a request by Allied forces for help in clearing the area. 
 But, according to documents revealed in court yesterday, four days later Lord Aldington's V Corps wrote to Eighth Army requesting &bquo;a free hand&equo; to use force if necessary &bquo;to honour our verbal agreement with Soviet forces&equo; and return all Soviet nationals to Soviet forces. 
 Lord Aldington &mdash; formerly Brigadier Toby Low &mdash; who is suing for libel damages over allegations that he is guilty of war crimes, denied a suggestion by Richard Rampton QC, for the defence, that he was responsible for drafting the 23 May request. 
 He said the request was drafted by Brigadier Edward de Fonblanque on the day after he left the area to return to England. 
 Lord Aldington's departure date is disputed by the defence, who claim Lord Aldington left either on 23 May or early on 24 May. 
 Lord Aldington agreed with Mr Rampton that the date on which he left V Corps area was important. 
 But he said: &bquo;Even if I had been in Austria longer, I would still be able to defend myself against the outrageous charges of behaving like a war criminal &mdash; a charge made against no one else.&equo; 
 Lord Aldington said he spent the nights of 22 and 23 May in Naples before flying back to England on the 24th. 
 He visited his mother, staying the night of 24 May with her, before meeting on 25 and 26 May with Sir Anthony Eden, the Foreign Secretary. 
 Lord Aldington said his earlier statements that he left the area between 25 and 29 May were made before he had properly researched the matter and before he realised his departure date was crucial. 
 Lord Aldington, former deputy chairman of the Conservative Party, who lives at Knoll Farm, Aldington, Ashford, Kent, is claiming libel damages over allegations in a pamphlet that he arranged the repatriation of 70,000 Cossacks and Yugoslavs, knowing they would be massacred. 
 Count Nikolai Tolstoy, 53, of Southmoor, Oxfordshire, and Nigel Watts, 51, of Tunbridge Wells, Kent, deny libel. 
 They claim the pamphlet is true, although they contest Lord Aldington's interpretation of it. 
 Mr Watts circulated 10,000 copies of the pamphlet among staff and parents of pupils at Winchester College, old boys, MPs, and others in 1987 in an attempt to force Lord Aldington's resignation as college warden. 
 Count Tolstoy provided much of the information for the pamphlet. 
 Lord Aldington, ex-chairman of Sun Alliance Insurance, has told the jury he is the victim of a campaign of harassment by Mr Watts who was annoyed by the company's failure to pay out on the death of his brother-in-law. 
 The hearing continues today. 
 Farmers to curb straw burning 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 FARMERS voted yesterday for a tough licensing system to curb straw burning, after complaints about smoke pollution at the end of this year's harvest. 
 The National Farmers' Union Council backed the idea of licences, with penalties of up to &pound;2,000 and the refusal of future permits for offenders. 
 The proposal came amid fears that the Ministry of Agriculture might introduce tougher restrictions or even an outright ban. 
 Proposals for the licensing system will now go forward to the ministry for approval. 
 More than 400 letters complaining about straw burning were sent to the ministry, and 120 MPs protested after the harvest. 
 The protests were the highest since the early 1980s, the council's quarterly meeting was told. 
 In Oxfordshire, smoke from burning staw obscured roads and led to a pile-up. 
 The NFU's president, Sir Simon Gorlay, said: &bquo;We have got to put our house in order. 
 We have got to work towards a situation where burning is no longer the routine disposal method for getting rid of surplus straw.&equo; 
 He said there had to be a curb on the &bquo;smut&equo; straw burning left on people's homes, their clothing and on other farmers' crops. 
 The council decided the cost of administering the licensing scheme should fall to the cereal growers who burned straw. 
 Woman, 74 sees off developers 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 KATHLEEN MACK, a 74-year-old stud owner, has forced a development company to amend its plans for a new overspill village for Cambridge by turning down a &pound;6m offer and chasing the company's surveyors off her land with a shotgun, writes Christian Wolmar. 
 Mrs Mack owns the 90-acre Lower Hare Park Stud four miles away from Newmarket which is on the site of a proposed 3,000-house scheme by Charles Church Developments, one of nine suggested sites for new settlements in the Cambridge area along the A45 corridor. 
 All are subject of a planning inquiry due to begin in February. 
 Mrs Mack said she could not accept the offer: &bquo;&pound;6m would not buy what I already have, which I want to keep. 
 They might have gone higher but this is a matter of principle. 
 Newmarket is the centre of the horse racing industry and this development would ruin it.&equo; 
 When surveyors started sizing up her land, &bquo;I got my shotgun out and showed them the gate,' she said. 
 Richard Hay, land director of Charles Church (East Anglia) Ltd, agreed that Mrs Mack had been approached but said the scheme could go ahead anyway. 
 &bquo;Our original proposal was for 840 acres but we're now going to file an amended proposal for 750 acres,&equo; he said. 
 Civil service time &bquo;misused to cost Labour programme&equo; 
 By COLIN HUGHES, Political Correspondent 
 LEAKED memoranda from the Department of the Environment were yesterday used by Labour to protest at the alleged abuse of civil service time to cost Labour's programme. 
 But the Treasury issued a counter-statement saying that nothing improper had been asked of civil servants by ministers. 
 Labour frontbenchers said they had been shown a note written by Sir Terence Heiser, Permanent Secretary at the Department of the Environment, to Nicholas Ridley, the then Secretary of State. 
 The note, headed &bquo;Costing Labour's Programme&equo; and dated 17 July 1989, says: &bquo;The Labour review document has been drafted much more carefully than on some earlier occasions. 
 The promises do not readily lend themselves to precise costings. 
 And in some cases the assumptions you have asked us to cost are vulnerable to counter attack from the Opposition. 
 You will want to consider whether to stick to the assumptions, and if so, how far to make use of the costings in public.&equo; 
 Sir Terence adds that he is enclosing for Christopher Patten a copy of the rules which the Cabinet Office has issued for the guidance of officials &bquo;on such exercises&equo;. 
 Gordon Brown, Labour's shadow to the Treasury chief secretary, said yesterday that he and Jack Cunningham, Labour's environment spokesman, had been shown additional internal Government papers which proved that the Conservative Party had asked the Treasury and individual departments to cost Labour's policy review according to Tory Central Office assumptions. 
 Mr Brown refused to say how the papers had been shown to him or to disclose their further contents. 
 But he added that government departments had been asked to complete forms and return them to the Treasury. 
 &bquo;What the documents conclusively reveal is that ministers asked the civil service to cost the Labour review using figures and interpretations provided by the Conservative Party. 
 Civil servants were not asked to cost Labour's policy review, but to cost Conservative Party fabrications about the review.&equo; 
 Mr Brown said that in other parts of the documents civil servants had described the Conservative Party assumptions as &bquo;remote from Labour's proposals&equo;, and &bquo;implausible&equo;. 
 He urged Sir Robin Butler, the Cabinet Secretary and Head of the Home Civil Service, to issue new guidelines preventing further attempts &bquo;to drag civil servants into the party political arena&equo;. 
 The Treasury, however, issued a statement saying that &bquo;civil servants have not been asked to do anything they have not been asked to do under previous Governments of both parties, in accordance with the guidelines laid down by the Cabinet Office&equo;. 
 &bquo;Ministers, assisted by their political advisers, are responsible for specifying the proposals to be costed, and for supplying any further interpretations or assumptions necessary. 
 Officials merely provide factual material, as they would in answer to similar questions from an MP, drawing attention to any technical assumptions that have been made.&equo; 
 PC is jailed for raping woman in patrol car 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 A POLICEMAN was yesterday jailed for seven years for raping an 18-year-old woman in his marked patrol car while he was on duty and in uniform. 
 Sentencing Constable Peter Anderson, 41, Mr Justice Jowitt told him he had done &bquo;great damage to the trust in police&equo;. 
 Anderson, married with two children, attacked the woman in a deserted allotment, after agreeing to give her and a boyfriend a lift home from a discotheque. 
 He first dropped the man off and then drove to the allotment. 
 He threatened her by forcing his truncheon under her chin and then raped her. 
 She said he only refrained from inserting his truncheon into her, after she begged him not to. 
 Afterwards he told her not to report the incident because he could have her &bquo;nicked&equo; for soliciting. 
 She did not report it because she did not think she would be believed. 
 Police investigated after an anonymous report. 
 The victim, now 20, said she had drunk nine or 10 Pernods with blackcurrant and was merry, but knew what she was doing and saying. 
 She said she tried to push him off, but he was too forceful. 
 Mr Justice Jowitt told Anderson: &bquo;I accept that you were not on the prowl looking for a victim and that it was by chance that this young lady got into your car. 
 I accept that there was no great degree of violence used by you. 
 &bquo;But you took her against her will in your car to the place where this rape happened, and one of the very disturbing and serious features of this case is the way you abused your position as a police officer in uniform on duty.&equo; 
 The judge added: &bquo;This girl plainly trusted herself in your company, as she was entitled to. 
 The public expect that they can treat the police with confidence. 
 You did great damage to that trust in the police when you behaved in this way.&equo; 
 Anderson, who had pleaded not guilty and claimed the woman had handed him &bquo;sex on a plate&equo;, was convicted by a 10-2 majority of raping the woman on 4 April, last year. 
 He claimed she had instigated the intercourse by first, and without invitation, performing oral sex on him. 
 He said he had only offered to use the truncheon as a sex aid but desisted when she shook her head. 
 Jean Southworth, QC, in mitigation, said: &bquo;This was not a case of him taking away the virginity of this young woman. 
 &bquo;He has lost his pension rights and the personal affection of those dear to him and also, when a police officer goes to prison, he often carries an extra load for his misdoings.&equo; 
 Verdict restores women's faith 
 By HEATHER MILLS 
 THE CONVICTION and jailing for rape of Constable Peter Anderson was yesterday welcomed by law reformers and women's groups, who said it should serve to encourage other rape victims to come forward and report crime, writes Heather Mills. 
 Coming in a week, when an American judge told a rape victim she &bquo;deserved what she got&equo; for wearing a lace mini-skirt, and an English judge dropped a rape charge because his 16-year-old alleged victim had the mental age of seven, yesterday's case has gone some way to restore their faith in the justice system. 
 The latest figures collated by Women against Rape show that only one in twelve women who are raped report the offence to police. 
 Of those cases reported, less than half are prosecuted through the courts and only 23 per cent result in convictions. 
 Pressure groups argue that women, already reluctant to report rape, will be further deterred when their attacker is a policeman, for fear that the charge will not be investigated impartially. 
 The outcome of yesterday's case could help dispel these fears. 
 But many believe that in spite of a growing public awareness of the trauma of rape, the legal process still fails women. 
 Sara Calloway, of Women Against Rape, said the 18-year-old victim's character had been put on trial and not the police officer's. 
 &bquo;It shows the low value placed on women's lives. 
 &bquo;They have to account for and justify what clothing they choose to wear, if they are on the Pill, their behaviour, and lifestyle. 
 &bquo;In this case, the victim's character was torn apart. 
 He (Anderson) played on a sexual stereotype, saying she was young, black, &bquo;the best sex he had ever had&equo; &mdash; anything that could be used as an excuse.&equo; 
 Although the judge, Mr Justice Jowitt, had questioned the victim about the length of her skirt &mdash; it was a mini-skirt &mdash; Ms Calloway said he had twice intervened on the victim's behalf. 
 The first time it was to stop the defence counsel from questioning her about her sexual history, the second time it was to stop Anderson referring to the victim by her last name, as if talking about a defendent. 
 Helena Kennedy, a barrister, said the law should be changed in rape cases to compel the defence to &bquo;reveal their hand&equo;, in relation to any attack made on an alleged victim's character. 
 This would give the victim chance to rebutt it. 
 In all sex offence cases juries are warned that that it is &bquo;dangerous&equo; to accept the word of the alleged victim alone and that they should look for corroboration. 
 Ms Kennedy said that coupled with the suggestion &mdash; left over from a case in 1976 &mdash; that woman and boys tend to lie, this initial suggestion of doubt can be an &bquo;appalling&equo; for the victim, who was already having to relive the ordeal in court. 
 Anderson had employed Jean Southwark QC, one of only a handful of leading women barristers. 
 Ms Kennedy, who is writing a book on women in the criminal justice system, said it had become common practice in rape trials to employ women lawyers for the defence. 
 &bquo;It is somehow seen as trying to soften the cross-examination of an alleged victim, and is somehow seen as more acceptable.&equo; 
 Art Market: Asian sculptures withdrawn from auction after tests reveal fake 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 THE MOST important Khmer and Thai sculptures were withdrawn from Sotheby's major sale of Asian art yesterday after one of the pieces was found to be a fake. 
 The large group of sculpture, including sandstone figures and bronzes, had been sent for sale from America. 
 After the catalogue had been sent to the printer, Sotheby's asked the Oxford Laboratory for Archaeology and the History of Art to try thermoluminescent dating on two pieces. 
 A Thai bronze figure of the Walking Buddha, which had been catalogued as dating from the fourteenth or fifteenth century and estimated at &pound;25,000-&pound;30,000, turned out to have been made within the last 150 years. 
 &bquo;The patination looked right,&equo; Brendan Lynch, Sotheby's expert, said. 
 &bquo;But there was something slightly odd about the style.&equo; 
 In the case of an eighth-century Pre-Khmer bronze figure of a Bodhisattva, estimated at &pound;40,000-&pound;60,000, the body had been tested and proved ancient but it was clear that the head had once been broken off and re-attached. 
 Tests of the head do not definitely identify its age and Oxford has asked for a second sample. 
 When Sotheby's told the owner that both pieces would have to be withdrawn from sale, he decided to withdraw his collection. 
 The results of the rest of the sale were wildly erratic with 36 per cent left unsold. 
 Sex appeal dictated the top price, &pound;46,200 (estimate &pound;25,000-&pound;35,000) for an eleventh or twelfth-century Indian sandstone relief carving depicting two lovers under a tree. 
 A ninth or tenth-century carved stone panel depicting the Seven Mother-Goddesses was sold for &pound;7,700 against an estimate of &pound;15,000-&pound;18,000. 
 Sotheby's sale of books about the Orient from the Blackmer library have made &pound;2.2m over the last two days with less than one per cent unsold. 
 There are two more sales today. 
 Greek bidders descended on the sale yesterday and drove up prices. 
 A collection of 12 large drawings depicting views of Constantinople and the Bosphorus, by Clara Mayer, dating from about 1790, made the top price at &pound;71,500 (estimate &pound;40,000-&pound;60,000). 
 The catalogue of Sir William Hamilton's collection of antiquities, published in Naples in 1766-67, secured &pound;39,600 (estimate &pound;18,000-&pound;20,000). 
 It was on this work that Josiah Wedgwood based his neoclassical pottery designs. 
 Only 500 copies are said to have been printed. 
 Still Life with Gladioli, a 1913 painting by the Dutch artist Leo Gestel, sold for 460,000 guilders (&pound;137,765), a record for his work, at Sotheby's Amsterdam sale of modern paintings. 
 Police use church video in barracks bomb hunt 
 By JACK O'SULLIVAN 
 KENT POLICE began re-interviewing 1,500 people in Deal yesterday in an unusual move to develop leads on last month's bombing of the Royal Marines' barracks in the town. 
 Hundreds arrived to be registered at a special inquiry centre in St Saviour's church, which will be open from 10am to 10pm until tomorrow night. 
 A video showing the alleged IRA safe house at 17 Campbell Road, asked people viewing it to try to remember whether they had seen, inadvertedly had drinks with, or queued at shops with members of the IRA unit. 
 Police believe the unit wandered openly in the Deal area and may have visited local pubs. 
 Drawings of three suspects, two men and a woman, are posted in the church. 
 Lists of questions ask about possible suspicious sightings of people and vehicles around the barracks and taxi rides to and from the area to pubs or Dover docks. 
 Det Chief Insp Nick Biddiss said: &bquo;People may still know things they have forgotten to mention and we hope this exercise will jog their memories.&equo; 
 Officers sat in booths in a side chapel for people wanting to give confidential interviews. 
 Police hope to identify men seen several times in the Campbell Road area in the six days between 16 September, when the IRA unit apparently left the safe house, and the bombing. 
 The officers know that time is against them as new descriptions from members of the public may be distorted by sight of the published artist's impressions. 
 They are interested in at least a dozen taxi journeys reported between Dover and the Campbell Road area in the month before the bombing. 
 The officers are also anxious to hear from people who noticed any suspicious strangers seeking rented accommodation in the Deal area during the last 18 months. 
 Their latest lead is a white transit van reportedly seen near the barracks in the week before the bombing. 
 This could provide a clue as to the bombers' whereabouts between 16 September and the bombing, which killed 10 bandsmen. 
 A light brown Mk II Cortina is believed to have broken down when used by the IRA unit and a black E registration Nissan Micra was seen near the barracks the night before the bombing. 
 Among those expected to be re-interviewed are Kathy Brown, 47, who usually cleans the Campbell Road house, which was let as a holiday home. 
 She said yesterday that the three-bedroom property was capable of sleeping five people comfortably. 
 Mrs Brown last cleaned the house at the end of July and was away when the IRA suspects used it. 
 Another resident, Williamine Dyson, 65, who looked after spare keys for the holiday home, said yesterday she saw a man lingering near the base at the end of August and then walking up Campbell Road. 
 She added that she never saw the suspected occupants of the house. 
 ITV set to sign Juno contract 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 ITV is this weekend expected to sign a deal believed to involve about &pound;3m for exclusive coverage of the British astronaut project, the Juno mission, writes Mary Fagan. 
 It will allow the network to cover everything from astronaut training in Moscow's Star City to life on the Soviet space station Mir. 
 But Juno, which will cost about &pound;16m, has yet to raise any money apart from the ITV deal. 
 The project is being underpinned by the London-based Moscow Narodny Bank, making television coverage all the more important in the effort to attract sponsors. 
 Several big British companies are said to be &bquo;extremely interested&equo;. 
 Their involvement, if it materialises, may be anything from straightforward advertising on the equipment, on Mir, and even on the astronaut, to support for scientific experiments. 
 A Soviet delegation arrives this month to discuss the experiments and the choice of astronaut. 
 Child transplant challenges liver surgeons 
 By CELIA HALL, Medical Editor 
 A GIRL aged two was in a critical but stable condition last night after undergoing a 10-hour liver transplant operation at Addenbrooke's Hospital, Cambridge. 
 Linda Prime is in the paediatric intensive care unit after the technically successful surgery. 
 The operation was conducted by three surgeons, led by Mr Peter Johnston, senior lecturer in surgery at Cambridge University. 
 Although Linda is not the youngest child to receive a liver, the Addenbrooke's team carried out a successful transplant on a seven-month-old baby two years ago, her size and the fact that she has received previous surgery for her condition complicated the procedure. 
 The surgeons had to join blood vessels of only two millimetres in diameter and use suturing materials no broader than a human hair. 
 The stitching is done holding the needles with tweezers with the surgeons wearing special operating glasses. 
 Linda suffers from biliary atresia, an abnormality in which the bile duct is blocked. 
 This means waste matter cannot be discarded through the system known as the biliary tree, one of the four major vessels connected to the liver. 
 This damages the liver leading to sclerosis and scarring. 
 She had already been given an operation for biliary atresia which is designed to unblock or bypass the blockage leaving scar tissue which is more likely to bleed. 
 At the same time the body develops ways around the scarring to maintain blood supply &bquo;growing&equo; little extra blood vessels into the gut and stomach wall. 
 All these have to be untangled before the damaged liver can be removed. 
 Linda received a liver from another child so surgeons did not have to cut an adult liver to size. 
 The main vessels that are cut and connected to the new liver are biliary duct, the hepatic artery which supplies the liver with blood from the heart, the portal vein which drains blood from the stomach and the gut and the hepatic vein which takes the blood back to the heart. 
 The success rate for liver transplants in children is about 75 per cent. 
 Government &bquo;committed&equo; to solicitors' legal rights 
 By PATRICIA WYNN DAVIES, Legal Correspondent 
 THE Government is committed to allowing solicitors as well as barristers to represent their clients in the higher courts, the Lord Chancellor, Lord Mackay of Clashfern, said last night. 
 But he refused to give details of possible limits on these new rights. 
 Despite recent pleas from the Bar and solicitors, the Lord Chancellor declined to say explicitly whether he backed the idea of special restrictions in some cases. 
 While making no overt concessions, he told lawyers and judges at the Middle Temple in London that discussions between a proposed advisory committee, the Law Society and senior judges &bquo;may lead to different conclusions for different types of case, and most important of all, our conclusions may change in the light of experience&equo;. 
 Following a speech by Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, to barristers this month, there have been fears that senior judges involved in drawing up rules would effectively block the use of the new rights in practice, by insisting that preparation of some cases and their presentation in court should be handled by different people. 
 Such a rule would prevent solicitors handling the client's case from start to finish. 
 But in a series of remarks broadly encouraging to solicitors, Lord Mackay said the lay-dominated advisory committee would be likely to consider what happens in other countries where there was no enforced separation of the two functions. 
 &bquo;I suspect that the advisory committee will wish to consider also the fact that solicitors are able now to prepare and present cases in the magistrates&equo; and county courts and in chambers in the High Court. 
 Some of these cases already involve difficult questions of law and fact,&equo; he added. 
 The committee would be likely to consider a suggestion by Lord Donaldson that case separation might be needed where the public had an interest in the outcome of a case but it would also play a role as representative of those who actually used legal services, he said. 
 Lord Mackay warned that it was &bquo;misleading and unfair&equo; to read Lord Donaldson's speech as an indication that judges would block solicitors' rights. 
 Any decision that preparation and presentation should be separate would have to be justified to the public and be open in the last resort to judicial review. 
 &bquo;For those who think that this is window dressing, I pause to remind you that not so long ago the Lord Chancellor was himself the subject of judicial review proceedings,&equo; he added. 
 But Walter Merricks, assistant secretary general at the Law Society, said: &bquo;We have urged the Government to think again about the framework. 
 We think it could lead to a stalemate. 
 He should adopt the approach outlined in the Scottish White Paper.&equo; 
 Lord Mackay supported a recent suggestion by Lord Donaldson that small claims procedures should be easily operated by the do-it-yourself litigant. 
 He added that there might be a sufficient pool of volunteers to act as a new breed of &bquo;civil justices&equo;. 
 Loan sharks &bquo;thriving on inner-city poor&equo; 
 By DAVID LISTER, Cities Correspondent 
 (First Edition) LOAN SHARKS enticing people into debt, then inflicting violence on them when they fail to pay 100 per cent interest rates, are a growing and deeply disturbing aspect of inner-city poverty, a conference was told yesterday. 
 Dr Bob Holman, a National Children's Home neighbourhood worker on the Easterhouse Estate in Glasgow, told a conference in London on growing up in the inner city organised by the Thomas Coram Foundation and chaired by Lord Scarman, that most of the 44,000 people there lived in poverty. 
 Many had to borrow money, a need that had grown since last year's replacement of social security single grants for urgent needs or repairs by social fund loans. 
 People could borrow from the social fund, he said, and get money that was interest-free, but money was taken from their income support immediately, even though that support was meant to be the lowest level of income on which one could cope. 
 Increasingly, people on these and other estates were turning to loan sharks, who offered money even without being asked. 
 He said: &bquo;The rate is a pound for a pound and the whole within a week. 
 If you can't pay pressures are applied, first verbal, then your windows are smashed, then violence. 
 So children grow up in an atmosphere of harassment and greater poverty.&equo; 
 He said his flat on the estate had been robbed by a man whose knees had been smashed with a baseball bat after falling foul of a loan shark. 
 Police had made video films of such people, but there were few arrests as most victims were scared to testify. 
 The best answer, Dr Holman said, was credit unions, local organisations of residents who save and lend to each other at low interest rates. 
 Peter Brown, chairman of the Thomas Coram foundation, said: &bquo;Unless the human imperative of individual dereliction is addressed alongside the more visual investment in environmental dereliction, and however well we spend it this means more money, the country will find itself in a downward spiral of inner-city social decay that could well substitute Drug Alley for the Gin Lane of Coram's and Hogarth's day.&equo; 
 Pollution curb 
 By DAVID LISTER, Cities Correspondent 
 The National Farmers' Union proposed a licensing system to curb straw burning, after hundreds of complaints about smoke pollution at the end of the harvest. 
 Van deaths 
 By DAVID LISTER, Cities Correspondent 
 Police were investigating the deaths in a fume-filled van of two cousins who had apparently connected a hose from the exhaust pipe to warm themselves. 
 The bodies of Alex Stewart, 28, and Hugh Stewart, 21, from Reading, Berkshire, were found on Wednesday at Barley Mow Lane, near St Albans, Hertfordshire. 
 Health awards 
 By DAVID LISTER, Cities Correspondent 
 The Medical Journalists' Association 1989 award for the most outstanding contribution to medical journalism has been won by Nicholas Timmins, The Independent's Health Services Correspondent. 
 Other winners of the award, sponsored by Reckitt and Colman, included Cherrill Hicks, a freelance journalist who works on The Independent's health page, for her book Who Cares; Looking After People at Home. 
 Insulin &bquo;plea&equo; 
 By DAVID LISTER, Cities Correspondent 
 The British Diabetic Association has urged diabetics not to stop taking genetically-engineered &bquo;human&equo; insulin. 
 The association has had calls from hundreds of sufferers after a report that 17 people on human insulin have died this year. 
 Brown selected 
 By DAVID LISTER, Cities Correspondent 
 Ron Brown, Labour MP for Edinburgh Leith, was reselected last night as his local party's parliamentary candidate. 
 He won 54 per cent of the ballot against two challengers. 
 Disease threat to beet crop 
 By DAVID LISTER, Cities Correspondent 
 A farm in Norfolk has been placed under strict quarantine after the discovery of rhizomania or &bquo;root madness&equo;, which attacks sugar and other beet crops, reducing the yield. 
 Ministry of Agriculture inspectors fear that the disease has spread from the Continent, and are carrying out detailed checks around Wood Farm, near Aylsham. 
 Doctors soften protest 
 By DAVID LISTER, Cities Correspondent 
 Patients who dislike the Government's NHS plans are to be urged by the British Medical Association to visit their MPs' surgeries and write to their health authorities. 
 Seven million new leaflets are being sent to 35,000 GPs as the next stage of the BMA campaign against the NHS White Paper, which has now cost more than &pound;2m. 
 The leaflets, softer in tone than much of the BMA campaign, suggest that hospitals that fail to compete in the new NHS market could go bankrupt; GPs will be forced to compete for patients, with those that take on more having less time for patients; while &bquo;opted out&equo; hospitals may drop some specialist services if they are not financially viable. 
 Home Office grants delay in deportation of Kurdish refugee 
 By NICHOLAS SCHOON 
 A HOME OFFICE minister yesterday intervened at the last minute to delay a Kurdish refugee being flown back to Turkey. 
 Selahattin Ozberk, who had been booked on an afternoon flight from Heathrow to Istanbul, will now be sent back next Tuesday evening unless another country can be found to accept him. 
 The decision by Timothy Renton, Minister of State, came after an urgent representation from the London office of the United Nations High Commission for Refugees on Wednesday. 
 The looming enforced removal of Mr Ozberk, 30, has the makings of a diplomatic incident. 
 The commission now has the task of finding another country to take him in the next five days, and it is not optimistic. 
 Jean Pierre Hocke, the commissioner of the Geneva-based organisation, has made it known he is concerned about the case. 
 The commission believes Mr Ozberk has good reasons to fear being returned to Turkey and qualifies as a genuine political refugee. 
 Amnesty International and several other groups have given their support. 
 Mr Ozberk had already been taken, handcuffed and escorted by police, to the police station at Heathrow airport from the Haslar detention centre, near Gosport, Hampshire, when Mr Renton's new orders were given to the Immigration Service. 
 Another Kurd who was with him, Halil Guzel, won no reprieve and was put on a flight to Istanbul. 
 The UN had not said he deserved political asylum. 
 About 60 Kurdish refugees tried to mount a demonstration in Terminal 2 but were led away by police who said it was illegal under airport by-laws. 
 Mr Ozberk has now been moved to Pentonville Prison which is nearer the airport. 
 Michael Hanley, his solicitor, said: &bquo;He will be isolated, with no other Kurds to talk to, and I fear it will make his mental state even worse. 
 He is on the brink of breakdown, sobbing and incoherent.&equo; 
 An attempt in the High Court to get the decision to remove Mr Ozberk quashed failed yesterday afternoon. 
 Mr Justice McCullough said the UN High Commission for Refugees was entitled to its view that he was a political refugee, and so was Amnesty International. 
 But, on the same evidence as they had, the Home Secretary had reached a different view quite lawfully. 
 The court heard Mr Ozberk had told immigration officials that in April he had been arrested by Turkish police seeking information about his brother, a member of an outlawed Kurdish independence organisation. 
 He was held for four hours and beaten with a truncheon. 
 A few weeks later he flew to Britain. 
 Six other Kurds at Haslar face imminent removal. 
 Over the next few months it is likely that the Home Office will order out hundreds more of the 3,500 Kurds who arrived in May and June and now live in north London. 
 Some are economic refugees who came to Britain seeking a better life; the rest are trying to escape oppression and even torture. 
 Therapy aids cancer patients' survival 
 By CELIA HALL, Medical Editor 
 A GROUP of American breast-cancer patients who were given supportive therapy and taught self-hypnosis to deal with pain survived for twice as long as women who received routine cancer care. 
 In all the cases the cancer had spread to other organs, giving poor survival chances; but on average the patients who received pyschological treatment lived for 37 months while those who did not lived 19 months on average. 
 The three women who were still alive after 10 years had all been in the therapy group. 
 The attempt to answer claims that psychological attitudes affect survival in cancer patients is reported today in The Lancet from researchers in California, but they add that other factors may have influenced the results. 
 They say that more of the therapy group were married, and married people with cancer are known to survive longer; that help with pain control meant they were more likely to remain active and continue with exercise; and that they tended to eat better. 
 The 50 women received group therapy for a year, in three groups visiting hopsital weekly for their sessions. 
 The psychiatrists from Stanford University and the University of California reported &bquo;intense bonding&equo; among the women who were able to share their experiences. 
 &bquo;Thus the groups countered the social alienation that often divides cancer patients from their well-meaning but anxious family and friends,&equo; they write. 
 Doctors at the Royal Marsden Hospital and St Bartholemew's Hospital, London, have discovered that a cocktail of anti-leukaemia drugs achieved complete remission in half the patients and a response in another quarter. 
 All the patients had multiple myeloma which affects bone marrow. 
 Shakespeare's Globe unearthed 
 By DAVID KEYS, Archaeology Correspondent 
 THE REMAINS of the Globe Theatre, where Shakespeare acted and at least a dozen of his plays were premiered, have been discovered by archaeologists excavating on the south bank of the Thames in central London. 
 Shakespeare partly-owned the Globe, which was built in 1599 and rebuilt in 1614 after a fire in 1613 started by a cannon used as a prop. 
 It was demolished in 1644, two years after the Puritans banned theatrical performances in England. 
 The current excavations are the first time that the theatre's remains have been seen since that destruction. 
 So far, excavations near Southwark Bridge have unearthed part of its outer and inner walls, and any further investigations could reveal its exact design. 
 Historians have long debated what the Globe looked like. 
 Theories have been put forward that it had anything from 6 to 24 sides, and even that it may have been circular. 
 The remains unearthed consist of chalk block and brick walls, and even some timbers. 
 &bquo;This spectacular discovery should once and for all prove what shape the original Globe was,&equo; Martin Clout, the theatre architecture historian, said. 
 Mr Clout was one of the founders of the Rose Theatre Trust, which championed the preservation of the late Tudor theatre's remains. 
 These are adjacent to the Globe site. 
 The current excavation at the Globe is merely to assess the site's archaeological potential. 
 It is not known whether there will be a full archaeological investigation of the entire site, or even of a large part of it; the excavation ends today. 
 Some of the Globe's remains lie beneath an officially protected early nineteenth-century listed building. 
 If a full excavation of the Globe were to take place, the building would need to be demolished first. 
 This would pose historians and conservationists with a dilemma. 
 Only a three-yard stretch of the theatre has been unearthed, and it is not known whether any more will be excavated. 
 However, the archaeologists and the site's owners, the property developer Hanson plc, are co-operating. 
 The Museum of London and Hanson are to ask Chris Patten, the Secretary of State for the Environment, to schedule the site as one of national importance. 
 It is believed to be the first time a developer has urged the Government to schedule an archaeological site. 
 David Trippier, the heritage minister, confirmed yesterday that the Department of the Environment would &bquo;be considering very carefully, with advice from English Heritage, the need to schedule the remains&equo;. 
 However, scheduling will not only protect the site from damage through property development, but is also likely to prevent further archaeological excavations being carried out &mdash; at least without special government authority. 
 Hanson and the Museum of London say that &bquo;as soon as practicable the site will be open to public view for a limited period. 
 &bquo;The Museum of London will then temporarily fill in the site to preserve and protect it while it is decided how it might be put on permanent display.&equo; 
 Pupils over 16 &bquo;should get loans&equo; 
 By PETER WILBY, Education Editor 
 LOANS SHOULD be offered to sixth-formers, and university and college students, a report commissioned by BP suggests today. 
 Professor Alan Smithers and Pamela Robinson, of Manchester University, say it is vital for Britain's economic future that more young people are persuaded to stay at school after 16. 
 &bquo;A college education should be regarded as everyone's birthright.&equo; 
 Given constraints on public expenditure, it is unlikely that the Government could be persuaded to introduce maintenance grants for 16 to 18-year-olds. 
 It will bring forward legislation in the coming parliamentary session to introduce student loans, partially replacing grants, from autumn 1990. 
 The authors also propose that A-levels and other exams for 16 to 18-year-olds should be reformed to be more like the GCSE. 
 &bquo;The problem lies with our present system of academic examinations where candidates compete against each other for grades so that there are winners and losers. 
 &bquo;It would be better to ask young people to show what they could do against explicit criteria so that the challenge would be between the person and the task, not between individuals, with one person's success being another's failure,&equo; the report says. 
 Degree exams should be reformed on similar lines. 
 Orders for secret trials challenged 
 By HEATHER MILLS, Courts Correspondent 
 FOR THE first time in English legal history, judges' decisions to close their doors to the Press and public have been challenged in the Court of Appeal. 
 Three Old Bailey judges were accused of ignoring the principle of open justice, and wrongly holding secret hearings. 
 They are the first tests of legal reforms introduced two months ago to allow judges' secrecy orders to be reviewed. 
 The person to bring the first challenge was Tim Crook, a radio journalist, whose campaign for more open justice to the European Commission led to the reforms contained in the Criminal Justice Act 1988. 
 However, believing that the reforms do not go far enough, and backed by the National Council for Civil Liberties (Liberty) and The Independent, he is still pursuing the campaign to the European courts. 
 Andrew Nicol, for Mr Crook, told Lord Lane, the Lord Chief Justice, sitting with Mr Justice Macpherson and Mr Justice Pill, that his client had been &bquo;zealous&equo; in trying to preserve the principle of open justice. 
 Mr Crook is appealing against two secrecy orders imposed last month, and applying for leave to appeal against another also made last month. 
 At the close of yesterday's hearing, the court reserved judgment on the two appeals and gave leave for Mr Crook to pursue the third &mdash; but not until the first judgment had been given. 
 The judges concluded by imposing a publicity postponement order on the day's proceedings under the Contempt of Court Act. 
 Lord Lane said: &bquo;No mention is to be made of any of the facts upon which these three orders were founded until after the conclusion of the last of the three trials involved, whenever that may be.&equo; 
 He added that this order would leave it open to the Press to deal with the questions of principle so far as they did not apply them to the facts. 
 Mr Nicol said that in each of the three cases the restriction of access to the public conflicted with the principle of openness which applied to all legal proceedings. 
 If there was a potential prejudice in reporting any of the proceedings it could have been dealt with by the lesser measure of a postponing order. 
 He told the appeal judges it would not be &bquo;just an empty gesture&equo; to vary the orders complained of and instead impose postponement orders. 
 The appeals were opposed by Robert Harman QC, who argued that to have allowed the Press to stay in court, subject to a postponement order, for the disputed hearing would have served only to satisfy the &bquo;inquisitiveness&equo; of Old Bailey journalists. 
 Stunning victory puts Yusupov on level terms 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON 
 ARTUR YUSUPOV scored a stunning victory against Anatoly Karpov yesterday to level the scores in the Pilkington Glass World Chess Championship semi-final, writes William Hartson. 
 Playing an unusual opening variation, Yusupov secured some advantage, but with accurate play Karpov fought back. 
 Just as everyone was expecting a draw, however, Yusupov made a an unexpected sacrifice of a bishop. 
 In time trouble and under severe pressure, Karpov was unable to find a defence as Yusupov's queen and rooks swarmed into his position. 
 Karpov resigned at move 37, facing inevitable mate. 
 It was the first time Yusupov has ever beaten Karpov, and leaves the scores level with three games left to play. 
 In the other match, Jonathan Speelman claimed a time-out, taking a break in order to think himself into the right frame of mind to fight his way back into the match. 
 He trails Jan Timman by one point with two games left. 
 Irishmen arrested in hotel raid 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON 
 FIVE Irishmen arrested in an early-morning raid on a Cheltenham hotel yesterday were last night being held for questioning under the Prevention of Terrorism Act. 
 Gloucestershire police said there was no evidence to connect them with recent bombings such as the attack on Royal Marine bandsmen at Deal, Kent. 
 Police said the arrests came after a tip-off from a member of the public. 
 The Prime Minister and other ministers are expected to attend a Conservative conference in Cheltenham next spring. 
 Armed police went to the hotel shortly before 7am to make the arrests, and sniffer dogs were later used in a search of the premises. 
 Under the Act, the men can be held for up to seven days. 
 The hotel's owner said nine Irishmen had been staying at the hotel since June, all of them apparently working as builders. 
 In Belfast, a brother of Gerry Adams, West Belfast Sinn Fein MP, was remanded in custody on charges arising from a gun attack on an RUC station last weekend. 
 Sean Patrick Adams, 30, and Anthony Gillen, 27, were accused of attempting to murder members of the security forces in west Belfast, and of possessing an AK 47 rifle and ammunition with intent to endanger life. 
 Daniel Joseph McBrearty, 36, from Londonderry, is to appear in court today charged with possessing the explosive RDX, according to Scotland Yard. 
 He was arrested last Thursday in London. 
 Five held in Brink's-Mat inquiry 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON 
 TWO MEN and three women were being questioned last night by Scotland Yard detectives investigating the laundering of proceeds from the &pound;26m Brink's-Mat bullion robbery. 
 They were arrested during early morning raids on nine addresses in London and the Home Counties and taken to Cannon Row police station in central London. 
 A Yard statement said the five were being questioned in connection with the alleged dishonest handling of &pound;16m of the &pound;26m in gold bars stolen in November 1983 from the Brink's-Mat bullion warehouse at Heathrow airport. 
 The statement said the arrests were made by the force's organised crime task force, headed by Det Chief Supt Graham Melvin, after several months' inquiries. 
 The task force was set up after detectives discovered that some of the money had been used to finance drugs and property dealing in the United States and even invested in London's Docklands, realising millions of pounds in profits. 
 About &pound;20m of the original money is believed to have been accounted for, although about another &pound;6m is still missing. 
 A number of people have already been sentenced to long prison terms in connection with the robbery. 
 Gordon Parry, 44, is in detention in Spain awaiting extradition proceedings to Britain in connection with the case. 
 He was arrested in Marbella in April by Scotland Yard detectives and Spanish police. 
 Villagers get lessons in rural protest 
 By CHRISTIAN WOLMAR 
 EVENING CLASSES are being used to educate rural protesters in the best ways to defend the countryside from polluters and developers, writes Christian Wolmar. 
 Villagers are being shown how to lobby for change by learning how to write press releases, organise protests and run clean-up campaigns. 
 The Action for Communities in Rural England (ACRE) has published a handbook, Doing by Learning, which explains how to start a course. 
 Ian Scott, co-ordinator of its rural adult education project, said that at times the enthusiasm of the groups being taught had to be dampened: &bquo;At the opening class of a course being run in Co Durham, the students frightened the tutor by demanding that there should be a march on County Hall. 
 In fact, they ended up learning that there were much more effective ways of organising.&equo; 
 The organisers of the courses, which have been run in 60 villages across 20 counties, often find they have to overcome opposition within the village first. 
 Bernard Lane, one of the authors of the handbook, said: &bquo;The students find that there is much more that can be done in the village than was thought. 
 The local parish council has often been in the hands of a group leading the area into decline. 
 The courses are powerful because they provide a link between the newcomers and the local indigenous population who find that working together can help them learn to influence the decision makers.&equo; 
 Ambulance action rethink 
 By BARRIE CLEMENT 
 (First Edition) AMBULANCE union leaders are to consider stepping up industrial action after it became clear yesterday that management had made no concessions in talks with Acas, the conciliation service, writes Barrie Clement. 
 Representatives of the five unions involved will meet on Tuesday to discuss the options, which will range from reballoting to allow for limited strike action to less disruptive forms of escalation in the four-week pay dispute. 
 Acas officials briefed union leaders yesterday on discussions with management last Tuesday, but there appeared to be no possibility of an early breakthrough. 
 Union sources thought last night that an all-out strike was unlikely, although various forms of non-co-operation might be considered. 
 Privatised BR &bquo;low on agenda&equo; 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correpondent 
 (First Edition) RENEWED doubts about the possibility of privatising British Rail were raised yesterday by Cecil Parkinson, Secretary of State for Transport, in a speech to the Tory party conference. 
 Although his predecessor, Paul Channon, sounded a note of caution at last year's conference, there were high hopes that the party would include privatisation of BR in its next manifesto. 
 Mr Parkinson told journalists later: &bquo;It has never been at the top of my agenda. 
 It was never going to happen before the next Parliament, if ever.&equo; 
 His remarks will disappoint many right-wing Tories who have been pushing hard for the Government to give a firm commitment to privatisation. 
 Studies on the options are still going on, and the Government's decision to increase BR's profit targets had been seen as part of the &bquo;fattening-up&equo; process. 
 Mr Parkinson, after devising the privatisation of the electricity industry, is under pressure to avoid creating a private monopoly with BR services. 
 He also appeared to distance himself from the BR route for the Channel tunnel link, saying that when BR brought forward the Bill for its preferred route through Kent, it would be &bquo;for Parliament to settle the way forward&equo;. 
 Law: Review of administration in Court of Appeal Civil Division 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correpondent 
 AS A measure for reducing delays in the disposal of appeals in the Civil Division of the Court of Appeal, Lord Donaldson of Lymington, the Master of the Rolls, said the categories of cases in which unsuccessful litigants were required to obtain leave to appeal should be extended. 
 Lord Donaldson gave the seventh annual review of the organisation and administration of the Civil Division of the Court of Appeal, on 12 October 1989. 
 He said the purpose of the annual review was to inform the legal profession, the users of the court and the wider public of what problems had been encountered in endeavours to achieve better, cheaper and swifter appellate justice, what steps were being taken to overcome those problems and what success was attending those efforts. 
 The critical equation The resources of the court, both human and material, were necessarily limited. 
 Delays would increase or decrease, according to whether the court was presented with more or less work than it could handle. 
 Over the seven-year period covered by the reviews, that critical equation had produced a state of equilibrium. 
 Lead times &mdash; the period which elapsed between an appeal being launched and its disposal &mdash; were largely unchanged. 
 It was against that background that the judges and staff of the court had throughout the year been examining what measures were feasible which tip the balance in the direction of reducing delays, either by an improved system for screening appeals or by an improved system for handling them or both. 
 Screening appeals The justification for the present system whereby some categories of appeal could only be brought by leave of the trial judge or of the Court of Appeal was threefold: 1. 
 It was no kindness to allow a litigant who was unsuccessful in the trial court to incur costs protesting at that result, if the decision was demonstrably correct or, as often in matrimonial disputes, if there was no &bquo;right&equo; answer and the trial judge must inevitably be the final arbiter. 
 2. 
 Allowing such appeals to proceed caused grave injustice to the successful party, who was denied the benefit of the judgment in his favour, pending the outcome of the appeal, and almost always incurred irrecoverable costs. 
 3. 
 The employment of the resources of the court in hearing such appeals inevitably postponed the hearing of other appeals where there was a real issue to be decided. 
 Extending the requirement for leave to appeal It was to be hoped that in the context of forthcoming legislation, consideration would be given to extending the requirement for leave to appeal across the board, both because there was no justification for allowing any appeal to proceed if it had no prospect of success and because the present dividing lines between those in which leave was required and those in which it was not, was quite illogical. 
 Thus, a litigant who claimed any form of injunction had an unfettered right of appeal. 
 So too had parents who disagreed with a judge's decision on any matter, however minor, concerning a child's education or welfare. 
 Yet a judgment striking out a complete action for want of prosecution or for any other reason was appealable only with leave. 
 A further, if slightly different, anomaly existed in relation to judicial review. 
 In recognition of the general interest in avoiding the disruptive effect of such proceedings on the public administration no one could apply for judicial review unless they had successfully applied ex parte for leave. 
 Where leave was given, it was not uncommon to find on investigation that there were no grounds for granting any relief. 
 Yet the disappointed applicant had an unfettered right to extend the period of disruption by appealing. 
 Improvements in the handling of appeals The year had seen two separate and different initiatives. 
 The first was announced in a Practice Direction (1989) 1 WLR 281, which provided for the much earlier delivery of skeleton arguments which would be studied by the judges before they sat to hear the appeal. 
 The primary purpose was to reduce the costly time spent on oral argument in so far as that was not necessary for the proper determination fo the appeal. 
 It was too early to reach firm conclusions as to the direction's effectiveness. 
 The need to monitor that experiment and the conviction that the court would benefit from improved lines of communication between it and those who used the court, either as practitioners or as litigants, had led to the establishment of a Court of Appeal Users' Committee, representative of both, which would have its first meeting later this month. 
 The second concerned the acquisition of a small number of &bquo;in house&equo; lawyers. 
 There needed to be a team leader and five other lawyers. 
 Each lawyer should be in full charge of case management of all application and appeals within his group, giving procedural advice to litigants in person, and, where necessary, providing summaries of the issues raised for the use of the judges. 
 The groups would be defined by reference to subject matter; eg public law, family law, contract and commercial law and so on. 
 The lawyers would also have other duties, such as providing an up-to-date data base of the court's decisions relevant to each group. 
 The Lord Chancellor's Department had now reached the stage of recruitment. 
 It was hoped that there might be one or more lawyers in post in the relatively near future. 
 The nature of the court's work There had been a tendency largely to disregard applications as being incidental to the main task of deciding appeals and as not significant in themselves. 
 The figures for applications heard by a single Lord Justice and two and three Lords Justices went a long way to explaining why, despite the facts that the rate at which appeals were begun had shown little change over the years, there had been some small increase in judge-power and that major improvements had been made in the court's procedures, the number of appeals outstanding at the end of each year and the lead times for hearing appeals showed no real improvement. 
 The judges now had to hear nearly as many applications as they heard appeals. 
 A 50 per cent increase in applications to a court of three judges and the overall 33 per cent in full court applications had very obvious implications for the availability of judges to hear substantive appeals. 
 Two other changes in the nature of the court's work had been identified as contributing to the failure to reduce lead times. 
 1. 
 The first concerned litigants in person. 
 No one denied litigants the right to prosecute their appeals in person, but deprived of the benefit of the assistance of counsel, it could take longer to hear and determine the application or appeal. 
 There was a 66 per cent increase in the numbers of applications made by litigants in person and a 20 per cent increase in the number of appeals. 
 2. 
 The second was the increasing complexity of the legal issues arising in appeals. 
 Dismissals of appeals without a hearing on the merits were a key factor in the &bquo;critical equation&equo;. 
 Twenty-six per cent of all appeals set down were disposed of in that way. 
 Judge power The authorised number of Lords Justices was at present 26, one less than at the same time last year. 
 At any one time five were working in the Criminal Division and in the Queen's Bench Divisional Court. 
 The effective full-time strength of the Civil Division was thus the Master of the Rolls and 21 Lords Justices. 
 There was undoubtedly a case for a small increase in numbers for the benefit of both divisions of the court. 
 Courtrooms The lack of sufficient courtrooms had been a continuing problem, but should be resolved when the new courts in the Thomas More Building came into use in January 1990. 
 Long vacation sittings The court sat in various strengths in the first half of August and the second half of September with judges available for truly urgent matters during the remainder of the vacation. 
 The future It was peculiarly difficult to predict future trends at the present time when it was anticipated that there would be a major re-distribution of work in the trial courts in consequence of legislation to give effect to the recommendations of the Civil Justice Review. 
 All that could be said was that the judges and staff of the court would continue to do all in their power to reduce costs and lead times in the disposal of appellant business. 
 The biggest single contribution in the success of those efforts would probably be a major extension in the requirement for leave to appeal. 
 During the coming year it was intended to undertake research designed, if possible, to show what would be the effect of any such change. 
 Law Update: City beckons dons 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correpondent 
 SALARIES for university law teachers have slipped so badly and professional salaries risen so dramatically that experienced staff are being lost at an alarming rate, the Committee of Heads of University Law Schools reported this week. 
 From 1984-88, 35 university law departments lost 127 staff, including nine professors, representing around a quarter of the total number of posts, while recruitment has become increasingly difficult, with some commercial law posts being left vacant because no suitable candidates can be found. 
 An aspiring university teacher appointed in his early 20s is likely to earn at least &pound;4,000 less than an articled clerk in a City solicitors' firm. 
 &bquo;His former students will within a few years of graduation be earning a salary twice that of his,&equo; the report says. 
 &bquo;If the financial rewards are perceived to be grossly unfair and inadequate - and they are &mdash; we shall simply not have the staff to sustain the quality of legal education and research,&equo; it warns. 
 A Guardian student survey published this week confirms the university law schools' worst fears. 
 Earning money was rated more highly by students wanting to work in legal services than by the average student and London is selected by 59 per cent of them as the region they would most like to work in. 
 Law Update: Driven off the road 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correpondent 
 CONTRARY to popular belief, a &pound;1m damages award is not over generous when a young person suffers severe brain damage in a road accident. 
 But in the wake of scare stories about so-called &bquo;defensive&equo; medicine comes a new twist: defensive driving, Action for Victims of Medical Accidents reports in its latest newsletter. 
 Questioned about high damages awards following motor accidents, Ivor Carr, Secretary of the British Motorists Association, said there were moves afoot to increase car insurance premiums by 1,000 per cent and this would encourage motorists to indulge in defensive driving to keep premiums down. 
 This might be thought to be a good thing. 
 Not so, says Mr Carr. 
 Many drivers were thinking twice about carrying out risky manoeuvres such as doing 90 miles an hour down the motorway even though such speeds benefited society in speeding up access to distant parts. 
 He fears motorists are no longer held in high esteem and it was time the Government took steps to limit the amount of damages payable after a traffic accident, otherwise there would soon be no motorists left. 
 Law Update: In court: who's suing whom 
 By COLIN BROWN, Political Correpondent 
 THE Sunday Correspondent has received its first brace of libel writs, with one from Emma Samms over &bquo;Fresh evidence widens Eagle Trust scandal&equo; in the 1 October edition and another from Jonathan Maxwell Wylie Samuelson, who claims he was libelled in the same article and also in one headed &bquo;Payments to Samuelson Jnr&equo; in the 17 September issue. 
 Rock musician Roy Harper began a libel action against Emap Metro Ltd trading as &bquo;Q&equo; magazine, following an article in the July 1989 issue which alleged he snorted cocaine on stage. 
 Harry Longmuir is suing Derek Jameson, National Magazine Co Ltd and Penguin Books Ltd for libel contained in Mr Jameson's book, &bquo;Touched by Angels&equo;. 
 Cricketer Rodney Ontong started an action for personal injuries against the Glamorgan County Cricket Club and others following an accident on 19 August 1988. 
 Reliance Security Services Ltd is being sued by biotechnology manufacturers APV Holdings plc. 
 The writ alleges that on the night of 26/7 February 1987 Sean Harris, a night security guard employed by Reliance, set fire to the company's premises at the Manor Royal Industrial Estate, Croydon, causing damage estimated at &pound;460,000. 
 Mr Harris was ordered to be detained under the Mental Health Act by Croydon Crown Court on 28 April last year. 
 Law: Crucial battle for the high moral ground: As Parliament prepares to debate embryo research, Simon Lee says the time has come to approach the issues more responsibly 
 By SIMON LEE 
 AFTER a five-year delay, the Government is finally bringing forward for legislation the 1984 Warnock Report's agenda on human embryo experimentation. 
 The coming parliamentary session will provide a momentous opportunity for public debate on a matter of deep moral significance. 
 The debate will centre on alternative clauses: one outlawing all experiments on embryos from the moment of conception, the other (the Warnock majority's view) allowing them for the first 14 days. 
 The Bill will be a special one in that the political parties are allowing their members in both Houses a free vote because the issue is deemed to be one of conscience. 
 But the likelihood is that bad arguments will dominate the discussions. 
 On all known form, campaigners, opinion-formers and politicians themselves will engage in polarising rhetoric rather than genuine debate, particularly since amendments by pro-life campaigners will seek to yoke the issue of abortion to the question of embryo experimentation. 
 What a beneficial change it would be if instead it was acknowledged that these issues present tragic choices between compelling arguments which are held on both sides in good faith. 
 There are five bad lines of approach which should be banished from the debate &mdash; and from all discussions of law and morals. 
 The first line of attack is often name-calling: &bquo;You would say that, wouldn't you, because you're a Catholic/a man/fertile/infertile/a doctor/a research scientist&equo;. 
 A second bad approach is seeking to win the debate by definitions. 
 On the one hand, there are scientists who are only too willing to call a spade a pre-spade. 
 The term pre-embryo, for example, is now used by some researchers. 
 Its attracts support for the Warnock majority proposal by implying that the pre-14 day embryo has an inferior moral worth to the post-14 day embryo. 
 These embryologists, who do not call themselves pre-embryologists, never used that before the Warnock committee drew that line. 
 All language is morally loaded (one campaigner's unborn child is another's clump of cells) but those who would trick the public by the term pre-embryo should be prepared to concentrate on the moral status of the early embryo, not on dreaming up a new vocabulary. 
 On the other side we hear the accusation that scientists are &bquo;playing God&equo;. 
 But what exactly does this mean? 
 This is a linguistic smoke-screen which obscures an absence of reasoning. 
 Surely it is not the scientists who are guilty of hubris here but their accusers, in implying that humans could play God. 
 A third approach is to pray in aid the so-called slippery slope. 
 Pro-lifers will claim that if we allow experiments up to 14 days, then next year it will be a month, then three months. 
 Meanwhile, pro-choicers argue that if we restrict abortion to 18 weeks, then next year it will be 15, then 12. 
 The reality is that it is extraordinarily difficult to get any change in these kinds of laws &mdash; as the last 30 years of procedural mugging by both sides shows in relation to abortion, and the five-year gestation period of this Bill shows with regard to experimenting. 
 Too often we are faced with clamouring up the slippery slopes to the law more than sliding down them. 
 We have to accept that the reality is that we are always already on the slope, holding a position. 
 A fourth bad approach is to claim that the law cannot stop research or whatever is under discussion, so why try? 
 This is usually expressed in terms of pushing an activity underground (eg pornography) or into the backstreets (eg abortion) or abroad (eg experiments on embryos). 
 But the law does not stop all murder, yet most of us are grateful that it tries. 
 A fifth mistaken approach is the facile assertion that opponents are being inconsistent. 
 There are two lines of rebuttal. 
 One is to say that there are subtle differences which explain alleged inconsistencies, as for example between banning experiments altogether or after 14 days yet allowing later abortions. 
 Some people believe that the different intentions of the experimenter and the abortionist, or the different location of the embryo in a petri dish or in a woman's womb, are morally relevant factors. 
 It behoves the sceptics among us to listen and argue rather than to whoop with delight at the superficial difficulties. 
 The other plausible strategy is to admit an inconsistency but to accept that the law should not necessarily be consistent across the range of tragic choices. 
 Indeed, the only way in which a society can come to terms with its conflicting values is to prefer one value in some circumstances and another in different conditions. 
 It is difficult enough for an individual to be consistent, let alone a society. 
 Are all pro-lifers anti-capital punishment, anti-nuclear weapons and anti-cars? 
 Supposing that we did turn away from the cheap arguments, where could we find a better way? 
 Sadly, the Warnock majority is confused as to its basic philosophical argument, condemning utilitarianism in its foreword but relying on it in justifying its crucial recommendation to allow experiments up to 14 days, only to reject it again in opposing the routine testing of drugs on human embryos at any stage from conception. 
 The Government has wisely allowed legislators to choose between this approach and one of the Warnock minority alternatives. 
 But how should we decide between them? 
 Help is at hand in the more constructive approach of the Glover Report on Fertility and the Family, compiled for the European Commission and now published by Fourth Estate. 
 Chaired by the distinguished philosopher Jonathan Glover, a small committee of experts recognised that the issue is a classic test of our deepest moral views. 
 What matters is not just what Parliament decides but how it decides. 
 In what is heralded as a vote of conscience, any conscience ought to be deeply troubled by the agonising choice between respecting human embryos from their earliest moments and responding to the plight of infertile couples. 
 The issue represents the ultimate test &mdash; and perhaps the convergence &mdash; of two opposing moral theories. 
 Recognition of that and an agreement to forego the linguistic tricks and the cheap jibes would help convince all sides that their arguments have been listened to with respect. 
 It would also help convince them that politicians have decided not on the basis of the best orchestrated campaign but by seeking to occupy the high moral ground, wherever it might be found. 
 Law: A bad system for tackling hackers: Proposals to curb computer crime may have the opposite effect, argues Mary Fagan 
 By MARY FAGAN 
 A REPORT by the Law Commission on computer misuse, published this week, angered those who believe that hacking for fun should not be outlawed but was treated as a triumph by lobbyists for anti-hacking laws. 
 Nicholas Ridley added to the general glee by saying the Government was in favour of legislation. 
 But few believe the findings of the Law Commission, or government action, will prevent either hacking or computer-related crime. 
 Indeed, there is a strong argument that stretching the long arm of the law to the &bquo;innocent&equo; hacker could escalate rather than curb serious crime. 
 Emma Nicholson's Private Member's Bill against hackers, which failed to make the grade in the last session of Parliament, required anyone who entered a computer to his or anyone else's advantage, or to another's prejudice, to be charged with a serious offence, with a maximum penalty of 10 years. 
 The Law Commission has been much more exact in specifying intent to commit serious crime as a necessary ingredient for one of the two more serious offences it proposes. 
 It leaves less to the discretion of the court and has decided on a maximum sentence of just five years. 
 It has also elegantly solved the problems surrounding theft with the aid of a computer. 
 This was already illegal, but under the new proposals, potential culprits do not have to have actually stolen anything. 
 The commission has also thrown out the idea, put forward by some industrialists and businessmen, that special provision is needed for computer fraud. 
 Most such attempts, it concluded, are actually perpetrated by authorised users, and can usually be covered by existing law. 
 But there are areas of fraud which still need to be tackled, such as the complicated matter of deceiving a machine. 
 Under the Theft Acts, it is not possible to deceive a machine ('hole in the wall' banks and automated machinery as well as computers). 
 Of more urgent concern is the international dimension. 
 Modern technology makes moving funds around the world all too easy. 
 The Law Commission pointed out in a report in April that the use of computers has greatly facilitated the ability to plan and implement in one country a fraud that has its deleterious effect in another. 
 It believes that unless urgent action is taken, on this front, law enforcement agencies will be deprived of a potentially powerful weapon against international crime. 
 According to Peter Sommer, a computer forensics expert, the commission has done a good job in proposing new legislation which is workable and fits well with other parts of the law. 
 But the report fails to live up to expectations in looking at how new legislation will be enforced. 
 He believes there are serious gaps, such as the limitations on using computer information (audit trails and logs for example) as admissible evidence in court. 
 Mr Sommer also believes the basic offence of entering a computer will be virtually unenforceable, partly because of lack of police manpower and partly because arrest warrants for this less serious offence will involve applying to a magistrate. 
 &bquo;This is &bquo;gesture legislation&equo; &mdash; a statute that says we do not approve &mdash; but without any real means of enforcement,&equo; he says. 
 It appears to be the commission's way of making clear that it sees a huge chasm between recreational hacking and hacking for more sinister purposes. 
 Whether or not this is true, other computer pundits warn that fear of enforcement will drive computer hackers underground. 
 Alistair Kelman, a barrister, believes this will have two nasty effects: it will prevent &bquo;innocent hackers&equo; from informing authorities about lax security or about real computer criminals; and it could drive those who do commit a basic offence into the hands of hardened criminals. 
 The evidence from abroad is that outlawing hacking has not stopped it. 
 In the United States, where many states have anti-hacking laws, magazines abound on hacking and how to do it better. 
 Ex-hacker Stephen Gold says he remains &bquo;astounded at the arrogance&equo; of the Law Commission for not drawing on the experience of others. 
 In the US, he asserts, the government has realised that legislation is not enough and has set up the Computer Expert Resource Team. 
 This examines hacking and computer crime cases simply to gain experience and hopefully prevent future violations. 
 But it is commonly agreed among those involved in the computer misuse debate that the Law Commission proposals will make it easier to prosecute those who do mean to do wrong using hacking skills. 
 Prosecution itself will not necessarily remedy losses incurred or damage done. 
 The stumbling block which remains is security within companies. 
 The CBI rejects warnings that companies will hide behind the new anti-hacking laws, rather than make efforts to keep intruders out in the first place. 
 According to Alistair Kelman, however, many companies do not even comply with the Companies Act by keeping detailed records of what goes on in their computer systems. 
 The commission's underlying reasons for favouring strong action on hacking stem from the losses and costs incurred by computer systems owners, the possibility of crime and general unwillingness by the public to invest in computer systems. 
 The onus must now be on the industry to provide more secure machines and on users to make sure that their own security procedures (including the simple step of locking office doors) is unimpeachable. 
 In spite of the risks, the challenge for hackers remains. 
 They might fade into the background, but they are unlikely to go away. 
 Law: Giving the lie to an old-fashioned hunch: Marcus Stone on how to tell truth from fiction 
 By MARCUS STONE 
 CAN YOU, just by looking into someone's eyes, know whether the speaker is telling the truth? 
 As a juror, would you find that a defendant had committed a serious crime on such a basis? 
 If you can, with confidence and accuracy, you have a faculty which psychology has yet to discover. 
 Research supports the conclusion that there are no observable signs of lying, only signs of anxiety. 
 Witnesses may be anxious for reasons other than lying. 
 In this respect psychology has rendered a service to the courts by undermining the traditional belief in the demeanour of witnesses as a guide to their veracity. 
 In a proper approach to the evaluation of evidence, three questions arise. 
 The first is &bquo;Do I trust this witness?&equo; 
 Such trust or distrust can only be based on an inference from personal facts about the witness and his circumstances. 
 Character, personality and motives are to the forefront. 
 Witnesses may not be lying, or be prepared to lie, just because they desire a particular outcome. 
 In considering the personal aspects of a witness, courts should always bear in mind the unreliability of subjective impressions and should base their judgments on these as little as possible. 
 The second main question then follows &mdash; &bquo;Is the evidence reasonable?&equo; 
 This is an objective inquiry and mainly a matter of assessing the effect of inconsistency or improbability in the evidence, which has usually been exposed by cross-examination. 
 Here, inconsistency refers to conflicts within the evidence of one or more witnesses who speak to the same version of the facts. 
 Improbability is tested by reference to one's experience of life. 
 The third question is &bquo;How does this evidence fit into the rest of it?&equo; 
 To reach conclusions on any part of the evidence in isolation is dangerous. 
 The assessment is like assembling a jigsaw into which pieces fit with some inevitability. 
 Within this context, whether witnesses are lying can usually be decided without difficulty. 
 A crucial factor is that one witness's evidence, though plausible, may be rejected because it is contradicted by another witness whose evidence is accepted as being beyond doubt. 
 This is typical of the adversarial system &mdash; a total approach in which truth emerges from conflict. 
 The emphasis is on objective analysis of evidence rather than on a subjective impression of any single witness. 
 This differs radically from the popular image of penetrating falsehood by perception of the liar. 
 Experience in court shows how rare this is. 
 If it were normal, the world might be a different place. 
 INTERVIEW / Consuming passions: Alan Howard talks to Sheila Johnston about his role in Greenaway's The Cook, the Thief, his Wife and her Lover 
 By SHEILA JOHNSTON 
 It is not every day that an actor gets eaten in a movie. 
 In Peter Greena way's The Cook, the Thief, his Wife and her Lover, Alan Howard, as the lover, passes through a restaurant, a kitchen, a cold store and a lorry full of putrifying flesh; eventually (the cuckolded Thief, played by Michael Gambon, having visited a terrible revenge), his naked corpse is served up, finely glazed and garnished, as an unannounced extra item on the menu. 
 It is a meaty role. 
 &bquo;They made a cast of my body, in sections, the torso, then the legs, then the head. 
 It's very weird to see yourself; looking in the mirror is not the same thing as seeing yourself three-dimensionally, which is very, very peculiar,&equo; says Howard, who politely declined the chance to take his effigy home at the end of filming. 
 By some accounts, both his and Gambon's agent found the script pornographic, and audiences at early screenings were repulsed by the brutality (although the film opens today to piquant reviews). 
 &bquo;I was profoundly unnerved when I read the screenplay; quite shaking with fear and disturbance. 
 I suppose, though, that if Titus Andronicus came through the letter-box as a new script, you would be a bit shocked. 
 But the violence, to me, is not arbitrary; it's a manifestation of the Thief as a power for evil. 
 What he does with the power is bound to be upsetting. 
 It is an old-fashioned morality tale in that sense.&equo; 
 To ponder all these points, the four main members of the cast (Howard, Gambon, Helen Mirren and Richard Bohringer) spent a week prior to filming studying the script. 
 &bquo;We tried to fit together the enigmas, of which there were a number. 
 The ambiguities, the secrets, or whatever they are. 
 The story, as a story. 
 A fable. 
 A myth. 
 A fairy-story, even, I used to think. 
 And then this vast restaurant; a temple, really. 
 A kitchen the same size, off which there are small rooms, rather like chapels off a cathedral. 
 A highly, I suppose, formalised world; highly civilised. 
 In which, then, an apparently very simple event takes place.&equo; 
 Howard has a rather formal, almost rhetorical way of speaking, and a deliberate delivery that has been taken for hesitancy, but seems more like the manner of someone who weighs and measures his words. 
 Of the film's religious imagery, he says: &bquo;We talked about the Fifty-First psalm (which is sung by one of the kitchen boys); it doesn't give you many clues, but I was reading it again this morning and it started making more sense. 
 We talked about why the story is set over ten days, which it quite particularly is: ten days of eating, from a Thursday to a Saturday. 
 Why a sacrifice, why the eating of a sacrifice. 
 Well, they're very big things to grapple with, and I don't know that there are any answers. 
 There's simply a number of bloody big questions. 
 But one does have to think about it a bit! 
 &bquo;There will be many people who won't like it, won't like it at all, and will walk out. 
 But you cannot deny Greenaway's craftsmanship, and his intention to put on screen these compound images, using all the arrows in a film-maker's quiver. 
 And it allows us to make out a vision of our own lives and, more importantly, the whole life, the world's life.&equo; 
 Howard's other films have not had quite comparable pretensions: he appeared in The Return of the Musketeers, Oxford Blues and &bquo;just, just&equo; in David Hare's Strapless. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't say they were in the same field,&equo; he says dryly. 
 &bquo;This is the first time I've done anything significant on film. 
 I was holed up forever with the RSC, and so just not available. 
 And perhaps I should have been, because I wanted to do the other as well.&equo; 
 Presently, he is making six TV films based on stories by Frederick Forsyth. 
 But that, he says, is &bquo;another meal, another menu.&equo; 
 FILM / New releases 
 By SHEILA JOHNSTON 
 THE ABYSS This, the biggest and almost certainly best of the current American wave of subterranean movies, nurtures expressly metaphysical intentions: it is, says the producer Gale Anne Hurd, about &bquo;the abyss inside each of us&equo;. 
 It is directed by James Cameron, though, and so primarily a first-rate action picture. 
 The underwater sequences &mdash; which occupy most of the film &mdash; warrant the price of admission alone. 
 But, in the most egregious error of judgement, the film, not content with human interest, ropes in aliens as well, arriving like a deus ex machina from the ocean bed, as though the characters were unable to face their darkest selves without prodding from a benign ET. 
 ASTERIX AND THE BIG FIGHT Asterix, whose village was the last in Gaul to resist the invading Romans, was conceived in the Fifties with, no doubt, the Occupation still fresh in memory. 
 He has proved a durable fellow, though, inspiring 28 comic books to date and six animated features, the latest being Asterix and the Big Fight. 
 Gaul might be divided into three parts, but this film, imperfectly cobbled together from two separate stories, displays no such narrative neatness. 
 Many of the gags expire when extended beyond a comic-strip frame, and few of the clever puns which have secured Asterix an adult following, survive translation. 
 THE COOK, THE THIEF, HIS WIFE AND HER LOVER The most startling feature of Peter Greenaway's new film is its formal visual design: the colour-coding of the different locations, the costumes (by Jean-Paul Gaultier), the constant tracking shots across the extraordinary sets. 
 The plot is a revenge drama &mdash; the film's title is fairly self-explanatory &mdash; and has a hand-me-down Jacobean tragedy feel to it, though he could not be accused of copying the richness of the language. 
 Michael Gambon, who plays the Thief, turns in a resolutely one-dimensional performance. 
 When Greenaway puts his formalism on a back-burner, and calls upon his actors to produce raw feeling &mdash; as with Helen Mirren's speech on the deathbed of her lover &mdash; there is nothing but empty pathos, artificiality in its weak form. 
 Greenaway has said he hates the idea of a shot in a film being only a preposition, linking what went before and after &mdash; but what writer would think of despising a part of speech for performing its indispensible task? 
 DRIVING ME CRAZY &bquo;The biggest mass art project in the history of the world&equo; was how the impresario Andre Heller modestly described his plan to stage Body and Soul, an extravaganza of black song and dance. 
 Nick Broomfield was hired to record the event. 
 It was a nightmare: early on, his budget dropped from dollars l6m to &pound;300,000, and his crew was reduced to two. 
 Driving Me Crazy mercilessly records the squalls, the vibrant performances and the inertia of the production team, who spend most of their time solemnly discussing what black music means to them and jockeying for pole position. 
 Broomfield gets under everyone's feet, but soldiers on and ends up with a revealing, funny film about the petty power plays and outsize egos of showbiz. 
 LOLA Jacques Demy's Lola, made in 1960, continues the little spate of revivals from the heyday of European cinema. 
 It plays with Godard's Une Femme est une Femme, made the following year, both graceful and romantic tributes to the MGM musical comedy, and to their vibrant stars, Anouk Amiee and Anna Karina. 
 NO HOLDS BARRED The title says it all. 
 This is an over-the-top wrestling caper (not previewed to critics) with the engaging Hulk Hogan. 
 SHIRLEY VALENTINE Shirley Valentine is a film version, directed by Lewis Gilbert, of Willy Russell's one-woman show, first performed by, and now starring, Pauline Collins. 
 The story is of ersatz oppression and liberation, oppression by domesticity and chips in suburban Liverpool, liberation by sunshine and retsina on a Greek island holiday. 
 Russell's screenplay is full of announced sympathy for ordinary people's lives, and actual condescension. 
 The ways for women to escape or understand their circumstances are systematically disparaged. 
 Only escapist fantasy is allowed any authenticity. 
 Still, Pauline Collins is genuinely charming, there are some perky one-liners, and if there was an Oscar for Best Crinkly Smile In A Supporting Role, Tom Conti would have it sewn up. 
 YOUNG EINSTEIN This is a mock-heroic biopic dedicated to &bquo;the genius rebel with a clowning sense of humour&equo;. 
 Probably Yahoo Serious, who not only stars in the film, but directed, wrote, produced and edited it too, would not mind the description being applied to himself. 
 It begins as Einstein, the hick son of Tasmanian apple farmers, is prompted by a Newtonian falling fruit to discover gravity only 300 years apres la lettre. 
 The main joke, a cheerily philistine one, is to pitch Australia from the margins of Western thought into its centre. 
 The jokes are very broad (the credits include a &bquo;collapsing dunny specialist&equo;): we're in Life of Brian territory, which may be more congenial here than in America, where the film failed to reproduce its massive success on home turf. 
 FESTIVAL / Stay scared all night: James Rampton highlights two weeks of cinema in Leeds 
 By JAMES RAMPTON 
 THE Leeds International Film Festival opens this evening at 8pm at the Cannon 1, Vicar Lane with Lewis Gilbert's charming version of Willy Russell's play, Shirley Valentine about a repressed Liverpool housewife (the eye-catching Pauline Collins, re-creating her award-winning stage performance) who &bquo;finds herself&equo; on a Greek island in the arms of local barman Tom Conti. 
 One of the other highlights this week is a salute to George Romero (who sent a message of thanks to the organisers urging them to &bquo;Stay Scared&equo;). 
 The tribute will feature a preview of his latest work, Monkeyshines, a characteristically disturbing psychological chiller about a paraplegic taken over by his pet ape, at the Cannon at 8pm tomorrow, and an all-night retrospective of his celebrated exercises in subversive horror, Night Of The Living Dead, Dawn Of The Dead, and Day Of The Dead at the the Hyde Park Picture House, Brudenell Road from 11pm tomorrow. 
 Also of interest are: An Evening With Terry Gilliam, at which the ex-Python will discuss the making of such movies as Brazil and The Adventures Of Baron Munchausen, at 8pm tomorrow at the Hyde Park Picture House; Michael Lehmann's black teen comedy Heathers, with Winona Ryder, on Wednesday at 8pm at the Cannon 2; and Bernard Tavernier's (Round Midnight) post-World War One love story, Life And Nothing But, with Philippe Noiret, at the Hyde Park Picture House at 8pm on Wednesday. 
 The Festival ends on 27 October with Great Balls of Fire, Jim McBride's biopic of Jerry Lee Lewis. 
 The Independent has free tickets to offer for: Shirley Valentine (2 pairs); Monkeyshines (5 pairs); and Life And Nothing But (5 pairs). 
 To claim these, readers should present this page at the Festival Central Box Office at The Civic Theatre, Cookridge St from 10am this morning. 
 First come, first served. 
 For more details, telephone 0532-462453. 
 Day Out: Going for the gut reaction: James Rampton visits an exhibition serving Food For Thought 
 By JAMES RAMPTON 
 WHAT with that handful of hardline Northamptonshire nuns blockading the door to their allegedly infected chicken coop, food is still Flavour of the Month with the media. 
 Which makes it an apposite time for the Science Museum to open a new &pound;1.2m permanent Gallery, Food For Thought, to &bquo;explain the impact of science and technology on today's food&equo;. 
 But, beyond that, it offers a range of attractive historical displays (de rigueur waxworks and &bquo;period&equo; dishes) and &bquo;interactive&equo; exhibits (instructive computer games and button-pushing). 
 The exhibition also provides a boon for &bquo;resting&equo; actors, who play everything from a sausage-machine operator to the discoverer of quick freezing, Clarence (Captain?) 
 Birdseye. 
 The Gallery makes good use of mock-ups: a convincing re-creation of a Futures Market trading floor where big-time foodstuff deals are struck (all braces, bravado and baked beans), or an authentic 1926 Lyons Corner House (graced with a sweetly smiling &bquo;Nippy&equo;). 
 Foodies of all ages can have a go at the laborious old-style methods of wheat-grinding, and see sugar-manufacture and milk-bottling in close-up. 
 (Strict Environmental Health Authority Rules prohibit the use of real sugar and milk.) 
 On-site tasting of foodstuffs is also forbidden, hence an ingenious, John Waters-esque display called Smellerama. 
 This functions like a fairground attraction: pick a number from a red barrel, scratch'n'sniff and guess its origin (apple, roast chicken, aniseed, etc). 
 The exhibits are imaginatively presented. 
 &bquo;Food poisoning&equo;, for instance, shows the effect of the 44,000 cases of the &bquo;runs&equo; reported this year with a cartoon strip depicting bacteria like so many vengeful Smurfs. 
 The display on consumption utilises the age-old trick of piling up an adult's average monthly intake of food (enormous amounts of chocolate) and invites the visitor to burn off excess calories on an &bquo;Energy Bike&equo; (it does, of course, take a depressingly long time to nullify the effect of just one grape). 
 This new Gallery is a welcome contribution to both the British Food and Farming and British Museums Years, and the organisers hope that it will help allay the public's sometimes exaggerated fears about food (they are running a public information service on 01-938 8217 from 10am today). 
 Just one word of warning: don't drink the milk, it's diluted Dettol.. 
 Day Out: Siobhan Dolan and Owen Slot list shows for the scientifically minded 
 By SIOBHAN DOLAN and OWEN SLOT 
 THE SCIENCE MUSEUM Exhibition Rd SW7 (01-938 8000). 
 Various Exhibitions: Food for Thought (permanent) First floor. 
 A comprehensive display of the history of food production. 
 Engineering Futures (to March) Demonstrates the technology behind engineering and its importance in everyday life. 
 1989, The Year Of The Microscope (to Jan) Largest ever collection of working microscopes on public display; the public are invited to bring along their own specimens and look at them through the different microscopes. 
 Apollo 2 (to Dec) Marking the twentieth anniversary of man's first step on the moon; various exhibits, aeronautical clothes, a model of the original launch vehicle and the inevitable piece of moon rock. 
 Housing The Airship (to Dec) Collection of photos and pictures of buildings which housed airships. 
 Launchpad (permanent) Large number of &bquo;hands-on&equo; experiments, which invite visitors' participation. 
 Wellcome Museum Of The History Of Medicine (permanent) Reconstruction of the major events in medical history. 
 History Of Veterinary Medicine (permanent) Gory display of veterinary instruments and anatomical model of a horse. 
 Mon-Sat, 10am-6pm; Sun, 11am-6pm. 
 Adults &pound;2, Concessions &pound;1. 
 ALDERSHOT Royal Army Dental Corps Historical Museum HQ &amp; Central Group RADC, Evelyn Woods Rd, Aldershot, Hampshire (0252-24431 ext. 2782). 
 Examines the history of dentistry within the army. 
 Close encounters with those instruments of torture such as the forceps, and probe (used in the early days for extracting root). 
 An opportunity to view provisions made for toothless conscripts &mdash; a hard rubber solution (vulcanite) was moulded to the gums and porcelain teeth attached. 
 BATH Geology Museum 18 Queen Square, Bath, Avon (0225-428144). 
 The work and collections of 19th-century geologist, Charles Moore. 
 Includes fossils from the Jurassic rocks of North Somerset. 
 Also herbarium and a collection of seashells. 
 BELFAST Ulster Museum Botanic Gardens, Belfast (0232-381251). 
 Includes impressive archaeological treasures dating from first arrival of man in Ireland c. 7000 BC until late 17th century. 
 Dept. of Geology has worldwide collections of minerals and gemstones and over 100,000 fossils plus displays of animals and plants of Ireland, the Origin, Structure and Evolution of Life and The Variety of Life. 
 BOURNEMOUTH Museum Of The Bournemouth Natural Science Society 39 Christchurch Rd, Bournemouth, Dorset (0202-23525). 
 Occupies listed Victorian house and holds a number of notable collections in Egyptology, botany, geology and zoology with special emphasis on butterflies, insects, birds and eggs and a diorama display of New Forest mammals. 
 BRADFORD Colour Museum Perkin House, 82 Grattan Rd, Bradford, West Yorkshire (0274-390955). 
 Located in a former wool warehouse, the museum highlights how we perceive and use colour. 
 Opportunities to experiment with light and colour-interactive displays. 
 Also displays on physics and chemistry of colour, optical illusions. 
 The colour and textiles gallery examines industrial history of coloration industries. 
 Tues-Fri, 2pm-5pm, 10-4pm on Sat. 
 Museum Of The Scott Polar Research Institute Lensfield Rd, Cambridge (0223-336540). 
 Arctic and Antarctic displays with relics from several expeditions. 
 Also Eskimo carvings, a display of scrimshaw, glaciological information on the Poles and Antarctic ornithology. 2.30-4pm. 
 CREETOWN Gem-Rock Museum Chain Road, Creetown, Kirkcudbrightshire (067182-357). 
 Global collection of gems, rocks, minerals and fossils with special displays of fluorescent minerals and Scottish beach agate. 
 DEAL Time Ball Tower Victoria Parade, Deal, Kent (0304-360897). 
 Built in 1821 as one of 17 semaphore towers, it was equipped with a time-ball in 1854 which drops daily at 1pm down a 15 ft-mast on the roof. 
 Displays illustrate the history of maritime communications, from shutter telegraphs, semaphores and time-balls to satellites. 
 EDINBURGH Museum Of Communication James Clerk Maxwell Building, University of Edinburgh (0506-824507). 
 Illustrates the development of communication by electrical means. 
 Exhibits include radio transmitting and receiving equipment. 
 Museum Of The Royal College Of Surgeons Of Edinburgh Nicolson St, Edinburgh (031-556 6206). 
 Charts grisly history of surgery in Edinburgh from 1505 to 1900. 
 Includes pathological specimens. 
 Plus the Menzies Campbell Collection -the most comprehensive dental collection in Europe. 
 INVERNESS Loch Ness Monster Exhibition Loch Ness Centre, Drumnadrochit, Inverness (04562-573). 
 Updated exhibiton with ten computerised audio-visual sections telling the monstrous tale from prehistoric to modern times. 
 Plus ecological background with emphasis on its deep water fauna. 
 MANCHESTER Museum of Science and Engineering Castlefield, Manchester (061-832 2244). 
 Large &bquo;Xperiments!&equo; science centre of &bquo;hands-on&equo; experiments. 
 Also, collection of running Steam Engines, Air and Space gallery, and &bquo;Underground Manchester&equo; with walk-down sewer with real sounds and smells. 
 All week, 10am-5pm. 
 Adults &pound;2, Concessions &pound;1. 
 NOTTINGHAM Green's Mill Museum Belvoir Hill, Sneinton, Nottingham (0602-503635). 
 Home of George Green, mathematical physicist and miller. 
 Visitors can see his windmill in action, and an exhibition of his main areas of experimentation: electricity, magnetism, light and sound. 
 Wed-Sun, 10am-5pm. 
 Free. 
 PADDOCK WOOD Whitbread Hop Farm Beltring, Paddock Wood, Kent (0622-872408). 
 Working farm supplies brewers with a quarter of the hops used. 
 Of the six Victorian oasts, three are now used as museums containing exhibits of rural crafts, hop-growing and processing. 
 Chance to see famous Shire horses which pull the coaches of the Lord Mayor Of London and the Speaker of The House of Commons. 
 SWANSEA Dan-yr-Ogof Showcaves Museum Abercrave, Glyntawe, Upper Swansea Valley, Swansea, West Glamorgan (0689-730284). 
 Comprises three limestone caves (one of which is the longest in Britain) all of which illustrate how they served as homes for both humans and animals: including the Bone cave, rich in archaeological evidence with details of the Flintsone-like inhabitants dating back to the Bronze Age. 
 Includes remains of some 42 skeletons which were found in the caves. 
 10am-5pm; &pound;3.50/ &pound;2.50. 
 Football: Why Robson must discover innovation: Patrick Barclay, Football Correspondent, on England's overriding need for understudies now a place in the Italian sun has been secured 
 By PATRICK BARCLAY, Football Correspondent 
 THE LATE Jock Stein laid down a strategy for the World Cup when he said that a team could wear working clothes to qualify, but needed to find evening dress for the event itself. 
 This has always seemed to make sense, despite the Scots' own tendency to be caught with a wardrobe of empty coat-hangers and crumpled piles, and one's fear on behalf of England is that they are running out of time in which to find a dinner jacket. 
 The boiler-suit stage was completed in Chorzow on Wednesday, when Bobby Robson's team made sure of a place in Italy next summer with a goalless draw, their third in six qualifying matches; having kept a clean sheet in the other three, all won, they are entitled to regard themselves as the most workmanlike team in Europe. 
 And that, of course, goes to the heart of England's next problem. 
 By qualifying, they have changed the criteria. 
 They looked plain ordinary in Poland. 
 For an hour they were outplayed by a recast side whose pace and touch, if not finishing, evoked uncomfortable echoes of England's embarrassments in the European Championship. 
 As Terry Butcher admitted afterwards, Peter Shilton's goalkeeping &bquo;kept us in the World Cup&equo;. 
 Shilton did a sort of Jan Tomaszewski in reverse with the Polish hero of 1973, now an assistant to the national manager, watching in frustration. 
 Five weeks earlier, in Stockholm, the 40-year-old Shilton had also made vital saves. 
 But he cannot be relied upon for ever. 
 Far from resting happily on this team, Robson ought immediately to disrupt it, to set aside his obsession with results, to experiment with players and tactics. 
 And yet, early yesterday morning, when the squad returned to Luton, the indications were that he would keep changes to a minimum for the friendly against Italy at Wembley next month. 
 Loyalty or conservatism? 
 Whatever you call it, Robson's refusal to jettison the bulk of the side that returned from Germany in shame had been vindicated by Wednesday's outcome. 
 He has rebuilt confidence and, on the triumphant journey home, the captain, Bryan Robson, was applauded for thanking him &bquo;for sticking to his principles&equo;. 
 The danger now is of being lulled into a false sense of family security. 
 Football can be a cruel game and the undeniable, unpalatable truth is that Robson's key players are not getting any better than they were two years ago (with the arguable exception of Shilton), and certainly no younger. 
 If the side that did duty this week trots out in the Italian sunshine in June, it will have an average age of 29&frac12;, which is ill-suited to the punishing conditions of a concentrated tournament in midsummer. 
 Each of the last three World Cup-winning sides, two from Argentina and one from Brazil (and, for that matter, the victorious Dutch in the last European Championship), were dominated by men in their mid-twenties. 
 England's projected backbone will be Shilton (40), Butcher (31), Bryan Robson (33) and Peter Beardsley and Gary Lineker (both 29). 
 This is not to suggest that all, or indeed any, should be discarded; if England have to go for maturity and hope for the best, so be it. 
 But they must all at least have plausible understudies, as experienced as possible, by early next year. 
 For Robson to throw away the opportunity to experiment against Italy, the first of seven countries England will meet before the World Cup, is dangerously wasteful. 
 Robson says he intends to assess young players in the B internationals against Italy (the night before the main match) and Yugoslavia. 
 Well, England made a B tour last summer, from which it was deduced that Terry Hurlock might have a full international future. 
 It was disturbing to hear the manager remind questioners of what happened when he made &bquo;sensible&equo; experiments in Saudi Arabia late last year: &bquo;We got a 1-1 draw and a nasty headline.&equo; 
 In the name of Allah, things have come to a pretty pass if the tabloids are influencing England's selection policy. 
 Surely Robson has no need to fear them now. 
 He must start planning for contingencies, which means dropping stalwarts as well as those over whom questions still loom. 
 What, for instance, is the point of playing Shilton against Italy? 
 The sooner Chris Woods, if fit, or David Seaman is brought in, the closer England will be to having an insurance policy should misfortune befall the great keeper, as in the infamous case of Gordon Banks in 1970. 
 In Stockholm, denied Bryan Robson, they discovered that Steve McMahon has genuine potential. 
 But blessings cannot simply be expected to come along in disguise. 
 Has Tony Adams, such a raw youth in Germany, become an adequate challenger to Butcher? 
 Or is Paul Parker a safer bet? 
 Until they play against teams of the quality of Italy and Yugoslavia, we shall not have a clue. 
 Tactically, the worry is that England's 4-4-2 system remains too rigid. 
 The Poles played 3-4-3, with a sweeper, and looked by far the more flexible. 
 Robson tires of pointing out that England always have a spare man, but unfortunately this often turns out to be Gary Stevens, an orthodox full-back, perhaps incorrigibly so. 
 Michael Thomas, a midfielder with experience at right-back, should be tried there. 
 Up front, Steve Bull, who scored on his debut against Scotland, merits a chance, after two more goals for the Under-21s in Poland, to show that his rampaging style can disconcert the best of defences. 
 Tony Dorigo must cease to be a non-playing member of the squad, Paul Gascoigne to be an unsolved riddle. 
 Continuity has served its purpose. 
 It cannot be allowed to drift into complacency. 
 The shot that came back off Shilton's bar in the last minute in Chorzow &mdash; a couple of inches lower, and England might have been on their way out of the World Cup &mdash; was a symbolic warning. 
 May: Rous Cup (dates to be arranged): Scotland (home); a South American country, possibly Paraquay (home). 
 June: Match and date to be arranged (away). 
 Golf: Beck refuses to enter into the spirit 
 By TIM GLOVER WENTWORTH 
 WHAT on earth, you may ask yourselves, was one Aki Ohmachi doing in a tournament which carries the title of the World Matchplay Championship? 
 The answer is that it is a small world, at least in terms of golf in October. 
 Another reason, of course, is that the 29-year-old Ohmachi is Japanese and so is Suntory, the company that sponsors the championship. 
 Its attractive format appeals to the BBC but, more to the point for Suntory, Japanese television shows three hours of play a day. 
 One of Suntory's products is whisky and Japan cannot get enough of the stuff. 
 They estimate an average annual consumption of 15 litres of whisky per head of the adult population. 
 Therefore it is only natural for the sponsors to indulge in a little nepotism and provide its Japanese audience with somebody they can identify with while they are enjoying a nightcap. 
 Unfortunately Ohmachi could not sustain the connection and the rising son went down 8 and 6 on the Burma Road to Chip Beck in the first round yesterday. 
 Beck, unbeaten in the Ryder Cup with 3&frac12; points out of four, is the sole American survivor in what is clearly a non-vintage field for this year's championship. 
 Jose-Maria Olazabal, 23, and Ronan Rafferty, 25, the youngest players in the championship, put out Scott Hoch and Mike Reid. 
 Olazabal, despite feeling like death warmed up, defeated Hoch, the runner-up in the Masters, 4 and 2 in a match in which the Spaniard was never headed. 
 Olazabal, unshaven, was suffering from a headache and fever and had had a sleepless night. 
 &bquo;What I need is a nice girl,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Well it's Woosie tomorrow,&equo; said the press officer with immaculate timing. 
 The unlucky loser was Reid but then that's been the story of his season. 
 Reid, who lost winning positions on the final day in the Masters and the US PGA, was beaten 3 and 2 and when he bowed out on the 34th green he was nine under par for the day. 
 Rafferty, however, was 12 under. 
 The Northern Irishman, second in the Order of Merit to Olazabal, went round in 66 to Reid's 67 in the morning and when the American, at the 22nd hole, had his eighth birdie, Rafferty's response was an eagle three. 
 He had eagled the same hole earlier. 
 Rafferty, who had reached the turn in 33 first time round, went out in 32 in the afternoon by which stage he was two up. 
 Reid was faultless but Rafferty was better. 
 In the quarter-finals today Rafferty plays the holder Sandy Lyle; Olazabal meets Ian Woosnam; Beck threatens Seve Ballesteros and David Frost will do the same to Nick Faldo. 
 Beck, a physical fitness fanatic, believes he has the confidence and the form to go all the way in this championship. 
 A graduate in journalism from North Carolina, he is 33 but says we have not yet seen the best of Beck. 
 &bquo;I'm looking forward to my future,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I hope Seve is at his best. 
 Beating him would be a feather in my cap.&equo; 
 His cap was a black and white check to go with black and white shoes and a black and white striped shirt. 
 Ballesteros should provide some badly needed colour, not least for the television sets of the patrons in Japan. 
 Rugby Union: Wasps shuffle pack 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 WASPS come to attention in the league tomorrow by calling for the old guard in an effort to repulse Gloucester's rugged raiders at Sudbury. 
 For the first time this season, Paul Rendall and Jeff Probyn are paired together in the front row in a switch of policy aimed at tightening up the pack. 
 Wasps are prepared to sacrifice the mobility which Gary Holmes and Paddy Dunston provided when Rendall and Probyn, the England props, made a delayed start to the season after taking part in the World XV tour to South Africa. 
 Having begun their Courage First Division programme with a 29-12 home win over Leicester, Wasps then lost direction and the match when they took on Harlequins at The Stoop. 
 On the same day, Gloucester stole a march by beating the champions, Bath, at Kingsholm in a fierce encounter during which another England prop, Bath's Gareth Chilcott, was sent off for punching. 
 Meanwhile, news concerning Mike Teague &mdash; the Gloucester back row forward who in South Africa aggravated a shoulder injury which had caused him problems during the Lions tour of Australia &mdash; is not brilliant. 
 Although Teague has resumed light training, he looks certain to miss England's match against Fiji on 4 November and has told his club that he does not expect to be fit until the middle of next month. 
 England are still awaiting news on another back-row man with shoulder problems &mdash; Leicester's No. 8, Dean Richards, who will not be making this weekend's away day to Orrell, whose coach, Des Seabrook, is in hospital recovering from a mild heart attack. 
 The Tigers, who will also be minus the magic of the holidaying Les Cusworth, are relieved to hear that their England centre, Paul Dodge, and the England B flanker, John Wells, have recovered from hamstring injuries in time for the trip. 
 Dodge and Wells return in place of Alan Warwood and Adey Marriott while Jez Harris, who also played in last weekend's hefty win over Coventry when Cusworth kicked his heels on the bench, remains at stand-off. 
 In the second row, Malcolm Foulkes-Arnold loses his place to Alex Gissing, a 21-year-old, 6ft 5in former England Colt. 
 Vince Cannon, a long-serving England squad member, has decided to retire after 438 games for Northampton. 
 Cannon, 39, had intended to play on for one more season, but he has a back injury that may require surgery. 
 Cricket: Boycott set to reopen county strife 
 By DEREK HODGSON 
 GEOFFREY BOYCOTT signalled the opening of a new phase in Yorkshire's internecine strife when he called a press conference yesterday morning to criticise the club's general committee. 
 Stung by comments about his walk-out from the committee meeting at Headingley on Tuesday, the 49-year-old former England opener and member for Wakefield, fired back in a modern hotel on the Wakefield side of the M1 in front of a local television crew, a radio reporter and five Yorkshire-based reporters. 
 &bquo;I left in exasperation,&equo; he declared. 
 Angered by suggestions that his conduct was inexplicable and that he had not offered any constructive criticism during a 3&frac12; hour inquest into Yorkshire's dismal summer, Boycott claimed that the cricket sub-committee would not accept any form of responsibility: &bquo;They have been in charge for five of the last six years but will not agree that they are at least partly to blame for the fact that Yorkshire cricket is in a mess.&equo; 
 He said he could not serve on that sub-committeee (consisting of Brian Close, Bob Appleyard, Phil Sharpe, Bryan Stott, Tony Woodhouse) &bquo;when I do not see eye to eye with them on any subject&equo;. 
 He also attacked Brian Walsh, the chairman, whom he called &bquo;a clever dick&equo;, a somewhat foolhardy reference to a Queen's Counsel. 
 &bquo;The hierarchy are now under fire because of the team's performance and are seeking to deflect criticism by blaming me. 
 It won't work. 
 I won't be the whipping boy,&equo; Boycott said. 
 Boycott has called a meeting of his own Wakefield members for next Tuesday and seems set on leading a campaign to unseat the majority of the committee, something he managed once before, in January 1984. 
 Whether he will be as successful again is open to doubt, because his own playing career was then an issue and he had substantial sympathy backing both inside and outside the committee and membership. 
 At present, he cannot count on more than five or six votes in the 23-strong general committee, while outside his once well-organised Reform Group/Members' 84 Group has disbanded. 
 Peter Briggs, who proved to be an astute campaign manager, has resigned his membership. 
 Five years ago, two of Boycott's supporters were Walsh and the present public relations chairman, Sid Fielden, both now among his strongest critics. 
 But while Yorkshire fail on the field there will always be discontent, and Boycott, after a period in which he appeared to have submerged himself in a media career, may head the opposition once more. 
 If he succeeds in stirring up tabloid backing again with &bquo;the people's champion against the gin-and-tonic brigade&equo;, the theme of 1984, then Yorkshire are in for another incendiary winter. 
 Rugby Union: Fox set fair for Cardiff 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 THE WELSH used to be a hindrance rather than a help to the All Blacks but, by giving Grant Fox permission to practise his goalkicking at the Arms Park prior to tomorrow's game with Cardiff, they might be contributing to their own downfall. 
 Like so many in the New Zealand tour party, Fox has never experienced the intimidating atmosphere generated at the great sporting shrine and may have taken time to slip into the groove. 
 After today's practice session, that seems unlikely. 
 &bquo;It's good to get your bearings and get a feel of the atmosphere and conditions of a ground before you play on it. 
 I generally ask to have a few kicks before a big game,&equo; Fox said. 
 &bquo;I've already had a brief look at the Arms Park and it seems a great ground.&equo; 
 The attention to detail displayed by Fox reveals much about New Zealand's attitude to the game, nothing being left to chance. 
 Not content with spending an extra half hour after training running through his technique yesterday, when two wayward kicks brought immediate self-rebuke, the 26-year-old Aucklander aims to put in a further 50 or 60 shots in his Arms Park warm-up. 
 In Fox's case, practice obviously goes a long way to making perfect. 
 He is the quickest man in Test rugby to reach 100, 200 and 300 points. 
 He has now scored 302 in 18 internationals, has an average of 17.5 per game since becoming the No. 1 kicker, and goes into tomorrow's game having stretched his top-grade tally to 2,533 in 188 matches. 
 Cycling: Yates disputes drug test 
 By ROBERT COLE 
 SEAN YATES, the Briton who won this year's Tour of Belgium, tested positive for steroids during the race, his lawyer said yesterday. 
 A Belgian cycling union official confirmed that an unnamed rider had tested positive and said that if it were Yates, he would receive a 10-minute penalty that would lose him the race. 
 Yates could also be fined 3,000 Swiss francs (&pound;1,140) and banned from competition for three months, though the ban would automatically be suspended. 
 Yates's lawyer, Philippe Grollet, said the rider, from Forest Row, Sussex, tested positive for nostestosteron, a proscribed muscle-building substance, after the first part of the split first stage of the tour on 9 August. 
 But he said Yates denied taking steroids and that there had been irregularities in the testing procedures. 
 Grollet said Yates was informed of the test result on 6 September, a delay of several weeks, instead of the eight-day delay provided for under the rules of the International Cycling Union. 
 Yates was also tested in each of the next five days of the Tour of Belgium as standings leader and each time tested negative. 
 &bquo;If he had taken that product, he would also have tested positive those other days as well,&equo; Grollet said. 
 Grollet said a laboratory in Utrecht had carried out a second test on 14 September and that, too, had been positive. 
 But the laboratory's report pointed out that the sample flask did not bear Yates's signature, casting doubt on its authenticity. 
 &bquo;That's even more bizarre, which makes us believe there has been a mix-up of flasks,&equo; Grollet said. 
 &bquo;We are now examining a few contradictions and will decide on the matter next week,&equo; a spokesman for the Belgian cycling union said. 
 It was disclosed a week ago that the Frenchman Laurent Fignon had failed a test after a race in The Netherlands last month. 
 He later described his three-month suspension as too lenient. 
 Scott's hard sell in the theatre of sport: Neil Wilson on the recruiting officer whose daunting mission is to win the Olympics for Manchester 
 By NEIL WILSON 
 MARTIN EDWARDS has not been the only man in Manchester trying to sell something of a sporting nature. 
 In the heart of the city, Bob Scott is further still from closing a deal. 
 By comparison, Edwards's task was child's play. 
 Selling Old Trafford to a first-time buyer on a 100 per cent mortgage would be easier than selling Manchester for the 1996 Olympics. 
 &bquo;Preposterous is a word I've heard used,&equo; Scott admits. 
 But tomorrow the British Olympic Association holds its annual meeting in Manchester, the first time in its 85 years that the meeting has taken place outside London, and the reason is that Scott asked. 
 &bquo;Simple as that,&equo; he says. 
 Scott, a 45-year-old theatrical impresario, is the sort of man who does not ask why, but only why not. 
 When he heard a breakfast-time radio report that the Government thought the Olympics should return to Britain, he recruited an eminent bid committee within two hours and had the news splashed in that day's first edition of the Manchester Evening News. 
 Private enterprise-led, of course, as the Government would have wished. 
 Five years later, and after an initial &bquo;thrashing&equo; by Birmingham for the British nomination, the bid is more substantial than a local headline, &pound;2 million more, the Duke of Westminster and a dozen of Britain's blue-chip companies and corporations each persuaded by Scott's vision of a North-west renaissance to dip into their accounts for at least &pound;100,000. 
 Mancunians will pay next to nothing, which is only right since they were not consulted. 
 Scott expects &bquo;pockets of horror&equo; among those who hate sport or would do not relish a stadium at the foot of the garden, but he senses excitement generally. 
 &bquo;It's a popular subject.&equo; 
 There is powerful support, too, from the Princess Royal, the BOA's president, &bquo;not your traditional Royal patron but a formidable worker for the cause&equo;. 
 She will be in the North-west for the next three days, for the annual meeting, briefings on Manchester's bid, a Royal Gala evening at one of his theatres and an Olympic bid dinner in Liverpool. 
 She then gives Scott and his team a lift to a congress in Budapest in the early hours of Tuesday in an aircraft of the Queen's Flight for further lobbying of her fellow International Olympic Committee members. 
 Scott sees her as Manchester's star turn. 
 Bobby Charlton, many foreigners' first two words of English, is the other. 
 &bquo;Thirty-nine IOC members give football as their first interest,&equo; Scott reveals. 
 He and Charlton plan a South American tour soon. 
 But behind it all is Scott, who is self-appointed and unsalaried producer, director and spokesman for an enterprise that never occured to British sport itself. 
 That remains a mystery to him. 
 The potential benefits in facilities alone should have been obvious to all, he thinks. 
 &bquo;When I first became involved, getting the Olympics to Britain wasn't on anybody's agenda within sport, not the Minister's, not the Sports Council's, not the BOA's or any sports body.&equo; 
 Even now, a year before the deciding vote, he does not believe that sport here understands what getting the Games would mean. 
 &bquo;They are geared to the narrow dimensions of their own sports. 
 They don't appreciate how massively they will be affected.&equo; 
 But in that, he says, Britain is not alone. 
 He detects tensions everywhere between national Olympic committees and their candidate cities, &bquo;certainly within the US and Australian candidacies, and within Britain's&equo;. 
 Those who briefed him on the successful Los Angeles bid &mdash; Manchester retains the same American consultants &mdash; reported similar problems. 
 Sports people have learned their place, and the limitations on them. 
 The entrepreneurial types who lead Olympic bids know none. 
 &bquo;My difficulty is that I haven't spent 40 years as an umpire or whatever, and there is a tension between people like that and those like me. 
 It's not uncreative. 
 They are not resistant. 
 But I'm having to learn to live with it.&equo; 
 He finds nothing perverse about a man of the arts fighting sport's corner. 
 &bquo;They are terribly similar. 
 I get as big a kick out of watching Seb on the top curve as I do watching a ballet dancer. 
 It's art.&equo; 
 Indeed he sees little place for &bquo;so-called culture&equo; surrounding an Olympics. 
 &bquo;If you have spent a day at the stadium, the one thing you don't need is to spend an evening at the theatre. 
 You've had your theatre for the day.&equo; 
 Keeping a foot in both camps is made easier because the bid committee's offices are on the same floor as his own at Manchester Theatres Ltd. 
 &bquo;The only way I could organise my time,&equo; he explains. 
 And the leases are not short. 
 If the bid fails next year, he will back again, and again, however long it takes. 
 &bquo;I have this wonderful warm glow that we are going to get it. 
 I don't think it will be 1996 but we might and I'll fight that corner. 
 My certainty is longer term. 
 Just so long as we maintain the candidacy.&equo; 
 Windsurfing event in the Hebrides 
 By NEIL WILSON 
 The old man and the sea: more than 50 windsurfers in the Pripps Energy Tiree Wave Classic in the Hebrides hold the attention of an island crofter. 
 Britain's leading wave-jumping event, in its fourth year, is staged in Tiree because the swells most resemble Hawaii's. 
 The event, which awards points for style, degree of difficulty and bravery, reaches its acrobatic climax todayPhotograph: Keith Dobney  
 Rugby Union: How club colours the issue 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 EVERYONE I have spoken to about the New Zealand tour of Wales agrees that, if they are going to be beaten by anyone, it will be by one of the clubs rather than by the national side. 
 However, I should not care to put any money on even a single defeat. 
 The apparent paradox is that, on the evidence provided by such teams as Neath and Llanelli, the clubs individually are more powerful than the country collectively. 
 I write that the paradox is apparent because there have been signs of the same phenomenon in England over the past few seasons &mdash; and also because it is not at all surprising when you come to think about it. 
 Players will tend to perform better when they are among friends than when they are placed in unfamiliar surroundings. 
 This remains so despite regular attendance at squad sessions and strenuous visits to sunny Portugal. 
 There have been only a few exceptions to this general rule. 
 Thus there were complaints about Jonathan Davies &bquo;not trying&equo; when he was playing for Llanelli (and previously for Neath) as he tried when he was playing for Wales. 
 On the whole, however, players were &mdash; and still are &mdash; happier turning out for their clubs. 
 This is not only a matter of familiarity but of the connected conditions of relaxation and self-confidence. 
 Rob Andrew has, as he himself admits, only recently begun to display his Wasps form for England &mdash; and this after 26 caps, an English record in the stand-off half position. 
 Les Cusworth was never as comfortable in a white jersey as he was in Leicester's Christmas-tree outfit. 
 Dusty Hare, true, played as well for England as he did for his club, and deserved to win even more than his 25 caps. 
 Bath players of recent years have never appeared as convincing for England as they regularly do for Bath; while if they are part of one of those curious South-West sides their form goes down yet another notch. 
 Indeed, the experiences of the South-West Division would seem to argue against the thesis of this column: that national selectors, in England as much as in Wales, should build their teams more around clubs and less around people. 
 The combination of Bath, Bristol and Gloucester does not succeed because they are an awkward lot down that way. 
 In France it has long been the practice to build the national side round successful clubs. 
 Or it used to be so. 
 One of the many adverse criticisms of Albert Ferrasse and Jacques Fouroux is that, for involved reasons of French rugby politics, they have ostracised the Toulouse club together with such players as Denis Charvet and Eric Bonneval, who would walk on merit into any northern hemisphere XV. 
 Again, the Lions combination which won the series against Australia was &mdash; despite differences in the forwards' techniques &mdash; essentially England and Scotland plus Robert Jones. 
 He, however, is becoming increasingly petulant and argumentative, playing scrum-half like a thwarted 15-year-old on the netball court. 
 In a pique against Harlequins last Saturday he flung the ball at the opposition tighthead prop and was lucky not to be sent off. 
 Admittedly the referee was a foolish fellow who kept re-penalising Swansea for failing to retreat 10 yards when he did not give them the remotest chance to do so. 
 In such circumstances, it was inevitable that Swansea tempers became ragged at the edges. 
 I did not see Richard Langhorn being kicked by Ian Davies. 
 But it is humbug for the Harlequins to make a great song and dance about it &mdash; and for Jamie Salmon to imply that the New Zealanders never kick anyone. 
 Their whole game depends on getting the man on the ground out of the way, if necessary with the boot, if he is so unfortunate as to be between them and the ball. 
 Ian and Stuart Davies and Alan Reynolds form an impressive back row who will clearly not be cowed when the men in black arrive at St Helens. 
 But I shall not be putting any money on the men in white. 
 I think Llanelli are the most likely to pull it off. 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Snooker 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Sailing 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 ALEXEI GRYSHENKO, the Soviet yachtsman whose body was found hanging from a tree in Uruguay's Punta del Este on Wednesday, committed suicide, Tass news agency said yesterday. 
 Gryshenko, co-skipper of the yacht Fazisi, which finished sixth in the first leg of the Whitbread Round the World race, left a note to his wife and parents. 
 Tass described Gryshenko as &bquo;an introvert, a reserved man who spoke little.&equo; 
 Fazisi will continue in the Whitbread race. 
 Sport in Short: Rugby League 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 SHAUN EDWARDS, the Great Britain international, was found not guilty at a meeting of the Rugby League's disciplinary committee in Leeds tonight, following his sending-off during Wigan's Lancashire Cup semi-final defeat by Oldham last week. 
 Sport in Short: Rallying 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Motor Racing 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Judo 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Ice Hockey 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Hockey 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Football 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Equestrianism 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Cycling 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 THE WOMEN'S Tour de France, traditionally held in July at the same time as the men's race, will be held in the first two weeks of September from next year. 
 Sport in Short: Cricket 
 Sport Page 31 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 DUKE McKENZIE, Britain's former world flyweight champion, beat the American, David Moreno, on points at the Elephant and Castle last night. 
 McKenzie was fighting for the first time since losing his IBF title to Ulster's Dave McAuley. 
 TONY WILSON's win over Steve McCarthy in the British light-heavyweight title eliminator at Southampton last month, when McCarthy refused to continue after Wilson's mother attacked him in the ring, has been officially ratified by the British Board of Control. 
 FRANK WARREN, who manages both Gary Stretch and Chris Pyatt, thinks it unlikely that the two light-middleweights will meet in a world title eliminator. 
 On Wednesday Stretch made a successful first defence of his British title against Derek Wormald. 
 Sport in Short: Athletics 
 By ALAN WATKINS 
 THE Amateur Athletic Association's five-strong committee to investigate appearance money and other payments to athletes and officials will be chaired by Wing Cdr Dan Davies. 
 Hockey: Fitting beginning for new trophy 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 IT IS appropriate that, for the first staging of the Heineken Trophy, hockey's answer to football's Charity Shield, the country's two foremost clubs should meet: Hounslow, the Hockey Association Cup-winners, and Southgate, the National League champions, writes Bill Colwill. 
 Southgate, who took the League title on goal difference from Havant, will be out to avenge their penalty-stroke defeat by Hounslow in the League Cup final at Luton last April, after the teams had drawn 2-2 at the end of normal time. 
 Under Sean Kerly, Southgate have got their act together quickly, even allowing for the loss of such players as Richard Dodds and Robert Clift, Peter Boxell and Jagdis Barber, and through injury, Rupert Welch and John Shaw. 
 Hounslow have been more fortunate. 
 With last season's squad intact, now that their goalkeeper, Veryan Pappin, has recovered from injury, they have added Paul Bolland &mdash; yesterday recalled by England for the game against West Germany next Wednesday &mdash; to their squad. 
 With both clubs in Europe next year, the generous sponsorship of this event will help them with their expenses. 
 Perhaps the only disappointment is that the money is to be shared equally, when a winning bonus would give the event the edge it deserves. 
 American Football: Dallas trade Walker to Minnesota 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 HERSCHEL WALKER, the outstanding running back of the Dallas Cowboys, was traded to the Minnesota Vikings yesterday for five players and up to seven draft choices. 
 Walker, who won the Heisman Trophy for the best college player and is regarded as one of the leading rushers in the NFL, was exchanged for Darrin Nelson (running back), Issiac Holt (defensive back), David Howard and Jesse Solomon (both linebackers) and Alex Stewart (defensive end) plus a first-round and up to six other draft picks in the next three years. 
 Ice Hockey: Durham move on Europe 
 By STEVE PINDER 
 DURHAM WASPS take their first steps into European competition today when they face Rotterdam Pandas, hosts of the four-team first round in the European Cup. 
 Wasps, present as last season's Heineken Premier Division champions, also face the champions of Poland and France, Polonia Bytom and Francais Volants, in the three-day round robin league. 
 Before joining Wasps as coach in August, George Peternousek's coached the Dutch national side. 
 So his experience makes him ideally placed to plot Durham's tactics: &bquo;The Dutch tend to be steady, defensive and go for the breakout while the Poles rely on disciplined passing. 
 But they don't like physical hockey, unlike the French, who are capable of very physical hockey. 
 &bquo;We're going to play a physical, passing game and we must keep the score low to stand a chance, so we need to slow the game down, not allow the opposition any space and keep possession. 
 We'll be playing three-line hockey, with the third line led by Ivor Bennett, but I'm realistic enough to know it is going to be a very difficult situation against three strong teams.&equo; 
 As well as the imports, Rick Brebant, Brad Beck and Robert Forbes, Wasps can count on talented British players such as the brothers Johnson &mdash; Stephen, Anthony and Sean &mdash; and Paul and Damien Smith. 
 Wasps' foray comes as the sport prepares to move into the next decade as a leading spectator attraction. 
 Despite the demise this summer of Richmond Flyers, Tayside Tigers and Birmingham Bulls, nearing completion are rinks at Alexandra Palace, Milton Keynes and a new home for Ayr Raiders. 
 Stewart Roberts, of the British Ice Hockey Association, has another six pencilled in, with news of more coming in weekly. 
 &bquo;Most of them are in the south of England, which could, in the next 10 years, see the top teams coming from Chichester or Eastbourne,&equo; Roberts said. 
 &bquo;They are towns where there is no other big sporting tradition, so ice hockey can attract fans who are eager for any sport rather than have to compete against existing sports.&equo; 
 The two top leagues still have two more years of a lucrative sponsorship deal with Heineken, and teams are also commanding local sponsorship. 
 The signs look good for ice hockey in the Nineties. 
 Judo: Mills bombs out in weight game 
 From PHILIP NICKSAN in Belgrade 
 IN THE final of the British Open in April, Sharon Mills took Diane Bell, Britain's world middleweight champion, to full time and lost only on a decision. 
 She underlined her potential yesterday in the World Championships here when, though moving up a weight, managed to work her way through to fifth place. 
 Even Bell could do no better. 
 Weight &mdash; or the lack of it, in the case of Mills &mdash; is generally a crucial factor in judo. 
 Part of the time, she happily balanced the books with skill and vigour. 
 Her style is to run around the mat, changing direction at a moment's notice, and then fly in for a throw. 
 She did this to Marianne Prommeger, a tall Austrian, in her first fight to earn a decision. 
 However, against Taiwan's Mei Ling Wu, her whirlwind pattern paid off. 
 She struggled and was nearly countered, but then negated Wu's defence and slipped in for a one-armed shoulder throw. 
 Wu, caught by surprise, went partly on to her back and conceded a waza-ari (seven points). 
 Power did count in the end, though, for try as she might Mills could not contain the might of Italy's Emanuela Pierantozzi, the European champion, who stood a head taller and reached over with a powerful grip. 
 The British girl held out until being caught in a hold 30 seconds from the end. 
 The situation was much the same in the bronze medal fight against Jimenez Reve &mdash; Mills gamely avoiding a score but never in contention for the match. 
 Diane Bell's path was similar, but less spectacular. 
 Clearly suffering from the after-effects of a hip injury, she was knocked down for a koka &mdash; just three points &mdash; by the Soviet Elena Petrova, but it was enough to wipe out her hopes of a third consecutive world title. 
 David Southby, the light-middleweight, lost his first fight against the eventual winner, Korea's Byung-Ju Kim. 
 Here, lack of confidence was at fault more than anything else. 
 He did superbly in his first repechage fight. 
 A koka down against East Germany's Torsten Brechot, who threw Neil Adams in the 1988 Olympics, he gained a yuko (five points) with a rolling sacrifice throw three seconds from time. 
 Then, though ahead on attacks against the American Jason Morris, a lapse resulted in a footsweep for three points and defeat. 
 Rugby League: Rovers have another return 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 Featherstone Rovers. 
 .18 Castleford&hellip;&hellip; .18 THE NOTE in the programme wishing Graham Steadman success in his quest for an international cap was not entirely altruistic. 
 Rovers stand to pick up an extra &pound;25,000 if their former player makes the Great Britain side. 
 Castleford are unhappy enough about the &pound;145,000 a tribunal made them pay for Steadman, though even with his presence, they were unable to defeat their neighbours, as the second successive Yorkshire Cup semi-final went to a replay. 
 Steadman's contribution in the first half was restricted to three penalty goals. 
 Paul Newlove, a Featherstone player who did gain a place in this week's Test squad, scored the first try at the other end, following Barry Drummond's kick. 
 Two minutes later, Mark Knapper gave Rovers the lead. 
 Castleford rallied quickly however, and a third try in eight minutes arrived after a mistake under a high kick by Chris Bibb. 
 Tony Smith broke clear and found room for Steve Larder to outpace the home cover on the left. 
 Bibb atoned for his error at the start of the second half, when after Castleford lost the ball in front of their own posts he pounced quickly and beat three tacklers for the third Rovers' try, Knapper adding his first goal. 
 Bibbs' effort was cancelled by Larder's second try on the hour, Steadman managing to hit an upright with the kick from under the posts, and although Knapper was successful with two further penalties, David Plange tied the scores when Gary French squeezed a pass out of a tackle on the line 12 minutes from the end. 
 Rallying: Biasion in the van of Delta force 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 MASSIMO BIASION, of Italy, driving a works Lancia, yesterday squeezed past his team-mate, Alessandro Fiorio, to win the San Remo Rally and lift the world title for the second year running. 
 The 31-year-old Biasion pushed his new 16-valve Delta Integrale to the limit in making up the half-a-second per kilometre he needed in the fourth and final overnight stage. 
 Biasion, who also won last year in San Remo, finished with a total time of 6hrs 48min 30sec &mdash; only five seconds ahead of Fiorio, who was driving an eight-valve Lancia Delta. 
 Having won 15 of the rally's 33 special stages, Biasion became world champion with the Ivory Coast and British rallies still to be run in a season spanning 13 events. 
 The San Remo produced another strong performance from the Lancias, three finishing in the top four places. 
 Last season, they swept the board with all four leading places. 
 But this time Carlos Sainz, who had held the lead since Tuesday, came third in a Toyota. 
 The Spaniard finished only 25 seconds behind Fiorio, while Dario Cerrato of Italy, in another Lancia Delta, was placed fourth overall after breaking front and rear differentials. 
 Cricket: Hard work the England ethic: Martin Johnson reports from New Delhi 
 From MARTIN JOHNSON in New Delhi 
 IF ENGLAND fail to win the Jawaharlal Nehru Centenary Cricket Trophy &mdash; the grand title (which is accompanied by the unofficial suffix of &bquo;Mini World Cup&equo;) presumably intended to persuade the public that they are about to witness something cosmic rather than just another one-day tournament &mdash; it will not be because of being under-prepared. 
 Despite having dispensed with sundry items deemed essential to sustain European stomachs on their World Cup visit in 1987 &mdash; doctor, diet sheets, microwave oven and Tesco-sponsored tuck-boxes all left them flushed, as it were, with lack of success &mdash; England have been here almost a week, practising every day in sauna-bath temperatures for their opening match against Sri Lanka on Sunday. 
 England's change of captaincy since the end of the summer and the make-up of their various winter tour squads suggests a belief a that hard work is the first component in the rehabilitation plan. 
 Allan Lamb, the vice-captain, now finds himself short of a quorum for the easily-bored touring club, which usually takes the form of a private knockabout well out of earshot of Micky Stewart. 
 No one, however, seriously believes that the omission of both David Gower and Ian Botham from the main event in the Caribbean is based entirely on cricketing form. 
 There are few better exponents of the art of looking as though life is a complete grind than Graham Gooch, who invariably begins his day with a long-distance run, and Stewart is altogether more comfortable when the ship is being run more like a galley than the Skylark. 
 The England manager is a slave to slip catching practice, difficult though it is to recall the last time one of his bowlers located an outside edge. 
 Today England, having demolished a Railways XI containing no opposition of any note, take on a team sponsored by Air India, which looks almost as weak. 
 The locals field one former Test player, Madan Lal, and although Maninder Singh &mdash; last seen being swept to oblivion by Gooch in the Bombay World Cup semi-final &mdash; was practising at the England net yesterday, he has yet to come to terms with an attack of the yips. 
 It is a problem which seems curiously common to left-arm spinners, and manifests itself with the bowler either failing to release the ball, or propelling it vertically into the air. 
 It finished (as a bowler) the former Derbyshire player, Fred Swarbrook, who gave up the unequal struggle when, peering frantically around to see where a delivery had gone, he found out only when the ball dropped out of the stratosphere and hit him on top of the head. 
 All three of England's players who did not play against the Railways on Wednesday &mdash; Gladstone Small, Eddie Hemmings and Alec Stewart &mdash; get a game today, although there is a slight doubt about Phillip DeFreitas, who suffered a reaction to an elbow injury sustained during fielding practice. 
 Lamb is another minor casualty; he is all right to bat, but he can only throw in underarm at the moment because of a niggle, which at first was thought to be a reaction to an inoculation, but is now believed to be a minor ligament problem. 
 The Nehru Trophy is already attracting widespread media attention, and is regarded as an important event, not least by the Prime Minister. 
 Mr Gandhi has an election coming up and a big one-day cricket tournament not only goes down well with the electorate, but also goes a long way towards providing a short-term solution to the unemployment problem. 
 The avalanche of red tape surrounding events such as this (the entire population of New Delhi appears to be employed handing out forms to fill in) has to be seen to be believed, and it is by no means certain that, come 1 November, there will be any paper left to provide the winners with their cheque. 
 The Sharjah Cup one-day tournament in Dubai involving West Indies, India and Pakistan was delayed yesterday due to the death of the United Arab Emirates deputy prime minister, Sheikh Hamdan. 
 The opening match between West Indies and India will now start today. 
 Next Friday's date for the final remains unchanged. 
 Football: Bingham's heated argument: Joe Lovejoy reports on Dublin's faith in a reserved passage to Italy 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 &bquo;IT'S now a certainty &mdash; almost.&equo; 
 No prizes for grammar, but yesterday's Irish Press headline said it all. 
 The combination of results needed to deprive the Republic of their first appearance in the World Cup finals is so fantastic that the possibility can be discounted. 
 Chickens were being counted even before Wednesday's 3-0 victory over Northern Ireland, and the inventory was completed when Jack Charlton received congratulatory telegrams from the Taoiseach, Charles Haughey, and other luminaries including Liam Brady, who will miss the trip to Italy after falling out with Charlton last month and announcing his retirement from international football. 
 Billy Bingham, whose make-do-and-mend team were no match for their southern neighbours' withering power game, added his good wishes. 
 And a warning. 
 Northern Ireland's experience in Spain and Mexico in the last two World Cups taught them that heat can pose more problems than the opposition for British-based players. 
 Bingham said: &bquo;The Republic have the potential to do well in Italy. 
 Just how well will probably depend on the temperature. 
 They play a physically demanding pressing game which is very effective under normal conditions, but they won't be able to maintain the pressure if it is very hot. 
 &bquo;In extreme heat you have to take a breather and slow things down. 
 Players can't sustain that sort of aggressive running for the full 90 minutes in Mediterranean summer temperatures. 
 The Republic blitzed us, but it will be difficult for them to put on that type of performance in Italy.&equo; 
 Charlton is aware of the problem, of course, and is planning a pre-tournament acclimatisation trip to Malta and early-summer friendlies in Portugal and Turkey. 
 The Republic are much in demand these days. 
 Their reputation is growing with each new victory, and it seems everyone is keen to test themselves at Lansdowne Road, where the Irish have been invincible throughout Charlton's three-year managership. 
 Yugoslavia and France are due in Dublin for friendlies in December and February, while the date England hope to fill in March is also wanted by Argentina, Brazil, Uruguay and Colombia. 
 The result apart, the principal sources of Irish satisfaction on Wednesday were further encouraging signs that Tony Cascarino can become the goal-scoring striker the Republic have lacked, and the quality of their football in midfield. 
 Instead of transferring the ball from defence to attack with the trajectory of a mortar shell, they passed it to feet, and were even allowed to run with it. 
 George Best travelled fearing the worst, but was pleasantly surprised. 
 He said: &bquo;I don't agree with Jack Charlton's long-ball tactics, but there were glimpses of the way I would like to see the Republic play. 
 In the second half Ronnie Whelan, Ray Houghton and Kevin Sheedy showed some lovely skills, and the North couldn't cope.&equo; 
 Best believes Brady's return to the fold would enhance the prospects of Irish success in Italy, but the most gifted Irish footballer of his generation insisted last night that there was no question of him changing his mind and resuming his international career. 
 Brady explained: &bquo;Jack Charlton wrote to me, saying he was sorry about the way it had ended and expressing the hope that we could still have a decent relationship. 
 I wrote back thanking him and assuring him that there were no hard feelings on my part, but my decision is unchanged. 
 There is no question of me going to Italy as a player.&equo; 
 Brady will go to the ball, but in the same role as Best and Johnny Giles: media pundit. 
 The all-Ireland press team should draw quite a crowd. 
 Golf: Feherty feeds on friendly advice 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 DAVID FEHERTY played what he considered to be the best golf of his life in the BMW tournament in Munich yesterday, thanks largely to a tip from a friend. 
 The 31-year-old Ulsterman, who was the leading Briton in the Open at Troon last July, had a 10-under-par 62 to lead by three strokes in the first round from the American, Davis Love III. 
 &bquo;I've shot nine under three or four times, but never 10 under,&equo; Feherty said. 
 He then gave a couple of reasons for his spectacular performance, which included 11 birdies. 
 &bquo;I felt numb from the neck upwards, which is the ideal way to play this game,&equo; he said, &bquo;and I had a little lesson yesterday from my friend David Jones.&equo; 
 Jones, a fellow-Irishman who had a 75, told him that he was not lining up his putter squarely. 
 &bquo;It worked for me,&equo; Feherty said, confessing that he had not seen the back nine of the course before because his practice had been restricted by bad light. 
 Love, 25, had two eagles and four birdies in a round which he said would probably not have been played on the USPGA tour. 
 &bquo;We Americans are spoilt,&equo; he said, &bquo;I doubt whether we would have played in the cold and soaking conditions we had here today.&equo; 
 Howard Clark, who played for Europe in the recent defence of the Ryder Cup, the Australian Peter Fowler, Sweden's Ove Sellberg and the American, Gary Koch, shared third place on 66. 
 Golf: British outshone by Moon 
 From JOHN BOLTON at Stoke Poges 
 BRITISH professionals were upstaged in the opening round of the Laing Charity Classic when Sweden's Sofia Gronberg and Susan Moon, the American challenger, led the field with six-under-par rounds of 67 here yesterday. 
 On a day of low scoring, they finished a stroke clear of Xonia Wunsch from Spain, winner of the Italian Open two weeks ago. 
 Britain's Dale Reid and Debby Dowling were on 69 together with Leigh Mills, another American. 
 It was on the par-five hole that Gronberg and Moon made their rounds. 
 Gronberg, a powerful hitter who won the Rome Classic in the first tournament of the season, gathered an eagle and four of her six birdies at the long holes. 
 Gronberg lost 50 per cent of the sight in her right eye following a car accident six weeks ago. 
 Since then she has abandoned her contact lens in favour of glasses, having been told that in time her sight will return to normal. 
 Starting from the 10th, the Swede only once moved over par. 
 Three putts cost her a stroke at the 18th, which she followed with an eagle three at the 430-yard first when her seven-iron second finished only two feet from the hole. 
 Moon, who led by two strokes half-way through the third round of the Italian Open, made birdies at all five of the long holes. 
 Like Gronberg, she had only one bogey and her two remaining birdies came at the 10th and 18th holes. 
 Football: Roxburgh has the flak flying: Don Lindsay looks at a buck-stopping inquest into a hiccup in Paris 
 By DON LINDSAY 
 IT IS pretty rare to come across a football manager brave enough to hold up his hands the day after a beating and invite criticism. 
 Andy Roxburgh, the Scotland coach, broke the mould in the wake of Wednesday's reverse in Paris by admitting both he and his players had to accept the blame for a defeat which jeopardises Scotland's chances of playing in a fifth successive World Cup finals. 
 &bquo;There is no way we can sit here and waffle,&equo; Roxburgh told the press corps which had assembled in Glasgow the morning after the nightmare of Scotland's 3-0 defeat at the Parc des Princes. 
 &bquo;Sometimes we can argue, but on this occasion we'll have to throw ourselves on the mercy of the court because once again, and this was the second time running, simple, basic errors cost us the game.&equo; 
 It was not long before the flak was flying, and the principal targets were the Scotland captain Roy Aitken, the Liverpool utility player Steve Nicol, and Jim Leighton, the Manchester United goalkeeper. 
 &bquo;It's easy for people to sit here and say get rid of Roy Aitken. 
 I know Roy's limitations, as does he, but there must be a physical presence to offset the rest of the midfield&equo; was the coach's verdict on a man who is one short of 50 caps. 
 Roxburgh felt that Nicol, as an integral part of a superb club side, had difficulty in realising his potential in the wider arena, but &bquo;you keep hoping and hoping, because you know he has it to give.&equo; 
 Leighton's error in allowing Didier Deschamps to beat him at the near post and present France with an advantage they did not deserve was crucial to the outcome of the match. 
 Scotland, with Paul McStay at his decisive best, had controlled the game until then. 
 It was the collective madness which gripped the Scots after the French defender Eric Dimeco was dismissed which proved their downfall. 
 Scotland careered forward, leaving vast gaps in defensive areas. 
 Eric Cantona's goal was caused by Richard Gough and Nicol being marked absent yards from where they should have been. 
 &bquo;What lost us the match was a rush of blood to the head when they had the man sent off. 
 It was terrible, Charge of the Light Brigade stuff,&equo; Roxburgh admitted. 
 All this leaves Scotland needing to draw against Norway to make it to Italy, a point taken by the Scottish League, who yesterday agreed to postpone three Premier Division fixtures four days before the decider. 
 Aberdeen v Rangers, Celtic v St Mirren and Dundee United v Hibernian, due to be played on 11 November, will be switched to a new date. 
 &bquo;I see it as an opportunity rather than a pressure,&equo; Roxburgh said. 
 &bquo;If we don't draw against Norway then we don't deserve to go to Italy. 
 It will be a big, big occasion, another one of those nights of mayhem at Hampden.&equo; 
 Football: Allen's chance to score 
 By DON LINDSAY 
 MALCOLM ALLEN, who has not been able to get into the Norwich first team this season, showed that Wales' absentee forwards, Ian Rush and Mark Hughes, had better beware of him. 
 Wales's 2-1 defeat to The Netherlands at Wrexham on Wednesday night meant almost certain qualification to the finals in Italy next summer for the Dutch &mdash; but left Wales bemoaning another failed campaign. 
 For Allen, however, the game, his fifth international appearance, provided a chance for him to prove that Wales have a viable attacking alternative to Rush and Hughes, both missing through suspension. 
 Allen, who had a goal disallowed, was one of the few players to perform well for Wales on a night when they were generally outclassed. 
 The 22-year-old Norwich forward is now aiming to keep his place in the side for the game in West Germany on 15 November: &bquo;It was a good experience for myself and Iwan Roberts last night. 
 Rush and Hughes have done it all over the years. 
 It is great to get the chance to play. 
 It's now up to me to use the opportunity to breakthrough.&equo; 
 With Wales notching only six goals in the last year, and with none coming from Rush and Hughes, Allen knows he has every chance. 
 Allen's success was noted by Terry Yorath, the Wales manager, who also commented favourably on Mark Bowen, who notched the 88th-minute consolation goal after Graeme Rutjes and Johnny Bosman had put The Netherlands two goals up. 
 Squash: Parke has character to match his ability 
 From RICHARD EATON in Singapore 
 ENGLAND earned a seeding position in the quarter-finals of the World Team Championships here with a 3-0 victory over Egypt yesterday. 
 They also acquired more knowledge about Simon Parke, one of the best pieces of selection ever made. 
 Parke, aged 17, had already showed us with two wins in the previous two days that he has great ability. 
 This time he showed us that he has character as well, struggling his way to a 10-8, 9-6, 4-9, 5-9, 9-2 victory over Amir Wagih. 
 The young man had the highly charged presence of Jonah Barrington to help him. 
 Barrington's words erupted from behind the court like venom. 
 &bquo;Push&equo;, &bquo;discipline&equo; or &bquo;dig in&equo; came hissing forth, and were once followed with a hilarious bellow when Parke made an injudicious shot selection: &bquo;brain'. 
 Parke certainly has a brain and showed he could use it under pressure. 
 But nobody coaches or motivates quite like Barrington and his personality, almost as much as Parke's burgeoning promise, was written all over this enthralling match. 
 Otherwise the Egyptians offered but modest resistance. 
 Once the greatest squash nation in the world and a major influence upon the development of the game, they have yet to show signs of a revival. 
 Today, in the final group match, England meet the Australians. 
 That will decide who goes into Pakistan's half of the draw. 
 It will also, as Barrington says, tell us the facts of life. 
 Non-League Notebook: Historical twist to the South Bank show 
 By &bquo;PARK AVENUE&equo; 
 A HUNDRED years ago, Gladstone celebrated his 80th birthday vainly trying to get himself and the Liberals back into power. 
 Not much change there, though England's cricketers actually won both Tests in South Africa. 
 The really important event, however, was J T &bquo;Pussy&equo; Richardson's two goals in South Bank's 3-0 defeat of Auckland Town &mdash; soon to be Bishop Auckland &mdash; in the inaugural Northern League fixture. 
 The world's second oldest league is celebrated in a new book that is an essential purchase for anyone who loves the game's nuances. 
 Northern Goalfields, a 466-page labour of love by Brian Hunt, is a rich seam of statistical information, but dig deeper and a wonderful social and sporting history of the North-east emerges. 
 There is the &bquo;Crook Town Affair&equo; of 1928, when 350 amateurs were suspended for accepting excessive &bquo;tea money&equo;; West Auckland's &bquo;World Cup&equo; triumphs in Italy in 1909 and 1911; the origins of Brian Clough's first club, Billingham Synthonia (named after an agricultural fertiliser!); and the brief flowering of the wonderfully named Thornaby Utopians. 
 Part of the modern football experience is the rush of excitement when the local pink or green &bquo;sports final&equo; arrives. 
 Many a train trek is enlivened by scrutiny of the myriad reports and results over a BR BLT and coffee. 
 Last week's Birmingham Sports Argus was especially rewarding. 
 Talk about cosmopolitan. 
 Diaz breached Atherstone's defence at Dorchester; Raji and Gonzales were in tandem for Boldmere St Michael's at Walsall Wood; while Oldbury and Rocester, in the FA Vase against Hinckley Athletic and Burscough respectively, looked to Rossi and Anastasi for goals. 
 Shades of Juventus&hellip; could they be, in any way, related? 
 The picture painted by the reporter at the Beazer Homes League match between Redditch and Willenhall was priceless. 
 &bquo;Redditch conceded an own goal after 90 seconds,&equo; it began. 
 &bquo;Smith, awarded the Player of the Month trophy before the game, was under no pressure when he turned Wainwright's cross into his own net.&equo; 
 Whoops&hellip; 
 Let's must hope Smith's mind is on the game tomorrow, when Redditch are at Hitchin to contest a place in the FA Cup's final qualifying round before the Third and Fourth Division sides enter. 
 The outstanding ties are the visit of Barnet, who almost made the Fourth Division twice in recent seasons, to Cambridge City's four-year-old stadium; a derby between Dover and Folkestone, who had four players sent off against Redhill in the previous round; and, by a nice coincidence, the meeting of Bishop Auckland, defectors to the HFS Loans League, and South Bank, loyal to their roots, almost exactly a century on from their historic match. 
 Netball: Aspiring England accept invitation to test the best 
 By LIZ ROUND 
 ENGLAND have accepted an invitation to take part in a Test series against the leading netball countries New Zealand and Australia in Australia next June. 
 The Tests for the Johnson &amp; Johnson Cup will take place in Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne and Sydney from 9 to 19 June. 
 The England squad &mdash; ranked fourth in the world &mdash; will be selected following trials in December, and the team's coach, Betty Galsworthy, will relish the prospect of pitting her team against the world champions from New Zealand and second-ranked Australia prior to the 1991 world tournament. 
 Trials for the England Under-21 and Under-18 squads begin this weekend, with the Northern trials in Sheffield. 
 The Southern trials will be at Crystal Palace in a week's time, with the final trials also at Crystal Palace in December. 
 Some 30 hopefuls from each age group will be selected for the finals, with the players competing for places in the Under-21 matches against Scotland and Wales, and the Under-18s United Kingdom and England tournament in Scotland. 
 There is also the possibility of a young England tour of Jamaica, which the All England Netball Association hope will give the young players some experience of the Caribbean game before the world tournament. 
 The first round of the National Clubs competition has now been completed with the holders Linden, of Birmingham, drawn against Nottingham's Cliftonettes in the second round. 
 The closest match of the first round was between Essex Wanderers and Vauxhall Golds with Vauxhall finally clinching a 36-35 victory. 
 The second round matches have to be played by 5 November. 
 Football: Turks fail to delight with foreigners ban 
 By LIZ ROUND 
 GOALKEEPERS Toni Schumacher and Jean-Marie Pfaff are among 46 foreign players who learned yesterday that their lucrative attachments to Turkish clubs will be terminated at the end of the season. 
 Schumacher, the former West German international who plays for Fenerbahce, and Pfaff who gives a Belgian flavour to Trabzonspor, have fallen foul of a Turkish federation ban on imported players. 
 &bquo;The decision has been taken for the good of Turkish football and its players,&equo; a federation spokesman said. 
 &bquo;We cannot back down from the decision, which we believe is rightful and just.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, Northampton Town yesterday spent &pound;70,000 &mdash; a record cash buy for the Third Division club &mdash; to buy the winger Bobby Barnes from Bournemouth. 
 Birmingham City have completed the signing of Doug Bell from Shrewsbury Town. 
 The fee for the 30-year-old midfielder will be decided by tribunal. 
 Nicky Johns, the Queen's Park Rangers goalkeeper, has joined Maidstone United on a month's loan, while Leeds have granted a transfer request by the central defender, Noel Blake. 
 Leeds play Sunderland tomorrow and police have appealed to supporters without tickets to stay away from Elland Road. 
 &bquo;Anyone without a ticket will not be allowed in,&equo; a police spokesman said. 
 Racing: Scudamore keeps up a record pace 
 By JOHN KARTER, Racing Correspondent 
 PETER SCUDAMORE, who breaks records as easily as a psychotic disc jockey, was at it again yesterday, shattering his own mark for the fastest 50 winners by a National Hunt jockey when he rode In-Keeping to an easy victory at Wincanton. 
 Scudamore has reached the half century in 12 fewer days than during last season's fantastic voyage into jumping history. 
 In that campaign, which he ended with a score of 221, he also rode the fastest 100 by a jump jockey, smashed Jonjo O'Neill's record seasonal total of 149, and not only became the first man to ride 200 winners over jumps, but the first to do so under either code since Sir Gordon Richards did so on the Flat in 1952. 
 William Hill quote Scudamore at the seemingly generous price of evens to reach 200 again this time. 
 To put those odds into perspective, however, it should be remembered that apart from having at his disposal the incredible equine resources of In-Keeping's trainer, Martin Pipe &mdash; who himself broke all records for a jump trainer last season &mdash; events conspired very much in favour of the four-times champion jockey. 
 There were exceptionally few meetings cancelled and Scudamore stayed remarkably free of injury. 
 After In-Keeping, the 11-10 favourite, had stormed to a five-length success, Scudamore refused to take any of the credit for his latest statistical breakthrough. 
 &bquo;Martin and his team keep kicking the ball into the penalty area and all I have to do is nod it into the net,&equo; the 31-year-old rider said. 
 And, having been presented with the customary bottle of champagne by the Wincanton executive, Scudamore added that he felt a lot less pressure than he had last season. 
 He also made it clear that any thoughts of topping the 221 mark are being put firmly on the back burner, with the fastest 100, set last year in mid-December, his next target. 
 As if to prove that the National Hunt supermen that brought off this latest feat are in fact human, Pipe admitted that he got it badly wrong over his assessment of In-Keeping. 
 Two days after the filly arrived in his yard, the Somerset trainer told the owner, Helen Read, that the horse would never win a race. 
 &bquo;The filly was desperate, even falling over walking on to the gallops,&equo; Pipe explained, adding that he puts more work into training In-Keeping than three normal horses. 
 &bquo;She's a right madam and I'm always afraid she might kill someone in the paddock,&equo; he said. 
 Allen Webb, the jump jockey, will be out of action for a week after injuring his neck while riding out. 
 Webb, who has trapped a nerve, hopes to be back at Cheltenham on Wednesday. 
 Another rider, David Wonnacott, missed the winning ride on Lizzy Longstocking at Wincanton yesterday as he has trapped nerves in his right shoulder following a fall at Taunton. 
 Racing: Bookmakers in the dark over Light 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 BOOKMAKERS, whose intelligence service makes MI5 look like a bunch of amateur sleuths, for once appear to have led themselves rather than punters up the garden path over the well-being of Travelling Light, the favourite for next Saturday's Cesarewitch Handicap at Newmarket. 
 William Hill yesterday quoted Travelling Light as their 7-2 market leader (from 4-1) but added a &bquo;with a run&equo; proviso as they had heard that all was not well with the three-year-old, who is trained by Lynda Ramsden at Sandhutton near Thirsk. 
 Mrs Ramsden's husband, Jack, whose successful punting exploits have regularly had the bookies reaching for the valium bottle, was at first stunned and angered by the suggestion that anything was wrong with Travelling Light, whom he has backed at 33-1 for the second leg of the Autumn Double. 
 &bquo;That's typical of the bookies. 
 They wind people up just to see their reaction,&equo; Ramsden said, confirming that Travelling Light was absolutely fine. 
 &bquo;They're not really bookies these days, they're just debt collectors. 
 They won't lay anyone a decent bet if they think he's capable of backing a winner.&equo; 
 Graham Sharpe, spokesman for Hills, who cut the second favourite, Double Dutch, from 7-1 to 6-1 and Royal Square from 16-1 to 10-1 yesterday, countered by saying: &bquo;We have often been criticised for including in our ante-post lists horses that trainers later said were never intended runners. 
 So when we received persistent telephone calls from our clients asking whether we had heard that all was not well with the horse, we had to take a view. 
 We were laying other horses in the race, sometimes taking bets from people who had already backed Travelling Light. 
 Anyway, punters don't lose their money if Travelling Light doesn't run.&equo; 
 Having been reminded that the bookies' smoke signals usually signify a lot more than just grandiose waves of their Havana cigars, Ramsden then revealed that he himself might have been inadvertantly responsible for the Travelling Light rumour. 
 &bquo;I suppose it could be the fact that I backed Double Dutch at 10-1 as a saver simply because I think she's good value and certainly not because there's anything wrong with my horse,&equo; Ramsden said. 
 &bquo;I didn't even back her under my name, so I don't understand how they could have known.&equo; 
 That last statement sounds uncharacteristically naive on the part of the former stockbroker whose shrewd reading of the form book has been greatly instrumental in providing the wherewithal to build possibly the most up-to-date training establishment north of Watford Gap. 
 With an all-weather gallop, equine swimming pool, blood-testing lab and weighing facilities, the 35-horse power yard is run very much on the lines of Martin Pipe's hi-tech winner factory in Somerset. 
 So far, the Ramsdens have sent out 30 winners this season and they are hoping that they can snap up a tasty hors-d'oeuvre before the Newmarket feast by saddling their first winner at Ascot this afternoon when they run Line Of Vision and Hunter Valley. 
 Line Of Vision, who finished second to the highly rated Argentum at Nottingham, should do best of the pair, but may fail to hold the impressive Brighton winner, Alysardi (3.40), who at &dollar;205,000 as a yearling, cost almost 10 times as much. 
 Alysardi could be the second leg of a double for Alec Stewart, her trainer, and Michael Roberts, her jockey, who may earlier have won with ELEGANT RAINBOW (nap 3.05). 
 She ran a marvellous race when third to Runun over the course recently. 
 Racing: Trainer given 20 year ban 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 THE JOCKEY CLUB yesterday meted out the stiff punishment of a 20-year ban from racing to Chris Willett, a point-to-point rider and trainer, who served a three-month jail sentence earlier this year for his part in a betting coup involving a ringer. 
 At his trial in April, Willett admitted registering the useful Flat performer Cecconi as Champagne Lover with the Arab Horse Society, and then taking the animal to Market Rasen for a Society race. 
 Champagne Lover was backed from 16-1 to 2-1 and beat 18 rivals by 12 lengths. 
 Bookmakers and officials realised something was amiss and Willett, who had hoped to net &pound;21,000 from his coup, got away with just &pound;1,964. 
 Veterinary examination revealed the true identity of the horse and led to a spell in Maidstone jail for Willett. 
 At yesterday's meeting of the Club's Disciplinary Committee, Willett, 33, was declared a disqualified person for 20 years. 
 This means he is banned from attending any form of racing in Britain, including point-to-points. 
 &bquo;I think I had an extremely fair hearing,&equo; he said afterwards. 
 The Committee also handed out a four-week suspension to Bruce Dowling, the jump jockey, for forging a doctor's signature. 
 Dowling, stable jockey to Richard Lee, admitted signing the name &bquo;Dr R Dowling&equo; in the medical record book that accompanied Laurence Todd's application to become an amateur rider. 
 Last year, Dowling was given a three-week ban, together with Peter Scudamore, after the pair were involved in a barging match at Newbury. 
 Mandela frames conditions for talks 
 From JOHN CARLIN in Johannesburg 
 NELSON MANDELA, the imprisoned leader of the African National Congress, is in favour of negotiations with F W de Klerk's government, but feels strongly that the black majority of South Africans should be in favour too, before embarking on such a venture. 
 Accordingly, he has drawn up a document outlining his position on negotiations which he means to make public, so the people are fully apprised of the proposals that would be on the table. 
 This, the clearest public indication to date of Mr Mandela's views on talks with the government, emerged from an Independent interview yesterday with Albertina Sisulu, who, together with anti-apartheid leaders, met Mr Mandela at his prison house for four hours on Tuesday. 
 &bquo;It was his feeling that in any country, even if there is war, there is time for negotiations,&equo; said Mrs Sisulu, whose husband, Walter, a former secretary-general of the ANC and a close friend of Mr Mandela, is to be freed from prison. 
 &bquo;If the people were ready for negotiations, he wouldn't be against it. 
 But he said the people must be well educated on this and everything must be explained to them before any steps are taken.&equo; 
 She said Mr Mandela told them that he had written a document setting out his views on negotiations, the prospect of which President de Klerk has been promoting since well before the National Party returned to power in the 6 September elections. 
 Mrs Sisulu, co-president of the United Democratic Front, said her husband would resume his leading role in the anti-apartheid movement and would not waver in his commitment to the ANC &mdash; considered a criminal organisation by the government. 
 At a press conference, also yesterday, given by leaders of a loose coalition of anti-apartheid organisations known as the Mass Democratic Movement (MDM), the point was restated that the political prisoners whose unconditional release Mr de Klerk announced on Tuesday &mdash; the exact day they will be out is not known yet &mdash; would take up their political activities under the banner of the ANC. 
 Cyril Ramaphosa, president of the National Union of Mineworkers and one of the group who met Mr Mandela on Tuesday, said that after their release the ANC men would demand passports so as to visit ANC leaders abroad for consultations. 
 Mr Ramaphosa said that the prisoners' release should not be construed as an act of goodwill by Mr de Klerk, but as a reflection of the &bquo;dismal&equo; failure of &bquo;the apartheid regime&equo; to emasculate the will of the black majority. 
 He warned Margaret Thatcher, as she prepares for a Commonwealth heads of government conference next week where the issue of sanctions on South Africa is expected to be central, against insisting that &bquo;the regime&equo; was moving in the right direction. 
 Mr Ramaphosa said marches would be held in various parts of the country on Saturday to celebrate the homecoming of &bquo;our leaders&equo;, for whom the MDM is preparing &bquo;a welcome befitting their greatness&equo;. 
 Mr Mandela, for his part, according to Mr Ramaphosa, had &bquo;a unique greatness&equo;, a magnetism which he felt in his presence on Tuesday before he had even looked him in the eye. 
 Ryan case dropped for &bquo;insufficient evidence&equo; 
 By ALAN MURDOCH and COLIN BROWN 
 PATRICK RYAN, the Catholic priest whose extradition was unsuccessfully sought by Britain last year, will not face prosecution in the Irish Republic, it was revealed last night. 
 The Irish Director of Public Prosecutions, Eamonn Barnes, said in a statement that the evidence provided by the British Crown Prosecution Service was &bquo;not sufficient for the purpose and accordingly a prosecution could not be justified&equo;. 
 Anglo-Irish relations were strained last year when Ireland refused to extradite Mr Ryan, who is wanted in connection with terrorist charges including murder and conspiracy to cause explosions. 
 Dublin claimed allegations made in Parliament and the British Press linking Mr Ryan with the IRA meant he would not have faced a fair trial. 
 However, since then Mr Barnes has been considering starting proceedings under the 1976 Criminal Law Jurisdiction Act, which allows for prosecutions of individuals in the Republic for offences allegedly committed in Britain. 
 Last night's statement said Mr Barnes &bquo;has given careful consideration to the material furnished by the CPS&equo;. 
 Initial documents were sent to Dublin from Britain in January, but Mr Barnes has since revealed that more documents were supplied by London as recently as July. 
 At Mr Barnes' request further inquiries into the case have also been made by the Irish Garda. 
 &bquo;On the question of whether the material which has been made available is sufficient to justify the initiation of a prosecution against Patrick Ryan he (Mr Barnes) has come to the clear conclusion that it is not sufficient for that purpose and that a prosecution would not be justified,&equo; the statement said. 
 Senior ministers were clearly disappointed last night at the news, but said they wanted to study the papers before commenting publicly. 
 However, the Government is unlikely to allow the Ryan affair further to upset Anglo-Irish relations. 
 Charity set to fund sex survey vetoed by PM 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 BRITAIN'S BIGGEST survey of sexual behaviour, vetoed by Margaret Thatcher a month ago, is set to go ahead with private funding from the Wellcome Foundation Trust. 
 The announcement has been delayed until next week, to avoid clashing with the Prime Minister's speech to the Conservative conference today. 
 Reliable data to help to predict the spread of the HIV infection are seen as vital by the Department of Health as it draws up strategies for fighting Aids. 
 The &pound;750,000 survey &mdash; in which 20,000 adults will be asked detailed questions about the frequency and nature of their sexual activities &mdash; was to have been funded by the Department of Health, the Health Education Authority and the Economic and Social Research Council. 
 But Mrs Thatcher said it would be a waste of public money and an unjustified invasion of privacy. 
 She was also said to have doubted whether it would produce accurate information. 
 Imperial College, London, two medical schools and a research organisation called Social and Community Planning Research were standing by to carry out the project after two successful pilot studies earlier this year. 
 When government cash was withdrawn they applied to several charitable foundations for funding. 
 The Wellcome Foundation Trust, a charitable arm of the Wellcome drug company set up to fund medical research, has agreed in principle to a request to pay for the three-year investigation. 
 Peter Williams, director of the trust, confirmed that the trustees had met this week but insisted no decision had yet been taken. 
 &bquo;There will be a press release next week if discussions are favourably concluded,&equo; Dr Williams said. 
 Wellcome has produced AZT, the first drug licensed for the treatment of Aids, and its share price has risen as a result. 
 Markets may force Thatcher to take the hated alternative 
 By PETER JENKINS 
 BLACKPOOL &mdash; The Chancellor's entrance to the platform was greeted with a standing ovation. 
 After his speech the conference clapped and cheered as if he had announced the abolition of the income tax. 
 In between these demonstrations of loyalty and discipline under fire he had said nothing to clarify the Government's policy for combating inflation other than that there was no alternative to what he had been doing. 
 That phrase &bquo;there is no alternative&equo; has a special meaning in the vocabulary of Thatcherism. 
 Margaret Thatcher herself said it so many times in reply to &bquo;wet&equo; critics that it became known, not very affectionately, as Tina. 
 Mr Lawson's summoning of Tina may have been his subtle way of saying that her policy for combating inflation was no alternative to his. 
 He was firm in saying that devaluation was no solution but imprecise as to what further action he might take to prevent it. 
 The speech consisted of little more than bullish assertions of the underlying dynamism and strength of the British economy. 
 When the final draft was completed, shortly after midnight in his suite at the Imperial Hotel, it was made known that he would have nothing to say to markets on this occasion. 
 His sole purpose was to defend his stewardship and reaffirm his policy before the audience of the loyal in the ballroom of the Winter Gardens. 
 If he has other things to say they will be said at Mansion House next Thursday, an occasion by tradition for the Chancellor to speak on monetary policy. 
 Glaringly absent from yesterday's speech were any mention of the balance of payments, the recent excitement on the money markets, exchange rate policy or the European Monetary System. 
 The first omission was regarded by some of his ministerial colleagues as an eccentricity bordering on the provocative, especially after the injunctions from Michael Heseltine and Sir Geoffrey Howe to take more seriously the balance of payments figures and what they said about the manufacturing base of the economy. 
 The absence of reference to exchange rates and the EMS was presumably because there was nothing he could say without exciting renewed speculation or reopening divisions at the top of the Government. 
 The City and the Confederation of British Industry had been looking for some indication of earlier participation in the exchange rate mechanism of the EMS. 
 It had been thought here that Mr Lawson might at least repeat the formula of the Madrid summit, which defined when the time would be ripe for the pound to join with the words &bquo;once inflation is again on a downward path and we have seen the removal of exchange controls by our Community partners&equo;. 
 But he said nothing at all. 
 One explanation is that he wanted to keep open an option should the pound run into fresh trouble, as well it may. 
 Then he could confront the Prime Minister with the choice of still higher interest rates or a relaxation in her opposition to the pound's joining the ERM. 
 If that is so, markets have the potential power of forcing Mrs Thatcher's hand. 
 At the Madrid summit last summer, Sir Geoffrey Howe, who at the time was collaborating closely with Mr Lawson, tried to insist that she name a date after 1 July next year on which Britain would join. 
 She refused and still today has no intention of tying the pound to the deutschmark this side of a general election, if ever. 
 Further troubles on this score are inevitable. 
 There is growing unease among members of the Cabinet at the way in which Mr Lawson's task is being made more difficult by the Prime Minister. 
 The events of the past few days have led several ministers to recognise the difficulty of restoring full authority to the Chancellor while the Prime Minister persists in her hostility to the EMS. 
 According to a senior and influential backbencher who specialises in financial affairs, the great bulk of the parliamentary party is behind Mr Lawson. 
 Meanwhile, there is mounting pressure from the City and from industry in favour of an earlier move towards full participation in the EMS. 
 Mr Lawson may win in the end. 
 Lawson insists on high interest rates 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 NIGEL LAWSON yesterday won a respite from political and City pressure on his anti-inflation policy with a firm pledge to defend the pound against devaluation. 
 The Chancellor of the Exchequer told the Conservative Party conference in Blackpool that there was no alternative to his policy of high-level interest rates in the &bquo;paramount&equo; fight against inflation. 
 The policy was working and inflation was falling, but Mr Lawson said he had to admit that it was &bquo;proving a slow process&equo;. 
 As for fears of a recession, he said that would be avoided if business and industry kept a firm grip on their costs, particularly wages. 
 But in a clear attempt to dispel City uncertainty over the pound, Mr Lawson restated his commitment to exchange rate stability, saying: &bquo;The Conservative Party never has been, and never will be, the party of devaluation.&equo; 
 Asked about the recent fall in the pound, he explained in a later BBC interview: &bquo;On the average, the exchange rate today is pretty well the same as it was three years ago. 
 So I don't see how you can say that that's devaluation.&equo; 
 He also ruled out what an ITN interviewer called a &bquo;gentle readjustment&equo; of the pound, saying that was an unacceptable soft option. 
 Mr Lawson said later that the stability of the pound and high interest rates were inextricably linked in keeping inflation down. 
 His conference speech was marked by the absence of any reference to membership of the European exchange rate mechanism (ERM), and in a BBC interview he added that he would have &bquo;no announcement to make about that&equo; in his key speech at the Mansion House next week. 
 John Major, the Foreign Secretary, said in another BBC interview that nothing had changed since the EC Madrid summit last June: Britain would become a full member of the European Monetary System (EMS) when inflation fell to &bquo;the approximate rate&equo; of European competitors, and when France and Italy abolished exchange controls. 
 Mr Lawson received a standing ovation for his low-key conference speech, but that appeared to be more of a defensive rank-and-file reaction to widespread media reports of party dissent than enthusiasm for the unflinching substance of the message. 
 Significant passages of the speech, particularly on interest rates, were received in silence and other keynote statements were given only polite applause. 
 Last night, the mood of conference representatives was a mix of public solidarity and private unease. 
 John Smith, the shadow Chancellor, said last night: &bquo;What he doesn't seem to realise is that interest rates mean that it will be much harder for industry to get on its feet to help us overcome the balance of payments deficit. 
 And he refuses to recognise that high interest rates are the price we pay for that deficit.&equo; 
 Paddy Ashdown, the leader of the Democrats, called the speech &bquo;dangerously complacent.&equo; 
 Sir Leon Brittan, Britain's EC commissioner, told a Bow Group fringe meeting last night that the Government should enter into the ERM as soon as turbulence subsided in the foreign exchange markets. 
 He said: &bquo;I think we should join well before next summer, but I do not think&hellip; that the time to join is this week.&equo; 
 Mr Lawson began his speech by going right to the heart of the political problem &mdash; last week's 1-point hike in interest rates. 
 He told the conference that his priority was to curb inflation, and that was why he had raised rates. 
 It had to be done, and he had known it would not be popular, but he added: &bquo;Anyone who becomes Chancellor in order to be popular has chosen the wrong job.&equo; 
 Replying directly to a businesswoman's plea during the debate for &bquo;one more little miracle&equo; to ease the impact of the new rate on firms, Mr Lawson said to muted applause: &bquo;The answer is that there is no alternative, and the policy will work.&equo; 
 Borrowing had to be curbed, and the only way was to make it more expensive. 
 Labour's advocacy of credit controls was &bquo;a cruel deception&equo;. 
 But there was no applause when he added: &bquo;I have to tell you that credit controls simply wouldn't work.&equo; 
 It also took representatives some moments to applaud the next phase of the speech, in which Mr Lawson responded to &bquo;turbulence&equo; in the money markets. 
 He warned that there was no salvation &bquo;in the rake's progress of perpetual devaluation&equo; &mdash; all that did was increase the price of imports and bring still more inflation. 
 Mr Lawson said: &bquo;The plain truth is that there are no easy answers. 
 But I give you this pledge. 
 I will continue to take whatever action is needed, however unpopular it may be, to keep our economy sound and strong.&equo; 
 Labour's lead over the Conservatives increased to 9.5 points after its party conference and the rise in interest rates last week, according to a Gallup poll in today's Daily Telegraph. 
 It gives Labour 47.5 per cent support, compared with 38 per cent for the Tories. 
 MUSIC / Beware the pitfalls of sincerity: Composer Robin Holloway considers the difficulties of assessing a new piece of music. 
 By ROBIN HOLLOWAY 
 How to ensure a sympathetic reception for a new piece of music? 
 Ideally the subject should combine Ecology (with special reference to tropical rain-forests) with Protest (preferably shrill and futile). 
 It should climax with an ecumenical prayer (in every known language simultaneously) for intergalactic peace. 
 The musical material should include at least three of the following: Jewish cantillation, Catholic plainsong, Tibetan chanting, Aboriginal drumming, whalesong. 
 The idiom should be middle-of-the-road, artfully diguised with mod cons (clusters, glissandi, electronics): there should be a strong pop-music element, plenty of repetition a la Philip Glass. 
 When inspiration fails, fill the gaps with ritual gong-strokes, prolonged and amplified to the threshold of pain. 
 But such cynicism will not do; this is a serious matter. 
 A recent first visit to the USSR brought into focus for me the large question of evaluating music whose basis of appeal is grounded in extra-musical circumstances. 
 The first problem is the dispassionate judgement of compositions that emerge from, and in some cases directly express, political oppression. 
 The wide current appeal of such music seems to touch a nerve of communal masochism. 
 Audiences yearn to groan under the yoke of suffering they may never have experienced. 
 There is even a kind of envy for the depth of vision which this fate is thought to produce. 
 The conspicuous case is Shostakovich, a composer of enormous gifts and awesome copiousness, the only one to satisfy, if intermittently, both his masters and the West. 
 Ever since the &bquo;just criticism&equo; meted out to his early excesses, then the gigantic success of the Leningrad Symphony in the 1940s, he has symbolized the artist caught in the net of public events. 
 As we now know something of the appalling story of his hounding by cultural officialdom, the raucous irony of the middle works and the bitter blackness of the last become entirely comprehensible. 
 His is the only post-war body of symphonic and chamber music to achieve genuine popularity. 
 Yet it is drastically imperfect. 
 Impressive inspirations mix with the coarsest triteness; there is an inordinate amount of padding and bombast; the reliance on formulae is the most shameless since Telemann. 
 Nor did things improve as he grew beyond subjection to state reproof. 
 Some late works, notably the Fourteenth Symphony and the songs on Michaelangelo texts are among his greatest. 
 But in the succession of late string quartets, poverty of substance and spiritual exhaustion are exemplified rather than expressed. 
 Shostakovich, obviously pre-eminent among Soviet composers, had to bear the cruellest treatment. 
 Bold spirits in the satellite countries were able to take liberties at home (Lutoslawski, Penderecki, Kurtag) when they didn't get away in person (Panufnik, Ligeti). 
 The recent change of policy has unfrozen a flood of music by younger figures who have not undergone similar cultural repression, though the conditions of their work remain poignant and precarious. 
 Recently it has been well-aired in this country through broadcasts and festivals; enough to form an initial overall view. 
 I believe that music-lovers are deluded when they claim to find artistic pleasure in any but a fraction of this music. 
 Here, as with most of Shostakovich, the content they locate is a projection of what they know of its circumstances - by which only a heart of stone would not be moved. 
 Take away this knowledge and the appeal would vanish, for the music is rarely able to stand on its own merits. 
 The second problem is the evaluation of new music that &bquo;deals&equo; with religious subject-matter, however vague. 
 A nostalgia has become apparent, after an era of aggressive atheism, either for the great organized beliefs or for substitutes chiming better with the would-be freer spirit of the times. 
 In the Sixties Gurus and pop music were the thing; the present mood is sombre and apocalyptic. 
 In both, the identification with music that attempts to express any part of this vast area tends to be one of self-deceiving empathy. 
 A spiritual void needs to be satisfied, so what is offered as serious and sacrosanct must be as good as it pretends. 
 Instances would include the St Luke Passion by Penderecki and the St John by Arvo Part, Messiaen's Transfiguration, Britten's War Requiem. 
 Tippett's Mask of Time and Birtwistle's Mask of Orpheus, Steve Reich's Desert Music, much of the output of John Tavener and Jonathan Harvey; above all, Stockhausen's seven-day wonder, Licht. 
 Such religious/humanitarian subject-matter &mdash; even the Holocaust, Hiroshima and Aids have not escaped &mdash; makes a fortress as unassailable by criticism as the art produced under tyranny. 
 The worth of individual pieces is, obviously, very various; consistent is the appeal to piety, ensuring that the elevated theme produces a warm-hearted response. 
 These composers are not coldly exploiting their audiences' kindness; they are all equally the victims of the going ideology. 
 And sincerity is not in question. 
 But the hard truth, nailed with all-time accuracy by the other great composer from Leningrad (the one who got out) is that sincerity does not guarantee quality. 
 &bquo;Most art is sincere,&equo; Stravinsky added, &bquo;and most art is bad&equo;. 
 Ersatz emotion replaces musical content. 
 The genuine difficulty of understanding intricate artistic designs is evaded by the factitious difficulty of being exalted or troubled by important messages which have nothing to do with musical worth. 
 Artistic value is not an &bquo;extra&equo; even in a threnody for Chernobyl. 
 Without it, message or vision are wishful thinking. 
 Audiences' large capacities for ersatz-importance show how eager they are to be deeply stirred; how easily gulled; how low the threshold of enjoyment must be set for music of our time. 
 What little appeal it has seems to depend heavily on these impurities. 
 No one would deny that music can embody great humane and religious themes. 
 That it does so, so profoundly, is a vital part of what it is for. 
 There is spiritual value in the very handling of its primary elements to write a little song or dance, even an exercise; even, as Bruckner used to show his classes, in a fifth or octave struck at a piano. 
 The essence of music's higher flights is transcendental in the highest degree imaginable, in ways that are manifestly intelligible and effectual, and quite insusceptible to verbal accounting. 
 Debussy's answer to a journalist who asked if he was familiar with heaven &mdash; &bquo;yes, but I don't natter about it with strangers&equo; - is not so silly as it sounds. 
 Evasive certainly, but only to acknowledge what cannot be uttered. 
 The good composer expresses what he feels and makes what he is making, from an essentially musical motivation, by essentially musical means, with all the skill and experience he can command. 
 The ends are various: here a visionary oratorio, there an opera buffa; here a craggy piano etude, there a melting morceau de salon. 
 The degree of craft, the degree of inspiration, are the measure whereby they can be valued; through these are achieved, consciously or inadvertently, the heights and depths of spiritual expression whereby they are &bquo;a joy for ever&equo;. 
 Music can only be judged on the basis of an attentiveness to its musical essence as sensitive and discriminating as possible. 
 Above all, as specific -an undogmatic reaction to the details in style and technique of the particular composer, piece, or passage. 
 Naturally this will include transcendental subject-matter if it's there, and recognize the moments where this sweeps all before it. 
 All the rest is emotional blackmail. 
 RECORD REVIEWS / Violent measure: Shostakovich: Piano Concerto No 1, Chamber Symphony, Seven Preludes Op 34. 
 Evgeny Kissin (piano), Moscow Virtuosi. 
 Vladimir Spivakov. 
 RCA Victor RD87947 Rachmaninov: Preludes Op 32. 
 Shostakovich: Piano Sonata No 1. 
 Lilya Zilberstein (piano). 
 DG427766-2 
 By SIMON MUNDY 
 IT IS 14 years since Shostakovich died. 
 Nonetheless his reputation as at once the most searching and accessible of contemporary composers has not diminished. 
 If anything, fashion is moving closer to the context of his style with the passage of time. 
 In the 1970s his language did indeed seem a little old-fashioned. 
 Now, as composers grope towards a language that satisfies audiences and yet manages to be sufficiently modern, Shostakovich's music sounds at the front once again. 
 There has been a welcome pile of new recordings issued recently; not just of the symphonies, but of the concertos and chamber music as well. 
 Two of them mark the start of international recording careers for extraordinary young Soviet pianists, Evgeny Kissin and Lilya Zilberstein, who were only children when Shostakovich died. 
 Kissin, aged 18, came to prominence a couple of years ago when he appeared to great acclaim at the Berlin Festival. 
 His recording of the First Piano Concerto is sparklingly assured &mdash; crisply articulated but with enough sensitivity to convey the inevitable bitter-sweet character of the slow movement. 
 This is anyway a stunning disc, thanks to the playing of the Moscow Virtuosi with Spivakov. 
 Their performances of the orchestral arrangements &mdash; the Chamber Symphony (arranged by Rudolph Barshai from the Eighth Quartet) and the Opus 34 Preludes (arranged by Victor Poltoratsky from the piano original) are superbly polished. 
 Lilya Zilberstein, at 24, is also an impressive discovery. 
 Her first record shows her to be as musical as she is technically accomplished. 
 The pithy violence of Shostakovich's First Sonata does not come naturally to her, but she is at home in the limpid impressionism of Rachmaninov's G major Prelude, which on its own makes this disc worth having. 
 The lyrical and passionate aspects of Shostakovich, rather than the bitterly satirical, also bring out the best in Julian Lloyd Webber's playing. 
 His elegiac tempo for the largo of the Cello Sonata allows him a sustained outpouring of feeling. 
 John McCabe's accompanying, too, is wonderfully supportive. 
 The Sonata is imaginatively coupled with Britten's, written after his first meeting with Shostakovich in 1961. 
 The usual characters of the two composers are reversed here; there is little of the English scene-painter in Britten's Sonata, and it stands as one of his most nervous and angry works. 
 Lloyd Webber and McCabe, both amiable men, sense the unease and respond to it deftly. 
 Itzhak Perlman's account of Shostakovich's First Violin Concerto is a more rough-hewn affair. 
 Perlman is usually the slickest of violinists, but here he seems to cultivate a rasping sound that emphasises the work's macabre portrait of Stalin's Russia in the late 1940s. 
 This, along with the concerto by Shostakovich's teacher Glazunov, was recorded live in Tel Aviv in July 1988 so there is a spate of clapping at the end. 
 But the acoustic captured by the engineers is reasonably spacious. 
 I have reservations about Perlman and Mehta's treatment of the Glazunov, though, which seems neither as richly romantic as Oscar Shumsky's on Chandos, nor as glittering as Anne-Sophie Mutter's on Erato: the other two versions to appear in the last year. 
 In this silkiest of works there needs to be an elegant bonhomie, mixed with a hint of gentle sadness, which quite eludes the Israel PO and the soloist, who seem intent on squeezing out each last drip of sentiment &mdash; surely a misunderstanding of the composer's style and aspirations. 
 MUSIC / Enlightened views: OAE / Mackerras &mdash; Queen Elizabeth Hall 
 By TESS KNIGHTON 
 HAYDN-LOVERS are in for a good time this autumn: coming up are the Haydn at Esterhaza concerts at the Wigmore Hall (part of the Magyarok Britain Salutes Hungary Festival); already on display is the Haydn and England exhibition at the British Library; and just started is the Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment's QEH Haydn series concentrating on his late choral works. 
 The opening concert &mdash; a performance of The Creation, conducted by Sir Charles Mackerras &mdash; sets a high standard for the remaining seven concerts in the series. 
 The ingredients were just right: three highly intelligent soloists (Lynne Dawson, Anthony Rolfe Johnson and David Wilson-Johnson); a small but alert choir (excellently trained by Julian Clarkson); a top-name period-instrument orchestra; and a conductor not afraid to cherish every aspect of Haydn's extraordinary score. 
 This was music-making of a high order. 
 Mackerras's account was compassionate but redblooded, direct but full of charm. 
 It did not set out to be radically different, though Haydn's colourful scoring was certainly enhanced by the use of period instruments (including a fortepiano in the recitatives and a bass line reinforced more consistently by bass trombone and contra bassoon), but it succeeded in being unforced and unfettered. 
 He made the most of his superb wind section, used the extra clarity of the strings to underline the richness of the harmony, and encouraged the brass to cut through the texture and pin down the rhythm as, for example, in the exhilarating chorus &bquo;Achieved is the Glorious Work&equo;. 
 The audiences at the first performances of The Creation in Vienna in the late 1790s were entranced by Haydn's musical depictions of every living creature from the mighty eagle to the lowly worm. 
 Only a short while later these were accused (by Schiller amongst others) of being not worthy of him - &bquo;Fit only for the nursery, to use in connection with Noah's Ark&equo; &mdash; but the truth is they are irresistible. 
 Lynne Dawson's clear voice soared and trilled through &bquo;The Birds&equo; number, while Wilson-Johnson's worm was creepily sinuous. 
 This was an uplifting experience &mdash; as Haydn intended it should be. 
 Days Like These 
 By IAN IRVINE 
 10 October, 1903 RAYMOND ASQUITH writes to Lady Manners from Aberdeenshire: &bquo;We had a storm yesterday and went out to watch the waves: I ventured too far out onto a rock and was knocked flat on my face against a granite floor by one of the biggest rollers ever seen on this coast: I never felt such a blow; luckily I fell in a crevice and wasn't washed away; but I was stunned for a few seconds, and when I got up my face and knee were streaming with blood. 
 Margot is always splendid on these occasions; she took me back to the house and covered me with ice and raw beef: but in spite of all I am a most revolting sight today and shall be for a week or more &mdash; lame in one leg, blind in one eye, and with a nose like Cyrano&hellip; 
 I'm glad you can't see me: you would never speak to me again.&equo; 
 10 October, 1979 STEPHEN SPENDER, teaching in Lynchburg, Virginia, writes in his journal: &bquo;My class, which I took last night, seems irremediable. 
 I have really almost given up trying to discuss their poems, and just talk about poetry. 
 In one of the poems were the following lines: I seem as though from a polished ship Torn Between the anchors at the dock And the currents of the sea. 
 &bquo;This doesn't work. 
 You can't think of a ship as having an emotional life divided between the attachment to its anchors and the call of the tides,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;She personalizes the ship,&equo; a friend of the poetess said, in a just audible squeak. 
 &bquo;Well, even if the ship was you &mdash; I mean &mdash; if you were the ship &mdash; it would be absurd,&equo; I argued, beginning to feel dizzy. 
 However I could see that the class was against me. 
 Crushed ambitions and women's lib feelings had rallied to the author's right to identify herself with a polished ship. 
 &bquo;When I got back to my apartment I ate some ham and beans, and opened a bottle of rather rust-coloured claret. 
 I ate too much and drank nearly three-quarters of the bottle. 
 I felt disgusted with myself, repelled by my heavy, unlovable weight of flesh.&equo; 
 14 October, 1969 TONY BENN records in his diary: &bquo;In the evening Caroline and I went to Number 10 for a dinner for the American astronauts, the first three men to have been on the moon. 
 Neil Armstrong and Buz Aldrin and their wives were there and Harold had laid on the evening in grand style with lots of television coverage. 
 I sat next to Pat Collins who is a very intelligent and delightful woman. 
 I felt sorry that she had George Brown, completely pickled, on the other side of her.&equo; 
 TELEVISION / He knew what he liked 
 By THOMAS SUTCLIFFE 
 AN OBJECT lesson for all those who bemoan the artistic indifference of government, last night's Omnibus (BBC 1) looked at a political leader who took the closest interest in art, a mediocre and embittered water-colourist who eventually turned to another medium &mdash; mass emotion and warfare. 
 &bquo;The Fuhrer loves art because he is himself an artist,&equo; Goebbels announced in a contemporary newsreel, at which, no doubt, all genuine artists looked uneasily towards the border. 
 This is still not an easy subject-matter &mdash; when the Royal Academy put together its recent retrospective of &bquo;German Art in the Twentieth-Century&equo; it dealt with the Nazi years by ignoring them altogether &mdash; a decision that put it in line with the orthodox view of the work's quality and conveniently avoided the embarrassing possibility that these works &mdash; kitsch, sunlit expressions of heroic physical vigour and serene landscape &mdash; might still prove more popular than German expressionism. 
 Omnibus's simplistic script favoured show-and-tell over analysis but that dangerous moral &mdash; that these years were a triumph of popular taste in art, not a suppression of it &mdash; could be glimpsed now and then. 
 &bquo;The Nazis didn't invent styles&equo;, the narration pointed out, &bquo;they occupied those that already existed&equo;. 
 In some cases this was rather literally the case &mdash; the syrupy domestic interiors beloved of German nineteenth-century painters began to reappear with pictures of the Fuhrer on the wall and the Volkischer Beobachter lying folded on the table. 
 Elsewhere the co-option was more subtle; the addition of the word &bquo;German&equo; to a landscape painting would usually guarantee its success. 
 Omnibus chronicled all this with exemplary thoroughness but finally elided the real aesthetic questions &mdash; of a battle between art that invites the viewer to think and art that passes through the mind leaving only a sugary trace of complacent pleasure. 
 &bquo;Aesthetic judgements are impossible&equo;, the narration concluded, a denial which implied that paintings are only as good or bad as the political opinions of those that paint them. 
 Earlier we had been told that some &bquo;lascivious&equo; nudes were &bquo;a sign of increasing decadence at the centre of an inflexible regime&equo;, a phrase with some deeply troubling echoes of vocabulary. 
 That this film, of all films, was prepared to judge paintings merely as symptoms of moral decay, was a little startling. 
 MUSICALS / Bows of Holly: Mark Steyn reviews London's latest musical biography, Buddy, at The Victoria Palace 
 By MARK STEYN 
 THE TEXANS drawl &bquo;Y'all&equo;, blacks go &bquo;Yo&equo;, Hispanics leer &bquo;Hey, ameeeeeeeego!&equo;. 
 And towering above these stage cliches is, of course, the driven genius whose music cannot be stemmed by the forces of reaction. 
 Who is it this time? 
 Wagner, Glenn Miller, Jason Donovan? 
 No matter; only the accents change &mdash; and the pants: here, the squares wear slacks, the good guys blue-jeans. 
 Warned not to sing rock'n'roll on a c&amp;w station, Buddy Holly insists, &bquo;I gotta play ma music.&equo; 
 Misunderstood by Decca Records, he maintains, &bquo;I wanna play ma music ma way.&equo; 
 Even when the hits start, he's not content. 
 &bquo;We gotta take our music more serious,&equo; he tells the Crickets, who remain unconvinced. 
 &bquo;You got money, you got fame,&equo; he pleads, &bquo;what you want to booze for?&equo; 
 Booze? 
 We're midway through Act II and a solitary six-pack has yet to hove into view. 
 But this is a plot development &mdash; the plot development &mdash; and, if it involves turning a couple of Aled Jones types into Oliver Reeds, why let logic get in the way? 
 As it happens, there is a kind of logic behind Buddy. 
 The most common reason for a biomusical is opportunism: take a star like Judy Garland or John Lennon, and you pick up a hit title and a hit score ready-made. 
 Now, Alan Janes's play matches the well-loved songs with equally well-loved dialogue in a K-Tel Golden Greats collection of Dramatists' Reliables. 
 Choke up at The Price Of Fame: &bquo;I give &bquo;em everything and they stick a knife in my back.&equo; 
 Fight back those tears at The Inevitable Parting: &bquo;You and me, boy, I reckon we've come to the end of our road.&equo; 
 Marvel at The Little Woman Behind The Man: &bquo;I'd like to sing a song fer a special girlfriend who's kinda important to me.&equo; 
 The justification for this is authenticity. 
 &bquo;All that happens in the play is based on fact,&equo; Janes pledges solemnly in the programme notes. 
 &bquo;As we know, truth is often stranger than fiction.&equo; 
 Often? 
 Most of us prefer to watch Dallas than our neighbours' home-movies, because, when it comes down to it, we know that truth is generally a lot duller than fiction. 
 Occasionally, though, a dramatist will uncover someone with an interesting story, regardless of how unknown or vaguely remembered the subject is. 
 How many of us can now recall the real Maria von Trapp or Fanny Brice? 
 They live only through The Sound Of Music and Funny Girl. 
 Buddy Holly comes somewhere between the subjects of those and more parasitic biographies. 
 His records are still played, but his personality, unexposed through movies or extensive TV interviews, is almost entirely unknown. 
 It is, in theory, the best of both worlds &mdash; except that Buddy Holly, by all accounts, was not terribly interesting. 
 He was born in Lubbock, married a nice Spanish girl and died young in a &bquo;plane crash in 1959. 
 All that counts are the records, a rhythmically unusual Tex-Mex fusion of rock'n'roll and older western elements, pioneering what became the standard pop instrumentation of two guitars, bass and drums. 
 The lyrics are another matter. 
 Of the two prototype rock songwriters, it's the more worldly Chuck Berry you turn to for the authentic picture of teenage pleasures in Eisenhower's America: &bquo;Gonna write a little letter, Gonna mail it to my local deejay.&equo; 
 Or: &bquo;Cruising and playing the radio With no particular place to go.&equo; 
 Berry's songs are plausible emblems of rock'n'roll rebellion or, at any rate, youthful hedonism. 
 Buddy invites us to regard Holly in the same light, mocking (in a horribly nudging re-creation) Lubbock old-timers like The Hayriders, who sing: &bquo;When the sun goes down on Blue Ridge Mountain It's the time to whistle in your ear.&equo; 
 At least, this has a surreal daftness. 
 The voice of rock'n'roll, in contrast, is almost unrelievedly soupy. 
 If you didn't know the tunes, you'd assume Holly's lyrics decorated some innocent backporch spooners from the turn-of-the-century: &bquo;Stars appear and the shadows are fallin' You can hear my honey callin'.&equo; 
 Or: &bquo;You give me all your lovin' And your turtle-dovin'.&equo; 
 Or: &bquo;When Cupid shot his dart He shot it at your heart.&equo; 
 Not only are these songs impossible to use dramatically, they're also too vague to use as incidental music, to underline or punctuate aspects of Holly's life or the 1950s more generally. 
 &bquo;I wrote it for you,&equo; he assures his gal before the ballads, but how can you tell? 
 All you can do with these songs is sing them, and Buddy fails even to manage that with any subtlety. 
 The finales to both Acts are effectively concerts, the sort of agreeably naff rock'n'roll revival that might just about pass muster as a Capital Gold one-nighter down the Hammersmith Palais. 
 And, for all the appeal of his singing and playing, Paul Hipp comes out pretty dull between the numbers. 
 To camouflage the failures of the play, Andy Walmsley has created a set which resembles a pile-up of roadside hoardings: Oldsmobile, Van Heusen shirts, Texaco Premium Type. 
 Rob Bettinson, the director, has deduced that he ought to have these images plus disc-jockeys, radio commercials, midwestern hops, but he doesn't seem to know why. 
 Like most shows which are manufactured with an eye to commercial success (Winnie, High Society, to name only Buddy's predecessors at the Victoria Palace), this one will probably fail. 
 It's not as if there aren't aspects of his career that aren't worth exploring: how did he come to use drums, then almost unknown in Texan country line-ups? 
 Was it true, as the chart performance of &bquo;Heartbeat&equo; (his last release) suggests, that his three-year career was already on the wane? 
 And surely any dramatist ought to be able to move us with that final night of Holly's life, when his musicians (including Waylon Jennings) gave their places on the &bquo;plane to the Big Bopper and Ritchie Valens. 
 The author's job is not merely to offer an illustrated Who's Who entry, but to turn elements of a man's life into a dramatic entity. 
 And, if Holly's too boring for that, perhaps the best approach would be to write about his impact on others. 
 That, after all, is what Don McLean did so brilliantly in &bquo;American Pie&equo;, a personal reaction to &bquo;the day the music died&equo;. 
 THEATRE / More than their jobs are worth: Peter Kemp on Roger Hall's Roll On Friday at the Palace, Watford 
 By PETER KEMP 
 The play Roll On Friday is one that very soon has you echoing its title's wish that time would pass more rapidly. 
 In its attempt to satirise an institution supposedly dominated by tedium, repetition and pointlessness, it perversely contrives to consist of little but these things itself. 
 The setting is Room 133: the stores branch of a vast government department in Wellington, New Zealand. 
 Into this cluttered little office &mdash; on a wet and windswept Monday morning in 1974 &mdash; burst five of its personnel. 
 In accordance with the procedures governing Roger Hall's comedy, they do so at regularly-spaced intervals, each entering with a gasp and clad in a ridiculous profusion of scarves, hats and rainwear, so that his droll point about the awfulness of the country's climate can be adequately appreciated. 
 It is usual in this office comedy, you quickly discover, for jokes to be transmitted at least in triplicate. 
 Often, the same bit of flimsy facetiousness gets disgorged with a frequency that suggests the whole thing is a product of some mechanically chortling Xerox machine. 
 Every 20 minutes or so, the play guffawingly alludes to the non-arrival of some long-ordered calculators. 
 When they finally appear, they turn out &mdash; in what for this play amounts to a considerable comic twist &mdash; to have been fitted with the wrong plug. 
 As a human variant on such running &mdash; or lumbering &mdash; gags, there is Wally, a farcically uncooperative caretaker who puts in a regulation grumpy appearance in each of the play's four scenes in order to enunciate his catchphrase, &bquo;Nothing to do with me&equo;. 
 Much of the play's humour comes straight from stock. 
 There are jests about administrative gaffes ('overtrousers' mistyped as &bquo;overt rousers&equo;) or about the craziness of bureaucracy (the staff have no order forms because they have run out of order forms with which to order them). 
 Traditional sniggerings are amply catered for, too. 
 The office's tubby female employee is the constant butt of lines like: &bquo;Of course you're not fat, Beryl&hellip; pull up a couple of chairs and sit down.&equo; 
 'Mind my yoghurt', she squeals when a workmate squeezes her breasts. 
 A further dismal feature of the evening is Hall's penchant for the unsurprising surprise. 
 Predictably, a much-mentioned colleague absent on sick-leave gets the job two of the characters on stage are rivals for. 
 Lumps of pathos intermittently introduce a note of sentiment into all of this. 
 Two of the men turn out to have family problems. 
 Plump Beryl who talks to the office cactus is lovelorn, it is revealed. 
 The awkward changes of tone caused by these disclosures are managed with some skill by the Watford cast, all of whom also do their impressive best to polish up the lustreless comic lines they are lumbered with. 
 In particular, Simon Slater as the sarky office cad and Annette Badland as Beryl put in performances far above the level of the sitcom script. 
 Made up of four 30-minute scenes, in each of which the same people say and do the same things in the same setting, Roll On Friday, it is no surprise to learn, has been developed into a five-year television series in New Zealand and Australia. 
 The only way in which it even faintly stirs your brain cells is in causing you to wonder what on earth it's doing on the stage at Watford. 
 THEATRE / Dunsinane via Bali: Macbeth &mdash; Marlowe, Canterbury 
 By ALEX RENTON 
 ACTORS have researched Shakespeare in prisons, zoos, hospitals: David Garrick constructed his Lear in a lunatic asylum, studying an old man who had managed to drop his daughter out of a window. 
 Rather more fun and doubtless just as fruitful was the Odyssey Theatre Company's research for their Macbeth: six weeks spent with the support of the Scottish Arts Council on the Indonesian island of Bali. 
 The official justification is that in Bali the company could work with local performers and learn to &bquo;shift our centres of gravity away from the head, down into the centres of our bodies&equo;. 
 On stage this is translated into the uncomfortable standing squat familiar from karate movies: knees splayed and bottom out. 
 In Bali, we are also told, life can be spent among people who daily interact with the forces of good and evil in nature. 
 This is the only really objectionable thing about Odyssey's odyssey; a daily communion with good and evil is not in any way the experience of the characters in Macbeth. 
 The intervention is extraordinary, and to think of it otherwise risks ignoring how the interest of the play lies in the psychological, in the testing of our sympathy and understanding of the Macbeths. 
 We get little of that. 
 Instead there is a designer's travelogue: the production (no director is listed, but Nigel Jamieson heads the company) veers all over the Far East and indeed round to the Caribbean. 
 It sports an instructor in kabuki, and much seems Japanese: the costumes, the men's top-knots and a fair part of the staging seem to come from Kurosawa. 
 For the domestic scenes &mdash; and these include the most moving Slaughter of the Macduffs sequence I have seen &mdash; we come right back to European naturalism. 
 There are many other good things in the production, a passionate and gripping Lady Macbeth from Clare Benedict; witches dressed to look like maggots; and fight scenes that presumably use the Balinese experience in becoming savage death dances. 
 The music, using Gamelan instruments, is a pleasure, though it can occasionally obscure the text. 
 Focus is often concentrated on the young, and on Emma Bernard who plays both Fleance and Macbeth's son. 
 At the play's opening she stands centre stage, silent in a white shift, until a stab brings red cascading from her belly. 
 The point seems to be that Macbeth's greatest crime is in tampering with the future. 
 But, as so often when a design idea takes over a production, an awful lot gets missed. 
 The text has been cut quite wantonly and only for expediency, you feel. 
 Ian Halcrow's Macbeth looks great but never draws us close, and he and others swallow or truncate their lines as though they cared very little for them. 
 This, according to the programme, is Kechak, a Balinese vocal technique involving &bquo;complex cross-rhythms and syncopations&equo;. 
 The talents of this company are obvious: it will be interesting to see what they do next, especially if the research happens at home, in London. 
 Second Thoughts: Presence of the past: Arthur Marwick on the principles that still sustain his argument in &bquo;The Nature of History&equo; (Macmillan &pound;8.95) 
 By ARTHUR MARWICK 
 &bquo;AH, DOING an E H Carr, eh?&equo;, was the invariable response when, at the end of the 1960s, I told people what I was up to. 
 For introducing students to history at Edinburgh University the basic text was Carr's What is History? 
 Carr drove home fundamental points, but said nothing about the actual working practices of historians, and, in his inspirational advocacy of a new kind of socialist history, left students with the impression that the solid, source-based stuff which formed their staple diet might as well be cast into the dustbin. 
 After almost 10 years in University history teaching I was concerned that my students seemed to have very little idea of how history actually came to be written and of what criteria might be used to decide whether one book was more worth reading than another. 
 I particularly wished to clarify why one studies history at all. 
 There was a fair deal of Oxbridge waffle around about history being &bquo;a training of the mind&equo;, a means of understanding the other chap's point of view. 
 From Dutch historian Gustav Renier I derived the formulation that history is a social necessity: in face of government philistinism and the fantasies of cultural theory, this, I believe, is the bedrock upon which claims for a proper respect for historical study should be founded. 
 Knowing our past does not automatically yield solutions to the problems of the present: but without a knowledge of the past it would be impossible even to contemplate addressing these problems. 
 The achievements of professional history are staggering: whatever topic you choose, you'll find there exists a sound body of historical knowledge. 
 To me, the nature of history lay not in pseudo-scientific speculation, but in the aims and achievements of working historians. 
 The heart of the book was a chapter on &bquo;The Historian At Work&equo; which I do believe was original in setting out the processes which historians go through, from discovering and analysing sources to producing written history at different levels. 
 Elsewhere I made a point of discussing historians, such as Taylor and Elton, whom students would actually be reading. 
 The trouble is that, today, much of this appears appallingly naive and disgustingly obsequious. 
 Further, the privilege of age is to develop prejudices of one's own: pronounced views about historical explanation, interdisciplinary studies, and how film and other visual sources should be used by historians. 
 In my second thoughts my aims remain the same, but are more thoroughly developed: and all these grovelling references to &bquo;great&equo; historians and their &bquo;brilliant&equo; works have been extirpated. 
 Historians are artisans, not geniuses. 
 BOOK REVIEW / The fading of Eco: a cautionary tale: &bquo;Foucault's Pendulum&equo; &mdash; Umberto Eco: Tr. 
 William Weaver Secker &amp; Warburg, 14.95 pounds 
 By HUGO BARNACLE 
 WHAT HAPPENS in Foucault's Pendulum is that three editors at a Milan publishing house, vetting manuscripts for a series of books on the occult, decide to amuse themselves by connecting up every conspiracy theory advanced by their half-baked authors and fabricating an elaborate master-plan which explains the whole of world history. 
 For reasons which never seem quite convincing, given the tediousness of the material and the fact that the three do not even believe in it, this becomes an obsessive hobby over a period of years. 
 They put it all on computer. 
 In go the Pyramids, Atlantis, the Holy Grail, the Knights Templar, the Freemasons, Napoleon, the Paris Metro map, Hitler, Ayers Rock and, unfortunately, much more besides; out comes a dread secret to do with control of the &bquo;telluric currents&equo; which cause earthquakes or continental drift or something; not that it much matters, since they made it all up. 
 When the various occult organisations get wind of the non-existent secret's existence, of course, they take it in deadly earnest and will stop at nothing to discover it and so make themselves Masters of the World. 
 Thus the editors &mdash; Belbo the disillusioned romantic, Diotallevi the dyspeptic amateur Cabalist, and Casaubon our hero-narrator &mdash; are in something of a jam. 
 It is a slight story, padded out to a mind-deadening 640 pages by the monotonous recital of the great redundant master plan itself. 
 Did I forget to mention Stonehenge? 
 The Essenes? 
 The Paulicians? 
 The Cathars? 
 The Jesuits? 
 Shakespeare? 
 The Rosicrucians? 
 Cagliostro? 
 Nicholas II? 
 The over-extension of the idea is ludicrous, but not ludicrous enough: the connectedness of absolutely everything is the first principle of conpiracy theory anyway, so for want of exaggeration or originality the joke falls horribly flat. 
 The book's unintentional humour is a little stronger. 
 To start with, there is the clunking obviousness of Casaubon's name, a cod-erudite allusion to George Eliot's mythomanic clergyman and his abortive Key to All Mythologies. 
 Just to explode any lingering subtlety, Unberto Eco even has someone ask, &bquo;Wasn't he a character in Middlemarch?&equo; 
 It is Casaubon, too, who supplies the most drolly wooden lines. 
 &bquo;We didn't know&equo;, he says as the three embark on the master plan, &bquo;that we were playing with fire &mdash; Greek fire,&equo; he adds, &bquo;the kind that burns and destroys&equo;, in case we don't know what playing with fire means. 
 This might be a glitch in the translation, but when Casaubon observes, &bquo;Life isn't simple, the way it is in detective stories&equo;, the gobsmacking banality can only be the author's. 
 No irony seems intended. 
 All characters offer splendid lessons in how not to incorporate research in dialogue, but again Casaubon is first among equals. 
 &bquo;Remember,&equo; he tells the others while summarising the Crusades at dissertation length, &bquo;the new kingdom of Jerusalem was sort of the California of the day, the place you went to make your fortune.&equo; 
 Later, to allow Eco to work in a chunk of St Bernard's writings, Casaubon actually takes a piece of paper from his pocket and says, &bquo;I brought this quotation with me, because it's worth hearing&hellip;&equo; 
 He is standing in a crowded bar at the time. 
 We are not told how rapidly the place empties out. 
 The thriller element is entirely a matter of cliche. 
 We begin with Belbo phoning from Paris to say, &bquo;They're after me,&equo; and the telephone going dead just as he is about to give the password for the computer file which holds the final explanation known to him alone. 
 We end, after a protracted flashback, with Casaubon unable to go to the police because nobody would believe his story. 
 In between we pass through the inevitable stages of people disappearing because they know too much. 
 The baddie saying. 
 &bquo;You have been very clever &mdash; in fact, too clever&equo; and the goodie saying, &bquo;Kill me, but let the girl go&equo; must be taken as read, but Casaubon does not fail to intone after the not tremendously exciting climax, &bquo;Maybe I imagined the whole thing.&equo; 
 The cliches may well be deliberate, but in a way this only makes them even more tiresome. 
 The constant references to Hammett, Chandler and Casablanca, supposed to be chic, are simply commonplaces. 
 Eco's social perceptions, too, are inclined to be trite. 
 Much play is made of the dual nature of Woman as madonna and whore: a chestnut by now, surely to God. 
 And Casaubon says of his left-wing, bar-propping days in the early Seventies, &bquo;I could write the political history of those years based on how Red Label gradually gave way to 12-year-old Ballantine and then to single malt.&equo; 
 You are what you consume. 
 Student rebels become mere trendy bourgeois. 
 I think we've heard this before as well. 
 The only character with any psychological depth is Belbo, the wistfully unhappy writer manque who asks, &bquo;Why write novels? 
 Rewrite history.&equo; 
 Umberto Eco himself clearly sympathises. 
 Belbo's iffy relationship with the evasive Lorenza Pelegrini is is deftly touched in, and his reminiscences of a wartime childhood in Piedmont are the only passages to achieve any distinction or elegance of style, or any vestige of human interest. 
 It is worth skipping through the rest just to read them, but their bearing on the story proper &mdash; Belbo is a man who missed his moment, and conspiracy theory is the refuge of the disappointed &mdash; is specious. 
 If Foucault's Pendulum fails as a novel, does it work as an intellectual game? 
 The ancient manuscript which sparks it all off is ingeniously devised to yield two possible meanings, one mystic, one mundane. 
 As for the computer password, on the other hand, this reviewer guessed it in one and had to wait twenty-odd pages for Casaubon to catch up. 
 And if the vast preponderant mass of occult lore is finally seen as empty and meaningless, so is the book, in which case we are wasting our time. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Tricks of the trade on show: &bquo;The Abundant Dreamer&equo; &mdash; Harold Brodkey: Cape, 12.95 pounds 
 By JONATHAN KEATES 
 PYTHAGORAS is said to have derived his doctrine of metempsychosis, the transmigration of souls, from discussions with Indian Brahmins. 
 I am not sure what Harold Brodkey may have been in his last incarnation, but he has now reached that most enviable of all earthly states, that of the American cult writer. 
 Awed critical voices salute his very occasional emergence in print, and invocations of Raymond Carver, Peter Taylor and Ellen Gilchrist are silenced upon reverent lips by a mere mention of his name. 
 He has been compared to Freud, Whitman and Wordsworth, although the late John Cheever, in one of his more paranoid outbursts, suggested that he was merely an invention of the New Yorker. 
 One rather sees what he meant. 
 Brodkey's prose, stately, handsome, so intensely, so painstakingly devised, is the perfect concomitant of those advertisements for the classic suit or the traditional chair which enhance the magazine's increasingly implausible air of quilted, buttonbacked ease. 
 About everything he writes hangs a faint savour of calculation. 
 We watch him, as it were, standing back rather too obviously from his work, its rhythms and syntax, its narrative tricks and technical effects suffused with their author's pleasure in his own accomplishment. 
 The themes that pervade this collection of stories have an appropriate gravity. 
 Behind the latticework of stylistic decorum lurk the preoccupations of a perturbed middle age, urbane, somewhat over-educated, confronting coarseness and spontaneity with the weapons of obliquity and understatement. 
 Parents and children stretch out flailing arms towards each other in fumbling efforts to communicate. 
 In &bquo;On The Waves&equo; Henry, a divorced father allowed to meet his daughter Melinda in Venice, sits in a gondola meditating on distance, trust and expectation against a background of ruthless infant prattle. 
 The vision which opens &bquo;His Son, in His Arms, in Light Aloft&equo; is that of the father as inescapable pursuer. 
 &bquo;The oddly shrewd-hearted torpor of being carried home in the dark, a tourist, in my father's arms&equo; enshrines the notion of love as essentially menacing and predatory. 
 In a more expansive variant of this theme, Brodkey's central weakness is painfully exposed. 
 &bquo;A Story in an Almost Classic Mode&equo; aims both at analytical biography and, as its title implies, at something grander and more generalised. 
 Brodkey's relations with his adoptive mother Doris, a Jewish Clytemnestra to his haunted Orestes, involve a bizarre attempt at incestuous symbiosis ('The feeling of obliteration or castration or whatever it was was unsettling as hell') and a deathbed reconciliation with a nervous breakdown as a postlude. 
 This is all very dignified, courageous and sincere. 
 It is also, like several of Brodkey's other stories, both here and in his earlier First Love And Other Sorrows, inescapably kitsch. 
 The final scene, with its tear-jerking hospital-bed supplications for forgiveness, is neither more nor less than the &bquo;I love you&equo;, &bquo;I love you too Momma&equo; curtain-line that has become mandatory in a thousand soap operas. 
 In the end Brodkey's apparently stupendous equipment as a writer, that sense of an almost Flaubertian anxiety about pitch and cadence which plays about every sentence, can scarcely conceal the second-hand quality of his inventions. 
 These people, the pubescent schoolkid, the 45-year-old English professor, the dim college girl, we have met before, and we might be pleased to see them again, but neither they nor their predicaments quite justify so uncritical a veneration. 
 Handel once threw a young composer's music out of the window, saying it wanted air. 
 Brodkey's talent is robust enough to survive a similar treatment. 
 BOOK REIVEW / The trail goes cold: &bquo;Polar Star'-Martin Cruz Smith: Collins Harvill, 12.95 pounds 
 By ANTHONY LANE 
 OUT IN the Bering Sea, all is not well. 
 Onto the deck of the good ship Polar Star comes a net of fish, 40 tons of cod and pollock, flatfish and crabs. 
 Someone looks closely and cuts it open to see what comes out. 
 Never mind the pollocks, here's Zita Patiashvili. 
 A Soviet kitchen hand, hit on the head and thrown overboard. 
 Martin Cruz Smith is a dab hand at beginnings, as readers of Gorky Park will remember; but he tends to fumble his middle sections, and by the time the climax arrives he's all fingers and thumbs. 
 Polar Star is no exception; its lovely clueless opening soon snarls up in a mess of motives and half-finished characters. 
 The author seems to have wandered towards the edge of the plot and fallen overboard himself; one misses the satisfying smack of resolution. 
 Yet there are strong amusements along the way, not least those provided by Zita herself, who although dead and stretched out on an autopsy table, still has one more shock in store. 
 Eels come into it somehow, but not in a way that can be described in a family newspaper. 
 More pleasant is the re-appearance of Arkady Renko, Senior Investigator from Moscow and hero of Gorky Park, now disgraced and employed below decks on the Polar Star. 
 There he works on the Slime Line, which is basically rather like the Northern Line, but slightly more regular. 
 A conveyor belt brings you the latest catch, which you then gut, clean and pack for freezing. 
 Overhead signs read: &bquo;Strive for a Decisive Upswing in the Supply of Fish Protein!&equo; 
 There seems to be a terribly quiet joke going on here, based on Renko's former reputation as a bit of a cold fish. 
 Released from duty and put on the case, Renko builds up a long list of suspects, Zita having slept with most of the crew and possibly some of the flatfish. 
 Matters are not helped by the presence of filthy capitalists; in a spirit of grudging co-operation, American trawlers supply the Polar Star with fish and split the proceeds. 
 The Yanks are tough and angry, apart from one who is small and blonde. 
 Renko takes his pleasure with her on the floor of a very small cabin &mdash; his only good break in a grim round of murders and chilblains. 
 The author is numbingly good on the effects of Arctic weather: &bquo;as it left his lips, his breath crystallized, glittered and snowed.&equo; 
 His other forte is in Believe-It-Or-Not items of Russian paranoia: &bquo;just as Soviet railroad tracks are a wider gauge than foreign ones to prevent an invasion by train, Soviet VCR's took a larger tape to prevent an influx of foreign pornography.&equo; 
 But for all the research, Polar Star is unsure of itself, tacking back and forth between a leisurely exposition of this frozen world and the more exacting pace of the whodunnit, with occasional bobs towards the spy story. 
 Martin Cruz Smith has an intriguing hero to play with; if he could only Strive For a Decisive Upswing in Plot Design, his mastery of the chilly thriller would be complete. 
 BOOK REVIEW / Sorrow drowned: &bquo;The Waterline&equo; &mdash; Joseph Olshan: Bloomsbury 12.95 pounds 
 By ANDREW ST GEORGE 
 &bquo;I'VE TRIED to imagine what it's like to drown. 
 You thrash around for a few minutes, trying not to breathe, but you have to inhale sometimes.&equo; 
 Death by water haunts Billy Kaplan. 
 He was seven when Mark Rosen drowned, the last to see the two-year-old alive; now 20, he still feels guilty. 
 Joseph Olshan's fascinating third novel, The Waterline, charts the emotional journey which Billy and his parents, Susan and Michael, undertake to arrive at this peaceful coexistence with their past; each narrates one of the novel's three sections. 
 Olshan makes Susan a powerful, smart, sensual woman moving surefootedly through the opulent Westchester County jungle where the Kaplans live: she issues orders to the au pair, knows the Manhattan-Hartsdale train times, and deals honestly with a husband who has taken a sexual vacation from her on the very afternoon of the Rosen drowning. 
 Later, she divorces Michael and lives with a spiritualist, Ravi, with whom she moves to New Mexico. 
 Unfortunately, Olshan stretches belief when he then introduces Susan's sister Tina, a virtuoso pianist now in psychiatric care, whose marriage, too, verges on disintegration. 
 So the narratives from Michael and Billy have much to recoup. 
 Michael grows into fatherhood and bachelorhood with graceless ease. 
 Billy's narrative addresses the drowned boy, giving a perspective on the past. 
 Having returned to haunt the suburbs, he begins a course of penance, teaching children to swim, joining the college swim team. 
 &bquo;I had become a strong swimmer mainly to conquer fear.&equo; 
 He survives a therapist, a suicide attempt and the sudden accidental death of a friend. 
 Finally, travelling upstate on the anniversary of the drowning, he takes a swim in a blood-red lake and meets a girl diving beyond the waterline. 
 He tells her his complete story and they become lovers: &bquo;I realised this must be the beginning of my healing&equo;. 
 The Waterline, then, returns to its origins, as the case study which is Billy's life painfully dredges up the first scenes of his disorder. 
 Olshan brilliantly captures a life in an incident: a broken marriage in a frayed bedspread, a grief or an infidelity in the domestic smells which waft through the book. 
 But The Waterline's absorbing issue, forgiveness of oneself and others, disappears in the three narratives overcrowded with portent and incident, as if clear thinking quailed at the messiness of the world. 
 Recommended Books 
 By ANDREW ST GEORGE 
 The Mezzanine by Nicholson Baker, Granta Books &pound;10.95. 
 The witty account of an American lunch-break, packed with surprising digressions. 
 Reviewed by Anthony Lane, 2 September. 
 London Fields by Martin Amis, Cape &pound;11.95. 
 A typically startling and ambitious novel of murder and other threats. 
 Reviewed by Wendy Steiner, 23 September. 
 The Trick of It by Michael Frayn, Viking &pound;11.95. 
 A novel about novel-writing, which handles its tricky subject with a light comic touch. 
 Reviewed by Mark Lawson, 23 September. 
 Europe, Europe by Hans Martin Enzensberger, Hutchinson &pound;14.95. 
 A lively tour of continental culture, seeking for signs of unity and predicting a grim future. 
 Reviewed by Anthony Burgess, 30 September. 
 The Bellarosa Connection by Saul Bellow, Penguin &pound;3.50. 
 Another late novella to follow on from A Theft (published earlier this year), offering similarly refined pleasures in its account of Jewish suffering and success. 
 Reviewed by Anthony Quinn, 7 October. 
 Eighteenth-century Women Poets edited by Roger Lonsdale, Oxford &pound;20. 
 This new anthology should disturb many literary preconceptions with its forceful and charming discoveries, taken from the work of more than a hundred women. 
 Reviewed by Claire Tomalin, 7 October. 
 Wartime by Paul Fussell, Oxford &pound;15. 
 This survey of personal experiences, ranging from close combat to literary society, constructs a memorable portrait of the last war. 
 Reviewed by Tim Blanning, 12 October. 
 BOOK REVIEW / America's double voice: &bquo;Willa Cather: A Life Saved Up&equo; &mdash; Hermione Lee: Virago 12.99 pounds 
 By A. S. BYATT 
 THE GREAT writers of the English novel are both male and female. 
 This is not so with the American novel, with its themes of male companionship and confrontation with death. 
 Women there have had to fight harder to be heard. 
 Willa Cather is not well known in this country, though her major work is now in print in Virago paperbacks. 
 It is to be hoped that Hermione Lee's excellent new book will help to change that, for Cather is one of the most original and inventive of modern writers, a more powerful artist, for instance, than her contemporary Edith Wharton. 
 Cather was born in 1873 and died in 1947. 
 She was taken as a child from Virginia to the plains of Nebraska, whose earth and immigrant farmers form the subject of her central fiction. 
 She went to the University of Nebraska, and was a star pupil, writing scathing reviews of books, theatre and opera, cross-dressing and forming passionate attachments to other women. 
 She worked as a journalist on McClure's magazine, and gave it up to write. 
 She shared her home with a woman friend and was intensely secretive about her privacy, leaving complicated embargoes in her will on the publication of her letters, many of which she destroyed. 
 She was intelligent and prejudiced, formidable and stolid, passionate and reserved. 
 She created new prose rhythms in the English language, and new formal possibilities for the novel. 
 She has often been criticised for not doing, or doing imperfectly, things she was not trying to do. 
 She wrote novels about the frontier, about poverty, difficulty, and the American virgin land, but she was not celebrating the American Dream, nor making any Marxist investigation into culture. 
 She also wrote novels about passion, adultery, and death in civilised societies, but she was not interested in psychological drama. 
 She wrote historical novels about Mexico and Quebec, but she was not interested in the drama of conquest or religious conversion. 
 She has been discovered by the feminists, who have rescued her from being seen as a minor pastoralist; but in certain cases, they have also subject her to psycho-symbolic sexual analysis which she would have loathed, or blamed her for not having cared more for sexual politics or stood out for lesbian sexuality. 
 Hermione Lee is admirably judicious about all this, pointing out both that we have a perfect right to say things about a writer that we would not have said in their lifetime, and that &bquo;to account for Cather's fiction by reading it as an encoding of covert, even guilty sexuality is, I think, both patronising and narrow.&equo; 
 Her own interest is in what she describes as Cather's doubleness. 
 She sees Cather as a writer whose work &bquo;gets its energy from contraries&equo;. 
 Cather explores native American newness but with a deep interest in European cultural forms, the epic and pastoral of Virgil, the opera of Wagner. 
 She is an iconoclast who became a grumpy conservative, rejecting the modern industrial world in a grand wholesale manner. 
 She is interested in religion and its cultural forms, but has a deeper darker interest in anonymous human fates and disappearances. 
 She is interested in the primitive and the raw, both culturally and emotionally, but is endlessly discriminating about the tenacious way in which cultural forms, from cookery to high literature and music, establish themselves and persist. 
 Cather's attitude to writing, Lee points out, is central to these contrasts. 
 She is a very conscious stylist, who constructs the form of her sentences, her paragraphs, her narratives, with precise attention. 
 Yet part of her aim is to &bquo;invent a fictional language which will be as invisible, as transparent, as close as possible to what it speaks of&equo;. 
 She felt she had found her own style in O Pioneers, a style as loose, as fluid, as unemphatic, as shifting as the fine earth of the endless prairies she wrote about. 
 Later she came to depend more upon excision, upon the evocation of what she called &bquo;the thing not said&equo;; castigating Balzac for delivering an excess of information, she praised the hint, the pared-down suggestion. 
 As Hermione Lee says, she combines, in a radically new way, two disparate American voices &mdash; the immediate one of the oral culture, the homespun, the unadorned, and the complex, civilised and allusive one of international modernism. 
 Hermione Lee's preference, which I share, is for the disturbed, dark novels of Cather's middle period &mdash; she is particularly good on The Professor's House, a story whose protagonist contemplates a failing marriage and a philistine world from a writing room containing two dressmakers' dummies, or &bquo;forms&equo;. 
 The centre of this novel is the interpolated tale of the dead and beloved Tom Outland, who discovers a prehistoric and beautiful city in the sun on the mesa, and tells about it in immediate, enthusiastic prose. 
 Hermione Lee pinpoints what I feel about this novel &mdash; that although its subject is depression and waiting for death, it does not feel gloomy because of its own formal delight, its interest in language, including the contrasted languages of the sophisticated &bquo;writer&equo;, the Professor, a historian of the European exploration of America, and Tom Outland, the indigenous traveller, discovering the primeval inhabitants, but teaching himself to read Virgil, and thus exploring in the other direction. 
 Cather's genius, in the end, is to do with certainty of pace, and certainty of focus. 
 She once put a jar in the middle of the table, in the light, and said she wanted her heroine to be like that; her novels create just such memorable images, not static, but still, like remembered paintings. 
 But they also catch the long and short rhythms of whole human lives and energies, the rush of youth, the coming of exhaustion and indifference, as no other writing I know does. 
 Her writing is as whole as sculpture and as steady and unobtrusive as breathing. 
 You can read it and not hear it and it can seem banal. 
 And then suddenly, its rhythm catches you and takes over, and you know you are in the presence of a deliberate art that seems completely right and natural. 
 BOOK REVIEW / The Alsatian sensation: &bquo;Ackerley&equo; &mdash; Peter Parker: Constable, 16.95 pounds 
 By D J TAYLOR 
 FOR SOMEONE who wrote so little and whose chief recreation &mdash; picking up men -involved a high degree of furtiveness, J R Ackerley's life is surprisingly well-documented. 
 The selected letters make a stout volume. 
 There are the end-of-tether diaries published as My Sister and Myself by his literary executor, Francis King, and any number of references in the voluminous literature that has grown up around the figure of E M Forster, whose acolyte Ackerley became between their first meeting in 1922 and his death, aged 71, in 1967. 
 Ackerley himself marches at the head of this file of memorialists. 
 Given his tiny literary output &mdash; four books and a play in 45 years &mdash; he wrote endlessly about his habits, frustrations and miseries: even his one novel We think the World of You was so transparently autobiographical as to prompt fears of a libel action. 
 Such is the volume of self-analysis that Peter Parker, a decent and sympathetic biographer, spends most of his 400-plus pages locked in a nervous struggle to find something new to say. 
 The result, tracking Ackerley through the Great War, Cambridge, his years as Literary Editor of The Listener and the relationship with the Alsatian dog for which he is popularly remembered, provides a continual feeling of deja vu. 
 The shabby ghosts of the Forster coterie waft out once more to pool their romantic gossip; Forster himself shuffles forward to complain that Joe's doings with one brawny menial have so put him off the lower classes that he has been obliged to travel first rather than third-class on a railway journey, and once again the air is full of that peculiarly spiritless twitter about guardsmen, homosexual tea parties and cure for pubic lice. 
 It says much for Ackerley &mdash; and Parker &mdash; that he emerges out of much camp narcissism as a figure of genuine humility. 
 As the posthumous My Father and Myself records, and everything else he wrote hints at, he had a low opinion of himself. 
 Even The Listener job, which he left acknowledged as the best literary editor of his day, produced a characteristic essay in self-denigration. 
 It becomes clear from Parker's researches that Ackerley's strongest emotion was guilt: over his supposed cowardice in the war, over his own survival at his brother's expense, over his &bquo;betrayal&equo; of various working-class boyfriends. 
 It was later compounded by the fall-out from a family explosion: on Roger Ackerley's death in 1929 the son discovered that, first, his father had been maintaining a separate menage and that, second, the money had run out. 
 A vague mother, an aunt described as &bquo;a figure entirely out of fiction&equo; and a hysterical sister who seems to have elevated emotional blackmail into a minor art-form, made his domestic environment a place of turmoil. 
 Ackerley's love live, a central feature of this biography, was quite as complex and unrewarding. 
 &bquo;It may be said to have begun with a golliwog,&equo; he wrote,&equo; and ended with an alsatian bitch'. 
 Between these two peaks there intervened four decades of joyless satyromania, two or three hundred invariably unsatisfactory encounters with &bquo;dumb pump handlers&equo;: working-class youths, often from army backgrounds, who cheerfully milked Ackerley for all he was worth and then disappeared. 
 It is a dismal chronicle, alternating Ackerley's vision of the &bquo;ideal friend&equo; with its glum reality ('It was all done for money. 
 Oh God, let me manage'). 
 All that emerges from it is the sheer nastiness of a group of homosexual writers for whom the working classes were not much more than a floating brothel. 
 It is not pleasant to read the account of the plot got up to entice Forster's boyfriend Bob Buckingham away from his wife, and not difficult to agree with PC Daley's description of the Forster circle as &bquo;pimps&equo;. 
 If Ackerley derived any satisfaction from this rough, rackety, frustrated life it was in his work at The Listener, where his enlightened editorial policies make him sound like a reviewer's dream (he telephoned contributors at midnight to query the removal of a comma). 
 But the emotional fracture cut through every aspect of his adulthood. 
 He was a primitive misogynist whose hatred of the wife of one of his friends led him quite seriously to plan her murder. 
 Late in life, having transferred his affections to the alsatian, Queenie, he became a professional bore over the superiority of animals to human beings, an obsession that led almost to derangement on the occasions when Queenie was cut by broken glass. 
 &bquo;I have devised a number of exquisite tortures for little boys who break bottles&equo; he wrote, &bquo;such as circumcising them with the jagged fragments&equo;. 
 Reading his letters about dogs, you incubate a silent fury that any intelligent man could be such an idiot. 
 For all that, on Queenie's death he was inconsolable: &bquo;no human being has ever meant as much to me as she&equo;. 
 Peter Parker does his best for Ackerley, praises his work &mdash; minor, but with an odd verve &mdash; and tries to bring out the more endearing sides to his nature revealed in letters to friends. 
 But while one can sympathise with Ackerley in his various predicaments, it is difficult to like him. 
 Appearing in Ackerley's books pages might, you feel, have been a privilege but an afternoon of Joe and Joe's dog would have been too much. 
 Eurodisney share offering is no Mickey Mouse operation: Eurodisney's share offer has drawn crowds but is not one for widows and orphans 
 By JASON NISSE 
 THE fact that Mickey Mouse did not turn up in London for the announcement of Eurodisney's share price, preferring to battle it out with anti-Disney demonstrators in Paris, shows where the focus of the Europe-wide issue is. 
 The issue is on offer in this country until Friday of this week and is likely to attract considerable attention from would be UK investors &mdash; not least of all because everyone knows what Disneyworld is. 
 The raising of Fr6.18bn (&pound;607m) to fund the theme park project, giving investors 51 per cent of Eurodisney with the US Disney group holding the rest, is geared towards Continental investors. 
 The Eurodisney share price, 707p in sterling terms, is determined by its price in Paris and the relative exchange rates, and the issue will succeed or fail on the willingness of ordinary French people to invest in this project. 
 It is noticeable that the French tranche, covering 50 per cent of the issue, is being sold by a general offer for sale while the British tranche, half as large, is split between an offer and a placing with institutions. 
 As this is the framework, the issue will be a roaring success. 
 The French investors are starved of the kind of new issues common to the British market -big, well-publicised privatisations or pseudo-privatisations aimed more at the general punter than the institutional investor. 
 The few French privatisations that occurred before the current Socialist government came in &mdash; Compagnie Financiere de Suez being a good example - excited heavy demand from French retail investors, rather as British Gas and British Telecom did in the UK. 
 &bquo;France has not seen many large equity issues recently,&equo; said Fred Bombrum, French equities analyst at stockbroker Hoare Govett. 
 &bquo;The Eurodisney issue has been heavily marketed and comes in a year when the French market is very exiting, probably the most exciting in Europe.&equo; 
 The French are attracted by the fact the Magic Kingdom and the proposed second theme park are to be located at Marne-la-Valee near Paris, the heavy involvement of the French government and the existence of theme parks such as the Asterix near Paris. 
 These factors have added up to heavy oversubcription in France, and across Europe, where the lists have already closed (British investors still have until Friday). 
 The French allotment was many times oversubscribed by last Monday and the price on the Parisian grey market, where shares are unoffically traded before issue, has been as high as Fr95, compared to an issue price of Fr72. 
 But though the excitement in France has been echoed in the London market, there remains heavy scepticism about the financial merits of the Eurodisney share offer. 
 The close proximity of the issue to the announcement of cost overruns at Eurotunnel has led many analysts to highlight the similarities between the schemes. 
 Both are gigantic construction projects, needing a large number of people to pass through them to be profitable, and with neither of them is the full return projected for a good few years hence. 
 Eurodisney, though, is already under construction, which Eurotunnel was not when it was floated, and as one stockbroking analyst commented: &bquo;It is on budget, overground and only two-and-a-half year's from completion.&equo; 
 The assumptions made in Eurodisney's prospectus are that 16 million people will visit the Magic Kingdom and 10 million will visit a second, as yet unnamed, theme park a year at their peak. 
 This will make them the first and fifth most visited attractions in the world, with the other three being existing Disney sites. 
 Eurodisney is also assuming 60 per cent of these will come from France. 
 This means that nearly 30 per cent of the population of France would have to visit Eurodisney each year. 
 The issue price also raised some eyebrows. 
 In the pathfinder prospectus, Eurodisney's advisers, SG Warburg, indicated the price would be between 600p and 700p. 
 Until a couple of days before the price was announced Warburg was working towards a Fr70 price, and only pushed this up to Fr72 (707p) when it saw how strong demand was. 
 Investors have argued that the involvement of the French government, which provided cheap land and finance for, and is promising a rail link to, the project, is seen as an insurance project. 
 It would be embarrassing for the project to slip behind schedule, especially in the light of Eurotunnel. 
 Disney has a good record on bringing in projects on time, and there is a great deal of faith in the Eurodisney management. 
 The latest Disneyland, near Tokyo, has been a roaring success, recently beating the world record for the most visitors at an attraction in a day. 
 This Japanese success brings another reason for the Eurodisney issue to go well. 
 Investors from outside the European Community are not allowed to subscribe, and there is strong demand from Japan to buy in the French market once shares start being traded. 
 The message from brokers is apply for shares, but do not look to hold them for the long term. 
 Washington Comment: The fight is on for the Fed to reserve its independence 
 By BAILEY MORRIS 
 THE chairman of the US Federal Reserve Board is a man people love to hate. 
 In his role as the world's Central Banker, a position bestowed on him by the dollar's reserve currency status, he cannot please all of the people all of the time. 
 He is on an unstable pedestal: considered too powerful because the Fed is too independent, a position fiercely guarded by its chairmen. 
 Therein lie the roots of the difficulties faced by the unflappable reigning chairman, Alan Greenspan. 
 Politicians are slinging arrows at him from all sides. 
 The periodic &bquo;Fed bashing&equo; which one has come to expect of the incumbent political Administrations has again resurfaced. 
 There are even suggestions that the US appoint its own Chancellor and rid itself of the high-handed monetary czars who ride unchecked across the economic landscape. 
 Nicholas Brady, the US Treasury Secretary and David Mulford, his aggressive deputy, have made it clear that they want Mr Greenspan to lower interest rates and do it quickly. 
 The same message is emanating from the White House. 
 The Administration is embarrassed that the Fed is not providing more support to its commitment to lower the dollar. 
 Perhaps more important, the Administration is again under pressure from US exporters who fear that the high dollar will drive them out of international markets. 
 The Fed and the Treasury are again at cross purposes, with one suggesting that rising inflation is the greater fear while the other insists that the climbing trade deficit is the most serious concern. 
 The remedy for one will exacerbate the other. 
 Soon Richard Darman, the budget director not known for his light touch, will resume his attack. 
 &bquo;The Federal Reserve needs to be more attentive to the need to avoid tipping this economy into a recession,&equo; he warns. 
 These are predictable messages. 
 What is slightly more unusual is that Congress has simultaneously joined the fray. 
 Suddenly, the Fed is faced with a plethora of legislative amendments to curb its independence. 
 Mr Greenspan will be summoned next week to defend his turf before a House tribunal and to defend the Fed's decision to focus on inflation, not the dollar. 
 But nothing terribly adverse is expected to occur, mainly because of the legislative stewardship of Rep. 
 Stephen Neal of North Carolina. 
 He is one of the Fed's best friends in Congress. 
 He supports the view that under current law the Fed has so much leeway that it can honestly claim to be fulfilling the will of Congress no matter what policies it adopts. 
 The law stipulates that the Central Bank must &bquo;promote effectively the goals of maximum employment, stable prices and moderate long-term interest rates.&equo; 
 It does not address the policy trade-offs. 
 Mr Neal has offered his own bill to check the Fed's independence but only by requiring it to adopt policies that would eliminate US inflation, now in the 5 per cent range, by 1994. 
 The Fed chairman actually supports Mr Neal's bill. 
 Not only does it meet his own policy expectations but it does so in language supplied by Mr Greenspan in congressional testimony which would allow Mr Greenspan to run rings around his Administration critics. 
 But there is other pending legislation which is much less friendly. 
 Two influential Congressmen, Lee Hamilton of Indiana and Byron Dorgan of North Dakota, are sponsoring bills intended to &bquo;politicise and democratise&equo; the Fed. 
 The bill would restore the US Treasury Secretary to the Fed's policy making committee, a position he lost in 1936 during Roosevelt's new Deal restructuring of the Central Bank. 
 Treasury Secretaries have been fighting for reinstatement ever since. 
 In addition, the legislation is intended to make the Fed more accountable to elected officials by insisting on reforms. 
 As Mr Hamilton explains it, this is not an attack on its authority but merely an attempt to establish communication &bquo;with the outside world.&equo; 
 It is populist zeal which is moving Mr Hamilton to clip the Fed's wings. 
 The prospect of a US Central Bank subject to interference from elected officials is frightening. 
 In a political system characterised by policy through stalemate, it cannot be tolerated. 
 Wiliam Proxmire, the former senator from Wisconsin, describes the Hamilton/Dorgam bill as &bquo;the most dangerous economic legislation before Congress,&equo; driven as it is by political hunger for short-term prosperity. 
 What would happen to US monetary policy guided by a Treasury Secretary like Donald Regan, who proclaimed that &bquo;deficits do not matter&equo;? 
 Although former presidents Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan endorsed the strong medicine prescribed by previous chairman Paul Volcker, neither was likely to initiate such a devastating cure. 
 The Fed must remain independent because it is the only US institution which provides the discipline of the long-term view and corresponding policy decisions. 
 As long as Mr Neal remains a strong bulwark against these incursions, nothing very significant is likely to happen. 
 But if a crack is allowed to open, a deluge of disastrous legislation could occur. 
 European Markets: Restructuring provides foundation for stakebuilding 
 By EDI COHEN 
 AFTER initial relief about last week's interest rate rises, the markets, most of them now fully valued, immediately searched for new issues to worry about. 
 The greatest insecurity lingering in investors' minds was the lack of effect the rate rises had on the dollar's ascent and the inflationary implications this might have for European economies. 
 There is more evidence in Germany that domestic inflationary pressures due to buoyant growth and expected fiscal stimulus for next year will leave little room for relaxation on the interest rate front. 
 Speculation about a possible realignment of the EMS clouded the air too. 
 As a consequence the markets were distracted from fundamentals and concentrated instead on special situations and gossip. 
 The French market was rife with rumours about takeovers in the financial services industry. 
 Jean Philippe Vernes, of BNP Securities, said although rumours in the French market are sometimes ways for punters to make quick money, some of the current ones are cases of stakebuilding based on the fundamental restructuring of the European financial services industry. 
 At the end of the week, some rumours became substantiated. 
 There is evidence now that both Paribas and AGF (Assurance Generale de France) have been allowed to build up stakes of more than 10 per cent in Navigation Mixte, a holding company with insurance and banking subsidiaries. 
 Navigation's share price rose by 14 per cent over the week as a result. 
 Since Paribas's rival Banque Indosuez won the insurance company, Victoire, analysts believe that Paribas did not have much choice but to look for a suitable target in the insurance field. 
 There is also talk of stakebuilding in Paribas itself. 
 The price of Paribas shares has soared by more than 10 per cent this week. 
 It could be that Navigation Mixte is teaming up to buy Paribas or that friendly defenders of Paribas such as Axa-Midi are strengthening their holdings. 
 Another possibility for the rise could be a general re-rating of the company on the basis of its net asset value. 
 According to those calculations, Paribas should be trading at around Fr650 while it has only this week started to trade over Fr600. 
 Some analysts believe that Deutsche Bank could be one of Paribas's suitors. 
 The German bank has been looking for a French opening for its global expansion for some time. 
 But it is believed that a takeover of Paribas by a foreign entity seems politically improbable. 
 The Week in Review: Business and City 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 IN Brazil they are wondering what all the fuss is about. 
 Inflation there was 36 per cent for the month of September alone and is expected to break new ground this month by touching 40 per cent. 
 So Britain's September rise of 0.7 per cent, revealed yesterday, giving an annualised rate of 7.6 per cent, seems rather meagre. 
 Nevertheless, it may be enough to keep the markets jittery about the country's economic prospects. 
 The Chancellor's decision to take base interest rates to 15 per cent was followed this week by mortgage rate rises from the Halifax and Abbey National building societies to 14.5 per cent. 
 Others are expected to follow suit next week and some may go for even higher rates for their borrowers. 
 Fears of mortgage defaults are adding pressure to an already depressed property market, while reports of industry feeling the squeeze proliferated. 
 A growing number of capital projects must now be in jeopardy. 
 Equity markets recoiled from these gloomy indicators by falling sharply at the beginning of the week, pausing only for the Chancellor's speech at the Tory Party conference, but still failing to recover lost ground by the close. 
 Market guru, Peter Thompson, now retired from Barclays de Zoete Wedd, but still forecasting market trends, has published a document predicting that the FT-SE 100 could be at 2,100 by the end of the month (it closed at 2,233.9, down 3.9, yesterday). 
 He says it will spiral down to 1,800 by next year. 
 Many would dismiss Peter Thompson's pessimism out of hand were it not for the fact that he was the author of a paper in July 1987, when the market was at its pre-crash high, called &bquo;The End of the Long Bull Market&equo;. 
 Market uncertainty forced Hays, the business services group which is seeking a stock market listing, to revise the launch price for its offer for sale scheduled to take place this month. 
 Faced with the decision of raising less money and hoping for a successful issue or shelving the flotation altogether, Ronnie Frost, chairman, opted for the cheaper share price. 
 Back at the Conservative Party conference in Blackpool, Nigel Lawson's carefully worded oratory did little to satisfy those wanting Britain to become full members of the European Monetary System sooner rather than later, nor did it provide comfort for others claiming that interest rates had reached their zenith. 
 The Chancellor appeared to be unmoved by the appeals from some of his party faithful, preferring to claim that his actions were in the country's long term interest. 
 Political expediency seemed far from his mind. 
 Meanwhile the pound showed some signs of stabilising having slipped below the psychological DM3 level earlier in the week. 
 The markets still remain unsure whether interest rates are rising to keep the economy in check by containing consumer spending or whether they are rising to protect the pound in the international market. 
 Interest and exchange rates are the least of Ferranti's problems. 
 The troubled defence and electronics group has spent the week in talks a clutch of potential bidders. 
 British Aerospace and Thomson-CSF, the French group are the favourites so far. 
 British Aerospace has confirmed that it has built up a 1.7 per cent stake in the company. 
 As for apportioning blame for the &pound;215m fraud at International Signal and Control, the Ferranti subsidiary, rumour and speculation abounded as it will for some time to come. 
 Ferranti has had its problems in the past so has rarely been an investors' favourite. 
 The same cannot be said of Saatchi &amp; Saatchi, once the darling of the stock market and counting the Conservative Party as one of its clients. 
 Responding to hard times, the world's biggest advertising agency is reshuffling its management. 
 In a move to tighten control of a far-reaching empire and to improve the group's own image, Maurice and Charles Saatchi, credited with building up the company, have stepped down from the day-to-day running of the group. 
 The new man at the top is Robert Louis-Dreyfus, a Frenchman, who is joining Saatchi from IMS, the market research group with Charles Scott, an existing colleague, as finance director. 
 Saatchi has been in the doldrums since late 1987. 
 Mr Louis-Dreyfus will have to work hard to recover the company's standing. 
 He may also have to fight off a takeover bid &mdash; Fininvest, the Milan-based media company controlled by Silvio Berlusconi revealed a 1 per cent holding last week. 
 Elsewhere in the media world, LWT has come up with a new plan to restructure itself ahead of the new franchise auction in 1992. 
 The scheme, which is not popular with some of the group's investors, includes tying in 40 of its top managers with the promise of an equity stake in the business. 
 And as Friday 13th drew the week to a close, City computer users viewed their screens nervously. 
 Rumours were circulating that a computer virus had been injected into software systems some time ago by computer terrorists and was programmed to break out yesterday, wiping out all data in the ailing computer system. 
 One suspicious City firm actually changed the date on all its computer systems to 14 October, hoping to side-step any trouble. 
 Isle of Man investors to get payout 
 By ALEXANDRA JACKSON 
 LIQUIDATORS of the Isle of Man Savings and Investment Bank, which crashed seven and a half years ago with debts of &pound;42.4m, said last night they would be paying more than 10p in the pound to the 4,000 mainly small investors who lost money. 
 Michael Jordan of Cork Gully and Timothy Beer of Peat Marwick McLintock said they had recovered &pound;13.2m of the missing deposits but &pound;5.5m of this had already gone to liquidation costs and legal fees. 
 That leaves &pound;7.7m to be distributed but Mr Jordan said some of this would still have to be held back for litigation. 
 The liquidators won an &pound;11.7m judgment against companies owned by disgraced City financier Jim Raper in the Manx court on Monday but said they were not expecting to see any of this. 
 Mr Raper is believed to be in Switzerland, in hiding from a two-year jail sentence imposed for moving assets out of Britain. 
 Mr Jordan said a payout, the first of several, will probably be made in early December. 
 Company News in Brief 
 Business and City Page 21 
 Market Report: Rothmans lights up at close of uneasy account 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 IS THE much rumoured takeover bid for Rothmans International, the tobacco and luxury goods group, about to materialise at long, long last? 
 As the stock market finished a depressing account on an uncertain note, Rothmans improved 21p to 666p. 
 Some suggested the progress was due to sterling's recent weakness. 
 Others were inclined to believe that Richemont, the Swiss-based South African controlled group, was preparing to bid. 
 Richemont and Philip Morris, the US brewing, food and tobacco giant, are the leading Rothmans shareholders with 64 per cent of the capital. 
 If Richemont should buy out the Philip Morris stake it would trigger an obligation to bid for the rest of the shares. 
 At 666p, Rothmans is trading below asset value, which some believe is more than 750p a share. 
 The shareholding shuffle is likely to have been provoked by Philip Morris which is thought to have lost interest in Rothmans. 
 It acquired its stake in the early 1980s, hoping eventually to acquire the tobacco group. 
 But with the South African Rembrandt group remaining committed to Rothmans the chance of a successful US offer has dwindled. 
 Rembrandt underlined its affection for Rothmans by pumping its shareholding into Richemont, a company it set up in Switzerland. 
 The rest of the stock market had a see-saw day. 
 When at the opening the mooted megabid failed to appear shares lost ground. 
 But gradually they clawed their way back, until the twin blows of the Bank of England's property loan warning and the worse-than-expected RPI figure sent prices into retreat. 
 However, new time buying inspired another rally which petered out towards the close as Wall Street performed poorly with junk bonds under pressure. 
 There are fears that Wall Street, which this week hit a peak, is in for a torrid time in the next few weeks. 
 One aspect which is worrying many is the increasing difficulty in dealing in beta and gamma stocks. 
 &bquo;It's as if there are two markets: the performance that the second liners offer has no relationship with blue chips,&equo; one market maker said. 
 The problems among the second liners was underlined by the sharp falls which occured in many USM and Third Market shares this week. 
 Property shares were hit by the Bank of England's worries about property loans, which revived memories of the 1970s banking and property crash. 
 Most property shares were marked down, although selling was not heavy. 
 Among those lowered were Land Securities down 6p to 516p; Rosehaugh 21p to 534p and Speyhawk 16p to 299p. 
 Banks also retreated. 
 All Thursday's takeover favourites gave ground. 
 Scottish &amp; Newcastle Breweries ended 4p lower at 385p. 
 The merchant bank Morgan Grenfell slipped 7p to 399p and Burmah, the oil group, 9p to 637p. 
 But United Biscuits responded to new time buying, gaining 6p to 360p. 
 Willis Faber, the insurance broker said to be on the verge of selling its 20.5 per cent shareholding in MG to a potential bidder, was unchanged at 242p. 
 Jaguar rose 14p to 677p. 
 Stories are circulating that Ford will announce it has built a 5 per cent shareholding early next week. 
 The Ford stake is aimed at frustrating the proposed deal between Jaguar and General Motors. 
 The GM plan is to buy a significant but not controlling stake in the British car maker. 
 It is in talks with Jaguar. 
 Saatchi &amp; Saatchi fell 10p to 334p on the arrival of new management. 
 Wardle Storeys, he plastic sheeting concern, had a nervous session, falling 27p to 266p. 
 Last month the company warned, for the second time this year, that profits would be disappointing. 
 It is expected to produce about &pound;9m which would compare with &pound;16.5m last time. 
 At one time this year the shares touched 664p. 
 ML Laboratories rose 33p to 528p. 
 The company has entered into a research agreement with the Royal Postgraduate Medical School for the development of polymers for Aids treatment. 
 Shares ended the account on a weak note. 
 Despite two attempted rallies, the FT-SE share index closed 3.9 points down at 2,233.9. 
 At one time it was up 10.0 points. 
 The FT 30 share index ended 0.3 points up at 1,818.0. 
 Government stocks fell by up to &pound;&frac14;. 
 Shares in Bennett &amp; Fountain will hit a fresh low for this year on Monday after an out-of-hours announcement last night that &bquo;the group has made a significant pre-tax loss for the year to 30 June&equo;, due to difficulties in the retail division. 
 There will not be a final dividend. 
 Pre-tax profits in 1988 were &pound;5.3m. 
 The shares stand at 65p against a high for 1989 of 127p. 
 Shares of Armour Trust, the sugar confectionery and car accessories business headed by Andrew Balcombe, slipped 0.5p to 47p yesterday. 
 Following recent confectionery takeovers, UBS Phillips &amp; Drew believe the trust has a break-up value of 100p. 
 Analyst Mark Simpson is looking for profits of &pound;2.4m this year and &pound;2.85m next year. 
 He rates the shares a buy. 
 View from City Road: Heavy water for the institutions 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 THE CITY is in grave danger of being bullied into subscribing for shares in the water industry that it neither wants nor needs. 
 The structure of the privatisation is such that institutions are effectively being left with no say in how they spend the funds they are supposed to manage on behalf of their clients. 
 Investment criteria that are applied as a matter of course to every other company are in danger of being abandoned completely as the institutions face the prospect of being sucked in by the Government's subtle propaganda. 
 At the heart of the problem is the fact that the Government is selling off 10 different companies but presenting them as a single package. 
 This makes sound political sense given that Environment Secretary Chris Patten is desperate to ensure an easy transition of water from public to private sector. 
 However, it is an approach that conflicts with traditional investment strategy. 
 If the water authorities were presented as individual companies, they would be scrutinised, assessed and either bought or discarded, depending on their merits. 
 But the Government is not prepared to allow this to happen. 
 It has to privatise an entire industry and cannot run the risk of the City picking up only the most attractive pieces. 
 So the institutions are being dragooned into subscribing for a package of shares in all 10 companies. 
 There is an option for institutions to subscribe for shares in individual authorities but that comes with the ominous warning that there is no guarantee the shares will be available. 
 The Government is therefore relying on the institutions to help guard against the problems that would be caused by any variations in regional demand from the small investor. 
 That is an unfair responsibility to impose on institutions that will not want to retain holdings in all 10 authorities. 
 Certainly they will have a presence in the instant sector that will be created but they will only want to hold shares in two or three companies. 
 It is made all the more unfair by the fact that the institutions have been deprived of any real access to the water authorities. 
 It is essential, therefore, that when the water industry prospectus is published next month it provides comprehensive information on all 10 authorities. 
 If it doesn't, the institutions should be prepared to exercise their power and veto the 10 in one package they are being bullied into. 
 View from City Road: Dearing bogged down by money 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 IT IS a year since Sir Ronald Dearing unveiled his committee's report on the way in which the accounting standards setting system in this country should operate. 
 The report was widely heralded as a blueprint for re-establishing the accountancy profession's right to set the framework for and to improve financial reporting in the corporate sector. 
 Yet despite praise for the report and stated commitments to implement it, Sir Ronald still has no tangible evidence that his work had any useful purpose. 
 That is not to say the report has been ignored completely. 
 Much work has been done behind the scenes to pave the way for its implementation. 
 Indeed the Government has draft clauses in the new Companies Bill which carry all the power necessary to put the system Dearing envisaged into place. 
 Unfortunately those clause do not represent a commitment by the Government to make that system work. 
 The Dearing Report has become bogged down by that oldest of problems &mdash; money. 
 Unless the Government is prepared to come up with some cash there is a real danger that the Dearing vision will be blinded by the dust which the report is rapidly gathering. 
 The only significant shortcoming in the Dearing report was its failure to assess the true cost of operating the system it proposed. 
 The annual cost will be about &pound;3m a year which compares with the &pound;500,000 currently spent on the Accounting Standards Committee. 
 The difficulty is in finding the sources of finance. 
 The accountancy profession rightly argues that the cost of establishing a new independent standards setting framework should be met, in part, out of the public purse. 
 That is only reasonable given that, in the new age of investor protection, the aim of a new system would be to improve the quality of information which was made available to shareholders. 
 The accountancy profession is prepared to concede that it no longer has the resources or the right to safeguard the integrity of accounting standards. 
 That is an important concession but one which will be wasted if the Government does not accept that part it now has to play. 
 It requires no dramatic change in policy to impose a small surcharge on the corporate sector through its filing of the annual return which will provide the funds to support the accounting standards system which this country needs and deserves. 
 View from City Road: Bidder has DRG sums all wrong 
 By DEREK PAIN 
 THE SLIDE in the market could, on the face of it, play into Roland Franklin's hands. 
 Share prices could fall so far that his cash offer for DRG, the Basildon Bond company, starts to look attractive. 
 For the time being, however, DRG's shares at 602p, down 2p yesterday, remain 12p above the offer. 
 Barring market collapse, they should retain their premium. 
 Mr Franklin was yesterday again arguing that his valuation is fair. 
 But there are glaring errors in his sums. 
 He starts by looking at DRG's pension fund surplus, which he says is worth &pound;25m. 
 But the company, backed by actuaries and auditors, says it is worth &pound;40.8m. 
 Further, he treats the surplus separately from the business. 
 But this ignores the effect of new accounting rules set out in SSAP 24, which require companies to spread a surplus over a number of years. 
 DRG has spread the surplus over 8.5 years, which is long enough to justify valuing it as part of the overall earnings stream. 
 DRG's property assets have also given rise to argument. 
 Mr Franklin says the promised stream of profits averaging &pound;10m over the next five years has a present value of roughly &pound;44m. 
 He says he is prepared to be proved wrong &mdash; suggesting he would raise his offer if DRG produced a higher valuation. 
 It looks as if Mr Franklin and other shareholders will have to wait another three weeks for news on that front. 
 Estimates vary but profits will probably rise from &pound;58.2m before tax to say &pound;66m this year and &pound;80m next, excluding property. 
 On this basis, the offer represents 14 times this years' earnings. 
 While it is a premium to the market, it should be more than accounted for by the property. 
 Do not be won over by Mr Franklin's arithmetic. 
 Column Eight: Ash blonde in the hot seat 
 By SIMON PINCOMBE 
 Does one detect in the week's events the motif of impending immolation? 
 It transpires that Professor Sir Alan Walters, Prime Minister Margaret &bquo;Brunnhilde&equo; Thatcher's favourite economist, is an ardent fan of the late Richard Wagner, composer of Germanic opera cycles. 
 Do our leaders remember how Gotterdammerung finishes? 
 After Brunnhilde throws herself on to the pyre Valhalla comes to an end, to be replaced by a new era of human love. 
 That cosmopolitan mouse Mickey is a roaring success, it seems, much to the chagrin of Warburgs, one of the sponsors of the Eurodisney float. 
 Demand for prospectuses has been such that an Independent scribe seeking a Warburgs telephone number for publication was told the firm really would prefer that it did not appear in print. 
 C'est la vie. 
 Even The Economist is turning green. 
 Amid advertisements for accountants and academics in the latest edition is an invitation to &bquo;cowpea breeders&equo;. 
 The International Institute of Tropical Agriculture wants a breeder, to be based in Mozambique, as part of its African development initiative. 
 Duties will include &bquo;accumulating, describing, evaluating and maintaining cowpea germplasm&equo;. 
 Candidates must have strong &bquo;interpersonal skills&equo;. 
 Headhunters are bound to find this one a challenge. 
 Steve Gold, the computer wizard and former hacker who got into Prince Philip's Prestel mailbox, still keeps names and addresses on paper. 
 The astute Mr Gold comments: &bquo;At least you can't hack a filofax.&equo; 
 For those who want a little more than Dulux Silk Emulsion, may we recommend &bquo;Colefax &amp; Fowler, the Best In English Interior Decoration&equo;, a publication lauding the USM-listed interior decorator. 
 The reader is told that founder John Fowler &bquo;took the romantic spirit of late eighteenth-century decoration, the simplicity of rural life with its celebration of nature, and fashioned it into a style of its own.&equo; 
 Later, in a chapter entitled &bquo;The Application of Paint&equo; it says that recent books on decoration have &bquo;done more to debase the traditional approach to decoration than to further an appreciation of its subtleties&equo;. 
 Now you know. 
 Next month Lowndes Queensway and Boots will face each other in court to settle a legal action neither started. 
 Not so long ago AG Stanley, the DIY group, sued Harris Queensway, the furniture and carpets retailer, over an alleged breach of warranties. 
 Since then Stanley has been taken over by Ward White, Harris by James Gulliver's Lowndes, and Ward White has been taken over by Boots. 
 And still the lawyers get their fees. 
 Ferranti had strong warning on takeover 
 By JEREMY WARNER, Assistant Business Editor 
 FERRANTI was warned in strong terms at the time of the takeover two years ago of the dangers of buying International Signal and Control. 
 A report commissioned from Lazard Brothers, the merchant bank, by members of the Ferranti family and obtained by The Independent, reveals that Sir Derek Alun-Jones, Ferranti's chairman, was told that Ferranti &bquo;may be unable to exercise full management control&equo; and that ISC was likely &bquo;to be a significant drain on its (Ferranti's) cash resources&equo;. 
 A &pound;215m fraud has since been discovered at ISC which has brought Ferranti to the brink of collapse and is likely to cost the group its independence. 
 The fraud involved creation of false profits and stocks in the books over a seven-year period through use of purported contracts, which in reality did not exist, with third world countries. 
 Some shareholders have called on Sir Derek, who masterminded the ISC takeover, to take responsibility for the debacle and resign. 
 Trustees of the family's shareholding in Ferranti commissioned the report on ISC to help them decide whether to support the takeover. 
 Although the report did not allude to the possibility of fraud, it has proved to be prophetic in a number of respects. 
 It pointed out that a prolonged period of profits growth at ISC had ended because of insistence by the auditors that ISC adopt more conservative accounting policies on long term contracts. 
 &bquo;Together with reported delays last year on international contracts, this may have implications for profits in the current year,&equo; the report said. 
 It went on to claim that ISC was a &bquo;highly cash-absorptive operation&equo;. 
 It had had new borrowings or rights issues in each of the last five years and &bquo;this pattern appears set to continue&equo;. 
 The report also questioned ISC's heavy reliance on three international customers with &bquo;one customer representing 15 per cent of trade debtors and two customers representing 45 per cent of contract work in progress&equo;. 
 The report noted that ISC was in dispute with the US Department of Defence over &dollar;4m of incurred costs relating to an ISC subsidiary and noted the acquisition would &bquo;lessen the group's attractiveness to a bidder&equo;. 
 It concluded with the comment that ISC was &bquo;more akin to a high-risk venture capital play moving between rounds of post-launch financing than as a stable company in conventional trading circumstances&equo;. 
 Kleinwort makes 11m Adollars on sale 
 By PATRICK HOSKING, Banking Correspondent 
 KLEINWORT Benson, the merchant bank, has received A&dollar;10.66m (&pound;5.3m) from the sale of its increasingly troubled Australian businesses - just half what it hoped for when it announced the deal in August. 
 It has also had to keep an undisclosed number of doubtful loans before offloading the unit, Kleinwort Benson Australia, to the California-based bank Security Pacific. 
 KBA's activities include merchant banking, stockbroking, bullion trading and leasing. 
 It fell into the red last year, losing A&dollar;2.6m. 
 But losses leapt to &pound;5.5m in the first half of 1989. 
 A strong merchant banking contribution was more than offset by losses on investment management and stockbroking and some heavy loan provisions. 
 Kleinwort said yesterday the deal price was based on the consolidated net assets of KBA on 31 August, and was still subject to final adjustment. 
 In August it expected to make about A&dollar;20m from the sale. 
 Kleinwort last month reported a decline in pre-tax profits of almost &pound;5m to &pound;30.1m in the first half, though recovering from loss in the previous six months. 
 The group now plans to concentrate on Europe, the US and Japan, having already closed offices in Hong Kong and Singapore. 
 Libra Bank, the London-based consortium bank which trades in third world debts, plunged to a pre-tax loss of &pound;174.6m in the first half of 1989 from profits last time of &pound;10.9m. 
 A &pound;191.1m exceptional provision caused the damage, but lifted the bank's third world cover from 16 to 32 per cent. 
 Operating profits improved strongly from &pound;10.9m to &pound;16.5m. 
 Libra's largest UK shareholder is NatWest with 5 per cent. 
 Interest charges hit Pergamon 
 By SIMON MANN 
 INTEREST charges associated with its continuing restructuring all but wiped out Pergamon AGB's profits in the half-year to the end of June. 
 However, directors of the 60 per cent-owned member of Robert Maxwell's stable of companies, said they expected to maintain a final year dividend of 3p &bquo;in view of the satisfactory progress&equo; of Pergamon's &pound;90m-plus disposal programme. 
 The half-year payout is steady at 1.5p. 
 Pre-tax profits slumped to &pound;700,000 (&pound;5.5m last year) derived solely from income on investments. 
 This was after the interest bill surged to &pound;11.5m from &pound;3.8m, negating operating profits. 
 The latter came from revenues of &pound;142m (&pound;124.9m). 
 However, a tax credit of &pound;1.8m checked the slump in Pergamon's net result with earnings per share holding up at 2.9p (4.1p). 
 Pergamon included an extraordinary charge of &pound;38.7m but gave no further details. 
 In recent months it has been expanding its market research activities while offloading its education publishing division and other subsidiaries in a bid to slash debt. 
 The directors said the disposal of non-core businesses would continue with the full benefits of its shift in activities not expected before 1991. 
 New CNIM fund tracks world markets 
 By CLARE DOBIE, Deputy City Editor 
 COUNTY NatWest Investment Management is launching an umbrella indexed fund which allows investors to track markets in different parts of the world and switch between them without incurring huge costs. 
 CNIM, the investment management arm of National Westminster, is the latest house to launch an umbrella fund of this type. 
 Others include Barclays' investment management arm, Lazards Investment Management and Paribas/Clerical Medical. 
 The fund consists of up to 22 sub-funds, each designed to track different markets, including Australia, Hong Kong, Italy, Malaysia, USA and Sweden. 
 Investors can switch between the sub-funds. 
 The World Index Trust is designed for investors who want to be able to move between overseas markets but do not want to choose particular stocks to buy. 
 Each sub-fund is indexed to a local market and so should perform exactly in line with it. 
 Aitken profits sparkle 
 By CLARE DOBIE, Deputy City Editor 
 AITKEN HUME International, the financial services group chaired by Conservative MP Jonathan Aitken, more than doubled pre-tax profits to &pound;1.449m in the six months to 30 September. 
 There was no interim dividend, but Mr Aitken said the directors would consider paying a final dividend at the year-end in the light of trading conditions then. 
 There were two large exceptional payments. 
 One was a &pound;230,000 &bquo;compensation for loss of office&equo;, the bulk of which went to the former chief executive, Emmanuel Olympitis, who suddenly departed last month. 
 The other was a &pound;310,000 provision for the diminution in market value of an undisclosed investment. 
 The bank, which also held its annual meeting yesterday, rejected a shareholders' demand for it to sell its US-based fund management business, National Securities &amp; Research. 
 The group lost &pound;1.368m last year and has since been radically slimmed down to three operating subsidiaries &mdash; banking, a Channel Islands fiduciary management business and NSR. 
 Caird Group plans a 34.5m pounds rights issue 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 CAIRD GROUP, the waste disposal company headed by former stockbroker Peter Linacre, is raising &pound;34.5m through a two-for-one rights issue of convertible preference shares. 
 Caird specialises in buying small waste management and landfill companies, integrating them and bringing them up to existing and proposed European standards on waste disposal. 
 This policy has brought it &pound;24m of borrowings, most at variable rates, and Mr Linacre said replacing these borrowings with convertible preference shares, yielding 7 per cent, would save the group about &pound;1.8m a year. 
 The convertibles swap into Caird ordinary shares at 535p, compared to a share price of 479p, down 12p, yesterday. 
 The move has been interpreted as making Caird less likely to bid for Leigh Interests, a rival waste disposal group in which Caird has a stake of about 5 per cent. 
 Caird is sending shareholders an external environmental audit which it commissioned from consultants Mott MacDonald. 
 Mr Linacre said the audit answered many of the criticisms voiced by stockbroking analysts about standards at some Caird acquisitions. 
 Coats sale raises 12m pounds 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 COATS Viyella, the textile group which expects to hear whether it is allowed to take over rival Tootal in the next few days, has sold its medical businesses to Pharma-Plast Holdings for &pound;12m. 
 The business comprises two operations, Steriseal, which distributes medical and opthalmic products, and Rotax, which supplies scalpels. 
 Sir David Alliance, Coats chairman, said the sales were part of Coats' continuing policy of disposing of peripheral activities that do not fit in the long term strategy of the group. 
 Business and City Summary 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 Ford confirms Jaguar stake: Ford has acquired 5 per cent of shares in Jaguar. 
 The company said it was advised last week by the US Federal Trade Commission that no objection would be raised to the acquisition of up to 15 per cent of Jaguar shares. 
 Ford said the ISE and SEC were being notified. 
 Ferranti warning: Troubled defence firm Ferranti was warned two years ago of the dangers of buying International Signal and Control. 
 Page 21 RPI up: Inflation rose to 7.6 per cent last month, worse than expected. 
 Page 19 Bank warning: Robin Leigh-Pemberton, the Governor of the Bank of England, has warned about record levels of property company borrowing. 
 Page 19 Car link: American car maker Chrysler is talking to Mitsubishi of Japan about setting up manufacturing plants in Europe. 
 Page 19 BSB launch: British Satellite Broadcasting has launched into the market for satellite communications. 
 Page 19 WH Smith drops claim: WH Smith has dropped its legal action against five directors it dismissed in August from Our Price Music, the record retailing chain. 
 Page 19 Waste rights: Caird, the waste disposal group, is raising &pound;34.5m through a two-for-one rights issue. 
 Page 21 Bestwood sale: Bestwood is selling British Drilling &amp; Freezing, its onshore drilling and services subsidiary, to its management, for &pound;4m. 
 Sterling decline: Sterling closed 0.33 pfennigs higher at DM2.9595 yesterday. 
 The pound has fallen 10 per cent against the mark since its peak early this year. 
 Yellow card: The Takeover Panel has rapped Michael Knighton on the knuckles for pulling out of his &pound;20m bid for Manchester United. 
 Page 19 Kleinwort disposal: Merchant bank Kleinwort Benson has sold its Australian businesses for A&dollar;10.66m. 
 Page 21 Pergamon wipe-out: Interest charges associated with restructuring almost wiped out Pergamon AGB's half-year profits. 
 Page 21 IoM payout: Liquidators of the failed Isle of Man Savings and Investment Bank will pay more than 10p in the pound to investors. 
 Page 22 World Markets New York: Prices plunged and by the close the Dow Jones average was down 196.70 points at 2,563.11. 
 The failure of the United Airlines bid deal was thought to have triggered the selling. 
 Hong Kong: Selling focused on selected blue chips dragged the Hang Seng index down 11.15 points to close at 2,782.30 on low turnover. 
 Sydney: The market shook off its bearish mood, boosted by a weaker local dollar. 
 The All-Ordinaries index closed 11.8 points higher at 1,741.9. 
 Tokyo: Talk the US may be easing credit policy gave an extra kick to a technical bounce, knocking prices higher in light trade. 
 The Nikkei index jumped 320.97 points to 35,116.02. 
 Zurich: Shares closed steady to lower in quiet trading as prices came off their early highs on slight profit taking. 
 Frankfurt: Prices fell sharply on inflation worries after news that wholesale prices surged by 1.1 per cent. 
 The DAX index fell 23.44 points, to 1,589.34. 
 Madrid: Shares closed lower as the government posted worse than expected inflation figures. 
 Stockholm: Foreigners were noted among the sellers. 
 The general index lost 0.41 per cent in low turnover. 
 Brussels: Stocks slipped further in moderate early trade as doubts prompted by high interest rates and the strength of the dollar resurfaced. 
 Milan: Shares closed lower in dull trading. 
 Inflation hopes crushed with jump to 7.6 per cent 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 INFLATION last month rose to 7.6 per cent, reversing a recent ebbing of inflationary pressures and ending hopes of a decline by the end of this year. 
 The increase was worse than expected and led to widespread predictions that base rates will not be cut before next spring at the earliest. 
 In the US, meanwhile, there was a sharp jump of 0.9 per cent in September wholesale prices, which were 4.5 per cent higher than a year ago. 
 In the UK, price increases for food, clothing and footwear, tobacco, alcohol and petrol helped to drive the retail price index 0.7 per cent higher in October, taking the retail price index (January 1987=100) to 116.6. 
 The figures deepened City anxiety over the outlook for inflation which is now expected to end the year between 7.5 and 7.75 per cent and remain above 7 per cent for the first quarter of 1990. 
 The figures were released as Nigel Lawson, the Chancellor, warned that interest rates could climb even further to clamp down on rising prices. 
 Speaking on BBC Radio 4 the Chancellor said: &bquo;You cannot escape the need to raise interest rates if you want to keep inflation down, nor can you escape the possibility that interest rates may go even higher.&equo; 
 But City sources said they believed that Mr Lawson might reinforce the fight against inflation without resorting to another increase in base rates, by announcing a further tightening of monetary policy in next Thursday's Mansion House speech. 
 The Chancellor is expected to modify the Government's policy of buying in enough long-dated gilt-edged stock in a single fiscal year to offset the financial drain on the economy created by the budget surplus and foreign exchange intervention to support the pound &mdash; the so-called full funding rule. 
 Current policy is intended to repay the national debt and also to ensure that long-term interest rates stay below short-term rates, in order to encourage the development of a corporate bond market and provide industry with lower borrowing costs. 
 But that policy has come in for sharp criticism from monetarists who insist that it has fed the rapid expansion of broad money supply, M4, and inflamed inflationary pressures. 
 The City expects the Chancellor to alter but not altogether abandon the rule, effectively reducing the amount of gilt-edged stock bought in by the Bank of England. 
 The measure would force up long and short-term interest rates and could help to support the pound. 
 Sterling's immediate fortunes are widely believed to hang on a positive reception to Mr Lawson's speech. 
 It is understood that the Government has done nothing to discourage City expectations that it will curtail its gilt-edged buying programme. 
 However, a Treasury official yesterday dismissed the reports as &bquo;pure speculation&equo;. 
 September's 7.6 per cent inflation rate follows one of 7.3 per cent in August and compares with a current peak of 8.3 per cent in May. 
 Although inflation in October is expected to decline to around 7.2 per cent, because a 1.25 per cent increase in mortgage rates in October last year will drop out of the annual comparison, the recently announced increases in mortgage rates will send inflation back up again in November. 
 Economists yesterday expressed concern that the increase in prices was becoming more generalised. 
 Excluding the impact of mortgage rates, regarded as the best guide to the underlying trend, inflation rose 0.1 points to 5.8 per cent in September, which suggests that high interest rates have yet to subdue inflation significantly. 
 But there was little reaction to the news in the London market. 
 The pound ended slightly higher at DM2.9595 but rose more sharply against the dollar, which fell on rumours of central bank intervention. 
 Bank governor warns of record property borrowing 
 By GAIL COUNSELL, Property Correspondent 
 ROBIN Leigh-Pemberton, the Governor of the Bank of England, sent shivers through an already-nervous property sector yesterday when he issued the latest in a series of warnings about the record level of property company borrowing. 
 Figures published on Thursday show lending to property companies grew by 50 per cent in the year to August to &pound;30bn. 
 &bquo;We cannot neglect the possibility that current levels of interest rates may challenge the assumptions underlying some of this lending,&equo; he told the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors in Paris. 
 Levels of lending, in which property companies represented about 10 per cent of total loan exposure to UK residents, did not present a &bquo;major&equo; supervisory anxiety, he said. 
 But the Bank had been monitoring the situation closely and there had to be &bquo;room for debate&equo; about whether there would be sufficient demand for office space in the early 1990s for the supply coming on stream. 
 Special attention, he added, had to be paid to highly geared developers, especially those with &bquo;excessive&equo; specialisation in particular markets and localities. 
 Comparison with the early 1970s, when a number of secondary banks nearly failed as a result of their over-exposure to falling property values, were not appropriate, however. 
 &bquo;The distribution of lending today is very different,&equo; he said. 
 It was spread across a wider range of banks, especially the &bquo;large London branches of strongly capitalised foreign banks&equo;. 
 His comments had an immediate impact on the City, where analysts have grown increasingly anxious in recent weeks about the risk that asset values may fall in the face of oversupply and forced sales of buildings. 
 Shares in development based companies were particularly hard hit. 
 Concern centres on the likely shortage of buyers for projects funded on short-term development finance from the banks. 
 &bquo;What worries us most is where the takeout will come from,&equo; John Atkins of Phillips &amp; Drew said. 
 &bquo;The institutions were net disinvestors in property in the second quarter of this year &mdash; they sold more than they bought. 
 So who is going to buy all these buildings once they are finished?&equo; 
 A spokeswoman for Barclays Bank stressed that British banks had already cut back their lending in response to earlier warnings. 
 &bquo;The growth in lending in the year to August by Committee of Scottish and London Clearing Banks was only 27 per cent, and for Barclays it was only 10 per cent,&equo; she said. 
 In 1980 British banks accounted for 80 per cent of company debt. 
 The figure has fallen to less than 60 per cent as overseas banks have become keen lenders. 
 Chrysler in European car plant talks with Mitsubishi 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 CHRYSLER, America's third largest car maker, and Mitsubishi of Japan are discussing plans to set up vehicle manufacturing plants in Europe. 
 The negotiations form part of Chrysler's strategy to increase dramatically its presence in Continental markets following its complete withdrawal from European car manufacture in 1978. 
 Robert Miller, Chrysler's chief financial officer, said in London yesterday that the two companies were &bquo;exploring the possibility for joint European ventures&equo;. 
 He declined, however, to specify what type of vehicle production was being considered and said the discussions were still at a preliminary stage. 
 Mitsubishi is expected to be the next Japanese company to begin car manufacture in Europe following in the footsteps of Nissan, Toyota and Honda. 
 The Japanese car manufacturer has a strong presence, however, in four-wheel drive utility vehicles and minivans &mdash; an area where Chrysler is also dominant. 
 Chrysler and Mitsubishi have already set up a &dollar;1bn (&pound;653m) car plant in Illinois which has a capacity of 250,000 vehicles a year. 
 It is currently making sports cars. 
 Chrysler also has a 12 per cent stake in Mitsubishi. 
 Chrysler has already announced that it is teaming up with Renault of France to build a &dollar;400m to &dollar;500m plant in Europe to produce the JJ - a four-wheel drive Jeep-type vehicle. 
 The favoured location is Spain. 
 The plant, which will manufacture around 50,000 vehicles a year, will begin operations in 1992. 
 The company is also examining the possibility of starting minivan production in Europe and Mr Miller said Chrysler had spoken to potential partners. 
 Chrysler's aim is to increase European sales to 100,000 a year over the next few years &mdash; a plan almost certain to involve right-hand drive vehicles for the UK. 
 Since it took the decision to re-enter the European market three years ago, annual sales have risen to 50,000 on the Continent. 
 Its earlier foray into Europe ended in the sale to the French car group Peugeot of all its European manufacturing sites. 
 &bquo;Now we are selling 50,000 vehicles it gives us encouragement that European consumers will forget the past and give us another chance,&equo; said Mr Miller. 
 Failed Manchester United bid draws reprimand from Panel 
 By FRANK KANE, Chief City Reporter 
 THE TAKEOVER Panel has rapped Michael Knighton on the knuckles for his failure to see his &pound;20m bid for Manchester United football club through. 
 The 37-year-old property developer pulled out of the bid, despite having a funding package in place and agreement to buy a controlling stake from the chairman, Martin Edwards, last Wednesday. 
 A Panel statement criticised him for a breach of General Principle 3 of the Takeover Code, which requires that a bidder should &bquo;only announce an offer after the most careful and responsible consideration.&equo; 
 When Mr Knighton announced his bid, the Panel says, he did not have any independent corporate finance advisers, nor lawyers advising him. 
 Details are emerging of the final stages of the talks which led to the collapse of the bid on Tuesday night. 
 Sources close to the talks say he &bquo;decided that the people backing him did not have the interests of the club at heart&equo;. 
 The backers are understood to have included Owen Oyston, the media entrepreneur, as well as a Middle Eastern businessman. 
 The hostility of United directors to his backers persuaded Mr Knighton that he could never hope to reconcile them to his ownership of the club. 
 Insiders also say the presence of his wife at the meetings contributed to his decision to pull out. 
 The bid attracted intense media attention, most of it critical of Mr Knighton, an Isle of Man tax exile who became a millionaire through property dealings in Yorkshire and Scotland. 
 &bquo;He wanted to develop his business on a private basis, and if he came into the glare of publicity as owner of Manchester United he would not be able to do that,&equo; one of the negotiators said. 
 WH Smith drops case against ex-directors 
 By JASON NISSE, Financial Reporter 
 WH SMITH has dropped its legal action against five directors it dismissed in August from Our Price Music, the record retailing chain it took over three years ago. 
 WH Smith took out an injunction against the five after it discovered what it says was a plot to launch a music chain to rival Our Price. 
 The five, who comprise the four founding directors of Our Price and a senior executive, have agreed to pay WH Smith's costs and WH Smith has dropped its claim for damages. 
 This is despite WH Smith's assertion that their actions damaged the ongoing business of Our Price. 
 In addition Gary Nesbitt, who was the non-executive deputy chairman, and Michael Isaacs, who was the development director, have agreed to a non-competition agreement, which last for two years in Mr Nesbitt's case and 18 months in Mr Isaacs'. 
 This restriction, however, merely limits Mr Nesbitt, who is chairman of the casino company Crockford's, and Mr Isaacs from conspiring together to start a rival record chain. 
 Dr Kevin Hawkins, the head of WH Smith's corporate public relations, said the agreement would not stop either taking a job with a rival chain. 
 BSB Datavision starts service 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 BRITISH Satellite Broadcasting has launched into the market for satellite communications, in spite of delays in the arrival of its television service. 
 BSB Datavision was one of six companies to be awarded a specialised satellite service operator (SSSO) licence last year. 
 This enables it to send video, audio and data from any point in the UK, via satellite, to closed groups of users. 
 Initial trials are beginning with the Press Association, which will send news and pictures via satellite to six customers. 
 BSB is also believed to be talking to Ford in the UK about providing communications with its dealers and to the Financial Times about a business service for large companies. 
 Datavision will use the BSB satellite and the same transmission technology, known as DMAC, but has opted to have the reception equipment made by different manufacturers. 
 While the parent television company has experienced serious delays with the supply of a vital set of electronic chips made by ITT, Datavision will be using chips made by Philips of the Netherlands and Plessey of the UK. 
 The Datavision business is expected to make about &pound;5m next year, but then to escalate sharply. 
 The six SSSO licencees are negotiating with the Department of Trade and Industry to make changes. 
 Currently only one-way transmission is allowed, but they want two-way communications and the ability to transmit to recievers in Europe. 
 If these relaxations are approved, the market could be worth as much as &pound;450m a year. 
 Patrick Scott, managing director of BSB Datavision, said: &bquo;I hope I am in the embarrassing situation of earning more than BSB.&equo; 
 BA plan for UAL collapses 
 By LARRY BLACK and GAIL COUNSELL 
 BRITISH Airways last night faced the collapse of its planned &pound;465m deal to buy into America's United Airlines. 
 The consortium behind the &dollar;7bn management buyout, in which BA would have a 15 per cent stake, admitted yesterday that it had been unable to complete its part of the financing. 
 The news prompted a 196.70 fall in the Dow Jones index, which closed at 2,563.11, the second biggest fall in Wall Street's history. 
 In a statement, British Airways said it believed that the finance for the deal would be raised in the near future, but that its &pound;320m fund raising issue would go ahead regardless. 
 &bquo;The issue is underwritten,&equo; said a company spokesman, &bquo;and what's happened in America will not affect British Airways&equo; independent finance raising, which will extend our equity base irrespective of the UAE deal.&equo; 
 British Airways has always insisted that it would continue with its convertible bond issue, which closes on Tuesday morning, regardless of whether the UAE deal goes through. 
 However, Wall Street's collapse raises spectres of a repeat of the 1987 stock market crash, in which lead and sub underwriters were obliged to take up shares at prices well below those quoted in the market. 
 Airline Acquisition Corp, the management and pilot group that had agreed to pay &dollar;300 a share for United, announced at 2.54pm New York time that its agent banks, Chase Manhattan and Citibank, had found insufficient interest in the issue because of &bquo;adverse changes in the market for this transaction&equo;. 
 Rumours in the market said that Japanese banks which had initially indicated a willingness to put up some of the necessary funds, were behind the problems. 
 A statement said the group would submit a revised proposal for senior financing for the deal &bquo;in the near term&equo;. 
 UAL said that it had been advised by AAC that syndication of the financing would be possible on revised terms. 
 Before trading was suspended, shares in United &mdash; America's second-largest airline &mdash; had fallen &dollar;5.50. 
 Delta lost &dollar;7.75 by the close, and US Air &dollar;3.75. 
 A spate of airline buyouts, which has touched every major US carrier during the last six months, has come in for growing criticism because of the heavy debt it loads on the companies. 
 Speculative investors have watched the deals closely for signs of financial trouble and potential government intervention. 
 &bquo;These deals have slowly been finding out that they just can't get financing,&equo; said William Lefebvre, a market analyst with New York's Advest group. 
 &bquo;Now the whole LBO market is suspect.&equo; 
 The United deal, if it had won US Transportation Department approval, would have made the airline the largest employee-owned corporation in America. 
 The United pilots' union had attempted unsuccessfully to finance a similar bid a year ago when the airline was trading at less than half the final sale price. 
 Despite objections from United's machinists' union, the participation of management, and BA's equity contribution, were considered to be ample assurance to potential investors in Airline Acquisition's junk bonds. 
 The junk bond market has been in trouble since Canadian developer Robert Campeau ran into trouble meeting payments on his debt in Allied and Federated stores last month. 
 Earlier this week, the Ramada hotels group was forced to withdraw a crucial &dollar;400m junk-bond offering because of continued skittishness about high-risk debt. 
 Unlike the October 1987 crash, when the Dow average fell more than 500 points, Friday's retreat was concentrated on takeover stocks that have surged in recent months. 
 &bquo;It was a full-fledged Friday 13th rout, but it was no crash,&equo; said AP Moore, research director at Argus Research. 
 But many analysts predicted a further slide when world markets open on Monday, as investors who heard Friday's news too late pull out of takeover portfolios. 
 Much the same old beast, slightly tamed: The new Porsche 911 looks very familiar, says Gavin Green 
 By GAVIN GREEN 
 ALTHOUGH you would never know it, a new range of Porsches has gone on sale in Britain to replace the rear-engined 911, the longest-lived sports car in the world. 
 Visual clues to the new model include body colour bumpers, small side skirts and a rear spoiler that rises automatically at speeds of more than 50mph; at low speed or when stationary it retracts, leaving the handsome sweep of the car's tail clean. 
 But in every other way, the new 911 looks identical to its predecessor. 
 That Porsche can show so little imagination when launching a new model is a corollary both of the popularity of the old 911 (the only model unaffected by Porsche's recent slump in sales worldwide), and of the conservatism at the top of the Stuttgart company. 
 Predictably, the styling rework has done the look of the 911 no favours: rehashing a beautiful original rarely does. 
 The front bumpers look heavy and bulbous, the side skirts look like add-ons. 
 The whole effect is as if an aftermarket body-kit specialist has had a go at embellishing a 911, with the predictable result. 
 Still, the new 911 is a better car than the old one, as you'd expect. 
 It's more aerodynamic, the interior has been improved (although not nearly as much as it should have been), the new engine has more power and yet is no thirstier, and the new suspension means safer, more predictable, handling. 
 The first Mk2 911 to go on sale in Britain was the Carrera 4 &mdash; the four-wheel drive version. 
 Unlike the 959, the transmission of the Carrera 4 is quite conventional. 
 Instead of the 959's computer-controlled variable front-rear power split, the Carrera 4 gets 31 per cent of the torque fed to the front wheels and 69 per cent to the rear. 
 It retains a five-speed gearbox: the 959 had six speeds. 
 As with the 959, anti-lock brakes &mdash; not available on old 911s &mdash; are now standard. 
 This is particularly welcome: the 911 had so much weight concentrated over its tail that it was prone to locking front wheels in the wet. 
 Alas, the great mass of weight over the tail also meant that, at high speed on damp surfaces, the 911 had a habit of disappearing off roads, backside first. 
 Get the car slightly crossed-up and the pendulum-like effect of the heavy tail could turn a twitch into a slide. 
 The Carrera 4 still has its engine sited behind the back axle, VW Beetle-style, in no man's land where no self-respecting car designer would ever site the engine of a truly new car. 
 But clever suspension changes and, more important, the four-wheel drive, have tamed the beast. 
 The Carrera 4 on damp surfaces is probably the fastest and most predictable car in the world. 
 The new 3.6-litre engine, of flat-six configuration like its predecessor but otherwise totally new, also ensures the Carrera 4 is one of the fastest sports cars in the world in a straight line. 
 It has, too, an inspirational engine: wailing gloriously when revved hard, yet still docile enough to pull the car along tamely in traffic. 
 Twin spark plugs per cylinder are one novel touch. 
 As with the old flat-six engine, the new motor is still air-cooled. 
 Power is increased from the old 3.2 litre engine's 231bhp to 250bhp. 
 As ever: the gear change and clutch are heavy; the throttle response terrific. 
 As ever: this 911 feels small and responsive, at your beck and call. 
 Small inputs are rewarded with a change in behaviour, not with mechanical slop. 
 Power steering is now standard, but it does nothing to blunt the feedback coming from front wheels to steering wheel: the old wrist-snapping kickback over bumps is largely eradicated but the important messages are translated as crisply as ever. 
 The cabin is small, a little cramped. 
 You can just about excuse Porsche for not altering the external shape, but forgiveness is impossible when it concerns the interior. 
 The old 911 had the worst laid-out cockpit of any new car. 
 The Carrera 4 inherits the title. 
 Although redesigned, the cockpit is obviously supposed to retain the character of the old 911. 
 And that means fiddly switches scattered haphazardly across the dash and centre console like bits of shot fired from a blunderbuss. 
 They are difficult to locate and activate. 
 The dash also looks uninviting. 
 Many cars costing a third as much have a more upmarket fascia, better quality trimmings and more comfortable seats. 
 At least the ventilation is improved. 
 Comfort levels are not high. 
 The ride is very firm: the Carrera 4 drops its wheels into bumps with real venom. 
 Yet this low-speed firmness can transform itself: on undulating secondaries taken at speed the chassis composure of the Carrera 4 is faultless. 
 It is a noisy car. 
 The tyres roar at high speed and a faint transmission whine &mdash; common on four-wheel drive cars &mdash; now joins the 911 cacophony. 
 The noise is not unpleasant. 
 It soundslike a fast, powerful car, and many would rather that than silence. 
 The new Carrera 4 is a significantly better car than the old rear-drive 911. 
 It handles better, grips better and has better brakes. 
 It shares most of the virtues of the old car: superb build quality, mechanical durability, compactness, good visibility, inspirational engine note, responsiveness. 
 As with the old 911, this is a super-car that can be used every day. 
 It is happy pottering through Sloane Square or belting around Silverstone. 
 That is not true of any Ferrari or Lamborghini, or of any other cars with this much performance. 
 Its only drawback, apart from the slightly adulterated styling, is that the Carrera 4 is not as much fun to drive hard as the old 911. 
 It is less entertaining, less of an untamed beast. 
 Driving this new 911 hard and safely is easy. 
 Bright new bonnets on show at the fair: Brett Fraser says that, for once, the London Motorfair is the place to catch a glimpse of the latest ideas from the world's car makers 
 By BRETT FRASER 
 THE WORLD debut of three British cars, and the first British showing of important models from around the world, should help to ensure that the London Motorfair, which opens on Thursday, is the most interesting and significant for years. 
 Traditionally, the biennial Motorfair plays poor cousin to the Motor Show, held at the National Exhibition Centre in Birmingham in the alternate years. 
 Seldom is anything genuinely new shown at the Earls Court venue, normally used more as a glorified car showroom by the manufacturers than as a showcase for forthcoming cars and innovative ideas. 
 This year it is different, and well worth catching a glimpse of the latest from the world's car makers. 
 Here we offer a guide to what is worth pushing your way to the front of the crowd for. 
 Nissan 300 ZX. 
 From being among the dullest of Japan's manufacturers, Nissan has blossomed into one of its most creative and capable. 
 At Motorfair, Nissan shows its new 300 ZX for the first time in Britain. 
 Not to be mistaken for the previous car to wear that badge, which was rather short on driver appeal, the new 300 ZX represents a serious threat to Europe's sports car makers. 
 It looks fantastic, muscular yet svelte. 
 And it has the firepower under the bonnet to do its appearance justice. 
 It is powered by a fuel-injected, 3.0-litre V6 engine which, if Nissan's figures are correct, give it a top speed of 156mph and a 0-60mph time of 5.6 seconds. 
 Not bad for a car which weighs as much as a Range Rover. 
 In Japanese tradition, expect equipment levels to be high. 
 There is no word on prices until Motorfair, but availability will limit sales of the 300 ZX in this country. 
 Lotus Elan. 
 In the 1960s, Lotus produced a delightful little sports car called the Elan. 
 It was fast, fun to drive and, despite a high price, had an enthusiastic following. 
 Its successor makes its world debut at Motorfair. 
 Although the new Lotus Elan is similar in concept to its popular predecessor, its styling is far removed. 
 It takes a while to get used to the looks of the new car, but it is clear that Lotus is seeking to advance sports car design rather than just repeat past successes. 
 It is a brave move. 
 Lotus will not reveal full details of the new Elan until Motorfair, but it is likely to have a Japanese Isuzu engine driving the front wheels. 
 This is a break with tradition: there is an unwritten law which says sports cars for the &bquo;enthusiast&equo; market have rear-wheel drive. 
 The engine is turbocharged and, according to Lotus, will shoot the Elan from 0-60mph in 6.7 seconds, and give a top speed in excess of 135mph. 
 Expecta non-turbocharged version, too. 
 The Elan's bodywork is of glass-reinforced polymer, as are all the Norfolk-based company's cars. 
 Lotus is a world leader in the development and manufacturing of this material, so expect the fit and finish of the Elan's body panels to be excellent. 
 No prices have yet been announced, but the Elan will probably leave a &pound;17,500-&pound;20,000 hole in your bank account. 
 You will have to be quick, for Lotus produces only small numbers of cars and demand is likely to be high. 
 Vauxhall Calibra. 
 For years the coupe market, once the preserve of the European manufacturers, has been dominated by the Japanese. 
 Recently the Europeans have been fighting back: Volkswagen with the Corrado, Audi with its 90-based Coupe; now Vauxhall with its sleek new Calibra. 
 The Calibra was first shown at the Frankfurt Motor Show in September and, for the moment at least, is the world's most aerodynamic production car. 
 It is pretty, too. 
 And unlike many coupes which have, at best, room only for children in the rear, the Calibra will seat two adults comfortably in the back. 
 It also has a large boot and a split folding rear seat, to add practicality to its virtues. 
 Underneath the Calibra's slippery body lies the floor pan and mechanicals of the Cavalier. 
 This gives the Calibra a big advantage when it is launched midway through next year, in that all its running gear has a proven track record. 
 Sometimes, when new cars are launched, it takes a couple more years of development before problems are sorted out. 
 The Calibra shares the Cavalier's 2.0 litre engine, in both its 8-and 16-valve forms. 
 In its 16-valve guise, the Calibra is claimed to reach 140mph; the less powerful 8-valve engine pushes it to 126mph. 
 Also borrowed from the Cavalier is a four-wheel drive system on the 16-valve car. 
 What assures the Calibra's success is its pricing: the base model is predicted to cost less than &pound;14,000, while even the 16-valve four-wheel drive flyer should be on the right side of &pound;17,000. 
 Panther Solo. 
 Panther is one of Britain's lesser-known car manufacturers. 
 Currently its sole model is the Kallista, a sort of replica of a 1930s open-top sports car. 
 At Motorfair, this retro-mobile will be joined by the Le Mans-racer-style Solo, which makes its world debut, in production form at least. 
 Those with long memories may recall that the Solo made its first appearance at the 1987 Frankfurt Motor Show, but that was only a mock-up prototype. 
 Built at Harlow, Essex, the Solo features a composite body shell bonded to a steel underbody. 
 The advantages are lightness coupled with great strength. 
 The Solo's engine is mounted just behind the optional rear seats, well towards the middle of the car, to help achieve more even weight distribution. 
 The engine itself comes from the Ford Sapphire Cosworth and is turbocharged. 
 Panther claims it will blast the Solo from standstill to 60mph in less than 6.0 seconds and take it on to a top speed in excess of 150mph. 
 Four-wheel drive is standard on the Solo, as are anti-lock brakes. 
 Given the power of its engine, and the traction and road-holding afforded by its four-wheel drive system, the Solo should prove exceptionally fast on anyroad. 
 A conceivable problem for the Solo is its price &mdash; &pound;39,850 is a lot to pay for an unknown quantity. 
 But as only 100 of these hand-built cars are allocated to Britain for next year, it is unlikely that Panther will have much trouble shifting its stock. 
 Citroen XM. 
 Think of executive cars and your mind turns to Ford, Vauxhall, Rover, BMW and perhaps Alfa and Lancia. 
 The marque unlikely to feature in your list is Citroen. 
 Its executive car contender, the CX, is too old and idiosyncratic to warrant much attention on the British market, and is further disadvantaged by chronic depreciation. 
 Against this background, Citroen is launching a new executive car, the XM. 
 Citroen's designers had an unenviable task when styling the XM. 
 It had to look ordinary enough to appeal to a much broader market than the CX, but quirky enough to attract 15 years' worth of loyal CX owners. 
 If anything, the big Citroen's styling leans more towards the quirky camp &mdash; there'll be no mistaking it for anything else on the road, love it or hate it. 
 As unusual as its styling is the XM's suspension system. 
 Instead of merely reacting to differences in the road surface, as a conventional suspension system does, it anticipates bumps and bends. 
 It does this through sensors which monitor speed and body movement, and this information is passed on to a computer. 
 For normal driving conditions the computer chooses a soft suspension setting, but at speed and during sharp handling and emergency manoeuvres, it switches automatically to a firmer setting. 
 Power for the XM comes from a pair of 2.0-litre engines (one of which is fuel-injected), a diesel, a turbodiesel and a 3.0-litre V6. 
 It remains to be seen how the XM stacks up against traditional executive fare, but the chances are that it will be too exotic for the British palate. 
 Land-Rover Discovery. 
 It's not often Land-Rover launches a completely new car. 
 The last was the Range Rover, 20 years ago. 
 So it's something of a treat that the Discovery has its first British airing at Motorfair. 
 The Discovery is Land-Rover's challenge to the Mitsubishi Shogun, Isuzu Trooper and Daihatsu Fourtrak, which have hit the British firm hard in the burgeoning four-wheel drive leisure market. 
 The traditional Land-Rover is simply too agricultural to compete against the Japanese, especially as these vehicles spend more time ploughing round town than wading through mire. 
 As in the Land-Rover and Range Rover, the Discovery's body, except for the roof, is made of rust-resistant aluminium alloy. 
 The Discovery has the same wheelbase as the Range Rover but, thanks to advances made in interior packaging, has much more room inside its well-appointed cabin than its big, expensive stablemate. 
 The Discovery also shares the Range Rover's suspension system. 
 This should ensure it rides more comfortably than its Japanese rivals on the road. 
 It should out-point them on the rough stuff, too, for the Range Rover is still king of the wild frontiers. 
 Another advantage the Discovery has is permanent, rather than part-time, four-wheel drive. 
 There are two choices of engine for the Discovery. 
 One is a carburettor version of the V8 which powers the Range Rover. 
 The other, sure to be more popular, is a brand-new turbocharged diesel engine developed by Land-Rover. 
 Although prices have not been announced, Land-Rover is said to be keen that the turbodiesel Discovery should undercut the &pound;17,859 Mitsubishi Shogun five-door turbodiesel. 
 Rover 200-series. 
 Rover launches its new car, the 200, to the world at Motorfair. 
 It's the second car designed, developed and manufactured in collaboration with its part-owner, Honda. 
 The Rover 800-series, to which the new 200 bears a strong family resemblance, was the first. 
 Some time ago, Rover's management declared its intention to move all its cars up-market, perhaps to produce them in smaller volumes than in the days of Austin Rover, to charge higher prices and make more profit per unit. 
 The idea was to create a British version of BMW or Audi; the new 200 is that idea's realisation. 
 The 200 is a five-door hatchback and is one of the new breed of Escort-class cars to offer almost as much room inside as a Sierra. 
 Also on offer is a hefty helping of class &mdash; the 200's interior design owes a lot to its big sister, the 800, and even shares its wood trimmings. 
 The interior has that feeling of solidity normally associated with German-built cars. 
 The 200 must be perceived as a refined car, if Rover is to justify charging slightly more than the going rate for its class. 
 Two engines power the 200; a 1.6-litre, designed and built by Honda, and a brand new 1.4-litre unit, designed entirely by Rover. 
 Known as the K-series, the Rover engine contains many innovative features to aid performance, improve economy and reduce service costs considerably. 
 Yugo Sana. 
 While the so-called &bquo;superminis&equo; &mdash; cars like the Peugeot 205 and the new Ford Fiesta &mdash; grow larger and more expensive, the Eastern bloc car makers have quietly crept in to capitalise on the market for more affordable transport. 
 Laugh, if you must, about Skoda, but its market share is increasing at a time when some &bquo;serious&equo; manufacturers are in decline. 
 The Yugo (nee Zastava), built in Yugoslavia, managed to escape the Iron Curtain car jokes but at the same time escaped, completely, the attention of press and public. 
 (Skoda, if you think about it, received priceless publicity, and emerged from its leg-pulling in surprisingly good shape.) 
 But Yugo hopes to change all that at Motorfair, when it gives its new five-door family car, the Sana, its first UK showing. 
 The rest of the Yugo range is based on old Fiats from the 1970s, but the Sana is a completely new design. 
 It maintains a link with Fiat, though &mdash; its 1.4-litre engine is the same as that used in the Tipo. 
 And there's another Italian connection: it was styled by one of the world's leading car designers, Georgio Giugiaro, whose portfolio includes the Fiat Uno, Seat Ibiza, and the first-series Lotus Esprit. 
 Inside, the Sana is extremely spacious, and though the quality of its cabin materials cannot match that of west European cars, it is better than some eastern rivals. 
 Prices will be announced at Motorfair, but as with Skoda and Lada you should be able to buy this Escort-size car for less than a Fiesta. 
 Motorfair, Earls Court Exhibition Centre, west London; 19-29 October. 
 Open 9.30am-7.30 pm, except on the last day, when the show closes at 5pm. 
 On preview day (19 October) tickets are &pound;10; for the rest of the show, &pound;5 for adults, &pound;3 for children and OAPs. 
 After 5pm adult tickets &pound;3. 
 Talk of the Trade: Surreal memories 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 JOHN Armstrong's paintings, &bquo;built up of remembered things which in my case have been miscalled surrealist&equo;, have a poetic appeal which often beats Dali, Magritte et al at their own game. 
 A group of 38 of his paintings are on show at Ewan Mundy and Celia Philo's Gallery (top floor, 29 New Bond Street, W1) until 28 October, some on loan from his family and some for sale &mdash; mostly from &pound;8,000 to &pound;12,000, but dipping as low as &pound;3,000 and running as high as &pound;40,000. 
 The catalogue has an introduction by his widow, Annette, through which one glimpses the man and the mind behind the images. 
 Armstrong was born in 1893 and had a classical education at Oxford before reaching art school just before the outbreak of the First World War. 
 He died in 1973. 
 Armstrong fought in the First World War and was a war artist in the Second, sharing with other Surrealists the challenge of creating a pattern out of devastation. 
 He held fast to beauty of form and colour and added a spice of wit &mdash; as pleasingly revealed in Bond Street by his Perspiring Venus. 
 Talk of the Trade: Chinese treasures 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 SINCE artworks began to flood out of China in the early 1980s &mdash; mostly smuggled by sea to Macao or Hong Kong &mdash; extraordinary rarities, hitherto unknown in the West, have begun to turn up on the market. 
 Bluett's (48 Davies Street, London W1) has got its hands on a group of three bronze vessels from the Warring States period (third century BC). 
 There is only one other known example of their size and elegance in the West &mdash; in the Freer Gallery in Washington. 
 Bluett's has a steamer, vase and bowl, each inlaid with intricate patterns and in startlingly good condition. 
 They are thought to be from south China. 
 Official excavations have recently unearthed similar pieces, which are unlikely to ever leave the country. 
 Prices - &pound;850,000 for the bowl and &pound;1.2m each for vase and steamer - reflect their rarity. 
 Talk of the Trade: Son of Epstein 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 THEODORE Garman, whose paintings are on exhibition at the Fine Art Society (148 New Bond Street, London W1), died as a result of pinching a cast from Chelsea Art School's antique room. 
 He would have returned it, of course, he only wanted it for a painting. 
 But the principal called the police. 
 Once his mental instability was recognised, he was sent to hospital, but died of a heart attack in the ambulance. 
 That was in 1954 when he was 30 years old. 
 This memorial exhibition combines his explosively colourful paintings with sculptures by his father, Jacob Epstein, and has been organised, following his mother's death, by her friend, Beth Lipkin, to whom most of the pictures were left. 
 The paintings are a revelation, hidden from the public since his two successful exhibitions at the Redfern Gallery in 1950 and 1952. 
 Matthew Smith compared him to Van Gogh. 
 Wyndham Lewis wrote in The Listener: &bquo;On entering the gallery you are overwhelmed by a rancid vegetation, tropically gigantic&hellip; 
 A little concentration on individual pictures will soon reveal how excellent is the workmanship.&equo; 
 Kenneth Clark was enthusiastic when he saw some hanging in Epstein's home. 
 Prices range from &pound;3,000 to &pound;12,000. 
 Finds: Get to grips with a matchbox: John Windsor meets a man fired with enthusiasm for matchbox covers 
 By JOHN WINDSOR 
 AT A top price of &pound;20-&pound;30 &mdash; &bquo;through the roof&equo; says Ian Hooker, with tongue in cheek &mdash; commemorative and advertising matchbox grips still cost peanuts compared with even the cheapest London saleroom collectables. 
 Much other printed ephemera can be picked up just as cheaply, a boon market for collectors sharp enough to spot history mirrored in the disposable scraps of everyday life. 
 Mr Hooker, a motor trade production foreman who began assembling the world's largest collection of grips 12 years ago, has seen antique fair prices for rare ones rise from a fiver, two or three years ago, to the present &pound;20-&pound;30, all due, he says, to the boom in advertising ephemera. 
 Production of matchbox grips by small businesses lasted for 42 years, from 1911 to 1953. 
 They consist of a rectangle of thin metal, bent twice to grip three sides of a matchbox, and a printed paper cover crimped in a protective film of transparent celluloid. 
 At least 645 different designs were published &mdash; the number in Mr Hooker's collection, shown for the first time last weekend at the British Matchbox Label and Booklet Society's annual exhibition in London. 
 Mr Hooker estimates that 12 years ago, when he paid &pound;1.50 for his first grip, there were up to 100 collectors of whom he knew a couple of dozen. 
 At the time, the hobby had been on the wane for years. 
 Today, he estimates, the number of collectors has dropped to about 50. 
 He knows most of them. 
 In the past couple of years he has started buying up small collections of 30 or 40, but his weekly forays around antique fairs are now yielding only three or four new designs a year. 
 His publication last year of the first matchbox grip catalogue has, he says, not contributed to the sudden rise in prices. 
 But it will certainly put the hobby on the map. 
 Its three illustrated volumes of 60 to 100 pages have sold 70 copies each, and a supplement of 200 newly discovered grips is due out at Christmas. 
 The Hooker collection charts not only the claims of obsolete products but also the swell of public sentiment during two world wars, as well as some prize not-in-front-of-the-children examples of publicans' ribaldry. 
 Matchbox grips, like today's bubble-gum wrappers, were a particularly accurate evocation of the man-in-the-street's pride and prejudices. 
 During the First World War a box of matches cost 1d and a matchbox grip 4d: a price just substantial enough to warrant a &bquo;Thank you&equo; when given free to a pub or grocer's store customer, and just substantial enough to make money for a stationer or the many charities which sold them. 
 But to prise 4d out of a working man's pocket, the slogans and graphics had to have street appeal. 
 Nationalism was the most gripping sentiment. 
 When a popular war hero emerged, like Lt William Leefe Robinson, awarded the VC in 1916 for shooting down the first enemy airship over British soil, the jobbing printers, metal benders and celluloid crimpers worked overtime. 
 The Leefe Robinson commemorative shows the flaming airship, &bquo;The end of the baby killer&equo; and fetches a top price of &pound;20-&pound;30. 
 Much of the First World War output was jingoistic. 
 The General Sir John French commemorative of 1916, which the Rose and Crown Hotel in Selby offered its customers at the time, is captioned &bquo;Souvenir of the Greatest War in History&equo;. 
 Today's price for run-of-the-mill First World War grips is &pound;7-&pound;15 and for Second World War &pound;3-&pound;8. 
 Swan pens and Spratt's, the pet food makers, were among regular advertisers. 
 Football clubs sold grips which listed forthcoming fixtures. 
 Matchbox grips were a peculiarly British institution. 
 But the Australians imported them in large numbers. 
 The coarsest grip jokes date from 1940s Australia, like the Lindeman Island grip captioned, &bquo;Well, what are you looking at?&equo;, whose illustration is described in Mr Hooker's catalogue as &bquo;man and woman at a urinal&equo;. 
 It would fetch about &pound;10. 
 The Australians are the biggest collectors after the British. 
 A series of &bquo;Famous British Film Stars&equo; of 1946, now worth &pound;5-&pound;10 each, apparently never got off the ground. 
 Mr Hooker has traced only five showing 10 stars: Patricia Roc and Gene Kent, Margaret Lockwood and Lilli Palmer, Humphrey Bogart and Lauren Bacall, Stewart Granger and Michael Rennie, Phyllis Calvert and Ann Crawford. 
 Any more, anyone? 
 Auctions 
 By JOHN WINDSOR 
 THE BOOM in colourful, vigorous Impressionist-style paintings which, with some astute promotion by auctioneers, has already rippled through the markets for the Scottish colourists, Italian, Scandinavian and Irish art, now has a chance to affect Belgian art, at Christie's on Thursday. 
 The 131-lot sale covers the late nineteenth and early twentieth-century Belgian movements. 
 Paintings come from the Paris-oriented group, Les Vingt, which exhibited Van Gogh, Gauguin, Cezanne, Monet and Renoir well before their reputations were established in France, from the dreamy Symbolists and the more forceful Flemish Expressionists. 
 There are nine paintings in the sale by Gustave de Smet (1877-1943), whose style switched from Impressionism to Expressionism around 1914. 
 Before Christie's first sale of Belgian art a year ago, in which a 1930s de Smet of Flemish peasants made &pound;275,000, the highest auction price for the artist was &pound;18,000. 
 British dealers bite the Big Apple: American collectors set the pace and the prices. 
 Geraldine Norman looks at the latest developments 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 THE AMERICAN art market, overblown on investment cash, is calling the tune internationally. 
 It is fashionable among rich Americans to buy art, donate art, exhibit art and appreciate art. 
 But they would not be so rich if they were not adept at minimising tax and maximising profits. 
 The schemes they have dreamed up for art-related asset-manipulation are being imitated throughout the world, notably in Europe and Japan. 
 This makes the precedents that have been set in America important to anyone who is interested in playing the market. 
 At the end of September, 35 English dealers and 15 from the Continent joined 35 American dealers to hold the first International Antique Dealers' Show at the Seventh Regiment Armory on Park Avenue, in the heart of Manhattan. 
 In the course of five days, during which the super-rich flooded through the hall, the Europeans learned just what American collectors want. 
 The show was a sensational success. 
 Organised by Brian and Anna Houghton, the London ceramics dealers who have launched two highly regarded specialist fairs in London during the past few years, it offered New Yorkers two innovations; an expert vetting committee, which checked that every item was genuinely what it was said to be &mdash; there had never been vetting in America before &mdash; and a showcase in their own city of top European dealers' wares. 
 The benefactors' preview, which cost &dollar;500 a ticket, was packed with the rich and famous, despite the approach of Hurricane Hugo, which raised temperatures into the 90s. 
 Some sweating millionaires were buying while others said they were too hot to think and would come back later &mdash; which they did. 
 Furniture was the focus of interest but, according to John Hill, from Jeremy of the King's Road, London, the Americans did not just want good examples of standard items, they wanted something different, with a gimmick or original style. 
 A serpentine commode, the central section of which pulled out as a silver table, and a Russian mirror of the 1790s supported on twisting ormolu snakes could have been sold many times over. 
 Alistair Sampson, whose Brompton Road shop specialises in primitive country wares &mdash; pottery, carvings, furniture, embroideries &mdash; hit a bull's-eye because of the close parallels with American folk art. 
 A seventeenth-century painted chest which would have cost &dollar;1m if it had been American seemed a bargain at one tenth that price. 
 &bquo;I had been advised to mark everything up by 20 per cent,&equo; Alistair Sampson said, &bquo;because the clients&equo; decorators would come round afterwards asking for a cut. 
 In fact, I only met one decorator&hellip; a young couple wanted to buy a piece and I offered them a discount as they hadn't got a decorator - at which she drew herself up and said: &bquo;We are not married. 
 I am his interior decorator.&equo; 
 ' Kate Foster of the Halkin Arcade, Belgravia, the scholarly specialist in Continental porcelain, found the opposite. 
 &bquo;I suppose we've got to get used to rich people coming along with their decorators&equo;, she said. 
 &bquo;I met new clients which is what I went for.&equo; 
 In the oriental field, Bluett's failed to find buyers for a group of Chinese Warring States bronze vessels of extraordinary scholarly interest, while Colnaghi Oriental found spectacularly decorative seventeenth-century bronzes easy to move. 
 AMERICAN buyers depend on advisers, whether decorators or art specialists, to an extent unparalleled in Europe. 
 They read publications that keep them abreast of market trends, personalities, lawsuits and prices &mdash; rather than delving into art history as do their counterparts in Europe. 
 Two publications are especially influential: a fat, glossy, monthly magazine called Art and Auction and a bi-weekly insider newsletter, The ARTnewsletter, published by the old-established magazine Art News. 
 The latest issue of The ARTnewsletter leads off with a report on tax bills, now being studied by committees in both houses of Congress, which are aimed at restoring the fiddle element to tax-deductible museum donations. 
 In America, the value of a museum donation can be deducted from gross income before tax is calculated. 
 In 1986 a law was passed that required donations to be valued at cost rather than an invented &bquo;appreciated&equo; value for tax purposes &mdash; though only in cases where the deductions would reduce the donor's tax bill to zero. 
 The result has been catastrophic. 
 The Association of Art Museum Directors recently reported that the value of art donations had declined by 63 per cent between 1986 and 1988. 
 Many museums have reacted by selling important works from their collections. 
 However, The ARTnewsletter says it is confident that the bills now being studied by Congress, which would restore the fiddle, will become law next year. 
 TWO LAWSUITS resulting from Christie's &dollar;39.6m sale last May of Impressionists from the collection of Hal Wallis, the Hollywood movie producer, are reported on in Art and Auction, the monthly magazine. 
 The Wallis Foundation, to which Wallis left the paintings, is being sued by the Los Angeles County Museum and by Wildenstein's, the international art dealers. 
 It has emerged that in 1980 Wallis's second wife, Martha Hyer Wallis, took four of his paintings, replacing them with copies, to raise a &dollar;1m loan. 
 When the copyists sold the originals to Wildenstein's for &dollar;665,000 and decamped with the proceeds, Wallis got to hear of it and had to buy back the pictures. 
 As part of the deal he gave Wildenstein's the right of first refusal on 15 of his paintings should his heirs seek to sell them. 
 Wildenstein's claims that this agreement was broken by the sale at Christie's. 
 The case has brought to light a &bquo;letter of instruction&equo; signed by Wallis two weeks before his death in 1986 asking the trustees of his foundation to exhibit the paintings on loan at the Los Angeles County Museum, &bquo;whether for a definite or indefinite period of time&equo;. 
 So the museum has gone to law to get the pictures back. 
 Leading Article: An alternative emerges 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 IS THERE an alternative? 
 That question has dominated the proceedings in Blackpool this week. 
 For the purposes of the Conservative Party conference, it was enough that the Prime Minister and the Chancellor of the Exchequer denied the existence of an alternative economic strategy. 
 The Labour Party's lead in the polls and the doubts which the Conservatives themselves cannot help feeling about the state of the economy, both made the audience in the Winter Gardens anxious to demonstrate unity by giving standing ovations to the architects of the Government's economic policy. 
 The wider, less devoted audience in the country will not be so ready to express approval. 
 Several weaknesses undermine the Government's position. 
 The first is that the Prime Minister has always said she regards the fight against inflation as paramount. 
 Why then, people wonder, is inflation so much higher here than in our main competitor countries? 
 By her own standard, Mrs Thatcher has failed. 
 She tightened her grip on the great enemy, only to loosen it again. 
 It is one thing to win the support of electors by defeating an enemy for the first time; it is quite another to expect admiration for slaying the same dragon twice. 
 Mrs Thatcher yesterday had the honesty to admit that inflation is &bquo;far too high&equo;, but she no more deigned to explain what has gone wrong than the Chancellor had the day before. 
 The second weakness in the Government's position is that in an important respect it is ambiguous. 
 The Prime Minister opposes entry into the Exchange Rate Mechanism of the European Monetary System; the Chancellor favours it. 
 Instead of adopting one or other of these policies, they have tried to hide their difference beneath an uneasy and evasive compromise. 
 Neither Mrs Thatcher nor Mr Lawson was able to mention the subject from the platform. 
 This is bad politics as well as bad economics. 
 Indeed, the division itself is as much about politics as economics: Mrs Thatcher's hostility to the ERM springs from her hostility to the European Community, which she did not mention yesterday. 
 The third weakness is that the method adopted to conquer inflation for the second time &mdash; raising the interest rate &mdash; only works by inflicting pain on borrowers, both corporate and domestic. 
 Hence the longing for an alternative policy, and the determined claims that one does not exist. 
 The contrast with other fields of policy is striking. 
 Here, alternatives are already being found. 
 Discontent with the introduction of the poll tax and the reform of the National Health Service can be assuaged by spending more money. 
 The reforms themselves can be modified: &bquo;The National Health service will not be privatised,&equo; Mrs Thatcher declared in her speech yesterday. 
 She claimed, indeed, that it was &bquo;never going to be privatised&equo;, though the aspiration certainly existed. 
 The project proved impolitic: the public would not stand for it, so the Government discarded or diluted ideology to avoid unpopularity. 
 The same has happened at the Department of the Environment: Christopher Patten has conducted himself this week as the antithesis of an ideologue. 
 No such retreat exists with the economy (though Mr Lawson did abandon pure monetarism). 
 Ministers can merely attack the Labour Party: the only passage in Mr Lawson's speech on Thursday which moved his audience to genuine enthusiasm was his attack on Neil Kinnock. 
 Labour is, however, becoming a less vulnerable target. 
 To deride the party's &bquo;mass conversion&equo; from its former belief, as Mrs Thatcher did yesterday, raises a cheer from committed Conservatives, but floating voters may reckon that it is intelligent to abandon wrong-headed policies. 
 The Labour Party's advocacy of credit controls remains unconvincing, but by supporting negotiations to join ERM, it has stolen a march on the Conservatives. 
 In short, an alternative is emerging, not one which enables the country to avoid the pain of high interest rates, but one in which these can be concentrated on their proper function: reducing domestic demand. 
 The ERM could provide a stronger framework for the maintenance of a stable currency. 
 Mrs Thatcher's heart would not be in that approach, any more than the Labour Party has yet taken the need for high interest rates to its bosom. 
 But at the end of the conference season, it is possible to see a political market-place reviving in Britain, albeit a market-place containing only two parties. 
 In the new battle against inflation, the old claim that there is no alternative has started to sound out of date. 
 Quote Unquote 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 The messages on our banners in 1979 &mdash; freedom, opportunity, family, enterprise, ownership &mdash; are now inscribed on the banners in Leipzig, Warsaw, Budapest and even Moscow. 
 Margaret Thatcher. 
 Polluted rivers, filthy streets, bodies bedded down in doorways are no advertisement for a prosperous and caring society. 
 Michael Heseltine. 
 Propping up the pound is like trying to get water to run uphill. 
 Sir Rhodes Boyson The market isn't enough, and I don't think that Tories have ever believed the market is enough. 
 We've always believed that the market has to be regulated. 
 Chris Patten Without the Winter of Discontent, I would now be running my third government. 
 Denis Healey Greater love hath no man than that he lays down his jokes for his Prime Minister. 
 Cabinet colleague on Chris Patten, scriptwriter to the PM We are an easy target, just 14 defenceless women with no expertise. 
 Sister Catherine, of Our Lady of Passion monastery, Northants, on the order to slaughter the nuns' salmonella-infected chickens I have never regarded the term &bquo;do-gooder&equo; as a criticism. 
 On the contrary, this nation's deep-rooted and flourishing tradition of doing good by voluntary service is something which enriches our community. 
 Douglas Hurd Can you take me to your planet? 
 Pavel Mukhortov, the Russian reporter who claims to have had a close encounter with extra-terrestrials He (Nelson Mandela) was trying to explain to us how he feels about negotiations, how it was his feeling that in any country, even if there is war, there is time for negotiations. 
 Albertina Sisulu Elderly people need to take more time over love-making and be less ambitious. 
 Dr John Kellett, specialist in geriatrics. 
 If you can't stand the heat, spend this winter with an old age pensioner. 
 Glasgow graffito 
 Sex, money and Golden Oldies: Profile: Katharine Hamnett, fashion's fireball 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 Amid the tension and gossip of this weekend's London fashion shows, Katharine Hamnett, rebel, provocateur and most likely candidate for the title of British Designer of the Year, is conspicuous by her absence. 
 Having declared London &bquo;shabby and out of the way&equo;, Hamnett has decamped to show in Paris, leaving a trail of controversy in her wake. 
 Hamnett's defection comes at a time of high anxiety in the British fashion industry &mdash; but then she's a woman well known for choosing her moments. 
 Her talent for publicity is acute and often unsettling. 
 Possibly the only person ever to have succeeded in upstaging Margaret Thatcher in a photo-opportunity, Katharine lined up to shake the Prime Minister's hand wearing a T-shirt declaring &bquo;58 per cent Don't Want Pershing&equo; at a Downing Street reception in 1984. 
 It was a coup not only for CND sentiments but for Hamnett personally, shooting her to instant fame around the world. 
 She claims proudly that one news agency had more requests for that photograph than any other that year. 
 Katharine Hamnett is a contradictory, impulsive figure: a feminist who sells on sex, a vegetarian hedonist, a Labour voter with two sons at private school and a &pound;20m turnover. 
 Some find her inconsistencies maddening, failing to understand how a right-on feminist could have done such a thing as using Mandy Smith in her show at the very height of the tabloid fuss over Smith's under-age relationship with Bill Wyman. 
 (Though it certainly got Hamnett's clothes in the papers). 
 Katharine Hamnett's instinct for kicking against the Establishment comes partly out of the mind-set of her own particular generation, partly out of a reaction to an upper middle-class upbringing. 
 She was born Katharine Appleton in Gravesend in 1948 into a diplomatic family, and remembers herself as &bquo;the girl on the reception line&equo; at dull diplomatic occasions in various European embassies while her father carried out his duties as an air attache. 
 Her deliberate breach of protocol at No. 10 might be construed partly as a late revenge for those teenage tortures, though her anger, now transmuted into political sloganising, runs deeper than mere petulance. 
 She was profoundly scarred by her father's suicide in 1976, and blames the tragedy on the mental stress caused by the Wilson government's reneging on a fighter bomber deal he had set up with Sweden. 
 He was, she says, &bquo;a moral man&equo;. 
 Hamnett was educated at Cheltenham Ladies College and went to St Martin's School of Art to study fashion design in 1965; she made an indelible impression there. 
 Elizabeth Suter, then Head of Fashion, remembers her as &bquo;an outstanding character, a marvellous girl, always amusing and sparky. 
 If she walked into a room, one was always aware of her&equo;. 
 Though her radicalism had not begun to develop, her individualistic streak was already fully formed, as Miss Suter recalls: &bquo;It was about the time we were beginning to have trouble with student sit-ins, and Katharine stuck out against it. 
 She wanted to get on with her work.&equo; 
 Katharine's quick-fire tongue and irreverent nature have often got her into trouble. 
 As a new graduate, she blew the chance to work for Yves Saint Laurent when she clashed with a fearsomely chic woman while visiting a textile company. 
 The woman was wearing a red hat which Katharine impertinently asked to try on. 
 The request was imperiously declined, to which Katharine retorted, &bquo;Red hat, no drawers!&equo; 
 The woman turned out to be Lady Claire Rendlesham, director of Yves Saint Laurent in London. 
 After making her way into the fashion business as a freelance designer and as a partner with Ann Buck in Tuttabankem from 1969 to 1974, Hamnett set up Katharine Hamnett Ltd on a &pound;500 loan in 1979. 
 It was her way with the pithy and quotable phrase that drew media attention to her work on the London catwalks in the early Eighties, a knack she called on again in her last collection, studding &bquo;Clean Up Or Die&equo; on to the backs of leather biker jackets. 
 She sees red, however, when the slogans and other aspects of her designs are copied and bowdlerised; she has sounded off a great deal about suing the culprits, a litigious reflex often apparent in her career. 
 Critics have sniped that the dividing line between the political and the profit motive has never been too sharply defined on Hamnett's agenda, a feeling provoked by such off-the-cuff comments as her enthusiasm for an idea that will &bquo;make me rich and won't hurt animals&equo;. 
 One politically committed ex-collaborator comments: &bquo;In the beginning what she was doing was an interesting exercise in radical chic. 
 But there's no real logic to hold it together. 
 And her behaviour could prove dangerous to the causes she speaks for.&equo; 
 Recently, however, Hamnett has improved her credibility by funding a Friends of the Earth research project into the environmental costs of clothing production. 
 Hamnett's design reputation is contradictorily positioned somewhere in the avant garde, even though her work is steeped in nostalgia. 
 School uniforms, Sixties starlets and rockers have all been her inspiration, while the slogan T-shirts themselves were less of an invention than a Woodstock revival. 
 While Hamnett may be seen as the campaigning Bob Geldof of fashion, in design terms she is more the Tony Blackburn, making a living, like him, out of replaying Golden Oldies. 
 Her shows, which generate something of the atmosphere of rock concerts, with her interpretations of fashion's greatest hits of the past 25 years, are rampantly sexy and commercial. 
 Her cleverness, as always, is in the timing, her feeling for identifying the exact moment when a certain slice of the past will have most resonance in the present. 
 Katharine Hamnett now has manufacturing deals with one Japanese and two Italian companies, the key to international distribution. 
 If all goes smoothly, she now has the chance to become the first &bquo;young British designer&equo; to be internationally recognised (oddly, in the fashion business, designers are believed to be as young as their clothes look, which, in Hamnett's case, is about 19). 
 It is to be hoped that her business is now sufficiently stable to realise the opportunity, for she has clocked up three managing directors in the past few years. 
 An inter-regnum was filled by her boyfriend, Nick Rosen, a freelance journalist, who is widely believed by friends and former associates to have a strong influence on Katharine's decision-making. 
 Rosen was introduced to Katharine Hamnett by John May, a Face journalist who worked with her on the ill-fated Tomorrow, a magazine that was to be, bravely, &bquo;a mix of fashion and politics&equo;. 
 Hamnett and Rosen became so close so quickly that May's magazine was scrapped at the last minute in favour of a version reworked by Rosen. 
 Tomorrow survived one issue. 
 Its short life is not remembered in Hamnett's current biography. 
 Long memories are rare in a fashion world where thoughts are more concentrated on what's happening next than on the past. 
 Yet those who have come off the worse from their dealings with Hamnett may have sharper recall, among them London's high fashion retailers Joseph Ettedgui and Peter Bertelsen. 
 Ettedgui, who had supported Hamnett by selling her first clothes in his shops, was upset when she abandoned him in favour of Bertelsen, an oil-rich entrepreneur who arrived in London offering designer deals and retail arrangements in 1986. 
 Hamnett's relationship with Bertelsen foundered early last year, but only after he had opened an extravagant shop the size of an aircraft hangar for her, designed by Norman Foster in trendy Brompton Cross, South Kensington. 
 The shop had no window to attract the public and cubicle-sized changing rooms without mirrors. 
 Concerned when turnover did not match the grandiose scale of the shop, Bertelsen tried various tactics to get the merchandise moving, including putting on an early sale. 
 Hamnett became irate and, alleging breach of contract and damage to her image, threatened to sue him for a &pound;500,000. 
 No one is willing to go on record with their feelings about Hamnett's sometimes capricious behaviour, but one says privately: &bquo;Like many creative people, she can be impossible to reason with, and the experience can be very painful.&equo; 
 Yet Katharine Hamnett has many friends who accept her quirks and continue to admire. 
 Colin Barnes, the fashion illustrator, who has known her since St Martin's, says, &bquo;Of course outspoken people tread on toes, but they are often the ones who make waves and achieve something.&equo; 
 It will be a piquant moment if Hamnett indeed wins the title of British Designer of the Year at the first televised Fashion Awards ceremony at the Albert Hall on Tuesday night. 
 The award and the ceremony itself were instigated by the British Fashion Council, which tried every tactic it could -including the setting up of a smarter venue at The Duke of York's Barracks -to persuade Katharine Hamnett to show in London. 
 Plans were at an advanced stage when Hamnett, having vacillated for some time, phoned the BFC to say she had decided in favour of Paris after all. 
 In spite of the mixed feelings that will undoubtedly be provoked on Tuesday night, Hamnett's move should be assessed in a cooler and more general light. 
 She is launching herself into Europe with at least as much conviction as any other British businessperson has so far shown. 
 Having spent many years arguing for government support for the British fashion industry &mdash; and getting nowhere &mdash; she cannot be blamed for opting to manufacture and show abroad. 
 Where supporters call her brave and detractors selfish, it is perhaps nearer the truth to see the passionately political Katharine Hamnett as developing all the pragmatic hallmarks of the hard-nosed businesswoman. 
 The advantages of higher perches 
 By DUFF HART-DAVIS 
 THE Black Sumatra has done it again. 
 Or perhaps I should say, &bquo;Another of the Black Sumatras has done it&equo; &mdash; for our three sooty chickens of this exotic breed are indistinguishable from one another, and we cannot be sure which of them has excelled itself. 
 Either way, a second miracle has just occurred. 
 I have often noticed that in any flock of genuinely free-range chickens there are one or two high-layers: that is, birds which seek out nesting sites in elevated positions, on inaccessible window-ledges or the tops of bale-stacks. 
 No doubt age-old instincts tell them that altitude gives a measure of protection, but often the fact that a site commands good views seems a positive recommendation, as if a distant prospect of fields or farmyard is in itself an aid to production. 
 Of our present flock, the high-layers favour various niches, among them one in an old pheasant crate resting on rafters in the old cow-shed. 
 But above all they seem to like an eyrie just beneath the eaves of the barn roof. 
 It cannot be very comfortable, for it consists merely of an uneven depression on top of the stone wall, barely softened by dust and a few wisps of hay. 
 Nor does it have much of a view, since it looks down into the stable. 
 But it does offer security and freedom from disturbance. 
 Recovery of eggs from such an eminence presents certain problems. 
 Unless one goes to the bother of fetching a ladder every time, the only way up is to scramble chimpanzee-like via a window-sill, the top of the stable partition, the nearest iron roof-girder, and finally the barn wall itself, along which one has to shuffle sideways, sitting down. 
 Since both hands are needed for the descent, as much as for the climb, one cannot keep hold of any eggs that one finds. 
 Nor is it much use to put them in a pocket, for the rigours of the downward journey are such that they arrive at ground level in the form of an omelette. 
 The best solution, I have found, is to throw them down, one by one, on to the horses' deep bed of wood-chips, off which they almost always bounce unscathed. 
 In spite of these hazards, I generally visit the wall-nest every two or three days; but now and then, I have to admit, it escapes my attention. 
 Some time in the summer we noticed that one of the Black Sumatras had started to incubate aloft. 
 How long she had been there, we could not be sure, for if she sat with head and tail aligned along the wall, she was invisible from below, and only when she turned sideways did she come into view. 
 We had owned the Sumatras for just a few months, but already we had seen that they are volatile and eccentric birds, much given to sudden screech-ups and bouts of cackling, which in other chickens would denote the arrival of an egg, but from them seem to signify only that they have given themselves a fright. 
 In appearance they are distinctly corvine, being not only crow-black, but slender, small-headed and powerful about the beak. 
 For various reasons, we expected little of the sitting hen. 
 For one thing, I thought I had cleared the nest recently, and that if she was sitting on anything at all, her clutch could not number more than two or three eggs. 
 For another, the padding beneath her was pitifully insubstantial. 
 As a boy I was always taught to use a sod of turf as a foundation, so that the eggs would remain slightly damp, and to build a snug nest of hay on top of it - and the barn wall was knobbly, draughty and dry as dust. 
 The worst hazard, though, was that as the days went by the Sumatra seemed to become increasingly irresponsible. 
 She spent more and more time off her eggs, parading about the yard, cackling as if demented and taking sudden rushes in whatever direction she happened to be facing when each fit of frenzy overcame her. 
 Nevertheless, she kept returning to the nest, and one morning I had a sudden feeling that she was about to hatch something, after all. 
 Sure enough, a high-pitched peeping drew me to the stable, and there on the floor was the hen with one minute black puff-ball of a chick. 
 More peeping sounded from high up, and on top of the wall, to my amazement, I found eight more toddlers, five black and three white (the father is a silver cockerel of mixed descent). 
 As the first one had managed to flutter down, it seemed that the rest should be able to do the same, but I judged it safer to load them into a cardboard box and lower them gently. 
 Once united with her brood, the mother became maniacally fierce. 
 Her protective instincts were wonderful to watch. 
 At the approach of any intruder &mdash; even a human being bringing food &mdash; she would screech, raise her wings in threat, weave about and retreat into a corner. 
 Less comforting for the chicks was her habit of scratching violently backwards with one foot after the other, which often sent the babies hurtling out of the way like fluffy ping-pong balls. 
 For the first few days we kept the family shut into the cow-shed, to protect them from the cats; but I really think that if any cat had had the temerity to put in an attack, the hen would have chased it half-way to Gloucester. 
 Soon the chicks were big enough to be out and about, and once they had left their mother, they began to exhibit her wild characteristics, wandering recklessly far up the fields into territory frequented by foxes. 
 Yet somehow all nine have survived, and now they are practically full-sized chickens. 
 This week, believe it or not, another, almost identical saga began. 
 This time we had not noticed any incumbent on the barn wall. 
 Thinking the site had fallen out of use, I had ceased to monitor it. 
 Then one morning came a tell-tale peep, peep. 
 Again there was a Black Sumatra and one chick on the ground, but this time there were nine others aloft, all more or less black. 
 Once we had got them down, we found that one could scarcely stand up. 
 It was certainly too weak to stagger along with its fellows. 
 Was it malformed, or merely hypothermic, the last to hatch? 
 On such occasions it often seems foolish to intervene, for nature has a way of eliminating stragglers. 
 Yet we felt we should give this fellow a chance, so my wife put it in a box and set it on top of the Aga. 
 For the chick, it must have been like suddenly landing in the Sahara. 
 At first it did not respond. 
 Maybe it was stupefied by the abrupt rise in temperature. 
 But then, at about 9pm, it suddenly set up a fortissimo peeping, and from that moment never looked back. 
 In the morning we slipped it back under the hen, and at once it was part of the family. 
 The mother, as I say, may or may not be the hen which hatched the first brood; but from her behaviour, which seems slightly less frenetic, I reckon she is someone else. 
 So another 10 puff-balls are starting life, and the summer's production totals 19. 
 Past experience suggests that one or two of them will come to rest in the belly of a fox, and of those that survive several, I fear, will turn out to be cockerels. 
 These will end up in the pot, a bit skinny from their hyper-active existence, but tasting five times as good as any bird you can buy. 
 Yet with any luck we shall have a dozen bold new hens to lay eggs for us next year - and even if only half of them manage to emulate their mothers in the matter of bringing up families, by mid-summer we shall be positively over-run. 
 William Donaldson's Week: Drug-induced terror is no match for &bquo;That's Life&equo; 
 By WILLIAM DONALDSON 
 I have had a religious experience &mdash; which is not to say, of course, that I am claiming a religious explanation for it. 
 What is incontrovertible is only that I had it, not that it was caused by anything &bquo;out there&equo; beyond my experience. 
 I do typically, however, have a need to describe it to total strangers. 
 This is what happened. 
 Lunching with Lord Dynevor, I told him of my settled feeling that I am playing in the final of the FA Cup, that there are three minutes to go and that my team is 0-4 down. 
 How to play out the last few seconds? 
 Do facetious back-flips? 
 Pick up the ball and run around with it? 
 Kick the referee? 
 Or strive to go down with one's dignity intact? 
 The important thing, he said, was to stop the opposition scoring four more goals, but I left the restaurant unconvinced. 
 Then, walking home, I was easily overtaken by Mrs Matthews, who is 93 and lives next door. 
 She asked me whether I'd taken the cat to the vet, and I admitted that I hadn't. 
 &bquo;Wake yourself up, dear,&equo; she said, and she hurried on. 
 I squared my shoulders, returned to the flat and cleaned the kitchen. 
 Then I rang the vet. 
 Then I thought stuff that, I'd rather go to Ibiza with my literary agent, Alison, and take some Ecstasy. 
 We flew out on Saturday and went straight to the Mar Y Sol to meet Tanit the Island God. 
 Apart from carrying enough controlled substances in his G-string to keep Spain happy for a year, Tanit has the divine attribute of being everywhere at once. 
 Whatever time it is, Tanit is where you are. 
 Once I asked him when he slept. 
 &bquo;I sleep when you sleep,&equo; he said. 
 That stumped me. 
 Anyway, Alison and I went to the Mar Y Sol and Tanit wasn't there. 
 There was a nice-looking American at the next table, however, so I asked him whether he was a drug-fiend, dealing in human misery, in which case, I said, I'd like some Ecstasy. 
 He took 15,000 pesetas off me and said he'd come to my apartment later that evening. 
 That seemed all right, but over dinner Alison began to act oddly &mdash; as if she was enjoying herself &mdash; so I scowled at her and asked her what the problem was. 
 I did, actually. 
 She wasn't meant to be happy, she was meant to be with me. 
 Then she said she felt happy enough to skip the Ecstasy experiment and, instead, to have an early night, so I refused to talk to her for the rest of the meal &mdash; rightly, I think &mdash; and on the way home I walked stiffly three yards ahead of her. 
 When my American friend pitched up with the news that we had to meet his contact at Ku Disco, Alison said she'd like to come too, but I sent her to bed. 
 &bquo;You're tired,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Remember?&equo; 
 She looked a little startled, but she did as she was told. 
 I and my new friend then went to Ku where he took another 15,000 pesetas off me &mdash; the price had gone up, he said &mdash; and he parked me by the dance-floor and said he'd be back in five minutes. 
 After two hours I began to wonder if he had stitched me up and then, worse, whether he was back at the flat with Alison. 
 I hurried home and was relieved to find her asleep in bed. 
 The next morning, she asked me how my night had been. 
 Brilliant, I said, pretending that I'd just got in. 
 My new friend and I had picked up two mad women, I said, and we'd taken lots of this and that and one thing had led to another, as often happens when young people get together. 
 She let me finish and then she said: &bquo;That's odd. 
 Five minutes after you left he was back here throwing stones at the window. 
 I told him to bog off.&equo; 
 I didn't speak to her for the rest of the day, of course, and this made her laugh, I don't know why. 
 Then, late in the evening, my new friend turned up with a little white pill for each of us. 
 Alison wasn't keen to take hers, but I managed to persuade her, pointing out that since I hadn't been asked for any more money these were almost certainly aspirins. 
 After 10 minutes or so we both got the most appalling horrors. 
 Chemically-induced terror can be dispersed, I've found, by concentrating on horrors in the real world, so I thought of That's Life and VAT and Mrs Thatcher, and after a while I began to feel better. 
 I went into the bedroom where Alison was lying down in what seemed to be a state of shock. 
 I was about to call a doctor and then, suddenly, I had a feeling which I can only describe as &mdash; excuse me &mdash; ecstatic. 
 I felt that the world and everything in it was benign, that Alison was infinitely precious and that Dummett's argument from value &mdash; that we know there is right and wrong &mdash; to a transcendent being was certainly sound. 
 I said all this to Alison, and I've been saying it to her ever since, and, back in London, I've been saying it to anyone else who'll listen. 
 On Wednesday I met Mrs Matthews in the street and she asked if I'd taken the cat to the vet and I admitted that I hadn't. 
 &bquo;Pull yourself together, dear,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Don't tell me to pull myself together,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I've had a religious experience.&equo; 
 She looked appalled. 
 &bquo;I don't want to hear about that,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;At my age I've got enough to worry about.&equo; 
 Keith Botsford in America: Know Nothings put a zip on art 
 By KEITH BOTSFORD 
 Robert Mapplethorpe was utterly American: flat-edged, suburban, Catholic and wary. 
 Also homosexual. 
 Also undoubtedly a major figure in the history of photography, in subject matter, style and technique. 
 In the last year of a brief life at the heart of a kind of doting celebrity that knew the value of success, he fell into notoriety of the sort that is just as American as his life. 
 He ran into the Know Nothings. 
 For all his coinciding with the world of fashion, with the glamour and risks of the pederasty he helped publicise, Mapplethorpe's pictures remain alien to the canons of American good taste and to meat-and-potato American ideas about art. 
 As part of a sexual sub-culture which conservative America would rather did not exist &mdash; but fears to attack in the open &mdash; Mapplethorpe was an obvious target for the new Know Nothings. 
 The original Know Nothing party arose in the 1860s (its name refers to the fact that it was a secret party and its members, if interrogated, said they knew nothing about it). 
 It was a &bquo;nativist&equo; party resentful of the alien, and dangerous, ideas immigrants, especially Catholics, could introduce into the American bloodstream. 
 Like the sort of heterodox culture which Mapplethorpe incarnated. 
 The occasion that brought the Know Nothings back to life in June was a 60in x 40in Cibachrome print of a wood and plastic crucifixion aswim in the artist's, Andre Serrano's, urine. 
 Serrano's Piss Christ (which he termed &bquo;a protest against the commercial invasion of sacred images&equo;) brought an outburst which continues to this day. 
 &bquo;We need to clean up our culture,&equo; thundered conservative columnist Patrick Buchanan. 
 &bquo;As a poisoned land will yield up poisonous fruits, so a polluted culture&hellip; can destroy a nation's soul.&equo; 
 That sort of language encouraged the many resentments Americans harbour against high culture (remember the disparagement of Adlai Stevenson as an &bquo;egghead&equo;?) and led to such curiosae as the Chicago attack on an Eric Fischl painting in which a fully clothed boy looks at a naked man swinging a bat. 
 Protesters claimed it promoted child molestation. 
 It also brought up the art quote of the year, from one Ziff Fistrunk (no, I do not make up the name), director of the Southside Chicago Sports Council, who organised the protest: &bquo;I have trained players in Little League and semi-pro baseball, and at no time did I train them naked.&equo; 
 In the end, the Know Nothings, led by Senator Jesse Helms, managed to force Washington's Corcoran Gallery to cancel a 150-picture Mapplethorpe retrospective and started a full-scale attack on the kinds of artistic projects which the National Endowment of the Arts (no radical force) reluctantly and sparingly backed. 
 During debates in the House, the offending Mapplethorpe photographs were not brought on to the floor lest they offend the &bquo;decorum&equo; of the House. 
 Why the commotion? 
 First, there is no tradition in America for public or state funding of the arts. 
 High culture has always been privately funded, either by individuals or by foundations. 
 Not for America the massive state pump-priming of the arts such as exists in the two Germanys or in France and Italy. 
 Second, such support as there is, via the National Endowment for the Arts (currently it is funded at &dollar;130m, which to the federal government is peanuts), is the more visible for being infinitesimal and therefore vulnerable. 
 The debate over 1990 funding for the NEA, and Jesse Helms's attempts to cut off federal funding for art that he and the fundamentalist lobby find obscene, continues. 
 Censorship, the pious say, is not involved, only federal funding of art offensive to the majority. 
 Few Americans take congressional silliness seriously. 
 But what of the larger question? 
 Mapplethorpe's photographs &mdash; whether of flowers or male nudes - are profoundly erotic. 
 Are they pornographic? 
 His celebrated &bquo;secret&equo; works, mainly from his early years, include a series of masochistic self-portraits, subjects in the terrible gear of subjugation and self-disgust, studies of penis and pistil, and move with astonishing art to consideration of the body (usually seen only in part) as a piece of classical relief. 
 One of the most celebrated is the 1980 Man in a Polyester Suit. 
 It shows a man in a suit and waistcoat from lower lapel to mid-thigh, a tuck of shirt emerging from his fly and casually nearby, his large (black) penis in repose. 
 The picture's erotic charge lies in the juxtaposition of the external world and the (normally) concealed, in its urinal's-eye-view. 
 As one critic puts it, the picture is &bquo;forensic&equo;, not pornographic. 
 His work is the exact opposite of Helmut Newton's neo-Victorian titillations. 
 It is not prurient but cruel, hip and disturbingly beautiful, intimate and playfully referential, as in Thomas and Dovana, where a naked black man and a ball-gowned white woman are caught, dancing, in a pose that both mocks and reveres the myths and fears of Gone with the Wind. 
 A culture unzippered. 
 Clearly stuff to trouble a Know Nothing. 
 Obviously alien. 
 The more sophisticated will decry the malaise of the unwashed millions. 
 I feel a certain sympathy for their wallflower purity, none for their legislators' regard for the morals of others, and most for Mapplethorpe's prophylaxis. 
 Loneliness of the long-distance candidate 
 By ANTHONY HOWARD 
 There are two schools of thought about the rules by which politicians ought to campaign. 
 The Kennedys always maintained that the secret of running for any office was a matter of pacing. 
 To succeed, you needed to take great care that you peaked just as the winning-post hove into view. 
 Richard Nixon, even when he was running against John Kennedy in 1960, took an entirely different view. 
 For him, from the moment you entered the race, there could be no respite. 
 The imperatives of competitive politics required that you ran flat-out from the start. 
 To judge by the events of the past week, Michael Heseltine has now enrolled in the Nixon school. 
 It is a long time since any potential national leader in Britain leapt up from the starting-blocks in quite such a dramatic way. 
 For a backbencher, it has been a remarkable performance. 
 To lead in all the polls as the favoured candidate for the Tory succession, to persuade your own party that you offer a distinctive viewpoint without being in any way overtly disloyal, to convince even the cynics of the Press that you pose a realistic alternative to the present leadership &mdash; no phenomenon like it has been seen in British politics for 50 years. 
 The achievement has been bought at a price. 
 To be blunt about it, the challenge confronting Mr Heseltine is how to maintain his momentum. 
 Under a parliamentary system, the &bquo;outsider&equo; will always be at a disadvantage. 
 Policy initiative, set-piece engagements with the Opposition, even a starring role from the conference platform (Heseltine has not delivered a speech there since 1985) remain the prerogative of those within the citadel of government. 
 The only area an exile hopes to cultivate is what the Americans call &bquo;the chicken and peas circuit&equo; &mdash; those endless dinners, lunches and buffet suppers by which the Conservative Party binds its supporters in a form of social cement out in the sticks. 
 By now Heseltine has probably got about as much mileage out of such occasions as he can reasonably expect. 
 He has certainly demonstrated that he is a &bquo;draw&equo;: there must already be some 250 Conservative MPs in his debt for turning out an audience at least double that which they would otherwise have been able to collect. 
 Part of the Heseltine strategy is, no doubt, based on the calculation that these debts one day can be collected &mdash; and certainly, within the Conservative Party's electoral college of MPs, he ought to have established some impressive lines of credit. 
 It is a nave aspirant party leader, though, who pins his faith to gratitude. 
 Politicians tend to act from baser motives, of which the strongest of all is an instinct for their own survival. 
 It is over this that Heseltine bumps up against what is both his opportunity and his problem. 
 If he is to persuade his colleagues that he can win for the party, he will need to seize every available chance for exposure over the next two, three, or even four years. 
 I noticed his saying in a magazine interview that he could never have survived these past few years without the help of Fleet Street &mdash; and that struck me as an unusually candid confession for a politician. 
 But the stakes are bound to get progressively higher. 
 Even to maintain his ratings at their present level &mdash; with 22 per cent in one poll choosing him as their preferred Prime Minister in a field that included Mrs Thatcher &mdash; he has no choice but to be constantly audible and visible. 
 And the easiest way to ensure that &mdash; a readiness to criticise the Government at each and every turn &mdash; is the one temptation he has at all costs to resist. 
 Within the Tory Party, what ultimately matters is not how many friends you have, but rather the power and strength of your enemies. 
 In America they call it &bquo;the antipathy quotient&equo; &mdash; and no ambitious politician can risk allowing it to get too high. 
 In Heseltine's case, it must already be approaching the danger level; he needs to be vigilant that nothing he says or does reinforces it. 
 What he cannot afford to bring into play is the kind of leadership veto that operated all those years ago against both Rab Butler and Iain Macleod. 
 Of course, Tory politics has changed a great deal since those days. 
 One memorable article by Macleod blew away &bquo;the magic circle&equo;; new leaders no longer emerge by &bquo;the customary processes of consultation&equo;. 
 One should not exaggerate the significance of the change. 
 Formal rules are one thing; human instincts quite another. 
 The reason why I continue to believe that Heseltine's best chance of getting the Tory leadership lies in the aftermath of an election defeat has nothing to do with inside knowledge. 
 It is based entirely on personal instinct. 
 To my mind, it is simply not plausible that a party already securely in government would allow &bquo;an outsider&equo; to bound one fine morning into the Cabinet Room and take charge of 21 individuals &mdash; all of whom, unlike him, would know not only what happened there last week but the battles of previous years as well. 
 The British Cabinet system simply does not lend itself to that sort of Novices' Handicap. 
 For that reason alone, I remain totally unpersuaded that the enterprise Michael Heseltine has embarked upon symbolises any effort to displace or dislodge Mrs Thatcher. 
 Even if she were to go voluntarily before the next election, that could only be very bad news for him. 
 At the very least, he would have to reckon on the 21 votes in the Cabinet being stacked up against him. 
 Why, then, should he have risked even giving the impression of having thrown his hat into the ring a full two years and more before the next election is due? 
 One explanation could be that the prospect of defeat now seems to him, if not inevitable, then at least sufficiently likely to be worth a contingency wager. 
 But that is a highly vulnerable position for any politician to take - and I doubt if it offers the whole answer. 
 The clue to that, I suspect, lies in Heseltine's increasing adoption not only of a Churchillian warning stance but of an almost Churchillian speaking style as well. 
 What he will not have overlooked is that Churchill &mdash; for 10 years (between 1929 and 1939), the only comparable &bquo;outsider&equo; within the Tory Party &mdash; did not vault straight into the prime ministership. 
 He got to No 10 because he had 18 months earlier forced Neville Chamberlain to readmit him to the Cabinet. 
 What we witnessed at Blackpool may have been the start of a campaign for the leadership. 
 But it was also something else. 
 Like every shrewd politician, Michael Heseltine has placed a two-way bet. 
 The other half of it lies in mobilising party and public support sufficiently strongly to leave Mrs Thatcher with no choice but to readmit him to the Cabinet if the Tories do return to office after the next election. 
 That way at least, the ultimate prize should remain within reach whatever happens inside the polling booths -always provided, of course, that he has not &bquo;peaked&equo; too soon. 
 Letter: Paradox in Eurotunnel forecasts 
 From Mr STEPHEN PLOWDEN 
 Sir: Eurotunnel's latest revenue forecasts for the first year of the tunnel's operation are virtually unchanged from the forecasts made a year ago, and the long-term forecasts are up. 
 These are paradoxical results in the light of the substantial cost increases. 
 The traffic forecasts are made in two stages. 
 First, the total amount of traffic in each market segment (eg, cross-Channel holiday trips by car) is forecast. 
 Then this total is split between the competing routes and services. 
 Total traffic is related to general economic variables such as GDP and car ownership. 
 Neither the price nor any other characteristic of the transport system enters into it. 
 Thus the model cannot take account either of changes in operators' costs or of developments such as road pricing or a carbon tax which could be in place in the medium or long term. 
 The model used to allocate traffic between competing services is, however, very sensitive to relative prices, so, one would expect increases in Eurotunnel's costs to give rise to a lower market share and hence to lower revenues. 
 The reason this has not happened is that Eurotunnel's fares fed into the model are not based on its costs. 
 Instead it has been assumed that Eurotunnel's fares will always be the same as those of the ferry services. 
 This may have been a reasonable starting assumption for the initial round of forecasts made in 1985, but it is not adequate now. 
 Eurotunnel should produce traffic and revenue forecasts based on the assumption that its fares will have to rise above those of the competition to reflect the increases in its own costs and in the cost of the rail link to London. 
 On safety, Eurotunnel's latest report states: The extended series of studies and tests required to support our proposals for non-segregation of passengers and their vehicles have continued. 
 The Safety Authority is kept fully informed of these proceedings and of their results. 
 All Eurotunnel's traffic and revenue forecasts published so far have assumed that passengers will remain with their vehicles. 
 Eurotunnel should now produce calculations showing what the effect would be if the Safety Authority were to insist on segregation. 
 Letter: Episcopal success 
 From The Very Rev MICHAEL MAYNE 
 Sir: Sir Frederic Bennett's letter (12 October) criticising the Archbishop of Canterbury is too clever by half. 
 To impute that Dr Runcie has been an unsuccessful archbishop by quoting falling numbers in that part of the Anglican Communion which is the Church of England is to ignore a whole complex of reasons for a reduction in church-going, including, no doubt, the encouragement of a highly competitive and success-orientated society. 
 Numbers have dropped consistently for 60 years, and if that is the litmus-test of an archbishop's success, then Archbishops Lang, Temple, Fisher, Ramsey and Coggan have also been failures. 
 Sir Frederic's suggestion -that as (in his terms) an &bquo;unsuccessful&equo; archbishop, Dr Runcie speaks of the &bquo;successful&equo; in his Director interview out of self-pity, bitterness or resentment &mdash; is unworthy. 
 The interview admirably combines the prophetic and the pastoral, and it is charitable throughout. 
 Westminster Abbey being a Royal Peculiar and not falling within the Archbishop's domain, I write as one who like you, Sir, is happily independent. 
 Letter: A mother mourns a victim of terrorism 
 From Mrs BARBARA ZWYNENBURG 
 Sir: I appeal to mothers around the world of all religions and cultures to teach and nurture their children to respect life and not to destroy it wantonly. 
 Today, 14 October, is my son's birthday. 
 He would have been 30. 
 Unhappily, he will not celebrate it this year. 
 He was murdered because of a bomb placed on Pan Am flight 103, just prior to last Christmas. 
 We know that all of us will eventually die from disease, natural disaster, accidents or whatever. 
 These deaths are largely out of our control. 
 But the intentional mass murder of innocent people is not. 
 This is incomprehensible to the vast majority of humanity. 
 I do not understand the motives, beliefs and values of terrorists. 
 I do understand intense misery and sorrow after losing a child to a terrorist's bomb. 
 I feel sure all mothers worldwide will understand my grief. 
 No doubt I will shed many tears today, as I do every day. 
 What purpose is served by such senseless and heinous acts? 
 As we all know, killings beget more killings. 
 Terrorism is totally unacceptable in a civilised world. 
 It is essential that all nations and their institutions co-operate with one other to bring about an end to this madness. 
 At the recent economic summit in Paris, leaders of the world's major industrial nations focused on the need to eradicate terrorism. 
 Government authorities in Scotland, Britain, Germany and the US are all co-operating and conducting independent investigations to identify and bring to justice the terrorists. 
 I personally beg all mothers to insist that their governments work towards this end. 
 Terrorism knows no borders &mdash; it is an international problem and demands international co-operation. 
 This is my way of memorialising my beloved son's life. 
 He gave much happiness to his family and friends during his abbreviated time on this earth. 
 Letter: Noise: the acid test 
 From Professor MARY CARTER 
 Sir: Tony Colston-Hayter of World Wide Productions (letter, October 11), in defending &bquo;dance music warehouse parties&equo; and welcoming the licensing of such parties, suggests that &bquo;so-called &bquo;acid parties&equo; ' are a &bquo;sensationalist fantasy of the gutter press&equo;, and that their massive popularity is &bquo;partly due to the fact that we offer all-night dancing&equo;. 
 He mocks the perception of a &bquo;drug-crazed youth cult&equo; as part of this gutter-press fantasy. 
 The salient fact is that what is uniquely on offer at these parties is not all-night dancing or a few boutique drugs, but fantasy-sensation itself: the orgiastic effect of thousands of people mainlining heavy acid rock at the level of total sound. 
 That sound is the drug. 
 And the problem is that its effect on the neighbours &mdash; within a radius of miles, given the capability of modern sound systems &mdash; is severely damaging. 
 Mr Colston-Hayter warns darkly that if laws are introduced to prevent all-night parties, the &bquo;right to freedom of association&equo; would be compromised, and calls on the Government &bquo;committed to freedom&equo; to reconsider. 
 One of the most basic freedoms anywhere is the right to peace, and the choice of quiet over noise. 
 The licensing of noise erodes that basic right. 
 One solution would be to license the promoters of warehouse parties on condition that they provide adequately soundproofed buildings, parking facilities and stewards for the surrounding areas. 
 Letter: Video surveillance 
 From Sergeant GRAHAM FOOT 
 Sir: Following your article on video &bquo;spy&equo; cameras (11 October), I feel compelled as a police officer to balance the National Council for Civil Liberties's views on the issue of video surveillance. 
 I work in a small shire force with a special responsibility to preserve public order on Friday and Saturday nights. 
 Frankly, I often struggle to control large gangs of hooligans who spill out of the pubs looking for blood. 
 I simply do not have the manpower to make arrests in the teeth of such concerted action. 
 It is also difficult to see more than a small part of the action while defending oneself, and difficult to convey to magistrates the naked aggression displayed. 
 The use of video cameras in police vehicles and at town-centre trouble spots could change all this. 
 I applaud the decision of my local council to install cameras around the centre. 
 There is a danger that it may displace some trouble elsewhere, but on balance it is a great step forward. 
 I see no immediate need for the regulation of such systems which are in themselves merely a means of gathering evidence. 
 It is true that such equipment has a limited intelligence application, but the knowledge that Joe Bloggs uses McDonald's twice a week is indeed of little value. 
 Now, if it were Ronnie Biggs&hellip; 
 The Orwellian nightmare portrayed by the NCCL is already five years late and sounds, itself, what they call an &bquo;extravagant claim&hellip; based on anecdotal evidence&equo;. 
 The fact is that the only reasonable method of securing conviction of individuals among a rioting football mob or crowd of lager louts or gang of shoplifters is to use video. 
 I welcome the public debate the NCCL is trying to stir up because I know I'll get the support of the majority who are frustrated and frightened by deteriorating public order. 
 Isn't it high time the NCCL thought of protecting their rights? 
 Letter: Pedestrian appeal 
 From Mr TONY KAY 
 Sir: If John Prescott thinks that higher taxes on motor vehicles, lower speed limits, charges for urban road use, cuts in tax perks for company cars, random breath testing, enforcement of parking restrictions, revitalised public transport and a general prejudice in favour of pedestrians, cyclists and public transport at the expense of cars will win the Labour Party votes, he's darn right. 
 Letter: Prime of life 
 From MRS DIANA STILES 
 Sir: Another item for your Margaret Regina file which may have escaped the notice of some of your readers. 
 Centenarians, as well as the traditional telegram from the Queen, now receive an additional one from Margaret Thatcher. 
 Food: Strange appetites on the big screen: Can the British digest a film about food, sex and death, asks Deirdre McQuillan 
 By DEIRDRE MCQUILLAN 
 I THINK I can safely say that Peter Greenaway's latest film will do nothing to increase the appreciation of food in this country. 
 Tampopo might have sold a few more bowls of noodles and Babette's Feast caused little hiccups of interest in historic cooking, but The Cook, The Thief, His Wife And Her Lover plays around with the relationship between food, sex and death in a way that is bound to cause offence. 
 &bquo;You must learn to appreciate your food,&equo; instructs the Thief (played by Michael Gambon) as he enters the restaurant in which most of the story takes place. 
 By this he means acquiring a thin veneer of knowledge to mask his corruption. 
 But the film goes on to develop graphic, orifice-stuffing permutations on the theme of you are what you eat. 
 Food symbolises many things in this film, but the recurring image is of a cycle of fleshly decay fuelled by appetite. 
 Greenaway colour codes the rooms of the restaurant, which mirror food's route through the alimentary canal. 
 We move from the cool blue, night street outside, where raw inedible food arrives, to the green cavernous kitchen where the unpalatable is prepared for consumption in the rich red dining room and on again to the clinically white lavatories. 
 The Wife (Helen Mirren) and her Lover (Alan Howard) discover their mutual hunger over the hors d'oeuvres, and proceed to reverse the cycle &mdash; they couple in the lavatory, are formally introduced in the restaurant, fall in love in the pantry and are expelled into the charnel house of a butcher's van &mdash; the price of tasting the fruit of knowledge. 
 As a precis this is pretentious, and The Cook &amp; Co is full of the hyperbole and complicated allusions that identify a Greenaway work &mdash; The Draughtsman's Contract, Drowning By Numbers, for example &mdash; but in the darkness of the cinema the film has a stomach-churning directness. 
 Actual details of food are fleeting: menus flash up, dishes make a brief appearance and the thief wonders why there is salt in the custard (because it is Hollandaise, naturally). 
 I expect restaurateurs will be itching to copy Jean-Paul Gaultier's extraordinary staff uniform with the fork epaulette, but the rest of the details are ingredients for thought only. 
 Asked how he decides on the price of a dish, the Cook (Richard Bohringer) explains that black ingredients are always the most expensive because people like to remind themselves of death. 
 &bquo;They like to say, death I am eating you.&equo; 
 It is a nice conceit, but it will prove unpalatable. 
 In Britain we do not like too much death with our dinner. 
 We do not buy live poultry from the local market and carry it home squawking and then wring its neck, nor do we insist that the fish we order in a restaurant should have been swimming about only moments before. 
 The sight of Peter Rabbit hanging up in an old-fashioned butcher's window brings tears to our eyes, while pretty pink portions prepared and hacked by the supermarket cause no such qualms. 
 Few people enjoy game rich with the taste of decay and cheeses that stink of mortality. 
 The preference is for things so young &mdash; like baby chickens with infant vegetables &mdash; that they have barely had an independent existence we might have to acknowledge robbing them of. 
 The causes, course and consequences of consumption are depicted by Greenaway with excessive physicality. 
 The Cook &amp; Co pursues the idea that no meal is made without sacrifice to an extreme conclusion that is macabre and funny, but there is an element of truth that ought to be more widely recognised in our squeamish society. 
 To sustain life we eat, and the cost of that sustenance is death further down the food chain. 
 Even the vegetarian has to cut the force, that through the green fuse drives the lettuce, in order to be able to live and say that meat is murder. 
 Our inability to celebrate death takes the flavour from our food and leaves us in a state of wilfully maintained childhood with nursery tastes to match. 
 Those who cherish the notion that the act of eating exists outside any context of cost, saving that recorded on the bill, will find The Cook, The Thief, His Wife And Her Lover most indigestible. 
 Recipe: Package deal for trout 
 By LINDA SUE PARK 
 PROMPTED, I would like to think, by my dentist's goading last week, readers have filled the mailbags with filo recipes. 
 Recent visits to Greece and/or Turkey appear to have been inspirational, with feta cheese oozing (figuratively, of course) from several entries. 
 Celia Cviic (no, it's not a typist's error) sends two recipes for burek based on street snacks she has eaten on visits to her husband's family in Yugoslavia; one with a meat filling, one spinach and cheese. 
 Susannah Perry of north London also uses spinach, combined with lamb and pine nuts for her filo rolls, serving them with an egg and lemon sauce. 
 A bottle of 1987 Torres Milmanda, a Chardonnay wine from Penedes, Spain, goes to Judith Abrahams, London NW1, for her winning recipe below. 
 The next challenge is for stuffing or dressing for game birds. 
 The winner gets a bottle of Metusalem Oloroso sherry, reputed to be one of Winston Churchill's favourite tipples, which recently won a trophy in Wine magazine's annual international wine challenge. 
 Please send recipes to Recipes/Weekend Section, The Independent, 40 City Road, London EC1Y 2DB. 
 Turbans of Trout in Filo Serves 2 Ingredients: 2 fillets trout 4 sheets filo 2oz butter, melted Salt and pepper 1tsp sesame seeds 1 onion, finely chopped &frac12; cucumber, diced &frac12; oz currants Dash powdered ginger Preparation: Melt 1oz butter. 
 Layer two sheets of filo, brushing each with melted butter. 
 Fold in two so you have four layers of pastry; brush again with butter. 
 Season one fillet of trout. 
 Roll into a turban; place in the centre of filo layers and set aside. 
 Saute onion and cucumber in the other 1oz of butter; season with salt, pepper and ginger. 
 Using a teaspoon, fill the trout turban. 
 Gather up four corners of filo, twist into a bundle. 
 Brush with more melted butter and sprinkle with sesame seeds. 
 Repeat the entire process for the second fillet of trout. 
 Drink: Street smart to lure finer wine seekers: The off-licence chains are making a big effort to catch the up-market customer, says Anthony Rose 
 By ANTHONY ROSE 
 &bquo;WE WANT to make it look as though it's a wine merchant,&equo; says Tim Waters in Clapham's Wine Rack, south London, one of Thresher's five prototype high-street wine shops. 
 &bquo;Twenty Silk Cut, please love,&equo; a middle-aged woman asks the manager, a little bemused by the new up-market surroundings. 
 &bquo;Even the label will be changed to keep the new concept distinct from Thresher,&equo; continues Tim Waters. 
 &bquo;What's your cheapest Scotch?&equo; inquires the next customer, oblivious to the new range of malt whiskies sitting in the window. 
 &bquo;Based on market research, we're locating the new Wine Racks to target the more affluent, urban areas. 
 &bquo;We want to focus more on wine, less on the traditional off-licence with its wider range of fags and beers,&equo; continues Waters, undeterred. 
 On cue, customer number four walks off dangling a six-pack of Castlemaine XXXX. 
 A fifth customer, a young man with baby in sling, wanders in. 
 Yuppie profile, surely. 
 He buys a can of cider. 
 A sixth selects orange juice and Perrier. 
 As we discuss the changing role of the traditional high-street off-licence, it is all too plain that none of the first six customers have browsed or bought wine or done what the market research says they should be doing. 
 But then a man in a suit heads for the cool cabinet and picks out two bottles of champagne. 
 At last. 
 We're in business. 
 On the morning I met Tim Waters to talk about Thresher's plans for the development of its off-licences, few customers corresponded to the anticipated profile. 
 But this was not entirely unexpected. 
 This particular store in Clapham's Abbeville Road used to be an ordinary branch of Thresher. 
 It metamorphosed to Wine Rack after its conversion to wine merchant lookalike with bottle green colour, smart wooden shelves, wine casks and wicker baskets on the floor for added ambience, and bottles labelled by country of origin with tasting notes attached. 
 &bquo;We see 50, maybe 100 new Wine Racks in a year's time,&equo; says Mr Waters. 
 &bquo;But you can't effect changes overnight,&equo; he adds, from the vantage point of 11 years with Oddbins. 
 The Wine Rack is the jewel in the crown of a 1,000-strong chain of shops which have been reorganised into two groups. 
 There are 550 traditional off-licences carrying the basic Thresher range and 450 &bquo;wine shops&equo; moving away from cigarettes and brands to concentrate on wine. 
 A slow, almost imperceptible evolution is already taking place in the high street. 
 Apart from Unwins and Davisons, both independent, and Oddbins, wine arm of the giant Canadian whisky corporation Seagram, the major high-street chains are concentrated in the hands of big brewers: Whitbread (Thresher), Allied-Lyons (Victoria Wine), Grand Metropolitan/Watneys (Peter Dominic) and Bass (Augustus Barnett). 
 This set-up helps to explain why the high-street off-licences (bar Oddbins), with blinkered attention to their brands, missed the Eighties wine retailing boom. 
 The legacy is all too clear. 
 Staff are underpaid and know next to nothing about wine. 
 Worse still, the product itself is often dull and unchanging. 
 How can a demoralised off-licence manager work up the enthusiasm to sell what an increasingly adventurous customer has no desire to buy? 
 As annual consumption of wine has risen from five to 11 litres per head in the decade between 1977 and 1987, the high-street off-licence has seen a golden opportunity snatched from under its nose by the supermarkets. 
 According to Wine &amp; Spirit magazine, the supermarkets overtook the specialist wine retailers (which include pubs and independent wine merchants) for the first time in 1987, increasing their slice of the table-wine market since 1984 from 47 to 53 per cent. 
 In the same period, off-licence chains owned by the brewers saw their share reduced to less than 25 per cent. 
 The brewers have at last woken up to the fact that their high-street shops have become dinosaurs slouching towards extinction. 
 The Uniform Business Rate, due to be implemented from 1 April 1990, is expected to land high-street shops, especially in London and the South, with a costly increase in overheads. 
 With the advent of the poll tax and higher interest rates, the squeeze on the customer's pocket seems likely to act as a curb on the current trend towards trading-up to more expensive, quality wines. 
 Even wine prices, having enjoyed a period of stability in the Eighties, are beginning to rise as an expanding band of consumers chases after a limited pot of quality wine. 
 &bquo;Obviously we've taken a close look at Oddbins,&equo; says Ann Tonk, standing in Victoria Wine's smartly re-fitted &bquo;Family Group 1&equo; store in London's Hampstead High Street. 
 Recruited from Tesco to oversee the transformation of Victoria Wine for the Nineties, she accepts that &bquo;Oddbins is the one retailer that took the 1980s very much to heart&equo;. 
 Like Tim Waters at Thresher, Ann Tonks has commissioned research and used all the available data to put new meaning into the company. 
 Victoria Wine has divided its 1,005 shops into four &bquo;family groups&equo;: the corporate family, that is. 
 The top two, consisting of 570 outlets targeted towards ABC1s, will carry an expanded range of 225 to 300 wines chosen by the new buying team of Marcia Waters and Mark Brunel-Cohen. 
 All the stores will be re-fitted with softer lighting and ash-coloured wood to &bquo;give them a lighter and warmer feel&equo;. 
 Shelves will look more inviting. 
 Top of the Victoria Wine profile is its Gare du Vin shops of which there are four at present, with plans for 50 by 1991. 
 According to marketing director Chris Bell, &bquo;Gare du Vin will be much closer to the traditional wine merchant with clarets to lay down, vintage ports, a cellar ambience. 
 But we want them to be accessible, not stuffy.&equo; 
 In the jargon of the trade, &bquo;segmentation&equo; is the name of the game. 
 The brittle high-street monoliths are being dismantled and reassembled bit by bit to enable them to become more adept at finding the most efficient way to the punter's pocket. 
 Peter Dominic is converting its Bottoms Up branches into spacious wine superstores with Hunter &amp; Oliver, its attempt at an identikit wine merchant, about to hit the high street. 
 Even Augustus Barnett, moribund since Bass took it over, is making &bquo;forward into the Nineties&equo; noises. 
 It is no coincidence that the Oddbins' name comes up so often. 
 Awarded Wine magazine's Wine Merchant of the Year title for the third year running, Oddbins is generally acknowledged to have bucked the trend. 
 &bquo;Wine is our strong point. 
 It's the product first and we move around it,&equo; says John Ratcliffe, Oddbins' buying manager. 
 &bquo;We take interesting wines and price them at what we think they're worth. 
 We put on tastings for staff as well as customers. 
 The staff care about and enjoy their job. 
 They want to be involved.&equo; 
 A good product, value for money, the right ambience, customer care and staff involvement. 
 There you have it. 
 Or do you? 
 Time will tell whether, in trying to tailor the magic formula to their own requirements, Britain's new-look high-street off-licences will sink or swim into the Nineties. 
 Top Ten on the Shelves: Wine 
 By ANTHONY ROSE 
 The Wine Rack Pinot Blanc d'Alsace 1987, Domaine Zind-Humbrecht, &pound;4.95; subtly fragrant with full-bodied, lightly spicy fruit. 
 Rully la Chaume 1987, J Dury, &pound;7.29; classic Cote Chalonnaise white burgundy with character and buttery texture and flavour. 
 Pouilly-Fume 1988, Domaine les Pres Bessons, &pound;5.99, also at Thresher; typical &bquo;grassy&equo; bouquet with stylish, concentrated, crisp fruitiness. 
 Cabernet Sauvignon Reserve Oriahovitza 1983, &pound;2.89, also at Thresher; good value Bulgarian claret-style with soft, plum and vanilla fruitiness. 
 Ch Haut-Bages-Averous 1986, &pound;10.70, also at Thresher; outstanding second label of Ch Lynch-Bages, oozing class and delicious, youthful ripe Cabernet fruit. 
 Will improve. 
 Victoria Wine Victoria Wine French Dry White, &pound;2.19; consistent, soft but crisp, appley dry white. 
 Victoria Wine Chablis 1987, &pound;6.39; this too has kept its crisp, nutty, lemony character. 
 Riddoch Chardonnay 1987, &pound;5.39 (fine wine selection); oaky, rich, pineappley Chardonnay in classic Australian &bquo;white burgundy&equo; style. 
 Sergioveto Rocca della Macie 1986, &pound;6.39 (Group 1 stores); ripe, voluptuous super-chianti, well worth the extra price. 
 Food and Drink Update: Rome at the top 
 By ANTHONY ROSE 
 THE ARISTOCRACY never fails to fascinate. 
 The Renaissance of Italian Cooking (Pavilion, &pound;20) lets the rest of us play Peeping Tom in the homes and kitchens of 12 of Italy's most blue-blooded families. 
 The photographs are wonderful, as is a dome of tuna mousse on the circular tiled marble floor of a hall in Princess Stefanina Aldobrandini's Rome palazzo. 
 Lots of credits to the downstairs bunch doing the cooking, whose recipes were collected by Lorenza de'Medici. 
 The former food editor of Vogue Italia, she now runs a cookery school. 
 Food and Drink Update: Edifying the soul 
 By ANTHONY ROSE 
 &bquo;MY GRANDADDY&hellip; would gently nudge me off the sidewalk if a white person ever walked close by.&equo; 
 Sheila Ferguson's US publishers wanted to excise the racial and political history that informs Soul Food (Weidenfeld paperbacks, &pound;6.95). 
 But the former lead singer for the soul group The Three Degrees (remember &bquo;When Will I See You Again'?) stood firm in her conviction that the development of black American cookery from plantation scraps to mainstream classics merits more than just lists of ingredients. 
 Her book contains plenty of recipes for pork (slave rations &pound;3 per week) but only two for beef (white folk's food). 
 Ms Ferguson's family, traced back to the illegitimate son of an English planter and a slave girl, is constantly present in the texts, photographs and recipes. 
 Food and Drink Update: Sensible eating 
 By ANTHONY ROSE 
 COPIOUS helpings of greens were available but Nescafe was off the menu on Wednesday at the first Caroline Walker awards ceremony, in memory of the campaigning nutritionist who died aged 38 last year. 
 The guests, who consisted mostly of green types and sensible eaters, were lectured by Jonathon Porritt, director of Friends of the Earth and very important Green Party spokesman, on his concern for the ill effects of Western food on the health of Europeans, and for the devasting results of exporting processed food to developing countries. 
 The actress Jane Asher, author of books on really sticky cakes, asked the audience to boycott Nescafe when she accepted the consumer section award on behalf of the Baby Milk Action Coalition, which has criticised the Swiss giant for selling milk substitutes to third world babes. 
 Our very own Oliver Gillie won a special award in the media category for the paper's health page, which he edited before moving on to become deputy editor of The Independent Magazine, and the overall winner was James Erlichman, The Guardian's consumer affairs correspondent. 
 Where East Germans conquer fear: A hunger strike and crowded services in the Gethsemane Church in East Berlin focus opposition to the rigidities of Communist orthodoxy 
 By ANDREW BROWN 
 IN A LITTER of sleeping bags on the floor of the Gethsemane Church in East Berlin, Irene Schwidurski, who had not taken any solid food for four days, was trying to explain her reasons to a Western journalist, with the help of a pocket dictionary. 
 She was, she explained, absolutely opposed to Gewalt - &bquo;power&equo;. 
 No, he objected, surely she meant &bquo;violence&equo;: she was committed to non-violence. 
 An appeal to the dictionary supplied both meanings. 
 And suddenly the dispute seemed unimportant: in East Germany, might is violence. 
 That is the large reason why she is there, with about 25 other people waiting quietly to one side of the altar in the church which has become the place in the city where freedom most nearly is. 
 The proximate cause is more simple. 
 The hunger strike was started on 4 October by a woman called Angela Kunze, who is, she says, a physiotherapist, part-time circus clown and student of theology: &bquo;With three jobs together, I can work.&equo; 
 That was before the running street-battles of the weekend, when a demonstration around the church was broken up by a police riot which lasted five hours. 
 Irene Schwidurski missed all those, since for many years she has refused to observe the major public holidays of the GDR, 1 May and 7 October, the date the state was founded. 
 In line with this principle, she ignored the Gorbachev visit and went to the cinema to watch a film that had been banned for 20 years, since it deals with the Russian invasion of 1945. 
 When she emerged, Rosa Luxemburg Platz was full of police, with lorries and water-cannon, who cordoned off the broad cobbled street that runs out of the town centre to the church. 
 The underground was still working, and brought her near the church, where she could see the crowd and the candles outside. 
 The young policemen in the cordon were polite, she said, but an older officer told her to get off home in obscene terms. 
 She pushed through the cordon anyway, and stayed in church until 3am, through all the worst of the police violence. 
 It was then that she read Angela Kunze's manifesto, written in blue on a long ribbon of paper above her head where she rests against the wall: &bquo;I am fasting to cleanse myself of fear and hopelessness, hate and violence, impatience and the lust for novelty. 
 &bquo;I am fasting because I see no other way to express my protest against the ways in which our politicians brazenly keep up appearances and celebrate the fortieth anniversary of the state as their victory. 
 &bquo;I am fasting because, unlike our state media, I am worried about the great number of people who have left our country. 
 &bquo;I am fasting to live in solidarity with all who suffer and are persecuted because they have committed themselves to social justice. 
 &bquo;I am fasting in the hope that others will take part, for an hour or for days, and that we will show our personal commitment to this country by limiting our material needs.&equo; 
 This is high-minded and perhaps romantic, but so is the opposition: so are the large things that they want, like freedom and justice. 
 It is worth noting that there are few narrow political aims involved, and that repeated reference is made to &bquo;our country&equo;: East Germany. 
 This is not a movement for reunification. 
 Nor is it exactly a movement for westernisation. 
 There is a strong streak of greenery, both as a policy and as a political style. 
 The side walls of the church are covered in documents. 
 There are blurred photographs of the weekend fighting: since totalitarianism needs power over history, these too are subversive. 
 There are various manifestos: many of the hunger strikers have put up their own, alongside Angela Kunze's. 
 One woman's reasons include the memory of a friend &bquo;murdered while trying to cross the frontier&equo;. 
 All these look, to Western eyes, childish as well as amateurish. 
 The paper is coarse and absorbent; little is even typewritten; the predominant style is Blue Peter make-your-own-revolution: large lettering and primary colours. 
 The most professional is a leaflet expressing solidarity from Poland. 
 Above, on a page torn from an exercise book, is a handwritten question: &bquo;Where was our solidarity with Poland under martial law?&equo; 
 But coming in from the shabby streets outside, which smell of coal and cement dust and Wartburg exhausts, the effect is of life and excitement. 
 One of the New Forum posters shows a well-drawn man addressing a largely faceless crowd, one of whom is holding up a placard that reads &bquo;Keep it short&equo;. 
 The slogan on top is &bquo;Stop the monologue&equo;. 
 Not the least power of a totalitarian state is the power to bore the people out of their right minds. 
 In this sense, the unpredictability of all that happens in the church is a necessary precondition of freedom. 
 The services at six in the evening seem unstructured. 
 They are certainly unpredictable. 
 There was mime and a resolutely modern organ piece one evening, between announcements and prayers. 
 Hardly anyone in the packed congregations of about 1,500 people seemed to know either the hymns or the prayers. 
 Bishop Forck of Berlin-Brandenburg gave an account of his negotiations with the Mayor of Berlin at the beginning of the week. 
 They had spoken for an hour and 45 minutes, and one of the bishop's assistants is setting up a programme of regular meetings between the local party and the opposition. 
 There is still an abyss or several to be crossed, but the bishop was applauded with vast intensity as he told how he had demanded the release of the 150 people reckoned to have been arrested during the street fighting, and had been told that complaints of police brutality would be investigated if the names of the victims were submitted in writing to the authorities. 
 Pastor Hans Simon preached on the unlikely text that the Sabbath was made for man, not man for the Sabbath. 
 Yet as he developed this, the government emerged as the Pharisees, weighing down the people with unjust laws, and the right claimed by Jesus to satisfy his disciples' hunger became the right of East Germans to satisfy their hunger for truth. 
 Again, he was interrupted repeatedly with applause, but this was a crowd which does not cheer. 
 They only clap, with extraordinary vigour. 
 All through the service, and all day and night, people come and go, moving intently along the walls, listening and reading everything. 
 Some stop to talk to the hunger strikers. 
 Irene Schwidurski said: &bquo;They come and tell us their stories of the weekend; or they come because of what they saw of it on (Western) TV. 
 And they come because they want to be rid of their fear: it gives them a completely new feeling of life to overcome their fear and come here.&equo; 
 Outside, the police are no longer present in uniformed strength. 
 There is still a great deal of fear about. 
 This is a city where people move away in a marked manner when you open a notebook, and turn their faces from a camera. 
 Only the plain-clothes thugs of the security police, who can easily be told by their well-fed oafishness, their training shoes and anoraks, go out of their way to move close in and stare down at anyone writing. 
 The church steps are lined with candles, burning all the time, so that now they rise from a layer of wax four inches high. 
 The plain-clothes goons lounge in the lamplight below, and above them, children work patiently through the evenings, tending this rampart of candles against the wind. 
 Pinball barons chance it with Japanese MPs 
 From DAVID POWERS in Tokyo 
 THE LATEST joke in Tokyo is that the leader of the Socialist Party, Takako Doi, slipped on a pachinko ball. 
 She is nursing a chipped elbow and an image that has been dented by allegations of party members taking kickbacks from the barons of pachinko, a form of pinball which is a national passion. 
 Ms Doi is an avowed addict of what might be described as watching hundreds of tiny steel balls clatter through a maze of pins on a vertical board. 
 Pachinko is a &pound;3.8bn-a-year industry which has a Svengali-like hold over a quarter of the adult population. 
 Some admit they like it because the noise of hundreds of machines helps numb the mind after a hard day at work. 
 It numbed the mind of one woman so much recently that she left her baby to suffocate inside her car while hoping to hit the jackpot, a bucketful of balls, which can be exchanged for jars of coffee or pairs of tights. 
 It also has connections with the Yakuza, Japan's equivalent of the Mafia. 
 Most of the country's 15,000 parlours are run by Japan's Korean minority, who have been denied the right to Japanese citizenship. 
 As with all good scandals, it is a complicated story. 
 Chapter One begins with allegations printed in one of the more respectable weekly magazines that do their best to ruin the reputation of everyone in the public eye. 
 It alleged the industry had paid off several Socialist MPs to block legislation in parliament that would have laid pachinko parlours more open to the scrutiny of the tax authorities. 
 With Ms Doi's passion for pachinko and the industry's reputation for large-scale tax evasion &mdash; both public knowledge - who could have asked for more? 
 A federation of recreation industry unions compiled a list of more than 100 MPs from ruling and opposition parties who allegedly received huge sums of money from pachinko barons for the past five years. 
 Chapter Two seemed even better. 
 Newspaper journalists came up with the information that the pachinko barons had been just as liberal with their cash as the Recruit corporation had been with political donations and cheap shares not long before. 
 As in the Recruit scandal, the only party to be left out were the Communists, and the lion's share of the money went to the the ruling Liberal Democrat Party. 
 The Chief Cabinet Secretary, Mayumi Moriyama, ordered all cabinet members yesterday to search campaign fund records for any contributions from an industry notorious for tax evasion and links with organised crime. 
 So far at least two cabinet members have confirmed acceptance of campaign contributions from the pachinko industry. 
 The next chapter saw the Prime Minister, Toshiki Kaifu, being questioned in parliament about the &pound;2,000 he is alleged to have received. 
 It was not for nothing that he was chosen as Mr Squeaky Clean after the sexual and financial aberrations of his two predecessors. 
 The most exciting admissions the opposition could squeeze out of him were &bquo;Yes, I have played pachinko&equo; and &bquo;Yes, in some respects, I like it.&equo; 
 The Liberal Democrats are such past masters at riding out scandals that they are remaining calm, simply instructing all cabinet members to report within a week whether they have received any donations from the pachinko industry. 
 The Socialists, though, are not taking it lying down. 
 They have issued an eight-page statement, which exonerates their members and puts the knife into all other parties. 
 &bquo;It's an anti-Socialist plot,&equo; said the party's secretary-general, Tsuruo Yamaguchi, threatening to take the magazine to court. 
 He admitted the party and individual MPs received a total of nearly &pound;38,000, but insisted it was all legal and there had never been any attempt to favour the pachinko industry in parliament. 
 He went on to allege that the Liberal Democrats had received 15 times as much in donations, but refrained from naming names. 
 That will no doubt be done by the press, clearly bored at not having had a good scandal to get its teeth into for all of two months. 
 A soldier in Tiananmen Square shoos away a teacher and her class from the Monument to the People's Heroes before a ceremony marking the foundation of a Communist youth group 
 From DAVID POWERS in Tokyo 
 A soldier in Tiananmen Square shoos away a teacher and her class from the Monument to the People's Heroes before a ceremony marking the foundation of a Communist youth group  
 Gandhi steps up counter-attack in scandals war 
 From TONY ALLEN-MILLS in New Delhi 
 THE INDIAN government tried yesterday to deflect attention from the Bofors corruption scandal by linking one of the fiercest opposition critics of Rajiv Gandhi, the Prime Minister, with shady financial dealing. 
 This coincided with newspaper reports purporting to detail the financial arrangements by which millions of dollars were siphoned from the Bofors howitzer contract and allegedly paid to senior Indian officials. 
 The revelations, which are seriously embarrassing Mr Gandhi's Congress (I) Party, were accompanied by documents apparently leaked to the Indian press by Swedish sources. 
 They provided more circumstantial evidence that, despite official denials in Stockholm and New Delhi, big bribes were paid to companies controlled by Indian agents. 
 But the reports still fell short of conclusively identifying the ultimate recipients of the money. 
 Faced with the prospect of a stream of disclosures as the general election approaches, Mr Gandhi's advisers have apparently concluded that their best defence is also to attack the opposition with the corruption stick. 
 The leader of the Janata Dal party, VP Singh, has found himself and his family under scrutiny in recent weeks over highly suspect allegations that his son controlled a secret bank-account in the Caribbean island of St Kitts. 
 The allegations that Mr Singh, a former Congress (I) finance minister, had stashed millions of dollars in a numbered St Kitts account, were made in August in the Arab Times of Kuwait, not previously known for its scoops about India. 
 It said the account was controlled by Mr Singh's son Ajeya, a New York-based accountant. 
 To many, the report smacked of an attempted smear by Congress (I) 's dirty-tricks department. 
 Ajeya Singh returned to India and tried to refute the allegations, pointing out numerous flaws in the report, and offered his passport as evidence that he had not been in St Kitts when he was supposed to have signed documents opening the account with the now-defunct bank, the First Trust Corporation. 
 He also said he had never been to St Kitts. 
 Despite this, VP Singh's enemies kept the issue alive with the help of George Maclean, a former managing director of First Trust. 
 Mr Maclean, who had fled St Kitts leaving a pile of debts, surfaced in Canada, claiming that the account had existed. 
 When challenged by Mr Singh, Mr Maclean obliged the Janata Dal leader's enemies by suggesting that Ajeya Singh was a liar. 
 Mr Maclean's reliability as a bank manager can be judged from his admission that he was not very good at mathematics, hence the mistakes in calculating interest on Mr Singh's alleged account. 
 It has been reported from St Kitts that several of Mr Maclean's former co-directors are wanted on drugs charges. 
 Although the affair stinks of a set-up, the government has been able to manipulate the publicity to deflect some of the heat from the Bofors affair. 
 Allegations of Swedish corruption have been countered with suggestions of Caribbean fraud. 
 Ajeya Singh, who voluntarily provided documentation of his personal finances, is under official investigation. 
 At this early stage of the Indian election campaign, the debate is not over who is most suited to run the country, but which politician is the least bent. 
 The Week in Review: Foreign News 
 By FIONA LENEY 
 ONLY three weeks into his term, South Africa's President, FW de Klerk, took what may turn out to be a milestone decision and announced the unconditional release of all but one of the black activists jailed more than 20 years ago in the Rivonia treason trial. 
 Even more extraordinary was the fact that Nelson Mandela, the sixth and most eminent member of the group, appeared to have negotiated the terms of the release of his colleagues, who are expected to be freed this weekend. 
 Although Pretoria said the release of Mr Mandela himself was not on the agenda, that decision appears to be his own. 
 Mr Mandela is thought to want trusted lieutenants, such as Walter Sisulu, to ensure everything is in place before he leaves jail to reassume the reins of the ANC leadership. 
 Mr de Klerk's announcement is being seen as recognition finally that the South African government will have to deal with the black majority through the leadership of the ANC if civil war is not to wipe the republic off the face of Africa. 
 Mr de Klerk's statement was also interpreted as a favour to Margaret Thatcher, who is facing increased pressure for sanctions against South Africa at the Commonwealth summit next week. 
 He failed, however, to get the rapturous reception he may have expected from his chief apologist on the international scene. 
 Rumours that Britain would ask for anti-apartheid sanctions to be relaxed were quashed, although the Prime Minister offered some encouragement by calling the release &bquo;a major step in the right direction&equo;. 
 Hungary appeared to take a step in the right direction when its rulers voted to transmute the old Hungarian Socialist Workers' Party into a new, reformist-led Socialist Party &mdash; and in effect divorced the party from the state. 
 No one was quite sure whether this was a good idea, however, as some of the old party's members refused to recognise the new party, though they hedged their bets by saying they might consider applying for membership. 
 The new party published a list of past mistakes, including the Communist Party's forcible suppression of the opposition in 1948, and a list of proposed remedies, headed by the creation of a multi-party system. 
 But while their leaders considered these lofty goals, the party's bureaucrats had more immediate problems on their hands &mdash; the prospect of unemployment. 
 Now that the party can no longer call on state finances, it will have to streamline its bureaucracy, and has already decided to hand back to the nation all superfluous assets, including the party's holiday homes, hotels&hellip; and its headquarters. 
 The East German leadership at last showed some reaction to the enormous vote of no confidence expressed by its citizens over the past weeks. 
 The Politburo issued a statement regretting for the first time the mass exodus to the West. 
 It even admitted that there were &bquo;problems&equo; &mdash; a slight euphemism, given the tens of thousands of people who had attended mass protests up and down the country &mdash; and hinted that the government might be to blame. 
 Although the move was hailed as sensational at first sight, the vagueness of the language used to promise &bquo;travel opportunities&equo; and &bquo;media that are close to life&equo; failed to convince observers that the leadership had significantly softened its attitude. 
 Few expect change while Erich Honecker remains leader. 
 Meanwhile, China, East Germany's biggest ally, had to step up patrols along its border with Hong Kong after creating, to some extent, its own refugee problem. 
 In a fit of pique, Peking suspended an agreement with Hong Kong to take back Chinese economic refugees who cross into the colony illegally. 
 The dispute was triggered by Hong Kong's decision to allow a top Chinese swimmer, Yang Yang, who had sought political asylum, to travel to the United States. 
 China had demanded that he be returned home. 
 The residents of the Soviet town of Voronezh experienced a rather more exotic kind of refugee. 
 According to Tass, no less, the town was terrorised by visitors from outer space &mdash; small-headed hominoids about 12ft tall who landed their flying saucer in the local park and then went walkabout. 
 Tass quoted eminent local scientists as confirming the incident. 
 Perhaps even the outer galaxy has its own Erich Honecker. 
 History stalks the Kremlin: Khrushchev fell 25 years ago, and the parallels with today are stark. 
 But, Rupert Cornwell in Moscow argues, Mikhail Gorbachev is stronger 
 From RUPERT CORNWELL in Moscow 
 IT WAS one of those days which news editors will remember on their death-beds. 
 A wafer-thin election victory returned the British Labour Party to power after 13 years. 
 China exploded its first nuclear device. 
 And, exactly a quarter of a century ago today, Nikita Khrushchev fell. 
 As glasnost has its way, and Khrushchev's &bquo;rehabilitation&equo; proceeds apace, the occasion has not gone unnoticed. 
 And there is plenty of food for thought. 
 For one thing, the memoirs of several surviving actors in the drama have appeared with compelling new details of the intrigue. 
 Far more pertinently, the parallels with what is happening now scream at anyone with the slightest sense of history. 
 Khrushchev's was the first and only involuntary departure of an established Kremlin leader. 
 But the problems and discontent of today far outstrip the grumblings heard in 1964. 
 Could history repeat itself? 
 The superficial similarities might make a lesser man than Mikhail Gorbachev tremble. 
 Take, for example, an article this week in the Ogonyok magazine by Alexei Adzhubey. 
 A former editor of Izvestia, who was at the Central Committee plenum of 1964 which &bquo;accepted&equo; the resignation of his father-in-law on the grounds of age and health, Mr Adzhubey is perfectly placed to recall the &bquo;stifling atmosphere&equo; in the Politburo court at the time. 
 Then as now, he says, basic goods suddenly disappeared from the shops. 
 This &bquo;artificial deficit&equo; vanished almost as soon as Khrushchev had departed. 
 He writes that while the state plan of the day was &bquo;coming apart at the seams&equo;, Khrushchev was toying with radical reform that would reshape the Stalinist economy, and pondering sweeping changes in the constitution of 1936. 
 Shades indeed of Mr Gorbachev today. 
 It was all too much for Khrushchev's colleagues &mdash; notably Leonid Brezhnev, unequivocally identified as organizer of the coup, and Mikhail Suslov, in charge of ideology in those years, but also Yuri Andropov, a Central Committee secretary in 1964 who 18 years later would succeed Brezhnev as the Soviet leader. 
 Gennady Voronov, another Politburo member of 1964, says that the plot was in progress for a year, although he was not in the know. 
 But a few days before Khrushchev was summoned back to Moscow from the Black Sea for his political execution, Mr Voronov received an unexpected invitation to go hunting with Brezhnev. 
 &bquo;Andropov was there too, and on the drive back to Moscow we talked about what was going to happen. 
 Andropov produced a list of names with crosses against them, and I understood I was practically the last Presidium member who had not been &bquo;sworn in&equo;. 
 Andropov added that if Khrushchev resisted, he would produce documents showing the latter's signature on the warrants of many arrested during the 1935-37 purges.&equo; 
 In the event, the appointed victim went tearfully, but quietly. 
 Two months ago Pyotr Shelest, the former Ukrainian party leader who was also in the Presidium, gave Moscow News a moving, if possibly self-serving account of the moments after Khrushchev had been informed of his fate. 
 &bquo;It was the worst ordeal of my life. 
 Nikita Sergeyevich asked to be allowed to say a few words to the Central Committee plenum that would be held immediately afterwards. 
 Brezhnev and Suslov said no. 
 Nikita Sergeyevich started to cry, tears rolled down his cheeks. 
 &bquo;If it is so, then I get what I deserve&hellip; 
 Write a resignation application for me, and I'll sign it.&equo; 
 ... it was hard to look at him. 
 Even now I see Khrushchev's face in tears. 
 I'll remember it at my death hour.&equo; 
 So could something similar happen now? 
 The short answer, almost certainly, is no. 
 For one thing, the Politburo reshuffle last month has strengthened him. 
 The instigators of a palace coup would have to take into account Mr Gorbachev's other role as the elected president of the Supreme Soviet, a parliament becoming more influential by the week. 
 The risk would be, at least, constitutional conflict: at worst the &bquo;civil war&equo; to which Mr Gorbachev himself has referred, however dismissively, in recent months. 
 Ordinary citizens, moreover, now dare speak out, while the party's standing is the lowest in 70 years. 
 Any plotters would have to mount little short of a full-scale coup, involving probably the army and certainly the KGB. 
 Finally, at 58 Mr Gorbachev is still at the height of his powers. 
 Read Mr Adzhubey and you sense a Khrushchev who, at 70, knew that his end was near. 
 Mr Gorbachev, you feel, is only starting. 
 Touch of glasnost as East Germany frees protesters 
 From PATRICIA CLOUGH in Bonn 
 EAST GERMANY'S leaders yesterday released most of the demonstrators arrested last Saturday, and let a whiff of glasnost into the state-controlled press as part of their new conciliatory approach. 
 In Bonn meanwhile, the government announced that East Germany had agreed to let 600 of its refugees in Bonn's embassy in Warsaw go to the West. 
 East Germany had agreed to give them papers allowing them to go to the country of their choice, and they were expected to leave Poland &bquo;in the very near future&equo;. 
 People could hardly believe their eyes when they opened their newspapers yesterday morning: alongside the ritual party propaganda there was genuine criticism and complaints. 
 The Communist youth paper, Junge Welt, printed a complaint by show-business personalities that colleagues had been arrested, harassed or forbidden to appear for defying orders not to read out an appeal for reforms during their performances. 
 A writer in the Berliner Zeitung said the authorities' failure to respond to complaints had created a feeling of insecurity. 
 Even the official television news broadcast comments by a building worker that people need &bquo;a little&equo; more freedom and the shops should have &bquo;a little&equo; more in them. 
 This sudden glasnost, unthinkable a week ago, was evidently the result of the Politburo statement on Wednesday calling for discussion of the country's problems and for media that were &bquo;close to life&equo;. 
 However, party guidelines circulating in East Berlin forbade any attacks on the socialist state or the leading role of the Communist Party. 
 They also made it clear that the party fears that New Forum and other opposition groups could turn into mass movements. 
 New Forum tried to take the Politburo up on its offer to talk, and again demanded legal status so that it would not constantly be accused of subversion. 
 Erich Honecker, the party leader, spoke about the country's problems for the first time in an address to party leaders, but simply echoed the Politburo statement. 
 He flatly rejected talks with the opposition, saying: &bquo;We don't need suggestions for the improvement of socialism that are really intended to cause its demise.&equo; 
 It is not known how many of the people arrested in last Saturday's protests on the night of East Germany's 40th anniversary have been freed. 
 About 150 are estimated to be still in jail. 
 The announcement yesterday said 11 people, mostly with criminal records, were being held on charges of arson, looting and violence. 
 Wolfgang Vogel, the lawyer who negotiated deals for East Germans who took refuge in West German missions in the East bloc, had earlier appealed to the government to free the demonstrators and hundreds of people jailed for trying to escape through Poland, Czechoslovakia and Hungary. 
 It was indefensible to keep the latter in jail while thousands of others who had succeeded in escaping had been allowed out to the West, he said. 
 PRAGUE &mdash; Czechoslovakia has deported 400 East Germans who entered the country illegally over the past week to try to reach the West, Reuter reports. 
 The official Svobodnoe Slovo newspaper said 50 more East Germans were taking refuge in the West German embassy in Prague. 
 &bquo;Their departure will be subject to bilateral negotiations between the GDR and West Germany,&equo; it said. 
 Left and right warn of Polish &bquo;tragedy&equo; 
 From EDWARD STEEN in Vienna 
 ALFRED MIODOWICZ, the ex-Politburo member and Communist OPZZ trade union leader, yesterday stood in the rain with 150 protesters outside the Sejm (parliament) in Warsaw. 
 His complaints against the economic policies of the new Solidarity-led government are much the same as those of Lech Walesa, the Solidarity union leader. 
 He talked of &bquo;a tragic situation&equo;; Mr Walesa more outspokenly of mounting popular anger and the danger of civil war. 
 At issue yesterday &mdash; the Sejm deputies prudently decided to adjourn their debate until Monday &mdash; as the first spoonful of the bitter economic medicine announced this week to restore a market economy &bquo;in the swiftest possible way&equo;. 
 In an attack on inflation heading for 1,000 per cent by year-end, he government proposes to limit automatic wage indexation. 
 The formula involves 100 per cent indexation (falling to 80 per cent) minus increases already awarded. 
 This means trying to claw back the pay rises extracted by workers since deregulation of food prices on 1 August: butter has since then gone up 1,000 per cent, meat by 700 per cent. 
 &bquo;If we were to go for full indexation,&equo; said Jacek Kuron, the Labour Minister, &bquo;there would be a mountain of money on the market leading to enormous price increases, with all the dangers that implies, especially for the poor.&equo; 
 Wage increases, he said, had often exceeded price increases. 
 Standing up for pensioners has rarely been popular except among pensioners. 
 The OPZZ presented a petition to the Sejm demanding equal indexation for all. 
 It was backed by a group of mothers whom OPZZ leaders described as tearful. 
 The small Democratic Party, Solidarity's coalition, has already said it will not vote for the indexation plan. 
 What is peculiarly difficult for Solidarity is that, as a trade union its power base is identical with that of the OPZZ, namely the museums of Socialist gigantism, from the Nowa Huta steelworks to the shipyards on the Baltic. 
 According to finance minister Leszek Balcerowicz, architect of the new economic plan, between 10 and 20 per cent of the 7m-strong Polish workforce stand to lose their jobs through cutting inefficient industries as well as reducing the army and police. 
 Outspoken Czech feels the pressure 
 By EDWARD LUCAS 
 PRAGUE &mdash; An influential Czechoslovak economist, whose criticisms of the country's stagnation have achieved cult status, returned from the Soviet Union to find his department dissolved and himself under threat of dismissal, writes Edward Lucas. 
 Milos Zeman, in an article in the popular monthly Technicky Magazin, directly attacked the country's hardline Communist rulers for their refusal to accept change, saying that their leadership had turned Czechoslovakia into a backward country. 
 He amplified his views in a broadcast on state television. 
 Because his article appeared in an official magazine, it could be legally photocopied and circulated, and this, with foreign radio broadcasts, has made his critique even more widely known. 
 Mr Zeman, a former member of the Communist Party, said yesterday that he regarded the current leadership as &bquo;anti-socialist, counter-revolutionary, and right-wing&equo;. 
 Mr Zeman expects to become unemployed soon as a result of the sudden, unexplained decision to close his forecasting department in the economics institute where he works, but he denies that he is a martyr in the reformist cause. 
 &bquo;The benefit is higher than the cost,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;My paper is known by practically all the adult population in Czechoslovakia.&equo; 
 Mr Zeman was sharply attacked in the official news media in the days following the publication of his views, which he followed up with an article in the most important samizdat newspaper, Lidove Noviny. 
 In another move to silence criticism, police on Thursday detained the paper's editor, Rudolf Zeman. 
 Grey Wolf shoots transsexual star 
 From TIM KELSEY in Ankara 
 (First Edition) FOR YEARS, Bulent Ersoy has been a source of confusion to music-loving Turkish Muslims. 
 They adore her as the queen of their traditional music, and then revile her, with equal enthusiasm, as a moral obscenity. 
 The singer, herself, has made a fortune out of the insatiable popular curiosity to watch her perform: leggy, tall and unfailingly feminine, with the controversial husk in her voice. 
 Until 6 six years ago she was a man. 
 Since then, after a series of well-publicised operations, to the consternation of her fans among the fundamentalists, she has been a woman - Turkey's first and most famous transsexual. 
 Several times in the past, there have been attempts to murder her. 
 Jagged bottles, hurled at her, in the dusk of an Istanbul night club, injured but did not kill her. 
 Early yesterday morning, a 27-year-old Muslim radical tried again. 
 She had just started her act in the southern city of Adana when Haci Tepe, a member of the &bquo;Grey Wolves&equo;, an extremist right-wing paramilitary group, demanded she sing an old nationalist song. 
 She refused, and so he shot her. 
 Doctors say she may survive: &bquo;We were very surprised at the strength of her body, after all the&hellip; well you know what I mean,&equo; said one. 
 The gunman, now in police custody, is repentant. 
 He maintains he did not want to shoot her, but that he was angry with her and was also agitated by a huge bar bill, and as well as by being put in a particularly smokey corner of the night club. 
 &bquo;She can't die,&equo; said the nightclub owner miserably. 
 &bquo;She stands for so much. 
 You see, she is so Turkish.&equo; 
 Antarctic leak 
 Foreign News Page 12 
 Extreme penalty 
 From TIM KELSEY in Ankara 
 NICOSIA (Reuter) &mdash; Three men were beheaded and then crucified in public in the Saudi capital, Riyadh. 
 Warning that a similar fate would befall other convicted killers, the interior ministry said the three, two brothers and a relative, had killed three people and wounded a policeman. 
 Pinochet's police 
 From TIM KELSEY in Ankara 
 COYHAIQUE, Chile (AFP) &mdash; President Pinochet said he has decided to abolish the secret police which he established 16 years ago, shortly after coming to power. 
 The organisation has frequently been accused of torturing and killing opponents of the regime. 
 Data glasnost 
 From TIM KELSEY in Ankara 
 MOSCOW &mdash; Huge amounts of computerised information held in Soviet data bases are to be made available for the first time to Western research, it was agreed at a conference for Western and Eastern scientists here, writes Justin Arundale. 
 Student attack 
 From TIM KELSEY in Ankara 
 SEOUL (AP) &mdash; South Korean students swinging iron bars and hurling home-made bombs broke into the residence of the US ambassador, Donald Gregg, to protest at US pressure on Seoul to open up its agricultural markets. 
 The students were captured by police after half-an-hour. 
 Mr Gregg was not injured in the attack. 
 PM resigns 
 From TIM KELSEY in Ankara 
 OSLO (Reuter) &mdash; The Norwegian Prime Minister, Gro Harlem Brundtland, resigned as head of a minority Labour government. 
 The head of a centre- right coalition, Jan Syse, will become prime minister on Monday. 
 Warsaw bound 
 From TIM KELSEY in Ankara 
 BONN (Reuter) &mdash; The West German Chancellor, Helmut Kohl, will visit Poland next month, the first Western leader to meet the Solidarity Prime Minister, Tadeusz Mazowiecki. 
 Mr Kohl is expected to offer Poland a credit package worth at least &pound;645m. 
 Drug war support 
 From TIM KELSEY in Ankara 
 BOGOTA (Reuter) &mdash; Francois Mitterrand, winding up a four-day Latin American tour, expressed Europe's support for Colombia's fight against cocaine barons. 
 &bquo;It seemed to me necessary to bring the testimony of our solidarity for the courage and determination of Colombia to fight a danger that extends beyond the borders of this country,&equo; Mr Mitterrand told President Virgilio Barco. 
 Gaddafi to visit Egypt 
 From TIM KELSEY in Ankara 
 CAIRO (Reuter) &mdash; Libya's leader, Muammar Gaddafi, will visit Egypt tomorrow for the first time in 16 years and hold talks with President Hosni Mubarak, Egyptian presidential sources said. 
 Relations between Egypt and Libya have been erratic since Colonel Gaddafi seized power 20 years ago, and he has not been to Egypt since the 1973 Arab-Israeli war. 
 Libya and Egypt fought a brief border war in 1977. 
 &bquo;Wolf&equo; shoots transsexual 
 By TIM KELSEY 
 ISTANBUL &mdash; Turkey's first, and most famous, transsexual has narrowly escaped the latest attempt to kill her, writes Tim Kelsey. 
 For years, Bulent Ersoy, a night-club singer, has been a source of confusion to Turkish Muslims. 
 They adore her as the queen of their traditional music, and then revile her, with equal enthusiasm, as a moral obscenity. 
 Early yesterday morning in a nightclub in Adana, a member of an extremist right-wing paramilitary group, the &bquo;Grey Wolves&equo;, demanded she sing an old nationalist song. 
 She refused, and so he shot her. 
 Doctors, expressing surprise at her robust physical condition, believe she will survive. 
 China fury at British base move 
 By KEVIN HAMLIN 
 HONG KONG &mdash; China reacted angrily yesterday to Hong Kong's decision to move a centrally-located British naval base to an outlying island, a switch apparently designed to undercut any plans China had for a high-profile military presence after 1997, writes Kevin Hamlin. 
 Although China wanted the naval base retained, Chief Secretary Sir David Ford announced that by 1992 it would be moved from its central site to make way for land reclamation. 
 Peking's top official in Hong Kong, Xu Jiatun, said the decision was &bquo;not worthy of consideration&equo;. 
 Dona Carmen joins battle for Socialism 
 From TIM MCGIRK in Cadiz 
 IN CADIZ, a province of fighting bulls, sherry vineyards and cork forests, a strange electoral clash is shaping up, between a man with the biggest mouth in Spanish politics and the Prime Minister's wife. 
 The mouth belongs to Pedro Pacheco, the brash mayor of Jerez and a leader of the regional Andalucian Party, which is challenging the ruling Socialists on their own territory. 
 His foe is Carmen Romero, wife of the Socialist Prime Minister, Felipe Gonzalez, and perceived by most Spaniards as far more forthright and honest than her husband. 
 The Socialists are so rattled by the prospect of losing at least three of the seven Cadiz parliamentary seats to Mr Pacheco that they coaxed Dona Carmen into leaving the Moncloa palace and joining the fray. 
 Mr Pacheco's speciality is the crude insult. 
 He has attacked the Spanish justice system as &bquo;a crude farce&equo; and has insulted the pampered pop-star son of one of the wealthy sherry families, which was accustomed to destroying any politician it pleased in Jerez. 
 Lately, Mr Pacheco has gone further. 
 He suggested the acid-tongued Deputy Premier, Alfonso Guerra, does humiliating and unprintable things with other men. 
 Half a century ago Mr Guerra, a fellow Andalucian, would have fought a duel over this remark, but he is happy, come the 29 October elections, to crush Mr Pacheco's party into the ash-white earth of Jerez. 
 Apart from the insults, and setting up a Formula I race-circuit in Jerez, Mr Pacheco's record of social change is unremarkable. 
 But many of the Andalucian farm workers who voted for the Socialists in 1982 and 1986 are turning to Mr Pacheco's party to voice their discontent. 
 Unemployment has risen in Cadiz province above 30 per cent, nearly twice the national average. 
 Worse still, the Socialists, who campaigned to end amigismo &mdash; in which the local mayor and his cronies hand out jobs and contracts to friends and families &mdash; have embraced this custom with gusto. 
 In Alcala de los Gazules, a white village in the cork forests of Cadiz, Manolo Jimenez, an unemployed mason, said: &bquo;You need a Socialist Party card to get work. 
 It also helps if you play good football. 
 Our mayor is crazy about football. 
 We don't have any factories or co-ops here in Alcala, but we've got a marvellous football field. 
 It cost millions. 
 &bquo;The mayor also gives jobs to people from other villages if they're good football players. 
 I'm no good at football, and I haven't had a steady job since last March,&equo; he said glumly. 
 He belongs to the General Workers' Union (UGT), which has quarrelled with the Socialist Party. 
 Mrs Gonzalez, wearing proletarian earrings made of screws and miniature spanners, arrived in Alcala de los Gazules on Tuesday afternoon, the second stop on the campaign. 
 Her speeches were so dull and rambling that her nervous advisers tried to stop newsmen from recording them. 
 According to one columnist, Carmen Rigalt, her inexperience does not matter: &bquo;Carmen is the smile of the regime.&equo; 
 Not only is she pretty; she has a reputation for being more of a Socialist than her husband and far more level-headed than he about the trappings of prime ministerial power. 
 Spaniards respect her for keeping her schoolteacher's job for as long as possible. 
 She refuses to be ornamental and will not go with her husband on state trips that do not interest her. 
 She was also instrumental in nudging him into giving 25 per cent of the positions in the Socialist Party to women. 
 Mrs Gonzalez has also tried to mend the fratricidal split between her husband and Nicolas Redondo, leader of the UGT union, of which she is still a member. 
 Women admire her. 
 At Alcala's adult education centre, one toothless old woman in slippers sang her a flamenco lament about a lovely but strong-headed girl from the next village who was stabbed seven times by her jealous husband. 
 Did she have Mr Gonzalez in mind? 
 Lebanese cling to remains of accord 
 From JONATHAN WRIGHT of Reuters 
 TAIF, Saudi Arabia &mdash; Lebanese members of parliament clutched at the threads of a peace plan yesterday after a brief period when agreement to end 14 years of civil war seemed within their grasp. 
 But conflicting demands by Muslim and Christian deputies confounded an apparent breakthrough the previous day. 
 Sixty-two MPs, equally divided between Christians and Muslims, have been in this Saudi resort for the past two weeks examining a &bquo;National Reconciliation Charter&equo; drafted by Arab League mediators as the basis for a permanent peace. 
 It answers Muslim demands for more political power and offers the Christians promises that Syrian troops will pull out of western Lebanon within two years of the reforms taking place. 
 But although the deputies said they clinched an agreement on the charter on Thursday morning it began to collapse when Lebanese leaders, including the Christian army commander, Michel Aoun, and the Druze leader, Walid Jumblatt, criticised it. 
 More than 820 people have died in and around Beirut in battles between General Aoun's forces and Syrian and Syrian-backed Muslim militias since mid-March, after the general's declaration of a &bquo;war of liberation&equo; against the occupying Syrians. 
 An Arab League-sponsored ceasefire has been in force since 23 September. 
 Muslim deputies here said they were optimistic that a working group of senior deputies could agree on the reforms, which give the Muslims equal representation in parliament and transfer executive powers from the Christian president to a cabinet led by a Sunni Muslim prime minister. 
 Britain will seek something new at Commonwealth summit 
 By JOHN BULLOCH, Diplomatic Editor 
 THE HEADING is innocuous enough: Executive Session 3, Reports of Special Committees, presented by Joe Clarke, the Foreign Minister of Canada, with Kenneth Kaunda, President of Zambia in the chair and Bob Hawke, Prime Minister of Australia, to speak. 
 So reads the order of business for the Commonwealth Heads of Government at their meeting in Kuala Lumpur next Thursday. 
 But despite its bland style, it hides a time bomb for Britain, for the reports are on southern Africa. 
 British officials say they believe this conference will not be obsessed with South Africa, as previous meetings have been. 
 The election of FW de Klerk as president is a sign of progress, they say, and the imminent release of Walter Sisulu and the apparent movement towards negotiations are signs of a new atmosphere. 
 Britain wants to encourage movement, not to stifle it, and any talk of sanctions would be bound to have a bad effect. 
 Yet even the British acknowledge that there are individuals and countries &bquo;wedded to sanctions&equo;, and according to Commonwealth officials, Britain may well again find itself in a minority of one when the subject is debated. 
 Many Commonwealth leaders believe the movement in South Africa is the result of pressure already applied, and that only by turning the screw can the world be sure that there will be no turning back. 
 African leaders who recognise that it may be difficult to impose any further sanctions believe they have found the way forward. 
 They want to see financial pressure applied, to ensure South Africa cannot roll over its debt or raise new capital. 
 Britain argues this would result in an impoverished country, prey to all the economic ills which have beset other African states. 
 Whatever the discussion's outcome Margaret Thatcher will not yield, so that the Commonwealth may again be forced to take decisions from which Britain will dissent. 
 Attending her seventh meeting of this odd club, the British Prime Minister is unlikely to shrink from going it alone. 
 Britain is looking for something new from this conference. 
 The environment, the battle against drugs, and measures to combat terrorism will be high on the agenda if the British have their way. 
 Yet even here there are minefields, for the report of a group of Commonwealth experts is likely to be the basis for the discussion on the environment, and its main recommendation is that the developed countries should foot the bill for the under-developed to adopt environment-friendly means of production. 
 Freedom flight for Mandela's comrades 
 From JOHN CARLIN in Soweto 
 SIX OF the long-term political prisoners whose release the government announced this week, including Walter Sisulu, the former ANC secretary, were flown up from Cape Town to Johannesburg under guard yesterday morning and transferred to Diepkloof prison in Soweto, according to the South African Press Association. 
 They were expected finally to be freed either late last night or, more likely, this weekend. 
 Amid much rumour and mystery, the consequence of a complete news black-out by the authorities on the circumstances of the pending releases, it was not possible to obtain independent confirmation of the report. 
 The authorities showed less reticence in dealing with a group of black youths who gathered outside the Sisulu home in Soweto yesterday evening to sing and dance in celebration of the ANC leader's imminent freedom. 
 Two lorries crammed with riot policemen arrived and fired tear-gas canisters, rapidly dispersing the small crowd, which included news photographers. 
 A seven-year-old child was reportedly hit by one of the canisters and taken, injured in the leg, to hospital. 
 The incident appeared likely to diminish the chances of the prisoners being freed last night. 
 Piling on the confusion, Ramish Vassen, a Cape Town lawyer representing three of the prisoners, said he went yesterday to Pollsmoor prison, where they have been kept in recent years, to deliver a suit for one of his clients, Elias Motosaledi. 
 He did not see any of the prisoners but was led to believe they were still inside. 
 One of the prison warders, he said, had asked him if he knew when the men were to be released. 
 Reporters spent the day scurrying around in far from dignified fashion but not even the foreign television networks, with the vast logistical operations they run, were able to establish any sightings or obtain any hard information. 
 Why the authorities were being so apparently perverse, it was possible only to speculate. 
 One line of thought was that the government wished to dampen as far as possible the spirits of anti-apartheid demonstrators who are planning marches all over the country today in celebration of the releases, which have been proclaimed &bquo;a great victory for the people&equo;. 
 One happy participant in the march planned in Johannesburg will be Mr Sisulu's wife, Albertina, who, in the one thankfully concrete news development of the day, had her restriction orders lifted by the police yesterday morning. 
 She had been restricted on account of her political activities as co-president of the United Democratic Front (UDF) from leaving her house at night, from taking part in public meetings and from making public statements of any kind. 
 &bquo;This is wonderful,&equo; Mrs Sisulu said. 
 &bquo;The whole time since I heard that Walter would be released unconditionally I have been wondering how things will work with him being allowed out at night and to talk to whoever he wishes and me sitting at home in the evenings, gagged.&equo; 
 Mrs Sisulu had a short meeting at her home yesterday with Winnie Mandela, who said afterwards that her husband, Nelson Mandela, would not be freed this year. 
 He would &bquo;refuse to be released into a South Africa where the ANC is banned&equo;, she said. 
 He would also not leave jail into the state of emergency. 
 ANC man warns of false optimism 
 By RICHARD DOWDEN, Africa Editor 
 THE African National Congress has warned against false optimism over South Africa created by the new presidency of FW de Klerk and his decision to release key political prisoners. 
 Thabo Mbeki, the ANC foreign affairs spokesman, said in London yesterday: &bquo;FW de Klerk has decided to shift the defensive line on which PW Botha stood. 
 He is shifting the defensive line without changing the central objective.&equo; 
 Mr Mbeki said the importance of recent victories should be recognised, but Mr de Klerk had no choice but to make concessions. 
 &bquo;FW de Klerk and the National Party went to the electorate on an apartheid platform which was very clearly and consistently stated&hellip; 
 &bquo;He said Mr de Klerk wanted to produce a race federation and co-opt the ANC and Nelson Mandela to legitimise it. 
 Reiterating the ANC's willingness to negotiate with the South African government, he said the time was not right for the ANC to abandon violence: &bquo;The struggle inside South Africa and outside South Africa must continue.&equo; 
 Mr Mbeki was speaking at a meeting of the South Africa Coalition, a broad grouping of British organisations trying to change British policy over South Africa. 
 &bquo;In this country you are faced with a stubborn and self-assured lady who sees it as one of her tasks to protect the regime,&equo; Mr Mbeki said. 
 Abortion is Bush's unwinnable war 
 From PETER PRINGLE in Washington 
 PRESIDENT George Bush as much as admitted yesterday that he is in a political bind over the abortion issue. 
 As a pro-abortion mood sweeps the country, he may have to modify his stance. 
 Gains made this week by abortion-rights groups in the Florida legislature, in governors' races in New Jersey and Virginia, and in the House of Representatives have weighted the balance markedly toward the pro-abortion forces. 
 The House passed a bill on Wednesday that would provide abortion funds for poor women who become pregnant as a result of rape or incest, funding which Mr Bush is against. 
 But the measure seems likely to pass Congress. 
 If Mr Bush vetoes the measure, he risks losing abortion-rights voters who supported him for other reasons, and if he changes his firm anti-abortion stance he runs the potentially greater risk of losing his hard-core right-wing support. 
 At a press conference yesterday, he was asked whether he is willing to negotiate or accept a compromise on the House measure. 
 He admitted he wanted to see if there was &bquo;room for flexible&hellip; language (in the bill) which may be able to avoid a veto on my part&equo;. 
 The Democratic leadership in Congress has pushed him hard on the issue. 
 The House Speaker, Tom Foley, and the Senate majority leader, George Mitchell, have urged him to reconsider his stance &mdash; even though they concede they do not have the votes to override a veto. 
 In a joint statement they said Mr Bush &bquo;holds it in his power to deny the right of choice to the poorest, most vulnerable American women&equo;. 
 Free rein for FBI &bquo;snatch&equo; squads 
 From MARC CHAMPION in Washington 
 THE Justice Department admitted yesterday that it had granted the FBI authority to &bquo;override&equo; international law in order to seize fugitives from US justice living abroad without first obtaining the consent of the country where they were sheltering. 
 Responding to a report in the Los Angeles Times yesterday, Justice Department officials confirmed that the policy had been in place since 21 June. 
 It could have important implications for American efforts to arrest drug dealers, terrorists and the Panamanian leader, Manuel Noriega, for prosecution in the US. 
 Within the administration the new line is reportedly known as &bquo;the President's snatch policy&equo;. 
 A legal opinion requested by the Attorney-General, Richard Thornburgh, effected the change in June, but it had been kept secret since then. 
 According to the Los Angeles Times, the opinion is entitled: &bquo;Authority of the FBI to override customary or other international law in the course of extra-territorial law-enforcement activities.&equo; 
 Justice Department officials declined to discuss the precise content of the opinion or the rationale behind it. 
 A former Justice Department prosecutor, Lawrence Barcella, said that the policy risked offending otherwise friendly countries, which might even bring kidnapping charges against the FBI. 
 The &bquo;snatch policy&equo; overturns a Carter administration edict, to which it is diametrically opposed. 
 When the FBI then proposed to kidnap a fugitive US financier, Robert Vesco, from the Bahamas, the Justice Department produced a legal opinion blocking the plan. 
 The opinion stated: &bquo;US agents have no law-enforcement authority in another nation unless it is the product of that nation's consent&hellip; in the current international climate, this country can ill afford an operation that would permit others to argue that the United States does not respect international law.&equo; 
 Since 1984 the Justice Department has had authority to prosecute terrorists who attack Americans abroad, but the FBI has had to request permission from the host countries to return them to the US. 
 Only one terrorist, Fawaz Yunis, has been arrested under the 1984 law and the FBI lured him into international waters to make the arrest. 
 There was speculation yesterday that the new policy was tailored for the Noriega case. 
 The ruling would appear to permit the FBI to go into Panama and kidnap General Noriega, but when reporters asked President Bush yesterday morning if that was the case, he said: &bquo;I'm embarrassed to say I don't know what (the answer) is.&equo; 
 UK urges Savimbi to keep the peace 
 By JOHN BULLOCH 
 JONAS SAVIMBI, the Unita leader, was pressed yesterday to abide by &bquo;the letter and spirit&equo; of the agreement reached in June with the Angolan government which should have ended fighting in that country, writes John Bulloch. 
 John Major, the Foreign Secretary, said the withdrawal of the Cubans from Angola and the Namibian settlement were an opportunity to end the fighting. 
 The Blackpool meeting was the first between Mr Savimbi and a British minister, underlining the importance Britain attaches to persuading Mr Savimbi to return to the conference table. 
 The Unita leader indicated that he was ready to do so, and suggested a meeting in Libreville within the next month. 
 Mr Savimbi is meeting President Mobutu Sese Seko of Zaire in Paris on Monday, and yesterday the Angolan Foreign Minister, Pedro de Castro van Dunem, hurried there to put his side of the argument to the Zairean mediator. 
 Officials say it is because the two sides have different versions of what was decided at the previous negotiations that the ceasefire has broken down. 
 Angola wants Mr Savimbi to go into voluntary exile while elections are held, perhaps to return later, but his supporters say there was no such agreement. 
 It seemed yesterday that the conflicting ideas would be sorted out by President Mobutu, and that a political settlement was in sight. 
 One indication of that was that at the request of the British, both sides agreed to stop the radio propaganda campaigns they have been waging against each other. 
 Comedians, not crime, preoccupy New York voters 
 From LEONARD DOYLE in New York 
 THE 24 HOURS preceding President George Bush's stop in New York last night on behalf of Rudolph Giuliani, the Republican candidate for mayor, were among the bloodiest the city has seen. 
 For Mr Giuliani, however, for whom crime is a main campaign theme, the night in which 11 people were killed did little to boost his chances of winning next month's election. 
 As he has been discovering, the issues which excite New Yorkers are not rising levels of crime, poverty and the deteriorating quality of life. 
 Yesterday's newspapers were consumed not with Mr Bush's campaign stop for Mr Giuliani, but with the position of David Dinkins, the Democratic candidate, on security for the state of Israel, and Woody Allen's defence of the comedian Jackie Mason. 
 Mr Allen said Mr Mason was joking when he called Mr Dinkins &bquo;a fancy schvartze with a moustache&equo; and that Jews would only vote for him out of guilt. 
 Yesterday's newspaper columns on the election were devoted to Mr Dinkins' promises to defend Jewish interests in the same way that Mayor Ed Koch did for the past 12 years. 
 In a front-page headline, the New York Post proclaimed &bquo;Woody Allen Backs Jackie Mason&equo;. 
 Mr Allen was tactless enough to offer his opinion while standing beside Mr Dinkins. 
 The coverage given to Mr Allen's remarks must have been particularly galling to Mr Giuliani's backers in the Republican party who have been unable to make crime an issue in the race. 
 Last year Mr Bush came from 17 points behind at the polls when a skilful advertising campaign persuaded voters that Michael Dukakis, the Liberal governor of Massachusetts, was soft on crime. 
 More people than ever are leaving New York before they get killed, raped or mugged. 
 There were 1,019 murders in the first seven months of 1989, 1 per cent below the same period last year, which eventually reached a record 1,896. 
 Still, the Giuliani campaign theme of &bquo;crime, crack and corruption&equo; is apparently failing to ignite voter interest. 
 Mr Bush described Mr Giuliani as &bquo;America's greatest crime fighter&equo;, and the evidence of the anarchy on the streets was on the television news for all to see. 
 On Wednesday night a 52-year-old Baptist minister was shot dead by robbers in the vestibule of his Bedford Stuyvesant church. 
 Six blocks away a 52-year-old doorman who tried to protect himself with an ice pick was killed by a teenager with an automatic handgun. 
 In Times Square an off-duty law enforcement officer felt a knife against his throat as he went to catch a train home at 11.15pm. 
 The mugger, who probably thought he was accosting a tourist, said &bquo;don't move&equo;. 
 The agent pulled out a gun and shot him dead. 
 Mr Giuliani has been unable to focus voters' attention on the fact that Mr Dinkins once went several years without paying his taxes, or that he is a product of a corrupt Democratic machine. 
 Mr Dinkins has stayed in the headlines by pandering to Jewish sensibilities, and by removing from his campaign a volunteer who once read an antisemitic poem on the radio and praised it. 
 Autumn's conjuring trick: As leaves begin to show off their colours, Anna Pavord suggests some dazzling trees and shrubs 
 By ANNA PAVORD 
 IT IS the Keats time of year again, when inefficiently brainwashed poetasters grope about trying to remember whatever it was that came after the &bquo;mellow fruitfulness&equo; bit. 
 It is the time for Nature's great conjuring trick, when green leaves become crimson, gold, russet and purple. 
 Nobody knows when the show is going to take place. 
 It could be tomorrow. 
 It could be next month. 
 Or we could have missed it already. 
 Nothing is simpler than the question &bquo;Why do trees change colour?&equo; says John White, the Forestry Commission's dendrologist at Westonbirt Arboretum in Gloucestershire. 
 Nothing could be more complicated than the answer and even the answer, he says, is in question. 
 For instance, it is commonly supposed that trees and shrubs colour better on acid soils than they do on alkaline. 
 At Westonbirt, noted as the best place in England for autumn colour, they do not find this so. 
 At one site, where there is a particularly brilliant display, the soil is pH8, quite determinedly on the alkaline side of neutral (pH7). 
 White has been at the arboretum for 14 years and observes that the best autumn colour often comes after the worst summers. 
 There is a pleasing sense of justice about the observation, but the effect has more to do with rates of growth than fair play. 
 In the drought year of 1976 and in this summer, too, many trees were stressed by lack of water. 
 Their natural reaction to this is to shed leaves, to cut maintenance back to the essential main frame as it were, and this may happen during August or at the beginning of September, long before the frosts which generally trigger leaf fall. 
 When they shed leaves because of drought, trees do not usually bother with all the razzmatazz of colouring them beforehand. 
 Foliage just curls up and drops off. 
 The best autumn colour will obviously occur when maximum leaf surface is available for change. 
 This usually happens after damp summers, when growth has been lush and unchecked. 
 There are other factors to take into account. 
 Gales in September can tear off leaves before the display begins. 
 The best colour seems to happen after a warm, still Indian summer, terminated by a short, sharp frost. 
 These conditions do not come to order. 
 All we can do is plant and hope. 
 Only in the biggest gardens will it be worth planting trees that have nothing to say apart from their brief autumn statement. 
 In most gardens the show must be made up of performers that can do a spring or summer act as good as their autumn one. 
 It is important also to sort out those trees and shrubs that, like rhododendrons, will only thrive on acid soils. 
 If you have an alkaline one, forget stewartia, enkianthus, fothergilla and nyssa. 
 Most of the acers, including the Japanese maples are perfectly happy in un-acid soils, provided they are reasonably moist. 
 They like living in the dappled shade of taller trees. 
 Full sun is likely to shrivel the leaves and it is this, rather than the soil, that will spoil autumn display. 
 We used the common field maple (Acer campestre) to replace a line of dead elms that formerly marked our boundary with the lane. 
 The foliage is handsome and the autumn colour is relatively long lasting, yellow and gold with the odd slash of red. 
 It is not a fine enough tree to recommend for a star position, but good in a hedge or to bulk up planting in a relatively wild corner of the garden. 
 Acer palmatum &bquo;Heptalobum Osakazuki&equo; is the star of the tribe for autumn colour. 
 It has deeply divided mid-green leaves that flare to wild, improbable scarlet. 
 Even after they have dropped, they are valuable, lying in a blood-red pool under the dense thicket of branches. 
 The hawthorns are a greatly under-rated family and several are ideally suited for small gardens. 
 The local bird population will appreciate them too. 
 Crataegus prunifolia is particularly good at this time of the year, a tough, compact little tree, no more than 15-20ft at maturity, making a broad, spiny head furnished with glossy green leaves. 
 The undersides of the leaves are slightly downy. 
 The one I saw this week at Hillier's Arboretum, Ampfield, near Winchester, was already on the turn, with leaves orange and scarlet amidst clusters of large red haws, much bigger than those you find on wild hawthorns. 
 It was a delectable sight. 
 The thorn C lavallei is of similar build to C prunifolia. 
 They share a parent, who seems to have given them both the same handsome shiny leaves. 
 The haws on C lavallei are the orange side of red and both haws and leaves seem to hang longer on this tree than the other. 
 In the country, blackbirds and mistle thrushes are likely to have stripped most of the glistening haws by the end of November. 
 In town they will last longer. 
 Both thorns are tolerant of pollution and are tough enough to grow in open, exposed seaside sites regularly raked over by salt-laden winds, although these of course will do nothing for the autumn display. 
 Both have clusters of white flowers in early June. 
 The stag's-horn sumach (Rhus typhina) brings out many people in a cold sweat of hatred. 
 At Hillier's, however, there were two close cousins that would look splendid in any garden. 
 Both had superb, doubly dissected leaves, as elegant as the foliage of ferns, hanging down for 2ft or so. 
 One, Rhus glabra &bquo;Laciniata&equo; had scarcely begun to turn, but was decorated rather in the manner of a horse chestnut with dense conical clusters of red seeds, developed from the earlier flowers. 
 The second sumach, R trichocarpa, stood by the lake in the arboretum and was already ablaze in the most brilliant scarlet. 
 It must have been a male tree for there was no sign of the drooping clusters of yellow fruit that female trees would now be bearing. 
 Either of these would be ideal to use as foliage backing for earlier flower plantings, for their leaves are handsome at any season. 
 They would blaze into prominence just as the foreground planting was falling to pieces. 
 They did not look as though they were suckering in the baleful way that the ordinary stag's-horn sumach does, but as I have not grown either myself yet, I cannot vouch for their good behaviour. 
 Both could be kept within bounds by a severe pruning in early spring. 
 The most extraordinary performer in my own garden at the moment is not a leaf but a seed pod, actually 18 seed pods, belonging to the shrub Decaisnea fargesii. 
 They are the size and shape of chipolata sausages but the most extraordinary colour, slaty metallic blue. 
 I am told that the Chinese name for them (the shrub comes from China) is &bquo;cat droppings&equo;. 
 Some cat. 
 Coming down to earth: Over the next four weeks Sally Tamplin looks at the problems of a small town garden. 
 First: sorting out soil 
 By SALLY TAMPLIN 
 OPTIMISM and patience are the basic requisites of the town gardener, food and water those of the garden. 
 After many years and three gardens, the optimism is going well; I still battle with my impatience, but I am finally coming to grips with giving the essentials of sustenance to the garden. 
 Town soil is not like country soil, and the smaller the area the worse it is. 
 Rain does not get near the walls, there is not enough rotting animal and vegetable matter, and the last people have always used the garden as a rubbish heap. 
 First you have to dig out all the junk, bag it up and probably lug it through the house. 
 Then it is time to make a tipping policy. 
 Either you tip the dustmen to take it away or you take it to the tip yourself. 
 As the problem will continue with the Great Autumn-Putting-to-Bed and the Great Spring-Tidy-Up and all the cutting back in between, a store of large sacks is essential. 
 Next it is feeding time. 
 What the soil needs is body, humus, bulk and nutrients. 
 Home-made compost is wonderful, but you will need a lot of space to make the necessary amount. 
 What do you get and where do you get it? 
 I have never found the perfect answer. 
 Garden centres will have horse and hop or horse and mushroom, but they are not cheap, can be full of weed seed and, if sawdust and not straw is used in the horse's stable, and can create problems of nitrogen deficiency. 
 Sawdust (as I, imperfectly, understand it) uses all the nitrogen to rot itself down. 
 I put Growmore fertiliser on at the same time as the compost and it seems to have no ill-effects. 
 The local garden or allotment society may have access to good cheap muck; stables sometimes let you take it free, but this will be steaming fresh and needs time, and space, to rot. 
 Good farmyard manure is what we all need in towns, and I am sure a farmer could make money marketing his pig, chicken and cow dung. 
 If you cannot do the whole garden at once, I have found it better to do a small area really well and then concentrate on another the next year. 
 Leaf mould is what I really lust for, but no one sells it and it would be ecologically unsound and legally unwise to go digging it out of Wimbledon Common. 
 I now use Dug, a decomposed poultry manure from Pelco, when planting and give an annual mulch of bark to the acid areas and spent mushroom compost to the rest; it improves the body of my sandy soil and also works magnificently as a weed suppressor if put on thick enough. 
 The mulch went on this year in March (together with the Growmore, as ever), and only the keenest weeds have managed to struggle through. 
 The mushroom compost might look a bit straw-like at first, but the plants soon grow together over it. 
 When I think of the hours of weeding it saves, it appears nothing but beautiful to me. 
 The mushrooms are good too. 
 In the Garden Update: Rosy delays 
 By SALLY TAMPLIN 
 COMMERCIAL rose growers are praying for rain so they can start getting bare-root plants out of the ground and away to customers. 
 Deliveries, they warn, are likely to be a little late this year, but rose planting can safely be done in any frost-free period between October and March. 
 In the Garden Update: Alpine prizes 
 Weekend Garden Page 43 
 In the Garden Update: Herbal calendar 
 By SALLY TAMPLIN 
 CAROLINE HOLMES, who has her own herb nursery at Denham End Farm, Denham, near Bury St Edmunds, will be choosing and talking about a Calendar of Herbs on Monday (7pm) at the Museum of Garden History, St Mary at Lambeth, Lambeth Palace, London SE1. 
 Admission &pound;3. 
 Money raised will go towards the appeal to establish a permanent museum on the Lambeth site. 
 In the Garden Update: Weekend work 
 By SALLY TAMPLIN 
 LIKE many other plants, asparagus seems to have got a second wind. 
 Fresh green growths should not be cut down, but any stems that have yellowed and withered can be cleared away. 
 A thick mulch of mushroom compost round the crowns is beneficial. 
 Window boxes need clearing of summer bedding. 
 Fill the containers with fresh compost before replanting with winter pansies or spring bulbs. 
 Low-growing crocuses and irises will be easier to manage than full-size daffodils, which get beaten about by wind in exposed situations. 
 Ivy is an elegant gap filler for winter months. 
 Many apples and pears are now ready for picking. 
 Temperature is the most critical factor in successful storage. 
 It should be between 36-41F. 
 Somewhere dark and slightly damp will be ideal. 
 If you cannot find wooden boxes, use large polythene bags for storage, but leave the bag tops open. 
 Houseplants should be allowed to drift into semi-dormancy. 
 Cut down on feeding (once a month is plenty) and watering, but keep the atmosphere round the plants slightly humid by misting over leaves, or standing pots on a layer of damp pebbles. 
 Shading should be washed off greenhouses and insulating film fixed. 
 Court Circular 
 By SALLY TAMPLIN 
 BUCKINGHAM PALACE 13 October: The Queen was represented by Mr Michael Bevan (Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Cambridgeshire) at the Memorial Service for Colonel Geoffrey Hurrell (formerly Her Majesty's Lord-Lieutenant for Cambridgeshire) which was held in Ely Cathedral this afternoon. 
 13 October: The Prince Edward attended an evening of greyhound racing at Kingsmead Stadium, Canterbury, in support of the Royal Marines School of Music Disaster Fund. 
 His Royal Highness, attended by Major William McLean, travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 Her Royal Highness travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight and was attended by the Hon Mrs Legge-Bourke. 
 Her Royal Highness travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 Viscountess Campden and Lieutenant-Commander Patrick Jephson RN were in attendance. 
 The Princess of Wales, President, The Printers' Charitable Corporation, attended the Corporation's annual dinner at the Guildhall, EC2. 
 Mrs Max Pike and Lieutenant-Commander Patrick Jephson RN were in attendance. 
 13 October: Princess Alice, Duchess of Gloucester, President, The Gardeners' Royal Benevolent Society, was present this morning at the Society's Council Meeting at Rayner Court, Henfield, West Sussex. 
 Her Royal Highness subsequently had luncheon at Red Oaks, the home for retired gardeners at Henfield. 
 Princess Alice, Duchess of Gloucester, attended by Mrs Michael Harvey, travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 The Duke of Gloucester, as President of the British Consultant's Bureau left Oporto today at the conclusion of His Royal Highness's visit to Portugal. 
 The Duke of Gloucester, attended by Major Nicholas Barne, travelled in an aircraft of The Queen's Flight. 
 Princess Alice, Duchess of Gloucester and The Duke and Duchess of Gloucester were represented by Mr James Crowden at the Memorial Service for Colonel Geoffrey Hurrell which was held in Ely Cathedral this afternoon. 
 YORK HOUSE 13 October: The Duke of Kent, as Vice Chairman of the British Overseas Trade Board, this morning visited Colman's of Norwich and, later, visited Norwich City College of Further and Higher Education, Norfolk. 
 His Royal Highness was attended by Mr Andrew Palmer and Captain the Honourable Christopher Knollys. 
 ROYAL ENGAGEMENTS The Queen and The Duke of Edinburgh visit Malaysia, and will be present in Kuala Lumpur for the Opening Stages of the Commonwealth Heads of Government Meeting. 
 The Princess Royal, President, British Olympic Association, today attends its Annual General Meeting at the Midland Hotel, Manchester; and tomorrow attends a Variety Show in aid of the Army Benevolent Fund at the Palace Theatre, Manchester. 
 Princess Alice, Duchess of Gloucester, Air Chief Commandant, WRAF, today attends a Service to mark the 50th Anniversary of the WAAF and the 40th Anniversary of the reforming of the WRAF, at St Clement Danes Church, Strand, London WC2. 
 Faith and Reason: Why God suffers but is unchanged: In the fifth article in a series on God's mutability, Canon Roy Porter argues that the idea that God suffers can exist side by side with the idea that He is unchanging 
 By CANON ROY PORTER 
 IN THE recent report of the Church of England's Doctrine Commission, We Believe in God, the doctrine of divine impassibility, that God cannot suffer, is described as &bquo;the most venerable theological position&equo; and so it has generally been when Christians have endeavoured to think or speak about the nature of their God. 
 Yet, in the preface to that report, the Chairman, the Bishop of Salisbury, states that as the result of the Commission's deliberations, &bquo;belief in an impassible God is discarded&equo; and many contemporary theologians would wholeheartedly echo this. 
 So can the traditional view any longer be maintained, especially perhaps in view of the picture of God that is found in the Bible? 
 It is important to realise that divine impassibility is an aspect of God's immutability, that God is utter perfection and completely self-sufficient and therefore cannot be subject to change. 
 He is not subject to any action from without, action which could compel him to change His attitudes or behaviour. 
 Now suffering, in the proper sense, is caused precisely by external factors affecting us, physical conditions or the actions of other human beings which afflict or constrain us. 
 It is because God is not subject to such things that He may be said not to suffer, at least in the way human beings do. 
 Belief in the impassibility of God, it is worth noting, was developed in the early Christian centuries against the background of popular religious belief in the world of that day, where gods were no more than human beings on a large scale, subject to the same contingencies, passions, frustrations and feelings of pain or pleasure that determine human nature. 
 The God of the Bible and the Church was to be wholly free from all these. 
 But, it may be objected, what of God's relationship with His creation and the men and women He has made? 
 God in no way needs the world and He did not need to make it: creation is the expression of His pure outgoing love and indeed traditional Christian teaching has held that one day this present world will come to an end but God will still be the same God. 
 But this implies that the world is an entity other than God and God has given it freedom and thus the possibility of &bquo;going wrong&equo;, of producing evil, sin, pain and suffering, whatever explanation we may try to give of how such things have come about &mdash; at least they are only too obvious in the world we know. 
 Yet because God is love and creation is a manifestation of His love, He continues to love the world and wills to &bquo;put right&equo; whatever has gone wrong. 
 But does this not mean that God has to be affected by what happens in the world and that the challenges and frustrations which the world's freedom continually presents to Him force ever new responses from Him, so that He is continually changing? 
 As the Doctrine Commission puts it, &bquo;He exposes Himself to being acted upon and, in that sense, being compelled to change.&equo; 
 Is not this how we see God revealed in the record of Himself in the Bible? 
 And does not the fact that God is love mean that when His creation suffers He suffers too? 
 Above all, does not the cross show that this is how God always acts in and towards the world, eternally vulnerable to the worst of pain and suffering which it manifests? 
 Now, as John Bowker has pointed out in the first article in this series, &bquo;to say that God is not affected by His creatures is not to say that He takes no interest in them&equo;, nor that, seen from our viewpoint as creatures in time and space, God cannot do one thing at one moment and something apparently quite different the next. 
 It is inevitable and right that if we are to make God real for ourselves we must, to a considerable degree, speak of Him in human terms, which is what the Bible does when it speaks of Him as repenting, changing His mind, being provoked or made angry or sorrowful. 
 But we must never forget the inadequacy of all human language before the mystery of God's essential being, of God as God. 
 What is important is that God always acts towards us with an outbreak of invariable love, the expression of His unchanging nature. 
 Love which was forced on God would not be divine love at all. 
 Further, it is noticeable that those who speak of a &bquo;suffering God&equo; tend to employ rather different language when they speak of &bquo;God in action&equo;, as the report of the Doctrine Commission illustrates. 
 It talks of God &bquo;taking upon Himself the suffering of the world&equo;, of God being &bquo;involved&equo; or &bquo;in&equo; our suffering. 
 None of these expressions implies of itself that God as God suffers as we do, still less, as is suggested in Margaret Spufford's quotation from The Man on a Donkey, in her book Celebration that He renders Himself &bquo;powerless against the free and evil wills of men&equo;. 
 For when God freely wills to take on Himself the world's suffering, He does so in order to absorb it, to transform it and to overcome it by the positive power of His eternal and unchanging love. 
 It is here, one feels, that Margaret Spufford is not wholly consistent. 
 On the one hand, she finds it true that &bquo;the definition of &bquo;Almighty&equo; means that there is no evil out of which good cannot be brought', while on the same page she writes that, &bquo;if those theologies who assert that God is in total control of His creation are right, I cannot worship Him&equo;. 
 But a God who can bring good out of the worst of evils is wholly in control. 
 The creation may groan and travail in pain but it cannot escape the destiny that God has eternally willed for it. 
 Such is what the traditional doctrines of divine omnipotence, preservation and providence are really saying. 
 Lastly, it is a serious over-simplification to claim that Christ on the cross shows that God as God, God in His essential being, must be held to suffer and suffer repeatedly and continuously. 
 This is to ignore the question, from the Christian standpoint, of the relationship of the divine and human natures in Jesus and the character of the involvement of the other two persons of the trinity in the Incarnation &mdash; difficult problems, no doubt, but not to be set aside in the search for truth and understanding. 
 Theologians have generally found it possible to hold together belief in the fulness of God in Christ and belief in the unchangeable perfection of the divine nature. 
 We need the latter for the ultimate goal of human existence is the vision of God, the mystic's vision, where there is not pain or suffering or mutability, but only unchanging, radiant and joyful perfection. 
 Obituary: John Denison 
 By ROBIN MACHELL 
 John Denison, architect, born Bradford 1936, married Frances Attrill (two sons; two daughters), died Sheffield 4 October 1989. 
 IN THE design- and style-conscious Eighties, John Denison was an architect who did not court publicity or revel in the limelight. 
 He was more interested in his art than the polemics of his profession. 
 In the past 15 years Denison's work has had a direct influence on the conservation movement in the North of England. 
 His buildings were never precious or timid, and avoided the excesses of some recent schemes which have been presented as wearing the conservation mantle. 
 Always pioneering, his work in Leeds helped shape the direction of development within the City. 
 His first important conservation scheme in Leeds was for the conversion of St Paul's House, a Moorish-style Victorian warehouse in Park Square, which he designed while an Associate at Booth Shaw and Partners in 1970. 
 This conversion was a benchmark for the conservation movement both locally and nationally. 
 It proved to planners and developers that modern, desirable office accommodation could be provided in existing buildings. 
 It is a local landmark which received national and international recognition and helped turn the tide against the thoughtless demolition of the Sixties. 
 Still with Booth Shaw, Denison produced the radical proposal for flats for single people in the heart of the city centre. 
 The site was a rambling and derelict pub, the Royal Hotel, which was originally a Georgian coaching inn. 
 Denison's use of glass-fibre mouldings, a technique previously employed at St Paul's House to replace the original stucco facade, was an innovative solution which created some debate among purists at the time. 
 He also insisted on the re-use of bar fittings discovered during demolition, and these now grace the offices of the Housing Association which occupy part of the site. 
 During this project the landlord of The Whip, a once notorious hostelry, was concerned that the vibration of the adjacent building operation would affect the quality of his beer. 
 Denison gladly agreed to sample the ale daily. 
 In 1984 Denison set up his own practice, Denison Peters Limited, to work on the first big project on the Leeds riverside, a housing scheme of part converted corn chandlers and part newly built flats. 
 This scheme, which was the first which opened up the riverside in Leeds, an area which up to this time had been ignored and declining for 100 years, led the way for the mass of development which has since followed. 
 Denison was often consulted by the Civic Trust, Victorian Society, Save Britain's Heritage and the local building preservation trusts. 
 His advice was always solid and practical. 
 He died as the result of a fall while surveying the interior of St Barnabas' Church in Sheffield. 
 He brought to friendship, as to his work, perceptiveness, integrity and above all enjoyment. 
 Obituary: Sir Henry Ware 
 By DEREK RIPPENGAL 
 HENRY WARE was a notable Government lawyer. 
 He was Treasury Solicitor &mdash; the head of the government legal service &mdash; from 1971 to 1975, and in his career in the Treasury Solicitor's Office he was involved in the setting up of the intricate Prices and Incomes Acts of the 1960s and the formation of the new departments of Environment and Trade and Industry. 
 The Treasury Solicitor's office provides legal advice and conveyancing and litigation services to a wide range of Government departments and Henry Ware's career in the office, until he became head of it, was entirely on the advisory side. 
 Over the years he was involved in a variety of fields from Transport to Defence. 
 A modest man, he was inclined to self-deprecation but had a quick, sharp mind of considerable penetration, together with a robust common sense. 
 He also had an unerring instinct, when faced with awkward legal problems, of finding solutions to them which would work in practice. 
 These qualities were all evident when he took charge of the task of preparing the instructions for the drafting of the Prices and Incomes Acts of the mid-Sixties and he made a notable contribution to those formidably difficult exercises. 
 Ware qualified as a solicitor after Marlborough and St John's College, Oxford, and entered the Treasury Solicitor's Office shortly before the war. 
 He returned there in 1945 after serving with the Royal Artillery throughout the war. 
 It was the office in which, apart from a space of three years with the Independent Television Authority, he spent his entire career. 
 Ware took over the post of Treasury Solicitor at a difficult time. 
 The setting-up of the large departments of Environment and Trade and Industry in 1970 had led to an enquiry into the provision of Government legal services. 
 This was conducted by Sir Edmund Compton and as a result of his report the Treasury Solicitor's office lost a considerable amount of its advisory work (which it has since regained) at about the time Ware became Treasury Solicitor in 1971. 
 At the same time, however, the Compton Report recommended the establishment of central machinery for securing more movement of lawyers between departments. 
 A Central Management Committee was set up for the Government legal service and, as senior Government lawyer, it fell to Ware to be chairman of this and to become head of the parallel Legal Career Service. 
 He thus became the key figure in implementing the changes in the Government legal service arising out of the Compton Report. 
 This role he discharged with great success and it was probably the most notable feature of his time as Treasury Solicitor. 
 Ware was a shy man, given to covering his shyness with a good deal of banter. 
 But underneath there was a remarkably warm and kind heart. 
 He shared with his wife Harriet a passion for fly-fishing and gardening and he made no secret of the fact that his years of retirement, when they were able to fish and garden to the full, were the happiest of his life. 
 Birthdays 
 Gazette Page 15 
 Obituary: The Rev Keith Elliott VC 
 By JULIA STUART 
 &bquo;WELL DONE, thou good and faithful servant&equo; was the text for one of the more memorable sermons preached by the Rev Keith Elliott VC. 
 Keith Elliott's sermon, delivered in 1948, was a tribute to his battered bicycle which served as his transport during his curacy at All Saints' Parish, Palmerston North. 
 But the text could serve equally as a tribute to the man himself. 
 Sergeant Elliott won the Victoria Cross on the battlefield of Ruweisat Ridge in July 1942. 
 There he led a small group of men from the 22nd NZ Battalion to rescue an injured officer, in the process silencing five machine-guns and an anti-tank weapon and taking 130 prisoners. 
 Already wounded in the chest during an earlier rapid dash away from Rommel's tanks, Elliott suffered three leg wounds in action. 
 His VC was presented to him in the Western Desert by Montgomery, and he returned to New Zealand in 1943 after active service in Greece, Crete and North Africa. 
 Farming was Keith Elliott's original career. 
 Born of a farming family in Apiti, in the rural Manawatu, he trained at Feilding Agricultural High School and started work as a &bquo;cow cocky&equo;, dairy farming in the northern Wairarapa. 
 In his tribute at the funeral in Wellington on Thursday, the Right Rev Hapai Winiata, Assistant Bishop of Wellington, described how that made Keith Elliott a man who worked with people. 
 &bquo;You never got any of the big jobs, Keith,&equo; said Bishop Hapai, addressing the deceased in Maori style. 
 &bquo;You got appointments among your people. 
 You understood them.&equo; 
 As a priest in the pastorate of Wainui-a-rua, Keith Elliott had tremendous influence upon Maori people in the Wanganui and Taihape area. 
 A mission he ran there &bquo;began me on my journey to St John's Theological College,&equo; Bishop Hapai recalled. 
 &bquo;We called Keith &bquo;the hunataway&equo;, like the dogs that round up the sheep. 
 He didn't sit around. 
 He got out and did the Lord's work. 
 And he was deeply loved by the Maori people.&equo; 
 He loved them in return. 
 He found that way of living very much to his liking, but regretted never having the opportunity to learn the Maori language before he began his ministry. 
 After his death, the Maori honoured him with a lying-in-state at Pipitea Marae, near Wellington Cathedral, and a karanga (lament) by two kuia (older women) who remained with the casket throughout the ceremonies. 
 Fund-raising was one of Keith Elliott's talents. 
 A new church in his last parish of Karori West; the local bowling club; Te Omanga Hospice (where he died); sports clubs&hellip; all benefited from his ability to encourage others' generosity. 
 The week before he died, he reckoned he had raised over &dollar;100,000 in his lifetime. 
 Twice he worked for the Wellington City Mission, among the lost and lonely people of the inner city. 
 He was chaplain to Waikune Prison during his time in the Maori pastorates, and welfare officer to the Fire Service in Wellington during his retirement. 
 The overflowing congregation at his funeral was evidence of the range of people he touched; politicians, military, Maori people, clergy, welfare workers. 
 His casket, carried from the Cathedral on the shoulders of infantrymen, was covered by a Maori cloak, on which was placed a sword and a soldier's &bquo;lemon-squeezer&equo; hat. 
 As Bishop Winiata said, they were farewelling a legend &mdash; a man who got things done, a man who was prepared to lay down his life for his friends. 
 Anniversaries 
 By JULIA STUART 
 On this day: the Battle of Hastings was fought, 1066; Mary, Queen of Scots was tried, 1586; Marie Antoinette was tried, 1793; bread riots took place in Hyde Park, 1855; Oxford degrees were first conferred on women, 192050-pence coins were issued to replace the 10-shilling note, 1969. 
 Today is the Feast Day of St Angadriama, St Burchard of Wurzburg, St Callixtus I, pope, St Dominic Lauricatus, St Justus of Lyons, St Manacca and St Manechildis. 
 Deaths: Mata Hari (Margaretha Geertruida Zelle), executed for espionage 1917; Hermann Goering, Nazi leader, committed suicide 1946. 
 On this day: the new calendar, as promulgated by Pope Gregory XIII, came into force in Italy and Spain, and 5 October became 15 October, 1582. 
 Train sit-in leader arrested 
 By JULIA STUART 
 COMMUTERS who staged a sit-in on a British Rail train they claim is cancelled frequently were ejected by police, and their leader arrested, at a station last night. 
 Passengers on the 5.18pm train from Waterloo in London to Alton, Hampshire, were enraged when it stopped at Woking, Surrey, and the driver said it would not go further. 
 Their leader, Peter Bancroft, 36, said: &bquo;We have been struggling with British Rail's shortage of drivers for months and have christened our regular train home the ghost train.&equo; 
 He added that when platform staff asked the commuters to leave the train, &bquo;we refused and I borrowed a portable phone to ring Waterloo to complain. 
 An official I spoke to said there were no staff to take the train on and we had to leave and wait for another to come along.&equo; 
 British Rail said the train was halted because there was no relief guard. 
 &bquo;We are human and understand why people's feelings run high&hellip; 
 But we would point out that this sort of sit-in action doesn't help resolve anything.&equo; 
 Scientists resolve quest for the heart of all matter 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 THE AGE-OLD search for the fundamental building blocks of matter has been resolved by results from the new particle accelerator, or &bquo;atomsmasher&equo;, at CERN, the European centre for particle physics in Geneva, just three weeks after experiments there began. 
 Since the fifth century BC, when Democritus of Abdera first put forward the idea, scientists and philosophers have speculated on the nature of the fundamental constituents of matter. 
 Excited physicists packed a seminar at CERN yesterday to hear that tests in the recently-opened LEP (Large Electron-Positron collider) had showed all matter is made from exactly three families of sub-atomic particles. 
 The results confirm the so-called Standard Model, the theory which physicists have built up over the past 15 years to explain both the nature of matter and the forces which govern it. 
 They are a dramatic success for CERN and confirm Europe's primacy in sub-atomic physics. 
 LEP's Californian rival, the Stanford Linear Collider, has been trying, and failing, to get this result for more than two years. 
 Dr Terry Sloan from Lancaster University, who is working on LEP, said: &bquo;Everyone is overjoyed. 
 We got what we wanted. 
 This is proof of the Standard Model.&equo; 
 LEP is the most powerful atomsmasher in the world. 
 It accelerates pencil-sized beams of electrons and their anti-matter equivalent, positrons, to near the speed of light in opposite directions around a 17-mile circular tunnel, roughly the length of London Underground's Circle line. 
 At a few selected points, the particles crash together head-on, generating energy of an intensity matched only by the first moments of the explosion physicists believe created the universe. 
 The energy generates a cascade of new particles. 
 The one of most interest to physicists is called the Z or Z-naught. 
 In less than a month, LEP has produced more than 11,000 of them, compared to a few hundred detected in California. 
 The Z particle decays into other particles too quickly to be detected directly, but by measuring the speed and direction of the tracks of the particles into which it decays, physicists at CERN have been able to measure the Z particle's vital statistics with unprecedented accuracy. 
 It has a mass of 91.1 GeV (a thousand million electronvolts) &mdash; roughly 100 times the mass of the proton &mdash; to within an accuracy of 0.06GeV. 
 From this and from the particle's measured lifetime, physicists at CERN have deduced that there are only three families of fundamental particles. 
 Each family contains four siblings: two fundamental particles known as quarks and two known as leptons. 
 Quarks bind together to make up larger particles such as the protons and neutrons found in the atomic nucleus. 
 Leptons include particles such as the familiar electrons, which orbit the atomic nucleus, and the mysterious neutrinos, which are almost undetectable particles capable of passing through the entire earth untouched. 
 Yesterday's results represent a great advance towards physicists' ultimate goal, a Theory of Everything, or TOE, which would explain the innermost workings of the universe &mdash; and put particle physicists out of a job. 
 A guest arriving at Westway Studios, west London, yesterday for the opening catwalk show of London Fashion Week 
 By WILLIAM BOWN 
 A guest arriving at Westway Studios, west London, yesterday for the opening catwalk show of London Fashion Week. 
 The first designer to unveil his collection for the spring season was Rifat Ozbek, whose successor as designer of the year, is to be announced on Tuesday at the British Fashion Awards at the Royal Albert Hall. 
 More than 1,500 buyers and journalists attended Ozbek's two shows. 
 Katharine Hamnett, fashion's fireball; page 16  
 Foot to step down at next election 
 By STEPHEN WARD 
 At the age of 76 and realising that the lifetime of the next Parliament would take him into his eighties, he has decided to make way for a younger man. 
 Neil Kinnock, who like Mr Foot is an MP for a south Wales constituency and came to the leadership from the left of the party, described his mentor yesterday as unique and irreplaceable: &bquo;Michael is as fit and fiery as ever. 
 His marvellous personality in the Commons and his brilliant books confirm that.&equo; 
 Mr Foot took a principled but electorally disastrous stand against nuclear weapons in the 1983 election, and has always vehemently rejected the charge that he or Labour are unpatriotic. 
 He was first elected in 1945, lost his Plymouth seat in 1955, then represented Ebbw Vale and Blaenau Gwent from 1960. 
 But he came to the front bench late, as Secretary of State for Employment from 1974 to 1976, and leader of the House of Commons from 1976 to 1979. 
 He defeated Denis Healey to become Labour leader the following year. 
 He is a prolific author and writes regularly for newspapers. 
 He has not said whether he will consider taking a peerage. 
 Crucial game for nervous Speelman 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 THE Pilkington Glass World Chess Championship semi-finals will resume at Sadler's Wells, London, this afternoon with both matches delicately poised. 
 Jonathan Speelman must avoid defeat in his seventh game against Jan Timman to stay in the match. 
 One down with two to play, he will need to conquer his nerves and indulge in the creative style that brought him this far. 
 The semi-final between Anatoly Karpov and Artur Yusupov has come alive following Yusupov's win in the fifth game. 
 Before the match began, Yusupov was quoted as a 5-1 outsider. 
 But Karpov's play has been far below his best and Yusupov's brilliant equalising victory has generated a murmur of a possible upset. 
 When Karpov fought back to near equality after a difficult opening in Thursday's play, commentators were all expecting the game to drag on towards a turgid draw, but as both players came into time-trouble, Yusupov played a remarkable piece sacrifice to expose Karpov's king. 
 With 10 moves to the time-control Yusupov had six minutes to Karpov's four. 
 Neither player could calculate all the possibilities, but Yusupov's judgement and bravery paid off. 
 Aldington denies lie over dates 
 By WILLIAM HARTSTON, Chess Correspondent 
 LORD ALDINGTON yesterday denied that he had lied to a High Court libel jury about the date in May 1945 on which he left the British Army's V Corps in southern Austria. 
 The former wartime brigadier, who is accused of being a war criminal &bquo;with the blood of 70,000 Cossacks and Yugoslavs on his hands&equo;, insisted that he left V Corps on May 22. 
 The defence allege he was still there the next day and had insisted on the compulsory repatriation of Cossack prisoners to Soviet forces. 
 Richard Rampton QC, who is defending Lord Aldington's libel action against historian Count Nikolai Tolstoy and property developer Nigel Watts, suggested that the peer had given false evidence because it was &bquo;essential&equo; to his case that he was not in Austria on 23, 24 and 25 May. 
 Lord Aldington replied: &bquo;This will be the hundredth time you say what I've said is a lie, and it is the hundredth time you have made me very angry.&equo; 
 He said that after more than two years of searching through war documents he was now certain that he flew from Klagenfurt on 22 May. 
 It was a memorable flight because the wings iced over, forcing the pilot to dive, and left Lord Aldington feeling that &bquo;we came close to death&equo;. 
 The aircraft returned to Klagenfurt and then went on to Naples where he spent two nights before flying to England on 24 May, he said. 
 Mr Rampton read extracts from Sir Anthony Eden's May 1945 diaries which Lord Aldington agreed showed he could not have had dinner with the minister on 25 and 26 May as he had claimed. 
 The diaries contained no reference to Lord Aldington until 9 June. 
 But Lord Aldington insisted: &bquo;I most definitely saw him on May 25 and I remember having dinner with him on two successive nights around this time. 
 But that must have been later.&equo; 
 Count Tolstoy and Mr Watts are alleged to have libelled Lord Aldington in a pamphlet distributed to staff, pupils and other people connected with Winchester College, where he was warden. 
 The Week in Review: Home News 
 By DAVID LISTER 
 ET TU, BRUTE. 
 Nigel Lawson awoke at the start of the Conservative Party conference to find himself described as &bquo;This Bankrupt Chancellor&equo; on the front page of the Daily Mail. 
 &bquo;Would you give this man a job as chairman of a bank? 
 Or as city editor of a national newspaper? 
 The Daily Mail certainly would not,&equo; its front-page editorial said. 
 Deprived of this option, Mr Lawson decided to soldier on as Chancellor of the Exchequer, claiming in his speech on Thursday that there was no alternative to his economic policy. 
 Exuding confidence that there might be an alternative &mdash; notably himself &mdash; to Tory policy, Michael Heseltine told a fringe meeting: &bquo;Polluted rivers, filthy streets, bodies bedded down in doorways are no advertisement for a prosperous or caring society.&equo; 
 Another advertisement figured in the speech by Kenneth Clarke, the Secretary of State for Health, who parodied a British Medical Association poster which asked: &bquo;What do you call a man who will not take medical advice&hellip; 
 Kenneth Clarke.&equo; 
 The minister asked the conference: &bquo;What do you call a man who will not take medical advice&hellip; healthy.&equo; 
 This witticism received rapturous applause and left his speechwriters beaming, no one seemingly bothered by the fact that it made no sense. 
 Archaeologists claimed to have found the remains of Shakespeare's Globe Theatre, where Hamlet was given its first performance. 
 The site's owners, Hanson Plc, promised to preserve the site, to spare it from the two perennial dangers of the era &mdash; being covered by an office block or, worse, being renamed the Branagh theatre. 
 A survey showed that four out of five of Britain's biggest firms have introduced no smoking areas at work as a result of worker pressure. 
 It also showed that the greatest health worry of many companies for their male employees was smoking, but added that computers and visual display units (VDUs) were rated greater health risks for women. 
 Whether or not we will shortly have a passive computer lobby, it certainly gives a new meaning to the hacking cough. 
 Another survey, by The Indy, the weekly paper for young people, found that the British teenager was happy at home and one in three did not want to leave the family nest. 
 In a week when government figures showed that cases of people infected with the Aids virus are now increasing at a rate of almost five a day, one could see their point. 
 Newsagents seek money in magazine &bquo;shelf wars&equo; 
 By MAGGIE BROWN, Media Editor 
 MAGAZINE publishing is bristling with talk of &bquo;shelf wars&equo;, as companies haggle with newsagents over which titles get best positions on overcrowded racks. 
 Some of Britain's 35,000 newsagents are asking for payments, called retail display allowances, to give magazines special treatment. 
 This may include placing new titles in prime positions by the till &mdash; in the way that sweets are put next to supermarket checkouts. 
 Publishers are also being invited to pay for four or five copies of a magazine to be lined up against each other along a shelf, so the title appears to be a fast seller &mdash; a common US practice. 
 Even magazine publishers such as the Radio Times are producing a range of cardboard &bquo;shelf talkers&equo; and &bquo;shelf wobblies&equo; bearing the name of the magazine, designed to catch the browser's eye, and guide the hand. 
 Customers may find it more difficult to locate their favourite magazine, as money, rather than popularity, influences what goes where. 
 Brian Jackson, trading director of Martins the Newsagent, with 850 branches, said: &bquo;Publishers are offering us inducements, advertising support money. 
 The tactics of the supermarkets are starting to rub off on newsagents.&equo; 
 The practice is intensifying among women's magazine because many circulations are falling owing to sustained competition from new titles, and the reduction in consumer spending. 
 &bquo;They are all fighting over the same cake. 
 Meanwhile, the long-standing players are coming back in to defend themselves,&equo; Mr Jackson said. 
 Andy Rand, product group manager (news) for W H Smith said no one was charged to get titles into any of the company's 450 branches. 
 But it did sell &bquo;prime promotion space&equo; &mdash; the shelves at the end of each island unit that faced customers as they entered the door, and allowed four or five copies to face outwards. 
 &bquo;No one can book a spot for two consecutive issues. 
 If we went along with retail display allowances only the richest publishers would benefit,&equo; he said. 
 David Shields, marketing manager of the American-controlled National Magazines, publishers of Cosmopolitan, Good Housekeeping, Country Living, She, and Harpers &amp; Queen, said of retail display allowances: &bquo;It is not something we would like to encourage here.&equo; 
 However, the company plans to buy shelf space in the New Year, when it launches its new title, House Beautiful, as a monthly magazine. 
 Travel firm delays plan for air cruises 
 By FRANK BARRETT 
 A TRAVEL firm has postponed plans to launch a programme of lavish air cruises to Paris, Vienna, Cairo, Moscow and Peking in two specially designed Boeing 727 aircraft &mdash; the latest casualty of the rapidly growing recession in the package holiday business, writes Frank Barrett. 
 The Imperial Air Cruising Company said that due to &bquo;the troubles in the Soviet Union and China&equo;, the holidays &mdash; which cost up to &pound;7,000 each - would start next year. 
 The company had planned to begin its programme of holidays this month, which would &bquo;signal a return to the style and elegance of travel in the Twenties and Thirties&equo;. 
 But the travel industry is presently experiencing a Thirties- style depression, with probably its worst slump in bookings. 
 The severity of the depression was highlighted this week by the decision of the Automobile Association to pull out of the retail package holiday market, creating 400 redundancies. 
 Andrew Johnson, general manager of AA Travel, said: &bquo;It frankly became pointless to continue to compete in the overcrowded, heavily discounted and ultimately unprofitable air-package holidays business.&equo; 
 Thomson Holidays, Britain's biggest package holiday company, this week made a fresh effort to stimulate bookings for winter holidays by cutting prices on 100,000 holidays. 
 In the short term, the situation for the industry is serious. 
 In the long term, with bookings for next summer arriving in a bare trickle, the prospects are disastrous. 
 Science comes to defence of the chapati 
 By TONY HEATH 
 SCIENTISTS in Wales are helping to boost production of one of India's staple foods &mdash; the ubiquitous chapati, writes Tony Heath. 
 In areas of the sub-continent where pearl millet &mdash; the basis of the unleavened bread &mdash; is grown, soil temperatures often soar to 120F or more, killing seedlings and setting in train crop failures and food shortages. 
 Now experiments at the Welsh Plant Breeding Station near Aberystwyth on the Cardigan Bay coast are under way to find which strain of millet can best withstand the intense heat. 
 From more than 80 strains, four have been singled out to be grown from seeds which are tested for protein, which helps them to withstand heat. 
 Art Market: Tokyo sale of prints makes 5.5m pounds 
 By GERALDINE NORMAN 
 SOTHEBY'S first attempt since the 1970s to sell art to the Japanese on their own ground, a modern print sale at the Imperial Hotel in Tokyo yesterday, was a sensational success. 
 It made 50 per cent more than expected at &pound;5.5m and every lot was sold. 
 Since prints are multiples, their prices can normally be predicted far more accurately than other works of art. 
 By taking the prints to Japan, Sotheby's was selling to rich Japanese collectors without a retailer as an intermediary and the retailer's mark-up was subsumed into the auction price. 
 While bidding was strong throughout the sale, prices for selected artists went through the roof. 
 These included: Bernard Buffet, the French post-war limner of spiky flowers and views of Paris; the best Chagall portfolios (but not individual plates, for which prices were normal); David Hockney; a group of modern Americans including Jim Dine, Sam Francis, Frank Stella and Donald Sultan (but not Jasper Johns, who sold on estimate); Alphonse Mucha, the ornamental master of Art Nouveau; Andy Warhol; and Picasso. 
 The star lot was Picasso's most famous Blue Period etching, Le Repas Frugal of 1904, at 61.6m yen (&pound;275,369), three times pre-sale estimate. 
 His almost equally famous, brightly coloured linoleum cut of 1958, Buste de Femme d'apres Cranach, was a close runner-up at 57.2m yen (&pound;255,699), almost double estimate. 
 Christie's meanwhile set a new auction price record for a stamp in its New York dispersal of the Weill Brothers' stock. 
 A block of four 1918 24-cent stamps featuring an early aeroplane, from a famous sheet of 100 on which the aeroplane was printed upside down, sold for &dollar;1.1m (&pound;705,128), against an estimate of &dollar;600,000-&dollar;800,000, to an American broadcasting executive. 
 This block is widely considered the most important item in US philately; a second block of four from the same sheet made &dollar;528,000 (&pound;338,462), in line with estimate. 
 The original sheet of 100 was bought in a Washington post office by William T Robey on 14 May 1918; it had changed hands for &dollar;15,000 within the year. 
 Saatchi sneezes and the art world shivers: Charles Saatchi has been selling paintings and the dealers are worried. 
 Andrew Graham-Dixon reports 
 By ANDREW GRAHAM-DIXON 
 IT HAS BEEN in the air for months: Charles Saatchi, according to New York's uniquely garrulous and paranoid clan of dealers and artists, is selling, and he is selling in a big way. 
 The possessor of what is unquestionably the world's largest and finest collection of contemporary art, Saatchi has sold before &mdash; but never, according to the rumours, on anything like this scale. 
 During the past six months, hardly a week has gone by without yet another whisper about a sale from Saatchi's collection. 
 Major works by Anselm Kiefer previously thought to be in Saatchi's possession were, it was said, changing hands for prices in excess of &dollar;1m; Saatchi was rumoured to be selling equally major pictures from his unrivalled holdings of works by Georg Baselitz, Francesco Clemente, Julian Schnabel and others. 
 Saatchi, the most spectacular collector of recent times and probably the most active collector in British history (with the exception of King Charles I), had bought their work in greater bulk and more intelligently than any other individual or institution. 
 Now, as one New York dealer put it a week ago, &bquo;the word is that he's cashing in.&equo; 
 While a good many artists and dealers have clearly been upset by Saatchi's actions, no one feels absolutely confident about the motives behind them, and Saatchi himself absolutely declines to discuss his dealings, whether in art or business. 
 While he may not be collecting as actively as he was a few years ago, his name still inspires sufficient awe in most art world people for them to request complete anonymity when discussing him. 
 Earlier this week the rumours hardened into fact. 
 On Wednesday a spokeswoman for the Saatchi Collection told The Independent that &bquo;approximately 40 to 50 works have been sold&equo;, but she was equally insistent that the motive behind the sales was Saatchi's desire to shift the emphasis of the collection more towards British art. 
 Over the past two years, she pointed out, Saatchi had purchased major works by many of those British painters whose rise to prominence has been such a striking feature of recent years: Saatchi has bought work by, among others, Frank Auerbach, Lucian Freud, Leon Kossoff and Howard Hodgkin. 
 The sales of work by other artists in no way signalled a lessening of commitment to the collection and its future. 
 Art prices have now spiralled to the point, it was suggested, where even a collector of Charles Saatchi's great wealth can no longer afford to buy without selling. 
 What we were seeing was simply a &bquo;rationalisation&equo; of the collection, a &bquo;refining process.&equo; 
 Further investigation suggests that while that may be part of the story it is almost certainly not all of it. 
 Inquiries among certain dealers in this country have established that while Saatchi has been selling extremely heavily during the past six months he has actually bought very little British art. 
 He has also, inquiries revealed, sold rather more than the 40 or 50 paintings suggested by the Saatchi Collection spokeswoman in mid-week, and the pattern of his sales suggests that what we are seeing is rather more radical than a &bquo;refinement&equo; of the collection. 
 Saatchi has made no secret of his admiration for the work of the German painter Sigmar Polke, yet he has sold at least 17 works by the artist in his collection, including what many regard as Polke's finest work, Paganini; according to three separate sources of information, Saatchi has only one Polke left in his collection. 
 Investigation revealed the sale of at least 63 works in the past six months; yesterday a source close to Charles Saatchi was prepared to concede that the volume of sales was higher than previously stated, and that the works disposed of account for some 10 to 12 per cent of the collection, which suggests a true figure of between 70 and 100 individual sales. 
 Saatchi's extremely active deaccessioning has caused a stir partly because so many major artists and dealers have a personal stake in his collection - and have, in some cases, risen to prominence as his collection has expanded -but also because his collection is almost unanimously regarded as the greatest of its kind in existence. 
 Prominent figures in the British art world are naturally concerned by the possibility that they could be witnessing the beginning of the end of the Saatchi Collection. 
 Many feel that the pattern of the sales, given Saatchi's known admiration for the work of the artists involved suggests that choices are being made at least as much on the basis of the market as on the basis of taste. 
 When you sell 10 Kiefers, it becomes questionable whether you are refining or decimating your collection. 
 When the Saatchi spokeswoman's explanation of the sales was put to one New York dealer, his response was crude but succinct: &bquo;They're full of shit. 
 They're selling the work of artists who are on the crest of the wave in the market; every indication is that they're selling to raise capital. 
 If you want to refine a collection, you sell off in much smaller quantities than this &mdash; and you certainly don't sell your finest works by an artist everyone knows you admire.&equo; 
 'He's a collector,&equo; says another, &bquo;but he's really operating like a dealer. 
 Look at the stuff he's holding on to: he isn't selling any of his great Minimal works, his Carl Andres or Donald Judds, but those are works that are still climbing in value.&equo; 
 Four years ago the Saatchi Collection issued a lavish catalogue of much of its contents, a boxed set with the title Art of Our Time which comprised four beautifully illustrated volumes that retailed at the not inconsiderable price of &pound;100. 
 A guide to the collection, it seemed to many to underline, too, the extent to which the Saatchis had superseded the Tate Gallery as the most adventurous and successful purchasers of modern art in this country. 
 Even its critics concede that the Saatchi Collection has had a profound effect on the visual culture of this country, but it has always occupied an uneasy position &mdash; it has the status of a national institution, yet it is in private ownership. 
 According to reliable sources, the Tate Gallery greeted the expansion of the Saatchi Collection with a mixture of relief and complacency: it was felt that it would inevitably, one day, be bequeathed to the nation, and since that was so, the underfunded Tate Gallery need not bother to acquire major work in the same area as the Saatchis. 
 If the Saatchi Collection were to be dispersed, it is true to say that a whole era of international art would be effectively lost to the nation. 
 Artists and their dealers are always bitter when a major collector decides to sell, but the level of bitterness aroused by Saatchi's deaccessioning is, as one New York dealer puts it, &bquo;something else&equo;. 
 It is not merely the fact of Saatchi selling works that has upset the dealers, but the manner in which he has done so. 
 It is common practice for a collector wishing to resell works that he owns to do so through the gallery of origin, for a variety of reasons. 
 For one thing, the gallery knows very well which other collectors may be interested in making a purchase; for another, the gallery, since it represents the artist, likes to have some control over where a major work may be placed. 
 Saatchi has sold exclusively through a dealer called Larry Gagosian, well known in New York as a ruthless specialist in what is known as the secondary market. 
 Gagosian does not represent artists or their interests, he simply buys and sells works on the market, and he is known to be spectacularly good at it. 
 Gagosian's tactics, according to one New York dealer, have earned him &bquo;a questionable reputation&equo;. 
 Interviewed last year, Gagosian responded to the accusation that he had made transparencies of paintings reproduced in art magazines and offered them for sale as &bquo;a scurrilous charge&equo; &mdash; but he went on to admit &bquo;Well, I may have done it once.&equo; 
 Saatchi's decision to sell through Gagosian is understandable purely on business terms, but other aspects of the sale are less readily explicable. 
 &bquo;There is no doubt that Charles has been offered major works at good prices&equo;, says one dealer, &bquo;because people wanted to see those works in his great collection; artists have sold him paintings that they would not have sold to anyone else, and they feel betrayed.&equo; 
 Dealers and artists complain now, but it should be remembered that they were happy to sell to Saatchi in the first place, and doubtless reaped the benefit of having placed work by their artists in such a prestigious collection in terms of increased prices. 
 In many cases, one suspects that dealers are simply jealous of Gagosian for getting Saatchi's business, but in others there do seem to be justifiable grievances. 
 In at least one case, an artist has requested the option to buy back his own work, only for his letter to go unanswered; Saatchi is known to have split up one series of paintings which were sold to him on the strength of verbal assurances that they would stay together. 
 Several major galleries now claim that they have ceased trading with Saatchi - &bquo;I wouldn't sell him a napkin,&equo; said one prominent figure in the New York art world &mdash; but since no one is prepared to go on the record with such an assertion, or to have their name directly linked to a quote, it is hard to avoid the conclusion that dealers and artists are hedging their bets. 
 Nevertheless, the fact that Saatchi has been prepared to offend so many dealers and artists does seem to have seriously damaged his credibility in the art world. 
 The four volumes of Art of our Time, it can fairly be said, no longer represent the Saatchi Collection, now that so many of its glossy pages reproduce what have become absences. 
 Given the most cynical interpretation, although one that seems to be surprisingly widely held in New York, &bquo;those four beautiful books have become the most glamorous mail order catalogue in history.&equo; 
 There are some grounds for optimism about the future of the Saatchi collection. 
 Saatchi is known to have purchased five major Warhols in the last six months, for extremely high prices, which few would argue is the action of someone dispersing their collection. 
 A source close to Saatchi insists that there is &bquo;absolutely no intention of dispersing the collection&equo; and is equally adamant that &bquo;the collection will be greater in five or 10 years time than it is now.&equo; 
 It is to be hoped that is so. 
 The Conservative Conference: Tory generals underestimate the old enemy: As the final party conference of the year ends, Colin Hughes evaluates the positions of the parties 
 By COLIN HUGHES 
 TWO FEATURES dominate the post-conference political landscape. 
 The first is that both Labour and the Conservatives emerge more or less united &mdash; the former striking an attacking pose in the foreground, the latter stoutly closing defensive ranks behind. 
 The second is that, electorally, the Democrats, Greens and SDP look like distant follies on a faraway hill. 
 It is hard to escape the view that this scene will remain, in essence, unchanged. 
 This is the mid-term moment when rivals turn their banners towards the general election battlefield and start marching. 
 It is clear that there are only two armies. 
 An ICM poll in The Guardian this week showed Labour and the Tories picking up three percentage points, while the smaller parties fell yet further behind. 
 At Brighton a month ago we watched Paddy Ashdown keep a tight enough grip on his party to ensure that it does not slip away into the political undergrowth. 
 But he had to reformulate its strategy on the run. 
 The idea that the SLD exists to replace Labour carries little conviction, and so he had to bow to those of his followers who advocate an outright anti-Thatcher stance. 
 In Wolverhampton we learned that the Green Party, it seems, has no strategy. 
 It had one for last June's European elections, but few prominent Greens have any clear idea of where they go now. 
 But the party did have the sense to remove the figures from a policy commitment to halve the UK population. 
 There is no way of knowing, yet, whether the Greens at the next election will be playing Pan pipes in the background, or piping briskly into the fray. 
 The SDP, by contrast, has a fully-formed and firmly articulated strategy. 
 It must seek every conceivable way of persuading the next government to introduce proportional representation &mdash; for without PR, the SDP is dead. 
 It is the untainted success of Labour at Brighton which dominates the view of the conference season. 
 Brighton 1989 was the most smoothly achieving conference Labour has held since 1963, and probably since the 1940s. 
 The one point rise in base rates on the Thursday added an unexpected garland to Neil Kinnock's design. 
 But even without that gift from the political gods, Labour would have ended its conference in confident composure. 
 In retrospect, Labour's leadership team miscalculated: they could have wrung more from a week when the party was so eagerly compliant. 
 In Blackpool the strongest feeling among representatives has been one of relief that the party sang in harmony under stress. 
 But the Tory anthem is loyalty, not joy. 
 The most striking aspect of the past week is the degree to which the Government is underestimating Labour's post-conference political strength. 
 Among Tory MPs there is calm trepidation. 
 Among ministers the mood seems unbelievably complacent. 
 The Tory calculation is that Labour's unity is a facade which will crack the moment it is exposed to stormy assault. 
 Elements of Labour's new programme are vulnerable: nuclear defence, trade unions and industrial relations law. 
 But these are not fatal flaws. 
 Labour has not only neutralised most of those policy areas which make it unpopular; more importantly, it has virtually erased the opportunity for Tories to accuse Labour of being run by the &bquo;loony left&equo;. 
 Ask ministers privately what they perceive as Labour's terminal weakness, and they will reply: Neil Kinnock. 
 They cannot imagine him as a Prime Minister, and they cannot imagine that the British public can be persuaded to elect him to that post. 
 They forget that many people once felt that way about Margaret Thatcher. 
 Conservatives are foolishly lulling themselves with their own rhetoric if they think that the reformed Labour Party is an image-makers' fantasy. 
 The change will not endure another election defeat; if Labour loses next time the party will probably tear apart. 
 But it will survive right up to polling day &mdash; and, if Labour wins, far beyond. 
 The transformation of Labour is not an invention of Peter Mandelson; it has been delivered by Mr Kinnock himself. 
 If Mr Kinnock can lead his party this far, it seems at least possible that he can now turn himself outward, away from the party, and begin to project himself as a potential national leader. 
 The central point is that he and his advisers recognise that this is now the main task. 
 Mr Kinnock is uninterested in finding a visionary &bquo;big idea&equo; for the party; he is convinced that Labour's values remain popular. 
 The real problem is to persuade the people that there is a big Neil Kinnock. 
 Chris Patten has drawn some of the venom from the poll tax this week, but not all: it will still bite individual losers hard. 
 Privatisation of electricity and water will not be easy in a tightened economic climate. 
 Health reforms have yet to travel through the system. 
 And even if Nigel Lawson contains inflation and brings interest rates down over the next year, Labour will be able to remind voters &bquo;Don't forget&equo;. 
 And on the ideological plane, the Conservative Party itself is having to revise its own &bquo;big idea&equo;. 
 Unbridled market competition is plainly not going to be the prevalent 1990s tone: but the Conservative Party only this week began its reversion to a faith in conservative stewardship, as opposed to laissez faire liberalism. 
 Margaret Thatcher has allowed her ministers &mdash; notably Mr Patten &mdash; to speak of intervention and regulation again. 
 She has witnessed the party applaud. 
 But she is not yet using the same language herself. 
 On what, then, does Tory optimism continue to rest? 
 Very simply, on a 102-seat majority. 
 Any Conservative you care to converse with will predict a close contest at the next election. 
 But, they will assure you, there are just too many seats that Labour has to win, in all the wrong parts of the country. 
 The one factor that still tilts general election predictions in the Tories' favour is that their hillcrest position seems ultimately impregnable. 
 They think they will stay on top with a 20 to 30-seat lead. 
 The Conservative Conference: Conference quotes 
 By COLIN HUGHES 
 &bquo;To win the next General Election, we must stop being so darned nice.&equo; 
 - Elizabeth Rex, chairman of the Harwich Conservative Association &bquo;You only have to look at the way we have annoyed the Establishment and the professions to gauge the success of our populist policies.&equo; 
 &mdash; Tim Loughton, of Battersea &bquo;Now my name's Binge and I like a party, but these parties are something else again.&equo; 
 &mdash; Brenda Binge of Burnley calling for a ban on acid house parties &bquo;I went to Oxford University, but I've never let it hold me back.&equo; 
 - Margaret Thatcher &bquo;I would ask you to reserve any demonstration of support and affection which I know we all have for her until the end of her address.&equo; 
 &mdash; Viscount Whitelaw, introducing the Prime Minister &bquo;What happened in Russia in 1917 wasn't a revolution. 
 It was a coup d'etat.&equo; -Margaret Thatcher &bquo;As for the leaders of the former Alliance parties, I will say no more than this: they have never learned what every woman knows &mdash; that you can't make a souffle rise twice.&equo; 
 &mdash; Margaret Thatcher &bquo;Although it is uncomfortable, the note which is being sounded is not bad; it is one of being prepared to take occasionally rough and unpopular decisions in the belief that they will work through successfully.&equo; 
 &mdash; Douglas Hurd, Home Secretary 
 The Conservative Conference: Calls to legalise drugs scorned 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN 
 INTELLECTUALS calling for legalisation of drugs ought to know better, Peter Lloyd, Under-Secretary at the Home Office, told the conference yesterday. 
 It would be &bquo;an unmitigated disaster&equo; and a course the Government would never follow. 
 Replying to an emergency debate on drug abuse, Mr Lloyd echoed the view of one Tory that &bquo;people who are soft on drugs are soft in the head&equo;. 
 &bquo;What do they look for?&equo; 
 Mr Lloyd asked. 
 &bquo;Boots and Sainsburys selling heroin and cocaine in neat little packets with helpful little leaflets saying it may be lethal to exceed the stated dose?&equo; 
 No respectable retailer would dream of stocking any such products, he said. 
 Supply would remain in the hands of crooks who would continue to push, but with total impunity, not just to their existing customers but as hard as they could to new ones as well. 
 &bquo;If we have learned anything from the last few years, it is that availability is the main occasion and the trigger for experimentation among the young.&equo; 
 Mocking supporters of legalisation writing in &bquo;sophisticated newspapers&equo;, the minister said perhaps they believed that suppliers, unmolested by the police, would, &bquo;as an act of Christian charity&equo; reduce their prices so their customers did not have to steal and prostitute themselves. 
 &bquo;Of course the traffickers would do no such thing. 
 They will continue to charge as much as that market will bear. 
 It will just be a very much larger market, that's all.&equo; 
 The debate also brought demands for the Government to ban &bquo;acid house&equo; parties. 
 Ronald Clements, South Leicester, suggested the &bquo;thugs posing as security guards&equo; were the pushers at parties where drugs were portrayed as harmless amusement. 
 &bquo;These awful events create a drug culture which can never be a part of our culture, and they must be stopped,&equo; Mr Clements said. 
 The Conservative Conference: Activists attack lack of Central Office support 
 By JUDY JONES 
 THE TORY hierarchy was urged by the rank-and-file yesterday to &bquo;get off its butt&equo; and give more practical support to constituency activists in the run-up to the next general election. 
 During a debate on party organisation, some representatives complained that Conservative Central Office was not providing Tory workers with the necessary back-up to sustain and win support at the grass roots. 
 Tim Loughton, of Battersea, accused the party headquarters of running &bquo;a shambolic campaign&equo; at the European elections in June. 
 The Tories were heading for disaster if they continued to delude themselves that only a little fine tuning of presentation was required to secure a fourth consecutive general election victory. 
 &bquo;It is not enough for blue-suited ministers to rush for cover into the ivory towers of Whitehall every time a controversy blows up. 
 How much better it would be for ministers to be seen in the constituencies giving us the ammunition we need to fight on the doorsteps.&equo; 
 He urged Kenneth Baker, the Tory Party chairman, to &bquo;get Central Office off its butt, and put the Government back on the beat&equo;. 
 Elizabeth Rex, of Harwich, raised the Tories' much-criticised European elections poster whose message read: &bquo;Stay at home on June 15 and you'll live on a diet of Brussels.&equo; 
 She said: &bquo;We must have pithy, punchy posters which make their point in one, and no more daft adverts like that diet of Brussels rubbish.&equo; 
 The party could not rely on the achievements of the past decade to win the next election. 
 &bquo;Voters will look for continued improvement in the quality of life and we must show exactly how Tory policies will provide it.&equo; 
 Andrew Tinney, chairman of the Young Conservatives, pointed out that in the 18-24 age group. 
 the Tories trailed Labour in opinion polls by 37 per cent. 
 &bquo;We have sown the seeds, but we have failed to reap the harvest. 
 If we are going to win, and win again, we must be as vigorous in promoting our cause as the Labour Party.&equo; 
 Simon Lee, of Stratford-upon-Avon, said that although the party machine was &bquo;getting a little bit tired&equo;, every member should accept their share of the blame for recent dents to the party image. 
 But dozens of representatives shouted &bquo;Yes&equo; when he recalled the European election campaign and asked them: &bquo;Can any of us say in all honesty that we did everything we could?&equo; 
 Much of the blame for their slide in popularity could be attributed to &bquo;Cabinet ministers arguing over their official residences, and backbench Tory MPs taking an independent line to further their own political careers&equo;. 
 Replying to the debate, Mr Baker said the task for Conservative Associations in 1990 was to recruit 10,000 extra committed supporters. 
 He also urged them to remember Tory supporters living overseas at the next election. 
 &bquo;There could be as many as 4-5,000 in some seats. 
 Their votes could make all the difference.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Labour takes lead in council by-elections 
 By PETER KELLNER 
 LABOUR achieved a clear lead over the Conservatives in local council by-elections held during the conference season, according to an analysis by The Independent. 
 The Social and Liberal Democrats also performed well &mdash; in contrast to their poor opinion poll showing. 
 Where they fielded candidates they won 25 per cent support on average. 
 Green candidates won 7 per cent where they stood. 
 Altogether 70 by-elections have been held since 7 September. 
 The Conservatives won 20 (gained 6, lost 9); Labour won 29 (gained 10, lost 4); the SLD won 17 (gained 6, lost 5); the SDP lost both seats it previously held; independents won 4 (gained 3, lost 5). 
 There is nothing new about the centre doing better in by-elections than polls, but the difference is now particularly marked. 
 One indicator of the SLD's campaigning strength lies in its performance compared with that of the Greens. 
 Candidates from the two parties fought each other in 11 seats. 
 In nine the SLD scored the higher number of votes, while in two the Greens did better. 
 Overall, SLD candidates outscored Greens in head-to-head contests by almost four-to-one. 
 David Owen's SDP made little impact on council elections during the conference season. 
 It fielded four candidates who averaged just under 10 per cent where they stood. 
 The Conservative Conference: Hats flop deafeningly into leadership ring 
 By JOHN PIENAAR, Political Correspondent 
 RITUALISTIC as it was, the Tory grass-roots' orgiastic display of support for their leader came from the heart yesterday. 
 If it were up to the faithful in Blackpool, Margaret Thatcher would go &bquo;on and on&equo;. 
 But all the stamping and cheering in the Empress ballroom might almost have been a vain attempt to muffle the sound of hats flopping intermittently into the leadership ring. 
 This week arguably saw the first real skirmishes of that impending struggle for succession: the sub-text of set-piece deliveries by Sir Geoffrey Howe, Kenneth Baker, Michael Heseltine et al. 
 To some around the Winter Gardens, it was all an unwanted distraction from the &bquo;real business&equo; of rallying the party to deal with a wayward economy and an Opposition united as never before. 
 But the sound of leadership campaigning had been clearly audible even to the doughtiest Thatcher-devotees, and most were prepared, if pressed, to take sides. 
 &bquo;We are not looking for a leader,&equo; Douglas Wilson from Burton said. 
 &bquo;As far as the grassroots are concerned we have got one, and I hope we have her for a very long time.&equo; 
 His own preferred choice, rather untypically, was Norman Fowler, the Secretary of State for Employment, who had made a &bquo;resounding and superb&equo; conference speech. 
 The local activists have no constitutional role in choosing their leader, a task alloted exclusively to Conservative MPs. 
 But they were as aware as anyone of the variables of timing and electoral fortune which could dictate the succession or lead Tory MPs to &bquo;skip a generation&equo; and look to such figures as John Major and Chris Patten. 
 And although the names of all the contenders could be heard, high-profile politicking appeared to have paid off particularly in the cases of Kenneth Baker and Michael Heseltine, who were cited frequently as the &bquo;obvious&equo; front-runners. 
 To Victoria Roberts, a young full-time party worker from London, they were the only two in serious contention and she was backing Mr Heseltine: &bquo;Mrs Thatcher is a strong leader, and we will need a moderate Tory who will be equally strong &mdash; there goes my career.&equo; 
 Charles Barwell, a Manchester University student, was rather more effusive: &bquo;It is difficult to choose between Baker and Heseltine. 
 &bquo;But Britain will need a world leader of fantastic proportions. 
 Mr Heseltine obviously has that potential.&equo; 
 In both camps, there was agreement that an orderly succession with the Conservatives faring well would tend to favour Mr Baker. 
 A narrow election victory, or a defeat, could spur a change of image and direction to the advantage of Mr Heseltine. 
 Some Baker supporters, and those backing John Major, Tom King and Michael Portillo, a long-term, right-wing long shot, dismissed Mr Heseltine's claim with equal vigour. 
 Time and again, his resignation during the Westland affair was held against him. 
 &bquo;I don't want a leader of the country who walks out on the job when things are not going as he wants. 
 I would go for Ken Baker.&equo; 
 So would Mary Freeman from Oxford East, who was deeply sceptical of Mr Heseltine's efforts to cultivate grass roots support. 
 &bquo;Where he used to cut them dead, he now helps them on with their coats.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't believe this is a Thatcherite party. 
 I belong to the Conservative party,&equo; said Sandra Gilfillan from Newcastle upon Tyne. 
 &bquo;Are we going to be called Bakerites?.&equo; 
 The Conservative Conference: Thatcher lays claim to torch of freedom: Vision of Eastern Europe inspired by Tory &bquo;turning point in history&equo; stirs outburst of wild adulation 
 By STEPHEN GOODWIN and JUDY JONES 
 MARGARET THATCHER yesterday portrayed her Conservative government as the pioneers of a world revolution, sweeping socialism from Britain and now inspiring the people of Eastern Europe to throw off their chains. 
 &bquo;The messages on our banners in 1979 &mdash; freedom, opportunity, family, enterprise, ownership &mdash; are now inscribed on the banners in Leipzig, Warsaw, Budapest and even Moscow,&equo; she told the enraptured Tory faithful at the close of the Blackpool conference. 
 But the Prime Minister also sought to reject the charge of having created a selfish society. 
 &bquo;For every Pharisee our system produces, you will find at least three good Samaritans,&equo; she said in a direct response to criticism by Dr Robert Runcie, the Archbishop of Canterbury. 
 She pledged never to privatise the National Health Service, reaffirmed the party's commitment to protect pensions against inflation and her intention to take a lead on world environmental problems. 
 On interest rates, Mrs Thatcher repeated the stern message of the Chancellor of the Exchequer to the conference on Wednesday. 
 &bquo;I know what a worry high interest rates are for families with mortgages and for those involved in farming and small businesses,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;But when the choice is between high rates now or persistent higher inflation later, with all the damage that would do, the choice is clear. 
 Inflation will come down through the use of high interest rates, as it has in the past. 
 And so it must, for the rest of the world isn't standing still.&equo; 
 Nor should industry expect &bquo;to find refuge in a perpetually depreciating currency&equo;, Mrs Thatcher said, underlining Nigel Lawson's opposition to devaluation of the pound. 
 Only by steadily improving efficiency would Britain win and keep its share of the world's markets. 
 But she said Britain's economy was strong and would be stronger still when inflation was beaten. 
 Acknowledging that yesterday's inflation figure of 7.6 per cent was &bquo;far too high&equo; for a Conservative government, she promised it would be brought down again. 
 She told representatives the new inflation figure was the one used for the pension increase next April. 
 Therefore the single pension would go up by &pound;3.30 and that for married couples by &pound;5.30. 
 A full two hours before Mrs Thatcher delivered her address, Tory representatives had occupied every seat in the Empress Ballroom and were reserving standing places. 
 At its close, they cheered for 13 minutes, stamping, waving flags, chanting &bquo;10 more years&equo; and singing &bquo;Happy Birthday&equo;. 
 It was the Prime Minister's 64th. 
 As she repeatedly pointed to the backdrop slogan, &bquo;The Right Team for Britain's Future&equo;, Viscount Whitelaw, the former deputy prime minister, tried to bring the adulation to close by bellowing &bquo;No more, no more&equo; and ringing the chairman's bell. 
 Describing 1989 as &bquo;a fantastic year for freedom&equo;, Mrs Thatcher said 1979 had been a turning point in history and Conservatives were the pathfinders. 
 &bquo;We did not know it at the time but the torch we lit in Britain, which transformed our country &mdash; the torch of freedom that is now the symbol of our party &mdash; became a beacon that has shed its light across the Iron Curtain into the East. 
 Today that beacon shines more strongly than at any time this century. 
 You can see it reflected in the faces of the young people from the Communist countries who have reached the West.&equo; 
 Mrs Thatcher said no one could know the direction in which free nations would progress. 
 But she went on: &bquo;This we do know &mdash; and dare not forget. 
 Only those whose commitment to free enterprise and opportunity is a matter of conviction, not convenience, have the necessary strength to sustain them. 
 Only those who have shown the resolve to defend the freedom of the West can be trusted to safeguard it in the challenging, turbulent and unpredictable times that lie ahead.&equo; 
 Labour at Brighton last week had shown itself a party of disposable ideals and throwaway conviction. 
 She did not believe Labour was now the party of home ownership, strong defence and financial rectitude: &bquo;If it's that easy for the Labour leader to give up the principles in which he does believe, won't it be even easier for him to give up the principles in which he does not believe? 
 &bquo;The truth is nothing has really changed. 
 Labour just wanted power at any price and they'll say anything to get it. 
 Labour's real prescription for Britain is the disease half the world is struggling to cure.&equo; 
 Socialism was a secular creed which had utterly failed, she said, citing the migration of East Germans and the dismantling of Communism in Poland and Hungary. 
 &bquo;What happened in Russia in 1917 wasn't a revolution. 
 It was a coup d'etat. 
 The true revolution is what is happening in Russia and Eastern Europe today. 
 In 1979, we knew that we were starting a British revolution; in fact, we were the pioneers of a world revolution.&equo; 
 Countering those who painted wealth as selfishness, she said only by creating wealth could poverty be relieved. 
 It was what one did with wealth that counted, and in the last 10 years voluntary giving had doubled. 
 The Prime Minister praised Nigel Lawson and Sir Geoffrey Howe as the two finest Chancellors of the Exchequer since the war. 
 &bquo;Their achievements have enabled us to provide more resources where they were needed &mdash; for schools, hospitals, pensioners and disabled people.&equo; 
 But money could not achieve everything. 
 People had to be given the chance to exercise choice over schooling, hospital treatment, and housing. 
 &bquo;What could be more democratic than to give people a direct say in these things? 
 What could be more arrogant than to deny it to them?&equo; 
 Mrs Thatcher was at pains to emphasise the Government's commitment to the National Health Service. 
 &bquo;In every year since I became Prime Minister, more money has been spent on the health service. 
 In every year, more doctors and nurses have been recruited and more patients treated. 
 These are the actions of a Government determined to make the health service one of the best in the world. 
 &bquo;The NHS will not be privatised. 
 No matter what the emergency, accident or disease, no matter how long or complicated the treatment&hellip; the health service will always be there, to provide the finest care.&equo; 
 In education, the Tories had erected ladders for children to climb. 
 But there remained too many blocks to opportunity after schooling, and prejudice about the age at which people could begin a new career. 
 &bquo;I started being a prime minister at the age of 53. 
 I had never been a prime minister before. 
 But I adapted to the work. 
 I did my best. 
 And my employers have twice asked me to stay on.&equo; 
 She went on to emphasise the growing need to tackle environmental problems: &bquo;It is no good proposing that we go back to some simple village life and halve our population by some means that have not yet been revealed. 
 &bquo;It is prosperity which creates the technology that can keep the earth healthy.&equo; 
 People had been awe-struck by the pictures sent back to earth by Voyager 2 of arid lifeless planets and moons. 
 &bquo;They were a solemn reminder that our planet has the unique privilege of life. 
 How much more that makes us aware of our duty to safeguard the world. 
 The more we master our environment, we more we must learn to serve it.&equo; 
 On defence Mrs Thatcher said: &bquo;Times of great change are also times of uncertainty and even danger. 
 The lesson is that you must always keep your defences strong so that you are prepared for any situation. 
 Some of us remember all too well what happened in the 1920s and 1930s when we allowed our hopes for a peaceful world to outrun our judgements on the need for defence. 
 The world paid a terrible price.&equo; 
 President Gorbachev well understood the need for weapons reduction by negotiation, without jeopardising common security. 
 &bquo;From our very first meeting he has always told me that he would never do anything to put the Soviet Union's security in danger &mdash; and he knows that I would never endanger our security. 
 Nor would the Government I lead. 
 Labour, however, would endanger Britain's security. 
 &bquo;Labour's supposed conversion to multilateralism is no more than a confidence trick to try to make Labour electable. 
 You don't reach Downing Street by pretending you've travelled the road to Damascus when you haven't even left home.&equo; 
 Informers recruited to prevent bombings: Mark Urban analyses the intelligence war against the IRA in Europe 
 By MARK URBAN 
 INTELLIGENCE documents obtained by An Phoblacht, newspaper of the Provisional Sinn Fein, and said to describe British attempts to recruit informers on the Continent, mark a new stage in the overseas war between the IRA and the Army. 
 It began with the bombing of eight barracks in West Germany in 1978. 
 More bombs were used the following year, and it was this, according to MI5 documents obtained by the IRA, that prompted efforts to recruit informants among Irish people in Europe. 
 The Provisionals realised that the Army's poorly-protected barracks were easier targets than fortified bases in Northern Ireland. 
 It was normal for sentries to be given no bullets. 
 This changed in 1980 after a major died in one of two shooting attacks against soldiers. 
 The Army ordered sentries to wear flak jackets and constructed many sandbagged emplacements, although most barracks were still protected by little more than chain link fences. 
 The IRA did not choose to attack again until March 1987. 
 A possible reason is that it was difficult to get arms and ammunition to the right place, despite the virtual absence of border controls between Germany and its western neighbours. 
 Communication with an &bquo;active service unit&equo; &mdash; two to 10 terrorists &mdash; far from Ireland was a further obstacle. 
 Another reason could be that the IRA had become aware of British intelligence's drive for informers. 
 It appears that starting in 1979, the Intelligence and Security Group (G), an Army Intelligence Corps unit based at Rheindalen, West Germany, had recruited five informants within the Irish community. 
 These informants were turned over to British intelligence in 1981 under an operation code-named Ward. 
 Both Britain's Security Service, MI5, and the Secret Intelligence Service or MI6, appear to have been involved. 
 The number of sympathisers able to support IRA operations on the Continent is smaller than in Northern Ireland, so the recruitment of a few informers may have had a disproportionate effect. 
 There has been no official confirmation that the documents are genuine, although sources suggest that they are. 
 This raises a question of how long the IRA have had them. 
 It can be speculated that the informants recruited in Operation Ward may have been known to the IRA for months or even years. 
 The IRA says the more recent of the documents is dated 26 January 1984. 
 Indeed, it may be that the collapse of the MI5/MI6 informer network in Germany and other European countries restored the IRA's confidence in its ability to resume operations on the Continent from March 1987, when it placed a car bomb at Rheindalen. 
 The IRA's campaign broadened in March 1988 with the attempt to plant a bomb in Gibraltar. 
 The attack was foiled and three terrorists killed in a joint MI5/SAS operation. 
 It is likely that this group was betrayed by an informer. 
 Two months later the IRA launched a bomb and shooting attack on RAF servicemen in the Netherlands, killing three. 
 In July last year a German border guard apprehended two Irishmen with Kalashnikov assault rifles. 
 Attacks have continued every few months since then. 
 Last month a soldier's wife was shot dead near Dortmund. 
 It appears that about 20 IRA members, organised into several units, are operating on mainland Britain and the Continent. 
 In July, Europe's counter-intelligence agencies scored a coup with the apprehension of five IRA members. 
 Leonard Hardy and Donna Maguire were arrested in the Republic of Ireland carrying bomb-making materials on a trip from France. 
 Five days later three terrorists were apprehended by the DST, French counter-intelligence, as they drove towards the German frontier. 
 Police said that their two accomplices arrested in Ireland had been carrying several addresses of safe houses in France. 
 It seems remarkable that the three who remained in France did not abandon their mission following the arrests in Ireland. 
 It may be that the IRA, fearing informers, had gone to such lengths to restrict the knowledge of where the &bquo;active service unit&equo; was that it was unable to warn them that their presence was compromised. 
 Spy network changes target: Security groups liaise on tactics 
 By MARK URBAN, Defence Correspondent 
 OVER THE past few years Britain and her European allies have been trying to adapt a system designed to catch Warsaw Pact spies to the task of hunting international terrorists. 
 Information on the IRA threat flows through a myriad of British and West German organisations &mdash; each with its own headquarters, staff and acronym. 
 Many organisations might be involved after an attack on British forces. 
 The illustration above however, shows only those bodies involved in combating the IRA threat in West Germany. 
 The attacks which took place in Belgium and The Netherlands involve still more organisations. 
 The British Army of the Rhine and Royal Air Force Germany have their Joint HQ at Rheindalen in West Germany. 
 Each organisation has its own intelligence and counter-intelligence units. 
 There is also a unit of Ministry of Defence civilian intelligence specialists called the British Services Security Organisation (Germany) or BSSO. 
 One of BSSO's major functions is to liaise with the Security Service (MI5), which is particularly active in trying to stop IRA terrorism on the Continent and in mainland Britain. 
 BSSO is also the liaison point with the West German equivalent of MI5, called Bundesamt fur Verfassungsschutz &mdash; the State Office for the Protection of the Constitution or BfV. 
 However, it appears that in sensitive operations where the military does not have a &bquo;need to know&equo; MI5 and BfV's Section 7, which is active against terrorist groups, have their own direct channels of communication. 
 BSSO's director, heads of Army and RAF intelligence, the chief British military policeman in Germany and MI6's chief of Bonn Station sit on the Joint Intelligence Committee (Germany). 
 JIC(G) meets occasionally, is chaired by a senior diplomat from the British Embassy in Bonn, and leaves the daily work of assessing the IRA terrorist threat to a sub-committee, the Joint Security Group. 
 The Joint Security Group takes intelligence about possible forthcoming terrorist attacks &mdash; usually provided by MI5 or BfV &mdash; and puts Army and RAF units on to a higher state of alert. 
 When the intelligence experts feel the threat has receded, the state of alert of military units is reduced. 
 At provincial and city level there are also many ties between the Royal Military Police, other British units, and the local West German police. 
 The Bundeskriminalamt or BKA is supervising the hunt for the IRA units which have attacked British servicemen and their families in recent months. 
 BKA has wide-ranging powers to supervise local police operations. 
 Secrecy is exploited by terrorists 
 By MARK URBAN, Defence Correspondent 
 INTERNATIONAL terrorism has been able to exploit the natural competitiveness and secretiveness of Europe's counter-intelligence organisations. 
 Claims that the West German authorities have mishandled inquiries into the Lockerbie bombing have caused ill feeling between officials. 
 In recent years the British Government has attempted to extradite terrorist suspects from Belgium and The Netherlands after they had been discovered by British intelligence. 
 Britain has reacted angrily when it felt other European governments were not co-operating in these efforts. 
 Intelligence sources in West Germany say that efforts to stop the current wave of IRA attacks have not been hampered by rivalries and that different organisations have been co-operating well together. 
 Nevertheless, the large number of organisations involved and the fact that their activities are not centrally co-ordinated as in Northern Ireland, suggests that there may be scope for confusion or conflict between them. 
 In 1978 and 1979 a series of changes began in Northern Ireland which resulted eventually in the direction and co-ordination of intelligence gathering activities by the Royal Ulster Constabulary Special Branch. 
 Although the Army and MI5 still retain some independent intelligence gathering capabilities in the province, the system is now largely centralised and works well &mdash; the IRA itself has admitted that one of the reasons it has exported a growing proportion of its violence to the continent and mainland Britain is because it has become increasingly risky for them to operate on home territory. 
 But in the mid-1970s there was an acrimonious conflict between the different intelligence gathering agencies in the province. 
 Matters became so serious that in August 1979 Sir Maurice Oldfield, the former Chief of MI6 &mdash; and model for John Le Carre's fictional spy master George Smiley &mdash; was sent to Northern Ireland to cover the differences between MI6, MI5, Army intelligence and the RUC. 
 Sir Maurice reportedly decided to reduce MI6's role in Ireland, although it still conducted operations on the continent and against IRA gun runners in North America. 
 During the 1970s intelligence organisations were often reluctant to share information from their best informants. 
 A participant in discussions between intelligence organisations in Ulster during the 1970s said: &bquo;There was an element of &bquo;if you tell them everything, we haven't got a position have we?&equo; 
 In the intelligence business knowledge is power.&equo; 
 This reluctance to share information is alleged to have led to several disasters where information was not passed to the right people in time, and where one organisation arrested the informants of another by accident. 
 Extra complaints against detectives went undisclosed 
 By TERRY KIRBY, Crime Correspondent 
 AN ADDITIONAL series of allegations that Serious Crime Squad detectives in the West Midlands Police fabricated confessions were not disclosed to the public and the Police Complaints Authority for more than a year. 
 Inquiries by The Independent have confirmed that while West Midlands Police were publicly acknowledging the existence of four or five complaints against the squad, its internal investigations department knew of three more in which serious allegations had been made against detectives. 
 Between July 1988, when it is now known the department knew of at least seven cases, and August 1989, when Geoffrey Dear, the Chief Constable of the West Midlands, purged his CID department &mdash; moving 39 serving and former squad officers into administrative roles &mdash; at least two more men were convicted on the basis of disputed confession evidence. 
 Mr Dear has said he did not take earlier action because he was told there was no evidence to suggest a wider conspiracy. 
 It is not precisely clear when he knew of the extra cases. 
 It is one of the tasks of the inquiry by the West Yorkshire Police, supervised by the authority, to discover how many of the 754 arrests by the squad since January 1986 may have resulted in convictions from fabricated confessions. 
 Two trials that went ahead during late 1988 were of Hassan Khan and John Edwards. 
 They were convicted of armed robberies and sentenced to 15 years and 14 years respectively. 
 Both say they were convicted on the basis of fabricated confessions. 
 No attempt was made to withdraw the prosecutions. 
 Clare Short, Labour MP for Ladywood, who raised the issue in the Commons in January, said: &bquo;I think the West Midlands Police were trying to brush the matter under the carpet and it was only pressure from MPs and the media that made them do anything.&equo; 
 At the time, the force declined to name the five cases under investigation. 
 The authority knew of two where officers had been disciplined &mdash; the Paul Dandy and Clifford Jones cases &mdash; and one under investigation &mdash; the Brown case. 
 They knew of a fourth case, later confirmed to be that of Keith Parchment, and believed the fifth referred to the Brown case, which technically involved two separate trials. 
 The Independent has learnt that the complaints department knew of three more cases. 
 One involved a man called Raymond Fryer, whose name was shown up by tests on notes of an interview between a detective and Jones. 
 When interviewed by complaints department officers he made similar allegations about fabrication of admissions. 
 Earlier this week Fryer, while on home leave from prison, went missing, saying it was to draw attention to his case. 
 Fryer also alleged that a fellow prisoner, Ronnie Bolden, a car dealer, was claiming his alleged confession to two armed robberies was fabricated. 
 Bolden spent almost two years in custody before being cleared by a jury in June. 
 The third case involved Paul Fitzsimmons. 
 Charges against him were dropped in May 1988 after a meeting between the Crown Prosecution Service and the force complaints department, because his alleged confession had been given to an officer, Det Sgt James McManus, who was already under investigation in another case. 
 Because none of the men formally lodged complaints, the authority was not told of the three extra cases until after Mr Dear's purge. 
 A source close to the investigation said: &bquo;Although there was no obligation to notify the authority, one might have felt that under the circumstances they should have done.&equo; 
 All the files will be examined as part of the inquiry. 
 West Midlands Police and West Yorkshire Police yesterday declined to comment. 
 Judge attacks jury &bquo;lottery&equo; 
 By TERRY KIRBY, Crime Correspondent 
 SELECTING jurors is &bquo;a lottery within a lottery&equo; and can be unfair to the administration of justice, an Old Bailey judge said yesterday, as he fined a man &pound;100 for failing to turn up for jury service on the second day of a trial because it was &bquo;not his scene&equo;. 
 Vern Clarke, 19, a London Underground maintenance worker, caused the trial to be aborted, held up court proceedings for half a day and cost the taxpayer more than &pound;7,000. 
 After hearing that he meant no disrespect, but had not felt emotionally and intellectually up to trying the case, Judge Robert Lymbery accepted Clarke was partly a &bquo;victim of the system&equo;. 
 He said: &bquo;I think many people think the present system is really a lottery within a lottery to the prejudice of the Crown, defendants and justice alike. 
 &bquo;But so long as the system remains as it is, those who choose to disregard their obligations must realise they may face a fine.&equo; 
 Priest tells of foreign fundraising 
 By TERRY KIRBY, Crime Correspondent 
 PATRICK RYAN, the Irish Catholic priest sought by Britain on terrorist charges, said yesterday he had spent the 14 years since dropping out of active priesthood raising money from foreign embassies for the victims of the conflict in Northern Ireland. 
 He was speaking at a press conference in Dublin following the decision by the Irish Republic's Director of Public Prosecutions on Thursday not to bring a case under the 1976 Criminal Law Jurisdiction Act, allowing prosecutions in the Republic for offences allegedly committed in Britain. 
 Both the Republic and Belgium had earlier refused to extradite him to Britain. 
 Mr Ryan declined to name the embassies or the foreign countries he had approached or to specify what sums had been raised. 
 He refused to say whether these were Arab embassies and whether Libya was involved. 
 &bquo;I have visited many countries. 
 As to what particular countries, in what particular circumstances, I would prefer to let that sleep. 
 &bquo;I was approached by some of the victims of that situation (the Northern Ireland conflict) to help them in whatever way I could. 
 I approached the embassies of many countries for help.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;I was never engaged either in supplying or use of explosives or arms. 
 That was never part of my business or intention. 
 At no time did I supply money for arms.&equo; 
 Asked if he intended resuming his duties with the Pallotine order, the Catholic missionary body he joined in 1954, he said his position had not yet been clarified. 
 Eamon O'Neill, Mr Ryan's agent in the June European elections, chaired the meeting. 
 He turned down several questions concerning his past activities on the Continent, saying they could affect 16 current libel actions. 
 Key witnesses in Ryan case &bquo;refused to testify&equo; 
 By TERRY KIRBY, Crime Correspondent 
 THE DECISION of Eamonn Barnes, the Irish Republic's Director of Public Prosecutions, not to bring explosives charges against Patrick Ryan is believed to be due to the refusal of key witnesses to testify against him. 
 According to security sources in Dublin yesterday, the absence of two key witnesses had effectively determined Mr Barnes' decision not to press charges under the 1976 Criminal Law Jurisdiction Act, which allows for prosecution in the Republic for offences allegedly committed in Britain and Northern Ireland. 
 The two witnesses are said to be a retired Swiss shopkeeper who had business dealings with Mr Ryan in the early 1970s, and a British businessman who had dealings with Mr Ryan in Libya. 
 The first witness had decided at an early stage not to travel to Dublin; the second only recently made his decision not to give evidence. 
 The rest of the evidence against Mr Ryan is understood to be mainly circumstantial. 
 In a This Week interview screened by Thames Television in June, Mr Ryan, 59, admitted he was a republican sympathiser and that he had bought electronic equipment, which it is alleged found its way into IRA bombs. 
 He said: &bquo;I buy them the same as I buy anything else and pass them on. 
 It's none of my business &mdash; but I would stress that the IRA never requested that I buy any such items for them.&equo; 
 Mr Ryan also admitted buying hundreds of Swiss memopark timing devices in the 1970s. 
 The devices are designed for parking meters, but are also the main timers used in IRA bombs. 
 The programme alleged that an electronic device bought by Mr Ryan was found in bomb-making circuitry in an IRA arms cache discovered in Salcey Forest, on the Northamptonshire-Buckinghamshire border, in 1984. 
 Identical circuitry was used in the 1982 Hyde Park bomb which killed eight people and injured fifty-three others. 
 Untransmitted tapes of the interview with Mr Ryan were handed over by Thames to Scotland Yard under the Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act 1989. 
 Dublin sources claimed yesterday that following recent examination of the evidence submitted by the English authorities, the Garda and the DPP had major misgivings about parts of it relating to the alleged discovery of bomb-making materials and documents in Mr Ryan's Brussels apartment in July last year. 
 There were fears that statements made by Belgian security service officers would not stand up in court. 
 Neither Mr Barnes nor the UK's Director of Public Prosecutions, Allan Green QC, would confirm or deny the claims. 
 Last year the Republic refused to extradite Mr Ryan to Britain to face terrorism charges, including conspiracy to murder and cause explosions, on the grounds that allegations in the Press and Parliament linking him with the IRA meant he would not receive a fair trial in Britain. 
 The 1976 Act allows charges of possession and handling of explosives to be brought in the Republic, but not charges of conspiracy to cause murder or explosions. 
 Schools &bquo;will have to modify entrance exams&equo; 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 BRITAIN's independent schools will have to replace or modify the traditional Common Entrance examination if they are to follow the new national curriculum, a former independent head warns, writes Simon Midgley. 
 A confidential paper considered this week by the Independent Schools Curriculum Committee, which represents all the main independent school associations, suggests that the Common Entrance exam be replaced in preparatory schools with assessment tasks designed for 14-year-olds. 
 The author, Gavin Alexander, until recently head of Hampton School in Middlesex, for boys aged 11 to 18 years, says it might be better for 13-year-old pupils to be assessed in this way rather than sitting the Common Entrance and then being assessed again a year later. 
 The national curriculum involves assessing pupils at ages 7, 11, 14 and 16. 
 Although independent schools are not legally obliged to follow the new national curriculum, which involves the study of 10 subjects, most are likely to do so. 
 Their problem, however, is trying to reconcile national curriculum demands with their desire to offer a second modern language, three sciences and perhaps Latin and Greek. 
 Kurdish asylum seeker detained by police 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 A KURDISH asylum seeker forcibly returned to Turkey was detained yesterday for questioning by the political police, writes Nicholas Schoon. 
 Halil Guzel was taken into overnight custody by the regular police at Istanbul airport when he landed on Thursday. 
 The political police, the equivalent of Britain's Special Branch, detained him yesterday morning. 
 Last night there was no news about whether he had been released. 
 The United Nations High Commission for Refugees had called on the Home Office to reconsider Mr Guzel's removal on compassionate grounds. 
 It said another Kurdish refugee, Selahattin Ozberk, detained in Pentonville Prison, had good reason to fear ill treatment if he was returned to Turkey and should be granted refugee status. 
 The Home Office says he has until Tuesday evening to find another country to take him. 
 Two other Kurds in detention are expected to be sent back to Turkey over the weekend. 
 &bquo;Mappa&equo; plan 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 The Mappa Mundi will go on permanent exhibition at Hereford Cathedral next summer under a new rescue package, currently being negotiated, aimed at preserving the 14th century relic. 
 Brink's-Mat case 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 Three people charged in connection with an alleged plot to launder more than &pound;16m from the &pound;26m Brink's-Mat gold bullion raid six years ago were remanded in custody by magistrates at Horseferry Road Court, London. 
 A fourth person was freed on &pound;50,000 bail. 
 Party convictions 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 Robert Darby, 25, a youth leader known as The General, and Leslie Thomas, 26, were yesterday convicted at Southwark Crown Court of permitting premises to be used for the control and supply of drugs in relation to acid house parties. 
 Darby was remanded in custody for a week. 
 Thomas will be sentenced on Friday. 
 Five freed 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 Five Irishmen arrested in Cheltenham, Gloucestershire, on Thursday under anti-terrorism laws were released without charge. 
 Drink-drive ban 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 A motorist who was five times over the drink-drive limit, twice within 24 hours, was put on probation for two years, and banned from driving for three years by magistrates at Exeter. 
 Noel Birch, 37, was also ordered to spend 60 days on an alcohol education programme, and to take a driving test before reapplying for a licence. 
 Man accused 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 Wayne Shaw, 29, was remanded in custody for a week by magistrates at Eccles, Greater Manchester, charged with attempting to murder a motorist, kidnapping two others, and three armed robberies between 25 and 29 September. 
 Cannabis case 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 Four people will appear in court today charged with smuggling 1.6 tonnes of cannabis resin valued at &pound;4.8m after a yacht was boarded off Falmouth, Cornwall. 
 The four are: William Sullivan, 45, unemployed, from Romford, Essex; his daughter Jenni, 22, unemployed, of the same address; William Elliott, 48, a photographer, from Watford, Hertfordshire; and Pamela Frank, 36, from Pennsylvania, USA. 
 Two more UDR men charged 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 Edward Stewart, 32, and James William Edgar Neill, 46, both members of the Ulster Defence Regiment, were remanded in custody accused of firearms offences. 
 The two men were among 28 UDR soldiers arrested last weekend by detectives investigating the alleged leakage of security forces' information to Protestant paramilitary groups. 
 Six UDR men have now been charged. 
 Victim's view on sentence sought in sex case 
 By SIMON MIDGLEY 
 A JUDGE has put off sentencing a 26-year-old sex attacker in order to give the victim, a young mother, an opportunity to express her view on what the punishment should be. 
 Lord McCluskey's decision yesterday is believed to break new ground for a Scottish criminal court. 
 The judge described it as &bquo;a highly unusual circumstance&equo;. 
 But he said he was &bquo;very anxious indeed&equo; to discover &bquo;the feelings&equo; of the victim &bquo;in relation to the disposal of the accused's case&equo; if she were prepared to assist. 
 The case before the High Court in Edinburgh involves a violent assault on the 25-year-old woman in her home last June while her husband was at work. 
 Brian McKenzie, a single man, of Beachmont Court, Dunbar, East Lothian, admitted attempting to murder her and assaulting her with intent to rape. 
 An earlier court hearing was told that the woman awoke one morning to be confronted by McKenzie, who was naked apart from a pair of underpants on his head. 
 He held a knife to her throat, sexually assaulted her and dragged her outside to the garden where she was forced to perform obscene acts. 
 She was taken back into the house and made to fill a bath and to get into it. 
 McKenzie tried to push her head under water but she pulled out the plug. 
 She was forced to refill the bath and McKenzie again held her head under water. 
 He cut her throat, stabbed her in the stomach and tried to poke out her eyes with his fingers. 
 The floor was covered with blood. 
 Although weak, the woman fought back. 
 She bit him on his shoulder and grabbed his testicles. 
 Eventually, he calmed down and began to cry. 
 He ran from the house saying that he was going to commit suicide. 
 The woman, who will be scarred for life, was treated in hospital for a number of injuries including a 3in cut to her neck. 
 McKenzie, who has never been in trouble before, was described by people who knew him as a pleasant individual. 
 At the earlier hearing Lord McCluskey had asked for a report from a sex-problems clinic after inquiring about pornographic material &mdash; 65 magazines and 45 videos &mdash; listed as exhibits in the case. 
 But Graham Robertson, McKenzie's counsel, told the court yesterday that the report emphasised that his client came from a stable background in the west of Scotland and had felt lonely for the two years he had lived in Dunbar. 
 McKenzie had told him that he had not looked at the videos or magazines for some years before the assault and felt they played no part in his behaviour. 
 Psychiatrists had been unable to find anything of significance to explain his actions. 
 Lord McCluskey described the case as &bquo;highly unusual&equo;. 
 He felt he would be in &bquo;a better position to settle on the appropriate form of punishment&equo; if he knew the victim's feelings. 
 He added that it was entirely up to her whether she chose to assist. 
 There could be no hint of criticism on the part of the court if she felt she wanted nothing more to do with it. 
 He deferred sentence for two weeks. 
 His decision was described as &bquo;very innovative&equo; by Sue Moody, director of Victim Support Scotland. 
 She said: &bquo;This is not something that has happened before. 
 It's something that we regard as an interesting development. 
 We would wish to seek the views of our members on it.&equo; 
 Sheriff Gordon Nicholson, a leading authority on sentencing in Scottish courts, said: &bquo;I am not aware of any precedent in Scots law. 
 I believe this sort of thing does happen in the United States and some other countries where one of the pieces of information put before the judge at the stage of sentencing is a victim-impact statement.&equo; 
 Tests show nuns' hens &bquo;pose no health threat&equo; 
 By LIZ HUNT 
 TESTS carried out by the Ministry of Agriculture on the flock of 5,000 hens owned by nuns at Our Lady of the Passion Monastery in Northamptonshire, showed that there was no danger to public health, it was claimed yesterday. 
 Mr Alan Rawley QC, for Mother Catherine, 82, the Mother Superior of the monastery, said that evidence supplied by the Ministry yesterday morning revealed that salmonella typhimurium had been isolated from a &bquo;bulked up&equo; sample of the intestines of five of the chickens. 
 &bquo;An intestinal infection is of no significance whatsoever in the field of public health because such infection will not give rise to any problems to public health,&equo; he told Lord Justice Parker and Mr Tudor Evans during a judicial review of the Ministry's order to slaughter the chickens. 
 &bquo;If it is the intestine which is infected, the infection is transient and will not reach inside the egg,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Rawley told the court that he had received full details of the scientific tests carried out by the Ministry that morning. 
 His request for an adjournment to consider this evidence and to produce scientific evidence that supported the nuns' claim that the flock was not a threat to human health, was granted by the judges until Tuesday. 
 Later, Mother Catherine, who attended the hearing, accused the Ministry of &bquo;moving the goal posts&equo; of the case. 
 The nuns' request for a judicial review of the order to slaughter the flock had been based upon John Gummer, the Minister of Agriculture, &bquo;failing to comply with natural justice&equo;. 
 Until yesterday morning, the Ministry had not given the nuns any information on the tests they had made or what these had revealed. 
 The nuns, therefore, had no opportunity to determine whether the Ministry could have been wrong, she said. 
 Now that they had been presented with the information which they had requested all along, they had to prove that faecal contamination of the egg shell did not constitute any great risk to public health, Mother Catherine said. 
 Richard North, a local environmental health officer who has been advising the nuns, said that contamination of eggs through the shell via the faeces had never been considered a serious risk either by the working party who had submitted evidence to the Select Committee on Salmonella in Eggs, or by the Public Health Service Laboratories. 
 As a result there had been very few scientific studies which would make their case harder to win, he said. 
 &bquo;We will continue with the fight for as long as we can,&equo; Mother Catherine said. 
 The nuns believed themselves vindicated both morally and scientifically, she added. 
 &bquo;It is not for us because we are going out of this business. 
 It is for all the poor farmers. 
 I think someone else should have done it because it is not our vocation. 
 It just seems to have fallen to us &mdash; the Providence of God you know.&equo; 
 The United Kingdom Egg Producers' Association, which is meeting the legal costs of the nuns' case, was &bquo;pleased and surprised&equo; with the ruling that the nuns should be paid the full market price of &pound;1.42 each for the birds if they were slaughtered. 
 At present, compensation is paid on the assumption that all the flock is infected &mdash; 39p per bird &mdash; and not just the birds removed for testing. 
 The Ministry said that it would refrain from slaughtering the birds until the ruling on Tuesday. 
 Eggs are not being sold from the monastery at present. 
 Confusion over fate of Channel rail link 
 By MICHAEL HARRISON, Industrial Editor 
 CONFUSION reigned last night over the fate of the &pound;3.5bn Channel tunnel high-speed rail link and the route it will take through Kent to London. 
 It emerged yesterday that one of the two private consortia negotiating to build the line with British Rail had rejected BR's preferred route because it said it could cost up to &pound;5bn. 
 The high-speed line proposed by BR would end at new terminals at King's Cross and Waterloo in London. 
 It is in discussions with two consortia led by Trafalgar House and the shipping and property group P&amp;O. 
 However, environmental improvements demanded by ministers have increased the cost of this route three-fold to &pound;3.5bn. 
 The alternative route, proposed by a consortia led by the American bank Manufacturers Hanover and the construction group Bechtel, would end at a terminal in Stratford, East London. 
 It is claimed this route would cost &pound;1bn less than BR's. 
 It is understood, however, that P&amp;O has now concluded that the link should terminate at Stratford. 
 As an interim proposal it has suggested a new line be built through Kent overground to a new terminal at Swanley, close to the M25, and the upgrading of the existing Waterloo line. 
 Trafalgar House, BR's favoured partner, is reliably understood to have rejected the idea of building a terminal at Stratford and to be sticking to the final route chosen by BR. 
 It has submitted final proposals to ministers along with a range of options as to how the link might be built. 
 These include a government cash injection by way of loan stock, linked to an equity participation which would enable the Government to recoup some of its money if the line is a success. 
 Computer viruses cause little disruption 
 By MARY FAGAN, Technology Correspondent 
 THE PANIC world-wide over the Friday 13th computer viruses came as something of an anti-climax, with the Royal National Institute for the Blind emerging as the major casualty. 
 But experts warned computer users that Friday 13th viruses are only a tiny proportion of the 30 or so known types of virus which exist, and that they would be wise to keep taking precautions. 
 According to Owen Keane, a barrister and computer expert, one way to prevent infection is to avoid copying programs and games from friends or electronic bulletin boards, as the virus can spread through infected floppy dics. 
 Although there have been cases of viruses spreading on shrink-wrapped software, these are relatively rare. 
 One of the most notorious ways of spreading infection has been the computer game Leisure Suit Larry, which was widely pirated and became infected. 
 Pirated computer games are the most likely source of spreading infections, according to one expert. 
 Viruses can also spread if computers are linked by modems to the outside world. 
 But users who do not have modems and keep their data &bquo;hygienic&equo; by not borrowing software have little to fear, Mr Keane said. 
 The viruses often work by attacking a section of the disc known as the &bquo;boot&equo; section. 
 This block of data includes the index, and if the index is rendered useless then so is all the data on the hard disc. 
 It cannot be recalled in any coherent form. 
 The virus is activated when the computer program is &bquo;executed&equo; by running it on a computer. 
 It replicates itself, and each new copy, which is independent of the original, goes on to carry out the task for which the virus was designed. 
 Call for sacking of conservation convention chief 
 From NICK CATER in Lausanne 
 INTERNATIONAL conservation groups yesterday demanded the immediate sacking of Eugene Lapointe, the secretary-general of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species, amid mounting controversy over the conduct and funding of the CITES secretariat. 
 The 18 organisations &mdash; from the Africa Wildlife Foundation to the World Society for the Protection of Animals &mdash; claimed there was a crisis &bquo;threatening the effectiveness of CITES.&equo; 
 The convention meeting has been bitterly divided over proposals to ban all trade in ivory because of decline in elephant numbers from more than 1.2 million to 600,000 in the last decade. 
 Set up in 1975, CITES regulates trade by its 103-member nations in hundreds of rare and endangered species from orchids to orang utans. 
 Informed sources within CITES yesterday indicated that a number of allegations of corruption within the secretariat had been fully investigated by its standing committee without any evidence of wrongdoing being found. 
 It is, however, increasingly felt by members of CITES delegations and the many observer groups from the world of conservation that Lapointe's position is becoming untenable and he will be forced to resign &mdash; probably before the next CITES meeting, expected to be held in 1992. 
 The sacking demand by conservationists was contained in a letter to Dr Mustapha Tolba, the executive director of the United Nations Environment Programme, which is the supervising body for CITES. 
 The letter says: &bquo;Mr Lapointe and his staff have exceeded the responsibilities and mandate of the secretariat. 
 &bquo;The owners of the poached ivory stock piles have been able to achieve a virtual monopoly of the international ivory trade, which was used to force prices up by as much as 300 per cent in three years.&equo; 
 Demanding the &bquo;immediate dismissal &bquo;of Lapointe, the letter accuses the secretary-general of &bquo;a lack of leadership and judgement&equo;. 
 One senior delegate, who asked not to be identified, said yesterday: &bquo;The problem is Lapointe is supposed to be the servant of CITES, not its boss.&equo; 
 Commenting on the letter to Tolba, Mr Lapointe, who has previously insisted that his actions and those of his staff are entirely correct, would only say yesterday: &bquo;My comment is that I am fed up with all the garbage.&equo; 
 In the convention discussions yesterday, delegates remained deadlocked on how to protect the elephant and discussion will now continue through next week. 
 Income support rise &bquo;derisory&equo;: This week's rise takes many pensioners back to where they were 18 months ago, Sue Fieldman reports 
 By SUE FIELDMAN 
 INCOME support was increased this week for pensioners aged 75 and above, or 60 plus and disabled. 
 However, the increase of up to &pound;2.50 a week for a single person, and up to &pound;3.50 a week for a couple, is considered small by many involved with the elderly. 
 Furthermore, many pensioners who are struggling financially, do not qualify for income support. 
 Sally Greengross, director of Age Concern, said: &bquo;Age Concern remains very worried about the financial position of older pensioners, despite the October increases in income support and housing benefit for certain disabled pensioners and those aged 75 or over. 
 &bquo;Many of those who gain in October, will be the same people whose benefits were reduced 18 months previously. 
 The October increases have been estimated to help around 2,000,000 pensioner claimants, yet the Department of Social Security's estimates in 1987 showed 2,090,000 pensioners likely to have decreased benefit as a result of the 1988 structural reforms, with 710,000 of these losing &pound;3 a week or more,&equo; she said. 
 For many pensioners this week's increases will only bring them back to where they were 18 months ago, and some pensioners will still be worse off. 
 If you already get income support you do not need to claim the extra amount -the increase will be in your next order book. 
 However, if you think that you may now qualify, there is an explanatory leaflet NP1 which is available in post offices and from the DHSS. 
 Those who get income support, will usually also receive housing benefit. 
 If your income is a little higher, you can also qualify for housing benefit, but not income support. 
 From this week, housing benefit also goes up, although again the amounts are derisory. 
 Those who get housing benefit, but not income support, will find a single person's rent rebate goes up &pound;1.63 a week. 
 A home-owning pensioner over 75 who does not qualify for income support gets a mere 50p a week extra rate. 
 A couple who get housing benefit, but no income support, will from 9 October receive &pound;2.88 extra in rent rebate, and a 0.70p a week increase in rate rebate. 
 Twenty per cent of pensioners do not take up benefits that they are entitled to. 
 Even so, one in five pensioners rely entirely on state benefits for their income. 
 And for most pensioners, even those with supplementary pensions or savings, the state pension is their financial lifeline. 
 Pensioner's received a 5.9 per cent increase in the state pension last April. 
 &bquo;Had the increase in pensions been in line with inflation in the 12 months ending April 1989, a single person with the basic state pension would have received an additional &pound;44.20 and a couple another &pound;72.80 during the year,&equo; said Mrs Greengross. 
 &bquo;Of even greater importance is the need to restore the link between earnings and pensions. 
 Earnings have consistently risen at a higher rate than prices, widening the gulf between the incomes of working people with average wages, and those dependent on state benefits. 
 &bquo;Had the Government not broken the link in 1980, the basic state pension would now be &pound;9.70 a week higher for a single person, and &pound;15.45 higher for a couple. 
 &bquo;Age Concern believes it is essential, in order to maintain living standards after retirement, that at least one part of pensioner's income, the state pension, is raised in line with earnings. 
 Age Concern has written to Tony Newton, Secretary of State for Social Security, calling for state retirement pensions to be increased substantially so that the real value is maintained. 
 Mrs Greengross added: &bquo;Isn't it about time that the Government exercised some seasonal goodwill to all men &mdash; and women &mdash; of pensionable age and increased the &pound;10 Christmas bonus?&equo; 
 If the bonus had risen in line with prices since its introduction in 1972, it would have been worth &pound;48.85 last Christmas. 
 A lobbying letter to Mrs Thatcher on the subject may be timely. 
 After all, if this week's polls are anything to go by, she may be joining the ranks of Britain's retired pensioners in 1992. 
 TOM and Doreen Longhurst are pensioners. 
 They live in London. 
 Tom supplements their pension by working part-time, even though he is nearly 70. 
 &bquo;Pensioners are the forgotten people,&equo; said Tom. 
 &bquo;No one cares about pensioners, as they are no longer an earning commodity. 
 People's pets are better fed than some old age pensioners. 
 Pensioners who just have their state pensions are really suffering. 
 They are the people I worry about. 
 &bquo;My wife and I are not badly off as we have the state pension, my police pension, and a police civil staff pension. 
 I saved well for my retirement, but I find it swallowed up with increased living costs in London. 
 Pensioners should have a London allowance to cope with such increases,&equo; said Tom. 
 &bquo;Our income is a quarter of our previous police salary, and while pension increases remain practically static, inflation pushes up the cost of living beyond our reach. 
 One year, we were given an increase of 40p a week on our state pension. 
 I sent a letter to Mrs Thatcher saying if she was so hard up as only to pay us 40p, then she could have the money back.&equo; 
 Big City brokers turn their backs on small investors: Martin Baker reports on where private investors can go for advice and dealing services as shares falter 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 THE London stock market is down by about 8 per cent from this year's peak. 
 Share traders remained unimpressed by Nigel Lawson's rallying speech, and the consensus among analysts was that the FT-SE 100 index of shares would end the year lower than yesterday's close. 
 Some estimates put the close of year figure at 2,050 &mdash; 150 points lower than the worst of last week's pessimists. 
 The managers of the cheap share-dealing services, aimed at small investors, report that many of their clients are telephoning to sell. 
 Others are asking for advice and reassurance amid fears of recession and the advent of a full- scale bear market. 
 &bquo;They are certainly apprehensive,&equo; said a Barclayshare spokesman of the company's 19,000 clients. 
 The small investor might well feel cheated by the City because it has failed to provide the services necessary to buy and sell shares. 
 The Cheltenham &amp; Gloucester Building Society this month withdrew its cheap share-dealing service, which it could not make profitable. 
 The C&amp;G was preceded out of the market by stockbrokers Kleinwort Grieveson and Hoare Govett. 
 But not all the news is bad for small investors. 
 A new company, Raphael Zorn Helmsley, starts business with the small investor on Monday. 
 It offers a full discretionary management service &mdash; anything from PEPs, shares and gilts to traded options &mdash; for first-time investors with as little as &pound;10,000. 
 There is also a &bquo;no-frills&equo; dealing service with a minimum commission of &pound;30 &mdash; 1.65 per cent for the first &pound;10,000, and 0.5 per cent thereafter. 
 Stockbroker Malcolm Roberts of Fleming Asset Management will take on clients with &pound;150,000 to invest in shares. 
 He reports a significant increase in interest since private clients began to be deserted by some of the big City brokers. 
 Regional stockbrokers like Leeds-based Redmayne-Bentley have a low minimum of &pound;10,000 for their management service and report consistent interest in their portfolio management services. 
 The investor who has a few privatisation shares and wants to extend a portfolio without paying for advice does have a cheap alternative to discretionary portfolio management. 
 The banks and building societies, together with specialist execution-only services such as Sharelink and the Debenhams share shops, now offer a range of services to the would-be investor. 
 Sharelink has built up a clientele of about 57,000 in two years. 
 The commission structure is a significant improvement on pre-Big Bang charges at a minimum of &pound;16 and a rate of 1.25 per cent on the first &pound;2,500 of a transaction, falling to 0.75 per cent for the next &pound;2,500 and 0.2 per cent thereafter. 
 &bquo;Our services have been very well received by the public,&equo; says Sharelink chief executive David Jones. 
 Sharelink is considering an advisory service, but &bquo;will not compete with the full discretionary service offered by stockbrokers. 
 Anything Sharelink offers will be quick and clean, like the transaction service.&equo; 
 Unit trust managers Fidelity offer a good-value service for the slightly larger investor. 
 The Fidelity Share Service has a &pound;25 minimum commission with a &pound;50 maximum up to &pound;20,000. 
 The service becomes cheap after the &pound;4,000 level. 
 Not surprisingly, the 3,000 users of the service average &pound;8,000 when they deal. 
 This compares with an average transaction level of under &pound;1,900 at Sharelink. 
 The leading share service offered by the high street banks is Barclayshare, which offers both an execution-only facility and a portfolio management service. 
 The transaction service costs &pound;20 a year, charged in two instalments. 
 On top of this there is a charge for every transaction of a minimum &pound;16, with 1.25 per cent on the first &pound;5,000, 0.75 per cent on the next &pound;10,000, and 0.5 per cent applying thereafter subject to an overall maximum charge of &pound;250. 
 Barclayshare's advisory service, which has &pound;250m under management, has the same charging structure, but costs &pound;15 quarterly. 
 In both cases the customer is sent quarterly statements plus a monthly bulletin of market analysis and research. 
 There is now plenty of choice for the investor who knows what he or she wants to invest in, but there is still something of a vacuum for investors with less than &pound;50,000 which they want to put into shares directly. 
 Appeal of mortgages in foreign currencies: Malcolm Craig explains why only the financially sophisticated should take out these mortgages 
 By MALCOLM CRAIG 
 WITH UK mortgage interest rates heading towards 14.75 per cent, and the possibility of even higher rates in prospect as a result of the sterling crisis, borrowers can be forgiven for taking notice of the proliferation of newspaper advertisements extolling the virtues of foreign currency loans. 
 After all, if you can borrow (or exchange your existing UK mortgage where you are paying rates at the highest level in real terms for over a century) for a Swiss franc mortgage at around 9.5 per cent, a mark mortgage at just under 10 per cent, an Ecu mortgage (Ecu is the European currency unit which is made up of a &bquo;basket&equo; of 10 currencies including sterling) at about 10 per cent or a Japanese yen mortgage at just under 8 per cent, why not do so? 
 The saving on interest rate costs by taking out a foreign currency mortgage is obvious enough &mdash; about 5 per cent to 6 per cent. 
 The big pitfall is the prospect of a currency loss if sterling declines still further, which can wipe out the benefit of interest rate savings and leave the borrower owing more debt than he borrowed in the first place. 
 Because of this, foreign currency mortgages, which are being sold very heavily at the moment by financial intermediaries (linked to banks and other financial institutions which are providing the funds), are only for the financially sophisticated. 
 There are ways of hedging against the exchange rate risk. 
 One method is to switch the foreign currency loan back into sterling if you think that sterling will weaken significantly &mdash; more than a possibility. 
 This again is a strategy to be pursued only by those with considerable financial sophistication. 
 However, if you do take out a foreign currency loan, make certain that it is possible to switch back into sterling at least once, and at short notice without incurring heavy charges, otherwise you are very exposed. 
 Another is the use of currency &bquo;hedging insurance&equo; which is provided by the forward foreign exchange market or by the foreign exchange options market. 
 A few intermediaries offer this facility on a limited basis but forward foreign exchange markets and the currency futures options market are designed for big players and the smaller customer would neither be welcomed, nor would he, or she, easily know how to gain access to these markets. 
 The only real insurance, so far as foreign currency mortgages are concerned, is to cover the foreign currency mortgage with income in the same currency, and also secure the loan on the house in the same currency. 
 For example, someone buying a French property which is the security for a French franc mortgage, who obtains rental income in French francs to cover the cost of his borrowings can sleep reasonably easily at night. 
 Those who take out foreign currency mortgages secured on their UK (sterling based) properties are not likely to because of the exchange rate risk. 
 Similarly, if you take out a foreign currency mortgage where sterling is exchanged for foreign currency at the time of the purchase, and you subsequently want to repay the mortgage &mdash; you then have to pay over sterling to secure foreign currency with which to do so. 
 You can find yourself facing a much larger debt if the pound has weakened against that foreign currency in the interim. 
 Players in the market include a host of intermediaries. 
 The best known include John Charcol which has Kleinwort Benson, the merchant bank, as its loan provider, and P&amp;G Associates, part of the London &amp; Manchester Group, which offers Ecu loans. 
 London &amp; Capital, which is linked to UCB, the French-owned mortgage company, provides a comprehensive foreign currency mortgage service for UK and overseas properties. 
 Behind the intermediaries are British banks, and British and Scottish insurance companies. 
 Their rationale for entry to this flourishing new market is easy to understand. 
 With the UK housing market flat, and with competition high, business generated by foreign currency mortgages can generate a higher &bquo;turn&equo; for the lender than UK mortgages, and produce extra fees and commissions for the intermediary arranging the facility. 
 It is very much a case of caveat emptor. 
 Creche vs cash in the childcare debate 
 By MALCOLM CRAIG 
 WITH competition to recruit new employees likely to intensify as the shortage of school leavers grows, the issue of child care provision by employers becomes ever more important. 
 How much does it cost an employer to provide childcare facilities and what is the cheapest option? 
 According to employee benefit specialists, Mercer Fraser, the cost of providing a creche for 75 children would be &pound;590,966 in the first year with an ongoing cost of &pound;290,966 a year. 
 To provide the cash equivalent, (assuming an average of &pound;50 per child per week) would work out at &pound;215,377 a year. 
 But to provide Childcare Cheques would cost &pound;250,200 in the first year with on-going costs of &pound;206,200 a year. 
 At the end of five years the employer providing a creche will have paid &pound;2,154,830 while employers providing equivalent cash or childcare cheques will have paid half that at &pound;1,076,885 and &pound;1,077,000 respectively. 
 Cash figures are based on the employee receiving &pound;50 net of tax and national insurance. 
 &bquo;Cost, of course, is not the only criteria,&equo; commented Don Allen of Mercer Fraser who developed the Chidcare Cheque scheme in conjunction with the National Childminding Association. 
 &bquo;Quality of childcare and practicality are also important and although cash works out cheapest, it has a serious drawback in that the employer has no control over how the money is being used. 
 This is one reason why the DSS has never paid this subsidy to single parent families. 
 With both creches and Childcare Cheques the employer has a say in the quality of care provided.&equo; 
 Maximum exposure from a new PEP 
 By MALCOLM CRAIG 
 PERSONAL Equity Plans (PEPs) are rolling relentlessly onto the market. 
 Save &amp; Prosper launched a new plan on Thursday, MIM Britannia has a new plan available from next week, and the investment trust arm of Robert Fleming has recently unveiled a plan. 
 Until 31 December individual investors can run the last tax year's PEP maximum into this year's quota, and commit up to &pound;7,800 into shares and unit or investment trusts tax-free. 
 To offer the maximum exposure to tax-free collective investment, managers must be able to provide &bquo;old&equo; PEPs (ie have started PEPs in the tax year 1988-89) plus new PEPs which run in this tax year. 
 And if they offer the unit or investment trust options, they must also offer shares or you will not be able to invest the maximum amount. 
 The most interesting new PEP is a plan from Broker Financial Services, which guarantees the initial investment by investing part of the money outside the PEP in zero dividend preference shares in investment trusts. 
 These shares are redeemable for an increasing amount. 
 The danger to an investor would be if the investment trust's net asset value fell so much that it could not afford to meet its commitments to the zero dividend preference shareholders. 
 BFS claims this is highly unlikely. 
 For an investor who has selected a 1995 maturity date, BFS says the net asset value would have to fall by 5 per cent over the six years for the investment trust to be unable to pay up. 
 BFS is offering two standard maturity dates of 1995 and 1999. 
 Fund manager Tony Reid said: &bquo;Provided there's stock available we will match stock for the maturity dates the client wants. 
 Most dates up to 2000 can be covered.&equo; 
 BFS splits the &pound;4,800 PEP investment between capital shares in the M &amp; G Dual investment trust and a selection of blue chip shares. 
 Accident scheme 
 By MALCOLM CRAIG 
 MOTORISTS who are the innocent victims of accidents can now have more legal muscle to pursue uninsured losses with a low-cost legal fees scheme from DAS. 
 The scheme, which already covers more than a million motorists in the UK, can cost as little as &pound;6.50 a year. 
 Maximum cover is &pound;50,000 per insured incident. 
 The Ecology Building Society launches conservation bonds 
 By ANDREW BIBBY 
 BRITAIN'S youngest and most unusual building society, the Ecology, is hoping to raise &pound;250,000 from savers prepared to &bquo;invest in the alternative&equo;, and take out the society's fixed one-year conservation bonds. 
 From 1 November, the return on the bonds will be increased from 10.0 per cent payable at the end of the 12-month term to 11.5 per cent. 
 But only 11.0 per cent of the interest is paid to the investor: the remaining half per cent is donated to a conservation organisation of their choice. 
 &bquo;In the past, these bonds have usually been oversubscribed,&equo; says the Ecology general manager, Bob Lowman. 
 &bquo;People like to feel that they're doing something with their savings. 
 We've given money to organisations like the RSPB, Greenpeace, the Woodland Trust and Working Weekends on Organic Farms.&equo; 
 The Ecology Building Society was established in 1981 with just &pound;5,000, but has now seen its assets grow to almost &pound;4m. 
 Savings deposited in the society's conservation bonds, in its ordinary account (6.00 per cent interest) and 90 day account (8.5 per cent) are used to finance new mortgage business. 
 &bquo;We have lent over &pound;1m this year, above our target,&equo; Mr Lowman says. 
 In line with its principles, the Ecology chooses its business carefully. 
 Its rules restrict it to lending on property which encourages self-sufficiency, the ecologically efficient use of land and the saving of non-renewable resources. 
 In practice, this means that mortgage loans may be available for small-scale workshops, derelict but sound houses which would otherwise be abandoned, houses with energy-saving features and organic smallholdings. 
 The Ecology also lends on terraced houses and back-to-backs in city areas, particularly in the North. 
 &bquo;People think that ecology means a return to the countryside, cows and sheep and trees and that sort of thing, but the conservation of energy is just as important in the towns, and back-to-backs are by their nature more energy efficient,&equo; says Mr Lowman. 
 Borrowers pay 14.5 per cent interest, though it is due to rise to 15.5 per cent on 1 November. 
 Despite the premium rate, Mr Lowman claims that mortgage demand is still high at the moment. 
 The Ecology Building Society argues that it is recreating the original grass-roots feel of a membership-owned mutual society, and says that it involves its members closely in the development of new savings accounts. 
 New Amex cover for high-risk activities 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 AMERICAN Express has introduced an accidental injury insurance plan which covers cardmembers for high-risk sports excluded from most insurances. 
 It covers such activities as parachuting, mountaineering, hang-gliding, sub-aqua diving and motor racing. 
 &bquo;It's a simple case of supply and demand,&equo; said Bill West, general manager of cardmember financial services. 
 &bquo;Our research shows that Amex members generally lead active social lives, regardless of whether or not they spend their weekends risking life and limb and that there is a need for this sort of cover. 
 This is very much what we are about in developing financial services for our cardmembers which meet their particular requirements and provide added value.&equo; 
 The sports and leisure accident plan offer two levels of cover for injury during leisure time &mdash; standard or premium &mdash; with the option to include particularly hazardous sports and to provide cover for cardmembers' spouses. 
 The benefits include a lump sum payment for accidental injury up to &pound;50,000 for standard cover and &pound;100,000 for premium cover; up to &pound;25,000 standard and &pound;50,000 premium for a fatal accident; &pound;25 or &pound;50 for each day's hospitalisation for up to a year, &pound;250 or &pound;500 towards specialist outpatient treatment after leaving hospital and up to &pound;500,000 on both levels to cover against third party claims for injury or damage to their property. 
 This includes free legal advice. 
 But the cover is not cheap. 
 The cost of standard cover is from &pound;7.20 a month or &pound;18 to include hazardous sports, double for premium cover. 
 News Round-Up: Girobank seeks mythical customer 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 IS YOUR name JA Ashton? 
 If it is you could win &pound;500. 
 Girobank is looking for JA Ashton, a mythical customer whose name has appears in brochures and leaflets promoting the bank's services. 
 Real life JA Ashtons who come forward will have their name and address entered in a draw. 
 The first to have his or her details drawn will be given &pound;500 in a Girobank high interest notice account, paying 10.75 per cent net of basic rate tax. 
 To qualify, entrants must be over 18 and able to prove their identity if necessary. 
 &bquo;JA Ashton already seems a real person to our marketing team and new services are designed with his or her needs in mind,&equo; said Ian Martin, Girobank's head of marketing. 
 &bquo;Of course, today's JA Ashton is likely to be very different from that of our original concept when far fewer people had bank accounts, when the great majority of customers were male and when credit cards had barely hit the scene.&equo; 
 News Round-Up: Pru preaches to unconverted 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 THE Pru is jumping on the green bandwagon and as one of Britain's major motor insurers is encouraging car owners to convert their vehicles to unleaded petrol. 
 The Pru has half a million motorists on its books and is sending them each a booklet when their policies are renewed explaining the benefits of conversion. 
 David Roper, marketing executive, said: &bquo;Car exhaust emissions are a major source of lead pollution in the atmosphere, which can have long term effects to health, particularly young children. 
 &bquo;A recent RAC survey showed that nearly six out of 10 car owners don't know if their car can run on lead-free fuel. 
 We hope the leaflet we are sending out to our motor policyholders will bring home to them the fact that most cars can be converted both simply and cheaply.&equo; 
 But the Pru has stopped short of offering a discount to motorists who convert to lead-free petrol. 
 News Round-Up: Switching at Sainsbury 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 SOME 10 per cent of the goods bought at Sainsbury's stores is now paid for by Switch debit card, accounting for a quarter of a million shoppers. 
 Sainsbury launched its Eftpos in November 1987 and now accepts Switch as a debit card at terminals in all 243 of its stores which operate barcode scanning, as well as at all 40 of its petrol stations. 
 Moreover, Sainsbury now offers a Cashback facility which allows Switchcard customers to draw up to &pound;30 in cash as a part of the Switch transaction. 
 This is available at only four branches at the moment - Maidenhead, Chertsey, Archer Road Sheffield, and Purley Way, Croydon. 
 News Round-Up: Guide to sunny retirement 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 RETIRING abroad is not just a fantasy but a reality for an increasing proportion of the population. 
 But there can be problems and it is wise to read up on the subject and take professional advice before you make the plunge. 
 Retiring Abroad, published by the Financial Times is a useful guide to the making the break. 
 It covers buying a property, arranging removals, pre-retirement savings, investments, pensions, taxation, social welfare and health. 
 It contains profiles of popular retirement countries such as Spain and for those who really want to get away from it all there are outlines of more exotic locations. 
 News Round-Up: Managing your pension 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 THE attractions of personal pensions has been enhanced by a change in the rules allowing individuals to manage their own investments within a personal pension plan. 
 Peter Lilley, Financial Secretary to the Treasury, said: &bquo;This new investment opportunity complements other measures for widening share ownership and will encourage greater personal responsibility for pension provision.&equo; 
 Individuals will only be able to take advantage of this facility if the pension providers offer this option. 
 But from 11 October personal pension schemes may introduce facilities allowing scheme members to direct how funds are to be invested. 
 There will be rules to prevent assets being acquired by the pension fund from the owner of that pension fund and vice versa. 
 News Round-Up: Time to make financial plans 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 WITH interest rates going through the roof and budgets stretched now could be the time to embark upon some serious financial planning. 
 The latest edition of Financial Planning for the Individual includes explanations and advice on unit and investment trusts, business expansion schemes, personal equity plans, pensions, life assurance, tax planning and mortgages. 
 It is aimed at both the interested amateur and the professional. 
 Written by accountant, Alan Kelly of Grant Thornton, the book is available from business bookshops, price &pound;11.50. 
 News Round-Up: Music to help Aids 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 ALL royalties from the English Symphony Orchestra's recording of Elgar's Enigma Variations, launched this week will be donated to the National Aids Trust. 
 The compact disc is sponsored by the insurer Legal &amp; General and the royalties are expected to raise at least &pound;25,000 for the Aids charities and projects the Trust supports. 
 Once the sum raised passes the &pound;25,000 mark, royalties will revert to the Orchestra and Nimbus Records, the producers, while Legal &amp; General's will continue to go to the National Aids Trust. 
 News Round-Up: County court judgments fall 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 INTEREST rates may be rising, pushing borrowers even further into debt, but the number of county court judgments against individuals in debt has fallen by 16 per cent in the first half of 1989, according to figures released by the Registry of County Court Judgments. 
 The registry also reports an increase in the number of searches as people verify their situation in the light of tougher credit granting procedures, says chairman, Malcolm Hurlston. 
 If you have owed money, you could find that the lender has obtained judgment against you without your knowledge. 
 Anyone wanting to find if there is a judgment against them should contact the Registry at 173-175 Cleveland Street, London W1P 5PE. 
 Tel: 01-380 0133. 
 News Round-Up: Insurer's idea for NI saving 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 REDUCTIONS in National Insurance contributions came into effect last week. 
 Workers earning &pound;115 a week or more will receive just over &pound;3 extra in their weekly pay packets, while salaried staff will see an increase of more than &pound;13 a month. 
 The Pru says that Britain is becoming a nation of spendthrifts with less than &pound;5 in every &pound;100 of disposable income being saved last year -the lowest level for 30 years &mdash; and is encouraging people to save the extra cash. 
 A 30-year-old man could use his extra &pound;13 a month to buy &pound;60,000 worth of 20-year term cover, says the Pru. 
 Interest-free loan offer for new car buyers 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 WITH interest rates going through the roof the offer of an interest-free loan for two years for buyers of new cars should be investigated. 
 Anyone considering buying a new Metro 1.0L, Montego 1.6L or Rover 820 Fastback can obtain interest-free loans over two years from AA Financial Services, provided you are prepared to put down a 25 per cent deposit on the car. 
 For example, a G-registered Metro costs &pound;216.42 a month over 24 months with a deposit of &pound;1,731.25. 
 The purchase price includes six months road tax and delivery. 
 The total amount payable is &pound;6,925.25. 
 Repayments can also be spread over three years at an APR of 3.9 per cent, or four years at an APR of 6.9 per cent. 
 However, car buyers should be aware that all kinds of discounts are available on new cars and that an interest-free loan for 75 per cent for two years might still work out more expensive than borrowing elsewhere and getting a large cash discount on the purchase price. 
 You will have to do your sums. 
 At today's overdraft rate of around 18 per cent the value of a two-year interest free loan of say, &pound;5,000 is around &pound;1,800. 
 You would therefore need to be able to buy the Metro for about &pound;5,200 cash or less to be better off financing the deal yourself. 
 High interest rates are good for savers: Lorna Bourke looks at the options for investing your money at a time of soaring loan rates 
 By LORNA BOURKE 
 HOMEBUYERS now know the worst. 
 Halifax and Abbey National have announced their new home loan rates &mdash; up 1 per cent to 14.5 per cent from 1 November - and most other large lenders are likely to follow suit. 
 With demand for homeloans at a low ebb, few will want to go higher. 
 For the average borrower with a &pound;30,000 home loan over 25 years, monthly repayments after income tax relief on the interest, go up from &pound;278.70 to &pound;294.90. 
 In May 1988, when the mortgage rate stood at 9.8 per cent the same borrower was paying only &pound;221.40. 
 For those who want to work out what their new repayment will be, the increased cost each month per &pound;1,000 borrowed is 54p net of basic rate tax or 76p for each &pound;1,000 borrowed over the &pound;30,000 limit for mortgage interest relief. 
 Those lenders who have announced their new rates are the Skipton which goes up from 13.4 per cent to 14.65 per cent (14.9 for higher risk lending) from Monday and Stroud and Swindon which is putting its rate up by 1 per cent to 14.5 per cent immediately for new borrowers and from 1 November for existing loans. 
 &bquo;The society operates an annual repayment date system and borrowers will not have to increase their repayment until 1 February,&equo; commented chief executive, Richard Payne. 
 Town &amp; Country Building Society is putting on 1.25 per cent to bring its mortgage rate to 14.75 per cent. 
 Norwich &amp; Peterborough Building Society is moving up 0.5 per cent to 14.5 per cent, but it put on 0.5 per cent just before the base rate rise was announced. 
 At these levels, borrowers with savings or investments must be wondering whether it is worthwhile using some of their cash to pay off the mortgage in part or in full. 
 The net cost of borrowing for those with loans of &pound;30,000 or less works out at 10.87 per cent for a basic rate taxpayer, 8.7 per cent for those paying tax at 40 per cent. 
 With a net return of 12 per cent easily attainable from building society and bank high interest accounts, it is still cheaper to borrow and keep your savings on deposit. 
 But for those with loans over &pound;30,000 where there is no tax relief, it is certainly worth considering paying off some of the mortgage - particularly since there is no clear indication of when rates might come down. 
 But if it is bad news for borrowers, investors have never had it so good. 
 Returns of 12 per cent and more are on offer from banks and building societies while the rate of inflation &mdash; even taking into account this latest mortgage rate rise &mdash; is around 7.5 per cent. 
 Investors are getting a real return of 4.5 per cent on their cash. 
 This looks like the best return available on income bonds but investors should move fast as these offers tend to be fully subscribed very quickly. 
 If the Regency Life bond runs out, the next best rate is available from Aetna (Tel: 01-837 6494) which also has a one-year fixed rate bond paying between 11.6 per cent net of basic rate tax to 12.10 per cent for investments betweeen &pound;5,000 and &pound;1m plus. 
 Britannia Building Society has a fixed rate one-year bond at 11.75 per cent for sums of &pound;25,000 or more. 
 Investors who should really be thinking of making a move are those in National Savings Deposit Accounts which are paying only 10.75 per cent gross (without deduction of tax). 
 This is well below what can be obtained from building societies. 
 National Savings Certificates are paying a miserable 7.5 per cent tax free and no one should be holding any certificates which have reached maturity as the rate paid under general extension terms is only 5.1 per cent. 
 National Savings income bonds might just be worth hanging on to at 11.75 per cent if you are a non-taxpayer. 
 For investors who do not want to tie up their money for a year in an income bond, Town &amp; Country's (tel: 01-353 1476) new Classic investment account is paying 12 per cent net of basic rate tax for sums of &pound;25,000 and over. 
 Nottingham (tel: 0602 481444) is offering the same return on its Anniversary Bond for investments of &pound;5,000 or more but there are penalties on withdrawal within 12 months &mdash; 90 days' loss of interest. 
 Skipton is paying 11.75 per cent on its Excel Bond for sums of &pound;5,000 or more and there is access to your money. 
 For those wanting monthly income, Town &amp; Country again tops the bill offering 11.85 per cent on its Classic Account for sums of &pound;25,000 or more. 
 If you want instant access to your money, some of the bank high interest accounts are offering the best terms. 
 Humberclyde Finance (Tel: 0256 846874) is paying 11.73 per cent net of basic rate tax on sums of &pound;50,000 or more. 
 Hedge your bets with a foreign currency fund: Martin Baker reports on the best ways for investors to make the most of a falling pound 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 IN SPITE of the rise in bank base rates and the Chancellor's tough defence of his strategy at last week's Blackpool conference, the pound has continued to decline. 
 From DM3.07 sterling has fallen to DM2.96. 
 The descent, mirrored by a similar plunge against the dollar, has taken little more than a fortnight. 
 Interest rates were raised to make the pound more attractive and stop its fall. 
 The most immediate effect of all this has been the announcement of increased mortgage rates. 
 More unpleasant side-effects, such as a stock market decline and spiralling credit card problems may be in store. 
 Although the situation is bad, investors can make the best of it. 
 &bquo;It is a good time for sterling-based investors to buy a holding in a managed currency fund,&equo; says currency manager Philip Saunders of Guinness Mahon. 
 &bquo;Sterling has moved into a major bear market. 
 &bquo;You can argue that a change in rates might make a decisive turnround in the next six months or so&hellip; but recent behaviour of the foreign exchanges suggests that government control is not possible. 
 &bquo;No interest rate mechanism will bribe the markets to hold sterling at an unacceptable level.&equo; 
 The investment logic is simple. 
 By converting pounds to other currencies investors are gambling that the pound will fall. 
 To take an oversimplified example: if an investor buys marks at three to the pound, and the pound falls until it is valued at just two marks, every pound of the original stake will be worth &pound;1.50 at the new rate. 
 Investment managers have invented various ways of making this kind of currency investment. 
 The two main types are the self-administered currency scheme and the managed currency fund. 
 Self-administered schemes are cheap to run. 
 The investor decides on the currency most likely to appreciate against sterling and puts money on deposit in that currency. 
 The manager executes the deals for a small annual fee &mdash; usually 0.5 per cent deducted from the interest earned. 
 Rothschild's Old Court International Reserves has the widest choice of currencies and it is easy to invest. 
 The evidence is that you stand as good a chance of getting the choice of currency right as the experts if the return from the managed funds is anything to go by. 
 With a managed fund the investor makes a deposit, and the manager decides on the spread of currencies and the contracts. 
 So will sterling continue to fall, bringing more gloom to homeowners but perhaps some pleasure to those who have hedged their sterling savings into foreign currencies? 
 Few analysts are optimistic. 
 &bquo;It's already taken a very big hit,&equo; says Ian Amstad, an economist with Chase Manhattan. 
 &bquo;But if it falls below the 2.95 level against the Deutschemark, sterling will plummet. 
 The markets are demanding a higher and higher premium to hold sterling and they may sell it unless and until it reaches 2.80 against the mark.&equo; 
 Peter Harman, independent adviser at Berkeley St James', agrees with Mr Amstad. 
 His preferred currency is the dollar. 
 He believes that &bquo;managed currency funds are a good way of protecting the purchasing power of sterling-based investors. 
 They have to be a good thing for anyone who is content to be out of shares and keep part of their money in liquid money funds&equo;. 
 Philip Saunders makes a starker contrast between the limited exposure of currency funds and holdings in shares or unit trusts: &bquo;With charges at 4 per cent initially and three-quarters of a point annually for a currency fund, would you pay 6 per cent to go into a plain old unit trust?&equo; 
 Mr Saunders' fund has a 40 per cent exposure to the mark, with a similar commitment to the dollar. 
 The rest is split between yen and sterling. 
 Our table shows the top 10 sterling-based funds. 
 The statistics provided by Opal show 25 dollar-based funds over one year which outperformed those in the table. 
 The strength of these funds, 17 of which show a return of better than 17 per cent, lies in their re-conversion from dollars to sterling. 
 Most UK investors will want to invest with a sterling denominated cheque, rather than convert to dollars beforehand. 
 The sterling-denominated funds have recorded relatively modest gains across a narrow spread of returns. 
 The worst has produced 7.7 per cent over the year, while the best, Lloyds International, is more than six points better. 
 The average performance of all funds, both sterling and dollar-based, is just over 14 per cent. 
 Only one fund managed to lose money. 
 This underscores the paradoxical nature of these investments: while they invest in notoriously volatile markets, the returns they produce are extremely solid, as befits an investment which is also a hedge. 
 OTC investors left in the dark 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 INVESTORS in Over-The-Counter (OTC) shares have been left in limbo since the market fizzled out, often unable to sell their shares or, in some cases, trace the company in which they invested. 
 Yesterday's edition of the Investors Chronicle contains a special report on the 158 companies traded on the OTC market. 
 Of the companies traced, 40 have failed, another 22 were taken over and 22 are now quoted on Stock Exchange markets. 
 The remaining 74 are not quoted on any recognised exchange, although many can be traded by members under rule 535(2). 
 Fixtures, fittings and fallow deer 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 PRIORS MESNE, at Aylburton in the Forest of Dean, has an unusual addition to the normal list of potential fixtures and fittings that come with a property for sale &mdash; 110 red and fallow deer. 
 The current owners farm the two herds on the estate on a commercial basis - though sentimentalists need not worry, as the animals are reared for breeding purposes rather than the dinner table. 
 Although they intend taking some of the animals with them, the rest will probably remain with the estate. 
 The main property, which was built in 1880 and stands in about 60 acres of parkland, has nine bedrooms. 
 It is for sale together with a coach house with two flats, a courtyard and outbuildings, through Knight Frank &amp; Rutley (0285 659771) for &pound;650,000; the deer, however, come extra. 
 As a guide, Christopher Cornell of KF&amp;R's Cirencester office points out that a top quality red deer stag is worth around &pound;2-3,000, a hind about &pound;400-500. 
 Fallow deer, he says, are less pricey &mdash; a buck will fetch around &pound;4-500, a doe about &pound;80-90. 
 L'ESPARCETTE, is a new Swiss development aimed at well-heeled skiiers. 
 It consists of 11 two- and three-bedroom apartments in Villars, a mountain resort in the Vaudois Alps, about an hour-and-a-half drive from Geneva. 
 The properties, all of which have balconies or terraces, range from &pound;173,000 to &pound;262,000. 
 The selling agent, Ellis (01-706 0844), says it can arrange a Swiss mortgage to finance up to 60 per cent of the purchase price of the property &mdash; but remember that if you borrow in Swiss francs and the pound falls against the Swiss currency, the amount and cost of your mortgage could rise. 
 Property Update: Swap shop 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 THE Property Exchange, a new company publishing a national directory of people who want to swap homes rather than sell them (if the properties have different values, one party pays the other the difference) says that so far most people are looking for smaller homes. 
 &bquo;It's split about 70/30 between people who want to trade down and those who want a more expensive place,&equo; says founder Phillip Nunn. 
 &bquo;The main reason for a lot is that they are in trouble because of higher mortgage rates.&equo; 
 The company then enters details of your property, and what sort of exchange -price, location and so on &mdash; you are looking for, in its computer database. 
 The advantages of an exchange rather than a sale, says Mr Nunn (who set up the business after he successfully swapped his own home), are: no chain of buyers and sellers to fall through, stamp duty is payable only on any difference in price between the two properties, and agents' fees are less. 
 Around two thirds of Mr Nunn's &bquo;exchangers&equo; are looking for a nearby property. 
 Details on 0273 608311. 
 Property Update: Basement plans 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 THE Traditional Housing Bureau has sunk to new depths in its latest piece of research. 
 According to its study, seven out of 10 British buyers want a revival of basements and cellars. 
 More than two thirds of 1,344 respondents considered a basement a desirable feature, with a third considering them very desirable. 
 The bureau observes that housebuilders ignore such market demands at their peril and points out that basements serve a useful ecological purpose. 
 &bquo;With housing land becoming increasingly scarce, building into the ground must become an even more attractive proposition,&equo; the bureau says. 
 Property Update: Dockland dreams 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 BRAVE souls thinking of buying in London's Docklands should get hold of a new free guide from the London Docklands Development Corporation. 
 Although the glossy articles provide a relentlessly positive approach to an area with more than its fair share of disadvantages, the guide is packed with useful practical information on, for example, restaurants, wine bars, developments and estate agents. 
 Property Update: In arrears 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 WHILE the number of mortgage defaulters is rising in Britain, it is falling in the United States. 
 According to the US Mortgage Bankers' Association, the number of homeowners more than 30 days behind in their repayments fell in the second quarter of the year to its lowest level in 10 years. 
 Mortgage &bquo;delinquency&equo; rates fell to 4.52 per cent in the second quarter of 1989 from 4.62 per cent in the first quarter, marking the fourth straight quarter in which the figure has fallen. 
 America produces much better statistics on mortgage arrears than Britain. 
 Figures for the first half of the year from the Building Societies Association showed that only around 54,360 people were in arrears with their mortgages. 
 This is a 20 per cent rise on the same period last year but still a tiny 0.7 per cent of the 7.6m mortgage loans. 
 But the BSA counts only repayments more than six months in arrears, compared with one month in the United States. 
 Worse still, the banks refuse to produce any arrears figures at all. 
 Experts estimate that more than 350,000 people &mdash; or 4 per cent of British borrowers &mdash; are likely to be a month or more behind with their repayments. 
 Property Update: Franc speaking 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 THE FRENCH have been shifting their money from the stock market into Paris property, according to Donnelle Higbee, who runs Hampton's Paris office. 
 She estimates prices have risen in the French capital by 25-30 per cent a year since 1985. 
 In prestige arrondissements of Paris, such as the 6th, 7th, 16th, Neuilly and Le Marais &mdash; the equivalent of London's Kensington, Chelsea or Knightsbridge &mdash; you can expect to pay &pound;200,000-&pound;400,000 for a good two- or three-bedroom flat, she says. 
 On the rental side, a three-bedroom flat in such an area will cost around 25,000 francs (&pound;2,500) a month. 
 For cheaper up-and-coming areas, she advises buyers to look around the Bastille and Le Valois Perret, where prices work out at &pound;20-&pound;40 a square metre &mdash; about &pound;100,000 for a typical two-bedroom flat. 
 If you are going to buy in France, remember that cultural differences can have a big impact. 
 The French seem more nervous about buying garden flats, for example, than the British, so these can often be proportionately cheaper. 
 Flats at the top of older buildings without lifts are also less expensive for those healthy enough to cope with walking up six floors. 
 Property Update: Hopeful Hart 
 By MARTIN BAKER 
 A Gloucestershire publican is pinning his hopes for moving on a part-exchange deal. 
 Martin Cocks owns the Red Hart (right) at Awre, situated on the banks of the Severn in Gloucestershire. 
 He is so frustrated by the dearth of buyers for his pub, which is partly sixteenth-century with a 26-seat restaurant, that he has declared he will take a buyer's property in part-exchange and then rent it out until the market improves. 
 Forward Planning: Enhance your appealing prospects: Ruth Richards on how to object to council decisions 
 By RUTH RICHARDS 
 MORE THAN four out of five people who apply for planning permission get it. 
 Objections by neighbours and others are often dealt with not by scrapping a proposal altogether, but by amendments agreed between the applicant and the council which meet most, if not all, concerns. 
 But sometimes applications are refused. 
 If the proposal is yours, you may feel aggrieved. 
 Alternatively, if you are an objector, any amendments may still leave you feeling dissatisfied. 
 In such cases what can you do? 
 Appeals: If planning permission is refused, the person who applied for it can ask the Department of the Environment to reconsider the decision. 
 However, this must be done within six months of planning permission being refused. 
 An appeal can also be made if the council takes more than eight weeks to come to a decision &mdash; this is called an appeal against non-determination. 
 A planning inspector will be appointed by the DoE to deal with the appeal. 
 He or she will hear evidence from the council, the applicant, neighbours and local groups. 
 The inspector will then make a recommendation &mdash; though this is occasionally ignored by the DoE. 
 The recent fuss over whether to build a new town at Foxley Wood in Hampshire, for example, was a case where the then Secretary of State, Nicholas Ridley, intended to ignore the inspector's advice to reject an appeal by the potential developers. 
 Appeals can be decided either through a public inquiry or by written representations. 
 Written representations &mdash; which are what they sound like &mdash; are the usual route for the small developments usually proposed by house-owners. 
 The council, applicant and any interested parties are invited to write to the inspector giving their objections or support for the proposed development. 
 The decision can take four or five months. 
 At present if either the applicant or the council (though not objectors) insist, a public inquiry must be held. 
 However, the Government has proposed changing this so that the final decision would be up to the DoE. 
 The council is obliged to inform anyone who made observations on a planning application, if there is subsequently an appeal by written representations. 
 If there is a public inquiry the council has to put up a site notice. 
 A public inquiry is usually employed, however, only if the appeal involves a very large or highly contentious development. 
 The evidence will be given to the inspector in person and witnesses can be cross-examined. 
 Neighbours and other third parties are allowed to speak at a public inquiry &mdash; though they usually appear last. 
 In both cases a site visit will usually be made by the inspector, so he or she can see the property, usually accompanied by the appellant and the council. 
 Neighbours may also attend by asking the inspector in advance &mdash; it is a good idea to include this request when you write to the inspector outlining your objections. 
 Normally, developers paying a barrister to represent them at an inquiry must pick up the tab. 
 But if the DoE decides that the council has acted unreasonably, the developer may claim costs back from the council. 
 Equally, if the developer acted unreasonably, the council and third parties may be able to claim their costs from the developer. 
 The courts: Very occasionally a decision by the council or, on appeal, by the DoE can be challenged in the courts through a judicial review. 
 But this is only available where the council or inspector has either misinterpreted the law or not followed the proper procedures. 
 A High Court hearing can be very expensive as barristers usually have to be used &mdash; anything from &pound;10,000 upwards. 
 Also, the person asking for the review has to agree that if they lose they will pay the other side's costs. 
 Injunctions: If a neighbour gets planning permission to build something that you feel is grossly unreasonable, you may be able to protect your rights by obtaining an injunction. 
 If you suspect, for example, that your neighbour intends to build on your land, or if your windows are going to be blocked so that no light can get through, or if an unreasonable nuisance is going to be caused, then your last hope may be to go to the courts and ask for an injunction. 
 These are usually temporary measures which can be obtained quite swiftly and will involve the court directing the developer not to carry out the development until the court has had an opportunity to consider the dispute in detail. 
 Ombudsman: Third parties &mdash; neighbours et al &mdash; cannot appeal to the DoE if they disagree with a planning decision. 
 However, if the council has not acted properly it may be possible to get the Local Government Ombudsman to investigate whether there has been maladministration. 
 This would include, for example, insufficient consultation. 
 The Ombudsman cannot rescind planning permission but can insist that the council gives an apology, and possibly a small amount of compensation. 
 Enforcement: If someone builds without planning permission, the council may take enforcement action against the owner or occupier of the property. 
 You can appeal against an enforcement notice on a number of grounds. 
 The procedures are basically the same as for an ordinary appeal but you will have to pay a fee &mdash; usually about &pound;38. 
 If the appeal is lost you will have to take the steps required in the enforcement notice. 
 This may mean demolishing the building or returning it to its original use. 
 If these steps are not taken, the council can take the offender to the magistrates' court and a fine of up to &pound;2,000 may be payable &mdash; and the fine may be repeated on a continuing basis if the notice is still not complied with. 
 Neighbours cannot take enforcement action on their own behalf, but they can lobby the council. 
 The Department of the Environment produces free booklets on planning permission, enforcement, appeals and compulsory purchase. 
 These are available from the Planning Inspectorate, Tollgate House, Houlton Street, Bristol BS2 9DJ or your local planning department. 
 While we wait for the pendulum to swing: Gail Counsell warns that house prices could take years to recover after the latest rise in interest rates 
 By GAIL COUNSELL 
 BAD NEWS for anyone wanting to move: you will probably have to wait two years for a substantial recovery in the housing market. 
 The latest round of interest rate rises has postponed for another six months the earliest date the pendulum can be expected to swing back. 
 The end, rather than the beginning, of 1991 seems to be the choice of many pundits. 
 But there is better news for the gloomies who thought that the North was destined forever to remain the hunting ground of wealthy southerners. 
 While the environmental attractions of moving out may remain as strong as ever, the financial advantage from the fact that southern prices boomed first has largely disappeared. 
 The old relationship between prices in the London area and elsewhere appears to be reasserting itself. 
 More of that anon. 
 But first, if you were hoping for a swift end to the depression in the housing market, think again. 
 Until recently most pundits expected the market to improve in the spring of 1991 after stagnating next year. 
 They said 1990 would be fairly gloomy, with little increase in the number of houses being sold (currently sales are running at about a third of the level of the last few years) and no movement in prices throughout the UK. 
 But because interest rates were expected to drop gradually over the coming 12 months, the view was that by early 1991 confidence would have returned, volumes picked up and prices started to lift &mdash; even if only by the inflation rate. 
 The latest shift has prompted a rethink, not only because rates have risen but because chances of them falling significantly have receded probably until the spring. 
 That does not mean plummeting house prices &mdash; the old adage about most people simply refusing to move rather than sell their house for less than they paid for it remains as true as ever. 
 Rather, it looks as if we will have to wait until the end of 1991 before we get any dramatic improvement. 
 &bquo;The market is so bad now that it won't get any worse, at least in the South,&equo; said Richard Roberts, an economist with Barclays Bank. 
 &bquo;It will go on being like it is for longer.&equo; 
 Many estate agents were whistling to keep up their confidence this week, claiming that people were already used to the idea of higher mortgage rates and that the latest increase would make little difference. 
 But Gary Marsh, head of research with the Halifax, the UK's biggest building society, says it is inevitable that the modest improvement seen in the market over the last couple of months &mdash; especially in the South, where sellers have started to adjust to more realistic levels &mdash; will be damaged and the date of its recovery put back. 
 &bquo;I think we are going to see that slight pick-up disappear. 
 There will probably be a lull over the winter, followed by a resurgence of activity next spring. 
 Nevertheless, the market is going to remain very depressed throughout next year and I see the recovery shifting to late, rather than early, 1991.&equo; 
 Moreover, he says that the present level of interest rates may mean that instead of prices stagnating next year they could fall by around 10 per cent. 
 (While so far there have been some falls in prices, basically in the South, the national price picture has remained positive.) 
 All this has to be put in perspective. 
 In the last 20 years there have been three major price booms &mdash; 1972/73, 1979/80 and the most recent from 1985 to 1988. 
 Each time house prices rose rapidly, by substantially more than inflation. 
 Then inflation started to accelerate and house prices fell back. 
 In each case, London led the way, but was the first into recession, which meant in the long run that the relationship between the value of property in different areas was maintained. 
 The tax incentives behind housing, the fact that house price increases have made people feel that property is a &bquo;sure bet&equo; and the lack of a rented sector, however, have combined to ensure that property has out-performed many other sorts of investment. 
 In the last three years, for example, property prices have risen by 68.5 per cent, while the FT All Share Index has risen by only 52.1 per cent. 
 Add in the tax payable on share gains, and the comparison looks even worse. 
 Before you cheer up too much, though, there is an important difference. 
 It is much more difficult to get at property profits than at share profits &mdash; everyone has to live somewhere. 
 It is also a lot easier to &bquo;shop around&equo; among different shares. 
 Which brings us back to the Southern Effect. 
 For the last few years, increasing numbers of southern owners have been capitalising on the relative strength of property in the South. 
 Because southern prices rose faster than those in the regions in the mid-1980s, for instance, by last year an average house in Yorkshire and Humberside, which in 1983 had been worth 69 per cent of a similar one in London, was worth only 40 per cent of one in the capital. 
 Remember how southerners, aided by improved transport links, piled into Yorkshire and East Anglia, realising they could buy a country mansion for the price of a Knightsbridge broom cupboard or a Surrey dovecot? 
 The theory was, though, that once the boom ended the traditional relationship between prices in the South-east and other regions would reassert itself. 
 This appears to be exactly what has happened. 
 Prices have continued to rise in the North, but to stagnate and fall in the South. 
 A house in Yorkshire and Humberside now costs 55 per cent of one in London &mdash; exactly the same as in 1969. 
 And the chances are that by the time the market picks up again in 1991 we will be back to the 1983 figure. 
 The same is true for East Anglia &mdash; in 1969 average prices in the region were 69.4 per cent of those in Greater London: currently the figure is 69.8. 
 Mr Marsh said: &bquo;There is only one real exception, and that is Northern Ireland.&equo; 
 A combination of the Troubles, economic decline and net emigration means that the average property in Northern Ireland, which 20 years ago cost 63 per cent of one in London, now costs only 36 per cent. 
 As the financial edge has disappeared, so have the buyers. 
 Tim Blenkin, of the York office of agents Jackson-Stops &amp; Staff, says that sales of up-market properties &mdash; in the &pound;200,000-plus bracket &mdash; to southern-based buyers have halved from more than 50 per cent of his firm's sales last year to about 25 per cent. 
 One important factor, he suspects, is that the market in the South-east is so depressed that southern buyers simply cannot sell their own homes in order to move. 
 There is one significant caveat to all of this. 
 While the prices of average properties have followed the normal pattern, there does seem to have been a shift in the relative values of &bquo;up-market&equo; or &bquo;prime&equo; properties. 
 As the rich, after 10 years of Conservative government, have become proportionately wealthier, the houses they want to buy have become more sought after. 
 ('Prime' does not simply mean &bquo;expensive&equo; &mdash; it refers to the more desirable types of property within each group, whether quaint country cottages, Georgian rectories or large estates.) 
 According to the buyers' guide produced by estate agents Savills, who specialise in such properties, the price of prime properties in Yorkshire has risen by more than 130 per cent over the last three years. 
 In contrast, the price of &bquo;average&equo; properties, those on which the Halifax has lent mortgages, has risen by only about 85 per cent. 
 With most agents in agreement that the top end of the market has held up better than the bottom end, this widening differential between the values of prime and mass-market housing is likely to increase. 
 Racing: Heights to hasten Cauthen's pursuit 
 By JOHN KARTER, Racing Correspondent 
 ASCOT racegoers should keep the champagne temporarily on ice while warming up with a Scotch and American this afternoon, when Willie Carson and Steve Cauthen may dominate the last Flat meeting of the season at the Berkshire course. 
 The championship may be a two-man affair, but the numbers game does not tell the whole story and Carson is riding with as much inspiration and dash as either of the younger men. 
 The effervescent Scot should consolidate third position in the table by booting home Gallant Hope (3.0) and Somethingdifferent (3.35). 
 By his flamboyant standards, this has been a disappointingly low-key year for Snow Bride's trainer, Henry Cecil. 
 True, Old Vic has carried off the French and Irish Derbys, but Michelozzo's success in the substitute St Leger has been his only major English strike. 
 That could change on a technicality if, as seems likely, Aliysa is disqualified from first place in the Oaks for having traces of camphor in her system. 
 Snow Bride, who finished three-lengths second to Aliysa, would then be declared the winner and she should consolidate her enormous value as a broodmare by taking today's Princess Royal Stakes. 
 On her best form she is a cut above the rest, but Carson's mount, Princess Sobieska, could be a dangerous rival. 
 Cauthen could have a banker in the opening event in Golan Heights. 
 This handsome son of the Derby winner Shirley Heights looked a first-rate prospect when cantering home at Haydock. 
 Western Wolf, on whom Cauthen won over the course last month, should follow up, but faces several threatening rivals, notably Single. 
 Cauthen's prolific American contemporary, Cash Asmussen, will miss four booked rides at Ascot as he pulled muscles in his neck when falling from his mount who crossed his legs at the start of the last race at Maisons-Laffitte yesterday. 
 He was taken to hospital for an x-ray examination. 
 Carson gets on famously with another veteran of the racing game, Gallant Hope, and the seven-year-old, who is back to his right trip and ground, could be the solution to a devilish-looking Bovis Handicap. 
 The Cornwallis Stakes also has the look of a bookmakers' benefit, but the rugged Somethingdifferent, who ran so well behind Welney in a high-class event at Newbury, could be hard to contain. 
 Luca Cumani's promising colt, Montendre (next best 3.15), got even closer to Welney at Yarmouth and has since won easily at Brighton. 
 Despite the presence of the unbeaten Daarik, Montendre looks the best bet at York. 
 Cumani has a chance of taking the big sprint on the Knavesmire with Khaydara, but she has not run since June and will be hard pressed to hold Runun (3.45), who was the convincing winner of a valuable Ascot handicap on his last outing. 
 Half an hour later, Baldomero (4.15), who chased home Runun at Ascot, should underline the merit of the form. 
 Racing: Sheikh has triple aim 
 By JOHN KARTER 
 &bquo;TOMORROW the world&equo; may be the case for Sheikh Mohammed this weekend when his horses seek global domination in big races in the United States, France and Italy, writes John Karter. 
 Warrshan, the most expensive yearling of his generation but a flop in the Derby, carries the Sheikh's colours in the &dollar;500,000 Oak Tree Invitational at Santa Anita in California late tonight. 
 Great Communicator and Pay The Butler, winners of the Breeders' Cup Turf and the Japan Cup, are among his opponents. 
 This will be Warrshan's last race for Michael Stoute, who saddles the Sheikh's Shaadi for his swansong in Longchamp's Prix de la Foret tomorrow in which Gold Seam also represents Britain. 
 Reprimand is the Sheikh's standard bearer in Italy tomorrow in the valuable Premio Vittorio di Capua in Rome. 
 First Person 
 By KEN JONES 
 SOME time ago, but not so far back that it can be dismissed as incidental, a belligerent centre-half, who needed very little encouragement in such nefarious matters, was instructed to discover how fast the visiting centre-forward could limp. 
 When committing himself enthusiastically to an undeniably outrageous tactic, this brave and noble warrior not only left his mark on the opposition but touched significantly upon a dilemma that threatens to develop into an insurmountable and perhaps crucifying problem for Bobby Robson, the temporarily reprieved England manager. 
 From evidence available this week, by which I mean the remarkable feats of sharp reflex and well-practised agility Peter Shilton performed against Poland in a crucial World Cup qualifying tie in Chorzow, England ought not to embark for Italy next summer without first packing trench tools and barbed wire, while giving some serious attention to the laying of mines in their penalty area. 
 Even if Shilton, inevitably cautious in his 41st year, is now most likely to be found out by teasing centres (never mind the &bquo;hand of God&equo;, he should have been quicker, more positively to the ball than Diego Maradona in Mexico four years ago), his reliable and spectacular shot-stopping in Poland emphasised glaring inadequacies stemming from the grossly misguided philosophy that continues to gain ground in the Football League. 
 The emphasis on athleticism, power play, sustained long-ball assaults, blitzkrieg, has bred a proliferation of muscular but blunderingly naive defenders who appear to be alarmingly, untidily vulnerable when required to cope with more subtle forms of attack; show them dribblers, runners with the ball or an incisive exchange of sharp passes, and panic sets in. 
 This was certainly true of England last Wednesday, their back line in such stark disarray, so frequently outsmarted and embarrassingly wrongfooted by intelligently applied Polish speed and trickery that but for Shilton's alertness and determined auxiliary support from midfield they would have been overwhelmed. 
 It has to be admitted that this was observed from long range, an unsatisfactory two-dimensional experience but nevertheless valuable as a guide to England's immediate potential. 
 Much of what we saw related discouragingly to familiar bad habits, a thought that occurred, not for the first time, to George Cohen, who for the benefit of younger readers made a notable contribution to the history of English football when turning out in the 1966 World Cup final. 
 As a young professional with Fulham some 30 and more years ago, he prospered hugely from advice offered in no uncertain terms by Joe Bacuzzi, a redoubtable professional of the old school and a firm believer in the unassailable principle that full-backs who cannot defend should seek alternative employment. 
 &bquo;You couldn't buy what I learned from Joe,&equo; Cohen said, &bquo;and it makes you wonder about the people who are teaching them now. 
 I see wide attackers being allowed to come inside for shots, centre-backs who do not appear to have a clue about positional play and plenty of evidence to suggest that we are no longer producing defenders with the ability and confidence to cope on their own.&equo; 
 As English football has a proud record of defensive authority &mdash; Warney Cresswell, Wilf Copping, Eddie Hapgood, Stan Cullis, Billy Wright, Neil Franklin, Bobby Moore and Ray Wilson are illustrious names that spring immediately to mind &mdash; Cohen's testimony amounts to a penetrating indictment of prevailing doctrine. 
 For all that England are the only European nation not to concede a goal in the qualifying tournament, it is no exaggeration to suggest they have never been so ill-equipped for the persistent rigours of a World Cup. 
 Football has always been played at both ends, a fact made significant by Robson's assertion that England were forced to fight a rearguard action in Chorzow. 
 Had they managed this comfortably, without laying claim to the truth, more could be expected of them. 
 The truth is that Shilton remains central to their cause, a man in early middle age, heroic but not infallible and therefore symbolising the extent of their aspirations. 
 Baseball: Clark's hits as Giant of swing: Richard Weekes reports from San Francisco as the opening skirmish looms in baseball's battle of Bay Bridge 
 By RICHARD WEEKES 
 IT IS open season for bombast in northern California. 
 All week the phoney war has raged as the populations of San Francisco and Oakland have, under licence of sport, declared their allegiance to one of two baseball teams who tonight march out on to a field to contest the title of world champions. 
 While the rest of America has to make do with a fridge full of beer and a chair at screen-side, the two participating cities are permitted a temporary suspension of reason for this the first Bay Bridge Series. 
 Already the mayors at either end of the Bridge, Art Agnos (Giants) and Lionel Wilson (Athletics), have taken time out from civic duties to place ritual side bets with each other on the outcome. 
 And last Monday Dr Harold Varmus let it be known that the thrill of winning the Nobel Prize for Medicine in the morning was as nothing compared with being at Candlestick Park in the evening to see the Giants take the National League pennant for the first time in 27 years. 
 Who knows, if things get really out of hand, maybe the warring crack gangs of Oakland's ghettos may be moved to declare a truce for the duration. 
 Yet whatever the prospects of peace on the city's streets, the battle set to be staged in Oakland's Coliseum in games one and two of the World Series have already been fought over long and hard in bar rooms and news rooms on either side of the Bay. 
 How will you stop Rickey Henderson stealing bases on you the way he did against Toronto, Roger Craig, the Giants' manager, is constantly asked. 
 To which the great shambling John Wayne figure replies: &bquo;By stopping him getting on base in the first place.&equo; 
 That's what the Blue Jays said, too. 
 And then there is the hypothesis put to the A's Tony La Russa, the lawyer-manager and quiet ringmaster of what can be a wild Oakland circus troupe: &bquo;What do you do if Will Clark (the Giants big-hitting first baseman) comes to the plate with the bases loaded?&equo; 
 To which the reply is: &bquo;Make sure we don't load the bases if Clark is due up.&equo; 
 What is certain is that Oakland start their second consecutive World Series as firm favourites, their combination of power (Jose Canseco and Mark McGuire), pitching (Dave Stewart and Mike Moore), defence (Mike Gallego and Carney Lansford) and speed commonly seen as too strong for a San Francisco side carrying several half-fit pitchers and vulnerable defensively to Henderson's base stealing. 
 Yet Oakland were also supposed to wipe the floor with Los Angeles a year ago. 
 Then they were a single out away from going one game up in Dodger Stadium &mdash; only for Kirk Gibson to turn the Series on its head with a home run at the last moment. 
 And when the time came for the A's big bats to show their muscle, they froze like rabbits in the spotlight of Orel Hershiser's fastball. 
 There is no obvious Hershiser figures in the Giants' pitching ranks this time, but in Clark they do have a man &mdash; like Gibson &mdash; in the mood to burn Oakland with the bat. 
 Will &bquo;The Thrill&equo; Clark, possessed, according to experienced observers, of the sweetest swing in baseball, came of age during the National League Championship series against the Chicago Cubs. 
 Yet the list of play-off records he set &mdash; .650 batting average, 13 hits, 24 total bases &mdash; fails to convey the full magnitude of his achievement, coming in as he often did at moments of unbelievable pressure, and usually delivering the vital hit. 
 Clark insists that he enjoys the responsibility of having the rest of the team looking to him to save the day. 
 &bquo;If you don't want to come up there with the bases loaded, hang &bquo;em up. 
 You don't belong in the game,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;That's what baseball is all about.&equo; 
 He showed what he is all about in the eighth inning of game five against the Cubs at Candlestick. 
 The Giants were leading the series 3-1 and wanted desperately to avoid returning to Wrigley Field for a sixth game. 
 The score was 1-1 when Clark came to bat, the bases were loaded and Mitch Williams, the Cubs' best relief pitcher, was on the mound. 
 After conceding two quick strikes, Clark fouled off four pitches in a row before blasting the next into centre field. 
 Two runs scored, and the Giants were in the World Series. 
 The 25-year-old from New Orleans spent much of the season in the shadow of Kevin Mitchell, the man he followed in the Giants' batting line-up and the leader in home runs and RBIs in the majors. 
 When Mitchell cooled off in September, Clark came into his own, to the delight of his manager. 
 &bquo;People talk about athletes who can rise to the occasion, about Joe Montana and Michael Jordan,&equo; Craig said. 
 &bquo;Let me tell you, there's no one better than Will Clark. 
 He's in a class by himself.&equo; 
 Dave Stewart, who will open the Series as Oakland's starting pitcher tonight, knows how hard it is to shut Clark down. 
 &bquo;He bats for average and for power,&equo; Stewart said. 
 &bquo;It's a combination pitchers hate. 
 If you go in their with no plan at all, he's going to beat you.&equo; 
 It may all come down to Clark if Oakland are to be kept at bay. 
 Glossary of popular terms Ball: called by the umpire when a pitch misses the strike zone. 
 Strike: called when a pitch enters the strike zone &mdash; an imaginary rectangle above home plate, roughly from the batter's shoulders to his knees. 
 A batter is out after three strikes. 
 Out: each team has three outs per innings. 
 Single: (also known as base hit) when a batter hits the ball in fair territory and reaches first base without being thrown out. 
 Thus a double is two bases, a triple three. 
 Walk: if the pitcher throws four balls before a third strike, the batter is automatically &bquo;walked&equo; to the first base. 
 Four to follow in this year's World Series RICK REUSCHEL (Giants) Age: 40 Position: Starting pitcher (right-handed) At 240lb and proportioned like a darts player, &bquo;Big Daddy&equo; is proof that you don't need to be a super-athlete to succeed. 
 Keeps bouncing back: dumped by the Chicago Cubs in 1985 after injury, but was reprieved by Pittsburgh; lasted a mere 18 pitches against the Cubs in game two of the NL play-offs but came back to win the decisive game five. 
 Makes up in subtlety and control what he lacks in speed of delivery. 
 KEVIN MITCHELL (Giants) Age: 27 Position: left fielder Misspent youth running with a San Diego street gang called Pierules. 
 It was only after he took two bullets in the thigh and wrist and a shotgun blast in the back, and his brother was murdered by rival gangs that he channelled his aggression into baseball. 
 Credits his grandmother with turning him around. 
 Began this season at record home-run pace, slowed later on but still finished first in majors for home runs (47) and RBIs (125). 
 Position: closing relief pitcher (right-handed). 
 His job is like that of a matador brought on to pitch final one or two innings when Oakland have the lead and need to kill off any opposition rally. 
 Relies mostly on fastballs and the slider. 
 Claims his long battle with alcoholism has helped him deal with pressure of late innings. 
 Admits, though, that he stayed in the clubhouse for the first six innings of a game &bquo;because I don't want anyone to see me sweat&equo;. 
 Best base stealer in the game, Henderson has a high opinion of himself, and thrives on psychological warfare on the basepaths to unnerve opponents, a strategy that worked against Toronto in the AL play-offs. 
 Yet Henderson is also fully capable of hitting home runs if he cannot get on base. 
 Against a slow-moving catcher like the Giants' Terry Kennedy in the World Series, Henderson is expected to make hay. 
 Rugby League: Injury blight offers NZ hope 
 By PAUL WILSON 
 ONE SOURCE of solace to the so far disappointing New Zealand tourists, who have a last chance at Leeds tomorrow to silence the doubters prior to the first Test next Saturday, must be the rate at which Great Britain's best players are falling by the wayside. 
 Before the Kiwis arrived Britain had lost Ellery Hanley and Garry Schofield, two of their most experienced and feared performers. 
 Yesterday they lost two more in Joe Lydon and Tony Myler, ruled out with hamstring and back injuries respectively at Malcolm Reilly's preliminary squad session. 
 Among Britain's backs only Andy Gregory has been capped more than his former colleagues at Widnes, and the Wigan scrum half himself makes a comeback from injury against Barrow tomorrow, his fitness still in doubt. 
 The withdrawals of Lydon and Myler bring a squad call-up for Darryl Powell, who could become Sheffield Eagles' first international. 
 Powell only has a remote chance of playing, for Reilly's squad has retained its shape and strength. 
 Britain only have this weekend to worry about, and Widnes and Wigan, with nine squad members between them, should not be extended by the visits of Wakefield and Barrow. 
 The hamstring pull which put Lydon out of the Test series was sustained in the closing minutes of a 50-4 win over Chorley. 
 Bradford's Yorkshire Cup semi-final replay against Halifax, if it is half as good as the first game at Thrum Hall, will be the most keenly contested of tomorrow's fixtures. 
 David Hobbs and Kelvin Skerrett are the potential Test players in the home pack. 
 Dick Fairbank, the Halifax forward, had his five-match suspension quashed last night. 
 This afternoon, Mike Gregory leads Warrington against Oldham in the Lancashire Cup final. 
 Oldham surprised St Helens and Wigan en route to Knowsley Road, and possess in Tony Barrow a coach with intimate knowledge of Warrington's strengths and weaknesses. 
 But Warrington achieved an emphatic win over Widnes with a highly disciplined performance. 
 Discipline was a failing during Barrow's years at Warrington, but there are signs that Brian Johnson has aggression under control and is about to tap the club's potential. 
 The Yorkshire Cup semi-final replay between Castleford and Featherstone will be played at Castleford on 22 October. 
 Squash: Australian revenge is complete 
 From RICHARD EATON in Singapore 
 ENGLAND'S hopes of reaching the semi-finals of the world team championships remain high, despite a 3-0 drubbing from Australia in the last round-robin match here yesterday. 
 The Australians magnificently took revenge for their defeat last time when they had the bronze medal taken away from them, but England were happy to learn that they have a last-eight encounter today with Sweden. 
 &bquo;We will have the psychological edge over them,&equo; Jonah Barrington, the coach, said, even though he had seen Del Harris, Bryan Beeson and Jason Nicolle fail to purloin even a single game between them against their rampaging opponents. 
 Barrington, nevertheless, has some good reasons for believing it. 
 It was the best Australian performance so far, by a long way. 
 They set out to peak for this particular match, both to erase from their minds the upset in London two years ago and to prove they could manage a good performance after several indifferent ones. 
 It also proved that they can come close to relieving Pakistan of the world title, provided they can peak again on Tuesday. 
 Only Harris, who played a fine third game against Chris Dittmar, the World Open finalist, provided much joy. 
 Four times the England No. 1 had game points, and had he secured one of them, it could have become interesting. 
 Instead, he lost 9-1, 9-0, 10-9, and all three encounters were over in little more than two hours. 
 But today is another day. 
 Australia now play Canada in the quarter-finals, while Pakistan, for whom Jahangir Khan has thundered his way through five matches with the loss of only 25 points, meet Egypt. 
 New Zealand, silver medal-winners last time, may not find it easy against the improving Finland. 
 Scotland's last hopes of pipping Canada for a quarter-final place ended with the 3-0 defeat to Sweden. 
 Hockey: Leicester need Nevill's goals 
 By BILL COLWILL 
 LEAGUE competition returns this weekend after a disjointed start to the season. 
 In the Typhoo Women's National League, the leaders, Ealing, visit Leicester. 
 Leicester could only manage a goalless draw midweek with Sutton Coldfield and will be keen to return to winning form. 
 Both sides have quality strikers able to turn a game. 
 Mary Nevill, a front runner for Great Britain and England, will be the threat in Leicester's attack while Ealing will be relying on their England under-21 striker, Mandy Langridge, the leading goalscorer in the league. 
 The opening salvoes will take place today in most of the regional leagues. 
 (the giant Peroni South League swings into action next week). 
 In Wales, the Premier League gets under way with Whitchurch hoping to repeat their success of last season. 
 The return to his old club of Andy Gowman, from Harborne, will greatly strengthen Cardiff's challenge, where he will team up again with Tim Percival to form a powerful combination. 
 Southgate and Hounslow flex their muscles in the Heineken Trophy match at Reading today, while the other Poundstretcher National League sides are in action tomorrow. 
 Havant, the leaders, who travel to Chigwell to take on Old Loughtonians, will be without their left-half, Alan Cave, with a leg injury, with the likelihood that Steve Lawson will deputise. 
 The Old Boys will hope that their captain, England international Julian Halls, who has been plagued with injuries since the summer, comes through a second XI game today without problems; if so, he is likely to be in the squad. 
 Teddington's 20-year-old captain, Jason Laslett, will be looking to secure the club's first points of the season at home to Harborne, who include 19-year-old Walid Abdo, from Penarth, for the first time, but will be without Denys Shortt. 
 Snooker: Fisher becomes a fisher of men 
 By CATHY GIBB 
 DESPITE the riches on offer in the men's game, the prize for the winner of the women's World Championship, which starts tomorrow, will be a miserly &pound;3,500. 
 The tournament, which runs for six days at Pontin's Holiday Club, in Brixham, south Devon, has 70 competitors taking part. 
 Pontin's, for the second consecutive year, have agreed to stage and sponsor the championship, assisting the women's game, which desperately needs the financial input and widespread television coverage enjoyed at present only by the men's game. 
 There is no physical strength involved in snooker, but Allison Fisher, the No. 1 seed and three-times world champion, possesses the skill and concentration which enables her to regain form after unexpected defeats. 
 Although she has again failed to earn her professional ticket, and with it the right to compete against the men, but she has defeated Mike Hallett in an exhibition match this year and has gained ample experience competing in Barry Hearn's Matchroom League. 
 On form, there is no one in the women's game who can compete with Fisher. 
 Last Sunday, in the Bristol Open, in Solihull, which Fisher went on to win, she scored 116 &mdash; the highest break achieved by a female player. 
 But, like all professionals, Fisher is prone to the odd upset. 
 Her close rivals, Stacey Hillyard, the No. 2 seed, and Ann Marie Farren, the No. 3 seed, have both defeated Fisher in previous competitions. 
 Hillyard, from Dorset, in 1984, when aged 14, became the youngest player, to win the world title, after defeating Fisher in the semi-finals &mdash; a result which she repeated in 1987, only to lose 5-1 in the final to the then 15-year-old Farren. 
 Farren, who beat Fisher 3-2 in last August's Hellerman Deutsch Classic, has since suffered some unexpected defeats, winning only the Pontin's Women's Bowl, this May. 
 Basketball: Lee case unsettling for Rams 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 ERNEST LEE faces a fine and possible suspension this weekend after becoming unwittingly enmeshed in the red tape which is also likely to bring punishment on Derby Rams. 
 The American has become the Carlsberg League club's leading scorer since joining them this season. 
 But he should not have played since 1 October, when temporary clearance from the English Basket Ball Association expired. 
 The Association, which has responsibility for licensing players, and the League told Derby that Lee was ineligible. 
 The club's original application to the American authorities for his transfer had to be resubmitted and clearance has not yet arrived. 
 Martin Shaw, the Derby director who represents his club on the League management board, said: &bquo;The existing rules allow for flexibility in dealing with a case where the player clearly has done nothing wrong himself.&equo; 
 David Clarke, the League administrator, added: &bquo;The Association is being inflexible and unhelpful.&equo; 
 Since the start of the month, Lee has played in two League matches, including a 105-83 win at London Docklands. 
 Derby's action in disregarding Lee's ineligibility may force the League to order a rematch or award the game to London. 
 Lee's case is now on the agenda for today's competitions committee meeting in London. 
 The Week in Review: Sport 
 By DUNCAN HOOPER 
 SUNDAY: Michael Kinane, Ireland's champion jockey, wins the Prix de l'Arc de Triomphe at Longchamp on the British-trained 19-1 outsider, Carroll House, a day after partnering The Caretaker to victory in the Cartier Million, Europe's most valuable race. 
 MONDAY: With ominous power, the All Blacks beat British Columbia 48-3 the day before arriving to start their United Kingdom tour. 
 Amid claims and counter-claims, friends of Michael Knighton, the aspiring Manchester United chairman, report he is close to arranging a deal to salvage his attempted take-over. 
 The San Francisco Giants beat Chicago Cubs in the National League Championship play-off to join Oakland Athletics, American League conquerors of Toronto Blue Jays, in baseball's World Series. 
 TUESDAY: As England's senior footballers marshall their resources in Chorzow, Steve Bull scores twice as the Under-21s beat their Polish counterparts 3-1. 
 WEDNESDAY: A point-winning string of saves from Peter Shilton against Poland takes England into next year's World Cup finals. 
 With one point needed from their last two games Scotland lose 3-0 in France. 
 The Republic of Ireland beat Northern Ireland 3-0, but Hungary's draw with Spain means Jack Charlton's team must wait for the arithmetic to be resolved. 
 Knighton and the United chief executive, Martin Edwards, tear up their take-over contract &bquo;in the interests of the club&equo;. 
 THURSDAY: Herschel Walker, the running back who rushed more than 1,500 yards for the Dallas Cowboys in 1988, is traded to the Minnesota Vikings for five players and up to seven draft picks. 
 FRIDAY: UEFA halve the two-season ban imposed on Ajax for the crowd trouble against Austria Vienna last month. 
 In golf's World Matchplay Championship quarter-finals at Wentworth, Seve Ballesteros beats the American, Chip Beck, 9 and 8, but Nick Faldo is taken to the 38th hole by South Africa's David Frost before winning a sudden-death play-off. 
 Triathlon: Ironman Scott will galvanise the field 
 From GORDON RILEY in Kailua-Kona, Hawaii 
 THIS MORNING at 7am, 1,250 pairs of arms will churn the warm blue water of the Pacific into foam as the competitors set off on the first, swimming stage of the 11th Ironman Triathlon on and around the little resort of Kailua-Kona here. 
 The Hawaii Ironman is the original and ultimate triathlon, where the swim is through 2.4 miles of ocean, and is immediately followed by a 112-mile cycle ride up on the black lava fields, where by mid-morning the temperature will be over 100 degrees. 
 The ride will take the top competitors less than five hours, but the race will still not be over, as there is still a full marathon to be run. 
 Dave Scott, then, must be a specially galvanised sort of Ironman, having won the event six times, and holding the course record of 8hr 28min 37sec, a time he predicts will be shattered today. 
 To push him towards a record, Scott will be challenged by Mark Allen, six-times winner of the Nice Triathlon, plus Mike Pigg, Ken Glah and Scott Tinley, while the top European will probably be Rob Barel, from The Netherlands. 
 The women's champion, Paula Newby-Fraser, from Zimbabwe, who set a course record of 9hr 1min 1sec last year, is in good shape, having won at Nice in May. 
 Her opposition, drawn mainly from north America, includes Britain's Sarah Springman. 
 Springman, 32, was seventh last year. 
 She is in good form and hoping to break the 10-hour barrier today, having already done so in the European Ironman in August, where she took an individual bronze and a team gold medal. 
 Rowing: Redgrave in Serpentine test 
 By HUGH MATHESON 
 FIVE nations compete on the Serpentine this weekend in a six-event accumulator for a possible &pound;5,000. 
 The Serpentine Regatta, in its third year, is an indicator of rowing's future, a sprint event at a venue easily accessible for the public. 
 The international regatta on Sunday afternoon is an ingenious test of rowing skill and versatility, where a maximum of nine oarsmen must be deployed among six events, with no individual competing in more than three races. 
 West Germany, in the event for the first time, bring four world champions to Hyde Park to take on a British team that has six silver and bronze medallists from the recent World Championships, as well as squads from Italy, the Soviet Union and France. 
 Steve Redgrave twice an Olympic gold medallist, will race for Britain in the single sculls, the coxless pair and the eight. 
 Because the Serpentine course is only 500 metres long, a quarter of the normal international competition distance, success is dependent on an explosive start and high technical skill. 
 High winds and borrowed equipment have in the past two years reduced some events to water-borne stock-car racing, with Olympic champions disappearing in a welter of spray and shame. 
 Today's racing centres on the national dragon boat championship, with 1,400 competitors, the winners to represent Britain in Hong Kong next year. 
 Ice Hockey: Pandas punish Wasps 
 From STEVE PINDER in Rotterdam 
 DURHAM WASPS' dream of becoming the first British League team to win a European game abroad ended in a 10-1 defeat here last night after Robert Herckerrath had opened the scoring for Gunco Pandas of Rotterdam in the second minute. 
 Pressed back over their own blue line, Wasps rallied around their minder, Frank Killen, and held out for another two minutes before Herckerrath added a second as three of the Wasps sat out penalties in the box. 
 Pandas then took a turn in their penalty box but &mdash; despite fierce shots from their captain, Paul Smith &mdash; Durham were unable to capitalise on the power play and, with two minutes of the period left, Bert Hille's slapshot made it 3-0. 
 The second period was much the same story, Ron Barteling and Robert Nerckenrath making it 5-0 in four minutes. 
 Jamie Richmond added another on the stroke of half time and Gert Jan Vreevurg brought the score up to 7-0 with a slapshot from the point. 
 For Wasps, there was no chance of making a recovery &mdash; even though their duck was eventually broken when Rick Brevant passed to Robert Forbes with 13 minutes remaining &mdash; Pandas running on to complete a comfortable victory with three goals in 90 seconds. 
 Golf: Beck is burned in the &bquo;crucible of humiliation&equo; 
 From TIM GLOVER at Wentworth 
 SANDY LYLE conducted another exercise in self-immolation while Chip Beck discovered that his gunpowder was damp and useless but at least the American left a legacy after his first visit to the Suntory World Matchplay Championship. 
 After losing to Ronan Rafferty by one hole in the quarter-finals, Lyle remarked: &bquo;I'm over the moon. 
 I've never felt better.&equo; 
 Beck was overwhelmed 9 and 8 by Seve Ballesteros and his response was somewhat more original: &bquo;Every good man is tested in the crucible of humiliation. 
 I think that is where I have been today.&equo; 
 But then Beck majored in journalism at the University of Georgia. 
 While Beck's adventures were cut short, Nick Faldo, beaten by Lyle in last year's final, went into overtime against David Frost of South Africa before coming through on the 38th hole. 
 In a match made in heaven, if not the sponsors' dreams, Faldo will play Ballesteros in the semi-finals today and Rafferty will meet Ian Woosnam. 
 On the prospect of facing Ballesteros, Faldo, who did not get a degree in journalism, remarked: &bquo;With all the time he's had off this afternoon I hope Carmen will have worn him out. 
 I hope she gives him a right going over.&equo; 
 Carmen Ballesteros, for one, would probably love to know exactly what he meant by that. 
 Faldo, who has never won this championship, went into lunch one hole down against Frost who had a 66 to a 67. 
 The scores were transposed in the afternoon although Faldo appeared to have matters in hand from the 35th. 
 Up to then he had never been in front &mdash; he was three down with 11 holes to play &mdash; but he went one up at the 17th the second time around. 
 He did not hit a crisp drive but recovered with an excellent three wood which enabled him to secure a birdie four to Frost's par. 
 After hammering another three wood on to the green at the 36th, Faldo's position seemed impregnable. 
 However, he left his first putt five feet short and missed that to take a five to Frost's four. 
 Both had pars at the 37th - their third visit of the day to the first hole &mdash; and the end came at the short second where Faldo hit a seven-iron to three feet to break the deadlock with a two to a three. 
 Ballesteros, who has won the title four times, opened up with a 66 and enjoyed a comfortable lunch, sitting on a cushion of a five-hole lead. 
 Beck, who had defeated Aki Ohmachi of Japan 8 and 6 in the first round, was heading for an even bigger defeat. 
 He lost five of the first seven holes in the afternoon and was in danger of going into the record books as Wentworth's bloodiest casualty. 
 An 18-foot putt on the 26th by the American meant that Dale Hayes, beaten 11 and 9 by Tom Watson in 1978, was left holding that particular nettle. 
 &bquo;I must have got out of the wrong side of the bed,&equo; Beck said. 
 &bquo;I don't want to take anything away from Seve. 
 He played a lot of great shots but I felt I beat myself. 
 I hit it all over the place. 
 It's the craziest thing. 
 I will learn from this. 
 It will make me a stronger man.&equo; 
 Before the match Beck had said he hoped Ballesteros would be at his best and his wish was granted. 
 The Spaniard had only one bogey &mdash; at the 13th &mdash; and was nine under par when the match reached its premature conclusion. 
 Lyle, who lives on the estate here, will be able to watch Faldo, his fellow Wentworth member, on television today. 
 Lyle was three up after 22 holes against Rafferty but then once again went through the crucible of humiliation. 
 There were several watersheds. 
 At the 28th hole, the 10th, Lyle was five feet from the flag off the tee and the Irishman missed the green. 
 Rafferty chipped in from 20 yards, Lyle missed. 
 Lyle one up. 
 At the next they were all square when Lyle missed from three feet. 
 A birdie two at the 32nd gave Rafferty the lead and he went two up at the 34th where Lyle, disturbed mid-swing by the clicking of a camera, pulled his tee shot into the trees on the left. 
 He attempted to escape by hitting a nine-iron left-handed but succeeded in only moving the ball a couple of inches. 
 He conceded the hole and although he won the 35th two fours at the last saw Rafferty home. 
 Woosnam reached his third successive semi-final with a 3 and 2 victory over Olazabal after the Spaniard held a one-hole lead in the morning. 
 Woosnam was so dissatisfied with his putting that he missed lunch and spent an hour on the practice green. 
 Olazabal should have emulated him for in the afternoon he proceeded to miss a string of short putts. 
 Woosnam piled on the agony with four successive birdies. 
 Golf: Feherty to spin himself a cocoon 
 From TIM GLOVER at Wentworth 
 DAVID FEHERTY missed four short putts in the BMW tournament, in Munich yesterday, but still leads the field by six strokes. 
 The 31-year-old Ulsterman had another fine run of birdies on the new course to record a 66 for a remarkable 16-under-par, two-round total of 128. 
 Only Sandy Lyle, who was 17 under in the 1983 Swiss Open, has bettered that half-way score on the PGA tour. 
 With Kent's Peter Mitchell, who had a 67, far behind in second, Feherty now is going &bquo;to put on the blinkers&equo;. 
 He said: &bquo;It's lonely being a long way ahead so you have to get youself into a cocoon to protect yourself from the thoughts that can trouble your mind.&equo; 
 Feherty made an ideal start by sinking a 65-foot putt for a birdie at his opening hole, the 10th. 
 He also birdied the 11th, but then dropped his only shot of the round at the 12th, after playing a poor bunker shot and missing from 15 feet. 
 He also missed three from inside six feet. 
 Davis Love III, the American, slipped from second place with a one-over-par 73 for 138, and another American, Mark Calcavecchia, missed the cut for the second successive tournament. 
 Golf: Davies' investment in excellence 
 By JOHN BOLTON 
 LAURA DAVIES produced a marvellous exhibition for those loyal supporters who opted for Stoke Poges rather than nearby Wentworth, with a round of 64 in the second round of the Laing Charity Classic yesterday. 
 With a 10-under-par halfway aggregate of 136, the former British and United States Open champion moves into today's third round one stroke ahead of Susan Moon, with Spain's Xonia Wunsch one stroke further adrift. 
 A &pound;19.95 investment in a Blackjack putter is the catalyst which has brought about a change in fortune for Davies. 
 Yesterday, she took only 28 putts as she equalled the course record. 
 &bquo;I had been playing well since I returned from America, but the putts have just not dropped. 
 I holed a good putt for a birdie at the first hole and that set me up,&equo; she said. 
 This was the first of the eight birdies Davies gathered, the best of all being her three at the 315-yard 13th hole, where she drove the green. 
 A wedge approach to three feet produced an eagle three at the ninth, while her solitary lapse was the four she made at the short 16th. 
 Moon had set the target early in the day. 
 In her opening round of 67 on Thursday, the American made fours at each of the five long holes, and it was the same par fives which served her well yesterday. 
 Without a tour success since 1980, Moon had 35 putts in yesterday's 70, such was the consistency of her play through the green. 
 Moon birdied four of the par fives, three-putted the seventh and completed her round with only her second single putt of the day to save par at the 18th. 
 Rugby Union: That old Black magic ready to cast its spell 
 By STEVE BALE, Rugby Union Correspondent 
 IT TAKES about five minutes in New Zealand to comprehend why the All Blacks are the best. 
 Everyone &mdash; from the woman who stamps your passport, through the taxi driver, to the hotel receptionist &mdash; talks constantly and instinctively about rugby. 
 To these people, Black is beautiful. 
 Put another way, the All Blacks have the whole nation behind them, and even Wales cannot quite claim that. 
 So when they run out to kick off their tour against Cardiff at the Arms Park this afternoon, around three million souls (a population not much bigger than that of the Principality) will be with them in spirit. 
 For these superlative players it is a position of great privilege, but also intense pressure. 
 &bquo;The expectation of the New Zealand public is very high,&equo; Wayne Shelford, the All Blacks captain, said. 
 &bquo;They expect us to win by a reasonable margin nowadays.&equo; 
 Thus, through the effect of public opinion, do his team's standards have to be set higher and higher. 
 To the Welsh, this has a familiar ring. 
 When Wales were successful in the Seventies (and even then they could not beat the Blacks), mere victory was not enough; it had to be done with panache and by a heap of points to satisfy the demands of a voracious populace. 
 The fall, when it came with the Eighties, was from a great height. 
 In New Zealand's case, &bquo;if&equo; rather than &bquo;when&equo; is a better word to use when considering the possibility of a fall. 
 Their three-year run of 17 Test wins equals the All Black record, and it takes no great clairvoyant skill to predict that this will be broken against Wales on 4 November and extended against Ireland a fortnight later. 
 If it is true that some of them are not quite what they were &mdash; and even this grasped-at straw is no more than speculation &mdash; we may rest assured that the successor generation brought on tour to breathe down their necks will be as good if not better. 
 &bquo;We have too much competition within the side for there to be any complacency,&equo; Shelford said. 
 This is the comment of an All Black thought to be under as much threat as any, in his case from the Auckland No. 8 Zinzan Brooke (whose christian name, incidentally, is English not Maori). 
 That Shelford has a few doubters to disprove is cold comfort to Cardiff, who have had an unconvincing start to the season and whose main hope is to catch the tourists either cold or rusty after a lay-off which for most has lasted all of a fortnight. 
 Even Alan Phillips, the former Wales hooker who became Cardiff coach this season, concedes that now is not the moment for his players. 
 &bquo;If they have a bit of jet-lag or anything that's going wrong we have the chance to get among them early on,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The only problem is it's about a year too soon for us. 
 But we've got a young side at Cardiff now and it's good for them to play against these players, to see that they're only human beings after all.&equo; 
 Neither jet-lag nor anything going wrong has been evident at the tourists' training, which has been comfortably the most impressive seen in Cardiff since&hellip; well, since the last time the All Blacks were there in 1980. 
 Then, at today's venue, they beat Wales 23-3 (a margin greeted with horror by the Welsh at the time) and Cardiff 16-9. 
 Yesterday produced the tour's first injury scare of any note. 
 John Kirwan, the wing who has scored 25 tries in 30 Tests, missed training with an inflamed Achilles tendon but is firmly expected to play. 
 (Steve Ford, who will mark Kirwan, is part of a family double; brother Phil plays for Leeds against the NZ rugby league tourists tomorrow.) 
 Cardiff's concern, as it will be for everyone else the All Blacks play in their seven matches in Wales, five in Ireland and one in England, is that the tourists match the mood of their public back home. 
 They beat everyone in sight &mdash; and still yearn to do better. 
 To take a memorable example, even after thrashing Wales 52-3, 10 tries to nil, in Christchurch last year they were thoroughly dissatisfied with themselves. 
 Things have not changed: as Cardiff are about to find, these All Blacks are at once an irresistible force and immovable object. 
 0p3 0p3 Cardiff: M Rayer; C Thomas, M Ring, G John, S Ford; D Evans, A Booth; J Whitefoot, I Watkins, D Young, H Stone, M Rowley, T Crothers, M Edwards, R Collins. 
 Football: UEFA halves Ajax ban to a year 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 AJAX, disqualified from European competition for two years after their fans had caused the abandonment of a UEFA Cup tie, had the punishment halved on appeal yesterday. 
 The Dutch club were banned when misbehaviour by their supporters, who threw missiles on to the pitch, felling the opposition goalkeeper with a metal spike, brought a premature end to the first-round match at home to Austria Vienna last month. 
 UEFA awarded the Austrians a 3-0 win, and a second-round place. 
 After considering Ajax's appeal, UEFA reduced their suspension from two years to one. 
 The Football Association was also preoccupied with disciplinary matters yesterday, fining Peter Reid &pound;1,000 and suspending the Queen's Park Rangers midfielder for two matches, banning Arsenal's Gus Caesar for three and summoning Wimbledon's manager, Bobby Gould, and Ray Wallace of Southampton, to appear before them on Thursday to answer unrelated charges of bringing the game into disrepute. 
 Reid was found to have made &bquo;foul comments&equo; to the referee, George Tyson, at the end of QPR's match against Manchester City on 9 September, while Caesar's punishment follows his sending-off during Arsenal's pre-season friendly against Independiente in the United States. 
 A UEFA tribunal yesterday set the fee for Michael Laudrup's transfer from Juventus to Barcelona at &pound;1.2m. 
 Because of their players' League commitments in England, the Republic of Ireland have cancelled their friendly international against Yugoslavia on 14 December. 
 Sport in Short: Windsurfing 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Tennis 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 BORIS BECKER has pulled out of a third tournament, the Tokyo Grand Prix, which begins on Monday, because of a nagging knee injury. 
 He hopes to be fit to defend his Masters title at the end of next month and has begun light training. 
 Sport in Short: Squash 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Speedway 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Sailing 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Rugby Union 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 ALAIN GALLO, a former player with the French club Agen, has made claims that team-mates were being paid as long as 10 years ago. 
 In a letter published yesterday in the French sports paper L'Equipe, Gallo alleges that leading players today earn up to &pound;600 a month, plus expenses. 
 &bquo;All those involved in French rugby are businessmen,&equo; Gallo said. 
 Sport in Short: Rugby League 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 CHRIS BURTON, Featherstone's former Great Britain forward, has been suspended for five matches by the Rugby League disciplinary committee after being sent off for a head tackle in Featherstone's home championship defeat by Leeds last Sunday. 
 Sport in Short: Motor Racing 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Judo 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Ice Skating 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Gymnastics 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 ADRIANA DUFFY, the 18-year-old American gymnast, broke her neck in Stuttgart yesterday while training on a vaulting horse for the World Championships which begin tomorrow.. 
 Sport in Short: Golf 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Football 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Equestrianism 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Cricket 
 By JOE LOVEJOY 
 VIV RICHARDS showed his renewed appetite for the game with a fine all-round performance as West Indies beat India by five wickets in the opening Sharjah Cup match yesterday. 
 He ran out two batsmen, took two wickets with his off-spin and helped West Indies recover from 31 for 3 with a quick 34. 
 RODNEY ONTONG, 33, the former Glamorgan captain, who had to retire from the game after a car crash, is to sue the county for damages in his benefit year. 
 The crash happened as Ontong, a Glamorgan player for 15 seasons, and Steve Barwick, his team-mate, were on the way to a Championship game in Essex 14 months ago. 
 Sport in Short: Boxing 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Sport in Short: Athletics 
 Weekend Sport Page 59 
 Rugby Union: Park to face the Bath backlash: Barrie Fairall on today's rugby union action 
 By BARRIE FAIRALL 
 COURAGE is the keyword this weekend, even among the nit-pickers who may have noted that the league sponsors' official directory lists today's third series of matches as having been played in midweek on 4 October. 
 Surely some mistake? 
 But there is no mistaking the fact that the First Division door has been left ajar. 
 This was due entirely to the ferocious efforts of Gloucester, no lovers of Bath, whose idea of a welcome last month was to treat their visitors rather like a doormat. 
 Indeed, there was a lot of &bquo;shoe&equo; put about at Kingsholm, and the end product was unfortunate to say the least. 
 Gareth Chilcott &mdash; popularised as the Oddjob of English rugby during the first World Cup in Australia in 1987, but affectionately referred to as &bquo;Coochie&equo; in these parts &mdash; was sent off for punching, and 14 men of Bath succumbed to Gloucester's 15. 
 &bquo;A great win,&equo; Mike Hamlin, Gloucester's affable and capable captain, said with a broad grin. 
 In Hamlin's opinion, the crucial thing about the result was that others would be grateful to Gloucester for knocking the champions down a peg or two. 
 &bquo;It's opened up the league,&equo; Hamlin said, &bquo;and we may not be the only ones to benefit.&equo; 
 The England B stand-off has a point, although the benefits may not be all that lasting. 
 Rosslyn Park, for example, are first in line to experience the probable backlash of that defeat when they set foot on the Recreation Ground this afternoon. 
 Park &mdash; like Gloucester, Bristol and Saracens &mdash; are unbeaten in the league so far. 
 &bquo;Don't be surprised if we get a good result,&equo; Colin Horgan, a spokesman for the club, said yesterday. 
 Brave words, but Horgan will be able to put some distance between himself and the pitch. 
 Out there, it will be hard and uncompromising stuff as Bath seek a return to the winning habit on the afternoon that Stuart Barnes has chosen to return. 
 The captain and stand-off has taken time out to recover fully from a pre-season hand injury, and Bath will be grateful of his guidance. 
 Gloucester, in the meantime, descend on Wasps, who, having lost out at Harlequins, have shored up their pack with their England props, Jeff Probyn and Paul Rendall. 
 Rugby Union: Wallabies enjoy the festivities 
 By NICK CAIN 
 Australia, shorn of some 12 Test players due to unavailability, stopped off in Canada on the way to their eight-match engagement in France to join in British Columbian rugby's centenary celebrations. 
 They also put in a visit to Edmonton where, last weekend, their dirt-trackers beat the North American Wolverines (non-BC Canadians, plus two Americans) 24-6. 
 British Columbia, who fielded only five of the players that tackled the All Blacks, have acquitted themselves admirably in a four-day period that has seen them take on the might of the two Antipodean giants. 
 The locals, inspired by three superb long-range penalties from their full back, had the satisfaction of raising the roof with their one try of the game. 
 But there was no fairy-tale ending as Bob Dwyer's men set about party-pooping in serious fashion when the experienced half-back combination of Nick Farr-Jones and Michael Lynagh began to click, each scoring a try. 
 Dwyer said: &bquo;I think we can develop into a handy side given another three or four games. 
 All our boys ran and handled well and the forwards looked quite tight. 
 There's a lot of talent among these youngsters and we expect a lot of them.&equo; 
 But for all Dwyer's optimism, this was just the sort of loose game in which the Wallabies excel and, although they have undoubted talent, the youngsters are going to find things considerably tighter in France. 
 Cricket: Stewart's sun set to shine brightly 
 From MARTIN JOHNSON in New Delhi 
 ENGLAND'S second warm-up match for the Nehru Trophy may not have been the biggest event here yesterday (of the 100 or so people who turned up, about a dozen were neither sponsors nor members of the Delhi constabulary), but it did, by happy chance, provide near-perfect practice for their opening group match against Sri Lanka tomorrow. 
 The opposition thoughtfully provided a batting line-up of stroke-playing dashers, and bowlers that could easily have been selected at random from a passing Delhi omnibus. 
 As this is more than a fair reflection of Sri Lanka's strengths and weaknesses, it was all very accommodating. 
 England won comfortably enough, as indeed they ought to have done against a team containing 10 players whose ages ranged between 16 and 21, and one - Madan Lal &mdash; who lays claim to being 38, despite the strong suspicion that (were he as famous as Nehru) the Centenary Trophy could just as easily have been named after him. 
 However, the Sri Lankans are always dangerous floaters in events such as these. 
 With four teams to qualify from six for the semi-finals, they are 100-1 on to finish last, but if any of the others has a bowling off-day against them, it could well be thank you and goodbye. 
 England twice beat them easily enough in the World Cup (by 138 runs and eight wickets), but in the opening match of that competition, Pakistan only succeeded in defending 267 against them by 15 runs. 
 England's batsmen looked in decent enough form yesterday on a shirt-front pitch, nor does the heat appear to be causing them undue distress. 
 But then again this is the one form of cricket they are reasonably competent at. 
 Since the advent of Micky Stewart as team manager, England have won 29 of their 43 one-dayers (one tied), and three of 29 Test matches. 
 Whether this lopsided record and Stewart's stewardship is more than just coincidental will be a matter for the Test and County Cricket Board to discuss when his contract comes up again next April. 
 Wayne Larkins (123 in the first practice game) retired again, this time on 55, which left Graham Gooch (90 off 95 balls and unbothered by anyone resembling an Alderman) to enjoy the rare experience just lately of batting with more than one partner. 
 Allan Lamb and Alec Stewart also made half-centuries, and the manager's son could well play tomorrow whether England pick Jack Russell to keep wicket or not. 
 There is certainly the prospect of Stewart, a slow starter but a class player when set, rivalling Robert Bailey for the No. 3 batting spot in the Caribbean. 
 England's one fitness doubt tomorrow concerns Phillip DeFreitas, who was resting a sore elbow yesterday, but otherwise their major problem is whether to play both their spinners. 
 Eddie Hemmings is already inked in, but Nick Cook &mdash; still trying to puzzle out why he has been brought here but overlooked in favour of Keith Medlycott for the West Indies &mdash; may end up as one of the drinks carriers. 
 Not an unimportant role in a place as hot as this, but not quite the one he has in mind. 
 Nasser Hussain may get in on the strength of his fielding. 
 If DeFreitas is out and Lamb remains unable to throw the ball properly, England's outfield would have a Madame Tussaud's look about it, which is also a point in favour of David Capel above Derek Pringle. 
 Capel's presence here, though, does not mean that England &mdash; and Micky Stewart in particular &mdash; have shed their doubts about his ability to contain, and there was no evidence yesterday that Capel has yet acquired the mental capacity to try to bore people out in one-day cricket. 
 The local team's reply to England's 334 for 4 was a not unimpressive 221 for 3, with a trio of schoolboy prodigies ('We could produce them like this on better pitches,&equo; Stewart said) in their line-up. 
 Vinod Kambli (aged 18) and Sachin Tendulkar (17) appear destined for full Test careers, although yesterday's partnership of nought was 644 runs fewer than the one they shared in a schools game two years ago. 
 Football: Brazil scratch seven-year itch: Paddy Agnew in Rome on a match which many Italian fans would like to see repeated in the 1990 World Cup final 
 By PADDY AGNEW 
 ITALY play Brazil in Bologna this afternoon in a game that one section of the Italian press, with typical enthusiasm, has christened &bquo;The Friendly of the Century&equo;. 
 Hyperbole, perhaps, but this meeting of two of world football's traditionally strongest sides should none the less prove highly informative. 
 Not only does Italy-Brazil represent many people's ideal coupling for next summer's World Cup final in Rome but this afternoon's game also marks the first occasion the two countries have met since that afternoon seven years ago in Spain when the Italians dismissed Falcao, Zico, Junior et al, 3-2 on their way to winning the 1982 World Cup. 
 Times have changed since then. 
 As Brazil's midfield dynamo, Dunga, of Fiorentina, says with a wry grin: &bquo;Brazil 1989 wouldn't have lost that game to Italy in 1982. 
 Today, we might play less spectacular soccer. 
 But we get results.&equo; 
 Since taking over as Brazil's manager on 6 January, Sebastiano Lazaroni has attempted to pull off a transformation that has hitherto seemed impossible in Brazilian football. 
 He has tried to &bquo;stiffen&equo; the side defensively, to teach the virtues of match-long disciplined marking without stifling his players' natural creative talents. 
 With the South American championship trophy on the sideboard and the side safely through to next summer's World Cup finals, it would seem that the Lazaroni system has worked pretty well so far. 
 Against Italy, Lazaroni is keen to experience a foretaste of the atmosphere that he and his side can expect next summer. 
 Key figures in the new-look Brazilian team are the goalkeeper, Taffarel, the libero, Galvao, the midfield ball winners, Dunga and Alemao, and the strikers, Bebeto and, of course, Careca. 
 When asked to assess the opposition, manager Lazaroni replied diplomatically that he fears no single Italian player, rather he fears the whole side. 
 Lazaroni's opposite number, Azeglio Vicini, can call on an almost full-strength squad for a game in which he hopes Italy will prove his assertion that the side has made significant progress since being defeated by the Soviet Union in last summer's European Championship semi-final. 
 Walter Zenga in goal, Franco Baresi the libero, and Gianluca Vialli in attack, will carry the brunt of the responsibility today. 
 Most Italian eyes, however, will be focussed on &bquo;wonder boy&equo; Roberto Baggio, of Fiorentina. 
 A good performance from Baggio today would probably guarantee his place in Vicini's World Cup side. 
 Football: McLean in looting mission: Don Lindsay on today's Scottish programme 
 By DON LINDSAY 
 AS THE title of his admirable autobiography &mdash; Jousting with Giants &mdash; admits, Jim McLean has always enjoyed taking on the Scottish game's major forces. 
 Dundee United have been the corner shop competing with the hypermarkets of Glasgow, and business has been brisk with pockets of profitability. 
 Another trip to the Ibrox superstore beckons for McLean this afternoon, and the United manager would dearly love to sneak out by the tradesmen's entrance after slipping the points into his travelling bag, leaving Rangers to balance the books in a highly competitive Premier Division. 
 The Tayside men hold an advantage of a single point over their well-heeled Glaswegian rivals, and they traditionally fare well on visits to Govan. 
 Indeed, McLean was the first manager to inflict a home League defeat on Graeme Souness after his immersion into Ibrox life. 
 There is brighter news for the Rangers boss on the selection front. 
 Chris Woods has been added to Souness's squad along with Mark Walters and John Brown, although both Fergusons, Ian and Derek, will be absent. 
 Only five points cover the entire Division, and top encounters bottom at Dens Park. 
 Dundee, who languish in the basement, and Celtic, the leaders, are the two highest-scoring teams, although neither has a defence which would intimidate opponents. 
 Celtic are likely to be without the last Parkhead man to score, Joe Miller, injured playing for the Scotland Under-21s in midweek. 
 A genuine and pleasant surprise has been the development of Motherwell, previously forced to carry the banner of the most boring team in the League. 
 Tommy McLean, the Fir Park boss, was responsible for a shrewd piece of business which saw his old Rangers colleague Davie Cooper join the Steelmen to add dashes of invention and experience. 
 Cooper's contribution has galvanised the club, and they now have the same points as Celtic and Aberdeen, with a visit to second-placed Hibernian in prospect this afternoon. 
 Football: Team news 
 By DON LINDSAY 
 ARSENAL v MAN CITY Marwood is ready to return for the champions after proving his fitness in the reserves on Thursday. 
 Allen and McNab are fit again, but will be restricted to the bench by City, who will not change the team that has scored 12 in winning their last three games. 
 CHARLTON v TOTTENHAM Charlton, beaten in their last four League games without scoring, include Achampong, the former Fulham striker, in place of the injured Mortimer. 
 Peake is fit to return in midfield. 
 Spurs' squad of 14 includes Garland, 19, a forward yet to appear in the League, and Butters, recovered from injury. 
 COVENTRY v NOTTM FOREST Coventry are without Drinkell, their record signing, who has pulled a thigh muscle, but Kilcline, McGrath and Gynn are all available again. 
 Hodge, who injured a hamstring training with England, is fit to return for Forest. 
 DERBY v CRYSTAL PALACE Derby, still without Cross (knee), are likely to retain the team who beat Cambridge 5-0 in the Littlewoods Cup. 
 Palace, with seven points from their last three games, again use midfielder Thomas in central defence in place of the injured O'Reilly, and are expected to recall Pemberton at right-back at Shaw's expense. 
 EVERTON v MILLWALL McCall, who injured an ankle with Scotland Under-21s, is doubtful for Everton, who introduce Keown in defence in place of the injured Ratcliffe. 
 Tony Cottee reappears in a 14-man squad. 
 Millwall also choose from 14, with Briley, Coleman and McLeary hoping to start. 
 LUTON v ASTON VILLA Nielsen, Villa's Danish defender, will start for the first time if McGrath fails to recover from the hamstring injury which kept him out of the Republic of Ireland team in midweek. 
 Williams returns to the Luton midfield, six weeks after a cartilage operation, in place of the suspended Kennedy, and Rodger is set for his League debut at centre-half. 
 MAN UTD v SHEFF WED Ince has recovered from a groin strain and United are unchanged for Ron Atkinson's return to Old Trafford. 
 Wednesday will be unchanged after their 8-0 drubbing of Aldershot in the Littlewoods Cup &mdash; provided Palmer shakes off a knee injury. 
 NORWICH v CHELSEA Norwich, unbeaten but yet to win at home, are unchanged for the seventh match in succession. 
 Chelsea include defenders Hall and Cundy, 19, in a squad of 15. 
 QPR v SOUTHAMPTON Rangers are unchanged, but Trevor Francis delays his choice of substitute. 
 Southampton, already deprived of Forrest and Ray Wallace by injury and suspension, hope Horne, their Welsh international midfielder, will recover from a groin strain in time to deputise at right-back. 
 WIMBLEDON v LIVERPOOL Wimbledon are unchanged, which means Lawrie Sanchez has to be content with a substitute's role. 
 Liverpool give John Barnes only an even-money chance of recovering from his hamstring strain. 
 Ian Rush (groin) is also doubtful. 
 ELSEWHERE: Sunderland may be without Agboola (hamstring) at Leeds, who hope to recall Hendrie in place of Williams&hellip; 
 West Ham are without Gale and Brady for their visit to Second Division leaders Sheffield United. 
 Judo: Hughes makes light of her load 
 From PHILIP NICKSAN in Belgrade 
 &bquo;THEY keep on writing you off &mdash; but they're wrong,&equo; beamed a delighted Roy Inman, the women's team manager, as Ann Hughes, Britain's top lightweight, stepped off the mat having won her semi-final at the World Championships here yesterday. 
 She could not, however, carry off the gold medal, losing the final to the title holder, Cathy Arnaud of France, the European champion who, at 26, is at her fighting peak. 
 Hughes, aged29, has a remarkable record going back to the first women's World Championships in 1980 including a world gold in 1986, world bronze in 1987 and two European titles. 
 Yet she was not one of the women tipped to reach the finals here. 
 She comfortably made her semi-final, where she met the Canadian, Nathalie Gosselin. 
 At the half-way point, Gosselin attacked with a poor hip throw, Hughes nimbly stepped off it and managed a pick-up for yuko (five points). 
 Although there was still two minutes to go, the Liverpool-born fighter was too experienced to be drawn into a mistake. 
 In the final Arnaud was too strong, and threw Hughes twice, taking her backwards for a koka (three points) and then with a shoulder throw for yuko. 
 In her first fight, she armlocked Jaana Utrainen (Finland) and followed with two decision wins against the Australian Angela Deacon and the more problematic Kate Donahoe of the United States. 
 The British Judo Association has already begun to make use of her vast experience. 
 Hughes took the British junior team to Austria earlier this year, and the BJA has agreed to employ her as a part-time coach when she retires after the Commonwealth Games. 
 Roy Stone, the 22-year-old lightweight from Middlesex in his first major international, did well to take Bertalan Hajtos, Hungary's 1986 European champion, to a decision. 
 Motor Racing: Ferrari abandon Mansell appeals 
 From PHILIP NICKSAN in Belgrade 
 FERRARI yesterday decided to drop its appeals against the &pound;32,000 fine and ban imposed on Nigel Mansell following his failure to stop after being disqualified from the Portuguese Grand Prix, writes Maurice Hamilton. 
 The Portuguese authorities had promised to hear Ferrari's appeal against the fine next Wednesday, after which the FIA, the international automobile federation, was due to reach a decision on Ferrari's appeal over Mansell's ban from the Spanish Grand Prix which was staged on 1 October. 
 Ferrari, while still convinced their arguments against the sanctions were valid, but mindful of the tradition they represent, said they wished to &bquo;remove any disturbing elements from Formula One racing&equo; during the final two races of the season in Japan and Australia. 
 Apart from clearing Mansell's name if they upheld the appeal, the FIA tribunal would be of little further use to either the Englishman or his team. 
 The FIA said last week that the results of the Spanish Grand Prix would remain, regardless of the outcome of any appeal. 
 Ferrari's decision places Mansell in a dilemma. 
 He announced on the eve of the Spanish Grand Prix that he would contemplate retirement &bquo;sooner rather than later&equo; if the ban was not lifted. 
 Athletics: Making of Superman II: Daley Thompson's air of invincibility was undermined by a fear of the knife. 
 Now a knee operation could restore his athletic powers. 
 Neil Wilson reports 
 By NEIL WILSON 
 Thompson's career &mdash; the Daley record 1976 Olympic Games (Montreal) 18th 1977 European Juniors, 1st 1978 Commonwealth Games (Edmonton) lst European Championships (Prague) 2nd 1980 Olympic Games (Moscow) 1st World record (Gotzis) 8,648 pts 1982 World record (Gotzis) 8,730 pts European Championships (Athens) lst World record 8,774 Commonwealth Games, Brisbane, lst 1983 World Championships (Helsinki) lst 1984 Olympic Games (Los Angeles) lst World record 8,847 1986 Commonwealth Games (Edinburgh) lst European Championships (Stuttgart) lst 1987 World Championships (Rome) 9th 1988 Olympic Games (Seoul) 4th It has not been a good year for the class of &bquo;76. 
 David Moorcroft called it a day, and Steve Ovett cried in public and was urged to. 
 That leaves Daley Thompson as the sole survivor of the British men's team at the Montreal Olympics still at the top. 
 Will he be the next to go? 
 The question was given pertinence suddenly last month when Thompson, citing a knee injury, withdrew from a decathlon in France after only five events, already then 300 points behind the leader. 
 Was age catching up on him as well? 
 Every year or so since &bquo;76 found Thompson in some far-flung place, emerging from the fictional telephone box to do his Superman act and beat the world, or Europe or the Commonwealth, the great all-rounder, Victor Ludorum. 
 Britain took him for granted. 
 Recently, though, the trick has not worked. 
 He turned up without fail but there was an ordinariness about him. 
 Ninth in the world championships in Rome, fourth at the Olympic Games in Seoul. 
 Was Clark Kent a newspaperman after all? 
 Or perhaps the phone boxes were all vandalised. 
 We never knew because he never said, never offered mitigating circumstances. 
 &bquo;If you start, you're fit,&equo; he would say. 
 But he was not, and he knew it. 
 For the past three or four years, that finely-tuned body, that running, jumping and throwing machine, was flawed. 
 Behind his left knee-cap, a growth of calcium on his patellar tendon prevented the smooth working of the joint, a cartilage was chipped and fragments floated in the joint. 
 Thompson did not know the details then because he did not want to. 
 Doctors and physiotherapists were never allowed close enough to examine him. 
 &bquo;I've never been one for doctors, and hospitals were for visiting other people,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The thought of being in one for a week and unconscious for half a day wouldn't have appealed to me very much. 
 Not that I gave it serious thought. 
 I was always flippant about it.&equo; 
 Those who trained with him, the &bquo;old crowd&equo;, they knew. 
 &bquo;They could see I was taking it easier on some of the sessions and they told me so. 
 But I've never been the world's best listener. 
 Mine's a strange mentality, an invincible mentality. 
 I think I can do anything, one leg, no legs, one arm tied behind my back. 
 Whatever it takes.&equo; 
 The rest of the world was kept in ignorance. 
 What concern is it of theirs? 
 Thompson has never done what he does for anybody but himself. 
 He admits it. 
 Even Frank Dick, the coach close enough to him to be the one he ultimately asked to be with him for his operation, did not have an inkling until the competition in France that Thompson had not high-jumped in training all year. 
 For Thompson, living with the knee became a way of life. 
 He won the Commonwealth and European titles, married and became a father in the time he lived with his particular pain. 
 &bquo;Yes, about five years, but then I didn't at first have anything to judge my pain against. 
 I never felt stiff after training even before I was 27. 
 So whatever I felt, I'd think other people had worse. 
 &bquo;Only in the last three years did it get in the way of anything and I wasn't able to do any bounding (a vital exercise in training) or, in the end, any high jumping.&equo; 
 So why did he not sort it out three years ago? 
 &bquo;I was busy three years ago. 
 And two years ago, and last year. 
 There was always something going on. 
 I couldn't afford the time. 
 Well, I could have but then I always think I can do anything, don't I? 
 Even when I'm injured I think I can do it regardless. 
 The mentality that got me where I was, then held me back.&equo; 
 Did it really not come down to a fear of the knife? 
 &bquo;If I'm honest, yes. 
 Nothing else. 
 I can't think of another reason. 
 I have a very low threshold for pain. 
 I imagined the operation would be excrutiating.&equo; 
 Dick and the nurses told him that, even after the pre-med, they had to chase him round the ward to get him to remove his shorts. 
 &bquo;The silly thing is that it wasn't painful, not at all. 
 A headache would be worse. 
 And the pain I've had for three years was far worse. 
 It's a bit stiff still but I've had the stitches out and still no pain.&equo; 
 In the end, the decathlon in France convinced him. 
 &bquo;I knew I wasn't going great but I thought I'd score 8,200-8,300. 
 My training had started to get better at the back end of the summer. 
 I thought, &bquo;same as usual, a bit of inspiration and desire and it'll come right&equo;.' 
 Among the world's best decathletes, he wanted to &bquo;make a short, sharp statement&equo;. 
 He laughs at that now. 
 &bquo;I made that all right, didn't I? 
 I couldn't do it. 
 Or, at least, it was very difficult. 
 It had never hurt before in anything but high jump but this time it hurt long jumping. 
 I started sweating when they called out the bloke ahead of me in the high jump. 
 I knew it was going to hurt.&equo; 
 He managed only 1.91 metres (his best is 2.14), went through the motions in the final event of the first day, and quit. 
 The next morning, a Sunday, he agreed to Dick's suggestion to see a West German doctor, had tests done the following Wednesday and was referred to Zurich for an operation a week later. 
 &bquo;They said I'd just got 50-60 years wear out of the knee in 15 years.&equo; 
 Why the acceptance finally that there was no other way? 
 &bquo;The doctor said it would never get better by itself and could lead to arthritis. 
 That was the thing. 
 In the end it wasn't just for me but for those I wanted to share my life with. 
 I couldn't face having kids and not being able to kick a football to them.&equo; 
 This week, two weeks after the operation, he was limping well at his home in West London. 
 He had been round 18 holes at Wentworth, if only on a buggy, and spent an hour in the weights room working on his upper body. 
 In two weeks he will go to Germany for rehabilitation, and, by his doctor's &bquo;most optimistic expections&equo;, could be training as hard as he was in July by the end of December. 
 That makes a defence of his Commonwealth Games title unlikely. 
 His left thigh, his jumping take-off leg, which was always an inch and a half thicker than the right, is now two and a half inches thinner. 
 He is under 13 stone in weight for the first time since his teens. 
 He will not go only to compete. 
 &bquo;That's one thing Baron de Coubertin and I don't agree on.&equo; 
 But he thinks a score of 8,300 would be enough to win, compared to his world record of 8,847, so he will not rule it out. 
 &bquo;It'd be great to be there but I'm not that fussed. 
 I'm not planning to try so hard for it that I might break down.&equo; 
 The future is too precious, at least the three years of European and world championships ending in the Barcelona Olympics in 1992, his fifth Games. 
 His 34th birthday will be during the Games, as his 18th was during Montreal. 
 &bquo;When I started I was always in a hurry, wanting to get it done, to get up there. 
 Then I had four or five years when I was there. 
 I could relax, enjoy it. 
 Now I'm in a hurry again.&equo; 
 If he retires then, it will only be from the public arena. 
 &bquo;In 10 years, it won't be Crystal Palace but it may be Southern League, Division Seven.&equo; 
 Certainly nobody will tell him the moment to go. 
 &bquo;What right do people have to tell anybody they can't do something they like? 
 I get enjoyment out of a challenge. 
 OK, so they'll come a time when I'm not challenging the world record. 
 But it seems a shame not to challenge yourself because other people say you're not as good as you used to be. 
 So what? 
 &bquo;I keep hearing people say they don't want to see Ovett running 3:58 because they want to remember him running 3:48. 
 Would they stop a great painter painting just because his eyes were going and his brushwork wasn't as good? 
 Maybe he enjoys it. 
 Perhaps I wouldn't want to do it before an audience but then I've never performed for others. 
 I've always done it because I have a good time doing it. 
 I'll think of stopping when I'm not.&equo; 
 Does he regret now avoiding the operation all those years ago, before he failed to scale his own Olympian heights in Rome and Seoul? 
 &bquo;If I'd done it then, perhaps I wouldn't have been fit to go to the Olympics and worlds, and I'd hate to be sitting here now thinking I could have won. 
 I'd rather know I came fourth and ninth.&equo; 
 But does he not wonder what might have been had he been fit? 
 &bquo;No, I know exactly. 
 Nobody would have beaten me. 
 I still don't think there is anybody out there better than me. 
 Not yet. 
 Perhaps not born yet.&equo; 
 Fishing Lines: The staring eyes have it for a longer life 
 By KEITH ELLIOTT 
 THIS HAS been a very good week for fishermen and a very bad week for Findus, Bird's Eye and all the other producers of frozen peas and pizzas. 
 It hasn't been much of a week for my wife either; she now sees little prospect of winning back even a beefburger space in the deep freeze. 
 On the other hand, I've been as happy as a turkey in January, and all because of a story I spotted in a medical magazine, stating that regular lashings of oily fish cut sharply your chances of having a heart attack. 
 Tests show that eating lots of fibre or switching to polyunsaturated fats has about as much chance of prolonging your life as wearing a wig, but a kipper two or three times a week will have your life assurance rep collecting the premiums for ever. 
 Now one thing the Elliott household is not short of is oily fish. 
 Opening the deep freeze is like standing on stage at the Palladium: there are that many eyes staring out at you. 
 All four racks are crammed with fish as oily as a politician's smile. 
 There are eels, mackerel, salmon and trout. 
 There are even a few herrings for good measure. 
 (I didn't catch these because they are rarely taken on rod and line, but herrings make excellent bait for skate and pike. 
 You never know when you're going to need a herring). 
 There are quite a few other fish too; in fact, there are enough different species to make a show that would rival the daily display at Harrods. 
 Working from the top, there are a couple of skate wings, a few flounders, dabs and plaice, and a last bit of turbot. 
 Then there are the codling; wonderful eating and nothing like that tasteless stuff you buy with a crispy brown skin. 
 The third drawer is for big fish; a decent sea trout, a hefty cod, a couple of salmon. 
 We're always well off for salmon and trout because my friend Chris the Stuffer keeps us liberally supplied. 
 He's probably the country's top taxidermist, and he's sick to the gills with eating salmon. 
 He got so fed up with it that he even tried a salmon shepherd's pie to make it more interesting. 
 Even his cat won't touch it now. 
 When most people bring their catch of a lifetime to him, they don't realise that he just wants the skin, not the flesh. 
 (One of the few times we missed out was with a 200lb sturgeon caught in the North Sea. 
 We were looking forward to gorging ourselves, but the buyer was a restaurateur and his chef had skinned it so cleanly that there wasn't enough flesh for a sandwich). 
 On to the bottom shelf. 
 Still a few sea bass here, though they're so delicious that they hardly have time to freeze. 
 A few eels, caught in the sea rather than in the local river; plenty of mackerel, a chunk of monkfish, and some roach for pike deadbaits. 
 As you can see, there's not a lot of room for ice cream, crispy pancakes or TV dinners. 
 In fact, it's standing room only even for fish fingers. 
 This has been a source of some less than harmonious comments from my beloved. 
 She feels that I should take my cod and coalfish, garfish and grayling, salmon and sole and even the shark steaks, and install them in the old deep freeze in the garage. 
 The trouble is, that's impossible. 
 You see, Chris the Stuffer's deep freezes are so full that a while back, I promised him I would take the overflow. 
 So that one is now full of fish too. 
 I have not always found it easy to counter my wife's complaints that frozen peas have to be eaten the same day. 
 She has even suggested that a little less fishing might deplete the shoals enough to squeeze in a few vegetables. 
 But this new research has given me just the ammunition I need. 
 All I have to do is tell her that our cold stores are full of life-saving health foods, without which I would be keeling over and clutching my left ventricle. 
 The children, as long as they learn to whinge less about the bones, are all set to become nonagenarians. 
 The springer spaniels, who gulp down what the children leave, will probably outlive next door's parrot. 
 And I can go fishing to my heart's content. 
 Letter From Singapore: Touchstones lost in a State of constant repair 
 By RICHARD EATON 
 THEY have shut down Raffles for repairs. 
 Sipping a Sling does not have the same flavour of nostalgia when you are not sitting in the old hotel with the arches and verandahs imagining you are Somerset Maugham. 
 To provide a polite reminder that the country was started by Englishmen they took the Queen to a hostel called Raffles Hall and Westin Stamfords, another hotel. 
 This week was her first state visit here in 17 years. 
 She arrived in blue and white silk and wore floral dresses and a more natural smile than usual. 
 She was given a decent welcome by the crowd at the Ang Mo Kio town centre. 
 Of course, President Wee made most of the right remarks to relax her. 
 How lucky they were to have the English language, for instance, plus the system of law and public administration. 
 Wouldn't have happened without Sir Stamford Raffles and all that. 
 The PM, Mr Lee, expressed a slightly different view. 
 The Commonwealth would remain relevant, he said, and little pleases the Queen more than that. 
 But a few locals regretted her presence, and Lee Kuan Yew knows it. 
 In future, he said, &bquo;there won't be the same reference points, the same vocabulary, the same diction, the same touchstones&equo;. 
 Ah well, they are refurbishing plenty of other things besides the buildings and the language. 
 They are planning a 100 per cent digital phone system that will enable voice images and data to be carried on the line. 
 It will be linked to videophones, picture mail, teletext and home banking. 
 Is British Telecom itemising the bills back there yet? 
 There's a &bquo;Speak Mandarin' campaign on too. 
 Plus a powerful empathy with the plight of the peoples of Hong Kong. 
 The poor Chinese footballers understandably got a coolish reception in their World Cup qualifying tournament here, especially as they spoilt the script by winning their opening match. 
 What almost everyone is waiting for is the showdown between North and South Korea on Monday. 
 Nearly 40 years ago these two were trading bullets over the river Potong-Gang, and sometimes it is not far short of hostilities when they trade shots on the pitch. 
 There have been some serious ructions when they have played table tennis, with rows and cheating and shouting matches. 
 But with football it is going to be different. 
 Or so says the North Korean delegation leader, Li Han Bok. 
 &bquo;There will be no problem. 
 We are of the same blood, the same language,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;And the same nation.&equo; 
 Trouble is, as many people know, the South Koreans do not completely agree with the last bit. 
 Couldn't say who will win. 
 A draw would probably be the best result. 
 The South Koreans are rated because they made it to the last World Cup finals, but personally I will always think of the North Koreans in &bquo;66. 
 Remember Ayresome Park and that centre forward, what was his name, Pak Doo Ik? 
 Knee-high to a gnat but it made no difference. 
 Couldn't stop him. 
 The North Koreans whupped the Italians, and actually caused a debate on football in the Italian Parliament. 
 Then they led the Portuguese 3-0 at half-time until the great Eusebio galvanised them into action. 
 They've got another World Championship here, too, at the moment, the squash. 
 A Pakistani called Jansher Khan is the champion, and they will not give him his prize money because he walked out of the official dinner. 
 The other Khan, Jahangir, is the more popular one. 
 He once went five and a half years unbeaten and he is still as modest as a mouse. 
 He said he's pleased that Pakistan has decided to come back into the Commonwealth. 
 I reckon the Queen would like him. 
 Sports Diary: Quotes of the Week 
 By RICHARD EATON 
 It was a night for men and we had a lot of men out there. 
 Bobby Robson in Poland. 
 Throughout all of this Manchester United has been kicked around like a football. 
 Bobby Charlton on the take-over saga. 
 Whatever it brings, one day my son can turn round and say &bquo;My dad managed Real Madrid&equo;. 
 John Toshack. 
 Don't ask me if it was a good game &mdash; it would be like asking a surgeon if it was a good operation. 
 They didn't exactly have three girls at centre-back either. 
 Howard Wilkinson, Leeds manager, on criticism of team's performance at West Ham. 
 I've been trying to be a footballer, and that isn't me. 
 I got a bit carried away with the Wogan show and all that. 
 Vinny Jones. 
 Soccer star cut off my kitty's privates. 
 The People headline. 
 Player involved in alleged cat castration was a Leeds reserve. 
 We are not concerned with any bridges being built in South Africa so much as ensuring that our own are not destroyed. 
 Clive Rowlands, Welsh Rugby Union president, on severing of South Africa links. 
 I have torn Wales from my heart. 
 My wonderful memories are now sour. 
 The Welsh will crawl in future. 
 Dr Danie Craven, SA board president. 
 I was very lucky I was caught. 
 Ben Johnson, supporting crackdown on steroid use. 
 They're not really bookies these days, they're just debt collectors. 
 Jack Ramsden, husband of racehorse trainer Lynda. 
 Sports Diary: Cricket for John McCarthy 
 By RICHARD EATON 
 THE FRIENDS of John McCarthy have been reminding the Foreign Office that the British Government is the only government without a single success in efforts to achieve the release of any of its hostages. 
 Bearing in mind the England team's attempts to break out, cricket must have seemed an appropriate fund-raising event, and a knock-out competition among teams from the media will be played this weekend at North Middlesex CC, Park Road, Hornsey, London. 
 Sports Diary: Football: Wednesday night out 
 By RICHARD EATON 
 CONNOISSEURS of the bizarre will recall the night Sheffield Wednesday players spent on wintry moorland, one of their ex-commando trainer's ploys to get them out of the Third Division. 
 But how many know whether the expedition worked? 
 Howard Holmes does, and it is included in Owls Trivia (&pound;2.80, from Sheffield Trivia, 286 Meadowhead, S8 7UH). 
 A companion volume, Blades Trivia (surely the club's entire history?), asks how Leeds United's hopes of a win went up in smoke when Steve Cammack scored a late equaliser on April Fools' Day 1975. 
 The sponsors' firework display, timed to start on the final whistle, went off early, and during the distraction Cammack scored. 
 As for Wednesday, they descended from the company of sheep to beat the might of Chester 2-0. 
 Sports Diary: Athletics: Mind your language 
 By RICHARD EATON 
 AMAZING what the Tyneside air can do. 
 In the case of Primo Nebiolo, the mere fact of being in Gateshead suddenly seemed to give the president of the International Amateur Athletic Federation a fluency in the English language he had not erstwhile possessed. 
 Nebiolo was being stalked by World In Action, anxious to interview the Italian about the alleged disappearance of large sums of money from athletics. 
 He was conversing merrily in English at a reception during the European Cup meeting, but several weeks later in Rome when confronted by the television team he seemed to lose his linguistic powers. 
 Various requests were made for Granada to give up their film of the Gateshead meeting, but it will be included in their report on Nebiolo &mdash; and the Princess Royal's attempt next week to unseat him as chairman of the Association of Summer Olympic Federations &mdash; to be broadcast on Monday at 8.30 on ITV. 
 Sports Diary: American Football: The rude awakening 
 By RICHARD EATON 
 HER contacts book was known to be extensive, but who would have thought Cynthia Payne's network stretched to Austin, Texas. 
 Yet there was Lynn Amedee, an American football coach, resigning following disclosure of his &pound;11,690 &bquo;personal services&equo; contract. 
 Since Amedee's contributions to the world's most butch game are made as an &bquo;offensive co-ordinator&equo;, the spectre is raised of some extremely rude sessions down Ambleside Avenue. 
 Not so; &bquo;personal services&equo; in the obfuscating vocabulary of grid-iron means&hellip; well, nobody quite knows. 
 Amedee was employed in the college football system, which exists primarily to raise revenue for academe and players for professional teams. 
 Contradictions in a system which expects players to concentrate on football, yet not be paid (unless you count scholarships?) are causing increasing problems. 
 &bquo;I can't say what I'll do until I find out what it all means,&equo; one official said. 
 Could be some time. 
 Sports Diary: Football: Dress rehearsal suited to Italy 
 By RICHARD EATON 
 NOW that England and Scotland are getting ready for the World Cup finals, the question on the lips of two rejoicing nations is: &bquo;What will the lads wear for the big date in Italy?&equo; 
 Not since Lady Di qualified for the Big Match has the fashion world been as tremulous about the chosen design. 
 Will Bryan Robson, Roy Aitken and the boys come down the catwalk in gathered sleeves, button-down collars, funny geometric patches of colour, or even power-dressing shoulder pads? 
 And will the sartorially-conscious supporter have to pay for a new wardrobe in which to battle the carabinieri? 
 The present England shirt costs about &pound;24.99 for a full-sized fan, but the little number that saw us through (and its red going-away alternative) is beginning to reek from all those coach trips, nights spent in railway stations and sweaty terrace pens. 
 Football couturiers are critical of the rather plebian collar, the shirt's tailored lines, and the overall failure of a style designed in 1986 to reflect today's less structured look. 
 There could also be a pot of money in a change for the manufacturers. 
 Umbro have the England and Scotland teams on contract until 1994, and are entitled to introduce a new look at least once. 
 &bquo;I don't think the question of a change is one we'd like to answer at the moment,&equo; a Football Association spokesman said. 
 &bquo;We're not planning a change in the near future, but how you define the near future is another matter.&equo; 
 A spokesman for Umbro said: &bquo;We'll have to have a think about it.&equo; 
 One thought they might ponder is to consult the supporters through programmes and fanzines about whether their teams should affect the latest Viscosuisse fabrics cut along more ample lines (thus disguising the ample Paul Gascoigne?). 
 The supporters will have enough familiarisation to do in Italy without struggling to recognise their team's kit. 
 One Roman eating place, at least, is sure to fill the fans with wonder. 
 It is a hamburger chain called Willys. 
 Sports Diary: Lookalike: Robin Smith / Chewbacca 
 By RICHARD EATON 
 THE empire's bat strikes. 
 Chris Patrick, from Hertford, reckons the force of England's batting has been with Chewbacca, the South African at Hampshire, who bears resemblance to Robin Smith, grunting goody in Star Wars. 
 &bquo;Or could they be, in any way, related?&equo; 
 Getafix on Asterix, with Vitalstatistix: Albert Uderzo talks to Dalya Alberge about his creation of the mini-hero and his Gallic chums 
 By DALYA ALBERGE 
 THERE was no particular reason to have expected the creator of Asterix, the cuddly but cute Gallic mini-hero, or Obelix, the hefty menhir delivery-man, to be anything like his cartoon characters. 
 Yet it came as a surprise to find Albert Uderzo, the Parisian illustrator, is suave, sophisticated and softly spoken, a man whose idea of fun is racing one of his six Ferraris. 
 It was as a mere 12-year-old &mdash; forever doodling characters from favourite children's stories &mdash; that Albert Uderzo set his heart on becoming France's answer to Walt Disney. 
 Thirty years since Asterix came to life, sales of the books &mdash; 28 so far &mdash; have topped 180 million (Asterix's magic potion for superhuman strength enables them all to speak in 29 languages). 
 And France's answer to Disneyland &mdash; a &pound;69m Asterix theme park in Picardy &mdash; received its millionth visitor within months of opening last spring. 
 This month sees publication of How Obelix Fell into the Magic Potion when He was a Little Boy (Hodder &amp; Stoughton, &pound;4.95) and the seventh film, Asterix and the Big Fight, opened yesterday in the West End. 
 The previous picture, Asterix in Britain, grossed &dollar;34m in cinema and video releases. 
 Unlike Felix the Cat or Mickey Mouse, brought to life in motion pictures, Asterix started off in a comic strip. 
 While some have pointed to political messages and deep moralising bursting from the cartoon bubbles, Asterix followers have simply enjoyed the fun and the humour. 
 Asterix inhabits a world of childlike innocence, peopled with characters such as Getafix, the venerable village Druid, Caco-fonix the bard and Vitalstatistix the brave chieftain, whose only fear is that the sky may fall on his head. 
 &bquo;Its appeal lies in that the characters are very human,&equo; says Uderzo. 
 &bquo;The story is not dependent on one character. 
 And it's a spiritual, intellectual humour.&equo; 
 Asterix might never have been born but for a chance meeting in 1951 with another cartoonist, Rene Goscinny, at the Paris offices of a Belgian newspaper syndicate. 
 Uderzo's father was an Italian lute-maker who had moved to France shortly before his son's birth in 1927. 
 Uderzo, like Goscinny, was untrained. 
 He had endured a period in an animation studio, frustrated by being directed what to draw. 
 Goscinny had worked in America with Harvey Kurtzman of MAD fame: he had become dissatisfied as a draughtsman and chose to redirect his talents to story-telling. 
 Soon the Uderzo-Goscinny double signature was familiar to young readers of comic strips in Belgian newspapers. 
 Asterix was not an instant success. 
 He made a quiet debut in 1959 in Pilote, a comic magazine, and a book was published in 1961. 
 But it was only four years later that he became truly animated. 
 Their first attempts to invent an anti-hero strong enough to vie with the popularity of Tarzan and Superman, and soft enough to melt the hearts of children, did not quite come off: &bquo;I drew him bigger and more handsome. 
 It was Goscinny who suggested changes until we got him just right.&equo; 
 Something approaching international humour has been achieved by Asterix, whose popularity in France is surpassed by sales figures in Finland. 
 It is the universal appeal of the character that convinces Uderzo the stories must be kept decidedly apolitical. 
 &bquo;If we had made political statements, Asterix would be too French. 
 That would detract from his worldwide appeal. 
 &bquo;But during the Gaullist years, people said it was propaganda for De Gaulle,&equo; he sighs, weary of denying either political message or moralising. 
 &bquo;They linked the two names, interpreting the setting in Gaul as Gaullist propaganda, even though there was no intended connection. 
 We had very personal political views, but we didn't let them come through. 
 We never even had the courage to send De Gaulle a copy of one of our books.&equo; 
 The Romans may be the chief enemies in the books, but they are not the only ones who would like to suppress Asterix. 
 There has been a sensitive reaction to the teasing of national stereotypes. 
 The Swiss, for example, feel blackened at being caricatured as the world's sweepers-up, and the Spanish smart at their portrayal as lazy gypsies. 
 But those who can take a joke have ranged from children to adults - something that the Uderzo-Goscinny team had never anticipated. 
 &bquo;Funnily enough, we could detect how the readership was developing from book signings: initially it was the children who came; then mothers, mumbling that their children were at school, and then the fathers saying, &bquo;I want to know what my children are reading&equo;; and finally, the parents on their own, no longer needing childish excuses.&equo; 
 The Uderzo-Goscinny partnership came to an abrupt end with Goscinny's death in 1977. 
 Distraught, Uderzo resolved never to draw again, to kill off Asterix. 
 Moved by appeals from the public and the Press, he decided to write the text himself. 
 &bquo;I considered finding another writer but, as I only wanted a talented writer, I feared such a person would want to change the characters.&equo; 
 He composes the storyline first, from beginning to end, before putting illustrator's pen to paper. 
 &bquo;That way, you get a better flow,&equo; he explains. 
 &bquo;I learnt that from Goscinny.&equo; 
 He relies on a team of illustrators to colour his drawings. 
 &bquo;I do all the drawings, unlike other studios where you have someone to do the cars, someone to do the buildings. 
 I do everything from the Gaul huts and chariots to people. 
 I work in pencil, then outline it all in heavy black ink.&equo; 
 Being colour-blind has not cramped his style: &bquo;Although, because I mix up greens and browns, I seem to have had lots of green hair.&equo; 
 Sketching, says Uderzo, is a fast process. 
 It has to be as, apart from briefly translating ideas for a new character on to paper, he finds &bquo;there is so little time. 
 We're always behind on deadlines.&equo; 
 His sketching speed was amply illustrated at our meeting: at the request of The Independent photographer for a cartoon to be positioned against a picture of him, within seconds a huge Asterix bounced off a sheet of paper. 
 Uderzo is never satisfied with the results, &bquo;but, again, there's no time to retouch&equo;. 
 While the strip cartoons are produced with a small team, the latest multi-million dollar animated feature film has occupied an international team of as many as 300 artists and technicians for two years. 
 Uderzo says they preferred not to film in America: &bquo;They would have had a very different idea of how to approach the jokes. 
 Asterix is too intellectual for them.&equo; 
 Instead, it was co-produced by ExtraFilm, Berlin, and Gaumont, Paris. 
 Although the books have been translated into Latin (the most gentle of language teaching aids), it is unlikely that the film's dubbing team will have to contend with ablative absolutes. 
 Voice-overs for the English-language version include Bill Oddie as Asterix and Bernard Bresslaw as Obelix. 
 The smooth-talking soothsayer is played by Ron Moody: &bquo;Doing the voice-over made me realise just how intelligent and satirical the writing is. 
 There are such sharp observations about people. 
 I don't know what it's satirising, but this is not a cartoon with superficial, naive characters.&equo; 
 Style Update: Young M &amp; S 
 By VINNY LEE 
 CHILDREN'S rooms are the latest target for the co-ordinated look. 
 Jumping on the pram, rather than the bandwagon, M &amp; S has just launched Nursery and Young Living furniture with bedding, wallpapers and curtains. 
 The furniture range in utilitarian pine and kitchen-like white melamine offers a cot for &pound;170, bunk beds &pound;285 (excluding mattresses), desk &pound;175, wardrobe &pound;225, and chests of drawers from &pound;150. 
 Decorating and bedlinen designs are a choice of &bquo;Dancing Bows&equo; with ducks and mice, or &bquo;Noah's Friend&equo; with elephants, tigers and zebras. 
 Cot quilts &pound;15.99, reversible duvet cover &pound;10.99, wallpaper &pound;6.99 a roll, borders &pound;6.99 a roll, curtains from &pound;45. 
 Style Update: Primarily paper 
 By VINNY LEE 
 TESSA FANTONI, wife of cartoonist Barry, trained as a bookbinder and used her knowledge of paper to develop a collection of beautiful albums and books covered with marbled and original 1930s and 1940s printed papers. 
 Mrs Fantoni is a paper-lover: &bquo;The world is divided into people who don't sniff paper and those who do. 
 I'm a paper sniffer.&equo; 
 The handmade albums and plain-paged books (below) are ideal wedding or christening presents and come in red, blue or black bindings with co-ordinating cover-papers. 
 All the albums are refillable and come in large &pound;29, medium &pound;24 and small &pound;16.50. 
 Fashion: Parisian poet clothed in wit: Charlotte Du Cann looks at an exhibition to mark the centenary of Jean Cocteau's birth 
 By CHARLOTTE DU CANN 
 COCTEAU, poet, painter, novelist, playwright, muralist, designer and film maker, whose centenary it is this year and whose ceramics are on show at the David Gill gallery in west London, was also one of the wittiest dressers of his time. 
 He designed for others (costumes for Diaghilev and embroidery for Schiaparelli), but he also &bquo;designed&equo; himself; his unquenchable desire for fame and his talent for self-publicity made him the most photographed man in Paris. 
 There are many photographs of Cocteau in his trademark suit staring with absolute assurance into the camera: Cocteau wearing a thick alpaca coat; Cocteau with a dark wool coat flung over his shoulders; Cocteau in dungarees; Cocteau in a duffel coat with Chanel. 
 He was photographed by Man Ray in a sharp, dark suit with a striped shirt and white collar. 
 He was painted by Modigliani and Picarbia in a white shirt and tiny bow tie. 
 His style was of the poet-dandy. 
 He was never merely flamboyant or vulgarly bohemian. 
 He never wore swirling capes or giant fedoras. 
 He wore his suits very tight and his collars very large. 
 He clashed striped shirts, check jackets and spotted ties. 
 His eccentricities were revealed in his habits of unbuttoning his suit cuffs and turning them back, or wearing one v-neck jumper on top of another. 
 His narrow shoulders were habitually draped by a challis scarf, his hands adorned by two Russian wedding rings. 
 There are many reasons why fashion has begun to look to Cocteau, not simply because it is his centenary and his Hellenic graphics have begun to adorn cult objects in designer stores (on white vases at Oggetti, on black watch faces at the Watch Gallery). 
 Even his &bquo;classics with a twist&equo; style makes him an obvious role model for this season's slim suiting. 
 In 1990 many people will prefer to look like Parisian poets than American businessmen. 
 Design: A game of follow-my-leader: Jonathan Glancey anticipates a jamboree on Designers' Saturday 
 By JONATHAN GLANCEY 
 FROM warehouse studios, down the narrow stairs of Soho attics, out of countless houses marked by metallic silver blinds, come London's design fraternity. 
 Alaia tops, Paul Smith suits, extravagant spectacles: the designers are an instantly recognisable breed. 
 Next weekend, on Designers' Saturday, they scurry from design showroom to design showroom, laden with colourful brochures, bags, posters, booze and designer snacks in a fleet of black cabs laid on free by the organisers. 
 Officially, those of you excluded from the league of designers are not meant to join in this day-long visual and alimentary orgy. 
 You are meant to follow in the wake of the stylised men and women with the Pentel pens on Monday 23 October, while design students only will be welcomed on the Tuesday. 
 Designers' Saturday is not an exhibition of how to furnish your home, but concerns itself with interior design as a whole. 
 Many of the designs on display are specifically for offices. 
 If more people bothered to bring decently designed office furniture to the attention of their office manager, fewer people would be taking days off with bad backs. 
 Designers' Saturday was transplanted from New York eight years ago. 
 The idea was an attractive one. 
 Designers from different disciplines would be able to meet one another in London's best modern design showrooms, linked by a chain of taxis, drink, food and music. 
 Yet, within a few years, the whole affair had degenerated into a foodies' free-for-all. 
 So delicious were the nibbles and munchies in some showrooms that designers and hangers-on appeared to have starved themselves for days, before descending on the groaning showroom tables like a flock of unusually well-groomed vultures. 
 Such were the quantities of alchohol consumed that it seemed only a couple more years before London saw its first designer louts and designer riots. 
 This year, under the benign influence of fizzy mineral water, visitors to showrooms are expected to behave in a well-designed manner. 
 This year the event has become positively altruistic, offering debate and charity as well as a party at the Design Museum open to all-comers. 
 Charity takes the form of talented young illustrator David Hughes who will be touring at least some of the 17 showrooms on Saturday (9.30-10am Baumann Kendix; 10.30-11.30am, Herman Miller; 12-1pm OMK Design, 2.30-3.30pm Vitra, 4-5pm Erco Lighting) and offering to draw gently satirical on-the-spot portraits at &pound;25 a throw. 
 Hughes will forego the pleasure of trousering this money which will go to the Leukaemia Research Fund. 
 If you want to know why Phillipe Starck appears in just about every magazine, why Tokyo is still the in-place for designers, and why no one gives a tinker's cuss about public design, your chance to find out is at a public debate next Friday under the gaze of Rubens's corpulent characters on the painted ceiling of the Banqueting House in Whitehall. 
 Stephen Bayley, former director of the Design Museum, will chair a debate, taking questions from the floor (many pre-wrapped) and flinging them at a panel of designers, architects, patrons and critics, among them Peter Palumbo, chairman of the Arts Council, and Mies van der Rohe buff. 
 The debate will be held, the organisers say, in the guise of BBC television's Question Time. 
 The shops and showrooms themselves are worth visiting if you want to catch up on some of the latest modern furniture, lighting and fabric design. 
 Designers' Saturday has traditionally been used as a launching pad for designs and this year is no exception. 
 Scott-Howard is showing Vincent Fallon's elegant &bquo;Manifesto&equo; office range (compare with the spine-bending stuff most office workers still have to put up with); Erco Lighting is switching on Mario Bellini's highly sculpted &bquo;Eclipse&equo; spotlight (light years removed from the near statutory clusters of white spotlights peddled by DIY warehouses); and Rodney Kinsman of OMK will be sitting on his own &bquo;Trax&equo; seating, designed primarily with public spaces in mind. 
 If the whole notion of Designers' Saturday is altogether too much for you, or if your designer credentials are simply too thin to merit attendance, do not despair. 
 You could always look at a small selection of the best furniture on display, chosen by fashion designer Paul Smith and on show at his Avery Row and Floral Street shops from Monday 16 October. 
 City gives sterling a respite 
 By PETER TORDAY, Economics Correspondent 
 FINANCIAL markets displayed little enthusiasm for Nigel Lawson's speech to the Tory party conference yesterday but were prepared to grant the pound a respite from the hammering of the past few days. 
 There had been few expectations that the Chancellor would announce a significant change of course, but disappointment that Mr Lawson said nothing new on monetary policy sent sterling 0.50 pfennigs lower to close at DM2.9562. 
 Against the dollar, sterling finished 0.60 cents firmer at &dollar;1.5510, chiefly because of expectations of lower US interest rates. 
 Moreover, discreet intervention by the Bank of England helped to ensure that the pound's losses were slight. 
 The stock market chose to ignore Mr Lawson and instead turned its attention to potential bid targets. 
 The FT-SE 100 Index of leading shares gained 19.0 points to close at 2237.8. 
 But sterling's respite could prove short-lived. 
 Financial markets had expected Mr Lawson to give a clear signal on when the pound will enter the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System in a speech to the City at the Mansion House next Thursday. 
 But Mr Lawson later told BBC Television's Newsnight: &bquo;I have no new announcement to make about that, neither today nor indeed at the Mansion House.&equo; 
 France yesterday stepped up the pressure on the Government to join the ERM. 
 Pierre Beregovoy, the Finance Minister, told a business meeting: &bquo;What is happening in Great Britain should perhaps show Mrs Thatcher and Chancellor Lawson that they should act more quickly than anticipated in terms of bringing the currency into the EMS.&equo; 
 A well-rounded elder statesman: Denis Healey has a personal Hinterland, filled with poetry, history, classics and philosophy, which he fears may have made him an over-tolerant politician. 
 Yet this does not stop him being blunt about Rhoda the Rhino &mdash; otherwise known as Margaret Thatcher 
 By TERRY COLEMAN 
 &bquo;What I think will puzzle people,&equo; said Denis Healey, &bquo;is all this bloody poetry.&equo; 
 Mr Healey &mdash; the best leader Labour never had, and a man of such substance as the party no longer possesses &mdash; was regarding, from under shaggy eyebrows, the large and rollicking volume of his autobiography, just published, which lay on the table between us in his hotel suite. 
 It is largely the story of his political life, but poetry there certainly is: Shakespeare, Hopkins, Blake, Defoe, Auden, Cavafy, and lots of Yeats. 
 Well, I said, he'd always had what he called Hinterland (laughter here from his wife, Edna, across the room) &mdash; not just politics, but poetry, and opera, and painting, and what appears to be a mastery of half a dozen languages, and his family. 
 &bquo;She,&equo; said Mr Healey, indicating his wife, &bquo;says Maggie (Thatcher) has no Hinterland, and she's right. 
 It's also knowing and being interested in the history of things, which I don't think Maggie has at all. 
 It's not possible really to understand Eastern Europe now unless you know a little bit about its history for the last 150 years.&equo; 
 But could too much Hinterland be a political disadvantage? 
 &bquo;It tends to make you over-tolerant, because, you know, you can think yourself into someone else's point of view. 
 Thatcher's great advantage is this laser sight which fixes in a very narrow, straight beam on one thing at a time.&equo; 
 How much Hinterland had Neil Kinnock got? 
 &bquo;Well, more than you think. 
 I mean, he's always been passionately keen on music, which I suppose is a very Welsh thing. 
 And when he was nearly killed when he crashed his car on a motorway he had a Brahms symphony on his radio, which he now uses as his theme tune. 
 Poetry, I don't know.&equo; 
 He loyally went on to call Mr Kinnock happy, open, generous, and possessed of a thing you might not suspect, timing&hellip; 
 What had all that to do with Hinterland? 
 &bquo;If you want me,&equo; said Mr Healey, in his Hinterland-enriched voice, &bquo;to stick to one subject at a time, well. 
 .. &bquo;(Laughter). 
 That being an impossible expectation, I went off on a tack and remarked that he'd been lucky, as a politician, that he was also a natural entertainer. 
 &bquo;Developed it late, really,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I was a very poor public speaker to begin with, wasn't I?&equo; 
 Mrs Healey: &bquo;Used to lecture people.&equo; 
 That was strange. 
 Because, when he'd seen Olivier, just after 1945, hadn't he said there was a man after his own heart? 
 &bquo;Oh yes, he swings from the box, on a curtain, on to the stage, as Mr Puff. 
 Oh yes, absolutely. 
 I'm not a dull chap&hellip; 
 And, I mean, I like doing these ridiculous things like a song and dance routine with Roger Moore and the Australian cultural attache (Sir Les Patterson). 
 But my jokes when I was young tended to smell of oil rather. 
 And now I really make my jokes on the spot. 
 Like &bquo;savaged by a dead sheep&equo; (said of Sir Geoffrey Howe). 
 That came into my mind &mdash; from &bquo;savaged by a pet lamb&equo; by Winston. 
 So I adapted it suitably.&equo; 
 And what also ran through the book, I said, was a constant, happy appreciation of women. 
 &bquo;I didn't notice that.&equo; 
 No? 
 What about this photograph facing page 115? 
 &bquo;Oh, that's of Edna. 
 I took that. 
 Edna's best in profile, and besides, if you have a soft skin like that, you really need an interesting background, and ivy on a wall's ideal for that.&equo; 
 What about the young captain in the Female Auxiliary Nursing Yeomanry (FANY), with whom he spent weekends in Italy in the war, seeing with her some of the great Sienese paintings? 
 Mr Healey: &bquo;I did send her a copy of what I wrote about her to see that she didn't object. 
 She only asked for one word to be removed.&equo; 
 Mrs Healey: &bquo;He's obviously fond of women. 
 But he's brilliant at old ladies, bright old ladies with shining eyes.&equo; 
 And he even had some affection for Mrs Thatcher? 
 &bquo;I said in the House we all had an affection for Mrs Thatcher but, but, but, and Edna never forgave me.&equo; 
 Being a woman was central to Mrs Thatcher's political personality, and she knew it. 
 And he thought there was some chemistry between her and Lord Carrington? 
 &bquo;Peter is the zoo-keeper; she's Rhoda the Rhino.&equo; 
 And with Mr Gorbachev, who could charm the birds off a tree, she was, said Mr Healey, like a gushing schoolgirl with a crush. 
 Norman Mailer had found her very sexy, hadn't he? 
 &bquo;Some men do like that type of woman. 
 I think she does appeal to the public schoolboy as the sort of mixture of the matron and many other things which psychiatrists could describe.&equo; 
 This brought us to female suffrage and, indirectly, to dictatorships. 
 Mr Healey said that Labour, always having had a majority of men, would have won every election since 1922 if women hadn't been given the vote. 
 And as to dictatorships &mdash; in which he says two people in every 100 are interested in politics as opposed to three in a hundred in a democracy &mdash; you could argue that some dictatorships succeeded because they appealed to primitive instincts in people who were not interested in politics. 
 &bquo;That was true of Mussolini and Hitler above all; and to some extent of Reagan, you see. 
 People would say in America, &bquo;He's given us back our self-respect.&equo; 
 ' I was objecting that, whatever you thought of Reagan, the United States was the archetypal democracy; Mr Healey was remarking how very few people bothered to vote there at all, only one in five of the eligible voters having been enough to elect Bush; and then we arrived obliquely at the part played in politics by exhaustion. 
 Mr Healey was arguing that the 1951 Labour government fell because its principal members were tired, having spent five years of the war, and five years afterwards, in government. 
 If Attlee had carried on for another year, and the economy had turned round, Labour might still be in power. 
 As Chancellor of the Exchequer, in the Seventies, hadn't Mr Healey often written in his diary that he'd gone to bed dog-tired? 
 If this were true of him, and if the animal stamina demanded of a Secretary of State were so great, didn't that disqualify good men who lacked only that stamina? 
 &bquo;Well, in fact, they always disqualify themselves by dying.&equo; 
 He named Gaitskell, Macleod, Bevan, Crosland, all dead before 60. 
 There was a lot of stress, and a political career was something you wouldn't undergo unless you enjoyed it all. 
 For himself, he enjoyed government but not opposition. 
 He enjoyed doing things. 
 Mr Healey had said he was himself knackered that morning, having returned the previous day, very late, from a seminar in Florence, and taken a dose of the cough mixture Benylin to get to sleep, which he found worked better than Mogadon. 
 At this point he was instantly revived by the appearance of a waitress bearing coffee, sandwiches, and a pint of beer. 
 &bquo;That's lovely, dear. 
 Oh gosh.&equo; 
 The waitress retired enchanted. 
 And so, refreshed, we passed on to Hong Kong. 
 Hadn't his book, in which he retained a belief that two systems in one country would work when Hong Kong went back to China, been rather overtaken by events? 
 He didn't know. 
 He thought the transition period had always been too long, because authority deserts a dying king, and neither China nor the Hong Kong people were going to take much notice of us by the time it got to the Nineties. 
 But it might still work. 
 And one of the oil men to whom he had been talking at that seminar in Florence had told him that the Chinese enterprise zone (Shenzhen), just over the border from Hong Kong, was still working. 
 But there had been no sign since Tiananmen Square that the Chinese had been in the least influenced by the disapproval of the West. 
 Well, take that Sino-British agreement on Hong Kong. 
 Let me put a wild thesis to him. 
 Now Mrs Thatcher had originally gone to Peking just after the Falklands war, full of vim, and taken a hard line. 
 The received wisdom was that the Foreign Office then rescued her&hellip; 
 Yes, but mightn't her show of determination have done better? 
 &bquo;I doubt it. 
 She's not been good at negotiating. 
 She got a better deal, to be fair, out of the Common Market, because she was so difficult. 
 But only up to a point, you see. 
 And what's happening now, increasingly, is that the Europeans are saying, &bquo;Well, bugger her. 
 We'll go along without Britain.&equo; 
 And they certainly will do&hellip; 
 &bquo;Again, why the hell doesn't she say OK, and then handle it like everybody else, do the bits that suit her and not do the other ones? 
 That's what the others do all the time. 
 But the diplomacy of Alf Garnett allied to the economics of Arthur Daley is not good in international affairs.&equo; 
 Mr Healey here went on about Labour's success in the Euro-elections; I said it was just mid-term and all that; and he said, With respect, no. 
 When he says &bquo;with respect&equo; he means you're barmy. 
 He said the Tories were openly divided. 
 &bquo;It's like the Labour Party. 
 We've been bugged for 10 years by a reputation for extremism and division, which we're just getting rid of. 
 The Tories now are running into this. 
 They think she's extremist on many issues &mdash; poll tax, the health service. 
 And of course there's enough chuntering for them to appear divided as well.&equo; 
 Very well. 
 But what socialist governments, in which countries, had ever worked? 
 This is a question I have often asked. 
 It excites strange answers. 
 Tony Benn once named Ken Livingstone's London: Mr Livingstone named Cuba. 
 Mr Healey said Sweden. 
 I accepted that but, having in mind Sweden's small population and great resources of iron and timber, thought it an untypical sort of country, and asked for another. 
 At which Mr Healey named Austria. 
 But surely, since Austria was tiny, and moreover neutral&hellip;? 
 &bquo;Every time I produce an example you say it's unusual. 
 I think the Labour Party worked bloody well here after the war for five years, and I don't think a Tory government could have made the adjustment we then faced.&equo; 
 And socialist governments had worked well in West Germany for more than 10 years. 
 Pretty social democrat, that? 
 &bquo;Well, I'm not talking about command economies. 
 I don't believe in that. 
 And I never have.&equo; 
 We came to the Shirt of Nessus. 
 The thing about Mr Healey's delightful book is not only the bloody poetry but the classical allusions. 
 After five years as Chancellor of the Exchequer, and after the lost election of 1979, he says he found himself wearing this Shirt of Nessus. 
 What about that? 
 &bquo;The Labour Party in travail,&equo; Mr Healey explained. 
 &bquo;I originally called all those chapters according to the Labours of Hercules. 
 But then I thought this might not be understood by many people, and also, by the time it got to the Augean Bulls and the Birds of Stymphalus, it would be a little recondite for people like Terry Coleman.&equo; 
 Quite right; but I'd had a vague recollection, and looked it up, and although the shirt of the centaur Nessus, saturated as it was in his poisoned blood, had caused Hercules no end of pain&hellip; 
 &bquo;Killed him,&equo; said Healey-Hercules cheerfully. 
 Right, killed him; but then surely he went to heaven? 
 &bquo;Well, I'm going to heaven too, without the slightest doubt.&equo; 
 (Laughter here, mine in admiration at Healey-Hercules's sheer lightness of footwork.) 
 By way of Nero and his brief successor Galba (who happened to be 73, which is Mr Healey's present age), we arrived at a picture, on page 483, of Mr Healey dressed as Father Christmas, which I suggested was deeply melancholy. 
 Mr Healey: &bquo;I rather like dressing up.&equo; 
 Mrs Healey: &bquo;That is in no way a sad picture. 
 It could have been: &bquo;Here am I, a man of 70, dressed up like Father Christmas, but&hellip;&equo; 
 ' Mr Healey, merrily: &bquo;Don't keep harping about age.&equo; 
 Mrs Healey: &bquo;But that is not what it is. 
 It's a boy. 
 He just likes being a child.&equo; 
 So it was not melancholy? 
 All right. 
 But what that picture was leading me to ask was something he had quoted Plato as asking &mdash; whether it had all been worthwhile, his whole life? 
 At this Mr Healey was jolly pleased to see me trapped in the Thickets of Quotation, and, again merrily, said, &bquo;Plato? 
 That was Leonardo da Vinci.&equo; 
 He then gave me the line, in Italian, from memory: &bquo;Dimmi se mai fu fatto qualque cosa?&equo; &mdash; &bquo;Tell me if anything was ever done?&equo; 
 Well, was anything ever done? 
 &bquo;Moments of doubt and uncertainty always arise, even with the greatest people. 
 I mean Leonardo, without question one of the most outstanding geniuses the world has ever known &mdash; but he said that.&equo; 
 But on the whole politics had been worthwhile. 
 You had to go into politics if you wanted to change the world. 
 Technologists might, but they did not set out to do so. 
 Civil servants might, though in the end it was the politicians who decided, which was why he had declined the highest office with both Nato and the International Monetary Fund. 
 What about other people who might change the world, or had done? 
 Well, he thought Jesus Christ was no slouch there. 
 Marx, certainly. 
 &bquo;But you have to be bloody lucky there. 
 It was an absolute toss-up whether that book (Das Kapital) caught on or not. 
 The Communist manifesto on its own didn't&equo; 
 Harold Wilson always used to say he'd never got past page one, didn't he? 
 &bquo;Well I've read a bit of it, mainly in order to be able to quote it at Communist opponents, who've never read it.&equo; 
 Then he told me about chaology, which he called the new buzz thing. 
 The world was so complex that tiny events could produce enormous effects by a process of causality so complicated that no one could trace it. 
 The example always given was that the fluttering of a butterly's wing in the forests of Amazonia could change the climate of the north Atlantic, which might in theory be true because things very often changed just at the margin, and no one could trace quite how. 
 In other words, the world was too complicated to be comprehended in systems, but the trouble was that the chaologists were oversystematising even chaos. 
 &bquo;But, you know, I'm not trying to explain the secrets of the universe in this book. 
 Just kissing the joy as it flies, the whole time.&equo; 
 That was Blake. 
 I remarked that, of the politicians I had known, only Mr Healey and Mr Powell could and did talk philosophy. 
 Ah, said Mr Healey, Enoch had been with him at that seminar in Florence he'd mentioned. 
 Enoch had mellowed, but he had been terribly hurt at losing his seat in 1987. 
 &bquo;What he really misses, he tells me, is the constituency, and the contact with the people. 
 I've given a whole chapter to my constituency. 
 Very few politicians write about their constituencies, do they? 
 But to Enoch it meant a very great deal.&equo; 
 Then Mr Healey came to the changing of nations. 
 They did change. 
 He had bought a second-hand paperback about nineteenth-century English railway navvies. 
 They had built French railways too, and there was this Frenchman, watching them, who said: &bquo;My God, these English, how they work.&equo; 
 Mr Healey said he would go round quoting that example to people. 
 Or, he said, take Heine. 
 When he was in England (circa 1830) he was given a steel screw at a factory. 
 He looked at this wonderful thing and said: &bquo;I wonder if our Germans will ever be able to make anything like this?&equo; 
 For a moment Mr Healey recalled Mr Powell again, saying his own Italian was better than Enoch's. 
 We got up. 
 Mr Healey said: &bquo;Tout passe; tout casse; tout lasse,&equo; which I dare to translate as meaning something like &bquo;All is Vanity&equo;, and then, to end the conversation, he half-sang a little, final, syncopated drumroll, which went something like this: &bquo;Da da de da di DUM.&equo; 
 Identities of informers for MI5 &bquo;leaked to IRA&equo;: Worst Ulster security breach suspected as secret operation in Germany is revealed 
 By MARK URBAN, Defence Correspondent 
 THE GOVERNMENT is facing the most serious leak of secret information in its 20-year war against the IRA. 
 The IRA says it has obtained documents detailing operations by British intelligence to recruit agents within the Irish community on the Continent. 
 It is understood that the documents include material identifying several informants. 
 The identity of what are known as &bquo;human sources&equo; within the republican community is among the most closely guarded secrets in the war against terrorism. 
 Such information is of greater intelligence importance than the photographs of IRA suspects, usually given the lowest levels of security classification, which have been leaked to various newspapers in recent weeks, triggering a political row and a big police investigation. 
 The loss of the documents appears to be a more serious breach of security than that which occurred in 1979, when the IRA obtained a copy of a secret Army intelligence assessment. 
 A major leak inquiry was launched following that loss. 
 On Thursday An Phoblacht, the Sinn Fein newspaper, specified two documents revealing details of an MI5 operation, code-named Ward, to recruit informers within the Irish community in West Germany. 
 The republican newspaper says it will publish next week the names of informants and further details of the operations, which it said were conducted initially without the knowledge of the Bonn government. 
 However a West German paper, the Tages Allgemeine Zeitung, published more details of Operation Ward on Thursday. 
 It says it has obtained a copy of a memorandum concerning co-operation between MI5 and its German equivalent, the Bundesamt fur Verfassungsschutz or BfV &mdash; the Federal Office for the Protection of the Constitution. 
 A spokesman for the British Army of the Rhine would not confirm or deny whether the documents were genuine, saying yesterday: &bquo;We do not comment about these matters.&equo; 
 A former British government official who was in Bonn at the time of Operation Ward declined to comment on the authenticity of the material, but told The Independent yesterday: &bquo;It is obvious that if attacks are going on, you should try and get informers.&equo; 
 The German newspaper says that the Army's Intelligence and Security Group in Germany recruited five agents following terrorist attacks against British forces during the late 1970s. 
 A page from the documents reproduced in An Phoblacht says that the Army's recruitment of agents in Germany &bquo;raised difficult policy considerations&equo;. 
 Apparently the difficulties arose from the fact that the Army had not informed the West German government about its recruitment of agents. 
 In 1981 British intelligence took control of these agents under Operation Ward. 
 By 1984 the Ward team was running eight agents and had targeted another five people for possible for recruitment. 
 It appears from the German newspaper report that the Bonn authorities, in the form of BfV, were told what was going on following MI5 and MI6's involvement in 1981. 
 It is an established rule in intelligence circles that a country should not conduct intelligence operations on the territory of an ally without informing its government. 
 The fact that the Ward documents may contain the identity of sources may indicate that the informants had already been compromised and were no longer active by 1984, when the latter of the two memoranda was apparently written. 
 A source familiar with intelligence operations in Ulster said yesterday: &bquo;Nothing is more sensitive in the whole field of intelligence than their identities.&equo; 
 If the sources were not already known to the IRA, the author of the alleged MI5 documents may have committed a grave breach of security by alluding to them. 
 It remains unclear why Sinn Fein has chosen to wait until next week before publishing the full content of the documents. 
 It may be that the IRA hopes that it will flush out current informants by publicising the fact that it knows the identities of some agents. 
 The page reproduced in the Sinn Fein newspaper also refers to the Secret Intelligence Service, MI6, an organisation the existence of which the Government still does not officially admit. 
 The Conservative Conference: Thatcher hits back at Kinnock 
 By ANTHONY BEVINS, Political Editor 
 MARGARET THATCHER yesterday took on Labour's enhanced challenge to the Conservatives with a strong condemnation of socialist controls and Neil Kinnock's conversion to more palatable policies. 
 She told her party conference in Blackpool: &bquo;In 1979, we knew that we were starting a British revolution; in fact, we were pioneers of a world revolution. 
 &bquo;So it's ironic that as enterprise and liberty rise from the dead ashes of state control, the Labour Party here is still trying to blow life into those old embers.&equo; 
 The Prime Minister won a strong ovation when she added: &bquo;The trouble with Labour is that they're just not at home with freedom. 
 Socialists don't like people choosing, for they might not choose socialism.&equo; 
 The speech was greeted with the customary jubilant and lengthy ovation &mdash; and a rendering of &bquo;Happy Birthday&equo; to celebrate Mrs Thatcher's sixth-fourth birthday. 
 But the Prime Minister's dominant recognition of the Labour threat was underscored by the fact that she chose to avoid the contentious issues of water and electricity privatisation, poll tax, the trade deficit, the European Community, and the Exchange Rate Mechanism. 
 Mr Kinnock exploited political and City tensions over sterling yesterday with a call for the Government to enter immediate negotiations to become a full member of the European Monetary System. 
 John Smith, Labour's Treasury spokesman, is to tour a number of European capitals next week to hammer out the party's terms of entry. 
 But the gaps in Mrs Thatcher's address reflected her own standing instruction to Cabinet colleagues: to &bquo;calm down&equo; the Government's confrontational image. 
 That message, and yesterday's speech, contrast sharply with previous conference speeches in which the Prime Minister insisted that there could be no let-up in the long Thatcherite march. 
 Nevertheless, she did give outright support to the stand taken by the Chancellor of the Exchequer. 
 Repeating yesterday's news that inflation had risen to 7.6 per cent, she said it was too high &mdash; it must and would be reduced. 
 She stressed, however, that that could be achieved only through interest rates. 
 There would be no resort to devaluation. 
 The overall theme of the speech was based on freedom and choice, something which coincided with a year in which &bquo;the people of half our continent&equo; followed Britain's trail-blazing lead and &bquo;began to throw off their chains&equo;. 
 Relating that to Labour's &bquo;unprecendented mass conversion&equo; to moderation in Brighton last week, Mrs Thatcher said she did not believe her opponents now stood for home ownership, strong defence and financial rectitude. 
 In a personal attack on Mr Kinnock &mdash; a prime target for the Conservative counter-offensive &mdash; she added: &bquo;If it's that easy for the Labour leader to give up the principles in which he does believe, won't it be even easier for him to give up the principles in which he does not believe?&equo; 
 As for Mr Kinnock's conversion to multilateral nuclear disarmament, Mrs Thatcher said: &bquo;How does one explain the Labour leader's contortions? 
 Is he being false to his convictions? 
 Or true to his character?&equo; 
 She added: You don't reach Downing Street by pretending you've travelled the road to Damascus when you haven't even left home.&equo; 
 Turning to what she called &bquo;the heart of the matter&equo;, the Prime Minister said: &bquo;Remove man's freedom and you dwarf the individual, you devalue his conscience and you demoralise him.&equo; 
 Labour painted wealth as selfishness, improved living standards as greed, but Mrs Thatcher insisted: &bquo;Only by creating wealth can you relieve poverty.&equo; 
 Responding directly to perceived criticism from church as well as opposition leaders, she said: &bquo;For every Pharisee our system produces, you will find at least three good Samaritans.&equo; 
 She then went on to address one of the underlying themes of the conference week: the &bquo;quality of life&equo; requirement to improve state sector service in health, education, environment, housing and social services. 
 Some senior party figures believe that theme itself represents a strategic political withdrawal to ground that can be more easily defended in the face of Labour's onslaught. 
 That shift, together with the emphasis on &bquo;the right team&equo; leadership and traditional Tory reserves of loyalty, undoubtedly helped the party to fend off the week's much-resented media attention to division and disarray. 
 Defiant rallying call to the old firm 
 By PETER JENKINS 
 BLACKPOOL &mdash; Since her first as leader of the Conservative Party, delivered here at the Winter Gardens in 1975, Margaret Thatcher and her team of speechwriters have made of the conference speech a minor art form. 
 Yesterday's, her eleventh as Prime Minister, was one of the very best - well-constructed, lucid, punchy and funny. 
 This year's production number was of particular interest and significance because the Conservative high command is planning to make leadership a key issue at the next general election, only two years away. 
 Hence the Prime Minister's scathing, almost vicious attacks on the sincerity and integrity of the Leader of the Opposition. 
 &bquo;Not for us disposable ideas, not for us throw-away convictions, not for us rent-a-principle,&equo; she declared. 
 This contrast between her &bquo;conviction politics&equo; and Neil Kinnock's alleged lack-of-conviction politics is to be a recurrent theme of Conservative propaganda. 
 Intertwined with this line of attack on Labour, and running right through yesterday's speech, was another theme, that of freedom. 
 At Brighton last week Mr Kinnock had portrayed her as an anachronism as the Nineties dawned, &bquo;out of step, out of touch, out of date&equo;. 
 Now she identified herself with the future, as freedom was breaking out everywhere, and Labour with the failed past. 
 &bquo;As enterprise and liberty arise from the dead ashes of state control,&equo; she said, &bquo;the Labour Party here is still trying to blow life into those old embers.&equo; 
 It was a characteristically defiant performance coming from the leader of a party trailing 8-10 points in the opinion polls, her own satisfaction ratings slumped beaneth her opponent's, and after a week which had rocked the credibility of her government's economic policy, on which all else depends. 
 Beneath Mrs Thatcher's defiant manner there was, I thought, a layer of hurt feeling. 
 This was her first big opportunity to reply to the barrage of criticism and, as she saw it, ingratitude which had marred for her the celebration last May of her 10 years in office. 
 So she rehearsed the triumphs and achievements of the Thatcher Revolution and laid lavish claim to having lit in Britain the torch of freedom for the whole world. 
 The loss of heart she experienced in May perhaps contributed to the loss of touch she demonstrated through the summer. 
 On the strength of this speech she is back in form. 
 Nevertheless, there is in the air at Blackpool a first whiff of post-Thatcher. 
 By general consent Kenneth Baker and Michael Heseltine finished the week as co-favourites in the succession stakes. 
 Mr Heseltine is slowly reaping the reward of the patience, persistence and self-restraint he has demonstrated since his stormy resignation in 1986. 
 He is the only major figure offering an alternative party programme which is not a watered-down version of Mrs Thatcher's. 
 Support for him is slowly growing among influential Tories. 
 While Mrs Thatcher yesterday celebrated the achievements of the Thatcher Revolution, a spectre of the past was hovering over Blackpool &mdash; decline. 
 Sir Geoffrey Howe delivered a sombre warning of the dangers of relapse. 
 Both he and Mr Heseltine warned against making light of the huge trade deficit and what it said about the manufacturing base of the economy. 
 For the first time since the end of the Falklands war there was, also, a less than total confidence among ministers in the certainty of the coming victory at the polls. 
 I put it no higher. 
 Ostensibly a new agenda for the Nineties is in preparation with the emphasis on the &bquo;quality if life&equo;. 
 In the opinion of most ministers, however, the next election, like past ones, will be won or lost primarily in the pockets of the people. 
 &bquo;The Right Team for Britain's Future&equo; was the conference slogan. 
 But the right team will be the old firm, hoping that the old magic can be made to work once more. 
 Saatchi sells 70 paintings 
 By ANDREW GRAHAM-DIXON, Visual Arts Correspondent 
 CONCERN is growing in the art world over the news that Charles Saatchi the advertising agency millionaire has sold between 10 and 12 per cent of his art collection in the past six months. 
 A source close to Mr Saatchi confirmed yesterday that between 70 and 100 works from the collection &mdash; the largest of its kind in the world &mdash; had been disposed of through the New York art dealer Larry Gagosian for up to &dollar;1m per painting. 
 A spokeswoman for the Saatchi Collection said the sales did not signal a lessening commitment to the collection, but had been made to finance new acquisitions. 
 However, the sales have been interpreted differently by many dealers, some of whom believe they presage the beginning of the end of the collection. 
 One said from New York yesterday: &bquo;If you want to refine a collection you sell off in much smaller quantities &mdash; and you certainly don't sell the finest works.&equo; 
 Departures: Palin the globe-trotter 
 By FRANK BARRETT 
 ON THE fae of things, Michael Palin seems an unlikely double for the archetypal stiff upperlipped phlegmatic Englsihman Phileas Fogg, hero of Jules Verne's Around the World in Eighty Days. 
 Palin, ex-Python star &mdash; most recently appearing as Ken in A Fish Called Wanda &mdash; was invited by BBC 2 to tread in Fogg's footsteps by recreating the fictional journey. 
 (Alan Whicker, it seems, was first choice: Palin makes an interesting substitute given the wicked Python parody of Whicker Island: a place full of Alan Whickers endlessly interviewing each other.) 
 It's hard to imagine Mr Fogg, for example, ever having been a train-spotter: if there was any train-spotting to be done, Mr Fogg would have despatched his loyal French manservant Passepartout to do it on his behalf. 
 Yet young Palin, who grew up in Sheffield, was an enthusiastic train spotter, neatly underlining each newly spotted locomotive in his Ian Allan book. 
 &bquo;I didn't cross them out &mdash; that would have been too much like defacing the book,&equo; he says. 
 And while he has travelled a lot since the success of Monty Python, as a child his family holidays were spent in the unadventurous climes of Southwold and East Anglia (recalled in his TV play East of Ipswich). 
 He travelled far, however, in his imagination. 
 &bquo;I'd been everywhere in books: I read a lot about exotic places. 
 And I went to church every Sunday where we used to have missionaries who would come and tell tales about how they built churches in jungle clearings with lions gnawing at their legs.&equo; 
 Until the series idea came up, had he ever read Around the World in Eighty Days? 
 &bquo;I'm not sure whether I'd read the book or the &bquo;Classics Illustrated&equo; edition.&equo; 
 (Classics Illustrated were comic book versions of great literature: David Copperfield, for example, condensed to 80 pages of finely drawn comic strip.) 
 He has no illusions about why he was chosen for the Fogg job: &bquo;They thought I was someone who wouldn't mind the suffering involved &mdash; and someone who was cheap. 
 they were wrong on the second point at least.&equo; 
 Palin may not have travelled much as a young man, but he has now made up for lost time. 
 &bquo;When I ever have a week off, I try and visit a new city in Europe.&equo; 
 His most recent summer holidays were spent with his two sons walking in the central Pyrenees: &bquo;It was quite gruelling.&equo; 
 He has plans now to buy a property in Venice: &bquo;I love the palce so much: a five-room apartment there costs about the same as studio flat in Tufnell Park.&equo; 
 His great ambition, however, is to write a &bquo;real&equo; travel book in the Colin thubron or Paul Theroux style. 
 What he has in mind seems curiously like the Ripping Yarns TV series in which he and Terry Jones sent up the boy's adventure story with tales like &bquo;Across the Andes by Frog&equo;. 
 In fact, his &bquo;book of the series&equo; is a very good read, although he fears that as a TV-linked publication it is unlikely to get serious reveiws. 
 He is still smarting from a put-down in the magazine City Limits which condemned his Around the World in Eighty Days as an exercise in &bquo;male back-slapping imperialism&equo;. 
 One thing he has discovered since his global circumnavigation, is that it's a big conversation killer. 
 &bquo;At parties, if people ask what you've been doing and you tell them that you've just been around the world, it stops the conversationd ead.&equo; 
 One good reason, if you need one, for not going around the world. 
 Waiting games with Rembrandt and Vermeer: Brian Cathcart learns how to take it easy on a trip to The Hague, our last Channel Hop 
 By BRIAN CATHCART 
 MANANA should be a Dutch word. 
 As a rule in the Netherlands, it is the customers, not the waiters, who do the waiting. 
 For a country that has grown rich doing business, service in restaurants and cafes can be astonishingly slow, and catching the waiter's eye is about as easy as catching sunstroke on a North Sea beach. 
 There is no point in complaining; they may try to mollify you in their irritatingly good English, but they will not have a clue what you are so anxious about. 
 This is a country where people are not in a hurry. 
 So try to be Mediterranean about it. 
 Take it easy. 
 Sip your drink, don't gulp it. 
 Eke out the little pleasures. 
 The beer, for example, is rather good, so is the coffee. 
 Notice the strange way in which the table is covered by a carpet while the floor is bare, as in the best Vermeers. 
 Enjoy the warmth: outside it is almost certainly blowing razor blades from the Steppes. 
 Relax: you are on holiday. 
 This is the appropriate mood for The Hague, a town so bourgeois it makes Amsterdam seem rough and ready. 
 It has the reputation of a Dutch Bonn, a provincial place of exile for civil servants, where nothing more exciting than Dutch politics ever happens. 
 This is unfair, for it is a historic city and once in a while something does happen. 
 In 1672, for example, the Dutch Cromwell, de Witt, was torn limb from limb in the street by a frenzied mob, and in 1986 I was beaten up in a bar. 
 Such excitements are rare; The Hague has a few clubs and theatres and it will soon have its own ballet company, but for the most part the Hagenaars, as the residents are known, spend their evenings at home and retire at a respectable hour. 
 What the city has to offer the weekend visitor is first-class art, a variety of shops and bars, a little seaside air and some good food to fill the evenings. 
 It also has that quintessentially Dutch quality: smallness. 
 For a place with a population of half a million or so it is a handy size. 
 Most distances are walkable and the rest an easy tram ride. 
 Start at the Mauritshuis. 
 Small enough for a coach party to whip through in half an hour, but good enough to occupy the more patient visitor for an afternoon or more, the princely town house stands beside a broad pond in the heart of the city. 
 Its collection is from the cream of Dutch art, rivalling the Rijksmuseum's in quality if not quantity. 
 It has three Vermeers (only 30 exist), notably Head of a Girl and View of Delft (to Proust, the most beautiful painting in the world), a dozen jolly Steens, full of lasciviousness and coded morality, a dozen or more great Rembrandts, and Paulus Potter's huge Young Bull. 
 These are the products of an age when the Dutch were the richest people in the world &mdash; the Japanese of their time &mdash; and they expressed their wealth by painting, not scenes of classical grandeur, but homes and streets, faces and families. 
 The Mauritshuis galleries are made to match: comfortably sized rooms that let your eyes do the work, not your feet. 
 Beside the Mauritshuis is the Binnenhof, the homely Dutch Palace of Westminster. 
 Its cobbled courtyard and centrepiece &mdash; the thirteenth-century Knights' Hall &mdash; are open to the public. 
 On the far side, a narrow arch leads to the main shopping streets: Grote Markt, Spuistraat and the classy Noordeinde. 
 Dutch department stores tend to be disappointing &mdash; De Bijenkorf ('The Beehive') is the best &mdash; for this is another sphere of Dutch life in which smallness wins. 
 Antiques, art and bric-a-brac are strong points. 
 Somewhere along the way, call into a cheese shop and buy some sliced Gouda to sustain you; ask for something old and it will come hard, dry, salty and orange &mdash; a prince among cheeses and a revelation to anyone who thought Dutch cheese was that yellow soap they sell in wax balls. 
 To the north and west of the Binnenhof is the statelier part of The Hague. 
 Fine town houses of the eighteenth century, some of them now embassies, give way slowly to the more compact residences of the nineteenth, then to the woods and then the seaside suburb of Scheveningen. 
 Take the tram. 
 A century ago Scheveningen was a place of painters as much as of fishermen, and not far off the tram route you can still see exactly what the artists saw. 
 Down a little tunnel at the Mesdag museum, up a flight of stairs, and you are standing atop a dune looking at an enormous 360-degree panorama painted in 1881. 
 Bathing huts, a steam engine, cavalry on manoeuvre and beached fishing boats: it must have been lovely. 
 Today, thanks to overcrowding and overdevelopment, it is a bit of a nightmare in season, but on a bright day there is still no better place to eat chips with mayonnaise. 
 For exercise and air, go for a walk on the dunes. 
 The dikes get all the credit for keeping the water out, but most of the work is done by the natural wall of sand facing the sea. 
 The dunes are carefully conserved &mdash; the Dutch government boasts an inspectorate of dunes &mdash; and criss-crossed with paths. 
 When you get back to your starting point, reward yourself with a cocktail in the Kurhaus, an enormous hotel with a magnificent salon like something out of Death in Venice. 
 On the far side of The Hague, another 10-minute tram ride away, is Delft, the picture-postcard Dutch canal town. 
 Canal tours, blue-and-white china, narrow streets &mdash; if it were not also a university town it would be merely beautiful. 
 The students give it liveliness: motorbikes in the market square and a bit of noise in the bars. 
 Back in The Hague there is still enough art for the most voracious appetite, at the Prince Willem gallery and the Gemeentemuseum. 
 Andrew Carnegie's Peace Palace, filled with the gifts of the nations, is open for tours, and the woods where Hitler launched his V2s against London are there to be walked. 
 Or you might be better sitting down and ordering yourself a drink: the waiter may be gone some time. 
 Fact File Hook of Holland Ferries: Sealink (0233 47047) has two sailings a day in each direction from Harwich to the Hook, crossing time around seven hours; a 53-hour return for a car and two adults costs from &pound;77. 
 Rotterdam Ferries: North Sea Ferries (0482 77177) has a daily sailing from Hull to Rotterdam: crossing time 14 hours. 
 A short break to The Hague, including a night's hotel accommodation and two nights on board ship, costs from &pound;84 per person, not including car. 
 The Hague About 12 miles from the Hook of Holland. 
 Restaurants: Dutch cuisine is rich and creamy and comes in large portions; pork does not dominate as it does in West Germany. 
 Le Gentilhomme (464664) on the Noordeinde may sound French but is not. 
 Luden (601733) on Frederikstraat is stylish, Frenchified and rather good. 
 Trias (651175) on Het Plein is good value. 
 Don't forget Indonesian: Raden Ajoe (644592), Kantjil (654398) or the family-run Soeboer (883737). 
 It is best to book. 
 Vlissingen Ferries: Olau Line (0795 666666) operates two sailings a day from Sheerness to Vlissingen: crossing time is from seven hours. 
 A 53-hour return for a 4.5m car and two adults costs from &pound;80. 
 Travel Update: Travel Top 10 
 By BRIAN CATHCART 
 Britain's 10 biggest tour operators, according to the number of holidays they are licensed to sell in the year ending March 1990: 1. 
 Thomson Holidays: Holidays 3.6 million. 
 Organisation also includes Horizon (511,000 holidays); Sky Tours (348,000) and Portland Holidays (323,000). 
 Each of these companies, if listed separately, would be in the top 10 biggest list in their own right. 
 2. 
 Intasun Holidays: Holidays 2.2 million. 
 International Leisure Group organisation also includes Select Holidays and Lancaster. 
 3. 
 Falcon Holidays: Holidays 896,000. 
 Falcon is the main operator of the Owners Abroad group which includes Tjaereborg. 
 Travel Update: Operatic packages 
 By BRIAN CATHCART 
 MGP (0825 84891) is offering a choice of weekend packages to see Luciano Pavarotti, the Italian opera singer, in concert in Munich, Frankfurt or Cologne. 
 Prices start at &pound;199 for a weekend in Cologne including return flights, accommodation and a concert ticket. 
 Travel Update: Britrail sale 
 By BRIAN CATHCART 
 BRITISH Rail has launched a winter sale, with cut-price deals on long-distance Saver tickets. 
 A London to Edinburgh Saver, for example, has been reduced from &pound;59 to &pound;53. 
 Until 31 March, passengers travelling Standard (second) class can buy two sleeper tickets for the price of one: the offer applies to all services except those wholly within Scotland. 
 During the same period, the cost of putting a car on the train is cut to &pound;19 single, &pound;20 return. 
 Winter Motorail services operate from London to Aberdeen, Inverness and Penzance overnight and from London to Carlisle in the daytime. 
 The London to Edinburgh route has both day and night services. 
 Drivers and their passengers will pay normal fares, including Saver fares. 
 Railcard holders will be able to get further reductions of up to a third: children pay a flat fare of &pound;1 single. 
 The Young Persons Railcard, valid for anyone aged between 16 and 24 &mdash; or for any full-time student - normally costs &pound;15. 
 Until 4 November it is available for &pound;10. 
 It provides discounts of up to one third on most fares and a 50 per cent discount on the Network Card for travel in London and the South-east. 
 The Weekend First scheme, which offers First class at a small supplement to Saver-class fares, has also been extended. 
 The &pound;3 supplementary charge now applies to the whole journey, rather than to each train taken. 
 Available on Saturdays, Sundays and bank holidays, the concession is available on most InterCity trains in and out of London. 
 Look for special &bquo;Weekend First&equo; window labels and pay the supplement on the train. 
 Seat reservations cost no extra if you book in advance. 
 Travel Update: Planes to Spain 
 By BRIAN CATHCART 
 IF you book and pay for two Iberia (01-437 5622) &bquo;Moneysaver&equo; tickets to Spain before 27 October, you will get a &pound;25 discount on the second ticket. 
 The tickets must be for travel between 30 October and 14 December and between 2 January and 8 February. 
 The Moneysaver tickets are for travel from Heathrow, Manchester and Birmingham airports to a choice of 14 Spanish destinations. 
 For example, a Heathrow to Seville Moneysaver return costs from &pound;97 to &pound;209 per person, depending on departure date. 
 Travel Update: Sites of LA 
 By BRIAN CATHCART 
 ARCHITECTURAL Tours (01-267 6497) offers a 10-day tour to Los Angeles, &bquo;the architectural Mecca of the Western world&equo;, to visit many of the buildings including those by Frank Lloyd Wright, Frank Gehry, Ray and Charles Eames, M Schindler, art galleries and museums &mdash; as well as the opportunity to visit several architects' practices. 
 The tour, from 14 to 23 November, costs &pound;897 including return flight, transfers, accommodation (at the Biltmore Hotel and Westlake Plaza) and architectural guide. 
 Travel Update: Ephesus death 
 By BRIAN CATHCART 
 THE parents of 20-year-old Howard Ross-Bain, who died after he was hit by a car near the ruins of Ephesus in Turkey between 2pm and 4.30pm on Tuesday 16 August, wish to hear from any witnesses to the accident. 
 A visit to the Minotaur's lair: Poppy Holden is captivated by the layers of life on the island of Crete 
 By POPPY HOLDEN 
 THE WAITER in the Calypso bar at Chania carries a smiling blond baby on one hip, and my Cretan breakfast in one hand. 
 For about &pound;2 there are tomatoes, olives, bread, cheese, a sausage, a boiled egg, a nectarine, and a bowl of yoghurt, honey and sultanas, orange juice and mountain herb tea. 
 All is fresh, local and utterly delicious. 
 The tea is made of malotira and, I'm sure, peppermint. 
 This herb has tiny leaves here, and is furiously strong: I made tea from some herbs I picked, put in a generous sprig of peppermint, and spat out the result in shock. 
 At the north-western tip of the island I picked malotira, on the long empty golden beach of Phalasarna, thinking from its exotic perfume that I was gathering the famous dittany of Crete which grows nowhere else but on this island. 
 I then bought some dittany in the fine, covered, nineteenth-century market. 
 Dittany when dried is greyer than malotira, although the leaves are similarly furry like so much of the vegetation, which needs to conserve moisture in the hot atmosphere, and the tea made from it has a muskier, more soothing quality. 
 In a nearby workshop a goldsmith is making earrings of long, dull-faceted Afghan lapis lazuli and old Indian gold beads. 
 There's a lot of lapis here, together with some very fine turquoise, coral and amber. 
 None of it is local stone: there is a tradition, perhaps connected with the Venetians or, later, the Turks, who successively occupied Crete till the late nineteenth century, of importing these stones and making jewellery. 
 The beauty in both cheap and expensive artefacts is remarkable: even in a shop that aims low, the most cynically tawdry confections of perspex and metal have charm and grace. 
 You can get anything made here. 
 In our Venetian palace the furniture and marble floors were made to measure in open-fronted workshops in the surrounding streets. 
 A few doors away I watched for half an hour through a film of sunlit flour motes as a small, soft mass of dough was miraculously spun and flung out to cover six-foot squares of sacking by two whirling, wizened old men. 
 A symbiotically mute pair then sectioned each of these into eight translucent oblongs, flouring them and stacking them delicately to sell on to the baklava and bougatsa makers round the corner. 
 Chania's visitors have a vast store of good, although not first-quality, leatherware to choose from. 
 The hide is uncoloured and is much better than you will find in Cairo, though not as supple as Florentine work. 
 You can buy a large well-sewn satchel-briefcase for &pound;20, and a good strong pair of women's sandals for &pound;4. 
 These are all stamped out with a huge press and dies like pastry cutters, in a dark vault in our street, by an old man who cuts from one skin first the back of a large rucksack, then a couple of handbag sides, and eventually bits of miniature hanging purses, like a thrifty housewife making tarts. 
 I happened upon the tannery when I walked east along the coast towards the beginning of the Akrotiri peninsula. 
 The impact of tourism stops pretty soon outside the medieval walls of the town, and the dwellings are like those of any impoverished fishing village in Cornwall, Sicily or Provence: low, simple buildings containing no more than the most primitive necessities, but opening on to the turquoise bay, with the Venetian walls on the western side and red cliffs to the east. 
 Walk on round to those cliffs and you come to what seem like utterly derelict sheds hanging on the edge of the precipice, stinking of goat: these are stacked with piles of skins for tanning, which goes on below in Brobdingnagian wooden barrels and enormous concrete troughs. 
 The extreme poverty of the whole concern is pathetic, and I wished I'd paid more for the things I bought so as to make life easier for these tanners who look just about ready to give up. 
 The energy and devotion given to making a living are remarkable. 
 On Sunday at 11pm, Mrs Biky's basement cavern was still humming with the sound of her sewing machine as she turned out ladies' dresses and blouses. 
 She's been working flat out every day since I came; from at least 8.30am till way past my bedtime. 
 To hire a car would be a mistake if you want to enjoy the White Mountains, which extend over the western end of the island, from immediately behind Chania and the north coast road to the edge of the south coast. 
 The roads are terrifyingly steep and on the map look like coils of intestines, which translated into reality become dizzying sets of hairpin bends, too narrow for two vehicles to pass in comfort at any speed. 
 The buses are cheap and excellent, the drivers are virtuosi, and cars give way to them, so it makes sense to use this facility and relax. 
 Having seen photographs of ancient Cretan coins portraying a labyrinth or maze, I was longing to see whether any trace of it survives at Knossos, a three-and-a-half-hour bus ride east along the coast road, just past Heraklion. 
 Here is the 3,500-year-old site where Minos, king of Crete, incarcerated the Minotaur &mdash; his dangerous half-man half-bull stepson. 
 Athenian youths had to be sent every three years to assuage the monster, and when Theseus, prince of Athens, grew old enough, he demanded to go and try to slay it. 
 Minos's daughter Ariadne fell in love with him and gave him a ball of string to unwind on his way to the creature's lair at the centre of the maze. 
 All he had to do was wind it up again to find the way out. 
 Theseus slew the Minotaur and with Ariadne set sail for home, stopping at Naxos, where, after a night of love, he slipped away at dawn without her. 
 There are lots of wonderful musical settings of her grief and rage at this point, notably one by Monteverdi. 
 I took a bus there, but found it hard to tell what the place might have been like. 
 Sir Arthur Evans bought the hill of ruins in 1900 and &bquo;reconstructed&equo; part of it according to his idea of what might have been. 
 The result is heavily dependent on the use of reinforced concrete, and although it looks impressive, it doesn't feel right. 
 If the pillars are really in the proper places, there is not a stone on the site long enough to act as a lintel, and to provide a basis for the stone-built superstructures which at present sit on Evans' concrete and iron supports. 
 There's now no trace of a labyrinth, though some shapes echo part of that on the coins. 
 It's tempting to wonder if Evans obliterated parts of it: certainly at least one seemingly obvious doorway has been walled up. 
 The hill feels peaceful in spite of tourists: it's surrounded by fragrant pine trees and deafeningly noisy with cicadas. 
 Even if I haven't seen the labyrinth, at least I've smelt and heard Ariadne's home landscape. 
 Back in Chania, the Calypso bar is filling with elderly Cretan men who click a lot: worry-beads clatter through their fiddling fingers, and they smack down counters on backgammon boards with ferocious violence. 
 An old gentleman enters, in a traditional blue and black costume, with knee-length white boots many times repainted. 
 His stumpy, yellowed silver moustache rides proudly over his camel-like sneer as he strides to the back of the bar, probably to renegotiate his olive and yoghurt contracts with the owner. 
 The waiter says this man used to live here until 15 years ago, and the bright boats bobbing on the undulating water of the main harbour would have been at his front door. 
 The five bells of the cathedral ring out a weirdly charming peal: perhaps some of the bells come from the foundry next door to the nineteenth-century cathedral. 
 The foundry operates in a former Turkish bathhouse roofed with nine ventilated domes, where, in deep gloom lit only from the dome vents, two teenage boys and an old woman produce all sizes of bells and ecclesiastical brassware. 
 FACT FILE Flights: Thomson is operating charter flights to Crete on Thursdays and Sundays until the end of November: seats booked through Vivair (01-636 5466), for example, cost from around &pound;190 return. 
 Books: There are several excellent guides to Crete. 
 The Landscapes of Eastern Crete and Landscapes of Western Crete (Sunflower Books, &pound;5.95 each) have good maps and plenty of interesting ideas for walks and car tours. 
 Also useful are The Rough Guide to Crete (Harrap-Columbus, &pound;4.95), The Blue Guide to Crete (Black, &pound;7.95) and Groc's Candid Guide to Crete (APP, &pound;7.95). 
 Fly high on a wing and a prayer: Simon Calder gives 10 commandments for making the most of US unlimited airpasses 
 By SIMON CALDER 
 THE airpass holder who whinged to the Dallas check-in clerk that she had spent all day standing by for a flight out of one of America's less attractive airports was gently chastised. 
 &bquo;Look lady, for what other people pay for a one-way ticket to Chicago, you can travel anywhere Delta flies for a month.&equo; 
 Two of the largest US airlines, Delta and Northwest, offer the air bargain of the year: unlimited travel on their domestic networks for 30 days for &dollar;399, about &pound;8 a day. 
 My itinerary was unambitious compared with those of some of my fellow standbys. 
 Judging by the number of young Germans I encountered, wanderlust has gone haywire. 
 They seem driven by a Teutonic determination to rack up as many airline meals as possible. 
 Just as Inter-railers traditionally take overnight express trains to get a night's sleep, so small teams of Germans are roaming North America, checking the schedules carefully for flights with catering or overnight trips which save on accommodation. 
 I took a meagre 22 flights. 
 Even so, at the official fares my trip would have cost more than &dollar;4,500. 
 Don't make firm plans: Your ticket bears a warning that you are &bquo;subject to removal if a confirmed passenger arrives before actual flight departure&equo;. 
 This happens. 
 Your cousin in Chicago will not thank you if he spends hours waiting at the world's busiest airport while you're supernumerary in San Jose. 
 Once you've paid your &dollar;399, you are a &bquo;non-revenue passenger&equo;, worth nothing to the airline. 
 You come to fear and loathe reserved passengers who turn up after the flight is supposed to have left, squeezing out standbys. 
 Given the forces of fate ranged against the standby passenger, the statistics of my trip were encouraging. 
 Of 22 chosen flights, I failed to get on only six and was carried on one of the next two flights. 
 You can minimise disappointment by calling the airline (toll-free) to check availability, and by being ready to switch at the last moment to a different, less popular destination. 
 Acquire a free spirit: You are at the mercy of check-in staff, late passengers and air-traffic control. 
 A party of Mormons making a pilgrimage to Salt Lake City or a hydraulics problem on a 737 can thwart the most carefully laid plans. 
 Go where the airline, if not the mood, will take you. 
 Be prepared to fly from A to B via Z: Delta's network is based on hubs, whereby waves of flights arrive simultaneously in Atlanta or Cincinatti, and take off an hour or so later. 
 This enables efficient connections, although airpass passengers are obliged to go on standby for each leg. 
 One consequence of this hub-and-spoke system is the maddening inability to fly direct between seemingly obvious routes. 
 Delta has no services from New York to Washington DC, so you have to go via Cincinatti. 
 To cover the 395 miles between Boston and Buffalo (for Niagara Falls), I was obliged to fly via Atlanta: a total distance of nearly 1,700 miles. 
 Take carry-on baggage only: If you register to travel on a flight, your bags will get on even if you don't. 
 At one stage my trousers were safely in San Diego while I was still in shorts in Albuquerque. 
 Travel alone: One person can travel faster than two. 
 I have found a seat on flights from way down in the &bquo;relegation zone&equo; on standby lists, simply because there was one space left and the couples above my name loyally refused to split up. 
 (The Cincinatti Corollary, as it is known, is to stay in the departure lounge until the aircraft leaves. 
 I was told one flight was full, and left the gate to mooch around the newsstands. 
 Later I found out that a standby wife had got halfway down the aisle before turning back, remorseful at abandoning her husband, leaving one empty seat &mdash; my seat, I brooded, as I waited for the next flight.) 
 Assume every flight will be late: British Rail is a model of good time-keeping in comparison with US airlines. 
 The shortest Delta flight is 21 miles between Miami and Fort Lauderdale; the longest is 2,212 from Orlando to Los Angeles. 
 Most were about 15 minutes late, some more than an hour. 
 Think small: Take full advantage of the small airlines affiliated to big carriers and open to airpass passengers. 
 Delta's partners hop around many of the more interesting parts of the USA, such as the Florida Keys or the national parks of the Rockies. 
 These 16-seat aircraft almost put the fun back in flying. 
 Being buffeted around the sky at 10,000 feet with an engine just inches from your ear is not the most comfortable way to fly, but it is more interesting than an anonymous 767. 
 Watch the weather: Every US newspaper devotes copious space to weather forecasts. 
 Thunderstorms will scupper the airline's schedules, and hence yours. 
 And if Portland is colder and wetter than Palm Beach, change your route and head for Florida. 
 Give up smoking: You can smoke only on flights of more than two hours, and soon smoking will be banned on all domestic flights. 
 Northwest bans smoking entirely within North America. 
 Most US airports ban smoking except in designated areas, usually far from the departure gate. 
 Don't overlook ground arrangements: Airports such as Washington National, a 50p subway ride from downtown, are rare. 
 Surface links between American airports and the cities they are supposed to serve are usually dire. 
 It is easy to spend more on taxi fares from airports than your airpass cost. 
 For example, Memphis airport is a &dollar;20 cab ride from the city. 
 There is no no bus service. 
 You solve this one by taking the Holiday Inn airport bus, buying a drink there to salve your conscience, and crossing the street to pick up a local bus. 
 You could follow my example and hitchhike out of Miami airport, but only if you're prepared to risk being picked up by a religious maniac, or dropped off in an impenetrable jungle of freeways close to the cocaine-dealing centre of America, or both. 
 FACT FILE Flights: Only Delta and Northwest offer unlimited travel airpasses. 
 Each costs &dollar;399 (about &pound;250) and must be bought outside the USA. 
 You have to produce a return transatlantic ticket and your passport both when buying the airpass and when checking in for each flight. 
 Northwest is strongest in the Midwest and allows you to fly in and out of Canada. 
 Delta is good for the South and South-west and has a more interesting selection of commuter airlines. 
 If you are prepared to take fewer flights and welcome the security of confirmed flights, a fixed-route airpass may be best. 
 The regional airpasses offered by America West (01-839 9381) and USAir (0800-777333) are particularly good value. 
 Rail: Travellers with a fear of flying or an abhorrence of airline meals may prefer a 45-day unlimited rail pass, available from Amtrak (2 Cinnamon Row, Plantation Wharf, London SW11 3TW: 01-978 5222) for only &dollar;299 (about &pound;185). 
 But American trains are infrequent and the network is patchy. 
 The giant, the witch and the weed: Legends cling to the dramatic coastal path of north Antrim, says John Forte 
 By JOHN FORTE 
 ALONG the north Antrim coastal path, you can admire the work of a giant, see the place where a witch turned a king's daughters into swans and sample the local delicacy, dulce, which resembles burnt tagliatelle but is in fact dried seaweed. 
 This is Ireland. 
 Not the Ireland beloved of the tourists who fill the pubs of the south-west, but the neglected northern coast, where a walker can sample some of Western Europe's most dramatic coastline, indulge in legends without recourse to a leprechaun, and on occasions enjoy the trip without bumping into a non-resident. 
 The path we followed is only a short section of the 560-mile Ulster Way, which takes in most of the province and requires a good three weeks to complete, but this section of the coastal path can be completed in a couple of days, though longer is highly recommended. 
 Probably the best place to start is Murlough Bay, reached by one of those narrow, winding roads that unnervingly dips out of sight so you wonder whether it continues or not. 
 The bay is a beautiful and tranquil enclave on a generally rugged coast. 
 Sea pinks cling to the lichen-covered rocks and huge beech trees, carved into oblique shapes by the wind, stand defiantly along the length of the bay and, to the south, on the slopes of Greenanmore where the kings of Dalriada had their summer residence. 
 The ruins of an ancient church stand near the pebble beach, which you may have to share with cows coming down for a paddle. 
 The water was a touch chilly for us to join in. 
 Just beyond the church is a track which leads back out of the bay and on towards the soaring cliffs of Fair Head. 
 From here, on a clear day, you can see right across the Moyle channel to Scotland, less than 13 miles away. 
 No wonder this part of Ireland felt a closer allegiance to Scotland than to the rest of Ireland over so many centuries. 
 Standing on these dramatic cliffs, the legends of the area seem quite plausible. 
 Below us is the spot where King Lir's second wife, a witch naturally, turned his two daughters into swans. 
 They swam for centuries in the sea below the cliffs, until the ringing of the first Christian bell changed them back into children and they drowned. 
 To get down to Ballycastle from here you have to return to the road, but before reaching the town you pass the well-preserved ruins of the Franciscan Bonamargy Friary, dating from about 1500. 
 It contains the massive coffins of several MacDonnell chiefs, a colourful family inextricably linked with this part of Antrim. 
 Ballycastle is one of the more attractive seaside towns, managing to avoid the excesses of other resorts, and there are no end of guest-houses if you want to break your walk or use the town as a base. 
 My English travelling companion was game to try the dulse seaweed, which is a speciality in Ballycastle, so I went into a little shop on the seafront. 
 &bquo;Folk aren't eating it like they used to, owing to the radioactivity from Sellafield,&equo; the shopkeeper said. 
 He said that radioactivity from &bquo;across the water&equo; accumulated in the seaweed. 
 We also passed over the other Ballycastle delicacy, the rock-hard &bquo;yellow-man&equo;, sweet as honeycomb, on account of dental rather than radioactive decay. 
 Further along, near the harbour, is a memorial to Marconi, who with his assistant, George Kemp, proved that wireless telegraphy was feasible by transmitting signals between Ballycastle and nearby Rathlin Island in 1898. 
 The walk follows a winding road out of Ballycastle for a short while, but it is worth branching off at the sign for Kinbane Castle. 
 Built by Colla MacDonnell in the sixteenth century, it clings to a narrow promontory, and although there is not much left of the castle itself, its magnificent position is worth the long haul back up the cliff path. 
 A couple of miles further on is the Carrick-a-rede rope bridge which, according to the tourist blurb, is &bquo;a tourist must &mdash; one of the famous things-to-do in Ireland&equo;. 
 It is certainly popular, but is only a &bquo;must&equo; for those happy with a bouncy bridge of wooden planks held together with rope suspended 80 feet above the sea. 
 The bridge provides a link to a small island for the salmon fishermen and is erected in May and dismantled in September. 
 Nearby, the National Trust has an information centre, and there is a camping site. 
 From Ballintoy harbour, the path winds round the bottom of the cliffs to Whitepark Bay, a beautiful, curved sandy beach where oyster-catchers are common and fulmar petrels nest on the surrounding cliffs. 
 At the western end of the bay a few houses and Ireland's smallest church, measuring 12ft by 6ft, make up the picturesque hamlet of Partbraddan. 
 From here the path is grassy and it is an easy walk to the ruins of Dunseverick Castle, which in prehistoric times marked the northern end of Ireland's oldest road, from where the Celts crossed to and from Scotland. 
 Although only fragments remain, Dunseverick manages not to be outdone in the legend stakes; Conal Caernach who lived here is said to have witnessed the crucifixion of Christ while serving in the Roman army. 
 After Dunseverick, the path hugs the clifftop contours of Benbane Head. 
 This section is one of the most dramatic, weaving in and out of sheltered coves and exposed headlands. 
 As an appetiser to the spectacle approaching, the rocks begin to take on an unusually geometric shape, until on turning the jagged headland of Part na Spanaigh, the astonishing site of 40,000 mostly hexagonal stone columns comes into view. 
 The Giant's Causeway is hard to believe until you are standing on it. 
 Unlike most of the sights before, you are unlikely to be standing alone and I noticed that other visitors wandered round in disbelieving silence. 
 Maybe they were looking for traces of cement which would give the game away, but the excellent visitors' centre explains that building materials such as cement were not available when the giant, Finn McCool, built the causeway. 
 The visitors' centre also describes the pride of the Spanish Armada, the galleon Girona, which was wrecked off this coast in 1588 with the loss of over 1,000 lives. 
 Some of the magnificent treasure from the ship is now on display in the Ulster Museum in Belfast. 
 The walk's last leg follows the embankment of the world's first electric road-railway, which used to take Victorian tourists from Portrush to the Giant's Causeway but now covers only the easy descent into Portballintrae. 
 With Bushmills distillery just up the road, this is an apt place to celebrate the end of a great walk. 
 Or perhaps, bearing in mind some of the coastal path's legends and sights, it is a good place to start. 
 Fact File Flights: British Airways and British Midland operate seven flights a day from Heathrow to Belfast International Airport; for example BA early saver return &pound;85 (01-897 4000). 
 Also flights from other major airports throughout the UK. 
 Car Hire: All major car hire companies at airport. 
 Accommodation: A choice of hotels, guest-houses, self-catering apartments and camping sites. 
 Guest-house prices from around &pound;18/double. 
 Self-catering from &pound;150 per week in high season. 
 Useful information: To tackle the Ulster Way, contact The Sports Council in Belfast (0232 381222). 
 The Oul' Lammas Fair in Ballycastle (28-9 August) is Ireland's oldest large fair, when you can dance in the streets at night. 
 Skiing: America versus the Alps: Transatlantic attractions of the Rocky Mountain heights 
 By CHRIS GILL 
 THIS MAY or may not turn out to be the winter when serious numbers of British skiiers forsake the Alps for the Rockies. 
 Nigel Lawson's achievements on exchange and interest rates could be the deciding factor. 
 Keen skiers are motivated to consider the transatlantic option by the notion that paying a bit more for their holiday and enduring a longer journey may cut out the uncertainty about snow conditions that hangs over European skiing. 
 The American question is inescapable. 
 If you pick up a handful of ordinary package brochures, America will be there: Crystal, Inghams, Intasun, Neilson and Thomson all have new or expanded American programmes. 
 My qualification for writing about skiing in the USA is unusual: I have never done it. 
 So I cannot claim to be an expert, but I have been considering spending my own money on America this year. 
 My deliberations (drawing on reports to The Good Skiing Guide) may sharpen the issues for others. 
 Snow apart, the main attractions of American skiing seem clear. 
 Like most American enterprises, ski resorts are run with an eagerness to please that is virtually unknown in Europe. 
 Ski patrols, lift attendants and restaurant staff are uniformly cheerful and helpful. 
 Runs are routinely groomed to standards that you find in Europe only when fundamental snow conditions are near perfection. 
 Information abounds &mdash; piste maps are dispensed beside lift queues, weather forecasts are posted everywhere and broadcast incessantly. 
 Other plus-points are civilised lift queues; efficient use of the lifts' capacity (four-seaters always carrying four skiers); good child-care facilities; accommodation which really can accommodate the advertised number of occupants; and ski instruction which is enthusiastic, fun and conducted by native English-speakers. 
 If your skiing is normally ruined by disrespect for British queueing principles or by surly shepherds doing winter duty as lift attendants, these matters will weigh heavily. 
 But for many people (me included) most are peripheral to holiday enjoyment. 
 On the other side, there are drawbacks. 
 The first is that the US ski areas are no match in scale or mountain drama for those of the Alps. 
 The Rocky Mountains have no shortage of rocky mountains, but the ones open to skiers are rounded, wooded hills. 
 With the conspicuous exception of Jackson Hole (in Wyoming), few ski areas reach more than 1,000m above resort level &mdash; a run-of-the-mill vertical drop in Europe, where 1,500m vertical is common and 2,000m not difficult to find. 
 In length of runs, equally, the Rockies are overshadowed by the 10km, 15km and 20km set-pieces of the Alps. 
 And the great piste-bashers' adventures of Europe &mdash; the Trois Vallees, Sella Ronda, Portes du Soleil &mdash; are not matched. 
 More important in some eyes is the difficulty of access. 
 Total journey time to a Rockies resort can exceed 24 hours if your itinerary involves connecting flights. 
 When combined with the need to acclimatise to life at 3,000m (at Breckenridge or Copper Mountain, for example), the after-effects of a journey like this can eat into precious holiday time. 
 Seekers after Alpine charm may or may not be content with the neo-Tyrolean style of Vail; they may or may not adapt to the Wild West clapboard houses of resuscitated mining towns such as Breckenridge. 
 But they will certainly be disappointed by the style of Rockies skiing above valley level. 
 Lunch on the mountain is the norm in many areas, but in most it is consumed in cafeterias designed more for efficiency than atmosphere, and even these are not immune from crowding. 
 (An additional consideration is that alcohol is often rationed on safety grounds, which many skiers of my acquaintance would judge to be an unjustifiable infringement of their liberty.) 
 And what about cost? 
 A package price of &pound;700 for a fortnight is typical. 
 If I want to share the room with only one other person, rather than the three the brochure presumes, that will add around &pound;300. 
 Like most packages to the States, it provides only the room (some also provide breakfast, but few provide other meals). 
 From The Good Skiing Guide reports I estimate that for those with a taste for Cabernet-Sauvignon, a budget of &pound;30 a day would not be extravagant, adding another &pound;400. 
 Lift pass &pound;200. 
 Total, excluding tuition and equipment, &pound;1,600. 
 For that I could have three separate weeks in Alpine chalets. 
 So where does this leave us or, more precisely, me? 
 Back where I started, with concerns about snow. 
 The Rockies are touted as having guaranteed snow. 
 In fact, of course, they offer no such thing: there have been lean years there, and even lean patches last winter. 
 So what we are talking about is probabilities, and unquantified ones at that. 
 With the mortgage payments in mind, I think I'll give the Alps one more chance. 
 Skiing Update: Feel the burn 
 By CHRIS GILL 
 VIDEO recording as an aid to skiing tuition is a well established idea and apparently a powerful one. 
 Powder Byrne, which offers off-piste skiing courses as add-ons to its hotel and chalet holidays in the Swiss Alps, is a confirmed user, and has hit on the bright idea of recycling some of last winter's footage as a low-key promotional device. 
 The unspoken message of the video they lend you is that you start the week head-planting in the snow and finish it bouncing imperturbably down virgin slopes. 
 The video is low on information, but high on evocation of the Alpine experience. 
 For more details contact Powder Byrne (01-223 0601). 
 Skiing Update: Trial smiles 
 By CHRIS GILL 
 THOSE who yearn for the smiling helpfulness of American skiing, but whose credit limits do not permit access to it, can console themselves with the news that the French resort of Les Arcs is launching a campaign to distinguish itself from competing resorts by encouraging staff to be unfailingly polite. 
 Before long, the famous pouting Gallic shrug may be but a fond memory. 
 Researching the Police in Easton 
 INTRODUCTION 
 It might be claimed that studying routine policing in Northern Ireland avoids the real issue of policing in the province and that attention ought to be addressed to those sections of the RUC which are responsible for what Turk (1982) calls &bquo;political policing&equo; and Brodeur (1983) &bquo;high policing&equo;, such as the Special Branch, the mobile support units, which are in effect riot police, or the various surveillance units like E4A. 
 While there are studies of the RUC's role in security and public-order issues (Brewer et al . 
 1988: 47&ndash;84; Enloe 1978; Pockrass 1986; Weitzer 1985, 1986, 1987 a, b) , this forms only part of RUC duties, given the special position of Northern Ireland among divided societies. 
 Primarily, however, an empirically based study of public order policing is impossible to undertake in the midst of the province's continuing violent conflict, and certainly could not be done with the degree of depth, empirical focus, familiarity, and, frankly, personal safety which an ethnographic study of routine policing allows. 
 Nor would such a study have been given permission by the RUC, for it is utopian to expect police authorities in divided societies to open up these sections of their force to scrutiny and observation by outsiders. 
 An analysis of routine policing at least allows the possibility of empirical research being undertaken on police forces operating in divided societies, which is itself important because studies in the sociology of policing focus almost exclusively on police forces in stable liberal democracies. 
 In the process of examining how routine policing is affected by social divisions, researchers may, however, obtain some direct and first-hand impression of public order policing, if only unsatisfactorily as it briefly or infrequently enters their research location. 
 But routine policing in a divided society also constitutes an important substantive topic in its own right, for it  provides an additional dimension to the analysis of routine policing, as well as expanding and clarifying our understanding of what divided societies are like. 
 As certain areas of Great Britain, for example, take on some of the characteristics of divided societies, the focus of this study also has a relevance, of increasing proportion, outside the province and beyond what many residents in Northern Ireland might see as most directly pertinent to them. 
 Finally, any analysis of the RUC is worth while because of its intrinsic interest and relative neglect. 
 The interest which the RUC has as a police force derives entirely from the social context in which it operates, but this context is both a spur and a hindrance to research on the RUC. 
 Policing in Northern Ireland is a very controversial topic in a sensitive environment, and this sensitivity has implications for the research (on which see Brewer 1990 b ), especially its design and location, as well as for the validity and reliability of the results. 
 In most situations it is unusual and unnecessary to dwell on features of the research design, except perhaps in a boring and unread appendix, but in our instance we feel it is important to spend a chapter outlining the nature of the research design and location, and the associated problems, in order for the findings to be placed in their context, and to ensure that these considerations be taken seriously. 
 Further, if, as Woolgar emphasizes (1988a), reflexivity on the part of authors is a vital quality in helping others understand how social-scientific knowledge is produced, these reflections are important to demonstrate some of the social processes lying behind and operating upon this study. 
 Above all, however, this chapter is intended to begin a debate about the methodological and theoretical influence upon research of &bquo;sensitivity&equo;, whether deriving from the sensitivity of the topic, its location, or both. 
 Textbooks on research methods rarely mention the problems that arise when undertaking research on controversial topics or conducting it in sensitive locations. 
 When it is considered, sensitivity is usually approached from the perspective of ethics (for example see Rainwater and Pittman 1966), and comments range from the commonplace to the anecdotal. 
 In fact, our research shows that sensitivity needs to emerge from the shadows and be recognized as an important problem in research. 
 Researchers should therefore give more attention to its negative effects on their conduct, especially in the way it requires researchers to make a number of pragmatic  compromises which depart from the textbook portrayal of ideal research practice. 
 In the past, many researchers have tended to underplay the problems that arose in the process of research in case they affected the evaluation of their results, although there have been a few ex post facto  disclosures in books intended to show social research as often a messy enterprise (Bell and Newby 1977; Bell and Roberts 1984). 
 The only issues to be explored systematically are those of negotiating access (for example, Fox and Lundman 1974; Holdaway 1982), and the effects of gender on practice in the field (for example, Easterday et al . 
 1977; Hunt 1984; Warren 1988; Warren and Rasmussen 1977). 
 However, until very recently, the leading ethnographers of the police made few disclosures on the difficulties they encountered, implying that their entry into the field and relations with police officers were unproblematic. 
 Although often studying less controversial forces than the RUC, this panglossian portrayal has to be disbelieved, especially as the authors often indicated in an occasional footnote, or in a revealing preface or aside, that they faced problems in the field similar to our own (for example, see van Maamen 1981: 479, 492; Westley 1970, p. vii), even when the research was covert (Holdaway 1982, 1983: 12). 
 The only exception to this is the discussion of the likely reactive effect caused by the presence of observers (McCall 1975; Policy Studies Institute 1983b: 11&ndash;15; Reiss 1971; Softley 1980; Southgate and Ekblom 1986; Steer 1980), although no serious doubt is put on the validity of observational data on the police. 
 However, an increasing awareness of this omission has led some specialists in the area of ethnographic work on the police to address systematically the problems they encountered in the field (Punch 1989; van Maanen 1988). 
 In the case of the RUC it is essential to reflect on the problems that arose in the research. 
 We believe that results can only be properly evaluated if the problems connected with the study are made manifest rather than concealed. 
 We do not wish to commit the mistake that Woolgar believes is widespread in social science: namely, of suggesting that the only knowledge which is not  subject to the influence of contingent historical, cultural, and social processes is that which we ourselves have written (Woolgar 1988b). 
 This reflexivity, what Woolgar more accurately calls benign introspection (p. 22), is thus a virtue rather than a limitation because it provides some of the necessary contextual background to help evaluate the  study. 
 We will look first at problems arising during the field-work, before describing the nature of Easton and its police station. 
 RESEARCHING THE RUC 
 Many people have noted how the police are not helpful in initiating research or in welcoming sociologists (Greenhill 1981: 91; Holdaway 1979: 1, 1983: 3&ndash;4). 
 In part this reflects a reluctance to let outsiders interfere with the job of policing, as well as a suspicion about soci &mdash; ology, which for many policemen sounds too much like the word &bquo;socialist&equo;; social work suffers from the same association. 
 A constable in Easton once said, &bquo;If anything gets me down it's bloody sociology. 
 I think it's the biggest load of shite, simple as that&equo; (FN 13/9/87, pp. 5&ndash;6), although a senior officer was prepared to explain his antagonism more fully: 
 I think most policeman can't relate to sociology at all, because, you see, the way we're taught everything is black and white: those who do bad should be punished, those who do good should be rewarded. 
 Sociology just seems to turn all that on its head. 
 It would seem to say that all those who are right and honest are wrong. 
 Just say a man doesn't earn as much money as me and he has to steal to keep his family, well, sociology says that's OK. 
 Another thing, sociology would seem to be saying that those who have wealth and do well do so at the expense of the poor unfortunate. 
 (FN 24/6/87, p. 2) 
 But the ethos of professionalism with which police authorities are imbued has led to a recognition that social research can bring valuable results, so they have opened up their leviathan to strangers and specially commissioned specific pieces of research. 
 This came somewhat late to the RUC because of the added security risks its members run by admitting outsiders, and because police authorities in divided societies like Northern Ireland have to be more sensitive about public perceptions of the police and therefore more conscious of the risks they run through research. 
 It is as a result of fears such as this that members of the RUC are required to obtain official permission before they cam talk to outsiders, such as the Press and researchers, or face being sacked from the force. 
 For ethical reasons, no social researcher should expose respondents to that possibility, and others over whom this threat does not hang or by whom it is treated lightly, such as ex-policemen and women or disgruntled members of the force, are too unrepresentative to give a balanced view of policing  Therefore, it was necessary to undertake an overt study and to obtain permission for the research from the Chief Constable. 
 Many different kinds of research require the permission of a &bquo;gatekeeper&equo;, including all overt police research, and the reliability of the data depends upon what control the gatekeeper demands (something Douglas (1972) calls &bquo;retrenchment from the front&equo;) and the integrity of the researcher in withstanding such pressure. 
 Research on policing in divided societies is especially likely to provoke suspicion about its reliability for these reasons. 
 Hence it is worth explaining, in a way that elsewhere might not be necessary and would be seen as an indulgence, that in our case, once permission was granted, no limits were laid down by senior officers and no censorship role has been retained by the RUC over the final manuscript. 
 The field-worker was able to spend as much time in the field as the principal investigator thought necessary, and no restrictions were placed on her going out on patrol, travelling in vehicles, or going to incidents of routine police duty. 
 The particular section within Easton station upon which we came to focus attention was decided by us not the police management. 
 Visits were allowed to other stations, including, on three occasions, those in areas of high tension in West and North Belfast, and to the Women's Police Unit, dealing entirely with sex crimes. 
 The important step in the research was therefore in obtaining initial permission. 
 The key to this undoubtedly lay in the attraction to the RUC of the idea of research on how routine policing is affected by Northern Ireland's security situation, and the appeal of giving ordinary policemen and women an opportunity to express their views about policing. 
 The experience of other police forces who had granted researchers permission also showed that no great difficulties were created as a result, and allowing research accords with the professionalism which is the core value of senior officers in the RUC. 
 This topic has less attraction for ordinary policemen and women, for although they might take pleasure in thing someone is interested in their views, it is they who run the risks associated with answering questions and from being observed doing their job. 
 This is what Fox and Lundman (1974: 53) mean when they say that there are two &bquo;gates&equo; within police organizations which affect access &mdash; winning the support both of senior managers and of the ordinary members of the force who are the subjects of the research. 
 A technical problem such as this raises interesting methodological  questions, because it forces one to ask which style of research is better suited to overcoming respondents' resistance and suspicion, especially when talking about sensitive and controversial topics. 
 It was thought that a questionnaire which asked police officers to tick the answer which came nearest to their attitude toward Catholics, or best reflected their feelings about being targets, would be very unreliable, especially when asked by someone with whom they were unfamiliar. 
 Past questionnaire research on the police has suffered from a low response rate (for example, Policy Studies Institute 1983a). 
 Ethnographic research has special qualities suited to dealing with controversial topics in sensitive locations, for it entails a gradual and progressive contact with respondents, which is sustained over a long period, allowing a rapport to be established slowly with respondents over time, and for researchers to participate in the full range of experiences involved in the topic. 
 This is why a great deal of the best police research is based on the ethnographic methods of participant observation and in-depth interviewing, and why workers in several other unusual, off-beat, difficult, or demanding occupations have been studied ethnographically, such as lorry drivers (Hollowell 1968), coal-miners (Dennis et al . 
 1956), traffic wardens (Richman 1983), cocktail waitresses (Spradley and Mann 1975), prison warders (Jacobs and Retsky 1975), and health visitors (Dingwall 1977), among others (for a selection see Berger 1964; Hughes 1958). 
 Hence many books on the technique of ethnography have been written by those with a background in police research (Fielding and Fielding 1986; Punch 1987). 
 Although in these circumstances the ethnographic method is the best way to obtain trust, it does not ensure it will be won from every respondent in the field. 
 In our case, it was never a simple matter of trust, once having been won, being taken for granted, as the textbooks suggest. 
 Although this was true for some respondents, most policemen and women in Easton periodically sought reassurance from the researcher about the purpose of the research, what was being written down about them, who would have access to the material, what the researchers' politics, religion, allegiances, and so on were. 
 The field-worker's legitimacy had to be proved continually and skilfully, and trust was gained as a result of a progressive series of negotiations. 
 As Johnson puts it (1975), trust is not a &bquo;one shot agreement&equo; but is continually negotiated during field-work (also see Emerson 1983: 176; van Maanen 1982). 
 This was especially so in our  case because the field-worker was a female within a masculine occupational culture and quickly identified as Catholic by the usual means through which people in Northern Ireland &bquo;tell&equo; identity (Burton 1979). 
 The permission of the Chief Constable was also a disadvantage in the field because it raised doubts among respondents about the purpose of the researcher's questions over and above those that naturally arise from the political situation in Northern Ireland. 
 The almost inherent suspicion the police have of strangers was in the RUC's case added to by worries about whether their personal security would be compromised and concern over the intentions of the police management. 
 To help engender trust and familiarity, the field-worker's contact in the station was restricted at the beginning to a few hours a shift once a week, gradually being built up to a full shift, including mights, twice a week. 
 Time was initially divided between two sections within the station in order to broaden the range of contacts, and visits were made to other stations, but, as the time devoted to data collection lengthened and data collection itself became more intensive, the focus narrowed to one section: roughly about twenty people. 
 However, other constables in Easton were encountered regularly in the canteen, on guard duty, and in the neighbourhood and community policing units of the station, and the personnel in the section periodically changed as a result of transfers. 
 We were provided, therefore, with as broad a range of contacts as is possible within one station (although this breadth does not approach that which comes from survey research) while still becoming close to one section, as is necessary in ethnographic research. 
 Field-work took place over a twelve-month period between 1987 and 1988, and was sufficiently prolonged to avoid the criticism which brief &bquo;smash-andgrab&equo; ethnographies often deserve. 
 Data were recorded by means of notepads not tape-recorder. 
 Initially the field-worker's relations with respondents in the field were especially and unusually warm, which runs counter to the norm in ethnographic research. 
 She was seen as a light relief from the boredom or demands of the shift, and, as a female, she was treated as a pretty face in a working environment which is heavily masculine. 
 As contact in the field increased, and the presence of the fieldworker became routine, her treatment by respondents similarly became routine. 
 It was only at that point that we felt confident that the field-worker was being talked to by respondents as a person  rather than as some novel sex object, and the veracity of what they said could be treated by us with more confidence. 
 We therefore dispute van Maanen's view that researchers on the police have to be male (1981: 480), in order to be able to participate fully in the masculine occupational and leisure culture of the police. 
 What is more important than gender is the personality and skill of the fieldworker in overcoming the feelings of suspicion the police have of all outsiders, especially in the more enclosed and threatened world of the RUC, and in our case the field-worker's gender seemed no bar to her obtaining access to the masculine &bquo;canteen culture&equo; of the men or to participating in conversations on the topics which are popular in that culture, which van Maanen describes as &bquo;sports, cars and sex&equo; (1981: 476). 
 And, given the men's views of gender roles, being female actually facilitated and encouraged the introduction of certain topics, especially topics of a more emotional kind to do with stress, death, the terrorist threat and its effect on the family, and so on, which are particularly pertinent in Northern Ireland's police force. 
 Moreover, it also allowed entry into the policewomen's world, which, using van Maanen's logic, would have been denied a male field-worker (for the difficulties in establishing rapport experienced by a male researcher on the police see Warren and Rasmussen 1977: 358). 
 It is well known that the personal characteristics of a participant observer affect their research practice (see Hunt 1984; Warren 1988; Warren and Rasmussen 1977; Wax 1979), and that being female brings its own problems in the field. 
 In this regard, the fieldworker's experiences with the RUC are similar to those of other young female researchers, in that she was subject to sexual hustling, fraternizing, and paternalistic attitudes from male respondents (see Easterday et al . 
 1977). 
 However, there are also advantages in being of this gender. 
 Young female researchers can be treated as &bquo;acceptable incompetents&equo; (Lofland 1971: 100), and perceived as nonthreatening (Easterday et al . 
 1977: 344; Warren and Rasmussen 1977: 360&ndash;1). 
 As Jennifer Hunt (1984) showed in respect to her work on the police, these qualities can increase a female researcher's penetration in the field and facilitate the development of rapport. 
 While no researcher, irrespective of their gender, can ever be totally sure that respondents are being truthful (specially so in our case), the research design compensated for this. 
 It is difficult to sustain untruths and false masks over twelve months of contact in  the field, particularly when this contact involves sharing private moments with respondents, such as those provided in the canteen or during the quiet hours of the might shift, tiding in the back of a vehicle or on security duty in the sanger (guardpost). 
 After several months of working full eight-hour shifts, the constables frequently forgot that an outsider was present, or no longer cared, and the fieldworker experienced moments when it would have been difficult to maintain a front. 
 While a few policemen tried to the bitter end to avoid conversation with the field-worker, sufficient rapport was established over time for the majority to talk quite openly to her about what are highly sensitive and controversial topics in a Northern Ireland context. 
 It is for this reason that many of the extracts from the data which we use in the volume are accounts and nearverbatim records of spontaneous conversations in natural situations, for we thought it unreliable to &bquo;interview&equo; respondents formally (van Maanen 1982: 140 argues that most ethnographic data are conversation-based). 
 As one further measure of the rapport that was established, most respondents eventually became assured enough in her presence to express their feelings about being the subject of research. 
 Over a twelve-month period a field-worker's persistent inquisitiveness is bound to become something of an irritant, and van Maanen notes how field-workers cannot expect to be liked by all respondents (1982: 111). 
 But leaving aside instances of momentary irritation, of which there were many, as all field-workers must expect, most respondents became confident enough in the field-worker's presence to express what were undoubtedly widely held fears about the research. 
 Sometimes these concerns were expressed through humour and tibaldry. 
 The field-worker became known among some policemen as &bquo;Old Nosebag&equo;, and there were long-running jokes about spelling people's names correctly in Sinn Fein's Republican News . 
 On one occasion, they were expressed through anger. 
 Towards the end of a long and tiring night shift, when news was coming through of the murder of another member of the RUC, one policeman in particular decided to put the field-worker through a test of trust. 
 PC. 1. 
 Look, just hold on a wee minute. 
 What gives you the right to come here and start asking us these personal questions about our families and that?&hellip; 
 You're not going to learn anything about the police while you're here. 
 They're not going to tell you anything&hellip; 
 And you know why? 
 Because you're always walking around with that bloody notebook writing  everything down, and you're not getting anywhere near the truth&hellip; 
 Like, what use is this research you're doing anyway? 
 Is it going to do me or my mates any good? 
 What you doing it for? 'Cos let me tell you, the only people who are going to be interested in your bloody research are the authorities. 
 WPC. 
 Can't you see that. 
 They're just using you&hellip; 
 PC. 1. 
 And I'll tell you another thing, you're too much of a liability. 
 See, when I go out, I'm looking out for me and my mate, I don't want some researcher in the back who's just going to be a liability&hellip; 
 Nobody gives a shit about you and your research. 
 Like, why did you feel the need to do this research on the RUC anyway?&hellip; 
 The bobby is the same the world over. 
 They worry about: number one, the money; number two, their social life; and number three, the job. 
 WPC. 
 Number one, their family. 
 Years ago people might have put the job first, but not any more. 
 Now it's family&hellip; 
 People have been murdered for this job and no one gives a shit. 
 PC. 1. 
 How do we know we can trust you? 
 What religion are you? 
 How do I know I can trust you if I don't know what religion you are? 
 RESEARCHER. 
 I'm a Catholic. 
 PC. 1. 
 Are you ashamed of it? 
 Then what are you crying about? 
 You would think you were ashamed of it or something&hellip; 
 Like, I'm just asking things everybody wanted to know&hellip; 
 Has anyone ever spoken to you like this since you've been here? 
 What's so bad about it. 
 Do you know, it makes it a lot easier for us to work with you if we find these things out about you. 
 See, this research, as far as I'm concerned you'll learn nothing. 
 It's a waste of time. 
 To be honest, I couldn't give a monkey's fart about your research. 
 If you really wanted to learn something you should have started at the top. 
 It's them you need to be looking at. 
 They don't care about the family man getting shot, they don't care about the families. 
 The guy shot tonight will be forgotten about in another few weeks&hellip; 
 It's them you should be talking to. 
 The so-called big men up at the top don't care about us. 
 WPC. 
 But it's us who are getting shot and blown up. 
 PC. 1. 
 Like, you're apologizing for crying. 
 Nothing wrong with that, but if you want to learn anything about us we have to feel we can trust you. 
 I didn't speak to you before because I didn't know you. 
 &lsqb;Others&rsqb; don't want to know the things you want to know, see the things you want to see&hellip; 
 Like, I've seen my name written down about five times on that last page. 
 If the authorities read that they'd put me on the next bus to &lsqb;name of border area&rsqb; and keep me there. 
 PC. 2. 
 I'll tell you this. 
 See, when I come in here on a night, it's not the IRA  I'm worried about, it's them upstairs. 
 PC. 1. 
 I don't care what you're writing down, just as long as I don't see it in Republican News . 
 Maybe the police has made me this way, but do you not see that if you're going to come in here asking me questions about my family, if you're going to want to know all these things, I've got to be able to trust you? 
 Like, after this tonight, I'd let you come out in a vehicle with me. 
 (FN 30/8/87, pp. 33&ndash;45) 
 This extract is useful in order to illustrate how the field-worker, on the one policeman's own admission, both needed to be tested and was successful in passing. 
 Trust is an overriding consideration of all policemen and women, because it is part of the team basis by which police work gets done, whether formally in terms of managerial expectations or informally within the occupational culture (Holdaway 1983: 1 15), but it is particularly important in the RUC. 
 There were many different sorts of trials set for the field-worker (something noted in their field-work experience by Douglas 1972 and van Maanen 1982), and the apologies other members of the section later gave her because of this policeman's conduct is proof that these other trials, too, were successfully passed. 
 But this particular extract is useful for another reason, in that it shows, through the sub-plots which appear within it, the range of issues provoked by the research which respondents were sensitive about. 
 Some of these are worth highlighting in greater detail as a means of contextualizing the data and illustrating some of the social processes operating upon them. 
 One of the consequences of the RUC's dual role is that it has features typical of most police forces and qualities special to it. 
 This is reflected in the respondents' sensitivity towards the police management, an enduring theme in the conversation of ordinary policemen and women in any force, and towards the terrorist threat, which is not faced by others to the same degree. 
 The latter makes what is already an internally homogeneous organization even more enclosed and protective. 
 As one constable put it, &bquo;I don't mind you being here, I don't mind you taking notes. 
 I don't mind you at all, but the boys they'd be suspicious of anyone who's not a member of the police force, and that's how people will see you: you're not a member of the force&equo; (FN 23/10/87, p. 20). 
 Establishing an overt research role was therefore always going to be a task of sisyphean labour, but the sensitivity of the topic and location made it more difficult than is usual in ethnographic research. 
 The issues about which respondents expressed concern included  the use made of the results by, variously, the police authorities and the IRA, and the associated question of whether the field-worker was a spy for the authorities or the Republican paramilitaries (on researchers as spies see Hunt 1984: 288&ndash;9; Manning 1972: 248); the obtrusiveness of the ethnographer's ubiquitous notepad; sensitivity to how the research might compromise their personal security or lead to a transfer, and worthies over the field-worker's religion; and the whole focus and topic of the investigation. 
 Concern about our motives in doing the research was combined with a feeling that it would do those participating in it little good, but would certainly benefit those in the police management and outside who wanted to do them harm. 
 Variations on the fears expressed below reappear many times in the field notes. 
 The way we look at it is, there's people out there want to kill me, and the authorities let you in here and give you access to more than we will probably ever get. 
 It's OK for the authorities because it's not them you're looking at &mdash; you won't be walking the beat with them. 
 It's not them you're writing about. 
 It mightn't be a bad idea if it was. 
 The way some people look at it is, why should I let you write a book that won't do me any good but might do me some harm. 
 Like, the men who won't talk to you think they're just protecting themselves. 
 Something you write could lose somebody their job&hellip; 
 It might be the authorities who give you permission but when it comes to the bit it's the ordinary policeman who's getting shot. 
 By letting you do this research they're putting a additional risk on us&hellip; 
 But, like, most people here accept you. 
 For goodness' sake, there's some peelers they never accept. 
 (FN 19/9/87, pp. 12, 15) 
 Well, like, I can remember when the word went round that someone was coming to do research on the RUC. 
 Like, you must think for yourself; look at the IRA's intelligence network&hellip; 
 I've seen how they recruit young girls. 
 (FN 2/3/87, pp. 9&ndash;10) 
 It was easy to anticipate that respondents would be sensitive about such matters, and it was our general tolerance of such fears that continually led us to try to pacify and reassure respondents. 
 This in large part won in return their acquiescence in the research, at least for the majority, even though this was usually a reluctant and resigned co-operation. 
 Their enthusiasm for the research increased after the policemen and women in Easton had reassured themselves about the field-worker's religion, sensitivity towards which was initially intensified by the common-sense view among some ordinary  constables that Queen's University is a Republican stronghold. 
 Some respondents knew from the beginning that she was Catholic, and those that did not soon learnt about it. 
 It is impossible to know the extent to which this knowledge had a reactive effect in the field, although the research was designed in such a way as to try to establish, as well as one ever could, whether there was a mask behind which respondents were concealing their true behaviour and feelings. 
 Ultimately, however, it is easy for readers to charge that the mask was not penetrated, and therefore that we have only scratched at the surface. 
 But it is our considered judgement that this knowledge did not have the reactive effect which the sensitive nature of the issue might suggest. 
 On one level, it did not prevent some respondents expressing disparaging remarks about Catholics, nor dissuade them from giving opinions on controversial political issues. 
 On a deeper level, however, as we shall see in later chapters, the identity category &bquo;Catholic&equo; is, for the majority of policemen and women, not an all-inclusive typification in which every Catholic is categorized alike. 
 Most members of the RUC we encountered used an interpretative process which contains a set of typifications for distinguishing between &bquo;good&equo; and &bquo;bad&equo; Catholics, as for &bquo;good&equo; and &bquo;bad&equo; people generally. 
 Once the field-worker was categorized as conforming to their typification of a &bquo;good&equo; Catholic (the meaning of which we will outline elsewhere), then her religion was no longer as important as it appears at first sight, although the extent to which it had a residual effect is impossible to estimate. 
 But it only remained of crucial importance to that small minority of bigoted constables who classify all Catholics as equally evil and nefarious. 
 We suspect, therefore, that this knowledge had a markedly distorting effect only among a minority of respondents. 
 It is this relatively more subtle classification system which explains why policemen and women were so concerned from the very beginning with the field-worker's background, schooling, area of residence, affiliations, political opinions, and so on, even those visited on only a few occasions. 
 These &bquo;search questions&equo; are the usual means by which one &bquo;tells&equo; identity in Northern Ireland, but they were used particularly by policemen and women to tell, as they interpret it, which &bquo;sort&equo; of Catholic the field-worker was. 
 This explains the anomaly of why these questions were asked by people who already knew she was Catholic, and why they were periodically asked in different ways throughout the year of field-work, for they  are the means for establishing and then reconfirming and testing the typification. 
 And, further, in areas like Easton, where there is very little crime related to the troubles, the police do not on the whole develop the attitude that law and order is a battle between the RUC and Catholics. 
 This encourages a balanced view of Catholics, something which, as we shall emphasize in later chapters, can be absent amongst some policemen beleaguered behind their reinforced stations in areas of high tension and conflict. 
 A final point worth making in defence of the data is that the observational material cannot be impugned to the same degree, because in the flow of action during an incident the exigencies of the situation usually take over, making it difficult for policemen and women to act in ways contrary to what the situation requires or their colleagues demand. 
 Hence many extracts from the data used in this volume are near-verbatim records of natural conversations in reallife settings. 
 While on the whole we feel knowledge of the field-worker's religion was not detrimental to the research, we believe it also had positive effects, in that it immediately forced respondents to confront their attitudes towards Catholics, as did the field-worker's gender in relation to sex roles in the force, placing both issues high on the research agenda. 
 It also facilitated access to the minority of Catholic policemen and women in the force, and, perhaps, was important in obtaining permission for the research from the police management, for it asserts their commitment to professionalism, an important part of which in Northern Ireland is religious impartiality. 
 Undoubtedly there were other reactive effects, for this occurs with all overt research. 
 Indeed, senior officers initially warned policemen and women at Easton to be careful in the field-worker's presence, with particular emphasis placed on swearing. 
 Once again, the intensity of contact spread over such a long time in the field makes this form of self-monitoring difficult to maintain, and there was also a general resistance from below to the management's instruction. 
 PC. 1. 
 We were told to be very careful about what we said and done when you were around, like. 
 But, quite frankly, what's the point? 
 You're here to see us acting naturally and I don't see why we should change, because then you're not getting a true picture, are you? 
 PC. 2. 
 I just fucking act myself anyway. 
 (FN 16/3/87, p. 16) 
 When a sergeant congratulated one section on the improvement in  the language in the guard room over the last few hours when the field-worker had been present, one constable shouted, &bquo;Fucking good job too, Sir&equo; (FN 2/2/87, p. 6), and the occupational culture of the station soon reasserted its typical forms of expression, which are widespread in all police forces and occupational cultures that are predominantly masculine and working class. 
 The tendency of sergeants to follow the field-worker around and to ask what she had learnt also soon dissipated as the routine demands of their job became a more pressing priority. 
 Some constables initially played up to the fact that their remarks would be appearing in print, hoping to identify themselves by saying something outrageous which was then suffixed by &bquo;How about that for a quote for the book?&equo; 
 The sheer length of time spent in the field ensured that this, too, lost its novelty. 
 But there must have been other reactive effects which were more subtly marked than this and were concealed from the fieldworker. 
 Occasionally it was suspected that the behaviour of respondents was being affected by the presence of the field-worker, to what extent it is impossible to estimate, but this is the disadvantage of all overt research techniques and is not unique to ethnography. 
 On the whole, therefore, researching the RUC has been more difficult than has been the case in most other studies in the sociology of policing (for an exception see Punch 1989), precisely because of the sensitivity of the topic in its social context. 
 However, one also suspects that other researchers have underplayed the difficulties of their field-work in order to avoid pejorative assessments of their results. 
 The sensitivity of our topic in Northern Ireland can only lead us to make its problems manifest to readers in order for them to be able better to assess the reliability of the data. 
 There is one other distinguishing feature of researching the RUC compared to other police studies. 
 Many studies describe a &bquo;retrenchment from the front&equo;, which occurred as police management sought to control or influence the research design and practice. 
 What retrenchment we experienced was from below, which illustrates that working daily with the field-worker was a source of greater sensitivity to ordinary policemen and women than was the idea of research to senior officers. 
 The result of this sensitivity for the majority of respondents was a friendly but uneasy and measured co-operation, although there were extremes at either pole. 
 It is worth mentioning the techniques by which a minority of  respondents sought to impose limits from below. 
 There were direct refusals to answer questions &bquo;for security reasons&equo;, occasional resorts to lying, and frequent use of coded conversations in which the meaning was concealed by maintaining a protective hold on the background knowledge to the conversation and the meaning of phrases. 
 Sometimes they would drive off in their vehicle without the fieldworker, only to be called back by the sergeant after she made a complaint. 
 On one occasion, they locked her in the car when they went to a call and wound up the window to prevent her overhearing. 
 Once, upon her getting out of the car, they manoeuvred the vehicle so as to trap the field-worker to prevent her accompanying them. 
 Dodges like this immediately make one suspicious about what they had to hide, and they tended to occur when they were wishing to do some &bquo;personal business&equo; while on duty, or simply to skive. 
 Such techniques were therefore popular amongst the work-shy, as other officers explained. 
 Below is an extract from the field notes, where the field-worker was talking with two plain-clothes men: 
 PC. 1. 
 You should have heard some of the stories that went round when you first came to Easton&hellip; 
 There was one that you were being paid by Jack Hermon to keep a eye on us all. 
 But then once they got to know you&hellip; 
 PC. 2. 
 Is there going to be a book? 
 I think it would be dead interesting. 
 Anyway I'd like to read it. 
 Like, what is it exactly you are interested in? 
 Everything I suppose. 
 RESEARCHER. 
 Yeh, everything. 
 It's on ordinary policing. 
 Like I was saying to one of the men in the section who hasn't been that co-operative, like, I'm only here for a year and you all know more than I will ever know about policing. 
 PC. 1. 
 Was it &lsqb;name&rsqb;? 
 RES. 
 I'm saying nothing. 
 PC. 1. 
 &lsqb;Name&rsqb; wouldn't talk to you, sure he wouldn't. 
 Aye, some boys will be like that. 
 Usually they're not the best policemen. 
 A good policeman will sit you down and tell it you his way. 
 He'll want you to know because he's nothing to hide. 
 These other boys, you'll usually find they're the skivers like &lsqb;name&rsqb;. 
 Yer not losing out on anything by him not talking to you. 
 &lsqb;Name&rsqb; is the type of fella that if there's something to be done that might cause him paperwork, he'll do anything to avoid it. 
 Those boys are the type of boys, all they want to do is put in their eight hours and go home. 
 They've no interest in promotion, they've no interest in the job really. 
 You're not missing out on boys like that not talking to ya. 
 (FN 16/11/87, p. 25)  
 These were the sort of respondents who nicknamed the fieldworker &bquo;Tell her Nothin&equo; and &bquo;Nosebag&equo;, and tried to assert informal checks on colleagues who were conversing with her by reminding them of the notepad and that she &bquo;writes everything down&equo;. 
 The ethnographer's conventional notepad can be obtrusive, yet when time in the field extends to a full eight-hour shift, it is impossible to dispense with it, for without notes one is left only with general impressions recorded at the end of the day or fragmentary notes recorded surreptitiously; yet to use a tape-recorder would have been more obtrusive. 
 We tried to allay these fears by taking notes in as unobtrusive a manner as possible. 
 This was done primarily by reducing the visibility of the pad and the physical activity of notetaking, occasionally forgoing it when the situation seemed appropriate, as in the canteen or recreation and television rooms, and by emphasizing that the notebooks were not secret. 
 This was reiterated from time to time by showing them pages from the field notes and extracts from the data. 
 But in a sense we were missing out by these sorts of policemen being unco-operative (there were no policewomen like this), for those who have things to hide, even if it is only laziness, are a part of every police force. 
 But the majority of policemen and women we encountered were not like this and did not engage in little acts of subterfuge to limit what the field-worker saw or heard because either they had nothing to hide or, more rarely, they were not concerned to conceal it. 
 Their sensitivity to the research did not stem from having something to hide, hence their greater co-operation. 
 But even for those who had little or nothing to hide, their sensitivity to the research led, in a minority of cases, to a reluctance to engage in conversation, the resort to silence being something which Westley noted in his research in the United States (1970, p. viii). 
 Situations of private one-to-one contact with the field-worker were avoided by some constables, retreating into the relative security of public encounters with their characteristic form of non-intimate discourse. 
 Westley explains how he made sure he stayed around long enough so that his respondents had to talk, because of the difficulty people have of remaining silent for long (1970, p. viii). 
 Our research was designed to ensure that the field-worker was also around a great deal and was stubborn in exploiting the naturally occurring situations of privacy, where natural conversation is inevitable because it is interactionally difficult to abstain from it, such as in the back of vehicles,  in the sanger while on guard duty, relaxing in many of the recreational rooms, or off duty. 
 Of course some policemen and women, at the other extreme, welcomed the research as an opportunity to talk about issues which are so often taken for granted among colleagues and family that they are not topics of conversation. 
 Over lunch in the canteen, very early on in the field-work, the conversation turned to stress and the danger members of the RUC face. 
 One constable said, &bquo;Why didn't you get a bit of discussion going like this before? 
 I think it's great. 
 I find all this dead interesting. 
 This is the sort of stuff you should be asking us&equo; (FN 16/3/87, p. 18). 
 Many also saw it as a means of informing the authorities of their grievances. 
 For example, on the comment form which we gave to all respondents at the end of the field-work, one policewoman wrote, &bquo;The idea of research being carried out within the RUC, or indeed any police force, is a good one. 
 It brings points to the notice of the authorities that can well be overlooked in the dayto-day running of the force; points that can, when corrected, benefit a great many people.&equo; 
 There is, however, a more fundamental reason why silence could not be used extensively as a ploy to impose limitations on the research from below. 
 The study of policing in Northern Ireland is benefited by the fact that conversation and social context are so interrelated. 
 Sensitive and controversial topics often occur naturally in the conversation, or can be introduced in what appears a casual manner, because the social context encourages this. 
 Events seen on the television the might before, or read about in the day's newspaper, or relayed as they happen to police stations throughout the province over the MSX machine, naturally facilitate talk on sensitive topics or cam be used as contextually related props to achieve the same end. 
 It should therefore be no surprise at all that we got policemen and women to talk. 
 EASTON AND ITS POLICE STATION 
 The familiar adage is that ethnographic research provides depth by sacrificing breadth but, as Finch (1986) argues, it is possible to build an element of generality into this type of research not by random sampling, which is usual in quantitative research, but by constructing individual projects in the mould of similar ones in different  settings so that comparisons can be made and a body of cumulative knowledge established. 
 Our project was designed deliberately to follow the pattern of ethnographic studies of routine policing, so as to add to this tradition the dimension provided by studying this kind of policing in a divided society. 
 In a strategy pioneered by the affluent-worker study in Luton, which one might call the optimal-case approach, a site was chosen for the research which was not representative, nor claimed to be, but was particularly germane to the topic of the investigation. 
 Easton was not randomly chosen for the location of this research, but purposely selected because it is an area of Belfast where routine policing is possible as a result of the virtual absence of political violence in the locale, whether Catholic or Protestant in origin (and, as later chapters will show, it is a mistake to see the RUC's relationship with Catholics only as problematic). 
 If we are to establish how and to what extent routine policing is affected by Northern Ireland's divisions, it would be useless to base our research where there is only militarized political policing (even though there are at least formal attempts to try to normalize policing in areas of high tension), for it is necessary to explore the extent to which policing in so-called &bquo;soft&equo; areas is contaminated by wider societal conflicts. 
 Given the nature of crime in Easton, the problems that Northern Ireland's divisions create for routine policing are as well studied there as anywhere. 
 Our choice was one which policemen and women from areas of high tension could not appreciate. 
 People from the stations we visited in such areas, or whom we encountered upon their being transferred to Easton, felt policing there was not typical and that we were obtaining an unrealistic view. 
 As one said, what Easton has, unlike many areas, is &bquo;ordinary civil policing&equo; (FN 16/11/87, p. 6), so that there is a continuity with policing in Easton before the current troubles began: &bquo;I was in Easton years ago when it was the old station, though basically policing at Easton hasn't changed from when I was here years ago. 
 It's still ordinary policing, though the station and the set-up within it has changed&equo; (FN 17/12/87, p. 1). 
 Thus, amongst policemen and women working in &bquo;hard&equo; areas of high tension, policing in Easton is abused as family disputes and barking dogs, a caricature which many respondents hold and is even reproduced by constables at Easton: &bquo;One minute you could be called out, someone's budgie has escaped and is flying around the living-room. 
 The next minute you could be called out to a sudden  death. 
 You'd never have to deal with things like that in Crossmaglen. 
 You know, they'd never get the type of calls we get&equo; (FN 1/3/87, p. 2). 
 This influences the expectations that the public in Easton have of the police, and of their role in the community &mdash; a point which one constable made by explaining that one resident in Easton, upon finding himself locked out of his home, called at the station asking for the duplicate set of keys to his house which he thought the police would routinely possess for the residents' benefit; phone calls from the public asking for air and train information also sometimes occur. 
 Therefore, the opinion ordinary law-abiding residents in Easton have of the police is good, as one elderly lady without prompting told the researcher: &bquo;Easton police always give a very good service. 
 Whenever I've needed them they always get here right away&equo; (FN 5/10/87, p. 22). 
 This is a picture of policing which some constables in hard-line areas dispute as typical of Northern Ireland, with one policeman m West Belfast denying that any routine policing occurs in Northern Ireland, arguing that no area could be considered &bquo;soft&equo; because policemen and women are at risk everywhere (FN 29/4/87, p. 6). 
 This begs a number of questions. 
 What form of policing is representative of the province? 
 What in Northern Ireland does routine policing consist of? 
 What are the effects of Northern Ireland's divisions upon it? 
 For, given that areas of relative peace and stability exist alongside those where tension is much higher, there is no reason to suppose that policing in West Belfast, for example, is any more representative of the divided society. 
 It is intrinsic to divided societies that both forms of policing occur simultaneously, and it is important to establish what effects one has on the other. 
 Easton is the fictitious name we have given to the area of Belfast in which our research was located. 
 We have taken every step to conceal its true identity, deleted names, places, and personal details, especially information which might identify the policemen and women with whom we worked, and even, following the example of others, employed security measures to protect the field notes (Holdaway 1983: 13). 
 Like Bulmer (1982), we believe that social researchers have a responsibility to the subjects of their research, but this is doubled in our case because of the additional obligation on us to protect their personal security in whatever small way, as researchers, we can. 
 Anonymity is not used to neutralize the moral responsibility respondents would otherwise have for their actions and opinions,  but is our attempt to keep faith with the trust we earned. 
 Few basic facts about Easton station can be recorded without breaching this trust, and the manpower of police stations in Northern Ireland is not disclosed for security reasons. 
 In August 1987, the complement of the regular RUC throughout Northern Ireland was 8,500, with an additional 2,500 full-time reservists and 1,500 parttim e members of the reserve police. 
 For the regular force alone, this is a ratio of just over five policemen and women per thousand of population, a proportion which has grown steadily since the troubles began in 1968, when it stood at just over two (see Brewer et al . 
 1988: 56). 
 Although pro-rata extrapolations from Easton's total population give a poor estimate of its police force because the RUC is not evenly dispersed throughout the province, Easton station is large. 
 Thus some police newly transferred from small rural stations find Easton lonely and anomic, although those with long service at Easton comment on its friendliness. 
 The social structure of the district of Easton is worth noting. 
 In terms of what Drew (1978) calls Belfast's religious geography, Easton is almost entirely Protestant. 
 Police administrative districts do not neatly coincide with local-government wards, but the 1981 
 Census showed that in the wards which closely (but not completely) correspond to the jurisdiction of Easton's police, there is a total population of just over 50,000, a mere 2.5 per cent of which is Catholic, compared with 22.6 per cent as a whole in the two district council areas over which Easton straddles. 
 Easton's district is more prosperous than the norm for these two council districts, with an overall unemployment rate in 1981 of 9.2 per cent, compared with 19.5 per cent for the two district council areas. 
 This is explained by the fact that the unemployment rate is lower among Protestants generally and that Easton's population, besides being Protestant, is also disproportionately middle class. 
 Using the Registrar-General's classification of social class, the distribution of the classes in Easton compared to its immediate locale is represented in Table 1.1, which demonstrates that the class structure in Easton is not typical of the general area. 
 As measures of relative prosperity, the number of households with three or more cars in Easton is more than double that for the two district council areas in which it is located, and the quality of the housing stock and amenities is higher, with the proportion of households in Easton which have use of only an outside flush toilet being half that of the general area.   
 However, these generalizations obscure the pockets of quite marked poverty which also exist in Easton. 
 In addition to the palatial and leafy suburbs, there are areas of inner-city terraced housing awaiting redevelopment and large outlying council estates. 
 One of the wards in Easton is ranked tenth highest in the number of households with use of only outside flush toilets out of the seventy wards which comprise the two district councils. 
 Three of the &ndash;e wards which make up Easton have a proportion exceeding 500/0 of households with no car; one of these wards is above the average for the general area at 53.5 per cent of households. 
 The average for Easton is 39.8 per cent. 
 The level of unemployment in one of Easton's wards in 1981 was 2.5 times higher than that in another, which, at nearly 17 per cent, approached the average for the two district councils as a whole. 
 This social cross-section gives Easton's police a variety of crime and law-and-order situations to confront, in conjunction with which there is the ever-present danger and threat from the IRA, whose activities are not restricted to Republican areas. 
 In the wake of the Anglo-Irish Agreement there is now also intimidation from Protestants. 
 In this respect, Easton provides an excellent opportunity to establish the nature of routine policing in Northern Ireland and how it is affected by societal divisions.  
 Routine Police Duties 
 INTRODUCTION 
 A dominant preoccupation in the sociology of policing is the description and analysis of the routine, day-to-day police work done by low-ranking policemen and women. 
 Within this there are three particular concerns: the practical reasoning employed by ordinary policemen and women to help them accomplish routine duties; how they interact with various sections of the public, from ethnic minorities to road users; and how they perceive various aspects of police work, including the area within which they function and its people, what comprises &bquo;real&equo; police work, and what constitutes &bquo;good&equo; or competent practice. 
 In pursuit of these themes most researchers discuss the occupational culture of the police, showing that on the whole ordinary policemen and women get their notions about routine police work from this collection of background beliefs, values, and attitudes. 
 Very few studies have challenged the generally accepted view that &bquo;canteen culture&equo; is influential in determining ordinary policemen and women's common-sense conceptions of their work (for an exception see Fielding 1988a, b). 
 The corollary to this is the claim that bureaucracy in police stations is chimerical. 
 The formal rules and regimen are not the bases for the ways in which ordinary policemen perform their tasks, for very few rankers follow even a proportion of the management's rules of conduct (for example see Bittner 1967; Cain 1973; Chatterton 1976, 1979; Eticson 1982; Holdaway 1980, 1983; Manning 1977, 1979; Punch 1979a; Rubinstein 1973; Wilson 1968). 
 Hence sociologists of the police (and of crime and deviance generally) were first among those researchers who led the revision of the concept of bureaucracy (beginning with Bittner 1965). 
 It is commonplace in the sociology of the police to emphasize how police stations are a &bquo;symbolic bureaucracy&equo;, to use Jacobs's telling phrase (1969), or that they  have, in Goffman's terminology, front and backstage regions where different sets of rules apply (see Holdaway 1980). 
 This work relies heavily on American ethnomethodological and interactionist discussions of bureaucracy constructed by people on the basis of their social interaction, which explains why much police research in sociology has taken this theoretical shift. 
 This chapter and the next will address some of the above topics in order to demonstrate the parallels between routine police work in the RUC and other police forces in non-divided societies. 
 These two chapters are therefore intentionally derivative and familiar in their themes to allow the arguments to build upon and add to the cumulative knowledge about routine police work. 
 However, this will be done with a very broad sweep to permit the focus in later chapters to concentrate on what is the essential and most interesting feature of routine policing in Northern Ireland: namely, how societal divisions affect and constrain it. 
 But inasmuch as these two chapters show that routine policing exists in the province, they are useful as a corrective to the folk model of policing in Northern Ireland, which assumes that all policing is related to the troubles; that police officers have been brutalized as a result of their baton guns, face masks, and riot shields; and that they know or prefer no other mode of police work. 
 It is this folk model, epitomized by the graffito &bquo;SS/RUC&equo;, seen as much in working-class Protestant districts as in Catholic ones, which makes it difficult for &bquo;ordinary crime&equo; to compete for the attention of criminologists in Ireland (as a recent publication on crime in Ireland complained; see Tomlinson et al . 
 1988a: 14). 
 Therefore, it is the very ordinariness of the RUC's policing in Easton which is surprising and provides the greatest disjuncture with public imagery rather than the fact that it contradicts, to some extent, the formal regimen of the police manual or the bureaucratic ethos of police management. 
 This tends to be the concern in Great Britain, as attested to by the public response to the Policy Studies Institute study of the Metropolitan Police (Policy Studies Institute 1983a, b; for a similar and earlier example, see Holdaway 1977).  
 FORMAL CONTROL AND THE LABOUR PROCESS IN EASTON STATION 
 Routine policing in Easton is the responsibility of the uniform branch, which is divided between organizational units known as sections and the neighbourhood and community relations teams, as well as the plain-clothes units like the CID and CDU (Crime Detection Unit). 
 Our attention was almost entirely focused on uniformed police, although some community relations work, such as juvenile liaison, is done out of uniform but was also within our brief. 
 Chapter 4 deals with community policing in its various forms, so that the arguments in this chapter and the next apply to routine policing by the uniformed sections. 
 Easton station operates four sections (what in other police forces is called a &bquo;relief&equo;), each working in turn one of three shifts, with the fourth week off. 
 There is a great deal of competitiveness between the sections, sometimes not always friendly, with each thinking itself the most efficient and &bquo;best&equo; at policing. 
 Sections comprise approximately twenty policemen and women, made up mostly of regular constables, but each has attached to it a number of full-time reservists. 
 The number of policewomen in each section varies, although there is always a minimum of one, which is low because women constitute less than 10 per cent of the regular force (Brewer et al . 
 1988: 56). 
 Absences from work due to leave, sickness, court attendance, police business elsewhere, or transfers can seriously deplete this number on occasions, leaving the section very understaffed, which is why managers are so sensitive about constables phoning in sick, although this sensitivity is not always communicated in a heavy-handed manner. 
 Below is an extract of conversation at the beginning of a shift. 
 SERGEANT. 
 Where's &lsqb;name&rsqb;? 
 PC. 
 Oh, he's got s desperate migraine. 
 SERGEANT. 
 Aye, the auld plumbing is desperate for bringing on migraines. 
 What happened, did he not get it finished over the weekend or samething? 
 (FN 2/11/87, p. 2) 
 The roars of laughter told that they knew the sergeant was right to suspect moonlighting; something which is quite common to the lower ranks of the RUC because many have a background as skilled tradespeople.  
 Sections have their own sergeant (sometimes two) and inspector, in addition to which there is a separate station duty sergeant, responsible for the running of the station rather than the work of the section. 
 Above this lies the usual hierarchy found in all police bureaucracies. 
 Formal control is therefore immediately effected by the sergeant and inspector, and their personality and leadership style can have a great influence on the morale (if not the work rate) of a section. 
 This is especially evident when there is more than one sergeant and there happens to be a clash of personality and leadership style between them, although senior managers within the station are sensitive to this sort of problem and switch sergeants about when it occurs. 
 They also change sergeants when a section is considered to need an improvement in discipline or work rate. 
 Hence, senior managers recognize the pivotal role played by lowranking officers. 
 Work duties are assigned by the sergeant at the beginning of the shift in what is known as &bquo;parade&equo; when all members meet together, occasionally in the presence of senior officers. 
 This is the opportunity for senior managers to endorse warnings for vigilance or diligence, which they do occasionally, and for sergeants to review both the incidents which occurred on the last shift and the matters which need special attention on the present one. 
 Although it is a means of asserting authority, coming as it does at the start of the shift, parade is very relaxed and, from the point of view of the ordinary constables, serves as a way of casually reorientating themselves to the demands of work. 
 In this manner it continues the adjustment process begun before parade in the canteen. 
 It is almost titualistic that parade is turned into a celebration of the communal-like bonds of the section. 
 This is done by, among other things, the sharing of stories, exchange of gossip, and a friendly and very sharp banter (at which policemen are very good), during which sergeants sometimes have to struggle to rise above the one-line wit and are often themselves forced to succumb (on the use of rituals at the beginning of work in American police departments see Niederhoffer 1967). 
 Along with the canteen, therefore, the parade room is a key location where, at the beginning of the day's work, individuals start to immerse themselves again in the occupational culture of the station and adjust to the labour process. 
 Being a large station, the many senior officers who come and go at Easton act as a constant and visible reminder to constables of the  structures of power and authority in the station, and a prominent item in the conversations of ordinary policemen and women is complaints against &bquo;the authorities&equo;, which is an indexical category flexible enough to include everyone above their own level. 
 (The substance of these complaints will be dealt with elsewhere.) 
 There are other reminders of where formal control lies. 
 Constables know that all radio messages are taped and that the time they take to arrive at calls is recorded, which is often unnecessary, given the competition to beat other stations and colleagues by getting there first, although stories were told to us of instances where people were transferred for failing to respond to a call. 
 Punishment transfers, known as &bquo;dirty moves&equo; and &bquo;big transfers&equo;, further remind rankers of what happens when formal rules are seriously breached, as does the frequent requirement to sign registers and books concerning equipment and duties. 
 A further reminder is the complaints procedure which members of the public can initiate against police officers. 
 Some members of the public bring these so routinely that their complaints are not taken seriously by rankers, although complaints from others are (see Weitzer 1986). 
 But the authorities take all complaints seriously, which leads some constables to fear &bquo;the flippin' solicitor's letter&equo; (FN 5/10/87, p. 16), although one middleranking officer once expressed considerable sympathy for the post &mdash; tion some police constables find themselves in as a result of being hedged (as they are in Northern Ireland's more unusual position as a divided society) between authorities who are exceedingly sensitive to complaints against the police and a public which has sections eager to complain, even in Protestant-dominated Easton. 
 Indicating with a thumb and forefinger positioned closely together, he said: 
 The police officer has about that much space to operate in. 
 Have you ever seen a prisoner being beaten up at Easton? 
 Well, I can assure you that if you were to go and look it up, you'd find complaints against policemen in Easton. 
 It's almost a occupational hazed. 
 You arrest somebody, maybe a drunk, the next day he's feeling a little disgruntled and almost inevitably he'll make a complaint&hellip; 
 The thing is, young officers coming into the force, doing what they've been taught is their job, the next thing they know they've got people making complaints against them. 
 They've got all this on top of them as well as, say, they may be in a dangerous area. 
 As well as that, security. 
 I'm really surprised more don't creak under the pressure. 
 (FN 6/11/87, p. 15) 
 Formal control, however, is only one aspect of the labour process in any work organization. 
 Constables have a definite view about the style of authority they prefer in officers, which is summed up well by the remark that they need to be &bquo;one of the boys&equo;: that is, they should not stand on ceremony and overtly assert their authority. 
 Some sergeants conform to this, others do not, but the general resistance from below to the excesses of authority, coupled with a relative autonomy in the work place, affords the men and women in a section the latitude, if they so wish, to &bquo;ease&equo;, using Cain's now familiar term (1973), or, to use their word, &bquo;bluff&equo;. 
 A whole system of informal work practices is able to exist alongside those of the police management and they form a vital part of the labour process in the station. 
 On the whole, these informal practices are conducive to the management's organizational goals rather than a departure from them. 
 Moreover, control upon those members of the section who are not pulling their weight is often asserted from below, as it was in the mocking manner in which the policeman quoted above reported his colleague's absence from work due to migraine. 
 The comradeship so typical of the occupational culture of the police does not extend to &bquo;covering the ass&equo; (a phrase made eloquent in the sociology of policing) of someone who lets the whole side down. 
 However, the characteristics of police occupational culture in Easton and the question of informal rules and control will be addressed in later chapters, to allow the focus here to narrow towards an outline of the nature of routine policing and its accomplishment. 
 REGULAR VERSUS RESERVE POLICE DUTIES 
 In Easton routine policing is performed only by regular constables, but the ambiguous position of reserve police within the RUC warrants a brief mention of this section of the force, if only because there are no parallels between reserve police in the RUC and those in police forces in Great Britain and the United States. 
 In 1987, the size of the RUC reserve was 4,000, just under two-thirds of which were full-time members. 
 The overwhelming majority were men (Brewer et al . 
 1988: 57). 
 The reserve force was established in 1970 to take over the policing functions of the disbanded B Specials and was designed as back-up for the regular force, freeing regulars from lowlevel security work in order to concentrate on both routine policing  and high-profile riot policing. 
 Reserve police in the RUC wear the same uniform, for all that an outsider can distinguish, and as a consequence face the same security risks, but most are marginalized by the restricted range of duties they perform and the short-term status of their contract. 
 Part-time male reservists do only sanger (guard) duty, either at the station or at other locations; female reservists are restricted in the main to the guard room inside the station, with only full-time reserve policemen carrying the responsibility for a broader range of tasks, although few are involved in the paperwork for a case file. 
 But the tasks of reserve police vary across sections and stations, and in some rural areas there is no difference in their responsibilities compared to regular policemen, knowledge of which makes part-time reserve police in Easton very sensitive to their lowly position within the police bureaucracy. 
 Full-time reserve police on the whole are people who are disqualified from entering the regular force as a result of age, height, or physical health. 
 A few are &bquo;trying out&equo; policing by joining the reserves first, although the common view amongst the reserve police is that it is harder for them to transfer to the regulars than it is for someone without experience to sign up straight away because of the greater number of reasons the police authorities are thereby given for turning them down. 
 This fact tends to make full-time reserve police very cautious in their behaviour, for they feel they have less opportunity to ease, which further means that their opinion of some regulars is not good. 
 But part-time reserve police are the most bitter. 
 Stories relating the inexperience and ineptitude of young regular recruits or their laziness are particularly common amongst the parttime reserve police. 
 This is because part-time members of the force have only slight contact with regular policemen and women, and experience greater status incongruity as a result of the contrast between the responsibility held in their day-time employment and the more restricted range of their police duties. 
 Dingwall, in another context, calls these stories &bquo;atrocity stories&equo; (1977), and Richman shows how they feature prominently in the discourse of traffic wardens, in an attempt to socialize new recruits into what they can expect, as well as being a means of stressing the moral worth of traffic wardens: a concern which was high on the priorities of such a stigmatized occupational group (Richman 1983: 115). 
 They perform a similar role with respect to the RUC's reserve police. 
 These stories usually counterpoise the young, inexperienced, or work-shy regular  recruit with the wise and diligent old-timer on the reserves, although part-time reserve police quickly come to know the bounds within which they too can &bquo;slack off&equo; or ease, which are much narrower. 
 These stories also serve to give to the part-time reserve police a self-respect which they feel is otherwise lacking from an organization which undervalues and marginalizes them. 
 They see themselves as occupying a position at the bottom of an organization which places a heavy emphasis on hierarchy, making their location all the worse. 
 As one part-time policeman said, &bquo;The regulars are all right, but there's definitely a difference between them and us. 
 You feel almost like new boys in a school. 
 In fact, the whole hierarchy of the police is very much like a school, and a public school at that, and the reserve men are at the bottom of the line&equo; (FN 7/7/87, p. 25). 
 Being at the bottom, they feel their contribution often goes unrecognized, at least by the authorities. 
 The following is part of a conversation between two part-time policemen: 
 PC. 1. 
 We get treated like shit in this job. 
 PC.2. 
 But we get killed just the same by the Provies. 
 That's one thing, at least the Provies give us credit for doing this job. 
 PC. 1. 
 Aye, they don't discriminate. 
 PC.2. 
 They need us to back up the regular force&hellip; but some of the police who are in a supervisory role are anti reserve police. 
 PC. 1. 
 That's true. 
 There used to be a woman sergeant in &lsqb;place&rsqb; who used to refer to the reserve men as &bquo;dick-head reserve men&equo;, &bquo;fucking idiots&equo;, till one day this reserve man says to her, &bquo;See that man over there, before he came to this job he was a aircraft technician, &lsqb;name&rsqb; used to be a chief mechanic. 
 &lsqb;Name&rsqb; there used to be a architect and &lsqb;name&rsqb; has a degree in law.&equo; 
 And he says to her, &bquo;What did you do before you joined the police?&equo; and she ran off. 
 She used to be a check-out girl in &lsqb;name of supermarket&rsqb;. 
 PC. 2. 
 You know who are the worst, the younger men with no experience. 
 PC. 1. 
 The young regulars come to a station and they think they can tell a reserve man what to do. 
 (FN 23/11/87, pp. 23&ndash;4) 
 Then followed a story about the ineptitude of a young policeman in handling a domestic dispute, who was only rescued from his incompetence by a wise reserve man. 
 The field-worker was a captive  audience for tales like these, which are told and retold by part-time reserve police in an attempt to cope with their marginality. 
 A feature of such stories is their selectivity, for they omit to mention the number of part-time reserve police who are unemployed or in low-status employment, or who sign up for mercenary reasons or for the power and respect that they believe accompanies the uniform. 
 But even those who said they joined in order to serve the community (and there are many) feel a disappointment upon entering the force as a result of the limited opportunities for this allowed by their duties. 
 As one complained, &bquo;I'm not a policeman, I'm a gatekeeper&equo; (FN 19/9/87, p. 4): sanger duty is not considered &bquo;real&equo; police work. 
 It is boring, often done in locations where it is difficult to avoid &bquo;bosses&equo;, it affords only a limited range of &bquo;bluffs&equo; or easing techniques, and is looked down upon by regular policemen and women, a view unintentionally reinforced by those sergeants who apologize to regulars when asking them at parade to do sanger duty. 
 Added to this is the perpetual insecurity reserve police suffer as a result of the management's control over the renewal of their contract: and sergeants are not averse to using this as a threat in parades. 
 Formal control within the police bureaucracy is therefore experienced by the RUC reserve as a tangible and omnipresent reality to a far greater extent than by regular police, which leads reserve police to have critical views of police management and some resentment towards the regulars, whom they feel &bquo;get away with things&equo;. 
 The camaraderie so emphasized in discussions of police occupational culture is fractured in the RUC's case by some important divisions, and the regular/reserve police distinction is an example. 
 This is true even in West Belfast, where, as we shall see, companionship amongst work colleagues is one response to the stress of policing, for part-time reserve police still &bquo;moan&equo;, as one regular described it, about the management and the regular police in the manner of Easton's reserve force. 
 Reserve police in this part of Belfast correctly point out that uncertainty over their contract is only one form of insecurity, and simply adds to the pressure of working in West Belfast (FN 9/10/87, p. 25). 
 And generally it is the case that the personal security of the part-time reserve police is most at risk of all the members of the RUC, because of the difficulties of maintaining three identities (police officer, member of family and neighbourhood network, and employee), with their associated and sometimes conflicting modes of discourse and thinking.  
 ROUTINE POLICING IN EASTON 
 Contrary to what folk models of the RUC might lead one to expect, most policemen and women at Easton have not even drawn their gun, let alone fired it. 
 Those that have did so while stationed elsewhere, for the district of Easton has predominantly &bquo;ordinary crime&equo;. 
 However, &bquo;crime fighting&equo; is not the sole task of the section police in Easton, for the calls for assistance to which they respond vary considerably in nature. 
 Before demonstrating this variety, it is necessary to outline some minor technical details of relevance. 
 The calls come via three sources: personal requests made by members of the public at the station's enquiry desk; telephone calls made directly to the station; and messages relayed from BRC, the central communications network. 
 The last is by far the most frequent type of request for assistance. 
 The first type tend to be over more mundane matters, with the third being the more serious. 
 In answering these calls, the RUC's section police are modelled on their British counterparts, where the emphasis is placed on rapid response to logged calls. 
 This requires a sophisticated communications network, and efficient and fast vehicles. 
 Easton's section police tour the district in their vehicles awaiting such calls, although this meander does have another purpose in that &bquo;You just never know what you could come across: maybe someone in a car that might containammunition, perhaps a stolen car, or perhaps your wife in a car with a best mate&equo; (FN 7/3/87, p. 3). 
 Accordingly special attention at might-time is given to alley-ways, entrances, and shops. 
 The mileage accumulated in a shift cam therefore be surprisingly high: a vehicle in which the field-worker was present covered 84.7 miles in one shift, which is about the average. 
 As a means of formal control, station management record the mileage per shift of each vehicle. 
 However, the sophisticated technology required for rapidresponse policing can sometimes be found wanting in Easton. 
 BRC frequently relay wrong information (primarily because they receive wrong information), and wider societal divisions ensure that the main mode of transport in Easton, as elsewhere, is reinforced Land Rovers in order to afford occupants some protection from attack, although policemen and women see them as having their own vulnerabilities. 
 Land Rovers are cumbersome and difficult to drive, noisy, slow, sometimes mechanically unsound, and spartan. 
 When driving with the rear doors open, as is necessary on warm days to  provide ventilation, exhaust fumes escape into the vehicle, making the journey for those in the back even more uncomfortable; and it has been known for policemen in the back to fall out of the vehicle. 
 Because of the nature of crime in Easton, most Land Rovers on routine calls only contain the driver and observer, both seated in the front, making some sort of conversation between them possible. 
 There is no official policy of deliberately choosing partners for their compatibility, whether in terms of personality, age, experience, or religion, and long-standing partnerships do not develop informally because of the frequent transfers of staff to other duties or to new stations altogether. 
 The calls the section police receive constitute the bulk of their routine duties, although they also undertake the administrative tasks that might follow from them, such as preparing case files and attending court and post-mortems. 
 The calls can be classified under a number of headings, illustrating the range of work which routine policing comprises in Easton (for a different classification see Sykes and Brent 1983: 42). 
 The first type is public-service calls, which includes requests for information, such as airport flight times and advice over legal matters, and community service tasks, such as signing passports, pushing (and sometimes towing) broken-down cars, giving lifts to young children and youths late at night, and making a point of driving around areas of Easton to reassure, by their presence, worried Old Age Pensioners or other members of the public. 
 As the policemen and women themselves note, these tasks are really forms of public relations (FN 20/6/87, p. 13). 
 Under this category there are also requests for assistance which amount to acts of community welfare, such as calls to lift aged and disabled people on to and off the toilet as well as into bed, and calls from very distressed pensioners and young children concerning lost pets (on the police as a social service see Punch 1979b; Punch and Naylor 1973). 
 Nothing much can be done about missing pets, but the impression of diligence and earnestness they leave with the bereft alone is a comfort. 
 In the occupational culture of Easton station most of these incidents are rendered afterwards into humorous stories, retold to new recruits and outsiders to demonstrate the &bquo;funny side&equo; of policing; and the familiar RUC term &bquo;all is regular&equo;, used to signify that a call has been attended to, has obvious humorous connotations for one of the community welfare tasks described here. 
 Another type is problem-solving calls, such as helping owners  with injured dogs (provoking enough interest for subsequent enquiries to be made about the dog's progress); giving impromptu lessons on road safety to young children who have narrowly avoided accidents; and dealing with arguments between neighbours (usually over noise) and family disputes. 
 Often the section police mop up the after-effects of problems, such as attending calls to fires, suicides, natural deaths, domestic disputes, and road traffic accidents. 
 The police on the British mainland do not attend many of these incidents unless a crime has been committed, but the RUC do so in order, as one said in relation to domestic disputes, to prevent crime. 
 With experience of service in the Metropolitan Police, the policeman remarked, 
 I think the public get a really good deal over here. 
 Like, in England we'd never have gone to a domestic dispute unless a crime had been committed. 
 The idea here is that you go to a domestic dispute to prevent a crime from being committed&hellip; 
 Also in England the police wouldn't go to a fire, but we go in the hope that perhaps we could save life. 
 (FN 3/3/87, pp. 8&ndash;9) 
 Southgate (1980: 33) has shown how British police have diffiulties in dealing with domestic disputes, but if anything the situation in Northern Ireland is easier for the police because they have a clearer knowledge of their role: to be on hand to prevent serious crime. 
 As another explained, &bquo;To most people a family row is Mummy and Daddy having a few words&equo;, but when police are called to a domestic dispute in some areas of Belfast, 
 It's most likely it will involve the TV being thrown out of the window and possibly followed by the wife. 
 By the time we arrive the house is usually wreaked, the kids are in a terrible state, and the wife's been beaten up, and the father's lying there stoned, probably taking half-a-dozen peelers to get him out of the house. 
 Actually family rows are quite good sometimes. 
 Police work involves so much bloody paperwork these days and a lot of boring stuff that a family row can quite spice up a night. 
 (FN 4/12/86, pp. 2&ndash;3) 
 In contrast, the effect of dealing with domestic disputes can be traumatic on some policemen as they momentarily place their own children and family in the situation of emotional horror they encounter. 
 However, it is generally the case that violence against women provokes no strong emotion in policemen. 
 Faragher (1985) found that police in Great Britain downgraded the seriousness of violence  against women in the home, for although formal regulations state that it is to be treated as an arrestable offence, policemen often redefined the incident as lying outside law enforcement (emphasized by Policy Studies Institute 1983b: 64). 
 In the case of the RUC, domestic disputes are routinely attended for reasons other than law enforcement. 
 This is true irrespective of the level of violence, although the masculine occupational culture of the force contains many of the same sanitizing euphemisms for violence against women (&bquo;giving the wife a diggin'&equo;). 
 In the one instance of domestic violence we encountered during field-work, the officers arrested the man against the protestations of the wife, as is often the case (see Fielding et al . 
 1988), despite Faragher's argument, although primarily in our case because the man redirected his attack towards the police. 
 There are also &bquo;big crime&equo; calls, which refer to the &bquo;real&equo; job of crime-fighting, which the section police enjoy most. 
 During the period of field-work the sorts of crime that occurred in Easton under this heading included murder and major robbery, possession of drugs, breaking and entering, car chases for stolen vehicles, and the occasional sex-related crime. 
 &bquo;Little crime&equo; calls, what the Metropolitan Police call &bquo;beat crime&equo; (Policy Studies Institute 1983b: 35), include a host of infringements and public nuisances, many of which do not come within what the section police define as &bquo;real, police work, although some none the less have an intrinsic appeal to ordinary policemen and women. 
 The range of &bquo;little crime&equo; calls is tremendous, and covers such things as sheep-worrying, prostitution, moving on loitering youths and courting couples (the latter being another popular subject for the humorous stories which circulate in the canteen culture of Easton's police), drunken fights, and incidents involving supporters of animal rights. 
 The typical shift involves most of these types of call, although &bquo;big crime&equo; calls occur more rarely. 
 It is possible to illustrate this by selecting at random two occasions when the field-worker accompanied policemen in their vehicles and cataloguing the calls they attended. 
 During a shift when the men considered that very little was happening, they responded to calls concerning a house fire and an attempted break-in, calls to check on the whereabouts of a pensioner who had not been seen by a neighbour for a few days, a request to pick up and transport a prisoner, and a call to move on some youths. 
 On a much busier occasion the calls before break were to attend the home of a widowed pensioner who thought she had  heard an intruder, two road accidents, a near hit-and-run accident, and to move on youths. 
 The normality of these tasks parallels the mundaneness of routine policing elsewhere. 
 This parallel is further reinforced by the similarity in the way time structures the RUC's routine policing compared to other forces in non-divided societies. 
 The calls Easton's section police receive vary with the time of day and the day of the week. 
 Like elsewhere, the busier times are Friday and Saturday, when many of the calls are drink-related, as an officer at BRC explained: 
 You should come here on a Friday or Saturday night. 
 From about 12 o'clock to three or four in the morning it's absolute madness in here. 
 You see, &lsqb;it's&rsqb; once people get drink in them. 
 You know, it's my opinion that in some areas of Belfast, if you haven't gone out, got drunk, had a chinkers, thrown up, and beaten the wife up, you haven't enjoyed yourself. 
 Like, we get literally hundreds of calls on Friday and Saturday nights and we're sending vehicles out to the same thing every time. 
 (FN 3/3/87, p. 8) 
 However, Monday morning is also busy because of the number of premises that are found broken into after the weekend. 
 The slack periods are night shifts during the mid-week, and the boredom compounds the general dislike of night duty, the only redeeming feature of which is that formal control in the station is relaxed because of the absence of senior managers. 
 While night duty therefore affords a greater opportunity to ease, as a later chapter will emphasize, for most ordinary policemen and women this is little compensation for the boredom, for there are fewer opportunities for the diligent to &bquo;make work&equo;, the reverse process to easing. 
 Hence a &bquo;good&equo; might duty for most members of the RUC is a busy one: &bquo;It was a brilliant night, you know, one of those nights you're all go. 
 Next thing you look at your watch and it's 4 o'clock. 
 You could do with more nights like that&equo; (FN 30/8/87, p. 1). 
 Hence the attraction, if one has to do night duty, of weekend work. 
 But might duty also disrupts family life, appetite, and sleeping patterns, and policewomen particularly complain of its effect on their roles as mother and housewife, although some policemen also talk sadly of how they miss seeing their children when on nights. 
 For some policemen and women, their family is very important indeed, and, as a later chapter on stress demonstrates, the family can function as a tension release mechanism and an escape from police work, so that ordinary policemen and women tend to protect this preserve from infringement by  outsiders, whether social researchers, senior police managers, the IRA, or the public. 
 ROUTINE POLICING AND GENDER DIVISIONS 
 One other parallel between routine policing in Easton and police forces in non-divided societies is the common way in which police work is structured by gender as well as by time. 
 Southgate (1980) and Jones (1987) have shown how policewomen in Great Britain are principally involved with juvenile and female offenders, and the Policy Studies Institute found widespread discrimination against policewomen in the Metropolitan force (1983a: 19, 29, 163&ndash;8). 
 Women were first recruited into the RUC in 1944, and were restricted to Belfast and Londonderry, where they dealt exclusively with offences against children and women. 
 As they broadened their location in the province, their duties were similarly extended to cover traffic control at pedestrian crossings and shoplifting. 
 Today senior managers in the RUC have a formal commitment to equal opportunities for women in pay and promotion and in many facets of their duties. 
 With respect to the latter, for example, women are no longer excluded from night duty and they perform a wider range of section duties than before. 
 However, ordinary policewomen tend to feel that there are constraints upon equal opportunities within the force. 
 Some of these are official, in that senior managers do not allow policewomen to carry arms, from which follows some restrictions on where policewomen cam be stationed, and on their involvement in high-profile political policing, such as at riots. 
 Most of the constraints, however, are informal. 
 With relatively so few policewomen, the occupational culture of the force is heavily masculine, and the wider cultural values that exist in Northern Ireland generally make men more conservative in their attitudes towards gender and sex roles. 
 This not only affects how the male public react to policewomen in the province, it also influences how male colleagues treat policewomen in the work environment and the sorts of duties they are assigned in practice; and the dearth of senior female officers makes it easy for male colleagues to impose such limits on the role of policewomen. 
 The focus here will be on the way gender structures routine police duties, with more general issues concerning women in the RUC being developed elsewhere.  
 The view is widespread among the senior officers we talked to, and among ordinary policemen, that policewomen, as women, have instincts and capabilities which make them better suited to specific types of police work. 
 One senior officer described policewomen as having an &bquo;instinct for tidiness&equo; which made them good administrators (FN 30/11/87, p. 33); frequently they were described as being suited to dealing with child and female offences because of their more compassionate natures compared to male colleagues. 
 The ethos of the force therefore lends itself to gender differences in police work, and so popular are beliefs about the different capabilities of policemen and women, that some policemen shy away from handling these sorts of cases on the view that they are less able than women colleagues, and many policewomen adopt these notions as self-typifications. 
 Hence some policewomen deliberately seek out desk jobs &mdash; secretaries with uniforms, as someone described them &mdash; or jobs as drivers, in juvenile liaison, or in units which deal with sex crimes, because they see themselves as better suited to this type of work. 
 The few females there are in senior management seem to endorse this. 
 A senior female officer explained to an assembly of policewomen who were being trained in how to operate a casualty bureau that they were better suited to operating the telephones because of their &bquo;good manners and compassionate nature&equo; (FN 29/5/87, p. 2). 
 In talking to ordinary policewomen, we found many themselves adopt notions of gender differences in order to explain the marginalization of their duties, although others prefer this kind of work simply because it makes it easier to manage their difficult and conflicting roles as policewoman, wife, and mother. 
 That is, transfers are fewer for those in administrative posts and in specialist sex abuse units, and the hours of work are less disruptive to home life. 
 Yet others rebel against this marginalization and demand both the right to perform the full range of police work (from which follows the wish to carry guns) and that men should become more involved in dealing with child and female offences. 
 However, there are signs of change at some levels, because men are now being accepted on to the CARE course, which provides specialist training in how to deal with victims of sex crimes, although this might simply reflect a recognition that an increasing number of victims are young boys. 
 A policewoman with long experience in dealing with sexual abuse did express the opinion that policemen can sometimes be more effective than women in encouraging very young  male victims to talk about their experiences: and this policewoman was in favour of male colleagues joining her at the RUC's specialist sexual abuse unit. 
 But whatever change there is in the higher echelons of the RUC's bureaucracy (and some policewomen say there is little), sexist attitudes are widespread amongst ordinary policemen, and, in the day-to-day police work of a station, policewomen's routine duties continue to be structured by gender. 
 In Easton, there are only a few policewomen attached to each section. 
 Mostly they do administrative work inside the station, drive for the section inspector, or are seconded to administrative work elsewhere in the station. 
 However, on occasions they do patrol work in vehicles (on policewomen on patrol work in the United States see Bloch and Anderson 1974; Ehrlich 1980; Sichel 1978). 
 With regard to this duty, there were no instances in the observational data where policewomen were deliberately sent to deal with injuries to children, for example, or injuries to people in road traffic accidents, functions which senior managers think them very suited to. 
 During field-work there was only one incident related to sexual abuse, and this was dealt with by policemen, and while they showed something of a blas&eacute; attitude towards it in feeling that the victim was &bquo;hardly touched&equo; and the offender &bquo;didn't do anything anyway&equo; (FN 2/11/87, pp. 5&ndash;6), they pursued the case thoroughly. 
 However, it was noticeable how policewomen on patrol would be sent by male colleagues to move on the younger children, while the men, being protective of policewomen, would deal with the older youths. 
 Policewomen on section duty are usually asked to convey emotionally disturbing news to relatives and notification of death. 
 They also deal with female prisoners in the station cells and with young offenders. 
 It was also apparent from the observational data that Easton's section police are occasionally presented with difficult encounters between public and police because of the gender differences in police work. 
 Policewomen sometimes had to be called from other duties in order to deal with an incident which male colleagues felt incapable of handling. 
 But more fundamentally, the typical deployment of policewomen affects public expectations of the police. 
 In Northern Ireland, where wider cultural values about gender and sex roles are reinforced by common practice, policewomen can be humiliated and face hostility and resentment from some male members of the public who expect to deal with policemen, and normally do. 
 On the other hand, female members of the public who are involved in incidents  other than those for which policewomen are normally assigned can find the preponderance of policemen disturbing and problematic. 
 For example, when out on a call one policewoman at Easton was asked by a male member of the public where the constables were. 
 Diplomatically, she pointed to where her male colleagues were standing. 
 But more frequently it arose that, in the absence of a policewoman, the female field-worker was relied upon for comfort by female members of the public, engaging her in eye contact to find what they expected would be a special &bquo;feminine&equo; understanding and reassurance. 
 The opinions policemen express about sex crimes are worth noting, because they reinforce the structure which gender gives to routine policing. 
 Generally, the policemen encountered in fieldwork disliked dealing with sex offences against children. 
 The compassion and sympathy which the victims of these offences naturally cause in all policemen can sometimes be complicated by the anger and emotional hatred felt toward the perpetrator, and the tough type of policeman may find it difficult to distance the one reaction from the other. 
 Some policemen with children of their own expressed difficulties in remaining detached. 
 Most find the easiest solution to the problem is to avoid it wherever possible. 
 Policemen also disliked dealing with rape, although obviously for different reasons. 
 One policewoman said that, while the men disappear when a rape victim is brought in, they all want &bquo;to gawp at the girl when she's being examined and read her statement&equo; (FN 17/2/87, p. 19). 
 Rape does not provoke such strong emotions in policemen, and their resistance to dealing with it is expressed more in terms of the greater competence policewomen are supposed to have. 
 However, there might well be other reasons for this. 
 Compared to sex offences on children, which cause universal shock and horror to policemen, in the masculine occupational culture of the station women are sex objects and, in other circumstances, would be considered &bquo;fair game&equo;. 
 Attitudes towards rape thus get confused with ideas about the sexual desirability of women, which can lead some policemen to see the victim as partly responsible. 
 For example, in the course of the only natural conversation that occurred on the topic of rape, the following account was given of how rape is evaluated: 
 SERGEANT. 
 Like, most of the rapes we get at Easton, they're not what I'd call rape at all. 
 You see, some girl's been out for a drink, or to a disco, met a fella, the fella invites her back, she goes, and things go a bit further than  she intended. 
 She turns around, comes to us, and utters the magic words &bquo;I've been raped&equo;. 
 And once she utters those words we've to deal with it like rape, the whole procedure, medical examination, and questioning. 
 And we've to ask some very personal questions&hellip; 
 Most of the time I find it's regret on the part of the victim. 
 Regret because maybe her husband will find out and want to know why she was going with another man in the first place. 
 I've yet to see a case of what we would define as really rape. 
 My ides of real rape is, say, a woman walking home at night and dragged into an entry and forcefully raped. 
 Most if not all the cases we get in Easton, I'd honest to God say the victim was asking for it.PC. 
 Aye, God, aye. 
 SERGEANT. 
 Like, sometimes it might be a prostitute, she never got paid for her services and she tries to claim she's been raped. 
 (FN 16/3/87, pp. 14) 
 Therefore, one further reason why policemen dislike dealing with rape might well be that they feel uneasy about having to ask the very personal questions which are necessary in order for the victim to be taken seriously, and on the occasion quoted above the sergeant went on to say that as a result of asking for these very personal details policemen &bquo;have had a very bad rap over dealing with rape cases&equo; (FN 16/3/87, p. 14). 
 While the men are reluctant to confront the emotions raised in dealing with sex crimes, policewomen have to, and it can be stressful. 
 Most serious cases of sex abuse are passed on to a unit which is designed for this purpose and has specially trained staff. 
 It is worth briefly discussing the work of this important unit. 
 That it was established reflects both an enlightened commitment on the part of senior management and a recognition that the problem is pervasive in Northern Ireland. 
 Although the unit has a male inspector, it is policewomen who deal with both victims and offenders. 
 In the station in which the unit is based (not Easton), the attitude of the policemen towards it is not positive, partly as a result of their ambivalent attitudes toward sex crimes, but mostly because it is policed by women, who therefore are said to spend their time in Boots and Marks and Spencer, making it an easy duty (FN 30/11/87, p. 18). 
 The unit is nicknamed &bquo;Charlie's Angels&equo; and, ironically, the men are not averse to drawing sexual graffiti on the office door. 
 Perhaps this reflects no more than the elevation of masculinity that permeates the canteen culture of the station, but the view that nothing busy happens in the unit and that it is an &bquo;easy turn&equo; is a sad  reflection on how the marginalization of policewomen's duties has divorced some policemen from the reality of sex crimes. 
 A time-budget diary completed by one of the policewomen for a week shows her time divided between welfare duties (including visits to the homes of victims and children in care, and attending children's parties), serving summonses on offenders and witnesses, paperwork and case files, liaison with other badies (such as the social services, concerning children who are missing or on the special-risk list, and the RUC's Community Relations Branch), and enquiries and interviews regarding offences. 
 Welfare work with victims is very important because there is no widespread communal or police campaign of prevention of sex offences, unlike other types of crime. 
 As one policewoman in the unit explained, &bquo;You're only getting at the problem left behind after the crime has been committed.&equo; 
 Another said, &bquo;The way I look at it, it's too late now; there's nothing can be done which can put the clock back; let's see what we can do to help the victim&equo; (FN 6/11/87, p. 35). 
 It is possible to cite one case to illustrate what they try to do for victims which further demonstrates the commitment of the unit to a welfare service role. 
 An elderly widow who was robbed, attacked, and raped by a gang of youths was moved to sheltered dwellings with the help of the police, visited by policewomen from the unit at least once a week, and taken regularly to visit the family of one of the policewomen, which adopted her as the children's granny. 
 But this degree of involvement takes its toll on policewomen in the unit. 
 Having to talk little children through the horrors which some adults inflict upon them is horrific and stressful, and emotional distancing is difficult to maintain when you are dealing only with sex abuse cases day after day. 
 I find I can't get away from the job. 
 I wake up at night and I think of maybe some kid we've been dealing with. 
 I think, with having children of my own, I think what it would be like, God forbid, if that happened to one of my kids. 
 I can't get away from it. 
 I think of &lsqb;name&rsqb; and how someone could do that to a wee woman like that. 
 Dealing with sex abuse all the time, it can he very depressing. 
 After a while you need a break from a unit like this. 
 Dealing with that sort of thing day in and day out does you no good&hellip; 
 I find kids the hardest to deal with. 
 Like, when they come in here I'll bring them down to the canteen and let them have Coke and sweets. 
 Then I bring them up here and let them draw. 
 You get them round that way, and eventually you ask them about themselves, and you get round to it. 
 We have  these anatomical dolls, but anyway, you should have seen what that &lsqb;name of 4-year-old girl&rsqb; went through. 
 Kids never recover; buggery, rape, oral sex, never leaves them. 
 (FN 6/11/87, pp. 23, 34&ndash;5) 
 Despite the disparaging views of some policemen, these women have a harder job than any of the &bquo;Action Men&equo; in the riot police units. 
 Of course, as we shall see, not all policemen see themselves as Rambo in police uniform, and the emotional effects of routine policing cam be as traumatic for some men. 
 Some policemen are both reflective and compassionate enough to realize this and admit to it. 
 For example, upon discussing domestic disputes with the fieldworker, one policeman said, 
 See, the thing about this job, outwardly you have to be unemotional and cynical, but inside it can really screw you up. 
 Like, I'll tell you, see, last Christmas we spent practically the whole night going to family rows. 
 The first row the husband stabbed the wife and she wouldn't make a complaint about it. 
 The kids were in the house and Daddy was up in the roof throwing bikes down. 
 Like, the kids were my kids' age, and, like, my kids still believe in Santa. 
 Those kids had nothing to look forward to. 
 Then the second row the father just went berserk. 
 Ended up we had to get her and the kids out of the house and get them somewhere to stay the night. 
 And, like, you go home ad see your own kids. 
 They say, &bquo;Daddy, look what I've got,&equo; and you try not to let what you've seen that day get to you. 
 I'll tell you, that really screwed me up that Christmas Day. 
 I couldn't sleep that night. 
 (FN 23/10/87, p. 22) 
 CONCLUSION 
 These quotations hint at a number of important dimensions to policing in Northern Ireland: that policemen and women in the RUC have common-sense conceptualizations of their role, with some defining it in terms of community service; that they have sets of standardized guide-lines, what Schutz (1967) calls &bquo;recipes&equo;, appropriate for the situations they handle; that they make, and try to maintain, a distinction between work and leisure; and that they employ various distancing strategies to cope with the demands of their job. 
 All these sorts of considerations are also aspects of routine policing. 
 However, used in this way, and in the sociology of policing generally, the term &bquo;routine&equo; tends to have a dual meaning. 
 It is widely used in this tradition to describe a quality of the tasks of which policing is normally comprised &mdash; that these tasks are mostly  mundane, ordinary, and day-to-day. 
 This chapter has followed this usage and stressed how the RUC also discharge the same ordinary, mundane tasks which characterize routine policing elsewhere, despite the folk images of the force. 
 But the term takes on a specific meaning in those studies in the sociology of policing which are inspired by ethnomethodology and phenomenology, where it describes a quality of the accomplishment of these tasks &mdash; that they are produced in a taken-for-granted, commonsensical, and habitual manner. 
 In the one sense, the term is used to refer to the ordinary aspects of police work, in the other, it is the process by which police work is done that is described as &bquo;routine&equo;. 
 It is this second meaning which will be addressed in the following chapter.  
 Doing Routine Police Work 
 INTRODUCTION 
 In ethnomethodological terms, routine policing is a practical achievement accomplished through the practices ordinary policemen and women use in &bquo;doing&equo; the tasks which comprise their job. 
 Hence, the quotation marks around the word &bquo;doing&equo; emphasize that it has a technical meaning in sociology, for lying behind the process is a body of common-sense and official police knowledge which informs the methods and practices according to which activities are done. 
 These practices range from the methods and resources used by the police in handling the various situations they encounter, to the interpretative processes or &bquo;cognitive map&equo; used in the practical reasoning which their work uniformly requires. 
 In order to establish how police work is accomplished, therefore, it is necessary to examine such things as the common-sense notions ordinary policemen and women have about their role, what they consider to be the essence of police work, what typifications and categorizations infuse the practical reasoning they employ to accomplish policing tasks, and what &bquo;recipes&equo; or guide-lines they adopt in undertaking the various aspects of their job. 
 The key to ethnomethodological and phenomenological interpretations of &bquo;doing&equo; routine ( qua  ordinary) police work, is that such interpretative processes and practices are employed in a routine ( qua  taken-for-granted) manner. 
 Routine policing as a set of tasks is therefore accomplished as a process of routine. 
 That is, these methods, typifications, and practices are employed by policemen and women as the main resource for accomplishing police work, and their relevance and applicability is taken for granted and never challenged. 
 The intention in this chapter is to document some of the resources Easton's policemen and women draw on in accomplishing their work, with a view to demonstrating the similarity in the way  they &bquo;do&equo; ordinary policing compared to what we know of policemen and women in societies without Northern Ireland's extreme divisions. 
 We will look first at some of the common-sense conceptions they have of police work and their role as policemen and women. 
 CONCEPTIONS OF POLICE WORK 
 It appears that policemen and women the world over have similar views about their job and agree on what aspects of police work they like and dislike. 
 Such consensus was originally explained as the product of a distinct personality which members of the police either possessed before coming to the force or quickly develop as a result of the job (for a survey of the literature on this see Adlam 1981). 
 However, most modern studies on the police emphasize the variety of people attracted to the force and now focus more on styles of policing (for example, see Black 1980; Broderick 1973; Brown 1981; Cain 1973; Muir 1977; Reiner 1978, 1985; Shearing 1981; Walsh 1977; Wilson 1968), although the idea that policing attracts people with distinct personality traits is still popular among some social psychologists (see Colman 1983; Colman and Gorman 1982; cf. Waddington 1982). 
 Manning's seminal work offers another explanation, claiming that &bquo;Anglo-American policing&equo; is a discrete entity, socially constructed on the basis of shared symbols, myths, and folklore (Manning 1977; on &bquo;Anglo-Saxon policing&equo; generally, see Bayley 1982; for criticism of the term see Brewer et al . 
 1988: 227&ndash;37). 
 More recently this consensus has been attributed to similar patterns of socialization into the canteen culture of the police (for example, Brogden et al . 
 1987; Reiner 1985; for an earlier and related argument see van Maanen 1973, 1975), and thus to the existence of a generalized police occupational culture. 
 But it is not only typical patterns of informal on-the-job training which are important, for there is also a congruence in aspects of formal police training (on both aspects of training see Fielding 1984, 1988a, b). 
 The ubiquity of these notions also reflects that the labour process itself influences policemen and women in how they view their work, and the sociology of policing has shown how routine policing consists of similar tasks wherever it occurs. 
 Hence van Maanen claims that policemen and women tend to have a common &bquo;working code&equo; (van Maanen  1978). 
 Whatever the reasons, Easton's police agree in what seem fairly general conceptualizations of police work. 
 The Metropolitan Police refer to work which they dislike as &bquo;rubbish work&equo; (Policy Studies Institute 1983b: 64), but in the RUC work which is disliked falls into three categories. 
 There is boring work, such as administering the enquiry desk, guard duty in sangers, and paperwork (on boring work in American police forces see Sykes and Brent 1983: 31&ndash;50). 
 Despite being an important opportunity for public relations, work on the enquiry desk is unpopular because &bquo;nothing happens&equo;, so probationers and inexperienced recruits tend to be left to deal with the public's enquiries. 
 Sanger duty is particularly boring because there is nothing else to do but look out of the window, and since it is rarely done in pairs social interaction provides no compensation. 
 Describing the boredom of sanger duty, one policeman said, &bquo;You've got to be able to read in this job. 
 If you can't read a book or a paper you're fucked, because there's fuck all else to do. 
 See, up at the likes of Paisley's there, &lsqb;name of policeman&rsqb; was desperate, he didn't read. 
 &lsqb;It&rsqb; nearly killed him&equo; (FN 23/11/87, p. 27). 
 But paperwork is the most boring part of the work of the section police. 
 That this is disliked by all policemen is well known (Ericson 1982: 5&ndash;6; Holdaway 1983: 21, 52; Manning 1977: 160). 
 In Easton, the dislike of it made some policemen reluctant to attend certain sorts of incident where a great deal of paperwork could be expected (such as road traffic accidents), although means of formal control usually ensured they responded in the end. 
 Of course, paperwork is itself a form of managerial control, which adds to the dislike, especially since returning a file as incorrectly prepared is perceived as a mechanism by which management assert their &bquo;glory&equo; in the labour process. 
 The dislike of paperwork influences other aspects of police work. 
 Being the observer in the Land Rover on patrol is unpopular because observers do the paperwork on incidents; those who cannot drive are thus left with a great deal of boring work. 
 It also affects the evaluations of incidents and what counts as a &bquo;good turn&equo;. 
 Incidents are categorized by the degree of paperwork involved, and the best shifts are those where &bquo;you're kept busy but with stuff you can clear up on the spot&equo; (FN 26/5/87, p. 34). 
 Great pleasure is therefore taken when the buck is passed and the paperwork is handed to someone else. 
 And there were occasions when banter and humour were used by low-ranking officers to convey the impression to the section police  that they should go easy on the number of &bquo;skulls&equo; (prisoners) they accrued because of the excessive paperwork it was causing. 
 In other words, dislike of paperwork is an important consideration in the operation of police discretion. 
 But it has one redeeming feature, for the claim that paperwork needs to be completed is used as an excuse to avoid other types of police work which are disliked even more. 
 It thus becomes a contextually specific form of easing. 
 Another type of work which is disliked is emotionally demanding work, a category not recognized elsewhere in the literature on the police. 
 This is work which requires an emotional coldness but which can on occasions be so demanding that detachment is difficult to maintain. 
 Good examples are crimes of sex abuse against children, and calls to natural deaths and suicides. 
 A few of these examples come within the category Hughes calls &bquo;dirty work&equo; (see Hughes 1958, 1964) but certainly not all. 
 Even so, the unpleasantness of these duties arises less from contact with things which the police consider either literally or metaphorically unclean (such as decomposed bodies and the &bquo;dregs and scum of society&equo;), and more from the risk the police run of displaying emotion. 
 It is for this reason that these sorts of incident are particularly disliked by policemen and are marginalized to policewomen, wherever staffing levels allow. 
 When they talk about work of this type, policemen stress the importance of remaining detached and emotionally cold. 
 Young probationers are instructed by older, more experienced men to follow the &bquo;police pattern&equo;, what Schutz would call the &bquo;recipe knowledge&equo;. 
 An elderly sergeant once remarked on his experience of attending a cot death for the first time, &bquo;You just have to say to yourself, the next time I will be better equipped to cope with this type of situation&hellip; 
 There's a pattern police follow in every situation. 
 You lay the pattern down whatever you're dealing with, and you follow it through. 
 You know, I always feel desperate, and I apologized to that family, but it has to be done&equo; (FN 5/1/87, p. 2). 
 It is part of this recipe knowledge to remain emotionally detached and consider it as just another incident or another death, and to treat the dead body, for example, &bquo;as a piece of meat&equo;: a phrase used several times by policemen and women. 
 If she could look at meat hanging in a butcher's, the fieldworker was told when she was accompanying policemen to a postmortem, she could look at dead bodies. 
 The tendency to render  horrific incidents of this sort into funny tales or &bquo;atrocity stories&equo; (Dingwall 1977), told ritualistically within the occupational culture of the station, is a further attempt to strip them of their emotional hold. 
 And some of the most popular subjects for &bquo;atrocity stories&equo; are decomposed bodies, bloody suicides, cot deaths, and the smell at post-mortems. 
 The purpose of these stories, however, is conditioned by their context. 
 Sometimes they are told to demonstrate what new recruits (and the field-worker) can expect; on other occasions they are told to illustrate the funny or the tragic sides of policing; or are used as a vehicle for the story-teller to display some features about him or herself, such as his or her experience and skill and ability in handling all things, and that he or she is professional in being able to talk about horror in a cold and detached manner. 
 More rarely, such stories are told at other times to demonstrate the reverse: that policemen and women are human beings and are affected by emotionally demanding work. 
 The telling of atrocity stories is therefore a highly structured occasion which reveals little about the teller other than that he or she is performing a ritual for a contextually specific purpose. 
 Therefore, the existence of atrocity stories on subjects such as this does not of itself reveal that this work is emotionally undemanding; simply that this is one impression that the story is intended to convey. 
 The same applies to the impression of emotional involvement. 
 Outside these structured occasions, when conversations are more natural and spontaneous, policemen reveal that in specific types of emotionally demanding work their distancing and coldness is tenuous and risks being broken down. 
 In the midst of passing on advice to the field-worker on how to cope with her imminent attendance at a post-mortem, one policeman said, &bquo;You get used to them. 
 I don't mind them any more.&equo; 
 But after a pause he went on to add, &bquo;Except for kids, I hate going to post-mortems for kids&equo; (FN 26/5/87, p. 21). 
 Below is an extract of conversation between two policemen who are telling a third about a cot death the two of them had recently attended. 
 PC. 1. 
 Jesus, it was awful, and the worst thing about it was, when we arrived the baby was still warm, so we tried to revive it with mouth to mouth. 
 Now the couple had expected it was dead and we gave them false hope. 
 When we couldn't revive it, it made the whole thing worse for them. 
 Than when the ambulance men arrived they also tried to revive it. 
  God it was awful. 
 Like we have to ask these really personal questions.PC. 2. 
 I always feel like saying, &bquo;Look, it's OK, I'll come back in a couple of weeks.&equo; 
 But you never do, like. 
 You'd get the balls chewed off you if you returned without all the details.PC. 1. 
 But it was awful. 
 God, the couple were really upset. 
 It was their first baby, tao. 
 (FN 16/3/87, pp. 31- 2) 
 It is not that policemen and women fail to achieve emotional detachment, even though one policeman once remarked that at postmortems he was appalled by the way pathologists treat the body simply as a lump of meat and fail to show respect (FN 17/12/87, p. 15). 
 Primarily what makes this type of work unpopular is the ever-present danger that work of this sort will break the veneer of coldness, exposing them as emotionally involved, which is something they dislike because it is considered unprofessional. 
 A third type of work which is disliked is work that risks displaying incompetence. 
 Although paperwork is boring, it is not difficult to do, but there are other duties where there is a risk of being shown to be incompetent, which are disliked for this reason. 
 This fear does not arise from a view of themselves as unskilled in formal police requirements, for no policemen or women would express that they suspect this of themselves, although some admit to suspecting it of others. 
 This fear derives more from a recognition that they often lack the additional personal qualities which they see as necessary for certain types of work, which is why most policemen are reluctant to deal with rape victims or to undertake community and neighbourhood policing. 
 This is work which the majority of section police see themselves as unsuited for and dislike when they have to do it. 
 Often this fear is expressed in the form of sexist remarks about the different instincts of policewomen compared to policemen, or disparaging remarks about the duties of those who work in community relations and neighbourhood policing. 
 This fear also arises from a recognition that in certain types of work they will not be able to match the public's expectations of competence, whether finding lost pets or settling disputes between neighbours. 
 This is work they are able to do little about, despite public faith, and it is unpopular because of a reluctance or inability to display that little will be done. 
 It is not just that dealing with Old Age Pensioners who have reported missing budgies falls outside the definition of what counts as &bquo;real&equo; police work, the work is also  disliked because it is problematic, for policemen need to display competence in the way they convey sympathy while admitting that nothing will be done. 
 The fear that the encounter might have been handled incompetently is concealed in dismissive remarks about this type of work, about it not bring their job, as well as critical comments on the members of the public who think it is and who therefore make unrealistic demands on them. 
 As one reflection of this, telephone calls about matters like this were occasionally terminated by the slamming down of the receiver, followed by the defiant expletives of &bquo;old bag&equo;, &bquo;old cow&equo;, or &bquo;bastard&equo;, which Manning's ethnography shows is a common closing remark among disgruntled policemen (1977, p. xiv). 
 Where possible, therefore, this is work to be avoided because of the risk of being seen as incompetent. 
 The dislike of enquiry desk duty, because of its boredom, is thus compounded because it involves dealing with these sorts of incident. 
 Above all, this fear arises in work where the police encounter outsiders whose job it is to make them appear wrong or incompetent &mdash; mostly court duty. 
 Appearance in court is feared by many policemen and women, who express a worry about being humiliated by an aggressive counsel, of becoming &bquo;tongue-tied&equo;, and generally of having &bquo;a rough time&equo;. 
 Their nervousness only adds to the dislike of this type of work. 
 The overtime and opportunities for easing which court duty affords is often not compensation enough for the stress it involves. 
 However, certain situational factors can transform it into enjoyable and legitimate police work. 
 Given the particular disposition of the policeman or woman and the nature of the case, court duty can become an opportunity for them to have a &bquo;good fight&equo;, and pleasure can be taken in &bquo;getting one over the solicitor&equo;. 
 This also appears to be an attraction to members of British police forces. 
 Holdaway (1983: 72) noted how lawyers were seen by Hilton's police as a threat because they unmask police practice, and, along with doctors and social workers, they were considered &bquo;challengers&equo;. 
 This led some policemen to enjoy the sport which the court room offered (Holdaway 1983: 74). 
 In the case of policemen at Easton, this sport is situationally constrained by the common-sense knowledge they build up of the court room setting and its players. 
 Some lawyers are typified as &bquo;clever&equo;, others as &bquo;stupid&equo;; the former require one to be cautious, while the latter give greater opportunity for having the wool pulled over their eyes. 
 The following is an extract from the field notes,  describing the return from court of two policemen, one a relatively inexperienced recruit. 
 During the court proceedings &lsqb;name&rsqb; and the young con &lsqb;constable&rsqb; gave conflicting statements. 
 The barrister for the defendant picked up on this. 
 Eventually the judge abandoned the point as irrelevant. 
 &lsqb;Name&rsqb; and the young con were triumphant; they had won the case. 
 It was the young con's first time in the box. 
 He and &lsqb;name&rsqb; kept exclaiming how stupid the barrister was, yet &lsqb;name&rsqb; reminded him. 
 PC. 
 They won't all be as stupid as that. 
 All the police present were scathing of the legal system, saying that the stupid barrister was from &lsqb;name of legal firm&rsqb;, and would probably end up a judge. 
 They mentioned the names of a few judges who they did not think highly of. 
 (FN 10/2/87, p. 3) 
 As this makes clear, judges are also typified. 
 There are those who are &bquo;hard&equo;, who accept &bquo;no messing&equo;, and who &bquo;put people away&equo; often for quite minor crimes. 
 These are judges who accept &bquo;no grovelling on the part of prisoners&equo;, even those who play on having a relative in the RUC (and we did come across a policeman who believed that his brother had been treated leniently in court as a result of this connection with the force). 
 &bquo;Soft&equo; judges are the opposite, and these might well be considered the &bquo;stupid&equo; ones. 
 In between are the &bquo;fair&equo; judges, whose judgement is seen to be unaffected by mood or the time of the day, and whose punishment fits the crime. 
 Surprisingly, given the folk image of policemen, on the one occasion when the field-worker accompanied some policemen on court duty, the men expressed a preference for &bquo;fair&equo; judges and actually criticized what they thought was the excessive penalty imposed by a &bquo;hard&equo; judge for the offence of throwing an empty can (FN 9/3/87, p. 10). 
 However, this is but the reverse side of the Janus face of justice, for in their eyes it happens more often that criminals are released or are not put in prison for long enough. 
 The case only confined for the policemen the inequities of the legal system: justice depends on who the prisoner gets. 
 There is but one type of work which police everywhere enjoy, and that is active crime-fighting on the streets (for example see Ekblom and Heal 1982; Ericson 1982; Holdaway 1983; Manning 1977; Policy Studies Institute 1983b; Punch 1979a; Reiner 1978, 1985). 
 This is &bquo;real&equo; police work. 
 The problem is that so little of police time is devoted to it. 
 McCabe and Sutcliffe (1978) have shown how only 6  per cent of the time of patrol police is occupied with incidents defined as &bquo;criminal&equo;. 
 Studies into the nature of the calls which the public make to the police show that demands are consistently unrelated to crime (Comrie and Kings 1975; Hough 1980; Jones 1983; Policy Studies Institute 1983b; Punch and Naylor 1973; Southgate and Ekblom 1984, 1986), and many ethnographic studies document how the majority of contacts between public and police do not involve criminal matters (Cain 1973; Comrie and Kings 1975; Cumming et al . 
 1970; Ericson 1982; Holdaway 1983; Manning 1977. 
 Payne 1973; Punch 1979a). 
 Historically policing has always involved controlling the petty (Ericson 1982: 7; Ignatieff 1978). 
 None the less, Easton's section police believe that crime detection is their primary role, their work place thus being the streets. 
 In words which almost parallel one of Manning's respondents (see Manning 1977: 160), one policeman in Easton said that &bquo;real policing is out on the streets&equo; (FN 23/10/86, p. 5). 
 Inside the station &bquo;nothing happens&equo; (FN 16/2/87, p. 11), even traffic control outside in the open is preferable to administrative work inside (FN 15/5/87, p. 51). 
 There again, while not all street-located work is crime-fighting, not all crime work involves action. 
 A distinction is made between &bquo;big&equo; and &bquo;little&equo; crime, with the latter often being quite trivial and offering less enjoyment and satisfaction. 
 The crimes that are put under these headings were identified in the last chapter, but that such distinctions are made is clear, for example, in the casual remarks the police make when responding to the respective incidents. 
 At one level, policemen and women claim that they pursue all crime with equal vigour, which on the whole is true, but this formal discourse conceals the evaluations they make of different crimes. 
 The observational data reveal that qualitative judgements are made about the seriousness of particular types of crime, evaluations which are often conveyed in casual remarks made in the real-life situations of policing &bquo;little crime&equo;. 
 Thus, for example, when apprehending a thief with &pound;40 of stolen money, the policemen concerned still argued they had &bquo;not come up with anything&equo; (FN 31/1/87, p. 10). 
 Referring to their work observing a house which was suspected of being used for prostitution, the policemen remarked that it was &bquo;a wee tuppence ha'penny job&equo;. 
 Big crime &bquo;puts wee jobs&equo; like suspected prostitution &bquo;in the shade here, its not like they're killing anybody, unless they've got AIDS, and then I suppose that would be suicide&equo; (FN 30/7/87, pp. 17&ndash;18).  
 In contrast delight and satisfaction are shown in the excitement of pursuing crimes involving robbery, car chases, burglary, drugs, and the like. 
 Pride is taken in making a detection of this importance and the section police dislike CID taking any credit when the &bquo;skulls&equo; are brought in by them. 
 The number of prisoners a section has accumulated during a shift is used as a measure of performance and becomes one of the bases of competition between the sections. 
 Manning calls this conceptualization of work the &bquo;threat-dangerhero&equo; syndrome (1977: 302), which he believes is widespread amongst those who discharge &bquo;Anglo-American policing&equo;, while Reiner refers to it as &bquo;old-fashioned machismo&equo;, which he argues is widespread within the occupational culture of the police (1985: 99-100). 
 The preference for fighting &bquo;big crime&equo; fits into these characterizati ons and led policemen in Easton to continually hope that &bquo;big crime&equo; would be discovered in the pursuit of the petty. 
 Those very rare instances where &bquo;little crime&equo; develops into &bquo;real&equo; police work are recounted by policemen often and told with pleasure and delight. 
 As an illustration of how it can occur, the field-worker was told of an incident in which a driver was asked to stop for failing to wear a seat-belt, upon which he sped off, necessitating a car chase, which eventually ended with two cars being wrecked and a policeman injured. 
 It is not just the situation of the accounting which is important in stories of this sort, for, although the telling of exciting stories is often used to enliven boring work, the moral of these particular action stories is crucial to their accounting. 
 This type of story shows that the pursuit of &bquo;little crime&equo; can have some satisfaction and legitimacy, which explains in part why most policemen and women pursue it diligently while deprecating it. 
 These stories also demonstrate the need for policemen and women to be continually prepared for &bquo;a big one&equo; and to be ever vigilant, which lends further significance to some &bquo;little crimes&equo;. 
 And when experience teaches that the chances of getting a &bquo;biggy&equo; are faint, this expectation can be offset by the telling of these sorts of stories. 
 The moral is that in special circumstances &bquo;little crime&equo; can be exciting, and the opportunity for &bquo;real&equo; police work can be missed unless one remains prepared. 
 Below is an extract from the field notes which illustrates the context in which this moral was recounted: 
 A stolen vehicle had been stopped in the &lsqb;name of place&rsqb; area so we sped up there. 
 &lsqb;Name&rsqb; found a small driveway in front of some shops and we parked  there, which allowed us to speed off in either direction after the vehicle, should it appear. 
 &lsqb;Name&rsqb; muttered, 
 PC. 1. 
 Imagine if we got it. 
 PC. 2. 
 No chace. 
 When did you last see a stoley? 
 PC. 1. 
 Never, not like this. 
 PC. 2. 
 I did once up in Derry on the edge of the Creggan. 
 We were driving around and I seen these two young lads in a car and I says, &bquo;They look a bit young to be driving that.&equo; 
 Stopped them. 
 &bquo;Can I help you, Constable?&equo;, all very nice. 
 Let them go, gets back to the station &lsqb;there was a&rsqb; description of a stolen vehicle. 
 Wasn't it the vehicle I'd stopped? 
 Couldn't believe it. 
 Joy-riders, I'd let them go. 
 (FN 27/10/87, pp. 11&ndash;12) 
 It is stories like these which help to protect Easton's policemen and women from the loss of morale which Manning claims is an inevitable result of the contradiction between the image the police have of themselves and their work and the low-key nature of practical policing (Manning 1977: 349; also see Holdaway 1983, 1988, who makes a similar point). 
 The conceptualizations of police work that are found in Easton not only fit what is known of police forces elsewhere, they parallel the portrayal of policing in the wider culture. 
 The image of policing gleaned from police programmes on British and American television and in films is very much how Easton's police see themselves, as others have commented with respect to police forces elsewhere (Holdaway 1983: 147; Hurd 1979; Klockars 1983; Morris and Heal 1981; Tuska 1979). 
 The popularity of these programmes among the section police in Easton is both cause and effect of the evaluations they make of their work. 
 The excitement, suspense, and danger which seems the lot of the police on celluloid feeds into the definitions many of Easton's section police give to their work experience, and the supposed similarity of this experience leads them to see police films and television programmes as an accurate portrayal, to be watched avidly because of this shared world. 
 Even though the portrayal of police work on celluloid is not a realistic description of policing in Easton, the conceptualizations they have of their role as fighters of &bquo;big crime&equo;, which they have to be continually prepared for, encourages them to see the media portrayal of policing as accurate, thus completing the circle. 
 Aggressive, action-packed police programmes are popular because of their supposed realism and the congruency of their imagery, so  that features of the symbolic portrayal become adopted by Easton's police as part of their practice. 
 This was particularly noticeable among the younger policemen, for whom this imagery seems to be a defining characteristic of their work. 
 Klockars refers to this as the &bquo;Dirty Harry&equo; syndrome (1983). 
 It was reflected in the expressions used by some members of the RUC (&bquo;OK, let's hit the streets and do it to them before they do it to us&equo;, &bquo;This is where the law stops and I take over, sucker&equo;, the reference to probationary police as &bquo;rookies&equo; and to bullets as &bquo;slugs&equo;), their dress (mirror sunglasses, blue jeans, and white T-shirt, sometimes with the Miami-Vice parallel reinforced by the words being printed on the T-shirt), and other ephemera (the engraving of &bquo;San Quentin' on the keys to the cells, jumping through the enquiry room window rather than using the door). 
 Those policemen who have racist views are faced with problems when the hero on celluloid is black, but when discussing such an instance, one policeman expressed his dislike for blacks but still found the film &bquo;brilliant&equo; (FN 9/10/87, p. 57). 
 More importantly, this imagery affects the demeanour of these macho men when dealing with the public. 
 Sensitivity to public relations is not a quality which accompanies the Rambo self-image, and sergeants sometimes avoid placing the policemen who live out this imagery in situations where their insensitivity can damage public perceptions of the police. 
 Various studies have shown that the public evaluate the police in terms of the attitude the police show them when they are victims in need of police help (for example, Jones 1983; Maguire 1982; Shapland 1982; Southgate and Ekblom 1984). 
 It is not always possible for low-ranking officers to anticipate the situations which &bquo;Action Men&equo; need to avoid, and some instances were observed where the aggressive manner of the policeman acted as a form of &bquo;amplification of deviance&equo; (Young 1971), transforming a minor situation into &bquo;big crime&equo;. 
 Moving on loitering youths is a policing situation ripe for such amplification, as other research has shown (Southgate and Ekblom 1986: 35, 37; Young 1971), and there were several occasions when policemen for whom this imagery is very important over-reacted to the presence of young people on street corners and were aggressive in the way they moved them on. 
 On one occasion the aggression was returned, resulting in the person being brought into the station and charged. 
 Of course, there are other situations when the toughness that accompanies the Rambo self-image is useful in disarming trouble-makers and preventing  further crime, as happened more than once during field-work. 
 The view of senior management is that policemen need to combine the qualities of compassion and toughness and know when each is appropri &mdash; ate (FN 11/11/87, pp. 7&ndash;8), although in practice it is difficult to strike this fine balance. 
 Where it is seen by work colleagues to be getting out of kilter, informal controls can be used to restore equilibrium. 
 Thus, some policemen are urged by their tough-minded colleagues to treat marginal incidents as criminal behaviour and are encouraged into action. 
 The reverse is equally evident, for informal controls sometimes operate to moderate the actions of those members of the RUC who see themselves as Rambo in police uniform. 
 The satirical phrase used to embarrass the &bquo;Action Men&equo; is that they have the &bquo;John Wayne syndrome&equo;; the fact it is Wayne rather than Rambo who is used to ridicule them gives a clue that it tends to be the older members of the force who use the term to describe the exuberant younger policemen. 
 The &bquo;Action Men&equo; are aware that it is used as a term of abuse and often become angry when it is applied to them. 
 Nicknames such as &bquo;Rambo&equo; and &bquo;Action Man&equo; serve the same purpose of informal social control. 
 The symbol which the older and more experienced policemen on the sections use as their model is Dixon of Dock Green, although the avuncular figure of Dixon is ridiculed by many younger policemen as outdated and antiquarian, even for Great Britain. 
 Conceptualizations of police work are therefore derived from and embedded in such phenomena as the day-to-day experience of police duties, which is itself contextually related to the sorts of crime that occur in the area in which the station is located, common-sense notions about policing contained in the occupational culture, and stereotypes of policing found in the wider culture. 
 However, these conceptualizations also derive from the biographical situation of policemen and women, which predisposes them to define their role in a certain way. 
 The clash of symbols represented by Dixon and Rambo represents a more fundamental conflict between those policemen and women who emphasize their role in terms of crime-fighting, especially &bquo;big crime&equo;, and those who see themselves as having a public service and community welfare role. 
 This contrast is a familiar one in the sociology of policing and the subject of much comment, all of which argues that only a small minority of policemen and women define their work in terms of social service. 
 Reiner  put it as only 1 in 20 constables (1978; also see Southgate and Ekblom 1984: 25). 
 The police are called upon to perform many public services (for example, see Punch 1979b; Punch and Naylor 1973), which is true even of a police force in a divided society like Northern Ireland, as the last chapter showed. 
 Therefore, the unwillingness of policemen to define their role in these terms does not show itself in a failure to perform these duties but as a judgement that it is &bquo;really&equo; the work of others. 
 This view is common to the &bquo;Action Men&equo; among Easton's section police who are called upon to do what they consider is the job of the social services. 
 Community relations and neighbourhood police in Easton take the opposite view, as we shall shortly show, but not all section police demean or demur from this type of work. 
 As one explained, &bquo;I get great satisfaction from the job. 
 I enjoy helping the public; like, that's what we're here for. 
 We're paid by the public, so they deserve a good service&equo; (FN 26/5/87, p. 32). 
 While they might be expected to say this, most do not admit to it. 
 Those who do might also be thought to be insincere, but some policemen showed real regret and disappointment when they were unable to provide the service they felt they should, whether because of the nature of the call or because of unrealistic public expectations (such as finding lost budgies, preventing sheep-worrying, or reconciling warring spouses and quarrelsome neighbours). 
 EVALUATIONS OF COMPETENT POLICE WORK 
 As Fielding has shown (1988b), what counts as good police work to ordinary policemen and women is not determined by official standards of performance, but by a range of contextual factors. 
 Thus, criteria of competence only become evident when policemen and women give accounts of what they assess as &bquo;good&equo; police work in real-life settings (p. 45). 
 Considerations on which they seem to draw include: how they construe their role as members of the police, which is itself informed by their interpretation of the organizational mandate of the force, by informal organizational requirements and occupational culture, and by local community expectations; their knowledge of locale; whether constables are able to resolve the momentary demands of the situation; and their ability to handle the complex mix of law enforcement, local expectations, and the need  for good public relations. 
 In short, official notions of effectiveness are only one set of criteria among several contextual evaluations of competence, and often constables diverge in their assessments. 
 But amongst the influences upon evaluations of competence are conceptualizations of police work. 
 With evidence drawn from his field-work in Great Britain, Fielding showed how some constables place primacy upon providing counselling assistance, displaying forbearance in their dealings with the public, and in possessing the communication skills to process the encounter with the public smoothly and to enlist the support of members of the public. 
 Others, however, emphasize the importance of enforcing the law and obtaining a &bquo;good crime arrest&equo;, one part of which is displaying to criminals sufficient potential for coercion as to mount arrests without further assistance. 
 Research on encounters between police and public has shown that from the public's view even the crime-fighters need communication skills (Dix and Layzell 1983; Southgate and Ekblom 1984, 1986; Sykes and Brent 1983), although these abilities are all too often absent. 
 Fielding notes how some constables subsume these negotiating skills under the category of &bquo;talk&equo;, which gives meaning to their complaint that many younger policemen seem no longer to know how to talk to members of the public (1988b: 60; also see Holdaway 1983: 90; Southgate 1982: 11&ndash;12). 
 Other research has shown how evaluations of &bquo;good&equo; policing vary with types of police practice, with the different &bquo;types&equo; of policemen conceptualizing competent practice in contrasting ways (Muir 1977; Reiner 1978; for a review of the numerous typologies of policemen that exist in the sociology of policing see Reiner 1985: 104&ndash;6). 
 But one point on which all policemen and women seem to agree is that competence is experiential rather than textbook in origin. 
 The term which gives shorthand expression to this in the sociology of policing is &bquo;common sense&equo;. 
 Among Easton's section police &bquo;common sense&equo; subsumes all competences, being an indexical category flexible enough to include different sorts of skills, all of which are described as constituting common sense. 
 As Easton's section police see it, a competent member of the RUC is one who uses his or her common sense. 
 This skill overrides otherwise important divisions within the force, such as gender, age, religion, and background, so that policewomen, for example, are assessed as competent despite the sexist nature of the occupational culture of the station if they have &bquo;common sense&equo;. 
 The incompetent,  therefore, are the bookish, the &bquo;smart&equo; ones, those who have the theory but not the common sense, which only comes from experience and practice. 
 Many times the incompetent were described as being smart but lacking even an ounce of common sense. 
 But not only is it a way of classifying policemen and women: the term is also used to criticize those outsiders who think they know something about policing, such as lawyers, academics, researchers, and journalists; it is also a self-appellation of praise. 
 You get some boys join the police, they're blessed with brains but they've no common sense. 
 Like, you can tell people who are, like, geniuses, you can almost tell to look at them, they're on another planet. 
 You get a lot of professors and that. 
 &lsqb;They&rsqb; have no common sense. 
 I don't have that much brains, but I'd say I had good common sense. 
 Like, you get teachers who join the police; they're not good policemen to me, they don't eat and think like policemen. 
 (FN 17/12/87, p. 23) 
 The notion thus serves to give moral worth and competence to members of an occupational group whose level of education is often quite low. 
 However, as an indexical category, what counts as common sense is contextually specific. 
 Its meaning is influenced by the nature of the occupational task, so that it is &bquo;common sense&equo; for a member of the police to try to save lives, catch terrorists, make arrests, fulfil public expectations, do the paperwork properly, and so on. 
 It is also structured by the biographical situation of the person using the term and the definitions they give to their work role. 
 To some constables &bquo;common sense&equo; is knowing how to talk to people: 
 You've got to be able to talk to people on their own level, you get the best out of people if you treat them a certain way. 
 Like, I'd say to a young officer, maybe just out of the depot &lsqb;training centre&rsqb;, if a old lady calls you for assistance to her, you're a police officer and she will look to you for help, ad we have to leave people with a certain level of satisfaction. 
 (FN 30/11/87, pp. 34&ndash;5) 
 It follows then that the &bquo;Action Men&equo; are often seen as incompetent and as avoiding work which calls for common sense. 
 As one constable stated, the &bquo;Action Men&equo; who are fitness conscious and orientated towards crime-fighting only adopt this mode &bquo;to get them off doing work&equo;. 
 &bquo;Bluffers. 
 Like, say they've been out on a run and there's a call, they say they can't go out because they're not in uniform and are all sweaty&equo; (FN 26/5/87, p. 27). 
 &bquo;Good&equo; work has to  be seen as More than crime-fighting: &bquo;Like, this is the sort of job that you come off at the end of the night and say to yourself &bquo;What did I do?&equo; 
 But, like, you don't know what you might have prevented&equo; (FN 20/6/87, p. 8). 
 Hence some of the older hands in the force complain about the younger, more exuberant policemen. 
 They lack the experience and practice which gives them the ability to communicate with the public: they lack common sense. 
 &bquo;The thing you often see with young men is that they have had very little experience in dealing with people. 
 Sure, who have they talked to but their school mates?&hellip; 
 The police makes them streetwise within no time at all, but they're missing out on something&equo; (FN 9/8/87, p. 3). 
 Yet, given the predominance of the crime-fighting conceptualization of police work, the main ingredient to common sense is local knowledge of crime and criminals. 
 The &bquo;good&equo; policemen and women know their area: the sites of trouble and danger, as Holdaway describes them (1983: 39&ndash;42), which need special attention, the places to avoid without having further back-up, the places where events and incidents have occurred in the past, the people on whom to focus attention, such as the &bquo;troublesome families&equo; in whom crime historically runs or the VIPs in the area who get special protective care. 
 This knowledge is also recursive, in that the competent policeman or woman needs to know which criminals have a common-sense knowledge about the activities and deployment of the police, which requires that they have the additional common sense to confound the criminal's working knowledge of the police. 
 Hence &bquo;a policeman is only as good as his interest in his and surrounding areas&equo; (FN 30/11/87, p. 28). 
 The field-worker was a captive audience to whom members of the force could display their competence when riding around Easton in a police vehicle, and conversations were punctuated by policemen pointing out significant sites and personnel. 
 So, too, were new recruits and staff transferred from outside the area. 
 However, the dissemination of this knowledge to newcomers has the additional purpose of inculcating in them the common sense that is necessary to police Easton. 
 One experienced constable explained the process as follows: &bquo;Like, whenever we get a new constable in this station, they are guided along by the rest of the men. 
 When they go out on patrol the other men will point out that such-and-such happened here, soand-so lives there, that's a bad area, and so on. 
 Eventually that constable learns who to watch&equo; (FN 30/11/87, p. 35). 
 The training of  probationers encourages this transmission, because after formal training in the depot each recruit is assigned to an experienced senior constable in the station. 
 One such senior said the intention was to allow the probationer to learn from the experience of others (FN 4/4/87, p. 6), on the assumption that people learn &bquo;on the job&equo; rather than in the depot. 
 That is, policing is experiential: it is based on the common sense that is built up from doing the job, and senior constables have some influence on the meaning which new recruits give this &bquo;common sense&equo;. 
 But irrespective of how they construe the common sense which is the policeman or woman's working knowledge, seniors are agreed that new recruits need experience of life to enable them to deal with the range of situations and people they encounter in their work. 
 Seniors in Easton recommend a later starting age than the current 18 years, with one even suggesting a compulsory twelvemonth work experience to broaden the range of experience of recruits. 
 To achieve a similar end, one was opposed to recruits restricting their social networks to other members of the force. 
 All were opposed to graduate entry. 
 University is claimed to provide too narrow a background and the ethos of academe runs counter to the experiential emphasis in police bureaucracies. 
 There is also opposition to the &bquo;specialist knowledge&equo; which textbook-learnt policemen and women employ, sometimes drawn from the liberal social sciences. 
 These boys can be all very good on paper. 
 Say, you have a problem with a youth, they could do you out this plan that would sound very good on paper &mdash; bring in the social workers, bring in the DHSS and juvenile liaison. 
 You ask a man who has a bit more experience and plenty of common sense ad he'll say to you, &bquo;Get the lad in, bring him home to his parents and the father will give him a clip round the ear.&equo; 
 That will do him a lot better than this other guy's plan. 
 A clip round the ear has more chance of preventing him from doing something a second time than bringing all these other agencies in. 
 In my mind it's common sense that makes a good policeman, not education. 
 Education in this job doesn't mean an iota. 
 That's why I think all this rapid promotion is a load of crap. 
 (FN 16/11/87, p. 26) 
 Attempts to professionalize the police by recruiting more graduates and introducing specialist training is thus resisted by many from below. 
 Understood in this sense professionalization contests what ordinary policemen and women see as long-established, wellgrounded, practical experience. 
 This view contrasts with that of  many outsiders, and the research of Muir (1977) and Reiner (1978) describes the &bquo;professional&equo; type of policeman as the most competent, although the indexical nature of the notion of &bquo;common sense&equo; enables these views to be dismissed by ordinary policemen and women because the authors lack this same quality. 
 Other parts of the working &bquo;common sense&equo; of the police in Easton are the typifications and recipe knowledge which they employ when doing policing, and it is to this that we now turn. 
 THE COGNITIVE MAP OF EASTON'S SECTION POLICE 
 In his account of social phenomenology, Alfred Schutz (1967) claimed that the variability and complexity of the everyday world requires members to use particular cognitive processes which reduce this ambiguity. 
 The means by which this is done is through the &bquo;schemes of experience&equo;, such as typifications, recipes, and other idealizations which members build up over time and into which are allotted new experiences and encounters, rendering the unknown into the known, the unfamiliar into the familiar. 
 Apprehending the world through these types gives it a preliminary coherency and &bquo;standardized sameness&equo;. 
 However, these &bquo;schemes of experience&equo; are not invented ex nihilo  but are disseminated through the commonsense knowledge shared by members of the life-world, so that members come to learn the relevant typifications and their meaning (see Natanson 1970; for an application of these ideas see Brewer 1984a, b, 1988b). 
 Hence experience and type originate together: the individual cannot endow experiences with meaning without types, yet types are constituted from and through lived experience (see Rogers 1981:. 
 139). 
 Policemen and women are members of a close-knit occupational world with a discrete culture and also face a world which has great variability and confusion, and considerable attention has been focused on the cognitive processes, typifications, and recipes they employ to accomplish policing (for example, see Bittner 1967, 1980; Chatterton 1975; Holdaway 1983; Manning 1977; Policy Studies Institute 1983b; Reiner 1978; Rubinstein 1973; Skolnick 1966; for a study of police typifications in the United States which has a very odd combination of Schutz's ideas, symbolic interactionism, and quantitative and mathematical models, see Sykes and Brent 1983). 
  This has been one of the central preoccupations of ethnographic police research, especially that inspired by phenomenology and ethnomethodology, and so apposite is policing to this focus that many theoreticians from within phenomenology and ethnomethodology have used it for the application of their ideas (Cicourel 1968; Pollner 1987; Sacks 1972; Sudnow 1965). 
 These idealizations are referred to by Holdaway as the &bquo;mental map&equo; of the police (1983: 63&ndash;4), and he addressed the typifications Hilton's police had of their area (sites of &bquo;danger&equo; and &bquo;trouble&equo;, &bquo;mump holes&equo;, and so on), and the people they encountered (&bquo;challengers&equo;, &bquo;disarmers&equo;, &bquo;prisoners&equo;). 
 However, most studies focus on the latter set of typifications. 
 The research by the Policy Studies Institute on the Metropolitan Police outlined the typifications they had of the public, contrasting the &bquo;slags&equo; and &bquo;ordinary people&equo; (1983b: 180). 
 Manning lists numerous categories employed in a London subdivision, such as &bquo;old boots&equo;, &bquo;old dears&equo;, &bquo;cows&equo;, &bquo;slags&equo;, &bquo;greasers&equo;, &bquo;John Does&equo;, and &bquo;yobs&equo; (1977: 236&ndash;8). 
 There are many similar examples that could be cited. 
 Reiner reviews the studies on police typifications of the public and he focuses on seven which are identified in the literature &mdash; &bquo;goad-class villains&equo;, people so powerless that they are &bquo;police property&equo;, the &bquo;rubbish&equo;, &bquo;challengers&equo;, &bquo;disarmers&equo;, &bquo;do-gooders&equo;, and &bquo;politicians&equo; (1985: 94&ndash;7). 
 A point which these listings often miss is that typifications are not all of equal generality within the everyday world. 
 Schutz emphasized how typifications are related to the &bquo;purpose at hand&equo;, which suggests that some typifications will be universal (&bquo;mother&equo;, &bquo;father&equo;) and others more restricted depending upon how general is the purpose of their use. 
 The overriding purpose of policing as perceived by ordinary policemen and women is to uphold the law, which requires typifications of very general use and applicability which distinguish between those who keep and those who break the law. 
 It is for this reason that ordinary policemen and women dislike it when the typifications become confused, when decent and honest &bquo;victims&equo; of crime, for example, become &bquo;trouble-makers&equo; by taking the law into their own hands. 
 But around these primary typifications exist a whole array which operate in more specific settings (court duty, post-mortems, the enquiry desk, and so on), whose use therefore is not only contextually related but also more restricted. 
 There are two ways in which these secondary typifications are less general. 
 Firstly, they achieve purposes less central to the main tasks of policing  because of the narrower range of settings in which they are used. 
 Secondly, related to this, there is a much smaller number of policemen and women for whom they are relevant, which limits their use. 
 Easton's section police have two sets of primary typifications: one categorizing trouble-makers, the other the abnormal. 
 Criminals and other trouble-makers are referred to widely as &bquo;gougers&equo;: &bquo;there are basically two types of people. 
 There are the decent members of the public and the gougers&equo; (FN 26/5/87, p. 23). 
 The term &bquo;gouger&equo; is flexible in that it refers to known criminals as well as others who look or act as if they have a potential for crime and trouble. 
 To be known to the police as having a history of crime is sufficient to be categorized a gouger, and people in Easton who are well known as gougers are always the first suspects. 
 For others it is sufficient to look or act like a gouger by being rough-looking and dirty or disrespectful to and disliking the police, &bquo;giving lip&equo; and swearing, coming from &bquo;a problem family&equo; and being of low intelligence (&bquo;not all there&equo;, &bquo;air getting in&equo;, &bquo;not right&equo;, &bquo;a few bricks short of a full load&equo;). 
 In short, gougers are life's losers. 
 Because the typification is very inclusive, covering known criminals and people who look as if they might be, it gets its meaning partly from practical experience of people who typically commit crime in Easton, but also from prejudices that derive from middleclass notions of respectability. 
 Local knowledge is therefore one important influence on the application of the typification. 
 For example, on one occasion a youth was caught urinating in the street late at might, and was very respectful and deferential when caught in the act, but, upon the policeman recalling that he had recently been one of a group which had shouted abuse at him, an act expected from gougers, he was arrested, and the incident was treated as a case of indecent exposure. 
 But local knowledge is not the only influence. 
 Middle-class notions of respectability enable policemen and women &bquo;to tell just by looking at someone whether there's something a bit suspicious about them&equo; and &bquo;to be able to recognize a decent member of the public&equo; (FN 20/6/87, p. 20). 
 For example, a drunken woman was brought into the station one night after assaulting a policewoman and using very abusive language, something to be expected from gougers, but was allowed home uncharged after spending a night in the cells: she was even allowed to leave early enough in the morning to avoid all  but the milkman from seeing her arrive home in a police vehicle. 
 Talking about the woman, a policeman said, &bquo;She was a clean person, wasn't she? 
 She wasn't the usual gouger element type. 
 She was probably just seeking attention.&equo; 
 The injured policewoman added, &bquo;She just needed someone to talk to, I think&equo; (FN 25/9/87, p. 24). 
 Through remarks like these the police were normalizing the behaviour to distinguish it from that which cam be expected from gougers. 
 &bquo;Appearance&equo; can relate to class, as in the following remarks: 
 You adapt your personality depending on who you're dealing with. 
 Say I was dealing with one of our gougers, I come down to &lsqb;his&rsqb; level. 
 I'd tell him to fuck up, because he understands that. 
 You've got to bring yourself down to their level. 
 There's two methods of policing, one for the decent people and one for the trouble-makers. 
 You wouldn't walk into &lsqb;name of a middleclass suburb of Easton&rsqb; and say, &bquo;Would you all fuck up.&equo; 
 I remember once a sergeant explaining to a constable. 
 The sergeant had just told a group of kids to fuck away off. 
 We went to another call and like these were upper class and this young constable got out and told them to fuck away off. 
 I seen the sergeant rolling his eyes. 
 Like there was a gap, if you see what I mean. 
 One group was working class and one was upper class. 
 You get a bit more respect from those. 
 (FN 25/6/87, p. 23) 
 It is in the initial anticipation that the middle class will show respect that the bias lies, for where this deference is lacking, even from someone who appears middle class, a variant of the gouger typification comes into force. 
 A subcategory of gougers are &bquo;mouths&equo;: young people who &bquo;give lip&equo;, primarily as a result of drink. 
 Middleclass youths are often &bquo;mouths&equo; but rarely become gougers because the latter require an element of &bquo;pure badness&equo;, which from the view of the police tends to exclude the middle classes, for &bquo;pure badness&equo; derives from being (or appearing to be) educationally subnormal, coming from &bquo;bad homes&equo;, or having a history of crime. 
 But some &bquo;mouths&equo; can have their &bquo;deviance amplified&equo; (Young 1971) in order for it to come within the conduct expected of gougers. 
 The incident described in the following extract from the field notes, provides a good illustration of this: 
 A crowd of about seven or eight youths on their way out of a Chinese carryout were in high spirits. 
 As soon as they saw the car, which had a police sign on the roof, they quietened down. 
 We stopped beside a autobank, which was out of order. 
 Referring to the crowd, one constable said, 
 PC. 1. 
 I bet ya it was one of them that put that out of order. 
 I think I saw one of them over at it. 
  &lsqb;Name of another policeman&rsqb; got out. 
 He had been incensed by the guy on the comer &lsqb;who had said &bquo;Fucking bastards&equo; as they drove past&rsqb; and I felt wanted to take it out on somebody. 
 He said, 
 PC. 2. 
 Drive down past these boys again. 
 As we turned the comer, passing the guy &lsqb;who had earlier sworn at the police&rsqb;, &lsqb;PC. 2.&rsqb; said, 
 PC. 2. 
 Look at that piss artist. 
 Did you see what he did when we passed him first? 
 PC. 1. 
 He said &bquo;Fuck off&equo; or something. 
 PC. 2. 
 But he gave us that there. 
 &lsqb;PC. 2.&rsqb; made the sign that the man thought the police were wankers. 
 PC. 2. just drive slowly past this guy. 
 &lsqb;PC. 2.&rsqb; leered intimidatingly at the guy, who had no comment to make. 
 So we drove after the youths, who had begun singing again. 
 &lsqb;PC. 2.&rsqb; got on the radio to ask for assistance even though nothing had happened. 
 He said, 
 PC. 2. 
 We'll drive past them and once we get past them they'll probably start shouting. 
 If you could try and pinpoint one of them that's doing the shouting. 
 We drove past slowly. 
 The singing and shouting ceased as we did this. 
 As soon as we passed, loud shouts went up. 
 We pulled in a driveway. 
 By this time there was a Land Rover and an unmarked escort &lsqb;car&rsqb; at the scene&hellip; 
 One of the youths was arrested. 
 Referring to the arrested youth, a third policeman new to the scene said, 
 PC. 3. 
 I've seen worse. 
 Maybe just throw him out down the road here. 
 &lsqb;PC. 3.&rsqb; didn't think the guy was that bad. 
 However, he was not thrown out, he was taken back to the station and locked up for the night. 
 The youths were neither causing damage nor harm. 
 They were from their appearance obviously working class. 
 &lsqb;PC. 2.&rsqb; commented as we left the scene, 
 PC. 2. 
 &lsqb;Name of working-class council estate&rsqb; boys. 
 (FN 7/11/87, p. 2) 
 The deviance of &bquo;mouths&equo; was in this instance amplified by direct provocation by the police, in part because one member of the force wanted some &bquo;skulls&equo;, but also because they were elevated into &bquo;gougers&equo;: the &bquo;lip&equo; was typical of that of gougers and they fitted the social class from which gougers come. 
 The other primary typification used by Easton's section police is for the purpose of categorizing the abnormal. 
 The &bquo;purpose at hand&equo;, to distinguish between criminals and decent people, requires also  that policemen and women be able to sense that something unusual and abnormal is occurring. 
 The two sets of categorizations are closely related, for this sense of the abnormal is based in part on typifications of people, but also in part on typifications of place and of people in (or out of) place. 
 Although specific assessments are heavily contextualized and influenced by such things as the time of day and fashion (Rubinstein 1973: 249), the evaluations are standardized into discrete types of abnormal situation. 
 Ericson notes how the patrol police he studied in Canada considered the following situations to be abnormal: individuals considered to be out of place; individuals in places of special significance; particular types of people regardless of place; and unusual circumstances regarding property (Ericson 1982: 86). 
 This is a useful typology for understanding the sense of abnormality which Easton's section police operate. 
 Thus, for example, gougers are gougers and need to be watched wherever they are. 
 Also in need of special attention are key locations where crime can be expected, especially at might, such at commercial properties and residential areas in the suburbs. 
 People of any description become suspicious persons when found at these sites. 
 The first category has the greatest potential for ambiguity, for it requires more interpretative work, in that it associates places with types of people. 
 Thus, for the police, it is unusual for youths to be driving &bquo;up-market motors&equo; in &bquo;poor areas&equo; (for similar typifications see Dix and Layzell 1983: 107&ndash;8). 
 However, there is another type of abnormal situation to those identified by Ericson, which concerns objects out of context. 
 For example, Easton's section police consider it abnormal if cars are out of context, such as expensive cars being driven in &bquo;poor areas&equo; and old bangers in the exclusive suburbs. 
 People of all types with unusual objects upon their person are also considered suspicious, whether this be holdalls or pocketfuls of 2p pieces (suspected of being used to entice children). 
 Identifying the typifications of abnormality used by Easton's section police in this way should not be taken to suggest that there is universal agreement on the abnormality of each specific incident. 
 Considerable ambiguity arises when the appearances of the incident are such that it is uncertain whether or not it fits one of these types of abnormal situation. 
 This occurred frequently during field-work, and in these circumstances the police concerned negotiated the appearances of the case in order to decide whether or not something  abnormal was taking place. 
 The resources on which they call in making this decision include the above typifications, as well as local knowledge of the area and its crime, and contextual and time variables. 
 But in addition to these primary typifications there are a large number of more contextually specific typifications whose use has a less general purpose. 
 This might be because the people to whom they apply are encountered only infrequently in the course of police work. 
 Examples here are typifications of judges (&bquo;hard&equo;, &bquo;soft&equo;, &bquo;fair&equo;), solicitors (&bquo;clever&equo;, &bquo;stupid&equo;), rape victims (&bquo;pure&equo;, &bquo;asking for it&equo;, &bquo;good-time girls&equo;), the typification &bquo;common-law job&equo; for children born out of wedlock, and &bquo;old dear&equo; for friendly female pensioners. 
 Another reason for the more restricted use of these sorts of typification is that the situations in which they become operative are infrequent, such as the typifications &bquo;old biddies&equo; or &bquo;old dolls&equo; for pensioners who make petty complaints, &bquo;Easton funny&equo; for strange and odd events, and &bquo;loopers&equo; for odd and strange people. 
 Again local knowledge is used, for example, to classify specific pensioners as either &bquo;old dears&equo; or &bquo;old biddies/dolls&equo;, and the categorization is often negotiated between the police concerned on this basis. 
 Part of the cognitive map of Easton's section police is their recipe knowledge. 
 As understood by Schutz, &bquo;recipes&equo; are standardized guide-lines for behaviour which are adopted as a matter of course, and vary depending upon the type of situation. 
 They have a dual purpose, for on the one hand they teach how to act in specific situations, but, conversely, the guide-lines also function as a means of typification for classifying incidents. 
 The adoption of a particular recipe therefore avoids any ambiguity and uncertainty by allowing a situation to be typified so that the appropriate behaviour is known. 
 Easton's section police call such recipes &bquo;patterns&equo;. 
 Some of these &bquo;patterns&equo; are formalized in the police manual, so that the procedure is laid down for dealing with rape cases, domestic disputes, medical examinations, road traffic accidents, and so on. 
 However, the experiential nature of police training usually ensures that a commonsense knowledge about these patterns is also built up. 
 The procedures adopted for each category of incident are of less interest than the issue of how these patterns are able to coexist with the unexpected nature of much police work. 
 Quite often things will not go to plan because of the variability of people's behaviour in situations of stress or the unusual and horrific nature of some of the  calls the police have to attend. 
 In such circumstances one particular recipe takes over, which Easton's section police call &bquo;bluff&equo;: &bquo;Even though you mightn't have a clue, you bluff your way through.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bluff&equo; is a recipe which consists of giving the impression to the public that the police know what they are doing when they do not. 
 Verbal and non-verbal behaviour is used to bluff, so it is necessary to issue advice in an authoritative and calm voice, and appear to be busy and active, if only in seeking the assistance of others. 
 &bquo;Bluffing&equo; is thus an indexical term used in different ways by Easton's section police. 
 Used in one context it is an essential skill for handling difficult situations, in another it is used as an equivalent for laziness. 
 DISCRETION 
 One important role which typifications play, along with other factors, is in structuring the operation of police discretion. 
 We have already noted how deviance is amplified upon the application of the gouger typification, so that the failure to apply it can result in a dissipation of deviance and an attempt to normalize the behaviour. 
 Discretion such as this, what Klockars (1985) calls &bquo;selective enforcement&equo;, has provoked considerable interest right from the beginning of sociology's concern with policing (for example Goldstein 1960, 1963; La Favre 1965). 
 Within this literature, discretion tends to be interpreted in purely legalistic terms &mdash; being a decision about which rule is appropriate and whether or not to apply it (see Ericson 1982: 11&ndash;12). 
 A broader conception of discretion should include a knowledge about the interactional skills appropriate to the different types of encounter between police and public. 
 These skills are particularly important following the introduction of community policing, as the next chapter will document. 
 But within the first interpretation of the term, many authors have emphasized how the increase in the number of legal statutes makes the law impractical to apply in every case, so that Sheehe has calculated that only one offence in every 7,600 is detected (see Dix and Layzell 1983: 7). 
 It is organizationally impractical because of the lack of capacity and resource in the police to deal with the resulting offenders. 
 Nor could the courts cope, and there would be a deterioration in the public's perception of the police as a result of the disjuncture with lay conceptions of legality. 
 As a constable at Easton  explained, &bquo;I could stand at that comer there and catch a hundred people breaking some law or other in one shift, no bother. 
 But you just couldn't book everyone you saw infringing some minor law or other. 
 Not only would you not have the time to deal with them all, but you'd be harassing the public and getting the police a bad name&equo; (FN 23/4/87, p. 2). 
 This lends further significance to the distinction Easton's section police make between &bquo;big&equo; and &bquo;little&equo; crime. 
 However, this strength is also a weakness. 
 While discretion filters out from the legal process all minor and inconsequential infringements of the law, what counts as minor can rest on the whims and prejudices of individual officers and lead to inconsistent and unequal practice. 
 Yet studies of police discretion also emphasize how its operation is structured, so that to a great extent its use becomes standardized, although individual whim cannot be ignored entirely. 
 While there are formal rules by which discretion is effected, research shows that the primary means for standardizing its operation is the set of informal on-the-job rules of thumb developed within the occupational culture of the police. 
 Hence it can be determined by practical considerations arising from the organization of police work, such as the time of the shift, the approach of shift change-over, the time of the year, considerations about overtime, and the dislike of paperwork (Gardner 1969: 132; Holdaway 1980: 59, 1983: 57). 
 But there also appears to be what Phillipson, drawing on Cicourel, would call &bquo;basic interpretative rules&equo; (Phillipson 1972: 148), which the police employ when making practical decisions of this sort: the reasonableness of the offender's excuse (Ericson 1982: 147), and whether or not offenders display deference (Black 1970: 1101; Dix and Layzell 1983: 73; Sykes and Clark 1975). 
 This is what Smith and Vischer (1981) have in mind when they emphasize the &bquo;situational determinants&equo; of &bquo;street-level justice&equo;. 
 These factors are also important to Easton's section police. 
 For example, it was noticeable how infringements were treated more leniently at times of ritual celebration, such as at Christmas, New Year, and on &bquo;11th Night&equo;, when Protestants in working-class districts light bonfires on the eve of the Orange Order parades on 12 July. 
 Notions of ritual celebration can also be invoked to override the effect of a person's lack of respect towards the police. 
 When the motivation of younger constables leads to offences being treated seriously, older or more dominant constables often use the celebration as a reason for discretion, especially in relation to drink-related  offences. 
 For example, on 11th Night a vehicle was called to some youths at a bonfire near to a middle-class suburban area, and a young recruit was keen to act, but an older constable urged against it: 
 PC. 1. 
 Let them stay. 
 They're not doing any harm. 
 PC. 2. 
 You're going to end up going back up there, you know. 
 PC. 1. 
 If we move them on to the street, there'll be more trouble. 
 You're better off leaving them there, for Christ's sake. 
 It's the 11th Night. 
 PC. 2. 
 Aye, you try telling that to these people round here. 
 PC. 1. 
 What's wrong with these people? 
 Do they know about the 11th Night, New Year's Eve, and things like that? 
 (FN 11/7/87, p. 7) 
 The youths were not moved on. 
 This is an example of what Cain (1973) calls the &bquo;instructional attitude&equo; which senior constables adopt in relation to probationers, passing on not just a knowledge of law but of the situations in which to apply it. 
 However, the time of year is less important than the time of the shift. 
 Towards the shift's close, ordinary policemen and women are generally reluctant to become involved in work which requires them to extend their duty, unless they need the overtime money, in which case it is a spur. 
 The extra money earned from attending court on a day off can be attractive, but it is more often the case that reminders about the approaching end of the shift are given to those constables who suggest work which involves &bquo;going over&equo;. 
 As a consequence, they dislike having to attend incidents at this time which are so serious that action cannot be avoided. 
 One of the most important variables which structures the operation of discretion is whether the offender shows &bquo;the right attitude&equo;. 
 This is described as the factor which &bquo;means everything&equo; to the decision about whether or not to proceed. 
 So standardized is it that it is widely called &bquo;the attitude test&equo; (a phrase also used by American police, see van Maanen 1978), and when stopping members of the public constables are routinely instructed by colleagues to give the potential offender &bquo;the attitude test&equo;. 
 To pass it one has to be &bquo;dead on&equo;: polite, deferential, and avoid the use of foul language. 
 One policeman from an area outside Easton once stated that he had &bquo;sort of fixed it&equo; for a lorry driver who had run over a lady's leg because &bquo;the lady wasn't very nice but the lorry driver was dead on&equo; (FN 22/2/87, p. 1). 
 What the &bquo;fixing&equo; amounted to we can only guess. 
 However, there were occasional instances where the &bquo;right attitude&equo; was undercut by two other interpretative processes which  are crucial to the operation of discretion: the typifications used to classify the potential offender and the &bquo;reasonableness of the excuse&equo;. 
 For example, a woman who over the phone sounded to one policeman as &bquo;dead on&equo; still had a complaint against her noisy dogs investigated because the complainant appeared to another policeman not to be &bquo;spinning a yarn&equo; (FN 19/9/87, p. 29). 
 Similarly, having the wrong attitude is a constituent part of being a &bquo;gouger&equo;, but there were a few situations when the subsequent application of the gouger typification late into the encounter undercut the effect of the politeness of the offender, and the deference displayed was less important than the knowledge that later led to the use of the typification. 
 The gouger typification is important to discretion in another way. 
 To know someone to be a gouger gives some policemen and women cause to believe that they have the excuse to ignore the minor requests for assistance that the person may make, and for his or her minor infringements of the law to be taken seriously. 
 As one policeman remarked after a gouger had been treated leniently by a judge, &bquo;Right, we'll get him for every wrong move he makes&equo; (FN 9/3/87, p. 8). 
 More frequently, the decision to take no action over an individual's request for assistance is influenced by whether or not the individual acts in ways typical of a gouger, in part by showing the wrong attitude. 
 For example, one night a youth with distinct working-class dress and accent walked into the station: 
 PC. 1. 
 We called on you earlier tonight, didn't we? 
 MAN. 
 Aye, you did, but you see, there's this girl in my house and she won't leave and I'm asking you if you'll come down and shift her. 
 PC. 1. 
 You told us earlier that she was your girlfriend. 
 Now you want us to throw her out. 
 MAN. 
 Yes, that's correct. 
 Are you saying that you're refusing to do that?&hellip; 
 Could I have your number? 
 PC. 1. 
 Take yourself away off. 
 Have you been drinking? 
 Did you drive here? 
 MAN.No. 
 PC. 1. 
 You better not be driving. 
 MAN. 
 Are you refusing to come round and remove this girl? 
 PC. 1. 
 Didn't we call earlier and you told us she was your girlfriend? 
 MAN. 
 Could you give me your number there? 
 You're refusing to come round, is that right?  
 PC. 1. 
 Yes&hellip; 
 The door's that way. 
 PC. 2. 
 Don't you be getting into a car, now. 
 WPC. 
 Did you see her earlier? 
 PC. 1. 
 Aye, some wee slut. 
 PC. 2. 
 He's probably give her one and now he wants rid of her. 
 (FN 6/6/87, pp. 15&ndash;16) 
 The reasonableness of the individual's excuse is also important in structuring the operation of discretion. 
 There is considerable sympathy for members of the public who commit some minor infringement under circumstances which are considered justifiable and understandable. 
 This not only involves a mutual understanding of the common-sense notions in everyday life about what counts as an excuse, it requires that constables put themselves in the position of the offender to test whether they would have done the same. 
 Sympathy with the person involved is often mentioned as the reason for cautioning someone rather than charging them. 
 For example, emotional problems are often presented as justification for a person's drunkenness, especially if they are female, and on one occasion a youth who had been involved in an accident but who had only just passed his driving test was let off with a caution by a policewoman in sympathy for his inexperience. 
 Sensitive leniency is not the only principle operating, however, for constables also need to avoid being &bquo;taken for a ride&equo; by an unrealistic excuse which makes them look foolish. 
 For example, a car was stopped for speeding or &bquo;flying low&equo;, and upon returning to the police vehicle the constable related the following considerations which influenced his assessment: 
 Wait till ya hear this one. 
 The guy says he was in a hurry to get home because he has to get up at six tomorrow morning because he's donating some of his bone marrow so that his sister can have a bone marrow transplant&hellip; 
 Like, I didn't know whether to believe him or not, but you'd feel wick if he wasn't spoofing, so I let him off with a caution. 
 D'ya think the City Hospital would do bone marrow transplant? 
 I'm going to check it out anyway and if he's lying I'm going to do him. 
 (FN 28/3/87, p. 14) 
 The constable did investigate the incident and proudly told colleagues later how his discretion and instinct had proved correct: the man was telling the truth. 
 Assessments of what is reasonable are therefore contextually specific to the incident and the people involved, the contents of the  excuse, and the particular constables concerned. 
 These assessments are what ethnomethodologists call &bquo;situationally justified action&equo;, and they have a reflexive character, for the contextually justified nature of the person's action provides the situational justification for the conduct of the police (also see Smith and Vischer 1981). 
 Thus, for example, it was excusable for a pretty young girl to avoid wearing a seat-belt because she had been topping up her tan on the sun bed and got burnt, for two middle-class school children to ride their bikes without lights late at night because they were trying to stay up on their last might of the summer holidays, and for lads to urinate in the street because they had three miles to walk home. 
 Certain types of individual tend to get treated more leniently, such as part-time members of the security forces, firemen, and members of the Territorial Army, although pulling status does not always work. 
 It needs to be done subtly, for flashing a TA card or immediately mentioning membership of the police reserve, for example, incenses some regular police. 
 Other factors also seem relevant. 
 Their infringement should not be serious, and some considerations can undercut the status, such as managerial instructions warning against this form of discretion, or knowledge about past contact with the police. 
 At one time during field-work the traffic police became more unpopular than usual because they were under instruction not to let police colleagues off minor traffic violations. 
 Quite often all these sorts of considerations interact to influence the operation of discretion, as illustrated by the following incident, which concerned a road traffic accident (an RTA) towards the end of a shift. 
 A call came over the radio for us to go to a RTA. 
 PC. 1. 
 Yo, it's too late to be going to a accident. 
 It took us a good while to get to the location. 
 There was a group of four youths. 
 The car was bashed in &lsqb;but&rsqb; there were no injuries. 
 &lsqb;PC. 1.&rsqb; 
 was very sympathetic. 
 He turned to &lsqb;name of another policeman&rsqb;. 
 PC. 1. 
 You couldn't really call this an accident, could ya. 
 PC. 2. 
 Na, no damage except to his vehicle. 
 &lsqb;PC. 1.&rsqb; 
 turned to the youth. 
 PC. 1. 
 Is this your car? 
 YOUTH. 
 No, my dad owns it. 
 &lsqb;PC. 1.&rsqb; 
 pursed his lips and shook his head sympathetically. 
 He then came  over to &lsqb;a WPC&rsqb; to tell her it wasn't really an accident. 
 He then explained to the youth, 
 PC. 1. 
 Technically speaking as long as nobody was hurt, no injuries, no damage to the other vehicle, this is not an accident. 
 The insurance should fix it, though. 
 &lsqb;PC. 1.&rsqb; 
 then went over to &lsqb;the wpc&rsqb; again. 
 He shrugged as he said, 
 PC. 1. 
 Because there's no damage to property here, there's no reason to act under the Road Traffic Act. 
 Technically this isn't an accident, so its not reportable. 
 WPC. 
 Yeh, you're right&hellip; 
 That's easy enough done on s narrow bend like that one. 
 I've nearly had an accident there myself rushing to get to work on earlies. 
 (FN 19/9/87, pp. 44&ndash;6) 
 The constables were keen to display to the field-worker that they knew the appropriate law to apply and that the law gave formal justification to their decisions, but there were a variety of other factors which facilitated this sensitive interpretation of the law. 
 It is clear from the conversation that there was sympathy for the person involved because it was easy for them to place themselves in that position, allowing the event to be normalized. 
 This made the accident appear reasonable, something which even they could have done. 
 This reasonableness was further reinforced by the absence of any hint of the person adopting &bquo;the wrong attitude&equo;. 
 It was also close to the end of the shift and this legal reduction prevented them having to &bquo;go over&equo;, as well as getting them out of considerable paperwork later, and road traffic accidents are particularly disliked because of the amount of paperwork they involve. 
 There was also no possibility of come-back from other parties: only one vehicle was involved, and the occupants could be satisfied because the insurance would take care of the damage. 
 As the saying goes in the sociology of policing, they had &bquo;covered their ass&equo;. 
 Moreover, in terms of formal managerial rules, the incident could be shown to have been dealt with in terms of the letter of the law. 
 So the situationally justified actions of the constables had the same effect as the rules of the formal bureaucracy, although this outcome was reproduced in informal and symbolic ways (on the notion of bureaucracy as symbol see Jacobs 1969; for other examples of ethnomethodological and phenomenological accounts of organization and rule-following see Bittner 1965; Johnson 1972; Manning 1982; Zimmerman 1970, 1971).  
 CONCLUSION 
 The thrust of the last two chapters has been to demonstrate the ordinariness of policing in Easton. 
 Ordinariness is meant in several senses. 
 The research design was not intended to display how ordinary Easton's police are as people, although the topics about which they talk show a concern with the same mundane things as other people &mdash; family, sport and leisure, television, sex, work, overtime and the bosses, the in-laws, friends, the cost of living, holidays, pregnancies, the house and DIY, politics, and so on. 
 But their ordinariness as policemen and women is indisputable. 
 The previous arguments have pointed to two ways in which policing in Easton is ordinary. 
 Police duties in Easton are similar to those in non-divided societies, and the manner in which these tasks are viewed and accomplished parallels that elsewhere. 
 The routineness of police work in Easton is thus reinforced by the interpretative processes and practical reasoning that Easton's police share with policemen and women in other societies when doing routine police work. 
 However, these claims suggest a third way in which policing in Easton is ordinary. 
 It is clear from the nature of police work in the district that the relations the police have with the public in this largely Protestant area parallel those that police forces have in societies where religion is not a social marker. 
 There are the honest and decent people of Easton, and then the &bquo;gougers&equo;, &bquo;mouths&equo;, and other trouble-makers, with whom the police have as problematic a relationship as do all police forces with miscreants. 
 The social divisions within Northern Ireland society have little direct effect on the nature of crime in Easton, which influences the nature of routine police work in the area, enabling the police to pursue Easton's crime and criminals without recourse to religion. 
 These social divisions have other effects, as we shall emphasize later, but they have very little influence on the duties which comprise routine police work, so that routine policing is largely unaffected by religion. 
 Hence the attitudes that section police have towards Easton's &bquo;gougers&equo;, virtually all of whom are Protestant, are typical of those that policemen and women everywhere have towards criminals. 
 The reverse equally applies, for the remarks which some of Easton's Protestant residents express about the police reveal attitudes towards them which are typical of many working-class groups in urban areas in non-divided societies. 
 They are frequently  referred to as &bquo;black bastards&equo;, or some variant thereof, by young Protestant children. 
 As one policeman complained, 
 See, the other week there, I was on beat duty and this wee nipper, couldn't have been more than 6 or 7, came round the corner and says to me, &bquo;Fuck off, ya black bastard.&equo; 
 Like, a kid of that age. 
 Next thing his sister, about 13 or so, came round. 
 I says to her what he &lsqb;her brother&rsqb; said, and you know what she said? 
 &bquo;So what, nothing wrong with that, that's what ya are, isn't it?&equo; 
 Like, what do you do? 
 I remember when I was a kid, you daren't say &bquo;boo&equo; to a peeler. 
 See, kids nowadays. 
 (FN 30/3/87, p. 17) 
 Like policemen and women everywhere Easton's section police bemoan the deterioration in the attitude to authority shown by some youngsters. 
 Referring to his upbringing in the Protestant Shankill area, another said, &bquo;I remember when I was a kid, if you seen a policeman you'd run, nowadays kids are more likely to tell you to fuck off&equo; (FN 23/10/87, p. 18). 
 Reflecting considerable animosity toward the police, a 12-year-old once attacked one of Easton's policewomen with a chair. 
 It is not just children who have this animosity. 
 Some adults use very foul language to describe the police. 
 On one occasion during field-work a father who needed to be present while his young son was being questioned at the station instructed his child to &bquo;Tell these f'ing black bastards nothin'&equo;, and when told that that was a lovely way to bring up his son replied, &bquo;Aye, and I'll keep bringing him up that way&equo; (FN 11/7/87, p. 9). 
 Whatever attitudes Protestants in Easton might have towards the police because of Northern Ireland's social and political divisions, these are undercut by the police's pursuit of crime and its perpetrators, so that some Protestant in Easton encounter the police in situations which encourage negative views as a result of the ordinary criminal activity they engage in. 
 The police are aware of how problematic their relationship is with certain sections of Easton's population, irrespective of religion. 
 Thus, offenders who invoke their Protestant religion as a means of justifying some action get short shrift, although we came across only one instance where this was done. 
 A man gave the police a two-fingered gesture and upon being stopped exclaimed, &bquo;I'm a Prod, I'm on your side.&equo; 
 He received an official caution, being described as &bquo;your typical gouger&equo; (FN 26/5/87, p. 2). 
 Because these negative views are rooted in the ordinary nature of crime in Easton, they pre-date the deterioration in the relationship  between Protestants and the RUC following the Anglo-Irish Agreement. 
 Upon being asked about this, one policeman explained, &bquo;To tell you the truth I didn't notice much of a difference. 
 Like, this estate here, the people here have always been hostile towards the police as long as I can remember. 
 Its always been the same&equo; (FN 30/11/87, p. 16). 
 Hence, the folk model of policing in Northern Ireland, which reduces policing to the political containment of Catholics, does not apply in Easton. 
 Because of this, community policing is an important part of the work of Easton's police, and the next chapter focuses on this mode of routine policing.  
 Community and Neighbourhood Policing 
 INTRODUCTION 
 Community policing was once the normal form of policing in the United Kingdom, but the increasingly bureaucratic and professional nature of policing unintentionally yet progressively separated the police from the community, leading to more anonymous and impersonal contacts between them (see Ericson 1982: 24). 
 A study of crime in London's inner cities in the 1980s painted a gloomy picture of how &bquo;ordinary policing&equo;, as it was termed, was fast diminishing, with the police becoming alienated and marginalized from the community and increasingly reliant on high-profile strategies of crime control which destroyed the principle of consensus policing (Kinsey et al . 
 1986). 
 It is in this general climate that community policing has been reintroduced in recent years in many forces in Great Britain with the expressed intention of improving both crime prevention and relations between the police and the community (cf. Gordon 1987). 
 It is also now widely practised in Sweden (see Knutsson and Partanen 1986), Camada, New Zealand, and the United States of America (Trojanowicz and Harden 1985). 
 In the United States there is an extensive research programme on neighbourhood policing based at the University of Michigan, and considerable interest is shown by the federal and central governments. 
 Trojanowicz, Director of the National Neighbourhood Foot Patrol Centre in Michigan, is so enthusiastic that he has claimed that community policing can help in the policing of international terrorism (Trojamowicz 1988). 
 Community policing is a preventive rather than a crime control made of policing and in the United Kingdom it has become associated in the popular image particularly with those inner-city areas where crime rates have risen sharply and where police relations with  ethnic minorities have deteriorated, although it is also a response to the police's loss of contact with other sections of the community, especially young people (Schaffer 1980). 
 Similar experiences motivated its reintroduction in the United States (Trojanowicz et al . 
 1987: 30). 
 The interest which this shift in police policy provoked was considerable. 
 The Policy Studies Institute devoted a volume in their study of London's police to area police officers (1983b), and in 1981 the Home Office began a research initiative on beat policemen (for some of the results see Brown and Iles 1985; Grimshaw and Jefferson 1987; Morris and Heal 1981). 
 In addition, the ESRC has funded studies of liaison committees established upon a recommendation from the Scarman Report into the Brixton disturbances as forums for consultation between the police and representatives of the local community, and also funded Fielding's study of community policing in South London. 
 John Alderson made a case for the reintroduction of community policing in 1982 (Alderson 1982, also see 1979), but its advantages were recognized much earlier when the House of Commons Select Committee on Race Relations examined relations between the police and ethnic minorities in 1972, and in 1976 a report from the National Police College placed a central emphasis upon it (Pope 1976). 
 But, as Weatheritt noted, amid all this, there is considerable confusion over what analysts mean by the concept &bquo;community policing&equo; (Weatheritt 1983; also see Hartmann et al . 
 1988; Trojamowicz and Moore 1988). 
 It has been loosely referred to as any mode of policing other than the rapid-response crime control type; an alternative which specifically seeks to make constables part of the community by making them responsible for a geographical area, known as &bquo;permanent&equo; or &bquo;home&equo; beats; a means of developing communication between the police and the local community; and a process by which responsibility for crime control and prevention is shared with the community, both also known as &bquo;community relations&equo; (Weatheritt 1983: 4&ndash;5). 
 We take community policing to be a style which emphasizes the development of good relations between police and community, normally via active police involvement in, and contact with, the local community, and by deploying manpower in such a way that officers patrol a &bquo;beat&equo; on foot in order to build up familiarity with the local area. 
 In the RUC the former is known as community relations and the latter neighbourhood policing  although in many other forces both go under the rubric of community policing. 
 The societal divisions and problems of relations between the police and the community which this style of policing is called upon to ameliorate in Northern Ireland are more severe than is normally the case, which makes the RUC's implementation and operation of community policing of special interest and previous neglect of this aspect of policing in the province a significant oversight. 
 In the context of the folk model of policing in Northern Ireland, the RUC's commitment to, and implementation of, community policing becomes an important test of the reality lying behind the commonsense image. 
 In fact, so committed is RUC management to the principle of community policing that, in addition to specialist units, the new code of professional ethics specifies that it is the duty of all policemen and women to understand &bquo;those particular community needs and problems which can cause concern and friction&equo;, and be sensitive to &bquo;the various public viewpoints, including historical and cultural backgrounds&equo;. 
 The code states that the RUC 
 must be responsive to the needs and problems of the community it serves. 
 Good relations with the community are one of the most important prerequisites to the successful discharge of a policeman's duty and it is incumbent upon all members to avail of every opportunity to help reconcile and heal the visions in the community. 
 Read in this way, community policing in Northern Ireland seems designed exclusively to improve relations between the police and Catholics, but it is much wider than this for it is also employed in Protestant t areas like Easton, where the existence of &bquo;ordinary crime&equo; ensures that the police are keen to improve crime prevention by better relations with the public generally. 
 This latter intent is evidenced by the number of constables responsible for crime control in Protestant areas who see their role as also having social-welfare and community service dimensions, as illustrated in the last chapter, and, more significantly, by the fact that there are units in Easton specifically responsible for community policing in this largely Protestant district. 
 In Northern Ireland's divided society therefore, community policing has both a specific and a general meaning, for in one sense it focuses narrowly on overcoming Catholic hostility to the police, while in another the &bquo;community&equo; which is addressed is defined more broadly to encompass all residents in the province, although often these two aspects intermingle.  
 However, previous studies in the sociology of policing stress that, irrespective of the management's goals in introducing some innovation, there is often a disjuncture between official organizational policy and its implementation by ordinary constables. 
 For example, Manning (1977) showed how policemen and women in the ranks have an ability to bypass or undermine innovations introduced by police managers, some even doing so while appearing to endorse the policy change (Chatterton 1979). 
 Holdaway (1977) documented the difficulties police managers in Hilton had in overcoming wellaccepted practices in order to introduce more professional police practice in the form of unit beat policing. 
 While advocates of community policing express confidence in its ability to effect improvements (Alderson 1979, 1982; Scarman 1981), research contradicts this by pointing to resistance from those constables who are responsible for it or to organizational constraints (Fielding et al . 
 1988; Grimshaw and Jefferson 1987; Trojanowicz and Harden 1985), although there are a number of other studies which emphasize its success in overcoming public hostility to the police (Brown and Iles 1985; McKane 1980; cf. Cumberbatch 1983, Taylor-Griffiths 1988). 
 Nor is the idea of community policing popular amongst ordinary constables in other sections of the police, often because it contradicts their views of what constitutes &bquo;real&equo; police work, but also because they have misguided notions about what community policing is, as well as a practical awareness of the unrealistic expectations held of it by enthusiasts. 
 In the RUC, for example, a group of policemen and women taking a police studies degree were asked their opinions on community policing, and the following remarks are typical: 
 What gets me about this guy Alderson is that he served in the country area of Cornwall, and he makes all these proposals about inner-city policing; now how the hell would he know anything about the inner city? 
 All this community policing stuff is all very well, but has it worked? 
 I don't think these guys know what they're talking about. 
 I've been involved in community projects and I can say I enjoy going into schools, but at the end of the day there will always need to be the regulated type of policing of crime and violence. 
 You talking about going out on the streets, it doesn't get them anywhere half the time. 
 If you go into a youth club, they don't want you. 
 Although you may be at some bar or club with the community interest at heart, people don't look at you like that. 
 People think you could be there waiting to arrest them for drinking and driving in the car park. 
 (FN 20/11/86, pp. 1&ndash;3) 
 This chapter is intended to illustrate the operation of community policing in Easton, and in the process to assess the commitment given it by the ordinary policemen and women who carry it out, looking separately at the units responsible for community relations and neighbourhood policing. 
 Some comparisons will then be made with community policing in West Belfast. 
 SOME ORGANIZATIONAL ASPECTS OF COMMUNITY POLICING IN EASTON 
 One of the problems Brown and Iles discovered in their study of community constables (what, in the RUC, would be called neighbourhood constables), which was based on 300 officers in five police forces in England, was the relatively small proportion of working time devoted to activities the primary purpose of which was improvement in relations between the police and the public through direct involvement of constables in the community (Brown and Iles 1985: 29). 
 Only 14 per cent of their time was directed to &bquo;community relations&equo;, the bulk of which amounted to &bquo;informal contacts&equo; with members of the public (p. 19). 
 General administrative duties and time withdrawn from the beat together accounted for over half of the working day (p. 17). 
 In another study, however, the time given to &bquo;community contact&equo; by community constables in one area each of Surrey and inner London was estimated at 45 per cent, compared to 4 per cent for regular officers, although even here more time was devoted to dealing with offences than community relations (Fielding et al . 
 1988). 
 Crime prevention and control therefore assumed greater importance for community constables than contact with the local community. 
 In the RUC these two aspects of community policing are separated operationally and administratively. 
 Hence neighbourhood police cam deal with offences and develop a familiarity with their local area, knowing that the formal aspects of community relations, such as involvement with youth clubs, schools, and community groups, is being shared with people whose special responsibility this is. 
 Nor does the RUC consider these aspects of community policing to be scarce resources, thus there is no restriction on their deployment to those limited number of areas where there are particular problems,  as often happens in Great Britain (Brown and Iles 1985: 10). 
 The RUC also affords community and neighbourhood policemen and women the optimal organizational conditions necessary for effective policing, identified by Fielding et al . 
 (1988) as autonomy in such things as decision-making, the formulation of priorities and office accommodation, separate low-level officers, and managerial support. 
 Thus the Community Relations and Neighbourhood Units in Easton each have their own offices and their own sergeants (but not inspector), are free from the obligation of responding to logged calls from central control, and can decide for themselves their priorities and programmes. 
 There is a chief superintendent in RUC Headquarters whose sole responsibility is community relations, and no complaints were made about the level of managerial support given them by Easton's senior officers, something unusual for ordinary policemen and women in the RUC, and particularly so compared to community policing sections in other forces (Grimshaw and Jefferson 1987). 
 EASTON'S COMMUNITY RELATIONS UNIT 
 Community relations in Easton is divided into two parts. 
 There are the more restricted duties of juvenile liaison, which deals with young offenders and their families, and the general community relations work amongst juveniles and community groups connected with the young, such as schools and youth clubs (with the exception of the ubiquitous Christmas party for old folks). 
 It is therefore orientated towards the young and is not intended to provide adults with channels of communication with the police or forums for joint consultation. 
 This conditions how those responsible for community relations in Easton perceive its primary purposes and the time-scales they operate within. 
 Short-term benefits derive from crime prevention amongst the young and an improvement in their perception of the police, which it is hoped will have residual effects in the long term when they are adults, but the wider community in Easton is only addressed secondarily as parents or guardians, which limits the short-term effects the programme might have on improving its perception of the police. 
 Much of the criticism community relations attracts, especially from colleagues in the police, derives from a misunderstanding of these goals and time-scales and a consequent  failure to see that even its practitioners have clearly circumscribed expectations. 
 One of the traditional areas reserved for policewomen is work with juvenile and female offenders (Jones 1987; Southgate 1980), and juvenile liaison police in Easton are female, although other community relations police are male. 
 Two policemen are responsible for community relations and two policewomen for juvenile liaison, one each of whom is a sergeant. 
 The juvenile liaison policewomen, however, also carry out general community relations work, although the reverse is not the case, maintaining young offenders as a policewoman's preserve. 
 The fact that some policewomen carry out both sets of duties allows them to contrast the two types of community relations, with general community relations work being seen as &bquo;fun&equo; and juvenile liaison as more demanding and difficult. 
 This is a dichotomy which other police in Easton recognize, for a senior officer, with an obvious orientation towards crime control, once described the work with young offenders as &bquo;the real community work&equo; (FN 10/2/87, p. 11). 
 However, &bquo;fun&equo; does not translate for the community relations policemen as something opposite to work: the &bquo;fun&equo; is taken as a serious job of work. 
 As one explained in a conversation with the field-worker; 
 PC. 1. 
 I was talking to the boys &lsqb;members of the RUC&rsqb; and one says to me, &bquo;When do you start work, later on?&equo; 
 I says, &bquo;No, I'm on duty now.&equo; 
 Its funny you know, sometimes when I'm out at schools the kids will come up to me and say, &bquo;Do you have to go to work now?&equo; 
 I say, &bquo;This is work.&equo; 
 RESEARCHER. 
 Yes, it really is a pleasant job. 
 PC. 1. 
 Aye, but it's not very popular within the police, would you believe it? 
 RESEARCHER. 
 I suppose a lot of people think that's not what they joined the police for. 
 PC. 1. 
 Oh, but it is, that is what they joined the police for, to serve the community. 
 You see, all policemen have a community relations role. 
 Our job, of course, is a specialist one. 
 (FN 11/7/87, p. 2) 
 It would have been more accurate to say that all policemen and women &bquo;should have&equo; such a role, for unfortunately many do not (see Trojanowicz and Pollard 1986). 
 It was an attitude like this which made the individual transfer to community relations in the first place, as all those in Easton's Community Relations Unit did, one even from the Traffic Branch. 
 This self-selection process ensures that the Community Relations Branch  attracts people with enthusiasm and the necessary personal qualities which make them enjoy work with youngsters, and not one member of the Community Relations Branch we encountered in Easton and elsewhere expressed anything other than pleasure and enjoyment from working with youngsters. 
 Such enthusiasm makes them appear eccentric compared to policemen and women on the sections. 
 The marginality they experience within the force might lead them to exaggerate their job satisfaction, but this cuts both ways, for the unpopularity of community relations among many ordinary members of the RUC guarantees it will not appeal to any but the committed, and section duties already afford the work-shy many opportunities to hide. 
 Observed in operation on visits to schools, Easton's community relations police were quickly able to establish a rapport with the children and revelled in the joking and informal banter, although Easton is fortunate in having very experienced constables with long service in community relations, which is vital because a three-week course hardly qualifies as sufficient training. 
 The range of community relations programmes is impressively wide and is a further demonstration of imaginative commitment on the part of community relations police. 
 Annual holiday camps are held for boys and girls from poorer families who otherwise would not get away, with costs paid by the RUC; these are so popular that parents ring requesting that their children be allowed to go again. 
 Usually these are children from one-parent families, children in local-authority care, or youngsters who need a respite from the household chores they assume as surrogate adults because their parents are ill, and even, in some cases, children with a parent in prison, and are selected for inclusion in the scheme not by the police but by schools and other caring agencies. 
 Work is also done among the handicapped, and special camps are sometimes held for handicapped children. 
 The holiday camps are held separately for the different sexes, mirroring the gender segregation that occurs in the majority of Northern Ireland's schools, but another form of segregation in schooling which is not reproduced is that of religion, for the few Catholic schools that exist in the Easton area nominate participants. 
 This gives the scheme the additional bonus of crossing, no matter how fleetingly, the sectarian divide, so that the broad and narrow notions of community relations within the RUC coincide. 
 The same is time for visits to schools and for the school quiz, where Catholic  schools are always paired on the same side as Protestant ones in order to facilitate, again momentarily, some intercommunal co-operation. 
 The few Catholic schools in the area frequently draw on the services offered by Easton's Community Relations Branch, as do most of the Protestant secondary schools. 
 Which schools the police visit depends entirely upon the head teachers, and little work is done with grammar schools. 
 This reflects the view of head teachers that what the police have to offer does not apply to their children rather than any unwillingness among the police to deal with middle-class children, or, even more preposterously, a belief that grammar school children present no problems in terms of juvenile crime. 
 The services on offer from the Community Relations Branch include the &bquo;blue lamp disco&equo;, a title evocative of George Dixon and consensus policing; the organization of disco-dancing competitions and football tournaments with children from other police divisions in Belfast; nature rambles; access to outward-bound centres, some in Great Britain, the cost of attendance being borne by the RUC; swimming lessons, including swimming for visually handicapped children; and the provision in schools of classes on first aid, safety, and law, and of other general campaigns aimed at children, like the &bquo;Say No To Strangers&equo; campaign. 
 These are taken very seriously by the community relations police, with children being required to write projects and do homework. 
 Considerable indignation was expressed by one constable when recalling an incident at which a colleague was assigned by a headmaster to merely the non-examination classes, feeling that their work in schools should not be marginalized in this way. 
 Community relations in Easton thus amounts to a programme of youth work, but juvenile liaison is altogether different, for it is basically probation work. 
 It involves visits to the homes of children who are either convicted offenders, children at special risk, or who have recently been involved in trouble and have come to the attention of the police. 
 In the latter case the policewoman has to write a report on the child for the superintendent to determine whether or not prosecution should follow. 
 But the overall commitment in community relations to crime prevention means that the main intention is to resolve problems to prevent further incidents and keep youngsters from court. 
 As one explained, &bquo;Well, what we try to do is basically to stop young people from getting into trouble, or prevent them, in other words we keep them out of court. 
 Well, that's what  we try to do, but you know you will get the perpetual troublemakers&equo; (FN 8/7/87, p. 9). 
 So, characteristic of the &bquo;style&equo; of community policing generally (see Fielding et al . 
 1988), the emphasis is placed upon defusing and resolving situations and avoiding arrest. 
 The preference is to end with an official caution or the less serious warning, but this depends upon &bquo;whether it is a first-time offender; the seriousness of the crime involved; the attitudes of both parents and juvenile; has reparation been made? 
 If a theft was involved were the goods given back? 
 Did the juvenile apologize? 
 And so on. 
 All this is taken into account&equo; (FN 9/2/87, p. 7). 
 Thus the operation of discretion by juvenile liaison officers is structured by much the same variables as with the section police: &bquo;It all depends upon their attitude.&equo; 
 Mostly it is successful in its aim, for the juvenile liaison police estimate that very few youngsters reappear before them. 
 But there are what they refer to as the &bquo;problem families&equo;. 
 Again, they operate with similar typifications of who constitute the troublesome clients, based partly on experience but also heavily influenced by stereotypes of the educationally subnormal, one-parent families, families in whom historically crime runs, and so on. 
 As Furlong noted with respect to teachers (1977: 163), their typifications of problem pupils were also heavily conditioned by specialist sociological knowledge (&bquo;from socially deprived families&equo;) or common-sense notions of psychoanalysis (&bquo;never had a father&equo;). 
 These stereotypes can become deployed to explain persistent offending among the young even when there is little evidence that they are appropriate. 
 Backgrounds can therefore be reconstructed for the &bquo;problem child&equo; in which their persistent offending becomes understandable. 
 The following is an extract from the field notes where the field-worker describes a conversation in which a juvenile liaison officer is explaining who typically is encountered in her work: 
 RESEARCHER. 
 Do you find that it is a particular type of child who tends to come up in front of you? 
 WPC. 
 Oh no. 
 All across the board, we get kids from every walk of life. 
 However, later on in the conversation she said they very rarely encountered juvenile offenders from grammar school, most would be educationally subnormal or at least well below average. 
 Citing the case of one of the juveniles whom I had encountered the previous week: 
 WPC. 
 See, that family, big thick file. 
 He's been in trouble since he was six, and his older brother, he's ESN too, he's worse. 
 RESEARCHER. 
 Have their parents got any sort of criminal record?  
 WPC. 
 I don't know, now the mother&hellip; 
 &lsqb;The WPC&rsqb; didn't commit herself, but added, 
 WPC. 
 I wouldn't be surprised about the mother. 
 See, this little fella here &lsqb;points to another file&rsqb; comes from a one-parent family. 
 Once he reached adolescence, just couldn't control him. 
 He's been at glue-sniffing, underage drinking. 
 He is s problem child. 
 (FN 9/2/87, p. 8) 
 Indeed, these stereotypes can be used to render obvious to outsiders the motivation and blame for particular incidents. 
 Referring to a case where grammar school children got drunk one night and began damaging cars and property, one of the juvenile liaison police said, &bquo;It was the old drink, like, that did it, but there was one from a local children's home. 
 He was the instigator. 
 I don't know how these boys got in with him but it was him who put them up to all this. 
 Anyway, the parents had to pay up&equo; (FN 9/2/87, p. 11). 
 Therefore, despite their separation from the section police in terms of office accommodation, duties, and self-conceptions of marginality, the interpretative processes that juvenile liaison use to accomplish their routine policing parallel the typifications and stereotypes common in the occupational culture of Easton station and among police forces in America and Great Britain. 
 NEIGHBOURHOOD POLICING IN EASTON 
 The RUC's positive commitment to returning policemen and women to the streets in order to overcome their distance from the community is revealed in three ways in Easton. 
 Occasionally, when manpower allows, men from the sections are assigned to beat duty and can walk anywhere within the Easton district in order to show a presence and look for minor crime. 
 Part-time reserve policemen and women also patrol the Easton area on foot, with no particular intention other than, as one policewoman described, &bquo;being seen on the streets&hellip; usually we just walk around&equo; (FN 7/9/87, p. 23). 
 With full-time day employment in an office, this part-time female reservist actually enjoyed outdoor beat work compared to those occasions when she did guard duty in the station. 
 Although the reservists come under the authority of the neighbourhood police sergeant, both forms of beat work involve little active community policing, save that which their presence alone ensures, and both require constables to respond to logged calls from central control when necessary. 
 The  main contribution to community policing comes in the form of the Neighbourhood Police Unit. 
 There are nine neighbourhood police in Easton, with their own sergeant, and they operate as two shifts. 
 Following the pattern of community constables in England, where the overwhelming majority are male (Brown and Iles 1985: 9), there are no females among Easton's neighbourhood constables, although for a short period the sergeant was female. 
 The shift times are designed to place policemen on the streets at times when they will encounter the maximum number of members of the public, even though this public thus tends to comprise shoppers and tradespeople. 
 With no might duty neighbourhood police usually avoid loitering youths, drunks, and other might people, something which at least one complained about, leaving these categories to the section or reserve police who possess in less proportion the skills required for effective community policing. 
 Each of these constables has his own separate patch, so that Easton's built-up areas are divided into nine beats. 
 The intention is for the policeman concerned to develop a local knowledge of his area, to show a presence and develop friendly and informal contact with members of the public, although one was adamant that his role remained primarily one of crime detection rather than prevention, this being the responsibility of community relations. 
 This view was not widely held, nor does it accord with the observational data on the men's practice while doing beat duty. 
 The neighbourhood police also provide extra manpower for the Community Relations Unit at special events in youth clubs or at camps. 
 One of the reasons why it might have been felt necessary in the field-worker's presence to define the neighbourhood role as primarily crime control is because, like community relations, the Neighbourhood Unit is aware that the section police see them as having an easy duty. 
 Neighbourhood men are often the butt of jokes among section police about their laziness, because what the neighbourhood police do does not seem to them like work, and certainly not &bquo;real&equo; police work. 
 Towards the end of field-work a constable newly transferred to the Neighbourhood Unit from one of the sections expressed his difficulties in adjusting to the new round of duties, stating that it was more difficult to pass the time because nothing seemed to happen (FN 17/12/87, p. 16): establishing informal contact with the public was not yet itself seen as doing police work and boredom was unappealing. 
 In contrast, by  accompanying experienced officers on their beat we saw how seriously they took neighbourhood policing and the range of duties which it comprised: job satisfaction is high among neighbourhood policemen (Trojamowicz and Banas 1985). 
 Neighbourhood police are supposed to spend as much time as possible per shift walking their beat, even taking tea-breaks at some appropriate place on the round, returning to the station only for their main meal break and when a criminal, such as a shoplifter, is apprehended, although this is rare. 
 There is the inevitable paperwork, but this is much less than for section police although, given the antipathy to paperwork in all police forces, it is surprising how the neighbourhood men welcome it on cold, wintry mornings. 
 Other stalling techniques are also deployed to detain them in the station on such days (prolonging station business, extended conversations in parts of the station where they are less visible to management, carrying messages, and so on). 
 But, as a general principle, Northern Ireland's social divisions ensure that police management prefer neighbourhood police to be on the street, as is their purpose, and in practice about three-quarters of the normal shift is taken up with beat duty, which is much higher than in Great Britain. 
 But there is a reverse to this, for wider security concerns require that neighbourhood men accomplish community policing equipped with at least a side-arm, sometimes more, flak jacket and baton, as well as personal radio. 
 For some calls they wear plain clothes, but mostly work is done in uniform, as it must be if neighbourhood policing is to work. 
 Moreover, each patch has to be walked by two men: one providing cover for the other while he polices his beat, so that each spends only half of the shift on their particular area. 
 While doing this the men are supposed to be separated by some distance in order to be able to call for radio assistance and to allow fire to be returned should one of them be attacked, and for the constable whose patch it is to become solely identified as the area's neighbourhood policeman. 
 However, where they feel safe from the management's glare and there is a low risk of being attacked, the men often walk the beat together, although this risk ensures they never call at premises together. 
 Towards the end of field-work, after a neighbourhood policeman had been murdered in another area, which up until then had been considered &bquo;soft&equo;, with no threat from terrorists, Easton's neighbourhood men began going out in threes, with two men providing cover, so that only a third of beat time was devoted to each neighbourhood  patch. 
 The observational data was collected at a time when the men went in pairs, but they expressed concern over how this latest development worked against effective community policing: 
 You never get talking to people, it's ridiculous. 
 If you go around in threes it's useless. 
 You never spend enough time on your own patch to get to know anyone. 
 And, like, one policeman going into a shop, you've a bit of a chace that on your own people will talk to you. 
 Two policemen, you've even less chance, but three&hellip; 
 (FN 16/11/87, p. 2) 
 This is indicative of how the development of local knowledge is seen by the neighbourhood men as a key measure of their competence and effectiveness, as it was with the section police. 
 As another said, &bquo;Being a neighbourhood man, you get to know all the people in the area to chat to them, and they know you to talk to and that&equo; (FN 28/4/87 p. 5). 
 Asked whether they feel they have developed this, all reply in the affirmative, so in order to evaluate neighbourhood policing in Easton it is necessary to consider observational data to assess how true this appears from their practice. 
 The busy periods for the neighbourhood unit reflect those of all policing &mdash; Thursdays to Saturdays &mdash; and accompanying them on beat duty on these days further illustrates the range of duties which comprise neighbourhood policing and some of the factors which structure it. 
 DOING BEAT DUTY 
 It is up to the discretion of the neighbourhood policemen whether or not they respond to incidents reported over the personal radio, although major occurrences such as bomb alerts and fights, tend to attract them, as well as incidents that are nearby. 
 There is also a formal element of crime detection, although in the normal course of events all they encounter is shoplifting and parking offences. 
 In order to deal with the latter, all carry with them a book of fixedpenalty tickets. 
 One neighbourhood policeman was known among colleagues (and some members of the public) for his proclivity for dispensing parking tickets. 
 This was something about which he was continually teased, as a means of exerting informal pressure on him to desist. 
 This was not always successful because of the autonomy neighbourhood police have while on the beat, and he told us, with some regret, that as a final resort he was instructed by the sergeant  not to take his book of fixed-penalty tickets with him when he was accompanied by the field-worker. 
 There is no insistence from management that a certain proportion of tickets be given every shift, so his behaviour was more a result of the way that he defined the role of neighbourhood policemen as having crime control responsibilities. 
 From observing the conduct of others on their beat, this appears not to be the majority view. 
 Most neighbourhood police place the emphasis upon community service and informal contact, giving out few parking tickets: developing friendly relations with the local residents is their greatest priority. 
 There are two sorts of contact with the public, and how those neighbourhood police who see themselves as having a service role attempt to engender friendly and informal relations depends upon the type of contact. 
 The first type is casual encounters along the beat, so that neighbourhood police pass friendly comments with whoever they happen to meet, such as people working in front gardens, the unemployed, customers in shops, old folks trying to cross busy roads, mothers with young children in push-chairs and prams, young children being especially appealing to the older family men who seem to predominate in the Neighbourhood Unit, only one of whom is not married. 
 They also feel obligated to deal as effectively as possible with whatever problems these casual encounters throw up, such as people asking advice about a summons or other aspects of the law, or about some official form which they are having difficulty in completing, how to get rid of obstructions on the pavement outside their house, or traffic obstructions. 
 There are also conspired encounters, where the neighbourhood police make a special point of visiting certain people, such as shopkeepers, and especially those new to the area, security guards in shopping centres, pensioners, especially those without the security of living in old-people's homes, youngsters in children's homes, and RUC widows in the vicinity. 
 This type of contact requires local knowledge and that the neighbourhood policeman take an interest in people in his area. 
 Witness the following extract from the field notes: 
 Turning down a street off &lsqb;place&rsqb;, &lsqb;neighbourhood policeman's name&rsqb; decided to call on another Old Age Pensioner. 
 Approaching the door he said to &lsqb;name of another neighbourhood policeman&rsqb;, who was about to knack, 
 PC. 1. 
 No, she's not up yet. 
 PC. 2. 
 How do you know that?  
 PC. 1. 
 'Cos once she's up she opens the porch door and leaves it open. 
 Sometimes she'll lie in until the afternoon. 
 Like, she's old, don't knock. 
 (FN 28/4/1987, p. 22) 
 Some of these contacts are conspired in order to facilitate crime prevention, this being particularly evident in visiting young offenders in local authority homes or shopping centres to ward off shoplifters. 
 These conspired contacts also provide excellent &bquo;mump holes&equo; (see Cain 1973: 37; Holdaway 1983: 43) or &bquo;brew houses&equo; in the men's own terms, where it is possible to take a tea-break, have a relaxing chat, hang about on a cold day, or simply &bquo;ease&equo; in other ways. 
 Visiting them at Christmas was particularly rewarding for the field-worker in order to see conspired contacts demonstrate the regard in which they held the neighbourhood police; of course, it was equally rewarding for the police. 
 But this type of contact also demonstrates that the neighbourhood police see themselves as having a welfare function. 
 For example, they call on the widows of policemen to check that the RUC Welfare Branch has visited, as well as trying themselves in more informal ways to help the grieving process, check that pensioners who are alone are safe, as well as take an interest in the youngsters new to children's homes. 
 This sympathetic, welfare-orientated role was illustrated well when the fieldworker accompanied two neighbourhood men to a local children's home. 
 The field notes describe the encounter thus: 
 A little boy appeared in the doorway. 
 The neighbourhood policeman attempted to speak to him but the child ran away. 
 PC. 1. 
 He's new, haven't seen him before. 
 ATTENDANT. 
 He only came in last week. 
 PC. 1. 
 What age is he?&hellip; 
 God, he's big for three. 
 ATTENDANT. 
 He's in here with his sister and another brother. 
 They were sexually abused. 
 PC. 2. 
 How could anyone abuse a wee child like that, I ask you. 
 PC. 1. 
 Isn't that terrible. 
 Subsequently a little girl appeared in the doorway with the little boy. 
 She spoke to &lsqb;the neighbourhood policeman&rsqb;. 
 GIRL. 
 Who are you? 
 PC. 1. 
 We're your friends.  
 GIRL. 
 No you're not. 
 You're not our friends. 
 PC. 1. 
 Yes we are, we come here and play games and watch TV and all. 
 What's your favourite TV programme? 
 The little girl answered and the conversation flowed between them for a while; the little boy didn't say anything. 
 Eventually the girl opened up and was very chatty, laughing at &lsqb;the neighbourhood policeman&rsqb; 's voice, as he was a comical sort, making his hat wobble on his head. 
 We were just about to leave when &lsqb;the girl&rsqb; called to &lsqb;the neighbourhood policemen&rsqb;. 
 GIRL. 
 You came to my house to see my Daddy, didn't you? 
 I remember. 
 We left shortly after this. 
 I mentioned to &lsqb;the neighbourhood policeman&rsqb; what &lsqb;the girl&rsqb; had said, who obviously associated them with the police who arrested her father. 
 PC. 1. 
 Aye, when she said that, I thought it was best to get off the subject. 
 Like, I'm sure that child's seen enough policemen in the past few weeks, you don't know what goes through kids' minds. 
 (FN 28/4/87, pp. 15&ndash;16) 
 The abrupt ending of the contact, therefore, seems to have reflected the policeman's sensitivity to the girl's feelings and a general sympathy towards her welfare, even though beforehand he had very competently overcome her initial resistance by showing a warm and friendly disposition. 
 The style of policing exemplified by this extract derives not only from the personal qualities of the people in the Neighbourhood Unit but also from the whole organizational climate in which they work. 
 It is the management's commitment to the principle of neighbourhood policing which affords Easton's unit the autonomy and time to devote themselves to work other than crime control. 
 Being free from the constraint of responding to logged calls and from the need to react quickly to one call after another gives the neighbourhood police the opportunity to engage in prolonged contact with the public. 
 In this way, the organizational climate interacts with the men's personal qualities to predispose the majority of them to define their role as one of community service. 
 But at the same time this form of contact can seem to other policemen and women as skiving, as even one member of the public described it to the field-worker (FN 17/12/87), p. 6), although such a caricature obscures the fact that the contact often has a more meaningful purpose. 
 Therefore &bquo;easing&equo;, which is normally presented as the opposite to work, can for the neighbourhood men (and also the community relations police) be construed as  official police work, and quite often much of the best community work is done by neighbourhood men when they seem to be relaxing. 
 In this context &bquo;easing&equo; has to be seen as a means to accomplishing routine community police work, not as an alternative to it. 
 This autonomy is jealously defended by neighbourhood policemen in Easton, who see it as an essential part of their job, as one was ruefully reminded after being transferred to the Traffic Branch. 
 &bquo;You were more your own boss in neighbourhood. 
 As a motor-cyclist you have to do all the jobs for everyone, deliver this, pick up that.&equo; 
 And holding up his pad of fixed-penalty tickets he went on, &bquo;You're also under pressure to give out a certain amount of these things&equo; (FN 17/12/87, p. 25). 
 The accompaniment to this autonomy is discretion. 
 As we saw in the last chapter, the operation of discretion by the police is a particular fascination in the sociology of policing, but discretion is often viewed narrowly in terms of law: whether the police apply or omit the letter of the law. 
 But it is also a more general process describing the interactive skills of policemen and women: the knowledge of when and in what situations it is appropriate to show sympathy, tolerance, and understanding rather than aggression and force. 
 It is not just because of their greater autonomy that discretion in both senses is very important to neighbourhood police. 
 Their responsibility for improving relations between police and public makes them sensitive to the disastrous effect that wrongly exercised discretion can have on the public's perception of the RUC. 
 Therefore, another essential quality in effective neighbourhood policing is using experienced officers who have familiarity on the beat. 
 As one described it, neighbourhood policing requires constables who know that &bquo;All you learn in the classroom is what your powers are&equo;, and that &bquo;You don't learn about the real facts of police work until you're out actually doing it&equo;, and that you cannot afford to be &bquo;heavy-handed&equo;. 
 The following is an extract of conversation in which an experienced neighbourhood constable is talking while out on his beat about discretion, in which its exercise is linked to both the development of local knowledge and the possession of interactive skills: 
 RESEARCHER. 
 You know all the people? 
 PC. 1. 
 You'd nearly know them all in your particular patch. 
 RESEARCHER. 
 I suppose you'd know the trouble-makers as well? 
 PC. 1. 
 Aye, you do that, you get to know the trouble-makers and especially  how to deal with them&hellip; 
 Policing differs from town to town, from country to country. 
 When you're a policeman, if something comes up you deal with it yourself. 
 Like, if you came across some boys drinking in that driveway &lsqb;pointing to a small car park&rsqb;, like, first of all you'd just say, &bquo;Come on boys, you'll have to move on, built-up area and all that.&equo; 
 And, like, most of them will move on and that's the end of it, but, like, you can get the real bad ones. 
 RESEARCHER. 
 And how do you deal with them? 
 PC. 1. 
 Well, they're the ones who give you the backchat. 
 They give you any backchat, you take them in. 
 The thing about being a neighbourhood policeman is the way you police your beat. 
 Not everyone is suited to neighbourhood policing. 
 You get these boys in the sections and they're over-exuberant, heavy-handed boys. 
 (FN 28/4/87, pp. 5&ndash;6) 
 To echo the themes of the last chapter, a part of a policeman's discretion is, in Schutzian terminology, knowing which &bquo;recipes&equo; to apply to which members of the public in what situations. 
 As the constable quoted above makes clear, it is not that all neighbourhood policemen defuse every situation by the display of patience, sympathy, tolerance, and understanding, it is more that this is their first choice and they use other recipes, by becoming &bquo;heavy-handed&equo; and resorting to arrests, only when this one fails. 
 The skill, then, is in knowing which situations to handle with &bquo;kid gloves&equo;, as another put it. 
 Unfortunately no situations arose during field-work where the neighbourhood police were required to use these secondary recipes, although one did state how sympathetic he felt towards adolescents in parts of Easton because &bquo;they don't stand a chance&equo; there, a feeling which easily translates into sympathetic handling of situations in which youths are involved. 
 Another important component of the competence of neighbourhood police is knowing the answer to the conundrum of what to do when nothing cam be done. 
 That is, how to convey to members of the public that their request or complaint is taken seriously even though it is impossible to act upon it. 
 Many of these situations arose in the course of field-work. 
 In casual encounters with neighbourhood police while on the beat, members of the public complained of such things as the life-style of next-door neighbours, noisy traffic, and parked lorries. 
 While this demonstrates the public's faith that the police can resolve any situation, the neighbourhood police are thereby presented with a dilemma: they either criminalize formally legal behaviour or disappoint public expectations. 
 The observational  data show that Easton's neighbourhood police have two recipes for resolving this dilemma and its associated conundrum. 
 The first is deflexion, where the problem is diplomatically passed on to someone else, sometimes neighbouring police stations, for neighbourhood men dislike straying into other patches, but also the DHSS and, most frequently, the council. 
 However, the more popular recipe is empathy, achieved by having the patience to allow the complainant sufficient time to air the problem (reinforcing the importance of allowing neighbourhood police autonomy to manage their own time), coupled with displays of sympathy, understanding, and even agreement. 
 This defuses the immediate intensity of the problem even though the law cannot act to correct it. 
 The phrase that the law is an ass, because it falls to cover the circumstance, is a common pairing lime on the part of the neighbourhood men in situations like this. 
 On one occasion two neighbourhood men were asked to account for their handling of a complaint about parked lorries, at which the field-worker was present, and they described the substance of this recipe as follows: 
 PC. 1. 
 See, like, you can understand it too, that woman gets no peace. 
 There's lorries out there the whole day, like. 
 But, see, that woman, she's a frequent complainer, complains about everything. 
 She hasn't stopped complaining since that shopping centre went up, but, like, with people like that all you can do is listen and sympathize. 
 There's not much else you can do, like, if a law's not being broken you can't do anything. 
 PC. 2. 
 Some people think that the police can do everything under the sun like, but of course you can't. 
 Half the time you're just a ear to listen to them. 
 It takes a certain type of man to do a neighbourhood beat. 
 (FN 28/4/87, p. 11) 
 A process of practical reasoning amongst neighbourhood men such as this is, therefore, also vital to the accomplishment of effective community policing. 
 COMMUNITY AND NEIGHBOURHOOD POLICING IN WEST BELFAST 
 The management's dilemma with respect to neighbourhood policing in Northern Ireland is that, while communal divisions make it a particularly important style of policing, the people who carry it out on the streets are more identifiable and softer targets for terrorists. 
  This translates as a real problem for neighbourhood policemen, even in Easton, for the ever likely prospect of attack has to be adjusted to and lived with if the day-to-day tasks of neighbourhood policing are to be accomplished. 
 A subsequent chapter will address the question of how this threat is routinized by members of the RUC generally, but at this juncture it is worth considering how the management's dilemma leads them to organize community and neighbourhood policing in an area like West Belfast, where attack is imminent. 
 We were given some opportunity to explore this when making three visits to police stations in West Belfast, although the data on community policing are unsatisfactory because of the limited number of these contacts and the absence of supportive observational material. 
 But it is none the less interesting as a conclusion to this chapter to draw contrasts, albeit impressionistically, with community policing in West Belfast, for this puts Easton's community policing into sharp relief. 
 The primary emphasis in community policing in West Belfast is on neighbourhood policing. 
 In this area it is entirely focused on the specific question of improving police relations with Catholics, rather than community relations, although the latter is not absent altogether. 
 The main constraint operating on the community relations police in West Belfast is in establishing contact with youth groups and schools in the area because of either a general resistance to the police or fear of intimidation from Republican paramilitary organizations as a result of involvement in a community relations programme. 
 Some Catholic schools in the area have no contact with the RUC's Community Relations Branch, others do so when the police are in plain clothes and bring no uniformed neighbourhood police with them, while yet others restrict the lecture topics which the community relations police cam address. 
 But there remains a commitment on the part of the police to the principle of improving police relations with the Catholic community, and they try in several ways to overcome the practical difficulties schools are presented with when they associate with the community relations police. 
 For example, they transport schoolchildren to events in unmarked buses, or pick them up from locations outside West Belfast. 
 And while some parents complain to the head teacher about their children becoming involved with the RUC, at least one headmistress was reported as being committed to the community relations programme, telling parents that she was responsible for their education and that they  could move their child if they objected to the way this was done (FN 10/2/87, p. 7). 
 Indeed, a popular view amongst community relations police in the area is that many more schools would welcome them but for intimidation, a factor which the community relations police have to be very sensitive towards if they are not to threaten the safety of children and teachers. 
 One officer was describing a school quiz organized among schoolchildren of all denominations, and said: 
 I know schools up the &lsqb;place in West Belfast&rsqb; who would welcome us, but what happened one time, a school up there won the trophy and the next day some boys &lsqb;i.e. from the IRA&rsqb; came demanding the shield and threatening what they would do to certain teachers if it wasn't handed over. 
 So you see, in schools like that we would never go uniformed and we would have to discontinue visiting those schools as we would be jeopardizing the children and teachers. 
 (FN 10/2/87, p. 7) 
 Sensitivity to the physical security of the public in West Belfast thus becomes another constraint against introducing the sort of community relations programme that exists in Easton. 
 This leads directly on to an issue which will only be noted here, leaving further discussion until the next chapter. 
 It is widespread to policemen and women in &bquo;sandbag&equo; areas like West Belfast that their typifications of Catholics draw a distinction between the majority who are decent and honest and who would have friendly contact with the police but for fear of the paramilitaries, and the small number of &bquo;gangsters and criminals&equo; who support or undertake attacks on the police. 
 As we shall see, this typification is a resource used by policemen and women in several situations and for many different purposes, and it has clear relevance in explaining why community relations police in West Belfast retain their commitment despite the difficulties of their task and the restricted nature of their duties. 
 All would be different, they believe, if the majority of decent and honest Catholics could escape the grip of fear, and they define the role of community relations police in West Belfast as attempting, in a small way, to loosen the Catholic community from the stranglehold of the paramilitaries, as the commentary on a police promotional video stated: &bquo;The effort of trying to win the people's minds and hearts away from terrorism is personified in the Community Relations Branch, whose members regularly attend meetings involving civilian bodies, public representatives, and discuss problems such as  vandalism.&equo; 
 The reality, of course, does not accord with this gloss, but the commitment if not the viable programme exists. 
 One of the more usual benefits of a Community Relations Unit in West Belfast is its discouragement of police misconceptions about Catholics. 
 Here the normal flow of influence is reversed, with the unintended consequence being an improvement in police views of Catholics. 
 Community relations and neighbourhood policing reverses the process of depersonalization, and with regard to the police this encourages them to develop a more subtle set of typifications which categorize the majority of residents in West Belfast as decent, honest, and, at root, friendly. 
 As an experienced community policeman in the area said, the attitude of the police changes because policemen and women can see that the community &bquo;is not all yobbos&equo; (FN 15/5/87, p. 4): 
 You get a different view of the people here when you're in neighbourhood, like, it's different. 
 The vast majority of people here are decent people, friendly, and they'll be civil enough to you. 
 Like, we're in the position where we can differentiate between them and gangsters in the community, and, like, we have to show the decent people that the Provies might scare them, but they don't scare us, even if they do. 
 (FN 15/5/87, p. 12) 
 Neighbourhood policing in sandbag areas like West Belfast is even more difficult than community relations work. 
 Sympathetic typifications of Catholics do little to lessen the obvious problem of being attacked while walking the beat. 
 As explained by a senior officer in the neighbourhood unit for the whole of B Division, which includes dangerous areas in West and North Belfast, &bquo;men risk their lives for community policing&equo; in this area. 
 Neighbourhood police are all too aware of the risk: 
 We are identifiable by our uniform. 
 This means for the neighbourhood man, the man on the beat, that it is difficult for him to keep a low profile. 
 He might feel he's a easy target&hellip; 
 He doesn't know anybody, but everybody knows him (FN 29/4/87, p. 16). 
 Like, I know I've been lucky. 
 It's a desperate way to look at it but when you go out there's 16 soldiers to every 2 policemen and you work out the odds, and that's 8 to 1 against you being hit. 
 It's awful, but that's the way your mind works&hellip; 
 Like, I know guys who lost arms and legs&hellip; 
 See, now I deliberately sit, when I'm out in a Land Rover, with one arm up a bit higher than the other and one leg a bit higher. 
 Like, I suppose that way if I was hit I might stand a chance of only losing one arm or one leg. 
 (FN 15/5/1987, p. 15&ndash;16) 
 As intimated, the danger of attack means that two neighbourhood men walking their beat are accompanied by at least sixteen soldiers, sometimes also by another squad of soldiers providing cover for those who are protecting the police, by two or more Land Rovers from the British Army and the RUC, and an Army helicopter. 
 A neighbourhood patrol can thus assume the proportions of an armed convoy. 
 Irrespective of its formal purpose to introduce community policing, the appearance of a neighbourhood patrol restricts its effects to simply the demonstration of a police presence on the streets. 
 While this contributes to crime prevention, especially with respect to joy-riders who steal and drive cars at speed at might (which requires neighbourhood men in West Belfast to work might duty), it has none of the wider community service functions evident in Easton. 
 Casual encounters on the beat are kept to a minimum by the public, primarily, the police claim, as a result of intimidation, and constables get few opportunities to display the interactive skills that might foster good community relations, although the rare occasions when this happens are seized upon by the men and recalled with pleasure thereafter. 
 Moreover, neighbourhood police expressed a sensitivity to the effect which these casual encounters might have on the safety of those they talked to &bquo;for you don't know who's watching&equo;. 
 Therefore, they try to conceal the fact that they are talking to people, sometimes by giving the impression through non-verbal behaviour that they are issuing directions, or by calling at their homes. 
 However, casual or conspired encounters with the public are infrequent and a primary duty is to deliver court summonses and warrants. 
 Even senior officers admit that to call this neighbourhood policing is a misnomer (FN 15/5/87, p. 2), but, however dangerous and selfdefeating they appear, neighbourhood patrols are seen by police management as an essential and necessary feature of the role of the police in Catholic areas. 
 Hence, in the three stations visited in B Division there were twenty-seven neighbourhood policemen and three sergeants; a staffing level much higher than in Easton, where the range of duties is more extensive. 
 This reflects the management's recognition that the style of policing that occurs in areas like West Belfast heavily influences the public's perception of the police. 
 This creates problems for the neighbourhood police when events in the area force other sections of the force to adopt the more aggressive and repressive mode of public order policing, and the success the  neighbourhood men have in overcoming communal suspicion depends almost entirely on wider social and political circumstances rather than any feature of their own conduct. 
 This is not so in Easton. 
 In sandbag areas like West Belfast, months of patient hard work on the part of the neighbourhood police cam be destroyed as a single event inside or outside the locale increases Catholic distrust of or disaffection from the police. 
 Therefore, the assessments which the neighbourhood police give of how much support they obtain from the Catholic community (or, more accurately, how much support they see the majority of Catholics as feeling able safely to show), vary depending on wider circumstances and the time-scale used. 
 Compared to the situation just after the introduction of internment in the early 1970s, community relations are said to have improved considerably, which is true even for the period since neighbourhood foot patrols were first introduced following the hunger strikes of 1981. 
 See now, there's a lot of people who will speak to you friendly out on the street and there's a lot more of them who'll speak to you inside their own homes. 
 But recently since the big IRA push, things have changed. 
 Like, it used to be that &lsqb;place&rsqb; station might be attacked once or twice a year, like it was hit five times in one night this year&hellip; 
 If you got left behind by the Army you'd be lucky to come back alive, and that's no exaggeration. 
 There's no way any of us could walk out of this station in uniform. 
 (FN 15/5/87, p. 6) 
 This remark neatly summarizes the paradox of neighbourhood policing in areas like West Belfast. 
 Societal divisions are such that neighbourhood patrols are dangerous and have to take on the appearance of armed convoys, but it is the style of policing which comes nearest to breaching the divide between the police and the community, so that the RUC is required to be persistent in utilizing it even though there are few obvious signs of success and despite the cost in human life. 
 This paradox will. 
 remain while police management retain their commitment to improving community relations, which the British government will ensure they do. 
 Hence it should be no surprise that ordinary policemen and women come to feel that the police management and the government do not care that the risks associated with routine policing in a divided society are borne primarily by them: that the ordinary policeman and woman can be sacrificed for the sake of wider goals, the purpose of which they often have difficulty in comprehending. 
 This view is pervasive amongst  ordinary members of the RUC and leads us directly to the issue of how Northern Ireland's divisions affect policemen and women, which the following chapters begin to address.  
 yINTERNATIONAL MARKETING: THE KINGSTON BUSINESS SCHOOL OPEN LEARNING MBA PROGRAMME. 
 David Sagar, Brian Coyle, Tim Newton, Jim Reeve 
 INTRODUCTION TO INTERNATIONAL MARKETING 
 Topics covered in this chapter 
 Terminology 
 The decision to expand from the domestic market 
 Evolution of general marketing ideas 
 Application of marketing ideas in an international context 
 International marketing strategy 
 Common worldwide marketing &mdash; the Levitt approach 
 Customising global marketing &mdash; an alternative approach 
 1 Terminology 
 When international marketing  first appeared as a distinct subject few writers described it by any title other than that. 
 The implications of the title were simply that an organisation had extended its activities beyond exporting to consider markets distinct from its own domestic market. 
 With this limited view of &bquo;overseas operations&equo; there was little or no need to become trapped in a semantic jungle. 
 But as the subject developed first the term &bquo; multinational marketing &equo; was coined and then &bquo; global marketing &equo; was added to the picture. 
 The implications of these terms are considered later but the use of terminology in this study text needs to be made clear at the outset. 
 International marketing is treated as a generic term covering the distinctions made in describing marketing activities as &bquo;international&equo; or &bquo;multinational&equo; or &bquo;global&equo;. 
 2 The decision to expand from the domestic market 
 Few companies, when first established, have the resources or expertise to operate outside their home market. 
 The decision to expand outside national boundaries is therefore usually taken at some later stage in their development, and this section reviews the factors that may be taken into account in arriving at a decision which fundamentally alters the nature and scope of a company's activities. 
 Five major factors may be involved in the decision to &bquo;go international&equo; and these are shown in the diagram on the next page.  
 A useful distinction can be made between the defensive factors that cause companies to look beyond their domestic markets (reactive factors) and proactive influences. 
 The distinction is useful because companies that seize an opportunity in markets outside their domestic base are more likely to be successful than those that react in response to an external factor. 
 Reaction as a reason for going international is often characterised by: 
 badly thought out international marketing programmes that rely on insufficient understanding of the new markets 
 poor quality marketing research 
 inappropriate distribution channels and 
 expensive, lengthy and difficult implementation that makes the company vulnerable to more perceptive competitors. 
 Reactive factors 
 Probably the most common reason for a company to &bquo;go international&equo; is insufficient growth in the domestic market. 
 This may come in one of two forms: 
 (a) 
 lack of growth because the market is mature. 
 In the developed world, industries such as processed foods and commodity raw materials (eg gas and electricity) typify the problem; 
 (b) 
 a company's growth expectations are higher than can be met from growth in the domestic market. 
 Computer hardware companies, such as Apple and Compaq, found themselves in this position, as did their software counterparts Microsoft, Lotus and Ashton-Tate. 
 In either case a company's growth objectives may make foreign markets very attractive. 
 Threats in the external environment also provide a compelling reason to expand beyond the home market. 
 Again, this may be found in two forms. 
 (a) 
 The impact of a foreign competitor in the company's home market. 
 When a competitor successfully enters the domestic market, the company may look to expand internationally; partly as a means of retaliation and partly in defence of its home market. 
 This is seen particularly in the USA, where the very large domestic market has provided a safe haven for many companies of substantial size. 
 The US telecommunications industry, which became subject to foreign competition on the dismantling of the Bell System, has reacted by attempting to enter foreign markets, especially those of Europe and the Far East. 
 (b) 
 Regulatory threat, which may make the domestic market less attractive. 
 The manufacturers of heavily regulated products, such as tobacco and alcohol, often find that promotion is less regulated and more cost-effective in less developed countries than in their own domestic markets. 
 In a business environment of increasingly rapid change, industries such as component manufacturers, that have a supplier relationship with another industry, may be forced to expand internationally to meet the changing needs of their customers. 
 Many international expansions are clearly the result of more than one of these pressures. 
 After the 1986 &bquo;Big Bang&equo; in the City of London, many of the players in the security trading and banking industries looked to expand internationally. 
 A change in the regulatory environment (the abolition of fixed commissions and easier entry for foreign competitors) provided the initial stimulus. 
 Equally, however, their customers had outgrown locally-based suppliers. 
 Adjustment to their customers' needs compelled them to establish an international presence that had hitherto been unnecessary. 
 The securities industry also demonstrates particularly well the dangers of going international as a result of external pressure rather than internally-perceived opportunities. 
 Many financial services firms paid high prices for established brand names in the sector without considering sufficiently the nature of the markets they were entering. 
 Heavy losses or, at best, inadequate returns on capital invested have resulted in ignominious withdrawals from the market. 
 Banking in particular, seems particularly susceptible to failures in foreign markets caused by reactive pressures &mdash; much of the Third World debt problems can be traced to banks looking for easy foreign expansion routes when faced by lack of growth in domestic markets. 
 In contrast, it will be interesting to see how far Deutsche Bank succeeds with its acquisition of Morgan Grenfell in 1989, having chosen not to react immediately to the Big Bang by acquiring a merchant banking subsidiary in London in 1986. 
 Proactive factors 
 The main proactive reason for expanding internationally is perceived economies of scale and positioning on an experience curve. 
 Black &amp; Decker, the tool manufacturer, followed this course in expanding out of the USA. 
 The low cost strategy it employs is possible only with high volume production plants and low unit research and development costs. 
 Niche marketers usually develop an international outlook early in their development; in part because their domestic market is normally comparatively small, and also because their unique position in a product or market niche can be relatively easily extended. 
 Stihl, the West German manufacturers of chain saws for professional users, have developed an impressive international distribution network and are market leaders in most of the markets in which they operate. 
 Similarly, Dawson International, with its niche markets for cashmere and other woollen products (Ballantyne Cashmere, Pringle) depends heavily on overseas markets for its success, particularly the USA, Japan and West Germany. 
 Reactive and proactive factors: a list 
 Brooke and Remmers (1970) made a survey of 115 foreign subsidiaries operating in the UK, and identified a variety of reasons why overseas companies decided to create foreign subsidiaries. 
 They analysed the reasons into three categories. 
 (a) 
 defensive strategies &mdash; reactive factors (which were the most common); 
 (b) 
 aggressive strategies &mdash; proactive factors; 
 (c) 
 other pressures. 
 It is interesting to look in some more detail at what some of these factors were. 
 Defensive strategies, they found, arise in response to: 
 (a) 
 action by the national government to establish tariff barriers or import controls; 
 (b) 
 demands in the country for more manufacture by nationals (eg &bquo;Buy British&equo;); 
 (c) 
 transport costs and delays in sending goods overseas; 
 (d) 
 difficulties with agents or licensees in the foreign country; 
 (e) 
 difficulties with after-sales service and other technical problems are more easily handled by a subsidiary than by an overseas head office and national agent; 
 (f) 
 the protection of patents; 
 (g) 
 the desire to protect supplies of raw materials (a natural resources strategy); 
 (h) 
 responding to competitors, suppliers or customers who have &bquo;gone international&equo; ie there is a fear that by failing to respond to what others are doing, a company will fall behind and lose markets; 
 (i) 
 the wish to protect shareholders from a recession at home by expanding or diversifying abroad. 
 Aggressive strategies include: 
 (a) 
 the search for other uses of under-employed resources at home. 
 Under-employed resources may be capital resources, equipment, personnel or &bquo;know-how&equo;; 
 (b) 
 to gain access to foreign &bquo;know-how&equo; and methods; 
 (c) 
 the need to expand when domestic expansion is not possible (expansion in this case would probably be by acquisition); 
 (d) 
 a global strategy to control natural resources and corner overseas markets. 
 Other reasons include: 
 (a) 
 influence by the national government which may encourage foreign investors, grant tax concessions or cheap loans, offers grants or guarantees, or supply a building or factory free of charge; 
 (b) 
 pressure groups within the organisation which advocate expansion through overseas subsidiaries. 
 3 Evolution of general marketing ideas 
 Development of marketing theories 
 The basis for successful international marketing is a sound understanding of marketing in general. 
 And the modern focus on international marketing is reflected in the evolution of theories about &bquo;what marketing is about&equo;. 
 Although change in conventional wisdom has been gradual, evolutionary rather than revolu-tionary, three general periods and approaches to marketing can be identified.  
 The old idea of marketing, which in many cases was little more than selling, focused on making a better product that was easier to sell. 
 Making a better product is naturally still an important element of marketing today and is forcefully demonstrated by the Japanese consumer goods manufacturers. 
 What made the pre-1960 period distinctive, however, was the almost complete reliance on this one objective. 
 The consequence of this approach was a tendency for companies to be inward-looking. 
 Standards were set within the firm rather than externally and so organisations were essentially static rather than dynamic. 
 During the 1960s the focus of marketing attention changed from the product to the customer. 
 Profit remained the sole objective but the means of achieving it was transformed. 
 Internally-set values based on the product were replaced by attention to the whole of the &bquo;marketing mix&equo;: product, price, place and promotion. 
 And with this change came a transformation in the organisation's approach to its markets. 
 Because attention was focused on customers and their changing demands, the organisation became dynamic in outlook. 
 The 1980s has produced another shift in marketing ideas &mdash; the role of marketing as a strategic concept. 
 Attention is focused on the external environment and markets, rather than customers. 
 If marketing was partially dynamic when it focused on the changing needs of customers, the introduction of the external environment as a driver of marketing thinking forces firms to be fully dynamic in their approach. 
 Some marketing commentators also take the view that the objective of successful marketing has changed in the 1980s. 
 While profit used to be viewed as a sufficient objective in itself, creating benefits for stakeholders is seen as the ultimate objective. 
 Stakeholders are defined as any group or individual with an interest in the company's activities. 
 They include the financial owners, managers, lenders, customers and communities in which the organisation operates. 
 4 Application of marketing ideas in an international context 
 As companies &bquo;go international&equo; they need to pose the question &bquo;Are there differences between domestic and international marketing?&equo; 
 Although significant differences exist, the basic similarities should be remembered. 
 The essential concepts and processes of marketing apply as much to marketing in the international arena as the domestic one. 
 So, when a company first looks to expand abroad, the same process needs to be adopted. 
 Too many companies enter foreign markets without analysing sufficiently either the customers or the competition in those markets. 
 International marketing differs from its domestic counterpart due purely to the differences in the political, social, cultural and economic environment between countries. 
 Most of this text is devoted to considering the nature of those differences and how the international marketing manager can overcome them. 
 How much they need to be overcome to implement a successful international marketing policy is a matter of considerable debate among marketing experts and section 5 of this chapter reviews the idea of the two main schools of thought. 
 The remainder of this section, however, considers how firms develop a structure best equipped to succeed in the international environment. 
 Stages in international marketing development 
 Keegan (1989) has developed a typology which he argues illustrates the development process that companies undergo in transforming their marketing activities from the wholly domestic to the completely global. 
 The diagram below outlines the key elements of his classification.  
 Keegan's classification begins with companies whose outlook and strategy is wholly domestic. 
 Their view of the world is contained in the belief &bquo;if it's not happening in the domestic market, it's not happening at all&equo;. 
 And when, eventually, the international tide comes in on their market sector, they perish. 
 Stage 2 is really the tentative beginning of an international orientation. 
 Most of a Stage 2 company's strategy and efforts remain concentrated on the domestic scene. 
 And forays into international markets are planned, controlled and judged by criteria established in the domestic market. 
 Usually with an element described as an &bquo;international division&equo; the typical Stage 2 company's product policy is &bquo;extension&equo;. 
 Little or no account is taken of alterations in product policy to suit the conditions of non-domestic markets. 
 A frequently quoted example of the companies at Stage 2 is the British motorcycle industry of the 1960s and early 1970s. 
 The industry lost first its export markets and then its domestic market to the Japanese because it was totally unprepared for the challenge from companies that operated on a truly international basis. 
 The mark of the Stage 3 company, often described as the multinational company, is the adaptation of each element of the marketing mix to the different markets in which it operates. 
 In essence it becomes a matrix of connected businesses that normally have much weaker direction from the corporate centre than a Stage 2 company. 
 Typically, the decentralised management applies not only to marketing policy but also to financial and operations management. 
 When a company evolves to Stage 4 it ceases to view geographical units as necessarily important in marketing terms and instead takes a global view of its marketing, financing and operations. 
 It concentrates on identified market segments, irrespective of the geographic location. 
 For example, both Ford and Toyota have developed &bquo;world cars&equo;. 
 The principal customer needs are incorporated in a standardised design. 
 Product adaptation occurs (such as steering wheels located on the right or left), but is a refinement of the marketing policy, not the policy itself. 
 The emergence of the transnational company: Bartlett and Ghosal 
 Recent work by Bartlett and Ghoshal suggests that a further stage in corporate development will be required by the successful companies of the 1990s. 
 It is essentially an extension of the Stage 4 global company described by Keegan. 
 Bartlett and Ghoshal argue that Stage 4 companies are not truly global. 
 Although markets are treated globally, they assert that overseas operations act simply as delivery pipelines to a unified global market. 
 The distinctions Bartlett and Ghoshal make are illustrated below.  
 Key characteristics 
 Global organisational model 
 centralised hub 
 operational control 
 overseas operations treated as delivery pipelines to unified global market 
 Transnational organisational model 
 integrated network 
 strategic control 
 worldwide operations treated as integrated and interdependent 
 According to Bartlett and Ghoshal, the differing company structures that have been identified as a development sequence are, in reality, a function of different cultural management styles. 
 The &bquo;Stage 3&equo; multinational company, operating as a network of autonomous or semi-autonomous units, is seen as an outcome of European expansion before World War 2. 
 In this period barriers to trade were high and thus the multinational structure of operationally-independent companies was a necessity. 
 The international company, identified principally by its policy of product extension rather than adaptation, is viewed as essentially American in origin. 
 It was the result of efforts to transfer product systematically from developed to less developed economies, while at the same time retaining the essentially American management style of strong planning, coordination and control from the centre. 
 What Bartlett and Ghoshal refer to as the global company is alleged to be the result of Japanese practice developed in the 1960s and 1970s. 
 Lower trade barriers permitted their development, and Japanese government restrictions on overseas investment encouraged companies that treated markets on a global basis and benefitted from economies of scale. 
 According to Bartlett and Ghoshal, the transnational company is meant to be the vehicle for international marketing of the 1990s that integrates the strengths of the three former culturally-dependent types of company. 
 To some extent the difference between this view and the developmental approach is one of semantics: the term &bquo;global company&equo; does not mean the same to each. 
 Yet there is greater emphasis in the transnational company model on the complete integration and interdependence of operating structures. 
 This may occur in Keegan's &bquo;global company&equo; but there the emphasis lies more in the company's approach to products and markets, without the same global integration of flows of resources, ideas and people. 
 5 International marketing strategy 
 With the development of the concepts of what international marketing entails, a lively debate has developed as to how the international marketing manager should approach his task. 
 The argument centres around two distinct although connected items: 
 (a) 
 the extent to which a common worldwide marketing programme should be run; and 
 (b) 
 the degree of autonomy that should be given to &bquo;country managers&equo; in running the programme. 
 The two opposing schools of thought are represented on the one side by Theodore Levitt and on the other by John Quelch and Richard Hoff. 
 Common worldwide marketing &mdash; the Levitt approach 
 Theodore Levitt takes as his basic premise the belief that two forces are shaping business worldwide: (1) technology and (2) globalisation. 
 In his view, however, although human preferences may superficially appear to diverge due to social and cultural factors, in fact markets converge and economies of scale lead to reduction of costs and prices. 
 He uses this view to argue how forward-looking companies should act and contrasts strongly the modern global corporation with the ageing multinational corporation. 
 The globally-aware organisation is supposed to strive constantly for triple aims: 
 (a) 
 technical product innovation and leadership; 
 (b) 
 a streamlined product range which is promoted vigorously worldwide; and 
 (c) 
 low prices. 
 In his words the global corporation &bquo;sells the same things in the same way everywhere&equo;. 
 By way of contrast, he writes disparagingly of the multinational company that concentrates on idiosyncratic consumer preferences, and gives two reasons why he believes such organisations will lose the long-term commercial battle. 
 He asserts that when faced with paying higher prices (and significantly higher prices) for the precise product specification consumers are supposed to want, those consumers will opt for the low-priced goods. 
 He doubts whether the consumer preferences reported by market research teams can be translated into products with sufficient accuracy. 
 It may appear that his &bquo;recipe for success&equo; involves a corporate strategy which has traditionally been viewed as extremely difficult if not completely untenable: the linking of high product quality with low prices. 
 Levitt simply asserts the opposite &mdash; that low-cost operations are the stamp of corporate cultures pervaded by the ethos of quality. 
 They are, he says, &bquo;compatible, twin identities of superior practice&equo;. 
 There is another way of viewing Levitt's arguments; the relative importance of between-country and within-country differences to the marketing manager. 
 By implication, Levitt takes the view that a global market should be viewed as one with particular market segments that may bear little or no relationship to geographical boundaries. 
 In other words, variations in market homogeneity are more marked within countries than between them. 
 He backs this up with examples of marketing successes that have deliberately flaunted conventional wisdom of respecting the idiosyncrasies of particular national economies. 
 Smith Kline Corporation (now part of Smith Kline Beecham) intended to introduce its decongestant medicine to the Japanese market. 
 Having a highly fragmented retail distribution system, it was normal for companies to operate through about one thousand drug wholesalers. 
 Instead Smith Kline chose just twenty-five key distributors, with whom it maintained far closer contact than was usual practice. 
 The Japanese launch was a success, although it is open to question how much of the success can be attributed to innovative marketing and how much to the technical qualities of the product. 
 Komatsu, the Japanese manufacturer of farm machinery, provides a further example of success by ignoring conventional wisdom. 
 Intending to introduce its product range to the USA, it was confronted by a lack of a distribution system &mdash; the existing players in this market had tied it up. 
 It took its products to the southern USA, where lightweight machinery (in which it then specialised) was particularly suitable because soil conditions were sandier and so easier to work. 
 A new distribution channel was devised &mdash; construction equipment dealers. 
 Despite their lack of familiarity with the product type, the distributors managed to attract customers on the basis of Komatsu's product and price advantages. 
 Levitt considers many Japanese companies as the first truly global marketers and contrasts their practices strongly with the approach taken by Hoover in marketing automatic washing machines in Europe. 
 In the 1960s, Hoover was looking to increase the output of its manufacturing plant closer to its capacity level and so intended to boost its sales in mainland Europe. 
 Market research showed considerable differences in consumer preferences in various countries. 
 These are summarised below.  
 Hoover concluded that consumer preferences must be met by providing models for national markets that incorporated the specific features market research had brought to light. 
 The result of this decision was an increase in direct production costs approaching 20%, caused mainly by the relatively short runs for each model. 
 If one accepts Levitt's analysis, Hoover got their marketing badly wrong. 
 He notes that at the time that Hoover was engaged in this exercise, a basic Italian washing machine was gaining market share against a heavily promoted German product, in Germany. 
 Levitt concludes that the Italian's success demonstrates his belief that you should not provide consumers with what they say they want, because their behaviour demonstrates that they will take other features if the product is priced and promoted correctly. 
 6 Customising global marketing &mdash; an alternative approach 
 Quelch and Hoff represent an opposing school of thought to that put forward by Levitt. 
 In their view, global marketing as recommended by Levitt does not work because: 
 (a) 
 flexibility is essential; 
 (b) 
 customers and competitive conditions differ between countries; and 
 (c) 
 powerful local managers may not stand for centralised decision making. 
 They also add a new idea to the framework. 
 Whereas Levitt takes the view that the low prices permitted by scale economies in production offer the key to global marketing success, Quelch and Hoff suggest that the driving factor in global marketing should be the efficient worldwide use of good marketing ideas. 
 In the final analysis, Quelch and Hoff conclude, perhaps predictably, that the extent to which a standardised global product is practicable depends on two attributes: 
 economies or efficiencies in manufacturing and/or research and development; and 
 its cultural grounding. 
 For example, packaged consumer goods are inherently less susceptible than durable goods such as motor cars to either manufacturing or R/D economies. 
 Classic cases of successful global marketing by companies in the packaged consumer goods sector, such as Coca-Cola, may seem to contradict this view. 
 Quelch and Hoff, however, consider Coca Cola's tight global marketing co-ordination is driven principally by the intention of capitalising on the company's marketing ideas rather than potential economies of scale. 
 It may therefore be possible to reconcile the views of the opposing schools of thought by regarding global standardisation as the ultimate objective when substantial economies of scale are available but which may need to be modified in the context of the product concerned. 
 To determine the most appropriate international marketing strategy, products could be plotted on a chart similar to that below.  
 THE INTERNATIONAL MARKETING ENVIRONMENT 
 Topics covered in this chapter 
 Basic characteristics of the international market 
 Trade and consumption patterns 
 Development of markets 
 Political controls on international trade 
 Social and cultural factors 
 Legal framework of international marketing 
 1 Basic characteristics of the international market 
 The international marketing executive needs an understanding of the marketing environment in different localities of the world, in order to: 
 assess their market potential and 
 develop a strategy for marketing the company's products in each locality. 
 It was mentioned in the previous chapter that an awareness of the marketing environment has become a key element in the &bquo;modern-day&equo; approach to marketing. 
 Income 
 In assessing the potential market within a country for the majority of products, and in comparing the potential market of different countires, the most important factors are total income and income per head of the population. 
 It should not be assumed, however, that an analysis of the incomes per capita of various countries or regions will provide a precise measure of the market potential of each; income is a useful indicator, but it does not provide the full picture. 
 For example, a manufacturer of bathroom and kitchen taps might wish to assess the potential market for taps in country A and country B. The income per capita in country A might be three times the income per capita in country B, and so the manufacturer might assess the potential market for taps to be three times as large in country A as in country B. However, the inhabitants of country B might live in larger houses than people in country A, and the country B houses might have an average 1 &frac12; times more bathrooms/kitchens. 
 The manufacturer of taps would probably obtain better projections of the market for taps in each country by taking into consideration not just income per capita and population size, but also house characteristics. 
 Estimating comparative levels of per capita GNP between various nations is probably best done by assessing relative levels of purchasing power &mdash; what a currency will buy in the country in which it is issued, using comparisons between particular products. 
 Such comparisons are often difficult due to lack of available data, and comparisons are often made by measuring GNP per capita in local currency and using the exchange rate of the currency against an international standard (typically US &dollar;). 
 However, whilst this method of comparison relies on easily available information, it is not exact; exchange rates relate to goods which are traded internationally, whilst the the majority of the national product of most countries is comprised of goods which never enter the international marketplace. 
 The differences in real income can thus be distorted. 
 As just one example, agricultural goods are generally priced lower in relation to industrial products in developing countries than in industrial countries, and this may lead to an exaggeration of the apparent differences in per capita income. 
 Another potentially distorting factor is that whilst average incomes can be compared between one country and another, they do not of themselves reveal the true comparable standard of living, nor the comparable potential markets for all products. 
 Developing countries, for example, consume many of the same goods as industrialised countries, but may have little or no expenditure on heating, public utilities, medicine, etc. 
 Despite these potential distortions, certain conclusions can be drawn about global income distribution. 
 The most striking factor is that income is heavily concentrated in three regions of the world &mdash; Japan, Europe and North America. 
 These are therefore the key markets for most multinational companies. 
 The result of this relatively narrow income distribution is that a company can be truly multinational, doing business with a spread of nations with high levels of income, whilst confining its activities to a very small number of countries. 
 Doing business with a large number of national markets therefore implies that within most of these markets, operations will be relatively small in scale, because the markets will be small. 
 Population 
 Occasionally, population will be the primary factor which will influence the marketing of a particular product. 
 This will be so particularly in the case of goods which are of a very low price, so that there is little income barrier to their purchase. 
 2 Trade and consumption patterns 
 Trade patterns 
 International trade is predominantly between industrialised countries. 
 This explains the concentration of global income in these countries. 
 Consumption patterns 
 There is a clear connection between levels of income and the levels of consumption of various goods. 
 The studies of Ernst Engel in the nineteenth century, led to the conclusion that after income has risen beyond a certain level, there is a decrease in the percentage of total income that is spent on food. 
 The total spending on food still increases, but at a slower rate than the level of income itself. 
 &bquo;Engel's Law&equo; thus relates to the relationship between changes in income and changes in demand for necessities and other goods. 
 As income increases and a greater proportion is spent on non-essential goods, the percentage of the population who own a particular product also increases. 
 In other words, the level of product saturation rises. 
 It should be stressed that income is only one factor in determining consumption patterns, however. 
 Often the sales of one product will affect the sales of another product, since the latter is used in conjunction with (or in consequence of) the first. 
 A society which does not use toothbrushes, for instance, will be an unlikely target market for the introduction of toothpaste, no matter how cheap. 
 3 Development of markets 
 There is a view that marketing is not relevant to the needs of less developed countries, since these countries require means of increasing basic levels of output, not means of directing changes of production to satisfy a changing marketplace. 
 Furthermore, it is argued, the needs and wants of a less developed country are so far in advance of that country's productive capacity that it is useless to waste resources focusing on them. 
 There is an opposing view, that the marketing process should be seen in a rather different way. 
 If one examines the needs and wants of a less developed society and relates this information to the production capacity of that country, ways may be found to develop products that consumers want and which the country is capable of producing. 
 Electrical household goods may be unsuitable for many countries, for example, but the application of a creative marketing process may lead to alternative inexpensive, manually operated machinery being developed which can be both produced easily and suit the needs of the population. 
 When marketing principles are applied to distribution as opposed to production, further positive results may be observed. 
 As an example, say that wine is normally sold in litre bottles stoppered with a cork, at a price of &dollar;2.00. 
 Within a particular country, this puts the product out of the reach of most potential consumers. 
 If a local merchant then buys wine and decants it into re-sealable quarter-litre bottles, selling it retail at &dollar;1.00 per bottle, two effects might be observed. 
 The merchant would make a profit, which can be argued to have no discernable social benefit for the society as a whole. 
 But in addition to this, wine would be made available to the local population at an affordable price, and in a condition that allows it to be stored without spoiling. 
 A third effect which could be added is that business experience would be gained by the local merchant, and thus the society begins to develop a pool of people with such business experience. 
 Experience of this nature may reduce the reliance of less developed countries on goods imported from abroad; local manufacturers may be able to satisfy local market needs by intelligent marketing, and thus gain a larger share of the local market than before, with consequent results for local levels of production and the economy generally. 
 A further element in this argument is the possibility that advertising can be used as part of a marketing strategy to shape the wants and needs of a less developed society in a direction that is clearly beneficial. 
 For instance, if a country concerned still employs traditional systems which, in the light of more modern techniques, appear to be detrimental to public health, it may be desirable to change patterns of behaviour in, say, nutrition or hygiene. 
 Often this will not be successful if the population is attached to its traditional methods and the new methods are radically different from the old; a careful marketing campaign to change attitudes can have a dramatic effect, particularly by presenting new products in a way that is not dramatically different from the old. 
 Stages in market development 
 Five stages of market development have been recognised, delineated by gross GNP per capita, but showing a number of other common factors. 
 (a) 
 Preindustrial 
 Generally situated in Africa south of the Sahara desert, these countries have a per capita income (on 1983 figures) of less than &dollar; 400. 
 The economy is predominantly agricultural, often at subsistence levels, with very little industrial capacity, leading to great reliance on foreign aid. 
 Politically they tend to be unstable, with very high birth rates but poor education and very low levels of literacy. 
 (b) 
 Less Developed 
 Incomes here are between &dollar; 401 and &dollar; 1,635, with a degree of industrialisation in the economy, supplying cars, trucks, building materials etc. 
 Some exports are seen, and the pool of cheap labour and resources means that they may begin to pose a competitive threat. 
 (c) 
 Developing 
 Incomes are between &dollar; 1,636 and &dollar; 5,500, with the economy shifting clearly away from agriculture towards a significant level of industrialisation. 
 These countries can experience rapid economic growth and become strong competitors, since they benefit from a combination of large-scale industrial capacity combined with low levels of wage costs. 
 Education is well developed, and literacy rates are high. 
 (d) 
 Industrialised 
 Incomes range from &dollar; 5,501 to &dollar; 10,000. 
 The highly educated population, developed infrastructure and high levels of wages and costs mean that they are poised to move beyond their industrial base. 
 (e) 
 Advanced 
 Incomes are in excess of &dollar; 10,000. 
 A number of factors have been identified which distinguish this sort of country: 
 (i) 
 innovation flows from the application of theoretical knowledge, not from random invention; 
 (ii) 
 the service secor is vitally important, accounting for over 50% of GNP; 
 (iii) 
 knowledge replaces capital as the most important resource. 
 4 Political controls on international trade 
 Controls may be imposed on international trade for a number of different reasons. 
 Imposing tariffs on goods which are imported, for instance, has several results: 
 revenue is generated for the country concerned; 
 local industry is protected from outside competition; 
 local business is developed to meet the market demand within the country; 
 the market price for the good will be higher than if no tariffs were imposed, and this will result in lower total market demand for the product. 
 For a developing country in particular this might be a desirable outcome in the case of non-essential goods. 
 Protectionism (exchange controls, import controls) is likely to be extensively applied by developing countries, but it may still be relevant in an industrialised country which is suffering a high level of unemployment, with consequent pressure on the government to take economic measures to remedy this situation. 
 Governments might also wish to protect domestic industries to maintain industrial activity within the country, or to maintain or develop the country's involvement in certain key industries, such as electronics, defence equipment and so on. 
 Identifying the underlying motives of a particular nation for taking any restrictive action on trade should be an essential feature of any international marketing plan. 
 Such an investigation allows both an understanding of the actions of the country concerned, and, as a consequence of this, a realistic attempt can be made to 
 predict its future behaviour 
 take measures to forestal adverse actions 
 lobby for more favourable treatment. 
 As an example, consider the difficulty experienced by overseas companies wishing to begin direct operations in Japan, where applications were vetted by the National Planning Authority to ensure that they fitted the national economic plan of Japan. 
 At best, admission was obtained only on the basis of a joint venture with a Japanese company, and entry of any kind was often impossible to obtain, at least until the Japanese themselves had established a strong presence &mdash; domestically and internationally &mdash; in the market sector concerned. 
 This situation has been ameliorated to a degree, in the face of overseas pressure to change the system, not least because of the Japanese need to maintain its market position in other countries, and concern about retaliatory measures against Japanese imports. 
 This sort of interdependence of interests is a feature of the relations between industrialised countries; having built a strong overseas market position, a country will be forced to take more account of external pressures if that strong position is to be maintained. 
 The future behaviour of Japan, then, may be analysed in terms of the balance between commercial self-interest and the basic protectionist nature of many of the trade restrictions which still exist. 
 Example: Whisky exports to Japan 
 Until late 1988, whisky spirits in Japan faced a special tax which was not applied to other spirits. 
 The tax meant that a bottle of whisky attracted taxes of up to 220%, the equivalent of Y 2,000, or about &dollar; 15.70. 
 In theory, the tax applied equally to Japanese and imported whisky spirit, but in practice the position was radically different; imported scotch attracted the full tax, but the local spirit ('whisky') was in fact only 10% whisky spirit (which did not unduly worry the consumers, since they drank it as mizuwari, highly diluted with water). 
 The obvious course of action &mdash; to dilute the imported spirit in a similar way with other spirits &mdash; was not an option, since importers were banned by law from doing so. 
 The result was to put imported scotch at the top of the spirits price range, so that it was a valued gift, but was not bought to drink under normal circumstances. 
 The abolition of the domestic tax differential (an example of a response to external pressure) brought a soaring import market. 
 In 1987 the share of the total market accounted for by imported whisky was a mere 11%; in 1992, the figure is projected to be 27%. 
 The change in price has been dramatic &mdash; in 1986 it was estimated that it would be impossible to distribute imported whisky free of charge at a cost of less than Y 2,600 a bottle. 
 Today many brands are sold commercially for far less. 
 The Japanese have not been inactive however; Suntory have linked up with Allied-Lyons, and Takara have bought the large Tomatin Scottish distillery. 
 Takara now sell low priced 12 year old Scotch specially blended to Japanese tastes. 
 The process demonstrates both response to external pressure and the action that can be taken between companies which are both based in industrialised (and therefore interdependent) countries. 
 Until recently, high trade barriers have existed between countries of the Communist East and those of the capitalist West, stimulated by both the clear political opposition of the &bquo;cold war&equo; and the incompatibility between the free market system of the West and the centrally planned and controlled system of the East. 
 Trade has been stimulated by the process of detente, and the moves towards &bquo;democratisation&equo; of the Eastern Bloc can be expected to continue this process. 
 Practical problems, such as the lack of exporting systems and expertise in the East will, however, continue to be a difficulty for some time to come. 
 The process of bringing the Western markets and the Eastern bloc markets together is evident in the announcement by the multinational company General Electric (November 1989) of its intention to purchase a majority stake in Tungsram, the Hungarian lighting equipment manufacturer. 
 The Financial Times commented: (20.11.89) 
 &bquo;GE&hellip; is acquiring Tungsram with the aim of eventually integrating its management within its global empire. 
 Previous deals have concentrated on western companies providing eastern allies with help on sales, distribution and marketing. 
 GE intends to provide Tungsram with sophisticated production technology and management training. 
 Yet the deal's significance extends well beyond this. 
 For it is the clearest signal yet of how political reform in eastern Europe could redraw the contours of European industry, extend the geographic and political boundaries of the EC's 1992 programme and alter the global strategies of such companies as GE.&equo; 
 The future behaviour of a less developed country will, however, be more difficult to predict. 
 The flow of investment between such a country and an industrialised nation is one-way, not reciprocal, and the stake which the less developed country has in overseas interests is minimal (or possibly non-existent). 
 The restrictions on that country's course of action are therefore less powerful than in the case of the Japanese example above, and its future behaviour is less suited to accurate prediction. 
 An open policy to trade may be maintained if the nation is doing well economically, but a less successful economic position may lead to swift and much more extreme action to erect trade barriers and bring in other sanctions. 
 Nationalisation (in effect, confiscation) of overseas interests is not unknown, despite the bad feeling generated by such a measure. 
 The effect of nationalism on international trade relations should, therefore, not be minimised. 
 Nationalist feelings may well be ameliorated in relations between industrialised countries by the interdependence discussed above; this will not be the case when the industrialised country is dealing with a less developed state, yet it is in this latter kind of country where nationalism may be most strongly manifested. 
 A further consideration for market development is political stability. 
 The more volatile the political situation in a particular state, the more difficult predicting its future actions will become. 
 In times of political unrest, the danger that extreme measures will be taken increases. 
 An incoming government, fresh from the overthrow of an old regime, is quite likely to take measures for nationalisation, or on exchange controls and import controls. 
 5 Social and cultural factors influencing the international marketing environment 
 Culture may be defined as those ideas, traditions, points of view and modes of behaviour which exist amongst a particular people, and which are transmitted, through learned behaviour, from generation to generation. 
 This is not a question of instinct &mdash; culture is learned, not inbred, and does not refer to basic human needs. 
 Thirst, for instance, is not a cultural issue, but the means selected by the individual to slake his thirst &mdash; tea, coffee, fruit juices, etc &mdash; is influenced by his cultural background. 
 Some nations are predominantly tea drinkers, others will generally prefer coffee. 
 Culture influences almost every aspect of the reaction to a particular product &mdash; texture, colour, desire for innovation or respect for tradition and so on. 
 Although some cultural differences, such as meaning attributed to basic patterns of syntax in otherwise similar communication patterns are difficult to spot, a long list can be compiled of easily identified cultural seperations. 
 More difficult to identify are the basic factors which are common to all human beings, but it is in these that the international marketer will be most interested, since they provide a basis upon which to market goods in a way which should have broad appeal. 
 Some cultural universals can be observed from the work of A H Maslow, who hypothesised a hierarchy of needs, whereby the satisfaction of a lower need will result in its being replaced by a higher need. 
 The hierarchy is as follows: 
 Maslow's hierachy of needs  
 The first three levels are relatively self-explanatory. 
 On level four, however, the need for self-esteem on comparison with others emerges. 
 Once one has satisfied the needs for, say, food, drink, safety and social relationships, one becomes a target for goods which are status-enhancing. 
 These will range from larger cars in some Western countries to the possession of brassieres in some African nations. 
 It should be noted that although the need itself is culturally universal, the means of its satisfaction is culturally determined. 
 The marketer must therefore turn his attention to how to identify these factors so as to be able to construct an effective strategy. 
 Assessing cultural factors 
 Perception of the needs of cultures in other countries can be clouded by the point of view of our own cultural background. 
 As far as possible, this should be avoided, and an objective standpoint be taken. 
 One method of achieving this, at least to a relatively successful extent, is that suggested by James Lee in 1966: 
 Identify the issue, and define it in the terms of your own culture 
 Do the same in the terms of the culture which you are trying to examine 
 Compare the two formulations, which should allow you to identify the influence of your own cultural values (your self-reference criteria) on your assessment 
 Refine your formulation for the foreign culture, removing the self-reference criteria which you have identified, and use this assessment to solve the problem. 
 Having made this assessment, the marketer should be aware of the potential problems which exist in communication within different cultures. 
 Language differences are obvious, but a more subtle distinction can be made between lowand high-context cultures. 
 Low-context cultures are characterised by the predominance of verbal communication; little reliance is placed upon the background context in which the words are used. 
 Formal documentation, legal contracts and direct, to-the-point negotiations are features of this kind of culture. 
 Examples include the United States and Western Europe. 
 In a high-context culture, however, much more depends on &bquo;who you are&equo;, personal relationships and the idea that a person's word is his bond. 
 In a high-context culture business meeting, for instance, the parties may spend much more time establishing friendship and mutual trust rather than discussing the particular item of business. 
 The Japanese, South Americans and the Arab nations are particular examples of this kind of cultural style, and Western Europeans often have significant difficulty understanding how a meeting can be productive when it hardly addresses the business deal at stake. 
 The crucial issue which this sort of situation emphasises is the vital importance of perception between persons of different cultures, which can only be partially ameliorated by the procedure suggested by James Lee. 
 In making your assessment, you may find that an appreciation of the common factors in the process of adopting a new product, of innovation, and of the potential purchasers themselves will be of assistance. 
 It seems that each of these can be broken down into five identifiable stages. 
 Adoption of a product involves the following: 
 Awareness &mdash; which largely comes through advertising and other such media 
 Interest &mdash; having become aware of the product, the potential purchaser actively seeks information about it 
 Evaluation &mdash; where the potential customer decides whether or not to try the product out 
 Trial &mdash; which will involve purchase, accepting a free gift, or in the case of a more expensive product, a demonstration to test the evaluation of it 
 Adoption &mdash; having gathered information and tested it out, the purchaser either continues to buy the product ('repeat purchase') in the case of less expensive goods, or makes the single purchase which the producer of the product intends. 
 If the product is an innovation within the marketplace, the following features of the product itself will influence the rate at which it is adopted: 
 Relative advantage over other existing products &mdash; the importance here is whether the potential consumers perceive advantage in the product, which can be for many reasons 
 Compatability &mdash; does the product fit with the customs, values and experience of the consumers? 
 Complexity &mdash; difficulty in understanding a product can hamper its adoption. 
 This will be so in developing countries with little experience of technology, but may operate to the product's advantage in more developed areas. 
 In the United States, for example, there is a discernable preference for products with the technological appeal of a &bquo;gadget&equo; 
 Divisibility &mdash; the range of income levels in diverse marketplaces means that the divisibility of a product (so that trial purchase may be made easily) will be very influential 
 Communication &mdash; the value of the product must be communicable to the potential consumers. 
 The adopters of the product &mdash; the consumers themselves &mdash; can be categorised into: 
 innovators &mdash; the first 2.5% of the purchasers of the new product, those who are most open to new ideas; 
 early adopters &mdash; the next 13.5%; these people are critical in the process, since they tend to be influential, and are the people willing to be influenced by external information (such as advertising). 
 They do not merely follow others who have already adopted the product, as do the following three catagories; 
 early majority &mdash; the next 34%; 
 late majority &mdash; the following 34%; 
 laggards &mdash; the final 16%. 
 A further striking difference between countries which is partly cultural in origin can be found in the differing legal rules which apply to business relationships. 
 Individuals from different cultures may not only contract together using different cultural assumptions, but using an entirely different legal framework. 
 South Korean culture 
 In spite of moves by the South Korean government to open up its long-and-heavily protected domestic economy to foreign imports, efforts by many multinational companies to break into South Korean markets have run into trouble. 
 A US company that set up a film importing subsidiary in South Korea was subjected to intensive intimidation, including the release of snakes into cinemas to deter cinema customers. 
 A market for imported grapefruit, that grew from zero to several million dollars worth in a few months, was destroyed even more quickly. 
 Demonstrations by Korean housewives against the import of farm products helped to destroy the market. 
 The causes of this consumer (and local business) opposition to imports appear to be partly nationalism, partly cultural and partly political. 
 South Korea has a Confucian-style society which has a tradition of respect for hierarchical authority, but also one of egalitaranism and an expectation that rulers have a duty to treat their people fairly. 
 Materialism has until recently been virtually unknown in Confucian societies. 
 The rapid expansion of the South Korean economy brought wealth which has been unevenly distributed; many of the wealthy have started to purchase high priced goods (that is, imported goods from Japan and the West) and popular resentment of this materialism and unfair wealth distribution could explain the hostility to imported products. 
 6 Legal framework of international marketing 
 International law can be defined as the framework of legal obligations which states view as being binding upon themselves. 
 This definition suggests two of the major deficiencies of the international legal system &mdash; firstly that there is little one country can do if another fails to abide by the rules, and this is made worse by the second factor, the lack of a comprehensive single body of law that could form the basis of a truly coherent system. 
 There is a growing move towards such international codification, but the process is not greatly advanced. 
 The international marketer, therefore, is still faced with a multitude of differing legal environments, about which information may be difficult to obtain, and once obtained may be very difficult to interpret. 
 The best procedure to follow, then, is to attempt to avoid situations in which such conflict is likely to arise. 
 In doing this, attention should be paid to the following factors. 
 (a) 
 Jurisdiction 
 The conditions under which trade may be carried out may not be as simple as they might at first appear. 
 For instance, an individual may be under the jurisdiction of his own laws even when in a different territory. 
 Bribes to officials are part of the culture of some areas of the world (and therefore necessary to obtain business), yet US citizens are forbidden by law to offer bribes to officials of foreign governments, no matter where in the world the citizen happens to be at the time. 
 (b) 
 Patents and protection of trademarks 
 There is no such thing as an international patent, so it is essential to register a product under the laws of each country in which it will be sold. 
 Some agreements do exist (the International Convention for the Protection of Industrial Property is observed by 45 countries, for instance), but great care should be taken. 
 (c) 
 Legal jurisdiction and arbitration 
 Court actions in foreign countries expose a company to a number of risks: 
 (i) 
 unfavourable publicity may be generated; 
 (ii) 
 the court may be ill-disposed to foreign companies; 
 (iii) 
 many courts will be unfamiliar with international law and with the customs and practices which the business community take for granted. 
 For this reason, most international contracts contain a clause establishing the country in which any legal action under the contract must take place (a jurisdiction clause), and/or a clause establishing that disputes will be referred to arbitration. 
 There are a number of recognised arbitration agencies established internationally. 
 (d) 
 Taxation and incorporation 
 Tax rates differ enormously from country to country, and therefore the territory in which taxation is levied on a company is of great importance. 
 One particular factor to be taken into account is the country in which incorporation is deemed to have taken place; the criteria for this will vary from state to state, so care must be taken over this issue. 
 (e) 
 Control of the company 
 There is often political pressure on a company from the country in which it operates to allow a greater degree of control to be exercised by the country concerned. 
 Although a transfer of the ownership of a company is unlikely to be well received by the board, care should be taken before making the decision on how to react; agreeing to increase national control can be less harmful than (for instance) withdrawing from the country altogether. 
 The ultimate sanction a country can levy &mdash; nationalisation (expropriation) of operations is not unknown, but is less frequent than is sometimes believed. 
 It is, however, a real threat outside of the Western industrialised states. 
 (f) 
 Antitrust laws 
 The point of antitrust laws is to prevent restrictions on competition. 
 The principle developed in the United States, but is increasingly used elsewhere, notably in the European Community &mdash; although the EC exempts many areas of business to allow them to compete effectively in market sectors where the United States and Japan are strong. 
 (g) 
 Bribery 
 Bribery is a difficult area; what is illegal in one place may be almost mandatory in another. 
 The question is how far a company exports the mores of its own country to another (as the US tends to encourage by devices such as the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act, although this does at least exempt &bquo;greasing the palm&equo; of minor officials). 
 Responses range from bribing (as your competitors do) to refusing to bribe at all, but making adjustments (for instance to price) that will compensate for the bribe being offered and allow competition for a contract to be real. 
 (h) 
 GATT (The General Agreement of Tariffs and Trade) 
 GATT is an attempt to create stability in international trade relations, to which 92 governments are party. 
 The system exists on three principles: 
 (i) 
 each member must treat each other member's trade with equal consideration; 
 (ii) 
 protectionist measures are outlawed, so that open markets are guaranteed; 
 (iii) 
 export subsidies on manufactured goods are prohibited, and limited on primary products. 
 These principles are not completely applied. 
 One view of the system is that although formally an international agreement, it serves more to allow governments a way of countering internal pressures on trade than to regulate international trade relations. 
 PLANNING FOR INTERNATIONAL MARKETING 
 Topics covered in this chapter 
 Market opportunity 
 Global marketing information system 
 International marketing research 
 Some techniques for international marketing research 
 Marketing strategy alternatives 
 Competitive strategy 
 Marketing planning 
 Japan, the USA and the European Community 
 Marketing opportunity 
 A market opportunity exists when: 
 (a) 
 potential customer demand can be identified, and 
 (b) 
 the company believes that it is in a position to provide a product or service that would satisfy this demand profitably. 
 A story that is sometimes used to explain market opportunity concerns the managing director and marketing director of a shoe-making firm, who were visiting a less-developed country. 
 They found that a local custom in the country was to walk around barefoot at all times of the year and in all weathers. 
 The managing director commented, in despair, that the company could never sell shoes in this country, because demand for shoes was non-existent. 
 The marketing director, in contrast, replied with delight that an enormous marketing opportunity for shoes existed, because the entire population were potential customers. 
 This story draws attention to two points. 
 (a) 
 There is a difference between existing and potential markets. 
 A potential market might exist when there is not yet any such market in existence. 
 (b) 
 It is often the unresearched opinions of individuals that identify potential markets and market opportunities abroad. 
 (Research has suggested that this seems to be the case in many US and UK companies). 
 A more &bquo;scientific&equo; approach to researching market opportunities ought to be taken. 
 Ansoff has made a distinction between: 
 Existing demand Customers' needs are being met by existing products. 
 Demand can be measured or estimated. 
 Latent demand Customer needs are there already, but are not being met by existing products. 
 Demand cannot be measured or estimated, but demand will materialise if a suitable product and marketing mix are introduced. 
 Incipient demand Customer needs do not exist yet, but they will emerge if current trends continue. 
 Latent demand will then come into being, which can be exploited by a suitable product and marketing mix to turn into actual demand. 
 Internationally, incipient demand is important for marketing, because by projecting trends into the future, companies can estimate when latent demand will emerge, and can develop a marketing plan in advance accordingly. 
 The key elements of marketing 
 The key elements in marketing can be listed as: 
 (1) Customer needs (2) Product, price and place (3) Value (4) Promotion/communication. 
 Customer needs. 
 Identifying customer needs can enable a company to develop a product and marketing mix that give the company a competitive advantage over its rivals. 
 Needs will often differ from one country to another, or from one market segment to another. 
 Product, price and place (channels of communication). 
 These are three of the &bquo;4Ps&equo; in the marketing mix, the fourth being promotion. 
 These are elements in marketing that help to establish the company's market share and competitive performance. 
 Value. 
 A company's success depends on being able to provide greater value to customers than rival companies can. 
 Value can be defined by the formula: 
 V = Q + F / P where V = value provided by the company's product Q = quality of the product, as perceived by the customer F = features of the product that are valued by the customer P = price of the product to the customer. 
 Promotion/communication. 
 The company must be able to communicate to potential customers the way in which its product would satisfy their needs, and provide competitive value. 
 The strategic aim of marketing for a profit-oriented company should therefore be to identify market opportunities, in which: 
 customer demand can be created and met 
 in a way that gives the company a competitive advantage over rivals 
 and provides the company with a satisfactory return/profit. 
 Scarcity of resources and marketing opportunities 
 Companies are restricted by a shortage of resources from pursuing every identifiable marketing opportunity. 
 A number of choices have to be made, for example: 
 (a) 
 Should the company try to move into markets in different countries? 
 (b) 
 Which countries should be chosen for market development? 
 Opportunities ought to be compared and contrasted. 
 A function of marketing research is to provide information that will help opportunities to be identified, evaluated, compared and selected. 
 Market selection 
 Market selection means choosing the foreign markets in which the company will operate. 
 Paliwoda ('International Marketing') comments: 
 &bquo;It is a regrettable fact that the existing literature on the subject points to market selection as being an informal decision. 
 Often it is the result of a competitive move; or a chance sighting of a product from that particular market; the result of a business conversation or a chamber of commerce seminar; or a market is chosen simply because the target market is a pleasant location, the people are &bquo;nice&equo; and the managing director's wife enjoys going there on holiday! 
 Curiously, more attention appears to be paid to &bquo;industry talk&equo; than to the reports and publications produced by different trade and governmental bodies.&equo; 
 Global marketing information system 
 Any company that has plans for international marketing must build up or have access to marketing information about a large number of different countries. 
 (a) 
 Information is usually abundant in developed countries, and the problem is to choose reliable and sufficiently comprehensive information sources. 
 (b) 
 Information is usually difficult to obtain or unreliable in less-developed countries, and the problem is obtaining enough of it that is relevant and trustworthy. 
 Primary data will often be expensive to collect, and so companies will rely quite heavily on secondary data, despite its unreliability or scarcity. 
 The subjects or areas for which information about a country is required will vary according to the specific needs of each individual company. 
 It is not proposed to provide an exhaustive list of information requirements, but a broad guideline is suggested below. 
 Subject for a global marketing information system 
 Subject area Comments 
 A Market information 
 1. 
 Market potential Information about existing demand for existing products, the status of existing products, potential demand. 
 Current prices. 
 2. 
 Customer needs and attitudes. 
 3. 
 Channels of distribution. 
 What these are. 
 How well or badly they function. 
 4. 
 Communications and promotion. 
 What are the available media for sales promotion, and how effective/costly are they? 
 5. 
 The market place. 
 Where are the products actually bought and sold? 
 What form do the markets take? 
 B Competition and competitive strategy 
 1. 
 Competition Details about actual and potential competitors and their operations. 
 2. 
 Competitive strategy What is the company hoping to achieve in each target market? 
 What is its marketing strategy? 
 How well or badly is current strategy working? 
 C Foreign exchange aspects 
 The strength of the country's This will need to be assessed from matters such as currency the country's balance of payments, its inflation rate, real and nominal interest rates, the government's economic policies, and so on. 
 Exchange controls Controls on the outflow of foreign exchange, notably on the payment of dividends or fees to foreign companies, or the transfer price payments for goods from another part of the group in another country, or the transfer to the foreign holding company of proceeds from the sale of entire subsidiaries. 
 Restrictions availability of foreign currency to pay for imports. 
 Subject area Comments 
 D Taxation, legal and regulatory matters 
 1. 
 Rates of corporate taxation in Rates of tax on profits. 
 Taxes on dividends paid, the country abroad. 
 Tax allowances on new investments. 
 2. 
 Laws Laws that affect the operations of companies within the country. 
 3. 
 Regulations Regulations on product standards, safety requirements, and so on. 
 4. 
 Import controls Controls over imports from abroad, notably the supply of raw materials to companies from a foreign parent company, or the prices that can be paid for such imports. 
 E Resource information 
 1. 
 Men The availability, skills and cost of labour in the country. 
 2. 
 Materials The availability and cost of domestically-produced or imported raw materials and parts. 
 3. 
 Machines The availability of capital equipment. 
 New investment in the country. 
 4. 
 Money The availability and cost of finance in the country's financial markets. 
 5. 
 Companies, other organisations What other companies or partnerships operate already in the country, that might be a suitable target for a takeover, merger, joint venture, licensing deal etc? 
 F General conditions 
 1. 
 Political conditions 2. 
 Social and cultural conditions 3. 
 Economic conditions 4. 
 Other factors. 
 Information will be analysed by &bquo;units&equo;. 
 A &bquo;unit&equo; might be a group of countries, a single country, or a region within a country (eg California, the Southern States). 
 How much detail is needed? 
 The amount of information that is needed for a company's marketing information system will depend on the extent of its current involvement or potential interest in an overseas market. 
 W J Keegan ('Global Marketing Management') makes a distinction between: 
 surveillance, which is the &bquo;passive&equo; acquisition of information that becomes available, and 
 search, which is an active seeking out of information. 
 Investigation is an active but fairly informal search for specific information. 
 Research is an active and formally organised search for specific information for a specific purpose. 
 International marketing research in the gathering of information from search activities into international markets. 
 Sources of marketing information 
 The sources of &bquo;surveillance&equo; information, in practice, are mainly people rather than documentary sources or external data banks. 
 Source of information  Comments  
 1. 
 People 
 1.1 Within the company 
 In a multinational company, the main source of information about foreign markets comes from executives of the company, especially executives who are based abroad in the company's foreign subsidiaries. 
 Companies appear to rely on the perceptions of their own managers on the spot, with a loyalty to head office. 
 Head office managers often rely on obtaining information in face-to-face discussions with subordinates, and will happily assign large sums of money to travel budgets in order for meetings with executives abroad to take place. 
 1.2 External to the company 
 Distributors, suppliers, customers, government officials etc. 
 2. 
 Documentary 
 There are a number of publications and organisations that can provide market information about different countries. 
 (1) Official statistics will often be published on international consumer spending etc. 
 (2) There are trade directories and official market reports. 
 (3) Journals and periodicals often publish articles on foreign markets, and these are available at some libraries, 
 (4) Assistance for exporters is available from organisations such as (in the UK) the Department of Trade (British Overseas Trade Board) and even banks. 
 Personal perception 
 An executive might have a limited opportunity to see for himself/herself conditions in a foreign country. 
 Direct perception involves travel and time out of the office. 
 3 International marketing research 
 Marketing research involves a more active search for information than reliance on the sources listed above. 
 International marketing research can be defined as &bquo;research conducted to aid in making decisions in more than one country&equo;. 
 International marketing research differs from domestic marketing research because of: 
 the need for more information about environmental conditions and business conditions in the countries researched; 
 the need to carry out research in a variety of different contexts, environments (and languages). 
 It can be carried out by: 
 in-house staff or 
 an international marketing research organisation. 
 Since most organisations will not employ large research teams, in-house research will rely mainly (or entirely) on secondary data. 
 For primary data, a marketing research organisation is likely to be used. 
 &bquo;The diversity and complexity of the international environment, coupled with the frequent lack of familiarity with a foreign country, underscores the importance of undertaking research prior to making decisions. 
 This is true whether with regard to initial market entry decisions, product positioning or marketing mix decisions&equo;. 
 (Douglas and Craig: International Marketing Research). 
 Research can help a company to develop its global marketing strategy. 
 Research can help to prevent inappropriate market entry strategies, such as selecting an advertising campaign that fails to appeal to customers. 
 Research can help to avoid the missing of a market entry opportunity. 
 Research can help a company to re-formulate its product to suit national tastes. 
 Nestl&eacute;, for example, vary their instant coffee to suit the tastes of coffee drinkers in different countries. 
 Research can help a company to position its product in the market. 
 An example described by Douglas and Craig is the launch of the Renault 5 car some years ago. 
 A humorous advertising appeal was used in the domestic French market. 
 Research indicated greater concern in Italy with road handling and performance, and the car was launched there as &bquo;citizen of the world&equo; a comfortable car with good road-handling capabilities. 
 Research showed that West Germans were more concerned with technical reliability than good performance, and so advertising there was directed at technical features such as bodywork, engine power, braking performance, speed, petrol consumption and so on. 
 Research showed that Swedish customers were concerned about safety, and so the car was launched in Sweden with a campaign that emphasised safety mechanisms. 
 A further interesting example is the initial failure of an attempt by a US manufacturer of dishwashers to sell its product in Switzerland, promoting the dishwasher (without prior research) as a household convenience. 
 Swiss housewives rejected this appeal, apparently put off by the idea of being replaced in their homes by machines. 
 A subsequent successful re-launch of the product, based on research that revealed a Swiss pre-occupation with cleanliness, emphasised the germ-killing and hygienic aspects of the use of dishwashers. 
 A marketing research team should carry out its research within the following broad guidelines. 
 It should establish 
 what information is needed 
 why it is needed 
 how quickly/when it is needed. 
 It should try to collect the information as cheaply as possible. 
 Start with desk research, and use the company's own files or readily-available library sources, official statistics, databases, trade associations and so on. 
 If the information isn't available &bquo;locally&equo;, move on to secondary data from overseas sources. 
 When data is not available from published statistics, studies, existing reports and other secondary data, move on to direct collection of information (primary data), if this appears justifiable on cost/benefit grounds. 
 Only collect information if its actual or potential value exceeds the cost of collecting it. 
 Douglas and Craig (International Marketing Research) make a distinction between: 
 (a) 
 research information for strategic decisions such as the allocation of company resources between countries, products and markets. 
 As such, this information goes beyond pure marketing requirements; 
 (b) 
 research information for tactical decisions. 
 Tactical information 
 Marketing mix item 
 Type of research 
 Product policy decision 
 Qualitative research to generate ideas for new products. 
 Surveys to evaluate new product ideas 
 Concept testing. 
 Test marketing. 
 Product benefit and attitude research. 
 Product formulation and feature testing. 
 Pricing decisions 
 Price sensitivity studies. 
 Distribution decisions 
 Surveys of shopping patterns/behaviour 
 Surveys of distributor attitudes/policies 
 Advertising decisions 
 Advertising pre-testing 
 Advertising post-testing. 
 Recall studies. 
 Surveys of media habits. 
 Sales promotion decisions 
 Surveys of response to different types of promotions. 
 Sales force decisions 
 Tests of alternative sales presentations. 
 Secondary data 
 Secondary data provide an excellent starting point for many international marketing research projects. 
 Data 
 is readily available 
 is fairly inexpensive to acquire 
 can be analysed/consulted fairly quickly. 
 As a starting place for research, secondary data can pinpoint areas where investigation should be carried out in further depth, and so can help to provide the direction and focus area for further research. 
 &bquo;Secondary data also provide information relating to a wide variety of different aspects of international operations. 
 They cover, for example, economic data relating to the general business environment in a country. 
 They include specific industry data with a worldwide coverage. 
 In addition, other sources contain data relevant to specific marketing strategy decisions, such as information about demographic, economic, geographic, technological and sociocultural characteristics. 
 Also, they provide information about political, financial, foreign exchange, legal and regulatory data; data relating to the availability and character of distributive and communication networks and service organisations; and data about other physical, human and capital resources, which are needed in making market entry and investment decisions. 
 (Douglas and Craig International Marketing Research) 
 Direct research: surveys and samples 
 Information for strategic decisions will come mainly from secondary sources, but information for tactical decisions will rely more heavily on primary data. 
 When the direct collection of primary data is used in marketing research, the methods of survey (interview, questionnaire, observation) and the methods of sampling are broadly the same as for any &bquo;domestic&equo; marketing research exercise. 
 It is worth commenting, however, that any questionnaires should be designed with care. 
 The questions should be easy to understand and easy to answer. 
 This could be particularly important in less-developed or developing countries. 
 Embarrassing questions should be avoided. 
 What is embarrassing to respondents in one country might seem normal and &bquo;acceptable&equo; to respondents in another, and so there should be some &bquo;local knowledge&equo; input into questionnaire design. 
 &bquo;In multicountry research, the extent to which questions are formulated in precisely the same terms needs to be considered. 
 This is more likely to be feasible in relation to questions relating to demographic and other background characteristics, than for behavioural or product market data. 
 Greatest difficulty is likely to occur in relation to attitudual and psychographic data.' 
 (Douglas and Craig) Foreign market research will include an enormous scope for error, unless local nationals are used to gather data in the country concerned, because of ignorance about local markets and conditions. 
 Paliwoda (International Marketing) mentions the testing in China of the advertising slogan &bquo;Come alive with Pepsi&equo;. 
 Due to ignorance about the local language, the slogan was expressed in Chinese so as to mean &bquo;Pepsi re-awakens your dead relatives&equo;. 
 Data, once collected, should be analysed in two stages. 
 (a) 
 At country level, for the county unit. 
 (b) 
 By multi-country comparisons. 
 Comparisons between countries might be based on qualitative judgement, but a variety of quantitative techniques can be used for analysis. 
 Some of the simpler techniques will be mentioned later. 
 Problems with international marketing research Instead of analysing just one national market, international marketing researchers must analyse a number of national markets. 
 Each national market will have its unique characteristics. 
 Data will be more readily available for some countries than for others, and sources of data will differ. 
 Comparability 
 The research data from different countries will not always be directly comparable. 
 Official statistics are gathered and recorded in different ways between one country and another. 
 Even survey data gathered by the same multinational company might differ significantly between one country and another. 
 &bquo;Since decisions such as selection of target markets, segmentation strategy, or standardising marketing mix tactics cover several countries, it is important that the information on which decisions are based be comparable and consistent from one country to another.&equo; 
 (Douglas and Craig) 
 Example. 
 Suppose that Milwaukee Way Chocolates Inc is a multinational producer of chocolate bars, carrying out a market research survey into consumption of its chocolate bars in four different national markets. 
 The research data might be as follows.  
 In this example, the marketing research data might be useful for the management of the individual subsidiaries in Mexico, Canada, Spain and France, but management at Milwaukee Way's headquarters would not be able to extract data for global marketing information and inter-country comparisons. 
 The different age groupings, in particular, would make accurate comparisons impossible. 
 The research framework should be constructed to provide comparability of findings between one country and another. 
 (a) 
 Products in one country might not serve the same function as the same product in a different country. 
 Bicycles, for example, are used mainly as a method of transport in Holland, but for recreation in the USA. 
 Products that compete with bicycles differ between the two countries. 
 (b) 
 Concepts, attitudes and types of behaviour vary between one society and another. 
 Research into consumer attitudes and behaviour should recognise such differences. 
 (c) 
 Categorising data cannot easily be standardised. 
 As just one example, the grouping of occupations into &bquo;social classes&equo; might call for variations between one country and the next. 
 Products might be categorised differently too. 
 As just one example, beer might be seen as a soft drink in some countries (around the Mediterranean) and as an alcoholic drink in others. 
 Problems of comparability: examples. 
 1. 
 Car ownership per 100 of population. 
 In a country such as the UK, many cars are company-owned but available for private use. 
 This distorts the car ownership per 100 of the population to a low level compared with other countries. 
 2. 
 Population per square kilometre. 
 This can be distorted to comparatively low levels in countries with non-inhabitable areas, such as high mountain ranges, large deserts or extensive lakes. 
 3. 
 Retail systems. 
 Retail chains vary from being very long to very short. 
 In France, for example, there was a &bquo;quantum leap&equo; from small shops to hypermarkets, by-passing the &bquo;supermarket phase&equo; in retailing evolution. 
 Some techniques for international marketing research 
 There are several techniques that might be used in international marketing research that would not normally be used for research into &bquo;domestic&equo; markets. 
 Some techniques will be described here. 
 They deal mainly with the analysis of secondary data, rather than multi-country analysis of survey data. 
 Regional lead-lag analysis 
 This method of analysis works on the assumption that demand patterns in country or region B will follow demand patterns that have already been experienced in country or region A. The demand in country A can therefore be used to predict how demand will change in country B. 
 Obviously, the countries A and B must have similar social, economic and cultural climates, but with a sufficient time lag in demand to enable predictions to be made.  
 For example, it might be possible to predict the demand for desk-top minicomputers in West Germany or France from earlier demand for the product in the USA. 
 Lead-lag analysis is a fairly simplistic method of demand forecasting, and is not widely used. 
 (a) 
 There is a difficulty in measuring the time lag with sufficient accuracy. 
 (b) 
 It is questionable whether demand volume estimates based on lead-lag assumptions will be sufficiently accurately and reliable. 
 Estimating market demand by analogy 
 This technique might be used when there is no data available for estimating the total market size for a product. 
 It is only a rough-and-ready estimating method, but one which can be very useful (if its limitations are recognised). 
 (1) Cross section comparison. 
 A cross-section comparison works on the assumption that the current markets in country A and country B are analogous, and a relationship (correlation) exists in both countries between: 
 (a) 
 demand for the product; and 
 (b) 
 another factor. 
 Let Ax be demand for product A in country X Ay be demand for product A in country Y, which we are trying to estimate Fx be a factor for which data from country X correlates closely with demand for product A in country X Fy be a factor for which data from country Y correlates closely with demand for product A in country X. 
 It is assumed that: Ax = Ay Fx Fy 
 Thus, if values can be obtained for Ax, Fx and Fy, market demand for product A in country Y can be estimated as  A problem might be to identify the factor (Fx and Fy) for which data does correlate closely with demand for the product in country X. 
 (2) Displacing time comparison. 
 This allows a comparison to be made between markets in countries that are at a different stage in their development, but it is assumed that their development will follow a similar pattern. 
 Let Ax be demand for product A in country X in time period 1 Ayz be demand for product A in country Y in time period 2 Fx be a factor for which data in country X in time period 1 correlates closely with demand for A in country X in time period 1 
 Fyz be a factor for which data in country Y in time period 2 correlates closely with demand for A in country X. 
 It is assumed that  If Ax&bsol;, Fx&bsol; and Fyz are known, then market demand for product A in country Y in time period 2 can be estimated. 
 Estimating market demand by analogy has some obvious weaknesses. 
 (a) 
 It assumes that a single factor can be found that correlates closely with demand. 
 (b) 
 It assumes that the countries' markets are analogous. 
 (c) 
 It ignores the difference between actual demand and potential demand. 
 Even if it can estimate potential market demand in a country, actual demand will not materialise unless a similar situation applies to product availability, pricing, quality etc in both countries. 
 Income elasticity measurements 
 This approach to total market demand forecasting analyses statistics over time in a number of countries for: 
 (a) 
 gross domestic product (GDP) per head of the population, as a measurement of average income; and 
 (b) 
 the percentage of total manufacturing output (or total industrial output) made up by each major sector of the industry &mdash; for example, the percentage of total output made up by food and drinks production, textiles production, electrical goods, chemicals, metals and engineering, and so on. 
 The diagram above sketches this concept. 
 It is found, typically, that as GDP per head of the population rises from low levels, there is a rising percentage of total output made up of engineering goods, electricals, chemicals and so on, and a falling percentage of total output made up by &bquo;necessities&equo; such as food, drink and clothing. 
 Income elasticity measures the percentage change in demand for a product (eg electrical goods) given a small percentage change in GDP per head of the population. 
 Income elasticity of demand for any product will change as income per head rises, but when income per head is currently at a certain level, income elasticity of demand for a product can be estimated from the statistical analysis. 
 For example, suppose that the income elasticity of demand for electrical goods is +2.0 when GDP per head of the population is, say, &dollar;3,000. 
 Country A currently has a GDP per head of &dollar;3,000, which is expected to rise by 4% next year, and total market demand for electrical goods is currently &dollar;5,000,000 per year. 
 We can estimate that total market demand for electrical goods will rise by (2.0 O 4%) = 8% next year to 1.08 O &dollar;5 million = &dollar;5,400,000. 
 Regression analysis 
 Regression analysis is a statistical technique for predicting demand for a product (a dependent variable) from the value of one or more other factors (independent variables). 
 With linear regression, and using historical data (from countries for which such data is available) we can derive estimated values for a and b in the formula: 
 Y = a + b X where Y = demand for a product, typically expressed as the number of households per 1,000 of the population that own one of the product (a car, television, video recorder etc). 
 X = an independent variable, typically GDP per head or GNP per head of the population. 
 Demand for the product next year would be calculated from the formula by taking the difference between projected total number owned next year and total number owned currently. 
 The reliability of the statistical estimates can be measured by a coefficient of determination, Rs. 
 For example, the ownership of cars per 1,000 of the population might be estimated from historical data as follows. 
 (The figures are hypothetical).  
 Multiple regression analysis computer programs can be used to introduce other independent variables that might increase the statistical reliability of the regression equation (increasing the value of Rs towards 1.0) &mdash; in our example, perhaps, the cost of cars, the cost of petrol, the total length of roadway in the country, and so on. 
 Linear regression analysis is simpler, however, and the statistics from several countries can be combined together to produce a &bquo;conglomerate&equo; linear regression equation. 
 This can then be used to estimate demand for the product in another country for which statistics are not available. 
 Continuing with our example, suppose that the statistics for Brazil, Venezuela and Mexico are combined to produce a linear regression formula  where Y is the number of cars per 1,000 of the population and X is GNP per head of the population in &dollar;. 
 Now suppose that a car manufacturer wishes to estimate the demand for cars in Panaragua, a South American country, for which no data is available. 
 The current GNP per head of the population in Panaragua is &dollar;5,000, but this is expected to rise to &dollar;5,500 in the next 2 years. 
 The population of Panaragua is 4,000,000 people. 
 The &bquo;conglomerate&equo; regression equation could be assumed to apply to Panaragua.  
 The prediction would be for the ownership of cars to rise by 52,000 in 2 years, and so total market demand for cars in Panaragua in this period would be about 52,000 (or slightly more, allowing for old cars being scrapped). 
 Research has shown that in relation to many basic industrial commodities, such as paper, glass and cement, there is often a close relationship between total consumption (market demand) and GNP. 
 Douglas and Craig (International Marketing Research) comment that in some countries, there may be different market segments for the same product, where: 
 (a) 
 different factors influence demand, or 
 (b) 
 each segment is at a different stage of market penetration. 
 In such cases, it would be appropriate to use different &bquo;indicators&equo; of demand for each segment. 
 (a) 
 In the case of demand for diesel engines for small boats: (i) one market segment could be demand for pleasure boats, which might vary with income per head of the population; (ii) another segment could be demand for fishing boats, where demand might be dependent upon estimated sizes of fish haul, or length of coastline. 
 (b) 
 In the case of demand for hotels, market segments would be tourist visitors and business travel. 
 Factors influencing demand might be numbers of tourist visitors and growth in GNP respectively. 
 Comparative analysis 
 Comparative analysis is an international marketing research technique that is used to analyse the effectiveness of marketing expenditures. 
 Multinational companies will gather data about different countries in which they sell their products (and different regions within countries). 
 If there are thought to be sufficient similarities between the markets in two or more countries, comparisons can be made of selected statistics from each. 
 The selected statistics would probably include: 
 (a) 
 Total GNP 
 (b) 
 GNP per head of the population 
 (c) 
 Population size 
 (d) 
 Land area 
 (e) 
 Population per square kilometre 
 (f) 
 % dwelling in towns, % in rural areas 
 (g) 
 Television sets per 100 of population 
 (h) 
 Number of newspapers 
 (i) 
 Number of journals 
 (j) 
 Telephones per 100 of population 
 (k) 
 Road mileage 
 (l) 
 Largest cities, populations of each 
 (m) 
 Passenger cars per 100 of population. 
 If it is thought that there are some similarities between country A and country B in the market for microcomputers or car telephones or videocameras etc, a multinational company can analyse its market expenditures within both countries, comparing the effectiveness of these expenditures in each country. 
 From this analysis it can then try to identify ways in which marketing expenditure can be made more effective in each country. 
 S J Paliwoda (International Marketing) draws attention to the need to evaluate political risk in a country before taking a decision to set up operations within that country. 
 Although recognising that many such &bquo;Go, No-Go&equo; decisions are made after a brief examination by one or two executives, he argues that more &bquo;scientific&equo; or &bquo;realistic&equo; comparative methods of assessment should be used. 
 Business Environment Risk Index (BERI). 
 This is an index that assesses conditions for investment in each of about 50 countries. 
 Each country is rated (by a panel of local experts) on 15 economic, political and financial factors, on a scale of 0 to 4. 
 Each of the 15 factors is given a weighting, so that the total weighting for the 15 factors comes to 25. 
 The BERI value for each country is assessed by giving the country a score for each factor and applying the factor weighting, so that index values could in theory range from 0 (0 O 25) to 100 (4 O 25). 
 A score of over 70 can be taken to imply an already-advanced economy, and so not a particularly favourable climate for new investment. 
 A score of 55&ndash;70 will imply, mainly, developing countries with investment potential. 
 A score of 40 &mdash; 55 would include high risk countries, but with some possibility perhaps for profits that are reasonable in view of the high investment risk that would be involved. 
 A score of under 40 would indicate a very high investment risk, and so only in unusual circumstances would investment be worthwhile. 
 The Country Environmental Temperature Gradient. 
 This is an analysis of countries' environmental characteristics, and the classification of countries as &bquo;hot&equo;, &bquo;moderate&equo; or &bquo;cold&equo; on the basis of these characteristics. 
 (Countries can also be graded on a hot  cold scale). 
 (Litvak and Banting: 1968) 
 The categorisation of countries is re-assessed regularly. 
 The implications of this analysis are that: 
 (a) 
 in hot countries, the markets are dynamic, and a multinational company ought to seek greater control over the activities of the &bquo;middleman&equo; &mdash; ie over selling. 
 Companies are likely to seek ownership of operations within the country; 
 (b) 
 in cold countries, markets are not dynamic and investment would be more risky and difficult. 
 An international company is likely to rely on agents to sell its products to the country's markets. 
 Univariate and bivariate analysis 
 Statistical techniques can be used to compare survey data (primary data) collected in one country with survey data from another country, in order to test for similarities or differences between the countries. 
 Some of the simpler techniques are mentioned here. 
 Cross tabulation. 
 Survey responses from two different countries can be tabulated, and chi-squared tests used to assess the similarities/differences between them. 
 Illustration. 
 Which member of the family, husband or wife, makes the decision about the purchase of a dishwasher for the house? 
 (Hypothetical figures used for illustration). 
 Research findings  
 HW = Husband sees it as the wife's decision HJ = Husband sees it as a joint decision HH = Husband sees it as the husband's decision WW = Wife sees it as the wife's decision WJ = Wife sees it as a joint decision WH = Wife sees it as the husband's decision. 
 Here, chi-squared analysis would show a significantly greater decision-making role for the husband in Italy compared with the USA. 
 T-tests. 
 T-tests are a fairly simple way of testing for significance in the difference between the mean or proportion of a sample drawn from country A and the mean or proportion of a sample drawn from country B. 
 For example, a survey of 1,800 working women in France might show that 38% read at least one magazine weekly, and a similar survey in West Germany of 940 working women showed that 47% of them read at least one magazine weekly. 
 A t-test would show whether German working women appear to be significantly greater readers of magazines than their French counterparts. 
 Any significant differences could have implications for the selection of advertising media/overall marketing mix in each country. 
 Cluster analysis. 
 Cluster analysis is used to group variables, objects or individuals into groups or clusters of variables, objects or individuals that have certain similarities with each other. 
 In international marketing research, cluster analysis can be used to 
 group countries into clusters 
 identify different sub-groupings within all the countries researched. 
 Typically, countries are clustered on the basis of macroeconomic data such as GNP per head of the population degree of urbanisation, population size or density, between levels and so on. 
 Who should control international marketing research? 
 It might be apparent to you from a description of marketing research techniques that many of these techniques depend on comparisons between different countries. 
 For effective and useful comparisons to be made: 
 (a) 
 international marketing research efforts ought to be controlled from the headquarters of the multinational. 
 Research tasks will be delegated to operating subsidiaries in each country, but co-ordination and control should be tasks of head office; 
 (b) 
 the head office of the multinational should try to establish standard methods of research, so that data collected in each country will be more readily comparable; 
 (c) 
 head office will then have to channel the results of international marketing research back to its operating subsidiaries. 
 The marketing manager responsible for worldwide marketing research will: 
 (a) 
 respond to local conditions in each country, and arrange countries into groups or &bquo;clusters&equo; of countries with similar characteristics; 
 (b) 
 plan research programs that are tailored to the needs of each different &bquo;cluster&equo; of countries. 
 Marketing strategy alternatives 
 A company which decides to become &bquo;international&equo; or &bquo;multinational&equo; has to make some basic strategic choices. 
 (a) 
 About markets 
 Which product markets will be targeted? 
 In what sequence will they be targeted? 
 Which countries will be selected? 
 Which market segments in each country will be selected? 
 What objectives will be set for sales volume, market share and profits? 
 How should marketing operations within each country be organised and implemented to achieve these objectives? 
 (b) 
 About resources Decisions must be made about R &amp; D, production, delivery, pricing, promotion, direct marketing, profit margins and so on. 
 Where will the resources to make/supply the product come from? 
 Will materials, components, and the product be made internally or purchased from outside? 
 Where will the materials, components or product be made? 
 Or where will they be supplied from? 
 Setting up production facilities in a new target market will often be risky, even though labour might be much cheaper in the targeted country. 
 Exporting is often the cheapest and safest initial strategy. 
 As the market develops, setting up production facilities in the country will become a more financially-viable option. 
 (c) 
 About investment, finance and control 
 How much investment is required in each country, and how much is the company willing to invest? 
 As an alternative to 100% ownership and control, what about alternative arrangements such as a partnership or joint venture? 
 Will local partners help to overcome the company's lack of knowledge of the market? 
 Is there a legal requirement in the company for a minimum &bquo;local&equo; ownership of businesses in the country? 
 You may recall from your studies of Corporate Strategy that the identification of a market opportunity should result in the development of a product/market strategy. 
 For a manufacturing company, alternative product/market strategies are set out in the tables below.  
 Market expansion strategies  
 Example: market entry strategy in the USA for high-technology products 
 A survey by the London Business School into small British high technology firms in the USA found that: 
 management of such firms nearly always under-estimate the costs and lead times involved in establishing a market position in the USA 
 companies should concentrate initially on regional markets within the USA or specific market segments. 
 The entire US market is too large for small foreign firms to tackle 
 for innovation high technology products, success will depend on identifying a few early adaptors of the product 
 for established products, success may depend on winning a key customer, whose decision to buy will then influence other purchasers. 
 Marketing efforts should therefore be directed at one or two such potential key customers. 
 &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; many international marketing research projects. 
 Data 
 is readily available 
 is fairly inexpensive to acquire 
 can be analysed/consulted fairly quickly. 
 As a starting place for research, secondary data can pinpoint areas where investigation should be carried out in further depth, and so can help to provide the direction and focus area for further research.  
 I must have dropped off to sleep; next thing, someone was prodding me in the ribs with a rifle butt, and a voice was saying, &bquo;Come on, Piper. 
 Your turn to keep watch!&equo; 
 At first light the mortaring and sniping started. 
 The only difference was that the mortar bursts were further away than yesterday, some were even landing in the village. 
 The sniping was still fairly accurate and still concentrated in and around the orchard. 
 Someone brought me a mess tin half full of very hot tea; it tasted good. 
 Looking down towards the Orne I could see a thick mist over the water and patches of mist hanging over the cornfields. 
 Commandos were now moving about the road in front of the farmhouse. 
 This was a new day, D-Day 2, early in the morning. 
 I pulled out my grubby little diary from my hip pocket and entered the date, 7th June 1944. 
 Later, I made my way into the farmyard and joined a group having something to eat. 
 The porridge tasted very good (48-hour ration pack style) and hard tack biscuits ground down into the tea, not too bad. 
 Hoped to have something better by the evening. 
 The wounded were still in the barn as I entered to get my rucksack. 
 I looked inside it. 
 The bagpipes were still there, they had not played a note since yesterday afternoon. 
 Preparations were being made to evacuate the farm as I picked up my rucksack, slung it over my shoulder, and joined the others outside on the road. 
 We moved off in the direction of the crossroads, the scene of yesterday's action. 
 On reaching the crossroads, we moved quickly to the right, and up the very dusty road leading to  the village. 
 This was the road where the bagpipes had been hit by a piece of shrapnel. 
 About a hundred yards from the village we came under automatic fire from somewhere on our left, and continued the rest of the way walking in the ditch. 
 As we entered the village and turned right there were two dead German soldiers lying in the middle of the road. 
 They had no boots on. 
 At the entrance to the village and immediately on the right-hand side was a large house with a high wall round it. 
 At the entrance to the driveway were large iron gates. 
 A Commando opened the gates and Lovat entered, followed closely by about a dozen Commandos. 
 I looked round at the two dead Germans lying in the middle of the road. 
 they were being picked up by two Commandos and dumped on the grass verge. 
 It seemed strange to me that many dead Germans we had come across in the built-up areas after leaving the landing beaches yesterday morning had no boots on, some were even minus socks. 
 &bquo;What's happened to their boots and socks?&equo; 
 I asked one of the Commandos lifting the dead Germans. 
 &bquo;Bloody obvious, piper.&equo; 
 he replied, &bquo;There are bastards around just waiting for someone to cop it, then they dash out and pinch his bloody boots.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right,&equo; replied the other Commando, &bquo;If we had been screwed down by these Nazi bastards for four years, we would be doing more than pinching their boots.&equo; 
 I caught up with the others as they were entering the front door of the house. 
 Suddenly there was a long burst of machine gun fire. 
 It appeared to be coming from somewhere to the right, the bullets were hitting the house high up and smashing through the windows of one of the bedrooms. 
 I ducked down behind the garden wall until the firing ceased. 
 Then, after a couple of minutes, I entered the house in time to see Lovat and a few Commandos dashing upstairs. 
 They were in a bedroom at the left side of the house when I joined them. 
 A Corporal was indicating to Lovat where he thought the firing was coming from. 
 As we looked out of the shattered window and across the field opposite to where the Corporal was pointing, another burst of fire hit the house. 
 &bquo;There he is, Sir, in the corner of the field, close to the hedgerow.&equo; 
 The Corporal placed his Bren  gun on the window-sill and fired a long burst at the sniper's position. 
 There were a few cows in the field and they were wandering in the direction of the sniper's position. 
 Something was obviously attracting their attention. 
 The Corporal fired another burst and then he went off with two Commandos to find out the result. 
 After a few minutes we watched them crossing the field, alongside the hedgerow. 
 They returned a short while later stating that the sniper was dead. 
 The Corporal was carrying the dead German's Spandau, and the two other Commandos had a scruffy and shifty-eyed civilian by the scruff of the neck. 
 &bquo;This bastard was removing the sniper's boots when we arrived on the scene,&equo; stated the Corporal. 
 The shifty character was getting extremely agitated, waving his arms about and almost bursting into tears. 
 &bquo;What do you think we should do with him, Piper?&equo; asked the Corporal. 
 &bquo;Give him a packet of fags and tell him to piss off!&equo; 
 I replied. 
 Shifty-eyes had probably made up his mind that we were going to shoot him! 
 When he was handed the fags he could hardly believe his luck, he smiled broadly, revealing rows of black and yellow teeth, repeating over and over, &bquo; Merci, merci .&equo; 
 We were escorting him to the door when there was a loud explosion at the side of the house. 
 This was followed by two more, with the sound of shattering glass and lumps of plaster falling off the walls. 
 As we all dropped to the floor the shifty-eyed character bolted out of the front door and into a cloud of dust and pieces of masonry, caused by the explosions. 
 The mortaring stopped just as suddenly as it had started, and it was quiet again. 
 This house was to be Lovat's Brigade H.Q and it appeared that we were going to be there on high ground for some time. 
 The way things were going I thought it was time I had a slit trench to dive into. 
 I went outside and walked round the side of the house and into the orchard. 
 Commandos were digging in all over the place. 
 There was the usual sniping, but no one seemed to be bothering too much. 
 Yesterday when a shot was fired, everybody instinctively ducked and looked to where they thought the shot had come from. 
 In that sort of countryside  of hedgerows, orchards and narrow lanes, it was very difficult to assess where the shots were coming from. 
 Was it from somewhere close by, or from far off? 
 This was our second day in Normandy and I believed we were getting used to it. 
 &bquo;Hello there, Piper, you can dig in with me if you like.&equo; 
 I looked round. 
 It was Sid, the Commando with the Cockney accent who had worked in the Kent coalfields. 
 We had several conversations at the Concentration area at Southampton waiting for the invasion to get under way. 
 This was the first time I had seen him since the landings. 
 Sid had chosen a spot at the top of the orchard a few yards from the wall surrounding Brigade H.Q &bquo;We can have two trenches with one entrance,&equo; he said, &bquo;Your trench there, and my trench here,&equo; drawing a diagram with the point of his bayonet. 
 &bquo;What do you think, Piper?&equo; 
 &bquo;Suits me,&equo; I said, &bquo;but is it a good place to dig your trench under a tree?&equo;  
 He looked up at the apple tree and replied, &bquo;It makes no fucking difference, Piper, where you dig it. 
 If your name is on a mortar bomb and you get a direct hit, you have had it, no matter where you are!&equo; 
 The orchard was about two-hundred yards long by about three-hundred yards broad. 
 Thick hedgerows surrounded it on three sides. 
 On the right side the hedgerow ran parallel with the road as it sloped away down to the crossroads where we had had so much trouble yesterday. 
 The apple trees covered the whole orchard and were very close together, most of their branches touching each other. 
 The orchard thinned out at the top of the slope where we had started to dig our slit trenches. 
 A dirt track entered the orchard from the village road and ran down the side of the large house (Brigade H.Q). 
 A small cottage was on the left side of the track, opposite Brigade H.Q 
 The sniping continued all afternoon with occasional and sudden mortar explosions, mainly at the lower end of the orchard, resulting in the usual casualties. 
 The casualties were carried past our position on their way to the First Aid post. 
 This sight encouraged Sid and I to increase our efforts to finish off our double trench. 
 It was in the shape of a V with the entrance at the point of the V. We covered both trenches with large pieces of wood scrounged from the back garden of Brigade H.Q On top of the wood were placed thick pieces of turf which acted as very good camouflage. 
 It appeared that we were going to be there for some time. 
 I hoped this trench was deep enough, and the roof strong enough to give us some protection from the increasing mortar fire that was now coming our way. 
 We had our first main meal about 7 p.m. that evening. 
 Porridge, hard biscuits, a mug of tea, followed by very hard chocolate. 
 Not as good as yesterday evening when I dined on roast chicken, not very well cooked, but certainly much better than this homely fare. 
 I must have a look round later, maybe look in at the big house, and see what Shimi Lovat and his officers were having for dinner. 
 Sid had finished checking the Bren gun and the ammunition. 
 He placed the Bren on the turf at the entrance to the orchard from the village road. 
 The evening was fairly light at 10 p.m. 
 So Sid and I sat  just outside the trench discussing the events of the day, and swatting mosquitoes. 
 These Normandy mosquitoes were the largest and most persistent that I had ever encountered. 
 The air was thick with them, and lumps were beginning to appear on my hands and face as they thrust their needle-like heads into my skin. 
 &bquo;Christ!&equo; remarked Sid &bquo;These fuckin' mauses are worse then the mortars and the sniping. 
 Good job you are not wearing your kilt, Piper. 
 You would soon have lumps on your most tender spot. 
 Not that it would make much difference in this bloody place. 
 Fat chance of us running into any crumpet out here!&equo; 
 &bquo;You never know, Sid,&equo; I replied as I swatted a mosquito that had landed on my wrist, and watched the blood splatter from it. 
 Christ, I shall have no blood left if these little bastards continue to have a go at me! 
 We wrapped camouflage squares round our heads and faces as some protection and jumped into the trench. 
 At 11 p.m. a terrific barrage commenced. 
 At first I thought it was the naval guns out in the Channel. 
 Their shells had been passing over our positions from time to time all day, with a loud rush that sometimes appeared to shake the trees. 
 This barrage was much closer and more concentrated, the shells passing over appeared lower than the shells from the Naval guns, and the noise more intense, the guns appeared to be firing from the bottom of the orchard. 
 &bquo;Those bloody guns are close,&equo; I remarked to Sid. 
 &bquo;They are about half a mile or so away,&equo; he replied, &bquo;and, most important, they are our guns. 
 The more shit they throw over at the Jerries the better. 
 There is only one problem, Piper, with so many guns firing over our heads. 
 there is always one or two shells drop short and some poor bastards are going to stop a lump of shrapnel.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're a cheerful bastard!&equo; 
 I remarked, as we both ducked down into the trench. 
 For the next few minutes I had to put up with Sid's reminiscences about how much worse it had been during the campaign in North Africa. 
 The shelling continued until about midnight, then suddenly it stopped. 
 The German guns then opened up but not to the same extent. 
 They seemed further away, their shells passing over very high up and crashing into the area of the Orne  canal. 
 The German shelling lasted about twenty minutes, one gun continued to fire, starting with a clear crack, then the sound of the shell passing over, followed by the explosion as it hit the ground. 
 l was somewhat fascinated by this German gun. 
 I found myself listening for the distinct crack, then gazing up at the clear starry sky trying to follow the flight of the shell. 
 &bquo;Piper,&equo; Sid's voice from the back of his trench sounded agitated, &bquo;I'm knackered, and these bloody mauses are eating me alive! 
 Do you mind if I have a fag? 
 The smoke may help to keep them away, then I'll go first on the gun.&equo; 
 I'm knackered myself, I thought, as I sniffed the smoke from Sid's fag. 
 It's going to take more than one fag to get rid of these mosquitoes. 
 Sid finished his cigarette and took his place at the Bren gun. 
 I crawled into my trench, adjusted the camouflage square over my face and head, curled myself into a ball and tried to get some sleep. 
 There was very little sleep last night, our first hours ashore in Normandy, maybe tonight we could have some rest. 
 I hoped so. 
 I must have dropped off to sleep but was awakened by Sid kicking my boots. 
 &bquo;For Christ's sake, Sid, I've just got my head down. 
 What the bloody hell's going on?&equo; 
 &bquo;Listen, Piper, first, you have been sleeping for the past hour, and second, I think the Germans are counter attacking. 
 There's a lot of shelling and mortaring going on at the other end of the village.&equo; 
 But it's only 2.15 a.m! 
 I exclaimed. 
 &bquo;Surely they won't attack at this bloody hour?&equo; 
 I crawled out and joined Sid at the Bren gun. 
 Suddenly two shells landed in the orchard. 
 The explosions seemed just a few yards away. 
 We both dived back into our trenches, pulling the Bren and ammunition behind us. 
 The noise was ear-splitting as more shells landed in the orchard. 
 I braced myself against the sides of the trench and listened to the explosions and the debris landing on the roof. 
 It seemed like my last day had come. 
 This was the end this time. 
 My heart was pounding in my chest, the mosquitoes and everything else forgotten. 
 After about half-an-hour the shelling ceased and the mortar attack took over, continuing until about 4 a.m., just as dawn was breaking. 
 During the shelling and mortaring I  had heard nothing from Sid's trench. 
 He was probably just as shit scared as I was. 
 As soon as the mortaring finished we crawled out to the entrance to the trench, and manned the Bren gun. 
 The sky was now getting fairly light, and it would soon be stand-to, so there would be no going back into the trench to get the head down again. 
 We hadn't spoken to each other since Sid woke me up, just before the shelling started. 
 As we both stood staring through the slight mist wondering what would happen next, Sid broke the silence. 
 &bquo;You know, Piper, I was so shit scared during the bombardment that I lay on the floor of that trench and prayed. 
 We certainly don't want any more of that fuckin' lot,&equo; he continued. 
 &bquo;Anyway, Piper, you lucky bastard, you had an hour's kip, I've had nothing yet.&equo; 
 The Duty Officer appeared out of the mist. 
 &bquo;You lot in there OK?&equo; 
 &bquo;We're OK, Sir,&equo; Sid replied. 
 &bquo;How are the others around the orchard?&equo; 
 &bquo;We have had a few casualties,&equo; the Officer replied. 
 &bquo;Also one or two direct hits on slit trenches.&equo; 
 As he was moving away, he paused, and looking round at us with a smile on his face, he said, &bquo;Oh yes, and a direct hit on the newly-dug shithouse&hellip; shit everywhere!&equo; 
 He was gone before we could reply to his last remark. 
 &bquo;Why don't you get your head down now, Sid? 
 There'll be no one round for some time, I'll stay with your gun.&equo; 
 &bquo;OK, Piper, think I will,&equo; Sid replied, as he crawled into his trench. 
 He poked his head out almost immediately and exclaimed, &bquo;direct hit on the shithouse &mdash; shit all over the place&hellip; that's all we need!&equo; 
 From 6 a.m. the morning was fairly quiet, except for the occasional sniping. 
 Sid was awake at 7 a.m., still complaining of feeling tired. 
 It had just crossed my mind that I had not had my boots off since the evening of the 4th June and it was now 8th June. 
 I would have liked to take them off but the situation was still uncertain, and everyone still believed that the German forces were determined to push us off this high ground east of the Orne. 
 Two Commandos had taken their boots off yesterday evening and found after a couple of hours standing to they were unable to get them on again, both feet had swollen badly. 
 It would be too bad if the Panzers overran our positions and we were found to be  in our stocking feet. 
 I went along to Brigade H.Q The Officers and other ranks were looking just as knackered as the rest of us out in the orchard. 
 Reports from the Commando units around the village told of determined German counter attacks during the night with many casualties. 
 While in the big house, I had a look at my bagpipes. 
 The large drone was beyond repair, but the two tenor drones were in good working order and, most important of all, the chanter was OK. 
 I repaired the large drone as best I could, using a piece of sticking plaster from the First Aid kit, and then decided to try them out. 
 But where? 
 Certainly not there in Brigade H.Q 
 In the centre of the village was a fairly large building that looked like a church. 
 The very place for a little bagpipe practice, I thought. 
 My tiredness had now almost disappeared as I made my way along the drive of Brigade H.Q and out into the village. 
 The village green was oval shaped, with the road entering at one end and houses along one side, with a large chateau, a farm and a row of houses on the other side. 
 The church-like building was on its own in the centre of the green. 
 As I entered the building I could see that it was damaged, probably by mortars, or shellfire. 
 At the far end was a small hall with tables and chairs piled up along the walls. 
 I started up the bagpipes and was soon under way, marching up and down the church hall. 
 The pipes were going well considering the damage inflicted on them during and after the landings. 
 I was very pleased, not only with the pipes, but also that I was now playing them again. 
 I had been playing for about five minutes when there was a very loud explosion very close at hand. 
 I stopped playing just as the church door burst open and a very irate Officer came charging along the pews in my direction, his eyes bulging out of their sockets. 
 Obviously he was not very pleased about something. 
 &bquo;Something wrong, Sir?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;Something wrong!&equo; he exploded. 
 &bquo;Don't you fucking well know that the enemy have been mortaring the village green for the past four or five minutes while you have been playing those fucking bagpipes?&equo; 
 &bquo;But, Sir&hellip; 
 &equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;Don't you but me, and stand to attention when  you address an Officer. 
 I am going straight from here to report this matter to the Brigadier,&equo; he bellowed, as he charged along the pews and out of the door. 
 Placing the bagpipes in my rucksack I made my way back across the green to the orchard, expecting a summons at any moment to appear before Shimi Lovat. 
 The mortaring had ceased. 
 Maybe the Officer had a point, that this was no place to play bagpipes. 
 From now on I would only play on special invitation. 
 Several hours later I had not heard anything of the incident, so it seemed likely that the Officer had not reported the matter, or Lovat had just shrugged it off. 
 Anyway, I would stay away from Brigade H.Q for the time being. 
 Sid was sitting under the apple tree next to our slit trench as I approached. 
 He had a Jerry can in front of him, and a large grin on his face as he remarked, &bquo;Piper, I have the answer to those bloody mosquitoes!&equo; 
 He paused, then pointing to the Jerry can, he said &bquo;Petrol! 
 We shall soak the walls of the two trenches with this stuff, also soak the camouflage squares before wrapping them round our heads, then we can settle down tonight free of mosquitoes.&equo; 
 &bquo;But where did you get the petrol, Sid?&equo; 
 I enquired. 
 &bquo;Never mind where it came from, just give me a hand to splash it around.&equo; 
 We gave the walls of both trenches a good soaking, saving some petrol for later. 
 I did not like the idea very much as Sid was a smoker, and if he lit up during the night it was possible that we both could end up with a Blighty, or worse! 
 &bquo;Right, Piper, what we want now is something to eat. 
 I scrounged the petrol, now you can use your influence in the big house. 
 I'm sure those fucking Officers are not eating the same crap as we are.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's rather difficult for me to show my face at Brigade H.Q at the moment,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;I suppose it is, Piper. 
 I heard you playing your bagpipes in the church and when the Germans started to throw shit all over the village green, I knew that some bastard would be having a word with you. 
 Trouble is, Piper, some people do not appreciate good music, especially when they are dodging flying shrapnel. 
 Promise me, Piper,&equo; Sid continued &bquo;You will not play those pipes in this orchard!&equo;  
 &bquo;Not without an invitation to play them,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;You're not fucking likely to get that! were Sid's last words as he walked off in the direction of the latrine. 
 About 2 o'clock that afternoon, three Allied planes came over the coast and started to drop supplies by parachute. 
 The canisters were landing in a cornfield about half-a-mile away. 
 A Sergeant dashed up and shouted, &bquo;Come on, Piper! 
 Let's get down there and see if we can get some of those supplies.&equo; 
 He had a Corporal with him and we doubled to the front of Brigade H.Q and clambered aboard a jeep that had a trailer attached. 
 We roared off down the road from the village in the direction of the River Orne. 
 The aircraft were still dropping the canisters as we came near to the dropping zone. 
 The Germans had also noticed the canisters and were directing fairly accurate mortar and shell fire in and around the dropping zone, to prevent the Commandos, or anyone else, picking them up. 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ!&equo; remarked the Sergeant, who was driving the jeep, &bquo;Just our bloody luck.&equo; 
 He stopped the jeep at the edge of the cornfield, and we observed that the mortar and shell fire were following the canisters as they were landing, leaving a few canisters lying on the ground not far off from where we were. 
 the Sergeant started up the jeep and we entered the cornfield at speed, heading in the direction of the first three canisters. 
 We loaded the first two into the trailer, and were heading a few yards further on to pick up a third canister when we noticed that the enemy fire was now being directed at our part of the cornfield. 
 The Germans could probably see us now and had the jeep as a target. 
 We decided to forget about the third canister and made off across the cornfield at speed, the jeep bouncing up and down on the very uneven surface. 
 The Corporal and I shouted at the Sergeant to step on it, as the explosions were getting closer. 
 We finally made it to the road and sped along towards the village in a cloud of dust, the three of us crouching low in the jeep. 
 We reached Brigade H.Q a few minutes later and drove the jeep round to the back of the house where we unloaded the canisters. 
 One canister was filled with weapons and ammunition, the other full of tinned food, cigarettes, and several bars of thick chocolate. 
 We danced a little jig around the food, hardly believing our luck. 
 The tinned food  was of the self-heating variety and contained a full and varied menu. 
 That evening Sid and I dined off piping hot oxtail soup, steak and kidney pie, followed by a very rich plum duff, all washed down with a bottle of French cider, given to us by the old Frenchman who lived in the cottage near the entrance to the orchard. 
 The old man was delighted with the packet of cigarettes Sid had given him in exchange for the cider. 
 The time was just after 9.30 p.m. and beginning to get dusk. 
 There was an unusual quietness in the air, except for the sound of artillery in the distance and the occasional whine of a sniper's bullet through the orchard. 
 I was sitting under a tree opposite our trench, chatting to a Scottish friend. 
 Duncan was dug in at the bottom of the orchard and had called in for a chat on his way from Brigade H.Q He was very interested in bagpipe music, having served with the Gordon Highlanders before joining the Commandos. 
 Sid was sitting on the roof of his trench soaking his camouflage square with petrol from the jerry can. 
 He wrapped the square around his head and face, securing it with a knot under his chin. 
 He gave me the thumbs up sign then disappeared into his trench. 
 Duncan and I had been talking for about ten minutes or more and swatting the increasing number of mosquitoes that always arrived in force at this time of the evening. 
 Duncan looked at his wrist watch, and rising to his feet said, &bquo;I had better be going now, Piper. 
 Don't want to be caught out in the open when Jerry starts up. 
 The best place is in your own wee dug out.&equo; 
 He had hardly got to his feet when there was a muffled explosion from Sid's trench, followed by Sid catapulting out from the entrance, his head a mass of flames. 
 He ran screaming down through the orchard somehow missing collision with the trees, and clutching at the burning camouflage square. 
 &bquo;That silly bastard has forgotten about the petrol and has tried to light a fag!&equo; exclaimed Duncan. 
 Someone shouted from a slit trench near at hand, &bquo;Great &mdash; what some bastards will do to get a Blighty.&equo; 
 When I reached Sid, someone had brought him down and extinguished the flames. 
 The knot under his chin was still firmly fastened and he had extensive burns on his head and face. 
 Two medics  arrived and carried him off to the First Aid Post. 
 I made my way back up the orchard. 
 It was almost dark now and everyone had settled into their dugouts, prepared for another night of shelling and mortaring. 
 The Sid incident was probably forgotten as soon as he was carried away. 
 He was just another casualty. 
 Things had certainly changed since those days back in England. 
 This was the third night in Normandy. 
 It was midnight and the mortaring and shelling had started about 11 p.m. 
 I had pulled the two heavy pieces and wood across the entrance to the trench. 
 It seemed strange without Sid next door, and the barrage seemed much worse than yesterday evening. 
 About 3.30 a.m. there was a noise like a low-flying aircraft zooming very fast overhead followed by something very heavy hitting the ground. 
 &bquo;It's a bomb,&equo; I thought, as I braced myself against the walls of the trench waiting for the inevitable explosion. 
 The only sounds were the mortar explosions and the unmistakable noise of a shell passing overhead, followed by the characteristic thump as it hit the ground. 
 I soon forgot about the heavy object as I was finding it very difficult to keep awake. 
 How many more nights were we to do without sleep? 
 There had been several German counter attacks on the Commando positions around the village during the past three days. 
 The way things were going the enemy seemed very determined to push the Brigade off this high ground. 
 I moved closer to the entrance to the trench, pushed aside one of the heavy pieces of wood, and looked up at the sky. 
 It was getting light. 
 The German barrage seemed to be slackening off a bit, though the Allied guns were still firing over our positions, their shells shaking the trees as they headed toward the German trenches with a loud swish as they passed overhead. 
 This was the start of a new day. 
 Friday, day four. 
 &bquo;I could certainly go a mug of hot tea,&equo; I thought, as I examined my lumps and bumps caused by the ever-persistent mosquitoes. 
 Sid's petrolsplashing around the walls of the trench had, I believe encouraged the little bastards, they seemed to like the smell of petrol. 
 All the mosquitoes in the orchard were in my trench last night, or so it seemed! 
 About 8 a.m. 
 The orchard was fairly quiet. 
 The shelling and the mortaring had ceased except for the occasional  explosion near at hand. 
 I brewed a mug of tea using the small block of tea, milk and sugar, crushed into a mess tin of water and brought to the boil. 
 It tasted good, but the only resemblance to tea was in the tealeaves floating on the top of the liquid. 
 I was nursing my mug of tea with both hands and taking short sips of the very hot liquid when a Commando arrived at the trench, stating that he had come to take Sid's place on the Bren gun. 
 He was a seriouslooking Welshman whom I had met several times back in England and around the orchard. 
 &bquo;How's it going, Boyo? 
 Too bad about Sid. 
 Just call me Taff.&equo; 
 Taff continued talking in his very strong Welsh accent as he inspected the Bren, asking questions and giving himself the answers before I could get a word in. 
 When I finally got through to Taff to enquire about what sort of night he had had, and if there had been many casualties during the barrage, his reply was rather matter of fact. 
 &bquo;A bad night, Boyo, and a few wounded here and there.&equo; 
 He continued, &bquo;That friend of yours, the Scotsman, Duncan something or other, he was called out during the night to deliver something to 45 Royal Marine Commando. 
 He went by jeep and on his way back to Brigade H.Q he ran over a German mine and was killed.&equo; 
 Taff kept on talking, but I did not hear what he was on about. 
 The news about Duncan's death was quite a shock to me. 
 I could hardly believe what Taff had just said. 
 Taff prodded me with the butt of the Bren gun. 
 &bquo;You're not listening to me, Boyo,&equo; he exclaimed, a look of annoyance on his face. 
 &bquo;What were you saying, Taff?&equo; 
 I enquired. 
 &bquo;I was saying &mdash; any more of that fucking horrible tea?&equo; 
 He was smiling. 
 I hadn't seen him smiling before. 
 &bquo;Don't take it too bad, Piper,&equo; he continued. 
 &bquo;The way things are going we shall lose more of our friends, or it could be us next time round. 
 Don't you think I'm a cheerful bastard, Boyo?&equo; 
 &bquo;You're a cheerful bastard right enough,&equo; I replied, as I climbed out of the trench. 
 &bquo;Think I'll make my way over to the big house and see how things are going.&equo; 
 &bquo;OK, Boyo, see you later,&equo; Taff replied. 
 About twenty feet from the trench, in the centre of the dirt track leading to  the road two Commandos were standing peering into a large hole in the ground. 
 &bquo;What's in the hole?&equo; 
 I enquired as I approached. 
 &bquo;Look's like the base of a large shell or bomb,&equo; replied one of the Commandos. 
 I looked down into the hole. 
 It must have been about fifteen to twenty feet deep and a few feet across. 
 At the bottom of the hole were two figures hammering at the base of the object. 
 I immediately recognised one of the Officers. 
 It was the Officer who had turfed me out of the church yesterday when I was playing the bagpipes. 
 &bquo;What is it, Sir?&equo; 
 I shouted to the Officer. 
 He looked up and stopped his hammering for a moment. 
 &bquo;It's an unexploded bomb, Piper, and if it had gone off last night a lot of you silly buggers would have gone with it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Probably you as well, Sir,&equo; I replied, &bquo;Your own trench is just over the wall in Brigade H.Q&equo; He glared up at me and before he could say anything I beat a hasty retreat. 
 What a way to spend the morning, hammering away at the base of a bomb that is likely to go off at any moment. 
 As I quickened my pace in the direction of Brigade H.Q I was thinking: &bquo;That is the Officer who said that I  was mad!&equo; 
 At the rear of the big house I met Mick, the Irishman, who invited me to share his meal. 
 &bquo;Not bloody steak and kidney pudding again!&equo; 
 I remarked. 
 &bquo;You had better take your time eating this lot, as it's the last of the tinned food you helped to get out yesterday.&equo; 
 He thrust a mess tin full of steak and kidney into my hand, and with a scowl on his face he remarked, &bquo;After this lot, Piper, we are back to the usual shit, unless something special turns up, like cooks and normal rations!&equo; 
 We sat chatting for a few minutes after finishing our meal. 
 I could hardly keep my eyes open. 
 I was exhausted, no sleep last night, and very little the previous nights. 
 &bquo;For Christ's sake, Piper, get into that slit trench and get your head down. 
 I'll give you a shout in two hours&equo; time.&equo; 
 Mick picked up his rifle and the mess tins and made his way towards the house. 
 I clambered into the trench and was asleep before my head hit the ground. 
 It seemed that I was asleep for just a few minutes when I was awakened by some noisy bastard shouting into the trench. 
 &bquo;Come on, come on,  Piper. 
 Are you going to lie there all day? 
 You have been asleep for the past two hours.&equo; 
 I opened my eyes and looked up at Mick's grinning face, leaning into the entrance to the trench. 
 &bquo;For Christ's sake, Mick. 
 What time is it?&equo; 
 I enquired. 
 &bquo;Never mind the bloody time, Piper. 
 I have a message for you, and when you get out of the trench don't forget to keep your head down.&equo; 
 It appeared that a German S.P. gun had joined the snipers and was lobbing the occasional shell into the vicinity of the orchard. 
 Mick's head disappeared from the entrance to the trench as I sat up and listened to a shell burst close by. 
 Later, over a mug of tea, I asked Mick about the message he had for me. 
 &bquo;Oh yes, Piper. 
 No. 45 Royal Marine Commando have been enquiring about you and would you pay them a visit either this evening or tomorrow evening.&equo; 
 I knew a few of the Marines. 
 I had joined them on their route marches out of the concentration area at Southampton. 
 Others I had met at the Commando Training Centre in the Scottish Highlands. 
 &bquo;Do you think they want me to bring along the bagpipes?&equo; 
 I asked Mick. 
 Mick looked at me for a couple of moments and, scratching his head, he replied If the Marines want you to play your bagpipes in their area, and you agree to do it, then you are all bloody mad. 
 Don't you know, Piper, that they are closer to the Germans than we are? 
 Not much closer mind you, but certainly closer.&equo; 
 Mick was right. 
 The Brigade positions had been under attack for the past four days and Nos. 3, 4, 6, and 45 Royal Marine Commando had been having their share of casualties. 
 I decided to visit the Marines that evening and, after thanking Mick for his hospitality, made my way back to the orchard, thinking that as I had visited each Commando unit each day when we were in England, why not now that we were in France? 
 About 8 p.m. that evening Taff and I sat at the side of our slit trench eating what I thought was a rather dubious lump of meat. 
 Taff said it was lamb. 
 &bquo;Where the bloody hell would you get lamb out here?&equo; 
 I questioned. 
 &bquo;Well, Boyo. 
 You see that field over there, plenty of it?&equo;  
 The field Taff was referring to certainly had animals in it, but they were all lying on their backs, their legs in the air, dead for at least three or four days. 
 Some had been killed outright by flying shrapnel, others had been badly wounded and had died slowly. 
 It is always sad to see the wounded animals. 
 Three days ago on our way up here we passed a field with two horses standing at a five-bar gate. 
 Both animals had huge shrapnel wounds on their hindquarters. 
 The blood had dried on the wounds leaving gaping holes showing the bones. 
 The horses gazed at us as we passed by. 
 I looked back, they were still standing there showing no signs of pain. 
 I felt sad, and a little guilty. 
 I put the piece of meat back into the mess tin. 
 &bquo;Not hungry, Boyo?&equo; 
 Don't worry, we have plenty left for later.&equo; 
 Taff carried on eating his large piece of lamb. 
 For the next half-hour we watched hundreds of Allied planes bombing the town of Caen a few miles away from our positions. 
 The Germans were certainly getting a pasting. 
 Clusters of fire bombs falling from the planes, followed by tons of high explosives. 
 The bomb-bursts could be seen through the huge pall of smoke and dust that hung over the city. 
 just after 9 p.m. 
 I left the orchard to visit the Marine Commandos. 
 Taff was chatting to the 3 mortar team that had moved into the orchard that afternoon. 
 They had set up their mortar about twenty yards from our trench, and periodically fired off a couple of bombs in the direction of the German positions. 
 A thick cloud of mosquitoes had arrived on time and soon settled on everything and everybody. 
 On my way through the village I met a member of the French Commando. 
 He was escorting three German prisoners in the direction of Brigade H.Q The Germans were doubling along, their hands held high in the air, a look of apprehension on their faces. 
 As the Frenchman doubled past behind the prisoners he shouted a greeting. 
 &bquo;Ow are you, Beel? 
 &bquo;Ow are you bagpipes? 
 Come an&equo; veezeet us, but not your bagpipe!&equo; 
 &bquo;See you tomorrow,&equo; I shouted after him. 
 The Marine Commandos were well dug in in a wooded area just off the road and close to the village. 
 The other Commando units were spread around the village in a very tight perimeter,  and in places very close to the German positions. 
 Brigade H.Q was just at the entrance to the village with everyone within walking distance of each other. 
 The Marine position was very similar to where I was dug in. 
 The same mosquitoes, the same sniping and mortaring going on. 
 &bquo;Hello, piper. 
 Nice to see you. 
 Sorry about the noise and the mosquitoes.&equo; 
 The voice was Tony's. 
 He was walking towards me, his hand outstretched. 
 As we shook hands and started to walk along a narrow path in the direction of a few slit trenches, Tony remarked, &bquo;Big change out here from the South Coast of England, or the wilds of Achnacarry! 
 Or maybe you prefer the cold and the rain of the Commando Training Centre?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Achnacarry is not so bad once you get used to it,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;Well, Piper, here we are. 
 This is our forward area and the Germans are not far off.&equo; 
 Tony stopped at a slit trench. 
 &bquo;I think it would be safer if we continued our conversation in the trench. 
 Things are beginning to hot up a little.&equo; 
 We dropped down in to the trench and Tony produced a couple of tins of Compo rations. 
 As we ate, I asked him about 45 Marine Commando casualties since the landing. 
 &bquo;You probably heard, Piper, that our C.O., Lieut. -Colonel Reis, was wounded early on, and Lieut. 
 Colonel Gray is now in command. 
 You will meet him if you decide to stay here tonight. 
 there have been other casualties, killed and wounded. 
 You remember &bquo;Egg and chips twice,&equo; the Biblethumper who used to come into that little caf&eacute; with his girlfriend every evening when we were in billets on the South Coast? 
 He was killed about an hour and a half ago during a German counter attack on our positions. 
 His body is still here in the woods with three others killed in the same action.&equo; 
 I cast my mind back to the South Coast of England. 
 Les was a bit of a lay preacher, but did not push his views on anyone. 
 He got the name Egg and chips twice' because, each time he came through the door of the caf&eacute; with his girlfriend, he would shout to the caf&eacute; owner, &bquo;Bert, egg and chips twice.&equo; 
 I could never understand why he did it as there was nothing else on the menu but egg and chips! 
 He and his girlfriend would organise meetings in the local  Baptist hall and his girlfriend would play classical music on the piano. 
 Occasionally, two other musicians would accompany her, playing violin and flute. 
 After the music, Les would preach a short sermon, say a prayer, then he and his girlfriend would serve tea and biscuits. 
 No one could understand why he volunteered for the Commandos. 
 He did not seem the type, yet he passed his course at Achnacarry with flying colours. 
 Les was popular with everyone and I felt very sad about this news of his death. 
 The time was now 11.30 p.m., the Germans were putting up their flares. 
 The eerie lights would hang in the air for quite some time then the mortars came over to burst at the edge of the wood. 
 &bquo;Don't you think it's about time you pushed off, Piper? 
 They will be wondering what has happened to you. 
 This mortaring is going to continue for some time.&equo; 
 I clambered out of the trench and Tony escorted me back to the road. 
 We met one of the Medics who informed me that the bodies of Les and the other three Commandos had been taken through the village and laid out with the other dead in front of the Chateau. 
 &bquo;Goodnight, Piper,&equo; Tony shouted after me, &bquo;Hope to see you again sometime, when these German bastards have pissed off home. 
 Bring your pipes and give us a tune.&equo; 
 The night sky was still fairly light as I walked through the village, passing close to No. 6 Commando positions. 
 At the entrance to the grounds of the Chateau I could see a few Commandos. 
 As I approached I recognised one of them as a Medic from Brigade H.Q As we chatted together, I could see a number of dead Commandos lying on the lawn in front of the Chateau. 
 They were in rows, and each body was covered by an Army blanket. 
 &bquo;Where are the four Marine Commandos who were killed this evening?&equo; 
 I asked the Medic. 
 He pointed to the four bodies at the end of the row. 
 &bquo;That's them, Piper, over there.&equo; 
 I went over to the body nearest to me, the rubber soled Commando boots sticking out from under the blanket. 
 I drew back the blanket and uncovered the head of the body. 
 It was Les, he had a large wound in his chest, caused by a piece of shrapnel. 
 I replaced the blanket over his head and stood for a few  moments looking at the bodies in their neat little rows. 
 The sky was getting darker and the silhouette of the Chateau was casting a long shadow of gloom over the scene. 
 I made my way back to the orchard at Brigade H.Q, the time about 12.30 a.m. 
 The Allied guns had just started up as I entered the orchard. 
 Taff was with the 3&ins; mortar team as they continued to send over the occasional mortar bomb, their target a crossroads at the other end of the village. 
 &bquo;How's things with the Marines?&equo; 
 Taff enquired as we walked in the direction of our trench. 
 I was quite surprised at his reaction when I informed him of the death of &bquo;Egg and chips twice&equo;. 
 He turned away for a few moments and I could see that he was upset by the news. 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ, Piper. 
 He should have been the last person to be killed. 
 Look at all these blasphemous bastards that are still walking around this orchard.&equo; 
 He indicated who he was talking about by drawing his arm in a wide sweep around the orchard. 
 The guns firing from the direction of the River Orne were making it difficult for me to hear what Taff was now saying. 
 We got into the trench and listened to the swish as the salvoes passed overhead. 
 The four Commandos on the 3&ins; mortar were still firing their bombs, each as it left the muzzle of the mortar making a distinctive musical sound like someone blowing down a length of drainpipe. 
 &bquo;Right, piper. 
 I'll get my head down first, you stand by the gun and give me a shout in two hours&equo; time. 
 By the way, Piper,&equo; he continued, &bquo;why don't you sleep over at the big house? 
 I'm sure it must be more comfortable there.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, Taff, It's just the same at the big house, slit trenches and mosquitoes. 
 Anyway, I prefer to be with all you scruffy bastards out here.&equo; 
 Taff disappeared to the back of his trench, cursing the mosquitoes and muttering a Goodnight, Boyo. 
 The shelling from the Allied guns seemed to be much more intense this evening. 
 The time was now just after 1.30 a.m. 
 An enemy flare was lighting up the sky at the other end of the village, probably over No. 6 Commando positions. 
 I wondered how they were getting on. 
 I would pay them a visit this evening, our fifth day in Normandy. 
 The Marine Commandos looked exhausted, some of them appeared to be about to  drop off to sleep on their feet. 
 I had been very lucky, so far. 
 I had been able to have a couple of hours' sleep here and there since the landings and, most important, I was able to move around more or less as I wanted to. 
 No doubt No. 6 Commando were having a rough time in their area. 
 At 3 a.m. 
 Taff joined me at the gun. 
 &bquo;Had a good sleep, Taff?&equo; 
 I enquired. 
 &bquo;Not a fucking wink, Boyo. 
 Between the noise of the bloody guns and clouds of bloody mosquitoes buzzing around my head, all I've had for my two hours is more mosquito lumps on my face, and I'm more tired than ever., Taff and I chatted while he sat on the floor of the trench smoking his cigarette. 
 &bquo;You know, Boyo, this is the start of our fifth day here in Normandy and we have been stuck in these bloody slit trenches having all kinds of shit thrown at us. 
 Well, Piper,&hellip; 
 &equo; Taff continued, dragging on his cigarette, &bquo;&hellip; something must happen very soon. 
 Either we attack the enemy positions, or they are going to attack us in strength. 
 We just cannot sit it out here all the time or we'll all go mad.&equo; 
 &bquo;No&equo; matter what happens, Taff, first, I am going to get my head down.&equo; 
 I glanced up at the sky, &bquo;It's going to be light pretty soon.&equo; 
 I moved to the back of my trench as Taff stood up to man the gun. 
 I made myself as comfortable as possible on the floor of the trench, wrapping the camouflage square round my head and face in a vain attempt at protection against the mosquitoes. 
 Fiona's face seemed very real as I closed my eyes and scenes of the Highlands passed before me. 
 This was the first time she had come into my thoughts since I left England. 
 I opened my eyes, she was still there, just looking at me, no smile on her face. 
 &bquo;For Christ's sake, Piper. 
 Are you going to lie there all fucking day? 
 Don't you know that there is a fucking war on? 
 Come on, now&hellip; 
 Wakey, wakey!&equo; 
 I sat up, removed the camouflage square from around my head and crawled to the entrance to the trench. 
 Taff thrust a mug of very hot tea into my hands. 
 He appeared to be in a very good mood about something. 
 &bquo;Morning, Taff, thanks for the tea.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look, Piper, if those German bastards had overrun this  position, you would be a dead bloody duck by now!&equo; 
 Taff continued talking as I sipped at my tea. 
 &bquo;You know, Boyo, it's going to happen very soon, whatever it is. 
 I would say this morning, or tomorrow evening, the 11th. 
 All that shelling last night, the activity on the road this morning, things seem to be moving.&equo; 
 &bquo;Looks like it, Taff,&equo; I agreed. 
 As I gazed around the orchard the sun was coming up and there was that peculiar smell of the Normandy countryside. 
 Everything was peaceful except for the whine of a sniper's bullet through the trees and the sound of the mortar crew sending the occasional bomb to explode at the distant crossroads. 
 &bquo;Maybe this lot will know what's happening, Taff.&equo; 
 A jeep entered the orchard and stopped a few yards away. 
 &bquo;Christ, Piper, that's all we need, the bloody Navy!&equo; burst out Taff as two sailors got down from the jeep and started to unload their gear. 
 Taff and I watched fascinated as they set up their equipment, then started to dig a slit trench. 
 From the way they were digging it was obvious that they had no idea what it was all about. 
 The sailors stopped digging when the trench was about one foot deep, then they sat down and lit up their cigarettes, gazing around the orchard, taking not the slightest notice of the mortar team just a few yards from them. 
 They both soon scattered when a mortar bomb burst at the entrance to the orchard, sending shrapnel whistling through the trees and thudding into the walls of the little cottage just a few yards away. 
 As we emerged from our holes in the ground, the two sailors looked a bit sheepish. 
 Taff approached them with the remark, &bquo;You will have to do better than that, Boyos. 
 You have to get right down as far as you can. 
 That was just one near miss, you both may not be so lucky next time!&equo; 
 With that, Taff started digging while I searched around for timber to place over the trench. 
 The sailors rewarded Taff for his efforts with several packets of cigarettes. 
 I accepted a tin of pipe tobacco and two boxes of scented soap to trade with the old man in the nearby cottage. 
 Half-a-dozen fresh eggs would go down very well with Taff and I this evening. 
 The old Frenchman was delighted with the tobacco and soap and he insisted that I join him in a drink. 
 I  clambered over the wall separating his garden from the orchard and followed him into the cottage. 
 The interior was just as I expected from the books I had seen at school. 
 The flagstone floor, the long, bare wooden table, the low roof with the open fire and a large pot hanging from a heavy chain secured somewhere up the chimney. 
 A woman and three children got up from the table as I entered the room. 
 They all stared at me wide-eyed and continued to stand and stare even after I had sat down at the table. 
 The old Frenchman motioned for them to sit down and continue with their meal as he opened a cupboard and took out a bottle and two glasses. 
 He joined me at the table and poured out two generous measures of the clear liquid from the bottle. 
 The Frenchman lifted his glass and, holding it out in front of him, spoke one word Churchill. 
 I was so surprised I immediately responded with &bquo;de Gaulle.&equo; 
 He emptied his glass in one gulp and I followed suit, only to end up spluttering over the table, coughing, with eyes watering, gasping for breath. 
 As I regained my composure I could see a wide grin on the Frenchman's face. 
 He spoke one more word, &bquo;Calvados.&equo; 
 I had never heard of it before, but it was certainly something that I would look out for in the future with much apprehension. 
 The woman and three children were now laughing and I was pleased about that, as they had looked scared stiff when I entered their house a few moments before. 
 The Frenchman shook my hand and as I looked at him and his family I thought slowly to myself, &bquo;What a bloody chance he is taking. 
 Here I am, a British soldier, and he and his family are being friendly towards me. 
 The sea can still be seen from the orchard and it is possible at this stage that the German Army could push the Commando Brigade back into the sea. 
 And if that happened? 
 This family would probably end up in a concentration camp somewhere in Germany. 
 The Frenchman interrupted my thoughts by offering me another glass of the deadly Calvados. 
 I quickly declined his offer by shaking my head and putting my hands above my head in mock surrender. 
 The woman and children burst out laughing again, getting up from the table and crowding round me. 
 The family could not speak English and my  schoolboy French was almost exhausted so I bade them good afternoon but managed to make them understand that I would have dinner with them one evening soon &mdash; &bquo;An English dinner.&equo; 
 They all shook hands with me, and the Frenchman gave me a bag containing one dozen eggs before I clambered over the wall and into the orchard. 
 Taff was sitting on the grass just outside the trench, cleaning the Bren gun as I approached. 
 He nodded his head in the direction of the Orne river and remarked, &bquo;Those guns have started early, Boyo. 
 Hear all that shit going over? 
 Next thing Jerry is going to start up!&equo; 
 I could hear the salvoes going over as Taff got into his trench and indicated that I should get into mine. 
 As I crouched down in the trench I thought of the French family just a short distance away from us. 
 They would probably be down in their cellar. 
 They seemed to take everything so calmly, the shelling, the dead animals lying around, British soldiers all over the place. 
 I wondered how they would take to steak and kidney pudding, oxtail soup, and plum duff. 
 My mind had suddenly switched to my dinner date with the French family. 
 If the Brigade was still around the village and things got a bit quieter I would keep that date, and treat them to British steak and kidney, etc. 
 As expected, the Germans replied to the shelling with a heavy mortar attack on the area around the orchard. 
 When the shelling and mortaring ceased, Taff and I got out of the trenches. 
 As Taff started to cook the first half-dozen eggs I went along the road that ran around the village and passed near to the orchard. 
 As I expected, the jeeps were now arriving with the Commando dead and wounded from the areas around the village. 
 A jeep stopped just outside Brigade H.Q The two stretchers it carried contained two bodies, each wrapped tightly in an Army blanket. 
 I walked over and spoke to the driver. 
 &bquo;These are Airborne blokes,&equo; he said, &bquo;and there are plenty more just outside the village. 
 It appears that the Airborne and Commandos got caught up in the shelling and suffered casualties, dead and wounded.&equo; 
 The next jeep had two French Commando wounded aboard. 
 One was lying on his back on the stretcher and  appeared to be badly wounded. 
 The other, whom I recognised at once from the camp at Southampton and from the training centre at Achnacarry was sitting u&ndash; on the stretcher cursing his bad luck in getting a piece of shrapnel in his leg. 
 The two Frenchmen had one thing in common. 
 They both had that deathly pallor that showed on every soldier who had been wounded. 
 The Frenchman waved to me as the jeep sped away down the road. 
 As I gazed after the jeep, I thought &bquo;Those two, I suppose, are lucky in a way, they are alive and have a Blighty! 
 The two Airborne lads in the first jeep are dead &mdash; their war is over.&equo; 
 I remained at the roadside for a few minutes, sitting on the grass with my back to a low wall. 
 The occasional jeep was still passing by with its dead or wounded aboard, raising a cloud of dust as it turned out of the village and sped down the slight hill toward the Orne bridges. 
 The heavy mortar in the orchard was sounding its usual musical note as the high explosive left its barrel to fall in the enemy positions a short distance away, no doubt causing casualties, just as their mortars did when the high explosive landed in the Commando positions. 
 I got up from the grass and made my way back to the orchard as Jerry started to drop his shells in the dust cloud left in the wake of the speeding jeeps. 
 As Taff and I crouched in our trenches eating our afternoon meal and trying very hard to ignore the clouds of mosquitoes that were buzzing all around us, I looked at Taff. 
 He was eating his food, and, I thought to myself, &bquo;Christ, how he has changed his appearance after five days living in a hole in the ground!&equo; 
 He looked tired, his eyes seemed to be open wider than usual. 
 Of course, everyone I had met today had this wide-eyed look; the wounded, the jeep drivers, and the Commandos occupying the weapon pits. 
 Five days and four nights subjected to shelling and mortaring and the ever-present sniping. 
 Lack of proper sleep had affected everyone, in one way or another. 
 I continued to look at Taff as he cleaned around the inside of the mess tin with his forefinger and drawing the finger across his lips with a slow gesture. 
 He must have sensed that I was looking at him, he suddenly glanced at me out of the corner of his eyes and, still cleaning the mess tin with his finger, he said quietly,  &bquo;Why are you staring at me like that, Piper? 
 Have you never seen a Welshman eating his dinner, or do you think that I am going bomb-happy?&equo; 
 Before I could reply a shell burst a short distance away sending a hail of shrapnel tearing through the branches of the trees above us. 
 As Taff and I ducked down into the trench I upset the remains of my meal over the floor. 
 Taff raised his head and grinned at me and, shouting above the din, remarked, &bquo;don't worry about me, Piper, I'm all right. 
 Just a bit down today.&equo; 
 The grin left his face as he mentioned that he had been informed about an hour ago that his brother-in-law, who was a member of No. 4 Commando, had been killed during a German counter attack on the Commando positions. 
 It was most unusual to see Taff down like this and as I gave him my condolences I was thinking that the sadness was beginning to reach almost everyone. 
 The shelling had stopped now and it was certain that someone had been killed or wounded, maybe the chap in the next slit trench a few feet away. 
 As I clambered out of the trench and made my way across to Brigade H.Q I could see the jeep with the stretchers on top waiting at the entrance to the orchard. 
 A body wrapped in an Army blanket was being placed on one of the stretchers and a Commando with a bad face wound was being helped into the seat next to the driver. 
 As I reached the road the jeep roared off with its dead and wounded, leaving in its wake the usual cloud of dust. 
 I hurried along keeping close to a wall and waiting for the inevitable mortar burst that would follow in the path of the jeep. 
 A few seconds later there was a loud explosion in a hedgerow just off the road, a short distance away. 
 Yesterday morning at the crossroads leading to the village a jeep carrying wounded Airborne troops received a direct hit by a mortar bomb killing everyone on board. 
 At Brigade H.Q the Brigade Major was just leaving as I arrived and there was no sign of Shimi Lovat. 
 He was probably visiting one of the forward units at the village perimeter. 
 Mick informed me that the Brigade Major had gone to pay No. 4 Commando a visit, so I decided to make my own way there and keep out of the Brigade Major's path as much as possible. 
 No. 4 Commando positions were being heavily mortared  when I arrived, and Jock, my friend of many years ago, took me off to find some shelter in a dug-out, giving at least some protection from the flying shrapnel. 
 A short distance through the woods the Brigade Major was keeping his head down. 
 Jock laughingly informed me that when he had arrived in the area there had been a short quiet spell. 
 The German mortaring had suddenly stopped and the Brigade Major was standing out in the open talking to an Officer when, just as suddenly, the mortars started up again, sending their bombs swishing through the trees and sending the Brigade Major diving for cover. 
 &bquo;You've picked a fucking good time to pay people a visit!&equo; 
 Jock remarked. 
 &bquo;This had been going on almost all the time since yesterday, with two German counter attacks on our positions.&equo; 
 Jock seemed out on his feet, his head kept jerking forward and his eyes were continually closing. 
 I'm sure if it wasn't for the explosions close at hand he would have dropped off to sleep. 
 &bquo;Well, now that I am here it looks like I shall stay until things quieten down. 
 Let's hope the Germans don't decide to counter attack this evening.&equo; 
 &bquo;How is Lovat?&equo; 
 Jock enquired. 
 &bquo;He's OK,&equo; I replied, &bquo;Don't see much of him. 
 These days are very worrying for him, I suppose. 
 I'll tell you one thing, Jock, with Lovat in command there will be no retreat from these positions. 
 If the Panzers come through here before we have sufficient equipment ashore, you and I and every bastard in this Brigade have had it, including Lovat.&equo; 
 Jock was on his feet and leaning on the parapet of the trench. 
 He had picked up the Bren gun and was gazing to the left of the wood and pointing the gun in the same direction. 
 The mortaring had eased off a bit. 
 Now the German barrage seemed to be concentrating on the edge of the wood about a hundred and fifty yards to our left. 
 The concentrated explosions were throwing lumps of dirt and large pieces of wood in all directions. 
 &bquo;As you were saying, Piper, if Jerry breaks through the Brigade's positions, every bastard has had it,&hellip; maybe this is it coming up?&equo; 
 The light was fading and it was getting difficult to distinguish what was happening. 
 &bquo;What do you think is happening, Jock?&equo; 
 I enquired.  
 &bquo;It could be another attack on our positions, Jock replied. 
 &bquo;They usually mortar the area first, then come across the fields. 
 This morning they attacked the Marine positions and partly overran them, Piper,&equo; Jock continued, &bquo;You certainly picked a fucking good time to pay No. 4 Commando a visit. 
 It's quite possible you won't be leaving here tonight!&equo; 
 He had hardly finished his remark when there was a terrifying roar overhead as a salvo of shells crashed into the area near to where the Germans had been mortaring. 
 I his was followed by another salvo crashing nearer to the German positions. 
 Jock exploded with a mouthful of oaths. 
 &bquo;The silly bastards have landed that first salvo in our positions. 
 Jesus Christ! 
 Things are bad enough without our own guns shelling us!&equo; 
 It appeared that the naval guns, about five or six miles back in the English Channel, were either trying to break another German attack or were just shelling the enemy positions! 
 Whatever the Navy's intentions, their shells were landing in the Commando positions and causing some havoc. 
 There were loud cries of protest from around the wood as the Commandos were forced to keep well below ground. 
 &bquo;Are you staying here for the remainder of the night?&equo; 
 Jock enquired. 
 &bquo;I don't know,&equo; I replied, &bquo;It's just as bad back at Brigade H.Q We also have the Navy dug in with us in the orchard. 
 Up until now the naval salvoes are landing in the German positions somewhere in front of No. 6 Commando, at the other end of the village. 
 So, for the moment, our problem is not with the Navy observers who are directing the naval guns, it's with the increasing number of guns firing over our positions from the direction of the River Orne. 
 From time to time a shell or two falls short and we have several casualties.&equo; 
 &bquo;Talking about fucking casualties, there's not very many left of No. 4 since we landed at La Breche on Tuesday!&equo; 
 Jock's voice was raised as he continued to describe the events over the past five days: &mdash; The attack on the Casino at Ouistreham and the eventual capture of the town by the British and French of No. 4 Commando. 
 The noise of the exploding mortars in the wood and the accompanying rattle of small arms fire drowned the rest of Jock's words. 
 As I  looked at him sitting opposite me on the floor of the trench, I was fascinated by his resemblance to the other Commandos I had met over the past five days. 
 The same indescribable appearance of the eyes, probably caused by the constant lack of sleep and the strain of being on the alert all the time. 
 &bquo;Do I look like him?&equo; 
 My thoughts were interrupted by Jock saying very quietly, &bquo;If you are thinking of getting back to H.Q, Piper, I advise you to piss off as soon as you can.&equo; 
 The evening was now getting dark, but light enough to see my way. 
 As a last attempt at conversation, I asked Jock, &bquo;Tell me, why do they call you Jock? 
 You have an English accent, why the Jock?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, you silly bastard,&equo; he replied, &bquo;My father was born on the Scottish side of the Border and my mother on the English side. 
 I was born on the English side, but prefer to be Scottish. 
 Now fuck off Piper while the going is good for you.&equo; 
 He had a smile on his face as we shook hands. 
 The German mortars were exploding on the other side of the wood as I clambered out of the trench and made my way through the trees in the direction of the road. 
 Two explosions in quick succession made me throw myself to the ground. 
 They seemed so close, just behind me! 
 A voice from a slit trench close by shouted, You all right, Piper? 
 &bquo;Yes, I'm all right,&equo; I shouted back. 
 I lay on the ground for a few moments; there were no further explosions. 
 As I warily got to my feet I felt a compulsion to retrace my steps in the direction of Jock's trench. 
 He lay on the grass, a large open wound on the back of his head and one of his legs was missing. 
 His green beret lay close by. 
 A piece of shrapnel had hit his cap badge and had penetrated the front of his skull. 
 The cap badge with its St Andrew's Cross split in two brought a lump to my throat as I stood rooted to the spot. 
 Stretcher bearers were quickly on the scene, taking two wounded Commandos away and leaving Jock lying on the grass. 
 There was nothing they could do for him. 
 No doubt they would return and place him with the other Commando dead in neat rows in front of the Chateau to await burial. 
 German flares were lighting up the sky behind me as I hurried along the road, keeping close to the houses and in  their shadows as much as possible. 
 Away to the left across the fields, and probably in the area of No. 3 Commando, flares were going up, followed by very rapid rifle and machine gun fire. 
 The German Spandaus with their very fast bursts made them easily distinguishable from the British automatic weapons. 
 &bquo;How are things at No 4 Commando?&equo; 
 Taff enquired as I jumped down into the trench beside him. 
 &bquo;Not too good,&equo; I replied, &bquo;Anything to eat or drink? 
 I'm starving!&equo; 
 As Taff poured me a good measure of cider and handed me a boiled egg and a chunk of meat I described the situation at No. 4. 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ, Piper!&equo; 
 Taff exclaimed, &bquo;It's a wonder there's anyone left out there!&equo; 
 &bquo;Not many of the original lot that landed at La Breche five days ago,&equo; I replied, &bquo;There have been a lot of casualties since the landing, many of them caused by mortar fire over the past few days. 
 This, combined with very determined German counter attacks, is keeping everyone on their toes all the time, plus the lack of proper sleep is beginning to take its toll.&equo; 
 Taff had a couple of mouthfuls of his cider and, placing the empty mug on the floor of the trench, he remarked, &bquo;At least one thing, Piper. 
 We are all in the same boat out here. 
 You can be just as dead in this orchard as in any other around the village. 
 Furthermore, Piper, I won't be in this trench tonight,&equo; continued Taff, rising to his feet and climbing out of the trench. 
 &bquo;I shall be manning a weapon pit on the left side of the village. 
 You can come along if you want to, Piper. 
 It won't be as comfortable as this, but the fucking Mausers are the same, and the shelling and the mortaring, so we should feel at home.&equo; 
 I agreed to accompany Taff. 
 He picked up the Bren gun, I collected the ammunition and we made our way out of the orchard. 
 I was still chewing on the chunk of meat Taff had given me. 
 &bquo;What kind of meat is this?&equo; 
 I said, holding it out on the palm of my hand. 
 &bquo;Look, Boyo, it's the best Normandy lamb, it just dropped dead in the field over there this morning.&equo;  
 &bquo;The same lamb you put a rope round the neck of and then chased into the German minefield?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right, Boyo. 
 You know as well as I do that you cannot take an animal unless it's dead and that animal died in the minefield.&equo; 
 We arrived at the weapon pit at the side of the road and close to a low wall. 
 This is going to be great, I said to Taff as we settled ourselves in the trench and set up the Bren gun. 
 The mosquitoes had already arrived in force and made us feel as if one trench was very much like another. 
 The view from this weapon pit was very different from the one in the orchard. 
 In the semi-darkness the houses around the village and the church in the centre of the green stood out like monuments with their shadows changing their shapes from time to time as a cloud obscured part of the moon. 
 The Allied guns behind us sent a few shells rushing over our heads from time to time. 
 The Commando mortar team over in the orchard made its presence known by dispatching a single H.E. 
 bomb every few minutes, their target the German-occupied village about three-hundred yards along the road. 
 The musical sound as the bomb left the barrel of the mortar still fascinated me. 
 &bquo;Don't you think the sound of that mortar appears musical in some way, Taff?&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe to you, Piper, but I'm bloody sure the unfortunate bastards at the receiving end of the high explosive do not appreciate its musical talents. 
 Now, Piper, you try to get some sleep. 
 No use two of us standing here by the Bren.&equo; 
 As I wrapped myself in my gas cape and crouched down in a corner of the trench, I gazed up at the sky. 
 The night was calm and warm with just a slight rustle of a breeze in the trees. 
 The mosquitoes were hanging like a cloud over us. 
 They seemed to be everywhere. 
 Taff was standing by the gun swatting the mosquitoes that were landing on his face. 
 The shelling had increased and it was difficult to sleep because of the noise and, above all, the persistence of the mosquitoes. 
 I got to my feet and stood by Taff at the gun, both of us staring out into the night. 
 For the few brief minutes when the shelling ceased the scene before us looked  very peaceful. 
 &bquo;Are you married, Piper?&equo; 
 Taff suddenly asked, turning to look at me. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; I replied, &bquo;haven't found the right one yet. 
 Are you married, Taff?&equo; 
 Taff turned away and, staring straight ahead, answered, &bquo;Yes, piper. 
 I have a wife and a year-old son back in Cardiff. 
 I was married when I was twenty. 
 I am now twenty-five years old. 
 Christ knows if and when I will see them again.&equo; 
 I looked at Taff. 
 His face was half-hidden by the shadow of the tree behind us. 
 Before I could say anything he continued with, &bquo;You must have a girlfriend somewhere, Piper, a smart-looking bloke like you.&equo; 
 This was more like the usual Taff. 
 He could slip out of his depressed moods very quickly. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; I replied, &bquo;I have one here and there. 
 Nothing serious., 
 &bquo;What about the one up in the Highlands, Piper? 
 Isn't she something special? 
 I've heard that you and her were more than friendly when you were on the staff at the C.B.T.C.&equo; 
 I tried to change the subject by commenting on the lack of activity in front of our position. 
 Anyway, it was good that Taff was back to his old self. 
 &bquo;It's no good trying to change the subject, Piper, I know all about your activities with the crumpet. 
 You are a right crafty bastard as far as women are concerned.&equo; 
 We both started to laugh as I had the last few words on the subject. 
 &bquo;I should be so lucky!&equo; 
 The shelling had started again. 
 One or two shells were dropping short. 
 It was my turn to be concerned. 
 &bquo;We won't stand much of a chance if a shell lands near or on this trench,&equo; I remarked apprehensively. 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ, Piper. 
 You are a right cheerful bastard tonight. 
 Look at those flares going up over No. 6 Commando positions.&equo; 
 Taff was pointing at two bright flares hanging in the sky over the farm a short distance away. 
 There followed a lot of automatic fire and the usual crump of mortars. 
 &bquo;Seems like there is something special going on over there tonight, Taff. 
 All the shelling has probably got Jerry worried and he anticipates an attack.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look, Piper. 
 As I mentioned to you yesterday, those  bastards are going to attack us, or we shall be attacking them tomorrow, certainly on the following day.&equo; 
 All this increased activity, the shelling and mortaring, with the German counter attacks on the Brigade's positions increasing. 
 As Taff was talking he was looking around in front of our position. 
 He suddenly stopped talking and, gazing intently through the semi-darkness to our left, he said excitedly., &bquo;Piper, do you see anything moving about in that field over there?&equo; 
 About a hundred and fifty yards away I could just make out three figures crossing at the corner of the field and approaching the road in our direction. 
 &bquo;They can't be our lot,&equo; Taff whispered, &bquo;That's Jerry's positions over there.&equo; 
 He swung the Bren gun round and putting the butt to his shoulder, he whispered, &bquo;Right, Piper. 
 Get your rifle sights on that lot.&equo; 
 The three figures were now almost at the road and out in the open when Taff opened fire with a long burst. 
 I opened fire on the leading figure. 
 The first two fell to the ground and the third figure disappeared into the hedgerow, followed by a long burst of fire from Taff's Bren. 
 We continued to stare at the corner of the field for some time, expecting to see some movement. 
 &bquo;We got the first two! 
 Taff said excitedly, &bquo;The other bastard seems to have got away.&equo; 
 &bquo;It will be light in about another hour,&equo; I said, &bquo;Then we can see the results.&equo; 
 The shelling and mortaring had almost died away, except for the occasional round from the mortar team back in the orchard. 
 We were both fairly tired, having had no sleep all night. 
 &bquo;You try to get some sleep, Taff. 
 You have at least an hour. 
 I can always catch up with my sleep later on this morning. 
 Anyway, you will be allowed some rest after spending all night out here.&equo; 
 OK, Piper. 
 I think I will. 
 Taff lay down on his back on the floor of the trench, oblivious to the mosquitoes and everything else and was soon snoring loudly. 
 One very important thing that I had noticed since we landed in Normandy five days ago was  that no one had any problem with insomnia. quite the reverse. 
 I found myself talking to someone and watching him go to sleep on his feet. 
 I awakened Taff at first light (for stand-to) as the early morning Normandy mist was gathering over the fields and hedgerows. 
 A slight breeze was blowing from the left, bringing with it the stench of a dead bloated cow that was lying against the five-bar gate leading to a field. 
 There must have been dozens of dead animals lying around, most of them killed by shrapnel or having wandered into a minefield. 
 &bquo;How's it going, Piper?&equo; 
 Taff said sleepily as he stood up, then leaned over the side of the trench, his head resting on the grass. 
 Before I could answer his questions he remarked slowly, &bquo;You know, Boyo, I had a bloody good dream. 
 I dreamt that I was in Cardiff and in bed with the wife. 
 I was away from this fucking place for a while.&equo; 
 Looking at his watch, he stood up, &bquo;Great what you can do in an hour, Piper. 
 That dream was as good as my last leave.&equo; 
 &bquo;Glad you enjoyed it, Taff,&equo; I answered as we both climbed out of the trench, picked up the Bren and the ammunition and made our way along the road in the direction of the orchard. 
 I glanced back in the direction of the field where we saw the figures crossing. 
 The dead and bloated cow was still lying at the entrance to the field. 
 The two bodies were lying face down on the grass a few yards apart. 
 Even from where Taff and I were on the road it was obvious that the dead soldiers were German. 
 I wondered if the third soldier had made it back to his own lines. 
 The field they were in had British as well as German mines sown all over the place. 
 As Taff reported to Brigade H.Q I made my way into the orchard, made a mug of tea, had something to eat, got into my trench and immediately fell asleep. 
 &bquo;You bloody Pipers can certainly sleep. 
 Are you going to sleep in that pit all fucking day?&equo; 
 The voice belonged to the &bquo;Trog&equo;, a short, thick-set man who resembled a character of the Stone Age and was as strong as an ox. 
 I was rubbing my eyes as I clambered out of the trench. 
 &bquo;What's up, Trog?&equo; 
 I asked.  
 &bquo;What's up you say, Piper? 
 Jesus Christ, you have been in that pit for the past three hours. 
 We thought you were dead!&equo; 
 The Trog was a member of the 3&ins; Mortar team. 
 His face was not a pleasant sight to behold on awakening. 
 He had a large head with his hair cut right into the wood, piggy eyes and a broad flat nose that looked like it had been well punched in its day. 
 He had one redeeming feature &mdash; his very good nature, except when he was in the boxing ring or after a few whiskies, when everyone gave him a wide berth. 
 &bquo;Come on. 
 Follow me, Piper.&equo; 
 The Trog said, leading the way over to where the mortar team were sitting with their backs to the wall, having something to eat. 
 I was offered a choice of steak and kidney pudding or a couple of chunks of local pig. 
 I chose the steak and kidney pudding. 
 &bquo;I think I will be a vegetarian after the war. 
 At the moment it's difficult to tell the difference between beef, mutton or pig. 
 Or is it just the way it's cooked?&equo; 
 &bquo;One of the Officers over at H.Q was looking for you earlier on. 
 We told him that you had been out all night and that you were catching up on some sleep. 
 Nothing important, Piper the Trog said, handing me a full mug of cider. 
 &bquo;I think he said he was taking a trip down to the Orne bridges round about mid-day, and would like you to accompany him. 
 You have plenty of time yet, Piper. 
 Finish your meal first.&equo; 
 From time to time one of the team got to his feet, went over to a neat pile of mortar bombs, picked one up and slid it gently down the muzzle of the mortar. 
 The bomb shot out with its characteristic sound on its way to the enemy positions. 
 &bquo;Keeps the bastards on the alert,&equo; remarked the Trog, &bquo;Nothing like a load of exploding mortar shit to keep their fucking heads down!&equo; 
 The Commando who had sent the bomb on its way was looking at his watch as he sat down to finish his meal. 
 &bquo;In about three minutes we shall have one or two bombs from the German mortars falling near here,&equo; he remarked, as he started again on his steak and kidney. 
 The Commando sitting next to him looking at me  remarked, &bquo;The bombs never land on this mortar, Piper, They always burst among the squaddies somewhere else.&equo; 
 My thoughts went back to yesterday evening and Jock at No. 4 Commando, the damage done to him by a German mortar bomb, his head almost split in two and a leg blown off. 
 &bquo;Penny for your thoughts, Piper,&equo; the Trog said. 
 &bquo;I know what you're thinking! 
 You're looking at that meat there and you're wondering what nationality it is!&equo; 
 The Commando who had put the bomb into the mortar looked across at the Trog, shook his head and said slowly, &bquo;It's &bquo;species'&equo; you silly bastard. 
 We know the nationality of the meat. 
 It's French!&equo; 
 &bquo;OK, OK,&equo; the Trog replied, &bquo;makes no bloody difference, it tastes good, doesn't it, Piper?&equo; 
 I nodded my head in agreement. 
 At the big house I met the Officer who had been looking for me earlier on. 
 He was sitting in his jeep as I turned into the driveway. 
 &bquo;Come on, Piper!&equo; he exclaimed impatiently, For Christ's sake! 
 We can't sit here all day!&equo; 
 I got into the seat next to him and he quickly drove off, heading out of the village and down the road towards the Orne bridges, leaving a cloud of dust following close behind, no doubt attracting the attention of the German gunners and mortars a short distance away across the fields. 
 I was glad of the break to get away from the monotony of the orchard with the constant sniping and mortaring. 
 Not that this bothered me so much now. 
 As we reached the crossroads I looked back. 
 Sure enough, the enemy mortars were bursting in the fields on both sides of the road. 
 Some people back there would be cursing us for raising so much dust. 
 The jeep reached the River Orne and we turned off the road on to a narrow path just wide enough for the jeep. 
 About a hundred yards along the path I could see guns that were dug in fairly close together. 
 They looked like 15 pounders. 
 The guns were all along the river bank as far as I could see. 
 The jeep stopped at a caravan that was situated just off the path and under two trees. 
 The caravan was heavily camouflaged with netting and branches from trees. 
 An Officer came out of the caravan as we drew up. 
 His words to the Commando Officer in the jeep were  drowned by the crack of the 15 pounders as a few of them opened fire, the guns lurching forward as the shells sped off towards their target. 
 The two Officers shook hands, then they both went into the caravan after informing me that they would be attending a meeting for the next two hours. 
 I parked the jeep under a tree and then, looking at my watch, I decided that as I had a couple of hours to spare I would take a walk across to the other bridge where I had noticed a caf&eacute; on our first day into Normandy. 
 It was quite possible that it would be still open for business. 
 Troops and supplies were crossing the Benouville bridge as I approached the caf&eacute;. 
 Some of the troops were waving and seemed very cheerful. 
 Obviously they had no idea what lay ahead after they had crossed the bridges and got close to the enemy positions. 
 The odd German shell was bursting in the field about two hundred yards away from the bridge, far enough not to do any harm, except possibly to the cattle. 
 The caf&eacute; looked deserted as I approached the front door. 
 There was no answer to my knock so I went round to the side door facing the canal. 
 After two loud knocks the door was opened by a woman. 
 Immediately behind her was a man, probably her husband. 
 They looked at me apprehensively when I asked for a drink of cider or wine. 
 The woman was getting quite agitated, looking along the banks of the canal and exclaiming, &bquo;Ferm&eacute;, ferm&eacute;.&equo; 
 The man standing behind her spoke as I was turning to walk away. 
 &bquo;You are Scottish?&equo; he said, &bquo;You were playing the cornemuse  on the approach to the bridge six days ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; I replied, &bquo;You speak good English.&equo; 
 He shrugged his shoulders, &bquo;At times I like to speak English, but not for a long time. 
 Come in and have a drink.&equo; 
 They stood to the side as I entered then the woman showed me to a chair as the man brought two glasses and placed them on the table in front of me, then said very seriously, &bquo;This is my wife. 
 What is your name?&equo; 
 I stood up and shook hands with both of them saying slowly, &bquo;My name is Bill Millin.&equo; 
 The offer of a glass of Calvados was politely refused and I accepted a large glass of red wine that really tasted good. 
  After about twenty minutes I got up and prepared to leave, thanking both of them for their hospitality. 
 The woman in particular was rather nervous of my presence in her house and I didn't blame her. 
 After all, the Germans were still not far off. 
 As I reached the door the woman smiled and said something in French which I did not understand. 
 Her husband said, &bquo;Wait one moment, Monsieur, my wife has something for you.&equo; 
 She disappeared back into the kitchen and returned a few minutes later carrying a very dirty and dusty bottle of wine. 
 Addressing the husband, I said, &bquo;Thank your wife very much for the bottle of wine. 
 Tell her that I shall keep it until I am an old man. 
 That is, if I survive the war.&equo; 
 I slung my rifle over my shoulder and clutching the bottle of wine I crossed the bridge for the second time, heading east, turning to wave to the couple at the door of the caf&eacute;. 
 I wondered as I waved, &bquo;Shall I ever see them again? 
 I suppose not!&equo; 
 The guns along the banks of the Orne were still firing as I arrived back at the jeep. 
 The Officer was talking to two gunners who appeared to be Polish judging by their accents. 
 The Commando Officer shook hands with the gunners and we waved our farewells as we drove along the narrow path and on to the road. 
 There was a lot of activity around the orchard as we arrived back at H.Q The sniping had increased and a mortar attack seemed to be under way. 
 It was difficult to determine whether the explosions were from the German shells or from the Allied shells passing over, with the usual one or two dropping short. 
 We both got out of the jeep as fast as we could and sprinted in the direction of the slit trenches. 
 I decided to make for the orchard and the safety of my own trench. 
 The Officer had gone a few yards when he suddenly fell to the ground. 
 I turned back to see what was wrong. 
 He was clutching his foot and was obviously in a lot of pain. 
 I think I have a piece of shrapnel in my foot, Piper. 
 See if you can get hold of the medic at the back of the house.&equo; 
 Before I could do anything, two medics came sprinting along the path from the direction of the big house. 
 The Officer was put on to a stretcher. 
 The blood was oozing out  from the tip of his boot and his face had turned the usual grey colour of the soldier who had been wounded. 
 I decided to stay where I was at the moment until things quietened down. 
 As I lay flat on the grass close to a tree the blood from the Officer's wound had stained the grass a dull red colour. 
 I pulled up a few tufts of grass and covered the blood. 
 It made me feel uneasy. 
 My eyes were drawn to it as if the Officer had left part of himself here on the grass. 
 The shelling had ceased. 
 The explosion in the orchard seemed to be coming from further away, from the other side of the orchard. 
 They were probably mortar bursts. 
 Taff was in a foul mood as I jumped down into the trench. 
 He was briskly preparing a meal of compo rations. 
 &bquo;You know this, Piper? 
 Those bastards, I don't mean the squareheaded bastards across the fields, I mean the bastards who are sending all this shit over our heads all the time.&equo; 
 Taff's face was really mean looking as he continued to curse the gunners along the River Orne. 
 I decided to delay informing him of my visit to the Orne and speaking to the Artillerymen who were sending the shells over our heads. 
 &bquo;Not steak and kidney again.&equo; 
 I said, as Taff scraped out two tins of self-heating steak and kidney. 
 &bquo;Well, Boyo, it's either this or that,&equo; said Taff, pointing to the alternative &mdash; a large piece of meat that had been roasted over a fire and looked most unappetising. 
 &bquo;Think we'll stick to the good old British steak and kidney,&equo; I said. 
 Half way through the meal Taff produced a bottle of red wine scrounged from H.Q It certainly tasted good and set off the meal. 
 &bquo;Where is the mortar team, Taff?&equo; 
 I enquired as we clambered out of the trench after draining the last of the French wine. 
 &bquo;That's what I was on about, Boyo,&equo; Taff answered, pointing to the spot a few yards away where the mortar team had been this morning. 
 &bquo;A British shell dropped short during the bombardment earlier on and the explosion knocked out the mortar team. 
 They were all badly wounded! 
 Jesus Christ, Piper, our guns are better at inflicting casualties on us than the Germans.&equo;  
 The time was now late afternoon. 
 I decided to have a rest, then visit No. 6 Commando. 
 They were dug in at the other end of the village in an orchard very close to the enemy positions. 
 At about 7.30 p.m., after two and a half hours' sleep curled up on the floor of the trench, I made my way out of the orchard and on to the road. 
 The Allied guns were still shelling the German positions and there was a lot of activity going on. 
 There were minor explosions in the centre and at the far end of the village green. 
 Troops were marching through on either side of the road. 
 I walked alongside the men at the head of the column and soon learned they were the Black Watch, a well-known Scottish regiment. 
 The regiment had come ashore that morning and were going into action that evening, attacking the village just along the road, about two hundred yards from the edge of our village and close to No. 6 Commando positions. 
 They all looked so young, but were about my age, between eighteen and twenty-five years. 
 Their clothing and equipment were dusty but they appeared clean in comparison with the Commandos. 
 No doubt after six days of living in a trench, the dirt would have had time to grime itself in. 
 They all appeared cheerful as they marched away. 
 I left them as I approached No. 6 Commando positions and stood at the side of the road and watched them all pass by. 
 I had a very deep feeling that the attack on the village by the Black Watch was not going to be successful due to the fact that the enemy were well dug in and were determined to hold on to this position. 
 It was a tough nut to crack. 
 The Commandos and the Airborne had launched several attacks without success. 
 In fact, the Germans made several counter attacks on the Commando positions, also without success, so we both, over the past six days, had got to know each other very well. 
 The attacking column disappeared along the road, some of them entering the fields in the area of the No. 6 Commando. 
 From the road, No. 6 Commando positions could be approached by passing through the farm. 
 The front of the farm had received several hits by shrapnel. 
 All the windows in the farmhouse had been shattered, the whole scene resembling something from the Blitz. 
 As I entered through an archway into the cobbled  farmyard the shelling had increased, most of the shells passing over in support of the attack party going in just along the road. 
 I entered the barn at the corner of the farmyard. 
 Lying around on bales of hay were about a dozen Commandos. 
 They sat up as I came in, then relaxed when they recognised me. 
 There were faces among them that I recognised from England, and from the training centre at Achnacarry. 
 Christ, they had changed. 
 They looked older, certainly different. 
 &bquo;It's all right, I haven't brought the bagpipes,&equo; I jokingly remarked. 
 The response was nil. 
 They all looked too tired to be bothered with any joking. 
 &bquo;Changed days, Piper!&equo; remarked Jimmy, as I sat down beside him on a bale of hay. 
 &bquo;We have been under enemy attack since we arrived here six days ago, with practically no sleep. 
 This lot have been brought into the barn for a rest,&equo; indicating with his hand the others who had by this time fallen asleep, oblivious to the noise of the guns and the explosions very close to the barn. 
 &bquo;Not much of a rest for them in here,&equo; I remarked, as a mortar bomb burst close by in the orchard, causing the barn to shake a load of debris from the rafters, covering everyone below in pigeon and probably hen shit. 
 &bquo;There's nowhere else to go, Piper, You know that! 
 All the units are in the same situation. 
 The only fairly quick exit from here is feet first. 
 That is if the medics can get to you!&equo; 
 Jim lay back on the bale of hay and immediately fell asleep, still grasping the barrel of his rifle. 
 The barn shook again as I got to my feet and made my way to the door with the feeling that the barn had been very lucky so far in not receiving a direct hit from one of the frequent mortar bombs that were exploding in and around the farm. 
 Outside in the cobbled farmyard I glanced at the side of the barn. 
 It was covered in scars caused by shrapnel. 
 Here and there lumps of metal were sticking out of the masonry. 
 Across the farmyard the door of the farmhouse lay open. 
 There was no sign of the occupants. 
 No doubt they were down in the cellar sheltering from the bombardment. 
 The curtains were hanging outside the smashed windows, the whole scene one  of desolation. 
 At the far end of the yard, the metal five-bar gate was wide open. 
 As I entered the orchard, a few yards from the entrance the farmer was tending to two badly wounded cows. 
 The cows were standing at the entrance to a small byre, while the farmer poured a purple fluid from a bucket into their wounds. 
 Both cows had large gaping wounds caused by shrapnel in their hindquarters. 
 As the farmer poured the fluid into the wounds they would bellow loudly and kick out at him. 
 He turned to look at me as I approached, then carried on tending to the cows. 
 His hands and clothing were covered in the animals blood. 
 He was a medium-sized man, thick-set with a rough weatherbeaten face covered in grey stubble. 
 He was completely oblivious to the noise of the shells passing overhead, or the rattle of automatic fire echoing through the orchard. 
 As I stood watching him for a few seconds and looking at the damage to his farm buildings and the dead and wounded cattle around the orchard, I thought to myself. 
 How can these people ever forgive us for all this damage?&equo; 
 The farmer must have read my thoughts. 
 He stopped what he was doing and, placing the bucket on the ground, he turned to face me, holding out his right hand. 
 As we shook hands the Frenchman said very slowly in French, &bquo;Monsieur, we are very pleased to see you here in Normandy. 
 All this damage can be repaired when we have beaten the Boche.&equo; 
 He went back to tending his cows, and, looking at me as he bent down to pick up his bucket, he said, &bquo;I am Monsieur Saulnier. 
 You must come and visit me after the war and bring your Cornemuse .&equo; 
 As Monsieur Saulnier mentioned the bagpipes, he smiled and turned his head away. 
 I left the farm as it was getting late. 
 There was a strong smell of burning in the air. 
 A cottage across from the farm had been hit by a shell and was burning fiercely. 
 The smoke was drifting slowly across the farm buildings in the still air. 
 On the way back from No. 6 Commando positions to Brigade H.Q the road was busy with Jeeps ferrying the wounded from the area where the Black Watch had been attacking the German positions. 
 Some of the wounded were  being placed on the grass in front of the Chateau. 
 &bquo;How is the attack going?&equo; 
 I asked one of the medics who was unloading the wounded. 
 &bquo;Not very well, Piper. 
 The Germans have counter attacked and inflicted a hell of a lot of casualties on the Black Watch.&equo; 
 As the wounded were being unloaded from the jeeps I could see the wounds were mainly inflicted by shrapnel. 
 Large ragged tears similar to those suffered by the cattle in Monsieur Saulnier's farm. 
 The wounded who seemed to have a chance of recovery were left on the jeeps and were sped off down through the village to the dressing stations on the other side of the River Orne. 
 The less fortunate were the severely wounded who were being placed on the grass with two medics to attend to their wounds. 
 Clouds of mosquitoes were beginning to arrive and settle on the wounded. 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ! 
 As if things were not bad enough without those little bastards turning up to torment us,&equo; remarked one of the medics as he tried to pack a shell dressing into a large abdominal wound. 
 Darkness had suddenly settled as I entered the orchard at Brigade H.Q Taff was in the trench, standing by his Bren swatting the mosquitoes and cursing loudly to himself. 
 It struck me that Taff no longer used his favourite cuss words, like the four-letter variety, and was sticking strictly to the bloodys with the very often repeated &bquo;Jesus Christ.&equo; 
 As I approached the trench he remarked, &bquo;Jesus Christ, Piper! 
 You bloody well get around! 
 And you always seem to arrive back in time for supper.&equo; 
 He placed two tins of self heating soup on the grass in front of him. 
 &bquo;How are things at 6 Commando area, Piper?&equo; he enquired, &bquo;The attack by the Black Watch has not gone too well judging by the number of wounded passing through here!&equo; 
 A flare lit up the sky as Taff was talking, casting eerie shadows among the trees. 
 I got into the trench and opened my tin of soup, pouring the piping hot liquid into a mess tin. 
 &bquo;You're right, Taff. 
 The attacking troops are certainly not getting it all their own way and the shelling from both sides is causing casualties in the Commando positions.&equo; 
 The  flare had drifted slowly down behind the church on the village green and was followed quickly by a long burst of automatic fire. 
 There were two mortar explosions over by the road, then all was fairly quiet except for the sound of firing away in the distance at the other end of the village, where I had been earlier on in the evening. 
 We finished our soup and swilled out the mess tins with water from the jerry-can. 
 Taff produced a couple of pieces of meat and offered me one. 
 I accepted straight away. 
 I was getting used to these burnt offerings and, strangely enough, was finding them, on occasion, very tasty. 
 &bquo;Now, Piper, every good meal should be accompanied by a bottle of best French wine!&equo; 
 With that, Taff produced a very dirty and dusty bottle of Bordeaux. 
 For a moment I thought he had come across the bottle of wine given to me by the couple at Benouville bridge caf&eacute;. 
 &bquo;The thieving bastard!&equo; 
 I muttered under my breath as Taff pulled out the cork and commenced pouring the wine into the two mugs. 
 &bquo;Down the hatch, Piper!&equo; said Taff, raising his mug. 
 &bquo;Same to you, Taff,&equo; I replied, picking up my mug with one hand and the bottle with the other. 
 Straight away it was obvious it was not my bottle. 
 Before I could say anything, Taff remarked, &bquo;Come on, Boyo. 
 Drink up, there's another mugful each. 
 It's not often you come across a good Bordeaux!&equo; 
 We finished our meal. 
 Taff decided to do the first two and a half hours on the gun so I crawled to the back of the trench, curled up and immediately dropped off to sleep. 
 The mosquitoes and the noise of the guns were not as important as they seemed several days ago. 
 &bquo;Right, Boyo,&equo; Taff's voice seemed miles away in my half awake state. 
 It was very much closer when he accompanied his &bquo;Right, Boyo&equo; with a jab in my ribs with his rifle butt. 
 I crawled out of the trench and joined Taff at the Bren gun. 
 He thrust a mug of tea into my hands, with the remark, &bquo;Get that down you, Piper, and keep your head down.&equo; 
 We crouched down in the trench and drank our tea, listening to the crump, crump as two mortar shells exploded close by. 
 It  was still dark. 
 I gazed upwards and could see a few stars twinkling in the sky, one seemed much brighter than the others. 
 &bquo;You see that star, Taff&equo; See how much brighter it is.&equo; 
 I looked at Taff sitting opposite me in the gloom, his hands wrapped around his hot mug of tea, his shoulders hunched forward. 
 He was silent for a few moments, then he raised his head, took a couple of gulps of tea and remarked very slowly, Jesus Christ, Piper, you must be bloody bomb happy! 
 We are all living in holes in the ground having all kinds of shit thrown at us and all you can talk about is one star being brighter than the others.&equo; 
 Taff drained his mug of tea, turned on his side and crawled into his trench muttering to himself, &bquo;He's cracking up. 
 He's bloody bomb happy,&equo; then silence as Taff quickly fell asleep. 
 I stood up and gazed along the barrel of the Bren gun and couldn't help smiling to myself and thinking that Taff was at his funniest when he was annoyed about something, even though our circumstances at the moment were anything but funny. 
 The activity on the road on the other side of the orchard had increased, there were troops and the occasional vehicle moving up and through the village followed by the usual German mortaring of the road and orchard. 
 At first light I gave Taff a shake and presented him with a mug of tea. 
 He crawled out of the trench and joined me at the gun. 
 It was suddenly quiet in the orchard as the mist floated through the trees. 
 Taff's first remark was &bquo;I wonder how many copped it last night, Piper?&equo; 
 After breakfast I decided to visit Brigade H.Q Taff was sitting on the grass just outside the trench cleaning his Bren gun. 
 He seemed to be a lot more cheerful and appeared to have recovered from his bout of depression of the previous evening. 
 &bquo;See you later, Boyo,&equo; he shouted after me as I set off, rifle over my shoulder, through the trees in the direction of Brigade H.Q 
 I turned and gave him a wave, &bquo;Don't wait up for me, I may be late.&equo; 
 I didn't quite catch his reply. 
 No doubt it was something rude! 
 As I entered the big house by the back door I noticed a lot of activity, people dashing here and there. 
 This was not the usual scene. 
 I recognised Officers from the Commando units around the village. 
 I met up  with Pat in a small room at the front of the house tucking into a breakfast of fried eggs and an obscure piece of meat that took up about half of his mess-tin. 
 As I entered the room he got up from the floor, drawing his sleeve across his mouth. 
 &bquo;Hello, Piper, you are a little bit late for a bit of breakfast but sit down and have a mug of tea.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's that you're eating with the fried eggs?&equo; 
 I enquired, as I sat down on the floor beside him. 
 &bquo;Oh that, me boy, that is the rabbit that was in the cage when we arrived here last Wednesday morning.&equo; 
 I looked at the mess-tin containing the eggs and the meat. 
 &bquo;For Christ's sake, Pat, not the big fat rabbit that was in the hutch hanging on the wall at the back of the house?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's the one, me boy, and it has this morning presented itself in four mess-tins. 
 Those of three Officers and, of course, meself. 
 It was a lovely looking rabbit but it was wasting its time all cooped up in that cage!&equo; 
 Pat proceeded to polish off the remainder of his breakfast, with grease from the remains of the rabbit trickling down the sides of his mouth. 
 He placed the empty mess-tins on the floor, lit a cigarette, and, leaning back against the wall, remarked &bquo;i don't think the Frenchman who owned the rabbit would object. 
 After all, Piper, it's all in a good cause.&equo; 
 At the rear of many French houses I had noticed several rabbit-hutches containing the largest rabbits I had ever seen, certainly larger than anything in Britain. 
 These rabbits were probably fattened up for some special occasion. 
 Many of them must have ended up in a British soldier's mess-tin. 
 Pat finished his cigarette and, looking at me as he rose to his feet, said, &bquo;Piper, I believe it is all going to happen today. 
 There is a counter attack going on, and the target is the next village just along the road there,&equo; indicating with his forefinger in the direction of No. 6 Commando positions in and around the Saulnier farm at the other end of the village. 
 As he spoke I could hear the rush of shells passing over heading in the direction of the German positions. 
 The German gunners reply crashing in a couple of minutes later caused pat and I to get on the floor fast. 
 When the explosions eased off a bit, I bade farewell to Pat and got out of the big house as quickly as possible. 
 I always felt slightly  uneasy away from the slit trench in the orchard. 
 As I was leaving the house Pat shouted after me, &bquo;Piper, your friend Taff who shares the trench with you in the orchard has been transferred to one of the Commando units around the village. 
 Something to do with the number of casualties they are having.&equo; 
 As I was leaving the front of the house two jeeps arrived with wounded aboard, one of whom I recognised straight away. 
 He was sitting up on his stretcher cursing away in French and then in English at the top of his voice. 
 He was one of my friends of the French Commando who were attached to No. 4 Commando. 
 As I approached the jeep he recognised me. 
 &bquo;Ah, Bill, all the bloody bad luck, fucking wound in my leg.&equo; 
 He looked really fierce with his black beard and long black hair. 
 His wound was covered lightly with a shell dressing, and I moved it to one side to have a look. 
 There was a ragged hole just above the knee on his left leg caused by a small piece of shrapnel. 
 I hurriedly replaced the dressing and looked at him. 
 He was still cursing in French and English. 
 I thought &bquo;how can he possibly behave like that with a wound that would lay low any other soldier?&equo; 
 As the jeep moved away at speed I could still hear him shouting, then it was gone in a cloud of dust, road leading to the beaches to join the other wounded waiting to be shipped back to England. 
 I returned to the orchard to say goodbye to Taff before he left to join one of the Commando units around the village. 
 I found him in his trench enjoying a mug of tea and in deep conversation with a Commando friend of his. 
 As I helped myself to a drop of Taff's tea the guns down by the River Orne opened up again, the shells all heading in the direction of the German positions. 
 I just got into the trench in time as a few explosions were occuring in several parts of the orchard. 
 The German gunners were certainly not sitting about doing nothing. 
 Taff did not seem to mind going to one of the forward units. 
 In fact, he seemed quite cheerful and was looking forward to meeting some of his old mates at 6 Commando. 
 &bquo;Day seven today, Piper, 12th June,&equo; Taff remarked as he tried to move around the cramped area of his trench collecting his bits of equipment. 
 We were still confined to our trenches due to the bombardment which  continued for some time. 
 &bquo;The German shelling is very accurate Taff, don't you think? 
 See how there are shells exploding almost on the same spot in that field over there.&equo; 
 I indicated with my forefinger in the direction of the bursting shells. 
 Taff's answer was his usual &bquo;Not German shells, Boyo, its those bastards down by the Orne who are dropping their shells about. 
 Let's hope they keep to the field over there, at least until we leave the orchard.&equo; 
 Later in the day the shelling ceased so Taff and I were able to get his kit together and make our way through the village to the farm and No. 6 Commando positions. 
 I left Taff at the entrance to the farm and watched him as he continued along the road then, as he clambered up the grass bank and disappeared among the trees, I turned into the farm. 
 There was a lot of activity in the area of the farm buildings, people dashing about even though the farm was being heavily mortared. 
 Wounded were being brought out from the orchard at the back of the farm which was being subjected to unusually heavy mortaring from the German positions just a short distance across the fields. 
 I made my way through the orchard and into a slit trench. 
 The shells from the Allied guns were passing very low overhead and bursting at the edge of the wood in the German positions. 
 &bquo;You see that lot, Piper. 
 The bastards are getting a taste of their own medicine.&equo; 
 The voice came from my right. 
 I turned round to see who it was and immediately recognised Jim. 
 We used to chat a lot as we rested during the frequent route marches out of camp at Southampton. 
 I shouted above the din, &bquo;Big change in the scenery now, not like the peace and quiet of the waterworks at Southampton.&equo; 
 I don't think he heard me &mdash; due to a very loud explosion a short distance away forcing everyone to duck low into their trenches as lumps of earth and other debris accompanied the flying shrapnel through the trees. 
 Someone cried out &bquo;Where's the medic?&equo; 
 The voice sounded faint and was soon drowned out by the rush and moan of the shells passing over. 
 At least the German infantry won't be attacking us from across the field in front of our positions, as long as this barrage keeps up. 
 Wounded were being carried through the trees to the shelter of the farm buildings, the medics stopping from time to time to rest,  then continued quickly on their way. 
 After about an hour the shelling stopped and was followed by sporadic mortar and machine gun fire, the latter cutting up the ground along the front of the orchard facing the enemy positions. 
 Two medics arrived on the scene carrying a wounded Commando on a stretcher. 
 I scrambled out of the trench and accompanied them through the trees to the farm. 
 At the farm I met Pat from Brigade H.Q He was delivering a message to the C.O. of 6 Commando. 
 &bquo;Hello, Piper, bloody rough in this area, isn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;What's it like at Brigade H.Q?&equo; 
 I enquired. 
 &bquo;Just the same, Piper, makes no difference where you are this evening.&equo; 
 As we were talking the guns started up again, making conversation very difficult. 
 The wounded were being laid out against the wall of the barn. 
 I spoke to one of the medics, he informed me that the attack on the village just along the road was under way and already there were many casualties, particularly among 6 Commando, due to the heavy shelling from the Allied and German guns. 
 &bquo;Lovat was enquiring about you earlier on, Piper,&equo; shouted one of the medics who had come out of the barn to tend to the wounded. 
 &bquo;Where is he now?&equo; 
 I enquired. 
 As it was impossible to hear what he was saying above the din of the bombardment, he pointed to the area outside the farm indicating that Lovat was somewhere there. 
 Outside the farm, I could see the unmistakable figure of Lord Lovat standing on the grass talking to two other senior Officers. 
 Troops were moving through the village heading in the direction of the attack area and the artillery fire had increased in support of the attack, the usual odd shell or two dropping short causing casualties among the troops moving along the road. 
 As I approached Lovat and the two Officers, a shell burst a short distance away. 
 Everyone got down very quickly as another shell exploded in the front garden of a cottage across the road. 
 From my position lying flat on the ground, I looked up, Lovat and the two Officers were still talking. 
 They appeared completely unconcerned about the shelling going on around them. 
 I scrambled to my feet a little sheepishly as one of the Officers had turned round and was observing me as I approached. 
 I stood on the fringe of the little group  for a few moments waiting for a chance to speak to Lovat. 
 One of the Officers turned to me and indicated that I should push off. 
 I saluted him and then made my way back to the farmyard and the comparative safety of the farm buildings. 
 I had gone a few paces when there was a loud crashing explosion behind me. 
 I could feel the blast on my back as I was pitched forward, landing face down on the ground unable to move and gasping for breath. 
 I lay there for what seemed like an eternity and feeling in a sort of panic. 
 Was I wounded? 
 Had I lost an arm or leg? 
 I was now able to breathe properly and started to feel over my body with both hands. 
 I was all right. 
 The only injury was a bleeding nose sustained when I crashed down onto my face, following the blast. 
 I crawled over the grass and sat with my back against the farmhouse and stared at the blood pouring down the front of my battledress. 
 Where was Lovat? 
 He and the other Officers must have been very close to the shell burst! 
 As I struggled to my feet and started to search around in the grass for my rifle, two medics were coming towards me. 
 &bquo;Is Lovat all right?&equo; 
 I enquired. 
 &bquo;No, Piper, he is badly wounded. 
 Lump of shrapnel in his back.&equo; 
 The shelling and mortaring was still intense as I followed behind the medics. 
 When I came across Lovat he was lying on the ground. 
 As I looked down at him lying there it was difficult to believe that this was Shimi Lovat. 
 His battledress was soaked with blood on one side, his face was a ghastly grey colour with the mouth hanging open, his head was turned to one side with the eyes closed. 
 I just stood and stared for a few moments amid all the activity that was going on around the wounded Lovat. 
 One of the medics attending him looked up at me. 
 &bquo;For Christs sake, Piper. 
 It's no good standing there, there's nothing you can do to help.&equo; 
 As I turned away someone was shouting for the M.O. 
 and another voice was asking for a priest. 
 After a few paces I stopped and looked around. 
 Lovat had gone, probably tied to a stretcher, placed on a jeep and taken at full speed to the First Aid post. 
 The attack on the village along the road was still going on, wounded and dead Commandos were being placed against the walls of the cobbled farmyard, waiting their turn as the jeeps ferried to and fro through the village. 
  About twelve midnight the German positions in the village were over-run, and for about an hour the enemy mortaring in the farm area ceased. 
 I had time to enquire about Taff. 
 It appeared that the slit trench he was in during the bombardment had received a direct hit. 
 He had been killed instantly along with two other Commandos who were close by at the time, their remains scattered through the trees. 
 The remaining part of the night was spent lying in a trench near the centre of the orchard reflecting on the happenings of the day. 
 Lovat badly wounded, probably dead by this time! 
 Certainly, judging by his appearance as he lay on the ground, I did not give much for his chances. 
 As I stared up at the clear sky from the bottom of the trench, my mind drifted back to Achnacarry and Fiona. 
 I could see her face very clearly in the wisp of cloud that was now making its way across the sky. 
 A few seconds later her face had gone, as the cloud changed shape then disappeared. 
 Her words came back to me as I pictured her sitting by the fire in her tiny croft. 
 &bquo;Millin, you will be leaving here and going away with the tall man, Lovat. 
 He will be badly injured but will return to the Highlands and live for many years.&equo; 
 My thoughts were interrupted by several loud bangs from very close by, then two flares lit the sky, hanging eerily just above the trees, then drifting out of sight a short distance away, followed by a long burst of machine gun fire. 
 I moved further into the trench, lay on my back and tried to sleep, which was very difficult due to the mosquitoes and the uncertainty of the situation. 
 Taff was blown to pieces in his trench earlier this evening, probably thinking he was safe a couple of feet or so below ground. 
 Poor old Taff. 
 How could it possibly happen to him? 
 He seemed so different from anyone else. 
 His depressions, then his elations, his cursing, and his generosity. 
 I am certainly going to miss him, I have only really known him for the past seven days, but it seems like years. 
 I don't know how long I have been asleep! 
 I awoke feeling cold and crawled out to the front of the trench. 
 Dawn was beginning to appear through the trees. 
 Looking around I could see the duty Officer approaching from the direction of the farm. 
 He passed me by, probably more concerned about his own men of 6 Commando and the  large number of casualties inflicted on the Commandos during the attack on the enemy positions in the village just along the road. 
 The German defenders had pulled out and, from their new positions, they had lost no time in setting up their mortars. 
 The explosions were now occurring in the area they had just evacuated, probably inflicting casualties on the British troops who had taken over the German trenches. 
 I made my way through the trees to the farmyard, four Commandos were stacking ammunition against the farmhouse wall. 
 As I approached, a Corporal remarked &bquo;Too bad about Lovat, Piper. 
 He will be sadly missed by everyone in the Brigade.&equo; 
 As I entered the barn someone handed me a mess-tin full of hot tea. 
 I sat down on the straw and looked around. 
 A few feet away two medics were lying stretched out on the floor of the barn, one lying face down, his arms by his sides, he appeared to be dead. 
 &bquo;No, they are not dead, Piper. 
 The poor bastards are exhausted!&equo; 
 I turned round to see who was speaking, it was the Corporal who had mentioned Lovat being wounded. 
 &bquo;Yes, Piper. 
 When you and I were in our slit trenches sheltering from the shit that's flying about, these two here were running around the orchard picking up the dead and wounded.&equo; 
 The Corporal glanced sympathetically at the two figures on the floor and then he moved to the other end of the barn. 
 I drained my mess-tin, got to my feet and went out across the cobbled farmyard, under the arch, and out along the road leading to Brigade H.Q hoping that I would not be requiring the special services offered by the medics. 
 After a few hours' rest I had something to eat. 
 As I sat just outside the entrance to the trench it was very difficult to accept that Taff was dead. 
 I glanced round a couple of times expecting him to appear through the trees with a mouthful of oaths and a loud &bquo;Come on, Boyo! 
 Where is the bloody tea.&equo; 
 Later in the day a notice was hammered to a tree at the entrance to the orchard. 
 A few Commandos had gathered to read the notice. 
 As I approached someone remarked &bquo;at least he is still alive.&equo; 
 The few words posted to the tree informed everyone that Lovat had been badly wounded and was now in hospital somewhere in England. 
 He wished us the best of luck and advised us that the  Brigade was here to stay. 
 &bquo;There shall not be one step back. 
 The ground taken by the Brigade since the landing will be held at all costs.&equo; 
 The new Brigadier was the C.O. of 6 Commando, Derek Mills Roberts. 
 As I made my way back to my slit trench I wondered what would be my role now that Lovat had gone? 
 Would Mills Roberts wish to retain my services as the Brigade Piper or would he send me back to Achnacarry? 
 At least the new Brigadier served in the Irish Guards and they had Pipers. 
 I would just have to wait and see. 
 The capture of the village yesterday evening did not make much difference to our situation in and around the village. 
 The enemy, it appears, have withdrawn a short distance from the area in front of 6 Commando, the front being just the same in front of the other Commando units. 
 Another mortar team has moved into the orchard this evening, 13th June, and got down to work straight away by sending off several rounds of high explosives in quick succession in the direction of the enemy positions. 
 Later that evening I joined them for dinner, sharing a few tins of Compo and three bottles of French cider. 
 I don't like the cider very much, much too dry, but drink it just the same. 
 The clouds of mosquitoes are beginning to arrive and are hovering in strength over the slit trenches. 
 Monsieur Saulnier informed me the other day that it was not usual in this part of Normandy to have so many mosquitoes. 
 I believe the reason they are attracted here is the dead cattle lying around the fields. 
 Also the dead German soldiers lying in front of the Commando positions on the left of the village. 
 As I settled into my trench for the night Allied bombers were passing overhead to drop their bombs on Caen. 
 &bquo;Can't be much left of that bloody town,&equo; shouted one of the 3&ins; mortar team as we watched the bombs falling from the aircraft. 
 The sky was soon dark and the sound of heavy bombs exploding died away, to be replaced by shells passing over the orchard from the British guns down by the river Orne. 
 During the night a couple of German shells crashed into the far end of the orchard near the road. 
 I am beginning to count the days since the landing and to reflect on all that has happened. 
 It is 5 a.m., 14th June. 
 There is a slight drizzle falling through the trees and most of the  mosquitoes have gone, except one or two persistent little bastards buzzing about inside the trench. 
 One lands on the back of my hand and thrusts its needle-like head into my skin. 
 I wait until it fills itself and then I swat it, the blood splashing over my hand. 
 The mortar team have started up again, sending their shells through the drizzle. 
 One of the team replaces the cap on the mouth of the barrel then they sit down, backs against the orchard wall and eat their breakfast. 
 I enter the day and date in my diary and look again at the entry of the 12th June. 
 &bquo;Lovat badly wounded.&equo; 
 Taff killed during the intense shelling and mortaring of the Commando positions. 
 As I close the diary I notice that it's getting a bit grubby. 
 At least it survived the sea water during the landing and has come this far. 
 &bquo;What are you writing, Piper?&equo; 
 The voice came from one of the mortar team over by the orchard wall. 
 &bquo;Nothing,&equo; I replied as I scrambled out of the trench, replacing the diary quickly in my hip pocket. 
 After breakfasting with the mortar team I made my way over to Brigade H.Q As I passed along the wall of the orchard I suddenly thought about the Frenchman and his family who lived in the cottage on the other side of the wall. 
 I clambered over the wall and dropped on the other side and made my way quickly across the field in the direction of the cottage. 
 As I drew nearer I noticed that half of the roof had gone and there was a large gaping hole in the wall at the side of the cottage. 
 Surely the old Frenchman and his family haven't been killed! 
 The place was deserted, there was no sign of the family, smashed furniture and household goods were strewn all over the place. 
 It appears that the shelling of yesterday evening was responsible for all this damage. 
 As I turned away and headed back the way I had come I passed two dead cows lying on the grass, large shrapnel wounds on their bodies. 
 A short distance away another cow was grazing, apparently unconcerned about some of its intestines trailing in the grass from under its belly. 
 I clambered back over the wall, crossed the orchard and, as usual, entered H.Q by the back door. 
 &bquo;Piper.&equo; 
 I turned round, there was no mistaking that voice. 
 It was the new Brigadier, Mills Roberts. 
 I sprang to attention and gave him a smart salute. 
 &bquo;Sorry about Shimi  Lovat being wounded,&equo; he said, in his clipped manner. 
 &bquo;At least he is still alive and that's what is important.&equo; 
 &bquo;Now, Piper, no doubt you are wondering about your future with the Brigade? 
 Well, you can stay with the Brigade as Piper until we return to England at the close of the Normandy campaign.&equo; 
 &bquo;By the way, Piper,&equo; he continued, &bquo;can you play Wearin' o&equo; the Green ?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, Sir,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;Well then, carry on!&equo; 
 I saluted then watched him as he barged along the corridor and out of the front door. 
 Pat emerged from the kitchen &bquo;You know why he was askin' you if you could play Wearin' o&equo; the Green ? 
 Well. 
 he served with the Irish Guards before he volunteered for the Commandos, and you can be sure that he will have you playing that tune as often as possible, as long as you don't play it around this H.Q, I don't mind.&equo; 
 As we entered the kitchen Pat looked up at the roof and the large gaping hole caused by a shell that had passed through two floors then smashed through the kitchen door, ending up in the garden. 
 &bquo;We don't want any more of that lot around here, Piper, so we will forget about bagpipes and shells through the roof.&equo; 
 Crossing over to the sink he bent down, lifted up two floorboards and produced a small wooden barrel, exclaiming, &bquo;Now, Piper, you must try this, it's almost as good as your best Highland whisky.&equo; 
 He poured a small quantity into two mugs and handed one to me. 
 Pat's crater was a very good French brandy that he had probably scrounged from somewhere local, most likely the Chateau just along the road. 
 &bquo;Cheers, Pat,&equo; I said raising my mug of brandy. 
 &bquo;For the Officers, me boy,&equo; Pat replied with a wink. 
 &bquo;And sure, there is no harm in the other ranks having a wee drop before it is served up to the new Brigadier.&equo; 
 Pat recharged the mugs from the barrel. 
 I declined his offer of another brandy, made my excuses, and thanking him for his hospitality I left by the back door. 
 The sniping in the orchard has cased off since yesterday, the constant whine of a bullet passing through the trees is not so noticeable. 
 This has been replaced by an increase in the number of mortar shells exploding in the part of the orchard nearest to the road. 
 No doubt the Germans are  aware of the increased activity this side of the Orne, particularly on the road leading to the village. 
 Every cloud of dust on the road has an immediate response from the German mortars. 
 There are now obvious signs that we are here to stay. 
 The latrine situated near to the road at the far end of the orchard has been moved to the other side, as far as possible from the road, due to the increasing mortaring. 
 The new latrine now situated in a quiet corner of the orchard has been given a permanent status; a shithouse clerk has been appointed. 
 This appointment has convinced everyone that no matter what the enemy does now, or in the near future, we are here to stay. 
 The new shithouse clerk, a small, wiry Liverpudlian, was taking his new appointment very seriously when I arrived at his canvasstructured place of work. 
 &bquo;Two minutes, no more, Piper, he remarked from his comfortable armchair at the entrance to the latrine. 
 Three Commandos were perched side by side on a length of wood stretching the length of the latrine. 
 &bquo;Come on, Scouse, what's the grif? 
 When are we going home to Blighty?&equo; 
 One of the Commandos on the perch was addressing the newly appointed clerk. 
 &bquo;Next week some time,&equo; answered the Scouse, &bquo;This is a fact, he continued One of the staff at the big house overheard the Brigade Major talking to the Medical Officer.&equo; 
 The new latrine in its fairly protected situation, and the newly appointed shithouse clerk was to be a great boost to Commando morale during the days ahead. 
 After all, almost everyone would visit the latrine at some time or other, bringing with them a load of information concerning the course of the war. 
 The new latrine was now the source of a new cry, What's the grif, Scouse? as one took one's place on the length of wood, &bquo;When is the Brigade going home?&equo; 
 Scouse would give you time and date according to information supplied to him by his previous customers. 
 The next two days had settled into a daily routine of cleaning weapons and trying to catch up on lost sleep as every night was disturbed by the constant shelling. 
 Yesterday evening I went through the village and along the road leading to the village that had been attacked on the evening of the 12th June. 
 The village was a scene of  devastation with most of the villagers' houses flattened by mainly British shellfire. 
 German S.P. guns and other motorised equipment were lying about the approach road in grotesque twisted shapes, victims of direct hits from the British guns. 
 Several German bodies were sprawled about the road; they were beginning to swell. 
 Clouds of flies were crawling over the faces of the dead Germans. 
 One dead soldier was in a sitting position, his back against a wall, his head leaning backwards with the eyes staring and mouth hanging open, his blonde hair matted and covered with blood. 
 As I turned away there were several mortar explosions behind me, about a hundred yards back along the road. 
 A jeep trailing a cloud of dust was speeding in my direction. 
 The driver slowed as he drew level with me and shouted, &bquo;Get into the ditch!&equo; 
 The jeep sped on towards the crossroads. 
 I threw myself into the ditch as two further explosions occurred, this time at the crossroads just ahead of the jeep. 
 The jeep was gone and the dust had settled, surely the driver realised that dust-raising meant instant reaction from the Germans with shelling and heavy mortaring of the area and the inevitable casualties. 
 As I lay in the ditch I was suddenly conscious of a very strong indescribably sickly smell. 
 Raising myself on one hand to peer over the ditch before clambering out onto the road, my hand and forearm suddenly went through the soft earth up to the elbow. 
 As I pulled my arm out there was a rush of foul-smelling air; my hand and arm covered with a green and black substance. 
 I felt a strong feeling of nausea as I realised that I had put my hand through the chest of a dead British soldier that could have been lying in the ditch for several days. 
 The body had been covered by a thin layer of soil as was the practice when a soldier was killed in action and there was no time to move him to the rear. 
 Before the dead soldier was placed in the ditch his pay books, personal possessions, his equipment, and one of his identity discs were removed, leaving one disc on the body for identification purposes. 
 A light layer of soil was put over the body and the spot marked. 
 If there was time, a roughly made cross was placed at the head of the dead soldier holding his beret or steel helmet. 
 Later, people would come  along, dig him up and remove him to a more permanent resting place where the vicar would say a few words and it would all be over, except for those who remembered him. 
 As I made my way back along the road I noticed that the ditches on both sides of the road contained dead British and German soldiers. 
 The constant mortaring and shelling of the area had dislodged a few of the corpses and the flies and mosquitoes were everywhere. 
 The dead German sitting with his back to the wall that I had passed earlier on had slipped from his position, and was now lying with his blond head in the ditch. 
 At the Saulnier farm (6 Commando area) I washed my arm in the cattle trough but could not get rid of the smell. 
 Looking around the cobbled farmyard and at the farm buildings, the shelling and mortaring that went on during the attack on Breville had taken its toll. 
 There was a gaping hole in the roof of the barn. 
 Over by the entrance to the orchard, two smaller buildings had been demolished. 
 There were a few Commandos resting in the barn, they looked up as I entered but showed no recognition. 
 Their eyes were red through lack of sleep and exhaustion. 
 I turned and left the farm and made my way through the village to Brigade H.Q 
 Seventeenth June, it's 4 a.m. 
 &bquo;Stand-to&equo;, and a steady drizzle has been falling since 3 a.m. 
 The mosquitoes don't seem to like the rain either, they all seem to be at the back of the trench. 
 During the night a German 88 was intermittently shelling the road, making sleep impossible. 
 In my half awake state I heard a shell coming over very low and exploding close by. 
 There was a cry, followed shortly by a pounding of feet past the trench and down through the orchard, then silence, except for a rumble of artillery somewhere in the distance. 
 At 6 a.m. the mortar team started to drum up for breakfast. 
 I waited until the tea was ready then joined them for a warming meal of steak and kidney pudding, followed by a very hot mug of tea into which was placed a measure of Navy rum. 
 Yesterday the spirits and beer ration had reached us; rum for the Officers and beer for the other ranks, but as we were all involved in the war, everything was shared. 
 As I crouched against the wall which offered some  protection against the rain, the mortar team Corporal got up from the grass where he had been sitting and, crossing over to the small pile of H.E. 
 bombs beside the 3&ins; mortar, he picked one up and slid it down the barrel of the mortar. 
 As the bomb shot off over the trees in the direction of the German positions the Corporal returned to his seat, with the remarks. 
 &bquo;Have that for breakfast you bastards.&equo; 
 The team laughed and nodded their approval, continuing with their meal as the rain dripped steadily into the mess-tins and the mugs of tea. 
 Nursing my mug of tea in both hands and feeling the warmth of the rum through my body, the thought crossed my mind as I watched the mortar team sitting on the grass in front of me, &bquo;What if the Germans discovered where we were, and got our range? 
 No doubt they would send over a few H.E. 
 bombs in time for our breakfast tomorrow morning?&equo; 
 I recollect that it had happened before to the team's predecessors, practically on the same spot. 
 &bquo;Penny for your thoughts, Piper,&equo; the Corporal remarked. 
 &bquo;Just enjoying the taste of the rum, Corporal,&equo; I replied, getting to my feet and swilling out the mess-tins and empty mug as I made my way through the drizzle to my now very muddy slit trench. 
 By noon the rain had stopped and already the trees and grass in the orchard were almost dry as the hot sun shone through the leaves. 
 Hello there, Piper. 
 Fancy a run down to the river Orne to collect some water?&equo; 
 I looked up from cleaning my rifle. 
 It was &bquo;Gunga&equo; the driver of the water truck, he hated the nickname, Gunga Din of cinema fame, and everyone was careful to avoid addressing him as anything other than just &bquo;George&equo;. 
 George was a Sheffield man, and proud of it, accent and all, although everyone agreed that if George was dressed in a loincloth and turban he would make a very impressive hillman of the Khyber Pass, with his dark hair and very tanned skin. 
 I slung my rifle over my shoulder and walked across to join him as he was preparing to leave. 
 We called at Brigade H.Q where I picked up my bagpipes. 
 George stared at the bagpipes as I clambered into the passenger seat beside him and sat with the pipes on my lap. 
 &bquo;Right, George. 
 Let's go!&equo; 
 I said, closing the door. 
 &bquo;For Christ's sake, Piper. 
 What the bloody hell are you  going to do with those bloody bagpipes?&equo; 
 &bquo;Play them, of course,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;When you are sucking up all that filthy water from the River Orne into your tank, I shall be further along the river bank playing the bagpipes.&equo; 
 George reluctantly accepted the situation and with a mouthful of curses we drove off down the now dusty road towards the Orne. 
 As we approached the bridge he stopped the truck. 
 &bquo;Right, Piper, you get off here and blow your fucking pipes all you want to. 
 I'll pick you up on the way back.&equo; 
 Gunga drove off over the bridge as I looked around for a suitable spot to get some practice in. 
 The guns a short distance away along the river bank were shelling the German positions as I started up the bagpipes in a fairly secluded thicket, the sound of the drones and the pipe reed easily drowning the noise of the guns. 
 From the thicket I could see the bridge and to my amazement I could see Commandos marching in file across the bridge and coming slowly towards me, a few of them looking and pointing in my direction. 
 Stopping the pipes and stepping out on the footpath at the side of the river I walked towards the Green Berets. 
 Someone in the column seemed to recognise me; he was shouting and waving his arms. 
 &bquo;You are a long way from Achnacarry, Piper! 
 Have you come to march us in?&equo; 
 He was referring to the times at Achnacarry when I would on occasion meet the trainees returning from a speed march and pipe them the last two miles back to the camp. 
 I could see now that they were Royal Marine Commandos, No. 46 Commando of 4th Commando Brigade. 
 After a few pleasantries and the shaking of many hands, I accompanied the column for a short distance along the road. 
 The Sergeant informed me that No. 46 Royal Marine Commando had come ashore in Normandy on D-Day + 1 and had gone into action almost straight away at a spot further along the coast from here, against a crack German S.S. Unit (Hitler Youth). 
 During this and other actions in the area, the Commandos had lost many men, killed, wounded and missing. 
 They were now on their way to join 1st Commando Brigade on the ridge this side of the River Orne, on our left nearest to the coast and probably next to  No. 3 Commando. 
 I missed seeing their C.O. Colonel Campbell Hardy. 
 It seemed that he was further along the road. 
 As we said our goodbyes and hoped to meet up again soon, I couldn't help thinking as I watched the column disappear in the distance that the Marines were not going to find the situation any easier than their last venue. 
 &bquo;Come on, Piper, don't stand there dozing, let's get away from here as quickly as possible!&equo; 
 The voice belonged to George, he had drawn up on the other side of the road, and as I walked towards him his voice was getting impatient. 
 &bquo;With all these Commandos walking about and you playing your bagpipes, the whole German Army will be disturbed. 
 Let's get going, Piper, before they start throwing the shit about.&equo; 
 I got into the truck and George sped away along the road, the water slurping heavily to and fro in the tank immediately behind our seats.  
 The orchard as it is today. 
 Lovat's headquarters's on the left 
 Twentieth June &mdash; visited No. 4 Commando (French Troop) and was saddened by the number of casualties they have had since the landing at La Breche on the morning of 6th June. 
 Their positions were under constant sniper fire during the day so I had to keep as close to the ground as possible. 
 My friend of the South coast of England days, a Corporal Chauvet, informed me in his usual quiet manner that the two Troops of French Commandos, numbering almost two-hundred men, who had landed on 6th June were now, due to casualties, down to about sixty-seven men. 
 Their Commanding Officer, Philip Keifer, was wounded early on and was now back in England. 
 Many Frenchmen whom I met on several occasions at the Training Centre at Achnacarry and on the South Coast of England had also gone, either killed or wounded. 
 Colonel Dawson, Officer commanding No. 4 Commando, had become a casualty and had been evacuated to England. 
 As I spoke to Chauvet and several other Commandos scattered around the orchard, I was impressed by their determination to stay here in France, no matter what. 
 It was sad to think that they had waited so long in England for this invasion of their homeland and after a few hours ashore so many of them had been killed or wounded, the dead now lying in a temporary grave in the corner of a Normandy orchard. 
 I had a meal as a guest of the French Padre and two other Commandos, in a fairly large dug-out. 
 The meal was excellent. 
 I had no idea what it was, but it certainly tasted good, all being washed down with a very good red wine. 
 I have learned very quickly since landing in Normandy to eat  and drink what is offered, with no questions asked. 
 The Padre sitting opposite me had a rifle across his knees, the rifle not in keeping with his rather mild manner and angelic face. 
 He had a good knowledge of Scotland, particularly the bagpipes, and I am sure if I had offered to go along to Brigade HQ to fetch my bagpipes he would have had me marching up and down the orchard playing his favourite tunes, much to the consternation of the other Commandos, and possibly the annoyance of the Germans just a short distance away. 
 The other two Commandos were Bretons and had served in the French Navy. 
 They had to make their way from North Africa to England to join the Free French forces and then volunteered for the Commandos. 
 The time has passed quickly and it is now getting dusk, the mosquitoes have arrived and the German mortaring of the orchard has started, the first salvo exploding a short distance away causing pieces of earth to fall from the logs covering the roof of the trench, the earth and other bits of debris falling onto the now empty mess-tins. 
 I decided to leave before it got dark, first thanking the Padre and his two Breton friends for their very kind hospitality. 
 As I shook hands with the Padre, I said. 
 &bquo;Tell me, Padre, is it usual for a priest to carry a rifle?&equo; 
 The Padre and the two Commandos laughed, one of the Bretons pointing at the Padre with his forefinger, exclaimed, &bquo;He is a bloody good shot, Beel!&equo; 
 With that remark I took my leave and made my way through the orchard and onto the road leading to Brigade H.Q That evening as I lay in my trench I thought about the events of the first seven days in Normandy. 
 The heavy attacks on the Commando positions around the village and the counter attacks that followed have now faded away since the attack on Breville on the night of 12th June. 
 The first seven days of heavy fighting and shelling have caused a large number of casualties; the Commando units in some instances are down to less than half strength. 
 The German infantry facing us appear to have lost the initiative. 
 Or they may just be building up their forces to start another attack. 
 If they do attack again in strength I don't see how we can possibly hold them, due to our large number of casualties and the very few reinforcements that seem to be joining us.  
 A new type of warfare seems to have developed, constant sniping during the day by both sides, and increased mortaring and shelling at night. 
 The British guns behind us seem to have the edge on the German artillery. 
 More shells are passing over our heads on their way to blast the enemy positions, than are coming our way. 
 Of course, we are still receiving the odd British shell dropping in the orchard. 
 The big house (Brigade H.Q) received another hit this evening, it could have been a German or British shell. 
 The wall surrounding the house next to the road was demolished, with large chunks of masonry and shell splinters whistling through the trees. 
 The days passed with the jeeps carrying the dead and wounded from the forward areas stopping briefly at Brigade H.Q on their way to the beaches. 
 Twenty-sixth June &mdash; I accompanied an officer to a meeting at airborne H.Q near the River Orne. 
 Troops and tanks were coming over the bridge, the soldiers appeared very pleased to be here, waving and smiling at everyone. 
 As I stood and watched them pass by I wondered how many of them would be killed or seriously wounded by this time tomorrow afternoon. 
 On the 24th June a small number of reinforcements had reached us and were immediately deployed to the Commando units facing the enemy. 
 I recognised one of the Commandos as someone I knew before the war. 
 My parents had moved to the outskirts of Glasgow and I joined the local pipe band and met Duncan McIntyre. 
 He was a side drummer and very keen to join the Cameron Highlanders Pipe Band. 
 Meantime, he was employed at the local grocery store as a delivery boy delivering groceries to the local customers on his bike. 
 He had very red hair and a pale complexion with masses of freckles all over his face, he was very popular with everyone and lived for the day when he could join the Army, particularly the Camerons. 
 Eventually, we both arrived at Inverness as Privates in the Cameron Highlanders. 
 Duncan, by his keeness, was soon sporting three stripes and had got himself married. 
 We parted, I joined the Commandos, he stayed on with the Cameron Pipe Band as Sergeant. 
 We next met briefly at Achnacarry. 
 He had given up his three stripes to join the Commandos and was now the father of  two children, a boy and a girl, his wife living with her parents in Perth. 
 As we shook hands, I said, &bquo;For Christ's sake, Duncan, you have a wife and two kids. 
 You have given up your rank of Sergeant to run all over these hills. 
 &bquo;Oh, I shall soon get my stripes back and I shall enjoy the excitement of the Commandos; anyway my Piper friend, I shall enjoy running all over these hills. 
 I left for the South Coast to join Lord Lovat and the invasion that was to come.&equo; 
 Duncan stayed on at Achnacarry to complete his Commando training. 
 We next met the day he arrived in Normandy. 
 I was standing outside Brigade H.Q when the reinforcements marched through the village. 
 I recognised his shock of red hair and freckled face straightaway. 
 I walked alongside the column for a short distance. 
 He was desperately keen to be in action and was excited about being here in France. 
 That same evening, two hours later, he was killed by a German mortar bomb that had exploded directly on his slit trench. 
 He was lying on the ground covered with a blanket when I arrived, the medics were preparing to place the body on a jeep. 
 As they lifted him on to a stretcher and then on to the jeep the blanket slipped away from his shoulders revealing his red hair and a very white arm covered in freckles. 
 I stood staring at the jeep as it bumped and swayed over the uneven ground of the orchard until it reached the road and then disappeared in a cloud of dust. 
 &bquo;Friend of yours, Piper?&equo; remarked a Commando as he passed by. 
 &bquo;He didn't last very long in Normandy! 
 Just joined us this evening from England.&equo; 
 The tanks and troops were still crossing the river as the Officer I had accompanied drew up beside me with the jeep. 
 &bquo;Jump aboard, Piper,&equo; he said, &bquo;and let's get ahead of that lot,&equo; indicating with his arm the direction of the tanks grinding along the road. 
 &bquo;Some of these poor bastards won't be alive this time tomorrow, Piper.&equo; 
 As we overtook the tanks and troops the Officer turned to me and remarked, &bquo;Sorry about your friend copping a packet the other day. 
 Most unfortunate, had been in action only a couple of hours. 
 Well, that's the way it goes, Piper,&equo; and in the same breath, &bquo;look in that canvas bag on the back seat  and help yourself to what you want.&equo; 
 I looked in the bag, it was full of fish. 
 &bquo;Yes, Piper, fish, freshly caught, or should I say blown out of the water!&equo; 
 It appeared that the officer had been admiring the fish swimming about in the water of the Orne when a Royal Marine Commando asked him if he would like some for his supper. 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; the Officer replied. 
 The Marine said, &bquo;Get down behind that grass bank, Sir,&equo; and he immediately lobbed a Mills grenade into the river. 
 The resulting explosion had the dead and stunned fish floating on the surface of the water, a procedure I had practised a few times in the Highlands, lobbing a grenade into a salmon pool, a dangerous procedure if caught by someone in authority. 
 Seems that the practice is quite legal this side of the English Channel, at least for hungry British troops passing through. 
 The mortar team in the orchard were delighted when I turned up with ten fresh fish which were cooked immediately. 
 We ate the fish and polished off some cider while we watched the bombers blasting Caen, the British guns along the Orne joining in for good measure. 
 Twenty-eighth June &mdash; this evening I joined the Marine Commandos to take part in a night standing patrol. 
 These patrols had to be very careful owing to the close proximity of the German positions and the difficult countryside of high hedges and tall earth banks with trees on top. 
 The heavily wooded area was criss-crossed with tracks, some leading to farm buildings, others leading to a barn in a clearing of corn, the whole scene, particularly at night, required vigilance as the enemy had mined the well-worn tracks. 
 Many of the German mines were most unusual. 
 One in particular was a small wooden box, something like a shoe box and was filled with explosives. 
 If stepped on, it could blow a foot off. 
 This particular mine could not be detected by the ordinary mine detector. 
 The Germans placed this box usually in the gaps in hedges and the approaches to farm buildings, and the rest of a wide area they covered with ingenious booby-traps and other very strange devices, many of these being set off by wandering cattle and horses, as usually happened when the Commando mines and booby-traps were set out in the hedgerows and orchards  in front of our positions. 
 After being briefed by a Sergeant, the three Marine Commandos and myself, faces blackened and carrying weapons, set off through the orchard and out into the thickly wooded area in front of the German positions. 
 It was dusk and we would be out all night, returning at dawn next morning when we would be relieved by another patrol. 
 As we moved along I couldn't help feeling apprehensive as I looked for newly disturbed ground that could contain a box mine, or glancing at the trees and hedges for signs of booby-traps. 
 It was dark when we took up a position among thick briars and long grass. 
 A few yards through the gloom I could make out the shape of a hedge and what appeared to be the entrance to a sunken road. 
 We took up all-round observation with our boots touching in the centre. 
 My eyes had become accustomed to the now semi-darkness, so I could pick out shapes about seventy-five yards away. 
 We had a good field of fire all round in case the enemy came out of the sunken road or over the hedge. 
 The Sergeant had arranged signals with us if we happened to see anything to our front, by moving our feet and so prevent talking. 
 In the near distance to our rear the guns had started shelling the German positions, the shells uncomfortably low as they rushed overhead and crashed into an area a short distance away. 
 The shelling went on for about an hour then almost complete silence descended on the area as I continued to stare to my front. 
 After a couple of hours of observing in these conditions, shapes and objects in front of me appeared to move, if I stared at them for too long. 
 About one o'clock in the morning I was fighting to keep awake. 
 With the strain of listening for the slightest sound a desperate tiredness had set in and I was having to force myself to stay awake. 
 I felt a slight tap on my right foot, it was the Commando lying next to me. 
 I turned my head in his direction. 
 He had his fingers to his lips and was pointing to his right. 
 I listened and could hear the sound of voices, German voices, getting louder, or closer. 
 The talking went on for a few moments then the sudden, all too familiar, sound of a mortar bomb leaving the barrel. 
 &bquo;Christ, do they know that we are here and decided to blast us out?&equo; 
 All kinds of thoughts raced through my mind as I waited for the explosion in our midst. 
 I was suddenly very much  awake as the Germans sent off another two bombs, The first had exploded some distance away, followed by the two others; the German mortar team were dropping their bombs on the Commando positions to our rear. 
 They seemed about thirty or forty yards away from us as they now talked in lower tones with the occasional laugh, obviously unaware of our presence. 
 The German mortar team reminded me of the Commando mortar team back in the orchard at Brigade H.Q when they were mortaring the German positions. 
 Up until now I have been fascinated by the sound of a bomb leaving the barrel; this evening and the closeness to the enemy mortar had changed all that. 
 There was no more talking from the Germans, and no more mortaring, the remaining part of the night passed fairly quickly with no further signs of tiredness as we lay and listened. 
 As dawn came up in the sky we made preparations to move back to our own lines, covering our withdrawal and keeping careful watch for any signs of the enemy. 
 After a hot mess-tin full of oxtail soup, I was more than ready to get into any old slit trench to have some desperately needed sleep. 
 As I curled up. 
 in the rear of the trench, wrapped myself in an old Army blanket, I could hear the sound of the German sniping starting up for the day. 
 At least I shall miss all that for a couple of hours or so. 
 I was awakened around noon by the Sergeant who was in command of yesterday evening's patrol. 
 As I clambered out of the trench and sat on the grass with my back to a tree he handed me a mess-tin full of very tasty Machonachie stew which I soon polished off. 
 Looking at my arms I could see that the mosquitoes appeared to have had a field day. 
 There were lumps and bumps all over the place, accompanied by intense itching. 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ, Piper, the mauses have had a bloody good go at you last night. 
 Have you seen your face?&equo; 
 I drew my fingers over my face, tenderly rubbing at the swellings and could well imagine what the scene looked like. 
 &bquo;Piper, it's a bloody good job you were not wearing your kilt last night during the patrol.&equo; 
 &bquo;I agree, Sarge, the Bocage  is no place for wearing the kilt! 
 If it were so, I would now be scratching the lumps and bumps on a very delicate area.&equo; 
 We both laughed as we  got to our feet and cleaned out our mess-tins. 
 &bquo;Must be getting back to Brigade H.Q, Sarge,&equo; I remarked as I picked up my rifle and prepared to leave. 
 &bquo;By the way, Piper, the patrol that relieved us this morning, one of their number had his leg blown off and has other serious injuries.&equo; 
 It appears that he stepped on one of those box mines placed in a gap in a hedgerow. 
 As I made my way through the trees in the direction of the village and Brigade H.Q there were several loud explosions a short distance away to my right, followed by a loud burst of automatic fire. 
 By the time I reached the road the medics were bringing the casualties to the First Aid post. 
 I thought about the Commando losing his leg this morning and the two wounded being loaded on to the jeep. 
 Their plight made me feel rather guilty about my concern over the mosquito bites on my face. 
 First of July &mdash; there is a lot of activity on the road leading to the village but still no sign of a German attack or, more important, an Allied breakout. 
 The daily bombing of Caen appears to have increased. 
 How can anyone still be alive in that city after the days and nights of bombing since the 6th June? 
 The whole place must be flattened by this time. 
 Scouse (the latrine clerk) was asked this morning by two Commandos, &bquo;What's the latest Griff, Scouse?&equo; 
 His reply was as confident as usual, &bquo;We shall be going back to England most certainly some time next week. 
 That's official!&equo; 
 &bquo;You lying bastard,&equo; chorused the two Commandos sitting precariously on their perch. 
 &bquo;I don't know where the Scouse gets his information,&equo; continued one. 
 &bquo;He swears that the Brigadier and the Brigade Major use his establishment and supply him with this vital information. 
 If what he says is true, which is highly unlikely, they must visit his latrine during the hours of darkness. 
 A most precarious operation to say the least.&equo; 
 The Scouse always had the last word. 
 &bquo;If you bastards don't believe me, you can find yourselves another shithouse!, 
 With that final remark he would go into a huff and that would be the end of the conversation. 
 The days passed slowly, this static type of warfare was not too popular with the units in 1st Commando Brigade. 
 The training at Achnacarry did not include living for weeks on  end in a hole in the ground subjected to constant mortaring and sniper fire. 
 At least the enemy are in a similar situation probably much worse off then we are judging by the amount of shells passing over our heads to fall in their positions. 
 The aggressive patrols directed at the German lines have increased since the 12th June, no doubt to keep them on their toes. 
 It's strange that the Germans have not attacked us with tanks. 
 It has been very rare to see German aircraft in the sky. 
 Now and again one zooms over about tree-top height but soon disappears, followed a few seconds later by Allied fighters. 
 Most of the Brigade casualties so far have been caused mainly by mortar and shellfire and, of course, the constant sniping. 
 Judging by the number of dead Germans in front of the Commando positions around the village, it's not surprising that they had stopped their frontal attacks. 
 Ninth July &mdash; having supper with the mortar team, the menu pretty good. 
 Self-heating tins of oxtail soup, steak and kidney pudding, followed by plum duff and, of course, the usual battle with the mosquitoes. 
 This was a sort of celebration meal, as word had reached us of the successful British attack on Caen. 
 The German army had pulled out leaving the entire city in ruins and, according to the information at Brigade H.Q, the devastation was unbelievable. 
 It was now D-Day+33 as we discussed the possibility of an advance by the Brigade from these positions along the ridge. 
 Later this evening, about 11 p.m., the Germans mounted a bombardment of our positions which convinced us sheltering in the slit trenches that the enemy were still in front of us in strength and were telling us that they intended to stay there. 
 Next morning at &bquo;stand-to'&equo; there were the usual reports of wounded which were backed up by the increased activity of the jeeps carrying the casualties to the rear, among them several Airborne troops. 
 Nothing much has been seen of the civilian population since we entered the village on the 6th June. 
 The first evening we arrived, after digging in, a few of us from Brigade H.Q took a walk through the village and found the local caf&eacute;. 
 Here we were joined by a small group of French Commandos, no doubt with the same views in mind; something to drink and eye up the local crumpet! 
 We  were lucky in finding something to drink but unfortunate as far as the crumpet was concerned. 
 The young lady behind the bar was scared stiff by our presence. 
 She was quite attractive except for a very nasty skin condition, her face and arms were covered with a large number of pustules and it was obvious that she had been scratching them; the scratch-marks were bleeding slightly. 
 As I stared at her wondering what had caused the condition, I decided that it must be some kind of vitamin deficiency. 
 She handed me a glass of cider, others accepted a small glass of a clear liquid that made them wince as they swallowed it. 
 The gathering was suddenly brought to an end as a cluster of mortar bombs exploded on the village green shattering the windows of the caf&eacute; and dislodging bottles from the shelves. 
 Everybody scattered, including the scared young lady with the serious skin condition; she just vanished out of the back of the caf&eacute; leaving us with smashed bottles and glasses. 
 The mortaring continued for about ten minutes, then it was back to the orchard and comparative safety of the slit trench. 
 Our first evening out in France had gone off with several bangs and broken glass. 
 Now that Caen had fallen, some of the villagers, were beginning to drift back to their homes. 
 Once again I met up with the old Frenchman who had invited me into his home. 
 One evening as I was walking through the village, I heard a voice coming from the gable end of a cottage, &bquo; Bonsoir, Monsieur. 
 Comment allez-vous ?&equo; 
 The voice repeated the greeting, then, &bquo; Cornemuse, Cornemuse &equo;. 
 I turned round; it was the old Frenchman. 
 We shook hands warmly; I noticed that he had his old clay pipe in his mouth but there was no tobacco in it as he sucked at it and repeatedly removed the pipe from his mouth. 
 I made him understand that he was to stay where he was and I would return in a few minutes with a tin of tobacco. 
 I managed to scrounge some tobacco at Brigade H.Q and was soon handing it over to the Frenchman. 
 I thought for one moment he was about to perform a Highland Fling. 
 He jumped into the air several times then shook my hand, &bquo; Merci, merci, Cornemuse,; venez manger avec mois ce soir .&equo; 
 &bquo;OK,&equo; I replied, &bquo;but tomorrow evening at 9 p.m., c'est moi qui j'apporterai provisions ! 
 (I will supply the provisions)&equo;. 
 By the look on his face he obviously  understood what I was on about. 
 He filled his pipe with tobacco, lit it and, puffing clouds of smoke, he walked away, turning round to shout, &bquo; Demain ,&equo; and pointing to the cottage. 
 Next evening I arrived at the cottage with the rucksack half-full of tinned food, bully beef, steak and kidney and, of course, the tinned plum duff; chocolate (the hard stuff from the 48-hour ration pack, but still very tasty); tobacco and some cigarettes &mdash; in all, quite a collection of foodstuffs. 
 I felt like Father Christmas as I entered the front door of the cottage to be welcomed like a long-lost son. 
 It was good to be sitting down with a family for dinner even though I didn't understand everything the Frenchman and his wife were talking about. 
 The atmosphere in the almost semidarkness of the cottage was very homely; the food was good, a typical French meal of roast chicken, vegetables and roast potatoes. 
 The Frenchman had produced a bottle of champagne and a couple of bottles of burgundy 1924; with the help of a my little black book of French/English, I understood that he had buried the champagne and the wine in his garden just before the Germans entered the village shortly after the collapse in 1940. 
 The wine was very heady but extremely enjoyable. 
 The Frenchman sat opposite me at the large farmhouse table chatting away for all he was worth and after the meal he puffed away at his pipe as if he hadn't a care in the world. 
 During the evening his wife was very nervous and became extremely agitated when the British guns started up, the shells passing over the village with a loud roar. 
 After a few words with her husband she shook hands with me, kissed him on both cheeks, and then quickly disappeared down the cellar, leaving the two of us to finish off the champagne and burgundy. 
 About 11.30 p.m. 
 I left the old Frenchman still puffing away at his pipe and returned through the village to the orchard next to Brigade H.Q I had a feeling that I would not see the French family again. 
 They both appeared sad throughout the evening and I suspected that there was something wrong; possibly the two children had been injured when their previous home had been damaged by shellfire. 
 It started to rain about 4 a.m. 
 Soon the floor of the trench was covered in water &mdash; soaking into everything. 
  Fortunately the shelling had ceased with just the occasional mortar burst close at hand when the Duty Officer made his rounds at &bquo;stand-to'&equo;. 
 As the days dragged on the strain of continually living in front-line positions began to show in the faces of some of the Commandos. 
 Most of the Brigade, including Officers, were still living in slit trenches, fully clothed, with almost every night disturbed by enemy shelling and mortaring. 
 To ease the pressure, a truckload of Commandos were taken to the rear where they could relax for a couple of days. 
 Seventeenth July &mdash; I joined about 20 Commandos from the various units around the village on a trip to a quiet part of the beach a few miles from our front-line positions. 
 I put on my kilt, picked up my bagpipes, clambered aboard the truck, and we were off to the beach. 
 About one hour later we sat on the sands staring at the cool sea in front of us, thinking how long it was since we had had a bath. 
 My last bath had been on the evening of 4th June; it was now 17th July. 
 Surrounding us on the beach were a large number of French civilians who had come down to the beach to look at the British Tommies. 
 As we continued to stare at the sea, racking our brains about how to go for a swim without a costume, our thoughts were answered by a voice from just behind us. 
 It was Geordie, he was muttering out loud to himself in his strong Geordie accent. 
 &bquo;Well, ah don't know aboot you lot but I'm gangin' into the watter.&equo; 
 We knew that he had started to undress; the smell from his feet and his socks was almost overpowering. 
 I looked round. 
 He was naked, and obviously he was not called the biggest chopper in the Brigade for nothing. 
 He wound his way through us as we sat fascinated at the sight as Geordie tiptoed down the beach towards the sea, his top part a deep tan, from the waist down a dirty white colour. 
 About two yards from the sea he suddenly stopped and jumped round to face us, legs apart and arms above his head, &bquo;Right, you bloody lot, last man to Brighton beach is a sissy&equo;. 
 With that, Geordie ran splashing into the sea. 
 There was a hush for a few seconds then a roar from the French civilians, men, women and children, &bquo; Encore, encore, encore , Tommy.&equo; 
 As we all hastily undressed, Geordie was happily  acknowledging the cheers from his newly acquired fans who, judging by their enthusiasm, appreciated Geordie's special features. 
 We were soon splashing about in the surf washing off weeks of dirt accumulated in the slit trenches. 
 The feeling was exhilarating; the war and the fighting were miles away, and for the next four hours we lay stretched out on the sand drying off, and then into the sea again. 
 Just before we packed up and got aboard the truck, I piped up and down the beach for a few moments. 
 This raised a cheer from the French, but I must admit the day belonged to Geordie and his special attributes, so much appreciated by the French. 
 As we journeyed back across the Orne bridges, I looked around at the happy faces in the truck; up until now, there hadn't been much to laugh about. 
 I also wondered how many in this truck would survive the Normandy campaign and return to England. 
 Eighteenth July &mdash; it appears that a large attack by more than 1,300 British tanks on the enemy positions on the Caen front has been successful in tying down the German Panzer divisions. 
 Yesterday evening, 17th July, just after dusk, Allied bombers blasted the German positions in front of the Commando positions. 
 This was followed by an intense artillery bombardment lasting about two hours, forcing everyone in the orchard to keep well below ground. 
 Our day out to the beach now seemed like a dream. 
 As I crouched in the slit trench in the semi-darkness I could hear the odd British shell that had been intended for the Germans but had dropped short in the orchard explode with a terrific roar close at hand, causing a shower of dirt to fall from the roof of the trench. 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ, how long is this going to last?&equo; 
 I stretched out, forcing my legs against the side of the trench. 
 I found that if I did this, I felt much better and had the feeling that everything would be all right. 
 Next morning, 19th July, all is quiet, and after breakfast I decided to pay a visit to the other Commando units; 4 Commando and 3 Commando, lots of new faces, not many of those who landed on the 6th June are left. 
 The reinforcements in these units were trained after I left 
 Achnacarry and have probably done a shortened course. 
 It seems very strange to meet people who have passed through  the C.B.T.C. who have never seen me before, or marched behind me from Spean Bridge railway station to start their training. 
 I spoke to as many reinforcements as I possibly could, especially those who had just arrived from Achnacarry. 
 &bquo;How is Charlie Vaughan?&equo; 
 &bquo;Is it still pissing down?&equo; 
 Most of the reinforcements could not inform me of the health of Colonel Vaughan, but they all had vivid recollections of the most unusual weather conditions in the Highlands, and at the moment regarded their situation here in Normandy as an improvement on Achnacarry. 
 I thought a lot about Fiona; no point in making enquiries to these people. 
 Their busy day-to-day activities at the Commando Training Centre would not allow them time to get to know the locals. 
 The mail from home is now arriving fairly frequently and I look forward to each day hoping that a letter will arrive from Fiona. 
 Last week I received three letters from her all addressed to the Commando area in the South of England and forwarded to Normandy. 
 I enjoy reading her letters, and the way she describes the scenes, the weather, and the local gossip in Lochaber, especially after her very rare visits to Spean Bridge. 
 My cousin Kate, from near Fort William, also keeps me informed as to what is happening in and around Achnacarry. 
 Although I have mentioned to Kate of my association with Fiona, the two have never met. 
 That is according to Kate. 
 I mentioned in my last letter to Fiona that Lord Lovat had been badly wounded during an attack on the enemy positions on the evening of 12th June. 
 I also reminded her of her predictions concerning Lord Lovat and herself, and that I hoped very much to see the end of the campaign in Normandy and looked forward to meeting her again in the Highlands. 
 No doubt the person who censors the letters before they leave the Front has deleted all of my remarks concerning Lovat. 
 The censor at the moment happens to be the Medical Officer attached to Brigade H.Q How can one possibly write a love letter to someone when someone else reads it first, and draws at random a blue pencil through your choicest lines? 
 Come to think of it, that bloody M.O. 
 gives me some very strange looks when we happen to meet. 
 He probably thinks that my letters are a load of rubbish,  but still helpful to the enemy. 
 I would be interested to read what he writes to his  wife or girlfriend. 
 This week NO. 4 Commando have moved from the positions they have occupied at Hauger since the 6th june and moved to new positions in the village of Breville, a short distance from here. 
 The Germans who have been facing us all these weeks have pulled out and are now dug in in a thickly wooded area about three-hundred yards from No. 4 Commando. 
 The enemy have lost no time settling in and are now busy mortaring their former positions, causing the usual casualties. 
 Visited No. 4 Commando this morning in their new positions in the Breville area. 
 The village is almost completely destroyed, which is not surprising, due to the bombardments that it has been subjected to since 6th June by British artillery and naval guns. 
 The German infantry were very determined in their defence of this area and have repulsed several attacks by Commandos and Airborne troops. 
 By the number of enemy dead lying about the fields and approaches to the village, the British attacks have finally forced them to move out, taking shelter in a slit trench during a German mortar attack, everyone keeping their heads down. 
 After the mortaring had ceased I decided to get back to Brigade H.Q, probably it would be much quieter there. 
 As I climbed out of the trench I glanced to right and left; other Commandos were now scrambling out of their trenches. 
 All was silent except for the automatic fire fairly close at hand, somewhere down by the crossroads. 
 I exchanged a greeting with a Frenchman of No. 4 Commando as he walked towards me. 
 Suddenly there was the unmistakable swish of a mortar bomb, then the explosion a few yards away. 
 I stood frozen to the spot unable to do anything; I could see soldiers diving for cover; the Frenchman who was coming towards me with a smile on his bearded face was now lying on the ground. 
 It must have been all over in a few seconds. 
 They were now tending to the Frenchman as he lay on the ground. 
 His face was the usual grey colour, his mouth was open and his eyes were staring upwards. 
 As the medics were carrying him away I could see blood oozing out of the eye-holes of his boots and dripping on the ground. 
 As I walked through the rubble in  the direction of the road leading back to Amfreville and Brigade H.Q I passed a few slit trenches manned by No. 4 Commando. 
 One of the Commandos shouted a greeting. 
 Someone else shouted &bquo;Won't be long now, Piper! 
 Get your pipes ready! 
 We have got the bastards on the run!&equo; 
 I looked across and gave them a wave and wondered if they would still be alive next time I visited Breville. 
 I believe we have settled down to accept the situation. 
 A comrade is talking to you one moment and is gone the next, either blasted beyond recognition or seriously wounded. 
 Even those with the socalled minor wounds are taken out of the situation as their appearance can affect the morale of the others. 
 Twenty-third July &mdash; sitting under a tree a few yards from my slit trench writing a letter to my parents in Glasgow. 
 The weather seems to be changing, very misty and cold first thing in the morning, first time I have really felt miserable at 4 a.m. during &bquo;stand-to'&equo;. 
 By noon the sun has come up and it's getting very warm; the orchard appears peaceful, the sound of guns seem a long distance away. 
 I have finished my letter and sit staring down through the orchard thinking about those who have occupied the slit trenches since 6th June: Taff, the mortar team, the others who have gone and have been replaced by new faces. 
 My thoughts are interrupted by Mick from the big house. 
 &bquo;Come on, Piper. 
 Get off your arse and get over to H.Q The Brigadier wants to see you straight away!&equo; 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ, Mick, what does Mills Roberts want to see me  about?&equo; 
 &bquo;Never mind, Piper, get your kilt on and get over there fast, or you will soon hear him bellowing throughout the area., 
 I hurriedly changed, all the time thinking &bquo;what have I done?&equo; 
 &bquo;Why does he want to see me ?. 
 I am over at the big house within a couple of minutes, kilt on, best sporran and carrying the bagpipes, and prepared for anything. 
 A sternfaced Sergeant meets me at the entrance to the big house. 
 &bquo;Right, Piper, follow me.&equo; 
 I get into step with him and we stop at a door at the end of the corridor. 
 &bquo;Right, Piper, we'll forget the bloody left, right, left, right, routine,&equo; snarls the Sergeant, &bquo;When I knock on this door and you hear someone say &bquo;come in'&equo;, you go in, turn right, and salute. 
  OK Piper?&equo; 
 &bquo;OK, Sergeant!&equo; 
 I replied. 
 He knocked on the door, a voice rasped &bquo;Come in,&equo; the Sergeant opened the door, I stepped into the room, turned right and gave one of my best salutes. 
 In the dim light and seated behind a desk was the unmistakable smiling face of Colonel Charlie Vaughan. 
 There was a figure on either side of him but I could only see Charlie Vaughan. 
 It was only when he remarked, &bquo;You know Brigadier Mills Roberts and the Brigade Major, Piper?&equo; 
 I glanced at the faces on either side of the Colonel, but I was still fascinated by Charlie Vaughan. 
 &bquo;Stand at ease, Piper,&equo; remarked Charlie, a big grin on his face, then he went serious and remarked slowly, &bquo;You have done what you came here to do, Piper; you piped Lovat's brigade ashore and now I would like you to return to Achnacarry with me this evening. 
 There is still a lot of work to do at the Training Centre.&equo; 
 I looked at Charlie, then at Mills Roberts, and the Brigade Major. 
 I wanted very much to say to Colonel Vaughan. 
 Right, Sir, let's go. 
 Brigadier Mills Roberts was staring at me &mdash; he made me feel guilty. 
 Suddenly, I blurted out &bquo;I'm sorry, Sir. 
 I would prefer to stay here in Normandy and return to England with the Brigade at the end of the Normandy campaign&equo;. 
 I could hardly believe what I was saying. 
 I could be in London this evening with Colonel Vaughan having a good piss-up, then probably on leave for a couple of weeks. 
 Christ, have I gone mad? 
 Why do I want to stay here in this bloody place? 
 I thought I detected a smirk on the face of Mills Roberts. 
 I know for sure if he hadn't been on the scene and it was only Colonel Vaughan and myself, I would most likely have said. 
 Right, Sir, let's go. 
 Colonel Vaughan, as benevolent as ever, remarked &bquo;All right, Piper, see you at Achnacarry at the end of the Normandy campaign. 
 Best of luck to you&equo;. 
 The Brigade Major got up and opened the door. 
 I saluted, had a last look at Charlie Vaughan, turned about and marched out of the room, along the corridor, out of the front door and back to the orchard and the mosquitoinfested slit trench. 
 That evening is I crouched at the back of the slit trench,  swatting the mauses and listening to the sound of shells passing over and the rain dripping steadily in through the entrance to the trench, I stared at the pool of water getting larger and hoped that the rain would soon stop, if it doesn't I'm in for an uncomfortable night. 
 Colonel Vaughan will be in London by this time. 
 Oh well, I've stuck it out so far. 
 I may as well stick it out to the end. 
 One point that I must be very careful about. 
 That is, under no circumstances must I mention to anyone that I have turned down an invitation to return to Blighty. 
 They would really believe that I had gone completely mad. 
 Others, I suppose, would remark &bquo;You lying bastard, Piper. 
 Who would invite you to return to England?&equo; 
 About 2.30 a.m. the shelling increased and lasted until 3.30 a.m. 
 Luckily, the rain had stopped and I spent a few minutes baling out, thinking once again that I must do something about drainage, but never seem to get round to it as the weather clears up and everything dries out very quickly. 
 Ten a.m., 24th July; just finished breakfast with the mortar team and relaxing for a few minutes over a mug of hot tea discussing the number of casualties after the heavy shelling last night. 
 It appears that Geordie, the Newcastle chap who cheered things up during the trip to the beach last week, by being the first to run naked into the sea, was badly wounded when his jeep ran over a mine and the driver was killed. 
 The peace and quiet of the morning was shattered by someone bellowing something from the direction of Brigade H.Q Suddenly into view comes the Brigadier, Derek Mills Roberts. 
 He catches sight of the mortar team and myself sitting on the grass drinking our tea. 
 We spring to attention and salute as the Brigadier approaches. 
 &bquo;Noisy night, noisy night, but quiet now,&equo; he bellows, then suddenly stops in his tracks, raises his right arm and points with his forefinger down the orchard, shouting at the top of his voice. 
 &bquo;You there, you dozy man, don't you salute an Officer when you see one?&equo; 
 We turned our heads in the direction the Brigadier is pointing and see a Commando about a hundred-and-fifty yards away towards the end of the orchard and almost obscured by the trees, making his  way slowly in the direction of Scouse's latrine. 
 As we watch, the Commando stops, springs to attention facing the direction of the  the  Brigadier and gives a very smart salute; he obviously recognised the one and only Mills Roberts' commanding voice. 
 Turning in our direction, the Brigadier, in a much quieter voice, said &bquo;Piper, this afternoon there will be a parade and march past to be held on the village green. 
 You will lead the march, I shall be taking the salute. 
 Any questions?&equo; 
 Before anyone could say a word he had turned on his heel and strode off looking to left and right as he went. 
 We stood and stared after him for a few seconds, then one of the mortar team behind me remarked. 
 &bquo;Now, lads, there goes a mad bastard if ever there was one.&equo; 
 Mills Roberts was a stickler for discipline but everyone recognised him as a good soldier and therefore, for all his shouting, he was a popular figure. 
 After a few enquiries at Brigade H.Q I presented myself outside the big house at 2 p.m. wearing kilt, polished boots (which took some doing) and, of course, carrying the bagpipes. 
 Already assembled there were representatives from the Commando units in the Brigade, Nos. 3, 4, 6, 45 RM Commando and the French Troop of 4 Commando. 
 The Brigadier appeared and, after much foot stamping and saluting, everyone got lined up and ready to move off, but not before the Brigadier insisted that there should be a bodyguard of four Commandos to protect the Piper. 
 This was something new for me. 
 Lovat had never mentioned anything about bodyguards, he just said, &bquo;Get out in front there, Piper, and keep playing your pipes.&equo; 
 This had been the routine during the landing at La Breche and the advance to the Orne bridges. 
 &bquo;Sir, I prefer not to have a bodyguard. 
 I would just rather march at the head of the unit as I have done on many other occasions.&equo; 
 I fully expected to be instantly bawled out. 
 The Brigadier glared at me for a few seconds and replied rather quietly. 
 &bquo;You know that the enemy are just a short distance along the road?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, Sir,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;All right, forget the bloody bodyguards,&equo; he snapped, and strode off with the Brigade Major and two other Officers in the direction of the proposed saluting base,  which lay about half-way along our route. 
 I took up my place a short distance in front of the Officer in Command of the parade. 
 The RSM brought everyone to attention, &bquo;By the right, quick march,&equo; barked the Officer and we were off to a jaunty 6&ndash;8 time, Blue Bonnets Over the Border , as I got under way. 
 A little apprehensive at the turn just past the Saulnier farm, the spot referred to by the Brigadier that was within earshot of the enemy. 
 As we swung past the farm, the farmer, no doubt attracted by the sound of bagpipes, was standing at the entrance to his farm, a bewildered look on his face. 
 He doffed his cap as we marched past, and a few paces further on we negotiated the turn and were heading back along the road on the other side of the village green towards the saluting base. 
 I turned off the road when I drew level with the Brigadier and his Officers, and placed myself on the right of Mills Roberts as the Brigade swept past to the tune Highland Laddie . 
 As I looked at the faces marching past with a smart eyes right, I couldn't help thinking of those who would have liked to have been on this parade; those still manning the trenches, and all those buried in a shallow grave in the orchards around the village. 
 The parade was over and, judging by the expression on the Brigadier's face, a success. 
 &bquo;Very well played, Piper,&equo; remarked Mills Roberts as he and his Officers left the saluting base and made their way across the village green in the direction of Brigade H.Q I remained at attention until they disappeared through the gates of the big house. 
 I felt it was prudent to remain silent and then keep out of the Brigadier's way until he had forgotten the incident of the bodyguards. 
 The parade dispersed, the Commandos returning to their respective units, and soon the village green was quiet, except for the murmur of French voices as the civilians read the newsheet pinned to a tree. 
 Whatever the newsheet was telling them they all seemed excited about it; there was waving of arms and pointing in the direction of Caen. 
 The newsheet had started to appear over the past few days as the villagers began to return to their homes. 
 As the military situation changed, particularly after the fall of Caen, the military would pin the recent news to the large tree on the village green. 
 The reason for all the excitement  over this newsheet was the information it contained &bquo;The Allied armies are advancing on all Fronts&equo;. 
 This evening I visited Scouse's latrine, the mosquitoes and all the flies were having a fieldday; there were clouds of them hanging over the latrine in the still evening air. 
 Scouse was seated in his armchair reading a paperback &mdash; a Western &mdash; oblivious to the flies and mosquitoes, and as I approached it was obvious he was not bothered in any way about the smell. 
 There were three Commandos in the latrine, one was addressing Scouse with the usual, &bquo;Come on, Scouse, when are we going home?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's no use telling you disbelieving bastards anything, but I will tell you this: The Brigade is moving out of this place tomorrow.&equo; 
 The Scouse flicked over a page of his cowboy book and continued reading as the three Commandos chorused, &bquo;You lying bastard&equo;. 
 I thought I detected a knowing smile on the face of the Scouse as he ignored his critics, the flies, the mosquitoes, the smells, and settled into his armchair at the entrance to the latrine. 
 There had been a lot of activity in and around Brigade H.Q It appears that the enemy in front of the Commando positions has started to pull out, possibly due to the Allied advance in the Caen area about ten miles from here. 
 Twenty-sixth July &mdash; the Brigade advanced, No. 4 Commando has already gone. 
 I visited their positions this morning as a passenger in a jeep. 
 &bquo;Christ, they were quick off the mark, Piper,&equo; remarked the driver, swinging the jeep round and heading back along the road to Brigade H.Q. Nos. 3 and 6 Commando were pulling out as we entered the village; no sign of 45 Royal Marine Commando. 
 The transport attached to Brigade H.Q were lined up and ready to leave. 
 I placed my pipes and rucksack on the back seat of the jeep and informed the driver that I was going into the orchard for a last look round. 
 &bquo;That's OK, Piper. 
 I shall still be here; you and I shall follow on later.&equo; 
 As I entered the orchard it looked completely deserted. 
 Everyone had gone. 
 Even Scouse's latrine had disappeared as if it had never been there. 
 As I stood and gazed at the now empty slit trenches, I couldn't help a sinking feeling in my stomach as I pictured in my mind those who had occupied the trenches in this orchard, those who had been killed or seriously  wounded. 
 Taff, the mortar team, and all the others who were present one day and gone the next, some to hospital in England, and others to a shallow grave here in Normandy. 
 The big house (Brigade H.Q) was also deserted, the transport and the staff had just left, except the jeep still standing in the driveway. 
 I entered the house through the front door. 
 It seemed like a very long time ago when I and others followed Lovat into this house. 
 A lot of water had certainly gone down the burn since 6th of June. 
 Lovat wounded and back in England, Mills Roberts now Brigadier. 
 There has certainly been a lot of comings and goings in this Brigade H.Q 
 The village was quiet with only a couple of old men sitting on a bench outside the church as we drove through the gates of the big house and along the road through the village, passing the Chateau where the Commando dead had been placed on the front lawn shortly after we had entered the village, and during the bitter fighting of the first ten days. 
 The driver stopped the jeep outside the Saulnier farm for a few moments to say goodbye to the farmer, a very good friend to the Commandos, especially No. 6 Commando. 
 There were tears in the eyes of the farmer as he shook us warmly by the hand. 
 I was hoping he would not offer us a glass of his very potent drink that I now know as Calvados. 
 Luckily for us he was too overcome to offer us refreshment, so we said our farewells and got back into the jeep and drove off along the road leading to the village of Breville. 
 I looked round, the farmer was still standing in the middle of the road;. 
 I gave him a final wave just before we turned into the approach road leading to the village. 
 I was pleased to be on the move again. 
 It had been a long time living in a hole in the ground, let's hope things get better. 
 At least, I hope that the next slit trench is more comfortable, with fewer mosquitoes, and a minimum of mortaring. 
 The advance was a distance of about five or six miles, passing through Bavant, a small village now occupied by No. 6 Commando. 
 We drove on through the village and turned into a clearing surrounded by a thickly wooded area. 
 First things first, we dug in. 
 I chose a situation close to a hedgerow and was soon scouting around for logs or pieces of  wood to cover the trench and to give some sort of protection against shrapnel. 
 The time is now 7.30 p.m. and I have just finished a very good meal of my favourite steak and kidney out of, of course, the self-heating tin. 
 This was all washed down with a bottle of red wine. 
 There is no label on the bottle, it tastes a wee bit vinegary. 
 I suppose I cannot complain, the wine was scrounged from the Officers quarters at Brigade H.Q just before we left that area. 
 Before dusk I had a look around and was surprised to come across several graves of British soldiers, here and there in the undergrowth. 
 How did they manage to get this far into German-held territory? 
 The first two graves were one behind the other in a ditch, with a rough cross stuck into the ground at the head of each grave. 
 On top of the crosses were a soldier's Balmoral and the badge of the Gordon Highlanders. 
 The other graves contained soldiers of the Airborne, on each cross was a Red Beret. 
 These soldiers appeared to have been hurriedly buried by the retreating Germans, they had probably died of their wounds. 
 I felt a lump in my throat as I looked down at the first grave, the Balmoral on the cross was torn at the front as if a piece of shrapnel had smashed its way through the badge and into the soldier's head. 
 At least the enemy had taken time to bury the soldiers, but what a way to go; dead and buried in a ditch hundreds of miles from home. 
 The soldiers' families have probably received by this time a letter containing the words &bquo;missing in action'&equo;. 
 The first few days in Bavant were fairly quiet as far as the enemy activity was concerned, with a few mortar bombs coming over from time to time. 
 It was difficult to determine from which direction they were coming due to the thickly wooded area that we were dug-in. 
 Will we ever get rid of these mosquitoes? 
 Day and night they are hanging in swarms above the trench making it extremely difficult to rest. 
 Sleep is impossible yet the Commando in the next trench when I looked in on him was sleeping soundly, his face and arms uncovered and the mosquitoes completely ignoring him. 
 It appears to me that I have collected his and everyone else's quota of the annoying little bastards, so I return to my trench, wrap myself up, and sleep fitfully until  I am awakened to take my turn on guard. 
 First August &mdash; a very welcome trip with the driver of the jeep to the bridges over the Orne. 
 Passing through Amfreville we meet part of 4 Commando Brigade marching through the village to take up new positions near the village of Troarn, a short distance from 1st Commando Brigade area. 
 We stop the jeep for a few words with the Marines, some I recognise from a few weeks ago when they were on their way to take up positions on the coast, on the left of 1st Commando Brigade. 
 It appears that the German Infantry facing the Marines has surrendered, and now No. 4 Commando Brigade are following up the retreating Germans. 
 We sat in the jeep for a few moments watching the column as it disappeared along the very dusty road, and was soon out of sight, after passing Sulnier's farm. 
 &bquo;Don't fancy marching in this heat,&equo; remarked the driver as he started up the engine and we sped off in the direction of the Orne bridges. 
 Very cold, misty morning, 5th August I think. 
 I am beginning to get mixed up with the days of the month. 
 Surprise this morning. 
 &bquo;Piper,&equo; bellowed a voice. 
 I looked up &mdash; it was the Sergeant, he was walking towards me. 
 &bquo;There is a bloody madman over there and he requests the pleasure of your company, Piper. 
 His name is Colonel Young, CO of No. 3 Commando.&equo; 
 I stood up as the Sergeant approached. 
 &bquo;Yes, Piper, he wants you to get yourself, and your bagpipes, over there as soon as possible and play him a tune. 
 Christ knows, as if we hadn't enough problems with the bloody Germans without Peter Young stirring them up., The Sergeant marched off muttering loudly to himself, something about &bquo;fucking bagpipes'&equo; and &bquo;&bquo;crazy colonels'&equo;. 
 I collected up the pipes and made my way through the trees in the direction of NO. 3 Commando. 
 Colonel Peter Young was a popular officer, well liked by everyone, always seemed to be of the same temperament, in action, or sitting at the bar in a country inn. 
 Last time I visited No. 3 Commando they were being heavily mortared. 
 Peter Young was strolling about directing the defence of his area against a German counter attack. 
 It's strange as I look back; friendships shall never be the same; or opinions of Officers, especially Officers. 
 All ranks  when in action look at, and study, the facial expression of the Officer in Command. 
 If he is cool and relaxed, all ranks can cope with the situation. 
 I was impressed by Lovat's manner during the landing, on the beach under fire, and especially at the crossroads as he stood and directed the attack on the village of Amfreville. 
 No doubt there are those who have seen fear on my face in certain circumstances in this campaign, just as I have seen the same fear on their faces in the same circumstances. 
 After a few minutes' walk I arrived at the edge of the wooded area; in front of me was about two hundred yards of grass, rising to the high ground covered by thick gorse and ferns. 
 On the high ground a figure was waving to me. 
 Even from this distance it was obviously Peter Young. 
 I returned his wave, and started to walk towards him. 
 After a few minutes we were shaking hands. 
 During my short conversation with the Colonel, I was being observed rather suspiciously by three of his Officers a few feet away, sitting on top of their slit trenches performing their ablutions. 
 One Officer, his face covered with shaving cream, looked in my direction and remarked, &bquo;I hope, Piper, that you do not intend to play those bagpipes here?&equo; 
 &bquo;Certainly, Sir,&equo; I replied, &bquo;that's why I am  here, to cheer things up a bit!&equo; 
 My answer did not go down well with the Officer with the lather on his face. 
 &bquo;Don't you realise that the enemy are only a few yards from these positions? 
 You walking about playing bagpipes is bound to attract enemy fire on to us!&equo; 
 The other two Officers nodded in agreement. 
 Peter Young whispered into my ear, &bquo;Never mind, Piper. 
 The silly sods&equo;. 
 Not wishing to antagonise the Colonel or his Officers, I suggested a compromise. 
 &bquo;I shall start the bagpipes here and walk back down the hill towards the woods, playing as I go.&equo; 
 The Colonel smiled, the three Officers glared, as I placed the pipes on my shoulder. 
 &bquo;What tune are you going to play?&equo; remarked the Colonel. 
 &bquo;Well, Sir, I shall play a well-known bagpipe tune called Ahm No Awa&equo; Tae Bide Awa', Ahm No Awa' Tae Leave Ye, Ahm No Awa' Tae Bide Awa', I'll Aye Come Back Tae See Ye . 
 &bquo;Now what's that in English?&equo; enquired Peter Young, with a larger smile on his face.  
 &bquo;It means, Sir &bquo;I am not away to stay away, I am not away to leave you, I am not away to stay away, I shall always come back to see you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Very appropriate to the situation, Piper. 
 Good luck.&equo; 
 I struck up and walked slowly down the hill. 
 The pipes are sounding well, I thought. 
 As I reached the edge of the woods and stopped playing, I turned round and waved to Colonel Young. 
 He waved back. 
 I entered the woods just as three mortar explosions occurred in quick succession, somewhere in the trees a short distance away. 
 I immediately got down. 
 There was one more explosion among the trees, then silence. 
 I lay on the ground for a few more moments, then continued on my way through the trees in the direction of Brigade Headquarters, pondering on the likely thoughts of Colonel Peter Young and his three Officers back there on the hill. 
 The days spent in the woods close to the village of Bavent are passing slowly. 
 The enemy has not been very active since the 10th August and I somehow miss the occasional mortar burst in the area, or the odd German shell passing over. 
 The Allied artillery appeared to have moved to the south of Bavent and are concentrating their barrages during the hours of darkness, and the early morning, between three and four o'clock. 
 Judging by the sound of the guns, they must be of a heavier calibre, and their target many miles away. 
 It's raining heavily as I wrap myself in my gascape and move further to the back of the trench. 
 At least the rain keeps the mosquitoes away, and the flashes from the guns lighting up the sky appear somewhat comforting as I doze off, conscious of the rain dripping on to my boots. 
 Pleasant break in the daily routine on 16th August. 
 During a visit to Brigade Headquarters I overheard Officers discussing the situation in our area. 
 Someone mentioned the 51st Highland Division and the part of the Front they were dug in, which appeared to be fairly close to our area, probably about seven or eight miles from here. 
 Given permission by the Brigade Major to pay a visit to the Highland Division to obtain new reeds for the bagpipes. 
 The jeep driver was pleased at the opportunity to get away for a few hours and we set off about 3 p.m., arriving in the area of the Highland Division a short time later, after  following their divisional signs along the country lanes. 
 Crossing Benouville bridge we noticed the Highland Division (HD) sign in bold letters on the bridge. 
 Someone with a sense of humour had painted beneath the HD &bquo;D+?&equo; 
 Meaning of course that the 51st had landed in Normandy several days after D-Day morning. 
 The Highlanders were very generous, not only with their bagpipe reeds but also with their wee drams. 
 The hospitality extended to a good meal, and before leaving we were given the facilities of a nearby chateau, where the jeep driver and I had the luxury of a hot bath, laid on by the local Mayor. 
 There was also a touch of home &mdash; one of the Highlanders produced a few newspaper cuttings from the British Press. 
 I was particularly interested in the Scottish papers, the Oban Times  and the Glasgow Daily Mail . 
 Both these newspapers carried accounts of the landings and the important part played by Lovat's 1st Commando Brigade. 
 He would certainly be pleased to read all this about his Brigade. 
 I wonder how he is getting on! 
 Did he survive his wounds? 
 Haven't heard anything for quite some time now. 
 It was dark when we finally left the area of the 51st Highland Division, arriving back at the clearing in the woods near to Bavent, very much refreshed, outwardly and inwardly, not forgetting the gift of a bottle of best malt whisky. 
 Seventeenth August &mdash; visited No. 4 Commando (French Troop) and decided to remain with them for a few days, due mainly to their hospitality and the change of scene. 
 Returned that same evening to Brigade Headquarters to collect my rucksack containing all my worldly possessions and, of course, the bagpipes. 
 Rumours at H.Q about the Brigade advancing in pursuit of the German forces, who have now, it appears, pulled back towards the Seine taking all their equipment with them. 
 Nineteenth August &mdash; the 1st Commando Brigade left the area south of Bavent and set off in pursuit of the enemy. 
 It appears that No. 4 Commando is leading, with the French Troop to the forefront of the advance. 
 Earlier that evening we were visited by Brigadier Mills Roberts, accompanied by several senior Officers, whom I had seen on occasion at Petworth in Sussex (Commando Group Headquarters). 
 The  advance was to have been made during the hours of darkness and across country, keeping away from the roads and lanes. 
 I was excited about the prospect of leaving this area and the boredom of living in a hole in the ground since 6th June; at last we shall be able to stretch our legs. 
 I swung the rucksack containing the bagpipes, and my kit, on to my shoulders. 
 Then, picking up a rifle that had been give to me by the French Commandos, I joined the others, lining up in the darkness at the edge of the wood preparing to move off. 
 We set off in file moving along a narrow gauge railway in pitch darkness I was trying desperately to keep in contact with the Frenchman in front of me and cursing him when he stopped suddenly, causing me to bang my face on his rucksack. 
 We have now moved off the railway and appear to be moving across country, stopping and starting as someone scouts out ahead. 
 We have now been marching for more than four hours, it's still very dark. 
 A burst of automatic fire up front and to our left brings the column to a halt as we then squat on the wet ground and watch the tracers shoot off across the night sky. 
 We're off again, now wading almost waist-deep in water, stopping, starting, bumping into the man in front. 
 What appears to be a mortar explosion close by causes the column to get down on the flooded ground. 
 A few muffled voices a short distance ahead appear to be cursing in French, then silence as the advance continues. 
 At least the French soldier can get annoyed just like his British counterpart. 
 The Frenchman behind me on this march curses under his breath each time I stop suddenly and he bundled into my rucksack. 
 (Wish I knew what he is saying!) 
 As dawn appears in the sky our progress quickens; after crossing a few fields and climbing several hedgerows we are suddenly on a road with farm buildings a short distance away. 
 It's good to feel the firm ground underfoot after hours of trudging through flooded fields and over hedgerows in the darkness. 
 As we squelched along the road and into the farmyard I felt a feeling of utter exhaustion. 
 The rucksack and the rifle I had been carrying since yesterday evening seemed like a ton weight. 
 As my section settled into the straw-filled barn, I dumped the rucksack, and slinging  the rifle over my shoulder, went off in search of something to eat, coffee or whatever was going. 
 A few French Commandos were making their way across the farmyard in the direction of a large barn where it appeared that someone was attempting to prepare breakfast. 
 I joined the others with great anticipation, of, possibly, hot coffee, French bread, maybe fried eggs awaited us in the barn. 
 I could certainly smell coffee brewing. 
 All thoughts of tiredness had now gone as I prepared myself for breakfast and quickened my pace towards the barn. 
 Suddenly, as we were about fifty yards from that lovely smell of coffee, there was an almighty roar as the barn blew up, scattering burning straw and all kinds of debris all over the farm area. 
 l gazed at the devastation from behind a stone horsetrough, lying flat on my face as another explosion sent lumps of metal and cobblestones clattering on to the roofs of the farm buildings. 
 As the smoke cleared and the dust settled, two fighter planes came in over the fields and circled the remains of the barn. 
 Not wishing to remain in this part of the farm one moment longer, I picked up my rifle and dashed back the war I had come, taking advantage of the cover offered by the farm buildings. 
 As I settled down in the straw-filled barn that I had left a few moments ago in search of food, I looked around at the now sleeping Frenchman, stretched out in the straw. 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ,&equo; I thought, &bquo;to have marched all night, then someone blows up the kitchen!&equo; 
 I was awakened by a French Commando nudging me in the ribs with the toe of his boot. 
 As I looked up at him he placed a steaming hot mess-tin full of what looked like Machonachie stew on the floor of the barn beside me. 
 &bquo;'Ere you are, Piper. 
 This is your breakfast,&equo; he said with a large grin on his bearded face. 
 &bquo;We are leaving here in half-anhour so you must be quick with your food.&equo; 
 As I enjoyed the stew I looked at my watch, it was just after mid-day; I had been asleep for nearly four hours. 
 After mopping up the mess-tin with a large piece of French bread that had accompanied the stew, I got to my feet and looked around the barn. 
 Everybody had gone and, judging by the French voices outside in the farmyard, they were preparing to move off. 
 Picking up the rucksack and  the rifle I dashed down the wooden steps amid laughter from the French Commandos. 
 A voice from the front of the column shouted, &bquo;Piper, at Achnacarry and in England you wake us up with your bagpipes; here in France we wake you up with a hot dinner at the last minute.&equo; 
 As we marched out of the farm the Commando behind me thrust a mug full of very tasty wine into my hand. 
 &bquo; A votre sant&eacute; , Piper.&equo; 
 He smiled as I replied, &bquo;And the same to you!&equo; 
 We marched for several hours then rested in a thickly wooded area until darkness fell. 
 There seemed to be plenty to eat, the French are masters at rustling up something to eat at very short notice. 
 &bquo;'Ere you are, Scottish, have this.&equo; 
 I looked up from my sitting position under a tree. 
 The voice belonged to Jake, the French Algerian. 
 He had suddenly appeared through the trees and was thrusting what looked like half a chicken into my now outstretched hand. 
 As he walked away he looked back at me, &bquo;Better eat it, Scottish,&equo; he said, with a serious look on his face. 
 &bquo;Tomorrow morning we attack the German positions and it is possible that we have nothing more to eat after this evening.&equo; 
 I looked at the chicken. 
 By its appearance it had been cooked several days ago. 
 Nevertheless it tasted excellent, or it may have been the dry French cider from my waterbottle that improved the taste. 
 The night was dark as we set off in file through the trees after checking our weapons. 
 I had a look at the bagpipes before pulling the rucksack onto my back, they seemed to be all right &mdash; wonder when I'll play them again? 
 Certainly not in this situation, not in the middle of the Bocage . 
 I could see the outline of the soldier in front of me, at least that is an improvement on yesterday evening's march. 
 There is no bumping into the man in front as we cross the fields and move along the narrow Normandy lanes. 
 Some time in the early hours of the morning we cross over what seems to me to be a pontoon bridge, then suddenly we are up to our thighs in water. 
 Crossing a muddy field in semi-darkness I am surprised to hear voices, sounding like Canadian voices. 
 &bquo;Who are you guys?&equo; 
 The voice was just beside me. 
 I could make out two soldiers standing in a slit trench, they look like Airborne  troops judging by the type of steel helmet they are wearing. 
 &bquo;We are Commandos,&equo; I replied. 
 It appears that the Airborne are puzzled by the French voices as we move through their positions. 
 They are still more puzzled as I wish them good evening and they recognise my Scots accent, As I quickly follow behind the French Commandos I hear one Canadian say to the other. 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ, a load of frogs and a fucking Scotsman&equo;. 
 It's getting light as we scramble down one side of a blown bridge across a river, then scramble up the other side, slipping down, and pulling each other up again until we are all assembled on a grassy bank. 
 A French Officer is speaking to a small group of NCOs as a thick mist is forming all around. 
 I have just sat down on the wet grass when everyone around me starts to move swiftly in the direction of the wooded area just visible through the mist and gloom. 
 I joined the Frenchmen as we double across the grass. 
 As we enter the trees a few shots ring out. 
 I suddenly realise that we are attacking the enemy positions and we are now running through the trees. 
 Everyone around me seems to be firing their weapons. 
 Suddenly the mist clears and we are now in a clearing. 
 I can see several yards in front of me. 
 Figures are now running in front of us, shots are fired from automatic weapons, the running figures fall down. 
 We are now level with the fallen figures; they are German soldiers. 
 We have overrun the enemy positions &mdash; we have surprised them! 
 The excitement carries everyone forward. 
 Suddenly it's light, clear as day; we stop in front of a German 3&ins; mortar with a neat pile of HE bombs beside it. 
 The French Commandos have the heavy baseplate out of the ground and the mortar assembled and in action in what seems like a few seconds. 
 The bombs from the mortar are now exploding in what we believed to be German positions in the wooded area to our front. 
 We are in an orchard with a sunken road leading into it from the main road. 
 There are three fairly large dug-outs covered with heavy logs and camouflaged. 
 Looks like a Company Headquarters, its occupants having pulled out very quickly. 
 The dead Germans lying around had obviously not been quick enough. 
 The enemy have recovered from our sudden appearance in their midst. 
 There is now very active sniping,  followed by a couple of Moaning Minnies exploding close by, forcing us to take cover from the flying shrapnel. 
 I joined a group of five Frenchmen as they got onto the sunken road leading to the orchard. 
 The mortar team are still lobbing their bombs into the enemy positions as we dash across the road and over a five-bar gate, then double along the hedgerow that runs alongside the road. 
 We stopped at a gap in the hedge as the road swung round to the left. 
 About fifty or sixty yards away on the right-band side of the road a mortar bomb burst in the hedgerow, followed a few seconds later by four German soldiers carrying automatic weapons jumping from the hedgerow and scampering along the road. 
 From the gap in the hedgerow we opened fire on the running Germans, toppling them over one after the other. 
 We lay still for what seemed like ages, my eyes were riveted to the figures lying in the road. 
 The mortaring had ceased. 
 The French Commandos firing their captured German mortar had probably run out of bombs. 
 From the spot in the hedgerow where the four German soldiers had come from a white flag tied to a long piece of wood had suddenly appeared. 
 As we watched a German soldier &mdash; his hands above his head &mdash; one hand holding the white flag, was now in the centre of the road, facing in our direction; he beckoned us to approach. 
 As I stared at the German with the white flag, I remembered (as no doubt the five Frenchmen lying beside me also remembered) a short time ago in Amfreville a small party of Germans had surrendered and, as the Commando patrol approached, one of the Germans had lobbed a grenade, killing and wounding several members of the patrol. 
 All the surrendering Germans in this instance had been shot dead by the Commandos. 
 I moved slightly and beckoned the German to come to us. 
 He disappeared into the hedgerow, and soon reappeared with four others, two of them were carrying a wounded Officer between them. 
 They stood in the middle of the road as we approached cautiously. 
 The German soldier was holding the white flag above his head. 
 Several shots rang out. 
 The surrendering German soldiers fell flat on their faces, including the one carrying the white flag. 
 The two soldiers carrying the wounded Officer dropped him and got  down flat, leaving the Officer bleeding and moaning loudly in the middle of the road. 
 I quickly looked round. 
 One of the French Commandos had been wounded; he was lying close to the ditch at the side of the road, obviously in pain, his face the characteristic colour of the soldier who has been hit. 
 Judging by the position he was lying in, he probably has a leg wound. 
 His eyes are wide as he gazes around in a kind of apprehension. 
 The firing has ceased as we get to our feet, the Germans stand up, their hands above their heads leaving the wounded Officer on the ground. 
 The German soldiers look afraid; I believe they think we are going to shoot them. 
 The wounded Commando on the ground, obviously in great pain, is an incentive for us to kill them. 
 I looked up at the French NCO, he steps forward and orders two Germans to pick up their Officer and the other two to pick up and carry the wounded Commando. 
 The French Commando has been wounded in the thigh, the bullet passing in one side and out the other. 
 The German Officer appears to be seriously wounded, the clothing on his back is saturated with blood; the size of the wound indicates a fairly large piece of shrapnel has entered his back close to the spine. 
 We make our way back along the road to the orchard. 
 I feel sorry for the French Commando being carried by the two German soldiers. 
 Each time firing occurs close at hand, we all get down into the ditch &mdash; this adds to the pain and discomfort of the wounded. 
 Two French Commandos take over and carry their wounded comrade the remaining part of the way; he manages a smile as they pick him up. 
 No doubt he feels safer in their presence. 
 The sunken road leading into the orchard was full of wounded, mainly German, with a few British and French Commandos being attended to by a French medic. 
 The wounded German Officer was carried up the grassy bank and placed against a tree. 
 He was still conscious and was moaning loudly, his head moving from side to side. 
 I tried to make him as comfortable as possible and with the assistance of a French Commando placed a shell dressing into the large wound in his back. 
 The German stopped moving his head from side to side and looked at me. 
 &bquo;You are English?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I was in England before the war, at Cambridge to study law.&equo; 
 The  Officer's English was perfect. 
 &bquo;We did not want the war, he continued, his voice getting weaker. 
 The sniping was increasing and I had to move away to help guard some German prisoners we had collected in the action. 
 They were sitting in a hollow in the centre of the orchard, their hands on their heads. 
 As I sat facing the prisoners with an automatic weapon across my knees, I could still see the wounded German Officer a few yards away. 
 He had started moaning again and moving his head from side to side. 
 As I stared across at him his white face seemed to fascinate me. 
 &bquo;I thought for Christ's sake why doesn't he shut up? 
 How can he possibly be still alive with that large hole in his back?&equo; 
 My thoughts were suddenly interrupted by a terrific roar. 
 The trees shook, even the ground beneath me shook, as I suddenly realised that a salvo of heavy shells was passing over at tree height, and everyone &mdash; including the prisoners &mdash; scattered in the direction of the dug-outs; the salvo hit the ground a short distance away with an almighty roar, the explosions throwing debris over a wide area. 
 I was crouched in the entrance to a large German dug-out shaped like a frying pan as a second salvo roared overhead shaking the ground violently, the explosion causing parts of trees and other heavy objects to fall onto the roof of the dug-out. 
 There were about twelve or more German prisoners, all of them staring at me from the gloom of the interior. 
 The thought passed through my mind, &bquo;Do they intend to rush me and escape?&equo; 
 I realised that they were all as shit-scared as I was and were content to stay where they were. 
 The shelling stopped and all appeared to be quiet; even the sniping had ceased. 
 From my position at the entrance to the dug-out I could see the wounded in the sunken road in the same positions they were in before the shelling started. 
 The German Officer was now obviously dead. 
 There was blood pouring down his face from a head wound, he had slipped from his sitting position and was now lying on his side, his knees drawn up. 
 A French medic was climbing the grassy bank from the sunken road to look at the Officer as I got the prisoners out of the dug-out and back to their previous positions in the hollow. 
 I was not surprised to learn that the shelling of our positions was not the German guns but the British guns (the bastards).  
 I assisted the Frenchman who was tending the wounded before they were carried away. 
 There seemed to be a shortage of shell dressings. 
 The Frenchman handed me an aluminium tin, similar to the one my mother used when she was baking scones and shaking flour onto her baking board. 
 I cut the clothing away from the wound and shook a quantity of powder from the tin on to the wound, then on to the next one. 
 We moved from the orchard taking the prisoners with us and leaving the wounded to be taken to the rear. 
 The fighting in our immediate area seemed to have quietened down as we handed over the prisoners to join, I would think, about a couple of hundred, all gathered together in a field close to the orchard. 
 As a few of us stand and look at the Germans, Mills Roberts appears with a few of his Officers. 
 &bquo;Stand back from those bloody prisoners,&equo; he roars and points to a little group of French Commandos. 
 We move away from the Germans as the Brigadier is now pointing at some other unfortunate bastards. 
 About half a mile away an attack is going in on a hill, I can see Commandos advancing up the slopes, shells burst a short distance in front of the forward troops, probably covering fire from the British Artillery. 
 We are on the move again, advancing along the winding country road with high hedges on either side. 
 We meet up with other units of the Brigade and leave the road to continue the advance through the trees in the direction of small arms and automatic fire ahead. 
 The action has lasted most of the day and it is now early evening but still light as we have a short sharp skirmish with the enemy rearguard. 
 We enter the area that they had been defending and everything shows that the Germans have pulled out in a hurry. 
 The now deserted slit trenches still have equipment and items of clothing, and tins of food similar to our corned beef. 
 On opening one of these small tins and tasting its contents, I am pleased that we can still rely on good old Machonachie's stew, at least its edible. 
 The German soldiers' equivalent is just a mass of fat. 
 No wonder they are retreating. 
 It is now getting dark as we settle for the night in the German slit trenches and I share a trench with three  French Commandos. 
 Before we can settle down, the enemy launch a heavy mortar attack on their former positions, now occupied by the French, using the now familiar multibarrelled mortar, &bquo;Moaning Minnie'&equo;, or Nebelwerfer . 
 This weapon has a terrific killing power as well as being very effective against the morale of the troops in the vicinity of the explosions. 
 The three Frenchmen have just settled into the trench as I contemplated the hordes of mosquitoes that were now descending on the area. 
 As I squatted on the grass at the entrance to the trench, the stillness of the evening was shattered by the most awesome sound. 
 Several violent explosions close by, followed by clouds of black smoke rising in columns above the trees, shrapnel hissing along the ground and through the trees as I dived head-first into the trench to join the three Frenchmen. 
 The bombs of the Nebelwerfer  are fitted with a device that causes a moaning sound as the bomb descends, similar to the sound created by a German dive bomber. 
 The mortaring lasted about twenty minutes. 
 The Commandos in the trench with me did not seem to be put out by the noise and the explosions caused by the Moaning Minnies; no doubt they had heard it all before. 
 Darkness has descended and the mosquitoes have taken over from the enemy mortars. 
 In the darkness the three Frenchmen are sleeping soundly, oblivious to the sound and the attacks of the clouds of mosquitoes. 
 I pull my battledress jacket over my head in a forlorn attempt to escape from the tiny tormentors; sleep is impossible. 
 At first light the Commandos are on the move again in an attempt to keep up with the retreating enemy. 
 We march all day, stopping from time to time at the sound of automatic fire somewhere just ahead. 
 As I lie in a ditch during the short rest and watch Jake the Algerian move along the road just ahead of me exclaiming &bquo;A la attack&equo;, a voice from somewhere along the road shouts, &bquo;Oh, piss off&equo;. 
 The voice probably comes from one of the two English radio operators attached to the French Commando. 
 The French Officer gets us all out of the ditch and the march continues for about four or five hours, then, during a rest in the wood, I fall asleep, my face among the leaves reminding me of my home in Scotland. 
 It's dark, the  Commandos are forming up and preparing to move off. 
 I join the column as it leaves the wooded area and the Commandos continue the advance in file on both sides of a narrow road. 
 It's good to feel the tarmac underfoot; we are moving fairly fast, it's a lovely night and I feel great. 
 Up ahead there is the sound of automatic fire, but it does not seem to effect us. 
 I have a mouthful of cider from my waterbottle and eat the remains of a chicken, or is it a piece of lamb? 
 Whatever it is, it tastes good. 
 I have a feeling we must be just a few miles from the River Seine. 
 The German Army by this time must be across the Seine. 
 The opposition in front of us is getting less and less as we advance. 
 It is now daylight and another new day, as we continue to trudge along the road; there is no conversation, it's just heads down and continue to look at the boots of the man in front. 
 The sun is up and everything is peaceful. 
 We turn a bend in the road and there in front of us is an entrance to a town. 
 The group of houses are now just a few yards away and at the sight of the French civilians lining the route, all tiredness is now forgotten and a spring has appeared in our step. 
 &bquo;'Ow about a tune on your bagpipes?&equo; remarks the Commando in front of me. 
 I drop out to the side of the road and pull off my rucksack containing the bagpipes. 
 A few seconds later the pipes are assembled and I enter the town playing Highland Laddie , not at the front of the column, but bringing up the rear. 
 I don't think Lovat would have approved. 
 He would probably have halted the advance and ordered me up the front. 
 It appears that the whole town has turned out to welcome us; men, women and children are lining the main route through the town, shaking hands with the French Commandos and offering glasses of wine as they walk alongside the column. 
 I stop playing the pipes before we leave the town as I appear to be missing out as far as the wine is concerned! 
 About three miles beyond the town we turn into a leafy lane leading to a farm. 
 An Officer is standing at the entrance and directing the units to certain parts of the farm; he has a strong Scottish accent. 
 As we approach he points  to his left and with some aggression in his voice. 
 &bquo;Right, you bloody lot, in there&equo;. 
 In there happened to be a very comfortable-looking barn. 
 The Officer's face had a puzzled expression as he recognised Lochiel's Tartan on my green beret and on my shoulder flashes. 
 On looking around he was staring at us, no doubt wondering what I was doing marching along with the French Commandos. 
 Last time we met was at the Training Centre at Achnacarry. 
 The war was now a long distance away; everything was quiet, except for a very faint rumble of artillery in the distance, in the direction of the River Seine. 
 It's another day, I have slept for more than ten hours and am now famished as I follow the smell of cooking to a spot behind the barn. 
 The French Commandos are tucking into a meal. 
 &bquo;Help yourself, Piper,&equo; shouts a Frenchman who was busy placing a heap of straw under a pig hanging by its hind legs from the branch of a tree. 
 I fill a mess-tin with meat, potatoes, and various vegetables, and for the first time in many months, I pour a very delicious gravy over the lot. 
 As I eat I cannot help but notice the Frenchman attending to the pig; he has now cut the animal's throat and has set alight to the straw, the flames and smoke engulfing the unfortunate pig. 
 Between mouthfuls of food I enquire from the Commando sitting beside me on the grass &bquo;What is he up to with that pig?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, Beel, he is a very good chef and he is now preparing the menu for tomorrow; you like the food?&equo; 
 &bquo;I like the food,&equo; I agreed. 
 In no way could I possibly say otherwise, and I looked forward to tomorrow's pig. 
 I must try to keep away from the area of preparation. 
 At the moment I am too hungry to feel sorry for the pig. 
 The Brigadier has an appointment for dinner in a restaurant in the town that we passed through yesterday. 
 He requests that I accompany him and pipe him into the restaurant. 
 I report to H.Q at the appointed time. 
 &bquo;How are the pipes, Piper? 
 I hear that you piped the French through the town yesterday. 
 Very good,&equo; he snapped. 
 &bquo;Now, what are you going to play today?&equo; 
 &bquo;Whatever you like, sir,&equo; I replied, knowing very well that he always requested something Irish. 
 He certainly made a  great entrance: I played a slow air, a favourite of mine, Cuaist Nam Fir-Cun Og  (The Flight of the Eaglets). 
 Very good Piper,&equo; responded the Brigadier, &bquo;but let's have something a little more lively next time round.&equo; 
 The Brigade Major informed me that the Brigadier's party would be in the restaurant for at least one-and-a-half hours, which gives me time to look around the town. 
 Outside on the street a crowd had gathered, no doubt attracted by the sound of bagpipes. 
 As I emerged and joined up with two French Commandos, there was a short round of applause. 
 The civilians appeared to be very interested in the kilt that I am wearing and, of course, the pipes seem to fascinate them. 
 As we walked around the town I witnessed several incidents as girls who had been known to have collaborated with the German forces were seized by members of the Resistance and had their hair chopped off, to the jeers and cat-calls of those standing around. 
 The two French Commandos accompanying me steered me away from these scenes. 
 &bquo;It is best that we do not interfere, Piper, remarked one of the Commandos. 
 &bquo;The Resistance knows best how to deal with known collaborators.&equo; 
 I arrived back in time to pipe out the Brigadier, and judging by his jovial manner he must have enjoyed his meal. 
 We all stepped out to a lively tune, Mrs MacDonald of Dunach . 
 Last time I played this Strathspey was at a ceilidh  held in the village hall at Spean Bridge, attended by villagers and staff from the training centre at Achnacarry. 
 The Brigadier beamed and the Brigade Major returned the salutes of the local dignitaries who had gathered on the pavement just outside the restaurant. 
 I continued playing as the Brigadier sped away in his jeep, to the cheers of the fairly large crowd. 
 Our time at the farm passes very quickly; the days are sunny and the warm evenings are free of mosquitoes. 
 We eat well and sleep in the very comfortable barn; the war has gone on &mdash; over the horizon. 
 Twenty-fifth August &mdash; a lot of excitement around the farm. 
 The French Commandos are climbing aboard a couple of jeeps in the farmyard. 
 They are on the bonnets of the jeeps, some are clinging precariously onto the sides as  both vehicles speed away through the farmyard and out into the road. 
 It appears that Paris has been liberated and the French Commandos want to be there to join in the celebrations with the citizens of Paris. 
 I doubled across the cobbled yard and stood in the middle of the road to watch the jeeps disappear in the distance in a cloud of dust. 
 Twenty-ninth August &mdash; the German Army has managed to get itself across the Seine and, according to the news at the Brigade H.Q, 4th Commando Brigade has joined in the pursuit. 
 It appears that the enemy has suffered a major defeat in Normandy with a large amount of casualties and loss of heavy equipment. 
 All this exciting news is soon forgotten by the announcement of a dance to be held in the local town hall in honour of the Commandos. 
 The farmer's wife has kindly pressed my kilt and I set off into town with a small group of Commandos, all of us determined to enjoy ourselves, and, of course, to sort out the local French girls. 
 It seems very strange as I enter the town hall. 
 The dance band is playing, sounds like a military tune, certainly not like the local dances back home. 
 The dancers are jumping up and down, no comparison to our foxtrots or waltzes. 
 Everyone seems to be enjoying themselves. 
 I stop staring at the dancers as a French girl approaches. 
 She smiles, &bquo;You dance with me, Scottish?&equo; 
 Before waiting for an answer she takes me by the hand and leads me on to the dance floor. 
 We join all the other dancers jumping up and down, round and round the dance floor, stopping momentarily as I place my rifle in a corner near the band, then on again keeping time to the music. 
 As the girl dances close to me I can smell her perfume and all that has gone before is completely forgotten; the slit trenches, the mosquitoes, the wounded and my dead comrades. 
 As we dance I find myself staring at the French girl &mdash; she has a very pretty face with long, dark hair on to her shoulders, slim build and about 5&ft; 2&ins; in height. 
 I stop staring at her as she repeats several times, &bquo;You are Scottish? 
 You are Scottish?&equo; and each time she touches my kilt with her hand, throwing her head back and laughing as we spin around the dance floor. 
 The evening came to an end after about three hours' dancing, the final speeches being made by the local  dignitaries, this being followed by a round of applause for the French people, led by a British Officer. 
 As I look around at the happy faces it is difficult to realise that the German Army is only a few miles away across the River Seine where they are defending Le Havre. 
 Just a short time ago the German soldiers were retreating through this town, hotly pursued by 1st Commando Brigade. 
 It is midnight and after great difficulty I managed with my little bit of French to convey to my dancing partner of the evening that I would like to see her home. 
 She has a quick word with two of her female friends and returned to me with the words, &bquo;Right, Scottish, we go.&equo; 
 She slipped her arm through mine, I picked up my rifle from the corner near to the band, who were now packing up their instruments. 
 We stepped outside the hall into the dark cool, evening. 
 All the lights in the town were out as we made our way through the almost empty streets. 
 Half-anhour later we turned into a gateway leading to a small cottage. 
 The front door was open, as we approached, a light came on, probably from an oil lamp. 
 I could now smell the very strong aroma of frying onions as we entered the cottage. 
 The scene before me reminded me of the very similar scenes in the Highland crofts, the only difference being the now almost overpowering smell of onions. 
 In the dim light of the oil lamp hanging from a chain attached to a very black beam above the fireplace, and the glow from the log fire. 
 I could see that the room was very sparsely furnished. 
 The elderly couple sitting in chairs on either side of the fireplace rose to their feet as we entered. 
 The man moved towards us, a look of surprise on his face. 
 The woman stirred the onions around a bit with a long black fork and then settled the large frying pan more firmly on top of the blazing logs. 
 She then stood and stared at me, her eyes opening wide with disbelief. 
 &bquo;Mama, Papa, this is Scottish! 
 Scottish, this is Mama and Papa!&equo; 
 Her father produced a bottle of Calvados and four glasses. 
 The Calvados I quickly, but politely, declined and accepted a large glass of cider. 
 I joined the family for a meal of fried onions and what tasted like chicken. 
 Very enjoyable indeed, after the very rough fare that I had become used to living in the slit trench.  
 It was 4.30 a.m. when I finally said my farewell to the French family and their very charming daughter. 
 Her kiss at the cottage gate left my mind occupied during the long walk back to the farm. 
 &bquo;Just as well that the Germans are on the other side of Seine: I can sleep late today.&equo; 
 Fourth September &mdash; news at Brigade H.Q that the Brigade would be returning to England on the 6th September to reorganise and prepare to be sent to the Far East and continue the war against the Japanese. 
 The 4th and 5th of September were spent saying goodbye to our French friends. 
 As the Brigade assembled in a field near the farm buildings awaiting transport, many civilians from the nearby town gathered to see us off. 
 My dancing partner and her parents turned up, a little bit embarrassing for me as my French was very limited as far as conversation was concerned. 
 One of the French Commandos seeing my predicament involved the parents in conversation, while I found no difficulty in communicating with Francoise, their daughter. 
 We climbed aboard the transport and as we moved away in convoy I gazed at Francoise from the back of the truck. 
 She was waving to us, her face very serious; we turned into the road and she was gone from view. 
 I must have appeared sad. 
 I certainly felt sad, as I pictured the French girl standing in the middle of the field waving goodbye. 
 &bquo;It's all right, Piper, there are plenty of pretty girls in France. 
 It is possible that one day you will come back to Normandy.&equo; 
 I looked around to my right, Chauvet, one of my friends of French Commando, was leaning against the side of the truck, a large smile on his face. 
 &bquo;Yes, Piper, one day you will return here!&equo; 
 Darkness had fallen when we reached the beaches, having travelled over ground in places very familiar. 
 Large areas of the beach contained hundreds of German prisoners behind makeshift barbed wire compounds, waiting to go aboard the tank-landing craft, their destination prisoner-of-war camps in England. 
 They all looked completely dejected as they stared blankly through the wire as our convoy trucks approached. 
 Some of the Commandos could not resist the temptation and burst into the Horst Wessel  song, rounding it all off with three hearty cheers, much to the amazement of  the German prisoners. 
 I was beginning to become impatient as we lay about on the sand for several hours waiting our turn to go aboard one of the tank-landing craft, after it had discharged its cargo. 
 The Brigade has been in Normandy since the 6th June in constant contact with the enemy until we reached the Seine. 
 It is now the 6th September and my visits round the Commando units 3, 4, 6 and 45 Royal Commando, not forgetting French Commando, have made it clear to me the large number of casualties in this campaign. 
 Many of the Officers and other ranks who landed on D-Day have been replaced by faces I have never seen before. 
 At last we are going aboard a tank-landing craft: I slip off my rucksack, assemble the bagpipes, a couple of minutes to tune up, then on with the rucksack and we march on to the craft to the tune Highland Laddie . 
 Later, I gaze from the stern of the landing craft at the coast of Normandy, as it slowly slips from view, leaving me with the memory of those of the Brigade lying in shallow graves in the orchards and ditches of this part of France. 
 As the tank-landing craft heads out into the English Channel I play a slow Highland air, Loch Monar , a tune I have played many times at Achnacarry, and possibly recognised by many of those Commandos who had passed through the Training Centre. 
 After a good meal, served by the Royal Navy, then a few hours' sleep, I joined the others on deck as the South Coast of England came into view through the clearing mist. 
 What a sight! 
 The whole Brigade seemed to be on deck admiring the coastline in front of us. 
 &bquo;Piper,&equo; I turned round. 
 It was the Sergeant Major. 
 He roared once again, &bquo;Piper, over here at the double.&equo; 
 I doubled to the other side of the deck and joined the Sergeant Major and Brigadier Mills Roberts. 
 After giving the Brigadier a smart salute, he addresses me in his usual gruff manner, &bquo;Piper, I want you to play your bagpipes as we disembark&equo;. 
 &bquo;Certainly, sir,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;Do you wish a special tune?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, Piper, I would like a special tune played as we go ashore.&equo; 
 He looked at me, and in a rather quiet voice, which was most unusual for him, be enquired, &bquo;Do you know the  March Past of the Irish Guards?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sir,&equo; I replied. 
 &bquo;Right Piper that is what I want you to play as the Brigade is going ashore.&equo; 
 He paused for a moment, &bquo;Not as exciting as the landing on the morning of 6th June?&equo; 
 Before I could answer, he barked, &bquo;Right, fall out.&equo; 
 I saluted smartly and then doubled across the deck to join the others as the landing craft was preparing to tie up. 
 I felt a strange sensation in my stomach as I made my way down the sloping gangway and on to the tarmac, If I had felt like this on the morning of the 6th June, Lord Lovat would probably been going ashore without his bagpipe music. 
 Brigadier Mills Roberts and his Officers and the men of the 1st Commando Brigade disembarked to the March Past of the Irish Guards, followed by the March Past of the Scots Guards, Highland Laddie , the bagpipe tune I played going ashore at La Breche with Lord Lovat. 
 As I marched up and down the quay, the pipes sounded well. 
 The civilians and dockworkers were staring at me, the Commandos coming ashore don't seem to notice my piping. 
 They probably have other things on their minds. 
 It's exciting being back in England. 
 The people look different from any other people. 
 I shall miss the kind and generous people of Normandy, the farmer Saulnier, the Monsieur and Madame of the Caf&eacute; at Benouville bridge, and all the other French civilians, not forgetting my dancing partner and her very hospitable parents. 
 It may be possible that I shall meet them all again one day. 
 Much as I admire the French, nothing can compare with being back home in good old Blighty. 
 At this staging camp I picked up some mail. 
 My parents have moved to near Glasgow; there is plenty of work and my father and mother are happy in the big city. 
 Most of the time since we arrived back in England my mind has been full of thoughts about Fiona. 
 Her letters, three of them, contain no mention as to her health, or how she is feeling. 
 Just the usual talk about the weather and her occasional shopping trip to Fort William. 
 No doubt she has heard about Lovat being badly wounded during the early days of the fighting in Normandy and remembers her words to me as I left Achnacarry to join Lovat in Sussex. 
 The first two parts of her prediction have  come true; Lovat being wounded, and my safe return to England. 
 She has also predicted her own death a week before my return to Achnacarry. 
 These thoughts occupied my mind, even at night as I tried to sleep. 
 The Sergeant came barging into the Nissen hut, bawling out, &bquo;Right, you bloody lot, if you have any homes to go to, get out of those pits and down to the orderly room, sharpish, or you won't get a bloody pass.&equo; 
 I looked at my watch. 
 The time was 6.30 a.m., the bunks on either side of the hut were now showing signs of life and the Sergeant made his noisy way towards the door at the far end of the hut, banging on each bed with his stick as he went. 
 &bquo;Why didn't someone shoot that bastard when we were in Normandy?&equo; remarked the occupant of the bunk below me. 
 &bquo;Oh, piss off,&equo; shouted someone at the other end of the hut, as a boot bounced off the door just as the Sergeant made his exit. 
 I could hear him bawling and banging his way through the Nissen hut across the way. 
 After a quick wash and shave, dressed in a freshly pressed kilt and battledress blouse, polished boots and all, I presented myself with the other Commandos at the orderly room to get my hands on that very important rail pass. 
 Twenty minutes later I was at the head of the queue. 
 The clerk behind the desk looked up at me, &bquo;For Christ's sake, Piper, surely you have a home to go to? 
 Where do you want this pass made out to?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fort William,&equo; I quickly replied, not wishing to upset him. 
 The clerk lowered his head and commenced scribbling on a piece of paper, muttering loudly to himself, or anyone else within listening distance. 
 &bquo;You bastards have been over in France for the past three months, sitting in the sunshine and screwing all those French bints.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right, Corporal,&equo; I replied as I snatched my very important pass. 
 &bquo;You don't seem to be getting your ration, judging by your nasty temper.&equo; 
 The Corporal stood and glared at me as I very swiftly made my exit through the door, pausing briefly to pick up my rucksack and bagpipe box. 
 Several hours later I was in London making my way to another railway station to catch the train going North. 
 The  London-Glasgow train was packed to capacity as I struggled aboard and managed to find a small space opposite the toilet; the corridor and compartments being jampacked with a seething mass of Service people. 
 Even the luggage racks contained their quota of sailors, soldiers, or airmen. 
 The train shunted and jolted its way north with the occasional burst of speed to break the monotony of the sudden stops and starts. 
 At 6.30 a.m. next morning the train pulled into Central Station, Glasgow. 
 After a very uncomfortable night being on the hard floor of the corridor with all the accompanying smells, the sight of the drab factory buildings and the tall grey tenements passing slowly past the carriage window was a most welcome sight. 
 Even the washing hanging from the tenement windows seemed to be fluttering a welcome as we all struggled to our feet, pushing and shoving, as we attempted to get our packs on our backs, at the same time trying to get a clear view of the platform and the hundreds of people watching the train pull in. 
 After two days at home with my parents, I was again at the railway station, this time catching the early evening train to Fort William. 
 As the train left the suburbs of Glasgow I settled into my very comfortable corner seat to enjoy the views as the hills and lochs passed slowly by, and the train chugged steadily along the West Highland Line. 
 I must have dropped off to sleep. 
 When I awoke the train had just passed Rannoch Moor. 
 As I gazed out of the window I could see several groups of red deer in the distance, and in the foreground the brown ferns with clumps of heather here and there; it was a wonderful sight. 
 The train stopped at Spean Bridge for a few moments, the platform was almost deserted. 
 My mind cast back to the winter of last November when I stood on this same platform awaiting the arrival of a new intake. 
 The snow was falling steadily and it was bitterly cold as I covered my bagpipes and rubbed my almost frozen fingers in an attempt to keep the circulation going. 
 How I managed to pipe the intake seven-and-a-half miles to the Commando Camp at Achnacarry I shall never know. 
 Maybe the wee dram given to me by one of the Sergeant instructors kept out the cold. 
 It most  certainly lightened my step and made my fingers more nimble as we marched through the thick snow. 
 The train jerked and we were off again, next stop Fort William. 
 My thoughts changed as the now familiar landscape passed by; how was my cousin Kate? 
 She had no idea that I would be in this area. 
 My thoughts kept turning to Fiona. 
 I feel my heart pounding as I think of her, and I cannot push from my mind a strong feeling that something has happened to her. 
 Fiona's letters gave no indication that anything was wrong. 
 Certainly the last letter was dated the beginning of August, that's over a month ago. 
 The train pulled into Fort William. 
 A strong wind was blowing across the platform in the direction of the loch, accompanied by a cold, driving rain. 
 I pulled up my coat collar and sprinted along the platform and into the shelter of the waiting room. 
 The fire was warm as I sat down to contemplate whether to stay overnight with my relatives just outside Fort William, or start walking to Achnacarry some ten miles or so away. 
 &bquo;Hello, Piper Millin. 
 I looked up, the voice belonged to the local Police Sergeant. 
 He was standing in the doorway, a big grin on his face. 
 &bquo;What brings you to Fort William dressed in Locheil's tartan? 
 I would think that you should be wearing Lovat s tartan by this time?&equo; 
 &bquo;Hello, Sergeant. 
 I am just trying to make up my mind whether to stay overnight with my cousin Katy McKay or walk to Achnacarry.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, Piper, if you cannot make up your mind, you are welcome to spend the night at the Police Station; I have two empty cells at the moment. 
 It should not be too difficult for you. 
 As you know, Piper, the staff at the Commando Camp have been accepting free board and lodgings at my Police Station for some time now, especially when they miss the last transport back to camp.&equo; 
 I looked at my watch, the time was just after 11 p.m. and I could see through the doorway the rain was still driving hard. 
 Not a night to attempt the long walk to Achnacarry. 
 &bquo;OK, Sergeant, I accept your very kind offer of hospitality,&equo; getting to my feet and following the Sergeant outside. 
 Twenty minutes later the Sergeant was showing me  my accommodation for the night: a bare cell except for a wooden bunk in one corner and two blankets. 
 &bquo;What do you think, Piper?&equo; enquired the Police Sergeant. 
 &bquo;Very good,&equo; I replied, placing my pack on the bed. 
 &bquo;Now follow me, Piper, and you can join me in a bit of supper.&equo; 
 I followed the Sergeant out to the office; we both sat at a small table, and after a very enjoyable supper of cheese rolls we played the chanters until 1 a.m., pausing from time to time to drink a mug of tea. 
 The Sergeant was a very good piper and would have gone on all night. 
 I rose from the table, went into the cell and flopped down on the hard wooden bed and was asleep almost immediately. 
 The last words that I heard were, &bquo;Good night, Piper, I shall leave the door open.&equo; 
 Six-thirty a.m. next morning the Sergeant woke me with a very loud, &bquo;Good morning, Piper,&equo; and, placing a mug of cocoa on the floor beside me, he went back to his office. 
 After a wash and shave, then breakfast &mdash; a roll containing a fried egg washed down with one more mug of cocoa &mdash; I wondered what had happened to his tea rations. 
 Or do policemen in the Highlands now drink cocoa at breakfast? 
 At 7.30 I am walking out through the town in the direction of Lochy bridge then across Blarmhor. 
 I think I am going to have a pleasant walk, all the rain of yesterday evening has gone and a very fresh smell hangs in the air. 
 I cross the moor to Banavie then turn right to Gairlochy along the line of the Caledonian Canal. 
 There is still snow on the top of Ben Nevis. 
 The mountain looks great at this time in the early morning, with the sun now shining on one side and casting shadows and colours across the lower slopes. 
 By 12.30 p.m. 
 I am not far from Achnacarry. 
 After a brief stop at Gairlochy, I decide to make straight for Fiona's croft. 
 I leave the road at the first sight of Loch Arkaig and go across country, keeping to the paths through the bracken. 
 One hour later I cross over the burn and see the croft on the side of the hill about two hundred yards away. 
 I quicken my step, keeping my eyes fixed ahead, hoping for a sign of life about the croft. 
 I have a strong feeling that she is not there; there is no smoke from the chimney. 
 She  always has a log fire in the hearth, summer and winter. 
 The curtains are drawn and the place looks neglected. 
 The door is locked and the windows are covered with grime; in the silence the whole place looks as if it has not been occupied for several weeks. 
 As I walk round the croft I can feel a strange sensation in my stomach, a feeling not unlike fear, and I now know that she is dead. 
 Returning to the front of the croft I batter once more on the door, knowing full well that I shall never see her again. 
 After all, she said so herself almost five months ago, as she stood in the doorway and bade me goodbye. 
 &bquo;I will not be here when you return from the invasion of France. 
 Goodbye, Millin Tha gradh ogam ort  (I love you). 
 I picked up my pack, slung it over my shoulder and crossed the little bridge over the burn. 
 There was no looking back; I wanted to remember Fiona as she was the last time we met, standing in the doorway of the croft, her black hair blowing in the breeze as she waved me goodbye. 
 Later that day I was the guest of Locheil's gamekeeper, Donald Cameron, who informed me that Fiona had died three days after her admission to hospital in Inverness, ten days ago. 
 As long as warm blood flows in my body and I am fit to remember, my experience of Fiona will never be lost. 
 In the words of Scotland's poet, Robert Burns: 
 Had we never loved sae kindly 
 Had we never loved sae blindly 
 Never met or never parted 
 We had ne'er been broken-hearted. 
 As for the Normandy campaign, I wouldn't have missed it for the world. 
 I was proud and delighted when Shimi Lovat invited me to join him as piper, and later, on the morning of 6th June, to pipe his 1st Commando Brigade through the surf and on to the Normandy beaches, where so many men were killed or seriously wounded. 
 It is sad about Lovat being so badly wounded during the fighting. 
 At times I feel a wee bit guilty having returned home to Scotland all in one piece, when so many of my friends have died or were badly injured. 
 Piper Bill Millin 
 Public Reactions to the Media 
 Media analysts have generally concluded that British newspapers were highly partisan while British broadcasting was not. 
 We have argued that even broadcasting was biased towards the right wing and, separately, towards the government of the day. 
 But how did the public react? 
 If the bias we have detected in broadcasting was not obvious to media specialists we can hardly expect that it would have been obvious to the general public. 
 Even the much greater bias in the press may have seemed less obvious to them. 
 After all, they choose to buy their own newspapers and may be bound, psychologically, to defend their own chosen paper even if they accept that other people's papers are biased. 
 PUBLIC PERCEPTIONS OF MEDIA BIAS 
 In fact, our panel survey shows that public perceptions of media bias mirror expert opinion remarkably closely. 
 About a quarter thought the BBC was biased in its treatment of the Conservative government; rather less felt it was biased in its treatment of other parties. 
 Only one elector in seven thought ITV was biased in its treatment of the Conservatives and, again, rather less felt it was biased in its treatment of other parties. 
 In terms of the total percentage who alleged bias on television, those who actually watched BBC or ITV news were slightly more inclined to allege bias (Table 6.1). 
 (For corroborative figures see McGregor, Svennevig, and Ledger, 1989; Gunter, Svennevig, and Wober, 1986, p.82.) 
 Many of these perceptions of bias cancelled out however. 
 Some people alleged a bias towards the Conservatives, while others alleged a bias against  the Conservatives, for example. 
 On balance, the public felt that bias on both channels favoured the Conservative party and the Conservative party alone. 
 perceptions of net bias on ITV were very small indeed, the numbers who  detected an anti-Conservative bias almost (but not quite) equalling those who saw a pro-Conservative bias. 
 Opinion was also divided about BBC bias but rather more people detected a pro-Conservative, anti-Labour bias on the BBC than on ITV. 
 Both BBC viewers and those who did not watch the BBC were agreed on balance that it was biased towards the Conservatives though those who actually watched it were more evenly divided on the direction of BBC bias than those who did not (Table 6.1 again). 
 (For corroborative figures see IBA, 1987, p. 17.)   
 In sharp contrast, three quarters of all newspaper readers said that the papers they had read on the day of the interview were biased in their coverage of the Conservative and Labour parties, though less than half said their papers gave biased coverage of the Alliance. 
 (For earlier findings on public perceptions of press bias see Kellner and Worcester, 1982; Butler and Stokes, 1969.) 
 The direction of bias varied from paper to paper. 
 Roughly four-fifths of Sun, Express, Mail , and Telegraph  readers said their paper was biased towards the Conservatives, while a similar number of Mirror  readers said their paper was biased against the Conservatives. 
 Somewhat fewer readers of the Star  and the Guardian saw a Conservative versus Labour bias in their papers though, on balance, they thought the Star  was pro-Conservative and the Guardian  anti-Conservative. 
 A substantial minority of all paper readers, 42 per cent, thought their paper was biased in its treatment of the Alliance; and most of those who did detect bias thought their paper was biased against the Alliance. 
 Guardian  readers were exceptional, however. 
 Over half the Guardian's  readers thought the paper was biased towards the Alliance, while a mere 5 per cent thought it was biased against (Table 6.2).    
 WHO ALLEGED MEDIA BIAS? 
 Overall, readers of highbrow papers were less likely to allege bias in their own paper than readers of middlebrow or lowbrow papers but the differences were surprisingly small. 
 In the first fortnight of the campaign readers of highbrow and lowbrow papers detected the same amount of bias in coverage of the Conservatives and the Alliance, though highbrow readers found less bias in coverage of Labour. 
 As the campaign drew to a close, however, readers of lowbrow papers detected significantly more bias. 
 Readers of right-wing papers were well aware of their papers' pro-Conservative and anti-Labour bias though less unanimous about their papers' anti-Alliance bias. 
 Conversely those who read left-wing papers were largely agreed that they were anti-Conservative and pro-Labour but more divided on whether they had an anti-Alliance bias. 
 perceptions of both total and net bias increased during the campaign. 
 Readers of right-wing papers became more aware of their pro-Conservative, anti-Labour bias while readers of left-wing papers became more aware of their anti-Conservative, pro-Labour bias (Table 6.3). 
 Age, education, ideology, even strength of partisanship, had little influence over whether or not people perceived bias on television or in their papers. 
 Detection of bias was also unrelated to motivations for following the campaign or interest in politics during the campaign. 
 However, those who had expressed a general interest in politics during the parliamentary mid-term were more likely to see bias on the television and in their papers early in the campaign. 
 Towards the end of the campaign perceptions of bias became more widespread (Table 6.4). 
 Partisanship and allegations of bias  
 The direction of alleged bias was related in a complex way to the critics' own partisanship. 
 people tended to see television as biased against their own party while they thought their paper was biased towards their own party. 
 They asserted, rather than denied, the bias in their own preferred papers. 
 No doubt they chose their paper partly with that bias in mind. 
 The correlation between being Conservative and alleging anti-    
 Conservative bias on the BBC rose from 24 per cent in the first fortnight of the campaign to 32 per cent in the second. 
 There were almost identical correlations (and trends in correlations) between being Labour and alleging anti-Labour bias on the BBC. 
 And the same general pattern applied, in a much weaker form, to allegations about ITV. 
 By contrast, the correlation between being Conservative and alleging pro  -Conservative bias in the respondent's own paper rose from 28 per cent in the first fortnight of the campaign to 39 per cent in the second.   
 The correlation between allegations of bias and newspapers' actual partisanship (as defined in the footnote to Table 6.5) was twice as strong, however. 
 perceptions of newspaper bias depended more on the partisanship of the paper being read than on the partisanship of the reader who read it. 
 (Table 6.5). 
 By a majority of 51 per cent at the start of the campaign, rising to 58 per cent at the end, Conservative partisans claimed that their paper was biased towards the Conservative party. 
 A smaller majority of Labour partisans asserted that their papers had a pro-Labour bias (22 per cent rising to 32 per cent). 
 Alliance partisans admitted that they read anti-Alliance papers but they claimed their papers were less pro-Conservative than Conservative partisans' papers and less pro-Labour than Labour partisans' papers (Table 6.6). 
 In complete contrast Conservative and Labour partisans claimed that television news, particularly BBC news, was biased against their party. 
 By the end of the campaign a majority of 12 per cent amongst Conservatives claimed the BBC was anti-Conservative and even more claimed it was pro-Labour. 
 At the same time a majority of 23 per cent of Labour partisans claimed the BBC was pro-Conservative and anti-Labour. 
 Labour partisans also claimed the BBC was anti-Alliance (Table 6.7). 
 We have to be careful to compare like with like when comparing different elements of the media. 
 Conservative and Labour partisans who disagreed so strongly about bias on the BBC were all viewing the same source. 
 But Conservative and Labour partisans who disagreed about the bias in their daily papers were reading different papers.   
 It is difficult to compare the perceptions of Labour and Conservative identifiers who read the same paper since the numbers in our sample who read any one paper were low and tended to be drawn predominantly from one party or another. 
 A breakdown is possible only for large-circulation papers like the Sun  and the Mirror . 
 Amongst Mirror  readers, there was no difference between Labour and Conservative identifiers in their perception of the Mirror's  anti-Conservative bias, though Conservative Mirror  readers were somewhat less likely to detect a pro-Labour bias. 
 Amongst Sun  readers, there was little difference between Labour and Conservative identifiers in their perceptions of its anti-Labour, pro-Conservative bias. 
 Both Labour and Conservative   Sun  readers increasingly alleged pro-Conservative bias in the Sun  as the campaign drew to a close. 
 Another approach is to group together the readers of various right-wing papers and contrast them with readers of left-wing papers. 
 We can look at the relationship between perceptions of paper bias and the electors' own partisanship amongst &bquo;readers of right-wing papers&equo;, though it has to be remembered that different Voters are Evaluating different individual papers. 
 Despite that problem, the results clearly confirm our conclusion that paper readers did not react against the partisanship of their papers, they gloried in it. 
 Conservatives who read right-wing papers saw more  pro-Conservative bias in these papers than Labour identifiers who read the same set of right-wing papers. 
 Labour identifiers who read left-wing papers saw more pro-Labour bias in these papers than Conservatives who read the same set of papers (Table 6.8). 
 In partisan terms, people reacted against  television news, alleging antagonistic bias; but they reacted Very differently towards the press. 
 Ultimately, of course, those who find press bias offensive can change their newspaper, but the BBC is collective property and &bquo;exit&equo; is an inappropriate response.  
 PUBLIC PERCEPTIONS OF MEDIA USEFULNESS 
 In the week after the election we asked our panel to look back Over the whole campaign and tell us how useful they had found television, the press, and other sources for: (1) helping decide what party leaders and personalities were really like; (2) keeping them informed about the issues; and (3) helping them decide    how to vote. 
 We asked respondents to assess the usefulness of each source for each purpose by giving it a &bquo;mark out of ten&equo;. 
 Across nine sources and three purposes the Average mark awarded was 5.1, almost exactly half marks. 
 &bquo;Television generally&equo; scored best with an average of 6.0, closely followed by BBC-TV news at 5.7 and ITV news at 5.5. 
 Newspapers were not far behind with an Average score of 5.3. party Election Broadcasts on TV and  radio scored 5.1. 
 BBC Radio news scored 5.0 and Commercial Radio news 4.4. party leaflets came bottom with 4.0 while conversations with family, friends, and acquaintances scored 4.8, which was better than party leaflets or Commercial Radio but worse than the press or television. 
 Gunter, Svennevig and Wober (1986, p. 100), in their study of the 1983 election, also found that the public rated television the most useful, followed by the press, and then by personal conversations and radio news. 
 personal conversations are not independent of media news, however, since their content often consists of a review of information and opinion originally derived from the press or television. 
 (See McLeod et al ., 
 1979, for some empirical evidence on the content of personal conversations.) 
 Taking the nine sources together, they scored best on informing electors about the issues (5.7), slightly less well on informing them about personalities (5.4), and Very much worse on helping them decide how to Vote (4.1). 
 Every one of the nine sources was rated best for information on the issues and worst for helping people decide how to vote.   
 Moreover, the spread of scores was greatest on issue-information and least on vote-guidance. 
 Comparing television with the press, for example, the public rated television a full 1.0 marks better than the press for providing issue-information, and 0.7 marks better on providing leader-information, but only 0.3 marks better for helping viewers and readers decide how to vote (Table 6.9). 
 In Chapter 4 we recalled the well-established view that the British electorate came to rely more on television than the press from the late 1950s or early 1960s onwards. 
 Our present findings qualify that conclusion. 
 They suggest that in 1987 British electors relied much more heavily on television than the press for information, but only a little more for vote-guidance. 
 There is some corroboration for our conclusion in previous research, however: at the 1983 election Gunter, Svennevig and Wober (1986, p. 119) found that &bquo;whilst television clearly emerged from among various sources of information about politics as the major source, it seemed to be   relatively less important in the decision-making process of which way to vote&equo;. 
 It may be a surprise to find that television enjoyed its greatest competitive advantage on issue-information. 
 Surely television is the medium for getting to know personalities, but the press is the medium for a detailed understanding of the issues? 
 Surely the detailed issue coverage in the Guardian  and The Times  must be superior to the necessarily brief and superficial coverage of issues on television? perhaps that is so; but Very few British newspaper readers read papers like the Guardian  and The Times ; most read tabloids such as the Sun , the Star , the Mirror , the Express , or the Mail . 
 Against that competition it is not altogether surprising that British newspaper readers found better issue coverage on British television. 
 Our image of the typical newspaper reader in Britain has to be that of someone reading a tabloid, not a highbrow quality paper. 
 WHO FOUND THE MEDIA USEFUL? 
 Some people found the media more useful than others. 
 We used multiple regressions to gauge the influence upon media usefulness-ratings of: political interest and discussion, different motivations for following the campaign, social and political background factors, perceptions of bias, and the intellectual weight of the press. 
 ln addition we used voters' degree of preference for their first-choice party (over their second choice) as yet another potential influence upon their ratings of the media's usefulness. 
 The main influences on usefulness-ratings were people's interest in politics and their motivations for following the campaign. 
 Their degree of preference for one party Over others had an important influence upon the usefulness-ratings they gave the media for helping them decide how to Vote (those with clear preferences found the media less useful for that purpose) but had little or no influence on other aspects of usefulness-ratings. 
 Surprisingly, perceptions of bias never had a significant impact on usefulness-ratings. 
 The factors influencing ratings given to television for providing information on personalities and issues were almost identical to each other. 
 for both purposes, television scored significantly  higher amongst those who found politics interesting at the end of the campaign, amongst information-seekers, and amongst those who read lowbrow tabloids. 
 With minor variations the same factors influenced their ratings of both BBC and ITV. 
 But the factors influencing ratings given to television for helping people decide how to Vote were different. 
 Once again, motivations were a key factor but it was vote-guidance seekers, not information seekers, who now rated television most highly. 
 Since that showed a degree of consistency in attitudes, it was not entirely unexpected. 
 More surprising was the relationship with political interest. 
 Television scored best on helping people decide how to Vote if they found politics interesting during the campaign but had lacked a general interest in politics in the mid-term. 
 Television therefore helped make up the minds of those who were newly interested  in politics, or unusually interested  in politics, interested in the election campaign but not very interested in politics more generally. 
 Ratings of radio news were less predictable than ratings of television but they too were influenced by recent political interest, motivations for following the campaign, and degree of party preference. 
 Once again, perceptions of bias had no influence. 
 Similar factors explain newspaper ratings also. 
 Those who found politics interesting in the campaign but had not been interested in politics a year earlier gave the press high ratings for helping them decide how to vote. 
 Vote-guidance seekers found both the press and television specially useful for making up their mind how to vote. 
 But information seekers did not rate the press, unlike television, particularly highly for providing information. 
 Conversely, reinforcement seekers found the press, unlike television, specially useful, at least for providing information about personalities. 
 The most surprising influence on press ratings is, however, the one that is not  there. 
 Multiple regression analysis suggests that readers did not find the highbrow press significantly more useful than the lowbrow press for any purpose: reading a highbrow paper had no influence in the multiple regressions for newspaper &bquo;usefulness&equo; (Table 6.10). 
 Those who read highbrow papers found their papers no more useful for helping them decide how to vote or for revealing politicians' personalities, and only a little more useful for   explaining political issues. 
 Reading the highbrow press clearly made readers somewhat disdainful towards television news and party Election Broadcasts, but not much more enthusiastic about the press. 
 Of course, different kinds of people read different papers. 
 Those who read the highbrow press would probably have found the lowbrow tabloids woefully inadequate, but those who read the tabloids would probably have found the highbrow press too complex, long-winded, repetitious, waffling, and boring to be useful. 
 Our survey shows that highbrow readers rated their papers no more useful for  them than the lowbrow papers were for their readers  (Table 6.11).   
 By comparing the usefulness-ratings each respondent gave to television and the press we can see how many people found television more useful than the press, how many found the press more useful than television, and how many found them equally useful. 
 Given that usefulness was rated on an eleven-point scale   (0 to 10) we might expect that relatively few would rate television and the press exactly equal. 
 Alternatively, we might feel that people who took care to give different media sources exactly the same rating on an eleven-point scale were indicating quite strongly that they found them equally useful. 
 By a majority of 56 per cent to 22 per cent, citizens found television more useful than the press for providing issue-information (a further 22 per cent found them equally useful). 
 By a smaller majority of 48 per cent to 30 per cent, they found tele-Vision more useful than the press for providing information about party leaders (with 22 per cent, once again, rating the two sources equally useful). 
 But on helping them decide how to vote, opinion was much more evenly divided: 36 per cent preferred television, 24 per cent the press, and a remarkable 40 per cent said the two sources were equally useful (Table 6.12). 
  For providing issue-information, persistent readers of the Sun  or Star  preferred television to the press by 67 per cent to 12 per cent: a majority of 55 per cent. 
 Sun/Star  readers' preference for   television as a source of issue-information was just as great as that of people who did not read any paper regularly. 
 Next came Mirror readers, who preferred television to the press by a majority of 35 per cent, and Express/Mail  readers, who preferred television by a majority of 25 per cent. 
 Telegraph/Times  readers were more ambivalent, however, and our small sample of Guardian  readers preferred the press by a big majority. 
 On balance, people also preferred television rather than the press as a source of information about political leaders. 
 But despite its video pictorial qualities, and its much vaunted &bquo;personal&equo; contact with party leaders, television's advantage over the press in giving information about leaders was less than its advantage on issue-information. 
 Perhaps television was just too obsequious towards leaders to be revealing. 
 Overall a majority of 34 per cent preferred television for issue-information, while a majority of only 18 per cent preferred television for information about leaders. 
 Those who did not read a particular paper regularly, and those who read the Sun  or Star , showed a clear preference for television on leader-information; but readers of other papers were divided on whether the press or television was best.  
 When it came to deciding how to Vote however, the most frequent response was that television and the press were equally useful. 
 people who were not regular paper readers relied more on television, while Guardian  readers relied more on the press; but a plurality of every other paper's readers said they found press and television equally useful. 
 So amongst tabloid readers generally, but especially amongst Sun/Star  readers, there was a dramatic difference between their overwhelming preference for television as a source of information and their reliance upon both press and television for helping them decide how to vote. 
 We might have expected that people would give particularly low ratings to sources they described as biased but there was little evidence of any such reaction. 
 Most people thought their newspapers were biased and very few thought ITV news was biased. 
 Yet newspapers and PEBs scored only marginally lower than ITV news on usefulness. 
 More thought BBC-TV news was biased yet it scored marginally higher than ITV news on all three aspects of usefulness. 
 At the individual level, too, those who perceived bias on television news rated it only very slightly less useful than those who did not, while those who perceived bias in their papers rated their papers slightly more  useful than those who did not (Table 6.13). 
 perceptions of media bias never proved statistically significant in any of our multiple regressions predicting usefulness-ratings.    
 WHO FOUND ALTERNATIVES TO MASS MEDIA NEWS USEFUL? 
 Party Election Broadcasts (PEBs) at election-time and the equivalent Party Political Broadcasts (PPBs) at non-election times are one method by which broadcasting attempts to achieve balance and impartiality between the parties. 
 The parties themselves control the content. 
 In one sense they are the British equivalent of political advertising on American television &bquo;but they differ from such advertising in three very important ways: first, PFB broadcasting is free (although the parties have to bear at least some of the production costs &mdash; indeed, all of the production costs if they wish to use private production facilities); second, the number of PEB broadcasts is fixed by agreement between broadcasters and the parties to reflect (roughly) the current popular standing of the parties (in 1987 Labour, the Liberal-SDP Alliance, and the Conservatives got exactly equal time for PEBs while other parties received very much less); third, the broadcasters have insisted, against the politicians&equo; wishes, that PEBs be short programmes typically ten minutes long, rather than high-impact adverts of perhaps twenty or thirty seconds' duration. 
 While the politicians see PEBs as a device for party propaganda, the  broadcasters see PEBs as a platform for parties to inform the electorate by stating their case rather than chanting their slogans. 
 Our panel rated PEBs much lower than the press or television news for providing information on issues, but similar to the press for providing information on leaders, and close behind the press and television news for helping them decide how to vote. 
 Wober (1989a) presents evidence to suggest that electors find mid-term PPBs, especially opposition PPBs, much more useful than PEBs during the campaign. 
 During the final campaign, voters hardly need such contrived devices as PEBs to find out about the issues and personalities in party debate &bquo;but during the mid-term there is so much concentration on government actions and personalities that PPBs play a much more significant role in publicizing opposition policies and personalities. 
 At all times, electors find PPBs or PEBs very much more useful than party leaflets. 
 The most predictable usefulness ratings were those for PEBs. 
 Those with a recent interest in politics, who found the election interesting but did not have a general interest in politics at other times, gave PEBs high ratings for usefulness on leaders, issues, and voting choice. 
 The same people also found party leaflets particularly useful. 
 Lowbrow tabloid readers gave PEBs high ratings for all three purposes. 
 Reinforcement seekers gave PEBs high ratings for providing information about party leaders while vote-guidance seekers gave both PEBs and party leaflets high ratings on issues and voting choice. 
 Young voters found party leaflets more useful than older voters (Table 6.14). 
 Those who found the election campaign interesting gave personal conversations high ratings for all purposes. 
 Information seekers found personal conversations useful for gaining information about leaders and issues. 
 Vote-guidance seekers, and those who lacked strong preferences, found personal conversations useful in helping them decide how to vote. 
 people who discussed politics more during the campaign gave personal conversations a somewhat higher rating for providing information on the issues, but not for other purposes. 
 Indeed, frequency of discussion had remarkably little influence on usefulness-ratings for personal conversations, less influence than motivations, for example. 
 Clearly, quantity did not necessarily imply quality (Table 6.15).   
 CONCLUSIONS 
 Academic analysts are unanimous that the British press is highly partisan, even if it is less so than it was in the last century and even though proprietors are strongly profit-motivated. 
 It seems to have become more stridently partisan in the 1970s and 1980s than it was in the 1960s. 
 Three-quarters of all newspaper readers in our panel agreed that the papers they had read on the day of the interview were biased in their coverage of the Conservative and Labour parties, though less than half said their papers gave biased coverage of the Alliance. 
 Tabloid readers were more likely to allege bias than highbrow readers, particularly in the closing stages of the campaign, though differences between them were initially quite small. 
 On balance, newspaper readers agreed with academic analysts about the direction of bias. 
 In contrast, political scientists have usually claimed that television news is unbiased (though sociologists have been more sceptical). 
 Our content analysis of television during the election campaign seems to suggest that television was biased towards the right wing and, separately, towards the government of the day. 
 Our survey panel shows that about a quarter of the electorate thought BBC-TV news was biased in its treatment of the Conservative government, though rather less felt it was biased in its treatment of other parties. 
 Only one in seven thought ITV news was biased in its treatment of the Conservatives and, again, rather less felt it was biased in its treatment of other parties. 
 On balance, people felt the bias on both channels favoured the Conservative party and the Conservative party alone. 
 Age, education, ideology, even strength of partisanship, had little influence on perceptions of bias on television or in the press. 
 perceptions of bias were also unrelated to motivations for following the campaign or interest in politics during the campaign itself. 
 However, those who had expressed a more general interest in politics during the parliamentary mid-term were more likely to allege bias on television and in their papers during the campaign. 
 The direction of alleged bias was influenced in a complex way by the critics&equo; own partisanship. 
 People tended to see television as biased against their own party while they thought their paper was biased towards their own party. 
 No doubt they chose their  paper partly with that bias in mind while they felt that television bias was being inflicted upon them against their will. 
 The correlation between being Conservative and alleging anti  -Conservative bias on BBC-TV rose from 24 per cent in the first fortnight of the campaign to 32 per cent in the second. 
 By contrast, the correlation between voters being Conservative and alleging pro  -Conservative bias in their newspaper rose from 28 per cent in the first fortnight of the campaign to 39 per cent in the second. 
 perceptions of newspaper bias depended more, however, on the partisanship of the paper being read than on the partisanship of the reader who read it. 
 None the less, Conservatives who read right-wing papers saw more  pro-Conservative bias in these papers than Labour identifiers who read the same set of right-wing papers. 
 We might have expected that those who alleged bias on television or in their paper would be reluctant to describe that source as useful but there was little evidence of any such reaction. 
 Voters' assessments of media usefulness varied more with their political interest, and in a complex way. 
 Television, newspapers, PEBs, party leaflets, and personal conversations were all most useful in helping people decide how to vote if they found politics interesting during the campaign but had lacked a more general interest in politics in the mid-term. 
 The media helped to make up the minds of those who were newly interested  in politics, or unusually interested  in politics, interested in the election but not very interested in politics generally. 
 People rated television the most useful source of information about party leaders and political issues, and the most helpful source for making up their minds how to vote. 
 BBC-TV news scored best, followed by ITV news, newspapers, PEBs, personal conversations &bquo;and lastly radio news. 
 (For most listeners, radio news was not the high-quality, in-depth BBC Radio 4 news, but BBC Radios 1 and 2 news inserts, or Commercial Radio news.) 
 Every one of these nine sources was rated better for providing information than for helping people decide how to vote. 
 Although the public preferred television to the press for all purposes, they preferred television most of all for providing information about the issues. 
 For deciding how to vote, however, only a small plurality preferred television and 40 per cent of voters said they found television and the press equally useful. 
  Readers of the tabloid press overwhelmingly preferred television rather than the press as an information source but, like other voters, they had a relatively slight preference for television rather than the press for helping them decide how to vote. 
 Surprisingly, readers of the highbrow press found their papers scarcely any more useful than readers of the lowbrow press. 
 Reading the highbrow press made people somewhat disdainful towards television, but no more enthusiastic about the press. 
 Conversely, the reason why readers of the lowbrow press had such strong preferences for television news was not that they were particularly dissatisified with their papers but that they were particularly enthusiastic about the quality of television.  
 Media Influence on Perceptions of Politics  
 The apparently simple question &bquo;Does the media influence voters?&equo; is too general to be meaningful. 
 At the very least it prompts the response &bquo;What elements of the media? 
 What influence?&equo; 
 We need to distinguish between different media sources &bquo;and also between the media's ability to inform and its ability to persuade. 
 Different elements of the media perform different functions. 
 From what we know about their audience and their content, we would expect major differences between the influence of television and the influence of the press, and major differences also between the influence of highbrow and lowbrow sources. 
 If they have any influence at all, different media sources should influence their audiences in different ways. 
 THE EXPECTED INFLUENCE OF TELEVISION 
 Television news has three significant characteristics that affect its ability to influence the electorate. 
 First, it is pervasive. 
 Nearly everyone watches television news regularly. 
 Second, it is relatively undifferentiated. 
 Three-Quarters of the 1987 electorate said they regularly watched both BBC-TV and ITV news. 
 In addition, our analysis of television news content showed that BBC. and ITV news are very similar anyway. 
 Third, it is relatively unbiased. 
 Despite our finding that television news is biased, there is no doubt that it is less biased than the press, and that such bias as there is on television is in the same direction on both BBC and ITV. 
 Given those characteristics we should not expect BBC and ITV viewers to be influenced in different ways. 
 Whatever influence television news has on voters, it would be likely to affect all, or nearly all voters. 
 It would not affect different audiences in different ways. 
 If we seek evidence of television's influence, we  should correlate general trends in public opinion with trends in the content of television news. 
 Moreover, despite its failings, British television is still very much an information medium rather than a propaganda medium. 
 So we should expect it to have a stronger influence on public information and perceptions than on public attitudes and choices. 
 THE EXPECTED INFLUENCE OF THE PRESS 
 The press is entirely different. 
 First, it is not so pervasive. 
 Second, it is highly differentiated. 
 While most people regularly watch both BBC and ITV news, few read more than one morning newspaper. 
 Indeed there are so many newspapers in contrast to the two television networks, that relatively few voters (as a percentage) read even the best-selling paper. 
 In addition, analyses of press coverage show that their content varies enormously. 
 Third, the press is partisan, biased, and proud of it. 
 The press always has been a medium of propaganda as well as a medium of information. 
 Particular papers vary in the degree to which they emphasize propaganda rather than information, and this emphasis also varies through time. 
 In the final 1987 election campaign the press became more partisan and its emphasis on propaganda increased. 
 The tabloids in particular carried relatively little in-depth information but a lot of propaganda. 
 So we should expect readers of different papers to be influenced in different directions depending upon the content of their own particular papers. 
 We should expect the mass-selling tabloid press to have a stronger influence on public attitudes and choices than on public information and perceptions. 
 Highbrow papers might be more like television, primarily affecting their readers&equo; information and perceptions. 
 PERCEPTIONS AND ATTITUDES 
 At first it seems that we can draw a sharp distinction between perceptions and attitudes. 
 Attitudes involve preferences, choices, evaluations, approval, or disapproval, while perceptions do not. 
 Perceptions are simply a vision of political realities. 
 Whether people like or dislike what they see is a matter of attitudes, not  perceptions. 
 Perceptions need not be strictly accurate. 
 Different people may have different perceptions of politics. 
 Some may be more aware, more knowledgeable, than others. 
 Some may be misinformed because they misread their newspaper, or because their paper prints inaccurate information, or even because they do not believe what is printed in their paper. 
 Perceptions are not the same thing as knowledge, but they are what the holder of the perception believes to be knowledge. 
 Perceptions contain no element of approval or disapproval though they may trigger a reaction in terms of approval. 
 When someone notices the Chancellor's announcement of a tax cut that is a perception; when they approve or disapprove, that is an attitude. 
 Unfortunately this clear conceptual distinction between perceptions and attitudes is unrealistic. 
 In practice there is a continuum ranging from pure value-free perceptions at one end to pure choice at the other. 
 Towards the pure perception end of the spectrum is awareness of opinion polls, awareness of local constituency candidates, awareness of campaign activities by party leaders, and awareness of the parties' campaign themes. 
 At the other extreme, the pure choice end of the spectrum, are explicit statements of choice, preference, approval, or disapproval: which party people think is best on economic matters for themselves and their families, for Britain as a whole, or for the unemployed; their evaluations of how well each party has handled issues like unemployment, inflation, defence, health, education, and social services; how warm they feel towards parties and their leaders; whether the parties should change their leaders or their policies, or both; and, last but not least, voting preferences. 
 In the middle of the spectrum, however, are perceptions with more than a hint of approval or disapproval implicit in them: perceptions of each party's electoral chances; perceptions of whether national economic performance and prospects are improving or declining; and images of the parties and party leaders. 
 It is not at all obvious whether viewing party leaders as &bquo;energetic&equo; or &bquo;decisive&equo; is a perception or an attitude. 
 To a foreign correspondent covering the British election for a foreign audience, whether a party leader appears energetic or decisive is simply a matter of objective reporting: a perception. 
 To British voters, especially those who identify strongly with a political party,  &bquo;energetic&equo; or &bquo;decisive&equo; probably imply approval: for them, images are at the margin between perceptions and attitudes. 
 Media influence on perceptions is likely to depend upon whether they are at the pure perception end of the spectrum or at the margin between perceptions and attitudes. 
 Sheer information can be boosted Quickly by a media blitz, or by individuals' personal information-gathering resources &mdash; their education, their interest and involvement with politics, and their use of information-rich highbrow news sources. 
 By contrast, perceptions that verge on being attitudes are likely to be more resistant to change and more dependent upon individuals' partisan backgrounds &mdash; their pre-existing sense of party identification, and their use of partisan news sources such as right-wing (or leftwing) papers. 
 This chapter uses two techniques to investigate media influence. 
 To assess the impact of pervasive and consensual television news we can correlate trends in television news content and trends in overall public perceptions. 
 To assess the impact of more differentiated media sources we can look for differences between their different audiences: differences between readers of highbrow or lowbrow papers, for example, or between readers of right-wing and left-wing papers. 
 THE IMPACT OF A CHANGING TELEVISION CONSENSUS 
 Our analysis of television news content in Chapter 4 showed that controversy reached a peak on television in the third week of the campaign. 
 Both BBC-TV and ITV, both early and main evening news, all followed the same trend: they all screened more presentation than controversy until the third week; then they screened between two and four times as much controversy as presentation in the third week, before reverting to more presentation at the end of the campaign. 
 On television the campaign very clearly reached a climax in the third week (25&ndash;9 May). 
 But all that controversy on television failed to excite the public. 
 The frequency of political discussions rose sharply between the pre-campaign week and the final campaign, but then it continued to rise steadily throughout the campaign to peak at the very end. 
 The number of voters who found what was happening in politics &bquo;very interesting&equo; dropped sharply between our pre-campaign  week (when Thatcher was in Moscow and Kinnock newly returned from Washington) and the campaign itself. 
 During the final campaign interest sagged, if anything, though there was really very little trend. 
 So the tremendous burst of controversy in the third week of television's campaign coverage failed to stimulate either grass-roots discussion or public interest. 
 ln that respect television had no influence (Table 7.1).   
 One of the classic findings of media research in British election campaigns is Trenaman and McQuail's (1961) assertion that &bquo;the evidence strongly suggests that people think about what they are  told&hellip; but at no level do they think what  they are told&equo;. 
 This is usually called the &bquo;agenda-setting function of the media&equo;. 
 (The term &bquo;agenda-setting&equo; was popularized by McCombs and Shaw, 1972; Shaw and McCombs, 1977; though the idea had been around since at least Lazarsfeld, Berelson, and Gaudet, 1944. 
 For a producers' rather than a consumers' perspective on agendasetting see Hetherington, 1985; Blumler and Gurevitch, 1986; Blumler, Gurevitch, and Nossiter, 1986 and 1989.) 
 This agenda-setting thesis is very plausible and usually treated as an established law of social science in introductory textbooks, though much more sceptically in research reports. 
 But, as McQuail (1987, pp. 275&ndash;6) himself has recently pointed out, most of the accumulated evidence is inconclusive and the media-dominated agenda-setting hypothesis has &bquo;the status of a plausible but unproven idea&equo;. 
 Studies by McLeod, Becker, and Byrnes (1974) and Iyengar and Kinder (1987), for example, suggest that the media set the agenda for only a part of their audience: those highly reliant on a particular news source, those low in political involvement and information, and those who are relatively inattentive to the news generally &mdash; in short, those who are marginal to politics. 
 How did the trends in television's news agenda compare with trends in the electorate's agenda in 1987? 
 Chapter 4 showed that television's issue agenda was generally biased towards security issues when compared with the electorate's own agenda. 
 But perhaps television edged closer to the public, or the public edged closer to television, as the campaign progressed? 
 Unemployment came top of the list of issues that the public thought the parties &bquo;should be&equo; talking about (see Table 7.2). 
 Throughout the first two weeks of the campaign almost twothirds of our panel cited unemployment as the &bquo;main issue&equo; that should be discussed but it got little coverage on television news. 
 In the first week of the campaign over half our panel felt Labour was addressing the issue, but under one-third thought that about the Alliance and only one-fifth about the Conservative party. 
 According to our panel all three parties, including Labour, seemed to drift away from the issue as the campaign progressed. 
   So neither television nor the parties moved closer to the electorate on unemployment: they moved away from the electorate, increasingly avoiding an issue the public wanted to discuss. 
 Did the electorate follow the parties and the media? 
 Our panel gave more weight to unemployment throughout the final campaign than they had done in the Pre-Campaign wave. 
 They never wavered in describing the issue as extremely important for their voting decision: 64 per cent called it extremely important in the first week and 63 per cent in the last. 
 On the other hand, when television coverage of unemployment almost ceased in the third week, public demand for political debate on the issue also dropped slightly, from 66 per cent to 56 per cent, and it remained at this new lower level thereafter. 
 So on unemployment there is some evidence of a slight tendency for the public to follow the lead of the parties and the media but it was a very slight adjustment of public attitudes. 
 Inflation was the scourge of the mid-1970s but not the mid-1980s. 
 Throughout the campaign less than 3 per cent of voters said it was the main issue that should be discussed. 
 Very few television news items, less than 1 per cent, focused on inflation. 
 Labour and the Alliance seemed to ignore the issue. 
 At the start of the campaign people thought it was the main issue being stressed by the Conservatives, but they soon changed their minds. 
 On inflation, the Conservative Party seemed to fall into line with television, the other parties, and the public. 
 Health, education, and social services were issues that came second only to unemployment in terms of public priorities. 
 In terms of professed influence on their voting decisions, people rated them far more important even than unemployment. 
 Yet television paid relatively little attention to them. 
 Fully 77 per cent of our panel throughout the campaign rated these issues as &bquo;extremely important&equo; for their voting choice, but television news gave them less coverage than defence, though more than unemployment and inflation. 
 On these issues the parties moved towards the concerns of the electorate. 
 At the start only 14 per cent of our panel reported Labour stressing these issues, but the figure rose to 20 per cent in the fourth week and 32 per cent in the fifth as Labour sought to divert attention away from defence and to move on from unemployment, which directly affected only a small minority, to  education and especially the National Health Service, which directly affected the vast majority of the electorate. 
 According to our panel, the Alliance also switched towards a greater emphasis on health, education, and social services. 
 The number of voters who cited social issues as their top priority &bquo;or who claimed such issues were &bquo;extremely important&equo; to their voting decision, hardly varied at all throughout the campaign. 
 So on health, education, and social services there is no evidence that the public followed an agenda laid down by television or the parties. 
 Quite the opposite. 
 The enormous importance people attached to these issues seems eventually to have encouraged the parties to address them though it failed to encourage very much television coverage. 
 On social issues the public's agenda influenced the party agenda if not the television agenda. 
 During our Pre-Campaign Wave in March defence was the main issue on television, the main issue stressed by the Conservative Party, and second only to unemployment as Labour's main issue. 
 It could hardly have been otherwise when Thatcher and Kinnock were visiting Moscow and Washington to discuss Britain's defence policy. 
 None the less, even in that week only 39 per cent of the electorate rated it &bquo;extremely important&equo; and a mere 7 per cent said it was the main issue that &bquo;should be&equo; discussed by the parties. 
 In the first week of the campaign only 5 per cent of television's election news focused on defence, only 3 per cent of the electorate thought the parties were stressing the issue, and only 3 per cent wished them to do so. 
 The importance attached to every other issue rose sharply when the campaign opened but the importance attached to defence hardly changed. 
 But in the second week television coverage of defence doubled to 12 per cent, and in the third week it doubled again to 26 per cent before almost disappearing from the bulletins in the fourth and fifth weeks. 
 The number of voters who felt the Conservative Party was stressing defence as its main theme rose from 3 per cent in the first week to 39 per cent in the third and 46 per cent by the end of the campaign. 
 By the third week around 17 per cent thought Labour and the Alliance were also concentrating on defence. 
 If party rhetoric and television coverage ever set the public's agenda, they should have done so on defence. 
 The switch from  almost ignoring the issue in the first week to so much concentration in the third should have had some effect upon the public. 
 And it did. 
 But how much? 
 The number of voters citing defence as the main issue they wished to see discussed by the parties rose from 3 per cent at the start of the campaign to only 11 per cent in the third week and then stabilized at that level. 
 The number who cited defence as &bquo;extremely important&equo; for their voting decision rose from 42 per cent at the start to only 49 per cent in the third week and then it also stabilized at that level. 
 So we can Quantify the agenda-setting power of television and the parties during the campaign. 
 By their enormous concentration on defence they raised the issue by just 8 per cent in terms of public priorities and by just 7 per cent in terms of electoral significance. 
 It took an enormous amount of television coverage to produce only a small change in the public agenda (Table 7.2). 
 Towards the end of the campaign television focused more upon the two-party Labour versus Conservative battle and public expectations about Alliance performance declined. 
 Did television   marginalize the Alliance and thereby contribute to its failure? 
 Television certainly did marginalize the Alliance, but there is no evidence that the bias in television coverage influenced the expectations of the electorate. 
 Indeed the expectations of the electorate closely followed their awareness of opinion poll findings and ran ahead of the trends in television bias. 
 In the first week of the campaign only 44 per cent of the public felt Labour was a clear second in the opinion polls and as many as 19 per cent said the Alliance was running second. 
 But perceptions that the Alliance was running second in the polls collapsed in the second week; and voters' assessment of Alliance chances of winning a majority or even holding the balance of power dropped sharply in the third week; while television's sharp switch to focus on the two-Party Labour versus Conservative battle occurred in the fourth week. 
 This time sequence is conclusive. 
 Television bias was not the cause of declining expectations of Alliance success: it was a consequence of declining expectations amongst both journalists and the public at large (Table 7.3).    
 Relative coverage of Labour and Conservative was always biased towards the Conservative government but the degree of bias increased sharply (it tripled) in the fourth week of the campaign. 
 Yet public perceptions of Conservative chances of victory sank to a minimum in that fourth week and assessments of Labour chances reached a peak then. 
 (Though Conservative chances were always rated much higher than Labour's.) 
 Once again the weight of television coverage had no effect on party credibility (though the nature of the coverage may have done so). 
 Public perceptions of party unity increased between our Pre-Campaign Wave and the start of the final campaign. 
 During the pre-campaign week we recorded no items on television news which positively projected the image of party unity. 
 These rather artificial news items were very much the product of the final  election campaign. 
 In public perceptions the gap between Conservative unity and Labour unity narrowed sharply in the first few days of the campaign and again at the end, but actually increased very slightly in the third week. 
 That trend matches the trend in television projections of party unity, which were more favourable to Labour at the start and end of the campaign, but more favourable to the Conservatives in the middle, especially so in the third week. 
 This does seem to be an area in which television coverage influenced public perceptions (Table 7.4).  
 There was a precipitous decline in television's projection of the Conservative Party's overall credibility in the fourth week of the campaign, a week that included the infamous &bquo;wobbly Thursday&equo; (see Chapter 4, Table 4.16, for details). 
 But although it clearly had dramatic effects on the nerves of Conservative Central Office there is no evidence of any major shift in voting intentions at that time. 
 Adverse contextualizing comments on television news did not set an anti-Conservative bandwagon rolling in the electorate, despite the fears of Conservative strategists. 
 NON-CONSENSUAL INFLUENCES ON POLITICAL PERCEPTIONS 
 So far we have looked at the consensual influence of television: at influences that varied from time to time but affected all or most  citizens at any one time. 
 Now we turn to non-consensual influences, differentiated influences, factors that affected some individuals but not others, or that affected different individuals in different ways. 
 Such factors include their own personal characteristics, their social and political background, which newspapers they read, how much television news they watched, whether they watched television news on a particular day, and even whether they watched BBC or ITV on a particular day. 
 We can use multiple regression analysis to discover the relative influence of these factors on perceptions. 
 For consistency, we use a standard predictive scheme based upon thirty-five predictors representing the influences set out in the general model of media influence described in Chapter 1. 
 These are: 
 1. 
 Whether the individual identified with the Conservative party, Labour, or the Alliance in the Pre-Campaign Wave. 
 2. 
 Whether they claimed to be left-wing, right-wing, or neither at that time. 
 3. 
 Their age, education, and strength of partisanship at that time. 
 4. 
 Their interest in politics at four different times: the mid-term (early summer 1986), the pre-campaign week (March 1987), and the first and second fortnights of the final campaign. 
 The first of these measured generalized interest in politics, the others measured interest in politics at particular times. 
 5. 
 Their levels of political discussion in the pre-campaign week, the first fortnight, and the second fortnight of the campaign. 
 6. 
 Whether they were motivated to follow the campaign for reinforcement, vote-guidance, information, or excitement. 
 Motivations were measured in the second fortnight of the campaign, but the question wording was not time-specific (see Chapter 2). 
 7. 
 Whether they read a highbrow paper at each of four time points: the mid-term, the pre-campaign week, the first and second fortnights of the campaign. 
 8. 
 Whether they read a right-wing paper at each of these four time-points. 
 9. 
 The number of TV news programmes they watched regularly (asked in the Pre-Campaign Wave). 
 10. 
 Whether they listened to Radio 4 news regularly (asked in the Pre-Campaign Wave).  
 11. 
 Whether they watched BBC-TV news regularly (asked in the pre-Campaign Wave), and whether they had watched BBC-TV news on the day or day before the interview (in the first and second fortnight of the campaign). 
 12. 
 As (11) for ITV news. 
 Note, however, that over three-quarters of those who watched ITV news at any time had also watched BBC-TV news on the same day; and over 90 per cent of those who watched ITV news regularly also watched BBC-TV news regularly. 
 Approximately, therefore, ITV news viewers were a subset of BBC-TV news viewers, not an alternative audience. 
 Watching ITV news meant, in practice, watching more TV news. 
 It is a long list, but the SPSSX stepwise procedure seldom selected more than a few predictors as having a significant influence upon perceptions. 
 However, it is important to recall the full list, in order to emphasize the factors that did not  influence perceptions. 
 Whether people noticed the publication of opinion polls, whether they noticed local and national politicians, whether they noticed campaign themes &mdash; these seem relatively pure perceptions. 
 No doubt a few treated awareness as implied approval, but for most people that did not seem to be so. 
 Perceptions of opinion polls changed dramatically during the campaign. 
 In the pre-campaign week only 56 per cent had seen a recent opinion poll but this rose to 72 per cent in the first fortnight of the campaign and 77 per cent in the second. 
 What they saw also changed. 
 At all times, almost everyone who had seen a poll noticed that the Conservatives were top, but perceptions of which party was in second place varied sharply. 
 In the Pre-Campaign Wave a majority of those who had seen a poll thought the Alliance was second. 
 The percentage who had seen Labour in second place rose from a mere 13 per cent in the Pre-Campaign Wave to 78 per cent in the first fortnight and 95 per cent in the second. 
 Who noticed the opinion polls? 
 Awareness of opinion polls was most predictable in the Pre-Campaign Wave and became steadily less predictable as the election approached and awareness became more widespread. 
 Before the campaign opened the key influence on poll awareness was generalized interest in politics, but as the campaign drew to an end media use became   more important, especially viewing BBC-TV news (Table 7.5). 
 These findings broadly echo those of Gunter, Svennevig, and Wober (1986, pp.98&ndash;9), whose study of the 1983 election campaign showed that &bquo;objectively measured knowledge was significantly correlated with interest  in political discussion programmes both on radio and television, but with only one news-consumption  variable &mdash; claimed viewing of television news&equo; (italics added). 
 In our analysis of the 1987 campaign we have distinguished more  clearly between personal factors such as political interest and mobilizing factors such as television viewing; and we have detected a strong trend in the balance of influence between these two influences. 
 In the Pre-Campaign Wave there was a 41 per cent difference in awareness of polls between those with a high and low interest in politics. 
 Following J. S. Coleman's terminology we can say that &bquo;the effect of political interest on awareness of opinion polls was 41 per cent&equo; in the pre-Campaign Wave. 
 But this effect had declined to only 22 per cent by the last fortnight of the campaign. 
 Similarly, readers of lowbrow papers were relatively ill-informed about polls before the campaign but caught up on highbrow readers later: the effect of reading a highbrow paper declined from 33 per cent in the Pre-Campaign Wave to only 15 per cent in the closing stages of the campaign. 
 By contrast, the difference between those who did and did not watch BBC-TV widened: so the effect of television viewing rose from 12 per cent in the Pre-Campaign Wave to 20 per cent in the last fortnight of the campaign. 
 Thus, as the election approached, the basis of public awareness of opinion polls shifted from more personal factors like political interest or choice of paper, to more impersonal mobilizing factors like television news. 
 The kinds of people who were most aware of public opinion polls in the closing stages of the campaign were very different from the kinds of people who were most aware of them in the mid-term (Table 7.6). 
 At the start of the campaign, constituency candidates were almost invisible to the electorate: very few electors claimed to have heard anything about them. 
 Candidates became steadily more visible day by day throughout the campaign, however. 
 Taking the first fortnight as a whole, four-fifths of voters had heard nothing about their local Conservative, Labour, and Alliance candidates but that figure dropped to little more than half in the second fortnight. 
 So the election produced an enormous increase in at least minimal awareness of local candidates. 
 Those who were more interested in politics and used more highbrow news sources tended to acquire more information about local candidates, and party supporters acquired more information about their own party's candidate, but none of these patterns was very strong or consistent. 
 Information about local candidates was fairly haphazard.   
 We asked our panel whether they had, &bquo;in the last few days, noticed anything in particular that Mrs Thatcher has said or done&equo;; and similar questions about Kinnock, Steel, Owen, and &bquo;other&equo; (unspecified) Conservative, Labour, and Alliance leaders. 
 By those measures of visibility, national politicians were much more visible than local candidates from the start. 
 Indeed, Kinnock and Thatcher were more visible in our pre-campaign week, when both were on highly publicized foreign tours, than they   were during the campaign itself. 
 Their degree of visibility was also more predictable than the visibility of local candidates, though their visibility became less predictable as the election approached. 
 Before the campaign opened those who were particularly interested in politics were very much more aware of Thatcher's and Kinnock's recent activities. 
 By the end of the campaign that was no longer so true. 
 Awareness of Thatcher and Kinnock was spread much more evenly throughout the electorate, and in so far as it did vary it was particularly high amongst those who had recently watched television news or had recently discussed the campaign (Table 7.7). 
 In the pre-campaign week, the effect of political interest on public awareness of Thatcher and Kinnock was 36 per cent and 45 per cent, respectively; but by the last fortnight of the campaign its effect had fallen to 17 per cent and 20 per cent respectively. 
 The effect of reading a highbrow paper on public awareness of Kinnock dropped from 28 per cent to a mere 5 per cent as the election approached. 
 Meanwhile, the effect of television viewing on public awareness of Thatcher's activities rose from 12 per cent to 20 per cent (Table 7.8). 
 Such short-term &bquo;closure of the knowledge gap&equo; was noted by Blumler and McQuail (1968). 
 Robinson (1972)    found that, in America, the &bquo;knowledge gap&equo; was greater amongst those who relied on the press and smaller amongst those who relied upon television. 
 So there are precedents for both our finding that knowledge spread through the electorate as the election approached and that television played a particular role in that process. 
 Somewhat in contrast to these findings about Thatcher and Kinnock, the visibility of all &bquo;other&equo; Conservative and Labour politicians (taken in each case as a collective, unspecified &bquo;other&equo;) became more  predictable as the election approached. 
 With secondrank politicians, interest in politics continued to be a strong   predictor of their visibility, although the impact of television viewing also increased (Table 7.9). 
 Indeed, instead of declining, the effect of political interest on awareness of &bquo;other&equo; Conservative politicians actually rose from 32 per cent to 37 per cent between the Pre-Campaign Wave and the end of the campaign, and its effect on awareness of &bquo;other&equo; Labour politicians declined only from 38 per cent to 34 per cent. 
 Overall, there remained a roughly constant difference between the interested and the uninterested. 
 At the same time the effect of television viewing on public awareness of &bquo;other&equo; Conservatives rose from 11 per cent to 25 per cent while its effect on public awareness of &bquo;other&equo; Labour politicians rose from 6 per cent to 18 per cent (Table 7.10). 
 The influence of television on second-rank politicians' visibility is confirmed by a more detailed trend analysis. 
 When people said they had noticed a Labour or Conservative politician other than Thatcher or Kinnock we asked them who had caught their attention. 
 Denis Healey was noticed by 24 per cent in the pre-Campaign Wave when he accompanied Kinnock on his visit to President Reagan. 
 During the campaign itself Healey was noticed by only about 12 per cent on average but that concealed some sharp variations: 28 per cent noticed him in the last two days of the campaign, immediately after a spectacular on-screen row with TV-am  presenter Ann Diamond. 
 Throughout the campaign we asked what people thought were the main issues being stressed by each of the parties. 
 There were dramatic trends in public perceptions of, for example, the  Conservative Party's emphasis on defence. 
 We have already related those trends to the content of television news. 
 During the pre-Campaign Wave, visits by Thatcher to Moscow and Kinnock to Washington naturally led to intense television coverage of defence issues. 
 At that time both parties were clearly giving top priority to defence. 
 When the campaign opened, it was not immediately obvious which particular issues the parties would choose to stress; but by the middle of the campaign it was clear that the Conservatives were focusing on defence issues where    their policy was so much more popular than Labour's, if only because it seemed so much simpler to explain. 
 The public perceived enormous Conservative stress on defence in the Pre-Campaign Wave and again in the latter half of the campaign, but much less in the first half of the campaign. 
 None the less, despite these general trends in perceptions there were always some voters who felt the Conservatives were not stressing defence, just as there were always others who felt the Conservatives were stressing defence. 
 Those who were particularly interested in politics or discussed politics, read highbrow papers or watched television news, were a little more likely to be able to name some issues ( any  issues!) as the main themes being stressed by the parties, but the level of predictability was low. 
 When it came to selecting particular issues, it was difficult to predict who would name a particular issue. 
 Depending upon the date of the interview we could predict quite well whether people would name defence as the Conservatives' main campaign theme, but it was the date of the interview rather than the personal characteristics of the interviewee that mattered. 
 By the end of the campaign, political interest, watching BBC-TV news, and a Labour  identity made people somewhat more inclined to name defence as the Conservative Party's main theme, however; and those who had frequent discussions about politics developed a particularly clear perception of the Conservatives' focus on defence issues (Table 7.11). 
 THE INFLUENCE OF PARTISANSHIP ON PERCEPTIONS 
 Perceptions of party chances were obviously influenced by opinion poll findings. 
 Perceptions of Britain's economic performance and prospects were obviously influenced by objective economic factors and by government manipulation of economic statistics. 
 None the less there remained deep personal prejudices that affected perceptions of both. 
 Wishful thinking made political partisans more optimistic about their own party's prospects and more inclined to forecast their opponents' defeat. 
 It made government supporters more optimistic about the economy and opposition supporters more pessimistic. 
 Opinion polls are more or less inaccurate measures of voting intentions. 
 A succession of published polls typically produces a stream of more or less contradictory results. 
 In part that may reflect real changes in public opinion but to a large extent it merely reflects sampling and other administrative errors. 
 So if perceptions of party chances vary sharply with a succession of contradictory polls, it indicates that these perceptions are influenced by the published figures rather than by actual political preferences. 
 people probably realize that their own circle of acquaintances is too narrow to provide a reasonable basis for estimating party chances and so they must rely on a combination of personal contacts, media comments, and especially published opinion polls. 
 We have already noted the correlation between overall trends in perceptions of opinion polls and trends in perceptions of party prospects (see Table 7.3). 
 At any one time there were wide differences of opinion about party chances however. 
 Some of those differences were relatively unpredictable. 
 It was always fairly difficult to predict differences of opinion about Conservative and Alliance chances. 
 In the precampaign week, Conservative voters were more optimistic about Conservative chances, Labour voters about Labour chances, and Alliance voters about Alliance chances; but the partisan influence   on perceptions of Conservative and Alliance chances was much smaller than on perceptions of Labour chances. 
 As the election approached, perceptions about party chances became more homogeneous and the predictability of different perceptions of Conservative and Alliance chances sank to a very low level: most voters thought that the Conservatives' chances were good and that Alliance chances were poor. 
 Only a small and fairly random subset of voters disagreed. 
 Perceptions of Labour chances remained more predictable, though they also became rather more homogeneous as the campaign came to an end. 
 On the evidence of our multiple regression analysis, partisanship exerted a consistently powerful influence on perceptions of Labour chances and by the end of the campaign it was the only remaining significant influence. 
 In the precampaign week, other influences were also detectable: those who followed the campaign for excitement rated Labour chances highly; those who read right-wing papers or were themselves right-wing, those who watched BBC-TV news, and those who discussed politics a lot did not rate Labour chances highly. 
 Some of these influences carried forward into the first fortnight of the campaign, though they faded towards the end. 
 There seem to be three broad influences at work here: a partisan influence, which was the most powerful and consistent, plus information-based and propaganda-based influences, which declined as the election approached. 
 By the time of the election, even those with poor or biased information sources had enough accurate information to form the same judgement as those with better information sources. 
 Only their own personal prejudices remained to influence their perceptions in one direction or another (Table 7.12). 
 Labour partisans were consistently very much more optimistic than Conservatives about the Labour Party's chances of victory; Alliance partisans had intermediate views on Labour chances, though they were inclined to the Conservative viewpoint in the pre-Campaign Wave, but slightly more inclined to the Labour viewpoint by the end of the campaign. 
 It is hardly surprising that political partisans claimed (at least) to be optimistic about their party's chances. 
 But the trend analyses also confirm that press partisanship had a smaller but clear influence on perceptions amongst both Labour and Conservative identifiers. 
 By the end of   the campaign, Labour identifiers were 41 per cent more optimistic than Conservative supporters about Labour's chances. 
 At the same time, Labour identifiers who read right-wing papers were 10 per cent less optimistic than Labour identifiers who did not; while Conservatives who read right-wing papers were similarly less optimistic about Labour's chances than Conservatives who did not read right-wing papers (Table 7.13). 
 Long-term trends suggest that economic optimism was highly volatile. 
 It peaked in the election years of 1983 and 1987 and even the collapse of optimism over the period 1978&ndash;80 was halted and temporarily reversed at the 1979 election ( The Economist , 1990, p. 34). 
 Our own surveys confirm a strong switch towards optimism between our Mid-Term Wave in 1986 and our Pre-Campaign Wave in March 1987, but over the relatively short period from our Pre-Campaign Wave to the end of the campaign overall trends in economic perceptions were small. 
 We asked our panel about their perceptions of the past year and the next year, about the economic trends affecting the country and the economic trends affecting their family. 
 On balance the electorate was, and remained, strongly optimistic about the future for Britain and their family, strongly optimistic about Britain's performance in the past year, and optimistic (but much less so) about their own family's circumstances over the past year.   
 Our survey showed that there were strong partisan influences on switches in economic perceptions over the winter of 1986&ndash;7 (see Miller et al ., 
 1990, ch. 4) and partisan influences continued to influence the development of economic perceptions during the campaign itself. 
 Economic perceptions were fairly predictable in the Pre-Campaign Wave and became more so towards the end of the campaign. 
 Partisan influences were strong and became stronger as the election approached. 
 Perceptions of Britain's economic performance were more predictable than those of family circumstances,; and perceptions of the past were more predictable than expectations for the future. 
 Age influenced perceptions of family   circumstances (the older were more pessimistic than the young) but not perceptions of Britain's performance. 
 Conversely, reading a right-wing paper had much more influence upon perceptions of Britain's performance than on perceptions of family circumstances. 
 Remarkably, variables such as education and political discussion had relatively little influence on economic perceptions. 
 The better educated were slightly more optimistic about the past (not the future, though) in the pre-campaign week but even this slight effect disappeared during the campaign. 
 So, apart from age making people personally pessimistic about their own circumstances, economic perceptions were primarily influenced by a combination of personal political prejudice (partisanship) and biased information sources (right-wing or left-wing papers) (Table 7.14). 
 A trend analysis confirms these regression findings. 
 There was always an enormous difference between the economic perceptions of those who initially had Conservative and Labour preferences, especially those who described themselves as party &bquo;supporters&equo;. 
 The difference was largest when their focus was on Britain (not themselves) last year (not next year). 
 Irrespective of the focus,   however, the difference widened as the election approached. 
 Because a majority of Conservative supporters were economic optimists and a majority of Labour supporters were economic pessimists, the difference between net optimism amongst Conservative and Labour supporters exceeded 100 per cent: it was 105 per cent in the Pre-Campaign Wave, rising to 121 per cent by the end of the campaign. 
 Amongst party identifiers as a whole,  the difference between Conservative and Labour optimism rose from 93 per cent in the Pre-Campaign Wave to 108 per cent by the end of the campaign. 
 Compared to this enormous influence of personal prejudice the influence of the media on economic perceptions was small but none the less significant. 
 Amongst Labour partisans in particular the influence of the media more than doubled towards the end of the campaign, as Labour readers of right-wing papers switched from pessimism to optimism. 
 The effect of reading a right-wing paper was to make Labour identifiers 12 per cent more optimistic in the Pre-Campaign Wave, and fully 30 per cent more optimistic by the end of the campaign (Table 7.15).    
 CONCLUSIONS 
 There can be no simple answer to the apparently simple question &bquo;Does the media influence voters?&equo; 
 We need to distinguish between different elements of the media, and between the media's ability to inform and its ability to persuade. 
 In this chapter we have looked at influences on public perceptions of politics, not at influences upon attitudes. 
 From what we already knew about its audiences and programme content, we expected that television would have a stronger influence on public information and perceptions than on public attitudes and choices; while the press, particularly the mass-selling tabloids, would have a stronger influence on public attitudes and choices than on public information and perceptions. 
 Television news was pervasive, undifferentiated, and relatively unbiased. 
 It proved immensely effective at communicating party campaign themes to the electorate, but in the short span of an election campaign it had only a small influence on the public's issue-agenda. 
 The ebb and flow of controversy in television news items did not produce corresponding trends in public  interest and discussion. 
 Television's failure to publicize the unemployment issue was matched by only a small decline in public concern about the issue while enormous public interest in health, education and social services preceded television's switch towards those issues. 
 The most obvious test of television's ability to set the public agenda was provided by its massive shift of emphasis on to defence in the third week of the campaign. 
 That was matched by a similarly dramatic increase in public perceptions that the party debate had now focused on defence, but by only a small increase in the public's own concern about the issue. 
 While small influences in the short term may add up to large influences in the longer term we must conclude that, within an election campaign, television could influence but not dictate the public agenda. 
 However, it could dictate public perceptions of the parties' agenda. 
 Television coverage had surprisingly little impact on trends in party credibility. 
 Public perceptions that the election was increasingly a two-horse race matched trends in published opinion polls but preceded television's switch towards marginalizing the Alliance by focusing on two-party controversy. 
 Except in so far as they publicized opinion poll findings, television projections of party credibility did not dictate public perceptions. 
 In contrast to television, the press was highly differentiated: different papers reached very different audiences with very different messages. 
 While the pervasiveness and uniformity of television news made it unlikely that it would influence different people in different ways, the press seemed likely to influence different readers in very different ways. 
 Since political bias was so much a characteristic of the press we might expect its influence to be more apparent in terms of attitudes than perceptions, however. 
 We looked at variations in perceptions across the electorate to see whether television, the press, or both had any influence. 
 In general, the less objective the perception and the more it was influenced by partisan factors, the greater the influence of the press and the less the influence of television. 
 Public awareness of opinion polls was most predictable in the Pre-Campaign Wave and became steadily less predictable as the election approached and awareness spread throughout the electorate. 
 Before the campaign opened the key influence on poll awareness was a generalized interest in politics, but as the  campaign drew to an end television viewing became more important. 
 Before the campaign there was a 41 per cent difference in awareness of polls between those with high and low levels of interest in politics; but this declined to 22 per cent by the end of the campaign. 
 Readers of lowbrow papers were relatively ill informed about polls before the campaign but caught up with highbrow readers later. 
 Conversely the difference between those who did and did not watch television widened. 
 As the election approached, the basis of awareness shifted from more personal resources like political interest or choice of paper, to more impersonal mobilizing factors like television news. 
 The kinds of people who were aware of public opinion polls in the closing stages of the campaign were very different from the kinds of people who followed them in the mid-term. 
 Before the campaign opened those with a strong interest in politics were very much more aware of Thatcher's and Kinnock's recent activities. 
 By the end of the campaign that was no longer so true: awareness of Thatcher and Kinnock had spread much more evenly through the electorate and in so far as it did vary it was particularly high amongst those who had recently watched television news or discussed the campaign. 
 The difference between Kinnock's visibility to those with high and low levels of political interest dropped from 45 per cent before the campaign to 20 per cent at the end of the campaign; the difference between his visibility to highbrow and lowbrow paper readers dropped from 28 per cent to a mere 5 per cent; but over the same period the difference between his visibility amongst viewers and nonviewers of television news actually rose slightly. 
 Once again this shows a switch from personal resources to media mobilization. 
 Somewhat in contrast to these findings about Thatcher and Kinnock, the visibility of all &bquo;other&equo; Conservative and Labour politicians, taken in each case as a collective &bquo;other&equo;, became more predictable as the election approached. 
 With these second-rank politicians, interest in politics continued to be a strong predictor of their visibility although the impact of television viewing also increased. 
 Those who were interested in politics or discussed politics, read highbrow papers or watched television news, were a little more likely to be able to name some issues as the main themes being stressed by the parties. 
 When it came to naming particular  issues, however, it was difficult to predict who would name which issue. 
 Whether people named defence as the Conservatives' main campaign theme depended a great deal upon the date of the interview and rather less upon their personal characteristics or even their pattern of media use. 
 This was a clear case of television influencing the electorate as a whole. 
 None the less those who engaged in frequent political discussions became particularly aware of the Conservative Party's stress on defence. 
 We also looked at some perceptions which had attitudinal overtones. 
 The conceptual distinction between perceptions and attitudes is clear; but perceptions of party chances or the state of the economy imply an element of approval or disapproval when articulated by the electorate. 
 (They are purely objective perceptions when articulated by political scientists or professional economists, of course.) 
 These perceptions were influenced in varying degrees, though not completely determined, by partisan loyalties. 
 As the election approached, perceptions about party chances of victory became more homogeneous: most voters thought Conservative chances were good and Alliance chances were poor. 
 Perceptions of Labour chances remained more predictable, though they too became rather more homogeneous as the campaign came to an end. 
 There were three broad influences on perceptions of Labour chances: a &bquo;wishful thinking&equo; (partisan) influence, which was the most powerful and consistent (Labour supporters rated their party's chances highly); a pure information-based influence (discussion, education, television viewing all lowered expectations of a Labour victory), which declined as the election approached; and a propaganda-based influence (reading rightwing papers also lowered expectations of a Labour victory), which also declined as the election approached. 
 By the time of the election, even those with poor or biased information sources had enough accurate information to form the same judgement as those with better information sources. 
 Only their own personal prejudices remained to influence their perceptions in one direction or another. 
 Economic perceptions were also influenced, very strongly, by partisanship, especially when the focus was on Britain (not the voters themselves) and on the preceding year (not the forthcoming year. 
 Irrespective of the focus, however partisan influences on economic perceptions increased as the election approached. 
  Compared to the influence of personal partisan prejudice the influence of the media on economic perceptions was small but it also increased towards the end of the campaign, especially amongst Labour readers of right-wing papers. 
 Media Influence on Political Attitudes and Votes  
 PARTY AND LEADER IMAGES 
 Images of parties and party leaders are at the margin between perceptions and attitudes. 
 We asked our panel to rate each of the parties on four scales: being united, having convincing policies, being likely to keep their promises, and being moderate. 
 All of these images have overtones of approval as well as objective, factual perception. 
 Similarly we asked the panel to rate the four party leaders, Thatcher, Kinnock, Steel, and Owen, on twelve more personal scales: being decisive, trustworthy, energetic, willing to listen, well informed, caring, a good leader of a team, tough, likeable, and standing up for Britain &bquo;s interests against the European Community, the USA, and the USSR. 
 Ratings consisted of &bquo;marks out of ten&equo; for how well the image label applied. 
 Factor analysis of these images indicated just one general factor underlying image scores for Kinnock, Steel, and Owen, but two general factors underlying scores for Thatcher. 
 One grouped her images on being trustworthy, caring, likeable, and willing to listen, while the second grouped her images on being energetic, decisive, well informed, and tough. 
 But irrespective of whether there was one general factor or two, it was clear that these general factors only explained a part of the variation in images of parties and leaders. 
 Each of the individual images had a substantial component of uniqueness. 
 We investigated both the common and the unique elements of these various images. 
 For an overview we took each party's average score across the four party images, and each leader's average score across the twelve leader images. 
 That approximated a factor analysis and is conceptually easier to explain. 
 We also multiplied average scores by ten to eliminate decimal points, and turn them into percentages.  
 In the pre-campaign week, average Conservative and Alliance images were 10 per cent higher than Labour's but the gap was halved by the second fortnight of the campaign. 
 Thatcher scored 8 per cent higher than the other leaders in the Pre-Campaign Wave, but by the end of the campaign all four leaders enjoyed very similar scores. 
 Kinnock improved his score most, while Thatcher's actually declined. 
 Labour's rating on being united increased by 14 per cent though other aspects of its image improved by very much smaller amounts. 
 Kinnock improved his image most on being energetic and decisive but actually lost ground on being able to stand up to the USSR, reflecting perhaps the consequences of his &bquo;dad's army&equo; interview with David Frost. 
 Thatcher strengthened her image on being decisive but lost ground on being energetic. 
 At any one time, it was relatively easy to predict which electors would give parties and leaders high ratings. 
 Ratings for the Conservative Party and for Thatcher were the most predictable, ratings for the Alliance and its leaders the least predictable. 
 In addition, ratings for the two main parties and their leaders became more predictable as the election approached while those for the Alliance and its leaders became less predictable. 
 In other words, perceptions of the Labour and Conservative Parties and their leaders became more polarized as the election approached, while perceptions of the Alliance and its leaders became more homogeneous. 
 Thus by the last fortnight of the campaign, our regressions explained 59 per cent of the variation in Thatcher images but only 11 per cent of the variation in Alliance images (Tables 8.1, 8.2, 8.3). 
 As we might expect, partisanship was a major influence upon image ratings. 
 Indeed it was the  major influence on Conservative and Labour, Thatcher and Kinnock, and even Alliance images. 
 But surprisingly perhaps, it was not the major influence on David Steel's image; and David Owen's image was influenced more by Labour partisanship than by Alliance partisanship: the hostility of Labour partisans towards Owen exceeded even the affection of Alliance partisans for him (Table 8.3). 
 Much less obviously, age proved a significant predictor of party and leader images. 
 It was the  main influence on Steel's image and a major influence on most other images, especially those of Owen and the Alliance but also those of Kinnock and   Thatcher. 
 Older people were much more likely to give high ratings to politicians of all kinds and, to a lesser extent, to parties of all kinds. 
 Finally, media use had widespread effects. 
 Reading a rightwing rather than a left-wing paper improved images of Thatcher and the Conservative Party, and damaged images of Kinnock and the Labour Party, though it had little or no influence on images of the Alliance and its leaders. 
 Watching television had a much smaller effect and, like age, it had a positive effect upon images of all the parties and all the leaders.  
 Regression analyses suggest the influence of the press increased towards the end of the campaign. 
 Trend analyses confirm the overwhelming impact of partisanship and the small, but increasing impact of the press. 
 Thatcher's image ratings were 25 per cent higher amongst Conservative identifiers than amongst Labour identifiers in the Pre-Campaign Wave and became 30 per cent higher by the end of the campaign. 
 Kinnock's image rating was 15 per cent lower amongst Conservative identifiers in the Pre-Campaign Wave and 18 per cent lower by the end of the campaign (Table 8.4). 
 Reading a right-wing rather than a left-wing paper made Labour identifiers 6 per cent more favourable to Thatcher and 6 per cent less favourable to Kinnock by the end of the campaign though the effects were smaller before that. 
 A right-wing paper made Alliance identifiers 3 per cent less favourable to Kinnock and 8 per cent more favourable to Thatcher by the end of the campaign, and once again there was some evidence of a trend. 
    Press effects on Conservative identifiers were smaller. 
 Clearly party and leader images were dominated by personal partisan prejudice and that domination increased towards the end of the campaign. 
 None the less, there is evidence that the press had a small influence (Table 8.5). 
 Each aspect of party and leader images varied in a different way, some more predictably than others. 
 Opinion on certain aspects of party and leader images was more polarized, on others more homogeneous; and different aspects of images were subject to different influences. 
 Images of unity were less influenced by partisanship and media bias, and less predictable overall, than other aspects of   party images. 
 Thatcher's image of being tough and decisive was the least predictable &mdash; not, of course, because these two labels seemed inappropriate but because there was such general agreement that they were appropriate. 
 Few voters gave her low ratings for being tough or decisive, and they were an unpredictable few. 
 In sharp contrast, opinion was more divided on whether she was   trustworthy, caring, or willing to listen: Conservatives were inclined to give her high marks on these matters while others were not. 
 Age was the main influence upon all politicians' ratings for being energetic. 
 Older people were much more impressed by politicians' energy than were younger people. 
 Partisanship took second place when it had an influence at all, and often it did not. 
 Press bias (that is, reading a right-wing or left-wing paper) had a relatively large influence upon Thatcher's image of being willing to listen, caring, and likeable. 
 On all these &bquo;softer&equo; virtues, readers of right-wing papers gave Thatcher high marks, while readers of left-wing papers did not (even when we take account of people's own partisanship, as the regression analysis does automatically). 
 Reading right-wing papers also made people more inclined to believe the Conservative Party had convincing policies and was likely to keep its promises, that Kinnock was neither decisive, nor trustworthy, nor a good leader of a team, and especially that he could not be relied upon to stand up for British interests against the USSR. 
 Thus, reading right-wing papers had most effect upon increasing Thatcher's ratings on the &bquo;soft&equo; virtues and depressing Kinnock's ratings on the &bquo;hard&equo;  virtues &mdash; that is, on those aspects of each politician's image where they were generally considered to be at their weakest. 
 The press did not reverse general perceptions of party leaders: it sharpened and reinforced images they already had. 
 A bad press highlighted what were generally agreed to be a politician's weak points; a good press encouraged people to give politicians even higher ratings on their generally acknowledged strengths. 
 Defence policy and relationships with the Soviet Union played an unusually large part in political debate in 1987. 
 During our Pre-Campaign Wave Thatcher's visit to Moscow and Kinnock's   to Washington drew attention to the issue. 
 In the final campaign, Conservative propaganda focused on defence and Kinnock himself provided a target for attack in a TV-am  interview with David Frost in which, his opponents alleged, he advocated a strategy of guerrilla war as an alternative to nuclear weapons. 
 On being able to stand up to the USSR, Thatcher scored 80 per cent in the precampaign week, easing to 79 per cent in the last fortnight of the campaign. 
 Kinnock scored only 61 per cent in the pre-campaign week &mdash; the same as his average score across all image aspects. 
 By the end of the campaign, his average image score had risen to 65 but his score on standing up to the USSR had dropped to 56. 
 By the end of the campaign it was the weakest aspect of his image. 
 Scores on this image (standing up to the USSR) were never very predictable for any politician. 
 Partisanship was the main influence on Thatcher's and Kinnock's scores but not Steel's or Owen's; and even for Thatcher and Kinnock the partisan influence was weaker than on other aspects of their image. 
 Reading a rightwing paper never had any significant effect on this aspect of Thatcher's image and only a small effect on Kinnock's image in the Pre-Campaign Wave, though its influence grew steadily thereafter: in the first fortnight of the campaign press bias was a little more influential than anything except partisanship and in the second fortnight it was far more influential than anything except partisanship (Table 8.6). 
 As the campaign developed Kinnock's image as a man who would stand up to the USSR declined throughout the electorate, even amongst Labour supporters, though it declined slightly more amongst Conservative supporters. 
 Amongst both Labour   and Conservative identifiers, it declined twice as much if they read a right-wing paper. 
 The decline was never great, but it has to be judged against the fact that his general image was improving sharply (Table 8.7).  
 EXPLICIT ATTITUDES 
 Questions about perceptions were framed in terms of awareness rather than approval, though the partisan nature of the answers often betrayed a lack of objectivity. 
 We found that television had a large effect on those political perceptions which had little or no attitudinal content. 
 But on political perceptions where there were elements of approval or disapproval media effects were  much smaller, and it was the press, rather than television, which had more impact. 
 We turn now to influences on attitudes and votes. 
 Attitude questions explicitly sought statements of choice, preference, approval, or disapproval. 
 Given our findings on perceptions we should expect the press to have more influence than television on attitudes. 
 Whether its influence was large or small remains to be seen. 
 We sought to measure attitudes in several ways. 
 We asked respondents to give each party a mark out of ten for its handling of four issues: unemployment, inflation, defence, and a composite &bquo;health, education, and social services&equo;. 
 We also asked them to name the party they thought best on economic matters for themselves and their families, for Britain as a whole, and for the unemployed. 
 We asked for thermometer ratings (out of 100) for how warm people felt towards parties and their leaders. 
 After the election, we asked whether the parties should change their leaders, their policies, or both. 
 In addition, we asked about voting preferences. 
 In the Pre-Campaign Wave and the two Campaign Waves we asked electors to give each party a mark out of ten for how inclined they were to vote for it. 
 After the election we asked which way they had actually voted. 
 Total system approval  
 Where we asked for marks out of ten, or thermometer ratings out of a hundred, we can use relative scores for different parties to construct measures of preference. 
 But we can also add the scores for all three parties (Conservative, Labour, Alliance) in order to get a measure of total system approval . 
 One person might give the Conservative Party the highest of three high scores, another might give it the highest of three low scores. 
 Both would thereby indicate a preference for the Conservative Party but their attitudes would not be the same. 
 Not surprisingly, total system approval proved much less predictable than relative preference. 
 None the less, variations in levels of total system approval were not entirely random. 
 The most powerful and consistent influence on total approval was political interest. 
 Those who found the events of the  campaign interesting very consistently recorded higher  levels of total approval. 
 At the same time there was some evidence that those who had a more general interest in politics, as distinct from those who found the campaign interesting (a distinction we have already found significant in other contexts), were likely to record lower  levels of total approval. 
 Media influence was small but consistent. 
 Despite complex controls for various aspects of political interest and for other influences, those who watched a lot of television news, especially on BBC-TV, showed higher levels of total approval. 
 So did older people. 
 Those with high levels of education were hard to please: they showed particularly low levels of total system approval. 
 Conservatives and right-wingers were more satisfied with the parties, Labour identifiers and left-wingers less satisfied. 
 All of these findings remained broadly similar irrespective of whether we analysed total warmth towards parties and party leaders, total ratings for the parties' performance on issues, or total inclinations towards voting for all three leading parties (Table 8.8). 
 Relative preference  
 Suppose someone gives marks C, L, and A to the Conservatives, Labour, and Alliance for their handling of the unemployment issue, where each of C, L, and A is a mark out of ten. 
 Their measure of total approval for the parties on unemployment is thus (C+L+A). 
 We can calculate their relative preference for the Conservatives on the unemployment issue as C/ (C+L+A), that is, as the mark given to the Conservatives expressed as a proportion of the total mark given to all three parties (or multiplied by 100 to transform it from a proportion into a percentage). 
 Regression analyses of such relative preferences show: 
 1. 
 Relative preferences for the Alliance were much less predictable than for Labour or Conservative. 
 2. 
 Relative preferences for Labour and Conservative tended to be inversely related. 
 3. 
 Media influences on relative preferences for the Alliance were always weak and usually insignificant. 
 4. 
 Media influences on relative preferences for Conservative and Labour were always significant, usually similar in magnitude but opposite in sign.   
 So we can simplify the analysis of relative preferences by focusing on the electorate's relative preference for the Conservatives rather than Labour, that is on (C &mdash; L) / (C+L+A). 
 Naturally, Conservative identifiers gave relatively high marks to the Conservative Party, Labour identifiers to Labour, and Alliance identifiers to the Alliance. 
 Voters' ideological self-placement on a left-right scale also tended to predict their relative preferences for the Conservative or Labour Parties. 
 It would be very surprising if partisanship and ideology did not affect relative preferences in this way, but it is essential to control for partisanship and ideology before investigating other, less obvious influences. 
 Even with stringent controls for partisanship and ideology, multiple regression analyses show that the press had a significant influence on preferences. 
 Those who read right-wing papers proved significantly more satisfied with the Conservative Party's  handling of major issues, even when we controlled for their party identification and ideological self-placement. 
 Indeed, the ideological leanings of readers' papers had more impact than their own ideology. 
 The press had a substantial influence on their choice of the best party on economic matters, both for themselves and for Britain as a whole; and, indeed, on their assessments of overall party performance across the full range of economic, defence, and social issues (Table 8.9).   
 More detailed analysis suggests the press was more successful at influencing assessments of party performance on unemployment than on other issues. 
 It had a particularly strong influence amongst Labour identifiers, especially towards the end of the campaign. 
 Amongst Labour identifiers, the effect of reading a right-wing paper on their relative preference for the Conservatives on unemployment was 13 per cent in the Pre-Campaign Wave, rising to 19 per cent by the second half of the campaign (Table 8.10).  
 The press also had a moderately strong influence on public feelings of warmth towards parties and their leaders. 
 Once again, the ideological leanings of readers' papers were more influential than their own ideological leanings, though less than their partisanship (Table 8.11) Once again, the press had a   particularly strong influence on Labour identifiers; and its influence increased at the end of the campaign (Table 8.12). 
 Pre-campaign party identification exercised a particularly strong influence on voting preferences throughout the campaign and on final voting choices in the election itself. 
 None the less, the press still showed a moderately powerful influence on voting even when we controlled for voters' initial partisanship and ideology (Table 8.13) It had most effect upon those who were initially undecided or were Alliance identifiers. 
 Amongst those who were Conservative or Labour before the campaign, press bias had about a 6 per cent effect; amongst those who originally had an Alliance preference it had a 23 per cent effect; while amongst those who were originally undecided it had a 28 per cent effect &mdash; measuring all these effects in terms of the Conservative lead over Labour (Table 8.14). 
 After the election we asked whether each of the parties should now change its leaders, its policy, or both. 
 Most voters agreed that changes were needed in the Alliance and a large majority felt changes (at least in policy) were also needed in the Labour Party, but views were split almost exactly half-and-half on whether the   
 Conservatives should change anything after this, their third electoral victory. 
 Naturally Conservative identifiers were least inclined to advocate changes in the Conservative Party, but so were readers of right-wing papers and, to a lesser extent, readers of highbrow papers (Table 8.15). 
 THE LONGER TERM 
 A year before their landslide victory in the election of June 1987 the Conservatives lagged behind Labour in the opinion polls. 
 Most of the swing to the Conservatives between the summer of 1986 and the summer of 1987 occurred during the winter of 1986&ndash;7,  and there was relatively little swing in the last few months before the election. 
 What part did the media play in that year-long process? 
 Since we do not have a year-long content analysis of the media we cannot investigate the influence of a changing media consensus but we can analyse the differential effects of different elements of the media. 
 To what extent did persistently reading different papers or regularly watching different television channels make a difference to swings in political preferences? 
 for this longer-term analysis we have taken those panel members who were interviewed in the Mid-Term Wave (April-May 1986), the Pre-Campaign Wave (March-April 1987), and the Post-Election Wave (June 1987). 
 We have restricted the analysis to the   772 people who were interviewed in all three waves. 
 We have classified newspaper readers by their persistent choice of papertype. 
 We divide newspapers into six types:. 
 1. 
 no paper 
 2. the Express  or the Mail  
 3. the Mirror  
 4. the Sun  or the Star  
 5. the Telegraph, The Times , or the Financial Times  
 6. the Guardian  and classify voters as &bquo;persistent&equo; readers if they were &bquo;regular&equo; readers of the same paper-type in both the Mid-Term and Pre-Campaign Waves, that is, if they regularly read the same paper-type throughout the year preceding the election. 
 No one suggests that occasional exposure to the Sun  or The Times  will have an instant effect upon political opinions. 
 But persistent exposure to the same paper-type at least three times a week for a whole year may well have some effect, particularly if it is a preelection year when the political temperature usually rises.   
 With a small sample it is not advisable to carry out the analysis in terms of individual papers since so few respondents read any  single paper. 
 Grouping readers of roughly similar papers together improves the statistical reliability of our results. 
 No matter how small the sample size, however, it would obscure the analysis to group readers of very different papers, such as the Guardian  and the Telegraph , together. 
 Guardian  readers are sufficiently interesting and distinctive that it is worth tolerating the statistical uncertainties caused by our small sample and the Guardian's  small readership. 
 In classifying people as persistent readers, we have allowed them to switch between different individual papers, provided they stayed with the same paper-type. 
 Once again this is to retain larger numbers in the analysis and maximize the statistical reliability of the conclusions.   
 Not everyone proved to be a persistent reader of one paper (or even of a group of similar papers) but the majority did. 
 Just over two-thirds tell into one of our six categories of persistent readers (or persistent non-readers). 
 Some changed their paper-types, and others were persistent readers of a myriad of papers with individual readerships too small for us to analyse (the Scotsman , the Glasgow Herald , and regional English papers, for example). 
 Unfortunately our Mid-Term Wave was drawn from the 1986 British Social Attitudes Survey which asked no questions about television viewing or radio listening. 
 So we have had to classify viewing and listening by respondents' reports of their &bquo;regular&equo; behaviour in March 1987. 
 How long-term those viewing and listening habits were we cannot say. 
 We have classified them in two ways. 
 First, we have divided viewers into those who regularly watched BBC-TV news only, those who regularly watched ITV news only, and those who regularly watched both  (negligible numbers of voters watched neither). 
 Second, we have divided voters into those who regularly viewed or listened to any highbrow news programmes such as BBC-TV's Newsnight , ITV's Channel 4 News , or the BBC's Radio 4 news, and those who did not. 
 In the Mid-Term Wave, a year before the election, Guardian  and Mirror  readers were strongly Labour; Express , Mail , and Telegraph  readers were strongly Conservative. 
 Support for the Alliance was weaker amongst readers of the tabloids than readers of the quality press: all perhaps as expected. 
 Rather more surprisingly perhaps, Sun  and Star  readers (taken together) were at that time split fairly evenly between Labour and Conservative with the Alliance a fairly close third. 
 Sun/Star  readers were distinctive in other ways. 
 They were not quite the least well educated: in our panel, Mirror  readers had slightly less professional qualifications than even Sun/Star  readers, though every other paper's readers (and non-readers) had much more. 
 But Sun/Star  readers were less interested in politics even than Mirror  readers; and they were the least likely to tune in to highbrow news programmes such as Newsnight , Channel 4 News , or Radio 4 news. 
 Most clearly of all, Sun/Star  readers were uniquely uncommitted to party politics. 
 In the mid-term, fully 70 per cent of Mirror  readers not only had a party preference but regarded themselves as party &bquo;supporters&equo;. 
 The corresponding  percentage of party &bquo;supporters&equo; amongst Guardian  readers was 66 per cent, amongst Telegraph  etc., readers 62 per cent, and amongst Express/Mail  readers 56 per cent. 
 Amongst Sun/Star  readers it was a mere 41 per cent. 
 So there was a sharp contrast between relatively committed Mirror  readers and relatively uncommitted Sun/Star  readers despite their similarities in terms of class and education. 
 It was a contrast with important implications for the future. 
 Over the following year Mirror  readers as well as Guardian  and Telegraph  readers proved relatively stable in their political preferences. 
 On election day, in June 1987, 84 per cent of Mirror  readers (and only slightly less Guardian  and Telegraph/Times/ Financial Times  readers) voted for the party they had preferred a year earlier, in the summer of 1986. 
 But only 64 per cent of Sun/ Star  readers did so. 
 Sun/Star  readers were more likely than others to have no preference at all in 1986 (despite voting in 1987), and at the same time, those Sun/Star  readers who did have a preference in 1986 were more likely than others to change it during the next year (Table 8.16).   
 Overall, in this panel, the Conservative lead over Labour increased by 10 per cent between 1986 and election day in 1987. 
 It increased by 17 per cent amongst Express/Mail  readers, and by 34 per cent amongst Sun/Star  readers, but by a mere 2 per cent amongst Mirror  readers, which suggests the tabloids did influence their readers. 
 Guardian  readers swung primarily from Labour to the Alliance. 
 Telegraph  readers hardly swung at all. 
 Television viewing had relatively little impact (Table 8.17). 
 Throughout the electorate the swing to the Conservatives was stronger amongst those who generally had relatively little interest in politics; amongst those who did not tune in to watch highbrow television or radio news; amongst those without professional qualifications; and amongst those who, despite stating a party preference in 1986, none the less denied being party &bquo;supporters&equo; &mdash; we can call them politically &bquo;uncommitted&equo; &mdash; even when they had political preferences. 
 About half the electorate    were party supporters in 1986, and half uncommitted, by this definition. 
 The influence of the tabloid press was particularly strong on the uncommitted. 
 Overall, the Conservative lead increased between 1986 and June 1987 by only 5 per cent amongst party  supporters, but by 18 per cent amongst the uncommitted. 
 Amongst party supporters it increased by no more than 10 per cent, irrespective of what paper they read. 
 But amongst uncommitted voters, it increased by 28 per cent amongst Express/Mail  readers and 50 per cent amongst Sun/Star  readers. 
 In contrast, there was no drift to the Conservatives amongst uncommitted Mirror  readers. 
 Since Sun/Star  readers tended to be uncommitted they were relatively easy to influence. 
 But that is only part of the explanation for the magnitude of their swing to the Conservatives. 
 The fact that uncommitted voters who read the Sun  or Star  swung so much more than other uncommitted voters  suggests that these papers were particularly good at influencing their readers. 
 Swings were highest amongst voters who watched both  BBC and ITV news, and amongst those who avoided watching highbrow television news programmes, but the differences between these groups of television viewers were slight. 
 Once we distinguished between party supporters and uncommitted voters we found no consistent differences between voters with different viewing habits.  
 Swings were highest amongst those who relied more on television than the press for help in deciding how to vote, rather lower amongst those who relied more on the press, and lowest of all amongst the 40 per cent of the electorate who found television and the press equally useful. 
 (See Chapter 6 on who found the press and television most useful.) 
 However, that reflected the fact that readers of highbrow papers were more likely to place their faith in the press, and they were the least likely to change their voting intentions. 
 Amongst readers of the same paper (or paper-group as defined in Table 8.17) those who said they relied more on the press than on television were more likely to swing in the direction of their paper's partisanship: Sun/Star  and Express/ Mail  readers who relied more on their papers swung more strongly to the Conservatives than Sun/Star  and Express/Mail  readers who relied more on television; at the same time, Mirror  readers who relied more on their paper swung towards Labour, while Mirror  readers who relied more on television swung towards the Conservatives. 
 While these findings are plausible enough they depend upon very small subsamples of our panel, since we have to categorize voters by their choice of paper and their reliance on the press rather than television while discarding the large numbers who relied equally on both television and the press. 
 None the less they do seem to confirm our general findings that while television was much more informative than the press, it was much less persuasive &mdash; and intentionally so! 
 Though the highbrow press had the highest level of political content, it also had relatively partisan readers, and more of a mission to inform, less of a mission to persuade. 
 On issues like unilateralism or the economy, papers like the Guardian  and Telegraph  did seem to influence their readers as much as the tabloids, but not on the question of voting choice. 
 Persistent Guardian  readers swung strongly towards a more unilateralist position, while Telegraph  and Times  readers swung in the opposite direction. 
 The differences between Mirror  and Sun/Star  readers were in the expected directions but quite small. 
 Similarly, on swings towards optimism about the state of the economy, the difference between Guardian  and Telegraph/Times  readers was greater than between Mirror  and Sun/Star  readers. 
 Once again, however, differences between voters with different viewing habits were slight (Table 8.18).   
 CONCLUSIONS 
 Images of parties and party leaders are right at the margin between perceptions and attitudes. 
 As we might expect, partisanship was a major influence upon image ratings, and it became an increasingly powerful influence as the election approached. 
 Apart from partisanship, age also proved significant: older people had a much more favourable image of politicians of all kinds and, to a lesser extent, parties of all kinds. 
 Right-wing papers improved their readers' images of Thatcher and the Conservative Party, and damaged their readers' images of Kinnock and the Labour Party, though they had little or no influence upon their readers' images of the Alliance and its leaders. 
 Press influence increased towards the end of the campaign but it remained small compared to the influence of partisanship. 
 By the end of the campaign, Labour identifiers who read a right-wing paper were 6 per cent more favourable to Thatcher and 6 per cent less favourable to Kinnock than Labour identifiers who did not. 
 Clearly images of parties and leaders  were dominated by personal partisan prejudice and that domination increased towards the end of the campaign. 
 None the less, there is evidence that the press had a small additional influence. 
 Each aspect of leader and party images varied in a different way. 
 The press had a relatively large influence upon images of Thatcher being willing to listen, caring, and likeable. 
 Reading right-wing papers had most effect upon improving Thatcher's image on the &bquo;soft&equo; virtues and damaging Kinnock's image on the &bquo;hard&equo; virtues &mdash; that is, on those aspects of each politician's image where they were generally considered to be at their weakest. 
 Political attitudes were very largely determined by partisanship, but not completely. 
 Even with stringent controls for partisanship and ideology, multiple regression analyses show that the press, but not television , had a significant influence on voters' preferences. 
 Those who read right-wing papers proved significantly more satisfied with the Conservative Party's handling of major issues, and felt significantly warmer towards Mrs Thatcher and her party. 
 Indeed, the ideological leanings of readers' papers had more impact than their own ideology (though much less than their partisanship). 
 The press had a particularly strong influence on the attitudes of Labour identifiers, especially towards the end of the campaign. 
 A year before their re-election victory the Conservatives lagged behind Labour in the opinion polls. 
 Most of the swing back to the government occurred during the winter of 1986&ndash;7 and there was relatively little swing in the last few months before the election. 
 We undertook a longer-term analysis, to see what part the media played in the Conservative recovery. 
 In our panel of voters the Conservative lead over Labour increased by 34 per cent amongst Sun/Star  readers but by a mere 2 per cent amongst Mirror  readers, which suggests the tabloids were able to influence their readers. 
 Guardian  readers swung primarily from Labour to the Alliance. 
 Telegraph  readers hardly swung at all. 
 Television viewing had relatively little impact. 
 The influence of the tabloid press was particularly strong on those voters who denied being party &bquo;supporters&equo;, even when they had a party preference. 
 They made up half the electorate. 
 The Conservative lead increased by 50 per cent amongst politically  uncommitted Sun/Star  readers but not at all amongst politically uncommitted Mirror  readers. 
 Since Sun/Star  readers as a whole were relatively uncommitted they were relatively easy to influence anyway but, in addition, the tabloids were particularly good at influencing their readers' voting preferences. 
 Highbrow papers like the Guardian  or the Telegraph  were able to influence their readers at least as much as the tabloids on issues (like unilateralism or the economy) but not on voting choice.  
 Political Pluralism and the Media  
 Media analysis often arouses controversy, not just about the findings themselves but about their policy implications. 
 Detailed summaries of this study's findings appear at the end of each chapter. 
 But so far the conclusions have been empirical rather than moral. 
 Right or wrong they have simply attempted to state the facts. 
 But what are their moral implications, if any? 
 Do our findings justify complacency or urge the need for reform. 
 By themselves the facts are neutral but in so far as moral views about the proper role of the media are based upon presumptions about facts, our empirical findings are bound to have moral implications. 
 By way of introduction, this chapter outlines three views about the proper role and status of the media: the Mobilizing Ideal , the Libertarian Ideal , and the Public Service Ideal . 
 Other authors list a larger number of viewpoints but they seem to be relatively minor variants on these three. 
 (McQuail, 1987, ch. 5, presents a longer list of &bquo;ideals&equo; or &bquo;moral models&equo;. 
 There is a rough equivalence between our Libertarian and Public Service Ideals and the &bquo;Forensic&equo; and Clinical' models discussed by Wober, 1989b.) 
 Then we can relate the findings of our 1987 election news study to these three ideals. 
 This is not an attempt to deal with these ideals in a comprehensive way &mdash; no single empirical study could do that &mdash; but merely an attempt to see what bearing our factual findings may have upon moral views about the media. 
 THE MOBILIZING IDEAL 
 Views differ about the proper relationship between the mass media and society. 
 When the invention of the printing press first allowed mass production of political pamphlets and newsletters, British governments treated them as &bquo;seditious libels&equo; which challenged their sovereign authority and fomented public disorder. 
 In more recent times the behaviour of British governments has been more restrained and more sophisticated, but their  instincts and suspicions remain. 
 Conservative leader Stanley Baldwin accused the press of wanting &bquo;power without responsibility, the prerogative of the harlot throughout the ages&equo;. 
 Ironically, he made the accusation in 1931 shortly before he himself exercised &bquo;power without responsibility&equo; as the dominant figure in Ramsay MacDonald's National Coalition government, controlling MacDonald's government without bearing the responsibility of being Prime Minister. 
 Authoritarians of the left, right, and centre &mdash; including right-wing dictators, old-style communists, and post-colonial governments in developing countries &mdash; have all of them espoused the Mobilizing Ideal as the proper role for the mass media. 
 In their view, the media should be firmly subordinated to the state and its primary function should be to encourage whatever the state defines as &bquo;good&equo; &mdash; whether that be national consciousness and personal self-discipline, or socialist egalitarianism, or a relentless drive towards modernization and economic development. 
 What the media should not  do is cause friction and division within society and especially it should not encourage opposition or resistance to government decrees. 
 It should unite rather than divide, encourage rather than discourage. 
 Its purpose should be to mobilize support for the policies, personalities, and institutions of the regime. 
 Modern British governments are intellectually committed to the concepts of limited government and political pluralism, but they retain their old authoritarian instincts. 
 Even impartiality is not welcome. 
 During the General Strike of 1926, Winston Churchill accused the BBC of &bquo;being impartial between the fire and the fire brigade&equo;. 
 Margaret Thatcher took much the same view about BBC coverage of the Falklands conflict and the troubles in Northern Ireland. 
 Compared to overtly authoritarian regimes, British governments make relatively little use of suppression and censorship, though they do suppress some information and they do sometimes censor the media, especially on defence and security matters. 
 More frequently they try to manipulate the media to their advantage by the selective release of carefully timed and adjusted information and by threatening, punishing, and intimidating media staff. 
 Punishment ranges from denying interviewers access to cabinet ministers to holding down the BBC's licence fee, appointing suitable people to control both BBC  and commercial broadcasting, and stimulating the public to accuse the broadcasters of bias. 
 It has to be emphasized that, for those who support the Mobilizing Ideal, these authoritarian features of British governments' attitudes and behaviour towards the media are not defects but virtues. 
 They are evidence of efficient, determined, and forceful government, the alternative to which is drift, lack of authority, and chaos. 
 Authoritarians do not apologize for the smack of firm government. 
 THE LIBERATION IDEAL 
 The American Constitution is based upon the concept of liberty rather than strong, decisive government. 
 The First Amendment declares that &bquo;Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech or of the press&equo;. 
 Whether Congress and the President behave in accordance with the spirit of the Constitution and the Bill of Rights is beside the point. 
 In England, Milton argued passionately for the freedom of the press and J. S. Mill denounced the &bquo;peculiar evil of silencing the expression of opinion&equo;. 
 They were defending the right of the pamphleteer to publish ideas that were unpopular in society or inconvenient for the state. 
 The essence of this Libertarian Ideal is that people should be free to publish what they wish and free to read or view what they wish. 
 Some libertarians (though not perhaps Mill himself) hoped that such freedom would have consequent advantages: that it would provide a safety valve for dissent, encourage full expression of both majority and minority opinions, allow truth to drive out error, and provide some check on arbitrary misrule. 
 But these were merely pious hopes. 
 There is nothing about mere freedom that can guarantee anything. 
 Permission is by definition very different from prescription (though not necessarily incompatible with it). 
 Perhaps those who know the truth will be too lazy or too diffident or too poor to publish while whose who believe in error will be so rich, or well organized, or self-confident that they will control the presses and the television studios and dominate the &bquo;free market in ideas&equo;.  
 THE PUBLIC SERVICE IDEAL 
 Freedom is valuable and is valued by the public as an end in itself, but as a means to an end it has proved a failure. 
 The fundamental strength of the Libertarian Ideal consists of nothing more than the proud assertion that freedom is an end-product that people value. 
 Any diminution of freedom reduces the quality of life. 
 There may be compensations for a loss of freedom but there are no substitutes for it. 
 On the other hand, arguments that freedom is valuable for something other than itself are seldom convincing. 
 Usually they are a mixture of wishful thinking and libertarian special pIeading. 
 As far as British news media are concerned, freedom simply does not perform the tasks that Mill's followers hoped it would. 
 Information is as vital to a democratic regime as propaganda is to an authoritarian one (Blumler, 1987). 
 Yet freedom for publishers does not guarantee the adequately informed public required by democratic theory (Newton, 1988c). 
 In modern Britain, a mere six publishers now account for 80 per cent of all daily, Sunday, and local newspaper sales (Coxall and Robins, 1989, p. 312). 
 Whale (1977, p. 80) has justified unregulated commercial control of the press by arguing that &bquo;a newspaper controlled by a commercial group writes inhibitedly about a handful of concerns at most; a paper owned by the state, the effective alternative, would be guarded in its outlook on whole areas of the national life&equo;. 
 His critique of the alternative is more convincing than his defence of the status quo. 
 His argument is that newspapers may be inhibited about discussing the commercial interests of their proprietors but otherwise they exercise independent judgement. 
 In particular there is anecdotal evidence to show that they are willing to expose the faults of other companies, including those that buy advertising space in the paper. 
 But Whale is wrong. 
 A newspaper controlled by a conglomerate multinational business is inhibited in discussing large areas of business. 
 More important, it is inhibited in supporting political causes which clash with the politics of its proprietor. 
 The largest-selling newspapers in Britain are owned by swashbuckling businessmen who do not hesitate to interfere with the editorial content of their papers and whose personal politics are so well known to all their staff that the proprietors can set the  political tone of their employees' work without  crude, direct, and explicit interference. 
 Journalists and editors know what will please the proprietor and what will displease. 
 But in addition, despite controlling their staff by maintaining a high personal profile on political issues, proprietors also act directly. 
 Murdoch prides himself on being a journalist with the skill to edit his papers personally as and when he chooses. 
 Maxwell does not have the same depth of journalistic background but none the less occasionally issues a signed &bquo;message from the proprietor&equo; on the front page of his papers. 
 As a journalist himself, Hetherington (1985) emphasizes the role of editors as well as proprietors and defends their &bquo;honest journalism&equo; and willingness to resist both proprietorial and government pressure. 
 But even he notes that Maxwell would telephone &bquo;as often as six times in an evening to staff who were working on political reports&equo;. 
 He quotes Maxwell himself as boasting &bquo;I sure as hell have got control and everybody knows it&equo; (Hetherington, 1985, pp. 28&ndash;9). 
 To suggest that press barons only influence their papers on a &bquo;handful&equo; of mainly commercial concerns is totally misleading. 
 Indeed, the motivations of press barons have seldom been purely commercial (Jenkins, 1986). 
 The primitive concept of the Libertarian Ideal originally asserted the right of individuals and groups to voice (perhaps literally) their opinion in the market-place and to distribute their pamphlets and newsletters to those who passed by. 
 We have to ask whether today's press or television is the modern equivalent of the speech and the pamphlet or the modern equivalent of the market-place itself. 
 When technical or commercial factors limit the number of significant publishing organizations to a handful of major companies freedom, variety, and debate may have to be internalized within  them. 
 There simply are not enough competing news organizations to provide adequate variety and debate between  them, and the technical or commercial factors that hinder the creation of rival news organizations mean that free speech cannot be guaranteed by open entry  into a system of competing news organizations. 
 Freedom, variety, and debate may have to be provided by open access into existing news products (existing papers, existing television networks) and by variety and debate within these products. 
 The Public Service Ideal is based upon the realization that the  limited set of existing news sources are no longer pamphlets distributed in the market-place, they are the market-place itself; no longer speakers in a public debate, but the platform on which that debate must take place. 
 Within Britain, the Libertarian Ideal has traditionally been associated with the press and the Public Service Ideal with broadcasting. 
 The reason for that is simple. 
 There appears to be a wide variety of newspapers available to the public (even though appearances deceive), and it has always been possible in principle (if not in practice) to found a new paper. 
 By contrast, radio and television broadcasting began and remained a monopoly or near monopoly, subject to government licensing and control, until the 1980s. 
 With the exception of Radio Luxembourg's popular entertainment programmes, few British people ever listened to foreign broadcasts. 
 This distinction between the press and broadcasting is now much less clear. 
 Increasingly powerful transmitters, satellite relays, and cable systems have begun to open up the British electorate to a wider variety of broadcast news sources, while business mergers have effectively consolidated control of the press into a very few hands (Newton, 1988a, p. 314; Negrine, 1989, ch. 4). 
 This has made it a little more possible to contemplate a Libertarian Ideal for television, but even more necessary to consider a Public Service Ideal for the press. 
 While new technology has reduced the costs of entry into newspaper publishing, its main effect has been to improve the profitability of established press barons. 
 The range of newspapers read by the bulk of the British electorate has narrowed sharply over the last two decades &mdash; in terms of the political partisanship of mass-selling papers, if not in terms of the proliferation of low-circulation titles (Newton, 1988a, p. 320; Tunstall, 1983, p. 12). 
 Indeed, with the exception of Atlanta's Cable News Network, seen by a very small audience in Britain, even the introduction of new television technology has so far only extended the reach (if not the profitability) of Britain's existing press barons. 
 Of course, it can be argued that readers get the paper that they want or deserve. 
 As Whale (1977, p. 84) argues: &bquo;It is readers who determine the character of newspapers.&equo; 
 Up to a point that is correct. 
 If there were a huge demand for a quality left-wing paper then sales of the Guardian  would increase sharply and (less  certainly) an enterprising businessman might provide another left-wing alternative. 
 But people do not buy their paper purely for its politics. 
 They may choose a paper for its coverage of sports and scandals and then be subjected to its coverage of politics. 
 Overall, even if they do get the paper they want, it does not follow that they get the political coverage they want. 
 The Public Service Ideal does not assume, against all the evidence, that a free market will necessarily produce political access, variety, and debate; it insists upon mechanisms which aim directly at these goals rather than relying upon their being achieved as the accidental by-products of mechanisms whose primary function is to achieve quite different goals such as commercial profitability or proprietorial self-indulgence. 
 So, those who support the Public Service Ideal advocate specific  mechanisms designed to ensure that political coverage is wide-ranging, balanced, and impartial, as well as being independent of the state. 
 Both BBC and IBA structures were based upon this ideal. 
 Balance is difficult to define in simple terms and requires great sensitivity by journalists if it is to be achieved. 
 Here we are primarily concerned about balance and impartiality between political parties, but balance between social groups and institutions, or between alternative life-styles, may also be important; so too may balance between rival factions within parties &mdash; for example during contests for party leadership, such as the 1990 contest between Heseltine and Thatcher. 
 Outside government, few argue against the ambitions of the Public Service Ideal, but many argue that its mechanisms are oppressive and therefore support the Libertarian Ideal. 
 Conversely, few argue against the mechanisms (or lack of them) of the Libertarian Ideal but many reject its consequences. 
 The Royal Commission on the Press (1977) wanted to &bquo;transplant the public service rationale of broadcasting to the press, but was opposed to the framework of public regulation that underpins it&equo; (Curran and Seaton, 1985, p. 297). 
 Libertarians such as Samuel Brittan (1987) argue that regulation is no different from censorship. 
 Yet while some regulations are equivalent to censorship, others are not. 
 The real challenge is to devise mechanisms for extending the Public Service Ideal to the British press or to British news media as a whole while minimizing the damage to the Libertarian Ideal. 
 That clearly requires regulations that are  different from censorship.  
 THE ELECTION CONTEXT: ONCE IN FOUR YEARS 
 &bquo;The English people think that they are free, but in this belief they are profoundly wrong. 
 They are free only when they are electing members of parliament. 
 Once the election has been completed, they revert to a condition of slavery: they are nothing, (Rousseau, quoted by Pulzer, 1975, p. 18). 
 We need not agree entirely with Rousseau in order to accept his insight that election times are special. 
 Indeed from the standpoint of a cynical manipulator we could even invert his logic. 
 In order to enslave the English people, we might argue, it is only necessary to enslave them at election time: once in four years Is enough. 
 Governments are well aware that a cycle of economic activity can be very advantageous provided it can be synchronized with the electoral cycle, so that booms occur at election times and recessions at non-election times. 
 Indeed one characteristic of British democracy is that the country is normally ruled by the party that lies second or third in the opinion polls (if we take averages over all months since polls began, giving each month equal weight). 
 The British system of popular government is thus a system of unpopular government &mdash; a consequence of this electoral cycle. 
 The media implications must be obvious. 
 Media coverage of politics near to elections is more important than media coverage at non-election times. 
 Coxall and Robins&equo; (1989, p. 309) apology for a Conservative-dominated press, that &bquo;it has never shied away from criticising the Conservative Party or a Conservative Government&equo;, is misleading. 
 The question is not just whether  it criticizes the Conservative Party but when  it criticizes the Conservative Party. 
 Political balance cannot be achieved by criticizing one party during the mid-term of a parliament and another at election time. 
 Indeed that may be a more subtle form of propaganda than a constant barrage of criticism. 
 By criticizing the Conservative Party mid-term the right-wing press can build up a certain degree of credibility with its readers which it can then use to maximum effect by suspending criticism of the Conservative Party and increasing its attacks on Labour as the election approaches. 
 Anecdotal evidence suggests that the tabloid press stores up suitable material for use in election campaigns. 
 Editors do think explicitly about timing and they are not motivated merely to be the first to print a &bquo;scoop&equo;: they keep stories until the  time is ripe. 
 Old news was certainly presented as new scandal in the 1987 election campaign. 
 Exactly the opposite seems to happen on television. 
 As an election approaches, the Libertarian Ideal legitimizes a switch towards more strident press partisanship, while the Public Service Ideal encourages television to be even more careful than usual to maintain balance and impartiality. 
 The contrast between different elements of the media driven by the competing ideals of liberty and public service increases as the election approaches. 
 MOBILIZATION: THE FINDINGS 
 Despite British television's formal commitment to impartiality and balance our content analysis of national television news revealed a significant bias towards the government (Chapter 4). 
 Though the parties as parties  received roughly equal treatment, the government received additional coverage as a government  for activities that were ostensibly unconnected with the election campaign. 
 So because the government therefore got &bquo;two bites at the cherry&equo; there was a pro-government bias on television. 
 This bias was particularly strong during our Pre-Campaign Wave in March when Prime Minister Thatcher visited Moscow but it continued at a reduced level throughout the final campaign. 
 Only the utterly na&iuml;ve or the determinedly blind could believe that any government activity near to election time does not have electoral implications. 
 Martin Harrison (1989, p. 656) accepts that television &bquo;reporting of routine, uncontroversial activities may well give incumbent governments an inbuilt advantage&equo; but he rejects the idea of applying the concepts of impartiality and balance to the governing party's total television coverage. 
 He draws attention to the &bquo;French approach of dividing time into thirds &mdash; one third each to the government, the governing parties and opposition parties&equo;. 
 That approach, which gives two-thirds of news coverage to the incumbent government, is reasonable, even generous, if viewed in the context of the Mobilizing Ideal which accords priority to established authority. 
 Equally, it is unreasonable, even unacceptable, in the context of other ideals for the relationship between the media and society. 
 Harrison and others defend the present system with another argument. 
 They agree that the government gets extra television  coverage but argue that such coverage is not necessarily favourable. 
 In 1987 perhaps the Prime Minister's pre-election visit to Moscow and her eve-of-election trip to the Venice summit of Western leaders were favourable to her re-election, but &bquo;Harold Wilson always asserted that a bad set of trade figures a few days before polling cost him an election, while the effect of being centre-stage during the Iran hostages affair may have been devastating to Jimmy Carter's fortunes&equo;. 
 That may be true, but in 1987 hostile interviews with Neil Kinnock trying to explain his party's defence policy counted as part of the Labour Party's coverage. 
 Coverage of all  kinds can be both favourable and unfavourable &mdash; no matter whether politicians are in government or in opposition &mdash; and politicians themselves must bear the prime responsibility for ensuring that when they do get access to the media they present their own case well. 
 There is no difference between government coverage and party coverage in this respect except that government has more initiative in determining the news, which means that it has more opportunity than the opposition to ensure that its coverage is favourable. 
 So long as balance is defined in terms of the quantity of party coverage &mdash; and not whether it is favourable or unfavourable &mdash; then the only justification for awarding the government extra coverage is that the government represents order, stability, and legitimate authority, which the media has a duty to support. 
 Those who do not approve the Mobilizing Ideal for the media should not approve extra media time for the government, especially near to election time. 
 Throughout the 1980s leading supporters of the Conservative government, notably Norman Tebbit and his Media Monitoring Unit, alleged left-wing bias on the BBC (Negrine, 1989, p. 123; BBC, 1986). 
 It is difficult to see that as anything other than an attempt to intimidate the BBC. 
 Our content analysis of national television news in Chapter 4 suggests that television news was biased both towards the government of the day (through extra coverage of the government) and towards right-wing political viewpoints (through its emphasis on crime, defence, and security). 
 Our comparison of BBC-TV with ITV in Chapter 5 showed that there was little difference between them. 
 Our opinion survey in Chapter 6 showed that most voters felt television news on both networks was unbiased; but amongst the minority who felt it  was biased a majority thought it was biased towards the Conservatives and against both Labour and the Alliance. 
 At the same time a large majority of voters thought that the press was biased, and that it was biased towards the Conservatives, against Labour, and against the Alliance. 
 Both our content analysis and our survey of public opinion suggest that allegations of anti-Conservative bias on the BBC were wildly off-target. 
 If Tebbit wished to attack bias as such he should have directed his criticism at the press rather than television. 
 The media certainly were biased &mdash; but towards  the Conservative government, not against  it; and bias was very much more evident in the press than on television. 
 But, of course, his attack was very much on-target if he simply wished to attack those elements of the media that were least favourable to his own party and government. 
 Though television was pro-government and pro-Conservative it was much less so than other elements of the mass media. 
 Judged against the Mobilizing Ideal, therefore, both BBC-TV and ITV were guilty of failing to show enough enthusiasm for the government of the day. 
 Would it have been different under a Labour government? 
 Under a Labour government we might expect television to be somewhat more favourable to the Labour Party. 
 Labour would then benefit from the extra coverage given to the incumbent government. 
 But the bias towards defence and security (which have historically been natural right-wing issues) might well persist and offset Labour's advantage as the incumbent government, unless the 1989 Year of Revolutions in Eastern Europe ushers in a new era of world peace and tranquillity. 
 The 1990 Gulf Crisis suggests that world conflict will unfortunately continue, even though its location may shift. 
 So under a Labour government, television would probably not be quite so pro-Labour as it was pro-Conservative under a Conservative government. 
 A Labour government would feel the same need to mobilize support as a Conservative government and Labour politicians in office would probably feel even more disappointed with television than Conservative politicians. 
 But the enormous contrast between relatively  unbiased news on television and extreme pro-Conservative bias in the press would encourage Labour politicians to moderate their criticism of television and concentrate their attack on the press.  
 LIBERTY AND PUBLIC SERVICE: THE FINDINGS 
 It is ironic, but perhaps not surprising that the more virulent allegations of media bias have been levelled at the most balanced and impartial element of the media. 
 Conservative politicians attack the BBC for its alleged left-wing bias (Newton, 1988a, p. 326); academic sociologists attack it for its alleged anti-trade union and pro-right-wing bias (Glasgow University Media Group, 1976, 1980, 1982; Beharrell and Philo, 1977). 
 Our own content analysis also suggests that British television news has not, in fact, achieved its goal of perfect impartiality in absolute terms. 
 But in relative terms there can be no doubt that British broadcasting comes close to the Public Service Ideal while the British press comes nowhere near it. 
 Indeed most of the British press does not seek to do so. 
 Unlike the American press, where papers serve geographically defined communities, the English press operates on a national scale and serves social groups or campaigning proprietors rather than complete communities. 
 (The Scottish press is more like the American in this respect.) 
 That encourages the English press to take a divisive, partisan line. 
 The British electorate have no illusions about press balance. 
 Only a small minority of voters in our panel thought that television was biased and they were not agreed upon the direction of that bias. 
 But a large majority of newspaper readers felt that their own papers were biased. 
 A majority of readers of every one of the major-selling papers thought their own paper was biased &mdash; not just readers of the tabloids but readers of quality papers such as the Telegraph  and the Guardian . 
 We found evidence that the electors exercised a coherent choice amongst the media sources on offer; and that they enjoyed exercising that choice. 
 There was real choice available in terms of depth and detail, ranging from entertaining but uninformative tabloids to highbrow news sources like the quality papers, Radio 4 news, or television programmes like Newsnight  and Channel 4 News . 
 Highbrow sources were clearly much more attractive to people who were particularly interested in politics. 
 Younger voters tended towards the tabloid press and Radios 1 and 2. 
 Highbrow papers and highbrow radio were particularly sought after by the highly educated. 
 Highbrow television, however, reached the politically interested almost irrespective of their  education level. 
 These variations in media use suggest that radio and the press provide a choice of detail which matches the demands of different sectors of the public &mdash; in keeping with the Libertarian Ideal. 
 At the same time the audience pattern for highbrow television news seems more in keeping with the Public Service Ideal: reaching out to the interested public irrespective of social background. 
 There was much less choice in terms of the media's political partisanship. 
 Only the Guardian  amongst the qualities and the Mirror  (with its Scottish stable-mate, the Record) amongst the tabloids could be considered even moderately left-wing in 1987. 
 Even the Guardian  had advocated a Conservative victory, albeit with a &bquo;small majority&equo;, in 1983 (Roberts, 1989, p. 37). 
 Leftwingers were clearly more attracted to left-wing papers, particularly during the election campaign, but the poverty of partisan choice meant that many left-wing voters read right-wing papers. 
 The range of available papers, judged by their partisanship, was inadequate for either the Libertarian or Public Service Ideals, though left-wing perspectives were articulated by a small minority of the press. 
 Choice of television viewing was even more limited partly by the similarity between BBC-TV and ITV, but also by the electorate's tendency to watch both  BBC-TV and ITV. 
 Judged by the Public Service Ideal, television did well, though it fell short of perfection. 
 Variety existed within television programmes. 
 Though the news was at least relatively balanced and impartial, the balance was achieved by giving time and attention to a variety of alternative viewpoints, not by suppressing diversity. 
 None the less, viewers seemed to resent their lack of choice and lack of control over what they saw. 
 The variety of television news (and current affairs) programmes allowed them to choose the degree of depth and detail they wanted, but not the political viewpoints expressed. 
 In Britain, unlike some European countries, there is no choice between a right-wing and a left-wing television news channel. 
 So while television scored well in terms of public service, it scored less well in terms of freedom of choice. 
 While voters generally thought that television was unbiased and that the press was biased we found that allegations of bias were not synonymous with disapproval. 
 Partisan viewers tended to see television as being less  favourable to their own party than  it appeared to be in the eyes of other viewers. 
 In other words, general perceptions of bias (or the lack of it) were overlaid by a tendency for viewers to react against  television news, alleging that it was biased towards their opponents. 
 At the same time, partisan readers tended to claim that their newspaper was more  favourable to their own party than it appeared to be in the eyes of other readers. 
 So generally clear perceptions of strong press bias were overlaid by a tendency for readers to claim that their paper was relatively sympathetic to their own political viewpoint. 
 Right-wing readers of a right-wing paper were more  likely than left-wing readers of that same paper to claim that their paper was biased towards the right &mdash; though a majority of both left- and right-wing readers typically agreed that their papers were biased and agreed on the direction of that bias. 
 Instead of reacting against the bias in their chosen paper, readers tended (at the margin) to defend their paper (if it was biased against their party) or even to glory in its bias (if it was biased in favour of their party). 
 The difference between public responses to perceptions of bias in the press and on television was reflected in the complex relationship between voters' allegations of bias and their ratings of the &bquo;usefulness&equo; of the press and television news. 
 Viewers who alleged bias on television tended to give television news lower  marks for &bquo;usefulness&equo; than viewers who perceived no bias on television; but readers who alleged bias in their papers tended to give their papers higher  marks for &bquo;usefulness&equo; than readers who perceived no bias in their paper (Chapter 6). 
 Overall, although readers were well aware that their papers were relatively biased compared to television and although they rated television as much more useful for providing information about issues, they did not  rate television much more useful in helping them decide how to vote. 
 Their perceptions of press bias did not prompt readers to reject press guidance. 
 It is perhaps significant that there appeared to be more choice of newspaper than of television news. 
 To the general public, newspapers were visibly different in tone, style, and partisan bias, even though media analysts know that this apparent variety is controlled and constrained by a handful of publishers. 
 By contrast, television news is produced by only two networks (each broadcasting on two channels) which are constrained by law to offer  remarkably similar products, however balanced, internally varied, and impartial those products might be. 
 National television news originates &mdash; and was seen to originate &mdash; from either the newsroom at the BBC's London Television Centre or the newsroom of ITN, which supplies both ITV and Channel 4 news. 
 Voters who read a stridently left- or right-wing paper are at least exercising some choice, even if their own partisanship is different from that of their paper. 
 But any bias they detect on television is inflicted upon them by what seems like a television news cartel. 
 Impartiality can be irritating to viewers as well as to governments &mdash; though much less so to viewers. 
 The Libertarian Ideal is seductive. 
 Previous studies have repeatedly drawn attention to the fact that voters, particularly those who read lowbrow tabloids, tend to believe the news on television but remain sceptical about what they read in the press (see, for example, Negrine, 1989, p. 3). 
 Our study confirms that finding but questions its relevance and its implications. 
 Despite their scepticism, readers said they found the press useful, particularly for guiding their voting decision if not for providing information. 
 Academics regard bias as a sin, but others may regard it as a virtue. 
 In the real world of politics the distinction between &bquo;bias&equo; and &bquo;commitment&equo; is not always clear. 
 Our analyses of voters' information levels and their changing political preferences confirm and even strengthen that finding. 
 Once personal circumstances were taken into account, people's information levels were influenced primarily by how much television news they watched while their swings of political preferences were influenced primarily by which newspaper they read (Chapters 7 and 8). 
 Frequent television viewers were significantly more aware of opinion poll findings, more aware of party leaders' activities, more aware of second-rank politicians' activities, and more aware of the parties' campaign themes. 
 Watching television news also made viewers feel more warmth towards parties and their leaders generally (that is, towards any and all parties) and more inclined to vote (for any and all parties). 
 At the same time, readers of right-wing papers were significantly more inclined to be optimistic about the economy, had a significantly better image of the Conservative Party and its leader, gave the Conservative Party better ratings for handling issues, felt more  warmth towards the Conservative Party, and swung more strongly towards voting Conservative. 
 So despite the speculations of sociologists, television did not trivialize the news nor generate alienation and apathy. 
 Quite the contrary. 
 It did a particularly good job of informing people about the issues &mdash; especially if they were tabloid press readers, who could get relatively little information from the press; and it made electors feel more warmth and commitment to the party system and party leaders generally. 
 What it did not do was encourage people to discriminate between rival politicians and parties. 
 That remained much more a function of the press. 
 Also contrary to the speculations of media sociologists, television not only failed to determine what the electorate thought, it also failed to determine what they thought about , though it did communicate to the electorate what the parties were fighting about. 
 Television failed to &bquo;set the public agenda&equo; in 1987, though it succeeded in &bquo;communicating the party agenda&equo;. 
 Television's enormous shift of emphasis on to defence issues in the third week of the campaign correlated with a huge rise in the number of voters who saw defence as the Conservative Party's main campaign theme, but with only a modest rise in the number of who wanted a defence debate. 
 The switch of news focus clearly had some  influence on the public's agenda but a remarkably small one: in terms of television influencing the public's agenda the cause seemed much greater than the effect. 
 ONCE IN FOUR YEARS: THE FINDINGS 
 A major theme that ran through our findings was the enormous difference between election and non-election times. 
 In the midterm between elections interest in politics was much higher amongst highly educated voters and amongst regular readers of the quality press &mdash; the Guardian , the Telegraph , The Times , and similar papers. 
 But that was no longer true at election time: as the election approached the highly educated became less interested and the less well educated became more interested (Chapter 2). 
 Those who remained uninterested in politics reacted by avoiding the news during the campaign. 
 On any day towards the end of the campaign, those who had been very interested in politics just before the campaign opened were one and a half times as likely  to read a paper, and twice as likely to watch both BBC-TV and ITV news, as those with no interest in politics (Chapter 3). 
 As the election approached, voters' awareness of opinion polls became less dependent upon their interest in politics and on whether they read the highbrow press rather than the tabloids. 
 Instead it became more dependent upon how frequently they watched television news. 
 The same was true for the electorate's awareness of party leaders. 
 Even their awareness of second-rank leaders came to depend more upon television viewing though, in this case, no less upon their interest in politics and their access to the quality press. 
 Particularly at election time, television reached out and informed sections of the electorate which were usually much less well informed about politics. 
 Television reached those parts of the electorate that other high-quality news sources could not reach. 
 Also as the campaign drew to a close, partisan voters alleged more unfavourable  bias on television news and more favourable  bias in their daily papers. 
 No doubt both tendencies arose in part because the voters themselves became more strongly partisan at that time; but it also seems likely that television became more strictly impartial (thereby offending both Labour and Conservative partisans more) while the press became more stridently partisan (Chapter 6). 
 As the election approached readers of right-wing tabloids, particularly those who had had weak or non-existent party preferences in the mid-term, swung heavily towards the Conservatives while other readers did not. 
 Most of that swing occurred between our Mid-Term Wave of interviews in the early summer of 1986 and our Pre-Campaign Wave in March 1987. 
 During the final campaign itself swings in voting preferences were relatively small, but the change between the mid-term and election day was large. 
 Overall television fulfilled its public service role of informing the electorate, and did so particularly well as the election drew closer; while the press fulfilled its self-assigned role as pamphleteers within a libertarian system, and did so with increasing effect as the election drew closer.  
 PRESCRIPTIONS 
 Supporters of the Libertarian Ideal must be pleased by the degree of public satisfaction with the press despite public perceptions of press bias. 
 Indeed they must be pleased by the traces of evidence that suggest that bias in a freely chosen medium such as a newspaper is actually popular with the electorate rather than resented. 
 Similarly they must be pleased by the traces of evidence that suggest partisan voters find the relative impartiality of television news somewhat irritating. 
 They will advocate the deregulation of broadcasting and the proliferation of channels. 
 If they hoped that freedom would automatically bring intellectual variety and competition they must be disappointed with the press and pessimistic about the effects of deregulation on broadcasting, however. 
 Perhaps, for them, the introduction of a variety of deliberately partisan television channels might be a more attractive if less than perfect solution. 
 It would give the viewer freedom of choice, even if that freedom was not extended to the broadcasters. 
 It might require public subsidies to political parties to finance their own newspapers and television stations. 
 Alternatively, rival parties could be given control of different public television stations: so BBC 1 and Channel 4 might become &bquo;conservative-right wing&equo; channels while BBC 2 and ITV become &bquo;socialist-left wing&equo; channels, which could then compete for an audience. 
 The situation in some European countries approximates that model. 
 In Britain the idea of openly partisan broadcasting was pioneered by the Scottish Nationalists' clandestine and illegal Radio Free Scotland in the 1960s and more recently by Southern Sound, who used a discarded former commercial radio band to set up their entirely open and legal Conference Radio FM to cover the 1990 Conservative Party Conference from an unashamedly pro-Conservative viewpoint. 
 Supporters of the Public Service Ideal will be disappointed by our finding that television news is biased towards the incumbent government, and alarmed by our evidence that the tabloid press has such a powerful influence over its readers at election time. 
 For them, the solution to the problem of pro-government bias is simple: the broadcasters should treat government and governing party as one and the same, and give it the same coverage as the main opposition party. 
 The problem of an influential tabloid  press heavily biased towards one particular party is more difficult. 
 One solution would be to extend regulation to the press to ensure the same kind of impartiality as on television. 
 The Royal Commission rejected that solution as too oppressive, smacking of government censorship. 
 However, it would be possible to require all newspapers with a mass circulation (say, for example, half a million copies) to carry, without payment, the equivalent of television's Party Election Broadcasts &mdash; that is, pages of free advertising in the same party ratio as PEBs on television. 
 Sceptics may doubt whether anyone would read it but our survey shows that viewers take PEBs seriously and rate them only slightly less useful than news broadcasts for helping decide how to vote (though much less useful than news broadcasts for providing information). 
 That would not in any way restrict the paper's right to print whatever it wished in the rest of the paper. 
 Free and regulated newspaper advertising would also help to reduce the dependence of party politics on large trade union, business, or private donations; and the press could take some satisfaction, if no profit, from their public service contribution to an informed democracy. 
 Alternatively, the public service rules for television impartiality could be changed to require balance throughout the mass media as a whole. 
 The press would be left to adopt whatever political positions it wished, but television would be required to adjust its coverage to ensure that television plus the press, taken together, were politically balanced. 
 So when the press was biased towards the political right, television coverage would redress the balance by leaning to the left. 
 Conversely, if the press swung heavily to the left, television would have to reorient its coverage and redress the balance by leaning to the right. 
 (For an extended discussion of alternative approaches to media reform see Curran, 1986.) 
 These are radical suggestions which may seem impractical; but the status quo may be indefensible. 
 Satellite television stations under the control of press barons and modelled on the tabloid press may make inaction even more indefensible. 
 Those who support the Public Service Ideal could accept the combination of a polyarchic press putting forward a multitude of rival viewpoints and an impartial, balanced broadcasting monopoly. 
 That would produce both balance and variety in the media taken as a  whole. 
 But by the same logic they cannot accept the combination of a press controlled by a handful of publishers, overwhelmingly biased in one direction, and impartial, balanced broadcasting. 
 Still less can they accept impartial public broadcasting combined with a biased press and biased satellite television. 
 If balance is important it cannot be limited to public television. 
  National Insurance Statutory Sick Pay Statutory Maternity Pay from 6 April 1991 for employers Quick Guide New Easier to use For information or help, please call the Social Security Advice Line for Employers, free,  on 0800 393 539. 
 NI 268 from April 1991 Social Security  
 Contents 
 4 
 What should I use the Quick Guide for? 
 5 
 National Insurance 
 9 
 How do I make out contributions? 
 11 
 Any other questions? 
 14 
 Statutory Sick Pay 
 15 
 How do I prepare for SSP? 
 15 
 What should I do if an employee is off sick? 
 15 
 When do I not pay SSP? 
 16 
 What about the actual business of paying SSP? 
 17 
 How do I get my money back? 
 17 
 What SSP records must I keep? 
 17 
 Any other questions? 
 19 
 Statutory Maternity Pay 
 19 
 How do I prepare for SMP? 
 20 
 Who's eligible for SMP? 
 21 
 How do I get our money back? 
 22 
 What records are necessary? 
 22 
 Any other questions? 
 What should I use the Quick Guide for? 
 This guide tells you what you need to know and do about: 
 Class 1 National Insurance (NI) contributions  
 Statutory Sick Pay (SSP)  
 Statutory Maternity Pay (SMP) . 
 It replaces the April 1990 Quick Guide (NI 268). 
 You have been sent, with this guide, the following tables, to help you calculate NI contributions and benefits: 
 Not contracted-out Tables (CF 391 from April 1991) 
 SSP Tables (SSP 55 from April 1991) 
 SMP Tables (SMP 55 from April 1991) 
 If you have any problems, or would like fuller information and examples, please consult: 
 NI Manual (NI 269 from April 1991). 
 A copy was sent to you with this guide. 
 SSP Manual (NI 270 from April 1989). 
 SMP Manual (NI 257 from April 1990). 
 If you do not have these, or need further copies, please call your local Social Security office. 
 i 
 shows you where further information is available, should you need it. 
 NEW 
 This symbol indicates new or amended information. 
 For further help, call the Social Security Advice Line for Employers, free,  on 0800 393 539. 
 This publication is intended only as general guidance. 
 It is not a complete description of the law.  
 National Insurance 
 At a glance 
 National Insurance (NI) contributions are payments that go towards contributory benefits (such as Retirement Pensions) and the National Health Service. 
 Once you have started working with the Not contracted-out Tables, coupled with this Quick Guide, you'll find that, in the majority of cases, the business of working out Class 1 National Insurance (NI) contributions is straightforward. 
 In essence the system works like this: 
 &bull; 
 When you, as an employer, first take on an employee, you must tell the Inspector of Taxes, who then sets a Pay As You Earn (PAYE) scheme and sends you an &bquo;Employers' Starter Pack&equo;. 
 This contains all the necessary forms and information relating to PAYE tax and NI contributions. 
 &bull; 
 If employees are aged 16 or over and earn &pound;52 a week or more, you and your employee  will need to pay NI contributions. 
 &bull; 
 The Not contracted-out Tables show you how much to pay and what NI contribution information to record on the employee's Deduction Working Sheet (P11). 
 &bull; 
 If you pay your employees weekly, you use the weekly tables. 
 If you pay your employees monthly, you use the monthly tables. 
 &bull; 
 You must record personal details and NI numbers on each employee's P11. 
 You must also note on it the NI contributions and tax details each time an employee gets paid. 
 &bull; 
 Every month, you must complete and send a payslip from your payslip booklet P30 (AZ) (CL). 
 This goes to the Inland Revenue Accounts Office along with the NI contributions and tax deducted in the previous month. 
 &bull; 
 At the end of the tax year, you must complete an End-of-Year Return (P14) for each employee showing that employee's details and the total NI contribution and tax paid. 
 &bull; 
 You send P14s together with a completed Employer's Declaration (P35) to the Inspector of Taxes. 
 The final remittance of the tax year should be sent to the Inland Revenue Accounts Office together with a payslip. 
 &bull; 
 The calculations are, as you will see from the examples in this guide, simple to make and should not take much time. 
 If you have any problems, contact your Social Security office, or ring the Social Security Advice Line for Employers, free , on 0800 393 539. 
 NB  If you're more used to working with computers, you'll find that there's a wide choice of basic payroll software available. 
 New information can be incorporated as and when changes are made. 
 Contact your dealer for more information.  
 As an employer, you need to pay NI contributions for those employees aged 16 or over, who earn at or above what is known as the lower earnings limit, which stands at &pound;52 a week from 6th April 1991. 
 Class 1 NI are made up of the employer's share, which you pay, and the employee's share, which you can deduct from your employee's pay. 
 Employees' NI contributions are paid on earnings up to and including what is known as the upper earnings limit, which is &pound;390 a week from 6th April 1991. 
 There is, however, no upper earnings limit for your share. 
 NI contributions are calculated on a payment-by-payment basis according to the earnings period. 
 NI contributions are worked out on the gross pay, before all deductions. 
 The gross pay includes wages, overtime pay, arrears of pay, even superannuation. 
 i NI Manual, section 15. 
 Forms you'll need to use 
 P11 
 Deductions Working Sheet (see example, page 8). 
 For keeping weekly or monthly records. 
 P30 
 (AZ) (CL) Payslips. 
 Sent to you by the Inland Revenue and filled in by you monthly. 
 P35 
 Employer's Annual Statement, Declaration and Certificate. 
 Both this and the P14 must be returned at the end of the tax year (5th April 1992). 
 P14 
 End-of-Year Return (see example, page 10). 
 Make sure you use the latest version. 
 P60 
 Employee's Certificate of Pay, Income Tax and National Insurance contributions (this is part 3 of the P14). 
 This is given to every one of your employees on 5th April. 
 What is an earnings period? 
 This is the period for which your employee is paid. 
 For example, if you pay weekly, the earnings period is weekly, and so on. 
 Earnings periods for National Insurance match tax periods (this tax year is 6th April 1991 to 5th April 1992). 
 Sometimes, because your employee is paid at intervals which are not exact multiples of a week or a month, the earnings period may not match exactly with tax weeks or months. 
 Nevertheless, the first earnings period still starts on 6th April and the last period still ends on 5th April. 
 i NI Manual, section 2. 
 Does everyone have to have an NI number? 
 Yes, definitely. 
 So, before you can go any further you must ensure that, if NI contributions are due and your employees do not have a number, they obtain one. 
 The DSS gives NI numbers to all employees so that their NI contributions can be recorded on their personal NI accounts. 
 It is essential, therefore, that you show these numbers on all documents on which you record NI contributions.  
 NI numbers consist of two letters, six numbers and one letter. 
 For example, AQ 123456A. 
 Do not confuse the last letter of the NI number (which might be A, B, C or D) with an NI contribution table letter. 
 How do I get a number for my employee? 
 Employees must give you their NI number when you ask for it. 
 If they cannot, keep a separate record of their surname, forenames, date of birth, and address so that, if they leave before you get the number, you can give this information to your local Social Security office. 
 If an employee has forgotten his or her number, they should phone the Contributions Unit at the nearest local Social Security office for an application form. 
 If they have never had a number they must go personally with proof of identity. 
 i NI Manual, paragraph 36. 
 Who pays? 
 Earnings below the lower earnings limit (&pound;52 a week from 6th April 1991): 
 &bull; The employee pays NI contributions on earnings up to and including the upper earnings limit. 
 There is no upper earnings limit for employers, so you pay NI contributions on all your employee's earnings. 
 Earnings between the lower and upper earnings limits: 
 &bull; You and your employee pay NI contributions on all earnings, including those below the lower earnings limit. 
 At what rate are contributions paid? 
 &bull; The employee 
 NI contributions are normally paid at an initial percentage rate on all earnings up to and including the lower earnings limit, and at a main percentage rate on earnings between the lower and employee's upper earnings limit. 
 i Not contracted-out Tables, table A. 
 If your employee has the right to pay the married woman or widow's reduced rate NI contributions, she pays employee's NI contributions at a fixed reduced percentage rate on all earnings up to and including the upper earnings limit. 
 i Not contracted-out Tables, table B. 
 If your employee is over pension age, he or she pays no employee's NI contributions. 
 i Not contracted-out Tables, table C. 
 i Contracted-out occupational pension schemes: NI Manual, section 8 and Contracted-out Tables. 
 i NI contributions, people over pension age and contracting-out: NI Manual, paragraph 87. 
 &bull; The employer 
 Earnings are broken into bands called earnings brackets. 
 The percentage rates at which employer's NI contributions are paid depend on the band into which your employee's gross earnings fall. 
 Example: P11 
 You will need to keep and record a P11 for every one of your employees, as shown here. 
 i NI Manual, sections 3 and 16.   
 Which table 
 You will find the following tables in the Not contracted-out Tables. 
 Table A  (Standard rate) 
 Use this table for: 
 employees who are over age 16 and under pension age (65 men, 60 women) 
 employees who have their own appropriate personal pension (from July 1st 1988). 
 Table B  (Reduced rate) 
 Use this table for: 
 married women and widows who pay NI contributions at the reduced rate and for whom you hold a valid certificate. 
 i NI Manual, section 4 
 Table C 
 Use this table for: 
 employees who are over pension age (65 men, 60 women) including those previously contracted-out 
 employees who have made other arrangements to pay their contributions (i.e. those for whom a form RD950 is held). 
 Use the current tables at the time the payment is made. 
 Make sure you refer to the correct table: weekly  or monthly . 
 How do I work out contributions? 
 There are two methods: The exact percentage method . 
 For more details, see page 12. 
 The NI table method  involves using the Not contracted-out Tables, as follows: 
 Decide what is the right table (A, B, or C) to use. 
 Go to the weekly or monthly table 
 The tables show the contributions due according to the employee's gross weekly or monthly pay 
 If the exact gross pay is not in the table use the nearest lower figure and the contribution shown next to that lower figure 
 Write the amount due on a P11 
 Use a separate P11 for each employee to record earnings (table A only), NI contributions and SSP and SMP payments. 
 i Company Directors: National Insurance Fact Card (NI 274). 
 i Contracted-out occupational pension schemes: Contracted-out tables; NI Manual, section 8 and 16. 
 What am I expected to do on a regular basis? 
 At the end of each month 
 Within 14 days of the end of each income tax month you must pay to the Inland Revenue Accounts Office: 
 the NI contributions taken from your employee's earnings during that month 
 your own contributions 
 any income tax due. 
 You will be sent, by the Inland Revenue, a booklet containing payslips. 
 All you need to do is send one of these payslips with each month's payment. 
 One payment can cover both tax and NI contributions. 
 Follow the instructions on the payslips. 
 They tell you how to complete the payslips and how to pay. 
 Statutory Sick Pay (SSP) deductions 
 As from 6th April 1991, you can recover 80% of the total gross SSP paid to your employees in the tax month. 
 You must round the 80% calculation to the nearest penny. 
 Exact amounts of half a penny or less are rounded down. 
 Example: 
 Total SSP paid = &pound;141.38 x 80% = &pound; 113.104 = &pound;113.10 
 If SSP was due or paid before 6th April 1991 but you have not recovered it, you can still recover 100% of the SSP paid. 
 There is no National Insurance contributions (NIC) compensation on SSP from 6th April 1991. 
 But if SSP was due or paid before 6th April you can still recover the NIC compensation.  
 Example P14 
 Shown is an End-of-Year Return for an employee in not contracted-out employment paying standard-rate contributions.   
 Statutory Maternity Pay (SMP) deductions 
 You can recover 100% of SMP paid to your employees from the total NI contributions due for all your employees in the tax month. 
 You can also recover all SMP paid in previous months in the same tax year if you have not recovered it in an earlier month. 
 If you have not recovered SMP paid in an earlier tax year, please ask your local Social Security office. 
 you can also get back an extra percentage amount of NIC compensation on SMP. 
 i SMP tables 
 Example: 
 Total SMP paid = &pound;138 
 Recovery from NI contributions = &pound;138.00 total SMP plus &pound;6.21 (NI compensation at 4.5% of &pound;138). 
 i Recovering SSP and SMP: NI Manual, section 7. 
 At the end of the tax year 
 Employer's End-of-Year Return 
 Also known as the P14. 
 This must be completed for each employee . 
 The form is self-explanatory. 
 At the end of the tax year, simply enter the totals in the appropriate columns (they match those on the P11), along with the employee's details. 
 Employer's annual statement, declaration and certificate. 
 Known as a P35, this form is also self-explanatory. 
 It is a summary of all SSP and SMP paid, NI contributions and tax payable, for every employee. 
 You can get the total figures from a completed P14 or P32 (from April 1991). 
 Also show any NI contributions and tax still due to the Inland Revenue. 
 i NI Manual, sections 3 and 16. 
 In the case of a limited company, the secretary or a director should sign. 
 To whom should I send my P14 and P35 forms? 
 Having completed all P14 forms (or whichever substitute you are using), bundle Parts 1 and 2 separately and send both, together with the P35, to the Inspector of Taxes. 
 Bundle any alternative forms separately from any P14 forms. 
 If you use continuous stationery, please remove sprocket margins and separate the sheets clearly into individual documents for each employee. 
 Send also any balance NI contributions or tax due with a payslip, to the Inland Revenue Accounts Office. 
 What forms do I need to give to my employees? 
 At the end of every tax year, you will need to give every employee a P60 (Employer's Certificate of Pay, Income Tax and National Insurance contributions). 
 You will find this in Part 3 of the P14 form. 
 Information on the P60 corresponds with the totals taken from the P11. 
 Even if no tax has been paid, you need to issue a P60 if the employee has paid contributions and was working for you on 5th April. 
 How long should I hold on to records? 
 You should keep all your P11 forms and pay records for at least 3 years after the end of the tax year to which they relate, or longer if the Inland Revenue asks you to. 
 This applies even if your employees paid no contributions in a tax year. 
 i Using your own record sheets: NI Manual, paragraph 39. 
 Any other questions? 
 What should I do when an employee starts to work with us? 
 When you first pay your employee at or above the lower earnings limit of &pound;52 (from 6th April 1991), NI contributions are due. 
 Work out the contributions according to the normal earnings period (for example, weekly or monthly), even if the first payment covers less than that period. 
 Remember to use the contribution rates and earnings limits current at the date of payment, even though these may not be the same as those for the period the payment covers. 
 Do not count any earnings your employee may have received from other employment.  
 What should I do when an employee leaves? 
 i NI Manual, paragraphs 34 and 64. 
 What records do I need to keep? 
 For every employee, you must keep a record of the employee's name and NI number, and 
 their NI contribution table letter (which shows whether they must pay full, reduced rate or no contributions). 
 For every payment you must record: 
 its date 
 pay for tax purposes (gross pay including SSP and SMP, less any occupational pension contributions and allowable charitable gifts) 
 any occupational pension contributions 
 any allowable charitable gifts 
 where pension contributions or charitable gifts are deducted from pay for tax purposes, and keep a separate record of the amount of gross pay used for NI purposes. 
 Also record the pay figure for tax purposes on the P11 and P14. 
 For information on filling in a P11, please see page 8 of this guide. 
 i NI Manual, section 3 and 16. 
 What if I make a mistake? 
 The answer is simple: you can put it right in your next monthly payment, or when you pay any balance due at the end of the year. 
 If, however, you find you have made a mistake with contributions after your P14 (End-of-Year Return) has been sent to the Inspector of Taxes, you have two alternatives: 
 Before the tax year has ended, ask the Inland Revenue if you can still make an adjustment. 
 If it is too late, ask your local Social Security office. 
 After the tax year has ended, talk to your local Social Security office. 
 In neither case should you adjust your current payment to the Inland Revenue Accounts Office. 
 How do I use the exact percentage method? 
 An alternative way of calculating NI contributions is to use the exact percentage method instead of the tables. 
 To do this, apply the exact percentages (employees' and employers') to your employee's gross pay. 
 Each percentage calculation must be made separately. 
 Round each calculation to the nearest 1p (round down any amounts of &frac12;p, i.e. 
 0.0050 = &frac12;p). 
 Now, work out the employee's contributions: 
 at the initial percentage rate 
 and  at the main percentage rate (not contracted-out or contracted-out). 
 Round the calculation 
 then  add together the calculations to arrive at the employee's contribution. 
 In addition, you should work out your contributions, as an employer. 
 If you have to use more than one percentage rate because you have your own contracted-out occupational pension scheme, calculate each part separately and round each calculation. 
 i Current percentages, earnings limits and earnings brackets: Not contracted-out Tables or Contracted-out Tables. 
 What about contracted-out employment? 
 From 6th April 1991, there are important changes for married women and widows paying reduced rate NI contributions under contracted-out table E (or O for mariners). 
 i Contracted-out Tables and NI Manual section 8. 
 For other enquiries, contact the Contracted-out Employment Group, Contributions Agency, Newcastle upon Tyne NE98 1YX Telephone: 091&ndash;261 2341  
 What if I want to keep computerised records? 
 You can keep your own computerised records. 
 You can even make your returns on magnetic tape or floppy disc. 
 i NI Manual, paragraphs 141&ndash;42. 
 Or write to: 
 DSS Magnetic Media Recruitment Section Room D2914 Longbenton Newcastle NE98 1XY 
 Will I suffer a penalty on late returns? 
 Yes &mdash; if your End-of-Year Return (P14 or substitute) is submitted late. 
 Depending on the circumstances, you may also suffer a penalty if an underpayment of NI contributions and tax results from an omission from an omission from your End-of-Year Return. 
 Inland Revenue leaflet IR73 &bquo;Inland Revenue Investigations&equo;. 
 Any queries? 
 If you have any further queries on NI contributions, call the Social Security Advice Line for Employers, free , on 0800 393 539.  
 Statutory Sick Pay 
 As an employer, you are obliged to pay a minimum level of sick pay to most employees, aged 16 or over, who have been off sick for four or more days in a row. 
 This is called Statutory Sick Pay (SSP). 
 SSP is straightforward to operate and is paid by you, the employer, as if it were normal pay. 
 You can claim back 80% of it each month from your NI contributions or tax payments. 
 The weekly rate, from 6th April 1991, is &pound;52.50 (unchanged) or &pound;43.50, depending on the employee's average weekly earnings. 
 Employees who are not eligible for SSP can claim Sickness Benefit from the Department of Social Security (DSS). 
 SSP Terms 
 These are some of the terms you'll come across when you're dealing with SSP: 
 Period of incapacity for work (PIW) 
 This is a period of sickness lasting four or more days in a row. 
 Any period less than this, does not count for SSP. 
 Linking 
 Any two or more PIWs separated from each other by eight weeks or less are &bquo;linked&equo;, and treated as one PIW. 
 Qualifying days. 
 These are the only days for which SSP can be paid. 
 They are usually those days on which your employees are required by their contract to work for you. 
 Waiting days 
 SSP is not payable for the first three qualifying days in a PIW. 
 These are known as waiting days. 
 Forms you must use 
 SSP1 
 Changeover form. 
 Use this where your employee has not entitlement to SSP or where that entitlement has run out but he or she is still sick. 
 SSP1(L) 
 Leaver's statement. 
 Use this where your employee is leaving and has had at least four days' SSP in the last eight weeks of the contract. 
 Forms you may find helpful 
 SSP2 
 Record sheet. 
 This will help you to record all the details required by law. 
 SC2 
 Employee's Statement of Sickness. 
 You can ask your employee to fill this in for absences of between four and seven days. 
 These forms are available from your Social Security office.  
 How do I prepare for SSP? 
 Right from the start: 
 Tell your employees to phone or write if they're sick. 
 They may, if they wish, get someone else to tell you. 
 If they're sick for seven days or less, you may want them to fill in a form saying so. 
 This could be your own form or an Employee's Statement of Sickness (SC2). 
 You can ask them for a sick note from their doctor, but only if they have been away for more than seven days. 
 Make sure that you and your employees agree which are the their qualifying days for SSP. 
 These are the only days for which you can pay it. 
 They are normally working days. 
 For example, if someone usually works Monday through to Friday, these are the qualifying days. 
 If your employees have unusual working patterns, you can agree different qualifying days. 
 There must be at least one qualifying day in every week of an employee's contract. 
 i SSP Manual, paragraphs 9&ndash;12. 
 What should I do if an employee is off sick? 
 Is there a period of incapacity for work (PIW)? 
 First of all, has your employee been off sick for four or more days in a row? 
 This is known as a period of incapacity for work (PIW). 
 Count all days including Sundays and holidays. 
 If the answer is no, take no action. 
 If the answer is yes, you may have to pay SSP, but check first&hellip; 
 Does the PIW link with a previous one? 
 You can find the answer in the linking tables in your SSP 55. 
 Spells of sickness lasting four or more days in a row link and count as one PIW if separated by eight weeks or less. 
 This is important to know when working out whether you have to pay SSP, and how much. 
 What if it does link? 
 Check your records to see what you did at that time. 
 If you decided on the first day of the PIW you could not pay the SSP or that you had to stop paying SSP during the PIW, you employee cannot get SSP now. 
 In this case, fill in a Changeover form SSP1 and send it to your employee. 
 Keep a record of the employee's sickness and why you cannot pay SSP. 
 What if it doesn't? 
 Check whether any of the reasons for not paying SSP apply on the first day of the PIW. 
 These are listed below. 
 Be extra careful with new employees who have worked for you for eight weeks or less. 
 Please see page 17. 
 When do I not pay SSP? 
 SSP is not payable if on the first day of the PIW your employee: 
 is making average weekly earnings which are below the level at which NI contributions must be paid (&pound;52 from 6th April 1991). 
 If you're not sure what average weekly earnings are, see page 16 
 is a woman aged 60 or over, or a man aged 65 or over 
 is holding a contract of service for a specified three months or less 
 has a PIW which links with a Social Security benefit. 
 If you have a new employee, there are extra points to check: see page 17 
 cannot get SSP because of pregnancy 
 i SSP Manual, paragraph 63. 
 is not in the European Community 
 is away from work because of a trade dispute 
 is in legal custody 
 has already had 28 weeks' SSP with a previous employer 
 i SSP Manual, paragraph 59. 
 has not yet done any work for you 
 i SSP Manual paragraph 67 
 If any of the above apply on the first day of the PIW, do not pay SSP. 
 Fill in the Changeover form SSP1 and send it to your employee without delay.  
 Tell them to use the SSP1 if they want to claim sickness benefit. 
 Always keep a record of what you do. 
 When do I stop paying SSP? 
 You stop paying SSP when your employee is no longer sick, or when one of the following happens: 
 you stop employing him or her 
 your employee has had SSP for 28 weeks in the PIW 
 your employee goes outside the European Community 
 your employee goes into legal custody 
 your employee's PIW with you has lasted for more than three years 
 your employee can no longer get SSP from you because of pregnancy. 
 i SSP Manual, paragraphs 73&ndash;78. 
 If any of the above apply, do not pay SSP. 
 If your employee is still sick when you have to stop paying SSP, fill in the Changeover form SSP1 and send it to your employee without delay. 
 Tell them to use the SSP1 if they want to claim sickness benefit. 
 Always keep a record of what you do. 
 What about the actual business of paying SSP? 
 What days do I pay for? 
 You only pay for qualifying days. 
 These are usually the days when your employee works for you. 
 But you never pay SSP for the first three qualifying days of a PIW. 
 These days are known as waiting days. 
 Pay SSP from the fourth qualifying day in the PIW. 
 Example: 
 An employee is sick from Monday to Sunday. 
 The qualifying days are Monday to Friday. 
 No SSP is due for Monday to Wednesday. 
 These are the three waiting days. 
 Pay SSP for Thursday and Friday.  
 Remember, if a PIW links with a previous PIW there may not be any waiting days left to serve because waiting days are served only once in a PIW. 
 You can then start to pay SSP from the first qualifying day. 
 If you pay SSP when it is not due, you will have to make good any mistake. 
 How much do I have to pay? 
 There are two SSP rates, depending on your employee's average weekly earnings. 
 The rates from 6th April 1991 are: 
 &pound;43.50 a week for those earning between &pound;52 and &pound;184.99 or &pound;52.50 a week for those earning &pound;185 a week or more. 
 The daily rate of SSP is the weekly rate divided by the number of qualifying days in the week you are considering. 
 For SSP purposes the week always begins with Sunday. 
 And for how long? 
 SSP is payable for up to 28 weeks in a PIW, but most periods of sickness are over in three weeks. 
 How do I work out average weekly earnings? 
 If your employee is paid varying weekly amounts, or is paid monthly, you will need to calculate the average weekly earnings. 
 Use one of the following methods: 
 For weekly paid employees: 
 Add together the gross earnings on the last eight pay days before the start of the PIW and divide the total by eight. 
 The result is the employee's average weekly earnings. 
 If it is less than the level at which NI contributions must be paid, your employee cannot get SSP. 
 You must include all payments made on the eight calendar weeks. 
 If, on any of the pay days, your employee was not due any pay (for example, if wages had been paid in advance at holiday time), the &bquo;blank weeks&equo; are still included in the calculation. 
 For monthly paid employees: 
 Add together the gross payments made on the last normal pay day before the PIW began and any other payments made since the pay day which was at least eight weeks before that. 
 Multiply the total by 6 and divide by 52 or; 
 Where an employee is paid once each month, but in multiples of a week , for example on the last Friday of each month, add together the gross payments made on the last normal pay day before the PIW began and any other payments made since the pay day which was at least eight weeks before. 
 Then divide the total by the number of weeks covered by the payments. 
 i SSP Manual, paragraphs 84&ndash;87. 
 A helpful example 
 Your employee normally works for you from Monday through to Friday. 
 He or she is sick on Sunday and continues sick until the following Sunday. 
 What do you do? 
 First check whether there is a PIW (a spell of sickness lasting for four more days in a row). 
 Yes 
 Does the PIW link with a previous one? 
 No 
 Are there any reasons for not paying SSP? 
 (Check the lists on pages 15 and 16) 
 No 
 Identify the qualifying days in the week of sickness. 
 There are five, Monday to Friday 
 Stop the waiting days 
 These are Monday to Wednesday, the first three qualifying days in the PIW. 
 Pay SSP for the remaining qualifying days. 
 These are Thursday and Friday (Saturday and Sunday are non-qualifying days). 
 What rate do you pay? 
 &pound;52.50 or &pound;43.50 depending on your employee's average weekly earnings. 
 Deduct any tax and NI contributions due. 
 Record details of the PIW and SSP paid. 
 i Daily rate: SSP Tables. 
 How do I get my money back? 
 You can get back 80% of the total gross SSP you have paid in the tax month. 
 Simply deduct this from your NI contributions and tax which you send each month to the Inland Revenue. 
 See SSP deductions, page 9. 
 What SSP records must I keep? 
 If you wish, you can get a record sheet from the Department of Social Security to help you do this. 
 Ask for an SSP2. 
 You must keep records of: 
 all PIWs (periods of sick absence of four or more days in a row) 
 what days you have paid SSP for 
 how much SSP you have paid 
 reasons why you have not paid SSP. 
 You must give the total gross SSP payments you have made to each employee on your P14 End-of-Year Return. 
 You should also show the total gross SSP payments on a P35 form. 
 Any other questions? 
 ; What do I check if I've got a new employee? 
 If your new employee falls sick and has worked for you for eight weeks or less, check whether they have any of these linking letters from the Department of Social Security: BF218, BF220, BM7 or BM8 (or BF219 in Northern Ireland).  
 If they have, follow the guidance given on the form. 
 If this shows that no SSP is due, fill in the Changeover form  SSP1 and send it to your employee. 
 Keep a record of what you have done. 
 Alternatively, does your employee have a Leaver's statement  (SSP1&lsqb;L &rsqb); from a previous employer? 
 If so, check Date 2. 
 If this date is within eight weeks from the start of the PIW, you will not have to pay SSP for so long. 
 i SSP Manual, paragraph 44. 
 If the employee has been working for you for up to eight weeks and does not have a linking letter or a Leaver's statement, phone your Social Security office and ask if the start of the PIW you are dealing with links back to a claim to a Social Security benefit. 
 What should I do when an employee leaves? 
 If your employee is sick during the last eight weeks before leaving and you have paid SSP for more than three days you have to fill in a Leaver's statement SSP(L). 
 You can get this form from your Social Security office. 
 You must give this form to your employee . 
 i SSP Manual, paragraph 51. 
 What if we have our own sick pay scheme? 
 If you already have your own company sick pay scheme, it must pay the employee at least what he or she would have been entitled to on SSP. 
 If not, you are obliged to top it up to the statutory level.  
 Statutory Maternity Pay 
 SMP is normally paid by you to an employee who is away from work to have a baby. 
 You can get back any SMP you have paid from your normal NI contributions or tax payments. 
 You can also get back an additional amount as compensation for the NI contributions you have paid on SMP. 
 Abbreviations and terms 
 EWC 
 Expected Week of Confinement. 
 QW 
 Qualifying Week. 
 Fifteen weeks before the EWC. 
 MPP 
 Maternity Pay Period. 
 The period of up to eighteen weeks during which SMP can be paid. 
 Forms you may need to use 
 MATB1 
 Maternity Certificate. 
 A pregnant employee will be given this by a doctor or midwife. 
 SMP1 
 For employees not entitled to SMP. 
 Available from your local Social Security office. 
 SMP2 
 Record sheet (optional). 
 How do I prepare for SMP? 
 Make sure that your employees know: 
 they must tell you at least 21 days before they plan to take maternity leave. 
 You can ask for notification in writing if you wish. 
 i SMP Manual, paragraph 8. 
 they must normally give you notice in person. 
 If this is not possible, you should accept notice given on their behalf. 
 what sort of medical evidence you will need in order to decide whether you can pay SMP or not. 
 In addition, you should keep a supply of form SMP1 which you will need to give to those employees who cannot get SMP from you. 
 These forms are available from your local Social Security office.  
 &bull; What do I do if an employee says she is expecting a baby? 
 Before you can work out if SMP is payable, you will need medical evidence of the date the baby is due. 
 This will normally be on form MAT B1 (maternity certificate) which your employee will get from her doctor or midwife. 
 You can, however, accept other medical evidence. 
 i SMP Manual, paragraph 9. 
 Next, consult Column 1 of your SMP Tables to find the expected week of confinement  (the week in which the baby is expected). 
 Column 2 against this will tell you the qualifying week , which is fifteen weeks before the baby is due. 
 Check your records to make sure that your employee was employed by you at some time during that week. 
 If she was not, she cannot get SMP from you unless she was &bquo;fairly dismissed&equo;. 
 i SMP Manual, paragraph 13. 
 Who's eligible for SMP? 
 You have to pay SMP to any woman who has been continuously employed by you for at least 26 weeks into the qualifying week and whose average weekly earnings  are at least equal to the lower earnings limit for NI contributions which applied in the qualifying week . 
 How do I work out average weekly earnings? 
 If your employee is paid varying weekly amounts, or if she is paid monthly, you need to calculate her average weekly earnings. 
 Use one of the following methods: 
 For weekly paid employees: 
 Add together gross earnings on the eight pay-days up to and including the last pay-day before the end of the qualifying week (QW) and divide the total by 8. 
 The result is the employee's average weekly earnings. 
 If it is less than the lower earnings limit which applied in the QW, your employee cannot get SMP. 
 You must include all payments actually made in those eight calendar weeks. 
 If on any of the pay-days, your employee did not get any pay (for example, if wages had been paid in advance at holiday time), the &bquo;blank weeks&equo; are still included in the calculation. 
 For monthly paid employees: 
 Add together the gross payments made on the last normal pay-day before the end of the QW and any other payments made after the pay-day which was at least eight weeks before that. 
 Multiply the total by 6 and divide by 52 
 Where your employee is paid once a month but is paid in multiples of a week  (for example, on the last Friday of each month), add together the gross payments made on the last pay day before the end of the QW and any other payments made after the pay day at least eight weeks before that. 
 Divide the total by the number of weeks covered by the payments. 
 i SSP Manual, paragraphs 84&ndash;87. 
 If it is less than the lower earnings limit which applied in the QW, your employee is not entitled to SMP. 
 i Payment at other intervals: SMP Manual, paragraph 32. 
 How much SMP do I pay? 
 There are two rates of SMP. 
 The lower rate 
 If your employee has been employed by you for a continuous period of at least 26 weeks into the qualifying week, regardless of the number of hours worked, she is eligible for lower rate SMP. 
 The rate from 7th April 1991 is &pound;44.50 a week. 
 An employee who qualifies only for the lower rate of SMP is entitled to it throughout the Maternity Pay Period of up to 18 weeks.  
 The higher rate 
 If your employee was employed by you for a continuous period of at least two calendar years into the qualifying week and normally worked 16 hours or more a week, she is eligible for the higher rate of SMP. 
 Alternatively, if she has been employed by you for a continuous period of at least five calendar years into the qualifying week for 8 hours or more each week, then she is also eligible. 
 The higher rate is 90% of your employee's average weekly earnings. 
 If your employee qualifies for the higher rate, it should be paid for the first six weeks that higher rate SMP is due. 
 For the remaining weeks, you pay her at the lower rate of &pound;44.50 a week. 
 At what point do I start paying SMP? 
 Normally, the Maternity Pay Period (MPP) cannot start before the eleventh week before the expected week of confinement (EWC). 
 A woman has some say as to when her MPP starts. 
 She must, however, give up work before the start of the sixth week before the EWC  if she is to get SMP for the full eighteen weeks. 
 SMP is payable for up to 18 weeks unless the woman goes abroad outside the European community, is taken into legal custody, or returns to work. 
 i SMP Manual, paragraphs 20&ndash;28. 
 How exactly do I pay SMP? 
 Pay SMP in the same way that you would normally pay your employee's wages. 
 Remember that SMP is subject to NI contributions and tax. 
 A helpful example 
 Your employee gives you a maternity certificate (such as MAT B1) showing the date her baby is expected. 
 What do you do? 
 Find the expected week of confinement (EWC) in Column 1 of SMP Tables, and the qualifying week (QW) in Column 2. 
 Was she employed by you in the QW? 
 She was 
 Has she been employed by you for at least 26 weeks into the QW? 
 She has 
 Were her average weekly earnings (see page 20) equal to or above the lower earnings limit? 
 They were 
 She is entitled to SMP 
 Has she been employed by you into the QW for at least two years (full-time) or for five years (part-time)? 
 She has 
 Higher rate of SMP is payable for the first six weeks of her absence. 
 Did her maternity absence start more than six weeks before the EWC? 
 It did 
 SMP is payable for 18 weeks. 
 How do I get our money back? 
 You can get back the gross amount of SMP you have paid out, plus an additional amount (4.5% of the total gross SMP from 6th April 1991) as compensation for the NI contributions you have paid on SMP. 
 All you have to do is deduct both amounts from your monthly NI and tax payments.  
 What records are necessary? 
 &bull; 
 Any maternity certificate such as MAT B1 given to you by employees for whom you paid SMP. 
 &bull; 
 A copy of the maternity certificate where the original has been returned to the employee, for example, where your liability for SMP has ended. 
 &bull; 
 Dates of maternity absence notified by your employees. 
 &bull; 
 Any weeks within the maternity pay period for which SMP was not paid, with reasons. 
 If you wish, you can get a record sheet (form SMP2) from your Social Security office. 
 You need to: 
 &bull; 
 record SMP payments in Column 1g on your employee's P11 
 &bull; 
 show the total SMP payments on your employee's P14 
 &bull; 
 show total gross SMP payments and the total amount of NI contributions (NIC) compensation on a P35. 
 Any other questions? 
 What if an employee works during the Maternity Pay Period (MPP)? 
 You cannot pay SMP for any week in which your employee works for you. 
 She will lose one week's SMP for each week or part-week that she works during her MPP. 
 SMP which is lost in this way is at the lower rate first. 
 i Working for someone else or other changes in circumstances: SMP Manual, paragraphs 50&ndash;52. 
 What if we have our own maternity pay scheme? 
 If you already pay your employee any money while she receives SMP, for example, occupational maternity pay, this will count towards your SMP payment for the same week. 
 i Offsetting SMP: SMP Manual, paragraph 44. 
 What if an employee is not entitled to SMP? 
 If your employee is not entitled to SMP, you need to complete form SMP1 and give it to her together with any maternity certificate which she may have given you. 
 Keep a record of what you did. 
 i Disputes about entitlement: SMP Manual, paragraphs 55&ndash;61. 
 What if I make a mistake? 
 i SMP Manual, paragraphs 68&ndash;74. 
 The West  
 THE Western borderlands of Soviet Russia were the nearest to Moscow of all frontier regions, yet they were relatively neglected by historians and travellers alike. 
 Even by 1926 party contacts between the capital and Smolensk were to remain mostly at the written rather than at the human level. 
 Arnold Toynbee once argued that it is the &bquo;barbaric&equo; vital periphery that finally topples a declining civilization, but this maxim does not hold for the Russian Revolution. 
 The political centre suffered a series of heart attacks from 1905 onwards, of which the body of society as a whole was only to become fully aware after 1928. 
 Despite Lenin's theory of national self-determination, the new Soviet Union still embraced the great bulk of the old imperial domains, including minorities like the Georgians and the Ukrainians who had been civilized for centuries before the denizens of what was to become Muscovy. 
 After the Civil War Bolshevik control expanded easily from its bastion which had been reduced to the size of medieval Muscovy. 
 The Tambov revolt and other peasant disturbances were soon contained and squashed. 
 This does not mean that the vast provinces of Russia should be ignored, although they usually are. 
 The idea of centre is deeply rooted in the human mind. 
 The concept of a national centre has been a hierarchical mental device used by historians since the Reformation to over-simplify the chaos of diverse local stimuli. 
 In primitive societies with small, self-sufficient units there was no differentiation between centre and periphery, and it could be argued that many peasants in Russia remained at  this level of perception during NEP. 
 Yet urban, industrial polarization had already developed to a considerable degree before 1917, creating awareness of the political centre among the more sophisticated peasant strata such as village teachers, zemstvo clerks, bookkeepers, doctors' and veterinarians' assistants. 
 E. D. Vinogradoff has shown how local agrarian social and economic conditions shaped the collective political behaviour of peasants elected to the Fourth State Duma. 
 This was clearly the case in the Central Agricultural Region, which we shall consider in Chapter 2. 
 The difficulty is that its traditional features &mdash; communal tenure, a three-field system, and growing land pressure &mdash; have often served as all-Russian criteria, but they did not apply to the West. 
 Prior to 1917 most Belorussian peasant farms had belonged to individual families and had averaged less than 20 acres. 
 The small upper class &mdash; mainly Polish and Russian &mdash; had owned most of the land. 
 When this class disappeared in the Revolution, the peasants increased their landownership to 28 per cent more than they had before 1917. 
 Pressure was reduced further by state funds applied in 1922 to the improvement of the large marshy areas. 
 The Central Region also lacked those national and religious minorities whose commonly held views in some borderlands had bridged the psychological gap between town and country and had led to the formation of political parties after 1905. 
 Agrarian, ethnic, and religious influences will be examined here, but in the post-revolutionary situation they all had negative rather than active political influence on the conduct of high politics. 
 That an atheist regime was likely to take scant notice of advice based on religious preference is self-evident. 
 Less obvious is the indifference to ethnic variations, despite the fact that Belorussian nationalism was itself weak. 
 Moscow also neglected agrarian provincial variations even in the liberal conditions of early NEP. 
 Yet negative influences, so long as they were sufficiently weighty and cumulative, could have  enormous effects on the formulation of all-Russian policies. 
 This proved to be the case by the end of NEP. 
 The only positive line of local-central political communication was the Bolshevik Party network. 
 We shall see how much or how little of local nuances it succeeded in conveying to the top authorities. 
 Let us begin at the roots of this multifarious society. 
 In january 1922 79.29 per cent of the entire population of the ex-Empire, estimated at 133,890,100, lived in European Russia; 77.3 per cent of all inhabitants lived in the countryside. 
 Thus it is clear that our typical inhabitant is a peasant living in European Russia. 
 In a village somewhere in the uezd  of Roslavl' in the southwest of the Smolensk guberniia a peasant mother rises at dawn in the spring of 1922 on hearing the passing herdsman drum on his barabanka , a cast-iron drum. 
 She has slept in her clothes as usual, so she reaches at once for her birch-bark pail ( podoinik ) with its removable lid and spout for pouring out the milk once she has returned from milking her cow, or two cows if she is rich. 
 It has been calculated that in 1922 an average of 38 minutes would be spent on going to work and coming back, with a working day of between 14 and 15 hours in the warmer months. 
 The second job of the day is to light the stove, a monument in itself, taking up a quarter of the thatched hut with its various extensions &mdash; a sill ( pod ) with an area for keeping dishes warm ( chestok ), niches ( pechurki ) for small objects and matches, holes on the side for drying out leg and foot wrappings (for lack of shoes), holes near the summit for reviving chilled hens in winter, and on the triumphal summit worn clothing on which to stretch out and sleep in the delicious warmth &mdash; &bquo; U hholodnoi pechi ne sogreesh'sia &equo; (&bquo;You can't heat yourself at a cold stove&equo;). 
 Diagonally opposite the stove is the icon corner, although for a Belorussian peasant the most sacred spot is the stove column, where the souls of predecessors reside. 
 Together with the first harvest sheaf hanging beside the icon  for its protective magic, these are reminders that our peasant lives in several cultural times simultaneously, one of them embedded deep in the pagan past, another in the religious present, a third focused on the trip she is about to take to the town of Roslavl'. 
 And away and above her imagination lie the remote worlds of elegant Petrograd, and of Moscow, the city of the Communist future as well as of her inherited religious past. 
 After making first animal feed ( korm ) and only later cabbage soup ( shchi ) for the family, she may finally turn to the work that occupies the womenfolk from November until Lent &mdash; spinning flax from that blue-flowered, frail-leaved plant plucked by the root in handfuls in the August of 1921. 
 The thread is spooled on an enormous reeling-machine ( nituchha ) before being woven on a primitive loom into mens' shirts and trousers, household linen and curtains ( pologa ) to protect the sleeper from the mosquitoes that are so prevalent in the marshes of the western plains. 
 When the women gossip at their looms, they do not speak Tolstoy's pure peasant Russian, but a dialect that differs from one village to the next. 
 Here in Struga they speak what they call &bquo; struskii &equo;, a hotchpotch of Belorussian, Russian, and Ukrainian. 
 It would be mental laziness to assume that each national minority was more of a unity than the ex-empire as a whole. 
 Innumerable subcultures split up by language, region, class, religion, generation, type of work, and sex existed within Belorussia alone. 
 Women lived a different cultural, economic, and political life from men in the 1920s, as will be seen in more detail when we return to this area and topic in 1926. 
 Our peasant is starting off today to Roslavl', 55 miles away, in order to see her soldier son who has been away in the Civil War, and is passing with his peacetime unit by train tomorrow from Briansk further south to the city of Smolensk with an hour's stop in Roslavl'. 
 She knots up some girdle-cakes  ( lep&euml;shki ) in a kerchief and plunges through the thick spring mud of the village track to the river Iput' near by where she catches one of several small boats plying to Volga, a market town on the way to Roslavl'. 
 The next day she transfers to the much slower cart ( telega ) which arrives in the late afternoon in Roslavl', a bustling railway-town. 
 She buys some soap and ribbons in the market, where she notes the huge rise in prices since her last visit. 
 The gossip flows in, as at all meeting-places in a largely illiterate environment. 
 She gathers that she has been lucky on her journey to avoid the widespread banditry, carried out more often than not by deserters from the army. 
 Her son had better stay within the ranks, she thinks. 
 Another danger she must avoid is the typhus still raging in the town. 
 She hurries to the railway station. 
 Near chaos prevails here. 
 A group of people have just been arrested by the railway Cheka for trying to travel without tickets, yet our peasant notes how the wife of a Roslavl' party member flourishes an authorization for a free pass typed out on a Tsarist form. 
 It is clear to her that the old ropes are still being pulled by the new masters. 
 She wonders if she will in fact see her son, since a tender has come off the track down the line. 
 She knows from home that many trains do not run because thousands of peasants have not been paid for hauling wood to the engine fuel-dumps for the whole of 1920&ndash;1, and so have refused to carry on. 
 In fact the son's military train, despite the fact that it has priority (a hangover from the days of the armoured trains), only passes through on the following day, when his mother has left. 
 On the platform he picks up the local rumours. 
 The  Roslavl' party cell is thinking of recruiting up to seventy-five soldiers from the town garrison in order to collect potatoes from the area as a tax in kind. 
 He is glad that at least he will not be pitted against his own class in this way. 
 His pay is appallingly low and one month in arrears, and yet he hears that the local party is about to mobilize by force peasants aged between 20 and 40 for the army. 
 He fears a further decline in peasant confidence in the Bolsheviks. 
 In the voting for the Constituent Assembly during the winter of 191 7 his vote, together with that of many thousands of other ex-front soldiers and their wives and neighbours, had given the Bolsheviks healthy rural support. 
 On arrival at Smolensk, our peasant soldier discovers that all the equipment of his unit has been embezzled or stolen from the luggage-van. 
 To make matters worse, he finds that his unit has been brought to Smolensk in order to organize the procurement and protection of wood at local timber yards and fuel dumps. 
 All recalcitrant peasants are to be arrested, and the Presidium of the Smolensk gubispolkom  (the party executive committee) has put the campaign &bquo;on wartime footing&equo;. 
 Shades of Trotsky's labour armies, he and his comrades murmur between themselves when the political commissar leaves them. 
 In 1922 the capital of the guberniia could hardly be called a bastion of the proletariat. 
 The nearest useful census is for 1923, when the total population of Smolensk was only 63,669 of which a mere 15.1 per cent were workers. 
 Like the population of all the cities of European Russia, it suffered a decline (from 72,559 in 1917 to 56,826 in 1920). 
 This was far less dramatic  than in a much larger city like Petrograd. 
 At the turn of the century industrial production in Belorussia had been half that of the average for Russia as a whole. 
 The area was thus unusually weighted towards agriculture, but it was only an exaggeration of the normal situation in all provincial regions. 
 Throughout NEP Russia remained plunged in a largely preindustrial society, conditioned far more by its natural environment (of marshes, flax, large forests in Belorussia) than by its few industrial cities. 
 By the end of 1923 only 12,323 persons were engaged in all of Soviet Belorussian industry, compared with 23,438 railway-workers. 
 Belorussian industrial capacity had been split in half by the World War and its consequences. 
 Western Belorussia still lay under Polish control, with its heavier concentrations of textile-workers. 
 In 1922 10,000 textile-operatives in the Belostok region of Western Belorussia struck under the influence of the Polish Communist Party. 
 Ironically, and not for the last time in history, the Communist-inspired proletariat had more clout outside the Soviet borders than within. 
 Given Russia's high latitudinal position, her short farming season, low productivity, absence of markets, and scant incentives for yield improvement in the late Tsarist period and until the advent of NEP, the natural result was a strong peasant urge to supplement agricultural income by promysly  (craft industries), one of which was the production and working up of flax for the kustarnyi  industry. 
 The latter was defined by Soviet terminology in the 1920s as all establishments producing goods for more than one household but employing thirty wage-earners or less; or if motive power was used, fifteen wage-earners or less. 
 The accent on rural industry had actually increased heavily over the years prior to 1922. 
 The chaotic transport situation did not harm it, since it had access to local raw materials and fuel. 
 The clothing industry, including flax, had flourished because it supplied both the Tsarist and the Red  Armies which trampled through Belorussia. 
 There were also other reasons for the growing importance of small-scale industry during the Civil War and NEP. 
 The famine of 1919&ndash;21 forced industrial workers back to the countryside, where they proceeded to apply their skills, encouraged by the local peasantry, thwarted by the lack of industrial consumer goods from the towns. 
 The loss of the Polish and Baltic provinces, which had supplied the Russian market with a large quantity of consumer goods, also served to increase the dependence of the Soviet population on the kustari, particularly in the west. 
 The 1897 census had listed 20,000 kustari for the six Belorussian provinces of that period. 
 By the end of 1922 the number rose to 33,800 for Soviet Belorussia, a smaller area. 
 This figure was 2.7 times higher than for employees in large-scale industry. 
 Their volume of production was one and a half times greater, and they were engaged chiefly in clothing, woodwork, skins, and agricultural repairs. 
 During the war years 480 large and small-scale industrial enterprises had been knocked out in Belorussia. 
 A further huge reduction of about 80 per cent in the labour force had taken place since the introduction of khozraschet  at the start of NEP. 
 Throughout Russia heavy industry suffered the most. 
 Whereas the national monthly output of iron-ore had sunk from 45.87 million pudy  in 1913 to 0.98 by September 1922, and cast-iron from 21.43 to 0.94, flax yarn had only sunk from 0.236 to 0.104. 
 This set-back meant that flax prices went up steeply in 1922 to meet demand, and sowing increased sharply in the autumn, bringing quick prosperity to parts of Belorussia. 
 Another consumer industry of prime importance to this area, paper, recovered very rapidly during 1922, in the effort to supply the hungry central bureaucracies and cultural institutions which had been sorely deprived. 
 Yet until 1923  much pulp had to be imported from abroad in view of the atrocious transport situation in Belorussia and the chaotic state of the timber industry. 
 Capital investment in Belorussian industry, centred on Smolensk, was only 485,000 roubles in 1922, but this was stepped up by 271 per cent in 1923. 
 On average workers' pay in Belorussia had dropped by 1922 to 73.5 per cent of the 1913 level, but in 1923 it was to rise to 112.5 per cent. 
 In the first half of 1921 nearly all workers and state employees had been paid almost entirely in kind but by june 1922 66 per cent came in the form of cash. 
 The best-paid workers in Belorussia were in the bristle industry. 
 Metal-workers, the vanguard of the 1917 proletarian revolution in Petrograd, here received two-thirds less than bristle-workers, and flax-workers, most of them unqualified and women, earned four-fifths less. 
 Private firms paid up to 28 per cent of wages towards social insurance for their workers, whereas state concerns contributed between 15 and 19.5 per cent. 
 By the end of 1922 many relatives of war casualties began to receive small social-welfare payments. 
 Yet. 
 in all Belorussia there were only 1,669 hospital beds. 
 Such was the frail nature of the Belorussian working class, cut off from its metropolitan Russian brothers by a broad sea of peasants. 
 Now it is time to consider the area's ethnic relationship as a whole to the Great-Russian heartland. 
 Subsequently, three themes of great concern both to the local population and to the political authorities in Smolensk and Moscow will be treated &mdash; taxation, religion, and cultural and political education. 
 In the course of this book we shall come across other national minorities: the Ukrainians and the Kazakhs in our tour of the provinces, and the Georgian question at the more theoretical level of high politics. 
 At the outset it may prove useful, if only to discover differences rather than similarities, to contrast Great-Russian nationalism with French. 
 Both nations were highly centralized, and both underwent fundamental revolutions, but their geographical scale and relationship to national minorities were  very different. 
 After 1789 politicians were the main architects of French nationalism, but in Russia at the start of NEP Marxist internationalism and Trotsky's theory of permanent revolution still imbued most leading Bolsheviks, with the significant exception of Stalin, whose treatment of Georgia in 1922 was to shock Lenin. 
 French patriotism had been whipped Up through the antics of her revolutionary armies abroad, but the Russian Civil War had no effect of this kind. 
 For the most part Great Russians were fighting Great Russians, and in the process trampled over the lands of peasants, whether Russian, Belorussian, Ukrainian, etc., none of whom was more inclined thereafter to feel particularly attracted to Muscovite patriotism. 
 Moreover Lenin held the view from Babeuf via Marx that regular armies should be abolished, thus reducing the danger of the nationalistic Bonapartism that overcame France. 
 The second chief instrument of French post-revolutionary nationalism was her culture as disseminated through her educational institutions. 
 In the early Soviet period, until well after Stalin's introduction of the notion of &bquo;Socialism in one country&equo;, state education was rigorously infused with those same ideas of proletarian internationalism that influenced military circles. 
 Much of Russia's traditional culture was still rejected in early NEP. 
 What little remained of it had never rejoiced in the calm self-assurance of the French, who had equated their race with civilization. 
 Paris was the world's cultural capital in their eyes, but Russia suffered alternately from a deep-rooted inferiority complex, saddled with two cultural capitals looking away from each other towards Asia and Europe; or from an unstable Messianic superiority complex, derived from Byzantium via Dostoevsky and now resurrected phoenix-like by the Bolsheviks under a new guise. 
 The results of this brief comparison may surprise those Whig interpreters of Soviet history who read back into it before its time the dominant Great-Russian nationalism of the 1930s. 
 The only glimmer of it in early NEP was, ironically, the attitude of one Georgian, Stalin, towards his own national birthplace. 
 Nothing had changed radically between shortly before 1917 and 1922 to cause any further deterioration in non-Russian &mdash; Russian relationships. 
 As before 1917, so by 1922 the central political authority still mingled quite closely, at least  in the European provinces, on territorial and cultural grounds with the minorities, whether in Belorussia or the Ukraine. 
 Indeed the three languages were very close to each other. 
 The Bolsheviks proved in the Civil War that they could defend the minorities just as well, or indeed better than the Tsarist regime had done in the Great War. 
 One type of authoritarian rule had been followed by another, not allowing for that kind of unsettling liberalization which is so conducive to uprisings among minorities. 
 The Bolsheviks at least promised to tackle regional socio-economic backwardness, and their bureaucratic intervention in the localities was at first less oppressive in some ways than in the Tsarist past simply for lack of personnel. 
 The relatively relaxed stance of most of the leading Bolsheviks, many of whom in any case were themselves not Great Russians, was met at least half-way by the malleable reactions of the Belorussians. 
 A leading Western authority on the reincorporation of the nationalities into the Soviet Union opined that of all the minorities the Belorussians had the weakest urge to set themselves apart. 
 In purely practical terms the largest population in Belorussia after the indigenous inhabitants remained from the 1897 to the 1926 census the Jews and not the Russians. 
 Prior to the Revolution there was scant institutional evidence of deep-rooted nationalist sentiment. 
 There were no institutions of higher learning except for an obscure agricultural college in Mogilev province. 
 The very few secondary schools and the rare rural schools gave lessons in Russian only, on general Russian lines. 
 Belorussia had the lowest literacy rate among all the peoples of European Russia. 
 Without going into the intricacies of Belorussia's fate between 1917 and 1921 (she was occupied in turn by Germans, Poles, and Russians, and there were three successive Soviet governments), a few salient points may serve to show the indifference of all the four nationalities involved to Belorussian national claims. 
 In 1917 the Belorussian National Committee,  a hotchpotch of indecisive and divided intellectuals, eventually mustered sufficient unity to send demands to Petrograd, only to be nullified by the differing views of the Petrograd- and Moscow-based Belorussian groups (intimations of those wider cultural and political differences between the twin capitals which are taken up in a later chapter). 
 Abstract theorizing continued in Moscow and Petrograd, unrelated to the practical needs and wishes of the ordinary Belorussian back at home. 
 As a result, in the first free elections in the spring of 1917 to the zemstvo  and municipal Belorussian governments, not a single nationalist representative won any popular support. 
 If this tendency to ratiocinate in central isolation was already rife by 1917 in the microcosmic situation of the Belorussians, how much greater were the potential dangers for the future of the Bolsheviks' wider theories as applied to the all-Russian macrocosm. 
 At least, after the outcome of the Civil War and the suppression of all other parties, the Bolsheviks no longer feared non-election. 
 When the Germans invaded Belorussia in February 1918, they paid no attention to nationalist aspirations. 
 After the Polish invasion of April 1919, Belorussia was said to be historically an inalienable part of the Polish Commonwealth. 
 The local landowners were reinstated and Polish introduced as the official language. 
 At the end of 1919 Lenin showed Russian indifference by offering virtually all of Belorussia to Poland in order to stave off a Polish offensive, but the most telling instance of Russia's attitude had already occurred after the German withdrawal in December 1918, when the Northwestern Regional Committee of the Russian  Communist Party held a conference at Smolensk. 
 It blithely renamed itself the Belorussian Party. 
 When even Belorussian Communists complained, they were told that &bquo;the majority could not form a faction&equo;. 
 The majority cited was not in fact the Belorussian Communists, since Russians predominated: the reference was to the Belorussian ethnic majority in the republic's population. 
 The final Russian snub, though it does not appear to have been taken as such by the Belorussians, came in January  1921 when the Belorussian SSR was constituted. 
 It was confined to a small border strip of 20,000 square miles and 1,500,000 inhabitants, encompassing Roslavl' and Smolensk, but excluding important districts centred on Vitebsk, Gomel, and Mogilev which were incorporated into the RSFSR. 
 Over the last two centuries minority unrest has often stemmed from a thwarted intelligentsia impatient for power and capable of perceiving its nationality's relative backwardness. 
 However energetic such a group may be, it has to draw on popular ethnic support. 
 Its traditional ally, newly settled city-dwellers, were almost completely lacking in Belorussia, as we have seen. 
 The peasant grass-roots culture that has been examined briefly here was too local in scope, too illiterate, to line up strongly with the intelligentsia. 
 Two authorities on this question disagree with each other, the one claiming little or no contact, the other maintaining that some Belorussian intellectuals appealed to the peasant masses throughout the 1920s by proclaiming the Bezburzhuaznost'  (the non-existence of a bourgeoisie) of the whole nation. 
 On the positive side one could cite the wider political knowledge acquired by a territory invaded on all sides during 1917&ndash;21, so that at least the many peasants, caught up in military life, like our travelling soldier, might acquire broader interests. 
 On the negative side it should be recalled that many Belorussian nationalists were more pro-Western than specifically Belorussian in their emphasis, while many others became so identified with the Bolshevik Party that they shed earlier inclinations. 
 On balance Voltaire's maxim that the poor could have no patrie  probably still held sound for the vast majority of Belorussian peasants in early NEP. 
 Their main foe, irrespective of his nationality, was the tax-collector, and their main ally, if only they knew it, the educator, irrespective of whether he spoke Russian or Belorussian. 
 The only widespread bond that clearly separated some of them from Russians was their Catholicism, but it also separated them from fellow Belorussians. 
 We shall turn to these three themes shortly, but finally the relatively smooth course of Russian-Belorussian collaboration  during NEP should be underlined. 
 One of the liberalizing facets of NEP was the effort to reconcile the Bolsheviks and local nationalists, and even Stalin endorsed it. 
 This era of mild concessions to Belorussian culture impressed Belorussians amongst the diaspora abroad who continued to believe that a truly democratic system might yet emerge. 
 Only towards the end of the 1920s did the central regime start to suppress Belorussian cultural institutions, and it was not until 1933 that general persecution of nationalism became prevalent in the area. 
 Religious rather than political beliefs permeated the everyday lives of both Russian and national minority peasants. 
 These beliefs were rooted far deeper in the past than attitudes to taxation or to education, and they were to remain tenacious into late NEP despite mounting persecution, as will be seen when this same area is re-examined later. 
 There have been many Western and Soviet studies of religious belief per se , and of the interaction in Soviet history between an atheist regime and a highly religious peasantry, but scant reference is made to socio-economic views and actions derived from religion that had ultimate political repercussions. 
 Emphasis is laid on them here, since they coincide with the line of approach adapted for other themes. 
 Merle Fainsod once wrote &bquo;The vantage point which the Smolensk Archive affords for a study of religious activity in the area is a peculiarly distorted one&equo;. 
 This is because we can read only of anti-religious work as described in party documents and, from 1925 onwards, in the reports of the local League of the Godless. 
 In order to circumvent this bias to some extent, let us first burrow beneath this middle level to look at grass-roots religious sentiment which for the most part in 1922 escaped party supervision, since the latter was restricted geographically to the larger centres of habitation and their immediate hinterland. 
 The arrival of the atheist Bolsheviks as the new &eacute;lite merely  accentuated the cultural schism between the peasantry and the ruling strata that had existed since Peter the Great's reign. 
 Whereas the peasants continued to be edified through oral accounts of the lives of the Saints and of holy pilgrims, and occasionally learnt to read the alphabet through the Psalter, the upper classes had paid lip-service to the state religion whilst immersing themselves in rationalist Western thought. 
 Towards the end of the Tsarist period the Slavophils, Dostoevsky, Tolstoy, and others tried to bridge this gulf. 
 The last Empress, a German, was more Russian than peasant Russians in her devotion to Orthodox religion and to unorthodox holy men. 
 Yet all these trends were eccentric, neither pulling the bulk of the intelligentsia with them, nor penetrating to the heart of peasant psychology. 
 This was hardly surprising, given that earthy pagan beliefs mingled in the peasant mind with Christian tenets, creating a &bquo;double faith&equo; (doeverie ), the icon and the wheatsheaf together. 
 Before confessing to a priest, most peasants would ask the earth for forgiveness. 
 The passionate faith in the deep influence of the soil on man might at first sight appear to be an idea which a Marxist regime could easily harness to its own ideology, as was the Russian peasant's deeply ingrained sense of co-operative toil on the land, a notion likewise derived from his dvoeverie. 
 In accounts of religious opposition to the Bolsheviks, these possible points of convergence have always been overlooked. 
 That they never bore fruit was due as much to Bolshevik neglect of them as to the eventual insistence from above on the abolition of the private farms. 
 Another trait stemming from religious inspiration was the passive humility of the peasants. 
 Quite apart from educational and other handicaps, this was one reason why they and even their social betters took so little part in government, leaving it so often to Balts or Germans before 1917, and to other non-Russians after that date. 
 When they did bestir themselves on rare occasions, as in 1917, but more slowly than any other group, they could read plainly Christian meanings into Bolshevik slogans such as &bquo;universal peace&equo; and &bquo;if any would not work, neither should he eat&equo;. 
 When their typically apocalyptic  vision of a new world faded, they retreated for the most part into traditional humility. 
 In their rural isolation Belorussian peasants were at first little affected by anti-religious campaigns and actions emanating from the towns, even if priests disappeared and churches were commandeered. 
 Before 1917, as in most other parts of the Empire, one wooden church served for up to forty or fifty scattered villages. 
 There was no feeling, as there was among Catholics, that priests were indispensable: heads of families could and did conduct simplified forms of service in front of their domestic icons. 
 Increasingly some peasants realized the truth of the proverb &bquo; Dli popa temnota naroda &mdash; istochnik dokhoda &equo; (&bquo;For the priest the unenlightened people is a source of income&equo;). 
 Yet for lack of personnel, funds, and initiative, Bolshevik Party members were not making sufficient capital out of the situation. 
 As a peasant from the Kursk guberniia put it in 1922: &bquo;We are not for priests nor for the church, but if only the Comrades would give us a little of what they promise: they promise a school and Socialism, but our hands are still as empty as ever.&equo; 
 Certainly it would be wrong to associate anti-Bolshevik sentiment with religious persecution in too many cases. 
 Priests in the Tambov area, the centre of peasant revolt in 1921, reported in 1922 that church attendance had dropped by more than half as compared with pre-1914. 
 The extent and depth of religious belief is notoriously difficult to estimate at any time in any country, but a few general statistics can be applied reliably to the peasantry of 1922 in areas like Belorussia, Kursk, and Tambov. 
 Older people were more religious than the young, women more than men, and above all, the rural areas more than the urban workers, as S. G. Strumilin discovered in 1922 (Table 1). 
 That anyone could dream up the notion of quantifying time spent on prayers was indicative of the &bquo;scientific&equo; attitude of the central authorities, to whose actions in 1922 we now turn   briefly before considering the middle level of the local party men in Smolensk. 
 At the close of 1921 the Soviet government ordered a survey of church valuables, and in a decree of 16 February 1922 commanded that they should be collected and sold for the benefit of those suffering from the Famine. 
 When a further instruction stated that vessels used in services were not exempt, the Patriarch Tikhon told the faithful to resist. 
 Although similar requisitions were carried out on treasures in museums, it did seem that the state had finally decided to test the power of the Orthodox Church on a socially explosive question. 
 The government had also noted the proliferation of schismatic religious movements over the previous few years. 
 When Tikhon was placed under house arrest in June 1922, one of these movements, the Living Church, was given numerous concessions by the regime, and at first looked set to take over the role and some of the property of the Orthodox. 
 Trotsky went so far as to call the agreement &bquo;an ecclesiastical NEP&equo;, implying a similar tolerance to that meted out to &bquo; kulaks &equo; or to Nepmen, but this was a superficial and short-sighted judgement redolent with propaganda. 
 The year 1922 in fact marked the start of the regime's long-term siege of the Church. 
 In the spring a weekly journal, Bezbozhnik , was set up to conduct a popular anti-religious campaign. 
 The rise of the Living Church, which itself soon split into various groups, allowed the  party to divide and rule; at no point did it commit itself unconditionally to any sect. 
 The Living Church owed its popularity to the parish priests, the oppressed &bquo;white&equo; clergy whom it supported, rather than to any enthusiasm amongst the masses. 
 Like all cultural movements during NEP, its influence did not extend far beyond the towns. 
 Both Soviet and hostile critics observed subsequently that in the eyes of the people Living Church members often looked like Soviet agents and opportunists. 
 In the light of high political intent and peasant sentiment, let us now return to the market town of Roslavl' and examine Party and urban reactions there in 1922. 
 It is interesting to note that the local Party cell's initial report for January, that is, prior to the central decree of 16 February on church valuables, already concentrates on two things &mdash; possible rifts within the Church, and the flow of ecclesiastical monies. 
 A very large amount had already been collected on a voluntary basis by religious groups for the Famine, making it seem almost superfluous or extortionate to do more. 
 Party spies had been assigned to people sending sums through the post for the personal use of the bishop. 
 The February decree was only implemented in Roslavl' one month late, on 15 March. 
 This may have been due to a reluctance to suck more money out of a generous population, or to the usual delays in carrying out orders from Moscow. 
 On 15 March Party officials took gold objects from the main church, despite protests outside from a large crowd including factory workers. 
 When the clergy tried to calm them, the crowd declared that the valuables belonged to the people, not to the church, so that priests could not give them away. 
 Further Party raids were carried out into April. 
 On one occasion the church bell was rung to summon protesters. 
 Troops were called in (as they had been to protect fueldumps). 
 There was some shooting and a number of people lay dead on the church steps. 
 Others were arrested. 
 The Roslavl' Party also reported on events in Smolensk,  where shots were fired on 28 March when factory workers downed tools to protect churches. 
 From Vitebsk it was heard that a railway-wagon workshop meeting convened on 30 March with the aim of helping in the requisition of church valuables broke up because of the &bquo;thunderous outcries of believers&equo;. 
 Others in Vitebsk suspected that gold seized would not go to the Volga famine relief but into the Bolsheviks' pockets or their mouths in the shape of much-fancied gold teeth. 
 One workers' meeting had even suggested that it would be better to shoot Lenin or Trotsky rather than Patriarch Tikhon. 
 In the same period Trotsky was suggesting from his ivory tower in the capital that in order to avoid saints' names, children should be called Ninel (Lenin backwards) or simply Rem (the initials for revolution, electrification, and peace). 
 The remarkable features of this struggle were the extent of violence, the number of urban workers involved, and the outspoken nature of their protests. 
 Undoubtedly much of the anger was directed at further extortions of any kind, whether anti-religious or not. 
 In April the Smolensk Party advised the Roslavl' cell that contributions to the Famine were tailing off in the Roslavl' area, so two new directives were issued: first, to collect another famine tax, with every twenty town-workers or employees supporting one hungry child, and every five peasant households contributing for one hungry adult; second, to hold agitational meetings in all trade-union branches and at village skhod  meetings. 
 In view of the vastness of Russia and the striking parochialism of the localities, it must have been hard to whip up yet more sympathy and funds for remote peasants in the Lower Volga. 
 Yet as we shall see, the Famine did produce considerable horizontal side-effects between one province and another. 
 As a general principle it should not be imagined that all economic, social, and above all political repercussions were of a vertical central &mdash; local nature or vice versa. 
 Horizontal influences have been virtually ignored in Soviet and Western historiography alike. 
 Here we have stumbled on the first of many. 
 Another feature of Party activity in Roslavl' and Smolensk  reflected in microcosm top-level efforts in Moscow to divide and rule by setting the Living Church and other sects against the official Orthodox Church. 
 A January Party report in Roslavl' noted with glee that the local clergy were divided, even before the February decree. 
 By May the Smolensk authorities were writing that the &bquo;black&equo; Bishop Philip in the city still opposed the collection of church valuables, whereas the rural &bquo;white&equo; clergy assented to it. 
 The latter were to be encouraged by Party propaganda at the uezd level to send in supportive letters to the press. 
 Other religious scapegoats were not hard to find, especially in Belorussia with its preponderance of urban Jews and large Catholic minority. 
 In Roslavl' during March and April it was frequently noted that the public believed that ecclesiastical gold was to be handed over to the Jews. 
 In June town employees were angered because they had to pay six million roubles commission to Jews in order to exchange a hundred million given to them in the form of bonds for their pay. 
 The Smolensk open-air market was flooded in April with leaflets declaiming &bquo;Down with the Yids &mdash; save Russia!&equo; 
 On 13 May three Jews were robbed and killed 10 versts from the village of Liozno, and the perpetrators were allowed to get away. 
 At least a portion of the jewish population was saving its skin by allying with the Party, for in April we discover 400 Jewish delegates in Minsk speeding up the fight against Zionism and proposing the closure of their religious schools in Belorussia, a notion which had become a reality by September according to the central press. 
 No doubt the local Party authorities were helped in their divide-and-rule policy by Orthodox allegations that the Living Church had arisen due to &bquo;Jewish agitators&equo;. 
 Although Catholics are not cited in the Smolensk Archive with reference to the taking of church valuables, their activity can be traced from other sources. 
 At the time of the last and only census of 1897, there were more of them in the Vitebsk area than in any other part of the Empire except for Kovno,  Vilno, and Grodno. 
 As with the Orthodox Church, so with the Catholics it was the February decree that precipitated the crisis in relations with the Soviet government. 
 Catholic churches in Smolensk were heavily plundered. 
 Like Patriarch Tikhon, but rather later, the Catholic Archbishop Cieplak was called to trial for 17 November 1922. 
 Here too the Party could fend off opposition by a policy of divide and rule. 
 When an agreement was drawn up in 1922 between the Vatican and the Soviet government for a Catholic famine relief mission, some Orthodox leaders in Western Russia declared that the Communists hoped that Catholic propaganda would bring about the downfall of the whole Orthodox Church. 
 This was clearly a wild exaggeration, but it showed, at least as far as the large Catholic minority of Belorussia was concerned, that any attempt to base nationalism on Catholic separatism would be doomed to failure. 
 Despite the considerable pressures on the churches at the central and top provincial levels in 1922, sparse reverberations as yet reached that grass-roots base which was considered earlier. 
 On 2 February 1922, a reporter in Izvestiia  enthused, 
 It is a great rarity in the countryside to find a Communist who does not have an icon hung up at home. 
 Religion and Communism make an excellent household together. 
 Here are the facts. 
 A Communist gets married in a village. 
 All the wedding procession goes to church. 
 In front, the red flag with the inscription, &bquo;Workers of the world, unite!&equo; 
 Next come the icons, and then the bridegroom, with a red sash on his chest. 
 Such marriages are frequent in the villages. 
 In his fashion the peasant understands Communism and Soviet power. 
 Although the rustic idyll was no doubt the result of wishful thinking, it may have approximated to the real situation in some localities. 
 No such co-operation was possible in the sphere of taxation, but then it never had been under the Tsars, so Bolshevik extortion seemed hardly more arbitrary than previous methods. 
 There was no volte-face here as there had been on religion. 
  Requisition of grain at the point of a gun during War Communism had proved a novel experience for the peasantry, but by 1922 that had been replaced by slightly more civilized methods. 
 The lack of administrative control from the centre during the Civil War together with a rapidly depreciating currency meant that taxation became a dwindling resource after 1917. 
 In theoretical terms, however, Lenin had made it quite clear, when local Soviets advocated independent local finances in 1918, that &bquo;democratic centralism&equo; would be vigorously enforced. 
 Over the first nine months of 1922 money taxes reached on average a mere 3 per cent of the pre-war level in real terms. 
 Two-thirds of this was raised through excises, which had been the most common method in the late Tsarist period. 
 Despite the need to return to a monetary economy under the liberal market conditions of NEP, by the end of 1922 over onethird of total revenue still came in the form of taxes in kind. 
 A special series of graded poll-taxes towards famine relief began in February 1922. 
 Since national expenditure reached 14 per cent of the prewar level in the first three-quarters of 1922, huge currency issues had to be made to bridge the gap between income and expenditure. 
 The rate for the pound sterling was 1,650,000 roubles in January 1922 and 71,730,000 by October. 
 Internally the value of the rouble decreased seventy-two times with regard to goods during 1922. 
 Only at the end of November did the State Bank introduce a new denomination of notes equal to the gold content of the pre-war ten-rouble coin. 
 By the end of the year there were at least five methods of conducting business, starting at the centre and moving towards the periphery. 
 Moscow traders kept cash balances in gold or foreign valuta. 
 The more sophisticated provincial dealers tried to acquire the new denomination at the end of the year as a means of hoarding. 
 Meanwhile they and nearly all other levels below them in geographical terms were condemned to use the  rapidly inflating old notes. 
 In the sluggish provinces, as in some towns, double-headed-eagle notes from the old regime overstamped with Bolshevik signs continued to circulate for lack of anything else. 
 Below all these strata lay the immemorial peasant base of straight barter and the still-important tax in kind. 
 Thus NEP as a monetary phenomenon took time to seep slowly through the various levels of society, just as pistoles and &eacute;cus  had competed with the franc in the French provinces after that other great revolution. 
 The same was true of NEP as a fiscal reform. 
 The revival of trade between town and country was crucial to the NEP system, but it could clearly be conducted only in money. 
 Yet heavy taxes in kind continued until after the end of 1922. 
 The central authorities had great difficulty from the start of NEP in collecting taxes of any sort. 
 Confused data on peasant landownership and family size made it virtually impossible to make accurate assessments, so that for many provinces only half of the taxable land per head was in fact recorded in the tax lists. 
 This was exactly the proportion of the tax in kind collected in the Roslavl' area up to November 1921. 
 Since October 1921 military detachments had been sent out to the local villages to billet in them and to insist on the tax in kind (shades of expropriation by force in the period of War Communism). 
 Another throw-back to the past was reported by the Roslavl' Party cell in January: at a volost'  meeting an ex-member of the Kadet Party had spoken up against taxation. 
 In the same period a peasant group calling itself the Union of the True was also advocating opposition to taxes. 
 Resistance of this kind was to keep the authorities extremely nervous throughout 1922, and one has the sense from the enormous detail of the Smolensk Archive that fear of outright revolt and even counter-revolution was ever present in the local Party's thoughts. 
 Roslavl' officials would have lain quieter in  their beds at night if they had bothered to read Maxim Gorky's book On the Russian Peasantry  published that same year. 
 He pointed out that peasant opposition to government did exist, but on account of Russia's huge distances it expressed itself more by evasion than through open fighting. 
 This psychology naturally lingered on into the supposedly liberal atmosphere of NEP in the form of the utopian hope that obligations imposed &bquo;from the Centre&equo;, as the peasants put it, could be avoided, whilst retaining economic rights. 
 At the end of the winter of 1921&ndash;2 a cautious directive went out from Roslavl' Party headquarters to all local head collectors of the tax in kind. 
 They were not to put undue pressure on the peasants themselves, but only on their fellow subordinate collectors. 
 Nonpaying peasants were to be arrested in minimal numbers, and only millers were to be imprisoned. 
 They were to be very &bquo;diplomatic&equo; with recalcitrant poor peasants, and on no account were they to take to court more than a small minority in any one area, even if a majority were guilty. 
 Memories obviously lingered of the War Communism strategy of trying to divide richer from poorer peasants. 
 Above all head collectors were ordered to omit from court lists of non-payers all persons in positions of authority, and particularly Party members. 
 The Roslavl' Party report for 15 March hinted at the reason for this order when it revealed that peasants were of the view that the volost' authorities were imbued with self-seeking ( shkurnichestvo ); Soviet Russia was turning into a &bquo;purely bourgeois republic&equo;. 
 The peasants could not muster enough cash, on account of galloping inflation, to pay the excise duties. 
 The rumour was going round that a new tax on cattle and horse-ownership was to be introduced. 
 This was not true, but in a largely illiterate society the snowball effect of malicious rumours worried the Bolsheviks, as it had the Tsarist officials before them. 
 The last we hear from Roslavl' on taxes is in May, when fifty-eight of the seventy-eight soldiers requested from the town garrison were sent out to collect the potato tax in kind. 
 This failed in the main, not because of violent peasant resistance, but because they were simply too poor to give up  any of their potatoes. 
 The local Cheka quoted ominous peasant complaints against the government: &bquo;They aren't planning freedom for us, but serfdom. 
 The time of Godunov has already begun, when the peasants were attached to the landowners. 
 Now we are attached to the Jewish bourgeoisie like Modkowski, Aronson, etc.&equo; 
 This reminds us again of the anti-Semitism prevalent in Belorussia. 
 State investment, rare enough in itself, was earmarked for industry (in the 1923 national budget less than 5 per cent was to be allocated to agriculture). 
 The peasants had to rely on themselves, which meant recourse from 1922 onwards to private lenders &mdash; local Jews in this area. 
 It is interesting to observe that private capital was more significant both in absolute terms and in relative importance at these provincial levels than in the great urban centres in 1922. 
 Thus although the political initiative for the start of NEP came from the top, the economic life-blood at first began to flow from the bottom upwards. 
 The Roslavl' authorities were besieged by continual instructions on taxation from the Smolensk guberniia Party committee. 
 They were told in May to avoid making errors in assessments, and to stop peasants concealing the extent of their property. 
 This was not the only class at fault in this respect. 
 A female landowner of substance induced a handsome peasant to live with her in her mansion; the estate was cunningly converted into a collective farm, but the local peasantry frowned on this breakdown of the old class barriers. 
 A telegram from Smolensk on 1 June urged that the peasants be better informed on tax matters. 
 The wording of the telegram was badly misspelt and like some local banknotes was stamped with the Imperial eagle. 
 As was to be the case with far more important orders to the peasantry from the very highest level at the start of collectivization after NEP, bureaucratic delays and excessive central demands soon resulted in comparable excess of zeal at local levels. 
 By October we find Smolensk party officials  annulling a delayed payment of 425 pudy of rye still being demanded by one local authority (some taxes in kind had been reduced from March onwards to a single uniform tax calculated in terms of rye). 
 In November the Smolensk guberniia executive committee is being rebuked in turn by no less a person than V. Molotov, Secretary of the Central Committee in Moscow, for allowing subordinates to impose taxes beyond those laid down in the All-Union list. 
 The years 1921&ndash;2 did in fact cover one of the worst periods in the economic fortunes of the Smolensk guberniia. 
 By 1923 the area sown for food crops had increased by 14.8 per cent compared with 1920, making for improved incomes, more cash, and so more taxes in this area; but viewed from the middle of 1922, there was little prospect of such a happy outcome. 
 Over the whole of Russia there-was a dearth of agricultural goods caused mainly by the Famine, and a comparative glut of industrial products from the towns. 
 This was the start of the famous &bquo;scissors crisis&equo;. 
 The terms of exchange between manufacturers and agricultural produce moved swiftly to the disadvantage of the towns; a pair of boots which in 1913 had been worth 283lb. of rye flour was worth as little as 133lb. by May 1922. 
 Central reforms were eventually to adjust such discrepancies, but as with the tax changes, they turned out to be blunt bureaucratic instruments not sufficiently finely tuned to local needs. 
 By 1923 the scissors had opened too widely in the opposite direction, this time in favour of the towns. 
 In fact the whole financial framework of NEP was shaky, and much of it was brought in piecemeal on ad hoc  lines, as was the case with the vital currency reforms. 
 The introduction of the profit notion through khozraschet looked promising on paper, but in reality at the start of 1922 there was no definition, even in the highest economic organs, of what was meant by &bquo;profit&equo;. 
 As late as 1923 there were still many  different ways of assessing production costs and profits. 
 Similar discrepancies opened up in the agricultural sphere. 
 The Agrarian Code of 1922 strictly forbade the sale of land and the granting of mortgages. 
 Yet poorer peasants in their thousands in this year were turning to private, mainly peasant, lenders, though many Jews were also involved in Belorussia, as we have seen. 
 Many soon found themselves in long-term debt to richer peasants, particularly in the Famine areas. 
 This phenomenon was noted in the central press, where the lenders were often referred to as &bquo;beglye&equo; (unstable): however the shaky nature of their new-found prosperity, like the uncertain fits and starts of NEP in economic terms, was soon to turn into solid gains which looked like becoming permanent. 
 The &bquo;beglye&equo; became &bquo; kulaks &equo; when many poor peasants were unable to liquidate their debts despite the better harvests of 1922 and 1923. 
 Thus the very foundations of NEP were steeped in economic obscurities, loose interpretations, and plain evasion of coded principles. 
 In this sense as a system it was a house built of sand which could scarcely have lasted as long as Bukharin and others wished it to. 
 It seemed a near miracle that it got off to a relatively smooth start, politically speaking, in 1921&ndash;2. 
 Although these years witnessed a very low tide of economic activity including the horrors of widespread famine and even peasant revolts in some areas like Tambov, problems concerning religious belief and taxation never led to large-scale uprisings in the Smolensk guberniia (nor indeed anywhere else in Russia). 
 After all, the Civil War was over in most areas, so the peasants' best chance of retaliation, by linking up with local White armies, was lost. 
 Again, Lenin's promise that the main aim of NEP was to restore peasant fortunes did begin to bear real fruit before the end of 1922. 
 Yet through most of the year many government promises remained on paper. 
 The Bolshevik Party was therefore especially eager to win over minds by means of cultural and ideological propaganda and education. 
 Let us follow the method already adopted in an examination of religion and taxes, looking briefly at central political attitudes and then  observing their impact at middle and local levels in the Smolensk guberniia.. 
 The general situation had been most unsatisfactory right from the start in 191 7, even amongst the proletariat of Petrograd, the core of Bolshevik support. 
 In her capacity as a pedagogue, Krupskaia discovered a high proportion of illiterates among the factory workers of the Vyborg raion . 
 At many cultural levels the old Petersburg continued to prevail for a while over Moscow in many informal, non-governmental ways, as will be noted in a later chapter. 
 Its slightly more liberal ethos seemed to affect Krupskaia, for when she first went to work in the People's Commissariat of Education ( Narkompros ) after the revolution, she stressed the need for independence from central management by intellectuals. 
 Yet by 1920 she was already submitting to governmental pressures in her Moscow office. 
 She acknowledged that &bquo;cultural work must be closely combined with political tasks&equo;, and went on to prove it by signing three directives on the censorship of libraries between 1920 and 1924. 
 The tighter political hold was in part a reaction to the worsening economic and organizational situation in cultural affairs. 
 Whereas 10.4 per cent of the central budget was allocated to Narkompros in 1920, this was reduced to 4.2 per cent for 1922. 
 A substantial proportion of educational costs was transferred to local authorities at the end of 1921, although the latter had neither sufficient financial nor administrative means to carry out their new assignments. 
 The result was an alarming drop in resources &mdash; 3,684 public libraries in 1922 as opposed to 14,800 in 1920; 1,126 &bquo;illiteracy liquidation points&equo; as against 17,462 before NEP. 
 Only 38 per cent of children attended elementary schools at the close of 1922, compared with roughly 48 per cent in pre-revolutionary Russia. 
 A. Lunacharsky underlined the growing rift between  the educational health of the larger towns and the benighted countryside, but to no avail. 
 As was so often the case in central-local relationships, poor distribution was often to blame. 
 The nation-wide state publishing organization, Gosizdat , was responsible for the dissemination of official literature of all kinds, but the flow of materials to the provinces remained very weak even as late as 1923. 
 Only seven of the fifteen large bookstores in Moscow took the trouble to send anything out to provincial peasant reading-centres. 
 None of them made a special selection of materials suitable for the peasantry, so the few books that were dispatched were often too dry or too expensive. 
 Credit for this trade was hard to get, since publishers argued over terms with distributors. 
 In March 1922 a monopoly was granted to a new state advisory body on the publication of textbooks, but through the rest of 1922 it was powerless to stem the growing tide of texts from private publishers which threatened to drown official party ideology in educational affairs. 
 The precarious hold of the party over cultural ideology will be examined in greater detail in Chapter 6. 
 Turning now to middle levels of cultural control, in this case to the Smolensk guberniia offices and then to Roslavl', our chosen locality, it is clear that fresh unorthodoxies were apt to creep in below and beyond those emanating from private central sources. 
 It should not be imagined that the tiny Party &eacute;lite at either of these provincial levels could maintain a tight hold. 
 By the end of 1922 the size of the guberniia Party organization totalled 5,925,9 compared with, for instance, 3,286 local officials of the Commissariat for agriculture, most of whom were not Party members, but who, by the very nature of their work as surveyors, land-reclaimers, timber and livestock experts, were scattered more widely round the rural areas than were Party workers. 
 As late as i April 1924, 3,704 out of the 5,416 Party members were concentrated in the towns. 
  Thus there was obviously scope for the propagation of nonparty unorthodoxies at the grass-roots level. 
 The traditional sowers of culture at middle provincial levels were the schoolteachers. 
 They had far wider influence over the peasants than was indicated by their formal school syllabuses. 
 In the Smolensk area as elsewhere, they linked up with agricultural advisers in the effort to make the peasants realize that subsistence farming was a form of self-exploitation, since their energies were dissipated in a multitude of tiring undertakings. 
 It was the teachers too who taught the metric system as against the local weights and measures, thus slowly inculcating a sense of wider, national unity. 
 Yet as of 1922 the political reliability of the teachers was notoriously low: large numbers of them were remnants from the old regime. 
 Their pay in paper money was so bad and came so late that unless they had peasant relatives who could supply food, they were reduced to making shoes, singing psalms in church, or hiring themselves out as labourers to peasants. 
 When schools shut for lack of fuel in the winter, they gave private lessons to the richer peasants' children. 
 Thus their dubious loyalty to the new regime was eroded even further. 
 The inculcation of political orthodoxy and instruction of a more coercive nature was left strictly in the hands of the Party. 
 A reading of the directives of the Smolensk guberniia committee to all executive committees at lower levels for 1922 reveals centrally isolated bureaucrats surrounded by a swamp of unreliable social elements. 
 On the occasion of the first All-Russian Congress of the peasant committees of mutual social aid, a directive exhorted all local branches to interest the peasantry in the workings of central management. 
 Wherever possible, Red Army men were to be installed on the committees. 
 As we have seen, they were amongst the staunchest Bolshevik supporters in the voting for the Constituent Assembly, and in Belorussia they were more than usually numerous and influential due to the fact that this territory had lain directly in the path of invading and retreating forces in the Civil War. 
 Administrative help from Smolensk brought with it obligations, such as &bquo;compulsory self-taxation&equo; ( samooblozhenie )  for the peasant committees. 
 Within a mere three weeks the Smolensk Party authorities also required all uezd executive committees to collate, check, and comment to them on the minutes of every single peasant meeting on mutual aid. 
 When we shift our attention away from sources emanating from Smolensk city to Party archives based on Roslavl', we recapture through official documents that feeling of social, economic, and possibly political unrest sensed more informally by our peasant-woman visitor and her soldier son. 
 Even at the height of NEP prosperity in 1926, considerable resistance to central patterns and instructions was to linger on the further one got away from Moscow down through all the provincial levels, but in 1922 strong fears of such resistance provoked a siege psychology among those party officials located nearest to the grass roots. 
 They juggled nervously in Roslavl' with the various leading local social and power groups. 
 The agitation section of the town's Communist Party committee decided, or rather passed on a directive probably originating in Moscow, that the Paris Commune of 1871 should be celebrated on 18 March. 
 In particular all local factories and the military were ordered to rejoice. 
 Lectures and concerts were to be given, for which topics of current interest should be very carefully chosen, and which had to be free for all comers. 
 Throughout the year the anxieties of the Party were focused on local workers and soldiers rather than on the surrounding sea of peasants. 
 Great concern was often expressed about lack of military interest in political affairs. 
 At a meeting of the commissars of the Roslavl' garrison the military commander of the town hospital admitted that the political cell in his institution did not really exist, although there were occasional discussions of newspaper articles. 
 The automobile workshop, likewise under tight military control, had a cell with ten members, but the commander reported that few attended its Marsiksii  ( sic ) circle. 
 At a level where either the commander concerned or the typist could not render &bquo;Marxist&equo; correctly in Russian, it seems doubtful whether rejoicing for the Paris Commune would be very well informed or sincere. 
 The deputy  commander of the first artillery battalion reported that all its cell members had been so busily engaged on operations amongst the civilian population that there had been no meeting for over a month (they were probably occupied in some of the unsavoury tasks noted earlier by our peasant soldier and his mother). 
 The only optimistic statement came from the third cadre of military transport, which had recently held two cell meetings. 
 Thirteen per cent of the cadre were illiterate, so political and cultural training was being concentrated on this sector. 
 Work had begun on equipping a club. 
 The Roslavl' party committee expended most energy of all on plans for the commemoration of the fifth anniversary of the October Revolution. 
 Again, workers and soldiers were subjected to especially close scrutiny and control. 
 The four local factories were told in no uncertain terms that they had to celebrate. 
 Gifts were to be handed out to all soldiers, and their food rations were to be improved between 6 and 8 November. 
 In return the garrison was to decorate the main square with red materials as issued. 
 Military units were to stage a show depicting victories over counter-revolutionaries for the benefit of invited workers. 
 On the following day, 7 November, there would be a joint parade by trade-union representatives and their military comrades. 
 In the evening soldiers were detailed off to perform folk-dances in the primitive town theatre. 
 On 8 November they would continue to sing for their suppers by reading out newspapers to the less literate and explaining the significance of the Third International. 
 This could be a formidable task in a society where even widely travelled soldiers firmly believed that Thomas Cook's wagon-lits were the spearheads of the Third International since the latter word could be read in Cyrillic on the side of carriages. 
 The majority of local Roslavl' workers would undoubtedly be railway rather than factory personnel. 
 The main event on 7 November after the parade was to be a &bquo;spectacle&equo; in the railway club. 
 The town Soviet was also to hold discussions with representatives from the factories and the women's section. 
  The sole reference to the peasantry in these laborious instructions was an order to open all rural reading-rooms in the surrounding volosti on 7 November. 
 The meaning of the October Revolution was then to be explained to anyone who bothered to turn up. 
 Given the importance of this area of Russia in the Civil War and the Polish campaign, the Party's care for and vigilance over the army does not come as a surprise; nor does the considerable military presence in 1922 in civilian organizations like the hospital and the automobile workshop. 
 The Party's obvious nervousness about railway and other workers and relative neglect of the rural hinterland needs a little more explanation. 
 As the year went by the economic sops to the peasantry provided by NEP began to have a relaxing effect on this class, but industrial unrest throughout Russia continued to rise. 
 The level of productivity went up slowly, but employment prospects did not. 
 Provincial market towns, in 1922 as throughout the Soviet period, collected the first rural tide of those looking for work &mdash; peasant vagrants, demobilized soldiers, and in the case of the Smolensk area, flax-workers out of a job as their industry began to decline after the boom of the war years. 
 It also proved difficult at the start of NEP to gear local manufacturing industries to peasant demands. 
 These are some of the reasons why the Party devoted so much care to its favourite but weakling class in provincial Russia. 
 We shall come across this concern again in 1922 when we travel through the much stronger industrial nexus of Kharkov. 
 The peasants in the Roslavl' region did come in for some attention during 1922, though supervision was at best paternalistic, sporadic, and myopic. 
 In January 1922 the town Party committee observed that there was no anti-Bolshevik agitation amongst the local clergy, the main focus of possible rural discontent. 
 It was noted however that what was contemptuously called the &bquo;village intelligentsia&equo; still maintained a hostile attitude to the Party and the Red Army. 
 At the end of February news filtered in that no peasants were willing to join the military ranks, and there were quite a few desertions. 
 The  greater part of the required prodnalog  (tax in kind) had been collected, but several villages were fractious due to silly actions by some officials. 
 Most of the Party's agitational work was devoted to the very small number of local kolkhozy , as if, like Catherine the Great, it sought to derive comfort from over-concentrating on its equivalents of Potemkin's model villages. 
 The nation-wide number of these paragons for the Marxist future was a mere 8,641 even by 1924. 
 However, there was one big kolkhoz consisting of 150 households only 20 versts from Roslavl' that was said to be too well satisfied with itself, and so did not welcome visits from the town. 
 The party wished to introduce the shefstvo  system in its relations with the kolkhozy . 
 A shef  organization from the towns such as an individual factory would take on the role of cultural and political mentor to some rural group. 
 Shefstvo wag intended to be a nation-wide movement, the concrete expression of the more abstract notion of smychka, the theory of town and country alliance as expounded originally by Marx. 
 The ideal was very far from being a reality in 1922, or indeed throughout NEP. 
 A kolkhoz to the east of Smolensk city in the Dorogobuzhskii raion complained that in 1921 its two shefi, a nearby hospital, and a regiment, had helped with the harvest, but no one had visited it in 1922. 
 Sometimes the tie was purely economic in rationale. 
 One kolkhoz further to the north-east of Smolensk exchanged potatoes for farm machinery, whilst another shef factory that manufactured spare parts for linen plants gave iron to a local kolkhoz on its visits. 
 It insisted on calling a separate meeting for the kolkhoz women, so as to persuade them of their independence from their menfolk. 
 An undated set of questionnaires in the 1922 file for the Roslavl' area reveals the prickly atmosphere that prevailed between the busybodies from the towns, as the rustics perceived them, and the primitive mores of the rustics themselves. 
 When asked if their shefi acted in too authoritarian a manner, some kolkhozniki at first said it was very rare, but then in peasant  fashion slowly warmed up to the fact that they had been very angered by some young students who had written in Rabochii put &equo; that their horses were badly fed and cleaned, and that they had not sown enough crops. 
 The arrogance of Bolshevik-inspired youth towards the patriarchal rural community also transpires from other criticisms directed against younger visitors. 
 But peasants also complained when what they called &bquo;doctors&equo; came out to inspect their cattle and sanitary arrangements, or when two peasants who had murdered their wives had to be handed over to a visiting &bquo;social court&equo; ( obshchestvennyi sud ) set up by a shefstvo team. 
 The party's myopic concentration on the kind of agricultural organizations it wished to nurture for the future is also shown in the frequent reports for 1922 on the fragile co-operative network. 
 These efforts proved to be in vain for the most part. 
 By the middle of 1924 the Agitprop section of the Smolgubkom  was openly declaring that both shefstvo and smychka were a farce in actuality because they had deteriorated into mass weekend outings to the countryside in search of illicit stills. 
 This led to the usual &bquo;drinking bout&hellip; 
 This kind of smychka produces nothing but harm.&equo; 
 Three documents dealing with political culture at the Smolensk and Roslavl' levels convey several general impressions. 
 Party officials full of earnest endeavour were passing down all-Russian directives from Moscow in rather a wooden manner. 
 There were too many organizational structures with too few members and even less real action. 
 Above all, local educational standards were as yet not up to the demands put upon them by &bquo;the Centre&equo;. 
 In 1922 even the Moscow intelligentsia continued to confuse Old and New Style dates. 
 There was little hope for political enlightenment in the provinces at a time when the number of literary centres and of those attending them fell to one-tenth of what they had risen to in 1921. 
 This was largely the result of the application of khozraschet and the transference of funds for adult education to local budgets. 
 Menshevik  critics of the regime claimed that compared with the prerevolutionary period Russia in 1922 had 30 per cent fewer schools overall and that 70 per cent of all children between 8 and 11 years of age were illiterates. 
 When it is also remembered that Belorussia had the lowest literacy rate of all European Russia, the sluggish response of the denizens of the Roslavl' area comes as no surprise. 
 Local involvement in nation-wide politics does not just depend on intellectual evolution, however, but on the strong conviction that national affairs affect one's life and so need to be considered. 
 After all, hundreds of fundamental revolutions involving the whole and almost completely illiterate populace of countries have taken place in the history of civilization. 
 As late as the end of the nineteenth century in some Western European states local politics retained their dominance over central concerns, until markets, jobs, and communications like the railways became part of a national whole. 
 Until such a time peasants in a country like France were really only interested in a few restricted matters like land, taxes, and the threat of military service. 
 These remained the concerns of Belorussian peasants in the 1920s, but unlike French peasants there were no small-scale politics for them to latch on to in order to climb slowly out of their deep provincialism. 
 For lack of alternative parties or serious candidates with known individual characters to vote for, a gulf opened up between the isolated villagers on the one hand and the Roslavl' or Smolensk Party men on the other, intent on modelling themselves strictly on Smolensk or Moscow prototypes and on Moscow's instructions. 
 When we read in the Roslavl' files that twenty-three agitator brigades were dispatched to villages in order to celebrate international Women's Day, it is hard to imagine that they ever came across our peasant woman from Struga, and even more difficult to believe that they would have much impact on her ways of thinking even if they did. 
 She would probably conform to the type of village heroine K. Fedin described in his story Tishina  (Stillness) which depicts the depths of Smolensk guberniia in 1922&ndash;3, where Fedin was to spend several sum, mers during NEP. 
 In his notes Fedin writes of his heroine: &bquo;She  is somehow reconciled, and of course she would never go off anywhere for good. 
 She lives in stillness. 
 There is no world for her outside this stillness&hellip; the world ends somewhere beyond Kaluga&equo; (a nearby provincial centre). 
 The economic provisions of NEP were soon to act as a slow salve on the material well-being of the peasantry, but even before NEP had begun all political bridges between the centre and a free-thinking periphery had been burnt with the establishment of a one-party system and the elimination of any traces of local independence in the party hierarchy. 
 This lack of initiative in the hierarchy will be examined at the middle (Moscow-Smolensk) levels in the chapter on Bolshevik controls. 
 As good Marxists the Bolshevik leaders tended to believe that following on the eventual restoration and &bquo;correct&equo; development of favourable economic conditions, &bquo;correct&equo; social and political attitudes would also come about at all levels. 
 This view seems to have rubbed off on foreign, non-Marxist interpreters of the passage of NEP, who as a whole are inclined to think that a cultural policy of laissez-faire  was pursued throughout NEP. 
 In fact this was not so right from the start, even at the sophisticated intellectual heights of Petrograd, as will be seen when we approach that city. 
 If at the beginning of NEP local party attitudes appeared to contain an element of laissez-faire , this was only because very little in fact could be achieved for lack of human and other resources. 
 Certainly in the Smolensk and Kursk gubernii the will was there from the outset to mould and to control. 
 The strict pedagogic methods and moral precepts being worked out in 1922 by A. Makarenko at a microcosmic level near Poltava were to be taken over and applied wholesale to Stalin's Russia in the 1930s. 
 Even Krupskaia at the hub of power quickly modified her earlier liberal views concerning the inculcation of political culture. 
 In the early 1920s she published a series of three guide-lines for the removal of what she termed as &bquo;counter-revolutionary&equo; literature from local libraries. 
 The volume issued in the early spring of 1923 applied above all to village libraries. 
 She took a no-nonsense approach. 
 Although she held that both abstract and concrete points of view were valuable, she labelled all  Russian peasants as practically inclined. 
 She therefore proscribed all religious, philosophical, or psychological books for village libraries. 
 Tracts were to be chosen solely for their propaganda value and for their capacity to instil a Communist &bquo;world&equo; view. 
 The ex-peasant Maxim Gorky threatened to renounce his Soviet citizenship on discovering &bquo;this intellectual vampirism&equo;, as he called it, but Krupskaia's directives were allowed to pursue their philistine course. 
 If minds of the calibre of Krupskaia were so firmly closed so soon, there was little hope that her pedagogic instructions would serve to open the minds of the temnye liudi  in the Smolensk or any other guberniia.  
 The Centre  
 As the crow flies, or rather those rooks in A. K. Savrasov's famous painting, the distance south-east from Smolensk to Kursk is 480 km., which is a fraction more than the distance due north from Kursk to Moscow, and 80 km. deeper into the provinces than Smolensk from the capital. 
 Like Smolensk, Kursk was a guberniia administrative centre in 1922 and also lay in a river-valley (the Seim) amongst low hills. 
 However surrounding agricultural conditions were very different. 
 We shall not linger in Kursk itself but wander gently down a side road through this part of the Central Agricultural Region until we reach the Nikol'skaia volost' (cluster of villages) roughly 40 km. to the south-east (Roslavl' lay 110 km. from Smolensk). 
 Here relationships between the local inhabitants and party members and agents will be examined without reference to Kursk, let alone to Moscow. 
 Then we shall head due south again on the same road, passing into the Ukraine and out of the hills. 
 The first large and industrial city we reach is Kharkov. 
 After a brief stay there, we move south-west into the ubiquitous rural ocean until we arrive at a remarkable experimental settlement just off the main road between Kharkov and Poltava. 
 This is the colony for young vagrants and orphans recently established by Anton Makarenko. 
 In order to make some local comparisons with Nikol'skaia, ties between the fifty-nine party cells and the people in Poltava guberniia will be looked at in passing. 
 Again no reference will be made to party authorities in the guberniia capital, since this has already been done for Smolensk. 
 In Chapter 3 the focus will be directed instead on those contacts between the guberniia centres of Saratov and Samara and Moscow which were crucial for the alleviation of the famine conditions. 
 Kursk guberniia was in the famous central Black-Earth area  which also covered all, or most of Tambov, Orlov, and Voronezh gubernii, with the southern uezdy of Tula and Riazan' gubernii. 
 The fertile soil made it a grain-surplus area, in contrast to Belorussia and the north-west in general. 
 However market relations were much less developed in the Kursk guberniia than in the productive Ukraine and Volga areas. 
 This was partly due to the weak local transport system and remoteness from urban influences. 
 The most striking difference from Smolensk lay in the large numbers of peasant communes: before 1917 most Belorussian farms had belonged to individual families. 
 They had averaged less than 20 acres, whereas in Kursk guberniia heavily populated and extensive communes prevailed. 
 This system led to many problems. 
 Plot sizes were very small and the distance between them large. 
 Each household worked up to forty separate strips. 
 If a family held a small amount of land and was in a village with a large number of households, its strips could be so small and scattered that too much time was spent in travelling between strips. 
 Some of these would therefore lie fallow. 
 The overall result before and after the 1917 Revolution was pressure on land and frequent redistribution. 
 In this Kursk guberniia was quite unlike Western Russia and also Siberia, which had never experienced strip-farming and redistribution. 
 What broad effects did these diverse economic and social conditions have on nascent political behaviour? 
 Given the enormous upheavals in all areas from 1917 onwards and the consequent stirring up and obscuring of peasant reactions, the clearest historical clues oh this question may be gleaned from peasant elections and behaviour in the quieter period of the State Dumas. 
 Socio-economic problems remained largely the same in 1905&ndash;14 and 1922 in Kursk guberniia (though not of course in the Lower Volga area on account of the Famine). 
 Peasant representatives for the Black-Earth Region in the Dumas had shown ho interest in any political problem apart from the land issue. 
 On this question all social grades had taken the same line &mdash; the need to seize local gentry estates. 
 Yet despite  this unanimous view, the peasants of the Central Agricultural Region were completely incapable of uniting amongst themselves or of taking any joint action. 
 Instead of linking up with political parties, they relied on official helpers or on individual members of the gentry, who were normally their main opponents on the land question. 
 This lack of sophistication and coordination was in marked contrast to the behaviour of the Siberian peasant representatives in the Dumas. 
 They were active on a large number of political, economic, and cultural issues, and their views closely reflected their varying socioeconomic positions. 
 The fact that Siberia had never undergone strip-farming and redistribution, and was underpopulated, begins to account for this discrepancy. 
 Most Siberian peasants also farmed the complex multifield rotational system. 
 They could earn a return on a considerable number of different investments. 
 They had to take many economic decisions in the course of each annual cycle, and according to their status and wealth they made different decisions from one another in various places and over the year. 
 In all these ways they were more akin to urban dwellers, and felt they had some independent choices to make in order to improve their lives. 
 The lot of the Kursk peasant, in 1922 as shortly before 1917, was far more narrow. 
 In his three-field system only investment in land really counted, and the commune, not the individual, controlled most forms of capital. 
 Each annual cycle entailed the repetition of well-tried methods which had to be taken in common. 
 A mentality of servile subordination interspersed by ineffective jacqueries  tended to arise from such conditions. 
 Furthermore there were minimal chances for urban or industrial employment in the vicinity. 
 Worst of all there was very little interlocking between separate communes, a circumstance which was reflected in these peasants' lack of political cohesiveness in the Dumas. 
 When we come to look in detail at the Nikol'skaia peasantry  in 1922, many of these inhibiting features will become more evident. 
 Yet the influence of the socio-economic background alone should not be exaggerated. 
 Note should be taken of the political electoral system under which peasants had to vote, both in the Duma and the early Soviet period. 
 The peasants of the Nikol'skaia volost', in the Duma elections as in 1922, did what all others did throughout Russia. 
 The most enterprising and literate, those few who had travelled, in the army or otherwise, and the thin cream of village intelligenty  (agronomists and the like) everywhere rose to the top in order to represent their less sophisticated brethren. 
 When a great political crisis arose, however, there was little to distinguish the political reactions of the Siberian from the Kursk peasantry. 
 When the Constituent Assembly was dissolved after the 1917 Revolution, and the Bolsheviks' Land Decree had stolen the main plank of the Socialist Revolutionaries' platform, Siberian and Black-Earth peasants alike failed to give any further support to their still loyal party, despite the fact that for a period an SR-dominated Directory prevailed in eastern Russia. 
 The vote for the SRs had been strong in the Kursk and Poltava gubernii. 
 Further non-economic influences that cannot be ignored are ethnic and religious differences. 
 These do not concern us for Kursk guberniia, which was almost exclusively Great Russian and Orthodox, but the traditional independence of the Old Believer elements in the Siberian peasantry must not be forgotten. 
 Kursk differed radically in this way from Poltava, which lay in the Ukraine. 
 It was seen in the last chapter how minority ethnic and religious strands in the Smolensk guberniia presented a potential, though not an actual, source of unified protest against the central Great-Russian regime. 
 Significantly, the European areas of the ex-Empire that had been more pronounced than Belorussia in their ethnic and/or religious divergence from the Great-Russian norm had either broken away from Bolshevik Russia (the Baltic littoral and Finland) or else created serious difficulties for the Bolsheviks (Georgia in 1922). 
 The various provinces of Russia were too many and too mixed to allow of any division into two or a few camps, irrespective of whether socio-economic conditions, nationality, religion, or politics are concerned. 
 Thus in religious and ethnic  matters, Smolensk stood somewhere between safer Kursk and insecure Finland, but numerous other areas were scattered along this spectrum between Finland and Smolensk, and between Smolensk and Kursk. 
 In the present state of our knowledge of provincial life during the late Tsarist and early Soviet periods, no precise scale can as yet be drawn up on any single topic, let alone a general model that encompasses and balances all factors. 
 In 1917 Kursk guberniia was amongst the worst twelve Russian provinces affected by disorganized rural unrest. 
 Four others also fell within the Central Agricultural Region. 
 They all had a long tradition of agrarian troubles, and all suffered from overpopulation and land scarcity. 
 Peasant rental of nonpeasant lands was most widespread here and in the Middle Volga regions. 
 Violence was more widespread than in Smolensk and other gubernii near the fronts, despite the fact that the latter were more subject to disturbances caused by soldiers, according to militia reports. 
 The height of peasant unrest in the Central Agricultural Region was reached in early September 1917; the epicentre was the Koslov uezd of the Tambov guberniia, from where the killing of landowners and sacking of estates spread rapidly to Kursk and other neighbouring gubernii. 
 Conditions in Kursk town seemed propitious for an anti-Bolshevik armed peasant uprising in October. 
 Power lay in the hands of a Committee of Public Safety, which represented all  local parties and institutions. 
 By the end of November the Kursk Soviet had cast aside this committee and set up its own provincial executive in which the Left Socialist Revolutionaries were the largest group. 
 Rural representatives nearly outnumbered urban ones. 
 Anarchists and SRs continued to wield considerable influence into the spring of 1918. 
 In the middle of October 1917 peasants in the guberniia had carried out particularly aggressive seizures of land and timber. 
  According to the Bolsheviks' own admission, the local militia was incapacitated. 
 The diminutive local garrison was ineffectual and demanded more pay. 
 Peasants from nearby gubernii were coming in and exporting wheat. 
 The local railway administrators were terrorized into collaborating. 
 Such tales of peasants stealing grain from one area to take elsewhere, or of refusals to supply it to hungry neighbours, were very common throughout all rural areas in 1917&ndash;18. 
 Acts like these provide the superficial evidence for the failure, in Kursk as elsewhere, to keep Bolshevik encroachment at bay. 
 The deeper reasons have been cited already. 
 The peasants had little notion of belonging to any wider grouping than their own volost', like Nikol'skaia, or even sometimes, and depending on the subject, than their own village. 
 If students in the 1990s have difficulty in distinguishing all the political parties and coalitions that sprang up in Petrograd after the February Revolution, how could a peasant in 1917 be expected to assimilate them in the place of the Tsar, who at least represented a more easily understood form of political authority? 
 Peasant comprehension was low, but far from lacking altogether. 
 It was clear to them in 1917 that if they smashed the local power structure, they were at least achieving some short-term practical aims, such as grabbing woods, estates, and livestock. 
 They realized dimly that, for the moment at least, the Bolsheviks seemed even keener than the SRs to provoke similar disorder at all levels: and their Land Decree seemed indistinguishable from the old SR demands on behalf of the peasantry. 
 An outstanding example of peasant political particularism had occurred in 1921 in the Tambov guberniia bordering on Kursk. 
 This was the best-known and recorded peasant revolt in Soviet history, yet its practical achievements were nil. 
 As in Kursk, so in Tambov the potential had been there. 
 In Tambov town there were reported to be as few as three Bolsheviks on the very eve of the October Revolution. 
 The local Soviet was under the firm control of the SRs. 
 Yet at the height of the Tambov revolt in 1921 only three south-eastern uezdy of the twelve comprising the guberniia were engulfed by  disturbances. 
 Even here the peasantry was soon split as a result of Communist organization and the creation of a privileged group of peasant soldiers whose better food and clothes cut them off from their fellows. 
 More striking still was the failure of the Green movement to link up with Kursk or any other neighbouring area. 
 The Bolsheviks clung to Tambov town and prevented any contact with Makhno to the south in the Ukraine, or with Sapozhkov, another peasant rebel, on the Volga. 
 Antonov, the Tambov leader, probably never realized anyway the strength of his neighbours in a period of chaotic means of communication. 
 Yet it is hardly likely that even if links had been made a ramshackle group of peasant armies using antiquated military techniques could have stood out for long against the Red Army. 
 The effect of the Famine in 1921&ndash;2 was far more crippling in the Volga provinces than in Tambov guberniia, so that one can argue either way as to whether it had a stimulating or depressing effect on the mettle of the Tambov Greens; certainly in Samara and Saratov its vehemence blew out all hope of resistance. 
 More telling were the concessions ceded by NEP. 
 When Antonov was finally caught and killed on 24 June 1922, his slayers were warmly greeted by peasants as the corpse was taken into Tambov. 
 We know this from Soviet accounts, but there is little reason to doubt them. 
 They chime too well with human and especially Russian peasant nature. 
 What can be discounted as nonsense on the other hand is the conclusion drawn by a Soviet historian with regard to the Tambov revolt: &bquo;In that period the kulaks&equo; political banditry became the most important means of struggle by international imperialism, Antonov could not even make contact with subversive elements in Kursk guberniia, let alone London. 
 A closer look at relationships between the party and the people in the Kursk area may be obtained by accompanying Ia. 
 Yakovlev, nine statisticians, and four peasant communists on horseback along the road from Kursk to Nikol'skaia volost, at the end of 1922. 
 Yakovlev at this time was head of the  Agitation and Propaganda Section of the Communist Party. 
 His aim was to assess local reactions to Bolshevik rule in 775 peasant households. 
 By travelling with him we are reversing the process adopted with our peasant woman in the Smolensk guberniia. 
 Here the rulers are going to the ruled and examining them from their point of view. 
 The first change they noticed as a result of the Revolution was the indiscriminate and wasteful hacking down of the woods by the peasants: large trees had merely been deprived of their thinner branches. 
 Schoolhouses were soon easy to spot by their lack of doors and window frames and dilapidated thatched roofs. 
 They had been abandoned and pillaged. 
 In many ways, however, the old customs continued. 
 Although younger peasants stared with curiosity at the little band of visitors, the old ones made deep bows &mdash; &bquo;the legacy of the age of serfdom&equo;, as Yikovlev commented. 
 The best-kept huts were still those of the village priests. 
 They were the only ones with glass windows and metal roofs. 
 Outside one church the crowd of peasants young and old was so large that it was reminiscent of Repin's famous painting of 1882 of a church procession in this pious guberniia. 
 On asking the reason for such an assembly, Yakovlev was told that the local priest had refused to marry any couples unless the community attended services. 
 Here there was not the slightest evidence of &bquo;religion and Communism making an excellent household together&equo;, as Izvestiia  now reported. 
 Another sign of the past was carefully concealed from passing strangers, but Yakovlev's interest was aroused by the frequent sight of windowless huts with smoke pouring out from all sides of their thatched roofs. 
 On entering one, he discovered a home-brew still which the owners broke up in a trice, handing the retort to Yakovlev &bquo;as a trophy&equo;. 
 This practice was very widespread in Kursk as opposed to the Smolensk guberniia. 
 It was a prime grain-producing area with poor access to markets. 
 A barter economy still prevailed widely in 1922, so that alcohol was a money substitute that kept and travelled better than grain. 
 As one peasant put it to Yakovlev on a later  occasion: No one will help you for cash, but everyone will for home-brew.&equo; 
 A local priest was even so bold as to call the system &bquo;a home-brew democracy&hellip;. 
 In the towns they drink wine and liqueurs, but we can't do that in the villages&hellip; the result is that the gents can drink, but it's forbidden to the lower classes.&equo; 
 Another difference between Nikol'skaia and Roslavl' was the obvious greater isolation of the former, although it was nearer to the guberniia capital. 
 That did not mean much, since Kursk was itself a drowsy centre with almost no factories and only the main railway line from Moscow to enliven it. 
 As late as 1926 90.9 per cent of all inhabitants in the guberniia were in rural locations, one of the highest percentages for European Russia. 
 Nikol'skaia volost' had actually become even more cut off since 1917. 
 Whereas only 146 households out of 775 had lacked any horses, the number had risen to 175 by 1922. 
 Virtually all local trading was transacted in grain rather than in cash, thus limiting peasants' ability to travel far with their heavy &bquo;money&equo; loads. 
 Prior to 1917 there had been two annual fairs ( iarmarki ) in the area, but only one of them had been revived in 1921, with a quarter of its previous turnover. 
 In the past some craft-trading had been carried on beyond the vicinity, but this and nearly all other economic ties with the Ukraine to the south and their fellow Great Russians to the north had stopped. 
 The picture was even worse with regard to information from outside. 
 Out of the 775 households in five villages, only one, headed by an ex-merchant, subscribed to a newspaper of any kind. 
 Even Ivanovka, the only village not far from the Moscow railway line, had received its last single copy of a newspaper some months prior to Yakovlev's visit. 
 A striking example of the area's isolation occurred when Yakovlev and his thirteen men arrived at the end of their horse-ride in the village of Nikol'sk. 
 Since 1917 the locals had never seen such a large group of visitors. 
 As a result the peasant gathering (skhod) which happened to be scheduled then assembled an unusually high number of villagers. 
 All they could imagine was that some  new sort of tax was to be imposed on them. 
 They were relieved to find that this was not just another &bquo;Communist trick&equo;. 
 How was the common lot of this audience changing in 1922? 
 The number of working hands had risen in the volost' from 577 in 1917 to 872 now. 
 This was mainly due to demobilization, but others may have been attracted to the region due to the fact that through the expropriation of landowners, the area held by peasants had gone up by 65 per cent since 1917. 
 This huge increase should have allayed the peasants' suspicions of the new regime, but this was hot the case. 
 By 1922 only 232 households owned a plough, whilst 278 lacked even a primitive wooden plough with which to turn over their new earth, if indeed they possessed any. 
 In 1917 a mere fifty-three households had been able to sell off excess grain. 
 In 1920 this figure dropped to twelve, despite the fact that this area suffered less in the Civil War than Smolensk guberniia. 
 By the end of 1922 the figure had jumped to a remarkable 155, showing that recovery was on the way and economic activity increasing. 
 Another sign of security was the rising number of households which did not need to buy seeds, but planted their own 634 in the autumn of 1922, as against 554 in 1920. 
 The other side of the coin was the increasing subjection in 1922 of the poor peasants to those better off. 
 Yakovlev may have exaggerated this shift, given the abstract Marxist tenets on class struggle that he came equipped with from Moscow, but there was already some objective evidence of this right at the start of NEP. 
 Peasants told his collaborators that under NEP conditions not even the poorest received financial help and advice on sowing and agricultural methods from the local Soviets, as they had done previously, during the period of War Communism. 
 When the cutting of timber free of charge was prohibited, it affected the poor peasants most severely. 
 They could not afford to buy a horse, and although the richer peasants were more heavily taxed, this did not compensate for the wide difference in equipment, which was not taxed. 
 As there were up to sixteen different taxes, the more ignorant, who were usually also the poorest, were compelled to run to their more fortunate fellows for  advice on how to calculate, time, and pay (or avoid paying) these complex dues. 
 Another kind of hazard was already looming on the horizon for the weaker peasant elements. 
 As trade slowly picked up, so did the number of non-peasant traders. 
 They were later to acquire the vague title of &bquo;Nepmen&equo;, but in 1922 they were not so clear-cut a phenomenon, and even by the end of NEP it was not possible, despite all Bolshevik propaganda efforts, to lump their origins and subsequent characteristics into the same abstract pigeon-hole. 
 Their diverse origins can be seen in the microcosm of Nikol'skaia volost' alone. 
 Most scholars, both Soviet and Western, have thought that Nepmen sprang up from nowhere like mushrooms under the gentle economic rain of NEP. 
 In fact many of them were pre-1917 private traders who surfaced again after 1921. 
 The richest local personality was Dmitrii Alekseevich D'iakov. 
 After twenty years of trading in the volost' and in Kursk town he came to own by 1914 eight houses (four of them in Kursk) and had a turnover of a million roubles. 
 In 1918 his stock was confiscated, but he became chairman of the cooperative to which it was assigned. 
 By 1919 he was also heading a government grain-collecting centre. 
 When this job terminated at the start of NEP, he became the State Bank's Kursk agent for purchasing grain. 
 In December 1922 he resigned graciously to return to his large goods store which had already started up in June. 
 Here Yakovlev met him surrounded by packed shelves and metals acquired with two months' credit from the Tartar Republic. 
 He confessed that everyone trusted him now, as they had done in the old days. 
 Three other local traders from pre-war times had also acted as careful vicars of Bray until 1922. 
 All had served for state organizations during the period 1917&ndash;21. 
 One had served as chairman of a local Soviet through these years, with a canny transformation into starosta  (village elder) when the White Army appeared briefly. 
 Another had kept a continual eye on the grain trade by serving in a Red Army supply regiment and then managing a state grain-collecting centre. 
 Of the new &bquo;Nepmen&equo;, two were Jews who had come in from  some other guberniia, and the other three all had military experience but little capital in goods or cash. 
 Nevertheless they were to flourish. 
 From a monthly turnover of 400 roubles at the end of December 1922, one of them was to rise to a turnover of 2,000 by March 1923. 
 At the time of Yakovlev's visit, the state-controlled grain organizations still controlled 45 per cent of all trading turnover in goods and cash, as opposed to 12 per cent through private hands, but Yakovlev realized that the balance was changing quickly in favour of the Nepmen. 
 Thus not long after the start of NEP, in a province as sleepy as Kursk, we find already the seeds of socio-economic decay, from a Marxist point of view (Yakovlev's), leading to possible political difficulties for the centre. 
 The irony was that many Nepmen had in fact been nurtured by the state during the harsh economic stringencies of War Communism. 
 Here, as so often when one penetrates to particulars, the rigid historiographical divisions (War Communism, NEP, the Five-Year Plan years) crumble. 
 In our survey of the financial arrangements of NEP as they applied to the Smolensk guberniia, it was noted how they were unstable and poorly defined from the outset, leading to economic and social tensions at the lower levels. 
 Right from its inception NEP carried within itself the germs of its own fatal illness, whether one looks at its fiscal organization or the economic persona (like these Nepmen) which it soon evoked, or in many cases re-awakened. 
 It is true that high-level Bolshevik theorists in Moscow and Petrograd tended to select, filter, and interpret evidence from the localities in the light of their prevailing general beliefs, so that their conclusions had little foundation in hard evidence. 
 Yet although Yakovlev was one of their kind, his factual findings show little sign of conscious or unconscious censorship or exclusion. 
 What we do find, as with the few collective farms in Roslavl', is an obsession with possible growth-points admired by the Bolsheviks. 
 Yakovlev devotes loving attention to the single, insignificant sovkhoz  (state farm) in the whole area, although it only employed eleven people. 
 If only more leading Bolsheviks had left their ivory tower in the Kremlin in early NEP in order to examine Russia at first hand, as Yakovlev did,  the reifications that poured out from their pens and mouths might not have succeeded in obscuring the realities of actual life in the 1920s. 
 On reaching the rarefied heights of Moscow politics, more attention will be paid to the ideas of Lenin and others on smychka, the Marxist-Leninist theory of town and country alliance. 
 At this point of our journey attempts at smychka in practice between the more sophisticated and politically orthodox in and out of the party, and the Nikol'skaia peasantry, can be considered. 
 The volost' party cell and its activities are taken first, before moving to less politically secure organs like the local village Soviets and the Komsomol (Young Communist League). 
 Then other potentially useful agents, the ex-military, and teachers, will be examined. 
 At first sight the very core of party support appeared to be rotten. 
 The party cell contained several dubious characters. 
 Only three of the eleven members were peasants. 
 Two of the others, including the chairman, were using their positions to feather their own nests. 
 The cell secretary told Yakovlev that &bquo;for one named Kochergin and for the chairman of the cell they &lsqb;the peasants&rsqb; have stabbing eyes.&equo; 
 Kochergih was the son of a merchant, from the same type of background as D'iakov. 
 The cell members said that four of them read papers regularly (that is, once a week), four read them seldom, and the rest very rarely. 
 One member shone out from this picture of lethargy and petty corruption. 
 He was a former horse-vet who provided the teachers with food when it was short, criticized the priests, and guarded the local fire-carts. 
 This latter task was not as trivial as may be supposed in a society where wood and straw huts burnt down regularly. 
 There were no cell meetings open to the public. 
 The cell failed to send anyone to take part in the few educational courses available, such as those arranged by the agricultural station. 
 Its total energy seemed to be expended on the collection of taxes, and like Yakovlev himself, it had no interest in the mainsprings of peasant culture. 
 It comes as no surprise to discover from another source that in 1921 the Kursk guberniia party committee had tried to deal with these problems;  &bquo;the purge of the party was the first basic step towards the strengthening of the personnel of the party and yielded enormous results.&equo; 
 This declaration proved to be premature, although a recommendation that there should be a longer term for the candidate stage towards full party membership must have provided a useful mechanism for sifting the wheat from the chaff. 
 The reasons for the centre's heed fur taxes like the prodnalog and many others had not been made clear to the villagers by the party cell. 
 The peasants saw the cell as just one more town agency that confined itself to tax gathering, as all other organizations from the centre had done in history. 
 Indeed since eight of the eleven cell members were not peasants, they probably fell easily into this view of their own roles. 
 When an anti-tubercular campaign was initiated by the cell, the peasants called it the &bquo;tubercular tax&equo;, because money gathering methods were applied. 
 The party cell was afraid to have open meetings mainly because it feared criticism from what it called the &bquo; kulaks' . 
 Yakovlev acquiesced in this polemical and unfounded notion. 
 In actuality it was the poorer peasants who grumbled louder and suffered more from taxation, as Yakovlev was to discover for himself a year later in Tambov guberniia. 
 He at least, unlike his superiors in ideology in Moscow had the courage to revise his stereotyped class views in a second book he published in 1924. 
 He found that a poor Tambov peasant who harvested 35 pudy of grain from one desiatin of land had to pay 15 pudy of it for the hire of a plough, 7 pudy for having the grain carted off in a richer man's wagon, and to top it all 7 pudy in tax. 
 This left a mere 6 pudy for his family's consumption and to provide seed. 
 The crux of the problem lay in the lack of equipment. 
 In 1922 on average throughout European Russia and Siberia the percentage of peasant households without a plough was about 23 per cent. 
 In the Revolution landowners had disposed of large quantities of farm equipment to those who could afford it. 
 Subsequently only the latter  could pay to have complicated machinery repaired. 
 None of the sixteen taxes endured by the Nikol'skaia peasants was aimed at capital held in the form of equipment. 
 Despite the trials of many peasants in 1922, the Nikol'skaia villagers tolerated the party cell although they disliked some individuals within it. 
 Cell members themselves seemed to be much more impervious to the danger of possible political attacks on them than their nervous counterparts in Smolensk guberniia. 
 This difference appears to be a clear reflection of the traditional lack of political sophistication amongst Black-Earth peasants. 
 The quiet but bitter resignation of the vast majority was expressed to Yakovlev by one of them in this way: &bquo;A peasant is a sheep, and whoever wants his wool fleeces him. 
 The Tsar, the landowner, Denikin's troops, and your Comrades all fleeced him. 
 But now they'll have to spare his wool, or they'll rip off his hide and then there'll be no wool left to fleece.&equo; 
 Even at the level of the Nikol'sk village Soviet a high proportion of time was spent on tax problems. 
 Rabkrin  (the Central Workers' and Peasants' Inspectorate) calculated that at the start of 1923 from 20 to 26 per cent of all village Soviet business lay in this sphere, whereas cultural and commune activities took up only 5 to 10 per cent of their time. 
 In the village Soviets of the Nikol'skaia volost' 162 out of the 775 households had served since 1917 in some capacity. 
 This very high participation rate was due to the fast turnover in membership, especially of the chairmen, who were very poorly paid in a time of rapid inflation. 
 Two criteria had governed their election. 
 The leading one was that there were sufficient other able-bodied persons in the household to enable one of them to be freed for Soviet work. 
 The other indicator was political. 
 When the Soviets were first set up, richer peasants had become chairmen, but soon and throughout the period of War Communism poor peasants had replaced them. 
 Now, in 1922, some  of the same rich peasants were making a reappearance together with newly prosperous ones. 
 Relations between the village Soviets and the peasants varied according to local socio-economic conditions, not only from one region of Russia to another, but even between Nikol'sk and Ivanovka, roughly 75 km. apart. 
 The Nikol'sk Soviet was dominated by an ex-merchant, who was chairman. 
 He could compensate for his low official pay by means of the strings he could pull in conjunction with the other few rich peasants in the commune. 
 Most of the other peasants were poor, but almost as deferential to the Soviet as the old men who bowed to Yakovlev along the road. 
 They described their prosperous neighbours on the Soviet as &bquo;very wise and understanding&equo;, not only because they had proved it by accumulating a little property, but above all because they were pismennye , or literate. 
 They had also survived what was referred to locally as the &bquo;Old Economic Policy&equo;, or War Communism, which was universally disliked, even by the poorest. 
 As one of them related to Yakovlev, he had tried to get straw from his brother in a nearby village when he ran out of lighting-fuel, but officials had stopped him, since he was stealing &bquo;from the poor&hellip; there's sucilizm ( sic ) for you&equo;, Ivanovka Soviet on the other hand was managed by no obvious clique, and the very few rich peasants had no general influence in the village, which contained no poor households but a lot of middling ones. 
 Yakovlev found this contrast with Nikol'sk bizarre and inexplicable, but he should not have done. 
 The combination of deference to prosperity and literacy from one side, and the manipulation of equipment, local goods stores, and the like on the other easily created a vicious circle in Nikol'sk which could not be repeated in Ivanovka. 
 One of the prime aims of the system of Soviets was being thwarted in this region, and in many others throughout Russia. 
 This was to draw the &bquo;poor&equo; and &bquo;middle&equo; peasants away from the private trade of the &bquo;rich&equo; and to turn them eventually towards an alliance (smychka) with urban inhabitants. 
  Another important purpose was to use the village Soviets as gates through which peasants would enter into wider administrative experience and escape from the stifling parochialism of the mir and the skhod. 
 This goal too appeared to be self-defeating in the Nikol'skaia volost'. 
 It was true that there were now &bquo;whole chanceries&equo; of paperwork in the offices of village-Soviet secretaries, but most of the secretaries had worked for the volost' in the Tsarist regime and were somewhat suspect. 
 Other local agencies seemed to be flourishing. 
 There were now 13 militiamen as against 6 in the old regime; 7 secretaries in the medical centre as against 2; 72 administrators in the uezd-level agricultural centre as against 16. 
 The trouble was that their general educational standard was much lower than in the past. 
 In 1922 11.6 per cent of all village Soviet officials were illiterate. 
 Also there was a marked tendency for all efficient personnel, especially Communists, to move quickly up the hierarchy from the villages to the guberniia centres. 
 At the highest levels by 1922 there was an almost complete overlap of personnel between party and Soviet committees. 
 This meant that the localities were overstaffed with poorly paid semiliterates at the receiving end of an ever-growing mountain of paperwork from the hyperactive guberniia towns and from Moscow. 
 The result, at least in Nikol'skaia volost', was that the few literates from the old regime were starting to occupy the best bureaucratic jobs and to run parish-pump economics and politics in ways barely supervised from above and in fact quite inimical to the aspirations of the guberniia officials. 
 Yakovlev realized this, and recommended that party men be sent out in large numbers from Moscow and the guberniia towns. 
 Not only should they fill posts in the lower Soviets &mdash; they should grasp the core of the political problem, which was cultural in essence: they would have to run the literary points, the schools, and the agricultural centres themselves in order to push the peasantry into the twentieth century and towards socialism. 
 It was the age-old problem that had not been solved since the Populists first went to the people in the 1870s.  
 For lack of sufficient members in the countryside, the party had to rely on the most lively agents to effect smychka between itself and the masses. 
 Although the Komsomol in 1922 only enveloped 0.8 per cent of ill peasant youth, there did exist a cell in the Nikol'skaia volost', and seven of its twelve members were peasants. 
 Unfortunately their crude tactics, due to a very low educational level, made them better counter-agents than agents for the Bolsheviks. 
 They had not seen the party programme and regulations, nor any copy of their own journal Young Guard . 
 They tried to drive the adult peasants into paying their taxes, instead of coaxing them. 
 They spread round vicious tales about the priests, yet they had read nothing (those that could read) on religion. 
 A local priest told Yakovlev that the Komsomols were the most eager and confirmed &bquo;Communists&equo;, but then he had met no real ones to judge them by. 
 The Komsomols themselves knew they did not understand the instructions they got from the party cell, and said so, but received no advice as a result. 
 Yakovlev himself dismissed the Komsomols as &bquo;scamps&equo;, and turned to demobilized Red Army men as another feasible link between party and people. 
 This category was now proving vital to Bolshevik organization in the Roslavl' uezd, even if much of its work was more like security and espionage rather than positive encouragement to the peasantry to collaborate with the party. 
 In the five villages of the Nikol'skaia volost' there were no less than twenty to twenty-five ex-servicemen in each. 
 Their political knowledge surpassed that of the members of the party cell. 
 They were more articulate, had seen something of the wider world, retained a thirst for knowledge, and were sceptical towards the Church. 
 Yet this apparently admirable material proved to be of almost no use to the party. 
 They feared that if they refused to marry or baptize their children in church, they would be ostracized in a particularly religiously minded part of Russia. 
 They were sharp enough to realize that if they joined the party cell, they would likewise be cut off from their fellows for other reasons. 
 In their view the older generation could never be persuaded of the value of a proletarian ideology. 
 So they gave excuses of shortage of time or  involvement in other activities to explain why they did not register for the rural party cell. 
 One soldier even hid from Yakovlev the fact that he was a party member. 
 It may be imagined that the village schoolteachers could establish cultural ties between party and peasant, but some of the weaknesses of these agents have already been revealed in the Smolensk guberniia. 
 Those that had not fled out of fear, political animosity to the Bolsheviks, or for lack of food and pay, were apt to be shackled as much by their own situation as by peasant recalcitrance to learn. 
 Since the start of NEP schoolteachers had had to rely on the local mir, skhod, or Soviet for their pay. 
 Any attempt on their part in, say, Nikol'sk village, to undermine the new controlling clique of richer peasants and nascent Nepmen through Communist-inspired teaching on class structure in the local school would result in their immediate loss of livelihood. 
 Many peasants, particularly the less well off, still preferred the priest as a source of education. 
 As one told Yakovlev: &bquo;the priest is well taught, you can't chuck him out. 
 We don't want any new religion: a new religion means new churches. 
 We'd have to pay out more money, so let's stick to the old one.&equo; 
 The schoolhouses had been left empty in the Revolution, and then ransacked by peasants, as the Bolshevik investigators had noticed on their way to Nikol'skaia. 
 When questioned about this, one peasant retorted &bquo;From where else are we to take thatch, there's nothing left on which to feed the livestock,&equo; An exception proved the rule. 
 One peasant walked 15 versts to get Yakovlev to act on a building designated for a school that was still occupied by an influential peasant. 
 He was granted his request, but he walked another 40 versts to the uezd party committee to see that the promise was kept. 
 If necessary he would walk to Lenin himself in Moscow. 
 In this &bquo;Leninist&equo;, as he was dubbed, still shone that na&iuml;ve peasant trust in the very highest authority that had  kept the Romanovs secure for so long. 
 This anonymous peasant sensed intuitively the lack of communication between the centre and the grass roots, and was prepared to overcome it through personal effort. 
 In any backward society the role of sympathetic intermediary agents and interpreters between high and rural politics is crucial. 
 They have to ensure the concrete yet flexible transmission of written, central theories to illiterates by means of patient speech and demonstration. 
 Their kind was sadly lacking in Nikol'skaia volost' in 1922. 
 The plight of the teachers became even worse in 1923. 
 The central authorities, late as usual, grasped this detail of local life by 1924, when Krupskaia at the Thirteenth Party Congress noted that due to the tightening of the economic &bquo;scissors&equo;, the higher bread prices could no longer be afforded by starving village-teachers. 
 For lack of sympathetic agents, the peasants were often left to their own devices in matters of general and even political culture. 
 Yakovlev observed that state publications for 1922 from Gosizdat and Krasnaia Nov' included nothing on agricultural and rural affairs. 
 How could the undiluted works of Kautsky and Engels appeal to this audience at a time when even party members at lower levels rarely understood the meaning of such concrete words as &bquo;official&equo;, &bquo;categorical&equo;, &bquo;Plenum&equo;, &bquo;memorandum&equo;, or &bquo;territory&equo;? 
 Only five peasants in the whole of Nikol'skaia volost' had read any political or agricultural texts. 
 The minds of the other literate villagers were dissipated on what they could pick up in a random manner: most of it naturally consisted of religious tracts, the traditional fodder left over from the past. 
 To sum up, in 1922 the Soviet government found itself in a situation similar to that of the late Tsarist regime, which in its final years had grasped the connection between literacy and modernization and between formal schoolwork and social control. 
 Neither political system could rely with confidence on those to whom it entrusted the task of educating the peasants. 
  Yakovlev's group understood this perfectly well. 
 They advocated the promotion of party schools at the guberniia level to speed up the educational attainments of local leaders so that they really could set the tone in political culture in sufficient numbers without having to depend so much on shaky agents. 
 Yakovlev wanted to see eight to ten thousand new cultural workers sent to the villages over the next two to three years. 
 This large number would still provide just one per volost' in the largest of all countries. 
 The gulf between peasant and party which Yakovlev noticed in the Kursk guberniia was typical of all rural localities in early NEP, despite their enormous local differences from each other in every other way. 
 It was the case in Smolensk, and the position was very similar in Poltava, the guberniia to the southwest which we shall be visiting shortly. 
 During this same period a far wider survey had been undertaken of all the fifty-nine party cells in the Poltava guberniia. 
 It was found that scant attention had been paid to raising the cultural level of party members. 
 As to the wider dissemination of culture, the few cells that had been active in this respect seemed to equate success with the regular dispatch of newspapers and made no personal contacts to follow this up. 
 In other spheres the results of the Poltava survey were closely reminiscent of the Nikol'skaia findings. 
 There were no discussions at all on the improvement of the peasant economy, despite the fact that they would have reaped quick propaganda rewards for the Bolshevik Party. 
 This was the earth of which Aleksei Tolstoy wrote: &bquo;Know ye the land where all breathes plenty and content, where rivers flow as silver clear.&equo; 
 It comprised some of the very best of the Black-Earth belt, but after the Revolution it had been trampled over first by the Red Army advancing on Kiev from Kharkov, then by the German 20th Army Corps, and later by ruthless and bloodthirsty &bquo;Green&equo; armies. 
 The worst peasant uprisings in the Civil War had been against German expeditions in search of food supplies. 
 If there had to be a foreign, non-Ukrainian government  in Poltava, then for the local peasantry Great Russians were preferable to Germans. 
 Yet the Bolsheviks made no political capital out of the recent past. 
 As in Nikol'skaia volost, all fifty-nine Poltava cells spent nearly all their time and energy on tax-collecting and expediting administrative directives from higher authorities. 
 Let us now leave the Great Russians of the Kursk guberniia and move out of the hills to the south of Nikol'skaia volost'. 
 Eventually the plains of the eastern Ukraine are reached, and the city of Kharkov. 
 It was atypical of most provincial towns in that it had been a thriving industrial centre for some time, and was taking off again after the disruption caused by the Civil War. 
 We would be imitating the Bolsheviks' own rose-tinted over-concentration on their favourite study topics (like the proletariat state and collective farms) if we lingered here too long. 
 On the other hand any balanced survey of early Soviet society cannot ignore the presence in certain pockets of strong working-class forces. 
 The proletariat of the guberniia capital of Tver and Moscow city will be studied in more detail in 1926. 
 The special case of a disseminated labour force, the railway and other communications workers, will be looked at for 1922. 
 In 1917 roughly one million had been employed on the Russian railway network. 
 The town census of 1923 gave the population of Kharkov as 324,500. 
 Like its larger industrial brothers, Petrograd and Moscow, it had declined fast between 1917 and 1920 (the number of inhabitants fell by a quarter). 
 Yet by the end of 1926 its strength would rise to 417,300, of whom 28.8 per cent were industrial workers, and 13.5 per cent independent traders, including kustary. 
 In 1926 38.3 per cent of the population were Ukrainian as against 37.9 at the time of the 1923 census. 
 Kharkov was a major centre for metallurgy, chemical, and machine-building plants. 
 By 1924, when these industries had re-established themselves, one-fifth of all factory workers in the Ukraine were concentrated in the Kharkov and Ekaterina  gubernii. 
 The kustar' system, which recovered much faster than heavy industry, had 122 arteli  in the city in 1922. 
 They organized a craft exhibition in January that attracted interest from abroad. 
 The more isolated character of Kursk guberniia may be illustrated by the fact that the whole province contained only 595 arteli. 
 Although most of the new recruits to Kharkov's metallurgical plants in 1914&ndash;17 had been ex-peasants from western Ukraine, there was no danger of nationalist sentiment ousting the Bolsheviks from the city. 
 They had wrested factory management from the hands of the very right-wing Congress of Mining Industrialists which had disallowed even neutral forms of workers' control in 1917. 
 For part of the Civil War Kharkov rather than Kiev became the temporary capital of the Ukraine, and a Bolshevik military stronghold. 
 Its civilian upper echelons remained predominantly Great Russian into the 1920s. 
 As we travel south-west along the main road to Poltava, the feeling of being under secure Bolshevik rule recedes. 
 In this rural area there had been no fewer than nineteen peasant uprisings in 1919. 
 It was clear from the reports on fifty-nine cells in this guberniia that collaboration between the party and the people was minimal. 
 The density of population in this finest of all Black-Earth regions rose to 60&ndash;70 per sq. 
 km. 
 There were scarcely any towns of significance near Poltava. 
 As in Kursk guberniia, the classical three-field system prevailed, but there was more variety. 
 The lucrative sugar-beet industry had led to the buying up of large tracts of land before the World War. 
 The production of vegetable oil, especially sunflower seed, was also important. 
 The climate becomes more benign as we move nearer to the Black Sea. 
 Male peasants in the fields wear their distinctive broad-brimmed straw hats, with their coats hanging loosely over their shoulders.  
 Six kilometres short of Poltava we turn aside from the highway into a colony for homeless vagabond children run by Anton Makarenko. 
 He had come here in the autumn of 1920. 
 Born in 1888 of working-class parents in Belopole, a small Ukrainian town, he had graduated from the Poltava Teachers' Institute in 1917 with a gold medal. 
 He then taught in a higher elementary school, but became critical of the local Bolsheviks' lack of progress in educational and social affairs. 
 As a challenge the chief of the Poltava guberniia Department of Education offered him the directorship of this residential school for war-orphans. 
 The human contents of the colony were symptomatic of the general state of Russia in 1922. 
 The Civil War was over, but the social repercussions of external and internal war and revolution flowed on right through the 1920s. 
 Young victims from all over the Ukraine and far beyond came in and out of Makarenko's institution. 
 There are social phenomena that are specific to confined areas: that is why any survey of Soviet politics and society must refer to discrete geographical localities. 
 Yet even in a country so vast and diverse as the ex-Empire, there were some features that affected most parts, and set up their own horizontal influences at all lower levels of society irrespective of any vertical political pressures acting from a single centre. 
 The orphans were one of these phenomena, as was the great Famine of 1921 2. 
 So that although reference is made here to a remote children's colony, its social significance had much wider reverberations, as indeed did the pedagogical theories worked out by Makarenko. 
 At the end of NEP the author of an article in the Bolshevik Encyclopaedia  claimed that Russian orphanages were &bquo;the result of capitalist exploitation of the masses&equo;. 
 Krupskaia admitted more truthfully that at least three-quarters of their inmates were the result of contemporary conditions, not of past sufferings. 
 Since 1914 millions of Russians had been on the move &mdash; four to five million away from the advancing armies of the Central Powers; at least twelve million fleeing into exile during and after the Revolution; the largest land army in the world  manoeuvring, dying, and deserting from the longest front-line in history &mdash; to give the major examples alone, with very approximate numbers. 
 The Famine affected many more millions further east. 
 Parents left children in food asylums by the thousands. 
 The traditional founts of charity, the church and the local gentry, had dried up. 
 Jobs were unavailable in the towns to which the hordes of young found their way. 
 Overnight the new Soviet government, with plans for social welfare that on paper went far beyond those of Scandinavia or Britain in 1945, had to take over. 
 It set up a succession of bodies to deal with the problem, but in 1922 it actually cut back expenditure, already insufficient, in this sphere. 
 Krupskaia reported in early 1923 that seven million bezprizornye  (neglected ones) were registered; Lunacharsky later put the early NEP figure at nine million. 
 The pressure was still so great by 1924 that 40 per cent of all urban youths under the age of 18 were unemployed. 
 In 1920 the government discussed the idea of placing the bezprizornye in Red Army units. 
 At the end of the Civil War roughly one-quarter of a million roved around the Ukraine, a region that had suffered greatly from the hostilities. 
 These orphans and vagabonds were just one group among many that were virtually lawless in the disturbed countryside. 
 Leaving the reasonably safe confines of Kharkov town was like quitting E. Zamiatin's proletarian city for the rough no man's land of instinctive outsiders as described in his famous anti-Utopian novel My . 
 The workings of the legal system in 1922 will be examined in a later chapter as one aspect of Bolshevik control over society, and the general extent of crime will be noted. 
 In the daily life of Makarenko's colony crime can be observed in microcosm. 
 For a long time after his arrival there, armed groups of various kinds continued to be chased through the nearby woods by Red Army units. 
 Every evening throughout 1922 a band of youths from the colony volunteered to guard the local stretch of the main road into Poltava. 
 This was to prevent attacks by bandits on  travellers whose cries floated nightly over the fields to the colony. 
 Another youth patrol fended off neighbouring peasants who constantly tried to fell trees belonging to the colony (shades of Nikol'skaia volost'). 
 They had already carefully taken away the entire orchard, roots and all, and the glass and window frames from the hostel buildings. 
 Makarenko was thus driven to take the law into his own hands in order to survive, but his pupils needed no encouragement in this respect, since they themselves were the product of a disturbed society. 
 Makarenko describes them in this way: 
 During those early years of the colony's existence we received very few of the homeless children who had grown accustomed to street wandering. 
 The majority of the colonists had only recently lost contact with their families. 
 During the war and the revolution many old criminal families, living on the outskirts of the town or in bandit villages, left their influence behind even after they had been broken up. 
 The weakening of family ties during the war &mdash; through death, evacuation, and executions &mdash; led to many youngsters becoming accustomed to wandering as regimental camp-followers in Tsarist, White, Red, or guerrilla bands. 
 These lads were adventurers who had acquired the habit of applying a simplified anarchistic logic to life, involving contempt for all property, contempt for life and human personality, contempt for cleanliness, order, and so on. 
 But they were not used to wandering by themselves, in the manner of the later homeless children. 
 Bands of boys and girls from the colony made illegal forays that were countenanced by Makarenko just in order to live. 
 Their thefts of milk, honey, and melons from local household plots he ironically termed as acts of smychka. 
 They also smashed up the peasants' illicit vodka stills. 
 More striking examples of lawlessness took place in Makarenko's dealings with several local authorities. 
 They are indicative of the government's shaky hold over grass-roots politics. 
 In 1922 Makarenko acquired the nearby estate of Trepke as a more suitable future home for his colony. 
 The local village Soviet, whose members Makarenko referred to as &bquo;a lot of parasites&equo;, declared that the Trepke cistern was state property. 
  The issue was solved, not by due legal process, but by a brawl between the colonists and the village lads, who were chased back into the Soviet building which was later smashed up. 
 Nevertheless the official surveyors who came to map the Trepke boundaries remained too afraid to go into the fields of the estate. 
 When the Soviet sent the militia to the colony in order to accuse the inmates of robbing peasants, Makarenko sent even it packing. 
 He showed the same scant respect for other agents of central power. 
 His opinion of the local Komsomol was no doubt coloured by the fact that his own colony was a kind of rival organization, but his view broadly reflects that of Yakovlev on the Nikol'skaia Komsomol; Yakovlev was a more disinterested outsider. 
 Makarenko wrote: &bquo;The local Young Communists were very weak in both number and quality. 
 They were far too interested in girls and vodka, and they had a rather negative influence on the colonists.&equo; 
 Soviet historians have subsequently tried to cover over this situation. 
 They have written that &bquo;It is well known that the great Soviet pedagogue, A. S. Makarenko, succeeded in forming a genuine Soviet collective of charges only after a Komsomol organization was established in his colony.&equo; 
 In reality, a Komsomol political instructor (with a criminal record) entered the colony in 1925, well after Makarenko had established discipline. 
 This Komsomol representation apparently played no role in the subsequent administration of the colony. 
 Makarenko also dealt summarily with the Poltava educational authorities who had appointed him in the first place. 
 He made fun of the pseudo-learned, bureaucratic speech of an inspector which began like this: 
 The localized system of medico-pedagogical influence on a child, in so far as it is differentiated in an institution for social education, ought to prevail to the extent that it is in accordance with the natural needs of the child and to the extent that it opens creative prospects for  the development of the given structure &mdash; biological, social, and economic. 
 Arising out of this, we consider&hellip; 
 This reads just like the conversational style of the Soviet satirist of NEP, M. Zoshchenko. 
 It was used in a similar way by the newly literate or semi-literate Bolsheviks at the higher levels of the Smolensk and Kursk guberniia party organizations, as can be seen from even a cursory reading of their minutes. 
 This style also reflects the attempt by the political &eacute;lite in Moscow to hand down to the provinces general directives which were as sophisticated as possible and based on Marxist tenets in so far as they could be understood at lower levels. 
 Zoshchenko could caricature them in the 1920s, but by the 1930s it became too dangerous to ridicule what had solidified into a standardized bureaucratic mode of oppression. 
 Makarenko went further than making fun of educational inspectors. 
 When they tried to stop him from taking into the colony a youth from the Political Special Section of the Army First Reserves, he appealed over their heads to the Workers' and Peasants' Inspectorate ( Rabkrin ), which came down on his side. 
 This is not the first time nor the last that we encounter this influential organization. 
 It was one of the more effective Bolshevik controls as early as 1922, and not only in negative ways. 
 When the colony ran short of horses, the manager of the Economic Section of Rabkrin offered to lend some in exchange for wheels and wheat. 
 He drew up an agreement in two copies, setting out the terms in ponderous detail: &bquo;&hellip; referred to henceforth as &bquo;the colony'&equo;&hellip; which wheels shall be considered as handed over to the Economic Section of the Provincial Workers' and Peasants' Inspection after their reception by a special commission and the signing of the corresponding protocol.&equo; 
 During his inspection of Nikol'skaia volost', Yakovlev prided himself on his objectivity in criticizing local party activities, given that he was a highly orthodox representative of the central apparatus with a broad knowledge of all-Russian affairs. 
 In sharp contrast Makarenko was a deep provincial who had an independent, determined mind. 
 He was never to become a party member, and was not conversant with Marxist  ideas in 1922. 
 In any case Marxism was broad enough to lend itself to different educational interpretations. 
 Makarenko made the important deduction that as the theories discarded at the Revolution had not been replaced by precise new ones, the abstract and muddled notions of officials like the education inspector were no substitute for practical self-help. 
 This colony was virtually self-subsistent, in management methods as in food. 
 Its solidarity was achieved by its sense of being a small-scale unit isolated from the rest of society, and frequently preying on it in 1922. 
 There was a moral dilemma here, since what was good for the survival of the colony was harmful for others in a society which Makarenko wished to see participating in group ownership on collective lines. 
 Education and socialization were almost synonymous in his view. 
 He wanted to incorporate the individual into the collective in a way that he believed himself to belong to it &mdash; freely and without compulsion. 
 This noble idea was all very well in the relatively lax atmosphere and control of early NEP, with only one unique educational experiment involved. 
 Yet even at this time many members of industrial trade unions realized fully that they were no longer free agents in a wider collective, but increasingly regimented subjects of the Party. 
 The aim of creating a sense of prime loyalty among members of the colony, which was small enough for them to know each other, did not constitute any kind of a threat to central authorities in 1922, but it would not have been tolerated in the 1930s, when family members were encouraged to spy on one another in the state interest. 
 Yet paradoxically Makarenko's educational theories were to be taken up, approved, and widely publicized in the Stalinist period. 
 Why was this so? 
 One way of answering the question might be that Stalin was as unorthodox a Marxist as Makarenko, but this avoids the crucial problem of political control. 
 The real answer lies elsewhere. 
 A military career had fascinated the young Makarenko, though he disliked it and had to be discharged on account of poor eyesight. 
 As if to compensate for this, he applied military techniques in the colony. 
 Without thinking twice about it, and without a single shudder, I  began to drill the boys in military exercises and manoeuvres. 
 They were delighted, and gladly followed my lead. 
 After the day's work we had all the colony drilling for an hour or two in the yard, which formed a spacious square. 
 As we added to our knowledge we extended the field of our activities. 
 By the winter our squads were carrying out very interesting and involved military manoeuvres throughout the area covered by our group of villages. 
 Soon afterwards we were able to use real rifles, for the authorities made us members of the &bquo;Universal Training&equo; organization, our criminal past being deliberately overlooked. 
 I soon noticed the influence of military training. 
 The change of behaviour in the boys was very marked. 
 Their faces took on a different expression; they grew more spruce and upright of bearing, ceased to loll about on the tables or against the walls, and held themselves up. 
 Makarenko had better relations with the local secret police than with any other official authority. 
 They found many candidates for admission to the colony, and in 1922 Makarenko wrote of them: 
 Among the Cheka people high intellectual standards combined with education and culture had not assumed the outward expression which I had found to be so hateful among the former Russian intellectuals&hellip;. 
 The Cheka people are devoted to principle&hellip; &lsqb;they have an&rsqb; all-pervading good humour, terseness of speech, a dislike of ready-made formulae. 
 Makarenko was not alone in the disorderly climate of 1922 in thinking on these lines. 
 Yakovlev was worried by the way in which teachers were being turned into what he called &bquo;the slaves of the kulaks&equo; through their financial dependence on richer peasants in the Kursk guberniia. 
 He recommended that Red Army youths become village teachers to counteract this trend. 
 The shadow of long-term violence since 1914 hung over many aspects of Russian society. 
 External and internal war produced their victims, of whom Makarenko's stray youths were but one example. 
 Military violence had led to civil coercion in many forms, of which the Secret police in peacetime was the most notorious example. 
 It had also led to  the adoption of military influences in Bolshevik governmental organization and propaganda jargon which did not disappear at the end of the Civil War. 
 Trotsky's idea of converting whole regiments into Labour Armies had failed, but it was symptomatic of the time. 
 Makarenko revived the military model in microcosm, and his strict pedagogical methods were adopted on a vast scale in the 1930s by Stalin, who reawakened many other lingering aspects of military-inspired government. 
 Often in NEP when thoughtful leaders at many levels became exasperated by the seemingly chaotic situations they saw about them, they dreamt of, and sometimes put through, as in Makarenko's case, schemes which looked forward to the methods of the 1930s. 
 Stalin was by no means alone. 
 We find Makarenko by the 1930s writing, &bquo;How is it that the resistance of materials is studied in all higher technical institutes, while in the pedagogical institutes no study is made of the resistance of personalities to educational measures?&equo;. 
 Humans had become mere technical grist to the mill like any base metal. 
 The position eventually taken up by Makarenko was one where the ultimate criteria of truth and morality had to reside in the centralized state. 
 From there they would flow outwards to the masses through all state agencies, which by the 1930s included even the family. 
 He failed to show how from the other direction values could arise from the people and become incorporated in the state ideology.  
 The South-East  
 EASTWARDS from Poltava lay the gubernii of Tsaritsyn, Saratov, and Samara (now Kuibyshev) on the Volga. 
 In 1922 they were the hub of the maelstrom that was the great famine of 1921&ndash;2. 
 The whole of Russia was affected by its repercussions. 
 Many historians maintain that they are concerned, not with human actions of all kinds, but only with those that are reflective, arising from a purpose pursued. 
 They rarely study natural events, and only in so far as they impinge on the human world. 
 In the Soviet context an inordinate amount of attention has been paid to the willed aims of Bolshevik leaders. 
 On the other hand, since nearly 80 per cent of the nation were illiterate in early NEP, consisting of a disorganized and fragmented peasantry, it has often been assumed that the actions of this class have been both unreflective and ineffective. 
 Illiterates leave no written record of their views, but they nevertheless reflect and act accordingly. 
 Peasants caught up in the Tambov and other revolts did just this, although they remained politically ineffective for lack of large-scale organization. 
 We have noted how the peasantry of the Black-Earth region was palpably influenced in its social and political manners by its traditional natural background. 
 In the case of the famine of 1921&ndash;2, a sudden alteration in the agricultural setting deeply affected, not just the local peasantry, but all the other provinces of European Russia and the very basis of the economic and political calculations that had led to the introduction of the NEP in the first place. 
 No such claim could possibly be made for the Smolensk, Kursk, or Poltava gubernii. 
 They deviated from central expectations and in many ways escaped from rigid control from above, but their local eccentricities did not upset Moscow's broad calculations in the short term. 
 Neither  Belorussian nationalists nor Catholics, nor the proximity of the Tambov revolt to Kursk guberniia, set any major political fires alight. 
 In the longer term the accumulation of social and economic deviations in all areas of Russia would indeed have profound effects on Bolshevik plans for the future. 
 This was already clear by 1926, and could even have been in 1922, if only the central authorities had kept a closer watch on the pulse of rural life. 
 Any study of the Lower Volga in 1922 differs from investigations of other localities in another respect. 
 Since foreign aid from many countries poured into the famine area, a wide variety of non-Russian accounts can be consulted. 
 Not a single articulate foreigner penetrated the Smolensk or Kursk gubernii to leave a record behind. 
 It is true that the Smolensk archives dropped uncensored into German hands in the Second World War, and that Yakovlev is remarkably self-critical of his own party; but only Makarenko stands outside the Bolshevik view of things. 
 Yet we cannot take foreign accounts at their face value either. 
 Political propaganda on the part of the American Relief Administration, by far the longest foreign source of aid, warped its judgement at the time, and the subsequent polarization of Russian-American relations has not improved the objectivity of later scholarly accounts of the Famine as seen through American eyes. 
 Even F. Nansen, the esteemed Norwegian co-ordinator of many other foreign relief organizations, could on occasion be carried away by his emotions and give a semi-fictional account of conditions in the Volga provinces. 
 Calm assessments were hard to come by in the shadow of a tragedy of such proportions. 
 A native Russian of genius, L. Tolstoy, had been blinded by his feelings in the famine of  1891&ndash;2 when he made mildly inaccurate statements about the Tsarist relief administration. 
 Most students of the 1921&ndash;2 Famine have concentrated on foreign aid, the causes of the Famine, statistical evidence on mortality and disease rates, and the extent of crop failures. 
 The aim here is to look at its political and social repercussions and to set it in the wider context of central-local administrative relations. 
 Another interesting aspect that has been almost entirely neglected concerns horizontal influences in near and distant gubernii. 
 But first the causes of the Famine should be given in order to put it in perspective. 
 The Middle Volga region, like the Nikol'skaia volost' in Kursk guberniia, was an area of good chernozem  soils and so predominantly grain-producing. 
 Unlike the Central Agricultural Region, the grain here was partly produced for market and transported on the Volga. 
 The pressure on land was also less severe here. 
 The number of strips held by households were larger and fewer than around Kursk, but distances between houses and plots were even larger, since peasants lived alongside the water-courses away from their land. 
 Water shortage was often acute, especially in the Lower Volga area. 
 In general, conditions of land tenure, communal arrangements, and cultural traditions differed considerably in the Volga provinces from those in the West and the centre of European Russia. 
 For instance, members of Volga communes were apt to be more outward-looking than those in Kursk guberniia because of their wider market ties and better transport facilities. 
 This was one of the reasons why they were more prepared than many sedentary peasants to escape over huge distances in the Famine, though of course hunger was the main spur. 
 In August 1921 the Commissariat of Foreign Affairs stated that the Famine covered Ufa and Viatka and the Volga  gubernii of Astrakhan, Tsaritsyn, Saratov, Samara, Simbirsk, and the German Volga Commune. 
 Foreign sources added several other provinces: Tambov, Voronezh, Tula, Riazan', and the Ukrainian gubernii of Kherson and the Crimea. 
 The widespread implications of the Famine were already coming to the surface. 
 Both Soviet and foreign estimates of the numbers threatened with starvation and death over the period 1921&ndash;2 varied enormously, and no amount of detailed research is ever likely to come up with reliable figures. 
 By the early autumn of 1922 the Soviet government put the number at 22 million, or about one-third of the population of the RSFSR. 
 Nansen's estimates fluctuated between 20 and 30 million in September 1921 to 50 million twelve months later. 
 For the long-term causes of the Famine we have to delve deep behind the flat time-dimension of 1922. 
 Famines had been a cyclical phenomenon in the Volga region, as they had been in Asia, for centuries. 
 Poor irrigation, transport, education, and medicine multiplied the chances of disaster, together with the fact that even in good years many peasants hardly existed above subsistence level. 
 The organizational defects of the commune system were another barrier, as elsewhere in Russia. 
 The short-term cause of overriding local significance were the droughts and crop failures in 1920 and 1921. 
 Due to wartime conditions the peasantry got the same amount of agricultural machinery over the years 1915&ndash;21 that they had been able to buy in a single year prior to the World War. 
 They had suffered in the Civil War from requisitioning by Red, White, and Green armies, and to some extent from the Bolshevik-inspired kombedy  (committees of poor peasants). 
 As the Famine grew, poor co-operation between the Soviet authorities and foreign relief groups, and amongst the foreign organizations themselves, exacerbated the situation. 
 The worst aspects  of co-ordination, however, were central-local relations within the Soviet hierarchy. 
 We will return to this later, but at this point the course of the Famine needs to be related very briefly. 
 Between early May and late August 1921, no rain had fallen in the Middle Volga, central and eastern Ukraine, and the steppes north of the Caucasus. 
 Taken together, these areas supplied three-fifths of Russia's grain. 
 The steppes were the first to be affected, so that in June alone over a million peasants left them for the Volga. 
 Thousands died in transit. 
 Since the total grain harvest proved to be a mere 52 per cent of what it had been in 1913, even the least affected areas had barely enough. 
 Livestock was slaughtered in the worst-hit areas on the Volga, thus rendering any movement and the basis for any future recovery even more precarious. 
 Epidemics spread with the diaspora. 
 The winter of 1921&ndash;2 was bitterly cold. 
 Grain-importing regions now suffered, beginning with the Donbas and then the Moscow region. 
 It was only after the reasonable harvest of 1922 that the spectre of nation-wide starvation receded. 
 Since the accent in this study lies on 1922, a report in The Times  for 6 January may suffice as an eye-witness account of conditions in Saratov and Samara gubernii. 
 The author was an Englishman, Dr Farrar, who had just died from typhus. 
 He can still be seen on film in November 1921 in Saratov surrounded by hungry children. 
 It would need the pen of a Zola to do justice to the reality and appalling intensity of the famine in these parts (Saratov and Samara). 
 It is getting steadily worse and is moving westward with the stream of refugees, who, having eaten their last stores and sold everything that would buy a morsel of bread, are wandering they know not whither. 
 To give an idea of the desolation of some of the villages (in the Saratov area) (may mention that the village of Kano, in the Markstadt district, which has a normal population of over 3,000, has now only 1,100 inhabitants left, and remember the winter is only just beginning. 
 One of the worst features is the number or enfants trouv&eacute;s  &mdash; orphans or children abandoned by their parents, who are found in the streets. 
  The ghastly emaciation of these children is horrible. 
 I saw yesterday' in Markstadt a shelter which has beds for 100 of these children; 42 children had died in the last 24 hours, but these places had been filled up. 
 I saw the corpses of eight, photographed some of them. 
 More than 50 per cent of these enfants trov&eacute;s  perish in spite of the care that is given them. 
 But if the children some under the care of the relief agencies, little ones, who were emaciated, hollow-eyed, and listless, become after about a fortnight's feeding quite plump again and begin to laugh and sing. 
 Since beginning this letter I have been with Nansen in the Samara district, where the conditions are even worse than in Saratov, in spite of the very good work done by the ARA in Samara and by the Friends in Bouzoulouk. 
 We saw awful conditions in Bouzoulouk, where, out of a population of 35,000 they are dying at the rate of 100 a day. 
 Corpses are found lying almost every day, and murders are frequent. 
 We saw in the cemetery a pile of about 60&ndash;70 corpses, two days accumulation (not reckoning the private burials), waiting to be tumbled into a pit, and also a pit full of other corpses. 
 We saw in the main street the corpse of a woman already gnawed by dogs (people are beginning to be afraid of dogs). 
 Copemaman of the Friends, told us that he seldom went out without seeing corpses lying about. 
 There are whispered stories of cannibalism. 
 Conditions in the guberniia capitals were dire, but they were even worse in the rural hinterland. 
 It was still possible in early 1922 to buy foodstuffs in the city markets if one had the money. 
 Soviet and foreign relief organizations had installed themselves with efficiency and were giving out free food. 
 The villages on the other hand were quite desolate. 
 Up to half of the houses were boarded up in areas that were starving. 
 Village clerks could not keep a proper record of deaths, since they were so frequent. 
 This was the source of the central authorities' difficulty in making adequate assessments. 
 A member of the Indian Civil Service who visited Samara guberniia in January 1922 noted how the whole of the rural population in the famine region proper was absolutely starved. 
 In Indian famines of which he had long experience, only landless labourers and smaller cultivators &mdash; &bquo;the submerged tenth&equo; &mdash; needed relief. 
 Local agronomists from the Commissariat of  Agriculture discovered in the Samara guberniia that 40 per cent of the machinery that had been hired out was unusable, and virtually all the rest was in need of repairs. 
 There was neither time nor money to deal with agricultural pests. 
 The agronomists&equo; reports on the spring-sowing campaign reveal a long list of mainly unfulfilled bureaucratic resolutions passed down from Moscow. 
 In Saratov guberniia the reduction in livestock between the springs of 1920 and 1922 was found to have been 94.6 per cent in pigs, 68.7 in sheep, 61.3 in horned cattle, and 59 in horses. 
 When agronomists held courses for peasants, they fretted that on average only 150 turned up, as compared with attendances of 4000 at a single conference in Smolensk guberniia. 
 Given their atrocious living conditions, it is a tribute to the tenacity of the Saratov peasantry that even this number appeared. 
 The effects of rural famine took their toll on city-workers in due course. 
 The sewing industry in Saratov reported that its factories were closing in January through lack of demand for its products. 
 Another plant which made military uniforms was on the verge of closure for lack of orders from Moscow. 
 This was due to the impossibility of conveying such goods between the two cities at a time when the railways could not cope with grain supplies coming into Saratov. 
 Agronomists were much in evidence in the localities in the spring of 1922. 
 This was not the case for those other connecting agents between town and country that have been studied in Smolensk and Kursk gubernii. 
 Rural teachers melted away into the towns as their schools closed down for lack of pupils and funds. 
 By February only forty-three of the 394 schools in Samara guberniia remained on the official food supply list. 
 All local funds, which had been cut as a result of the introduction of NEP, were poured into famine relief. 
 There was even less money available for education after September, when many new famine duties and financial burdens were shifted from Moscow on to local authorities.  
 There is little evidence of either the presence or practical aid of Russian priests in the afflicted rural areas, though a considerable number of West European churchmen came in with relief organizations. 
 Churches, like the schools, were abandoned. 
 The government's anti-religious campaign in connection with the Church's alleged refusal to donate money and valuables for the Famine crippled the reputation of church aid and made some priests unwilling to become entangled in relief work. 
 Others saved their own skins and left the worst-hit areas. 
 At high and local levels the government intervened to stop what active church help there was. 
 On 22 April the American Relief Administration wanted to clear a shipment to Patriarch Tikhon for him to distribute at his discretion. 
 An earlier load had been passed on to him, but this was no longer permitted. 
 Tikhon was arrested at the end of April and charged with advocating resistance to the confiscation of church treasures. 
 When ARA village committees wished to elect Russian priests as members, back came the objection, phrased in the usual official provincial style: &bquo;according to the laws of our constitution, the said element (ecclesiastical) is harmful to the younger generation, and by the principles of the Soviet government this element is deprived of all active or passive participation in our work.&equo; 
 Another unwelcome element in Soviet eyes was lacking altogether. 
 Whereas Nepmen were already flourishing in Kursk guberniia, they could not yet arise here in an area where as the Indian civil servant observed, rich and poor peasants alike were afflicted. 
 The only conceivable opening for venality was in the private shipment of food supplies for profit. 
 Traffic of this kind had occurred on a large scale in the period following on the October Revolution, but if there had been any &bquo;bagmen&equo; left by 1921&ndash;2 in the Middle Volga region, they would have been ruthlessly stamped out. 
 It was lucky for the Bolshevik government, though not accidental, that two of its most suspected categories in local society were powerless in the Famine areas.  
 On the other hand, neither did the faithful military figure so much here as it did in the political activities of the Smolensk party organization. 
 During 1922 soldiers were used almost exclusively in civilian affairs for guarding the train-loads of grain entering the Famine region, and for monitoring the distribution of food. 
 The rations of the Red Army were assiduously protected. 
 In March food supplies purchased by the Commissariat of War for the Red Army were given priority in evacuation at the Black Sea port of Novorossiisk over ARA famine stocks. 
 It was different for the rank and file at the receiving end. 
 The officials who sent them off from the ports with the loaded railway-wagons gave them rations for the number of days which the grain would in normal times take to its destination. 
 Due to the enormous delays, soldiers arrived in the Volga cities nearly dead for lack of food. 
 It has been argued that the Famine led to a long-term levelling process amongst the afflicted peasantry, thus keeping the &bquo; kulak &equo; at bay in the stricken areas. 
 This was indeed the immediate consequence, but only until the middle of 1922. 
 In 1921, there was a huge increase in the emigration and physical extinction of households. 
 A big drop took place in rates of partitioning. 
 The poorest households suffered the most, and this led temporarily to both a levelling and an aggregate move downwards in Volga peasant society. 
 Yet by the summer of 1922, when recovery was in sight, the slightest advantage of one peasant over another could be manipulated to gain quick and large profits. 
 Meagre amounts of food were bartered by the less unfortunate to the starving in return for land and equipment. 
 Between June and September 18,000 bargains of this kind in Samara guberniia were annulled by the government, which declared them to be invalid, but thousands more went undiscovered. 
 Twenty pounds of butter was enough for the lease of two and a half desiatiny of land for five years.l Five pudy of linseed cake were exchanged for the approaching  harvest of a desiatin of wheat. 
 Machinery was much scarcer than land, as has been seen. 
 In 1922 the percentage of households without even a plough was 32.7 in the Central Industrial Region, 33.6 in the Siberian guberniia of Omsk, and 55.8 in the guberniia of Tsaritsyn to the south of Saratov. 
 Peasants with a minimal surplus of food could barter it for vital equipment. 
 In the spring of 1922 only those households in the Famine area which possessed the necessary machinery and livestock were given grain to sow for the next season. 
 By the mid-1920s the universal result of the earlier shortage of equipment had become clear: 75 per cent of all cases of letting out land were due to lack of adequate tools. 
 It was difficult for the authorities to detect this cumulative process at work. 
 Richer and poorer peasants connived to hide the indebtedness of the latter, who were often described in the tax returns as relatives or voluntary helpers of the farmer. 
 As always, the better-off peasants were more successful than others in avoiding taxation. 
 The new tax in kind fell on all areas of Russia and on all types of peasant in 1922 except for the completely destitute. 
 A progressive tax on the more productive regions and peasants might have been more just and welcome from the political point of view, but it was not applied for fear of removing the incentive to sow from the better-placed peasants. 
 Even the famine area was made to pay one-half of the supplemental tax levied for famine relief. 
 This had a crippling effect on the worse off at a crucial stage of recovery from the Famine. 
 To this extent the region was actually encouraging the formation of richer peasant strata at the expense of the poorer. 
 At this point we can embark on an investigation of the spatial or &bquo;horizontal&equo; effects of the Famine in 1922. 
 Internal movement within the worst-affected areas should be looked at first. 
 Those peasants who continued to own draught animals had lent them to relief organizations at the height of the  Famine, but by the spring of 1922 they refused to do this any longer, since they now found many profitable uses for them. 
 Owners of draught animals had a virtual monopoly oh the transport of grain to the miller, the market, and the local collection-point for the tax in kind. 
 If the tax was paid promptly, a discount was given. 
 They could carry goods for local co-operatives and state authorities. 
 Their cultural as well as their economic life could be broadened: in the winter of 1922&ndash;3 it was found that more peasant children from families owning draught animals attended school regularly than those without any. 
 Less fortunate children still converged on the village relief-kitchens to which food and other supplies fur a month to two months were brought in peasant carts over lung distances from railheads and steamer-landings. 
 In the more remote localities Bolshevik officials, desperate for transport facilities, &bquo;ignored NEP and all its works, and commandeered right and left as if military Communism &lsqb;War Communism&rsqb; was still pure and undefiled&equo;, yet another indication that military methods did not go completely out of fashion with the advent of NEP. 
 Communications did not improve away from the grass roots. 
 For Saratov guberniia the main supply-base was at Pokrosk, on the east side of the Volga, directly opposite the city of Saratov. 
 From Pokrovsk railway lines ran in three directions through famine areas, but in January 1922 there were only one locomotive in the yards, and that took up to seventeen days to cover less than 150 miles. 
 Camels were used for moving railway-trucks round the Pokrovsk yards. 
 The spring of 1922 was the crucial period, when the unmetalled roads began to break up into mud and the rivers had not yet melted By the time grain had arrived from the Black Sea to an area north of Samara, only one in ten of the available sledges could get through to rural areas, so that instead or 48,750 pudy of corn, a mere 1,500 were delivered. 
 The ice disappeared from the  Volga in the last days of April, when steamers, tugs, and barges converged at Tsaritsyn on the warmer Lower Volga to transport supplies up the river and its tributaries. 
 There were six village landing-points in the Samara guberniia and eight to the north and south of Saratov. 
 This campaign suffered from the reduction of the river fleet from four to two thousand steamers between 1917 and 1921. 
 Barges had been destroyed for fuel or left by their previous owners to be broken up by ice or swept downstream by the spring floods. 
 Grain converging on the Middle Volga from other parts of Russia and from abroad was subject to similar near-chaotic conditions. 
 Massive bottle-necks built up in the early spring on the railway network, at Koslov, west of Saratov on the route to Moscow and particularly at Balashov, between Saratov and Tsaritsyn on the west side of the Volga. 
 On 21 March there were forty-two trains there, each with about thirty trucks. 
 The leader of the American Relief Administration agreed with A. Giduk, his Soviet counterpart, that 1,100 trucks should be unloaded temporarily into warehouses. 
 Coal specially imported from England to Baltic seaports was still stuck there, so that most engines were fuelled with &bquo;nothing but logs&hellip; in most cases wet and covered with ice and snow&hellip; giving no heat&hellip;. 
 The gratings are ruined and finally the engines have to be taken out of service&hellip; &bquo; 
 The number of ARA truck-loads failing to reach their destination had accelerated, from 11 per cent in October 1921 to 35 per cent by the end of January 1922. 
 The position began to improve in spring. 
 Later figures showed that for the whole of 1922 over twice as much grain was transported by rail and waterways as in 1921. 
 The Famine in the south-east of Russia even affected international relations in the far north-west. 
 The ARA used its good offices to speed up railway agreements between Latvia and Poland on the one hand, and Russia on the other, so that relief supplies could flow in more easily from Western Europe. 
  Goods trains coming from the Baltic to Moscow took between one and four weeks, a distance that was covered in fourteen hours by passenger trains. 
 The first goods train from Novorossiisk, a vital grain port in the north-east corner of the Black Sea, wandered over much of European Russia before arriving at Ufa. 
 Novorossiisk like most other ports had suffered from the Revolution and Civil War. 
 Scuttled ships lay in the bay and only two quays were fit for use. 
 Bottle-necks were not restricted to the railways; at the end of March twentyfive ships lay in Reval harbour waiting for berths. 
 At Theodosia in the Crimea dockers struck for better wages and rations. 
 ln good capitalist fashion local officials recruited Tartar shepherds and quarrymen from the hills to act as temporary stevedores and strike-breakers. 
 Drastic action was indeed necessary to keep transport cogwheels turning all over Russia to supply the Volga provinces. 
 Vital grain supplies due in from Siberia were so badly held up that in January 1922 the national Council of Labour and Defence sent there Felix Dzerzhinsky, the head of the secret police, and since April 1921 Commissar for Transport. 
 With forty picked men he was given special powers; 228 wagons were needed, but only thirty had been sent to Siberia. 
 Dzerzhinsky found explosives in many of the railway workshops. 
 They had suffered from twenty cases of arson in the last two months of 1921, which he ascribed to White supporters of Kolchak. 
 He proceeded to declare a state of military alert in nineteen railway stations. 
 The trucks slowly began to roll. 
 ARA officials met Dzerzhinsky on 12 April to complain about the requisitioning of their supplies. 
 By 27 April the problem was solved, to the surprise of the Americans. 
 Thereafter they learnt to invoke the name of the head of the secret police when dealing with obdurate local officials. 
 Central intervention was successful to a certain degree where means of communication were concerned, especially those between Moscow and the provinces. 
 They will be examined in  more detail when we quit regional life and approach the political capital. 
 Traditionally, Tsarist as well as Soviet local government was conducted on a strictly bilateral basis between the centre and each separate guberniia. 
 Independent lateral contacts at provincial levels were discouraged. 
 So that when want numbers of non-directed peasants began to spill out of the disaster areas in the early summer of 1921, the Central Committee of the Communist Party ordered its guberniia counterparts to put a stop to migration &bquo;since the flight of the peasants&hellip; will ruin entirely our economic life&equo;. 
 Fears for the political stability of the area, once the bastion of the Socialist Revolutionaries and bordering on Tambov guberniia, were also rising, though not expressed publicly. 
 Refugee movements were very complex throughout 1921&ndash;2, but the main tides swept in a south-westerly direction from Saratov and Tsaritsyn gubernii towards the Ukraine or westwards from Samara, Simbirsk, Ufa, and Kazan' towards Moscow and beyond. 
 In one sense international or even civil war had less disturbing effects on central administration, since the' had more clearly defined fronts than those of the Famine. 
 Troop numbers and locations were also much more precise. 
 It is impossible to have even approximate figures for the diaspora. 
 One careful observer, a British Quaker, gave a figure of 800,000 for the period between 1 July 1921 and April 1922. 
 The fact that Omsk railway station on the less-frequented eastern escape route was sometimes deluged with up to 20,000 refugees a day gives some idea of the scale of migration. 
 Another reason for our inability to give accurate figures is due to the prevalence of several other types of population movement, some of them on a huge scale, although extended over a longer period. 
 In the winter of 1921&ndash;2 an American relief organizer discovered several thousand Polish war refugees huddled in railway trucks at Orenburg, waiting to be repatriated. 
 The dislocations caused by the World War and the Civil War were immense in terms of human lives. 
 The  White emigration added at least another twelve million. 
 Then there were the mass flights from the industrial cities of European Russia after 1917, besides many regional movements too numerous to mention. 
 Given this situation, which persisted into 1922 and beyond, what hope was there for Gosplan to construct a carefully planned economy and society under any kind of political conditions, whether those of War Communism, NEP, or the Five-Year plans of the future? 
 The future was indeed at stake, since official Soviet figures put the number of starving children in the famine areas at 7,246,317. 
 By 1920 the government had already been giving public support to 7,667,769 children in need. 
 These colossal numbers diminished very slowly through NEP. 
 Makarenko's colony near Poltava was a drop in the ocean at a time when 200 children a day were abandoned in Samara. 
 Renewed commitment to child welfare had the initial effect of inducing parents to desert their offspring at an even faster rate. 
 The incidence of the Famine was in fact worse for those peasants who wandered into the nearby Volga cities or travelled much further afield. 
 Cut off from regular feeding-points, subjected to atrocious public transport conditions, and more prone to the cold and disease, up to half of the migrants died in transit on the railways. 
 A minority were more fortunate, if one can take as reasonably accurate the report by the Commissariat of Agriculture that 109,705 peasants were taken out of the famine zone and settled on farming land in Siberia, the Ukraine, the Caucasus, and elsewhere. 
 The results were beneficent, but less well handled were the reverse migration procedures ordered by Pomgol  on 15 March 1922. 
 They appear to have been premature. 
 For example 1,530 persons were reevacuated to the Saratov guberniia in early June, despite the fact that the Central Evacuation Department had taken 2,151 refugees away from there in late May. 
 More ominous for the  future was the fact that the central authorities were learning how to control and transport huge numbers of peasants. 
 The great bulk of population movement occurred independently of Moscow in the years 1917&ndash;22, but after the end of NEP it was to be strictly enforced, and took place on a vast scale again. 
 Another horizontal effect of the Famine that was also hard to check was the spread of disease, carried above all by refugees. 
 Those fugitives who congregated on the Omsk railway passed on spotted typhus to 60 per cent of the regional railway workers. 
 Through Samara passed the chief railway lines from Siberia and Central Asia, bringing in diseases of all kinds from the east. 
 The ARA dispensary at the station filled out 75,000 prescriptions for arriving passengers and inspected 868 trains. 
 At the receiving end of refugees from the Middle Volga, Rostov-on-Don was the prime source of cholera outbreaks. 
 They occurred from 1920 onwards, but 1921 and 1922 were the peak years. 
 Rostov stood at the crossroads of another traffic stream, from north-west Russia to the northern Caucasus by train and boat. 
 At the hub of the crisis, hospital conditions in Samara and Saratov were atrocious. 
 Patients suffered from frost-bite in bed. 
 Thermometers were lacking completely. 
 It has been estimated that in a narrow clinical sense the Famine probably accounted for under 15 per cent of the extra mortality recorded at the height of the disaster in Saratov in 1921&ndash;2: but in a broader sense, including deaths due to severe malnutrition and other causes, the Famine contributed to most of the rise in mortality that took place before the 1922 harvest. 
 After that point, the recovery from widespread disease and the high death-rate was dramatic. 
 By the end of 1923 levels were down to the best pre-1921 records for Saratov. 
 For lack of funds, equipment, and means of control, central  government and famine-free areas had to stand by passively to some extent as disease-ridden migrants besieged them. 
 In other ways positive help could be given by more fortunate regions. 
 Indeed M. I. Kalinin, the nominal head of famine relief, claimed that 70 to 80 per cent of the adult population of Russia was active on the &bquo;hunger front&equo;. 
 Party, Soviet, co-operative, military, educational, and trade-union organizations were involved. 
 The latter designated special weeks for the production or collection of goods to be contributed to the aid programme. 
 By February 1922 trade-union lotteries were being held in forty-eight gubernii. 
 For lack of sufficient central funds the rudimentary basis of a welfare state was being set up through contributions from the workers' own meagre wages. 
 In Saratov itself it was suggested that there should be a 2 per cent deduction from water-workers' pay in order to improve cultural facilities. 
 The national union of workers in education and the arts gave 5 per cent of their pay for famine relief. 
 The prestigious university of Petrograd, whose affairs will be reviewed later in another context, set up a famine commission and sent an expedition to afflicted areas. 
 On 2 January 1922 a decree issued by VTsIK (the All-Union Central Executive Committee of the Communist Party) arranged for the requisitioning of valuable articles from museums, and this was followed on 16 February by the more controversial decree on the seizure of Church treasures. 
 The violent repercussions of the second decree have been examined in the case-study of Roslavl' in the Smolensk guberniia. 
 Citizens died on the church steps in their attempt to prevent altar-pieces being taken away. 
 If tension was so high in an area not stricken by famine, it may be assumed that as much or more violence occurred in regions like the Ukraine and Tambov guberniia, which were nearly as badly off as the Volga. 
 Every twenty Roslavl' inhabitants had also to contribute to the support of one hungry child in the distant south-east, whilst  every five peasant households had to help one hungry adult. 
 In addition a special series of graded poll-taxes for famine relief began in February 1922. 
 By 11 October we find local party authorities demanding from peasants the delayed payment of 425 pudy of rye for maintaining ten children on the Volga. 
 This order was annulled on 26 October by the Smolensk guberniia party committee for being excessive and too late to be of any use. 
 On 9 November a Moscow circular from Secretary V. Molotov himself forbade somewhat belatedly the imposition of any local taxes not laid down in the list issued by VTsIK. 
 This move can be interpreted either as yet another instance of poor central-local ties or as deliberate slowness so as to let more money flow into public funds. 
 In contrast local military authorities would brook no delay. 
 The commander of the Western Front virtually ordered the Smolgubispolkom  to eject school number 9 out of what was now a Volga orphans' home run by a &bquo;revolutionary military committee&equo;. 
 The effects of the Volga famine were more disruptive and politically dangerous in another national minority area that had more ethnic pretensions, and above all suffered nearly as much from famine as the Great-Russian Volga provinces. 
 On the day of the Kronstadt uprising, 23 February 1921, Lenin appealed to the Ukraine to step up its aid, in the form of foodstuffs to the workers of Petrograd and Moscow. 
 The proclamation of NEP did not apply to the Ukraine, where the punitive requisitioning methods of War Communism were officially extended until the autumn of 1921. 
 In the Civil War the Red Army had blocked off the northern part of the Ukraine from the hungry south and commandeered the crops from the north for Great-Russian cities. 
 When the &bquo;official&equo; Famine struck the Volga, the Soviet press made no mention of the position in the Ukraine. 
 Only later did occasional references appear on inner pages devoted to food collection there. 
 It was poor propaganda for the outside world to know that the granary of Europe was suffering from famine  conditions. 
 In fact it soon found out, since by the end of July 1922 the ARA was having to feed 822,000 children and over a million adults in the Ukraine. 
 When the starvation rate accelerated in the southern provinces, and no help was available from outside, peasant refugees from the west added to the flood from the east converging on the less afflicted Ukrainian gubernii of Chernihiv and Poltava. 
 It was not at all surprising that the main road to Poltava town near Makarenko's colony was full of travellers and plagued by bandits. 
 Ukrainian sources claimed that ninety-two wagons of grain were collected from starving Ukrainian gubernii, of which thirty-six were sent off to feed the hungry in the Volga-Ural area. 
 So-called food gifts arriving in Saratov were forced out of Ukrainian peasants by the food-collecting army ( Prodovol'stvennaia armiia ), although they were still paying agricultural taxes which had been waived in the Volga provinces. 
 Central policy seemed to be so prejudiced against the Ukraine that it evoked the suspicion in several foreign observers that this particular national minority was being deliberately neglected as a punishment for its hostility to Russian rule in the Civil War. 
 In the religious sphere the government was quite clearly using the Famine as a political weapon with which to subdue the Orthodox Church. 
 Certainly in 1922 Ukrainians came to envy and hate the preferential treatment given to their eastern neighbours on the Volga, thus falling prey to the methods of divide and rule which the Bolsheviks inherited from their imperial predecessors. 
 In terms of the survival of the regime, such a policy may have been deemed necessary. 
 The peasant revolt that broke out in February 1921 in the Tambov guberniia threatened to cut off rail connections between Moscow and the Volga region, since hungry peasants held up wheat trains and ransacked them. 
 Bolshevik sources reveal that about half the population of the guberniia did not have enough to eat by then, and the position was no better by spring  of 1922. 
 The revolt was squashed, but Tambov peasants in 1922 were still compelled to pay a levy on the acorns they picked to eat as a substitute for bread. 
 The economic plight of the Volga peasantry was even more crippling than that of the Tambov or Ukrainian population. 
 There was no fear of revolt in the countryside on the Volga, due to sheer exhaustion. 
 Consequently no clearly visible political strings were attached to relief operations there. 
 This does not mean that they were entirely lacking, as will be seen later. 
 The main problems in the Volga region, however, lay more in the administrative than in the political domain. 
 Most of them arose as a result of an all-Russian phenomenon in 1922 &mdash; the lack of co-ordination and exchange of information between the centre and the localities, together with nonchalant neglect of provincial problems so long as they did not affect central political issues. 
 These attitudes were reflected in the arrangements for famine relief in Tsaritsyn guberniia, to which we will now turn, since our attention has been directed so far on Saratov and Samara gubernii to the north of it. 
 Organization at the grassroots level was clearly the most urgent need in order to reach remote starving villages, yet in Tsaritsyn as in other gubernii no local relief committees were set up at the uezd and volost' levels until October 1921, that is, over two months after the formation of the guberniia committee. 
 This was due to the lethargy of the central and guberniia authorities who appointed local committee members. 
 Uezd and volost' organs were required to report twice a month only to the guberniia, which sent a monthly summary to Moscow. 
 The local committees varied greatly in their composition and operating procedures, some of which were highly unusual. 
 Between January and May 1922 no money from any central agency was given to them, so they had to depend on the surplus of local  revenues and gifts after the guberniia relief committee had made its own collections. 
 These local committees were supplemented in the autumn of 1921 by the newly formed peasant Committees of Self-Help. 
 They had been suggested as early as 3 August by VTsIK, but typically no action was taken until the Communist Party had time to look into the question. 
 Village as well as volost', uezd, and guberniia peasant committees were established in Tsaritsyn and other gubernii. 
 At the lower levels their aim was to promote aid from less unfortunate households to the poor and the starving. 
 They also collected seed grain for the 1922 sowing campaign. 
 Neither they nor the local relief committees were given any remit whatsoever with regard to how food should be dispensed or who was eligible to receive it. 
 The contrast between this complete lack of instructions and the highly detailed directives from the centre to, say, the Roslavl' uezd or the Nikol'skaia volost' party committees on political matters is striking. 
 The results were often counter-productive. 
 In the villages the peasant committees consisted entirely of local peasants. 
 Some of them were ex-members of the committees of poor peasants (kombedy) that had requisitioned in military style during War Communism, a style that lingered on. 
 There were many cases of theft, misappropriation, and favouritism which tended to destroy confidence in officialdom in general. 
 Since peasants who still possessed any seed reserves or livestock were excluded from relief, they were compelled to sell them off in some cases in order to survive. 
 This depleted the famine areas further, and sparked off new hatred amongst the peasants. 
 In the subsequent scramble for survival and enrichment which mounted towards the end of 1922, it was not surprising that those who were slightly better off often took a kind of revenge in driving hard bargains with their poorer neighbours, as has been noted earlier. 
 The intermediary between local bodies and Moscow were the guberniia Commissions for the Relief of the Starving. 
 The  Tsaritsyn Commission was set up on 8 August 192 1, and like its counterparts in other gubernii, were very closely modelled on Pomgol, the all-Russian organ in Moscow. 
 It had no special apparatus, but consisted of thirty-one members chosen from nearly every branch of local government. 
 Its working methods were almost a caricature of those prevailing in high political bodies in Moscow. 
 Plenary sessions were held once a month only, even at the height of the Famine, and merely ratified previous decisions of the two-man presidium. 
 Five subsections were supervised by eight &bquo;technical staff&equo;, whose title by implication precluded them from taking political decisions. 
 The sections were for agitation, public works, public feeding, the investigation and procurement of resources, and after February 1922, a special section for the removal of church treasures. 
 The Tsaritsyn gubpomgol was similar in structure and operation to other gubpomgoly. 
 Like them it relied heavily for income on local sources such as gifts, taxes, profits from licences, lotteries, etc. 
 They yielded over 68 million roubles by December 1921. 
 By that date Moscow had provided a mere three and a half million roubles, and one million had come in from other gubernii. 
 Each guberniia that was officially designated as lying within the famine area was linked up with supposedly &bquo;rich&equo; gubernii which had to provide supplies. 
 Tsaritsyn was linked with Kursk and Voronezh, Saratov with Kursk and Voronezh again, and also with Tambov and Or&euml;l while Samara was allied with no less than five other gubernii. 
 Given that co-operation and consultation in more normal times was virtually unknown on this lateral basis, inexperience led to many defects. 
 There were no specifications as to what type or quantity of goods should be sent. 
 Poor control over shipments led to theft and other misdemeanours. 
 Despite internal and foreign suggestions as to how to improve horizontal co-operation, the central authorities took no action throughout 1922.  
 At both guberniia and central levels the Soviet government established a liaison system between their own plenipotentiaries and all foreign relief organizations. 
 It was headed by Alexander Eiduk, a pugnacious character who was a member of the GPU collegium. 
 Foreign organizers soon discovered that the system seemed to be modelled on Trotsky's military commissars. 
 Co-operation was often subordinated to the more important task of insulating local Russian relief staff and the general population from political contamination by foreigners. 
 Given the disturbed local conditions, and keen memories of American, British, and other intervention in the Civil War, this suspicious approach was not entirely unwarranted, particularly with regard to the cities of the Middle Volga. 
 They contained a large middle class, which together with dissatisfied refugees and war workers from the fighting zone in the World War, had often expressed dislike of central intervention, and had even encouraged local autonomy. 
 Moving for the first time in this book to Moscow and central administration, we find that from 18 July 1921, the Central Commission for the Relief of the Starving (Pomgol) was in charge of the Famine programme. 
 Although its decisions were intended to have &bquo;military urgency&equo; for the rest of the government, Pomgol had an independent apparatus, since its staff was drawn from many Commissariats and departments. 
 To put teeth into it, Pomgol was chaired by M. I. Kalinin, who was to become president of the newly formed USSR in December 1922. 
 He was supported by three well-known figures, L. B. Kamenev, A. Rykov, and P. G. Smidovich, who took a prominent part in the suppression of the Tambov revolt according to the Great Soviet Encyclopaedia . 
 Pomgol's activities extended to the purchase and distribution of foodstuffs, medicine, and other supplies; help to the starving to get work; and collecting donations. 
 That it was not always successful, even in  its own backyard, so to speak, can be gleaned from critical Rabkrin reports. 
 In April 1922, Moscow collectors of valuables were not making proper valuations, and foodstuffs were being left to rot in warehouses. 
 Rabkrin was less perspicacious in its investigations of distant pomgolgub  committees. 
 It claimed that there were not enough members on them; yet we have seen that in Tsaritsyn at least there was a superfluity of ineffective plenary members. 
 As with the guberniia committees, the small Pomgol presidium conducted nearly all the business, and in considerable secrecy. 
 Only its formal subdivisions are known, despite the fact that the press was admitted to its open sessions. 
 Mystery also surrounds the brief existence of a rival non-governmental body, the All-Russian Famine Relief Committee, set up in July and dismantled at the end of August 1921. 
 Besides Maxim Gorky and a daughter of L. Tolstoy, it included the President of the Second Duma and even S. N. Prokopovich, the Minister of Food in the Provisional Government of 1917, who was neither a Bolshevik nor a Menshevik. 
 The official reason given for the committee's demise was that it had indulged in counterrevolution and illicit dealings with foreign powers. 
 Certainly suspect committee members had attempted to go abroad, but the real reason was probably that the committee had served its purpose by acting as a bait to attract foreign relief organizations (the ARA drew up an agreement on 20 August). 
 Alternatively the committee could have served as a scapegoat if Pomgol activities had failed completely. 
 Since all foreign relief organizations dealt with Pomgol and with Eiduk as chief plenipotentiary, subsequent non-Russian scholars have tended to over-concentrate on the workings of Pomgol and its guberniia equivalents. 
 Yet Pomgol was little more than a conglomerate made up of other relevant state departments. 
 The Commissariat of Agriculture was the key element within Pomgol. 
 Light can be thrown on the administrative  efficiency of this Commissariat ( Narkomzem ) by looking into the account of an inspection of it in early 1922. 
 The Commissariat was found to be &bquo;exceptionally developed&equo; and full of &bquo;a series of purely academic-parliamentary institutions&equo;. 
 Staffing had increased by 189 per cent between 1 January 1921 and 1 March 1922. 
 Both large and small versions of many sections coexisted, but did not communicate with one another, or even know of one another's presence. 
 There were chronic reshuffles of all organs. 
 Central-local ties were weaker still. 
 Provincial branches of Narkomzem only contacted Moscow when in need of salaries and funds &mdash; otherwise they led independent lives. 
 When Narkomzem handed out a questionnaire with 226 questions at an All-Russian Congress of Agricultural Organizations, a single reply was returned. 
 Central officials were ignorant of the number and location of their own local agencies. 
 They gave out huge cash advances without checking: each local branch had its own accountants. 
 If even only some of these criticisms were true, then national leadership in the agricultural sphere, and above all the subjugation of the Famine, was in precarious hands. 
 Another report from Rabkrin accused Tsentroevak , the Central Refugee Evacuation Commission, of behaving in a very complacent fashion over the number of migrants piling up in the cities of Samara, Penza and Voronezh. 
 The administration of the Famine was divided into two distinct parts by VTsIK. 
 On 12 September 1922 it issued a decree abolishing Pomgol and replacing it with Posledgol  (the Committee for the Struggle Against the Consequences of the Famine). 
 It was announced that &bquo;the impact of the Famine had disappeared&equo;. 
 Substantial foreign aid had helped; weather conditions seemed likely to give good crop yields, and the early  returns of the spring harvest had provided a new supply of food. 
 Gosplan and other central economic organs from 1921 on had accumulated on paper a number of plans for reconstruction which they were now eager to realize. 
 As in the recent past, and as was to be the case with much greater frequency after the start of the Five-Year Plans, planners in Moscow drew up neat and rather abstract formulations that did not match up closely with local realities and timings. 
 Foreign relief organizations and subsequent students of their work have tended to exaggerate this dichotomy with regard to the Famine, but internal Soviet sources lend credence to the view that the sudden withdrawal of many kinds of domestic relief was premature. 
 In 1922 it was not so easy to predict crop yields as it is today. 
 In that sense the shift in policy contained an element of chance. 
 More important in human terms, Izvestiia  and other papers in early October recorded many instances of further starvation. 
 Local correspondents were &bquo;warning every day that the events which we saw last winter may occur again'. 
 As late as January 1923 Pravda  reported that in some villages in the Saratov guberniia 80 to 85 per cent of the population were still starving. 
 The abolition of Pomgol was greeted with so many protests from the affected areas of Russia that Kalinin had to issue two statements in which he tried to show the stricken population that it had not been abandoned by the government. 
 At first this was hard to prove, since local authorities were now given many new relief duties: at the same time a number of extensive taxation rights were transferred away from them to the Centre. 
 This move at least gave greater financial stability. 
 Between 15 October 1922 and 1 August 1923, for example, it received 719,502 gold roubles from the tax in kind (its highest source of income was 1,344,639 roubles from church treasures). 
 When in September 1922 the ARA discovered that the Soviet government intended to export grain in considerable quantities, most foreign relief organizations joined in the hue and cry. 
 The government gave a series of reasons for its  decision, some of them more plausible than others; but the main aim seemed to be to acquire cash or foreign credit for the rehabilitation of its industries. 
 More grain than expected had to be exported due to the precipitous fall in the grain price in the middle of the winter of 1922&ndash;3. 
 The fact that the price fell so steeply indicated that the gamble on the harvest had paid off, but due to delays and maladministration peasants were still starving, as we have seen. 
 It is clear that there were disagreements at the highest levels on the timing of the abolition of Pomgol and the export of grain. 
 The correspondent of The Times  in Riga, with access to both current Western and Soviet sources, picked up the discrepant views of M. Litvinov at the Hague and L. Krasin, the Commissar for Trade in Moscow. 
 At the start of August the former was telling the outside world of Russia's quick recovery, just when the latter was still being very pessimistic. 
 Lenin's attitude, in so far as it is discernible, will be looked at in a moment, but by this time he was more cut off through illness from daily supervision of affairs. 
 That there were divisions within the Politburo was indicated by the absence of Stalin, Trotsky, Bukharin, Tomsky, and Zinoviev from the friendly farewell ceremonies for the ARA. 
 The administration of the Famine was remarkable for the absence of nearly all leading Bolsheviks, apart from a few speeches from one or two of them. 
 Kamenev and Rykov served on Pomgol, but the extent of their participation is unclear. 
 Alone of all the top Bolsheviks, Kalinin visited some of the stricken areas by train, a peasant among peasants. 
 Lenin knew the Middle Volga better than any other leader, for he was born in Simbirsk, not far up river from Samara, had studied at Kazan&equo; university, and been a barrister in Samara. 
 Traditionally it was an area of peasant insurrectionists,  schismatics, and sectarians whose acerbic style was reflected in Lenin's own. 
 Did he have any political motives for apparently dealing with the Volga population almost as harshly and coldly as with starving Ukrainians or the Tambov peasantry? 
 What follows must be speculative in nature until the Cheka archives for 1921&ndash;2 are opened up, since matters are involved which would never have been aired publicly. 
 Certainly from the spring of 1918 Lenin was almost obsessed by the need to get grain to the cities of the north-west, for it was their turn to starve at that time. 
 He named the food supply crisis as the most important question of all, and called for a great &bquo;crusade, against speculators and the &bquo; kulak' , that recurring bogeyman of the regime until 1928. 
 Conceivably he may have thought in 1921&ndash;2 that previous peasant intransigence was now receiving its just reward. 
 Beyond this, it is quite clear that the Middle Volga still contained strong pockets of potential political resistance to the centre &mdash; the tradition of revolt died hard. 
 At the Left Socialist Revolutionary trial in Moscow in 1922 it was revealed that the Left Socialist Revolutionary Central Committee had sent emissaries to Tambov and other nearby gubernii. 
 One of them was probably the Samara guberniia, where since July 1920 a Left Socialist Revolutionary peasant called Sapozhkov had led an insurrection in the Buzuluk uezd. 
 After his death the standard was taken up by Serov, who still commanded 3,000 men as late as January 1922. 
 The threat to supply lines between Moscow and the Volga provinces was obvious. 
 Lenin decreed the taking of hostages from villages along the rebels&equo; line of march and instructed local party leaders to &bquo;cut down at the root&equo; any evidence of sympathy with the rebels on the part of the population. 
 Repercussions of these disturbances came to the attention of foreign relief workers. 
 In April 1922 an ARA representative complained to Eiduk that the local Soviet plenipotentiary's assistant had arrested five of his Russian employees in the Pugachev district of the Samara guberniia. 
 Eiduk's reply was  swift: &bquo;all active members of the Socialist Revolutionary Party were being arrested and the ARA happened to have employed them.&equo; 
 In Samara city another hostile faction, the Workers' Opposition, had been very strongly entrenched up to March 1921. 
 One authority on nation-wide local party activity in this period states that of all provinces Samara was the most troubled by wrangles inside the party in 1921. 
 The wounds were still visible in 1922. 
 May not Lenin have reacted in private in a way not so dissimilar from Stalin's overt and more violent reaction to political opposition in Georgia in the same year? 
 Both men no doubt were vexed by the unorthodoxy of their own birthplaces. 
 Whatever was in Lenin's mind, it is certain that the great Famine of 1921&ndash;2 wiped out any likelihood of peasant resistance. 
 Until 1921 some elements among the peasantry had kept a certain independence of outlook. 
 The Revolution had impinged on their consciousness only in so far as it provided them with land, or took away foodstuffs during War Communism. 
 It is usually said that the introduction of NEP pacified the peasants, but the Famine had a quicker effect in this respect. 
 Agricultural resources had been reduced drastically. 
 In the course of eight months 20 per cent of all horses in the country had been killed. 
 Thirty-five per cent of all draught animals were lost, if Civil War casualties are included. 
 Although the provinces round Petrograd and Moscow and on the Upper Volga recovered fast economically and were probably better treated, since they had stayed faithful to the Bolsheviks from 1917, they were relatively unimportant as agricultural producers. 
 The fact that the government thought it vital to supplement the economic incentives of NEP by a new Agrarian Code, brought out at the end of 1922, showed how far the Famine had altered previous calculations. 
 Rural areas were now allowed more freedom of choice as to farming methods, and the peasants' propensity to more individualistic action was encouraged. 
 The main consequence of the Famine, after human loss of life and suffering, was continuing economic and social  instability. 
 At the conclusion of the survey of tax and other fiscal arrangements in the Smolensk guberniia it was noted that the financial framework of NEP was shaky from the outset. 
 When the disruptions caused by the Famine are added to this scenario, the situation appears more grave. 
 Discounting loss of human and animal lives and equipment, the dislocation in revenue alone was enormous. 
 The tax in kind for 1921&ndash;2 realized only 150 million pudy, half of the total collection for 1920&ndash;1. 
 The estimate had been 240 million pudy. 
 This was not for lack of punitive methods. 
 One uezd in Simbirsk guberniia, just to the west of Samara and nearly as badly affected, had been assessed for tax at 470,000 pudy in 1919 on a good crop, of which 350,000 had been collected. 
 In 1922 the tax was 698,000 pudy on an indifferent crop. 
 The chief symptom of continuing instability was the &bquo;scissors crisis&equo; which began to affect Smolensk and all other gubernii in 1922, as has been seen, and reached a climax in 1923 when the scissors opened too widely in favour of manufactured goods. 
 Industrial prices by then had risen two to three times more quickly than agricultural ones. 
 The huge slump in the grain price on the Volga and elsewhere in the winter of 1922, and the lesser slide in the price of flax from Belorussia, were but two of the contributing factors, though grain played a basic role. 
 As a result the rural population of all Russia would need four years, until 1926, to recover from the combined disasters of the Famine and crude central fiscal and administrative measures. 
 There was little hope that it would weigh for much in the balance of political life until then. 
 One of the main reasons for the introduction of NEP had been the peasants, ability to throttle the industrial towns of European Russia by withholding food supplies. 
 The cities and the regime survived this temporary threat, but the boomerang effect of the Famine on the countryside had more lasting influence.  
 Communications  
 PROVINCIAL LIFE as such is now left behind as we turn to various types of connections between it and the political and cultural centres of Russia. 
 Some nationwide systems of Bolshevik political control are examined in the next chapter, whereas here more neutral communications networks are studied. 
 However, since the accent in this book lies on social and political affairs, the railways and the press will be considered from this angle. 
 In fact both networks were subject to heavy political intervention. 
 The first carried goods and people, the second ideas and information. 
 Within their own spheres, they were of overriding importance. 
 Road, air, and even river transport were of little significance by comparison with the railways. 
 The public relied to a minimal extent on what were by modern standards vestigial radio, telephone, and film-distribution systems. 
 Lenin and the Bolsheviks had grasped the supreme political importance of the railways and the press as instruments for turning their domination of some cities of European Russia in 191 7 into an all-Russian revolution. 
 This lesson had been reinforced as far as the railways were concerned each spring from 1918 to 1920, when urgent orders went out from the highest level to rehabilitate them in order to cope with the influx of vital foodstuffs and fuel to the towns. 
 In addition the strategic significance of the railways had impressed itself on the Bolsheviks. 
 Through their hold over the nine main lines fanning out from Moscow to all points of the compass they had succeeded in cutting off one White force from another in the Civil War. 
 Lenin took a personal interest in railway and  electricity technology for another reason. 
 Both networks fed energy (light, and food, fuel, human agents) round the ex-Empire. 
 Both were subject to easily measured norms, timetables and co-ordinated planning: therefore of all systems they seemed to be the most suitable for the immediate application of Taylorism and what Lenin called &bquo;the precision of clockwork&equo;. 
 He also realized that if large-scale economic and social organization on Marxist lines was ever to replace the small-scale realities of early Soviet life and improve the volume of exchange of goods between manufacturing plants and the villages, then efficient railways would serve as the thin edge of the wedge. 
 The ex-peasant Sergei Esenin viewed them in a more suspicious way in a poem published in 1922: 
 With what blind fear in snow-chaos 
 The changing terror rocked and swayed. 
 Good day to you, black Nemesis! 
 I come out to meet you half way. 
 The railway system continued to figure largely in high political planning in 1922. 
 As Tomsky put it at the Fifth Congress of Trade Unions on 2 October 1922: &bquo;Without the strengthening and support of transport there can be no construction of socialism.&equo; 
 In reality, as opposed to the somewhat utopian visions of Lenin, the railways in 1922 were an unlikely candidate for Taylorist methods. 
 Although the government placed &bquo;the political and economic backbone of the Republic in heavy industry and in transport&equo;, Trotsky observed at the Twelfth Party Congress that they actually formed the rearguard. 
 During the Civil War 1,885 km. of railway track had been destroyed; 8.6 million pudy of metal were required to repair them, but only 5.3 million could be produced. 
 Of the 19,067 engines in stock in 1921&ndash;2, 64 per cent were unusable  according to official estimates. 
 Not until 1926 did servicing catch up with urgent repair needs. 
 In 1922 3.32 per cent of all wagons lay idle for lack of maintenance. 
 Gudok , the railway newspaper, reported on 22 September 1922 that the Moscow workshops on the Kursk line were full of rusting machinery, since rain came through the roof. 
 Railway stock sent from Black Sea ports to another area, the Middle Volga, was not sent back for more grain, but for the most part ended up in Siberia. 
 In Smolensk guberniia a long list of bridges, points, and crossings had been blown up in military action. 
 In the chapter on Smolensk guberniia it was noted how peasants were bludgeoned into hauling wood to engine fuel-dumps, although they were not paid for it. 
 In January 1922 the Smolensk party committee estimated that there was only enough fuel of all kinds left for seven to eight days' consumption. 
 This was a nation-wide phenomenon. 
 In Kharkov and Poltava lack of fuel was cited as the worst problem of all. 
 Three times as much unsuitable wood, which ruined engine-boilers, was being used throughout Russia than in 1913. 
 It comprised 38 per cent of all fuel, as opposed to 13.1 per cent in 1913. 
 The layman usually thinks of passenger traffic first, and freight second, but the latter is usually of far greater importance, and Russia was no exception. 
 The level of truck loadings for 1922 was under one-third of what it had been in 1913, although there was a vast improvement towards the end of the year. 
 The carriage of private goods accelerated most. 
 Despite Gosplan's Marxist ideal of trying to stop uneven economic development, by the end of NEP the position had changed very little from the old Tsarist need to move commodities from the south ind cast to the more heavily populated north and west of European Russia. 
 That is why the Moscow Kursk and Moscow Volga lines were so sensitive, amongst others. 
 In industry  machines are stable and raw materials are mobile. 
 On the other hand agricultural land is fixed so that beasts and tools have to be taken to the fields and then off them. 
 Russian agriculture in early NEP was an involuntary small-scale transport industry which for the most part lay far away from the railway lines. 
 Remember how our peasant woman made her way painstakingly on foot, then by boat and cart to the uezd centre of Roslavl' in Belorussia. 
 The railways, like rivers, fertilized only a very narrow strip along their course, leaving nearly untouched the rhythm of life in the rural hinterland. 
 A Soviet propaganda film showing a map of Russia lights up the rays of the 1917 Revolution spreading round the country. 
 It is not fortuitous that they follow the railway lines from Petrograd and Moscow. 
 Both the Provisional Government and the Bolsheviks were aware of this in 1917. 
 The position had not changed by early NEP. 
 The more remote the locality from the main network of political and other communications, the more likelihood there was of unorthodox behaviour, whether of a passive kind, as in the recesses of the gubernii of Smolensk or Kursk, or of a more menacing nature, as with the Tambov and Siberian peasant revolts. 
 As late as 1926 this general pattern, though subject to some exceptions, is clearly observable, as will be seen in the case-studies of Tver guberniia and Kazakhstan. 
 The number of passengers on Russian railways in 1922 was calculated to be 91.1 million, as opposed to 184.8 million in 1913. 
 This huge decline was soon to be reversed in NEP, for by 1926 the figure was 259.9 million. 
 Some allowance must be made for the large number of passengers without tickets in 1922. 
 In one incident alone near Smolensk, seventy-four persons were arrested for not paying for their journey. 
 The different categories of traveller are very hard to assess at all precisely. 
 Before 1914 they would have been mainly peasant-workers commuting twice a year to the cities, gentry and their numerous domestic servants moving from their estates to town, kustari with their wares for sale, government servants, and the military, etc. 
 By 1922 the first three types had either disappeared completely (the gentry) or were at a very low ebb. 
 The  &bquo;Nepmen&equo; had not yet prospered sufficiently to replace the &bquo;bagmen&equo;, those petty speculators of War Communism. 
 Demobilization was drawing to an end, and many of the suffering migrants like the Famine refugees and the wandering hordes of orphans and youths could not often afford to take a train. 
 Travel went at a very slow pace. 
 The average commercial speed was 12.8 km. per hour at the start of 1923. 
 When ARA famine officials went from Kazan' to Simbirsk in the autumn of 1921, it took them four days to cover 150 miles. 
 In July 1921 the new statutes of the Commissariat of Ways and Communications had been issued, putting the railways on a peacetime basis. 
 In the spring of 1922 their management was decentralized to some extent and subjected to khozraschet (strict accounting principles). 
 It was hoped that this would result in better co-operation from local administrators and party members in the supply of labour and fuel, etc. 
 The reorganization was recommended by an engineer in the pages of a leading Petrograd journal, since he thought it would lead to the dissemination of experts. 
 At the local level, too, there were calls for the maximum amount of latitude in self-administration. 
 However, tension arose between the need for decentralization in order to ensure more technical efficiency and political fears of too much independence. 
 It was not long before the chairman of each local railway-board was compelled to become a representative of the central Commissariat. 
 Railway construction, together with textiles, had provided the impetus for large-scale industrial products in Russia. 
 For long-distance hauls the public, the economy, and virtually all messages in the form of letters, newspapers, telephone, and telegraph, continued to rely heavily on railway communications in the 1920s. 
 Railways are a type of transport that fall easily under central control, and whose construction may even intensify political centralism, because of the rationality of disposing lines so as to converge at a central point. 
 Like the absence of useful maritime peripheries, however, they can only serve as a secondary reinforcement of pre-existing leanings to  political centralism. 
 Canada similarly depends greatly on railways, has widely separated confines and high latitudes, but possesses a very different socio-economic and political system. 
 Sea, inland waterway, and road transport came under the control of the Commissariat as well as the railways. 
 For long hauls the rivers still remained more important than roads in NEP, despite the fact that many of them flow to the Arctic and are frozen for long periods. 
 Long- and cheap-haul facilities were vital in a poor country occupying 17 per cent of the inhabited surface of the earth. 
 Natural resources were scattered over vast areas. 
 The faster Russia modernized, the more she needed her population dispersed in order to extract newly developed wealth. 
 The massive preponderance of peasants up to the end of NEP and beyond also ensured a widely disseminated population. 
 River traffic suffered in the Revolution as the railways had done. 
 In 1913 there had been 59,400 km. of navigable internal waterways, but this was reduced to 53,900 by 1922, a relatively small decline compared with the railways. 
 It is not so easy to destroy a waterway. 
 The number of passengers carried was 11.5 million in 1913, 7 million in 1920, and 12 million by 1924: the productivity of river transport rose much faster after 1921 than that of the railways, although many problems had to be overcome, as was seen with regard to the Volga fleet in Chapter 3. 
 The length of metalled roads in the country was well under half that of navigable rivers in 1913 &mdash; 24,300 km. 
 This remained steady at 25,000 km. in 1920, but actually dropped in the more prosperous years after 1922 to 23,100 in 1924. 
 Roads much traversed in the Civil War or in the invasion of Poland, like those of Belorussia, deteriorated from use by military vehicles. 
 Even less important than long-distance  roads were air routes. 
 The first regular civil flight opened up in May 1922 between Moscow and K&ouml;nigsberg. 
 A new service began between Moscow and Nizhnii Novgorod in 1923. 
 Nearly all messages in the form of letters, newspapers, telephone, and telegraph went along the railway lines. 
 Telecommunications were easier to build, service, and tap in this way. 
 In 1913 there were 11,000 post and telecommunications offices, of which only 3,000 were in rural localities. 
 The figures for 1924 were 9,000 and 2,700, showing yet another decline in facilities. 
 On 9 February 1922 a letter of complaint to the press from postmen headed &bquo;The uncommunicative Commissariat&equo; stated that the Moscow post office, with 4,000 employees, was frozen up for lack of snow-cleaners. 
 Letters had to be sent in bulk to Smolensk to be sorted and distributed. 
 It took fifteen days for telegrams to get from Moscow to Tsaritsyn during the Famine. 
 In Smolensk guberniia 350 telegraph-workers went on strike for better pay and conditions on 29 April. 
 On 5 May telegraph-wires were cut down near Bykhov. 
 The party authorities ascribed this to sabotage by peasants objecting to tax assessments. 
 Even by 1926 links remained feeble. 
 In Kursk guberniia the telephone system was a subject for derision. 
 Frequent administrative changes &bquo;created conditions for its progressive ( sic ) decline and to a kustar&equo; development of communications' (it is interesting to note that &bquo;kustar'&equo; had by then followed &bquo; kulak &equo; as a term of abuse). 
 In the Tver guberniia conditions in 1926 were as good as anywhere outside a few industrial regions. 
 Letters were delivered twice a week only. 
 The inhabitants of Goritskaia volost' near Tver received fewer letters towards the end of 1926 than they had done in 1913. 
 There were single telephones in one or two villages. 
 It was too expensive for most private individuals there to send telegrams; the network was used almost exclusively by the authorities. 
 Whereas 577  telegrams had been sent off and 1,158 received in the volost' in 1913, the figures for 1926 were 672 and 785 respectively. 
 The overwhelming majority of peasant communications were oral in nature in a society that was still largely illiterate. 
 The range of information was thus short, though the art of rumour sometimes had widespread effects. 
 The radio was a useful political and social tool in a society of this kind, but its impact did not hit even Britain until the 1920s. 
 In Russia there were almost no major broadcasts until 1922. 
 The retarded development of all the means of communication mentioned above had certain economic, social, and political consequences throughout NEP. 
 Not until the years of fast industrialization and construction were these defects to be remedied. 
 The lack of an efficient railway system was a major contributing factor to the stagnant economy. 
 Since the railways and the cables alongside them carried most of the nation's newspapers, letters, and long-distance oral messages, little stimulus could be given towards the social and ethnic unification of a country that was notorious for the gap between town and country living conditions. 
 Together with Germany in the 1930s, Russia since 1917 has had the most penetrating system of political propaganda, but it was severely hampered at first by inefficient technical means for dissemination over vast spaces and many minority nationalities. 
 In order to show how acute the problems were, let us return to the government's handling of the railway network in 1922. 
 On the last day of 1921 the Party Central Committee appointed Feliks Dzerzhinsky, the head of the Cheka and Commissar for Transport, to the commission for the dispatch of food supplies and grain seed from Siberia and the Ukraine. 
 On 5 January he went to Siberia. 
 Three motives lay behind this. 
 The first was as stated in the conditions of his appointment; but there were two other political reasons which will be examined later. 
 One-fifth of all Russian victuals came from  Siberia at this time according to local estimates. 
 Dzerzhinsky discovered 2,583 unused railway-trucks there (some of them sent on from the Volga and dumped, as has been seen). 
 Over two thousand telegrams, mainly concerning the supply of the Famine areas, had been held up inside Siberia. 
 Railway workers had gone without pay, proper food, and clothes for months. 
 Dzerzhinsky at once put his programme on a military footing in nineteen rail-centres. 
 The central authorities were instructed to send 100 million roubles to pay the railwaymen. 
 As a result loading went up in volume by four times within a month. 
 Yet by the end of the year the fuel supply was still critical. 
 Gudok  reckoned that there would be only two to three days' reserve for the railways as a whole. 
 This newspaper also criticized Dzerzhinsky for neglecting water transport and port facilities, though no doubt his great energies were stretched in Siberia where he stayed until March. 
 He did in fact inspect the port of Petrograd in late June. 
 Although politically a centralist, Dzerzhinsky was pragmatic enough on the spot. 
 Once in Siberia he realized that estimates made on paper in Moscow for the dispatch of 250 wagons a day to the Volga were completely unrealistic. 
 Only seventy could be handled. 
 In a letter sent later to the central authorities he advised that transport problems should be viewed in organic conjunction with local economic needs. 
 Gosplan was still demanding central control. 
 Dzerzhinsky was also a strong advocate for the application of khozraschet, although he understood the peculiar difficulties of nation-wide utilities in this respect. 
 In a report to a plenary meeting of Tsektran  in June, he said that trains should stop acting like droshkys, carrying people and goods where they wished for little or no pay. 
 The tariff for goods carriage now stood at  20,000 times previous rates, but this still fell far below the cost-of-living index due to astronomical inflation. 
 The second reason for the dispatch of Dzerzhinsky to Siberia was to clear up the situation after the Civil War, and to deal with Siberian peasant revolts. 
 These aims are admitted to in Soviet sources, but we as yet know very little from any source about the nature and extent of peasant disturbances. 
 White forces had intended to blow up more railway lines and workshops. 
 Explosives were found in nearly all of the latter and there had been twenty fires in them between 1 November and 26 December 1921. 
 Dzerzhinsky had been made Commissar for Transport in the first place to deal with internal troubles among the railwaymen, many of whom had opposed the Bolsheviks in 1917 and nearly brought Lenin's government to its knees after the October Revolution. 
 Lingering resistance was not confined to Siberia. 
 The railway secret police were active throughout 1922 in Smolensk guberniia: in their February report, they noted the presence in one section of the railways of six active Mensheviks, one SR, and an ex-Tsarist secret police agent. 
 Equal ruthlessness was applied to those who misused the railways and were brought before &bquo;the revolutionary tribunal, whose avenging hammer will fall with all its crushing might and wrath&equo;. 
 In September 211 speculators in railway tickets were arrested at Moscow stations. 
 In October the secret police were permitted by the Central Committee to start shooting railway bandits on the spot without legal proceedings. 
 Yet another suspect category were the many spetsy  (bourgeois specialists) who worked for the Commissariat. 
 Dzerzhinsky stressed that local authorities should collaborate with them, but at the centre he was adamant that they should take no part in transport decisions that had any, political implications.  
 The third reason why Dzerzhinsky was sent off to distant Siberia was purely political, and had little to do with the railways. 
 At the Ninth All-Russian Congress of Soviets on 22 December 1921, Lenin called for the reform of the Cheka. since NEP required more &bquo;revolutionary legality&equo;. 
 Dzerzinsky's absence the Cheka was replaced by the GPU ( Gosudarstvennoe politicheskoe upravlenie ), which was now to be integrated within the Commissariat for Internal Affairs. 
 No doubt it was easier to reform it with Dzerzhihsky nut of Moscow, although he retained his post as head. 
 In fact its effectiveness was hardly diminished, although its staff was reduced, like those of all Commissariats at the time. 
 The new secret police swiftly recovered many of the powers of its predecessor. 
 It was one of those Bolshevik instruments of nation-wide control which will be studied in the next chapter. 
 Dzerzhinsky frequently thought of the railway network in very similar terms. 
 For lick of adequate progress in the improvement of central local party and social ties in general, he and others, including Lenin, diverted their energies into the immediate practical tasks of rehabilitating the transport system. 
 Dzerzhinsky wrote that the swifter exchange of goods would help to reduce taxes levied on the peasants and so mollify them and speed up the realization of smychka between town and country; but towards the end of the year he admitted in a resigned tone: &bquo;Can such a huge enterprise like transport really change in a moment, can people really be regenerated at once? 
 It is done slowly, step by step.&equo; 
 He was to die in 1926 with his vision still unfulfilled, although the Turkestan-Siberian railway, that considerable economic, social, and ethnic unifier, was on the drawing-boards. 
 It was opened in 1931. 
 What type and number of men did Dzerzhinsky control on the railways? 
 For the first time in this book we shall take a closer look at one branch of the proletariat. 
 It was a very special branch in many way. 
 In the first place it comprised by far the largest number of workers in one industry. 
 In 1922 there were no less than 983,045 of them, though the number  was reduced to 793,000 by 1923&ndash;4. 
 Their trade union was instructed to find jobs for those thrown out of work. 
 Some had already left because pay was so far in arrears. 
 Others with more initiative from the administrative ranks had taken up farming. 
 Whereas there had been 12.8 workers for every verst of line in 1913 there were 10.4 in 1922. 
 This was still overmanning to a considerable degree by world standards. 
 The labour code of 1922 made labour productivity worse by introducing an eight-hour day for engine crews. 
 Under the previous rules fourteen hours had been the maximum shift allowed. 
 The railway industry was huge in both size and geographical extent. 
 At the top of the hierarchy were the civil service employees in the administration headquarters of the different branches and in Moscow. 
 Next came the engineers, planners, statisticians, and less important office-workers. 
 None of these could be classified strictly as proletarians, even by the loose and ideologically biased definitions of the early Soviet period. 
 In 1917 this group had comprised between 16 and 17 per cent of all railway employees. 
 The gamut then descended from skilled engine-drivers and railway telegraph workers, conductors, points men, couplers, etc., to depot-workers and porters. 
 At the bottom end of the scale we leave the proletariat altogether with the track-maintenance men, who were usually recruited from the local peasantry. 
 In less industrial areas of the country there were more railway-workers than any other kind. 
 In Belorussia in October 1922 there was a labour force of 23,428 on the railway network, as against 12,323 other workers in all Belorussian industry. 
 Numbers alone did not mean automatic economic and political strength. 
 The geographical and social distribution of railway-workers meant that they were not as cohesive a force as  other industrial groups like the steel- or textile-workers. 
 These weaknesses were exploited by the Bolsheviks in 1917 when Vikzhel , the old railway trade union, threatened to cut off the capital and the government from the rest of Russia unless Lenin listened to its political demands. 
 a rival trade union was formed which drew much more heavily on the lower social strata in the labour force and on the Moscow railway workshops and other industrial centres. 
 Never again was there to be a nation-wide intervention by the railway-workers, although those social tension persisted which had helped the bolsheviks to divide and rule in 1912. 
 In March 1922 &bquo;snobbish clerks&equo; on the Moscow Kursk line, which had been on of the most revolutionary, in 1905 and 1917, were refusing to attend meetings where common signalman and the like were to be found. 
 Other lines showed more solidarity and local initiative. 
 In the Gomel'sk workshops in Belorussia 450 railway staff collected one and a half million roubles in order to start up their own social insurance scheme for lack of an adequate state system. 
 A training-school with forty students was opened. 
 Like all other workers in 1922, Belorussian railwaymen complained about their pay. 
 In May 200 struck on the Orlov-Vitebsk line on this account, declaring that instead of devoting its energy to extracting gold from the churches, the government should find ways of paying them better. 
 The rank and file pointed out that even skilled workshop men earned only 12 million roubles, but administrative heads got 45 million: &bquo;it's like the old monarchical structure.&equo; 
 On the Moscow Petrograd line workers reported in the middle of February that they had not been paid for all January; in the Caucasus the backlog in August stretched back to October 1921. 
 When forty-two railway-workers who defected from Syzran' station were put on trial, their sentence was alleviated because they had not been paid. 
 Railwaymen were encouraged to start up kitchen gardens near the stations in order to survive. 
 Gudok  ran frequent articles on the wage demands of badly paid German railwaymen. 
 The severe military tribunals of War Communism for  railway discipline were not disbanded until 1923, so potential strikers could be discouraged by the threat of what amounted to a court martial. 
 Civil War conditions lingered on in other ways. 
 In January an armoured car of the type that had proved so useful to Trotsky's campaign blocked the Tashkent-Moscow line and held up a locomotive that had been seized by an armed gang. 
 In April a complete armoured train was sent in pursuit of bandits on the Vladikavkazskaia line. 
 Gudok  pointed out that such an exploit could not be repeated all over Russia, so staff on individual railway lines would have to keep their eyes skinned for military or criminal activity. 
 From the start of the year until 20 October there were thirty major railway crashes in contrast to none for all of 1913. 
 The bad state of the tracks and the huge shortage of sleepers were mainly to blame. 
 Railway officials, like their political bosses in Moscow, were apt to muse on the brilliant future in order to escape from pressing current problems. 
 The electrification of the network, a topic close to Lenin's heart, was discussed in the pages of Gudok . 
 It was hoped that soon the lines to the Don basin and Nizhnii Novgorod would be electrified, followed quickly by the whole of the Siberian network. 
 The railways were seen as &bquo;colonization &lsqb;sic&rsqb;  pioneers&equo; for a huge agricultural country with vast mineral and other resources waiting to be exploited. 
 In reality the system was caught between the stringencies of the Civil War and the burgeoning petty corruption of NEP. 
 Bureaucratic wrangles were conspicuous at every level. 
 Other Commissariats were accused of holding on to rolling-stock that should be handed back now the war was over. 
 The Commissariat for War still hung on to 752 coaches; the Commissariat for Health had no fewer than 2,718, and was even demanding a further 1,200. 
 From a reading of Gudok  for the whole year the impression is received of workers indulging in an endless series of meetings on a range of subjects from pay to culture, the Famine, technical improvement, national and international politics, usually during work hours. 
 One sector pilfered from another, causing havoc. 
 When the Vladikavkazskaia line stole the only shunting locomotive from Mozdok station, camels and bullocks were harnessed to trucks which had to be moved. 
 A  cartoon shows them being supervised by an ass in uniform. 
 &bquo;Uncultured&equo; workers loaded manure on to a passenger train bound for Ekaterinburg, so that not even &bquo;hares&equo; (passengers without tickets) would board it. 
 Corruption flourished in the wake of galloping inflation and the relaxed conditions of NEP. 
 Hens pecked at unwanted rouble notes from piles of sacks dumped on the railway lines for no clear reason. 
 One enterprising station-master frequently told all passengers that their trains would not leave for a long time. 
 When the trains left at once, those stranded were invited to eat at the buffet, heated by fuel filched from locomotives and run by the master and his cronies. 
 As trade picked up slowly towards the end of the year, genuine Nepmen started to make their presence felt. 
 Railway employees, or &bquo;Nepo-idols&equo; as they were called, queued for hours for scarce tickets for the Nepmen who tipped them for their service. 
 Other Nepmen used Pomgol labels on their goods in order to avoid paying the railway tariffs. 
 Compared with the railways, the press network suffered very little from corruption or abuse. 
 In this sphere Lenin had an ever stronger interest than in the railways. 
 His mainstream career prior to 1917 had been that of a journalist. 
 The imposition of a severe censorship and the sacking of all hostile editors (there were almost no spetsy in the press) immediately upon the seizure of power in October 191 7 had ensured its smooth running from the political and administrative point of view. 
 The key to any understanding of the prime importance of the Soviet press is contained in Lenin's remarks on its function. 
 For him a paper was much more than a published news-sheet. 
 It had to be a collective propagandist, agitator, and organizer as well. 
 He compared the press to a scaffolding, surrounding a building under construction (the worker's state), which marked the outlines of the structure, facilitated communication among the builders, enhanced the effective assignment of tasks, and made possible a clear view of the achievements of the builders. 
 In its role as the chief purveyor of propaganda and  agitation, the press had shifted its accent at the start of NEP. 
 The years 1917&ndash;21 had been devoted chiefly to the legitimization of the regime, whereas the stress from 1922 until 1926 lay on the urgent need to raise the cultural level of the population. 
 After 1926 the accent was to lie on the development of technical education. 
 Three levels of consciousness were involved in creating a sense of political and cultural unity in the largest country in the world. 
 the first level was concerned with the stamping out of political regionalism and other local attitudes that limited central authority. 
 This had been accomplished in the main by 1921, thanks to the combined application of brute force in the Civil War and the persuasive methods of the press and other media. 
 Pockets of resistance still remained in 1922, in Tambov, Siberia, Georgia, and Central Asia: seemingly safe areas, like the Smolensk and Kursk gubernii, were not as stable as they seemed to be on the surface. 
 Yet the general position had improved enough for the government to proceed to its second level campaign &mdash; the creation of nation-wide cultural uniformity through mass education as the chief instrument of modernization in a period when technical means and financial resources were not as yet adequate for fast modernization through industrialization. 
 The problems confronting the Bolsheviks in early NEP were formidable. 
 The difficulty of undermining traditional ways and beliefs has been noted again and again, in the continuing hold of religion in Smolensk, the educational crisis in Kursk, the peculiar problems in Makarenko's colony. 
 The cultural conquest of the countryside by the towns and of oral by literate culture was the prime aim of the press, and we shall examine this role in more detail. 
 The third and most sophisticated role in initiating cultural ideas comprised those intellectuals who were faithful to Bolshevik goals. 
 They played a significant role in initiating cultural ideas at the centre for subsequent vulgarization and dissemination throughout Russia, at first through &bquo;fat&equo; specialized journals and then later via the popular press. 
 Their activities at the start of NEP are studied in the chapter devoted to the cultural capital, which was still Petrograd rather than Moscow in 1922. 
 As will be seen, there was a serious lack of cohesion within the cultural &eacute;lite itself. 
 Furthermore their activities at the rarefied levels of Petrograd and Moscow often had very little impact,  either at the time or subsequently, on the masses and on provincial life. 
 The low circulation and poor distribution of leading literary journals provide clear evidence of the &eacute;litist character of the cultured few. 
 Young Guard , one of the most popular of this type of journal, had a circulation of only 9,000 in 1922, and dropped to between 5,000 and 6,000 an issue by 1926. 
 As the son of a school-inspector and a typical representative of the pre-Soviet intelligentsia, Lenin was torn between the conflicting needs of creating a politically and culturally conscious nation as fast as possible, yet at the same time ensuring that vulgarized, superficial agitation did not become a substitute for thoroughgoing education on a broad base. 
 The second alternative would take a long time to achieve. 
 Neither alternative was anywhere near implemented by 1926, let alone in 1922. 
 Prevailing conditions in the organization and distribution of the popular press were partly responsible for this. 
 Two factors at the start of 1922 had an inhibiting influence. 
 In January all newspapers were transferred to khozraschet. 
 The initial deleterious effects of cost accounting struck the press as badly as they upset the railways, education, local Soviet administration, and trade. 
 The Agitprop section of the Central Committee of the party worked out a blueprint for all the central and local press networks in January. 
 Papers under the control of the gubispolkomy should be curtailed drastically, whilst central organs directed at mass party propaganda would expand quickly in numbers and influence. 
 Party committees at every level should supervise local editorial boards more closely. 
 As a small sop to regional differences, special networks were to be set up in the Ukraine, the Caucasus, and the other national minority areas. 
 Moscow and Petrograd papers were allowed to continue at the same volume but the rest of the press was to be reduced eventually to 232 papers, 158 of them guberniia and 74 uezd.  
 The combined result of khozraschet and the over-centralized and ill-informed onslaught oh the local press by Agitprop was a fast decline at guberniia and lower levels: of the 802 papers in existence on 1 January 1922, a mere 313 remained by 1 July. 
 Some of the casualties had small circulations, but by the spring papers with an average circulation of about 50,000 copies were also going to the wall. 
 The total number picked up to 423 by 1 December. 
 This situation was hardly conducive to the unification of the country through the medium of the press. 
 Journalists themselves as well as the party seemed almost oblivious of the harm being wrought. 
 The third congress of journalists which met at the end of January simply stressed the importance of party leadership of the press and made no practical survey of what was actually happening. 
 Only a few delegates sensed that pressing problems had been shelved. 
 The situation had become so severe by the spring, however, that the Eleventh Party Congress took time off other matters to discuss it. 
 The debate was opened by none other than our party visitor to Kursk, Ia. 
 Yakovlev, the head of Agitprop and one of the chief architects of the cut-back in provincial newspapers in January. 
 Yet he appeared surprised to find in Kursk guberniia near the end of 1922 that even villages near to the Moscow railway line had received their last single copies some months earlier. 
 The Congress was told that journalists had been registered in only fifty of ninety guberniia committees. 
 Editors were instructed to mould their articles far more to the educational levels of workers and peasants. 
 Prime costs for newspaper production were rising fast as supporting industries and services demanded real payment under khozraschet conditions. 
 Thus subscription prices were shooting up and cutting off thousands of readers who could no longer afford them. 
 The Congress made several resolutions. 
 Party members were now obliged to subscribe to at least one party newspaper. 
 Such a basic prescription indicated how low the readership was sinking. 
 The output of private presses, which was growing much faster than that of the party and the state, had to be monitored, and surpassed in quality by party organs. 
 &bquo;The rising gutter  literature&equo;, as the private press was called, appealed especially to wayward youth. 
 In this connection the whole of the local Komsomol press was ordered to put itself under the leadership of the party guberniia committees. 
 In view of the unorthodox behaviour of the Komsomol that we have noted in the provinces, such a move was overdue. 
 Finally, guberniia executive committees were charged with the resurrection of village reading-rooms, most of which had gone under in the changed economic conditions of NEP. 
 Mere words could do little in the short term to reverse the chaotic situation. 
 Saratov guberniia, admittedly a troubled area, reduced its press network from twenty-five organs in mid-1921 to two by the spring of 1922. 
 Petrograd, still the cultural centre of the whole country, had been spared the cut-back of January 1922, but due to financial pressures four papers merged into two in order to save costs. 
 By the spring a single copy of krasnaia gazeta  in the city cost 100,000 roubles. 
 Only at the close of the summer did things improve at the central, though not yet at the local level. 
 In August the Agitprop section of the Twelfth Party Conference had set up a commission to start a state subsidy for the politically reliable press. 
 Private journals continued to burgeon, as will be seen in Chapter 6, but the state press could henceforth stand better on its own feet financially. 
 A glance at the pages of Gudok , the organ of the railwaymen, will show the style and problems of a central newspaper at this time. 
 A long puff of printed steam trailed over the title of the paper, and this popular touch prevailed through its pages. 
 The language used was simpler and chattier than that of Pravda  or even of Trud , the main labour organ. 
 The format was smaller. 
 Cartoons for semi-literate railwaymen studded the pages, and the back page was nearly full of capitalist-style advertisements of all kinds. 
 This novel source of income was not available to papers in the stagnant agricultural hinterland. 
 Despite the huge number of potential customers (just short of a million)  and the fact that all copies of Gudok  were delivered free on the railways, the circulation was a paltry 30,000 in June. 
 A campaign was started to raise this figure to 100,000 by 1923. 
 The military was more crucial in terms of political control than the railwaymen. 
 As early as March 1918 the Bolsheviks had merged military and peasant newspapers into the single organ Bednota  (Poverty) under the direct supervision of the Central Committee. 
 The largest army in the world was recruited mainly from the peasantry, and, as has been seen in the provinces, the party still relied heavily in 1922 on ex-army men to act as leaven among the &bquo;dark people&equo;. 
 Bednota  up until 1923 was not a successful paper, however. 
 It cost too much, its intellectual standard was far too high, and its distribution was inefficient. 
 The independent Red Army press was rather better adapted to its readership. 
 In 1922 it received a shot in the arm through a large subsidy from the Central Committee. 
 The end of the Civil War, the transition to khozraschet, and its inability to use advertisements, had put all the military press in jeopardy. 
 The Commissariat for War stressed that the new funds should be concentrated on papers produced for distant units which would not otherwise get any press organ. 
 In his writings on the military press, Trotsky made it quite clear that party interests came first and the military second. 
 Despite good intentions and solid backing, the military published only fourteen papers with a circulation of about 70,000 copies, or little more than double that of Gudok  alone. 
 Another vital area in terms of sensitive political control were the national minorities. 
 Their press network, built up from 1917 on, had fluctuated in extent with the fortunes of the Civil War, but at its end nearly sixty papers in various national languages had been set up. 
 Most of them had been due to efforts on the spot by units of the Red Army. 
 At the start of NEP many of these papers collapsed for the same reasons that affected others. 
 It is strange that the party gave priority, not only to central and military organs, but also the guberniia- and  uezd-level papers in 1922, before intervening in the national minority sector in 1923. 
 Non-Russian papers were left to local military supervision until the end of Civil War, and largely to their own devices throughout 1922, unless they exhibited blatant defiance of high political directives, as in the case of Georgia. 
 This did not necessarily mean that all local party chiefs in the minorities were also lethargic during 1922. 
 We know from the Smolensk archive that the guberniia committee in the winter of 1922&ndash;3 convened meetings of many local organizations, compelling their members to subscribe to various Belorussian and Great-Russian newspapers. 
 Particular stress was laid on subscriptions to Rabochii put' , the guberniia party and Soviet organ. 
 The local peasant press was in a lamentable condition still. 
 Bednota  was read very rarely in the villages and hardly ever subscribed to, because, as the peasants themselves recounted, it never printed real peasant articles but presented the countryside as some kind of fairyland. 
 Even Smolenskaia derevnia , an organ specifically designed for local peasant consumption and far better attuned to Belorussian interests than Bednota , was criticized in 1923 for insufficient contact with village life. 
 At the start of NEP experienced Bolsheviks were not at the editorial helm of central and especially local newspapers. 
 Frequent orders from Moscow to appoint them indicate that until after the Twelfth Party Congress party editors were the exception rather than the rule in the regions. 
 Only by 1926&ndash;7 were 94.3 per cent of provincial editors party members. 
 In the early days of Soviet rule it was not unheard of for remote journals to attack Izvestiia  and the Central Committee. 
 Below the editorial level the real contact between the masses and the press was intended to be the worker-peasant correspondents ( Rabselkor ). 
 Until the beginning of NEP they constituted a disparate group of individuals to whom the party appealed for letters on local affairs, but in 1922 they acquired their official title and were subject to much more pressure from the centre. 
  This change took place for three reasons. 
 The fast growth of private trading and corruption associated with it could best be checked by individuals familiar with their localities. 
 Secondly, the switch to khozraschet meant that the press had to attract paying subscribers, who wanted to read about their own regions and not be submitted to generalized and boring directives from Moscow all the time. 
 In the third place peasant correspondents in particular looked as if they would be a useful source of information for the central authorities on dissatisfaction in the countryside and on the rising influence of peasant types not in favour with the party. 
 As with most initiatives, however, strength flowed from the centre first. 
 In 1922 formal circles of worker correspondents sprang up in Moscow and Petrograd, and then in Rostov-on-Don and Baku. 
 After the murder in April of one of Pravda's  rabkory who had reported abuses in a Moscow factory, the whole movement was galvanized into greater activity, and was to spread round the provinces by 1923. 
 By that year Bednota  had a circulation of roughly 100,000, with a network of about 4,000 peasant correspondents. 
 From January 1922 on, Lenin received a report every two months from the Bednota  editor on the contents and tenor of letters from peasant correspondents. 
 Since the majority of them were neither party members, nor teachers or agronomists, they represented a valuable addition to the ranks of those who might be able to promote smychka in the countryside. 
 The hopes with regard to smychka that were current in this period were proved utopian once again. 
 By 1923 there were frequent reports in the press of murders of peasant correspondents by fellow muzhiks. 
 This only incited the centre to renewed activity. 
 In November 1923 a new peasant paper, Krest'ianskaia gazeta , was to appear, with a circulation of 125,000 by March 1924. 
 Many correspondents complained that their constructive advice, as opposed to their prying, fell on stony ground, since most peasants lacked the means to put technical advice on agriculture into effect. 
 There were other reasons. 
 The  peasants did not fail to note that the correspondents were often ex-clerks of the Tsarist regime, and so extremely bureaucratic and long used to writing what their employers wanted to read. 
 We can in fact penetrate beyond the officialese of the correspondents, thanks to the investigations conducted by R. Shafir at this time into the peasants' own view of the press. 
 His main conclusion, after long travels round the countryside, was that among the peasants &bquo;there are no subscribers, no readers&equo;. 
 He found that most of them relied for information on their nearest educated contacts, the priests and the Nepmen, or else fell back on rumour, which still loomed large in their news lives. 
 Most of the gossip was about taxation. 
 It was thought that anyone subscribing to a newspaper would have to pay a special tax. 
 Among the wilder rumours in strong circulation were that Lenin was dead, that the French had chosen Nicholas as their Tsar, and that England had declared war on Russia, so there would be wholesale peasant mobilization once again. 
 The distribution speed of oral rumour was much quicker than that of newspapers, which from the guberniia capital of Voronezh' Shafir calculated to be one verst for every four and a half hours.The chief stumbling block to a wider newspaper audience remained the high illiteracy rate. 
 Shafir made a detailed study of comprehension levels by the supposedly literate. 
 A 27-year-old party member and ex-Red Army man had read the press regularly since 1917, but did not know the meaning of words such as &bquo;class enemy&equo;, occupation, period, or most abbreviations, including the USSR. 
 Words of foreign origin defeated many readers, and place-names of remote areas like Georgia had no meaning at all. 
 From 1923 onwards the party was to single out key categories of the rural population for education: these included ex-Red Army men, Komsomol members, and women deputies to the local Soviets. 
 In 1922 the number of literacy centres and those attending them fell to one-tenth of what they had risen to by 1921. 
 Menshevik critics of the regime claimed that compared with the pre-revolutionary period Russia in 1922 had 30 per cent  fewer schools overall and that 70 per cent of all children between 8 and 11 years of age were illiterate. 
 The burden of Russia's social backwardness could not be thrown off as quickly as the threat of political counterrevolution had been by the end of the Civil War. 
 It lingered on well into the 1930s. 
 Illiteracy was but one of its multiple facets. 
 Military victory in the Civil War had been achieved by a heavy emphasis on combined political and military control from the centre, and this successful method was broadly reapplied in NEP to social life, despite the relaxation on the economic front. 
 Insensitivity to local needs and aspirations was the result. 
 The Tsarist system had suffered from a similar defect. 
 Students of Russia who hail from much smaller and less heterogeneous countries might pause to ask themselves whether democratic rule under any kind of government is possible in a country as awesome in its administrative complexity as this one. 
 The example of the United States may be cited in order to refute such a fatalistic approach, but the American colonies were the progeny of the most sophisticated democratic country in the world, and in any case the American republic expanded from a near tabula rasa , politically and geographically speaking. 
 The Bolsheviks inherited a long tradition of centralist rule from which they had suffered, but whose methods they had imbibed only too deeply. 
 So had the provinces, which scarcely knew how to struggle for local political and cultural rights. 
 This is not to deny that the Bolsheviks' intentions for future political, social and national minority devolution were genuine, but at the close of the Civil War they governed a financially exhausted country. 
 Sufficient funds did not exist for the fast rehabilitation of the railways, for the immediate implementation of mass education. 
 In the long run the centralist traditions were to win the race against all hopes for some measure of local autonomy. 
 OUTDOOR ACTION 
 WALKING. 
 WHERE TO GO. 
 EQUIPMENT. 
 TESTS 
 September 1991 &pound;1.40 
 Gear test 
 Best selling boots 
 Weekend breaks in Pembrokeshire 
 Walks and activities in every region 
 Dinghy sailing learning the ropes 
 Top treks Great backpacking routes 
 Win &pound;1000 of gear 
 OUTDOOR ACTION 
 WALKING. 
 WHERE TO GO. 
 EQUIPMENT. 
 TESTS 
 On the trail 
 14 
 BACKPACKING ROUTES we look at some of the best 
 24 
 MOUNTAINS IN FOCUS the Czechoslovak Tatras 
 29 
 BOOK OFFER special deal on new guide to Czechoslovakia 
 30 
 WALKING around Scotland's &bquo;Queen of the Mountains&equo; 
 31 
 GREECE walking on the Greek island of Thassos 
 50 
 FLORA AND FAUNA watching nature in September 
 Keeping track 
 5 
 COMMENT the editor sets the world to rights 
 6 
 ACTION UPDATE what's happening where and when 
 8 
 WALK TALK a look at the lighter side of walking life 
 9 
 LETTERS readers air their views 
 9 
 QUERIES your outdoor questions answered 
 10 
 OUTDOOR UPDATE all the latest news from the countryside 
 19 
 SCOTLAND IN FOCUS challenge for conservationists 
 33 
 COMPETITION &pound;1000 of Camping Gaz gear to be won 
 53 
 ARMCHAIR UPDATE essential reading for the outdoors 
 73 
 NEXT MONTH what to look forward to in October 
 74 
 A DAY OUT WITH Pathcraft manager Keith Wilson 
 75 
 SUBSCRIPTION OFFER great free torch for new subscribers 
 Action stations 
 21 
 WEEKENDER walking and cycling in Pembrokeshire 
 34 
 LAKE DISTRICT walking holiday on the classic peaks 
 35 
 OUT AND ABOUT a walk and an activity centre in every region 
 44 
 EYE TO EYE with obsessive traveller Mark Shand 
 46 
 DINGHY SAILING all you need to know to take to the water 
 Gearing up 
 54 
 BUYERS' GUIDE outdoor products in the spotlight 
 56 
 EQUIPMENT TEST leather boots are put through their paces 
 60 
 GEAR GUIDE all you need to know about sleeping bags 
 65 
 MARKET ROUND UP wise ways to whip the wet 
 Comment 
 Raising money for charity has got to be worthwhile. 
 But sometimes it's difficult to sort out which causes are the most deserving of support. 
 However, there is no such dilemma with Climb For The World . 
 Here the organisers have set up an international event where walkers, climbers and people everywhere can do something they enjoy doing and benefit others at the same time. 
 On September 21&ndash;22 people from all over will join together to walk or climb one of the designated summits. 
 For some it will be a treacherous ascent of a sheer rockface, for others an easy stroll up a small hill. 
 Some will be in far-flung climates, others in their local patch. 
 The physical difficulty nor the location matter. 
 If you take part you will be showing solidarity with the poorest nations in the world and letting governments everywhere know that you care about the environment and its undeniable rush to destruction. 
 Hopefully you will also be raising money through sponsorship to help selected projects in countries far worse off than our own. 
 You'll find more details and information on how to register and select a designated peak on page 11. 
 At last doing something worthwhile can be the same as having fun! 
 Look out for the Outdoor Action  team when you do go and tell us what you think of the magazine. 
 Laura McCaffrey  
 Action update 
 Orienteering in the south east 
 September 14&ndash;15. 
 Now's the time for all would-be orienteers in the south-east to get out there and have a go on a Try Orienteering Weekend. 
 Events are being organised at venues throughout London and the south-east aimed at beginners of all ages and levels of fitness. 
 Members of orienteering clubs in the region will be on hand to help you get started. 
 Individuals and groups are welcome and entry fees range from free to &pound;2. 
 Wear long trousers/tracksuits and sturdy footwear. 
 Bring a red biro and a see-through bag for your map. 
 For more information contact: Jack Richmond) 81 776 0831 (eves). 
 Cycling in Nottinghamshire 
 September 8. 
 Investigate the oak and beech woodlands of one of the most wooded areas of England on a five hour cycle ride along bridleways and minor roads in Nottinghamshire. 
 The route will also take you to some of the finest areas of heathland in the country and will include a tea stop at Clumber Park Tea Rooms. 
 The ride begins at 10.30am outside the main gates to Sherwood Forest Visitor Centre. 
 Bring a picnic lunch. 
 Contact: Phil Keynes 0623 823202 for further information. 
 Walks around the country 
 September 29. 
 Assert your right to walk on land to which access is denied by taking part in the Ramblers' Association Forbidden Britain Day. 
 Walks are scheduled to take place all over the country taking routes which highlight various problems which have arisen from landowners denying access to the countryside. 
 National events will take place at six venues. 
 To find out more details about these and local events send a SAE to The Ramblers' Association, 1/5 Wandsworth Road, London SW8 2XX or telephone 071 582 6878.  
 Deer spotting in Lancashire 
 September 3 and 5. 
 Don't miss these two chances to see red deer and roe deer as they leave the cover of their reed beds in the Leighton Moss Nature Reserve. 
 The early evening watches will start at 7.30 pm until dusk, when you should see the deer and maybe some otters from the observation hides. 
 The watches will be led be experienced wardens who will also tell you about the species of deer you will see. 
 Bring your own binoculars or hire them for 80p at the reserve. 
 The watches cost &pound;1 for adults and 50p for children. 
 For more information contact: 0524 701601. 
 Navigation in the Lake District 
 September 6/8/13/15/22/29. 
 If you already know the basics of map and compass work but want to improve your skills, why not take part in one of the day courses organised throughout the Lake District National Park? 
 The practical courses are an informal opportunity to learn more about hill navigation, route planning and preparation, and walking across different types of terrain. 
 Places on the courses are limited and advance booking is essential. 
 Price &pound;2 for adults, &pound;1 for accompanied children. 
 Bring lunch and a 1:25 000 leisure map and compass if possible. 
 Contact: 09662 6601 for details. 
 Charity walk in Hertfordshire 
 September 29. 
 Put your best foot forward and walk all or part of a 25 mile route from London to Ware in Hertfordshire to raise money for the Heart Research Charity. 
 The walk covers flat terrain, following the Hertford Union and Lee Navigation towpaths through the Lee Valley Park. 
 The whole route is estimated to take eight hours but there will be checkpoints along the way for refreshments. 
 The walk starts at 8am at St Mark's Gate, Victoria Park in London and ends at Ware College, Scotts Road, Ware, Herts. 
 Entrants should be over 16, although younger experienced walkers accompanied by adults will be considered. 
 For further information, sponsor and entry forms send a 9in x 6in SAE to Lee Valley Park Countryside Centre, Abbey Farmhouse, Crooked Mile, Waltham Abbey, Essex. 
 Tel: 0992 713828. 
 Closing date for entries is September 9.  
 Picking poor packed lunches gets people in a proper pickle 
 Paper sandwiches don't reach the parts proper packed lunches penetrate, laments Ken Ward. 
 Chalk and cheese 
 You wouldn't dream of going into a restaurant and just ordering &bquo;a meal please&equo;. 
 So it's surprising that when we're staying in a guest house on a walking holiday we're content just to order &bquo;a packed lunch&equo;, and hope for the best. 
 Why do we do it? 
 I've had some packed lunches which were perfect, but I've also been sold some horrors. 
 The problem seems to be that the people who prepare the lunches have never actually opened one sitting on a hill. 
 Consequently there are several things they do not know. 
 Firstly they don't seem to know there's a good chance that the &bquo;picnic&equo; will be taken in unfriendly weather. 
 The collection which they have prepared may have looked wonderfully appetising in the kitchen. 
 A couple of bread rolls perhaps, a little plastic pack of butter and a pack of pat&eacute;, nicely finished off with a plastic knife and a paper serviette. 
 All very civilised. 
 But on the hill, crouched against a stone wall which may or may not be providing protection against wind-swept rain, such a dainty arrangement fast loses all its attraction. 
 In such conditions what is needed is something which will fill the hunger gap quickly and with as little movement as possible &mdash; when passing food through the little Niagara Falls running off the hood of my waterproof &mdash; deeply envied those astronauts who can squeeze a whole meal into their mouth from a plastic &bquo;toothpaste&equo; tube. 
 Oh how I have longed sometimes to crouch with my head in my rucksack and give myself a squeeze of self-heating steak and kidney pudding, followed by a quick squeeze of hot custard and delicious spotted dick. 
 But it is not just bad weather which takes the gilt off the packed-lunch gingerbread. 
 On those rare days when the weather has run out of rain and the sun has driven away the clouds, the wrong packed lunch can be just as disastrous. 
 When the morning walk has been a hot, hard climb and all breathing has been in gasps, you can arrive at lunchtime with a mouth as dry as a salt mine. 
 You have probably been perspiring quite impressively too, and you are beginning to have fantasies of pints of a cool drink. 
 You fall with relief upon your packed lunch &bquo;mystery parcel&equo; &mdash; and what do you find? 
 Sandwiches of bread as dry as Weetabix, enclosing a slice of ham with the texture of a piece of old lino! 
 With courage, you take a mouthful and begin to chew. 
 Soon the chewed mass has sponged up any moisture left and your dry tongue is clanging against the side of your mouth like the great bell of Notre Dame. 
 When ordering my lunches these days, I try to avoid the use of the term &bquo;packed lunch&equo; and merely ask if I can be supplied with certain items in a bag to take away. 
 My list may include a tomato, a buttered roll, a chunk of moist cheese, a slice of fruit cake, and an orange. 
 It usually works&hellip; but not always. 
 Earlier this year I led a party of Americans on a walking tour in the Scottish Highlands. 
 The June weather had included rain, sleet and three inches of snow! 
 Then in typical fashion the sun came out and dried the heather till it crackled and Scotland recorded the highest temperature in the British Isles. 
 Walking during this heatwave was bound to be warm work and I was determined to avoid sandwiches of chalk and modelling clay. 
 So I had a word with the hotel chef. 
 He was most understanding about the needs of our party. 
 &bquo;How about a buttered roll and a chicken leg each wrapped in tinfoil?&equo; 
 Great! 
 &bquo;And perhaps some cold new potatoes which had been glazed in mint flavoured butter?&equo; 
 Wonderful! 
 &bquo;A fruit yoghurt to finish?&equo; 
 Magnificent! 
 The next morning's walk was superb, with the altitude providing just enough breeze to stop everyone from boiling over. 
 The thought of the delicious lunch gave me the extra boost I needed to reach the summit. 
 Once there I handed out the packs and sat waiting for approval. 
 What had we got? 
 Two cheese sandwiches and a Kit Kat! 
 Emergency wanted A few years ago I wrote a little book called Discovering Backpacking . 
 Just before Christmas I was intrigued to get a letter in careful dictionary English from Kenya, saying that the sender had read my book and was now putting some kit together along the lines I had suggested. 
 However one piece of equipment was causing him a problem &mdash; a &bquo;survival bag&equo;. 
 Where could he obtain one, and how much would it cost? 
 In reply I sent him a cutting from the catalogue of a well known UK mail order equipment company. 
 Earlier this year I received another carefully written letter from my correspondent. 
 &bquo;Dear Mr Ken Ward, I made an order for the survival bag as you kindly indicated. 
 Unfortunately when it arrived, it was empty. 
 Can you please advise my what should have been contained, and explain how it is used?&equo; 
 So, again I wrote, telling the would-be backpacker that having the survival bag was a bit like taking out insurance &mdash; it only became useful if he had an emergency. 
 And yes, you've guessed it &mdash; a few weeks later what should I discover among my mail but a letter: &bquo;Dear Mr Ken Ward, where may I purchase an emergency&hellip; 
 The First N&ouml;el Guidebook In April I had the pleasure of meeting the TV personality Noel Edmonds in Grasmere, and we talked briefly about guidebooks for walkers. 
 He is chair of the Unique Group Limited which has just launched a new Guide to the Countryside . 
 The guide should be well received by those who love the countryside, and particularly by those who walk. 
 And I think it will be a great success. 
 Of course Noel is an expert in publicity and the use of the media. 
 In a mail-order advertisement for the book he makes a unique offer: &bquo;Tick box if you would like your boob personally signed by Noel Edmonds.&equo; 
 I have been producing guidebooks for fifteen years and I have never thought of that.  
 Letters 
 Coasts at risk 
 Some of the highlights of my summer are occasional weekend camping trips with friends. 
 On a recent trip to Somerset, I became aware that no one was swimming along what is an impressive and beautiful stretch of coastline. 
 A look at the may told me why &mdash; we were just a few miles away from Hinkley Point nuclear power station. 
 However, according to locals, there is actually more of a risk from the conventional pollutants that are pumped into the sea than from the power station, and this stopped people swimming in it. 
 I find it very sad that the traditional weekend by the sea cam now be considered a health risk. 
 Linda Weston, London 
 An end to toxic algae 
 As a keen watersports enthusiast I was greatly alarmed to read in your news pages about the high quantities of toxic algae currently present in many of our inland waterways. 
 What are things coming to if it is no longer possible to spend time sailing and taking part in other water sports without subjecting yourself to the risk of such symptoms as rashes and vomiting? 
 Codes of practice set out by bodies such as the RYA to avoid the effects of contaminated waterways are all very well, but shouldn't we be taking direct action upon the problem itself &mdash; rather than making the best of a bad job? 
 I also find it quite interesting that the National Rivers Authority are urging people not to overreact to the problem. 
 I would have thought that overreaction would at least be preferable to the apathy currently being shown by both the government and general public alike. 
 I for one will be approaching my MP to see what they can do to help end this appalling threat. 
 Rowena Ridgeway, Wiltshire 
 This month the &pound;10 prize for the best letter goes to Richard Wallis from Twickenham 
 Caravans spoil the view 
 I was very interested in your article on West Dorset in the August issue. 
 It is an area I have visited many times, especially the coastal areas which are superb for walking. 
 Although it has been designated an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty, several things blot the landscape. 
 The main blot is the increasing number of caravan sites which spoil the views from Lyme Regis in the west to Abbotsbury in the east. 
 You don't notice them when you are in the valleys, but after an invigorating climb up Black Ven or the Golden Cap, it is a huge disappointment to be confronted by rank upon rank of square box-shaped caravans. 
 What is worse is that the caravans are painted white so that they stand out against the green landscape. 
 Of course people need places to stay when on holiday and I'm all for economical breaks such as caravanning, but I have a few suggestions which might help to improve the look of unsightly caravan parks. 
 Firstly they could be painted in camouflage to lessen the visual impact or alternatively, they could be dispersed among trees and in copses, so as to be out of sight from the very well used coast paths. 
 Better still, would be to think again about the best sort of accommodation for these sensitive areas. 
 Chalets made from natural materials would be a big improvement and could look really attractive. 
 Such chalets have been used in other parts of the country and are also common on the continent. 
 With the drop in agricultural support from the EC and with the policy of Set Aside taking land out of farming production, local farmers should be encouraged to use their spare land in Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty more sensitively. 
 Why not drop us a line here at Outdoor Action ? 
 We want to hear your views about any issue affecting the countryside. 
 A &pound;10 prize will go to the best letter published each month. 
 Write to Outdoor Action , 13 Park House, 140 Battersea Park Road, London SW11 4NB. 
 Queries 
 Q I wish to take up a career in outdoor activities and am looking for information on the qualifications and training needed for this kind of work. 
 Whereabouts do they run courses and do you know if any centres provide training while you work? 
 Mark Jones, Surrey 
 A You'll find the Mountain-walking Leader Training Board (MLTB) a useful source of information. 
 They have a very comprehensive information sheet giving details of qualifications and training courses relevant to a career in outdoor pursuits. 
 The most basic qualification which is generally required to work anywhere is the Mountain Leader Course (summer award). 
 This offers training (minimum age 18) and assessment (minimum age 20), qualifying you to lead others on summer hill walks on British mountains. 
 The Scottish MLTB also run a winter award. 
 The governing bodies of other sports such as the Royal Yachting Association (RYA) and the British Canoe Union (BCU) operate similar awards to qualify you as an instructor of their own particular sport. 
 Contact each of these bodies directly for more details. 
 The Sports Council at 16 Upper Woburn Place, London WC1H 0QP. 
 Tel: 071 388 1277 should be able to supply you with the relevant addresses and telephone numbers. 
 The MLTB information sheet also lists universities and colleges which offer suitable courses and it gives a list of useful bodies to contact concerning employment in outdoor activities, eg Glenmore Lodge National Outdoor Training Centre, PGL, Outward Bound etc. 
 To get a copy of the information sheet contact the MLTB at Crawford House, Precinct Centre, Booth Street East, Manchester M13 9RZ. 
 Tel: 061 273 5835. 
 Q I have been trying with little success to get hold of a list of camping barn and bunkhouse type accommodations. 
 Do you know if such a list exists and if so where I might get hold of it? 
 O Edwardson, Hertfordshire 
 A The Countryside Commission are the people to contact. 
 They produce a leaflet called The Accommodation Barns Guide 1991  which contains useful information and lists of camping barns and bunkhouses grouped according to county. 
 This guide is available free of charge and can be obtained by sending a 4 x 8in SAE to Countryside Commission Publications. 
 Printworks Lane, Levenshulme, Manchester M19 3JT. 
 Alternatively you will also find a section on independent hostels, bunkhouses and camping barns in The Rambler's Yearbook 1991 , available from bookshops priced &pound;3.50. 
 The section lists all such accommodation in the UK. 
 If you have a query about anything concerning the outdoor world why not write to us at Outdoor Action ? 
 Send your query to Outdoor Action , 13 Park House, 140 Battersea Park Road, London SW11 4NB.  
 Outdoor Update News 
 1 Walkers speak out 
 Walkers are challenging the government to prove their green credentials in Scotland after the shock resignation offer of a senior government conservation officer. 
 Sir Frederick Halliday offered to resign from his position as chair of the Joint Committee for Nature Conservation &mdash; a body set up four months ago to supervise Britain's conservation standards following the break-up of the Nature Conservancy Council. 
 The resignation follows a government decision to back a Scottish landowner's amendment to the Scottish National Heritage Bill (as reported in last month's issue of Outdoor Action . 
 The Bill, which has now received Royal Assent, will review all the Nature Conservancy Council's previous work in setting up hundreds of Sites of Special Scientific Interest in Scotland. 
 Speaking on behalf of may walkers and climbers, the British Mountaineering Council (BMC) argue that the resignation shows a clear crisis of confidence in the government's commitment to nature conservation. 
 BMC Information Officer Brill Wright said &bquo;This is further evidence of the government's need to take new initiatives to restore its countryside and nature conservation profile.&equo; 
 In practical terms they call for the government to help buy and protect the Mar Lodge Estate &mdash; 77 000 acre plot of land in the Cairngorms which has been up for sale since May. 
 They also want the government to support proposals for national parks in Scotland. 
 They are strongly opposed to the government-proposed National Heritage Areas which Wright argues would be completely &bquo;toothless&equo;. 
 Footpaths win more cash 
 The Countryside Commission has contributed a grant of &pound;75 000 towards the cost of improving Lancashire's network of footpaths and bridleways. 
 The sum of &pound;30 000 will go to the Country Council's highways department for signposting and other capital costs, while &pound;22 500 will be spent on footpath maintenance and improvement. 
 The grant also includes &pound;15 000 for the appointment of two temporary staff to update maps showing legal rights of way. 
 Commenting on the grant, Alex Wright of the Commission said, &bquo;We welcome this grant and we hope it will assist Lancashire County Council in opening up the rights of way network by dealing with several major problems and paths that need modifications.&equo; 
 Bird success 
 Birdwatchers are more likely to catch sight of Britain's largest bird of prey, the white-tailed sea eagle, following its most successful breeding season since being reintroduced in 1975. 
 The eagle had become extinct in Britain in 1916. 
 Four pairs of white-tailed sea eagles raised a record seven young at specially guarded nests in Scotland. 
 This brings the total number of birds in the UK to around 40. 
 There was mixed success however, for a similar reintroduction project for red kites. 
 The RSPB reports that although a record number of the birds bred in Wales this year, the number of surviving young was disappointingly low. 
 76 pairs of red kites nested in the valleys of south-west Wales this year but only 62 young survived to maturity &mdash; eight less than last year. 
 The kites' breeding success was affected by a cold wet spring, accidental disturbance and the theft of eggs from six nests. 
 Egg theft would have been far worse had it not been for round-the-clock protection from the army at the end of the season. 
 Competition prize winners 
 Kathryn Winkler of Dundee, your lucky number is up. 
 You're the winner of our July competition and will receive a wide selection of goodies from Burton Mc Call including a Karoo tent, a Snowfox sleeping bag and a pair of Trezeta Vajolet leather walking boots. 
 The five second prize winners, who will each receive a pair of Trezeta boots, are Grainne Lynch of Sutton, F Eatwell of Peterborough, Joanne Barwise of Whitehaven, A Huggett of Mexborough and Dave Cluley of Nottingham. 
 No fewer than twenty lucky readers have won our third prize of a Recta D0310 compass and a 905 Liquipak. 
 They are A Baker of Hasbury, N Sutton of Stone, A Brazier of Suffolk, I Forster of Newton Aycliffe, J Drake of Boxford, S Tulett of Wallsend, G Burke of Cheadle Heath, CA Fearnyough of Great Sutton, B Fenton of Farndon, Kate Doughty of Shieldaig, J Revill of West Bridgford. 
 J Quinton-Zorn of Salisbury, B Anderson of North Shields, Paul Wilson of South Glen, Geraint Roberts of Tynant, JE Adams of Nunthorpe, Christine Heath of Bowness-on-Windermere, S Bunn of Burnley, A Spencer-Jones of Kidderminster and M Morrison Shrewsbury in Shropshire. 
 If you weren't lucky in July turn to page 33 for details of yet another bumper competition with &pound;1000 of Camping Gaz gear up for grabs. 
 There will be 29 winners who will each receive outdoor gear. 
 New walk guides are released 
 Footpaths in south Somerset and Kent will be easier to follow with new publications by the respective country councils. 
 Walks in South Somerset  gives full instructions and a detailed map for 
 ten walks ranging from 2&ndash;1/2 to seven miles long. 
 It is available from the Leisure and Arts Department, South Somerset District Council Offices, Brympton Way, Yeovil, Somerset BA20 1PU. 
 It costs &pound;2.35 plus 25p p&amp;p.  
 The BMC are calling for urgent action to preserve some of Scotland's most beautiful countryside areas 
 Red kites had a mixed year 
 Climb for the world 
 Over 25 000 walkers and climbers are expected to climb as many as 600 summits in the UK in a bold initiative to support conservation and human rights around the world. 
 Climb For The World  will take place from noon on September 21 to noon 
 on September 22 when participants will climb to one or more of the designated summits. 
 The official summits will be outlined in an OS publication which will be available in bookshops in August, and through Climb For The World  registration packs. 
 Summits include Parliament Hill in London and the Old Man of Coniston in the Lake District National Park. 
 Once participants reach their chosen summits they'll be able to get their world passports, available from Climb For The World , stamped with an official commemorative stamp. 
 They'll also sign a &bquo;Plea of People's&equo; petition calling for world governments to cooperate with the United Nations (UN) to eradicate basic poverty by the year 2020; secure the environment against global warming, ozone depletion &bquo;and other grave threats to its health&equo;; to provide enough human, financial and other resources to make sure these aims are met. 
 This petition will be delivered to the UN Secretary General, Javier Perez de Cuellar, at the 1992 United Nations conference on environment and development, to be held in Brazil. 
 At the summits there will be invigilators, primarily Venture Scouts, who will maintain a 24 hour vigil with lanterns lighting up the night sky. 
 Participants with experience of the wilderness will be welcome to bivouac through the night. 
 Registration costs &pound;5 and a form is enclosed with this month's issue of Outdoor Action . 
 To coincide with the Climb For The World  event there will be a major inter-continental climb of the Eiger in Switzerland. 
 Several teams will climb routes from all the compass points of the mountain including the North Face route. 
 Each team will carry a lantern and a section of the flag of flags &mdash; made up of each flag of the UN member states. 
 And when the teams and flag are reunited on the summit, a message from the Secretary General of the UN will be read out. 
 Other Climb For The World  events are planned in Argentina, Kenya and Brazil. 
 A Canadian expedition will also be taking a Climb For The World  flag to the summit of Everest. 
 It is hoped that &pound;1m will be raised worldwide from the event through sponsorship and donations. 
 The money will help a number of UN-recommended projects worldwide including a soil erosion programme in Bolivia, a women's tree planting project in Kenya and a clean water campaign in Cambodia. 
 This event follows the success of a pilot Climb For The World  last year. 
 It is hoped that the idea will snowball around the world. 
 It is planned to be held as an annual event until the end of the decade. 
 Director of Climb For The World , Edwin Drummond said &bquo;We are promoting the concept that we are citizens of one world. 
 It's about individual people realising they can do something beyond what they may normally expect to achieve.&equo; 
 Further information and additional forms are available from Climb For The World, Brincliffe House, 861 Ecclesall Road, Sheffield S11 7AE. 
 Tel: 0742 663869. 
 We at Outdoor Action  will be climbing one of the summits on the day. 
 Hope to see you out there. 
 News from the National Parks 
 Road threat in the Brecon Beacons 
 The Welsh Office are proposing the construction of a bypass to Crickhowell, an attractive small town to the east of the Park. 
 The proposals would take the bypass to the south of the town, which would involve a major new road and two river crossings of the River Usk. 
 The picturesque thirteen-arched stone bridge would be dwarfed by the modern bridges and the new road would encourage greater and much faster traffic. 
 There is much local opposition to this scheme and a public meeting has been held to get a campaign going. 
 The problem of traffic congestion in the town should not be solved by building a major new road through this sensitive landscape in the Brecon Beacons National Park. 
 Estuary survey of Shelduck 
 Potential conflict between recreation and its associated development and the conservation value of the beautiful Dugleddau Estuary in Pembrokeshire Coast National Park is looming large. 
 The National Park Authority and Dyfed Wildlife Trust have carried out a survey into the summer population of shelduck. 
 The results confirm the importance of the estuary for shelduck and identify particularly sensitive areas for breeding. 
 The data collected will be used by the Pembrokeshire Coast National Park when considering future management policies for the Estuary. 
 Village information scheme for Exmoor 
 Exmoor National Park has decided to set up information agencies in selected village shops. 
 These will have the dual benefit of providing an information service for visitors and supporting village shops, an essential element of the local community. 
 Each shop will be identified by a window sticker and leaflets will be displayed inside the shop. 
 The pilot scheme will involve shops in five selected villages for the first year, and if successful will be extended and developed for a further three years. 
 EC money boosts conservation scheme 
 The Yorkshire Dales National Park has been awarded a European Commission grant of more than &pound;50 000 to help conserve the traditional Dales farming landscape. 
 The grant gives a significant boost to the National Park Authority's Barns and Walls Conservation Scheme to protect drystone walls and scattered stone field barns in upper Swaledale and Arkengarthdale. 
 The demand for grants has consistently outstripped the National Park Authority funds. 
 News supplied by the Council for National Parks  
 It is hoped that &pound;1m will be raised through events staged in this country and across the rest of the world 
 Walkers protest for greater access 
 Members of the Ramblers' Association (RA) recently staged a symbolic trespass on Thurlstone Moor in the Peak District in a move which heralds a more militant approach to increasing access to some of Britain's most beautiful countryside. 
 Through this mini trespass the RA are hoping to encourage hundreds of members to stage a mass trespass on the moor on September 29, as part of Forbidden Britain Day  &mdash; an annual event with nationwide protest walks calling for greater access to the countryside. 
 But this is the first time that RA members are being so actively encouraged to trespass. 
 And the momentum is set to continue after the day of protest with the publication of a trespass guide to the Thurlstone Moor area. 
 Chris Hall of the RA said this will be the first in a series of &bquo;mini-trespass guides&equo; to closed land around the country. 
 He said the RA expected it to be long campaign but were prepared to give it as long as it took to secure their aims. 
 &bquo;Trespassing is not a criminal offence and we want more people to understand that. 
 It is a weapon of last resort where landowners and grouse shooters are unreasonably keeping walkers out of parts of the Britain's countryside.&equo; 
 News in brief 
 Wildlife booklet 
 The Forestry Commission have published a new booklet Forests for Wildlife  which details some of the wildlife conservation projects the commission carries out around the country. 
 Copies are available free from Forestry Commission District Offices or by contacting the Public Information Division, Forestry Commission, 231 Corstrophine Road, Edinburgh. 
 Tel: 031 334 0303. 
 Bike challenge Polaris All-terrain Clothing are hosting a unique mountain bike event on October 5&ndash;6 this year. 
 The MTB Challenge is a two day self-supported trip across a wilderness area testing two-person teams, their bike skill, endurance and abilities to survive. 
 Full details are available by sending a large SAE to: Polaris International, MTB Challenge, 87 Hollin Springs Avenue, Dronfield, Sheffield S18 6RP. 
 Special dinghy 
 Diana Campell, originator of special trimaran dinghy for disabled sailors, has just launched the updated Challenger II at Cowes. 
 She went on to officially hand it over to OXRAD, the disabled sailing group based at Farmoor Reservoir near Oxford. 
 Diana, herself a keen sailor despite being confined to a wheelchair for the last 45 years, hopes the boat will encourage more disabled people onto the water. 
 Green grants 
 The Open Spaces Society, Britain's oldest national conservation society, has awarded grants from its Creech Jones Fund to local groups from Blackpool, Bournemouth, Southampton, Crawley, Dulwich and Bovingdon for their efforts to protect threatened open space. 
 Army attacked 
 The Ramblers' Association (RA) have condemned as &bquo;shameful&equo; the government's approval of an army plan to take over for training 900 acres of common land at Holcombe near Bury, Manchester. 
 David Beskine of the RA said &bquo;This is not private land but open moorland over which the public has for many years had a right to roam. 
 The public will now be denied their rights.&equo; 
 Trust launched 
 The Kent Times-side Groundwork Trust was officially launched in July this year. 
 The Trust aims to create a better living and working environment in the boroughs of Gravesham and Dartford by promoting conservation action. 
 It was set up in partnership with local authorities, industry, businesses and community and voluntary groups to produce effective solutions to environmental problems in north-west Kent. 
 The launch took place at the site of the Trust's first major project, a disused clay pit at Bean, near Dartford, where work has started to create an 80 acre country park. 
 In a message of support Michael Heseltine, Secretary of State for the Environment said &bquo;I am confident that the Trust can play a major role in the regeneration of the area.&equo; 
 Bellamy opens youth hostel 
 YHA hostel Ilam Hall in the Peak District National Park has been reopened following major refurbishment to the tune of &pound;472 000. 
 The hostel, located in a National Trust country mansion, was officially reopened by YHA President David Bellamy. 
 Bellamy led over 200 children on a nature trail around the grounds of the hostel before cutting the ribbon to declare the hostel officially open. 
 Work to modernise and improve Ilam Hall took place during the last two winters. 
 A wing was converted in keeping with the existing architecture of the hall to provide accommodation for families and disabled guests. 
 Toilet and shower facilities were improved and a new cafeteria was also built. 
 Work at Ilam Hall is part of an ongoing YHA programme to refurbish its hostels.  
 Veteran campaigner Benny Rothman (left) leads fellow trespassers across Thurlstone Moor in Derbyshire 
 Countryside under threat 
 Urgent government action is needed to stop proposed wind farms being built on some of Britain's most beautiful countryside, according to a report from the Council for National Parks (CNP). 
 Proposed sites for wind farms include areas bordering on the Yorkshire Dales, Lake District and Snowdonia National Parks. 
 There is also a plan for over a 100 turbines in the Cambrian Mountains in Wales. 
 Amanda Nobbs of CNP says one of the major problems stems from the government subsidies offered to wind farm developers. 
 As these will stop in 1998, developers are favouring projects which give a rapid return on their investments. 
 This means building farms in higher areas where the wind is strongest, but which are unfortunately some of Britain's best areas of countryside. 
 Nobbs argues that the problem has been compounded because the government hasn't issued any planning advice to guide the industry. 
 In the report CNP calls for a number of proposals including &mdash; abandoning the 1998 deadline for renewable energy subsidies; enabling grants to run for 15 years from the start of any one project; issuing planning policy guidance on how to deal with planning applications, and giving encouragement to offshore wind generation which they claim could provide 50% of energy needs. 
 The report warns that unless the government acts quickly much of the natural heritage could be severely damaged. 
 Gravel pits help wildlife 
 Excavation of sand and gravel may scar the landscape but it does increase habitats for wildlife. 
 This is the conclusion of a new RSPB report Gravel pit restoration for wildlife &mdash; a practical manual . 
 Over 3700 acres of land each year are left available for other uses following excavation work by industry. 
 In the last 40 years an estimated 25 000 acres of these scarred landscapes have been flooded, providing important nesting and roosting sites for many waterbirds. 
 Over 50 per cent of the little ringed plovers in the UK nest on gravel pits, as do a third of great crested grebes and just under a third of the tufted duck population. 
 The flooded pits also provide a suitable habitat for other types of wildlife such as otters, fish, bats, butterflies and dragonflies. 
 The guide also suggests how excavated areas can be made into wildlife havens through the addition of features such as trees, islands and marshy areas. 
 An RSPB spokesperson commented: &bquo;careful planning and design can produce attractive sites which are enjoyed by people and wildlife.&equo; 
 Call for more open spaces 
 A new document concerning the future of open spaces in London has just been published. 
 It is the result of research by four leading environmental organisations concerned with planning in the City &mdash; the Countryside Commission, English Nature, the London Ecology Unit and the London Wildlife Trust. 
 The document has been launched to aid borough councils throughout the capital as they draw up development plans for the future of the City. 
 It calls for councils to adopt key policies in their current planning which will affect the future of the city until the year 2000. 
 The Green Capital  document urges that Green Belt and Metropolitan Open Land be protected, wildlife sites safeguarded and the management of greenspaces improved. 
 It also calls for reduction in the amount of pollution, greater protection and planting of trees and easier access to greenspace. 
 Environmentalists believe that the mere designation of areas as greenspaces is insufficient. 
 The argue that if the environment is to be properly safeguarded policies must be formulated which will encourage favourable ongoing management. 
 Pop star stops stag hunt 
 An 84 acre commercial conifer woodland near Exmoor has been bought by Paul McCartney and given to the League Against Cruel Sports as a sanctuary against hunting. 
 News of McCartney's intention to give the woodland, known as Sir John's Allotment, to the anti hunt protesters was strategically released just days before the opening meet of the Devon and Somerset Stag Hounds. 
 The purchase of the land is believed to have cost McCartney around &pound;140,000, and was inspired by his keenness &bquo;to stop this barbaric so-called &bquo;sport&equo;. 
 Commenting on his purchase, McCartney is said to be delighted that the land is now &bquo;free from the huntsmen.&equo; 
 However other reactions have been less positive. 
 One local farmer commented that for McCartney to put an end to the hunt might not necessarily be in the best interests of the deer. 
 He said &bquo;The farmers have always tolerated the hunt because it controls the deer, but whenever it's stopped the deer have died have died out very quickly. 
 I'm sure that's not what the McCartneys want.&equo; 
 New grants 
 Grants to help offset the out-of-pocket expenses incurred by volunteers in geological conservation work have been announced by English Nature &mdash; the English branch of the now disbanded Nature Conservancy Council. 
 Money will help volunteers involved in an English Nature initiative. 
 RIGS (Regionally Important Geological Sites) &mdash; set up to build a network of local voluntary groups to collect geological information on their areas. 
 This includes identifying sites of particular importance and liaising with local authorities, site owners and tenants to improve protection and access. 
 English Nature will be offering up to &pound;500 per RIGS group, once information on the key sites has been passed to the relevant planning departments. 
 Badger victory 
 Wildlife campaigners are celebrating after winning an 18 year fight to protect badgers from badger baiting. 
 A new bill, which will become law in October, will close a legal loophole which allows unscrupulous badger diggers to avoid prosecution by claiming they are digging for foxes. 
 The bill will also stop landowners and developers from bulldozing badger  setts.   
 Wind farms could soon become an unsightly blot on Britain's landscape 
 Top treks 
 Britain's long distance paths offer some of the most wonderful countryside. 
 Cathering Moore picks six of the very best 
 Over 300 long distance backpacking routes wind their way around Britain and we've picked out six of the best for you to try. 
 We've deliberately stayed away from the official national trails in England, Scotland and Wales. 
 The national trails, including paths like the Pennine Way, the Pembrokeshire Coast Path and the West Highland Way, tend to be the best known routes and deserve a rest after the summer of pounding they had. 
 Anyway, they represent only a fraction of the long distance paths Britain has to offer. 
 The paths we've chosen are all recognised long-distance routes and some are waymarked for their entire length. 
 They're all fine routes for backpacking holidays but local youth hostels or bed and breakfasts are also available. 
 At least one guidebook giving precise route descriptions has been written about each of the walks and without exception they'll take you through some of the loveliest countryside we have. 
 The Cambrian Way 
 Start: Cardiff Castle 
 Finish: Conwy Castle 
 Distance: 274 miles 
 This is a  grandaddy  of a long distance path which traverses Wales through some stunning and remote mountain country. 
 This high level route is not for the faint hearted &mdash; as well as being longer than the Pennine Way it involves much more climbing. 
 It should only be tackled by fit walkers who know what they're doing with a map and compass. 
 From Cardiff the route snakes up through the valleys south of Caerphilly, over the Ebbw River, through the Ebbw Forest and on via the mining town of Risca to Pontypool. 
 The Way continues up into the Black Mountains going over Sugar Loaf and up onto the main escarpment. 
 Crossing over Table Mountain the Way goes into the Brecon Beacons via the small market town of Crickhowell. 
 Here you get to scale some classic Welsh summits like Corn Du and Pen y Fan. 
 It's spectacular wild country. 
 From the mountains it's on to stunning waterfalls as you follow the Afon Hellte to Ystradfellte. 
 However it's soon back to mountains as the Way enters Mynydd Ddu, the Black Mountain region. 
 Here are the hauntingly beautiful lakes, Llyn y fan fawr and Lyn y fan fach and the windswept ridge of Fan Hir. 
 From Mynydd Ddu the Way pushes northwards through the town of Llandovery and up into the Cambrian Mountains, passing close to the shores of the huge reservoir, Llyn Brianne. 
 Despite its beauty this whole area is little visited. 
 This loneliness makes it an ideal home for the red kite &mdash; a  rare and nervous bird. 
 If you are lucky enough to see one, observe it from a distance. 
 You'll be moving into largely featureless moorland here so compass skills are necessary as you make your way up to the Teifi pools which feed the Teifi river. 
 From here it's on to Plynlimon with its high point of Pen Pumlumon Fawr at just under 2500ft. 
 Close by are the sources of the rivers Severn and Wye. 
 More classic Welsh scenery lies to the north as the Way continues on to Cader Idris in the Snowdonia National Park. 
 And to get to its end point of Conwy Castle you travel right through the heart of Snowdonia taking a stunning high level route crossing peaks like Rhinog Fach, Rhinog Fawr, Glyder Fawr and Snowdon itself. 
 It's a tough section to finish on but the rewards are tremendous. 
 And at the end of it all you'll really know Wales. 
 A Cambrian Way  by Richard Sale. 
 &pound;8.99. 
 Constable. 
 Two Moors Way 
 Start: Ivybridge 
 Finish: Lynmouth 
 Distance: 102 miles 
 This route gives you a good flavour of the West Country. 
 It starts at Ivybridge in south Devon, takes you over the wilds of Dartmoor through mid-Devon and on across Exmoor to finish at the coastal resort of Lynmouth. 
 The walk is waymarked for some of its length &mdash; look out for the MW symbol. 
 However there are no waymarks where the route crosses open moorland so it's best if you can use a map and compass. 
 The terrain is very varied from the great expanse of Dartmoor to the gentler stretch of Exmoor. 
 And the route passes through wooded river valleys and along green lanes. 
 Some road walking is included especially in the middle section between moors. 
 It is acceptable to wild camp on Dartmoor provided you're around a mile away from a road. 
 If you prefer not to go camping you'll find youth hostels at Bellever, Exford and Lynton. 
 This is a walk full of interest aside from the scenery. 
 On your first day you'll cross Ugborough  Moor and see several bronze age stone rows and hut circles. 
 The Way runs next to one of the best preserved bronze age enclosures on Dartmoor at Grimspound. 
 Further north and nearby on Hamel Down you'll find ancient burial mounds. 
 You'll also see remnants of Dartmoor's obsolete industries, warrening/rabbit breeding &mdash; and tin mining. 
 After following field tracks and minor roads across mid-Devon, passing through quaint villages, you arrive in Exmoor. 
 As well as sections through open moorland a lovely stretch of the walk follows the River Barle through rich woodland to Tarr Steps. 
 Two Moors Way  by Devon Ramblers' Association. 
 &pound;1.20 plus 40p postage 
 and packaging. 
 Available from The Ramblers' Association, 1&ndash;5 Wandsworth Road, London SW8 2XX. 
 Tel: 071 582 6878. 
 The Cumbria Way 
 Start: Ulverston 
 Finish: Carlisle 
 Distance: 70 miles 
 The Cumbria Way is a marvellous route running from south to north across the Lake District National Park. 
 It's large a low level route, sticking to valley bottoms and passes rather to going up on the fells. 
 As you'd expect in this part of the world, the route passes through spectacular countryside. 
 The route follows public footpaths and bridleways for the most part which are signed conventionally with yellow marks for footpaths, blue for bridleways. 
 From the south the route leaves Ulverston near Morecambe Bay and makes its way up to Coniston Water where there's some wonderful lakeside walking. 
 The lovely scenery continues as the walk travels along woodland paths to reach the little lake of Tarn Hows and goes on past Elterwater to Dungeon Ghyll. 
 Walking over Mickleden the route leads up to Stake Pass and goes around the shores of Derwent Water to Keswick. 
 From Keswick to Way goes to Carlisle via Caldbeck, passing over the lower slopes of Latrigg and the highest point of the Cumbria Way at High Pike (2159ft). 
 Woodland routes and paths following first the River Cardew, then a railway line, lead you to Carlisle. 
 You could backpack the route or stay at youth hostels as there are plenty nearby &mdash; Coniston, Elterwater, Longthwaite, Derwent Water, Keswick, Carnock Fell and Carlisle. 
 The Cumbria Way  by John Trevelyan, &pound;3.50. 
 Dalesman. 
 Isle of Man Coastal Path 
 Start/Finish: Any coastal town 
 Distance: 96 miles 
 The Isle of Man Coastal Path or Raad ny Foillan (Way of the Gull) is a route that doesn't get half the publicity it deserves. 
 It's easy to follow, hugging the coastline and waymarked with white gull signs. 
 It takes you across lonely beaches and over wild cliff-tops. 
 If you're not camping there are plenty of b&amp;bs in the coastal towns. 
 Many people choose to start the walk going south from Douglas, the island's capital. 
 It doesn't take long once you've left town before you're walking along the cliff-path with spectacular views. 
 The first stretch to Castletown takes you past sights such as the smugglers' hideout at Jackdaw Cave and a treat for birdwatchers at Derby Haven where huge flocks of birds feed in the bay. 
 Birdwatchers should also stop to look at The Stack on Scarlett Point &mdash; a favourite with seabirds. 
 At times where there is no clifftop or beach path the route heads across fields and minor roads. 
 One of the most spectacular parts of the route is on the stretch from Port St Mary to Port Erin where the rocky cliffs soar from the sea. 
 The Chasms, an area designated by the Manx National Trust for &bquo;Public Ramblage&equo;, is especially breathtaking. 
 And offshore rocks like the Sugarloaf and Burroo Rock add interest. 
 Moving on from Port Erin there's a mountain section over the three summits of Bredda Hill, Lhiattee ny Beinee and Cronk ny Arrey Las with the western sides of the hills falling down into the west side of the island to Point of Ayre there are long sections of lonely beach walks. 
 You round the Point to make your way south to Douglas &mdash; first on beaches, then on cliff and meadow paths. 
 The Isle of Man Coastal Path  by Aileen Evans &pound;4.95. 
 Cicerone Press. 
 The guide also includes descriptions of the other two long distance paths on the Isle of Man &mdash; the Millennium Way and the Herring Way. 
 The Dales Way 
 Start: Ilkley 
 Finish: Bowness-on-Windermere 
 Distance: 81 miles 
 The Dales Way is an especially beautiful walk through the Yorkshire  Dales and the south-eastern Lake District. 
 In the south the route follows the River Wharfe, going on to follow the River Dee and River Lune before finishing up at Lake Windermere. 
 Though it travels through some wonderful hill country the Way isn't a tough route &mdash; much of it follows level footpaths with plenty of riverside walking. 
 If you're not camping there are bed and breakfasts along the route and youth hostels at Linton, Kettlewell, Dentdale, Kendal and Windermere. 
 There are also six camping barns along the route. 
 From the start of the Dales Way at Ilkley Bridge the path travels beside the River Wharfe passing Haw Pike and following woodland paths near Bolton Priory. 
 The path continues to the Strid &mdash; a spectacular chasm where the Wharfe reaches a frantic pace. 
 More riverside and woodland paths lead to the town of Grassington, continuing on to Buckden. 
 This action of the Way passes through wonderful limestone scenery including the impressive mass of Kilnsey Crag. 
 The Way then leads to Langstrothdale over to Oughtershaw and carries on to cross a section of the Pennine Way, giving fine views of the Three Peaks en route. 
 The path continues along Dentdale and follows the course of the River Dee, pretty waterfalls characterising its upper reaches. 
 Following next the River Lune, the Way goes into the Lake District. 
 The final miles are among the best of the whole route through Lakeland fells giving marvellous views of Windermere. 
 The Dales Way  by Colin Speakman. &pound;3.95. 
 Dalesman Books. 
 Dales Way Handbook  (gives accommodation information) 75p plus 30p postage from Ramblers' Association, 1&ndash;5 Wandsworth Road, London SW8 2XX. 
 Tel 071 582 6878. 
 The Isle of Wight coast path 
 Start/Finish: any coastal town 
 Distance: 65 miles 
 This is a gentle and beautiful route ideal for the whole family. 
 If you're backpacking there are many campsites to choose from, especially on the more popular east side of the island. 
 And there are three convenient youth hostels open throughout the year at Totland Bay, Whitwell and Sandown. 
 As you'd expect on the Isle of Wight there's an endless list of bed and breakfasts. 
 The path is waymarked throughout its length and for the most part sticks to the coast, running over the chalk and sandstone cliffs which characterise the island. 
 Most people arrive on the island on the north side and from here it's best to travel east and walk from the port of Ryde over to the town of Seaview and down to Sandown. 
 The route follows minor roads, woodland paths, paths across fields and cliff-tops as you cross Whitecliff Bay to reach Sandown. 
 The section to the next town of Shanklin is built-up but the route improves dramatically on the way to and out of Ventnor. 
 As you approach St Catherine's Point and make your way up towards the Needles you'll fully appreciate the true beauty of this much lonelier west and south section. 
 Avoid Blackgang Chine which is over-commercialised and continue on to see some of the other chines &mdash; dramatic fissures in the cliff faces &mdash; such as Whale, Walpen and Shepherd's Chine. 
 Soon the route arrives at Tennyson Down, one of the highlights of the route, and on to Alum Bay which looks out over the chalky points of the Needles. 
 The path winds its way around the Newtown river and Clamerkin Lake providing some fine estuary walking and taking you inland a little. 
 Further to the north you take the ferry across from East to West Cowes to avoid a big detour inland via Newport. 
 The Isle of Wight Coastal Path  by Alan Charles. 
 &pound;3.95. 
 Thornhill 
 Best of the rest 
 Viking Way 
 140 mile route over Lincolnshire Wolds from the Humber Bridge to Oakham, Leicester. 
 Guide: The Viking Way  by John Stead. 
 &pound;5.95. 
 Cicerone 
 Coast to Coast Walk 
 Wainwright's classic 190 mile cross country walk from St Bees Head to Robin Hood's Bay. 
 Guide: A Coast to Coast Walk  by A Wainwright. 
 &pound;7.95. 
 Westmoreland Gazette. 
 Cotswold Way 
 Chipping Campden to Bath, a 100 mile route over the Cotswold Hills. 
 Guide: The Cotswold Way  by Kev Reynolds. 
 &pound;5.95. 
 Cicerone. 
 Glyndwr's Way 
 A 120 mile waymarked route from Knighton to Welshpool, mid-Wales. 
 Guide: Series of 16 leaflets and accommodation list, &pound;2 from Powys County Council, County Hall, Llandridnod Wells, Powys LD1 5LE. 
 Heart of England Way An 80 mile route from Cannock Chase to Chipping Camden. 
 Guide The Heart of England Way Walkers Guide  by The Heart of England Way Steering Committee. 
 &pound;1.60. 
 Thornhill Press. 
 Forth and Clyde Canal 
 A 29 mile walk following paths from Bowling to Falkirk. 
 Guide: leaflet describing the canal from Forth and Clyde Countryside Ranger, British Waterways Board, Applecross Street, Glasgow G4 9SP. 
 Tel: 041 332 6936. 
 Wye Valley Walk 
 Beautiful, easy 75 mile walk from Chepstow to Hay on Wye. 
 Guide: Maps and route description &pound;3.60 + 50p postage and packing from County Planning Officer, Gwent County Council, County Hall, Cwmbran, Gwent NP44 2XF. 
 Tel: 0633 832787. 
 Dyfi Valley Way 
 A 108 mile route along the lovely valley of the Afon Dyfi from Aberdyfi to Borth. 
 Guide: Guide to the Dyfi Valley Way  by Lawrence Main. 
 &pound;3.95. 
 Kittiwake Press. 
 Nidderdale Way 
 a 53 mile circular walk following the valley of the River Nidd. 
 Guide: Nidderdale Way  by J K E Piggin. &pound;2.95. 
 Dalesman Books. 
 White Peak Way 
 An 80 mile circular walk through the white peak area designed for walkers staying at youth hostels. 
 Start at Bakewell or Hathersage Youth Hostels. 
 Guide: The White Peak Way  by Robert Haslam. &pound;3.95. 
 Cicerone Press. 
 Fact file 
 Useful books 
 The Ramblers' Yearbook 1991 . 
 &pound;3.50. 
 Ramblers' Association. 
 Long Distance Walkers' Handbook . 
 &pound;7.95. 
 Long Distance Walkers' Association/A &amp; C Black. 
 Contacts 
 Long Distance Walkers' Association . 
 For details send an SAE to membership secretary: Kevin Uzzell, 7 Ford Drive, Yarnfield, Stone ST15 0RP. 
 Long Distance Paths Advisory Service . 
 If you have questions about any 
 aspect of long distance walking routes contact: Gerald Cole, Administrator, Long Distance Paths Advisory Service, The Barn, Holme Lyon, Burneside, Kendal, Cumbria LA9 6QX. 
 Tel: 0539 927837.  
 The Cambrian Way takes in the best of Welsh hill country. 
 Here walkers travel in the shadow of Cribyn (left) and Pen y Fan in the Brecon Beacons 
 The Two Moors Way in Devon 
 Langdale is just one of the highlights of the spectacular Cumbria way 
 The Isle of Man coastal path at Bradda Head gives views to the Calf of Man 
 Looking to the impressive Kilnsey Crag on the Dales Way in Wharfedale 
 Freshwater Bay, Isle of Wight 
 News in focus Scotland 
 New property presents challenge for conservation group 
 The John Muir Trust needs to get the balance right. 
 Rennie McOwan reports 
 The sunshine on the Isle of Skye earlier this year was hotter than in Bombay. 
 But it was not just the short-lived weather which sent spirits soaring. 
 The rapidly growing John Muir Trust in Scotland had just bought the Torrin Estate on Skye. 
 The Torrin Estate provides a major challenge for the Trust because living communities exist alongside beautiful scenery. 
 As well as great views, it is home to a crofting community and a quarry. 
 Prince Charles is Patron of the Trust and is full of praise for its activities to date. 
 In a patron's letter delivered by video to the Trust's annual general meeting and repeated in full in the recent newsletter, Prince Charles said &bquo;The recent purchase of the Torrin estate is the best possible demonstration of what the Trust is all about. 
 A wonderful limestone landscape and its specialised flora will now be well-catered for, in co-operation with the crofting community&equo;. 
 He also mentioned the increasing number of visitors to the hills, disturbance to wildlife, changing landscape and ugly estate tracks (of which Balmoral estate has some prime examples). 
 The Prince calls for everyone to realise that it is time to take adequate stock of such landscapes, our collective effect upon it and our responsibilities towards it. 
 I have written before about the controversy raised in Scotland over the National Trust for Scotland's mountain properties and breaking the &bquo;rules&equo; set by its mountaineering benefactor Percy Unna, who wanted the hills kept natural. 
 Prince Charles comments on this in the John Muir Newsletter and refers to Unna's wishes first expressed 50 years ago. 
 He says &bquo;His rules made good sense then and they make better sense now as the pressures grow inexorably, yet they have been ignored in certain sensitive areas, with results which are both plain and heart-rending to see.&equo; 
 Prince Charles also supported the Torrin purchase financially. 
 The Trust's initial appeal to members raised &pound;31,000. 
 Substantial cash help has also come from the National Heritage Memorial Fund (&pound;40,000), the Countryside Commission for Scotland (&pound;40,000), the Christopher Brasher Trust (&pound;30,000) and many others. 
 Andrew Thompson has been appointed conservation officer with financial help from CCS, the World Wide Fund for Nature and the outdoor firm Graham Tiso. 
 For those who love wild places and are concerned for their management, the John Muir Trust presents an endearing and attractive face. 
 The Trustees include widely experienced people and it is good to see Jim Hunter of Skye &mdash; crofting expert, historian and author of the definitive book The Making of the Crofting Community  &mdash; heading the management committee for Torrin, which also includes the energetic national director, Terry Isles of Dundee. 
 The Trust looks like becoming the premier wilderness organisation in Scotland. 
 If you want to join the John Muir Trust or help with the Torrin appeal, write to: Keith Anderson, Membership Secretary, FREEPOST, John Muir Trust, Edinburgh EH9 0LX. 
 Glen Coe Still on conservation issues, it came as a pleasant surprise to many when the news leaked that the Countryside Commission for Scotland, who built and own the controversial visitors centre on National Trust for Scotland ground in Glen Coe, had recommended that the centre be moved. 
 A consultant's report, which was not made public, put forward three options. 
 Firstly, that the centre and car parking be extended, secondly that the centre and parking space be removed entirely and the ground restored to its natural state and thirdly, that the centre be moved to the area of Ballachulish and Glen Coe villages, where there are already buildings and a tourism infrastructure. 
 This would reduce the Glen Coe parking space and keep the original building solely for rangers and related activities. 
 Much of the glen is owned by NTS and there has been increasing adverse publicity recently over a vast upsurge in visitor numbers, the centre's failure to stop indiscriminate car parking up and down the glen and increased mountain erosion. 
 The centre was also criticised for being in breach of the &bquo;Unna Rules&equo;, which state that there should be no artificial structures on the property and no facilities for food and drink. 
 At this stage, the National for Scotland's response to the CCS decision is unknown. 
 This writer would certainly have preferred the option for moving everything out of the main glen, but the fact that the centre is now seen as being a mistake is encouraging and the partial solution is vastly better than the centre being a rapidly-growing monster. 
 Bennachie I recently reported the appointment of Fred Gordon as Gordon District Council's Ranger at Bennachie, that prominent hill near Inverurie. 
 Now comes the Bailies of Bennachie, the voluntary body which helps look after the hill, has almost topped an astonishing 4000. 
 Bennachie (pronounced pain-ah-hee) must be one of the most cared-for hills in the country. 
 It has an almost mystical appeal for north-east people, with its prominent blue peaks attracting the eye from so many quarters. 
 Life membership of the Bailies is at the bargain price of &pound;1 (yet they say north-east folk are mean!)  
 Prince Charles, Patron of the John Muir Trust, gave financial support to help buy the Torrin Estate 
 Weekender Pembrokeshire 
 Pembrokeshire 
 Heather Barrett discovers stunning walks and great cycle routes in the Pembrokeshire Coast National Park 
 Cliffs along the rugged coast, golden sands, estuaries, wooded valleys, hills and harbours are just some of the features which make Pembrokeshire an area of such outstanding beauty. 
 The scenery is breathtaking and the feeling of isolation and ruggedness is easily found. 
 Pembrokeshire &mdash; Penfro in Welsh &mdash; translates as &bquo;Land's End&equo; and today lies within the new county of Dyfed, named after the ancient Welsh kingdom. 
 In 1952 a unique national park was created here. 
 Apart from being one of the smallest (225 square miles) of the 11 national parks in England and Wales, the Pembrokeshire Coast National Park is also the only park in Britain which is largely coastal and mainly covering lowland areas. 
 The area is quite densely populated and the majority continues to be actively farmed. 
 Many visitors naturally come to walk part of the 180-mile coast path which meanders around the peninsula, threading past high clifftops and dropping  into a succession of sandy beaches, rocky coves and inlets. 
 Opened 20 years ago, the Pembrokeshire Coast Path is a paradise for walkers, bird watchers and nature lovers. 
 The nearest island, Ramsey, is a nature reserve with superb seal and seabird colonies while to the south are the seabird islands of Skokholm and Skomer. 
 Far out to sea lies the gannet colony of Grassholm. 
 Inland the wild and vast Presely Hills which dominate the area are well worth exploring. 
 On top of these ancient hills, which are over 400 million years old, you will be rewarded by magnificent panoramic views. 
 Milford Haven lies to the south with the Bristol Channel and Lundy Island beyond. 
 To the west it is possible to see the Wicklow Mountains in Ireland and you can sometimes see the peaks of Snowdonia to the north. 
 Although justifiably most famous for the coast path there are plenty of other outdoor activities to enjoy in Pembrokeshire. 
 The dramatic headland of St Govan's Head is a firm favourite with climbers and there are many bridlepaths and riding schools. 
 The impressive tidal rapids of The Bitches have gained the region an international reputation for first class sea canoeing. 
 There are also calmer coastline stretches where novices and experts practise all kinds of watersports from windsurfing to jetskiing. 
 Inland there are attractive narrow rivers for gentle canoeing. 
 The area is steeped in history. 
 The first people to reach this remote peninsula were the Old Stone Age people who sought shelter in caves such as Hoyle's Mouth near Tenby and Priory Farm Cave at Monkton. 
 Through the ages these western seaways have been used as a highway by settlers and saints, pilgrims and pirates and traders and travellers. 
 Early settlers built large burial chambers and the solitary standing stones are memorials to the people who, it is believed, transported Bluestones from the Presely Hills to Stonehenge 4000 years ago. 
 Tenby was the first resort in the region to attract tourists and was fashionable in Georgian times. 
 Today it retains much of its charm and is a lively place full of good restaurants, caf&eacute;s and pubs. 
 I was surprised at the mild temperatures in St David's and the surrounding areas. 
 While the rest of Britain was shivering in one of the most sodden, miserable June months on record, the west coast of Wales had been sizzling through a heatwave. 
 According to locals this is not unusual. 
 Although surrounded on three sides by the sea the warming influence of the North Atlantic helps give mild winters and good summers. 
 But take waterproofs just the same as rainfall is usually high &mdash; up to 60 inches a year in the Presely Hills. 
 The region's exposed position also means it's often notoriously windy. 
 Good weather is an added bonus but the real appeal is the fantastic variety of landscape within a compact area. 
 This makes it one of the most spectacular parts of Britain to visit. 
 Coast walk around Wooltack Point 
 One of the nicest things about walking around coastline peninsulas is that it is often easy to stick to the coastline without doubling back on yourself at the end. 
 We parked in the small village of Marloes and planned our route on the map. 
 We wanted to walk around as much of the coastline as we could in several hours. 
 We headed onto a small lane which took us straight towards Marloes' magnificent sands. 
 We were then on the coast path, near an old abandoned aerodrome and could see ahead in the distance Wooltack Point near a cluster of islands. 
 It was hot and sunny and the sea was as calm as a lake. 
 Keeping to the coast path &mdash; which goes very near the edge in places without any safety ropes &mdash; we passed close by Gateholm Island before meandering past craggy rockfaces. 
 The sea was far below and the view terrific. 
 Several times we spotted seals basking in the calm waters. 
 They would lie for hours, hardly moving, before a sudden noise startled them and they instinctively dived for cover. 
 Schools of porpoise, dolphin and sometimes even turtles can also be seen but we weren't so lucky that day. 
 However the birds were spectacular. 
 This is a fantastic place for birdwatchers &mdash; puffin, falcon, raven, gannet, guillemot and cormorants, to name but a few, make their homes along the coastline and on its islands for part of the year. 
 When we stopped for a picnic lunch we were pestered by a cheeky jackdaw which squabbled with seagulls for its share in the scraps of our sandwiches. 
 We reached a deer park almost on the Point but unfortunately didn't see any deer. 
 On the outermost point of the peninsula we  could see straight over to Midland Isle and just beyond that to Skomer Island. 
 Skomer itself is primarily a seabird reserve with over 320 000 birds and is owned and maintained by the Countryside Council for Wales. 
 We continued on to Musselwick Sands, where bathers were enjoying the beach. 
 And then, invigorated by the fresh air and natural beauty, we headed back towards Marloes. 
 Bike ride from Fishguard into the Presely Hills 
 Most visitors to this region concentrate on the coast but it is worthwhile heading inland where a large network of lanes provides some quiet cycling. 
 However it is important to avoid the A roads which are too narrow and busy to be much fun. 
 If you leave them behind and take to the lanes you'll rarely see a car. 
 We decided on a 25 mile circuit from Fishguard through the Presely Hills which offered a mixture of bare hillsides, wooded valleys and pastoral scenes of hedgerows and farms. 
 Soon after setting off we came to a forested valley along the banks of the Gwaun. 
 Large wooded areas are rare in Pembrokeshire due to the strong winds and salt spray, but Cwm Gwaun, a few miles east of Fishguard, is one of the notable exceptions to the rule. 
 We then cycled uphill to the town of Rosebush with its deserted slate quarries. 
 This is quite a steady climb but well worth it for the superb views. 
 From the heights of Foel-cwmcerwyn, just to the east, you are supposed to be able to see Exmoor, Snowdonia and the Wicklow Mountains in Ireland. 
 But the worsening weather conditions as we cycled destroyed any possibility of us seeing such stunning views. 
 We skirted the artificial Llys y-fran reservoir and chose a route back on the tiny lanes which connect the farms. 
 Most of these lanes have grass down the middle, testifying to the light traffic. 
 We timed the ride well because just as we cycled back into Fishguard the sky darkened and yet another downpour drove us none too reluctantly into a tearoom. 
 Walk from St David's around peninsula 
 No visit to this area is complete without a walk around one of Wales' most famous headlands. 
 We started with breakfast in St David's, the smallest cathedral city in Britain. 
 Before starting the walk we couldn't resist a peek at the 12th century Norman Cathedral, the oldest in Wales. 
 Suitably inspired by such a religious and historic atmosphere we rambled down the lane for a mile and a half towards Whitesand. 
 This is where many people choose to start the walk around one of the oldest geological areas in Britain &mdash; there is a large car park near the one mile long beach. 
 With a fair breeze blowing in from the sea, we kept the majestic peninsula in sight as we headed along the coast path. 
 Surprisingly there were few other walkers around, just a couple of locals walking their dogs. 
 The path was narrow and rocky in parts but caused no difficulties. 
 I'd heard it was a lovely area but wasn't prepared for its rugged beauty. 
 The flowers were amazing. 
 Bank upon bank of thrift and proud long-stemmed daisies intermingled with huge expanses of gorse and foxgloves. 
 It was a spectacular sight &mdash; the best I've had of wild flowers in Britain. 
 There were also remnants of late bluebells which were well past their best but must have been magnificent in spring. 
 Later in summer heather and bracken also cover the clifftops. 
 The mild climate and the many different habitats support a wide variety of birds and flowers, butterflies and moths. 
 We saw evidence of what would later promise to be a riot of butterflies with entire bushes covered by baby caterpillars and chrysalises. 
 We also saw several foxes' earths but weren't lucky enough to get even a glimpse of the inhabitants. 
 We stopped for a breather at Porthmelgan, a small sheltered beach tucked in on the south of the headland, before starting down the hill to look at the outline of St David's Head with its craggy 500 million year old rocks. 
 Just before leaving the path we heard a frantic rustle and spied a baby adder slithering away. 
 It was tiny but a reminder that there are still poisonous snakes in the region &mdash; a fact which is all too easy to forget. 
 Before reaching St David's Head we passed a massive rampart of stone stretching 200ft from cliff to cliff. 
 This was originally a defence system, known as Warrior's Dyke, which isolated the headland from attackers &mdash; another reminder of how vulnerable the spot was in ancient times. 
 The walk to the Head was easy, the views spectacular. 
 We could see right out to Ramsey Island and the deadly line of rocks known as The Bitches. 
 It's easy to sit up here for hours, feeling fresh and invigorated and envying the local people their beautiful surroundings, but we were keen to press on and see a Stone Age burial chamber sited just off the path. 
 The cap stone is about 12ft by 9ft and is supported by other stones. 
 Here we debated whether to abandon our planned route and continue along the coastline. 
 But time didn't permit and we reluctantly headed slightly inland, through fields, along dirt tracks and past more burial chambers, walking parallel to our earlier route back to the car.  
 Above: the craggy coastline offers new treasures at every turn. 
 Right: the deer park looking at St David's Head 
 Mountains in focus 
 Czechoslovak Tatras 
 Few countries can rival Czechoslovakia for mountain scenery. 
 Whether it's walking, skiing or climbing, the Tatras are definitely the place to go 
 Tourist Offices 
 Cedok is the official Czechoslovak travel agency &mdash; 17/18 Old Bond Street, London W1X 4RB. 
 For general enquiries and advice for independent travellers telephone the 24 hour answering service: 071 629 6058. 
 There are Cedok offices in most of the large towns in Czechoslovakia. 
 We recommend contacting Cedok once you know where you want to go as they can arrange package holidays as well as provide a great deal of information for the independent traveller. 
 Visas and Bureaucracy 
 The requirement of a visa was dropped in October 1990 as was the requirement to spend a set amount of money per day. 
 In the past you had to spend around &pound;12 per day. 
 This proved almost impossible when camping, even eating all your meals in restaurants. 
 Language 
 There are two main languages in Czechoslovakia &mdash; Czech and Slovak &mdash; which are very similar and can be understood by anyone who speaks either. 
 Russian has been forced upon the country and many people are fluent. 
 Since the revolution however there has been an urgency to learn English, especially among the younger generation. 
 A few words of Czech or Slovak learned beforehand will certainly be a great help and in the cities German is often understood. 
 Where to Walk 
 The best known walking and skiing area in the country is the High Tatras in Slovakia. 
 It is very spectacular but tends to get crowded these days. 
 The main town in the area is Tatransk&aacute; Lomnica &mdash; a good centre for skiing in the winter months and walking throughout the year. 
 The Low Tatra mountains and the Slovensk&yacute; Raj National Park on the other hand remain more of a well-kept secret. 
 The easiest way to get there is by train from Prague. 
 The stations at Vydrn&iacute;k, Letanovce and Spissk&eacute; Tom&aacute;sovce just past the large town of Poprad in Slovakia will all leave you near campsites on the edge of the Slovensk&yacute; Raj. 
 It is definitely worth flying to Prague and taking a few days to look around before you travel across the country to Slovakia. 
 Prague is a spectacular city with its churches, museums, castles and street after street of baroque &mdash; and many other &mdash; style buildings, many more than 200 years old with the fa&ccedil;ades at least still in good condition. 
 When to Go 
 The Low Tatras are accessible all-year round though you won't be able to do much walking in the winter. 
 It's best to go walking from May through to September. 
 Skiing is possible in winter. 
 How to Get There 
 There are daily flights to Prague by BA, tel: 081 897 4000 and CSA the Czechoslovak airline, tel: 071 255 1898. 
 The APEX fare is &pound;222 return with either airline. 
 Rail travel to Prague costs only slightly less than going by air. 
 Internal Transport 
 Bus and train are much the same price at the moment though it's quicker to take the bus. 
 If you take the overnight train across the country beware of public holidays when they're very crowded. 
 International car hire organisation like Avis, Budget, Europcar and Hertz operate in Czechoslovakia and car hire is available  from Pragocar. 
 See Cedok for addresses. 
 Car hire for foreigners is very expensive, about &pound;50 per day plus mileage, plus petrol. 
 Independent car hire companies are new setting up so ask around. 
 Currency and Prices 
 The currency is crowns (Kcs). 
 It is not possible to obtain any currency until you arrive in the country. 
 Exchange bureaux are sited at all main entry points. 
 The official exchange rate (at the time of writing) is around 50 Kcs to the pound. 
 The unofficial rate on the black market is much the same and you are more than likely to end up with either Polish money or old Czechoslovak currency which is not legal tender. 
 By warned! 
 Half a litre of lager (the real thing &mdash; Pilsner and Budweiser were invented here) will cost 7&ndash;10Kcs. 
 Transport is considerably cheaper than in the UK but prices are on the increase. 
 In fact all prices are increasing. 
 On the whole though, it is a very cheap country to visit if you don't stay in the big hotels. 
 Food 
 This is where a phase book is most important. 
 Menus are totally incomprehensible unless you understand at least some of the language. 
 Vegetarians have a hard time as the staple diet is meat and dumplings and fresh vegetables are difficult to find. 
 Where to Stay 
 Away from Prague and the big cities camping is the cheapest way to travel. 
 Most campsites also have huts for hire for a few pounds per night per person. 
 The huts provide beds, toilet and wash basin but you should bring your own stove and equipment, etc. 
 Campsites generally have a restaurant on site with good food. 
 The official travel agency Cedok can provide lists of places to stay throughout the country. 
 Maps and Guides 
 Strangely enough you need look no further than p29 of Outdoor Action for details of the very latest, full-colour guidebook on Czechoslovakia &mdash; so up-to-date it's not even in shops yet. 
 It's edited by Outdoor Action's editor Laura McCaffrey and we are offering it at a very special price. 
 Otherwise there's a limited selection at the Travel Bookshop Ltd, 13 Blenheim Crescent, London W11 2EE, tel: 071 229 5260. 
 They have maps of the country and guidebooks. 
 Stanfords are also worth a try, 12&ndash;14 Long Acre, Covent Garden, London EC1V 2PT. 
 Tel: 836 1321. 
 Maps of national parks and walking areas are available from book shops in the main cities and also from street kiosks. 
 You can buy maps and guides from campsites in the country areas. 
 Organised Walking 
 Explore Worldwide, 1 Frederick St, Aldershot GU11 1LQ. 
 Tel: 0252 344161. 
 Walking holidays in Low and High Taras. 
 Ramblers Holidays, Box 43, Welwyn Garden City, Hertfordshire AL8 6PQ. 
 Tel: 0707 331133. 
 Walking tours. 
 Sherpa expeditions, 131A Heston Road, Hounslow, Middlesex TW5 0RD. 
 Tel: 081 569 4101. 
 Walking holidays in Polish and Czechoslovak Tatras. 
 Bike Events, PO Box 75, Bath BA11BX. 
 Tel: 0225 480130. 
 Cycle tours of Eastern Europe. 
 Tours of Czechoslovakia planned for 1992. 
 Alternative Activities 
 Don't expect the same kind of organised tourist activities you'd find in countries like Austria or Switzerland. 
 You'll have difficulty trying to get hold of a bike or a canoe in the Tatras. 
 It's best to go with an organised group if you want to cycle or paddle your way through the area. 
 There are caves to explore and some good areas for climbing with fine sandstone in the Slovensk&yacute; Raj National Park in the Low Tatras. 
 The High Tatras are popular for skiing and skiing is also possible in the Low Tatras though not on such an organised scale. 
 Flora and Fauna 
 The Slovensk&yacute; Raj is well covered by natural pine forests on limestone hills. 
 Larger numbers of roe deer live near there and Czechoslovakia still has bears and wolves roaming in the wild. 
 In the Slovensk&yacute; Raj look out for black woodpeckers and storks.  
 Far left: The Hornad River in the Slovensk&yacute; Raj. 
 Left: sometimes you need a cautious approach to appreciate the views. 
 Below: trekkers are helped on their way 
 Czechoslovak Tatras 
 Paul Glendell takes a trek through the gorges and waterfalls of the Slovensk&yacute; Raj &mdash; aptly known as the Slovak Paradise. 
 Mention Czechoslovkia to walkers and most will think of the High Tatras, the well known and majestic mountains in Slovakia. 
 But a few miles south-west of these peaks are the Low Tatras. 
 And though they are popular with the people of Czechoslovakia they're little known outside the country. 
 Not far away is the Slovensk&yacute; Raj National Park &mdash; translated it's Slovak Paradise. 
 Its steep, wooded, narrow gorges with 600ft cliffs and fast flowing mountain streams with waterfalls cascading literally hundreds of feet are enough to tempt any enthusiastic walker. 
 And in the Slovensk&yacute; Raj the paths go through the steams and when you get to a waterfall, ladders have been built to take you to the top. 
 This is no place for a short Sunday afternoon stroll, the paths are very well marked but the going is tough. 
 One moment you are on a path by a stream, the next you are balancing on a carefully placed tree trunk to cross the stream for the hundredth time. 
 A few minutes later you are walking up a short wooden ladder, round the corner and you find a 200ft waterfall &mdash; bridges cross the torrent twice before you reach the top and continue along the path. 
 All this in the most magnificent scenery, a national park where the natural forest hasn't been logged for years and grazing sheep is prohibited so as not to upset the natural balance. 
 Wild camping in the forest is prohibited but numerous organised sites are available both within the park and around the edges. 
 It is possible to rent Scandinavian-style huts if you fancy a more comfortable night. 
 They have no cooking facilities but plenty of running water. 
 There's usually a restaurant and shop on site though. 
 With the paths so well marked it's easy to make up walks to suit your mood and fitness. 
 The walk from the campsite near Hrabusice gave us a real taste of Paradise. 
 From the camp we followed the path going south-west. 
 The start of the walk is very gentle with a wide dirt track taking you into cool woodland with spring vegetation and all shades of mosses on the banks by the side of the path. 
 There are wood anemones and violets much in evidence in the spring. 
 After an hour or so we reached a Slovak village with houses in the traditional wood construction with wooden roofs. 
 From here we carried on along a river and soon arrived at Sokol which has just one house &mdash; a traditional forester's cabin with deer antlers above the front door. 
 We continued to follow the Sokol river up the Velky Sokol into the heart of the national park. 
 The sides of the valley grew slowly steeper and steeper and the marked path (white-yellow-white markers) criss-crossed the river. 
 Our waterproof walking boots were really necessary here as we balanced on rocks to cross the gushing stream. 
 On more than one occasion our feet slipped in. 
 At the valley sides continue to steepen, the path spends more of its time in the river and the going toughens. 
 Wood ladders greeted us at the most difficult places across the stream. 
 As we walked on, patches of snow laying in the darker areas of the gully grew ever more frequent. 
 The sun must only be a rare visitor to this mysterious landscape where spring flowers push through the slowly melting ice. 
 The path through the still narrowing gorge by now had frequent ladders and sometimes chains so we could steady ourselves as we climbed crystal clear waterfalls &mdash; some stopped in motion, still under the all-encompassing spell of the powerful winter ice. 
 After two miles or so of this beautiful scenery we emerged at the top of the gorge into sunlight again and were greeted by a wonderful expanse of forest. 
 We followed as easy path through this still spectacular but very different scenery back to the campsite, picking up blue then yellow and finally red markers back. 
 They are clearly marked on the map from the campsite. 
 Along the way we noticed young pine trees with cloth wrapped around the top shoots to stop deer eating them. 
 Also dotted around were beetle traps &mdash; squares of cloth with collecting bottles below. 
 The presence of beetles is acknowledged as an indicator of the general health of the forest. 
 Look out for the huge holes in the trees made of black woodpeckers and with luck you will see the culprit and even hear it at work. 
 In the Sokol valley I was lucky enough to watch a stock circling above for several minutes. 
 I'd originally gone to Czechoslovakia to photograph pollution but I'm so glad I was  pursuaded  by my Czechoslovak friends to spend three days out of my precious two weeks walking in the Slovensk&yacute; Raj. 
 I returned with some spectacularly horrible photos of the country's many problems but also with a good many showing Czechoslovakia's stunning beauty.  
 Gorges give way to lush fertile valleys in the spectacular Slovensk&yacute; Raj National Park 
 Royal ascent 
 The peaks if Ben Loyal, Queen of Scottish mountains, rise regally above a wild lowland landscape. 
 Caroline Lindsay reveals their majestic charm 
 Ben Loyal sits regally under the wing of the Munro Ben Hope in the northern quarter of the Sutherland wilderness near Tongue. 
 It fails to be a Munro by some 580ft, yet for me, it more than earns its title Queen of the Mountains . 
 It is best viewed from the north side, from where the four peaks dwarf the tiny Loch Hakel nestling at its feet and the three corries, home to wild deer, embrace the morning sunlight. 
 On a clear dawn or a copper sunset I know of no other mountain which has quite such dramatic appeal. 
 The long drive north may act as a deterrent to some, yet for those willing to make the effort the rewards can be breathtaking. 
 The area is as yet largely untouched by the ugliness of mass afforestation and still a paradise for lovers of the outdoors. 
 The peak itself has quite a past. 
 Its name come from a Gaelic word Lagh  which meant Law &mdash; Mountain of Lawgiving . 
 Indeed one of its peaks is Sgurr a' Chleirich which means peak of the clerics . 
 As judicial proceedings are thought to have been held at prominent landmarks, legal decisions could have been held at prominent landmarks, legal decisions could have been made in the vicinity of Loyal centuries ago. 
 Another interpretation is from the English corruption of the Gaelic word Laogh meaning calf &mdash; Mountain of the Calves . 
 Ben Loyal dominates the Kyle of Tongue and holds a magnetic attraction for many hillwalkers. 
 Its magnetism is not only spiritual &mdash; in some quarters the rock pegmatite has a strange distorting effect on compass bearings. 
 So how best to approach and try to conquer the Queen? 
 There is an easy way to climb Loyal. 
 For those who wish to take a car close and then walk to the top of the hill without too much difficulty, take the A836 to Loch Loyal near Lettermore and climb straight into the corrie Loch Na Creige Riabhaich and on to the main summits. 
 The views are stunning, looking to the sea over the Kyle of Tongue, to Ben Hope dominating the west and the wilderness of North Sutherland stretching away almost infinitely to the south. 
 For those who want more of a challenge to their walking I recommend the following route via the shore of Loch Hakel for drama and scenic beauty. 
 Cross over the (at times boggy) moor towards the facing buttress of the Queen. 
 Try to pick a line through the birch forest on the northern slopes and look out for the wreckage of a World War II aeroplane on the north-eastern side. 
 This crashed into the mountain at the end of the war, possibly due to the magnetic anomalies the mineral  composits  created in its compass readings. 
 Climb up into the first lost valley viewing the towering cliffs of Sgor Chionasaid and Sgor a' Bhatain on either side. 
 Go past the hugh boulders &mdash; some are the size of double decker buses &mdash; and ascend into the left col between the main summit of An Casisteal and Sgor Chionasaid. 
 Go east onto the tor of the main summit. 
 Approach this from the north or west side for the easiest ascent &mdash; its rather steep in places. 
 At last you will have conquered the Queen. 
 Treat her with royal respect though, for she can be fickle, given to sudden mists, blizzards and occasionally blistering sunshine. 
 Go well prepared with a map and compass and warm waterproof clothing. 
 Even in July the windchill factor can be intense. 
 Allow a full day or more, if you can spare it &mdash; there is a wealth of cliff, pinnacle and precipice to explore. 
 The beautiful underfoot carpets of blue gentium delight the eye and, above fly buzzards, eagles, skylarks and wheatears. 
 The farms below become dots as you climb and heather, alpine plants and red deer now mark you progress. 
 Though I have lived a lifetime in Scotland and several years in the Highlands, I never feel I am &bquo;at home&equo; until I see Loyal. 
 It's that sort of a mountain in a wilderness of splendid proportions. 
 The Queen may not be a Munro, nevertheless she is as regal a lady as any walker could wish to climb. 
 OS Map: Sheet 10 Strathnaver Stalking season: Usually Sept and Oct for deer and it is unwise to venture on the hills during shoots. 
 Some grouse shoots take place after Aug 12. 
 Enquire at Keeper's House near Lettermore if concerned, but note no shooting generally takes place on a Sunday .  
 Breaking Loose 
 Martin Bewsher leaves the Retsina and package tours behind to discover the charm of Ipsarion. 
 &bquo;So how do we get up there?&equo; 
 Beth asked, leaning on her elbows in the sand. 
 I raised my eyes, distracted for a moment by the blonde splendours of Golden Beach, to the more distant peaks of Ipsarion and its neighbour, Profitis Ilias, glowering over our idleness like the Old Testament patriarch whose name it bears. 
 Our first week on the Greek island of Thassos had been idyllic. 
 We had splashed in the clear Aegean Sea with the kids, explored the ancient ruins and thrown plates around the tavernas like regular tourists. 
 However in this second week the mountains were beckoning. 
 &bquo;I'll ask Andy&equo;, I said. 
 Our Scottish courier, a fount of knowledge on 
 all things alcoholic, proved disappointing on the subject of Ipsarion. 
 He thought he'd been there once but had no idea now. 
 &bquo;There are snakes up there&equo; he muttered, and retired behind his shades. 
 Morning was a bad time to ask Andy about anything. 
 Next day I tried to question our landlady about walking to Ipsarion as she served us breakfast on the marble terrace under the walnut tree. 
 This proved tricky as Maria spoke little English and I even less Greek. 
 I pointed out the mountains. 
 &bquo;Ipsarion?&equo; 
 She nodded. 
 I indicated my chest and made like the Happy Wanderer up and down the terrace. 
 Her eyes widened. 
 She no doubt thought I'd been out in the sun too long. 
 She brought her husband to help but all he could offer was a shrug which was no comfort at all. 
 Shrugs were all I received from the Tourist Information Centre on the harbour. 
 Our neighbours, with whom we drank Metaxa and broke plates most evenings, thought they were trying to discourage tourists from venturing into the mountains because of the risk. 
 Much of the forest in the south east of the island had been destroyed by fire in recent years. 
 But I was beginning to wonder if Ipsarion had ever been climbed by uncloven feet, a suspicion intensified by studying the maps available in the local shops. 
 Relief and scale were not indicated. 
 Ipsarion varied in height between 3700 and 4200ft above sea level and was pinpointed with the &bquo;here be dragons&equo; accuracy of medieval manuscripts. 
 By this time I had developed a gut feeling for the topography of the island. 
 Thassos sits in the Northern Aegean like a soupbowl on a plate &mdash; the mountains rise steeply from a narrow coastal plain, gradually decreasing in height the closer you get to the centre. 
 Its one town Limenas and most villages cluster round its 60 mile perimeter, joined by the one decent road. 
 Limenas, or Thassos Town where we were staying, is on the north coast opposite the mainland. 
 Access to the centre of the &bquo;bowl&equo; is conveniently on the south coast where a track could be seen on the map heading for but stopping short of Ipsarion. 
 We booked a moped for penultimate day of the holiday allowing 24 hours for recovery before the flight home. 
 Our neighbours volunteered to keep an eye on the kids who were too absorbed in catching a tan and the biggest fish in the harbour, to come with us. 
 To avoid climbing in the heat of noon we decided to leave at daybreak. 
 So much for good intentions. 
 It was mid-morning when we set out nervously along the coast road on the first two-wheeled motor I had ridden for 20 years. 
 By the time we had reached Skala Maries and turned inland, I had mastered the gear changes sufficiently for Beth to relax the vice-like grip she had on my waist and enjoy the scenery. 
 Bright flowers stabbed the grey-green scrub. 
 The air was a warm soup of their scents. 
 In the village of Maries the surfaced road came to an end. 
 They we were half riding, half pushing up into the mountains. 
 At first the track was lined with bright terraces of beehives, their owners in makeshift tents busily extracting the honey for which Thassos is famous. 
 After that just forest, mile after mile of pines, the track worsening noticeably at each junction. 
 Eventually the boulders in the road became too large to dodge. 
 We abandoned the moped by a spring where clouds of orange butterflies came to drink the spray. 
 We too drank gratefully. 
 I was now hot so we filled our water bottle and set off up the track towards to skyline. 
 The terrain here was more open, like something out of the Wild West, with deeply eroded crags and ravines. 
 The rest was silence &mdash; a deep, beautiful silence. 
 Except for the flies that is which had the persistence of pit bull terriers. 
 Despite a decent map it had become obvious that we were approaching the high ridge of the mountains. 
 As we sweated up the final rise, the stern brow of Profitis Ilias came into view on our left. 
 Then we were crossing a rutted rock pavement, a trig point incongruously ahead. 
 Abruptly the ground fell away from our feet, an awesome void opened before us. 
 We looked at each other &mdash; we had finally reached Isparion's elusive summit. 
 We sat with our backs against the trig point and gazed down like Gods on the coastal plain of Thassos. 
 Far below us pine forest bearded the foothills, broken here and there by the scars of red roofed villages, sensibly sited well away from the vulnerable coast. 
 Pale roads snaked from them down to the newer tourist settlements by the sea. 
 And then two human torsos appeared in the distance. 
 They never reached the summit and we never say their legs. 
 Beth thought it was something to do with the heat haze but I know a centaur when I see one. 
 Our sense of achievement lasted the few hours until we collected the kids. 
 They and the neighbours were but mildly impressed and Maria clearly disbelieving. 
 But it was in talking to a fellow tourist at the airport on the return journey that we really came down to earth. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; I told him casually, &bquo;And we did Ipsarion on Tuesday. 
 It was truly incredible.&equo; 
 &bquo;Really,&equo; he said, &bquo;never got round to that club myself. 
 Did most of my drinking at Georgio's.&equo;  
 Winning Ways 
 A week of walking around the beautiful Lakeland Fells proved an energetic break for outdoor action. 
 Holiday prizewinner Michael Taggard. 
 The prospect of a week's walking in Borrowdale at the end of July would raise the spirits of any walker, but to spend a week there as Outdoors Action  prizewinners was an added bonus. 
 Our break with the Countrywide Holiday Association (CHA) was spent at their Glaramara Centre, in a beautiful part of the ever popular Lake District. 
 We arrived on Saturday afternoon to a friendly welcome from Dorothy, our CHA hostess for the week, and Neil, one of the walk leaders. 
 Unfortunately we missed tea, which was a shame as it was wholesome, homemade and in vast quantities, like all of the meals at Glaramara. 
 On Sunday we rose early and after a good breakfast were eager to get out on the hills. 
 CHA make it easy by providing walking guides for groups &mdash; our group consisted of a rich mix of walkers of all ages and nationalities. 
 That day we walked from Glaramara to Castle Crags, where we had an excellent view over Derwent Water before crossing the valley to explore Grange Fell. 
 Monday began with yet another blaze of sunshine. 
 We set off through the lovely village of Stonethwaite and up the steep woodland path towards Great Crag. 
 Before reaching the summit we stopped for a snack at Dock Tarn, sure one of the most underestimated spots in the Lakes. 
 It is isolated yet beautiful. 
 From here we returned to Borrowdale via Jopplety Haw, grateful that the heatwave had transformed the moss into springy turf. 
 On Tuesday we opted for a more strenuous hike from Braithwaite village up the steep sloped of Grisedale Pike. 
 The long trek in hot weather sapped our energy and emptied our water bottles. 
 According to the itinerary Wednesday was a rest day but after a half-hearted attempt at browsing around the Keswick shops we decided that the call of the fells was too strong to resist and headed for the Langdales. 
 We started from the Dungeon Ghyll hotel and crawled up Mill Gill in the heat of the midday sun. 
 Several stops later we staggered to the side of Stickle Tarn for lunch. 
 Before us lay Pavey Ark like a vast seacliff and on either side lay several safe, if uninspiring, ascents. 
 But our aim was Jack's Rake, a tortuous climb running right across the cliff. 
 Jack's Rake is a difficult scramble and at one or two points positively frightening as we climbed the final yards we felt a great sense of achievement. 
 For many, the ascent of Great Gable on the Thursday was the highlight of the week. 
 We walked along Styhead Gill to follow the south traverse and crabbed our way across scree slopes. 
 We reached the much photographed Nape's Needle and skimmed up the short, yet difficult, chimney of boot-worn rock. 
 From here we worked our way carefully across the rock base until we reached the treacherous scree slope known as Little Hell Gate. 
 Although it is a difficult route to ascend by, we reached the summit and were rewarded by some spectacular views. 
 We approached our last day with mixed feelings. 
 We were looking forward to our walk but didn't want the holiday to end. 
 The easiest part of the day was parking the car by the Fish pub in Buttermere. 
 However the sudden steep haul up Red Pike quickly brought us all to our senses. 
 We rested for a while at Bleaberry Tarn which turned out to be a wise move. 
 The hot, dry weather was beginning to break, to be replaced by ferocious winds which seemed determined to pluck us off the mountainside. 
 After being welcomed to the summit of an amazingly red Red Pike by the rain, we were happy to descend to Scarth Gap. 
 We went to the nearest pub in our sodden clothes and reflected on our great holiday. 
 For mor information about CHA holidays, contact: Countrywide Holidays, Birch Heys, Cromwell Range, Manchester M14 6HU. 
 Tel: 061 225 1000.   
 Out &amp; about in Britain 
 Every month we feature a great walk and visit an activity centre in your region of the country 
 Highlands and islands 
 Lowlands and borders 
 Northern England 
 North Wales and Central England 
 South Wales and the Midlands 
 South west England 
 South east England 
 1. 
 Very easy 
 2. 
 Easy 
 3. 
 Moderate 
 4. 
 Energetic 
 5. 
 Demanding 
 Highlands &amp; islands 
 Southern Skye shores and Loch Slapin 
 Low coastline and some slightly boggy moorland. 
 Easily managed in comparison to most circular walks on the island; the 40 minutes walk along the A881 (very quiet unfenced road) can be avoided by catching the daily post-bus &mdash; check times at Broadford tourist office. 
 Some care needed with path junctions through quarry at start. 
 An intermittent moorland path to the coast, with a hard track for the last two miles before joining road; route-finding moderately easy. 
 Length 9 miles (14.5km(), 4&ndash;1/2 hours Difficulty 3&ndash;4 Start Ruined chapel at Suardal. 2 miles SW of Broadford, Skye. 
 Take A881 out of Broadford. 
 After 2 miles road passes three houses; cemetery is 1/4 mile further on right. 
 Roadside parking. 
 Grid reference NG617207. 
 OS maps: 1:50 000 32; 1:25 000 Outdoor Leisure . 
 Walk directions 
  Follow road towards Broadford. 
  Pass first house; (bungalow) then after 50 yds turn right through gate on to track. 
  Where track reaches old crofter's cottage bear half (no path) across stream, up bank, to reach grassy former railway track after 30 yds. 
 Turn right along this. 
  Keep to left fork after 1/4 mile. 
 Track passes through old marble quarry and rises for 1/4 mile (a). 
  Near end of quarry ignore wide grassy track on right (incline of old railway) leading gently downhill but bear half left on path passing large spoil heap after 50 yds.  30 yds after spoil heap ignore minor left fork. 
 Keep left on main path 100 yds later. 
 Path through moorland is boggy but passable and maintains same direction, soon crossing fence and continuing along bottom of small valley, then on right side of valley. 
  Reach shore, turn right along it (b). 
 First stream is crossed by stone bridge within walls of old croft (ruined) (c), subsequent streams can be stepped across and require no jumping. 
 Avoid walking on rocky foreshore; clear path runs just inland from it. 
  Metal (covered) sheep-pen comes into view; your objective is the stony track leading from far side of it. 
 Reach fence above the pen, turn right and follow fence. 
  Once level with deserted stone croft down on left, take small gate on left (the second passed) down to croft (d), by which turn right on track and follow for 2 miles (e). 
  Ignore driveways on right and 30 yds later, left. 
  Turn right on A-road; follow to start. 
 What to look out for 
 (a) A working marble quarry is passed at the end of the walk. 
 Flora Two types of Alpine flower &mdash; white-petalled mountain avens (May) and yellow mountain saxifrage (August). 
 (b) View Across Loch Eishort (a sea-loch) to the southernmost part of Skye. 
 17m SW out to sea lies the island of Rum. 
 (c) The ruined huts are all that remain of the old crofting settlement of Borreraig, an extreme example of the eviction of crofting communities in the 19th century. 
 (d) The croft is the last remnant of the settlement of Suishnish. 
 (e) View to Bla Bheim (3047ft) 
 Skye Environmental Centre 
 Address: Broadford, Isle of Skye, IV49 9AQ Tel: 04712487 Activities on offer: birdwatching, wildlife observation holidays/ 
 The Skye Environmental Centre is a charity involved with a whole range of environmental works. 
 The centre has published a range of environmental guides to Skye, is closely involved in environmental education and acts as geological and biological recording centre, collecting valuable data for a range of surveys. 
 On site there's an environmental museum and an animal rescue centre. 
 As well as all this the Environmental Centre runs wildlife and birdwatching holidays on Skye. 
 The holidays are especially interesting since they are guided by environmentalists. 
 You can choose from a weekend (&pound;95) or a week long holiday (&pound;265) where you'll observe wild life while walking an average of six to eight miles each day. 
 Guests stay at the environmental centre in guest house accommodation. 
 There's an &bquo;honesty&equo; bar where you get your drinks yourself, and observation lounge which looks out over the lovely sweep of Broadford Bay. 
 Vegetarians are catered for. 
 If you're staying elsewhere on the island you can join the wildlife walks for a day or more. 
 Phone in advance to reserve your place &mdash; it cost &pound;10 per day. 
 Or if you want to do your own thing you can use the centre simply as a guest house.  
 Lowlands &amp; Borders 
 Craigend and Mugdock Castles 
 Leads from suburban Glasgow straight into moorland; further on are mixed woods, three lochs, two ruined castles, a reservoir path and a view of Glasgow, which feels miles away. 
 comes down to earth at a residential road close to Milngavie station. 
 All paths and tracks are well defined and mostly signposted; route-finding quite easy. 
 Length 5&ndash;1/2 miles (9km), 2&ndash;1/2 hours With extension  8 miles (13km), 4 hours Difficulty 1 Start Milngavie (pronounced &bquo;Mulguy&equo;) station, 23 minutes by train from Glasgow Central. 
 Large car park. 
 Sundays: bus service only (to station). 
 OS maps 1:50 000 64; 1:25 000 NS 47/57 Refreshments Milngavie 
 Walk directions 
  With station entrance behind you, turn left under pedestrian tunnel. 
 West Highland Way (WHW) begins here (map displayed) and is clearly signposted or waymarked with thistle motifs. 
 Allander Way signposts are also followed. 
 Follow Station Road beyond tunnel, down main pedestrian street in Milngavie, turning right just after crossing river (signpost) down ramp, right on road then immediately left on signposted tarmac path. 
  After 300 yds turn left as signed (yellow arrow), then after 50 yds turn right along riverside (waymarked). 
  WHW turns right to leave river after 500 yds (waymark), turning left 300 yds later at T-junction (waymarked). 
  Straight on after 1/4 mile (signposted Mugdock Wood) at junction. 
 Follow to reach road after 3/4 mile. 
  Turn right on road, (For extension see below). 
  Turn right after 1/2 mile into Kyber car park, then turn left after 30 yds through gate (but first detour ahead a few yards for view of Glasgow) on track signposted Craigend Castle (a). 
  Turn right at Craigend Castle (signposted Mugdock Castle) and follow track for 1/2 mile. 
 . Turn right (signposted Mugdock Castle) to path, which leads into and across field to kissing-gate, beyond which fork right. 
  Reach T-junction with track (castle on left) and turn left to pass in front of castle (b). 
  200 yds later, keep on main track as it bends left down to lochside. 
 Track soon bends right into woods. 
  Just after passing level with house (visible away to left), avoid stone bridge on left leading to iron gates but fork left 20 yds later on to path which crosses stream and follows it then reaches road. 
  Turn right on road. 
  At bottom of hill pass through gateway in reservoir wall on left, then right along reservoir path (c); follow to buildings. 
  Turn left on road at far end, past waterworks building on left (d) then turn right at ornamental garden into driveway. 
  200 yds before (locked) gates ahead, take parallel residential road on right to keep in same direction. 
  Right at road junction at bottom into Moor Road. 
  Left at T-junction (Buchanan Street) follow back to start. 
 For extension , from , turn left on road, then right after 30 yds 
 through kissing-gate, continuing on WHW, track passes lake after 1/2 mile. 
 On reaching small lake on left, keep forward on track (waymark misleading at time of writing), reaching turning-circle after 100 yds. 50 yds later, turn sharp right through gate to leave WHW, and follow 1/2 mile to T-junction. 
 Turn right; track is obvious to road. 
 Right on road then first left into Kybner car park. 
 Resume route at . 
 What to look out for 
 (a) Craigend Castle Sinister ruin of a Gothic country house built c . 
 1816 by James Smith. 
 (b) Mugdock Castle A 14th century ruin (being restored at time of writing) previously belonging to the Earl of Lennox, David De Grahame and the Montrose family. 
 By it, a pleasant lily-covered loch. 
 (c) Reservoir Opened in 1859 and later extended. 
 The pipeline comes from Loch Katrine to supply water from Glasgow. 
 (d) Memorial (where you turn right at the ornamental garden) to one of the Water Board's founders, 1904. 
 In the art nouveau style, the lettering and bronze basin showing the influence of Charles Rennie Macintosh.  
 Northern England 
 Castle Howard Estate 
 Through the woods and landscaped parklands of one of England's great country houses, rising to the ridge of the Howardian Hills &mdash; a gentle escarpment overlooking the Vale of Pickering and the North York Moors. 
 Takes a quiet road at the start. 
 Paths mostly well defined; route-finding moderately easy. 
 Length 6&ndash;1/2 miles (10.5km), 3 hours. 
 Difficulty 2 Start large lay-by 1 mile N of Castle Howard by gatehouse on main estate avenue (100 yds S of crossroads where E turning is sign-posted Coneysthorpe), 5 miles W of Malton. 
 Free parking. 
 Grid reference SE 707712. 
 OS maps 1:50 000 100; 1:25 000 SE 67/77 Refreshments Shop at Coneysthorpe; cafe at Castle Howard, 1 mile off route. 
 Walk directions 
  Turn left out of lay-by then left at crossroads (signposted Terrington). 
 Follow road (very quiet for 3/4 mile. 
  Where road bends left, keep straight on, on track signposted bridleway. 
  After 300 yds, turn right on track waymarked by arrows. 
 Keep left at junction 150 yds later. 
 Left again at next junction 150 yds after this (waymarked) and keep right 20 yds later (waymarked). 
 Follow along until you reach gate . 
 Beyond gate, follow track across parkland to gate ahead, then uphill through woods (ignore cross-track after 100 yds). 
  Turn right at top of ridge by waymarkers. 
  Cross road to track opposite (a) (b). 
  After 1&ndash;1/2 miles path leads through small gate and follows right edge of field. 
 Leaving it by waymarked stile in righthand corner. 
 Head half right (farmhouse ahead) to corner of fence, then proceed alongside fence on left to stile . 
 Turn right on farm track. 
 At end cross road, take signposted bridleway via gate opposite and turn left in field; faint grassy path gradually diverges from hedge on left and where bank of trees immediately on right ends, track becomes very clear and zigzags downhill. 
 Castle Howard Mausoleum (prominent round classical building) is visible on skyline with (smaller) temple to right of it (c). 
  After 1/2 mile, keep right (left leads to farm). 
 10 1/2 mile later and 1/4 mile after woodland begins on left, turn right at junction of tracks as waymarked (ahead leads to gate marked private). 
  At gate at top (turn round for view of Castle Howard) turn left on road past Coneysthorpe hamlet (d) and back to start. 
 What to look out for 
 (a) An arresting view of Castle Howard. 
 The palatial house is of strikingly original design for the early 17th century. 
 No one really knows who designed it. 
 Vanbrugh was appointed as designer but at that time he is not known to have had any architectural experience; his career had until then been a military one. 
 Hawksmoor, who had already had a great deal of experience as an architect, was brought in as clerk of works and it is quite likely that the design was by both men. 
 Hawksmoor had been working for Wren since he was 18 and Castle Howard was very probably modelled on Wren's proposed plan for Hampton Court (which never got beyond the drawing board). 
 (b) Shortly after, view on left opens out across the Vale of Pickering (much of which is also owned by the Castle Howard Estate) to the N York Moors. 
 (c) Mausoleum and temple The mausoleum is huge and majestic, with 20 columns encircling a rotunda. 
 Designed by Hawksmoor in 1731, it was not completed until after his death. 
 The Temple of the Four Winds was built between 1724&ndash; . 
 (d) Coneysthorpe Built for the estate around an oblong green, at the top of which is a handsome classical chapel (1835). 
 The Diver Training College 
 Address: Malt Kiln Lane, Appleton Roebuck, York YO5 7DT. 
 Tel: 0904 84424 Activities on offer: diving. 
 This landlocked location isn't the first place you'd think of for a diving school but the Diver Training College is proving to be very popular. 
 It's run by the Fila family and is based on a purpose built centre with a 22ft (7m) dive tank, a decompression chamber and lecture rooms. 
 There's also a multigym, sauna and a bar on site. 
 For initial lessons students go to a swimming pool in York. 
 The college runs courses recognised by the British Sub Aqua Club and the Professional Association of Diving Instructors &mdash; an American organisation. 
 Courses cater for all levels of diver from the absolute beginner up to those who want to fine tune their technique. 
 Most beginners take the four day PADI Open Water Diver course which enables you to dive in open water. 
 This course will cost you &pound;260. 
 There is no accommodation at the centre but staff will find you a local bed and breakfast.  
 North Wales and Central England 
 Tennyson's birthplace and the Central Wolds 
 Some of the quietest parts of the Wolds. 
 Six villages on the way, with the remotest of the scenery coming after Tetford. 
 Route-finding moderate. 
 Length 11 miles (17.5km), 5 hours Difficulty 3 Start Fulletby, 4 miles NE of Horncastle, by petrol station. 
 Grid reference TF 296733 OS maps 1:50 000 122, 1:25 000 TF 27/37 Refreshments Cross Keys Inn, White Hart Inn and shop. 
 Tetford Blue Bell, Belchford. 
 Walk directions 
  With petrol station on left, follow road to T-junction. 
 Turn right, then after 300 yds take track on left signposted bridleway. 
 Track descends; 150 yds before bottom of slope, where track bends to the left and immediately before copse begins on right, cross ditch on right and bear half left on other side, keeping close to copse on your left. 
 After 30 yds emerge into field; ahead is prominent triangular top of Hoe Hill. 
 Do not make for it but bear half right aiming just to right of nearest bushes. 
 On reaching them turn left and at corner after 30 yds turn right. 
  200 yds later, just before the end of the field, cross ditch on right by waymarker post and continue up slope ahead to reach edge of field 20 yds later. 
 Bear half left, aiming 100 yds to the right of group of trees, to find gate at right extremity of hedgerow. 
 In next field keep well to left of trees ahead by bearing quarter left (soon fence away to right comes into view). 
 Leave field by gate in far right-hand corner. 
 Turn left on road then immediately right, signposted Ashby Peurorum. 
 After 1/2 mile turn right, for Ashby Puerorum. 
 Keep left just before church then turn right at T-junction. 
 Take next right turn. 
  After 600 yds fork left just after large barn (signposted public footpath) and 50 yds later keep left passing between old brick barn (on your right) and modern barn (left), beyond which enter field to follow farm track downhill. 
  After 200 yds and immediately after track bends right through break in hedge turn left (waymarked) proceeding alongside hedge on left. 
 On reaching corner of hedge, right of way proceeds quarter left, aiming for left-hand side of small conifer plantation just in front of which  cross footbridge and proceed to left of plantation to pick up track leading uphill to village of Bag Enderby (a). 
 Turn left when level with thatched cottage on track. 
 On entering first field keep forward along right edge. 
 After 300 yds, by electricity post, cross neck of field to stile ahead. 
 Proceed down slope in second field to stile ahead. 
 Proceed down slope in second field to stile by electricity post, then ascend third field to gate in front of farm. 
 Enter farmyard, turn right and keep right, to pass through gate and on to road. 
 Left on road into Somersby (b). 
 Ignore right turn just before church and ignore left turn 1/2 mile later. 
 Road bends right then left, then passes small pine wood. 
  At end of pine woods, turn right on track (signposted) into right-hand of two fields. 
 Where track ends, continue forward with hedge on left. 
  Keep to left of sheds, follow left edge of two fields and proceed to road. 
 Turn right on road and turn right at next junction then left, signposted Louth. 
 Proceed through Tetford village, keeping left by church and right at next fork, then turn right by grassy triangle. 
  After 100 yds, where road bends right, forward on track (ignore immediate left fork to farm). 
 After 600 yds keep left at fork (signposted) and, where track ends, maintain direction alongside hedge on left to reach gate and footbridge , beyond which turn right (waymarked), very soon alongside ditch on right, then after 300 yds turn left on signposted grassy track. 
 After 300 yds keep forward cover cross-track, now with trees on right. 
  Where trees end, turn right (waymarked), ascending on track alongside ditch. 
 After 300 yds, when level with gate on right, turn left on track. 
  Reach farm road, turn right along it then left at T-junction. 
 Follow into Belchford. 
  After passing church turn left (Dams Lane) Viking Way (VW waymark), for path between fences. 
 Cross footbridge, take stile on right and turn left alongside fence, on clear track. 
  At top of field turn right on cross-track (VW waymark), and after 100 yds turn left through right-hand of two fields alongside fence on left. 
  At far corner of second field cross stile and turn left on track. 
 Fork right by signpost and electricity pole after 80 yds, continuing alongside hedge on right. 
 (VW waymark). 
 Cross stile just before bottom of rise and immediately turn left to cross second stile. 
 Bear quarter right to stile at bottom of field (VW waymark). 
 Forward in next field, making for lower of two radio masts. 
 Cross stile, to find stile in top corner. 
 Left on road, then take third turning right and first left by post-box to return back to start. 
 What to look out for 
 (a) Bag Enderby Attractive small village, where Tennyson's father was vicar (as well as at Somersby). 
 (b) Somersby Tennyson was born in the Georgian rectory (not open to the public) in 1809. 
 Tattershall Park Country Club 
 Address: Sleaford Road, Tattershall, Lincoln LN4 4LR Tel: 0526 43193 Activities on offer: waterskiing, windsurfing, sailing, rowing, canoeing, fishing, jet skiing, pony trekking, adventure playground, nature walks. 
 Despite the name, the Tattershall Park Country Club isn't a pricey place &mdash; admission is only &pound;1 for adults and 50p for children. 
 This gives you access to the main centre's restaurant, bar, squash courts, snooker rooms, gym, sauna and solarium. 
 And then there's the nine lakes for watersports and the surrounding countryside for walking and pony trekking. 
 It isn't too good to be true though &mdash; your admission fee just gets you in there &mdash; all activities cost extra. 
 If you want to go canoeing or rowing you can hire out equipment. 
 There's jet skiing available too. 
 Contact the Wet 'n Wild Jet Ski Club on 0366 383746. 
 You can also hire out windsurfers, tuition is available and you can learn to sail here. 
 Contact Surflark for details on 0860 2941 or 0205 358062.  
 South Wales &amp; The Midlands 
 Witley Court and Abberley Hill 
 Wooded hills and quiet farmland, later descends into Abberley Park. 
 Follow directions carefully, especially in woodland sections. 
 Length 6 miles (9.5km), 3 hours Difficulty 3 Start Hundred House, Great Witley, on A451 and A443, 11 miles NW of Worcester. 
 Grid reference SO 752662 OS map 1:50 000 150; 1:25 000 66/76 Refreshments Hundred House and post office shop, Great Witley 
 Walk directions 
  From Hundred House (a) cross road to gate by phone box with public footpath signpost. 
 Go through gate then bear right across field heading for stile that can be seen on skyline. 
 Go through gate on to sunken road and over stile on opposite bank. 
 Maintain direction across field to another pair of stiles. 
 Bear left on road beyond for 400 yds, until reaching minor road on left at house called The Old Turnpike . 
 Turn up minor road for  yds, then left through fate into field. 
 Cross field to well-defined path up shoulder of Walsgrove Hill, starting at corner of wood. 
 Ascend hill by path, through small fields with wide views to right (b). 
  At signpost, follow direction right, then left into wood till stile is reached. 
 Cross and continue up field, ignoring gate on right and bear slightly left to gate leading uphill to farm . 
 Pass in front of farm (c) then enter wood by gate. 
 Continue forward on path running just inside the wood, leading to Lippetts Farm. 
 Pass to left of farm, then re-enter wood by gate. 
 Continue around side of Woodbury Hill (d) on overgrown track and descend with path to stile and into field next to house. 
 Continue down field to stile and road . 
 Turn right along road for 300 yds, then left down tree-lined track and descend to derelict farm buildings. 
 Continue on track as it bends right then curves round edge of large field, then past a second building and up minor ridge, where it meets another track coming up from right . 
 Turn left on this and follow for 1/2 mile to junction with main drive of Witley Court. 
 Detour right to visit house and church (e) . 
 Return along drive past points where it was joined earlier and descend into minor valley with pool on left, turning right onto another track as soon as drive starts to ascend again. 
 Follow track across field to road and cross to footpath signposted Redmarley. 
 Follow track over rise to Hillhouse Farm, then  swing around to right of farm buildings and descend steeply on tarmac road to another small valley, passing between pools. 
 Continue on road as it ascends to another main road and cross to footpath signposted Abberley Hill . 
 Cross field and when track divides at edge of wood take right-hand fork. 
 Follow this, keeping edge of wood on left and take next left fork which runs up on to a shoulder where another path joins from left and then ascends shoulder steeply (f). 
  At top of rise, turn left on track which after 200 yds descends slightly then turns to left while in minor valley. 
 At this corner (g) take somewhat overgrown path steeply uphill following valley, to summit ridge of Abberley. 
 Here join path which follows ridge and turn left . 
 Continue along ridge for 1/2 mile, ignoring side paths. 
  At obvious junction of paths keep right and at further junction just beyond, keep left. 
 When path picks up line of iron fence continue to follow this, keeping it on left-hand side, to reach trig point on summit. 
 Beyond summit, bear down slope to left to reach well-defined path below, leading down end of hill to join minor road just right of house . 
 Turn left on road and follow downhill. 
 At bottom, cross A443 and follow bridlewalk immediately opposite, signposted Stamford Road. 
 This runs directly below Abberley Hall clock tower (h). 
  At crossing of tracks turn left and immediately right on track, passing under footbridge and skirting school buildings. 
 Beyond buildings continue along sunken trackway. 
 At junction turn left to pass behind range of farm buildings. 
  At clearing with pond on left, turn right round back of house and over stile on to track leading shortly down to road. 
 Cross and turn right on footway back to Hundred House. 
 What to look out for 
 (a) Hundred House A substantial Georgian inn 
 (b) View Over the Teme valley. 
 The Clee hills are beyond and in clear weather the Black Mountains can be seen. 
 (c) There may be peacocks here. 
 (d) Woodbury Hill Large Iron Age fort. 
 (e) Witley Court Spectacular ruined Victorian mansion. 
 (f) View Back over the Severn Valley to Bredon Hill. 
 (g) This point has to be identified very carefully. 
 (h) Abberley Hall Home of William Walsh, an 18th century poet remembered chiefly for his friendship with Dryden, Addison and Pope. 
 Heart of England Balloons 
 Address: Cross Lanes Farm, Walcote, Nr Alcester, Warwickshire B49 6NA Tel: 0789 488219 Activities on offer: ballooning. 
 There are two approaches to ballooning. 
 You can just go up for a ride, letting someone else do all the work while you enjoy the sensation, or learn to pilot the thing for yourself. 
 Heart of England Balloons, run by Mike Gabb and a team of experienced balloon pilots, offer both options. 
 An hour's ride out across the surrounding countryside will cost you &pound;117.50. 
 One session of pilot training will cost you &pound;323 which will include ground training and a flight. 
 Ballooning isn't cheap. 
 The fuel is expensive and you have to pay the cost of a ground crew. 
 It will cost you about &pound;3000 to reach pilot standard. 
 You have to fly at least 12 hours before your initial flight test and on average people fly around 20 hours before getting their licence.  
 Southwest England 
 Hooken Cliffs and Branscombe 
 Take the coast path out of Beer, passing Beer Head and descending into the undercliff to reach sea-level at Branscombe Mouth, then up West Cliff. 
 Here the sea views soon disappear but there is a panorama of the gentle green landscape around Branscombe. 
 Beyond the village there is one steep ascent on to Stockham's Hill before the leisurely drop on a green track down into Beer. 
 A little care is needed with the directions in section 7 otherwise the route is easy to follow. 
 Length 5 miles (8km), 2&ndash;1/2 hours Difficulty 2&ndash;3 Start Cliff car park, Beer (1 mile W of Seaton). 
 Follow main street to sea, keeping right behind The Anchor Inn on Common Lane. 
 Car park is 1/4 mile up, on left. 
 Grid reference 229889. 
 OS maps 1:50 000 192; 1:25 000 SY 08/18 and SY 29/39 (Pathfinder 1330 and 13161) Refreshments Plenty in Beer; caf&eacute; at Branscombe Mouth; shop and pub in Branscombe. 
 Walk directions 
  (a) Take Little Lane, signposted Coast Path to Branscombe Mouth, by car park. 
 This soon becomes path, bending left in front of caravan site and crossing edge of field before running close to cliff (there is always a fence between you and the edge). 
  After 3/4 mile, take stile on left, signposted Coast Path which descends into the undercliff (9b). 
 Later pick up track through caravan site but  leave it at cattlegrid (signposted Coast Path), descending to Branscombe Mouth. 
 Continue on coast path, keeping left (seaward side) of thatched caf&eacute;, then right immediately after it (signposted); path now ascends West Cliff. 
 At top, path bends right and enters woodland losing sight of the sea. 
 1/4 mile later, keep straight on by stiles and National Trust sign for West Cliff (facing other way). 
  350 yds later turn right by post with yellow arrow waymarkers leaving the coast path and descend to Branscombe church (first with fence on right, then after doubling back beyond stile down steps then along edge of field). 
 (c) Beyond church, turn right on road. 
  At road junction by houses, take cul-de-sac on right opposite bus stop. 
 Where this lane ends, continue forward through gate by National Trust sign for Manor Mill and follow left edge of field, at end of which keep to left of seat. 
 Go over footbridge and pick up enclosed path, then lane into Branscombe village centre. 
  Emerge at small square, turn sharp right (signposted to beach) and follow to T-junction. 
 Turn left on road then after 30 yds turn right on to enclosed path up steps by National Trust sign for Stockham's Hill. 
  On reaching stile into open ground, turn left, with fence and woodland on left (soon ignore stile on left) still ascending. 
 200 yds later, by another stile, fence veers half right, path turns right here, still uphill and now away from fence and bends right a few yards later up to stile into field . 
 Turn left and go alongside hedge on left side of the field and leave field by stile at far end (near corner). 
 Continue forward across second field to stile ahead, then  forward on track (which soon runs between hedges), eventually descending to pass car park on your left and Pecorama on your right , track has now become a road on outskirts of Beer. 
 At T-junction turn left, then where road bends left after 75 yds, take enclosed path on right (signposted). 
 Descend to road and take path opposite to reach another road . 
 Here either turn left for centre of Beer or take lane opposite (for cliff car park). 
 Ignore Higher Meadow on your left, then ignore right turn, soon picking up another enclosed path to reach road where turn right to car park. 
 What to look out for 
 (a) Beer Small resort, joined on to larger Seaton, with fishing still important. 
 Its past activities included smuggling, lace-making and quarrying; the latter dates back to Roman times. 
 (b) Hooken undercliff Spectacular rock towers and pinnacles, thick undergrowth and a broken terrain caused by landslips. 
 (c) Branscombe A village in two parts; in the 9th century it was owned by King Alfred and it later belonged to the Benedictine Abbey in Exeter. 
 River Dart Country Park 
 Address: Holne Park, Ashburton, Newton Abbot, Devon. 
 Tel: 0364 52511 Activities on offer: climbing, canoeing, orienteering, lightweight camping, archery, rifle shooting, obstacle courses, simulated parachute jump. 
 River Dart Country Park is a large and well run centre situated in extensive grounds with the River Dart running along one perimeter. 
 Home base is a lovely country house with accommodations for up to 104 people in dormitory style rooms. 
 The activity holidays on offer are really best suited to groups. 
 Some activities take place at the centre &mdash; initial canoe training is in the swimming pool and on the small lakes in the grounds. 
 There's archery on-site too as well as a simulated parachute jump. 
 The wilds of Dartmoor are close by for climbing, canoeing and lightweight camping expeditions. 
 Climbers also go onto the sea cliffs on the south Devon coast. 
 Prices vary enormously for group holidays but a typical price would be somewhere in the region of &pound;25 per person per day. 
 As well as offering group holidays, during the school summer holidays the centre runs activities on a daily basis for anyone who wants to join in. 
 You'll need to ring and book in advance though because the activity days are very popular. 
 A day of activities will cost you &pound;12.50. 
 If you want to be close to the centre there's a campsite within the grounds.  
 Southeast England 
 Everdon and Fawsley Park 
 Three attractive villages in orange-coloured stone amid rolling farmland and parkland are the high points of this route. 
 Length 8 miles (13km), 4 hours Difficulty 3 Start Prestor Capes church; turn off Maidford-Charwelton Road at Preston Capes, taking N turn signposted Daventry, down High Street and turn left into Church Way. 
 Grid reference 574548. 
 OS maps 1:50 000 152; 1:25 000 SP 45/55 (Pathfinder 999) Refreshments Pub at Everdon; pubs and shops at Badby. 
 Walk directions 
  (a) Return along Church Way to High Street and take path opposite and slightly to right through gates of Manor Farm. 
 Go forward (not on the track of the farm) across (first) field to where the wall meets fence to the right of the farm and here take gate into second field. 
 Keep forward alongside wall on left and then alongside fence on left to gate in corner. 
 In third field go forward to waymarked stile at far end, keeping just right of slight rise. 
 Proceed half right across fourth field towards another barn to reach minor road. 
 Turn left along road; after 200 yds ignore track on left up to barn, carry on along road to  just where, before field on lefthand side ends, take gate on left. 
 Go forward on track through field; in next (second field), proceed close to right edge, at end of field which is to right and beyond the hedgerow, turn right on track which leads down through gates and up left side of the third field. 
 Track bends left near top of field, through break into hedge, to follow bottom side of fourth field, past red-brick barn and along bottom of this field then, as enclosed track, eventually reaching Snorscombe Farm . 
 Keep to left of farm buildings on main track. 
 Beyond the farm, track dips down to gate and bends left. 
 Past next house on left (Snorscombe Mill), then  fork left. 
 Track crosses bridge, then immediately turn right to leave track and cross stile; cross another field to stile ahead. 
 Emerge into next field, where go forward and slightly left, passing to right of projecting corner of hedge coming down from left to take stile at corner of field into allotments. 
 Proceed through the allotments on track towards Everdon church, turning right on the road to enter village. 
 Turn left on Main Street, past village green. 
  Near end of village, fork left, signposted Fawsley. 100 yds after 30mph speed derestriction sign, take signposted stile up on right into (first) field. 
 Turn left, alongside hedgerow fence on left, to leave by stile in top left-hand corner. 
 In second field, the route proceeds forward with right edge of field about 30 yds away to reach waymark in hedgerow ahead; in third field go quarter right to cross right-hand hedgerow at waymark on tree which is 90 yds before far end of field . 
 Go diagonally across fourth field to stile in left-hand hedgerow. 
 Cross fifth field to prominent gate in hedge (keeping level). 
 Follow right edge of sixth field on defined track to gate in far righthand corner; turn left in seventh field downhill to farm in bottom corner. 
 Go through farmyard and on to road. 
 Turn right along road. 
  Turn left after 1/2 mile at crossroads and follow minor road 5/8 mile to Badby. 
 Go forward into village centre turning left at T-junction by green along Main Street. 
  After 200 yds turn left into Vicarage Hill. 
 At church follow road as it bends to right but immediately take enclosed path on left, signposted Knightley Way. 
 Path drops, rises and crosses stile into field, where bear right to waymarked stile. 
 Cross second field diagonally left up to stile at corner of Badby Wood (b). 
 Proceed on woodland path along inside edge of woods ignoring all left turns. 
  After 1/4 mile, leave woods by gate and immediately keep left over gate beside stile as waymarked, bearing ahead and slightly left across open area to waymarked stile into woodland. 
 Follow waymarks (slightly left and downhill) to stile, and descend through three fields to waymarked stiles below and slightly left. 
 Emerge on to estate road, turn right and  after 50 yds where road bends right, take gate ahead and cross parkland, passing just to left of Fawsley church. 
 At the church, note the direction of route which proceeds down between the two lakes and then keeps half left towards a barn and which is to left of and below distant tower of Preston Capes church. 
  Leave (first) field by waymarked stile, at point where power-line leaves field and 100 yds before brick ruin. 
 Go straight uphill in second field, initially with right edge and the barn 100 yds away; the route finally veers right to leave field by far right-hand corner. 
 Ascent third field slightly right then drop to stile. 
 Head straight to waymarked stile at end of fourth field. 
 Continue ahead to leave the fifth field by gate beside stile in far left-hand corner, giving on to road . 
 Turn right on road, up to Preston Capes. 
 What to look out for 
 (a) Preston Capes An ironstone village, with its church on the hill looking down towards Fawsley. 
 (b) Badby Wood Enchanting in spring for the spectacular shows of bluebells; also a habitat for foxes. 
 Draycote Water 
 Address: Kites Hardwick, Rugby, Warwickshire. 
 Tel: 0788 811107 Activities on offer: sailing, canoeing, fishing, walking and birdwatching. 
 At 650 acres Draycote Water is the biggest stretch of water in the south Midlands and offers a wide range of activities. 
 Most people who sail on Draycote Water are members of the sailing club, located on the lake shore. 
 Individual memberships costs &pound;109.98 per year, family membership is &pound;143.82. 
 And there's a &pound;50.76 joining fee. 
 But there's no need to join to get out on the water. 
 The sailing club sometimes runs open days when novices can have a go. 
 Alternatively, if you're keen to sail the club will try to make arrangements for you to go out with a club member. 
 Occasionally RYA youth training schools are run on Draycote Water. 
 For full details 0788 811153. 
 There are also trout in the lake and boats available for hire. 
 To fish you'll need a rod licence and a fishing permit. 
 These are available from the fishing lodge at Draycote Water Tel: 0788 812018.  
 Eye to eye Mark Shand 
 Passage to India 
 From travels in search of head-hunting tribes in Indonesia to trekking across India on an elephant, Mark Shand's life has been one big adventure. 
 Henry Druce reports 
 As I was ushered into Mark Shand's spacious flat in South Kensington I saw lying on the living table a book called Living Dangerously . 
 How apt. 
 It was a biography of Timothy Dalton, the actor who plays James Bond &mdash; the epitome of adventure and excitement for so many. 
 With Shand you get a real-life Boy's Own  character &mdash; a man who has had more than his fair share of adventure during 20 years of obsessive travelling. 
 And with his tanned skin, snake tattoo on his left arm and fit physique he certainly looks the part. 
 In fact he bears a vague resemblance to Crocodile Dundee, although his strong upper class English accent, roughened by a liking for Rothman cigarettes, quickly dispelled that image. 
 As he reclined in his sofa, surrounded by a treasure trove of knick-knacks collected from around the world, Mark said he had always had a taste for travel. 
 At the age of 16 he travelled through the Far East and went to Australia to work on a sheep station. 
 The travel bug had truly taken a firm hold. 
 To make a living he worked at Sothebys for two years and then set up business selling Cartier objects and  jewelry  which involved travelling all around the world. 
 He also managed to go on some exciting trips such as following part of the old Inca trail in Ecuador on horseback. 
 And in 1977 he competed in the London to Sydney car race. 
 But as the business grew Mark became ever more restless. 
 His quest for adventure led him to give up the business and sail around the world with a friend in 1980 &mdash; but disaster struck. 
 Mark was hit by Hurricane Bernie in the Solomon Islands and left shipwrecked in the South Pacific. 
 &bquo;It was the lowest point of my life I'd sold everything to do this trip.&equo; 
 But Mark bounced back and in 1983&ndash;4 he went on an expedition in search of the head-hunting tribes of Indonesia, the Orang-hutan. 
 They are found in the most remote part of Indonesia at Irian Jaya where the renowned anthropologist Michael Rockefeller disappeared in the early sixties. 
 &bquo;It was a very shaky area and we had one or two incidents with tribes who buzzed a few spears at us&equo;, said Mark as he inhaled deeply on another cigarette. 
 On one occasion he and his travelling partner Don McCullin were lined up by Indonesians bearing automatic machine guns. 
 &bquo;I thought they were going to shoot us. 
 I remember thinking, well this can't happen to me. 
 I remember looking at the back of Don's anorak and seeing Made in England  and thinking, I wish I was back there.&equo; 
 Mark escaped unscathed thanks to a fast-talking Indonesian who was with him on the expedition. 
 &bquo;He was very clever and went into an entire theatrical about the whole thing and produced pieces of paper with stamps on them. 
 He befuddled them so much that we just ended up paying them off.&equo; 
 Mark co-wrote a book Skulduggery  about his experiences searching for the Orang-hutan tribes, but it is his most recent adventure &mdash; travelling through India on the back of an elephant &mdash; which has really captured the public's imagination.  
 In his book Travels on my Elephant , which topped the best sellers' list, he wrote &bquo;This idea evolved from a drawing I had discovered while clearing out my grandmother's house after she had died. 
 The drawing was of an infuriated male elephant about the charge a little mahout or elephant driver. 
 I took it out with me and forgot about it &mdash; at least I thought I had.&equo; 
 But the idea germinated and slowly grew into an obsession. 
 Mark bought an elephant, Tara, for &pound;4000 and embarked on a 600 mile trek with five eccentric Indian companions, from Konarak on the shores of the Bay of Bengal to Sonepur by the mighty River Ganges. 
 On an average day Mark and his entourage would cover 18 to 20 miles with Tara carrying half a ton of equipment on her back. 
 They also had a jeep to give backup support. 
 The normal daily routine involved getting up at around 6am and stopping for a long lunch at midday in order to avoid the most intense heat. 
 In the evenings they mostly camped. 
 Travelling with a huge mammal has its own special problems. 
 Not least of which was the vast amount of food she ate &mdash; between 400lbs and 600lbs of fodder per day. 
 Mark smiled and said &bquo;She would eat anything you gave her, I've never known an animal like it in my life.&equo; 
 Tara also took quite a liking to rum which she was sometimes given to make her sleep. 
 Tara loved water which caused some  embarassing  moments for Mark. 
 In the town of Keonjhar there was a small reservoir which Tara couldn't resist leaping into. 
 Mark leapt in after her shouting commands and trying to cajole her back to shore, but she wasn't listening. 
 &bquo;I had the entire town around me, about six or seven thousand people. 
 They were all mimicking my accent and pissing themselves laughing.&equo; 
 On another occasion Mark and his merry band were staying at the Raja's palace at Seraikella. 
 At the Raja's insistence Tara was chained up to a 500 year old tree. 
 The following morning Mark discovered that the tree and a nearby wall had been demolished. 
 Mark said that when the Raja saw the damage he was wearing glasses &bquo;which steamed up a bit.&equo; 
 Learning to ride Tara proved a big challenge for Mark. 
 &bquo;They're not like a horse where you have a rein. 
 With an elephant you can kick it till the cows come home but it's not going to worry about it. 
 It's a question of the elephant getting used to your voice and feel. 
 You have to develop that relationship because they can take advantage of you when ever and where ever they want.&equo; 
 People reacted very differently to Tara than to Mark. 
 He said &bquo;you would thing that people were used to elephants, but they love them and would come out and be blessed by her. 
 Whereas the reaction to me was usually one of complete hilarity. 
 And the nice thing was that people used to join us. 
 We would come into a village and 20 to 30 people would come and join us for two or three days.&equo; 
 During the journey Mark became increasingly attached to Tara and concerned about her future after the trek was over. 
 His original plan had been to sell her at the Sonepur Mela in Bihar, the world's largest animal fair and their final destination. 
 But he soon had second thoughts. 
 &bquo;I had this thing in my mind that she had to be in a place where I could get to her and she would be well looked after.&equo; 
 Mark's wishes couldn't have been better fulfilled as she ended up in a small tourist camp in Kanha National Park. 
 &bquo;She's looked after like a little princess.&equo; 
 Through his association with Tara Mark has become very aware of the plight of the Asian elephant. 
 Loss of wildlife habitats caused by population explosions means there are only between 30 000 and 40 000 elephants left in 13 countries. 
 He has been researching and trying to raise money for a documentary to highlight the problem. 
 This, along with research for a new book which is &bquo;under wraps at the moment&equo;, will take him back to India for the next six months. 
 But how does Mark afford to live this enviable existence? 
 In the first instance he made money from his business. 
 &bquo;Then when I started travelling seriously I used to go and be nice to my bank manager, which wasn't so easy.&equo; 
 Now he is beginning to make money from his books, &bquo;although I never went out to write&equo; he adds. 
 Mark says that anyone can travel if they really want to. 
 &bquo;You'll be faced with enormous problems but it's a matter of having a dream and following it through.&equo; 
 And for budding young adventurers he says the most important thing is to have a sense of respect for the countries you visit and leave things as they are. 
 For Mark travelling is an addiction and a way of life. 
 He says the appeal is &bquo;the unpredictability of it &mdash; you never know what's going to happen next. 
 I'm an incredibly impatient person so travel is perfect, it never leaves you bored. 
 There's always an ever-changing scenery in front of you and people. 
 And people are the most important of all. 
 It's also the love of living outside. 
 I enjoy putting up a tent, I like campfires and food for me tastes so much better outside. 
 I'm a schoolboy when it comes down to it. 
 Mark Shand's account of his trip, Travels on my Elephant is published in hardback by Jonathan Cape and costs &pound;14.99.   
 Tara the elephant's love of water caused some embarrassing moments 
 During the 600 mile journey Mark became increasingly attached to Tara 
 Setting Sail 
 Skimming across the water in small sailing craft can quickly become addictive. 
 Belinda Stannage of the RYA gives the low-down on how to get started 
 Surrounded by water and obsessed with the weather your average Briton has perfect credentials to be a very good sailor. 
 And indeed Britain has notched up an enviable record in the sport. 
 One of the few British medals at the last Olympics was in the Star two-man keelboat class, and our line-up for the 1992 Games in Barcelona is looking very strong in many of the ten different classes. 
 But you don't have to be an Olympic hopeful to enjoy the excitement of sailing dinghies &mdash; defined as cabinless boats with retractable centreboards that are kept upright by the weight of the crew. 
 It is a sport which has something to offer almost everyone, regardless of age, fitness, amount of leisure time or depth of pocket. 
 Dinghy sailing can be exhilarating and exhausting, exciting and relaxing, competitive and rehabilitating &mdash; all at the same time. 
 There is nothing like sitting out on a trapeze on a windy day, getting completely soaked by each new wave to make you feel cleansed of the city grime. 
 At time it feels like a matter of survival against the elements, keeping your boat upright in a strong breeze. 
 In complete contrast on windless days it is a case of using your ingenuity to make the best of favourable currents and limited sail capacity. 
 Every available stretch of water &mdash; be it river, sea or reservoir &mdash; is likely to harbour a sailing club. 
 They vary from the smallest tin shack propped up against a breakwater to the smartest yacht club in Cowes &mdash; but you will find the same enthusiasm for the sport in each. 
 The most common introduction to the sport is through sailing courses run at almost 500 RYA-recognised centres around the UK. 
 Some of these may be local authority centres, offering tuition on a sessional basis at between &pound;2 and &pound;6 an hour; others are professional sailing schools, usually situated in the popular UK holiday areas where a week's fully residential course will cost up to about &pound;200. 
 Some are sailing clubs, aiming to attract new members by running beginners' courses over a number of weekends, with charges from about &pound;20 to &pound;70. 
 Your decision when choosing a course will probably be influenced by location, time restrictions and whether the way the course is structured suits you. 
 The most important thing to check is that the instructors operate to standards set by the Royal Yachting Association, the governing body for the sport. 
 Most sailing schools do run to these standards and it is quite rate to find one that doesn't. 
 RYA recognition of a sailing school, club or centre implies that you will be taught by qualified, experienced instructors in sea-worthy boats with adequate safety back-up and shore based facilities. 
 In addition, your course will follow a nationally agreed syllabus and will result &mdash; assuming you are successful of course &mdash; in an internationally recognised certificate. 
 Free lists of RYA-recognised sailing schools can be obtained by sending an SAE to the RYA Headquarters. 
 Having learnt the basics of dinghy sailing, the next stage for most people is to join a local sailing club. 
 Quite apart from the other benefits of club membership, inland clubs often have the only access to local water, while coastal clubs might have the best launching facilities in an area. 
 Both coastal and inland clubs offer dinghy parking areas, changing room, safety boat cover and the facilities you would expect of a club house, including catering and a bar. 
 In addition most clubs organise a full programme of races over the season which, once you've mastered the basics of sailing, can improve your skills very quickly by matching them up with other boats in the fleet. 
 Club racing tends to be fun and competitive, without being too serious, and usually becomes the principal activity for many dinghy sailors.  
 You don't even have to own a boat as most clubs will let you put your name forward as a crew member for a season. 
 The RYA produces a booklet called &bquo;Clubs for Newcomers&equo; (&pound;1.50 from the RYA) which lists over 400 clubs around the country which are open to new membership with a contact name of someone who knows the club well and could show you around. 
 By visiting two or three clubs in an area, you'll get a better idea of which one is best for your type of boating. 
 Catamaran sailing 
 Catamaran sailing is an exciting and fast growing side of the sport. 
 A dinghy sized catamaran has two thin hulls withe a sheet of canvas stretched inbetween for the crew to sit on. 
 They are high speed and fun, cutting through the water with little wake, and are raced and cruised all around the UK. 
 Most sailing clubs will have a few catamarans clustered together in one end of the dinghy park, but if you are keen to race one it is best to choose a club that has plenty of water space and specialises in a large multihull fleet. 
 Sailing and the disabled 
 Multihulls are also very useful for enabling the disabled to get afloat. 
 Diana Campbell, herself a keen sailor despite being confined to a wheelchair for the last 45 years, dreamt up the idea of a specially adapted dinghy sailing boat in the early seventies, and persuaded Roderick Macalpine-Downie to design it. 
 The first Challenger trimaran (three hulls) was produced in 1978 and there are now more than 120 in use throughout the UK. 
 The Challenger is ideal for disabled sailors because of its inherent stability. 
 In Diana's words it can provide &bquo;disabled people with freedom from the wheelchair they spend so much of their life in, making them as mobile as the next gust of wind&equo;. 
 Buying a craft 
 Buying a dinghy of your own is rather like buying a car. 
 You have to decide which type you want, whether to buy it new or second-hand, whether to buy a two/three-person or single-handed variety, one hull or two. 
 The choice of dinghy class will depend on what you want to do. 
 Boats start from as little as &pound;200 for a popular second-hand Mirror, right up to over &pound;5000 for a state-of-the-art racing &bquo;machine&equo;. 
 If you are keen to do some racing at a local club, the best thing to do is check out which classes have strong fleets in your area. 
 Although there is a widely-used handicap system for working out your place in relation to other types of boats, it is always more fun to battle against similar one-design boats, in which the only difference is the skill of the crew. 
 If you want a stable boat for the whole family to use and generally potter around in, you might choose a larger cruising dinghy. 
 Some come complete with a tent that fits over the boom to make a very snug overnight bedroom. 
 Whatever your preference, one of the most convenient places to look at all the different classes under one roof is Sailboat , the National Dinghy Show, which takes place at Crystal Palace Sports Centre on March 7&ndash;8, 1992. 
 Organised by the RYA and a collection of enthusiasts, it's Britain's oldest boat show and the world's largest all-dinghy exhibition. 
 What to wear 
 Don't go and buy all the kit until you know what sort of sailing you enjoy. 
 Most sailing courses can provide buoyancy aids and waterproof clothing, while a pair of trainers and shorts will get you by with a borrowed lifejacket while crewing in the summer. 
 Like all sports, when you get keen and decide to sail all year round, including the March &bquo;Frostbite&equo; Racing series, you will need some good kit &mdash; preferably wet or drysuit clothing &mdash; but there is not need to rush into it. 
 See what other people are wearing and what they recommend. 
 The sailing bug 
 The problem with dinghy sailing is that once the sailing bug is caught it grabs hold. 
 It catches you with the boathook and won't let go, seeping its salty tentacles into your very bones. 
 Some have sudden urges to take a year off and sail around the world &mdash; others sell house and home to sit in damp unstable quarters writing books. 
 Others pack up a tent, put the dinghy in the back of the car and disappear up to the west coast of Scotland with only a collection of Arthur Ransome books for company. 
 Be prepared for anything. 
 For details of RYA clubs and recognised centres and information on all aspects of sailing contact: Royal Yachting Association, RYA House, Romsey Road, Eastleigh, Hants. 
 Tel: 0703 629962.  
 Dinghy sailing has something to offer everyone regardless of age, fitness or depth of pocket 
 Nature watch 
 September 
 September lays a carpet of heather across the country and brings seabirds to our shores. 
 Richard Marpole is your guide 
 Wood mouse 
 The wood mouse (or long-tailed field mouse) apodemus sylvaticus  is around three inches long with a tail of about the same length. 
 In preparation for winter it will be busy putting on fat by eating all the wild fruit that it can find, and by making a nuisance of itself feeding on produce growing in the kitchen garden. 
 This animal does not hibernate, but stores food for the winter, which means that the damage it can cause is out of proportion to its diminutive size. 
 Ling 
 At this time of year the moors turn purple with the flowering of heathers. 
 The most common is ling calluna vulgaris . 
 In the past this plant would only have been found on the better drained slopes leading to our moorland plateaux, but because of man's interference in this environment, by digging drainage ditches and lowering the water table, the plant has been able to spread onto the plateaux themselves. 
 Nutrients are still at a premium here, so the plants form an association with a fungus pezzizella ericae  which enables the heather to have a higher nitrogen uptake and to be more resistant to elements of heavy metals found in the soil. 
 Bell heather 
 Bell heather erica cinerea  has brightly coloured flowers which are bigger than ling. 
 This type of heather also grows better in a much drier habitat.  
 Oystercatcher 
 The oystercatcher haematopus ostralegus  with its striking black and white plumage will also be making its journey south to winter grounds. 
 Predominantly a coastal bird, where it can usually been seen in large flocks from now until spring, in recent years it has spread inland to breed. 
 It follows rivers to find an area where there is suitable stony ground to make its nest. 
 Oystercatchers use their bright orange bills to open shellfish, but use two distinct types of opening techniques. 
 &bquo;Stabbers&equo; and attack the muscle which holds the shell closed and &bquo;hammerers&equo; simply bash a hole in the shell. 
 Young birds learn from their parents and will carry on the same method. 
 Badgers 
 Badger cub meles meles  born at the beginning of the year are leaving their family  setts  now and digging out their own homes. 
 It is a time when there are many fatalities on the roads as the inexperienced young try to dash across in the face of oncoming traffic. 
 Badgers' coats are also getting thicker as winter approaches and this put them at risk from diggers who sell their pelts to unscrupulous collectors. 
 Marsh lousewort 
 Flowering in September, the marsh lousewort pedicularis palustris  can be found in boggy and marshy areas and wet grassland at altitudes up to almost 3000ft. 
 The two-lipped flower has two pairs of small teeth on the upper lip. 
 When in fruit the lower part of the flower inflates and the ripe seed inside can rattle around, giving this plant the alternative name of &bquo;red rattle&equo;. 
 Great skua 
 The great skua stercorarius skua  is an exciting bird to see along our coasts at this time of year as it makes its way from its northern breeding ground to its wintering area. 
 This bird is a real pirate of the air. 
 It harasses other gulls until they drop their hard-won food and then swoops down to catch it &mdash; often in mid-air. 
 Lycoperdon perlatum 
 One of the first fungi to show is lycoperdon perlatum . 
 When ripe these pear-shaped fungi are filled with dust-like spores which pour out of the small central opening at the slightest movement. 
 Lycoperdon perlatum  are found growing in large groups on woodland soil and are edible when young.  
 Armchair update Books 
 A High an Lonely Place Jim Crumley 
 It is refreshing to read Jim Crumley's views. 
 He says what he believes to be true and even if one disagrees with him, his uncompromising stances are vastly preferable to some of the gobbledy-gook that comes from some sections of the countryside establishment or those who change their views from year to year. 
 In A High And Lonely Place  he makes a trenchant analysis of the despoilation of the Cairngorms. 
 He puts forward the radical solution that the range be given almost total protection as a wilderness area or area of land where the hand of man is less evident. 
 This would mean an end to skiing facilities, a marked drop in the development of tourism, the removal of car parks and access roads and a strick control of land owning. 
 While this might seem rash or unreal to some, it is in fact already an accepted idea, supported by such prophetic figures as John Muir, Fraser Darling and Percy Unna. 
 Whether it can now &mdash; or should be &mdash; applied to the Cairngorms is open to argument. 
 The book is divided into three parts. 
 Crumley starts by analysing the piecemeal approach to development and lack of adequate environmental control in the Cairngorms. 
 He then tells of his love for the hills and their wildlife, in a celebration reminiscent of Nan Shepherd's famous book The Living Mountain . 
 The book ends with a conclusion which points to his aforementioned radical solution. 
 Scorn will heaped on the book by people who cannot think of the countryside as anything other than a marketable resource, or those who think they are being environmentally perceptive because they call a gate a  peripherial  access point and a path a mountain access route. 
 Nevertheless, Crumley's is a starkly presented argument which should be read and studied alongside the barrage of soulless technical documentation already written on this emotive subject. 
 A High and Lonely Place: The Sanctuary and Plight of the Cairngorms by Jim Crumley. 
 Jonathan Cape. 
 &pound;14.99. 
 Hardback. 157 pages.  
 Colour photographs . 
  Rennie McOwan  
 Bartholomew Walk Edinburgh &amp; the Pentlands 
 This handy sized guide is an ideal companion for walkers wanting to explore this part of Scotland. 
 It is the 33rd in the series of Bartholomew walking guides. 
 Each of the 40 walks selected, which range from one mile to eight miles long, are illustrated with a simple map and easy to follow step by step instructions. 
 There is a summary of the walks and a useful fact file with information about the length of the walk, the height climbed, how easy or difficult the walk is and whether there are public conveniences or public transport. 
 The 14 page introduction gives a good background to the history of the area, which really makes you want to get out there. 
 This well written, concise guide is presented in a very easy to use A5 ring bound format. 
 Walk Edinburgh and the Pentlands by Richard Hallewell. 
 Bartholomew. &pound;4.99.  
 Paperback. 64 pages. 
 Black and white with maps . 
  Henry Druce  
 British White Water 
 Few canoeists carry guidebooks with them, for obvious reasons, but this one certainly won't be left behind in the car. 
 Terry Storry's British White Water  is the first canoeing guide to comprehensively cover the classic white water rivers of England, Scotland and Wales. 
 He writes clearly and lightheartedly about the 100 best rivers and gives his expert advice on how to navigate their reaches. 
 Each detailed river description is headed with a brief but exacting summary which helps in making a quick decision about which river to tackle next. 
 For a more leisurely read he has included sections on hydrology and the debate on access to rivers. 
 British White Water by Terry Storry.  Constable &pound;10.95.Paperback.  332 pages with black and white photographs, maps and illustrations . 
  Erica Anderson  
 Windsurfing in a week 
 I'm sure that if I'd had this excellent book when learning to windsurf my progress would have been much faster. 
 The book is divided into seven chapters/days, which guide you on from novice to competent windsurfer, with the help of written explanations and step by step photos and diagrams. 
 The opening chapter gives an in-depth and simple to understand account of all you need to know before taking to the water. 
 Royal Yachting Association (RYA) trainer Hart sets out to familiarise his reader with the equipment, rigging and de-rigging techniques and how to recognise a good sailing location. 
 Subsequent chapters are devoted to mastering various techniques and manoeuvres. 
 Goals are set and everything you need to know to reach those goals, from where to position your feet and hands to dealing with wind conditions, is clearly explained. 
 The book assumes the role of the most patient instructor. 
 It gives clear detailed instructions, answers queries and suggests ways to improve your technique. 
 Hart's approach is down to earth and realistic and the tone throughout is overwhelmingly encouraging. 
 The author acknowledges that you will have difficulties but then suggests and explains what you can do to prevent them. 
 Whether you choose to set yourself the task of becoming an accomplished windsurfer within seven days or opt to learn the sport at a more leisurely pace, Windsurfing in a week  will prove as invaluable a companion as your buoyancy aid. 
 Windsurfing in a week by Peter Hart. 
 Hodder and Stoughton. &pound;4.99. Paperback.  122 pages with colour photographs and illustrations . 
  Vanessa Thompson   
 Buyers Guide 
 Pioneer venture bike from Raleigh 
 This hybrid bike from Raleigh combines popular mountain and road bike features making it perfectly suited for people who like mountain bikes but have no intention of going near a mountain. 
 The Pioneer is different from a mountain bike in that it has a less rugged frame and thinner wheels and tyres. 
 This makes it well suited to road use while it is still sturdy enough to cope with bumpy paths and tracks. 
 The Aris Powergrip gears are excellent. 
 There's a generous 21 speed selection to ensure you always find the right gear to suit the terrain. 
 I found them very easy to use &mdash; you simply twist the grips on the handlebars and the indexed gears click into place. 
 I used the bike extensively around London and it was perfectly suited to dealing the city's often poor roads. 
 The bike's many gears, light frame and thinnish tyres also make it highly suitable for cycle touring, as I found out on a weekend's cycling trip in Normandy. 
 Most of the people I went with took mountain bikes and they envied me the Pioneer as I sped along with far less effort that they had to use. 
 The one minor gripe I have is that the Pioneer doesn't have mudguards. 
 Mountain bikes don't have guards because if you're using them on wet and muddy terrain you don't want to constantly have to stop to unclog the wheels. 
 At the Pioneer is designed for road or light off road use this wouldn't be a problem. 
 The bike gave good all around performance and at &pound;250 is excellent value for money. 
 Contact: Raleigh Industries Ltd, Triumph Road, Nottingham NG7 2DD. 
 Tel: 0602 420202 Henry Druce 
 Berghaus sultra overtrousers 
 Design: lightweight breathable and windproof overtrousers. 
 The trousers have elasticated waist and bottoms and the waist also has an adjustable toggled drawcord. 
 Full length zips covered with press studded storm flaps run down the side of each leg. 
 Material: polyester shell bonded to Goretex, polyester lining Size: extra small &mdash; extra large Colour: assorted colourways Price: &pound;129.95 Contact: Berghaus Limited, 34 Dean Street, Newcastle Upon Tyne NE1 1PG. 
 Tel: 091 232 3561  
 Multi purpose tube from bivvy bug 
 The Tube is an interesting piece of equipment which can be used for at least six different purposes. 
 It converts into an individual or group survival bag bid enough for eight people, a two person high or low profile tent, an emergency cape and a wind break. 
 It is a 10ft long round tube make from PU coated nylon. 
 It opens at both ends and fastens with drawcords. 
 It has five small lightweight poles, eight shockcorded guylines and eight small pegs. 
 Small elastic loops, toggles and ring plate eyelets are attached to the outside of the tube. 
 Clips on each end of the guylines pass through the eyelets to double-up or shorten the guyline so that they can be used in a variety of different ways. 
 Single poles are used at either end to convert the Tube into a high profile bivi tent. 
 However, the high profile design is not very stable in strong winds &mdash; I preferred the lower profile design even though you don't get as much headroom. 
 One problem when using the Tube as a tent is that the lightweight alloy poles have a tendency to bend at the joints when under strong pressure. 
 The Tube is also prone to suffer from condensation due to its shape. 
 This can't really be avoided but can be reduced by letting in as much ventilation as possible. 
 However the Tube is not designed as anything more than a temporary tent so it shouldn't be expected to give normal tent performance. 
 The Tube is definitely a worthwhile inclusion among your safety and survival equipment. 
 It comes with taped seams for &pound;89.50 or untaped seams for &pound;79.50. 
 It weighs only 2 lbs 10oz and is available by mail order. 
 Contact: Bivvy Bug, Boscarhyn, Syra Close, St Kew, Highway, Bodmin, Cornwall PL30 3ED. 
 Tel: 0208 84649 Dave Weatherley 
 Delesman Delux Kiddykarrier 
 Design: lightweight self standing carrier with adjustable seat, padded frame and hip belt. 
 Material: nylon/aluminium Colour: sage or teal Price: &pound;45.99 Contact: Dalesman International Limited, Dalesman House, Marathon Place, Moss Side Ind Estate, Leyland, Lancs. 
 Tel: 0772 453918 
 Panasonic Super Mini Compact Camera 
 Design: compact, lightweight cameral with built-in flash unit and a 34mm lens Features: The C625AF camera has five flash modes with two these modes designed to reduce the red eye effect. 
 The lens is protected by a scratchproof UV filter. 
 The camera has an auto focus and a programmed shutter. 
 It also comes with a free camera case. 
 Weight: 5.6oz Price: &pound;99.95 Contact: Panasonic Business Systems, Panasonic House, Willoughby Road, Bracknell, Berkshire RG124FP. 
 Tel: 0344 853552.  
 Gear test 
 Best selling Leather boots 
 What sets some boots above the rest? 
 We took ten of the top trekkers through their paces 
 Daisy Roots Veta V 
 The first pair of real hiking boots I ever had were Daisy Roots and I've always been impressed by their comfort. 
 They've come a long way since those days though &mdash; the soles of that pair were completely worn through after 400 miles walking in the Andes so that I ended up walking in my socks! 
 In spite of this I still have fond memories of them as they were such a soft, comfortable pair of boots from day one. 
 There's not much chance of wearing through the Vibram soles of these Veta V Daisy Roots though. 
 After several hundred miles they are as good as new with a reassuring grip in most conditions. 
 My one reservation concerns their performance on wet rock &mdash; however I've never found a sole that really grips well on it. 
 The uppers, made of one piece calf leather with leather bellows, well padded tongue and collar, provided the comfort I remembered from the first day. 
 I liked the soft Cambrelle lining which incorporates the new Molto pren (MTP) interliner &mdash; it cushioned my feet without making the boots too hot or sweaty on a warm day. 
 I found the ankle cuff the right height and shape to provide support without restricting my movement. 
 It is slightly cut away at the rear and so doesn't put pressure on the Achilles tendon. 
 At the end of this test I can find no failings in the manufacture or materials of the Veta V. Despite all the use I've made of them they are as good as new. 
 They are also extremely comfortable and competitively prices with other leather boots on the market. 
 Price: &pound;69.95 Material: one piece calf leather upper, Vibram dual density sole and Cambrelle lining Sizes: 36&ndash;47 Contact: Daisy Roots, Westfield Trading Estate, Midsomer Norton, Bath BA34XD. 
 Tel: 0761 417777. 
  John Harrison  
 db Mountainsport Bowfell boots 
 These boots are a fine, solidly made pair of traditional walking boots. 
 They have stiff calf leather outers, a leather lining and the collar is comfortably padded. 
 There's a removable shaped insole with a Cambrelle top to wick moisture away from the foot. 
 And the full bellows tongue is topped with Cambrelle covered padding. 
 When I first put the boots on I found them surprisingly stiff &mdash; given this solid feel I wondered why there wasn't a traditional square cut heel on what's quite a heavily cleated waterproof sole. 
 Many prefer this for hill safety. 
 Once I felt comfortable in them I wore them on a couple of long section of the Cotswold Way and they fared well. 
 And when I was lucky enough to enjoy some rare hot weather my feet stayed as cool as I could have expected. 
 Later in the test on very wet days they performed well and gave good support and grip on grassy hillsides and rough stony paths. 
 Price: &pound;71.99 Material: Calf leather, Skywalk sole, leather/Cambrelle lining Sizes: 38&ndash;47 Contact: db Mountainsport, PO Box 30, 60 Highgate, Kendal LA9 4UT. 
 Tel: 0539 733842. 
  Catherine Moore  
 Zamberlan Trek Lite 
 During the past seven years I've worn fabric and plastic boots so my feet needed some encouragement to weather leather again. 
 After five minutes all those memories of breaking in came flooding back. 
 However, the boots soon moulded themselves to my feet. 
 The Trek Lite is a very well constructed lightweight boot which has an all-in-one upper and is well made with strong stitching. 
 It is one of Zamberlan's original lightweight and best selling boots.  
 The Trek Lite use a premium grade Hydrobloc leather which absorbs very little water. 
 I used them on many rainy days, and never once suffered from wet feet. 
 The boots have a Vibram dual density sole that gave me all the grip and comfort I needed over steep wet grass and rough ground. 
 The foot and ankle were also well supported inside the boot. 
 The boot is lined with soft Cambrelle in the front half while the heel areas has a soft leather lining. 
 I liked the lacing design. 
 With only four D ring eyelets and three top hooks on each side, this makes the boot easier to slip on and off. 
 Although primarily a three season walking boot, I would use the boots during the winter. 
 The sole of the boot is strong enough to attach articulated crampons. 
 Price: &pound;95 Material: Hydrobloc leather, Vibram dual density sole, Cambrelle/leather lining Sizes: 35&ndash;48 Contact: Europa Mountain Sport, Ann Street, Kendal, Cumbria LA9 6AB. 
 Tel: 0539 724740  Malcolm Anderson  
 GT Hawkins Dalesman 
 On my first walk testing the Dalesman boot along a stretch of the Pembrokeshire Coastal Path, I developed blisters by the end of the day. 
 I felt the boots were rather narrow and inflexible. 
 But after the initial blisters and a bit of breaking in, I've been fairly impressed with these boots. 
 A new Skywalk sole with an environmentally-friendly cleat pattern gives a good grip even on slippery rocks. 
 And extra adhesion is given by the positive heel step, which is quite distinct. 
 The one piece upper has kept my feet dry even when walking through peat bogs. 
 The leather also still looks good, although I've notices it wearing away at the top of the ankle seam. 
 The boots are lined with Cambrelle throughout which effectively wicks away any excessive perspiration. 
 The removable sole is fairly thin and when I took it out I noticed that several small staples protrude quite sharply through the inner lining, which could become a problem after more use. 
 Although these aren't as stylish as more expensive models they are good basic boots which will keep your feet comfortable and dry &mdash; without breaking the bank. 
 Price: &pound;54 Material: Water resistant leather, techniflex inner sole and Skywalk sole. 
 Cambrelle lining throughout Sizes: 37&ndash;46 Contact: G T Hawkins Limited, Overstone Road, Northampton NN1 3JJ. 
 Tel: 0604 32293. 
 Heather Barrett 
 Vango Andalo 
 The Andalo is a well constructed boot designed for the wider British foot, which gave me many miles of trouble-free walking. 
 The upper is made from a one piece Pro-Aquaguard calf leather which has a low cutaway padded cuff around the ankle to reduce pressure on the Achilles tendon. 
 The Andalo is made with a medium stiff Torsion Flex 3 midsole which gives rigidity and strength without being too inflexible like some heavier leather boots. 
 The inside of the boot is lined with Cambrelle and has a removable high density footbed &mdash; this combination added extra comfort when I was pounding over rough and stony ground. 
 Made into the lower part of the boot is a special &bquo;water shed&equo; membrane which successfully helped keep my feet dry. 
 The double density Skywalk sole gives good all-around grip on most types of surface. 
 Throughout the three month test I didn't have any trouble with my feet apart from a few blisters after first wearing them. 
 Price: &pound;69.90 Material: Pro-Aquaguard treated calf leather, Cima &bquo;Torsion Flex&equo; 3, medium still midsole, Skywalk double density sole. 
 Cambrelle lined. 
 Sizes: 37&ndash;46 Contact: Vango, 70 East Hamilton Street, Ladyburn, Greenock PA15 2UB. 
 Tel: 0475 44122. 
  Pat Weatherley  
 Brasher Hillmaster 
 The Brasher Hillmaster is a well established boot which has proved its suitability for three season walking. 
 Designed in conjunction with Olympic gold medallist runner Chris Brasher, these boots are extremely lightweight and comfortable from the moment you first slip them on. 
 In fact they needed little breaking in and after only a couple of long walks they were very comfortable indeed. 
 Comfortable feet are ensured by a proofed leather upper which is much softer than most other lightweight boots, while a shock-absorbing wedge in midsole cushions every step. 
 A deep cutaway padded ankle cuff also improves comfort although the low cut gives limited support. 
 I was a little disappointed by the grip even on wet and damp rock by the rubber-cleated and stud-pattern sole. 
 However I found they performed excellently on steep and wet grass. 
 On my second outing with the boots I was trying to assess how watertight they were as it was raining heavily. 
 After two hours with dry feet I stepped into a bog up to my knees &mdash; end of test. 
 Since then I have had no problems with wet feet though. 
 Price: &pound;79.99 Material: Proofed leather upper, rubber cleated and stud-pattern outsole with a microcellular midsole. 
 Nylon lining. 
 Sizes: 3&ndash;13 Contact: Brasher Boots, c/o Reebok UK Ltd, Moor Lane Mill, Lancaster LA1 1GF. 
 Tel: 0524 580100. 
  Dave Weatherley   
 Daisy Roots Veta V: no failings in design &mdash; support without restriction 
 db Mountainsport Bowfell: traditional walking boots with a solid feel 
 Zamberlan Trek Lite: comfortable, supportive and good in the wet 
 Vango Andalo: strong yet flexible, and comfortable over rough terrain 
 Hawkins Dalesman: performed well after breaking in 
 Brasher Hillmaster: no problems with wet feet 
 High Country Brecon 
 My first outing in these tough looking boots was three miles in good weather. 
 For the first mile they were brilliant, very comfortable, but then the Big Bs struck. 
 Dreaded blisters on the back of both my heels. 
 Undaunted I was sure it would be worth the effort of breaking them in &mdash; and it was. 
 A few more short-ish walks and I had the boots fully under control. 
 In fact the leather is softer than in many boots on the market and so the rest of the breaking in was painless. 
 The Brecons have a one-piece upper and therefore fewer seams to let in water. 
 The lightly-padded bellows tongue and Cambrelle lining stopped any water seeping in under the laces. 
 In retrospect I would not choose a boot with such a low-cut ankle again. 
 The padded collar is comfortable enough and they look more like a tough shoe than a walking boot &mdash; designed, I suspect, to appeal more to women. 
 Personally though I don't mind hefty boots and would prefer to feel the greater support around my ankles offered by other boots in the High Country range. 
 Otherwise I had no complaints. 
 The Vibram soles gave plenty of grip, wet and dry, and the boots have become comfortable friends for distance walking over reasonable terrain. 
 Price: &pound;59.95 Material: water repellent leather, Vibram sole, Cambrelle lining Sizes: 3&ndash;12, 36&ndash;47 Contact: Dalesman International Ltd, 29 Marathon Place, Moss Side Ind Est, Leyland, Lancs PR5 3QN. 
 Tel: 0772 453918. 
  Laura McCaffrey  
 S-L Attak &mdash; Performance Flex 
 The S-L Attak is a high quality boot from its Hydro-Stop 12 calf leather to the Trionic sole. 
 Even so I did not expect my feet to be trouble-free after using them for the first time on a full day's hiking in the Purbeck Hills. 
 What impressed me most was the support the boot gave &mdash; almost like a ski boot but with no compromise of movement or sensation of cramping. 
 The Hydro-Stop leather, designed to improve breathability, was very effective &mdash; my feet remained dry and not too hot despite serious drenchings. 
 Other features include the attachment design for the Yeti Attak Gaiter and Cambrelle inner lining. 
 Price: &pound;99.95 Material: Hydro-Stop 12 calf leather, Cambrelle lining, Performance Flex Nylon midsole Sizes: 36&ndash;48 Contact: Berghaus, 34 Dean Street, Newcastle upon Tyne NE1 1PG. 
 Tel: 091 232 3561  Simon Abbott  
 MOAC Lightranger 
 The MOAC Lightranger certainly lives up to name being a lightweight boot but without sacrificing weight for durability. 
 The boots were very comfortable from new even when wearing a single pair of walking socks. 
 The uppers are made from durable leather with a padded leather ankle support. 
 The lining is calf leather and there is a comfortable insole of shaped close cell foam. 
 The bellows tongue is unpadded. 
 I was impressed by the good adhesion and grip of the Vibram soles, performing well even in wet and slippery conditions. 
 The boots also showed high water resistance. 
 I soon became a fan of these boots which remained comfortable and performed well. 
 Price: &pound;69.96 Material: leather upper, Vibram sole, top grade calf leather lining Sizes: 36&ndash;47 Contact: Mountaineering Activities, MOAC House, Demmings Road Ind Est, Cheadle, Cheshire SK8 2PE. 
 Tel: 061 428 1178. 
  James Harrison  
 Black's Paterno Boot 
 Black's Paterno is a traditional sturdy walking boot which provides the foot with a high level of firm support. 
 In the early stages the rigidity of the boots did put pressure on the front of my ankles, making them uncomfortable to wear. 
 However with time this subsided and never once have the boots given my blisters. 
 The boots are constructed using a solid one-piece leather upper with padding around the ankle collar and on the suede bellows tongue. 
 The boots are suede-lined and have a thin contoured footbed. 
 They lace using four sets of D-rings and three sets of hooks. 
 The boots served me well in wet weather doing an admirable job in keeping my feet dry, but on some of the hotter days this year I did find that my feet got unpleasantly hot and sweaty. 
 These are the sort of boots I would prefer to use for autumn and winter walking when a tough and study boot is required. 
 The Skywalk sole adds to the general solidity of the boots and gives good grip even in wet conditions. 
 All in all these boots are tough and overall good performers. 
 Price: &pound;59.99 Material: pu coated leather, Skywalk dual intensity blakesewn sole, suede lining Sizes: women's 37&ndash;40, men's 40&ndash;47 Contact: Black's Camping and Leisure, Unit 3, Stephenson Ind Est, Washington, Tyne and Wear NE37 3HR. 
 Tel: 091 417 8800. 
  Vanessa Thompson   
 High Country Brecon: soft but tough leather with good grip in the wet 
 S-L Attak: impressive support without compromise of movement 
 Black's Paterno: traditional support 
 MOAC Lightranger: lightweight but still tough and water resistant 
 Gear Guide 
 Sleeping bags 
 Nights of restful slumber or drawn-out agony can depend on your sleeping bag. 
 We help you choose wisely. 
 A comfortable sleeping bag provides the means to re-charge your batteries at the end of a long day so it's important to ensure you have the right one for the job. 
 A bag which is too hot can be as uncomfortable as one which is too cold and while you can always add extra clothing when the temperature drops, it isn't necessarily convenient or desirable. 
 Season Ratings This is the most common way of expressing the performance of a sleeping bag. 
 The scale goes from 1 to 5 with 1 being summer, 2 late spring, summer and early autumn, 3 spring, summer and autumn, 4 all year around, and 5 expedition. 
 The ratings are only approximate and even where manufacturers quote a temperature as &bquo;good down to&hellip;&equo; these refer only to valley performances so camping at higher levels will require a warmer bag. 
 As a rough guide for the UK you can reckon on adding an extra season rating if you intend to use the bag at high level. 
 Construction If the filling distinguishes between good and poor sleeping bags, the way they're put together is the other main determining factor. 
 Synthetic sleeping bags are insulated with layers of insulating wadding. 
 If just a single layer is used it will be stitched through to the outer shell of the bag at intervals and sometimes stitched right through to the lining on cheaper bags. 
 The obvious disadvantage here is the possibility of cold spots along the stitching and such bags tend only to be good for one or two season use. 
 Heavier weight synthetics tend to use a double layer of wadding with the outer layer quilted to the shell and the inner to the lining. 
 The stitch lines are offset to prevent cold spots occurring. 
 Down-filled bags use a system of internal baffles at intervals between the inner and outer shells to keep the down evenly dispersed and maintain loft. 
 Because it's a loose filling there can be problems with it shifting in a poorly designed bag. 
 The very best quality bags are made not with single large pieces of fabric for each side of the shell but in smaller strips sewing shell and baffle together. 
 This eliminates stitch lines along the outside. 
 Down bags have inner and outer shells differentially cut &mdash; in other words the inner shell is smaller than the outer and this again ensures the filling achieves maximum loft for better performance. 
 Fillings Not so long ago, the dividing line between quality and budget seemed to fall neatly between natural and synthetic fillings. 
 But the bulky fillings of ten years ago are now for the budget bags only with a new generation of low-bulk polyester waddings now available which turn in much better all-round performance than down. 
 Durability is still a point of concern because most tend to lose a certain amount of loft with extended use. 
 Despite the recent tremendous advances in synthetic fillings goose or duck down is still favoured by those after good performance, light weight and small pack size. 
 Down itself comes from the breasts of birds as a by-product &mdash; they're farmed mainly in China for food. 
 A down bag will suffer no damage if left compressed for a long time &mdash; a synthetic-filled one almost certainly will and this is a serious disadvantage. 
 Some sleeping bags are made from fibrepile which is not a filling as such. 
 The fibrepile is either used as a liner to uprate existing sleeping bags or on its own as single or double layer bags. 
 They're particularly useful where a layer system can be tailored to the individual's needs and they are very tough-wearing. 
 Size Some sleeping bags are available in a choice of sizes but sadly not enough manufacturers provide the choice because of the costs of production. 
 As with the shape of the bag, size plays an important role in efficiency. 
 Too small and you're likely to compress the filling and lose loft, too large and the bellows action of air as you move about in the bag will ensure you never keep a nice layer of still warm air around you, essential to keep you cosy. 
 Always try a bag for size before you buy it. 
 Apart from checking the length make sure you can do the hood up fully without pulling the bag tightly over your feet &mdash; check for width at the knees, hips and shoulders in particular. 
 Shape The most efficient sleeping bag would be one which followed the contours of your own body perfectly. 
 But the trouble is it would feel pretty uncomfortable trussed up like that. 
 The compromise shapes manufacturers use try to give the best insulation without restricting movement unduly &mdash; most lightweight bags are either mummy shaped or tapered. 
 Rectangular bags sold as family camping and caravanning bags are fine for summer camping but no use for cold conditions. 
 Foot A sleeping bag should have some means of accommodating feet which after all can't lie flat. 
 The most common way of doing this is to put in a box-shaped insert at the bottom of the bag. 
 The alternative is to simply stitch across the bottom of the sleeping bag  &bquo;tube&equo; but to make the bottom seam vertical rather than horizontal, producing a fish-tail shape. 
 Whatever sort you have, make sure there's enough room for your feet without compressing any of the filling within the bag. 
 Hood For one or two season use you can get by quite comfortably in a sleeping bag without a hood. 
 But in colder weather a hood makes a lot of difference. 
 The most basic bags have a curved flap at the top with a drawcord running around the circumference. 
 This is alright but it does tend to bunch up a lot when it's pulled in close to the face. 
 The best hoods are shaped so that when they're pulled in there's less material to bunch up which means a closer and more comfortable fit around your head. 
 Linings Most lightweight sleeping bags are made of the same shell material inside and out. 
 They can feel cold at first but they do warm up quickly and in warmer conditions the modern micro-fibre fabrics commonly used don't feel sticky in the way that older nylon linings did. 
 Some bags are available with cotton or polycotton linings and these are more comfortable but they weigh more. 
 Zips There are the most common way of fastening sleeping bags. 
 Some manufacturers give a choice so you can have a bag without a zip, with a short length zip or with one which runs the full length of the bag. 
 For the purists a bag without a zip is going to be the most efficient at keeping warmth in and will always be lighter than the same bag with a zip. 
 But it can be difficult to get in and out of and there may be times when it's too warm &mdash; then what do you do? 
 A short zip is a compromise but most bags now come with a full length zip, generally with a double puller which enables you to open it up from the top or bottom to allow air to ventilate in warmer weather. 
 Many full-length zip bags are available in left and right hand versions enabling two to be zipped together. 
 And it is important to make sure that zips have a generous baffle behind them to prevent cold spots. 
 Cheaper bags often have small thin baffles which can flatten away from the zip or none at all. 
 Some good quality bags also have an anti-snag strip sewn between the zip and the baffle to prevent the fabric itself becoming caught in the zip. 
 Damp This is often a problem with sleeping bags. 
 While most bags have stuff sacks very few can be considered waterproof, so always pack your sleeping bag in its stuff sack inside a separate plastic bag. 
 Sleeping bags can become damp through normal use. 
 The human body produces something like two litres of water vapour in an average night and in cold conditions this can condense inside the filling. 
 Extreme cases on high altitude expeditions have ended up with sleeping bags frozen solid! 
 It's important to air your bag thoroughly whenever possible. 
 Damp affects down particularly badly causing the fluffy tendrils to clog together and lose the ability to insulate. 
 Some bags use a silicone treated down to enable them to resist damp. 
 Even if yours doesn't you can get the same effect by treating it with Nikwax TX 10 which you can use in the washing machine. 
 Synthetic bags maintain their insulation even when wet and they dry out much more quickly than the down bags. 
 Glossary 
 Fillings Bonded polyester: polyester fibre, coated with resin and bonded flat. 
 Dacron Hollofil: bonded polyester, each fibre has a hollow core trapping still air and aiding warmth. 
 Dacron Thermoline: solid structure polyester fibre bonded into a thin sheet. 
 Hollowfibre: hollow core polyester. 
 Hi-loft: hollowfibre polyester, continuous filament. 
 Isodry: slimline bonded polyester with a high warmth-thickness ratio. 
 Neidhart: micro-fine high thermal. 
 Polar-Guard: hollowfibre polyester, continuous filament. 
 Quallofil: bonded hollowfibre. 
 Superloft: continuous filament polyester. 
 Thinsulate fleece: heat reflective fleece. 
 Materials Caravan Technology: fine weave lightweight nylon. 
 Gore-Tex: microporous membrane, glued to various fabrics making them waterproof and breathable. 
 Pertex: fine lightweight nylon. 
 Taffeta nylon: lightweight nylon. 
 Trilobal: lightweight nylon with a shiny finish. 
 Vesa Tec: densely woven, highly breathable superfine fibres. 
 Construction Box wall: filling held in position via &bquo;boxes&equo; between the outer and inner. 
 Off-set stitched: method of stitching used on bags with more than one layer of filling. 
 Stitching does not pass straight through the layers but is &bquo;offset&equo;. 
 Shingle: sections of filling overlap each other for extra warmth. 
 Slant wall: filling is in slanted sections giving more even distribution. 
 Through stitched: stitching travels through all layers of the bag. 
 V-Baffle: filling is in a series of overlapping tubes &mdash; bags tend to be warmer as more filling can be used. 
 Foot construction Box: bags have a raised square end. 
 Elephant's foot: raised circular foot, usually with a special circle inset section. 
 Fishtail: tapered foot section. 
 Flat: straightforward flat squared end, sometimes with a zip across bottom. 
 Shaped: Caravan's shaped feet take basic elephant's foot without insert. 
 Key to specifications 
 Price: A typical selling price including VAT to the nearest pound. 
 This is a guide price only. 
 Ctry: Country of origin. 
 Au-Austria, Ch-China, FE-Far East, F-France, HK-Hong Kong, Is-Israel, J-Japan, K-Korea, N-Norway, S-Spain, SW-Sweden, T-Taiwan. 
 Length: The length of the sleeping bag in feet and inches. 
 Width: The width of the bag in inches. 
 Where two figures are shown this is the chest width and foot width. 
 PCKD size: The packed size of the sleeping bag in inches. 
 WGT: The weight of the bag in pounds and ounces. 
 Filling: The type of filling: BP-Bonded Polyester, D-Down, DD-Duck Down, DH-Dacron Hollofil, DT-Dacron Thermoline, DF-Down/Feather, F-Feather, FD-Feather/Down, FP-Fibre Pile, GS-Goose Down, GLT-Thermal Fibre, HF-Hollowfibre, Hi-Hi-Loft, Ho-Hollofil, In-Insul 200, Is-Isodry, Mi-Microsoft, Ne-Neidhart, Nov-Novaloft, PoG-Polarguard, Py-Polyester, PyF-Polyester Fibre, Qu-Quallofil, SD-Superdown, SHF-Siliconised Hollowfibre, SL-Superloft, SDP-SP27, Su-Superloft thermal fibre, TF-Thermoflect, Th-Thinsulate Fleece, TP-Thermal Polyester, W-Wool. 
 Material: The type of material used for the outer and inner cover of the bag: AluN-Alu coated nylon, BS-Balloon Silk, BTr-Brushed Tricot Flannel, C-Cotton, CC-Cotton Cambric, Cl-Caralight Nylon, CP-Cotton Polymide, Ct-Caratex (Caravan Fibre), FP-Fibre Pile, Go-Goretex, Fl-Fleece, M-Microlight Microfibre, N-Nylon, N219d-Nylon 219 Denier etc. 
 NV-Nylon/Viscose, PC Polycotton, Per-Pertex, PM-Polymide, Pno-Polynosic, PS-Parachute silk, Py-Polyester, Rp-Ripstop, T-Trinyl (Polyester cotton/nylon), Tf-Taffeta Nylon, TrL-Trilobal, Ve-Versa Tec, VP-Viscose Polymide. 
 Suit: Which season the bag is suitable for. 
 A number shows how many seasons. 
 FC-Family camping for caravans etc. 
 E-Expedition. 
 Const: The type of construction: BW-Box wall, DB-Double bag, D-Diamond Quilted, DL-Double layer, OS-Offset stitched, OSA-Offset stitched with Thermoflect (aluminised reflective barrier), RB-Radiant Barrier, RS-Random stitched, Sh-Shingle, SW-Slant wall, TS-Through stitched, VB-V Baffle. 
 Foot Const: B-Box, E-Elephant's foot, F-Fishtail, Fl-Flat, Sh-Shaped  
 Market roundup 
 Waterproofers 
 There's plenty of products to help you beat the leaks and protect your outdoor gear 
 Nikwax waterproofing wax 
 A colourless non-softening wax giving abrasion-resistant waterproof coating to leather boots. 
 Price: 3.6fl oz/102ml &mdash; &pound;1.60; 6.3fl oz/180ml &mdash; &pound;2.30; 4.4lbs/2kg &mdash; &pound;15.80. 
 Liquid Nikwax 
 A non-oily liquid wax which cleans as it waterproofs. 
 Nikwax penetrates deeply giving a natural sheen to leather equipment and increases suppleness in the leather. 
 Price: 4.4fl oz/125ml &mdash; &pound;1.85; 17.6fl oz/500ml &mdash; &pound;4.40 
 Nikwax non-tack wax 
 A polymer-reinforced wax for reproofing waxed cotton making it water repellent and hardwearing. 
 Price: 6.3fl oz/180ml &mdash; &pound;2.90 
 Texnik spray-on fabric re-proofer 
 This non-aerosol spray restores water-repellency to the polyurethane-coated nylon of outer clothing, rucksacks, tents and all extreme-use equipment. 
 Price: 10.6fl. oz/300ml &mdash; &pound;4; 17.6fl. oz. /500ml &mdash; &pound;5.20 Nikwax Tx.10 wash-in waterproofing TX.10 waterproofs all natural and synthetic fabrics and fillings in the washing machine. 
 Once treated fabric will be quicker drying, less absorbent and better insulated. 
 Price: 10.6fl. oz/300ml &mdash; &pound;3.75; 35.2fl. oz/1 litre &mdash; &pound;7.50. 
 Contact: Nikwax Durgates, Wadhurst, East Sussex TN5 6DF. 
 Tel: 0892 88 3855. 
 Granger's G-Wax 
 A mix of Beeswax and other waxes which waterproofs and protects leather. 
 Also available in cream form for restoring and conditioning hard or new leather without over-softening it. 
 G-Wax can be polished to a shine. 
 Price: 1.13ft. oz/35g &mdash; &pound;1.07; 2.09oz/82g &mdash; &pound;1.41; 4.9oz/140g &mdash; &pound;2.15. 
 Granger's Fabsil 
 A colourless spray containing silicone and other rainproofing agents for waterproofing cotton, nylon and polyester. 
 Designed for use on tents and awnings, raincoats and anoraks. 
 Price: 14.1fl oz/400ml aerosol &mdash; &pound;2.68; 21.2fl. oz/600ml aerosol &mdash; &pound;3.81; 17.6fl oz/500ml non-aerosol &mdash; &pound;4.09. 
 Granger's Super-Pel 
 Waterproofs cotton, wool or nylon items in the washing machine. 
 Suitable for quilted garments and sleeping bags. 
 Price: 3.5fl. oz/100ml &mdash; &pound;2.57; 12.36fl oz/350ml &mdash; &pound;4.69. 
 Granger's Wax cotton dressing 
 A high quality wax for waterproofing and protecting cotton without affecting its colour. 
 come in solid or spray forms. 
 The solid wax gives heavier protection. 
 Price: 6.3 oz/180g tin &mdash; &pound;2.37; 7.04fl. oz/125ml aerosol &mdash; &pound;2.45; 4.4fl oz/200ml &mdash; &pound;2.50. 
 Granger's Mapdry 
 A spray-on treatment which makes paper and cloth maps water-repellent and to some degree oil-repellent. 
 Available in aerosol and non-aerosol sprays. 
 Price: 7.04fl. oz/200ml aerosol &mdash; &pound;3.08; 4.4fl oz/125ml non-aerosol &mdash; &pound;2.96. 
 Granger's G-Sport 
 This spray-on waterproof contains a high percentage of silicone and is suitable for use on fabric, suede and leather. 
 Available in aerosol and non-aerosol sprays. 
 Price: 7.04fl. oz/200ml aerosol &mdash; &pound;3.10; 4.4fl. oz/125m; non-aerosol &mdash; &pound;2.89. 
 Granger's Superpruf 
 Spray-on Superpruf waterproofs laminated fabrics without destroying breathability. 
 Water and oil are repelled while sweat escapes. 
 Approved by W.L. Gore. 
 Price: 7.04fl. oz/200ml aerosol &mdash; &pound;3.18; 4.4fl. oz/125ml non-aerosol &mdash; &pound;3.03. 
 Contact: Granger's Ltd, Grange Close, Clover Nook Industrial Park, South Normanton, Derbyshire DE55 4QT. 
 Tel: 0733 521521. 
 Mars Oil Original Leather Dressing 
 Free from acids, resins or solvents this natural concentrated dressing restores, preserves and waterproofs all leather articles. 
 It soaks in completely leaving a dry feel to the surface. 
 For restoring old leather or for breaking in new boots. 
 It cannot be used on suede or synthetic materials. 
 The oil comes complete with brush. 
 Price: 50ml &mdash; &pound;1.50; 125ml &mdash; &pound;2.25; 500ml &mdash; &pound;4.75. 
 Mars liquid was leather conditioner 
 This liquid cleans, conditions and waterproofs all kinds of leather articles from shoes to jackets and can be used on lightweight and pale coloured leather. 
 It can used with waterproofing wax and polish for extra protection. 
 Price: 120ml &mdash; &pound;2.25. 
 Mars leather wax 
 A wax treatment for waterproofing modern lightweight and waterproof leather walking boots. 
 The wax penetrates the leather and doesn't leave a film. 
 Price: 100ml &mdash; &pound;1.99; 400ml &mdash; &pound;4.49. 
 Contact: Mars Oil Company, Drayton, Banbury, Oxon OX15 6EE. 
 Tel: 0295 262844.  
 You can revamp everything from boots to tents with today's specialist products 
 a day out with&hellip; 
 Keith Wilson 
 Constructing repairing and maintaining footpaths is all in day's work for pathcraft manager Keith Wilson 
 &bquo;I'm Operations Manager of Pathcraft, a private company set up in 1990 which specialises in the care, maintenance, repair and construction of upland footpaths. 
 I have the authority for setting up jobs, making initial contacts, specifying work to be done and negotiating contracts with individual clients. 
 I also make sure that the five-strong work teams are up to strength and have all the equipment they need. 
 On completion of a job I give a report to the client, raise invoices and if necessary chase them up. 
 It's the whole  enchillada . 
 The worst thing about the job is dealing with bureaucracy while the best thing is the two or three days I spend each week out on the hill getting my hands dirty, visiting worksites and clients. 
 We work all year round but can't work on the uplands during the winter months &mdash; we might not see it for six to eight weeks. 
 In winter we look for work on the more difficult lowland sites such as coastal paths. 
 Most of our work is for institutional landowners and managers such as the National Trust for Scotland, Scottish Heritage and local authorities. 
 We also work for private landowners. 
 Our activities are restrained by the availability of resources of clients. 
 We have innumerable paths that need constant work but due to financial pressures the lucky ones might only receive around six weeks' work a year. 
 However it's developing. 
 To correct erosion damage we built paths to concentrate pressure on a thin line that is capable of taking it. 
 For example if we run a path through an area which has an erosion damage of 20 metres across you're focusing pressure from 20 metres to one metre &mdash; that leaves 19 metres to reclaim. 
 Every path has its own problems. 
 A five-person team could cover 50 metres in a day, if the work is of a minimal nature. 
 In some particularly difficult circumstances, such as constructing a footpath on deep peat, it could only be four to five metres a day. 
 To create a one metre wide path on peat you need to excavate a one metre wide trench with a depth of eight inches. 
 Two geo (artificial) textiles are laid into the bottom of the trench which is then covered with four to six inches of angular cobbles which are laid in by hand so they knit together: A two inch layer of fine gravel is then spread on top. 
 A lot of landscaping work is also done on the surrounding area to encourage walkers to follow the path. 
 For example strategically placed peat mounds might be created on either side of the path. 
 When constructing a footpath we follow rules of thumb. 
 We have a policy of not importing alien materials unless we have to, using stone, turf and gravels from the area. 
 If materials do have to be imported we make sure they're appropriate, for example helicoptering in a supply of gravel from a similar type of hillside. 
 We work on the basis that we are not inflicting a footpath on the countryside but developing a footpath that is part and parcel of the landscape. 
 If we do our work well walkers won't realise that they are walking on a reconstructed path. 
 That encompasses what we are trying to achieve. 
 The way official paths often come into being is absurd. 
 Instigated by people in offices who say let's put out a guidebook. 
 They look at a map, draw a line and produce leaflets but nothing is done on the ground to withstand the pressure of hundreds of people following the route. 
 You just need to look at the disaster situation on the Pennine Way. 
 Resources must be applied so that there won't be unacceptable damage. 
 Walkers should stick to obvious paths even if they're badly eroded. 
 They shouldn't walk on the edges as that is what causes them to widen and the erosion to spread. 
 I'm from the countryside and have always earned my living from it. 
 I was always involved in tree planting and general countryside employment before getting a job as Field Officer when Scottish Conservation Projects came into existence in 1984. 
 I got my current job in 1990. 
 My ambition is for Pathcraft to have permanent employees in remoter parts of the country doing vital work and earning a living. 
 I firmly believe that the quality of the Scottish countryside is our greatest sustainable resource but it must be looked after. 
 If we continue to use the countryside in an exploitative manner it will run out. 
 And once it's gone it's gone.&equo; 
 Report by Henry Druce 
 The Years of retreat 1969&ndash;1879 
 THE YEARS OF DISCONTENT 1977&ndash;1979 
 BRITAIN after the IMF crisis had an air of being a nation after the deluge. 
 The cuts had been agreed without the collapse of the government or immediate catastrophe in the economy. 
 The unions were acquiescent; other than in Northern Ireland, there was no overt social conflict. 
 The Labour government, it is true, did suffer an immense personal blow soon after the IMF negotiations were completed, with the sudden death of Anthony Crosland, recently appointed Foreign Secretary. 
 Apart from disturbing the balance in the Cabinet, this removed the only major socialist theoretician of the day. 
 His Future of Socialism  in 1956 had provided a point of reference for the party, and progressives throughout the nation, over the past twenty years with its emphasis on social equality rather on public ownership as the instrument of change. 
 He was replaced, not by the senior figure of Denis Healey, who was chained to his oar at the Treasury in the aftermath of the IMF cuts, but by the youthful and little-known figure of David Owen, Crosland's junior minister at the Foreign Office. 
 The Cabinet, however, even though shorn of Crosland, and also of Roy Jenkins on the right and Barbara Castle on the left for different reasons, still remained credible as an agent of authority, and in the early months of 1977 Britain slowly emerged towards a plateau of greater tranquillity and modest economic recovery. 
 The revival was in many ways only a relative one. 
 Unemployment continued to rise to reach over one-and-a-half million by mid-1977. 
 The people's standard of living was further depressed as both the longer-term effects of the oil-price increase of 1973 and the post-IMF cuts of the immediate past began to sink in. 
 Nevertheless, by the time of  the Queen's jubilee that summer there was some sense that a good deal of the worst might be over. 
 The custodian of this mood of growing calm was the new Prime Minister, James Callaghan, who imposed himself on the public consciousness as a new Baldwin, the apostle of peace in our time. 
 His press soubriquet &bquo;Sunny Jim&equo; was rather misplaced since it concealed a somewhat touchy disposition, just as Henderson's unwontedly benign term of endearment, &bquo;Uncle Arthur&equo;, had been in the past. 
 But he commanded general respect as an authoritative voice, in tune with the need for social order, sensitive to the needs of the unions and his own party, but also with a genuine cross-party appeal. 
 &bquo;You can trust Jim&equo;, was Labour's appeal, reminiscent of a friendly village bobby or a family doctor of the old school. 
 He proved to be the most effective Prime Minister since Macmillan's first phase. 
 In the Cabinet, Callaghan's open methods and refusal to countenance conspiracies made for a more harmonious atmosphere than ever prevailed under Harold Wilson (now Lord Wilson of Rievaulx). 
 Even the left-wing Tony Benn was relatively quiescent, not least perhaps because he was now the bringer of good news at the Department of Energy, as North Sea oil began to flow in large quantities. 
 No doubt, Callaghan had his limitations. 
 Although an advocate of open Cabinet discussions, he also firmly believed in the principle of confidentiality or plain secrecy in key areas. 
 Thus, defence policy was kept in the hands of a small group of ministers (Callaghan, Healey, Owen, and Fred Mulley). 
 A major consequence was that the development of the extremely expensive &bquo;Chevaline&equo; warheads went ahead despite all the economic difficulties of the period, with no Cabinet discussion at the time. 
 Even David Owen was later to admit that they should have been scrapped during his time at the Foreign Office in 1 977&ndash;9. 
 Chevaline in all had risen in cost from &pound;350 m. in 1974 to over &pound;1 billion by 1982, on top of the Polaris missile programme-even though by this time US-Soviet arms limitation agreements had made Chevaline redundant. 
 It was the price of maintaining Britain's posture as a supposedly independent nuclear power, under Labour as under the Tories. 
 Equally, exchange rates and aspects of market economics were kept for close-quarter deliberation, notably within Harold Lever's so-called &bquo;economic seminar&equo;.  
 Along with this, Callaghan was not by instinct an institutional radical. 
 He had been a trade-union official, in a white-collar civil-service union, in his young days, and he regarded as sacrosanct maintaining the liaison between unions and party at all costs. 
 Thus, in 1969 he had been the main Cabinet instrument of dissent in rejecting Wilson and Mrs Castle's proposed statutory incomes policy. 
 Many, therefore, blamed Callaghan for the explosion in union wage claims that followed in the early seventies. 
 In the Home Office, he had demonstrated broadly conservative views on crime, drugs, and racial issues, not surprisingly so perhaps for one who served as parliamentary spokesman for the Police Federation. 
 Over such key issues as the European Common Market he had followed a prudent, unadventurous course, only moving to endorse membership at the last moment when political circumstances seemed so to dictate. 
 In his years in Number 10, he showed limited interest in social or institutional reform. 
 The changes wrought by the Heath government were allowed to survive, to be left for Mrs Thatcher gleefully to dismantle in the eighties. 
 But this cautious, adroit, enigmatic leader seemed for long to be very much what the nation and the times required. 
 The country seemed to be on a knife-edge, with a minority government, the economy poised on the edge of collapse, and potential disorder in industrial relations, racial matters, and the affairs of the Celtic fringe. 
 Callaghan proved to be an imperturbable and shrewd pilot for these storms. 
 Further, he was not unwilling to show enterprise. 
 The move towards cash limits, cuts in current expenditure, and a generally monetarist policy were heralded by a speech to the TUC in September 1976, which (as noted) reflected the influence of his son-in-law, Peter Jay. 
 Again, on education, Callaghan attempted to promote new standards of literacy and numeracy, based on an agreed core curriculum in schools. 
 In foreign policy, while seldom innovative, he did try to carve out new relationships with Britain's new European partners, especially through his close personal association with Helmut Schmidt, the West German chancellor and a fellow social democrat, as well as maintaining his contacts with the new US Democratic administration of Jimmy Carter. 
 In 1977 and 1978, Indeed, Callaghan showed the ability to do more than survive, and emerged with a stature which perhaps surprised his many jaundiced critics in the party and press. 
 He became the personal embodiment of a new solidarity, a new ralliement , nudging his fellow-countrymen  towards a new accommodation to changing circumstances at home and overseas. 
 The new Conservative leader Mrs Thatcher, was finding it hard to assert herself, especially with a Shadow Cabinet consisting largely of followers of the defeated Edward Heath. 
 In Sir Ian Gilmour's Inside Right , a defence of the post-1945 political consensus, it was clear that the Tory centrists could fight back, and the monetarist radicals had, therefore, to be wary. 
 With little pressure from that quarter for an early general election, Callaghan almost imperceptibly emerged with growing command. 
 Until a sudden decline from September 1 978, he seemed almost unchallengeable. 
 He was fundamentally assisted by political accommodation, and by evidence of growing economic recovery. 
 The first was his own work, the latter the somewhat ambiguous achievement of Denis Healey, with incidental assistance from the IMF, the central banks, and Jack Jones of the Transport Workers. 
 The political accommodation stemmed from the &bquo;pact&equo; concluded between the Labour government and the tiny Liberal Party. 
 The latter had a mere twelve members but nevertheless carried weight in a situation where the Callaghan government was in a technical minority in the House and in danger of imminent defeat. 
 In March &mdash; April 1977, however, the so-called &bquo;Lib-Lab pact&equo; was concluded between Callaghan and the new Liberal leader, David Steel. 
 The Welsh leader of the parliamentary Labour Party, Cledwyn Hughes, himself a &bquo;Lib-Lab&equo; figure of noted moderation and an admirer of Lloyd George, was an important go-between. 
 The upshot was that the Liberals promised to support the Labour government in the House by their votes. 
 The conditions included a joint consultative committee being set up to consider future legislation, chaired by Michael Foot, the leader of the House, and regular meetings between Cabinet ministers and Liberal spokesmen to consider government measures. 
 The government agreed to press on with devolution, and also to advance direct elections to the European Parliament, to which Labour had been hostile, while the Local Authority Works Bill, perhaps Labour's last instalment of  socialism, was watered down. 
 On balance, it was a package strongly in favour of the government. 
 No major concessions were made; in particular, no ground was given to the Liberal demand for proportional representation to give minor parties a more enhanced position in the country. 
 The government, in effect, was guaranteed perhaps an extra two years in power. 
 For the Liberals, they gained an indirect foothold in government for the first time since 1931 in peacetime circumstances, and it flattered their self-esteem as a small third force to become part of the governing process. 
 David Steel, the Liberal leader, was anxious to enhance his, and his party's, authority following the damaging departure of the former leader, Jeremy Thorpe, in a series of scandals involving accusations of homosexuality, fraud, and even attempted murder. 
 Steel himself was a noted tactician, more concerned with manoeuvre than with policy-making, a style appropriate for the parliamentary situation. 
 The government thus gained a new foothold on power relatively painlessly, apart perhaps from the consultations between Denis Healey and the Liberals' economic spokesman, John Pardoe, two combustible personalities whose stormy meetings (or shouting matches) provided amusement and entertainment throughout Whitehall. 
 With its political basis ensured, the government could now settle down to consolidate and enjoy the fruits of recovery. 
 There was much to enjoy in 1977. 
 The benefits of North Sea oil were now coming through strongly. 
 The first oilfield to come on stream had been the small Argyll field in mid-1975, followed by pipeline deliveries from the Norwegian &bquo;Ekofisk&equo; field and the massive British Forties field later that year. 
 Five more oilfields were producing oil from the North Sea continental shelf in 1976, including the massive Brent and Alpha fields. 
 By the end of 1978 nine were in production and several more on course for development. 
 It was evident that by the end of the seventies Britain would be self-sufficient in oil and was likely to remain so, depending on depletion policy, until at least the end of the century. 
 By 1980, Britain would be producing 100 million tonnes a year, with 500,000 barrels a day from the Forties field and 370,000 from the Brent field, putting the United Kingdom on a par with Kuwait, Nigeria, or Iraq as a major oil producer. 
 With a  growing number of nuclear power stations (the old Magnox reactors such as Calder Hall in Cumbria or Wylfa and Trawsfynydd in North Wales being supplemented by stations such as Sellafield, despite the opposition of environmentalists and the anti-nuclear lobbies); with hydroelectric power in the Scottish Highlands and North Wales; and a still important, if aged, coal industry, together with another huge energy bonus in the shape of North Sea gas, Britain's energy position seemed remarkably secure. 
 Many of the problems faced by other industrial nations thus disappeared. 
 Among other things, the successful strikes of North Sea oil proved a notable bonus for British technology, reinforced in the seventies by other achievements such as the Anglo-French Concorde transatlantic airliner, and the emergence of the &bquo;high-speed train&equo; capable of speeds of up to 130 miles per hour. 
 Clearly the native resources of scientific talent and ingenuity had not run dry, for all the disappointment caused by the failures of the &bquo;science and government&equo; campaigns of the early 1960s. 
 External improvement in the balance of payments was accompanied by a steady fall in the rate of inflation from a peak of 25 per cent at the end of 1975 to around 7 per cent by mid-1978. 
 The precise cause was open to debate. 
 Labour partisans hailed the effectiveness of the Jack Jones &bquo;flat-rate&equo; formula which had introduced a virtual wage freeze until mid-1977, and which the government then continued with a year-long pay-restraint policy. 
 Critics claimed that a more likely cause of the fall in the rate of inflation was the stagnation of the British and international economy, with the loss of manufacturing output and rising unemployment. 
 This took pressure out of the economy by reducing demand. 
 For all that, the decline in inflation was undeniable. 
 By August, after Healey's latest mini-budget had been passed through the Commons with surprising ease, there was a glow of good news, with bank rate falling to 7 per cent, the stock market rising strongly, the pound being sustained, and the balance of payments showing impressive recovery. 
 The month of August 1977 showed a balance-of-payment surplus of &pound;316 m., the largest ever recorded in numerical terms for one month. 
 Share prices soared, although some of this was due to falling interest rates that followed the unhooking of the pound from the dollar, stimulating gilt-edged, rather than a major increase in manufacturing output or exports. 
  Healey was able to pay back the first instalment of &pound;2 billion to the IMF with some ease, and indeed the full IMF loan proved to be unnecessary, while income-tax allowances were raised and a bonus for Christmas could be afforded for old-age pensions. 
 A balance-of-payments surplus of &pound;206 m. in October meant a surplus of &pound;758 m. for the past three months, much helped by North Sea oil cutting the fuel deficit, and a strong pound. 
 Exports showed some improvement, although the rise in the import of finished manufactures such as motor cars and other vehicles was continuously alarming. 
 At the end of the year, Britain seemed much revived from the black days of the IMF crisis twelve months earlier. 
 The market soared, especially in government gilt-edged stock, and the pound emerged ever stronger. 
 Denis Healey himself, a long-established whipping boy, now became almost popular, with his chairmanship of the International Monetary Fund inner steering committee making him a figure of greater eminence. 
 Alongside his Chancellor, Callaghan emerged with more credibility in the international arena, especially through his pact with the West German Chancellor, Helmut Schmidt, and the partial decline in the reputation of the French President, Giscard d'Estaing. 
 Britain seemed in almost bullish mood as 1977 went out. 
 It seemed well on the way to revival, with the balance-of-payments surplus rising to &pound;1,000 m. in 1978 and the pound, now a petro-currency, rising to not far short of &dollar;2 on the foreign exchange. 
 Douglas Jay observed that the later 1970s were a time of genuine recovery &mdash; &bquo;one of the few examples of any Western governments in the seventies reducing both inflationary pressures and unemployment&equo; at one and the same time. 
 The revival continued for much of 1978. 
 Indeed, by the middle of that year critics were saying that the cuts imposed at the time of the IMF crisis may have been too harsh, and that fixed investment in manufacturing capacity needed to be stepped up, even though it actually rose by 8 per cent in 1978. 
 Sir Brian Hopkin was later to describe the relaxation of monetary targets at this time as &bquo;the last dying kick of Keynesian demand management&equo;, but clearly there was life left in the old orthodoxy yet. 
 Denis Healey, nevertheless, had  to contend with a wide range of critics, from socialists such as Benn who claimed that his successes resulted from such right-wing nostrums as a wage freeze and cutting public spending, to the monetarists of the Policy Studies Committee who attacked him for being far too dirigiste . 
 In the spring of 1978 there were signs of the happier times coming to an end, with the pound under pressure and Healey himself attacked for anticipating tax cuts that summer in the budget he introduced in April. 
 Under some pressure from the Liberals, he agreed to accept amendments to reduce the standard rate of income tax in his Finance Bill, but his alternative scheme of including a 2 per cent surcharge on employers' National Insurance contributions was much attacked in the City. 
 There were, indeed, tremors both in the markets and in the strength of sterling that summer. 
 But, on balance, the government seemed able to claim that it had turned the tide, albeit with the aid of &pound;2 billions from North Sea oil to swing the balance into surplus. 
 After a steady series of by-election blows throughout the seventies (including a calamitous defeat at Ashfield in April 1977), Labour was cheered by a decisive defeat of the Scottish Nationalists in the Hamilton seat (May 1978), one of the markers in the SNP advance in the 1960s. 
 After lagging as much as 15 per cent behind the Tories in the opinion polls in 1977, Labour was actually level with them in July 1978 and threatening to pull ahead. 
 Whether by luck or careful management, Callaghan's administration looked much more credible now, and many expected him to call an autumn election in 1978 to cash in on favourable economic and political trends and, against all the odds, snatch another term of power. 
 The significance of the economic recovery, such as it was, in 1977- 8 caused much debate and some perplexity. 
 Some genial foreign observers claimed that it illustrated that gloomy predictions about Britain's demise, like that of Mark Twain, were much exaggerated. 
 Keynesian apologists partially recovered their confidence. 
 The North American economist, John Kenneth Galbraith, took a distinctly positive view, claiming that the crisis had shown both the revival of industrial technology and the reimposition of civic discipline as demonstrated by the pay pause, in the face of difficulties which might have led feebler nations to buckle under, or even lapse into military or other dictatorships. 
 The American journalist, Bernard Nossiter, even saw Britain's decline of manufacturing output as a sign of  advance and of maturity, since the British, civilized and civic-minded as they were, were proclaiming the need for more leisure and less regimented ways of living. 
 Without lapsing into the complacency, or even euphoria, of some of these judgements, there was certainly evidence of a nation enjoying the fruits of prosperity, however deceptive. 
 Public spending had risen from 40 per cent to 45.5 per cent of gross domestic product in 1974&ndash;6, partly through heavy industrial subsidies and the cost of maintaining the &bquo;social wage&equo; through the social security system. 
 Despite the severe cuts imposed in late 1976, public spending continued to rise in absolute terms. 
 There was, in particular, a renewed surge of spending on state schools, part of it to finance the rapid completion of the comprehensive secondary education system now being finished under the aegis of Shirley Williams, a right-wing member of the government but also a critic of private schooling. 
 Expensive new capital projects were under consideration including a vast new British Library to replace the Georgian splendour of the British Museum. 
 One spectacular monument of much value to historians opened in 1977 was the glossy, computerized Public Record Office at Kew, to supplement the venerable Victorian legacy in Chancery Lane. 
 Elsewhere, in Scotland and Wales, regional policies continued to thrive, as if the economic hammer blows of the 1970s had never been. 
 The Welsh Office and the Welsh Development Agency were active in extending financial aid for a variety of local causes from advanced factories in decaying mining villages to Welsh-language schools and the Welsh National Opera. 
 Throughout Britain there was an extensive road-building programme, including a rapid growth of the motorway system and such impressive developments as the new bridges across the Humber and the Severn. 
 The arts generally continued to thrive through public subsidy, to orchestral music above all, and new forms of partnership were being developed between the Arts Council and local authorities and industry and finance. 
 Much of this artistic creativity was more innovative than before. 
 In the world of youth or pop culture, Britain, without reaching the frenetic heights of the years of the Beatles and the Rolling Stones  in the sixties, remained a market leader, with rock festivals taking place in such unlikely locations as Windsor Great Park and Stonehenge. 
 Even so, there was broad agreement that this evidence of innovation and vibrancy was being achieved at the cost of institutional inertia, a reluctance to champion enterprise, and an avoidance of any deep-seated restoration of the national economy. 
 The linchpins, after all, were such traditionally unsocialist (or even anti-socialist) policies as a very severe incomes policy, a move from direct to indirect taxation, and swingeing cuts in public expenditure in both 1976&ndash;7 and 1977&ndash;8. 
 Under the shield of North Sea oil and gas, the endemic problems of the economy in the sixties &mdash; low productivity, backward manufacturing capacity, immobile and inadequately retrained labour, and excessively cautious unions and management &mdash; remained untouched. 
 On balance, the general reaction to the greater social tranquillity was one of relief rather than euphoria. 
 Britain was proving itself to be better than the ungovernable &bquo;banana republic&equo; of hostile critics in 1975&ndash;6, but still an ailing ex-imperial giant lacking focus and perhaps even faith. 
 There was much national rejoicing at the jubilee to celebrate Queen Elizabeth II's reign since 1952. 
 But it was countered by the somewhat cooler attitude towards the royal family that had emerged in recent years, some of it captured in an &bquo;anti-jubilee&equo; number of the New Statesman  edited by Anthony Howard. 
 The jubilee, like, indeed, the royal wedding of the then Princess Elizabeth and the Duke of Edinburgh back in 1947, was less than unbridled in its lavishness. 
 The Department of the Environment confined itself to spending &pound;175,000 on banners and other adornments along the Mall and in Trafalgar Square. 
 For all the obvious potential of the pageantry in attracting tourist income from America and the Commonwealth, official expenditure on flags and bunting in the City of London came to just &pound;150, while, to save money, the cleaning of the floor of St Paul's Cathedral before and after the jubilee service was done by an army of volunteers. 
 Like George VI and the then Queen Elizabeth eating spam from a gold plate during the Second World War, this was pageantry on the cheap rather than an unrestrained recapitulation of the glories of the first Elizabethan Age. 
 Many of the major issues confronting government and nation  remained unsolved, or at best marginally confronted in the 1977&ndash;8 period. 
 In the Commonwealth, Callaghan (previously a supporter of arms sales) took a firm line in promoting a ban on sporting and other contacts with South Africa, and enforced the so-called Gleneagles Agreement with other Commonwealth countries, amongst whom the Conservative Prime Minister of Australia, Malcolm Fraser, proved an unexpectedly vigorous opponent of apartheid. 
 But the abiding issue of Rhodesia, still in the unilateral and technically illegal control of the minority white government of Ian Smith, despite strong black guerrilla opposition from supporters of the rival Nkomo and Mugabe factions, remained undisturbed. 
 The main new initiative attempted by Callaghan was the dispatch of the much-respected former Cabinet minister, Cledwyn Hughes, to southern Africa in 1978, partly to facilitate a continuing rapport with the Carter administration in Washington on relations with the illegal Smith regime. 
 Hughes's talks with black African leaders such as Robert Mugabe and Joshua Nkomo, and the heads of the so-called &bquo;front-line&equo; African states, Zambia, Malawi, and Mozambique, suggested, however, that there was no common ground or any possible basis of negotiation with the Smith government. 
 Remarkably, however, the seeds of change emerged in Rhodesia itself. 
 Under pressure from the South African government, and in the face of growing guerrilla warfare, Ian Smith unexpectedly announced on 24 September 1976 that there would be majority rule in the country within two years. 
 In May 1978 he reached agreement with the more moderate African leaders, Bishop Muzorewa and Nabadingi Sithole. 
 In April 1979, on the eve of a British general election as it happened, Bishop Muzorewa's United African Council received more than 60 per cent of the votes in a general election, and the Methodist Bishop became Prime Minister of &bquo;Zimbabwe-Rhodesia&equo;, although in the face of the opposition of the Nkomo/Mugabe forces. 
 It was an astonishing climax to the long-running Rhodesian crisis. 
 But it owed everything to political manoeuvres and economic pressures in southern Africa, and nothing to British influence. 
 Elsewhere, the legacy of Empire was allowed to decay. 
 Gibraltar, whose importance as a naval base was now much diminished, caused continuing diplomatic embarrassment with Spain, although the local population made clear their wish to remain British. 
 In the Far East, the future of Hong Kong, an immensely important financial and manufacturing centre, where the British lease was due to run out in  1997, was left in abeyance by both the British and the Chinese governments, in the post-Mao era. 
 Only in one remote, unnoticed, and unreported area did imperial authority ring out with any confidence. 
 This was the Falkland Islands in the distant southern Atlantic, where Callaghan managed to deter, or dissuade, the Argentine military junta from taking naval action in the vicinity of the Falklands or occupying South Georgia. 
 The British vessel, Endurance , an ice-patrol ship reinforced with helicopters and missiles, was kept in Falklands waters despite pressure from the Ministry of Defence. 
 Callaghan not unreasonably claimed in his memoirs that the Tories won the Falklands War but that Labour had kept the peace. 
 On the other hand here was again a problem where a settlement was postponed rather than achieved. 
 Meanwhile, the dispatch of a Foreign Office minister, Ted Rowlands, to Port Stanley to try to persuade the Falklanders of the merits of starting up diplomatic negotiations with the Argentine government, which claimed the islands as their sovereign &bquo;Malvinas&equo;, had an ominous ring to it. 
 Nearer home, Northern Ireland only produced renewed deadlock. 
 There was, in truth, little initiative that any British government could offer in the unpromising circumstances of 1977&ndash;8. 
 The return of a Fianna F&aacute;il government under Jack Lynch meant something of a decline in Anglo-Irish cordiality or willingness to collaborate in security matters, while the end of the constitutional assembly in early 1977 had removed any prospect of finding any viable Ulster administration to modify the picture of direct rule from Westminster. 
 Under Roy Mason, the tough ex-miner who had succeeded Merlyn Rees as Home Secretary, a strong policy was adopted against the violence of Sinn Fein. 
 This was foreshadowed by the appointment of Major-General Timothy &bquo;Bull&equo; Creasey as General Officer Commanding in Northern Ireland in late 1977, along with the increasing use of SAS forces and a freer hand given to the RUC police. 
 The government's policy was formally one of &bquo;Ulsterization&equo;, namely allowing a wide range of local programmes and policies to be taken over by local leaders. 
 But the realities were spelt out mainly in military terms. 
 Indeed, in 1978 there was some evidence that the British security forces, coupled with divisions amongst the  Provisionals, were swinging the balance away from the IRA. 
 The year 1978 saw only 81 deaths, the lowest annual total since 1970. 
 The &bquo;men of violence&equo;, it was claimed, were truly against the ropes. 
 But these successes were achieved by military and legal means which did Britain's international reputation much harm, including the use of the &bquo;Diplock courts&equo;, stern methods of interrogation and arbitrary imprisonment, and severe conditions of detention or confinement amongst political prisoners in the H block and elsewhere. 
 A new wave of IRA attacks then broke out early in 1979, including several on the British mainland. 
 The most spectacular of them (April 1979) was the assassination through a car-bomb attack of the right-wing Tory MP, Airey Neave, a close friend and confidant of the Conservative leader, Margaret Thatcher. 
 This was claimed to be the work not of the IRA proper, but of the Irish National Liberation Army, an offshoot of it. 
 Clearly as a military phenomenon alone Ulster would continue to trouble the conscience of the British in the 1980s. 
 In political terms, there was no sign of breakthrough. 
 Indeed, 1977&ndash;9, with Roy Mason at the Northern Irish ministry, was the most unproductive period that Ireland had known, in political or constitutional terms, since the troubles began in the late 1960s. 
 The tenth anniversary of the civil rights movement was celebrated on 1 January 1979 amidst a growing alienation of the minority Catholic population, a rising toll not only of violence but also of poverty and unemployment in the six counties, and an increasingly unbridgeable gulf within the majority Protestant ranks, with the Official Unionists and the so-called Democratic Unionists under the Revd Ian Paisley vying with one another in intransigence and extremism. 
 Relations on security matters between the Westminster government and the Dublin Fianna F&aacute;il government of Jack Lynch were never close or cordial. 
 In short, Ulster remained more of a violent backwater, removed from the mainstream of British social development, at the end of the 1970s than it had been at the start of that troubled decade. 
 The irony was that, for all their political ineffectiveness, the Ulster Unionists exercised a matchless political influence for quite fortuitous political reasons. 
 Their existence, like that of other nationalist splinter groups, was vital to the continuance of a Labour government, and private negotiations with them (amongst whom was now numbered Enoch Powell) ensured that their numbers in the new House of  Commons would be raised from 12 to 18. 
 But this was the only positive outcome of an otherwise peculiarly negative and dismal phase, even by the standards of Northern Irish history. 
 The issue of governmental devolution for the other Celtic nations of Scotland and Wales made more headway. 
 The Scottish and Welsh Devolution Bills made steady progress through the Commons, until both became law in 1978. 
 But there was much evidence of divided counsels on both the Labour and Conservative sides, as has been noted above. 
 Indeed, the government had to make major concessions during the committee stage, especially to Labour critics. 
 The amendment by an expatriate Scot, George Cunningham (Labour, Islington), by ensuring that a 40 per cent vote of the electorate (not simply of those voting) would have to be achieved for a devolution bill to go through and for a repeal order not to be tabled, made devolution, at least for Wales, virtually an impossibility. 
 Even when the Scottish and Welsh Bills became law in July 1978 it was clear that the issue was very far from settled and that the referendums, finally announced for 1 March 1979, would be the decisive factor. 
 The &bquo;great debate&equo; over the structure of the United Kingdom and the relations of the Celtic nations to the predominant English partner, was likely to be diverted from the outset. 
 It was achieved in a mood of almost stunned boredom amongst English opinion, confident that the dismantling of the United Kingdom as it had endured since 1707 or 1536 would not in fact take place. 
 There was much criticism of the time taken up in the Commons by these devolution measures, and also of the careless drafting of two bills which were likely to produce a legal and constitutional nightmare if they ever took effect. 
 The devolution campaigns began in the winter of 1978&ndash;9 when, as will be seen, the public was far more concerned with the &bquo;winter of discontent&equo; with the trade unions and the likely approach of a general election. 
 In Wales there was not much doubt that the result would be negative. 
 The dominant Labour Party included large sections of industrial South Wales which was openly hostile, fearing that devolution would separate Wales from the economic and social structure of England and perhaps become a paradise for linguistic nationalists. 
 Plaid Cymru itself was distinctly half-hearted on the issue. 
 There was never any prospect of a &bquo;Yes&equo; vote being recorded, and the treasured plans for a Welsh assembly to occupy a derelict  corn exchange in Cardiff docks were put on ice. 
 In the event, on 1 March 1979 there was a 4 to 1 majority in Wales against devolution, 243,048 votes in favour and 956,330 against. 
 In Glamorgan and Gwent the votes were overwhelming, but even in Welsh-speaking Gwynedd, with its two Plaid Cymru MPs, there was a 2 to 1 majority against devolution. 
 Self-government disappeared from Welsh history amid universal derision, and attention now concentrated on further building up the Welsh Office instead. 
 Even in Scotland, the huge majorities in favour of devolution once recorded steadily diminished in the opinion polls in 1978 as the Scottish economy appeared to recover and Labour regained much of the ground lost to the Nationalists. 
 Two of the main Labour devolutionists had been lost, Professor John Mackintosh, an eloquent and gifted academic advocate of devolution, by death, James Sillars through defection to a minority splinter-group, the Scottish Labour Party. 
 (Sillars later married the Scottish Nationalist ex-MP Margo MacDonald and became SNP member for Govan in November 1988.) 
 Labour's devolution campaign in Scotland lacked force and credibility and Scottish enthusiasm waned steadily. 
 On 1 March 1979, devolution did, indeed, gain a majority amongst the Scottish voters, by 1,240,937 to 1,153,502, 51.6 per cent to 48.4 per cent, but over 36 per cent of electors did not vote at all. 
 Even Scotland was far removed from the necessary 40 per cent margin. 
 The decade ended with Scottish Nationalism as a political force decidedly on the wane, and devolution discredited. 
 The issue was clearly much more buoyant than in Wales, and Scottish Labour circles continued to be sympathetic. 
 But in general, here, too, was a major issue in which the 1970s had been wholly unproductive, in which Celtic nationalism had been inflamed but left impotent and dissatisfied, and real questions about accountability and democratic participation left unanswered. 
 Devolution, even in Ulster, was a relative sideshow. 
 The main issue, undoubtedly, lay in the sphere of industrial relations. 
 This would decide whether the hard-won economic recovery of the post-IMF phase would be destroyed by rampaging wage demands and raging  inflation. 
 Between the Labour government and the unions there was an uneasy d&eacute;tente  at the start of 1977. 
 An interlude of social peace had been forged of which Jack Jones of the Transport Workers' Union was the architect. 
 Jones was now in the twilight of a complex and often controversial career. 
 In 1977 the campaign was already afoot to choose the successor to him as General Secretary, with Moss Evans as the favourite. 
 Certainly, such peace as prevailed owed an immense amount to Jones's personal stature in the movement, as one of the old-style union leaders who had, nevertheless, taken an outward-looking and creative role in trying to relate union demands to a wider pattern of economic stability and also, incidentally, the wellbeing of a Labour government. 
 Jack Jones was an interesting, transitional figure. 
 He was an old leftist who had fought in Spain in the International Brigade. 
 He had grown up in a quasi-syndicalist tradition in the Liverpool docks, and his influence in the sixties had been thrown behind the growth of the shop-stewards movement and local plant bargaining on a devolved basis very much on the lines of the 1968 Donovan Report. 
 He was far removed from the centralism embodied by his predecessors Ernest Bevin and Arthur Deakin. 
 On the other hand, he had played a nationally constructive role also, especially since he and Hugh Scanlon helped the TUC defeat Barbara Castle's incomes policy in 1969. 
 Jones had then worked closely with the docks employer, Lord Aldington, in getting a new wages agreement for the docks including a settlement for the problem of casual labour which drew on him the fire of many militant shop stewards amongst the stevedores. 
 He was also the leader of a pressure-group to improve the lot of old-age pensioners. 
 Jones emerged in 1975 and 1976 as the unique champion of a policy for wages which reconciled voluntary bargaining with a national perspective. 
 Until the autumn of 1976, the &pound;6 fiat-rate increase for wages and salaries below &pound;8,500, agreed by the TUC General Council by a narrow margin in July 1975, held firm and clearly played a major part in the sharp reduction of inflation that year. 
 As a testimony to one trade-unionist's authority and stature, carried through in the face of some hostility within the administration and somewhat glacial relations with Denis Healey at the Treasury, it was a remarkable accomplishment. 
 But the achievement was always precarious and was maintained only with some difficulty. 
 With the mounting  balance-of-payments crisis, the TUC was reluctantly persuaded in the summer of 1976 to renew a virtual wage-freeze policy with a limit of 5 per cent increases for the next twelve months. 
 The financial atmosphere was dire at this period. 
 Even so, the new relationship between government and the unions was unlikely to last, at least on the present basis. 
 Jack Jones told Healey that summer: &bquo;We will have to get back to normal collective bargaining. 
 The most you can expect from us is an attempt to organize an orderly return with emphasis on some priorities.&equo; 
 Clearly, the optimism in some quarters that the unions were moving towards any long-term incomes or anti-inflation policy was quite unfounded. 
 Jack Jones himself remained poised, perhaps torn, between his traditional stance as a union negotiator committed to autonomy and his wider view of the need to recast an adversarial industrial-relations system. 
 Somewhat remarkably, he gave strong support to the proposals emanating from a committee under Lord Bullock for co-determination or industrial partnership as a basis for management. 
 But the horizons of most trade-unionist leaders were much more limited. 
 In 1977 the skein of any agreement on wages policy began to come apart. 
 Trade-union leaders, hailed in the press as industrial statesmen during the period of the fiat-rate wage policy, were now denounced as over-mighty tyrants. 
 Jack Jones found himself assailed by Paul Johnson, the ex-editor of the New Statesman  who had moved to the far right, as &bquo;The Emperor Jones&equo;, almost a fourth estate of the realm in himself and the symbol of overweening trade-union power. 
 Despite the warnings of Callaghan and Healey, the TUC at its conference in September 1977 voted for a return to &bquo;unfettered collective bargaining&equo;, with Jones and Scanlon taking the adverse view. 
 Although the TUC also, and somewhat contradictorily, endorsed a twelve-month gap in pay settlement, the banks of wage agreements were being burst again. 
 The pressure for an increase in wage levels, at least as agreed at the local branch or shop-floor, steadily mounted, and in the 1977&ndash;8 pay round settlements averaged over 1 5 per cent. 
 TUC support for a national limitation steadily eroded, not least because a so-called &bquo;Top People&equo; pay-review inquiry under  Sir Edward Boyle recommended large rises for already well-paid professions such as High Court judges and top civil servants, while the police, the armed services, the dentists, and doctors also benefited from substantial salary rises. 
 This was not helpful to TUC advocates of wage restraint. 
 Len Murray, the General Secretary, worked solidly on behalf of the government's 5 per cent policy but, unlike his predecessor Vic Feather, had no illusion of his power or ability to dictate to autonomous and all-powerful national unions. 
 Anxiety about trade-union power was rife at this period, as the personal attacks on Jack Jones indicated. 
 National unions like the Miners seemed able to advance almost any inflationary proposition with some real hope of success. 
 In the NUM a left-wing spokesman like Arthur Scargill advocated a broad pay increase of up to 80 per cent, and denounced local incentive schemes accepted in most coalfields as a means of increasing productivity. 
 Although nationwide strikes diminished in 1976&ndash;7, such disputes as did occur caused the maximum of attention, most of it highly unfavourable in tone. 
 When the firemen went on strike in 1977, a state of emergency was called by the Callaghan government and the army was employed in a strike-breaking capacity with the use of &bquo;green goddess&equo; fire-fighting vehicles. 
 A similar occurrence came when NHS ambulance drivers also stopped work. 
 An episode which attracted particular concern was a strike that occurred at an obscure photo-processing plant in North London, the Grunwick works. 
 This saw mass picketing by the unions after the employer, George Ward, a member of the &bquo;National Association for Freedom&equo;, sacked some Asian workers following his dismissal of employees who were members of unions. 
 After almost a year of dispute, mass picketing began in June 1977. 
 The union involved was APEX, a notoriously moderate union with a right-wing General Secretary, Roy Grantham. 
 In addition, the mass picketing outside Grunwick's works was intended to publicize the dispute rather than cause violent obstruction, as with Arthur Scargill's massed legions at the Saltley coke depot in 1972. 
 Nevertheless, violence outside the Grunwick works rapidly escalated, culminating in a so-called &bquo;day of action&equo; (11 July 1977) when about 18,000 people turned up to picket and there was much fighting with the police, resulting in seventy arrests and several injuries. 
 Daily scenes of confrontations outside the Grunwick works between the pickets and their supporters (sometimes not members of unions at all) and police cordons dominated television  news coverage. 
 Right-wing members of the Labour government like Roy Hattersley and Shirley Williams felt it their duty to show solidarity with the pickets. 
 In the end, picketing was much reduced from the summer of 1977. 
 But the entire episode promoted anti-union sentiment, not only amongst Conservatives, and led to many cries for legislation on picketing to clip the power of the overmighty trade unions once and for all. 
 The TUC had now the dilemma of wondering how far to authorize secondary action, for instance by calling out water workers or electricity power-station personnel. 
 In the event, the General Council drew back from this extreme policy and the outcome was that, after months of violence and intense bitterness, George Ward won his point and unions were excluded from the Grunwick plant. 
 The workers on strike found jobs elsewhere. 
 But, even in defeat, the unions had succeeded in imprinting the notion of workers' power on the minds of the public. 
 They had reinforced international criticism, not always well founded, of the &bquo;British disease&equo; of chaotic and adversarial industrial relations and endless strikes. 
 The industrial scene thus looked much more alarming in the early months of 1 978. 
 The government's hard-won economic plateau seemed unlikely to last. 
 Len Murray of the TUC worked hard but was unable to exert power that he did not possess. 
 A major factor was that the two famous left-wing union leaders, both to some degree poachers turned gamekeepers, Hugh Scanlon and Jack Jones, were now removed from the scene through retirement. 
 Scanlon's successor as President of the Engineers' Union, Terry Duffy, was, in fact, a strongly right-wing figure anxious to reach an accommodation with the government, but naturally it would take him time to build up his authority. 
 Jack Jones's successor was Moss Evans, a Welshman who had worked in the car industry as TGWU National Organizer. 
 He was a man with a limited grasp of wider economic or political implications who had set his face against wage restrictions, or even any notion of a social contract. 
 Indeed, it was largely because of this stance of old-fashioned industrial unionism that he had been elected in the first place. 
 The government's reaction pivoted on the response of the Prime Minister, James Callaghan. 
 As noted, his prestige had steadily risen since his accession to office. 
 In particular, as an old union man  he was thought to have a particularly sensitive, almost intuitive, understanding of the unions and how best to sell a policy of wage restraint to them. 
 In the crisis, quite unexpectedly, Callaghan seemed to lose some of his touch, with fatal results. 
 In July 1978, he announced bluntly that the government would commit the unions to a pay-increase norm of just 5 per cent for the next twelve months. 
 This proposal, unexpectedly small and unexpectedly rigid, took the unions aback. 
 It was by no means clear how the figure arose in the first place. 
 Callaghan later stated that it &bquo;popped out&equo; at the end of 1977 and then became firmer following a television broadcast. 
 It was argued that 5 per cent on paper would mean nearer 8 or 9 per cent in reality through wage-drift effects. 
 Even so, to proclaim so dogmatically a single-figure norm (instead of something attainable such as 10 per cent) was widely perceived to be a mistake. 
 The previous year, a more credible figure had been achieved without the need of a formal agreement at all. 
 Defending the increasingly indefensible policy of a 5 per cent pay norm led the government into growing difficulties. 
 Closely related to this was the prospect of a general election. 
 Labour had actually moved ahead of the Tories in some polls at the start of August 1978. 
 Many in the Cabinet felt that Callaghan would be in a uniquely favourable position, both politically and in terms of the balance of payments, to call an election in October. 
 Nicholas Kaldor urged him: &bquo;It is a peak. 
 Maybe a submerged peak, but a peak nevertheless.&equo; 
 The Prime Minister wavered throughout the summer with the contradictory signals coming from his colleagues and closest advisors. 
 Some trade unionists later felt that they had been misled by private assurances from the Prime Minister that there would be an early election. 
 In the end, Callaghan backed down because his private information suggested that Labour prospects were too precarious. 
 The Tories had again moved ahead in the polls at the start of September. 
 In part, perhaps, this was because of an effective advertising campaign on their behalf by Saatchi and Saatchi who published posters of the alleged army of unemployed people (recruited, in fact, from the affluent ranks of the Young  Conservatives) which claimed that &bquo;Labour isn't working&equo;. 
 Private polls in the constituencies conducted by Robert Worcester also suggested that in seventy marginal seats in England Labour would do badly, partly because a decline in the Liberal vote there was likely to assist the Conservatives. 
 Callaghan, therefore, decided against an early election. 
 But he did so in the most unfortunate manner. 
 At the TUC conference, which was intended by its chairman, David Basnett, to be a pre-election rally, the premier displayed some unwonted frivolity, singing an old music-hall song about &bquo;There she was, waiting at the church&equo;. 
 On 7 September he delivered a television broadcast in which he claimed that, for the sake of the economy and the national wellbeing, the election would be postponed to some time in 1979. 
 It was altogether a mysterious episode. 
 The Liberals had decided to end their pact and so the government had no firm majority in the House on which to rely. 
 Their policies on devolution seemed to be going awry. 
 There was every indication that the economic prospects would be much less favourable in 1979, with industrial trouble of a major kind looming up. 
 A mood of excitement had been allowed to build, followed by a feeling of let-down. 
 It made Callaghan seem untypically fragile and lacking in confidence. 
 There followed an alarming period in which the carefully contrived economic recovery and social peace created under the Callaghan government disintegrated. 
 This became enshrined in popular memory as the &bquo;winter of discontent&equo; in which all the components of the British malaise emerged in heightened colours. 
 The manoeuvring ability left to the Callaghan government was now slight, following the decision not to call an early election. 
 In the Labour party, as in the TUC, the policy to impose a 5 per cent norm had provoked much fury, and the party conference in October heavily rejected the policy, even though Callaghan and Healey made it clear that they would ignore the views of the delegates. 
 The party continued to swing to the left, with the prestige of Tony Benn, albeit still a Cabinet member, rising ever higher, and new left-wing figures like Neil Kinnock and Dennis Skinner elected to the constituency section of the NEC. 
 At the same time the party continued to contract and  disintegrate, even in its old mining and inner-city strongholds. 
 The official figures showed the party membership to be around 650,000; the real figures were well known to be far below that number, possibly below 300,000, with an undue proportion being middle-class activists who had taken over old and decaying working-class parties or management committees. 
 Transport House was, in terms of its organizing capacity, under-financed and distinctly run down. 
 On the Conservative side, the decision of Callaghan not to hold an election came as a shot in the arm. 
 Mounting industrial unrest gave the party new heart after internal disputes over incomes policy, immigration, Rhodesia, and much else. 
 Mrs Thatcher found it more possible to assert her own right-wing views as against those of moderates like Prior or Walker, with a strong thrust towards monetarism emerging in the party's The Right Approach to the Economy . 
 She now called, with increasing confidence and with the backing of a sophisticated advertising campaign, for &bquo;a change of direction&equo; and an attack on the monopolistic powers of the state and the crushing incubus of the trade unions. 
 The suburban middle class were fighting back, in the wake of the economic setbacks and union advances of the 1970s. 
 A new mood of aggressive support for &bquo;privatization&equo; and economic liberalism resulted. 
 The union troubles mounted apace that autumn, partly as a sign of growing strength. 
 Union membership continued to rise steadily, especially in service employment, to reach a peak of over 13 million in 1979. 
 The flash-point came, as so often in the past, in the car industry, with Ford workers, members of the TGWU, deciding to smash the 5 per cent guideline with calls for a minimum pay rise of &pound;20 a week and associated fringe benefits. 
 By the end of September, all twenty-three plants were lying idle, the management's offer of talks on productivity deals being abruptly rejected. 
 Moss Evans, the new Transport Workers' Union leader, made no effort to rein in his members' demands, while the Ford company itself, worried by loss of profits, was in no mood for a prolonged fight. 
 After two months, a settlement of 17 per cent was agreed, but the green light had been given for others to follow on. 
 There followed a 22 per cent pay rise  for the firemen, a 14 per cent deal for the bakers, and no less than 30 per cent, in two stages admittedly, for heating and ventilation engineers. 
 It was in the Transport Workers, above all, that the main battle was taking place, with the Ford dispute leading to another threatened strike by British Oxygen workers, and finally a conclusive dispute amongst the drivers of long-distance lorries and oil tankers. 
 A nation-wide strike by lorry drivers was declared for early January, starting in Scotland, with also an overtime ban, and another threatened strike by oil-tanker drivers early in the new year. 
 Britain faced the prospect of a winter without food and without energy, at the mercy of powerful unions and ineffective employers. 
 The Cabinet did what it could both to promote talks and also to set up emergency procedures under the Civil Contingency Unit chaired by Merlyn Rees, the beleaguered Home Secretary. 
 But the sheer impossibility of providing a national network of food and oil delivery made these efforts relatively ineffective, especially in the absence of legal or financial sanctions against the unions. 
 The situation was worsened by the ineptitude and intransigence of the oil companies. 
 No doubt the threat of national paralysis seemed much worse than it was: after all it would take many weeks for the full effects of a national strike to have an impact. 
 But the prospect was alarming enough and it was a gloomy festival at Christmas 1978. 
 Early in the new year there was a meeting of the leaders of the main industrial nations, Carter, Schmidt, Giscard, and Callaghan, on the attractive island of Guadeloupe in the French West Indies to discuss both economic and defence matters. 
 From this, Callaghan, sun-tanned and confident, returned to cold, strike-torn Britain. 
 At the airport, he replied to interviewers with words that were memorably misreported as being: &bquo;Crisis &mdash; what crisis?&equo; 
 Certainly, he failed to respond immediately to the gravity of the situation, and his authority slumped accordingly. 
 On 19 January the lorry drivers' strike ended with an almost total victory for the unions. 
 A rise of between 17 and 20 per cent was agreed, amounting to &pound;64 a week, a dramatic demonstration of workers' power. 
 But the malaise of discontent was now spreading  fast. 
 Public-service workers in such unions as NUPE and NALGO objected to the effects of the 5 per cent pay norm on low-paid workers, and on 22 January a national strike of 24 hours was declared by public-service workers. 
 It was followed by a rash of local selective strikes by health-service workers, dustmen, even the grave-diggers of Liverpool. 
 Rotting rubbish piled up in the streets. 
 Schools were kept closed because their caretakers stayed away, as did cleaners, cooks, and deliverers of fuel. 
 In the end an agreement on St Valentine's Day 1979 was cobbled together of 9 per cent plus an extra &pound;1 a week, but the stakes were going up all the time. 
 Some COHSE hospital workers told Bernard Donoughue, the Prime Minister's personal adviser: &bquo;We'll tell you straight. 
 Our purpose is to get more than you offer and whatever you offer it won't be enough.&equo; 
 Formally, the main crisis was now over, even though strikes by civil servants and many local groups continued in February and March. 
 The government and the TUC were now committed to a concordat to bring inflation down to 5 per cent over three years, while new TUC guidelines were issued over picketing and the operation of the closed shop. 
 But this hardly carried credibility in view of the collapse of three attempted wage-restraint initiatives by the Labour government since 1974, and the failure of the 1969 &bquo;solemn and binding&equo; covenant, the 1974 social contract, and a myriad other scraps of paper in the past. 
 Correctly or not, the public interpretation was of an industrial system out of control and a government in a state of near-paralysis. 
 Literally this was not so, since the emergency procedures of the Civil Contingency Unit were kept in being and it felt able to cope with almost every dispute other than that of council grave-diggers. 
 But it was obviously impossible to deal with a nation-wide emergency such as lorry-drivers' strikes, and equally impossible to respond properly to a rash of major disputes all at the same time. 
 The evidence also suggests that, in the two weeks between the Prime Minister's return from Guadeloupe and the subsequent attempts to settle the public-service strikes, there was a remarkable absence of initiative in the Cabinet and Whitehall and an unusual mood of despondency in Number 10 Downing Street. 
 Callaghan told Joel Barnett that he had never felt so depressed, and the news spread.  
 The Callaghan government never recovered from the sense of ungovernability and social chaos heralded by the winter of discontent. 
 In a vote of confidence on 28 March about the government's handling of the industrial crisis, the Liberals, the Scottish Nationalists, and most of the Ulster MPs voted with the Conservatives, while the government enlisted the support only of the 3 Welsh Nationalists, 2 Scottish Labour, and 2 Ulstermen. 
 One Labour MP, Sir Alfred Broughton, was away sick and that proved decisive. 
 The government lost by one vote, 311 to 310, and for the first time since October 1924 an administration had been voted out of office through a Commons vote. 
 The general election followed, in which Labour fought a vigorous but undeniably defensive campaign. 
 Callaghan himself followed a staid and dignified, but uncharismatic, course. 
 The main excitement, apart from the concerns of Ulster, came with disputes between Tony Benn and his NEC colleagues over the future direction to be pursued by a socialist government. 
 In the end, Callaghan managed to remove such policies as unilateralism, abolition of the House of Lords, and nationalizing the &bquo;big four&equo; banks from Labour's manifesto. 
 The polls showed a drift back towards Labour during the campaign and an NOP poll, extraordinarily, even showed a Labour lead of 0.7 per cent at the end of April, though this was not confirmed elsewhere. 
 Peter Jenkins in The Guardian  opined that &bquo;it would no longer be amazing to see Mr Callaghan win by a whisker&equo;. 
 In general, though, it was notable that Labour, as in 195 1, fought a negative and backward-looking contest, offering no new initiatives, and reiterating its well-known support for the National Health Service, public education, and fuller employment. 
 What Labour could hardly claim was that it had a magic formula for preserving peace with the unions, although the St Valentine's Day &bquo;concordat&equo; with the unions was milked for what it was worth. 
 The radicalism of the campaign came wholly from the Conservatives, redolent of the shift in the political and intellectual climate of the period generally since 1974. 
 The overall expectation was that the Conservatives would win and in the event they did so with rather more comfort than the polls had tended to suggest. 
 There was an overall majority for them of 44, which guaranteed a full term in office, with 339 Conservatives. 
 268 Labour, and only 11 for the Liberals who had clearly not benefited  from their quasi-governmental experiences of the Lib-Lab Pact. 
 Even though its vote was slightly up on that of October 1974, Labour's share of the poll had fallen to 36.9 per cent, the worst since 1931, while the Tories had risen to 43.9 per cent. 
 With the Liberals in decline and nationalism in retreat (only 2 SNP and 2 Plaid Cymru members were returned), the discontent with Labour had flowed strongly towards the Conservatives. 
 Under the leadership of a woman Prime Minister for the first time in western European history, the forces of the right, of private business, and the beleaguered middle class regrouped to redesign their nation before it was too late. 
 The &bquo;winter of discontent&equo; and the subsequent return of the Conservatives for what proved to be a very lengthy period of rule seemed to most observers to mark a profound watershed. 
 It seemed to provide an envoi  to the policies and economics of consensus, which had coincided with decades of calamitous financial and international decline. 
 Few doubted that Britain's position had eroded substantially. 
 This was powerfully expressed in a valedictory message from the retiring ambassador to Paris, Sir Nicholas Henderson, who was about to succeed Peter Jay at the British embassy in Washington. 
 The gloomy terms of his report to the then Labour Foreign Secretary, David Owen, were widely leaked. 
 Henderson drew a sharp contrast with the years after 1945 when Britain was still a major and respected force in world affairs, the dominant power in the Middle East down to the time of Suez, the second most important power in the Far East at least down to the 1954 Geneva Conference. 
 More controversially, Henderson linked subsequent failure with the inability of Britain to involve itself in &bquo;Europe&equo;. 
 either in the Schuman Plan or in the Messina Conference. 
 This meant, he argued, that in the 1960s the members of the EEC were able to develop a large and sophisticated market with much technical innovation as a result, while Britain continued to trade in its traditional markets, still partly obsessed with its Commonwealth relationships. 
 In the 1970s, Henderson argued, Britain was clearly not in the front rank, even as a European power, with its declining economy and lack of investment in managerial and engineering resources. 
 This diagnosis, that linked national decline so closely with non-membership of the European  Common Market, was open to much debate. 
 But the broad facts of internationally diminishing status, linked with economic weakness and social division at home, was generally accepted. 
 They were underlined by Labour's Defence Review of 1974&ndash;5 which committed Britain's ground forces solely to the defending of continental Europe, and stripped away the last fragments of the country's global pretensions. 
 There was, indeed, a broad sense that the gloomy seventies had brought about a transformation not only in Britain's external status but also in the main instrument and agents of planning and social policy, after the oil-price explosion, the IMF crisis, and the winter of discontent. 
 The mandarins were losing their charisma. 
 Sir Alec Cairncross, himself a distinguished practitioner of the Keynesian policies of the 1950s and 1960s, ruefully recalled in 1981 that the standing of economists, which was at its peak just after the war, was now back &bquo;at its pre-war low&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;We live in a society in which all forms of management and leadership, however advised, are under constant challenge&hellip;. 
 Consensus and cohesion in the execution of policy are increasingly hard to achieve.&equo; 
 The sense of common purpose and common direction that governed the war years had been lost, perhaps for ever. 
 In place of the Fabian imperatives of post-war planning and the corporate outlook of the 1944 White Paper, there had come sectional interest and a declining confidence in the public sector. 
 A nation unsure of its standing in the world was also unclear in its internal lines of direction and command structure. 
 No doubt, in many ways this gloom about the condition of Britain in the seventies was exaggerated. 
 The partial recovery of the economy after 1983 was to show that some of it was misplaced, and that fears about national ungovernability and inability to adapt were ill-founded. 
 The seventies came to an end with somewhat contradictory signposts of national advance or regression. 
 The arts continued to flourish, amidst growing argument over the role of the Arts Council, the right balance to be struck between the metropolitan and the regional, and between private and public funding. 
 British higher education remained another source of national pride and complacency, with the high international standing of British universities and polytechnics generally assumed, even though the  differential fees imposed on overseas students in Britain, first by the Callaghan government, and later by the Conservatives after 1979, somewhat eroded this appeal. 
 Above all, there was a general belief that, after three decades of social welfare and redistributive taxation, the spirit of Beveridge and &bquo;fair shares&equo; was not dead, and that Britain was a far more equitable society than before the war, with more genuine opportunity for different classes and races. 
 Thus, the marked advance of women in education and in the professions in the seventies was a notable, if belated testament to social advance, even if some of this progress owed much to the belligerent assertiveness of the feminist movement as well. 
 The Royal Commission on the Distribution of Income and Wealth, chaired by Lord Diamond and originally set up by the Wilson government in 1974 to appease the unions over a wealth tax, made a series of oracular judgements which confirmed the progress which was generally assumed. 
 Reporting between 1976 and 1979 it showed how the share of the before-tax distribution of wealth of the top ten per cent had fallen from nearly 30 per cent in 1959 to 26.6 per cent in 1974&ndash;5. 
 The effect of taxes and social benefits had achieved &bquo;a substantial redistribution towards equality&equo;. 
 Even at the poorer end of the scale, the effect of the distribution of benefits in cash and in kind had been substantially to equalize the wealth of older and poorer people. 
 The 20 per cent of the poorest households, who had claimed only 0.9 per cent of the &bquo;original income&equo;, rose through welfare benefits and other supplementary assistance to a &bquo;final income&equo; share of 9.0 per cent. 
 A social wage had been provided for those unable for whatever reason to earn, or those whose earning capacity had been interrupted by illness, injury, and unemployment. 
 Beyond aspects of redistribution, almost all classes of the community showed a picture of greater affluence and comfort over the past thirty years. 
 Aided by substantial tax relief on house mortgages, the proportion of owner-occupiers had risen from 29.5 per cent of dwellings in 1951 to 52.8 per cent at the end of 1975. 
 Conversely,  privately rented dwellings had fallen in proportion from 44.6 per cent at the former date to 16 per cent in 1975. 
 Clearly, a large and growing majority of occupiers owned their own home. 
 Their assets had improved in other ways also. 
 For instance, building-society deposits, bank cash accounts, and National Savings holdings all rose sharply throughout the period, especially with high interest rates prevailing for almost the whole of the 1970s. 
 It was a good decade for the rentier  and the small investor. 
 In many ways, then, it seemed that the pressure of welfare policy and social planning had indeed led both to greater equality and to more diffused prosperity as pioneers like Beveridge and theorists like Titmus had long forecast. 
 It had promoted social provision, income maintenance, and (down to 1973) full employment, in contrast to the social misery after 1919. 
 Yet there was cause for anxiety even here. 
 This affluence was disproportionately concentrated in southeast England. 
 Even in the seventies there was awareness of a &bquo;north &mdash; south&equo; divide. 
 In 1978, 42 per cent of all personal income went to 33 per cent of households concentrated in south east England, especially Greater London. 
 The new patterns of the economy, the steady decline of manufacturing industry (in which 6.5 m. of the population were directly employed at the end of the seventies) as against the rise of the service and transport sector (which employed 7.25 m. at the start of 1980) also told in favour of the redistribution of resources in favour of particular regions and occupational groups. 
 Managers, technicians, and other &bquo;lower professionals&equo; expanded in number with especial rapidity. 
 Again, the welfare state had in many respects advanced equality of opportunity, but not equality of outcome. 
 It was above all the white middle class who benefited from a free health service, earnings-related pensions, and the growth of larger secondary schools. 
 The new comprehensive schools, educationalists complained, seemed to have less social mixing than the old grammar schools had done. 
 Less than ten per cent of the  university or other higher-education student population came from working-class households. 
 The welfare state, then, had not closed the gap between classes, despite the growth of supplementary and other benefits under the 1974&ndash;9 Labour governments. 
 There had been some redistribution of income. 
 But in terms, say, of residual wealth and capital, educational mobility, or occupational status, even in everyday terms such as dress, hobbies, or accent, British social divisions remained unusually pronounced by European or transatlantic standards. 
 Some of the social and economic assumptions on which Beveridge and other pioneers had based their welfare schemes had been proved to be over-optimistic. 
 There had been steady, if slow, economic growth down to the 1970s. 
 The national income had doubled since 1948; in the period 1951&ndash;73, the average annual rate of growth was 2.3 per cent. 
 But, apart from being a relatively poor performance by international standards, national resources had not grown sufficiently to take account of total need. 
 There had been weakened competitiveness, endemic balance-of-payments problems, cyclical stop &mdash; go movements in the economy, and a falling off of the rate of capital accumulation. 
 This weakness had become far more pronounced since the oil crisis of 1973 with a severe cut-back in output and demand, and the annual percentage rate of growth in 1973&ndash;9 a mere 0.7 per cent. 
 The welfare state was a particular casualty. 
 Pensions and benefits had not risen to keep pace with the rate of inflation, especially in the 1970s. 
 Hopes that private and voluntary agencies, along with the nuclear family, could supplement the welfare state did not apply with equal validity to a society with more dislocation, more one-parent families, a growing divorce rate, and less active involvement by religious and other charitable bodies. 
 The army of social workers had indeed risen sharply. 
 At the start of the 1970s, at least 135,000 people were employed in local authority social service departments. 
 But the task was increasingly beyond them, as social surveys showed the inability of the welfare services to cope with the specific needs of  the aged, the disabled, and one-parent families. 
 Divorces rose steadily, though the real acceleration in the divorce rate was to come after the Matrimonial and Family Proceedings Act of 1 984 which allowed petitioning for divorce after only one year of marriage. 
 Especially disadvantaged were children, whose needs were dramatically highlighted by the Child Poverty Action Group and similar organizations. 
 The ending of the former child allowances and their replacement with tax-free child benefits in 1975 meant an increase in the problem of dependency, with only about half the 750,000 one-parent families in 1976, for instance, able to rely on their income as means of support. 
 An unduly high proportion of such families were black. 
 The rising toll of unemployment was another alarming problem, involving as it naturally did the families and children of the unemployed man or woman as well. 
 Over a million people found themselves dependent on supplementary benefit to eke out an inadequate existence as regards food and drink, with inflation taking its toll of what was provided. 
 Relative poverty, more markedly than absolute poverty, clearly rose rapidly throughout the 1970s. 
 On balance, social scientists glumly concluded, the welfare state, in spreading its net so wide, was often avoiding the needs of specifically targeted groups and individuals who needed help. 
 The social provision that had been Britain's thank-offering to an expectant postwar world after 1945 had left the problem of poverty, in some respects, remarkably and alarmingly unaffected. 
 It had also generated complacency and an insufficiently productive, administratively-oriented work-force. 
 In most respects, Britain spent a smaller proportion of the annual budget on welfare than did continental European countries with a system financed from contributory sources or with a greater mix of public and private provision. 
 Nor could it be said that the British welfare system identified, or even defined, let alone assisted, the genuinely needy groups as effectively as did some systems prevailing elsewhere. 
 In short, quite apart from economic or foreign policy considerations, the social momentum which had sustained the British throughout their difficult experiences since 1945 was not being maintained. 
 Underlying these themes was the belief that the problems of the British system were being thrown into stark relief by the endless economic difficulties of the 1970s. 
 The Oxford economists, Bacon and Eltis, found a receptive audience across the political spectrum  for their diagnosis that Britain was generating far too few producers of wealth. 
 In their stead came a new intermediate breed of service operatives working in administration, in finance, or in the professions. 
 University graduates became accountants, solicitors, or stock-brokers instead of entering industry. 
 One consequence in industrial terms was the greater bargaining power of professional and white-collar groups, especially focusing on their trade unions as during the &bquo;winter of discontent&equo;, able to use their bargaining muscle to claim a growing share of the national income for themselves without much compensation in manufacturing or investment. 
 Eltis linked this with the basic errors he detected in Keynesian ideas, as propounded by such recent disciples as Harrod or Kaldor, who gave full employment and job creation the priority over price stability. 
 Demand management had been given priority in preference to profitable or productive work. 
 Rather than being the workshop of the world, Britain was becoming one of the world's secretarial colleges, with priority given to non-manual clerical and service occupation. 
 While the drift out of industrial employment was common to all developed countries after 1945, in Britain in 1975 the ratio of non-industrial to industrial employment was 41 per cent, compared with 32.8 per cent in Germany, 27.9 per cent in the USA, 22.5 per cent in France, and just 4.5 per cent in Japan. 
 One pointer was the way that a growing percentage of the work-force was employed in the various activities of tourism, much of it of necessity on a shortterm or seasonal basis. 
 This disparity loomed ever larger in the rescue of the balance of payments. 
 It affected not only rural or seaside communities (some of which were now facing a crisis with the growing attractiveness of continental holidays and the inroads made by car and caravan into the traditional domain of the seaside landlady), but even industrial areas, where such attractions as Big Pit at Blaenavon in South Wales paid testimony to the passing of the age of coal. 
 The socalled &bquo;heritage&equo; industry brought large numbers of foreign and other tourists to old centres of attraction like country houses (now increasingly taken over by the National Trust), towns like Stratford, York, or Bath, and also to monuments of industrial or other archaeology. 
 But the entire heritage concept was an ambiguous one, culturally and financially. 
 It had an educative purpose, and it brought in some cash to hard-pressed regions. 
 But it also increased the focus on unproductive, marginal, service employment, and perhaps encouraged a pervasive, discontented nostalgia, in which the inheritance of the glorious past was either unrelated to, or else unhistorically contrasted with, the bleak, discontented present. 
 Survey after survey in the 1970s pointed both to growing public expenditure (much of it on defence) and yet also to a run-down public sector. 
 Trains and telephones broke down, cities and highways were grubby and unhygienic. 
 There was a failure to invest, an inability to sustain science which led to renewed talk of a &bquo;brain drain' of British scientists to American and other campuses, an inherent suspicion and division which prevented effective collaboration in industry. 
 Britain's social engineers had prided themselves on the ability to plan as they had done during the war. 
 But compared with the Monnet ideal in France, or the corporate strategy of Japan, Britain had scarcely planned in any meaningful sense at all. 
 Harold Wilson's &bquo;white heat&equo; talk of 1963 seemed in 1979 extraordinarily dated. 
 Michael Shanks, author of the powerful Stagnant Society  of 1961, bitterly criticized fifteen years later the sterile failure of the planning imperative. 
 In 1977, at the time of the Bullock Committee on remoulding industrial relations, Chancellor Helmut Schmidt of West Germany had been brought in to instruct the Prime Minister, Callaghan, and Britain's industrial leaders and trade unionists on the need to frame a new industrial climate as a basis for productive growth and a revived influence in the world. 
 Callaghan and some of the CBI, at least, were duly impressed. 
 But the consequences were abuse from the unions, hostility from the CBI, caution in Whitehall and Westminster, and no real change at all. 
 Bullock's call for worker-directors was generally derided as utopian. 
 The very lack of dynamism, or pro-active vision in British industry, government, and scientific development, while widely perceived and understood, resisted efforts at reform.  
 The &bquo;winter of discontent&equo; thus encouraged a wider sense of national enfeeblement and decline. 
 There was a tidal wave of pessi &mdash; mistic literature on this theme &mdash; The Future that Doesn't Work: Social Democracy's Failures in Britain  (1977); The Politics of Economic Decline  (1979); Britain: Progress and Decline  (1980); and, most evocatively of all, Is Britain Dying ? 
 (1979). 
 History text-books invariably included in their titles such key-words as &bquo;Decline&equo;, &bquo;Downfall&equo;, and &bquo;Eclipse&equo;. 
 Turmoil in industrial relations, ethnic disturbances, the growth of violent crime, even the dismal competitive record of British footballers, cricketers, and tennis players, were all grist to the commentators' mill. 
 The roots of all this, it was agreed, lay deep in British history &mdash; perhaps in the moral nihilism of the 1960s, perhaps in the collectivism of the 1940s, perhaps in the decline of the entrepreneurial spirit in the late Victorian period, perhaps even in the many centuries of geographical isolation and freedom from foreign occupation behind the barrier of sea power. 
 The point of reference for the origins of Britain's eclipse could be placed almost anywhere from 1968 back to 1066. 
 But, however sketchy or plain foolish the history and social anthropology might be, the existence of long-term degeneration, in some key respects at least, commanded widespread assent. 
 One demographic factor, much noted, was that the British, an old nation, were an increasingly elderly people. 
 The proportion of the population over 60 rose to nearly 29 per cent by 1980, most of them women. 
 At the other end of the age-scale, renewal was less in evidence. 
 In the seventies, after a rise in the birth-rate from the midfifties to the mid-sixties, creating a &bquo;bulge&equo; in the school and student population in the 1970s, there was a gradual decline in the birthrate in the seventies. 
 The Registrar-General's statistics showed a low point of 11.8 per cent of live births per 1,000 of the population in 1977, with a slight rise thereafter. 
 In part, this was because of  rising affluence, and a sense of financial and other independence among women. 
 Working women were delaying or curtailing their capacity to bear children, marrying later or perhaps being reluctant to have children at all. 
 The rise of a new stratum of child-minders and cr&ecirc;che facilities, public or private, was testimony to the wish of women to lead more relaxed, interesting, child-free lives, accentuated by the fact of more women being middle class in status or perhaps aspiration. 
 The classic working-class &bquo;mum&equo;, living at home to look after her numerous children with the man as the bread-winner, while a folk myth sustained by the Inland Revenue and the population census amongst others in the 1970s, conformed less and less to the reality. 
 These factors might well be seen as socially beneficial. 
 But many commentators saw only a decline in the desire to rear or look after children, a weakening of the cohesive effects of the family, and an associated diminution of the buoyancy of the stock in terms familiar at least since the Boer War. 
 The partial compensation found in the fertility of the black and brown immigrants of the Commonwealth countries who had sent over 3 million people into Britain since 1962 did not meet with universal enthusiasm, as the evidence from the Race Relations Board frequently suggested. 
 Afro-Caribbeans huddled in ghetto areas like Brixton or Southall. 
 Non-white Britons were having a growing impact, notably in mass sport and entertainment; commercial advertisements to an increasing degree focused on a poly-ethnic consumer market. 
 But only an enlightened few saw this as a symbol of national renewal. 
 In the face of this varied sense of internal malaise, the return of the Thatcher government, with its young-Turk generation of monetarists and entrepreneurs, marked at least a change of gear, even if the privatization of publicly-owned enterprises was a very minor feature of the Conservative manifesto in 1979. 
 An updated welfare state was linked with &bquo;strengthening family life&equo;. 
 As yet there was no great sense that the policies of welfare and social egalitarianism since 1945 needed to be reversed. 
 The recasting of economic policy in a supply-side direction still remained the faith of a minority. 
 But that there was need for a substantial change in British society was a widespread conclusion. 
 The British in 1979 were poised between a reverence for old historic symbols which had provided order and cohesion over the centuries, and an uneasy awareness that such reverence had become a recipe for immobilism and devotion to the outdated totems of the past. 
 Polls in the state of  public opinion and attitudes offered contrary findings. 
 They suggested that, despite everything, most British people remained calm. 
 They continued to prefer (and, indeed, to expect) a quiet life. 
 A poll commissioned by the EEC in 1977 showed that 82 per cent of the population declared themselves to be broadly satisfied with living in Britain, compared with 68 per cent in France and 59 per cent in Italy. 
 Compared with most continentals and, indeed, Americans, the British by this crude test were a relatively happy people. 
 Their democracy had remained secure. 
 Suggestions in 1975 of a military coup by Colonel Stirling's &bquo;non-party, non-class organization of apprehensive patriots&equo; or General Walker's &bquo;non-class Militia&equo; met with almost universal derision. 
 So, too, did the alarmist outpourings of the National Association for Freedom, a far-right pressure-group directed by a clutch of ex-army officers and Norris McWhirter, better known as the author of the Guinness Book of Records  and apologist for South Africa. 
 At the same time, the British were in distinctly worried mood. 
 Since 1961 (to be precise, since Selwyn Lloyd's &bquo;pay pause&equo; that summer) British people had given sustaining the economy the priority over foreign affairs among their concerns. 
 They had become increasingly introspective. 
 In the sixties, polls showed that, even if they believed that they themselves were doing rather well, most British people felt that their country was doing rather badly, and falling further behind foreign competitors. 
 By the late 1970s, both private and public expectations were in parallel decline. 
 Britain in mid-1979 was unlikely to lurch into any drastic transformation, let alone a dictatorship. 
 Record inflation would not reproduce the panic of the Weimar Republic in the twenties, nor the &bquo;winter of discontent&equo; the pre-Vichy, neo-fascist despair of the French Third Republic in the later thirties. 
 The British had no wish to move elsewhere. 
 Emigration to Australia or New Zealand, let alone the United States, which had its own extreme problems of crime and racial violence, was little more than a trickle. 
 Like the immortal &bquo;Old Bill&equo; in Bruce Bairns father's First World War cartoon of the trenches, the patient British urged their neighbours that if they knew of &bquo;a better'ole&equo; they should go to it. 
  For all that, it was a dismal phase in the chequered history of postwar Britain. 
 The urge for a redirection of effort to repair national self-esteem was predominant as the unpermissive, unproductive seventies came to their close.   
 Storm and Stress 1979&ndash;1989 
 The Foundations of &bquo;Thatherism&equo; 1979&ndash;1983 
 MORE than any change of government since 1945, Margaret Thatcher's election victory was taken as marking a decisive shift in the national mood, politically, intellectually, and culturally. 
 The fall of James Callaghan in the summer of 1979 meant, according to most commentators across the political spectrum, the end of an ancien r&eacute;gime , a system of corporatism, Keynesian spending programmes, subsidized welfare, and trade-union power. 
 To enthusiasts, it meant the passing of &bquo;the dependency culture&equo; in favour of a new wave of enterprise and individualism. 
 After forming the core of a post-war consensus for over three decades since the Attlee period, the bitter legacy of the old order was now seen in the uncollected refuse bins and undug graves which popular credence (somewhat exaggeratedly) identified with &bquo;the winter of discontent&equo;. 
 On all sides, both in the government service directly and in its associated echelons of closed institutions, corporations, committees, and &bquo;quangos&equo;, there had been evidence of a loss of national confidence. 
 The conventional wisdom of the pre-1970 period had perished in the &bquo;stagflation&equo; and social strife of the recent past. 
 In place of the chastened, latter-day apostles of Keynes and Beveridge, a new generation of hard-headed spokesmen of free enterprise emerged, taking their cue from the dogmas of the new Prime Minister herself. 
 Certainly there was abundant evidence as to how the centre-left had lost its entrenched intellectual and ideological ascendancy. 
 As the Thatcher government gradually recovered from a shaky and difficult start to retain power  by a hugely increased majority in 1983, followed by another overwhelming electoral triumph (in seats if not in votes) in 1987 and as the spectacle was observed in 1989 of a Prime Minister remaining in unchallenged power for over a decade, comparable to Lord Liverpool if not yet Robert Walpole in the past, the belief took hold that the values and style of modern Britain had been transformed. 
 More than any Prime Minister since Lloyd George, Mrs Thatcher appeared justified in proclaiming after some years in office, &bquo;I have changed everything&equo;. 
 To adopt her favourite adverbs, everything had been &bquo;totally and utterly&equo; transformed, or so it seemed. 
 By the mid-1980s, this became increasingly the accepted view of what the Thatcher years had meant for Britain as a society and a polity. 
 On the political right, this implied the triumph of the market philosophy, the private ethic, and the imperatives of early-nineteenth-century liberalism in place of the dead hand of state-directed corporatism which Attlee, Macmillan, Wilson, and Heath had variously created. 
 Mrs Thatcher appeared to see herself as the embodiment of revenge upon a whole generation of social engineers. 
 She committed herself to the view that &bquo;there was no such thing as society&equo;, only individuals and families, an extraordinary reaction against the outlook of the past forty years. 
 On the political left, a popular approach was to adopt the terminology of the long-dead Italian Marxist, Antonio Gramsci, to argue that Thatcherism was more than a governmental system, more even than an ideological banner. 
 It was truly a hegemony that extended the market ethic beneath the shelter of an increasingly powerful state apparatus, at the cost of both social cohesion and personal liberty. 
 It penetrated the very substructure of national culture, with the message of traditional capitalism proclaimed in an unusually explicit and aggressive form. 
 Between the ideologues and monetarists of the New Right, and the revisionist Marxists of the New Left, defenders of what they took to be the post-1945 social order floundered unhappily. 
 One after another, down to the end of 1988 at least, attempts to reform or redefine the old consensus on &bquo;one-nation&equo; lines proved ineffective. 
 Hopes  attached to the new Social Democratic Party of right-wing Labour Party defectors in 1981 collapsed after the internal divisions that followed electoral disaster in June 1987. 
 By mid-1989 the centre in British politics, split between the renamed &bquo;Democrats&equo;, the remaining Social Democrats, and &bquo;green&equo; environmentalists, seemed weaker than at any time since the leadership of the old Liberals by Jo Grimond at the time of &bquo;Orpington man&equo; in the early 1960s. 
 The Labour Party, riven by schism and self-doubt, seemed in long-term, inexorable decline, for sociological as well as ideological reasons. 
 The long march to 1945 and beyond had truly been halted. 
 Large sections of the community, especially the blacks in the urban ghettos, young unemployed in urban areas of the north, and a considerable swathe of the people of Scotland, seemed almost to contract out from traditional forms of participation and civic involvement. 
 The cultural activity of the land remained vigorous, with a notable revival, for instance, in British sculpture. 
 But the new generation of novelists and playwrights in the 1980s were somewhat more inward-looking in finding their cultural stimulation than, say, their predecessors in the fifties and sixties. 
 They were increasingly prone to introspective analysis without a social cutting edge. 
 Successful, Booker Prize-winning women novelists such as Anita Brookner or Penelope Lively, for example, did not reflect the feminist awareness of the time to any marked extent. 
 Aspects of class, race, or nationalism passed them by, though this was less true of another distinguished author, Margaret Drabble. 
 John Osborne's Look Back in Anger  was presented in a new production in 1989 as a study of a failed marriage rather than of the playwright's early ideological concerns. 
 Truly, there were now &bquo;no great causes left&equo;. 
 Meanwhile, significant groups of intellectuals and artists, often in a somewhat modish, self-conscious way which attracted derision in the press, seemed to move away from identification with their society, so alien to their instincts did what they saw as the unacceptable, philistine face of Thatcherism appear to be. 
 In the face of the self-confident panache of the new monetarists, the Policy Studies group, and the apostles of the market-place, significant numbers of British intellectuals seemed to lose heart. 
 There was open, if despairing, resistance in the plays of David Hare, Howard Brenton, or David Edgar, or in a realist film like My Beautiful Laundrette . 
 Critics tried to rescue older notions of &bquo;community&equo; or &bquo;citizenship&equo; to set against the competitive values of the Thatcher government &mdash;  only to discover that the latter was highly adept in taking over these themes itself in such areas as housing, education, and &bquo;neighbourhood watch&equo; crime-prevention schemes, partly as a weapon against left-wing local authorities. 
 In the summer of 1988, a group of writers and other intellectuals, ranging from Alliance supporters to Euro-Communists, formed a new journal, Samizdat . 
 It openly evoked the example of the Soviet dissidents, and voiced the despair of liberals of varying shades at what had happened to the fabric of British society since 1979. 
 Not until the spring and summer of 1989 when, for the first time, the Thatcher government showed clear signs of frailty, with electoral defeats, economic difficulties, and internal acrimony which recalled the later years of Macmillan's government in the early 1960s, did the critics begin to regain their confidence. 
 For the first time in a decade the Thatcherite crusade seemed to be faltering, though how permanently it was too early to judge. 
 The new regime took its cue, to a truly extraordinary extent, from the personality and outlook of the new Prime Minister. 
 Margaret Thatcher was remarkable, of course, for being the first woman Prime Minister, and she could use this factor to persuade or beguile male colleagues on occasion. 
 But it was very seldom her femininity, but rather her image of toughness, determination, and ruthless single-mindedness that dominated public perceptions. 
 She took office in May 1979, proclaiming on the steps of Number 10 Downing Street the healing words of St Francis of Assisi &mdash; &bquo;where there is discord, may we bring harmony.&equo; 
 Yet it was not the message of saintly benevolence but the jarring note of conflict, belligerence, and confrontation which marked her style from the outset. 
 Moderates or doubters were dismissed as &bquo;wets&equo; or sometimes &bquo;wimps&equo;. 
 From the outset, Mrs Thatcher had the sense of being a political outsider. 
 It went far beyond her role as a woman in public life. 
 She was the self-conscious product of a grocer's shop and a frugal Methodist background in Grantham in rural Lincolnshire. 
 Her exemplar was her father, a local patriarch and evidently an apostle of Samuel Smiles-type individualism: she omitted reference to her mother in Who's Who . 
 A minister in the Heath government, she had rebelled totally against its corporate style, and joined with Sir Keith Joseph in forming the Centre for Policy Studies in 1 974 as a forum for  proclaiming the cause of market individualism and monetary discipline. 
 She was elected as Tory leader in 1975 as the voice of petit bourgeois  protest in the constituencies, as against grandees like Whitelaw, Carrington, or Pym. 
 It has been perceptively written that her victory was the product of a kind of &bquo;peasants' revolt&equo; within the Tory Party. 
 She rejected the complacent, paternalist inactivity of the &bquo;common ground&equo;. 
 Her ability, like that of Lloyd George (a previous premier for whom she had no affection) to project herself as an outsider, detached from her party leadership, her civil service, even the Cabinet which she led, was a vital key to her effectiveness and impact. 
 When she was attacked by her venerable predecessor Harold Macmillan (now elevated to the Lords as the Earl of Stockton) for &bquo;selling off the family silver&equo;, it added to her proud sense of detachment. 
 Mrs Thatcher was usually termed &bquo;a conviction politician&equo;, most at home with others of that stern, unbending creed. 
 Moderates, liberals, &bquo;wet&equo; Tories of the old school, were witheringly dismissed as &bquo;not one of us&equo;. 
 She was not an intellectual; her philosophical baggage was comparatively light. 
 The abiding influence, it appeared, was that of the venerable Austrian anti-statist, Friedrich von Hayek, a critic of encroaching government since before the 1945 election. 
 Mrs Thatcher claimed to have read Hayek's Road to Serfdom  while she was still a student at Somerville College, Oxford, just after the war; but it was not until the 1970s, while in opposition, that she seems to have read Hayek's writings more generally. 
 In any case, her main ideological inspiration, like that of Lloyd George, came from people rather than from books. 
 One ideological guru was businessman, Sir Alfred Sherman, founder with her of the Centre for Policy Studies in 1974. 
 Even more did she rely on the guidance of Sir Keith Joseph, another rebel against the Heath interlude, whose speeches in 1974 first traced the clear lines of monetarism and market strategy which by 1979 had become the orthodoxy in many Conservative circles. 
 The main thrust of Thatcherite social and economic philosophy was far from clear when she took office in May 1979, so entrenched were key figures of the Heathite past in the party; but the general thrust would clearly lie in pursuing the monetarist approach of the Chicago economist, Milton Friedman, in which control of the money supply  through M3 indicators, and identifying inflation rather than unemployment as the central enemy, were the fundamental themes. 
 The central issue was seen to be the relationship between the growth or contraction of the money supply and the pattern of national income and expenditure. 
 In general, though, Mrs Thatcher's approach was not really philosophical at all. 
 Indeed, instinct rather than inductive reasoning marked her approach to life. 
 In the Burkeian sense, she followed prejudice and (sometimes) prescription. 
 Time and again, she would turn to simple, homely precepts drawn from the grocer's shop in Grantham, embellished with strongly held views about human nature. 
 On one famous occasion, these were defined as &bquo;Victorian values&equo;. 
 This implied a distinctly selective view of the nineteenth century which omitted Dickens, Disraeli, Arnold, and Ruskin among others. 
 More than any Prime Minister, perhaps, since Douglas-Home, she had little interest in the development or clash of ideas. 
 It followed that her associates and most admired colleagues were invariably businessmen or entrepreneurs rather than intellectuals, writers, or artists, doers rather than talkers or thinkers. 
 She formed a distinctly close relationship with some business figures prominent in the Jewish community, though this did not unduly colour her view of the state of Israel. 
 She symbolized her down-to-earth philosophy in her own busy persona, ceaselessly active, endlessly combative at home and abroad, hardly ever taking a holiday, never relaxing with music, books, or in the world of the arts. 
 She apparently read every civil-service memorandum, personally confronted or abused officials, and intervened in departmental affairs as few premiers had done since Sir Robert Peel. 
 In time she also found allies in a handful of civil servants like Charles Powell and Sir Bernard Cradock and an occasional diplomat like Sir Anthony Duff and Sir Crispin Tickell. 
 On all issues, she appeared formidably well-informed. 
 A politician of intuition not of intellect, she served as the perfect antidote to the cerebral doctrines of the Keynesian planners of the 1945&ndash;79 period, against whose dominion she had so memorably rebelled. 
 It was not endearing, comfortable, or perhaps attractive. 
 But for many years after 1979 this approach seemed to embody many of the qualities which a depressed, declining nation yearned for and acclaimed. 
 The real essence of &bquo;Thatcherism&equo;, indeed, lay not so much in its ideas, which proved to be increasingly malleable as the years went by, and especially when Nigel Lawson took over the Treasury in  1984. 
 It lay rather in the company it kept, the classes with which it was associated. 
 As noted, Mrs Thatcher came from a relatively humble, unprivileged background, though a degree at Oxford and later marriage to a millionaire businessman gave her a distinctly haut bourgeois  status in time. 
 But her outlook was subtly different, say from that of Edward Heath, whose father was a carpenter in a small town in Kent and who, like Mrs Thatcher, went to a local grammar school rather than the private boarding schools favoured by most Tory leaders. 
 The Heath background was one of constructive, but deferential, working-class Toryism. 
 The Thatcher background was one of entrepreneurial, upwardly-mobile, self-sufficient, middle-class neo-liberalism. 
 It followed that her main associates and the figures to whom she was most naturally attracted, and who in turn revered her ascendancy, were self-made businessmen and smaller entrepreneurs, usually from the fields of finance, speculation, and investment. 
 The roots of Thatcherism lay in acquisition rather than in production. 
 It sought to create a business, perhaps a rentier , culture. 
 Its spokeswoman imposed on the Conservative Party values very different from those of industrialists like Peel, Bonar Law, or Baldwin in the past. 
 She was liable to propel into the governmental system men associated with business success, of whom Lord Young became the prototype from 1984 onwards She was truly a distinctive phenomenon, linked neither with the patrician values of the grandees in the shires, nor with the manufacturing Tories of northern England cherished by Disraelian Tory Democracy in the last century, nor again with the suburban Toryism dominant in the party in the interwar years and after 1951. 
 Mrs Thatcher gloried, among other things, in being a provincial, whose Lincolnshire origins would sometimes come out unexpectedly in her rhetoric. 
 Such time-honoured Conservative themes as reverence for the Church and the gentry, for &bquo;one-nation&equo; cohesion in the romantic style of the Primrose League, made little impact on this perpetually embattled leader. 
 Her relationship with Queen Elizabeth II was believed to be frosty and her regard for the Commonwealth, now dominated by black- and brown-skinned leaders from Africa and Asia, slight. 
 She made precious few concessions to the old orthodoxies. 
 Her detachment from her own party as well as her nation added to her strength and sense of invincibility. 
 The nation expected a radical new impetus from Mrs Thatcher in May 1979, but it was curiously long in coming. 
 For, alongside the  conviction politics, and the violent rhetoric, was in practice an ingrained pragmatism. 
 After all, Mrs Thatcher was also a supreme politician, not just an evangelist. 
 She could eat her words, while denying with the maximum of emphasis that she was ever &bquo;for turning&equo;. 
 In fact, her first administration down to June 1983 showed the impact of Thatcherite policies to be somewhat muted, with even so single-minded a Prime Minister apparently lacking in direction. 
 There are many reasons for this. 
 No doubt it was hard to dismantle, or even dent, the consensus policies of thirty-five years at a stroke. 
 There were also inherited pledges which no new Prime Minister could disavow. 
 Thus, the Conservative attack on inflation and public-sector wage explosions was in part nullified by the Clegg awards on pay comparability. 
 This meant a huge rise of &pound;1&frac14; billion in public-sector wage settlements in 1979&ndash;80 and drove inflation up far higher than the Callaghan government had ever done previously. 
 The decisive factor, though, was that Mrs Thatcher, for all her election triumph, was far from being mistress in her own house yet. 
 With far more reason than Harold Wilson in 1964, she could claim to be running ( mutatis mutandis ) a Bolshevik revolution with a Tsarist Cabinet. 
 The domination of the old Heath Conservatives in her first Cabinet was overwhelming. 
 Lord Carrington, a consensual aristocrat of the old school whose experience of government went back to 1951, had to be Foreign Secretary. 
 The Home Secretary was Willie Whitelaw, another traditional practitioner of one-nation ideas, and a major influence on party and government. 
 James Prior went to the Department of Employment; in the words of one critic, Jock Bruce-Gardyne, he was to make this key department a citadel of &bquo;unrepentant corporatism&equo;. 
 Francis Pym went to Defence; Peter Walker to Agriculture; Sir Ian Gilmour also to the Foreign Office; Norman St John-Stevas became Leader of the House. 
 Against these powerful Heathite figures, there were indeed very few colleagues whom the Prime Minister could safely regard as &bquo;one of us&equo;. 
 The minority included Sir Keith Joseph, who took his bleak monetarist outlook to the Department of Trade and Industry, and John Biffen, an early apostle of Enoch Powell's financial credo, who became a Treasury Minister (and who also shared the Prime Minister's lack of enthusiasm for &bquo;Europe&equo;). 
 Lower down in the government were such potential  agents of &bquo;Thatcherism&equo; as David Howell and (more doubtfully) Nigel Lawson. 
 The rogue figure of Angus Maude became Paymaster-General, another symbol of revolt against Macmillan-style &mdash; politics and an opponent of the consensus approach. 
 But, in general, fully three-quarters of her first Cabinet were identified with the mainstream Toryism of post-1945. 
 They were welfare democrats and public spenders, not at all in tune with Mrs Thatcher's awkward imperatives. 
 This was the supreme limiting restraint upon her ascendancy. 
 Not until the end of 1981 did she begin to fight free of their domination. 
 The real test of Thatcherite radicalism would surely lie with its economic and financial policies. 
 Here, the appropriate leader of change had been in some doubt. 
 Some Conservatives, astonishingly enough, had even visualized the return to the Treasury of Roy Jenkins, a Labour minister until 1976 and now President of the European Commission in Brussels. 
 In fact, though, the new Chancellor turned out to be the emollient figure of Sir Geoffrey Howe, once a vaguely progressive Heathite minister too, but a notable convert to monetarism in the later 1970s. 
 His yielding to the edicts of Number 10 on financial policy eventually enabled the main thrust of Thatcherite innovation to show itself here, even though it was often the moderation as much as the radicalism which was to impress observers. 
 Certainly, the Treasury was to be a major battle ground between contending philosophies. 
 Its respective champions were personified by the Permanent Secretary, Sir Douglas Wass, an entrenched mandarin prone to statements like &bquo;We're all Keynesians here&equo;, and Mrs Thatcher's new army of private advisers, monetarist apostles like Terry Burns and, from 1981, Alan Walters. 
 Not until two years had passed was the outcome of these disputes at all clear. 
 Geoffrey Howe's first budget on 14 June 1979, only three weeks after the government had been in office, marked out the early objectives of the monetarist advance. 
 It included a sharp attack on public spending, with cash limits on the public sector, the raising of minimum lending rate to 14 per cent, some sale of public assets to help finance the public-sector borrowing requirement, and a major switch from direct taxation to taxes on spending. 
 The standard rate of income tax was lowered to 30 per cent, whereas the raising of  Value Added Tax and other indirect taxes switched tax policy to focus on expenditure. 
 The supply side was elevated in contrast to, Keynesian demand management. 
 Exchange controls were also notably relaxed; in the autumn they were to be abolished altogether. 
 This strikingly different budget was clearly intended to spearhead a monetarist assault on cost inflation. 
 Yet, in fact, inflation continued to rise sharply, partly through the effect of the Clegg awards. 
 Howe's budget deflated the economy and seriously added to unemployment. 
 Yet it managed to raise prices and to add to inflation at one and the same time. 
 For the next year and a half, the attainment of the monetarist objectives proved exceptionally difficult. 
 For the nation as a whole, the visible effect was a huge rise in unemployment and a vast drop in the gross domestic product, with factories, mills, and pits closing down all over the country. 
 In 1979&ndash;81, while other nations saw their GDP rise by 5.3 per cent, Britain's fell by 2.5 per cent. 
 Unemployment rose to 13.3 per cent, the highest in Western Europe. 
 Britain's productive capacity was falling more rapidly than at any time since the dawn of the industrial age. 
 Howe's second budget of March 1980 assumed a drop of 2 per Cent in the real national income, and continuing and rising unemployment. 
 After a year in office, the Thatcher government found itself presiding over mass de-industrialization, inflation of more than 20 per cent, a rise in public spending, and the prospects of a slump. 
 Only the blessings of a continuing income from North Sea oil kept the balance of payments in reasonable condition, but even here the emergence of the pound as a &bquo;petro-currency&equo; (along with high interest rates) led to its appreciation in value to the cost of British exports. 
 A government elected to cut public spending and reduce inflation as the basis for economic recovery had achieved, it seemed, exactly the reverse. 
 The arguments within the Thatcher administration went on apace over whether to swing the axe fiercely into public spending in the winter of 1980&ndash;1, with ministers like Prior, Pym, Walker, and Carrington arguing the case for maintaining public expenditure and investment, monetarists outside the government like Alan Budd urging far more stringent monetary restraint, and Sir Geoffrey Howe at the Treasury buffeted about in between. 
 The bleakness of the government's economic approach was never more apparent. 
 The  Heathite ministers effectively won the Cabinet debates over the public-spending round in the autumn of 1980, but their victory was short-lived. 
 The Howe budget of March 1 98 1 marked a clear triumph for the monetarists and a new level of austerity. 
 In the face of the open dissent of Prior, Pym, Walker, and Gilmour, and even some resistance from the Chancellor of the Exchequer himself, the Prime Minister, urged on by her newest economic adviser, Professor Alan Walters, forced through the most resolutely anti-Keynesian budget of modern times. 
 It imposed Britain's biggest-ever tax increases, including a rise of 20p in petrol tax, and heavy taxation on smokers and drinkers. 
 A total of &pound;3,500 million was taken out of the public-sector borrowing requirement. 
 Never before had there been so savage a fiscal squeeze; not since the thirties had there been a comparable increase in unemployment, now approaching 3 million. 
 There were widespread murmurs in Tory ranks, and the government's standing fell to only 27 per cent in the polls of March 1981. 
 A total of 364 economists, almost one for each day of the year, dispatched a formal letter to The Times  denouncing the government's economic approach as ruinous &mdash; though they were soon matched by a similarly large number of economists who were prepared to endorse it. 
 Both the city and the CBI were strongly critical of the budget: Sir Terence Beckett of the CBI spoke of the need to have a &bquo;bare-knuckle fight&equo; with the government, though this aggressive posture later disappeared. 
 The government seemed to be presiding over massive industrial contraction; Mrs Thatcher at this time was the most unpopular Prime Minister since Neville Chamberlain in 1939. 
 At the 1 980 Tory Party Conference she pronounced stubbornly that &bquo;the lady's not for turning&equo;. 
 There would be no &bquo;U-turns&equo; in financial policy. 
 But the cost of such rigour, both in economic and political terms, seemed almost unacceptable. 
 In fact, the government's policy from 1982 onwards became somewhat less rigid. 
 This was in part because it was simply not working. 
 The effect of high interest rates and a &bquo;petro-pound&equo; was to strengthen sterling; the consequences were for exports to sag and for inflationary pressure to increase rather than diminish. 
 Government ministers tried to stem the tide of mounting public expenditure: John Nott's replacing Francis Pym at the Ministry of Defence in January 1981 was thought to be a pointer in this direction. 
 Public spending  continued to rise nevertheless, not least because of the colossal bill of social-security payments to relieve the rising number of unemployed. 
 But after this period economic policy showed some moderation. 
 Attempts to claim that M3 was a precise yardstick of the money supply were abandoned; after all, it had actually expanded by 20 per cent with high inflation. 
 The much more limited test of M1, &bquo;narrow money&equo;, including non-interest-bearing deposits, was favoured instead. 
 New curbs on wage settlements reminiscent of Selwyn Lloyd's &bquo;guiding light&equo; of the early 1960s replaced the doctrinaire &bquo;hands-off&equo; policy of 1979&ndash;81. 
 As production began to recover somewhat during 1982, and inflation to fall (partly because of an improvement in the US economy), a less rigorous approach was adopted towards the money supply in the 1982 budget, while &pound;1.3 billion in taxes were prudently &bquo;given away&equo;. 
 By the end of the first Thatcher administration, even Geoffrey Howe was scarcely to be identified as a strict monetarist, and the &bquo;medium-term financial strategy, was in retreat. 
 Mrs Thatcher, ironically, now found herself criticized by the Chicago sage, Milton Friedman, for failing to apply the monetarist remedy with sufficient consistency or determination. 
 The major achievement that could be claimed by March 1983 &mdash; a notable one indeed &mdash; was that inflation had fallen from a peak of 22 per cent in early 1980 to a mere 5 per cent. 
 On the other hand, this was partly the result of huge unemployment depressing demand and consumer pressure, while the sharp fall of sterling against both the dollar and the deutschmark was also not what was intended. 
 It also reflected the passing of the second OPEC price shock of 1979&ndash;80. 
 At the time of the June 1983 general election, with Geoffrey Howe widely believed to be destined for transfer to the Foreign Office, the financial strategy unveiled in his first budget of June 1979 was being quietly buried. 
 Its major advocate, Professor Alan Walters, was back in the United States teaching economics. 
 While far from being a &bquo;wet&equo; herself, Mrs Thatcher was presiding over a distinctly watered-down form of Tory economic policy by the summer of 1983. 
 The relative caution of her first administration was equally confirmed in industrial and social policy. 
 For all the anti-statist rhetoric of the 1979 campaign, privatization, or the dismantling of public enterprise, was not seriously on the agenda down to 1983. 
 The sale of part of the assets of BP oil owned by the government in Howe's  first budget did little more than continue the policy of Denis Healey's Labour budget of 1976. 
 There was little or no attempt to denationalize the giant state monopolies thereafter. 
 Privatizing Cable and Wireless, Amersham International, even Britoil, excited only limited controversy. 
 There were, indeed, large subsidies still being paid to state-owned industries such as British Leyland, Rolls Royce, and the coal and steel industries, even by that apparently doctrinaire minister of Trade and Industry, Sir Keith Joseph. 
 The discipline of cash limits was repeatedly disregarded, with political factors often intervening to soften the government's monetarist convictions. 
 Thus the political decision was taken to keep all five major steel plants in operation, including the distinctly vulnerable plant in Ravenscraig in Scotland. 
 Celtic nationalist passion certainly was a factor here. 
 On the trade unions too, the Thatcher government again proved to be more cautious than its language might imply. 
 Under the aegis of James Prior, the Department of Employment was unlikely to go in for strongly anti-union policies. 
 Prior's Trade Union Act of 1980 was a moderate measure intended to forestall further attacks on union power. 
 There would be public money to provide union ballots on strikes and leadership changes. 
 Closed-shop arrangements would be made more difficult and secondary picketing outlawed, to avoid the kind of violence that had disfigured the Grunwick dispute. 
 On balance, the least inflammatory of the available options were selected. 
 More rigorous was the measure introduced by Prior's right-wing successor at Employment, Norman Tebbit, in 1982. 
 This went further by challenging the immunity that the unions had enjoyed from any financial damages incurred during strikes, a privilege dating from the Liberal government's Trade Disputes Act of 1906. 
 Henceforth unions could be fined very heavily for conducting what were deemed to be unlawful strikes: several of them were to suffer accordingly, starting with the National Graphical Association. 
 Tebbit's bill also applied firmer penalties to secondary picketing, and gave compensation for those dismissed as a result of closed-shop agreements. 
 Even so, the unions' power to strike and picket remained  substantial; Tebbit found himself unable to outlaw the closed shop entirely. 
 Despite the Act of 1982, Mrs Thatcher was obliged to give some ground to the unions on a number of occasions. 
 Thus, in February 1981, in the face of a series of lightning strikes in parts of the coal industry, notably in the Welsh mining valleys, the government had to retreat and extend a subsidy for this struggling industry in a way totally at variance with its basic philosophy. 
 A similarly timid attitude had to be taken with regard to strikes by ASLEF, the train-drivers' union, and the bailing out of British Rail. 
 Certainly, the government's rhetoric towards the union was much harsher, with the replacement of Prior by Tebbit at Employment a symbol of it. 
 Len Murray and the TUC General Council found themselves frozen out from communication with government to an extent unknown since before 1939. 
 But what was really neutralizing the power of the unions was the growing economic crisis and resultant unemployment. 
 The number of strikes fell dramatically; in 1981 only 4.2 million days were lost in industrial disputes compared with an average 13 million per year throughout the seventies. 
 Union membership had fallen from over 13 million in 1980 to below 10 million three years later. 
 The TUC itself, and especially Len Murray, repeatedly threw its influence, such as it was, against militancy and against challenging the government through industrial action. 
 In industries like British Leyland, workers were disavowing their own shop stewards; the star of such local firebrands as &bquo;Red Robbo&equo; and Alan &bquo;The Mole&equo; Thornett seemed to have set. 
 It was really wider economic and sociological factors which were expunging memories of the &bquo;winter of discontent&equo; and uncontrolled union power, rather than the policies of the Thatcher government, which in this early period were broadly non-confrontational. 
 Social policy showed the same relatively moderate trend. 
 In one important area, indeed, the Thatcher government did launch a bold change of course, and one that had widespread popular backing among working people. 
 This was the conscious policy of furthering the sale of council houses, promoted by Michael Heseltine's Housing  Act of 1980. 
 This was attacked by Labour as dismantling the housing welfare programme as it had existed since 1945, or perhaps since the Addison Act of 1919. 
 But amongst many working-class Labour voters, the prospect of emulating their middle-class neighbours and owning their own homes on tax-subsidized mortgages proved irresistible. 
 This break with post-war social assumptions proved relatively easy to initiate: by the end of 1984, 800,000 council tenants were buying their own homes. 
 Elsewhere, the government proved to be surprisingly cautious. 
 The National Health Service, though evidently under-funded, was to survive as the basis of the health-care system of the nation. 
 Radical plans to remodel the education system, especially anything which resembled the undermining of the comprehensive secondary schools against which Tories had long since railed, were scrapped. 
 So, too, were proposals to end the state-funding of higher education and charge full-cost fees, or alternatively abolish the system of grants for university students (a particularly unpopular idea amongst middle-class Tory voters). 
 On the other hand, Britain's universities were afflicted from 1 98 1 with very severe cuts in their funding, amounting to a 2 per cent drop in income for most universities. 
 The era of the 1963 Robbins Report had truly come to an end. 
 With memories of the student &bquo;unrest&equo; of the late sixties still part of the living past, Sir Keith Joseph was able to impose a stern monetary discipline upon British higher education with the prospect, many feared, that some universities and polytechnics might disappear entirely. 
 Nevertheless, the conclusion must be that, down to 1982, Mrs Thatcher was anxious not to give many hostages to fortune by breaking too openly with the one-nation traditions of Butler and Macleod. 
 She bowed to Scots nationalists over Ravenscraig steelworks and to Welsh nationalists over the Welsh television channel, &bquo;Sianel Pedwar&equo; or S4C. 
 Bizarrely, even Mrs Thatcher became a kind of Bevanite now. 
 &bquo;The National Health Service&equo;, she had to proclaim in 1982, &bquo;is safe with us&equo;. 
 This same pragmatism showed itself also in many aspects of Commonwealth and foreign policy. 
 Here again, the apparently abrasive style of Thatcherite &bquo;conviction politics&equo; proved less robust in reality, at least on one occasion. 
 Her government began with a huge surrender, the quite unexpected settlement in which she acquiesced which ended the long-running saga of British relations with the former  Southern Rhodesia, now renamed Zimbabwe. 
 When Mrs Thatcher took office in May 1979 it was assumed that southern Africa would cause a massive rift between her and the black African states of the Commonwealth. 
 It was expected that she would show sympathy with the white settler minority associated with Ian Smith's Rhodesia Front and propose a deal between him and the near-puppet government of Bishop Abel Muzorewa. 
 In the event, under heavy Foreign Office pressure which she secretly resented, Mrs Thatcher gave way completely. 
 A conference at Lancaster House in August 1979 saw the British government make concession after concession to the Black nationalists. 
 Both Muzorewa and the white minority had to undergo severe pressure. 
 It was agreed that elections would be held in Zimbabwe, despite the activities of various black guerrilla forces led by Joshua Nkomo and Robert Mugabe, and a constitutional convention was to be held in London. 
 At this conference in November, an agreement was laboriously worked out to the effect that Zimbabwe would shortly gain its legal independence. 
 Sanctions would cease to be applied from 15 November, while the senior patrician figure of Christopher Soames (Winston Churchill's son-inlaw, no less) was sent to Zimbabwe to act as temporary governor to supervise new elections and restore the country's trade. 
 Much to the British government's surprise, the elections in early 1980 resulted in a massive victory for the Marxist Robert Mugabe, whose party gained 57 seats, as against 29 for Joshua Nkomo and only 3 for Bishop Muzowera. 
 A legally elected Zimbabwean state now came into being. 
 In fact, Britain's relations with black African states and the Commonwealth generally greatly improved, not least because the long-turbulent figure of Ian Smith was finally forced off centre-stage. 
 Mrs Thatcher's own demeanour at the Commonwealth Conference at Lusaka that August had certainly helped, as in the good relationship she struck up with President Kenneth Kaunda of Zambia. 
 On the other hand, the main credit for resolving the dilemma of Rhodesia/ Zimbabwe really belonged to Commonwealth leaders such as Julius Nyerere of Tanzania and Malcolm Fraser of Australia, and especially to Lord Carrington and the mandarins of the Foreign Office. 
 Indeed, the very success of the Zimbabwean settlement, in line with  repeated British withdrawals from colonial territories since the late 1950s, encouraged a growing impatience on Mrs Thatcher's part with the consensus men of the Foreign Office and with Lord Carrington, its grandee incumbent. 
 The bien-pensant , anti-colonialist, &bquo;Eurospeak&equo; Foreign Office, in Mrs Thatcher's view, was distinctly not &bquo;one of us&equo;. 
 Otherwise, the Commonwealth relationship remained more tranquil under Mrs Thatcher than might have been expected. 
 Her differences with other Commonwealth states over economic sanctions in South Africa did not prevent collaboration with them on other issues, notably in maintaining a boycott of cultural and sporting links with South Africa under the Gleneagles agreement, which the British government faithfully observed. 
 Perhaps the truth was that for Mrs Thatcher, the Commonwealth, like &bquo;Europe&equo; was relatively low in her priorities. 
 She was no more a disciple of Churchill than she was of Heath. 
 Meanwhile the media kept the imperial mystique well to the fore, especially India. 
 Such notable films as Gandhi  (a severe treatment of the Raj), A Passage to India , and Heat and Dust , even the james Bond spectacular Octopussy , kept the Indian sub-continent securely in the public's imagination. 
 One of the most triumphant television productions of the decade was ITV's dramatization of Paul Scott's &bquo;Raj Quartet&equo; under the title, &bquo;The Jewel in the Crown&equo;, a testament to the uneasy, Forster-like, imperial conscience of a pre-Thatcherite age. 
 In foreign affairs, Mrs Thatcher's experience was slight, and her responses at first simple and superficial. 
 She had built up a reputation as &bquo;the Iron Lady&equo; with some stern condemnations of Soviet Communism and its imperialist designs, before she became Prime Minister. 
 Her prevailing stance in foreign affairs was one of cold-war hostility towards Eastern Europe, and an aggressive self-sufficient nationalism, almost Gaullism. 
 She adopted an abrasive stance towards the European Common Market, for which she had never been a strong enthusiast. 
 Her clashes with other European heads of state over Britain's budgetary contribution to the Community aroused all her basic emotions: here, indeed, she had strong support in Britain itself where sympathy for the bureaucrats of Brussels, with their butter mountains and wine lakes, was distinctly muted. 
 At the Dublin summit of the EEC countries in December 1979 she took a highly belligerent, insular line. 
 She claimed that the British  contribution to the budget was &bquo;our money&equo; which foreigners were taking away. 
 She came close to threatening the Community with a repetition of de Gaulle's policy of &bquo;the empty chair&equo; in the sixties. 
 Her relations with Helmut Schmidt, the German Chancellor, and Giscard d'Estaing, the French President, were glacial. 
 Yet here too the practice of Thatcherism proved less abrasive as time went on. 
 By mid-1982, an acceptable compromise had been reached over European affairs, including the budget and agricultural policy. 
 Mrs Thatcher was at least in a functional sense, beginning to show greater capacity for involvement in the life of the community, if without the passion of Edward Heath in the past. 
 On Europe, she was an agnostic rather than an unbeliever. 
 Indeed, surprisingly enough, Mrs Thatcher's reputation, in the doldrums at home at least to the end of 1981, began to grow in foreign affairs as she became more self-assured. 
 Ultimately, though, her success lay neither in Commonwealth nor in Common Market affairs, but in the North Atlantic alliance. 
 She struck up an effective rapport with the new Republican President of the United States, Ronald Reagan. 
 At last the &bquo;special relationship&equo; seemed to have some meaning, perhaps for the first time since the days of Macmillan. 
 There was accord over trade policy and over regional policy in such areas as Latin America. 
 Most important of all, on defence issues, the needs of Britain and the United States came closer together. 
 A deal was struck under which Britain would allow US Cruise missiles to be sited on British soil. 
 In return, Trident would be offered as a replacement for the ageing Polaris submarine-based missiles as the basis of the so-called &bquo;British independent deterrent&equo;. 
 This provoked furious controversy. 
 Trident was hugely expensive &mdash; &pound;10 billion at the first assessment alone. 
 The Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament found in Cruise and Trident a stimulus it had not had since the early 1960s. 
 The campaign against the Cruise missile bases, in particular, led to passionate demonstrations. 
 One of the most notable protest movements of the early Thatcher years was the series of demonstrations by feminist and other women supporters of unilateral nuclear disarmament at Greenham Common in Berkshire, where the Cruise missiles were to be based (along with Molesworth in Cambridgeshire). 
 Clashes between the Greenham Common  women and the police were prolonged and often violent. 
 On the other hand, the general theme was one in which Mrs Thatcher was able to tap reserves of nationalist sentiment, as could her flamboyant, flak-jacketed Defence Secretary, Michael Heseltine. 
 On balance, the Cruise missile demonstrations embarrassed the left, and turned much to Mrs Thatcher's advantage. 
 The Prime Minister could strengthen her growing reputation as a tough, determined champion of British national interests, one whose role in the transatlantic alliance was testimony to the growing influence of her nation after decades of consistent decline. 
 Her firm stance enabled her to speak to the Russian government with greater authority also. 
 As Helmut Schmidt was defeated in the German elections in 1982, following Giscard d'Estaing's failure in the French presidential elections in 1981, Mrs Thatcher, to general surprise, emerged as a strong and respected world leader. 
 Yet she was one whose reputation was in reality based on dialogue rather than on sabre-rattling. 
 The same tendency to compromise showed itself in a facet of internal policy much closer to home, one whose violent impact threatened life and property on the British mainland herself. 
 Mrs Thatcher's sentiments were staunchly Unionist. 
 A close political ally was Airey Neave, a former intelligence officer who was to be murdered by the IRA in the precincts of Westminster. 
 Relations between Mrs Thatcher and the new Irish Fianna F&aacute;il premier, Charles Haughey, were at first tense. 
 Horrific events continued to scar Anglo-Irish relations, as terrorist attacks, mainly by Provisional Sinn Fein, continued. 
 In the summer of 1980, an indefinite hunger-strike by Republican prisoners in the Maze prison in Belfast was followed in May 1981 by the death, after a lengthy hunger-strike, of the recently-elected Sinn Fein MP and convicted terrorist, Bobby Sands. 
 Violent events both in Ulster and in Britain itself continued to escalate, with the murder of Lord Mountbatten on his yacht in 1982 at the hands of the IRA. 
 Attempts by the Northern Ireland secretary, Humphrey Atkins, to promote a representative assembly, proved a complete failure. 
 Nevertheless, the prospect of a dialogue between London and Dublin remained, and the prospect strengthened when Fine Gael returned to power. 
 The result was a summit meeting between its leader, Dr Garrett FitzGerald, and Mrs Thatcher in November 1981, with the objective of exploring the idea of a kind of inter-governmental council. 
 This would clearly imply some involvement by the Dublin government in the internal affairs of Northern Ireland for the  very first time. 
 The dispatch of James Prior to the Northern Irish office, in place of Atkins, in the government reshuffle of September 1981, also presaged an attempt at further negotiation. 
 Prior came forward with the idea of a form of &bquo;rolling devolution&equo;, with an elected assembly of seventy-eight members and a thirteen-man executive. 
 This was inevitably rejected by the Catholic SDLP as perpetuating Protestant rule in Ulster, while the Paisleyite Unionists condemned any form of power-sharing with the &bquo;Papists&equo;. 
 Yet, while the background of terrorist violence remained, and the gulf between the two communities in the North hardly seemed to narrow at all over the years, the stance of the Thatcher government was clearly one based on diplomacy and compromise. 
 It would inevitably lead to a closer relationship between the government of the Republic and the people of Ulster. 
 Here again, the practice of the Thatcher government by 1983 was less strident and aggressive than its rhetoric suggested. 
 In many areas, then, the Thatcher government in the period 1979&ndash;83 was not far removed in many respects from the post-war outlook of the kind familiar to British experience since 1945. 
 And yet, to many British people and social groups, the Prime Minister and her colleagues appeared to be not moderates but extremists. 
 Their legacy was seen in rising unemployment, a growing gulf between a prospering, high-tech south-east and the squalid and declining towns and cities of the north, Scotland, Wales, and Ulster. 
 The &bquo;north &mdash; south divide&equo; became a familiar part of popular folklore as in the days of Mrs Gaskell. 
 Thus, in its first two years, the government's reputation slumped sharply; Mrs Thatcher's ability to impose her personality upon it suffered accordingly. 
 By the end of 1981, she seemed almost a Prime Minister at bay. 
 Throughout 1980 she had battled against a largely hostile public opinion and formidable critics in her own Cabinet such as Ian Gilmour, Peter Walker, and James Prior. 
 She won one victory in January 1981 when a palpable &bquo;wet&equo;, Norman St John-Stevas, was removed as Leader of the House (where he had been a conspicuous success), while younger men like Leon Brittan and Kenneth Baker were promoted, the latter having been one of Heath's campaign managers in 1975. 
 But there still remained immensely powerful ministers who led the fight for increased public investment and spending measures to cut unemployment. 
 Men like  Prior, Gilmour, Pym, Walker, and perhaps Heseltine seemed to be challenging the very premisses of monetarism. 
 In the summer of 1981, Mrs Thatcher was at her lowest ebb, very far from the invincible leader she was later to appear. 
 There was open talk of revolt in sections of her party. 
 The economy continued to lapse into decline, with manufacturing output having fallen by no less than 10 per cent in the past twelve months. 
 At this time, too, there came violent racial disturbances in black ghetto areas like Brixton in London, Toxteth in Liverpool, and Moss Side in Manchester. 
 The subsequent Scarman Report on the Brixton riots spoke eloquently of the despair of unemployed young blacks, and their sense of alienation from the community and especially from the police, whose intolerance and insensitivity were deplored. 
 Britain, it appeared, was threatened with a racial explosion on American lines. 
 Although the Commonwealth immigration acts since 1962 had slowed the inward flow from Commonwealth countries to a trickle, the problems of assimilating the black population now resident were as acute as ever, especially during the period of rapidly rising unemployment. 
 From all these matters the embattled Prime Minister seemed strangely detached. 
 It was noted that she kept herself almost isolated from her own colleagues. 
 She had no senior heavyweight figure like Cherwell or Swinton to advise her, and indeed no close colleague at all. 
 Even Peter Thorneycroft, the veteran proto-monetarist of 1958 whom she had made Party Chairman, proved to be a &bquo;one-nation&equo; man at heart, and she was eventually to sack him in favour of a little-tried new favourite, Cecil Parkinson, the Paymaster-General. 
 Almost in desperation, Mrs Thatcher seized the initiative with a political purge. 
 It evoked comparisons with Macmillan's bloody &bquo;night of the long knives&equo; in July 1962. 
 On 14 September 1981, she removed four major Heathite ministers, Christopher Soames (the patrician Churchillian with whom she had clashed over civil-service pay), Mark Carlisle (Education), St John-Stevas (Arts), and Ian Gilmour (Lord Privy Seal). 
 The last-named issued a furious resignation statement in which he accused the Prime Minister of steering the ship of state &bquo;straight on to the rocks&equo;. 
 More traumatic still, James Prior, with the greatest reluctance, was forced to move from Employment to the exile of Northern Ireland, even though Mrs Thatcher had to  keep him on the Cabinet's main economic forum, the E Committee. 
 In their place, new, rightish figures emerged &mdash; Nigel Lawson at the Department of Energy; Norman Tebbit in place of Prior at Employment; Nicholas Ridley, the driest of dry monetarists, as Financial Secretary to the Treasury. 
 For the first time, it appeared, Mrs Thatcher had some measure of command over her own Cabinet. 
 Its centre of gravity had shifted markedly to the right. 
 But Carrington, Pym, Walker, and, of course, Prior were there still, as was the equivocal figure of Whitelaw. 
 Throughout the autumn, even with the economy beginning to show signs of bottoming out and inflation falling fast, Mrs Thatcher was still under siege. 
 The turning-point &mdash; and in many ways the great divide of British politics since 1979 &mdash; came totally unexpectedly in March 1982. 
 It arose from a crisis in a disregarded part of the world, of no consequence to the British since the days of Captain Cook, namely the South Atlantic. 
 On Good Friday, 1982, it was announced that the government of Argentina had invaded and occupied the British colony, the Falkland Islands, long coveted by Argentinians as &bquo;Las Malvinas&equo;. 
 This episode followed a period in which the Thatcher government had shown reluctance to maintain such meagre defences as the Falkland islanders possessed. 
 It had recently withdrawn the ice-breaker Endurance , generally taken as a clear sign of retreat. 
 This d&eacute;marche  by the Argentine government of General Galtieri, however, provoked a furious political reaction. 
 The House of Commons met on a Saturday for the first time since the war. 
 There were violent condemnations of the British government for its weakness, including from the leader of the Labour Party, the veteran near-pacifist, Michael Foot. 
 All the Foreign Office ministers, headed by Lord Carrington, had to resign from the government, though Carrington was replaced by the hardly more resolute figure of Pym. 
 The Defence Secretary, John Nott, narrowly retained his office. 
 The Prime Minister, however, responded with the instinctive nationalist belligerence that came most naturally to her. 
 On 10 April it was announced that a &bquo;task force&equo; of 10,000 men would be assembled under the command of Rear-Admiral &bquo;Sandy&equo; Woodward, to sail into the South Atlantic, whatever the hazards, and recapture the Falklands for the British Commonwealth. 
 It was a dramatic approach, but one which was recorded as having  the support of 83 per cent of the British people. 
 Conservatives disliked the Argentine government for being aggressive foreigners; Labour men attacked it as &bquo;a tin-pot fascist junta&equo;. 
 A mood of bellicose jingoism, unknown since the days of Suez in November 1956, swept the land, directed against &bquo;the Argies&equo;. 
 But it was a most risky strategy. 
 The task force was only made possible by cobbling together the remnants of the battle fleet, including the two last aircraft-carriers, Invincible  and Hermes . 
 The latter had been intended for the scrap-yard a short while earlier. 
 There would also be amphibious assault ships, notably the Fearless, while troops would be carried in tourist passenger vessels headed by the QE II . 
 The logistic capacity of the Royal Navy would be stretched to the very limit, as would that of the RAF to provide air cover and defence against missile attack. 
 The diplomatic context was also highly uncertain, with much opposition in the United Nations to the British action, not only from Latin Americans. 
 It so happened that the UN Secretary-General, Perez de Cuellar, was himself a Peruvian. 
 Most vital, and also most uncertain, was the support of the US government, whose radar detector services would be crucial to any British victory. 
 There were abortive attempts at a settlement by the American Secretary of State, General Alexander Haig, and discussions over a Peruvian peace plan which would bypass the British contention that it possessed sole sovereignty over the Falklands. 
 In the end Mrs Thatcher had to gamble that her friend, President Reagan, would, despite anti-British feeling from Irish-Americans, Hispanics, and others, throw his weight behind his old ally in the alleged &bquo;special relationship&equo;. 
 In the event, through the use of a US air-base on Ascension Island, the gift of antiradar weapons and Sidewinder missiles, and much intelligence information, the Americans materially helped the British to win the war. 
 Mrs Thatcher's gamble, which might have caused a huge crisis and the fall of the government, came off triumphantly. 
 A War Cabinet, consisting of Mrs Thatcher, Whitelaw, Pym, Nott, and Cecil Parkinson, assisted by civil servants such as Sir Robert Armstrong, Sir Anthony Acland, and Sir Frank Cooper, along with Admiral Sir Terence Lewin of the Chiefs of Staff, directed operations, At this kind of uncomplicated executive command, the Prime Minister excelled: her instinct for isolated decision-making was now a strength, not a  weakness. 
 Information to the public was carefully processed and censored by the Ministry of Defence. 
 As the task force made its slow way towards the Falklands exclusion zone, hostilities began in earnest on 2 May when a torpedo from a British nuclear-powered submarine sank the Argentine cruiser, General Belgrano , with the loss of 360 lives; it was a highly suspicious episode, since the Belgrano  appeared to be leaving the exclusion zone and heading back to Argentina at the time. 
 Mrs Thatcher's later versions of the affair showed much uncertainty over the facts. 
 Two days later, in reply, an Argentine Exocet missile sank the British vessel, HMS Sheffield , with the loss of twenty sailors. 
 Then, on 26 May, British troops landed near San Carlos Bay in East Falkland. 
 The early experiences were disastrous since there was only limited defence against persistent Argentine air attacks. 
 The Coventry, Ardent , and Antelope  were all sunk; many Welsh Guardsmen, waiting to land, were killed or maimed in an air assault on the Sir Galahad  at Bluff Cove. 
 But in the end the British troops managed to land successfully and soon proved their technical superiority over the poorly trained and equipped Argentine conscript army. 
 A British parachute batallion won a notable engagement at Goose Green, despite losing their commander, Colonel H. Jones (who gained a posthumous V.C.), with the capture of 1,200 Argentine troops. 
 There was a final assault by 7,000 British forces, including Nepalese Gurkhas, on Port Stanley, and on 14 June the Falkland capital was easily recaptured. 
 A tally of 14,000 bedraggled, disillusioned Argentine prisoners of war were taken. 
 It was a triumph beyond all expectations. 
 In three weeks, the British had re-evoked past imperial triumphs over inadequate opposition. 
 Omdurman and Mafeking had come again. 
 Mrs Thatcher urged the nation to &bquo;Rejoice! 
 Rejoice!&equo; 
 The British tabloid press, notably Rupert Murdoch's somewhat pornographic Sun , reached extraordinary levels of distasteful jingoism. 
 The Governor returned to Port Stanley from which he had been expelled, and huge defence installations were then erected to prevent any further Argentine attacks, including a massive new airport at Port Stanley. 
 As a military exercise, however, many gaps in British naval and air provision had been shown up; but it was a spectacular triumph, the first that Britain had known since the 1950s.  
 The Falklands War totally changed the public and political climate. 
 Its mood of self-confident chauvinism galvanized the nation, however little the British knew of the culture, economy, history, or even postage stamps of the distant Falklands and its population of just 1,200 sheep-farmers and their dependants. 
 Mrs Thatcher turned from being the least popular Prime Minister of modern times to becoming an Iron Britannia, a new Boadicea, the very embodiment of toughness, triumph, and grim resolve. 
 For the first time in her premiership she had won a knock-out victory. 
 The opinion polls, which had shown a small move towards the Tories in the early months of 1982, now showed a large and growing Conservative majority. 
 From the time of the Falklands War, it was certain that the Tories would win the next general election, and that Mrs Thatcher would gain new stature as Prime Minister. 
 Within six months, the war had receded from most people's minds. 
 A service of thanksgiving in St Paul's Cathedral was marked (to Mrs Thatcher's displeasure) by a distinctly muted and moderate sermon from the Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Runcie, himself certainly no jingo. 
 It now seemed extraordinary that so remote and irrelevant a place should ever loom so large in national and international affairs. 
 And yet, after the war in the Falklands, the triumph of &bquo;Thatcherism&equo;, however that ambiguous concept be defined, was assured. 
 The political and social landscape was now transformed. 
 From this time onwards, commentators who had speculated on the Prime Minister's early removal from office, now assumed confidently that Thatcherism was here to stay. 
 One major factor, of course, was that the possible alternatives seemed enfeebled and lacking in conviction. 
 The Labour party showed little sign of recovering from its election defeat in 1979. 
 Indeed, it became increasingly torn apart by sectarian and ideological division. 
 The tension between the traditional, consensual centre-right and the doctrinaire, neo-Marxist left in the constituencies and many unions, who saw Tony Benn as their charismatic champion, became more acute. 
 The resignation of James Callaghan as party leader in November 1 980 added to the party's disarray. 
 Indeed, by a somewhat surprising decision, the parliamentary party elected not Denis Healey, the last of the centre-right heavyweights, but the deputy leader Michael Foot, ex-Bevanite and present unilateralist, the authentic voice of the old left. 
 He was unlikely to suppress the Bennites however little he sympathized  with their methods. 
 In a disastrous party conference at Wembley in January 1981, new constitutional procedures were adopted to form a hybrid &bquo;electoral college&equo; to elect the party's leader and deputy leader. 
 This followed proposals from a left-dominated &bquo;committee of inquiry&equo; at Bishop Stortford in 1980. 
 In addition, the compulsory re-selection of all parliamentary candidates, including sitting MPs, had already been agreed, to give spokesmen of the far left in constituency management committees the power to remove right-wing or moderate figures. 
 Only the drafting of the manifesto still remained precariously in the hands of the leader and the NEC. 
 In disgust, Shirley Williams, David Owen, and William Rodgers of the Labour right left to form a new Social Democratic Party. 
 Twenty-nine Labour MPs were eventually to join it. 
 With Michael Foot installed as party leader, his position was temporarily secure. 
 But Labour was shaken to the core by a passionate battle for the deputy leadership (a post originally created to placate Herbert Morrison after 1951) between Denis Healey and Tony Benn. 
 It was a battle of social leadership as much as of ideas. 
 Healey was the spokesman of the centre-right, the older unions, and the more traditional &bquo;broad church&equo; sections of the party. 
 Benn was the voice of the far-left, middle-class zealots in the constituencies, unilateralists and radicals of all persuasions, extra-parliamentary as well as parliamentary, college lecturers, and the newer public-sector unions. 
 The very identity of the party and the movement was at stake. 
 In the September 1981 party conference it was revealed that Healey had indeed won, by the narrowest of margins, with 50.3 per cent of the popular vote; the star of Tony Benn began to dim somewhat thereafter, not least because Michael Foot was able subtly to mount a movement of the old (or &bquo;soft&equo;) constitutionally-minded left against the &bquo;hard left&equo; of the neo-Marxist, unilateralist fringe. 
 But the entire episode left the party looking damaged and fragile. 
 Its support began to crumble alarmingly even in its own working-class strongholds. 
 Far from being a challenger for power, it could not even hold on to its old citadels. 
 In a disastrous by-election in February 1982 in Bermondsey, a docks constituency in east London, Labour since 1918, Labour's youthful, far-left candidate, a Marxist homosexual  from Australia, was crushingly defeated by the Liberals. 
 Labour's support in the polls, partly it is true as a result of the Falklands War, steadily languished. 
 Beyond electoral matters, there was growing belief that, for long-term sociological and historical reasons, Labour was in terminal decline. 
 The Marxist historian Eric Hobsbawm, in an important lecture entitled &bquo;The Forward March of Labour Halted?&equo; (the questionmark was often mischievously omitted), argued that the old, historic, back-to-back working class based on mass labour-intensive industries and the distinct proletarian culture associated with the older industrial and urban areas, was rapidly eroding. 
 A much more flexible and pro-active strategy was needed, unless Labour was to pass into total oblivion. 
 Professor Hobsbawm's remedies included electoral reform and alliance with environmentalists, the peace movement, Scots and Welsh nationalists, and other dissenters. 
 The belief that Labour was a relic of an older past, of the first industrial revolution rather than its successor, took hold. 
 It seemed to be in permanent decline, possibly for some of the same reasons as the Liberals after 1918. 
 The idea of socialism, so passionately affirmed by the Bennite multitudes, attracted less and less support amongst the population at large. 
 The links with the unions, increasingly unpopular, dispirited, and losing membership, were no longer a source of strength. 
 The nostrums of statism, centralization, and planning had lost much of their thrust with the stagflation and popular disaffection of the 1970s. 
 No new Crosland seemed likely to emerge to give them a fresh charisma. 
 Neither sociologically nor ideologically did Labour have much to offer. 
 Instead, under an amiable leader, Michael Foot, who was savagely pilloried by a largely right-wing press, it was compelled by constituency pressures to have a far-left programme hostile to NATO, to membership of the Common Market, and to a system of national nuclear defence; it would also be committed to mass nationalization, reinforcing further the power of the unions, and a variety of other proposals unlikely to have much popular appeal. 
 The manifesto Labour finally adopted in the 1983 election paid deference to the wishes of &bquo;greens&equo;, unilateralists, Irish republicans, homosexuals of both sexes, and feminists. 
 It included demands for ending the House of Lords and abolishing fox-hunting. 
  It was a very lengthy document, wryly termed, with some reason, &bquo;the longest suicide note in history&equo;. 
 If Labour suddenly seemed old and unelectable, a real youthful challenge to the Thatcher regime seemed to come from the new Social Democratic Party. 
 It was formed after the &bquo;Limehouse Declaration&equo;, issued from David Owen's home in February 1981. 
 This seemed a refreshing attempt to &bquo;break the mould&equo; of British politics. 
 It could appeal to old Gaitskellites like the &bquo;gang of four&equo;, Owen, Williams, and Rodgers, joined by Roy Jenkins whose Dimbleby Lecture in 1979 had first outlined the prospect of a new centrist movement. 
 It could also draw in apolitical idealists alienated by both the extremism of the far left and the abrasiveness of the Thatcherites. 
 For much of 1981 and early 1982 the Social Democrats seemed to carry all before them. 
 An exciting new prospect of political transformation was opened up. 
 The SDP won an extraordinary by-election success at Crosby in Liverpool in November 1981, when Shirley Williams turned a Tory majority of 19,000 into an SDP majority of 5,000. 
 There was another gain from the Tories in Croydon in the south London suburbs. 
 Roy Jenkins, who had fought a striking campaign at Warrington that summer, won Glasgow Hillhead in March 1982, just before the Falklands War. 
 For a time, the Social Democrats seemed able to appeal to disaffected middle-class Tories and to moderate opinion of all shades. 
 Twenty-nine Labour MPs joined the new party, along with a reformist Conservative MP from East Anglia, Christopher Brocklebank-Fowler. 
 The mould was being broken and the two-party system left in fragments, so the SDP exultantly claimed. 
 But the momentum did not last long. 
 The Falklands factor was an element in pushing Mrs Williams and Jenkins from the forefront of the stage. 
 The SDP did not and could not have a good war. 
 The new party was also demonstrably vague in its ideological position &mdash; whether it was a reborn version of Attlee/ Gaitskell-type social democracy, a humane version of Butler-style Toryism, or a completely new variant of political programme which transcended all known political categories. 
 It was in many ways a mood rather than a movement, a transient phenomenon with shallow roots in the  constituencies, and particularly weak in local government. 
 Working-class voters were suspicious of its patrician, incurably middle-class image. 
 The main problem bedevilling the SDP, though, was its relationship with the old Liberal Party led by David Steel. 
 This problem was to plague the new party until its virtual disappearance from the scene after the 1987 general election. 
 The SDP claimed to have its own tradition and style, and to be more governmentally orientated than the decentralized, almost anarchistic, community-based Liberals. 
 It also had a tougher, pro-Trident stance on defence. 
 On the other hand, the Liberals were undeniably out there in the country, and it would be electorally suicidal to have two smaller centrist parties fighting for leadership of the middle ground. 
 The Liberals had powerful grass-roots strength and an historic identity in much of the Scottish Highlands, rural Wales, and especially Devon and Cornwall. 
 In early 1983, therefore, a somewhat difficult pact was concluded, the so-called &bquo;Alliance&equo;, between the Liberals and the SDP, in which they would agree to choose one Alliance candidate in the different constituencies, and fight a joint election campaign with Roy Jenkins as leader and putative Prime Minister. 
 But the tense negotiations over the formation of the Alliance, debate over what precisely it meant in terms of policy and tactics (did it support a coalition, for instance, and if so, with whom?), left the SDP hamstrung from the start. 
 In the winter of 1981&ndash;2, at the time of the Crosby by-election, the Conservatives had been terrified by SDP threats to their support in south and east England and suburbia generally. 
 Roy Jenkins and Mrs Williams gave the impression of governmental timbre, with the Napoleonic figure of David Owen, an ex-Foreign Secretary after all, as the likely heir-apparent. 
 In the spring of 1983, with the public mood changed by the Falklands War and the fragmented nature of the Alliance already evident, the threat from the new party was manifestly beginning to wane. 
 Its novelty was wearing off. 
 The general election of June 1983 reflected all these factors. 
 With the consequence of the Falklands still exerting its potency, the economy showing distinct signs of recuperation, and inflation falling fast, Mrs Thatcher had been able to call an early election. 
 The outcome was never in doubt. 
 Labour was still in deep disarray, its  campaign badly led and generally disorganized. 
 The Alliance failed to make a distinct impression. 
 For the Tories, the issue was simply Mrs Thatcher's leadership, and she banged the election drum with fierce attacks on &bquo;pacifist&equo; unilateralists like Michael Foot, and &bquo;the dark, divisive clouds of Marxist socialism&equo;. 
 The campaign showed few issues and, with the Conservatives overwhelmingly backed up in the popular press, was wholly one-sided. 
 Labour ended up with only 209 seats and 27.6 per cent of the popular vote, its lowest since 1918. 
 It finished only just ahead of the Alliance poll of 26 per cent (which produced for them only seventeen Liberal and six SDP seats). 
 Less than 40 per cent of trade unionists had voted Labour; even less than half of the unemployed. 
 They too had imbibed the market culture, it seemed. 
 The Conservatives, with 397 seats, had a huge majority of 142; the legacy of 1945 had indeed been reversed. 
 The victory for the Thatcherite ethic seemed overwhelming. 
 The evidence is less convincing on closer examination. 
 The Conservative Party won only 42.9 per cent of the popular vote, less than they had achieved in any election between 1945 and 1979, and did badly in Scotland and much of northern England. 
 It won because of its residual strength in southern and eastern England, and also greater London, where most of the constituencies were located. 
 As has been seen, the progress of Thatcherism had been erratic, even hesitant, since 1979, though the Falklands victory had given the record of the past four years a spurious consistency. 
 In large areas of Britain the results of the Thatcher government had been mass unemployment, collapsing public services, and urban decay. 
 In. 
 Merseyside or Tyneside there had been almost a general deindustrialization. 
 Britain's economic fortunes generally had fallen sharply compared with other western European countries since 1979. 
 In Brixton or Toxteth, the black ghettoes of the inner cities, alienation from the police, the government, and the social structure generally left a potentially combustible debris of explosive material. 
 Northern Ireland had deteriorated in its social and economic fabric too since 1979. 
 For most British people, certainly, living standards showed some absolute overall improvement since 1979; but there was also a popular sense  that the quality of life had degenerated, and that in particular violent crime had risen sharply. 
 Thatcherism, however, triumphed because of its political and social roots. 
 It had coincided with rising prosperity in the expanding towns of southern England and East Anglia. 
 High-tech industries, based on computer software and the like, had meant near-boom conditions for such places as Cambridge, Basingstoke, Winchester, and especially Swindon, the outstanding growth town of the decade. 
 Along the so-called M4 corridor, as far west as Newport in Gwent, new, technically sophisticated smaller industries were mushrooming. 
 The legacy of four years of Thatcherism, therefore, was an intensification of social division and varied economic expectations in different parts of Britain. 
 It went further than the much-discussed &bquo;north &mdash; south divide&equo;. 
 Prosperity, too, had been the product of small enterprises and a lengthy consumer boom financed by credit. 
 The decline in Britain's manufacturing base was indisputable, though the causes were open to scholarly debate. 
 But for the clients of the Thatcher order in the south and east of the nation, it was more than enough. 
 The dispiriting memories of the seventies were fading. 
 Mass unemployment had lost its old political potency. 
 For the next four years, it was the suburban conquerors of southern Britain, not the decaying and dispirited north and west, who would pay the piper and call the tune.  
 High Noon for the New Right-Resurgence or Retreat? 
 1883&ndash;1989 
 GOVERNMENTS often lose momentum in their second term. 
 Many Conservatives still recalled the disarray into which the Macmillan administration had plunged after its striking election victory in 1959. 
 Mrs Thatcher was determined that this would not happen to her. 
 On the contrary, from the Queen's Speech of November 1983 onwards, she turned her second term into a crusade of increasing radicalism, the doubts and hesitancies of the first administration mostly shed. 
 It was in these years that the main contours of &bquo;Thatcherism&equo; as a phenomenon were firmly established. 
 It is on these years that the government's historical reputation will surely be based. 
 Faint hearts were summarily dispatched. 
 Francis Pym, who had given a somewhat hesitant performance at the Foreign Office in the Prime Minister's view, was removed from his post immediately after the election. 
 He was replaced by the safe, if decidedly dull, figure of Sir Geoffrey Howe, a diplomat not a policy-maker. 
 In his place at the Treasury came the younger, almost reckless, figure of Nigel Lawson, an able former financial journalist and apparently still a nominal enthusiast for monetarism. 
 To an increasing degree, the government and its outlying establishments bore the Prime Minister's stamp; her press secretary, Bernard Ingham, seemed more powerful than most Cabinet ministers, somewhat on the pattern of Lloyd George's use of &bquo;Bronco Bill&equo; Sutherland in 1918&ndash;22. 
 There were personal setbacks, as when her close political confidant, Cecil Parkinson, had to resign from the government in October 1983 after a sex scandal involving his former secretary. 
 But this caused little permanent difficulty for the  government. 
 Parkinson's successor at Trade and Employment, Norman Tebbit, a working-class Tory and former trade-union official, emerged as a key performer in this high noon of renascent Conservatism. 
 He urged the unemployed of the north to &bquo;get on your bike&equo; and look for work, as his window-cleaner father had done in the thirties. 
 No social compassion here. 
 The Thatcherite band-wagon rolled on relentlessly, though with crises, errors, and &bquo;banana skins&equo; aplenty littering the route. 
 In many key directions the new radicalism now showed itself in full. 
 Much the most notable of these novelties was the policy of the privatization of industries and utilities. 
 After 1983, the &bquo;frontiers of the state&equo; were, in this respect at least, rolled back as they had not been since 1945. 
 There had been only piecemeal policies of denationalization in 1979&ndash;83, and indeed the Conservatives had been reluctant to replace state monopolies with privately-owned ones. 
 The turning-point came with the triumphantly successful privatization of British Telecom in 1984 for almost &pound;4 billion. 
 This was not argued particularly in terms of service to the consumer. 
 Indeed, the efficiency of a denationalized, deregulated British Telecom somewhat declined thereafter, and led to complaints about poor service and rising telephone bills. 
 It was rather a huge success in sociopolitical terms, in vastly expanding the range of the shareholding classes. 
 It made privatization part of a wider cultural shift among the British people, including wide swathes of the working class. 
 Many hundreds of thousands of trade unionists were among those who became shareholders for the first time. 
 Even more important, the sale of public assets made possible large cuts in taxation in the 1985 and 1986 budgets. 
 There followed the privatization of British Aerospace and Britoil, and finally the huge sale of British Gas for &pound;5,434 million in December 1986. 
 This was another enormously successful sale. 
 The government's cartoon publicity telling the British public to ask &bquo;Sid&equo; made its point. 
 Rolls-Royce and British Airports followed, and there was talk of electricity and even coal being privatized in due course. 
 The legacy of the Second World War and the Attlee government, the very notion of the mixed economy as familiarized by &bquo;Butskellism&equo;, was being dismantled. 
 On the other hand, the thrust for privatization somewhat lost its appeal as the  public came to realize that share values could fall as well as rise. 
 The aftermath of the stock market crash of October 1987 was to make the sale of British Petroleum shares (over &pound;7 billion in all) much less successful. 
 Many of the share purchasers now were large institutional buyers rather than the small saver or investor, the &bquo;little man&equo; or aged widow beloved of government propaganda. 
 Even so, the advance of privatization was a notable shift in public debate, a great reversal of the growth of corporatism as it had rolled on, government after government, since the centralization of the First World War. 
 It chimed in with a mood of anti-&eacute;tatisme  in many countries, notably in France where the Chirac government used the Thatcher policy as a model in its privatization of state banks and other enterprises in 1984&ndash;6. 
 It is notable, too, how few tears were shed for nationalization and state control. 
 Trade unionists seemed reluctant to defend the &bquo;bureaucratic monoliths&equo; that Herbert Morrison had created after 1945. 
 The Labour Party, under a youthful new leader, Neil Kinnock, elected in October 1983, was significantly hesitant in proclaiming its zeal to renationalize, even in cases such as British Gas where state-run industries had been clearly successful. 
 Down to the 1987 general election and beyond, nationalization on the old pattern played an increasingly smaller role in Labour's priorities. 
 Even the Euro-Communists of Marxism Today  welcomed the end of the old order. 
 There were few to oppose the pattern of denationalization and deregulation on strict efficiency grounds. 
 Here the Thatcher revolution was considerable, almost complete. 
 Financial policy, which deviated increasingly from monetarist orthodoxy, also pursued a more distinct course with Nigel Lawson as Chancellor. 
 Finally abandoning M3, the medium-term financial strategy, and other totems, he strongly urged major cuts in public expenditure and extensive cuts in personal taxation to offer incentives for the rich or the would-be rich. 
 Under his aegis, the gulf in personal resources between rich and poor became very much wider than it had been in the period 1945&ndash;79. 
 By 1985 it was recorded that the top 6 per cent of the population in income terms now received 25 per cent of national income, while for the poorest 20 per cent their share had actually fallen from even the 5.9 per cent they enjoyed in  1979. 
 As it happened, largely because of a world-wide expansion in trade, the British economy advanced considerably down to 1987. 
 There was an annual growth rate of some 4 per cent, while inflation continued to fall. 
 The balance of payments, much helped by oil of course, was comfortably in surplus down to 1986. 
 It could be claimed that Lawson was the custodian of success, however risky his strategy appeared to be. 
 Unemployment remained high by historic standards (a peak of 3.2 million being reached in April 1985); but somehow it appeared to have been defused as a major political issue during the eighties, partly through redundancy payments. 
 Despite much popular resentment at the effects of cash restraints on public services, the government's continuing popularity largely rested on its claim to have been the architect of new prosperity, based on finance, credit, and consumer pump-priming rather than on mass manufacturing industry as in the past. 
 How long it would last, however, when precisely inflationary pressures would build up, and how much the entire fa&ccedil;ade rested on Britain's possession of North Sea oil and associated export revenues, were unanswered questions. 
 Lawson remained confident and buoyant in his commitment to tax cuts. 
 His budget of March 1987 took the standard rate of income tax down to 27p, and in all a huge budget surplus of over &pound;16 billion was recorded. 
 Less noted was the fact that taxes other than income tax were, in fact, rising steadily under the Conservatives. 
 The main reason for buoyant government revenues lay in the increasing returns from VAT and other taxes on the consumer, and on increasing Corporation Tax returns from business profits. 
 Lawson ran a high-risk strategy at the Treasury. 
 It rested, in part, on an ability to neutralize international pressures. 
 At various times, notably from midsummer 1985, these threatened the value of sterling and seemed likely to cause an old-fashioned &bquo;run on the pound&equo;. 
 By 1987 there were clearly long-term problems emerging for the balance of payments. 
 But, in his distinctly supply-side programme of aiding the wealthy and &bquo;achievers&equo; in general with tax cuts, his relative disregard for social inequality and the mounting costs for the unemployed and other socially disadvantaged groups, and his hedonistic endorsement of private gain, Lawson's financial methods became the pivot of government policy. 
 Social commentators noted, in a  transatlantic usage, the rise of the &bquo;yuppy&equo; (young upwardly-mobile professional) whose girl-friends and families took over older working-class areas such as Limehouse, Islington, or Hackney. 
 Lawson himself, while neither tactful nor popular, was astonishingly successful for a long period. 
 He came to be regarded as the major reason for the government's post-Falklands electoral strength, its reputation for competence, enterprise, and success. 
 The government's new abrasiveness showed itself especially in industrial policy as it related to the trade unions. 
 After 1983, Norman Tebbit's Act of 1982 on strikes and other industrial practices came to be much used. 
 Strikes rapidly disappeared as union after union either found their members unwilling in union ballots to risk strike action which might mean unemployment, or else felt wary of running up huge costs through fines in the courts. 
 The TUC itself contributed to a mood of defensiveness. 
 Thus, in December 1983 it was made very clear that other unions would not encourage the small National Graphical Association when it defied the law over Eddie Shah's nonunion printing operations in Warrington and insisted on conducting a strike deemed by the high court to be illegal. 
 The outcome was huge financial damages for the NGA and a sharp defeat for the restrictive practices by which traditional craft-workers such as the printers had hamstrung British newspaper and book publishing. 
 The stranglehold of &bquo;the closed shop&equo;, the &bquo;British disease&equo; of strikes, official or unofficial, prolonged or &bquo;wild-cat&equo;, seemed under Mrs Thatcher to have been finally loosened. 
 There was one supreme test of the government's resolve in &bquo;standing up to the unions&equo;, as the phrase went. 
 This was the miners, whom Harold Macmillan had once bracketed with the Catholic Church and the Brigade of Guards as institutions with which no Conservative government ought ever to tangle. 
 In April 1984 the National Union of Mineworkers called a national strike against pit closures, including that of the lately closed pit at Cortonwood in south Yorkshire, and in favour of a vastly increased basic wage. 
 Whether this momentous event, the first national coal strike since 1926 was the result of  accidental circumstances or a long-term conspiracy between the National Coal Board and the Department of Energy was subsequently fiercely debated. 
 Much attention focused on the aggressive personality of the virulent Marxist, Arthur Scargill, a Yorkshireman who had succeeded the moderate, Joe Gormley, as president of the NUM in 1982. 
 There was also much emphasis on the personality clash between the youthful Scargill and the new chairman of the NCB, Ian MacGregor, an elderly Scots-American of Thatcherite persuasion. 
 But the miners' sense of anger at the prolonged destruction of their industry is also worthy of note. 
 Support for the strike was virtually solid not only in old militant areas such as South Wales, Scotland, Yorkshire, and Kent, but also (at first) in traditionally moderate Lancashire, Durham, and Northumberland. 
 The deep disillusion of the mining community (including miners' wives who played an unprecedently prominent role in the strike) at the erosion of their pits, their villages, and their way of life since the 1950s was spontaneous and genuine. 
 The strike lasted for virtually a year, ending in April 1985. 
 It was a battle that Mrs Thatcher, recalling Heath's humiliating climb-down in 1972 (and her own in 1981), was determined not to lose. 
 The government, indeed, had made careful preparations, both in conserving fuel stocks and protecting the power network with the aid of other European nations, and also in building up the co-ordinating powers of the police nationally to deal with mass picketing. 
 In 1972, at the time of the Saltley flying pickets mobilized by the young Scargill, the miners had held the upper hand; not so this time around. 
 There were violent clashes between police and pickets, notably at the Orgreave coking depot in Rotherham in the summer of 1984. 
 Britain seemed at times to be close to open class war; Mrs Thatcher denounced &bquo;the enemy within&equo;. 
 There were several times in 1984 when the government seemed fairly near to defeat, notably in November 1984 when the pit deputies&equo; union, NACODS, seemed likely to strike also. 
 This would mean that safety procedures would not be carried out and all the nation's pits might have to be scrapped in a mass act of collective suicide. 
 There was much public sympathy for the miners in general, however rebarbative the personality and creed of Arthur Scargill himself. 
 In October 1984, The Economist , remarkably enough, committed itself to the view that &bquo;Mrs Thatcher  is not now going to win the miners&equo; strike outright.&equo; 
 It based this false judgement on the need for conciliation and for restoring the fabric of industrial relations. 
 But there could be only one winner, in 1985 as in 1919. 
 The miners themselves were deeply divided, not least because Arthur Scargill had refused to carry out a ballot prior to calling a strike. 
 In Nottinghamshire and adjacent Warwickshire and Leicestershire, pits continued to operate, despite physical intimidation by mass pickets. 
 The eventual result was the breakaway from the NUM of a new union, the Union of Democratic Mineworkers, with a membership of close to 30,000. 
 After the turn of the year, with victory nowhere in sight, more and more miners returned to work in Lancashire and Scotland. 
 In early January, 71,000 out of 187,000 miners were back at work. 
 The personality of Arthur Scargill, with his apparent willingness to receive money from the terrorist regime of Colonel Qadaffi's Libya and his condoning of violence, alienated many, including the leader of the Labour Party, Neil Kinnock. 
 Himself the son of a South Wales miner, Kinnock compared Scargill with a world war general who wanted &bquo;another Gallipoli&equo;. 
 The police were far better organized than ever before, with the National Reporting Centre to co-ordinate police movements and intelligence and a high degree of latitude given to police in the handling of pickets, however violent the methods used. 
 The government, in the confident person of Peter Walker, the Energy Secretary, had a carefully worked-out policy of safeguarding power supplied through the national grid. 
 He forbade the Electricity Board to order voltage reductions, since this would give comfort to the NUM leadership. 
 A major turning-point came at the start of 1985 when Peter Walker announced that there would be no power cuts at all in the coming year, however long the strike lasted. 
 It was a kind of public dethroning of King Coal. 
 The winter was mild, which also told against the miners' cause. 
 The trade-union movement was reluctant to help, and there was relatively little sympathetic action from the railwaymen, dockers, or others. 
 Imported coal continued to be unloaded, some of it from Communist countries. 
 A general strike was  never remotely on the agenda, especially after the harsh treatment received by Norman Willis, the new TUC General secretary, from miners' meetings in militant areas. 
 Coal no longer dominated the national economic scene. 
 The industry employed barely 150,000 men. 
 It supplied only a fifth of the nation's energy supplies, far behind oil, and was now challenged by nuclear power. 
 No longer had the miners, the shock troops of the British working class, the power to dictate to a British government or to hold the community to ransom by sheer industrial muscle. 
 Nor, in truth, had they done so often in the past. 
 The era of class confrontation in Britain's coalfields had been confined mainly to the short period 1910&ndash;26. 
 In early April, in fine spring weather, the miners went back to work, &bquo;their heads held high&equo;, with brass bands blaring and ancient banners on display. 
 There was proud talk of Tolpuddle, Tonypandy, and Jarrow. 
 But they knew that it was a humiliating defeat. 
 Mrs Thatcher, who had routed President Galtieri of Argentina, had achieved a similar defeat of another president nearer home, Arthur Scargill of the miners. 
 Further contraction, pit closures, and industrial erosion would certainly follow. 
 The membership of the NUM, already attenuated by the defection of the UDM, fell drastically to total a mere 60,000 by the end of 1989, and they even lost their automatic right to a seat on Labour's national executive. 
 There was talk of the NUM being absorbed by the Transport and General Workers. 
 By late 1989 the labour force in the Welsh pits, once a quarter of a million men in those proud valleys, had fallen to less than 5,000. 
 In both Scotland and Lancashire it was barely 3,000, while the militant Kent coalfield had been totally wiped out with the successive closures of Snowdon, Tilmanston and Betteshanger pits. 
 As in 1926, so in 1985 the old legend of the impact of workers' solidarity and union power had been exploded. 
 It was the climax of a long, and indeed largely popular, campaign by the Thatcher government to undercut union monopoly in the labour market, and to exorcize memories of the &bquo;winter of discontent&equo;. 
 Along with privatization, supply-side finance, and &bquo;union-bashing&equo;, the government expressed its radicalism with a series of assaults on major segments and institutions within British society. 
 In effect, the security and strength of major professions were undermined for ever.  
 This meant in particular a direct attack on public-sector institutions and their custodians. 
 The enclosed world of the &bquo;quango&equo;, the public board, and the corporation came under fire in various guises. 
 Thus, in the Bank of England a series of clashes between the premier and the governor, Gordon Richardson, resulted in his replacement in 1983 by Robin Leigh-Pemberton, a banker of enterprise outlook and, politically, a known Conservative. 
 The stock market was fundamentally reformed by the &bquo;big bang&equo; (27 October 1986) which ended old restrictive practices. 
 Henceforth the old spectacle of brokers milling around on the Stock Exchange floor was replaced by silent, almost invisible, computerized networks for dealers, reflecting the new internationalism of the stock market. 
 In the Treasury, Keynesian critics such as Sir Douglas Wass were winkled out of their positions of influence, and new monetarist advisers such as John Hoskyns, Alan Walters, and Brian Griffiths emerged elsewhere, with the Policy Unit under first Ferdinand Mount and then, in 1985, John Redwood, assuming greater prominence. 
 The civil service found itself penetrated and politicized in the mid-1980s in a manner unknown since the days of Lloyd George. 
 The Civil Service Department, invented by Lord Crowther-Hunt in the Wilson years, was merged into the Treasury scheme of things in 1981. 
 A popular television series, &bquo;Yes, Minister&equo; (later &bquo;Yes, Prime Minister&equo;) openly parodied the consensual, complacent ways of the permanent secretaries and under-secretaries. 
 It was said to be Mrs Thatcher's favourite television programme &mdash; indeed, she actually took part in a rehearsal. 
 A particularly important sacred cow to slaughter was local government, to which the Thatcher government devoted much attention. 
 Since 1945 there had been repeated inquiries into the structure and finance of British local government, but until the 1970s no reform at all. 
 In the Wilson &mdash; Heath period of corporatism, local government had swollen in power and importance, especially after the massive eight metropolitan authorities set up by the Heath-Walker reforms in 1973. 
 Local authorities like the Greater London Council were spenders on a massive scale. 
 They were employers of a huge new group of middle-class employees, lecturers, social workers, local-government personnel of all kinds; local-government unions such as NALGO had expanded massively since 1970. 
 More, the major local  authorities were usually in Labour hands, frequently those of the far left. 
 Thus, men like Derek Hatton, the leader of Merseyside, and Ken Livingstone, who led the Greater London Council (after a brutal coup which removed the previous Labour leader, Andrew McIntosh) became symbols of ideological extremism and financial extravagance at one and the same time. 
 Of all the local authorities, however, it was, above all, Liverpool which marked out the challenge. 
 Once the happy city of the Beatles and &bquo;pop&equo; permissiveness, home of the most consistently successful football team in the land, Liverpool was now a visibly decaying city. 
 Its massive cathedrals towered over a community whose port and commercial infrastructure had collapsed as investment declined and union power encroached. 
 Some of the least attractive features of Liverpool society emerged in May 1985, when a riot of Liverpool football supporters at the Heysel football stadium in Brussels led to the death of many Italian football fans at the European Cup Final between Liverpool and Juventus of Turin. 
 It was Liverpool's housing and employment problems which had sparked the Toxteth race riots, and which led Michael Heseltine to launch a much-publicized new initiative at inner-city regeneration through more inward private investment. 
 The far left totally controlled Liverpool's city council, with Militant Tendency figures like Derek Hatton and Tony Mulhearn in command. 
 (Militant was a group of far-left activists working with constituency parties since the late 1970s.) 
 Liverpool inevitably became the centre for disputes about rate-capping for excessive expenditure, and then for surcharging when it tried to defy the government over expenditure cuts. 
 In the end, the government's 1986 Local Government Act ended the problem by, in effect, abolishing the metropolitan authorities, and indeed greatly curbing the power of local councils in general. 
 Despite popular laments for the great days of Herbert Morrison and &bquo;municipal socialism&equo; on the LCC, such Tory bugbears as the Merseyside authority and the Greater London Council disappeared from the scene. 
 A story of local democracy and participatory initiative dating from the reforms of the later 1880s came to its sad close. 
 It was a victory for Mrs Thatcher &mdash; though a debatable one since it largely snuffed out the power of British local government at a time when many other European countries were trying to decentralize  and devolve. 
 It was also a problem which enabled Labour's new young leader, Neil Kinnock, to make his mark, perhaps for the first time since his election in October 1983. 
 His passionate onslaught at the 1985 party conference against the Militants of Merseyside (whom he accused of hiring taxis to hand out redundancy notices to their workers) appealed to the unions and gave him new public stature. 
 But the longer-term victory was one for central government and its determined custodians. 
 Other public institutions were put to the sword elsewhere. 
 The Arts Council found its ability to provide patronage made more selective &mdash; perhaps rightly so, though the effects proved a serious blow to many theatres and galleries. 
 Its new chairman, Lord Rees-Mogg, showed an enthusiasm for applying the market approach to museums, art centres, and the like. 
 The American model of private funding of the arts was much cited. 
 In effect, this meant a steady decline in public funding, problems in finding support for artistic experimentation, and financial crises for such famous museums as the Tate Gallery in London and the Ashmolean in Oxford. 
 Some theatres had to close, though the opening of the Barbican Centre in the city of London provided yet another boost to musical and dance performances in the metropolis &mdash; which hardly needed it. 
 The BBC found itself embroiled in a long series of disputes with the government, partly over its financing, partly over alleged anti-government reporting of such episodes as the Libyan bombing raids in 1986 (covered by an able woman reporter, Kate Adie). 
 There were frequent clashes over the reporting of Northern Ireland, ending with a ban on interviews with members of Sinn Fein. 
 The BBC found itself increasingly demoralized, the proud corporate ethic of the days of Lord Reith under constant challenge. 
 Once again, a chairman sympathetic to the Thatcher regime was chosen, in this case &bquo;Duke&equo; Hussey, while a policy of supplying franchises to a variety of new commercial television and radio companies, exploiting the potential of satellite transmission, again threatened the BBC's position. 
 Many observers were disturbed by the way in which the high standards of service and integrity associated with the BBC as a public corporation were being compromised. 
 The commercial ethic meant some deterioration in standards, while the cutbacks in the Overseas News department, one of the glories of Bush House, caused much dismay in the public communications world. 
 The press was another estate of the realm cut down to size. 
 This  was partly by governmental pressure and the constraints placed on it by Bernard Ingham of the Prime Minister's press office. 
 More, it was the result of the involvement of large multi-national concerns like the newspaper empire of the American-based Australian, Rupert Murdoch, which took over not only the downmarket Sun  but also The Times . 
 The partisanship of both organs was not in doubt. 
 Whether press standards declined after this was a matter for debate. 
 What was clearer was that the range of opinion in the press tended increasingly to favour the government. 
 In both the 1983 and 1987 general elections the government had strong press support, with only the erratic Maxwell-owned tabloid, the Daily Mirror , to support Labour, along with the Alliance-inclined Guardian  and the Observer  on Sundays. 
 An impressive newcomer was the Independent , a centrist newspaper which emphasized finance, higher education, and other middle-class concerns. 
 The prospects of significant dissent from Fleet Street no longer existed. 
 Indeed, &bquo;Fleet Street&equo; itself was a misnomer from 1985 onwards, as modern technology and high unit costs led major newspapers to move out of central London to the eastern inner suburbs, to avoid the unions' stranglehold. 
 The long, sometimes violent, dispute with the print unions over the relocation of The Times  plant at Wapping marked a notable step both in the new financial and technological independence of the press and its ideological separateness from the union-corporate approach of the past. 
 The Church of England was also, to some degree, a victim of the Thatcherite attempt at hegemony. 
 The Church had continued to lose members in the 1970s and 1980s, yet it remained a powerful source of social criticism. 
 Its 1985 report on the inner cities, Faith in the City , was attacked by government ministers for its allegedly &bquo;Marxist&equo; inspiration. 
 The implied condemnation by Archbishop Runcie of the jingo spirit of the Falklands War, and the open, if confused, critique of the government's handling of the miners' strike by the Bishop of Durham, David Jenkins, caused a widening breach between government and the established Church. 
 The latter, it was claimed, was now in effect &bquo;the SDP at prayer&equo;. 
 Mrs Thatcher herself made appearances at Church and Methodist assemblies to rebuke bishops and nonconformist leaders for their hostile approach towards material gain, their over-involvement with issues such as poverty and urban decay, and their over-zealous support for black African nationalists in South Africa. 
 She rapped their collective knuckles (along with those of the Church of Scotland, which showed nationalist tendencies  as well) for their inability to see wealth creation as an essentially Christian act. 
 The good Samaritan with his non-mercenary values, it seemed, was not &bquo;one of us&equo; either. 
 In return, the Church cut a somewhat uncertain figure. 
 It was hesitant about its role, and indeed divided within itself over doctrinal issues like the significance of the Resurrection, and over such indicators of change as the ordination of women. 
 Wags commented on a search for &bquo;closet Christians&equo; among the bishops. 
 But here again was a major institution in the land in clear conflict with the determined woman who bestrode government &mdash; and actually appointed bishops and archbishops as well (though they often disappointed her). 
 The doctors, the architects, and, after 1987, the legal profession were all to face the same mood of antagonism. 
 No group in society, however, symbolized the alienation of key institutions from the government more clearly than did the university teachers. 
 The wheel had come full circle since the heady days of expansion after the Robbins Report in 1963. 
 In the sixties, the universities acquired a public esteem unique in British history. 
 Now, in the bitter 1980s they found themselves facing the impact of annual cuts in real funding, and pressures to apply new codes of managerial techniques and short-term profit-making out of tune with the traditional practices of British universities. 
 They also faced a loss of morale, with the drain of talented staff to the United States and Canada. 
 No group in Britain better illustrated the gulf between the old professional order and the new Thatcherite ethos. 
 To Mrs Thatcher, the universities were an enclosed, complacent guild, managerially incompetent, with little interest in wealth creation and lacking in accountability to government. 
 The University Grants Committee had acted as a buffer against change. 
 She herself, though a product of Oxford University, identified with wealth-producers and businessmen rather than with academics and intellectuals. 
 They in turn responded with incomprehension and then with anger. 
 In a famous episode in February 1985, Oxford University congregation voted by a 3 to 1 majority to deny the Prime Minister an honorary degree, a rebuff previously extended only to the late President Bhutto  of Pakistan. 
 The cause, it was stated, was the &bquo;systematic damage&equo; she had wrought on higher education &mdash; and indeed education in general. 
 It was a vigorous gesture, but also a risky one, since it emphasized the yawning gulf between the traditional pattern of autonomous free institutions within a plural culture and the new centralizing regime. 
 Universities continued to languish through the eighties. 
 Research programmes, especially in medical and other science, continued to be under-funded. 
 A revamped University Funding Council, directed by a former Cambridge don, Sir Peter Swinnerton-Dyer, threatened to impose much more severe financial disciplines on universities that were already struggling; on the other hand, the 1985 Jarratt Report resulted in complex new structures of planning, resource management, and managerial accountability. 
 Partly by way of compensation, the government lent its favour increasingly to the allegedly more cost-effective polytechnics (now made independent of local authorities), and to more practically or vocationally orientated institutions such as business schools. 
 They were more in tune with the thinking of a managerial government than were the traditional scholarly citadels of unproductive, useless learning. 
 In all these areas &mdash; the unions, the local authorities, the Church, the media, the universities and schools &mdash; the paradox was that a government notionally dedicated to extending individualism and the private ethic became a champion of greater centralization and state control. 
 Indeed, the central state built up its authority, directly and indirectly, in the Thatcher years more decisively than in, say, the Attlee period, which was by comparison a model of high pluralism, evidence by the retreat from &bquo;planning&equo; in 1947&ndash;50. 
 This new centralism was in part because the Thatcher government perceived these institutions as potentially so damaging that they needed the maximum of intervention to suppress them. 
 It was also the case that the conversion of the population to the market philosophy needed direction on a massive scale. 
 Thatcherism was philosophy teaching by encroachment rather than by example. 
 It was thus the very strength of the state, the power of major government departments such as the Environment or Education and Science over the somewhat ragged army of local-government officials, dons, bishops, editors, and men and women of letters that contemporaries noted. 
  In the universities, where in the sixties rioting students and the educated tele-celebrities of the &bquo;chattering classes&equo; had commanded public attention, there were now dormant, apolitical students anxious only for their future employment, and embittered lecturers suffering a crisis of morale and lamenting the bureaucratic invasion of time traditionally left for teaching and research. 
 The freedom and autonomy guaranteed for universities by the old University Grants Committee were no more. 
 It was a centralization that was not only institutional in its forms. 
 It was also highly personal in its focus. 
 The Thatcher Cabinet after 1983 radiated from the woman at the centre. 
 It was personalized and identifiable in a way unknown since Lloyd George's heyday. 
 The Thatcher Cabinet had become crystallized as a system of conviction politics all on its own. 
 The Prime Minister relied in part on private advisers like Charles Powell, Robin Butler, and her press secretary, Bernard Ingham, a &bquo;garden suburb&equo; no less than in 1918. 
 Indeed, she had a talent for implying that somehow she did not belong to her own Cabinet. 
 She communicated instead with a small group of trusties like Lord Young, and advisers within her policy unit. 
 Her relations with both her Foreign Secretary and Chancellor of the Exchequer became somewhat cool, not least because she attempted to run both foreign and financial policy herself. 
 The dangers to the Thatcher regime, it appeared, came not from revolts or putsches  on the back benches. 
 Dissidents like Francis Pym came and went; his banner of revolt, The Politics of Consent  (1984), a cool, rational argument in favour of &bquo;consensus&equo;, failed to spark a Heathite revival. 
 Still less did the danger lie in overthrow by Labour or by assorted dissidents or intellectuals. 
 It lay rather in its rigidity, in the way that centralization was hardening, some felt, into something approaching personal dictatorship. 
 Like Louis XIV before her, Mrs Thatcher might provoke an eventual revolution. 
 It was this growing tendency after 1983 which almost brought the government to its knees. 
 The crisis arose from an extraordinarily  parochial subject, namely whether the small Westland group of helicopter manufacturers, situated in Yeovil in the West Country, should be purchased by a European consortium or by the US-dominated Sikorsky &mdash; Fiat group. 
 There were thus foreign-policy implications as well as business issues at stake. 
 There was a furious row over the negotiations in Cabinet between Michael Heseltine, Minister of Defence, and Leon Brittan, Secretary for Trade and Industry, which soon became embarrassingly public. 
 By November 1985 it became apparent that the real antagonists were neither the Westland company nor British Aerospace, but Michael Heseltine, as a vigorous champion of the European link, and Mrs Thatcher. 
 On 9 January 1986 Heseltine dramatically walked out of a full Cabinet and resigned in the full glare of televisual attention. 
 He accompanied his resignation with biting public criticisms of the dictatorial style of the Prime Minister. 
 Nor did the matter end there. 
 In increasingly bizarre circumstances the Attorney-General, Sir Patrick Mayhew, discovered that a letter of his, partially rebuking Heseltine, had been selectively leaked to the press without his permission or knowledge by a young female official in the Department of Trade, one Colette Bowe. 
 After denying knowledge of the leak to the House, apparently to protect the Prime Minister, Leon Brittan, the Secretary for Trade, also resigned on 24 January. 
 Whether Mrs Thatcher herself was implicated in the leak is not known, but it was widely believed that Brittan resigned to save her skin. 
 It was also known that Mrs Thatcher's closest advisers, Charles Powell and Bernard Ingham, were implicated in the leak, and it seemed improbable that the Prime Minister should have been totally ignorant. 
 There was a real threat that she might have to resign. 
 In the event, she just survived, partly because Neil Kinnock made an inadequate speech in the Commons debate, but perhaps really because helicopters were really too parochial an issue to involve the fall of governments. 
 But the Westland affair lingered on for some time to come. 
 It showed up the Achilles heel of the government &mdash; its excessively dictatorial tendencies. 
 Collective responsibility seemed to be disappearing. 
 At this time Mrs Thatcher looked somewhat less in  command, with coded criticism of her style coming from such ministers as Douglas Hurd and, more surprisingly, John Biffen, a previous admirer of hers. 
 Younger men like Kenneth Clarke, Kenneth Baker, and John MacGregor were less identified with the Prime Minister personally. 
 In the summer of 1986, the legacy of Westland and local-government losses led to a relatively low point for the government. 
 A defeat by an Alliance candidate in the Ryedale by-election confirmed this. 
 As in the autumn of 1981, it seemed to be losing its way, with doubts over government support for British Leyland, ministers attacked over repeated strikes by secondary school teachers, and criticisms also over Britain's support for President Reagan at the time of bombing raids on Libya. 
 The government had to retreat over a plan to sell British Leyland trucks to America's General Motors &mdash; partly because of a rooted popular affection for Britain's &bquo;Land Rovers&equo;, partly because it had the air of a Westland mark II. 
 The very parliamentary strength of the government and its consequent lack of accountability, were proving its weakness. 
 For most people, unaware of the implications of an obscure West Country helicopter firm, it was in other ways that the government's problems showed themselves. 
 One of the notable features of the mid-Thatcher period was a revival of the civil liberties movement, as governmental pressures against individual right of expression impressed themselves on the public consciousness. 
 There was some pressure for a Bill of Rights, notably from the &bquo;Charter 88&equo; group. 
 The use of the Official Secrets Act against government employees and others became more widespread. 
 One civil servant, at least, managed to escape the net when Clive Ponting, a Ministry of Defence official who had leaked documents about apparent ministerial lies on the sinking of the Belgrano  during the Falklands War, was acquitted by a jury when the case came to court. 
 A Guardian  journalist, Sarah Tisdall, was not so fortunate. 
 Otherwise, the pressure exerted by the security services, aided by the police, caused much concern. 
 The free-ranging behaviour of the police during the miner's strike, for instance, provoked some alarm, since it appeared to negate the traditional approach to freedom of movement around the country. 
 That the police should stop law-abiding Kent miners at the Dartford tunnel on the grounds that they were thought to be destined for the Yorkshire coalfield two hundred miles away was remarkable indeed. 
 More concern was caused by the abolition of free trade unionism in the GCHQ security establishment at Cheltenham; this appeared to  equate trade unionism with disloyalty, even treason. 
 There was also a strange security operation against a journalist following disclosures about espionage devices (&bquo;Zircon&equo;) in the New Statesman . 
 In addition, there was the matter of John Stalker, the Deputy Chief Constable of Manchester, who was flagrantly obstructed within the police service when he attempted to inquire into abuses by the Royal Ulster Constabulary. 
 In disgust, Stalker left the police force altogether. 
 Aspects of the Westland case also showed the dangers of a government monopoly over the dissemination of information and its resultant debate. 
 One, more entertaining, episode was the lengthy attempt to suppress the publication of the book Spycatcher , the memoirs of an elderly ex-member of MI5, Peter Wright, an emigrant to Tasmania. 
 Among other things, he alleged that MI5 had tried to destabilize the Wilson governments. 
 The Secretary of the Cabinet, Sir Robert Armstrong, who had stonewalled successfully on Mrs Thatcher's behalf during the Westland inquiries, was sent to Australia in a vain attempt to stop the book being published there. 
 Armstrong's patrician Oxbridge performance was not very successful in the brash atmosphere of the Australian courts &mdash; significantly less so than his performances before House of Commons committees. 
 In a near-fatal aper&ccedil;u , Armstrong's comment on the civil servant's need to be &bquo;economical with the truth&equo; seemed to set the seal on a growing process of encroachment on individual freedoms by a strong-minded, centralist government. 
 Meanwhile, travellers abroad found no difficulty in buying Spycatcher  in airport bookstalls. 
 Whether civil liberties or freedom of expression really languished in this period is open to debate. 
 The Thatcher government's strong stance on many issues won much popular support amongst a people weary of attempts to defy the law by left-wing local authorities, strike pickets, or disaffected journalists. 
 The emotion roused by the murder of a policeman in late 1985 during racial disturbances at Broadwater Farm, a dismal sixties high-rise housing estate in Tottenham, north London, confirmed much public endorsement of the role of the police in a public-order capacity. 
 It also showed up the disasters of previous patterns of so-called neighbourhood planning. 
 The Labour Party seemed to sense that it had gone too far in criticism of the police, perhaps in response to the far-left, middle-class activists of sociological inclination, and had been too tender towards violent criminals and other deviants. 
 It turned its attention to &bquo;victim support&equo;. 
 of  children especially. 
 From 1985 onwards, &bquo;law and order&equo; became a watchword for the British left, too. 
 Artists of various kinds complained of the restrictions under which they laboured. 
 Yet, compared with the literary censorship of the sixties, these were in most areas miniscule. 
 The long moralistic campaigns of Mrs Mary Whitehouse directed at BBC television had not made much headway. 
 It was lack of funding rather than lack of freedom that was the main burden for British writers and artists in this period. 
 For all that, the Thatcher high noon seemed to show the balance between state power and individual self-expression, in some key episodes, tilting against the individual or the dissenting minority. 
 The police and the security services grew stronger; the press and media generally were more subject to control. 
 It made dissent, social criticism, and alternative scenarios more difficult to articulate. 
 The image of the government was one of strength in domestic affairs. 
 So, too, was it overseas, though in a less belligerent mode as time went on. 
 Mrs Thatcher herself emerged with greater international stature now, in large measure because of her relationship with President Ronald Reagan. 
 This went through some crises, as when the Americans dispatched marines to put down a left-wing government in the British island of Grenada in 1984, without communicating their intentions to the British government. 
 But on the main episodes, Anglo-American collaboration stood firm. 
 During the Falklands War, as has been seen, American support, including missiles, materially assisted towards a British victory. 
 In the bombing of sites in Libya in April 1986, in the face of much criticism at home, Mrs Thatcher strongly defended the right of the Americans to use British bases such as Upper Heyford for long-range attacks. 
 The bombing was, she argued, intended to dislodge the Qaddafi regime in Libya-even though it was civilian property as much as air-bases that were bombed, with much loss of life amongst children and others. 
 One major result was the confirmation of a long-term American commitment to maintain the British nuclear deterrent, including the use of Trident missiles. 
 Mrs Thatcher had emerged with much more confidence on the world stage by 1987. 
 On the one hand, she was able to temper President Reagan's willingness to engage in long-term negotiations over intermediate-range and other missiles based  in western Europe. 
 She remained dedicated to the American nuclear umbrella over the west. 
 At the same time, through a somewhat unlikely relationship with the emergent Soviet leader Mikhail Gorbachev, she was able to present herself as no longer an &bquo;iron lady&equo; but an instrument of greater international co-operation. 
 She &bquo;could do business with Mr Gorbachev&equo;, she told the world. 
 She also appeared more convincing in a European role. 
 The old abrasiveness over the community budget had for the moment disappeared. 
 The British Prime Minister emerged as a much more accommodating personality; at the Fontainebleau summit in June 1984 she was deemed to be now &bquo;a good European&equo;. 
 But on longer-term issues such as membership of the European Monetary System she remained hostile. 
 The British attitude to Europe remained as functional and piecemeal as it had been in the time of Ernest Bevin after 1945. 
 One symbolic breach with age-old insularity came with the decision, confirmed in a ceremony in Canterbury Cathedral in February 1986, for Britain and France to build a channel tunnel to provide a rail link between the two countries. 
 The ceremony in this Anglo-Norman setting was replete with references to Charlemagne, Napoleon, and Churchill. 
 But in fact it rested on more pragmatic considerations of Anglo-French trade common to both Mrs Thatcher and President Mitterrand, along with the need to boost employment in south-east England and along the Pas de Calais. 
 Despite this, Mrs Thatcher's European sympathies remained distinctly moderate. 
 In time, both Howe and Lawson were to prove more sympathetic to the notion of monetary and economic union with the Community. 
 But at least since 1984 the major flashpoints of conflict between Britain and her European partners had disappeared, while Mrs Thatcher found, with the departure of Schmidt and Giscard d'Estaing, a greater eminence as both a European and a world statesman. 
 This image of statesmanship also held true nearer home. 
 In Ireland the tide of murder and violence continued, though the IRA felt increasingly desperate in the stranglehold maintained by the security forces. 
 In one terrifying episode, Mrs Thatcher and her ministers came close to being collectively murdered in the bombing of the Grand Hotel, Brighton, in October 1984. 
 Many felt that a grand gesture of statesmanship was required in relation to Northern Ireland. 
 It was Mrs Thatcher who appeared to supply it. 
 The situation  in Ulster in 1985 was as bleak as ever. 
 In addition to the background of violence and sectarian division which had ruined Prior's plan for &bquo;rolling devolution&equo;, there was growing economic decay. 
 Northern Ireland's was heavily a public-sector economy; its rate of unemployment, at 21 per cent, was the highest in Britain. 
 In Catholic working-class areas like Newry, Londonderry's Bogside, and parts of West Belfast, it rose to even 30 or 40 per cent. 
 Major giants in the Ulster economy like Shorts Aircraft were in difficulties, while the Harland and Woolf shipyards were making heavy losses. 
 Without a political initiative, however, it was hard to see how economic progress could be made. 
 Much was owed here to the new Northern Irish Secretary, Douglas Hurd, and to Robert Armstrong on the British side, and to the genial presence of the Fine Gael premier, Garratt FitzGerald, in Dublin. 
 But Mrs Thatcher, too, lent her moral support to what resulted. 
 The outcome was the Hillsborough agreement of 15 November 1985. 
 Under this Mrs Thatcher and Dr FitzGerald agreed that Northern Ireland would remain a part of the United Kingdom according to the wishes of its majority, but that ministers from Britain and the Republic would meet regularly to review political and security aspects. 
 In effect, for the first time since 1922, the direct interest of the Dublin government in the internal affairs of Northern Ireland was explicitly set out. 
 It caused uproar in Ulster Unionist ranks where all fifteen Unionist MPs, among them Enoch Powell (South Down), decided to resign their seats in a mass protest. 
 The Prime Minister's personal secretary, Ian Gow, also resigned. 
 The agreement, however, passed the House of Commons by 473 votes to 47 and received a similar endorsement in the Irish D&aacute;il. 
 As a symbolic act it was of much importance since it offered the prospect of a framework for a wider Anglo-Irish settlement and provided a hope of genuine political involvement for the Catholic minority in Northern Ireland, not in a failed local assembly but through their co-religionists in the south. 
 But the question remained whether it could really mean much in practice. 
 The Protestant majority in Ulster totally refused to acknowledge, let alone operate, the Hillsborough Agreement. 
 The truth, indeed, was that the agreement was conceived essentially in a British context. 
 It marked a fresh stage in the process of the isolation of  the Ulster Unionists from the British political scene &mdash; and indeed from the Conservative Party itself which had once proudly named itself &bquo;Unionist&equo; in the days of Balfour and Bonar Law. 
 The security problem remained acute, not least because the Royal Ulster Constabulary, which had suffered grievously in various shootings and bombings, was clearly seen as a Protestant ascendancy force. 
 Only 3 per cent of its members were Catholic. 
 But the Hillsborough Agreement made Mrs Thatcher look credible and constructive over Northern Ireland in the eyes of world opinion, and especially in the United States. 
 In this, at least, it succeeded, however limited its success as a settlement for the endemic, historic problems of Ireland. 
 In this period there was much journalistic talk of Britain's world reputation having recovered after decades of decline. 
 Mrs Thatcher herself claimed to have &bquo;renewed the spirit and solidarity of the nation&equo;. 
 There was, indeed, some truth to this. 
 Her varied responses in the North Atlantic alliance, in the European community, in Irish affairs, and in attempting to mediate in the Middle East as broker between the Arabs and Israel added to this impression. 
 At the same time, this belief in British national strength owed much to short-term factors. 
 Military victory in the Falklands gave Britain a new stature for a time, but by 1987 the impact of this had disappeared. 
 The strength of the British economy in the mid-1980s, the signs of growth and rising prosperity, helped dispel the old image of &bquo;the sick man of Europe&equo;. 
 As long as the balance of payments remained boosted by North Sea oil and the pattern of growth continued, so Britain's international credibility would continue to grow. 
 Above all, there was Mrs Thatcher's uniquely close link with President Reagan &mdash; but this, too, could only be a temporary phenomenon. 
 Even in this area, notably over the Americans &bquo;Star Wars&equo; defence system, there had been rifts as well as accord in the transatlantic relationship. 
 The Reykjavik summit, when President Reagan met Mr Gorbachev for the second time, led to a notable strain between Washington and London. 
 The world reputation of the Prime Minister provided grist for the mill of the Conservative Party managers by 1987, but it was invariably presented in terms of the traditional imagery that Thatcherism meant strength, secure defence, and freedom from the defeatism of socialism and the unilateralists. 
 Mrs Thatcher's approach to world affairs remained in key respects significantly insular, her approach to full European collaboration notably hesitant. 
 To the extent that her position was based on a reputation as a  creative world leader or participant in great events, it was a partial deception. 
 In the spring of 1987, with the economic omens still cheerful, Mrs Thatcher decided to call another general election. 
 The campaign was not without its strains, not least because of tactical disagreements between Lord Young and the Party Chairman, Norman Tebbit. 
 The latter also diverged from the Prime Minister, with whom he had latterly differed over Westland, Libya, and other issues. 
 For all that, the result as in 1983 was not in doubt. 
 Neil Kinnock fought, personally, a highly effective and energetic campaign. 
 He succeeded amply in Labour's main objective of defeating the Alliance as the main alternative to the Conservatives. 
 Yet Labour still operated against a background of long-term decline. 
 It was based essentially on the old industrial areas of Scotland, Wales, and the North, on the public-sector unions, and on client electors on council housing estates and in the local-government services. 
 It had less and less to say to a home-owning, share-owning, bourgeoisified population, at least so it seemed. 
 Labour seemed happiest when proclaiming its undying support for the National Health Service and the state education system of the post-Beveridge era. 
 It continued to celebrate the glories of the Attlee years. 
 On the issues of the future, especially on wealth creation and technological change, Labour had little to say. 
 It was muffled on trade-union reform and taxation policy. 
 It was confused on Europe, and on defence still caught in the grip of an unpopular unilateralism. 
 The spectre of Bennery haunted it still. 
 In much of southern England, Labour hardly existed. 
 Outside parts of inner London, it held only two seats now in the south and east, below a line drawn from Bristol to the Wash. 
 In the metropolis, its seats were largely dilapidated older boroughs; it held none of the thriving suburban seats or commuter constituencies. 
 The movement begun in 1945 had indeed come full circle. 
 If Labour offered only a feeble challenge, the Alliance was scarcely more than a rabble. 
 The Alliance campaign, with the differing emphasis posed by Liberals' David Steel, who was of the centre-left, and the Social Democrat, David Owen, who contemplated a possible coalition with the Tories, was a disaster. 
 At no stage did the Alliance make any serious impact or strike any distinctive note. 
 In the end,  the Tory majority remained virtually intact. 
 The Conservatives, with 42.3 per cent of the vote, won 376 seats; Labour, with 30.8 per cent, won 229, only a small improvement on the d&eacute;b&acirc;cle of 1983; and the Alliance won a mere 22 seats, with 22.6 per cent of the vote. 
 Election experts could legitimately point to the fact that a system of proportional voting could have given a very different result. 
 Once again Mrs Thatcher won a huge majority with the support of well under half of the British people. 
 But this was, in every sense, academic. 
 After another successful campaign, apart from some setbacks in Wales and near-disaster in Scotland, the Thatcher regime seemed as impregnable as before. 
 The new mood established in 1979 seemed amply confirmed. 
 The 1987 election marked the high noon of the government of Margaret Thatcher. 
 All its major innovations &mdash; the sale of council houses, the reform of the unions, privatization of industry, tax reform &mdash; had met with popular acclaim and substantially added to the Conservatives' constituency. 
 There was a genuine public image of national strength and rising prosperity, though the latter was distinctly variable in its regional impact. 
 Even though opinion polls might show that &bquo;Butskellite&equo; or &bquo;Labourish&equo; attitudes prevailed among the people on such issues as health, housing, education, and pensions, the main thrust of the election was clearly to give backing to the anti-socialist, anti-planning revolt which had gathered momentum since 1979. 
 For several years, a sustained attempt had been made to inject the institutional and cultural life of the nation with market philosophies and business values, to galvanize national complacency with the short, sharp shock of enterprise. 
 One after the other the main adversaries, local authorities, the miners, the universities, the bishops, dissidents of various shades, had retreated in disarray. 
 As Mrs Thatcher reflected on her sweeping victory in the aftermath of the polls, urging her weary troops to yet more frenetic endeavours in the future, with the inner cities (and their Labour-led councils) as the next target, she could contemplate a major seachange in the national consciousness. 
 No less plausibly than Attlee and his colleagues in 1945, Mrs Thatcher was entitled to declare: &bquo;We are the masters now.&equo;  
 After the 1987 election, the battle went on with new intensity. 
 Radical measures heralded by the Queen's Speech proliferated as the momentum of change was kept up. 
 No one by 1989 could doubt the Prime Minister's stamina as, politically, a long-distance runner. 
 The question now was whether she was going too far, straining the responses of an ancient nation beyond what was acceptable or practicable. 
 Indeed, in the very aftermath of the elections, a series of government initiatives all ran into some difficulty. 
 They suggested perhaps that more remained of the pre-1979 order than Thatcherite zealots had imagined. 
 There were limits to the extent to which the post-1945 consensus could be overturned. 
 Thus, in local government, attempts to curb the spending and pretensions of local authorities from Liverpool to Lambeth, especially when they could be designated &bquo;loony left&equo;, were widely acceptable. 
 Much less so were efforts to remodel the existing rating system by a new local tax, imposed without regard to the ability to pay. 
 The proposal for a community charge &mdash; or &bquo;poll tax&equo; &mdash; put forward by Nicholas Ridley in 1988 ran into furious local opposition, not least among the Scots who were to be the first to pay this new imposition, After all, freeborn Englishmen, led by Wat Tyler, had revolted against a poll tax as long ago as 1381, and its bluntness and social inequity helped fuel a considerable popular protest, including in the Conservative shires. 
 The advent of the poll tax in Scotland in 1989 and in England and Wales in 1990, with its heavy burden on working-class families in urban areas, enormously added to the government's unpopularity. 
 Again, the relatively popular policy of the privatization of industry fell on stony ground when it was proposed for extension to the electricity supply industry and to water services. 
 The case for efficiency in each case was not made out, and there was a clear prospect, at a time of rising inflation, of large increases in charges for both, especially for water supply, with privately metered arrangements likely to increase the cost to the domestic consumer. 
 The environmental advantages of privately-run water supply services were also far from clear, with European reports drawing attention to the pollution of Britain's rivers and beaches. 
 There were early signs that the proposed &pound;7 billion flotation of water shares was going slowly. 
 Some felt Mrs Thatcher was now denationalizing out of dogma, without making out a case on managerial or cost grounds. 
  Labour recovered its confidence here and firmly promised that a future Labour government would return both electricity and water to public ownership and control. 
 Privatization was losing its magnetism with the public, as the government's decision to delay the electricity measure until late in 1990 seemed to confirm. 
 Aspects of the government's attempts to infuse the welfare state with the spirit of competition and the market-place also ran into difficulties in both education and health. 
 Kenneth Baker, the Secretary of State for Education, met with opposition to his proposals to weaken the structure of state education, notably by allowing comprehensive schools to opt out of the secondary system, and by giving more powers to parents in running schools, a latent veto for the middle-class. 
 The 1988 Education Act was much criticized. 
 So, too, were its features relating to universities and higher education generally. 
 The government found itself having to make concessions to normally docile bodies like the House of Lords and the Committee of Vice-Chancellors and Principals, over such matters as security of tenure for academics and the universities' powers to raise their own finance. 
 Government ministers now boasted of having increased spending on higher education and struck an expansionist note in calling for doubling student numbers over the next twenty-five years. 
 It was increasingly difficult for the government to rely on popular hostility towards the teachers' unions in getting through what many saw as a direct attack on quality in the schools. 
 The attempt to achieve a national core curriculum, while widely supported as a way of improving literacy and numeracy amongst schoolchildren, was also feared as yet another turn in the ratchet of state control over local experimentation. 
 It was also a comment on years of underfunding, by international standards, in the nation's schools. 
 Perhaps the most strongly opposed of all the government's innovations was its challenge to the National Health Service in February 1989. 
 The NHS had long become a totem of bipartisan welfare provision, Bevan's conflict with the BMA long forgotten. 
 Mrs Thatcher had been constrained to observe in 1982 that the NHS was &bquo;safe&equo; with her. 
 Labour's attack on the under-funding of hospitals and long waiting lists for patients awaiting operations had been effective in its otherwise ineffectual 1987 election campaign. 
 Kenneth Clarke, the Minister of Health, now proposed to introduce the market  mechanism, to give doctors more control over their own budgets and, perhaps more alarmingly to many, to allow hospitals to contract out of the health service altogether if they wished. 
 This seemed to many privatization run mad. 
 A notable feature of the resultant controversy was that the British Medical Association, the virulent opponent of Aneurin Bevan in 1946, was now most forceful in defending the health service, in denouncing the government for threatening its existence and failing to fund it as was properly required. 
 Clarke engaged in a vigorous debate with the doctors but found public sympathy running against him. 
 Despite years of Thatcherism, both deep-rooted sympathy for the NHS as a bulwark of the welfare state, and the professional strength and influence of the doctors as a pressure-group were still remarkably strong. 
 It was widely believed that the Conservatives' heavy defeat in the Vale of Glamorgan by-election in May 1989 was partly due to the campaign of local general practitioners against the government's health plans. 
 Labour had now the most natural of themes, invoking the almost sacred name of Nye Bevan. 
 Conservative attempts to find new radical impetus seemed to have backfired. 
 Other unpopular new measures were the deregulation of private rented housing and the &bquo;targeting&equo; of social security benefits, with disadvantage to many. 
 There seemed grounds for believing that the Thatcher government was, at least for a time, losing direction. 
 The loss of William Whitelaw, who suffered a stroke and had to leave the government, was a blow to the Prime Minister. 
 He had chaired major Cabinet committees, including that for home affairs and the &bquo;star chamber&equo; on public expenditure cuts. 
 More, he was almost the last representative of Tory paternalism of the old one-nation type, an important source of consolidation within the Cabinet. 
 Mrs Thatcher had no one else like him. 
 All the old Heathites, save for Peter Walker (a highly individualist and most effective leftish Secretary of State for Wales) were on the back-benches. 
 Norman Tebbit had also fallen out with Mrs Thatcher and left the government, while Leon Brittan, recently knighted, found a new niche at Brussels. 
 A symptomatic problem came with a ministerial wrangle over salmonella in egg production which cost the government the presence of Mrs Edwina Currie. 
 By early 1989 the Prime Minister was at odds with several colleagues,  not only Nigel Lawson with whom she quarrelled incessantly, but also with Sir Geoffrey Howe whose sympathy for European monetary union and generally benign approach to foreign affairs came increasingly to jar with her. 
 She had no Cabinet intimate and seemed increasingly isolated on her lofty eminence. 
 Another former confidant, John Biffen, in effect removed himself from the government after coded criticism of the Prime Minister's strident, dogmatic style. 
 The administration became more and more centralized and the civil service enmeshed with it, notably after Robin Butler became Secretary to the Cabinet in 1988. 
 Something more fundamental than the &bquo;banana skin&equo; of Westland seemed to be happening. 
 The government was plunging on into uncharted waters without a pilot or perhaps a map. 
 But the main reason why the tide of Thatcherism seemed to ebb after the 1987 election was that its main claim to popular support, the apparent revival of the economy and the stimulus to productive growth, was beginning to lose credibility. 
 There was a huge stockmarket crash in October 1987 which wiped 24 per cent off stock prices. 
 Yet Nigel Lawson continued with a vigorous supply-side policy of tax cutting. 
 This reached a climax in the budget of March 1988 which reduced the rate of income tax to two bands only, 40 per cent for the rich and 25 per cent for all other income-tax payers. 
 This was hard to justify on either monetarist or public equity grounds. 
 Left-wing critics furiously attacked the Chancellor's cynicism and blatant inegalitarianism. 
 More orthodox critics feared that he was only stoking up a consumer boom which would reap the whirlwind in a vast price inflation. 
 Mrs Thatcher tried to respond to social critics by emphasizing the government's caring image in help for the elderly and programmes for schools. 
 But the latter charge concerning domestic inflation appeared to be correct. 
 By the summer of 1989 the old evils of &bquo;stagflation&equo; seemed to have returned to haunt the government. 
 Non-oil imports had been rising steadily throughout 1987 and 1988. 
 The current-account deficit in the year following the March 1988 budget was to reach nearly &pound;20 billion, easily the largest figure  on record. 
 The pound came under pressure and fell steadily against the dollar and the deutschmark in the spring of 1989; in the autumn the dollar and the deutschmark in the spring of 1989; in the autumn, the slump in its value became far more alarming. 
 Worst of all, the conquest of inflation, the government's main boast, seemed undone as inflation rose to reach 8.3 per cent by June 1989. 
 Nigel Lawson, it seemed, was neither holding the pound steady abroad nor keeping down prices at home. 
 This time it was a consumer-credit and spending boom, not government borrowing, that was causing the problem. 
 Critics dated this from the controversial tax-cutting budget of 1988. 
 Lawson's chosen weapon was the most politically damaging that he could have selected &mdash; successive increases in interest rates, to reach a minimum lending rate of 15 per cent by October 1989, on the eve of the Tory party conference. 
 With Britain a nation of mortgage-holders who operated in an economy based in large measure on the credit system, this brought home the immediacy of the government's difficulties with the economy to almost every householder in the land. 
 Indeed, as the indices stubbornly refused to improve, there seemed little prospect that interest rates would not remain at this historically high level for a long period to come. 
 Hope of a &bquo;soft landing&equo; for the economy were at least deferred, and the stock-market plunged downwards that troubled autumn. 
 The crisis deepened when Nigel Lawson resigned as Chancellor in October after a disagreement with Professor Alan Walters. 
 John Major replaced him. 
 The main Conservative claim to national support, therefore, namely that they had worked an economic miracle, seemed increasingly shallow. 
 Monetarism had run into the sands long before Lawson himself effectively buried it, along with the medium-term strategy, in 1985. 
 But his alternative, more flexible approach had proved fallible also. 
 Evidently he had rejected the Keynesianism of the past, though the course of economic debate now suggested that apostles of the old orthodoxy were beginning to recover their confidence. 
 It would be hard, though, to call Lawson a strict monetarist either. 
 Control of interest rates loomed far larger than control of money supply. 
 On balance, it was his wish to defend sterling by interventionist methods, to check activity at home and keep down the sterling price of imports, rather than curb the flow of money, that dictated much of his policy. 
 But what kind of post-monetarism he was espousing was uncertain, too. 
 This uncertainty was reflected in  unprecedented levels of argument within the government, conducted in the full glare of public attention. 
 The Prime Minister came close to accusing the Chancellor of starting the inflationary spiral by an attempt to link the rate for sterling with the value of the German deutschmark. 
 Nigel Lawson rebutted this with some vigour. 
 It seemed that the Prime Minister was unable to dismiss her Chancellor, but was unable to invest him with full confidence either. 
 On the approach to the European monetary system, Prime Minister and Chancellor were more at odds. 
 Mrs Thatcher, in effect, did not anticipate being linked to the monetary system of an increasingly interventionist Europe in her political lifetime. 
 Nigel Lawson, by contrast, saw the EMS as a potential brake against violent fluctuations in the rate of exchange. 
 The debate between them oscillated, sometimes violently. 
 Britain was indeed committed to entering a free and open European market in 1992, but it could well do so with the highest inflation rate in western Europe, the worst balance of payments, and the sharpest contraction in the manufacturing base. 
 Whether or not Britain joined the EMS in due course, it would be operating against a background of some endemic weakness. 
 Without exactly being in the &bquo;stop &mdash; go&equo; cycle of Selwyn Lloyd or the &bquo;hard slog&equo; of Roy Jenkins in years gone by, Britain's posture in the later Thatcher period still seemed to reflect the historic structural weakness of former years. 
 The Prime Minister, after all, had been unable to change everything &bquo;totally and utterly&equo;. 
 Arguments over the EMS confirmed that in overseas affairs the country had not really recovered the proud international stature that had been proclaimed. 
 The nation's foreign policy remained highly personal, with Downing Street bypassing the Foreign Office time and again. 
 Mrs Thatcher was still highly visible at international summits, but often now as an obstructive, quarrelsome figure. 
 Her main claim to influence had been her close association with President Reagan. 
 His retirement in January 1 989 left, inevitably, a much more indirect relationship between London and the new incumbent, President George Bush. 
 The special relationship looked more formal and detached, with Mrs Thatcher in danger of being sidelined, with her suspicion of long-range missile agreements that might mean the end of Trident and a potential British nuclear presence. 
 Instead of her more bellicose approach, the somewhat more neutralist stance of the  West Germans loomed larger in NATO, and indeed it was Bonn rather than London that seemed to have the closer relationship with Washington in 1989. 
 Mrs Thatcher's international stature also rested on the curious chemistry of her relationship with President Gorbachev of the Soviet Union, but the rigour of the Prime Minister consorted somewhat uneasily with the fluid world of perestroika , democratization throughout eastern Europe, German reunification, and moves towards international disarmament. 
 It seemed, in the wake of rival expulsions of alleged spies from London and Moscow, that Anglo-Russian relations were not as buoyant or as important as the British Prime Minister had claimed. 
 Meanwhile in the European Community, even with old arguments over the budget and farm policy removed, the British government looked like a somewhat negative force. 
 The Prime Minister argued strongly against any form of federalism that would undermine the sovereignty of the nation-state. 
 Her Bruges speech in the autumn of 1988, drafted by Charles Powell, which attacked the notion of &bquo;a United States of Europe&equo;, aroused much controversy, though the &bquo;Bruges group&equo; of right-wing historians and others declared their support for Mrs Thatcher's stand. 
 The irony was that it was the British Labour Party which now responded more sympathetically towards Europe, since the social charter of the Community, drafted by its French socialist president, Jacques Delors, was in most respects highly congenial to the British left. 
 On the other hand, Mrs Thatcher was wont to see in the Delors Charter the kind of creeping state socialism and patronage of the trade unions which she hoped to have dispelled in Britain itself. 
 Within the Common Market, Britain in 1989 seemed as much the odd nation out as it had been in 1979 at the time of the rancorous Dublin summit, unable to prevent major changes within the Community by responding in a negative, bad-tempered way. 
 Britain as a committed member of the European world was not a wholly credible concept at the time of the Madrid summit in June 1989, or in the Strasbourg conference that November. 
 Ten years of vigorous overseas promotion, therefore, left Britain somewhat isolated in Europe and outweighted in NATO. 
 Within the Commonwealth, Mrs Thatcher's hostility towards trade sanctions on South Africa had long weakened ties with the African and Asian states so fruitfully built up at the time of the settlement in Zimbabwe in 1979. 
 As Dean Acheson had commented back in 1962, Britain had indeed lost an empire yet failed to find a post-imperial role. 
 The  years of decline had not really been reversed. 
 In 1989 the agreement concluded some years earlier with the Chinese government for the peaceful winding-up of the 1 50-year lease on Hong Kong suddenly seemed hard to defend. 
 It was clear that the free-enterprise (indeed, Thatcherite) peoples of Hong Kong were likely to be swallowed up in a huge Marxist empire of uncertain direction. 
 But there was nothing Britain could do. 
 It could expect to defeat a lesser power like Argentina, but taking on Communist China was unthinkable. 
 With the British government unable to contemplate much immigration of Hong Kong holders of British passports to these shores either, the posture struck was a weak one. 
 Abroad, therefore, as at home, the future of &bquo;Thatcherism&equo; looked in some doubt, and the vision of &bquo;the strong state&equo;, based on free enterprise and nuclear defence, that much feebler. 
 The replacement of Geoffrey Howe by the little-known John Major at the Foreign Office in July 1989 added to the uncertainty, as did Major's replacement by Douglas Hurd three months later. 
 Much of the electoral strength of the Thatcher government was based on the claim that &bquo;there was no alternative&equo;. 
 In the summer and autumn of 1989 it seemed possible that this might no longer be true. 
 The threat from the Alliance had evaporated since the division of the Social Democrats in 1987. 
 Two of its five MPs (the Scots, Kennedy and Maclennan) joined the Liberals in the newly named Social and Liberal Democrats, while the other three, headed by Dr David Owen, remained independent. 
 By the time of local elections, it was apparent the SDP of &bquo;claret and chips&equo; mould-breaking fame at the time of the Limehouse Declaration in 1981 was disintegrating. 
 It still had some major figures but no broad base. 
 Three of the &bquo;Gang of Four&equo; (Jenkins, Rodgers, and Mrs Williams) had left front-line politics. 
 The Democrats had yet to attain anything like the rooted strength of the old Liberal Party. 
 In the Euro-elections of June 1989 they polled disastrously, and actually did much worse than the new and untried Green Party concerned with environmental issues. 
 The Democrats now seemed in much disarray, and presented a dismal prospect for their new leader, Paddy Ashdown, who had succeeded David Steel. 
 The centre ground of British politics remained the same uncertain terrain it had been ever since 1918. 
 One major Democrat theorist, David Marquand, a former Labour MP, wrote an  important book, The Unprincipled Society  in 1987. 
 In this he argued powerfully for a revival of social citizenship and the &bquo;developmental state&equo;. 
 With the Tories moving on to more radical positions, and the Labour Party now much more centrist, logic seemed to dictate that this kind of Alliance supporter should move back to a Social Democratic outlook identical with that of old Gaitskellites. 
 Much of the intellectual &eacute;lan  of the Alliance moved with him. 
 One sign of the times was that Lord Young of Dartington, a founder member of the SDP in 1981, moved back to rejoin the Labour Party. 
 He had been the head of Labour's Research Department at the time of the 1945 election. 
 His odyssey thus brought the history of an important part of the British intellectual left full circle. 
 The mould thus stubbornly remained unbroken. 
 The real and only alternative to Thatcherism, at least for the foreseeable future, was a return of the old two-party system, with Labour moving back towards credibility. 
 Neil Kinnock had by now established his leadership strongly in the party. 
 He dominated the National Executive with his &bquo;soft left&equo; allies. 
 In 1988 he crushed a vain attempt to challenge his leadership by the veteran Tony Benn, with an 8 to 1 majority, while Roy Hattersley comfortably held on to the deputy leadership. 
 In the 1989 party conference, Ken Livingstone was thrown off the NEC. 
 There were many signs of the so-called &bquo;new realism&equo; now. 
 Labour's economic programme accepted the thrust of the market in allocating social goods and advocated an obviously mixed approach towards economic planning in place of the stereotyped nationalization of 1983. 
 On Europe, as has been seen, Labour was by 1989 much more committed to developments within the Community. 
 Jacques Delors actually was warmly received at the Trades Union Congress as &bquo;fr&egrave;re Jacques&equo;. 
 Labour also moved towards more concern for the consumer, towards an acceptance of the need for legal curbs on the power of the unions, and the party's need to confirm itself as the defence of the law and order sought by working-class citizens. 
 After all, it was they who tended to be the main victims of burglary, assault, and other forms of violent crime. 
 Roy Hattersley's testament, Choose Freedom  (1987), emphasized Labour's commitment to equality as the  guarantee of pluralism, tolerance, and personal freedom. 
 Above all, over a unilateral nuclear policy, a stance previously adopted with fervour by Kinnock and Michael Foot before him, it was now accepted that this was a programme unpopular with the mass of the British people, and actually rejected by the glasnost  of President Gorbachev as well. 
 Labour's foreign-affairs spokesman, Gerald Kaufman, was anything but a unilateralist. 
 In 1989, therefore, Neil Kinnock made it explicit that he was rejecting the unilateralist approach of his youth. 
 Labour, in effect, was reverting to Gaitskell's (and Bevan's) stance of 1959 and going multilateralist once again. 
 On this basis Polaris, and even Trident, could be retained as at least a bargaining counter. 
 Unilateralism was formally renounced at the party conference in October 1989. 
 There were real signs that Labour's new strength, confirmed by a growing lead in the polls, was more solidly based now. 
 The unions, so dormant in the 1980s, were now more positive in their approach, through leaders such as Gavin Laird (Engineers), Tom Sawyer (NUPE), and John Edmunds (Municipal Workers), representatives of the older craft industries and some of the newer high-tech, white-collar workers, too. 
 There were signs that the onward march on which Labour prided itself would be replaced by something differently constituted but no less rooted in British society. 
 In the autumn of 1989, therefore, the evidence for a permanent revolution in British public and private attitudes as a result of ten years of Mrs Thatcher's rule was far from conclusive. 
 The comparatively muted way in which the Thatcher decade was celebrated in May 1989 suggested some hesitancy amongst the Conservatives themselves. 
 Over ten years the market philosophy had undoubtedly penetrated the social services, education, the professions, and a whole range of public institutions. 
 Changes such as extensions of working-class home- and share-ownership had been accepted as part of the norms of British life. 
 Much of Britain in the Midlands and the south relished the new prosperity the Thatcher years had brought. 
 The glossy shops and building societies of towns like Swindon and Basingstoke, the proliferation of &bquo;leisure centres&equo; and recreational amenities in much of the south, appeared to be firm signs of the enjoyment of the good life. 
 The reaction against &bquo;society&equo; voiced by the Prime Minister herself was also in evidence, from the disappearance of a  once influential weekly like New Society  to the criticism of social workers resulting from the 1987 Cleveland cases of alleged child sexual abuse. 
 On the other hand, the despair and decay of much of the northeast or Merseyside had left their mark, too. 
 In Scotland, especially, the rejection of the Conservative Party and the Thatcherite ethic was almost total. 
 In the Euro-elections of June 1989 the Tories were wiped out north of the border. 
 The revival of the campaign for Scottish devolution &mdash; indeed, for Scottish nationalism, as shown in Jim Sillars' by-election victory in Govan &mdash; was a notable feature of the later phase of Mrs Thatcher's regime. 
 Here and elsewhere, the government strove to identify itself with new themes. 
 In particular, the &bquo;green&equo; argument advanced by environmentalists, fanned by the importance of themes such as land conservation, acid rain, and the protection of the ozone layer and &bquo;the greenhouse effect&equo; in the 1989 Euro-elections, suggested that the message of Thatcherite consumption and wealth creation failed to mesh with wider concerns for the quality of life. 
 The rise of &bquo;green&equo; issues, indeed, was more naturally appealing to Labour or Alliance politicians, and a powerful reminder of the rich variety of resistance to Thatcherism that British society could release. 
 It led to Nicholas Ridley's removal from the Environment department in July 1989, in favour of the notoriously &bquo;wet&equo; Chris Patten. 
 The government was not omnipotent after all. 
 A surrender to the farmers over the egg controversy, hesitancy in confronting the brewers, and some retreat in the face of the judges' opposition to legal reform indicated that there were lobbies and vested interests which even the all-conquering Prime Minister could not challenge with impunity. 
 In the summer and autumn of 1989, Labour led strongly in the opinion polls again. 
 By-election victories for them in the Vale of Glamorgan, Glasgow Central, and Vauxhall confirmed the trend, with black pressure from an ethnic candidate in the last-named constituency failing totally. 
 The European elections saw Labour capture forty-five seats to the Conservatives' thirty-two, the first major defeat for Mrs Thatcher in ten years of premiership. 
 The Democrats, significantly, finished well behind even the Greens and won no seats at all. 
 There appeared to be some similarity with the decline of Macmillan's regime in the early sixties &mdash; Cabinet reshuffles; acute balance of payments' difficulties, a shaky pound, and high interest rates; a renewal of strikes on the railways, the docks, and in  local government services; a somewhat disaffected public apprehensive at Britain's declining power in the world. 
 The truth or otherwise of this diagnosis would be revealed in the future. 
 The electoral and sociological omens favoured the Conservatives still, with their entrenched position in the prosperous and populous southern half of Britain. 
 It seemed unlikely, however, that a more abrasive or divisive programme would be the way for them to recover their position. 
 The enduring strength of post-war social and economic policy, for all its frequent and perceived failures, still commanded enough allegiance for the Conservatives to fight it with only danger to themselves. 
 A series of appalling disasters in the public services, notably the Kings Cross underground fire and the rail crashes at Clapham and elsewhere underlined the damage that could result from the public sector being run down. 
 As the Conservatives themselves hesitantly took up the theme of citizenship in response to opposition challenge, it was argued that only a more flexible, compassionate style of Toryism could be their route to safety. 
 Mrs Thatcher herself remained an imperious figure, respected, perhaps feared, but rarely viewed with affection. 
 In December 1 989 an obscure Welsh member actually challenged her as party leader, gaining 33 votes. 
 For all her professed populism, she was seen as remote from ordinary people, hardly ever catching a train, watching a film, or relaxing in a British holiday resort, turning instinctively to privileged private treatment in educating her children or adopting health-care systems for herself. 
 She was unduly prone to use of the royal &bquo;we&equo;. 
 As a phenomenon, the most triumphant premier since Lord Liverpool in 1812&ndash;27, she was unique. 
 But the essence of the nation, its temper, its geology flowed on beneath her. 
 The basic logic of her programme since 1979 had been to reverse the main lines of her country's history as it had developed since the Second World War. 
 Through ceaseless activity and a triumph of will-power, she had by 1987 come as near to success as was possible for one, self-sufficient human being. 
 The nation had formally rejected neither her nor her policies by the end of 1989. 
 But, below the surface, it may have been defeating her, just the same.  
 Conclusion 
 IN assessing the course of recent British history, the historian encounters a clear gulf between the perceptions of public commentators and the responses of ordinary people. 
 Commentaries written in the 1970s and 1980s on the British experience since 1945 were full of clich&eacute;-ridden observations on the decline of an ailing titan, and a fall from imperial and industrial greatness. 
 Any alternative view, it seemed, would imply a fatal lapse into Whiggism and a naive belief in progress. 
 The successive supplements of the Dictionary of National Biography  down to 1971&ndash;80, in their way, provided a development of this theme, as they recorded the past achievements of a Churchill, a Bevin, a Montgomery, a Shaw, a Russell, a Rutherford, all that race of former giants who had once trodden England's green and pleasant land. 
 In all areas of British society, it seemed, from science to sport, the quality of leadership and performance was steadily diminishing. 
 Not only were there no great causes left, as Look Back in Anger  would have it. 
 There were no great men or women either, as Britain settled down resignedly into the second or even third-class status enjoyed by Venice, Spain, Sweden, Holland, and other failed empire-builders of the past. 
 The anxiety that this process of eclipse produced, however, was strangely removed from day-to-day experience. 
 All the findings of opinion polls and other surveys suggested that the overwhelming majority of ordinary citizens were convinced that the period of their nation's history through which they had lived in the forty-odd years since the end of the war in 1945, was a time of comfort and content. 
 It was after all, a time of peace. 
 The last of the great classic European wars ended in 1945, and by 1989 seemed most unlikely  to be succeeded by another. 
 There had been several local, peripheral wars in which Britain had been engaged, notably that in Korea in 1950&ndash;3, and a long series of conflicts to resolve colonial problems &mdash; Malaya in the late 1940s, Kenya and Cyprus in the 1950s, Suez (most traumatically) in 1956, Aden and Southern Arabia in the sixties. 
 By 1970, with the passing of the old empire, these were all over, and only the totally unexpected war with Argentina over the Falklands in 1982 interrupted what was one of the longest periods of unbroken peace that Britain had known since the later middle ages. 
 While British defence expenditure was consistently high by comparative international standards, and while many idealists agonized over Britain's possession of nuclear weapons, the vast bulk of British citizens, outside Northern Ireland, neither experienced military conflict nor ever expected to do so. 
 Montgomery (a very outdated figure at the time of his death in 1976) had been Britain's last military hero, and he seemed as remote as Wellington or Marlborough. 
 Peace abroad was accompanied by peace at home. 
 While there were periods of internal stress, notably the emergence of the various racial, Irish, and student troubles of the late sixties, and the concern over the alleged &bquo;ungovernability&equo; of the unions at the time of the &bquo;winter of discontent&equo; in the late seventies, Britain was a relatively stable society internally throughout these forty-four years. 
 Compared with the regional and social tensions that disrupted so many European countries from Portugal to Greece, compared even with the events in France in 1958 and 1968, British institutions and social cohesion stood firm. 
 Allegations by American commentators that the land was &bquo;as ungovernable as Chile&equo; seemed to be wild exaggerations. 
 Rumours of putsches , paramilitary fantasies by Colonel Stirling, destabilizing activities by MI5, the theatricalities of the National Front &mdash; all these seemed relatively insubstantial, even a joke. 
 The great exception, of course, was Northern Ireland. 
 A comparatively tranquil province until 1968, the liberal attempt to reform the inbred Protestant ascendancy and extend civil rights to the exploited Catholic minority led to a revival of the unbridgeable schisms and endemic violence in Ulster. 
 No governmental initiative, from Heath's abolition of Stormont in 1972 to Mrs Thatcher's Anglo-Irish agreement of 1985, appeared likely to resolve it. 
 But as always, Ireland was a land apart. 
 For the remainder of the United Kingdom, this was a time when social or political upheaval seemed comparatively remote, and society appeared relatively orderly.  
 It was also, for most ordinary citizens, a time of prosperity. 
 After the travails of austerity in the late 1940s &mdash; when, in fact, Cripps and his associates were laying the base for a new export-led recovery &mdash; the land entered new affluence in the 1950s. 
 National income doubled between 1948 and 1976. 
 The average citizen's standard of living rose accordingly, as income and social expectations mounted steadily. 
 In the 1950s, the purchase of a car, along with electrical consumer durables, became the aspiration of most citizens, along with holidays overseas. 
 Take-home pay rose persistently during the inflation of the 1960s and early 1970s. 
 By the late 1970s, the average self-respecting British household expected to have its video recorder or microwave oven; in a variety of occupations the computer was taking over. 
 Twenty million people took overseas holidays in 1986, many in the Americas. 
 By the eighties, affluence was expressed, to a growing degree, in the purchase of a second home, often by city-dwellers whose alternative residence hastened the endemic decay of village life &mdash; or open political hostility in Wales where a campaign of house incendiarism by some cultural nationalists, the &bquo;Sons of Glyn D&wcirc;r&equo;, punctuated the otherwise peaceful history of the principality from the 1960s to the 1980s. 
 Two features were especially notable. 
 One was the growth of house purchase. 
 It spread rapidly first in the 1950s as the private-house market was decontrolled and building societies vastly extended their operations. 
 By 1961 there were 7 million homes owned by their occupiers; by 1987 the total was 14.5 million, as against about 6 million rented from local authorities, and under 3 million privately rented. 
 By 1990, over two-thirds of the occupiers of all dwellings in the British Isles would own them. 
 There were also many more shareholders, though this was a much more recent development stemming largely from the privatization policy conducted by the Thatcher government after 1983. 
 Over a fifth of the adult population owned shares in late 1988, contrasted with only 6 per cent in early 1984. 
 It appeared that prosperity was being spread around according to classic distributist models, and that the Conservative aspiration of a &bquo;property-owning democracy&equo; had largely come about since 1945. 
 And yet, this relatively peaceful country, moving out of the stagnation of the 1930s to the growing affluence of post-1945, was  seldom contented or placid for long throughout these forty-four years. 
 On the contrary, for all the general flow of tranquillity and prosperity, a number of specific themes consistently emerged which made this a time of anxiety, even torment. 
 Surveys of opinion invariably revealed that, while attachment to Britain remained strong, patriotic emotions still flourished, and very few people ever wished to live anywhere but in Britain, estimates of national progress and decline were progressively more gloomy. 
 Most British people believed that, whatever their own prosperity, the fortunes of their country were bad and getting worse. 
 First of all, the economy was seldom under effective control at any time after 1945. 
 Of all the Chancellors of the period, only Cripps, Butler, Jenkins, and (briefly) Lawson seemed to have matters under secure direction. 
 In the immediate post-war period down to the mid-1950s there were endless external difficulties as the economy tried to recover from the strains of the war; balance-of-payments crises of a severe kind in 1949, 1951, and 1955, often accompanied by pressure on sterling, were endemic. 
 In the early 1960s, a more long-term series of pressures, associated with comparative and well-publicized industrial decline, took root, with a new sense that the economy had not really regained its balance. 
 The attempts to enter &bquo;Europe&equo; in 1961, 1967, and finally in 1973 were always accompanied by a sense of economic weakness and the perils of isolation. 
 The Wilson years of 1964&ndash;70 saw the trauma of the monetary crisis of 1966 and the devaluation of 1967, with the nation &bquo;blown off course&equo; in a mood of some panic. 
 In the 1970s &bquo;stagflation&equo; set in apace, as external forces such as the 1973 oil-price explosion was accompanied by intense inflationary pressures at home, many of them associated with the rise of trade-union power. 
 The Thatcher government, after a period of rapid decline in manufacturing and a sharp rise in unemployment, which reached 3.2 million by mid-1982, appeared to have conquered many of the major difficulties in the mid-1980s, and there was talk of a &bquo;British miracle&equo; comparable to those of Germany and Japan. 
 But by the end of the 1980s record balance-of-payments deficits, rising inflation, a weakened pound, and failure to impose the monetary disciplines on which the government had prided itself, suggested that most of the old problems were still present. 
 Only the fortunate existence of North Sea oil, as a boost to exports, appeared to have mitigated their effects. 
 Naturally, like all developed countries, Britain showed a rise in  economic growth from the 1950s to the 1980s, but it was usually patchy and sluggish by international standards. 
 The reason for the failures of the British economy led to a wide variety of diagnoses by economists, sociologists, and other soothsayers. 
 The failures of British industrial relations usually loomed large, with some blaming backwards-looking trade unions defending antique work practices, and more finding consistent weaknesses in British management in both the private and public sector once the immediate post-1945 boom had spent itself. 
 Others looked back further in time, perhaps to the late-Victorian era, with the long-term failure to invest, to engage in industrial or technical training, to develop new industries, or perhaps to create an industrial or business-minded culture at all. 
 It was noted that the apparent recovery of 1983&ndash;7 rested heavily on finance, banking, and credit, rather than on a genuine revival of industry or manufacturing. 
 The share of manufacturing in British GDP fell from 25.4 per cent in 1979 to 19.5 per cent in 1986. 
 Many people anticipated the coming of the European single market in 1992 with apprehension. 
 One way and another, the problems of the British economy, with unpleasant side-effects for individuals such as the &bquo;austerity&equo; of 1948&ndash;9, the &bquo;pay pause&equo; of 1961, the deflation after the 1976 IMF crisis, or the rise in personal indebtedness after 1986, were a persistently gloomy theme after 1945. 
 So, perhaps less visibly, was a decline in the confidence, perhaps the very legitimacy, of the state and its instruments. 
 In 1945 there was immense confidence in the civic and administrative institutions of government. 
 The gentleman from Whitehall not only knew best; he was the unacknowledged legislator of the world, who had (indirectly at least) won the war. 
 Abroad, he had his counterpart in trained imperial administrators from India to Jamaica. 
 The Attlee government in some ways is a final commentary on the deep-rooted strength of this faith in the institutions of the state. 
 The partial reaction against it in the Tory 1950s &mdash; &bquo;setting the people free&equo; &mdash; did not lead to the contraction of the government service. 
 On the contrary, as Professor Northcote Parkinson noted at the time, the civil service expanded as never before, locally as well as nationally, and the prominent place of central-government expenditure (consistently over 40 per cent as a proportion of gross national product  in this period) is an outstanding feature of the period 1951&ndash;64. 
 By the time of the Wilson government in 1964, it was clear that the old confidence in governmental planning was, for a variety of reasons, in some disarray. 
 In part, it was part of a wider decline in the authority of national institutions from the monarchy to the police; satire and culture criticism reflected the process and took it further. 
 But it was also clear that the governmental machine had failed to revive the economy or reform social institutions in the 1950s. 
 Its Keynesian ethos was running out of steam. 
 The feebleness of the Wilson government's attempts to deal with national economic growth or industrial relations in the 1960s discredited the ideals of the planner and central state still further. 
 The National Plan and In Place of Strife  both led to nothing. 
 So did efforts at civil service reform. 
 Meanwhile, the average wage-earner noted that, whereas in 1960 tax and insurance took 8 per cent of his or her earnings, in 1970 they took nearly 20 per cent. 
 In 1950 the average wage-earner had paid no income tax at all. 
 Heath's revived corporatism in the early 1970s crumpled with the miners' strikes and the OPEC price explosion, while the Labour government of the late 1970s was able only to breathe intermittent life into a system of corporate direction which powerful producer-groups and multinational companies in the so-called &bquo;meso-economy&equo; were both undermining. 
 A major prop for the Thatcher government in the 1980s was a strong reaction against central government, the world of the quangos and over-mighty metropolitan authorities &mdash; although, ironically, that administration was also to take centralization still further, especially in its crusade against local government and the vested interests of the professions. 
 If there is one supreme casualty in British public life between 1945 and 1989 it is the ethos of planning. 
 Its advocates, from Gaitskell in 1955 to the SDP in 1981, all fell by the wayside. 
 Planning had failed; perhaps, compared with the French Monnet Plan or the &bquo;reform bureaucracy&equo; of Scandinavia, it had not even been tried. 
 Of course, these developments were part of a wider process common to many countries. 
 The European world in general saw a flurry of enthusiasm for planned reconstruction in 1945. 
 Equally, it went through many of the same traumas as Britain in the 1960s and 1970s while the Thatcher crusade for the market-led economy  found an echo not only in Reagan's America, but in France, Australia, Spain, and even social-democratic Sweden. 
 Even the moderate left had become devotees of the enterprise culture and the regime of the market, albeit a &bquo;social market&equo;. 
 But in Britain, with its strong governmental impulse as created in the Victorian period in the aftermath of the 1855 Northcote-Trevelyan report, with the British faith in the educated, patrician &bquo;expert&equo; which kindled the support of American progressives and &bquo;genteel reformers&equo; in the previous century, the decline of planning and the loss of confidence in the effectiveness of social engineering had a deep cultural impact. 
 It had a special message for the Labour Party, and was surely a major reason for Labour's growing loss of confidence between the 1950s and 1980s, including the failure to produce any convincing successor to Crosland as a theorist of democratic socialism. 
 It was ironic that 1989 saw the centenary celebration of the Fabian Essays  of Webb, Shaw, and their comrades; this came at a time when Britain seemed in more complete reaction against the imperatives of Fabian rationalism than at any time for a century. 
 Intellectually, too, one notable feature was the steady demise of British Marxism as an influential body of ideas and doctrine. 
 By 1989 there were very few significant Marxist philosophers, critics, or film directors in Britain. 
 There were still celebrated Marxist historians, such as E. P. Thompson, Eric Hobsbawm, Christopher Hill, and John Saville, but they were all at the veteran stage, and there appeared to be no significant youthful successors, as their creed withered throughout eastern Europe. 
 Another gloomy feature of post-war Britain was the prevalence of endemic social inequality. 
 Britain was and remained a notably unequal country in terms of income, capital, and social opportunity throughout this period. 
 Even more did this apply to economic power &mdash; witness the failure of repeated attempts to build up copartnership or anything resembling profit-sharing in industry. 
 Britain was divided (very approximately) between a thriving high-tech &bquo;south&equo; and an ageing industrial &bquo;north&equo;, between Celtic fringe and southern English heartland, employed and unemployed, waged and salaried employees, average earners and low-paid, in a rigid, predetermined pattern almost without parallel in the industrial world. 
 On these rooted distinctions of wealth and social class (masked by  the apparent growing classlessness of dress and speech, especially among the young) were superimposed other, more specific inequalities. 
 The limited opportunities in terms of employment, housing, or social mobility for Britain's urban black community, following the Commonwealth immigration of the 1950s, was one unresolved feature of the period. 
 Another was the comparative economic weakness of the Celtic nations, especially felt with passion in Scotland where a continuous nationalist upsurge from the mid-1960s threatened a major disruption of the United Kingdom. 
 Divisions of colour and region/ nation were accompanied by those of gender. 
 The feminist movement of the 1970s highlighted the restricted opportunities and expectations for women, especially for mothers. 
 Some headway was made as a result. 
 But, by the end of the 1980s, while a larger and larger proportion of the female population was in employment, it was seldom employment at a level of high command, and often not of a permanent kind. 
 In 1987, 3,430,000 part-time women workers fell below the Council of Europe's &bquo;decency threshold&equo; for pay. 
 Under a female Prime Minister in 1989, Britain was still very much a man's world. 
 Incidentally, the divorce rate, at 12.9 per cent per 1,000 existing marriages in 1986, was the highest in the EEC. 
 Decrees granted for divorce, which had stood at only 27,000 in 1961, and 80,000 in 1971, reached 175,000 in the mid-1980s, from which women suffered most. 
 These various divisions were superimposed on a deeply rooted inequality between different groups and occupations which modified other apparent signs of social progress. 
 Thus, the great advance in literacy over the period and the expansion of the young population. 
 receiving secondary education was checked by the presence of a divisive system of private education with few parallels in other countries. 
 Indeed, the proportion of children attending &bquo;public&equo; (ie. private) schools rose throughout the eighties. 
 The great gains in public health, following the establishment of the National Health Service in 1948, was modified by, among other factors, the existence of class attitudes towards health which meant, for instance, that older working-class communities in the industrial north were still marred by the health problems of a poor diet, excessive beer drinking and smoking, and a prevalence of heart and lung disease in consequence. 
 The passion for &bquo;health&equo; foods and mineral water, and exercises such as &bquo;jogging&equo; and aerobics, were largely middle-class enthusiasms. 
 The Second World War, apparently a halcyon era for popular  unity and &bquo;pulling through together&equo; was, as noted, a time of social division, which wartime experiences such as evacuation or the pattern of female employment intensified. 
 This continued to plague Britain as a society after 1945. 
 In the 1980s, under the Thatcher regime, most of the indices of social equality seemed to show that things were not improving. 
 The redistribution of wealth, erratically pursued by successive governments since 1945, was markedly reversed in the 1980s. 
 Especially did this structural inequality apply to older working-class people, by now a huge under-class. 
 As a growing proportion of an ageing population lived on into their eighties or even nineties, the disparity between their life chances and those of the able-bodied employed became more and more apparent. 
 The overhaul of superannuation policy in the late 1960s never really happened. 
 For decades, as the Royal Commission on Wealth and Income demonstrated in the late 1970s, those disparities were modified by the social benefits available under the welfare state. 
 By the end of the 1980s, partly as a result of deliberate government action, more perhaps because the unduly optimistic assumptions of Beveridge and other founders of the British welfare system were being falsified by financial and cultural factors (such as the breakdown of the old nuclear family of fabled tradition), the welfare state was far less able to temper the asperities of a harsh and divided society. 
 The beleaguered ranks of social workers and investigators of the 1980s documented a society more unsettled, more helpless, and to some degree more violent than at any period since the century began. 
 Finally, there was constant angst  about Britain's world role. 
 The direction of Britain's post-imperial policy was unclear after 1945. 
 There was a general belief that the nation should remain &bquo;strong&equo; and have that strength publicly acknowledged &mdash; hence the relative failure of CND and other anti-nuclear groups. 
 Not until the early sixties did it seem to be generally acknowledged that Britain was no longer a great power as previously understood. 
 Until then, its leaders continued to reflect the ascendancy they enjoyed at the time of the 1945 Potsdam conference. 
 In the Middle East especially, British power was still a decisive factor down to 1956, however illusory its basis. 
 But in which direction its strength and influence should be pointed thereafter, once the Suez crisis and subsequent Bermuda Conference of 1956&ndash;7 showed up Britain's basic weakness in the Atlantic relationship, was not apparent. 
 Only during the 1960s did it become generally appreciated that the cosy &bquo;special relationship&equo;  of the war years and of the period of Oliver Franks's distinguished tenure at the Washington embassy in 1948&ndash;52 had changed, and to Britain's disadvantage. 
 In response, Britain made a series of halfhearted, and finally somewhat desperate, attempts to become &bquo;European&equo; instead. 
 In the end, Britain entered the Common Market in 1975, but with weary reluctance. 
 Even at the end of the 1980s, while the British left was now largely reconciled to membership of Community, the British remained hesitant Europeans. 
 Mrs Thatcher was far from alone in condemning any thought of a &bquo;United States of Europe&equo; in her Bruges speech. 
 Britain's role in the world, which had generated a series of transient late-imperial crises between 1956 to 1982, remained decidedly obscure, as Dean Acheson, Nicholas Henderson, and others had long forecast. 
 On the other hand, there was much to be commended in the way Britain relinquished the reins of empire. 
 Beginning with the transfer of power in India and Pakistan in 1947, through the retreat from Egypt, and the rapid withdrawal from Africa in the Macleod period in the late 1950s and early 1960s, the rapidity and lack of tension with which Britain shed her imperial domain is perhaps the most notable of tributes to national stability and, possibly, maturity in the post-war world. 
 There were few outcries by settlers, as in France with regard to Indo-China and Algeria, no crisis comparable with the chaotic fate of the former Belgian Congo, no agony approaching that of the United States over Vietnam. 
 The curtain went down in dignity and tranquillity. 
 The Commonwealth remained in large measure a ceremonial affair after 1960, with a role for the Queen as figurehead, with cricket matches and Rhodes scholarships to preserve links with the older dominions, and little effectual attempt to exert collective pressure on the apartheid policy within South Africa. 
 After Britain's entry into the Common Market in 1975, trading links with the Commonwealth countries loomed much less large, as did defence considerations after the Wilson government withdrew Britain's presence from &bquo;east of Suez&equo; in 1968&ndash;70. 
 Yet all this led to comparatively little public outcry. 
 Kipling and Elgar need never have been. 
 Old-fashioned advocates of a cohesive empire like Beaverbrook's Daily Express  seemed purely eccentric. 
 Equally, Enoch Powell's speeches in the 1960s which might have been designed to stir up racial animosity between the various Commonwealth communities, had only a limited impact, with Powell himself becoming politically marginalized. 
 Compared with its problems at home, Britain shed her  imperial role between 1947 and 1970 (Rhodesia excepted) with much skill and humanity. 
 It was decolonization without traumas and without tears. 
 Throughout these forty years, the British increasingly believed that they were badly led. 
 Public figures suffered a collective loss of esteem. 
 Prime Ministers from Eden to Wilson left office with their prestige lower than when they had entered Downing Street. 
 On Mrs Thatcher, the jury was still out in 1989. 
 The old enthusiasm for governments and the governing classes &mdash; anatomized with much effect by Anthony Sampson and others in the early 1960s &mdash; evaporated into a more cynical disillusion. 
 Certainly, the components of Britain's &eacute;lite of leadership changed considerably in this period. 
 The patrician planners of the late 1940s were in some retreat a decade later. 
 The Tory paternalists of the 1950s seemed dated by the time of the Heath government in 1970&ndash;4. 
 The corporate ascendancy of the trade unions and employers' groups, with their many offshoots in the world of the quangos, was dismantled after the 1970s. 
 This was partly through economic failure, partly because of structural changes like the growth of plant bargaining as opposed to national agreements, and the extreme difficulty industrial and administrative bodies had in imposing settlements on local wage conventions and work practices. 
 In the Thatcher era, the nation's leaders seemed now to reflect the &bquo;enterprise&equo; outlook of finance, banking, and credit rather than that of traditional manufacturing or other industries. 
 Both the TUC and CBI went into decline. 
 The old planners, with their Keynesian nostrums, were isolated. 
 The universities were in visible retreat. 
 Intellectuals were dismissed as uncreative and unproductive. 
 University students, once anxious to become civil servants or perhaps teachers, now became stockbrokers or market researchers as the public service lost its charms. 
 An older regime, based variously on deference, status, and structure, had been dismantled, but with no obvious replacement in view. 
 In the Attlee era, the British people knew by whom they were led. 
 The direct chain of command, in central and local government alike, related both to recollections of wartime victory and older notions of authority embodied in the public-school, cricket-loving Edwardian philanthropist who occupied 10 Downing Street. 
 Churchill, in a very different, romantic fashion, appealed to some of the same values, with free use (and abuse) of history in the process. 
 By the 1960s, partly through its own inner uncertainties and weakness, partly  through a torrent of satire and journalistic exposure, the stable base of British public leadership, the pivot of civic culture for generations, was being undermined in government, industry, religion, neighbourhood, and family life. 
 In the later phase of Mrs Thatcher's government, Britain was in danger of being rudderless as nothing very obvious came to succeed this older source of authority. 
 At the dawn of the 1990s, with the European single market looming ever closer, most British people still seemed to feel content with their identity. 
 They were still proud to be British with powerful national variants in Wales, Scotland, and especially Northern Ireland. 
 But the nature of that identity, the ultimate sources of British national awareness, remained obscure. 
 In part, the sense of Britishness seemed to rest on an often sentimental obeisance to the past, as shown in the flourishing &bquo;heritage&equo; industry of the eighties extending from Chaucer to Churchill, to the delight of tourists and the scorn of social critics. 
 In its fashion, the Labour Party also subscribed to this nostalgia, albeit directed towards Labour's alternative &bquo;people's history&equo;. 
 But the main institutions which the British had adapted in keeping their nation together &mdash; the Crown, Parliament, the forces of law and order, civil and commercial institutions &mdash; had all in different ways turned sour with the progressive disillusion of the years after 1945. 
 More than most Europeans, the British were still a lively, distinctive people at the end of the twentieth century &mdash; and not only for geographical reasons. 
 They had survived the trials of imperial retreat, economic decline, and industrial conflict, and remained cohesive and intact. 
 British &bquo;exceptionalism&equo;, like American, was still a major force in the world. 
 The British still believed themselves to retain &bquo;shared values&equo; which the debate over a national educational curriculum in the 1980s helped stimulate anew, as it had done in the French Third Republic after 1875. 
 But British particularism too often meant an unwillingness to experiment and a yearning for a quiet life. 
 There remained an inherent lack of energy, initiative, and perhaps ambition, a kind of public exhaustion. 
 Legends of the nation &bquo;standing alone&equo; in 1940 had been damaging and illusory, contributions to &bquo;the glamour of backwardness&equo;. 
 In forty-four years the British had yet to recover fully from victory in the Second World War, even though the Germans and Japanese had so manifestly recovered from defeat. 
 It is rash indeed for the historian to turn prophet. 
 But the record since 1945 suggests that it is highly improbable that the British people will play anything like  the major role in the affairs of mankind in the twenty-first century that they have done so frequently, if often unavailingly, in the course of the twentieth.  
 The Royal Air Forces Association For year ended 31st December, 1990 
 Annual Report &amp; Accounts 
  The Royal Air Forces Association 
 Annual Report &amp; Accounts 1990 
 Foreword 
 by the Chairman of the Central Council Air Vice-Marshal D G Bailey CB CBE 
 It was fitting, in the 50th anniversary year of the Battle of Britain, that the Association should have engaged in a full range of activities aimed at meeting its responsibilities towards former members of the Royal Air Force, both men and women. 
 The Association's main activities continued to be welfare, housing and fund-raising to enable us to provide the facilities, the support and the companionship that a caring membership has always regarded as of paramount importance. 
 These areas of activity are dealt with in detail elsewhere in this report but I am very pleased in this foreword to highlight a most successful year of achievement &mdash; a year which owed so much to the inspiration given to use all by those who saved the Nation in 1940. 
 One highlight of the year was the major extension to Sussexdown in the form of a new Therapy Wing. 
 This offers physiotherapy and occupational therapy facilities to all residents and also provides a beautiful sun lounge with views of the South Downs. 
 A legacy from Flying Officer D J L Andrews, who had been a Flight Engineer on Stirling and Lancaster aircraft and who remembered Sussexdown in his will, provided a major source of funds for the project. 
 Many others also contributed towards the costs including Royal Air Force Stations, charitable trust, Association Branches and individual donors. 
 We are grateful for all these contributions which have substantially enhanced the quality of life of the residents at Sussexdown.  
 A futher highlight was the opening of the first Eagle Lodges: Wexford House near Melton Mowbray and Woodford in Southport. 
 These shared residential houses for single elderly persons provide an important new welfare resource for the Association at a time when increasing numbers of those who served in World War II, and their dependents, are reaching an age when they need the support of a housekeeper. 
 A third Eagle Lodge, at Bexhill-on-Sea, was under development during the year and will be ready for occupation in early 1991. 
 The Association began the year wondering how the Royal Air Force Benevolent Funds's &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal could best be supported. 
 The Association was also concerned that its income from various sources, but in particular from Wings Appeal, should be maintained in a year when the public might feel confusion over the two appeals. 
 It is, therefore with considerable pleasure that I can report that the Association was able during 1990 to contribute directly more than &pound;250,000 to the &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal, and was able to see the income generated by its own Wings Appeal increase by 47%. 
 Clearly much of the credit for this is due to a very generous and grateful public. 
 Another factor contributing to the success of the two Appeals was the Battle of Britain Parade and Flypast on 15 September. 
 This national event aroused such emotions and nostalgia that people everywhere responded with magnificent donations. 
 We also acknowledge the tremendous response from our members and our Branches, for without their enthusiasm and organisation we could not have made this 50th anniversary such a financial success. 
 We are very pleased to be able to point to increased co-operation and liaison with other Service charities. 
 Apart from working closely with the Benevolent Fund, The Association is contributing to the work of The Council of British Service and Ex-Service Organisations. 
 Already we are providing, through the Association's War Pensions Officer and Area Welfare Officers, support to our sister charities, and in turn we have benefited from co-operation in the design of training courses. 
 We have made a sound start in 1990 to achieving the degree of co-operation and mutual aid that we know the Government and Public expect to see more in evidence throughout this decade. 
 As the year ended the events in the Gulf reminded us sharply that we cannot take peach and freedom for granted, and that substantial risks continue to be faced by those serving in the Royal Air Force. 
 In turn these may lead to welfare needs extending well beyond the year 2000. 
 It is for the Association to continue to build a sound foundation of welfare facilities and support that will enable both today's and the future's needs to be met &mdash; in meeting this objective we are deeply indebted to the continuing dedication of our members and the support of our many friends. 
 My grateful thanks go to them all. 
  D G Bailey   
 Welfare 
 The 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain provided an opportunity to pay a tribute to &bquo;The Few&equo; who flew in the Battle and the many who supported them. 
 The Anniversary also served as a reminder of the sacrifices made during the wartime years by those who gave unstintingly to preserve the freedom we now enjoy. 
 Proudly and thankfully the Association will remember them. 
 Even more importantly the Association will do this in the most practical way possible &mdash; by helping those who are now in welfare need. 
 Honorary Welfare Officers 
 The Association's Branches, numbering over 630 worldwide and comprising a membership of over 103,000, provide a network of Honorary Welfare Officers. 
 These are available to help men and women, and their dependants, who serve of have served in one of Her Majesty's Air Forces. 
 They provide welfare support ranging from hospital visits to helping with the completion of applications for financial assistance for a variety of needs, such as rent, gas, electricity, telephone arrears, purchase of essential household equipment, clothing and travel costs to visit sick relatives. 
 They arrange convalescence, specialist accommodation such as Eagle Lodges and, in exceptional circumstances, holidays including those financed by the Swiss Branch under their Welfare Holiday Scheme. 
 The incidence of indebtedness continues to rise due to redundancy, unemployment and inflation. 
 These cases require frequent visits and continuing follow-up by the Honorary Welfare Officers. 
 Central Council would like to record its grateful thanks to them all for their work throughout 1990, and especially for the way they have accepted the increased work load. 
 Central Council is also grateful to their spouses who often support the welfare work of their partners, and to the many other volunteers who also help. 
 The success of two trial Training Courses held in June and October at Birmingham and York confirmed the belief that the wider demands being placed on the Honorary Welfare Officers meant that some formal training was essential. 
 It is important that they should know about changes in Department of Social Services benefits, how other Service charities and voluntary agencies work, how to help people to cope with bereavement, the steps to take regarding the increasing problems of debt, and how to meet the special needs of the elderly. 
 These courses, designed to provide this information, were over-subscribed and the feedback from those who attended was that they wished they had been available earlier. 
 It is intended that they will be run on a regular basis. 
 Central Council would like to thank SSAFA for their help in establishing these courses. 
 The Royal Air Force Benevolent Fund 
 The Association continues to work in close co-operation with the RAF Benevolent Fund. 
 The Association's Honorary Welfare Officers disbursed some &pound;1.8m in 1990 on behalf of the Fund. 
 The Association is pleased to continue this work to maintain these close ties for the benefit of the Royal Air Force &bquo;family&equo;. 
 Medical and Legal Panels 
 Central Council would like to record its grateful thanks to the members of the Medical and Legal Panels. 
 Their advice and assistance offered to those seeking help through the Association during 1990 has been very much appreciated. 
 Links with other Ex-Service Organisations 
 This year The Council of British Service and Ex-Service Organisations (COBSEO) endorsed the major proposals made by Sir Greville Spratt in his Report of July 1989 that still closer co-operation and mutual aid is needed in all aspects of benevolent work. 
 The Association continues to work with its sister charities to achieve this.  
 Sussexdown 
 The new Therapy Wing together with improvements and refurbishment of the Lord Tedder Wing were completed during the year. 
 The opening ceremony was performed by the Rt. 
 Hon. 
 Nicholas Scott, MBE, JP, MP, the Minister of State for Society Security and Disabled People at an Open Day on the 14th July. 
 The event was attended by those who generously contributed to the project, by representatives from the RAF and by local dignitaries. 
 Sussexdown looked at its best in the summer sunshine and a marvellous day was enjoyed by guests and residents. 
 A two-seat Spitfire, operated by Mrs Carolyn Grace in memory of her husband, gave an exciting aerobatic display during the afternoon. 
 Music was provided by the Chichester City Band. 
 The Therapy Wing has provided much improved facilities for occupational therapy and physiotherapy. 
 A light, airy sun lounge with delightful views of the garden and South Downs greatly improves the quality of life for the residents. 
 The reinstatement of the Lord Tedder Wing has enabled a total of 63 beds to be available for permanent residence, convalescence and respite care. 
 During 1990 a review of the quality and appropriateness of the nursing and residential care at Sussexdown took place. 
 With the help of specialilst consultants the policy and organisation has been reviewed. 
 Organisational changes have been introduced and a policy statement has been formulated that provides the blueprint for care for the future, and ensures that it will be conducted in accordance with the latest and best practices of the nursing profession. 
 The year was a busy one for the residents with an increase in the number of outings, many in connection with the 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain. 
 Holidays were provided at Pontins near Weymouth by the &bquo;Not Forgotten&equo; Association, and in Jersey by the Jersey Branch. 
 The generous support given by Branches of the Association, organisations and individuals to enable residents to enjoy outings and holidays is very much appreciated as they are so important to the well-being of residents. 
 The average bed occupancy for the year was 90.5%, indicating that the accommodation was well used. 
 The average number of permanent residents throughout the year was 43 and 250 people benefited from periods of convalescence and respite care. 
 In a new project with the local community the pupils from Rydon School, Storrington, undertook a community programme whereby they were allocated a Sussexdown resident and visited them twice a month. 
 Their teacher has said that the project &bquo;has opened their eyes to the problems that have to be met by the elderly and disabled.&equo; 
 The visits have been much appreciated by the residents.  
 Sussexdown The new Therapy Wing, opened by the Rt Hon Nicholas Scott MBE, JP, MP on 14th July.  
 PPP Beaumont Nursing Homes 
 To relieve the periodic overload at Sussexdown, the Association has used a contract scheme for nursing beds with Private Patients Plan Beaumont Nursing Homes. 
 This has worked well for both permanent and respite care. 
 The scheme is based primarily on the use of beds at a Nursing Home near Oxford but a number of other Homes have also been used. 
 Central Council would like to thank PPP Beaumont's management and staff and the Oxford Branch of the Association for their contribution to the success of this scheme. 
 Richard Peck House 
 Richard Peck House was named after Air Marshal Sir Richard Peck, President of the Association from 1949&ndash;1952. 
 He is still remembered with great affection within the Association and his widow, Lady Peck, continues a most welcome interest in the House. 
 Central Council sends its good wishes to her. 
 The House, at Lytham St Annes, provides convalescence for 23 guests, and is situated a short walk from the sea and promenade. 
 Guests can enjoy trips to local beauty spots, dancing at a local hotel, and visits to local theatres. 
 During 1990, 450 guests benefited from convalescence at the Home, and the Association has received many letters of appreciation of the good food, the good company and the kind care of the staff. 
 Central Council would like to express their gratitude for the many generous donations and gifts which help to maintain the high standard of care given to the Home's guests.  
 Sussexdown &bquo;Working Out&equo; in the new physiotherapy department  
 War Pensions 
 The following two cases illustrate some of the work of the War Pensions Officer and the Area Welfare Officers: 
 A young SAC developed a nervous state that resulted in his discharge from the RAF. 
 His claim for a War Disablement Pension was rejected by the Department of Social Security. 
 Twenty years later he decided to lodge an Entitlement Appeal against the decision, and nominated the Association to represent him. 
 The Tribunal decided that the mental condition was attributable to service and allowed the Appeal. 
 A Flight Lieutenant underwent surgery to repair a broken blood vessel in the brain. 
 After the operation his personality had changed, his memory was impaired and he was discharged from the RAF. 
 The War Pensions Branch assessed the degree of disability at 40% which he appealed against. 
 He was represented at the hearing of his Appeal by the Association and the Tribunal increased the assessment to 80%. 
 Many claimants and appellants are in a poor state of health, and are often not able to present their cases unaided. 
 1990 saw an increase in the number of Tribunal hearings when the Central and Area Headquarters' representatives attended 127 Entitlement and 86 Assessment Appeals. 
 Chateau Holidays 
 Once again the Association is most grateful to Mr and Mrs Frank Cannon and their fellow trustees for their generosity in providing superb holidays for Association members at the Chateau de Monviel in France. 
 A party of ten visited between 25th May and 8th June, whilst a similar number went there between 7th and 21st September. 
 The visitors were invited to an RAFA Battle of Britain banquet organised by the Sud-Ouest Branch. 
 For one couple this happily coincided with their Golden Wedding Day. 
 Letters that have been received show that Mr and Mrs Cannon are most excellent hosts. 
 Their great kindness has helped members enjoy a holiday they will never forget. 
 Charity Shop 
 The Wales Area has opened a charity shop at its headquarters in Cardiff. 
 The aim of the shop is to raise funds for an Eagle Lodge in the Principality.  
 Eagle Lodge Wexford House situated in Melton Mowbray 
 RAFA Housing 
 Sheltered Housing 
 An increasing number of ex-Service personnel and their dependants are now reaching the age when they require some form of supportive housing, and this number will continue to grow over the next decade. 
 At present the Association administers 80 sheltered flats. 
 There are schemes at Storrington, West Sussex, at Moffat, Dumfriesshire and at Bolton, Greater Manchester. 
 This latter scheme is administered by Norwest RAFA Housing Association. 
 Waiting lists for all three locations bear witness that demand exceeds supply. 
 The Association is grateful for the help and advice in connection with the Storrington scheme that has been received from Orbit Housing Association. 
 The Association was also pleased to learn that Dowding House at Moffat had received a &bquo;Special Mention&equo; in the 1990 Civic Trust Awards. 
 Eagle Lodges 
 The Eagle Lodge concept, which is to provide supportive housing for elderly single persons, has proceeded with increasing momemtum throughout 1990. 
 By the end of the year, the Association had two Lodges with residents in occupation, and a third in the final stages of conversion. 
 Considerable enthusiasm has been shown by the Association's Areas, and some have initiated fund-raising to develop further Eagle Lodges. 
 Wexford House. 
 Situated in a quiet, residential area of Melton Mowbray, Wexford House was the first Eagle Lodge to open. 
 Purchased by the Association in May 1989, extensive alterations were necessary to convert it to provide for eight residents, the first of whom arrived in September 1990. 
 It is gratifying that the initial residents have built up a very happy family atmosphere, and have expressed their thanks to the Association for providing them with what they now regard as their home. 
 Wexford House has demonstrated that the Eagle Lodge concepts should be a success. 
 Woodford. 
 Located in Southport, Woodford is the Association's second Eagle Lodge, and can accommodate nine residents. 
 Formerly a private hotel, it has needed only a little work to convert it to its new use. 
 Six residents are currently living there and enjoying the comforts of a very homely atmosphere. 
 Woodford was developed as an initiative by the North Western Area. 
 The White House. 
 The Bexhill-on-Sea Branch identified The White House as a potential Eagle Lodge in January 1990, and its first resident will shortly move in. 
 Although it had been a rest home for British Telecom, alterations were necessary to provide the ten individual bed sitting rooms and the Housekeepers flat, whilst at the same time some safety improvements were needed to meet the Fire Officer's regulations. 
 The Branch has formed a local Management Committee to operate the Lodge on behalf of the Association within agreed guidelines and, judging from the number of applications specifically for The White House, Bexhill-on-Sea will retain its reputation as the retirement centre of the South. 
 Appeals 
 Achievement 
 The celebration of the 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain provided a magnificent opportunity to achieve new records in fund-raising. 
 The Association is both pleased and proud to report that the opportunity was, indeed, seized and that the target for the Wings Appeal was comfortably surpassed. 
 A &pound;2,000,000 target had been set for the Battle of Britain Wings Appeal in the full knowledge that our sister charity, the RAF Benevolent Fund was launching its &pound;20,000,000 &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal, and that the Association would be offering as much support as possible to that. 
 In the event the Association's Honorary Wings Appeal Organisers, together with enthusiastic and voluntary helpers, set about the challenge with such determination and energy that a total of &pound;2,437,637 was reached, an increase of 47% on the pervious year. 
 On top of that, the Association was able to contribute over &pound;250,000 to the &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal through events and undertakings run by both Branches and Central Headquarters. 
 Other fundraising continued with the Dowding Housing and Eagle Lodge Appeals, both receiving significant sums. 
 In addition, support continued for the Association's welfare homes at Sussexdown and Richard Peck House. 
 In all, over &pound;3,000,000 will have been raised in what has been a record fund-raising year. 
 Central Council is indebted to the Honorary Wings Appeal Organisers, members and friends who worked so hard to achieve this huge success. 
 On behelf of all those who the Association will now be able to help, the Association sends its sincere thanks.  
 Battle of Britain Wings Appeal Gross Proceeds 1984/1990 
 Battle of Britain Wings Appeal Trophy Winners 
 Almost all Branches were winners in 1990. 
 Substantial increases on the previous year were made by 446 Branches, 138 Branches sustained their last year's contribution, which in many cases had already been a record, and only 43 were significantly down. 
 The list of the champions is headed once again Bexhill-on-Sea, who beat their own record to win the Sir Thomas Pike Trophy with a net total of &pound;28,497. 
 A new name will appear on the Buckhurst Hill Trophy for the runners up; after being in the top ten for some time Solihull made a quantum leap to a net total of &pound;27,015. 
 The success of the year can be measured by the number of Branches that deserve special mention. 
 The Association normally publishes a list of the 12 Branches with the best Wings Appeal total, but in 1990 a new club was formed, &bquo;The 10,000 Club&equo;. 
 The 37 Branches listed below all achieved totals of &pound;10,000 or more; the include Branches both large and small, with and without Branch Clubs, from all parts of the country and continental Europe. 
 The Association congratulates all of them.   
 Girls Venture Corps Members of the Downham Market Unit set off on a 100 mile walk for Wings Appeal.  
 The Wings Appeal total divided by the number of members gives an average of &pound;21.56 per member, well up on last year. 
 Because the number of members who took an active part in the fund-raising is comparatively small, the true amount contributed by everyone who was actually involved was more than &pound;200. 
 Many Branches exceeded the national per capita average, and the top twelve are given below. 
 In the UK the Stock Exchange and Roe Valley Branches win trophies, while the overseas per capita trophies go to the Luxembourg and the St Germain and District Branches. 
 Northern Ireland excelled as usual, with an area total of &pound;58.70 per member, well ahead of the national average figure and also that of any other single area. 
 While sending hearty congratulations to the trophy winners, Central Council also offers sincere thanks to all the Branches whose extra endeavours led them to beat their own previous records.  
 The Royal Air Force Family 
 In spite of becoming very busy from August onwards, because of heighened international tension and a heavy commitment to the &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal, RAF Stations and personnel managed to give substantial help to Wings Appeal. 
 Overseas stations actually managed to increase their contribution. 
 Record crowds were the reward of RAF Abingdon, RAF St Athan, RAF Finningley and RAF Leuchars for their hard work in preparing and running their &bquo;At Home&equo; days. 
 The Association benefited from their endeavours in 1989 by a valuable contribution of &pound;135,000. 
 Among the RAF Trophy winners RAF Stornaway deserves a mention, it will this year receive the very handsome Sir Charles Wheeler Trophy for the ninth consecutive year &mdash; a record that will be hard to beat. 
 The RAF Trophy winners are:  
 It becomes more difficult each year to find words that will reflect the invaluable help given to the Association by the young people of the Air Training Corps and the Girls Venture Corps Air Cadets. 
 Very few Branch collecting sheets appear without the names of many cadets, and it is a great encouragement to know that so many are prepared to give up so much of their time to help the Association. 
 The Sir Douglas Bader Trophy has been won by No 1143 (8th Edinburgh) Squadron with an astounding figure of &pound;290.76 per cadet. 
 They were chased quite hard by no 2423 (Treorchy) Squadron, which became the first Welsh Wings Appeal National Trophy winner with the award of the Sir Gus Walker Trophy. 
 The second GVCAC recipient of the Sir Andrew Humphrey Trophy will be No 1095 (Rotherham) Unit. 
 The Association is most grateful to the AOC Air Cadets and the Director of the Girls Venture Corps for permitting their respective Corps to provide this much appreaciated help.  
 Cinema Industry 
 Even though the long, hot summer took its toll on audiences, the generous support of Cannon Cinemas still provided the Association with the substantial sum of &pound;88,358. 
 In addition, this company also contributed to the Association's efforts on behalf of the &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal by helping to arrange a Royal Film Gala night at their Shaftsbury Avenue cinema. 
 The film of the Douglas Bader story &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; was shown on the big screen for the first time in many years, and the Association was able to contribute &pound;20,200 to the RAF Benevolent Fund as a result of this effort. 
 Branches report from all over the UK on the interest and help provided by the management and staff of Cannon Cinemas, and the company's support is gratefully acknowledged by Central Council. 
 Tesco Stores 
 Many Branches have been fortunate in making successful collections in their local Tesco stores for several years. 
 The company is famous for its generosity and support for charitable causes, as indeed are its employees who have record of practical help to charities that is second to none. 
 In 1990 Tesco made the Association the beneficiary of one of the six nationwide collections that it allows in its stores. 
 The collection took place on 15/16 June and resulted in the most valuable contribution of &pound;125,903 to the Association. 
 The excellent interest and co-operation by Tesco store management and staff, and the practical help given to the Association's Branches in carrying out collections is much appreciated. 
 Charitable Trusts, Corporate Donors and Private Donors 
 Substantial donations, in cash and kind, have been received from charitable trusts, commercial and industrial concerns, and many kind and generous individuals. 
 When there are such considerable demands on the Nation's generosity to support many worthy causes, the Association feels privileged to receive their considerations. 
 At Appendix D is a list of donating Trust and Corporate Donors. 
 The individuals who have contributed are far too numerous to mention. 
 Central Council extends its sincere thanks to them all.  
 Canon Collection Our President, Marshal of the Royal Air Force, Sir Keith Williamson accepting a cheque from George Lennox (Cannon Cinemas) and Robert Garofalo (Film Director) for the 1989 collection . 
 Home Collecting Boxes 
 In 1990 the income from Home Collecting Boxes (HCB's) increased by 15.9% to &pound;26,848. 
 However, only 308 Branches managed to raise income from this very cost effective method, and of those only 60 achieved a rate of &pound;1 or more per member. 
 To put things into context, if half of the membership were to put up 10p a week into an HCB, they would make a total yearly contribution of &pound;260,000. 
 The Andover Branch have again shown how it can be done and wins the Anna Neagle Trophy with a contribution of &pound;1,466.54 &mdash; or &pound;10.40 per Branch member. 
 Central Council congratulates the Andover Branch, and recommends that other Branches seek their advice on methods. 
 Royal Air Force Yearbooks 
 Sale of Yearbooks by both the Association and RAF Stations have again declined. 
 However, the book remains popular with a large increase in sales fron commercial outlets being recorded. 
 The Association's partnership position in this endeavour will be reviewed in 1991. 
 RAF Benevolent Fund's &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal 
 At the 1989 Annual Conference in Bournemouth it was resolved to support the RAF Benevolent Fund's 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain Appeal, and Branches were asked to provide support at local level for what became known as the &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal. 
 A number of central activities were initiated to provide a core contribution to the Appeal. 
 In March, a limited edition of the Frank Wootton fine art print &bquo;Adlertag, 15 August 1940&equo; was signed at RAF Biggin Hill by the artist and six Battle of Britain pilots. 
 The prints were produced by the American company &bquo;The Greenwich Workshop&equo;, which also produced a video of the signing and of the pilot's recollections of their wartime experiences. 
 By the end of 1990, &pound;15,000 had been raised from the sale of the prints for the Appeal with more to come when the project is finished.  
 Annual Conference &mdash; 1990 Sir Peter Harding, Chief of the Air Staff, presenting a cheque for &pound;50,000 from the Royal Air Force to our President, Marshal of the Royal Air Force, Sir Keith Williamson . 
 April saw the launching of the 370 page commemorative publication Against All Odds , which had been produced by the Rococo Group. 
 The book was &bquo;A Tribute to 'The Few' who flew in the Battle of Britain, and to the many who supported them&equo;. 
 Contributors included Dame Vera Lynn, Sir Richard Attenborough, Sir Edmund Hilary, Rt Hon Norman Tebbit, Cliff Michelmore, Max Bygraves and Warren Mitchell. 
 By the end of 1990 &pound;50,000 had been raised from the sales of the book and donated to the &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal. 
 The Association is most grateful to the Rococo Group for their work in producing an excellent book and to all those who contributed to it and supported its sales. 
 Other centrally sponsored events, including a Film Premier and the Battle of Britain Ball, raised substantial sums for the Appeal and the Association's links with the Rugby League led directly to a donation to the Appeal by the League of &pound;10,000 at the Rugby League 1990 Challenge Cup Final at Wembley. 
 The South Eastern Area supported the Appeal through public collections at events in the London area and also at a special street collection in Central London on 10 July. 
 There were widespread fund-raising activities by Areas and Branches throughout the Association, both in the UK and Overseas. 
 Dances, buffet suppers, flower festivals, supper shows, poetry reading, craft shows, sales stands, aircraft model making and flying, car treasure hunts, boat cruises and sponsored sports events of many types were among the fund-raising efforts reported. 
 Central Council thanks all those Branches and individuals who worked so hard to ensure that the Association's contribution to this Appeal was so substantial. 
 Dowding House Appeal 
 The joint Royal Air Forces Association and Royal Air Force Benevolent Fund Appeal for Dowding House remained open for donations during the year. 
 Support continued to come forward for the Appeal from Branches, individuals and organisations. 
 Particularly noteworthy support came from the Joint Services Philatelic Consortium which has now raised &pound;100,000 for the Appeal through the sale of philatelic covers. 
 The Appeal will benefit by a share of the profits of the &bquo;Adlertag&equo; fine art print project and some other commercial initiatives. 
 The full costs of the project have now been covered by the Appeal and a modest maintenance reserve set up to help sustain the future of the House. 
 Any continuing contributions received will be put to this reserve but active fund-raising for the Appeal has now ceased. 
 Central Council is most grateful for the generous support that has led to this successful outcome.  
 &bquo;Adlertag&equo; Wing Commander Unwin, Frank Wootton (Artist), Group Captain Carey and Group Captain Cunningham signing the prints . 
 General 
 The Links with the Royal Air Force 
 With a membership at the end of 1990 of 103,000, there exist the closest family ties between those who have served in the RAF and those who serve today. 
 In particular, Central Council appreciates the help, guidance and continued support of the Director General of RAF Personal Services and his staff throughout the year. 
 The RAF/RAFA Consultative Committee is the culmination of this support which continues behind the scenes from Station Commanders onwards. 
 The year has seen continued support of the Association by the RAFA Liaison Officers (RAFALOs) with membership from the serving RAF continuing to increase. 
 RAFALOs work hard in promoting the Association on their Stations and supporting the local Branches. 
 At least one RAFALO has been elected to an Area Council. 
 Central Council appreciates the contribution made by the RAFALOs and thanks them for their efforts. 
 Air Displays 
 The Association was represented at the &bquo;At Home&equo; Days at RAF Leuchars, RAF Finningley, RAF Abingdon and RAF St Athan. 
 In addition, Association branches sponsored air displays in Guernsey, Jersey, and the Isle of Man. 
 British Aerospace generously sponsored an Air Display at their Woodford, Cheshire, airfield which was promoted by the North Western Area. 
 National Ceremonies and Services 
 The Association participated in the following national services and ceremonies during 1990: 
 The Annual Service at St Clement Danes, Central Church of the RAF, to commemorate the formation of the RAF. 
 The Service of Rememberance at the Commonwealth Air Forces Memorial, Runnymede. 
 The Battle of Britain 50th Anniversary Commemorative Parade. 
 The Wreath-laying ceremony at the RAF Memorial on the Embankment. 
 The Battle of Britain Service at Westminster Abbey. 
 The Festival of Remembrance at the Royal Alber Hall. 
 The Remembrance Day Parade and Service at the Cenotaph in Whitehall. 
 The opportunity to participate in the Parade on 15 September to commemorate the 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain was a particular honour for the Association. 
 It was a perfect Autumn day as the Association's Flight led the parade down the Mall to form up in front of Buckingham Palace. 
 Mr F B Brisley was the Association's parade marshal, Air Marshal Sir Ivor Broom, President of the Wales Area, was the Right Marker and Group Captain the Earl Ilchester, President of the South Eastern Area was the Left Marker. 
 The Standard of the Association was paraded by Mr J Kirkpatrick. 
 A Flypast of representative Squadrons and aircraft of the Royal Air Force, including the Battle of Britain Memorial Flight, started the formal ceremonial. 
 The Association's Flight was subsequently honoured to be inspected by Her Majesty The Queen and to march past Her Majesty. 
 It was a great honour for the Association to take part in this National occasion, an occasion which provided an opportunity to pay a tribute to those who fought the Battle of Britain, and to remember the welfare needs that exist today as a result of that Battle. 
 Air Vice-Marshal N S Howlett, Chairman of the Executive Committee and Mrs Howlett were present when 91 Branch Standards were paraded on the evening of 13 July at the Royal Tournament. 
 Throughout the period of the Royal Tournament the Association stand, sponsored by British Telecom, was staffed by members from branches in the South Eastern Area, to whom Central Council extends its grateful thanks. 
 The President, Marshal of the Royal Air Force Sir Keith Williamson and Lady Williamson were present when the Standard of the Association was paraded at the Festival of Remembrance at the Royal Albert Hall.  
 Special Events 
 The annual Greyhound Race Meeting at Wimbledon Stadium in July was, as usual, well supported by RAF Stations, and raised some &pound;4,000. 
 TV stars Peter Dean and Wendy Richard supported the event and presented trophies on behalf of RAF Akrotiri and RAF Aldergrove. 
 On 15 September some 80 guests were present at an Overseas Reception at London Weekend Television House, where they had a first class view of the flypast from the eighteenth floor. 
 Those unable to attend the parade watched it on television, and were joined later by some of the overseas visitors who had proudly paraded before Her Majesty The Queen outside Buckingham Palace. 
 This reception was kindly sponsored by Martin Brothers International. 
 The Annual Battle of Britain Ball took place this year on 28 September in the Grosvenor House. 
 Over 1,480 guests came from around the world to celebrate the 50th Anniversary of the Battle. 
 Dancing was to the Johnny Howard Orchestra and to Tony Charles and his Trinidad Steel Band. 
 During the evening, the Central Band of the RAF entertained the assembly with their marching display, and Dame Vera Lynn enthralled all present with songs from the war years. 
 As an outcome of the Ball, a donation of &pound;15,000 was made to the &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal. 
 The Grand Summer Draw, the first prize for which was a Nissan Sunny car provided through AFG of Sevenoaks, raised &pound;44,100 for the Association's work. 
 The keys were presented at RAF Biggin Hill to the winner, Mr J D Fletcher of Biggleswade, by Bob Ogley, author of Biggin on the Bump . 
 Central Council is very grateful to all those who donated prizes or sold tickets to help reach this excellent result.  
 Flight Lieutenant T.E. 
 Jonsson, DFM Finally retired after 36,000 hours of military and civil flying, Flt Lt Jonsson from Iceland attended the Battle of Britain 50th Anniversary reception after representing the Luxembourg Branch on the Battle of Britain 50th Anniversary Parade . 
 Awards 
 In the 1990 Queen's Birthday Honours List Mr C A Blachford, Chairman of the North Western Area Council, became a Member of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire, and J T Jones from the Cheltenham Branch was awarded the British Empire Medal. 
 In the 1991 New Year Honours List, Mr W J Chignell, an Elected Member of Central Council, became a Member of the Most Excellent Order of the British Empire, and Mr E F Jackson from the Storrington Branch was awarded the British Empire Medal. 
 Presidential Certificates to coincide with the 1990 Queen's Birthday Honours were awarded to:  
 Presidential Certificates to coincide with the 1991 New Year's Honours were awarded to:  
 A special Presidential Certificate was awarded at Annual Conference to Mrs C W Crawford, the Administrator at Richard Peck House. 
 Central Council records its thanks to the recipients of Honours and Presidential Certificates for their support of the work of the Association, and extends its congratulations on their awards. 
 The Branch Efficiency Competition 
 The judges for the 1989 competition were Air-Vice Marshal N S Howlett, Mr A R Kendrick and Mr F C Pegg. 
 The results were as follows:   
 Annual Conference 
 Annual Conference was held in Blackpool from 11&ndash;13 May, and was attended by 381 delegates from 347 branches and some 2,240 visitors. 
 No 1855 (Royton) Sqn ATC provided a Guard of Honour for the arrival of Air Chief Marshal Sir Peter Harding, Chief of the Air Staff. 
 The President, Marshal of the Royal Air Force Sir Keith Williamson, took the Chair, and Conference was opened by The Worshipful The Mayor of Blackpool, Councillor Mrs Mary A Barnes JP. 
 The silent tribute was led by the Venerable B N Halfpenny, Chaplain in Chief of the RAF.  
 First Leisure Gift at Blackpool Chief of the Air Staff, Air Chief Marshal Sir Peter Harding, handing the keys of the coach to John Ray, Administrator at Sussexdown. 
 The Chinook and crew which delivered the coach to the airport, came from RAF Odiham . 
 Battle of Britain 50th Anniversary Parade The Hurricane and Spitfire from the BBMF over the Mall on September 15th . 
 The Chairman acknowledged messages of greeting from Her Majesty The Queen, Patron of the Association; Her Royal Highness Princess Alice, Duchess of Gloucester, Vice Patron; Their Royal Highnesses The Duke of Edinburgh and The Prince of Wales, Past Presidents and from some eighty organisations throughout the Commonwealth. 
 Mr Jack Price, National President of the Air Force Association of the United States of America then addressed Conference, extending his Association's fraternal greetings to the Association in Conference and presenting an inscribed plaque to the Chairman. 
 In a stimulating address, the Chief of the Air Staff, Air Chief Marshal Sir Peter Harding enlarged upon his theme of last year, and described how it was planned to improve Service life. 
 There was every reason to believe that the new modern, but smaller RAF would be well able to meet any demands upon it. 
 Sir Peter acknowledged the part that the Association played in the RAF family, with its support of members past and present which was highlighted with the continued development of Eagle Lodges. 
 Sir Peter then presented the Association with a cheque for &pound;50,000 to help further development of this concept. 
 Formal business opened with the adoption of the Standing Orders Committee Report, and the presentation of the Annual Report and Accounts for 1989. 
 Conference then looked at 31 Resolutions covering Service Liaison, Welfare and Pensions, Homes, Appeals and Fund-raising, the Rules, Byelaws and Regulations, Standard Club Rules, Organisation and Annual Conference itself. 
 Following a resolution supporting the RAF Benevolent Fund's 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain Appeal, the Chairman invited Air Chief Marshal Sir Thomas Kennedy to address Conference. 
 In his address, Sir Thomas Kennedy spoke of the enormous communications gap that had to be bridged if the Appeal was to be successful, and sought delegates' help in publicising the Fund and the Appeal especially through the medium of provincial and local newspapers. 
 In gratefully acknowledging the Association's support of the Appeal, Sir Thomas outlined the progress made to date and gave details of planned events for the immediate future. 
 In concluding his address, Sir Thomas said that while the Appeal was under way the Fund would continue to support welfare work in its usual fashion, recording that a cheque had earlier been presented to the Chairman of Conference for the Association's Eagle Lodge project. 
 In thanking Sir Thomas Kennedy for his address, the Chairman of Conference announced that the cheque for &pound;50,000 had been received from the RAF Benevolent Fund.  
 Royal Salute The Association's flight passing Her Majesty The Queen outside Buckingham Palace on September 15th . 
 On Saturday afternoon the RAF Presentation Team, which normally attends one of the Area Conferences each year, gave their presentation to Conference for which they received the grateful thanks and applause of those present. 
 Conference provided a focus for Telethon 1990, when delegates and visitors donned blue &bquo;ears&equo; to raise money for this charity. 
 At the same time, the First Leisure Corporation presented the Association with a &pound;17,000 coach which had been specially customised for use at Sussexdown. 
 The Chief of the Air Staff and a crew from RAF Odiham with a Chinook helicopter lifted the coach from Blackpool beach providing useful publicity for First Leisure and the Association. 
 The Rendezvous Dance on Friday evening and the Civic Reception hosted by the Mayor on Saturday evening provided an opportunity for delegates and visitors to relax and renew old friendships. 
 The Band of the RAF Regiment, Catterick, provided an orchestra for both evenings. 
 The RAF Halton Gymnastic Display Team showed how well they are trained when they performed their sparkling routine in the Empress Ballroom on Friday evening. 
 The Parade along the Promenade on Sunday morning was led by the Band of the RAF Regiment, supported by the Band of No 2193 (Prestatyn) Sqn of the Air Training Corps. 
 The salute was taken by the Mayor of Blackpool. 
 The Service of Dedication at the War Memorial was led by the Chaplain-in-Chief. 
 Central Council 
 Air Marshal Sir Charles Soutar completed his term as Chairman of Central Council and remains a Vice President. 
 Air Vice-Marshal D G Bailey has been elected Chairman to succeed Sir Charles. 
 Air Chief Marshal Sir Joseph Gilbert was elected Vice Chairman of Central Council in place of Air Vice-Marshal N S Howlett. 
 Mr F W Lindgren, a Life Vice President of the Association, whose service on Central Council extended o0ver 45 years and who is now permanently living overseas resigned at the end of the year.  
 South African Tour Vic Duggan, Area President, Bernard Ramsbottom, Area Director and David Green, CHQ's Overseas Director . 
 Air Commodore P G Naz (HQ Air Cadets) left Council on retirement from the RAF, and was replaced by Air Commodore R P Skelley, Sergeant D Greenfield joined the Council as the SNCO representative, and left at the end of the year on retirement from the Service. 
 Mr R A Owens lost his seat as an Elected Member of Council and was replaced by Air Vice-Marshal D Whittaker. 
 Central Council welcomes the new members and extends its thanks to all those whose membership has ended. 
 Executive Committee 
 Air Vice-Marshal N S Howlett was elected as Chairman and Mr H Dickinson was re-elected as Deputy Chairman. 
 Mr D Pugh was elected to the Committee, replacing Mr A J Taylor. 
 The Chairman welcomes Mr Pugh and thanks Mr Taylor for his efforts over the years past. 
 Overseas 
 The number of Overseas branches has remained steady despite the inevitable decline in membership. 
 The average age of the overseas membership is somewhat higher that the UK average as there are very few younger members to join these branches. 
 There are still some very active branches, however, and their efforts are very much appreciated by Central Council. 
 In October, the Overseas Director visited South Africa accompanied by a group of members from the UK. 
 The party met many of the Branch Officers, and received hospitality from both Civic authorities and the South African Air Force. 
 The visit was very much appreciated by the South African Area and enjoyed by those who went. 
 The South African Area continues to work hard in support of both the Association and the RAF Benevolent Fund, and has made a special effort this year, the 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain. 
 The problem of continued support in the face of declining membership is being addressed. 
 The European Area has made another considerable contribution to the work of the Association during the year. 
 As well as looking after their own members, the Branches have supported the efforts of the Association within the UK. 
 The support from the RAF in Europe continues to be strong. 
 The support of Air Chief Marshal Sir Anthony Skingsley, Deputy Commander-in-Chief Allied Forces Central Europe is warmly acknowledged by Central Council. 
 This year the Autumn meeting of the European Area was held in Athens where, at a simple but moving ceremony, a memorial was unveiled to commemorate all those Greek and RAF aircrew who lost their lives during the battle for Greece. 
 This memorial was raised by the joint efforts of the Athens Branch and the Hellenic Air Force. 
 The Independent Overseas Branches continue to support the Association both locally and in the UK. 
 The Channel Island Branches, Guernsey and Jersey, again lead the list of winners in the Battle of Britain Week Appeal. 
 Branch Clubs 
 The Association has continued to clarify the legal relationship between Branches and Branch clubs through the introduction of formal leasing arrangements. 
 This has been done to demonstrate that the charitable assets of the Association are being utilised within an appropriate framework that is acceptable to the Charity Commission. 
 The Branch Clubs have continued to receive the support of the Committee of Registered Clubs Association and to benefit from the work of the All Party Parliamentary Committee for Non-Profit Making Members Clubs. 
 One useful change has been the restoring of parity of permitted hours for clubs opening with those enjoyed by public houses.  
 Public Relations 
 During 1990 the Department worked together on several projects with the RAF Benevolent Fund's &bquo;Reach for the Sky&equo; Appeal. 
 The Association proved once again to be a formidable field force when helping the appeal, and provided an excellent point of reference for the media in respect of both the 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain and the work of the Association. 
 Many valuable contacts were made and several projects that could not be implemented during 1990 will be followed through in the future. 
 Support for the Association's work continues to come forward and the Association is increasingly benefiting from working with other organisations on mutually beneficial projects with the Association often achieving both publicity and financial assistance. 
 Branch Welfare Officer profiles have been featured in the local press and the Association's new welfare facilities have also served to provide a focus of interest for the media. 
 In 1990 the Association's Annual Conference achieved nationwide television coverage because of its involvement with ITV's Telethon and the First Leisure Corporation. 
 Air Mail 
 Air Mail has continued to follow the format that was developed in 1989, and which seeks to maintain a balance between Association policy, news and items of historical, Service and general interest. 
 It remains very conscious of the need for advertising revenues. 
 The Autumn issue marked the 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain with articles on the Battle and those who fought in it. 
 The Editorial staff much appreciate the keen interest in the magazine shown by the membership, and thank all who send information on activities and who contribute articles.  
 Battle of Britain 50th Anniversary Fly Past Spitfires and Hurricanes over Nelson's Column on September 15th . 
 Staff 
 Mr T F Connolly, the former Chief Welfare Officer, has retired from the post of Welfare Adviser. 
 Mrs C W Crawford has retired from the post of Administrator at Richard Peck House and has been replaced by Mrs A Mulvey. 
 Mr W I Paterson has retired as the North Western Area Director and has been replaced by Mr D M MacInnes. 
 There were two new appointments during the year. 
 Mr I J Stephen was appointed Assistant Area Director and Welfare Officer for the North Eastern Area, and Mr G M Halloran was appointed Assistant Area Director and Welfare Officer for Scotland. 
 Central Council records its appreciation for the hard work, dedication and enthusiasm of all staff throughout a very busy and demanding year.  
 Westminster Abbey Service Mr F B Brisley leads the Association's Standards from Westminster Abbey after the Annual Battle of Britain Service on September 16th . 
 European Area Conference The Marquis of Amodio, President of the European Area with some of the trophy winners in Blackpool . 
 RAFAMACS Limited 
 RAFAMACS, the Association's trading company, had a busy year in 1990. 
 The primary business of gaming machines provided a valuable source of income although there is growing pressure of competition in this area. 
 The centralised trading operation also had a busy year, particularly with sales of commemorative items to mark the 50th Anniversary of the Battle of Britain. 
 Even though substantial orders were placed well in advance with the trade for some of these items the general pressure of demand was such that deliveries to RAFAMACS were delayed. 
 This was disappointing for some of RAFAMACS customers. 
 In all some 7,200 trading invoices were dealt with during the year and 1,500 stationery orders. 
 Trade prices increased during the year and this will need to be reflected in customer prices for 1991. 
 The Company continued to act as a trading agency for Commemorative Promotions Ltd during the year. 
 The Company covenents its profit from its trading operations plus the proceeds from the Grand Summer Draw to the Association. 
 RAFA ADS Limited 
 RAFA ADS, the Association's company to deal with the selling of advertising space and the production of Air Mail, completed its third trading year. 
 Sales of Air Mail advertising increased by25% during the year and the company was able to covenant a useful profit to the Association.  
 Battle of Britain 50th Anniversary Fly Past Spitfires and Hurricanes flying up the Mall on September 15th . 
 Accounts 
 Treasurers Report 
 1990 was a year of substantial achievement for the Association in terms of development of welfare facilities and in fund-raising. 
 Income for the year increased by &pound;1,411,384 to a total of &pound;3,622,386. 
 The net proceeds of the 1990 Wings Appeal provided &pound;618,637 of that overall increase: a remarkable achievement thanks to the generosity of the public and the magnificent &bquo;collective&equo; efforts of members, friends and associates from RAFA Branches throughout the world. 
 Legacies increased by &pound;538,154 to a record &pound;634,736 with the estate of Cyril and Stella Green providing &pound;250,000 of this amount. 
 General donations increased by &pound;219,882 and subscriptions income by &pound;34,439. 
 The trading companies had a mixed year. 
 RAFA ADS achieved a small increase in profits of &pound;3,257 by RAFAMACS' profits were down by &pound;33,929. 
 The activities of both companies were affected by the general economic recession prevailing throughout 1990 and the loss of some machine sites on RAF stations has also reduced RAFAMACS' revenue. 
 Capital expenditure amounted to &pound;1,307,571, mainly for the purchase, modification and furnishing of the three Eagle Lodges and the completion of the new Therapy Wing at Sussexdown. 
 This expenditure was funded from a surplus of income over expenditure of &pound;876,208 with the balance coming from specific donations to the Eagle Lodge and Therapy Wing projects and from the Association's general funds. 
 Looking to the immediate future, the Association will need to conserve and build up its reserves to fund further projects and to provide sufficient investment income to meet rising costs. 
 Operating expenditure increased by &pound;295,048, an increase of 12.0%. 
 Welfare expenditure was up by &pound;78,842 (8.6%); Air Mail costs by &pound;24,470 (16.6%); administration and publicity by &pound;17,132 (2.6%) and Annual Conference by &pound;5,202 (11.6%). 
 The increase of &pound;68,908 in interest paid on Branch deposits was partly due to high interest rates and partly because more Branches put their surplus funds on deposit with Central Headquarters. 
 This is a welcome and encouraging trend which not only ensures that the investment of Branch funds complies with the Trustee Investment Acts, but provides Branches with an excellent return on their money and assists management of the Association's cash flow. 
 The costs of running the Welfare Homes, after taking into account accommodation fees and sundry receipts, were &pound;622,478 for Sussexdown and &pound;129,642 for Richard Peck. 
 After donations to the Homes, the net costs amounted to &pound;501,415 and &pound;106,875 respectively. 
 The overall increase in the net costs of the two Homes for the year was &pound;75,789. 
 The net costs of Eagle Lodges appear for the first time in the income and expenditure account and are largely attributable to setting up costs as there was little income from occupancy during 1990. 
 The Dowding House Appeal was brought to a close on 31st December 1990, having achieved its objective of covering the costs of the scheme and of the Appeal. 
 The Association can be justly proud of this project which has provided a fitting memorial for Lord Dowding and a long term investment in much needed welfare accommodation. 
 The debt which never appears in any balance sheet or account is that owed by the Association to the fund-raising efforts of its supporters and the generosity of the public. 
 We will continue to depend heavily upon their help for the foreseeable future and gratefully acknowledge their invaluable help. 
 Finally, I wish to record the Association's sincere thanks to Sam Churchman, the Financial Secretary, and his staff for their work during a very busy year. 
 Their dedication and support have been invaluable in both accounting for the Association's funds and managing them effectively.  
 Notification of Specific Receipts from Public Funds 
 In accordance with a request from the Association of Charity Officers, it is confirmed that an amount of &pound;5,000 from public funds provided through the Association of Charity Officers has been received by the Association and utilised for provision of physiotherapy equipment for the new Therapy Wing at Sussexdown. 
  J.P. Wood Honorary Treasurer 27th March 1991  
 Report of the Auditors to the Members of The Royal Air Forces Association 
 We have audited the financial statements on the following pages in accordance with Auditing Standards. 
 In our opinion the financial statements give a true and fair view of the state of affairs of the Association at 31st December 1990 and of its result and source and application of funds for the year then ended. 
  Whitehead &amp; Aldrich Chartered Accountants, Preston, Lancashire. 
  27th March 1991   
 air mail 
 Journal of the Royal Air Forces Association 
 Air Mail 
 Winter 1991 Volume 44 Number 3 
 Journal of The Royal Air Forces Association 
 In this issue 
 2 
 Secretary General's Desk 
 4 
 Target &mdash; Berlin! 
 6 
 Welfare Matters 
 8 
 What's the food like here? 
 16 
 Royal Tournament '91 
 17 
 Area and Branch News 
 22 
 Bill Berry's Diary 
 26 
 Wexford House 
 28 
 Berling Bale-Out &mdash; and Escape! 
 32 
 The Structure of Remembrance 
 36 
 Letterbox 
 40 
 Album 
 42 
 Books 
 48 
 RAF Benevolent Fund 
 50 
 Calling Old Colleagues, Reunions, Help! 
 55 
 Obituaries 
 63 
 Tailfin 
 Editor  Stan White 
 Assistant Editor  Shirley Gelderblom 
 Advertisements  David Batt 
 RAFA Ads Ltd (a subsidiary company of The Royal Air Forces Association) 43 Grove Park Road, London W4 3RX Telephone 081&ndash;994 8504 
 Air Mail ISSN 0002&ndash;2446 ABC Member of the Audit Bureau of Circulations Jan-Jun 1991 103,894 
 Tysetting &amp; Colour Origination  LazerType 5 &amp; 6 Oyster Park, Greenstead Road, Colchester CO1 2SJ Printing  Pindar Graphics Print, Thornburgh Road Eastfield, Scarborough YO11 3UY 
 Our lifeblood 
 If our membership is our strength, then our subscriptions are our lifeblood. 
 Each January the Association gets a transfusion with the payment of the annual subscriptions, but our corporate health is not all that it could be. 
 For a start, that transfusion is always late in its completion. 
 Many of you, of course, make your contribution in good time, and deserve the cup of tea that helps you to recover from donating your &bquo;blood&equo;! 
 Latecomers, however, do make life difficult &mdash; and unnecessarily expensive. 
 While the Association will never pursue members with the determination of a Time-Share salesperson, it doesn't like to lose members, particularly those who are just too forgetful to get subscriptions off in good time. 
 Postage and paperwork is a waster of the Association's valuable resources which the membership does so much to create in the first place. 
 Please be sure, therefore, that the Association's heart still has something to pump and doesn't miss a beat every January. 
 Send us your subscription now &mdash; there is a form included on page 37 of this issue of Air Mail  &mdash; before all the New Year's bills become a distraction!  
 Our Cover Interior, looking east, St Clement Danes, Strand, Church of the Royal Air Force. 
 Secretary General's Desk 
 Remembrance 
 Reading the article in this issue on Remembrance  led me to reflect on the statement in our Royal Charter which says that one of the objects of the Association is to: 
 &bquo;&hellip; preserve the memory and honour the example by charitable means of comrades or members of the Association who have died in our Service&hellip;&equo; 
 The Key words in this are &bquo;by charitable means&equo; and we acknowledged this recently when we appealed for funds for Dowding House under the theme &bquo;We honour the dead by helping those who live&equo;. 
 This example of practical remembrance is paralleled in our other welfare facilities &mdash; at Sussexdown and Richard Peack House and the Eagle Lodges &mdash; and perhaps most importantly as we reach out through our Honorary Welfare Officers and out members to find and to help individuals in need. 
 That help could not be provided without the fund-raising efforts of the Association members together with the work of all those who sustain our membership and the comradeship of the Association. 
 It is through this team effort that we are able to match the words of our dedication &bquo;We shall remember them&equo; with the practical reality of care and concern. 
 Remembrance is thus able to move further into our lives than visits to memorials, was graves or churches &mdash; important as these are as symbols and as a focus of personal and public remembrance. 
 Annual Conference Resolution No 25 
 A considerable amount of my time since Annual Conference has been spent in following up Resolution No 25 which called for a specialist review of administration and expenditure. 
 Preparations are now well advanced for this review and it is intended to seek views from all levels of the Association starting this winter. 
 It is also intended that a survey of a sample of the membership is carried out by questionnaire as well as consultation meetings at Area and Branch level. 
 The review is important for the future of the Association and we hope that the process of wide consultation will lead to recommendations based on a considered analysis of the needs and views of the membership. 
 Area Presidents 
 Air Vice Marshal J Morris recently assumed the Presidency of the Scottish Area from Group Captain G P Marvin who retired after some 32 years as the Area President. 
 We wish them both well. 
 Recording this news reminded me of the valuable role played by Area Presidents in guiding their Area and representing the Areas at a variety of events and functions. 
 Members may be interested in who fills those positions and I therefore list the other Area Presidents below. 
 South Eastern 
 Group Captain The Earl of Ilchester 
 South Western 
 Air Vice-Marshal Sir John Severne 
 Eastern 
 Air Commodore E G P Jeffery 
 Midland 
 Air Commodore B W Opie 
 Wales 
 Air Marshal Sir Ivor Broom 
 North Western 
 Mr E F Woodruff 
 North Eastern 
 Mr F T Wilson 
 Northern Ireland 
 Air Vice-Marshal D Whittaker 
 European 
 The Marquis of Amodio and Moya 
 South African 
 Mr V G T Duggan 
 Our grateful thanks go to them for their support of the Association. 
 Staff Matters 
 Simon Martin has taken up the new post of Membership Officer based at Malvern. 
 He also takes over the responsibilities of Overseas Director as well as managing the membership on the CHQ roll. 
 Ken Hollands has taken up the appointment of North Western Area Director from David MacInnes. 
 John Hartley will shortly take up the position of Deputy Secretary General following a restructuring of responsibilities within CHQ. 
 David Green who held the combined post of Overseas Director and Senior Administrative Officer is leaving us for other employment. 
 We will them all well. 
 PR Report 
 The Association was once again well supported by the media during Wings Appeal. 
 Free newspaper groups in particular welcomed the opportunity to provide their readers with interesting features about both the Battle of Britain and the work of the Association, whilst at the same time encouraging their regular advertisers to support the Appeal by purchasing space on the feature. 
 Some newspapers even donated a proportion of the advertising revenue to the Association. 
 This year for the first time, we mailed a pre-recorded tape cassette to all radio stations in the UK. 
 On the tape Dame Vera Lynn is interviewed talking about the work of the Association. 
 This proved quite a successful intiative and was an inexpensive exercise because Air Vice-Marshal Bill Bailey kindly arranged for us to make use of the recording facilities at Services Sound &amp; Vision Corporation. 
 In April this year the Association helped with a USAFE Band Tour, providing standard bearers and ATC Cadets and members to sell programmes and make collections. 
 Although we had little notice of the tour, branches were keen to help and the Association will receive &pound;6,628 representing 50% of the total profits. 
 Another tour is planned for next year starting on 27 March and nine venues have been chosen, including Bournemouth, Newport, Hove, Stoke and Manchester. 
 I have a new assistant in the PR department and her name is Susie Gandar. 
 If you need to contact us, please telephone: 0684 573665.  
 Target &mdash; Berlin! 
 The infamous Berlin Wall now has only a few vestiges remaining. 
 In 1945 one could have been excused for believing that scarcely a wall could be left standing in the German capital after years of night raids by the RAF. 
 But many were still standing after five years of air attack, and although German civilian morale was largely unbroken, it was the psychology behind the attacks which yielded valuable dividends. 
 One of the most significant air raids of the entire war was against Berlin. 
 True there was not the drama and deceit of the Japanese raid against Pearl Harbour, but the raid on Berlin of the 25/26 August 1940 proved to be an event that very likely affected the course of history. 
 Last year we were reminded of those epic days when Fighter Command denied the Luftwaffe air superiority in the skies over Britain. 
 We were reminded, too, how narrow the margin was, and how the RAF's airfields were reprieved through the German High Command's decision to switch the attack to London. 
 That raid on Berlin of the 25/26 August pulled a psychological trigger in Nazi minds, and produced results that were entirely out of proportion to the military resources employed on that particular raid. 
 The raid was approved by the War Cabinet in retaliation for an inadvertent bombing of London. 
 81 Hampdens, Whitleys and Wellingtons from 3, 4 and 5 Groups were given targets in Berlin. 
 One must remember that these were times when each crew had to find their own way to the target, nearly always having to use dead reckoning to do so, and when moonlight or a fortuitous flare might illuminate the target. 
 On this occasion, Berlin had a thick cloud cover that went down to 2,000 ft and made accurate bombing impossible. 
 On the night in question there were also strong headwinds on the return flight. 
 29 aircraft claimed to have bombed the city, 21 brought their bombs back having failed to locate their targets and six jettisoned their loads in the sea. 
 The remaining aircraft attacked alternative targets. 
 The aircraft that claimed to have attacked Berlin were from 44, 49, 50, 58, 61, 83, and 99 Squadrons. 
 The only bombs that fell within Berlin's city limits destroyed a summer house in the suburb of Rosenthal, other bombs falling on farmland to the south of Berlin. 
 Berliners could afford to joke that the RAF was aiming to starve them to defeat! 
 Six Hampdens were lost, three of them through running out of fuel on the return. 
 The raid had profound effects on both Goering and Hitler. 
 Goering had boasted that no enemy 'plane would fly over the Reich and here they had shown that they could not only do this but could attack the capital itself. 
 Hitler was to convinced that the advantages of drawing the RAF's fighters into combat to protect London now outweighed the political advantages of not bombing Greater London. 
 A result of the Berlin raid of 25/26 August was the planning and execution of the Luftwaffe raid on London on 7 September which started a new phase in the Battle of Britain, and a turning point in Fighter Command's fortunes. 
 Bomber Command's immediate priorities after this raid switched to bombing the concentration of invasion  barges in the Channel ports, but raids on the German capital were to follow for the rest of the war. 
 The first noteworthy example came about a month after this August attack. 
 Martin Middlebrook and Chris Everitt's excellent book, The Bomber Command War Diaries  tell us that on the night of 23/24 September Bomber Command for the first time concentrated its main bomber strength on one city &mdash; Berlin. 
 18 individual targets, comprising seven railway yards, six power stations, three gasworks and two factories involved with aircraft production. 
 The attacking force was 129 Hampdens, Wellingtons and Whitleys, all but 17 claiming to have bombed the target. 
 Unfortunately there are no German records in existence (perhaps something may now turn up after the reunification!) but we can assume that the result of the raid fell short of causing significant damage to the German war machine. 
 In the following year the Poles of 300 and 301 Squadrons bombed Berlin, as did the Russians, but it was not until 1942 that the first of the four-engined &bquo;heavies&equo; made the long flight to this target. 
 The ubiquitous Mosquito (in its PR) role) had appeared early in the year and was recording details of damage inflicted by the night raids. 
 It was still only relatively light damage, however. 
 The German Air Ministry building in the Leipzigstrasse, for example, which had been a target since September 1940, remained unscathed until it suffered slight damage in a US daylight raid in 1944! 
 How much &bquo;Bomber&equo; Harris would have appreciated Gulf War laser technology if it had been available then! 
 By 1944 the air war against the German capital was hotting up further. 
 The Fortresses and Liberators of the USAAF, escorted by long-range fighters, were penetrating the defences &mdash; which were now much more formidable than they had been in 1940/41. 
 Heavy losses were sustained by both sides. 
 The night raids were almost non-stop, with Mosquitoes sometimes carrying out two sorties in a night thanks to the quick re-arming and re-fuelling at bases such as Marham, Upwood and Bourn. 
 The Lancaster was now the mainstay of Bomber Command, each aircraft delivering a bombload that would have needed four aircraft of 1940 vintage to have lifted it. 
 But all this is a different story, for the bomber aircrews not only had better aircraft to take the war to Berlin, they had better navigational aids, better weaponry, the Pathfinder Force, radio counter-measures, better planning and a host of other factors to make them more effective. 
 We should remember, however, two facts in particular. 
 The first is that Luftwaffe defences became better, too, and that caused a high price to be paid in terms of casualties. 
 No aircrew ever thought Berlin was an easy op. 
 The second fact is that those crews that took off on 25/26 August 1940 from bases like Waddington, Scampton, Lindholme, Hemswell and Newmarket, ill-equipped though they were to inflict any real damage on the enemy, achieved an impact on the course of the war that none could have truly appreciated at the time.  
 Air Mail  is grateful to Leslie Hunt for undertaking the research on which this article is based. 
 Welfare Matters 
 Motability 
 I read with interest an article in the Summer '91 issue of BLESMAG  and felt the subject could be usefully mentioned in Air Mail . 
 Brenda McLaren, Chief Welfare Officer . 
 WHAT IS THE MOTABILITY SCHEME 
 Motability was set up in 1977 on the initiative of the government to help holders of mobility allowance and war pensioners' mobility supplement use their allowance to obtain a vehicle. 
 Motability Finance Ltd was established with funds from the major banks. 
 The sole qualification for obtaining a vehicle is that you receive mobility supplement for a long enough period to cover the length of the agreement. 
 For new cars the length of the agreement varies according to whether you buy on contract hire (commonly known as &bquo;lease&equo;) which is for a period of three years, or on hire purchase which can be between four and five years. 
 Motability is not connected with the allocation of mobility supplement, which is controlled by the War Pensions Directorate of the Department of Social Security at Blackpool. 
 Any questions relating to the length of the award, or refusal to grant one, must be addressed to them. 
 The contract hire scheme is by far the most popular and it attacts over 90% of new car applications. 
 A wide selection of cars are available, and all manufacturers try to include a range to suit varying disabilities. 
 The fact that the car must be returned at the end of the hire term means that the range of adaptation is limited to those that can be easily attached and removed, eg hand controls, wheelchair hoists, rotating seats, etc. 
 If you wist to alter the car struturally, eg raise the roof to take a seated wheelchair passenger or change the doors to ramps, you would have to obtain a car through Car Chair, Gowrings or Widnes Car Centre Ltd, or buy the car on hire purchase. 
 For most cars you will have to give up the whole of your mobility supplement for the three year period. 
 You may need to make an advance payment (the difference between the total cost of the three year hire for the vehicle selected and the amount of finance available from mobility supplement), but for smaller cars there may not be anything to pay. 
 Choosing a suitable vehicle 
 Important points to consider when choosing a vehicle are: 
 &bull; 
 Can you get in and out easily? 
 &bull; 
 Can you reach and operate all the controls? 
 &bull; 
 If you have a wheelchair, will it fit behind the seat, in the boot, etc. and can you manage it yourself. 
 &bull; 
 Look ahead &mdash; is your disability likely to get worse in the next few years? 
 Would it be better to go for an automatic or power steering now? 
 &bull; 
 Will the rest of the family fit as well as all your requirements? 
 &bull; 
 What sort of adaptations would be required? 
 There are many ways in which a car can be adapted. 
 These include fitting an automatic gearbox, hand controlled brakes and accelerator, extending seat runners and moving foot pedals. 
 The application form asks if you require adaptations, and you must say what you need and why. 
 Motability forwards the form to Blackpool and within 4&ndash;6 weeks will inform you how much they will pay towards the costs. 
 It is important to realise that if you decide to get a car without using the Motability scheme you will have to pay the full costs of adaptations. 
 What is included in the contract hire scheme? 
 &bull; All maintenance and servicing apart from repair/replacement for damage caused by punctures. 
 &bull; 
 AA cover, including home start, relay and relay plus. 
 &bull; 
 Off the road insurance. 
 &bull; 
 The whole of the insurance premium. 
 The only running cost you will have to pay is for petrol. 
 What does the insurance cover? 
 It is fully comprehensive and covers the mobility supplement holder and two drivers nominated by the holder, so you don't have to be a driver to run a Motability car . 
 The only condition is that the driver has a clean licence and has the permission of the mobility supplement holder. 
 Only people with a good driving record may drive a contract hire car, and any driving conviction (other than for parking) must be reported to the insurance company. 
 What can the car be used for? 
 Many people are worried that it can only be used for the disable person. 
 Obviously in many cases the car is a &bquo;family car&equo; and as long as it is generally used for the benefit of the disabled person it can be treated as any normal family car. 
 It should also be noted that there is a mileage restriction over the three year period of 12,000 miles a year. 
 The Hire Purchase scheme 
 Almost any vehicle from an approved manufacturer can be supplied under this scheme. 
 You should understand, however, that under the Hire Purchase scheme all you are buying is the car itself. 
 Motability Finance Ltd provides a set of finance tables over 4&ndash;5 years, taking into account the rate of mobility supplement and current interest rates. 
 The top rate of finance, giving the whole of your mobility supplement for five years will not cover the cost of most cars, so you will have to find a substantial deposit. 
 Fully comprehensive insurance, maintenance and servicing costs etc. are also not included. 
 The range of adaptations possible on a hire purchase car, however, is greater that those available on the hire scheme. 
 Severely disabled people who need major adaptations to a car or van that is not available on the contract hire scheme are exempt from a car tax and VAT on both the vehicle and the conversion. 
 Further information 
 If you would like further information please write or telephone Motability Finance Ltd, Gate House, West Gate, Harlow, Essex CM20 1HR. 
 Telephone 0279 635666. 
 There is also a booklet &bquo;New Cars for War Pensioners&equo; for those in that category, and a scheme for the provision of used cars and powered wheelchairs. 
 A copy of the fuller article on Motability that appeared in the BLESMAG  can be obtained from RAFA Area Headquarters on receipt of a sae. 
 RAFA is grateful to BLESMAG  for permission to quote from and reproduce this article.  
 What's the food like here? 
 A quick taste of the RAF's food in 1991 
 I bet we all have some special memories of how RAF food tasted in OUR  days! 
 Indeed, many will recall what it was like to prepare RAF food. 
 May own efforts at making custard, on what I think was called a Hydra Burner, may have been forgotten by those who subsequently had to eat the awful stuff, but I am not likely to forget the watery culinary disaster! 
 There was not a lot of style about the way food was served either. 
 A Brooklands Museum friend recalled that while staging through Toulon in 1947, with eating irons and mess tins packed in their kit, they were served scrambled egg with a sausage stuck in it in their cupped hands!  
 Many will recall what wartime rations meant, and even if we never were eligible for an &bquo;Ops egg and bacon&equo;, we have all read about them. 
 &bquo;If you don't come back, can I have your egg?&equo; the aircrew are said to have joked. 
 How times changed &mdash; now someone would express their concern ove whether the thing had been cooked long enough to annihilate any salmonella! 
 To find out what the food was like in the RAF today I asked the Catering Branch to tell me how things were different from my days (the 1950's, I'm not that old!). 
 Well, just about everything is different. 
 For a start &bquo;Standard rate food charges are payable on a continuous basis by people in Marital Categories 3, 4 or 5 when they are occupying single accommodation, and also by personnel who are in receipt of Special Messing Allowance, Retail Messing Allowance or are accommodated under the Approved Board and Lodging Scheme. 
 Food charges at the Married Unaccompanied Food Charge Rate are payable by personnel in Marital Categories 1 and 2 when occupying single accommodation and also by those in receipt of the special allowances mentioned above in relation to Categories 3, 4 and 5&equo;. 
 Got that? 
 Well, never mind! 
 It seems that the Catering Officer gets &pound;1.43 per day per man or woman, and that each airman (or airwoman) contributes &pound;2.35 per day. 
 SNCO's and commissioned officers pay a bit more because they have a few gourmets amongst them! 
 So there is &pound;1.43 per day to feed an adult, and to ensure that a sound nutritionally-based diet is available with its appropriate calories and vitamins, and &pound;0.92 for associated heating, lighting and other administration charges. 
 With this kind of budget you don't have to ask whether the Catering Branch are doing a good, professional job &mdash; if it wasn't they would be having to organise domestic famine relief drops! 
 It would be impossible, of course, to offer the quality standard and the variety without the financial benefits of bulk purchasing. 
 Nowadays the Army and the RAF identify the food items and the quality standards they require for their menus (they work to a three or four week menu cycle to give them flexibility), and their requirements are then purchased on their behalf by the NAAFI purchasing organisation. 
 Standard specifications have been agreed for some products like hamburgers and meat pies, for example, and the NAAFI have the task of sourcing supplies for these and for all other items such as fruit and vegetables. 
 The Royal Navy, of course, does things differently! 
 Ration accounting is now a computerised orperation. 
 The computer programme (Carafe &mdash; Computer Assisted Ration Accounting and Food Evaluation) allows a wide range of management information to be available so that the efficiency and performance of staff and systems can be monitored. 
 The programme can tell the operator the costs  of menus and ingredients enabling better planning and budgetary control. 
 Following government policy on market testing, and so as to ensure that the MOD operates within the agreed financial and manpower budgets, some catering facilities on RAF units have been transferred to contract catering operations. 
 RAF Swinderby was &bquo;contractorised&equo; as far back as the 1960s because the ending of National Service led to a shortage of cooks and stewards and now ther are probably about a score of units which work a mainly 9&ndash;5 day, or where the numbers are fairly small, that may be most suitable for &bquo;contractorising&equo;. 
 Those that need round-the-clock support generally stay with the MOD. 
 All are kept under constant review to ensure that Service personnel (and the taxpayer) get the best value for money. 
 Various recent legal enactments covering food safety and the environment have required the Catering Branch to set up continues review procedures. 
 In under a year's time the Services will also lose Crown Immunity, so that will add to the vigilance that will be necessary. 
 The practical implications of these matters are very real and may escape some of us microwave aces, for example. 
 Frozen meals and a microwave oven may sound the answer to a quick meal for someone on shift work or nightflying. 
 If, however, the food or the equipment is not handled with professional care not only are people open to a health risk, but someone can get prosecuted! 
 Large quantities of frozen food are nowadays delivered regularly to stores and the Service must ensure that the temperature of the stock at the time of delivery is correct before it goes into the cold store. 
 Environmental Health Officers could soon be an even greater hypertension threat to the Catering Officer that this Orderly Officer ever was! 
 So there are some new facets to catering in the RAF today compared with even a few years ago. 
 Chips with everything there is not. 
 Healthy eating is in, and there is plenty of advice available about what is healthy eating. 
 The needs of vegetarians, or those with special diet requirements are met, and a reasonable variety of menus is provided. 
 The proof of the pudding as we all know is in the eating, and I thought where better to sample the pudding than at RAF Uxbridge. 
 RAF Uxbridge is the current holder of the Jolliffe Trophy, which is awarded to the unit that is judged to provide the best standard of catering for all three messes. 
 Clearly the RAF would be happy to show me their trophy-winners &mdash; while my cunning instincts told me that this would be the best place to do food-tasting! 
 Readers will appreciate that even if a combination of Sgt Bilko and the Roux Brothers was running the Cookhouse, with only &pound;1.43 to feed an adult with three meals a day it is not possible to challenge the Savoy Grill. 
 Uxbridge did me proud, however. 
 Their hospitality would doubtless have extended to me sampling the food in each of the three messes &mdash; but not wanting to risk either myself or the computer's Carafe programme developing hiccups, I enjoyed visiting each mess and settled for eating in the Sergeant's Mess. 
 In each mess the menu was sufficiently wide to make one dither a bit because there were several options that looked appetising. 
 I picked an individual Cottage Pie, because that is something I sometimes prepare at home and I think I know how good (or terrible!) it can be. 
 There must be quite a number of readers who have had Uxbridge Cottage Pie at some time &mdash; and I obviously cannot tell how the 1991 version compared with earlier versions &mdash; but I can say that I enjoyed this particular dish and that the taste and texture were very good. 
 It was nicely presented, moreover, and since I hadn't taken any eating irons with me I am pleased to report that nobody asked me to cup my hands together to take my Cottage Pie a la Toulon? 
 Nor was tea or coffee served a dollop of condensed milk for those who wanted it &bquo;au lait&equo;! 
 There is healthy eating available in today's RAF, and with messing committees to ensure that everyone has an opportunity to contribute their views and ideas, there seems wider appreciation of the skills of today's cooks and of the results that they achieve with their limited financial resources. 
 We all know how Service morale is closely related to the standard of food, so it is comforting to conclude that the RAF looks in pretty good shape in 1991. 
 The Editor is grateful for the help that was given to him by catering personnel at MOD Stanmore who supplied the photographs and RAF Uxbridge .  
 Scene from the Past 1 &mdash; Balloon Site Catering 
 Scene from the Past 2 &mdash; A Canadian Orderly Officer tentatively tastes the food while others watch with amusement. 
 A training session in progress 
 USAFA Visit 
 Mr John E Kittelson, National Vice President of the United States Air Force Association, visited the Headquarters at Grove Park with his wife Marcia on 19 July 1991. 
 During his visit he was briefed on the work of the Association by the Financial Secratary Sam Churchman and Mrs Wyatt, and took great interest in the Welfare work that we do. 
 After the briefing our visitors were entertained to lunch and presented with a plaque to commemorate the visit. 
 Mr and Mrs Kittelson live in Sioux Falls, South Dakota. 
 The photograph shows (l-r) Mrs Kay Wyatt, Mr Sam Churchman, Mr John Kittelson and Mrs Marcia Kittelson. 
 Wartime WAAF's become Hon F-16 pilots 
 A dozen wartime WAAFs this Summer paid a flying visit to the USA, attracting in the process some good publicity for the RAFA &mdash; for their hats which bore the RAFA Battle of Britain logo were much in demand! 
 Veterans of many WAAF reunions, the group decided to have a holiday together, and with kind help from Richard Branson and Virgin Airlines, spent two weeks in Florida. 
 Two US Air Force bases were visited &mdash; Homestead, Miami, and Patrick at Cape Canaveral. 
 At Homestead they were guests of the 482 Tactical Fighter Wing which recently had seen action in the Gulg, and It was here that each was given a certificate making them Honorary F-16 Fighter Pilots. 
 At T/Sgt John E Smith wrote: &bquo;You wouldn't have known these ladies served as mechanics and armourers in the Women's Royal Air Force beginning 52 years ago by the way they climbed up and the down the stairs at the control tower or scrambled up to the cockpit of an F-16&equo;. 
 The group managed to find time to visit Disneyland, the Epcot Centre and MGM Studios as well! 
 Three of the &bquo;Dainty Dozen&equo; (as the 482nd christened them) who had been MT drivers during the war drove the party around in a 12-seater minibus that flew Union Jacks to warn the unsuspecting American public that they were not used to driving on the wrong side of the road. 
 Two of the party, Katie Ball and Dorothy Smith also wrote and asked Air Mail  to give their exploits a mention. 
 Who could refuse the request of such ladies? 
 They are pictured at Gatwick before their Grand Tour. 
 Remembrance in Florida 
 Our thanks go to Mrs Margaret (Peggy) Kaye, a member of the Fareham Branch, and an ex-pat WAAF, who writes to us from Orlando, Florida to tell us of a moving memorial service that took place at Arcadia, Florida on 27 May 1991. 
 It is a story that fits in well with our article on the Structure of Remembrance in this issue of Air Mail . 
 The arrangements for the service were made by the Rotary Club of Arcadia, the service being held at the graveside of the British Plot in Oak Ridge Cemetery. 
 May organisations take part in this annual event, including Canadian Clubs, British and American Clubs, Scottish/American Clubs and many more to honour the young men who dies while serving at Flying Training Schools at Riddle Field, Clewiston and Carlstrom Field, Arcadia. 
 A great welcome was given to all the visitors by the Rotary Club, by the K-Post 11 of the American Legion Auxiliary, by the British Ceremony Committee and by the Mayor. 
 Floral tributes came from HM The Queen (The Royal Yacht was cruising in the Florida Straits), HM Government as well as many of the British and Canadian organisations in the US. 
 The Transatlantic Brides and Parents Association of Orlando also proudly laid a wreath. 
 With the Union Jack and the RAF Ensign at half-mast, with an aircraft flying overhead in salute while the Last Post was sounded, it was an emotional and meaningful moment for those participating in this act of remembrance. 
 &hellip; and Northern Ireland 
 The 50th anniversary of the death of the crew of a 50 Sqn Hampden was marked with a Service of Remembrance for the four who died and the dedication of a granite marker at the crash site. 
 At the memorial service at Blessington, Sir Nicholas Fenn, the British Ambassador, unveiled a plaque; also well represented were RAFA Branches, the British Legion and the Irish Army Air Corps. 
 Relatives of the four airmen had been traced by air historian, 14 travelling from England for this special occasion. 
 Paddy Sutton of the Lisburn Branch kindly send us this story which demonstrates that remembrance is a continuous process. 
 &bquo;Sailor&equo; Malan 
 On 17 September 1991, the Secretary General, Mark Tomkins represented the Association and its South African Area at the unveiling of a print of one of Gp Capt &bquo;Sailor&equo; Malan's air battles during the Battle of Britain. 
 Sailor Malan was one of many South Africans who served with great distinction in either the RFC or the RAF &mdash; including such names as Andrew Proctor VC, &bquo;Boetie&equo; Venter and S M Kinkead from World War I and &bquo;Pat&equo; Pattle, John Nettleton VC and Edwin Swaley VC from World War II. 
 The Association remembers with gratitude the contribution of South Africans in preserving the freedom we enjoy today.  
 HAUTE-SAVOIE RESISTANCE MUSEUM OPENS 
 HRH Queen Elizabeth, the Queen Mother, visited the Resistance Museum at Morette, shortly before its opening on 18 June. 
 Jeff Noble arranged the display sections illustrating SOE and RAF support. 
 Shown here is the Queen Mother looking at the display relating to Frank Griffiths, the sole survivor of a Halifax that was shot down on a supply mission, and who was successfully hidden by the local Resistance. 
 Group Captain Griffiths was a most welcome guest at the opening. 
 Also present was the Chairman and a number of members of the Swiss Branch who paraded their Branch Standard. 
 BLESS THE DOG! 
 Flt Lt Helen Brown and Sgt Norman Drake present the owner of &bquo;Bless&equo;, winner of the Locking Bolt Stakes with her trophy at the RAFA Charity Greyhound Meeting on 9 July at Wimbledon stadium. 
 &pound;5,000 was raised for the event. 
 (Photo David P Poole)  
 &hellip; and the Albatross Flying Club, too! 
 At the same venue that saw Bless performing for our benefit, the Albatross Flying Club of Berlin donated &pound;1,750 to the Association. 
 The sum was raised at a model aircraft flying display that was all but washed out through appalling weather. 
 The Club, however, made the best of it and handed the Station Commander RAF Gatow a cheque for DM10,000 that was to be split between SSAFA and RAFA. 
 The RAFALO at Gatow, WO C R Oliver presented a cheque for the Association's share to AVM Bill Bailey, Chairman of Central Council on the occasion of the Wimbledon meeting.  
 ROYAL TOURNAMENT '91 &mdash; A PHOTO RECCE BY AIR MAIL  
 WE are the Back Markers! 
 It's no more difficult that walking a tight-rope, sonny! 
 Arena rehearsal, with the Central Band of the RAF. 
 With the band too, being in mufti, one can pick out some of the five ladies who have recently joined the band. 
 A professional photographer really gets down to it&hellip; 
 The big moment arrives and everything is a spectacular success. 
 WELL DONE EVERYONE! 
 AREA and BRANCH News 
 Luxembourg 
 The Branch was recently visited by a Victor tanker of 55 Sqn. 
 This aircraft, which was much admired by the many members and friends of the Branch who came to see it, had been active during the Gulf conflict. 
 The crew was warmly welcomed, and promptly &bquo;mucked-in&equo; to help sell RAFA fund-raising goods. 
 They got so much satisfaction from helping the Association, in fact, that as this photo shows, they signed application forms for Life Membership! 
 Luxembourg thanks (l-r) Sqn Ldr R Druitt, Flt Lts P Jackson and D Mannion, F/Sgt J Dearden and Flt Lt E Billings, and looks forward to their next visit. 
 Abbots &amp; Kings Langley 
 This small branch &mdash; it has only 42 members &mdash; showed that something that is a little &bquo;out of the ordinary&equo; can prompt a very good public response to Wings Appeal. 
 Wings Organiser Bill Osgothorp arranged a 25-mile bike ride, two of the bikes being &bquo;penny-farthings&equo; and a third being a 1906 BSA. 
 The reward for the exersions of these intrepid cyclists was that they raised more than &pound;200. 
 Pictured left are Bill, his wife, the vehicles that made up the Antiques Roadshow and their energetic and skilful riders. 
 Beverley 
 At the end of WWII, the Beverley, East Yorks firm of Richard Hodgson's Tannery had a Memorial to those employees who lost their lives in the two world wars displayed on the outside wall of their social club. 
 Subsequently Jack Cooper, a member of the Beverley Branch fround that the name of his twin brother, Ernest, had been omitted. 
 Ernest had been killed in 1940 in an aircraft accident when on duty as a Drogue Operator. 
 The Branch decided, of the social club building had been acquired by the Beverley Borough Council, that the marble memorial should be cleaned, re-gilded and the name of E Cooper added. 
 The cost of the work was met by donations raised through the efforts of Branch Vice Chairman John Wortley. 
 At a ceremony on 17 August, the Mayor unveiled the renovated memorial, and it was re-dedicated by the Revd H A Hall of St Mary's Church Beverley; branch members of the RAFA, Royal British Legion and of the Green Howards Association attended with their standards. 
 Bangor 
 Earlier this year the Branch decided to make very substantial donations to the RAF Benevolent Fund and to Richard Peck House. 
 These two worthy causes are seen as being particularly close to Welsh hearts as Welfare Officers in the area appreciate the support that the RAF Benevolent Fund has given to persons in Wales, and as Richard Peck House is the nearest RAFA convalescent facility for people in North Wales. 
 The sum of &pound;25,000 was donated to each, the total of &pound;50,000 being possibly a record. 
 It should also be remembered that the Branch had already made a donation some 10 years ago of more than &pound;13,000 to Richard Peck House. 
 Norwich 
 At a well-supported social evening, attended by the Lord Mayor and Lady Mayoress of Norwich, the Officer Commanding RAF Neatishead and representatives from RAF Coltishall, RAF Swanton Morley and RAFA Diss Branch, the Branch was pleased to receive the Senior Branch Efficiency Trophy from the hands of AVM N S Howlett. 
 Photo show l-r Brian Fish, Hon Treasurer, AVM Howlett, Brian Marston, Chairman, and Frank Bennett, Hon Secretary. 
 Sydney 
 John Hopley writes of the RAFA participation in the Anzac Day parade and march-past. 
 This photograph shows the contingent after it passed the Cenotaph, with Jerry Jones DFC leading, John Higham, President of the Sydney Branch and Don McComish bearing the Standard. 
 Parade marshal Harry Foster is to the right of the unit. 
 Don McComish travels 1,000 miles from his home in Adelaide to perform the standard-bearing duty each year. 
 That is surely leading by example! 
 Newsletter competition 
 Entries for the Branch Newletter Competition should be received at Central Headquarters by December 31. 
 These should be either printed or duplicated and state how many issues are produced during the year. 
 Trophies will be presented at Annual Conference to the winning branch runners-up.  
 Swiss 
 The Swiss Branch, on the occasion of the 700th anniversary of the Swiss Confederation and the Branch's own 40th anniversary celebrated in style with Sussexdown's residents. 
 The Branch supported the running costs for this special day when they were to be hosts at Storrington. 
 Three committee members drove from Geneva to be present and in all some 17 Members and Friends of the Swiss Branch gathered at Sussexdown in the late morning of 1 August. 
 They were joined by Chief Welfare Officer Brenda McLaren and four guests, including Sir John Saverne, President of the South Western Area. 
 Everyone joined in to serve Swiss wine to the residents and then enjoyed a superb buffet prepared by Faye and her catering staff. 
 Hong Kong 
 Receiving a copy of the AGM Minutes from the Branch prompts Air Mail  to give a little space to describe the activities and efforts being made by the Branch Committee, a committee which has been virtually unchanged since the Branch was re-activated six years ago. 
 Such stalwarts as Chairman Peter Harris, Hon Treasurer and Welfare Officer Tom Smith and Hon Secretary Roger Draper continue to serve in spite of all the pressures of work in this uncertain environment. 
 Anyone who knows Hong Kong will appreaciate that spare time is at a premium there, and the efforts of those members who ensure that a successful branch exists deserves recognition and thanks. 
 The main event of 1990 was a programme of three concerts by the Central Road of the RAF. 
 These were organised by Roger Draper, and took place at The Hong Kong Arts Centre (17 Nov), The City Hall Concert Hall (21 Nov) and the Hong Kong Cultural Centre Concert Hall (25 Nov). 
 Clearly these involved Roger in a considerable amount of work, and at a time when Roger's wife was giving birth to their daughter in the UK! 
 What it is to have an understanding wife! 
 Profits from the concerts went to the RAF Benevolent Fund amd tp RAFA Welfare Funds. 
 A Sword of Excellence was presented to the Central Band through private donations by Branch members. 
 Understandably, the great issue in members' minds is what will the changes due in 1997 mean to them as individuals and to the Branch as an organisation. 
 The Branch is determined to take a positive approach and plans a full range of social and fund-raising activities for the year ahead. 
 Branch recruitment is of key importance, and it is good to report that Flt Lt C Harris, RHKAAF, has volunteered to help in this area. 
 May the Hong Kong branch find inspiration in the mottoes of both the RAF and the RAFA in the years to come.  
 Carlisle 
 The Carlisle Branch disposed of its Club and Branch premises during 1990. 
 As a result it has been possible to provide donations to both RAFA and other local charitable causes until a major RAFA project in the area is identified. 
 The Eden Valley Hospice is nearing completion in Carlisle; the Branch therefore decided to donate 10,000 to the Hospice Appeal for the purpose of furnishing and maintaining a room in the hospice and ensuring that the RAFA Club at Harraby is not forgotten. 
 At the same time donations were also made to the Eagle Lodge project and Dowding House, Moffat, with a further donation promised to the Cumberland Infirmary for extra portable X-ray equipment. 
 Pictured below are Carlisle RAFA Branch Treasurer John Watson (centre) presenting an Association plaque for the Harraby Room to Peter Whitley (left) the Chairman of the Eden Valley Hospice Appeal Fund, while Ken Dewar, Fund treasurer holds the &pound;10,000 cheque. 
 North Cornwall 
 The Branch recently presented a picture of a Bristol Blenheim to Launceston's twin town of Plestin-les-Greves. 
 Photographed above Branch President, Ben Crawley, hands over the picture to Mme Christianne Lagadec, the President of Plestin-les-Greves twinning association. 
 The event commemorated the courage of the villages of Plestin who helped the crew of an RAF aircraft to escape on 27 September 1941. 
 The village priest was arrested and later executed and deportation and death for other villagers also resulted. 
 The Branch PRO, Stuart Voden, would like to learn more about this particular story and the fate of aircrew &mdash; Englishman Francis Reece, Irishman William Smith and Canadian Douglas Appleyard. 
 Diss 
 For the second year running Diss &amp; District Branch have been awarded the Frank Larner Trophy for efficiency and a Wings Appeal &pound;1,000 break award. 
 Air Commodore Jeffery, President RAFA Eastern Area was at the Annual Dinner on 7 June to congratulate the branch on its achievements. 
 It is good to report that branch membership has increased by 46% over the last four years. 
 Bridgwater 
 On an evening in April, the Branch gave 65 Sqn ATC a plaque to mark the 50th anniversary of their inauguration. 
 Parents, friends and members of the Association were present, including AVM Sir John Severne and his wife. 
 Sir John presented cadets with a number of trophies, and Mrs R Webber presented WO Frank Crane with the Bill Webber Memorial Cup. 
 The photo shows Sir John flanked by Flt Lt Jim Lampard (CO of 65 Sqn ATC), WO Crane and trophy-winning cadets.  
 Stanley 
 The first Certificate of Appreciation to be awarded in the North Eastern Area was presented to Sam Parker earlier this year at the Branch AGM. 
 The presentation was made by Ken Richardson, the Branch President. 
 Sam has served the Stanley Branch for more than 30 years, filling such positions as Branch Secretary, Branch Treasurer, Membership Secretary and Entertainment Officer. 
 In leaner years, the branch might have folded without the hard work put in by Sam Parker, and the award of this certificate will be applauded by all who know him. 
 Airdale and Wharfedale 
 The Branch recently received the Wings Trophy, awarded annually to the branch which has made the most consistent progress in the Wings collection over the past 10 years, from North East Area Chairman Brian Wilkie. 
 Last year the Branch collected &pound;89.67 per head of membership. 
 Shown below is Branch Chairman Alan Furze receiving the trophy from the Area Chairman.  
 Bill Berry's Diary 
 Far East POW Appeal 
 With the approach of the 50th anniversary of the start of the war in the Far East, a special appeal has been launched. 
 Member Les Stubbs, who is also newletter editor of the Birmingham Far East Prisoners-of-War Association, has begun compiling a list of the 3,388 RAF personnel who survived captivity by the Japanese. 
 He already has about 700 of the names. 
 Les, with the active support of his wife Pam, has spent several years listing the 1,000 prisoners, 600 of them RAF and himself among them, who were drafted to Ambon from Java in April 1943. 
 His original appeal in Air Mail  reached no fewer than 40 of the 250 survivors of that grim episode in Far East war history. 
 In the course of their researches, Les and Pam discovered that the Ministry of Defence (Air) had no list of Far East survivors nor even a complete list of those captured by the Japanese. 
 The appeal now is for names, service numbers, squadrons or other units, country in which taken prisoner, countries in which held, and country of release. 
 Les lives at 143 New Road, Bromsgrove, Worcs, B60 2LJ. 
 His phone number is 0527 73452. 
 Ploesti raid 
 A planned remembrance reunion to mark the 50th anniversary of the low-level raid on the Ploesti oilfields in Romania in August 1943 has interested R G Crick of Welling, Kent. 
 He was then a flight sergeant with 104 Mobile Signals Unit in the Middle East. 
 &bquo;We were sent to a landing strip on the coast near Bardia to set up a listening post on a wavelength contained in sealed orders. 
 We were given three weeks to make ready and our curiosity was heightened when four American cypher sergeants from Headquarters Squadron, Middle East US Forces, were attached to our unit. 
 &bquo;On reaching our destination and opening the sealed orders, we discovered that other RAF units would provide refuelling, mechanical and medical services. 
 A landing strip was organised to provide emergency services for any of the aircraft that suffer damage or be short of fuel. 
 &bquo;Ours was a humble part of the operation but we were all full of admiration for the crews that carried out the raid in such difficult conditions.&equo; 
 Mr Crick has sent a full account of his involvement to Lt Col William Feder who has made an appeal for information to anyone concerned with the mission. 
 Col Feder is curator of the International B-24 Museum at Pueblo International Airport, Colorado. 
 Fitters Reunion 
 Eight engine fitters had their own reunion within the 1661 Heavy Conversion Unit reunion at Newark Air Museum. 
 All LACs, they were all from B Flight and all were billeted in Hut 107 (known as Goon Palace) at RAF Winthorpe. 
 Seen in the accompanying picture, they are: Back row, from left, Stan Cape, Ken Munday, Harry Eccles, Albert Daubney and Bill Sammonds; front, Ray Darney, Charlie Chase and Don Clarkson. 
 About 50, some from Canada, Australia, South Africa and USA, attended the reunion which was graced by a fly-past by the Battle of Britain Memorial Flight's Lancaster, City of Lincoln . 
 The reunion is held every two years and although this year's was intended to be the last, organiser John Gray of Plymouth, said: &bquo;Every time I say I'm not going to do it again, they twist my arm to plan another.&equo; 
 In fact, the attendance was better than that in 1989. 
 Lone Grave 
 While on a tour of Normandy earlier this year, I made a point of visiting and photographing the grave of Battle of Britain pilot Seageant H R J Barrow. 
 His is the only war grave in the churchyard adjoining the 11th century church at Colleville-sur-Mer. 
 It is within sight of the huge US military cemetery at Colleville St Laurent near Omaha Beach where 9,300 American soldiers and airmen are buried. 
 Sergeant Barrow, who came from Isleworth, Middlesex, died on 28 November 1940 aged 21. 
 He was reported missing on a wing patrol with 602 Squadron while flying Hurricane V6691. 
 His body was washed ashore on what was to become Omaha Beach. 
 His grave is not forgotten. 
 As reported in the Winter 1990 issue, it is cared for, beautifully I can report, by Pierre Regnault, a pre-war French airman who escaped to England in 1940, and enlisted in the RAFVR. 
 Pierre, who has a summer cottage at Colleville, looks upon the grave as part of his own family. 
 Honour at last 
 Three of our gallant Polish allies, two of them airmen and RAFA members, have been awarded the Polish Cross by the present Polish Government in recognition of their war efforts. 
 All from Exeter, where they settled after the war, the three are Joe Wasniowski, who was a flight mechanic with 317 (Wilenski) Hurricane and Spitfire Squadron; Ted Wijaszko, a radar techician with 307 (Lwowski) night fighter Squadron, which flew Defiants, Beaufighters and Mosquitos; and Stan Kadzielski, a naval gunner who came to Britain as a crew member of the destroyer Burza . 
 Joe was serving with the Polish Air Force when the Germans invaded his homeland and escaped to Britain via Romania, Lebanon, France, Casablanca and Gibraltar. 
 He says: &bquo;Although the medal has only recently been created, it was a proud and memorable day when we went to the Polish Embassy in London to receive it.&equo; 
 The medals were presented by Polish Foreign Minister Zdzislaw Rapacki accompanied by Ambassador Kochanowski. 
 Ted also received the Polish 1939 Defence Medal which Joe received at a ceremony last year. 
 Stan already holds the Norwegian Defence Medal, awarded for service in the Battle of Narvik.  
 Crete Memorial 
 News now of the unveiling of a fine memorial commemorating the 30 men of 30 Squadron and 20 men of 33 Squadron who died in the defence of Maleme airfield, Crete, in May 1941. 
 Forty-four of them have no known graves. 
 The memorial is on the slopes of Hill 107 where the few remaining officers and 200 men of both squadrons including mechanics, armourers, clerks and cooks, fought as infantry alongide New Zealand soldiers. 
 The memorial was unveiled on 25 May, the 50th anniversary, in the presence of 24 veterans, including the then squadron commanders. 
 Money for the memorial was subscribed by former members of both squadrons, friends and relatives of those killed and by a Cretan friend. 
 The 50 names are engraved on three granite tablets. 
 The memorial itself was designed by present and former members of the squadrons and the plans were drawn by students of the Reading College of Technology. 
 Air Vice-Marshal A D Dick, chairman of 30 Squadron Association, in an appeal for relatives to be made aware of the memorial's existence, recalls that Squadron Leader Edward Howell, the 33 Squadron commander, was critically wounded in the battle and nearly died. 
 The Germans evacuated him to Athens then to Salonika. 
 Some months later, though still very weak, he managed to escape to Turkey, mostly by walking. 
 Relatives can contact Air Vice-Marshal Dick at 44 St Peter's Avenue, Caversham, Reading. 
 More &bquo;dreams&equo;? 
 Member Johnny Day of Bexhill, envies the other member who after complaining to the Diary  that his service must have been a dream, was subsequently contacted by old colleagues. 
 &bquo;I have never found any of my old friends, despite scouring the columns of Air Mail ,&equo; he says. 
 He was a wireless operator of AMES 15063, served with other units and was also seconded to the Royal Corps of Signals and other Army units. 
 &bquo;I even found myself very briefly attached to the US 8th Army Air Force! 
 Maybe the frequent shifts were due to my having BO,&equo; Johnny suggests. 
 Anyone who can rekindle a friendship should write to him at Flat 11, Grove Court, Cooden Drive, Bexhill, Sussex or ring him at 0424&ndash;212456. 
 In similar vein, Stan Twigg, of Wigan, asked what happened to the wartime personnel of 105 Squadron. 
 &bquo;Surely a squadron with Hughie Edwards, VC, DSO, DFC as commander and the first squadron to have Mosquitos hasn't just faded away,&equo; says Stan who was an &bquo;erk&equo; wireless operator at Marham from July 1942 to April, 1943, and now lives at 46 Ingram Street, Springfield, Wigan. 
 It is from South Africa that Marjorie Pearson, No 8833346, writes to complain that there is never any mention of WAAF dental or medical orderlies. 
 Marjorie, who joined up at Sheffield in September 1939, joined Sheffield RAFA in 1946. 
 She and her husband are members of the Hottentots Holland, RAFA and now live at 23 Columbine Street, Nerina, Durbanville 7550, Cape Province. 
 While still on this theme, a friend who was a cook bemoans the lack of stories from or about those who kept us fed. 
 Perhaps some of the cooks who fought as infantry at Maleme, Crete, could drop us a line. 
 Appeal sequel 
 Two years ago I published an appeal by Mrs Mary Marsden, of Church Stretton, Shropshire, for news of any relatives of six airmen of 57 Squadron killed when their Wellington crashed at Staplefore, near Cambridge, on 3 September 1941, when returning from a raid on Frankfurt. 
 A memorial to them was unveiled in St Andrew's Church there 22 years ago, Mrs Marsden being then a member of the memorial committee. 
 The airmen were Sgt L T Hutchinson, RAAF, captain; Sgt F McNeill, RAF, second pilot; Sgt F K Crossley, RAF observer; Flt Sgt L T Lawson, RCAF, first W/T operator; Sgt A C Turgeon, RCAF, second W/T operator; and Sgt D E Soles, RCAF, air gunner. 
 Mrs Marsden tells us that by chance, Sgt Lawson's sister, who now lives at Beckenham, Kent, was in the church last Remembrance Sunday when, to her surprise, her brother's name was read out. 
 She had no idea there was a tapestry plaque made by the parishioners. 
 After the appeal in Air Mail , Mrs Marsden had calls from men who had known members of the crew. 
 She also sought the help of the Canadian High Commission and her appeal was forwarded to the Canadian Veterans Affairs Department, which has provided information on the three Canadians in the crew. 
 In the case of Sgt Soles, the Department said that Mrs Marsden's inquiry had resulted in the discovery that his widow, who had remarried by was now very ill, was entitled to have her widow's pension reinstated under new legislation and this had now been done. 
 Her husband said the extra 1,100 dollars a month would enable her to go into a private nursing home. 
 She would never have received the money but for Mrs Marsden's inquiry. 
 Brenner Mural 
 Another version of the story behind the mural on a covent in the Brenner Pass, first mention in the Summer Diary , has been provided Dick Bailey, of Credenhill, a serving member, also say the mural while on a coach tour last year. 
 He was told that soon after the official ceasefire in Europe in 1945, a Nazi of some notoriety was escaping through the pass and it was decided to try to annihilate him, the only means available being bombing. 
 There were civilian casualties followed by protests and condemnation of what was seen as a violation and atrocity. 
 &bquo;Maybe this is folklore/legend but it's another version and I too would be interested to hear the authentic account,&equo; says Dick. 
 Maybe some member can provide it? 
 French Pilgrimage 
 One of our members with his own special interest in the area has visited and photographed five RAF graves in the village churchyard at Gouesnou, just north of Brest. 
 Freddie Crewe, of Maidstone, who left the RAF as a squadron leader in 1962, flew Hurricanes and Spitfires in the war and was shot down near Brest on 3 August 1943. 
 He went to Gouesnou during a recent visit to meet friends who helped him to evade capture for a time. 
 Four of the graves are those of a 98 Squadron Mitchell bomber crew who died on 24 June 1943 and the other is that of a Typhoon pilot of 266 Squadron who crashed the same day as Freddie Crewe. 
 The five are buried in adjoining graves, the Typhoon pilot, Plt Off R K Thompson, just a little apart from the others. 
 Next to him is the Mitchell observer, Flt Sgt E L Reed, then the pilot, Fg Off J P Toeg, the wireless operator, Flt Sgt T Ellis and the gunner, Sgt J Glover. 
 Mr Crewe will be pleased to provide photographs for any next-of-kin or relatives. 
 His address is 2a Birchwood Road, Poplar Grove, Maidstone, Kent ME16 OBB.  
 Belgian Ceremony 
 Through the initiative of a Belgian, Cynrik de Decker, seven members of 90 Squadron Association have attended a ceremony of remembrance to the seven crew of Stirling EH907 (WP-O) which crashed on 4 July 1943. 
 The crew were Flt Sgt M Morrison, pilot; Sgt A P McGinley, navigator; Sgt C Reddell, air bomber; Sgt W MacGuire, wireless operator; Sgt A Leonard, mid-upper gunner; Sgt C H Fenton, rear gunner; and Sgt M Scheddle, engineer. 
 The bomber, one of 10 from Wratting Common assigned to a raid on Cologne exploded over the village of Moortsel and fell in pieces in fields. 
 Six of the crew were found dead in the fuselage and the rear gunner, Sgt Fenton, was found in the tail some distance away, barely alive. 
 He died soon afterwards. 
 Cynrik has spent some years researching the crash and succeeded in tracing Sgt Fenton's younger brother, Raymond. 
 A local committee was set up to organise a remembrance weekend, publish a book telling the story of WP-O and arrange a small exhibition. 
 Raymond Fenton joined the seven from 90 Squadron Association, who were accompanied by our Eastern Area standard bearer, R Pearson. 
 The party first visited the Mariakerke Cemetery at Ghent, where the crew are buried, then attended a service at Moortsel church. 
 A memorial plaque was then unveiled by Raymond Fenton and the group walked across the fields to where WP-O fell. 
 A Union Jack flew over the exact spot and George Jeffery, of Bury St Edmunds, laid a poppy wreath on behalf of the squadron. 
 Belgian veterans also laid a wreath. 
 George praises the hospitality and warmth of welcome extended by the Belgians. 
 The recent picture shows the ceremony at the crash site, the other was taken secretly on the day of the disaster. 
 Are you here? 
 Also from Belgium comes an appeal for any information about the six men seen in this picture. 
 They are believed to have worked in the officers' mess of a signals unit posted to Moortsel, a village near Tervuren, 10 miles east of Brussels, in September 1944. 
 They left the following month. 
 The picture belongs to M de Bijser, of Langestraat 53, 30400 Neerijsen, Belgium, who says the six were entertained in his family's home at Moortsel. 
 Unfortunately, their names are not known. 
 Through a member of our Belgian branch, he was advised to seek Air Mail'  s help in tracing any of the six. 
 &bquo;We are grateful to them for helping to liberate Belgium,&equo; he says. 
 Station mags 
 My item about station magazines in the Summer issue has prompted Clifford H Frost of Torquay branch to send a copy of The Tiger Rag , the official magazine of No 5 Air School, Witbank, Transvaal. 
 Clifford says that when he and Flt Sgt L Lewis suggested the idea of a magazine to the station commander, Wing Commander Leslie Bennet, MC, he gave them every encouragement and support. 
 Lewis was the first editor and the first issue appeared early in 1943. 
 The venture was well supported by local advertisers. 
 &bquo;It so happened that No 5 Air School was not far away from the mine where Churchill hid during the Boer War,&equo; Clifford recalls. 
 &bquo;The mine manager showed us a gold watch which Churchill gave to his father for hiding him. 
 An article about this appeared in The Tiger Rag  and a copy was sent to Downing Street and duly acknowledged. 
 When John Colville, Churchill's secretary, joined the RAF, he was sent to Witbank for flying training.&equo; 
 Harrogate branch member H Sawyer still has a February 1945 copy of Delta, published in Calcutta for 180 Wing, South East Asia Air Forces. 
 He also has an April 1945 copy of Victory , published by the Government of India in New Delhi. 
 &bquo;I did have a copy of Boost , a monthly magazine published from late 1942 for 212 (Catalina) Squadron based at Korangi, south of Karachi. 
 I handed it to a former flight engineer of 213 when I visited him in Toronto some years ago. 
 He came over to last year's boat reunion at Pembroke Dock.&equo; 
 BB   
 Wexford House 
 Formal Opening 
 In October 1986 Central Council approved a proposal made by Air Vice-Marshal Bill Gill that Eagle Lodges should be developed as welfare facilities for the Association. 
 On 24 June 1991 Air Chief Marshal Sir Michael Graydon, Air Officer Commanding in Chief Strike Command, formally opened the Association's first Eagle Lodge at Wexford House, Melton Mowbray. 
 It was most appropriate that Bill Gill and his wife Mary were present at the ceremony. 
 On his arrival the AOC in C inspected a Guard of Honour mounted by No 1279 Squadron Air Training Corps and was met by our President Air Chief Marshal Sir Joseph Gilbert, the Chairman of Central Council Air Vice-Marshal Bill Bailey and the Chairman of RAFA Housing Ltd Roy Kendrick. 
 In their speeches both our President and the AOC in C drew attention to the close links between the Association and the serving Royal Air Force. 
 With Wexford House situated in what was the heart of Bomber Command during World War II it is very fitting that it will honour in particular the men and women of that Command. 
 It was equally fitting that following the opening, the Battle of Britain Memorial Flight Lancaster flew over Wexford House in salute. 
 After the ceremony Sir Michael and Lady Graydon circulated amongst the guests and met the residents before partaking of an excellent buffet lunch provided by RAF Cottesmore &mdash; another example of the support given by the serving RAF. 
 Because of the constraints of space, the number of guests had to be severely limited but during the afternoon more visitors were invited to look around the Lodge and see for themselves this latest jewel in the Association's welfare crown. 
 Tea was served and a Tornado flew past &mdash; both events again thanks to RAF Cottesmore. 
 The Association has a total of three Eagle Lodges in operation, the others being Woodford House in Southport and The White House in Bexhill-on-Sea.  
 Top: Carly Bowes the eight-year-old daughter of the Relief Housekeeper, presents a posy to Laydy Graydon. 
 Above: Air Chief Marshal Sir Michael and Lady Graydon with some of the residents. 
 Back row (l-r) Ken Jeffries, Sam Mann, Alf Rippin, Lady Graydon and Sir Michael. 
 Front row (l-r) Mary Wilson, Doug Park, Edith Holder. 
 Left: RAFA President, Sir Joseph Gilbert, welcomes the guests. 
 Berlin bale-out &mdash; and escape! 
 As told to Leslie Hunt 
 The night of 31 August/1 September 1943 say Berlin heavily bombed. 
 A Halifax of 158 Sqn Lissett had both its port engines and fuselage set ablaze by night fighters. 
 Ken Ward gave orders to bale out saying how sorry he was that he'd got his crew into this mess! 
 Flight engineer Harry Simister followed wireless operator, bomb aimer and navigator through the hatch, feeling a terrific pull on his legs as he fell through space, and realised his harness was not properly adjusted. 
 He was reliever to feel a slight tug as the parachute eventually opened; it was bitter cold but fortunately he was being blown away from the capital's fires, and after drifting for a time, hit the ground &bquo;like a wet sack&equo;. 
 Harry knew he'd been hit in the aircraft, feeling now the wetness of blood inside his shirt and trousers, although the wounds didn't hurt, only causing numbness. 
 He was in a field, and picked out what he thought was a wood, to which he headed and placed his unwanted gear in a ditch, covering it with tufts or grass. 
 Within a clump of trees he lay down, trying to sleep. 
 Dawn came and he, determined not to be taken prisoner, removed his brevet, stipes and badges, plus his battledress pockets, using his escape-kit knife. 
 Burying the &bquo;evidence&equo; he smeared the telltale marks on his blouse with mud, reluctantly cutting off the tops of his flying boots, hoping that the small holes in his uniform, from shrapnel, would pass unnoticed. 
 Startled by a sudden noise he looked out to see a Junkers Ju 88 flying low but, luckily, into mist. 
 Skirting the wood he walked for hours, resting after spotting potato-pickers and distant houses. 
 When darkness came he ventured out, selecting a large potato &mdash; which tasted awful although he ate it all. 
 Smoking the first of five cigarettes from his case which had been undamaged in his rear pocket (matches from escape kit) Harry made up his mind to head for a port, walking north-westerly to avoid Potsdam. 
 Coming into a village he brazenly replied to a child's &bquo;Heil Hitler&equo; with something entirely different! 
 For his second night Harry used his helmet and legs of his flying boots as a pillow, and woke up with uncontrollable shivering. 
 At dawn he walked again, and coming to a boating lake he drank from it like a horse, and filled his rubber bag. 
 Now with the bag in one side of his blouse, and helmet and leggings in the other, he felt (and looked!) like a woman. 
 Some 30 miles from Berlin he comtemplated hitch-hiking, but rejected it, trudging along and coming upon allotments with apple trees. 
 Risking everything he grabbed two tomatoes and the biggest apples before bedding down for another night under cover of trees. 
 Next day, footsore, he saw a bicycle beside a house and, with nobody in sight, he quickly mounted it and rode &bquo;like the clappers&equo;, feeling that every time a car passed him, it might be the police. 
 After two or three hours, Harry say a sign indicating that Hamburg was 300 kilometres away, and he took this road as he knew Lubeck might be an alternative if no vessels for Sweden were berthed in the larger port. 
 That night he was woken by planes and saw flares over Berlin, bringing a moment of &bquo;homesickness&equo; that he wasn't up there too. 
 Next day, in Schwerin, after drenching rain, he listened to a band, German soldiers ignoring him, and restocked with apples, standing on the cycle's crossbar to reach them. 
 By nightfall he believed he was 30 miles from Lubeck, so next morning he headed for the port along with workpeople. 
 Most ships had the German flag, but one with a blue cross on white Harry thought must be Swedish or Finnish. 
 German soldiers guarded the coal wagons into which this ship was unloading, but Harry attracted the attention of crew members on deck and, nodding to the German nearest, boldly strode up the gangway, showing his RAF-decorated cigarette case to the crew and asking if any spoke English. 
 One who did listened intently to Harry's story and told him that the Germans inspected all sections of the vessel before sailing. 
 In the galley, Harry had his first meal for six days, before being given some bread and butter and cigarettes and being advised to return in two days, just before the ship sailed. 
 Retrieving the cycle, Harry found the time passing slowly to nightfall, but next day, needing water, he went into Lubeck, passing by an aircraft factory where Dornier 217 fuselages were being worked on. 
 Heading for the same ship again, he was once more ignored by the guards and was fed by the crew before being told to return the next day. 
 One can imagine his dismay when he returned to the port and found the ship had gone &mdash; either earlier than planned or because the crew didn't want to be caught helping him. 
 His spirits sank, but after trying another non-German ship without success, he remembered being briefed that Rostock was worth trying. 
 So, with a tail wind, he began the 130/140 miles, picking some carrots and apples en-route, and noticing the barrage balloons that were protecting the factories. 
 Rostock's Heinkel works came into view as darkness fell, and in the small docks Harry could see swastika-flagged vessels and a couple of U-boats. 
 Half awake, he was hailed by a guard for, inadvertently he'd cycled through the entrance gates, so he quickly turned and pedalled away with heart churning. 
 That night he slept in an old cardboard box that he'd found, and that gave him some protection from the chilling morning dew. 
 Finding no neutral ships on the eighth day, Harry risked entering a cafe, proferring a French note from his escape kit, for cigarettes. 
 He was asked for &bquo;coupon&equo; which caused his  hasty retreat. 
 A second cafe also refused the French note but gave him drink and black bread. 
 That night he boarded a small ship flying a Finnish flag and fell asleep in the deserted wheelhouse. 
 He was awakened by a seaman who told him that the ship would not be leaving for seven days, and there would be no place for him to hide as timber was being loaded under German supervision. 
 After a night in a shelter, very wet and depressed, Harry got out his maps and decided to try to cycle to Holland where patriots might help him. 
 Going via Hamburg, Harry now had troubles in the form of a punctured front tyre, and &bquo;tummy-trouble&equo; resulting from a surfeit of apples and vegetables. 
 He made good use of every piece of newspaper that he could pick up and every convenient hedgerow! 
 He continued through Bremen to Osnabruck. 
 A derelict house was &bquo;home&equo; for the eleventh night; next day wayside milk churns and orchards compensated for his saddle-sore state. 
 Panic set in on the twelfth day when, after &bquo;lifting&equo; milk, a lorry picking up the churns stopped, the driver beckoning Harry. 
 &bquo;Papers&equo; the man said &mdash; to which Harry replied &bquo;Dutchman&equo;. 
 Just as Harry was preparing to aim a kick at this driver where it might hurt, the man offered him more milk, saying that he was a Frenchman doing forced labour and had recognised Harry's RAF uniform &mdash; by now extremely unsuitable for pay parade! 
 Now near the Dutch frontier, Harry felt it might be an idea to cross from Germany by climbing into a wagon in a marshalling yard, but after a tedious wait when nothing moved he returned to his cycle and was soon in sight of the red and white border posts. 
 As cyclists ahead were made to dismount and show documents, Harry left the road, took a cart track into woods and crossing fields rejoined the main road again. 
 In minutes he was, at last, in Holland, riding through sleepy Oldenzaal, and shortly afterwards in Hengelo. 
 Seeing a youth of about 17 about to cycle away, Harry whispered that he was RAF and did he know anyone who could help. 
 Luckily the lad spoke a little English, telling Harry to cycle on and he would overtake for Harry to follow at a distance. 
 At some allotments he went to a shed, with Harry following. 
 Inside he asked many questions, before telling Harry that he would be safe there that night, and that he would bring food and, if possible, soap and razor. 
 Over the next two days, Harry cycled through Zutphen and Arnhem to Eindhoven, where a cafe owner gave him coffee and rolls, and a priest, who was a friend of the cafe proprietor advised Harry who was now headed for the Dutch/Belgian border. 
 At Borkel-en-Schaft, in another cafe, Harry showed his RAF cigarette case and notes that Dutch friends had prepared for him, and he was taken to a back room for food, and to have his blood-stained shirt and vest washed. 
 Soon he was in Belgium and facing a committee of patriots who knew only too well how the Gestapo had infiltrated supposed POWs into organisations. 
 Whilst Harry's replies were being vetted, his photo was taken for a false identity card, and his uniform and shoes exchanged for a civilian outfit. 
 Space does not allow a full description of Harry's successful progress from Brussels (as Jean Henri de Smat, a deaf and dumb basket maker) and then through France, to Switzerland, which Harry eventually reached on 14 October 1943. 
 Here he could have seen out the war, but he, and Reg Wallace, another RAF evader, &bquo;escaped&equo; into France and joined the Maquis. 
 After the Americans landed in the south, Harry and Reg &bquo;hitched&equo; a flight via Corsica to Naples, found the British Army, and then flew to Tunis, Algiers, Oran and Casablanca before arriving back at St Eval, Cornwall courtesy of RAF Coastal Command. 
 It was a year and ten days after bailing out over Berlin! 
 Harry Simister was awarded a well-merited Military Medal and flew with Transport Command, dropping food and bringing back POWs. 
 He was able to re-visit many of his helpers. 
 He later joined British European Airways and the RAF Escaping Society. 
 Perhaps one day the full story of Harry's epic journey from the skies over Berlin to St Eval's runway will be told.  
 Rough map showing Harry Simister's long return leg from Berlin. 
 The Structure of Remembrance 
 How do we remember? 
 What process is it that goes on in our brains that enables us to recall people and past events? 
 None of us can remember everyone we've met, everything we've done, and yet most can store away in their memory the things that we want to remember. 
 Things that we don't want to remember may be indelibly engraved on the mind, little eroded even by time, but million of unimportant things are blissfully forgotten &mdash; which is just as well for our mental health! 
 Our society and culture, together with our spiritual awareness, has built a structure over the years to help us remember those people and events that have done much to determine the kind of lives we live today, and that part of the structure that relates to the Royal Air Force has, of course, a special interest for our Association. 
 The main features of the structure are the cemeteries and memorials of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission, the Air Forces Memorials by the Thames at Runnymede and on the Embankment, and those within the Church of St Clement Danes in the Strand. 
 There are, of course, many other important memorials in the UK and in &bquo;foreign fields&equo;, a number of which have been mentioned in earlier editions of Air Mail . 
 The Commonwealth War Graves Commission was established by Royal Charter in 1917 &mdash; while the First World War was still being fought. 
 Its duties are to mark and maintain the graves of the members of the forces of the Commonwealth who died in the two world wars, to build and maintain memorials to the dead whose graves are unknown, and to keep records and registers. 
 The cost is shared by the governments of Australia, Britain, Canada, India, New Zealand and South Africa in proportions based on the numbers of their graves. 
 In fact there are 141 countries in which there are Commonwealth war graves and memorials, and the Commission is responsible for 1,694,930 commemorations. 
 Almost all of the cemeteries and memorials are maintained by the Commission's own staff. 
 The care of the war graves in civil cemeteries and churchyards is generally entrusted to local and church authorities who maintain them in agreement with the Commission. 
 The work is founded on the principle that each of the dead should be commemorated individually by name either on the headstone on the grave or by an inscription on a memorial. 
 Each headstone is 32in high and of uniform appearance (no distinction is made on account of military or civil rank, race or creed). 
 In some cemeteries, particularly overseas where there may be a risk of earth movement, stone or bronze plaques on low pedestals are used instead of headstones. 
 Two monuments are common to the cemeteries: the Cross of Sacrifice, usually on an octagonal base and with a reversed Crusader's sword on its shaft, and, in the larger cemeteries, the Stone of Remembrance upon which is carved &bquo;Their Name Liveth for Evermore.&equo; 
 With cemeteries to maintain all over the world it is nor surprising that a variety of arrangements, contracts and agreements have had to be set up to ensure proper care and maintenance. 
 In many far off lands the Commission's gardeners have no knowledge of the English language, while their supervisors are not fluent in the native tongue; the result has been, so the Commission reports, that a form of hybrid speech has developed in certain countries that would be incomprehensible to other natives of the country and to ordinary English-speakers, but which is &bquo;very eloquent&equo; on matters relating to cemetery maintenance! 
 The Air Forces Memorial at Runnymede, Surrey, is also one of those memorials which is a responsibility of the Commonwealth War Graves Commission. 
 In recognition of the enormous contribution that their Service had made to the successful conclusion of WWII, the Air Council set up after the war a war memorial committee. 
 In memory of the fallen, the RAF decided to rebuild a London church &mdash; St Clement Danes &mdash; but more of that later. 
 Such a memorial, however, was not likely to satisfy Catholics, Jews and members of other denominations so the RAF sought the help of the CWGC. 
 It was decided to build a separate memorial to the airmen who were lost in WWII during operations from bases in the UK and North West Europe, and who have no known grave. 
 The included not only airmen from the Commonwealth, but also those from Europe whose countries had been overrun but whose airmen  fought in the squadrons of the RAF. 
 Runnymede offered a most appropriate site for such a memorial on account of its historical associations and its closeness to London and Heathrow. 
 The Principal Architect of the CWGC, Sir Edward Maufe, conceived the design of the Runnymede memorial. 
 He was deternined to use the dramatic location and its views to make a powerful memorial rather than to build a lofty edifice that would dominate the skyline. 
 His objective was to create an atmosphere of quiet and intimacy, so he made a garden, then a cloister and a shrine. 
 The cloister includes panels that list the names of 20,435 airmen, grouped according to the year of death. 
 The structure is in Portland stone with Westmoreland green slate roofs, while the Shrine itself is a square tower that is, coincidentally, slightly reminiscent of an airfield control tower. 
 Without doubt, Sir Edward achieved his objective, and the Air Forces Memorial at Runnymede is a beautiful tribute. 
 The Royal Air Force Memorial on the Victoria Embankment was built in 1923. 
 The Royal Air Force Memorial Fund (later to become the RAF Benevolent Fund) had originally hoped to erect a memorial on ground between Westminster Abbey and St Margaret's Church, but they had been unable to get permission. 
 It was the Office of Woods and Forests which offered the RAF the site at the head of the Whitehall Stairs on Victoria Embankment, and the Memorial Fund gratefully accepted the offer. 
 The monument is fortuitously under the windows of the Ministry of Defence and under the gaze of Lord Trenchard whose statue was placed in Whitehall Gardens in 1956. 
 Furthermore, as the gilded eagle seems poised for take-off to do battle with enemy hordes coming from the south-east, the memorial seems to have anticipated most aptly the events that followed 17 years after its unveiling. 
 It is entertaining to learn, therefore, that the original design had the eagle facing inwards, ie to the north-west! 
 The Portland stone bears a few battle scars from the Blitz as well as the inscription from the Book of Exodus: 
 &bquo;I bear you on eagles wings 
 And brought you unto myself.&equo; 
 The Blitz reduced the ancient church of St Clement Danes to gutted and smoking ruin on the night of 10 May 1941. 
 Thus was begun another chapter in the extraordinary history of St Clement Danes &mdash; a history that goes back until the time of King Arthur, who expelled the Danes from the city of London but allowed those with English wives to settle just outside the city walls. 
 St Clement, chosen by the Danes as the Patron Saint of their church, was martyred by being tied to an anchor and dropped in the sea &mdash; which explains why the symbol of today's church shows an anchor surmounted by an eagle. 
 Work was started on the restoration of the bombed church in 1956, substantial funds being raised by the RAF, Commonwealth and Allied Air Forces, as well as from civilian benefactors. 
 The church was reconsecrated in the presence of HM the Queen in October 1958 as the Central Church of The RAF. 
 A Latin inscription on the ceiling high above the chancel tells how this church was built by Sir Christopher in 1682, was destroyed by aerial bombardment in 1941 and was restored by the RAF in 1958. 
 Books of Remembrance record the names of over 125,000 and women who gave their lives in the Service, and Roll of Honour commemorates over 19,000 US airmen who died on active service while serving in the UK. 
 Nearly 800 Unit and Squadron badges are embedded in the floor; they are of Welsh slate, many the work of Madge Whiteman. 
 The church is full of exquisite works of craftmanship which have been donated by individuals and by air forces. 
 Standing high in the nave is the pulpit attributed to Grinling Gibbons. 
 During the war it had been stored (for safety!) in the crypt of St Paul's Cathedral, where it suffered from the effects of high explosive. 
 The pulpit was marvellously restored restored to its former glory and is further evidence that the powers of creation can surmount even the most destructive forces of mankind. 
 In the crypt is a simple chapel, the stone altar was the gift of the Netherlands Air Force, the black granite font the Norwegians, the candelabrum came from the Belgian Air Force. 
 St Clement Danes is a place of pilgrimage for many who come to see the incribed names in the Memorial Books of those whom they have lost. 
 Fresh pages are turned each day, keeping memories alive. 
 Each year the Royal Air Forces Association pays homage to this Church of the RAF to all of the RAF family who have died. 
 The church of St Clement Danes, the RAF Memorial on the Victoria Embankment, the Runnymede Air Forces Memorial and the thousands of graves carefully tended by the Commonwealth War Graves Commission provide us with a structure of remembrance. 
 To this framework people may add their own memorials to their loved ones, while the Association can ensure that memorials can benefit the living through undertaking projects such as Eagle Lodges and providing homes for the sick and elderly. 
 Both individually and collectively we are given many opportunities to achieve that part of the Association's Dedication that announces &bquo;We shall remember them.&equo;  
 The Shrine of the Air Forces Memorial, Runnymede, Surrey. 
 Floral tributes decorate the cloisters at Runnymede. 
 The Royal Air Force Memorial on the Victoria Embankment, London. 
 The organ of St Clement Danes, donated by the USAF. 
 Regroup and remember 
 1993, 1994 and 1995 will mark the 50th anniversaries of some of the greatest, most notorious battles and victories of this century. 
 The Allied Bomber Campaign, the Dambusters Raid, the liberation of Rome, the Battle of the Bulge and of course D-Day to name but a few. 
 All were momentous events that will never be forgotten, least of all by the men and women who fought in them. 
 To commemorate these key events in world history, Saga is looking into organising various reunions and commemorative tours, gathering together those who fought so gallantly to revisit and remember those events of nearly 50 years ago. 
 Saga has been specialising in quality holidays for the older generation for 40 years now. 
 Over this time we have continuously expanded and developed our range, with the highest priority always placed on value for money and customer care. 
 Our Group Sales Department specialises in organising holidays, reunions, weekend breaks and conferences specifically tailored to individual group requirements. 
 Our buying power with major hotel chains means that we can put together an excellent package, complete with rail and coach fares, and we also look after all the administration of the holiday. 
 If your group or association would be interested in a tour based around any of the events listed opposite, please tick the coupon appropriately. 
 However if there is a particular occasion we have missed, we would be happy to organise a special tour to your specifications. 
 If this is the case, please indicate under &bquo;Others&equo; on the coupon. 
 Individuals who wish to travel alone or in small groups may refer to Saga's latest brochures, whick contain details of holidays to all of these countries, though obviously not to the specific locations. 
 Our UK Hotels and Short Break brochures feature resorts and hotels which are particularly suitable for reunions and conferences. 
 You may use the coupon to indicate which of these brochures you are interested in. 
 All Saga brochures are free. 
 If you would like further details of our reunions, conferences and holidays, simply cut out and return the coupon to Gloria Nielsen, Group Sales, Saga Holidays Ltd., FREEPOST, Folkestone, Kent, CT20 1BR. 
 No stamp is required. 
 Alternatively if you would like to speak to someone about your specific requirements, freephone Gloria Nielsen on 0800 300 666 and she will be able to answer any questions you many have. 
 Yes! 
 I would be interested in receiving details on the following: ( please tick ) 
 1942 
 St. Nazaire Raid 
 Award of George Cross to Malta 
 Dieppe Raid 
 Battle of El Alamein 
 Allied Bombing Campaign 
 1943 
 Allies enter Tunis 
 Dambusters Raid 
 Sicily landings 
 Allies land at Salerno 
 Allies take Naples 
 Monte Cassino 
 1944 
 Glider Assaults on Burma 
 Rome liberated 
 Allies break out at Anzio 
 D-Day 
 Arnheim 
 Battle of the Bulge 
 British recapture Rangoon 
 Berlin falls 
 Others ( please specify)  
 INDIVIDUAL TRAVEL 
 Europe and Mediterranean 
 Traveller's World 
 REUNIONS AND CONFERENCES 
 UK Hotels 
 Short Breaks 
 Mr/Mrs/Miss/Mr &amp; Mrs Address Postcode Telephone Number Sqn/Ass Other 
 SAGA  
 Letterbox 
 Canadian Reunion 
 In 1941 I was trained as a Navigator/Radio in the RAF and was eventually sent to an OTU where I crewed up with a Canadian pilot, Bob Tidy of Toronto. 
 We were trained in nightfighter techniques, using airborne radar. 
 We were then posted to 406 Sqn RCAF where we converted to Beaufighters. 
 We stayed with 406 Sqn for 18 months, a normal tour of duty at that time for nightfighter crews, and were then posted to an English squadron on Bomber Support work. 
 We left 406 in October 1943, and that was the last I heard of them until I received my Spring 1991 issue of Air Mail  when I spotted that 406 Sqn were having a 50th Anniversary Celebration and Reunion in earlyh May at Shearwater Forces Base, Dartmouth, Nova Scotia. 
 I phoned the squadron at their base and immediately booked a flight to Halifax NS. 
 I flew over on 6 May. 
 I will not try to describe everything that went on. 
 I would take too long and use too much paper, but it was fantastic! 
 I was treated like a long lost brother! 
 About 150 former squadron members attended the official banquet (I had earlier been asked to propose the Toast the the Squadron), there was a Squadron Parade, the dedication of a cairn to mark the 50 years and a flypast of present day aircraft. 
 I was the only Englishman present, but if any English members of 406 Sqn should read this I hope they will contact me. 
 Leonard (Tiny) Giles, 1 Eaton House, Priesty Court, Howey Lane, Congleton CW12 4AH.  
 OZ Hospitality 
 My wife and I returned recently from a visit to our son in South Australia, and whilst there we paid several visits to the local RAFA branch. 
 The Chairman, Charles Holmes, Vice Chairman Frank Scott, Secratary John Potter, their wives and all the other members we met gave us an exceptionally warm welcome and instantly made us feel at home. 
 It was in April when we arrived and I was invited to join branch members in the Anzac Day Parade in Adelaide. 
 Prior to the parade, RAFA members joined ex-service and serving members of the RAAF at a memorial service at Adelaide Airport. 
 Gp Capt Gilbert, Commanding Officer of the Base Support Wing of the local Edinburgh RAAF Station was present, and wreaths were laid by the various association and units represented in front of plaques of squadrons and units of the RAAF which served in WWII. 
 After the service we were taken to the centre of Adelaide for the main parade. 
 In the region of 8,500 serving and ex-service members of the Forces marched that day, and I felt privileged to be among them. 
 Later we returned to the RAFA Branch HQ, where ladies of the branch had been very busy preparing food for members, and this was followed by a Tea Dance. 
 We were made so welcome that the evening of our last visit to the Club was a sad one, but we have happy memories of our time with the 1200th Branch. 
 Any members who find themselves in the Adelaide area can be assured of a warm welcome there. 
 Howard Cload, Newton, Swansea, W. Glamorgan.  
 Battle of Britain Memorial 
 There have veen &bquo;snippets&equo; in the national press of a possible impressive memorial to be sited on the cliffs above Dover to commemorate the Battle of Britain. 
 As an ex-member of 64 Squadron I would appreciate this recognition of a memorable period of RAF history. 
 However, as we ex-Service members are constantly involved in appealing to the genral public for financial donations to our appeals, would it not be prudent to keep the expense of any such memorial to the minimum? 
 A well-equipped sheltered housing scheme or rest home, suitably named &bquo;Battle of Britain House&equo; could well serve the same purpose. 
 Any comments from our members? 
 H W (JB) Priestley, Morecambe  
 I'm alive and to prove it I'm here 
 You may be interested in an event that happened to me after our Remembrance Service at East Kirkby early this July. 
 In 1944 our Lancaster of 57 Sqn, piloted by Flt Lt Bulcraig was shot down on a raid on Revigny, Northern France, killing the pilot, Bomb Aimer Fg Off Robson, Flt Eng Sgt Gale and W/Op Sgt Loughlin. 
 Sgt Taylor, the mid-upper gunner and myself, the rear gunner, were evaders for three months until liberated by the Americans. 
 Our navigator, Fg Off Ruston was taken prisoner. 
 You can imagine my surprise when looking around the Lancaster hangar at the display boards, I came across a copy of Flt Lt Bulcraig's DFM citation, with a typed caption stating that our pilot had been killed with all his crew! 
 Fred Panton who owns the East Kirkby museum will be correcting this error with the complete story of what happened. 
 He said I was the healthiest ghost he'd ever seen! 
 L E S Manning, Sudbury, Suffolk.  
 Wings Co-operation 
 Your editorial on page one of the Summer 1991 issue prompted me to record the following thoughts which have a direct bearing on the subject of active participation. 
 Having collected for Wings Appeal at a number of sites (railway stations, house-to-house, town centres, London) over the years it is apparent that the collection rate per hour varies quite significantly from point to point. 
 The prime site out of the above-mentioned locations is, in my experience, London, and the worst the railway stations, but there are far better places than even the City of London and I have been made aware that the airports are an example of sites that fall into this category. 
 The organisation that is demonstrated by the London collection deserves a marking of 10 out of 10 but there must be many more collection points in the country that deserve similar consideration by &bquo;the centre&equo;. 
 The initial setting up could be carried out by them and then circularised to the nearest branches some time before September in order for the most capable branch to make an offer for the franchise. 
 The contracting branch could then, if necessary, seek the support of smaller neighbouring branches/organisations who are not able to mount a major collection project. 
 There are many members who are uncomfortable shaking a can in public but would be more than willing to man a City of London style distribution, counting and recording centre while the enthusiastic collectors stretch themselves to the limit. 
 A greater co-operation between branches to units in covering prime sites should increase collection returns and at the same time remove any parochial attitudes. 
 Peter Harper, Hitchin, Herts.   
 ALBUM 
 The de Havilland Mosquito T MkIII (G-ASKH) that belongs to BAe. 
 During its service life it served in Egypt, Aden and Nairobi as well as in the UK (eg at No 204 AFS, Driffield). 
 The code letters are spurious, dating from this aircraft's film star days with &bquo;633 Sqn&equo;. 
 ( photo Darryl Cott ).  
 The de Havilland Mosquito MkIV, DK 338, photographed December 1942. 
 The de Havilland Hornet. 
 TT202 was, in fact, a Sea Hornet used in manufacturer's trials and at RAF Farnborough. 
 The Hornet could reach speeds of about 474mph and was the fastest piston-engined aircraft to serve with the RAF. 
 This fine portrayal of the Short Stirling is by John Young. 
 It is one of the 12 excellent pictures by this artist that is featured in the 1992 RAF Museum Calendar. 
 BOOKS 
 The Battle Re-thought. 
 A Symposium on the Battle of Britain. 
 Joint Editors: H. Probert &amp; S Cox. 
 (Airlife Publishing &pound;15). 
 To mark the 50th Anniversary of the Battle, the RAF Historical Society and the RAF Staff College convened a joint seminar at Brackness in June 1990. 
 This book (103pp) contains the edited texts of the main talks, and a digest of what was said in the discussion groups. 
 These groups addressed The System, The Tactics, Intelligence, The Commanders, The Strategy and Writing the History. 
 Reading the book gives you a picture of wiath number of BoB participants think about these topics, and also what a number of learned air historians have concluded on the same subjects. 
 Inevitably the symposium brought out some conflicting opinions (there were 300 people present!) but that is what makes the book interesting. 
 This is recommended reading for all those who think the interpretation of facts is simple matter! 
 The Green Fields and the Sky. 
 The History of RAF Cottesmore. 
 Norman Roberson &amp; Jack Talliss. 
 (Obtainable from RAF Cottesmore, Oakham, Leics LE15 7B1 &pound;10.99 + &pound;1.95 p&amp;p. 
 Cheques payable to RAF Cottesmore Nonpas). 
 Written by two RAF officers this 127pp book provides an interesting ans well illustrated history of this airfield which was opened in 1938, and which was home to such units as 14 OTU, 1668 HCU as well as various squadrons of Canberras, Victors and Vulcans. 
 Since 1981, Cottesmore has accommodated the Tri-National Tornado Training Establishment. 
 The station featured in a number of important historical events, such as the 1,000 bomber raid on Cologne, and Operation Market (the use of airborne troops to take the bridges over the Meuse, Waal and Rhine). 
 Five appendices add useful historical date to the commentary. 
 Proceeds from the sale of the book go to the RAF Benevolent Fund. 
 The Bomber Battle for Berlin. 
 John Searby. 
 (Airlife Publishing &pound;13.95) 
 The late John Searby was very well qualified to write this story for he commanded 106 Sqn and 83 (Pathfinder) Sqn in nightly raids over Germany, and was the Master Bomber on the Peenemunde raid. 
 He describes two raids on Berlin at different stages of the conflict, but, more than that, he puts them into the general context of Bomber Command's war over Germany. 
 There are nicely balanced views about the great commanders &mdash; Harris, Cochrane and Bennett &mdash; with careful avoidance of the temptation to be smart after the event. 
 This is surely a slice of history shown as it really was, and all who served with Bomber Command will be delighted that John Searby recorded their courageous efforts so well. 
 Middleton VC. 
 Stuart Bill. 
 (Published by S &amp; L Bill, 18 Pollina Street, East Bentleigh, Victoria, Australia 3165. (&dollar;31.60 inc postage)). 
 This is the story of Flt Sgt R H Middleton, RAAF, who was posthumously awarded the VC following a raid on Turin while captaining a Stirling of No 149 Squadron. 
 Well researched, the book covers Ron Middleton's life from his schooldays in Australia to his gallant death off the coast of Kent in November 1942. 
 Vivid pictures are presented of Middleton's training in Australia, Canada and the UK, and of life on wartime bomber airfields. 
 It is a moving story that leaves one marvelling not only at the bravery of Middleton himself but that fate had brought so many courageous men together in the one crew. 
 Further Along the Path. 
 H A Owens. 
 (Published by the author, and obtainable from him at 1, Eva Road, Cheadle Heath, Stockport, Cheshire SK3 OSX. &pound;6.25). 
 This sequel to the author's &bquo;Nightmare Towards the Path&equo; deals with his experiences while with the Desert Air Force in WWII. 
 There is a thread of spiritualism and mysticism.  
 Eagle's Wings. 
 The Autobiography of a Luftwaffe Pilot. 
 Hajo Herrmann. 
 (Airlife Publishing Ltd. &pound;15.95). 
 The style and the political and military viewpoints of Hajo Herrmann are what might be expected from one who was an officer cadet in the German army of 1934, a founder member of the Condor Legion in Spain, a proposer of suicidal ramming of Allied bombers and a confidant of Herrmann Goering. 
 A patriot or a fanatic? 
 Who knows. 
 There have been relatively few books written by senior officers of &bquo;the other side&equo;, and this certainly provides a commentary that will interest historians of the 1939&ndash;1945 air war. 
 Beyond the Dams to the Tirpitz. 
 Alan Cooper. 
 (Goodall Publications Ltd. &pound;3.50). 
 This is a paperback edition of a book that first appeared about eight years ago, and it tells the story of 617 Sqn after the dams raid had taken place. 
 It is a well-researched book &mdash; it lists hundreds of sources (including Air Mail!) at the back, and there are some interesting appendices. 
 While I would have liked to have seen a bit more about 9 Sqn's contribution to the Tirpitz attacks, I appreciate that this is a book about 617 Sqn. 
 Three Stripes and Four Brownings. 
 Bill Jackson. 
 (Published by Turner-Warwick Publications, Box 1029, North Battleford, Saskatchewan, S9A 3E6. 
 (Canadian &dollar;25.95)). 
 This book came out about a year ago but merits a mention because the subject matter will interest quite a number of our members. 
 Bill Jackson was a rear gunner of 218 (Gold Coast) Sqn operating Stirlings out of RAF Downham Market. 
 This is more than a book about a rear gunner, however; it is a factual account of a bomber crew, and, written with an unpretentious style, it is both easy to read and hard to put down. 
 Ironically, bearing in mind the casualty statistics of rear gunners, &bquo;Jacko&equo; was the sole survivor of the crew &mdash; perhaps because the aircraft crashed while flying too low over enemy territory. 
 Rear gunners have written some good books &mdash; remember &bquo;Revs&equo; Rivaz' &bquo;Tail Gunner&equo;? 
 I am glad that Bill Jackson's wife (an ex-Waaf) persuaded him to write the book, and that her beautiful little poem about P-Peter's crew is included. 
 The Forgotten Bomber. 
 Graham Warner. 
 (Patrick Stephens &pound;17.50). 
 This is the story of the Bristol Blenheim that was so painstakingly restored by Graham Warner and his team of enthusiasts, only to be destroyed so soon afterwards in a crash. 
 All the drama of this tragedy is told in a book that is always interesting, and which is exceptionally well illustrated. 
 There are enough accounts of Blenheim operations to put things into historical perspective, while the detailed description of the restoration project enables one to understand how mortified all felt when human error undid years of endeavour in a few seconds. 
 The second restoration is underway, however, and there can be no greater tribute to the determination and resilience of Graham Warner and his team than that fact. 
 It seems most fitting that the qualities of the Blenheim's wartime crews are being perpetuated by such people. 
 Aircraft for the Few. 
 The RAF's Fighters and Bombers in 1940. 
 Michael J F Bowyer. 
 (Patrick Stephens &pound;17.50). 
 This is an invaluable new reference book, listing the serial numbers, by squadron, not only of the fighters and bombers of 1940, but of such lesser favourites as the Lerwick and Botha, for example. 
 There are some very good photographs and some intriguing snippets of information &mdash; Michael Bowyer tells how the Operational Requirement that led to the Hampden and Wellington specified that the aircraft should have folding wings for hangar storage! 
 The book provides a nice blend of information and entertainment, and gives the reader a broader appreciation of RAF aircraft of 1940 than other publications. 
 The American Airman in Europe. 
 Roger Freeman. 
 (Arms &amp; Armour &pound;16.95). 
 Roger Freeman is a most knowledgeable writer on all things to do with the machines, units and  campaigns of the USAAF in WWII. 
 This latest book turns the spotlight on the human aspects and it offers excellent entertainment. 
 Well-chosen stories are illustrated with some interesting photographs. 
 While this is not a reference book, it complements well those that Roger Freeman has written &mdash; and should interest an even wider audience. 
 Aftermath. 
 Along the Way&hellip; 
 One Man's War and Peace (1940&ndash;1990). 
 Graham Burrell. 
 (Published by A.H. 
 Stockwell Ltd. &pound;9.50). 
 Graham Burrell was a Wop/AG with 114 Sqn (Blenheims), then he was posted to India, serving with 152 OTU and 215 Sqn. 
 In 1949 he crashed at Tangmere in a Wellington, suffered burns, and after treatment at the East Grinstead Queen Victoria Hospital, left the RAF to become a night time telephone operator and union Branch Secretary. 
 The story is not an easy one to follow, particularly as it goes back and forth in time, and locations change quickly. 
 The Guinness Book of Military Blunders. 
 Geoffrey Regan. 
 (Guiness Publishing &pound;11.99). 
 A book with a title like this has to be full of choice bits of information that confirm what most of us who have been in the Services have always known &mdash; that high-ranking officers can do the daftest things. 
 This has been so for centuries, and afflicts all nations. 
 Could we not have all guessed that Lt Col Custer (he gave himself the rank of general) came 34th out of the class of 34 at West Point. 
 Sir Kinsley Wood, Secretary for Air, is reported to have responded in September 1939 to a plan to burn the Black Forest with &bquo;Are you aware it is private property? 
 Why you will be asking me to bomb Essen next.&equo; 
 This book should appeal to all with a sense of humour and an appreciation of the ridiculous. 
 Possibly a good choice for a Christmas gift for it will amuse a wide readership. 
 The War That Never Was. 
 AVM A G Dudgeon. 
 (Airlife &pound;16.95). 
 This is an excellent book about the defeat of the Iraqi army that was sent to capture the RAF base at Habbaniya in 1941. 
 This army, with German backing, and supported by the Iraqi Air Force, was defeated by the men of No.4 FTS, which was the unit stationed at Habbaniya, and which was equipped with Audax and Oxford aircraft. 
 It is a story of courage and of improvisation that made a nonsense of the enemy's numerical and material superiority. 
 There are no photographs to illustrate this important victory achieved over five days &mdash; presumably because everyone was too busy working at staying alive to take pictures &mdash; but the Frank Wootton dust jacket is evocative. 
 Journeys Into Night. 
 Don Charlwood. 
 (Hudson Hawthorn &pound;9.95). 
 The author of No Moon Tonight  (which was about 103 Sqn at Elsham Wolds) has just produced another most interesting book. 
 It is a factual memoir of 20 young Australian airmen who trained in Canada as navigators before most went to Bomber Command. 
 Three quarters of the group were killed. 
 Their letters and diaries have been threaded together to provide a fresh perspective on the lives of young airmen during times when their survival statistics were grim. 
 Don Charlwood survived 30 ops and is well qualified to bring their stories together. 
 Wings of War Over Gwynedd. 
 Aviation in Gwynedd during WWII. 
 Roy Sloan. 
 (Published by Gwasg Carreg Gwalch, Capel Garman, Llanrwst, Gwynedd, Wales LL26 0RL. &pound;5.00). 
 If you served at RAF Valley, Mona, Bodorgan, Llandrog, Penrhos, Hell's Mouth, Llanbedr or Tywyn, or if you would like to know more of the aviation heritage of North Wales, you might well find Roy Sloan's researches to be of special interest. 
 A considerable amount of detail covering the war years is contained within the 190 pages of this book, which also has a number of illustrations. 
 And We Thought the War Was Over. 
 David Lee. 
 (Thomas Harmsworth &pound;15.95). 
 It does not seem generally known that for more than a year after VJ Day more than 120,000 Allied POWs were kept in internment camps in Java. 
 Indonesian opposition to their release was intense, and, to make matters worse, the exact locations of many camps was not known. 
 Air Chief Marshal Sir David Lee, then a Group Captain commanding 904 Wing, took over the airfield at Kemajoran which was to play a key role in the repatriation of POWs and internees. 
 This book sheds some light on events that deserve to be better known as for many the months that elapsed proved fatal. 
 Wings &mdash; and Other Things&hellip; 
 Hugh Lynch-Blosse. 
 (Square One Publications. 
 &pound;8.95). 
 The author says in the Foreward that this is the story of a very ordinary RAF General Duties Officer and Pilot. 
 That may be self-effacing, but the honesty and humour with which this autobiography is laced make it entertaining. 
 Who, anyway, would want to read an autobiography of someone who saw himself as God's gift to aviation and the RAF in particular? 
 Digressions are numerous, but never irritating and the story is entertaining. 
 Flying Aerobatics. 
 R T Bowring. 
 (Aviation Theory Centre, 131 Nelson Place, Williamstown, Vic. 
 3016, Australia. 
 &pound;15). 
 Written by an ex-Halton apprentice/RAF Central Flying School graduate, this manual explains the basic manoeuvres in simple language and with many diagrams. 
 It is a practical guide for the beginner &mdash; or for those who have never been taught the proper way! 
 Difficult to read without moving hands and feet! 
 Voice From the Stars. 
 Tom Scotland. 
 (Published and distributed by T &amp; L Scotland, 18 Eastbourne St., Lynwood, 6155 Western Australia. 
 &pound;11 inc postage, &pound;14 airmail). 
 Tom Scotland flew 62 ops from Italy with a Pathfinder squadron (614); his autobiography is a story of his search for truth, for something that would enable him to make sense out of all the destruction and chaos that was a part of wartime life. 
 It is also an emotional story, notably when Tom revisits Devil's Glen, near Leeds, which was where he crash-landed a burning Halifax in 1943.  
 Pilot Officer Prune's Picture Parade! 
 Bill Hooper. 
 (HMSO &pound;7.95) 
 This is a colourful and amusing 56 pages of cartoons and anecdotes. 
 Indeed, even if you find Prune a bit of a bore you could find the stories behind the character and the &bquo;finger&equo; awards entertaining and funny. 
 Colourful and with good artwork, this would make an appropriate Christmas present for anyone who has laughed with the RAF at some time. 
 Bob Doe &mdash; Fighter Pilot. 
 Wg Cdr Bob Doe DSO DFC. 
 (Spellmount Ltd. &pound;15.95). 
 One of the highest scoring fighter pilots of the Battle of Britain, Bob Doe has written an interesting book that goes a good deal further than describing some of his exploits in the Battle. 
 One of its five chapters is about those epic times, while others describe Bob Doe's experiences in the Middle and Far East. 
 Finally he talks of the trials and tribulations of garage management. 
 It adds up to a picture of a man in a wider context that just as a fighter pilot. 
 Happy Is the Day. 
 A Spitfire Pilot's Story. 
 Tom Slack. 
 (United Writers Publications Ltd &pound;9.50). 
 Quite different from any other Spitfire pilot's story, this ex-41 Sqn pilot has written a racey and humorous account of his 1940&ndash;45 experiences &mdash; which has also illustrated with his own skilfully drawn cartoons. 
 Tom Slack's sense of fun effectively camouflages the dramas and dangers he endured as a pilot, as an escaper and ultimately as a POW. 
 The reader is never bored &mdash; but could be disappointed that the book does not go beyond its 120 pages. 
 Good value.  
 Videos&hellip; 
 Red Nine. 
 The Red Arrows. 
 RA2 Aviation Video Library. 
 This is about the pilots who make up this famous aerobatic team, and it focuses on the three new pilots who join it each year. 
 It is an excellent video that does much more than just show the superb display that the public expects from these professionals. 
 The photography and commentary are of high standard. 
 Wings of Thunder. 
 Simitar SUK60022 (&pound;10). 
 Excellent filming of precision aerobatics feature in this dramatically titled video. 
 Included is the US Navy Flight Demonstration Team, The Blue Angels, flying their F-18 Hornets in characteristically very tight formation. 
 There is, however, an &bquo;original sizzling rock sound track&equo; &mdash; you have been warned! 
 Hell in the Skies. 
 Simitar SUK24002 (&pound;10). 
 The Italian Air Force's display team suffered a terrible accident in August 1988 while performing over the Ramstein Air Force base in West Germany. 
 The accident happened when the team was carrying out the &bquo;Arrow through the Heart&equo; manoeuvre. 
 This video shows a typical display and a part of the Ramstein performance, together with &bquo;computer enhancement&equo; of the accident. 
 The pictures of the disaster are not, however, very clear.  
 Talking books&hellip; 
 Durban's Lady in White. 
 We have had early notification from Sam Morley of Aedificamus Press that plans are in hand to publish this excellent book, the autobiography of Perla Seidle Gibson, as a Talking Book. 
 Thousands who heard her singing to the troopships passing through Durban remember &bquo;The Lady in White&equo;, and there will be many who will appreciate the opportunity of hearing her story through the medium of audio tape. 
 A review will be undertaken when a copy of the recording is available; Sam Morley (0707 872720) can provide more information.  
 Seeing Life from A New Angle. 
 R C Bowers. 
 (Courtney Books, Road End Cottage, Stockland, Honiton, Devon EX14 9LJ. &pound;6.95). 
 This is the tale of 575237 Bowers R C, an ex-Halton apprentice who served for 38 years with the RAF before retiring as Wing Commander Engineer. 
 It is a tale full of interest, and it reveals an attitude to work and to the Service that makes pleasant reading (unhappily some authors give the impression they had a less than fulfilling time while in the RAF). 
 Was service as an airman in the Middle East and India is graphically described, as are a number of post war assignments of great variety covering a multitude of aircraft from Meteors and Javelins to rocket-assisted Valiants! 
 Probably unintentionally, Ron Bowers has written an excellent recruiting bookk for the RAF Engineering Branch, but it will interest all ex-brats&hellip; and many more besides. 
 Royal Air Force Woodvale. 
 The First Fifty Years. 
 Aldon P Ferguson. 
 (Airfield Publications Ltd. &pound;10). 
 It is fifty years since this &bquo;temporary&equo; RAF station became operational &mdash; and it is still in use. 
 Aldon Ferguson tells the Woodvale story with affection, and his bood is particularly well illustrated. 
 Irvin Caterpillar Club 
 There has apparently been some misunderstanding about the future of this Club and we have been asked to reassure members that the Club is continuing and that eligibility remains as before. 
 The authorised Secretary of the Club is Mrs J Adams at Irvin Great Britain Ltd, Icknield Way, Letchworth, Herts SG6 1EU.  
 News from the RAF Benevolent Fund 
 The Great Haggis Shoot 
 The &bquo;Glorious Twelfth&equo; signalled the start of the first &bquo;Haggis Shoot&equo; of the season &mdash; a kindly alternative to the usual grouse. 
 The competition between three teams &mdash; local sportsmen, the 15th Parachute Brigade and RAF Leuchars took place in the Kingdom of Fife and raised money for the RAF Benevolent Fund and The Airborne Initiative Appeal. 
 The day continued with six haggis and six bottles of famous Grouse Whisky being flown to RAF Leuchars, then whisked to RAE Farnborough in a Tornado. 
 Standing by, were six Red Devils from the Parachute Regiment who were flown by helocopter to their drop point above the Thames, close to the Savoy Hotel in London. 
 After parachuting into the Thames with their precious cargo, the Red Devils were quickly recovered by members of the MOD Police Marine Unit and escorted to the Savoy by a Shetland pony, Sgt Pegasus, the Regimental Mascot of the Parachute Regiment! 
 Waiting the meet them were ACM Sir Brendan Jackson, RAF, Lt Gen Sir Michael Gray, Col Cmdt, Parachute Regiment and Maitre Chef des Cuisines Anton Endelman. 
 Sponsors and guests were invited to estimate the exact time of the flight of the Haggis from the Sandford Hotel, Fife to The Savoy. 
 The correct answer &mdash; two hours and 30 seconds and the final amount raised is expected to be in the region of &pound;11,000. 
 &bquo;Battle of Britain&equo; Wins 
 In 1990 the Sunday Mirror  and Sporting Life  ran a competition to win a racehorse for a year; the horse was a two-year-old colt by the name of &bquo;Battle of Britain&equo;. 
 The competition raised nearly &pound;4,000 for the RAF Benevolent Fund. 
 &bquo;Battle of Britain&equo; made his racing debut at Wolverhampton in April 1991 and since then, the colt trained in Lancashire by Jack Berry, has certainly proved to be winner as the photograph shows. 
 Supersonic Strength 
 A Concorde tug was the brainchild of PC Bob Gilbert based at Maidstone, Kent who also happens to be a member of the Vulcan Association. 
 Teams from RAF Manston and Kent policemen pulled a Concorde along the runway at RAF Manston, to raise funds for the Vulcan Association and the RAF Benevolent Fund. 
 The pull was made on to a slightly uphill gradient and into the wind, in spite of this a record breaking 100 metres was reached in 40.8 seconds at a speed of 4.5 mph. 
 The 95 ton Concorde's usual air cruising speed is 1,340 mph!   
 Alan Munro powers &bquo;Battle of Britain&equo; to victory in the EBF Saffron Maiden Stakes at Lingfield in June 1991. 
 (Photo Ronald Frain)  
 Dutch children at Arnhem (Oosterbeek) War Cemetery, the Netherlands. 
 Tailfin 
 Now go round and try that again! 
 Gp Capt R C Hockey sent Air Mail  the excellent photograph of what happened at Kinloss on a dark night in October 1943 when an Anson was approaching to land at the same time &mdash; and on the same bit of field &mdash; as a Whitley was just starting its take-off run. 
 The photograph was found in an album made up by the late Sqn Ldr G Beeby. 
 Apparently nobody was injured in this freak accident. 
 Whitleys must have had pretty strong undercarriages and Ansons unbending props. 
 Any similarities with the picture above&hellip; are purely coincidental, but P J Ferry of the Penarth Branch through we should meet the latest recruit to 1148 (Penarth) ATC. 
 This is a goat, who because her main duty is to keep the grass in check around the HQ has been named &bquo;Flymo&equo;. 
 Cadet Diana Grant is not playing the part of a Whitley, but would have us believe she is playing the part of a mountain. 
 CWO Simon Grant holds Flymo's lead which seems to be tied to the HQ drainpipe. 
 One fact we do know about this versitile act is that 1148 (Penarth) ATC each year provide tremendous help with the branch Wings Appeal. 
 Keep up the excellent work &mdash; but don't let Flymo eat the money! 
 After the auction Joint Services Public Relations, HQ British Forces Cyprus have thoughtfully sent us information about those recently retired Shakletons. 
 Four of the five remaining were auctioned off by Sotheby's, two going to Cypriot businessman Savvas Constantinides (who paid &pound;110,000 for the two and who plans an aviation museum in either Pathos or Nicosia) and two (WR963 and WL790) are now in Coventry, owned by the Shackleton Preservation Society. 
 The fifth (W756) is at RAF St Mawgan where it will be broken up. 
 Cpl. 
 Bob Stonehouse, JSPRS, took the photograph of WL747 flying along the coastline near Episkopi on its way to say goodbye to the RAF and to join WL757 at Paphos. 
 On each flight to Cyprus six groundcrew were on board to cope with any problems encountered en route and to remove the avionics not included in the sale. 
 It may seem early for Air Mail  to wish readers a happy Christmas! 
 This, however, is what we do, together with a big &bquo;Thank you&equo; for all the news and views that you've given us in 1991. 
 We look forward to hearing from you in 1992! 
 Central Headquarters 43 Grove Park Road, Chiswick, London W4 3RX Telephone: 081&ndash;994 8504 
 R.A.F.A. Residential Home &mdash; Sussexdown 
 Sussexdown is situated nine miles from Worthing and stands in seven acres of grounds. 
 It was originally built as a private residence and the Association bought the home in 1962. 
 It has been converted to provide accommodation for up to 60 chronically sick or severely disabled residents. 
 A small number of convalescent cases can also be accommodated. 
 Sussexdown is a happy place, run by caring staff who provide a full 24-hour nursing service, physiotherapy and occupational therapy. 
 The aim of Sussexdown is to enable the residents to enjoy as full, varied and independent a life as is possible given their disabilities. 
 Although the DSS is able to assist in meeting some of the costs of residents, the large part of the costs is met from welfare funds raised by the Association. 
 No one is turned away because of a lack of means. 
 R.A.F.A. Convalescent Home &mdash; Richard Peck House 
 Richard Peck House was opened in 1958. 
 The house is situated in the seaside resort of St. Anne's-on-Sea in Lancashire and is only a short walk from the beach. 
 Richard Peck House provides a convalescence not readily available through the NHS for serving or ex-Service personnel or their dependants. 
 Convalescents can be accompanied by their spouse who can also benefit from the rest and relaxation provided. 
 The House can accommodate up to 22 persons and offers a very high standard of comfort. 
 Richard Peck House has earned a reputation as one of the finest convalescent homes in the country and those who stay there return home rested and restored to good health. 
 The costs of convalescence are normally met in part by individual or Branch contributions and in part by the welfare funds raised by the Association. 
 No one is turned away because of a lack of means. 
 R.A.F.A. Sheltered Housing &mdash; Storrington, Bolton and Moffat 
 The Association's sheltered housing schemes at Storrington in Sussex, Bolton in Lancashire and Moffat in Scotland enable residents to live independent lives but with support from an on-site warden should they have any difficulties. 
 The sheltered housing is close to local amenities to allow residents easy access for shops and other facilities. 
 The residents are able to enjoy the privacy of their own accommodation together with the communal facilities offered within these projects. 
 Importantly, the comradeship of Service life can be continued into retirement and the welfare support of the Association and other Service charities can be readily and swiftly available. 
 Eagle Lodge 
 The aim of an Eagle Lodge is to provide supportive housing for single, elderly ex-Air Force persons, encouraging independence within a caring environment, thereby overcoming the problem of loneliness which affects so many in old age. 
 The Association has recently purchased a large, detached house in a residential area of Melton Mowbray, Leicestershire. 
 Within easy reach of the town centre and on a frequent bus route, Wexford House stands in a large garden which will afford a pleasant area for future residents. 
 The house will be converted, to provide eight single flatlets with private facilities together with communal rooms and a self-contained flat for the housekeeper. 
 Residents will be provided with two main meals each day and a &bquo;Care-Call&equo; alarm system will be installed. 
 The intention is that the housing will be self-funding once initial capital costs have been met. 
 DSS support of individuals will be sought where applicable. 
 The Royal Air Forces Association 
 This leaflet is designed to tell you about the Association and how to join. 
 The Association is a registered charity incorporated under Royal Charter. 
 Its primary aims are comradeship and welfare. 
 The Association has over 100,000 members and some 600 Branches worldwide. 
 Nearly 200 of these Branches have clubs. 
 Membership is open to serving and ex-Service men and women of all ranks who serve or have served in one of Her Majesty's Air Forces. 
 The Association's welfare support is not confined to its membership but extends also to serving and ex-Air Force non-members and their dependants. 
 The Association has its headquarters in London and nine area offices in the UK. 
 It maintains a residential home for the disabled, a convalescent home and sheltered housing developments. 
 The Association has both full-time and voluntary welfare workers who assess individuals in need of help, referring many to the RAF Benevolent Fund for financial support. 
 In this way, the Association provides a field force of welfare workers for the Benevolent Fund and the two complementary organisations work closely together. 
 The full-time welfare workers of the Association also represent individuals at War Pension Tribunals. 
 We Need You 
 Over recent years both the Association and the RAF Benevolent Fund have experienced an increase in welfare casework and this is also reflected by the other ex-Service charities. 
 It is expected that this trend will continue at least until the turn of the century: indeed forecasts suggest that between now and the year 2000, the 70 year old ex-Service population will nearly double, while by the end of that period some 500,000 ex-RAF personnel will be over 80 years old. 
 At the same time, recent Social Security legislation reflects a shift in Government policy which places a greater responsibility on the community and on charities. 
 We therefore have to assume a future of substantially increasing welfare need combined with a decrease in government support. 
 The key issues for the future of the Association are sustaining the number of voluntary welfare workers and their helpers and giving them the financial and other support they need to deal with both increasing and more complex welfare needs. 
 We need your help and support in this vital work. 
 Joining the Association 
 If you have served for 3 months or more in Her Majesty's Royal Air Forces you are entitled to apply for membership of the Royal Air Forces Association. 
 If you wish to join, you should complete the membership form below and send it to The Royal Air Forces Association, 43 Grove Park Road, Chiswick, London W4 3RX,  together with your remittance for the appropriate membership fee. 
 If you wish to pay by Bankers Order then please complete the form below and send that to the RAFA with your membership application form. 
 The application form provides an opportunity for you to join your local Branch. 
 If you are unsure which branch is nearest to you, just put in your local town and your name and address will be passed to your nearest Branch. 
 If you do not wish to join a Branch you may join the Central Headquarters membership roll. 
 Please indicate your choice on the form. 
 The Association needs you and can help you. 
 It needs you to sustain its welfare work and it can help you by providing comradeship and support. 
 Join your Association now.   
 The Royal Air Forces Association 
 The Royal Air Forces Association is a Registered Charity with a membership of 110,000 and over 600 branches worldwide. 
 Its welfare activities extend to all serving and ex-Air Forces men and women and their dependants, backed by full-time and voluntary helpers working closely with the RAF Benevolent Fund. 
 The Association maintains a Home for the disabled, one for convalescents and three Sheltered Housing schemes. 
 The full time Welfare Officers of the Association represents individuals at War Pension Tribunals, and offer professional advice on legal matters and housing, as well as handling day to day welfare problems. 
 Last year only voluntary Welfare Officer alone, made over 102 domiciliary visits. 
 He is just one of our 600 voluntary Welfare Officers in this country and overseas who help us with our work. 
 The Association is becoming increasingly involved in welfare work, as the needs of those who survived World War II become more urgent. 
 Welfare trends 
 Over recent years both the Association and the RAF Benevolent Fund have experienced an increase in welfare casework and this is also reflected by the other ex-Service charities. 
 It is expected that this trend will continue at least until the turn of the century; indeed forecasts suggest that between now and the year 2000, the 70 year old ex-Service population will nearly double, while by the end of that period some 500,000 ex-RAF personnel will be over 80 years old. 
 At the same time, recent Social Service legislation reflects a shift in Government policy. 
 In considering priorities for the future it would be sensible to assume a substantial increase in welfare need combined with a decrease in government support. 
 The key issues for the future are how to sustain the number of voluntary welfare workers and their helpers, and give them the support they need to deal with both increasing and more complex welfare needs. 
 RAFA residential home &mdash; Sussexdown at Storrington 
 Sussexdown is situated at Storrington, nine miles from Worthing, and stands in seven acres of grounds. 
 It was originally built as a private residence, and the Association bought the home in 1962. 
 It has been converted to provide accommodation for up to 60 chronically sick or severely disabled residents. 
 A small number of convalescent and recuperative holidays can be arranged. 
 Sussexdown is a happy place, run by caring staff who provide a full 24-hour nursing service, physiotherapy and occupational therapy. 
 The aim of Sussexdown is to enable the residents to enjoy as full, varied and independent a life as is possible given their disabilities. 
 Although the DSS is able to assist in meeting some of the costs of residents, the larger part of the costs are met from welfare funds raised by the Association, and from donations to the Home. 
 No one is turned away because of a lack of means. 
 Extract from a letter received from a disabled resident at Sussexdown  &bquo;It really is a privilege to be in such a lovely place, and to be so well cared for, there can't, I'm sure, be another Home like it in the whole of Britain.&equo; 
 RAFA Convalescent Home &mdash; Richard Peck House 
 Richard Peck House was opened in 1958. 
 The House is situated in the seaside resort of St Annes-on-Sea, in Lancashire, and is only a short walk from the beach. 
 Richard Peck House provides convalescence not readily available through the NHS, for serving or ex-Service personnel or their dependants. 
 Convalescents can be accompanied by their spouse, who can also benefit from the rest and relaxation provided. 
 The House can accommodate up to 22 persons, and offers a very high standard of comfort. 
 Richard Peck House has earned a reputation as one of the finest Convalescent Homes in the Country, and those who stay there return home rested and restored to good health. 
 The costs of convalescence are normally met in part by individual or Branch contributions, and in part by the welfare funds raised by the Association. 
 Again, no one is turned away because of a lack of means. 
 Extract from a letter received from an ex-member of the Womens Royal Air Force after a period of convalescence at Richard Peck House  &bquo;It was my good fortune to be given a period of convalescence at Richard Peck House after major surgery. 
 It was so nice and restful there with everyone being so kind. 
 I have returned home feeling much better and of course, will be ever so grateful to the Association. 
 I find it very comforting to know the Association is there when I need help and advice.&equo; 
 R.A.F.A. Sheltered Housing &mdash; Storrington, Bolton &amp; Moffat 
 The Association's sheltered housing schemes at Storrington in Sussex, Bolton in Lancashire and Moffat in Scotland, enable residents to live independent lives, but with support from an on-site warden should they have any difficulties. 
 The sheltered housing is close to local amenities to allow residents easy access to shops and other facilities. 
 The residents are able to enjoy the privacy of their own accommodation, together with the communal facilites offered within these projects. 
 Significantly, the comradeship of Service life can be continued into retirement and the welfare support of the Association and other Service Charities can be readily and swiftly available. 
 Eagle Lodge 
 The aim of an Eagle Lodge is to provide supportive housing for single, elderly ex-Air Force persona, encouraging independence within a caring family environment, thereby overcoming the problems of loneliness which affects so many in old age. 
 The Association has recently purchased a large, detached house in a residential area of Melton Mowbray, Leicestershire. 
 Within each reach of the town centre and on a frequent bus route, Wexford House stands in a large garden which will afford a pleasant area for future residents. 
 The house will be converted, to provide eight single flatlets with private facilities together with communal rooms and a self-contained flat for the flatkeeper. 
 Resident will be provided with two main meals each day and a &bquo;Care-Call&equo; alarm system will be installed. 
 The intention is that the housing will be self-funding once initial capital costs have been met. 
 DSS support of individuals will be sought where applicable.  
 Why you should make a Will 
 THE IMPORTANCE OF LEGACIES TO THE ROYAL AIR FORCES ASSOCIATION 
 The income we receive form legacies is used to support our extensive welfare facilities which include a residential home for the disabled, convalescent homes and sheltered housing. 
 Recently we have developed supportive homes for elderly and frail ex-R.A.F. men and women. 
 The need for these continues to grow. 
 SOME QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS 
 Why make a Will? 
 There are many good reasons. 
 Peace of mind, adequate provision for family and friends, and the knowledge that one's wishes will be carried out. 
 Ensure that you  are the one to decide what will happen to everything you own. 
 If you consult a Solicitor, making a will is a simple procedure. 
 What will happen if I don't make a Will? 
 If you die entestate, the law decides how your Estate will be sorted out. 
 This can be an expensive and lengthy business. 
 The legal costs will be paid from your Estate so there will be less to divide between relatives and other beneficiaries. 
 But I haven't anything worth leaving! 
 Many people imagine this. 
 Just sit down for few minutes, you are probably worth more than you think. 
 Could I save money and write my own will? 
 &bquo;Home-made-Wills&equo; can create more problems than they solve. 
 Unless you have legal experience you may find that what you have written is open to misinterpretation. 
 Can I change my Will? 
 Yes. 
 You can change your Will, or made a new one, as often as you wish although your Solicitor will have to charge a fee each time. 
 This is especially important if you marry, divorce or re-marry. 
 A change is added to your will as a Codicil. 
 This is a separate document which must be signed and witnessed in the correct legal manner. 
 The Tax Advantages 
 Reducing Tax Liability 
 Legacies made to a registered charity are free from inheritance tax. 
 This can reduce the tax liability on the estate, and can mean that money which might otherwise go to the taxman will be used instead to support a worthwhile cause of your choosing. 
 For example, supposing your estate is worth &pound;10,000 more than the tax threshold. 
 If Inheritance Tax is 40% at the time of your death, normally &pound;4,000 (40%) would be payable in tax. 
 But if you were to make a legacy of &pound;10,000 to the Royal Air Forces Association or any other registered charity, the notional value of your estate would be reduced by that amount &mdash; so in this case there would be no tax to pay. 
 You would have put &pound;10,000 towards a good cause &mdash; but it would only have cost you &pound;6,000, because you would have saved the rest in tax. 
 A LEGACY MADE OUT IN FAVOUR OF A CHARITY COULD WELL BE THE ANSWER. 
 WOULD YOU LIKE TO HELP THE ROYAL AIR FORCES ASSOCIATION WITH A LEGACY? 
 Further advice can be given by completing and posting the coupon below. 
 The Royal Air Forces Association Appeals Department Portland Road, Malvern Worcestershire. 
 WR14 2TA 
 I am interested in leaving a bequest to RAFA and would like to obtain further details of how I can help. 
 Name 
 Address 
 Forms of Bequest 
 There are different ways of helping the work of The Royal Air Forces Association. 
 You may bequeath your Entire Estate, a Specific Sum of Money, Specific Property, or all or part of the Residue of your Estate &mdash; or even make a Conditional Bequest in the event that another potential beneficiary pre-deceases you. 
 All these can be covered quite simply by writing into your Will wording such as: 
 Bequest of Entire Estate 
 I GIVE my estate free of all taxes and duties to the Royal Air Forces Association (Registered charity No. 226686) whose Central Headquarters is at 43 Grove Park Road, Chiswick, London, W4 3RX and I declare that the receipt of the Treasurer or other proper officer for the time being of the said Association shall be sufficient discharge to my executors or trustees. 
 You can of course also: 
 A &mdash; 
 Bequest a sum of money 
 B &mdash; 
 Bequest specific property 
 C &mdash; 
 Residual Bequest  (after providing for your family and friends) 
 D &mdash; 
 Conditional Bequest 
 All these can be covered by a simple set of wording in your Will which we would be happy to provide. 
 You many also direct your Legacy to a specific R.A.F.A. project or purpose 
 Many benefactors, especially those remembering lost loved ones, like to leave property, money or other possessions for the benefit of a particular Royal Air Forces Association home, project or fund. 
 We are onluy too pleased to respect such wishes whenever possible, and will gladly advise on the best way of wording a Will to ensure that the bequest is used for 
 * 
 Endowing a room or flat in a loved one's name 
 * 
 Providing extra amenities in a particular home 
 * 
 Funding mobility aids. 
 &mdash; or for some other specifically preferred purpose. 
 You may be interested to know that the name of every legator in recorded in a Book of Commemoration kept at our Headquarters. 
 Royal Air Forces Association 
 The Association has over 600 voluntary welfare workers throughout the U.K. who are able to help ex-serving R.A.F. personnel or their dependents. 
 A broad scope of care is available through the Association, which falls into three main categories: 
 residential and convalescent homes, housing and general welfare. 
 Full time welfare officers represent individuals at pension tribunals, and are able to offer professional advice on legal matters and housing. 
 The Association is experiencing an increase in welfare casework, particularly from those who served in the Air Force during the Second World War, and who are now elderly and in need of our support. 
 At the same time, the Association is finding it increasingly difficult to meet the requirements of all those who need our assistance. 
 Can you help us? 
 RAFA All Enquiries to:  The Royal Air Forces Association Appeals Department Portland Road, Malvern, Worcestershire. 
 WR14 2TA Telephone: 0684 892505 
 Incorporated by Royal Charter Registered under the War Charities Act, 1940 &amp; Charities Act, 1960 Charity Registration Number 226686 
 We need your help with tomorrow's world 
 Yesterday and today the Royal Air Forces Association provided care for elderly and disabled ex RAF men and women. 
 Please give your financial support to help them continue their work tomorrow. 
 RAFA BATTLE OF BRITAIN WINGS APPEAL 
 Please help by giving all you can for an emblem during Wings Week or send a donation to: 
 THE ROYAL AIR FORCES ASSOCIATION APPEALS DEPT., (DS) PORTLAND ROAD, MALVERN, WORCESTERSHIRE. 
 WR14 2TA 
 I enclose a donation of &mdash; for the Wings Appeal. 
 Please debit my Credit Card no: 
 Name 
 Address 
 I am ex RAF, please send me details about membership (tick if required). 
 REPLY FORM 
 We are prepared to help by advertising your Wings Appeal and will use the following design: 
 Design A 
 Design B 
 Design C 
 Design D 
 Please supply final film/artwork in the following format: 
 Positive Film 
 Negative Film 
 Bromide 
 (Please tick one box) 
 100 lpi Screen 
 120 lpi Screen 
 133 lpi Screen 
 (Please tick one box) 
 Publication &mdash; Insertion Date &mdash; Copy Deadline &mdash; 
 We would/would not* like a full Press Pack to enable us to feature further details about your work in our publication. 
 (*Please delete as appropriate)  
 Please send the film/artwork to: 
 We will forward a voucher copy of above issue, showing the insert, as soon as possible. 
 Further requests&hellip; 
 Wings Appeal Publicity &mdash; Donated Space Appeal 
 We shall be grateful if you will donate space for any of the enclosed adverts in any of your publications, or ask advertisers to insert them as part of their own publicity. 
 If you require final, one piece film for any of the designs, then please fill in the attached reply paid card or telephone 0684 573665. 
 APPEALS DIRECTOR The Royal Air Forces Association FREEPOST  Malvern Worcs. 
 WR14 1BR 
 Battle of Britain Wings Appeal 
 Hope is not enough 
 We need your help 
 &bquo;Dramatic events in the Middle East proved once again the importance of the Royal Air Force as a fighting service. 
 Our RAF men and women have, as before, shown great spirit and courage. 
 Many RAF veterans are now fighting against the effects of disablement and illness. 
 Isn't it your turn to help them? 
 Please make a donation.&equo; 
  Patrick Moore CBE  
 How last years donations were spent 
 How the money was spent from the 1990 Wings Appeal collection 
 A 
 RAFA Welfare Aid and Advisory Services 
 1. 
 Assistance in dealing with Pensions, Legal Problems, Housing, Employment Grants and General Welfare to ex RAF men, women &amp; their families irrespective of membership 
 2. 
 Convalescent Homes and Home for the Permanently Disabled 
 3. 
 Returned to Branch Welfare Funds for Local Branch Welfare cases 
 B 
 Administrative 
 1. 
 Administrative and Publicity costs of the Appeal throughout Great Britain, Northern Ireland and Overseas 
 2. 
 Costs of Emblems and Equipment used, Printing etc. and Branch Expenses 
 TOTAL EXPENDITURE 
 Gross 1990 Wings Collection 
 Surplus* 
 *The surplus of income over expenditure will help to neet the heavy expenditure planned for the development of further supportive housing facilities for the elderly and frail. 
 If we are to continue to meet our welfare task, our target for the Wings Appeal must increase year by year. 
 How can you help the 1991 Wings Appeal 
 1. 
 Become a Member &mdash; If you have served in the Royal Air Forces you are eligible for membership. 
 Annual Membership costs only &pound;5.00. 
 2. 
 Send a Donation &mdash; I enclose a donation of &pound;&mdash; payable to the Royal Air Forces Association. 
 I would like to pay by Access/Visa Please debit my Account Signature 
 3. 
 Help the Appeal by &mdash; House to house collections during September Street collections during September Cinema collections Organising a fund raising event Providing Publicity opportunities Provide other assistance. 
 NAME ADDRESS 
 Please tick the relevant boxes if you require further details, or would like to make a donation or feel that you can help us and return this form to the appropriate address below. 
 Thank you. 
 FOR DONATIONS, DETAILS ON MEMBERSHIP AND GENERAL ENQUIRIES: 
 Appeals Department, The Royal Air Forces Association Portland Road, Malvern, Worcestershire. 
 WR14 2TA Telephone: 0684 892505. 
 The Making Of A Christian Leader 
 Schooling 
 CHILDHOOD 
 The making of Archbishops of Canterbury has been as various as the making of Popes. 
 Since the reign of Queen Mary in 1558, when the last Plantagenet to be an Archbishop died, they did not include among their number members of the royal family. 
 It was natural that most of them were educated at Oxford or Cambridge, since until the Victorian age those were the two places for training the clergy of the Church. 
 From the first Protestant Archbishop Thomas Cranmer under King Henry VIII, all the Protestant Archbishops were educated at Oxford or Cambridge and a majority taught at one of those universities. 
 For 130 years after 1558 every archbishop had been the head of an Oxford or Cambridge College. 
 They came from almost every variety of home, from one grandson of a duke to the son of someone who survived on a small-holding. 
 Several of them were the sons of merchants, some prosperous, some small, two ruined. 
 In modern times differences appeared. 
 Six of them during their career were headmasters of great schools, and this never happened before 1829, and was a sign of the rising importance which the nation gave to the teaching profession. 
 More of them were the sons or grandsons of someone in the Christian ministry. 
 All the five archbishops before Michael Ramsey were the sons or grandsons of Christian ministers. 
 Therefore, on historical precedent, in contemplating the origin of a modern archbishop we would expect him to be educated at Oxford or Cambridge; to have a good chance that he taught there; and to be the son or grandson of a Christian minister. 
 On all three counts Michael Ramsey scored. 
 Cambridge lay at the heart of his education and his career. 
 On both his father's side and his mother's side he was the grandson of a Christian minister. 
 He did even better than that. 
 On both his father's side and his mother's side he was the great-grandson of a Christian minister. 
 He was a Cambridge man born and bred. 
 He lived in the town of  Cambridge for more years of his life than in any other town, and this though he managed during his life to live in nine different towns and in one village. 
 He was the son of a Cambridge don. 
 He was sent to his first school there. 
 He was sent to study at the University of Cambridge. 
 In his student days he was happy and successful in his undergraduate career. 
 Always he remained grateful to his college. 
 Later he became the vicar of a Cambridge parish. 
 Later still he became for a short time a professor at Cambridge. 
 His aunt and sister-in-law always lived in Cambridge. 
 It surprised some that he did not retire to Cambridge. 
 After his retirement there was no place where he took more delight in an invitation to talk than in one of the Cambridge churches or one of the college chapels. 
 The place always held affection for him. 
 In the town, and in the university, he felt at home. 
 His father's father was a Congregational minister who came from Ireland early in life and ministered in various English chapels. 
 While he served a flourishing chapel at Dewsbury in Yorkshire, his son, Michael Ramsey's father, won a scholarship in mathematics to Magdalene College, Cambridge, the first generation of the family to go to a university. 
 He worked hard, which was rare among the undergraduates of Magdalene College in those days, and came out with a high degree in mathematics. 
 Though the college was very Anglican, he retained all his family's loyalty to the Congregationalist tradition and way of worship. 
 After a time teaching in a Scottish school, Fettes, the degree got him a fellowship in mathematics at his own college of Magdalene; where he remained the rest of his long life &mdash; teaching mathematics, holding various college offices, going every week to Emmanuel Congregational chapel, and becoming after a time one of its deacons or church officers. 
 He was a good mathematical teacher and he wrote a number of text-books, some of which went on selling into the 198os. 
 To the outward eye he was austere, even bleak. 
 Colleagues and pupils thought of him as formidable; a few found him frightening, a few found him affable. 
 The Master of the College, Arthur Benson, said of him humorously that when roused he would become &bquo;all eye and moustache&equo;. 
 But, wrote Michael Ramsey in retrospect &mdash; it is his own but  &mdash; &bquo;he had wit and generosity and there were pupils who had deep affection for him. 
 I was never consciously frightened of him and felt close to him and was regarded as a favourite child to him in some ways. 
 Yet I think that at the subconscious and half-conscious levels he was a heavy weight upon me of a perhaps oppressive or repressive kind. 
 In later life I was made unnecessarily unhappy by my religious divergence from his position.&equo; 
 In the long view he thought that his father's unbending moral conviction was important in his own life.  
 On a return visit to Fettes, Arthur Ramsey stayed with one of the housemasters and met the sister Agnes Wilson, who kept house there. 
 They were married in 19o2. 
 They lived at first not far from Magdalene College in a house which looked across the river Cam to Midsummer Common. 
 There the first three children were born &mdash; Frank in 1902, Michael two years later (14 November 19o4), and then Bridget, the elder daughter. 
 His grandfather on the mother's side, that is the father of Agnes Wilson, was the vicar of Horbling in Lincolnshire. 
 Michael Ramsey was therefore the grandson of a Congregationalist minister on one side and of an Anglican vicar on the other. 
 He was baptized by his Wilson grandfather at Horbling. 
 The nurse was an impostor who drugged the baby but was exposed after two days and sacked. 
 Michael Ramsey's mother was one of nine children and of the brothers two were schoolmasters, two were clergymen, one an organist, and one a doctor. 
 She studied history at St Hugh's College, Oxford &mdash; early days for a woman &mdash; and knew Lewis Carroll, and was taught by one of the best teachers then in the historical school at Oxford, a future Master of Balliol, A. L. Smith, upon whom she always looked back with gratitude. 
 Later she taught English and history at Putney High School, and before marriage published a book about Lamb's Essays of Elia  and another book about a play by Browning. 
 Child of the vicarage, she did not press her Anglicanism against her husband's nonconformity. 
 They attended the Congregational church regularly and took the children. 
 During her too short life she never ceased to be Anglican; but she was a Socialist, and a suffragette, and religion for her came to mean, not so much creed or piety, as having a lively social conscience. 
 She was not a violent demonstrator as a suffragette but she worked hard for the women's vote, and at times vociferously at public meetings. 
 After the end of the first World War she was active in the co-operative movement and the Labour Party, which was not common for a woman of her background in those early years. 
 Her son Michael's memory of her had nothing in it that was not good; a woman radiant, friendly, outgoing, understanding. 
 Politically she was alive. 
 She brought Socialist thinkers or politicians into the house, like Graham Wallas or Hugh Dalton. 
 She was a good speaker on public platforms. 
 It was recorded that when she was speaking in the market-place she was audible by the Senate House. 
 She paraded round the town in processions for votes for women. 
 She also had the powerful sense of humour which her children inherited, and could be very amusing in conversation. 
 She had other gifts which her son Michael inherited. 
 She could hold the interest of a group of  undergraduates at a tea-party and have a serious exchange of ideas with them. 
 On Sundays she would invite a group of Magdalene undergraduates to lunch and they would stay till tea; then another group still larger came to tea. 
 Her younger daughter remembered them clustered round her chair as she talked and, as someone said, &bquo;toyed with the frayed edges of a bun&equo;. 
 She took little interest in how she dressed. 
 One who knew her remembered a very large hole in her stocking. 
 Her daughter could remember greenish-black wrinkled stockings, and a newspaper report of a speech, &bquo;Mrs Ramsey &mdash; proud to be shabby&equo;. 
 But her face was interesting and intelligent and attractive. 
 Her personality was magnetic. 
 Despite the cook and the housemaid the house gave the impression of being unloved. 
 The dining-room was full of ugly sepia prints of old masters &mdash; mostly angels. 
 Much of the house was painted dark brown with pale brown walls. 
 Arthur Ramsey told his daughter that he chose this colour &bquo;because anyone could throw a coffee-cup at the wall without it showing&equo;. 
 In the kitchen stood a large bag of coke. 
 The centre-piece of the dining-room table was a bowl of electric light bulbs. 
 Despite the hilarious hostess, the house was a bit grim, not only in its d&eacute;cor. 
 Father was convinced that his wife would not have enough to live on when he died and overworked to get money. 
 He wrote textbooks, took lodgers, took pupils. 
 The children saw not much of him because all day he was out at his duties and in the evenings he retired to his study to convert his lectures into books. 
 They followed him to the study because for economy it was the only fire in the house, but he worked through their conversation and did not join it. 
 There was a cook and a maid and he could be fierce with them. 
 He could be stern even with his wife if something went wrong. 
 He was liable to terrible migraines. 
 Meal times were felt by the children to be dreary occasions. 
 He had no real friends and was difficult. 
 But he had a deep affection for his wife, and she for him. 
 They had family prayers every day after breakfast led by father. 
 The young Michael found Emmanuel church austere, and later, when he knew what that meant, puritan. 
 They sat in the family pew. 
 He thought the extemporary prayer very long and hard to bear. 
 The sermons were livelier, for the resident minister Carter was a cultivated man. 
 Michael's younger sister found him a fidget in church and thought it was fidgeting to excess. 
 He whiled away the time by contemplating the stained glass lancet windows behind the preacher and the holy table. 
 They were windows of puritan worthies, including Cromwell and Milton. 
 He liked the hymns and ever afterwards admired the Congregational hymn book.  
 The little boy loved toy soldiers and drafted speeches for the commanders-in-chief. 
 The family had holidays at Perranporth in Cornwall and if the soldiers fell into a rock pool and were drowned, Michael conducted a funeral service for them. 
 But soon he discovered that politicians were more interesting than colonels so he arranged his soldiers as though they were the House of Commons and made them harangue each other. 
 About the age of 6 he wrote a book called &bquo;Ways to the City Bright by the Rev. A. M. Ramsey&equo;. 
 Notice that at so young an age he knew that &bquo;the Rev.&equo; was better than &bquo;Rev.&equo; But the book was not orthodox in divinity because father locked it up and would not let Michael's sister read it. 
 When Michael was 5 the family moved house, only half a mile, to a larger house nearer Magdalene College, Howfield beyond Castle Hill. 
 What the older Michael mostly remembered about this were the games &mdash; croquet in which the parents joined the children, tennis, a sort of squash with his brother hitting a tennis ball against a veranda wall, expeditions up the river through the Backs and then up to the village of Grantchester. 
 The other children found Michael to be very odd, and the girls (two sisters now) resented the oddness. 
 This was in part due to a disability which was not realized. 
 He had a physical clumsiness in the management of his hands. 
 He learnt to eat tidily later than most children, and the mess down his front was hard for the others to bear. 
 But this was not all. 
 His younger sister remembered that suddenly he might leave the table with a wild mad look on his face and rush round the garden. 
 In the night he might be heard running up and down his attic bedroom banging the wall at each end, and keeping other people awake. 
 The sisters found him a loner, difficult to relate to in a normal friendly way. 
 The house, nevertheless, had visitors interesting to the children; a couple of famous Congregationalist laymen Frank Salter and Bernard Manning, both of whom were historians and riotous rompers with children; the Reddaway children who lived next door; the daughters of G. G. Coulton the English hammer of Popes; and the friendship between the two sets of children caused Coulton to take an interest in Michael and carry him off to the village church at Coton to see medieval graffiti. 
 The lodgers in the house were interesting &mdash; Indian and Siamese students trying to get into the university. 
 Michael specially liked the Siamese. 
 As the children grew, Michael felt himself a backward boy. 
 This was because of his elder brother Frank, whose academic career was already starred. 
 Michael had a sense that he pushed along behind a much cleverer creature and could not keep up. 
 Boys who feel backward grow  backward, even when they are not, for they suffer from the illusion that by nature they cannot solve the problems set to them. 
 Ramsey was sent to two dames' schools in succession but learnt so little that his parents took him away and for a year he was taught at home by his mother. 
 This he hated. 
 His mother was the most important object in his life. 
 But being taught by her made him squirm. 
 He told his sister how it was impossible to listen, and how he felt compelled to pull horrible nervous faces all the time. 
 Then the parents tried the opposite method. 
 They sent him to the King's College Choir School. 
 This is situated on the Backs, with only a short walk across to King's College and its great chapel. 
 It was not necessary for a boy to be musical; in addition to the choirboys there was an ordinary school. 
 They had day-boys. 
 Ramsey was one. 
 The boys who boarded in dormitories despised the boys who slept at home. 
 They denounced them as &bquo;mouldy day-bugs&equo;. 
 For the rest of his life Ramsey treasured with vast amusement that once he was a mouldy day-bug. 
 Here the boy met the first Anglican priest who interested him in religion. 
 The chaplain of King's College, whose work was with undergraduates, came to teach divinity to the day-boys, among whom was the little Ramsey, before breakfast on two days in the week. 
 This was Michael Ramsey's first meeting with Eric Milner-White, whom he later came to regard as one of the big men in his life and whose photograph was on his wall when he died. 
 When he looked back upon his short time at the Choir School of King's College, it was the meeting with Milner-White which he saw as the memorable gift from the school. 
 Milner-White was then a charming young man of rather Anglo-Catholic opinions who was beginning to make himself an expert both on stained glass and on ways of English worship and prayer. 
 Since he was to be the founder of the service of carols and nine lessons, he made a permanent mark on English, and not only English, life and religion. 
 What the little boys remembered about his class was that he made divinity fun, even though it was before breakfast. 
 The parents continued to find Ramsey's progress too slow. 
 They found the system of being a day-boy unsatisfactory. 
 They had four children and not much income and in those days believed like the rest of the middle class that they could only find a good education for their boy at an independent fee-paying school. 
 Therefore, if this backward boy was to get a good education, he must somehow be crammed up or taught up to scrape a scholarship at one of the big independent schools where most of the fees would be paid for scholars. 
 They now tried a boarding-school at Sandroyd in Surrey where one of the two headmasters was the brother of Mrs Ramsey. 
 Michael was  desperately homesick at first. 
 The sufferings of the young when first they go away from home and try to hold their own with cruel contemporaries are felt to be very great even when they are not. 
 It was the occasion of the first letter from Michael Ramsey which is preserved: 
 Tuesday Evening just after tea. 
 My dear mother, I never were more utterly miserable. 
 I have just had Greek before tea; It is horrid. 
 we did translation, Xenophon, I do not know a word of it I do not think Greek alone makes me miserable, I am always miserable. 
 I cannot bear it any longer, I am crying now. 
 I cannot stand it any longer, if someone does not come to me I will give up and be miserable for ever and perhaps go home of my own accord, write or wire to Uncle C. and say you are coming at once pleas darling, and come on Saturday or I will give up altogether and always wretched. 
 Do not tell any about me nor anyone except father and possibly Frank, write at once if you are going to. 
 I am too miserable for words. 
 I beleive that you will take pity and come at once, Your loving son Michael I am just crying like anythinke Come at once never mind anything else I am utterly miserable 
 His mother came, but she did not take him away, and his Uncle Charlie told him that if he wrote another letter like that he would get a thrashing, so he stayed and coped. 
 And this school, of which afterwards he could only remember that he was so homesick, must have helped the mind which was alleged to be backward and was not. 
 For in 1918 he just missed a scholarship to Winchester College; and in those days the scholarship at Winchester was regarded as the crown for the cleverest boys in England. 
 How to translate Xenophon and ancient Greek military mano&eacute;4uvres must have got into his head after all. 
 In the same year he won a scholarship at Repton not far from Derby. 
 It was not a scrape. 
 He was second to the list of scholars. 
 One of his Wilson uncles became the organist of Ely cathedral. 
 The boy often went to stay at Ely and at the age of 8 could be observed giving strangers a guided tour. 
 The visitors could be seen to be bewitched at the learning about the cathedral coming out of such callow lips. 
 Later he thought that his early affection for Fly cathedral had something to do with his interest in churches and their architecture. 
 He began to make a collection of brass rubbings.  
 REPTON 
 Repton was an Anglo-Saxon town, on the south bank of the River Trent, and was at one time a chief city of the Kingdom of Mercia. 
 Saxon remains could still be found among the buildings, there is a Saxon crypt to the church, and the setting is hauntingly beautiful. 
 It was one of the schools that came out of the Reformation, for it was founded during the reign of Queen Mary by a landowner who sat for Derbyshire in Parliament. 
 Like several such places it was a quiet little charity school until the railways came and boys could travel long distances to school and the Victorian needs of parents turned it over two decades into a modern and reputable independent school. 
 The school at Repton achieved a record by having as its headmasters two future Archbishops of Canterbury in succession. 
 William Temple came at the age of 28 and was headmaster from 1911 to 1914. 
 The Dictionary of National Biography  describes this as a pleasant interlude in his life. 
 He did not think that he judged wisely to accept, because he accepted another job only two years after he was appointed and then had to withdraw because he was found not old enough to be legal. 
 Everyone remembered him as a big man in all senses but not as a good headmaster except that he liked everyone and everyone liked him and in chapel he was a superlative speaker. 
 He was succeeded by Geoffrey Fisher, who was 27 when he became headmaster and pulled the school together. 
 In most of the seventeenth century Archbishops of Canterbury were ex-heads of Cambridge and Oxford colleges. 
 In all the eighteenth century none of the archbishops held such a post. 
 In the century from 1862 to 1961 six of the eight archbishops were former headmasters of public schools. 
 That famous churchman Arnold of Rugby put a stamp upon independent education which helped to produce this consequence. 
 Reformed universities produced able clergy whom the school could attract to their staffs; and the Victorian parent still wanted to feel that the principal educator of his child was in some way a man of God. 
 William Temple and Fisher at Repton were among the late manifestations of this feeling. 
 The pattern, that this was the way archbishops happened, was broken by the steady increase in lay headmasters during the earlier twentieth century. 
 Although Ramsey himself was to be the person who altered the pattern in archbishops, he was not the cause of the change. 
 Therefore the little Ramsey, when he arrived at Repton in 1918, met a headmaster destined to play a far more important part in his life than is the fate of most headmasters. 
 Fisher was quick, affable, capable. 
 He always saw straight to the point of an argument. 
 He could remember  who everyone was. 
 He could be a severe disciplinarian but he was not a rigid man. 
 Despite the geniality he kept his distance. 
 The small Ramsey respected Fisher with that derogatory respect which schoolboys attribute to headmasters. 
 He called Fisher &bquo;the little snipe&equo;. 
 Ramsey had no sense of rapport. 
 But it would be a miracle if a small boy felt rapport with the headmaster of a public school. 
 He came to regard Fisher as distant, but forceful and rapid and efficient, and later as friendly. 
 What at school he most admired about Fisher was the teacher of Latin and Greek. 
 Fisher had zest. 
 He rushed them along. 
 He did not delay boringly on points of scholarship. 
 He bubbled along with enthusiasm and humour. 
 He made the dead languages into living literature. 
 The small Ramsey was not happy. 
 His eye was not swift in pursuit of the ball, his muscles not yet co-ordinated. 
 He did not like cricket or football. 
 The school was very good at cricket, Ramsey was not. 
 He resented the cult of those religions. 
 He preferred to spend time in the school library. 
 He liked to work away at Latin or Greek, or to pick books of history or biography off the shelves. 
 Some afternoons he was forced onto the field and trotted around with boredom. 
 When there were not games he disappeared into the library and found himself the only person in the building. 
 He was not a good fielder at cricket. 
 He would go off into a musing in the outfield. 
 &bquo;I had a curious strain of not attending to things which failed to grip my interest.&equo; 
 His father believed that he had a good eye and could have played the game well if he was not liable to slip into a trance and forget that his attention was needed. 
 These attitudes did not commend themselves to his colleagues. 
 They regarded him as an oddity. 
 Boys of 15 are not accustomed to make the lives of odd boys happy. 
 They believe in conformity. 
 His trousers usually fell down a bit and he was observed to be always hitching them up by peculiar digs with his elbows. 
 Even Geoffrey Fisher decided that he was eccentric. 
 The young society was not drawn to quaintness, or studiousness, or absence of mind in the outfield. 
 The three schoolmasters upon whom he looked back with gratitude tell something about the boy: (1) a clear-headed Anglo-Catholic priest with a rasp of a voice who taught classics, Henry Balmforth: (2) the librarian Burd, a true classical scholar, and the only master in the school said not to know the name of the captain of cricket: (3) a gentle teacher (Hayward), more expert at moths and butterflies than adolescents. 
 In his last years at Repton he was happier. 
 By then he won the right to be an oddity. 
 He discovered an unexpected gift which won boys' respect. 
 He found that he could make a speech &mdash; that is, he could think on his feet, and not be at a loss for words. 
 At the school debating society  he won a name; and he quickly discovered a truth never discovered by some undergraduates nor even by some mature debaters, that you cannot speak well unless you care. 
 At that moment the politics of the world was exciting. 
 The emotions of a just-ended war, with millions dead, were rampant. 
 The general election of 1918 brought Lloyd George to renewed power on an unpleasant ticket, Hang the Kaiser. 
 Ramsey's father and mother were nauseated by the jingoism. 
 They resented Lloyd George for ousting his predecessor Asquith, whom they admired as a great Liberal prime minister. 
 In the election of 1918 they could not bear it and both voted for the Labour Party. 
 Their young son at Repton was stirred. 
 He turned Asquith into a private hero. 
 He was excited by Asquith's successes, cast into melancholy by his defeats. 
 In the school library he hunted out books on politics. 
 Soon this hero-worship was informed. 
 He discovered about Liberal politics in Ireland, or Free Trade, or the League of Nations. 
 And this caused a flaming row at the school debating society. 
 At the age of 15 this boy was blisteringly opposed to the Allied armies being sent to Russia to fight Bolshevism. 
 An assistant master with Tory opinions spoke in favour of the need for the armies in Russia. 
 Ramsey was very rude to him in the debate. 
 It was not customary for boys at school to attack their masters rudely even in debate. 
 There followed what Ramsey described as &bquo;some unpleasantness&equo;. 
 He had to recite from memory in front of his headmaster fifty Greek lines from the play Medea  &mdash; a severe punishment, for learning fifty lines of verse in a language imperfectly known would take several hours of spare time. 
 The severity may have had a cause hidden from the young Ramsey. 
 just before he arrived at the school Victor Gollancz left its staff, ejected because he tried to rouse boys' minds by heady and daring political argument. 
 In a war for the nation's life this was held by external authorities to be provocative. 
 The Gollancz scandal, as the blimps thought of it, was widely known. 
 Though the war then ended, the headmaster of Repton could not but be wary of political passion expressed by boys. 
 Gollancz was the notorious thing about Repton in 1918&ndash;19. 
 The small Ramsey knew nothing about this controversy. 
 Yet he had to spend hours of his time learning Greek iambic verse as a punishment for being rude to a master in a political debate. 
 This boyish hatred of military interference to put down Communism in Russia had a long consequence. 
 Ramsey developed a hatred of the chief proponent of interference in Russia, Winston Churchill. 
 For the rest of Churchill's life, Ramsey distrusted him. 
 Meanwhile he became a regular speaker at debates. 
 In his maturity what he remembered of his  style of speaking were purple passages and a rather caustic irony. 
 But he also remembered that by the time he left school he was &bquo;a thoroughly political animal&equo;. 
 He came into battle with the school over the obligation to parade with the Officers Training Corps. 
 By 1920 the memory of the Great War spoke more loudly than ever. 
 During the war military training took several hours of the school curriculum and this did not end with the armistice. 
 To get out of the military training then given at boarding schools needed iron determination and met pressure from schoolmasters and unpopularity among boys. 
 Ramsey could not say he was a pacifist. 
 He was nothing but glad that Britain won a war. 
 He could not say that he had scruples of conscience for not joining in the military training. 
 When asked by Geoffrey Fisher to explain his reasons, he found that he had difficulty in finding a reason. 
 He said that he thought it wrong to encourage a military spirit, and that it was contrary to the ideals of disarmament. 
 He made his headmaster admit that military training was not (strictly speaking) compulsory, armed himself with a letter from his father, and won the contest of wills. 
 That summer of 1920 he had conversations which affected his mind and may have been decisive indirectly for his future choice of career. 
 In the summer of 1920, the family went on a sea-side holiday to Hollandon-sea near Clacton. 
 His elder brother Frank was 17 and revered by Michael who was 15. 
 Frank, at the age of 16, had already won a scholarship to Trinity College in Cambridge. 
 But the disparity in intelligence which Michael felt or imagined made no difference to their affection. 
 They were both ungainly. 
 Both had huge laughs. 
 Both were untidy. 
 Both were thought odd by their contemporaries. 
 And, already in adolescence, both cared for the things of the mind. 
 They walked together along the sands, and talked. 
 Michael had a problem on his mind. 
 He was the child of a religious father and a more vaguely religious mother. 
 Yet his closest school-friend, that previous summer term, he found to be an agnostic. 
 The quarrel between faith and unbelief touched him for the first time and unsettled his mind. 
 On one of the walks on the beach, he told Frank about his unsettlement. 
 He discovered to his astonishment that Frank now professed atheism. 
 Frank said that he did not believe in God; such a belief cannot possibly be proved; the good life is possible without it; and the only faculty to judge is the reason, which tells us to say, we do not know. 
 This discovery of Frank's atheism was more than a perturbation to Michael. 
 He was so worried by it that he took it, and his own doubts about faith, to his father. 
 Arthur Ramsey gave Michael a book by a  scientist (Romanes) who was once an atheist and later became a believer. 
 When he got back to Cambridge Michael (still a boy of 15) read Romanes. 
 The book helped him and satisfied his mind for the time. 
 This debate caused a reaction in the direction opposite to Frank's. 
 He resolved to practise his religion better. 
 Accustomed at home to Congregational worship and at school to the Book of Common Prayer, he found that he liked the Common Prayer better. 
 With father's leave he was confirmed in the Church of England at school. 
 He was just 16. 
 Father made no difficulty. 
 He expected him henceforth to be both a Congregationalist and an Anglican. 
 Neither father nor son realized that this was the start of a sundering between them. 
 Geoffrey Fisher prepared him for confirmation. 
 Afterwards he thought this course of instruction sound and sensible. 
 At Repton he was already interested in Anglo-Catholicism; perhaps from reaction against father's nonconformity, perhaps from reaction against his headmaster Fisher's common sense. 
 In the school library he found a bizarre book from the Protestant underworld, Walsh's Secret  History of the Oxford Movement  (third edition 1898), which pictured Anglo-Catholics as conspirators to promote tyranny, lies, and immorality. 
 The boy saw through the fanaticism and found that his sense of chivalry was excited. 
 One of the nastiest pseudo-religious books of the Victorian age helped to condition the impressionable mind of a future Christian leader of the next century. 
 On top of all this was the constant need to defend his religion against a clever elder brother who was an atheist. 
 The two brothers had conversation after conversation on the theme of religion, the younger one sticking to his guns. 
 The elder said that reason dismissed religion. 
 The younger said that religious experience was too valid to be dismissed by mere reason, that reason was not all of humanity. 
 The argument went on and on. 
 The elder was contemptuous when the younger replied to his crushing arguments by the reply, the reason why you think like that is that you don't say your prayers. 
 Michael's problem was that he saw the glamour in Frank's position: the love of liberty; the excitement in the free pursuit of truth; the shaking off of convention and mere conformity; the feeling that religion was a &bquo;stuffy valley&equo; out of which he had grown. 
 He also had to recognize that his brother was an unselfish person; so that the axiom, &bquo;only religious people are unselfish&equo; did not wash. 
 The argument was a fire in which to test an immature faith. 
 A school prize was offered for a study of the book Belief in God  by Bishop Charles Gore. 
 When Frank heard that Michael thought of going in for the prize on this set book he was indignant and sent a message to Michael, &bquo;Who in his senses would read a book by a bishop?&equo;  
 Where should he go next? 
 Everyone took it for granted that it must be Oxford or Cambridge. 
 Fisher saw that this mind was not the grammarian or writer of Greek and Latin prose such as Cambridge liked, but was a meditative, half-philosophical mind, which might be better suited in the Oxford school. 
 Ramsey's father was determined to have the boy at his own university and if possible at his own college. 
 The Master of Magdalene, Arthur Benson, encouraged the idea. 
 In December 1922 Ramsey took the scholarship examination of a group of colleges containing Magdalene and was given the top classical scholarship. 
 At the time all the family rejoiced with him. 
 It paid for a lot of education. 
 Later in life he wondered whether it was the blessing that it seemed. 
 Though he had won a scholarship, he would never be interested in the niceties of Greek and Latin languages. 
 He was glad to have the equipment to enable him to read Greek and Latin. 
 Afterwards it turned out to be indispensable to his career. 
 But the books which he took from the shelves in those stolen hours in the school library were history and biography and political science. 
 What he most wanted to know about was not the ancient world but modern politics with its historical background. 
 He wondered afterwards whether his unlooked-for success in the examination caused him to read the wrong subject at the university. 
 In old age he used to regret that he did so well in the classical scholarship because it caused him not to read history. 
 Ramsey went out of his years at school with a sense of contentment which in retrospect he knew to be a veneer. 
 He pretended to himself that Repton was a gloriously happy time. 
 He was too much of a nonconformist in his origins, too much of an individualist, at that time too much of an oddity, ever to be really happy in so tight-knit a community as a boarding-school. 
 Geoffrey Fisher wrote a last school report which in later years became legendary: &bquo;A boy with plenty of force of character who, in spite of certain uncouthnesses, has done good service on his own lines&equo;. 
 In this report the mature Ramsey specially valued not only the word uncouth-  nesses  but also the pointed description of his nonconforming character in the phrase on his own lines.  
 In September 1923 the Master of Magdalene, Arthur Benson, lunched with the Ramsey family in Cambridge. 
 It was a few days before Michael Ramsey first became an undergraduate at his college. 
 The Master recorded in his diary: &bquo;Michael, a distressing object, so sharp-faced, dull-eyed, spotted&equo;. 
 Or, a little later, &bquo;Michael sharp-faced, slightly priggish, friendly&equo;. 
 Ramsey was still 18 and had not shed the spots of adolescence. 
 Later in life no one could have called him dull-eyed or sharp-faced. 
 His adult eyes sparkled with amusement and  vitality. 
 His mature face was more likely to remind the observer of Friar Tuck's jollity than of Lord Brougham's long pointed nose. 
 MAGDALENE 
 Ramsey arrived at the university in October 1923. 
 He remembered that at his formal entry (matriculation) the praelector of the college gave all the new undergraduates advice on their deportment: &bquo;If a Fellow asks you to lunch, leave at 2.15 p.m.; unless the general conversation is particularly interesting when you may leave at 2.25 p.m.&equo; 
 His fellow-undergraduates thought of him as a gangly youth with brown hair. 
 He had rooms in the beautiful Pepys building, at the end which looked over the River Cam and across the river to some slum-like warehouses. 
 He found that the rooms next door were occupied by Selwyn Lloyd, whom he discovered to be like himself a strong Liberal and with whom he was therefore soon friends. 
 He did not find it awkward that his own father was the tutor of the college and so responsible in a double sense for his pastoral care. 
 Nor did he find it awkward that the tutor's rooms were immediately below his own in the Pepys building. 
 Evidently he did not expect to give riotous or alcoholic parties at times when the tutor might be in. 
 The undergraduates found him a leg-puller, and a reveller in political argument. 
 The chaplain of the college was a pleasant gentleman, his teacher of classics was a worthy pedant, and neither meant much to him. 
 The person who meant a lot to him was the Master. 
 Arthur Benson recovered from several years of mental breakdown about two years previously and was in the evening summer of his life. 
 He wrote beautiful, at times too beautiful prose. 
 He published at least one book a year; readers who began could not put them down, though at the end of the book they had received nothing. 
 He kept meditating on the highest ideals and professed weakness to do anything about those ideals. 
 He observed naughtily, subtly, wittily, passively, on occasion with a feline caress. 
 He enjoyed well-mannered, good-looking, and well-to-do undergraduates. 
 Michael Ramsey qualified only under the first of those epithets. 
 Benson had what Michael Ramsey called &bquo;romantic favourites&equo;. 
 But Benson drew out all undergraduates. 
 He talked to them as equals, criticized their essays, and was liked. 
 His mind usually stayed at the level of gossip and anecdote but not always. 
 His diary has been well edited: to read it is like looking into a large egg-shell full of bubbles. 
 The undergraduates of Magdalene used to say about their Master that he spent the morning doing nothing and spent the afternoon writing about what he had done in the morning.  
 Ramsey was fascinated by his Master. 
 He liked him very much, and felt the enchantment, and found it almost a spell. 
 In his first term he had to write for him an essay on the art of poetry. 
 Yet he also found in him a warning. 
 He observed the introspection and its richness of imagination with a certain alarm; Benson looking into himself and finding there, as Ramsey put it, &bquo;a huge world of fantasy&equo;, which caused him distress and yet conditioned his affection for the human race. 
 Ramsey realized that it was possible for a mind to inhabit a partly unreal world. 
 It was pleasant to be quiet in an armchair thinking. 
 He decided that for him to sit back and imagine, to follow a Bensonian way and be a dilettante among refined ideas, was an actual temptation. 
 He disliked the notion. 
 He kept fit at the university by playing a little hockey, in summer tennis, in winter walking and bicycling and going for runs. 
 Twice he won the Old Boys race at King's College school. 
 The early interest in church architecture and brasses afforded him destinations for the bicycle. 
 On these rides, sometimes of many miles, he found things with which Emmanuel Congregational church and Repton school chapel had not made him familiar. 
 He found Anglo-Catholic country churches. 
 He was interested in their notice-boards and what they said. 
 He started to pay attention to the fittings in the chancel and the ornaments. 
 These empty country churches were not dead or cold to him. 
 He rode his bicycle like a pilgrim on the quest for a holy city. 
 Neither the religion of the school chapel, nor the religion of a puritan church, satisfied. 
 He looked for signs of a faith more supernatural, less conventional, more revolutionary. 
 His mother was still prominent in the Cambridge Labour Party. 
 Michael went with her to meetings and joined her when she worked for the Liberal cause because it was the next best thing to Labour. 
 The freshman soon made a name for himself in debates at the Union, which is the historic Cambridge debating society. 
 His appearance, that first term, failed to impress everyone as it failed to impress the Master of his college. 
 He was thick-set, with a moustache. 
 He spoke with clarity, and humour, and charm, and when he felt strongly, with passion. 
 He had a curious sing-song voice which was a handicap, but the voice had musical timbre and was attractive. 
 Some critics thought him sonorous but the word was not uncomplimentary. 
 He first spoke on the French invasion of the Ruhr. 
 In March 1925 he beat a Conservative mediocrity in an election for secretary of the Union, in Michaelmas 1925 he was vice-president, in Lent 1926 president. 
 Ramsey's weight in debates rested upon more than his manner and his fluency and his command of words. 
 He could be vehement in  denunciation. 
 On occasion marvellous phrases sprang out of his mouth and enthralled the audience. 
 On off days he could sound tired, and sometimes excitement carried him away to an excess of length. 
 He was not the cleverest speaker in the house, a palm which by general consent went to the very Tory Charles Smyth, and the house also contained Patrick Devlin and Selwyn Lloyd and sometimes Rab Butler. 
 But he was the most persuasive speaker in the house, for he had a cause which he believed in morally. 
 Patrick Devlin regarded him as the most effective speaker of his time: 
 He was not clever or epigrammatic in the Union manner and only occasionally witty, but always spoke as though he had something to contribute to the debate. 
 He projected himself as a man who would be worth listening to. 
 He spoke weightily &mdash; the words deliberately produced and, as it were, laid on the table. 
 He left behind him the impression &mdash; but not as if he had ever meant to say it &mdash; that anyone who disagreed with him must really be rather stupid. 
 In the autumn of 1924 the general election reduced the Liberal Party to a pitiable number of MPs. 
 Asquith lost his seat. 
 Whether it was the unsavoury reputation of the government of Lloyd George; or whether it was the division in the party between the followers of Lloyd George and the followers of Asquith; or whether it was the aftermath of universal suffrage and the desire of the working man for a party which he could call his own &mdash; it now looked certain that the party division of the country would no longer lie between Liberal and Conservative but in a wider gulf between Conservative and Labour, with the Liberal Party on the sideline. 
 And since Cambridge University of 1924 was hardly likely to breed recruits for the Labour Party &mdash; that took another three years &mdash; the young men and women of the university could not do much but move, or move further, towards the Conservative side. 
 Ramsey believed none of this. 
 He was sure that the Liberal idea was what the country needed. 
 He was determined to resurrect the Liberalism of Cambridge, and turn it into a force among junior members of the university. 
 In what the Liberal idea consisted he was clear. 
 Whether he would have been able to stick to it if he had ever risen to be national leader of the Liberal Party is not certain. 
 It had about it the idealism of youth. 
 But because it was idealistic it was the more persuasive when he preached it to his young contemporaries. 
 Conservatives and Socialists are committed to dogmas. 
 Socialism has a dogma that private enterprise is wrong. 
 Conservatism has a dogma that the State should not intervene. 
 Only Liberalism is free to use State action where it is needed, to refrain where that is better. 
 It is the Liberal idea which gives its adherents the freedom to think and enquire, and not  follow a party leader like sheep. 
 Liberals care passionately for the individual, and for the freedom of the individual. 
 Here was Socialism putting forward irrelevant theories of class war and wanting to rule the country by a set of theories which had nothing to do with the welfare of the people. 
 And here was Conservatism, with a do-nothing prime minister in Mr Baldwin, with an out-of-date commitment to maintaining the British Empire in a world where it had ceased to be possible or right to maintain it, so that we spent millions in building a fortress at Singapore while we spent nothing more on housing or education. 
 Ramsey could grip the house by pouring ridicule into whatever he hated. 
 He could be scarifying in his abuse of imperialists. 
 At the end of one debate there was nothing left of either Fascism or Communism when he had finished with them. 
 But what causes them? 
 Who will be our upstart Mussolini? 
 To be an upper class party is to breed malcontents, that is to encourage revolutionaries. 
 To be a Socialist class party is to encourage revolutionaries and therefore to breed reaction, which is Fascism. 
 &bquo;Liberalism alone is the great Lady Surgeon of a nation's maladies, and while she is temporarily abed with a broken limb, the nation is the sufferer&equo; (Ramsey in the Gownsman , 6 December 1924). 
 He electrified the house by vituperating the way the House of Commons behaves. 
 Members troop into lobbies at the beck of a party leader as though they have no minds to use. 
 He spoke of the monstrous word Whip to describe the officer who marshals the privates. 
 He spoke of the way Britain failed to take care of the environment and lamented the creeping of towns and the vanishing of the fields and hedgerows, not so much because of the animals as because of the air and the nature of man and the liberty of the soul. 
 He had one side of him, in those days, which suspected modern science because of its part in the process of industrialization, and its philistine attitude, as he supposed, to literature. 
 He bewildered his audience for a moment, and then moved them, when he suddenly turned a political invective about government's neglect of the environment into a lament that one of the sad losses was going to be the poetry of the countryside, the pastorals of a Vergil or a Theocritus. 
 &bquo;He would be keener&equo;, thought one young observer, &bquo;upon reviving perishing literature than a perishing political party. 
 In the Union he was very popular. 
 A visitor who heard him speak long remembered how the feeling of the meeting rose towards him when he got on his legs. 
 He could be very funny indeed. 
 He had a gift of mimicry, and when he made a speech as though he were Asquith or Lloyd George it would raise shouts of laughter. 
 Once he acted the part of Asquith in some amateur dramatics, and danced round the stage with &bquo;Lloyd George&equo;, singing most comically a refrain which he wrote himself.  
 In the eyes of that generation of students he gave Liberalism a magic, a faith in the future. 
 And he carried that Conservative generation to vote a motion which preferred Liberalism to Conservatism as the better future for the country. 
 Meanwhile he neglected his classics by engaging as a Liberal campaigner in the elections of 1923 and 1924. 
 He toured the villages of Cambridgeshire speaking on behalf of the candidates, and spoke in several halls of the town. 
 At one village he was the only one of the appointed speakers to turn up. 
 Undismayed, he haled an old man out of the audience, stuck him in the chair, and then spoke himself for an hour and answered all the questions. 
 At another meeting in the open air he spoke from a cart and was tumbled when a member of the proletariat told the horse to Gee up. 
 He wrote &bquo;Michael Ramsey's Monthly Message&equo; for the Cambridgeshire Liberal Magazine, which thereafter was scattered among the villagers. 
 The climax was on 10 March 1925. 
 Asquith came to speak at Cambridge &mdash; now as the Earl of Oxford and Asquith. 
 He brought with him his wife Margot, whom Benson in his diary described as very witch-like. 
 Ramsey was asked to meet him at dinner in Magdalene before the meeting and to second the vote of thanks in the Guildhall. 
 At dinner the undergraduate in his second year got on well with the ex-prime minister, which is a mark up to both sides. 
 There were queues for the meeting, many could not get in, war-songs of the Liberal party were sung, they greeted the speaker with &bquo;For he's a jolly good fellow&equo;. 
 A lady chairman, horribly nervous, spent too long introducing Asquith. 
 Asquith made a speech of forty minutes which Benson described to himself as robust but dull, and which reads dully. 
 He spoke a message which the country has heard before &mdash; that taxation is too heavy, that unemployment (1&frac12; million) is too high, that we spend far too much on armaments and must get disarmament in Europe, that we must stick to Free Trade&hellip; 
 Frank Salter, who was the Liberal candidate for Cambridge borough, made &bquo;a genial solid&equo; speech of thanks. 
 Then Ramsey rose to second the vote of thanks. 
 The local newspaper called his speech breezy. 
 It is usually good to speak when the audience is bored. 
 Ramsey spoke out about his faith for Liberalism and talked eloquently about the freedom of Liberal minds. 
 He could say sentences which would have been preposterous if they were seen as rhetoric but which he could carry because they were delivered with uproarious humour &mdash; &bquo;Liberalism prolonged one's youth, Liberalism did not decay&equo;. 
 The speech, observed Benson, who thought it remarkable, was &bquo;rapturously received&equo; by that huge audience. 
 Asquith was moved. 
 He rose to give thanks for the thanks. 
 He  publicly prophesied from that platform that this young man would one day be the leader of the Liberal Party. 
 Ramsey afterwards could not remember a word that he had said in his speech. 
 He only knew that the speech had told and that he raised applause, and that he made some jokes which aroused laughter. 
 Not long afterwards the Liberal Party invited this undergraduate in his second year to be the party's candidate for the county of Cambridgeshire in the next election. 
 He went to a meeting with the party caucus. 
 &bquo;I said that I could not commit myself as my academic time was not yet finished, but I would like to be at their disposal later.&equo; 
 He had decided that his career would be in politics. 
 As vice-president of the Union he went to the United States (September-November 1925) as part of a debating team of three, all of whom were later well-known in public life. 
 The other two were Patrick Devlin and Geoffrey Lloyd. 
 They went round American universities challenging the debaters. 
 The moments which both Devlin and Lloyd remembered most clearly were the perils to Ramsey's life. 
 He had long shown traces of absent-mindedness. 
 If he thought something interesting, he would desert what he was doing and amble off to meditate on the new idea, muttering to himself as he walked. 
 When he played tennis with his sister, he would infuriate her by wandering off the court to contemplate. 
 He scared the passengers when he drove a car, if some bright idea came into his mind. 
 So now in America his two friends had to rescue him from certain death by yanking him back, as he meditated and was about to walk in front of a fast street-car. 
 In American universities they poured scorn on the cult of material prosperity. 
 The new law of prohibition of alcohol afforded them marvellous matter for the pleading of the liberty of men and women against the tyranny of majorities, and they sang or preached several eloquent perorations in praise of freedom. 
 An agitated old lady addressed Ramsey severely and asked why he did not go back to his own country and do good there instead of stirring up trouble in the United States. 
 They made a lot of jokes in their speeches, which pleased and shocked the Americans, for it was not then thought right in American debates. 
 Ramsey's own preferred subjects were literature versus science as making for happiness, modern democracy, and internationalism, in which he denounced American isolationism and had an imaginative picture of the American Middle West as a lot of boors who did not know where Europe was. 
 The Americans got them to debate the League of Nations. 
 But Ramsey had an alarming faculty for seeing through his own utterances. 
 As he waxed into an eloquent period, he would realize the absurdity of his situation or the humbug of his pleading and be  overcome with internal laughter, a laughter so vast that on occasion it left him too weak to go on with the speech. 
 All three speakers had Celtic blood. 
 They let Celtic fire run, uninhibitedly. 
 The result of all this politics &mdash; and Ramsey's sense that he might be reading the wrong subject, because his interests were now more modern than ancient &mdash; meant that his classics did not go as might be expected of someone who won a scholarship. 
 In the examination of that June 1925 (Classics Part I) Ramsey's name was to be found in the second class. 
 His Magdalene friend Selwyn Lloyd was in the same class. 
 Ramsey turned to study law, which then was regarded as the best training for a future politician. 
 He started eating dinners at the Inner Temple. 
 This was a necessity to qualify for a later call to the Bar. 
 But across this political work came another interest. 
 A legend was afterwards believed that William Temple converted Ramsey in a mission to the university in February 1926. 
 The truth was more complex. 
 The relationship with his brother Frank must not be forgotten. 
 In private Michael still had to keep his end up against attacks, that to be religious was to be a fool, though less frequently now because Frank travelled abroad and was away much of the time. 
 Across the road from Magdalene College was the parish church of St Giles. 
 It was Anglo-Catholic in its way of worship. 
 Ramsey attended. 
 Here for the first time he found something of what the pilgrim on his bicycle had sought: &bquo;the sense of mystery, and awe, and of another world at once far and near&hellip; a sense that we were vividly in the presence of the passion of Jesus and also vividly near to heaven, to which the passion mysteriously belonged, so as to be brought from the past to the present&equo;. 
 His nonconformist origin found it strange, if not reprehensible, that at the main service of the day no one but the priest took the sacrament. 
 Soon he came to value this practice very much. 
 It left his mind free for &bquo;pondering, adoring&equo;. 
 In 1926 the Anglo-Catholics in Cambridge were strong. 
 At Little St Mary's was the future stalwart enemy of apartheid, Geoffrey Clayton. 
 The vicar of St Giles introduced him to the little religious group called the Oratory of the Good Shepherd, and one of those priests, Gordon Day, became a friend of Ramsey and adviser in religion. 
 At King's was the former teacher of little Ramsey at the choir school, now a member of the Oratory of the Good Shepherd, Eric Milner-White. 
 At Pembroke College was Edward Wynn, one of the kindest dons to grace Cambridge during the twentieth century, and another member of the Oratory of the Good Shepherd. 
 The author of this memoir, while an undergraduate, once borrowed fourteen books about history from Edward Wynn and, on the way to return them, inadvertently dropped  them all into the River Pem &mdash; and so is better placed than anyone to testify how good a man was Edward Wynn. 
 At the house of the Oratory of the Good Shepherd not far from Magdalene College was one of the remarkable Knox brothers, Wilfred. 
 He earned an honest penny by teaching the New Testament to a few undergraduates, who needed to be agile to follow his paradoxes and who found themselves hoeing the weeds when they expected to study St Paul's Epistle to the Galatians. 
 Ramsey invited his Master to lunch and invited Knox to meet him. 
 Benson was not impressed. 
 Benson's Diary, 25 May 1925: &bquo;I'm not wholly at ease with Michael. 
 Father Wilfred Knox, a nice fellow but with a horrible mirthless titter. 
 We sparkled with energy, but I struck few sparks. 
 He is a priest of the Oratory&hellip; 
 I wonder if the Oratory is any good?&equo; 
 Wilfred Knox's laugh was the highest titter most of his friends ever heard. 
 But it was a titter far from being mirthless. 
 He passed his life in a cacophony of amusement at the quaintness of the human race. 
 This meeting was one of Benson's last meetings with his undergraduate Ramsey. 
 That 17 June 1925 he died of heart-failure following pleurisy. 
 He was succeeded as Master of Magdalene by another Eton schoolmaster, A. B. Ramsay. 
 Slowly Michael Ramsey began to realize that the eternal verities were more important to him than the political excitements. 
 He started to see that in his opinion more could be done for humanity by Churches than by political parties, even the best of political parties such as he took the Liberal Party to be; or at least that the Churches engaged at a more profound level with the predicament of humanity. 
 How should he express this feeling? 
 He tried attending meetings of the Student Christian Movement, and was bored. 
 He tried the historic evangelical society, the Christian Union, known as CICCU, and was repelled by its insistence that every word of the Bible was historically true. 
 In spare time &mdash; between politics and classics there was little spare time &mdash; he began to read a few books of theology. 
 By the middle of 1925 he had fairly clear convictions about Catholic Christianity. 
 In his third year (1925&ndash;6) he went to private confession for the first time. 
 For that purpose he went to Edward Wynn. 
 In February 1926 the religious groups in the university agreed, after much difficulty, upon the common organization of a mission to the university. 
 The difficulty was that the evangelicals took a low view of the deans and chaplains of colleges, and did not expect that anything run by them would have force and challenge. 
 The deans and chaplains of colleges were nervous lest the evangelicals bring in a firebrand of a missioner who would repel their undergraduates not only from his  mission but from religion. 
 The various parties reached agreement at last. 
 William Temple, the future Archbishop of Canterbury, then Bishop of Manchester, fat, jolly, eloquent, and philosophical, should be the chief missioner and give his talks for a week in the university church, Great St Mary's. 
 Norwood from London should be the missioner from the nonconformist Churches. 
 The evangelical group, the CICCU, brought in a Northern Irish missioner, W. P. Nicholson, who was a man of fire. 
 The mission opened with a meeting at the Guildhall; at which Ramsey, being now president of the Union, was selected to take the chair. 
 He read the opening prayers from the platform and spoke impressively to the undergraduates about their attitudes to the mission. 
 Temple's address was fine, Norwood's middling, and Nicholson's embarrassing in the extreme, so that the chairman hastily closed the meeting. 
 Coming out of the meeting, a lady was heard remarking, &bquo;Mr Ramsey spoke very nicely but I do think he is young to be Master of a College&equo;; for she thought that he was the new Master of Magdalene whose name was the same except for the spelling. 
 Nicholson was an Irish presbyterian of one of the more extreme sorts. 
 He used to be a seaman. 
 He worked among the poor of the Shankill Road, and later became an evangelist in America. 
 The time of Irish Civil War after 1919 was a time of hot emotion, of many murders in Belfast, and of religious revival in Northern Ireland. 
 Nicholson was an important piece of that revival. 
 Shipyard workers used to march to his services. 
 He was against tobacco, and against dancing, and against cinemas, and against going to church only once on Sundays. 
 He was much against theologians. 
 He was much against choirs in church. 
 He was much against professors of theology. 
 There were sensible men who thought him the finest evangelist of his generation. 
 And if the committee of the CICCU be taxed with bringing in someone who did not fit the undergraduates of a university, it might be replied, first that they were desperate to find someone at short notice, and secondly, was it desirable that a missioner should fit the undergraduates? 
 The contrast during the week of mission was so extraordinary as to affect Ramsey's life. 
 In the three places of mission there were on aggregate some 2,500 members of the university every night of the week. 
 Temple talked rationally and effectively in Great St Mary's and held his audience. 
 Norwood, despite thoughtfulness and humour, slowly lost adherents to the other two speakers. 
 In Holy Trinity Church Nicholson abounded in anecdotes, vulgarity, rudeness, emotional appeals, a dogmatism so dogmatic as to frighten. 
 More and more people went to hear this phenomenon in a university of the crudest fundap 25 mentalism, which horrified some of the dons as a caricature of Christianity. 
 People who could not bear it walked out. 
 The speaker offended by gross lapses of taste &mdash; &bquo;It is time that old bachelor on the Tiber got married&equo;, &mdash; &bquo;Nicodemus was a religious sneak&equo; &mdash; and by forceful appeals &mdash; &bquo;Will the hypocrites please leave the church?&equo; 
 &mdash; and thirty or forty people walked out. 
 He was not, commented the journalist from the local paper, &bquo;perhaps very convincing to men and women eager to find out what Christianity really means&equo;. 
 Some of the young were moved by Nicholson; he was human and had pathos and they needed dogma. 
 The university sighed with relief when he went away. 
 Afterwards it was said that at this mission Temple converted Michael Ramsey to decisive Christianity. 
 No one who reads the speech of the President of the Union at the inaugural meeting of the mission, before Temple opened his mouth, can suppose that that President needed converting to Christianity. 
 Later in life Ramsey denied that Temple had this supposed effect upon him. 
 Nevertheless, effect there was. 
 Ramsey's friends thought that he was an agnostic and were surprised to see him so prominent at the mission. 
 Chairman at the inaugural meeting, he attended Temple every night of the week and attended Nicholson once. 
 That Nicholson evening had consequences. 
 He was nauseated by the absurdities of the faith propounded and the way it was presented. 
 The seven evenings under Temple gave him not much new, because he had read Temple. 
 It was not Temple's oratory which persuaded him, for he thought it &bquo;rather rotund&equo;. 
 What persuaded him were two bits of Temple's mind which he could not mistake. 
 First, Temple confronted the life of the real world in all its complexity. 
 Secondly, he cared about the intellectual question in religious life. 
 He looked at the difficulties, with open eyes. 
 Ramsey ended the week with a conviction that Temple's quiet explanation of a Christian philosophy of life was the right way to expound Christianity in modern society and that the emotional popular mission was the wrong way because it appealed to the wrong emotions. 
 His experience of Nicholson shocked him. 
 &bquo;That one evening created in me a deep and lasting dislike of the extreme evangelical style of evangelism.&equo; 
 Temple had neither converted him, nor given him his vocation. 
 But, Ramsey put it, his mission &bquo;certainly helped to clinch matters&equo;. 
 Throughout his life he never lost the admiration for the mind, character, warmth, and friendliness of Temple. 
 Into extreme old age he would lecture about Temple's mind in words rendered all the more penetrating by the obvious gratitude which the memory brought. 
 He wanted to be buried near Temple's remains. 
 And for the rest of his life he recoiled from the popular mission and missioner. 
 He so disliked  them that when he became archbishop it complicated his life. 
 It made him naturally suspicious of Billy Graham, who among popular missioners was as far from William Nicholson as was possible. 
 In this new mood where religion was more important than politics, he thought he would like to see how the Church went in East London, at that time notorious as a depressed urban area within the national life. 
 During the Easter vacation he spent a fortnight working in Stepney. 
 A fortnight is not long. 
 It was enough. 
 At the end he knew with certainty that it was not the lawyer, nor the politician, who was the best hope for care in the country, but the Church. 
 Afterwards he decided that his intense preoccupation with politics and the Liberal Party had not represented his true conviction. 
 He felt the change to be rather like &bquo;the shedding of an adolescent enthusiasm,. 
 The observer is sure that his memory must be wrong. 
 The Liberal politics were too ardent to be mere intellectual exercise. 
 We may question whether between the young Liberal Party candidate and the young Christian teacher lay such a gulf as afterwards he fancied. 
 THE ORDINAND 
 The best of deciding to be ordained is the knowledge that you dimly see your future and have the courage to embark on an irreversible way and feel that at least you commit yourself to help humanity in its suffering or its moral predicament. 
 The worst is the complexity of personal relationships that ensues. 
 Old friends who are not Christians think that you have gone fey. 
 Old friends who are Christians in moderation think that such talents as you have could be more effective in some other vocation. 
 Is the man becoming a fanatic? 
 Why should a future leader of the Liberal Party throw up that possibility in order to be a curate, whose work in popular mythology (and sometimes in reality) consists in having cups of tea with elderly women? 
 But the tenderest difficulty lies with the family if they disapprove. 
 His mother had seen how his mind moved. 
 She half-expected what happened. 
 His father had not expected anything of the kind and was disappointed. 
 An eminent nonconformist might well have reservations about a now Anglo-Catholic son seeking holy orders in the Church of England. 
 But his father was tolerant, and said nothing to stop him. 
 Ramsey could feel that his resolve had a sufficient consent from his parents. 
 The worst difficulty came with his brother Frank, whom Ramsey thought to be the cleverest person he knew. 
 Frank did not conceal his regret.  
 Ramsey lost neither his sense of humour nor his power of mimicry when he became an ordinand. 
 For party occasions he delivered a skit sermon called &bquo;Under the Juniper Tree&equo; which could reduce his audiences to helpless laughter by its caricature of the most platitudinous and pontificating type of preaching. 
 Ramsey expected that once the resolution was taken everything in the mind would be peace after doubt. 
 He discovered that this did not happen. 
 He found that he was now sensitive to a new series of demands and worries and was liable to be hurt in new ways, and he suffered moments with a sense of futility. 
 In April 1926 he abandoned the study of law and started to read theology. 
 This was not easy to do. 
 Universities dislike students who change courses in the middle of a year. 
 Cambridge liked undergraduates reading theology to have two years over the work and believed that if they tried to do it in fourteen months they would do it superficially, or else they would be sure to hurt themselves by overwork. 
 His college must have hesitated before it gave him permission. 
 But colleges shrink ultimately from stopping a person doing what he is ardent to do and forcing him to do what he is bored to do. 
 They gave him the leave which he sought. 
 The result was fourteen months of the hardest work that Michael Ramsey ever knew in his life. 
 He lived a very retired life; gave up games, and took exercise by occasional short sharp runs; and concentrated. 
 Never again did he remember going at anything with such concentration. 
 He made it harder for himself, though much more valuable, by refusing to take short cuts or to mug up the subject from the textbooks: he went to the original sources. 
 The fear on colleges of ill consequences from overwork in such circumstances was not avoided. 
 But he found it a very happy time. 
 He took the theological honours examination, after a preparation of only four terms, in June 1927 and was placed in the first class. 
 The change to theology brought a new influence into his life: Sir Edwyn Clement Hoskyns, the dean of Corpus Christi College. 
 The coming together of Ramsey and Hoskyns was inevitable. 
 The undergraduate was Anglo-Catholic. 
 The teaching staff of the faculty of divinity was not &mdash; with one exception, Hoskyns. 
 To say that the teaching staff were not Anglo-Catholic is an understatement. 
 The faculty of divinity at that moment was dominated by a hard intelligence, Professor Bethune-Baker, known to all behind his back as the Bath Bun. 
 Bethune-Baker was learned and clear-headed in his writing, quick in repartee, astringent as a critic, angered by muddleheadedness in his colleagues, and willing to use sarcasm. 
 He  dedicated this formidable intellect to eradicating nonsense from the world, especially nonsense in divinity, which was a world where in those days he could find plenty of targets for his scorn. 
 And in the faculty he was surrounded by several men of substance with much the same opinions though with less hardness in their advocacy. 
 Since most Christian teachers are kind persons who prefer to avoid controversy when they can, and doodle anxiously during fierce argument at meetings, things tended to go the way of Bethune-Baker; partly because he was devastating, and partly because often he was devastatingly right. 
 To be of Anglo-Catholic opinions in this group was to be a man apart. 
 Bethune-Baker regarded Anglo-Catholicism as part of the nonsense which it was his mission to destroy. 
 Hoskyns, sitting at meetings of the faculty, felt alone. 
 His sense of isolation was the chief suffering of his life in Cambridge. 
 It was true that there were other Anglo-Catholics in Cambridge: Ramsey's helpers Milner-White and Edward Wynn, for example. 
 But intellectually they had no weight. 
 They taught a little easy history to the weaker students. 
 It grieved Ramsey all his life that Milner-White of King's, whom he so admired, refused out of diffidence to play any part whatever in the work of theology. 
 The student needed to hear from the throne of the lecturer something which spoke to his intellectual condition and his religious condition, his mind and his soul, simultaneously. 
 He found such a person in Hoskyns. 
 Hoskyns, at this moment aged 43, lectured on the thought and the ethics of the New Testament. 
 He had studied at Berlin. 
 &bquo;Hoskyns&equo;, said one of the astringent colleagues who disapproved of him, &bquo;went to Berlin and they muddled his mind and when he came back he could never get it unmuddled.&equo; 
 Hoskyns was not a good lecturer. 
 At least, he lectured in such a way that many in the audience found him impossible to understand. 
 This was one of the reasons why Bethune-Baker, who thought that everything obscure was woolly, regarded him as useless if not bad for the young. 
 Students were known to spend their time in his lectures counting up the number of clich&eacute;s which he used. 
 A future bishop, Launcelot Fleming, went to the lectures and was enthralled; but the class ran a sweepstake; if Hoskyns said theme it scored one mark, if he said ultimate theme it scored ten marks. 
 A really good score could reach 100, so there were plenty of numbers to draw. 
 Every time he said theme or ultimate theme he held up his finger and waggled it in front of his nose. 
 He seemed to regard the New Testament as a stormy sea in which he was tossed about in a little boat as he explored. 
 Or he gave them the impression that he wrestled, with limbs contorted, in the effort to seize hold of what truth could be found.  
 Ramsey found him inspiring. 
 Hoskyns communicated enthusiasm. 
 He infected his hearers with the sense that this search after religious truth was of urgent importance to humanity. 
 He introduced Ramsey to modern German thought. 
 He showed him the work of Karl Barth, who, though a Swiss, then taught at the Protestant faculty at M&uuml;nster in North-West Germany, and was the leader of European reaction against the conventional liberal schools of divinity. 
 Ramsey always remained critical of Hoskyns. 
 The Christian mind which he revered was then and ever after the mind of William Temple, whom Hoskyns thought to be able but superficial. 
 Ramsey never doubted that in the formation of his mind Hoskyns was influential, and ever afterwards he was grateful. 
 &bquo;I learned from him, more vividly than from anyone else, that the study of the New Testament is an exciting adventure, and that while it calls for a rigorous-critical discipline, it is not made less scientific if the student brings to it his own experience of faith.&equo; 
 We have now the basic ingredients of Michael Ramsey's mind. 
 A nonconformist origin. 
 A discovery of Anglo-Catholicism and its devotional power, originally through its fanatical critics, and then fostered by wise friends. 
 The admiration for the mind and personality of William Temple. 
 A desire to understand the thought and experience of the apostolic Church. 
 A suspicion that the normal liberal interpretations of the evidence about the apostolic Church, among the leading English thinkers of the day, were clever and persuasive and yet were open to the charge of superficiality. 
 An openness of mind to the European religious reaction against liberal Protestantism, represented especially by Karl Barth. 
 And a belief that the Church (if it could get its message right), more than the lawyers or the economists or the political leaders, was the chief hope for society and the world. 
 All these constituents needed fusing and moulding into a unity in his mind. 
 He thought and meditated; filled them out by experience of pastoral care and by writing; and came to such a unity that all his later life he had a coherence of outlook, in thought and devotion and ethic, which was an anchor to the Church of England in difficult days. 
 Such a fusion and coherence of mind entailed certain rejections. 
 He rejected fundamentalist ideas of the biblical evidence. 
 History was history, and minds must be free. 
 He rejected hot methods of evangelism by mission and believed that quiet rational exposition was the true Christian way even if its results were not spectacular. 
 He suspected the dominant divinity of shallowness and an undue optimism. 
 Though deeply Anglo-Catholic he rejected what the world thought of as Anglo-Catholic fuss, a mistaking of the right vestment for the right religion. 
 The question of questions was at bottom this: the nineteenth century,  with its partial proof of evolution and its axiom that miracles do not happen, enabled the chance of historical enquiry into the life and work of Jesus through the testing of ancient documents. 
 Since the documents are full of the supernatural, the process of enquiry must strip away subsequent accretions. 
 The historical person was so marvellous, that legends grew round him and then doctrines were organized. 
 The principal organizer of doctrine was St Paul. 
 Therefore the process of finding the historical Jesus meant stripping away what St Paul was supposed to have added. 
 There was a contrast between what Jesus intended and the Church which Paul created. 
 But by the middle of the twenties, when Ramsey began to study the matter, a new vision appeared. 
 As the text of the gospels was dissected, there came indeed to appear layers or strata; some bits looked earlier than others; the documents were made up out of a weaving of stories and sayings circulating in the earliest Church and then put together by a single hand or more than one hand. 
 But what was suddenly seen as extraordinary was that the supernatural, the miraculous, and certain doctrines were just as present in the layers now believed to be the earliest as they were in the layers believed to be later. 
 The theory of an original simplicity about the good Galilean carpenter Jesus, which was surrounded with supernatural stories and so corrupted and made complicated, began to look far more doubtful; at least, more difficult to get out of any evidence available. 
 Was it possible that the quest for the historical Jesus, of which Bethune-Baker was a leading representative, was based upon an illusion about the nature of the sources which were used? 
 Hoskyns believed that these new methods could prove that the alleged contrast between Jesus and Paul was wrong; and that there was an identity between the Jesus who lived in Palestine and the Christ who was the object of the faith of the apostolic Church. 
 Bethune-Baker and his school supposed that the more you strip the documents of the New Testament the more clarity and simplicity you will find. 
 This new vision began to prove that the more you strip the documents the more mysterious they are found to be. 
 So far from all the problems being solved, we seemed to be not far from the beginning of the quest. 
 This excited Ramsey. 
 He wondered whether, before ordination, he should stay at Cambridge a little longer to do more advanced work. 
 By the advice of his college he competed for a college research Fellowship, known as the Charles Kingsley Bye-Fellowship. 
 The college failed to elect him to the Bye-Fellowship. 
 They elected a man from jesus College. 
 Other things being equal among candidates, Magdalene College would take a Magdalene man before a Jesus man. 
 But things were  not equal. 
 The jesus man had a first class in history behind him, and a first class with distinction in English Literature behind him, and was president of the university mountaineering club. 
 In his later life he became for a few months nearly as famous as Ramsey, though in a different context. 
 For he was Jack Longland; and his name ran across the world after his experiences high on the unclimbed Mount Everest six years later. 
 Later still he was well known for his work in education. 
 Ramsey was only a little disappointed at this failure. 
 Really he wanted to get on with seeking to become a priest. 
 Everything was happy. 
 His mind was forming. 
 His future way was clear. 
 He was content to do what he would do. 
 And he was in this mood when disaster struck. 
 CUDDESDON 
 A man who spent four heady years as an undergraduate was often advised to go to another place to train for the ministry. 
 Wise men thought that he should not be too near old haunts and old friends. 
 And this was not only a Cambridge graduate but a Cambridge resident. 
 He needed a place of quiet, a good library, and a chapel where the worship was Anglo-Catholic and he would feel at home. 
 Milner-White recommended ordinands to go to Cuddesdon, his own old college; and so he advised Ramsey. 
 It stands six miles outside Oxford, in lovely and in those days remote country, with one bus a day. 
 Neo-Gothic in turrets and corridors and battlements, it was founded by Bishop Samuel Wilberforce of Oxford opposite the front gate of his palace, and then developed by two of the leaders of the Church of England in Queen Victoria's days into the foremost training college of that Catholic tradition. 
 Ramsey arrived there on 30 July 1927. 
 He pushed his bicycle up the hill from Wheatley station in the company of another new student who had a strangely similar background: of nonconformist origins, with his father an official of a nonconformist Church; a young man who postponed his own confirmation into the Church of England because his parents might be hurt; and who swung at the university from his very Protestant background into a sense of the devotional stature in Anglo-Catholicism, and into convictions which never left him for the rest of his life; a graduate of Balliol College, by name Austin Farrer. 
 It is pleasant to think of the two new Cuddesdon students, pushing their bicycles up the hill together from Wheatley station that July day of 1927, and so meeting for the first time. 
 One would like to know if there was a conversation. 
 Both of them were already known for silences. 
 To idealize Cuddesdon has been easy for many. 
 They came with their  ideals, found idyllic peace in the countryside, where a man could hardly fail to notice God in the quietness; said their prayers in one of the fairest little parish churches in all the land; reacted against, and then threw themselves into the orderliness of quasi-monastic life; and studied what they wanted, and thought about truth. 
 In all these ways the place was perfectly suited to what Ramsey needed at that moment. 
 To say prayers in the Catholic way of worship, and feed one's soul on frequent sacraments, and practise a little fasting, and use the sacrament of confession, and study Marcion and the early Church and the Bible, and to have time for quietness and silence and meditation &mdash; that was what he looked for at this moment of his life. 
 He did not get it. 
 A fortnight after he arrived at Cuddesdon his father set out in the car from Cambridge to Stamford. 
 He carried with him the minister of the Congregational Church, H. C. Carter, and in the back seat three ladies, Mrs Ramsey, and Mrs Carter, and a Danish friend of Mrs Carter. 
 They proceeded up the Huntingdon Road at about 20 m.p.h. or sometimes 30 m. p. h., a suitable pace for cars and roads of those days. 
 At the top of the hill before Godmanchester Mr Ramsey felt uncomfortable with his coat and turned to pull it right. 
 As he did not look where he was going, the car's near-side wheels started running along the grass. 
 A telegraph pole was ahead. 
 Mrs Ramsey and Mr Carter cried, &bquo;Look out!&equo; 
 Mr Ramsey swung the wheel over violently to avoid the telegraph pole and the car careered across the road, skidded, hit the grass verge the other side, and overturned. 
 Carter was thrown clear and escaped serious injury. 
 The car pinned all the other four. 
 Mr Ramsey had broken ribs, probably on the steering-wheel. 
 The Danish lady had a fractured skull and was unconscious but alive. 
 Mrs Carter only had a broken arm. 
 And Mrs Ramsey was dead. 
 She was badly injured about the head and many other bones in her body were smashed. 
 Arthur Ramsey was found with his injuries and in a state of shock and muttering, &bquo;It was such a little thing, I was just trying to put my coat right.&equo; 
 Probably it was hardest for the husband and the two daughters. 
 Frank did nothing but sit in the house for two days silent and with tears. 
 But it was very hard for Michael Ramsey. 
 The resulting turmoil, mental and emotional, ruined (the word is not too strong) his preparation to be a priest, and blotted his memory of Cuddesdon. 
 He hardly ever spoke about his mother again. 
 When his father died he burnt all the letters he could find. 
 He took a fortnight away for the funeral and to visit his father in hospital. 
 In October he passed the first part of the examination for  ordination, and afterwards could not understand how he passed. 
 He went back to Cuddesdon for the autumn term, but the mental condition was very adverse. 
 He was sleepless, and kept suffering from deep depressions. 
 Other students had always found him eccentric but now they found his behaviour very odd &mdash; a lot of muttering to himself, and a total incapacity for the practical things, and sudden disappearances into silences. 
 He hoped that a New Year's holiday in Belgium would help him but the mental turmoil came back in force. 
 He dreamed a lot and the dreams were perturbing. 
 He felt as though he lived in a purposeless world. 
 He found himself in enormous buildings, with a labyrinth of rooms, and he was lost in the pile. 
 He wandered from room to room without aim, and without knowing whether he was on the top floor or in the basement, &bquo;just up and up and on and on and on&equo;. 
 Sometimes he would be climbing up and down a cliff and he found himself stuck, unable to get higher and unable to climb down and once he was left clinging on a ledge for ever. 
 He put himself into the hands of a psychiatrist who passed him to another psychiatrist, Leonard Browne. 
 He visited Leonard Browne three times a week for four months. 
 Therefore he needed to be in London and could not be in Cuddesdon. 
 He lived at the settlement for helping London boys, Cambridge House. 
 He spent the mornings reading, and the afternoons visiting for two charities, one of them a school for the physically handicapped. 
 Once, in one of his younger sermons (Liverpool, on John 20: 21&ndash;2), he gave a hint of what it was like with the psychologist. 
 His life was wrecked by fear, even by terror. 
 God was cruel. 
 Sleep failed. 
 The doctor probed &mdash; the longer memories, the childhood. 
 Terror of father when very small? 
 &mdash; a fear then forgotten but driven down into the subconscious? 
 &mdash; and yet, when this is recognized, the terror still appears again, in a new and dreadful form; and the memory must be brought to &bquo;the touch of Jesus&equo; and so the whole inner man is cleansed. 
 This became a strong reason to him for the practice of private confession. 
 You cannot cure yourself. 
 You cannot forget. 
 If you do, it will submerge. 
 You need to bring it to a place where God reaches out into the secret places of the soul. 
 When he looked back later in life he did not think that this dark night was caused by what happened on the road at Godmanchester. 
 He thought that its roots reached back, as the doctor thought, into earlier life. 
 But the historian can hardly doubt the connection. 
 Here was a student who overworked for more than a year and needed rest; who was already in an emotional condition by the recognition of the highest ideals and their obligation upon him; and then, instead of the rest which he needed, he had to endure the utterly unexpected death, in very  distressing family conditions, of the person in the world to whom he felt nearest. 
 By Easter 1928 Michael was better. 
 He was able to manage the May term at Cuddesdon, though he needed still to go three times a week to London to see Browne for treatment. 
 The students at Cuddesdon still found him very odd, and very unpractical, and very absent-minded, and much given to muttering to himself. 
 Austin Farrer watched him, and was amused at all the oddities of behaviour. 
 But Farrer saw other things about him. 
 First, there was no question of the power of his mind, even if that mind moved eccentrically. 
 Second, this was not a person who bored everyone by overearnestness. 
 On the contrary, he had a teasing humour, and a sarcasm which struck hard. 
 Thirdly, and unexpectedly, he was a champion on the croquet pitch. 
 Farrer decided that he was a born don. 
 We have another description of him at this date from a diarist who happened to meet him. 
 &bquo;A most curious-looking young man with a mobile white face and small red-rimmed eyes; he is said to be very clever as well as deeply religious. 
 He seemed devoted to his little sister&equo;. 
 It was 3 March 1928, in the middle of Ramsey's bad time. 
 Later Ramsey used to mock the complacency of clergymen who said that their training college gave them habits of devotion &bquo;which they had never lost&equo;. 
 He attributed no such quality to his disturbed time at Cuddesdon. 
 Nevertheless Cuddesdon was important to him. 
 For later he also believed that the motor accident and its consequences could have destroyed his morale but for the tranquil worship of the little Oxfordshire village which for the time was his base. 
 He did not think much of the lectures. 
 He resented the inadequacy of the library, in which he worked long hours during such time as he was there. 
 He regarded the chaplain as a buffoon though a dedicated buffoon. 
 His intelligence owed nothing to the college. 
 He felt frustrated academically. 
 An ancient actor, with an absurd way of talking, taught elocution to the future preachers. 
 But the place was a port in the storm. 
 He felt apart; withdrawn; like Newman, feeling there was nothing in the world but God and his soul. 
 He did not find learning to pray an easy occupation. 
 Still, he had a sense of movement; as though in the quietness they were seeking some kind of glory. 
 Two people helped. 
 The principal of the college was Jimmie Seaton, a plump, cheerful, outgoing little man known as Friar Tuck, who bubbled with amusement and good sense of vitality and who liked people and gardening while he hated committees and pomposity. 
 The second was the Bishop of Oxford, Tommy Strong; the bishop with the  most sensitive taste and rare learning and musical apprehension of all the bishops' bench. 
 Ramsey described him as a character, without popular appeal, donnish, with no great interest in his big rural diocese, but full of wisdom and learning, and eager for friendship with young men. 
 If you walked round the bishop's wood shortly before you left Cuddesdon, you were likely to become aware of an elfin prelate hunting you through the shrubbery like a gaitered satyr; and when he caught up with you he would say breathlessly, &bquo;If you ever need a bed&hellip; (panting)&hellip; don't forget I have fifteen spare bedrooms&equo;. 
 During his time at Cuddesdon something happened to the Church of England, at the national level, which left an indelible mark upon many young ordinands of the time, and certainly upon Michael Ramsey. 
 In December 1927, while he was in the midst of his darkness, and in june 1928 when he was better, the House of Commons rejected a proposal, carried by large majorities in the Church bodies, for a new prayer book, which was the old prayer book, from the age of King Charles II, modestly revised in a pastoral spirit long after the time when it needed revision. 
 A majority in the House of Commons fancied that it possessed the training in theology, the experience of ways of worship, and the sensitivity to religious feelings, to tell a Church how it ought to say its prayers. 
 That the House of Commons, which had its share of agnostics and non-Anglicans, should order the Church how to worship God was an interference by the State in the affairs of the Church, just where those affairs were sacred and touched the conscience. 
 The manner of the rejection on the floor of the Chamber was unpleasant, with ranting and prejudice flaunted and loud, though it is not certain whether such sickening speeches moved sober MPs. 
 The rejections, and the manner of the rejections, ensured that for the future the Church would take no notice of what the House of Commons thought about the way in which the Church of England worshipped. 
 Ramsey was a former nonconformist who had not lost the idea that Churches must be free from entanglement with the State. 
 He was now a young Anglo-Catholic who acquired the Catholic sense of divine rights in the Church which no State can touch. 
 He had no idea that he would ever be able to do anything about the predicament. 
 But he formed the opinion, which he never afterwards lost, that the Church must gain its proper freedom from the State in the care for its own way of worship, if necessary by disestablishment, from which he never thereafter shrank. 
 Whenever he thought about this in later years, his memory would go back to the Cuddesdon time and the shock of seeing a House of Commons pretending that it knew how people ought to say their prayers. 
 It was the one time when he doubted William Temple. 
 Ardent for  liberty, he wanted the bishops to behave fiercely, like Hensley Henson, the Bishop of Durham, and threaten the Commons with disestablishment as the answer to its unconstitutional behaviour. 
 He expected William Temple to back Henson and was grieved to find that his hero was weak because he refused to stand up and fight. 
 Later in life he thought that of the two, Henson and Temple, Temple was the statesman on the question. 
 &bquo;It was rather exasperating that the great and radical William Temple soft-pedalled. 
 In retrospect I am glad that he did.&equo; 
 But because he was in the middle of his mental stress he suffered a disaster. 
 In January 1928 he was invited back to speak at the Cambridge Union, on the motion that the Church of England ought to be disestablished. 
 In his horror at what happened in the House of Commons, he started to speak in favour of the motion. 
 But a few minutes after he was launched into the speech he came to a dead stop, stared strangely at the gallery in silence, and could not go on. 
 He found himself saying, &bquo;In 1919 the Enabling Act was passed&equo; and then could not remember what the Enabling Act was; although it was and still in part is the Act which defines the nature of the establishment in England. 
 So in the middle of his speech he walked straight out of the debate and the Union chamber. 
 The family worried about it in their different ways. 
 His father suspected that he had a glass of wine too many at dinner. 
 His brother said that he had been more excitable lately, and more ineffective, and running up and down more. 
 Frank was sure that the cause was not physical but was part of the mental unsettlement. 
 His friends on the Union committee thought that what happened was best accounted for if he saw a vision of his dead mother in the gallery watching him speak. 
 They did not dare to ask him. 
 Where was he to go next? 
 The young man was an obvious don. 
 Hoskyns wanted him in Cambridge as the chaplain of his college, Corpus Christi. 
 The rector of Liverpool, john How, knew Ramsey from Cambridge days. 
 He wanted a noisy, breezy curate to get at his rough teenagers. 
 He was aware that this description did not fit Ramsey. 
 &bquo;I fear&equo;, said How to Ramsey, &bquo;that you might be too retiring for the job.&equo; 
 It looked as though the donnish youth would go straight back to donnery and be a don for the rest of his life; perhaps he was not suitable for other kinds of clergyman. 
 The vacancy at Corpus Christi vanished. 
 And on 23 September 1928 Ramsey was ordained deacon, to be the curate of St Nicholas, the parish church of Liverpool. 
 His stipend was &pound;200 a year. 
 The Parish Minister 
 LIVERPOOL 
 St Nicholas is the old parish church near the quay-side and the docks. 
 The church where Ramsey ministered was bombed to bits in the Second World War. 
 It was mostly built early in the nineteenth century with a tall fair spire topped by a ship. 
 Near the docks the inhabitants were poor dock labourers. 
 Many were unemployed, many had only casual work. 
 Higher up the hill the streets were full of office buildings, so that the parishioners were caretakers. 
 To visit his people Ramsey had to go up in lifts. 
 The parish had about 7,000 people. 
 More than half the parishioners were Irish Roman Catholics, who went to two churches. 
 Both these churches were remote and estranged. 
 Their priests were intransigents. 
 Ramsey felt it odd that in two Christian churches, working side by side in a crowded port, the ministers could not pray together or work together and could hardly speak together. 
 He disliked this situation. 
 Moreover the diocese was not only divided between Anglicans and others. 
 The Anglicans were divided &mdash; the stoutest of Irish Protestants versus a few stiff Anglo-Catholic parishes; and in a fight the sympathies of Ramsey's parish lay with the second. 
 He disapproved of his bishop (A. A. David) for the tough way in which he handled three recalcitrant Anglo-Catholic priests who refused to conform to rules laid down by the bishop and yet did nothing about the radical dean of the cathedral who did things equally nonconforming in a Low Church direction. 
 Ramsey thought this an injustice; he decided that his bishop was vague and na&iuml;ve in his theology, someone who took up new ideas with enthusiasm and with very little precision of thought; and yet he saw that the bishop disliked controversy and was hurt by it, and thought him to be a friend and a man of prayer. 
 It specially pleased him that the bishop encouraged him, in the midst of all the parish chores, to keep time for hard study. 
 The congregation of St Nicholas consisted of a few poor people from the neighbourhood and otherwise of less poor people from various parts  of the city or from Birkenhead across the Mersey. 
 Its congregation quite flourished. 
 John How was a solid good preacher but not a magnet to multitudes. 
 He was formidable, laconic, self-disciplined, earnest but not humourless, and it was said of him that he did everything with a kind of good-natured fury. 
 Most of the time he left his two curates to get on with their thing. 
 Ramsey could find nowhere to live within the parish. 
 Some distance away, only a few yards from the vast unfinished Anglican cathedral, he found lodgings (13 St James's Road) with a spinsterish landlady who by origin was a Northern Irish Protestant. 
 One of the other lodgers was a dwarf, with whom Ramsey made friends. 
 They called their censorious landlady IT. 
 The lodging was neither convenient nor happy. 
 To get to morning service in the church he had to catch a tram at 6.50 a.m. 
 If his work kept him late for a meal, he had satirical reproaches cast upon his head by the landlady. 
 At the general election of 1929 the landlady could be heard telling a Tory canvasser that everyone in the house would vote Conservative and Ramsey said forcibly that he was voting Labour (there was no Liberal candidate). 
 The air of the house turned sour. 
 For the last weeks of his curacy he left the lodgings and hired a room in a small hotel up Mount Pleasant. 
 The people liked him. 
 They are reported to have said &bquo;The new curate's not chatty&equo;. 
 In later years he was once asked whether he, who was shy, was anguished when forced to go out visiting homes in Liverpool and to try to make the first touch with a strange family. 
 He said, &bquo;As a curate I was never frightened of visiting. 
 I never minded being shy. 
 I was content to be shy. 
 I perplexed other people. 
 I was content to be silent.&equo; 
 He loved his confirmation class. 
 He visited the sick often, in homes and in hospital. 
 He disliked his Bible class of teenage boys because they misbehaved, but at times it was happy. 
 He disliked the work at the boys club because the teenagers misbehaved, and because he could see no use in the work. 
 He disliked teaching twice a week in the school because the children misbehaved. 
 He enjoyed and admired his rector. 
 He found his fellow-curate odious. 
 He loved the morning hours of hard study at the Bible. 
 He also read much else, for example a lot of Newman's sermons. 
 To his surprise, he discovered that what was needed to make a powerful political speech was not the same gift as that which was needed to make a powerful sermon. 
 The technique was different. 
 He discovered that various kinds of audience needed various kinds of utterance. 
 He thought that he learnt a lot about preaching from this experience. 
 Once at least he could feel that a sermon of his moved his  hearers. 
 But he told the bishop at a private interview that he was depressed about preaching, he felt the people to be so remote from the practice of religion. 
 An envelope of a few Liverpool sermons survived; including the first sermon which he ever delivered there (text I Peter 2: 9, &bquo;ye are an elect race&equo;). 
 Like most first sermons it puts in too many ideas at once. 
 He calls St John's gospel &bquo;the most beautiful book in the world&equo;. 
 The collection is very biblical. 
 It has no jokes, no digressions, nothing to lighten, except occasional quotations of poets like Tennyson. 
 It conveys the feeling of the grandeur of the sacrament. 
 The reader smiles when the preacher tells the people of dockland that they live &bquo;in a garden near the slopes of the heavenly mountain'. 
 Sometimes he wrote his sermon out in full. 
 Sometimes he prepared summary notes. 
 As he got on, and less nervous, the words came easily; and then he began to dislike being restricted by a written text and to prefer headings. 
 A little reputation outside the parish began to grow &mdash; that this was a curate who could talk. 
 William Temple ran a mission on the Blackpool sands, preaching from a tub to the buckets and spades. 
 He summoned a lot of helpers; among them Ramsey, who watched fat Temple on his fat tub talking profound truths in simple language. 
 That was a compliment to Ramsey. 
 No doubt Temple remembered that once they stood on the same platform at Cambridge. 
 It would be pleasant to have a film of curate Ramsey talking to the young architects of sand-castles. 
 The curate was troubled by the conflict between his love of biblical study and the chores of the parish. 
 He was saved from isolation of the mind by a lucky proximity. 
 He lived hard by the cathedral. 
 This cathedral had an exceptional canon. 
 Charles Raven was a fiery charismatic man with a large heart. 
 At Liverpool he turned himself into the most powerful preacher in all England. 
 In background he was nothing like Ramsey. 
 Low churchman versus high churchman; philosopher of religion and science versus close student of the Bible; radical divine versus enquiring conservative; suspecter of orthodoxy versus a young man who saw the stature of the Catholic tradition. 
 Nevertheless Raven cared passionately about things of the mind. 
 He was forward at seeking out young people of promise and giving them encouragement. 
 The coincidence was extraordinary. 
 An isolated curate who wanted knowledge found himself living a few yards from a man who at first sight was an explosive popular preacher, but who happened also to be one of the coming academic theologians of England, and an inciter of younger minds. 
 Raven ran a weekly class on the New Testament. 
 Ramsey joined it.  
 Raven's mode of running a class was provocative. 
 He drove Ramsey to contradict him. 
 Never before had Ramsey run up against so formidable a Christian opponent, and never before been so forced to defend his biblical ideas. 
 He found the experience good for his mind. 
 Raven also had him round several times to meals at his house. 
 After one of these lunches Ramsey recorded his affection for Raven. 
 This was not everyone's opinion of Raven. 
 Some good men feared his radicalism, and some good men disliked his passion, and some less good men thought him little but a rhetorician. 
 Ramsey penetrated to the essence of the man. 
 During the summer of 1929, nearly a year into his curacy, and aged 24, Ramsey was attracted to a Lancashire girl. 
 It was important to him, important enough to see that members of his family met her and that he found out what they thought of her as a possible wife for him. 
 They were unanimous that she would not be right for him. 
 And gradually he came to realize that there was a particular reason for the attraction which was not the empathy of the girl. 
 She had a physical resemblance to Ramsey's dead mother. 
 The friendship passed. 
 The priesthood  
 It was then the custom of the Church of England that a curate should be ordained to be a deacon (the lowest order of the ministry) whose duty was to help the parish priest in all his pastoral duties but who could not perform the priestly acts of celebrating the sacrament or giving absolution or blessing. 
 After he served for a year as a deacon he was ordained as a priest. 
 To most people coming forward to be a Christian priest, the moment when they became deacons was a bigger turning-point in the life, and more emotional, than the moment when they became priests. 
 Truly to celebrate the sacrament for the first time, and to feel for the first time that the hands were the instruments through which God chose to nourish the souls of his people, could be overwhelming with gratitude or with penitence. 
 But to be made a deacon was for the first time to profess before a multitude that the soul undertook the cause of God in a special ministry, and for the first time to feel sent to an apostolic work. 
 Afterwards to wear clerical clothes for the first time, and instantly to be expected to be a confidant or soul's friend, was to many ordinands the more heartfelt turning-point. 
 Ramsey was unusual in that to him the priest's ordination meant much more than the deacon's ordination. 
 He used to say that his ordination to the priesthood, in Farnworth parish church on 22 September 1929, with Raven preaching, mattered to him much the more. 
 Why this was so we can only guess. 
 He was a high churchman for whom the sacrament of holy communion was the supreme moment of  worship. 
 His preparation to be a deacon was disturbed by a death and by mental illness. 
 Later in life he compared his own feelings at the two ordinations to be a deacon and a priest and his later consecration to be a bishop. 
 He said: 
 When you are ordained deacon you have arrived. 
 But being a priest &mdash; that meant far, far more. 
 That meant far more to me than being a bishop. 
 Becoming a bishop is an incident in the life of a priest. 
 I sometimes forget that it is the day of the year when I was made a bishop. 
 I never fail to remember on the day of the year when I was made a priest. 
 A little fold of the veil can be drawn aside to disclose his mood at that time. 
 In September 1929, before the ordination at Farnworth, he went into retreat at Bishop Tommy Strong's Cuddesdon Palace with its fifteen spare bedrooms. 
 During a time of meditation in that retreat, he wrote a note which survived. 
 It is in fading pencil. 
 Not quite all is legible: 
 &bquo;My grace is sufficient for thee&equo;. 
 How I do need to look away from self to God, I can only find satisfaction: in him. 
 My heart, to love him; my will, to do his will, my mind, to glorify him; my tongue, to speak to him and of him; my eyes to see him in all things; my hands to bring whatever they touch to him; my all only to be a real &bquo;all&equo;: because it is joined to him. 
 And this will be utter joy: no man can take it away. 
 Self, self-consciousness, self-will, the self-centre cut away, so that the centre which holds all my parts is God. 
 Inquietum est cor nostrum. 
 Yes it is so because it is nostrum, cut out the nostrum, and let me give my heart to God &mdash; and all is... &lsqb; rest of line illegible &rsqb; 
 Thanks be to God for being what He is, for showing Himself to me&hellip; 
 &mdash; and then comes a list of benefactors: Carter the Congregationalist minister, and Henry Balmforth the sixth form master at Repton, and Geoffrey Fisher the headmaster at Repton, mother, father, Frank his  brother , Jimmie Seaton the head of Cuddesdon, Tommy Strong in whose chapel he then meditated, John How at Liverpool; the institutions, Cuddesdon and Magdalene, his home, and his Bible; his special teachers William Temple and Charles Raven (Hoskyns, note well, is not mentioned); and then gratitude for his crosses: the troubles of  school-days, the death, &bquo;the desolation&equo;, the anxieties and wearinesses in Liverpool, &bquo;tiresome boys&equo;. 
 And still my mind runs back to self. 
 Cut it out, God is in me; He is my centre &mdash; let me only believe it, and His energy will flood the whole of me, and self will be drowned&hellip; 
 Drive out, kill self, let God be then alone in me &mdash; then in God we will find (no, he-in-us will find) ourselves selfless free sons Come God &mdash; my God is and is in me, in you rather let God explode burst from within filling the whole of us away from self just He He He He Theos &mdash; no, the one &mdash; Heis. 
 Between November 1929 and February 1930 he kept a diary. 
 Unfortunately for the historian, it was the only time in his life when he kept a diary. 
 We find a man busy about his parish, up early, taking services, preaching, preparing to preach, visiting the sick, conducting funerals, running a club. 
 Some of it was happy, some less happy. 
 The rector was delightful, the people friendly, Raven's classes excellent. 
 He dreaded his own Bible class and found it hard to keep teenagers in order. 
 Two frustrations appear in the diary. 
 The contrast between the rural peace of Cuddesdon and the noise and dirt of Liverpool was hard to bear. 
 And an inner conflict lay between books and parish. 
 When he studied, he was happy. 
 When he could not study, he was miserable. 
 He asked himself whether he was someone like Arthur Benson, the Master of Magdalene, for whom books were a form of escapism from the real world. 
 He saw that the intellectual side of him could not be wrong, somehow he must baptize it. 
 But when he was in this mood, fear came. 
 During the time of desolation a year before, he suffered from fantasies. 
 When he got exhausted from parish work, and felt unwell, a fear would darken him, that the demon, seemingly exorcized, might return. 
 And already he knew in his heart that to be a vicar or a curate was not his vocation as a priest for the rest of his life.  
 While this internal argument reached its height, his superiors argued about him without his knowledge. 
 From opposite ends of England the academics said that this was a born teacher who ought to be in teaching as soon as possible. 
 Raven said it in Liverpool. 
 Hoskyns said it in Cambridge. 
 Bishop and rector expected him to serve his minimum engagement as a curate. 
 Raven pushed at the bishop that he ought to be in an academic post and soon. 
 Hoskyns found him the opening &mdash; sub-warden of Lincoln Theological College. 
 Lincoln brought in the big guns of William Temple to get bishop and rector to release the curate before the time. 
 Finally bishop and rector agreed, and Ramsey accepted the Lincoln work. 
 Later in life Ramsey believed that he learnt a lot from his short time at Liverpool. 
 It introduced him to the human race. 
 He met new-born babies, and said prayers in the rooms of the dying, and consoled families at the cemetery, and struggled to communicate with teenagers who did not know how to read. 
 It introduced him to the bizarre situation that Churches treated each other worse than they treated anyone else; and to the recognition that the reason for this was not religious but racial. 
 He met the descendants of Lascar seamen or other immigrants who settled into Liverpool and for the first time saw the need for justice to an immigrant community. 
 Later he knew that he learnt a lot. 
 But at the time he was glad to leave. 
 &bquo;It's been a great school for the temper.&equo; 
 He left Liverpool at Easter 1930. 
 Before he left, his brother Frank died very young, of a liver complaint after jaundice (19 January 1930). 
 It was important to Michael Ramsey, not only then but much later, that before Frank's death he felt him to be less far apart over religion. 
 In the last week of the previous October Michael stayed in Cambridge. 
 Michael saw that his brother's mind had moved &mdash; not far, hardly at ail, but still he had moved. 
 He no longer accepted determinism and was willing to see a meaning in the words &bquo;free will&equo;. 
 Instead of rejecting religion out of hand as irrational, he enquired about it. 
 He wanted to know what are the experiences and emotions of religious people. 
 He said that as a boy at school he had such experiences and wondered whether they were like Michael's. 
 What struck Michael was, the enquiry was humble &mdash; as though religion might be something worth knowing about. 
 Michael told him about the evidence of religious experience in the Christian mystics; both of what some of the great masters had said about it and of the slighter experience of simple Christians. 
 All through this conversation he had the impression that Frank no longer sneered; and as he went back to Liverpool he was sure that he was more tolerant and sympathetic and &bquo;was willing to grant that there was some sense in some of the things which I longed for  him to share&equo;. 
 In mid-January 1930 he stood by Frank's death-bed and imagined his heart going out to his brother. 
 It cannot have been easy for an ordinand or a curate to stand up to contemptuous persiflage about his religion from one of the ablest minds of the generation who happened to be his own brother. 
 In later years he thought that twice in his life, and twice only, he seriously wondered whether Frank was right, and he wrong, about religion. 
 The first time was when his mother died; the second time was when Frank died. 
 Maynard Keynes wrote an obituary of Frank in his Essays in Bio-  graphy  (1933), pp. 
 335 ff. 
 We see the younger brother's personality reflected in his friend's portrait of this atheist mathematical economist: the stony heights and rare atmosphere in which his mind moved; the easy efficiency of the intellectual machine which ground away beneath his broad smiling face, his bulky Johnsonian frame, and spontaneous gurgling laugh, and simplicity of feeling, and honesty of heart and mind and purpose; and with it a common sense and practicality. 
 Later in Michael Ramsey's life it disturbed his conventional critics when they found a guardian of Catholic orthodoxy saying that he hoped and expected to meet atheists in heaven. 
 LINCOLN 
 The Bishop's Hostel at Lincoln was one of those mid-Victorian foundations intended to train future clergymen. 
 Most of these foundations were sited in or hard by cathedral buildings because after the cathedral reforms old cathedrals had buildings or land available. 
 The window of Ramsey's study looked out to the west end of the cathedral. 
 The students were about forty in number, most of them not from universities. 
 The warden to whom he was sub-warden was Leslie Owen, a man of delicate health whom Ramsey liked. 
 His stipend was &pound;220 a year but this was a big increase on his Liverpool pay because he had free rooms and free meals. 
 He gave a lot of lectures &mdash; four a week. 
 The worst of the teaching offered in theological colleges occurs because the staff are few and the ground to be covered enormous. 
 Therefore the few staff sit up late at night to prepare lectures on a few things they know about and a lot of things they know not much about, and spend their time keeping one page ahead of the class and depending on the textbook. 
 This was more  educative for the staff than the students. 
 Ramsey lectured on all the later part of the Bible and on the central Christian doctrines. 
 Every moment therefore of his time was dedicated either to preparing or to giving lectures. 
 Unlike some members of the staff who resented a forced superficiality, he liked the system. 
 He enjoyed educating himself in the things he wanted to know about. 
 For the first time he told himself that he was fully at home in his work. 
 He felt the teacher's rostrum to be his fit place; the place where he knew that what he had to offer was valued. 
 He worked hard. 
 He had to work hard. 
 And because no knowledge is fully clear in the mind until it is explained to someone else, the time at Lincoln was further formative for his mind. 
 &bquo;Everything later&equo;, he said, &bquo;was an extension. 
 At Lincoln I built a structure of thought.&equo; 
 The story got about over the years that his lectures were very obscure. 
 That was probably the opinion of persons who found ail lectures obscure. 
 It was not the opinion of most students from those days. 
 They found him a teacher of clarity, whose lectures were the most enjoyable and most instructive which they heard during their training. 
 When he had leisure he went bicycling to Lincolnshire village churches. 
 He enjoyed the Cuddesdon-like monastic-like regularity of the daily worship. 
 Some of the students started to use him as their confessor. 
 He played tennis with them under the willow-trees by college, playing not well but with a brisk gusto. 
 He went round the golf-course in 95 strokes. 
 His shirt-tails flapping in the breeze, he faced the green at an angle of forty-five degrees and sliced every shot. 
 He helped to reorganize the local golf course so that students could play legally and cheaply. 
 He played the game of Murder in the dark through the vast rooms of the bishop's vast palace and told his nonconformist father that at last he found a reason why bishops should live in such large houses. 
 In vacations he consoled his father's loneliness by taking him on holiday &mdash; Cornwall, Criccieth, the Lakes, the Black Forest and Bavaria. 
 At other times in vacations he spent weeks doing hard reading in the library of Cambridge University and got good talks with Hoskyns. 
 He discovered the virtues of the Gladstone Library at Hawarden near Chester, a residentiary library founded on the basis of Mr Gladstone's own books. 
 In 1930 he went to Bavaria to see the passion play at the mountain village of Oberammergau. 
 The students from that time remembered a man with a sharp sense of the ridiculous; who ragged them but was too shy to be intimate with them though they liked him much for his friendliness and his humour; who was famous for long, sudden, and embarrassing silences; who was so eccentric that none of them believed that he could later be a man of  distinction in England or his Church; a man who loved theology &mdash; they never met anywhere else a man who so loved theology, and who regarded theology as the highest intellectual activity for humanity; a fierce defender of liberty of opinion, for Marxists as for anyone else; whose principal theme was the glory of God, and who was evidently touched by his ideas of Plato; who did not give the impression of a mind of exceptional ability &mdash; there was not enough knife in the mind &mdash; but who gave the impression of being an exceptional person; who disturbed other people's prayers in chapel with convulsive fidgets and sudden face-rubbings &mdash; they regarded him as tense in his devotions and were afraid of a nervous breakdown; who had a manifest and rare mystical sense of the immediate presence of God, a presence so brilliant that it could almost overpower. 
 Late at night one of the students passed Ramsey's room and heard strange sounds within, and it was Ramsey going round and round his table saying It is fire!  
 It is fire! 
 There was one occasion when he went into a caf&eacute; and asked for tea and then while he waited he suddenly saw a solution to a theological argument which he had with Leslie Owen the warden, and his waving of hands was so convulsive that the caf&eacute; refused to serve him with the tea. 
 Once the students, not without glee, watched him celebrating the sacrament with the ends of his back braces protruding out of the top of his vestment. 
 Sometimes he could be observed wearing some garment inside out. 
 Austin Farrer came on a visit to Lincoln and reported that Ramsey was a great man in the college and held his audiences spellbound and was less mad. 
 From Lincoln days descended a story which sounds like Ramsey-legend but the truth of which he confirmed. 
 An applicant for entry came to be interviewed. 
 For fifteen minutes interviewer and applicant sat opposite one another. 
 Neither said a word. 
 Then Ramsey said, &bquo;I think you will find Lincoln rather a quiet place.&equo; 
 This was the end of the interview. 
 In vacations he still went for interviews with his psychiatrist, who did not feel that he had quite got &bquo;to the bottom of things&equo;. 
 But this no longer disturbed the even tenor of life. 
 A little group of letters survived which affords insight into his attitude in this earlier time at Lincoln. 
 His Aunt Lucy came to live at Howfield in order to look after Ramsey's father and the family after Agnes Ramsey was killed. 
 She wanted help with being prepared for confirmation and turned to her nephew for guidance. 
 He wrote her letters. 
 From these letters to an aunt we can gather something of his  habits of devotion. 
 He taught her the words of the Angelus, the Hail Mary; though he said that he could not quite use all the words himself literally, but he respected those who could, and he did not think there was anything in it which made Mary take the place of her Son. 
 He taught her that the sacrament of the eucharist was so big that he did not feel that he had finished with it when he came home after the service at 8 a.m. on Sunday morning. 
 It was many-sided &mdash; worship, praise, offering, commemoration of our Lord's life and death, sacrifice, fellowship with the faithful in the unseen, all the many sides which centre in this one act. 
 He did not need words to join in this act, he could use the words of the prayer book or his own words, but he needed no words at all. 
 He liked incense, but he did not like an excess of ceremonial (&equo; scarlet, lace etc') which he condemned as vulgar and intrusive. 
 He could never be happy with morning prayer and not the sacrament as the chief morning service. 
 He thought a procession a bore. 
 He began to be known. 
 Invitations poured in. 
 He refused to preach in St Paul's Cathedral. 
 Offers of jobs started to come in. 
 He refused work in London. 
 Geoffrey Fisher went from Repton to be Bishop of Chester and invited him to be an examining chaplain; which he accepted &mdash; it would mean two or three visits a year &mdash; and was surprised to find how friendly Fisher was when they were not in the relation of boy and headmaster. 
 At this time of his life he always called Fisher behind his back Halieus, which is Greek for fisher. 
 Observers still thought them to be in the relation of boy and headmaster. 
 Here were two future leaders of the Church of England, the one a man of supreme common sense, the other a mystic; the one a conservative and establishment-man, the other a liberal and a reformer &mdash; they were fated never to understand each other. 
 After Fisher died Ramsey said that the time in their lives when they were closest in friendship was the time when he was examining chaplain to the Bishop of Chester. 
 As the first years passed, and the courses of lectures did not have to be prepared out of nothing, he sat at the bay window in the sub-warden's study, looking out towards the cathedral, and started to write his first book. 
 He did not start writing the book because he wanted to write a book. 
 He had something he wanted to say to the Christian world and the question was how best to say it. 
 Occasionally he would descend to the students' common room immediately beneath and beg them to make less noise so that he could write. 
 The students later believed a legend that part of this famous book was written ail over the walls of his room. 
 Longman's published the book in January 1936 at 7shilling; 6d: title, The Gospel  and the Catholic Church . 
 For centuries men have fought for the Church, died for it, loved it, or  hated it. 
 Now no one seems to mind about its existence. 
 Its worship and its priests and its teaching are strange to the society in which it lives. 
 Society is not hostile, it passes by on the other side. 
 Can we make the Church real to society by turning it political; by making its essence not old creeds but moral judgements on bombs, or on socialist policy? 
 This is not the answer to which the study of the New Testament leads. 
 There the Church's work is to point to Jesus the Messiah and his death, and to sin, and to judgement. 
 &bquo;In all this the Church was scandalous and unintelligible to men, but by all this and by nothing else it was relevant to their deepest needs.&equo; 
 The Church cannot be any easier to understand than its Messiah. 
 And the society of his day doubted, questioned, despised. 
 The word scandalous is repeated four times in the first three pages. 
 So Ramsey cried to the Church not to dilute itself, or adjust itself to what contemporary Smith or Jones can swallow. 
 It cannot convert its gospel into social reform. 
 Ramsey cried to the Church to be itself; to know that its being rests upon a death and an empty tomb; and to be itself whether modern Britain will listen or close its ears. 
 The book had a second, equally important purpose. 
 The child of a nonconformist father learnt to drink deep of the Catholic tradition. 
 At the centre of his mind was a fusion between the evangelical Christian and the churchman; the first, biblical, a man of gospel and of conversion, of faith and the Word of God; the second, a man with a reverence for the Christian society through the centuries, its sacramental inheritance, its order, and ministry, and continuity. 
 And therefore this young evangelical churchman had something original to say, which was an effort to fuse the Protestant idea with the Catholic idea as they were fused within his personal history. 
 He would show the Catholic that the Church is nothing without the Word spoken in the crucifixion. 
 He would show the Protestant that the Church, with its order, and structure, and mission, is a necessary part of the Word spoken in the crucifixion. 
 The book is full of the Bible, and yet is an essay in Church order. 
 So, on one side, the book was a Catholic churchman proclaiming the cross of Christ in a way more common among Protestants. 
 On another side it was an assault upon the corruption of the highest truths; against turning love of the Bible into bibliolatry, or creeds into scholastic definitions, or the sacrament into magic, or Popes and priests and bishops into a bureaucracy or a rigidity where structure becomes the end instead of the means; or turning the Church into a social club. 
 Some people disliked this book very much. 
 The nonconformists noted that he did not unchurch them but were not happy with his plea  that they recognize bishops to be essential to the Church. 
 Bethune-Baker and his school at Cambridge disliked the anti-rational quality in the book &mdash; the &bquo;scandalousness&equo; of the Church and its gospel &mdash; and took several more marks off Hoskyns for begetting such a child. 
 When Ramsey came to read the book himself, later in life, he was astonished, and at one point burst out laughing, to discover what irrational expressions he could use. 
 Through Hoskyns he had come for the time under the influence of the leader of anti-rational European theology, Karl Barth, who at this moment was back in Basle after being expelled from Germany by the Nazis. 
 But the caustic critics were not the majority. 
 Whatever the book's faults might be, it was seen to be an original contribution of power, and that a new force in Christian thinking had appeared among the Churches in England. 
 Here was a young man learned in the New Testament and in the early Fathers; thinking hard for himself; manifestly a lover of God and of the gospel; an Anglo-Catholic but one who spoke in tones more persuasive to Protestants than was usual among Anglo-Catholics, with tolerance, and respect, and a gratitude for all that was best in the Protestant tradition. 
 The letter which he valued most came from the leader of English theology, who was now Archbishop of York, William Temple: &bquo;Men ought to acknowledge their major obligations, and so I write to thank you...&equo; 
 He was also very pleased when he heard that George Bell, the famous Bishop of Chichester, took the book to read on his holiday in Switzerland. 
 Books of academic religion (or of any other academic subject) are not lasting because scholarship in all fields advances. 
 If they last twenty years before being replaced they have done a good service. 
 Yet fifty years after Ramsey's book a good judge of religious thought and literature during the twentieth century declared it to be an enduring masterpiece, which pointed forward to the road which Anglicans and not only Anglicans would follow. 
 That year, Cambridge University advertised a lectureship. 
 The lecturer would have to teach the history and the doctrine of the early Church. 
 This was what Michael Ramsey knew about. 
 Hoskyns badly wanted him for the post. 
 But this was impossible. 
 Before he wrote the book he could hardly get the job because he had not published a book. 
 After he wrote the book he could not get the job because it was a Hoskynsish sort of book. 
 Ten years later Professor Marsh was asked why the faculty refused to elect Ramsey to a lectureship. 
 He replied  laconically, as though it was a sufficient explanation, &bquo;He was influenced by Hoskyns.&equo; 
 Moreover the book alienated the only one of Ramsey's backers who could stand up to the Cambridge establishment. 
 In a note Ramsey criticized Raven's view of a particular question. 
 Raven thought the criticism unfair. 
 He protested, coldly. 
 The note destroyed the intimacy between the two. 
 But even if the note was deleted (and Ramsey deleted it in a later edition), Raven could not have voted for Ramsey with enthusiasm. 
 Ramsey was now a channel for Barthian influence into England. 
 Raven regarded Karl Barth as the worst menace to sane rational thinking. 
 And Ramsey's book said that bishops were essential to the Church. 
 Raven thought this nonsense. 
 All his life Ramsey was sorry about the breach with Raven. 
 So Cambridge elected another person. 
 Hoskyns, who only had another year to live, was angry at his university. 
 If Cambridge did not want Ramsey, others did. 
 Suggestions of jobs kept flowing in. 
 One of them brings us evidence of how Ramsey appeared at this time to an austere critic. 
 St Chad's College in Durham, which was then a theological college, tried to get him as its Principal. 
 He went to see the Bishop of Durham, who gave him tea. 
 The bishop was Hensley Henson, who kept a frank diary: &bquo;26 November 1936. 
 Ramsey is a heavy fellow with a fat face, and a cumbrous manner, not prepossessing, but improving on acquaintance.&equo; 
 After Hensley Henson's death this became one of Ramsey's favourite quotations. 
 There was a contrast. 
 Inside the college at Lincoln the students thought that this teacher was a fine teacher and fun but too odd to be offered responsibilities; and outside the college were a plethora of people who were not the university of Cambridge, anxious to offer every variety of job, pastoral, academic, or administrative. 
 Ramsey kept refusing. 
 This contrast was pointed by William Temple. 
 In July 1936 he gathered in his palace at Bishopthorpe a select team of ten for the purpose of preparing for the coming ecumenical conference. 
 There was Emil Brunner one of the two leading Christian thinkers on the Continent of Europe; there was Reinhold Niebuhr, one of the two leading Christian thinkers from the United States; there was Visser t'Hooft, the Dutchman who built up the World Council of Churches; there was J. H. Oldham, at that moment the leading thinker about Christian society in the British Isles; and there was Bernard Manning, the Congregationalist historian who was a friend of the Ramsey family in Cambridge. 
 And there too, in this galaxy, was the sub-warden of Lincoln Theological College. 
 He was not there only by courtesy. 
  Temple and Oldham pressed at him hard &mdash; he must write one of the essays, he was the only person who could do it, they told him. 
 He thought that they were wrong to press him. 
 He reluctantly agreed to write the essay and then did not. 
 It was the only time when he was intimate with his hero Temple. 
 He found him a charming host without any touch of stiffness or pomposity; &bquo;like a merry rollicking schoolboy&equo;. 
 He enjoyed Temple's huge laugh. 
 With surprise he watched him consume a lot of macaroni. 
 They dressed for dinner every night. 
 The occasion hardly sounds important. 
 But to be a young unknown among the famous, and to hear them argue, he felt to be an education. 
 This meeting with Temple was so important to him that the photograph of the group hung on the wall of his room when he died. 
 The next move was strange. 
 That spring Ramsey gave a course of addresses during Holy Week in Lincoln Cathedral. 
 The Bishop of Lincoln, Nugent Hicks, in whose palace Ramsey played Murder, attended this course. 
 He could not understand what Ramsey was talking about. 
 He decided that this clergyman was in the clouds and out of the reach of the common man. 
 He told Ramsey that his language was paradoxical and difficult. 
 He said that what he needed was more contact with ordinary people. 
 Ramsey hoped now to be a teacher in a university. 
 He needed colleagues and a bigger library. 
 But he had a high doctrine of bishops. 
 He thought that a priest should if possible go where his bishop sent him. 
 The bishop gave him the extraordinary advice to go and be a curate again, at Boston in Lincolnshire. 
 Ramsey agreed. 
 It was the only strange decision of Ramsey's career. 
 For an unintelligible speaker to learn to speak intelligibly, it may not be the best training, and certainly it is not the only training, to send him to the pulpit of Boston parish church. 
 To cure woolly-headedness it is not indispensable to inflict the woolly-headedness on the denizens under Boston Stump. 
 And something is curious. 
 The evidence of the students at the college is that this was a clear teacher. 
 They told Austin Farrer that he was a spell-binder. 
 Ramsey was asked later, were you getting unintelligible, or was it only that the bishop was a bad listener to Holy Week addresses? 
 Ramsey replied, &bquo;I kept saying Yes is No and No is Yes.&equo; 
 He was laughing when he said it. 
 Perhaps there was something more than coherence at stake. 
 A theological college is a narrow world, frequently compared to a greenhouse. 
 After only eighteen months breathing the dust of the docks, Ramsey taught for six years and a half in a greenhouse. 
 If he went to be the head gardener of another greenhouse and did another ten years  teaching among the geraniums, what species of hothouse plant might result? 
 Perhaps this is what Nugent Hicks saw, or feared. 
 But we know something else about the bishop's motive which he could not or would not say to Ramsey. 
 He told the rector at Boston that this was a person of unusual spiritual powers; that how to train him for the whole Church was a responsibility; that he was anxious that these abilities should not be confined to academic spheres. 
 Did the bishop see, what no one else could see, that this unusual teacher had the possibility of being a great bishop? 
 BOSTON 
 Boston Stump, a famous parish church and landmark, had a rector and four curates. 
 The senior curate, who was Michael Ramsey, was called lecturer but his duties were no different. 
 He lived in a little hired house five minutes from the church, on a stipend of &pound;260 a year. 
 At first he was melancholy at leaving the friendships of Lincoln. 
 One of his fellow-curates was a champion cyclist, with incredible expeditions all over Europe and Asia. 
 His fellow-curates found him liable to vast silences, during which he twisted a bit of cotton with the fingers of both hands. 
 Ramsey had his district to visit. 
 He taught once a week in the primary school and felt a failure at it. 
 He had a weekly class for Sunday school teachers, which included a Methodist headmaster and several women who taught in the nonconformist Sunday schools. 
 This he enjoyed. 
 From autumn 1937 he had a large class of teachers to instruct on the gospels. 
 He was in demand as a confessor, from a few parishioners, a few neighbouring clergy, a few old students at Lincoln. 
 He found the parish set-up conventional and that was hard to be bear; &bquo;irksome&equo; he called it. 
 Told by high authority that no one could understand him in a pulpit, he worried about sermons more than anything. 
 He who had preached with power in Liverpool suddenly found preaching very difficult in Lincolnshire. 
 He was sure that the bishop was right and that he was hard to follow. 
 His struggles for clarity were painful. 
 But they made him realize that he was getting across what he wanted to get across, and not a holy-sounding fog of words. 
 If the people of Lincolnshire were thought by their bishop not to understand Ramsey in a pulpit, this was not the opinion outside the  diocese. 
 The invitations came thick and fast. 
 He was bad at saying no. 
 He could not lecture for the Archbishop of Canterbury because he was already committed to lecture for the Archbishop of York. 
 It was clear that he was no ordinary curate. 
 He was already a member of ecumenical committees. 
 A mind with original ideas, who wished to persuade the Protestants to be more Catholic and to persuade the Catholics to respect the truths of Protestantism, was instantly a must for those who thought about the reunion of the Churches. 
 He started to have to attend meetings in London. 
 William Temple got him an honouring invitation, as a delegate to the vast ecumenical conference at Edinburgh in 1937. 
 Ramsey refused this invitation because if he were away it would be awkward for the holiday plans of the staff of Boston parish church. 
 He afterwards thought this refusal very foolish and regretted that he did not go. 
 For his refreshment he played hockey vigorously in the local team or cycled in the fen country. 
 He would walk a long distance out to some pub, often the Malcolm Arms at Anton's Gowt, and have lunch in the bar on beer and bread and cheese. 
 On his walks he could sometimes be observed waving his hat about and talking to himself. 
 The oddity which the fellow-curates remarked was that as he walked in the procession from the vestry up the aisle he could be heard whistling. 
 No one minded. 
 They took it for granted that this was Ramsey. 
 The most famous story of Ramsey's absent-mindedness comes from Boston. 
 It sounds like legend but there is excellent evidence of its truth. 
 He went out without his front-door key. 
 When he came back he rang the bell. 
 His landlady was nervous of strangers and called through the door, &bquo;I'm sorry, Mr Ramsey is out.&equo; 
 Ramsey: &bquo;I'll return later.&equo; 
 About this time he started to wonder whether he ought to be a monk. 
 If he was not to be a lecturer at Cambridge because they did not think him academic enough, and if he was not to be a parish priest because he could not keep teenagers in order and because the adults were said not to understand him and because he felt a teaching vocation, where was his right place? 
 He had three functions in which he knew that he was at home. 
 The first was in prayer. 
 The second was in teaching the truths of Christianity, not in conventional ways. 
 And the third was as a confessor, because he knew that many souls valued him in this work. 
 A monastery was a place of prayer, and some monks had teaching duties, and most of them had to guide souls. 
 Was it possible that for the sake of prayer and guidance of souls he had a calling to the unmarried state? 
 The thought that it might be right to be a monk kept coming back. 
 His knowledge of the Anglican religious communities, such as it was, made him think that if he decided to try this out, Mirfield in Yorkshire  would be the right place; for at Mirfield many of the fathers had a vocation to teach, or to hear confessions. 
 Once he took this far enough to discuss the plan with one of the fathers from Mirfield. 
 In June 1937 Hoskyns died suddenly, at the age of only 52. 
 Ramsey felt the death to be a personal calamity. 
 The master and the pupil had moved apart intellectually &mdash; Hoskyns willing to be more and more obscure in his wrestlings with truth, Ramsey struggling for clarity of thinking. 
 Not till later was it diagnosed that the mental breakdown which destroyed Hoskyns crept upon him for a year or more before he died. 
 But the death was a &bquo;terrible blow&equo;, as he said, in the affection and gratitude of a former disciple. 
 And it put still further off the remote vision of a lectureship at Cambridge. 
 The death had an unexpected consequence. 
 Corpus Christi College provided for Hoskyns's teaching in such a way that their parish of St Benet's, on the edge of the college precinct, was vacant. 
 They asked Ramsey to be the vicar. 
 The offer appealed. 
 The parish was tiny, hardly anyone lived in it, the church was small and easy to fill; congregations select; a little Sunday school but run by a lady; some undergraduates; hardly anyone to visit; the proximity of Edward Wynn and Milner-White and Wilfred Knox and his father. 
 If the students of Lincoln were right in thinking that he was not a good administrator, this church had less administration than any church in the land. 
 He would have access to the great library, and some touch with the academics, and yet his pastoral instinct, and his work as a confessor, would have outlet. 
 He then preferred the idea of such mixed work to a university lectureship. 
 The Bishop of Lincoln thought it ridiculous that this powerful engine which was Michael Ramsey should be used in a tiny little parish, and said so, but blessed him when he found he wanted to go. 
 He became the vicar of St Benet's Cambridge on 6 January 1939. 
 Corpus Christi College made the suggestion that he should sleep in Corpus but take his meals in his old college of Magdalene; a proposal so bizarre that it should be accounted for by a motive, not to have at dinner a famously silent person, imagined as a wet blanket. 
 In those days the Fellows of Corpus were rather proud of the briskness of their conversation. 
 Instead Ramsey moved into lodgings in Newnham (45 Owlstone Road). 
 ST BENET'S AT CAMBRIDGE 
 The number in the congregation did not rise. 
 A few dons came. 
 Ramsey's father frequently deserted his Congregational church and  came to hear his son. 
 Ramsey had a time announced for hearing confessions and some people came. 
 The service ground its way through, because the lady organist insisted on playing the hymns Lentissimo  and this slow pace gave torments to the new vicar. 
 We have a memory of Ramsey from a girl whose family attended St Benet's. 
 She was sent to him to be prepared for confirmation. 
 He seemed to her to be extremely ancient (he was 35). 
 His hair was grey but with a trace of red hair remaining in his bushy eyebrows. 
 She noticed that he walked as though he had pebbles in his shoes. 
 &bquo;He was very shy, and preparing teenagers for confirmation was not really his m&eacute;tier., Despite this verdict, she became a faithful member of the Church. 
 Usually a priest matters more by what he is than by what he says. 
 We have another memory from a girl who was then 16. 
 She agreed with the Bishop of Lincoln rather than with the students of Lincoln, for she thought him a disaster in the pulpit; blinking, and articulating his words with difficulty, and often using the peculiar phrase &bquo;paradoxic ally speaking&equo;. 
 Then the children were evacuated from London in fear of air raids and that made life difficult for many Sunday schools, since the London children wanted to show the local children how tough they were. 
 But the girl remembered Ramsey taking the evacuees round him in the children's corner, and sitting on one of the low chairs meant for a child, and talking to them naturally and with an obvious pleasure. 
 The churchwarden Mrs Eagleston was to become a devoted friend of Ramsey. 
 It distressed her that her vicar should be seen charging through the town with his underpants showing through his trousers. 
 She thought that he needed a wife. 
 She was relieved, for the sake of the parish, when he rang her up in 1940 to say that he was leaving. 
 He saw little of Raven. 
 He had nothing whatever to do with the faculty of divinity. 
 He taught two pupils from Magdalene. 
 He studied hard at the Epistle to the Hebrews. 
 He meant to write a book about it. 
 The book never got written. 
 The world moved to war. 
 He must black out the house, and the vestry of the church. 
 He asked the bishop to put his name on the list for an army chaplaincy. 
 The worst of being in a job which the world regarded as not the right place for him was that the world would not leave him alone. 
 A month before the World War broke out, and only a few months after he became a parish priest, the Archbishop of Canterbury tried to make him head of St Augustine's College at Canterbury, which had the work of training men to be missionaries. 
 A month after the outbreak of war the Bishop of Durham, A. T. P. Williams, wrote in his lovely handwriting a letter sounding Ramsey whether he would become the professor of divinity at the university of Durham. 
 With the chair went a canonry at the  cathedral. 
 On 30 November 1939 the bishop converted this into a definite offer of the chair and the canonry. 
 Ramsey's college refused him a research fellowship. 
 His university refused him a not lofty post in the faculty of divinity. 
 And now he was offered a professorship at another university. 
 Most of the stipend at Durham came from the canonry. 
 Therefore the university was in the habit of leaving the choice of professor to the bishop. 
 The bishop was headmaster of Winchester College at the time that Ramsey's brilliant brother Frank was a scholar. 
 He asked the opinion of William Temple about filling the chair. 
 Ramsey asked himself whether if the electors had been the university officers without the bishop they would have regarded a man of one book as electable. 
 He decided that they would not. 
 His diffidence blinded him to the truth that the one book was already influential in modern thinking. 
 He was instituted to the canonry in Durham cathedral on 27 January 1940 and in mid-February settled into a gigantic house which went with the canonry. 
 The rooms were vast. 
 All the furniture which he possessed in Newnham furnished one half of one of the rooms. 
 He went to an auction of a big house in Cambridge and bought a lot of cheap carpets. 
 He seemed born to be a professor. 
 He arrived at this destination at the early age of 35. 
 He looked certain to remain a professor for the rest of his life. 
 Professor Ramsey 
 MARRIAGE 
 The house had historic escutcheons on the outer walls, and unhistoric battlements on the roof, and a glorious view from its cliff over the River Wear. 
 It poked its front door out into the green as though to challenge an equality with the deanery opposite. 
 It had no heating, its paint was peeling, and its wallpaper obeyed the rule of the new canon's parents that it does not show the dirt when it is dark. 
 The house was suitable for a prolific father who wore two pairs of combinations next the skin. 
 Ramsey lived in the rooms of the bishop's chaplain at the Castle while an architect put in central heating and clothed the walls in lighter paper. 
 Even with the new heating, warmth was hard to get: two years later the chapter struggled to find firewood for the canons since other fuel could not be got; and a defective boiler in the cathedral was made in Germany and could not be mended. 
 The first thing that struck the other dons who lived in the Castle was his oddness. 
 The Warden (Vice-Chancellor) Duff assured them that he was now not nearly so odd as he was when he had known him at the choir school of King's College. 
 The Principal of St John's declared roundly that he was a lunatic &mdash; &bquo;I saw him yesterday afternoon walking down the Bailey with one foot on the pavement and one foot in the gutter all the way&equo;. 
 Certainly he waved his arms about more than most men when in action. 
 And most of the seniors had not welcomed the appointment. 
 He was absurdly young. 
 Some of them disliked his book. 
 They thought that he looked antique, when at rest. 
 He was not yet quite bald, but nearly. 
 He had a grey fringe round back and sides, although a few wisps that had once been fair or ginger were combed over the top. 
 Occasionally he was referred to by those who saw him at services as &bquo;the old canon&equo; though he was much the youngest of the canons. 
 They were privately amused at his clumsiness. 
 In the college at Durham they saw him, as they thought, learning to ride a bicycle; but the truth was that whenever he rode a bicycle he looked as though he  was learning to ride. 
 They found that he was not good in processions, for the curious roll prevented him from keeping ranks like the others. 
 They attributed this not to anything physical but to meditation on higher things. 
 He had no curtains but shutters and makeshift scraps for the black-out. 
 That summer he enlisted as an air-raid warden and sat long hours of the night by a telephone doing nothing. 
 In October 1940 the army billeted an officer in one of the numerous spare rooms. 
 People who needed rooms came into his empty spaces. 
 A young Roman Catholic soldier from the Lancashire Fusiliers was billeted on him for two summer months of 1941 and never forgot the joyful singing which used to accompany Ramsey's washing and shaving before he went off to the cathedral each morning. 
 The Lucas boys kept their model railway in the house and their cries penetrated the professor's study disturbingly. 
 Sometimes he played soldiers with them and they thought little of his plans for defence in depth. 
 He ran races with their younger sister in the monks' dormitory. 
 John Lucas, the future philosopher, remembered being taught Greek grammar by Ramsey and sitting on his head while reciting Greek verbs. 
 As a canon of Durham Ramsey was one of the custodians of a great monument of the European inheritance in architecture, at a time when bombs dropped upon Britain. 
 The dean and canons organized their rota of fire-watching and felt helpless. 
 They took a vow like those of the Middle Ages where someone swore to go on crusade if his wife's life was saved. 
 They promised that if their cathedral came through unscathed, they would dedicate a window in gratitude to the Royal Air Force. 
 The window by Hugh Easton is at the north-west corner of the cathedral and was erected in 1950. 
 It has the text of Isaiah 31: 5, &bquo;As birds flying, so will the Lord of hosts defend Jerusalem&equo;; and above the city and cathedral of Durham an airman rides upon an eagle, protected from above by a winged seraph. 
 The Dean of Durham was Cyril Alington, a former headmaster of Eton. 
 An assistant master at Eton reported a message from the dean's wife, a delectable woman: &bquo;We have a new canon here at Durham. 
 His name is Michael Ramsey. 
 He is nice. 
 But he has no small talk. 
 He can talk about the Atonement. 
 But, whether unfortunately or not, that is not the subject which is usually uppermost in our minds.&equo; 
 Alington allowed him and two other canons to introduce the daily sacrament on condition that they did not expect it to be part of the cathedral's official usage. 
 Ramsey preached in his canon's turn at the cathedral. 
 Some people found the sing-song voice a barrier, and found the beginning and the middle easier to listen to than the end. 
 It was soon  agreed, however, that he was worth hearing. 
 The music meant little to him, but the history, the architecture, the stones, the daily sacrament, and all the associations of the place remained with him permanently. 
 He was in demand for the hearing of confessions and made a little chapel for this purpose on the ground floor of his house. 
 He also took it in turns with other canons to act as verger and lock up the cathedral at night in the shortage of vergers caused by the war. 
 He once locked two visiting American soldiers inside the cathedral one evening and promised to come to let them out in half an hour but forgot to come. 
 Two doors away lived his former warden at Lincoln, Leslie Owen, now the Bishop of Jarrow. 
 Leslie Owen had a secretary who also was his chauffeur, Joan Hamilton. 
 She visited Durham to see a friend and fell in love with the city and began to help with girls' clubs in Durham and Sunderland. 
 Then she became Bishop Owen's secretary and driver and staff officer. 
 The idea of becoming a monk vanished from Ramsey's heart. 
 They announced the engagement in November 1941. 
 The morning it was announced a vast audience arrived for Ramsey's lecture and cheered him all the way up to the dais. 
 His eyebrows twitched and he said, &bquo;This week we are dealing with the sixth chapter of St Matthew&hellip;&equo; whereupon 90 per cent of the audience tumbled out of the room. 
 They were married on 8 April 1942 in the Galilee chapel of Durham cathedral. 
 It was the time of the Baedeker raids, when German bombers struck cathedral towns, and some of the guests who stayed in York the night before had sleepless hours. 
 Joan Ramsey, open-hearted, smiling, caring, changed his life. 
 The cold vast house became warm in atmosphere and hospitable. 
 Since she had been secretary to a bishop (she learnt to type by trial and error), and also chauffeur to a bishop (she learnt to drive by trial and error), she knew a lot of the clergy and their wives and had visited them all over the diocese, often in the black-out, and sat with the wives while the husbands talked to Bishop Owen, so she was good at remembering about them and their children and found the wives of the clergy to be fun. 
 She helped to create for him widening circles of friends, the cathedral community, the university, the clergy of the diocese, the students. 
 She could not provide him with small talk, or prod him to abandon his silences. 
 She did not cure absent-mindedness. 
 She would send him off to some lecturing engagement with butter and other  rations to give his hostess, and when he came back the rations would be found as a soggy mess in his pocket. 
 But she made him less formidable. 
 It was also noticed that he ceased to whistle unconsciously as he walked up the aisle from the vestry. 
 If he was in a procession the other members of the procession still worried about his inability to walk a straight line and feared that at some point he would peel off from the file. 
 Even five years later a clergyman who came to a retreat which he conducted thought him the oddest sight, sartorially, which he had seen among academics. 
 His high-pitched southern university voice caused amusement to North Country clergy who came. 
 But, said one of them, &bquo;when he began to talk about St John, all this was forgotten&equo;. 
 The wit which once held the Cambridge Union in thrall was again in evidence. 
 Later in life he looked back upon the married time of his professorship at Durham as an idyll; the paradisal years of his life. 
 No children ever came. 
 Occasion ally they were vaguely sad about it but they never considered adopting. 
 They were happy together and both were fulfilled in their work. 
 And after a time they accepted it as their vocation to be childless. 
 But they were not deprived of children. 
 Various children, with whom both of them were very good, were about the house in profusion. 
 There were the Lucas boys with their model railway, there were a couple of evacuees with their mothers, there was a German Jewess refugee with her adopted child, there was a friend who lived with them and helped at a school and her children were in and out a lot. 
 Then the first &bquo;maid&equo; they ever had was a girl of 16 called Mollie and she had been deserted by her husband and came to live in the house with three tots. 
 Married life was a contrast with the experience of the bachelor living solitary amid echoing halls. 
 In the midst of all this young life it was fortunate that the house was roomy enough for the professor still to get enough quiet and space to write. 
 They started to run meetings in the house for the wives of the clergy, where Ramsey talked theology to them and mixed it with a lot of humour. 
 The professor was asked out to preach in mining parishes; and he discovered that, despite the views of the Bishop of Lincoln and the teenagers of St Benet's that he was unintelligible in a pulpit, he could feel them hanging on his words. 
 We have an eye-witness who heard him when he went to preach at Easington colliery to a large congregation of miners and their families, who felt that he himself and the other hearers were electrified. 
 Ramsey spoke of eternal life. 
 The witness judged part of the secret to lie in the way he seemed to think out what he wanted to say as he went along and made the audience share his struggle after truth.  
 THE DURHAM CHAIR 
 The faculty of divinity at Durham had as Ramsey's predecessor Oliver Quick, who with William Temple was a leading mind in the Church of England. 
 Michael Ramsey succeeded someone famous throughout the land. 
 The faculty could not think that a young man of 35 years, who had written one book which not everyone thought wonderful, could hold a candle to his predecessor. 
 They felt coolly towards the newcomer. 
 His first achievement as a professor was to overcome and then reverse the suspicion with which his appointment was received. 
 They found that he knew what he wanted; that he was persuasive in trying to get it; that what he wanted was good; and they suddenly realized that this new young professor dragged them into the twentieth century. 
 On the board of theology he was dominant, to reform the curriculum and the examinations. 
 This was the place where there were rows about his reformation. 
 The other members began to find that he gave the faculty coherence and a sense of purpose. 
 This was not by drama, but by being around, and by being himself, and by an infectious enthusiasm. 
 Whether or not he was a sound thinker, on which they could disagree, no one could doubt that they had a professor who loved his subject; he bubbled with it. 
 He was kept busy writing lectures for he found the faculty grossly understaffed. 
 He had a class of thirty young men. 
 He did not think many of them bright (but the record afterwards shows that several were very bright). 
 He got to know them well: years later when they appeared suddenly he could remember who they were. 
 At their request he umpired their boat-races on the River Wear. 
 As a lecturer he was concise and audible. 
 Though he did not dictate, he went at a pace slow enough for the listeners to take down a lot of what he said. 
 He would end his lecture with a summarizing epigram. 
 After a time it became known in other faculties that this was rather a special lecturer and people reading classics or history or the sciences took the trouble to go over to Ramsey's lectures and swell his class. 
 He managed to increase the staff in two ways; first by getting the endowment for the chair of Greek freed from the attachment to a canonry and then the endowment of the canonry used to give a second professorship of theology; secondly by persuading the vice-chancellor to find money for a lectureship in New Testament studies. 
 For this lectureship he chose (1945) Kingsley Barrett, who was a dedicated  
 Methodist. 
 Since all the teachers in the faculty hitherto were Anglican, this choice of a Methodist for a key post did not go unobserved. 
 It was destined to influence Ramsey's later career. 
 He widened the faculty from being Anglican to being for all denominations. 
 He widened it from a training for future priests of the Church of England to a course which anyone might wish to read for their education. 
 Afterwards he felt that he had a hard struggle. 
 The teaching method which he found he regarded as spoon-feeding. 
 He thought the lectures far too many and that he gave too many lectures for his own good. 
 He reduced their number. 
 He wanted more seminars and more individual tuition. 
 He also wanted more theology. 
 Why should a faculty of theology teach only the history of Christianity or the study of language? 
 By the time he left it was the most respected faculty of divinity in English universities. 
 He hated the word student . 
 In his view it divided young from old by its suggestion that only young people study. 
 He hated the word department  because it suggested bureaucracy. 
 But otherwise he preferred the system at Durham, where the teaching unit was powerful, to the system he knew at Cambridge, where the social unit was powerful yet excluded the spouses. 
 He also preferred the Durham system to the Cambridge system because it afforded the chance of more general courses of study. 
 He did not like an excess of specialization and thought that a university should do what it could to counteract the trend, and help arts undergraduates to learn a bit of science or vice versa. 
 With his experience of an old university and a less old university, with two different systems, he was able to frame for himself what he valued in the English university. 
 He thought that a lot of residence was of high importance; for he believed that the object of higher education was not just information, or preparation for a career, but a community of minds and personalities. 
 &bquo;It is not difficult&equo;, he would say later, &bquo;to produce sophisticated men and women by collecting them to learn certain subjects. 
 But it is not sophisticated men and women that a good university tries to produce. 
 It is men and women whose knowledge goes with character, and with reverence for persons and for the things of the mind.&equo; 
 Young John Lucas, who lived hard by and sat on Professor Ramsey's head to recite Greek verbs, heard stories from his father of Ramsey taking on atheists in the university in public debate and wiping the floor with them. 
 Whether the boy understood what father said, or whether Ramsey did so, is more doubtful. 
 It was never his habit to try to wipe the  floor with anyone. 
 His experience of his brother Frank made him respectful of sincerity, and well able to hold his own against clever atheist onslaught. 
 The early years were war years &mdash; the horror of news, and fear of raids, and blackness at night, and poor food, and sitting up all night, and very earnest prayer. 
 Ramsey never failed to be grateful to the young pilots who won the Battle of Britain, and always afterwards remembered Battle of Britain Sunday. 
 In 1943 he suffered a disaster when the stock of his now famous book was all destroyed in the London blitz. 
 He continued to write. 
 The book which he spent most of the war writing was naturally about death: The Resurrection , published in 1945. 
 It had large sales for a time in England and America, but it had neither the originality nor the power of his first book. 
 The heirs of Bethune-Baker at Cambridge thought it lamentable. 
 The Modern Churchman  produced what Ramsey called a &bquo;rather vehement and contemptuous&equo; review; slightly with an air of &bquo;we settled this question long ago, why must this young man interfere?&equo; 
 Ramsey was not moved and printed a reply. 
 Then in 1949 he published a lovely book, The Transfiguration . 
 The thought of glory always rose quickly amid his devotions and the book was scholarly meditation on glory in the New Testament. 
 In far away Haiti a young black Methodist minister, Philip Potter, who would one day be Secretary of the World Council of Churches, mulled over the book as he struggled with villainy in a very poor and very sad land. 
 Near the end of his life Ramsey was asked which of his books he was most glad to have written. 
 He replied unhesitatingly,&equo; The Transfiguration  '. 
 One other book came out of the Durham days, though it was not published till later. 
 Frederick Denison Maurice, the Christian Socialist, was the most cloudy, some said most woolly, some said most profound, of the Victorian thinkers. 
 Because of the impact of Socialism in power in Britain and of the welfare state during Attlee's post-war government, Maurice attained a celebrity not known since his death eighty years before. 
 Lots of people wanted to know how Christians were Socialist and how Socialists were Christian. 
 Lots of people wanted to read Maurice. 
 They tried it and were baffled. 
 Michael Ramsey was the son of a mother who was a Socialist and who thought that her Socialism sprang out of her Christianity. 
 He decided to make Maurice understood by the undergraduates of Durham University. 
 That feat could not be achieved without making Maurice more down-to-earth than he was. 
 Ramsey grew famous in the Churches. 
 He got more and more entangled in committees of the ecumenical movement, which was on a rising tide of Christian hope, and which badly needed trained English  academics to help. 
 In 1947 he was well known as one of the authors &mdash; in fact he was the chairman of the group and the principal author and the person in charge of publication &mdash; of a report to the Archbishop of Canterbury, now Geoffrey Fisher, on the nature of Catholicity . 
 This report made such an impact that two other groups wrote answers to it. 
 At such meetings he was valued. 
 Here was an Anglo-Catholic who insisted on the apostolic succession of bishops, and thought intercommunion between the Churches, before a proper union, to be wrong, and yet refused to unchurch the Protestant Churches. 
 Rome refused to take any part in these proceedings, except by unofficial observers. 
 Therefore a man like Ramsey brought the argument about Christian unity up against the fundamental question of Catholicity versus Protestantism in a way which few others could. 
 The Protestant leaders found him far too rigid. 
 But he was curiously persuasive. 
 He was never tempted to see &bquo;bishops&equo; as a key for locking the door on dissenters. 
 He never separated &bquo;bishops&equo; from an agelong body of historic Catholic devotion and prayer. 
 He hated definitions of apostolic succession which made it sound as though a lot of laying on of hands from century to century was a bit of magic by which God preserves his Church. 
 He once defined the Anglican doctrine of apostolic succession to several Lutherans so that at the end they could be heard saying &bquo;Hear, Hear&equo;. 
 And another reason why he grew more and more weighty was his refusal to accept Guff. 
 There was a mood, if we cloud all this up in realms of high theology then we shall all agree on what we cannot understand. 
 Ramsey was determined on clarity. 
 &bquo;Seeing through a glass darkly&equo;, he once told an ecumenical committee, &bquo;is not the same thing as an ecumenical fog., After the war he began to travel to meetings as a consultant. 
 The most important of these was at Amsterdam for the first meeting of the World Council of Churches 1948. 
 Here he argued with the European leaders of Protestantism, from Karl Barth downwards, over the difference between a Catholic and a Protestant idea of the Church. 
 At this point the old-looking young professor from Durham entered a European scene. 
 The Nazis created a wave of Christian feeling in Europe, almost a religious revival, in antipathy to their racialism and anti-Semitism and violence and injustice. 
 Before 1939 the ecumenical movement was always a clerical &eacute;lite within the older Churches. 
 Its force among people  lay in the missionary areas and the young Churches where Indians or Africans could not see what European divisions had to do with them. 
 But Hitler made world Christianity something that for a moment even people in the pews could see as an expression of peace, and amity, and human rights, and the moral law in politics. 
 The old committees where clergymen of various denominations talked in polysyllables to each other's waistcoats were given a sudden strength as they touched the aspirations of the peoples. 
 The meeting at Amsterdam was the focus of these hopes. 
 It could not fulfil them. 
 As a Cold War frustrated the yearnings which the people put upon the new organization of the United Nations, a cold war entered Christendom. 
 Was a meeting of world Christianity a propaganda design against an atheist Soviet union? 
 The American Secretary of State, John Foster Dulles, practically said so at the Amsterdam meeting. 
 The Soviet government said so. 
 Therefore the Russian Churches, at a synod in Moscow that year, said so and refused to send a single representative. 
 The satellite states of Moscow followed this lead &mdash; no Bulgarians, nor Romanians, nor Yugoslavs. 
 How could Christendom be represented when the weightiest part of the most historic of Churches refused to have anything to do with the meeting? 
 Ever since the days when Ramsey was a boy at Repton, the Pope refused to have anything to do with the ecumenical movement. 
 The Churches said that they would try to unite &mdash; but this was nonsense, there was only one Church and he was it. 
 Rome suspected the ecumenicals of planning a Protestant federation across the world which would be designed as a force against Rome. 
 Some of the utterances of ecumenical s gave ground for this suspicion. 
 An American Congregationalist, for example, saw no possibility of uniting with Rome and every reason for not uniting with Rome &mdash; let us join the Churches which teach more or less the truth, not the Churches which do not. 
 Such speeches shocked Rome. 
 At some meetings during the twenties and thirties unofficial Roman Catholic observers were permitted. 
 But Rome did not merely refuse to send any representative to Amsterdam. 
 It banned unofficial observers from attending. 
 This rigidity shocked the ecumenicals. 
 How then could the meeting at Amsterdam pose as a meeting of Christendom when the largest Church in the world refused to have anything to do with it? 
 These strange circumstances pushed into prominence the only Catholics who were not banned from attending the meeting. 
 The Russian revolution of 1917 drove out many Russians. 
 At Paris Georges Florovsky taught theology and interpreted the Russian tradition to the  West. 
 At Amsterdam he talked out of a vast tradition which otherwise was not very articulate at the meeting. 
 His presence and influence there made him a figure in world Christendom. 
 And the Anglo-Catholic tradition would never swallow the idea that world Christianity was a federation of Protestant Churches. 
 Of the Anglo-Catholics the professional thinker in Amsterdam was Michael Ramsey. 
 The cold war condemnations of Moscow and the obsessive rigidity of Rome elevated Florovsky, on that stage, into a mouthpiece of the eastern Catholic tradition, and elevated Ramsey into a mouthpiece of the western Catholic tradition. 
 He described his own experiences in a public article ( Ecumenical  Review , I (1949), 388&ndash;92). 
 They met as a commission, under the chairmanship of the Swede Gustaf Aul&eacute;n, to debate the first theme of the agenda, the Universal Church in God's Design. 
 The commission contained Karl Barth, and Florovsky, and the American Protestant Mackay who was a man of polysyllables, and the more profound American Protestant Richard Niebuhr, and Ernst Wolf to represent the German Lutheran tradition, and a few others. 
 Ramsey described the contrast as strange, between the hard hitting of the debate and the friendliness of the people. 
 They quickly discovered that they could not agree. 
 They made no attempt to cover up the disagreement with beautiful words. 
 Any member on a committee to which Karl Barth belonged had a rough ride. 
 Afterwards the general meeting was disappointed and some said that this commission was unrepresentative of the Churches and ought to be disregarded. 
 It was, they said, a set of academic hair-splitters. 
 But, said Ramsey, the idea that we can get Christian unity by going for a highest common factor and leaving everything else in the shadow will not work. 
 What is vigorous and worth while in the various traditions is precisely what is not in common. 
 The commission moved away from the idea that Christians agree on what is important and disagree only on what is trivial. 
 They were therefore accused of putting the clock back and bringing the best hope of Christendom to an impasse. 
 Still, despite the absence of Rome and Moscow, the antithesis between Catholic and Protestant was taken seriously by Amsterdam. 
 Ramsey had moved out of the Barthian influence which via Hoskyns attracted him during the earlier 1930s. 
 The continental commentators on Amsterdam were in the habit of minuting Ramsey's name as that of the chief opponent of Barth. 
 The recorded utterance of Barth to Ramsey at Amsterdam was, &bquo;I am sorry you do not hate the Pope&equo;. 
 But Ramsey and Barth found that they shared a common sense of humour. 
 They had instant rapport. 
 Barth was amused and pleased when he heard  how someone said that if he and Ramsey could get on so well &bquo;the millennium must be round the corner&equo;. 
 Barth had never met a real Anglo-Catholic before and was excited by what he found. 
 When he went home to Basle he showed the photographs to his family and pointed out to them &bquo;my very good neighbour Canon Ramsay &lsqb; sic &rsqb; from Durham, an authentic Anglo-Catholic, with strange views concerning tradition, succession, ontology and so on, but also with a very convincing twinkle in his eye&hellip; a man with whom I more often agreed than disagreed&hellip; the  outstanding figure in the picture of my first ecumenical experience!&equo; 
 The Roman Catholics were interested that a combination between a Russian refugee, Georges Florovsky, an English high churchman, Michael Ramsey, and a dogmatic Swiss Protestant, Karl Barth, brought the ecumenical movement to an impasse because none of them was prepared to put up with a Protestant federation, and the union of these unlikely allies was too powerful to overcome. 
 The nature of the meeting left Ramsey with a doubt. 
 These meetings could not be said to be unimportant because world Christianity ought to be seen to meet. 
 But could the discussion do any good? 
 With such numbers, and so many set speeches, and with most of the participants having done no work beforehand, could you ever get clarity into a report produced by a mass debate? 
 This doubt about world synods was not lessened by later experience. 
 By the time of the World Council at Amsterdam the question began to come into Ramsey's head what he ought to do next. 
 He found that the canonry and the cathedral, and the administration in the university, took up a lot of time. 
 He seemed to himself to need more leisure to pursue his studies of the New Testament and of Christian thought more profoundly. 
 He wondered where he could find a chance of quieter work. 
 Some of the Scotsmen talked of getting Ramsey as Bishop of Edinburgh but not enough of the Scotsmen wanted an Englishman and no doubt there were those who wondered whether this professor who lived among clouds of glory would make a bishop who perforce lived in a too real world. 
 Then, by an extraordinary fortune, the three Cambridge chairs of divinity which were or could be in his field of study fell vacant within three years. 
 All of them had the attraction of fewer chores and a better library &mdash; as well as, for him, the genius loci  of a childhood home. 
 They also had more of a challenge than Durham. 
 He would have to  move into a school where the powerful names were still Bethune-Baker (though he was retired) and Marsh and Raven and he would be, intellectually speaking, up against it in a way that he was not at Durham. 
 That was a challenge which he would like to undertake. 
 He thought the post &bquo;more exposed&equo;, &bquo;less cosy&equo;. 
 He applied for the first chair and then thought better of it and withdrew the application; refused to apply for the second despite the supplications of Cambridge friends; and finally applied for the third, the chair of primacy, the regius chair made vacant by the retirement of Charles Raven. 
 Raven did not want Ramsey to succeed him. 
 Although the chair was a regius chair, it was not like most regius chairs an appointment by the King. 
 Since the reign of Queen Elizabeth I the professor was elected. 
 In 1950 the electors consisted of a board of the vice-chancellor and eight persons of whom five were at Cambridge and three from outside Cambridge; but one of the five was away in America, and absent persons cannot vote. 
 Elections are confidential and no one knows what happened. 
 It is certain that the vice-chancellor in the chair gained the impression from what was said at the meeting that they were forced to elect from a weak field of candidates. 
 It is certain that the electors discussed the name of Stephen Neill, who had had a far more brilliant academic career as an undergraduate than Michael Ramsey and had lately dazzled the university by his lecturing and preaching power. 
 It is certain that they discussed the name of the neo-Thomist philosopher Eric Mascall, who succeeded Ramsey at Lincoln. 
 Professor Marsh, whose superb lectures the undergraduate Ramsey attended, refused to vote for Ramsey no doubt because he disapproved of Hoskyns. 
 The Cambridge philosopher of religion on the board refused to vote for Ramsey for he did not think his work up to standard &mdash; the Cambridge philosophers never forgave the &bquo;irrationality&equo; which was a streak in his first and most original book. 
 But in the eyes of other electors Ramsey had merits. 
 There was nothing arid about him. 
 He never lost sight of the religious nature of his subject, and never turned it into a boring desert. 
 Here was a person who took a faculty in another university and turned it into the most famous faculty in the land. 
 He was also an English thinker whose name was respected on the continent of Europe. 
 Whether his books were or were not weighty, he thought for himself, and was no man's copy. 
 Although a free and critical mind, he reached reasonably conservative conclusions about the New Testament &mdash; which pleased the nonconformists and the bishop on the board. 
 And those who worked with him on ecumenical committees knew that this was nothing like so rigid an Anglo-Catholic  as sometimes he was portrayed; and remembered what he did for the Methodists and other non-Anglicans in Durham. 
 Moreover we have the proverb that no one is elected to anything except to keep two other people out &mdash; and some of Cambridge doubted whether Stephen Neill for all his brilliance was reliable, and thought that neo-Thomism, despite the quality of Mascall's mind, was a retrograde movement in divinity. 
 The Methodist leader Newton Flew proposed Ramsey. 
 He worked with Ramsey on several ecumenical committees and respected his mind. 
 The Presbyterian T. W. Manson, a leading scholar in the New Testament and capable of judging whether or not Ramsey had academic weight, seconded the proposal. 
 And Ramsey was elected the Cambridge regius professor by the votes of five men out of seven. 
 None of the five was on the teaching strength of the faculty at Cambridge, and three of the five came from other universities. 
 It says something for Ramsey's person and mind and reputation that one of the two most Anglo-Catholic professors in England could be elected on the proposal of two nonconformists. 
 If two Cambridge electors voted against, that must mean that the faculty divided about Ramsey. 
 A lot of people in Cambridge were disappointed at the choice. 
 But some of the younger dons were ecstatic about the election. 
 So were Magdalene College, and Ramsey's father, and Archbishop Fisher, and Edward Wynn who was now the Bishop of Ely. 
 Eric Abbott prophesied falsely, &bquo;It is to be the great work of your life&equo;. 
 And so it seemed. 
 &bquo;The iniquity of the Amorite&equo;, wrote Austin Farrer, &bquo;is at length full, and the progeny of Hoskyns is to return on the third decade to the Promised land.&equo; 
 THE CAMBRIDGE CHAIR 
 Joan and Michael Ramsey moved to a house in Newnham, not far from where he lodged when he was vicar of St Benet's eleven years before: 3 Wordsworth Grove. 
 The house was large for their needs and soon they did not like it. 
 Ramsey became a Fellow of his old college Magdalene. 
 There he was a formidable force. 
 The Fellows were accustomed to do mostly what the Master, Sir Henry Willink, Bart., wanted. 
 Ramsey the Liberal politician had ideas of democracy which cut across this benevolent dictatorship. 
 He had the more force because it was, so to speak, hereditary in  the college. 
 But he liked the Master and admired the vigour of his leadership. 
 The faculty of divinity needed him. 
 Marsh, the professor of Old Testament, had been a superlative teacher but his health was gone and he was now a passenger. 
 No one except Ramsey could teach the New Testament. 
 No one except Ramsey could teach what Christian doctrine was about. 
 At his first lecture in the Cambridge divinity school the large room was packed. 
 The caretaker was heard saying to the professor of Hebrew, &bquo;It's only curiosity Sir&equo;. 
 He found his work different from his work at Durham. 
 There were fewer lectures, many more private interviews with students, many more research students to see, a seminar for graduates and lecturers, far more leisure and therefore more time for study. 
 He gave two courses of lectures and the notes for both courses survived: one on the New Testament and one on the Christian idea of redemption. 
 &bquo;To the preparation of both courses of lectures I gave far more attention than I had latterly been giving at Durham.&equo; 
 He had a professor's room where he interviewed. 
 He was influential on the board of divinity. 
 It was a good time for building up the faculty. 
 The numbers of students grew, therefore the university could justify the money for new posts. 
 Within a very short time several of those who were disappointed at his election swung over to gratitude for his coming and enthusiasm for what he did to the faculty. 
 The swing from suspicion to welcome which he met at Durham he now met at Cambridge. 
 Ramsey missed his canonry; that is, he grieved that he no longer had a priestly connection with a church in the town. 
 He was in demand for preaching and conducting retreats. 
 He would appear at 6 a.m. in Addenbrooke's Hospital to celebrate the sacrament as its honorary assistant chaplain. 
 Bothered about Joan's health and the overspaciousness of the house, they searched and found a little terraced house almost opposite the Fitzwilliam Museum. 
 They sold the monumental furniture suitable for the acreage of Durham canonries and moved into Fitzwilliam Street. 
 They spent a whole day placing the furniture. 
 Then they sank back into armchairs, thanking the Lord that never again in their lives would they move house. 
 Never was gratitude more misplaced. 
 Ramsey bicycled over to Wordsworth Grove to see if there were any letters. 
 On the mat was a letter from Winston Churchill. 
 It offered him the see of Durham. 
 Ramsey had been a professor at Cambridge for exactly twenty months. 
 It is not usual for the advisers of the Crown to draw people out of important work when they have hardly had a chance to do what they have undertaken. 
 The offer had a history behind it.  
 Since the days of Queen Victoria the method of choosing bishops for the Church of England had changed, not wholly for the better. 
 Queen Victoria achieved a big improvement when she insisted that prime ministers should not choose whomsoever they liked without consulting the Archbishop of Canterbury; and in later stages she was able to insist that if the archbishop objected, the prime minister's nomination should not go forward. 
 Her son Edward VII, though he knew far less about clergymen than his mother, continued the same trenchancy. 
 If he found that the archbishop disliked a nomination, he coolly referred it back to Downing Street. 
 But with the coming of Lloyd George a Celtic nonconformist began to nominate. 
 King George V, who also knew not much about clergymen, had no desire to make trouble. 
 The system of consulting one or both archbishops continued. 
 But on occasion the prime minister disregarded what they said. 
 Lloyd George was not a person who knew little about clergymen. 
 He knew nothing. 
 Therefore he developed of necessity the system which Gladstone started under Queen Victoria, a little private team of secretaries or advisers. 
 This was desirable. 
 Prime ministers have various duties. 
 If they had to be responsible for choosing the leaders of the Church, they needed information and their secretaries should be able to talk to people who had the information. 
 Much depended upon the quality of the secretaries. 
 One of Lloyd George's advisers was a sensible and informed man. 
 The others were ignorant and prejudiced. 
 Lloyd George was driven from office. 
 The prime ministers between the World Wars, who were mostly Conservative, ran the system with sense and responsibility. 
 They consulted the archbishop or archbishops, took their advice, did not persist if the archbishop brought good reasons for a contrary opinion, and did not allow their &bquo;patronage secretary&equo; any &bquo;independent&equo; authority. 
 The system ran well for the sake of the Church. 
 Successive kings had no reason to grumble, cathedral chapters were happy to elect, and the Church of England was given good leaders &mdash; William Temple of York and George Bell of Chichester among them. 
 With the Second World War the system started to creak. 
 Churchill was a sort of Anglican but was as ignorant about clergymen as Lloyd George. 
 He was supposed to take the advice of Archbishop Lang of Canterbury but he distrusted everything Lang said because he thought him an appeaser of Hitler. 
 The relation between archbishop and prime minister became at times very uneasy. 
 Lang thought Churchill (from this point of view only) the worst prime minister who ever worked the system. 
 Some of Churchill's nominations in fact were very good, that of Temple to Canterbury being the best. 
 But it made the situation no  easier because Churchill distrusted Temple as a sort of Socialist and as too outspoken a politician. 
 One of his secretaries Colville tells us that Churchill's attitudes to clergymen had a touch of King Henry II's attitude to Thomas Becket. 
 After the war Attlee went back to the more responsible system. 
 But in October 1951, when Ramsey had professed at Cambridge for exactly a year, Churchill came back to power. 
 This was a Churchill decaying physically, slower in the uptake, less able to work long hours, less interested in the peacetime problems of the country, but still well enough to make his own decisions. 
 He had an archbishop, Fisher, with a good judgement of men and with a lot of information about them. 
 So the discussion, and the argument, began to develop not so much between prime minister and archbishop, as between archbishop and Churchill's patronage secretary Anthony Bevir. 
 For the first time a civil servant, perforce, began to affect what happened. 
 The see of Durham was the fourth senior see in the Church. 
 Its occupant had an instant seat in the House of Lords. 
 When it fell vacant, one bit of history conditioned the argument. 
 For the last seventy-three years the Bishop of Durham was a scholar; five bishops in succession ranging from one who was among the leading minds of Europe to one who was more a publicist than a scholar but who still had academic interests. 
 During the recent years after the war the university rose in national importance and always had a close connection with the bishop. 
 Archbishop Fisher and Archbishop Garbett of York started to look around for scholarly clergymen and hovered over various names, ail of whom taught then or had taught in universities. 
 On 8 April 1952 the patronage secretary went to see the Archbishop of York. 
 Bevir's habit was to roam with a cloud of verbiage and then pop out of his hole with a startling suggestion, almost as quickly popping back. 
 He talked of the excellence of Mortimer at Exeter, formerly a professor at Oxford. 
 Then he started to talk about Ramsey and said &bquo;probably the best man for Durham&equo;. 
 It did not seem to occur to him that Ramsey had been only eighteen months in an important job for which he was perfectly fitted. 
 Thus came a conflict of views. 
 The two archbishops thought that Ramsey would be an excellent bishop but it was not right, it was bad for the Church as well as for the study of divinity, to take him out of the Cambridge chair after so short a tenure. 
 (Notice the change which the Durham professorship, and Joan's coming, wrought &mdash; in 1940 no one could conceive of this absent-minded man as a bishop, and six or seven years later the electors to the see of Edinburgh mulled over his name and decided that it would not do, and five years after that both archbishops  and the prime minister's office were agreed that he would be a very good bishop.) 
 The prime minister hardly minded much, as yet, what was going on. 
 His civil servant thought that Ramsey should be invited. 
 And against the archbishops Bevir had this on his side. 
 He had talked to the Durham people. 
 He stayed at the deanery and talked far into the night about the needs of Durham and its diocese. 
 The outgoing Bishop Williams wanted Ramsey to succeed him. 
 Everyone in Durham to whom Bevir talked wanted Ramsey to come back. 
 The dean and chapter wanted him. 
 Behind the scenes they may have affected the prime minister directly. 
 For Canon Lucas, sub-dean and father of the boys with the model railway, decided while Ramsey was the professor at Durham that this was a possible Archbishop of Canterbury. 
 This was contrary to the opinion of the world and society which thought of him as a boffin. 
 Lucas knew Lord Halifax from his university days and now wrote to tell him that Ramsey was the man whom the diocese wanted as its bishop, and hoped that Halifax would do what he could with Winston Churchill. 
 Also, Bevir had another argument. 
 Possibly, he said, this was a future archbishop. 
 If so, it was good to give him experience as a bishop as soon as possible. 
 And Bevir was in the strong position, that neither archbishop wished to deny that Ramsey would make a good bishop. 
 If Churchill recommended Ramsey to the new young Queen who had never before been confronted with the situation, and the Queen asked the archbishops whether they objected, they could not say that they did. 
 This was a new development in the system of choosing bishops. 
 The prime minister's secretary went down to the diocese to consult the leading churchmen. 
 That meant, the secretary exposed his part in the proceedings. 
 Instead of a faceless figure behind the scenes, he was obviously a person who counted. 
 Yet he had no constitutional place in advising the Queen on the choice of bishops. 
 That made the system look more Erastian than it ever looked before. 
 Here was a civil servant exercising obvious power in the choice of a Church leader. 
 On the other hand it had a large compensation. 
 Always in English history bishops were chosen for national reasons and the diocese took second place. 
 But now for the first time the diocese was being consulted &mdash; informally, quietly, but systematically. 
 Under the old system, where bishops were chosen by archbishops and prime ministers who thought about the needs of the nation, Ramsey would not have been chosen. 
 He became a bishop because, and solely because, the diocese knew him well and wanted him back. 
 That was no small gain to set in the balance against the more obvious Erastianism of the new system. 
 There is a little evidence that the final choice lay between George  Chase, the Bishop of Ripon, mature in years and experience, a scholar, solid, stable, absolutely reliable, shy, and at times remote, and Michael Ramsey, without experience, untried, but one of the leaders of a party in the Church and someone who would do more to represent learning among the bench of bishops. 
 Churchill, confronted by a choice between a totally safe appointment and an exciting gamble, would have no doubts. 
 The new Queen approved inform ally. 
 On 30 May 1952 a letter went from Churchill to Ramsey offering him the see of Durham. 
 The house in Fitzwilliam Street at Cambridge was in a state of shock. 
 Someone who &mdash; has accepted a leading chair at one of the universities expects to do a job and does not lightly change after less than two years. 
 And this was more than just a professorship. 
 It was work towards which all Ramsey's training and expectations led as the right contribution which he could make to the life of his Church and to that of Christendom. 
 He knew that his gifts were those of a scholar rather than an administrator. 
 He knew that he was not going to be happy if he were deprived of the chance to study. 
 That the letter came from Winston Churchill was a point against it. 
 The Repton boy's horror at Churchill's anti-Bolshevist campaign had turned into a more adult and less ferocious criticism. 
 The Liberal Ramsey thought that Churchill was totally wrong to put Britain back on the gold standard; that he was illiberal over miners in the General Strike; that he was very mistaken in resisting the advance of India to independence. 
 He admitted the great debt which the country owed to Churchill for the Second World War. 
 But he would have preferred Lord Halifax to Churchill as prime minister in 1940 and even in retrospect believed that the country would have fought the war better under Halifax and that the admirals and the generals would have had a less neurotic time. 
 To receive the offer from Churchill did not raise it in Ramsey's estimation. 
 And something about the tone of Churchill's letter displeased Ramsey. 
 He thought it pompous. 
 But the actual letter survives and only a mind predisposed to suspect the sender could think it pompous: &bquo;After the most careful consideration I have decided, if you are willing that I should do so, to recommend your name for the succession to the see of Durham.&equo; 
 Did Ramsey suspect that Churchill's &bquo;very careful&equo; consideration was more by proxy than in person? 
 Or dislike the ego of &bquo;I have decided&equo;? 
 Anyway he did not like the tone. 
 That was an excess of suspicion, for the letter was drafted by David Hunt, vice  Bevir who was ill, and Hunt made it conform to precedents. 
 And Churchill was not yet senile. 
 He cross-examined Hunt and knew perfectly well what he was doing.  
 Still, Michael Ramsey, being Ramsey, had to think that this might be the will of God for him. 
 Durham stood for an idyll of ten years. 
 He knew the people, and the work, and a lot of the clergy. 
 He also knew that his wife, after being secretary to a bishop and then secretary to the professor of divinity, and his hostess for eight years, was better equipped to be the wife of the new Bishop of Durham than any other woman in the country. 
 Durham was the place where he had found happiness. 
 But he had a fixed idea in his mind that to be a bishop was not his work. 
 Eric Abbott, his best man, had once begged him not to become a bishop in England. 
 He told him that a mitre could be a candle-snuffer. 
 Ramsey had read the life of Archbishop Randall Davidson by George Bell and found it very depressing &mdash; a noble and unspoilt man inside a sickening system &mdash; &bquo;the wire-pulling, the hedging, and energy spent on things that don't matter, and all the sitting on the fence&equo;. 
 But he had also read the life of Bishop Charles Gore and found it inspiring, so it was not always sickening to work as a bishop. 
 His first need was to find out whether Cambridge University would regard his leaving as betrayal. 
 He went first to the then elder statesman of the faculty of divinity, William Telfer the Master of Selwyn, whom Ramsey respected. 
 Then he went to the Master of Corpus Christi, Sir Will Spens, who was a lay Anglo-Catholic. 
 Then he went to the head of his own college, Sir Henry Willink. 
 To his surprise and discontent the first two thought that he ought to go. 
 Willink thought that perhaps he should not go; but he also discontented Ramsey by treating it as a problem in how Ramsey should get the best career in a worldly sense. 
 Nevertheless, it was clear that the wisest Cambridge leaders whom he could consult would not regard his going as betrayal if he felt it right. 
 On the eve of Whitsunday Joan drove him over to Ely to see the bishop, his first confessor Edward Wynn. 
 Wynn was not a man prepared to decide anyone else's future for them. 
 On the Tuesday Ramsey called on his former best man Eric Abbott in London, who had urged him never to be a bishop in England. 
 Abbott thought at first that Cambridge was bound to win. 
 But before the end of the conversation he realized how vocation pulled Ramsey towards Durham, and talked about &bquo;a theological bishop&equo; and did not discourage. 
 From Eric Abbott he went on to Canterbury to talk to the archbishop, Geoffrey Fisher. 
 The meeting with Fisher, in the Old Palace at Canterbury, was felt by Michael Ramsey to be odd. 
 Fisher, as was his way, was honest. 
 He did not pretend that he wanted Ramsey to go to Durham. 
 As clearly as anyone he saw what was  owing to the university of Cambridge. 
 He said that the diocese of Durham wanted him and that the Archbishop of York was now persuaded that they were right. 
 He said that he had an open mind. 
 He said no word to persuade Ramsey to accept the see. 
 And then he gave what Ramsey thought a startling answer to a question which to Ramsey was a crux. 
 Ramsey asked how valuable it was to have scholarly men as bishops. 
 Fisher replied that it did not matter much. 
 But, he added, sometimes commissions were needed and then it was valuable to have a scholar-bishop as the chairman. 
 Ramsey had formed the view that a bishop is an apostolic teacher. 
 His vocation is to guard the faith, to present it, expound it. 
 He did not think that the then bench in the Church were all well qualified to this end. 
 He had told a friend not long before, &bquo;If you walked from Humber to Severn and dodged Derby, you would not find a bishop who can read or write&equo;. 
 That Archbishop Fisher treated all this as unimportant perturbed him. 
 If the official view in the Church cared nothing about the bishop in his function as apostolic teacher, anyone who was trained to teach had a duty to join the bishop's bench if he were asked. 
 The interview with Fisher strengthened Ramsey's feeling that he had a duty to go. 
 The settling blow was delivered by Archbishop Garbett, whom on the Friday Ramsey went to see at York. 
 Garbett had a retreat for ordinands and smuggled Ramsey into the house lest one of the young men guess that something was up. 
 He said that the Durham diocese wanted Ramsey. 
 He said that theology among bishops was important. 
 He said that it needed strengthening in the northern province. 
 He was sure that a bishop was not stopped by his bishoping from going on with some scholarly work. 
 Thus a Dean of Durham, and an ex-Bishop of Durham, and a complicated patronage secretary who popped out of holes like a rabbit, and a doctrine of apostolic authority, and an Archbishop of York, and a desire to follow the calling of God even if it looked unlikely, winkled a professor out of a career to which he seemed to have been born. 
 In old age Ramsey looked back and knew that this was the hardest decision of his life. 
 On 17 June 1952 a Fellow of Magdalene College walked down Trinity Street in Cambridge and was suddenly aware of the regius professor of divinity waddling ahead of him and throwing his arms about and muttering gloomily to himself, &bquo;Hell! 
 Hell!&equo; 
 &equo; Why, what's the matter?&equo; 
 &equo; The Lord works in mysterious ways! 
 I am to be Bishop of Durham.&equo; 
 Despite the advice of William Telfer that he ought to go, Cambridge  was not pleased with Ramsey. 
 Some of the younger members of the faculty of divinity were angry. 
 The church historian Norman Sykes thought it a bad choice for the see, too party a man for a see which needed breadth of mind. 
 Cambridge, which always assumes that anyone who leaves it passes into outer darkness, found the decision incomprehensible. 
 They decided that it could only be because Joan's health was so poor in the fens that the professor was forced to move. 
 This story Ramsey had flatly to deny. 
 Durham was very pleased. 
 Kingsley Barrett, the Methodist, whom Ramsey had chosen for the faculty at Durham, wrote of his belief that a special providence must watch over the Church of England to give them at least some good bishops in spite of the deplorable method of their appointment. 
 On 8 August 1952 he and Joan gave a farewell party to Cambridge friends. 
 On the doorstep his final words to the last guest to leave were, &bquo;You must vote for me when next I apply for a Cambridge professorship&equo;. 
 Occasionally, when he came back to Cambridge in later years, and especially when he came back to help the university elect another professor of divinity, he would be nostalgic, and say, &bquo;I should like to have another go at being regius professor,. 
 They went on holiday to a farmhouse at Ponsworthy in Devon and thither came a vast parcel, from the Clerical and General Tailors (Breeches Makers etc.), of Sackville Street, Piccadilly, bill &pound;376; chimeres, wristbands, rochets, frills, breeches, gaiters, purple dress coat, black barathea breeches, patent court shoes, silver-plated shoe buckles, and other less rare articles of apparel. 
 In the farmhouse he practised putting on the gaiters and found it a struggle. 
 Much of the rest of the holiday he spent writing articles or reviews for publication. 
 He also read carefully the famous book of Pope Gregory the Great, from the sixth century, on the pastoral office in the Church. 
 He practised a new signature, Michael Dunelm. 
 On 24 September he went into retreat at Mirfield in Yorkshire, where once he thought of becoming a monk. 
 The retreat was a time for fear at first, and self-scrutiny. 
 It passed &bquo;into great peace with the help of Father Horner an old and saintly monk who gave me absolution and good counsel&equo;. 
 He must do his homage to the Queen &mdash; her first bishop to do homage. 
 The civil servants in Downing Street played it humorously. 
 They warned the Queen's private secretary Sir Alan Lascelles that the Queen was about to meet an eccentric. 
 David Hunt from Downing Street told Lascelles that Ramsey had been known to stop in a procession, send for a pair of trousers to replace the wrong ones which he had put on by mistake, and change them in the middle of the aisle. 
 The Queen, he  said, should not be put off by any oddity of manner but could be assured that this was a man of great learning, deep human sympathy, and outstanding pastoral gifts. 
 (There was no truth in this legend but such legends gathered about the young Michael Ramsey and certainly he was odd in processions.) 
 Lascelles reported next day to David Hunt. 
 He said that the Queen eagerly waited for the bishop to show some of his eccentricities but, &bquo;fortunately or unfortunately&equo; he had acted with the utmost decorum. 
 On 29 September 1952 Ramsey was consecrated bishop by Archbishop Garbett in York minster and enthroned in Durham cathedral on St Luke's Day, 18 October. 
 The Marquess of Londonderry arrived with his traditional gift to a new bishop of two pheasants and a pound of butter. 
 The Master of Magdalene asked him whether he found it uncomfortable to wear the received garments of a bishop. 
 Ramsey replied, &bquo;They are like false teeth. 
 At first they irritate a bit but when you are used to them you find them serviceable.&equo; 
 The Bishop 
 DUNELM: 
 Both the Ramseys loved living in Auckland Castle, a historic pile eminent in the history of England and of the Church, with magnificent memorials of celebrated prelates of past centuries. 
 &bquo;I have never lived in a place where the past was so alive, and my great predecessors seemed like daily companions.&equo; 
 At first they found it very cold, especially as they moved in just before Christmas. 
 To live in such a castle meant demands on the purse. 
 It was the time of their lives when they found it hardest to make ends meet. 
 It could not have happened unless the Church had helped to pay for the heating. 
 They inherited also a historic butler, of quaint majesty, Ernest Alexander, who governed the castle since near the beginning of the century. 
 When they arrived at Auckland Alexander asked them for the silver and his Presence was such that they did not dare to tell him that they had no silver, so Joan said that it was &bquo;in the bank&equo;. 
 Ramsey loved the many-acred park with its structure to shelter deer, though there were no deer, and its grazing cattle and its river-banks. 
 Since the twelfth century the Bishop of Durham had a manor, and lived here except during the Commonwealth when bishops were in exile and this was the seat of the general who governed the North. 
 In spare half-hours he would wander in the market-place and streets and shops of Bishop Auckland and talk with the people. 
 He liked to sit on a bench in the square and talk with, or rather be talked to by, the old retired miners. 
 In 1954 he completed the restoration of the chapel, which was ravaged by death-watch beetle. 
 It had once been the great hall of the castle, and is among the fairest buildings of the twelfth century which Britain possesses. 
 Under King Charles II Bishop Cosin turned the hall into a chapel after the dilapidations of the Commonwealth general, and gave the medieval windows a clerestory. 
 Bishop Cosin's original colours of the roof, from the seventeenth century, were discovered during the  restoration and Ramsey had them brightly restored. 
 A panelled room, which was Bishop Cosin's study, Ramsey turned into a small oratory for weekday sacraments or prayers. 
 He liked to show parties of visitors round the house and to talk to them of Oswald, or Hild, or Cosin, or Lightfoot. 
 The finance for the restoration of the chapel was a gamble. 
 He asked the Church Commissioners to do it but would not wait to see whether they consented. 
 When the head of the Commissioners, Sir Malcolm Trustram Eve, who was no man to be trifled with, arrived a few days after the Commissioners approved the expenditure, the butler Alexander showed him the restoration already complete. 
 &bquo;Never&equo;, said Trustram Eve, &bquo;have I known craftsmen to be so expeditious.&equo; 
 Ramsey felt the same ecstasy, of history speaking out of sanctified stones, in Durham itself. 
 He found that in such a place present was near to past and visible near to the invisible world. 
 He was often aware of the which defended the realm of England against the Scottish raiders and then back to the Celtic saints coming out of Scotland into Northumbria. 
 He found that he enjoyed going to a parish to confirm the children, or to institute a new incumbent, and stay afterwards for the sausage rolls or sandwiches at the bunfight and chat up the people with a mixture of silence and belly-bumping laughter and beams all round and leg-pulling but with care and affection. 
 Sometimes he felt desperately shy and this specially seemed to happen when titled laymen or captains of industry appeared. 
 But mostly he did not need to talk at a bunfight, people came up and talked to him, and he would nod his head and smile benevolently and say happily, Yes, Yes, Yes. 
 In February and March it was hard going out almost nightly but he liked it and Joan got to know the wives and children of the clergy. 
 One Sunday in four he refused to go out and stayed at home to read and write. 
 He was willing to go to confirm in an emergency at very short notice and this earned him some long-lasting gratitude. 
 On a parish visit the pastor would sometimes take him to the bedside of a dying man or woman and Ramsey would sit long by the bed, saying almost nothing, but holding hands and at the end giving a blessing. 
 At his first diocesan conference he told them his idea of a bishop's job. 
 He finds today unbelief, or apathy, and sometimes a collapse of the sense of right and wrong. 
 He needs to try to see the subtler reasons for this mood. 
 He needs not to forget that there are demonic forces in the universe whatever people say about the existence of the devil. 
 He needs to be aware of the social reasons pulling at ordinary people, the conditions of work in an industrial society, the nature of a people's amusements. 
 He needs continually to be at work dealing with the  shifting population of a modern age, so that people who move house to a new estate shall still find a priest and a sacrament for their souls. 
 He needs to think of how we are to find the right ministers, men and women &mdash; to let people know that there is a vocation called holy orders, of &bquo;unique difficulty and unique happiness&equo;; the variety of ministers, deaconesses, teachers in schools, lay preachers, monks and nuns and friars who belong to &bquo;the praying heart of the Church&equo;, without which its mission would not have the power of God within it. 
 He needs therefore to think about stipends and houses and church buildings. 
 He recognized that many of the weapons were not in the power of the parish system &mdash; broadcasting, or literature, or education, or public life. 
 But the parishes, and the parish missions, were central to the care of souls; and their ministers ought always to be refreshing themselves in the truths of the Christian faith, so that they do not slip &bquo;into versions of it which miss its height and depth and wonder&equo;; and those ministers ought always to make room in their lives for silence and the chance of realizing their nearness to eternity. 
 A special happiness was the care of those who wished to be ordained. 
 He talked with them in his study or took them for walks in the park. 
 He would talk not only of their vocation to the ministry but of the books which they were reading and the circumstances of their family. 
 He usually knew their tutors and made jokes about them. 
 He found the ordinations, three times a year, to be his happiest moments. 
 With his lay people he had good fortune. 
 On 2 June 1953 the Queen was crowned in Westminster abbey. 
 By long history the Bishop of Durham had the privilege of standing at the right hand of the sovereign throughout the coronation as her chief supporter. 
 Since this was the first coronation to be televised to a nation, Ramsey was suddenly famous among the people of England; all the more so because the vast head, baldness girt by flowing white locks, mobile expressive eyebrows, and waddling gait drew the attention of millions of viewers. 
 Some people thought that with the mitre on his white hair he looked like one of the effigies on the tombs of the prelates which they met recumbent in cathedrals, and fancied that here was a bishop out of the Middle Ages. 
 The lay people of Durham were proud to have their bishop at the right hand of the Queen. 
 This cemented their acceptance of Ramsey. 
 He was a magnificent figure in ritual clothes. 
 On his massive head a mitre did not appear comic, and in gaiters and apron he looked every inch a bishop, with nothing fancy-dress about him. 
 As with William Temple, who looked equally natural in gaiters and apron, the bubbling humour and lack of pomposity heightened the effect of the personality. 
 Ramsey thought it a protection against wrongful ceremony to understand its  principles. 
 He said, &bquo;People who don't understand liturgical acts generally get pompous when they dress up.&equo; 
 He worked mostly with secretary and chaplain. 
 He did not hold staff meetings, and hardly consulted those who expected to be consulted, like the suffragan bishop or the archdeacons. 
 He was reported to have said, &bquo;I did not really know what an archdeacon does.&equo; 
 Afterwards he asked himself whether he did all that he should have done about the miners and the working men. 
 He diagnosed that his concentration on getting to know the clergy and the church people prevented him from moving among the wider community as he should. 
 He admired what the early Methodists did for the miners and how the earliest of the miners' unions was Methodist in its inspiration. 
 He knew what the Victorian churchmen of the north had done for the miners and how by the third quarter of the nineteenth century the Church was strong within the mining communities though it never took the place of the Methodists. 
 No Bishop of Durham could ever forget, or was ever allowed to forget, how one of his predecessors Westcott mediated in a bitter strike; how a vast crowd stood outside Auckland Castle, seeing the owners through the windows of one room and the miners through the windows of another, waiting for five hours as they watched the bishop go to and fro between the two rooms; until he brought the parties to a happy agreement, and when he came out among the crowd he received an ovation. 
 Ramsey knew of the bitterness engendered by the coal royalties paid to the Church, and how the miners once tried to throw a bishop into the River Wear. 
 He believed that the nationalization of coal was a blessing both for Durham and for the Church in Durham. 
 He became a friend of Jack Lawson (Lord Lawson) who was a faithful Methodist, and Sam Watson the Durham miners' leader, whom he came to know intimately. 
 He always attended the Durham miners, gala, which was the festivity and political demonstration of the mining community, and in 1955 preached them the gala sermon by invitation of the miners. 
 There they made him sing them a song and were enchanted by the noises which came out. 
 He thought that there was no barrier and that in time he could have done more for them. 
 Under the English system of parishes every diocese had variety; that is each parish had the Prayer Book but used it as it thought, with simple or elaborate ceremonial, and with variations of language sanctioned by the (illegal) Prayer Book of 1928 if it wished. 
 The person who decided this was almost always the vicar; though of recent years he could not make elaborate changes without the support of a majority in his church council. 
 Thus the possibility of a quarrel in the parish was still there. 
 A  parish used to simple ways of ceremony might be confronted with a new vicar who suddenly elaborated the ritual; or the opposite. 
 These quarrels were rare. 
 But when they came they were distressing and they particularly distressed the bishop responsible for healing; because Christians are not supposed to quarrel, and quarrelling about clothes or tinklings or perfume looked like fanaticism or obsession with triviality. 
 But it was more than these to those in the quarrel. 
 Were we making a Protestant Church to resemble the Church of Rome? 
 Or were we trying to make meagre the devotions of minds which were helped to pray by colour and symbol? 
 To mediate in such a dispute was the dreariest occupation of a bishop. 
 Ramsey inherited a battle like this from his predecessor. 
 The most Anglo-Catholic parish in the diocese was in South Shields, St Mary's Tyne Dock. 
 This had a record of superb parish priests and a full congregation. 
 While Ramsey was a canon the chapter appointed a new vicar; and while Ramsey's predecessor was bishop, a minority of the parishioners started to protest against the vicar's innovations and were in a strong position because the vicar introduced certain ornaments without the necessary faculty to do so. 
 When the vicar got a new bishop who was Anglo-Catholic he appealed to him for his sanction, in the hope that the bishop's approval would make up for the lack of faculty. 
 Ramsey's first holiday in Devonshire as a bishop was made unhappy by the news of the quarrel in the parish. 
 He thought little or nothing about law, or jurisdiction, or faculty. 
 What mattered were, first, to maintain the tradition of worship in the parish, and second, reconciliation. 
 He cheerfully gave his sanction to most of what the vicar did, the use of incense, the reservation of the sacrament, the wearing of vestments, the ringing of sanctuary bells, the veneration of the cross on Good Friday, the blessing of the palms on Palm Sunday, the blessing of a Paschal candle, and the pictures of the Stations of the Cross on the walls. 
 He only asked the vicar not to use Hail Marys with the Stations. 
 He went into the whole ritual and found nothing open to the charge that it encouraged superstition. 
 Meanwhile he separately interviewed the vicar, and churchwardens, and opposing groups of parishioners, and tried to get conciliation, and persuaded the lawyers to postpone the court while he tried conciliation; all to no purpose. 
 In the judgement (Jerusalem Chamber I February 1954) the Chancellor mostly backed bishop and vicar; but ordered out the statue and the sanctuary bells and the tabernacle on the altar, saying that what was illegal could not be made legal by the bishop's permission. 
 That did not settle the matter, which ran on for eight years more, long after Ramsey left the diocese of Durham. 
 The case brought the diocese, and  the parish, and its bishop, a little unwelcome publicity; but not much; for the world was tired of ritual quarrels, whereas sixty years before there would have come questions in Parliament. 
 On the whole Ramsey was no friend to dramatic public occasions. 
 But he revelled in the Northumbrian past, of Aidan and Cuthbert and the Venerable Bede. 
 On 19 July 1955 he walked barefoot across the sands of Northumbria to Holy Island, at the head of 3,000 people. 
 On the grass in the ruins of the historic priory, surrounded by parochial banners, Ramsey told the crowd that though they were outside the modern diocese of Durham, this was their true home. 
 He conjured before their minds a poetic word-picture of St Aidan coming from Iona in Scotland and settling there with his band of monks to pray and to spread Christianity among the heathen English; and spoke of St Cuthbert to whom on that spot the people went to seek help and comfort and guidance, until he fled across the sands and sea to be alone with God on his island &mdash; so carry the lesson back, to a county black with people and with coal, carry back the need for quiet, and separation from whirl, and silence; and so heaven will be nearer. 
 His predecessor but one, Hensley Henson, invented the magazine the Bishoprick  and by the force of his writing made it a national and not only a diocesan journal. 
 Since the heady days of Henson it had become a duller and more local object. 
 Ramsey did not see why it should not have a wider interest as in Henson's day. 
 He started not only to print his addresses or charges but to review books of general interest; to consider a book on diplomacy and war, and not to lose a chance of holding up the character of Asquith to admiration, or to contrast the laziness and drift of Stanley Baldwin as prime minister with the crusading fervour of a Gladstone. 
 Some of the articles were hard for the layman to follow and quite hard for some clergymen to follow. 
 He tried to educate them about the nature of demythologizing , a word of which the press had got hold, and to guide them about the best modern writing on the New Testament. 
 He found that he could pay a compliment to Charles Raven, from whom he was so sadly sundered in spirit, for his book on Religion and Science. 
 The irksomeness lay in London. 
 He attended the House of Lords but did not speak. 
 He disliked the Church Assembly (which was the forerunner of the General Synod) and made only one speech there while he was Bishop of Durham, against the idea of recruiting  people to come and be priests. 
 He enjoyed the friendly little Convocation at York. 
 But what irked him most were bishops' meetings. 
 Towards the ecumenical movement, as a system of vast Christian jamborees like the meeting at Amsterdam, his suspicions deepened. 
 He  attended a meeting at Lund in Sweden in 1952 and thought the atmosphere happy but the meeting useless and wondered whether the day of such occasions was not past. 
 But the assembly which shocked him was the next, at Evanston in the United States in 1954. 
 He hated what he saw at Evanston. 
 It was too large. 
 They sat in a place vast enough to &bquo;house a fleet of Zeppelins&equo;. 
 &bquo;I have rarely known such stultifying of the personal touch between speaker and audience.&equo; 
 The American media moved in. 
 He hated the vulgarity of showing off the delegates as though they were exhibits, and the insincerity of pretending that platitudes were pronouncements of world-shaking import, and the feeling that he came a long way to greet fellow-Christians and found himself turned into a ham-actor on a second-rate stage. 
 A whirl of oratory for a fortnight. 
 He liked to take ideas gently, to get time to meditate on the best modes of expressing truth. 
 &bquo;How futile to announce that some great lead to thought was going to emerge from the mountain of memoranda discussed at high pressure by exhausted delegates.&equo; 
 And he was opposed to the idea of Christian unity which dominated most of the Protestant delegates from the United States &mdash; to create a world federation of different Protestant denominations. 
 His frustration and boredom were at their worst in the debates on the main theme of the Conference, Christian Hope. 
 A committee led by Karl Barth proposed a message for the Churches to adopt. 
 But the committee was hopelessly divided on what it meant by Christian hope &mdash; whether it was hope for peace and perfection in this world, or hope for a future life, or hope only of forgiveness at the last. 
 The document finally &bquo;agreed&equo; by the disagreed committee was stuffed with jargon and so incomprehensible that it was useless as an agenda for discussion; yet the meeting at Evanston had to discuss it; with results which may be imagined. 
 Ramsey made a speech which disconcerted the managers of the conference, who thought it a bad example of English insularity. 
 The speech led to a quarrel, soon patched up, with the general secretary Visser t'Hooft. 
 The meeting at Evanston clinched the sense of scepticism which Ramsey felt, not about the ecumenical movement, but about its inflated claims and its mode of organization. 
 That scepticism and memory were to be important when he became an archbishop and was expected to be a leader in the organization. 
 Still, at Evanston, he allowed the personal meeting to count &mdash; with Hungarian Christians oppressed in a satellite state, with a black South African who merely by being there seemed to make the Afrikaaner defence of apartheid incompatible with Christianity. 
 He realized, as he  never realized before, how Asian and African Christianity took the lead in the world-wide Church. 
 Always thereafter Ramsey's attitude was consistent. 
 He cared about Christian unity, no one more. 
 That unity must look towards Catholics as well as Protestants. 
 The way to find it was not by diplomacy and negotiation (though these had their part), still less by razzmatazz and public relations, but by trying to get nearer to God. 
 All meetings were boring to him unless the participants could talk in depth and unless the debate was by a small enough number of people for personal friendships to be fostered. 
 His principles were very strong, that the Church of England is a Catholic Church and must never compromise its Catholic principles. 
 In those days he contemplated the idea that if the Church abandoned that inheritance he would have to resign his see. 
 In his family he found an unlooked-for happiness. 
 During his twenties his father and he were sundered by religion. 
 His father did not mind his son becoming an Anglican priest but wished that he were not so Anglo-Catholic and not so high-principled about bishops. 
 Still, he was proud that his son should be a professor of divinity at two universities, and proud when his son became a bishop. 
 He did not wish to desert his Congregational cause or his Church. 
 But at the age of 86, immured by infirmity in his house, he wanted to receive the sacrament from his son. 
 With the consent of the Bishop of Ely, who was Edward Wynn, the Bishop of Durham came to Howfield and confirmed his father and ministered the sacrament to him. 
 The son said that this brought his father deep happiness. 
 &bquo;It is unusual&equo;, he wrote, &bquo;for a bishop to confirm his own father &mdash; but it is as a great Nonconformist that I revere him.&equo; 
 Ramsey was already a leader, not just in the diocese of Durham, but in the Church. 
 He had a big personality. 
 What he said counted. 
 Archbishop Fisher went so far as to tell him that he was a possible future Archbishop of Canterbury. 
 The Catholic minds in the Church rejoiced to have one of such influence, and such prayerfulness, high in the counsels of their Church. 
 During the autumn of 1955 Bishop Wand of London retired and the health of Archbishop Garbett of York failed. 
 The two leading sees after Canterbury needed new occupants simultaneously. 
 Anyone who looked round the Church of England saw Ramsey as possible for one of them. 
 But he had been Bishop of Durham for less than three years, and was in a see which fitted his gifts perfectly. 
 It was a long and anxious debate about Ramsey without him knowing; between the Archbishop of Canterbury, the prime minister Eden,  the prime minister's patronage secretary Bevir, Garbett the outgoing Archbishop of York, and Wand the outgoing Bishop of London. 
 Who was the biggest person in sight? 
 Without question &mdash; George Bell, the Bishop of Chichester. 
 Lover of Christian unity, friend of the European leaders, ally of the Germans who stood against Hitler, courageous critic of area bombing, patron of art and theatre, compassionate over refugees, he was the only bishop in England that the world had known about since William Temple died. 
 But he was 72 and would be 73 by the time he had to move if he moved. 
 Is it sensible to move a man to new work at the age of 73? 
 What is the point of moving a person who is famous through the world as Chichester to the anonymity of being Archbishop of York? 
 There is a point in moving him to London because that is near the Houses of Parliament where he has weight. 
 But the see of London is work for the physically strong, not for declining energy. 
 Who else has stature? 
 Ramsey of Durham. 
 He is much younger. 
 He could manage the see of London. 
 But he is a new bishop. 
 And he values scholarship. 
 Are we to kill his scholarship and make him unhappy? 
 His wife has uncertain health, could she manage life in London? 
 Two sees, York and London &mdash; Bell or Ramsey? 
 If Bell is ruled out as too old and Ramsey as too new, who else has stature? 
 George Chase of Ripon, good as gold and wise as Solomon, but even shyer than Ramsey and without his intellectual bite? 
 Two other circumstances entered this prolonged argument. 
 These were hardly mentioned but underneath were not trivial. 
 First, the York diocese had no desire for George Bell and every desire for Ramsey. 
 Its dean was his former teacher and friend, Eric Milner-White. 
 Dean and chapter did everything in their power to get Ramsey. 
 And in this new structure, where the prime minister's secretary popped out of holes and asked them what they thought, they had a better chance than any previous dean and chapter. 
 The leading layman of the York diocese was the politician whose judgement was likely to weigh with the Crown: Lord Halifax, the former Foreign Secretary, and a devout Anglo-Catholic. 
 Halifax helped over prising Ramsey out of Cambridge. 
 He was now likely to want the prominent Anglo-Catholic bishop. 
 And Garbett wanted Ramsey to succeed him at York. 
 The authorities of the York archdiocese were unanimous. 
 The second almost silent circumstance was Bell's reputation. 
 He was revered in the Church of England. 
 In Germany he was a hero. 
 But he was resented by long memories in those who had fought a war; by Churchill's men for weakening the morale of the Air Force through his attacks on area bombing; by the school of Lord Vansittart which  loathed Germans and said that Nazis were typical of that race, and hated a bishop who told them never to identify the true Germany with Hitler. 
 The prime minister Eden was Churchill's man; a fight-to-the-limit man; an unconditional-surrender man. 
 Suppose that Archbishop Fisher thought Bell the best person despite his age for one of these sees, could he get Bell's name past the prime minister? 
 Or would Eden think of the air marshals, and the children who had lost their parents in a blitz, and former warriors who had seen too much blood on a battlefield, and exercise a silent veto, by going for the second preference? 
 Archbishop Fisher was aware of these circumstances. 
 He had the merit of going always straight to the point &mdash; what is best for Christianity in England? and besides that the scruples of air marshals, or the wishes of the Dean of York, or the comfort of Bell, or the scholarship of Ramsey, are nothing. 
 If York or London needed Bell or Ramsey they had a moral duty to move whether or not they wanted it. 
 He did not think Ramsey's scholarship a weighty part of his quality as a bishop; occasionally he hinted that he thought the books were a distraction from pastoral care. 
 And he had another point for moving Ramsey. 
 He saw him now as a possible Archbishop of Canterbury. 
 If we ask, how do we best train the next Archbishop of Canterbury, which see is better? 
 Obviously (in Fisher's eyes), London. 
 So on 29 October 1955 Fisher recommended to the prime minister that Bell be asked to move to York because he was the biggest person in sight and &mdash; despite his age &mdash; &bquo;he might tide over for five or six years&equo;; and that Ramsey be invited to go to London, because that huge see would &bquo;respond to his commanding ability&equo;. 
 But he made the recommendation with a proviso. 
 He, Fisher, should be allowed to ask Ramsey privately whether his wife's health would stand up to life in London. 
 The first Ramsey knew about these discussions between Fisher and the prime minister was when a letter arrived in Durham on 8 December 1955. 
 The letter asked whether Joan's health would prevent Ramsey accepting the see of London if it were offered to him. 
 This letter horrified both the Ramseys. 
 The aim of his life was to remain a scholar and a teacher while he was a bishop. 
 This was of the first importance to him. 
 He felt it a necessary part of his vocation. 
 The London diocese was vast, difficult, rent with controversy, dotted with rebel or eccentric clergymen comic and uncomic, and needing a dedicated administrator whose time would be loaded. 
 It would be a candle-snuffer. 
 He did not want the job at all. 
 He decided only to answer the question which he was asked. 
 He talked to Joan. 
 He consulted Joan's doctor. 
 He wrote to Fisher that while she might never be strong, her health did not depend upon  locality. 
 Therefore &bquo;no personal circumstances would preclude my giving thought to coming to London&equo;. 
 He signed himself, not without a touch of misery perhaps, &bquo;ever sincerely and dutifully&equo;. 
 Fisher now pressed him. 
 You are the best appointment to York. 
 You are the best and most convincing appointment for London. 
 I think it would be best for you also. 
 No other bishop can meet the demands of the see of London, in statesmanship, scholarship, spiritual force, &bquo;and the rest&equo;. 
 If this is right, who should go to York? 
 And meanwhile Garbett was still spreading doubt on whether to send him to the see of London was the best way for the Church to use the best scholar on its bench of bishops. 
 Fisher's next move was to consult Ramsey about the entire problem of the two simultaneous sees. 
 On 12 December 1955 Ramsey went to Lambeth Palace. 
 He determined beforehand that he would not mention to Fisher his longing for time to read books. 
 But Fisher raised the question of time for study and writing. 
 Ramsey asked the pointed question whether William Temple would have been able to write if he had been Bishop of London and not Archbishop of York. 
 Finally Ramsey said that he would respond to any invitation provided that it had a consensus of advice behind it, and provided he was sure that the need for strength in the North was considered. 
 Fisher thought that Ramsey at this interview was &bquo;gloriously analytical and dispassionate&equo; and that his point about weight in the North had force. 
 Ramsey's long memory always regarded the decision to leave academic life as the hardest of his life. 
 To the observer this decision of 1955 looks as hard or harder; to agree to accept a post which he expected to hate, and for which he regarded himself as unsuitable, and in which he would have to neglect that scholarship which was essential to his happiness and to his sense of vocation and to the reason why he ever became a bishop at all, if the leaders of the Church declared that this was where he was needed. 
 His long memory also told him that this was a moment of his life when he felt a total rapport with Fisher. 
 On 14 December 1955 Fisher repeated his recommendation to Anthony Eden that Ramsey should become the Bishop of London. 
 On the same day, knowing nothing of what Fisher was doing, Ramsey drove to Bishopthorpe outside York to see his frail and dying archbishop. 
 Garbett said that he thought it would be right to go to London, for the sake of the Church; that he longed for him to come to York, for the sake of himself, he wanted Ramsey as his successor. 
 &bquo;If you go to London I shall feel it right. 
 If you come to York, I shall be happy.&equo; 
 Ramsey knelt by his bedside and Garbett blessed him. 
 Ramsey never saw him again.  
 For the twelve days before Christmas a black cloud hung over the Ramseys. 
 He had no desire to move anywhere. 
 This was not just a bishop married to the see and people of Durham, it was a love-marriage. 
 Those years were not long enough to do what he had hoped to do for Durham, but long enough to know what needed to be done. 
 Joan was at home both in Durham and in Auckland Castle. 
 But from 12 December he knew that he had to move somewhere, under orders. 
 And the fear was a burden, that he might need to move to a place which would kill his intellectual life. 
 On Christmas Eve among the Christmas cards he found a letter from Anthony Eden offering to recommend him to the Queen for the see of York. 
 Whether it was the wishes of the archdiocese; or whether it was the inarticulate growls of air-marshals; or whether it was the judgement that someone of 73 carries too many years to move to big new work; or whether someone among Eden's advisers thought scholarship important for some bishops &mdash; Eden rejected Fisher's preference that Ramsey should go to London. 
 The relief to the Ramseys was overwhelming. 
 Michael Ramsey took Eden's letter into the chapel but knew what his answer would be even before he put it on the altar. 
 In view of what was to happen, it is important to notice the situation. 
 In 1952 Archbishop Fisher had not wanted Ramsey for the see of Durham. 
 He thought it wrong to take him out of Cambridge so quickly. 
 Now he preferred him at London, for Bishops of London are by geography close colleagues of archbishops at Lambeth. 
 But Fisher was happy in accepting what happened, and glad to have Ramsey moving to York. 
 He openly talked of him as the probable successor to the see of Canterbury. 
 He looked forward to working with him. 
 The historian has a doubt. 
 If Ramsey was to be Archbishop of Canterbury, what was wrong with leaving him in the weighty see of Durham until the day came? 
 What higher interest of Church or nation was served by driving him to move too quickly? 
 Did the Church of England have so obsessed an idea of hierarchy that it liked promoting people up a ladder without any snakes? 
 Was it a mania for translating bishops &mdash; represented at its oddest in the idea that it was sensible at the age of 73 to move the revered George Bell to one of these sees? 
 Or was it true that the Church was so short of people of stature (under the age of 73) that only one man among them had enough stature for the see of London and for that reason his scholarship must be sacrificed on the altar of a higher good? 
 This last motive was present in Fisher's mind. 
 It is hard to believe that it was a right judgement about all the other people possible.  
 Ramsey's last act for the Durham diocese was to publish a collection of his Durham Essays and Addresses . 
 It is one of his best and most readable books. 
 In it the mutual affections of bishop and diocese cannot be missed. 
 Ramsey felt no sense of gratitude to anyone who moved him out of Durham. 
 He was seen weeping in the waiting-room at Durham station, and the misery was the giving up of Durham with its epic history, its Bede and Cuthbert, its beauty and its strength, his new friends and his old, the university and the mining communities. 
 He felt it as a bereavement. 
 The prime minister Anthony Eden was a Durham man. 
 Ramsey felt remote from him. 
 Soon after all this was agreed, he went to see Eden to have a talk with him about new appointments, and because Eden wanted to know him better. 
 This meeting was a failure. 
 Ramsey was abnormally shy about meeting the upper class and Eden's voice was the caricature of an upper class voice. 
 But worse than this pardonable affliction was Ramsey's discovery that when they talked about his beloved Durham this Durham man showed no interest. 
 Later he made to himself excuses for Eden; that he left Durham young and that his childhood was unhappy. 
 Still &mdash; &bquo;I did not see him again and I did not want to&equo;. 
 EBOR: 
 Ramsey's confirmation as the new Archbishop of York was held at Lambeth on 13 March 1956 and was marked by one of those protests which to the outsider are amusing and which to the subject of the  protest are vexatious. 
 Mr Kensit, a name long famous in the history of Protestant expostulations against Anglo-Catholicism, the secretary of the Protestant Truth Society, appeared at the ceremony and presented a document. 
 He lodged what he took to be a legal objection against Ramsey being admitted to be Archbishop of York. 
 The grounds were two. 
 First, he had failed to do what he ought to have done when Bishop of Durham to discipline the ritualists in the parish of St Mary's Tyne Dock, although some of the parishioners appealed to him for protection against illegal practices and ornaments of a Romish character. 
 Secondly, he had published doctrine at variance with the Athanasian Creed and the Homilies of the Church of England and his teaching was at variance with that of the Archbishop of Canterbury and other bishops. 
 This second charge came because Ramsey had written an article in the Bishoprick  which criticized the evangelistic work of Billy Graham, who led a mission in England a few months before. 
 Ramsey said that the name of Billy Graham was linked with fundamentalism; and that fundamentalism was the error of regarding the Bible as so divine that the human element disappeared. 
 Billy Graham like all such evangelists called for people from the congregation to make an immediate decision and to come out from the crowd; and Ramsey wrote that the call for an immediate decision had danger because the mind could be stifled in the process and this could bring a later revenge in scepticism and indifference. 
 He said that at the recent mission in Cambridge Billy Graham had taught the grossest doctrines. 
 The reader of the article remembers Michael Ramsey's experience of the missioner William Nicholson in his undergraduate years. 
 Since many of the evangelicals shared Billy Graham's opinions and valued his methods and saw the good which he did, his article stirred wrath among them and fear about the Bishop of Durham becoming the Archbishop of York. 
 For this purpose Archbishop Fisher acted in his capacity as the Queen, s commissioner. 
 He ruled the objection out of order. 
 He said that the only questions under discussion were whether Ramsey was Ramsey and whether he had been legally elected. 
 Since no one could imagine that in these circumstances or in any other circumstances anyone could successfully impersonate Ramsey, the ritual was a piece of legal nothing which allowed a Protestant agitator the chance of publicity which might help his own cause but must also help Ramsey. 
 If a man is worth protesting against he must be somebody. 
 Nevertheless, Ramsey found the experience of Kensit's protest a little frightening. 
 For the first time he met, peeping above the surface, the force of a prejudice which had unrelenting ferocity. 
 He would meet it, not peeping, later in his career.  
 Less fanatical minds of the Protestant school were not pleased with the choice for York. 
 The editor of the Church of England Newspaper  remarked that the overzealousness of Ramsey's friends did him a disservice by making him the representative of an intolerant school of thought and by inflating his reputation beyond what his record would endorse. 
 Archbishop Fisher went so far as to write a very tough letter to the editor in defence of Ramsey. 
 The new archbishop was enthroned in York Minster on St Mark's Day, 25 April 1956. 
 That the Dean of York was Eric Milner-White, his former teacher, gave pleasure to both parties. 
 The dean said, &bquo;My child in the Spirit has become my Father in God.&equo; 
 It was the first enthronement of an archbishop since television became a national service; and Ramsey agreed to broadcast on television on the night before his enthronement. 
 The diocese was larger than the diocese of Durham and more varied; industry on Teesside, moors of the North Riding, wolds of the East Riding, the plain of York, cities like York and Hull. 
 But although it was larger his life was easier. 
 He had three suffragan bishops and three archdeacons. 
 By now he had discovered what archdeacons do, and did not have to do everything himself. 
 He inherited a regular staff meeting and was penitent that he had never invented such a meeting in Durham. 
 He now had a whole-time chaplain. 
 Martin Kaye, whom he put in charge of the ordinands. 
 One of them, Peter Cornwell, later published a sunlit retrospect of what it was like to be one of Ebor's ordinands, and how he valued the privilege that the bishop who ordained him was a thinker, as he put it, so profound. 
 Martin Kaye also helped Joan to make sure that the conversation was not too oppressively silent when ordinands or clergymen came to meals. 
 Thus Ramsey found leisure to read, and write, and make friends in the diocese. 
 Afterwards he wondered whether he visited parishes less often than his predecessor and took the trouble to work it out. 
 He found that he did just better than his predecessor and was pleased. 
 Despite this diligence in the diocese he had more leisure than at Durham and much more leisure than later. 
 At York he was able to write a weighty book, From Gore to Temple , which traced changes in Christian thought in England during the last eighty years. 
 His first problem was where to live. 
 He had insisted on living in Auckland Castle though some people said that it was absurd for the Bishop of Durham to be saddled with such a pile. 
 Garbett decided that no one after himself ought to be made to live in a ch&acirc;teau like  Bishopthorpe. 
 He planned to turn Bishopthorpe into a retreat house and to put the archbishop into a small house nearby called the Chantry. 
 Ramsey instantly scrapped this plan. 
 The Ramseys wanted a house big enough to be able to entertain the clergy and their wives in their own home. 
 He needed room for a lot of books and wanted his chaplain and secretary to be able to live in the house. 
 He was determined to be under the same roof as his chapel. 
 His sense of history and of genius loci  was potent. 
 And the memory that William Temple used to meditate in the garden was not trivial to him. 
 The chapel went back to the thirteenth century; in the Restoration of Charles II Archbishop Frewen gave the house a fa&ccedil;ade to the river and built a magnificent dining room; and during the eighteenth century Archbishop Drummond added a Gothic gatehouse and made the surround a charming bit of eighteenth-century Gothic. 
 Joan had an eye which knew what to do with apparently unpromising houses. 
 Their bachelor predecessor had no such eye and did not try to change it. 
 Joan saw that it needed cheering up. 
 She put coral paint in the panels of the Strawberry Hill Gothic hall. 
 She picked out the arches in ivory white. 
 She transformed the entrance so that it sang a welcome to the visitor. 
 In summer she filled the great blue and white Chinese vases with the deep blue delphiniums grown from buds which Cosmo Gordon Lang originally planted. 
 Visitors found it a lovely house, full of air and hospitality. 
 Joan was discovered to have a genius for turning an ancient block of stone into a home. 
 The house had not the vistas or the parkland of Auckland Castle, and its chapel could hardly compete with the chapel at Auckland, but it had good walks along the Ouse. 
 The diocese was pleased that he lived there. 
 Robert Reid from the BBC interviewed Ramsey in the garden at Bishopthorpe in April 1956, with daffodils spattering the lawn. 
 &bquo;He's a most engaging fellow &mdash; essentially human&equo;, Reid reported as though there was something odd about an archbishop being human. 
 &bquo;He's a huge fellow. 
 He looks as though he's been a footballer in his time. 
 He's got a keen sense of humour and there's a perpetual twinkle in his eye&hellip; 
 This is not a scholar emerging into the world. 
 He's already in it... 
 He will not be a rubber stamp. 
 He already has the shape of a great leader.&equo; 
 In the following year a BBC man who came to Bishopthorpe to have a brains trust in the house was shocked to discover that there was no television set in the house and told him that he was cut off from the experience of millions of his countrymen. 
 He presided three times a year at the Convocation of York, which he  found a happy body. 
 This last statement should be noticed &mdash; he disliked assemblies and places where speeches were made at length and he did not enjoy being a chairman &mdash; but he made this single exception, the Convocation of York; he always gave a presidential address, about which he took much trouble. 
 He visited the other dioceses of his province, including a tour of several days to the Isle of Man. 
 He preached to the World Scout Jamboree and was blamed by the Daily  Telegraph  for reading  his sermon to a multitude of boys and that the notes were too visible when they were blown about by the wind. 
 He went with the Dean of York and the Lord Mayor of York to interview the chairman of the University Grants Committee about setting one of the new universities in York and was glad, before he left York, to see the plea accepted. 
 He continued to conduct retreats: the old students at Cuddesdon, clergy at Pleshey in Essex, the Franciscans at Cerne Abbas in Dorset, the nuns at Whitby; probably he was the first archbishop in the history of the see to make so much time for such days of peace, even though, for the conductor, they were days of intellectual and emotional effort. 
 The work dearest to his heart was the development of the Retreat House at Wydale Hall near Scarborough, for which he made money available, encouraged the nuns, Sisters of the Holy Paraclete, who ran it, and was grateful when he saw more and more people go there to say their prayers. 
 For one who was nervous with aristocrats, it was unusual that he made a special friend in the diocese of the hereditary lay leader of the Anglo-Catholics in England: the Earl of Halifax at Garrowby, whom he would have preferred to Churchill as a war leader. 
 They found plenty of common Church interests and then friendship; they had conversations, which Ramsey enjoyed enormously, about matters political as well as religious; Ramsey went over to Garrowby several times for meals or to stay the night and celebrate the sacrament in the morning; and he conducted Halifax's funeral at Kirby Underdale in 1959. 
 He afterwards regarded making friends with Lord Halifax as one of the happinesses of the York years. 
 During his time at York he was invited to be the visitor of the House of the Resurrection at Mirfield in Yorkshire, the community of priests founded at the end of the last century by Charles Gore. 
 He liked his association with the monastic life in this form. 
 He conducted a visitation every five years, when he went there and interviewed each individual member of the community and finally gave them all a charge. 
 Their work was mainly that of missions and teaching ordinands and conducting retreats, though their work in Africa was both tense and world-famous. 
 He respected the community, valued its work, and was grateful  for the friendship of its members. 
 He shared enough of the monk's ideal to be able to help. 
 It was in part because of this love of the specially religious life, and in part because of the affection for the long history of the Church, that he led another pilgrimage (1959) of several thousand people to Holy Island on the coast of Northumberland and even The Times  had a piece about the archbishop walking barefoot. 
 William Temple, while Archbishop of York, wrote in the York  Quarterly , a journal which expired in the first year of the Second World War. 
 Ramsey knew that as a bishop he had a teaching ministry, and that this needed a journal which was more than diocesan news. 
 No sooner did he reach York than he resurrected the York Quarterly  and kept it going for five years and nineteen numbers, with the arms of the see on the outer cover, and underneath, &bquo;Editor: the Archbishop of York&equo;. 
 In some numbers he wrote half the contents; in others, especially at the time of an operation on his eyes for glaucoma, little. 
 This operation (1960) seriously delayed him, for it left one eye permanently damaged, and he was in the Purey-Cust nursing home by the minster in York and then had a convalescence of several weeks. 
 In the York Quarterly  he used the services as writers or reviewers of good men about him. 
 Here he weighed nuclear disarmament or the latest ways in the study of the New Testament or the nature of the establishment in Church and State or the Church in industrial society. 
 He expounded to his clergy advanced books of original thinking which most of them were never likely to see or read. 
 Two or three of his articles were hardly intelligible to some of the subscribers. 
 It was no wonder that the journal had no easy task making ends meet. 
 It is a well-written journal of value to the contemporary interpretation of Christian thought and life. 
 In the York Diocesan Leaflet  he wrote a more popular message to his diocese. 
 He quoted Newman's sermons, which he loved for their awareness of the closeness of the divine behind the veil of matter. 
 He mentioned the possibility of sacramental confession at the time of Lent. 
 He pleaded for a regular reading of the Bible, and for sermons which expounded biblical passages, and for the use of the Bible in connection with prayer. 
 He recommended retreats in a noisy world, and gave a beautiful description of their purpose. 
 He begged for more laymen and more laywomen to teach in Sunday Schools. 
 He wanted to keep the church schools and the church colleges for the training of teachers despite the large sums of money which this needed. 
 He brought before their minds disarmament, or the plight of refugees, or the plight of countries in poverty, or the work of the Church in other lands, or murder in the Congo. 
 He told them how  morally indefensible was the policy of apartheid, and asked for prayer for Africa. 
 He recommended to them lists of books for the better understanding of their religion, and the advice was excellent. 
 He liked them to try one or two of the classics of Christian writing. 
 While he was Archbishop of York both the ancient universities made him an honorary doctor. 
 Their different ethos was illustrated by the difference in the virtues which they celebrated. 
 The Cambridge deputy orator of 1957 commended him for his ecumenical work, and as the tireless pastor of the northern province, and made no mention of his academic originality &mdash; perhaps the ghost of Bethune-Baker still peeped through a window of the Senate House. 
 The orator mentioned his debt to William Temple and to Edward Wynn, and his wit, and gargantuan laugh. 
 The Oxford public orator of 1960 commended him for all he had done in persuading Oxford undergraduates to a reasonable faith and called him a most penetrating interpreter of the New Testament and a very powerful bulwark of Mother Church. 
 Perhaps the Oxford public orator consulted Austin Farrer. 
 In 1958 Archbishop Fisher assembled the Lambeth Conference of bishops. 
 Ramsey entered this conference with a reputation outside England as well as inside it; and the proceedings of the conference confirmed the opinion of a lot of bishops that he ought to be their next leader. 
 George Bell, retired, fatigued, soon to die, attended the conference against the advice of his doctor. 
 He thought the agenda too large and the business too hurried. 
 He recorded in his notes that there were not many weighty bishops at the conference but of those who were weighty Ramsey was outstanding. 
 At the opening service in Canterbury cathedral (3 July 1958) Ramsey muddled his instructions and wandered all round the cathedral looking for where he was supposed to sit and stand. 
 This conference was not without hiccoughs. 
 First, Fisher invited Archbishop Makarios of Cyprus whom some held responsible for the murder of British soldiers in the quasi-civil war in Cyprus. 
 Makarios accepted but did not come. 
 When the conference opened, a couple of members of the League of Empire Loyalists, one a journalist and the other a chiropodist, hired eastern bishops' flowing robes from a theatrical costumier, walked in unchallenged, and got up to make a speech against the &bquo;archterrorist&equo; Makarios. 
 They left quietly when asked but their pictures gave fun to the newspapers. 
 The second hiccough concerned Ramsey directly. 
 The Church  Union, organ of Anglo-Catholics, decided to hold a eucharistic congress at the Albert Hall just before the Lambeth Conference opened; a demonstration of Anglo-Catholicism at a key point of Anglican history. 
 They invited Ramsey to give the inaugural address. 
 He gave an address which the hearers thought masterly and was the more needed in that the succeeding speeches bumbled. 
 The Observer  commented that Ramsey destroyed his chances of succeeding Fisher as archbishop by so openly identifying himself with the extreme high church party. 
 The Sunday Express  speculated about the next primate and thought that Ramsey probably ruled himself out by his partisan behaviour in attending the eucharistic congress. 
 Archbishop Fisher did not approve of his fellow-archbishop being prominent in such company at such a moment of history. 
 At breakfast together Fisher exploded and attacked the Church Union and all that it stood for and said that they had done great harm and ought to apologize. 
 Ramsey confessed that they had done a lot of harm and ought to apologize but said that the best of them were trying to, and that the Church of England ought to apologize to the high churchmen for the way in which it sometimes treated them. 
 The main theme of the Lambeth Conference 1958 was the Bible. 
 Ramsey was made the chairman of the commission on this theme. 
 He drafted the report. 
 The Bible and the modern world: the problem with which he had wrestled since he was an undergraduate; a Bible world-picture and a modern scientific world-picture, each hardly able to understand the other. 
 If we take a knife to the Bible and cut out the bits which the modern world cannot understand we compromise the message which Christianity has to give to society. 
 If we baldly declare the Bible world-picture and do not interpret it to the modern world in such a way as to make it intelligible, we are useless. 
 Therefore on one side we must assert the authority of the Bible over man and the Church, and not the authority of man and the Church over the Bible. 
 It probes to the roots of moral distress and brings the remedy. 
 While we do this we must beware of those who are so hungry for authority in our societies that they want to press the authority of the Bible over men and the Church in such a way as to lead to extravagance or to sectarianism. 
 On the other side we must assert freedom of enquiry. 
 We must accept that study has proved that the Bible is not historically true in all its parts; we must declare that no Christian need suppose the book of Genesis to be an accurate physical account of the making of the world, nor mind if study proves contradictions in the different accounts in the gospels. 
 The divine spirit is at work not only in the consciences but also in the minds of humanity, and the careful study of the texts is a  part of that. 
 And we have to remember that God always remains above the possibility of human words, even when those words are the words of inspired men or women. 
 Treated so, the authority of the Bible is not diminished but enhanced. 
 Thus we commend the Bible to be read by the Churches and by Christian families in their homes, as nourishment for their souls, and not to be separated from the sacrament in the liturgy; we commend modern translations, into the various languages, as a help to understanding; we commend the people who have the duty of seeking to interpret the Bible in terms of the modern scientific view of the world; and remind the Churches that all knowledge is of God and therefore that scientific discovery is also part of His work; and so the world will be brought to know God as its Maker, and the Cross as timeless. 
 The critics fastened upon two sections of this report. 
 A long paragraph presented the acts of God in the Bible as like a mighty drama. 
 This was the single part not drafted by Ramsey. 
 The word drama, with its suggestion of a stage-play, did not please everyone. 
 The idea of a day of creation being &bquo;flashed upon the screen&equo; by Genesis, as the report said, was incongruous. 
 And at one point, showing how the books were formed into the New Testament by the early Church, the report expressed the belief that God gave the early Church its three gifts of ordering of the New Testament, creeds like the apostles' creed, and the ministry of bishops in their succession from the apostles. 
 This did not please everyone. 
 The Church of England Newspaper  said, unkindly, that the weakest part of the Lambeth Conference of 1958 was its report on the Bible; and that this would have been an excellent report for a Lambeth Conference of 1858 not 1958. 
 But this was not a common opinion. 
 Most bishops thought that the handling by Ramsey of this difficult theme was masterly. 
 No Church before committed itself so decisively to the rightness of modern biblical criticism and the freedom of biblical scholarship, while it continued to maintain the Bible and the faith of Easter as indispensable to the moral predicament of humanity and of its societies. 
 One can picture Hoskyns looking down from the skies and being grateful for his pupil; and Bethune-Baker looking down and thinking that he always knew where Hoskyns might lead the Churches. 
 Those who encouraged new translations did not yet imagine what would happen. 
 The bishops expected the hallowed Authorized Version to maintain its mastery because it was sanctified in everyone's affections and moral sentiments. 
 They had no idea, as yet, that the coming of modern translations, and the making of English into an international  language, would destroy the commonness of a single text of the Bible which was the property of the simple as of the sophisticated. 
 The Lambeth Conference of 1958 took other resolutions. 
 It called for a revision of the Prayer Book &mdash; and the bishops of that day had no idea how far this call would lead the Churches. 
 It surveyed the reunion schemes across the world. 
 It sanctioned the ordination of men while they continued in their lay occupations. 
 It urged the full use of trained and qualified women &mdash; and the bishops had no idea as yet how far this resolution would lead some of the Churches. 
 It blessed the religious communities and thereby committed the Anglican Communion to an official acceptance of monks and nuns in a way which was so far unique to the Churches which came out of the Reformation. 
 It asked governments to abolish nuclear bombs, and wished for the strengthening of the United Nations. 
 It condemned racialism in the strongest language. 
 It warned against the abuse of drugs and alcohol. 
 It demanded the concern of government for the plight of refugees. 
 It accepted that monogamy was inherent in Christianity and yet that there were polygamous societies where even the Church could not enforce the rule at once, and that the chief way forward lay in a progressive emancipation of women in those societies, especially in the sphere of education. 
 Those who afterwards blamed Lambeth 1958 for platitudes did not know what they were talking about. 
 The resolution which hit the headlines was that which approved the rightness of contraception. 
 It denounced the idea that gratification is the end of sex, but said that parents have the duty of choosing how many children they have. 
 They partly justified this by an eye upon the too rapid growth of population in some countries. 
 A Jesuit instantly declared that the Anglican Communion was pandering to paganism. 
 Archbishop Fisher was very pleased at what Ramsey did for the conference. 
 In particular Ramsey helped the Anglo-Catholic members of the Conference to take a more friendly attitude to the South India Church, which united a Church with bishops to Churches without bishops in a unified structure over a period of years. 
 If the conference began with a breakfast explosion between the two archbishops, it ended with mutual gratitude for what was achieved. 
 Yet nothing could alter the double personal difficulty &mdash; a difference of principles between a low churchman and a high churchman, and an indefinable difference of temperament. 
 The first problem was order in the Church of England. 
 The legal Prayer Book was still that of 1662. 
 Since the noises in the House of Commons in 1927 and 1928, the bishops sanctioned or winked their eyes at various modifications which were sensible and did not mind that  they were illegal. 
 For centuries the Church of England was liberal in its spirit and never pressed its clergy to conform to every rubric. 
 But there was a difference between liberal freedom and anarchy. 
 State law could not provide discipline because it met resistance from consciences. 
 Therefore church law must do it &mdash; that is, canon law. 
 The last code of canon law, still nominally in force, was made just after the death of Queen Elizabeth I Tudor. 
 Some of these canons were still observed (what to wear when conducting morning prayer) and some were long obsolete (rules about clergy nightcaps or yellow stockings on their legs). 
 It therefore occurred to the canon lawyers &mdash; a rarefied group of experts &mdash; that Church law, framed by the Church organs and then approved by the sovereign, could achieve the canons which would bind consciences. 
 Archbishop Fisher accepted the argument and became the enthusiastic leader of the new movement. 
 The work was hard; hard to frame, hard to get through committees, hard to get accepted. 
 No archbishop but Fisher would have had the administrative ability or the tenacity to achieve the end. 
 During the discussions Ramsey grew uneasy. 
 He had in his background two things which were missing from Fisher's background. 
 He was a Free Churchman by origin, likely to suspect religion by law. 
 And during his dark night of the soul while he was at Cuddesdon, part of the darkness was the behaviour of the House of Commons. 
 Thus he had an inherent antipathy to the idea that law, even Church law, canon law, could achieve anything that was good for the Church. 
 It should be an axiom, he thought, that the fewer the rules the better. 
 He may have remembered St Mary's Tyne Dock, where he freely sanctioned certain things that were illegal because the parish church council wanted them for purposes of devotion. 
 He disliked the whole idea of tidying up worship. 
 Not that he liked anarchy. 
 But he saw the prayers of the Church as a living and fruitful tradition which threw up new ideas, some on reflection wrong or offending and to be rejected, others the seeds of devotion. 
 He had an inner contradiction which rose out of his background. 
 He wanted order in the Church. 
 But he could hardly bear the idea of law as an instrument for telling people how to pray. 
 This difference between the two archbishops was illustrated over the memorial requiem in York minster for Lord Halifax. 
 As the son of a stalwart Anglo-Catholic Halifax loved the form of the first English Prayer Book, that of 1549 under King Edward VI. 
 Naturally this order, which Halifax had in his little church, was appropriate for his requiem. 
 But it was illegal. 
 An order which was quietly used in some parish churches round the country without offence looked different when used  on what was a national occasion with a national congregation. 
 So Fisher knew. 
 But Ramsey, who had come to love Halifax, wanted what Halifax wanted; in such a case, in his view, the law does not care about trivialities. 
 Fisher objected that an Archbishop of York ought not to encourage illegality by being present at the requiem; and, painfully for himself, felt under a duty of conscience not to attend the memorial service. 
 Nothing was going to stop Ramsey attending the memorial service for a close friend, whether it was legal or illegal. 
 He had a feeling that the Archbishop of Canterbury was now too powerful in the Church; that he and the other bishops were more like sheep as they sat saying yes to what Canterbury suggested. 
 Ramsey afterwards felt that he was partly to blame that he and Fisher were not closer together. 
 He never lost the early sense of a gulf in age, and experience, and speed of mind. 
 He never quite got over the sense of being a boy in the presence of an adult. 
 Fisher called him Michael, Ramsey did not yet dare to call Fisher Geoffrey. 
 Some things he longed to talk about &mdash; he agonized over the Christians' attitude to nuclear bombs and it grieved him that Fisher did not agonize. 
 He admired so many qualities in Fisher: the shrewdness about people, the grasp of practical problems, the ability to work very long hours, the patience under abuse from the press, the humility which went with a cocksureness that was not arrogance. 
 And yet, despite all this, the Archbishop of York was not comfortable with the Archbishop of Canterbury except in the moments when the two powerful senses of humour coincided in laughter. 
 In these differences there was nothing unusual. 
 It is orthodox doctrine that the Archbishop of York ought not to hold exactly the same opinions as the Archbishop of Canterbury. 
 The Queen obeyed this doctrine in the choice of Ramsey for the see of York. 
 But now, for the first time in English history, a set of circumstances existed which tested, whether this doctrine is always workable. 
 The test came over the choice of a new Archbishop of Canterbury. 
 In former days this emotional moment could not arise because archbishops had little say in the choice of bishops and no say at all in the choice of their successor. 
 But the sovereigns from Queen Victoria onwards turned consultations with the archbishop into a constitutional convention; so that now the Archbishop of Canterbury had the principal say in the choice of bishops and had a right to be consulted on the choice of his own successor; or, if he had not a constitutional right, at least he had every right to proffer advice to the prime minister whether  the prime minister asked for it or not. 
 Harold Macmillan, prime minister since 1957 and an Anglican wanting to do the best for the Church, was sure to ask Fisher for his advice and would have felt scandalous if he had not. 
 Fisher determined to resign from early in 1961. 
 He was 74 that coming April and felt that he was tired mentally. 
 And he was  tired mentally, for once he addressed a bishops' meeting for a whole hour without stopping. 
 By the convention in force he had the duty of suggesting the name of a successor. 
 The biggest man in sight was the Archbishop of York. 
 Yet the last three years made Fisher doubt whether Ramsey was possible &mdash; because of his Catholic restraint on reunion schemes and his suspicion of the ecumenical movement, because of his willingness for wide Catholic liberties in the way of worship, and because of his attitude to law. 
 A glory of the Church of England was its comprehensiveness. 
 It had never yet had as its leader someone who represented one of the more extreme parties in the Church &mdash; never at least since the days of Archbishop Laud which ended in the archbishop's head being cut off. 
 Was it conscientiously possible, in such circumstances, for the Archbishop of Canterbury to recommend to the prime minister that the Archbishop of York should succeed him? 
 ELECTION TO CANTERBURY 
 Ramsey was told by Fisher that he intended to resign. 
 He asked himself whether Fisher would recommend him to the Crown as his successor. 
 He thought it possible that he would and probable that he would not. 
 He asked himself, who else? 
 The Bishop of Peterborough, Stopford, was an excellent administrator. 
 The Bishop of Bradford, Coggan, was an evangelical with a quality then rare among evangelical leaders, namely learning, and was a likeable person who made himself respected by good sense at bishops' meetings. 
 Ramsey narrowed his private short-list to three: Stopford, Coggan, Ramsey. 
 For the first time since he was a professor at Cambridge, he began to hope, though with modesty, that he might be chosen for the work. 
 If one is partly responsible already for the general policy of a Church or for anything else, it is better to be more responsible. 
 It puzzled him into the New Year of 1961 that no one asked his opinion. 
 Five years before, Fisher drew him into the argument. 
 This silence was marked. 
 He assumed that this could only be because he was one of the possibles.  
 Without Ramsey's knowledge, Fisher came to the decision that he could not want Ramsey to succeed him, for reasons given above. 
 He pressed Harold Macmillan not to recommend to the Queen that the choice should fall upon Ramsey. 
 He did not think that Ramsey would be interested in the load of administration which he would have to carry. 
 He said to one of his chaplains that Ramsey spent too much time theologizing up in York instead of tackling problems practically. 
 He thought aspects of the Anglo-Catholic movement had danger; and that though Ramsey was not a danger, he would have such sympathy with them as not to be vigilant. 
 He threw before the prime minister other names &mdash; Coggan, Stopford, and some more. 
 Harold Macmillan was perturbed. 
 No prime minister before him had faced this exact situation. 
 He found himself with the duty of helping to make a vital decision for the Church of England at a moment in its destiny. 
 Like the rest of the world he could see that one possible successor was larger in stature than the others. 
 His personal religious feelings would not make him doubt Ramsey, for he owed something in his private religion to that tradition of the Oxford Movement which Ramsey represented. 
 Early in his time as prime minister he asked Ramsey to come down from York so that they could meet. 
 They talked in the Cabinet Room at No. 
 10 Downing Street. 
 Ramsey, formerly put off by Eden's drawl, was at first put off by Macmillan's blear-eyed appearance and puffy eyes. 
 &bquo;To start with I really thought that he was asleep.&equo; 
 But then they talked about the North, of Stockton and Teesside, and Macmillan enquired with a warmth of feeling which Ramsey found impressive. 
 And at one point in the conversation they touched on the kind of people who ought to become bishops. 
 Macmillan was very frank about his personal preference. 
 &bquo;He discoursed about his understanding of the Church and he said that we had to hold the high and the low together but for his part his sympathies were with the high. 
 He added that while the evangelicals had their part in the Church he did not think that on the whole they had the qualities suitable for being bishops.&equo; 
 History knows a cynical law: that in all lands politicians dislike ecclesiastics who interfere and therefore, when influencing who is to be a new bishop, prefer not to have bishops too practical and too effective; and a respectable way of having ineffective bishops, the only respectable way, is to have otherworldly bishops, who live to God and spend much time in prayer and are not well informed on matters of this world. 
 Those who talked to Harold Macmillan at this time were sure that this cold politicking did not enter his head; that he was sincere and only wanted to do the best that he could for the Church. 
 The kind of  clergyman with whom Macmillan felt kinship was a person of spirituality and otherworldliness, not the person who was a born administrator or Church politician. 
 Therefore he felt a rapport with Ramsey. 
 That Fisher said that Ramsey was too Catholic would not disturb Macmillan; and that Fisher said Ramsey was not an administrator would leave Macmillan unmoved. 
 Yet a lay statesman ought not in such a matter to trample upon the opinions of his Church advisers. 
 England was no longer in the days of Lloyd George or Palmerston. 
 And the only Church adviser with a constitutional right to speak thought that he would be wrong to tell the Queen the name of the person whom his instincts told him to be the right person. 
 There is evidence of Macmillan's perturbation of mind at this predicament. 
 He started by going to unofficial advisers and seeing whether they agreed with his official adviser. 
 He interviewed, one by one, some of the other names put forward by Fisher, to see what they were like in comparison with Ramsey whom he knew already. 
 He summoned the Dean of Westminster, Eric Abbott, to Downing Street. 
 We do not know what Eric Abbott said but he was Ramsey's second superior at Lincoln Theological College and then his best man at the wedding. 
 Macmillan talked to Sir Henry Willink, the Master of Magdalene. 
 Perhaps the prime minister expected that Willink would push for a Magdalene man but he did not get a firm line out of him. 
 Willink as a lawyer had a lot to do with the administration of the Church and saw the argument that an archbishop must be able to bear a load of administration. 
 Macmillan consulted the Queen, who knew and liked both Ramsey and Coggan. 
 He also took the trouble to buy and read a new book of theology which Ramsey at that moment published; an account of the development of English religious thought from the late Victorian age to the age of William Temple &mdash; From Gore to Temple . 
 It is hard to imagine Lloyd George or Churchill, Disraeli or Palmerston, reading the rather obscure books which some prelate wrote about religion. 
 From  Gore to Temple  is not an easy read for the layman. 
 It is a study of Liberal Catholic thought in English religion. 
 It has good things about Gore, about Hoskyns, about Temple. 
 It mentions Bethune-Baker six times in each case with the object of dissent and in one case to imply that his opinions were obsolete. 
 We are not aware that Macmillan had ever heard of Bethune-Baker. 
 We do not expect that he perused every word of the book. 
 Nevertheless we know that he liked it. 
 From what he was told by the Queen, by his unofficial advisers like the Dean of Westminster, and from his own conviction, Macmillan was sure that he must recommend Ramsey to the Queen. 
 He knew that this  would disturb Archbishop Fisher, which he did not wish to do. 
 He hoped to show his respect for Fisher's advice by simultaneously recommending Donald Coggan for the see of York. 
 He knew that he could be accused of acting like some less satisfactory prime ministers in this constitutional field, that is, choosing an archbishop of his own lay power without the approval of the Church; and he disliked that situation. 
 But he felt that he could do no other. 
 Fisher announced his retirement to the Convocation of Canterbury on 17 January 1961. 
 Ramsey, who knew the announcement was coming, delivered a public tribute to Fisher in the York Convocation. 
 On the evening of 17 January Harold Macmillan telephoned his offer to recommend Ramsey to the Queen for Canterbury. 
 He apologized for this method of enquiry. 
 He asked Ramsey to telephone an answer, next morning. 
 He said that if Ramsey accepted he had it in mind to recommend Donald Coggan for the see of York. 
 &bquo;How should I shirk?&equo; 
 Ramsey asked himself. 
 He telephoned next morning and said Yes. 
 Macmillan asked if he were willing for Coggan at York and he said Yes. 
 Ramsey was sure that this was a first in history; the settlement of the choice of an Archbishop of Canterbury by telephone. 
 All the courtesies were then observed by letter. 
 Macmillan made two mistakes of protocol. 
 The Queen was about to go abroad for several weeks. 
 Therefore this all had to be settled before Friday. 
 This made the country talk of breathless haste. 
 The Church likes time to say its prayers. 
 It preferred to be allowed to say some prayers for the Queen, the prime minister, and everyone else concerned with the choice, before they reached their conclusion. 
 Ramsey pointed this out to Macmillan in the famous telephone conversation and was overruled because of the Queen's movements. 
 Not all the members of the Church welcomed the instantaneousness of resignation and appointment. 
 There were protests. 
 Some of the protests came from people who were afraid of Ramsey at Canterbury. 
 Some came from people who longed to have Ramsey at Canterbury. 
 The second mistake was more technical and more secret. 
 Without realizing it Macmillan trespassed on the modern constitutional convention. 
 He asked the Queen to appoint an Archbishop of York without first asking the Archbishop of Canterbury. 
 He got the sanction of Ramsey, which was important because Ramsey and Coggan would have to work together. 
 The doctrine of dissimilarity was being observed. 
 As Fisher pressed Coggan for Canterbury he could not object to Coggan going to the see of York. 
 But technically, it was a breach of convention. 
 Fisher was disturbed by it. 
 He thought it retrograde constitutionally. 
 He made his displeasure plain to the prime minister. 
 London was  coming vacant and London was a more important see than York and Coggan ought to go there. 
 Thus Archbishop Fisher had two reasons for not being pleased with the prime minister. 
 But this question was quickly resolved when it was discovered that Coggan much preferred moving to York and not London. 
 Macmillan said to Ramsey, &bquo;Fisher doesn't seem to approve of you.&equo; 
 Ramsey defended him. 
 &bquo;Fisher&equo;, he said, &bquo;was my headmaster and he has known ail my deficiencies for a long time.&equo; 
 &equo; Well', said Macmillan, &bquo;he is not going to be my  headmaster.&equo; 
 Later Macmillan was reputed to have defended his decision in a sentence which is likely to be authentic because it has the Macmillan ring: &bquo;I thought we had had enough of Martha and it was time for some Mary., 
 Fisher wrote a kind letter to Ramsey, who found that in the circumstances it showed a generous spirit. 
 &bquo;You will add great distinction to the office in ways to which I could not aspire; but I fear you will find a great deal of the work here work which does not really interest you.&equo; 
 He warned Ramsey of the burden of administration and how he would need advisers. 
 Those who are interested in the affairs of Church and State will observe that, at two of the three crossroads of Ramsey's life, it was the State authority which secured the result. 
 The State winched him out of the professorial chair when the ecclesiastical authority was lukewarm. 
 The State made him the ecclesiastical head of the Church of England by trampling on the opinions of the relevant ecclesiastical authority. 
 Thus was made an archbishop who did more than any Archbishop of Canterbury since Stephen Langton of Magna Carta to make the Church more free in its relation to the State. 
 In May 1961 a girl to whom Archbishop Fisher allowed a flat in Lambeth Tower when she and a husband were desperate for a place to live walked her pram round the courtyard, and observed the two archbishops also circling the courtyard and deep in conversation. 
 She took it for granted that they talked about &bquo;the handover&equo;. 
 She recorded her description. 
 &bquo;It was like a cock-sparrow hopping about by the side of a dinosaur. 
 The new and younger archbishop looked twenty years older than the older archbishop.&equo; 
 In June 1961 Michael Ramsey was enthroned Archbishop in Canterbury Cathedral. 
 &bquo;It is a macabre thought&equo;, wrote Monica Furlong in the Spectator  (30 June), &bquo;that if the Canterbury Special had crashed last Tuesday morning it would have wiped out at one go practically the whole of the English episcopate together with numerous foreign archbishops and bishops, most of the Orthodox patriarchs, the leaders of the Lutheran Churches in half a dozen countries of Europe and the  heads of our own Free Churches.&equo; 
 In the cathedral she observed the new archbishop moving among the strange costumes, the rosary with purple tassles and red beads the size of pigeons' eggs, and the purple velvet fez. 
 She expected him to keep looking over his shoulder to make sure that all the fuss was not intended for the man behind. 
 She was moved by his address: not so much by the declaration of the reformed and Catholic nature of the Church of England, nor by his condemnation of racialism, nor by his challenge to the State to give the Church more liberty to follow its vocation in worship; but by his gratitude at the growing longing within the Church for a deeper life of prayer. 
 SOCIAL POLICIES 
 The business of compulsion is not something theoretical or peripheral; it is of the essence of a right, because there is no point in declaring a right to what everyone is going to have anyhow. 
 The whole object of declaring a right is to justify or commend the use of compulsion to alter the existing relationship between individuals is a society. 
 &bquo;Human Rights&equo;, Journal of Medical Ethics, 3, 1977  
 &bquo;HOUSING&equo; from One Nation , 1950 
 The first parliamentary Acts concerning housing in the nineteenth century were Public Health Acts, which laid down requirements as regards sanitation and public safety. 
 Detailed regulations for the construction of new buildings were laid down in a great variety of Acts and bye-laws. 
 In 1868 and 1879 the two &bquo;Torrens Acts&equo; made the owner of a house responsible for keeping it in a habitable condition, and gave powers of compulsion to the local authority. 
 Further steps forward were taken in 1875 and 1879 when the &bquo;Cross Acts&equo; were passed. 
 These empowered local authorities to clear and reconstruct unhealthy areas, with powers to purchase compulsorily and to limit compensation. 
 The Housing of the Working Classes Act, 1890, unified previous housing legislation and remained the principal Housing Act until the consolidating Act of 1925. 
 This Act of 1890 incorporated the &bquo;Cross&equo; and the &bquo;Torrens&equo; provisions, and empowered urban sanitary authorities to erect workers' dwellings independently of clearance schemes. 
 Its powers were extended by the Housing Acts of 1894, 1900 and 1903, and also by the Housing and Town Planning Act of 1909, the first major housing measure not introduced by Conservatives. 
 These early Acts stemmed very largely from sanitary powers, and did not provide any financial assistance beyond powers of borrowing money. 
 In tackling the grave problem of dilapidated and overcrowded property by reconditioning old houses and building new ones at low rents, the way was led, as it has so often been, by private individuals and voluntary associations. 
 Pioneers such as Octavia Hill showed what could be done in altering and repairing sub-standard property and in new methods of housing management and rent collection. 
 Others such as George Cadbury, who initiated Bournville Village in 1897, and Joseph Rowntree who started New Earswick Village, York, in 1904, experimented in creating model communities of houses built at prices which would enable them to be let at rents within the reach of working-class incomes. 
 It was an important principle that these housing schemes should pay their way. 
 In Joseph Rowntree's words, this ensured &bquo;that residents should not be placed in the position of being recipients of a bounty&equo;. 
 Octavia Hill, too, adopted the principle that her housing ventures must be self-supporting, and that the  tenants should pay an economic rent; she maintained that rate-aided housing might be a danger to poorer tenants, who would be in the position of having to contribute through the rates to council housing, when they could scarcely afford the rent for their own inferior accommodation. 
 Bournville and New Earswick were followed by other estates put up by Industrial Housing Associations such as Lever Brothers at Port Sunlight, and many more recent ones, to the present number of about fifty-four. 
 The Housing Associations or Public Utility Societies took many forms and have prospered to this day. 
 There are the Old People's Associations, about 100 of them, which do not pay dividends and, therefore, function as charitable institutions; also counted as charities are the Housing Trusts, such as the Peabody, Astor, Guinness, Lewis and Sutton Trusts, which started to build large blocks of flats in industrial areas at an early date. 
 Then there were the Garden City Trusts, such as Welwyn, Hampstead and Letchworth. 
 These pay a limited dividend and provide a variety of dwellings. 
 The various types of Housing Associations continued to grow after the 1914&ndash;18 war, and under the Acts of 1930, 1936 and 1949 they became eligible for subsidies under certain conditions. 
 The Inter-war Years 
 After the 1914 war the building industry was completely run down and the nation's building capacity was almost non-existent. 
 When Lord Addison was made Minister of Health he concentrated entirely on methods of financing council housing, and under the ill-conceived Housing and Town Planning Act of 1919 he guaranteed local authorities all losses over that covered by a penny rate. 
 The money was raised on long term, mainly for forty years, and carried a high rate of interest. 
 The annual payments in 1934 were about &pound;6and3/4; millions. 
 But the worst effect of this Act was its inflationary tendency. 
 The local authorities had little encouragement to economise, and housing costs rose steeply. 
 In August, 1920, the average cost of a local authority house was &pound;930, about two and a half times as much as before the war. 
 Mr Neville Chamberlain, in his Housing Act of 1923, changed the subsidy arrangement to one by which the Government undertook to give a definite and limited contribution of &pound;6 per annum per house for a period of twenty years. 
 The grants applied to houses both for letting and selling, and the local authorities were empowered also to give help to private builders. 
 The Chamberlain Act also provided for subsidising slum clearance schemes. 
 The Acts passed by Labour Governments, the Wheatley Act (1924)  and the Greenwood Act (1930) to assist local authorities, were both used very extensively by subsequent Conservative and National Governments. 
 The National Government's Housing (Financial Provisions) Act, 1933, by confining subsidies to those for slum clearance, provided the local authorities with an increased stimulus to clear away the slums. 
 For the first time a mathematical definition of overcrowding was given by the National Government in their Act of 1935, and a determined attack was made on this evil. 
 As a result the average number of people in a house, which was 4.0 in 1931, was reduced to 3.5 by 1939. 
 The basic Conservative policy between the wars was to encourage the speedy building of houses at low cost by every means and through every agency. 
 The building of houses was not put into the hands of any one authority or any one agency. 
 Local authorities, housing societies, private builders, all were encouraged to build or convert property, either to let or to sell. 
 By encouraging the private builder to build houses at low cost to be let or sold, houses were provided at the least cost to the community. 
 These operations were largely financed by the building societies, at a very low rate of interest. 
 Modernisation and repair of rural cottages were also made possible by grants. 
 As a result of the stimulus given by Governments, mostly Conservative, to the building of small houses, and the free play of competition in the building industry, costs fell greatly, till the average cost of a council house in 1939 was &pound;380, instead of &pound;930 in 1920. 
 The results of this policy were remarkable. 
 Ninety per cent of the houses built in the inter-war period were of low rateable value, not exceeding &pound;26 (&pound;35 in Greater London). 
 During 1938 and 1939 slum-dwellers were being rehoused at the rate of 1,000 a day. 
 In the five years 1934 &mdash; 8 an average total of 335,000 houses was built each year in Great Britain. 
 In 1938 the total was over 360,000. 
 The present 
 We do not condone the bad quality and deplorable appearance of some of the speculative building between the wars, nor the lack of physical planning and the wasteful development of land (often good farming land); we shall have more to say about this later in the chapter. 
 But Mr Bevan's ranting polemics on the subject would perhaps sound better in the mouth of a Minister of Health who was getting enough houses built. 
 We must now examine his record. 
 In the five years up to the end of April, 1950, the post-war housing programme had provided 686,018 permanent houses and flats in Great Britain. 
 To this must be added the 157,000 temporary houses (the provision of temporary houses has now come to an end), the  repair of war-damaged property, and the use of huts and service camps. 
 For the month of April, 1950, the output of permanent houses and flats was under fifteen thousand. 
 In his Budget speech in April, 1950, the Chancellor of the Exchequer announced that &bquo;for the three years 1950&ndash;2 we have decided that the programme for Great Britain should be at the completion rate of 200,000 houses a year&equo;. 
 It so happens that this rate is exactly the output of the building industry, averaged over the previous three years. 
 In fact the &bquo;decision&equo; is not a decision at all, but an acceptance of things as they are. 
 Output of New Houses 
 The building industry has today an appreciably larger number of men at work than in the years immediately before 1939, though probably rather a smaller percentage of the total are building new houses. 
 Yet the output is little over half what it was in the last five years before 1939. 
 Even when allowance is made for a certain diversion of effort from new house-building to repair, and for the possibility that the average size of the houses built in 1947&ndash;9 is slightly above that of those built in 1934&ndash;8, the contrast remains startling. 
 If the production of houses could regain the level of the 1930s, the rate at which overcrowding, sharing, and sub-standard houses could be eliminated would clearly be greatly accelerated. 
 The important work of slum clearance has been virtually at a standstill since 1939, only individual houses having been demolished, apart from an area in London intended as a showpiece for the Festival of Britain. 
 Although there is no survey which would give the extent of overcrowding and involuntary sharing, the evidence of the local authority waiting lists and of everyone's personal experience shows it to be very great. 
 These conditions touch on many aspects of our national life: health threatened by overcrowded and insanitary homes; education retarded when children have no room in which to do homework, or arrive tired at school after sleeping in a room with several others; marriages broken up through the strain of sharing a home or making do in cramped and uncomfortable quarters; Borstal institutions, remand homes and approved schools filled by the products of an unhappy home life. 
 A home of the right size and in the right place and at the right rent is everybody's first need. 
 Less would need to be spent on the other social services if housing conditions were drastically improved. 
 Nothing short of absolute impossibility ought to prevent those measures from being taken which will as soon as possible restore the  &mdash; pre-war productivity of the building industry in new houses. 
 There is no such impossibility. 
 Alleged Limiting Factors 
 At various times three different factors have been alleged to justify the limitation of the production of houses: the &bquo;capital investment programme&equo;; labour; and materials, especially timber. 
 None will withstand logical examination. 
 The capital investment programme is, or rather purports to be, a plan for the employment of available resources of manpower and materials. 
 If more output is obtained from the same manpower &mdash; which it is here contended could and should happen &mdash; then the allocation of resources so far as manpower is concerned will be unaffected. 
 There remains, therefore, only the factor of materials. 
 Home-produced building materials, such as bricks and other refractories, adjust themselves to the prospective demand indicated by the numbers of houses contracted for and begun. 
 Capital equipment (except in expanding lines like cement) and, to a large extent, labour employed, remain constant whether or not producing at full capacity. 
 Generally speaking, the home materials industry could support a greatly expanded building programme without an appreciable increase of labour or capital. 
 A commentary on the effect of Government planning in the last few years is found in the recent report of the Working Party on the Building Industry: &bquo;The producers of building materials&hellip; found that their assessment of the demand for their goods was liable to be upset by sudden changes of policy which they could not possibly foresee.&equo; 
 There remain finally the imported materials, of which timber alone is alleged to be a real limitation. 
 The price at which timber for building is bought has been higher than it need be and the amount  much smaller for two reasons: Government buying and Government decisions. 
 Both must be changed at once. 
 With an average of nine months' notice, the timber trade &mdash; buying on its own responsibility &mdash; could procure, at a lower average price per standard than is being paid at present, enough timber for all the houses that the building industry can build. 
 As long as import licensing continues, the requisite permits to import from dollar sources (Canada) should, if necessary, be given. 
 It is not generally realised what a tiny percentage of our current dollar bill would be sufficient to buy another 100,000 houses' worth of dollar timber. 
 Dollar expenditure on tobacco alone is at present ten times that on timber. 
 Mass production 
 All turns, therefore, upon restoring the output of the house-building industry as soon as possible to at least its pre-war productivity. 
 How is this to be done. 
 The answer lies in a comparison between the conditions under which it worked before the war and works now. 
 Now, nearly the whole output of houses is built under contract to local authorities and the remainder &mdash; between a tenth and a fifth of the whole &mdash; are built by licence to individual order. 
 Before the war the preponderant output was produced in mass for a prospective demand. 
 At the ruling prices fixed in a market determined by competition to meet this demand, the local authorities placed their contracts for estates to be built for slum clearance and relief of overcrowding. 
 The contrast, as nearly as the character of the house-building industry admits of the comparison, is that between mass-production and individual work, and shows itself alike in cost and output. 
 Under &bquo;mass-production&equo; conditions the industry was obliged to keep its labour-teams steadily employed, moving in a planned succession from one undertaking to another, and progressively brought down its costs to reach an ever-widening circle of demand for homes to buy or rent at economic figures. 
 Council building reaped the benefit of the price set by private enterprise. 
 The building materials industry geared itself to meet the steady predictable demand of the house-building industry, thus eliminating one of the chief impediments to the output of houses.  
 If the conditions of the 1930s can be reproduced, the same effects will follow from the same causes. 
 Our task is to bring back the mass-production element into the house-building industry, which can be done only by enabling it largely to work on its own authority for a prospective demand &mdash; by &bquo;letting the dog see the rabbit&equo;. 
 Two main changes are indispensable to this end: the complete or virtually complete abolition of the licensing system, and a drastic alteration of the principles of the Town and Country Planning Act, 1947. 
 Licensing 
 As long as the volume of work undertaken by house-building firms is dependent either upon local authority contracts or upon the doling out at yearly or half-yearly intervals of a meagre number of individual licences, so long will increased productivity, and the gearing to it of the output of the building materials industry, be impossible. 
 It is a mistake to suppose that abolition of the licensing system would now mean an excessive number of houses started, or a soaring of prices, or the cessation of council house building. 
 The builder will not start more houses than he can reasonably be sure of completing in an economically short period of time, nor at a price at which he will be unable to dispose of them. 
 So far from sending prices up, the abolition of licensing would immediately bring down the market price of existing houses and would in a short time begin to make an impression on the costs of new ones; for the pressure of demand for new houses at a cost of nearly &pound;2,000 apiece for a council-type is, in our opinion, very limited. 
 There is no objection to retaining an upper limit on size, though in practice people desiring large houses would either purchase old ones or wait until building costs fall. 
 Nor, again, would local authorities be prevented from continuing to build at something like the present rate &mdash; though (as will presently be shown) for different purposes. 
 The contractors who mainly tender for local authority contracts would continue to do so, just as in the 1930s, when private building was unrestricted, they built close on 100,000 council houses annually. 
 The local authorities would, on the other hand, be able to take increasing advantage in their contracts of the competitive prices established in the private sector of house-building. 
 Town and Country planning 
 The Town and Country Planning Act, 1947, in its present form offers an insuperable obstacle to competitive private building for a prospective demand. 
 By nationalising the right to use land for a new purpose &mdash; in this case, to build houses on it &mdash; the Act has placed on all building  land a value which is both high (because monopolistic) and arbitrary (because determined not by the market but by the individual, unappealable decisions of the Central Land Board in assessing &bquo;development charge&equo;). 
 Somehow or other, a competitive market value for land for development must be restored. 
 Only thus will land be made available at minimum instead of monopoly prices, and only thus will the would-be developer be enabled to foresee his commitments and calculate his risks &mdash; both essential conditions of &bquo;mass production&equo; in house-building. 
 The central idea of the Town and Country Planning Act was to make possible the control of development without incurring charges for compensation, by the device of nationalising all development rights in advance. 
 We regard nationalisation of the land for all but its existing use (which is what nationalisation of development rights means) as a long step towards the nationalisation of the land itself. 
 It may or may not be true that positive  control of development, the compelling of development to conform to a particular plan determined by the state, is unattainable without nationalisation. 
 But we do not want planning in this sense. 
 We want rather to see the state intervene only to prevent  such use of land as is clearly anti-social or wasteful, while otherwise development is guided and determined by choice and by economic forces. 
 Planning in this latter sense is, in our opinion, perfectly attainable without either nationalisation or an insoluble compensation problem. 
 Briefly, we would prescribe certain categories of development which were prohibitable without compensation, while allowing others to be prohibited subject to full or partial compensation. 
 Whether, or what, compensation accrued would be determined by impartial tribunals, judicial and expert. 
 This method would mean prevention of development which was definitely unsound upon recognised objective standards, and the community would still be able to engage in amenity planning under the salutary control of paying for any economic value destroyed. 
 It would be associated with exclusive powers to planning authorities to buy, redevelop and resell areas of &bquo;obsolete or unsatisfactory development&equo;. 
 We believe that a Town and Country Planning measure on the lines indicated would give planning authorities all the scope which they need and which the 1932 Act failed to give them.  
 Private Building 
 The re-creation of a large and expanding sector for private house-building, in the manner outlined above, would yield valuable byproducts. 
 There are, no doubt, many modern methods of construction, including far-reaching standardisation and various forms of prefabrication, which, developed and applied over years, would produce permanent and substantial economies. 
 The building industry, given an open field, competing for purchasers and paying a competitive price for its materials, will automatically be stimulated to invest in developing these modern methods, knowing that the reward of successful enterprise will in due course be reaped. 
 Government assistance is not only unnecessary, but positively harmful. 
 Again, those elements of the house-building industry, both firms and individuals, which are at present to an alarming extent drifting into jobbing and repair work on account of the difficulty of obtaining licences, will find their way back into the housing field, and the existing danger of skilled house-building teams being broken up and not replaced will be avoided. 
 When a considerable proportion of the industry is working competitively for the market, the inducement to employees and employers to introduce and operate incentive schemes will be greatly strengthened. 
 Experience in the past two and a half years has shown both the general effectiveness of such schemes and the need for a much wider extension of them. 
 Finally, in location, size and amenities, the private builder (including to a large degree the housing association) necessarily builds to suit his customers and thus provides an index of demand. 
 The distortions which occur under a system of all but exclusively local authority house-building &mdash; the tendency to conform to the past rather than the future location of population (with consequent immobilisation of labour), the wrong proportion of houses of different sizes, and the provision of more amenities than those for which tenants are prepared to pay the economic price &mdash; these will naturally correct themselves when private building is restored. 
 To combat the opposite extreme of jerry-building, we would make membership of the Housebuilders' Registration Council's register compulsory upon all contractors for local authority houses, with a view to rendering the building industry eventually an industry subject throughout to publicly-approved standards.  
 Social policy 
 So far from disabling local authorities from pursuing a social policy and achieving the two great purposes of subsidised housing, 
 (a) 
 the abatement of overcrowding or undesirable sharing, when associated with economic need; and 
 (b) 
 the clearance of slum areas, 
 the abolition of licensing and the restoration of private building would again set them free to perform these tasks. 
 At present, local authorities are building not for the poorest, nor for the slum-dweller, but mainly for those better off. 
 While the really poor live in privately-owned, deteriorating homes &mdash; and about 90 per cent of the houses in Britain are still privately-owned &mdash; the new council houses are occupied by those who will pay up to twice or three times as much in rent, even after allowing for a subsidy of at least 8s. 6d. a week, and often far more, out of the general rates and taxes. 
 The vast waiting lists of the local authorities, as well as the existing local authority houses, contain large numbers of families who, with private enterprise building again at the rate and real cost of the 1930s, would be both able and willing to accommodate themselves at economic rents or prices. 
 There is no need to apply a means test to applicants for council houses when the building industry has been freed: the lists and the tenancies will &bquo;sort themselves out&equo;. 
 At the earliest moment, local authorities should be required to submit a building programme for five or ten years to come, based upon a systematic plan to deal with slums and with acute overcrowding. 
 As the volume of private building increases over the two or three years following the proposed changes of policy, local authority housing must as soon as possible be restricted to these objects. 
 This is the logical consequence of bringing the building industry to full productivity; otherwise, the absurd situation is reached that housing, unlike any other normal necessity of life, is something with which a substantial proportion of the population can never be provided at a decent standard without subsidy. 
 The conclusion of the policy being pursued at present is that eventually everybody will be subsidising nearly everybody's housing. 
 It would be wrong not to draw attention to the grave problem which is being created for the future by the production of large  numbers of council houses at such rents that, if a fall occurs in building cost, difficulty will be experienced in letting them, despite the subsidy. 
 It seems that when this crisis breaks, drastic policies of rent-pooling and of sale may be necessary to extricate local authorities from their financial difficulties. 
 Rent Policy 
 We have referred to council rents, but, of course, these are the only ones which are not frozen by the Rent Restrictions Acts. 
 No housing policy can be sound which does not deal courageously with rent restriction as a whole. 
 In its present form, rent restriction is causing an appalling wastage of existing accommodation and condemning millions of families to ever-worsening conditions, by restricting rents to levels which render the repair and maintenance of premises impossible. 
 The general lines of reform must be to permit increases on prewar standard rents which will cover maintenance costs with a certain allowance for arrears; but these costs should be certified by the relevant local authority and only collectable upon that authority's certificate that the appropriate standard of maintenance has been attained. 
 As soon as possible afterwards, the existing legal obligations on landlords in regard to repair and maintenance should be put into full force again. 
 The system of rent tribunals for furnished and post-1939 unfurnished houses is in our opinion a disgrace to British justice. 
 A Court of Appeal from their decisions must be immediately provided. 
 The whole arbitrary system itself, which was a temporary measure of protection for tenants in a period of acute post-war scarcity, should be dispensed with as soon as the output of the house-building industry has regained a satisfactory level. 
 This measure of reform in rent restriction will save hundreds of thousands of homes from becoming slums. 
 By bringing restricted, council and &bquo;free&equo; rents closer together, it will also facilitate exchanges. 
 This will liberate an undoubtedly large reservoir of housing space at present withheld from full use by sitting tenants whom rent restriction prevents from moving. 
 Conclusion 
 It is abundantly clear that the homeless have nothing to hope for from the socialist Government, which promised them so much in 1945 and so little in 1950. 
 In the intervening five years the socialists have allowed the national stock of houses to deteriorate gravely, have  allowed the building industry to drift into an inefficient and wholly artificial pattern, and have done their best to disorganise the building materials industries. 
 They have created slums, not cleared them. 
 We believe that a Conservative Government, putting the provision of homes above the sanctity of unpractical doctrines, could stimulate a rate of building which would rise rapidly year by year. 
 But we recognise that, in addition to a much higher rate of new building, additional emergency measures are needed to reduce the tragic number of homeless people. 
 For example, it cannot be right that the Government should retain as offices private houses and blocks of flats while homeless families are dossed down in imperfectly converted workhouses, or forced to &bquo;squat&equo; in Nissen huts. 
 Similarly, it would seem that an excessive amount of expensive building work is being put into palatial Government offices all over the country. 
 We are as anxious as anyone to provide good working conditions for public servants; but would the public servants themselves honestly contend that working conditions during eight hours of the day should, in the present emergency, take priority over the living conditions of mothers and children for the whole twenty-four hours? 
 We can scarcely believe it. 
 At present, too many of the sacrifices are being borne by those who, for the sake of posterity, should least be called upon to make them.  
 &bquo;THE WELFARE STATE&equo; Brighton Speech, 12 October 1961 
 The Roman poet says, &bquo; dutce est desipere in loco &equo;, &bquo;an opportunity for indiscretion is sometimes pleasant&equo;. 
 If the doctrine of collective responsibility can never quite be forgotten or discarded, at least it weighs most lightly on the wearer in the bracing, not to say rarefied, intellectual atmosphere of the CPC. 
 Therefore I do not see why tonight I might not occasionally, if the argument should lead that way, be guilty of saying in office some of the things which I have said out of office. 
 The Plowden Report on Control of Public Expenditure  contained, amongst other nuggets of wisdom, the following sentence which I should like to take as my starting-point: &bquo;The social changes of the last fifteen years have altered the incidence of hardship, so that there now may well be excessive social services for some purposes and inadequate ones for others.&equo; 
 I should have thought that, in the abstract, no one was likely to quarrel with that statement. 
 Indeed, the reference to &bquo;the social changes of the last fifteen  years&equo; makes it an understatement: for there is not a single social service today which was not framed more than fifteen years ago. 
 The conception of all of them, in more or less their present form, dates from the social revolution of 1942 to 1944. 
 Yes, you heard me correctly: I said 1942 to 1944. 
 The general election of 1945 was in some ways only a consequential recognition of the revolution which took place under, and inside, the Coalition Government at the height of World War II, and was announced to the outside world by a cloud of White Papers &mdash; on planning, social insurance, employment, a national health service &mdash; much as the election of a new Pope is first evinced by the smoke from the burning ballot papers. 
 But not only does the framing of the existing social services date back twenty years already. 
 The conditions in the light of which those services were then framed were the conditions of the inter-war years &mdash; the only available peacetime background for the wartime revolutionaries to use. 
 If the Plowden Committee had referred therefore to &bquo;the social changes of the last thirty  years&equo; instead of fifteen, they would have been guilty of no inaccuracy. 
 Those thirty years span some of the sharpest changes of trend in modern history, from persistent deflation, for instance, to persistent inflation, or from unemployment  averaging 10 per cent to unemployment averaging 2 per cent, as well as a rise of at least one-third in national income per head. 
 It is therefore wildly unlikely that the Plowden Committee's assertion should not be well founded, that &bquo;there now may well be excessive social services for some purposes&equo;. 
 It is also quite likely that there is truth in the other half of their assertion, which sounds as though it were consequential, but really is a quite unconnected proposition, namely, that there now may well be inadequate social services for other purposes. 
 However, without for the moment looking at the two halves separately, I imagine everyone would be prepared to accept the proposition in theory . 
 In theory, too, the Plowden Committee left it. 
 They did not &mdash; and it was admittedly no part of their business to do so &mdash; inform us for which purposes the existing social services are &bquo;excessive&equo;; and it may be observed that other commentators, political and non-political, though they are frequently willing to indicate social services which in their opinion are &bquo;inadequate&equo;, are extremely taciturn when it comes to illustrating the more obvious half of the truism with specific examples. 
 Admittedly the CPC itself, in its 1958 symposium on The Future of the Welfare State , and more recently the Bow Group too have ventured to step upon the tail of this coat. 
 But these are exceptions which prove the rule. 
 Inertia and Institutionalisation 
 Acceptance of a proposition in principle and rejection of it in practice is a perfectly normal human attitude, as common outside politics as inside. 
 It is, I suppose, one manifestation of man's indomitable urge to &bquo;have it both ways at once&equo;. 
 None the less an examination of the special reasons why the Plowden proposition is accepted as a truism in general but treated as an abominable heresy in particular may be worthwhile. 
 The most obvious of these reasons are political ones, in the pure, party, vote-catching sense of that term. 
 In politics it is more blessed not to take than to give. 
 The termination of a benefit or a payment or a service is a sharp, specific assault upon identifiable individuals; it gives political opponents something solid to talk about; they can actually produce the bodies and point to the wounds. 
 By contrast, the failure to introduce new benefits, payments or services is a much blunter grievance: political opponents have only something hypothetical to discuss; individual electors do not easily identify themselves with the deprived. 
 As Pericles told the Athenians in the Funeral Speech: &bquo;It is not the lack of what we have never experienced, but the deprivation of what we are accustomed to, that we feel and regret.&equo; 
 Ministers of Health would have incurred little or no extra  criticism if they had failed to provide the services which the &pound;25 million yielded by the prescription charges have made possible; what criticism there was, would have been diffused over a hundred objects and none of it would have made a distinct impression on the mind of the electorate. 
 Yet the utility of those services to the public is out of all proportion greater than the continuation of prescriptions free or at one shilling each would have been. 
 Moreover, while the minus  is always identifiable and indisputable, the plus  is often not identifiable separately or not identifiable as a consequence of the minus . 
 No one, for example, can take hold of twenty-five million pounds' worth of health services and say that these, and these precisely, are owed to the fact of a prescription charge: you cannot point to the beds, the treatments, the nurses and demonstrate that these would not individually have been provided, however undeniable the fact may be in general. 
 Even if the equation could be established, the beneficiaries are not the same or do not see themselves as the same: the patients paying two shillings for their bottles of medicine do not identify themselves with the patients admitted to hospital sooner or treated more efficiently. 
 Similarly the citizen as a taxpayer does not identify himself &mdash; and indeed is only partially identical in fact &mdash; with the citizen as a recipient of tax-financed benefits. 
 Finally, there is the fact of human nature summed up in the saying, &bquo;There's no gratitude in politics.&equo; 
 Even if there were equal numbers of equally identifiable gainers and losers, the political resentment of the losers would outweigh the political gratitude of the gainers. 
 When an addition is made to the system of state-provided services, it is only made because there is a general opinion that the time is ripe for it and that such provision is &bquo;only right&equo;. 
 The beneficiaries thus regard themselves as having received no more than their due, to which they were entitled anyhow, while those whose benefits are discontinued regard themselves as cheated of what they had a right to and had been encouraged to expect. 
 Politically, therefore, the inducements to continue what the Plowden Committee call &bquo;excessive social services&equo; are much stronger than the inducements to discontinue them or to supplement any which may happen to be &bquo;inadequate&equo;. 
 But it would be a cynical mistake to limit the forces of inertia to these narrowly political ones. 
 It is the characteristic of social services that they become rapidly and strongly institutionalised. 
 True, all acts of government policy create a presumption that they will remain in force and are an invitation to the citizen to adapt his private behaviour accordingly; but the tendency of decisions in the social service field to create vested interests is of a quite peculiar order. 
 Take, by way of comparison,  the fiscal system: even here, as in all human affairs, it is easier to leave things alone than to alter them. 
 But look at the effective freedom which a Chancellor of the Exchequer possesses to make major alterations over a comparatively short span of time in the methods by which a given amount of revenue is raised. 
 Surtax, profits tax, fuel tax &mdash; none of them, not even Schedule A of the income tax, has achieved the independent existence and power of survival which belongs to an institution. 
 The institutionalisation of the social services is an interesting study in its own right, especially for Tories, who are the connoisseurs of institutions, and I should like to offer some case histories. 
 Subsidised Housing 
 I will begin with what I always think is the queerest of the social services, and the one with the strangest story &mdash; subsidised housing. 
 This was the social service which happened by accident. 
 The story is well known, but always worth retelling. 
 At the end of the First World War it was confidently and almost universally assumed that after a short time money would be back to its pre-war value and market prices (including market rents) to their pre-war levels. 
 Meanwhile, as a very temporary measure, wartime rent restriction was retained and, equally as a very temporary measure, since new houses would not be built to let commercially in these circumstances, a subsidy was introduced to bridge the gap &mdash; between pre-war and post-war rents. 
 We know the sequel. 
 Pre-war values never did come back; rent restriction never did cease to be considered necessary, even after the building of three or four million new houses; subsidies never were discontinued. 
 Instead, they became an institution, and a vested interest. 
 Mankind has a powerful desire to rationalise its actions; and when people found themselves ten, twenty years after the First World War still paying housing subsidies, this desire to rationalise, and perhaps a natural sense of shame, forbade them to recognise that they were doing so merely out of unwillingness to recognise that 1914 prices and money values had gone for ever. 
 So it began to be asserted that this was a social service, and that there was something inherently reasonable and even laudable about subsidising the price of rented house-room &mdash; though how it could be reasonable or laudable to reduce by arbitrary and locally varying amounts the rents of an arbitrarily selected minority of families who have no common economic or other characteristic, is something which no one to this day has attempted to explain. 
 It is as if we were to pay family allowances to every third family on a different scale in each place. 
 The natural history of the upas tree of housing as a social service,  growing from the twin roots of rent restriction and indiscriminate subsidy, would be a fascinating subject for a long book. 
 At each stage the vested interests &mdash; of protected tenants, of council tenants, and of local and national politicians &mdash; in the system, grew stronger and more complex, so that the wonder is not that it lived so long but that two men were found at last, in Duncan Sandys and Henry Brooke, of sufficient courage and determination to lay the axe to the roots and start hewing a way back to sanity. 
 If anyone thinks my language exaggerated or highly coloured &mdash; and such there might well be, considering that no one here under pensionable age can have any recollection of a world without rent restriction or subsidised rents &mdash; let him recall another upas tree which we only managed to cut down in the nick of time ten years ago. 
 It was growing from the twin roots of controlled food prices and food subsidies. 
 Perhaps you have forgotten about the food subsidies? 
 Sir Stafford Cripps in 1950 pegged them at &pound;410 million. 
 (But after all he also pegged the cost of the National Health Service at &pound;400 million!) 
 If the incoming Conservative Government had not swept them away at once it would today seem no less difficult to abolish the &bquo;social service, of subsidised food than the &bquo;social service&equo; of subsidised housing. 
 Luckily we killed it before it became a full-blown institution and today no one seriously expects that food, or clothing, or even that overriding necessity, a television set, should be subsidised for all consumers, still less for a minority. 
 Otherwise, in the production and distribution of food we should have all the corresponding phenomena to those we actually have in housing: ten million family budgets based on artificially low rents; the machinery of house production divided sharply into two, councils building to rent, companies building to sell; the price of rented house-room a voting issue in local and parliamentary elections. 
 In short, the ration book would have become a national institution like the council house. 
 As I said, housing is perhaps the extreme instance of irrationality among all the social services; each has its own peculiar form of institutionalisation. 
 Health Service and Education 
 The National Health Service was created by nationalising the hospitals and placing comprehensive state contracts for medical, dental and ophthalmic services. 
 The new structure replaced the previously existing variety of organisations through which medical care had been financed: national health insurance, a multiplicity of forms of private insurance, local government finance, private contracts and payments, charity and endowment in all manner of guises. 
 Comparison with  other advanced countries, where medical care is financed in different ways, and with the trends in this country before the National Health Service, suggests that if the forms of organisation which the National Health Service replaced had continued and developed, the quantity, quality and distribution of medical care here today would not be very substantially different from what it is under the National Health Service. 
 This does not mean, however, that it is practicable to switch out of this system again. 
 The old channels through which the relevant resources flowed have dried up or been dug up. 
 Without underestimating the possibility that we may still witness some increase of private medical insurance, it would not be realistic to pretend that one can see how an alternative system could now grow up beside, or be substituted for, the channelling of this &pound;1,000 million of the national income through government agencies. 
 Indeed, this institution is self-perpetuating positively, and not only negatively &mdash; not only through inertia, but through activity. 
 When the responsibility for providing medical care is focused and vested in a department of government, all the aspirations to improvement are bound to strengthen the institution. 
 In the hospitals, for example, a Minister of Health who is trying to do his duty must aim at increasing the corporate sense, morale and public esteem of the service, because he knows that this will be one of the ways of raising standards. 
 In proportion as he succeeds, the institution itself will be that much more deeply rooted. 
 In this respect the National Health Service is unique among the social services: it is the only instance where the great majority of a specific service is the direct responsibility of an organ of the central government. 
 This makes it very different from education, where only the supervisory responsibility is central, while direct responsibility rests with between one and two hundred executive bodies, deriving their authority from a local electorate. 
 Nor is the public education system historically the product of an act of nationalisation: it is the slow outcome of the fostering of voluntary, as well as the planting of state, establishments. 
 Moreover, the commitment of the state to provide education is still quantitatively controlled, in a sense in which the commitment of the National Health Service to provide medical care is not: for example, the state fixes a compulsory period of school attendance, defines the standards of provision in schools within the system, and indicates the stages and branches in which further commitments will be accepted. 
 It should perhaps be added that, although neither the National Health Service nor the education system is exclusive in the sense of prohibiting private provision, the prestige and importance of independent provision is immensely greater in the field of education than in that of health.  
 Pension Expectations 
 An interesting example of a different type of social service institution is that concerned with the provision of livelihood for those unable to earn by reason of sickness, disablement, lack of work, or above all, age. 
 Provision for the subsistence of those no longer working has always been made by the community. 
 It is the organisation for collecting and distributing that provision which changes. 
 The history of state insurance and assistance from the early years of this century is one in which social and demographic changes intertwine strangely with political theories and motives. 
 Socially and demographically the period has been dominated by two factors &mdash; the fall in the size of families and the increase in the expectation of survival to retirement, the effects of which are still far from having exhausted themselves. 
 These changes stimulated the search for some substitute for the individual proof of need or &bquo;means test&equo;. 
 In very broad outline, the first stage (1908) was to pay, subject to means, a pension well below subsistence which would supplement income from other sources. 
 The next stage (1925) was to increase the pension but make it conditional on having paid certain contributions, which were compulsory below a given income. 
 The third stage (1946) was to increase the pension to what was intended to be subsistence level, but render it conditional on retirement and make contribution compulsory for virtually all. 
 Thus, leaving the graduated scheme out of account for a moment, the position we have reached today is that the state pays to all retired persons, without regard to means, a pension roughly of subsistence value. 
 It finances these pensions from a flat-rate weekly poll tax, called a contribution, and a levy on employers per head of employee, with some supplement from general taxation. 
 The amount of the pension is not related actuarial to the sums which each recipient has actually paid in contribution; but the right to receive it is treated as flowing from the possession of a contribution record, and indeed the pension rates are represented as related to the contribution rates, assuming contribution over a full working life. 
 In this social service, therefore, the institutional element consists not in the great organisation over which John Boyd-Carpenter presides, with its large and efficient staff and its famous calculating machine at Newcastle. 
 It consists in the expectation on the part of the whole population that they will receive from the state on retirement a pension sufficient for subsistence, whatever their income. 
 They have been indoctrinated for nearly forty years with the belief that their right to this pension does not arise simply out of a public decision to pay it but is a right vested in the individual by virtue of certain payments made by him, and analogous to what would be his  entitlement under a contract with an insurance company. 
 This expectation has rather been confirmed than otherwise by the superimposition in the last two years of an element of graduation in the contribution, the additional yield of which for many years to come will mainly help to finance the standard pension but which creates a right to additions to it which will gradually build up over the next forty years on an actuarial basis. 
 Meanwhile, assisted and deliberately encouraged by various tax remissions, an increasing number of people are covered, to an increasing extent, by non-state pension schemes, many of which provide benefits well above subsistence. 
 A priori it might have seemed logical that as these increase and spread, they would render the state pension superfluous and enable the system of compulsory redistribution which finances it to be discontinued progressively. 
 In practice, the state scheme contributions pre-empt a slice of incomes which would otherwise be available for saving through pension schemes, and thus to that extent would be expected to slow down the growth of non-state provision. 
 The great obstacle, however, to a withering away of the state pension is the fact that, although in economic reality current pensions are paid from current contributions and other taxes, the state pension scheme has been institutionalised as a structure of vested rights or expectations stretching forward over half a century. 
 Compared with the social services we have been examining, the residue present the institutional problem only in a comparatively mild form. 
 Even the family allowances, though based in their present form upon the experience and conditions of the inter-war years &mdash; when Seebohm Rowntree's surveys in York suggested that one male in four earned less than was necessary to maintain a man, wife and two children above the poverty line &mdash; consist of a simple system of payments and enter into budgetary habits and expectations no more and no less than the fiscal allowances, of which I once suggested to a CPC conference they might be regarded as an extension. 
 Coping with Crime 
 So let us turn from the obstacles to applying in practice the theoretical truism in the first proposition of the Plowden Committee &mdash; that &bquo;there may now well be excessive social services for some purposes&equo; &mdash; and consider the second proposition &mdash; that there may now well be &bquo;inadequate ones for others&equo;. 
 If we have blind spots, in what sectors will they lie? 
 What social services ought this generation to be constructing which the next or next but one will erect when the need for them is already yielding place to others? 
 Can we catch up, by a little clairvoyance, on the persistent tendency of state provision to come thirty  years late? 
 I will offer two guesses, in as many words &mdash; crime and age. 
 Ten years ago I remember I used to think that it was our mental hospitals which later generations would regard as the most staggering and incomprehensible blind spot of our time, on which they would look back as we do upon the generations which burnt witches or tried by ordeal. 
 Thanks mainly to two or three key discoveries in the field of medical science, we now have it in our power and, I hope and believe, in our will, to expunge this blind spot. 
 Treatment of the delinquent claims today the place which treatment of the lunatic but lately occupied, as a gross example of society's inadequacy to cope with its members. 
 I am not referring to the debate on methods: the disagreements of the floggers and anti-floggers are dwarfed by the appalling facts of prison provision and the deficiencies of our penal system. 
 It may not be a popular view, but I would dare to say that prisons are our most important, and also our most deficient, social service. 
 Here, whatever else is obscure, the need for a much greater commitment of resources is indisputable: without, for example, a massive renewal and expansion of physical provision, men and methods will not avail, though men are the essence of the service and methods cry out for more and more exploration. 
 New methods will come, no doubt, with the fruition of that research which the Home Secretary has urged and supported; but we cannot even claim to be using existing methods, when 7,550 prisoners are sleeping tonight three in a cell, and when policies which, but for the war, would have been on the statute book in 1939, and have already been on the statute book for half a generation, have hardly begun to be carried into effect for lack of premises. 
 Responsibility for the Old 
 It the maintenance of law and the management of delinquency are fundamental to any ordered society, responsibility for the old is scarcely less so. 
 It seems as certain as anything can be that the absolute numbers of the old, and for a long time also their number relative to the whole population, will be far higher in future than anything experienced in the past. 
 This large and increasing number of old, and very old, people will contain a high proportion of individuals who have either no family setting and connections, or at any rate none that is of practical relevance to their way of life. 
 The altered structure of society &mdash; the small family size, the small dwelling unit, the substitution of mechanical aids for domestic service &mdash; has contributed as much as the  mere increased expectation of survival to this striking phenomenon of a large and increasing number of aged and isolated individuals. 
 The problem which it presents is not primarily a financial one, but a physical one. 
 It is not a problem which is solved, or even touched, by another 10s. or &pound;1, or &pound;2, on the pension. 
 It is the problem of how the necessary support, in a physical and environmental sense, which in different circumstances the old would obtain in the setting of a family or a closely-knit village community, can be available to these millions of ageing individuals isolated in a modern industrial society. 
 I mean no disrespect to the geriatric branch of the hospital service nor to the domiciliary services or the rapidly increasing old people's houses and homes provided by local housing, health and welfare authorities when I say that I believe we are still groping and fumbling with this problem &mdash; all of us, social scientists and politicians alike. 
 I also believe that the size of it and the rate at which it is growing indicates the use of the central organising function of the state (which is one characteristic of a social service). 
 At the same time I doubt whether the state alone can solve it. 
 Of course, the problem can be expressed in economic terms &mdash; the maintenance of a given number of aged people in the conditions of modern society is relatively more costly than in the past: in accommodation, in service, and in attention &mdash; but, as I say, money benefits and subsidies are not the heart of the matter. 
 The heart of the matter is the provision of a physical and social environment through which the members of society may gradually withdraw from it as securely and as worthily as they enter it through the environment of home and education. 
 It is in this form that I would express the challenge of the social and medical revolution which has given rise to the modern problem of old age. 
 I question whether we have yet found the secret. 
 The more I see of provision for the old, the more irresistibly a thought rises in my mind, which, however hesitantly, I will try to express. 
 It seems to me that it lacks somehow a soul or a purpose. 
 As more and more survive and are kept alive beyond the utmost limit of working life, the economic or social function of the individual provides less and less of a motive or framework for his survival; and when we ask Why? we find ourselves thrown back upon purpose in a sense which is neither economic nor social nor even secular. 
 We are brought face to face with the question, &bquo;What is the purpose of human life itself?&equo; 
 The monastic rule of the Middle Ages expressed an answer to this question. 
 &bquo;The purpose of man,&equo; it declared, &bquo;is to praise God, and this, man's proper work, remains when all else is past or put aside.&equo; 
 The rule was a framework within which this answer to the question could be lived. 
 I am conscious that I speak in parable; but all that vast  organisation and provision which must be made for the old in the coming generation will bring disappointment unless the purpose at the heart of it is one that satisfies. 
 Principles and Practice 
 But I am straying from my theme. 
 Enough if I have shown that if we care to do so, we can illustrate the second as well as the first half of what I may call the Plowden proposition. 
 We see a range of existing social services, entrenched to varying degrees in institutional form, reflecting to varying degrees needs and economic conditions which have passed or are passing away. 
 We see new needs, born of newer economic and social conditions, which call to be met. 
 We recognise that logically this demands a transfer of resources and effort from the former to the latter, that in the words I have so often quoted, some social services are &bquo;excessive&equo; and others &bquo;inadequate&equo; &mdash; that it was bound to be so and that it is so. 
 The question for us, for the Conservative Party, is whether, having seen this, we put the file into the &bquo;Too Difficult&equo; tray and &bquo;pass by on the other side&equo;. 
 I can see the expediency of that course; I can see the expediency of ministers not making addresses which explore this kind of territory and arrive at this kind of conclusion &mdash; except, of course, to the CPC, which is a living protest against the politics of expediency. 
 However, I confess that I do not believe a party, any more than the society which it serves, can fail to suffer if it knowingly allows institutions to fall more and more out of correspondence with contemporary needs. 
 In Britain of the 1960s this challenge of the Welfare State is not isolated: it is but one aspect of the challenge which confronts us throughout the whole political field. 
 The world wants to know if Britain can adjust to the facts of life or will allow old fears, old habits, old prejudices, old prides to weigh down its vitality and eat up its resources. 
 Dare I say, as a once member of One Nation, that the world wants to know if Britain dare make Change its Ally? 
 I don't know the answer, for only the people can give it; but I do know that it is our duty to ask them. 
 The question falls to be posed in different terms in the different fields of policy. 
 Here in the social services, which, in volume of resources involved, represent between one-third and one-half of the activities of the state, the question, it seems to me, cannot be posed by disconnected, spasmodic pluses  and minuses  but by presenting a broad and large conception of the manner in which resources ought to be redeployed to meet modern realities, and this will not be done without soberly assessing but boldly facing the in-built obstacles to that redeployment. 
 This evening I have attempted a contribution to  the work by taking the Plowden propositions and suggesting that if they are true in theory they demand recognition in practice. 
 Perhaps in this operation the CPC can give a lead to the party and the Government. 
 It would not be the first time that it had done so.  
 &bquo;A VIEW OF EDUCATION&equo; 14 DECEMBER 1963 
 I rise to return thanks on behalf of my fellow guests and myself for the honour you have done us, and the pleasure you have given us, by asking us to share in this, your annual occasion. 
 As my own thank-offering I would like to try briefly to express some thoughts on education by which I have long been troubled and to which no place, for reasons which I will show, could be more appropriate than this. 
 One of the great moments in the literature of the world is a passage near the end of the second part of Dante's Divine Comedy . 
 It is, in a sense, the climax of the whole work. 
 The poet has ascended through all the regions of Hell and Purgatory, and now at last, on the threshold of Paradise, comes to his long-expected reunion with Beatrice. 
 Her greeting to him is a speech of rebuke so savage that at first he stands dumb, then bursts into tears, and finally falls insensible. 
 What was the fault that had deserved this punishment? 
 What was the error from which he could only be saved by the apocalyptic vision of the future world itself? 
 It was no more and no less than this: he had deserted the only proper employment of the human mind, theology, to go a-whoring after other studies and other learning. 
 The reproof of Beatrice is not, I conceive, as remote as it might seem from our own world. 
 On the contrary, it reasserts a central truth about education which ever and again we are tempted to forget or ignore, but a truth which we neglect at peril of our immortal soul: that it does matter infinitely what we teach and learn. 
 The silliest and the most sinful of the many heresies of pseudo-democracy is to pretend that all studies and all learning are &bquo;created equal&equo;. 
 They are not. 
 It matters just as much to a person's education what he learns and is taught as it matters to his salvation what he believes. 
 True education does not consist in being taught just anything, any more than true religion consists in believing just anything. 
 This, like most truths, is &bquo;a hard saying&equo;. 
 it does not indeed oblige us to assert that in 1963, unlike 1300, theology is education and all else vanity. 
 It does not even oblige us to assert that nothing but classics, or philosophy, or mathematics, or PPE is education. 
 It does prevent us from assuming that students are being educated because they are at a university, irrespective of what their studies are. 
 It does  prevent us from daring to say that a subject becomes part of education because you teach it in a school, or at a CAT or in a university. 
 There are two aspects to education: one is the content, the subject matter itself; the other is the manner in which, and the purpose with which it is studied. 
 &bquo;All men,&equo; said Aristotle, &bquo;by nature desire to know.&equo; 
 The pursuit of truth, the effort to comprehend, arrange, interpret some aspect or other of the universe we perceive is an activity of humanity which justifies, rewards and motivates itself. 
 The study of something for its own sake, for the sake of knowing, understanding, grasping it and for nothing else, is an essential characteristic of education, lower or higher, though more obviously of higher education. 
 The content of education must therefore be that which men would wish to know for its own sake. 
 The knowledge which men desire for its own sake is never mere information, mere acquisition of separate isolated facts, like trains in a timetable, or careers in Who's Who ? 
 It is knowledge of a kind which relates facts to one another and illuminates, however faintly, a part of the great scene of life. 
 It must therefore be acquired and taught in a way which gives it general significance. 
 These are the tests which determine what is education and what is not. 
 There are some things which no one would wish to know for their own sake, some subjects which have no possibility of being endowed with general significance. 
 In the words of the Robbins Report, &bquo;it is this that furnishes the criterion of what institutions of higher education may properly teach&equo;. 
 Education is not the whole of life and there is much information that men must acquire and many skills they must learn which are no part of education. 
 No doubt people must learn hairdressing; but until the subject crosses into physiology &mdash; and ceases therefore to be hairdressing &mdash; it is not education. 
 No doubt people must study management or business; but until they cross the boundaries of the social or economic sciences &mdash; until the knowledge becomes such as is sought for its own sake and organised to illuminate human life and history &mdash; management and business studies are not education; and then they are management and business studies no longer. 
 We can apply the test to the technical and technological subjects, and not only those, but the professional subjects also; and the boundary line will run now on this side, now on that; but the things that it divides are different in kind, and only on one side of that line lies what we ought to allow to be education. 
 True, education is often also useful in its results &mdash; useful in the sense of promoting the creation of material wealth. 
 It is probably this incidental side-effect of education which has given currency to another widespread heresy of our times: that education is desirable  because it promotes economic growth. 
 The facility with which not only politicians but people who should know better argue for education in the name of economic growth is frightening. 
 Only a day or two ago in The Times , a high academic figure was complaining that &bquo;the nature of the demand for education, at least over the next few years, seems unlikely to correspond with any precision to the national need for more scientists and technologists&equo;. 
 Why on earth should it? 
 &bquo;Considered,&equo; say the Robbins Committee, &bquo;as an investment, there seems a strong presumption in favour of a substantially increased expenditure on higher education,&equo; and they argue that there is a relationship of cause and effect between the education and the productivity of a community. 
 Simply as a proposition this is open to grave doubt. 
 If the citizens of modern London are more productive in a material, measurable sense than those of ancient Athens, it is not because more of them are educated or because they are better educated. 
 The times and places of striking advance in productivity have by no means generally been times and places of educational advance; nor, where they have been, is it clear whether this is cause and effect or, if so, which is cause and which effect. 
 But even if the proposition be true, it could not be the case for more and better education because of the nature of education itself. 
 Education is a good in its own right, something which men desire because they are men, and which they will therefore spend their effort and their riches to procure for themselves and to bestow upon others. 
 Being a good in itself, to provide it is a work of charity, an opus caritatas , which individuals and churches, cities and nations, may vie with one another to do, as they build hospitals or raise temples. 
 If they are rich, they can spend more on it, and will; but there is no calculus which can tell us the optimum amount that we ought to spend on education, any more than on the relief of suffering and the cure of the sick, or on the arts. 
 These things are absolutes and incommensurable. 
 The people who founded the Working Men's College understood all this very well. 
 The working men for whom this institution was created had a thirst for education in a way we can scarcely any longer imagine today. 
 It was not to pass examinations and qualify for better wages, not to raise themselves into a higher social class &mdash; though these are respectable ambitions and no doubt many of those early students felt them &mdash; but to get at knowledge for its own sake because without it their existence would be less worth to them, that the working classes demanded education and got it. 
 This was part of the good life, and they were not to be denied it. 
 To read and write, to borrow books and debate, to study the sciences and learn a foreign  tongue &mdash; all these were so many steps not of economic advancement but of human dignity. 
 All that vast enlargement of educational opportunity which has happened in the century since then and continues to accelerate has not robbed their vision of its truth nor their example of its value. 
 It may serve today as a living protest against the cheapening, the misunderstanding, the betrayal of education which programmes of expansion and popular education policies can so easily conceal. 
 The Working Men's College says today, as it said a hundred years ago: &bquo;We seek no greater good than education; we scorn to justify it save by itself.&equo;  
 &bquo;THE IRRESISTIBLE MARKET&equo; New Society , 6 February 1964 
 Neddy meets again next week. 
 It last met on the 8th of this month. 
 You may remember that on that occasion the employers took the initiative in tabling a number of remarkable propositions about prices and profits. 
 I would like to examine them with you this evening, because they appear to me to contain much more than the permissible percentage of nonsense. 
 A little nonsense now and then is not a bad thing. 
 Where would we politicians be if we were not allowed to talk it sometimes? 
 But nonsense in massive doses, solemnly swallowed by large and representative bodies of men, and commended, without the flicker of an eyelid, to the nation at large, is very dangerous indeed. 
 It soon becomes respectable. 
 Before long no one who aspires to be taken seriously can dare to question it in public. 
 A conspiracy not to &bquo;let on&equo; is tacitly formed among those who know better, and those who do not take their cue from them. 
 Unfortunately nonsense remains, however many people accept or pretend to accept it; and it has a nasty habit of exploding in a nation's face with effects which can be as devastating as those of a nuclear weapon. 
 It is high time, therefore, to promote a test ban on this particular brand before dissemination has gone too far to be reversed. 
 It is indeed high time. 
 Already on the day following Neddy's pronouncement the industrial correspondent of The Times , whom I take as a representative of respectable opinion, was ecstatic with metaphors. 
 The employers' initiative had &bquo;opened the door for a new and fruitful phase in the council's activities&equo;; the unions must now decide &bquo;whether to keep the door open, let it swing, or slam it shut&equo;; the employers' action was &bquo;momentous in itself for British industry&equo;, it was &bquo;nothing less than a confrontation&equo; &mdash; the word had become indispensable for all of us, from French planners to Indonesian terrorists. 
 Let us look then at the propositions which earned these encomia. 
 They are as follows: 
 The employers acknowledged that management should accept responsibility for doing everything possible to keep prices stable or reduce them. 
 The employers acknowledged that, in addition to the force of public opinion, another way to curb prices would be to establish a body (probably  a prices commission) to examine particular prices and report on them publicly. 
 The employers acknowledged that if over a period profits should rise more than incomes, the balance should be redressed by taxation policy. 
 This last was expressed in other words as willingness &bquo;to see the ratio between profits and incomes preserved at a reasonable level by a tax which would become operative upon all industry when a certain figure was exceeded by profits as a whole&equo;. 
 Now, when you find management &mdash; the representatives of enterprise and risk capital &mdash; standing up in public and saying that they have a responsibility to keep prices stable, or lower them, that individual prices ought to be reported on by a commission, and that profits ought to attract special tax penalties if they exceed a certain level, then it is a sign that either the millennium has arrived or else something is going very seriously wrong indeed. 
 I am afraid it is the latter rather than the former. 
 Let me now take the propositions in order, examine them individually, and then indicate how, in my opinion, the employers came to be talking this kind of tripe. 
 First then the proposition that management should accept a responsibility for doing everything possible to keep prices stable or to reduce them. 
 Management has no business to accept any such responsibility; or rather, since &bquo;management&equo; is merely a collective abstract expression, managements have no business to accept any such responsibility. 
 The duty of every management is to conduct the business, including the price policy of the business, in the way which in the opinion of the management is likely to maximise the return on the capital invested in the business. 
 A management which does not do this betrays more than the shareholders in the business; it betrays the employees and the nation as a whole. 
 The national interest lies in all the nation's resources being put to the most advantageous use possible. 
 Anywhere outside a Communist state &mdash; and perhaps the time looks like coming when even that qualification will be superfluous &mdash; this is done by seeking to secure the largest possible return on capital. 
 To maximise profits is for management not an optional exercise or a work of supererogation: it is management's basic duty. 
 If private enterprise in a capitalist society is not trying to do that, there is no point in private enterprise &mdash; nor, for that matter, in a capitalist society. 
 In some circumstances returns will be maximised by keeping prices stable or by reducing them. 
 But in other circumstances returns will be maximised by raising prices. 
 Wherever that is so, it is the responsibility and duty of the management concerned to raise its prices, whether in the home or in the export market. 
 There neither is, nor  can be, any general  responsibility in managements not to alter prices, or if they alter them, only to lower them. 
 Of course, if prices generally do rise, the value of money falls with all sorts of unpleasant consequences for the classes who cannot raise their money incomes as fast as others, and, in the case of Britain particularly, for the national balance of payments. 
 But this is a general proposition, which cannot be translated into a practical guide for individual action by declaring it to be the responsibility of each and every management never to raise prices and if possible to lower them. 
 Indeed, stability of prices generally is perfectly consistent with the increase of some prices, provided others are reduced. 
 But then again, how is the individual management to know if it happens to be one of those which ought to acknowledge a responsibility to maintain or lower prices, or whether it is one of the lucky ones which can be let off that responsibility? 
 This brings us to the second proposition , which was evidently begotten of inability to answer that difficult, because inherently unanswerable, question. 
 Let us go, says the second proposition, and find somebody else, some wise man who will be able to answer the unanswerable, who can tell us which are the sheep who can properly raise their prices, and which the goats who ought to keep their prices stable or lower them; and then, when he tells us, we will all go and scream blue murder at the goats and make them thoroughly ashamed and sorry for themselves. 
 This is the meaning of the proposition that &bquo;another way to curb prices would be to establish a body (probably a prices commission) to examine particular prices and report upon them publicly&equo;. 
 Anyone who has got as far as saying this, has already thrown the first proposition overboard, because if it is &bquo;the responsibility of management to do everything possible to keep prices stable or reduce prices&equo;, then we would not need a commission to tell us that managements which raise prices are falling down on their responsibility. 
 All we would need to do would be to chop off the head of the price raisers. 
 But everyone sees that this is absurd. 
 One could imagine a &bquo;price pause&equo; for a limited time; but after that &mdash; is there something familiar about all this? &mdash; one would have to start discovering which prices ought to rise and which ought to fall to offset them, and this is just what we want a commission to do for us because we pretend that we don't know how to do it for ourselves. 
 (Actually we do know, perfectly well. 
 The apparatus is there all the time. 
 But for certain reasons, which I will mention presently, we don't want to use it; so we pretend that it does not exist and hope that no one will be guilty of such bad taste as to refer to it.)  
 However, more of this later. 
 Meanwhile, may I enquire how the commission would go about its task? 
 Management A has raised its prices. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; asks the commission. 
 &bquo;Please, sir,&equo; answers the management, &bquo;my suppliers of components have raised their  prices, and unless I raise mine too I shall make a loss and have to sack my employees.&equo; 
 (A telling point, that; handkerchiefs at the ready!) 
 &bquo;Oh, very well,&equo; says the commission, &bquo;you can maintain your margin as before &mdash; but not a penny more, mind.&equo; 
 (At this point there is a disturbance at the back, while a small boy who shouted out &bquo;Why?&equo; is bundled into the street.) 
 &bquo;And remember,&equo; continues the commission, &bquo;if you ever find yourself here again, you will be most severely dealt with.&equo; 
 Exit Management A, concealing a grin of triumph. 
 Enter Management B. 
 &bquo;Please, sir,&equo; says Management B, &bquo;I haven't really raised my prices; I have actually produced what is a new and better article, so much better than those of my competitors that, although my price is much above theirs, I have full order books and the retailers tell me they are accumulating waiting lists.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have your profits gone up?&equo; asks the commission. 
 &bquo;Well, yes, I must admit,&equo; replies management, &bquo;that I am making a good thing out of this, the best break we have had for years &mdash; you see, my methods of production are so cheap and efficient.&equo; 
 &bquo;Wicked management,&equo; thunders the commission. 
 &bquo;Have you not read that restraint of profits is just as important as wage restraint? 
 What would happen to us all if everyone were to behave like you? 
 We shall be obliged to animadvert most severely upon you in our report.&equo; 
 &bquo;May I ask just one question?&equo; says management. 
 &bquo;If I cut my profits and prices to whatever lower level you prescribe &mdash; for I assume I shall have your guidance on what that should be &mdash; will you advise me about the basis on which I should ration the consumers of my article? 
 Ought I to restrict supplies to certain retailers only, or release them only on the certificate of a doctor or justice of the peace, or simply rely on those who can afford to pay getting them on the black market?&equo; 
 &bquo;These,&equo; replies the commission, in a state of much irritation, &bquo;are not questions for us. 
 We have no intention of interfering with the conduct of your business.&equo; 
 Management B leaves the court wearing an expression like Joan of Arc at Rouen. 
 I will bore you with no more such little scenes. 
 They could be, and  would be, multiplied indefinitely. 
 The commission has no criterion, because it can  have no criterion, to decide which prices ought to go up and by how much, or vice versa . 
 As long as the public is not prevented from choosing one thing in preference to another, people will express their choice by what they are prepared to pay for the one compared with the other. 
 Every change in the preferences of the public at home or abroad, every alteration in supply and demand &mdash; those dreadful archaic words had to be pronounced sooner or later &mdash; will express itself in a change of prices. 
 But the only way to find out which  prices and how much  change is to &bquo;suck it and see&equo;. 
 Either the commission intuitively knows how supply and demand will change &mdash; in which case the commission is miraculous but unnecessary &mdash; or else the commission is applying some other unspecified standards and judgements of its own &mdash; in which case the commission will be a tyrant if it can impose its decisions and a laughing stock if it cannot. 
 Better try something else, then; and here it is, in the shape of the third proposition : &bquo;if over a period profits should rise more than incomes, the balance should be redressed by taxation policy&equo;. 
 We accept then that, responsibility or no responsibility, commission or no commission, prices may behave in such a way that profits rise faster than a certain rate, that rate being the rate at which incomes other than profits &mdash; or perhaps incomes including profits? &mdash; are increasing. 
 Now, I leave entirely on one side the question why on earth the present ratio between profits and incomes generally is so supremely right that for all time it ought to be preserved, or at any rate allowed only to diminish, regardless of anything else that happens, such as the growth of savings and accumulation of capital. 
 I leave entirely on one side all the difficult questions which are concealed by that little phrase &bquo;over a period&equo;. 
 I address myself wholly and simply to the proposal that there should be some form of excess profits tax &mdash; that profits above a certain level should be taxed away. 
 The first question to be asked is: would this tax be imposed business by business, or overall? 
 For example, if incomes were rising at 4 per cent, would any individual business whose profits rose more than 4 per cent have the excess taxed away? 
 Or does it mean that if total incomes rise by 4 per cent and total profits by 5 per cent, all profits are subject to a levy of one-fifth of their increase over the previous period? 
 This is a very obvious question. 
 Someone must have asked the employers which they meant, and so they had to plump. 
 They said it meant the latter; they said they were &bquo;prepared to see the ratio between profits and incomes preserved at a reasonable level by a tax which would become operative upon all industry when a certain figure was exceeded by profits as a whole&equo;. 
 This is very difficult, however. 
 Because some people are making  large profits, and raising the total of profits by so doing, it is proposed to come down on the &bquo;innocent&equo; businesses, whose profits may actually have gone down, who have been being &bquo;responsible&equo; and not increasing their prices; and their taxes will be put up &mdash; all because of the other bounders, who meanwhile are laughing their heads off. 
 And how, pray, will this affect the attitude of the &bquo;innocent&equo; who are made to suffer for the &bquo;sins&equo; of the &bquo;guilty&equo;? 
 The best thing for them to do would be likewise to get their profits up as far as possible above the datum line. 
 They have gained nothing by &bquo;restraint&equo;; in fact, they have lost by it. 
 So no more restraint for them! 
 This is so stupid that you might wonder why the employers did not plump for the other alternative &mdash; until you come to look at it! 
 I dare say some of the employers remembered EPL and EPT and reminded their colleagues of them. 
 That alternative means taking a datum line for each business and limiting the rise of its profits above that datum line to a certain rate. 
 But unless the relative profitability of different enterprises on 1 April 1964, or whatever date you like to choose, is sacrosanct and uniquely right, it must be wrong to freeze that pattern in perpetuity.  
 &bquo;SHOULD WE HAVE AN INCOMES POLICY?&equo; 
 Inflation , 1968 
 The subject &bquo;Should we have an incomes policy&equo; is in fact yours rather than mine. 
 My first shot was &bquo;Incomes policy and exchange rates&equo; which rather reveals perhaps the track upon which I find my own mind has been running in recent months if not years. 
 Still, any stick is good enough to beat with. 
 I think we ought to start by definition. 
 Failure to define, at any rate in politics, is the principal factor which keeps us in employment. 
 If we could succeed in defining accurately and agreeing upon the meaning of the terms which we are employing, then I am afraid the House of Commons would be very largely deserted. 
 By an incomes policy I take it that, for the purposes of our discussion, we mean an attempt to influence the value of money by operating directly upon specific prices; and price of course includes earnings, i.e. the price of a quantity of labour in a particular application. 
 I do emphasise this definition, which relies upon the influence upon the value of money being direct, being exercised upon particular prices; for of course all economic policies have an effect upon the value of money and thus upon prices, including incomes. 
 It is therefore possible to say that any economic policy is an incomes policy, and in particular that any economic policy designed to prevent or reduce the rate of inflation is an incomes policy. 
 It is in this latter sense that very often it is claimed that the Conservative Party is advocating an incomes policy, by which is simply meant that the policies which we advocate would, we believe, have as a result the stability of money values and thus have the effect that increases in earnings were real and not merely monetary. 
 So that is the sense, in which I am proceeding to consider incomes policy. 
 Its object is concerned with inflation, with preventing or restraining a general fall in the value of money, as seen in a general rise in prices &mdash; however difficult it may be to attach a precise concept to a &bquo;general rise&equo; in prices. 
 So far as I know, one cause of a general fall in the value of money is not open to dispute, either as theoretically possible or as practically instanced within our own experience: that is the monetisation of debt, in other words, the process whereby part  of the expenditure of public authorities is financed by the creation of additional spending power. 
 You are as familiar as I am with the processes of monetisation of debt and of the part which the money market in the City plays in the operation of that mechanism. 
 So far as I know, no one has denied that inflation can be, and in fact often within our experience is, caused by the Government financing part of its expenditure by the creation of additional spending power which it then exerts. 
 I do not believe it is disputed that this factor has been powerfully in operation recently. 
 If that were not so, there would be little meaning in the Budget of last month. 
 The whole significance of that Budget was that it was designed to eliminate the need for, or the risk of, the monetisation of debt as a result of the level of Government expenditure in relation to the level of the national product. 
 If one looks at the figures presented at Budget time for the previous financial year, for the financial year 1967/1968, it is pretty clear in broad terms on what scale the process had been in operation. 
 The excess of Government expenditure in that year over the yield of taxation was forecast to be &pound;1 billion and actually turned out to be just over &pound;1and1/2; billion. 
 Since there was little or no lending to the Government during the year 1967/68, it follows that that billion and a half of expenditure was financed from one of two sources. 
 One was the inflow of pounds into the Exchange Equalisation Account as the counterpart of the loss of reserves. 
 The other &mdash; necessarily, by elimination &mdash; was the monetisation of debt. 
 Now, I don't think we know what was the exact Sterling equivalent of the fall in our reserves during the last financial year, but it can only have been a minority of that total of &pound;1and1/2; billion of public expenditure which was met neither by the product of taxation nor by borrowing from the public. 
 We are accordingly reaping, and have been reaping, the effects of monetisation of debt during the last twelve months on that sort of scale. 
 But for the alteration in taxation in the Budget and also the minor alterations in projected expenditure which preceded it, we should have been facing 1968/69 with the identical prospect of a further creation of additional purchasing power. 
 I come now to what will be the first of many simplicities which I shall offer to you this afternoon; for I am sure you already realise from what you know of my speakings and writings &mdash; and it will be all the more painfully obvious in half an hour's time &mdash; that I am incurably simpliste. 
 This is partly due to my experiences as a politician, because I know as a politician that when you are doing something naughty, nothing is more effective than to muddy the waters with complication. 
 What you fear most is an opponent who will point to a few simple but undeniable facts, and this is why the economists,  and above all that wonderful race of men the economic journalists great and small, are such indispensable allies to the politician: they enable the politician to fog up what he is doing, so as to escape the blame and often even criticism for his actions. 
 So I am encouraged in my perhaps natural na&iuml;vet&eacute;, I am encouraged to be simpliste, by my knowledge of the value of complication in fogging up the real issues in politics. 
 My first simpliste proposition is this. 
 the natural deduction from what I have said so far would be for Governments to end the necessity of monetising debt and make sure that they don't put themselves in the position of monetising debt &mdash; at any rate in circumstances where there is not a substantial deficiency of demand for labour and where therefore the monetisation of debt would not be counterbalanced by an increase in real production. 
 Now see what has happened! 
 Here we have an undoubted theoretical cause, and also the undoubted fact that this cause has been in operation on a massive scale. 
 The natural reaction to that situation would be to say: &bquo;Well, let's take the cause which is admitted to be in operation, and stop it, and then see if things are all right afterwards. 
 If we find that when we have stopped it, either things are just as bad (which is improbable) or that they are still fairly bad, then indeed it will be easier, scientifically easier, to detect any other causes which may be at work.&equo; 
 You may ask me then: &bquo;Why don't we do just that? why has there been this passionate search for some other method of preventing the fall in the value of money or controlling the fall in the value of money, if a cause and perhaps the major cause is undisputed, assessable and obvious?&equo; 
 The answer is of course a political answer. 
 The answer is that we politicians exist to enable the public to have its cake and eat it. 
 This is a yearning which mankind insists shall be fulfilled and it has a specialised organ for doing this. 
 That organ is the politician. 
 The politician is the organ of society for having its cake and eating it, for escaping, if only for a moment, if only through a form of art &mdash; art is, after all, a means of escape &mdash; from the grimness of reality, from this grim fact that you can't have the cake and eat it, that you can't have public expenditure increased in excess of the rate of increase of the national product, unless private claims are correspondingly surrendered. 
 Now the most painful way to call upon the public to sacrifice its claims is by taxing. 
 That is the last recourse to which any politician comes. 
 Having read his Burke, he knows the aphorism which I will not insult you by quoting about taxation. 
 Naturally, if he can borrow he borrows; but that is a lark that hasn't been &bquo;on&equo; in this country, taking one year with another, for the last ten years or more. 
  Borrowing from the public is more or less finished, perhaps it is finished for our lifetime, but at any rate it has been finished for the last ten years or so; you may get in a bit one year but you lose it again the next year. 
 Therefore, if the Government can finance its expenditure without taxation by some other method, namely through inflation, by creating the additional spending power and infusing it into the economy, that is an ideal solution to an insoluble problem &mdash; how to increase public expenditure faster than the rate of increase of the national income without the rest of the community having to surrender any claims or expectations. 
 You do it of course by deceiving them. 
 It is a method of deceiving the public. 
 It is a method of fulfilling a deep desire of the public to be deceived by the politician into thinking that public expenditure can be increased faster than the national income is increased without their noticing any diminution of their own rate of increase in purchasing power and standard of living. 
 So, the answer is that the strongest motives restrain Governments from limiting the rate of growth of public expenditure to that rate which they could be sure of meeting within the growth of the national product and thus without any substantial increase in taxation but also without relying upon borrowing and without monetisation of debt. 
 It's a dangerous operation to set out on. 
 You might think the only safe course is straightforward, sound, economic government and you might wonder therefore why so rarely in recent years Governments have practised it, except when they have been hit over the head by external forces and events that they couldn't resist. 
 However, you know, there is a powerful law which operates in politics, the law of the Dutch auction. 
 Let us suppose that a Government, a party, observing that the rate of increase of the national income has been as high as 3 per cent in real terms over the last few years, were to decide to make plans which involve the growth of public expenditure at the rate of 2and1/2; per cent, so as to be a little within the recent happy experience. 
 Just imagine the abuse with which they would be showered by people who would tell them: &bquo;Since it is easily possible for the economy to grow at 4, 5, 6 per cent or any other figure you like, the public are being cheated of the growth of public expenditure which they have a right to enjoy by this niggardly Government which is only counting on being able safely to increase public expenditure at a rate of 2 to 2and1/2; per cent.&equo; 
 When the late Conservative administration did its sums at the end of 1963 it found that its future programme worked out at an annual rate of increase of 4.1 per cent. 
 As this was higher than the average rate over such a period that had been experienced at any historical time, something had to be done. 
 There were two things that could be done. 
 One was, in the year before an election, to say:  &bquo;Well, in that case the programme has to be scaled down; otherwise you will have higher taxation or inflation.&equo; 
 That was one course. 
 The other course was to say: &bquo;It will be all right, boys, because we are going to grow faster, we gotta growth plan.&equo; 
 Accordingly the Conservative Government &mdash; a non-planning party, mind you &mdash; announced that. 
 Of course, they only started by &bquo;examining the implications&equo; of growing at 4 per cent; but presently they were planning  to grow at 4 per cent, and soon they were promising  to grow at 4 per cent. 
 This is the other way: you fix the expenditure first, and you hope afterwards; and if it doesn't come off (which it is unlikely to, if you are gambling on an improbability), then the result is the monetisation of debt with the consequences which we know. 
 So there is the psychological explanation. 
 We therefore have: 1) the malady if it is a malady; at any rate it is assumed to be a malady by the proponents of incomes policy; 2) a theoretical cause of the malady, which is not disputed; 3) the practical demonstration that this cause has been in operation; and 4) the psychological explanation why that cause is desired, fomented and sustained by Governments. 
 &bquo;What need we more?&equo; the scribes and Pharisees said. 
 Nothing more, according to me. 
 That's why I am so simpliste. 
 In other words, so far as I am concerned, unless and until we are prepared to deal with this demonstrated cause of inflation and want to do so, we are wasting our time; and as soon as we want to do so, there is no reason to suppose that there will be any problem or therefore any reason for an incomes policy as defined. 
 I apprehend however that it would be disappointing to you &mdash; I can't think why &mdash; if I were to stop at this point. 
 I therefore pass to examine further &mdash; still in an entirely simplistic frame of mind &mdash; other theories which have been advanced to account for inflation. 
 Remember the strong vested interest of politicians in alleging other causes of inflation, because if they can persuade the public that other causes than their own behaviour are really at work, then they will be able to transfer the responsibility from themselves to other people. 
 In fact the principal political significance of incomes policy is as a device for transferring responsibility from the Government to others, something which politicians are expert at doing &mdash; which indeed is necessary for their survival. 
 Since the politician is blamed for what is not his fault, he couldn't survive unless he devised methods of blaming other people for what is  his fault. 
 Hence the elaboration and the perfection of explanations for inflation which have nothing to do with Government is something in which you naturally find politicians of all schools, but particularly of the public expenditure school, joining with good will. 
 It is sufficient motivation. 
 Well, there is the theory of spontaneous generation &mdash; like worms  in Lucretius. 
 Lucretius believed that worms were spontaneously generated in mud. 
 There is for instance the theory that inflation is spontaneously generated by trade unions. 
 This is very popular in the country because upon the whole trade unions are unpopular, and therefore, if you can attach the consequences of your own actions (for which you desire to transfer the blame to other people) to somebody who is unpopular already and attribute it to him, you are almost certain to be home and dry. 
 The &bquo;worms in Lucretius&equo; explanation of inflation works as follows: a trade union, because of its bargaining strength with monopoly powers, secures an increase in the remuneration of its members, say, 5, 10, 15 per cent &mdash; what they call &bquo;excessive&equo; or &bquo;unjustified&equo;. 
 Then, says the theory, this naturally causes all the other wages and prices to go up too. 
 Now, the beauty of this sort of explanation, where you have everybody on your side, when you are dealing with somebody who is unpopular, when you are all desperately anxious to find a scapegoat, is that your argument is unlikely to be at all jealously scrutinised. 
 As Professor Housman used to say, &bquo;Stand on a barrel in the streets of Baghdad and say twice two are four and ginger is hot in the mouth and therefore Mohammed is the prophet of God, and it is unlikely that anyone would question your reasoning; but if he should be bold enough to do so, you could easily silence him by calling him a Christian dog.&equo; 
 So it is, say I in my simplistic fashion, that the plain, screaming absurdity of the statement that trade-union action causes a general rise in wages and prices escapes scrutiny. 
 Of course I realise that the fallacy is so crude that it would be below the dignity of any academic economist to soil himself with such much. 
 I mean he has to take it seriously and occupy himself the effluvium which rises from it. 
 But it is absurd.  
 &bquo;ENVY&equo; The Spectator , 12 March 1970 
 It is time that envy was reinstated in its rightful place, as one of the basic data of individual and social psychology. 
 Treated by theology as one of the deadly sins and recognised and discussed without inhibition by philosophers, poets, psychologists and other observers of the human scene until the present century, it has all but disappeared from view in our own time and reference to its existence, let alone study of its function, has been sedulously avoided. 
 Helmut Schoeck, the professor of sociology at Mainz, explains the reasons why in a comprehensive analysis which restores the phenomenon of envy to a central place in social motivation. 
 His book is not particularly well arranged, and tends to heaviness and repetition. 
 One suspects that the language was no more beautiful in the German original than the English translation. 
 But it provides a powerful aid to the understanding of some of the more baffling political manifestations of our time. 
 Envy, the thesis runs, is universal and ubiquitous in human beings. 
 It is not dependent on any particular cause, so that, if that cause were removed, envy would disappear. 
 There are no circumstances, and no society, where envy does not find the material it needs to feed on. 
 In all societies, from the most primitive to the most advanced, envy and its counterpart, the fear of being envied, give rise to a whole series of often elaborate systems of behaviour. 
 Envy would not be so strong and indefeasible an instinct, unless it had an important function in the evolution and survival of human society, and therefore of mankind itself. 
 Like other such instincts, however, envy is both preservative and destructive. 
 Those societies survive and flourish which have discovered how to exploit its preservative effects while containing the destructive ones. 
 Envy-management, in short, can be life or death for a society. 
 The negative social effects of envy (including, once for all, the fear of being envied) may be to stultify and prevent all progress, by making variation between individuals and manifestation of individual superiority too dangerous to be persisted in. 
 This is characteristic of many primitive, taboo-ridden societies, and may be one of the explanations of economic backwardness. 
 Moreover, if the validity of  the envy motive is once accepted by a society, there is no limit to the sheer self-destruction which is possible, since no divestment of authority or privilege or difference is capable of neutralising envy:. 
 for instance, &bquo;it does not need an exceptionally vivid imagination to realise the extent to which people of different ages would become obsessed by the discrepancies arising in a society in which age was the only distinguishing feature&equo;. 
 We are not far here from an insight into the deeper causes of current anarchical unrest. 
 On the other hand, it seems likely that a positive function in the evolution of human society has been exercised by envy in that it maintained variations of individual behaviour within tolerable bounds and maintained a mutual bond, policed by envy and the fear of envy, between all the differentiated members of a society. 
 Success or failure have thus depended on the devices by which a balance could be maintained between the preservative and the destructive effects of envy. 
 The notion of luck is one of the simplest of these devices. 
 Unknown to many primitive societies, it provides a lightning-conductor for envy, as may be seen from the readiness with which gains of pure chance are left outside an otherwise highly egalitarian (&bquo;envious&equo;) system of taxation. 
 The notion is the very opposite to that widespread but typically Greek attribution of envy to the universe itself, as divinely personified by the envy of the gods, who lie in wait to punish the good fortune or prominence of mortals. 
 Professor Schoeck identifies the counteracting of envy and of the fear of envy by Christianity as one of the decisive factors in Western progress. 
 Not only was the deity rendered benevolent (unenvious) towards men, but Christianity offered an interpretation of human life in which envy and the fear of envy became irrelevant. 
 When St Paul declared that in Christ there is neither rich nor poor, bond nor free, man nor woman, he was precisely not  advocating egalitarian taxation, equal rights or the abolition of slavery. 
 That the Christian message is today thus misinterpreted &mdash; so as to destroy its envy-neutralising effect &mdash; is significant for the modern predicament. 
 Any policy which aims at exorcising envy and the concomitant sense of guilt &mdash; the reason why so many intellectually eminent individuals are attracted to levelling doctrines, because they aspire to purge the sense of guilt to which eminence itself is prone &mdash; by measures of social or economic equalisation is foredoomed to failure, because it rests on the false presumption that envy and envy-guilt exist only because they are &bquo;justified&equo;, because the materials exist on which they feed. 
 It is not possible, because of human nature itself, so to reorganise economic or social life that by that means envy and resentment cease to exist. 
 The utopias which those most sensitive to  envy and guilt have devised throughout the ages for their own relief remain literally utopian: the question is not how envy is removed, but how it is lived with. 
 In a deliberately egalitarian policy it becomes actually less manageable, because envy fastens most upon the smallest, not the largest, inequalities and upon those who are nearest to ourselves, not furthest away. 
 Perhaps in the command to &bquo;love thy neighbour as thyself&equo;, the word &bquo;neighbour&equo; is after all meant in the most precise and narrow sense. 
 One of the areas which the social psychology of envy illuminates best is the modem craze for policies of international aid. 
 One aspect after another yields to the open sesame of the envy theory. 
 The exorcising of guilt and envy at a distance &mdash; as between people and peoples, who have no knowledge of one another &mdash; is a recognisable method of evading the problem posed by neighbour envy: hence the often observed fact that international and long-range do-gooders are commonly highly uncharitable at close quarters. 
 The policies of international aid, which defy rational justification on either economic or strategic grounds, are at once intelligible when viewed as a collective purgation of the fear of envy, to which the &bquo;affluent society&equo; &mdash; itself an envy-guilt coinage &mdash; is especially prone and which is more vivid to the donors than the imagined envy is to the recipients. 
 The result, of exacerbating both the fear and guilt of the affluent countries and the envy and hatred of the recipient countries, was perfectly predictable. 
 The fact that the receiver of a gift hates the giver is commonplace: the gift does nothing to remove the material for envy; on the contrary, the act of giving becomes both a justification for the envy and an additional ground for feeling it. 
 The parallel with policies inside multi-racial societies for banishing or reducing racial &bquo;discrimination&equo; or for exorcising by economic and social reorganisation the mutual envy and fear of envy between the races, does not need to be laboured. 
 When so large a part of modern politics, above all in America, is concerned with policies which an insight into the psychology of envy would reveal to be inherently futile, it is perhaps not surprising that the study of that psychology has been instinctively or deliberately neglected.  
 &bquo;HANGING, LOGIC AND THE PUBLIC&equo; Daily Telegraph , 1973 
 Few, if any, Members of Parliament who voted, as I did more than once, for the abolition of the death penalty, can have failed to revolve in their minds many times since then both the reasons for their vote and what cause there might be to repent of it or to vote otherwise on a future occasion. 
 Perhaps the only person who finds his course clear is someone with an absolute objection, moral or religious, to society taking the life of any of its members. 
 This has never been my own position. 
 I am ready to acknowledge that there can be circumstances in which the taking of human life is, humanly speaking, the lesser evil. 
 I have never been disturbed by the apparent anomaly that the death sentence remains in our law as the penalty for treason: I see no parallel or analogy between the punishment of crime within a society and the self-defence of a society against its enemies. 
 For me, therefore, the issue of the death penalty is primarily &mdash; though not, as I shall admit, wholly &mdash; a practical one. 
 If I were reasonably satisfied that, other things being equal, substantially fewer persons would be murdered if the death penalty were available than if it were not, I should have opposed its abolition and would support its restoration. 
 The words &bquo;reasonably satisfied&equo; and &bquo;substantially fewer&equo; are selected deliberately; for the alternative is so grave that the choice ought not to be made on only a narrow margin of evidence or probability. 
 It is so grave, because, on any view, the putting to death of a human being by the society to which he belongs is an appalling act, calculated in itself rather to familiarise that society with the taking of life than to heighten the sense of life being held sacred. 
 The onus of proof must therefore lie heavily upon the advocacy of the capital penalty: the counterbalancing benefit must be clear and considerable. 
 It will not do to say, &bquo;If the death penalty will save a single life, it is justified.&equo; 
 This brings me at once to what I have always found the most impressive fact about the evidence on this subject: its ambiguity, not to say its neutrality. 
 If the death penalty did deter, then so distinctive and so dramatic  is the sanction that its effect ought also to be too marked to overlook or dispute. 
 We might expect to find difficulty in relating, for example, the average length of prison sentences to the incidence of the crimes for which they are imposed; but to be at a loss to trace any clear connection between the prospects of being executed for murder and the prevalence of the crime of murder is startling and impressive. 
 The Royal Commission on Capital Punishment which reported in 1953 (Cmnd. 5932) examined the experience of countries throughout the world where the death penalty has been abolished, restored, abolished again or where it existed in some parts and not in others. 
 The outcome of the analysis of this mass of evidence was indecisive as the Commission reported: 
 This is an issue on which it is extraordinarily difficult to find conclusive arguments either way&hellip; 
 The general conclusion which we have reached is that there is no clear evidence in any of the figures we have examined that the abolition of capital punishment has led to an increase in the homicide rate, or that its reintroduction has led to a fall. 
 We also reviewed such evidence as has been submitted to us about the possible relation between the number of executions in particular years and the incidence of murder in succeeding years. 
 It is sufficient to say that we are satisfied that no such relationship can be established. 
 It was natural, but not logical, that when the capital penalty in Britain was first restricted (in 1957), and then abolished, the sequel was scrutinised in the expectation of finding confirmation or refutation. 
 By an irony of fate, abolition coincided with a period of rising crime, both violent and non-violent, in which Britain shared with most other countries on both sides of the Atlantic. 
 It is a period which has not yet manifestly reached its climax; and in the more recent past it has been characterised in Britain, as elsewhere, by a marked increase in the use of firearms. 
 To complicate matters further, substantial changes in criminal and penal law were made by the Criminal Justice Act, 1967. 
 In these circumstances facile and fallacious deductions about the consequences of having abolished the death penalty were bound to be rife. 
 There was, however, one perfectly clear and simple condition which had to be fulfilled if any rational deduction was to be drawn as to the effect of abolition. 
 That was that the crime of murder should behave distinctively. 
 If murders, however defined, followed no more unfavourable a pattern than other violent crimes or crime generally, then at the very least a verdict of &bquo;Not proven&equo; must be returned. 
 It would be mere superstition to attribute the increase in murders to the change of penalty and the increase in the rest of crime to some other cause or causes.  
 I realise that no series chosen to test this proposition can be free from some criticism or objection; but this fact is less serious when no such series has, so far as I know, been constructed which fulfils the condition of a uniquely unfavourable pattern for murder. 
 With that caveat I offer one table out of many, which illustrates the negative outcome.  
 Thus, in 1973, we are no wiser than we were in 1948: the experience of twenty-five years has shed no more light upon the question, does the death penalty deter? than was available at the beginning &mdash; except perhaps that the neutrality of the evidence, which I have explained I find so logically impressive, has been reinforced. 
 But has anything else that has changed in those twenty-five years &mdash; or, for that matter, in the years since abolition &mdash; been such that it ought to influence the mind of a Member who is unable to convince himself that capital punishment deters? 
 The questions and the answers are bafflingly subjective. 
 The most recent perhaps is the emergence of terrorism, and not only in, or connected with, Northern Ireland (where incidentally capital punishment is available). 
 I confess I do not find much relevance in this to the death penalty. 
 The terrorist is normally a person who, as such, risks death either by his own weapons or in the commission of his act, and is at least as likely to court what he might regard as a martyr's or patriot's death as to be deterred by it. 
 Much more difficult is the general fact of rising lawlessness itself, whether violent or non-violent; for, though I feel obliged to consider the death penalty primarily by the test of deterrence, I recognise that  the interrelation of crime, punishment and the opinion and behaviour of a society is something far more subtle and profound. 
 Without plunging into the moral and intellectual &bquo;deep end&equo; of the arguments about retribution, I suspect there is a relationship of cause and effect between the state of opinion and the incidence of crime, and further, that the state of opinion and the penalties of the law are interrelated &mdash; at least to this extent, that, other things being the same, milder penalties generally imply less reprobation. 
 An increase in seventy may betoken &mdash; even, more arguably, may occasion &mdash; a salutary change in the climate of opinion. 
 For this reason I am not averse from seeing a sharpening of sentencing policy within the present law. 
 Last and most impalpable of all is public sentiment. 
 It also presents the most difficult problem for those who, like myself, are convinced on practical grounds that a sufficient case cannot be made out for the restoration of capital punishment. 
 I should be the last to imply that a Member of Parliament ought to subordinate his judgement of what is wise or right to even the most overwhelming majority of opinion. 
 If he believes a thing harmful, he must not support it; if he thinks it unjust he must denounce it. 
 In those judgements the opinion of those he represents has no claim over him. 
 But capital punishment is not for me in that category: it is not self-evidently harmful, not self-evidently unjust. 
 I cannot therefore deny that in this context a settled and preponderant public demand ought to be taken into account or that at a certain point it would have to prevail. 
 I do not believe that point has been reached; but it would be disingenuous for me to deny that it could exist.  
 &bquo;THE ROLE OF THE INDIVIDUAL&equo; Address to &bquo;The Challenge of Crime&equo;, Police Federation Seminar, Cambridge, April 1976 
 Since I knew that I was to have the privilege of addressing this seminar, I have studied with great textual care the document issued by the federation under the title Dear Fellow Citizen  because it appeared to me that it was &bquo;the brief&equo; for what I was to say to you. 
 I have done so with the earnest endeavour to be able to speak to that brief, but I have to start by declaring failure and announcing that the results have been negative. 
 So perhaps, if I spent my time explaining how and why I found difficulty, that must be some sort of substitute. 
 I take as typical of my difficulty a sentence from item six in your summary of your campaign: &bquo;The need for the silent majority to assert itself in order that politicians and judges fully understand the true feelings of the public.&equo; 
 I have to tell you that this is a contradiction in terms. 
 It contains an inherent fallacy: you are expecting the silent majority to speak. 
 I am not joking. 
 I have really nothing else to say, except to draw attention to the inherently contradictory nature of that for which you appear to be asking. 
 For the silent majority will always be silent. 
 It can never become the vocal majority. 
 The majority never does speak. 
 It is always the minority, the specialised organs of a society, that do the speaking. 
 This is a similar fallacy to that of those in my profession who are constantly aspiring to bring everybody up to the average. 
 You can't do that, because unless everyone is identical, the average will always be somewhere around the middle. 
 For similar reasons, the majority will always be silent, and by definition, will not, at any rate by speaking in an overt way, assert themselves. 
 There is perhaps only one situation in which one can envisage the majority speaking, and it is not a voice which one wants to hear. 
 When the majority does speak, it becomes a mob. 
 The function of the majority in any society, like the function of the average, is to be silent or average. 
 That brings me to my next proposition. 
 In all society, and as a condition of the survival of society, there is a balance between human  characteristics. 
 Particularly there is a balance between courage and cowardice and the average between the two. 
 The average between courage and cowardice is the normal state of human beings and the characteristic of the silent majority. 
 I have the gratification, if such it be, that people not infrequently come up to me and say, &bquo;Mr Powell, I wish all politicians were like you,&equo; to which I reply, &bquo;God help you, the place would be a madhouse.&equo; 
 Society would be ungovernable, Parliament would be unmanageable, if the majority of the Members had my courage and independence of thought and expression. 
 Society would be inconceivable under those terms. 
 It would be equally inconceivable that any army should be composed as to the majority of cowards, of gun-shy. 
 It is neither composed of VC holders or aspirants nor of those who in earlier days would have been shot for cowardice. 
 It consists principally of the in-betweens. 
 For the survival of a society you have to have a certain number at one extreme and, therefore, a certain number at the other extreme, for without cowards there are no VCs. 
 It is the same with the notion that you can bring everybody up to the average. 
 You can't, for if you are to have those who are above the average, you must have those who are below the average. 
 And if you are to have those who are far above the average, you must have those who are far below the average. 
 Some kind of mysterious balance of good and evil, of extreme good and extreme evil, is of the nature of human society and necessary to it. 
 Though I do not desire to stray into fields where others here are expert, I must point out that according to the first chapter of Genesis the world was so constituted from the beginning that good and evil were created together in it, and also that the knowledge of them existed before mankind. 
 I will go further, and say that crime itself has to be viewed from the same aspect of society as a balance &mdash; a balance that can be lost, like the physiological or chemical balance in an organism, in which cases the organism is destroyed, but a balance which is always there, whether being gained, maintained or lost. 
 Crime is part of society. 
 Delinquency is an indispensable part of society. 
 You can't have a human society without crime. 
 You can't have law and order without lawlessness and disorder, just as you can't have light without darkness. 
 A certain element of delinquency, like a certain element of altruism, is essential to the life and health of any society. 
 We need evil that there may be good. 
 I do not want to go too far into the philosophical or even the physiological aspects of the matter. 
 My object at this stage is simply to depose the concept of society as an organism in which, far more subtly than we can measure or identify (it is only recently that we  have begun to identify the chemical balance of the human organism of society), a certain balance between tendencies and elements, many in themselves dangerous, destructive and evil, has to be maintained as a condition of survival, but a balance which can be endangered, or lost, reversibly or irrevocably. 
 I notice that the federation talks about crime, about law and order and the breakdown of law and order as if they were single things. 
 Crime to me is not one. 
 The more I observe, the more different categories I think I discover, with different characteristics. 
 Consequently, if law and order are the opposites to the breach of the law and the creation of disorder, then law and order are also not one thing, but a great complexity of things. 
 I find it impossible to begin to think about the phenomena which are giving you anxiety and which, I assure you, are giving me anxiety, without some elementary attempt to classify those phenomena. 
 I am going to attempt such a classification not with the belief that it is either scientific &mdash; this University has a Department of Criminology, and I am sure that my attempts would be regarded as very crude in those august circles &mdash; nor with the idea that the classification will be exhaustive, but by way of illustration of my essential point that different criminal phenomena, or anti-law-and-order phenomena, require different types of reaction on the part of the rest of society and imply different prognoses. 
 Let me start with the case which you mention first, the growth of mugging. 
 Although there are aspects of mugging which are continuous, permanent, old-fashioned, the new word is describing a typically new thing. 
 That new thing, as is recently being admitted, is connected with the change in the composition of the population of certain of our great cities. 
 To use a crude but efficient word for it, it is racial. 
 Its prevalence is due to the fact that an implant into our society has changed a community that was previously homogeneous into a community which is no longer homogeneous and self-identifying. 
 I am fascinated to notice that your profession has at last started not merely to say that, but to criticise those who refuse to allow so manifest a fact to be stated in order that it may be examined. 
 I was delighted with the terminology of the Metropolitan Police report to the Select Committee on Race Relations and Immigration, a fortnight ago. 
 No politician could have bettered it: &bquo;Experience has taught us the fallibility of the assertion that crime rates amongst those of West Indian origin are no higher than those of the population at large.&equo; 
 Splendidly expressed! 
 Beautifully expressed! 
 I don't think even the most jealous Committee of Privileges could do anything with such a sentence, but its meaning is clear enough. 
 Indeed the same evidence has been tendered, the same facts had been brought to the attention of the same Committee in 1972; but the Committee had reported to  Parliament in the opposite sense, stating the opposite to the evidence they had actually received from those who were competent to tender it. 
 Still, we have to this extent moved on, that not merely are we, in the context of this phenomenon, allowed to refer to the facts but we are actually now allowed to criticise those who suppress the facts. 
 This, I suppose, must be regarded as some sort of progress. 
 Here then is a criminal phenomenon that is associated with social disintegration &mdash; the fact that a society, the inhabitants of these areas of the great cities, who once regarded themselves as one, now no longer regard themselves as one, are not one, were one in the past but are not one now, and are still growing apart. 
 What is the prognosis? 
 What is the relevance to that public concern which you wish to stimulate here? 
 It is that there is no community to appeal to; for the phenomenon itself is the evidence that there is more than one community, or a divided community. 
 Consequently, the reaction of the host society to a growing imbalance, a growing injection of this particular form of crime, is not the natural reaction by way of the formation of antibodies, as it were. 
 Society is increasingly helpless to deal with it because it has ceased to be society. 
 No silent majority there  to appeal to! 
 Indeed, it is because there is no silent majority, no single entity which is being attacked by a hostile element, that this form is increasing. 
 My prognosis is extremely grave and follows from the diagnosis, that these are consequences of a divided society. 
 There are those who believe that out of a divided society you can create a unitary section. 
 I do not see. 
 I see not the slightest prospect with the scale of introduction of these alien wedges into the population of our cities, of a community attitude growing up in the future. 
 On the contrary it seems to be that, as the respective numbers become closer together, or even tend to overbalance in the opposite direction, alienation is bound to progress. 
 So this is an area where no sort of remedy is obtainable from the attempt to invoke or elicit the natural response of a community to an attack upon its health. 
 If you are asking me where the remedy lies, my answer is that I have told you before and I shall go on telling you, and you know perfectly well what it is, though everybody thinks that it is too difficult and that therefore there must be a different remedy. 
 I leave my first category, therefore, and come to one where the prognosis is less gloomy. 
 You describe it in your notes as hooliganism, and you give the example of our national pastime (one with which I have never sympathised!) of watching football in large crowds. 
 There is no doubt that a form of parasitic violence has battened upon this pastime and flourished to such an extent that it has almost killed the host institution.  
 The phenomenon seems to me to be different in kind from the first. 
 I suggest &mdash; this is merely an illustrative explanation &mdash; that we are here dealing with a cyclical phenomenon. 
 The propensity to hooliganism is inherent in every society. 
 Historically we can establish that there have always been these waves of hooliganism in particular form. 
 You can read in The Spectator  of two hundred and sixty years ago that the streets of London were not safe at night because of the Mohawks, gangs who terrorised London and beat up the Watch, who tarred and feathered innocent citizens. 
 It came and it went. 
 It did not go of its own accord. 
 Society reacted to it, the organs of law reacted to it and eventually but not as a result of direct cause and effect &mdash; it is something more subtle than that &mdash; it went out of fashion. 
 So here is an endemic form of crime and disorder, which becomes epidemic periodically under different forms and taking advantage of different fashions, such as the excursion train and the large football arena. 
 I would have thought it is very dangerous to get football hooliganism mixed up with mugging. 
 My suggestion to you is that the only connection between them is basic human nature itself, namely that the heart of man is incurably evil. 
 For your professional purposes, and mine as a politician, we have to keep them as far apart as we can &mdash; providing of course that my analysis is sound. 
 Exploiting further this notion of that which is endemic becoming epidemic, there is the phenomenon of the increased use of firearms. 
 This seems to me to illustrate what I would call the &bquo;Breakthrough Phenomenon&equo;: the sudden discovery that something which has been assumed to be out of the question is not out of the question at all. 
 Unless my recollection is at fault, it seems to be that two generations ago it was accepted in our society that we did not use firearms. 
 There was no more objective reason why firearms should not have been used in burglaries and bank hold-ups thirty or sixty years ago than today; but it &bquo;wasn't done&equo; &mdash; until it was discovered that it was  done, that you could  do it. 
 There was never any problem in getting hold of the firearms; but nobody wanted to get hold of them, because it was &bquo;not done&equo; to use firearms. 
 Then, after a bit, it becomes not something unacceptable, but something accepted or at least something which is demonstrated to be not out of the question. 
 So you have the sudden appearance of a Breakthrough Phenomenon. 
 After all, people have always wanted to do violence to those who stood in their way when they were attempting to commit robberies; but they have been bound by certain conventions of which they were unaware. 
 They have assumed that certain methods were not available to them. 
 Then something happened to destroy their former assumptions, and you have the phenomenon of the breakthrough. 
 Here again, I don't see why the prognosis is particularly gloomy; for self-adaption to changing  methods and circumstances is of the nature of a continuing society. 
 So again I exhort you to isolate yet another category of what you generalise as the deterioration of law and order. 
 As an extreme example of the Breakthrough Phenomenon, the scourge of hi-jacking is quite fascinating. 
 It presents the appearance of a contagious epidemic. 
 It is one of those forms of crime which appear to be &bquo;catching&equo;, as a disease is communicated from one country to another and one continent to another, like the importation of smallpox from India into London. 
 What is happening is the discovery that a new method has made its appearance. 
 &bquo;Wheresoever the carcase is, there shall the eagles be gathered together.&equo; 
 When it is discovered that the combination of certain proportions of charcoal, sulphur and saltpetre produces disagreeable results, then there is no reason why the benefits of gunpowder should be restricted to China. 
 You can make it in the kitchen. 
 The ingredients are common. 
 They have always been there. 
 But someone discovered in China that you could put them together and it went off with a bang. 
 That seems to be the story of hi-jacking. 
 You only have to show that this act works for there to be takers everywhere. 
 It can be applied to all kinds of objective situations or none at all. 
 I am coming later to the &bquo;none-atall&equo; which is one of the more emphatic observations that I have to make, namely that one must not assume there is necessarily a rational purpose, or even a felonious purpose, in the breach of law and order and the commission of crime. 
 However, staying for a moment with hi-jacking, here we have a specialised form of the Breakthrough Phenomenon, which until the antidote is produced or produces itself, has quite startling pyrotechnic results, but collapses again as the antidote is devised. 
 It is rather like warfare, the seesaw of offensive and defensive, of tank armour and the high-velocity penetrating bullet. 
 In fact I think it possible that in the context of hi-jacking we are  developing the anti-tank weapon &mdash; one which is largely a moral weapon and lies mainly in the hands of political authority. 
 This is my pivot on which to turn to the last, and I think most important category of what you call the breakdown of law and order, because it leads us to concentrate our attention not on the silent majority but on another point in society. 
 This last category is the thing that started, at least to the naked eye, in Berkeley, California about 1964, and swept around the world reaching its zenith about 1969&ndash;70 &mdash; just five years flat. 
 You can plot its movement on a map of the world and date the times of arrival of the outbreaks. 
 For instance, it arrived in Cambridge in November 1967: that can be dated almost to the day. 
 What is this thing? 
 I used to have a file, but I found that, as with so many files one opens, I was putting so much in it that it ceased to  be useful. 
 It was called, &bquo;The Thing&equo;. 
 I used to tell my secretary: &bquo;That can go in &bquo;The Thing'&equo;.' 
 It did not have to have a name. 
 It was the thing that started in Berkeley. 
 It took various forms: university disorder; civil rights movements; anti-apartheid activities; race and immigration protests. 
 The essense of &bquo;The Thing&equo; is that violence is used in order to subjugate the will of the majority by destroying its good conscience. 
 Let me take the university manifestation as perhaps the simplest. 
 Quite suddenly, students at universities begin to behave outrageously. 
 They break the rules, they break the things, they make life intolerable and impossible. 
 But this is done in such a way that it creates the presumption that the university and its authorities, the institution, are at fault. 
 It creates the presumption of grievance, of remediable grievance, and instantly shifts the onus of guilt from the wrongdoer to the institution which is under attack. 
 &bquo;The Thing&equo; learnt how to make authority apologetic. 
 It is one of the great discoveries of mankind. 
 It will be looked back upon by history as one of the remarkable achievements of the human spirit to have discovered how a very little violence can destroy the good conscience of the major institutions of society, and interchange the positions of sense and nonsense, right or wrong. 
 Once the action and reaction grievance-violence-remedy of grievance has been set up, it goes on of its own accord. 
 For the remedy which is sought to be applied, the removal of grievance is not a remedy at all, because the grievance is not the case, on the contrary it is an aggravation, it is dynamic. 
 Another of the characteristics of &bquo;The Thing&equo; is that it doesn't have a rational cause. 
 It is not revolutionary in the old-fashioned sense of the term. 
 It is not the attempt of the sans-culottes  to get some culottes . 
 It is not the revolt of the hungry against those who are hoarding food. 
 It is not the revolt of those who are denied the franchise against those who are monopolising the franchise. 
 It does not have a purpose in that sense of purpose. 
 Its purpose is to destroy. 
 This was stated in total emphatic form by the anonymous French student who retorted when General de Gaulle returned in haste from Romania and said: &bquo;La r&eacute;forme, oui. 
 Le shie-on-lit , non&equo;; the student said, &bquo;No, you have it wrong; Le shie-on-lit , oui. 
 La r&eacute;forme, non.&equo; 
 That is the essential motto of &bquo;The Thing&equo;. 
 There is another secondary effect besides this establishment of the destructive spiral of violence-grievance-attempted remedy. 
 It is not merely the passivity but the subjugation of opinion. 
 Opinion, certainly overt opinion, has been on the side of the university disorder. 
 University opinion has been on the side of it, and public opinion has been on the side of it. 
 The teaching body in the university, so far as it has  not joined &bquo;The Thing&equo;, has always preferred to accept the philosophy of &bquo;The Thing&equo; rather than reassert what it well knew was the requisite of any academic society. 
 Universities are now governed on the principle that it is right and natural for the management of a university to respond to the opinion of the students &mdash; a thing which is manifestly absurd. 
 It is an illustration of the way in which &bquo;The Thing&equo; works by substituting nonsense for sense, so that presently everybody is talking nonsense, and nobody can talk sense any more. 
 Nobody can draw attention, for instance, to the rational scholastic relationship between professor and student, without being considered a candidate for a mental institution. 
 I remember that in 1970 I was actually called deranged because I drew attention to the various forms of manifest nonsense on which &bquo;The Thing&equo; was battening. 
 The civil rights movement in Northern Ireland in 1968&ndash;70 was a classic example of &bquo;The Thing&equo;. 
 It applied the methods of Kent campus to imaginary grievances in a divided, or divisible, community in Northern Ireland. 
 There were no grievances, and everybody knew there were no grievances. 
 But immediately the violence started, everybody said: &bquo;There must be grievances. 
 Authority must be at fault. 
 Therefore authority must remedy the grievances.&equo; 
 When authority had remedied the imaginary grievances and the violence still went on, and got worse and worse, then people said, &bquo;Authority must be disposed of, because clearly it is evilly intentioned.&equo; 
 (Maybe you think that is a partisan statement of the circumstances in Northern Ireland? 
 It is no more partisan than my description of what has happened in the universities.) 
 In Northern Ireland &bquo;The Thing&equo; eventually unchained some of the other phenomena that we have been discussing here, which are inherently separate: endemic hooliganism; the breakthrough of the use of the firearm; and the infinite potential for blocking the formation of antibodies, for blocking the natural reaction of a society to violence, which exists in a divided community. 
 The forms of criminal or lawless activity which have followed the civil rights movement which came and went in 1969&ndash;71 will disappear as and when there is a general conviction that there is going to be one society and one particular sort of society in Northern Ireland &mdash; that is to say, one state, one particular sort of state, and no other. 
 I will not go on to examine by the same criteria the other manifestations of The Thing, such as the anti-apartheid demonstrations, in which open breach of the law was widely condoned and encouraged by the organs of public opinion. 
 I need not even mention the agitation surrounding race and racialism and immigration in the unique circumstances of the last twenty years in the United Kingdom. 
 In all these cases the reaction of society as a whole in the face of &bquo;The Thing&equo; is  like that of an organism attacked by a parasite, or a specialised aggressor: it behaves in exactly the way which renders the aggression successful. 
 There is a general passivity, a loss of good conscience &mdash; &bquo;they must have been doing something very wrong there&equo;; &bquo;we must have been wrong&equo;; &bquo;I suppose these new ideas must be right&equo;; &bquo;I suppose we have got to get used to them&equo;, etcetera, etcetera. 
 The overt expression of that passivity and self-condemnation is that a whole range of the voices of public opinion are on the side of what you and I call the criminals. 
 They are on the side of this new engine for society-breaking. 
 That has brought us back again to the conundrum which you posed to me and in the face of which I had to express my helplessness &mdash; namely, how do we make the silent majority unsilent since that is by definition impossible? 
 How does any society protect itself against this kind of comprehensive assault, which does not even need the charcoal, sulphur and saltpetre to make the gunpowder but can find the materials for the application of its marvellous discovery anywhere in the world and in any circumstances? 
 I will offer the best consolation I can. 
 I put to myself the question: &bquo;How then, does it come right?&equo; 
 My first reply to that is: &bquo;It doesn't have to come right. 
 Societies do not have to survive. 
 There is no law of nature which says that human societies are bound to survive so that we could say &bquo;Cheer up, chaps!'&equo; 
 Indeed, history proves the opposite. 
 There may be no answer, in the sense that there may be no available cure which will work.&equo; 
 I am therefore reduced to asking: &bquo;If there were one, what would it be?&equo; 
 In doing so I am rather like the doctor by the patient's bedside, who knows; although of course he does not tell the patient &mdash; that the outcome of the disease will depend upon something in the constitution of that patient which he cannot control nor further influence and which he cannot even ascertain, except by the event. 
 I have often thought that one of the most interesting things for doctors about their patients is to see whether they survive or not. 
 So we are referred to the chemistry of the reaction of society; and here we are involved inescapably in a circularity of reasoning. 
 If it is the sort of society that survives, it will react like this. 
 If it does not react like this, it is not one of the sorts of society that survive. 
 Not much consolation in that! 
 But at least one can attempt to say what form the reaction is going to take. 
 What one needs and has to have is a reaction. 
 What we are looking for is the politics of reaction. 
 I do not mean being reactionary, simply going back to a past state of affairs, I mean reaction as the antithesis of action. 
 That will not, by definition, come from the silent majority. 
 It must come from the minority of one. 
 Anything in this world which is any good comes  from a minority &mdash; above all, the minority of one. 
 If you doubt that, read the Old Testament. 
 I do not believe that reaction occurs except through individual resistance in the first place. 
 This, therefore, is not the business of the silent majority which you have presented as your target. 
 That's escapism. 
 That's an excuse. 
 You are really saying, &bquo;We must find a way to do the impossible.&equo; 
 You are saying that the answer is to do that which is inherently contradictory, to make the silent majority speak, to make the average the exception and so on. 
 Reaction against the weapons of &bquo;The Thing&equo; &mdash; I take that now, in concluding, as typical of some, though not all, of the classifications into which I have exhorted you to divide the breaches of law and order &mdash; reaction against its contradictions, its absurdities, its defiance of known, established, healthy reality, can only come from individual persons &mdash; and from individual persons who speak. 
 You will not find those individual persons amongst the majority, because by definition the majority is composed of individuals who do not speak. 
 You therefore need people in the minority who will speak, the heretics, not to say martyrs. 
 Indeed, martyrdoms you must have; for martyrdoms are a sign that the next generation will be orthodox. 
 Generation One you burn at the stake; Generation Two you decorate with the CBE. 
 Unless people go out into the open, the reaction cannot take place. 
 You ask, how do we set about organising that? 
 You can't. 
 There either are such people in sufficient quantities or there are not. 
 There either is room for them in this society, and an eventual hearing (whether pre- or post-martyrdom), or there isn't. 
 You cannot do anything about it. 
 Or can you? 
 That question is not addressed to an association or a federation. 
 Federations don't do these things. 
 Only individuals do them. 
 I don't know &mdash; perhaps it might be you . 
 But the you , remember, is in the singular.  
 &bquo;HUMAN RIGHTS&equo; Journal of Medical Ethics , 3, 1977 
 What are human rights? 
 In this article Enoch Powell, MP (a former Conservative Minister of Health), approaches this question through a critical discussion of Article 25 (1) of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights. 
 Article 25 (1) of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights, subscribed by the United Kingdom in December 1948, runs as follows: &bquo;Everyone has a right to a standard of living adequate for the health and wellbeing of himself and of his family, including medical care., 
 The Declaration was &mdash; not surprisingly &mdash; unaccompanied by any mechanism for the enforcement of the rights which it declared. 
 In that respect it differed from the European Convention of Human Rights, to which the United Kingdom adhered in November 1950 under the auspices of the Council of Europe and which came into force in September 1953. 
 The Convention established a European Court of Human Rights, to which the signatory states accorded supranational powers, and before which at this moment Britain awaits judgment in respect of acts committed in Northern Ireland in 1971. 
 Significantly, there is no provision (yet) in the European Convention corresponding to Article 25 of the UN Declaration. 
 However it would be unwise to conclude that, just because it has no enforcement mechanism, the Universal Declaration is as harmless as it is futile. 
 Nonsense can never be talked with impunity by anyone; and when governments solemnly talk nonsense in the name of nations, harm is certain to come of it sooner or later. 
 Most of the contents of the Universal Declaration are not merely nonsense but pernicious nonsense; and Article 25 is in this respect typical, not least in being both nonsensical and pernicious in several different ways at the same time. 
 A right is a claim which is, or ought to be, enforceable against others. 
 An individual, apart from society, cannot be conceived as having rights &mdash; or if he does, they are rights as against God, which  is blasphemy. 
 Robinson Crusoe on a desert island may experience good luck or bad luck; but he can have no rights. 
 The concept of enforcement involves &mdash; as the word implies &mdash; the use of force, compulsion: one man's right is enforced by others being compelled to do what they would not have done of their own free will. 
 This is true even of immaterial rights: a right to free speech is a claim to say to others what they do not want to hear, and to do so, if necessary, thanks to the exercise of force against those who would like to interfere. 
 But the compulsion becomes specially evident when the right is a claim to something material, because what one has another must go without: a right to free travel is a claim to compel others to transport me at their expense; a right to a pension is a claim to compel others to transfer part of their income to me. 
 This business of compulsion is not something theoretical or peripheral; it is of the essence of a right, because there is no point in declaring a right to what everyone is going to have anyhow. 
 The whole object of declaring a right is to justify or commend the use of compulsion to alter the existing relationship between individuals in a society. 
 An existing right is a claim which the society already enforces. 
 A proposed right is a claim which the proposer would like the society to enforce. 
 In fact a statement of human rights is either a description of a society or a critique of a society. 
 The compulsion with which rights are concerned will be either arbitrary or lawful depending on whether the compulsion is exerted in known and foreseeable circumstances by known and foreseeable process. 
 For the compulsion to be lawful, the right must be &bquo;justiciable&equo;; that is, it must be definable, so that it can be uniformly and predictably applied, upon known principles. 
 A right not stated in justiciable terms is tantamount to a claim to exert arbitrary compulsion. 
 Article 25 is exactly of this character. 
 The terms &bquo;adequate&equo; and &bquo;wellbeing&equo;, not to mention &bquo;standard of living&equo; and even &bquo;medical care&equo;, are purely subjective: to prescribe a &bquo;standard adequate for wellbeing&equo; is not to interpret a rule; it is to make an arbitrary decision, and an arbitrary decision about the compulsion to be exerted upon the members of a society. 
 The definition will be not the ruling of a judge but the manifesto of a revolutionary junta. 
 A &bquo;standard adequate for wellbeing&equo; is potentially unrestricted &mdash; &bquo;the sky's the limit&equo; &mdash; and therefore the actual limit imposed and the performance exacted are necessarily arbitrary, the decisions of brute force. 
 The arbitrary implications of undefinable rights are particularly evident where the right claimed is by its nature not capable of being satisfied by any degree of compulsion exercised within the relevant society. 
 However vague may be the concept of &bquo;medical care adequate for health&equo;, the right clearly cannot be realised if there are no doctors. 
  However subjective the &bquo;standard of living adequate for health and wellbeing&equo;, it obviously cannot be achieved if population is outstripping subsistence. 
 Unless therefore the right asserted is tautologous and meaningless &mdash; unless &bquo;adequate&equo; means simply whatever is available in the given circumstances &mdash; its assertion is a threat not merely of arbitrary compulsion but of unlimited and inherently futile compulsion: it is a programme of nihilistic aggression. 
 This is precisely the purpose with which it was framed by its authors in the United Nations. 
 The society implicit in any statement of a right is not, in the context of the United Nations, a national society. 
 The society intended is international &mdash; the so-called community of nations, or world society. 
 The compulsion to be exercised in the attempt to satisfy the claim of right is not purely or mainly internal to particular societies: it is compulsion to be exercised by some societies against other societies, coercion to be brought to bear upon an international scale. 
 The statement &bquo;everyone has a right to medical care adequate to his health and well-being&equo; is, in the Universal Declaration, tantamount to the highwayman's &bquo;stand and deliver&equo;: if this right is not realisable within a society, it must be realised by compulsory redistribution and reorganisation as between societies, and if it is still impracticable even by compulsion on an international scale, so much the worse for the international community! 
 The implicit nihilism and aggression are global. 
 It is not accidental that the assertion of &bquo;the rights of man&equo; has been characteristic of revolutionary regimes which aspired to interfere with and overturn the systems of law and society of their neighbours; and there could be no more striking evidence of the antagonism of Soviet Russia to Trotskyism than that &bquo;human rights&equo; have to be forced down its throat at Helsinki or Belgrade like spoonfuls of brimstone. 
 On the other hand it is possible to differentiate the nature and effects of the human rights &bquo;declared&equo; by the United Nations from those asserted as the basis of the American state in the second section of the Declaration of Independence. 
 A right to &bquo;life&equo; may be philosophically opaque; and right to &bquo;liberty&equo; may mean anything or nothing; but a right to the &bquo;pursuit of happiness&equo; is unmistakably individualist, a claim upon society for the absence or minimum of restraint upon oneself, counterbalanced by the renunciation of restraint upon others. 
 The right to the &bquo;pursuit of happiness&equo; and the right to an &bquo;adequate standard of living&equo; are dead opposites, as opposite as the right to pursue something and the right to be given something, as opposite as the demand for minimum compulsion in society and the demand for maximum compulsion. 
 What a strange freak of human history it is that the Declaration of Independence  should be among the lineal ancestors of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights! 
 It is a paradox upon which a Tory may perhaps be permitted one parting reflexion. 
 The attempt to understand or to construct society starting from the individual is foredoomed to failure, if not to worse. 
 The initial word &bquo;everyone&equo; in Article 25 (and in most of the other Articles) &mdash; however illogically linked with &bquo;his family&equo; &mdash; contains the same fallacy as &bquo;all men&equo; in the Declaration of 1776: &bquo;rights&equo; are not an attribute of individuals but a description of societies. 
 Those who, wittingly or not, use the concept of &bquo;human rights&equo; to attack societies from within or without find in the end that the result is neither health nor well-being.  
 &bquo;GIVING AWAY THE ROD&equo; The Spectator , 21 January 1978 
 I am opposed to judicial corporal punishment, always have been and, so far as I can see, always shall be. 
 I am even more opposed to the question of that penalty in the United Kingdom being submitted to a tribunal outside this country and to the decision of that tribunal being treated as binding. 
 Assuredly the verdict of the Fool upon King Lear has come home to us: 
 When thou gavest them the rod and 
 puttest down thine own breeches, 
 Men they for sudden joy did weep 
 And I for sorrow sung, 
 That such a king should play bo-peep 
 Ang go the fools among. 
 Indeed we have &bquo;given the rod&equo; to nations which have been better acquainted than ourselves with tyranny and inhumanity. 
 It was no good the Prime Minister telling the Bangladeshis last week that the making and administration of the laws of this country is our own business. 
 He had evidently suffered a fit of amnesia, and overlooked not only the European Communities Act, 1972, which tore a great hole in this country's legislative independence, but that much earlier aberration, the signature of the European Convention of Human Rights in 1950. 
 At least the European Communities Act, if I remember rightly, had been the subject of a debate or two. 
 The Convention of Human Rights did not even rate a half-hour adjournment. 
 The Attorney General of the day (one Shawcross), informed an inquiring MP that &bquo;it is not contemplated that any legislation will be necessary to give effect to the terms of this Convention&equo; because &bquo;I think we are entitled to say that the law of this country has always been in advance of the laws of most other countries in regard to human rights&equo;. 
 All humbug is punished sooner or later; but Nemesis is notoriously slow, and it was a quarter of a century before she struck and the United Kingdom found itself, to the malicious glee of her neighbours, the first signatory state to the Convention to be found guilty of a breach of its terms, in Ulster in 1971. 
 And now we have come up before the beak for a second wigging, because on the application of  one of our own citizens we are accused of &bquo;degrading treatment or punishment&equo; inflicted in the Isle of Man. 
 It is impossible to exaggerate the revolutionary significance of the recognition of a binding judicial tribunal external to the realm. 
 There is no similarity between this and international arbitration, where a state voluntarily agrees in a particular case to accept the judgment of a tribunal, as two individuals might freely agree to accept the adjudication of an arbitrator. 
 International arbitration is no more a transfer of sovereignty than private arbitration is an ousting of the jurisdiction of the courts. 
 The European Convention is different in kind, and the British signatories of it, worthy predecessors to the signatories of the Treaty of Brussels in 1972, put an end to a period of more than four centuries during which no causes have been carried out of this realm. 
 It is a thousand pities that the writ of praemunire  which Henry VIII used against Wolsey etc. was no longer available to prevent them; for despite the fair-seeming terminology of Human Rights, the result is incompatible with the elementary principles of justice and of democracy as we understand them. 
 The consequences strike at the right of the people of this country to live under the laws made and altered by their representatives in Parliament. 
 This ceases to be possible where a document accepted as binding is bindingly interpreted by an external court. 
 In order to arrive at its findings, the European Commission does what no court in this country can do, namely sit in judgment upon the policy and justification of an Act of Parliament. 
 What is more, and equally incompatible with our conception of parliamentary democracy, the judicial interpretation of the terms of such a document as the Convention is not susceptible to statutory control or modification. 
 In the system to which the European Convention belongs, the judiciary are the legislators, and their powers as such are the more sweeping because of the necessarily vague and general terms in which the socalled human rights are defined. 
 There is a further twist of the knife in the birching case. 
 it calls into question our right to maintain the peculiar forms of connection which exist between the United Kingdom on the one hand and the &bquo;Islands&equo;, viz . 
 Man and the Channel Islands, on the other hand. 
 By accepting the jurisdiction of an external authority in domestic matters, the UK in effect converted her responsibility for the external relations of the Isle of Man into a total responsibility for its internal affairs, and abrogated by a sidewind the semi-independence of the Islands, which are under the Crown but not part of the United Kingdom. 
 I wonder if the Manxmen and the Channel Islanders understood that  in 1950! 
 However, if we do not like being judged by an external tribunal,  if we do not like our citizens being interrogated by foreign judges about acts committed in the United Kingdom, if we do not like our Acts of Parliament and our internal administration being scrupulously picked over by a European Commission, if we do not like the relations between the Crown and its possessions being altered over our heads, the remedy is in our own hands. 
 Do we really believe that the rights we enjoy under our laws compare favourably with those in other societies? 
 Then let us tell the world so. 
 If not, let us put our own house in order and not wait for others to do it for us. 
 In either case, let us call off our participation in the dangerous humbug of international conventions of so-called &bquo;human rights&equo;. 
 I don't expect we shall &mdash; not yet. 
 But one day, if the long sickness of self-abnegation and denigration is ever over, we shall have to do it.  
 LETTER IN ANSWER TO SOLZHENITSYN'S HARVARD STATEMENT 21 June 1978 
 I am one of what must be an increasing number who find the portentous moralisings of A. Solzhenitsyn a bore and an irritation. 
 Scarcely any aspect of life in the countries where he passes his voluntary exile has failed to incur his pessimistic censure. 
 Coming from Russia, where freedom of the press has been not so much unknown as uncomprehended since long before the Revolution, he is shocked to discover that a free press disseminated all kinds of false, partial and invented information and that journalists contradict themselves from one day to the next without shame and without apology. 
 Only a Russian would find all that surprising, or fail to understand that freedom which is not misused is not freedom at all. 
 Like all travellers he misunderstands what he observes. 
 It simply is not true that &bquo;within the Western countries the press has become more powerful than the legislative power, the executive and the judiciary&equo;. 
 The British electorate regularly disprove this by electing governments in the teeth of the hostility and mispresentation of virtually the whole of the press. 
 Our modern Munchhausen has, however, found a more remarkable mare's nest still: he has discovered the &bquo;false slogan, characteristic of a false era, that everyone is entitled to know everything&equo;. 
 Excited by this discovery he announces a novel and profound moral principle, a new addendum to the catalogue of human rights. 
 &bquo;People,&equo; he says, &bquo;have a right not to know, and it is a more valuable one.&equo; 
 Not merely morality but theology illuminates the theme: people have, say Solzhenitsyn, &bquo;the right not to have their divine souls&equo; burdened with &bquo;the excessive flow of information&equo;. 
 Just so. 
 Whatever may be the case in Russia, we in the degenerate West can switch off the radio or television, or not buy a newspaper, or not read such parts of it as we do not wish to. 
 I can assure Solzhenitsyn that the method works admirably, &bquo;right&equo; or &bquo;no right&equo;. 
 I know, because I have applied it with complete success to his own speeches and writings.  
 &bquo;SOCIAL SERVICES&equo; The Times Health Supplement , 13 November 1981 
 The old Minister of Health, 1949&ndash;64, was responsible to Parliament directly for the hospital services, being almost wholly provided by the taxpayer, and indirectly for the health and welfare services provided partly out of the rates and partly out of taxes by local authorities. 
 He also answered for the general practitioner, dental and pharmaceutical services. 
 There is nothing in common between all this, which consists in &bquo;real, services, and the fixing and payment of money benefits, financed in great part by one special tax called &bquo;contributions&equo; &mdash; at least there is nothing common to these two functions which justifies demands for their being the province of one minister. 
 Maybe deficiency of income affects health; but so do housing and the environment, and so do conditions of employment. 
 The unity of the consumer creates no presumption in favour of the unity of the supplier. 
 Unfortunately nowadays every departmental minister has to be a secretary of state, just as every unimportant diplomatic station has to be an embassy. 
 This, and the multiplication of that half-breed known as ministers of state, is a product of a political inflation which even the present Government has not attempted to control. 
 No longer therefore, apparently, can we have one minister for health services and one minister for social payments; but that would be more sensible, all the same. 
 So I must restate the question as &bquo;What would my priorities be if I were now what the Minister of Health was then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Then&equo; in 1960&ndash;3, eighteen years ago; and in the meantime, apart from summarising my reflections and discoveries before they passed from my memory in a slim volume entitled Medicine and politics , I have done what most ex-ministers do when they have a left most departments &mdash; given the subject a wide berth. 
 There is a good reason for this: with any luck, they will never be back there  again, unless it was one of the great departments like the Treasury, Defence and the Foreign Office. 
 Your career politician is a generalist and eschews becoming &bquo;typed&equo;. 
 In the case of Health, there is the special relief at having escaped from those incessant wrangles over money with income-orientated professions, whose members are taken by the general public for  altruistic servants of humanity, if not for angelic comforters. 
 Any past Minister of Health who wanted to be Minister of Health again would have very peculiar tastes. 
 So, &bquo;What would my priorities be if the bad dream came true, and I were Minister of Health now?&equo; 
 If by &bquo;priorities&equo; is meant ambitions for changing the pattern and content of the service, I should be very reluctant to form any priorities. 
 That pattern changes gradually as medical practice and fashions change and as public demand changes. 
 The plant &mdash; hospitals, equipment, surgeries &mdash; being state-owned and state-administered, those changes do not come about by a gradual process made up of an infinite number of individual decisions: they happen in lurches, of which the most visible form is not the provision of new plant but the discontinuance of old plant. 
 It is the nature of this process that it is always being overtaken by further changes in medical practice and fashion and public demand. 
 One never, as a result, can get it right. 
 My mind goes back to the original fifteen-year Hospital Plan, published in January 1962. 
 It was based, because in the then state of medical opinion it could not be otherwise, upon the concept of the district general hospital, with the full range of specialities. 
 It was consequently characterised by the supersession of large numbers of small local hospitals, including those survivals from a byegone age, the &bquo;cottage hospitals&equo;. 
 If rumour speaks true, the pattern on which the plan was based was obsolescent before the second five-year phase of the plan was far advanced. 
 Opinion and fashion had changed: to talk of the &bquo;district general hospital&equo; now stamped the speaker as a Rip Van Winkle. 
 In the flush of enthusiasm, if not youthful, at least inexperienced, I set myself in 1960 two major objectives: one was the development of extramural services &mdash; &bquo;community care&equo; was the jargon &mdash; which would reduce the incidence of hospital care and counteract the institutionalism of long-stay hospitals; and the other, not unconnected, was to break down the huge mental hospitals inherited from the nineteenth century. 
 It is, as I noted at the time, a peculiar fact that most laymen who have had responsibility for the health service have interested themselves personally to a preponderant extent in the case of the mentally afflicted, both the mentally ill and the mentally handicapped. 
 I attribute that fact, rightly or wrongly, to the realisation of everyone who occupies that position that, while in every other direction insistent and vocal public and professional demand keeps up a constant pressure for expansion and improvement, it is frequently only his own influence and authority which will be exerted to redress the balance.  
 I shall return presently to this matter of the popularity or unpopularity of different aspects of the health service. 
 Meanwhile a sad reflection dawns upon the well-intentioned occupant of the ministerial chair. 
 Contrary to common assumption, community care is far more costly than institutional care. 
 Indeed, one of the reasons why it is superior is the much higher ratio of carers to cared-for, not forgetting the greater administrative cost of organising the one than the other. 
 It is vain to think that more of the load will be shouldered by voluntary effort. 
 Every health minister gets put into his mouth in his early months an ambitious and laudatory summons to voluntary effort. 
 In fact, the limits within which voluntary resources can be effectively used are narrow; and they can only be effectively used even within those limits if professional full-paid effort is put into making it happen. 
 Voluntary effort is not an easy option or a cheap supplement. 
 The only naturally efficient form of community care is the family &mdash; but that is quite another story. 
 Institutional care, therefore, especially of the long-term patient, is, however unattractive from some points of view, by far the most efficient in terms of manPower per patient. 
 Thus the endeavour to replace as much as possible of institutional with community care is a Sisyphean labour, which encounters the maximum obstacles, financial and organisational, quite apart from the fact that the responsibility for developing community care is fragmented and isolated through residing, in large part, with local health authorities and thus falling within a different system of finance and budgeting. 
 I would therefore be much more modest in my expectations and ambitions and would bear in mind one of the fundamental demand factors operating in the health service. 
 This is the law that demand increases proportionately to the improvement and increased acceptability of the service offered. 
 Demand that had been suppressed or masked by what the old Poor Law debates used to call &bquo;ineligibility&equo; emerges as effective demand in proportion as, for example, custodial and institutional care is replaced by community care. 
 The substitution is thus not only inherently costly, but it evokes increased demand or, if you like, creates increased need. 
 Nevertheless, I should be wanting, as twenty years ago, to lean with all my weight in that direction. 
 I should, again as twenty years ago, be the Chancellor of the Exchequer's best friend. 
 Let me hasten to explain what I mean. 
 The total volume of resources applied by the health services is essentially an arbitrary figure. 
 If it were 20 per cent greater, there would be no less dissatisfaction and unfulfilled demand at the margin; if it were 20 per cent less &mdash; I do not mean if it were reduced by 20 per cent  but if it were now 20 per cent less than it actually is, nobody would be the wiser. 
 It is not a cumulative figure obtained by adding up the cost of treating a given volume of specific diseases and of restoring to health, or transferring to a better world, a given number of patients. 
 All the same, I would expect and (I anticipate) receive agreement from the Chancellor to two propositions: first, I would wish the &bquo;real&equo; budget to be maintained, though I would not argue for any test of &bquo;reality&equo; other than the rough and ready conventional scale used for measuring inflation; and secondly, I would seek to agree a modest and gradual increase in that &bquo;real&equo; budget. 
 Let me be clear about the reason. 
 This country has a static but ageing population and will continue to have one for some considerable time ahead even if the birthrate kicks upward again. 
 Such a population, especially if the average size of a family continues to diminish, calls for more looking after, medically and physically, than an equal population of lower average age: it does not die so cheaply and it does not, medically speaking, survive so cheaply. 
 Consequently, to maintain a constant level of satisfaction &mdash; or, what is the same thing, of dissatisfaction &mdash; with the health services, expenditure upon them ought relatively to increase somewhat in real terms. 
 The &bquo;somewhat&equo; is quite unquantifiable. 
 That is why I said I would &bquo;seek to agree&equo; with the Chancellor: there is little by way of logical leverage that I could bring to bear upon them. 
 Within that slowly changing real total, major changes of pattern will, as I have already said, take place under the pressure of changes in medical practice and changes in medical fashion, as well as more subtle social and environmental changes. 
 These changes of pattern take place by a process which bears much more resemblance to that in areas outside public provision and within the scope of market forces than is commonly supposed. 
 The new items of treatment or care are not superimposed as net additions upon what exists; they are, as it were, &bquo;shoe-horned in&equo; by the increased pressure of professional and public demand for them confronting types of provision of which the relative popularity and fashionableness is diminishing. 
 In this welter, such deliberate pressures as the responsible minister may himself exert are included and absorbed; but the less he purports or believes himself to be determining the outcome, the better. 
 This is where lies the virtue, in the organisation of the NHS, of a certain institutionalised paradox. 
 Although the minister is uniquely and personally responsible to Parliament for everything &mdash; everything, that is, outside clinical decisions &mdash; which is done or left undone in the health service, he administers it through a hierarchy of non-elective bodies on which  the professions are strongly represented and are influential more than in proportion to their numbers. 
 This enables him to preside over the process which I have described with the minimum of overt interference, the constriction of the budgetary limits performing much the same role as the balance of supply and demand in a market system. 
 Before I was Minister of Health, I was inclined to be sceptical of the utility of this hierarchy, especially of the tier interposed between the minister and the direct administration of the hospitals. 
 Reflection and experience changed that opinion. 
 I made it my practice, not without some official misgivings, to work through the chairmen of the regional boards as a collective body, behaving, though they were my appointees, as no more than their primus inter pares . 
 I would do so again, believing that that relationship corresponds best with the reality of the processes which determine the composition and content of care within the NHS.  
 TO THE MIDDLE COMMON ROOM BANQUET Magdalene College, Cambridge, 12 June 1991 
 Her Majesty's Government, by the mouth of the Queen's chief minister, has announced that no distinction is henceforward to be made between universities and other places in which students of similar age and attainments seek instruction and qualifications. 
 This is grievous news, grievous not only for this and other universities but for the nation; for it is a grave national misfortune to be governed by those who do not know what a university is and what distinguishes it from other institutions of learning and study, not to mention training. 
 The difference has been essential to European culture and civilisation since the Renaissance at least. 
 It would be shameful and alarming if the United Kingdom professed a deliberate intention to contract out of recognising that difference. 
 A university, as Western civilisation has known a university, is an institution which is peculiar in a precise and definable way. 
 It is a place where there live side by side in mutual intercourse persons whose life is dedicated to the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake, regardless of the consequences or applications of the knowledge thus acquired. 
 The definition however does not end there; it has another essential element. 
 It is a place to which resort, during the formative years of early adult life, those desirous and capable of learning how people engaged in the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake go about their business. 
 A university is a place where there is research, teaching and learning; but not just any research, any teaching and any learning. 
 At a university the meaning of those terms is crucially qualified. 
 A university is a society &mdash; a society of those engaged in similar endeavour and for similar reasons. 
 They do their life-work the more successfully and enjoyably because, living together, they encourage, support and cross-fertilise each other. 
 It is possible to pursue knowledge for its own sake in isolation, in a hermit existence; but the outcome is impoverished and the happiness is diminished thereby. 
 I have already used several interchangeable terms for happiness. 
 Man is endowed with an insatiable curiosity about himself and about the world around him, in his perception of which his own nature finds  its reflection. 
 The attempt to satisfy that curiosity, because it obeys a deep and strong instinct, produces, especially in certain personalities, uniquely powerful sensations of pleasure. 
 In the last resort the only satisfactory answer to the question, &bquo;Why do you devote yourself to the attempt to understand?&equo; is, &bquo;Because I derive so strong a satisfaction from doing so.&equo; 
 Joy is the note and the reward of all learning. 
 A university congregates together that type of personality and places it at the disposal of the succeeding generation. 
 The decision to make this process possible by the foundation of colleges or universities and the financial maintenance of students has been taken, down through the ages, by the sources of munificence in each succeeding period, until in our own day the lion's share is produced through public funds voted by central government and local authorities. 
 It has at all times been an act of faith and a declaration of belief, the faith and the belief that a society and a nation will fare best, in this world and the next, where the most promising of its youth are withdrawn at a critical period of their development to spend several years in close and intimate proximity with one another and with those whose talent and delight is the pursuit of knowledge of all kinds for its own sake and the communication of that talent and delight to their successors. 
 Like all acts of faith, it is not capable of mathematical or logical demonstration and can therefore be disavowed by those who do not share it. 
 To our sorrow we know now that it is disavowed by the spokesmen of this nation today, who publicly and proudly profess not to share it. 
 No doubt they are also the victims of a gross and barbarous fallacy. 
 The astonishing achievements of Western civilisation in controlling and exploring the resources of the world, and the consequent increase in material wealth and standards of living, would not have taken place if the procurement of knowledge for its own sake had not mapped out the paths of which technology and investment for profit thereafter took advantage. 
 If thought and study had been restricted to whatever held out the visible prospect of material advantage, that explosive corruscation of human achievement which is European civilisation would never have occurred. 
 Those who created nuclear physics were as innocent of ulterior motivation as those who distilled a knowledge of the administration and society of ancient Egypt and Assyria from cuneiform inscriptions or Greek papyri. 
 The fatal fallacy is to try to turn the world inside-out and make economic progress the criterion of the pursuit of knowledge. 
 That way lies futility and the strangulation of the human spirit. 
 It is easy to be misled. 
 Human physiology and biochemistry are no less appropriate subjects for understanding in their own right and for university study and research because they have become the tools of  the lucrative and utilitarian profession of medicine. 
 Jurisprudence is no less an exploration of society and human nature because the practice of a solicitor requires acquaintance with statutory codes and court procedures. 
 The philosophical implications of the physical universe are no less challenging to the human intellect because aero-engines and production lines function in obedience to the laws of physics. 
 The same subjects &mdash; at any rate, the same subjects nominally &mdash; can be part of a university education and of a course in technology. 
 That does not equate universities with polytechnic colleges nor university education with technical training, nor can any overlap between the two negate the essential difference in kind between them. 
 There is something about a university which is naturally antipathetic to the state. 
 That is its autonomy. 
 Those whose business is the pursuit of knowledge for its own sake recognise their fellows: there is a community between them which they acknowledge because their mutual cross-fertilisation depends upon the underlying unity of human inquisitiveness in all its manifestations. 
 &bquo;Show me the results in advance,&equo; says the barbarian state, &bquo;and then I will give you money. 
 Provide me with a calculus of benefit, and I will justify distributing it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not so,&equo; replies the university; &bquo;give if you will; withhold if you must but understand if you can what nature of community we are and do not deprive us of our freedom, the freedom to pursue, and to teach others to pursue, knowledge for its own sake in whatever guise it presents itself to us; for that is of our very essence.,   
 THE EMPIRE AND COMMONWEALTH 
 HOWARD:&hellip; you used to believe in the British Empire. 
 What caused you to change your mind? 
 POWELL: After the war&hellip; 
 I thought that it was still possible for there to be a political link between the United Kingdom and India. 
 I realised that that was an absurdity&hellip; after the evidence that India could not be part of the same political system, I still believed for a short time that an Empire of positions &mdash; that is to say the possession of points of communication around the globe &mdash; gave a significance to this country and a tenable and lasting position. 
 That too was wrong and my lesson was learnt. 
 &bquo;Face the Press&equo;, Channel 4 TV, 9 October 1983 
 &bquo;THE MYTH OF EMPIRE&equo; Round Table 1910&ndash;1917 
 It is a solemn experience to sit in 1970 and watch the British people, seventy years before, being taught to &bquo;think Imperially&equo;. 
 What is impressive is that the failure of all that was so busily constructed, attempted and imagined, was not merely predictable but predicted. 
 We are not being wise after the event in pointing to the reasons why Imperial consolidation was foredoomed. 
 They were known to our predecessors at the time and were expounded by them as clearly then as we can demonstrate them now; for the reasons were implicit in the facts of the world in 1900. 
 It therefore required no feat of prophecy to assert that long before the twentieth century was out, the United Kingdom would be a country without empire and not in the front rank in size and power, and yet that this would not be synonymous with disaster, dishonour or extinction. 
 Watching the spectacle, one has the weird sensation that the actors really knew all the time that their professions were illusory, and that there was a kind of gigantic tacit conspiracy to pretend. 
 Otherwise, one wonders, how could there constantly be those &bquo;asides&equo;, which seem to reveal that the participants were actually aware the game was up or rather perhaps had never started? 
 One of the lessons to be drawn from the study of early-twentieth-century imperialism is the extraordinary durability of policies and programmes which lack all possibility of being realised. 
 The remarkable thing about political houses built on sand, or castles in the air, is how long they often take to collapse; and this very time-lag becomes an argument in their favour and a supposed refutation of those who draw attention to the absence of foundations. 
 &bquo;There must be a foundation somewhere,&equo; says the populace; &bquo;for look, the building continues to stand up.&equo; 
 There is yet one further stage of insight &mdash; and of pessimism &mdash; which awaits the student. 
 In studying a period and a phase in which what could be proved at the time to be shadows were so determinedly pursued, is he after all studying not an aberration, not a deviation from the normal, but the common behaviour of mankind? 
 Will it not be found that the political activity of societies consists ordinarily, perhaps invariably, in filling sieves and making sand ropes &mdash; sieves which those who fill them half know to be sieves, sand which those  who weave it into ropes suspect to be sand after all? 
 And the final reflection which suggests itself is that if this pattern of behaviour should prove to be normal, it should be assumed &mdash; at least until the contrary is demonstrated &mdash; that it is beneficial and has been evolved by trial and error as a preservative device or mechanism. 
 Nations, and perhaps humanity itself, would then be seen to owe their survival to their follies, or at least to an appropriate dilution of rationality with pretence and self-deception. 
 South Africa, for example. 
 A united South Africa within the British Empire was the purpose for which, almost from the beginning of the Boer War, Lord Milner laboured and assembled the galaxy of British talent soon to be known as his kindergarten. 
 In 1899 he was writing: &bquo;The ultimate end is a self-governing white community&hellip; from Cape Town to Zambesi. 
 There must be one flag, the Union Jack, but under it equality of races &lsqb;i.e. British and Boer&rsqb; and languages&hellip; but not before a loyal majority is assured&equo;; or again, &bquo;if ten years hence there are three men of British race to two of Dutch, the country will be safe and prosperous; if there are three of Dutch to two of British, we shall have perpetual difficulty&equo;. 
 He was as good as his word. 
 By 1908, when he saw that his stipulation was ruled out by the failure of British immigrants and the Liberal acceleration of colonial self-government &mdash; soon to be followed by South African union &mdash; he unhesitatingly drew the correct conclusion: 
 The policy to which we devoted years of labour must be regarded as a thing of the past. 
 The S. African British are entirely relieved from any obligations to the mother country. 
 They should devote themselves wholly to the problem of making life in South Africa, regarded as more or less a foreign country, bearable for self-respecting British men and women. 
 Mere logic and abstinence from wishful thinking had enabled Milner to summarise the story of the next sixty years. 
 Significantly, his kindergarten would not see &mdash; or would not look. 
 So they devoted themselves to promoting political movements which they could imagine would still reach the Milnerian goal. 
 &bquo;Both races hope for prosperity, prosperity means expansion, expansion means immigration, immigration means British&equo;; the syllogism was false, in logic and experience, but it was good enough for those who did not want to go where logic and experience pointed. 
 One is not prepared, however, for the discovery that Milner, so realist and clear-sighted about South Africa, was himself at the very same time an illusionist on a world scale. 
 In 1917 he could refer Garvin to a speech made in 1905 where he stated his ideal for the  British Empire: &bquo;we think of a group of states, all independent in their own local concerns, but all united for the defence of their common interests and the defence of a common civilisation, united not in an alliance &mdash; for alliances can be made and unmade &mdash; but in a permanent organic union' . 
 That anyone of Milner's mental power and insight could envisage a course of events which ran contrary both to the logic and experience of the actual British Empire over a hundred and fifty years is a staggering fact. 
 He retained, however, sufficient contact with reality to know, and privately to say, that such a development was incompatible with the British parliamentary system. 
 That given, the Burkian thesis must work itself out inexorably to the separation and independence not only of the great colonies (in the original sense of that word) but of every island and speck of rock on the globe: where there could not be representation in a common sovereign assembly, &bquo;unity&equo; would only be de facto  and on sufference, and thus diminishing with the passage of time &mdash; organic  it could never be. 
 Significantly the dream of an Imperial organic entity perished on the very battlefields of Flanders where the self-governing Dominions did apparently fight &bquo;for their common interests&equo;: 
 The more realistic minds in the &lsqb;Round Table&rsqb; movement quickly saw that the sacrifices made by Dominion troops and the concurrent growth in Dominion nationalism were harbingers of a new imperial relationship unlike anything they had proposed (Nimocks). 
 And even that sombre assessment understated the inevitabilities. 
 Still, after all, Milner was a man who stood aside from politics and despised them, and his kindergarten were defiantly administrators, not politicians. 
 The power of the Imperial illusion is only properly appreciated when we watch the last phase in the career of a politician's politician of the first rank, Joseph Chamberlain. 
 He built out of that illusion a political cause which stirred the British electorate as it had not been stirred for decades and which has left its imprint on the Conservative Party and on British trade policy down to the present. 
 The story of how the Birmingham radical, turned &bquo;unionist&equo; in the United Kingdom context, became Colonial Secretary in a Tory administration is well remembered. 
 It is not so commonly remembered that for him too it was the South African experience of the Boer War and its aftermath from which he emerged &bquo;unionist&equo; in the Imperial context. 
 The sudden chill of isolation which Britain felt in a hostile world, and the thrill of Dominion contingents serving alongside troops from &bquo;home&equo;, raised in new form what had long been a nagging conundrum &mdash; that the outlying parts of the  Empire which Britain defended bore no appreciable share of the burden, precisely because of the fundamental political syllogism: no taxation without representation; no representation without common responsibility; no common responsibility without sacrifice of separate independence. 
 Over and over again initiatives towards &bquo;Imperial union&equo; had broken into spray against the rock. 
 Was there perhaps some route by which it could be circumvented? 
 When Chamberlain returned from his post-war African tour to a hero's welcome in March 1903, he found to his hand a request from the Dominions themselves which, though it had nothing to do with Imperial unity, and indeed was rather symptomatic of growing independence, he seized upon and elevated into the first step towards &bquo;consolidation of the Empire&equo;. 
 (It is a standard procedure of politicians, when embarking upon a course which lacks logical coherence, to disarm critics and criticism by describing what they do or commend as &bquo;only a first step&equo;; for who can demand logic from &bquo;a first step&equo;?) 
 Unlike the mother-country and its dependencies, above all India, the self-governing colonies were protectionist; but they were now prepared, and indeed in some cases were anxious, to afford the mother-country preferential treatment within their tariff system if the mother-country would reciprocate. 
 In order to do this, however, Britain must herself become in some degree protectionist and place tariffs on foreign imports of at least the things which the Dominions had to sell to her &mdash; above all, food, if not also raw materials. 
 It was thus a revolution in British fiscal policy which Chamberlain advocated in the name of Empire; and from his Birmingham speech in May 1903 until he was struck down three years later his advocacy of tariff reform and his Imperial theme dominated British policies. 
 Yet the Imperial side of the argument &mdash; whatever view may be taken of the fiscal, economic and domestic &mdash; would not stand up to examination. 
 If the Empire was to be welded into an economic unit, the parts of which would be interdependent economically because they were parts of the Empire, and if this unity was to stand in default or in anticipation of political unity, then what was necessary was Imperial free trade, a genuine Zollverein . 
 Yet this was the last thing the Dominions would contemplate. 
 They meant to build up their own industries behind their tariff barriers, and not to remain the permanent primary producers for the industrial United Kingdom; and when Chamberlain once incautiously disclosed this logical implication of his policy, he was forced to beat an instant retreat. 
 Nor could Chamberlain ever show how a preference within the low tariffs, which were the most that Britain would conceivably tolerate upon her food or raw materials, could make the difference, as he constantly reiterated, between Imperial consolidation and Imperial dissolution.  
 Nevertheless, the magic worked, and the narrowness and unsoundness of the practical basis did not prevent the most glorious imaginary structures being reared upon it. 
 Like the kindergarten, Chamberlain did not hesitate to invoke as a parallel the formation of the United States, transposing Alexander Hamilton's &bquo;Learn to think Continentally&equo; into &bquo;Learn to think Imperially&equo;. 
 How can the blowing of such a bubble, and, once it was inflated and released, its durability, be accounted for? 
 The answer, in principle, is the same as for all political illusions which are successfully propagated &mdash; that vast numbers of people want to entertain them, that they fulfil a need. 
 And some of the needs which sustained Chamberlainite and Milnerian imperialism are not far to seek. 
 One was the need for reassurance in a world of visibly consolidating Great Powers &mdash; from the United States in the West to the Teutonic and Slav empires in Europe and the East. 
 The Recessional  of 1897 was not the hymn of a nation strong in its own security. 
 In the 1890s the atmosphere was not of that settled calm with which it was credited by later and even more anxious generations. 
 However confident the mass of the population may have felt in the durability of Britain's world role, those who ruled in Britain knew full well the kind of dangers the country faced and the need to take steps to meet them&hellip; 
 It would need a profound belief in providence to make one refrain from wondering why a group of foggy islands off Europe's north-western shores, populated beyond the means of subsistence that the islands could provide, endowed with no great natural assets outside the coalfields, should have become both the centre of a world empire and a possible arbiter of European rivalries. 
 It might seem that so artificial a superiority was certain to prove as transient as the hegemonies that it had replaced, although those in whose hands power lay were for the most part undaunted by the new challenges to Britain's position that they sensed&hellip; 
 They took it for granted that the international world was one of competing powers and that their duty was to make the most of whatever assets were available to them. 
 I doubt, however, if it is right to limit these anxieties to &bquo;those who ruled Britain'. 
 The audiences of working men who acclaimed Joseph Chamberiain were not just afraid for their jobs, though the fear of German competition was real enough &mdash; the three men, in a speech of Chamberlain's, unloading trucks containing German wire, who remarked &bquo;this is rather hard: we used to make this&equo;. 
 They also believed that other countries were overtaking Britain in every way;, and of course, as in the 1950s and 1960s, the fallacy of a &bquo;declining share&equo; of world trade etc. was easy to convey and difficult to expose. 
  Britain wanted to feel safe. 
 Strategically, the alliance with Japan and the entente  with France were expressions of this instinct; economically, it released the yearning for a closed area within which Britain could be commercially safe, even if perhaps less well-off than if she could have outfaced her rivals in open competition. 
 But need  she be less well-off? 
 The wish was father to the thought. 
 Could not imperialism go hand-in-hand with prosperity for the working man? 
 Here was the genesis of the myth, destined to lead to so many follies and disasters, that Britain was rich, as well as powerful, because of  her Empire. 
 The close links between the Fabians and Milner's kindergarten on the one hand, and the personal link in Chamberlain's own career between radical reform and tariff imperialism &mdash; he wanted the Conservative Party to hypothecate the financial yield of the preferential tariff to providing old age pensions &mdash; are reminders that at the beginning of the century &bquo;social imperialism&equo; did not sound the paradox it does today, and that the forefathers of modern British Socialism are to be found in larger numbers in the ranks of the imperialists than of the Little Englanders. 
 Milner in 1907 was writing: &bquo;there can be no adequate prosperity for the forty or fifty million people in these islands without the Empire and all that it provides&equo;. 
 It was the same idea of the Empire as a patrimony, or an estate, the source of a livelihood for the mothercountry, to which Chamberlain had appealed: &bquo;I know how our forefathers&hellip; bore themselves bravely in the titanic strife with Napoleon and came out victorious. 
 What is our task to theirs? 
 It is a mere trifle; it is only for us to keep the fruits  of the victory that they have won&equo; (Liverpool, 1903). 
 Weirdly, but by a traceable line of descent through Unionism and Socialism, almost the same accents recur after thirty years: &bquo;With the vast imperial resources which are the heritage of this country, the problems of poverty and want can easily be solved by a government empowered by the people to carry out their will. 
 While democratic governments are giving away the Empire which our fathers won, our people are abandoned to poverty and unemployment. 
 Yet the Empire belongs to you, the people of Britain.&equo; 
 The voice is that of Sir Oswald Mosley in October 1936. 
 So easily did the rational fear of not being able to exchange their products so advantageously merge, for a whole generation, into the absurdity of supposing that they could somehow have access to a source of wealth other than their own production. 
 It was not for that generation to complain if the inhabitants of India and of the dependent colonies took them at their word, albeit a mistaken word: the myth of an Empire exploited by the United Kingdom was a plant  which grew in the same soil as the myth of an Empire that alone secured &bquo;adequate prosperity&equo; to the forty or fifty million inhabitants of the United Kingdom. 
 Curzon was wont to complain, and with justice, that Chamberiain &bquo;forgot all about India when he launched his scheme&equo;, and whimsically mused on &bquo;what would have become of him and us if he had ever visited India&hellip; 
 The Colonies would have been dwarfed and forgotten, and the pivot of the Empire would have been Calcutta.&equo; 
 The remark goes deep. 
 It was not only Chamberlain but all the Imperial consolidators and Milnerites and Empire Traders who &bquo;forgot India&equo; &mdash; and with good season: they needs must. 
 The Empire which would be bound together by reciprocal preferences, freely accorded, and which would thence ascend, perchance, to the unity of common counsels and common institutions, was an Empire of independent &bquo;kith and kin&equo; &mdash; &bquo;the conception of the people of these islands as a great family bound by indissoluble ties to kindred  families in other parts of the world&equo; (Milner). 
 Yet the Empire which the British Navy defended, and which made Britain an Asiatic power, or a world power, or indeed a power at all, was not the few million kith and kin living in North America or in Australasia or mingling with the Dutch in South Africa. 
 It was overwhelmingly the empire of India. 
 But with India there could be no &bquo;consolidation&equo;; its hundreds of millions were, necessarily, left out of the cosy computations of the Imperialists; and its membership of a community of independent yet united states was beyond the power of imagination to conceive. 
 Yet it was not beyond the power of reason and foresight to know that the days of the Indian Empire were numbered, if not in years, still in decades: the best and the wisest of the British in India had known and said it from the beginning. 
 Nevertheless, a whole generation and more succeeded in forgetting or ignoring it, in order to live with the imperial illusion &mdash; &bquo;ideal&equo; was the kinder word &mdash; which they seemed to need.  
 &bquo;A WEEK IN POLITICS&equo; Channel 4 TV, 29 January 1983 
 ANTHONY KING: I would like to bring in, ah, Enoch Powell (really?) who, who has ah &mdash; very much&hellip; 
 ENOCH POWELL: I do enjoy listening to other people talk. 
 I'm quite used to it in the House of Commons&hellip;. 
 DENIS HEALEY: I've never noticed you enjoying it, Enoch. 
 POWELL: Oh yes, I enjoyed your speech the other day. 
 HEALEY: I'm so glad. 
 Yes, well you should. 
 KING: Mr Powell, what do you conclude from all this; you once described the Foreign Office as a nest of vipers. 
 Does listening to this conversation lead you to reinforce that conclusion? 
 POWELL: That &mdash; that nursery of traitors and nest of vipers. (clears throat)  A phrase which has become classic if not an actual thing. 
 The authorised description for that Department since then. 
 What we've been shown in the Report, and what has, ah, emerged from this discussion, is that for some fifteen years, we engaged in a game of blind man's buff. 
 We engaged in the game of looking for something which did not exist. 
 Looking for something between sovereignty and not sovereignty. 
 Something which as the Argentines were in no circumstances, ah, going to settle for, ah, and anybody could have told them that, and anybody knew that. 
 There is nothing between sovereignty and not sovereignty. 
 But we hoped that something could be found. 
 You know, you go on looking for a solution to this difficult problem. 
 That's the formula by way &mdash; way &mdash; by which you get yourself nearer to disaster. 
 And in addition to that, as governments knew that the House of Commons would not be agreeable, ah, the ah, polite phrase is &bquo;had not been educated up to&equo;, ah, the acceptance of a transfer of sovereignty of the islands, an additional ingredient was thrown in. 
 That this wouldn't happen, except it had the consent, sometimes &mdash; and I fear Nick Ridley fell into this &mdash; it wobbled over except aft &mdash; into &mdash; after consultation. 
 HEALEY: Even Mr Pym made the same wobble, yes. 
 POWELL: Yes, it's, it's a very dangerous wobble&hellip; 
 (Interest and wishes&hellip; 
 ) And it helped to make the House of Commons very anxious and very angry. 
 KING: Are you saying in effect&hellip;  
 POWELL: Ah, ah, I, I am saying in addition that that either meant that the thing was going to be vetoed anyhow by the Falkland Islanders, and that therefore even if Britain wanted to get rid of, of sovereignty, she wasn't going to get rid of it in terms of her own statement; or that the Falkland Islanders were going to be put under so much pressure, ah &mdash; we needn't go into the details of what is meant in those connections, by pressure; I'm sure the Foreign Office will supply the details if requested &mdash; ah, would be put under so much pressure that eventually they would collapse and give way. 
 Now that was what we were doing. 
 We were playing a silly game, which had not a tragic outcome &mdash; it had, thanks to the mercy of providence, a fortunate outcome &mdash; but it had an outcome which is not one which ah statecraft should either aim at or be proud of having achieved. 
 KING: Simon Jenkins, you're the &mdash; you're the author of, ah, of the Battle for the Falklands , or the co-author. 
 Ah, you probably know more about this than just about anybody outside government. 
 Do you think that the Foreign Office, successive British governments, were playing a silly game? 
 SIMON JENKINs: No, I disagree with Enoch Powell on that. 
 Ah, I think the Foreign Office was trying to pursue the only sensible policy as it perceived it at the time, right through the entire period, um, since 1965. 
 And it&hellip; 
 POWELL: But it did exist.  
 &bquo;COMMONWEALTH MORNING AFTER THE IMPERIAL NIGHT BEFORE&equo; Daily Telegraph , 22 November 1983 
 With an impish glint of mischief in her eye the Muse of History looked down and watched the American Marines assault Grenada. 
 Grenada was the last tiny but bitter dreg in the constitutional cup which the United Kingdom has drained in the past thirty-five years; and bravely, though not without a grimace of disgust, did we swallow it. 
 Anybody who supposes that the events of 1983 in the Caribbean have left the humbug of the Commonwealth unscathed is as self-deceived as those who imagine that the humbug of the United Nations has been unscathed by the events of 1982 in the South Atlantic. 
 After World War II the Crown in Parliament of the United Kingdom well understood that it could no longer govern the King Emperor's non-British, any more than his British subjects who were not represented, and could not be represented, in Parliament. 
 With admirable diligence it worked away, renouncing its authority over one territory after another. 
 Thereby, in the eyes not only of the United Kingdom but of the world, each of these territories became a sovereign independent state, alias a nation. 
 As such it was duly added to the membership roll of the contraption known as the United Nations, which asserts that all nations are equal (albeit some more so than others), with one vote each, just as if they were individual human beings in a right-little tight-little democratic State. 
 We disposed of the big fish first, not even so without difficulty; for while some, like Ceylon and Jamaica, were islands, which was a good enough demarcation for rough and ready purposes, others, like the Indians or Nigerians, were not so unmistakable and quarrelled violently over who they were. 
 At times this caused quite a scuffle, especially when we tried to insist on lumping several together and pretending that the result was a nation, albeit a federal one &mdash; rather in the same way as the parliamentary managers of the eighteenth century used to bribe Scottish peers by the batch, half a dozen or a dozen at a time.  
 It was partly because these artificial agglomerations soon broke up that we were left at the finish with a lot of little scraps, which nobody, when not talking through the back of his head, could mistake for potential nations. 
 What to do? 
 We swallowed hard, stiffened our upper lip, and decided to &bquo;see it through&equo; by shutting our eyes and applying the same old formula regardless &mdash; a constitution, a mace, a copy of Erskine May, a Speaker's chair and national independence. 
 By 1982 we had swept up all but a handful of awkward items whose inhabitants, for varying reasons, didn't want to be or couldn't be &bquo;nationalised&equo; &mdash; which was very untidy and inconvenient of them. 
 So, as I say, the Muse of History laughed when Britain, which had risen almost as one man to take the Falklands from the Argentine, then quite logically watched, passive and embarrassed, while the United States occupied the independent sovereign state of Grenada. 
 Shall I say what the Muse is waiting for now? 
 It is to see whether, when someone pinches Rockall, we shall sail to replant the Union flag upon it, exclaiming &bquo;Rejoice, rejoice,&equo; as when we repossessed the likewise uninhabited South Georgia. 
 The Grenada story is delicious on another account. 
 It exposes on a minuscule scale a widely misunderstood but tiresome fact which Australia, Canada and other nations spawned by Britain have learned and taught on a larger scale. 
 It is the fact that when people and territory previously ruled by the Crown in Parliament become a separate and independent state, we do not, because we cannot, endow it with a statehood like our own. 
 Britain is a prescriptive monarchy. 
 The sovereign power inherent in the British Crown, as exercised through Council and through Parliament, derives not from a treaty or document or compact, but from prescription, from the fact that it has been so from time immemorial &mdash; that it is immanent in the nation itself. 
 When we create a new nation, however, we cannot transfer to it this prescriptive authority which is the essence of our own state. 
 We can only pass an Act of Parliament and give it to them with a slap on the back and a &bquo;best of British luck&equo;: &bquo;Here's your constitution,&equo; we say, &bquo;now do what you like with it; you can because you are now independent.&equo; 
 Before 1948 we used to pretend that all such countries were just copies of the United Kingdom, except that, in place of the monarch, they had a Governor-General, who, we assured ourselves and them, represented the monarch. 
 We purported to atomise the person of the Sovereign, so that she was Queen of Canada, Queen of Australia, etc., and eventually, in the pantomime season, Queen of Grenada. 
 She was not, and she is not: the reference to &bquo;her realms&equo; (plural) in the Royal Titles is spurious. 
 The Queen is the prescriptive sovereign  of one realm only, the United Kingdom: elsewhere neither she nor her so-called representatives the governors-general possess an ounce of prescriptive sovereignty. 
 The proceedings of Sir Paul Scoon after the American invasion were just as revolutionary &mdash; meaning validated by force not law &mdash; as had been the proceedings of the superseded military regime. 
 Putting the same point another way, Australia and Canada are as truly republics as are India, Pakistan and Bangladesh. 
 There was a time, no doubt &mdash; it must have been before 1948, when the United Kingdom itself abolished allegiance as the basis of citizenship &mdash; when the pretence of daughter monarchies around the globe was harmless and even arguably beneficial. 
 People wanted to believe it, and no practical reality came into conflict with it. 
 Now the signals are flying everywhere that that time has gone. 
 The prescriptive monarchy of the United Kingdom stands constitutionally isolated in a world where some forty independent republics, large and minuscule, trace their historical origin from a period of rule under the British Crown in Parliament. 
 That common accident endows them with nothing else in common &mdash; nothing else in their own eyes, nothing else in the face of the world, nothing else in verifiable fact, nothing else except a fiction British-made for British consumption. 
 How long can we healthily continue the diet of delusion? 
 Not long, I think, now that internal revolution, disruption and secession, external interference, aggression and absorption are likely to be more and more the fate of these often unstable and highly artificial British ex-dominions. 
 Zimbabwe, Grenada, Cyprus &mdash; they are so many flares that mark the outline of a new path. 
 Their fates concern us in reality no more than those of other independent states which were never British dominions. 
 Our danger is to be beguiled by our own fiction into imagining otherwise. 
 Some time there will have to be an end to this make-believe. 
 Some day the queen's ministers will have to stop advising her to undertake another and yet another journey through the phantasmagoria of cheering crowds and empty ceremonies which mock the memory of a power that was but is no longer.  
 &bquo;WHAT COMMONWEALTH?&equo; 
 The Times , 26 January 1984 
 In a speech at Leicester last Friday I stated what I took to be a constitutional axiom: &bquo;All the public utterances of the sovereign,&equo; I said, &bquo;are covered by the advice of ministers.&equo; 
 Immediately it was announced on behalf of the Prime Minister that there is an exception to this principle, namely, when the sovereign is addressing &bquo;the Commonwealth&equo;. 
 The consequences of that assertion, if it is valid, are peculiar and alarming; but fortunately I can examine it without criticising the sovereign or impugning her judgement, because ministerial advice that ministerial advice is not requisite is also ministerial advice, for which ministers must take responsibility and stand question. 
 If the alleged exception is valid, it must be valid whenever and wherever the sovereign speaks &bquo;to the Commonwealth&equo;: it must apply equally on the Feast of Stephen and on Holy Innocents Day; it must apply whether she addressed &bquo;the Commonwealth&equo; from London or Ottawa or Delhi. 
 Now, it has long been understood that the public utterances of the sovereign to the people of a realm overseas, be it Australia or Grenada, are covered by the advice of her ministers in that realm. 
 This proposition, admittedly, is not without its difficulties when the sovereign is the same person in two or more realms where her ministers may tender divergent or opposing advice on the same subject; but so far the possibilities involved in these different capacities of the sovereign have not caused embarrassment in practice. 
 The same principle however is scarcely thinkable in those countries of the Commonwealth which are republics and where therefore there are no sovereign or ministers. 
 In what capacity does the sovereign address the citizens of India? 
 As Queen of the United Kingdom, visiting India as she might visit France or Israel? 
 If so, her utterances are covered by the advice of her UK ministers, notably the Foreign and Commonwealth Secretary. 
 Or is it as Head of the Commonwealth? 
 If so, there are no responsible ministers by whom she can be advised, because the Commonwealth as such has no government and no ministers, and she must be speaking therefore without responsible advice. 
 The difficulty is magnified when the sovereign is conceived as  addressing &bquo;the Commonwealth&equo; comprising some countries which she rules on the advice of the respective ministers and other countries over which she does not reign at all. 
 This is not merely a curious conundrum. 
 It is a situation which poses an insoluble problem for the Monarch, since there is by definition no common organ of consent and consequently no responsible ministerial advice on which she can constitutionally act. 
 Expressed in other terms, &bquo;the Commonwealth&equo; is not a political entity, or indeed an entity at all except in make-believe. 
 The title &bquo;Head of the Commonwealth&equo;, against which from the government benches I registered a lone protest upon the second reading of the Royal Titles Bill in March 1953, enshrines a paradox which thirty years ago two countries in particular conspired for their own purposes to ignore: India, in order to become a republic while forfeiting none of the privileges which allegiance had conferred, and Britain, in order to feed its delusion that the Empire was being transformed into something brighter and better still. 
 The way had been paved, also deliberately, by the disastrous British Nationality Act of 1948, which purported to recognise a common citizenship based not upon common loyalty but upon adding together the citizenships defined by an ever-increasing number of independent states. 
 It was, incidentally, this severance of citizenship from political realities which made technically possible a huge and unintended settlement in Britain of Asian, African and Caribbean populations. 
 It is the same severance which has placed the monarch in a situation constitutionally inexplicable and indefensible. 
 There is no doubt where the blame lies. 
 It was upon the advice of the Crown's United Kingdom ministers that the chimera of the Commonwealth was invented and installed. 
 Without the legislation, the UK legislation, of a series of British governments, the paraphernalia of a Commonwealth comprising eighteen kingdoms, five other monarchies of which the Queen is not the monarch, and twenty-six republics, with our sovereign as its purported &bquo;head&equo;, could never have come into existence. 
 There is equally little room for doubt who is responsible for its continuance and who alone could end the constitutional contradiction in which the sovereign has been caught up. 
 It is Her Majesty's ministers in the United Kingdom &mdash; who else?  
 &bquo;END THIS FICTION&equo; The Times , 17 July 1986 
 Certain Cabinet ministers told the press on Tuesday they feared a head-on constitutional clash between the Prime Minister and the Queen over sanctions on South Africa. 
 They did what they oughtn't. 
 The sovereign is under a constitutional duty to accept the advice of her ministers tendered through her chief minister so long as they command her confidence &mdash; so long, that is, as they command a majority in Parliament. 
 That being so, it is a gross breach of a privy councillor's duty to attribute to the sovereign personal opinions at variance with the advice of her prime minister or, worse still, to suggest that the sovereign might not accept that advice constitutionally offered. 
 The situation is in no way affected by the title &bquo;Head of the Commonwealth&equo;, which, against my protest, was attached by Parliament in 1953 to the Crown of the United Kingdom. 
 There is no function corresponding to that title which the monarch can constitutionally perform, for one very simple and conclusive reason. 
 There is no constitutional source of advice to the sovereign as &bquo;Head of the Commonwealth&equo;, because as such she has no responsible ministers on whose advice to act. 
 In those Commonwealth countries of which she is the sovereign, she or her representative acts in respect of those countries on the advice of their ministers. 
 In the republics or a country like Malaysia, which has its own monarch, she has by definition no function and receives no constitutional advice. 
 The Queen, I am sure, understands the constitutional position fully and would not contemplate acting other than constitutionally. 
 We have wronged her, and ourselves, by constructing the pretence of a political entity, the Commonwealth, and acting as if it really existed. 
 No amount of talk and pretence will make it reality. 
 Unfortunately, in the course of talking and pretending, the sovereign states can harm themselves in the real exercise of real power. 
 That is the nature of the self-punishment which Britain inflicted on itself by maintaining in its law the assertion that citizens of other countries, wholly independent and acknowledging a different head of state, were nevertheless in every respect members of the single category of &bquo;British subjects&equo;,  possessing within the United Kingdom the rights that attach to that category. 
 The consequences of that monumental humbug belong in this country to the realm of reality. 
 Thirty years of contention and legislation have been powerless to prevent or reverse them. 
 What we can still do is to escape at long last from the constitutional fiction which we once grasped to ease our transition from the capital of a worldwide empire to a nation state alongside other nation states, but which, having produced so much havoc here at home, has turned into an instrument for external duress to be brought to bear on our own political institutions. 
 Above all, I do not believe the people of Britain want to see our constitutional monarchy, the &bquo;eternal jewel&equo; with which our political liberties are bound up, brought into danger or contention by the deceptive device once adopted so ill-advisedly so many years ago for a purpose that is past.  
 &bquo;THE CAUSES OF SUEZ&equo; The Spectator , 26 July 1986 
 After thirty years the memory which abides with me of the Suez episode that began with Egypt's nationalisation of the Canal on 26 July 1956 is of complete bewilderment and the sense of watching an unintelligible drama It was not surprise that Egypt had appropriated the Canal. 
 It was astonishment that anybody could have expected anything else and consequently at the paroxysms of indignation which Government and opposition, press and public, exhibited. 
 What did they think was going to happen after the last British troops evacuated the Canal Zone on 13 June 1956? 
 I had been one of the twenty-eight (twenty-six plus two tellers) Conservative Members who voted on 29 July 1954 against the conclusion of the treaty with Egypt under which that evacuation took place. 
 But I had done so not in the belief that indefinite British occupation of the Zone was practicable but in protest against a treaty which purported to give Britain rights of reoccupation and a policy which proclaimed that Cyprus, Jordan and Kenya afforded adequate geographical alternatives. 
 The frisson of angry surprise and the instant impulse to prepare for a resort to arms which greeted the inevitable puncturing of those myths were therefore emotions I could neither share nor understand. 
 Hunched in a remote and subordinate cranny of government &mdash; devising a rent bill at the Ministry of Housing and Local Government, as a matter of fact &mdash; I was not disposed to go overboard when our armed forces were launched into the attack in November; but what on earth was intended to come out of it and how an occupation found untenable could be tenably restored and sustained by force was beyond the comprehension of this unmoved spectator. 
 How did it happen, and what did it mean? 
 And what if anything does it mean still? 
 William Clark, who was press adviser to Anthony Eden during his premiership, wrote, while under sentence of death from the cancer of which he died last year, a book of m&eacute;moires d'outre tombe  in the unconventional yet quite literal sense of that description. 
 In them he included his diary entries of the days from Nasser's announcement to his own resignation on 6 November when  the ill-fated invasion was ignominiously terminated by a ceasefire. 
 As usual with any major historical event, the causes can be perceived at alternative levels, and as usual all are &mdash; partially &mdash; true. 
 In the situation which he occupied William Clark's eye-level was necessarily that of personalities, above all the personality of the Prime Minister, who combined the propensity to violently emotional reactions with deep anxiety about his alleged indecision. 
 The Prime Minister's wife, Clarissa, appears in the story as an aggravating factor: &bquo;He &lsqb;the PM&rsqb; rang up Clarissa, who is becoming his unofficial and wholly bad press adviser, and asked her advice.&equo; 
 At this level of causation the outcome with a different personality at No. 10 would have been different; but is that historical reality? 
 &bquo;The fact is,&equo; wrote Clark himself on 15 August, &bquo;that if we lose out in the Middle East, we shall be immediately destroyed.&equo; 
 The entry on stage of the French is equally significant. 
 &bquo;The French have been pressing Anglo-French union again &lsqb;11 September&rsqb;. 
 We feel it is impossible at present  because of the Commonwealth.&equo; 
 Indeed, in the very thick of the Suez preparations (14 September) &bquo;the Cabinet was about Plan G &mdash; the current plan for Britain going in with European federation &equo;; and then (18 September) &bquo;the Cabinet held its second meeting on Plan G for British association with the Messina powers in Europe. 
 Clearly the general view is that it will be very dangerous for us to stay out  because we risk a German-dominated Europe.&equo; 
 The Suez event was a parting of many ways; but justice is not done to their complexity by perceiving it as merely the last spasm of an Empire-orientated Britain, a Britain conditioned to regard &bquo;losing out in the Middle East&equo; as immediate destruction. 
 Nor does the crude coincidence of the Suez episode with the run-up to an American presidential election tell all about the changes in Anglo-American relations which flowed from 1956. 
 The assumptions of total British dependence on the USA with which the Clark memoirs show successive British Governments operating in the aftermath of World War II and which were pleaded as necessitating the climb-down in November 1956 were already undergoing an examination which 1956 only accelerated. 
 The pattern of the 1970s and the 1980s was already beginning to be woven on the warp of America and the woof of the European continent. 
 &bquo;A pleasant, cheerful FO character said &lsqb;30 October&rsqb;: &bquo;It's rather fun to be at No. 10 the night we smashed the Anglo-American alliance.&equo;&equo; 
 William Clark put his resignation in on the day of the ceasefire. 
 It is not altogether clear why. 
 &bquo;I must go, clearly, because I cannot defend a policy I candidly dislike,&equo; he wrote on 4 November, having already told Sir Walter Monckton, the Paymaster General, on 1 November that &bquo;I felt I might have to resign as I thought the policy  bad and disastrous.&equo; 
 Yet Clark had known all along of the military preparations &bquo;Musketeer I&equo; and &bquo;Musketeer II&equo; and had been dismayed when Dulles seemed to have aborted them with his Suez Canal Users Club; and after the Anglo-French meeting in London in September he had put out &bquo;a dull communiqu&eacute;, and no one has the least idea of what big things were abroad' . 
 The operative straw seems to have been his exclusion from the inner circle during the twenty-four hours of the joint Anglo-French ultimatum, though back in August Clark had recorded quite dispassionately that &bquo;a good deal of effort is going into trying to find a proper pretext for taking military action. 
 This is because we need to justify our action, though its real basis is salus populi suprema lex .&equo; 
 So in the end what was wrong was the pretext. 
 Professionally that is understandable enough. 
 To the lay reader the revelation of Clark's memoirs is the complete self-assurance with which the effective influence of No. 10 over what does and does not appear in the national media is assumed, whatever slips may occur between cup and lip. 
 There reigned at No. 10 &mdash; and reigns no doubt to this day &mdash; the conviction that the press relations people can &bquo;fix it&equo; the way they are instructed to. 
 Yet the two professions remain deliciously distinct. 
 I do find the habit of ministers of being bloody when things go wrong a trying feature of this job. 
 Success is theirs, failure is ours. 
 I see now why civil servants get so desiccated. 
 Perhaps the secret of all these people at the top is that they have vertigo but out of a feeling of &bquo;the show must go on&equo; they smile in public and are sick off stage. 
 Not all of them, I think.  
 &bquo;THE UK AND COMMONWEALTH&equo; Sydney University, 7 September 1988 
 There is no experience so uncomfortable for a nation as to run headon unawares into an axiom. 
 So unpleasant is the experience that nations adopt a variety of devices for coping with it. 
 The simplest device is simply to deny the axiom altogether; but that is by definition foredoomed to failure. 
 The alternatives are various kinds of pretence or self-deception. 
 The rebellion of the American colonies in the eighteenth century confronted the British with an axiom which, for reasons which are capable of being understood, they found so unpleasant that more than two centuries later they have still not ceased attempting to wish it out of existence. 
 It is a scene of national psychopathology that has its humorous moments as well as its deplorable aspects. 
 By the middle of the eighteenth century the Parliament of England first and then Great Britain had established de facto  control over all aspects of government. 
 The people of Great Britain were governed, however tortuous and artificial the modalities, upon the authority of an elective institution which for historical and other reasons they were content to regard as representing them. 
 The axiom with which America confronted them was that a government so controlled could not govern any population not represented in that Parliament. 
 In front of a consequence so stark the deepest political thinkers recoiled. 
 In the noble eloquence of his plea for conciliation with the colonists, Burke, who based his case on the proposition that they had not been represented at Westminster, drew a strange and illogical conclusion. 
 His own argument involved the admission that no common government, no common state, comprising both Great Britain and the colonies could subsist. 
 Yet he proceeded to declare that by refraining from exercising in America the power of the executive which it controlled in Great Britain, Parliament would preserve the unity of the Empire: 
 The more ardently they love liberty, the more perfect will be their obedience. 
 Slavery they can have anywhere. 
 It is a weed that grows in every soil. 
 They may have it from Spain, they may have it from Prussia. 
 But&hellip;  freedom they can have from none but you&hellip; 
 Deny them this participation of freedom, and you break that sole bond which originally made, and must still preserve, the unity of the empire. 
 It was magnificent; but it was nonsense, and self-contradictory nonsense. 
 The dying Pitt, rejoicing in the House of Lords that the grave had not closed over him before he could protest against &bquo;the dismemberment of this noble empire&equo;, was a tragic figure; but the tragedy was in the absurdity of the protest. 
 After a few years the axiom had taken upon itself the shape of practical reality. 
 There was a new independent nation in the world, and its ambassador, striped waistcoat and all, was presenting his credentials to King George III. 
 The British forthwith addressed themselves to attempting to cope with the axiom nearer home. 
 Gloriously but illogically they rode off to tilt at another windmill. 
 Their trick this time was to pretend that Parliament was really only a legislature and not also in consequence the effective controller of executive government. 
 On that basis the Irish Parliament, whose legislative powers had since the fifteenth century been subject to the sanction of the executive in London, had that limitation removed from it and became a &bquo;free Parliament&equo;, but a Parliament on which no executive, not even the local Irish executive, was dependent. 
 It was an ingenious idea; but the war with revolutionary France soon destroyed the fiction that there could be two Parliaments with but a single executive. 
 The defence of the British Isles was, and only could be, conducted by the Government in London. 
 The deduction was drawn that Ireland and Great Britain, like England and Scotland after 1707, must therefore have one single Parliament. 
 The Union of 1800 was a blamelessly logical acknowledgement of the deadly axiom. 
 It was not however for geographical reasons an acknowledgement that could have been applied across the Atlantic; and subsequent history in the British Isles emphasised a rider or refinement without which the axiom itself is not complete. 
 The axiom states that a population not represented in a parliament cannot share a government which that parliament controls. 
 However, &bquo;not represented&equo; must be understood to include &bquo;not willing  to be represented&equo;, as well as &bquo;not able  to be represented&equo; &mdash; a qualification without which the very essence of parliamentary representation itself is denied. 
 From the mid-nineteenth century onwards it turned out that not the whole population of Ireland was willing to be represented at Westminster but only a portion, the portion namely in which sixteen out of seventeen constituencies still choose to send Members to Westminster today. 
 Meanwhile across the Atlantic Ocean an event had taken place  which was destined to have the most far-reaching consequences. 
 It was essentially a new attempt to revive the Burkeian fallacy of empire through freedom, obedience through liberty. 
 Its surname is Canada; and its christian name is Durham. 
 The immediate impulse was the prospect which arose in the 1830s that Canada might go the same way of rebellion as the American colonies. 
 &bquo;We know better now,&equo; said the British. 
 &bquo;We lost the American colonies because the colonial governments were not in all things answerable to the local parliaments but to the Parliament at Westminster. 
 So all we have to do is to tell the Governor-General of Canada to behave in relation to his local Parliament exactly as our monarch at home behaves in relation to her Parliament of the United Kingdom.&equo; 
 Such was Britain's brave attempt to evade the dreaded axiom. 
 The fatal, fateful thing was that for a century the device appeared to work: Canada felt and behaved as if it was still part of the empire. 
 The impression which was made upon the British by what came to be known as the Canadian model was correspondingly deep and powerful. 
 They were highly self-congratulatory. 
 They had found the answer to the American conundrum, and they assured themselves that no other people on earth would have had the qualities necessary to do so. 
 In fact, they exhibited all the satisfaction of someone who has hit upon a method for causing water to flow uphill. 
 Of course they had not. 
 They were overlooking two facts. 
 As neighbours of the enormously powerful and expansionist United States, the Canadians had a direct and abiding interest in maintaining for their part the fiction that they belonged to the same political entity of the rich and powerful United Kingdom. 
 The fiction seemed a low insurance premium to pay for diplomatic and naval protection, the more desirable in a world where other predatory powers besides the United States were arising. 
 The premium and the insurance however gradually came to look less and less desirable; and when the nexus between them was finally broken in the Second World War, the fiction would be abandoned. 
 Meanwhile &mdash; and it was a long meanwhile &mdash; the British were delighted with themselves and with their statecraft. 
 The other fact which they had overlooked was of a different character but no less important in the long run. 
 The Governor-General had not, by acting like the sovereign on the advice of the spokesmen of a majority in an elected assembly, become the same thing as the sovereign. 
 He had become the president of a republic, exercising a defined formal and ceremonial function, and no amount of royal visits and royal Governors-General could alter the fact. 
 The British monarchy is the seedbed in which parliamentary authority germinated in the soil of England. 
 It is unexportable, because prescription, the  inherent authority of that which has always been so, is a writ which runs only where it has always been so and amongst those amongst whom it has always been so. 
 The British were mistaken in supposing that they continued to have the same sovereign and therefore the same national identity vis-&agrave;-vis  the outside world as the Canadians. 
 They did not: the Canadians had one sort of sovereign, and the British had another sort. 
 The person who sits on the dais in Ottawa or Canberra and goes through the motions of opening a Parliament is not and can not be the same being at all as the person who does these things and has done them from time immemorial at Westminster. 
 The difference is subtle, but the difference is fundamental, even though for a hundred years the British managed not to realise it, because they desperately wanted not to. 
 The point is not, as sometimes supposed, that the sovereign had been made divisible. 
 That could be met by the division of the spheres in which the divided sovereign acted upon different collective advice. 
 The point is that by its nature the British parliamentary monarchy exists only in Britain. 
 However as the nineteenth century proceeded, even the division of the spheres of government &mdash; the separation of internal and external policy &mdash; became increasingly difficult to maintain. 
 If there was to be a common external policy, economic and strategic, which appeared more and more desirable, as between the parliamentarily self-governing populations around the world that were deemed all to be parts of one empire, the logical but crazy conclusion must be to defy the impracticability that had been so clear in the eighteenth century and to envisage an imperial parliament. 
 Sure enough, Joseph Chamberlain and others proceeded to do just that; and sure enough, it was the Canadians who patiently but persistently explained that they would have none of it. 
 A parliament is an institution which implies the common governability of those represented in it. 
 That was where lay the inherent strength of the axiom which the British imagined they had defeated. 
 A common desire and willingness to be subordinate to it is the essential pre-condition of a parliamentary state. 
 In their futile endeavour Joseph Chamberlain and his contemporaries were only re-enacting in modern dress the plot of the mideighteenth-century drama, by proceeding as if a common will and desire to be subordinate existed when it did not. 
 The Canadian model has a curious corollary, which was to have an unhappy future, extending almost down to the present day. 
 I refer to the federal corollary. 
 In Canada the British not only deluded themselves that they had defeated the axiom; they also imagined it was the federal ingredient that had enabled them to do the trick. 
 For the Canadian model to work, a unitary electorate analogous to that  of the UK is required. 
 Where populations, therefore, are incapable of sustaining a single parliamentary representation through their internal differences, the prescription runs: in that case, create a federation, give the federation a parliament, and you have solved your problem. 
 It is of course cheating. 
 But if cheating is necessary, you can commonly get away with it for a time. 
 So everybody had to go federal &mdash; Canada, Australia, South Africa and later on Central Africa and the Caribbean, where it all came unstuck. 
 I have run ahead of chronology however and in particular of the First World War, which the peoples that had entered it as parts of the Empire ended as free-standing independent nations. 
 Britain in 1918 was deeply impressed with the strategic and military contribution made by those nations to victory in Europe and assumed it to be proof of the success of the Canadian model, to which the second Labour Government in 1931 gave statutory form, rather like catching moonbeams, by declaring in the Statute of Westminster preamble that the common identity of the sovereign was of the essence. 
 The end of the First World War was accompanied by unmistakable evidence that the population of the greater part of Ireland had no intention of remaining within the United Kingdom; and when the attempt to force a home rule constitution upon them provoked a rebellion, Britain had to recognise defeat, but insisted upon the Irish Free State accepting what was called Canadian status by recognising the King Emperor as its representative for external purposes. 
 Thereby it remained, in Britain's eyes though not in its own, a part of the Empire, which was beginning about that time to be called the Commonwealth, and its citizens remained British subjects. 
 Crazy logic had reached the ultimate apogee of absurdity &mdash; or perhaps not quite. 
 The British in India had from the beginning of the nineteenth century seen clearly that so unnatural a phenomenon as the government of that teeming subcontinent by the parliamentary electorate of the British Isles could not be destined to be permanent. 
 What they did not profess to understand was how it could be terminated. 
 However, as the nineteenth century proceeded, two developments took place. 
 Britain became obsessed with the conviction that its very existence as a great power hinged upon the possession of India, to the extent that all major policies &mdash; Britain's activities in Africa, for example, or in the Mediterranean, and even its alignments in Europe &mdash; were deduced from the supposed requirements of the Indian Empire and the Route to India. 
 The other concurrent development was the growing and irrepressible conviction that the inhabitants of India would claim and must sooner or later obtain responsibility for their own government. 
 Fantastic though it may seem, in retrospect, the British proceeded  to apply to India the Canadian model, complete with its Burkeian fallacy, that liberty equals empire, and with its federalist corollary. 
 An Indian federation would continue part of a transformed Empire by dint of becoming a self-governed nation. 
 It is doubtful whether a more impressive specimen of mass self-delusion can be produced from any era of recorded history. 
 The final shattering of the delusion did not take place until the 1940s; but when it did occur, it prompted not the abandonment of the system of the delusion itself but a further and almost incredible elaboration of it. 
 The architects and future leaders of the Indian successor state were determined utterly to obliterate any trace or relic of former dependence on Britain and at the same time to maintain that political unity of the subcontinent which British rule had produced. 
 History sometimes exhibits weird symmetries between events distant from one another in place and time. 
 There is such a symmetry between the impossibility of a Canadian-style India and the impossibility of a Canadian-style Ireland. 
 In each case the Canadian fiction of a supposedly identical sovereign was repudiated; and in each case the continuance of a unity which had been due only to the former British connection was made a prior condition for even pretending to play the Canadian game. 
 However, 1948 was not 1921; and India, it may be added, was not Ireland. 
 In order to maintain the illusion that the Indian Union, though a republic in form as well as in reality, remained nevertheless part of the same political entity as the United Kingdom, the British in effect abolished their monarchy itself. 
 That may be an arresting statement, but it is hardly an exaggerated description of what they did. 
 In 1948 they abolished allegiance as the basis of the status of British subjects. 
 Henceforward British subjects were to be the sum total of the citizens of those territories &mdash; some independent and some not independent as yet &mdash; which had formerly been within the allegiance as dominions of the Crown. 
 This alteration in the basis of national status was to have devastating consequences for the present and future population of the United Kingdom. 
 With those consequences I am not in this lecture concerned. 
 More immediately, it meant that, as a matter of self-respect, nearly all the remaining territories of the former empire, as they successively became independent, were bound to become independent as republics. 
 In order that the element of farce might not be missing, it was recognised that the old trick with the Irish Free State and the King Emperor was now obsolete. 
 Rather however than acknowledge that the Irish state, which refused any longer to play the Commonwealth game and declared itself a republic, was therefore a foreign country, Britain proceeded to divide the world not as hitherto into two portions  &mdash; British subjects and aliens &mdash; but into three &mdash; British subjects, aliens and Irish. 
 By a crowning touch of irony, the last-mentioned were still to be treated in the United Kingdom as equivalent to British subjects. 
 The unitary monarchy, though itself (as I have argued) fictitious, on which the Statute of Westminster had insisted in 1931, had now vanished. 
 The reality that an independent nation could pick any sovereign it liked had to be recognised. 
 Still a device was invented to cover up the disappearance of an old landmark; and at the accession of Her present gracious Majesty, she was unlawfully proclaimed by a new title &bquo;Head of the Commonwealth&equo;, subsequently legalised by the Royal Titles Act 1953, against which I am proud to recall that I protested in my place in the House of Commons. 
 I would not wish to underestimate the capabilities of my fellow countrymen for self-deception; but it is difficult to believe that there can be further instalments of the saga which began for the people of Great Britain with the successful revolt of the American colonies. 
 It is an amazing web of delusion which has been woven continuously from Burke in 1775 to, let us say, Fiji in 1987. 
 I am not able, as others may be, to find an aesthetic pleasure in admiring the pattern as it unfolded; for the spectacle is not to an Englishman a reassuring one. 
 Today the United Kingdom is the only prescriptive monarchy which remains on the face of the globe. 
 In it alone, from the Reformation Parliament of 1529 to the European Communities Act of 1972, the prescriptive and therefore undefined and unlimited authority of the monarch has been exercised through an equally unique representative institution. 
 It is an institution which until recently my fellow countrymen valued so highly as willingly to pay any price needful for its preservation. 
 Whether, as one generation succeeds another, that valuation remains intact, I have no means of judging; but there is a counterpart to the uniqueness of that inheritance. 
 The counterpart is that by its nature it cannot be shared with those who by disposition or location are incapable of being represented in the Parliament of the United Kingdom. 
 If parliamentary self-government is the essence of British liberty, the condition upon which we enjoy it is that the United Kingdom is politically distinct and separate. 
 It is easy to understand how irksome that condition has been felt to be and how strong has been the temptation to try to tamper with it. 
 There is something in the British character which predisposes us to push to the limit, and beyond, the resources of self-deception to create the illusion that we can enjoy incompatible advantages simultaneously and secure a prize without paying the price for it. 
 In this process the danger is that we destroy  the inner reality of that which we appear to be preserving. 
 To this anxious and not impartial observer, the United Kingdom today looks perilously near to destroying the inner reality of its inherited parliamentary liberty. 
 13 Doing it the Right way 
 HORACE TRUBRIDGE is the Musicians' Union Careers Adviser. 
 previously having been the project co-ordinator of the Hackney Agency for Music Marketing Action (HAMMA). 
 London's only free music business advice and information agency. 
 As a founder member, songwriter and saxophone player, Horace played in the 1950s-revivalist band Darts from 1975 to 1985. in the early 1980s he also ran an independent record company. 
 worked as a session player and appeared in West End shows. 
 From my experience in many areas of the music business, I offer my &bquo;gameplan&equo; for a band's success. 
 If this is followed, it should let bands progress as far as their creativity will allow. 
 This involves a lot of hard work. 
 But although graft is indispensable, it is no replacement for raw talent. 
 Along with luck, this is the scarce commodity which no one in the music business can manufacture and which everyone in the industry is looking for. 
 I wish you lots of both. 
 The Right Stuff 
 The British music business is extremely competitive and only the bands who are prepared to commit themselves totally to their careers will succeed. 
 When you are forming a band, try to make sure that everyone involved shares the same commitment and dedication. 
 You don't want to work hard for a year establishing your act, get offered a tour, and then find that your drummer won't give up his milk round. 
 Many bands break up because of personality clashes between musicians. 
 For instance, if there is a conflict between the vocalist and guitarist, you can't ignore it hoping that it will go away. 
 The chances are it will blow up into a huge row, or even a fight, just as you are about to go on stage at the Marquee. 
 If you all get on well and are prepared to make the same sacrifices to succeed, you might just be &bquo;the right stuff&equo;.  
 Equipment and Band Economics 
 Adequate equipment is essential. 
 So often there is an imbalance in the quality of a band's gear. 
 For instance, the keyboard player may be using &pound;5,000 worth of state-of-the-art technology while the bass guitarist is playing through a tired old AC30. 
 This shows that this band isn't working as a unit. 
 The keyboard player obviously cares more about advancing his or her career than the future of the band. 
 To buy the equipment you need, open a band bank account and put in whatever you can afford every week. 
 Probably, some band members will contribute more than others. 
 As long as proper written accounts are maintained, everyone can be paid back when the band begins to make money. 
 Also, keeping band accounts is useful to familiarize you with the practicalities of money coming in and going out. 
 If you never lose sight of this information, you should be able to guard against extortion by unscrupulous industry entrepreneurs. 
 Finally, try not to go wild with the amount of equipment you buy, because you can use money for other things. 
 For example, if you hadn't spent so much on a &bquo;super duper&equo; multi-flange guitar pedal, you could have made a profit by having more band T-shirts on sale at your gigs. 
 The Band Sound 
 Every successful band has its own sound. 
 Whatever music they play, you always recognize the band's unique style. 
 This is the elusive quality which record companies look for. 
 To develop your band &bquo;sound&equo;, you have to identify it. 
 If you rehearse in different rooms, setting up the equipment randomly, then it will take you a very long time to achieve this (the chances are you never will). 
 It is worthwhile to choose a rehearsal room which suits your music, and stick to it. 
 The first time you use the rehearsal room, spend as long as necessary setting up your equipment until each member of the band can hear themselves and everyone else clearly. 
 Then draw diagrams showing exactly where the gear is positioned, where the musicians and vocalists are standing, and what the levels are on the amps and the instruments. 
 From now on, every rehearsal should be arranged and set up in this way, so that your band will sound the same every time you rehearse. 
 With this method, you should be able to identify your band's strengths and weaknesses quite quickly, and to write and arrange accordingly. 
 Tape every rehearsal on a portastudio or cassette machine, and distribute copies of the tape amongst the band well in advance of the next rehearsal. 
 This gives each musician time to practise so that you all arrive at the rehearsal ready to try out new, revised musical parts. 
 Taping rehearsals also reduces the likelihood of arguments about who played what at the last rehearsal. 
 If you need someone to do the taping, either make it one musician's responsibility, or try to find    someone who would like to mix your sound at gigs. 
 At this stage you don't need an experienced sound engineer. 
 Enthusiasm and a willingness to learn are far more important, because working with a portastudio and a mixing desk in the rehearsal room will teach a novice engineer a lot about sound mixing. 
 The advantage of this is that when you start gigging, you have someone out front who knows your songs, and who can either mix your sound or at least keep an eye on the house engineer. 
 The Smiths 
 The Team around the Band 
 Ideally, your basic team should be a roadie and a sound engineer. 
 Your sound engineer should mix the out-front sound at every gig and attend rehearsals regularly to keep up with new material. 
 Your roadie should organize transport to gigs, getting your equipment in and out of venues and also attend to any on-stage problems which may come up when you are playing. 
 You may also have a manager who organizes the arrangements for gigs as well as developing new areas of work like contracts for recording, publishing, with an agency or for merchandising. 
 If all goes well, you may eventually sign an agency deal so that you have someone booking your gigs and possibly arranging tours for the band. 
 If you reach the stage where you are playing national tours, then you will also have a lighting crew, more sound technicians and maybe even wardrobe staff. 
 As soon as any contracts are offered you will have to engage a lawyer to negotiate on your behalf. 
 And when the money starts rolling in, you will need an accountant to handle all of your financial affairs. 
 As a general rule, it is a good idea not to choose the same accountant as your manager. 
 Style and Image 
 The UK has the most fashion-conscious record buyers in the world. 
 Although some bands achieve success without considering their clothes and haircuts, these aesthetic qualities have an important influence over a band's commercial potential. 
 Often, bands are naturally pushed into the style and image that is associated with their music, like heavy metal, gothic, hip-hop, punk and ragamuffin. 
 All of these have an accepted code of dress which the people who buy these records also adopt. 
 If your band's sound is less strongly defined, then you may need some help to dream up a style and image Libraries are a good source of inspiration, and by browsing through the books and magazines on fashion you may get some ideas. 
 Try the local charity shops as well. 
 Many bands have taken on a style of clothes which they bought second-hand.  
 Making the Demo 
 Once you have rehearsed, you will need to record a demo, especially as many venues won't consider you for a gig unless they have heard you on tape. 
 Ideally, you should record the three strongest songs in your set. 
 Go to the best studio your budget will allow and remember that studios will often drop their price if you haggle. 
 The most common mistake that bands make on their first recording session is to be underrehearsed. 
 Usually that results in a lot of wasted time and money as you sort out problems which should have been dealt with before you opened the studio door. 
 Also, uncertainty on your part can lead to the risk of you surrendering all control over the session to the engineer, who will be more than happy to move into the producer's chair. 
 Try to meet the engineer before your sessions. 
 Play him or her you can explain the results which you want from the session and the engineer can advise you on any extra equipment which you may need to hire. 
 This gives the engineer a chance to hear your music and assess how to record your band. 
 All of this saves valuable and expensive studio time. 
 Never combine mixing tracks with recording sessions. 
 If you try to do it all in one go, you will almost always be dissatisfied with the result. 
 Probably, you will end up paying for a remix. 
 If you can afford it, spend two or three days recording your tracks, take away a rough mix and then go back to the studio after a week or so. 
 Then you have time to fix on a definite idea of how you want the final mix to sound. 
 Getting Gigs 
 The main thing to remember when looking for your first gigs is that promoters, bookers and pub landlords aren't bothered whether you are going to be the next U2. 
 Apart from a few notable exceptions, all they care about is feet through the door and selling beer. 
 With that in mind when you approach them, stress that this is one of your first gigs and you are going to get all your family and friends along to support you. 
 This should be enough to convince someone to give you a chance. 
 However, you can't rely on your family and friends forever. 
 You are going to need to develop a following if you want to move on and play bigger and better venues. 
 Some bands think that just playing gigs will be enough to attract a following. 
 The trouble with this attitude is that there are just too many bands around for that to happen. 
 To give your band a better chance, you will have to do some marketing. 
 The secret of attracting more people to your gigs is to get your band's name better known. 
 Currently, most people won't go and see a band who they haven't heard of. 
 Similarly, people tend to assume that if they have heard of a band, then they are probably worth going to see.  
 If you can come up with an interesting band &bquo;logo&equo; or visual image, that can be a cheap way of self-promotion on stickers and badges. 
 Just think of how many people will walk past and subconsciously absorb your band's name on a sticker which is on a high street lamp post, even if it only stays there for a couple of days. 
 If only one of those people is wondering what to do on a Friday night, thumbs through the listings, spots your band's name, and thinks &bquo;I've heard of that band, they must be worth seeing&equo;, that sticker, which cost you less than a penny, has been very cost effective. 
 T-shirts are worthwhile and can be very cheap to produce. 
 Everyone wants an original T-shirt, and they are walking advertisements for your band. 
 Also, you could put your regular fans on a mailing list, writing to them every month to inform them of your next gigs and urging them to bring more of their friends along, in return for a back stage pass to Wembley when you play there! 
 Contact the local press and encourage them to write about the band and advertise or review your gigs. 
 Put together leaflets listing your forthcoming gigs and distribute them around colleges, street markets, other people's gigs, and trendy clothes shops. 
 If none of this works, maybe the band is just no good. 
 Doing the Gig 
 It is essential to have written confirmation from the booker or the venue of all the arrangements about your gig. 
 The most important of these are the gear &bquo;get-in&equo; time, sound-check start and finish times, on- and off-stage time, the guest list allowance, the food and drinks allowance, dressing-rooms, PA and lighting details, and the fee. 
 Arrive punctually to be ready for the sound check at the agreed time. 
 If you are in the support band, you will almost inevitably have to put up with delays in your sound check as well as other inconveniences. 
 In this situation, it hardly ever helps if you start shouting or losing your cool. 
 The best approach is to be patient and philosophical. 
 If you arrive late, raise merry hell, and insult the stage crew you will certainly be remembered. 
 However, if you are charming and efficient you may actually get booked again by the venue: Similarly, all sorts of things often go wrong on stage, and the golden rule here is not to communicate mistakes to the audience. 
 The chances are that the punters only know an error has been made if the drummer decides to smirk at the guitarist, or the guitarist turns away from the audience to have a good laugh at the keyboard player. 
 If you learn to keep your emotions in check until you are all back in the dressing-room, then at least you will leave the punters thinking that they have seen a professional band who might not be quite ready for a week at the Hammersmith Odeon.  
 Spare guitar strings, picks, and drumsticks should always be on hand so that any equipment breakdowns can be solved quickly and efficiently. 
 When you finish your set, get your equipment off stage quickly. 
 If you leave your gear on stage, you may find that someone else has moved it for you, and they won't be as careful as you. 
 No matter how badly your set goes, if you have a professional attitude to your work and a friendly disposition, you will find that people will want to work with you again. 
 Doing a Showcase 
 The purpose of a showcase is to perform in ideal conditions to an audience mainly of music business professionals whom you have invited. 
 This can be expensive and you are always gambling with the possibility that the people who you want to hear your music won't come. 
 Usually showcases are paid for by management companies in an attempt to &bquo;open the bidding&equo; on a new act. 
 Due to the cost and unpredictability of showcases, few bands without management arrange them. 
 If you want to chance it, the first thing to do is book a venue. 
 This will cost you anything from &pound;200 to &pound;1,000, depending on the hall's size, equipment and location. 
 It is impossible to guarantee that anyone you invited will turn up, so you could try to guard against wasting your time and money by sending courtesy cars to pick up the more important people. 
 If you go to those lengths, you are obviously taking a big financial risk. 
 There are a number of showcase venues around London, most of them connected to studios. 
 often, showcases take place in the afternoon. 
 To create more of an atmosphere, you could invite some of your ardent fans to indulge in the free drinks and snacks which are generally provided for the guests, along with a band publicity pack. 
 This should contain band photos, a demo tape and a biography. 
 successful showcases can create substantial industry interest in a band, but if you are going to pull out all the stops, you have to spend a lot of money with no guarantee of a positive result. 
 Get to Know the Biz 
 By now, you should have reached the stage when your potential as a successful recording artist is evident. 
 In this situation, you may only need to wave your tape under the right A&amp;R person's nose to be offered a recording contract. 
 But who is the right A&amp;R person? 
 Currently, major record companies' A&amp;R departments are a lot more efficient than musicians realize. 
 If you are regularly attracting a big audience at your gigs, then you have probably been seen by A&amp;R personnel, whether you live in Camden, Cardiff or Carlisle. 
 If you have worked hard to develop a solid gigging career and no one is offering you a deal, the time may have come to approach record  companies directly. 
 sending tapes to the A&amp;R departments is almost a total waste of time. 
 Instead, you need to wise up about how the industry works and which people in recording companies are the most influential when it comes to signing and selling musicians, work. 
 Reading the popular music press helps build a picture of which record companies deal in the different styles of music, but only by reading the trade papers will you identify the key individuals in each company who should be invited to your gigs and sent your tape. 
 The trade papers are expensive, but you could ask your local library to order them. 
 Then, someone from your band can take charge or reading them through every week, taking notes on anything which might be useful. 
 This way, you can make up a &bquo;hit list&equo; of personnel within companies to whom you want to send your tape. 
 once you have mailed out your tapes, it becomes somebody's job to phone all of these people everyday until you make contact and you get some feedback. 
 When you do speak to your target people, it is important to emphasize that all you want is the person's opinion and that you will phone back in a couple of weeks to find out what they think. 
 This process rarely runs as smoothly as I have suggested. 
 often, it takes months of phone calls before you have completed your &bquo;hit list&equo;, and I would suggest that whoever takes on this job should have a very carefree and optimistic attitude. 
 Eventually, you should have collected the opinion of everyone on your &bquo;hit list&equo; and, if no one has shown any interest in your music, you need to consider their reactions very carefully. 
 If certain criticisms have cropped up consistently, you must decide either to correct these problems or to soldier on in defiance of market opinion. 
 Protect Yourself 
 Young songwriters are often worried about record companies and other artists stealing their songs. 
 The instances of this happening are few and far between. 
 Nevertheless, it makes sense to take a few simple precautions. 
 Always mark your demos clearly with the copyright symbols (a letter &bquo;c&equo; in a circle) followed by the year in which the songs were written and the writers' names. 
 In Britain, copyright exists as soon as a song is recorded on to tape or written on manuscript. 
 It is easy to protect your songs' copyrights. 
 The best ways are included in the &bquo;Copyright and performing Right&equo; article in this book. 
 Any musician who is seriously embarking on a career in the music business should join the Musicians' Union. 
 The union will fight your case through the courts if someone tries to rip you off, it will check over contracts for you and offer cheap instrument insurance (see the Musicians' Union article for details). 
 If you are offered any work on television or radio you will need to join the union.  
 The Buzz 
 The most effective way to attract record company interest is to create a buzz. 
 Everyone has heard that there is a big buzz going around about one band or another, but what does that mean? 
 Usually, a band creating a &bquo;buzz&equo; is doing very successful gigs and totally ignoring the record companies. 
 If you go to one of their gigs, you will see row upon row of A&amp;R men standing at the back in their black leather jackets, all ready to make an offer to record the band. 
 Don't think you have to be based in London to create a buzz, as recent history has shown that new music movements rarely originate in the capital. 
 You are probably much better placed in your home town or nearest city. 
 The main ways to produce a buzz are by being brilliant live and by winning over the media. 
 If the popular music press start raving about you, people will flock to your gigs. 
 If you are a great live act, they will keep coming back and so will the record companies. 
 You should always keep the press up to date with what the band is doing and where you are playing. 
 It may be worth sending them your demos, as well as pictures and biographies, and hope that someone takes an interest in you. 
 Like most of your career, starting a buzz depends on the success of your gigs. 
 Any number of things can create your buzz &mdash; a much touted line of original band T-shirts, well-attended &bquo;happening&equo; gigs, or something as basic as an unusual band name. 
 It is by no means unheard of for a band to be offered a deal on nothing more than a &bquo;concept&equo;. 
 Your job is to go out and create as large a market for your band as is possible for an act without industry representation. 
 If you achieve this, then a record deal is just around the corner, and you will have earned yourself a strong negotiating position which should enable you to sign the deal you want and not the first deal that is offered. 
 It is important to realize that a deal's merits should not be judged solely on the size of the advance and the royalties being offered. 
 You may feel that only a major record company can offer your band the right level of investment and promotion. 
 But you have to balance that with the way a major won't allow you the same freedom of artistic licence and influence over your promotion and development that an independent company can offer. 
 There are innumerable instances of bands signing large deals to major record companies only to find that the aim of the record company is to try and push the band in a totally unsuitable direction. 
 When that happens it is rare for the band to win the resulting battle and emerge unscathed. 
 In fact, months of wrangling between the band's manager and the record company usually ends with the band being dropped, by which time the other record companies who initially showed interest have gone cold. 
 As in any large money-making industry there are crooks and con men masquerading as successful industry figures, and there is an  understandable temptation to sign a deal with absolutely anyone after years of rejection. 
 That is precisely what these crooks play on. 
 As a rule of thumb never sign a recording/publishing/production deal where you are expected to invest your money in the recording or promotion of your material. 
 This is certainly not a mainstream industry practice and the instances where this has occurred have largely proved to be cases of cleverly couched extortion. 
 Single Release 
 Releasing a single is probably the most effective way to promote a band. 
 Initially, you only need five hundred records, the total cost of which can be less than &pound;500. 
 Once you have recorded your music, the first step to releasing it is to make the cuts. 
 These are soft lacquer discs which record your &bquo;A&equo; and &bquo;B&equo; side from your studio master tape (these discs can be either 7&ins; or 12&ins;, depending on your chosen format). 
 The next process turns these soft, lacquer discs into metal stampers, and all your records will be pressed from these. 
 There are lots of companies who will take charge of this whole operation, including the printing and fixing of the labels. 
 Alternatively, you can sometimes save money by using different firms for each process. 
 Look in the trade press to find them. 
 If you want a printed sleeve for your record, you need them before the discs are being made so that they can be delivered to the pressing plant and bagged up. 
 Five hundred picture sleeves can cost from &pound;200 to &pound;500 depending on the number of colours and the thickness of the card. 
 It is worth trying to get a distribution company to take your record on. 
 Their cut will be around 30 per cent of the &bquo;dealer&equo; price, which is what the shops pay for your record, bearing in mind that your record will only reach the shops if the dealer asks for it. 
 That is where the plugger and press officer come on the scene. 
 If you can't afford them, you will need to do both jobs. 
 send your record to every DJ and radio producer in the country who you think might give it a play, and follow up your mail-out with a phone call. 
 Also, send your record to journalists on all of the popular music press and phone them as well. 
 If you can get some coverage, that may encourage the dealers to respond to the media's interest in you. 
 If that doesn't work, you can always sell the record at gigs and get back your investment that way. 
 Pluggers and Press Officers 
 If you can afford it, hiring a press officer and a plugger will maximize the impact of your record. 
 A press officer should try and gain exposure for your record through the media. 
 He or she should have good relationships with music press journalists and also have contacts within radio and television. 
 He or she should mail out your  single with a press release and photo to all their contacts. 
 The press release will include information about the music and the band which you hope will be used in reviews. 
 A plugger's job is to get your record played on the radio. 
 BBC Radio 1 is the most influential radio station in Britain and it is every plugger's dream to get their records regularly on to Radio 1's &bquo;A&equo; list. 
 However, there are many other radio stations around the country that can influence the success of your record, albeit only on a regional basis. 
 Your plugger should contact all the DJs with whom he or she has a good relationship, trying to persuade them to play your record. 
 To hire a plugger and a press officer, will cost you anything from &pound;100 a week each, depending on their track record. 
 Unless you have a personal recommendation, you can find professional pluggers and press officers listed in industry handbooks and advertising in the trade press. 
 Three weeks is usually long enough to see whether your single is going to be a national success. 
 If your record starts to pick up air play and get reviewed just after three weeks, it may be worth keeping  yor  plugger and press officer on for a bit longer. 
 If the record isn't happening in any of the media, it is probably best to cut your losses and pay the bill. 
 When you approach pluggers or press officers, bear in mind that this is how they make their money, and the amount of enthusiasm which they show for your product may not be a true indication of the coverage which they can secure. 
 Indies 
 The rise and fall and rise again of independent record companies is a topic of great debate within the industry. 
 What makes a successful indie label? 
 Everyone has their own idea but history shows that certain elements are essential to the long term success of an indie. 
 It may take several releases and many months before the company starts to see a return on its investments, so it is essential for an indie to have a relatively solid financial base to see it through the difficult early stages and to sustain the levels of promotion until an act on the label breaks. 
 some of the most successful of the small indies have achieved success largely by catering for specialist markets (generally ignored by the majors) and developing a good reputation for its product with the fans of particular styles, so much so that some indie labels enjoy instant sales of a new release on the strength of the quality of their past product. 
 This is called niche marketing which is a familiar concept in all forms of retailing. 
 situation Two, 4AD, Creation and Factory are good examples of this practice. 
 These companies realized at an early stage that there is no point in trying to compete with the majors in releasing daytime radio or &bquo;Top of the Pops&equo; material, and that it would be better to find acts who have    proved popular on the live circuit but who are considered too left field for the majors. 
 This approach has paid dividends for some indies and has helped to establish the following companies as real market forces: Mute with Depeche Mode, Rough Trade with the Smiths, stiff with Madness, and more recently silvertone with the stone Roses. 
 Depeche Mode 
 Whether you sign a deal with an indie label, or release your own records, the success of your records will depend on the amount and quality of their promotion. 
 A distributor won't take your record unless he or she can see a demand for it. 
 Likewise, a dealer won't want a record taking up space in the racks of his or her shop unless he or she thinks the public will ask for it. 
 People aren't going to request your record unless they have heard of it, and finally, they won't have heard of your record unless it has been promoted properly through the usual channels of TV, radio, music press, national press and live shows. 
 Your record doesn't have to be picked up by all these routes for promotion, but if you enjoy Record of the Week in NME  at the same time as receiving good reviews of your live shows and the occasional play on Radio 1, this should allow you to make impression on the Indie charts or even the national top 100. 
 This would be considered a success for a first release from a fairly new act. 
 It is rare for an Indie band to take off big on the strength of a first record. 
 The process is more gradual than can be the case on a major. 
 The timing of your promotion in relation to your record's release date is crucial. 
 The idea is to try and develop a steady build up of air play before the record is released so that on the week of release there is a good demand for the record and this reflects in your chart position. 
 The real trick is then to sustain a high enough level of air play, press and TV to allow the record to &bquo;cross-over&equo; and appeal to people other than the band's fans. 
 When this happens it is time to celebrate and consider all the various offers raining in from the major labels. 
 Don't Delay, Start Today! 
 I want to underline the biggest mistake which I believe bands make when they are starting out. 
 Bands spend too much time chasing A&amp;R personnel and other industry figures, and not enough time chasing punters, developing a following and creating a &bquo;buzz&equo;. 
 If you can do those three, then the music business will soon be chasing you. 
 Further Reading 
 These are some sources of useful information about who's who in the industry. 
 Those listed with addresses aren't always easily available in the shops. 
 A. Jenkins and O. Smith (eds.), 
 The Town and Country Music Guide  (Penguin). 
  Music Week  magazine (bi-weekly) The British Music Yearbook  (Rhinegold Publishing). 
 The Making Music Handbook  (Track Record Publishing). 
 The Music Week Directory  (Music Week Publications, 40 Long Acre, London WC2E 9J2). 
 The White Book  (Birdhurst Ltd., PO Box 55, Staines, Middlesex TW18 4UG). 
 Rock Journalists and How to Use Them 
 DAVE HILL began his career as a contributor to the NME  in 1981, moving swiftly on to become music editor at London's City Limits  listings magazine. 
 By 1986 he had reverted to freelancing on several national newspapers and magazines before joining the newly launched Independent  as rock critic. 
 He now works as a general freelance feature writer for the Guardian, Independent  on Sunday  and Arena among others and has published several books including a biography of Prince. 
 Who do They Think They Are? 
 There was a time when rock journalists were easy to characterize or, at least, to caricature. 
 Wan and red-eyed, and nearly always male, they wore rebel chic regalia and communicated in either a hyperactive babble or a laboured monotone. 
 They could be found, posing madly, directly adjacent to whatever was going free at any bohemian hostelry in town. 
 They wrote for a small range of specialist titles, some of them bright and poppy, others resoundingly self-important, and all of them perfectly arcane to anyone outside a specific, like-minded clientele. 
 In this, the rock hack fraternity unerringly reflected the culture it documented. 
 As a bizarre amalgam of egalitarianism, rebellion, idealism, moral sloth and wanton self-indulgence, rock generated the literati it deserved, from the early-1960s generation of giggly pop scribes (who pushed the old-school showbusiness correspondents aside) to the &bquo;serious&equo; boy obsessives who stumbled from the 1970s' underground, wielding big neuroses and even bigger words. 
 The post-punk era has made these convenient stereotypes if not redundant, at least seriously limited. 
 Even apparently subversive convulsions like punk ended up encouraging rock's incursions into all sectors of modern consumerism, and so the music's press coverage has altered accordingly. 
 Today, the specialist pop and rock rags  no longer have the subject to themselves and only the most conservative publications on the news-stands fail to acknowledge that some subsection of the now sprawling rock field is of interest to their readers. 
 Indeed, the music industry can reasonably claim its market to include anyone from 5 years to 50, taking in both sexes and every social class. 
 As a result, it is hardly surprising that everything from Patches  to the Daily Telegraph  employs at least one rock correspondent, from a teenage school-leaver in doorstep Nikes and a back-to-front baseball cap to some affable dilettante with a plum in his mouth and old school tie. 
 Elvis has a lot to answer for. 
 Where do I Begin? 
 Aspiring rock artists should remember one golden rule when dealing with the press: there are no rules. 
 Winning the favour of this curious breed is largely a lottery. 
 Those with any degree of power and influence are already deluged with promotional material, atrocious records and pre-release cassettes, the vast majority supplied by the generously resourced press offices of major record companies. 
 only the most conscientious (and, frankly, those with nothing better to do) dutifully plough through everything that flops out of a jiffy bag and on to their desk. 
 The few communications which do receive full attention normally achieve this through a combination of chance, inside information and relentless harrassment. 
 As an unknown you can't rely on the first, and very likely have no hip London friends or business connections to facilitate the second. 
 That leaves only the third, and even then any serious nagging offensive requires careful planning and execution to stand a chance of success. 
 First, select your target publications. 
 The national dailies can be dismissed quickly, especially the tabloids. 
 Unless you can promote yourself as a bit-part player in some concocted yarn involving Madonna, outlandish sexual indiscretions, wilful substance abuse or, better still, all three, they aren't going to be interested. 
 At the snob end of the market, the Independent , the Guardian , and the Observer  offer the most serious critical coverage of the rock world, tending to employ writers with some previous pedigree. 
 However, editorial priorities are inevitably slanted against the exposure of new acts. 
 When it comes to profiles and interviews, familiar names usually get the nod over the up-and-coming, partly because they are the ones the powers-that-be have heard of, and partly because the famous and/or notorious are what a less obsessive and more catholic readership wants to know about. 
 This inclination to celebrate the established rather than unearth the unknown is also echoed by many of the specialist titles. 
 Smash Hits , easily Britain's biggest-selling pop magazine, is completely geared to  reflecting the mainstream. 
 You need to be either in the charts or heading that way to earn space in those gossipy pages. 
 The same goes for its imitator, Number One , and also the reams of general interest glossies aimed at girls and women. 
 In the end, the print media offer only very limited avenues to the exposure of bands and artists without industry backing or friends in the right places. 
 What hope there is resides primarily in the same section of the news-stands as it has for several years &mdash; the &bquo;serious&equo; and &bquo;specialist&equo; music press. 
 Covering the broad territory of rock and pop New Musical Express , Sounds, Melody Maker  and RM  (formerly Record Mirror ) are the longest-established weekly titles. 
 still blessed with a scent of what used to be called the counter-culture, they are also the most responsive to music generated from outside the mainstream corporate structure. 
 Most of their readers are young, white and male and their interest in the music scene is intense. 
 These four publications tend to reflect the range of musics which fit most neatly into the category of &bquo;rock&equo; (white music as opposed to the primarily black forms, &bquo;soul&equo;, &bquo;funk&equo;, &bquo;reggae&equo; and so on), although the emphasis varies from one magazine to the next. 
 NME , for instance, has always included substantial coverage of black popular forms &mdash; soul, reggae, hip-hop &mdash; although this has not always met with their readers' approval. 
 Sounds , on the other hand, is strongly orientated towards guitar-based white rock. 
 Today's Melody Maker  concentrates on pop's more adventurous independent fringes, while RM  remains a likeable dog's dinner, differing from the others in its A4 format, its glossy colour pages, and content which veers from a left-field feature style to consumer-guides for club DJs. 
 All four are united by a healthy disrespect for dominant tastes and the remains of a reputation for exposing new talent before the industry finds it. 
 The bad news for small-time acts is that this exploratory role has diminished significantly over the last ten years. 
 In the period beginning just before the punk explosion and ending around 1982, the rock press played a decisive part in the making and shaping of a succession of trends from punk itself to Two-Tone, the so-called new pop phase and the emergence of quasi-mystical underground acts like Echo and the Bunnymen. 
 The tight links between journalists and the flourishing independent label scene, local entrepreneurs and key grass-roots venues meant that they all helped to form tastes rather than simply reacting to them. 
 However, as the industry became more organized, the rock papers have declined in importance. 
 This is reflected in the pre-eminence of the smart, highly professional and rather conservative rock monthly Q , launched in 1986. 
 With little of the didactic or combative attitude which characterized NME  during the late 1970s, Q  concentrates  most successfully on giving its affluent, young male readers what they already know they want. 
 Currently, Melody Maker , written by a verbose array of excitable young ideologues, is the most dissenting and innotative of the four general titles and the one most inclined to put some avant garde confection like the sugar Cubes on the front page before anyone else has heard of them. 
 The other group of music papers which aspiring acts should look to are those catering to some very specific style and its devoted audience. 
 The most successful title of this type is the heavy metal bible, Kerrang . 
 Founded by a breakaway group of journalists from Sounds , it has gone on to outsell its progenitor and, though primarily star-oriented, considers it has a duty to reflect the grass-roots scene as well. 
 It is an obvious place for young hard rock/heavy metal acts to make themselves known. 
 In a similar way, exponents of anything fitting the nebulous description New Acoustic Roots (and its variants) should keep a keen eye on Folk Roots  magazine (monthly) for potential sympathizers; jazz practitioners should get the studious Wire  (monthly) and those operating in the more popular black fields of soul, funk, rock or rap should follow the perennial Echoes  (weekly, formerly Black Echoes ) or Blues and Soul  (biweekly). 
 There is also a steady turnover of smaller, and often short-lived, black music mags reflecting underground phenomena like hip-hop. 
 Regular perusal will make clear which journalists might be most sympathetic to your particular style. 
 Finally, don't forget the entertainment pages of your own local papers or the arts coverage of college magazines. 
 Their patronage may not launch you to instant international attention, but they might help to raise the takings at your next gig in the junior Common Room or village hall, simply by listing the date, time and place. 
 You now know who it is you want to impress. 
 The next stage is to take a long, hard look at yourself. 
 Who Are You? 
 Except in the most arid and scholarly publications, your value to journalists can never be measured simply in terms of the quality of your music. 
 so before you embark on your campaign of harrassment, put yourself in the shoes of your prospective target. 
 First, ask: &bquo;Why should he or she want to write about me?&equo; second, and just as important, consider: &bquo;Why should his or her editor want to publish an item about me?&equo; 
 The crucial point is that having a great sound is one thing, but being a good subject for an article may be something else entirely. 
 For that reason, it is worth thinking about what is interesting about you from a journalist's point of view before trying to woo him or her with your beautiful noise.  
 It is no coincidence, for example, that stars like Boy George and Morrissey enjoy so much front-cover exposure. 
 It isn't only that they enjoy commercial success and critical acclaim, but because they are, in the jargon of the trade, &bquo;good copy&equo; &mdash; talkative, controversial, witty and opinionated on a whole range of topics. 
 Journalists just pop them a question and let them get on with it. 
 The subsequent article almost writes itself. 
 But you don't have to be as colourful a performer or as vivid a personality as these two to make an interesting subject. 
 From the journalist's position, any sign that you have put some thought into your music, your look or your lyrics, is welcome. 
 stock responses like &bquo;well, you know, we don't really think about it that much, actually&equo;, send the hearts of even the least demanding interviewer plummeting into their boots. 
 so before you start trying to make contact with the press, try to figure out what is engaging or unusual about you. 
 It could be your background, your experiences, the audience you attract or anything that smacks of idiosyncrasy. 
 Whatever else you do, please  avoid musicianly prattle about your favourite brand of guitar strings. 
 Such an exercise of critical self-analysis will not only help make you a more appetizing prospect as a subject, it will probably benefit you artistically as well. 
 The Leisure Process 
 Once you have decided which of your manifold assets to emphasize, you need to get practical. 
 Rock journalists receive far more unsolicited material than they know what to do with. 
 The bulk of it, though, is just standard major record company dross which is greeted with a yawn and propelled directly into the nearest rubbish bin. 
 To avoid this routine ignominy, you need to turn the journalists' boredom to your own advantage. 
 1. 
 Printed Matter 
 The staple mode of communication is the press release. 
 This comprises, quite simply, one or more pieces of paper on which are typed details of forthcoming gigs, record releases or just general bits of news and information relating to individual artists. 
 With new acts, a brief biography is also often included by way of introduction. 
 Record companies generally send these out some time before an event or the release of a product in order to whip up a bit of advance interest from the press. 
 The reasons for this are obvious. 
 Firstly, the bare details find their way into the news sections of all relevant publications so the artist's fans can place orders at record shops,  apply for concert tickets and generally help to build up the (ahem) &bquo;buzz&equo;. 
 secondly, it gives individual journalists due warning that they should plan any prospective coverage to coincide with the artist's activities, simultaneously responding to public interest and amplifying it further. 
 The trouble with most biographies and press releases is that they are boring &mdash; very, very boring indeed. 
 The press officers who compose them aren't employed for their outstanding literary flair and their missives routinely come replete with weak jokes and dismal puns. 
 What a joy it is to find a press pack that is genuinely unusual, interesting, witty, self-deprecating or even just plain mad. 
 since unknown, unsigned acts have no one to compose such epistles but themselves, there is a great opportunity to bring a little sunshine into a cynical hack's life. 
 Economy is the key. 
 Get to the point, tell people what they need to know and do it with as much style, clarity and substance as possible. 
 The corporate communiqu&eacute; can be set out on anything from regulation A4 paper with a staple in the corner, to grandiose box presentations containing &bquo;sampler&equo; cassettes or compact discs previewing the alleged highlights of a forthcoming release. 
 However, any sceptical correspondent worth their salt will show far more respect for a personalized, do-it-yourself presentation with a touch of imagination rather than all the glitz in Hollywood. 
 2. 
 Cassettes 
 Naturally, any prospective support from a journalist will depend most of all on what you sound like. 
 Ultimately, if people don't want to hear you, they don't want to know you. 
 once again, many rock critics receive enough tapes &mdash; and, for that matter, video promos &mdash; to build a model village. 
 As ever, the knack is to make yourself stand out from the corporate crowd. 
 Obviously, the way you sound is up to you, but it is worth deploying all the resources you have to ensure a decent quality of recording and to present the cassette in an appealing way. 
 It is a dull dictum, but true, that if you give the impression you care about what you do, then others are more likely to care about it too. 
 Again, economy is important. 
 A C30 tape is usually quite long enough and, assuming your songs are of average length, three of the best will do nicely. 
 And make them your most accessible. 
 If they are listened to at all, it will probably be in the bath, on a car stereo, or in some other environment where the music is competing for the listener's attention. 
 If journalists are going to like you, they will make their minds up quickly and it is a positive advantage if they like what they hear, but haven't got enough. 
 It means they  have to get  in touch with you  to ask for more. 
 on the other hand, if they are unmoved by the first track or two, it is unlikely they will bother with numbers three to fifteen anyway. 
 But whether they love you or loathe you, never expect to get your property back. 
 Just think of it as a loss leader and keep your fingers crossed. 
 3. 
 Gigs 
 Folklore insists that the best way to lure a usually male journalist to a gig is to offer him a drink. 
 Certainly the kind of modern-day would-be Kerouac who survives entirely on the proceeds from trading-in free albums and indulging in the fine art of &bquo;ligging&equo; &mdash; tagging along to any show in town where the record company picks up the catering bill &mdash; is not extinct. 
 However, aspiring unsigned acts with a reputation to make aren't likely to be in a position to sweeten up the hordes of sceptical scribes in the West End of London who spend their days loafing from one free lunch to the next. 
 In fact most young bands aren't based in the capital at all and it is a long-standing complaint of artists with their souls in the provinces that the concentration of the national media in London obliges them to abandon their regional roots. 
 That said, one of the best chances an unknown has of national music press exposure is in the live review section. 
 There are several reasons for this. 
 One is simply that you don't need to have made a record or done anything very much except earned a local reputation as a watchable band playing original material. 
 This alone can make it worth a reporter's time to come along. 
 Artists based outside London should certainly make it their business to locate each publication's local &bquo;stringer&equo; whose job it is to reflect the scene in their own city or town. 
 Very often the live review section's smaller items are written by junior reporters who are more willing to make their way to obscure gigs if it means getting their by-line in the paper. 
 Keep your eyes open for the names of new writers on the magazines you read regularly and try to make contact by letter or telephone. 
 Convince them you are worth a look and, almost out of the blue, you might end up with 300 words in Kerrang  or Echoes  or the NME . 
 If they are favourable words, it could be the first write-up of many. 
 4. 
 Nagging 
 All the press releases and all the triumphant pub gigs in the world will amount to nothing unless you are prepared to nag. 
 As a species, rock journalists are often dedicated free spirits, either too young or just too immature to believe that the normal responsibilities of life &mdash; good manners, for instance &mdash; might apply to them. 
 This means that  the thankless task of nagging is of an elevated importance in the unknown band's armoury of skills: the less notice they take, the more you need to pester them. 
 When you have sent off your pristine cassette, your witty biography and your complimentary tickets, the next thing you need to do is make a follow-up call: &bquo;Oh hello. 
 I was just calling to make sure you received our tape/tickets/press release 
 &hellip; 
 Yes, it is in a turquoise envelope with a silver band insignia and a Grimsby postmark&hellip; 
 You've found it? good. 
 I'll call in a couple of days to see what you think. 
 Bye.' 
 The voice at the other end may be sullen, bored and indifferent or else cheerily superficial, but don't let that put you off. 
 Remember, in five years, time, most of these people will either be press officers (doing the same as you are, but with less loving care) or they will have been kicked upstairs to edit a page instead of writing on it, thereby saving readers from any more of their insufferable prose. 
 obviously, go with your instinct, but as a basic approach, try simply to be polite. 
 Don't give them a sales pitch because there is nothing more irritating. 
 Just make friendly noises and go away. 
 This is the best way to lay amicable foundations for your more concerted efforts in the days and weeks to come as you try to prise a response out of your carefully selected target hack. 
 Lastly, don't expect too much. 
 If you can get them to absorb your material at all, that counts as an achievement. 
 If they like it, that is rare. 
 If, finally, you get any column inches out of it, buy yourself a drink, cut out the precious words carefully and make a pile of photocopies. 
 Even if you have been made the target of naked literary abuse, it will make satisfying reading when you play your first sell-out show at Wembley! 
 Eye of the Tiger 
 For freshly signed artists as well as unknowns, encountering the press is a new and sometimes uncomfortable experience. 
 Rock isn't the art form of the chattering classes and only a minority of its practitioners have any expertise in elucidating a rigorous conceptual rationale for their work. 
 Meanwhile, those garrulous starlets who utter a quotable phrase almost every time they open their mouths are few and far between. 
 This means that interviews are often an ordeal for inquisitor and subject alike. 
 The trick here is to know what you want to say and make sure that you say it. 
 Politicians do this all the time, turning any given question into a cue for making the point they  think is important and never mind what their questioner wants to hear. 
 There is no need to go quite that far with the pop scribes of this world, but the principle is worth keeping in mind. 
 often, the journalists are far more neurotic and insecure than you are. 
 After walking in and setting down their  pocket tape recorder, they soon reveal themselves as inarticulate and badly prepared and the whole encounter is punctuated with long, awkward silences. 
 On the other hand, some writers take a more interrogative approach, grilling their beleaguered subjects from a prepared list of queries  ike  a policeman in search of a conviction. 
 From a personal point of view, the best interviews are the ones which become conversations, discussions which proceed on an equal basis, that are informal but still retain some kind of shape. 
 Ideally, all that needs to be said can be said in an hour, and if you think the journalist is genuinely interested in your work, try to give him or her as much time as required &mdash; it is appreciated. 
 It takes the co-operation of both parties to pull this off and all artists would be wise to give their general interview method some thought in advance. 
 One obvious, important factor is to consider which publication the journalist is from. 
 A sweet young thing from Smash  Hits  isn't going to be after the same kind of material as some cerebral haircut boy from Melody Maker  or a hack from your local paper. 
 Plainly, individual journalists have individual styles but ultimately they have to turn the result of meeting you into the type of article their publication requires. 
 Smash Hits  will want to know about your make-up or your boxer shorts, Melody Maker  leans towards aesthetics and primal therapy and the local Argus  might just want to know a few biographical details and where your next gig is. 
 It is also worth working out how to create the best conversational chemistry. 
 Many bands feel that each member should be present at every interview. 
 This is commendably democratic and can work perfectly well, but sometimes the intimacy of one-to-one conversation yields more interesting results for both parties. 
 Usually, one or two of the band are more chatty, outgoing or just plain pretentious than the rest. 
 These are the people to let loose on the press. 
 Remember, your value to a magazine isn't only your prowess or popularity as a musician. 
 People can enjoy reading about you even if they don't like your music and if enough of them do, it improves your chances of more coverage the next time you need it. 
 The End 
 Although the total press coverage of pop music increased dramatically over the last ten years, the quality hasn't improved and the power of music papers to make and break an artist has greatly dissipated. 
 As a medium through which to secure your fame and fortune, even those publications for whom discovering new talent is an important role aren't the force they were. 
 Record companies have become far more adept at monitoring and exploiting new acts, and  their links with the smaller labels &mdash; who they once only heard about by way of the left-field rock press &mdash; are now thoroughly institutionalized. 
 Though they would hate to admit it, the rock press was once the most important stepping-stone on the way from obscurity to celebrity. 
 There are now other routes to follow. 
 But although, in career terms, it may currently be more effective to woo record companies rather than journalists, the rock press isn't a completely spent force, nor is it a worthless one. 
 What decent journalists have that most people in the pop industry don't, is a proper critical faculty. 
 spiteful, verbose and stupid though rock hacks can be, they are at least sometimes driven by something other than the logic of the balance sheet. 
 If you take your music seriously and arouse the interest of a committed writer, the resulting article can make a genuine contribution to people's understanding of your work and of popular culture in general. 
 With more and more people getting their pop information from our squalid popular press and with most modern magazines covering music using only the language of consumerism and gossip, it is increasingly difficult to feel optimistic about rock journalism's values. 
 At its best it remains one of the few areas of the modern press where imagination, honesty and idealism, however fatuous, can still, occasionally, be found. 
 A positive interaction with these characteristics can only be to the benefit of artists and their followers alike. 
 It might even make you a star. 
 Management 
 ED BICKNELL is manager of Dire Straits who he says that he wanted to represent within five minutes of seeing them live. 
 Before his management career Ed worked as a drummer. 
 had been Hull University's social secretary and was a successful agent representing British and international artists. 
 This is an edited version of an interview with Ed at Damage Management's London offices. 
 Managers and Artists 
 The most important relationship in any artist's career is with their manager. 
 A manager tries to co-ordinate, push and stimulate everything concerned with the music business to get the artist's product in front of the public. 
 To achieve this, the manager needs a knowledge of the record industry, music publishing, concert promotion, tax and of how to run a business; as well as how to keep the act's family happy. 
 A complete job description almost defies definition. 
 The best I can do as a manager is a combination of threatening, cajoling and being nice to everyone who can help to give my act the best possible shot. 
 However, the artist must play an active part in their business career. 
 When the record is finished and the studio door is finally shut, the artist has to get out and sell. 
 They have to do the tedious promotional work, the dodgy TV shows in Belgium and the interviews at American radio stations where no one knows who they are. 
 It is a treadmill, but if an artist isn't prepared to do it, there are two or three hundred others just waiting for their chance. 
 There are certain things I won't do as a manager. 
 I didn't get into music to be a travel agent, have people's gardens done, or to arrange their mortgages. 
 That is a trap which people get into with acts and it is very dangerous for both sides. 
 Managers are focal points in the music business. 
 They co-ordinate the production and promotion of an artist's music, making it possible  
 for the music industry to have a success. 
 For instance, this can mean persuading record companies to spend money on adverts and employing pluggers. 
 Even with a band like Dire straits that can be quite hard, because there is sometimes a certain complacency surrounding a big artist's release. 
 The music business marries art and commerce. 
 However, the artist's aims may not be the same as a record company's. so the manager has to vet what big business wants musicians to do. 
 Managing a New Band 
 Ideally, the manager should be there at the beginning of a band's professional career because he or she is going to operate the various deals which are set up. 
 Generally, it is best for him or her to have some input into the management and other contracts instead of inheriting them from a lawyer. 
 Lawyers mainly deal with the theory of things whereas an experienced manager is concerned with practicalities. 
 I have seen clauses in record contracts which are absolutely meaningless and which I would happily have traded for a defined amount of money for a tour support, video, or promotional commitment. 
 A manager has to create an environment in which a new act can get on with their music as free as possible of worry about business. 
 The first thing to do is sort out the basis of the young artists&equo; business. 
 The manager has to organize their companies, hire them an accountant and a lawyer (if they haven't already done that), get them VAT registered, and do a lot of simple administration like applying for passports. 
 This organization is very important because the business structure with which the act starts ought to be the one they have forever. 
 Next, the manager would want to find the act a record contract, even before getting a publishing deal. 
 Most publishers won't pay artists any money until a record has been released in a major market because the publisher has no other way of recouping any investment. 
 Currently, getting a record deal for a new act is difficult. 
 This is partly due to the increasing technological influence on songs. 
 A lot of records are broken but not many careers are established. 
 There is a difference. 
 For a new artist to progress, the most important management role is allowing the act to develop its songwriting potential. 
 Ultimately, it doesn't matter how well a band's guitarist plays, if an act doesn't have good songs they will go nowhere. 
 That is what it takes to become internationally popular and to have a longlasting career. 
 If a band don't write their own songs, the manager has to find the right    songwriters. 
 The best thing Tina Turner's management ever did was to find the songs for her Private Dancer  album. 
 one happened to be by our client Paul Brady, and &bquo;Private Dancer&equo; was written by Mark Knopfler. 
 The only difference between Tina Turner today and a few years ago is her material. 
 she has always been great, but she made a tremendous jump when she started recording decent songs instead of versions of old R'n' B tracks. 
 Songs are the lifeblood of pop music, and all the artists I have represented have been heavily involved in songwriting. 
 Tina Turner 
 A manager has to believe totally in a new act. 
 If that isn't why he or she gets involved, the manager shouldn't be doing the job. 
 The manager must work to ensure everything is in place so that the band's product comes out in time for the public to make up its own mind. 
 If the talent which the manager believes in is recognized by the public, then hopefully they will go and buy the record. 
 But if the act doesn't get success, two things may happen: the record company will probably drop the act, though they may try one more record; and the finances of running the band will probably cause the act to go bust. 
 The manager can manipulate some things to stave that off, but pop music is about being popular. 
 You need to have hits. 
 If musicians want to do jazz albums or make obscure folk records there are routes for that. 
 However, a band would be doing incredibly well to sell 15,000 jazz LPs throughout the UK. 
 For pop and rock artists, success has to be measured by records selling in millions. 
 Artists need time to develop. 
 once the rollercoaster of success gets going, the most common problem in pop music is the second album. 
 An act can make a successful first LP which may have taken five or seven years for a band's songwriters to create. 
 suddenly, the music industry is demanding album number two within four months. 
 To cope with this, the manager has to try and stave off time pressures without losing the momentum of gaining popularity. 
 This is an extraordinarily difficult balancing act, particularly with new artists. 
 After their successful first record, they can go into the studio without proper preparation. 
 They might jam a bit and produce substandard material because they are trying to satisfy the record industry's mania for following up success. 
 Often this situation doesn't allow the artist enough time to write good new songs. 
 My attitude is that if a band manages to release a second album of poor songs four months after their first album left number one in the charts, it isn't worth the rush. 
 If Mark Knopfler took five years to produce another record, and it was a classic, I don't have any worries. 
 I have to allow the songwriting people within this operation to have the time and security of mind to get on with their art.  
 However, it can be dangerous when an artist becomes very established. 
 He or she can go to seed having bought a mansion and put a million pounds in the bank. 
 part of a manager's responsibility, with new and established acts, is to keep the stimulus going which makes the artist want to write, record and perform. 
 Live Work 
 Live gigs are the most interesting and enjoyable part of my work. 
 I have a great live band, probably one of the best in the world. 
 However, there are lots of acts who can't work live very well. 
 Despite this, it is amazing how many managers put inadequate live bands on tour. 
 It is self-defeating. 
 The problem with a lot of acts is that they don't realize their limitations. 
 As a result, they go on tour without knowing how to produce a good live show. 
 If I were taking on a new act, their ability to perform on stage would be second only to the quality of their songwriting. 
 Of course, I am leaving out the personality element. 
 If the manager doesn't get on with the band, the whole thing collapses. 
 I have to like the act and their music. 
 If one of these things were missing, I couldn't do it. 
 To set up a new band's live work, a manager needs to organize things like equipment, crew, trucks, boats and planes (given the constraints of economy), and get a decent agent and promoter. 
 For a new act, I would have to pitch them at the right venue for their type of music. 
 It is part of the manager's brief to make sure the artist isn't put into the wrong level or type of venue. 
 For instance, people have booked white country bands into rap clubs. 
 Having worked as an agent, I always take care of Dire straits' concert bookings and I have made that sort of mistake with them. 
 I booked them into a working men's cabaret club in South Wales. 
 I didn't know what it was, and they had to play in-between bingo sets. 
 Fortunately, they were professional enough to do the gig, but it served no useful purpose. 
 It is very difficult to marry up the sale of a record with a live show. 
 An established live act will almost certainly play to people who have bought their records. 
 This doesn't necessarily apply to new artists. 
 As a band's career develops, by album two or three, most of the concert audience will own at least one of the band's records and probably all of them. 
 In that situation, the band isn't using the live gig to plug their current record, like an appearance on the &bquo;Wogan&equo; show. 
 Instead, they are establishing a relationship with the audience, not by promoting the current record, but by securing a future audience for the one they haven't even made yet. 
 As long as a band can physically and economically do it, I would want to take their music to the people wherever they are. 
 Dire straits have  persistently played in Belfast, Tel Aviv and Auckland, not just London, Frankfurt, New York and Los Angeles. 
 That has made their tours very long and everyone needs enormous stamina and commitment. 
 If I were interviewing a new act, I would try to ascertain their sheer punishment factor. 
 During a tour, the straits' live show is three hours a night, but they travel for at least three hours a day, as well as doing interviews, a sound check, eating, and phoning home. 
 As a manager I have to judge whether a young band's professional tail is wagging the domestic dog or the other way round. 
 This is something a lot of people ignore. 
 I need to find out how my acts view their lives. 
 Do they want a family? 
 If so, when? 
 It is important to realize an act isn't a robot. 
 There are plenty of people in the music business who would like it that way, but I have to bear in mind that people get ill, home-sick and miserable. 
 For instance, touring is very boring. 
 The show is great, but after a three-hour musical high, it is back down to sandwiches on the bus, trying to find somewhere to eat after 2 a.m., or getting into the hotel when the night porter has locked up. 
 Touring is so important. 
 I would never take on an act who couldn't perform live. 
 It would have no interest at all. 
 Live work is the one area where the artists and audience meet face to face. 
 In most other circumstances, the public is one step removed from the artist, holding a record or watching a TV show. 
 At a concert, the band actually meet their fans. 
 The straits make a point of having autograph-hunters back stage in the dressing-room so they can stay in tune with their punters. 
 There is an idea which creeps in, particularly among younger musicians, that after a few hit records they are somehow better than other people. 
 They aren't. 
 They happen to do something where there is an enormous organization geared up to pushing them on to a pedestal. 
 I have never mollycoddled any of my artists. 
 I don't use limousines and the straits have only needed a security person once. 
 If I meet a new act, I always try and assess their maturity in order to judge whether they might go off the deep end as soon as they have success. 
 Fan Clubs 
 Fan clubs are a situation where a band can't win. 
 For most people, music is just a part of their leisure, although inevitably there are some who want more from it. 
 For the very young pop acts, there are very large numbers of teens and schoolchildren writing to them. 
 With the straits we get a fair amount of mail each year, most of which is easily categorized. 
 They want information about what the band is doing; or they want to know where they can get T-shirts, sweatshirts, concert tickets and other merchandise. 
 To deal with  this, we established an information service. 
 This isn't a fan club. 
 Members get newsletters, the option to buy tickets first and some fans have met the band. 
 If I were managing an act like Bros, I would run a professional fan club. 
 However, one of the problems with fan clubs is that they tend to operate for very young people. 
 There is an exploitative element to them. 
 You are unlikely to offend the teenage punter, but you may disturb their parents. 
 This is a very narrow line. 
 Often there are letters in the papers from parents who have sent off for T-shirts and pictures from a band's fan club, only to have their cheque cashed and to receive nothing for months. 
 I believe that if an act wants to run a fan club, it should be a service rather than a profit-making enterprise. 
 Ours regularly loses money, as do those of many other major artists. 
 My attitude is that if somebody has taken the trouble to write a letter, they deserve a reply. 
 To be very hard-nosed there is also a vested interest in running an efficient information service for a band. 
 If we can write back to somebody, or send them the CD or shirt they want, we will almost certainly have them for life. 
 Most people are amazed to get an answer from the band at all, so it is good business and public relations to try and answer these enquiries. 
 Finding Bands 
 Most acts who approach me fall into two categories: new and established. 
 The new acts can be divided into those with and without a record deal. 
 Those still looking for a record deal usually send a tape, some photographs and a biography. 
 I play the tape and make my judgement. 
 I don't know any more than other people what is likely to succeed. 
 I just have to react to what I like and what I can believe in. 
 After twelve years in management, I haven't yet had a tape arrive which I thought I could do anything with. 
 statistically, I get far more phone calls from record companies, lawyers and very occasionally from publishers telling me about a new act they have just signed. 
 They send me exactly the same as unsigned bands except the tape is invariably a finished master of high quality. 
 Again, I have only rarely heard anything which has interested me. 
 With established acts the same thing happens. 
 I often get calls from their lawyers, sometimes from their record companies, and extremely rarely from the artists. 
 For most major managers the problem is time. 
 The music business works in cycles. 
 Bands and their managers tend to have periods of relative quiet, maybe for six months, after which they are in a fever of activity. 
 This means managers have to be careful when considering whether to take on a new act. 
 If I were to begin to manage another major artist, and Mark Knopfler were to ring up and ask me to get the band back together for an album and a world tour, something would    have to suffer. 
 probably it would be the efficiency with which my artists' careers are dealt with, and my brain. 
 Ed Bicknell 
 In the UK, we have a tradition of management firms with only one or two clients. 
 In the UsA, there are massive companies which have fourteen or fifteen acts. 
 They operate by using fourteen or fifteen tour managers with fourteen or fifteen acts going to fourteen or fifteen gigs in fourteen of fifteen trucks. 
 Vast amounts of money are made and I find it all very boring. 
 Having tried it both ways, I am more comfortable with the single act approach, and in the history of rock management, that has generally been the most successful route. 
 Management is a very personal service. 
 A new act's problem is that if they approach an established manager, he or she will already be representing at least one major act. 
 New acts are attracted by First Division managers because we are visible and our addresses are in Music Week. 
 What new acts really need is the embryonic version of these people. 
 All of us started from a very low position. 
 Quite a lot of top managers had been in the agency business. 
 Although young bands can find the established people in Music Week , they are probably a waste of time. 
 They may get to one of these people if they get a record deal without a manager, and if their record is a mega hit, but that is very unlikely. 
 With most young bands, the manager is often the guy who owns the van. 
 He or she may even be the local greengrocer who hears a band rehearsing down the road in the village hall. 
 sometimes that works, though problems can arise when the band gets down to London. 
 suddenly the greengrocer/manager has to choose between a safe livelihood and dedicating often sixteen or seventeen hours a day to the hurdle race of the music business. 
 The reason it worked for me and the straits was threefold. 
 I genuinely liked them as people, I loved their music, and I was in exactly the right place at the right time. 
 If it had happened two years earlier, I couldn't have coped. 
 However, when I first encountered the straits, I was a successful agent, thinking about leaving the agency business. 
 I didn't have it in mind to go looking for a four-piece group. 
 Like most managers, I don't seek out groups, even at showcases. 
 The Artists, Their Money and Their Manager 
 Most top managers are very honest Amongst these people the idea of ripping off an act is offensive. 
 Paul McGuinness (U2), Roger Forrester (Eric Clapton), Roger Davies (Tina Turner), Bill Curbishley (The Who, Judas priest) or myself don't concoct ways of conning our acts. 
 Most of us have been with our artists a very long time. 
 We regard our work as a team effort. 
 It may not be a legal partnership, but it ought to be one ethically.  
 My golden piece of advice is not to have the manager handling the artist's money. 
 In the history of litigation in rock &bquo;n&equo; roll it is almost always about money. 
 Any artist I represent could tell me I am useless, but no one will ever be able to claim I stole from them, because I have never had the opportunity. 
 There is one exception to that with the straits. 
 For purely practical purposes, I deal with the artists' money for recording and touring expenses. 
 It is too complicated to send large numbers of bills over to their accountant every day. 
 To cope with this, I set up separate clients' accounts with the bank with some funding from the band's accountants. 
 All the bank statements and back-up bills go to the band's accountants to be audited, together with a complete statement of income and expenditure. 
 on the 248 dates of the &bquo;Brothers in Arms&equo; world tour, the entire accounts were only &pound;4.04 out of balance. 
 However, I don't handle the band's royalty income from records and publishing. 
 Those cheques and statements arrive here, made out to the band's companies. 
 We check the statements, file them and send them on to the band along with our commission invoice. 
 Any manager who does handle the artist's money is taking a foolish risk, as well as letting themselves in for an enormous amount of unnecessary work. 
 Management Commissions 
 The commission arrangement shouldn't leave either side resenting what the other is getting. 
 Traditionally, management commission rates have ranged from 15 to 25 per cent of the band's gross income. 
 The manager's commission doesn't have to be the same on everything, and my initial rates with the straits were set by their lawyer at the beginning of our relationship. 
 At various times I have altered my charges on particular areas. 
 on radio, television, sponsorship, sessions and producer work I take 20 per cent because those things are often rather fiddly, involving quite a lot of work and not producing very much of a financial return. 
 The commission on records is between 15 and 20 per cent, while on publishing I got 15 per cent until Mark Knopfler voluntarily put it up to 20 per cent. 
 on live work I used to get 20 per cent. 
 They were losing money on their early tours so to help them I dropped the touring commission to 10 per cent. 
 When the band became profitable on the road, it went back up. 
 In fact, the straits raised this an extra 5 per cent just before the &bquo;Brothers in Arms&equo; tour in recognition of the agency service which I have always provided. 
 This sort of relationship is ideal! 
 When working out commission rates the most important factor is the artist's ability to pay. 
 If an act is starting out and the manager immediately takes 25 per cent of their money, the band are almost certainly going to be in financial difficulties. 
 That doesn't mean the  manager shouldn't take a considerable share of the act's income at the beginning. 
 The manager will have business overheads which make sure he or she can do the job properly. 
 My office costs &pound;5,000 a week to run, employing four people. 
 That has to be paid before I or my partner get anything. 
 There is no point in the act giving the manager only 5 per cent and then complaining he or she doesn't turn up to their shows. 
 The manager probably can't afford to get there. 
 When a band starts out, they could pool everything with their manager. 
 Also, some people do deals on the net income. 
 There are cooperatives in which the manager gets the same as the band members and the manager's office expenses are treated as a band cost, along with the trucks, boats and recording. 
 However, the subject of commission rarely crops up with major artists. 
 I have probably discussed it less than five times in twelve years with the straits. 
 Good Management 
 The manager is the manager because he or she takes the job on. 
 As Colonel Parker said &bquo;I'm Elvis's manager because I say I am, and Elvis says I am&equo;. 
 Most people get into management because they find an act they want to work with. 
 They don't necessarily need to know what management is, they can learn all that. 
 Managers have to believe in their act because the low points can be very low, even though the high points are exhilarating. 
 If I have ever had any doubts about my work with Dire straits, I pull out one of their albums and play it. 
 That is enough, I am back up straight away. 
 The manager has to be honest, competent and use common sense, while getting on with the artist. 
 I have been lucky enough to have almost the perfect relationship with my act. 
 We have a very similar Northern background, are roughly the same age and have the same sense of humour. 
 Apart from the music, that has really helped us to stay together. 
 The greatest compliment Mark Knopfler ever paid me was in a magazine when he was asked to list the members of Dire straits. 
 He said that apart from himself, the band would be John, Ed and Paul. 
 I thought that was great. 
 Working with Dire straits has always been a vocation for me. 
 The others have just been a job.  
 Booking Agents 
 CARL LEIGHTON-POPE runs Prestige Talent agency. 
 part of the Bugle Group of companies which includes IRS records. 
 He began in the music business running a recording studio and in band management. 
 Carl moved into agency at NEMS in the late 1970s and after a few years was instrumental in the formation of the PAN agency. 
 In the 1980s Carl has managed several successful artists and has run his own companies. 
 Bonair Records and Bonair Songs. 
 This is an edited version of an interview with Carl at his Prestige Talent offices and in the back of a taxi en route  to a band's showcase. 
 An agent deals with live gigs, concerts and touring. 
 To that end, the agent meets with an artist's management and its record company to decide the best touring period. 
 This is usually linked with an album release date. 
 Together, we assess when the album should reach the market place, and from that the agent books the territories where the band is to play. 
 From talking to local promoters we decide the level at which the band is to work. 
 That is measured by the size and capacity of the halls in each territory. 
 Deciding on the right level for a band depends on the policy ideas which characterize different agents. 
 I favour the approach that if the band is worth 2,000 people in a town, then it is smart to book the 1,500-seat venue. 
 If there are two or three hundred people left outside trying to get in, there is a certain excitement surrounding the gig. 
 Other agents would choose a 2,500-seater for the same band. 
 They put pressure on the record company and the promoter to sell those extra 500 seats. 
 However, I believe that particular gamble is often lost by negative press coverage. 
 Instead of reporting the number of people at the gig, journalists query the 2 or 300 empty seats in the hall and question whether the band is really gaining popularity. 
 If there are 2 or 300 people outside, the gig is sold out, and that term still has a certain magic in the music industry.  
 The Ticket Price 
 Having decided the touring period and the size of halls a band will play, the agent's job is to work with local promoters to determine the ticket price. 
 After agreeing the hall's capacity, this is the most important decision during the tour. 
 To set the ticket price, the agent has to look at what is happening in the industry, what an average ticket price is, and what the touring artist is worth as an attraction. 
 A ticket price directly affects a concert-goer. 
 When it is set, the artist is immediately linked with an amount of money in the public's mind. 
 In the UK, there is still something magic about the &pound;10 figure. 
 If an artist's concert can be priced at &pound;9.50, people don't consider it especially expensive. 
 The aim with pricing is not to sell your act cheaply and not to leave the audience feeling ripped off. 
 Having decided on the capacity of the venue and the ticket price, it is simple to multiply one by the other to &bquo;gross the hall&equo;. 
 Most halls are one ticket price. 
 If the ticket price is &pound;10 and there are 200 people in the hall, that is a &pound;2,000 gross. 
 After VAT has been paid, the rest of the money is split three ways: to the act, to the promoter, and to the cost of the event. 
 Costs 
 While planning the gig, the agent works with the promoter and looks at the event's costs. 
 These include security, staging, promotion, marketing, radio adverts, catering on the night for the artist, carrying the equipment in and out of the hall, the PRS percentage, the hall hire, as well as the printing and distribution of posters. 
 The list is very long! 
 Once these expenses have been fixed, the agent goes to the record company and tries to reduce the event's costs. 
 The agent may suggest a joint postering campaign, advertising the band's album on the gig's posters. 
 Another idea is to split the cost of radio adverts. 
 The record is played during the advert while the gig's details are broadcast. 
 The reason for reducing the event's costs is that the less money which is spent on the gig means that more money goes to the artist. 
 Having deducted the costs after VAT, 50&ndash;60 per cent of the money taken from ticket sales is left to share between the promoter and the artist. 
 Depending on the reputation of the artist, the agent makes a deal to split this percentage of the ticket money from 70:30 up to 90:10 or 95:5 in the artist's favour. 
 If the artist is a major attraction, whose concert tickets are certain to be at premium, a 90: 10 deal is likely. 
 In that case, the promoter receives 10 per cent of the net and the band gets 90 per cent. 
 However, a 90:10 deal after costs also means that every expense is borne in that proportion. 
 If the band spends a lot of money in the venue (with a big stage extension, an early &bquo;get-in&equo; to the venue, playing very late, or running up an  enormous catering bill), all of these costs are paid mainly by the artist. 
 Every pound spent on these extra expenses is one less pound which can't be split between the artist and the promoter. 
 For each pound of these costs, the artist pays 70, 80 or 90 per cent in lost revenue, depending on the percentage split between the artist and the promoter. 
 The agent also has a vested interest in keeping the event's costs at a minimum. 
 The agent is paid by commissioning the artist. 
 Whatever money the artist leaves the venue with is the amount which the agent can commission. 
 This is around 10 per cent. 
 I he exact commission figure is a matter for negotiation between the artist's manager and the agent. 
 The art of making a good deal as an agent is to keep the promoter's costs down, while allowing him or her a sufficient budget to make sure the event is successful. 
 Guaranteed Fees 
 Most bands work on a guaranteed fee against a percentage. 
 For instance, if the not gross is &pound;10,000, and &pound;4,000 of that pays the event's costs, there is &pound;6,000 to split between the promoter and the band. 
 The agent's trick is to persuade the promoter to guarantee as much of the artist's share as possible. 
 This is the moment when the promoter has to demonstrate faith in the act's ability to do good business. 
 If an 80:20 deal is negotiated, the &pound;6,000 should be divided with &pound;1,200 going to the promoter and &pound;4,800 to the band. 
 The ultimate deal is for the promoter to guarantee the band the whole &pound;4,800. 
 This proves the promoter's confidence that every ticket will be sold, committing him or her to paying the artist a fee as if the event is a sell-out, however many people actually attend the gig. 
 When there is a certain amount of risk involved in an event, most promoters opt for paying the minimum amount of guarantee possible against a larger percentage for the artist. 
 In this situation, the onus is on the band to sell all the tickets and to come out with the extra money. 
 If the band don't attract a sell-out crowd, the promoter's risk has been minimized. 
 Then the promoter only has to pay the band the guaranteed fee plus costs. 
 The &bquo;Gross&equo; Deal 
 The agent can also make a deal with the promoter on the gross and not the net figures. 
 The agent would agree with the promoter that for every pound taken on the door, the artist will receive a certain percentage. 
 As an example, this could be 50p of every pound. 
 The agent and artist don't care what happens to the other 50p, whether it is spent either as the show's costs or as the promoter's profit. 
 The promoter simply has to guarantee the artist's 50p. 
 In this case, the  agent only needs to see a ticket manifest (a government-stamped document showing how many tickets are printed for the venue) and a box office statement from the hall (stating how many tickets were sold) when checking the promoter's expenses. 
 If 1,000 tickets were sold at &pound;1, the promoter would take &pound;1,000. 
 If the deal were 50 per cent of the gross, the artist takes &pound;500 and that is the end of the matter. 
 If the agent cuts this type of deal tightly enough, the promoter is forced to think twice about spending money. 
 However, if the deal were, for instance, a 90: 10 split and not a gross deal, the promoter would realize that for every pound he or she spends on costs, 90 pence of that pound belongs to the artist. 
 This could lead the promoter into spending more money on advertising than may be necessary because only 10 per cent of these expenses are his or her costs. 
 But if the deal were a gross deal, then the promoter would look to save as much money as possible. 
 The disadvantage of this is that some promoters underadvertise, underpromote, and undermarket the gig to try and put more pounds in their pockets by reducing their expenses. 
 Here the artist can often suffer by not selling a lot of tickets, while the promoter loses money as well. 
 Promotion 
 The result of good promotion can be a sell-out. 
 It is great to drive through a German city and see full colour posters for your band with a ribbon across the poster which reads: AUSVERKAUF (sold-out). 
 This raises the status of the ticket in the public's mind. 
 Kids walk along the street, look at the concert poster, see the band's name and read &bquo;sold-out&equo;. 
 They realize they may have missed an event. 
 By doing that, an advance ticket-buying market is created. 
 The next time the band plays in that town, kids will run out early and buy tickets. 
 They won't want to be the one in their class, group or gang who missed buying a ticket having known the show was sold out last time. 
 This is just one way a band can build up its market in the territories it tours, from a 500- or 1,000-seat club up to a 10,000-seat arena. 
 Talent Acquisition 
 As an agent my strength is in my clients. 
 I can't rely on people coming into my office and booking artists. 
 In my early years, I set out to find a roster of acts who I would represent. 
 one of my first artists came through a very old friend called Richard Ogden who now manages paul McCartney. 
 Then Richard managed a band on Virgin records called the Motors. 
 Richard played me their record and invited me to the end of recording party. 
 I met the guys, loved the songs and they asked me to be their agent. 
 Richard wanted me to book thirty shows in the clubs and I did. 
 I had also been very friendly with Jeff Jukes and Max Hole (Max is the managing director of Warner  Brothers and Jeff manages the Fixx and Rupert Hine, a very established producer). 
 Max and Jeff managed a group called Camel. 
 This band were doing very good business in the town halls. 
 They had just done a big concert at the Albert Hall with an orchestra for an album called Snowgoose . 
 They came to me because they were unhappy with their agent and wanted to change to me. 
 Richard Ogden was working on the Motors with a lawyer in New York, Charles Levison, who later became the managing director of Arista records in the UK and managing director of Warner Brothers. 
 While he was at Arista, Charles and I got to know each other well. 
 I impressed him with my work on the Motors and Camel. 
 He had Patti Smith on Arista who had released a big hit, &bquo;Because the Night&equo;. 
 she wanted to do some concerts in Europe and I booked the tour. 
 Andrew Bailey, an A&amp;R man also at Arista, asked me to look after a young guy named Roy Hill. 
 This is the typical career pattern of a lot of agents. 
 Apart from demo tapes, agents find new acts from four sources within the business. 
 The main source is record companies. 
 Young A&amp;R guys are out every night looking at bands. 
 They sign an act whose manager is inexperienced and asks for advice on choosing an agent. 
 Record companies look at agency rosters, like mine, or those of Barry Dickens (Fleetwood Mac, Bee Gees, Bob Dylan) or Ian Fluke (Eurythmics and simple Minds) and they choose the agent who is suitable. 
 Two other sources are becoming more productive of new talent. 
 one is lawyers and the other is accountants. 
 These professional advisers to musicians have immense importance to the longevity of an artist's career and the retention of his or her wealth. 
 Pat savage and O. J. Kilkenny run a very successful accounting firm. 
 They represent Van Morrison and U2. 
 They knew Van needed an agent and suggested I speak to him. 
 These recommendations go on all the time, but they are recommendations and that is all. 
 The agent has to make the artist believe he or she can do the job. 
 The fourth way of finding acts is from among an agent's existing managers. 
 Jeff Jukes managed Camel in the 1970s and the Fixx in the 1980s. 
 They are both clients of mine. 
 If Bruce Allen signs another act, hopefully he would come to me after my work with Bryan Adams and Lover Boy. 
 Managers are not necessarily as transient as acts. 
 A successful manager may manage five or six bands in his career. 
 If an agent does a good job with the first one, and builds a successful relationship with the manager, there is no reason why that agent can't deal with all of a manager's acts. 
 However, if an agent is enjoying the wine with a Bryan Adams, he or she may be drinking the vinegar with a manager's smaller act who makes much more work than the bigger act, with absolutely no income. 
 Here the agent is investing in the small artist,    trusting the manager's judgement that this act should go on to be the next big thing. 
 Bryan Adams 
 I look at the charts every week. 
 If there is something interesting, I make a call to the record company and find out whether an agent is in place. 
 If there isn't, I speak to the manager and arrange a meeting. 
 I saw Bryan Adams on the front of his album. 
 He was wearing a T-shirt and jeans and looked perfect for the UK market. 
 I listened to the record. 
 It was a rock &bquo;n&equo; roll record which is my kind of music. 
 I called Bruce Allen, his manager, and we met in Germany. 
 Bruce also managed a band called Lover Boy. 
 I agreed to represent Lover Boy and Bryan Adams throughout Europe. 
 The younger acts are the major problem in the music industry. 
 At Prestige Talent, we have three young agents learning the business from booking colleges and clubs like the Borderline in London. 
 We need these people to be our filters and talent scouts, going out to gigs and finding new bands. 
 However, 90 per cent of the bands we sign attract us either with recently recorded product or with a record due out on release. 
 It is now virtually impossible for a major London agency to book gigs for many acts who don't have a record deal. 
 The agent's problem with acts who are still looking for a deal is how to judge their potential for success. 
 If an agent decides to invest in an act for the first year of its career, this band may not sign a record deal. 
 In fact, they may split up, probably owing the agent money. 
 Agents have to regard these young acts as an investment. 
 The safer investments are ones with more people involved. 
 If the agent knows that a publisher, a record company and a manager have all invested, at least he or she can feel there are a number of people needing this act to be successful. 
 Young New Acts 
 Bands can't make it alone. 
 They must have a team of people to present their case to the industry. 
 The industry doesn't like dealing with the artist direct because that makes it difficult for music business professionals to be as critical or as observant as they would like. 
 The business wants to deal with a representative. 
 Young bands have to find their own team (agent, manager, publicist and others) to put around them and to believe in their music. 
 The most effective way of finding support is through gigs. 
 Any major music paper, such as NME  or Melody Maker , lists the telephone numbers of music clubs and pubs and these places do book young bands. 
 They put on new acts if they are called direct and are sent a rough demo tape. 
 some members of a band could go out in the evening and pop into a whole bunch of places to ask if they will give  them a gig. 
 They won't pay a young act any money, but they will let them play third on the bill on a Monday night or on a Thursday night when there aren't many people in the venue. 
 Bands have to stay out there. 
 They have to be seen. 
 Nothing happens while you are rehearsing in a garage. 
 Nothing at all. 
 Record companies, managers or anyone in the music business can only notice your music if your band is at a venue playing in the public eye. 
 For example, I have been at a venue like the Marquee club to check out a band for a record company and have also watched 30 minutes of the first act. 
 Most often the support band are terrible, but they could have been great and they could have been you. 
 You might have been up there playing and somebody like me or a young talent scout from a record company. 
 might have been in there to look at someone else, to talk with a club owner or having a drink. 
 Maybe they would feel there was something interesting about your band. 
 Our young bookers look at about ten acts a week. 
 Most of these aren't signed, but if we look at them early and register our interest in the act, we hope the band will consider us to be their agent when they have a record deal. 
 As an established agent, I have to remember that our big acts of today were our little ones of yesterday. 
 I look after several young bands. 
 One of my successful young bands is Del Amitri, who are on A&amp;M Records. 
 This is a scottish rock band (every album has to be categorized to some extent in order to sell it). 
 After meetings with A&amp;M Records and the band's management, we realized Radio I wasn't necessarily going to welcome this band with open arms. 
 This posed a particular problem for an agent. 
 Usually, an artist can be booked out on the strength of a record's popularity and radio air play. 
 As the band's agent in this case, I had to work with the record company to circumvent the rigid Radio I Top 40 format. 
 We opted to promote the band at a local level, and not nationally. 
 This avoided putting full page ads in Melody Maker, NME  and Sounds , and hoping somebody would read them. 
 Instead, we booked the band into pubs and clubs all around the country, anywhere we could. 
 Wherever there was a gig or a support, we took anything for Del Amitri. 
 The moment we had a gig, that city was faxed through to the record company marketing people. 
 They instructed us to tell the promoter that they would give some money towards the gig's adverts in the local papers. 
 The record company told their sales rep to go into the town's music shops with T-shirts, get the local papers promoting the act and put the band into the local radio station. 
 The following day the band was in another town, the day after that somewhere else. 
 As the band were good enough live, we could build up a ground swell of interest at a local level which then translated into national success.  
 The Problems of Success 
 After young bands have had a couple of hit singles, with their album selling well, everybody wants to see them perform live. 
 Everything is going right and the act have a very good chance of success. 
 However, modern artists haven't always played live very much and &bquo;paid their dues&equo;. 
 They haven't worked in the clubs and colleges, building themselves up over the years. 
 suddenly, they are put into a situation where the expectations of their performance are much higher than they can possibly deliver. 
 That causes a problem. 
 The record buyer who has fallen in love with the band, and goes to see them play, is often disappointed by a lacklustre show. 
 It isn't the fault of the band. 
 They have become wildly popular, with their record sales and media profile, without knowing how to work with an audience, how to project, how to sell their performance or how to deal with their emotions on stage. 
 Why should they? 
 Probably they hadn't been on stage more than half a dozen times before they were put under this microscope. 
 The Making of a Good Agent 
 A good agent really understands the route a band has to take and must have a great relationship with his or her promoters to persuade them to believe in an artist. 
 Although the agent represents the artist, he or she also must represent the promoters' interests. 
 A lot of agents don't subscribe to this idea. 
 I believe that the more promoters to whom agents sell acts that lose money, the less people there will be around to do business with. 
 When an agent is cutting a deal, he or she needs to leave something for everyone. 
 The agent must ensure the promoter makes enough money, and that the manager doesn't squeeze the promoter's profit margin too much. 
 Getting into the agency business isn't as easy as it may seem. 
 A lot of young agents and bookers come from colleges where they have started as social secretaries and begun to book bands. 
 The advantage of this is that social secretaries deal with other people's money, so a few wrong decisions won't hurt their own wallet. 
 During their work on a social committee they can build their relationships with people in the industry, like agents selling bands and record companies helping with marketing and promotion. 
 To become an agent, these social secretaries simply have to reverse their roles with the agents who have been selling them acts for the previous few years. 
 If an aspiring agent doesn't go to college or university, there is no reason why he or she can't apply to an agency and come in as a very junior person to work their way up. 
 This business is open to opportunists and opportunity. 
 Getting in can be quite difficult, but once you are in and you work hard, it will work for you.  
 For a young band first starting work with an agency, the normal commission rate is 15 per cent. 
 The agent takes 15 per cent of the band's earnings which has nothing to do with the band's costs. 
 If a band rents a van or hires a roadie, that is of no interest to the agent. 
 The agent's percentage comes from the band's gross earnings at gigs. 
 When an act becomes more established, or if it is a new band with good management and someone who knows the business, the agent may make a 10 per cent deal &mdash; the standard commission rate. 
 There is a &bquo;Mr 10 per Cent&equo; feel about being an agent and there always will be. 
 However, if you become a superstar artist, the agent's 10 per cent quickly starts to dwindle.  
 Major Recording and Publishing Agents 
 BRIAN SOUTHALL is a consultant to various music business companies and a freelance writer. 
 His career in music began in the mid-1960s, editing and writing the pop page of his local Essex newspaper. 
 From there he moved to the trade paper Music Business Weekly  and on to Melody Maker  and Disc  before joining A&amp;M Records as press officer. 
 He held a similar position at Tamla Motown before becoming the head of press at EMI Records. 
 During 15 years with EMI he worked in artist development, marketing, promotion and public relations, and on leaving the company in 1989 he was the director of public relations and communications, EMI Music Worldwide. 
 He has published a history of Abbey Road studios and wrote the BBC Radio 1 special, &bquo;The House of Wax&equo;, two programmes narrated by Cliff Richard telling the 90-year history of EMI. 
 The Structure of a Record Company 
 Record companies throughout the world operate in the same basic way. 
 They all try to achieve two simultaneous goals &mdash; success and profitability. 
 EMI Music Worldwide is one of the world's big five music companies along with CBS, Warners, BMG and polygram. 
 It operates in thirty-seven countries around the world and in 1988 celebrated ninety years in the recorded music business. 
 The activities of all its record companies, whether they are based in Europe, Asia or south America, centre around recording, manufacturing, distribution, artists and repertoire, sales, promotion, and marketing. 
 In some countries, EMI record companies aren't involved in all these operations. 
 Manufacturing, for example, is often carried out in one regional centre. 
 However, the areas of marketing, sales, and promotion are at the heart of every record company. 
 From wherever the music and artists originate, their recordings have to be marketed, sold and promoted, and this applies to international superstars as well as emerging talent. 
 The size of EMI's operation in any country is determined by the size of the local market, the availability of promotional outlets like. 
 radio  and television stations), and the number of local artists signed to the company. 
 The business of music publishing uses the same approach. 
 The size of each national publishing company is determined by the depth of the international song catalogue to be promoted, and the songwriting talent available locally. 
 The business of artists and repertoire, commonly abbreviated to A&amp;R, is the most important part of any record company. 
 Charged with the task of discovering signing and developing artists, the A&amp;R staff are the first point of contact with a record company for the new acts who are intent on becoming the superstars of tomorrow. 
 Before analysing the role of the A&amp;R department in both record and music publishing companies, it would make sense to look at the other areas which create a fully operational major record company: manufacturing and distribution, recording studios, marketing and promotion, sales, professional advisers, and the international division. 
 Manufacturing and Distribution 
 This is concerned with the manufacture of records, music cassettes and compact discs (generally known as &bquo;product&equo;) in factories owned and operated by individual record companies. 
 These factories are mainly concerned with manufacturing product for artists signed to the record company. 
 However, they also do contract work for other record companies which don't run their own plants. 
 All finished product, whether it is for EMI or another record company, is transported to a distribution centre. 
 From there, it is delivered to shops or to the warehouses of other record companies. 
 Telephone orders placed by retail dealers are processed at the distribution centre, and their requirements are &bquo;picked&equo; from the storage lanes and packaged for delivery to shops. 
 Under the direction of a senior executive, the M&amp;D facility is responsible for maintaining appropriate stock levels of the raw materials with which to manufacture records, cassettes and CDs, including labels and inlay cards. 
 Record sleeves, which are printed and produced by specialist printers, are delivered to the plant in quantities specified by the record company's own production department. 
 similarly, the quantity of records, cassettes and CDs to be manufactured is set by the company's sales and marketing departments. 
 This reflects the probable initial demand for each release. 
 With product that has a regular and consistent sales pattern, the factory is responsible for ensuring that the appropriate levels of stock are maintained. 
 The supply of all product to shops is in direct response to retailers' orders, which are placed either with the distribution centre or with the company's sales force on their monthly calls.  
 Sales 
 The company's sales division consists of a national team of representatives who sell all product. 
 As well, there is a strike force to concentrate on singles. 
 This smaller team takes records to shops which have a high singles turnover and also carries the most popular current albums to top up a shop's supply of its best-selling products. 
 On every release, targets are set for the whole sales force by the sales manager or director, in consultation with the marketing division. 
 Each month, the company's new products are presented to the sales people by the marketing teams. 
 The sales staff show these new releases to retailers who decide whether to place an order. 
 If the finished product isn't ready when the sales force make their monthly calls, advance cassettes, track details and campaign plans will be presented to the retailers instead. 
 Most major record companies have experimented with selling other music-related items such as T-shirts, posters, calendars and books. 
 Almost all companies have decided that these items are best left to specialist manufacturers. 
 However, record company sales forces do supply music videos to the limited number of record shops which stock them. 
 Recording studios 
 These are often owned and run by record companies. 
 EMI Music, for instance, owns the famous Abbey Road studios in London and the Capitol Tower studios in Los Angeles. 
 Artists don't have to use their record company's studios, but most companies encourage this. 
 studios owned by record companies can also be hired by any artists and producers. 
 Marketing 
 Within a record company this involves planning campaigns aimed at record retailers and the record-buying public, along with the press and promotion staff who deal with newspapers, magazines, radio and television. 
 After it has been decided to make a record, these departments, together with the artist's manager and the A&amp;R staff, discuss the release date. 
 Under the direction of a marketing director, artists will be allocated to a label manager, a press officer and a promotion person. 
 Their responsibilities include ensuring availability of the master tape to suit the release schedule; overseeing the production of artwork for the sleeve's manufacture; preparing the appropriate campaign for the single or the album release; and keeping within the promotion budget which is prepared with the marketing director.  
 In addition, they decide the quantity of the initial pressing of their artists' recordings (for a new artist's first single this would be around 5,000); they liaise with the manufacturing plant to ensure further stock is available if it is needed; and they avoid producing stock which would probably never be sold. 
 The label manager also organizes promotional material like T-shirts, badges, picture discs and special limited edition sleeves (in the right quantities to ensure maximum effect and minimum waste). 
 Along with the press and promotion staff, the marketing department has to ensure that every potential record-buyer is aware of their artists' work. 
 Assembling the right creative material, such as publicity photographs, sleeve designs, poster and advertisement material, is important for all artists. 
 This material emerges from a series of meetings between the label/product manager, the artist and their management. 
 Often artists have an idea of the image they wish to create. 
 For this, the choice of the right photographer and designer is critical. 
 some record companies have their own in-house designers. 
 These are usually the smaller, independent labels. 
 Major companies call on many of the world's leading photographers and designers. 
 The Promotion Team 
 The company's promotion team supplies records and promotional videos to all major radio and television stations, as well as arranging appearances by artists on particular programmes. 
 Without radio play, a record can disappear without trace. 
 The public will rarely buy a record they have never heard, particularly when it comes from a new or unknown artist. 
 Regional promotion ensures that TV and radio stations throughout the country are supplied with all the material and information available. 
 Club promotion reflects the importance of dance clubs and the contribution they make towards a record's popularity. 
 The Press Department 
 The press department is responsible for ensuring that records are sent to all major reviewers, as well as placing and arranging artists' feature articles and interviews in appropriate publications. 
 Marketing Records 
 Singles released by major, established artists often benefit from a substantial marketing campaign, with posters and media advertising. 
 The cost of this is covered by increased singles sales and the eventual high sales of the album. 
 Clearly, the more successful and popular the  artist, the greater demands there are from TV radio and the press while the promotional video will also be sought after by the media. 
 The release of a single by a new act doesn't usually result in a major marketing campaign. 
 While relevant trade and some consumer advertising will be placed, this early stage is more about attracting radio play and media coverage. 
 on the radio, the company can get the record heard by the public. 
 Newspaper and magazine articles create an interest in the artist. 
 As singles usually make a loss for record companies, being &bquo;tasters&equo; for the album, any large marketing campaign would only increase this deficit. 
 A new band's first album ideally follows some success with a single. 
 That doesn't always mean a high chart place, although it would be very helpful! 
 Good reviews, favourable media coverage and positive response from radio all serve to create a &bquo;buzz&equo; for the artist and promote interest in the album. 
 For the album, the marketing department constructs a campaign with appropriate advertising in newspapers and magazines, posters on buses, in the tube, at railway stations and on advertising hoardings, plus support for any live dates. 
 Live work for an up-and-coming artist is vital. 
 Although record companies aren't in the business of promoting tours (see the agent's article in this book), they will lend their support to ensure their artists' performances are in the right venues. 
 sometimes this back-up will be financial. 
 Releases from major acts have a bigger push and the marketing budget is much larger. 
 As TV advertising campaigns cost hundreds of thousands of pounds, there must be a guaranteed sales return to justify such expenditure. 
 For this reason the concentration on TV advertising is on compilation albums and greatest hits collections. 
 Packaging 
 The packaging of all artists' product is vital. 
 This is debated and discussed between the artist, manager, marketing staffs and the A&amp;R person in order to create and present a consistent &bquo;face&equo; to the public. 
 It is unlikely that the record company would enforce their views on a new artist over publicity photographs, clothing styles, sleeve artwork or video plans. 
 However, these are the very subjects that need clarification and agreement before a record's release or the setting up of any tour dates and making of a promotional video.  
 International Division 
 On the international level, major record companies operate a marketing and promotion division. 
 Its responsibility is to create awareness, both in and outside of the company, of current artists' product. 
 Under the direction of a director (or a vice-president in the United States), the international operation co-ordinates the simultaneous, world-wide release of major artists' product; and it organizes the delivery of new and developing artists' records, promotional material and videos to all overseas companies where these recordings are considered for release. 
 The decision to release new product in overseas territories is made by each local company, taking into consideration the musical preferences of their own market. 
 When a record is released overseas, the international marketing division works on the promotional opportunities which exist locally, ensuring artists are available to visit those countries where there is radio, TV and media interest. 
 Professional Advisers 
 Within each record company there are financial and legal departments who play an important part in the company's investment programme, like signing artists, acquiring labels and assessing manufacturing capacity. 
 They draw up contracts, ensure appropriate legal protection for copyrights, advise on recording and marketing budgets and check that royalty payments to artists and producers are made in a timely and accurate fashion. 
 While the final policy on all major legal and financial matters is set by the company's managing director or president, the advice offered by these specialist executives improves the efficiency, profitability and overall performance of the company. 
 Artists and Repertoire 
 This is the usual first point of contact with a record company for an aspiring artist. 
 As a result, many young acts regard the A&amp;R staff as the ultimate decision-makers: career makers or breakers, heroes or villains. 
 More often than not, the A&amp;R personnel are working to a brief. 
 They may have noted gaps in the company's roster of artists which need to be filled. 
 Major record companies, by the very definition of the world &bquo;major&equo;, are intent on targeting different audiences with specific styles of music. 
 To achieve that, they need a wide spread of artists.  
 Balancing an existing roster is of primary importance to a major company, whereas some smaller independent companies can and do concentrate on a particular sound or style of music. 
 The question most often asked of A&amp;R people is &bquo;What happens to all the tapes sent in?&equo; 
 The answer is simple. 
 Unsolicited tapes are allocated to the various members of the A&amp;R team. 
 They review them and respond accordingly. 
 Usually a standard letter is sent if the tape is unsatisfactory or inappropriate. 
 However, if there is something of interest, one of the A&amp;R team will make contact with the artist, assuming there is a contact address or telephone number on the tape (it is remarkable how many tapes arrive without these basic details). 
 The second popular question follows almost automatically, &bquo;What are the chances of getting a deal from an unsolicited demo tape?&equo; 
 The answer is not encouraging. 
 One in 5,000 is a rough estimate. 
 Record companies receive between 80 and 120 tapes in an average week. 
 As Nick Gatfield, director of A&amp;R for EMI Records (UK) says, &bquo;In three and a half years at EMI I have signed only one artist from an unsolicited demo tape.&equo; 
 According to Gatfield there is one obvious way of reducing the odds: 
 It is all about presentation. 
 Send in a good quality tape with no more than four songs. 
 Choose the songs which show the widest range of your abilities, and put the best one first. 
 Also, include a brief biography and, if possible, a picture. 
 It is as plain and simple as that. 
 Some of the tapes we receive arrive on dodgy cassettes, have various bits and pieces of other music on them, and we have to waste time trying to find the relevant bit of the tape. 
 Frequently there is no contact number, so even if we like the music, we can't do much about it. 
 The material included on any demo tape, to gain the attention of A&amp;R staff who are listening to tapes all week, should be strong properly presented and preferably original. 
 &bquo;Cover versions can give an assessment of singing ability&equo;, says Gatfield, &bquo;but not star quality. 
 I believe that non-writing artists need a staggering voice and great charisma. 
 We are really looking for original material performed in an original way.&equo; 
 star quality is the ingredient which is almost impossible to define and most sought after by record companies. 
 &bquo;Essentially what I look for is a star, somebody with great character,, confirms Gatfield. &bquo;of course, it is usually the front man, the singer, who needs to have that special appeal.&equo; 
 The visual presentation of a new artist is another area of interest to A&amp;R people. 
 presenting songs on video is a real bonus for the record company. 
 &bquo;producing a video is fantastic. 
 Every piece of material we  have helps to assess an act. 
 We don't expect videos from emerging artists because they can be very expensive,&equo; explains Gatfield. 
 &bquo;Leaving videos aside, I won't sign a band without seeing them perform live, if that is possible. 
 people are going out to see live bands again, and gigging is an important factor in establishing new acts. 
 Diesel park West sent us incredible demo tapes, but I would not do a deal without seeing them perform live., 
 The role of management in the first stages of a band's career should not be underestimated. 
 As Gatfield says, 
 all artists should look for management very early on. 
 They can certainly get record company interest without management. 
 However once a record deal is signed the value of good management becomes obvious. 
 In addition to the A&amp;R department's other duties, we also teach and help new, inexperienced managers who bring acts to us. 
 Inefficient management makes life very difficult for everybody, artists, record companies, agents and promoters alike. 
 A band's early live dates may attract interest from management companies who already have artists signed to record companies. 
 These are the people who open the doors which are closed to unsolicited demo tapes. 
 New artists without management could buy the annual directory published by the British music industry's leading trade magazine, Music Week. 
 This carries a list of managers plus all record company addresses. 
 However, managers have their own criteria before signing a band to their &bquo;stable&equo;. 
 The easy part is identifying the manager you want. 
 The hard graft may be persuading him or her to do the job. 
 Like record companies, managers want to hear good demo tapes, see a good live show and identify the act as having excitement and potential. 
 of course, not all management companies and managers are based in London. 
 Every city and many large towns have a management company which can open doors and who are in regular contact with A&amp;R staff, anxious for news about outside London. 
 With or without management, Gatfield has a few words of warning for up-and-coming hopefuls determined to make an impression on record company A&amp;R people. 
 Don't pull stunts. 
 Don't turn up and play live on the back of a truck outside the record company. 
 It was probably effective the first time, but now it is looked on as a desperate move, a last ditch attempt to gain attention. 
 Don't arrive at the record company expecting, even demanding, a meeting. 
 You won't get an appointment. 
 send tapes in, or leave them at reception. 
 The A&amp;R people will listen to them at their own convenience, which may be at midnight after a gig or on a flight across the Atlantic. 
 A&amp;R staff don't listen to a tape for the first time in front of a new artist. 
 Finally, don't assume winning a talent contest is a passport to success. 
 We avoid all invitations to judge or sponsor such competitions. 
 They lack credibility. 
 If an act is good, we aim to be aware of them already. 
 We never offer recording contracts as  prizes, although we are constantly asked to do so. 
 There are enough places around the UK in which to play live, create a &bquo;buzz&equo; and catch our attention without competing with jugglers and animal acts. 
 As most new artists signed by record companies are introduced to A&amp;R departments by established managers, or by music industry lawyers, artists should consider approaching more than just a record company when seeking a recording contract. 
 This situation also raises accusations that the record industry is an incestuous business in which the old pal's act dominates at the expense of new undiscovered talent. 
 Nick Gatfield disagrees. 
 &bquo;The music business is a small community which communicates by word of mouth. 
 Any artist should seek out those people who can get them closer to a record company.&equo; 
 The lucky few who are offered a recording contract must understand what they are signing. 
 As with any legal document, a record contract contains clauses and phrases which are not easily understood by the layman. 
 &bquo;To ensure that artists are fully aware of all conditions and clauses we will offer a list of music industry lawyers for them to choose from if they need help with the contract. 
 We will not sign any artist who doesn't have legal representation. 
 This is as much for their protection as ours,&equo; says Gatfield (see Mark Melton's and Mark Boomla's articles for details of the legal and financial aspects of recording, publishing and other contracts). 
 There are other ways for aspiring stars to catch the attention of a record company. 
 According to Gatfield, 
 the music press is read avidly by A&amp;R departments to find anything of interest. 
 These papers do review unsigned, up-and-coming acts and this is a useful source of information. 
 Also, anyone in the company can suggest names to us who? may be worth checking out. 
 In particular, sales people in the regions often notice or see promising local bands. 
 We check this information with our talent scouts. 
 We have two people working in A&amp;R who are rarely in our offices. 
 They spend seven to ten days in a particular area, seeing bands, checking out the local press and radio stations, getting contacts for future reference. 
 These scouts need to be aware of new fashions as they happen so we can react immediately. 
 Before detailing the terms of a recording contract, Gatfield insists that artists who have been rejected should keep trying. 
 &bquo;It is important that acts don't just send in exactly the same tapes time and time again. 
 Go back and work at it some more. 
 When you have something that is absolutely right, something you are proud to present, send it in.&equo; 
 Artists who had been turned down can't expect assistance from a record company which already has a number of signed acts needing help and attention. 
 As Gatfield points out, &bquo;I can't  work on a host of acts who I am vaguely interested in, just in case one day they come up with something exciting. 
 If there is something of real interest to us, but we aren't ready to do a deal, we keep in touch and might fund a demo tape or some rehearsal time.&equo; 
 The Recording Contract 
 &bquo;Any artist thinking they have made it when they sign a recording contract is totally wrong,&equo; warns Gatfield. 
 &bquo;That is when it really all starts.&equo; 
 The Advance 
 As new bands get a pittance for live work, the record company put them on a wage which can be in the form of an initial advance. 
 For instance, an album deal will mean 50 per cent of the advance on signing. 
 This can be paid out weekly or monthly. 
 The remaining 50 per cent would be paid on delivery and acceptance of the album. 
 In football, the world's major players are invariably signed to the world's top clubs. 
 In music, the world's top artists are most often with the world's top record companies. 
 Contracts offered by major record companies are basically the same. 
 Artists sign a world-wide, long-term deal, and the record company is committed initially to releasing one or two singles and an album. 
 The record company, however, holds annual options to extend the deal up to five, six or even seven albums. 
 A Major Artist Deal 
 World-wide deal for seven albums 
 Advance (recoupable) &pound;1.5m per album for first four albums; &pound;2.0m in total for the remainder 
 Recording costs (recoupable) &pound;150,000 to &pound;250,000 per album 
 Video costs (recoupable) &pound;300,000 to &pound;500,000 per video 
 Manufacturing costs 
 35p per cassette 
 50p per /album 
 &pound;2 per CD 
 Marketing costs &pound;60,000 per album 
 Unit sales required for: 
 Contribution break even 700,000 albums and 550,00 singles 
 To recoup advances 1.6m albums and 1.3m singles 
 Signing major artists is a highly competitive business. 
 often it involves a long chase in which the relationships between the record company personnel, the artist and the manager can be the deciding factor. 
 This example of a major deal outlines the money paid to the  artist as advances for a seven-album, world-wide deal, with recording and video costs recoupable. 
 An essential part of such a major deal is that the album from an established artist is launched into the market place with a strong impact. 
 This is the reason for the committed marketing budget. 
 This amount confirms the record company's belief in the artist. 
 In turn, the artist supports the album by undertaking promotional work and, where possible, touring when the album is released. 
 A deal of this size, done by a British record company and covering the world, requires success not just in the UK, but also internationally. 
 The British market represents about 8 per cent of the world-wide record business. 
 The USA has 33 per cent, followed by Japan (14 per cent) and Germany (9 per cent). 
 However, there have been times in the recent past when 50 per cent of the artists selling and succeeding in the USA have been British. 
 Also, UK-based artists have been regularly responsible for over 30 per cent of the world's record business. 
 Unknown Artist Deal 
 Worldwide deal for five albums 
 Advance (recoupable) &pound;30,000 to &pound;75,000 per album 
 Recording costs (recoupable) &pound;100,000 to &pound;120,000 per album 
 Video costs (recoupable) &pound;30,000 to &pound;50,000 per video 
 Manufacturing costs 
 35p per cassette 
 50p per album 
 &pound;2 per CD 
 Unit sales required for: 
 Contribution break even 110,000 albums 
 To recoup advances 350,000 albums 
 When signing a new artist the negotiating strength mainly lies with the record company. 
 However, the offer of a first record deal should not result in a &bquo;sign at all costs&equo; attitude from the artist. 
 An unsigned act which is being chased by half a dozen record companies does have some leverage in negotiations, but only as much as the levels of supply and demand will allow. 
 In the end, a record company makes a judgement on the value and potential of a new band. 
 The company is rarely persuaded to change that assessment, even in the light of competition from other companies. 
 The unknown artist deal reflects lower advances and reduced recording and video costs which sustain the emerging act through the development stage of their career. 
 A new artist with this sort of deal  should expect to receive a royalty rate of 10&ndash;14 per cent of the retail price. 
 This figure would include any producer's royalty. 
 As recording and video costs can rise with the artist's gradual development, there will be an evaluation of every record's sales figures to ascertain why a record failed or achieved only marginal success. 
 Then a decision can be taken about changing the artist's material, producer or musical style. 
 Finally, this decision amounts to the choice of whether to pick up the artist's annual option. 
 While it would be unlikely for a firm contractual commitment to be made which binds a record company to produce a promotional video, it is a matter of fact that a promotional video will be produced to support an artist's first single. 
 With limited production costs, this video would fall into the &pound;15,000 to &pound;30,000 range, as opposed to the six-figure costs incurred by the established major artists. 
 The cost of the promotional video for a developing artist would be recoupable against both audio and video income received by the record company. 
 The income to pay these video costs is usually minimal with new artists, so these expenses are often set against future video exploitation. 
 This is income which increases as the artist gains greater success and begins to release such items as compilation videos comprising selected promotional videos, or full length videos of live concert performances. 
 After the Deal: What Next? 
 After capturing the all-important record contract, the artist is left to work with the A&amp;R person who made their introduction to the company. 
 &bquo;In those early days,&equo; says Gatfield, &bquo;the A&amp;R person is everything to a new act &mdash; they hold the purse strings and there is a very special relationship because it was the A&amp;R person who offered them the way into a record company, which is very, very special.&equo; 
 However, the days of moulding artists (&equo; wear that, play this, look like this, get your hair cut like that') have gone. 
 As Gatfield says, &bquo;I would not want to sign an artist who demands much moulding. 
 I am attracted to artists needing assistance to bring out the talent which is already there. 
 starting with the right material, the A&amp;R staff try to encourage artists to write commercially and they introduce them to good studios, engineers, producers and other musicians.&equo; 
 The whole process takes time. 
 It can be a year from signing the deal that the first single is released. 
 &bquo;Those 12 months,&equo; explains Gatfield, &bquo;are spent preparing and fine tuning everything. 
 I don't like surprises in the recording studio. 
 I hope to go in with songs we are all happy with, the arrangements agreed and the musicians properly prepared. 
 It is too expensive to start rehearsing in the recording studio.  
 Having signed the new artist, spent time ensuring everything is right and finally gone into the studio to produce &bquo;the&equo; single, the record company puts its wares out for everyone to hear. 
 How will the public like it? 
 Will the radio play it? 
 Will it be a record that clubs get behind, or will the act become favourites with the media and no one else? 
 The A&amp;R person's job doesn't end with handing over the record to the marketing, promotion and sales teams. 
 As Gatfield stresses: 
 In A&amp;R, we are fully aware of the problems which exist in exposing new and developing acts, especially with the current state of British radio. 
 We are always looking for the revolutions in music, people like Prince or Jimi Hendrix. 
 But the nature of the media in this country isn't open to people breaking new ground. 
 Radio certainly isn't. 
 I believe that part of our responsibility in A&amp;R is to introduce new artists and sounds to the market place. 
 It is tough, but with top quality artists we have a responsibility to offer their music to the public, however difficult it is to let them hear it. 
 Despite British radio's disinterest in new music, and the reduced influence of the music press, I believe real talent will eventually get through. 
 With good quality records and exciting live performances, artists can attract the attention of individual journalists and disc jockeys, even if they don't benefit from much daytime radio play. 
 Hopefully, these opinion-formers will champion the act's cause and gradually the public will be interested enough to find out more. 
 The pure pop act also has its problems when it comes to exposure. 
 According to Gatfield, &bquo;there is so much competition for air play between a host of pop bands, new ones need to have something special and different to stand out&equo;. 
 Gatfield is still surprised by the record-buying public's assumption that the first record they purchase by a new act must be that artist's first release. 
 &bquo;It is amazing how often they are wrong. 
 sometimes artists have been working for two or three years, releasing records unsuccessfully, although the public's perception is that their first hit must be their first record. 
 significantly, the more time that bands take becoming successful is often reflected by their longer stay at the top.&equo; 
 Music Publishing 
 In music publishing there are also A&amp;R people. 
 They have similar responsibilities to their counterparts in the record business. 
 The main difference is that in music publishing the company's interest is predominantly in the music and the lyrics &mdash; the written song or composition &mdash; rather than the recorded sound. 
 More recently, record company and music publishing A&amp;R staff have been assessing much of the same talent from different standpoints.  
 This is because most of today's major recording artists compose their own songs. 
 similarly, most new and aspiring artists offer their own material for consideration. 
 There are some artists who rarely write their own material (Cliff Richard is the classic example), and as a result, the specialist songwriter always has a place in music publishing companies. 
 The music publisher represents the writer and their compositions. 
 The company's main duty is twofold: the exploitation and the protection of the &bquo;work&equo;. 
 To achieve these aims, publishers collect all money due to the works in their catalogue. 
 This is from record sales, live performances and broadcasting (including TV commercials and film soundtracks). 
 In the UK, songs remain in copyright for the lifetime of the composer plus fifty years. 
 so, the publisher has constant work for new and contemporary writers as well as established composers whose work has spanned decades. 
 Music publishing companies are always alert to the possibility of signing new songwriting talent. 
 This is their main means of improving and updating their catalogue of songs. 
 They discover much of this talent in the same way as record companies. 
 often, new songwriters are searching for a recording contract as artists. 
 A music publishing contract may be offered to a developing artist after they have signed to a record company. 
 However, publishing companies are also the recipients of demo tapes. 
 publishers' requirements from these tapes are the same as those of record companies: a good recording which is well presented. 
 The former head of talent acquisition at EMI Music publishing in the UK, peter Doyle, explains this: 
 Presentation may not get you plus points, but poor presentation gets the sort of result which reflects the lack of effort put into the tape. 
 During my time at EMI, we received up to fifty tapes a week. 
 sadly, most of them fell well below the acceptable level of quality. 
 Although we did receive some sheet music, we mainly got tapes. 
 The ideal tape would have no more than three songs, a brief, factual biography, a photograph and details of any live dates. 
 It may seem odd that a music publishing company would want a photograph, but Doyle points out that the look of an artist may be important to develop an act's recording career. 
 If we sign an act without a record contract, we develop their music and their image so we can present them favourably to a record company.&equo; 
 Many songwriting hopefuls never get that far. 
 Doyle believes it is mainly down to the quality of the songs which are submitted. 
 The songs are often badly written. 
 It is obvious the writers haven't paid enough attention to current popular songs and musical styles. 
 Unfortunately,  most of the material which is sent in comes from people who have no other way of getting in touch with us, or who are unable to seek the advice of professional songwriters or publishers. 
 Essentially, they are amateurs with little experience. 
 Regrettably, this shows in the quality of their work. 
 Like record companies, publishing companies have their contacts. 
 Many of these are in recording studios. 
 producers or engineers who are working with a new artist, and creating something unusual or interesting, regularly tip off their contacts in the publishing business. 
 Doyle confirms this: 
 Most of the good songs which I heard about came to me that way. 
 People at a studio might call me, or tell the act to get in touch with me direct. 
 Like any other business, it is all to do with contacts and getting introductions. 
 People who could open my door were managers, agents, engineers and producers. 
 It is difficult for unknown newcomers to find those people in the first place. 
 The question of management and legal representation for aspiring new-comers is just as valid in publishing as it is in recording. 
 According to Doyle: &bquo;no one is forced to have a lawyer or manager when they meet with a publishing company, but deals would never be negotiated unless artists were legally represented. 
 We would help artists by suggesting a list of industry lawyers for them to choose from.&equo; 
 To begin with, pure songwriters don't need managers as much as performing artists. 
 But when non-performing songwriters became successful, with their songs being recorded by major artists, and used in films or as TV commercials, then the need for a manager often becomes more pressing. 
 Contracts 
 The contracts on offer to music writers fall into two categories. 
 1. 
 The non-performing writer could be offered a firm one-year deal with options covering the next four years. 
 There would be an advance paid to the writer on signing the deal. 
 In return, the writer would give a product commitment. 
 This would be a promise to deliver anything up to ten songs in a year. 
 The royalties paid to writers for recorded music, referred to as mechanical royalty rates, are based on a percentage of the retail selling price. 
 This royalty is divided between the writer and the publishing company. 
 Initially, the split is around 70 per cent to the composer and 30 per cent to the publisher. 
 These shares will change with a writer's success, as an ever larger percentage will be paid to the composer, subject to negotiation. 
 The rights to the writer's compositions will remain with the publishing company for between ten and fifteen years after the expiry of the deal. 
 There is also the possibility of further income for the composer from sales of sheet music. 
 This is only a possibility when the songs are popular enough to be published in this form. 
 A royalty of between 10 and 15 per cent of the retail price of the sheet music could be negotiated for the composer.  
 2. 
 The songwriter who is also a performer, and has acquired a recording contract, could hope to receive a firm one-year deal with options covering the next three years. 
 There would be a product guarantee to deliver an album of material per year, which would be released under the separate recording contract. 
 If the publishing company are actively involved in acquiring a recording contract for the artist, they would provide studio time for producing demos. 
 Doyle explains another aspect of the deal: &bquo;the contract signed in the UK would be world-wide. 
 The advances would be at a level which enables the artist to live and concentrate on improving his or her writing skills. 
 The publishing deal is totally independent from any record contract. 
 There certainly would not be any conferring with the record company to try and establish comparable advances., 
 So what does the publishing company do for the non-performing songwriter? 
 Doyle explains that 
 the publisher attempts to place the artist's songs with record companies, or with artists, to get them recorded and released on record. 
 In the UK, publishing companies take on very few non-performing songwriters. 
 There is more potential in the United States for that. 
 Most British recording artists write their own material, so they are the composers who are signed to publishing companies. 
 Despite that, a talented songwriter would, I believe, still get a deal in the UK. 
 In general, the emphasis in Britain is on the performer/writer. 
 Doyle advises songwriters who don't perform and who can't sing: &bquo;Don't try to perform your own songs. 
 You are doing yourselves and your songs a disservice. 
 Try and find someone who can sing. 
 It helps publishers enormously in judging the merits of your song.&equo; 
 Having signed an artist, it is in the music publishing company's best interests to help this act win a recording contract. 
 &bquo;When you are developing an act up to a record deal, you spend a lot of time with them,&equo; confirms Doyle. 
 &bquo;At EMI we had our own recording studio. 
 our acts were in the building a lot of the time working on their songs, while we would help in the most appropriate ways to ensure the artist's continued development.&equo; 
 The writer who is also a performer isn't the only one who gets help. 
 We advise our composers, helping to sift out the bad songs and to search out opportunities for our writers to compose &bquo;covers&equo; for particular artists. 
 While we aren't ruled by the charts, we do want our songs performed by the right people. 
 However, a lot of money can be earned from non-chart songs which are regularly &bquo;covered&equo;, recorded, performed or used in films, television or commercials. 
 When a company runs a record and a publishing operation, there is some co-operation when signing artists. 
 some artists work with  EMI's music publishing operation and aren't signed to the record company, and vice-versa. 
 Doyle says: 
 Material did come to me at EMI Publishing from EMI Records, and if we were interested in an act who were also looking for a record deal, we would pass the information through to EMI Records. 
 Often, aspiring artists aren't as aware of publishing companies as they are of record companies. 
 As a result, record companies frequently receive demos tapes suited to a publisher's attention. 
 Artists interested in both publishing and recording contracts should send demo tapes to each company. 
 They should not assume their tape will get passed on. 
 The story of Elton John meeting his songwriting partner Bernie Taupin through a small ad in Melody Maker  is one of the music industry's most famous legends, but the chances of two developing talents &mdash; a music writer and a lyricist &mdash; being brought together to form a successful partnership aren't good. 
 According to Doyle: &bquo;in principle, a publishing company would marry up a lyricist with a music writer, but I have never found the opportunity or the talent to do it.&equo; 
 Breaking through, making it to the top and finding real success is never going to be easy, despite the well-voiced criticism of pop music being &bquo;tuneless rubbish&equo;. 
 Peter Doyle is a publishing man who &bquo;admires the skill of the songwriter. 
 &bquo;It is a craft that has to be learned, developed and finally mastered.&equo;  
 Independent Recording and Publishing Companies 
 STEPHEN TANNETT is managing director of IRS Records, After a short recording career with the punk band Menace, Stephen joined Miles Copeland's organization working his way up from a job in the company's warehouse. 
 This article is an edited version of an interview with Stephen at IRS's offices. 
 Everybody producing music for sale to the public has the same problem: because making music costs money, selling product (records, tapes and CDs) is the only way to survive. 
 So small and large record companies all try to bring their music to the market place for an audience to buy. 
 The structures of majors and independents are determined by the size of the repertoire each company handles. 
 The staff of a major can be huge, but the nucleus of people who deal with a band is very similar in a good small company. 
 The A&amp;R person is responsible for the artist's relationship with the record company. 
 At IRS, a lot of our A&amp;R work is done by Miles Copeland and myself. 
 our press and radio promotions people can be our own staff or a freelancer, depending on the requirements of our artist. 
 Our label manager gets the finished master tapes to the stage of putting a sleeve around it, while our marketing person decides when records are released, in which formats and how radio and television will be approached. 
 These departments all exist in major and independent companies. 
 However, if a small company doesn't provide for any one of these operations, it is unlikely that company can give its artists adequate service. 
 single-handed operations are very difficult. 
 No one can be in more than one place at any time, and in the life of a single or an album, a record company needs people working in more than five places all at once. 
 As majors handle much more product than independents, they have more staff, maybe two or three label managers, two marketing people, and three or four radio promotions  staff. 
 our personnel at IRs reflect the number of people we need to do the job. 
 The advantages of a small company over a large one is a matter of swings and roundabouts. 
 In independent companies, a band can talk to the people who count and who make the decisions. 
 If a manager is in the A&amp;R office at CBS, he or she rarely has access to anybody else in the company. 
 His or her only links are the A&amp;R staff and perhaps the marketing people. 
 Unless the manager represents a big artist, he or she wouldn't work with the record company's senior directors. 
 By contrast, when a manager comes to seem me, I can make things happen to sort out any problems. 
 A small company will probably focus its attention on each artist's project more than a major label. 
 This is because majors work on the priority system. 
 If your band isn't this week's priority, you are probably going to be forgotten. 
 It isn't quite that cut and dried, but if you are signed to a small company with any degree of commitment, you can be sure that the company and their staff are in their weekly meetings pushing to get results from your music. 
 Independent and Major Publishers 
 Basically, publishers make paper transactions. 
 They don't produce a piece of vinyl to be sold in a retail outlet. 
 Old-style publishing was based around retail sheet-music sales, but current publishing is a banking operation which involves taking a risk on an artist. 
 Anyone can be a publisher by registering their songs with the various societies (MCPS and PRS). 
 If their copyright music becomes a record and is sold, royalties become due. 
 A publisher can collect that money just as easily as an artist, but a publishing company has the resources to offer the artist effective promotion services. 
 Often, smaller maverick publishers are the talent scouts for the music business. 
 They sign up new artists' songs, and franchise off their rights in that music to bigger companies when these larger firms become interested. 
 In effect, the small publisher &bquo;subpublishes&equo; their songs through a big company like SBK or Warner-Chappell. 
 The small publisher collects money in the same way as a larger one, but a bigger publisher has extra staff to promote a writer's repertoire. 
 If a writer has produced a song he or she thinks is a must for Cliff Richard, a major publisher is most likely to get that song where it needs to be in order to interest Cliff. 
 However, a small independent may take on an unknown songwriter when nobody else is interested. 
 In that case, the small publisher invests money to own the new writer's copyrights. 
 This can be one time when a young writer has to compromise on some immediate ambitions in order to progress on to the next stage of securing a record deal or having artists cover his  or her songs. 
 It must be better to have a publisher supporting your music, however big or small, than still being yet another unknown songwriter trying to get your first break. 
 Finding New Talent for Publishing and Recording 
 At IRS and the Bugle group we are very lucky because there is an agency called Prestige Talent which books concerts for artists who aren't signed to IRS or any other record company. 
 Like all booking agents, they have to be very hot on new talent. 
 They need to find the latest popular artists who are going to sell concert tickets. 
 IRs hears about a lot of young acts from prestige Talent. 
 Other ways we find bands include: ( a ) being recognized in the industry as a company that is worth approaching (managers with new artists drop in to play a tape to me or any of the other A&amp;R people); ( b ) demo tapes (they all get heard eventually, but to get your tape picked out of the pile for special attention is difficult); ( c ) seeing them play live on the London circuit. 
 If you work very hard at making somebody in a record company come and see you, that is probably as good a way as any to get some indication of your music's commercial potential. 
 After sending in a tape, with a biography, contact address and a photo, a useful approach can be to update the A&amp;R department every time your band does one or a series of gigs. send in a sheet of paper personally addressed to your target A&amp;R person. 
 The mail will come through to the secretary, and most of the time if it isn't a tape and is just a letter, the A&amp;R person's morning mail will include your gig information. 
 At least your band's name and date sheet is on the A&amp;R person's desk and they have seen it. 
 You can't lose from that. 
 Tapes are the last resort because they are the least effective way of attracting attention. 
 They are a part of the process, although I have never signed an artist from a demo without seeing the group play live. 
 You have to be creative to make your tape jump out of the pile. 
 If your biography says we are a 3 piece rock group from Lancashire, we play soft pop and melodic songs', it doesn't show much initiative. 
 If a band can work that little bit harder to be more original, someone somewhere should start to be interested in their music. 
 I have been approached on many levels, from stripograms in the office to packages arriving at reception with worms and a message inside threatening even worse if I didn't see the band (I didn't). 
 I did look at the stripogram group because I was so horrified at the thought that they might do it again. 
 Attracting interest is down to persistence. 
 Drop by the record company, go to the reception, give your tape to the receptionist and try to persuade him or her to put your demo on to your target A&amp;R  person's desk. 
 You have to use these methods because there are fifty cassettes coming in every day and you need yours to be picked out and heard with particular care. 
 If somebody can manoeuvre your tape to the receptionist, who gets it to the secretary and then to the A&amp;R person, it has to help your chances. 
 Everyone is overworked in this business. 
 The A&amp;R work in smaller companies, when there isn't somebody whose sole job is sitting and listening to tapes, gets done when it can be. 
 If someone really works hard to get something to my attention, it will be heard that much quicker. 
 It is easy to find out who deals with A&amp;R in a record company, and it has to be worth the legwork to find the person specializing in your type of music. 
 However it is more difficult getting an opinion about an act's music over the phone. 
 The phone rings a lot and usually it interrupts a meeting. 
 Developing New Artists 
 Once I am interested in an act's music and I like their live performance, the first thing I want to know is where this new band sees itself going. 
 some artists expect us to make them stars. 
 Others present what they do and what they want to achieve in their first year, for example, putting out an album and going on tour. 
 This reassures me that the band are clear about what they are trying to do, and it is far easier for me to get excited by someone coming in with a plan and an idea. 
 A recent example of this approach was our six albums with REM. 
 When we signed them, they had already made an EP by themselves. 
 They asked us whether we would consider releasing this record. 
 We decided to take it on. 
 They didn't ask for any money, they just wanted a good royalty and help with promotion. 
 From then on, they delivered an album absolutely on time for an August or September release six years running. 
 They always had their own plans. 
 They never complained that their music wasn't on certain radio stations because they understood the scope of their work. 
 It made life very easy for us. 
 We could concentrate on trying to bring their product to as many people in the market place as possible. 
 We weren't also having to create the idea and the reason for the band's existence. 
 They had those already. 
 If a band's young manager could come to me with an independently produced EP, with live circuit work pulling good crowds, success in merchandising T-shirts, and evidence of media interest, that would be a fantastic beginning. 
 Then everyone starts to believe in this group. 
 When a manager walks in with none of these things a record company is being asked to use a lot of imagination. 
 sometimes that    works. 
 When Kate Bush was signed, she wasn't a live artist and someone had to envisage her potential. 
 Stephen Tannett 
 After deciding we like a band, we would consider whether to make singles with an option for an album, or to go straight for an album. 
 In an album deal at IRS, we would make the band an offer based on the percentage royalty points which we thought were appropriate, having worked out a budget to make a record. 
 Almost always the company will pay the artist's recording expenses, give them a small advance and choose and pay the producer. 
 In any album deal, we normally take options for six albums. 
 When we are developing an artist on an international basis, success doesn't necessarily happen in the first or second album. 
 We may have to wait until the third one. 
 In that case, we want to be around for the big money in the fourth, fifth and sixth records. 
 All of our artists are on long-term contracts. 
 Normally, we don't pay less than 10 per cent to an artist. 
 smaller companies may try paying less, but a starting royalty of between 10 and 12 per cent is fairly standard. 
 Working with the Same Recording and Publishing Companies 
 If a recording artist comes to me without a publishing deal, I always insist IRS is considered for publishing as we can pay better percentage splits, do just as good a job, and help invest in an act's career at a vital time. 
 For instance, an IRs artist may want to tour. 
 We may only be able to afford to put up a certain amount of money to help fund them. 
 The band may turn to their publisher, who is part of a different company, for some extra money. 
 The publisher might refuse and there is little IRS can do to force that publisher to help the band. 
 If the band were signed to the publishing company which is part of the Bugle group, I could ring them to try and force the publisher to invest even more money in the artist. 
 That can make all the difference. 
 If we sign a publishing deal in conjunction with a record deal, we usually make the deals co-terminous. so, if we only make one single with a band, we don't keep the publishing on that act forever. 
 In a publishing deal, the average splits used to be 50:50. 
 Then it went to 60:40 in favour of the artist. 
 Currently, 75:25 is very favourable, 80:20 is exceptional and 90:10 is fantastic. 
 Most deals are done on the basis of 60:40. 
 Showcases 
 If a band has an A&amp;R buzz, they may play a showcase at the Marquee or another London venue. 
 They probably invite the &bquo;fraternity&equo; (the A&amp;R staff from the major record companies) to the gig. 
 The risk is that there can be a collective NO from everyone. 
 one A&amp;R person might tell another that he or she doesn't like the band, and the feeling  can spread like wild fire. 
 suddenly, everybody rejects the group, even though they may be fantastic. 
 In one go, the band have killed their chances with twenty-five different companies. 
 At least if it goes wrong with just one A&amp;R person out front, there are plenty more to approach. 
 If I were looking for a record deal, I would be pursuing individual A&amp;R people, getting them to come and see my band. 
 The band would have to be playing a lot of shows so they are available as often as possible for viewing. 
 Then, if the target A&amp;R person does come, there is a better chance of him or her making a fair analysis of the artist without being caught up in A&amp;R peer pressure. 
 There is apathy within the A&amp;R departments of major record companies. 
 It is different for smaller companies like IRS. 
 If we go to see a band, we don't just send an A&amp;R person, one of our product managers or maybe the sales director might come as well. 
 We want to know their opinion of the band so that if we sign the group, we hope everyone in the company will like the artist's work and try to promote it as well as possible. 
 Self-Reliant Acts 
 Independent companies are often the setting for bands who already have an idea of the sort of music they want to make, and where they want to end up. 
 More importantly, independents can be the right place for artists who want to keep a degree of creative control. 
 Radio 
 STUART GRUNDY is an executive producer at BBC Radio 1, with direct responsibility for evening and weekend programmes as well as special events. 
 He began in radio with the British Forces Broadcasting Service as a producer/ presenter and moved to Radio Luxembourg as a resident DJ in 1965. 
 Two years later he joined the BBC to help launch Radio 1. 
 Through the years he has produced almost every Radio 1 programme, written and presented numerous internationally syndicated music documentary series and published books on Great Guitarists  and The Art of the Record Producer. 
 More recently he produced the overall sound coverage of Live Aid, and as a presenter one of his programmes, &bquo;Three at 30, Marvin Gaye&equo;, won the 1989 New York International Festival's Gold Award for Best Talk/Interview Special. 
 Although many people would disagree, radio is without doubt the musician's best friend. 
 To make the most of it, musicians need to understand how it works. 
 Within the BBC, music is confined to three national networks, Radios 1, 2 and 3, with a limited amount being featured on Radio 5. 
 In contrast, local radio is a mix of commercial and BBC stations. 
 In the offing, with a probable start date of 1992, are three INRs or Independent National Radio stations. 
 Although the new Broadcasting Bill stipulates that these stations will provide a varied diet of programmes, the best bet is that one will feature primarily classical music, the second will have a pop/rock music base, while the third is likely to be an American-style &bquo;talk&equo; station. 
 As Britain's only national pop music station at present, Radio 1 is most likely to interest aspiring rock and pop musicians, so I will explain its workings and policies in some detail (although much of what is said about Radio 1 will also be applicable to Radio 2). 
 Radio 1 
 Radio 1 broadcasts for twenty-one hours a day, although shortly this will be twenty-four. 
 Its programmes are presented by well-  established &bquo;personality&equo; broadcasters, some of whom are very music-oriented. 
 For them, music is their only consideration and they would regard themselves as fans and supporters of pop music. 
 other Radio I broadcasters see their job as being popular entertainers. 
 Indeed, one famous DJ was recently quoted as saying &bquo;I'm paid to provide the bits between the records&equo;. 
 Not only is that true, it is also nothing to be ashamed of. 
 A lively radio station has a variety of on-air personalities, and not all of them will be as devoted to music as others. 
 Even though some presenters use music merely as a vehicle for their own performances, it is worth remembering that they would all find it very difficult to do their job without the music base. 
 Although presenters are encouraged to take an active part in preparing their programmes, this work is basically the responsibility of producers. 
 Currently, Radio 1 employs nineteen producers who supervise 147 hours of broadcasting each week. 
 They are all answerable to two executive producers, a head of music department and a network controller. 
 so, the station's management structure is quite bare and this helps it to respond very quickly to current events. 
 Every radio station needs a target audience. 
 This helps to structure the content of its programmes as well as its public image, and until the mid-1980s, Radio I was aiming at the 16&ndash;25 age group. 
 The received BBC wisdom was that young people went through a period of obsession with rock and pop, but that as &bquo;sanity and maturity&equo; prevailed, they would graduate &bquo;like their elders&equo; to light, popular music. 
 Now, extensive research has proved that quite wrong. 
 It is very clear that today's parents don't fit the mould that society defined for them twenty years ago. 
 so, Radio I has widened its target audience to 16&ndash;35 year olds. 
 Radio 1 is heard by an average audience of over seventeen million every week. 
 The vast majority of people listen during the day, and the station has a different editorial approach to its weekday daytime programmes and to its evening and weekend shows. 
 put simply, weekday daytime programmes are more centrally co-ordinated and structured than all other shows. 
 The core of weekday daytime programming is the &bquo;playlist&equo;, which has three major uses for Radio I: it provides an overall sound or &bquo;station feel&equo;; it is an effective way to monitor how often the most popular records are played; and it makes a group responsibility out of a decision which may have far-reaching effects for individual musicians and the music industry. 
 The Playist 
 The Radio 1 playlist has changed its shape, size and effect considerably over the years. 
 Currently, there are fifteen records on its  A list and twenty on its B list (records on the A list are simply rotated more frequently than on the B list). 
 Every week, the playlisted records are programmed by a computer to rotate around the different weekday daytime shows. 
 out of the seven or eight records played in each Radio I half-hour, four or five will be from the playlist. 
 As a result, the A and B lists provide just over half of the records on daytime Radio 1. 
 As it is such an important programming tool, with such important consequences for musicians' careers, it is worth understanding how the playlist is chosen. 
 Every Monday morning, the Radio I playlist committee meets in one of the BBC's basement rooms. 
 This isn't for any covert reason, it just happens that most of the BBC's committee rooms are down there! 
 At this meeting are Radio 1's daytime producers and a chairperson who is usually the executive producer of weekday daytime shows. 
 Any presenters or other Radio I producers who want to contribute are welcome. 
 The emphasis at this committee is on records which have just been released, or which are about to be released. 
 Everyone arrives with a stack of singles which they think are worth considering for the playlist. 
 Each record is played and every member of the playlist group is asked to comment. 
 once the strength of the new week's material has been assessed, the next move is to decide which records will be removed from the present playlist to make room for the new ones. 
 This discussion may be based entirely on &bquo;gut feel&equo; or on more objective things like statistics of record sales or radio play. 
 But What Gets a Record on the Playlist? 
 This is a reasonable question often asked of all Radio 1 producers. 
 The truth is that although there are general criteria, like whatever is Record on &bquo;interesting&equo;, &bquo;acceptable&equo; or &bquo;fantastic&equo;, these change from season to the season, month to month, and even week to week. 
 The playlist discussion often dwells on a record's &bquo;freshness&equo; or &bquo;originality&equo;. 
 However, so much of what is now being produced lacks these very qualities that it may be more useful to look at successful artists' work to find an answer to this question. 
 If you listen to David Bowie, Elton John, Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen or Paul Simon, you immediately recognize their music. 
 often this is because of a distinctive vocal sound, but sometimes more subtle devices make everyone want to listen. 
 For instance, a few years ago I studied paul Simon's music quite extensively. 
 I discovered that for quite a long part of their career, every Simon and Garfunkel recording used a set of distinctive and unusual percussion sounds. 
 I believe that these helped to combine their characteristic voices with a small element of surprise which gave each track its own fingerprint. 
 But even if you  aren't another Bowie or Elton John, you still need to try and develop an original style. 
 If you sound like everyone else, no one will remember you, even for five minutes. 
 These are general criteria and it is dangerous to be too specific. 
 Have the courage of your convictions to play what pleases you. 
 It may be that your enthusiasm gives that extra bit of life to your record. 
 Also, remember that radio producers listen to over 100 singles a week. 
 They get bored easily, so if you can't excite them in the first 30 seconds of your record, you are probably in the wrong business. 
 Chart position is one criterion which is used to consider a record for playlisting. 
 But no chart placing carries as much weight as the sound of the record. 
 A song may be at number one, but if it doesn't &bquo;feel&equo; right for Radio 1, it won't be playlisted. 
 Andrew Lloyd Webber was reputed to be furious when Radio I declined to playlist Michael Ball's hit, &bquo;Love Changes Everything&equo;. 
 It is a lovely song, but it definitely sounds right on Radio 2 and very wrong on Radio 1. 
 Dance music, too, often doesn't work on radio. 
 Why should it? 
 Usually, it has been designed to be highly amplified in a night-club. 
 Chances are that it won't make an ideal radio record any more than &bquo;Candle in the Wind&equo; would be a dancefloor hit at Stringfellow's. 
 If you listen to the music on individual programmes you will soon get a fair idea of where the playlist is at each week. 
 There is no need to worry about the duration of a record. 
 It used to be said that &bquo;if you can't say what you want to say in three minutes, forget it&equo;. 
 But the three-minute song is just a left-over from when that was all you could fit on to one side of a 78 record. 
 There have been many examples of long, classic singles, like &bquo;Eloise&equo;, &bquo;McCarthur Park&equo; and &bquo;American pie&equo;. 
 At Radio 1, the producers aren't very concerned about a record's length. 
 If a record is terrible, then a minute is too long! 
 Also, lyrical parameters are as wide as current popular taste allows. 
 It is worth remembering that we are dealing with &bquo;popular&equo; music. 
 If you are the sort of band that wants an arts council grant, then you are probably too special or too precious to conform to the limits set by &bquo;popular&equo; taste. 
 The Radio 1 playlist is much maligned, but it is as honest and fair as any system. 
 Despite that, it still puts Radio 1 producers into a catch-22 situation. 
 If they playlist a band's record, then that band think the playlist is &bquo;marvellous&equo;. 
 But if they leave that record out, suddenly the playlist is &bquo;unfair, monstrous and corrupt&equo;. 
 Often musicians don't realize that a record can be played more on Radio 1 when it is off the playlist altogether. 
 It happens all the time. 
 Radio producers have to remind themselves each week that radio broadcasting isn't about selling records, but about entertaining an audience. 
 Research shows  that less than 10 per cent of listeners to Radio 1 are regular record buyers, so it would be unrepresentative of our audience's taste to be ruled by the movements of the singles' chart. 
 Radio presenters and producers often get great pleasure from seeing the success of a record which they have championed. 
 But they are generally happy just to programme and share the pleasant experience of listening to popular music on the radio. 
 Pluggers 
 Apart from albums, there are over 100 singles released every week in Britain, and only five to ten of them will have much commercial success. 
 Any conscientious radio producer will try to hear and consider all of these. 
 However, it is very difficult to make a final decision on one hearing. 
 This is when &bquo;pluggers&equo; start trying to &bquo;persuade&equo; presenters and producers to play a particular record. 
 I believe that in Britain an outstanding record will find its way into the system without much promotion, assuming that it has been distributed to producers. 
 pluggers exist to exploit the middle ground of those record releases which may be a hit, depending on whether radio producers and presenters are prepared to give them a &bquo;run&equo;. 
 At worst, a &bquo;plugger&equo; merely ensures the delivery of a record to someone's office. 
 At best, the plugger can be a creative link between the artist, management, record company and radio station. 
 Obviously, it is in a &bquo;plugger's&equo; interest to claim that it was his or her work which made a record into a hit, but if you employ a &bquo;plugger&equo; it is worth being sceptical when deciding what to believe. 
 Nevertheless, radio producers set aside some time each week to meet pluggers. 
 Producers will usually only meet pluggers who they know already, and rarely see any band's representative because they are probably far too close to the music to have any objectivity. 
 If you are new, young, and underfunded then don't worry. 
 Just make sure that a copy of your record reaches the producers of programmes that you value. 
 Your work should be your most eloquent argument. 
 If you can afford one, a good plugger can benefit both the artist and the radio station by acting as a fixer for guest appearances, or providing news and creative ideas; but like everything, some pluggers are better than others, and radio producers usually prefer to exercise their own musical judgement and not to pander to pluggers' suggestions. 
 Live Music Session Recordings 
 Radio 1 has always spent large amounts of time, effort and money recording live concerts and, in particular, recording full-scale sessions. 
 In the beginning, much of this effort was used to create music to play on the air when the station's needletime was used up.  
 (Needletime is a limit on the number of hours of commercially available recordings which can be broadcast by radio stations. 
 These limits were originally set by phonographic performance Limited, representing the record companies, and the Musicians' Union, to safeguard the viability of commercial recordings.) 
 Currently, Radio I devotes over 5,000 hours a year to recording musicians in its own studios, as well as at live concert performances. 
 The Maida Vale centre in London, for example, contains six music studios and has two of these regularly in use for pop and rock sessions. 
 On average, there is one session recorded each day which is likely to result in four broadcast items or songs. 
 The shape of a session is as follows: 
 1. 
 The setting-up and making of instruments. 
 2. 
 The recording or laying-down of tracks and vocals. 
 (Generally 2 x 3&frac12;-hour recording period.) 
 3. 
 The mixing of tracks and vocals (1 x 3&frac12;-hour period). 
 The only difference from a commercial studio is that the BBC's recordings aren't meant for release on record. 
 They are simply a recording of a band's live or alternative versions of their songs, which are used for one or two broadcasts. 
 This system of sessions lets certain producers develop young musicians' talent, and there is a lengthy list of internationally famous rock and pop stars who were helped by a Radio 1 session. 
 John Peel has encouraged hundreds of musicians on his programmes with his attitude that puts creativity and originality above musicianship. 
 It may be hard to accept, but the argument goes that it is easier for a creative and original performer to learn how to play his instrument than it is for a consummate player to learn creativity. 
 Certainly the numbers of internationally successful British musicians who came out of art school, rather than music college, seem to confirm this. 
 John Lennon, David Bowie, Eric Clapton, Jeff Beck, pete Townshend and Bryan Ferry are just the tip of the iceberg. 
 The producers who supervise Radio 1 sessions tend to be musicians who are used to coaxing good performances out of young bands in a limited period of time. 
 Artists are booked for these sessions by individual &bquo;commissioning producers&equo;, who are responsible for the shows which feature sessions. 
 At present, the programmes in question are those of John peel, Nicky Campbell, Richard skinner, Andy Kershaw and Mark Goodier, and the Friday Rock show. 
 The producers of all these programmes are inundated with cassette tapes from bands, so they may take some time before listening to them all. 
 In every case, you have a better chance of being considered if you are able to put your performance on record. 
 It is possible to make a single, and sell it at your own gigs, for quite a small sum of money (see Chapter 13, &bquo;Doing it the Right Way&equo; by Horace Trubridge). 
 It is  even cheaper to pool your resources with four or five other bands and put together a composite album. 
 If you aren't willing to take a risk on your own music, then don't be surprised if others won't either. 
 If you are after a session, don't waste your time sending tapes and records all over the place. 
 Target them. 
 Find out which of the above programmes and their producers are likely to be most sympathetic to your style of music and remember the following: 
 1. 
 A record is better than a cassette. 
 2. 
 Only send in three tracks at the most (naturally your best). 
 3. 
 Give some brief biographical information. 
 4. 
 Include your address and telephone number. 
 5. 
 Don't hold your breath waiting for a reply. 
 It may take some time! 
 Sessions are often recorded with bands who already have a record deal. 
 In organizing the session, the initiative will almost certainly have been with the commissioning radio producer who will have approached the record company or manager. 
 occasionally a manager or agent will suggest that a band is &bquo;available for session&equo;. 
 However, this usually produces a zero response. 
 As with their choice of records, producers like to rely on their own opinion when they book bands. 
 Other Ways of Attracting Radio's Attention 
 A local radio station might be worth contacting. 
 Regional breakouts aren't unknown, and local stations with a university campus nearby often provide the most fertile ground. 
 sometimes artists attract attention by producing some original news angle. 
 This is fine as long as the music stands up to scrutiny. 
 Often groups get publicity by claiming that their record has been banned. 
 This isn't a ploy to be recommended. 
 All too soon, bands find that their wish has been fulfilled! one of the few successful publicity ploys involved Elvis Costello being arrested for creating a disturbance outside the Hilton Hotel in London's park Lane. 
 CBS Records were inside holding their annual international conference, and Elvis stood in the street performing a selection of his songs using a small portable amplifier, just as his debut single &bquo;Less Than Zero&equo; has just been released. 
 This was a delightfully outrageous thing for a little label (stiff) to do, just to annoy one of the biggest international companies. 
 It gained terrific publicity, but it takes more than column inches to sell records, and I am sure that Elvis's continuing success has more to do with talent. 
 Local Radio 
 In its current form, local radio is shared between the BBC and the commercial companies of the ILR network. 
 In the main, BBC Local  Radio has pursued a programming policy based on local news. 
 But each station is autonomous and some are more music-oriented than others. 
 BBC Local Radio isn't well funded, and you may be able to provide some bargain-basement programming for them, particularly if you are a solo performer. 
 This would depend entirely on getting to know your local station and its personnel. 
 In contrast, ILR stations are businesses. 
 They have directors, sales directors and shareholders, and they broadcast to make money. 
 Recently there have been a number of mergers between these companies which have increased this financial pressure. 
 As a result, many stations are now programmed by one man and a computer. 
 Like their BBC counterparts, independent stations control their own programming policy. 
 some care about developing local musicians, like Radio Clyde, while many don't. 
 As part of their broad-based agreements with the IBA and the MU, ILR stations are obliged to spend at least 3 per cent of their net advertising revenue on live musicians. 
 Many stations choose to spend this money on recording their station's jingles, while others prefer to involve themselves with promoting local concerts by international artists. 
 Many stations still record local musicians in their own studios. 
 But, as always, it is worthwhile finding out more about your local station. 
 To get the best help from the radio, try to find someone in it who might be sympathetic to your music. 
 Listen to the radio carefully and choose your personal contacts accordingly. 
 If you are lucky, the radio can help your career enormously. 
 However, radio producers have the best music to choose from to entertain their audiences, and like its listeners, radio can transfer its affections overnight and without explanation. 
 Good luck. 
 The Musician's Union 
 STAN MARTIN is assistant general secretary of the Musicians' Union with responsibility for the media. 
 After drumming as a semi-professional in the 1960s, Stan took a degree as a mature student at Birmingham University, leading to ten years' work as a careers officer, In 1979 Stan became the Musicians' Union's South-East district organizer, and subsequently the Central London branch secretary and co-editor of the union's award-winning Musician  magazine. 
 Strip away the insincerity and the hype from the music business and see it for what it is, a jungle. 
 When you work in rock and pop music, you are in the thick undergrowth. 
 Like the real jungle, the music business holds a dual attraction for the entrepreneur: the thrill of a gamble and the chance of a quick large profit. 
 Added to this is the reflected glory of being associated with a high-profile, media-exposed product and the prized magical ingredient of youth. 
 It is a heady combination! 
 The music business has some straightforward, honest, &bquo;invest some money and hope to make a profit&equo; entrepreneurs. 
 However, one of this industry's main characteristics is that it attracts the maverick. 
 The tales of manipulation, creative accountancy and downright dishonesty starring some of these wayward entrepreneurs are numerous and well documented. 
 The resulting debris in musicians, careers would be disastrous, but for the MU. 
 The union acts as an industry police force and a rescue service for its members. 
 What is the MU? 
 Fiction: 
 The MU only recruits and is only interested in professional, session and orchestral musicians. 
 Fact 
 : The MU has 40,000 members, with offices and branches throughout the UR, and almost anybody who is either a performer or a composer of music is a member of the MU.  
 The MU's Image 
 The union often gets a bad press, and there are good reasons for this. 
 The union came into existence to serve the interests of musicians. 
 It protects them and ensures they receive adequate payment for their musical skills. 
 The union is not a record company, publisher, radio or TV company, promoter, agent or management company. 
 It has no shareholders or directors. 
 It is run by musicians for the benefit of musicians. 
 Given this, negative coverage from the popular music press, who rely on the commercial music industry for their survival, is excusable. 
 It is less understandable when the union is caricatured in more seriously researched publications. 
 In some guides to the music business the treatment accorded to the union can be shallow and misleading. 
 There is no intimation that the very existence of the MU benefits all musicians, especially the young and inexperienced. 
 Nor is there coverage of the breadth and scope of the union's services. 
 Indeed, readers can be put off from finding out more about the MU, which is the only organization providing protection and service solely to musicians. 
 The aim of this article is to help you find out more about what the MU really does for musicians, day after day after day&hellip; 
 The MU as a Trade Union 
 As a trade union, the MU exists to protect its members and to maximize their rewards, just like all trade unions. 
 The similarity ends there. 
 Musicians' work and way of life is different to that of the members of most unions. 
 For example, most musicians are self-employed. 
 They don't work for one employer on a regular basis. 
 Going to work for a young musician may mean days spent rehearsing &mdash; getting songs down on tape, producing a demo on a front-room recording unit, or playing at a pub gig. 
 This is a unique lifestyle and because of this the MU is a unique trade union. 
 Like other trade unions, the MU negotiates with employers such as TV companies so that when a band appears on &bquo; Top of the Pops &equo; or &bquo; Night Network &equo; the members of the band will be paid an MU-negotiated fee. 
 This is just one example of the MU as a negotiator on behalf of musicians. 
 There are many more, such as negotiating for musical employment in holiday centres or on ships. 
 one problem is that most live gigs are one-offs. 
 As the union can't negotiate separately with every club or pub in the country, the MU has established minimum rates of pay for these gigs. 
 These negotiations and setting of rates is only one part of the union's activities. 
 Printed across the bottom of MU application forms is the slogan: &bquo;Musicians&equo; Union &mdash; Working for Today's Musicians'.    
 Sting 
 Of course, there are all sorts of slogans. 
 some exhort &bquo;smash the&hellip;&equo;. others inform. 
 The union's slogan informs you that it is concerned with servicing the needs of today's musicians. 
 The MU is not preoccupied with the problems of yesteryear. 
 The Music Business Adviser (MBA) 
 Today's musicians are often quite young and new to the business. 
 of the union's total membership, approximately half are under the age of 30. since the advent of rock in the 1950s and 1960s, the union has been the only independent organization to give service, protection and advice to rock musicians. 
 In the 1970s, the union appointed a rock organizer and developed a specialist contract-vetting service. 
 But life was simpler then. 
 solo performers or groups were signed to major record companies. 
 The independent record sector barely existed, and recording was the concern only of established studios. 
 In the 1980s, the independents became a real force, recording technology is easily accessible, and bands are more energetic and enterprising in producing their own records and promoting themselves. 
 The union has responded to these changes by appointing a music business adviser who has expanded the range of services aimed at rock musicians. 
 Free contract-Vetting Service 
 On recording, publishing and  mangement  contracts, the MBA or our specialist solicitor provide union members with free advice and a contract-vetting service. 
 Also, a pre-contract discussion can be arranged with the MBA on an individual or band basis. 
 Music Business Seminars 
 These are regularly organized in London and other centres throughout the country. 
 Topics covered include: recording agreements, music publishing, management, merchandising, all financial matters relevant to a recording artist's career, the A&amp;R process and department in record companies, opportunities for composers in the mechanical media field, and making and marketing your own record. 
 Speakers include music business lawyers, accountants, record company A&amp;R staff, marketing directors, and press and publicity executives, Radio 1 producers, composers and members of independent production companies.  
 Other Services Provided by the MU 
 The services provided by the music business adviser are only part of the union's total commitment to servicing the needs of today's musicians. 
 The union works for musicians on two levels: supporting the individual member, and providing a protective umbrella for all musicians, whether or not they are MU members. 
 Insurance 
 All members are entitled to &pound;500 free insurance cover on their instruments and equipment against damage and loss. 
 For insurance cover over &pound;500, the MU Insurance Advisory service will arrange the best insurance deal to top up the excess. 
 The Insurance Advisory service will also provide cover for all your other insurance needs, such as for your car or your personal belongings. 
 The union's involvement in insurance stems from the difficulties musicians have experienced in getting car or van insurance. 
 Even when they did get cover in the past, the premiums were punitively high. 
 Benevolent Grants and Sickness and Accident Benefit 
 Financial  assisstance  from the union's Benevolent Funds and from the union's benefit scheme is available to meet some of the needs which arise because of a personal accident or illness. 
 If you are ill and unable to work as a musician, the union has funds to help you. 
 Standard contracts 
 The union provides free contract forms for virtually every type of engagement. 
 Currently, there are sixteen contracts available. 
 The most popular of these is for a one-off gig between a band and a venue, part of which is reproduced here. 
 If the type of gig you are offered is so unusual that it is not covered by any of the existing contracts, an MU official will devise one to suit your needs, or add necessary clauses to an existing contract (for performing on the back of a moving open-back lorry, the contract might require clauses covering additional risks!). 
 Legal Services 
 This provides musicians with legal advice on all matters relating to musical employment. 
 This might be legal assistance to recover unpaid fees or help with the negotiations after a cancelled engagement. 
 These legal services include advice on band names, partnership agreements between band members, social security rights and entitlement, and music licences &mdash; anything and everything relating to music, even including: &bquo;Can a freight company hold on to my instruments/equipment because the tour promoter hasn't paid the bill?&equo;  
 STANDARD CONTRACT 
 Musicians' Union Standard Contract 
 For the engagement of a band/group for casual arrangements The Agreement made this day &mdash; of &mdash; 19 &mdash; between &mdash; of &mdash; address &mdash; (hereinafter called the &bquo;Engager&equo;) of the one part and &mdash; of &mdash; address &mdash; (hereinafter called the &bquo;Leader&equo;) of the other part 
 Witnesses 
 1. 
 The Engager engages the Leader to provide a combination of &mdash; musicians (number) appearing as &mdash; (name of band/group) to perform for: *dancing/cabaret accompaniment/stage show/background music (*delete whichever is not applicable) at &mdash; (venue address) from &mdash; am/pm until &mdash; am/pm on &mdash; (date) 2. 
 It is agreed that the inclusive fee for the engagement shall be &pound; &mdash; which shall be payable in cash/by cheque (delete whichever is inapplicable) on the date of the performance.  
 Legal assistance is most commonly used to secure payment of unpaid fees, or payment for a cancelled gig. 
 You know the situation. 
 Your band is booked for a pub gig. 
 You perform. 
 There aren't many people present because the landlord forgot to advertise, even in the free listings papers. 
 As a result, the landlord blames the band for the poor attendance and refuses to pay. 
 He is a big man with two Rottweiler dogs, so you don't argue! 
 The union would attempt to secure payment. 
 If necessary, we will support you through the court process. 
 Information Leaflets 
 General leaflets are available to members about gigs, royalties, &mdash; copyright and contracts. 
 Also, there is a series of specialist leaflets on management, publishing, recording contracts, work abroad, and agents. 
 These leaflets are written in a direct readable style. 
 As an example, I have provided an extract from the &bquo;Gigs&equo; leaflet. 
 ALWAYS ESTABLISH HOW MUCH YOU ARE BEING PAID AND/OR HOW YOU WILL GET THE MONEY 
 Some examples of the arrangements that you might be offered are: 
 * Straightforward fee paid on the night. 
 * A small amount plus half the door take. 
 * The whole door take. 
 whatever it is. 
 * A guaranteed payment plus &bquo;Pass the hat around&equo; or similar arrangement. 
 In some cases these arrangements may seem reasonable, In others they are clearly a-rip-off'. 
 The Union believes that any musician playing to the public should be guaranteed reasonable money. 
 Directories 
 A directory of the MU members in each geographical area is produced every two years. 
 Every member receives a free copy and these directories are also supplied to contractors, agents and venues. 
 Posters 
 Good quality, well-designed, blank posters are supplied free to members and venues. 
 Many bands now take responsibility for advertising their gigs, and these posters encourage these self-help initiatives. 
 Diaries 
 Every member is given a free MU diary. 
 This isn't intended for the profound jottings which occur in the back of the van after a gig (to be  auctioned at Sotherby's when you are dead!). 
 The MU diary is a musician's professional pocket information kit. 
 It doesn't merely contain such valuable information as the date of Mothers' Day, the distance from London to Inverness, and how to control the bleeding of a wound. 
 It covers legal and taxation notes for musicians, as well as advice on recording contracts and other session engagements. 
 It lists the names, addresses and phone numbers of all the union's offices and officers, at national, district and branch level. 
 so wherever you are in the country, you can contact someone local when you need the union's help. 
 The Umbrella Activity 
 As well as these individual benefits and services to members, the union provides an additional service to all musicians by its presence and its activities. 
 As &bquo;the police force of the music business&equo; the union is heavily committed to &bquo;crime prevention&equo;. 
 It promotes this icy in two ways. 
 Firstly, by educating and advising musicians to avoid traps, and on how to secure the greatest rewards for their talents, the MU decreases the pool of prey on which music industry sharks can pounce. 
 secondly, pursuing untrustworthy promoters or record companies, if necessary through the courts and on to the enforcement of judgements, deters other business people from trying to get rich at the expense of musicians. 
 When the union publishes a special Notice in its magazine warning members about the activities of a promoter, record company or contact agency, this not only informs members, it also puts off other unscrupulous operators. 
 The value of these union activities isn't as easy to measure as the benefits and services to individual musicians, but they are just as important. 
 The &bquo;police&equo; role of the union is performed by its full-time officials. 
 As well as national officials such as the general secretary, assistant general secretaries, and the session organizer, who operate from the union's national office in London, there are full-time officials in every district of Britain. 
 The MU's geographical structure gives every member easy access to the union's services and to the ear of a full-time official. 
 These district officials are a combination of advisers, negotiators, lawyers and general trouble-shooters. 
 They are familiar with every branch of the music business, whether it is chamber music or anarchic rock. 
 They have a working knowledge of contract law and other legal areas which affect musicians, such as noise levels and music licences, so that they can give advice on anything and everything that affects musicians. 
 The least visible of the union's services is the constant activity which benefits all musicians indirectly. 
 This includes: making written submissions to public bodies; lobbying MPs and Members of    the House of Lords when legislation on anything connected with music, like copyright, is being enacted; representing musicians' interests in national and international forums on issues such as the collection and payment of royalties on behalf of performers and composers. 
 An example of this activity producing direct benefits to musicians is the case of commercial (ILR) radio stations. 
 In the 1970s when commercial radio was first introduced to Britain, the MU persuaded both the Government and the Independent Broadcasting Authority that the new radio stations should have an obligation to provide some musical employment, and not just fill every minute of air time with recorded music. 
 The agreement which the union negotiated is that commercial radio stations must spend not less than 3 per cent of their net advertising revenue on the employment of musicians. 
 since the union negotiated this, union officials have &bquo;policed&equo; the radio stations to ensure their compliance. 
 Stan Martin 
 Perhaps the most visible of the union's activities is the financial sponsorship of events such as the ICA/MU Rock Week held in May 1989. 
 This is one example of the union &bquo;leading by example&equo;. 
 The union teamed up with the Institute of Contemporary Arts to copromote a Rock Week held at the ICA building in London. 
 This was a showcase for a wide variety of young British musicians and bands currently working outside the mainstream of rock and pop. 
 The bands which appeared were selected by the Hackney Agency for Music Marketing Action (HAMMA) on behalf of the MU and the ICA. 
 The theme of the week was &bquo;Dangerous Bands in safe Hands&equo;, and this was an attempt to highlight the union's concern that live music promoters should be aware of their responsibilities to new artists, and provide them with opportunities for live work with fair conditions and rates of pay. 
 The union is constantly looking out for ways like this to show promoters, record companies and the rest of the music industry the right way to treat musicians, and to remind the business yet again of their responsibility to put back into music just a small part of the rewards which they enjoy, thanks to the skills of musicians. 
 That is the MU in action. 
 If you want to find out more, write to the Musicians' Union: 60 &mdash; 2 Clapham Road, London SW9 0JJ.  
 Copyright and Performing Right 
 BRIAN ENGEL is the membership representative of the Performing Right Society. 
 Before joining the PBS, Brian worked as a singer (including being a member of the New Seekers), songwriter, actor, artist and toy inventor among other creative and business interests. 
 People seem to find it relatively easy to understand the term/patent', but have difficulty with &bquo;copyright&equo;. 
 This is probably because, put simply, the word &bquo;patent&equo; applies to a physical thing, like a new piece of machinery or electrical gadget, whereas &bquo;copyright&equo; applies to &bquo;intellectual property&equo;, that is &bquo;ideas&equo; and &bquo;creations&equo;. 
 In the UK there is no requirement for a copyright reference, no copyright number or anything. 
 Copyright is exactly what it says: it is the right to copy. 
 The minute you have written a piece of music (providing it is genuinely original) you create a copyright. 
 However, you need to be able to establish and prove that it was you who created the copyright. 
 only then will you avoid difficulties which you would otherwise encounter in claiming any money owing to your copyrights. 
 The PRS 
 When you are starting out in the music business there seems to be an impenetrable jungle of initials to understand: MCPS, PPL, MPA, PRS, BASCA, BMI, ASCAP; the list seems endless! so what are they all for? 
 In the case of PRS, the title is self-explanatory. 
 The Performing Right society is a society of songwriters and publishers (or &bquo;copyright owners&equo;) which grants the &bquo;Right to perform&equo; copyright music in return for an annual fee (or licence). 
 The PRS was formed in 1914 and now has over 22,000 members. 
 As the UK is such a small geographical market, there is only one  performing Right society. 
 This works in favour of music writers, and  because the PRS is the only organization which can license venues and media in this country, it is sufficiently strong to make sure its members' copyrights are appropriately rewarded for any performances. 
 Securing a Copyright 
 A music writer can protect a copyright in a number of ways: 
 (i) 
 put the music down in some physical form, like a musical score or as a demo tape. 
 Date it and place it in the safe keeping of a bank manager or a solicitor (although these professionals often don't like doing this, as it is a lot of trouble). 
 (ii) 
 Get the copyright &bquo;signed&equo; to a publisher. 
 It is then the publisher's responsibility to see that you receive the money which you are due. 
 (iii) 
 put the song down into a physical form, as described above, and send it to yourself by REGISTERED POST. 
 Keep the receipt and DON'T OPEN THE PARCEL. 
 It is accepted in the musical business that this is the easiest and best way to secure your copyright. 
 As a musician it is worthwhile to deal both with copyright and performing right. 
 If you are a writer, the majority of your income may come from performances of your music either on the radio, the television or at live concerts. 
 Consider this: every time a writer/ performer sells an album, their royalty earns them around 60p (assuming they are on 10 per cent). 
 But each time their music is played on BBC Radio l, they are paid about &pound;50 &mdash; simple mathematics explains the rest! 
 It is never too early to consider the copyright and performing right on your songs. 
 As soon as you start writing original work, register the copyrights in one of the ways already outlined. 
 Then you should be able to collect any money which your songs may earn in the future. 
 PRS &bquo;Licences' 
 Anyone who &bquo;uses&equo; copyright music has to buy an annual licence from the PRS These &bquo;music users&equo; include everyone from radio and television stations, clubs, pubs, restaurants, shops, concert halls, dance halls and any other place where there is either live or recorded music audible to the public. 
 The money which is collected from PRS licences is distributed to the society's members (the writers and publishers) in proportion to the number of times their works have been played. 
 Of course, the amount which the society collects each year varies with inflation and the actual number of licences which are granted. 
 In the late 1980s, the PRS regularly received around &pound;100,000,000 for its members.  
 The Amount Each Member Gets 
 Each member's PRS earnings depends on how much money the society collects and how often a member's work is played on PRS-licenced media and premises. 
 For a three-minute play on a British national radio station, the PRS pays approximately &pound;50. 
 For a similar play on a small local station the payment will be less. 
 Often the writer doesn't earn the whole payment. 
 Instead, these fees are divided between a writer and a publisher. 
 so, if a songwriter has a 60:40 publishing deal, he or she would receive 60 per cent of the PRS payment, and the publisher would get the other 40 per cent. 
 However, a writer doesn't need to have a publisher, and in this case the writer would receive the entire sum. 
 How PRS Pays Its Writers 
 Every radio and television station submits lists of the music which they broadcast to the PRS. 
 To check the stations' information, the PRS also monitors their output. 
 From this steady stream of data, the number of television and radio broadcasts of every registered song, tune, or any other piece of music, is constantly being counted by the PRS. 
 Then, the amounts due to the society's writers and publishers are calculated and distributed either as a direct payment to a bank account or as a cheque. 
 There are four distributions a year and these payments also include substantial royalties received by the PRS from equivalent foreign societies for the performance of PRS members' music overseas. 
 As there are many types of live performance venues, like clubs, discos, and major stadiums, there is a variety of licence fees payable to the PRS. 
 For instance, a concert attracting 70,000 at Wembley would have to pay more than a gig at the sock and Warthog in the High street. 
 Also, it would be impractical for the society to pay out each time a particular tune is played at every PRS-licensed venue. 
 The administration costs would be endless and it would be difficult to prove exactly how many times a local pub rock group has played any one song. 
 To deal with this, the PRS has developed a complex scale of payments for live performances. 
 In short, the society requires a list of all music which is performed live only at major venues and  on the bigger tours. 
 A band doesn't have to concern itself with filling in PRS forms at their gigs until they are working in these larger venues. 
 At this point, the venue or the promoter will raise the issue with the band or their management. 
 The event's promoter will pay an agreed fee to the PRS for the works which are to be performed, and a payment is then made by the PRS to the writers and publishers for the works listed as being played.  
 For live performances at smaller venues there is no need for an itemized PRS form because no payment is made for each individual song. 
 A fee is collected by the PRS from the management of the venue and this is put into a fund called the General Distribution pool. 
 This fund is paid out to all members of the society. 
 For more details on this subject, consult the PRS Yearbook  which all members receive annually. 
 Running the PRS 
 There is no &bquo;owner&equo; of the PRS. 
 It is a non-profit-making organization which is controlled by its members. 
 They are represented by an elected general council of music publishers and writers who are drawn from a cross-section of the music profession (classical, popular, rock, TV, films, advertising). 
 Its administration is carried out by a staff of several hundred who work under the direction of the general council. 
 The council makes all the decisions which concern the society's policy, but on major issues, the members' opinions are sought through ballots and general meetings. 
 Membership of PRS 
 A writer is eligible for membership in a number of ways. 
 Membership may be given if a writer has had three works recorded for sale to the public which have been released by a recognized recording label lone which is registered in the Music Master  catalogue). 
 This doesn't have to be a disc &mdash; a cassette or video qualifies as well. 
 A writer is also eligible if he or she has three works broadcast on the radio or the television. 
 These broadcasts don't need to be records because live performances on local radio can also count. 
 If you write a song that sells well enough to reach the top 50 in the albums or singles chart you are eligible automatically. 
 Or if you have three works which are performed live in PRS-licensed premises at least twelve times over the course of two years, you can also become a member of the society. 
 A songwriter proves  these twelve live performances simply by supplying the society with copies of posters, press advertisements or tour dates &mdash; Anything  which confirms these plays. 
 providing that these gigs were at PRS-licensed venues, then an application for membership will be accepted for serious consideration. 
 A publisher is eligible for membership when they publish fifteen titles, ten of which must have been commercially exploited land they must all have been written by PRS writer members).  
 The Organizations which Deal with Copyright 
 MCPS : this is the Mechanical Copyright protection society Ltd. of Elgar House, 41 Streatham High Road, London SW16 1ER. 
 Their telephone number is 081&ndash;769 4400. 
 This society pays the copyright owners (the writers and/or publishers) for the manufacture  and sales  of the physical articles into which their music is made, like vinyl records, compact discs, videos, and cassettes. 
 This is a percentage of the selling price of these music products. 
 PPL : this is phonographic performance Ltd. of Ganton House, 14&ndash;22 Ganton street, London W1V 1LB. 
 Their telephone number is 071&ndash;437 0311. 
 This organization pays money to record companies and artists for the performances of their music on radio and television, unlike PRS which pays the writers. 
 If a performer is also a writer, then this society would be worth joining. 
 A quick phone call to either PPL or MCPS will establish whether you are eligible for membership. 
 Further details about the PRS can be obtained at 29&ndash;33 Berners street, London W14P 4AA. phone: 071&ndash;927 8345. 
 If you think you should be a member, we will take up your case.  
 Deciphering the Legal Jargon 
 MARK MELTON has been the Musicians' Union's music business adviser since 1987. 
 Before that he was involved in band management and ran an independent record company, New England Records. 
 He has a keen interest in popular music and the developing laws and rights in respect of musical performers and songwriters. 
 This chapter will discuss the main long-term contracts which a potential recording artist is likely to sign. 
 These long-term contracts differ from shorter or one-off agreements (for endorsements or live performances) because they almost always call for musicians' exclusive  services. 
 I will consider these five contracts: 
 1. 
 Agreements between band members 
 2. 
 Management agreements 
 3. 
 Recording agreements 
 4. 
 Music publishing agreements 
 5. 
 Booking agency agreements 
 All of these are for a personal service. 
 As such, they involve a high degree of trust, good will, confidence and faith in all parties' ability to do the job in hand. 
 Musicians must seek legal advice if they are offered any of these agreements, and their legal adviser should be a specialist in the music business. 
 A solicitor in divorce law or conveyancing will not deal with the music business on a day-to-day basis and he or she will not be able to advise you fully on the terms of a music industry agreement. 
 The best way to find a legal adviser is to ask musicians in other bands, write to the Law society or, if you are a member of the Musicians' Union, request a list of music business lawyers from the union's national office. 
 Currently, music business solicitors are in the talent-spotting game, just like record companies, publishers, managers and agents. 
 It is  quite common for specialist music solicitors to offer their services free of charge to a band who approach them, who are broke and are creating a &bquo;buzz&equo;. 
 Of course the solicitor will charge the band when a record or publishing deal is signed. 
 As the top solicitors are highly regarded in the music business, sometimes this can be another way of getting a foot in the door. 
 For the five contracts dealt with in this article, there is no such thing as a &bquo;standard&equo; agreement. 
 However, it is also unlikely that any company will draw up an agreement from scratch. 
 Most companies (record companies, music publishers and large management firms) have what they refer to as their standard agreement. 
 This is offered to all the artists they sign. 
 The company may be reluctant to deviate too far from the basic terms of this agreement, but there are a number of things which are negotiable. 
 Legal and business advice is extremely helpful in establishing exactly which areas in an agreement can  be negotiated. 
 1. 
 Agreements between Members of a Band 
 The first issue is when a formal agreement should be made between the members of a band. 
 Ideally, some sort of agreement should be worked out fairly early on. 
 This gives each band member a degree of security. 
 If there is no formal agreement between the band members, and if the band has been working in practice as a partnership, I have always viewed the band as operating as if there were a formal partnership agreement. 
 In that case, the following rules normally apply. 
 Joint Financial Responsibility 
 All members of the band are equally responsible for the band's financial affairs. 
 If there are any band debts, all members share the liability equally. 
 If a member leaves the band, he or she is only responsible for the debts incurred prior to his or her leaving. 
 New members of the band are only liable for debts incurred after their joining. 
 Profits and Assets 
 Without anything in writing to the contrary, it is legally assumed that all members of the band equally share the band's profits and assets. 
 This is always the case unless the purchase of equipment and other costs are undertaken privately by one or more members of the band.  
 Band Name 
 If there is no written agreement on the matter, all members of the band share equally in the rights of the name. 
 This makes it difficult if the band is split in half with both sides wanting to use the band's original name. 
 Other Points to be Considered in a Formal Agreement 
 Band member leaving the band 
 Often there will be a clause in a partnership agreement stating that if a band member leaves the band. 
 he or she is required to give a certain amount of notice. 
 This can range from one to three or six months, depending on what the band feel is most suitable. 
 Band member being dismissed from the band 
 This issue is always riddled with acrimony. 
 There needs to be a unanimous decision from all members of the band (except, of course, the band member being sacked) before anyone is dismissed. 
 Also, there is a need for a dissolution account to be drawn up so musicians know the state of the band's finances when a member either leaves or is dismissed. 
 The points about joint responsibility for assets, liabilities and profits apply whether a band member is dismissed or he or she leaves voluntarily. 
 Composer members 
 often only one or two members of the band write songs. 
 In recent years, it has been more common for songwriting members to allow the band's non-songwriters to share in a percentage of their songwriting royalties. otherwise, the non-songwriting members of the band would be considerably poorer than the others. 
 By sharing songwriting income, the songwriter is recognizing that without the help of the other band members, his or her songs may not be generating any income at all. 
 Band bank account 
 The partnership agreement may deal with where the band's joint bank account is held and how many signatures are required on the account to deal with the band's finances. 
 Band decisions 
 A democratic approach would be that a majority of the band constitutes the necessary authority to make decisions. 
 Limited companies 
 It isn't uncommon for a band to form a limited company. 
 Usually this is because of tax advantages. 
 However, in the early days of a band's existence it operates more often as a partnership.  
 2. 
 Management Agreements 
 Of all the music business agreements artists are likely to sign (with the possible exception of the agreement between the different members of the band), the management/artist relationship is a contract for services at its most personal. 
 As a result, both parties should always behave in good faith. 
 The manager should take into account the artist's wishes and aspirations. 
 The artist must undertake to act reasonably at all times if offered fair advice by his or her manager. 
 Also, the manager is expected to use his or her best endeavours to promote the artist's career, while the artist should do nothing to jeopardize the reputation of the manager. 
 Due to the &bquo;Fiduciary&equo; (trusting) nature of the relationship, honesty and integrity is to be assumed on both sides. 
 Below, I have dealt with the areas most commonly negotiable in a management agreement. 
 These should be discussed by both parties before entering into the relationship. 
 Exclusivity and Territory 
 A management agreement is an &bquo;exclusive&equo; agreement. 
 Most managers want to deal with all  of an artist's activities in the entertainment business throughout the world . 
 Neither of these limitations are necessarily negative for the artist. 
 Musicians need someone to co-ordinate all of their music business activities, and it makes sense that this should be done on a world-wide basis. 
 Length of the Agreement 
 Most management agreements are signed for between three and five years. 
 A maximum of three years is preferable for the artist. 
 Each year, the manager has the choice whether to continue the agreement. 
 These &bquo;options&equo; only work on behalf of the manager. 
 With an established, respected management company it is unlikely that any band would secure an agreement for less than five years. 
 There are certain safety clauses music solicitors put into management agreements to give the artist an escape from the contract. 
 This type of clause may demand that if the manager hasn't secured a recording contract to the artist's satisfaction within a period of twelve months from the start of the agreement, the artist should have the right to terminate the agreement. 
 other safety nets (known as &bquo;performance clauses&equo;) can require the manager to secure a certain level of earnings for the artist throughout the agreement. 
 Ideally, the artist could terminate the agreement at any time. 
 However, managers put a lot of time, energy and commitment into their artist's careers (as well as a substantial financial investment), so  it would be unfair for the manager to be dismissed at a moment's notice, just because the artist fancied a change of management. 
 The important thing is to achieve the right balance. 
 Commission 
 Management commission rates vary, but a current average is 20 per cent of the artist's earnings. 
 The agreement must specify that this 20 per cent should be on money actually received by the artist, not on items such as bad debts, and that there should be allowances for exactly what the commission is chargeable on in certain circumstances. 
 For example, most managers seek commission on gross earnings, whereas artists' representatives attempt to reduce the manager's commission to net earnings from the band's live touring. 
 Currently, touring is an extremely expensive business. 
 As a result, solicitors argue that managers should not take commission on what the artist is being paid each night, but on the money the band earns as profit after having paid for the PA, lights, accommodation and other expenses. 
 Non-Commissionable Items 
 The following should not be subject to commision by the manager: 
 recording costs; 
 promotional video costs; 
 producer's advances and fees; 
 tour support money (money advanced to artists by record 
 companies to underwrite any losses from touring). 
 Expenses 
 Clauses in management agreements about &bquo;who pays what&equo; are often the most contentious. 
 It is generally felt that the manager should be responsible for his or her own office overheads, telephone bills, secretarial services and so on. 
 All other expenses come out of the artist's earnings. 
 These can include equipment, artist's travel and accommodation, the engagement of a tour manager, any personal assistance for the artist/band, legal and accounting fees. 
 The most awkward of these are the manager's expenses when travelling at the request and on behalf of the artist. 
 It often pays the artist to try and put a ceiling figure on these expenses. 
 This ensures that the manager seeks the artist's permission before spending more than a certain amount of money. 
 other clauses could refer to the manager travelling and staying in accommodation of the same class as the artist.  
 Collection of Money 
 The British music business seems to be changing its practices for collecting money. 
 previously, managers received all the artist's money, deducted their commission and expenses, and finally paid the balance to the artist within an agreed period of time. 
 However, the American method is now gaining popularity. 
 In this situation, the artist is responsible for collecting money (often through their own accountants), while the manager invoices the artist on a monthly basis for his or her commission and expenses. 
 A manager who is efficient at plotting an artist's career isn't always the best person to look after the artist's financial interests or sort out VAT, tax and National Insurance. 
 If all the artist's money is paid to the artist's accountant directly, these financial matters can be dealt with by an expert, leaving the manager free to develop the artists career. 
 Some bands are extremely keen to sign with a respected manager who insists on collecting the artist's money. 
 In this case, certain safeguards can be built into the agreement to protect the artist and speed up the accounting of money. 
 If the manager collects the money, the artist may insist the manager sets up a completely separate bank account. 
 This would be in the artist's name, with the manager as the sole signatory. 
 No money from any of the manager's other interests could be mixed in with this account, and the manager should not be allowed to borrow money from it. 
 All he or she could remove from the account would be his or her commission and expenses. 
 The balance would be paid to the artist. 
 Usually, this payment would be made four times a year, but for larger sums the process should be quicker. 
 Finally, if the manager were to get into financial difficulties, and his or her creditors required payment, it should be clear that no money in this account belongs to the manager, and it cannot be used to settle the manager's personal debts. 
 Right of Audit 
 An important clause in a management agreement where the manager collects the money is the right of audit. 
 This allows the artist to look at the manager's books, with reasonable notice. 
 If the artist is to collect the money, then the manager will require a similar right. 
 After the Agreement is Over 
 Most managers want to take commission on any deals they set up for the artist. 
 However, record contracts tend to last longer than management agreements (a management agreement might last for three years while a record contract may go on as long as ten). 
 As a  result, artists feel that if they have parted company with their manager after three years it is unfair if their previous manager continues to take commission on album sales for another seven years. 
 Conversely, managers (quite reasonably) insist that it would be equally unjust if their rights to commission on projects which they have initiated were to cease the moment they parted company from the artist. 
 Consequently, compromises have built up over the years. 
 one of these is that when the two parties separate, the manager continues to take commission for a number of years, but only on those records issued or those songs written during his or her term of office. 
 This means that an artist can take on a new manager who can &mdash; take commission on all new projects, while the former manager continues to earn from all previous albums for a specified time. 
 The exact details are negotiable and depend on the circumstances of each deal. 
 Getting out of the Agreement 
 Both parties in a management agreement should have the right to terminate the agreement if certain things go wrong. 
 Like any legal agreement, if there is a material breach by either party there should be a right for the injured party to terminate the contract. 
 A manager's persistent failure to pay over money to the artist would constitute such a breach, as would constant failure to make him or herself available to the artist, or the wilful neglect of the artist's career. 
 Both parties need the right to end the agreement if the other goes bankrupt or is forced into liquidation, or ceases to operate in the music business. 
 When things go wrong between artist and manager, it is often difficult to prove any of these contractual points. 
 In that case, the four fundamental aspects of the manager/artist relationship are the focus of negotiation. 
 Have both the parties acted in good faith? 
 Has either party breached the fiduciary nature of the relationship? 
 Has the manager at all times respected the wishes and aspirations of the artist? 
 Has the artist acted unreasonably in ignoring the advice of the manager? 
 3. 
 Recording Agreements 
 The record deal is certainly the most important of an artist's longterm contracts. 
 The legal terms of this agreement will not necessarily govern the day-to-day relationship between the record company and artist, but it will set out the obligations of both parties, or &bquo;who is responsible for what&equo;. 
 As with other long-term agreements, a record company demands an exclusive contract with its recording artists.  
 This is hardly surprising as establishing new artists is a costly and lengthy process. 
 How is the Artist Paid? 
 Royalties on record sales govern how much an artist earns from his or her recording career. 
 Royalties vary depending on the perceived value of the artist to the record company. 
 An average of 10 to 14 per cent of the record's retail selling price is the average for a new band. 
 In pence per record terms, this means that most bands receive a royalty of between 50p and 70p per album sold. 
 This figure is calculated on the assumption that an album retails for just under &pound;7. 
 However, the royalty is based on the retail price less VAT and a percentage of the packaging charge, to which record companies require artists to contribute. 
 Before these royalties are earned, the company want to recover the cost of recording the albums plus any other financial advances they have paid to the artist. 
 For example, a new band signing a major record deal may well spend &pound;50,000 recording an album and receive another &pound;50,000 in personal advances (money to live on until royalty income is generated). 
 If their royalty from album sales is equivalent to 50p per album, the band needs to sell 200,000 albums before they break even. 
 This begins to explain why record companies require long-term agreements with artists and are looking for acts with world-wide potential. 
 Most new artists and bands aren't in a strong bargaining position. 
 They may have to settle for royalties which are lower than they would prefer. 
 Consequently, artists' representatives tend to build &bquo;bonuses&equo; into agreements with which record companies are usually quite happy. 
 It isn't uncommon for a record contract to allow for a royalty increase of I per cent throughout each year of the agreement, and for this to be raised once certain sales figures have been reached (commonly, this might be for gold and platinum status albums). 
 There are other areas such as 12&ins; singles, TV advertised albums and various mail order clubs which are all subject to negotiation between the record company and artist. 
 Once musicians' royalty income becomes greater than the cost of their recording time and personal advances from the record company, they start receiving royalty statements. 
 Usually these arrive twice yearly, within ninety days of the end of June and December. 
 The Length of the Record Deal 
 Most record company agreements are on the basis of a one-year period plus a number of options. 
 Major record companies normally  require at least five or six options. 
 potentially these options tie the artist to the record company for up to seven or eight years. 
 However, if the company elects to exercise its option at the beginning of a contract year, it must pay the artist a previously agreed sum of money as an advance against future royalties. 
 It is important to set a figure for these advance payments which is realistic for the band to live on throughout the period of the contract. 
 There is no &bquo;average&equo; advance figure, but major record companies are often willing to pay in excess of &pound;50,000 to a new band, rising each year throughout the contract. 
 smaller independent companies aren't in this league. 
 With an independent, it is vital to restrict the maximum length of the agreement to the shortest time possible. 
 Recordings 
 The artist needs to ensure the record company is committed to releasing a certain amount of product each year. 
 Ideally, artists should see an album released in every twelve months of the agreement. 
 Contracts should be structured so that if the company doesn't release any recordings during a certain contract year, the artist has the option to terminate the agreement and look elsewhere for a record deal. 
 The choice of material, recording studio and producer are always contentious. 
 Currently, the balance of power over these decisions seems to have swung in the artist's favour. 
 Most recording agreements allow for a mutual choice on all these areas between the artist and company. 
 Third-party producers often require a royalty as payment for their work. 
 More often than not, the producer's money comes out of the artist's record company royalty payment. 
 The most an artist can do is to limit the amounts which are paid to a well-known producer. 
 I suggest this should be a maximum of 2 per cent. 
 In this case, if the artist receives a 12 per cent royalty, and the producer requires a 2 per cent royalty on record sales, the artist is left with a royalty of only 10 per cent split between the members of the band. 
 Videos 
 Videos have proved spectacularly successful in launching many bands on a world-wide career. 
 In the early 1980s, many British bands were household names in the USA without having toured there. 
 Record companies normally want to recoup 50 per cent of the cost of videos from the artist's royalty account. 
 For the artist, it is certainly worthwhile watching the video's budget and not spending excessively if at all possible.  
 Tour Support 
 There are often phenomenal overheads in putting a band on the road. 
 In the early days of a band, the fees received from gigs are unlikely to cover the touring costs. 
 It has become usual practice for record companies to advance bands some money to underwrite the costs of these first tours. 
 This should not be necessary as soon as the band plays in larger venues. 
 Record companies consider this support quite economic because they view a band's tours as a good way of promoting records. 
 Tour support advances are invariably recoupable from the artist's royalty account. 
 All other expenses on marketing the artist's records (such as radio promotion, posters, and press advertisements) are the responsibility of the record company. 
 The artist should not contribute financially to these. 
 Major record companies invest vast sums of money in new artists every year. 
 It isn't rare for a quarter of a million pounds to be spent on an act in one year. 
 With these amounts of money involved, the relationship between band and record company can occasionally be quite strained. 
 The record company is anxious to recover their investment quickly. 
 The band is also in a difficult position. 
 They are likely to be in debt to their record company for a number of years. 
 Even though this debt isn't repayable if the band aren't successful, it is always an uncomfortable feeling to know someone else is pulling the strings. 
 Artists who can work with their record company effectively (often with the help of intelligent management) probably stand more of a chance than the naive, bad-tempered or egocentric band. 
 A potential recording artist must realize there have to be some compromises between art and business. 
 4. 
 Songwriting and Music Publishing 
 Most bands write their own material. 
 There is a great deal of money to be made from income generated by composers' royalties and fees as well as the earnings from performing and recording. 
 sometimes every member of a band writes songs, but often it is only one or two. 
 It is a matter for the band partnership agreement to clarify each songwriter's policy on whether the non-writing band members will earn any money from his or her publishing royalties. 
 Songwriters and composers are eligible to join various collecting societies such as the performing Right society and the Mechanical Copyright Protection society. 
 However, many songwriters still choose to sign an exclusive publishing agreement with a music publisher, thereby giving up a portion of their royalties and fees, and  assigning all rights in their songs to that music publisher for a set period of time. 
 There are various reasons why a songwriter/artist should do this. 
 I have listed four of the more common ones below. 
 Advances 
 Publishers often pay their songwriters fairly large, annual financial advances on account of future royalties. 
 The size of these advances will vary, but if a writer has already several hit singles in his or her catalogue the advance may be very sizeable. 
 Record Deals and Promotional Assistance 
 Alert music publishers are sometimes quicker than the record industry at spotting songwriter/artists' commercial talent. 
 In this situation, it is quite common for the songwriter/artist to sign an exclusive agreement with the publisher. 
 This would include annual advances (although not as large as in the previous situation), access to a recording studio for making demos, and involvement with the publisher's various contacts in the music industry to help secure a record deal. 
 Administration and collection 
 Later on in their career, musicians may decide to form their own publishing company and to seek only the administration services of a large corporate publisher. 
 In return for a small share of the songs' royalty earnings, the larger company takes over the day-to-day business of administering the musicians' song catalogues while the musicians retain all copyright and control of their material (see the &bquo;self-publishing&equo; section below). 
 Covers 
 Not all songwriters are active performers. 
 A non-artist songwriter will need a music publisher who can promote his or her writers, songs aggressively, trying to place them with major recording stars. 
 some music publishers certainly have a better track record in this area than others. 
 It can be worthwhile to look through trade magazines and check on various companies' success in placing their songs with artists. 
 Also, talk to other writers, solicitors and friends in the music business to confirm your research. 
 Earning Money as a Songwriter 
 The following areas are the most common ways of earning money from your songs.  
 Mechanical Royalties 
 As well as the recording artists receiving a royalty from record sales, the songwriter is also entitled to a royalty payment from each record sold. 
 These royalties are collected from the record company, on behalf of the songwriter, by either the songwriter's publisher or, provided she or he is a member, by the Mechanical Copyright protection society (MCPS). 
 Unlike artists' record royalties, all songwriters receive the same royalty which is a rate agreed between the record industry and the MCPS. 
 Performing income 
 Money is also payable to songwriters from radio and TV stations in the form of &bquo;air play&equo; money. 
 All songwriters should join the performing Right society when they become eligible. 
 The PRS collects this portion of money for writers. 
 Synchronization fees 
 These are one-off payments made by film or television companies to the copyright holder of a song. 
 They buy the right to incorporate a piece of music into a film or television programme's soundtrack. 
 Sheet music 
 some songs sell well in sheet music form (ballads are usually very popular). 
 There is a royalty payable on sales from this area. 
 The Publishing Agreement 
 All of the areas mentioned below are subject to negotiation. 
 It is very important to stress that the relative bargaining strength of each party governs the kind of a deal which is made. 
 Length of contract 
 An agreement may be for one song, or for everything a musician writes over a number of years. 
 Longer term contracts are often known as &bquo;blanket&equo; deals. 
 The most common period of time for this sort of agreement is three or four years, and the advances payable should reflect this. 
 As with recording advances, there is no such thing as a typical figure, but for a non-performing writer, enough money to live on should be sought. 
 Assignment of copyright 
 Copyright exists in a musical work until fifty years after the end of the year in which the songwriter dies. 
 At the end of this period, the musical work becomes public property. 
 Until quite recently, most music publishing agreements assigned all rights in a song to the publisher for this full copyright term. 
 However, the publishing business has recently become more competitive and it is now possible for songwriters to restrict the length of the assignment of copyright to what is known as a &bquo;retention period&equo;. 
 This is usually for the length of the publishing agreement (normally about three to four years) plus a period which could range from five to twenty-five years, depending on the writer's bargaining position.  
 Royalties and advances 
 For a songwriter/artist who the music publisher believes has a good chance of success, it is quite usual for there to be a royalty split of 70:30 in favour of the writer. 
 This should cover all the areas mentioned above except sheet music where a royalty of between 10 and 12 per cent of the full published price is the going rate. 
 As with record royalties, those songwriters who sign on less advantageous terms are sometimes successful in securing increases throughout each new year of the agreement. 
 For example, a writer who signs an agreement with a 60:40 split may be able to negotiate a rise of 5 per cent in every year of the contract. 
 Accounting 
 As with record companies, this tends to be twice yearly. 
 It is important that the agreement gives a songwriter a &bquo;right of audit&equo;, the right to inspect the publisher's books. 
 Reversion and determination clauses 
 These are particularly important clauses for the songwriter. 
 If the publisher has failed to exploit the song in any manner, within a given period of time, the songwriter is able to have all rights in the songs returned. 
 Also, if the publisher enters into liquidation, the writer must have the right to terminate the agreement and get back all rights to his or her songs. 
 Self-Publishing 
 At a certain point in a writer's career, he or she may want to set up his or her own publishing company. 
 This is the usual route to self-publishing. 
 Unless a writer is eligible to join the PRS as a publisher member (in addition to being a songwriting member) there is little point in setting up a new publishing company. 
 on the release of a writer's first album, it is unlikely that he or she would have enough qualifying works to become a publisher member of PRS (see the &bquo;Copyright and Performing Right&equo; article for details on these qualifying requirements). 
 For this reason, some writers enter into an &bquo;administration deal&equo; with a corporate music publisher. 
 In this case, the songwriter should retain his or her songs' copyrights, and the publisher is responsible for administering the song catalogues (collecting the money payable to the writer's songs). 
 The publisher will charge around 10&ndash;15 per cent of the royalties received from the writer's songs for this service. 
 Usually, these deals can be negotiated for a short term. 
 This allows the writer to join the PRS as a publisher member when he or she has enough qualifying works, to end the administration deal, and to sign the rights in his or her songs into a personally owned published company.  
 For a songwriter, the main advantages of owning a publishing company are usually regarded as keeping total control of, and earning 100 per cent of the income generated by, his or her songs. 
 some writers set up publishing companies for tax purposes. 
 Others believe it looks more professional. 
 However, there are disadvantages. 
 The most obvious is that a larger amount of time is required from the writer. 
 This is particularly evident when the writer has to organize the negotiations for the essential deals with foreign sub-publishers who collect royalties in non-UK territories. 
 5. 
 Booking Agency Agreements 
 The brief of booking agents has changed radically in recent years. 
 In the past, a band would acquire an agent fairly early in their career. 
 The main job of the agent would be to assist the band in moving up through various grades of gig. 
 Currently, bands seem to be facing a shrinking number of live venues coupled with the enormous expense of going on the road. 
 This has resulted in no one making a profit from most bands' early tours. 
 Indeed, some bands are unable to tour without their record company's financial support. 
 Not surprisingly, established booking agents have reacted to this situation by being ever more wary of signing bands without a record deal. 
 Another factor which has affected the band/agent relationship has been the prominent role of strong legal advice. 
 Lawyers always advise clients to limit the term of any music business agreement to as short a term as possible. 
 Recently there has been a certain amount of paranoia from agents who have been tied to short-term agreements, and then have lost a band to the highest bidder just as the act is becoming successful. 
 As a result, agents are becoming even more cagey about developing raw talent. 
 In the artist/booking agent agreement, the most important areas of negotiation are as follows. 
 Commission 
 Most booking agents charge a commission of 15 per cent which is payable on the gross fees for any live work. 
 As an act's appearance fees become higher, the agent may settle for a smaller percentage. 
 Length of Agreement 
 This is variable, depending on how the two parties perceive the relationship. 
 Most agents prefer a term of about three years, whereas bands want to work on a yearly basis. 
 some larger acts engage an agent for one tour at a time. 
 If an agent is insistent on a three-year agreement, it is quite common for the artist to negotiate performance  clauses. 
 These call for a minimum level of earnings at strategic intervals throughout the relationship. 
 Territory 
 Agents invariably want to represent an artist throughout the world. 
 This may not necessarily be useful to a band if the agent is a small or new company. 
 Larger companies have contacts throughout the world and reciprocal arrangements with foreign agencies. 
 Any commission paid to a foreign sub-agent should not be charged to the artist. 
 It should be paid by the artist's UK agent, out of his or her commission. 
 Collection of Money 
 This concerns the collection of revenues arising from the artist's live appearances. 
 The ideal situation for the artist is that all money should be paid to the artist. 
 Then the agent either sends an invoice to the artist for the commission, or arranges for the commission to be paid by the promoters. 
 However, some agents prefer to collect all gross revenues from promoters and, having deducted their commission, pay the balance on to the artists. 
 For a band, this is not at all desirable because their earnings are out of their direct control. 
 The Need for Legal Advice 
 All the long-term agreements facing a potential recording artist are highly complex legally binding documents which have a great effect on an act's career. 
 The value of good legal assistance cannot be overstressed. 
 I always advise musicians to digest at least a certain amount of knowledge about their business affairs. 
 There have been far too many examples of artists &bquo;living for the moment&equo;, putting their faith in others to run their career, and waking up to find themselves penniless, out of favour with the public and feeling rather stupid. 
 As an aspiring recording artist, I can only hope you will enjoy your music and live the lifestyle, while you remember that the music business is a career, just like any other.  
 Music Business Accountancy 
 MARK BOOMLA works in the Entertainments Division of Touche Ross, one of the biggest accountancy firms in the world, He has considerable experience of advising major pop artists and companies on all aspects of their finances. 
 Everything about a musician's life concerns money. 
 Whether it is hiring the local scout hut for rehearsals or the huge expenses of a worldwide tour, someone has to count the cost. 
 However, although your accountant is your &bquo;servant&equo; he or she isn't clairvoyant. 
 Your accountant relies on the information and explanations which you make available. 
 Then he or she can help you get the best financial return from your music. 
 The first stage of any band's life is playing for fun. 
 Unwittingly, the members of the band have formed an unincorporated association. 
 They aren't trading because they don't receive income. 
 All expenses are paid by the band's members as with any hobby, so an accountant doesn't need to be involved, although there are certain precautionary steps which should be taken at this early stage. 
 Firstly, all equipment should be bought and owned by specific members of the band, and all purchase invoices should be kept. 
 To avoid unnecessary disputes, draw up a list of equipment and its owners so that it can be agreed by all the members of the band. 
 similarly, all songs composed by the band should be credited to those members who actually wrote them. 
 If songs are co-written, then each songwriter should be credited with the proportion of the song which they created. 
 Turning Professional 
 This is the second stage in a band's life, when they first receive income. 
 This can happen in a number of ways. 
 A band could sign a recording contract, or receive income from live performances or session fees (the receipt of prize money from a talent contest is tax  free and does not give rise to taxable income unless this occurs on a regular basis). 
 Now, the band has been transformed from an unincorporated association into a partnership. 
 The existence of a partnership has significant legal consequences, and it is best practice for the members of any partnership to have a written agreement, drafted by a lawyer. 
 In this article, I have assumed that a band has reached this second stage by being offered a recording contract. 
 It is now that the band requires an accountant. 
 The band should meet their accountant before signing the recording contract to discuss the following: 
 1. 
 The accountant, in conjunction with the lawyer, will advise the members of the band whether they should form a limited liability company before entering into any legally binding relationship with a record company. 
 2. 
 The accountant should inform the band that, as they are about to start trading, it is necessary to notify the Inland Revenue (the tax man). 
 The accountant will be happy to do this on the band's behalf. 
 3. 
 It is likely that any &bquo;advance&equo; paid by a record company will be in excess of the minimum level of income for compulsory VAT registration purposes, so the band should be aware of their obligation to register for VAT immediately. 
 Once registered there is a requirement to file a VAT return every three months with the Customs and Excise and the accountant will discuss how these will be completed and filed. 
 4. 
 The band will need to open a bank account, if they haven't done so already. 
 It is best practice for the accountant to discuss with the band who should be the cheque signatories on this account. 
 A cash book should be maintained for each bank account to record every item of income and expenditure, analyse these into appropriate costs and back them up with supporting documentation. 
 It may seem a chore to gather invoices to document your expenses, but without these, items of expenditure may not be allowed as a deduction from income by the Inland Revenue. 
 Then the band would have to pay more tax than would otherwise be necessary. 
 For instance, when the accountant produces the band's first accounts, and files them with the Inland Revenue, the invoices for the band's musical equipment may need to be produced so that the accountant may obtain tax relief for these items, although they were purchased in the first stage of a band's life. 
 5. 
 As the accountant will, if required, help produce the annual accounts, he or she will want to ensure that adequate. 
 cash books are maintained. 
 To do this, the accountant will discuss who will be responsible for them (this might be a band member, the accountant  or the band's manager). 
 If necessary, he or she will advise on the detailed layout of the cash books, and suggest that he or she reviews them occasionally to ensure their adequacy. 
 Also, the accountant will wish to establish who is responsible for completing and filing the VAT return for the Customs and Excise. 
 It may be appropriate for the person who maintains the cash books to do this, but because of their technical nature it may be necessary for the accountant to do this instead. 
 6. 
 There may be an obligation for the band members to deduct income tax (Pay As You Earn) from the salaries of any employees. 
 In this case, it is necessary to set up a PAYE scheme with the Inland Revenue, to deduct tax and National Insurance, and to pay these over on a regular monthly basis. 
 For the band members' own &bquo;salaries&equo;, a Certificate of Tax Deposits can be purchased from the Inland Revenue. 
 The advantage of this scheme is that you don't need to remember to save the money which you would have paid to the Government later on! 
 The accountant will identify whether there is a need to establish a PAYE scheme and, if the band or their manager aren't willing to take on this responsibility, the accountant will operate this scheme on their behalf. 
 The Record Deal 
 The band is likely to negotiate a large non-returnable, but &bquo;recoupable&equo; (out of future royalties earned) advance from the record company. 
 The accountant will try to ensure that the band have given enough thought to how long this money is likely to last, and how best to use it until the next payment or earnings are due. 
 The budgets of anticipated income and expenditure which are prepared at this stage are vital if the band are to appreciate the limits of their financial resources. 
 All too often large advances can seem like a ticket to stardom. 
 In reality they are mercilessly small when you realize for how long they have to be eked out! 
 As an example, consider the situation of a three-piece band who are about to receive &pound;100,000 as a record company advance (and they have taken the decision to delay any possible publishing advances until after the release of two singles from the forthcoming album). 
 out of the &pound;100,000, it is likely that the manager of the band will take 20 per cent (&pound;20,000). 
 Various other costs such as administration, legal accountancy fees, as well as paying off any debts of the individual band members, could all amount to a further &pound;20,000. 
 This leaves the band with &pound;60,000. 
 From that, each member of the band is likely to have a &bquo;salary&equo; equivalent to around &pound;20,000 per annum before tax. 
 Although this is a fair wage, it isn't going to sustain a rock &bquo;n&equo; roll superstar lifestyle for longer than a few weeks,  so it is only by sensible use of budgets that the real size of the advances can be put in context. 
 This example might seem unrealistically pessimistic, as a new band may feel confident of being able to record and release their album in just a few months, with money from sales and royalties quickly starting to now in. 
 In practice this is never the case. 
 Recording an album inevitably takes longer than expected. 
 songs may have to be rewritten, particular studio engineers or producers may not be available when first required, band members may fall ill and the record company may delay the release of the album &bquo;until the market is right&equo;. 
 There are innumerable reasons why albums take longer than expected to get into the shops. 
 Also, because of the type of accounting system adopted by all record companies, it is quite feasible for royalties generated from record sales in the UK to take nine months before they are paid to the artist. 
 Record sales in foreign territories can take up to two years before they are paid. 
 Furthermore, the three-piece band's advance was to be &bquo;recoupable&equo;. 
 This means that all of the band's percentage of the royalties generated from their record sales are spent first on repaying the record company advance. 
 When that has been paid off, the band will start to see some profit from their records. 
 so, although the advance of &pound; 100,000 may appear a vast sum of money, it can result in a lack of spending power in the rockets of individual band members. 
 Recording Costs 
 Recording in a top flight studio is often new and exciting for any band. 
 suddenly, musicians can be working with engineers, producers and a whole host of technical equipment which previously had been the stuff of their dreams. 
 Musically, this can seem like an Aladdin's cave, but financially it can be a nightmare. 
 The band may not realize all the costs of recording and of hiring an engineer or producer. 
 The band must remember that recording costs are treated in a similar way to advances. 
 To start with, the record company will pay the costs of the recording studio, the producer and the engineer, but these will all be charged to the band's account at the record company. 
 The record company recoups this expenditure by making the band liable to pay these costs from their share of the royalties generated from record sales. 
 The band's earnings from their recording contract go towards paying this debt to the record company as well, putting off even further the stage when the band earns money from its records. 
 It is worthwhile for the band to keep some diary notes as to the studios they have used and on which days. 
 Also, record which engineers, producers and backing musicians were employed. 
 This  information will be particularly useful when checking the recording costs debited to the band's royalty statement. 
 Touring 
 Once the recording has been completed, it is likely the band will go on tour to promote their album. 
 The accountant, in conjunction with the lawyer, will consider using a separate limited company to undertake the touring activity, and advise accordingly. 
 The main advantage of a limited company is that in general only the company and not the individual is liable for the business debts. 
 once the coffers have run dry, there is no recourse to the individual band. 
 members to pay any outstanding bills personally. 
 There are important exceptions to this rule on which advice will need to be sought. 
 The principal disadvantage is that a limited company invariably incurs some additional costs. 
 Touring generates two particular problems for the accountant. 
 At the beginning of a career, any band's tours are likely to make a loss. 
 It is likely that this loss will be funded (at least in part) by the record company and, in this case, the band are likely to receive an advance against future royalties. 
 This is usually recoupable, so the band should realize that they are spending their own money on tour, and not the record company's. 
 The second problem of touring is that the volume of the band's financial transactions will increase dramatically. 
 From the dozen or so per week when the band is in the studio, there will be up to 100 per week as they go on the road. 
 Clearly, if a member of the band has maintained the books until this point, it wouldn't be practical for him or her to continue. 
 For small tours, a tour manager is the most suitable person to do this book-keeping. 
 For larger tours, bands need a tour accountant to travel with them and record all transactions as they are made. 
 The tour manager or tour accountant must maintain adequate books to reflect these transactions so they can all be accurately included within the band's finances. 
 Publishing 
 If a band delayed signing a publishing contract until the singles from their album had obtained some success, it was because they believed, not unreasonably, that they could negotiate a better contract by demonstrating their chart success to a publisher. 
 But how do writers' royalties arise? 
 There are two main sources of publishing income. 
 The first, and usually by far the largest, is the &bquo;mechanical&equo; royalty. 
 This is payable when a copy of a writer's or composer's song is made mechanically  (or these days electronically). 
 Consequently, a mechanical royalty arises each time a record company makes a copy of an album, cassette or compact disc. 
 The second source of publishing income is public performance. 
 This is collected by the performing Right society (PRS) from the licensing of TV, radio and venues for the public performance of music (see the &bquo;Copyright and performing Right&equo; article). 
 Songwriters, both lyricists and composers, have two alternatives for publishing their work. 
 Either they sign one contract with a worldwide publisher, or several contracts with music publishers in each individual country throughout the world. 
 The first option is referred to as a world-wide contract, and the second is known as a territory-by-territory contract. 
 The band's lawyer will advise as to which is appropriate, depending on the artist's circumstances. 
 The accounting for royalties by a music publisher, for a world-wide or territory-by-territory contract, is very similar to record companies' methods. 
 A music publisher will give writers an advance. 
 Like advances from record companies, this will be recoupable out of future royalties. 
 However, the main difference between the record company's and publishing company's advance is that the publisher usually has no large expenses to pay such as the recording costs of an album. 
 As a result, publishers have few costs to charge writers and composers against their publishing royalties. 
 This often makes songwriting more profitable than performing. 
 Doing both is ideal. 
 As with many of a band's activities, the accountant will consider whether a separate limited liability company is required in order to act as a vehicle for the publishing royalties. 
 Music publishing deals are often referred to by two figures, like 95:5 or 85:15. 
 The first figure relates to the writer's or composer's percentage (95 or 85 per cent), and the second to the amount retained by the publisher (5 or 15 per cent). 
 From the writer's point of view, the larger the first number and the smaller second, the better. 
 Before signing any deal, the band's writers and composers should discuss with their accountant and lawyer the proportion of the band's publishing royalties which they will receive. 
 It is quite feasible that band members will have contributed to the composition of songs in different amounts, so the income received from the band's songs is often split to reflect this. 
 In order to minimize the accountant's workload (and the accountancy bill), ask the publishing company to undertake this quite laborious division of royalties. 
 If the company are unwilling to do this, the accountant, possibly with the assistance of a computer bureau, will generally be happy to get this done. 
 It is important for musicians to appreciate the difference between an &bquo;income received&equo; deal and an &bquo;at source&equo; deal. 
 It may save bands a lot  of money. 
 If a writer or composer signs an &bquo;at source&equo; deal, they should receive the negotiated percentages of the royalties arising in foreign territories in tact . 
 If they sign an &bquo;income received&equo; deal, they will only receive their proportion of the royalties sent to their UK  publisher , after the foreign publisher has taken a percentage. 
 Royalty Examination 
 When the band have achieved considerable chart success (when they have sold approximately a million copies of their albums), they should consider whether a royalty examination should be done. 
 The right to carry out a royalty examination of a record or publishing company should be set out in the recording or publishing contract. 
 The recording artist or the writer and composer will have the right to appoint a firm of accountants to examine the accounts of the record or publishing company. 
 This is to ascertain whether these companies have paid over the correct royalties to the band. 
 Recording contracts can be particularly complicated due to the different royalty rates and &bquo;packaging deductions&equo; which can be applied to different types of record, and to where it is sold, when it is sold, and in which cover it is presented. 
 As a result, errors can occur in the processing of the royalty payments and the contract may be open to various interpretations. 
 A royalty examination usually begins with an analysis of royalty statements by the band's accountant to see if there are any peculiarities which warrant further investigation. 
 Usually there are a number of these which makes it necessary for the accountant to visit the record or publishing company. 
 There he or she examines the record or publishing company's accounts. 
 As a result of this visit, the accountant will prepare a royalty examination report, in conjunction with the solicitor, which will set out the claims for underpayment of the band's royalties by the recording or publishing company. 
 The lawyer, often with the assistance of the accountant, will then negotiate the claim with the particular company and reach a settlement. 
 Clearly, it is only worthwhile for the band to request a royalty examination if the potential claim will exceed the professional fees incurred. 
 As a result, this is usually only undertaken if a band has enjoyed significant record sales. 
 However, settlement payments by the record company or publishing company are often in excess of &pound;100,000, while the accountant's fees are measured in tens of thousands.  
 The music business is very fickle. 
 Careers at the top can be mercilessly short. 
 Usually, a band or artist will have only a short working life in which to earn sufficient money to live on for the rest of their lives. 
 While it is important to choose an accountant with whom you feel comfortable and professionally secure, you will also need the best available financial advice. 
 By the time you realize your accountant has been second rate, your career may be over. 
 Choose an accountant who specializes in the music industry. 
 When you meet your potential accountant, ask him or her about who else he or she acts for. 
 If he or she doesn't act for a number of successful bands, he or she is unlikely to have a thorough understanding of accounting in the music business. 
 You need to know whether your potential accountant could undertake royalty examinations, and if he or she has colleagues in other countries to assist with international tax problems at very short notice. 
 Deciding on an accountant isn't easy. 
 It may involve visiting several firms before you find the right one. 
 But with a good accountant, it could make the difference between you, the pop star, being rich and famous, or just famous. 
 WAITING FOR RAIN 
 ELIOT was always a careful listener. 
 Some phrases lay in his mind for years. 
 Others were more quickly put to use. 
 On 29 October 1914, he heard Collingwood, lecturing on Aristotle's de Anima , talk of how the soul might be supposed to leave the body and return to it later. 
 Eliot scribbled a reference to Frazer's treatment of such experiences in The Golden Bough . 
 By February 1915, he was sending Aiken &bquo;Suppressed Complex&equo;, a poem about a soul-like shadow dancing in the firelight of a woman's room, before passing out of the window. 
 In 1916 Eliot recalled &bquo;Tylor's dreaming aborigine who finds that his soul in sleep can part company with his body and roam the forests&hellip; 
 &bquo;. In &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, the concept of wandering souls would link anthropology and the romantic world of Dowson with his 
 hollow lands 
 Where the poor, dead people stray, 
 Ghostly, pitiful and gray. 
 The transfer of souls in reincarnation would be important for The Waste Land , but in 1915 the &bquo;revitalizing of the classics&equo;, as Eliot later described one of the effects of anthropology, seems most apparent in &bquo;Mr. Apollinax&equo; where we are made very aware of the primitive, and particularly sexual aspects of classical mythology. 
 In the few years that followed, Eliot adopted various strategies to keep his poetry flowing. 
 In each the primitive, sometimes bestial is joined obdurately to the modern and sophisticated. 
 City men walk by the Thames like wolves in &bquo;Le Directeur&equo;; &bquo;M&eacute;lange Adult&egrave;re de Tout&equo; links London banker and giraffe-headed African. 
 part of the reason for this is no doubt Eliot's hostility to ideas about &bquo;social progress&equo; one aspect of which was the eugenics movement. 
 Reviewing  McBride, Eliot quoted from that writer's conclusion that, given proper education of mind and body, &bquo;the next generation may start at a very slightly higher level of capacity than their fathers&equo;. 
 The quatrain poems give the lie to that. 
 Also important is his sympathy for &bquo;the classicist point of view&equo; which, he stated in 1916 &bquo;has been defined as essentially a belief in Original Sin&equo;. 
 The quatrain poems bind up such sympathies with a way of thinking which owed much to anthropology and Eliot's growing wish to include in his work the worlds of both the savage and the city. 
 In 1918 Eliot wrote of the need for artists to be at once very primitive and very sophisticated; he praised Lewis's Tarr  as being &bquo;like our civilization criticized, our acrobatics animadverted upon adversely, by an orang-outang of genius, Tarzan of the Apes&equo;. 
 Eliot's Sweeney fulfilled this function. 
 A caricature of Dr Sweeny's &bquo;manly&equo; man, he is a modern troglodyte, but one with a rich ancestry. 
 Book IX was by far the most thumbed section of Eliot's Odyssey , and it was the story of the Cyclops that &bquo;savage man&equo; which he read most attentively. 
 Though he found the passionate irresponsibility of the Homeric world &bquo;shocking&equo;, preferring its Virgilian successor &bquo;because it was a more civilized world of dignity, reason and order&equo;, Eliot also realized that the all-important &bquo;mind of Europe&equo; was one &bquo;which changes, and that this change is a development which abandons nothing en route , which does not superannuate either Shakespeare, or Homer, or the rock drawing of the Magdalenian draughtsmen&equo;. 
 It contained not only the Homeric, Cyclops and all, but also the troglodytic itself with its own representations, the dawn of the mind. 
 The Cyclops enters Eliot's poetry after a line which seems to mock the rising of the formulaic Homeric &bquo;rosy-fingered dawn&equo; in the poem &bquo;Sweeney Erect&equo; when: 
 Morning stirs the feet and hands 
 (Nausicaa and polypheme). 
 It dawns on us that we are back at temporal beginnings and slipping down the evolutionary tree. 
 Refusing to let even this distorted version  of myth lie still, the next lines confirm the evolutionary idea, lowering its level while at the same time raising the domestic temperature to the tropical: 
 Gesture of orang-outang 
 Rises from the sheets in steam. 
 Seedy modern guest house or brothel becomes primitive jungle. 
 Somewhere in between is a meeting on a Greek island. 
 Sweeney's encounter with &bquo;the epileptic on the bed&equo; parallels that of Nausicaa not with Odysseus but, more shockingly, with &bquo;Polypheme&equo;. 
 Sweeney's name pronounces him of the lineage of a man who sold human flesh for butchermeat, a &bquo;demon barber&equo;. 
 Eliot traces the line further back into primitive prehistory by an explicatory aligning of his protagonist and a putative ancestor, the Cyclops, who devoured Odysseus's comrades. 
 When Nausicaa meets Polypheme beauty meets the beast. 
 It is also the meeting of the cultured city dweller, who led Odysseus from undergrowth to city palace, with the savage Cyclops who wished to eat the hero in a cave. 
 The absurd encounter represented in Eliot's parenthesis is erotic, but also cannibal, each aspect reinforcing the outrageous horror-comedy of the other. 
 The situation and its elements foreshadow the later confrontation of Sweeney and Doris on their &bquo;cannibal isle&equo;. 
 The paralleling of Sweeney and the Cyclops here does on a small scale the work of the anthropologists' comparative method, &bquo;to make manifest the similarities and identities underlying the customs of races very remote in every way from each other&equo;, though both are part of the &bquo;mind of Europe&equo;. 
 The artifice of the opening stanzas with their 
 paint me&hellip; 
 paint me&hellip; 
 Display me&hellip; 
 sets us at a painterly remove from decorously observed suffering and does little to prepare us for the replacement of the distant tangled hair of Ariadne by immediate presence of the directly primitive 
 This withered root of knots of hair 
 Slitted below and gashed with eyes&hellip; 
 The Classical gives way to the savage and language grows hyperactive. 
 As the poem progresses it is beast, not beauty, which meets beast. 
 &bquo;Root&equo; is normally associated with a single hair, not &bquo;knots&equo; of it. 
 &bquo;Root&equo; here links the figure in the sheets to a tree from which life has drained, yet soon it will come alive with galvanic motion. 
 The resurrection of dead life through the repetition of supposed past actions will be a theme of the poem, and the poem will also be about suggesting a &bquo;root&equo; for primitive (which here includes apelike primitive) behaviour through mythological explanation which involves the merciless demystification of myth. 
 Eliot has learned from his anthropology. 
 Stanza three's shockingly different mythology prepares us for &bquo;This withered root&equo;. 
 When Nausicaa meets Polypheme mythology is cut up and reassembled to offer a shocking explanation of what underlies it, a parenthetical explanation which throws a provoking light on the relations between men and women, between civilization and savagery, between present and past. 
 The second half of the verse, &bquo;Gesture of orang-outang/ Rises from the sheets in steam&equo; simultaneously forces us back into human prehistory, before even polyphemus, and forward into the present of Doris and Mrs Turner, since monkey evolves into human where &bquo;orang-outang&equo; becomes homo erectus ; yet &bquo;knots of hair&equo; makes the modern return to the ape, and shaving Sweeney, for all his performing the action of his namesake, the demon barber, seems as crude and brutal as the Cyclops &mdash; such is the grotesquely comic evolutionary irony of the loss of hair. 
 The poem lets us posit an evolutionary series, Orang-outang  Cyclops  Sweeney but the way in which these three are introduced and relate to one another upsets any simple progressive development by raising questions about what evolutionists and anthropologists discussed as &bquo;reversion&equo; and &bquo;degeneration&equo;, countering all optimistic ideas about the growth of humanity. 
 Sweeney has no sooner stood up and shaved than he appears in a vision of reversion taking the form of the second parenthesis, the importance of whose material strains against the parenthetical format, guiding our reading of the poem:  
 (The lengthened shadow of a man 
 Is history, said Emerson 
 Who had not seen the silhouette 
 Of Sweeney straddled in the sun.) 
 Sweeney is a weapon against a too hopeful view of history. 
 Emerson's essay on &bquo;history&equo; begins, &bquo;There is one mind common to all individual men&equo;, whereas Eliot's anthropological reading had taught him to be wary of the nineteenth-century assumption of what was &bquo;in the words of M. L&eacute;vy-Bruhl, the uniformity of mind&equo;. 
 As poet, Eliot makes devastating use of such an assumed uniformity. 
 Inverting the &bquo;savage philosopher&equo; &mdash; a savage who attempts to reason like a modern &mdash; Eliot produces a modern who behaves like a savage, shockingly contradicting the idea of progress and modern &bquo;self-reliance&equo;. 
 Emerson wrote that he could find &bquo;the primeval world&hellip; in myself, but his thinking self is seen as confident master of that world. 
 As a commentary on such sentiments Eliot's poem reads with a vengeance. 
 His criticism of L&eacute;vy-Bruhl for overstressing the distance between the savage and the modern mind shows that for Eliot the two were linked, but L&eacute;vy-Bruhl's stress on the different, apparently unreasonable nature of the savage leads to the modern Sweeney whose world is far removed from the sweet reason of Emerson. 
 Sweeney shocks because he shows so clearly the effect of lack of themis . 
 Harrison had written of such a lack among the Cyclopes. 
 In Themis  she stressed the need for group rather than individual values in conducting life and saw them as the foundation of religion. 
 Sweeney cannot be outgrowm, but must be controlled. 
 Eliot, however, is content to show this here without curbing Sweeney's activities; they are too useful as violently funny weapons against the high priests of the progressive individualism of Eliot's youth, whom he saw as false prophets of a rigid pseudo-themis, &bquo;Matthew and Waldo, guardians of the faith, / The army of unalterable law.&equo; 
 Sweeney stands against those whose personal taste is too closely linked to morality in a falsely genteel way. 
 Himself unspeaking, armed with his razor he reduces life to the level of a primitive &bquo;shriek&equo; with which &bquo;the ladies of the corridor&equo;, despite the way in which they &bquo;Call witness to their principles/ And deprecate the lack of taste&equo;, find themselves inescapably &bquo;involved&equo;. 
 just as there is a tension between the  evolutionary ups and downs of the hairy epileptic on the bed who &bquo;Jacknifes upward&equo;, and the shaving &bquo;Sweeney Erect&equo;, so there is set against the prostrate unreason indicated by &bquo;The epileptic on the bed &lsqb;who&rsqb; / Curves backward, clutching at her sides, another woman who later walks upright: 
 But Doris, towelled from the bath, 
 Enters padding on broad feet, 
 Bringing sal volatile 
 And a glass of brandy neat. 
 Arriving like a final dea ex machina , Doris's condition makes her like an ironic version of that goddess in Tennyson's &bquo;oenone&equo;, &bquo;Idalian Aphrodite beautiful, / Fresh as the foam, new-bathed in paphian wells.&equo; 
 Certainly there is more mythology behind the poem. 
 Moody thinks that &bquo;the final stanza may allude to a variant of Ariadne's tale, which has it that she did not die of a broken heart but was loved by Bacchus&equo;. 
 The relevance of this variant comes earlier in the poem whose opening stanzas call for a painting of Ariadne deserted on Naxos. 
 What follows connects Sweeney both with his mate, an &bquo;orang-outang&equo;, and with a god, &bquo;polypheme&equo; being Poseidon's son. 
 Moreover, Sweeney is an ironic Bacchus to his own Ariadne. 
 Eliot had written an earlier &bquo;Debate between Body and Soul&equo;, entitled &bquo;Bacchus and Ariadne&equo;, and probably inspired by Titian's painting in the National Gallery. 
 He ticked this picture in his London Baedeker  whose commentary singles it out for its great &bquo;exuberance&equo;. 
 The &bquo;exuberance&equo; of Sweeney forms a disturbing parallel to that of the god, since it so obviously belongs to what Aspatia in The Maid's Tragedy  (from which Eliot's epigraph comes) calls &bquo;that beast man&equo;. 
 Anthropology for Eliot did not remake the myths, but showed how they had, while becoming the possessions of high culture, transmitted and not entirely transmuted primitive origins. 
 By purporting to de-interpret them by removing the excrescences of later interpretations it made possible a reinterpretation which allowed mythology to be seen again as something that while still existing on the level of the  most civilized and polished communication kept speaking of what it had sprung from &mdash; men's basic needs and desires. 
 Yet the very study of mythology from a scientific attitude distanced modern man at the same time as it seemed to bring him closer. 
 The size of the gap between students and studied fluctuated. 
 In &bquo;Sweeney Erect&equo; the modern seems closer to the savage Polyphemus than to Emerson, and the delight in attacking the nineteenth century is obvious; but so is the tension between modern and ancient. 
 It is not just that high myth looks down towards low present reality. 
 If Sweeney is a Bacchus, the god himself is nowhere present in the poem. 
 Theseus's ship, Aeolus, and the abandoned Ariadne &mdash; these too are absent, or at least they are present only in some later wish for an imaginative reconstruction, 
 paint me&hellip; 
 paint me&hellip; 
 Display me&hellip; 
 &bquo;Sweeney Erect&equo; is a poem about sexuality; that sort of erection clearly links at the most basic level the different planes of history in the poem. 
 But it is also about the unstable evolution both of homo erectus  and his culture, all of which may be a vast illusion if what man does is simply continue his savagery while trying to repeat faint echoes of some suspect original grandeur. 
 The movement from the initial grandly imperative wish for a creative act, reviving an older myth, to the final mundane narrative of the beginning of another, much less magnificent revival of potential creativity promised by &bquo;sal volatile/ And a glass of brandy neat&equo; is a movement away from a first situation (that of Ariadne on Naxos) which we never see in itself; the painting conjured up and the other parallels to this first situation are interpretations not just of each other, but also of that first situation which, because a &bquo;myth&equo; and so subject to constant reinterpretation, may never have happened in any of the ways presented, if indeed it ever took place at all. 
 Eliot had hinted in his primitive ritual paper that grand structures of belief might be founded on something false or grotesquely crude or even meaningless. 
 This idea grows in the poems leading up to &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, finding full expression in 1923 when he looks back to his seminar paper, speculating that &bquo;primitive man&equo; may have 
 acted in a certain way and then found a reason for it. 
 An unoccupied person, finding a drum, may be seized with a desire to beat it; but unless he is an  imbecile he will be unable to continue beating it, and thereby satisfying a need (rather than a &bquo;desire&equo;), without finding a reason for so doing. 
 The reason may be the long continued drought. 
 The next generation or the next civilization will find a more plausible reason for beating a drum. 
 Shakespeare and Racine &mdash; or rather the developments which led up to them &mdash; each found his own reason. 
 The reasons may be divided into tragedy and comedy. 
 We still have similar reasons, but we have lost the drum. 
 Here Shakespearian splendour, and indeed all art, is seen as springing from something beyond reason, and possibly senseless. 
 The Eliot who underlined Plotinus's  (finding the same exhortation to &bquo;return to the beloved fatherland&equo; in an essay which he translated in 1927) and who wrote Wanna Go Home , Baby ? was always concerned with returning to sources. 
 But in this return he sometimes found something as horribly inane as the tedium of the city clerk's world. 
 The quatrain poems identify in man lowest common denominators operating below the level of any &bquo;savage philosopher's&equo; thought. 
 Their characters, like those of Jonson's comedies, are grotesquely stripped down and caricatured. 
 &bquo;This stripping&equo;, Eliot wrote, &bquo;is essential to the art.&equo; 
 We recognize in the quatrain poems what Eliot occasionally found in Davidson: that though his &bquo;dwelling-place&equo; alters, the human &bquo;tenant&hellip; is the same through all ages&equo;, but Eliot's linking factors, though they may be comic and self-mocking, are scarcely reassuring. 
 The various sexual liaisons which parallel one another in &bquo;Sweeney Erect&equo; are like Jane Harrison's ritual dromena : things re-done and pre-done. 
 In &bquo;Burbank with a Baedeker: Bleistein with a Cigar&equo; we have another central situation whose repetition makes it analogous to one of Harrison's rituals. 
 The situation is that of the outsider meeting the pleasures of a different, reputedly splendid civilization. 
 In the central dromenon  these pleasures take an explicitly sexual form, represented by Burbank's encounter with Princess Volupine. 
 But such a situation is also presented as a thing pre-done, interpreted by being seen in terms of Antony's meeting with Cleopatra as portrayed by  Shakespeare, and as a thing re-done, since the third meeting, that of Princess Volupine with Sir Ferdinand Klein presents us again with a similar situation. 
 So we have the basic pattern of mutual interpretation, each performance of the ritual interpreting the others, which Eliot had examined in 1913. 
 It is convenient to relate the three meetings in terms of a diagram similar to that used by Eliot in his paper. 
 (See figure 3.) 
 We are not told that these are part of a continuing ritual, but we are encouraged to treat them as such by the similarity present in the three meetings which are connected with  each other further by the Shakespearian language applied to each. 
 It is a poem about cultural change. 
 By using such phrases as 
 the God Hercules 
 Had left him, that had loved him well. 
 and 
 Her shuttered barge 
 Burned on the water all the day. 
 and 
 On the Rialto once. 
 and 
 Lights, lights, 
 Eliot is able to recall Shakespeare closely enough to suggest at first sight that an ironic contrast is aimed at, but also to present the possibility that the allusion functions as the poetic equivalent of a legal fiction. 
 The words stay the same, but we are forced to ask awkward questions about how much their meaning has altered. 
 The simple ironic reading is based on the assumption that the high Shakespearian allusions are really inapposite. 
 The other, more disturbing reading is that the Shakespearian phrases are made appropriate because the present situation reinterprets them in such a way that we are forced to wonder if a Burbank-Volupine situation was not just the sort of thing they were talking about all along. 
 This use of Shakespeare, the central figure of Anglo-Saxon culture, stresses that the poem is not only about the cultural change in Venice, but about that at the heart of our own language and culture also. 
 Again the evolution of the mind of Europe is under scrutiny. 
 There is another side to this use of allusion. 
 Those lines 
 Defunctive music under sea 
 passed seaward with the passing bell 
 Slowly: 
 refer to a stage direction, not to life. 
 As Antony and Cleopatra  has it, &bquo;Music of the hautboys is under the stage&equo;. 
 Similarly, the reference to the barge really refers to an account in a play of a scene which we do not and in some ways could not witness, a scene which may never have taken place in those terms. 
 Eliot was well aware it was all a business of transmission and reinterpretation of past interpretations as he shows in writing that &bquo;Shakespeare acquired more essential history from Plutarch than most men could from the whole British Museum.&equo; 
 Reading this poem urges us to ask what &bquo;essential history&equo; is and wonder if it has some ritual pattern. 
 As &bquo;literary allusions&equo; the Shakespearian references point us back to previous dramatic interpretations of events rather than directly to &bquo;real events&equo;. 
 These are always lost under interpretation. 
 We are caught in a series of mimeses which push Burbank into the focus of ritual, his actions sliding imperceptibly into reactions to and reenactments of a past rite whose origins we can never witness. 
 A movement downwards towards origins is, though, perceptible in the poem. 
 Burbank's &bquo;descending&equo; leads to &bquo;fell&equo; and passes &bquo;under sea&equo;  to a divine explanation of events and then to the mythological splendour of the ascent of the horses of the dawn (a little sabotaged by the questionable diction of &bquo;Beat up&equo;). 
 But such an explanation is surely ridiculous to the modern reader forced to realize how far he stands from an age when mythological explanations were permissible. 
 He is tempted to reinterpret the past in a way that makes it fit in more readily with the rendezvous at the small hotel. 
 A parallel descent to first causes in the latter half of the poem locates a different underlying prime mover: 
 On the Rialto once. 
 The rats are underneath the piles. 
 The Jew is underneath the lot. 
 This leads to the rather less splendid ascent of Princess Volupine &bquo;To climb the waterstair&equo; and to entertain 
 Sir Ferdinand 
 Klein. 
 the sound of whose surname and its positioning at the start of the final stanza aurally and visually rhymes with &bquo;Declines&equo; which similarly ends a sentence as the first word of stanza six. 
 Climbing the waterstair, Princess Volupine moves on to the piles to meet the Jew who &bquo;is underneath the lot&equo;. 
 Ascent and descent are alarmingly confused. 
 Fittingly, at the poem's centre is the evolutionary joke, 
 A lustreless protrusive eye 
 Stares from the protozoic slime 
 At a perspective of Canaletto. 
 The way the poem is ordered allows us momentarily to read it as if the juxtaposition was just that of eye and Canaletto, for the eye appears at first as an independent entity. 
 But when we realize that the eye is most probably Bleistein's, we realize that it represents a degeneration from the expected human eye. 
 The eye which seems able physically to perceive as it &bquo;stares&equo; but unable to appreciate what it sees links the modern hybrid, a world of complex cross-breeding inhabited by &bquo;Chicago Semite Viennese&equo;, with the most primitive, &bquo;protozoic&equo; level of life. 
 Again we are faced with a shift in cultural values. 
 The Canaletto presumably has not altered, and men still come to look at it just as they repeat Shakespeare's words. 
 Ritual observances continue awkwardly as in the clumsy Hakagawa-like  genuflexion, &bquo;A saggy bending of the knees&equo;, but the original sense of the ritual, as in so many of the cases described by Harrison and Frazer, seems lost. 
 This poem hints that we can  go beyond the form of the ritual only.to be horrified by the realization that there is nothing there, or there is only some petty squalor, meaning having receded out of sight if it was ever present in the first place. 
 Evolution has given us the Canaletto whose complex city perspectives recede infinitely away and now it is itself seen regressing as 
 The smoky candle end of time 
 Declines. 
 Falling as decadent decline, degeneration, and as the sense of the result of Original Sin is ubiquitous. 
 &bquo;They were together, and he fell.&equo; 
 This is again a borrowing &mdash; from Tennyson, another staple of a cultural tradition. 
 The realization of that fact is awkward since Eliot's virtual repetition of Tennyson's line (which in &bquo;The Sisters,, reads &bquo;They were together, and she fell&equo;) in another context constitutes an act of reinterpretation. 
 Again the notions of legal fictions and of rituals whose meaning may alter despite continuity of formal behaviour are useful. 
 Tennyson's poem, though, is about a woman who lures a man to his doom, a man apparently of another race, so that this allusion in turn provides a further interpretation of the fates of Antony and Burbank. 
 It may flesh-out Burbank's story, and it may strip away some of the glory from the Shakespearian version of Antony's. 
 It does seem to strengthen the ritualistic patterning of history. 
 Life as ritual and art is a belief we associate very much with those &bquo;long-forgotten&equo; Nineties when sins were still scarlet against which Eliot professed to be reacting in 1917 when he declared that their &bquo;aesthetic eccentricities may now be ignored&equo;. 
 But it seems that his interest in primitive ritual had led him to place his own stress on life as a ritual. 
 For Eliot, though, this concern with ritual was to have the sanction of the anthropologists' &bquo;collective representation&equo;, being generated like a dromenon  by a group, a chorus across history. 
 Not Eliot alone, but Eliot, Shakespeare, and Tennyson produce the poem. 
 The combination seems to point to some underlying form of &bquo;essential history&equo; of which each individual provides his variant but which can only be hinted at, not revealed, because when the voices  join across time they never quite marry, though their coming together is an attempt to generate something which like a collective emotion is necessarily felt as something more than the experience of the individual, as something dominant and external'. 
 It might seem that the primeval Fall underlies this poem's events as surely as Venice underlies its epigraph, standing as the reality which underlies various writers' interpretations. 
 Yet even the meaning of that city seems doubtful. 
 Its bridges and canals are intact, but its meaning may have altered. 
 The final question, 
 Who clipped the lion's wings 
 And flea'd his rump and pared his claws? 
 Thought Burbank, meditating on 
 Time's ruins, and the seven laws 
 assumes a glorious past. 
 Following the poem's ritualistic treatment of history and treating it in accord with Eliot's method for ritual's interpretation, if we take &bquo;enough cross-sections to interpret a process&equo;, and the poem invites us to do so, then we must be aware of a general downward movement. 
 The falling of Burbank, taking us down the moral ladder, and the &bquo;saggy bending of the knees&equo; of Bleistein, taking us down the evolutionary ladder, lead to the declining &bquo;smoky candle end of time&equo; which prepares Burbank and the reader to ponder over &bquo;Time's ruins&equo;, the etymology of &bquo;ruins&equo; being important. 
 Royce's seminars had acquainted Eliot with the second law of thermodynamics if he had not known it before. 
 All time in this poem seems to be a running-down. 
 But the way in which present and past mutually interpreting falls are linked together suggests that the idea of the Fall itself may be illusory, a lost first cause. 
 Burbank falls; Hercules's departure marks Antony's decline. 
 We see only what is falling, never any Edenic first position fallen from. 
 A glance over the shoulder abolishes Eden. 
 For though Burbank's fall, that mere matter of crossing &bquo;a little  bridge&equo; to a &bquo; small  hotel&equo; (my italics) is a shrunken affair, lacking the panoramic mythological grandeur of the Shakespearian Antony's, it none the less offers a stripped-down representation of that event. 
 We are invited to read back destructively. 
 If the previous state was really as fallen as this, is the whole idea of a Fall illusory? 
 If the unfallen state is being pushed further and further out of sight, it may eventually vanish  into unreality. 
 If the continuing ritual represents a progressive pruning away of the trappings of mythology, then it would follow that no one has clipped the lion's wings or fleaed his rump or pared his claws since all these things, like classical-cum-Shakespearian mythology, are the ritual entrappings of the culture from which our own is descended, preserved among us as &bquo;survivals&equo;. 
 But while externally unchanged they have ceased to be our central &bquo;collective representations&equo;. 
 So that in a sense we have all been clipping, fleaing, and paring. 
 The poem is funny, but at everyone's expense. 
 The effect of Eliot's reading about primitive religion is clear in &bquo;Mr. Eliot's Sunday Morning Service&equo; where, as in his Wundt reviews, he is concerned to stress the importance of the sexual element in religion. 
 Coming from the reading of Frazer, Durkheim, and others, he does this by linking Christian rituals to sex and the continuance of vegetation. 
 Along the garden-wall the bees 
 With hairy bellies pass between 
 The staminate and pistillate, 
 Blest office of the epicene. 
 From the opening word, &bquo;Polyphiloprogenitive&equo;, the stress on religion as sexually oriented is evident. 
 There is a conflict of languages within the poem. 
 The overarticulate &bquo;Superfetation&equo; and the physically direct &bquo;hairy bellies&equo; both point in the direction of sex. 
 Formal games too consciously played increase the sense of unease. 
 Language flaunts itself, embroidering ritual in alliterative use of s  and p  through stanzas five and six. 
 But the linguistic oddness is deliberate. 
 Language itself, word following Word, is giving birth to new forms &mdash; &bquo;piaculative&equo; is listed in the OED  as &bquo;rare&equo;, this poem being its only cited occurrence. 
 Most likely it derives from Durkheim whose penultimate chapter in The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life  is entitled &bquo;Piacular Rites and the Ambiguity of the Notion of Sacredness&equo;. 
 The new word achieves mutant birth in a poem about fertility and birth, stressing the sexual element in religion. 
 For Durkheim part of the ambiguity of the sacredness involved in the aboriginal fertility rites was that 
 The same results are obtained by fasts, abstinences and self-mutilations as by communions, oblations and commemorations&hellip; 
 However complex  the outward manifestations of the religious life may be, at bottom it is one and simple. 
 It responds everywhere to one and the same need, and is everywhere derived from one and the same mental state. 
 In all its forms, its object is to raise man above himself and to make him lead a life superior to that which he would lead, if he followed only his own individual whims: beliefs express this life in representations; rites organize it and regulate its working. 
 This passage sheds much light on the method of &bquo;Mr. Eliot's Sunday Morning Service&equo; where the self-mutilation of &bquo;enervate Origen&equo; is placed in the same lineage as the sexual origin of &bquo;the Word&equo;, and where the initial &bquo;sapient sutlers of the Lord&equo; who &bquo;Drift across the window-panes&equo; is a passage with an ambiguous, or better ambivalent, reference, since it holds together in one term both the &bquo;sable presbyters&equo; who bring offerings to church and &bquo;the bees&equo; who bring pollen from one part of the plant to another and so perform the &bquo;Blest office of the epicene&equo;. 
 Religion is presented as a response &bquo;everywhere to one and the same need&equo;: the need for rituals of fertility. 
 Durkheim commented on the difficulty of regarding &bquo;an enlightened Catholic of to-day as a sort of retarded savage&equo;, but he provided the reminder that &bquo;the most primitive religions are not the only ones which have attributed this power of propagation to the sacred character&equo;. 
 As in &bquo;Burbank&equo; mythology was presented as painting, so here we have &bquo;Designed&hellip; 
 The nimbus of the Baptized God&equo; &mdash; perhaps based on &bquo;The Baptism of Christ&equo; by Piero della Francesca whose work hung in the National Gallery's Umbrian School room marked in Eliot's Baedeker . 
 The word &bquo;nimbus&equo; meaning both halo and rain-cloud is carefully deployed. 
 The primitive ceremony which came soonest to Eliot's mind, whether in his &bquo;Beating of a Drum&equo; or in 1926 when he spoke of savages who &bquo;believe that the ritual is performed in order to induce a fall of rain', was rain-making, probably because he had read about it for his 1913 seminar paper. 
 Frazer's Dying God  describes rituals where drums are beaten to beg rain from heaven. 
 Themis  describes various rain-making rites, including a Christianized one which involves entreating &bquo;S. John Baptist to baptize the Holy Child&equo;. 
 L&eacute;vy-Bruhl links rain-making with Christian practice; writing of the aboriginal intichiuma  ceremonies he points out that &bquo;Nothing  is more widespread than practices having as their object the cessation of drought, and the assurance of rain: (we see this even yet in our own Rogations)&hellip; 
 &equo; Durkheim, following Spencer and Gillen, described the aboriginal &bquo;Intichiuma of rain'. 
 &bquo;The object of the whole rite is to represent the formation and ascension of clouds, the bringers of rain.&equo; 
 The whole direction and tone of Durkheim's investigation was &bquo;to find a means of discerning the ever-present causes upon which the most essential forms of religious thought and practice depend&equo;. 
 In a poem continually relating Christian religion to fertility ritual Eliot's painted annunciation hints at the most primitive rites not only in its &bquo;nimbus&equo; but also in its drought-stricken landscape, where &bquo;The wilderness is cracked and browned., 
 The coming of God is linked with the making of rain both through the &bquo;nimbus&equo; and in what follows. 
 But through the water pale and thin 
 Still shine the unoffending feet 
 And there above the painter set 
 The Father and the Paraclete. 
 This presentation allows the hint of primitive ritual to remain in the background, just as later Eliot was to imply with deliberate provocation that behind the High Mass lay, if one went back far enough, &bquo;the Australian ceremonies described by Spencer and Gillen and Hewett &lsqb;sic&rsqb;&equo;. 
 This poem foreshadows the method of the later, greater poetry of The Waste Land  in trying to hold the most primitive and most developed in one by letting the former show through the latter and the development of one out of the other be seen. 
 Just how strongly Eliot was spurred on to emphasize the connections between sex and religion at this time is seen in &bquo;The Hippopotamus&equo; (1917) which contains one of his most shocking jokes: 
 At mating time the hippo's voice 
 Betrays inflexions hoarse and odd, 
 But every week we hear rejoice 
 The Church, at being one with God. 
 Throughout these quatrain poems sex and religion mix, so that always &bquo;The nightingales are singing near / The Convent of the  Sacred Heart., Whether there is anything beyond the sexual is uncertain. 
 Christ's feet in &bquo;Mr. Eliot's Sunday Morning Service, are &bquo;unoffending&equo; which may mean without sin, but might also mean just harmless or inoffensive, devoid of power in a way paralleling Origen's sexual impotence; the apparent presence of God need not guarantee Christ's power. 
 Jane Harrison had seen the Olympians as moving from fertility daimones  to objets d'art . 
 In Eliot's poem the status of God as objet d'art  is stressed (&bquo;And there above the painter set / The Father and the Paraclete&equo;) so that for all that we may penetrate beyond that either to gesso ground or vestiges of primitive fertility ceremony, the ultimate point of origin, the postulated God, is to be explained simply in terms of sexuality, or else remains unreachable and inexplicable. 
 Eliot, who was interested in mana  and orenda , worried that Durkheim's theory of totemism in terms of religious force might prove only &bquo;an admission of the inexplicable&equo;. 
 The learned gloss, &bquo;Superfetation of  is deliberately awkward. 
 It shows how the Word could give birth to commentators&equo; words, as could the castrated Origen, but gives no acceptable explanation of how it could produce Origen. 
 The poem enacts various creations as parts of an apparently continuing ritual pattern; it is polyphiloprogenitive in detailing the creation of the Word, Origen, the painting, and flowers; we seem able to trace all back to their cause, yet ultimately the cause is only a formal utterance, &bquo;In the beginning was the Word&equo;, whose repetition takes us no further. 
 We are back with the problem which Eliot had considered in March 1914 when one of his seminar colleagues, Sen Gupta, had read a paper that Eliot had written dealing with the work of L&eacute;vy-Bruhl &bquo;on primitive race-psychology&equo; and the &bquo;law of participation&equo;, a paper in which it was stated that, &bquo;Causality is something which can be explained away but not explained. 
 Perhaps it is due to superstition, but can we do without such superstitions?&equo; 
 The question of whether or not &bquo;In the beginning&hellip;&equo; is superstition is forced on us by the poem but left unanswered though it appears that to go back beyond Origen would be immensely difficult. 
 For Eliot in this poem the only way to banish endless debate lies not in accepting dogma, but in fleeing from speculation to Sweeney  in his bath. 
 With the comic appearance of this modern barbarian the resolutely physical takes over; we move back to the level of the naked man with no interest in the &bquo;polymath&equo;. 
 Yet Sweeney, found in the essential element of fertility for both aborigine and Christian, is also a mover of waters. 
 Ironically, though Sweeney appears to promise a way out, he may only lead the sensitive reader back into the circle of sexual-religious speculations. 
 Neither the religious nor the sexual anxiety in Eliot's poems came simply from his reading, but that reading allowed him to give supra-individual expression to his personal pain; he clothed his own cry in the language and mythology of great traditions and their interpretations, making it &bquo;impersonal&equo;. 
 Eliot was doing this before he had articulated a theory about it. 
 His reading also helped him articulate his theory. 
 Durkheim wrote that, &bquo;there is something impersonal in us because there is something social in all of us, and since social life embraces at once both representations and practices, this impersonality naturally extends to ideas as well as to acts.&equo; 
 It was as a possession of society that mythology and the great art of the past was of use to the poet, since as such its strength and currency was established and purged of personal intrusions. 
 Eliot wrote in 1916 that mythology was &bquo;dangerous literary material&equo; and had to be either a mythology in which the writer believed or else one in which a people had once believed. 
 &bquo;A mythology cannot be created for literary purposes out of whole cloth; it must be the work of a race.&equo; 
 Admiring Durkheim's stress on the need for community, Eliot wrote that, &bquo;For the savage or the civilized man, a solely individual existence would be intolerable: he feels the need of recreating and sustaining his strength by periodic refuge in another consciousness which is supra-individual. 
 So the poet recreates his strength in the tradition, which can provide a refuge and a strength, yet which can also appear founded on emptiness. 
 In voicing his theory of impersonality, and in searching for terms of extreme yet impersonal expression anthropology was important in terms of the ideas and structures which it provided, but also in terms of its vocabulary again often used for the communication of deep distress. 
 So Eliot, in &bquo;ode&equo;, a poem dealing with a tortured wedding night,  has a protagonist apparently lacking in all inspiration except that coming from the &bquo;bubbling&equo; of a river described as &bquo;mephitic&equo;. 
 In Adonis Attis Osiris , Frazer saw the goddess Mefitis as personifying &bquo;mephitic vapours&equo; and described her temple &bquo;where the exhalations&hellip; were of so deadly a character that all who set foot on the spot died&equo;. 
 Mefitis's lethal pool &bquo;continually bubbles up with an explosion like distant thunder&equo;. 
 But it could also serve for the purposes of inspiration. 
 The sick left there &bquo;sometimes&hellip; were favoured with revelations in dreams&hellip; 
 To all but the sick the place was unapproachable and fatal.&equo; 
 Frazer also mentions a sanctuary whose mephitic area contains only &bquo;the eunuch priests of the Great Mother Goddess&equo;, who have &bquo;a look on their faces as if they were being choked&equo;. 
 Sleeping with the succuba who may be disembowelled but also disembowelling, Eliot's speaker is in a position analogous to that of the eunuch priest; poetry like sex here points to horrible death and finds expression for that concept in the language of the rituals of primitive religion and mythology. 
 Except that the meaning of these has waned. 
 The rituals are repeated, the mephitic river risked, but only to find it finally uninspired. 
 Anthropology both masked and revealed Eliot's own concerns. 
 It was a lens through which he could view life, literature, and history, often with mischievous irony. 
 In view of all his interest in connections between worship of totemic plants, rain ceremonies, and modern life, it becomes clear why &bquo;Gerontion&equo; is sparked off by a passage from Benson's Fitzgerald  where Benson is quoting Fitzgerald. 
 &bquo;Don't you love the Oleander? 
 So clean in its leaves and stem, as so beautiful in its flower; loving to stand in water, which it drinks up so  fast. 
 I rather worship mine.&equo; 
 Here he sits, in a dry month, old and blind, being read to by a country boy, longing for rain&hellip; 
 Fitzgerald's oleander-worship and longing for rain are like those &bquo;survivals&equo; Eliot discussed in 1917. 
 Fitzgerald's brain was also haunted by survivals of past literature, &bquo;The old music of bygone singers, rich haunting sentences of old leisurely authors, rang in his brain, and came unbidden to his pen. 
 &bquo;Gerontion&equo; presents a little old man,  whose speech is riddled with other men's words, waiting &bquo;in a dry season, for rain. 
 We appear to be in the cosmopolitan city world of the uprooted. 
 My house is a decayed house, 
 And the Jew squats on the window sill, the owner, 
 Spawned in some estaminet of Antwerp, 
 Blistered in Brussels, patched and peeled in London. 
 Mr Silvero, Hakagawa, and the other figures stress this up-rootedness. 
 Yet, ironically, &bquo;waiting for rain,, we are rooted in the most primitive situation. 
 The communion ceremony is seen in terms stressing the physicality of Frazer's &bquo;Eating the God&equo;. 
 Rendel Harris's gods were originally plants. 
 Discussing the sacrificial meal, Durkheim, Harrison, and others saw eating totemic animals or plants as a primitive communion, as Eliot knew. 
 Eliot noted that in Australian religion Durkheim found the essential elements of all religion, and that for Durkheim communion , not worship, was the essential sentiment. 
 Eliot's &bquo;word, / Swaddled&equo;, with its suggestion of Christ's &bquo;swaddling clothes&equo; (Luke 2: 12) places us firmly within the area of fertility and birth, but Christ in &bquo;Gerontion&equo; comes not as baby but as frightening beast, associated, like totemic animals, with fertility. 
 Reviving vegetation is emphasized, being bound up in &bquo;judas&equo; with the Christian (and New England) story. 
 But the gap between Christ and the eating not only emphasizes the vegetation, but makes it seem for a moment that it is the plants which are devoured: 
 In the juvescence of the year 
 Came Christ the tiger 
 In depraved May, dogwood and chestnut, flowering judas, 
 To be eaten, to be divided, to be drunk 
 Gerontion, in the barren wilderness of modern life, the world of Antwerp, Brussels, and London, is terrified of the cycle of fertility which also traps him. 
 For him &bquo;The tiger springs in the new year.&equo; 
 His years are not modern calendar years, but governed by the rebirth  of vegetation &mdash; new year comes in &bquo;depraved May&equo;. 
 Rebirth for him would be fatal, in the word of a later poem &bquo;like Death, our death&equo;. 
 Both Christ and the fertility cycle seem terrifying. 
 Yet when he seeks refuge in history, other men's deeds and words, Gerontion finds nothing with which he can connect, only vacancy, vanity, and inane deception: the emptiness of the uninspiring, fragment-bearing wind that blows through much of Eliot's poetry. 
 The shrunken personal emptiness in an arid landscape, the hungering after other men's experience, and the combined fear and fascination which Gerontion feels for threatening rebirth seem to grow, partly at least, from Eliot's own situation. 
 In London he found himself chronically overworked, unhappily married, and a failure in his parents' eyes. 
 &bquo;Gerontion&equo; looks much towards death; Eliot's father died in January 1919. 
 To him Eliot dedicated The Sacred Wood . 
 Unable even to enlist because of ill health, Eliot had found work as a bank clerk while others fought in the warm rain. 
 He found the bank's routine congenial, keeping greater worries at bay. 
 Concentrating attention on tasks before him avoided the resuscitation of more painful parts of his life. 
 Such resuscitations, though, were inescapable. 
 Reviewing Henry Adams's Autobiography  in 1919 he attacked the Bostonian world and, covertly, himself, as he savaged Boston Unitarianism along with Adams who &bquo;abandoned lecturing at Harvard&equo;, and whose researches into primitive mythology &bquo;turned to ashes in his mouth&equo;. 
 Doubt choked Adams. 
 Like Gerontion, &bquo;there is nothing to indicate that &lsqb;his&rsqb; senses either flowered or fruited.&equo; 
 In 1919 Eliot felt himself to be in a similar position. 
 This seems ironic, but letters and later statements show how little faith Eliot had in his own literary output, however confident he might sound in verse, or in the ex cathedra  pronouncements of &bquo;Tradition and the Individual Talent&equo;. 
 In.1922 he threatened to give up literature. 
 His fascination with religious ideas brought no peace. 
 He was confronted with the failure of his personal life (impersonalized in &bquo;ode&equo; and elsewhere) and, it seemed, of his public life. 
 His reading of Henry Adams was not the only painful revival of memory or confrontation with his own apparent failure which he had to endure in 1919.  
 In June of that year Eliot met a figure from what must now have seemed to the London banker a remote part of his life. 
 At Harvard, another friend recalled, Eliot's 
 really closest friend was Harold peters, and they were an odd pair. 
 It was Peters who chided him about his frail physique, which led to his regular attendance at August's Gymnasium, which was in the basement of Apley Hall. 
 He took this work seriously and developed into quite a muscular specimen. 
 It also led to some boxing lessons somewhere in Boston's South End. 
 He took up rowing in a wherry, and finally worked up to a single shell. 
 peters also introduced him to small-boat cruising and they made many cruises between Marblehead and the Canadian border. 
 On one of these trips, in a 19-foot knockabout, before the days of power, they rounded Mt. 
 Desert Rock in a dungeon of fog, a rough sea and a two-reef breeze. 
 Such voyages would reappear in Eliot's poetry, and not only in the hunt for lost childhood and youth that fills &bquo;Marina&equo;. 
 In late June 1919 Eliot went to Garsington, but cut short his visit to stay with Peters who was about to be demobbed from the US Navy. 
 Vivienne found Peters extremely boring, but the next day, Sunday, Peters and Eliot, who was looking very ill, went off to Greenwich, a choice of venue which suggests that the two men talked about sailing for much of the time. 
 Certainly they would have had much to talk about, recalling voyages up the New England coast; how they had dared storms together and mixed with tough Maine characters at the Jonesport summer ball, or how one of Peters's cruises had been christened after the four B's which constituted their provisions: beans, bacon, bread, and bananas. 
 Peters would have had much else to tell Eliot. 
 In 1915 he had sailed to South America on  one of the last square-riggers. 
 In the war he had sailed to Cuba and between the east coast of America and Scotland. 
 Now he was about to return to America, a bachelor who would sail round the world on various cutters and schooners. 
 The next day, Monday 23 June, Peters left for America leaving Eliot an unhappily married London bank clerk on the fringes of a circle which he described as a &bquo;Bloomsburial&equo;. 
  Eliot's meeting with Peters brought a painful revival of past good times. 
 By 1 June &bquo;Gerontion&equo; had been half finished. 
 It seems to have been completed by the start of July. 
 In the last stages of composition, after the destruction of the &bquo;society&equo; names, &bquo;De Bailhache, Fresca, Mrs. Cammel&equo;, Eliot amended his original version, adding some lines which surely came as a result of his meeting with Peters: 
 &hellip; 
 Gull against the wind, in the windy straits 
 Of Belle Isle, or running on the Horn. 
 White feathers in the snow, the Gulf claims, 
 And an old man driven by the Trades 
 To a sleepy corner. 
 In late 1919 Eliot resolved to begin a long poem. 
 His meeting with Peters also seems to have sparked off the long voyaging section of &bquo;Death by Water&equo; in the Waste Land  manuscripts, which would be united with the fate of the ancient Phoenician sailor, Phlebas, and details of which would find their way into &bquo;Marina&equo; and &bquo;The Dry Salvages&equo;. 
 This section, describing in accurate seamen's language a voyage past The Dry Salvages in a fishing boat loaded with &bquo;canned baked beans&equo; combined Eliot's own sea knowledge with that of the Gloucester dory fishermen, and bound these up with the &bquo;well-told seaman's yarn&equo; of Dante's Ulysses and with Tennyson's Ulysses (who may be related to Gerontion). 
 The eventual dropping of this passage, retaining only the Phlebas section, makes Part IV of The Waste Land  entirely impersonal, but underlying it was a resuscitation of personal memories. 
 Further memories were revived by a visit from his mother in the summer of 1921 which brought &bquo;another anxiety as well as a joy&equo; when Eliot was working on what would become The Waste Land . 
 Eliot's 1921 meeting with Dr Roger Vittoz in Lausanne must have once more forced him to confront his own history and ambitions. 
 He also found peace there and renewed an old pleasure, by boating at Lugano where he met Hesse. 
 In Switzerland, though he met &bquo;people of many nationalities, which I always like&equo;, Eliot felt  that he had released Vivienne from the strain of being with him. 
 He too had time to think and to write. 
 In the Waste Land  which Eliot eventually produced, the pain of personal resuscitations persists, but that pain is bodied forth using a structure of ideas that results from the coming together in Eliot's mind of various views of the savage and city. 
 We now know that around 1922 Eliot was close to becoming a Buddhist. 
 His own studies in Japanese Buddhism, his attending Oxford's Buddhist Society, and his reviewing of Oriental books are indicators of such interests. 
 But they are present, too, in his literary theorizings. 
 &bquo;Tradition and the Individual Talent&equo; is grounded on the idea that &bquo;not only the best, but the most individual parts of his &lsqb;an author's&rsqb; work may be those in which the dead poets, his ancestors, assert their immortality most vigorously&equo;. 
 In the same year, writing of how as good writers &bquo;we have not borrowed, we have been quickened, and we become bearers of a tradition&equo;, Eliot complains (before quoting a revoicing of Seneca by Chapman which would be used in &bquo;Gerontion&equo;) that in contemporary poetry, &bquo;No dead voices speak through the living voice; no reincarnation, no re-creation.&equo; 
 Reincarnation and re-creation would be crucial to The Waste Land  where Buddhist ideas would have an important place and where various voices of the dead, from that of Dante to that of Mayne Reid, would play their part in a sort of literary metempsychosis, not entirely unlike that used by Joyce in Ulysses , which Eliot was reading at the time. 
 For Eliot, though, such ideas of tradition and reincarnation would be bound up with heredity at the most basic evolutionary level and with the continuing cycle of renewal and death which he found in the pages of the anthropologists. 
 These pages revealed rituals which, Jessie Weston informed him, had survived the passage From Ritual to Romance , remaining hidden in modern literary forms in the world of Tennyson and Wagner. 
 When Eliot became a Christian in 1927 he declared that he found in reading Paul Elmer More, with whose Shelburne Essays  he had  shown familiarity in 1916, the work of someone who had travelled by almost the same route, to virtually the same conclusions. 
 From More Eliot seems to have taken the word &bquo;anfractuous,, and read that the poet undergoes &bquo;a partial dissolution of his own personality&equo;. 
 Like Eliot, More had been interested not only in the classics and Christianity, but also in the East. 
 The More who was interested in a religious &bquo;bridge between the Orient and the Occident&equo;, and who juxtaposed Augustine and Buddha paralleled the Eliot of The Waste Land . 
 But More also linked eastern thought about reincarnation to Darwinism, since both stressed the presence of the past and the idea that the most primitive forms persisted in the modern. 
 More feels this presence of the past when &bquo;we look into the eyes of love&equo; and obtain &bquo;for one supercelestial moment &mdash; the glimpse of a reality never before imagined, and never again to be revealed&equo;. 
 He was fascinated by Lafcadio Hearn's having 
 brought together into indissoluble union our Western theory of Darwin and that strange doctrine of metempsychosis which was carried to Japan with Buddhism&hellip; 
 To understand the tremendous realism of horror and gloom connected with this doctrine of everlasting birth and death, and re-birth, one must go to the burning valley of the Ganges&hellip; 
 In The Waste Land  Eliot would go there, armed with anthropological ideas gained from Frazer and others. 
 More wondered if Hearn had 
 introduced a new element of psychology into literature? 
 We are indeed living in the past, we who foolishly cry out that the past is dead&hellip; 
 Mr. Hearn shows how even the very beasts whom we despise as unreasoning and unremembering are filled with an inarticulate sense of this dark backward and abysm of time&hellip; 
 By reason of this terror the savage trembled before the magician who seemed to have penetrated the mysteries of nature about him. 
 For Eliot, Frazer's work was of an importance paralleling the psychology of &bquo;the complimentary &lsqb;sic&rsqb; work of Freud &mdash; throwing  its light on the obscurities of the soul from a different angle&equo;. 
 Frazer &bquo;has extended the consciousness of the human mind into as dark a backward and abysm of time as has yet been explored&equo;. 
 Ideas from Buddhism, evolutionary theory, and anthropology combined in The Waste Land . 
 I have already remarked on the poem's opening where Mendel and Rendel Harris combine to reincarnate past voices, plant breeding and anthropology shedding a new light on the dead &mdash; from the Chaucer of the &bquo;Prologue&equo; to James Thomson and the Fitzgerald whose stanza More had quoted when writing about the growth of trees and flowers in an essay of &bquo;Saint Augustine&equo;:. 
 Now the New Year reviving Old Desires, 
 The thoughtful Soul to Solitude retires 
 Where the White Hand of Moses on the Bough 
 puts out, and Jesus from the Ground suspires. 
 Eliot's Bough was The Golden Bough  which had plenty to say about the rebirth of gods accompanying vegetation. 
 In the final version of the poem Buddha meets St Augustine, while Christ and Buddha merge in the &bquo;I&equo; of the abandoned &bquo;I am the Resurrection and the Life&equo; fragment. 
 The anthropological elements in the final poem are also present in the collection of manuscripts from which it emerged. 
 We see there how Eliot indulged his sense of irony by resuscitating the voices of older poets through his anthropological interests and satirizing &bquo;a time, barren of myths&equo; and a world of those &bquo;illimitable suburbs&equo; which he saw in 1921 as filled with the public school's &bquo;petrified product&equo;. 
 &bquo;Exequy&equo; uses the essentially Frazerian structure of &bquo;a man-god&equo;. 
 Its &bquo;sacred grove&equo; is a phrase straight from The Golden Bough . 
 Frazer's evocative and often imaginative description of Nemi's grove under &bquo;the dreamy blue of Italian skies&equo; ensures that Eliot's poem takes place in &bquo;that Italian air&equo;. 
 Yet we are uncertain of a temporal context for the poem. 
 If we are dealing with a &bquo;suburban tomb&equo;, then the word suburban suggests, though it need not mean, the life of the modern city. 
 Later, the &bquo;Austrian waltz&equo; will also suggest this. 
 As the anthropologists whom he had read had used poetry to exemplify  various rituals, so Eliot does the same with an ironic bite. 
 In the second stanza we find him still in the classical world, though this time it is the Greek rather than the Italian, and it begins by being the Greek seen not through the eyes of Frazer, but through the eyes of Keats. 
 Eliot's second stanza opens: 
 When my athletic marble form 
 Forever lithe, forever young, 
 With grateful garlands shall be hung&hellip; 
 There are quite sufficient echoes here to direct the reader to Keats's &bquo;ode on a Grecian Urn&equo; where he finds the urn &bquo;With brede/ Of marble men and maidens overwrought, / With forest branches&hellip; &bquo;and finds too scenes of love &bquo;For ever warm and still to be enjoyed, / For ever panting, and for ever young &mdash;&equo; as well as the heifer approaching the altar &bquo;with garlands dressed&equo;. 
 Eliot, though, is determined, like the anthropological writers he had been reading, to make plain the root of the custom, which he does in the next line, &bquo;And flowers of deflowered maids&equo;. 
 As in the Frazer of &bquo;The Influence of the Sexes on Vegetation&equo;, the strong links between sex and religion are revealed. 
 This is also in line with Eliot's own criticism of the lack of such relationships in Wundt's work. 
 But if Eliot in the poem has adopted the personality of a fertility god, this god is a peculiarly Prufrockian one in the sense that for all &bquo;The constant flame shall keep me warm,&equo; he remains not simply a minor divinity, neither being nor meant to be Prince Hamlet, but also, for all the lovers' attentions, an impotent ghost, &bquo;A bloodless shade among the shades/ Doing no good, but not much harm&equo;. 
 The poem is an undermining of traditional notions of love, through repeating love's rites in such a way as to show them as meaningless. 
 The Passionate Shepherd, Marlowe, invoked his pastoral love to be with him &bquo;By shallow rivers, to whose falls/ Melodious birds sing madrigals&equo;. 
 In Eliot's poem it is &bquo;While the melodious fountain falls&equo; that love is made, but we are forced to be conscious of an artifice &bquo;(Carved by the cunning Bolognese)&equo; which suggests that the apparently primitive fertility ritual where &bquo;The Adepts twine beneath the trees/ The sacrificial exercise&equo; has become a decadent pleasure, rather than a genuine ritual. 
 It is ritual decayed into spectacle where not continuity but surprise has  become the ultimate consideration, tradition and originality having their horns uncomfortably locked in the phrase &bquo;invariable surprise&equo;: 
 They terminate the festivals 
 With some invariable surprise 
 Of fireworks, or an Austrian waltz. 
 In 1921, The Waste Land  clearly on his mind, Eliot complained that the anti-Georgian poets were &bquo;mostly such as could imagine the Last Judgment only as a lavish display of Bengal lights, Roman candles, catherine-wheels, and inflammable fire-balloons. 
 Vous, hypocrite lecteur &hellip;&equo; 
 The last stanza of &bquo;Exequy&equo; is a summing-up of the kind of rituals described by Frazer in Adonis Attis Osiris  where in the declining year the representative of the year-spirit was put to death, often by burning. 
 This ritual suicide is seen as something deeper than the sexual rituals described in earlier stanzas, yet in Frazerian terms, it is itself a ritual performed in connection with the revival of vegetation in spring. 
 The visitor of the last stanza comes &bquo;more violent, more profound, / One soul, disdainful or disdained,&equo; and in the condition of the year-spirit or , &bquo;his shadowed beauty stained / The colour of the withered year&equo;, to go to a death which places him in the position of savage sacrifice and, for he is surely related to the saints of Eliot's other early poems, martyr &bquo;Self-immolating on the Mound&equo;. 
 This visitor is himself unable to escape from the sexuality found to permeate even the most intense religious belief. 
 Eliot was, of course, familiar with the association of death and sexual climax, having played with the idea in that murder of &bquo;Nocturne, which calls forth the explanation 
 &bquo;The perfect climax all true lovers seek!&equo; 
 but the nervous mark of this humorous poem's immature irony has been replaced by the much more horrific denial of the meaning of the action of the ritual 
 Upon the crisis, he shall hear 
 A breathless chuckle underground. 
 SOVEGNA VOS AL TEMPS DE MON DOLOR 
 In his draft Eliot has replaced this last cry with  
 Consiros vei  la passade folor. 
 &mdash; &bquo;in thought I see my past madness&equo;; these two cries are from the Arnaut Daniel speech ending Purgatorio XXVI , where the poet condemned to the circle of lust prays for the hearer's consideration and looks forward to the release from the to tortures meted out to the lustful. 
 This passage haunted Eliot who was to quote from it in the original title of Poems , 1920, as well as in Ash-Wednesday . 
 As it is used in the draft poem it seems to imply that not only are the decadent versions of primitive sexual rituals inane, the god dead and impotent, however passionate the rituals of his worship, but that even the ultimate act of martyrdom is a sexual indulgence. 
 Though the poetic richness of &bquo;Exequy&equo; would be surpassed in The Waste Land , a far subtler piece of writing, the emptiness of the lesser work and its pained despair would be repeated in the masterpiece. 
 The Waste Land  is not a Christian poem. 
 By the time when he began to work most intensively on what would become The Waste Land , Eliot was neither god nor martyr. 
 Instead, he was living in a north London flat and working weekdays in a City bank, returning home at night to a difficult marriage. 
 London itself, however, may have furnished encouragement for the lines Eliot's thought was taking. 
 Visiting the Notting Hill Victorian mansion of Ford Madox Ford, Eliot saw not quite a sacred grove, but a patch of grass surmounted by Gaudier-Brzeska's &bquo;Hieratic Head of Ezra Pound&equo; which Wyndham Lewis described as &bquo;Ezra in the form of a marble phallus&equo;. 
 While in 1920&ndash;1 Eliot admired both Edward Wadsworth's drawings of industrial landscapes and Picasso's primitivism, he found himself living the life of Thomson or of the city clerks he had read about in Conan Doyle, Davidson, Conrad, and elsewhere. 
 Haunted by the voices of the past, Eliot had come to inhabit the landscape of his earlier reading. 
 From that landscape, masking the real London around him, grew The Waste Land . 
 What appears to be one of the earliest sections of the manuscripts the section beginning &bquo;So through the evening, through the violet air&equo;  (dating from c.1914) contains an arresting image which would find its way into the final poem. 
 A woman drew her long black hair out tight 
 And fiddled whisper music on those strings. 
 This image conflates two images from Kipling's short stories, images which Eliot would again juxtapose in 1941. 
 Compare the description of the agony in In the Same boat  (a story the end of which is truer to the experience than i&ndash; the end of The Brushwood Boy ): &bquo;Suppose you were a violin string &mdash; vibrating &mdash; and someone put his finger on you&equo; with the image of the &bquo;banjo string drawn tight&equo; for the breaking wave in The finest Story in the World . 
 &bquo;In the Same Boat&equo; has Kipling's Conroy exclaim just before he meets the hysterical, drug-taking woman, Miss Henschil, 
 &bquo;I'm no musician, but suppose you were a violin-string &mdash; vibrating &mdash; and some one put his finger on you? 
 As if a finger were put on the naked soul! 
 Awful!' 
 Eliot transfers this, yet another image of terrible pain, to an almost surreal context in his poem, but the woman who draws her long black hair out tight is related to that other hysterical woman of &bquo;A Game of Chess&equo;, since she too is seen brushing her hair. 
 Eliot's youthful familiarity with Kipling's stories was clear in his 1 909 student essay on that author's prose. 
 Eliot was particularly interested in Kipling's use of the supernatural, &bquo;one of his most effective tools,, and saw him as roaming &bquo;from Greenland to the South Seas in search of effects&equo;. 
 Stories which Eliot knew then such as &bquo;They&equo; and &bquo;The End of the Passage&equo;, &bquo;one of the most striking tales of fear that I have ever read&equo;, would haunt his poetry. 
 The younger Eliot tried to revolt against Kipling, as against the Nineties, but the older had a &bquo;feeling of destiny&equo; that he was linked to Kipling. 
 Certainly &bquo;The  Finest Story in the World&equo; with its hero who emerges as the unlikely reincarnation of a Norseman from Greenland and a galley slave was to have considerable repercussions. 
 The hero of Kipling's story is a London bank clerk who is also an ambitious poet. 
 &bquo;His name was Charlie Mears; he was the only son of his mother who was a widow, and he lived in the north of London, coming into the City every day to work in a bank.&equo; 
 The widowed mother, the residence in north London, and the daily travel to work in the London bank were all pad of Eliot's own experience at the time of the composition of most of The Waste Land . 
 Charlie's &bquo;Business took him over London Bridge.&equo; 
 His poetic efforts are mocked by the narrator of the story, who is none the less fascinated by what stimulates Charlie's writing. 
 Like Eliot, this narrator goes to the British Museum, and like Eliot he has an interest in metempsychosis. 
 He introduces Charlie to &bquo;Mortimer Collins's &bquo;Transmigration&equo;, and gave him a sketch of the plot before he opened the pages.&equo; 
 Certainly Eliot's studies in Sanskrit and Pali at Harvard under Lanman and Woods had given him a thorough knowledge of Indian thought, but it is probable that Kipling's version of metempsychosis had at least an equally important effect. 
 Kipling's story presents, through the consciousness of Charlie, extreme historical juxtapositions. 
 Charlie Mears emerges as the reincarnation not only of a galley slave from ancient Egypt, but also of a seaman from the Vinland Sagas. 
 These past lives are confused with the life of a modern bank clerk. 
 So, just before speaking of the Skroelings (that is, Skraelings of The Vinland Sagas ) Charlie is walking through London. 
 Business took him over London Bridge, and I accompanied him. 
 He was very full of the importance of that book &lsqb;a bill-book&rsqb; and magnified it. 
 As we passed over the Thames we paused to look at a steamer unloading great slabs of white and brown marble. 
 A barge drifted under the steamer's stern and a lonely ship's cow in the barge bellowed. 
 Charlie's face changed from the face of the bank-clerk to that of an unknown and &mdash; though he would not have believed this &mdash; a much shrewder man. 
 He flung out his arm  across the parapet of the bridge and laughing very loudly, said: &mdash; 
 &bquo;When they heard our  bulls bellow the Skroelings ran away!' 
 Eliot, like Charlie, was preoccupied with bill books, so that a &bquo;Bill of Lading&equo; even finds its way into his note on &bquo;C.i.f. 
 London: documents at sight&equo;. 
 In The Waste Land  we move where &bquo;The barges drift/ With the turning tide&equo; where, just before, the &bquo;white and gold&equo; marble of the Church of St Magnus Martyr is admired. 
 Crossing London Bridge among the crowd of clerks, Eliot too has a most curious shift from a modern scene to an ancient seaman's cry. 
 There I saw one I knew, and stopped him, crying: &bquo;Stetson! 
  &bquo;  You who were with me in the ships at Mylae!' 
 Charlie is unaware of the spirits alive in him, so that the narrator of the story is frustrated in his attempt to come at the uncluttered account of past lives. 
 It remained now only to encourage Charlie to talk, and here there was no difficulty. 
 But I had forgotten those accursed books of poetry. 
 He came to me time after time, as useless as a surcharged phonograph &mdash; drunk on Byron, Shelley, or Keats. 
 Yet Charlie's method also hints at the method which Eliot would use in The Waste Land : 
 The plastic mind of the bank-clerk had been overlaid, coloured, and distorted by that which he had read, and the result as delivered was a confused tangle of other voices most like the mutter and hum through a City telephone in the busiest part of the day. 
 It is not only that Charlie's lives, like those of Tiresias, grow confused; his expression, speaking out of modern London about remote and contemporary affairs, all in &bquo;a confused tangle of other voices&equo;, like a poetic ventriloquist, points in the direction of 
 London Bridge is falling down falling down falling down 
 Poi s'ascose net foco che gli affina 
 Quando fiam uti chelidon  &mdash; O swallow swallow 
 Le Prince d'Aguitaine &agrave; la tour abolie 
 These fragments I have shored against my ruins  
 Why then Ile fit you. 
 Hieronymo's mad againe. 
 Datta. 
 Dayadhvam. 
 Damyata. 
 Shantih shantih shantih 
 Charlie Mears does not express himself in Sanskrit, but the narrator of the text knows who will most appreciate Charlie's story. 
 He tells it to an Indian friend, and soon ceases to speak the tale in his own language, substituting instead the Indian's. 
 &bquo;After all, it could never have been told in English.&equo; 
 The narrator dreams of how Charlie's tales of his reincarnations will be spread, as &bquo;the finest story in the world&equo; until the point when, &bquo;Every Orientalist in Europe would patronize it discursively with Sanskrit and Pali texts.&equo; 
 The narrator dreams of founding a new religion. 
 The Waste Land  seems at times to be attempting to piece together some new religion out of fragments of the old. 
 It also follows Kipling's story in its juxtaposition of seamen. 
 Eliot may not have in his poem Kipling's Greek slave on a galley out of Egypt, but he does give us a slightly earlier seafarer who sailed out of the Middle East and whose story might be thought to be specially appropriate to those clerks who work in the city &mdash; 
 Phlebas the Phoenician, a fort night dead, 
 Forgot the cry of gulls, and the deep sea swell 
 And the profit and loss. 
 Overwhelmed by water, Charlie Mears, the London bank-clerkcum-Greek-galley-slave met his death by water more than once. 
 &bquo;I had an awful dream about that galley of ours. 
 I dreamed I was drowned&hellip; 
 I could hear the water sizzle, and we spun round like a cockchafer&hellip; 
 &equo; A little later Kipling presents the description of a breaking wave as a &bquo;banjo string drawn tight&equo; which so impressed Eliot. 
 The manner of Charlie's death in this particular incarnation, coupled with the way in which he is able to look back over his earlier experiences no doubt contributed a lot to the fate of Eliot's Phlebas, 
 A current under sea 
 Picked his bones in whispers. 
 As he rose and fell 
 He passed the stages of his age and youth 
 Entering the whirlpool. 
 Similarly, Charlie's incarnation as a Norse explorer among the Skroelings, ending when a man who seems to be Erik the Red took his crew and &bquo;steered them for three days among floating ice, each floe crowded with strange beasts that &bquo;tried to sail with us,&equo; said Charlie, &bquo;and we beat them back with the handles of the oars&equo; surely relates to the long sea voyage, an account of which originally formed the bulk of the &bquo;Death by Water&equo; section. 
 In this passage, as in the Kipling story, food runs out and three ghosts haunt the seamen. 
 Norwegian pine is mentioned, and Eliot's voyagers also end among the ice-floes, among polar bears. 
 Charlie Mears, the bank clerk, however, is more usually a secondrate poet who does not understand the value of his &bquo;dreams&equo;, scorning to think of them in terms of actual reincarnations, though these dreams are so vivid that reality and unreality seem mixed. 
 Here was another aspect of the Kipling story which must have appealed to the student of F. H. Bradley, the Eliot who himself wrote on &bquo;Degrees of Reality&equo;. 
 Small wonder that his dreaming had seemed real to Charlie. 
 The Fates that are so careful to shut the doors of each successive life behind us had, in this case, been neglectful, and Charlie was looking, though that he did not know, where never man had been permitted to look with full knowledge since Time began. 
 This vision, what Eliot called Kipling's knowledge &bquo;of the things which are underneath, and of the things which are beyond the frontier,, was what made some of Kipling's short stories so important to the writer of The Waste Land . 
 It was like Frazer's looking into the &bquo;abysm of time&equo;, but it was a vision only imperfectly appreciated by Charlie Mears, as the narrator of &bquo;The Finest Story in the World&equo; emphasizes: &bquo;Above all, he was absolutely ignorant of the knowledge sold to me for five pounds; and he would retain that ignorance, for bank-clerks do not understand metempsychosis, and a sound commercial education does not include Greek.&equo; 
 To find its most lasting realization, Charlie's vision would have to wait for a bank clerk who did understand metempsychosis, and who had not only a commercial education gained in an underground room at Lloyds Bank, but also a knowledge of Greek. 
 The Waste Land's  tone would be grimmer, &bquo;throbbing between two lives&equo;. 
 But when such a bank clerk followed Charlie, Rudyard Kipling entered The Waste Land .  
 Kipling provided links between life in the modern city and ideas of incarnation, but Eliot further bound up these two elements with primitive ritual. 
 Again, Eliot found artistic incitements for doing this. 
 His 1923 review of Ulysses  ends by stating that a combination of psychology, ethnology, and Frazer's Golden Bough  has made possible a new method of artistic construction. 
 &bquo;Instead of narrative method, we may now use the mythical method.&equo; 
 But it would be wrong to see The Waste Land  as &bquo;controlling&hellip; ordering&hellip; giving a shape and a significance to the immense panorama of futility and anarchy which is contemporary history&equo; in the way that Eliot believed Ulysses  did. 
 For The Waste Land , while it does unite the themes which Eliot sees as paramount in &bquo;contemporary history&equo; and history as a whole, gives to those themes no firm significance which raises them above futility. 
 The tribes of Todas and Veddahs stuck in Eliot's mind for at least fifteen years because both had little sense of the meaning of their religious ceremonies. 
 At Harvard he read how apart from gods useful for economic purposes, &bquo;All the myths about their gods are otherwise hazy, and their names persist in a meaningless way in the Todas&equo; prayers.&equo; 
 Such a state of affairs is related to that of &bquo;The Kafirs of South Africa&equo; who have, we are told, &bquo;no definite social structure&equo; and whose &bquo;notion of Umkulunkulu, one of their chief divinities, &lsqb;is&rsqb;&hellip; extremely hazy, and there is little agreement as to who he really is.&equo; 
 Eliot mentioned Umkulunkulu in his 1913 paper. 
 Ideas of the relationship between developed drama and primitive rites and of the loss of meaningful mythologies continued to haunt Eliot. 
 In spring 1921, when &bquo;the English myth is pitiably diminished&equo; he discussed &bquo;the chief myth which the Englishman has built about himself, that of the fat country squire. 
 The language used to describe this is reminiscent of Harrison, as well as clearly relating to the technique of Charlie Mears, Tiresias, and the dromenon-  like patterning with which Eliot had been experimenting in the quatrain poems. 
 The myth that a man makes has transformations according as he sees himself as hero or villain, as young or old, but it is essentially the same myth; Tom  Jones is not the same person, but he is the same myth as Squire Western; Midshipman Easy is part of the same myth; Falstaff is elevated above the myth to dwell on Olympus, more than a national character. 
 As in &bquo;Exequy&equo;, Eliot ends with a ridiculous man-god. 
 His piece, appearing in Tyro  beside Lewis's totem-pole-like modern figures and John Adams's &bquo;Cafe Cannibale&equo;, was part of a contemporary interest in primitive roots. 
 Ulysses  was for Eliot in 1921 &bquo;the greatest work of the age&equo;. 
 Probably the most important effect of his reading of Joyce was to make him all the more aware of the possibilities of his anthropological reading, especially when applied to modern city life in the context of inanity or death: city life was filled with fatal torpor and Eliot described London as shrivelling, like an aged little bookkeeper. 
 In November 1921 Eliot expressed a dread of London, longing for sea or mountains. 
 In his discussion of the decay of English myth, he holds out only the slender hope of the music hall and laments that in general modern dramatists and probably modern audiences are &bquo;terrified of the myth&equo;. 
 Eliot at this period was searching amongst myths and rituals. 
 Weston's 1920 From Ritual to Romance  gave him the tarot pack and backed up Frazer's emphasis on links between sexuality and religion. 
 She furnished Eliot with the title and central concept of his poem, but was otherwise more important for summarizing and reminding him of other people's ideas, such as those of E. K. Chambers speaking of literary forms encompassing &bquo;fragments of forgotten cults&equo;. 
 Through quotation and allusion Weston reminded Eliot of his reading in Cornford, Frazer, Harrison, Spencer and Gillen, and Gilbert Murray, and discussed many of the questions which Eliot had explored in their pages. 
 His mind filled with primitive lore and with a sense of awkwardness at the numerous exhausting social roles he had to play in addition to that of the London banker, Eliot wrote to Mary Hutchinson in 1920 worrying about his inherited characteristics and suggesting that he might be a savage himself. 
 At  home, he read in Weston's book that 
 In the Rig-Veda &hellip; 
 Indra, while still retaining traces of his &bquo;weather&equo; origin, is no longer, to borrow Miss Harrison's descriptive phrase, &bquo;an automatic explosive thunder-storm,&equo; he wields the thunderbolt certainly, but he appears in heroic form to receive the offerings made to him, and to celebrate his victory in a solemn ritual dance. 
 Given the various elements present in Eliot's mind, it is hardly surprising that he found in the thundering drums of Stravinsky's ballet, Le Sacre du printemps , the equivalent of the myth he sought. 
 Attending the ballet, Eliot sought to use the point of an umbrella in order to stop his neighbours laughing. 
 The city man's rolled umbrella could easily become a spear. 
 For Eliot Stravinsky's piece itself united city and savage, seeming to metamorphose &bquo;the rhythm of the steppes into the scream of the motor horn, the rattle of machinery, the grind of wheels, the beating of iron and steel, the roar of the underground railway, and the other barbaric cries of modern life; and to transform these despairing noises into music&equo;. 
 This is hardly an average reaction to the piece, but the despairing Eliot was using Stravinsky's music to underpin his own endeavours in The Waste Land . 
 A member of Diaghilev's company had become Grishkin, uniting jungle and &bquo;maisonette&equo;, in &bquo;Whispers of Immortality&equo;. 
 Eliot's reading of Heart of Darkness  whose Buddha-like clerk, Marlow, saw London as &bquo;one of the dark places of the earth&equo; further blended savage and &bquo;sepulchral city&equo;. 
 Eliot returned to the Russian Ballet in 1919, and in 1921 saw their dancing in terms of vegetation rites and primitive ceremonies, but that dancing contained only marginal interest because not linked to the modernity of Stravinsky's music. 
 It was, however, of interest to those who had read The Golden Bough  and related works. 
 &bquo;In art there should be interpenetration and metamorphosis. 
 Even The Golden Bough can be read in two ways: as a collection of entertaining myths, or as a revelation of that vanished mind of which our mind is a  continuation.&equo; 
 That last phrase, presenting the savage mind as &bquo;vanished&equo;, yet suggesting that it continues in our own, is in line with Eliot's refusal when discussing L&eacute;vy-Bruhl, to pin down just how the savage mind is related to the modern. 
 In his poem it seems related to modern city life by both &bquo;interpenetration and metamorphosis&equo;. 
 Weston emphasized to Eliot that not only dramas, but poetry also derived from primitive rites. 
 By adopting the Waste Land theme, Eliot made himself the performer of the latest enactment of a repeated rite, just as in his poem clerk and typist (like the earlier Burbank and Volupine) enact their own sexual ritual. 
 Though doubtless partly motivated by a desire to draw the reader away from his own personal life, Eliot was serious in pointing out that, &bquo;Anyone who is acquainted with these works &lsqb;of Weston and Frazer&rsqb; will immediately recognize in the poem certain references to vegetation ceremonies&equo;, which, as in the quatrain poems, were associated with religion and human sexuality. 
 But in the same way that the sexual act is losing its meaning, in pub scene, or baroque interior, or city flat, with the result that we are brought to question whatever meaning it once may seem to have possessed, so in The Waste Land  the rituals of religion appear also to be failing. 
 Eliot had recounted in 1916 how in the excitement of the Australian aboriginal corroboree &bquo;with every stimulant of noise, torchlight, strange masks, and drink, the savage seems to himself to have become a new being&equo;. 
 Eliot was relying on Durkheim's account of intichiuma  ceremonies with &bquo;all sorts of processions, dances and songs&hellip; by torchlight&hellip; a&hellip; savage scene&equo;. 
 Durkheim went on to link aboriginal with Christian practices. 
 Eliot's earlier poetry had endowed scenes of Christian martyrdom with a savage violence and primitive overtones. 
 Now he linked corroboree, intichiuma  of spring, and Crucifixion, as if to find beneath the &bquo;stony places&equo; of the Bible the &bquo;stony places&equo; of the Australian desert photographed by Spencer and Gillen and presented in The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life . 
 After the torchlight red on sweaty faces 
 After the frosty silence in the gardens 
 After the agony in stony places 
 The shouting and the crying 
 Prison and palace and reverberation 
 Of thunder of spring over distant mountains 
 He who was living is now dead 
 We who were living are now dying 
 With a little patience 
 &bquo;Dying&equo; because the sustaining myths seem to be fading away. 
 There is deliberate incongruity in the cry to Stetson. 
 In The Waste Land  the idea of a fertility cult in City or suburb is made to seem not irrelevant, but horribly absurd as in the scenes overheard in the pub or observed by Tiresias. 
 Primitive religion interpenetrates other material throughout a poem which opens with roots, plant life, the stuff of heredity and apparently the basis of the most elementary religion. 
 In a work so concerned with the transmission of cultural values this is appropriate. 
 Roots and branches speak of plant-life and of the gods which anthropology stressed were totemically associated with it. 
 They introduce the &bquo;Son of man&equo;, and the relationships between Christianity and other religions whose heaps of broken images strew the anthropologists' pages and the sites of the world's past cultures. 
 Other themes, such as the importance of the shadow to primitive man, flicker through these lines. 
 That memorable &bquo;handful of dust&equo; belongs to the religion of &bquo;ashes to ashes, dust to dust&equo; in this burial of the dead, but also to more primitive rites. 
 As April, &bquo;the cruellest month&equo;, brings renewed life, which is a renewal of pain and memories of destruction, so antithetically, this dust looks not only towards the grave, but also towards birth as the handful of fecundating dust sprinkled over those red rocks of Durkheim's desert tribes. 
 &hellip; the grains of dust which the Australian detaches from the sacred rock are so many sacred principles which he scatters into space, so that they may go to animate the totemic species and assure its renewal. 
 The Waste Land  itself functions as a primitive ritual. 
 Cries, Eliot knew, were vital to the most basic corroboree when &bquo;on every side one sees nothing but violent gestures, cries, veritable howls, and deafening noises or every sort. 
 ln religious ceremony, &bquo;the same manifestations are to be observed in each case: cries, songs, music, violent movements, dances, the search for exciteants which raise the vital level&equo;. 
 Such  musical cries &bquo;raise the vital level&equo; in Eliot's poem, bursting strangely into the texture of the English: 
 The peal of bells 
 White towers 
 Weialala leia 
 Wallala leialala 
 But other cries are also present. 
 Spencer and Gillen photographed and detailed aborigines dressed as animals, emitting animal cries to promote fertility. 
 We may have a glimpse of sympathetic magic in &bquo;when we came back, late, from the hyacinth garden, / Your arms full, and your hair wet&hellip; 
 &bquo;. Jessie Weston reinforced Frazer in stressing that &bquo;Throwing into, or drenching with, water is a well-known part of &bquo;Fertility&equo; ritual; it is a case of sympathetic magic, acting as a rain charm.&equo; 
 But The Waste Land's  sounds, rather than sights, come closest to enacting savage ritual, as we might expect of Eliot's &bquo;auditory imagination&equo;. 
 Writing of human imitation of totemic creatures, Durkheim stressed that &bquo;In a large number of tribes, the Intichiuma of rain consists essentially in imitative rites.&equo; 
 Among the Arunta &bquo;in the Intichiuma of water, the men of the totem utter the characteristic cry of the plover, a cry which is naturally associated in the mind with the rainy season.&equo; 
 Eliot gives us not plovers' sympathetic magic but that of the Turdus aonalaschkae pallasii  whose &bquo;waterdripping song&equo; is justly celebrated'. 
 Drip drop drip drop drop drop drop 
 But there is no water 
 The ritual now is powerless. 
 The magic fails. 
 The Waste Land's  bestiary is a full one; other creatures such as bats and crickets were associated with rainmaking. 
 As L&eacute;vy-Bruhl pointed out, primitive men saw the chirping of crickets and crying of birds in spring as appeals for rain. 
 Such cries traditionally used to promote fertility occur ironically in The Waste Land , punctuating its infertile or sexually perverted world where previous rituals and beliefs seem to be lapsing into futility.  
 Twit twit twit 
 Jug jug jug jug jug jug 
 &hellip; 
 Co co rico co co rico 
 The first cry is associated with &bquo;The change of Philomel, by the barbarous king/ So rudely forced&equo;. 
 Eliot's interest in human animals, seen in the quatrain poems, intensifies in The Waste Land . 
 It is hardly surprising that a passage of Ovid is described in his Notes as &bquo;of great anthropological interest&equo;. 
 The poem's most crucial cry is that of the cock. 
 It comes from Rostand's Chantecler , a play which Eliot recalled in 1919, probably having seen it in Paris where it had been a hit in the winter of 1910. 
 This play which was in Boston in 1911 is set in a farmyard. 
 The actors dress in animal or bird costumes. 
 A nightingale is one of the chief characters. 
 The play must have struck Eliot as fitting in perfectly with intichiuma  ceremonies and with the general idea of drama evolving from primitive ritual. 
 Vain Chantecler refuses to recognize that it is not his own crying of &bquo;Cocorico&equo; which causes the sun to rise. 
 His description of that cry is, to anyone interested in anthropology, heavy with overt ones of fertility ritual: &bquo;La Terre parle en moi comme dans une conque.&equo; 
 Chantecler  must have fuelled Eliot's convictions about the origins of drama in primitive ceremony, as well as dealing with problems of religious decay and with mystical versus  rational belief. 
 Watching actors in animal costume making their sophisticated jokes was like proof of anthropologists' statements, as typified by Frazer in that same conclusion to The Dying God , where he stated that serious rites had become idle amusement, mummeries, and childish games. 
 Eliot, who occasionally attended Ouspensky's seances in London in 1920 and who used the Tarot and Madam Sosostris in the London of The Waste Land , was familiar with the decay of magic; but the man who attacked Back to Methuselah  in 1921 hardly shared Frazer's  Comtian, progressive tone. 
 Shaw's book, however, did encourage Eliot to think of the modern in terms of the ancient, of &bquo;creative evolution&equo;, of &bquo;Darwin', &bquo;biology&equo;, and the &bquo;ultimate questions&equo; raised by &bquo;the attempt to expose a panorama of human history &bquo;as far as thought can reach&equo;. 
 &bquo;Social evolution&equo; and its application to modern English society were already in Eliot's mind. 
 He attacked contemporary literature's taste for which all things were either too hot or too cold, and complained that it contained no culture. 
 He lamented the extinction of the music hall, home of the vestiges of the English myth. 
 The Waste Land , in presenting extreme emotional states, would encompass the extremes of city and savage. 
 Durkheim and others had emphasized to Eliot connections between primitive rituals like the intichiuma  and more developed religions such as Christianity. 
 For Durkheim and his associates such ceremonies did not represent, as they did for Frazer, magic as some separate predecessor of religion, but were themselves elementary forms of the religious life. 
 The Waste Land  hardly suggests that the inhabitants of the twentieth-century city are conscious actors in fertility rites, but since these, long forgotten, underlie our behaviour, since the &bquo;sexual instinct&equo; plays a role in &bquo;the religion and mythology of primitive peoples (indeed in all religion)&equo;, and since Christianity and primitive ritual are linked, the poem expresses despair at the change and decay not only of city churches which Eliot visited at this time, but of all belief. 
 Yet under all the various forms, the sexual act and natural fertility cycles persist. 
 In cities, where the seasons' impact is dulled, the rituals of fertility seem to lose their meaning, but they continue, processing like scenes in a play before Tiresias, epitome of the sexual process, male and female trapped together, who has &bquo;foresuffered all&equo;. 
 These modern performances interpret all earlier performances and interpretations, casting doubt on their total significance, just as, on a smaller scale, Eliot's reworking of the Enobarbus speech casts doubt on the validity of Shakespeare's interpretation of Cleopatra. 
 Whether Carthage or London, the poem's cities are seen as horrible, life-denying.  
 Jerusalem Athens Alexandria 
 Vienna London 
 Unreal 
 Yet the primitive pattern of sexual &bquo;burning&equo; underlying their inhabitants' actions and beneath religious belief is scarcely more attractive. 
 If the poem goes back to the origins of religion, it also goes back to the origins of society and language. 
 The old order has been destroyed. 
 The Waste Land  begins a new poetry, or seeks to, but also marks the reborn post-war society. 
 The lines which read in draft 
 Who are those hooded hordes swarming 
 Over polish plains, stumbling in cracked earth 
 became in the final version universalized through the substitution of &bquo;endless&equo; for &bquo;Polish&equo;. 
 The constant &bquo;hordes&equo; is significant. 
 Eliot knew the technical sense of this word: &bquo;The horde &hellip; is the protoplasm of the social domain&hellip;&equo; 
 Wundt wrote that about &bquo; horde , meaning&hellip; an unorganized, in contrast to an organized, tribe of people&hellip; 
 The Tartars called a division of warriors a horda .&equo; 
 The horde, &bquo;Characteristic of primitive times&equo;, was the basic social unit. 
 Eliot, who was putting &bquo;Tartar horsemen&equo; in his poetry in 1924, seems to have been impressed by this passage. 
 The Waste Land  returns to all sources, including the sources of human society. 
 What it brings back seems little, in terms of hope at least. 
 Religious hope flickers, as at Magnus Martyr, but the city crowds out the city churches, and going to the apparent sources of the religious life which seemed to hold promise in Lower Thames Street, Eliot found himself unable to sustain hope. 
 &bquo;Eastern and western asceticism&equo; merge. 
 Christian Burial of the Dead combines with Buddha's Fire Sermon, but both are shot through with the sort of primitive fertility cycle hinted at in &bquo;Death by Water&equo;. 
 The poem's exploration reveals all religions combined. 
 We are deliberately led on towards what Eliot knew was one of the phenomena found most universally in religions ranging from the most primitive to the most developed: thunder. 
 The veneration of thunder was mentioned continually in Eliot's anthropological reading: thunder as the terrifying voice of a god,  commanding respect and faith. 
 Such a voice was necessary also, as bringing the rain so essential to life's continuation. 
 Among the Australians, Harrison wrote, sounds of thunder were simulated. 
 The roaring, boys and women are told, represents the muttering of thunder, and the thunder &mdash; this is the important point &mdash; is the voice of Dhuramoolan. 
 &bquo;Thunder,&equo; said Umbara headman of the Ywin tribe, &bquo;is the voice of Him (and he pointed upwards to the sky) calling on the rain to fall and everything to grow up new.' 
 Thunder was associated with the Revelation story of death and rebirth (see, for example, Rev. 8: 5), with Australian rainmaking, with the Grail story lightning, and with the origin of drama. 
 Concerning thunder rites, Harrison even went so far as to quote Durkheim's &bquo; Le sacr&eacute;, c'est le p&egrave;re du dieu .&equo; 
 From sacred thunder the voice of a god might be born, a desert might be transformed, and man, savage man and even modern City man, might live again. 
 Ideas of the juxtaposition of the arid and the flowering desert were familiar to Eliot from the time when he had read Mayne Reid. 
 They grew with his reading of Frazer who described the &bquo;Burnt Land of Lydia&equo; contrasting with the surrounding verdure and marvelled (in the conclusion of The Dying God ) at &bquo;what may be called the Australian spring&equo; where &bquo;the sandy and stony wilderness, over which the silence and desolation of death appear to brood, is suddenly, after a few days of torrential rain, transformed into a landscape smiling with verdure&equo;. 
 Thunder, bringing rain, God's saving word, made possible &bquo;a new start&equo;. 
 To find this, Eliot goes from the city to the savage beginnings of religion, from literature and drama to their ritual origins, and from his present as a London clerk to his earlier life. 
 There he found fragments uniting the personal and anthropological, whether in the &bquo;memory and desire&equo; of the Thomsonian buried corpse about which he had read at Harvard, in the Frazerian Mayne Reid deserts of his childhood, in Kipling's metempsychosis, Rostand, or Jacobean dramatists, or a passage recommended to him by his Harvard Sanskrit teacher, Charles Lanman, who had laid special emphasis on the advice which the Hindu &bquo;Lord of Creatures&equo; gives to men in  thunder. 
 In a letter preserved in Eliot's copy of the Upanishads , Janman mentions this as an important passage. 
 But in Eliot's poem the response to these commands is uncertain and generally one of failure. 
 The &bquo;awful daring of a moment's surrender&equo; is an experience intense, but imprudent. 
 All there is in this thunder is not relief but a revival of &bquo;aethereal rumours&equo; which &bquo;only at nightfall&hellip; / Revive for a moment a broken Coriolanus.&equo; 
 Hope is fleeting (&bquo;for a moment&equo;) and lost (&bquo;broken&equo;). 
 &bquo;Your heart would have  responded&equo;, but did not (my italics). 
 The thunderword appears as the solution, the rain, a new beginning. 
 It looks back to Lanman as well as to Eliot's other Sanskrit teacher, the ex-anthropologist, Woods, who had written that to the Hindu, &bquo;Logically and temporally, the word seems to precede its idea and its meaning: a man thinks, the Hindu would say, because he is talking. 
 The benefactor of the race would be, not a Prometheus who brings a few sparks from above, but he who releases among men the most finished of all forces, an irresistible word.&equo; 
 It is not difficult to relate such an idea both to Eliot's general preoccupation with articulation in his poetry, and in particular to The Waste Land  where Eliot includes Lanman's explanatory gloss, &bquo;da &mdash; da &mdash; da = damyata datta dayadhuam &equo;, in his text. 
 After exhausting the gamut of expression from Cockney pub-talk to Dante, and running across the broad acres of comparative religion from intichiuma  to St Magnus Martyr, Eliot seems to be generating the commands of a new religion reborn from the old, by returning in his rainmaking to the origin of religious rites. 
 He also appears to be physically generating a new language, having gone back to the simplest animal and natural cries. 
 We hear the words being formed from nature: 
 DA 
 Datta 
 &hellip; 
 DA 
 Dayadhvam 
 &hellip; 
 DA 
 Damyata 
 This would seem very close to the &bquo;bow-wow&equo; theory of linguistic evolution, one of the theories much discussed in Eliot's youth, which saw language as deriving from the imitation of natural sounds. 
 Such a theory had been largely abandoned. 
 Certainly to derive the polysyllabic Dayadhuam  from the monosyllable DA is a precarious process. 
 Particularly associated with the discussion of theories of the linguistic origins of divinities was Max M&uuml;ller, whose views Eliot saw as outdated. 
 Praising Durkheim, Eliot had written about and summarized Max M&uuml;ller's attitude (largely based on Sanskrit philology), which looked at primitive religion chiefly through its myths, finding in primitive deities personifications of larger forces of nature and seeing in the primitive mind a sentiment of wonder at such forces, a basic intuition of the &bquo;infinite&equo;. 
 But Durkheim, Eliot noted, did not attribute the origin of religion to wonder or to speculation, but saw in mythology only the savage's attempt to rationalize and justify his religious practices, &bquo;in regard to the true origin of which he is as much in the dark as the scientific investigator&equo;. 
 The Waste Land  is a poem which leaves its readers in darkness. 
 The rituals of the past are perverted and decayed. 
 Savage and city alike reduce to childishness in the final babel-like collapse, &bquo;London Bridge is falling down falling down falling down.&equo; 
 The thunder ritual, which might offer salvation, is deeply suspect, potentially inane. 
 It is yet another part of the cycle of fertility which is seen in The Waste Land  as a torturing cage. 
 The poem is not structureless. 
 Themes discussed above clearly unite the diverse materials. 
 If the poem were a formal mess, reordering the five sections would make no difference; in fact, such a reordering would destroy the cyclic form. 
 Even if the awaited rain fell at the poem's end, it would only lead back to that beginning, &bquo;breeding / Lilacs out of the dead land,&equo; with all its attendant suffering. 
 Eliot in his July 1921 &bquo;London Letter&equo; saw the result of a hot rainless spring simply as a &bquo;poor&equo; &bquo;crop of murders and divorces&equo; in a &bquo;vacant term&equo;. 
 Whitman's sentiments 
 When lilacs last in the dooryard bloom'd, 
 &hellip; 
 I mourn'd, and yet shall mourn with ever-returning spring. 
  have been taken over with a vengeance and put into the anthropological perspective which in the poem Eliot has applied to so much past literature. 
 Life is painful throughout, with only the briefest moments of relief &mdash; the hyacinth garden, the fishmen at Magnus Martyr, boating &mdash; all of which only lead back into the cycle of further (often sexual) pain. 
 The &bquo;Shantih&equo; at the poem's end may be simply a way of stopping, a &bquo;formal ending&equo;; or it may be comparable to the exhausted collapse after the destruction at the end of &bquo;Gerontion&equo; (Eliot considered &bquo;Gerontion&equo; as preface to The Waste Land ). 
 Savage and city, bound together in a world fundamentally meaningless and hurtful, furnish expression for Eliot's private torment. 
 If there was to be an escape, it was to lie not in the &bquo;damp gust bringing rain&equo; but in &bquo;Shantih&equo; as the Buddhist's passing beyond the cycles of creation. 
 Eliot was unable to renounce the world he knew. 
 He remained with Vivienne, the bank, and years of exhaustion in which he came close to death. 
 He decided eventually that to embrace Buddhism would be to plunge into a world too culturally alien. 
 In the time following The Waste Land  he saw the world despairingly, in terms of inane, savage horror. 
 Run-down primitive rituals stalk &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;; in Sweeney Agonistes  they overpower jazz-age London. 
 That play has as an epigraph a Christian equivalent of the escape through &bquo;Shantih&equo; from the cycles of creation: &bquo; Hence the soul cannot be possessed of the divine union, until it has divested itself of the love of created beings .&equo; 
 But Sweeney Agonistes  follows The Waste Land  in presenting a world where fertility, renewing painful, inane life, is inescapable. 
 To see more deeply is only to see what Eliot found in the epigraph from Heart of Darkness  which he thought might have been &bquo;somewhat elucidative&equo; for The Waste Land . 
 Conrad too found the primitive and metropolitan uniting to hint at something underlying and awful, &bquo;The horror! the horror!&equo; 
 Tortured between the city and the savage, Eliot's was a nightmare world.  
 THAT'S ALL, THAT'S ALL, THAT'S ALL, THAT'S ALL 
 IN any marshalling of detailed evidence the dangers of forensic tedium are present. 
 They must always be risked. 
 Clues, however remote, may be crucial. 
 The argument for preserving Shakespeare's laundry bills is that, eventually, they may find their Sherlock Holmes. 
 The reader should bear in mind Eliot's exasperation at the graduate student who &bquo;identifies Corbi&egrave;re's &bquo;Rhapsode Foraine&equo; as an exploration &bquo;of folk-religion&equo;. 
 Nevertheless, in the early twenties Eliot's mind was clearly full of not only &bquo;Frazer&hellip; 
 Durkheim&hellip; 
 L&eacute;vy-Bruhl&equo;, but also of folklorists and anthropologists such as Sir E. B. Tylor, Robertson Smith, Miss Harrison, Miss Weston, A. B. Cook, F. M. Cornford, le Dr. Rendel Harris, Hartland, Elliot Smith, Gilbert Murray, et d'autres encore, &mdash; pour ne rien dire d'observateurs tels que Codrington, Spencer et Gillan &lsqb; sic &rsqb; Hewett, &lsqb; sic &rsqb; qui ont &eacute;tudi&eacute; les races primitives aux quatre coins de l'Empire.&equo; 
 Eliot's spelling of &bquo;Gillen&equo; and his misremembering of Howitt's surname show that he was recalling material from his past. 
 In &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; and Sweeney Agonistes  we see that such material had not lain gathering dust. 
 It had germinated. 
 &bquo;The Perfect Critic&equo; (1920) discusses Arnold in the context of English criticism as dead or dying. 
 In a letter of that autumn Eliot confessed to using Arnold as a scarecrow &mdash; apparently lifeless, but having under his arm a real gun to be fired against the old guard. 
 Later he saw Arnold as initiating &bquo;the degradation of philosophy and religion&equo;. 
 Associations of the scarecrow with powerlessness and religious degeneration resurface in &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, where the scarecrow is again camouflage, but this time hopelessly unarmed:  
 Let me also wear 
 Such deliberate disguises 
 Rat's coat, crowskin, crossed staves 
 In a field 
 Behaving as the wind behaves 
 The crossed staves of Christian iconography become a place for hanging vermin. 
 Dressing in animal skins for ritual purposes and making divine effigies from straw are favourite Frazerian topics, as is &bquo;The Propitiation of Vermin by Farmers&equo;. 
 The epigraph, &bquo; A penny for the Old Guy &equo;, stresses that Eliot's poem relates to ceremonial effigies. 
 Here, as in The Waste Land, Heart of Darkness  is important. 
 &bquo; Mistah Kurtz &mdash; he dead &equo; emphasizes a connection between savage ritual and Eliot's crossed staves. 
 To obtain power by embracing darkness, Kurtz deified himself in line with primitive belief; ironically, Eliot's speaker dresses in relics of forgotten ritual out of a sense of total impotence, wishing to avoid a horrid dusk: &bquo;Not that final meeting/ In the twilight kingdom.&equo; 
 It is landscape like Dowson's, &bquo;Hollow Lands&equo; where, in &bquo;the twilight of the year&equo;, &bquo;dead people with pale hands/ Beckon&equo; by a &bquo;weary river&equo;, &bquo;where pale stars shine&equo; where, at passion's enactment, &bquo;There fell thy shadow&equo;. 
 But the poem's world, lit by the half-light of inaction, was a transmutation of Eliot's own suffering. 
 Vivienne, who had felt The Waste Land  to be a part of herself, saw &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; as a fitting follow-on, and related it to her own nightmares. 
 But, as before, the personal world and that of late nineteenth-century poetry are sieved through anthropological ideas, emotion distributed among unsettled voices, narrative, optative, and choral. 
 The poem is typographically complex. 
 The first section's &bquo;Kingdom&equo; may not be section three's &bquo;kingdom&equo;. 
 Certainly &bquo;death's other  kingdom&equo; (my italics) suggests that the speakers' inane life is only another form of death. 
 So, for Sweeney Agonistes &bquo;Death or life or life or death / Death is life and life is death.&equo; 
 Cornford had quoted the Euripidean question, &bquo; who knows if to be living be not death ? 
 Through anthropology Eliot  resuscitates the idea of the living dead, so common in late romantic poetry, where Death-in-Life is the eternal king. 
 Eliot's Hollow Men share their hopelessness with the inhabitants of the City of Dreadful Night. 
 Though partaking of classical underworlds, Eliot's kingdoms draw heavily on other kingdoms of the dead. 
 L&eacute;vy-Bruhl, citing Ellis's description of West African wandering spirits, used the phrase &bquo;dead land&equo; ( le pays des morts ). 
 His &bquo;desert soul&equo; points to Eliot's &bquo;cactus land&equo;. 
 For L&eacute;vy-Bruhl's savage the &bquo;invisible&hellip; is most real&equo; and the dead &bquo;occasionally&hellip; heard in the wind&equo; when, ghostly, they blow straws in the air; &bquo;the murmuring of the wind betrayed the presence of the dead&equo;. 
 Eliot's &bquo;voices&hellip; 
 In the wind's singing&equo; signal a dreaded presence: 
 Eyes I dare not meet in dreams 
 In death's dream kingdom 
 These do not appear: 
 There, the eyes are 
 Sunlight on a broken column 
 There, is a tree swinging 
 Oesterley's The Sacred Dance , read by Eliot in 1923, discussed a savage who was awestruck when &bquo;a tree, swayed by the wind, moved&equo;. 
 The &bquo;broken column&equo; may relate to the traditional graveyard image of premature death, as well as to the &bquo;broken stone&equo; of section three where &bquo;stone images/ Are raised&equo;. 
 In W. J. Perry's The Origin of Magic and Religion  which he reviewed in July 1924, four months before these lines appeared, Eliot read of &bquo;old stone images&equo; of the Melanesians, of mana, of  the handing down of rituals, and of W. H. R. Rivers's work on &bquo;an extensive literature in which attempts are made to bring the symbolism of myth and ritual into relation with modern views concerning its r&ocirc;le in the dream and disease&equo;. 
 For Eliot in 1922, Rivers had been &bquo;the great  psychologist&equo;. 
 But, in Perry, he also read how the worship of stones fed off an earlier civilization and was dying out. 
 Such reading must have recalled Eliot's Harvard reading in anthropology and psychology of religion when he had noted, amongst other things Jevons's stress that &bquo;the worship of stones is a degradation of a higher form of worship&equo;. 
 Jevons also stated that &bquo;ceremonies may continue to be performed as a matter of custom and tradition long after their original purpose and object have been forgotten&equo;. 
 Eliot's stone images which &bquo;receive/ The supplication of a dead man's hand&equo; epitomize the dying embers of rites reduced to meaninglessness. 
 Such ritual brings no hope, and it diverts to barrenness emotions which might otherwise have been fruitful. 
 Is it like this 
 In death's other kingdom 
 Waking alone 
 At the hour when we are 
 Trembling with tenderness 
 Lips that would kiss 
 Form prayers to broken stone. 
 Again sex and religion combine through anthropological images invested with pain. 
 &bquo;Art and religion&equo;, Harrison had stated, &bquo;alike spring from unsatisfied desire.&equo; 
 The poem concerns degradation of language and ritual, failings of word and Word. 
 Eliot's witty 1918 truncation of an Arnoldian phrase prefigures the Hollow Men's predicament; Clive Bell, &bquo;lingering between two worlds, one dead&equo;, has the vice of inane mediocrity, incapable of &bquo;icy inviolability, or violent fury&equo;. 
 His being &bquo;the Matthew Arnold of his time&equo; again connects, through the scarecrow image, with the Hollow Men who, like so many of Eliot's literary adversaries, are afflicted with a stuffed language, emptily &bquo;poetic&equo;, the degradation of great poetry &mdash; 
 Leaning together 
 Headpiece filled with straw. 
 Alas! 
 After the starkly factual &bquo;Headpiece filled with straw&equo; comes that most absurdly poetic word of all, indicating the speaker's weakness. 
 Such  childish poeticizing is reinforced, in directing us to the level of the infant, by the &bquo; penny for the Old Guy &equo; epigraph, by the dressing up as a scarecrow, and by the nursery rhyme, &bquo;Twinkle twinkle little star&equo;, which inescapably underlies the line &bquo;Under the twinkle of a fading star&equo;. 
 This use of nursery rhyme looks back to The Waste Land  with its &bquo;London Bridge is falling down falling down falling down&equo; and anticipates another explicit nursery rhyme which, in slightly distorted form, opens section V of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;. 
 Other forms of words instilled into the young are also present. 
 The Lord's Prayer is quoted in the repeated fragment &bquo; For Thine is the Kingdom &equo; but the earlier uses of the word kingdom, particularly when it has a capital &bquo;K&equo;, must already have prompted questions about allusion to this fundamental Christian rite, and about how it relates to those &bquo;prayers to broken stone&equo;. 
 It is hard to avoid thinking that the hope of &bquo;Thy Kingdom come&equo; finds its opposite in 
 Let me be no nearer 
 In death's dream kingdom 
 which becomes an anti-Lord's Prayer, addressed to an unnamed hearer who may be the god of a universe of barrenness and death. 
 &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, not &bquo;The Hippopotamus&equo;, is Eliot's most blasphemous poem. 
 Ideas of childishness, linguistic degeneration, and confusion support the central theme of the degradation of essential ritual. 
 The barely glimpsed possibility of Christian hope plunges to crazy childishness. 
 Here we go round the prickly pear 
 Prickly pear prickly pear 
 Here we go round the prickly pear 
 At five o'clock in the morning. 
 &bquo;Ritual,&equo; Eliot wrote in 1923, &bquo;consisting of a set of repeated movements, is essentially a dance.&equo; 
 He called The Sacred Dance  &bquo;an excellent study of primitive religious dances&equo;, and read how these were performed round sacred trees, but also &bquo;how often with the decay of old faiths the serious rites and pageants&hellip; have degenerated into the sports of children&equo;. 
 It was ten years since Eliot had been  interested in Ecstasy and Dance Hypnosis among the American Indians , and had read in King about the lively &bquo;moonlight dances&equo; of Bushmen. 
 These would resurface, bereft of fun, in the childish dance of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, as later, much more lightly in the Jellicle Cats' &bquo;Reserving their terpsichorean powers/ To dance by the light of the Jellicle Moon.&equo; 
 Though anthropological theories of religious degeneration were becoming outdated, Eliot was familiar with the version propounded by, for instance, Andrew Lang in his Making of Religion . 
 Tylor, about whose theories Eliot had been sceptical, was particularly strong on connecting the mental processes of savages with those of children, connections emphasized by Cornford, Frazer, Oesterley, Webb, Wundt, and others. 
 Cornford's book on some of the greatest Greek drama had as its frontispiece a Punch and Judy show. 
 Eliot was fascinated by the idea which Cornford had put forward &bquo;in &bquo;The Origin of Attic Comedy&equo;, &lsqb;that&rsqb; this &lsqb;medicine-man&rsqb; Doctor may be identical with the Doctor who is called in to assist Punch after he has been thrown by his horse'. 
 Though primitive man may be something of a mystic, the distant voices and fading star in Eliot's poem show no &bquo;prelogical mentality&equo; from a golden age of childlike innocence. 
 The distant fading signals a run-down age of degenerate belief. 
 That it had paradisal origins is a simplistic assumption. 
 His criticism of Oesterley's work makes it clear that for Eliot a ritual's origins may be as meaningless as is its present form. 
 He attacks Oesterley for falling into &bquo;the common trap of interpretation&equo; by formulating intelligible reasons for the dancing of a primitive. 
 Eliot asserts that it is perfectly possible to claim &bquo;that primitive man acted in a certain way and then found a reason for it&equo;. 
 The last section of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; in particular places its rituals in a crazy emptiness. 
 The verve of the nursery rhyme spins us round in a sinister way, since it is disturbing to see the familiar &bquo;mulberry bush&equo; of the children's rhyme replaced with the arid &bquo;prickly pear&equo;, making the rhyme like some distorted survival of a primitive chant. 
 Eliot's substitution makes this seem an infertility dance. 
 As an American plant, &bquo;prickly pear&equo; also connects with his own childhood in a society whose religious values seemed atrophied.  
 Section V's voices are the most complex. 
 First comes the choral nursery rhyme, linked typographically with the italicized passages placed against the right-hand margin to differentiate them from the rest of the text. 
 These appear to be parts of the Lord's Prayer, but are confused by the addition of the complaint in the same typographical form, &bquo; Life is very long' , appropriately enough from the more primitive world of An Outcast of the Islands . 
 A third voice, represented by normal type and placed in the conventional part of the page, is itself like another ritual, a fact emphasized by the incantatory effect of semantic and lexical patterning in the repeated, only slightly varied form, 
 Between the a  
 And the b  
 Between the c  
 And the d  
 Falls the Shadow 
 This tripartite distinction, easy to uphold on the grounds of typography, is complicated, however, by the fact that fragments of the italicized Lord's Prayer passage find themselves brought in from the right-hand margin to form part of the body of the text when, further truncated, they make up the liturgical stutter of 
 For Thine is 
 Life is 
 For Thine is the 
 before a final all-embracing italicized section, looking back in its typography, placing, and, most importantly, its rhythm, recalls the opening nursery rhyme chorus, but gives it a universal voice which seems to include all that we have heard before in what is now a ritual chant ending with an appropriately childlike sound, 
 This is the way the world ends 
 This is the way the world ends 
 This is the way the world ends 
 Not with a bang but a whimper. 
 This combination of various voices, including the choric, makes the fifth section distinctly dramatic in its fragmentation, and, clearly deriving from the techniques employed in The Waste Land , also paves the way for the fragmentary drama of Sweeney Agonistes . 
 The final complexities and confusions of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; are deliberate. 
  Eliot's preoccupations with the &bquo;historical sense&equo; and cultural transmission grew from his own upbringing, but the particular stress on language was an important theme in the anthropology he read. 
 Language preserved a culture's essential social values. 
 Mallarm&eacute;'s line which Eliot quoted in 1926, discussing &bquo; l'hallucin&eacute; &equo; and &bquo;un &eacute;l&eacute;ment d'incantation &equo; in poetry, &bquo;Donner un sens plus pur aux mots de la tribu&equo;, was reinforced by those anthropologists who found that the fundamental mentality of the tribesmen they studied &bquo;no doubt&hellip; is transmitted socially by means of language and concepts without which it could not be exercised. 
 It also implies work which has been previously accomplished, an inheritance handed down from one generation to another.&equo; 
 In &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; we see the corruption of such an inheritance. 
 Shockingly juxtaposed with an apparently childish survival of a primitive chant, the Lord's Prayer grows increasingly fragmented, corruptly incorporating the complaint, &bquo;Life is very long&equo;, while being broken up and having its utterance prevented by &bquo;the Shadow&equo; in the long passages which are partly like a new ritual, usurping the old, and partly like a long gloss which dominates the original text of the prayer. 
 Vital patterns become distorted and lost in the sort of fragmentation and change with which Eliot's textual studies in a battery of languages and his reading of works like Cornford's had made him particularly familiar. 
 The mixture of religious vocabulary with philosophical &bquo;idea/ reality&equo;, and sexual vocabulary (&bquo;desire/ spasm&equo;) hopelessly rearrange the elements discovered at the roots of religion. 
 Such confusions may draw, too, on Eliot's fears about the barrenness of his own life and about losing his own creativity. 
 Middleton Murry had stated that Eliot would never pass beyond &bquo;the point where discrepancy ceases between intention and achievement&equo;. 
 The poem's &bquo;Shadow&equo;, though, is made widely impersonal. 
 It falls to stifle creative enterprise, with the result that all that remain are dying echoes 
 For Thine is 
 Life is 
 For Thine is the 
 fading away to the final &bquo; whimper &equo;. 
 These echoes are the verbal  equivalent of degenerating survivals of primitive rituals whose juxtaposition with Christian liturgy recalls The Waste Land  and Eliot's earlier interest in a possible universality of certain forms. 
 The anthropological scholars' emphasis on &bquo;Survival in Culture, is paralleled by one of the dominant motifs of romantic poetry: the fading, echoing voice. 
 So Wordsworthian romanticism gives way to Tennyson's &bquo;And answer, echoes, answer, dying, dying, dying&equo; and the Arnoldian &bquo;infinitely distant land, &lsqb;from which&rsqb; / Come airs, and floating echoes&equo; (&bquo;The Buried Life&equo;). 
 Whether or not we accept Eliot's note that the title of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; draws on both Kipling's &bquo;The Broken Men&equo; and Morris's &bquo;The Hollow Land&equo;, there is little doubt that this &bquo;valley of dying stars&equo; is not so far from the landscapes of Victorian romanticism. 
 As if to confirm this, Eliot's earlier draft of section II used the phrase &bquo;waking echo&equo;. 
 In its dying echoes of both phrases and rituals, &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; again shows romanticism and anthropology going hand in hand. 
 The confusion in the world of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; is furthered by a sense of confused identity. 
 Words come to the reader with little traditional sense of an author. 
 The use of nursery rhyme, prayer, and the splitting of the poem in section V, confirm this &bquo;authorlessness,, and the one time when the first person singular is employed, in section II, the reader senses a fear localized in the images used, more than in their beholder. 
 There are, of course, precise images employed and identifiable resonances. 
 &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; is about failures in creation, as well as about &bquo;the way the world ends&equo;. 
 So the line, &bquo;Shape without form, shade without colour&equo;, is reminiscent of the essential beginning when &bquo;the earth was without form, and void,&equo; but what follows is not a creation and a bringing of light, but only an impotence, &bquo;Paralysed force, gesture without motion&equo;, bringing a twilight. 
 Memories of Genesis, chapter 1 are identifiable here. 
 Elsewhere, though, Eliot deliberately pruned away details so as to universalize his imagery. 
 The final version omits the &bquo;Tartar horsemen&equo; who were, Perry taught him, a degenerate form of a higher civilization; but their &bquo;furious force&equo; makes them inappropriate company for those who will on no account be remembered as &bquo;lost/  Violent souls&equo;. 
 Beyond a certain stage it becomes pointless to indicate what went into the landscape of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;. 
 Suffice it to say that the desert landscape was no doubt encouraged by his enthusiasm in 1922 and 1923 for the work of an author whom he placed with James and Conrad &mdash; C. M. Doughty, whose &bquo;great work Travels in Arabia Deserta &equo; he recommended, mentioning also that a good essay on Doughty's prose, including quotations from it, was contained in Middleton Murry's recent book Countries of the Mind . 
 The landscape of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; is very much a country of the mind, drawing on many of the ideas found in the pages of the anthropologists whom he catalogued as folklore experts in 1924. 
 Almost any of these writers might have supplied, for instance, details of the importance of the wind in primitive supernatural beliefs, but the idea of &bquo;the wind's singing&equo; is also a prime romantic conceit, as seen in the &bquo;gentle breeze&equo; which wafts through The Prelude , or in the notion of the Aeolian harp. 
 The latter occurs as a trick used to fool the natives in Stevenson's &bquo;The Beach of Fales&aacute;&equo;, where &bquo;the sound of singing in the wind&equo; caused by an Aeolian harp is mistaken for spirit voices near a mock-temple of imitation gods, &bquo;idols or scarecrows, or what not&equo;. 
 The &bquo;voices&hellip; in the wind's singing&equo; and the &bquo;dried voices&hellip; quiet and meaningless / As wind in dry grass&equo; are again transformations of romanticism linked with anthropology. 
 Other themes, too, such as boredom, the wish to present poetry in an &bquo;authorless&equo; way, often through impersonal ritual, and a concern with the degeneration of culture, grew from The Waste Land  and are shared with Sweeney Agonistes . 
 &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; develops simpler diction. 
 The move to the stage was a logical one for Eliot, so many of whose poems have dramatic qualities. 
 In 1920, considering &bquo;the impotence of contemporary drama&equo;, he had concluded that &bquo;The natural evolution, for us, would be to proceed in the direction indicated by Browning; to distil the dramatic essences, if we can, and infuse them into some other liquor.&equo; 
 This The Waste Land  did, but when Eliot writes elsewhere that any modern poet who applied himself to the drama would be an extremely conscious poet, using  the historical imagination, it is clear that around the time of The Waste Land  he was also considering writing plays. 
 If Le Sacre du Printemps  was important for the poem, significantly in 1924 he was thinking of a new &bquo;strict form&equo; of drama, akin to the Russian Ballet. 
 His &bquo;Fragments of an Aristophanic Melodrama&equo; began as The Waste Land  reached conclusion. 
 Around 1920 when Eliot, with anthropological ideas in the forefront of his mind, had attacked Gilbert Murray's translations of Euripides, Pound tried to persuade him to translate Aeschylus' Agamemnon , but Eliot &bquo;sat on it for eight months or some longer period&equo;. 
 Pound then made his own attempt, &bquo;having the watchman talk nigger&equo;, and the project was still on the go in December 1921. 
 In early 1922 Eliot told Pound that he was trying to read Aristophanes, apparently on Pound's recommendation. 
 Pound replied that Aristophanes might be depressing, and that to raise the heavy phallus to its desired height Dixie folk melodies might be more effective. 
 This reveals a mutual awareness of theories of the origin of Attic comedy in fertility ritual. 
 It also shows Pound relating such ritual (and Greek drama) to jazz. 
 He was not the first to do this. 
 Popular American poetry of the period encouraged not only &bquo;the coming together of East and West&equo;, but also Vachel Lindsay's attempts &bquo;to carry&hellip; vaudeville form back towards the old Greek precedent of the half-chanted lyric&equo;. 
 Harriet Monroe looked to &bquo;the wonderful song-dances of the Hopis and other of our aboriginal tribes&equo; to &bquo;revitalize&equo; literature. 
 One of the best known of Lindsay's pieces of &bquo;Higher Vaudeville&equo; was &bquo;The Congo&equo;, which linked savage chants and jazz rhythms in a rather bathetically facile way that just misses being electrifying. 
 BOOM, steal the pygmies, 
 BOOM, kill the Arabs, 
 BOOM, kill the white men, 
 HOO, HOO, HOO. 
 Listen to the yell of Leopold's ghost 
 Burning in Hell for his hand-maimed host. 
 Hear how the demons chuckle and yell 
 Cutting his hands off, down in Hell. 
 Though Eliot did not like Lindsay's work, he did think that it might have paved the way for better things. 
 One of these, surely, is Sweeney Agonistes  where the worlds of jazz, primitive ritual, and Greek drama again combine in an anthropological perspective. 
 If &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; presents the degeneration of ritual, then Sweeney Agonistes  while remaining aware of the decline attempts a reconstruction, but that reconstruction, like The Waste Land , sees humanity as trapped in the torturing cycle of sexual fertility. 
 According to Moody, this play was in draft form by April 1923. 
 But Eliot continued to work on it, and it was not published until 1926&ndash;7. 
 This period is, if we except the years at Harvard, the period in which his interest in anthropology was strongest. 
 &bquo;The Beating of a Drum&equo;, whose very title relates to Eliot's ideas in Sweeney Agonistes , appeared in October 1923, listing Cornford and a host of anthropological writers. 
 Earlier that year, at around the time of the drafting of the play, Eliot had invited Jane Harrison to contribute to the Criterion . 
 In 1924 he was describing Lewis's anthropologically influenced &bquo;Mr Zagreus and the Split-Man&equo; as &bquo;a masterpiece&equo;; the following year Eliot and Lewis discussed Perry and Harrison. 
 In August 1923 Eliot had written to Alfred Kreymborg (who published &bquo;Portrait of a Lady&equo; in 1915), responding enthusiastically to Kreymborg's Puppet Plays , and asking for advice on manufacturing of puppets. 
 He told Kreymborg that he was planning puppet plays of his own. 
 Already we have seen Eliot's interest in the connection between the medicine men and Punch and Judy, as suggested by Cornford in The Origin of Attic Comedy . 
 Eliot's work was never performed by puppets, but Cornford's influence remained central, and a 1933 letter shows that other ideas expressed in &bquo;The Beating of a Drum&equo;  played their part in Eliot's concept of his play. 
 In &bquo;Sweeney Agonistes&equo; the action should be stylized as in the Noh drama &mdash; see Ezra Pound's book and Yeats' preface and notes to &bquo;The Hawk's Well.&equo; 
 Characters ought  to wear masks; the ones wearing old masks ought to give the impression of being young persons (as actors) and vice versa. 
 Diction should not have too much expression. 
 I had intended the whole play to be accompanied by light drum taps to accentuate the beats (esp. 
 the chorus, which ought to have a noise like a street drill). 
 The characters should be in a shabby flat, seated at a refectory table, facing the audience; Sweeney in the middle with a chafing dish, scrambling eggs. 
 (See &bquo;you see this egg.&equo;) 
 (See also F. M. Cornford: &bquo;Origins of Attic Comedy&equo;, which is import ant to read before you do the play) 
 Several points are significant about this passage. 
 First, Eliot's stress on a ritualistic presentation. 
 He was familiar with Pound's writing on Japanese drama, and had been impressed by the first performance of At the Hawk's Well  when he had seen a well-known Japanese dancer take the role of the hawk. 
 Moreover, he had emphasized to Kreymborg his wish to preordain every move and gesture and grouping. 
 Such a notion of &bquo;preordaining&equo; strongly suggests Jane Harrison's concept of the dromenon  &mdash; the rite pre-done  and re-done . 
 The drum taps seek to restore the drum whose loss in modern drama is stated at the end of &bquo;The Beating of a Drum&equo;, while the striking suggestion that the choral passages &bquo;to have a noise like a street drill&equo; corresponds to Eliot's praise of Le Sacre du Printemps  for its uniting the noises of primitive and metropolitan life. 
 Like The Waste Land , Sweeney Agonistes  explicitly unites the savage and the city. 
 Events in a modern flat follow the schema  according to which Cornford analyses Aristophanic comedy, relating it to fertility ritual. 
 Comford's analysis divided the plays initially into two sections. 
 Of these two pads, the first normally consists of the Prologue , or exposition scenes; the Entrance of the Chorus ( Parodos ): and what is now generally called the Agon , a fierce &bquo;contest&equo; between the representatives of two parties or principles, which are in effect the hero and villain of the whole piece. 
 The other main part of the plays was the Parabasis , normally split  into two parts and accompanied by one or more Scenes  and a Chorikon , before a finale often involving a feast or rejuvenation, and leading to a final Exodos . 
 As well as outlining this structure in the body of his text, Cornford supplied summary outlines of the plays in a &bquo;Synopsis of the Extant Plays&equo;. 
 The Birds , for instance, follows the pattern 
 PROLOGUE 
 PARODOS 
 AGON 
 PARABASIS 
 SCENE 
 PARABASIS II 
 Two Messenger announcements 
 CHORIKON 
 CHORIKON 
 SCENE 
 Another messenger announcement 
 EXODOS 
 Cornford's synopses emphasize such ritual elements as a &bquo;FIGHT&equo;, &bquo;COOKING&equo;, leading to a revival of life, the &bquo;FEAST&equo; and the &bquo;SACRIFICE&equo;, and, as in The Birds , the &bquo;Invocation of the Muse&equo;. 
 Certain parts of the play, frequently the Parabasis , would contain material relating to contemporary events, originally theological, but later political. 
 Interruptions of the action by figures of the Alazon  (Impostor) type, marked &bquo;AL.&equo; 
 by Cornford, were also common. 
 Those buffoon figures (related by Cornford to incidents in Punch and Judy plays) were often figures from contemporary life who are eventually driven from the stage. 
 Eliot's pencilled plan for Sweeney Agonistes  follows remarkably closely the format of Cornford's &bquo;Synopses.&equo; 
 The numbers on the left are proposed numbers of lines.   
 Eliot is here making use of the most modern anthropologically based classical scholarship in order to construct his own primitive play. 
 The artist is being at once more primitive  as well as more civilized, than his contemporaries. 
 The figure written to the right of &bquo; Parabasis II &equo; appears to be &bquo;P. 124&equo;. 
 In The Origin of Attic Comedy , page 124 is the beginning of the section entitled &bquo;The Second Part of the Parabasis&equo;. 
 As the rite is planned, the London bank clerk adds up correctly the figures in the left-hand column. 
 One of Cornford's most important implications for Eliot was his redefinition of what &bquo;comedy&equo; meant in terms of Greek and more primitive drama. 
 The concluding chapter of his Origin  was entitled &bquo;Comedy and Tragedy&equo;, and stressed &bquo;the derivation of Comedy and Tragedy from similar ritual performances&equo;, differing only &bquo;as emphasis were thrown on the conflict and death of the hero, or on the joyful resurrection and marriage that followed&equo;. 
 For Eliot in 1923 all  primitive or savage art contained comic and tragic elements, comedy and tragedy being not just late but maybe also &bquo;impermanent intellectual abstractions&equo;. 
 Eliot stressed that his own opinion was that once these abstractions had developed in the course of several generations within a civilization they required either renewal or else replacement. 
 A concern to return to such primitive roots no doubt explains why in his draft synopsis he originally used the word &bquo;Melocomic&equo; of what would later become his &bquo;Fragments of an Aristophanic Melodrama&equo;. 
 Melodrama, perched on the uneasy edge between tragedy and the horribly grotesque, points also to the music hall, where Eliot had found those last vestiges of English myth. 
 Now, through anthropology, he renewed them. 
 Eliot's synopsis included the murder of Mrs Porter. 
 Cornford's &bquo; Resurrection Motive &equo; showed that the aspect of physical violence in Old Comedy extended beyond &bquo;horseplay&equo; to the killing of a principal adversary, sometimes a villain. 
 Yet sometimes, as in the English Mummers' Play, &bquo;it is the representative of the good principle that is killed by the evil, and afterwards brought back to life&equo;. 
 It is not hard to fit Mrs Porter's death and resurrection into Cornford's schemes. 
 Nor is the final planned dispensation of eggs out of place in a &bquo;basic ritual scheme in which &bquo;the cooking and eating of a Feast&equo; are &bquo;canonical&equo;, part of a &bquo;sacramental meal&hellip; through which the God passes to his resurrection&equo;. 
 In the first London stage production, Sweeney pursued Doris with a razor, and her screams were heard offstage. 
 Eliot, who invited his friends to this performance, who attended some of the rehearsals, and who expressed his full confidence in the director Rupert Doone, continued to follow in his text the original impetus which Cornford had given him. 
 Eliot's irony produced 
 SWEENEY. 
 I'll be the cannibal. 
 DORIS. 
 I'll be the missionary. 
 I'll convert you! 
 SWEENEY. 
 I'll convert you ! 
 Into a stew. 
 A nice little, white little, missionary stew. 
 I have already cited in relation to &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; Cornford's idea of the degeneration of ritual into debased formats. 
 Concerning masks in the drama, he writes how at first the characters who wore them took part in &bquo;A certain unvarying ritual action,&hellip; a religious mystery&equo; which became &bquo;grotesque&equo;. 
 All Eliot's characters in Sweeney Agonistes  are grotesque. 
 Their actions are part of his reconstruction and interpretation of a once potent ritual, part of his own &bquo; Vitalizing of the Classics &equo;. 
 Yet the question arises whether the ritual performed in the London flat has any validity. 
 Can the fundamentally religious ritual be the new foundation of a piece of modern art, to be evaluated according to purely aesthetic criteria? 
 Such questions preoccupied Eliot at the time. 
 He wondered if art could continue to exist or be justified if it left behind its primitive purposes with the result that aesthetic objects became direct  objects of attention. 
 Sweeney Agonistes , as much as the later prose of Arnold, is an attempt to come to terms with this situation and to react against it. 
 Eliot's solution was to attempt to revive what anthropology had revealed to him as the very oldest form of ritual and express it through the phenomena of stylized contemporary life, uniting the savage and the city. 
 That he thought this possible is suggested by his comments on Frazer whom he saw not as an investigator of a remote and hence irrelevant past, but as someone whose researches are like Freud's, of apparently universal application, applying not to a particular historical period but to &bquo;the soul&equo;. 
 Frazer, through setting out to study an essential ritual of the primitive dead, had done what Eliot hoped modern literature, including Sweeney Agonistes  would do. 
 He had become a &bquo;vitalizing&equo; force. 
 Compared with Freud's, Frazer's work was &bquo;of perhaps greater permanence,, because for Eliot it was neither a collection of data nor a theory. 
 The absence of speculation is a conscious and deliberate scrupulousness, a positive point of view. 
 And it is just that: a point of view, a vision, put forward through a fine prose style, that gives the work of Frazer a position above that of other scholars of equal erudition and perhaps greater ingenuity, and which gives him an inevitable and growing influence over the contemporary mind.  
 Along with other scholars Frazer had produced a new view of classical studies which would, in Eliot's view, have a deep effect on future literature. 
 Eliot had long been accumulating the anthropological knowledge which would affect the literature of his own future. 
 As we have seen, it was not just the anthropology which he read at the time of composition which played its part in the great works of the early 1920s. 
 In 1926, for instance, he returned to Westermarck (whom he had read eleven years before) attacking his ideas that the origin and development of the ideas of good and evil were caused merely by economic, genetic, and hygienic factors. 
 Yet if Eliot continued to remember his anthropological reading, this does not mean that his view of it remained unchanged. 
 In 1913 he had attacked Frazer for attempting to explain the savage using the ideas of modern life, offering interpretation rather than fact. 
 In 1924, though, Eliot has come to perceive The Golden Bough  as a &bquo;stupendous compendium of human superstition and folly&equo;, seeing in it increasingly less &bquo;interpretation&equo;, so that it has become &bquo;a statement of fact&equo; which is not involved in the maintenance or fall of any theory of Frazer's. 
 Yet to present the deeds of savages as &bquo;folly&equo; is a crucial act of theoretical interpretation which undermines all claims to be presenting mere &bquo;fact&equo;. 
 Eliot in rereading Frazer omits to apply his own frequently used &bquo;difference between an interpretation and a fact&equo;; his blindness to the Frazerian interpretation which equates savage fact with folly comes about surely because Eliot himself sees the two as one. 
 He was quite prepared to argue the case that savage practices might be integral to a culture: &bquo;We may not like the notion of cannibalism or head-hunting, but that it formed part of a distinct and tenable form of culture in Melanesia is indisputable.&equo; 
 But this does not mean that he is advocating head-hunting. 
 Here, as more explicitly in &bquo;Marie Lloyd&equo;, he uses the word &bquo;culture&equo; in an anthropological sense which stresses its general inclusiveness. 
 It would be absurd for Eliot to advocate that head-hunting would reinvigorate British society, just as it is absurdly funny to listen to the description of Sweeney's &bquo;missionary stew&equo;. 
 Yet when such an absurdity threatens to become literal, its &bquo;folly&equo; becomes horrific. 
 Compelled to re-enact  rituals which appear only as stupid, trapped within the cyclic world of &bquo; the love of created beings &equo;, Eliot's characters lead &bquo;preord&equo; lives of deep horror. 
 A passage from Notes Towards the Definition of Culture , relying on ideas from 1913, hints how the poet was using his anthropological reading when discussing in an anthropological context the difference between imaginative understanding and lived experience. 
 Understanding involves an area more extensive than that of which one can be conscious; one cannot be outside and inside at the same time&hellip; 
 The man who, in order to understand the inner world of a cannibal tribe, has partaken of the practice of cannibalism, has probably gone too far: he can never quite be one of his own folk again. 
 * * Joseph Conrad's Heart of Darkness  gives a hint of something similar. 
 Nowhere in Eliot's anthropological reading had he come across an example of a student of primitive civilization who had himself turned cannibal. 
 But his mind naturally associates anthropology with artistic works dealing with primitive life, since these are the ultimate attempts at &bquo;imaginative understanding&equo;. 
 Heart of Darkness  mattered not for giving Eliot the anthropological reader a better idea of how primitive society worked, but for showing Eliot the poet that the life of the savage and that of the modern urban clerk intersected on the deepest level, the level of &bquo;The Horror&equo; which was, essentially for him, the realization of evil within man. 
 The work of art was especially fitted to reveal this, since its audience may both criticize, yet at the same time be involved in, its enactment. 
 The ritual nature of Sweeney Agonistes  emphasizes and encourages the notion of participation in a ritual process, through its use of those aspects of culture in which the people of the period participated most: jazz, music-hall songs, melodrama. 
 Eliot's use of primitive ritual to reveal the horror of Sweeney's existence relates to his connection of Conrad and James as writers who involve their audience in the apprehension of deepseated levels of evil. 
 The great affair not to relate, but to make the reader supply, cooperate . 
 Preface to Turn of Screw . 
 How to suggest Evil. 
 This not weakness. 
 I speak of T. of S. and H. of D. together because both attempt to present Evil&hellip; 
 Evil is rare, bad is common&hellip; 
 Real Evil is to Bad just as Saintliness and Heroism to Decent Behaviour. 
 Nothing  frightful in Kudz participating in native rites &mdash; or in Miles using vile language to schoolboys. 
 These notes date from 1932&ndash;3, but they make explicit what is implicit in the use of primitivism in Sweeney Agonistes . 
 Eliot's play aimed to penetrate beyond the &bquo;frightful&equo; to a deeper sense of universal evil &mdash; &bquo; Any  man might do a girl in&equo; (my italics). 
 This is manifested through the unity of supposedly civilized life and the most elementary barbarity on a level which appears to be that of the basic &bquo;need&equo; which Eliot had accused the anthropologists of ignoring. 
 This need seems caused partly by Original Sin closely bound up with sexuality. 
 Eliot was tormented, like Orestes. 
 Locked in a marriage with a wife who showed increasing signs of mental instability and whose health constantly brought her to the point of death, exhausted in his work and fearing for his own life and sanity, Eliot's view of relations between the sexes is at its bleakest, as is shown not least in the epigraphs, which were originally further universalized by including (in the draft synopsis), 
 Casey Jones was a fireman's name; 
 In the red light district he won his fame. 
 OLD BALLAD. 
 In Sweeney Agonistes  it is not mere action which matters. 
 As the fragments stand, Doris is not actually murdered. 
 What matters is the effect of basic instinct which Eliot had earlier presented as the result of actual murder in a simpler urban context when he described in &bquo;Eeldrop and Appleplex&equo; the living death experienced by a man who has murdered his mistress. 
 Such a man is already living in a different world. 
 He has &bquo;crossed the frontier&equo;. 
 In Sweeney Agonistes , the crossing of the frontier is more explicit. 
 Not only is it a move into a realm where the distinction between life and death seems, as in &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, to have broken down, it is also a crossing to the world of the &bquo;cannibal isle&equo; which is revealed as only another version of the life left behind, and where the realization that &bquo; Life is very long &equo; is not escaped from, but reinforced. 
 That phrase from An Outcast of the Islands  is a reminder that Heart of Darkness  was not the only Conrad novel in Eliot's mind during this period. 
 Willems in Conrad's story, is another one of the  clerks whose lives so fascinated Eliot. 
 &bquo;A confidential clerk&equo; in Macassar, Willems finds his marriage going wrong and himself, obsessed with an Arab woman with whom he flies to a remote tropical island, becoming a savage. 
 In its &bquo;threatening twilight&equo; over a &bquo;dead land&equo;, this work of fiction meshed with Eliot's anthropological reading to provide the means of expression for his personal agony in &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, and in The Waste Land . 
 Few men other than Eliot have read through the lengthy catalogues of ritual in Frazer's volumes and found those volumes to be &bquo;throbbing at a higher rate of vibration with the agony of spiritual life&equo;. 
 Much of this agony Eliot imported from his own sufferings, though, as usual, these are transmuted through his reading. 
 The agony of An Outcast of the Islands  is heightened by several occasions when the meeting of eyes between those who have been in love is one of terrifying intensity. 
 Eyes &bquo;moving no more than the eyes of a corpse&hellip; follow me like a pair of jailers&hellip; 
 They are big, menacing &mdash; and empty. 
 The eyes of a savage&hellip; 
 &equo; At the same time as this Conrad work was in his head, Eliot received anthropological proof that &bquo; Life is very long &equo; for &bquo;civilized&equo; people and for &bquo;savages&equo; alike in an age of degeneration, and that if the savage revealed a level of horror hidden in city life, then similarly civilized man might corrupt the savage. 
 A passage from Eliot's 1923 &bquo;London Letter&equo; in appreciation of Marie Lloyd, shows several of the ideas discussed above: fatal degeneration of the necessary participation in cultural actions, the inanity of modern life, and the uniting of city and savage. 
 Eliot describes how working men who went to the music hall to see Marie Lloyd and who joined in the chorus were performing part of the business of acting, collaborating with the artist in a manner essential in all art, most obviously (for Eliot) in dramatic art. 
 The cinema lulls such working men into an apathy similar to that shown towards art by the bourgeoisie and upper classes, Eliot argues. 
 Then, from discussing modern urban life, Eliot makes a remarkable leap. 
 In a most interesting essay in the recent volume of Essays on the Depopulation of Melanesia the great psychologist W. H. R. Rivers adduces evidence which has led him to believe that the natives of that unfortunate archipelago are dying out principally for the reason that the &bquo;Civilization&equo; forced  upon them has deprived them of all interest in life. 
 They are dying from pure boredom. 
 Eliot goes on to envisage a future in which applied science replaces each theatre by a hundred cinemas, each musical instrument by one hundred gramophones, each horse by one hundred cheap motor cars, with the result that the population of the whole civilized world speedily follows the lot of the Melanesians. 
 The relationship between this passage and the &bquo;There's no telephones&equo; passage of &bquo;Fragment of an Agon&equo; is clear, and has often been indicated. 
 Though Rivers gave some slight encouragement to Eliot in suggesting that even in our own society, religious changes have unforeseen and far-reaching effects parallel to those caused by the abolition of head-hunting in Melanesia, Eliot's linking of &bquo;cannibal isle&equo; and that &bquo;slick place&equo; London goes directly against the main thrust of the book which stresses &bquo;the almost immeasurable difference between Melanesian and European cultures, and the sharpness of the line which still divides them where they come in contact&equo;. 
 Fictional stressing of deep connections between primitive and developed man, as well as the connections between primitive ritual and modern dramatic and religious practice stressed by Cornford, Harrison, Frazer, and the others encouraged Eliot to interpret the Rivers book in a way which let him see in it a reflection of his personal crisis. 
 In the Marie Lloyd piece there are hints at Eliot's childhood linking of &bquo;civilized and uninteresting&equo;, as he laments the destruction of primitive South Sea life. 
 Certainly the author of &bquo;The Man Who Was King&equo; for whom savages were interesting, if rather silly, became the reader of the romantically tinged Frazer, but essentially Eliot's view of &bquo;civilization&equo; went deeper than gramophones. 
 There was, though, a sometimes subliminally romantic tinge to much of the anthropology Eliot read, not least in Frazer. 
 The criticism of anthropology, from L&eacute;vy-Bruhl's attack on the nineteenth century to L&eacute;vi-Strauss's critique of L&eacute;vy-Bruhl, followed by Derrida's deconstructions of L&eacute;vi-Strauss, has largely been an expulsion of perceived romanticism.  
 Sweeney Agonistes  also recalls Eliot's childhood when he wrote of the &bquo;South Pacific&equo;. 
 Eliot at twenty-one recalled reading The Ebb-Tide . 
 The theme of the importation to the South Seas of disease and decadence which opens Stevenson's novel would be the theme of Essays on the Depopulation of Melanesia . 
 In The Ebb-Tide , also, the exiled American and two Englishmen, one of whom is a &bquo;London clerk&equo;, initially rot on the beach with &bquo;memoirs of the music-hall&equo;. 
 Later, confronted with the ambiguously dominating Attwater who kings it over the natives on his atoll, one of them &bquo;broke into a piece of the chorus of a comic song which he must have heard twenty years before in London: meaningless gibberish that, in that hour and place&equo;, seemed hateful as a blasphemy: &bquo;Hikey, pikey, crikey, fikey, chillinga &mdash; wallaba dory.&equo; 
 Other music-hall songs punctuate the text. 
 The action takes place thousands of miles from &bquo;the perennial roar of London&equo;, but the reader remains very much aware of London and the civilization it stands for as moral standards crumble; &bquo;savage&equo; and &bquo;white man&equo; become confused until the conduct of the whites, intent on mutual destruction, seems worse than that of &bquo;these poor souls &mdash; and even Sally Day, the child of cannibals, in all likelihood a cannibal himself &mdash; so faithful to what they knew of good&equo;. 
 At one stage the story of the white man transported miraculously from Paumotuan beach to central London brings the mo worlds immediately together. 
 &bquo;At first I was dazzled, and covered my eyes, and there didn't seem the smallest change; the roar of the Strand and the roar of the reef were like the same: hark to it now, and you can near the cabs and buses rolling and the streets resound.&equo; 
 The idea of the traffic as waves is a traditional romantic conceit, uniting elemental nature and man-made metropolis. 
 Eliot's linking of noises from the Steppes with those of the London Underground is an extreme version of this conceit. 
 In the late romanticism of Stevenson's tale of corruption in the South Seas, the islanders are not seen as virtuous noble savages, but certainly appear no worse than the white men who take advantage of them. 
 Stevenson, like Tylor, sees his islanders as childlike. 
 Behind Sweeney Agonistes  lies Rivers, but Eliot's interpretation and use of Rivers owes much to the Stevensonian world of his childhood reading, where white men seek paradise with island  wives arrayed in &bquo;the scarlet flowers of the hibiscus&equo;, only to find too often that they are condemned to a life of soul-destroying boredom where &bquo;Night on the Beach&equo; is followed monotonously by &bquo;Morning on the Beach&equo;. 
 Eliot refocuses his island world for &bquo;the Age of Jazz&equo;, in a piece not entirely dissimilar to, but more bitter than, his earlier vaudeville experiment in &bquo;Suite Clownesque&equo;. 
 SONG BY KLIPSTEIN AND KRUMPACKER 
 SNOW AND SWARTS AS BEFORE 
 My little island girl 
 My little island girl 
 I'm going to stay with you 
 And we won't worry what to do 
 We won't have to catch any trains 
 And we won't go home when it rains 
 We'll gather hibiscus flowers 
 for it won't be minutes but hours 
 for it won't be hours but years 
 And the morning 
 And the evening 
 And noontide 
 And night 
 Morning 
 Evening 
 Noontide 
 Night 
 The emptiness of life reduced to mere sex and death is as awful on the island as in the flat. 
 Rituals of divination in the flat produce a combination of these which mirrors the elements of island life. 
 So Doris and Dusty in the flat read their cards and discover boredom in monotonously cyclical jazz rhythms and rhymes, while on the supposed &bquo;cannibal isle&equo; Doris discovers a similar tedium. 
 SWEENEY. 
 Nothing to see but the palmtrees one way And the sea the other way, Nothing to hear but the sound of the surf. 
 Nothing at all but three things 
 DORIS. 
 What things? 
 SWEENY. 
 Birth, and copulation and death. 
 That's all, that's all, that's all, that's all, Birth, and copulation, and death. 
 The twin emphases on the deaths of islanders and the need to repopulate produced many statistical tables in Rivers's book which stressed that 
 That's all the facts when you come to brass tacks: 
 Birth, and copulation, and death. 
 While the theme of loss of interest in life, linked to Cornford's pointing to the continual presence of phallic songs and rituals in the comedies he studied, combine in the crude punning that ensues. 
 DORIS. 
 I'd be bored. 
 SWEENEY. 
 You'd be bored. 
 Birth, and copulation, and death. 
 DORIS. 
 I'd be bored. 
 SWEENEY. 
 You'd be bored. 
 Eliot deliberately presents his South Sea life in crude terms. 
 Partly this involves his audience in material which seems at first sight the familiar stuff of the music-hall chorus. 
 Partly, though, it shows the degeneration of a world view according to which the conventionally &bquo;romantic&equo; tropics, strangely remote world of the &bquo; breadfruit, banyan, palmleaf &equo; have become a place 
 Where the Gauguin maids 
 In the banyan shades 
 Wear palmleaf drapery 
 Under the bam 
 Under the boo 
 Under the bamboo tree. 
 Clich&eacute; imagery reveals the banality of the vision. 
 Life under the bamboo is just as trite as life in the city where Doris, Klipstein, and Krumpacker exchange their polite, meaningless words. 
 DORIS. 
 You like London, Mr. Klipstein? 
 KRUMPACKER. 
 Do we like London? do we like London! 
 Do we like London!! 
 Eh what Klip? 
 KLIPSTEIN. 
 Say, Miss &mdash; er &mdash; uh &mdash; London's swell. 
 We like London fine. 
 KRUMPACKER. 
 Perfectly slick. 
 Essentially, in the world of &bquo;brass tacks&equo; what connects the kingdom of the bamboo and the city of London are eggs. 
 Sweeney scrambling eggs in his London flat is also the Sweeney of the fertility ceremonies  described by Cornford, as Eliot's conjunction of notes &bquo;(See &bquo;you see this egg&equo;) (See also F. M. Cornford&hellip;)&equo; reminds us. 
 You see this egg 
 You see this egg 
 Well that's life on a crocodile isle. 
 The human egg as centre of fertility is at the heart of Sweeney Agonistes  and of the rites on which it is patterned. 
 Yet the very value of that fertility is questioned. 
 If Eliot seeks to draw on the power of an ancient ritual, he also aims at the horrifying frisson  obtained by re-enacting the ritual with the opposite of its traditional meaning. 
 Speaking of the cinema in the Marie Lloyd piece, he accuses it of being &bquo;rapid-breeding&equo; and reducing its audience to a &bquo;state of amorphous protoplasm&equo;. 
 The generation of life and its source are both here seen as bad. 
 As source of fertility, Doris dislikes the very essence of life just as much as Sweeney finds it tedious to &bquo;drink this booze&equo; and &bquo;have a tune&equo;, 
 DORIS. 
 I don't like eggs; I never liked eggs; And I don't like life on your crocodile isle. 
 Life is where girls are murdered &bquo;with a gallon of lysol in a bath,, and where the tedious business of words only elicits the answer that there is no point to speech. 
 The play's action is zany and at times hilarious, full of mockery and tricks of speech. 
 Like the quatrain poems it is funny at the same time as serious. 
 One of Eliot's great strengths is his continuing sense of humour; even The Waste Land  has Mr Eugenides and the pseudo-gentility of Madame Sosostris's &bquo;dear Mrs. Equitone&equo;. 
 Yet through the sometimes bitter humour of Sweeney Agonistes  the horror is apparent. 
 At the first performance Vivienne was terrified by Sweeney, seeing him as a homicidal madman. 
 Sex in the play is grotesquely comic and horrible at the same time. 
 The age-old idea of the sexual union as a death comes literally true in the impulse to kill which thrusts a man into a new world of horror. 
 The murderous instincts of the sex war lead not to union but to a fragmentation which destroys the ability to comprehend life on any normal level, 
 There wasn't any joint 
 There wasn't any joint 
  after which horror one can only return to the banalities of modern city life which protect the individual from the terror of the deep insight. 
 The movement of Conrad's Marlow back to Brussels and London is the movement back from the realization that death and life are one to the simple considerations of drinking, having a tune, and paying the rent, however much these may be &bquo;nothing to me and nothing to you&equo;. 
 This matches darkly the closing of the gates of vision in &bquo;Burnt Norton&equo; where &bquo;human kind/ Cannot bear very much reality&equo;. 
 What seems to be about to be a tour of London given by &bquo;a real live Britisher, &mdash; 
 Sam of course is at home  in London, 
 And he's promised to show us around. 
 becomes at its most intense moments a journey, through distinctly modern music-hall conventions, to the most savage level of behaviour. 
 London transforms; the &bquo;real live Britisher&equo; seems to know all too much about death. 
 That original title, Wanna Go Home, Baby ?, is casually jazzy, but the baby's essential home is not London but the primitive roots of civilization and, specifically, the womb. 
 Sweeney Agonistes  takes its audience back not simply to what was seen as the childhood, even babyhood of ritual and civilization, but further down the evolutionary ladder to the most primitive level of that &bquo;amorphous protoplasm&equo; which makes up the human egg. 
 And this homecoming is seen as futile, nightmarish. 
 If &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; traces the degeneration of ritual to a final babyish &bquo; whimper &equo;, then Sweeney Agonistes  attempts to reconstruct the most basic rituals only to end in a bang. 
 The play tails off into the cries and inarticulate exclamations where, escaping the situation in which &bquo;I gotta use words&equo; in their normal sense, language becomes a cry of despair and horror as primal as the &bquo; Wah! 
 Wah! 
 Wah! wa-a-ah !&equo; which Oesterley had quoted from Spencer and Gillen's account of aborigines dancing around the destroyed home of a dead man. 
 And perhaps you're alive 
 And perhaps you're dead 
 Hoo ha ha 
 Hoo ha ha 
 Hoo 
 Hoo 
 Hoo 
 KNOCK KNOCK KNOCK 
 KNOCK KNOCK KNOCK 
 KNOCK 
 KNOCK 
 KNOCK 
 The connections in Sweeney Agonistes  between the &bquo;going home&equo; to primitive life and the &bquo;going home&equo; to childhood relates to Eliot's linking of anthropological material with psychological studies. 
 We have already seen him comparing Frazer with Freud. 
 His personal troubles sent him in search of analysts for both himself and his wife, sometimes with disastrous consequences. 
 Clearly Eliot was fascinated by the relationships posited between art and ritual, so that he stressed in 1923 that &bquo; all  art emulates the condition of ritual. 
 That is what it comes from and to that it must always return for nourishment.&equo; 
 As editor of the Criterion , Eliot at this period often used anthropological material, himself selecting books for review and reading every word of what would appear in print. 
 So, in 1923, he printed Yeats's &bquo;Biographical Fragment&equo; giving the poet's dreams with learned notes on tree worship, dying gods, and falling stars (which we may be tempted to relate to &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;). 
 In 1924, as well as a contribution from L&eacute;vy-Bruhl on &bquo;Primitive Mentality and Gambling&equo;, the Criterion  carried Lewis's &bquo;Mr. Zagreus and the Split-Man&equo; where, as in Tarr , modern civilization is constantly punctured by a deeper, often clearly anthropological element in a strange world of lustrations, masked figures, and phallic hands. 
 To encourage Lewis in this direction, Eliot gave him to review in the next year Egyptian Mummies  and Essays on the Evolution of Man  by Elliot Smith, as well as Medicine, Magic and Religion  by W. H. R. Rivers. 
 In 1923 he had himself mentioned Smith's work, and in 1925 he published Smith's long essay on &bquo;The Glamour of Gold&equo;. 
 Lewis's review of these books makes clear the nature of  their importance. 
 He points out how for Smith, &bquo;The similarity between the average Londoner or Berliner to-day, and the average &bquo;primitive man&equo;&hellip; is insisted on', and quotes from Smith's text sentiments which reverberate throughout Eliot's own work: &bquo;There is no innate tendency in man to be progressive.&equo; 
 Here were studies emphasizing the fragility of culture and producing a &bquo;doctrine&hellip; infinitely more pessimistic than Darwin's&equo;. 
 Reading Rivers and Smith a couple of years earlier, Eliot had appreciated this to the full, as his relating contemporary life to Melanesian death in &bquo;Marie Lloyd&equo; shows. 
 He was only too pleased to print, and to read, other men's views which strengthened his own position. 
 Though he quarrelled sharply with I. A. Richards's statement that Eliot had effected &bquo;a complete severance between his poetry and all  beliefs&equo;, the editor of the Criterion  did not dissent from Richards's hostile analysis of Lawrence's &bquo;reversion to primitive mentality&equo;. 
 To make the point clear, Eliot printed Richards's criticisms immediately before Lawrence's short story, &bquo;The Woman Who Rode Away&equo;, in the July 1925 Criterion . 
 As the story of a white woman who rides into the Mexican mountains to be sacrificed, naked and unprotesting, to the god of the Indians in order to maintain for them &bquo;The mastery that man must hold, and that passes from race to race&equo;, this piece, particularly when contrasted with Sweeney Agonistes , makes clear the essential difference between Eliot's interest in the savage and that of Lawrence. 
 For Lawrence, the savage world was authentic and admirable. 
 For Eliot in 1925 it was horribly inescapable. 
 Primitive sexual rituals pursue Sweeney and Doris even into the heart of London, pursue them like Furies. 
 What, for Lawrence, was to be embraced, was for Eliot a torment. 
 But it was a torment which had to be seen and analysed. 
 As Lawrence witch-doctored to the century's ills, Eliot too had his &bquo;craving for ritual&equo;.  
 He was also concerned with primitive ritual as underlying developed ritual. 
 For the proper &bquo;return&equo; it seemed essential to go to the earliest known sources. 
 In 1925, considering a book by Cecil Sharp on the history of dancing, Eliot made the criticism that though Sharp was a historian, he was neither a philosopher nor an anthropologist, and so his brief notes were not just insufficient, but actually conducive to error. 
 Eliot suggested that whoever studied dancing had not only to include its highest forms &mdash; ballet and the Mass &mdash; but also primitive dances such as the Australian ceremonies detailed by Spencer and Gillen and Howitt (whom Eliot misnamed Hewett). 
 Sharp's book is broken under Eliot's imaginative obsession. 
 Eliot goes on to wish for a combination of religious, anthropological, and neurological knowledge as exemplified by Rome, Cambridge, and Harley Street. 
 Harley Street was also the business premises of some of London's leading psychoanalysts. 
 Writing about the novel in 1 927, Eliot stated that &bquo;nearly every contemporary novel known to me is either directly affected by a study of psycho-analysis, or affected by the atmosphere created by psycho-analysis, or inspired by a desire to escape from psycho-analysis&hellip; 
 &equo; Eliot emphasized the dangers of this and drew attention to the importance of the Jamesian stress on &bquo;the whole deep mystery of man's soul and conscience&equo;. 
 But there seems little doubt that the psychoanalysts' stress on the childhood roots of adult problems played its part in the general investigation of primitive roots which fills Sweeney Agonistes . 
 Eliot's original design was abandoned. 
 The carefully conceived &bquo;return for nourishment&equo; to the rituals exposed by Cornford exhausted itself after two fragments. 
 That of the &bquo;Agon&equo;, was, as Eliot knew, the better. 
 In it the whole idea of the fertility rite is exploded, using the very forms and devices of the traditional ritual. 
 The original conception of &bquo;the return of Mrs. Porter&equo; would be pointless, or at least only a prolongation of horror, since life itself and the regeneration of it are seen, at bottom, as hideous. 
 Those concepts of the legal fiction and the ritual whose interpretation may change from age to age are essential to the understanding of Sweeney Agonistes  in Eliot's own development as an artist. 
 Sweeney Agonistes  reperforms a ritual, encouraging the participation of its audience &mdash; through  rhythms and songs, but distancing them in performance by its extreme stylization. 
 Yet, the work's direction is quite the opposite of that conventionally assigned to the fertility rite. 
 That rite is turned against itself in the way that the Lord's Prayer of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; is involved in an anti-Lord's Prayer. 
 The &bquo;Agon&equo; having demonstrated with such force that the core of the rite is not glorious but hideous, there is no point in continuing with the play. 
 This &bquo;return to the sources&equo; discovers either that such primitive celebrations are entirely divorced from modern sexuality, or that they always concealed a deathly horror. 
 Since the &bquo;history of belief and feeling&equo; cannot be traced, it is impossible to conclude which alternative is the true one. 
 All that becomes apparent is that the ritual, once exposed as deathly, is dead. 
 The basing of art on such a ritual is pointless, as Eliot indicated when writing of the medium about which some of his most important remarks of this period were passed. 
 He wrote that no new ballet could be founded on a dead ritual. 
 Revivals of quaint customs were mere amusements, &bquo;For you cannot revive  a ritual without reviving a faith. 
 You can continue  a ritual after the faith is dead &mdash; that is not a conscious, &bquo;pretty&equo; piece of archaeology &mdash; but you cannot revive  it.&equo; 
 Eliot draws a distinction between fertile &bquo;borrowing&equo; from remote cultural sources and &bquo;founding&equo; art on a dead ritual. 
 In its attempt to unite the worlds of city and savage, Sweeney Agonistes  had been all too clearly founded on the fertility rite as presented by Comford's investigation. 
 This did not mean that the play itself was not exciting as drama, but it meant that for Eliot, intent on his search for a vital relation between ritual and art, this play would not suffice. 
 All his probing to the roots of religion had discovered simply the bankruptcy of those roots, or at least their apparent irrelevance to the job of finding a meaning in modern life. 
 The union of the savage and the city confirmed the hopelessness of both and of the means of life, and brought a sharp reaction in Eliot against the continuation of such attempts. 
 Yet, as we have seen, the need in Eliot to relate art to ritual and to religious emotion continued unabated. 
 The themes of savage and city in his work would continue to be important to the moulding of his thought, but would for the moment grow less prominent. 
 His own failure in Sweeney Agonistes  to find anything worthwhile to his personal salvation in all the elaborate investigation of primitive  cults resulted in an apparent about-turn in the direction of his thought. 
 Eliot's preface to his mother's Savonarola  is a defence of nonrealistic drama of the sort that Sweeney Agonistes  embodied. 
 But a new note has surfaced, a note which points out that while philosophical scepticism may have nourished and stimulated the mind of Greeks trained in civic religious observances, it was not nourishing to modern minds trained on nothing at all. 
 For Eliot, the search for liturgy and ritual has continued. 
 The intense reading in mysticism emphasized by Gordon and Hay and so prominent in the 1926 Clark Lectures no doubt played its part in his 1927 conversion, but so did his allied interest in primitive civilizations. 
 For this convinced him of how essential was religious practice to all civilizations. 
 His exposing of the inanity and hideousness for his own time of the rites which underlay Sweeney Agonistes  only helped confirm his choice of the only religion whose rituals seemed open and potent to him. 
 This choice went hand in hand with his artistic development. 
 &bquo;The play, like a religious service, should be a stimulant to make life more tolerable and augment our ability to live&hellip; 
 &equo; This conclusion is contemporary with the abandonment of Sweeney Agonistes  and with Eliot's' being received into the Church of England. 
 Sweeney Agonistes  and &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; seem blasphemous in their despair. 
 Tormented, Eliot was searching for some sort of salvation. 
 He could countenance violence and killing, if only they might provide a way out of the taedium vitae  which formed his spiritual landscape. 
 Irony was to the fore when in 1925 he wrote of the Russian Revolution, but behind it was a more important urge leading him to the poem &bquo;Le Voyage&equo; of his favourite Baudelaire. 
 Eliot wrote of the huge scale of the Russian Revolution and of the huge scale of its violence, pointing out that only one result could justify such huge and terrible expense: &bquo;Such a cataclysm is justified if it produces something really new : Un &lsqb; sic &rsqb; oasis d'horreur dans un d&eacute;sert d'ennui&equo;. 
 Such an oasis Sweeney had discovered, when he penetrated beyond the &bquo;material, literal-minded and visionless&equo;. 
 This discrepancy between the illusory surface of life and what lies beyond, between Bradley's appearance and reality, is a perennial theme of Eliot's poetry. 
 He was fascinated by those deepest drives  which were as he put it in 1919 &bquo;canalizations of something&hellip; simple, terrible and unknown&equo;. 
 Those &bquo;indestructible barriers&equo; which in the Clark lectures he saw as characterizing post-Cartesian society are all too apparent in The Waste Land  where in Bradley's words, quoted by Eliot, &bquo;regarded as an existence which appears in a soul, the whole world for each is peculiar and private to that soul&equo;. 
 At the same time, Eliot saw men and women, whether aware of it or not, as bound to the cycle of manifold yet meaningless &bquo;Birth, and copulation, and death&equo;, perception of which yielded only &bquo;The horror&equo;. 
 Those who comprehend this see the noblest feelings frustrated or distorted. 
 From &bquo;Gerontion&equo; to Sweeney Agonistes , Eliot's work examined obsessively in various ways &bquo;the awful separation between potential passion and any actualization possible in life&equo;. 
 Whether in Kipling or Chapman or other authors, Eliot was attracted to glimpses of a world beyond. 
 &bquo;Beneath all the declamations there is another tone, and behind all the illusions there is another vision.&equo; 
 These words were used specifically of Whitman's writing about lilacs or the mocking-bird, and revealing that at such moments his theories and beliefs dropped away like needless pretexts. 
 So Eliot wrote in 1926 when for him the poet whose &bquo;horrified eyes&equo; saw most clearly the &bquo;chasm between the real and the ideal&equo; was Baudelaire. 
 He complained in 1927 of living in an age &bquo;so deficient in devotion and so feeble in blasphemy&equo;. 
 Baudelaire was much in Eliot's mind in 1927. 
 Marlowe in that year was for Eliot positively either a major atheist or a major Christian, but the enchantments of Faustus were Baudelaire's paradis artificiels . 
 Understandably for Eliot at this time &bquo;the relation of Belief to Ritual&equo; was an &bquo;immense problem&equo;. 
 In 1927, treating of the fascination with ritual on the part of a Baudelaire who was vitally relevant to the present Eliot seeks to rescue Baudelaire from &bquo;the Swinbumian violet-coloured London fog of the &bquo;nineties&equo;. 
 Eliot's Baudelaire is opposed to the &bquo;childishness&equo; of the decadent poets who enjoyed &bquo;dressing up&equo; in religious ritual and &bquo;a religion of Evil, or Vice, or Sin&hellip; 
 But to Baudelaire, alone,  these things were real.&equo; 
 Baudelaire's perception of terrible depths when surrounded by shallower figures sets him beside Sweeney. 
 But Baudelaire's perception also sets him beside Eliot himself. 
 The import ant fact about Baudelaire is that he was essentially a Christian, born out of his due time, and a classicist, born out of his due time&hellip; his tendency to &bquo;ritual&equo;&hellip; springs from no attachment to the outward forms of Christianity, but from the instincts of a soul that was naturaliter  Christian. 
 This seems to tie in closely with the Eliot who pronounced himself in 1928 &bquo;to refute any accusation of playing&equo; possum&hellip; classicist in literature, royalist in politics, and anglo-catholic in religion, The similarities are made more comprehensible in the 1930 essay, &bquo;Baudelaire&equo;, where he sees Baudelaire's Satanism as &bquo;an attempt to get into Christianity by the back door. 
 Genuine blasphemy&hellip; as impossible to the complete atheist as to the perfect Christian&hellip; is a way of affirming belief.&equo; 
 In his perception of the horror of fertility cycle and sexuality, Eliot saw himself as following Baudelaire. 
 Sex on Sweeney's cannibal isle is said to be a business of being &bquo;bored&equo;, but the horror of the perception takes it out of mere &bquo;boredom&equo;, which was killing the Melanesians and, Eliot thought, the modern world. 
 So, for Eliot, Baudelaire &bquo;was at least able to understand that the sexual act as evil is more dignified, less boring, than as the natural, &bquo;life-giving&equo;, cheery automatism of the modern world'. 
 If blasphemy was &bquo;a way of affirming belief, then it is possible to see how Eliot's most blasphemously despairing poem, &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, led up to his conversion. 
 Eliot's Baudelaire, too, as Moody points out, was capable of &bquo;looking into the Shadow&equo;. 
 Though it may never be possible fully to understand what converts a man to a religion, Eliot's view of Baudelaire gives us one of the best guides to his own conversion to Christianity. 
 It came about through a negative way more extreme than has yet been suggested. 
 The perception that a cruel savage cycle of fertility underlay all the trappings of modem life only served to emphasize for Eliot that there was a higher life, though one infinitely difficult to attain. 
 Eliot came to Christianity through a sophisticated decadence which he was able  to see as going hand in hand with the most primitive life. 
 In coming to terms with both he wished to pass beyond them. 
 The Baudelaire in whose work he had found at Harvard both the city and the savage now acted as his guide; blasphemy led to and joined belief. 
 So Boloisms accompany discussions of theology in Eliot's letters to Dobr&eacute;e. 
 In few places are the results of the explorations of Sweeney Agonistes  clearer than in his 1927 attack on Lawrence whom he sees as fatally humourless. 
 Mr. Lawrence is a demoniac, a natural and unsophisticated demoniac with a gospel. 
 When his characters make love &mdash; or perform Mr. Lawrence's equivalent for love-making &mdash; and they do nothing else &mdash; they not only lose all the amenities, refinements and graces which many centuries have built up in order to make love-making tolerable; they seem to reascend the metamorphoses of evolution, passing backward beyond ape and fish to some hideous coitus of protoplasm. 
 This search for an explanation of the civilised by the primitive, of the advanced by the retrograde, of the surface by the &bquo;depths&equo; is a modern phenomenon&hellip; 
 But it remains questionable whether the civilised man, the order of truth. 
 Mr. Lawrence, it is true, has neither faith nor interest in the civilised man, you do not have him there; he has proceeded many paces beyond Rousseau. 
 But even if one is not antagonised by the appalling monotony of Mr. Lawrence's theme, under all its splendid variations, one still turns away with the judgement: &bquo;this is not my  world, either as it is or as I should wish it to be.&equo; 
 In 1927 Eliot turned sharply against the sort of &bquo; love of created beings &equo; seen in Sweeney Agonistes  and against its world. 
 In &bquo;Charleston, Hey! 
 Hey!&equo; of 1927, Eliot judged John Rodker &bquo;up-to-the-minute, if anyone is; we feel sure that he knows all about hormones, W. H. R. Rivers, and the Mongol in our midst&equo;. 
 But Eliot appears to be turning his back on both savage and decadent city life. 
 Speaking of hearing in Gertrude Stein's prose the &bquo;hypnotic&equo; &bquo;rhythms&equo; of &bquo;the saxophone&equo; he concluded that if this were of the future, then the future was &bquo;of the barbarians&equo;. 
 But such a future, Eliot wrote, was not one in which he or his readers ought to be interested. 
 In the Criterion  generally, after 1927 when he sent Frederic Manning the latest works of Frazer, Eliot kept anthropology away from creative writers, with the exception of Charles Madge, who was a trained  sociologist. 
 Apart from pieces by Lawrence, he did not print further creative work which linked the primitive and the modern; he himself no longer reviewed anthropological books. 
 Noticeably, Graves's 1927 review of Malinowski and Rivers is immediately followed by a review written by Eliot and dealing exclusively with Christian books. 
 In 1927 Eliot was in correspondence with William Force Stead, the Anglican priest to whom he expressed his deeply anxious spiritual commitment and who had baptized him. 
 He admired a point which Stead had made about Polynesians and Christianity, but worried that he could not think of a Christian anthropologist. 
 Yet, ironically, Stead's recollection of Eliot's walking in the woods, in true Frazerian style, after his baptism at Finstock in Oxfordshire on 29 June 1927, perceives just the unusual link of savage and city which Eliot might appear to have renounced: &bquo;&hellip; after dinner we went for a twilight walk through Wychwood, an ancient haunted forest, &bquo;savage and enchanted&equo;. 
 I can see Eliot pacing under the mighty oaks and pushing his way through hazel thickets in a smart suit, a bowler hat, and grey spats.&equo; 
 &bquo;Journey of the Magi&equo;, written in 1927, contains not only material quoted in Eliot's 1926 survey, &bquo;Lancelot Andrewes&equo;, and recollections from Eliot's own life (some of which he catalogued when reminiscing in The Use of Poetry and the Use of Criticism ). 
 It also looks back towards his engagement with the primitive. 
 Like &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; and parts of The Waste Land , this poem's setting is a desert one. 
 The traditional landscape, however, is never mentioned, being involved indirectly through the details of &bquo;the camels galled, sorefooted, refractory&equo;. 
 The poem is deliberately unconventional: no mention of gold, frankincense, and myrrh. 
 But it is conventional in terms of Eliot's earlier poetry; though less dramatic, its conclusion is as apocalyptic as before. 
 The reader becomes aware that, Nemi-like,  the birth of the new priest-king means the end of &bquo;the old dispensation&equo; &mdash; an entire world order &mdash; as &bquo;this Birth was/ Hard and bitter agony for us, like Death, our death&equo;. 
 The &bquo;Kingdoms&equo; mentioned are perfectly sensible in the poem's context, but remind readers of Eliot's work of &bquo;death's other Kingdom&equo; and &bquo;death's dream kingdom&equo;. 
 Though explicitly Christian, &bquo;Journey of the Magi&equo; forms between the earlier and later work a bridge over which the reader (with access to the gospel word) may cross into the release of Christianity, the new birth; but, denied that access, the speaker of the poem can only seek relief in death to escape from having to return to the old way in which he is &bquo;no longer at ease&equo;. 
 This old way, &bquo;With an alien people clutching their gods&equo;, looks back to the savage world which Eliot had been exploring, the world trapped in the ritual of &bquo;birth, and copulation, and death&equo;. 
 The word &bquo;clutch&equo; has particularly strong sexual connotations in Eliot's work, as when Saint Narcissus writhes &bquo;in his own clutch&equo;. 
 Eliot had criticized Wundt for ignoring sexuality's part in religion. 
 By &bquo;Journey of the Magi&equo;, however, we have birth and death but not copulation. 
 The reader is faced with a renunciation both of the sexuality bound up with primitive rites and, for the moment at least, of modern sexuality. 
 Vickery overemphasizes vegetation references by relating the &bquo;temperate valley&hellip; smelling of vegetation&equo; with its &bquo;running stream&equo; to a particular scene in The Golden Bough , and by insisting that the &bquo;water-mill&equo; is that &bquo;in which Tammuz was ground&equo; and thus functions as &bquo;a reminder that death is the price of rebirth&equo;. 
 General hints at fertility ceremonies may be present, demonstrating another continuity in theme between this and earlier poetry; but it is important to see that, though its death and rebirth are also related, Christianity is presented by Eliot as an escape from Frazerian cycles of fertility (in the way that the Buddhist &bquo;Shantih shantih shantih&equo; hinted at such an escape), not as its mere continuation. 
 Ariel Poems , like Coriolan , look back to the world of Eliot's childhood and youth, whether to his reading of Mayne Reid's novels or to his sailing off the coast of New England. 
 They present us continually with death, 
 I should be glad of another death 
 I am dying in my own death and the deaths of those after me. 
 and birth or rebirth, 
 Living first in the silence after the viaticum. 
 &bquo;Issues from the hand of God, the simple soul&equo; 
 Living to live in a world of time beyond me; let me 
 Resign my life for this life, my speech for that unspoken, 
 The awakened, lips parted, the hope, the new ships. 
 Copulation surfaces once, only to be transformed immediately into a more familiar element: 
 Those who suffer the ecstasy of the animals, meaning 
 Death 
 As the worlds of savage and sexuality had gone together in the earlier poetry, now, together, they seem banished. 
 The apocalyptic Eliot gravitated in 1926 to Dekker's &bquo;heapes of dead mens bones&equo;, and the &bquo;very pleasing&equo; cannibalism of Wanley's &bquo;The Resurrection&equo;, which he quoted in extenso  in a review. 
 Entering again, after &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, his valley of the dry bones, Eliot dismembered himself with scarcely less thoroughness in the new Christian poetry of Part II of Ash-Wednesday , published in 1927. 
 He tears his past life to pieces with the ferocity of the convert. 
 He wrote to Stead in April 1928 that he felt that for reasons of compensation he required the most ascetic and violent form of discipline, and discussed having to come to terms with celibacy as a Christian. 
 Ash-Wednesday , dedicated, originally, &bquo;To My Wife&equo;, deals, amongst other things, with the resignation of sex, which goes hand in hand with the abandoning of primitive ceremony, the link between such primitivism and the erotic being preserved. 
 In July 1927 the Criterion  published &bquo;Land's End&equo; by Archibald MacLeish, a poem celebrating the sea and an &bquo;ancient people&equo; who had lived by it with gods &bquo;carved with the muzzles of jackals&equo;. 
 Looking back to this primitive folk, MacLeish uses the invocation &bquo;o my people&equo; (which would form the conclusion of section V of &bquo;Ash-Wednesday&equo;), and, after vividly conjuring up a seaboard landscape, recalls details of &bquo;real things&equo;, including  
 love, the weed smell of it, 
 Front against front, not hair blown 
 Dark over eyes in a dream and the mouth gone&hellip; 
 Eliot's renunciation of primitivism and sexuality recalls this phrasing while pulling away from the world which had fascinated him earlier; he sees from the fertile &bquo;slotted window bellied like the fig's fruit&equo; how 
 The broadbacked figure drest in blue and green 
 Enchanted the maytime with an antique flute. 
 Blown hair is sweet, brown hair over the mouth blown, 
 Lilac and brown hair; 
 Distraction, music of the flute, stops and steps of the mind 
 over the third stair, 
 Fading, fading; strength beyond hope and despair 
 Climbing the third stair. 
 Ash-Wednesday's  rejection of the erotic &bquo;garden god, / Whose flute is breathless&equo; is another move away from the preoccupation with primitive fertility and infertility in the earlier poetry with its &bquo;Priapus in the shrubbery&equo;, and its following out of &bquo;vegetation ceremonies&equo;. 
 There remain, though, links with that poetry. 
 Simeon's &bquo;Wait for the wind that chills towards the dead land&equo; recalls &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; with its &bquo;wind in dry grass&equo; and &bquo;dead land&equo;. 
 &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo; is a hidden presence in Ash-Wednesday , not only with its desert landscape, but also with its &bquo;twilight kingdom&equo; and 
 Eyes I dare not meet in dreams 
 In death's dark kingdom 
 foreshadowing the later poem's &bquo;dreamcrossed twilight between birth and dying&equo;. 
 Ash-Wednesday's  &bquo;dry rock&equo; is seen in a way which makes possible a spiritual pilgrimage apparently impossible in The Waste Land . 
 Yet Ash-Wednesday  maintains a connection with the fertility symbols of the savage world. 
 These lead now not to mere eternal recurrence, but, redeemed, to spiritual content and the possibility of a peace beyond time in the search for the word which is both the word of God's grace, healing, and the &bquo;cry&equo; of the poet aspiring. 
 The valley of the dry bones and the life-giving water of baptism are traditional Christian symbols, but Eliot remains aware of other similar more primitive traditions which lead him to invoke the Virgin in unusual terms:  
 Sister, mother 
 And spirit of the river, spirit of the sea, 
 Suffer me not to be separated. 
 Such language glances back to nature worship. 
 It also looks forward to the later poetry, where the &bquo;spirit of the river&equo; Mississippi becomes &bquo;a strong brown god&equo;, while the &bquo;spirit of the sea&equo; is that of the Atlantic of the New England coast of Eliot's childhood. 
 Ash-Wednesday , for all its renunciation, does at times look towards the childhood of the race, but more strongly it looks back to the poet's own childhood with which this primitivism is associated, as Eliot looks back, in language mixing &bquo;Gerontion&equo;, Virgil, and a new interest in his own childhood. 
 And the lost head stiffens and rejoices 
 In the lost lilac and the lost sea voices 
 And the weak spirit quickens to rebel 
 For the bent golden-rod and the lost sea smell 
 Quickens to recover 
 The cry of quail and the whirling plover 
 And the blind eye creates 
 The empty forms between the ivory gates 
 And smell renews the salt savour of the sandy earth 
 Such reminiscence of childhood presented at once as reality and illusion came frequently to Eliot around the time of his conversion. 
 In the very year when, after taking British citizenship and joining the Church of England, he wrote the famous &bquo;Preface&equo; to For Lancelot Andrewes  (dedicated to Eliot's mother), Eliot was recalling his own childhood in his introductory remarks to This American World , and his days at Fishermen's Corner in Gloucester. 
 Yet, as much as reversion to primitivism, so settling back into childhood enjoyment and innocence was undesirable to Eliot. 
 Salvation comes not from attachment to one's own past, but from controlling it in favour of a higher goal. 
 Teach us to care and not to care 
 Teach us to sit still 
 Even among these rocks, 
 Our peace in His will 
 Coriolan  presents even more strongly the rejection of mere &bquo;infantilism&equo; as a trap. 
 Combining elements from his childhood reading with his reading about recent political thought and events, Eliot shows the man-child who has not evolved a cry, and so for whom &bquo;the lost word is lost&equo;, as trapped in a corner, paralysed for all his magnificence and that of his City. 
 O mother 
 What shall I cry? 
 We demand a committee, a representative committee, 
 a committee of investigation 
 RESIGN RESIGN RESIGN 
 If Eliot largely renounced his interest in childhood and in anthropology during the few years that followed, he gave up neither entirely. 
 Just as he maintained an interest in psychological theories of childhood, such as those of Iovetz-Tereshchenko, so he continued to take an interest in some of the anthropological material which came his way. 
 In March 1928 he wrote on a theme which relates to that of Ash-Wednesday  (Part 11), hoping that Hardy's burial in more than one site would not establish a precedent and that future great men would not be &bquo;dismembered&equo; as if the nation were &bquo;given over to idolatry of relics and fetishes&equo;. 
 Eliot's linking of the savage and the city would never again be as prominent as in Sweeney Agonistes , but it would not be abandoned. 
 Though less dominant it persists and is modified throughout his later work.  
 THE SAVAGE AND THE CITY IN THE LATER WORK 
 EVOLUTION and the transmission of cultural forms, topics much discussed in Eliot's youth, continued to concern him in much of his later work, and he retained a profound distrust of the idea of evolution as progress. 
 Anthropology reinforced, rather than dispelled, his scepticism about the notion that humanity might be improving. 
 Sweeney still howled down Emerson. 
 In 1929 Eliot's important article, &bquo;Experiment in Criticism&equo;, began by discussing the work of Herbert Read. 
 He centred on Read's phrase &bquo;evolution of poetry&equo; and was particularly interested in the statement that &bquo;the beginning of this study belongs to anthropology&equo;. 
 Sceptical about over-simple uses of the word &bquo;evolution&equo;, Eliot wishes reader and writer to be aware of the detailed work of philologists and anthropologists in relation to literature. 
 He exposes the vague way in which Read deploys scientific vocabulary, pointing out how much work had had to be done by a great many people and already popularized, before a literary critic could talk in this way. 
 Eliot points to the work of Bastian, Tylor, Mannhardt, Durkheim, L&eacute;vy-Bruhl, Frazer, Miss Harrison, and many other anthropological writers. 
 He is suspicious not because Read uses too much anthropological material, but because he uses too little. 
 By this time his own anthropological reading was tailing off. 
 It seems, for instance, that he never read Malinowski, though he did read Graves's 1927 Criterion  review of Malinowski's work and referred in 1933 to the Trobriand Islands, site of some of that anthropologist's famous field-work. 
 Again, contra  Lawrence, it is obvious that for Eliot the idea that modern western society should adopt savage customs is seen as ludicrous and reprehensible, since he believed that not even the lowest of civilized people could adapt themselves to such society without deteriorating and frequently also  corrupting the natives. 
 But for Eliot now the choice was not between civilized and primitive society but between Christian, non-Christian, and anti-Christian orders.a Anthropology links with Conrad to counter the optimistic vision of a modern noble savagery, but the whole is seen in a new, explicitly Christian framework. 
 In the five years after 1928, the Criterion  printed little anthropological writing. 
 Instead, we see among contributors and books reviewed a gradual move towards some writers whom Eliot later would explicitly acknowledge as influential in the development of his own social thought &mdash; men such as Christopher Dawson and V. A. Demant. 
 Meanwhile (as in his treatment of Westermarck in 1926), Eliot began to dismiss some anthropologists who had earlier interested him. 
 Turning from savage to city, specifically to London and its &bquo;City Churches&equo;, he did not hope to turn again. 
 Yet the peculiar link of primitive and sophisticated, as displayed in &bquo;Marie Lloyd&equo;, still accompanied him. 
 Just as he reacted strongly against Richards's suggestion that The Waste Land  had severed poetry from belief, which carried the implication that the poem was a cultural museum, so Eliot campaigned now for the preservation of London's churches not as museum pieces, but as centres of religion. 
 Art was not the criterion of civilization. 
 Nor was religious development alone. 
 Eliot drew attention to the view that cars, gramophones, and central heating are inessential to civilization, but pointed to a more subtle fallacy which equated art with civilization and so saw &bquo;Alaskan or Solomon Island wood carvers were more &bquo;civilized&equo; than the workmen and workwomen who turn out the bibelots of Woolworth's.&equo; 
 Such a process of reasoning would result in an affirmation that the times of highest religious development were thus more &bquo;civilized&equo; than Eliot's own. 
 Religion had to be integrated with its surrounding society, not in a subservient position, but forming the vital heart of the culture. 
 This Eliot had taken from his reading of anthropology, as would become clear from his later social writings, and he sought to preserve the physical and spiritual bonds of his culture in the city of London. 
 In The Waste Land's  &bquo;Notes&equo;, Eliot the admirer of Wren had drawn attention (referring to St Magnus Martyr) to what was to his mind one of the finest among Wren's interiors. 
 By 1926, however, the  secular beauty had become distinctly secondary. 
 Recalling St Magnus Martyr and speaking again of the need to preserve the fabric of the church, Eliot declared he would cease to appeal in the name of Christopher Wren and his school, and appeal instead &bquo;in the name of Laud and the beauty of holiness &equo;. 
 London and its churches became the initial battle in his campaign for a Christian society. 
 An only somewhat reformed Bolo followed him. 
 In 1927 (when Eliot mentioned &bquo;the Mongol in our midst&equo;) he told Bonamy Dobr&eacute;e that he was preparing a small book, The Bolovian in Our Midst , proving that there was Bolovian blood in some of the leading figures of the day. 
 The tone here mocks both anthropology and the related theories of racial purity (as seen in the work of Frobenius) which were coming to the fore at that time. 
 Frequent Bolovian references (drawings, some rhymes, and much Bolovian dogma) show that in the period 1927&ndash;30 Eliot found this a valuable way of letting off some of the emotional steam generated by his conversion; serious discussions of theology are juxtaposed in this correspondence with ridiculous accounts of Bolovian religious practice, one letter dated according to the day of St Cecilia, another according to that of St Gumbolumbo. 
 The bowler-hatted (not entirely un-Bolovian) city gent photographed by his brother outside the offices of Faber and Gwyer in 1926 was determined that his new faith should be brought to the fore on his home, city ground with an emphasis on basic religious values, rather than those of sophisticated aesthetes. 
 Returning to &bquo;Ancient Buildings: And the City Churches&equo;, he stressed the need to preserve the Church's role in society, particularly where it was threatened by urban secularization. 
 In 1928 he returned to the &bquo;Stones of London&equo;, emphasizing that even when approaching a church building (here Westminster Abbey) as a historical monument of major symbolic value and aesthetic interest, the fact could not be ignored that, poets' corner or no, &bquo;the Abbey was not originally designed primarily as a Pantheon, but as a Church; and a Church  it remains until it is &bquo;disaffected&equo;. 
 Eliot was concerned with the physical conditions of city life. 
 That same year he worried over &bquo;Slum Areas&equo; concerned about overcrowding and the possible creation of new slums. 
 But it was the city's spiritual health which most preoccupied him, though he realized spiritual and economic were not always inseparable. 
 In a paragraph whose subtitle, &bquo;City, City&equo;, harks back to The Waste Land , he expressed astonishment that in an economic slump the City was pulling down buildings to erect ever more splendid banks. 
 Eliot was fond of familiar details of a London which, in a sense, he had known all his life, ever since the childhood reading of Sherlock Holmes which he recalled in 1929. 
 It was his own spiritual change which made possible after the poems of the early twenties a more affectionate view of London, but we should not assume that the owner of Down the Silver Stream of Thames  had ever been totally blind to the beauty of the city. 
 In 1929, he had again returned to a familiar theme, stressing that, while the establishment of a &bquo;National Preservation&equo; body was worthwhile, it was especially important that its attention be directed not merely to the countryside. 
 &bquo;St. Magnus Martyr was not as important as Stonehenge, but still it was not insignificant.&equo; 
 It was useless preserving relics of the primitive past while the living spiritual heart of London perished. 
 Eliot's concerns were to make him a natural contributor to The Rock  where the theme of the city would again be combined with a new modification of the theme of the savage. 
 Meanwhile, though, his interests in much of his prose gravitated towards the city and the consideration of social order. 
 Introducing Johnson's London , he lauded its poet as &bquo;the most alien figure&equo; writing &bquo;in this rural, pastoral, meditative age&hellip; a townsman&hellip; with no tolerance of swains and milkmaids&equo;. 
 With Johnsonian vigour, Eliot discussed the way to run a society; he surveyed with distanced irony &bquo;The Literature of Fascism&equo;, also printing MacDiarmid's &bquo;Second Hymn to Lenin'. 
 His classical and monarchist position led him to couple admiration for urbane, urban eighteenth-century verse with  more general wishes for social order, helping to develop his interest in the ideas of Maurras. 
 Yet Coriolan  seems to criticize such ideas when they produce an external show (&bquo;5,800,000 rifles and carbines&equo;) which may demonstrate force and flourish, yet has no central Word behind it. 
 For Lancelot Andrewes  (1928) was subtitled Essays on Style and Order . 
 In 1930, though, Eliot wrote to Dobr&eacute;e that he thought order and authority dangerous catchwords and was horrified at the modern scorning of democracy; he worried about the way national and racial characteristics were becoming contested issues. 
 Thinking it possible that London's streets would contain martyrs cudgelled to death, he wondered if that might be no bad thing. 
 This wish for martyrdom would be a temptation dealt with in Murder in the Cathedral . 
 Eliot's vision of London as a potential savage battleground is confirmed by Spender's memory of a lunchtime conversation in London during 1930: &bquo;&hellip; 
 I asked him what future he foresaw for our civilization. 
 &bquo;Internecine fighting&hellip; 
 People killing one another in the streets&hellip; 
 &equo; Eliot's relationship with London at this time is a mixture of love and hate. 
 Through the summer of 1929 he complained to Dobr&eacute;e of roasting in the modern city's horrors (yet wondered if he would find the country any more bearable). 
 The next year he wrote to Stead of having lived almost entirely in towns and, though not lacking in a feeling for nature, tending to go back to his memories of Missouri and New England for natural images. 
 In the early 1930s, from his city desk at Faber and Faber, Eliot was busy paying tribute to other cities which had educated him in his way of life and to city writers who had aided his way of writing. 
 Introducing Baudelaire's Intimate Journals , he praised the Frenchman's skill in elevating &bquo;imagery of the sordid life of a great metropolis&hellip; to the first intensity &equo; and creating &bquo;a mode of release and expression for other men&equo;. 
 In 1932 he returned to Bubu de Montparnasse , a novel of Parisian low life which underlay passages in his urban poetry. 
 But now Eliot sounded a new note: &bquo;an intense pity for the humble and oppressed.&equo; 
 To make his tributes to earlier cities complete, before returning to Cambridge and  Boston in 1932 he wrote to a correspondent in St Louis in 1930, telling him how much his poetry owed to his childhood there. 
 If Eliot had been formed by St Louis, then we should remember that for him St Louis had been not simply a city, but also &bquo;the beginning of the Wild West&equo;. 
 Though the city seems to dominate much of his thought at this time, in 1930 appeared his translation of St-John Perse's Anabase  where Christianity and mysticism often have a distinctly tribal feeling. 
 Men, dusty people and folk of diverse devices, people of business and of leisure, folk of the frontiers and foreign men&hellip; trackers of beasts and of seasons, breakers of camp in the little dawn wind, seekers of water and watercourses over the wrinkled rind of the world, O seekers, O finders of reasons to be up and be gone&hellip; 
 Such a feeling would be incorporated into Eliot's own later work. 
 Return to America refuelled him. 
 Before leaving England he had been hankering after his American roots, not only in those sections of Ash-Wednesday  which recall the New England coast, but also in his prose, invoking, for instance, his old master Josiah Royce, who was now mostly forgotten, &bquo;but a great philosopher in his day&equo;. 
 He was also expanding his social thought in general considerations on how &bquo;the word &bquo;civilisation&equo; comes to mean more and more: because it means all the things that we have gained, and want to keep and also all the good things that we have lost, and want to regain'. 
 Such thoughts were not purely abstract, but directed towards Eliot's own values and to London. 
 In his wish for a healthy city he was becoming more and more aware of rural virtues and leaning towards the sort of suspect organicism which would be developed with a vengeance by Leavis. 
 Defending the family as the centre of human life and the village as the basic social unit Eliot expresses his preference for London over other cities since it remains characteristically made up of a collection of villages whose borders touch, each maintaining its own local character. 
 But he worries grimly about &bquo;what sort of organic city can be left&hellip; 
 &bquo;. Eliot's thoughts on civilization would be developed in America, where his longing for the scenes of his youth would also be satisfied and would  enable him to return to London to minister, witch-doctor-like, to his civilization, to purify the dialect of his adopted tribe. 
 In The Use of Poetry  we see how by a reworking of his earlier, anthropologically inspired stress on poets as connected to the primitive man, Eliot adapted nineteenth-century views of the poet's task and brought them into his own later poetry. 
 The Norton Lectures do not simply look back sadly. 
 They also perfect a poetic reorientation and a restatement of poetic and cultural aims which leads Eliot to fare forward. 
 In his introductory lecture, Eliot quotes W. P. Ker's praise of Browning and nineteenth-century poets whose &bquo;themes are taken from all the ages and countries; the poets are eclectic students and critics, and they are justified, as explorers are justified; they sacrifice what explorers sacrifice when they leave their native home.&equo; 
 '. Doubtless, the relevance of these remarks to Eliot's view of his own time attracted him to them. 
 His work had taken him from London to the Arunta, from Boston Brahmins to Buddhist scriptures; he too was an explorer who had left his native home. 
 &bquo;East Coker&equo; states &bquo;old men ought to be explorers.&equo; 
 Later, in The Use of Poetry , he links in one sentence Fitzgerald and Buddhism: &bquo;I am not a Buddhist, but some of the early Buddhist scriptures affect me as parts of the Old Testament do; I can still enjoy Fitzgerald's Omar , though I do not hold that rather smart and shallow view of life.&equo; 
 This connection hints again that Fitzgerald led Eliot to the East, and that his reading in the history of religion affected his view of nineteenth-century poetry. 
 Against Arnold's &bquo;educator's view&equo; of poetry, he reacted strongly. 
 Feeling that &bquo;Arnold's notion of &bquo;life&equo;, in his account of poetry, does not perhaps go deep enough', Eliot presented his own essential requirement of poetry: that it possess &bquo;auditory imagination,. 
 Once again in this phrase reaction against the nineteenth century is bound to a standpoint which relies on anthropology. 
 The notion of &bquo;auditory imagination&equo; relates to the poles of city and savage. 
 It refers not simply to the sound of a poem's words, but has wider reverberations relating to Eliot's own explorations in anthropology, and to the sort of combination of primitive ritual and civilized world explored in The Waste Land  and Sweeney Agonistes : 
 What I call the &bquo;auditory imagination&equo; is the feeling for syllable and rhythm, penetrating far below the conscious levels of thought and feeling, invigorating  every word; sinking to the most primitive and forgotten, returning to the origin and bringing something back, seeking the beginning and the end. 
 It works through meanings, certainly, or not without meanings in the ordinary sense, and fuses the old and obliterated and the trite, the current, and the new and surprising, the most ancient and the most civilised mentality. 
 Such a theory was scarcely new in Eliot's mind. 
 It reformulates the 1918 statement that &bquo;The artist, I believe, is more primitive , as well as more civilized, than his contemporaries.&equo; 
 Ranging from London to Melanesia, Eliot's artist's vision is wider than Arnold's. 
 It is also deeper, seeing Melanesia in London, London in Melanesia. 
 Discovery of Conradian horror beneath polite society, rediscovery of an Original Sin which burdened savage and citizen equally, connecting them however much the latter might politely protest, left unredeemed modern humanity at a level as terrible as that of primitives trapped in their cycle of fertility rites. 
 Christianity was a redeeming force, making possible escape from the cycle, yet it did not cut man off entirely from the primitive. 
 On the contrary, Eliot saw his poet as able to travel deeper down into &bquo;the most primitive and forgotten&equo; far beyond Arnold for whom ritual meant little, the &bquo;inner light&equo; being all. 
 Such descents, according to a view which Eliot found &bquo;very interesting&equo;, allowed the poet privileged access to a primitive mentality. 
 This attitude may seem intensely romantic, but was acceptable to Eliot because sanctified through the anthropological eye. 
 Highly charged personal reminiscence is bound up with the anthropological perspective which gives it an impersonal respectability. 
 After wondering why out of a lifetime &bquo;certain images recur, charged with emotion, rather than others&equo;, Eliot sees these as symbolic, 
 but of what we cannot tell, for they come to represent the depths of feeling into which we cannot peer. 
 We might just as well ask why, when we try to recall visually some period in the past, we find in our memory just the few meagre arbitrarily chosen set of snapshots that we do find there, the faded poor souvenirs of passionate moments. 
 Eliot's note to this reads: 
 In chapter xxii of Principles of Literary Criticism  Mr. Richards discusses these matters in his own way. 
 As evidence that there are other approaches as well, see a very interesting article Le symbolisme et l'&acirc;me primitive   by E. Cailliet and J. A. B&eacute;d&eacute; in the Revue de litt&eacute;rature compar&eacute;e  for April-June 1932. 
 The authors, who have done field-work in Madagascar, apply the theories of L&eacute;vy-Bruhl: the pre-logical mentality persists in civilised man, but becomes available only to or through the poet. 
 These &bquo;depths of feeling&equo; again look back to Eliot's 1920 &bquo;canalizations of something again simple, terrible and unknown&equo;, but now are linked directly to &bquo;l'&acirc;me primitive&equo;. 
 Cailliet and B&eacute;d&eacute; focused attention on the Symbolist poets and L&eacute;vy-Bruhl, a connection familiar to Eliot who at Harvard had read these poets and the anthropologist. 
 References to Bergson, Ribot, and Durkheim plunged Eliot once more into his earlier concerns, offering him academic confirmation of his own stress on the poet's combining civilized and primitive. 
 Stressing the crucial importance of rhythm in poetry and primitive life, while emphasizing how both primitive thought and symbolist poetry appeared to move outside L&eacute;vy-Bruhl's principle of noncontradiction, the authors stated that &bquo;Le symbolisme institue la vaste exp&eacute;rience de la r&eacute;surrection du primitif.&equo; 
 Such theories must have attracted the Eliot who so often had connected modern and savage life and whose own poetry had been attacked for its apparently illogical movements from one image to the next. 
 Cailliet and B&eacute;d&eacute; also discussed Laforgue's &bquo;Afrique int&eacute;rieure&equo;. 
 In Symbolist poetry and primitive life, they found a sort of rapturous vision where living and dead appeared to unite. 
 The thoughts of Cailliet and B&eacute;d&eacute; point forward to the importance of communion with the dead in Four Quartets , with their intense, visionary moments; more immediately the Frenchmen's stress that, like primitive thought, &bquo;Le symbolisme, en effet, requiert tout d'abord une d&eacute;tente de l'attention&equo;, is paralleled in The Use of Poetry  by Eliot's presentation of poetic creation not as an act of concentrated attention, but as a relaxation, or removal of a normal barrier. 
 Certainly mention of Cailliet and B&eacute;d&eacute; brings back Eliot to a familiar uniting of primitive and urban as, after stating that &bquo;I myself would like an audience which could neither read nor write&equo;, he recalls Sweeney Agonistes  (published in book form in December 1932) and speaks of the poet as &bquo;something of a popular entertainer&hellip; having a part to play in society as worthy as that of the music-hall comedian&equo;. 
 The tone is abject, but Eliot approaches  a climax. 
 Though it does not end &bquo;on this sort of flourish&equo;, the book's hope for the future comes in the one &bquo;flourish&equo; in its dejected concluding lines. 
 Typically, for Eliot, this hope for the future, following the French anthropologists' piece, looks towards the distant past. 
 &bquo;Poetry begins, I dare say, with a savage beating a drum in a jungle, and it retains that essential of percussion and rhythm; hyperbolically one might say that the poet is older  than other human beings&hellip; 
 &bquo;Having said of the poet in The Use of Poetry  that &bquo;I do not mean that he should meddle with the tasks of the theologian, the preacher, the economist, the sociologist or anybody else&equo;, that was just what Eliot went on to do. 
 He felt his Christian faith impelled him to it. 
 In addition, his setting out the poet's connection with the primitive gave him the status of a societal elder, one who, lecturing in America, would pronounce on literature and society as Arnold had done less than fifty years before him. 
 Eliot's vision of the urbane savage was very different from Arnold's, but gave him the same privileges as his Romantic predecessor. 
 The poet who against Romantic diction forged a new contemporary language for a poetry which had been able to deal with the modern city face to face, had, to a considerable extent, reinstated Romanticism through anthropology. 
 The theory that the poet had access to deep and primitive levels put him awkwardly alongside the Romantic &bquo;explorers&equo;. 
 Eliot, in The Use of Poetry , quoted Jacques Rivi&egrave;re: &bquo;It is only with the advent of Romanticism that the literary act came to be conceived as a sort of raid on the absolute and its results as a revelation.&equo; 
 The poet who would go on in &bquo;East Coker&equo; to write of poetry as &bquo;a raid on the inarticulate&equo; now pulls back from his earlier position in his wish &bquo;to avoid employing the terms Romanticism and Classicism&equo;, and concludes that &bquo;we are still in the Arnold period&equo;. 
 The Use of Poetry and the Use of Criticism  showed Eliot again considering poetry's primitive roots and to some extent consciously reorienting himself towards romanticism. 
 In After Strange Gods  he continued his investigation, but with an attitude far from simple romantic primitivism. 
 He revealed that the poet's connection with and knowledge of the primitive were only beginnings and not ends in themselves. 
 Though savage rites might be interesting and even valuable, their greatest value was that, in showing the importance  of ritual in a society, they pointed towards the place which the higher Christian rituals should have in his own society. 
 He saw this society as increasingly menaced by industrialization which, particularly in the cities, where power was now centralized, was cutting off the population from its roots. 
 Eliot was more hopeful about the &bquo;re-establishment of a native culture&equo; in Virginia than in New England, he told a Virginian audience, since &bquo;You are farther away from New York; you have been less industrialised and less invaded by foreign races; and you have a more opulent soil.&equo; 
 The city, traditional centre of civilization, is here seen as its enemy: partly because too cosmopolitan, partly because too industrialized. 
 Eliot's sympathies lie not with urban industrialism of &bquo;half-dead mill towns of southern New Hampshire and Massachusetts&equo; but with humanized rural landscape which &bquo;has been moulded by numerous generations of one race, and&hellip; which&hellip; in turn has modified the race to its own character. 
 And those New England mountains seemed to me to give evidence of a human success so meagre and transitory as to be more desperate than the desert.&equo; 
 That mention of the desert takes us back to the territory traversed in The Waste Land , &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, and Ash-Wednesday . 
 The poet has emerged, wishing to save the city, ultimately presenting his true saving oasis as a version of pastoral. 
 Not, however, a personal or directly romantic pastoral. 
 Eliot's vision, which gives him his sympathies with &bquo;neo-agrarians&equo;, however &bquo;quixotic,, is a vision to counter the modern paganism of economic determinists whose theory has become &bquo;a god before whom we fall down and worship with all kinds of music&equo;. 
 He sees his own vision not as personal, but rooted in tradition. 
 This tradition is presented through an anthropological definition. 
 What I mean by tradition involves all those habitual actions, habits and customs, from the most significant religious rite to our conventional way of greeting a stranger, which represent the blood kinship of &bquo;the same people living in the same place&equo;. 
 It involves a good deal which can be called taboo &hellip; 
 This &bquo;tradition&equo; anticipates Notes towards the Definition of Culture , but also recalls the Eliot who had read Marett's &bquo;Is Taboo a Negative  Magic?&equo; 
 It is characteristic of Eliot to move in After Strange Gods  from the savage notion of taboo , which he sees as having decayed in our time so that it has become &bquo;used&hellip; in an exclusively derogatory sense&equo;, to the Christian notion of &bquo;heresy&equo; as being vital to the interpretation of the modern world and to the health of the (mainly Christian-based) &bquo;tradition&equo;. 
 On a small scale, this shift mirrors that in Eliot's poetry from &bquo;vegetation ceremonies&equo; to the Christian rituals of Ash-Wednesday . 
 His use of &bquo;traditional&equo; and &bquo;heretical&equo; allows him to sidestep the terms &bquo;classical&equo; and &bquo;romantic,, so incorporating elements otherwise labelled &bquo;romantic&equo; into the structure of his tradition which had been sanctified with an anthropological definition. 
 The process is helped by Eliot's reading of and reference to the works of Demant and Dawson (see below). 
 Eliot sees himself as an orthodox writer, trying to make his audience aware of the need to contribute to their own living tradition. 
 He makes explicit that he is not writing as some individual Messianic figure propounding an individualistic gospel deriving from &bquo;the ineffable wisdom of primitive peoples&equo;. 
 In After Strange Gods  his own view of savage and city is defined against that of Lawrence. 
 Eliot was engaged in a clarification of his boundaries. 
 Mention of &bquo;the dark gods of Mexico&equo; signals that we are about to move on to the writer for whom his strongest opprobrium is reserved. 
 Eliot had known Lawrence's work for some time, but in 1931&ndash;2 he had grown particularly interested in that writer, whose &bquo;travels to more primitive lands&equo; and use of Mexican divinities in The Plumed Serpent  were physical embodiment of Eliot's anthropological reading and a likely reason for that title, After Strange Gods . 
 In 1931 Eliot reviewed Middleton Murry's biographical study of Lawrence and went on to read Lawrence's letters, to which he referred in 1933. 
 Between 1931 and 1933 he also read Fantasia of the Unconscious . 
 Probably some personal connections both attracted and disturbed Eliot. 
 For instance, he had been particularly close  to his mother. 
 Lawrence's &bquo;emotional dislocation of a &bquo;mothercomplex&equo;, discussed by Murry, was picked up by Eliot in 1931, shortly after he had resisted return to childhood at the end of Ash-Wednesday ; in the same year he analysed Coriolanus's infantilism and his &bquo;Mother mother&equo;. 
 For Eliot and Lawrence sex was a constant source of anxiety. 
 Most important was the fact that personal circumstances and creative needs of each man had impelled him to be, in a phrase which Eliot applies to Lawrence in After Strange Gods  but which applies equally well to himself, a &bquo;restless seeker for myths&equo;. 
 The similarities between Lawrence and Eliot, combined with the differences, made Eliot's attack on Lawrence particularly strong. 
 For the man who had written the song &bquo;My little island girl&equo; Lawrence's blend of the sophisticated with savage sexuality was particularly disturbing. 
 Attacking Lady Chatterley's Lover  (which he was later prepared to defend), Eliot wrote of a &bquo;morbidity which makes other of his female characters bestow their favours upon savages. 
 The author of that book seems to me to have been a very sick man indeed.&equo; 
 Consideration of Lawrence prepares for the climax of After Strange Gods . 
 Parts of Mornings in Mexico  had appeared in the Criterion , and in mentioning them, Eliot returned explicitly to the theme of city and savage. 
 Against the living death of modern material civilisation he spoke again and again, and even if these dead could speak, what he said is unanswerable. 
 As a criticism of the modern world, Fantasia of the Unconscious  is a book to keep at hand and re-read. 
 In contrast to Nottingham, London or industrial America, his capering redskins of Mornings in Mexico  seem to represent Life. 
 So they do; but that is not the last word, only the first. 
 Eliot saw the savage here as simply a base from which to start in the critique of the modern. 
 His own critique of Lawrence leads to his climactic denunciation of his own generation when he turns himself prophet of the most orthodox sort, quoting a long passage from Ezekiel also used in The Waste Land . 
 It was after this critique of Lawrence's attitude to the modern industrial civilization and the savage world, joined to his own prophetic Christian stance towards his own time, that Eliot returned to London and the writing of The Rock .  
 Though lacking its crackling intensity, The Rock  looks back towards Sweeney Agonistes  and Eliot's earlier work. 
 The themes of the climax of After Strange Gods  now emerge further as we are presented with industrial London, its unemployment, and those collapsing City Churches which had previously claimed his attention. 
 The Rock  opens with the seasonal fertility cycle which had horrified the trapped Eliot of the earlier poetry and the dramatic fragments. 
 O perpetual recurrence of determined seasons, 
 O world of spring and autumn, birth and dying! 
 We move as in The Waste Land  into the financial heart of the &bquo;timekept City&equo;. 
 That City is attacked in The Rock , but &bquo;this London of ours&equo; is also celebrated as a city to be worked for and redeemed by a Christianity sometimes remarkably primitive, a pared-down Christianity among the wild men, as a London church is seen as a &bquo;House&equo; built of 
 brick laid upon brick; 
 While encompassed with enemies armed with the spears 
 of mistaken ideals; 
 The inhabitants of this city are savages without Christianity: 
 Men! polish your teeth on rising and retiring; 
 Women! polish your fingernails: 
 You polish the tooth of the dog and the talon of the cat. 
 Occasionally the City's dilemma seems more like the problems of the Wild West: 
 Remembering the words of Nehemiah the prophet: 
 &bquo;The trowel in hand, and the gun rather loose in the holster.' 
 Eliot's creation story, in thin verse, presents the movement from savage religions to the proper religion of his City. 
 Beginning with the making of the world, he guides his audience through the pageant of primitive man (&bquo;worshipping snakes or trees&equo;) with an urgency that for flickering moments recalls The Waste Land . 
 Sometimes biblical chant sounds too much like adaptation from simple anthropological textbooks, but we can see at any rate the exemplification of the way  in which Lawrence's &bquo;capering redskins&equo; had to be for Eliot now &bquo;Life&equo; but &bquo;not the last word, only the first&equo;. 
 And men who turned towards the light and were known of the light Invented the Higher Religions; and the Higher Religions were good 
 Here, among &bquo;Prayer wheels, worship of the dead, denial of this world, affirmation of rites with forgotten meanings&equo;, some of the stuff of Eliot's earlier poetry and his anthropological researches, there comes a visionary instant of incarnation forming a link between God and man and, in Eliot's own poetry, between Ash-Wednesday  and Four Quartets : &bquo;A moment not out of time, but in time, in what we call history; transecting, bisecting the world of time, a moment in time but not like a moment of time.&equo; 
 Religious development is counterpointed with the development of London. 
 Desert and city were negatively linked in the earlier poetry; they are positively linked in the play. 
 Primitive worlds or pagan savage and Old Testament prophet must not be forgotten: they are essential to the struggle between good and evil. 
 The chorus exhorts the audience to be aware that &bquo;The desert is not remote in southern tropics,&hellip; 
 The desert is squeezed in the tube-train next to you.&equo; 
 To forget this brings about the destruction of the values of civilization. 
 Eliot's apocalyptic imagination again hints at those glimpses of street violence which he had revealed to Dobr&eacute;e and Spender: 
 It is hard for those who live near a police Station, 
 To believe in the triumph of violence. 
 Convinced that the danger of the end of Christian society was at hand and that this would lead to the collapse of civilization, Eliot viewed London more in terms that contemporary Christians used to view Africa. 
 Christian work in places, urban and suburban, must be missionary  work', the work of &bquo;imperial expansion&equo; having exported the gospel like just another sort of industrial export, leaving &bquo;much at home unsure&equo;. 
 Eliot continued to see the danger of London reduced to a waste land where (with a momentary glance at Gerontion's coughing goat) debris lies 
 In a street of scattered brick where the goat climbs, 
 Where My Word is unspoken. 
 The Rock  picks up several points made in earlier Criterion  commentaries. 
 Thus, churches are not like theatres, nor to be valued primarily as works of art. 
 They must contribute towards constructing genuine communities, family values generating City values. 
 The City is again a place of insect-like life, drab scenes and rats, unless there is present what Eliot had earlier described as an &bquo;organic&equo;, a sort of tribal, community sense. 
 To bring about this sense of community, Eliot includes historical and contemporary Londoners of various social classes. 
 The workmen's dialogue, which he co-authored, though filled with pieces of carefully observed slang, is none the less stilted and sometimes too obviously theatrical. 
 More interestingly, Eliot returns to employing music-hall techniques at times reminiscent of Sweeney Agonistes  and the &bquo;Marie Lloyd&equo; essay which had pointed out how music hall encouraged sympathetic collaboration between performer and audience. 
 He makes a point of mentioning in The Rock  one of his music-hall favourites, George Robey. 
 Eliot made clear that his Pageant Play  made no pretence of being a contribution to the dramatic literature of England. 
 &bquo;It is a revue .&equo; 
 It was this aspect, along with the play's closeness to liturgy and ritual (two linked methods of securing a sense of community), which most excited critics. 
 Even those hostile found the play's closeness to music hall to be its strength. 
 One of the most carefully observed pieces of vaudeville comes in the song whose female part begins, 
 When I was a delicate slip of a maid 
 What could eat nothin' more than a couple o' chops&hellip; 
 Pound, though hostile to Eliot's Christianity, admired the song, classing it with &bquo;Bolo&equo;; clearly Eliot revelled in this composition drawing on a pleasure in music hall which dated back to his St Louis childhood, and his youth in Boston. 
 He was gleeful about the idea of a Faber &bquo;Vaudeville&equo; production in 1929 where he starred as a baritone singing Bolovian Ballads and a song about a blue baboon. 
 Yet probably The Rock  relies on a form too close to extinction at the time for it to bring the whole revue to life. 
 The later play's music-hall element seems strongest when closest to the  more daring Sweeney Agonistes , bringing to this distinctly urban form some of the ironic bite which Brecht and Weill had brought to Berlin stages in 1929. 
 This is seen most clearly in the song of Eliot's Blackshirts, whose bitter irony should be set against remarks concerning the undesirability of too many free-thinking Jews in After Strange Gods . 
 Eliot has been accused of making racist remarks, yet for him &bquo;All men are equal before God.&equo; 
 He had grown accustomed, even in the work of supposedly enlightened anthropologists, to terms such as &bquo;savage&equo;, &bquo;lower races&equo;, and &bquo;inferior races&equo;, so that when he speaks of &bquo;inequality&equo;, he may well be thinking of a vertical model, though he may mean simply &bquo;difference&equo; when he writes that 
 There will probably always remain a real inequality of races, as there is always inequality of individuals. 
 But the fundamental identity in humanity  must always be asserted; as must the equal sanctity of moral obligation to people of every race. 
 It is unlikely that Eliot would have taken the trouble to defend Kipling against the charge of race superiority if he had believed in it himself. 
 While publishing Dawson on &bquo;Religion and the Totalitarian State&equo;, he selected for notice in the 1934 Criterion  a book highlighting persecution of European Jews; he wrote to Pound speaking of his offence at Pound's antisemitic remarks; with regard to the Vichy government in 1941 he wrote in The Christian News-Letter  of his &bquo;greatest anxiety&equo; at news &bquo;that &bquo;Jews have been given a special status, based on the laws of Nuremberg, which makes their condition little better than that of bondsmen.&equo; 
 Eliot may have experienced displeasure at racial mixing in After Strange Gods , which he later withdrew from print as &bquo;a bad book&equo;, but it was no coincidence that in the same year as the performance of The Rock  he defended Frazer, but attacked Ezra Pound's favourite, Leo Frobenius, whose anthropological doctrines of racial purity he found particularly distasteful. 
 &bquo;How you gwine ter keep deh Possum in  his feedbox when I brings in deh Chinas and blackmen?&equo; 
 Pound wrote to Frank Morley in 1937, but for all his growing concentration on European civilization, Eliot saw more clearly than Pound the dangers of Fascism. 
 Moving from the elements of primitive worship to the rituals of Christianity and the chants of the London music hall, Eliot tried to strengthen his city against dangers of contemporary politics. 
 The Rock  transformed the motifs of city and savage found in Sweeney Agonistes , but they are preserved because essential to Eliot's thought. 
 His interest in them is confirmed by his return to the earlier play for the production by The Group Theatre Company in the same year as the performing and publication of The Rock. 
 Sweeney Agonistes  was performed by Doone's company with an appropriate mixture of anthropologically induced masked characters in hieratic postures and music-hall routines. 
 At its centre, the plain-suited figure of Sweeney looks like a city clerk, surely linked to the Eliot who jokily signed himself F. &lsqb;rancis? 
 &rsqb; X. &lsqb;avier? 
 &rsqb; Sweeney in 1933 when he talked of coming over all of a hoo-hah. 
 From the condition of being Agonistes , Sweeney points forward to the later ritualistic conception of Eliot's Christian drama. 
 Production and publication of The Rock  led directly to Eliot's being invited to write Murder in the Cathedral , which took further his idea of committed Christian drama and his warnings about the dangers of a society cut off from its religious roots. 
 It also developed his implicit warnings against the dangers of political extremism. 
 Bishop Bell, who commissioned the play, was an influential British churchman who had consistently supported the German Confessing Church in its opposition to National Socialism. 
 Eliot's Murder  demonstrates his agreement with that opposition. 
 It is a play which, again, has not entirely abandoned the traditions of the music hall. 
 As in The Rock , these are invoked in one of the most bitter moments, with the parody-hymn not unlike a ferocious music-hall song as the chorus of knights sings 
 Are you washed in the blood of the Lamb? 
 Are you marked with the mark of the beast? 
 Come down Daniel to the lions' den, 
 Come down Daniel and join in the feast. 
 Music hall had shown Eliot that the chorus of the Greek drama in whose primitive origins he had exhibited such interest, could still work on the modern stage. 
 There are signs at times of a reversion to a more primitive level of superstition in the play, a slipping beneath Christianity to Frazerian rituals half hinted at, but suppressed beneath normal life. 
 We have seen the young man mutilated, 
 The torn girl trembling by the 
 mill-stream-And meanwhile we have gone on living. 
 Horror brings Eliot's chorus a sense of unnatural reversion which earlier he had found associated with anthropological discussions and had detected behind Lawrence's &bquo;explanation of the civilised by the primitive&equo; sending his characters back &bquo;to reascend the metamorphoses of evolution&equo;. 
 I have lain on the floor of the sea and breathed with the breathing 
 of the sea-anemone, swallowed with ingurgitation of the 
 sponge&hellip; 
 &hellip; 
 I have seen 
 Rings of light coiling downwards, descending 
 To the horror of the ape. 
 A similar horror sends back the chorus far from their supposedly civilized city into a desert past where April would be again the cruellest month, as they pray &bquo;let the spring not come. 
 4 One problem with many passages in Eliot's plays is that they send us to similar but stronger passages in the poetry. 
 The essential thing which the plays carry on from Eliot's earlier anthropologically concerned work is a fascination with ritual. 
 The line of dramatic form running from primitive arrow dance to Pinero is worth bearing in mind. 
 Music hall was the living form closest to the liturgical extreme. 
 In The Rock  Eliot included song and dance. 
 Song persists in Murder in the Cathedral , but Christian liturgy takes over almost entirely. 
 Yet Eliot seems to have been attracted even to the most unlikely sources, including even Conan Doyle's &bquo;The Musgrave Ritual&equo;. 
 In 1934, the year of Murder in the Cathedral's  commissioning, he  wrote, &bquo;one of the reasons why the Morte Darthur  is a permanent source of refreshment, is the degree to which the primitive &bquo;ritual&equo; stories are and are not integrated into the narrative.&equo; 
 Eliot returned to familiar themes in suggesting that the morality of the Morte Darthur  was of that primitive type which was essential, whereas modern manners were things of the surface only. 
 &bquo;This primitive morality was refined by Christianity; but the passing of Christianity has left only the refinement without the morality&hellip; 
 &equo; The Morte Darthur  interpreted by Weston had contributed to The Waste Land . 
 Two other works with which Eliot linked Malory's &bquo;profound, tribal, Sophoclean morality&equo; were to form starting points for his own plays; Aeschylus' Tragedy of the House of Atreus and Sophocles' Oedipus at Colonus  underlie respectively The Family Reunion  and The Elder Statesman . 
 If in Murder in the Cathedral  he had chosen a particular martyrdom which functioned as a bloody, savage ritual, then in the plays which followed, connections with primitive ritual would be clearer &mdash; if anything, as Eliot later feared when thinking of The Family Reunion , too clear, the primitive outline getting in the way of the Christian story. 
 Harry experiences 
 The sudden solitude in a crowded desert 
 In a thick smoke, many creatures moving 
 Without direction,&hellip; 
 As in The Waste Land , spring appears &bquo;an evil time&equo;. 
 Harry's return to the sources at wishwood seems very much a return to the Frazenan wood, when 
 Spring is an issue of blood&hellip; 
 Do not the ghosts of the drowned 
 Return to land in the spring? 
 Momentarily it seems Harry will escape by &bquo;going away &mdash; to become a missionary&equo; in &bquo;a tropical climate&equo; and getting to know &bquo;the natives&equo;. 
 This hint of physical as well as psychological confrontation with primitivism predictably gives rise to the corresponding image of city apocalypse, presented by Charles, the character with whom as Eliot told Martin Browne he most closely identified.  
 As if the earth should open 
 Right to the centre, as I was about to cross pall Mall. 
 Primitive terrors remain dormant, continually erupting in &bquo;various spells and enchantments&equo;, or anxious questions, &bquo;What ambush lies beyond the heather/ And behind the Standing Stones?&equo; 
 The modern world is juxtaposed against and involved with a world very definitely presented in terms of primitive rite &mdash; nowhere more clearly than in the ritual expiation of the curse. 
 The laying of ghosts by moving &bquo;Round and round the circle / Completing the charm&equo; is like a rite rescued from &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;, presumably in Eliot's terms sanctified by the Christian connotations also present in the play. 
 Yet the play's overall effect is not necessarily Christian. 
 It simply communicates something of that &bquo;profound, tribal&equo; morality which Eliot associated with Greek drama and its ritual. 
 It is questionable if this play fulfils Eliot's new vision as powerfully as those Fragments of an Aristophanic Melodrama  fulfilled his old. 
 Relations between The Family Reunion  and Sweeney Agonistes  have often been remarked on. 
 Carol H. Smith's fine study details thoroughly connections between Eliot's late plays and the earlier dramas and primitive motifs which underlie them. 
 Having indicated such links, I shall not discuss each one, but concentrate on particular instances when the themes of savage and city come together. 
 This conjunction is particularly important in The Cocktail Party . 
 While Eliot might mock Pound's concerns with primitive society, it continued to interest him as is indicated by allusions in his correspondence to devil doctors, Bali, and Trobriand Islanders. 
 To a degree Eliot is just reassuring his correspondent that he has not changed absolutely. 
 Though a churchwarden, he can still tell stories of his American youth, use four letter words, or quote Bolovian rhymes and customs. 
 Looking back towards his study of Cornford and Harrison, he approves of Johnson's view that for the modern the distinctions between tragedy and comedy were superficial. 
 But Eliot emphasized that Johnson, unaware that such distinctions grew out of a difference  in ritual, had been ignorant of their importance for the Greeks. 
 Eliot's next sentence has a familiar ring: &bquo;In the end, horror and laughter may be one &mdash; only when horror and laughter have become as horrible and laughable as they can be&hellip; 
 &bquo;. Here again is Sweeney Agonistes . 
 Eliot's concern that his own urban society be well founded on a necessary myth was accentuated by the realization that this society was now annihilating other very different forms of civilization. 
 This led him in 1935 to discuss a newly &bquo;discovered&equo; agricultural Papuan tribe, the description of whose civilization Eliot utilized to criticize what he saw as some of the indulgences of his own inorganic civilization during the unemployment of the thirties. 
 The case of the Tari Furora paralleled that of the Melanesians in &bquo;Marie Lloyd&equo;, but it is to his ideal City, and his actual urban Western civilization that Eliot relates this Papuan discovery: &bquo;&hellip; if we are so helpless in the hands of our &bquo;civilization&equo; that we admit our inability to prevent it from ruining Papuans, what hope have we of saving ourselves?&equo; 
 He makes it clear that he believes &bquo;that there are higher civilizations and lower ones&equo;; the notion of Empire is &bquo;not necessarily an ignoble one&equo; when it is founded on &bquo;the notion of extending law, justice, humanity and civilization &mdash; with no other interest than glory, and no other motive than a sense of vocation&equo;. 
 It seems to him more likely though that Empire is working in tandem with exploitation. 
 This piece is intensely pessimistic and is a forerunner of his later &bquo;doubt of the validity of a civilization&equo; on the eve of the Second World War. 
 Civilization had to be more than a mere confluence of economic interests: &bquo;And until we set in order our own crazy economic and financial systems, to say nothing of our philosophy of life, can we be sure that our helping hands to the barbarian and the savage will be any more desirable than the embrace of the leper?&equo; 
 The Tari Furora greatly disturbed him. 
 A year later, they were still in his mind when thinking simply of western civilization; the Papuans came into his memory only to be cursorily dismissed as &bquo;weak inaudible voices&equo;. 
 Yet the mention of these voices leads Eliot on to wider questioning of what civilization is. 
 He does not try to pretend there would be any viable alternative in a &bquo;noble  savage&equo; existence. 
 But the realization that his own civilization is extinguishing cultures of &bquo;savages&equo; possessed of coherent ways of living prompts him to demand that civilization be considered in no narrow perspective. 
 He emphasized that peace had to be preserved for the entire human race and not for particular sections of it, pointing out that the word &bquo;civilization&equo; could be applied to a wide diversity of values. 
 Murder in the Cathedral  addressed such matters, posed in a different way. 
 They would be taken up in Eliot's later prose. 
 Though apparently divorced from &bquo;Cultural Progress&equo; as related to the Basutu, which Eliot was also considering in 1936, his idea of poetic drama was part of the same concern with embodying and strengthening what he had always associated with ideas of culture and community and which his dealings with the &bquo;lower races&equo; had helped to teach him: the need for art linked to religious ritual as a central value summing up and sustaining the social values of a culture. 
 He was appalled at the thought of turning into a pub at five-thirty for a quiet drink and finding that it had been converted into a Poets' Pub, &bquo;reverberating, like an African village, with the roll of &bquo;Drake's Drum.&equo;. 
 Yet he emphasized that, unlike some other societies, his own was vitiated by a lack of connection between ritual, drama, religion, and the centre of the culture: London. 
 In a consideration of religious drama which clearly descends from the theorizing about anthropology and literature in &bquo;The Beating of a Drum&equo;, and from the 1923 conviction that &bquo;the stage &mdash; not only in its remote origins, but always &mdash; is a ritual,&equo; he writes in favour of a closer union between ritual and metropolitan drama, seeing an essentially religious craving as latent in all serious patrons of drama, as opposed to cinema audiences seeking mere distraction. 
 Eliot stressed that there should be no maintaining of different attitudes for cathedral drama and for West End theatre. 
 He perceived instead a need to reintegrate both these types of drama and a parallel need to &bquo;strive towards a reintegration of life&equo;. 
 Clearly these ideas relate to Eliot's plays and to &bquo;Burnt Norton&equo; where dangers of being &bquo;Distracted from distraction by distraction&equo; seem connected with the spectre of a metropolis seen as the antithesis of religious values. 
  London, however organically composed of 
 Hampstead and Clerkenwell, Campden and Putney, 
 Highgate, Primrose and Ludgate 
 leads to a &bquo;twittering world&equo;, close to that of The Waste Land's  London or the &bquo;timekept city&equo; of The Rock . 
 &bquo;Burnt Norton&equo; retains many links with Eliot's earlier poetry. 
 For a moment balanced against London's distracting inanity are the equally distracting primitive rituals now seen as inane because sundered from the Word: 
 The crying shadow in the funeral dance, 
 The loud lament of the disconsolate chimera. 
 The funeral dance is part of that turning world which, like the remorselessly and vapidly revolving seasons of The Waste Land  (or the circles of the London underground in &bquo;Burnt Norton&equo;) threatens to trap its inhabitants in a cycle which is, eventually, empty. 
 So timeless Love is distinguished from temporal desire which, 
 Caught in the form of limitation 
 Between un-being and being 
 reminds the reader of that moment when the shadow falls &bquo;Between the potency/ And the existence&equo;, or of Tiresias's being trapped unfulfilled in sexual desire, bearing witness to all the ritualistically patterned couplings of history, &bquo;throbbing between two lives&equo;. 
 The themes of city and savage are marginally present in &bquo;Burnt Norton&equo;. 
 As the Four Quartets  develop, their importance increases. 
 The idea of &bquo;distraction&equo;, so strongly linked with London in &bquo;Burnt Norton&equo; was one which Eliot saw in this period as politically as well as spiritually dangerous. 
 For him spiritual and political ideas were becoming more and more inseparable in his concern with &bquo;culture&equo; as a whole. 
 His considerations of political distraction and its dangers were panoramic in scope. 
 The modern &bquo;dictator,&equo; a Hitler or Mussolini, must be thought of&hellip; as a highly paid leading actor , whose business is to divert his people (individually, from the spectacle of their own littleness as well as from more useful business)&hellip; 
 The ruler as dramatic star &mdash; with illustrations from the customs of African tribes &mdash; is one subject of Mr. Lewis's attention. 
 At the same period, though, Eliot continued to worry about &bquo; urbanization of mind &equo;. 
 In 1940 he wrote of an almost sanctified rural life as something vitally different from the separately developing urban culture which so disturbed him and pleaded that agriculture should be regarded as a vocation, rather than merely an industry, though he pointed out that such a view involved the whole orientation and scheme of values of a future society. 
 In The Idea of a Christian Society , published just before war, Eliot saw &bquo;our choice&equo; as being &bquo;between a pagan, and necessarily stunted culture, and a religious, and necessarily imperfect culture&equo;. 
 Unlimited industrialism is particularly dangerous, tending &bquo;to create bodies of men and women &mdash; of all classes &mdash; detached from tradition, alienated from religion, and susceptible to mass suggestion&equo;. 
 Though, that last phrase seems to point to Germany and Italy, Eliot also draws attention to dangerous mass &bquo;cults&equo; in Britain, which &bquo;has been highly industrialized longer than any other country&equo;. 
 Claiming that he is not &bquo;presenting any idyllic picture of the rural parish&equo;, Eliot takes as his &bquo;norm, the ideal of a small and mostly self-contained group attached to the soil&hellip; with a kind of unity which may be designed, but which also has to grow through generations&equo;. 
 He was clearly attracted to rural religious communities, such as that at Kelham where he himself participated or that seventeenth-century community of Little Gidding which he was later to celebrate. 
 Yet he saw the danger in making these communities an ideal, as he turned an anthropological eye on Christianity and perceived that such examples seem to proffer no solution to industrial urban and suburban existence &mdash; the way most people live. 
 Such a religious patterning of small communities reveals a &bquo;Christendom fixed at the state of development suitable to a simple agricultural and piscatorial society&equo;, and so imperfectly suited to the more complicated organization of modern society. 
 Eliot's solution of a widespread Christian community hierarchically organized, related both to the state and individual parishes and containing intellectual leaders, owes much to Benda's notion of clercs , as well as to the anthropologists' stress on the connection of religion with society. 
 As in After Strange Gods , he is concerned in his conclusion with a return to sources,  that is with going back to the savage and working forwards towards his solution to the problem&ndash; of modern industrial life; again such a movement is presented in terms of a familiar encounter. 
 The struggle to recover the sense of relation to nature and to God, the recognition that even the most primitive feelings should be part of our heritage, seems to me to be the explanation and justification of the life of 
 D. H. Lawrence, and the excuse for his aberrations. 
 But we need not only to learn how to look at the world with the eyes of a Mexican Indian &mdash; and I hardly think that Lawrence succeeded &mdash; and we certainly cannot afford to stop there. 
 We need to know how to see the world as the Christian Fathers saw it; and the purpose of reascending to origins is that we should be able to return, with greater spiritual knowledge, to our own situation. 
 Eliot does not see primitive religion as a necessary basis for Christianity, &bquo;I do not believe that Christianity germinates out of natural religion, but that it is given by revelation.&equo; 
 Though his &bquo;City&equo; is put forward as a remedy for secular, increasingly industrial-urban values, he does conceive of it as including non-Christians, though these he hopes would be a minority. 
 This period of Eliot's development is often seen as one of increasing narrowing, so that it is useful to emphasize that while it certainly represents a concentration of energy on Christian themes, it also represents a continuing openness to other elements and a drawing on resources whose foundations were laid in Eliot's studies at Harvard. 
 Discussing &bquo;Education in a Christian Society&equo; in 1940, Eliot cites eastern ideas of &bquo; sadhu , or mahatma &equo; in a demonstration that &bquo;In the East, and in pre-Christian Europe, the sage and the saint have been hardly distinguishable from each other. 
 We must recognize the truth in both the Oriental and the Christian views.&equo; 
 Such an openness would be seen increasingly in Four Quartets . 
 Elsewhere, he criticizes Mannheim's definition of charismatic education in the consideration of the awakening of religious feeling; since it seems neither to include the whole of the education of so-called &bquo;primitive races&equo; any more than of the higher races in their religious stage. 
 Eliot instances the co-ordination of different types of education in &bquo;the highly organized societies of Polynesia&equo;. 
 The breadth of this review, which goes on to discuss Sir Thomas Elyot's The Governour  and to conclude by looking at immediate reforms applicable in a modern world of  &bquo;industrial exploitation&hellip;&equo; where &bquo;local community does not exist&equo; relates clearly to &bquo;East Coker&equo;. 
 This poem shows how Eliot's increasing interest in ruralism had at its heart his earlier interest in the savage. 
 As in The Waste Land , this is combined with the city. 
 &bquo;East Coker&equo; is concerned with civilization at its beginning and end, as well as with purely individual values. 
 The poem's beginning is certainly biblical, drawing on Ecclesiastes, but it also involves the modern world (&bquo;factory&hellip; bypass&equo;), and deliberately seems to draw on the biblical passage closest to Frazerian fertility rites, the dead being reborn through the seasonal cycle. 
 Old stone to new building, old timber to new fires, 
 Old fires to ashes, and ashes to the earth 
 Which is already flesh, fur and faeces, 
 Bone of man and beast, cornstalk and leaf. 
 Eliot celebrates English pastoral rhythms. 
 In &bquo;East Coker&equo;, though, we seem to watch ghosts from the past, though the countryside itself may be little changed: 
 In that open field 
 If you do not come too close, if you do not come too close, 
 On a summer midnight, you can hear the music 
 Of the weak pipe and the little drum 
 And see them dancing around the bonfire 
 The association of man and woman 
 This vision is like that which Eliot praised in his childhood favourite, Kipling, whose Puck of Pook's Hill  and Rewards and Fairies  particularly &bquo;give at once a sense of the antiquity of England, of the number of generations and peoples who have labored the soil and in turn been buried beneath it, and of the contemporaneity of the past&equo;. 
 &bquo;They&equo;, one of Kipling's &bquo;most other-worldly stories&equo; was important for the opening of &bquo;Burnt Norton&equo;. 
 Kipling's historical and contemporary tales of the English countryside, stories such as &bquo;An Habitation Enforced&equo;, &bquo;My Son's Wife&equo;, and &bquo;The Wish House&equo;, are important to the start of &bquo;East Coker&equo;. 
 The earlier Kipling brought about an &bquo;introduction of India and the Colonies into the sphere of consciousness  of the inhabitants of the London suburb&equo;; the later was &bquo;discovering and reclaiming a lost inheritance&equo;. 
 Both were crucial to Eliot. 
 When he maintains the old spellings, &bquo;daunsinge&equo; and &bquo;matrimonie&equo;, Eliot links himself with his East Coker ancestor Thomas Elyot. 
 The poet chose burial under East Coker earth, completing a circle of ends and beginnings. 
 The attraction of the stately dance in &bquo;East Coker&equo; is strong. 
 The association of man and woman 
 In daunsinge, signifying matrimonie &mdash; 
 A dignified and commodious sacrament. 
 Two and two, necessarye coniunction, 
 Holding eche other by the hand or the arm 
 Whiche betokeneth concorde. 
 This is, however, mixed in with a more primitive element relating rustic to savage through fertility rituals. 
 Eliot changed &bquo;May midnight&equo;, (recalling Gerontion's &bquo;depraved May&equo; and ceremonies of spring) to &bquo;summer midnight&equo;, maintaining a primitive connection with &bquo;Midsummer Fires&equo;, ceremonies copiously described by Frazer, while looking back, too, to the Hollow Men's circular dance. 
 As in his remarks on Lawrence in After Strange Gods  and The Idea of a Christian Society , Eliot indicates the importance of contact with the savage as a beginning, while stressing its limitations. 
 He makes apparent both his sympathies with rural life and the fact that mere retreat to the tradition of the countryside is not enough. 
 He has respect for the almost tribal traditional wisdom of those whom he later called the &bquo;quiet-voiced elders&equo; and their &bquo;dead secrets,, but in the end these are to be renounced or incorporated in a higher Christian scheme and vision. 
 Though attractive and lyrical, the essentially primitive associations of the country dance in &bquo;East Coker&equo; lead it to be classed with the &bquo;folly&equo; of Frazerian savages; its fertility rhythm, &bquo;Nourishing the corn&equo; like that of the inescapably cyclic fertility ceremonies of Sweeney Agonistes  and The Waste Land , points towards &bquo;Dung and death&equo;. 
 Admired and rejected, the primitive rite is also linked with the city; the isolated last line of the poem's second section summons up the field and its dancing, leading to a juxtaposition with the urban world which follows.  
 The dancers are all gone under the hill. 
 III 
 O dark dark dark. 
 They all go into the dark, 
 The vacant interstellar spaces, the vacant into the vacant, 
 The captains, merchant bankers, eminent men of letters. 
 &hellip; 
 Distinguished civil servants, chairmen of many committees,&hellip; 
 As with the living dead of The Waste Land's  London and the inane savages of its &bquo;mudcracked houses&equo;, so in &bquo;East Coker&equo; the primitive rituals of the countryside and the (essentially commercial) life of the city and City both point only towards death. 
 But now Eliot clearly finds aspects of London life and country life congenial. 
 Having sympathetically implicated elements of his East Coker ancestry and private &bquo;mirth&equo; in the opening section, here the poet, himself content to sit on &bquo;many committees&equo; and regarded as one of the &bquo;eminent men of letters&equo;, is implicated in the world he attacks. 
 The circles of the dance are as invalid as the circles of the Underground. 
 Their form or pattern, dead in itself, may hint at something higher, but unless that higher truth is realized, they remain meaningless and deathly. 
 Both East Coker and London were in a sense &bquo;home&equo; for Eliot, but, as he reminds us &bquo;Home is where one starts from&equo;. 
 One of the uses of understanding how this transform of the city and savage theme continues in Eliot's work is that in seeing how this primitive countryside (like the animistic rose-garden) connects with London's metropolitan world, it becomes apparent that there is a political aspect to the Four Quartets . 
 The politics are closely related to Eliot's prose writing of the period. 
 He recalls how, seeing England from his own urban American background he has always been aware that the natural habitat of the Englishman was the little rural community and that industrial and large towns were accepted with reluctance. 
 Eliot sees London as unusual among big cities in having grown up gradually out of a grouping of villages and concludes that &bquo;there is something about England which remains stubbornly attached to the parochial&equo;. 
 As the very titles of the Quartets  remind us, Eliot is stressing the importance of this parochial tradition. 
 Significantly, it is here that he locates &bquo;mirth&equo;. 
 Yet the overt ruralism of the prose is more strongly qualified in the verse, where country, primitive, with  its &bquo;daemonic, chthonic/ Powers&equo; is seen as ultimately no better than city unless-redeemed by the Christian vision. 
 And in poems which make use of primitive ceremony, several foreign literatures, and much Buddhist thought, Eliot's parish is no Little England. 
 The Quartets  are all the more impressive for having this political dimension worked into them, yet still subordinated beneath the religious scheme. 
 Their homecoming, going to earth and returning to sources, reaches, in a sense, its furthest point in &bquo;The Dry Salvages&equo;, where Eliot returns to his own St Louis and Massachusetts childhood, to &bquo;The life of significant soil&equo;, and to the savage meanings associated with such beginnings. 
 The poem stresses throughout the elemental qualities of the landscape and seascape which it describes, leading Eliot to a particularly bare group of rocks which he had known from the sailing days of his childhood. 
 But the three rocks also attract him because of their name (see p. 34 above). 
 It is with this savage, primitive element that the poem begins: 
 I do not know much about gods; but I think that the river 
 Is a strong brown god 
 Eliot's familiar theme that the savage exists even below the urban world on a forgotten, yet still potent and often dangerous level is here reiterated: 
 The problem once solved, the brown god is almost forgotten 
 By the dwellers in cities &mdash; ever, however, implacable, 
 Keeping his seasons and rages, destroyer, reminder 
 Of what men choose to forget. 
 &bquo;Within us&equo; the Mississippi in St Louis, like the voices in the rose garden in &bquo;Burnt Norton&equo;, or the dancers in the field of &bquo;East Coker&equo;, or the village concealed in the shape of modern London, or the savage elements in modern man, maintains a secret presence, &bquo;waiting, watching and waiting&equo;. 
 It has been present from the beginning as a primitive rhythm, that element associated with the &bquo;auditory imagination&equo; of poetry, and so with the savage in the jungle and his gods, &bquo;His rhythm was present in the nursery bedroom&hellip; 
 &bquo;. Primitive and child are again linked, but not as the second childhood of &bquo;The Hollow Men&equo;. 
 The primitivism of the &bquo;strong brown god&equo; is healthier: a childhood promising growth. 
 Prefacing Huckleberry Finn  (first read &bquo;a few years ago&equo;) in 1950, Eliot recalled his own boyhood. 
 His words suggest that Twain's book brought back Eliot's childhood not merely  by functioning as an aide-m&eacute;moire . 
 It enabled Eliot to look not to the detested Unitarianism of his family, but towards a deeper, wider, yet also more personal &bquo;rhythm&equo; present, though scarcely recognized at the time. 
 Eliot, thanks to Twain, is able to see his childhood as containing, in Durkheim's phrase, The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life . 
 &hellip; the River makes the book a great book. 
 / As with Conrad, we are continually reminded of the power and terror of Nature, and the isolation and feebleness of Man. 
 Conrad remains always the European observer of the tropics, the white man's eye contemplating the Congo and its black gods. 
 But Mark Twain is a native, and the River God is his God. 
 It is as a native that he accepts the River God, and it is the subjection of Man that gives to Man his dignity. 
 For without some kind of God, Man is not even very interesting. 
 So accustomed to using Conrad's eyes, Eliot is able to see through Twain's the native emotion of his own nativity and childhood in the nursery bedroom, seeing that childhood in terms of a fundamental primitivism from which his religious consciousness has grown. 
 Here again, anthropology and romanticism have coalesced. 
 The experience represented by river and sea is the experience of tradition's endurance, and a tradition, even in its full development, has no truck with &bquo;superficial notions of evolution &lsqb;as&rsqb; a means of disowning the past&equo;. 
 Rather, the tradition includes and is aware of its primitive origins: this reminds the tradition of its vulnerability and need to look for higher guidance, while keeping it aware of crude root emotions which cannot be avoided. 
 The fear of savage &bquo;folly&equo; links with the fear of God. 
 I have said before 
 That the past experience revived in the meaning 
 Is not the experience of one life only 
 But of many generations &mdash; not forgetting 
 Something that is probably quite ineffable: 
 The backward look behind the assurance 
 Of recorded history, the backward half-look 
 Over the shoulder, towards the primitive terror. 
 EIiot's intense sympathy with the fishermen of the Massachusetts coast transforms them into figures of endurance, secular saints,  whose course is one of earthly failure which the toughest faith transforms into gain. 
 This daily confronting of the &bquo;primitive terror&equo; as represented by the sea is held up for our admiration. 
 There may be an eastern quality to such reverence for long, ancestral tradition; this section is followed by the episode of Krishna and Arjuna which is related to the business of the fishermen by the concluding &bquo;Not fare well, / But fare forward, voyagers.&equo; 
 All this contrasts sharply with the flimsy world of divination, of Madame Sosostris, which lands us unsurprisingly in the heart of London as we hear how all this &bquo;fiddle&equo; will always be found &bquo;When there is distress of nations and perplexity/ Whether on the shores of Asia, or in the Edgware Road&equo;. 
 What raises Eliot above the entrapping circles of city and savage is what for him has continually to raise words towards the Word, something made available in partial revelations. 
 &bquo;The hint half guessed, the gift half understood, is Incarnation.&equo; 
 Here city and savage are united and transcended. 
 We are left with a verdict which sees the savage as fatally limited because cut off from God's Word which passes understanding; similarly, The Waste Lands  fertility cults were cut off from the peace of &bquo;Shantih shantih shantih&equo;. 
 Eliot's leavetaking of the city comes in &bquo;Little Gidding&equo;. 
 In &bquo;The Dry Salvages&equo; he salutes and passes the &bquo;daemonic, chthonic/ Powers&equo; of the savage. 
 Charles I, Christ, and Frazer's monarchs coalesce in the &bquo;broken king&equo; of &bquo;Little Gidding&equo; whose &bquo;May, with voluptuary sweetness&equo;, recalling Gerontion's &bquo;depraved May&equo;, perhaps follows an urge to juxtapose spring's arrival with the breaking of the king. 
 What matters more is the poem's preoccupation with the city and its destruction. 
 If a savage element persists, it is the modern savagery of the Blitz which, physically, as a firewatcher, Eliot attempted to assuage. 
 The sight triggered deeply his apocalyptic imagination. 
 What had happened in verse at the conclusion of The Waste Land  was actually happening: London was being destroyed. 
 At first in &bquo;Little Gidding&equo;, the bombing and the burning seem to be happening in the countryside, part of that cycle of death and rebirth opening &bquo;East Coker&equo;, explicitly recalled. 
 Dust inbreathed was a house &mdash; 
 The wall, the wainscot and the mouse. 
 The death of hope and despair, 
 This is the death of air. 
 The cycle of death leads us on towards the urban landscape that  follows. 
 The &bquo;Dust in the air suspended&equo; seems to present us with a barren desert of death. 
 Eliot had again used the traditionally romantic similar alternatives &bquo;a desert or a city&equo;. 
 Yet, as one of his prose pieces of the period reveals, the desert remained for him not only a place of death, but also a place of Christian triumph. 
 He gave high praise to the biography of a French priest killed in North Africa. 
 Charles de Foucauld travelled disguised, the first explorer &bquo;in unexplored and unsubdued territory&equo;. 
 He gave aid to the tribesmen and aimed primarily not to convert by teaching, &bquo;but to live  the Christian life, alone among the natives&equo;. 
 Finally, Foucauld was killed by a marauding band which was unaware of his name and reputation. 
 &bquo;There is no higher glory of a Christian empire than that which was here brought into being by a death in a desert.&equo; 
 This piece relates to the &bquo;explorers&equo; of &bquo;East Coker&equo;, and to the poem on &bquo;the Indians who Died in Africa&equo;. 
 It is the revision of the theme of cannibal and missionaries in Sweeney Agonistes  which makes possible the fate of Celia in The Cocktail Party . 
 It also relates to Eliot's sense of the poet's mission in &bquo;Little Gidding&equo; when the streets of London become simply a tribal homeland. 
 In the city, &bquo;In the uncertain hour before the morning&equo;, Eliot meets his &bquo;familiar compound ghost&equo;. 
 The use of Dante is encouraged by The Waste Land  and by The City of Dreadful Night . 
 The time for Eliot is just after the passing of &bquo;the dark dove with the flickering tongue&equo;, a German plane which has left behind a city every bit as much of a waste land as the earlier poem's London, though now the &bquo;crowd&equo; has gone, leaving only the speaker who, &bquo;before the urban dawn wind&equo;, communicates with the ghost. 
 Since our concern was speech, and speech impelled us 
 To purify the dialect of the tribe&hellip; 
 Typically, the second line is not Eliot's own but is selected deliberately. 
 The English language, to which Eliot had dedicated (vainly, he worried) so much of his life is here reduced merely to &bquo;the dialect&equo; of a &bquo;tribe&equo;. 
 As dialect, it is all the more vulnerable to disintegration and collapse. 
 Similarly as a &bquo;tribe&equo;, rather than a nation, the English (and humanity) are revealed as more vulnerable. 
 The effect also forges a link with those primitive origins of poetry, which &bquo;begins, I dare say, with a savage beating a drum in a jungle&equo;. 
 This conversation  at the threatened end of a city and a civilization links its poet with the primitive, savage beginnings. 
 The speech is filled with self-reproach, yet it ends with what was promised at its start: dawn. 
 Day rises over the broken city. 
 The day was breaking. 
 In the disfigured street 
 He left me, with a kind of valediction, 
 And faded on the blowing of the horn. 
 All is clear. 
 The final, Jericho-like sound may be frightening, but is at least an escape from 
 The sound of horns and motors, which shall bring 
 Sweeney to Mrs. Porter in the spring. 
 The saving of the poet demands &bquo;that refining fire/ Where you must move in measure, like a dancer&equo;. 
 Similarly, the saving of the city seems to demand its destruction. 
 Eliot's apocalyptic urban imagination had destroyed London before. 
 Now it must be done again. 
 There is both an exultant and a suffering note in the return of the destructive dove which is also the Christian bird of Incarnation whose message for both individual and society, parish and city, is driven home in the famous anthem passage when &bquo;The dove descending breaks the air.&equo; 
 The God behind this love is a savage God as well as a redeeming, loving one. 
 After this passage, there is no more city, no more savage in the Quartets . 
 Only the return through poetry and childhood images to the final home which lies in the blank page following the moment when &bquo;the fire and the rose are one,. 
 In Eliot's next prose book and in his next play, the combined themes of city and savage were important. 
 Notes towards the Definition of Culture  supplements Arnold's definition not by abandoning it, but by setting it beside a wider, basically anthropological definition of culture. 
 The essentially anthropological basis of Eliot's most crucial definition of culture is clear in the published book, as Bantock indicates, but the earlier (1943) version of the first section reveals the intellectual movement even more clearly. 
 Eliot sets aside Arnold's notion of culture, stating that his own main interest is &bquo;with the culture that a whole society may develop and transmit&equo;. 
 Yet the first definition of culture which he now supplies,  &bquo;that of a refinement of living, including appreciation of philosophy and the arts, among the upper levels of society&equo;, is in many ways close to Amold's ideal. 
 In Eliot's own life such an idea seems to have been associated particularly with artistic movements of the big cities. 
 Against this first idea of culture he sets a second definition at once wider and &bquo;more fundamental&equo;. 
 &hellip; it is what we imply when we speak of Primitive Culture . 
 It is the whole complex of behaviour, thought and feeling, expressing itself in custom, in art, in political and social organisation, in religious structure and religious thought, which we can perceive most clearly as a whole in the less advanced societies, but which is equally present as the peculiar character of the most highly developed people or nation. 
 There is not detailed remembering of the book, but even the full title, Primitive Culture: Researches into the Development of Mythology , Philosophy, Religion, Language, Art, and Custom , shows that Tylor's conception of culture as all embracing is one of the keys to Eliot's work. 
 From the start, his two definitions of culture, that of a class and that of the whole people, &bquo;have to be kept distinct but always in relation&equo;. 
 Particularly in the music-hall connections of his plays (which later became their West End connections) we can see that he was attempting to do this in his own creative work at the time. 
 Notes towards the Definition of Culture  takes the &bquo;savage&equo; as a base. 
 Though Eliot refuses to treat the uneducated merely as &bquo;savages&equo;, his essential ideas about the indispensable contribution of religion to culture are presented as being derived from the study of a less complex model. 
 The original article shows clearly his move from primitive to sophisticated, as he demonstrates the way in which amongst primitive communities various parts of culture are inextricably interlaced. 
 Eliot instances the activities of Dyak headhunters the production of whose carvings is at once a task utilitarian and sacred. 
 As civilization develops, though, occupational specializations proliferate, and eventually there appears a capacity for abstracting religion, science, politics, and art from one another. 
 Eliot moves from such a primitive organization to discussing Greek drama, following the movement of Harrison, Cornford, and the other anthropologically influenced classical scholars whom he had read.  
 He sees that conflict between various elements in highly developed society can be creative, but that eventually deterioration will follow if connections are not preserved between the various areas of life which, in the primitive model, are integrated. 
 Without naming names, he goes on to outline the situations which had so interested him in the cases of the Melanesians and the Tari Furora, as he points out that to tamper with the pattern of primitive culture at one point is to endanger the whole structure. 
 He relates this to the state of culture of his own age, facing dangers of over-specialization, which impoverishes both the religious and artistic sensibilities by separating each from the other, so that only &bquo;the vestige of manners  may be left for those who, having their sensibility uninformed either by religion or by art,&hellip; have nothing left but an inherited behaviour which ceases to have meaning&equo;. 
 Eliot had written of and against such a milieu  when he combined the elements of the savage and the city, from the beating tom-tom of &bquo;Portrait of a Lady&equo; through the rituals of The Waste Land  and Sweeney Agonistes  to the cocktail chatter and jungle martyrdom of the play, The Cocktail Party , yet to come. 
 Revising the original articles for Notes towards the Definition of Culture , he complicated his argument's texture by involving more material relevant to his personal history and to the history of his work, such as that mention of Heart of Darkness  which looks back to The Waste Land . 
 The first article in the series which became the book demonstrated that Eliot's definition of culture begins with the savage. 
 The second showed that at the other pole is the city. 
 Eliot discussed the shrunken sense in which &bquo;culture&equo; was applied to the arts, culture centring on Paris, London, and more recently New York. 
 While the city is kept within bounds he sees that this can be healthy, though in both culture and industry a balance between town and country is necessary. 
 As in Four Quartets , it is the country which has inherited the virtues of primitive community, the savage's integrated civilization being reflected in what Eliot, following fashion of the day, praises as organicism. &bquo;organicism&equo; suggests close-knit near-to-the-soil values of rural communities whose established tradition and integrated value-system are threatened by the sophisticated metropolitan. 
 Eliot's thinking here sometimes relies on romantic clich&eacute;s insufficiently analysed in Russell Square, yet it could also produce provocative  insights. 
 The urge to preserve these rural communities led him from examination of dying primitive societies to sympathy with developing regionalism as a political force to preserve cultural values under threat. 
 Such regional movements, whether in Scotland or America, tended to be associated with agrarian, traditional integrated societies beyond the &bquo;wholly urban-minded&equo; capital. 
 Eliot made clear in Notes  that his true concern was &bquo;a problem of the first importance&hellip; that of the transmission of culture &equo;. 
 The book's scope extends far beyond consideration of Karl Mannheim's stress on a need for &bquo;elites&equo;. 
 Eliot's third article again stressed that linkage of primitive and sophisticated, first linked explicitly in the review of Wyndham Lewis's &bquo;cave-man&equo; novel in 1917. 
 Eliot did not want &bquo;a romanticized folk-culture&equo;. 
 Rather, &bquo;the censure of this essay must be on a somewhat different ground &mdash; that of my wishing to have all at once what can only be had in succession in an historical process, a co-existence of the primitive and the most highly sophisticated&equo;. 
 Here it seems Eliot's artistic practice is clearly carrying over into his social thought. 
 His reply to the expected criticism is that ideals must be striven for particularly now since &bquo;in a position in which old peoples and old cultures are likely to be supplanted by new &mdash; we are in a common danger to all races over the whole circumference of the globe&equo;. 
 This global stance and anthropological imagination continue to guide him in his consideration of the relation between religion and culture, and his fascination with &bquo;more primitive and self-contained peoples, where the culture and the religion are co-terminous&equo;. 
 Wishing for &bquo;much the same unity on a higher plane&equo;, he presents himself as a kind of agriculturalist, concerned with &bquo;our relation to the spiritual soil&equo;. 
 Against those iconoclasts who would rid life of all images in the name of religion, he sees repudiation of art as acceptable for the extreme ascetic, but, if universally applied, as starving the spiritual soil of nourishment. 
 Yet he insists that if the arts are a necessary element in culture and if culture is essential to develop a people's highest spiritual capacities, then it must not be  forgotten that without religion no culture can exist. 
 This is the main message of these &bquo;Notes&equo;. 
 Whether the reader disagrees with that message or not, Eliot cannot be accused of suddenly presenting it or of bringing it to the fore simply because of his Christian faith. 
 Certainly it accords with and draws on that faith, but also and explicitly it comes from Eliot's long concern with the meeting extremes of savage and city. 
 I have concentrated on the articles, &bquo;Notes towards a Definition of Culture&equo;, rather than the less tentatively titled Notes towards the Definition of Culture  because the book, while refining and adding to the argument, occludes that argument's clarity through continual divagation and a tendency to over-engage in discussion with Eliot's own contemporaries, many now forgotten. 
 A similar tendency vitiates The Idea of a Christian Society , with its many and lengthy endnotes. 
 The defence of the format of these books is that they were written as part of a struggle. 
 Now that details of that struggle in the later 1930s and 1940s have faded, the books have been weakened, though their central argument can still engage and provoke. 
 In various articles of the forties Eliot refined his material, whether in relating poetry to religious ritual in &bquo;The Social Function of Poetry&equo; or returning to Primitive Culture  and John Layard's studies &bquo;in the &bquo;stone age&equo; New Hebrides' in &bquo;Cultural Forces in the Human Order&equo; which reworks many of the points in the earlier &bquo;Notes&equo; series. 
 Simultaneously, he concerned himself with the idea that cities were necessary, not evil, but that &bquo;without the life of the soil from which to draw its strength, the urban culture must lose its source of strength and rejuvenescence&equo;. 
 He did not always side with the city, though he did concern himself with urban and industrial problems. 
 Writing on &bquo;Full Employment and the Responsibility of Christians&equo; (1945) in a response to a correspondent signed &bquo;Civis&equo;, Eliot signed himself &bquo;Metoikos&equo; &mdash; resident alien. 
 He continued to set out ideas on  cultural issues in a piece on &bquo;The War and the Blitz&equo; also incorporated into the Notes . 
 Again he pointed out &bquo;more marked differentiation of function&equo; in higher types of primitive society. 
 Writing about UNESCO in 1947, he repeated that he &bquo;had always understood culture to comprehend education and science, as well as other interests&equo;. 
 Prefacing Notes towards the Definition of Culture , Eliot acknowledged particular debts to V. A. Demant, Christopher Dawson, and Karl Mannheim. 
 Mannheim, whose work Eliot read after 1937 and whom he frequently met, has been discussed by Kojecky. 
 For the themes of savage and city it is Demant and Dawson who are important, though neither writer is gripping. 
 Dawson, the more significant figure, had featured in the Criterion  since the late 1920s, Demant since the early 30s. 
 Dawson's first book, The Age of the Gods  (1928), subtitled A Study in the Origins of Culture in Prehistoric Europe and the Ancient East , began by noting that &bquo;During the last thirty years the great development of archaeological and anthropological studies has prepared the way for a new conception of history.&equo; 
 Dawson was interested in history &bquo;not as an inorganic mass of isolated events, but as the manifestation of the growth and mutual interaction of living cultural wholes&equo;. 
 For Dawson, organic connections were good. 
 He emphasized what is summed up in the title of Simone Weil's book which Eliot would later preface, The Need for Roots . 
 &hellip; the earliest agriculture must have grown up round the shrines of the Mother Goddess, which thus became social and economic centres, as well as holy places, and were the germs of the future cities. 
 Dawson emphasized the importance of combining agricultural and urban for building a strong society. 
 He also discussed &bquo;savages&equo;, referring to figures such as Frazer, Tyler &lsqb; sic &rsqb;, Rivers, Elliot Smith, Marett, and Durkheim. 
 Often Dawson's ideas are remarkably similar to those of Eliot. 
 A culture can only be understood from within. 
 It is a spiritual community which owes its unity to common beliefs and a common attitude to life, far more than to any uniformity of physical type. 
 Hence the study of primitive culture is intimately bound up with that of primitive religion. 
 Dawson's 1932 book, The Making of Europe , drew his work into a more specifically European context, emphasizing classical tradition, the importance of tribal as well as urban culture, and the significance of asceticism, particularly as shown by the desert saints. 
 Carol Smith has pointed to the importance of this book for the primitive ritual elements in Eliot's drama. 
 It contributed also to his stress on &bquo;The Unity of European Culture&equo;, though ever since &bquo;Tradition and the Individual Talent&equo; Eliot had been preoccupied with &bquo;the mind of Europe&equo;. 
 Dawson underlined the importance of the family, a concept which became more and more explicit not only in Eliot's later social writings but also in his plays. 
 Like Eliot, Dawson emphasized the &bquo;two Englands&equo; created in the nineteenth century &mdash; &bquo;the England of the fields and the England of the factories&equo; &mdash; and wished to build on a common &bquo;English tradition&equo; which with some sort of religious sanction would take people Beyond Politics . 
 In many ways on the outbreak of war this was, of course, a na&iuml;ve position. 
 It was also profoundly necessary to understand roots and strengths of the culture so that what was best might be salvaged from carnage, and worries like Eliot's &mdash; that the war might be fought only to preserve financial interests &mdash; could be assuaged. 
 The positions of Dawson and Eliot moved closer and closer together, influencing one another. 
 The two men conversed. 
 Dawson's Religion and Culture  stressing Tylor's importance and relating theories of primitive religion to Christianity was selected by Eliot as one of his &bquo;Books of the Year&equo; in 1950. 
 V. A. Demant, a parish priest as well as a Fellow of the Royal Anthropological Society, also stressed &bquo;The Importance of Christopher Dawson&equo;. 
 Demant too combined interest in savage and city. 
 He cites Malinowski's Sex and Repression in Primitive Society , criticizing  the way in which &bquo;the fashionable psycho-analytic school of Sigmund Freud deduces the processes of the human psyche from the particular problems of the modem urbanized European&equo;. 
 Demant's &bquo;Christian Sociology&equo; was important not just in itself; it threw up names from Eliot's past, such as those of Maine and Durkheim, which maintained the importance of such figures within an explicitly Christian context. 
 The third section of Demant's 1936 Christian Polity  (Faber &amp; Faber) is given over to anthropological essays, such as &bquo;Idols: Their Place and Influence in Religious History&equo; where again we meet the names of Elliot Smith, Tylor, Ellis, Frazer, McDougall, Robertson Smith, and others. 
 Eliot now tended to be interested in anthropology mainly when it contributed to a Christian perspective, so that while he would maintain that &bquo;the actual religion of no European people has ever been purely Christian, or purely anything else&equo; since &bquo;There are always bits and traces of more primitive faiths, more or less absorbed&equo;, he became more and more interested in relating such faiths to Christian problems. 
 So he was attracted to Evans-Pritchard's contention that &bquo;the sociologist should also be a moral philosopher and that, as such, he should have a set of definite beliefs and values in terms of which he evaluates the facts he studies as a sociologist&equo;. 
 Evans-Pritchard's &bquo;Social Anthropology&equo; devotes much attention to the Victorian anthropologists, Tylor and Frazer, then passes on to their critics, &bquo;Durkheim and the Ann&eacute;e Sociologique  group of writers&equo;, thus recapitulating Eliot's own interests; some &bquo;features may be found to exist in all human societies, primitive and civilized alike&equo;; the paper relates anthropology to religious belief, &bquo;with special reference to Catholic apologetics&equo;. 
 This concurrence of anthropology and Christian belief was, similarly, what attracted Eliot to Demant, who was editor of the 1944 lectures, Our Culture: Its Christian Roots and Present Crisis . 
 Demant's own chapter would have been all the more attractive to Eliot because of its wide-ranging view which combined the primitive and the sophisticated. 
 As we might speak of the culture of the Hebrides, or as W. H. Rivers wrote of the culture of Melanesia, so we speak of the culture of the European West  to describe a set of outlooks, aims and ways of life, which has a history in the past of Europe and has spread to other parts of the world. 
 Again, there seems to have been cross-fertilization between Demant's work and that of Eliot. 
 The Cocktail Party , whose first draft of three scenes was completed by June 1948, more than any other of Eliot's later plays unites the themes of savage and city. 
 This is hardly surprising, since its gestation period comprised the years in which Eliot was working on the Notes . 
 The sharp combination of savage and city along with ritual and music-hall elements do much to make this the most powerful of Eliot's comedies. 
 &bquo; The scene is laid in London ,&equo; in the tinkling, surfacy cocktail world of sophisticated chiming dialogue more realistic than that of Sweeney Agonistes , but still reminiscent of the earlier play in the chinking rhythms of its conversation. 
 The Cocktail Party  presents again a world whose moral base has been eroded, though surface conventions remain. 
 Into it comes the shamanic figure of &bquo;An Unidentified Guest&equo; who is in control of potent and primitive forces, which the other characters do not seem to understand. 
 Reilly's knowledge seems to surpass the barriers of the natural. 
 Associated with the Devil by Celia (I. ii), he is a sod of devil doctor. 
 UNIDENTIFIED GUEST. 
 &hellip; to approach the stranger Is to invite the unexpected, release a new force, Or let the genie out of the bottle. 
 It is to start a train of events Beyond your control. 
 Straddling naturalistic setting and ritual drama, Reilly is the only character who sings. 
 His song seems like a recollection of one of Eliot's music-hall favourites and heightens the unusual, ritual element of his drinking. 
 The play's strength is that it draws on Eliot's earlier work and makes that earlier work transferable to the West End, a triumph in itself; its weakness, like that of most of the plays, is that it offers us little we cannot find more concisely and intensely expressed in the poetry. 
 Edward's speech, for instance, presented  &bquo;Contre Sartre&equo;, and stating that &bquo;Hell is oneself&equo;, recalls &bquo;Thinking of the key, each confirms a prison&equo;, and Bradley on &bquo;the whole world for each&equo; as &bquo;peculiar and private to that soul&equo;. 
 Other earlier themes resurface. 
 As in &bquo;Marie Lloyd&equo; the growth of the cinema was juxtaposed against the primitive Melanesian life, so in the play the interest of Peter Quilpe and Celia Coplestone in Hollywood contrasts with the reality of the primitive world for which, eventually, Celia abandons the Hollywood dream. 
 Unreality and reality continue to cross and recross throughout the play, as do the savage and the sophisticated. 
 London chatter, beginning with tigers in India, involves themes such as Montenegro peasants, primitive Guardians, libation rituals, and unrest among natives as well as more expected Hampstead material. 
 The matter of the drama continues to be eclectic as Eliot pokes beneath the glossy city surface to hidden depths of feeling, and as so often looks to Buddhism as well as Christianity. 
 Those last words of the Buddha, which are also contrived as Reilly's last words to Celia &mdash; &bquo;Work out your salvation with diligence&equo; &mdash; look back to Eliot's 1914/ 15 essay discussing the supremely attainable good. 
 But the final juxtaposition, and the final breakthrough to illumination and an absolute religious certainty, comes about through a direct confrontation between the savage and the city, which proved shocking to the original audiences and retains some of its power to shock today. 
 Celia's death is the equivalent of the death in the desert undergone by Foucauld. 
 It shows Christianity beside the most primitive of humanity and slashes a raw strength into the London lounge. 
 The confrontation is introduced by being absurdly dismissed, in a West End version of Sweeney Agonistes , with a small side glance at L&eacute;vy-Bruhl's prelogical mentality thrown in as &bquo;The native is not, I fear, very logical.&equo; 
 From slick dialogue about eating Christians, the play moves back to the world of the cinema. 
 Peter has just come from California to make &bquo;a film of English life&equo; which will involve the reconstruction of an English residence in Hollywood. 
 He wished Celia to star in his film, but the unreality of this world is punctured by the stark reality of the ritual slaughter. 
 Celia perished trying to help some natives dying of pestilence. 
 Only traces of her body have been found.  
 ALEX. 
 It was difficult to tell. 
 But from what we know of local practices It would seem that she must have been crucified Very near an ant-hill. 
 Initially the description of Celia's death had been more savagely horrifying, describing the body's &bquo;decomposition&equo; and the way in which the tribesmen &bquo;smear the victims/ With a juice that is attractive to the ants&equo;. 
 Because of shock caused among audiences by this last line, Eliot was persuaded to alter the passage, so that it is clear that shock is only a part of a deeper message which shows how contact with the primitive can renew values of faith, self-sacrifice, and idealism which seem to have become totally atrophied in the world of London cocktail party and Hollywood film. 
 The play's message then is fundamentally religious. 
 The London socialites come to seem no more important than the savages. 
 REILLY. 
 Who knows, Mrs. Chamberlayne, The differences that made to the natives who were dying Or the state of mind in which they died? 
 Christianity is largely defined against the savage world, though the savage world is seen as an essential base and background. 
 Eliot has been careful to avoid any sort of sentimental religiosity, and this strengthens greatly the play's climax. 
 Yet it is interesting to read another speech, reluctantly dropped very late in the play's completion, which both showed Christianity in some ways working with  the savage world, and looked back with a different point of view to the earlier worship of a human god in the unpublished &bquo;Exequy&equo; poem in the Waste Land  manuscripts. 
 LAVINIA. 
 &hellip; Yet I thought your expression was one of&hellip; satisfaction! 
 Interest, yes, but not in the details. 
 ALEX. 
 There's one detail which is  rather interesting And rather touching, too. 
 We found that the natives, After we'd reoccupied the village, Had erected a sort of shrine for Celia Where they brought offerings of fruit and flowers, Fowls, and even sucking pigs. 
  They seemed to think that by propitiating Celia They might insure themselves against further misfortune. 
 We left that  problem for the Bishop to wrestle with. 
 Martin Browne's question, &bquo;Do we hear echoes of &bquo;the glittering, jewelled shrine&equo; of Thomas Becket?&equo; may be a little too direct. 
 But certainly here, for the clearest moment in Eliot's later plays the savage and the Christian are joined in reproach of the oversophisticated city;, though it is essential, too, to remember that that city also contains Sir Henry Harcourt-Reilly whom Eliot once described as possibly &bquo;a god in  the machine&equo;. 
 It is possible to see faint remnants of the city/ savage confrontation in the later plays, and Carol Smith continues to track the ritual elements in these, but the feeling in them seems to me increasingly one of whimsy and, eventually, gentle pastoral. 
 The confidential world of the city clerk persists in Eliot's poorest play which looks again to Victorian melodrama. 
 Generally, though we may have the background threat of Gomez's South American violence or past humiliation (Maisie Mountjoy brings back the music hall again), the late plays are too conventional to take us again immediately from London to Kinkanja. 
 When they return to sources they do so in an increasingly normal, quietly acceptable manner that brings a more domestic way of ending. 
 I feel utterly secure 
 In you; I am a part of you. 
 Now take me to my father. 
 This is in keeping with the conclusion of Eliot's own life. 
 These late plays show a continuing interest in moments when &bquo;life is elevated to the dignity of dance or liturgy, with a gaiety&equo;, which Eliot (perhaps with a glance at Yeats's &bquo;Lapis Lazuli&equo;) now sees as &bquo;in all great poetry, and the greater seriousness behind the gaiety. 
 It is in fact the privilege of dramatic poetry to be able to show us several planes of reality at once.&equo; 
 In the distance, still, is Sweeney Agonistes . 
 The late prose shows occasional glimpses of themes discussed earlier. 
 But these later pieces are of most use for the light they shed  on the earlier development. 
 Sometimes perhaps unlikely sources of influence are revealed, as when Eliot quotes with interest Gordon Craig's statement that &bquo;The father of the dramatist was the dancer,&equo; or continues to admire the combination of &bquo;art, ritual and music&equo; now seen as &bquo;always the handmaid of the beauty of holiness&equo;. 
 Though he now said that he was &bquo;no longer very much interested in my own theories about poetic drama, especially those put forward before 1934&equo;, the old interests which had fascinated him from his first dramatic Fragments  continued to grip him, leading to the fact that each of his dramas had as its &bquo;sort of springboard&equo; a &bquo;Greek myth&equo;. 
 In 1955 he wrote to Philip Mairet, to whom he had dedicated Notes towards the Definition of Culture , stressing that he saw ritual as an essential element in life. 
 Eliot had not altogether left behind his earlier anthropological interests. 
 1956 saw him complaining that the author of an article on &bquo;Christian Social Thought&equo; had used the word &bquo;sociology&equo; so that &bquo;unless my memory is greatly at fault, Durkheim and L&eacute;vy-Bruhl&equo; would be excluded from its province. 
 In these years he remembered, too, his early concern with the city, recording his debts to Thomson and Davidson. 
 In 1958, Eliot was still pointing out the horror of a civilization whose materialism is &bquo;simply boredom&equo;. 
 A people without religion will in the end find that it has nothing to live for. 
 I did touch on this problem a good many years ago in an essay I wrote on the death of a great music-hall artist, Marie Lloyd. 
 He was musing that the synthetic religions of Stalin and Hitler should neither of them &bquo;properly be called pagan, but if you do call them pagan then we must say that they're inferior as religions to genuine primitive pagan religion&equo;. 
 Proof that the themes of savage and city stayed in Eliot's mind to the end is furnished by one of the last pieces which he published. 
 In his &bquo;Preface&equo; to Edwin Muir's Selected Poems , he gives high praise to a poet whose work is very different from his own. 
 Finally, he is drawn to the essence of Muir's genius  which he sees as that of &bquo;the sensibility of the remote islander&equo;, and the words that follow give one final transformation of the savage and city motif, when he describes Muir as &bquo;the boy from a simple primitive offshore community who then was plunged into the sordid horror of industrialism in Glasgow, who struggled to understand the modern world of the metropolis in London&hellip; 
 &equo; Like Muir, Eliot had won through to a vision of final acceptance, which allowed him to look back even to Sweeney and to call him, at Columbia in 1958, &bquo;friend&equo;. 
 This informal remark shows an inescapable attachment to a character epitomizing one of the most fascinating, longest-lasting, and most potent aspects of Eliot's work: its binding together of the savage and the city. 
 TRAILER 
 Going to the pictures, the movies, the flicks: Seeing in the Dark  is about poetic licence in a public place under cover of darkness. 
 This is where chance comes in. 
 You're in a dreary barn of a place, its halcyon days long gone. 
 You're surrounded by strangers, your dozy curiosity in their sayings and doings dimming as the house lights go down. 
 Then a rectangle of brighter light illuminates the dusty ruched curtains as they glide towards the ceiling. 
 Your neck muscles lock, your body dematerialises. 
 Later, for a whole scene in Fritz Lang's film You Only Live Once  you find your eyes flitting from a closeup of jailbird Henry Fonda to a dancing hank of fluff stuck in the projector gate. 
 Fonda studiously ignores the hairs as he drawls to an off-screen interrogator. 
 The silhouetted fibres crave his attention. 
 Tension mounts. 
 Finally, the actor's gaze shifts across screen to fix imperiously on the audacious fluff. 
 At that very instant the fluff throws in the towel and sashays from view. 
 The audience stamps and cheers. 
 It's at moments like this that something magical happens. 
 However engaging the film sequence is in its own right it remains Henry Fonda in a 1930s thriller, a captivating spectre, but a spectre nevertheless. 
 Yet, take an accident like that hair in the gate, put it together with the coincidental gaze of a ghost, and it's as if Fonda really has come back to life. 
 It seems there can never be an absolute spectacle overpowering cowed spectators: some hair will always get in the gate. 
 We looked almost in vain at one hundred years of literature on cinema for evidence of how going to the pictures is experienced by audiences as a collective rite rich in surreal experience. 
 Film critics and reviewers are obliged to describe films seen either alone, or in the company of fellow professionals, in preview theatres, on video or in archives. 
 Academics study and analyse films in  lecture rooms. 
 Yet in public cinemas we, the customers, watch film in the shadowy company of an anonymous crowd, each one of whom, like us, lives a life of which cinemagoing is but a part. 
 Those few studies of cinema audiences that do exist have employed the methods of mass sociology and market research, which cannot fully capture the individual, subjective experience of filmgoing, since they miss out idiosyncratic detail and the personal dreamworld. 
 Measuring applause does not reveal that the movie was memorable for the woman in the third row because the building on screen reminded her of where she went to school and all those childhood memories came flooding back intercut with the film while the auditorium gently shook as an underground train passed beneath and cigarette ash fluttered down from the balcony in the projector beam. 
 And who, sitting in the stalls next to John Hinckley at a matinee of Taxi Driver, would have guessed that their neighbour's conclusion from watching the film was that, in order to prove his love for Jodie Foster, he must go out and shoot Ronald Reagan? 
 So we started by asking our friends, who in turn asked others, until we were eventually inundated with testimonies from witnesses around the world who provided popular proof that there is something about the cinema that encourages, right there in the picture house, thoughts, feelings and behaviour in its patrons by turns enigmatic, terrifying, erotic, sad, hilarious and poetic, often triggered by uncanny interplay between screen image and real-time events in the auditorium and in the world beyond the muffled doors. 
 &bquo;Alone in a crowd&equo; is never so intense as at the movies, and never so open to sudden dislocation. 
 It is the complex play between me, you, them, the film, the cinema building and the world outside that enables us, on occasion, to experience reality more completely, and as in dreams to see in the dark. 
 IAN BREAKWELL &amp; PAUL HAMMOND  
 SNOWWHITE 
 I was three years old. 
 Nobody had told me what a cinema or a film was, and certainly nothing about the concept of an animated cartoon; and I was taken into the largest enclosed space I'd ever seen, into a crowd of strangers, put on a seat, and the lights went out. 
 Figures fifteen feet high loomed over me. 
 The film was Snow White ; and I felt my sanity slipping until the moment when the queen metamorphosed into the witch. 
 Then I screamed and screamed, and could not stop. 
 My mother called an usherette to have me removed, and I was handed into strange-smelling arms behind a bright beam that dazzled me. 
 The arms hugged my squirming form and carried me out, while my mother stayed to watch the rest of the film. 
 But the exit was at the foot of the screen, and I was being borne up towards that great and drooling hag, away from safety, pinioned by someone I couldn't see, and the witch was laughing. 
 When we got home I was thrashed for making my mother &bquo;look a fool&equo;. 
 The nightmares began and have haunted me ever since. 
 The witch has my mother's face. 
 &lsqb;Alan Garner&rsqb; 
 SHADOW CAPTURE 
 There were a few dark places my parents liked to go into besides under their covers in bed. 
 You have to be amazed how young and silly they could be or how solemn with foreboding. 
 In the midst of summer when you came out, your eyes burned with sunlight and your small meaty smooth arms and legs were stung by the pavement's heat. 
 Or leaving the dark glimmering interior in winter when the ice wind bit through your leggings, mittens and embroidered button holes. 
 Darkness mysteriously filled with people. 
 Where had they come from? 
 Why had they gathered in the shadowed space? 
 They did not even all know each other, unlike a herd  of cows, a coop of chickens, or a pen of pigs in communal mud. 
 My mother pinpoints the downfall of western civilisation as the moment when a teenager turned on a transistor radio during a screening of The Robe . 
 &lsqb;GLEN BAXTER&rsqb; 
 Two ritual spaces forever commingle. 
 The castle-like stretch to interior sky twinkling with crystal lights. 
 Aroma of incense and in the distance a terrifying version of Santa Claus, haloed in light and shadow as he swung a lamp and chanted hunting sounds. 
 We were immobile on the velvet cushions, my legs sticking out, jacket and skirt velvet enveloped by soft fabric. 
 Nevertheless terror was the measure. 
 That night I began to stutter. 
 My parents often mentioned their remorse, I was speaking so well before we went to the Russian Orthodox Easter Service. 
 But Dumbo  was different. 
 We carried sticky ice cream cones into the large dark room. 
 We each had to sit in our own chair. 
 I had crawled into mine and was turning round peering into the dark where many people sat eating popcorn and candy. 
 My parents were pointing up to a beam of light and saying &bquo;Dumbo&equo;. 
 I stared at a huge rectangle of light, it was pinkish floating flickering and suddenly I saw&hellip; a pig! 
 &bquo;Piglet!&equo; 
 I yelled. 
 &bquo;Piglet!&equo; 
 Piglet was up there! 
 From the book I held on my lap! 
 Piglet who I improved with blue and green crayons was here, huge powerful incandescent unreachable and in motion! 
 I sank into an exquisite passivity staring ahead as dazzling colours flushed and flew, metamorphosing into duck elephant cat dog house. 
 My parents were happy and proud that I was finally seeing what they saw. 
 &lsqb;CAROLEE SCHNEEMAN&rsqb; 
 TIME FLIES 
 We were watching Feuillade's Judex . 
 Insulated both against the cold and the ordinary activities of the town we abandoned ourselves delightedly, there amidst countless panelled enclosures in this little cinema in the sticks, to the all-consuming comfort of another era. 
 Suddenly on the screen there appears a clock set in the centre of the kind of sumptuous salon that epoch, and Feuillade, alone had a  taste for; it shows 4.40 p.m. 
 One of us automatically consults his watch: 4.40 to the second. 
 For an instant our present, across the ruins of several decades, has rejoined that of an afternoon in the 1910s. 
 &lsqb;PETR KRAL&rsqb; 
 We were watching a documentary about Canadian sports. 
 A commentator came on and my mother froze in her seat. 
 &bquo;What's up mum?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;That's your father up there on the screen,&equo; she said. 
 It's the only time I ever saw him. 
 &lsqb;Murray Martin&rsqb; 
 TRAIL 
 A lone horseman appeared in a vast landscape, a shot rang out in the badlands, dust rose from a wagon train. 
 We crossed the park to get home. 
 My brother walked. 
 I was carried at a smooth lope by Trigger, or sometimes Silver. 
 I sat snug in the tooled leather saddle, the reins lying easily in one hand. 
 Trigger, the palomino, was obedient to the slightest pressure. 
 Thus the magic lasted, and always lasts if the images on the screen take possession. 
 &lsqb;JENNI CALDER&rsqb; 
 DONKEYS 
 We drew out of the gravel drive in a perfect crocodile. 
 I was Elizabeth's partner. 
 She wore white ankle socks; my mother preferred me to wear fawn knee-length ones, but our skirts and berets were the same except mine had a leather band inside you couldn't see. 
 Before leaving school we had knelt on the floor in a row to make sure our hem lines touched the ground, just grazed it, and then we had stood up and had our knickers checked. 
 Now we were on the move. 
 Elizabeth was German and her mother was a clockmaster. 
 I wasn't afraid of Elizabeth but I was frightened of her mother and I was glad the nuns were leading us away from the road where she lived. 
 I didn't like her clockwork elephants. 
 It was strange seeing nuns outside. 
 I felt ashamed for them. 
  We were going all the way along Pond Street. 
 We were going to see a film and I hadn't seen a film before. 
 Stage presentation preceding Men of Two Worlds. 
 London, 1945 
 We followed the nuns to the steps of a tall, gloomy building. 
 We gathered in a long, low room surrounded by pictures of donkeys and men in long striped skirts like shepherds. 
 I was afraid that I was doing something wrong. 
 Being with the nuns only made it feel worse. 
 After being counted one more time, still holding Elizabeth's hand I followed the crocodile miserably through darkened rooms. 
 I wanted to go home. 
 I was told to sit down and not move. 
 The air was smelly and dim. 
 Elizabeth helped me with the flapping chair. 
 I flattened my thin skirt between my bottom and the furry seat. 
 A silver dish like a holy water font was fastened to the seat in front of me. 
 The bowl was covered in pimples. 
 In the distance a square of light flickered and I heard music swelling. 
 I wrinkled my socks down so they didn't feel so tight, and closed my eyes. 
 When I woke up Elizabeth was crying, a huge pale donkey was breathing down my neck, and Mother Ignatius was smiling. 
 Her beautiful brown eyes looked at my face. 
 perhaps she was a donkey too. 
 Everybody sitting around me in the dark knew something that I didn't know, because they were real Catholics and I was only pretending. 
 The film was called Never Take No for An Answer , but in my ignorance I didn't even know what the question was. 
 All my friends had been transformed, their faces shone, they couldn't move, while I just rolled my tie up and down and counted the bars on the radiator. 
 &lsqb;SELIMA HILL&rsqb; 
 WORD IS OUT 
 My mother is holding my hand to stop me getting away across the foyer. 
 I'm looking at the framed portraits of the stars: Anna Neagle, Liz Taylor, Dirk Bogarde, hand coloured like the photographs that Mr Fuller tints, an elderly artist who lives across the road from my grandparents. 
 This is my  first visit to the pictures, a treat to take my mind off starting school the following Monday. 
 When Cinemascope arrived many cinemas &bquo;widened&equo; screens by cropping the picture, thus giving the desired impression. 
 So when old films were shown with projectors masked for &bquo;scope the top of the image, where the most expressive part, the human face, tends to be, was lost. 
 Halfway through Wuthering Heights  I bitterly complained. 
 Came the reply, &bquo;You're not supposed to see the faces, it's a dark film.&equo; 
 &lsqb;Raymond Durgnat&rsqb; 
 &bquo;It's the pictures,&equo; I say, pointing. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 We'll see some big  pictures in a minute though.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh&equo;. 
 I know at once that I've made a fool of myself. 
 I remember my father saying earlier that we're going to see a big television. 
 I look around at the milling people, imagining we'll be split up into smaller groups and led through the blank doors to sit in armchairs and watch a TV set on some kind of plinth. 
 I decide to keep my mouth shut about this. 
 We take our seats in the front of the circle and the cinema gradually fills. 
 A series of ornate gilt mouldings on the walls funnels down towards the brocaded red curtain, arranged into rectangles like the huge old picture frames in Mr Fuller's house, surrounding the dark oil paintings he did as a student and smuggled out of Belgium when he settled here after the Great War. 
 Nowadays he copies postcards,  cropping them to improve the composition. 
 Years later he will show me the sketches he made with mud and chalk in the trenches, of fragile running men and tangled machines, lit up by exploding shells like arrested frames of film. 
 But for now there are only the empty frames on the walls of the cinema and the rich maroon emulsion they are set against. 
 I wonder if it is here that the pictures are to appear, worrying that the seats are badly arranged, pointing the wrong way, that we won't be able to see them properly. 
 And then the lights go down. 
 The film is One Hundred and One Dalmations . 
 Its images unfold in my mind as effortlessly as a story riding on the voice of a parent, a voice so familiar it disappears, entering in the half-dark, soluble in dreams. 
 My father carries me from the car and I glide up two flights of concrete steps, suspended in midair by anti-gravity. 
 I already know that school is bad news, but behind my lids Miss Fisher and her sidekick, Lavatory-legs Spencer, are receiving diabolical tuition from Cruella De Ville. 
 The school is a locked mansion of empty, high-ceilinged rooms, of dangerous clearings and winding stairs, a country through which children travel in huddled groups of five, flattening themselves against walls while brave scouts check the route ahead and guard the rear. 
 Word is out. 
 Miss Fisher and her cackling lieutenant are hungry again. 
 I'm new in this place but you've got to learn fast or go under. 
 A girl who's managed to stay alive for a whole year takes me aside and passes on the two basic rules of survival: 1) Never get separated from the others. 
 2) Always carry a dustpan and brush. 
 The only sure method of avoiding capture, she tells me, is to walk backwards at all times, flicking every particle of dust from every footprint into the dustpan as you go. 
 That way they can't pick up your trail. 
 &lsqb;JOHN MUCKLE&rsqb;   
 Papillon has just been recaptured for the fourth time. 
 An exasperated Scouser, anxious no doubt to reach The Grapes before half ten, explodes. 
 &bquo;For fuck's sake! 
 Give up, will yer?&equo; 
 &lsqb;Chris Proctor&rsqb; 
 THE BIRD 
 By the 1960s the Regal had long since had its day. 
 It never drew large crowds and The Birds  was no exception. 
 During one of the indiscriminate assaults by the murderous flocks of birds the screaming inhabitants of the town ran to and fro in a vain attempt to ward off their attackers. 
 From the cinema itself there also came a piercing cry. 
 The lights were on in a second and the usherette was at the screamer's side. 
 The woman concerned was in a state of shock. 
 A bird had gained entry through one of the broken windows and flown helplessly around until it collided with her. 
 The woman had lashed out in fear and given the bird a fatal blow, feathers everywhere. 
 She was helped from her seat and taken to the rear of the cinema. 
 The remains of the bird were gathered up and removed. 
 &lsqb;JOHN WEGON&rsqb; 
 THE CHILD'S BRAIN 
 King Kong plunging to his death from a great height and the real death of a bird in the sky, events dramatic enough for the whirring imagination of a seven year old to cope with. 
 ln the early 1930s part of my childhood was spent at Redcar on Teesside, then as now a down at heel seaside resort surrounded by steel works and wind swept dunes. 
 Yet I hold the town close to my heart, for it is the birthplace of many a dream and memory: it is winter, it was always winter and cold, I am alone on the beach building a secret world, a sand landscape of hills, mountains, ravines with bridges, towns and harbours. 
 Of a sudden a gull which has died on the wing crashes to the sand at my feet, its feathers brushing my forehead as it falls. 
 There it lies, twitching, huge as gulls are huge, and dead, a weird visitor to my private world. 
 Of the three flea-pits the town boasted my favourite was the pavilion, at the Coatham end of the prom. 
 It was, in  truth, all that remained of what had been the North Pier, blown away by a great storm in the 1920s. 
 Films like dreams come and go and are soon forgotten, yet King Kong, which I must have seen in 1933, or early 1934, with its scenes of adventure in a fabled land, was the one to overwhelm my mind and stay with me to the present day. 
 And of those scenes my hero, for that is what Kong had quickly become, tumbling head-over-heels from the roof of the skyscraper to his death on the street was the one to dominate my mind. 
 Death from the sky, again. 
 In my child's brain he crashed at my feet as I walked through a strange city. 
 &lsqb;ANTHONY EARNSHAW&rsqb; 
 ALFRED: A TRINIDADIAN TALE 
 The last time I saw Alfred was the day the police shoot them three fellas, remember? 
 We had just come out of a 12.30 matinee and the street was burning in the sun and those who had come out of the theatre was cool and real but the others in the street were moving in a white light that had them like shadows. 
 Alfred was like us, cool and real, but as the police moved in on him things became a bit confused. 
 The film had been two of those Kung Fu films. 
 By the time I had gone through the narrow tunnel to pit the first film had already started and I had to use the reflection of the action on the faces of the audience to find a seat without too much of &bquo;Here, Here&equo; and &bquo;Sit down nuh!&equo;. 
 Then the whole 12.30 thing began like it always had since I was small. 
 The whole audience became like one and anything somebody say is like you say it. 
 That afternoon there was a voice among us that seemed to be leading the whole thing &mdash; anything he say is what we thinking, but before. 
 As I saw the circle moving in on Alfred, I realised that that voice had been his. 
 The films were real &bquo;bad&equo; &mdash; plenty action and thing &mdash; and with Alfred there, our thoughts would gather together and sweep across the screen creating  Trinidad out of China. 
 At first I thought that was why the police wanted him, because the sort of way we were thinking in there had been definitely subversive, I mean they don't teach you that in school eh! 
 But no. 
 It wasn't that ner. 
 Really, I had heard something about him being involved in some &bquo;group&equo;. 
 After he leave school he had set up some sort of agricultural commune thing, he was always a man like that, saying we were people must make the most of we community skills and thing, but he get squeeze in that farming business and last I hear of him he had gone in the hills and become a guerrilla. 
 Many films of my youth were viewed on either side of bouffant and beehive hairdos which filled the centre of the screen. 
 In the hippy era images filtered weakly through a hairy sea of tangled tresses. 
 When afros came in I gave up. 
 &lsqb;George Littleblack&rsqb; 
 So there he was, all frozen in the hot sun, I began to realise things were really serious when I see them machine guns itching to smoke in the fuzz hand. 
 All of us stand up watching as we come out of the theatre and Alfred glance up at we. 
 Me ain't know what was in that glance, but we moved in behind the police. 
 They shouted for us to stop, but we ain't take that on any more than if they were Chinese in the film, we were recreating our life like how we recreate the film. 
 We were waiting for Alfred to drop he gun, I don't know how we knew he had one but we knew, and slowly he took it out of his waist and dropped it. 
 The police relaxed and move in. 
 All of a sudden, Alfred strike one karate pose there and leap one leap on the front man, knocking him down, grabbed his machine gun and with two more leaps he was past them and through us as we open up like a black red sea and close again. 
 The police catch theyselves and rush us shouting and some start to shoot, straight into we. 
 That was when they shoot them three fellas, remember, but they ain't get Alfred. 
 He was gone. 
 &lsqb;CHRISTOPHER LAIRD&rsqb; 
 SHORT-SIGHTED DISCIPLE 
 In Iraq we have &bquo;summer cinema&equo;, usually a building next to the real cinema. 
 Because of the heat this second cinema has no roof. 
 The flat roof of our own house was high enough for  me to see two summer screens for free. 
 The trouble was they were just too far away to see things clearly, and also I couldn't hear the sound. 
 One day I suggested to my father that he buy me a pair of binoculars. 
 Thus equipped I could watch the films in comfort, switching from one screen to the other. 
 I'd go up there every night and see the same films over and again. 
 One night I saw a film about Jesus Christ. 
 There was a scene in which Christ staggers away from the camera with his cross on his back. 
 I couldn't make out what was going on so I began walking towards the image, binoculars pressed to my eyes. 
 My mother grabbed me at the very edge of the roof, just before I toppled the two storeys to the street. 
 &lsqb;SALAH FAIQ&rsqb; 
 Written in biro on a scrap of paper stuck on the kiosk window of a cinema in Bangor, Co. 
 Down: &bquo;Closed Due to Lack of People.&equo; 
 &lsqb;Noel Spence&rsqb; 
 MISSIONARY 
 Mosspark Picture House. 
 1927. 
 Saturday matinee. 
 Age four. 
 A gothic thriller. 
 The tall lantern jawed villain in top hat and tails plays an organ. 
 I am terrified and run home as fast as I can. 
 Years of nightmare. 
 Age thirty-four. 
 I buy a harmonium &mdash; nearly an organ &mdash; and spend the rest of my life playing it, thickened with doleful dirges, vainly trying to lay the trauma, my only satisfaction the ashen faced, staring eyed audiences staggering out at the end of performances, primed, and ready to carry on the good work. 
 &lsqb;IVOR CUTLER&rsqb; 
 MR POWER 
 There were four of us, and our father, who was the Wesleyan Chapel steward, knew that cinema films would overstimulate our brains, give us over to vain imaginings and, worse, tempt us to worship false gods. 
 Our mother was an East Riding woman and her regime  was enlightened and less oppressive. 
 Now and then, on Saturday afternoons, she financed a mile and a half walk to Thirsk to visit Power's Picture House. 
 But first we called at Mr Macauley's sweet shop to stock up for the frequent film changes. 
 One of the never mentioned delights of the silent cinema was that you crunched and sucked to your heart's content, annoying nobody but the piano player. 
 Now the Bijou, the Globe, the Luxor, the Roxy and the Star are bingo palaces. 
 Old ladies with thick stockings holding veins like knots of worms, and men whose eyes are duller than clay alleys dream other dreams and watched the numbered screen, killing time, hoping for a win. 
 The Empire is a supermarket now, a freezer full of TV dinners where the Gents once stood. 
 &lsqb;Mike Harding&rsqb; 
 We liked to visit Mr Macauley's shop because his furious brother George played cricket for Yorkshire. 
 You will recall that in 1926, when A W Carr disastrously won the toss and put the Australians in, it was George who bailed us out with an unbeaten 76. 
 You may not  recall that, when Edgar Oldroyd asked him how he was enjoying a long spell bowling into the wind, he answered, &bquo;It's like bowling up t'bloody cellar steps.&equo; 
 Although it was a family business I don't think Mr Power worked the projector. 
 Perhaps Mrs Power did. 
 Mr Power can't have done because now and then when rebellion stirred during overlong film repairs he rushed down the aisle cracking a whip. 
 The North Riding is a long way from London. 
 As God is my witness, he cracked a whip . 
 &lsqb;J L CARR&rsqb; 
 GENDER 
 In 1954 I was eight and every Saturday morning I would set off to the movies with my first boyfriend, ten year old Skippy. 
 For several hours we would be transported via the newsreel to the exotic East, where American soldiers were valiantly fighting the red, or was it yellow peril, and then to the Wild West, where Hoot Gibson or Eddy Dean would be showing cattle rustlers or unfriendly Indians &bquo;what America stood for&equo;. 
 We would spend the afternoon re-enacting in the parking lot behind the apartment what we had seen in the morning on the screen. 
 It was then that I began to discover the fate that awaited me as a female. 
 Whilst I saw myself as the hero's faithful sidekick got up as I was in cowboy gloves with real leather fringes, two guns in holsters buckled on  and tied around the leg for fast draws, ten gallon hat and waistcoat, Skippy insisted that I be the daughter of the murdered rancher whose cattle were being rustled. 
 Gradually it began to dawn on me that while in the celluloid world all things were possible, in the other world it was quite a different story. 
 &lsqb;Had I been more perceptive I might have noticed that even in the movies women were always the rancher's daughter.&rsqb; 
 Years later, on the day our first child was due to be born, when it became obvious that the birth was not imminent, my husband Roger suggested that we go to a film to take our minds off the event. 
 The nearest film was a Canadian thriller called Shivers . 
 It turned out to be a story about the residents of a block of flats being used as breeders by aliens, who implant their offspring into the unsuspecting humans. 
 On reaching maturity they begin to wriggle furiously, eventually emerging via the startled human's mouth amid much blood and wailing. 
 Just as the film was reaching its climax my firstborn began one of his frequent exercise periods. 
 So lost was I in the film that for an awful moment I too was about to spawn one of the dreadful aliens. 
 &lsqb;MARLENE WINFIELD&rsqb; 
 A WOMAN'S PREROGATIVE 
 Something is troubling the curly-haired boy I'm playing with in the backyard of my grandparents' house. 
 His name is Christopher. 
 We've been prowling around all day on a level with earthworms and rusty, broken down appliances, pressing our ears against the hot wooden trapdoor to the cellar and hearing the silence of ghosts. 
 &bquo;Do you know what The Beatles are?&equo; he asks, letting me climb into his baby pedal car. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Beatles aren't boys, like us. 
 They're men.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know.&equo; 
 I'm eight and a half years old and disgusted that my mother has to come with me to see A Hard Day's Night   when usually she just sees me to the edge of the estate and across the main road. 
 I introduced Alice Guy's 1913 silent film A House Divided . 
 Halfway through the film broke, the houselights came up, and I was accosted by a wino. 
 He insisted that the female lead had worked in Woolworths in Plymouth and he retained an unrequired passion for her. 
 He grabbed me by the throat and began throttling me, all the while demanding her address. 
 &lsqb;Judith Higginbottom&rsqb; 
 &bquo;It's for the kids,&equo; she says to Freda Leader, our next door neighbour. 
 &bquo;Why do they want to go putting an &bquo;A&equo; on with it?&equo; 
 But when she sees the Teds and greasers and hard-faced girls who make up the matinee audience, she thinks it's just as well. 
 We take our seats half way up the stalls. 
 Below us rows of lads have put their winklepickers up on the backs of the seats, their feet crossed at the ankles, perching like a flock of shiny blackbirds with pointed wings. 
 &bquo;All right, missus?&equo; says a boy with a floppy quiff, turning round. 
 My mother's ears are burning and she squirms in her seat. 
 I begin to pronounce the sequence of words and numbers that will prevent her from giving him a piece of her mind. 
 Then the first film starts. 
 It's called A Woman's Prerogative . 
 &bquo;Of course, he didn't understand any of it, so that was all right,&equo; she says later to Freda Leader, in a whisper that echoes around the landing. 
 &bquo;1 mean, how could he know what a woman's prerogative is?&equo; 
 She laughs uncertainly. 
 &bquo;I wasn't sure I knew myself.&equo; 
 That night I lie awake in bed for hours, thinking about this. 
 I remember nothing from the film except a lot of droning talk and a fully clothed woman with dark lashes lying down. 
 What exactly is  a woman's prerogative? 
 I go through every part of the female body in turn. 
 Bosoms, bottoms, the lot. 
 Suddenly I realise that there must be another part, something like a gap, a hole left by the word I don't understand. 
 &lsqb;JOHN MUCKLE&rsqb; 
 NATURALISTS 
 Nineteen fifty two and mother and I were in Bordeaux. 
 My father had excused himself. 
 He had to look after his dahlias. 
 My mother, an innocent at home, aghast when told that &bquo;sod&equo; might mean other than &bquo;earth&equo;, was abroad easily  befriended by complete strangers. 
 This time they were naturalists. 
 In stature Don Quixote and Sancho Panza. 
 We drank evening coffee with them. 
 They corrected our accents. 
 The larger one claimed to be minor aristocracy. 
 For the weekend they suggested their camp. 
 &bquo;So much to see, so much to learn&equo;. 
 We caught a late bus out of Bordeaux and arrived in darkness. 
 We were shown our chalet, and then hurried along to the cinema to join the other camp residents. 
 Being shortsighted I moved to the front while my mother stayed at the back. 
 The film was of large happy female peasants dancing, with garlands held aloft. 
 I became aware that my mother was pushing her way towards me. 
 Her face was flushed with excitement. 
 &bquo;The men aren't wearing trousers,&equo; she stage whispered. 
 I looked at her, then behind me. 
 They all had jumpers on but she was right, definitely no trousers. 
 It is part of the tradition of naturism: no matter how cold you are, off come the pants. 
 &lsqb;HILARY PHILLIPS&rsqb; 
 CUT FOR CUT 
 Zaragoza is a windy town. 
 I think that is why it has so many cinema fans and why the best cinema creators in Spain come from there. 
 When I was ten the civil war started. 
 Films were not imported in the fascist zone. 
 Distributors showed repeatedly the old films from their stocks. 
 I must have seen De Mille's Cleopatra  a dozen times. 
 I used to stay until Claudette Colbert was unrolled from the Persian carpet, then I left. 
 Cinema was not just an entertainment for our generation. 
 It was a medicine, an antidote to the monstrous reality outdoors. 
 Films reflected another world, where comfort, joy and love were possible. 
 Movies were life and reality, and what happened in the murderous streets an absurd nightmare. 
 Censorship, dictated by the military and Catholic priests, cut a lot. 
 Dubbing films became obligatory by law, and they  took advantage of it to change the dialogue. 
 In their anxiety to eliminate sinful love they presented lovers as relatives, thus transforming the boring Hollywood sex code into a frolic of perversions. 
 We could see Garbo kissing her father in a most peculiar way, and Ava Gardner seducing her brother, Clark Gable, in Mogambo . 
 At sixteen I discovered an old man who exhibited silent films in villages. 
 He rented me a projector, and because he wanted to retire sold his movies to me for a few pesetas a twelve-reeler. 
 Some of the classics were in excellent condition, as he had seldom showed them. 
 They later became part of the collection of the National Film Library. 
 But most of the material was falling to pieces. 
 I had to learn to cut off the rotten celluloid and splice together the usable bits. 
 When projecting the resulting film the jump cuts of the narrative could produce interesting surprises. 
 Soon I mixed in bits of different movies: Lady Windermere looking down from her balcony and seeing&hellip; whatever! 
 Most of my splicing I did at random, automatically. 
 When I had completed a two hour programme my friends came to my home and we saw it together. 
 The Bunuel family was particularly fond of these programmes. 
 And that was the start of the first film society in Spain during the Franco dictatorship. 
 &lsqb;J F ARANDA&rsqb;   
 Doomed cinema, Madrid (photo: Andrew Greaves, 1985) 
 GOLD RUSH RUE EVERLOR 
 The war was over. 
 The family were staying with a friend of my grandmother's in La Ciotat, a small harbour town near Marseille, our normal home. 
 I remember a dark apartment, ships' masts, a smell of tar, iron and iodine, grownups. 
 My father said, &bquo; je vais t'emmener au cinema ce soir voir La Ru&eacute;e vers l'or .&equo; 
 &equo; I am going to take you to the pictures tonight to see The Gold Rush .&equo; 
 I did not know what &bquo;cinema&equo; was, it was one of those wonderful and unimaginable pleasures like La Semaine de Suzette  and its doll Bleuette, which the war had taken away. 
 Grown-ups would evoke them discreetly, so as not to make you envious, not to corrupt you with impossible desires. 
 They would say, &bquo; Avant guerre, tu vois, il y avait &hellip;&equo; 
 &equo; Before the war, there was&hellip;&equo; 
 My grandmother had a beautiful satin box with flowers painted on the cover. 
 She hoarded ribbons in it. 
 She said, &bquo;You see, before the war, this was given to me as a present, and it was full of chocolates.&equo; 
 I could not imagine what they were, apart from an unattainable marvel, part of a world gone for ever. 
 I thought that the ribbons were beautiful, all the colours of the bunch of flowers painted on the cover. 
 Now all these things were returning, one by one. 
 Cinema was one of them. 
 We went late one evening. 
 I remember dark streets, and walking hand in hand with my father. 
 I had misunderstood the name of the film, and not dared ask too many questions. 
 You were supposed to be bright if you took things in quickly. 
 I liked to play at being bright. 
 I had vaguely understood something about a press of people, and was surprised to see the streets so empty. 
 I had heard, not La Ru&eacute;e vers l'or, &bquo;ru&eacute;e'  being quite outside the bounds of my vocabulary, but &bquo;La rue Everlor&equo;. 
 Everlord, Everlaure, H&eacute;verlore, Aiverlaur? 
 It would be foreign, magical. 
 Each of the streets through which we went might have led to it. 
 I remember I kept saying, &bquo;Is this it?&equo; and my father said, &bquo;No, a bit further.&equo; 
 I loved my father, and he loved me. 
 It was so intense and we were both so strung up, uneasy about it. 
 But exalted. 
 All this spare passion between us, which we did not know how to show. 
 So we were exceedingly well-behaved towards each other. 
 I was promising myself to be  very quiet, whatever it would be. 
 He was coaxing me to walk a bit further without having to carry me, by promising that it was just a bit further. 
 It was all part of the Rue Everlor. 
 When he did say &bquo; nous voil&agrave; !&equo; 
 I just didn't get it. 
 It was a house, a kind of shop with a rather dingy entrance. 
 People were queueing to get in, but without ration stamps. 
 I never twigged what the gold rush was. 
 It took me years to finally comprehend. 
 But the house hanging over the cliff got me into agonies of suspense, and I was amazed, when the dark came without bombs, by how the black on the screen, especially the black of Charlie Chaplin's suit, his moustache, hat and rolling intense eyes, fitted the darkness of the little cinema. 
 And how the white, the snow, the sheet that was the screen, was the light, and you forgot yourself when you were watching. 
 The hunger that made Charlie, Charlot, chew the boiled slices of boot, moustache toing and froing under his nose, I understood as well or as little as the hunger of the grown-ups around me, my mother eating the woodworms along with the oats and the silence as everybody stopped to watch her. 
 I was lucky, thin as a rail and never hungry. 
 I remember the terror though: when the bear comes out of the wood and stalks after unsuspecting Charlot on the steep, cliff-edged mountain path. 
 I remember screaming and my scream breaking into ecstatic laughter and relief as the bear, instead of eating Charlot, started walking splay-footed in imitation of him, then went back into the wood. 
 Yes, the war was over. 
 And Charlot never even noticed. 
 &lsqb;NICOLE WARD JOUVE&rsqb; 
 WAR GAMES 
 Now aged seventy-four I have lived the past fifty years within hailing distance of Earl Grey's monument: he of the 1832 Reform Act. 
 Towering over the modern centre of Newcastle, the provincial capital of the north east, and facing Tyne-wards, he surveys the ancient city. 
 I was born  into the war torn world of May 1915 in a mile long street of two storey houses strategically located between Wallsend railway station and Wallsend drill hall. 
 It was the kind of street that money-grabbing, rather than socially inspired, landlords provided, and thus created their lasting and unenviable reputation. 
 No bathroom, no indoor water and an outside ash closet. 
 The back lane could have provided the set for Chaplin's The Kid . 
 The wartime government had promised the troops they would return to &bquo;homes fit for heroes to live in&equo;, but the sick joke was that you had to be a hero to survive in them. 
 I remember black faced miners and not so black faced shipyard workers passing to and fro to the nearby yards or the &bquo;G&equo; pit at the end of the street. 
 Much more inspiring and less frequent were the sight and sounds of soldiers marching to war from drill hall to station. 
 Less inspiring was the sight of those returning. 
 By 1919 the number of soldiers began to decrease and the numbers of unemployed to increase. 
 My father was one of them, and when &bquo;Buddy Can You Spare a Dime?&equo; topped what was then the hit parade, its lyrics summed up the poverty, dependence and despair of the millions of poor throughout the world. 
 We all knew how little and how vital a dime was. 
 A few ex-soldiers volunteered for the White Army, an unsuccessful venture designed to strangle the Russian Revolution at birth. 
 But most of them stood on street corners. 
 Nothing will ever feel as real as those times. 
 No other world will take me so fully into its secret ways. 
 No oranges will taste the same as those we ate on t hose Saturday mornings, saving the peel to throw at the screen when Roy Rogers brought out his guitar to serenade Dale Evans across a Texas campfire that was flickering in an enchanted cave in a Manchester street. 
 &lsqb;Mike Harding&rsqb; 
 On first seeing All Quiet on the Western Front  it was as if the whole cast had marched through my life on their way to Wallsend station and the battlefields of Europe. 
 With a little imagination I envisaged the hopes and fears, and the overwhelming horrors these young men had to face. 
 When Lew Ayres reached out to that ephemeral alighted butterfly his expression revealed the most delicately sensitive emotion I had experienced until then. 
 In a flash a sniper, who could have been any gun happy soul anywhere, had killed. 
 That contrast of tender sensibility and senseless brutality was etched into my mind, exposing the utter meaninglessness of violence and war. 
 By the time I was ten it seemed I had lived backstage to so many of those early film sets. 
 It was the revolutionaries who were the villains, the Royals and their supporters the  good and kind and handsome heroes. 
 Their  enemies were villains with downturned mouth and black moustache, not then Russian, always French. 
 The crowds that lined the roads on the way to the guillotine looked much like most of the people in Wallsend. 
 And the women seemed to knit the same kind of loops my mother did. 
 The next street towards the River Tyne was under the railway arch. 
 Hadrian Road was named after the Roman emperor who, we agreed, must have genetically bequeathed to us some superlative qualities. 
 What more natural then that we could hang up our football boots, change into our French cavaliers' outfits or as quickly become Roman gladiators? 
 Ben Hur's chariot race was re-enacted around the Roman Wall, too neatly preserved in Wallsend Park. 
 With iron gords, or hoops as the rich people called them, and with clashes and tensions no less thrilling and dangerous than the real thing, we competitively raced until we dropped. 
 Then our ash closets were exchanged for flush toilets. 
 The new metal dustbins were quickly lidless. 
 Armed with wooden swords, cardboard breast plates, and now shields, we set off with renewed enthusiasm. 
 Hand to hand fighting dominated our imagination as if right and wrong, good and bad, had to be decided in violent confrontation on the spot or at some predetermined location. 
 And the reward, as our film heroes had it, was the beautiful lady. 
 Alas, we always had to return to our cobbled back lanes. 
 If, as frequently happened, two of us would fall out and come to blows, then passers-by would stop, form a circle and watch without intervening, confirming their view that justice would be achieved this way. 
 The short is a film about sailing. 
 It turns its attention to the Isle of Wight Regatta. 
 &bquo;Ever since the days of Queen Victoria,&equo; runs the commentary, &bquo;the Royal Family has been associated with Cowes&equo;. 
 Round of applause at the Chelsea Odeon. 
 &lsqb;Chris Proctor&rsqb; 
 As I took my place with two jamjars in my first Saturday morning kids matinee queue, apprehensive lest the currency had been devalued or even replaced with money, I observed that not only were Royals the heroes in the films but that my choice of cinema was between the Queens and the Royal, and I was warned that before the performance you were supposed to stand for the pianist's rendition of &bquo;God Save the King&equo;. 
 I took against this practice and reflected later that &bquo;God Save the people of Wallsend&equo; would have been more appropriate, for few in authority cared much, let alone had the power to assuage the people's  meagre needs. 
 Foyer display with live bat, London, 1960 
 Then we moved into a street called Portugal Place. 
 Not even the most persuasive estate agent could have produced one environmental reason for moving there; but it was a miner's house and rent free. 
 Certainly my mother's successful campaign to have the nearby men's urinal closed was vigorous and rewarding. 
 The town's mortuary adjoined the urinal. 
 At that time it would provide a resting place for six to ten clients a week, and the arrival of each one had the macabre side of me guessing what kind of corpse it was. 
 On odd nights that would worry me but in time I realised they were the kind of neighbours who never caused a disturbance. 
 But there was a third amenity, and vitally essential it was: the corporation depot, with its stables and Clydesdale horses and endless line of carts. 
 Horse manure, horse muck or just plain horse shit, depending on your susceptibilities, was a much needed and highly effective fertiliser for the allotments, and so from an early age a daily chore was to keep an eye open for droppings, grab your shovel and bucket and run out to scoop it up. 
 Portugal Place was to the supply of horse shit what Wimbledon &bquo;insiders&equo; are to Centre Court tickets on final days. 
 You could almost stand and wait for a horse to deliver. 
 I want you to recall with me Chaplin in City Lights . 
 Charlie has taken a street sweeper's job to earn the money to pay off the cruel landlord who would otherwise put a blind girl and her mother out onto the streets. 
 It was like that in Wallsend in those days. 
 In addition Charlie needs to raise enough money to finance an operation to restore the girl's sight. 
 No money, no sight: the way it was before the National Health Service came to Wallsend. 
 Imagine Charlie with his sweeping brush and shovel neatly disposing of a pile of horse droppings and then, looking into the camera, observing a passing elephant. 
 A twitch of his moustache, a movement of the eyebrow, and what else did he need to do? 
 When the new sighted flower girl sees not a handsome, well groomed, six foot Adonis her eyes reveal something different. 
 You see he was a hero , a social hero, a small guy, a fall guy, not necessarily a brave or courageous guy, usually the opposite. 
 Chaplin was telling me that such  people don&equo; t qualify for medals or monuments, unlike those who fight and kill or wound, or are killed or wounded. 
 I was and remain a supporter of Chaplin's view. 
 &lsqb;T DAN SMITH&rsqb; 
 SEARCH LIGHT FOR QUALITY 
 &bquo;Rotting Hill! 
 Shocking Hill!&equo; was the 52 bus conductor's cabaret turn on his every approach to Notting Hill. 
 And so it was with the Notting Hill Gate Classic cinema around 1969. 
 At one late-night show the main picture was projected in the reel order 1, 2, 5, 4, 6, 3, 7. 
 The line I took with the manager was that, as a composer of music for films, I really needed to see equal commitment all along the picture beam to the public. 
 &bquo;I don't see any other dissatisfied customers&equo; was his reply. 
 This cinema had also capitalised on the psycho-acoustic phenomenon prevalent in rock music of suggesting heightened intensity with &bquo;fuzz&equo;: the speaker cone had plainly blown, rendering all dialogue and music as if through comb and paper. 
 And the projector's arc lamps were not so much set as sunset, through a fog. 
 How poignantly vignetted was the ice in Alexander Nevsky , but Eisenstein would have stabbed the projectionist with icicles. 
 &lsqb;RON GEESIN&rsqb; 
 ANTHEM 
 When we attended film shows in the RAF the National Anthem was played before the picture, accompanied by film footage of the Queen riding side saddle down Horse Guards Parade. 
 We had wagers on how many times the horse's prick bounced back and forth in the time it took to cross the Parade. 
 Arguments were fierce: some said six, some six and a half, some seven. 
 As we all stood to  attention in the darkened cinema, singing the anthem, we Would count them off: &bquo;God save our &mdash; one &mdash; gracious Queen &mdash; two &mdash; Long live our &mdash; three &mdash; noble Queen &mdash; four.&equo; 
 &lsqb;ALF MACGABHAN&rsqb; 
 I saw tombs open and the terrifying silhouettes of walking corpses set out on the road. 
 That night I couldn't close my eyes, the slightest creaking of the furniture announcing the imminent arrival of the undead. 
 My screams of terror awoke my parents and brought them rushing in panic to my room. 
 &lsqb;Nelly Kaplan&rsqb; 
 WITNESSES 
 Try watching Witness  in Dublin, where the inhabitants use films as an aid to conversation. 
 Every appearance of the boy Samuel is greeted with, &bquo;Ah, doesn't he just remind you of Kevin/Michael/little Christy? 
 Sure, they're all coming up on the bus from Mullingar/Limerick/Cork on Friday for the whole weekend.&equo; 
 Even when Samuel is facing death by having his throat cut in the Gents the exchange goes like this, &bquo;Mother of Mary, that reminds me of my poor Joseph going. 
 Didn't he have the anaemia, and the Hodgkiss, and a touch of leukaemia too. 
 How's your own then?&equo; 
 &lsqb;ROGER WAKELING&rsqb; 
 BEST OF BRITISH 
 The Odd Hour Cinema, Nottingham, the 1950s. 
 You went in, you came out; whenever you felt like it. 
 Through a tiny door off the dry page of the street, from the cold light of day to sitting in womb-like blackness. 
 Where did the giant images come from? 
 I didn't know. 
 I knew only that they happened there in the darkness and only a few feet from the pavements. 
 The blackness enveloped so warm and close and, I believed, extended infinitely away from the street on all sides, something that made any street plan impossible. 
 And I believed that this world of darkness and changing images went on without a break, as unceasingly as the other less real one outside, wherever outside was, and by some unlikely philanthropic gesture of the city corpo-  ration was allowed to co-exist and be connected by the little dark doors with dark portholes. 
 In the darkness I felt in the hands of God, someone who could do anything He liked with me, even though that someone was more likely to be Mr Slieman, the manager, who with his pencil moustache looked more like a used car salesman and was constantly trying to show Louise, the cashier and kiosk girl, his collection of prophylactics. 
 You left the cinema your hand in your pocket clutching a non-existent &bquo;rod&equo;, you went rat a tat tat Chicago piano machine gun style and did a James Cagney hoodlum staggering along the pavement with your hands to your chest until you collapsed into a doorway mown down by gangsters' bullets crying for Pat O'Brien or Joan Blondell to take the message to ma. 
 It was a great way to die. 
 &lsqb;Arthur Moyse&rsqb; 
 The Dale cinema. 
 Early 1960s. 
 A time of endless summer evenings, Bobby Rydell and Bobby Vee. 
 The last drainpiped leg of the Teddy boy era. 
 And the last show at this austere palace in the area of Nottingham full of smoke and even less substantial youthful dreams. 
 The one would be abolished by the Clean Air Act and the others would die and disappear one by one, passing through the gates of the fatal factories close by. 
 The final curtain as it was for so many cinemas at this time, before they became cash and carry warehouses for bowls and colanders, brushes, clothes pegs, cloths and uncountable tons of things being produced in orange plastic. 
 After that they slipped into anonymity, disappearing altogether into the buildings surrounding them, turning into workshops for alloy welding and serious industrial accidents. 
 The Dale, perhaps for the only time in its short life, was full. 
 The word &bquo;anticipatory&equo; falls limply from its first syllable in its attempt to describe the atmosphere, recharged from row to row. 
 Young next to old, doing-well next to down-and-out: a heterogeneous mass present for its own mutually exclusive reasons. 
 The buzz, the uninhibited, excited talking, yes, uninhibited talking, in a district where you were made to feel peculiar if you allowed any expression to cross your face in the street, died as the lights slowly faded. 
 Complete darkness. 
 Then, in that second of hushed silence before the screen and fanfare blaze out, there came from the middle of the auditorium a huge and shocked voice &bquo;What the fookin''ell are yo&equo; doin'? ', followed almost at once by two mighty smacks that could only have been someone being hit. 
 The fanfare seized up on its first chord and then seemed to fall over itself, collapsing in a welter of notes. 
 The first frame of the programme appeared for a moment, juddered, then disappeared. 
 The  lights came up and we were not in that magic world beyond the screen but back in the familiar tawdry surroundings of Sneinton, Notts. 
 A gargantuan Teddy boy was standing in the stalls, looking down at his feet. 
 The seat next to him was now empty. 
 The torches, that had from the back played on and around him like searchlights finding the enemy, were switched off. 
 Disbelief vied with sideboards as extensive and useless as Chesil Bank for domination of his face. 
 He looked up and all the way round; all eyes were on him. 
 He pointed down under the seats: the edge of a shabby raincoat could just be seen. 
 In a voice full of virginal astonishment he said, &bquo;'E were touchin' me fookin' cock.&equo; 
 A B western hero hiding up a gully while the posse rush blindly past was believable. 
 This was not. 
 The police arrived, three stripes followed by a constable. 
 There was some cheering. 
 It was a great performance by the sergeant as he strolled up to The Mighty Tharg. 
 The PC seemed a trifle unnerved playing to a full house. 
 The sergeant spoke inaudibly to the Ted and they began to escort him out, one on each side. 
 Halfway up the aisle the Ted turned his head again to the packed house and in the same pained voice of injured innocence repeated, &bquo;'E were touchin' me fookin' cock.&equo; 
 It was a low-down dirty day. 
 I was leading the life of a bat in a dark hole, eating candy and gobbling images. 
 I plugged my naked feet in between the empty seats as tears rolled down my cheeks. 
 I've learned to cry silently during movies. 
 &lsqb;Lynne Tillman&rsqb; 
 The Scala in the 1960s showed all-night horror films. 
 There were as usual only a few lone silent figures, sitting in isolation. 
 One, after watching the first two films, was hunched at the end of a row, asleep and snoring. 
 Except this time there was another, a thin, raincoated, restless figure. 
 I watched his silhouette moving from seat to seat, watching the others, shuffling and sidling closer, sometimes stopping as if uncertain, but then moving again until he was next to someone. 
 Then he'd sit for a while, occasionally glancing at the figure next to him, until at last he'd lean towards the other's ear. 
 The response was to push him off or to move away or no response at all. 
 Then the silhouette looked round again and began to move towards someone else. 
 An all-nighter was a triumph of will and my eyelids were already dropping, but I kept my eyes on the thin figure. 
 He would get to me soon. 
 Though the film was running I had seen no staff in the cinema for hours. 
 The film, Mr Sardonicus , was about a man whose face has frozen into a  wide and terrible corpse-like grin. 
 The silhouette sat down next to the snoring man, and looked hard at him. 
 I felt uneasy. 
 The thin figure leaned over and whispered in the sleeper's ear. 
 The man screamed, fell off his seat, and rolled down the aisle to the front. 
 He was awake by then, as was everyone else. 
 The thin figure had slipped through the velvet curtains and was away. 
 Halfway through Hush, Hush, Sweet Charlotte  big white subtitles came up saying YOUR MOTHER IS GOING TO DIE. 
 For weeks afterwards I prayed for her, though I'm not religious and she seemed as fit as ever. 
 Then one day my father sat me down and said, &bquo;Lisa, I have some bad news I'm afraid.&equo; 
 I interrupted him and said, &bquo;It's about mother isn't it? 
 I know already. 
 I went to see a film last month and the film told me.&equo; 
 &lsqb;Lisa Montague&rsqb; 
 The Odeon, St Albans, the 1970s. 
 The film Shivers , a real horror of bloody worm-like parasites the size of Errol Flynn's penis. 
 In front of me five youths, age seventeen, leaning back, arms spread, cool, sniggering and making jokes, pretending not to be frightened. 
 Next to me a girl eating a box of liquorice torpedoes. 
 On the screen a woman nonchalantly opens the lid of a washing machine and out leaps one of the Things. 
 Everyone in the cinema, everyone except the five youths, jumps and screams. 
 The box of liquorice torpedoes leaves the hand of the girl next to me. 
 As if in a slow motion sequence from a Peckinpah film I see the torpedoes escape from the box, turn head over tail as they rise, reach their zenith, and begin falling again, towards the heads and shoulders of the youths in front. 
 The sweets land. 
 The youths jump up, shouting with terror and disgust and begin waving their arms about, flapping at the air, furiously brushing their hair and shirts. 
 Jumping up they have made everyone else jump again. 
 Then they see the torpedoes. 
 They laugh now, but are shaking with the release of tension. 
 Everyone laughs, not at them but with them. 
 The youths are still standing, trembling laughing. 
 They meet the eyes of others. 
 They admit their fear. 
 Everyone is shivering together. 
 It is a lovely moment. 
 A little place on the Tottenham Court Road. 
 The 1980s. 
 The sort of place that still does double features, which it was doing that bright sunny afternoon. 
 My wife and I went up to the pay booth. 
 A friendly Asian face looked through at us, gave us our tickets, and pointed to the black double doors further in. 
 We paused at the kiosk. 
 The face disappeared from the pay booth and appeared again in front of us and sold us a packet of sweets. 
 We went on towards the double doors. 
 The friendly little Asian appeared from another door and held his hands out for our tickets. 
 He tore them, passed half back to us, pointed to the doors again and  said, &bquo;Anywhere you like.&equo; 
 I opened the black doors and we entered. 
 From behind the screen curtains an organ played a jolly tune. 
 There was no one else in the cinema. 
 It seemed so sad I could have cried. 
 We sat down. 
 After a minute or two the Asian suddenly slid out from the side of the big curtains and then stopped, a tray of drinks and ice creams round his neck. 
 He just stood there, right at the front with the curtains at his back, staring into the auditorium. 
 We stared back; there was nowhere else to look. 
 I had to walk down and buy something, lots of things. 
 He smiled and said &bquo;Thank you&equo; as if he'd never seen me before, as did I. I went back to my seat and faced the front again. 
 He stayed there a little longer, then disappeared back into the curtains. 
 The organ went on playing. 
 I wondered if it was him, playing on a pre-recorded tape; or his brother. 
 Whose face would it be, looking through the small square window behind us? 
 The films started and finished on time. 
 He was there at the end, opening the double doors for us. 
 We went out into the bright sunny street. 
 The traffic and the crowds were passing interminably in each direction, as they had been all the time. 
 If the cinema is right the film need hardly matter. 
 Mr Slieman may still be spending most of his working day shuffling ever closer to Louise, unaware or uninterested in the magic he and his house create. 
 But it is still there: the soaring vague walls and giant secretive curtain washed with colours you've only dreamt about, the colour of all the things you were never allowed to have as a child, suddenly real and there before you. 
 &lsqb;ROGER WAKELING&rsqb; 
 THE PERSIAN PANTHEON 
 Siah Armanjani once told me how he used to see the movies in his native Persia in the 1950s. 
 He said there was a person, famous throughout the land, whose job it was to visit the halls where films were being shown and to describe the films to the local people. 
 This man provided a  running commentary on the events on the screen, which were otherwise a fabulous mystery. 
 His non-stop verbal explications, declaimed as he strode up and down the crowded aisles, described the gods and mythology and history of the people of Persia; and his improvisation fitted what was happening in the film as the hair fits the head. 
 In this way were seen Gone With the Wind  and All Quiet on the Western Front : as events in the nation's history, peopled by characters from the Persian pantheon. 
 At the same time, our poet's impromptu verses &mdash; often he hadn't seen the film before &mdash; were in the complex scheme of Persian poetry, rhyming, scanning, and so on. 
 Armanjani reported to me that at the height of his powers our man sometimes accompanied a two hour programme of film trailers spliced together. 
 The popular poet's imagination, skill and learning could concoct, at that instant, a sustained story with a cast of hundreds that linked all those wars, love affairs, catastrophes, comedies and come-what-may into a coherent whole. 
 During a scene in W C Fields' The Bank Dick  in which men were digging a trench in the road I became aware that my feet felt cold and wet. 
 Looking down I saw they were in a puddle of water that hadn't been there at the start and seemed to be oozing out of the ground. 
 &lsqb;Ian Breakwell&rsqb; 
 Since Siah told me this story about a supreme storyteller, 1 have told the story myself many times. 
 I think it has grown in the telling. 
 &lsqb;PATRICK HUGHES&rsqb; 
 GUN LORE 
 As a child I was given a grey plastic gun as a birthday present. 
 Working on the torch principle the gun became a simple projector. 
 Hinged along its top edge, it was possible to open the gun so that a film loop could be inserted round its profile. 
 Two small batteries fitted the butt while the beam escaped at the muzzle. 
 One of my greatest pleasures was to load my gun, draw the curtains in my bedroom and then crawl under the bed. 
 I was now completely in the dark and it was here that I would shoot whatever film I had onto the skirting board of my makeshift cinema. 
 &lsqb;LES COLEMAN&rsqb;  
 BEING 
 I was the bad gunslinger who was new in town, and the snot-faced boy who wore army boots but no socks was the good cowboy. 
 As agreed, he swung a punch to my chin so that I should rise in an elegant arc of slow motion to fall sprawled in a dramatic contortion on the bar room floor. 
 I fell hard against the asphalt playground and I felt the pain that had not been visible on film. 
 When my brother looked through his new spectacles into the Cinemascope format of the wide mirror I saw that he gently let his lower jaw fall a little so as to give himself more of the thin-faced appearance of Hank R Marvin in Summer Holiday . 
 Once, when he was the centre of attention at the youth club I saw him do it again. 
 The other people seemed not to notice. 
 They were all being in other films. 
 &lsqb;TIMOTHY EMLYN JONES&rsqb; 
 ESSOLDO AND ENVIRONS 
 For me, movies and play were enmeshed during childhood, a certain cinema and its environs being both stimulus and setting for my juvenile adventures to the extent that, thirty years later, its contours and hidey holes still haunt my dreams. 
 When not submitting to its weekly invasion by hordes of kids, the back and sides of the Deco-fronted Essoldo in Chaddesden bore silent witness to our after-school games. 
 This monolith sat atop an escarpment which accommodated the raking of the auditorium and the levelled hardcore of a car park, and cast its long shadow over an adjacent bit of parkland, a cosy corner of scrub, stream and wood that drew me and my friends to it like a magnet. 
 We rarely played close to the building which, when not lit up, had something of the baleful haunted house about it. 
 And the car park was too rutted and stony to permit ball games, far too exposed to sustain our hiding and seeking, tick and  nicking. 
 This car park was not without charm, however. 
 In wet weather it was a site for spectacular puddles, a mucky moat from which the picture house rose like a medieval castle. 
 In one corner of the lot was a sad, wet-rotten arch which bore the legend &bquo;For Patrons Only&equo;. 
 just what was a &bquo;patron&equo; I wondered? 
 In another corner was an equally decrepit cabinet which displayed a handful of publicity stills that were changed twice weekly, along with the dayglo signwriting on the marquee, as if by legerdemain. 
 One day we were poking around in some sodden ashes by the rear exit and found a few slivers of celluloid with images on them. 
 In trying to conceal his negligence the projectionist had provided me with tangible evidence of the grand illusion. 
 I couldn't be sure how, but felt that a truth had been revealed. 
 At the height of the Teddy boy era the local cinema foolishly premiered Rock Around the Clock  on bonfire Night. 
 Bangers punctuated the soundtrack, snow fountains cascaded in the aisles, and the film ended abruptly when a five-bob rocket went straight through Bill Haley's open mouth. 
 &lsqb;George Littleblack&rsqb; 
 Come five o&equo; clock on a Saturday afternoon you'd bundle your way out of the pictures, delirious with image overload, to be hit between the eyes by the blinding light of day and a balmy blanket of heat. 
 You'd hesitate to drink in the hallucinatory detail of the visual field, to assimilate the odd distancing of natural sound, before joyously plunging with your cronies into your outdoor make-believe. 
 The park was reached via a slippery slope. 
 As we slid at speed down the escarpment we took care to avoid nettles and barbed wire, then we'd squeeze between the splintery struts of the Essoldo's picket fence. 
 Once through, we really cut loose. 
 This bit of park had just enough hint of wilderness to be readily transformed in imagination into prairie, canyon, rain forest, river delta, open sea. 
 Our hinterland of the imaginary actually consisted of grass tussocks, brambles, a grove of willows, some hawthorns, a beech tree or two, drainage ditches, a slow and deep brook with steep banks, a weir, twin tunnels which took the stream beneath the main Derby to Nottingham road and, upstream, a wooden footbridge and wobbly stepping stones. 
 All in all, the perfect showcase for a new identity as hero. 
 I recall imitating a stunt performed by the obscure Buffalo Bill Jnr in a Poverty Kow serial, when he outwitted his pursuers by swinging at speed from saddle into tree. 
 On dry summer days the dust raised by galloping posses could be evoked by a vigorous soft shoe shuffle in the red Derbyshire clay, your  sandals given spurs by a twig slid in by the outer ankle. 
 Any film appearance by Robin Hood reinforced a belief that this wooded playground was surely once part of a Sherwood Forest. 
 Our village had been written into the Domesday Book. 
 The park itself, only an arrow's flight from the movie theatre, still had the undulations of a feudal field system. 
 And the ecclesiastical yew wood slightly further afield would, we convinced ourselves, have been a perfect provider of the English yeoman's longbow. 
 The muscular derring-do of our film heroes inspired us to imitative feats of climbing, usually trees; and their prowess in stalking and sniffing out was echoed in our exploration of sombre, dingy and often damp places. 
 Up into the light, down into the dark. 
 The willows between Essoldo and stream were old, stunted and easy to climb. 
 Some were split and bent almost double by their own mass, which meant you could charge straight up them into the lower branches six feet above ground. 
 All were hollow, and with care, for there were protruding knots to buffet and bruise you, you could lower yourself into their embrace and experience the exquisite anxiety of claustrophobia and entrapment. 
 Looking up you would see an alluring smidgen of sky through the spiky branches. 
 The stream, tumbling over the weir, spread itself and then disappeared into two tunnels. 
 &lsqb;The &bquo;For Patrons Only&equo; sign loomed over this pool.&rsqb; 
 One of these tunnels, which seemed awesomely long, black and terrifying, was, with gumption and at such times as the brook was not in full spate, explorable. 
 When at last your gum boots got you, bent double, to the other end you could straighten up to see, again framed in foliage, the mature dream gardens of well-off homeowners, their sumptuous spreads a far cry from the fresh plots of intractable clay that fronted our council houses. 
 Somewhere a big old penny dropped. 
 Why of course: the Essoldo had been built for these middle class folk in the 1930s &mdash; they  were Patrons! 
 &lsqb;PAUL HAMMOND&rsqb;   
 Dear Son, There is a shilling on the mantelpiece. 
 Do not see any X films. 
 Get yourself a bag of chips on the way home. 
 &lsqb;Mrs Finch&rsqb; 
 A HOLE IN THE SCREEN 
 In the 1940s we lived alongside a cinema, in a small town lost in the southern pampas of Argentina. 
 The cinema was immediately adjacent to our house, so that every night we could hear the film and imagine what was on the screen. 
 All of us that is except uncle Eugenio, who had never been to see a film, saying that it was a fraud, all illusion, and that when the lights went up and all the characters disappeared the screen was no more than a rag. 
 When he saw us coming back from the movies every Sunday, discussing the film, he would say, &bquo;I don't believe it. 
 I never would have credited that people would talk about these illusions as if they'd really taken place.&equo; 
 He regarded us as stupid and ignorant. 
 If the film had a sad ending aunt Delicia, who always took anybody's love affair for her own, would return home crying. 
 &bquo;Poor thing,&equo; she'd sob, thinking about the heroine, and she'd get undressed so that she could carry on crying in bed. 
 Uncle Eugenio would get mad with frustration, utterly unable to find the words to refute the fact that illusions might provoke real tears. 
 We convinced him in Holy Week. 
 They were showing a film, The Life of Christ , and though this was clearly an illusion as well it had taken place in real life, and uncle was very much a believer. 
 He went in acting very worried, looking at people as though ashamed that they were seeing him in a cinema. 
 But five minutes into the film he was as possessed as when he was down at the football stadium watching a match. 
 When uncle Eugenio saw Judas striking a bargain with the Romans he cried out &bquo;I can't stand this!&equo; and ran out of the movie theatre. 
 He reappeared with his shotgun just at the moment Judas was handing over his master. 
 And so as not to hurt anyone inadvertently uncle Eugenio waited until the apostle was some way from the rest of the crowd. 
 The hole in the screen coincided with screams and the lights going up and the immediate disappearance of the images. 
 In the midst of the smell and dust of his incredible deed, and the smoke from the gunshot, it was uncle Eugenio who seemed like an illusion. 
 &lsqb;DANIEL MOYANO&rsqb;   
 To humour me my patient father agrees yet again to my choice of film. 
 He has endured most of the French New Wave, and anyway is content if the seats are comfortable and conducive to naps. 
 This evening my choice is Last Year at Marienbad . 
 During one of the long corridor scenes dad falls asleep. 
 He wakes up much later during another corridor scene. 
 &bquo;Mmm,&equo; he remarks, &bquo;that was a long corridor.&equo; 
 &lsqb;Pete Ayrton&rsqb; 
 HOLY SMOKE 
 Twice I was at the cinema when it burned down. 
 The first to go was the Alamein. 
 Panic ensued. 
 Fathers deserted their children. 
 The cowboy film carried on playing. 
 When we got out there were hundreds watching the blaze. 
 This was Allah's revenge, they said. 
 The second was the Gazi. 
 The fire started in the projection box. 
 From inside we could hear screams of &bquo;please, open the door!&equo; 
 Then the exits burst open and we swarmed out. 
 Again there was an assembled audience for the conflagration. 
 Because a mosque stood next door it was said that the cinema had been rejected by Allah as an unworthy neighbour. 
 Rumour had it the owner of the Gazi burned it down for the insurance money. 
 A bank was built on the site, a much better class of neighbour for the place of prayer. 
 &lsqb;SALAH FAIQ&rsqb; 
 PROTESTORS FAIL AS FILM IS SHOWN 
 Strident protests and strict security checks on everyone entering the Cork Opera House seriously delayed the screening of The Last Temptation of Christ  as part of Cork Film Festival last night. 
 The first public showing of what many Catholics view as Martin Scorsese's outrageous interpretation of the biblical epic drew both predictable and highly unpredictable howls. 
 The advice of Bishop Michael Murphy to his flock to stay away was heeded. 
 The great bulk of those who thronged Emmett place last night wanted to see the film, and they outnumbered protestors by a minimum of ten to one. 
 Extra security was designed to prevent trouble inside the Opera House. 
 One man was evicted when he was discovered to be carrying two small cans of paint. 
 What was unpredictable about the protest was a devastatingly subversive counter protest by a small group who said they were present &bquo;on behalf of the acolytes of Our  Lady of Ballinspittle&equo; and who said they wanted to &bquo;protect the rights of blasphemers and heretics and Nobel prize-winning great novelists&equo;. 
 As the small group of less than one hundred people genuinely opposed to the showing of the film sang hymns and said the rosary, the group of luridly dressed and made up &bquo;acolytes&equo; loudly parodied their prayers with phrases like &bquo;General Franco pray for us&equo; and &bquo;General Pinochet stand by us.&equo; 
 Those anti the showing declined to give their names and said they had come as individuals. 
 Those anti the protestors declined to give their names and said they were there as individuals. 
 The protestors carried placards saying things like: &bquo;Jesus, in Him there is no sin&equo;, &bquo;It's a sin to go in&equo; and &bquo;It is the work of the devil&equo;. 
 Those protesting against the protestors had placards stating &bquo;Mary Mag was a Hag&equo; and &bquo;Jesus was nailed not screwed.&equo; 
 When the lone girl &bquo;acolyte&equo; had the word &bquo;screwed, torn off her placard by an exasperated protestor she said. 
 &bquo;My fellow Christians are welcome to my placard, all they have to do is ask.&equo;   
 A protestor against the showing of  The Last Temptation of Christ tears a placard carried by an acolyte of Our Lady of Ballinspittle outside Cork Opera House (photo: Des Barry, 1988)  
 The genuine protestors were mostly middle aged and assembled outside the Opera House from 7 p.m. 
 One group of sixteen came from Ballyvourney by bus, another smaller group came from Ballinspittle and there were more from the city. 
 There were no clerics nor foreigners amongst them and it was obvious that many of those going in to view the film viewed them as a sad little group. 
 One man said it was significant that this was the 33rd Cork Film Festival and Christ died when he was thirty-three. 
 &bquo;Maybe the Film Festival will die at thirty-three as well. 
 I hope it does,&equo; he said. 
 Opponents of the film carried pamphlets which they distributed. 
 These stated: &bquo;Everybody who calls himself or herself a Christian must now rally to the side of Christ and defend Him, not only with their rosaries and prayers but by protesting in a public and persistent manner against this film.&equo; 
 This stern injunction was widely ignored in Cork last night. 
 &lsqb;DES O'SULLIVAN, The Cork Examiner , 4.10.88&rsqb; 
 DARBY O'GILL AND THE LITTLE PEOPLE 
 I saw heretics beheaded, martyrs burned at the stake, Mexicans massacred, gooks machine gunned, Indians annihilated; and strolled home happy. 
 But when the death coach came galloping out of the wild black sky to take Darby O'Gill to hell, it fairly put the fear of God in me; more so than any clergyman before or since, however vivid their threats of eternal damnation. 
 The Sunday sermon was so predictable, as were the plots and stock characters in every cowboy, pirate or war film. 
 In those early pre-TV Saturday afternoon matinee days at the Ideal cinema in Carrickfergus, only two movies broke the mould for me and lodged themselves forever in the imagination: The Wizard of Oz  and Darby O'Gill and the Little People . 
 Kansas and the land of Oz were sufficiently far away not to keep me awake at night, but Darby O'Gill  lived just down the road, somewhere in Ireland; and his world of leprechauns and banshees was outside my window at night. 
 The illuminated Moorish fountain in the cinema foyer contained goldfish. 
 One day a cable shorted and they were electrocuted. 
 But not killed: instead it put a uniform kink in their spins. 
 Afterwards the fish swam in jerky circles. 
 &lsqb;Paul Hammond&rsqb; 
 No matter how corny the characters in the picture postcard parish of Rathcullen, I recognised the fields, I knew the smell of Guinness from drunk men's breath, and my father wore a cap just like Darby O'Gill's. 
 I do not recall much of the plot but all through childhood and beyond I have remained haunted by vivid remembered images: little leprechauns in mad underground celebration dancing round pots of gold, leaping over plundered treasures; Michael and Katy skipping hand in hand through the fields; the jaunty, laughing, Guinness swilling, devil may care Darby with his pub stories, his sideways philosophy and his battles of wit with the wily King Brian of the leprechauns; but mainly, and most frighteningly, the dreaded death coach with its headless coachman come to call Darby's soul on the one way trip to hell. 
 The thought of it still sends shivers throughout me. 
 Therein is part of the magic of cinema: to implant a visual image so strong that somewhere in the psyche the cinematic illusion becomes as real or as powerful as any actual experience. 
 Hollywood sends back its version of Irish folklore and legend and we buy it with added Technicolor and schmaltz. 
 put it in the shop window in New York on St Patrick's Day along with forty shades of green paperweights, the lacquered shillelaghs, and the wonderful world of deedeelee eedeelee eedeelee Irishness; skipping dancing jolly little leprechauns in bright buckled shoes and battered hatted bow legged bright red drunken faced gombeen men with little devils in their laughing Irish eyes, mischievous gossipy white haired old women with shawls, pure white skinned colleens skipping carefree through green fields dutifully ready to return in an instant to domestic chores, strapping athletic lads with fine belts and sturdy boots ever willing to put in a fair day's work or hit each other a clout. 
 I suppose when they string together every possible Celtic clich&eacute;, you can only sit back and submit knowing that the stereotype is so overplayed as to be utterly ridiculous, yet at the same time resenting the perpetration of it.  
 While wanting to dismiss the stereotyping and silly superstition, the snag remains that within all the ballyhoo there are elements of truth. 
 So instead of being outraged, one is left with a resigned smirk. 
 How can Darby O'Gill  be dismissed as superstitious nonsense when it is part descriptive of a society where even now devotional queues are forming to watch supposedly moving statues. 
 If there is a bit of a want about such people then the good Catholic church surely provides for it. 
 Miracles and dramatic visions, wonderful and fearful, are the stuff on which the faith has survived. 
 The interweave of religion, superstition and legend within Irish history and culture is a living interrelationship which has not died with the coming of any modern age. 
 Exaggeration is an integral part of the Irish storytelling and myth making tradition and any tale will be followed by the remark &bquo;sure that's nothin'&equo; from an unimpressed listener who will then proceed to recall or invent an even more amazing yarn. 
 The whiskey glass from which King Brian drank is given pride of place as a hallowed relic on the top shelf of The Rathcullen Arms, destined to be the basis of many a tall tale. 
 It is no coincidence that we move from this shot to a view of the holy pictures and medals surrounding Katy's mirror.   
 Darby O'Gill serenades King Brian Walt Disney Productions 
 And then there was the review. 
 If it was like seeing a long lost friend again after twenty-seven years, Darby O'Gill  was comfortingly predictable with touches of the old sparkle but we had lost a lot of common ground as I had moved from a place of romance and innocence through a world of cynicism and calculated sophistication. 
 Every technical device and dramatic trick was blatantly obvious this time through, and yet there was still a lot of delight, not from smug recognition of prize kitsch, but for a good yarn well told with the perfect characterisation of Albert Sharpe in the title role. 
 If you are talking of definitives you are talking of Olivier as Richard III, Charles Laughton as the Hunchback of Notre Dame, W C Fields as Mr Micawber, Phil Silvers as Ernie Bilko, and Albert Sharpe as Darby O'Gill. 
 His bright eyed, dishevelled, toothless, likeable, harmless old rogue is a cinematic gem, crucial to the enjoyment of the whole film by providing an almost believable character focus in the midst of crudely painted cardboard mountains, fake Irish accents, and stick on red sideburns. 
 What was once awesome fantasy all seems rather tame now. 
 The magical world of Darby O'Gill was shattered long ago when television came into the houses of Carrickfergus. 
 The Ideal had to close down, and a vandal's brick made it the Id al, which spelled the end of an era. 
 &lsqb;JOHN CARSON&rsqb; 
 CLIPPED DIALOGUE 
 Approaching the 60 watt twilight, rocking on your heels at the leaden doors, your reason already gone into reverse as you pad across the spongey carpet. 
 Then the skinny fey usher in white gloves neatly snips your proffered ticket in two: with a pair of nail scissors. 
 Midway through the film the houselights come up, the screen goes dark. 
 Three men have forced their way in. 
 They make their way to the front and start peering, aggressively, into the faces of row upon row of startled punters. 
 In the  paranoid, anguished silence you surmise, or maybe you were told later, that these heavies have been swindled in some drug deal in the scuzzy wine lodge next door, and that they are out to commit violence against the perpetrator. 
 For a long moment you, and each and every one of your neighbours, pray that you are not this man's doppelg&auml;nger. 
 More or less satisfied we're not, the howling lowlife departs. 
 But we can't settle. 
 &lsqb;PAUL HAMMOND&rsqb; 
 I remember a cinema full of screaming kids giving the &bquo;fuck off&equo; V sign to a newsreel of Winston Churchill giving his &bquo;victory&equo; V sign. 
 Later I understood why our national hero was so unpopular: he was the Tory minister who had called out the troops against the miners in the 1920s, an action much more pertinent in our mining town than the defeat of Hitler. 
 &lsqb;Michael O'Pray&rsqb; 
 DAD 
 Some of the front seats on the other side of the aisle were occupied by a gang of Teds. 
 They took little interest in the film and just larked about. 
 Next to us sat a man and his two children. 
 I have this image of them being very poor. 
 He wore a cap and a longish mac done up at the neck. 
 The man asked the Teddy boys to be quiet. 
 He asked them a few times. 
 They stood up, laughed and fooled around. 
 The man finally stood up and went over to them imploring them to be quiet. 
 I remember his children becoming very agitated. 
 It was then he was stabbed. 
 He stood there slightly bent for a few seconds holding his stomach and then he staggered and slowly fell to the floor. 
 &lsqb;RALPH HAWKINS&rsqb; 
 DOUBLE DEATH 
 Custer of the West  climaxes with a reconstruction of the celebrated Battle of Little Big Horn. 
 Kirk Douglas in the title role finally stands alone on the battlefield in the midst of his dead troops, and exposed to the arrows of the Indians who circle round him. 
 Yet he is not to die: at the very last moment the image jumps slightly and then we note Custer's singular absence  at the centre of the famous circle,  which at that moment begins to break up. 
 Disappeared, literally, without a trace. 
 Obviously caused by a simple technical fault, this spiriting away of his death gave him a singular nobility totally lacking from the rest of the film. 
 &lsqb;PETR KRAL&rsqb; 
 PUTTING BACK THE RITZ 
 Between about 1947 and 1951, when the Ritz in Sheffield, Alabama was still open, my main encounters with the place &mdash; between the ages of four and eight &mdash; were on trips with my father across the river to pick up the final reports on the daily receipts on all four of the Rosenbaum theatres our family owned in Sheffield and Tuscumbia. 
 &lsqb;There were three more in Florence at the end of his route, and two more in Athens, where he drove once a month.&rsqb; 
 As soon as we left Florence and crossed the Tennessee River we passed from Lauderdale, a dry county, to Colbert, a wet one, and the difference was plainly visible: a sudden array of beerstands and gaudy neon nightclubs flickering past made Sheffield a sort of Baghdad next to the more prim outposts in Florence, the birthplace of W C Handy, and a bastion of respectability. 
 Sheffield was the smaller town, but it had a bigger train station, more industrial soot, more prostitutes, and an all black movie house, the Carver, all in close proximity to one another. 
 Across the tracks was &bquo;Jack's Chicken Shack&equo;, a Negro hangout that sold bootleg liquor after the county went dry around 1952, and Sheffield began to grow more ashen and dusty, shrivelling into a near semblance of a ghost town. 
 Today the town shows some signs of coming back to life. 
 Colbert went wet again in 1982, there's an active local theatre group, and some people in the area are in the process of restoring and reopening the Ritz &mdash; which had survived mainly as a warehouse, and briefly as a recording studio in 1957 &mdash; putting on plays, and possibly a film series too. 
 It hasn't shown a movie for over thirty years, but  the pink seashell murals, the stage, and the &bquo;white&equo; and &bquo;coloured&equo; balconies are still intact: fossils of another culture. 
 When I read Milton's description in Paradise Lost  of Satan, fallen to lie in Hell, a monstrous unimaginable bulk, I was reminded of that Odeon. 
 &lsqb;Roland Miller&rsqb; 
 My father's nightly trips across the river were usually to the Colbert in Sheffield &lsqb;built around the time of Pearl Harbour, half a block from the Ritz, today a parking lot&rsqb; and the Tuscumbian &lsqb;built in 1950, a block from the Strand, today part of a bank&rsqb;. 
 But if the daily figures hadn't yet been brought over from the Ritz and Strand, he would stop off there too. 
 Sometimes my brothers and I were allowed to get out of the car with him and peek at the movie in progress while he spoke to the manager or cashier. 
 In a way it functioned for us like window shopping: a random five minute slice of a feature would enable us to decide whether to see the whole thing at the Shoals, Princess or Majestic in Florence, when it resurfaced there. 
 But sometimes a double bill would show at the Ritz and nowhere else. 
 One such occasion was Labor Day 1949, when my parents went off on a holiday barbecue or picnic and deposited the three oldest toys &mdash; David &lsqb;eight&rsqb;, Johnny &lsqb;six&rsqb; and Alvin &lsqb;four&rsqb; &mdash; with a teenage black babysitter named Earl at the Ritz to see Li'l Abner  &lsqb;the early black and white version, with Buster Keaton in a small part&rsqb; and I Married a Witch . 
 It was Alvin's first time at the movies, but the other three of us were seasoned veterans by this time. 
 Jim Crow laws dictated that we all sit up in the coloured balcony, so we followed Earl up the stairs of the separate entrance, located to the right of the box office, and found ourselves in the highest tier of the auditorium. 
 Down below were the pink seashell murals lit by fluorescent lights, and distant black and white movies on the screen. 
 Li'l Abner  &mdash; without the colour of the comic strip in the Sunday paper &mdash; seemed bogus, and bogus hillbilly at that; but David and Earl, both schooled in the macho preference for raucous art, liked nothing better than a bogus barnyard. 
 For Alvin and me, bogus mansions and graveyards were the thing, and I Married a Witch  a sweeter brew. 
 The principal moment I'm left with is a shot of two smoky essences in bottles, the sound of dry autumn leaves rustling through a chill night wind, and the voices of Cecil Kellaway and Veronica Lake, father and daughter, con-  versing from their adjacent bottles. 
 Most of this has to do with Veronica Lake's deep, husky voice: a smoky spirit whose name and form collectively conjured up a feminine aura of water, vapour, air, smoke and flesh at the same time; a floating dreamboat that any boy of six would be proud to be married to. 
 Having just seen Topper at the Princess the week before, I had all I needed to complete my erotic evaporation fantasies. 
 Indeed, by the time that the credits of Ren&eacute; Clair's supernatural comedy came on, the ads had already done their work, and I was already invisibly inside that bottle too, ready to share in Veronica's throaty vibrato. 
 &lsqb;JONATHAN NOSENRAUM&rsqb; 
 If you live in the Aussie outback you need all the friends you can get. 
 When I saw my friend Bob Hope in some comedy or other at the age of six I provided him with an imaginary wife, who was called &bquo;Nothing&equo;. 
 I don't mean she didn't have a name; that was her name: &bquo;Nothing&equo;. 
 You can see I had no great hopes for my future as a woman. 
 &lsqb;Deirdre Clark&rsqb; 
 SIX PENN'ORTH OF DARK 
 In the 1930s you learnt how to behave as a human being from movies. 
 You learnt how to smoke, how to hold a cigarette. 
 I wanted to become a reporter because I lusted after a belted trenchcoat like the one Joel McCrea wore in Hitchcock's Foreign Correspondent . 
 Girls kissed with their eyes closed and raising themselves up on tiptoe, because that was the cute shot in American movies. 
 We believed in Hollywood. 
 Cinemas themselves were special. 
 Nobody had central heating, so it was warm. 
 It was dark: &bquo;six penn'nrth of dark&equo; was what people were after. 
 The cinema was our motel. 
 And it was opulent in the way nothing else in your life was. 
 They were called &bquo;picture palaces&equo; for a very good reason. 
 At the Empire, Leicester Square, the toilets were truly lavish: &bquo;I dreamt I dwelt in marble halls&equo; had red meaning. 
 Before the cinema opened the men on the staff were given cigars to puff, so that when you came into the foyer it had that smell of luxury. 
 There were staff rackets. 
 Teas were served in cinemas then. 
 When you wanted tea you could either have a pot of tea, or a &bquo;cinema tea&equo;, which was a pot of tea and a plate on which was a sandwich with the crusts cut off, which also represented something, and a cake. 
 It's very difficult to eat in the dark. 
 We noticed that quite often if people ate the  sandwich they left the cake, or vice versa, so when we used to collect the trays from them we would take whatever was left. 
 At the back of the stalls there were radiators which had plush curtains and we would shove these cakes and sandwiches under the radiators, and the next time somebody ordered a &bquo;cinema tea&equo; we would go to the kitchen and order a pot. 
 Maybe the &bquo;cinema tea&equo; was 9d and the pot of tea was 6d. 
 We'd then pull out a sandwich and a cake, put it on the tray: nobody could see what they were eating, and we'd pocket the difference. 
 The stuff could have been under there for days, if not weeks. 
 I remember in the RAF at Blackpool going to the pictures, and they didn't bother with an intermission. 
 Tea was served at 4.30 no matter what was happening. 
 Suddenly the film would stop. 
 The lights would go up and they would serve tea. 
 What you quickly learned was not to sit on the end of the row, because the usherettes would pass the trays down the row and as soon as everybody was served they'd give the nod to the projectionist, the lights would go down again, and on the film would go. 
 When people had drunk their tea they would pass the trays to the end of the row. 
 If you were sitting there you would have to peer over the pile of cups on your lap. 
 Originally a concert hall in which Liszt played and Dickens read, Cork's Assembly Rooms then became a cinema. 
 The usher's name was George, and during the westerns whenever a redskin bit the dust the audience called out, &bquo;Georgie, take out the body!&equo; 
 When the Assembly closed the story goes that they found hundreds of dead Indians behind the screen. 
 &lsqb;Mick Hannigan&rsqb; 
 There were other tricks you could pull. 
 You regularly turned the heating up before the intermission, when the icecream girl appeared. 
 If there was anything like a Foreign Legion story, or something like Hitchcock's Lifeboat , when the characters had to ration out the water, you'd slowly turn up the heat. 
 There were girls who couldn't walk backwards. 
 Some usherettes couldn't carry the icecream trays: &bquo;I can't do it, Mr Norden, I come over funny if I walk backwards.&equo; 
 You wondered what genetic quirk there was. 
 I was only seventeen and the girl would say, &bquo;I can't do the ice creams today, it's my time of month.&equo; 
 Ten days later she'd say, &bquo;I can't do it, it's my time of month.&equo; 
 I didn't know enough about the subject to be able to query it. 
 I was at the Trocadero, Elephant and Castle, as an assistant manager, and there were a hundred and twenty-two on the staff. 
 It was military, everyone in uniform, and there was a staff parade. 
 The manager would inspect the ranks. 
 You had to stand with your hands held out, and he'd  look at your nails. 
 The public paid to see gleaming buttons, luxury. 
 Everything had to preserve the illusion. 
 For example, we were not allowed to show &bquo;white screen&equo;. 
 When the curtains part and you see a white screen you know you're watching a screen and it isn't real. 
 So projectionists had to put a colour tint onto the screen before the first frame hit. 
 It was showmanship so that the illusion might have force, impact. 
 The Honorary consult : a slow, moody, almost mute film. 
 At one point our hero, drunk, mindless, ruined in body and spirit, crashes to the muddy ground, a monument to excess. 
 From the other side of the wafer-thin wall between Odeon One and Two comes the voice of The Jungle Book's  Baloo: &bquo;I want to talk  like you, walk  like you, I want to be  like you.&equo; 
 &lsqb;Chris Proctor&rsqb; 
 The Saturday morning club for kids was murder. 
 I had to announce a big disaster during the war, the fall of France or something, and it was during a children's matinee. 
 We had to tell them because they might have wanted to go home. 
 It was Christmas time, and we used to give them oranges and sweets. 
 This bad news had come through, and of course nobody had television then; not everybody had a radio. 
 Maybe it was Narvik, although now I can't even remember what Narvik was. 
 The place was full: twelve hundred kids. 
 So I said to the organist, whose name was Bobby Page, &bquo;I'll come up on the organ.&equo; 
 I announced: &bquo;We've had this bad news&equo;. 
 And the kids all shouted, &bquo;Where's the fucking oranges! 
 Where's the fucking oranges!&equo; 
 Unshelled peanuts: after the second house the floor was audible. 
 You walked audibly. 
 It was like the whole audience was eating celery. 
 I had a mate who could crack peanuts between his knees, which was an enormous asset if you had a girl with you. 
 At the Watford Gaumont, which I managed, people would come in dinner dress and they would have the same seat every week. 
 &lsqb;A&rsqb; you had to remember their name, and greet them by name; and &lsqb;B&rsqb; you had to remember their seat. 
 As a cinema manager you thought up your own publicity stunts. 
 If the film was, say, Old Mother Riley Goes to Paris , you'd have three of your doormen dressed up as Old Mother Riley, which was a very cheap costume to hire, and you'd build an Eiffel Tower, put it on a barrow and go round the town during the busy shopping time. 
 You'd give prizes of tickets. 
 You'd run competitions. 
 You'd do &bquo;tie-ins&equo; with the local shops: you'd sell the Paris idea to them for instance. 
 There was a magazine called Kine Weekly , which would give a showman's award for the best stunt.   
 Cinema manager grooms himself before the main feature 
 At the Trocadero there were gangs. 
 The tenement slums at Elephant and Castle have since disappeared. 
 The gangs were called up during the war. 
 But before that they used to raid. 
 They'd try and &bquo;bump in&equo;. 
 One of them bought a ticket and he'd go to an exit, open the door and his mates would flood in. 
 These gangs were thirty- and forty-strong, youths in long black overcoats and white knotted scarves, like Sid Field. 
 It was your job to chuck'em out. 
 There were pitched battles, so they lay in wait for you. 
 I took over from a guy who went out the stage door and somebody said to him, &bquo;Have you got a light?&equo; 
 As he put his hand in his pocket he was grabbed from behind and they razored his face. 
 I used to go back home via the local Underground and I'd take six of our Irish doormen with me, all of them six foot three, and they'd take the rollers from the roller towels in the Gents and they'd stand around me, and we would go out in a &bquo;flying wedge&equo;. 
 These were tough people. 
 The gangs would want to watch the film, but occasionally also drag an usherette into the exit. 
 They'd barricade themselves in. 
 We had a couple of usherettes raped. 
 We'd ring up the police, who would take a bunch of these youths into the same exit and do'em over. 
 At the Troc we had a list of troublemakers, plus police photographs, nicknames and descriptions, above the cashier's grille. 
 There was one lady called &bquo;Toss-Off Kate&equo; who used to go round the audience and sit beside various isolated gentlemen and ask them if they wanted to be serviced. 
 What I liked about her was that she charged less in the 6ds than she did in the 1/3s: she had a sliding scale. 
 At the Trocadero there were always six hundred people waiting in the 6d queue. 
 We did four shows a day. 
 As we took one house in the queue would form again. 
 An enormous bomb fell on a place nearby called Spurgeon's Tabernacle, so close that it blew in all the windows and knocked the marquee for six. 
 Nobody left the queue: they weren't going to lose their place, they'd been queueing for an hour. 
 People came anticipating a double feature. 
 They'd ring me up and say, &bquo;What's the also?&equo; 
 You had two films, the first feature and then the &bquo;also&equo;. 
 We got top West End variety acts. 
 We had an orchestra, an organ, two major feature films, all for 6d. 
 We did opera. 
 We played circuses  there. 
 The stage was wide but it had no depth. 
 When we had the circus the lions were put behind the screen, but we were showing an MGM picture and every time the lion at the beginning roared the lions at the back would answer him. 
 The auditorium of the Holloway Odeon hit by a V2 rocket, August 1944 
 I was a relief manager, sent around the Gaumont circuit. 
 At the Troxy, in Commercial Road, Stepney, they'd have American stars coming over. 
 One big American came out to do his act and I saw him blanch, and then visibly pull himself together before proceeding. 
 I went round afterwards and asked him what was the problem. 
 He said, &bquo;I've never seen anything like this.&equo; 
 It was an early show. 
 He had to come on and be funny at 1.30 in the afternoon. 
 And the whole front row was full of women who were breastfeeding their babies. 
 Cinemas had their own magazines: the Gaumont, Watford, had its own magazine; the State, Kilburn, had its own magazine, and I used to write for them and did verses. 
 It was a community. 
 People would ring up and say, &bquo;Can you get Mrs So-and-So, her baby's crying and I can't stop her. 
 &bquo;So you'd write a carbon-backed slide with this message and project it over the film. 
 And then you'd hear scurrying feet in the cinema. 
 I started writing organ solos. 
 A cinema organ is like a big jelly mould, illuminated from within, a most spectacular thing that changed colour according to whether a major key or a minor key was being played. 
 I would write parodies of popular songs and my selection would go all around the circuit. 
 I thought I was Terence Rattigan. 
 On a Sunday night you used to show different films from the rest of the week. 
 You'd show films that were old, even in those days. 
 One Sunday at the Trocadero the chief circle usher said to me, &bquo;I think you'd better come up to the back circle, Gents, we've got a bloke behaving obscenely.&equo; 
 So I went up and there was a bloke standing in the middle of the toilets, by the basin, tossing himself off, and I said, &bquo;What do you think you're doing?&equo; 
 He said, &bquo;I can't help it.&equo; 
 We were showing a Jessie Matthews film called Evergreen , one of her first films, in which she wore long silk stockings. 
 He said, &bquo;When I was a kid I saw that film, and I wanked for days on end. 
 And I've come back years later and it's had the same effect on me.&equo; 
  The habit of going to see the movie &mdash; that sophisticated notion &mdash; no, people went to &bquo;the pictures&equo;, they didn't go to see such-and-such a film. 
 &bquo;What are you doing Tuesday night?&equo; 
 &equo; Going to the pictures.&equo; 
 &lsqb;DENIS NORDEN&rsqb; 
 While the trailers trailed Anne visited the Ladies, then returned groaning and limping. 
 She's misjudged the weight of the chromium door and crushed her big toe. 
 Mary visited the Gents and returned, groaning and holding his head. 
 He's misjudged the size of the chromium door and knocked himself flat. 
 Nursing our wounds, clutching foot and forehead, the film began. 
 Aliens : &bquo;This Time It's War.&equo; 
 &lsqb;Marty St James &amp; Anne Wilson&rsqb; 
 WITH A FIGURE LIKE YOURS 
 I cannot recall the number of occasions I shuffled back in regulation sex cinema garb to see Daughters of Darkness , the lesbian vampire movie that starred Delphine Seyrig as Countess Erzs&eacute;bet B&agrave;thory and Andrea Rau as her lover Ilona. 
 In those days I lived with my parents and when the film resurfaced at a local cinema I convinced them to spend an evening feasting their eyes on those sanguinary sapphics. 
 My father had purchased a box of Maltesers, the chocolates with the less fattening centre, to sustain him through this no holds barred erotic horror film. 
 With my mother we settled down in the back row. 
 My father quickly  fell asleep. 
 He chanced to resurface at a moment in the film when the divine Ms Rau is indulging in carnal acrobatics with the leading male actor. 
 As she pouted and sighed, locked in an impossible sexual position, my father's leg jerked involuntarily, catapulting the Maltesers onto the floor. 
 The legs of Jessie matthews in Evergreen 
 The cinema was bereft of carpets and we all could hear, for what seemed an eternity, was the doleful roll of each Malteser down the incline to its nemesis beneath the feet of the people in the front row. 
 Not only was the rumble of the sweeties heard by the audience. 
 On the screen the actor had reached orgasm. 
 Then he turned his head to one side as if he, too, was listening to the Maltesers rolling past the front row, under the bed on which he and Andrea had cavorted, towards the French windows on the far side of his bedroom, and out into the garden. 
 &lsqb;CHARLES PELTZ&rsqb; 
 NOT IN YOUR HAND 
 For Simon and me, short light coloured macs, mohair sweaters, slim Jim ties, tight trousers and chisel toed shoes were obligatory for our adolescent cultural trips to the cinema. 
 The films were inevitably foreign and subtitled, and even if we didn't understand them it was as though through exposure to some cinematic photosynthesis we would absorb the esoteric and become all the better intellectually for it. 
 On one occasion, to kill time before a suitably uplifting film, we met at Waterloo station and decided to go to the cinema within the station precinct which showed a continuous programme of cartoons for the convenience of passengers with time on their hands. 
 This was not entirely true of the matronly middle aged woman and her elderly male companion sitting three seats away from me, as she applied herself methodically to his penis. 
 What intrigued me was their mutual indifference to an activity I'd always imagined to be both intimate and passionate. 
 As she ate  Maltesers from the box on her knee, apparently engrossed in the antics of Mickey Mouse, Donald Duck or pluto her left hand seemed not to know what her right was doing. 
 It felt inappropriate that my introduction to live sex was wholly voyeuristic and accompanied by images from Looney Tunes . 
 &lsqb;CHARLIE HOLMES&rsqb; 
 Have you ever been the only punter in a big cinema? 
 The film has been showing to an empty room. 
 Now there is you. 
 eventually, guilty about being there, you leave. 
 Does the film continue to the end? 
 &lsqb;Ian Walker&rsqb; 
 FAMILY ENTERTAINMENT 
 Carol, who went to see Jungle Book , has a daughter, so her child is not David, who ate the popcorn. 
 Snow White  was the main feature at the cinema where the choc ice was eaten. 
 Ann bought the hot dog, so Carol, who did not buy the ice lolly, must have bought the orangeade. 
 So Tom and Jerry must have been the support film for Jungle Book . 
 Therefore Carol's daughter is not Julie, whilst Donna was taken to see Mary Poppins , so it must have been Linda who went with Carol to see Jungle Book . 
 We know that David's mother is neither Carol nor Ann, who bought the popcorn,  nor is she Jean, whilst Meg is Simon's mother, so David's mother must be Helen, and they therefore saw Mickey Mouse . 
 We know that they did not see Jungle Book  and Popeye  was the supporting item for Peter Pan . 
 As David ate popcorn, he did not see Snow White , and we know that Donna watched Mary Poppins , so Helen and David must have seen Fantasia . 
 Mary Poppins  was not supported by Bugs Bunny , so Donna must have seen Donald Duck leaving Bugs Bunny  as the cartoon screened with Snow White . 
 Therefore Ann's child, who did not see Donald Duck, cannot be Donna, and must be Julie, who therefore ate the hot dog. 
 The film combination rules out Donna as the child who ate the choc ice, so Meg and Simon must have watched Snow White  and Bugs Bunny , leaving Donna as the eater of the ice lolly. 
 By elimination, Donna's mother must be Jean, and the programme seen by Ann and Julie must have been Peter Pan  and Popeye . 
 &lsqb;CHARLIE HOLMES&rsqb; 
 In  Diner Mickey Rourke bets his buddies that the sophisticated lady will hold his penis on their first date. 
 He pokes it through the bottom of the popcorn box they share. 
 She has a healthy appetite. 
 He wins the bet  
 UNCLE SAM 
 Until I was eight I lived in the village of Feltwell in Norfolk where there was a joint RAF and USAF base. 
 Although the RAF children came to the local primary school there was little contact between us locals and the American children. 
 However on Saturday mornings there was a film show, run by the Americans for their children, which the local children could also attend. 
 I went once, when I was five. 
 I remember nothing about who I was with or what the films were, I remember only the interval. 
 Members of the audience were invited to participate in some games. 
 I volunteered along with four or five others. 
 An American soldier gave us each a balloon and told us that the winner would be the one who could soonest burst the balloon by blowing it up beyond its stretching point. 
 We all started to inflate our balloons and eventually one burst. 
 It was not over then however, as the soldier said that the rest of us should continue until we had also burst our balloons. 
 One  by one everyone else's balloon burst but I lacked the courage to blow too hard. 
 The soldier, becoming bored with the game, laconically reached out his cigarette end and burst the balloon in my face. 
 Thirty years later my volunteering instinct has come through intact but I still mistrust the American Air Force. 
 &lsqb;VIEANNE LYLE&rsqb; 
 FIRST WESTERN IN THE EAST 
 A small cinema on a Royal Air Force camp near the Egyptian town of Suez in 1951. 
 A crowd of people filled the darkened space with noise and smoke. 
 Other noisy people who were very grey moved rapidly backwards and forwards on the end wall. 
 These people, one of whom was a whiskered old man, carried guns which they let off frequently, rode horses at terrifying speeds across an arid landscape similar to the one I played in each day, while breathless crashing music and a small dog pursued everyone everywhere they went. 
 Suddenly all this stopped and blinding bright lights came on. 
 As I was swept along by the noisy laughing crowd out into the tropical evening I persistently wanted to know what had happened to the dog. 
 For several nights afterwards nightmares of violence and death disturbed normally peaceful sleep. 
 A few days later the emergency evacuation of civilians from Suez to within the camp's barbed wire perimeter fence began. 
 Hand guns were issued to all personnel guarding the convoys of lorries. 
 At the end of each day my father would return, a holster on his hip. 
 The pistol would be discreetly locked away in a cupboard. 
 Soon afterwards we were all evacuated by air, back to England. 
 Later I learned the old man was Gabby Hayes and the film starred Roy Rogers. 
 &lsqb;MIKE LEGGETT&rsqb;   
 My friend was followed from seat to seat by a dirty old man during He-Man and the Masters of the Universe . 
 She'd soon had enough of this and yelled out, &bquo;I am She-Ra and I will break your balls!&equo; 
 That did the trick. 
 &lsqb;Gerry McCarthy&rsqb; 
 GATEWAY TO THE STARS 
 It was a life-size cutout of Roy Rogers on Trigger that held me. 
 It stood in the entrance to the cinema: the stetson, white suit, palomino horse, silver spurs. 
 I kept wondering what it had to do with the cowboy we were going to see on the screen. 
 Similarly, I remember peering through the expanded grille they drew across the cinema entrance when it was closed. 
 Although the movie had ended they, the stars, were still visible in the publicity stills behind glass just inside the entrance. 
 I was fascinated by these glossy black and white photographs. 
 I couldn't understand how these moments had become frozen in time like that. 
 Had they literally cut them out of the film? 
 Once, a still photograph had slipped from its frame, and lay enticingly just inside the gate. 
 I reached through one of the diamond shaped gaps between the bars and pulled the curling portrait out. 
 It felt illicit. 
 I was stealing something out of the film: I had captured the stars in the act, and they couldn't slip away, off the edge of the screen. 
 From the age of eight I attended the Odeon in Exeter. 
 It was the second largest building in the city, next to the cathedral, which was much less prominent. 
 The Odeon dominated from the highest point in Exeter, surrounded by terraced houses like regular furrows in a ploughed field. 
 There it crouched, hump backed on the hill, overshadowing everything round about, a Behemoth. 
 I suppose I had been given a sense of the evil of cinema by my strict Methodist grandparents, who were visibly shocked when once I confessed that I had been to see a film on Sunday. 
 Inside the Odeon, on both sides of the screen, up the soaring walls, ran a frieze of cartoon characters. 
 They seemed to ascend two giant rainbows: Snow White and her Dwarfs, Mickey and Minnie, Pluto, Donald and his nephews, Popeye and Olive. 
 I remember these figures illuminated from behind, like giant shadows. 
 It was as though they were marching up great soaring bridges to get on to the screen, where they would enter into the films we had come to see. 
 Then there were the sweeping layers of thin gauzy curtains that swished elegantly back to reveal the screen. 
 Sometimes this happened after the film had  begun, when the curtains rippled the frame round the black and white British film censor's certificate, like a giant bank note. 
 In a dream I went to the pictures, in Germany I think. 
 I paid in gold coins and got change in jewels, amethysts in gold mounts. 
 The audience sat in a warm honey glow, drinking tea and eating richly iced cake. 
 You appeared on screen, pretending to be a bush, a bush with round purplish leaves and pale green shoots. 
 &lsqb;P P O'Leary&rsqb; 
 I could never get over the transformation of the vast auditorium by the dimming of the lights, the beautiful changes of colour on the curtains, and the anticipation brought on by the roaring lion, the muscle man with his gong the snow capped mountain, the searchlights probing the 20th Century. 
 That moment seems in retrospect to have been more exciting than any of the films that followed. 
 The 20th Century Fox logo always made me think we were about to see a war film, as the searchlights that had woken us in London in the blitz always preceded an air-raid. 
 Even in peace time Exeter, bombed London, in reality and on the newsreels, was hard to dislodge from my mind. 
 &lsqb;ROLAND MILLER&rsqb; 
 THE FACTS OF LIFE 
 The three major cinematic events in my life have functioned as harbingers to major changes in my own life, after which things were never quite the same. 
 The first one, the first time in fact that I can remember going to the pictures, was being taken to the cinema in Lewisham by my mother to see Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs  just before the outbreak of the Second World War. 
 For a child of five this was a terrifying experience, although it was meant to be a birthday treat. 
 The fact that it had a happy ending was immaterial to me. 
 As far as I was concerned it was a nightmare, and merged in my memory with actually being evacuated; the kids going down to Ladywell station in a crocodile on one side of the road, clutching oranges and bars of chocolate, and the mothers on the other, weeping and wailing and shouting to us across the street, lots of dwarfs and lots of Snow Whites. 
 The second one: having got over the actual evacuation and the idea that I probably wouldn't ever see my mother  again, being evacuated in itself was great. 
 Our school was evacuated to Hadlow Down in Sussex, just about where the German bombers used to off-load their bombs to save themselves the trouble of having to go all the way to London. 
 There were a lot of French-Canadian soldiers stationed in the area, together with British and Americans, and a weekly film show was put on for all-comers in the Methodist chapel on Saturday nights. 
 The first, and only, film that I can remember seeing there was Sergeant York , the dialogue of which was very loudly interpreted by the more bilingual of the French-Canadians for their monoglot mates, much to the annoyance of the anglophones. 
 I think also that aspersions were cast, as asides, on the true soldierly qualities of Sgt York, and hence on all American soldiers, and a three-way fight broke out among the French-Canadian, American and British, to a background drone of German bombers wending their weary way to or from London, or circling in a desultory fashion prior to dumping their bombs with a dull thud on the surrounding countryside. 
 The very next day, Sunday, I would have to attend the same chapel in its religious function, and the fact that the previous evening it had been a battleground for people who were supposed to be friends and allies, while the &bquo;enemy&equo; got on with his job uninterrupted outside, led to a more or less permanent confusion in my mind, which I now believe to be totally justified, between violence and religion, and between fact and fancy &lsqb;or film&rsqb;. 
 On screen Peeping Tom . 
 Possessed by the movie camera with which his sadistic father tortured him in childhood &bquo;Tome&equo; skewers his girlfriend with a stiletto tripod leg while he films the grim business. 
 My companion leaps from his seat and himself shoots the scene with his Bolex. 
 An umbilicus is being tugged. 
 &lsqb;David Curtis&rsqb; 
 The third one: once the buzz bombs started to come over it was at last realised that it wasn't a very good idea to have children evacuated directly on the flight path between Germany and London, and we were all shipped off to other locations, myself to Teignmouth in Devon. 
 There, in the only cinema, we had a sadistic manager who delighted in not letting the kids into &bquo;A&equo; films unless we could con a grown-up into buying the tickets and going in with us, after which we would split up and go our separate ways, ourselves to the front row if possible, otherwise as near to the screen as we could get. 
 But on one mysterious occasion the sado-manager waived the rules and waved us in: we couldn't understand this behaviour at all, but took up the offer nevertheless, putting it down to grown-up incon-  sistency. 
 The programme took its usual course, until it came to news time. 
 The wartime commentator's jingoistic jangle was this time replaced by a solemn voice, and we were confronted with pictures of moving skeletons, some of them smiling weakly and making slow gestures. 
 This was the newsreel of the liberation of Belsen, and I think that I have thought about those images every day since. 
 Before that I had never known that human beings could do such things to others, but after that I knew. 
 &lsqb;JOHN FURNIVAL&rsqb; 
 A grim, angst-filled film by Ingmar Bergman became ludicrously enjoyable through the persistent hiccups of the person sitting in front of me, which provided a perfect counterpoint to the strangulated Swedish voices onscreen. 
 &lsqb;George Littleblack&rsqb; 
 WEEPING 
 As in a waiting room I sit. 
 Surrounded by breathing, close enough to neighbours to touch knees. 
 The seats are cushioned, and in the dark I am waiting for more than entertainment. 
 I am waiting to be bathed in film. 
 It is a matinee performance of ET The Extra-Terrestrial . 
 I am not lost in the story, it is like reading a comic on the bus. 
 Children chatter loudly. 
 What are they talking about? 
 Anything and everything. 
 A conference hall for the under elevens. 
 Towards the end of the film attention is gradually transferred to the screen. 
 Sadder things are happening. 
 ET is homesick. 
 He might die. 
 I am jarred by the sound of these children weeping. 
 &lsqb;FRANKIE EARNSHAW&rsqb; 
 THE PASSENGER 
 That shadowy world of small rooms visited by regret, of dim streets crossed by half familiar figures, of meadows steeped in yearning, beckoned to me. 
 There must have been a draught because I wrapped my coat around my knees. 
 As I left the cinema I was seized in an irresistible spasm of shivering. 
 My jaw hurt, my teeth were locked in  an instinctive bite, and when released they chattered as if propelled by clockwork. 
 It took ten minutes of brisk walking to get my blood flowing again, my consciousness slowly returning from a journey beyond my body. 
 I boarded a train. 
 The suburban setting of my destination was unexceptional, simply a footbridge over tracks, a few solemn railway buildings, a row of villas, a couple of trees. 
 And yet, alighting in the sunshine from the trembling train I found myself in a space transfigured by the three stages of the passage through the underworld that is matinee cinema: the transition from day to night; the day for night of the viewing; the transition back to daylight. 
 &lsqb;ROGER CARDINAL&rsqb; 
 Cinema in Buchenwald 
 UM AL-MARHOOM'S SHADOW 
 I was six years old and had to be accompanied to the cinema by my two brothers &lsqb;five and seven&rsqb;. 
 They had refused to go with me, claiming they wouldn't be able to face their friends after that. 
 My father threatened to punish them, so they were forced to accept my company. 
 The cinema we went to was the Al Washash summer cinema, situated in Baghdad City. 
 We had to be there one hour before the beginning of the film in order to get seats in the front row. 
 Following our father's advice both brothers made sure I was seated between them, at the same time refusing to exchange a word with me. 
 It was inevitable that I was fully occupied by my fear rather than watching an Egyptian film, Abla and Anter , a classic Bedouin love story. 
 Half an hour later an ambiguous shadow covered the screen, then manifested a distinct movement. 
 At once I turned my head to the source of the light. 
 My eldest brother told me to keep still. 
 The same shadow kept covering the screen at regular intervals. 
 Shrinking into my seat I murmured, &bquo;It has to be God.&equo; 
 Or was it part of the film? 
 Ten years later I discovered while watching the same film on TV that the shadow wasn't part of the film after all:  it was Um Al-Marhoom's shadow &lsqb;Um Al-Marhoom is what we in the Middle East call the woman who is left without children after the death of her only son&rsqb;, trying to sell some boiled chickpeas to us children. 
 &lsqb;HAIFA ZANGANA&rsqb; 
 Photomontage by Ian Breakwell, 1980 
 WHITE SQUARE 
 I remember watching flecks in the concrete passing under the tips of my black button shoes and the flaked brown paint of the step of my pushchair. 
 Then some grass, and a dark green van, and doors opening at the back of it, and grey flat people moving in a white square. 
 Must have been the early 1940s, my mother taking me for a walk near Bostall Woods during a gap in the bombing. 
 Some Ministry of Something travelling information film. 
 Towards the end of the war another memory. 
 A trip to London to visit my &bquo;Aunt&equo; Josie. 
 A bigger white square. 
 A man playing a ukulele and riding a bicycle across the sky. 
 Then a live magician on the stage; some singing; the flat white again and men firing rifles across dead buffalo at the rest of the herd. 
 Afterwards I sat on the mat that smelled of dog while my mother and Josie talked. 
 About Josie's son drowned at sea and her daughter Irma's fianc&eacute; &bquo;missing&equo;. 
 He was in the Fleet Air Arm. 
 I liked those words and repeated them often to myself. 
 &lsqb;TOM RAWORTH&rsqb; 
 SNAKE SCALE 
 As a kid the scale of the film images was frightening, and then there were the myriads of dots, scratches and lines, accompanied by clicks and plops on the soundtrack. 
 I remember trying to make sense out of these ghostly darting signs that overlaid the story of the film, which most  of the time I couldn't follow. 
 When I was older, eight or nine, I used to take a large piece of plasticine to the pictures and make what was appropriate. 
 Once, during a jungle film 1 made a snake by rolling out the plasticine on the back of the seats. 
 At a particularly exciting point I dropped it between the seats in front, and insisted that my parents ask the people to look for it. 
 After some time, and the lighting of matches, I got the snake back covered in fragments of crisps, popcorn and cigarette ash. 
 &lsqb;MAX EASTLEY&rsqb; 
 A MOTHER TO ME 
 My first visit alone to a Saturday matinee at the Queens, just off the docks in Whitehaven, next to the Quay Street Roman Catholic chapel and infant school I attended. 
 In the serial Superman was left in the final frames pushing desperately with his outstretched arms at the sides of a tunnel melting into a hot, dangerous, black treacle-like substance which threatened to engulf him. 
 The image was awesome and utterly seductive. 
 My second memory is of another matinee film, but not a children's one. 
 In its final moments a sophisticated urbane man in a nightclub is led discreetly through a back door into a room which is a mortuary run by nuns, one of whom shows him a dead body drawn out of a wall on a slab. 
 The scene has never left me. 
 I was seven years old or less. 
 In my third memory my mother takes me to see Chaplin's Limelight . 
 I know she liked the theme music. 
 I also knew then that seeing the film at a matinee on a weekday was an illicit pleasure for her. 
 My father would not have approved. 
 I had to be told which character was Chaplin; he was so old and looked nothing like the silent comic I knew so well. 
 All these memories are connected incoherently to my mother: the oozing uterine passage closing in on Superman; the dead man disclosed by nuns &lsqb;so pretty and so erotically close to the nightclub&rsqb;; and the sadness of Limelight  where,  sitting in the dark with her I knew her pleasure at the tale was different to mine, an adult one, beyond me. 
 So much that is inexpressible in our relationship survives in memories of late afternoon empty cinemas in a small northern town in the 1950s. 
 &lsqb;MICHAEL O'PRAY&rsqb; 
 Two locals were scrutinising the forthcoming attractions outside the tiny cinema in Glenarm, Co. 
 Antrim. 
 &bquo; Singapore . 
 Do you suppose it's a western? 
 &lsqb;Noel Spence&rsqb; 
 REVENGE OF THE &bquo;D&equo; STREAM 
 Sunday nights have always been a problem for the serious cinemagoer, since this is the night that brings out the lads whose parents don't make them go to bed early before a fresh week at school begins. 
 One Sunday night at the Wood Green Odeon a group of youths and girls were making so much more than a tolerable racket that I eventually asked them to quieten down. 
 Some hope. 
 Humiliated, I decided to fetch the manager. 
 The usherette assured me that the manager would do something about it but he was busy just then with the projectionist, so she would pass on my complaint when he came down. 
 After suffering another half hour of mouth farts and high-pitched giggles I was stiff with indignation: at the rabble, at the management, at my &bquo;don't make a fuss&equo; partner. 
 Why does nobody else seem to care? 
 I care. 
 Gary Cooper cares. 
 Marlon Brando cares. 
 This was an occasion that required character. 
 I'd go it alone and rid this cinema of the bums who terrorise it every Sunday night. 
 Striding boldly over I fired a sharp round of insults. 
 Wounded, the punks were stunned into silence as my vitriolic invective ricocheted around the stalls. 
 I was stopped short by torchlight in my face. 
 At last here's justice, I thought. 
 A black suit was stepping in to take the bodies away. 
 &bquo;All right you,&equo; he said, shaking the beam in my eyes, &bquo;out! 
 I've had complaints about you.&equo; 
 The wild bunch were giggling helplessly as I was escorted, proud and unprotesting, to the exit. 
 Tonto followed with the coats. 
 &lsqb;CHRISTINE HAMMOND&rsqb;  In 1958 there was only one television in our street, and when the Lone Ranger made his weekly appearance it was like a mini-cinema in John Logue's front parlour with about twenty of us clustered round the little walnut cabinet. 
 Our only hope for a TV of our own was our uncle John Hep who did the bins and could always be relied on for an old radio or a gramophone. 
 One day he excelled himself, turning up with a piece of furniture the size of a large sideboard which housed the coveted television set along with a radiogram and a place to keep your records. 
 It was corporation booty however, and it was only reasonable to expect that this early entertainment centre might not be firing on all cylinders. 
 In fact the only parts that worked were the radio and the sound on the television. 
 It was ours though, and Mrs Logue's parlour had been getting a bit rough lately. 
 So we used to sit and listen and try to work out what was going on, which gave the Lone Ranger even more mystery. 
 Then came a very special occasion. 
 Not only was the Ritz showing The Lone Ranger and the Lost City of Gold  on the screen, but the Lone Ranger himself was going to make an appearance &bquo;In Person&equo;. 
 My older brother and I immediately laid siege to our mother to let us go. 
 The first main feature we had ever seen. 
 Fantastic! 
 Like visiting the Sistine Chapel after having only read the Thames &amp; Hudson Michelangelo  in braille. 
 Then the actual Lone Ranger appeared. 
 He strode out onto the stage in his pale blue suit amid shouts of &bquo;Where's Tonto?&equo; and &bquo;Take off your mask!&equo; 
 My brother and I had already discussed the possibility of this not being the real Lone Ranger but an impersonator dressed up, and when our man appeared we knew. 
 His trousers were too baggy. 
 &lsqb;JOHN KINDNESS&rsqb;  
 KEYNAS AND CHIV IN RATBY 
 The sign over the box office of the Majestic cinema, Ratby, Leicestershire in the mid 1950s read: &bquo;It's warmer inside&equo;. 
 In summer the word &bquo;warmer&equo; was covered by a wooden panel, hung on nails, which read &bquo;cooler&equo;. 
 Beneath this, another sign reassured us that &bquo;This cinema is treated with DDT&equo;. 
 The cinema was built on a hill, giving a natural rake to the auditorium seating. 
 The back two rows of seats, from which every alternate arm rest had been removed, were for &bquo;Couples Only&equo;. 
 At the age of nine I wondered how I would handle my eventual initiation to the back row seating. 
 The occasion arrived in June 1960, for a screening of Samson and Delilah , with Victor Mature and Hedy Lamarr. 
 The front rows were a different world. 
 These seats were the province of yelling, farting, belching gangs of adolescent males, the bane of the long-suffering manager, Len. 
 It was a toss up whether to try for acceptance in the front row ranks, or work towards qualifying for the back row. 
 One night Len's wife, a small woman, had repeatedly asked a trio of Teds from the next village to cut down their noise and stop carving the backs of the seats. 
 On her ice cream round she lost her temper, bringing down on the head of the ringleader the entire tray of ice cream. 
 Tubs, wooden spoons, choc ices everywhere. 
 And silence. 
 In the centre of the screen was a dark, dribbled patch, a constant feature of every close up kiss, jungle scene and war torn sky. 
 In the late 1960s I went regularly to the plaza cinema in the Isles of Scilly. 
 In the middle of the screen was the same dark patch. 
 The two most notorious characters of the Majestic front row gangs were Keynas and Chiv. 
 Keynas was short, round, swarthy, with matt black hair and an oily burgundy Ted suit. 
 Chiv was tall, broad, fair and clean cut, ruddy faced, shirt collar open even in the depths of winter. 
 Keynas and Chiv were inseparable. 
 Always in the cinema, always wisecracking, often thrown out before the end of the film, but always back next time. 
 Sometimes they would sit on opposite sides of the aisle so that they could turn their banter into a public performance. 
 &bquo;Eyup Chiv, a yo farted?&equo; 
  &bquo;Wornt mey Keynas. 
 Musta bin the bugger beyind me.&equo; 
 My mother told me once that on November the fifth someone in the audience had thrown a firework at the screen and the people in the film jumped. 
 &lsqb;Max Eastley&rsqb; 
 Another night, during a close up shot of Yvonne De Carlo, Keynas called across the cinema: &bquo;Eyup Chiv, shey's got the kinda gob tuh smoke a prick!&equo; 
 And when, as often happened, the screen began to yellow and darken, the cry would go up from the front rows: &bquo;Purra nother bob in Len!&equo; 
 Then Len, who was also the projectionist, would adjust the carbon rods and brightness would be restored. 
 But if Len had nipped out the back for a smoke, the cry would go unheeded, the screen flickered and faded into blackness, then all hell would break loose. 
 Whistling, rapid stamping, cheering, hurling of wrappers, cartons and ice creams &lsqb;which would explain how the screen got stained&rsqb;. 
 Towards the end of the final reel came the scrape and swish of the velvet curtains being swept across on their metal rods followed by the clank of the push bars and the sudden rush of cold night air down the back of the neck. 
 A sure signal for those in the &bquo;Couples Only&equo; seats to adjust their dress, and the rest of us to prepare for the pre national anthem stampede. 
 With the crescendo of the closing music the audience scrambled for the exits, leaving national servicemen and isolated royalists standing to attention. 
 It was half a mile to the chip shop, so you had to get a head start. 
  I left the village in 1963. 
 By that time the cinema had closed down, sold to a firm making fibreglass covers for pneumatic drills. 
 From time to time I have had vivid dreams in which the Majestic has again been open for business, the glass cases full of photographs, lit up, with posters advertising wonderful movies covering the outside walls. 
 In 1986 the plastics factory caught fire and the building was razed to the ground and the dreams have not recurred. 
 &lsqb;CHRIS GARRATT&rsqb; 
 TE HOKINGA MAI KI WHANGANUI 
 The Maori name for the New Zealand Film Archive is Nga Kaitiaki o nga Taonga Whitiahua &lsqb;The guardians of treasured images of light&rsqb;. 
 The most significant of the Maori films in its care are those made by James McDonald during expeditions to various parts of the country in the 1920s. 
 The lengthy restoration process has included, besides the usual preservation and repair work, the translation of all intertitles into Maori by tribal experts, and the return of the films for screenings amongst local people. 
 So now after all these years we are taking He Pito Whakaatu i Te Noho a Te Maori i Te Awa o Whanganui (Scenes of Maori Life on The Whanganui River) , made in 1921, back to Koroniti. 
 It is dusk when we arrive. 
 We are cold and cramped, and apprehensive about our reception, the adequacy of our response to the speeches of welcome, and our awful singing. 
 But because the two meeting houses are enveloped in giant tarpaulins ready for overnight fumigation there will be no official welcome. 
 We meet our local hosts, and in the dining room tea and lamingtons are waiting. 
 While the equipment is being set up people come in from their work outside and visitors start arriving from up and down the Whanganui river. 
 By the time dinner has been eaten and evening prayers conducted it is eight o'clock and about a hundred people have gathered. 
 There is a vocal, direct reaction to all the films on the  programme. 
 Great interest is shown in the activities and scenes depicted: the skill and panache with which cat's cradle is demonstrated is commented on, the speed and technique of the weavers astounds, the making of crayfish pots and operation of eel weirs is studied intently. 
 The whole hall is convulsed to see children elbowed out of the way while the adults take over skipping ropes and doubledutch, 1920s style, fills the screen. 
 There is a contemplative silence when divinatory sticks move seemingly of their own accord. 
 In the Wimpy after 2001  we imitated the apes banging their bones on the ground with our knives and forks on the formica table. 
 &bquo;Daaah Daaah Daaah Da! 
 Da!&equo; me and my brothers sang in chorus. 
 &lsqb;Melissa Benn&rsqb; 
 More profound and moving is the direct communication which the film opens up between the living and the dead. 
 The children in the film are identified as the brothers and sisters of the elders among us. 
 The adults are their parents, grandparents, aunts and uncles. 
 Most are known by name and some are greeted as if they stood before us. 
 The effect, though tears do flow, is not maudlin. 
 personal characteristics are laughed at, family likenesses in the present generations are pointed out, even among the pigs and dogs which still wander around the village. 
 After the film some of the elders talk to the group about the effect the films have on them, of seeing people they still feel spiritually close to on the screen, of the inheritance they have received, and the traditions they want to pass on. 
 For some, the step back in time brings only sadness, for others what they have seen will provide an impetus for the future. 
 We all feel touched by the greatest gift our ancestors have handed down to us. 
 For a while there are speeches, then half the hall is up, performing song after song for us, the visitors, and for themselves as their pride in being Ngati Pamoana manifests itself. 
 At last the mattresses are brought out. 
 It has been both exhilarating and draining and we have to work tomorrow, so we put in our earplugs and pull our sleeping bags over our heads while all around us the talk goes on and on. 
 &lsqb;SHARON DELL&rsqb;   
 Ko &eacute;tehi whanganga a te M&aacute;ori/Aperahama demonstrating method of measuring, Loriniti 1921. 
 Photograph by James McDonald, courtesy National Museum of New Zealand 
 MIVVIS AT HIGH NOON 
 A day of B westerns brought in fans by the droves. 
 Members of western clubs from all over the country converged on a private cinema in Kings Cross. 
 Each group was dedicated to a particular cowboy, be it Red Rider, Tom Mix or Randolph Scott. 
 Their attire was that of their hero, complete with guns and leathers. 
 Hundreds of them assembled outside the cinema, and a group of Asian cowboys from Handsworth staged a shoot out in Grays Inn Road. 
 Self conscious in my normal clothes I seated myself at the rear of the upper stalls. 
 After the first two films there was an intermission. 
 Ice creams and soft drinks were to be served. 
 The ice cream girl must have had a lie in this Sunday morning, and she arrived towards the end of the film showing prior to the interval. 
 As the film ended she faced the darkened cinema. 
 When the lights came up the girl looked at the audience, her mouth slowly opened and on her face was an expression of incredulity. 
 The armed and thirsty outlaws were rising from their seats and moving towards her with jangling spurs and cap guns. 
 They had one thing on their minds and she was it. 
 The punk ice cream girl with the Mohican hair cut fled stage left. 
 &lsqb;JOHN WELSON&rsqb; 
 MAORI COWBOYS 
 In New Zealand's&equo; King Country' &mdash; so called because of the Maori kings who fought a guerrilla war against the settling English &mdash; Maori lads fresh from rounding up the droves of merino sheep from the bush clad hills would have a night out in the one horse town and go to the fleapit. 
 They'd cart a case of beer and their heavy saddles into the cinema under the cloak of darkness and, sitting astride their saddles in the front row, would cheer on the cowboys and ride rough with them, Waikato 4X in one hand and their stetsons in the other. 
 They hooped and hollered with john  Wayne, Sitting Bull, Doris Day and Jack Palance, thirsty for the shooting and the scalping, riding hell for leather through gorges and down hillsides. 
 Their hats sailed up, whirling black against the screen, as the dust rose from the red plush seating, while in the back rows the disapproving dentist's wife, would shake their heads and tut tut at the rowdies down front. 
 &lsqb;ALYSON STONEMAN HUNTER&rsqb; 
 MEN ON HORSEBACK 
 Because I found historical films about men on horseback so moving I was pleased when my then wife, Jenni, set to writing a book about the wild west. 
 She wrote it in Nairobi, where I had a university job from 1968 to 1971. 
 It was an exciting time, in retrospect a brief golden age between the end of colonial rule and the point when the repressiveness of the Kanu regime grew so blatant that disillusion, new East African writer would emerge, following in the  footsteps of my already famous colleague, who then called himself James Ngugi. 
 The first Kenyan African novelist was a man of anger, developing the marxist position that would eventually bring him detention without trial for a year, followed by exile. 
 After an argument about politics and poetics on the verandah of the Norfolk Hotel, I would often go with Jenni to the movies. 
 Nairobi commonly saw Hollywood films before they reached Britain. 
 We were not starved of new westerns in that era when great old stars were playing aged gunfighters and movie squabbled with movie on the ideological terrain laid out by the war in Vietnam. 
 I was captivated by Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid . 
 Newman and Redford seemed to express the youthful, anarchical values of 1968-and-all-that. 
 Then came a conference of the English departments of the East African universities at Moshi, in Tanzania, a wonderfully beautiful place near Mount Kilimanjaro. 
 As wagtails flittered over the swimming pool, Jack Mitchell heard me admire Butch and lectured me sternly. 
 Jack was a gingery Scottish communist normally domiciled in East Berlin but then teaching in Dar es Salaam. 
 He had not been one of the late Stalin's critics, but I liked the way he sang his large repertoire of Scottish folksongs and I heeded him when he denounced Butch and Sundance. 
  &bquo;Arrogant American imperialism. 
 Look, laddie, it takes the entire Bolivian Army to wipe out two gringos. 
 The Wild Bunch  did not seduce me. 
 We went to see it with Ngugi and his wife Nyambura. 
 I found the film's final frenzied violence detestable. 
 At the end, I turned half in shame towards Ngugi, who merely grunted. 
 I fancied that I knew what he was thinking; much like what Jack would have thought. 
 Back in Britain a year or two later, I was one of a panel collected to perform before a group of young Americans who were paying Richard Demarco, Edinburgh's most flamboyant cultural entrepreneur, for the privilege of drinking the wisdom of the New Scottish Enlightenment at source. 
 The issue of violence in the arts came up. 
 Another participant was an elderly Orcadian poetess prone to say very, very softly things such as &bquo;life is like a glass of pure water&equo;. 
 When I suggested that The Wild Bunch  was a prime example of nasty, unartistic violence, she reproved me. 
 &bquo;That,&equo; she said, her voice echoing with the cries of oystercatchers and lapwings over remote beaches where seals rolled and basked inshore, &bquo;That is one of the most beautiful  films ever made.&equo; 
 &lsqb;ANGUS CALDER&rsqb; 
 TICH'S NIGHT OUT 
 The Wheel Tapper pub behind the railway station in Taunton was my haven when I worked at the art college there in the late 1960s and early 1970s. 
 Straight off the London train and in the front door. 
 It was the one pub where students could be guaranteed not to gather in jabbering crowds: the reason was the clientele. 
 The Wheel Tapper was a cider pub, and the only one in town that tolerated the hard core of tomato-faced cider drinkers who, outside licensing hours, sat talking garrulously on public benches or passed out surrounded by flagons on the lawns of the Floral Gardens. 
 When the sun went down and the evening turned chill the cider-heads made for the warmth of  the Wheel Tapper bar. 
 At 9 o'clock I joined them. 
 The draught cider, poured from wooden barrels, was of two kinds: sweet, which no one drank, and rough. 
 The latter was aptly named, so tart that the first gulp curled your lips back. 
 No one called it scrumpy, just as no one in Ireland ever says, &bquo;Top o'the morning&equo;. 
 It was rough cider, known wryly as &bquo;cripplecock&equo; to those whose lifeblood it was. 
 Every barrel a different strength, no quality control in those days. 
 But never less than dangerous and unpredictable, as were its effects. 
 A domino game was cut short when one of the players clawed his jacket to shreds trying to ward off the spiders. 
 Another night a man rushed out of the bar and head-butted a double-decker bus. 
 The next day a father broke his son's arm. 
 A man playing cards had an open wound in his forehead, blood dripping onto the crib board. 
 An old woman telling me the story of her life shat herself halfway through the Second World War. 
 A regular in wellington boots plastered with cow dung ordered a pint, took off his overcoat and hung it up, unaware that he'd lost his trousers somewhere en route. 
 But most nights it was quiet and uneventful. 
 One Monday I was the only person out of four in the bar who was not unconscious. 
 By no means the perfect pub, but as good a place as any to spend an evening in a town which I always thought would make an ideal site for a nuclear test. 
 As the credits rolled my mother and father, like most filmgoers of that generation, stood for the National Anthem. 
 But my mother's leg had gone to sleep. 
 It gave way beneath her, she fell and then rolled helplessly down the aisle. 
 My father, torn between allegiance to The Wife or the Monarch, remained standing to attention, biting his stiff upper lip. 
 &lsqb;Jo Finn&rsqb; 
 Tich, my darts partner, was a loner. 
 When the rest of the crowd turned out at closing time and headed for the Floral Gardens with their carry-outs, Tich bedded down for the night in the public lavatory on the other side of the railway bridge. 
 On Christmas Day he was moved out by a policeman, and that, he said, was when he lost his faith. 
 A gentle, amiable alcoholic, Tich supplemented his dole money in the pea picking season, but the soil got into the cuts on his hands and poisoned his blood. 
 Rough cider destroys one of the healing vitamins in the body if drunk to excess, and Tich was pickled in it. 
 His face grew puffy, his arms and legs swelled up, and his fingers turned into purple sausages so that he kept dropping his darts. 
 They took him to the cider ward of the local hospital and a week later he was dead. 
 But Tich was always happy in his way, and curiously one of his merriest nights was when he and the  The Shepton Mallet pop festival was one of the first and biggest outdoor pop concerts, a drug-raddled campsite without tents, populated by beaded flower children in kaftans and body paint who had hitch-hiked west in their tens of thousands. 
 Some of them straggled back through Taunton, and being in no hurry to get home settled down in the Floral Gardens, playing guitars and tambourines, smoking joints, dropping acid and chanting mantras. 
 The ciderheads took an instant liking to these fellow dropouts who also slept rough and were equally unsteady on their feet. 
 But the old 'uns were scathing about the hippies' chemicals. 
 &bquo;You don't want to bother with none of that there marry jewarna m'dear, that's a king's ransom you'm paying. 
 Here, have a swig of this m'old beauty, and it only be a shilling a pint.&equo; 
 Glug, glug, glug. 
 &bquo;Wow, far out, and it's organic man.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh aah, it be that all right m'dear, you'm grow leaves if you drink enough of it.&equo; 
 One day we sat there enthralled by Hiroshima Mon Amour . 
 During the final minutes the woman in front of us exploded. 
 She's been wearing an inflatable plastic suit that slimmed your body and she'd ignited it with her cigarette. 
 &lsqb;Tom Wakefield&rsqb; 
 A bond of kinship spanned the generation gap. 
 The bar of The Wheel Tapper filled up and then one night emptied completely: Woodstock had eventually found its way to the local cinema. 
 The festival film to end them all, nonstop music and a million people stoned out of their skulls. 
 Nirvana. 
 The hippies and the ciderheads alike were keen to see it. 
 They formed a queue outside the cinema, pockets of greasy overcoats and grubby kaftans bulging with flagons. 
 Those few citizens of Taunton who walked the streets after dark tut-tutted and averted their gaze as the motley queue filed inside and settled down. 
 The film was everything they had hoped for and they loved every minute of it. 
 The miasma of cider, dope, urine and unwashed flesh filled the auditorium, while on screen their American friends wallowed in the mud with glazed eyes. 
 And when the little bouncing balls came up onscreen, pointing out the subtitled lyrics for &bquo;Fixin' To Die Rag&equo;, the ciderheads were in seventh heaven. 
 What was a night out without a sing-song? ln broad Somerset accents they bellowed out the words, waving their flagons in unison. 
 &bquo;And it's one, two, three, what are we fighting for? 
 Don't ask me I don't give a damn, next stop is Vietnam. 
 And it's five, six, seven, open up the pearly gates. 
 Ain't no time to wonder why, whoopee we're  all going to die!&equo; 
 Those who couldn't read the words made them up, and Tich, who'd lost his glasses, settled for singing &bquo;Widecombe Fair&equo; instead, coughing, spluttering and relishing his last night out. 
 &lsqb;IAN BREAKWELL&rsqb; 
 AN AFTERNOON AT THE OPERA 
 When I lived in Dublin at the end of the Second World War, one of my friends was an obsessive film buff whose dramatic recall, frame by frame, of scenes such as the Odessa Steps sequence from Battleship Potemkin  or the final chase in Fritz Lang's M  often hypnotized even the drunks in the bars we frequented. 
 One afternoon we went together to see an Italian filmed opera in a small cinema off Grafton Street which specialised in foreign films. 
 In his usual way, as soon as the film started, George begin to give me a run down on the technical assets I might otherwise be missing. 
 &bquo;Observe, dear Lionel, the remarkable framing of the leg and its juxtaposition with the Corinthian column.&equo; 
 And so on. 
 When, at the high point of the opera, Norma , the stir began to get into her stride with &bquo; Casta Diva &equo;, and George into his stride with gratuitous evaluations of the lighting and editing, a woman behind us brought a large bag of herrings smartly down on George's bald head, with the words: &bquo;Will yer for Jesus's sake hold yer gob while I listen to that poor woman there!&equo; 
 &lsqb;LIONEL MISKIN&rsqb; 
 SECOND EDIT 
 On an aeroplane you're helpless. 
 The film you see is somebody else's choice, and it usually has George Segal in it. 
 Once I watched a whole movie with the wrong soundtrack. 
 It was Fletch , and when Chevy Chase spoke it was  Julie Andrews who came out of his mouth. 
 On Saturdays in those Isle of Arran summers the picture palace became the dance hall. 
 The splintery stage was then commanded by a gramophone roaring out 78 rpm hits of the period. 
 Fronting it was a thin moustachioed man confined in a tight suit. 
 With nothing but a pole up his back and a drum wedged between his legs he bashed away with panache, as if frantically sewing up a leaking willie with giant needle and thread. 
 &lsqb;Ron Geesin&rsqb; 
 You're trapped in your headphones and trapped in your seat. 
 You feel helpless, too, because you're watching it in danger. 
 Cinemas are safe, that is one of their charms. 
 They're dark and upholstered and warm as the womb. 
 There's staff with uniforms to look after you. 
 A plane cabin tries to fool you with the same set-up, but suddenly it meets turbulence, bumps and jolts, and three hundred of you sit there thinking of the drop beneath. 
 In the middle of A Man for All Seasons  there's a ping, and on come the little red signs: FASTEN YOUR SEATBELT. 
 In front of the celluloid swordfight three hundred souls fear for their lives. 
 Once, coming back from New York, we were all watching a romantic comedy. 
 It was interrupted by the captain's voice telling us that thanks to the strong following winds we would be arriving in London three quarters of an hour before schedule. 
 Trouble was, the film wasn't nearly finished. 
 So a stewardess fast forwarded it. 
 We sat, rigid in our seats, as chunks of gabbling plot sped by. 
 Our suave heroes were transformed into Laurel and Hardy: suburban life speeded up into some manic, coronary inducing rush hour. 
 How time flies! 
 We were at our stewardess's mercy. 
 She had promoted herself into the film's second editor, and slowed it down to normal at the bits she liked, and thought we would appreciate. 
 These bits were the love scenes. 
 Suddenly, once they were in each other's arms, our hero and heroine acted like normal human beings. 
 According to our blonde stewardess, herself an object of fantasy, all life was a mindless rush, gabbled nonsense, sweaty commuting between the only moments that made sense, the embrace of a man and a woman. 
 And how beautifully she stage managed it: as we touched down at Heathrow, the final credits were rolling. 
 &lsqb;DEBORAH MOGGACH&rsqb;  
 BLIND MAN'S MOVIE BUFF 
 At this moment the creator of so many milestones in our young lives, our first childhood projections, lies somewhere in California, frozen stiff in a steel and glass drawer, boxed up well below zero. 
 There Walt Disney awaits the kiss of cure, as if he were his own Sleeping Beauty. 
 &lsqb;Tony Jackson&rsqb; 
 The screen &mdash; the sail of the new voyages of discovery 
 Movies in flight &mdash; 
 the jet held on its course by the steady pressure of an image 
 Listen &mdash; the seeing eye dog 
 whines in the darkroom 
 Celluloid begins to yawn and flower 
 As the atomic submarine approaches the pole 
 the sailor beginning to crack leaps up in front of the 
 projector 
 Across an outdoor cinema screen flaps a heavy 
 unidentified bird 
 A berserk laundromatte &mdash; the last switches are being 
 pulled in the control rooms of Atlantis T.V. 
 The montage gets too complex here &mdash; the film splits open 
 with screams of laughter 
 The mad dentist is projecting 
 grand canyons into cavities 
 baby movies onto atom-clouds 
 The hands in the laps growing still 
 as the lava pours over Herculaneum 
 The hell within the negative &mdash; 
 throats nostrils and all orifices 
 glow with an unearthly inward burning 
 X-ray plates clenched between the teeth of skulls grinning 
 on candid camera 
 snap into two &mdash; 
 And at last the darkroom door swings open 
 The seeing eye dog 
 is tracking the smell of burning 
 back to a cigarette on a luxury movie-house carpet 
 &mdash; Odour potent as the first 
 land-breeze 
 A field of crickets is heard distantly through the sound of 
 the projector 
 We are drifting towards a mysterious landfall 
 The faint ground-flicker of interior universes 
 within the darkening screen. 
 &lsqb;HARRY FAINLIGHT&rsqb; 
 KETCHUP ARTISTES 
 A wet afternoon in Pwllheli. 
 Lawrence of Arabia squinted across the dunes. 
 He was wearing a tea towel all right, but Lawrence was a funny name for an Arab and he seemed confused about caravans. 
 I suspected a con, especially when the shot horses didn't bleed. 
 The beach had been promised the night before, but rain had obliged an alternative treat. 
 Going to the pictures fitted the bill: somewhere to go, something to do, a rarity shared by crowds of strangers. 
 That week it was Lawrence of Arabia . 
 Next week it was probably The Sound of Music . 
 It usually was in Pwllheli, until the bingo. 
 I left the cinema with a rush of questions, mainly about blood, and a wise response answered them all: &bquo;It's only a film.&equo; 
 The realisation dawned from that moment. 
 Films were made up. 
 They were trying to put one over on us and would no longer get away with it. 
 Puzzlement gave way to bravado and a new found delight in catching the ketchup artistes at it. 
 Back home, matinees provided the chance to practise and shine. 
 For a while it was enough to heckle the love scenes and cackle at disasters. 
 When the novelty of criticism began to wear off  we set up rival fringe performances. 
 A bag of popcorn and a seat at the edge of the circle could attract more attention down below than Flash Gordon . 
 A marble and a stalls back seat could be worth several minutes of noisy bagatelle. 
 All this was kids' stuff though compared to the break into directing. 
 We were about ten when nuisance escalated into serious engagement. 
 Someone pretty old told us moths flew to light. 
 We already knew films were just projected light, as a spin-off discovery from experimentation with Park Drives. 
 Luckily, railway stations around Manchester kept their gas lamps well into the age of juvenile delinquency. 
 The prospect of the moth scam was so exciting we even bought platform tickets so as not to blow it at the development stage. 
 Captured moths were consigned to jamjars overnight to await the matinee. 
 The usherette was untrained in spotting sweaty palms. 
 The film was unmemorable Elvis. 
 Small guerrilla hands hovered ready to unscrew jamjar lids. 
 The moths suffered a rousing shaking as the right moment was watched for. 
 Framed by a swimming pool and women with pointed breasts, Elvis sneered lustily and was clearly about to burst into song. 
 Off with the lids. 
 The exquisite timing would have been a credit to the deftest of film editors, but was wasted. 
 The moths stayed  put. 
 Rattling the jars dislodged them. 
 Three or four dropped into the darkness and choc ice wrappers, dead; a few fluttered aimlessly to rest around us; some took off into the vast space above. 
 Half the faces in the stalls were turned the wrong way, trying to see what the fuss was about in the back row. 
 Anticipation turned to frustration. 
 Recriminations flew. 
 Too many privet leaves had made them dozy. 
 Not enough holes in the lids had made them breathless. 
 Suddenly, they'd made it: huge black fluttering blots on the smooth features of a full frame Elvis. 
 The cavalry had arrived, the dambusters had done it. 
 Yells of triumph and foot stomping attracted the attention of the manager, who attracted ours with a long cane. 
 Thrown out, blinking, into the daylight, we wondered if they'd find the jars. 
 If they did, would the silvery dust mean anything to them? 
 Some of us wondered about the moths. 
 We decided they'd be all right eating the bile yellow satin curtains. 
 And we were famous anyway. 
 The rest of the week was passed scrawling graffiti in splendid public places. 
 Next Saturday we were frisked, just like in the films. 
 The following week we took the Ritzy. 
 Like actors remembered as great for just turning up, the moths are recalled as gigantic, vivid images when they were probably just spectral smudges. 
 They made a mark though. 
 &lsqb;STEVE BUCKLEY&rsqb; 
 NILE ON FIRE 
 As we enter the darkened cinema it is around 11.30 p.m. and the seats are quickly filling with various rowdies, late-night drinkers and revellers to whom we eagerly add ourselves. 
 In the cinema foyer the two old ladies who run the cinema are both dispensing and receiving abuse from all sides as to the quality of the night's offerings, Storm Over the Nile  and Voodoo Woman . 
 They are dressed in blue nylon housecoats over knee length silver boots. 
  inevitable Pearl &amp; Dean advertising slot comes hurtling out of the screen. 
 Immediately we realise that something is very wrong. 
 The sound has been increased to such a volume that, as I turn my head as if from a physical blow, I notice rows of heads with their eyes staring wildly and hair blown back as in a fierce gale. 
 I stumble up the aisle to the immense ponderous tones of a god extolling the virtues of a restaurant in Moscow Road, Bayswater, and pass through some dingy curtains into the foyer. 
 I try to explain to the two silver boots &lsqb;now accompanied by the projectionist, drinking tea&rsqb; what is wrong but I cannot make myself heard even out here. 
 By pointing to my ears and making signs I eventually elicit the response from the projectionist, &bquo;I'll turn it down when I've had my tea.&equo; 
 The first night a girl put her hand inside my trousers was during a Kenneth More film about the sinking of the Titanic . 
 It was called A Night to Remember . 
 &lsqb;Mike Evans&rsqb; 
 During the first film, Storm Over the Nile , there is such a storm of noise in the cinema from the drunken audience that it proves impossible to follow the plot at all. 
 After about an hour when the pies and chips have stopped flying across the screen I notice a strange purple growth, like a cancer cell under a microscope, at the bottom left hand corner of the screen. 
 Growing in the most sinister manner, it is embedded in a battle scene taking place across the River Nile. 
 Suddenly at the height of the battle this purple and now orange mushroom bursts across the entire screen, devouring both armies in its path. 
 Immediately and without any explanation the screen darkens and the deafening strains of &bquo;Bye Bye Blackbird&equo; burst from the speakers. 
 &lsqb;NICK CUDWORTH&rsqb; 
 LE CINEMA AU PEUPLE! 
 A film festival in one of the poorest countries in the world, Burkina Faso, celebrating the development of authentic, indigenous African cinema. 
 Last night a group of small children sang &bquo; L'Internationale &equo;, uncertain about the words, out of tune, but with an authenticity and optimism that is  no longer possible in Europe. 
 A double bill in the afternoon. 
 I sit next to a down and out who has salvaged h is lunch from the bins. 
 He reaches into his bag, brings out a sandwich, then stands up and inspects it is the projector beam to see what it contains. 
 He has a classic sense of gastronomic order. 
 Meat and cheese must come after fish; there is fruit for dessert. 
 The whole meal takes almost an hour and makes me ravenous. 
 &lsqb;Pete Ayrton&rsqb; 
 La Patrie ou mort nous vaincrons ! 
 Here, this evening, in a local open air cinema on the sprawling outskirts of a one storey town (Secteur 14), the screening of a political documentary from Ghana with a Radio Moscow soundtrack. 
 The commentary is largely ignored by an animated audience that talks while watching and participates by applauding the rich images of trays of ripe fruit and tomatoes in the marketplace in Managua, Nicaragua. 
 Then Comrade President Thomas Sankara stepping off a plane, during a state visit, inspects a row of soldiers and salutes a flag. 
 L'Ecran africain aux films africains ! 
 The noises of scuttling and rustling on the concrete floor. 
 Glancing down to see brown rats moving confidently amongst the metal chairlegs, sniffling at the discarded sweet papers and orange peel. 
 The audience is blithely unconcerned as the rats' rancid pink tongues stretch out to lick gently at pink heels. 
 &lsqb;ROD STONEMAN&rsqb; 
 MOMA 
 The film shows at the Museum of Modern Art attract a strange audience. 
 Very old people who come to all the shows tend to talk throughout the experimental work or leave. 
 People drift in and out. 
 The serious remain. 
 Very big audiences become small ones. 
 It's a hard crowd to figure. 
 One night I was there, before the start of the film, a young man leaped onto the stage and announced that he was an unemployed actor looking for a role in a movie. 
 He pointed to his seat and urged anyone interested to contact him then and there. 
 Smiling he leaped from the stage and the audience applauded. 
 We became a more relaxed crowd and 1 remarked casually to the elderly woman beside me, &bquo;New York's such a crazy place.&equo; 
  Her answer was less casual. 
 She replied: &bquo;Yes, that's because of the Galiciani. 
 The Litvaks are not  funny.&equo; 
 She paused and continued: &bquo;the English are Jews. 
 Gaelic is Hebrew but no one knew this until Pitman invented shorthand and then without the vowels it was clear that Gaelic and Hebrew were the same. 
 The English are  Jews.&equo; 
 Her hand waved in front of her and she said: &bquo;My daughter wrote the best art book ever written. 
 It's across the street in the Donnell Library. 
 My husband invented radar. 
 All the books are across the street.&equo; 
 I consider this as the lights dim. 
 &lsqb;LYNNE TILLMAN&rsqb; 
 Street scene, Burkina Faso (photo: Rod Stoneman) 
 STRANGLING IN THE STALLS 
 Festival crowds here in Montreal are a committed lot. 
 By the time the two week World Film Festival winds down at the beginning of September most of the cinephiles standing in the long queues at the box office have no idea what they're waiting for; they'll watch anything that moves. 
 Once in the cinema, openness of mind and concentration tend to be their trademarks. 
 So it was with some surprise a few years ago that our attention was drawn from the dull French film noir  onscreen to the back of the cinema, where a couple were resolving a lovers' squabble. 
 The man had his fingers around the woman's throat and was banging her head against the back of the seat. 
 When another patron tried to step in, the enraged lover flew at him. 
 An usher made an unsuccessful attempt to separate the two men, but it took the intervention of the woman to calm things down. 
 She guided her emotional mate back to his seat and sat with her arms around him until he tried to kill her again. 
 This scene was repeated at five minute intervals until the police arrived. 
 &lsqb;BARBARA SAMUELS&rsqb;  
 CINEPHILES 
 The National Film Theatre in London shows a wonderful variety of films but obviously has little of the atmosphere of the high street picture palace. 
 Even the bars and foyers are reminiscent of nothing so much as an airport lounge, an impression reinforced by the tannoy announcements of five, three and one minute calls for Casablanca . 
 Paris Texas  and Roma . 
 But strange people, outcasts from public cinemas, can become members of the National Film Theatre by anonymous postal application. 
 So the stodgy respectability of the official state cinema becomes leavened with curious characters. 
 The tweedy lady, very county, who suffered from some extreme fungoid disease of her feet, which were wrapped in many layers of polythene and which in a public cinema would have guaranteed her a whole row to herself, but at the NFT caused whoever was unfortunate to have the adjoining numbered seat to retain vivid Aromavision memories of particular films. 
 Colonel Flasher, very military bearing, exposed himself with parade ground precision. 
 Napoleon's Number One Fan, who during Abel Gance's film was accused by the man in the next seat of masturbating underneath his hat and splashing his wife, but who stoutly defended himself by saying that the unfortunate staining would never have happened if she hadn't nudged him and thus dislodged the titfer from his lap. 
 And then there was Our Lady of the Leftovers who entered the NFT bar wearing a fur stole and carrying a sequinned evening bag. 
 Her face lit up with a delighted smile as she gazed at an abandoned plate of half-eaten sandwiches on a nearby table. 
 She stuffed the sandwiches into her evening bag and continued on her way, her eyes sparkling. 
 With special affection I remember the metro railway enthusiasts who, confronted by rigorous structuralist films or scenes of sexual and scatalogical excess, walked out of the cinema in baffled confusion during the first NFT International Underground Film Festival and indignantly demanded their money back after having booked for a whole season of what seemed like fascinating specialist  delights: German Underground, American Underground, Italian Underground. 
 In the first scene of Annie Hall  Woody Allen was talking directly at the audience. 
 The man behind me leant forward and whispered in my ear, &bquo;Tell that guy to quit yapping will you? 
 Tell him I wanna watch this film.&equo; 
 &lsqb;Timothy Emlyn Jones&rsqb; 
 Meanwhile, back in the &bquo;bar area&equo; the deadly serious cinephiles for whom going to the cinema had as much magic as attending evening class droned endlessly on. 
 An elegantly dressed man and an elegantly dressed woman were sitting opposite each other. 
 She was dressed in a two-piece suit, the skirt just above her knees, and black calf-length boots. 
 He was dressed in casual wear: grey sweater and slacks with knife edge creases. 
 He was telling her who, in his opinion, are the most important French film directors, pausing only to adjust the creases in his trousers. 
 She listened, her little finger cocked as she held her coffee cup poised above its saucer. 
 As he spoke he broke the seal on the carton of cream for his coffee, inadvertently squeezed the carton, and squirted a little jet of cream up her skirt between her thighs. 
 &lsqb;IAN BREAKWELL&rsqb; 
 BROBDINGNAG 
 I don't know how it came to be shown at the Carlton, East Ham, but one Sunday my parents took me to see The Sheep Has Five Legs  starring the French comedian Fernandel. 
 I was nine years old and this was the first foreign film I'd seen (probably the first most people had seen in East London). 
 As far as I recall Fernandel played all five brothers in five linked episodes. 
 The part I vividly remember was about a South Seas tramp steamer captain. 
 The scene was set in a cabin on the boat with two men lone Fernandell and a beautiful Tahitian girl wearing only a grass skirt. 
 In front of each man on the table was a lump of sugar and sealed in the cabin with them was a fly. 
 If the fly landed on your sugar lump you got the girl. 
 The tension mounted as the fly buzzed around the room giving the audience, every now and again, a fleeting glimpse of the girl. 
 I was already sliding down in my seat trying to indicate to my parents without actually looking away from the screen that I wasn't at all  interested, when suddenly there was a close shot of the fly as it settled on her shoulder. 
 The camera followed it down as it walked across her breast (thirty foot wide) and past her nipple (five foot high). 
 What a sight! 
 I sank down further until I could just see over the seat in front. 
 What a Sunday afternoon! 
 &lsqb;JOHN CHRISTIE&rsqb; 
 The manager was patrolling the aisles and found a pair of lady's panties on the floor by the back stalls. 
 He picked them up and courteously enquired of the young woman sitting closest with her boyfriend if they were hers. 
 With equal decorum she replied, &bquo;Oh no, mine are in my handbag.&equo; 
 &lsqb;Noel Spence&rsqb; 
 THE OPAQUE SCREEN 
 When I was six my grandparents took me to see a film which I was told to observe closely because I would learn lessons about good behaviour and deportment from one of the juvenile characters. 
 All I remember is that at one point he walked along with one foot on the kerb and the other in the gutter and was told off for limping. 
 After the film I tried it myself, with similar results. 
 Since then I have always had trouble with films that were supposed to teach me something, or from which I hoped to learn. 
 Film shows at school on the manufacture of coal gas intercut interesting views of hot coke being extruded from retorts with dull shots of gas scrubbers removing sulphur compounds from the hot gas. 
 But neither at school nor at home was there a gas supply. 
 I knew that occasionally people put their heads in gas ovens, but there was no mention of that. 
 When I looked to films for information on sexual and romantic matters they were not much help either. 
 It seemed that in emotional encounters men and women stood face to face, talking excited nonsense while each looked with agitation into their partner's eyes. 
 Then, unless gangsters broke in and disturbed them, they lay down and the screen went hazy, then the lights went out. 
 Slide shows were just as bad. 
 I went to a lecture on hermaphroditism. 
 The introduction was all about X and Y chromosomes in embryology, and I fell asleep. 
 I woke to see through half open eyes enormous Technicolour images of baffling genitalia filling the wall. 
 To this day just to see or  hear the word &bquo;hermaphrodite&equo; is sufficient to make those luminous pictures shimmer before my eyes. 
 I was watching Stalag 17  with my grandmother and being felt up by a dirty old man. 
 I was disconcerted but the fascination with the film went on. 
 I was seven years old. 
 It was an almost empty theatre in Long Beach, Long Island, a tourist spot with a boardwalk and beautiful beaches. 
 I came out and told granny, she was ashamed of me. 
 We never went there again. 
 &lsqb;Suzannah Hall&rsqb; 
 The seeds of further sexual confusion were sown by the custom, in the cinemas of Wellington, Shropshire, where I lived, of spraying the audience with perfumed deodorant during the intervals. 
 Sometimes I smell that odour as a perfume on women, like sweet Harpic. 
 Then came military service and a training film on snipers. 
 Two men with muddied faces and bracken on their helmets are in a ruined building, trying to spot an enemy rifleman. 
 At an upstairs window they present a life size dummy head: firm jaw, aquiline nose, shining complexion. 
 Crack! 
 The head disappears backwards. 
 Aha, just as they thought, and they have kept a lookout for movement, a flash that reveals the enemy position. 
 But questions remain as the film continues. 
 Do soldiers really carry around realistic papier-m&acirc;ch&eacute; heads just in case? 
 If, having signed for one of these heads, they return it with the nose shot off, what then? 
 Did some firm have a contract to produce these heads, and in what quantities: a hundred, a gross, a thousand? 
 Is there somewhere an MOD store, perhaps underground at Box Hill, a long wooden building smelling of oil and blankets, with row upon row of heads, snipers for the use of, gathering dust while the rosy, hand tinted complexions fade to chalk and grey plaster? 
 Code name &bquo;Warhead&equo;?. 
 &lsqb;P P O'LEARY&rsqb; 
 THE HEN THAT LAID THE SILVER EGG 
 At the end of the war my neighbour Mrs Cooper was young Giovanna Boccalon, growing up in Pasiano, an Italian village not far from Treviso. 
 Those were lean years, without money for trips to the cinema. 
 But the Boccalons kept chickens. 
 Giovanna and her friend Ninetta were willing to help with the hens, in fact to provide physical assistance in the premature delivery of eggs. 
 While Giovanna sang en-  couragingly, stroked and patted the chicken's back, Ninetta watched underneath for any result. 
 Patience was essential. 
 &bquo;With one bound he was free&equo;. 
 And we were too. 
 &lsqb;John Conquest&rsqb; 
 On a good day, eggs in their pockets, they would set off knowing the silver screen was theirs. 
 The cinema was tiny, run single-handed by Neno Rossi, who would store the entrance eggs in straw and then run the projector. 
 By the time films reached Pasiano they were far from pristine: they might be unintentionally silent and sometimes stopped altogether. 
 Giovanna would return home, ravished but resentful. 
 To her criticisms her mother would say: &bquo;Well, what do you expect for an egg?&equo; 
 &lsqb;MAGGI HAMBLING&rsqb; 
 FADING EDDIE 
 Each year, shortly before graduation, the sixth grade class of my elementary school was treated to a day of sun, roller skating, hot-dog gorging and swimming pool frolics at Tones Beach, Long Island. 
 The day came, and with it a forty days, forty nights style rainstorm. 
 We felt damned. 
 I'm sure none of us noticed what must have been expressions of pure panic on the faces of our two teachers and the several parents who had volunteered to keep their own children and their classmates from certain death by drowning in the pool. 
 Rut some desperate quick thinker had phoned Radio City Music Hall, that palace of film, live shows and the mighty Wurlitzer. 
 This was long before &bquo;X&equo; or any other ratings except those of the Catholic Church, and no one thought or cared to ask what was playing. 
 We arrived, toting our towels, watched the Radio City Music Hall Rockettes do their synchronised high kicks (a great bunch those Rockettes), the curtains parted in front of the screen, the symbol of the film studio appeared (I've always loved this part, but was it a lady or a lion?), and the title of the film zoomed forward: The Eddie Duchin Story , starring Tyrone Tower, my mother's favourite. 
 The film ended as poor Eddie met his Maker in a way unmemorable except in visual  terms: he sat at his piano becoming lighter and lighter in tone. 
 I found myself thinking, &bquo;old piano players never die, they just fade away.&equo; 
 I think this was my first conscious experience of cynicism in response to sentimentality. 
 &lsqb;ELENA ALEXANDER&rsqb; 
 Kids and chicks, Easter matinee at the Stepney Troxy, 1950s 
 TRICK 
 There are a couple of sequences in The Gaucho  that stay etched in the memory. 
 In one Douglas Fairbanks tells a woman to follow him and when faced with her persistent refusal, arguing as she does that she cannot abandon her home, he tethers his horses to the latter and carts the whole house off in a burst of white-toothed laughter. 
 At another moment in the film a door is closed and we see a key in the lock. 
 The gaucho slips a rug under the door, ejects the key and then recovers it by hauling the rug towards him. 
 As simple as can be, except that nowhere in the world have I encountered a door with such a gap between it and the floor. 
 Thirty-five years later I saw the film again in New York. 
 But the time to &bquo;recognise&equo; it image by image had gone; just as the moments of each day fade away, so I'd forgotten it. 
 A more precise impression remains of Shoulder Arms , seen around the same time. 
 It concerns the famous sequence in the flooded trench when the soldiers are getting ready to spend the night. 
 Charlie Chaplin lies down, his body disappears from view, then his head. 
 Even today I remember my stupefaction close to terror. 
 Because I couldn't countenance how you could stay under water without being asphyxiated, and yet at the same time I was incapable of comprehending the trick. 
 Faced with a fact that was visually undeniable I was snared in the total impossibility of &bquo;understanding&equo; it. 
 In short, here was an extremely succinct initiation into the notion of the &bquo;existence&equo; of the world, once religious fakery had been eliminated. 
 &lsqb;MARCEL MARIEN&rsqb;   
 In the sleeper compartment of a train speeding through the night a youth crouches over a naked woman he has drugged with a hypodermic syringe. 
 The youth unwraps a razor blade and slices through the veins of her wrist, fastening his lips to the wound as he hungrily drinks the spurting blood. 
 The man in the row in front arches backwards over his seat, his breath sucked in through clenched teeth. 
 &lsqb;Ian Breakwell&rsqb; 
 WATER AND DREAMS 
 I fell into a swimming pool. 
 My mother found me floating face downwards and I was saved by artificial respiration. 
 After that I had a fear of water, especially the sea, but I learned to live with it and even became a good swimmer. 
 Then, when I was grown up I saw the film The Sinking of the Titanic  and it brought back the terror. 
 people were floundering in the water. 
 My nightmares returned at a time when everything was crowding in on me and I couldn't cope. 
 I decided to commit suicide, by drowning. 
 I made two attempts but they both failed, each time my fear of water proved too much. 
 The first time I went back to a lake where I used to go as a child. 
 I tried to knock myself out with some cider I'd bought, then I swallowed a bottle of weedkiller and started to walk towards the lake. 
 But I'd bought the wrong weedkiller, it was Tumbleweed and I found out later it's only lethal to tropical fish, apparently I should have bought pathklear which is much stronger. 
 I was suddenly violently sick and fell into a ditch. 
 When I came round I felt much better and I turned my back on the lake and went home. 
 The second time I caught a bus to the coast. 
 The brambles were head high, my face got all scratched. 
 Eventually I reached the cliff top. 
 Down below were lots of fishing boats  and I decided to wait until they returned to the harbour. 
 I lay down across the path. 
 Some time later a man came along the path and stopped to ask me if I was all right, I told him yes and to please go away, which he did but I thought he'll go to fetch help so I'd better do it now. 
 I took off my rings and jewellery and put them in my handbag then lowered myself over the cliff edge. 
 I slid down until I became entangled in some bracken. 
 I looked down at the sea breaking on the rocks. 
 I became paralysed, unable to go down or up. 
 Then I heard voices saying, &bquo;Is this where she was? 
 Here's her bag. 
 She's down the cliff.&equo; 
 They must have rescued me, I can't remember anything except my terror of the dark sea. 
 I don't think I would ever do such a thing again, but when the depression settles on me I'm very vulnerable, and if I went to see a film and it had a drowning sequence in it, or swirling water, then you just can't tell. 
 people say it's only a film but they don't know. 
 &lsqb;LISA MONTAGUE&rsqb; 
 BLUE WATER 
 A John Wayne film. 
 A fight spills out of a saloon. 
 A cowboy falls into the horse trough, which is full of bright blue water. 
 Then he is repeatedly dunked in it. 
 What I remember is the unrealistic blueness of the water. 
 I had never seen water that was that  blue. 
 Thirty years on I saw it again, when I started going to the Aegean. 
 Most days there was that colour spread from the shore to the sky, bigger than a horse trough. 
 One summer I stayed in Molyvos on L&eacute;svos. 
 They have an open-air cinema there. 
 A toilet with a hose to wash it down, a kiosk from which to sell tickets and Pepsi-Cola, and a rude shelter for a projector they never secure. 
 And a wall. 
 You sit on rows of stacking chairs. 
 Intermittently a film is projected at the wall. 
 All kinds of films. 
 Films with women with big breasts and cars and fighting. 
 Cars got the biggest response. 
 The most forceful shout was for a Toyota  truck on a stand in a showroom. 
 It was big and it gleamed. 
 It was in the film to be blown apart. 
 And there was a man handcuffed to his chair. 
 In his other hand a grenade with the pin removed so he couldn't put it down to free himself from the handcuffs, and so from the chair, and so from the room. 
 Lots of explosions in that film. 
 Lots of advice from the audience: gasps, sighs of sympathy, roars of contempt, screams. 
 I walked into the college cinema to find the tutor watching the film on his own. 
 &bquo;This fucking audience is getting me down,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It hasn't turned up again!' 
 Coke cans, once emptied, would aec over the heads of the audience. 
 Good throwers could hit Lee Marvin or Clint Eastwood full in the face. 
 And always the unawareness of the actors that anything had touched them: not a flinch. 
 The cans banged and rattled over a fuzzy soundtrack already overlaid with calls to Vassilis to move his head or Kostas to provide a cigarette. 
 Out of the darkness beyond the white wall, streaks of fireflies: sudden lines of light matching the projected gashes on the film, which would suddenly stop and the lights come up to make an interval. 
 Often elements of the story would be edited out by the interval. 
 If the projectionist didn't like the film it didn't get shown, or only part of it. 
 Sometimes events were shown reordered or shown twice. 
 Sometimes no picture for a while. 
 Sometimes no sound. 
 They sold many Pepsi-Colas. 
 One night along came Doctor Strangelove , so we went out early to eat before the film started, in a taverna near the cinema. 
 We chose something quick to prepare. 
 And they took a long time making it. 
 And they took a long time serving it. 
 And while they were taking their time we argued about something else. 
 Some small argument, but it was immobilising. 
 As we sat there Doctor Strangelove  began. 
 We listened to the soundtrack through the back wall of the cinema, separated from each other by plates filmed in olive oil with pools of tomato juice, and half finished wine. 
 Alcohol and heat, unreason against unreason. 
 And the aural projection of a film mocking unreason, mocking stupidity. 
 Two years later: Batsi, on the island of Andros. 
 Another open-air cinema. 
 The same communality, the same responses. 
 We were watching a film with many trees in it. 
 It began to rain. 
 In the film. 
 It began to rain. 
 In Greece. 
 In the  world outside of the film. 
 In our world. 
 We sat in the rain, looking at filmed rain. 
 Some of the audience calmly fetched additional chairs from a store and we each sat holding our stacking chair over our heads until the shower subsided, in about the same time it took the film rain to subside. 
 When we were twelve our aspiring sex lives were chronicled by seat location in the cinema. 
 If you sat with a girl in rows A to F, you'd just met. 
 F to M you were undoubtedly snogging (mouths closed). 
 M to P was snogging (mouths open). 
 While P to V meant access to the inside of a liberty bodice. 
 I never could believe what they said happened in rows behind V. &lsqb;Chris Proctor&rsqb; 
 We walked home in the dark along the wet road around the bay. 
 Car headlights made it difficult to see, in the way that an usherette's torch can temporarily blind. 
 On our right the dark sea which, if the sun were back on, would have been an impossible blue. 
 &lsqb;LAWRENCE UPTON&rsqb; 
 DRIVE-IN 
 The perfect evening would be sometime in August when the heat of the summer is distilled and concentrated and the ground in the pine forests has become brown and crackly, the tarmac on the roads quite soft. 
 At eight o'clock I get into my car, a Chevy with bench seats in the front and the back, no bucket seats. 
 I drive down the strip past the car dealerships and the drive-in motels with their dusty swimming pools out front. 
 I stop at the drive-in bank then I drive out the highway to the lake to pick up my date. 
 We  have a quick swim in the dark, cold water, touching the sandy bottom with our toes as we dive off the raft, the evening still bright, still hot. 
 Then we drive down to the drive-in restaurant where we eat lots of crap including a double order of onion rings. 
 One night in 1962 Kurdish rebels entered a Kirkuk cinema disguised as policemen and silently surrounded an officer known to be torturing opponents of the government. 
 They took him outside and up into the mountains. 
 Then they threw him over a precipice. 
 &lsqb;Salah Faiq&rsqb; 
 About 10.00, dusk, we motor over to the drive-in which is showing a triple bill of horror movies. 
 We park near the back of the lot. 
 My date gets out of the car to go buy popcorn while I fix up the speaker. 
 When my date comes back the credits are rolling on the first film. 
 We settle in to watch. 
 All of the films are about teenagers getting massacred by monsters. 
 The first to die are always the ones who have had sex with each other. 
 The heroes and heroines are nearly always virgins. 
 This makes my date and me laugh. 
 There is a lot to do in a dark car late at night besides staring across the roofs of other parked cars at flickering images on a screen. 
 We turn off the speaker. 
 &lsqb;KATE PULLINGER&rsqb; 
 IN THE FLESH 
 In 1970 I was a member of an Anglo-American theatre troupe, the Wherehouse La Mama Company. 
 One afternoon Beth Porter, an American founder member of the company, invited the rest of us to a double bill of soft core porno movies in Piccadilly. 
 Eight of us took our places in the small but crowded cinema. 
 Some of us, including Beth, sat in the front row. 
 Our four female members were the only women in the audience. 
 The reason for our excursion was that, back in the USA, Beth had taken a leading role in one of the films now showing. 
 Being a radical experimental company of the time, given to onstage nudity, we were no strangers to Beth's voluptuous physique and it was hard to suppress our giggles at the absurd movie, in which a deformed, slobbering handyman ogles and gropes our heroine before coming to a violent end. 
 But our real kick came at the end of the film when the lights went up. 
 Beth  rose from her front row seat, turned, and allowed the audience to get a good look at her before making her way out. 
 A frisson of disbelief and unease passed though the male patrons as the woman they had been watching in simulated copulation on the screen materialised in the flesh before their very eyes. 
 &lsqb;NEIL HORNICK&rsqb; 
 Surrounded by local hardknocks, Bob Golden was the only gringo in a Taos, New Mexico, fleapit. 
 The film was a western, and the moment John Wayne walked onscreen a rain of knives traversed the auditorium and killed his image. 
 &lsqb;Paul Hammond&rsqb; 
 YMIR AT THE COLISEUM 
 The Coliseum in Green Lanes, North London, was originally a Victorian music hall. 
 Refitted as a cinema in the early years of this century it subsequently became a bingo hall and finally a flood-damaged carpet warehouse. 
 In the early 1960s one result of shrinking cinema audiences was the Sunday double bill of low budget horror movies. 
 One of these was a 1957 black and white feature called 20,000,000 Miles to Earth , in which a spaceship, returning from Venus, crashes into the sea. 
 A canister is recovered from the craft, the contents of which solidify into an at first small creature called an Ymir. 
 The creature grows at an alarming rate, then escapes and cuts a swathe of destruction as it moves through the southern Italian countryside. 
 It approaches Rome, lumbering up the Appian Way, doubling its size every few minutes. 
 The pursuing army patrol the streets in jeeps with mounted machine guns, until one soldier flings his arm into the air, pointing: &bquo;Look,&equo; he shouts &bquo;there it is on top of the Colosseum!&equo; 
 At this, a girl in the audience with a beehive hair-do leaps to her feet screaming, &bquo;Where? 
 Where?&equo; 
 Others in the auditorium begin whistling and stamping their feet. 
 There is a rush for the door, the audience spill out into the road, stopping the traffic and gesturing wildly at the roof of the cinema. 
 &lsqb;TERRY GENIN&rsqb;  
 When the shapeless Blob  cornered the heroine Tina, a voice came from the back of the stalls, &bquo;You're all right Tina, he's got no thingy.&equo; 
 &lsqb;Mike Evans&rsqb; 
 PART 7 Beleaguered Norms and Perverse Dynamics  
 Homophobia (1): Sexual/Political Deviance 
 Part 5 considered two contending theories of perversion and homosexuality, one deriving from psychoanalysis, the other from anthropological, sociological, and historical perspectives, in which Foucault's History of Sexuality  was both a culmination and a new departure. 
 Henceforth, primarily for convenience of reference (and so provisionally), I shall designate the second account materialist. 
 This post-Freudian, materialist reinterpretation of sexual deviance diverges so considerably from the sexological/psychoanalytic tradition that perversion comes to signify quite differently. 
 This becomes even more so when deviance is regarded in the light of the pre-Freudian, pre-sexological histories of perversion. 
 Two points made before are thereby worth reiterating: first, that the meaning of perversion is crucially context dependent; second that one objective of this book is to restore to the concept dimensions which were obscured within the sexological/psychoanalytic traditions, though remaining inscribed within them, especially in Freud's texts. 
 The reiteration is necessary partly because conventional sexological and psychoanalytic assumptions prove so difficult to dislodge. 
 In response to my attempts to historicize perversion it has been said: &bquo;OK, we see how you might want to rescue homosexuality from the pejorative category of a perversion, but surely not incest or bestiality?&equo; 
 This response misses the point on several counts. 
 First because a recovery of the histories of perversion precisely disarticulates the sexological and psychoanalytic classifications which would lump together as perversions homosexuality, incest, bestiality, etc. 
 Second, because those histories eventually facilitate a reversal in the object of analysis: at a certain stage it is no longer homosexuality, or the perversions as ordinarily understood, which need explaining, but (among other things) the classification of heterosexuality as the norm with homosexuality as its perverse other, and the splitting, displacements, and paranoia which accompany that division. 
 It is through the only recently developed concept of homophobia that this reversal proceeds. 
 Indeed, the charge of homophobia is itself a kind of reverse discourse facilitated by the dynamic of perversion itself. 
 As  Ken Plummer observes, whereas once it was the homosexual who was viewed as sick, now it might be the heterosexual who is charged with pathology: &bquo;Whereas once the homosexual was identified by a long series of character traits, it is now possible to identify the traits of the homophobe: authoritarian, cognitively restricted, with gender anxieties, (Plummer, &bquo;Homosexual Categories&equo;, 62). 
 Most provocatively, those gender anxieties are found to harbour a repressed homosexuality. 
 As we shall see, the reversal remains inadequate in that it conceives of homophobia in mainly psychosexual terms, and phobic ones at that. 
 However I do not propose that we too quickly problematize the concept out of existence, since some of the questions it begs, even in its inadequate form, are just the sort which need to be asked. 
 The broad sense in which I shall be using homophobia is loosely descriptive of a manifest phenomenon: the hatred, fear, and persecution of, the raging at, homosexuality and homosexuals. 
 Man-holes 
 In the UK in 1983 there was a by-election in Bermondsey, London. 
 Its run-up included a homophobic attack on one of the candidates, Peter Tatchell, whose political &bquo;extremism&equo; was regarded as inseparable from his sexual &bquo;deviance&equo;. 
 It was largely mobilized by sections of the press, to a degree then unprecedented, but which heralded the onset of the intensified homophobia which has characterized that country ever since. 
 Taking only the period in which this book has been written, and limiting the location to the UK, there have been numerous similar press-provoked scandals in which the homosexual has kept turning up where he or she should not, especially at the &bquo;respectable&equo; centre of things: in MI5, the Houses of Parliament, as parliamentary candidate, schoolteacher, council employee, prison chaplain, vicar, guard to the Queen Mother, film star, circuit judge, to cite only some (and some whose lives have been destroyed by homophobic media harassment). 
 The same press represents homosexuals as the corrupters of public morals, of children, the family, and even the armed forces; or as deviants conveying  to other aliens (their external counterpart) the state's innermost secrets. 
 As Simon Watney indicates in Policing Desire , hysteria over AIDS has fuelled press hate-campaigns, virtually fascist in their vindictiveness. 
 One end result has been an increase in the extent to which gays and lesbians have been subjected to physical violence, including murder and mutilation. 
 In many instances this homophobia is crude. 
 But it is none the less effective for that, and it would be wrong to see it, as do some liberals, as a superstitious remnant from a blighted past. 
 That contemporary homophobia, even or especially in its crudest forms, is not a residual superstition, can be seen in that initiating attack on Peter Tatchell. 
 It may well have been rooted in a repressed homosexuality according to the psychoanalytic model. 
 Indeed Tatchell, in his book on the events of those months, surveys the hate mail sent to him and concludes as much ( Battle , 72). 
 More significant though was a displacement into, a condensation within, the homosexual of a whole range of political fears and anxieties made possible by existing and long established representations of homosexuality: 
 Dear Mr Tatchell When I lived in Bermondsey, until my family were bombed out while I was fighting to protect my country from outside evils, we had a saying, Bermondsey was a place where men were men and women counted as &bquo;manholes&equo; and members of the &bquo;Middlesex Regiment&equo; would not be tolerated. 
 So why don't you piss off back to where you come from and leave the decent people of that once great borough alone. 
 This country is in enough trouble without the likes of you, and Tariq Ali etc, stirring it up. 
 Anyway what is wrong with that land of sunshine Australia, that you want to leave it, is it because you have to work for your living there? (quoted from Tatchell, Battle , 72) 
 In this letter, masculinity &mdash; &bquo;when men were men&equo; &mdash; is vigilant against &bquo;outside evils&equo;, especially racial infiltration and homosexuality, the latter conceived as sexual ambiguity (&bquo;Middlesex Regiment&equo;). 
 Each provokes fears of a social decline which in turn evokes imperial decline: &bquo;that once great borough&equo; where men were men, women were &bquo;manholes&equo;, and queers were given short shrift. 
 It is a letter which indicates several things about homophobia, and three in particular. 
 First and most obviously perhaps, it shows how homophobia is often integral to a conventional kind of masculine identity. 
 But already more is going on than first appears. 
 I have already  had several occasions to remark that binary oppositions are, in Derrida's phrase, violent hierarchies. 
 From this letter we can see how the opposition masculine/homosexual is a conflation of two other classic binaries: masculine/feminine; hetero/homosexual. 
 It is often observed that misogyny and homophobia go together. 
 One reason is that this conflation of binaries enables a merging of misogyny and homophobia, each of which then potentially expresses the violence of the other. 
 Second then, homophobia often intersects with other kinds of phobia and hatred: in this case, and rather economically, not only misogyny but also racism and xenophobia. 
 While different kinds of discrimination are not to be conflated, I believe there is something to be learned from homophobia about other kinds. 
 Third, the analysis of homophobia demands both the psychoanalytic and materialist perspectives, not least because, as this letter suggests, it is so obviously and inseparably both a psychic and social phenomenon. 
 I remarked earlier my interest in a cultural critique situated at the points where these two perspectives converge without ever becoming compatible; at the points of overlap which are also gaps. 
 This is nowhere more necessary than in the analysis of homophobia. 
 I believe too that this analysis must proceed historically, which is why I approach it via the now familiar historical detour. 
 It is customary to frame the history of homosexuality with reference to the essentialist/constructionist debate (homosexuality as essential human given versus homosexuality as socio-historical construct). 
 Important as this is, it tends to ignore other histories. 
 Here I focus on the genealogy of two aspects of discrimination already addressed by this study, namely displacement between the political and the sexual, and the idea of perversion as an inimical absence. 
 Political and Sexual Subversions 
 The mythology which, as in the Tatchell affair, connects sexual deviation and political subversion is very old. 
 It is typically inflected by other kinds of fears, especially religious and racial ones. 
 A case in point is those forms of nationalism committed to policing not only actual geographic borders and literal or legally defined aliens, but symbolic and ideological boundaries (both internal and external) between the normal and the abnormal, the healthy and sick, the conforming and the deviant. 
 Himmler launched his attack on homo/sexuals on the basis that they, like the Jews, were involved in a conspiracy to undermine the German race. 
 Such associations of sexual deviance and political threat  have a long history sedimented into our language and culture. 
 The term &bquo;buggery&equo;, for example, derives from the religious as well as sexual nonconformity of an eleventh-century Bulgarian sect which practised the Manichaean heresy and refused to propagate the species; the OED  tells us that it was later applied to other heretics, to whom abominable practices were also ascribed. 
 Arthur N. Gilbert has written about a particular instance of the way social and political crisis provokes renewed urgency in the policing of sexual deviance. 
 During the Napoleonic wars the number of prosecutions for sodomy increased. 
 To understand why, argues Gilbert, we need to understand the construction of the sodomite, his association at that time with evil, rebellion, and insurrection, and the belief that to tolerate his sin was to court the possibility of divine revenge (as with Sodom and Gomorrah). 
 This mythology found an immediate focus: the sodomite was perceived as an internal deviant who refigured a foreign threat, in this case the threat from the French. 
 Gilbert refers to a dissertation by Richard Allen Soloway which shows contemporary fears of Christianity falling before the atheistical, licentious, and immoral foreigner (&bquo;Sexual Deviance and Disaster&equo;, 98, 99, 100&ndash;1, 110&ndash;11). 
 The sodomite becomes a virulent image of this threat, embodying a foreign infection which in turn is linked to social disorder and economic collapse at home. 
 A violent, enduring mythology is activated to make sense of immediate socio-political crisis and fear. 
 This analysis suggests that if, in periods of intensified conflict, crisis is displaced on to the deviant, the process only succeeds because of the paranoid instabilities at the heart of dominant cultural identities. 
 Further, such displacements of non-sexual fears on to the sexual deviant, be he or she actual, imagined, or constituted in and by the displacement, are made possible because other kinds of transgression &mdash; political, religious &mdash; are not only loosely associated with the sexual deviant, but &bquo;condensed&equo; in the very definition of deviance. 
 It is a process especially apparent in early modern England, not least because of the differences between its categories of sexual deviance and ours. 
 At that time sodomy was associated with a whole range of evils, including insurrection and heresy; all such evils could be, and often were, &bquo;imagined&equo; in the form of, or at least in relation to, the sodomite. 
 Recent studies emphasize the different ways homo/sexuality was conceptualized in early modern England &mdash; a difference so considerable in fact that &bquo;homosexuality&equo; becomes anachronistic, since at that time there was neither the concept nor, exactly, the identity it signifies. 
 Briefly, the argument is as follows: the homosexual is a creation of modern discourse, medical, sexological, and psychological, as evidenced  by the fact that the word &bquo;homosexual&equo; was coined in 1869: neither it nor the sexual sense of perversion appeared in the OED  until its 1933 Supplement. 
 The nearest concepts to it in early modern England were probably sodomy and buggery. 
 As we saw in Chapter 14, Michel Foucault argues that before the nineteenth century the sodomite was someone who performed a certain kind of act ; no specific identity  was attributed to, or assumed by, the sodomite. 
 The attribution or assumption of this identity marks the creation of the homosexual. 
 Alan Bray and Jeffrey Weeks have given historical support to this view, though not without qualification; I remarked in Part 1 some further reservations. 
 Additionally, we should recall that, before the nineteenth century, the meanings of terms like sodomy and buggery might have been even wider than is suggested by Foucault's argument. 
 Sodomy was associated with witches, demons, werewolves, basilisks, foreigners, and (of course) papists; and it apparently signified a wide range of practices including prostitution, under-age sex, coitus interruptus, and female transvestism. 
 Socially, sodomy was repeatedly equated with heresy and political treason; metaphysically, it was conceived as &bquo;sexual contusion in whatever form&equo;, a &bquo;force of anarchic disorder set against divine Creation&equo;, not a part of the created order but an aspect of its dissolution. 
 As such it potentially functioned as a perverse dynamic &mdash; neither a part of created nature, nor a sexuality in its own right, but rather &bquo;a potential for confusion and disorder in one undivided sexuality&equo;. 
 Imaged in such terms, the sodomite indeed became the supreme instance of the demonized other. 
 But so extreme was the sodomite's construction that most of those actually engaging in &bquo;homo/sexuality, did not identify themselves with it; not only did they not have our modern categories, but the prevailing categories were so tar removed from how they saw themselves, that apparently the connection was not made. 
 Nor was it made by the authorities &mdash; except, apparently, in times of political and social crisis, the eruption of class hatred, religious and political persecution. 
 Certainly then in early modern England the ways of conceptualizing  sexuality and sexual deviance were fundamentally different from ours, as were the perceived relations between sexuality and subjectivity. 
 That individuals prosecuted for sodomy did not necessarily identify themselves with the demonized sodomite of official discourse also lends credence to Foucault's distinction between sodomy as a kind of behaviour, and homosexuality as a modern identity. 
 But we should not rely too heavily on that distinction. 
 There remain certain continuities which should give us pause. 
 Laura Levine has pointed to an interesting relationship in early modern England between fears of sodomy and fears of the theatre. 
 She observes that the frequent indictments of theatre for encouraging sodomy are symptomatic of the anti-theatricalists&equo; fear that gender difference is ever under threat of breakdown and, more generally, their fear that &bquo;under the costume there is really nothing there or, alternatively, that what is there is something foreign, something terrifying and essentially other&equo; (&bquo;Men in Women's Clothing&equo;, 135; see also Chapter 17 below). 
 Such arguments suggest that the perception of the sodomite was already implicated in the constructions of gender and sexual difference, and, through them, of identity, subjectivity, and social ordering more generally, and the anxieties attendant upon all these things. 
 Moreover, it is not true that prior to the nineteenth century (or eighteenth, depending on when the change was said to occur) sexual deviance was conceptualized only as a form of behaviour. 
 I suggest that in early modern England the sodomite, though not an identity in the modern sense, could and did denote subject positions or types; &bquo;he&equo; precisely characterized  deviant subject positions as well as denoting the behaviour of individuals. 
 Sodomy was not thought to originate in a pathological subjectivity (the modern pervert); rather, the sexual deviant was the vehicle of a confusion never only sexual, and sexual in a way different from the sexological and psychoanalytic accounts. 
 As such the deviant was the point of entry into civilization for the unnatural, the aberrant, and the abhorrent, the wilderness of disorder which beleaguered all civilization; a disorder in part, but rarely only ever, sexual. 
 And it sodomy signified diverse types of evil, so too might evil itself infiltrate civilization through diverse subject types. 
 Both forms of diversity were subject to either displacement or condensation. 
 Displacement might involve a sliding along the signifying chain which connects the ditferent manifestations of evil and subject types, conflating two or more of them; thus the sexual deviant may also &bquo;be&equo; a witch, an  insurrectionary, or a papist. 
 Condensation might entail the one kind of subject and/or manifestation standing in for the whole domain of evil, incurring responsibility for the whole in the process of being made to signify it. 
 Hence condensation and displacement were, and are still, related ways of identifying  the deviant. 
 It is in these terms that we find sodomy lurking in the cultural histories of the deviants in early modern England, and in a way which throws light on the persistence today of the connection between political and sexual subversion, and the condensation/displacement of social crisis into  sexuality. 
 Wilde: The Pernicious Absence 
 As we saw with the pre-sexological theories of perversion, condensation and displacement are strangely enabled by the view of perversion as an inimical threatening absence. 
 What is not often recognized is the extent to which this theological sense of perversion as the negative agency at the heart of privation, hence an inverted positivity, survives into the &bquo;modern&equo; sense of perversion/homosexuality as a profoundly inimical, vitiating lack (of normality, of truth). 
 Increasingly the fate of Oscar Wilde has been analysed in relation to the construction of the modern homosexual along lines suggested by Michel Foucault. 
 Again, this is important and relevant, but so too is this older history. 
 After he had been found guilty of homosexual offences and sentenced to two years' imprisonment with hard labour, the press subjected Oscar Wilde to vicious attack. 
 As we saw in Chapter 4, the London Evening News  accused him of trying to subvert the &bquo;wholesome, manly, simple ideals of English life&equo;, and connected his sexual perversion with intellectual and moral subversion. 
 He possessed, as the Daily Telegraph  conceded on 27 May 1895, &bquo;considerable intellectual powers&equo;. 
 It advocates &bquo;a reaction towards simpler ideas&hellip; for fear of national contamination and decay&equo;. 
 Queensberry, in a letter published in the Star  on 25 April 1895, expresses the connection clearly enough when he describes Wilde as &bquo;a sexual pervert of an utterly diseased mind&equo; (Goodman, The Oscar Wilde File , 133&ndash;4, 99). 
 Reading through the press comment on Wilde we find the same fear of cross-over between sexual perversion and intellectual and moral subversion. 
 On the one hand the world of normality and conformity is stridently affirmed. 
 It is variously described as &bquo;health and right reason&equo;, the &bquo;wholesome&equo;, the &bquo;healthy and unvitiated&equo;, and characterized by &bquo;unalterable standards of right and wrong&equo; (Goodman, The Oscar Wilde File , 78, 1 33, 1 34). 
 By contrast Wilde and his art are described as &bquo;false&equo;, &bquo;cheap&equo;, &bquo;shallow and specious&equo;, &bquo;nerveless and effeminate&equo;,  marked by an &bquo;unreality&equo; and &bquo;essential emptiness and frivolity&equo; (pp. 75, 78, 1 33, 1 34). 
 The oppositions invoked in these descriptions &mdash; the substantial versus the insubstantial, depth versus shallowness &mdash; are just the ones Wilde inverted and subverted. 
 Here they are reinvoked to discredit Wilde, yet in a way which still acknowledged him as a threat. 
 But why? 
 In the terms of the binaries invoked, and reinstalled rightway-around, he should have been perceived as only shallow, specious, ineffectual. 
 Not so: these editorials identify Wilde as very evil. 
 His falsity and hollowness are not just the opposite of the true and the wholesome, but threaten to undermine it. 
 He is not only spurious but also &bquo;diseased&equo;, the two being inseparable. 
 Something informing these descriptions of Wilde and his art is a fear of degeneration as conceived by writers of the time. 
 It was not just that degenerates were thought to be intelligent and gifted; their intelligence manifested one of the most disturbing paradoxes of the perverse: a vitiating regression to the primitive from within  an advanced cultural sophistication. 
 For these commentators Wilde represents both a cultural &bquo;decay&equo; and a resurrection of &bquo;pagan viciousness&equo; and &bquo;primal errors&equo; (pp. 98, 134). 
 Recall that for Robert Burton in 1621 it was not our bestial qualities that were the most dangerous, but our civilized ones perverted (above, Chapter 8); now, the civilized in perverted form is also  the primitive and bestial. 
 Here is the Telegraph  again: 
 opinions and principles like &lsqb;Wilde's&rsqb; have from time to time manifested themselves all down the course of history, generally in over-ripe civilisations wavering on the brink of decay. 
 In the next place they are found side by side with great intellectual brilliance, and&hellip; clothed in glamour which hides the hollowness within. 
 (Goodman, The Oscar Wilde File , 134) 
 Decline, brilliance, hollowness: such things, essentially empty in themselves, nevertheless undermine the nation. 
 Again, sexual perversion echoes attributes of Augustinian privation: evil lacks authentic being itself (&bquo;the hollowness within') and because, rather than in spite of, that tact is utterly inimical to true being. 
 What is simultaneously acknowledged and denied is that &bquo;wholesomeness&equo; is not invaded from without so much as corrupted from within. 
 Its own strength is turned against it. 
 Thus while Wilde is merely &bquo;a parasite, an excrescence, an aberration, (p. 78), those allegedly most susceptible to his perversion are quite  otherwise: the family in general, young men at university, sometimes even their tutors, boys at public school, maidens, and novelists (p. 133). 
 This might plausibly be dismissed as &bquo;Victorian stupidity&equo; were it not for the tact that in Britain in 1988 a similar view was actually inscribed in law. 
 Here too the emphasis was on the susceptibility of the &bquo;innocent&equo; to the specious; section 28 of the Local Government Act 1987 &mdash; 8 states that a local authority shall not 
 (a) 
 intentionally promote homosexuality or publish material with the intention of promoting homosexuality,; 
 (b) 
 promote the teaching in any maintained school of the acceptability of homosexuality as a pretended family  relationship. 
 (my emphasis) 
 How could anything so demonstrably inferior to the real thing ever pretend to be it, and with such potential (or feared) success that the parliament of an &bquo;advanced western democracy&equo; must legislate against it? 
 Because still in 1988, under the pressure of social instability and political crises, homosexuality could be regarded as a kind of privation or error, an &bquo;inverted positivity&equo;, an inimical, pernicious, inauthenticity always threatening to return from within the true and the authentic. 
 The Return of Homosexuality 
 It the trouble with the materialist view of perversion is its tendency to functionalist reduction (above, Chapter 14), the Freudian position faces equally intractable problems, though of a ditferent kind. 
 Considered from a materialist perspective it has at least three damaging limitations: first it tends to construe sexuality in terms of an original pre-social plenitude, an initially unstructured natural energy; second (and consequently) sexuality is conceived in certain of Freud's central texts as a drive with hydraulic characteristics; third, a phenomenon like homophobia, when it is not being blatantly disregarded, is explained too much in terms of the subjective, psychic repressions of its agents. 
 The consequences of this last point can be pernicious, actually encouraging a way of thinking whereby the aggressor in homophobic violence is somehow identified with his or her victim: both are homosexual, the one repressed, the other overt. 
 Or, as it is sometimes switched round in  homophobic (or just careless) thought: the victim is somehow the same as the aggressor and hence in some vague sense complicit with the aggression. 
 But it would be wrong to hold psychoanalysis entirely responsible tor this slippage. 
 It stems also from the inherent violence of sexual subordination and the (mis) representation which (re) produces it, especially in and through the category of the sexual deviant. 
 We saw in Chapter 7 how the enemy is &bquo;homosexualized&equo;, with the result that, even while homosexuals were being imprisoned and murdered by the Nazis, it could be said that to eliminate homosexuality would be to get rid of fascism. 
 A further vicious twist in this kind of representation, again remarked by Richard Plant in The Pink Triangle , concerns the way that in the Nazi concentration camps homosexual inmates were held responsible by non-homosexual inmates for crimes committed by homosexual guards: &bquo;homosexual guards, however hostile, were seen by non-gay prisoners as belonging to the homosexual underclass. 
 Thus, homosexual prisoners were often tainted by the crimes of homosexual guards &mdash; even though they themselves were often the victims, (pp. 166&ndash;7). 
 A related problem with the psychoanalytic account is the implication that so many different kinds of close relationship between heterosexually identified men, be they complicated or simple, conflicted or supportive, brutally vindictive or discerningly tender, are really  rooted in repressed homosexuality. 
 This way of thinking has to be one of the blinder alleys that we have been led up by psychoanalysis. 
 Hence the importance of Eve Sedgwick's category of the homosocial: we must insist that there are different kinds of masculine heterosexual alliance that are not necessarily (though may be) homosexual, repressed or overt; but we also need to make this point in a way which does not then privilege this distinction between the sexual and the non-sexual since this is to re-establish the primacy of the sexual, something partly responsible for the original misrepresentation. 
 Having said all that, the Freudian model stands as an indispensable starting-point for identifying a certain kind of homophobia, namely that conjunction of hatred, paranoia, and desire (repressed, ambivalent, or overt) which characterizes some of those same heterosexually identified men in their relationships with lesbian and gay people. 
 Misleading as it often is, the notion of the repressed homosexual does accurately describe some people. 
 More revealing than their obvious differences are those points of overlap between the materialist and the psychoanalytic accounts. 
 First, both theories suggest an eventual return of homosexuality: in the one (psychoanalytic) it is a psychic return of the repressed from within, in  the other (materialist) a social or cultural return from without; either an inner resurgence of desire through the breakdown of psychic repression, or the oppositional approach via the proximate of the demonized other from beyond, from the social margins where he or she has been discovered, constructed, displaced. 
 Either way he or she returns to disturb the heterosexual norm, especially in its masculine form, and does so according to a psychic and/or social dynamic which is intrinsically perverse: deviance emerges from the terms of its exclusion, eventually undermining that of which it was initially an effect, and which depended upon its exclusion. 
 We have already seen how the psychic return of homosexuality is central to Freud's account of neurosis, possibly becoming, in Hocquenghem's phrase, the &bquo;killer of civilised egos&equo; because such egos are rooted in and conditional upon the repression of that same homosexual desire which returns. 
 Meanwhile its social and cultural return has been explored in the literature of Wilde, Gide, and others, as well as in reverse-discourse theory of which the very concept of homophobia is an instance. 
 It is probably the case that we live in a time when the cultural return of homosexuality exacerbates, even intensifies, the psychic return of repressed homosexuality. 
 This suggests a second and related sense in which the psychoanalytic and the materialist perspectives converge: both suggest that identity &mdash; individual and cultural &mdash; involves a process of disavowal, exclusion, and negation. 
 In the first it is the negation of desire, in the second, of the culturally defined other of cultural difference. 
 The following remark of Dennis Altman's, even if not strictly correct historically, rightly implies how the negation of desire and the negation of difference are in practice often inseparable: &bquo;the original purpose of the categorization of homosexuals as people apart was to project the homosexuality in everyone onto a defined minority as a way of externalizing forbidden desires and reassuring the majority that homosexuality is something that happens to other people&equo; ( Homosexualization , 72). 
 A yet further, intriguingly perverse, aspect of this convergence involves the phenomenon whereby the culturally negated other becomes the focus of the very desire which is being policed within the dominant culture: the other, in the very process of being identified, displaced, and negated, becomes the object of &mdash; indeed may actually incite &mdash; desire. 
 Such desire for the other may be less the result of a desublimation of repressed desire than a consequence of desire itself being structured by social repression generally: thus the other may be cathected as (an) other beyond repression. 
 Romantics know about this.  
 Divergence 
 These two areas of convergence also direct us to the main area of divergence and the reason why, though in actuality inextricably related, the psychic and the cultural return of homosexuality still need to be distinguished. 
 On the Freudian model it is the repression and sublimation of homosexual desire that helps secure identity and social organization. 
 Conversely, on the materialist model it is much more homophobia itself, as an aspect of the construction of homosexuality and independently of the question of the actual subjective repression of desire, which helps secure a coerced identity and social organization; homophobia enforces the heterosexual norm by policing its boundaries: &bquo;Homophobia is only incidentally directed against homosexuals &mdash; its more common use is against the 49% of the population which is male&hellip; 
 The taunt &bquo;What are you, a fag? '&equo; is used in many ways to encourage certain types of male behaviour and to define the limits of &bquo;&bquo;acceptable'&equo; masculinity.&equo; 
 So, whereas in the psychoanalytic account, homophobia might well signal the precariousness and instability of identity, even of sexual difference itself, in the materialist socio-political account it typically signals the reverse, namely that sexual difference is being secured, homophobia being &bquo;a mechanism for regulating the behaviour of the many by the specific oppression of a few&equo; (Sedgwick, Between Men , 88). 
 Even in the first case, where homophobia is the expression of repressed desire, we should neither overestimate its destabilizing effects, nor regard its homophobic projection as an always ultimately futile effort to avoid the crippling effects of repression and/or neurosis. 
 Indeed, even where homophobia is  directly connected with a disturbing repression and/or neurosis, the actual psychic dislocation involved may be very effectively offset  by the political and cultural gains of homophobic displacement. 
 Such displacement may  be a symptom of a continuously destructive semi-repression, but it may also be an effective way of minimizing within oneself, or a group, disabling complications within identity. 
 Also, even if a subject is never directly or completely &bquo;freed&equo; trom repression by its displacement, he or she may be empowered in other ways &mdash; for example, by being seen to be homophobic in a homophobic culture. 
 Relatedly, as a means of securing sexual difference, homophobia may also be a displacement of homosocial anger &mdash; resentment at coerced identification and the persistent intimidation to conform. 
 If so, then there is a sense in which homophobia may feed itself,  securing the framework (sexual difference) which promotes and intensifies its displacement as anger. 
 So while homophobia may sometimes originate in and, as it circulates socially, reconnect with repressed desire, the latter cannot be homophobia's necessary condition since it often circulates without it, and in a socio-political form which is more rapid, more widespread, more economical, and possibly more destructive. 
 Instead of positing psychically repressed homosexuality as the necessary and/or sufficient cause of homophobia, we might better regard socially proscribed homosexuality as one of homophobia's several interconnected and enabling conditions, none of which is independently either necessary or sufficient. 
 It is often difficult in retrospect, or even contemporaneously for that matter, to discern the part that psychic repression plays in any instance of homophobia. 
 But, for the reason just given, it is hardly imperative that we should. 
 But even this important distinction between the psychoanalytic and the materialist account is complicated by another equally important convergence: since, in cultural terms, desiring the normal is inseparable from and conditional upon not desiring the abnormal, repression remains central to identity, individual and cultural, even &mdash; or indeed especially &mdash; for the materialist view of homophobia as a strategy of social control. 
 Initially this appears not to be so, since while the Freudian model posits a repression within the subject, the materialist model posits a repression outside the subject in the form of its other. 
 But the latter still involves psychic repression: the identity of the normal is inseparable from, rooted in, what it is not, what is socially excluded. 
 In principle, of course, whether the repressed constituent of identity is outside or inside the subject makes a difference. 
 But in practice how exactly might that difference be discerned? 
 In both cases the repressed/ excluded remains subjectively/socially central. 
 Or rather, the distinctions between the repressed and the excluded, the subjective and the social, break down, especially when we recall that the other is often constructed via, or in terms of, the proximate. 
 So, for instance, while it may be that specific instances of homophobic panic are provoked by repressed homosexuals (in the Freudian sense), the panic may only &bquo;take&equo; socially, because of the other kind of repression &mdash; exclusive identity formation &mdash; as it affects a tar greater number.  
 Desire and Disgust 
 In their remarkable study, Stallybrass and White argue that &bquo;the bourgeois subject continuously defined and re-defined itself through the exclusion of what it marked out as &bquo;low'&equo; &mdash; as dirty, repulsive, noisy, contaminating. 
 Yet that very act of exclusion was constitutive of its identity. 
 The low was internalized under the sign of negation and disgust.&equo; 
 But, they add, &bquo; disgust always bears the imprint of desire . 
 These low domains, apparently expelled as &bquo;Other'&equo;, return as the object of nostalgia, longing and fascination' ( Politics and Poetics , 191, my emphasis). 
 Conversely, desire bears the imprint of disgust: even as the low other becomes an object of longing, it is simultaneously that on to which is displaced a self-disgust that inheres at the centre of bourgeois desire, and for that matter other forms of desire. 
 The difference of the other becomes a displaced and intensified facet of the same, the object of desire and disgust. 
 The disgust which inheres in desire is not, as the Freudian analysis might suggest, necessarily generated by or focused upon the repressed constituent of the self; it may  be, but what I am pointing to here is an additional structural interdependence of desire and disgust. 
 So even when homophobia is not obviously a projection of repressed desire, being more a hostile response to the intolerably different, even then, the homosexual, through condensed association, may be one on whom is projected the repressed disgust inherent in desire. 
 The convergence I have been exploring does not suggest that we should collapse materialism and psychoanalysis into each other. 
 Rather a theoretical conflict indicates that we need to pluralize the notion of repression, as we need to pluralize that of homophobia, and even that of desire itself. 
 There are different kinds and the differences are crucial, helping to mark the otherwise indistinguishable overlaps in historical actuality, and  the crucial differences made by historical factors. 
 Let us finally return to that letter written to Peter Tatchell in 1983. 
 Many interrelated fears and phobias are suggested by that image of women as &bquo;manholes&equo;. 
 Anal phobia perhaps, or fear of sexual engulfment, maybe even castration itself. 
 Either way, in this masculine imaginary the vagina signifies a most disturbing absence, a hole which is also privation, deficiency, lack, a negativity which engulfs and vitiates what is full. 
 &bquo;Either way&equo;: maybe in this imaginary, or at least in its unconscious, the homosexual is also a vagina. 
 But isn't this &bquo;manhole&equo; also a condensed image which, like the letter generally, fearfully anticipates engulfment in the return of those actual others (&bquo;outside evils&equo;) whose subordination, persecution, or exclusion has hitherto seemed to guarantee a sexual,  racial, and national purity &mdash; women, homosexuals, foreigners? 
 I am reminded that with the literal manhole &mdash; the actual thing in the street &mdash; we can indeed walk all over it. 
 But don't we also know, if only in our dreams, that even as we do so we will one day just as surely tall down it?  
 Homophobia (2): Theories of Sexual Difference 
 The criminal classes are so close to us that even the policeman can see them. 
 They are so far away from us that only the poet can understand them. 
 (Wilde, &bquo;Maxims&equo;) 
 The way we see the other is connected to the way we see ourselves. 
 The other is ourselves as the stranger. 
 (Ben Okri discussing Othello  and race, &bquo;Leaping Out&equo;) 
 &bquo;Difference&equo; is a fashionable concept. 
 So too is &bquo;the other&equo;, that highly charged embodiment of difference. 
 I propose a distrust of both concepts. 
 Several kinds of difference figure in contemporary cultural theory but two especially: sexual difference (deriving usually though not invariably from psychoanalysis) and cultural difference, with each of these complicated by a third kind of difference which construes meaning and identity in terms of difference or, more exactly, differential relations. 
 I shall call this third kind &bquo;semiotic difference&equo;. 
 The homosexual is significantly implicated in both sexual and cultural difference, and for two main reasons. 
 First because he or she has been regarded (especially in psychoanalytic theory) as one who fears the difference of the &bquo;other&equo; or opposite sex, and, in flight from it, narcissistically embraces the same sex instead. 
 Difference and heterogeneity are sanctified, homogeneity is distrusted. 
 The eminent Kleinian psychoanalyst, Hanna Segal, has recently declared the adult homosexual structure to be inherently pathological, disturbed, and perverse, and this because of an inbuilt, narcissistic desire for the same: &bquo;homosexuality is of necessity a narcissistic condition, as the name itself betrays. 
 Loving homo &mdash; the same as me not hetero &mdash; the other, ditferent&hellip;. 
 Heterosexuality can be more or less narcissistic, it can be very disturbed or not so. 
 In homosexuality it's inbuilt&equo; (&bquo;Interviewed, 212). 
 In some instances &bquo;sameness&equo; comes to signify the tyranny of Western patriarchal metaphysics, and homosexuality its practice or, more vaguely, its metaphor. 
 Luce Irigaray speaks of a dominant philosophic logos with a  &bquo;power to reduce all others to the economy of the Same  &lsqb;and&rsqb; eradicate the difference between the sexes &equo;. 
 It is manifested as a &bquo;dominant phallic economy&equo; which is described as hom(m)osexual (sometimes hom(m)o-sexual) and rooted in singularity &mdash; &bquo;The one  of form, of the individual, of the (male) sexual organ, of the proper name, of the proper meaning&hellip;&equo; &mdash; and characterized by censure and repression. 
 Conversely woman's pleasure is &bquo;more diversified, more multiple in its differences&equo;. 
 Metaphorically sameness is associated with perversion in an almost Augustinian sense: &bquo;the artifice of sameness&equo; involves a process of &bquo;turning away, of deviation, and of reduction&equo;. 
 Irigaray goes further, exalting the metaphor of homosexuality as a kind of anti-difference into nothing less than a far-reaching theory of patriarchal society. 
 She contends that &bquo;the exchanges upon which patriarchal societies are based take place exclusively among men&equo; and that &bquo;this means that the very possibility of a sociocultural order requires homosexuality  as its organizing principle&hellip; all economic organization is homosexual&equo;. 
 But such homosexuality must in some sense be repressed; overt &bquo;masculine&equo; homosexuality is subversive, says Irigaray, because it openly interprets the law according to which society operates and in so doing threatens it: &bquo;once the penis itself becomes merely a means to pleasure, pleasure among men, the phallus loses its power &equo; ( This Sex , 74, 24 &mdash; 8, 128, 171, 192 &mdash; 3; her emphases). 
 The second reason why the homosexual is involved with difference is because, contrary to what the foregoing theory implies, she or he has, in historical actuality, embraced both cultural and racial difference. 
 The relationship to these other kinds of difference has, for some homosexuals, constituted a crucial dimension of their culture. 
 Sexually exiled trom the repressiveness of the home culture (to which psychoanalytic theory has contributed in no small part with theories like the one just mentioned), homosexuals have searched instead for fulfilment in the realm of the foreign. 
 Not necessarily as a second best: over and again in the culture of homosexuality, differences of race and class are intensely cathected. 
 That this has also occurred in exploitative, sentimental, and/ or racist forms does not diminish its significance; it anything it increases it. 
 Those who move too hastily to denounce homosexuality across race and class as essentially or only exploitative, sentimental, or racist betray their own homophobic ignorance. 
 This crossing constitutes a complex, difficult history, one from which we can learn. 
 I shall argue for the importance of this history for all three kinds of difference &mdash; sexual, cultural, and semiotic &mdash; as they figure in current theory. 
 Although I concentrate in this chapter on sexual difference and on cultural and racial differences in the last chapter, it is worth remembering that in some contexts they interrelate.  
 First a by now familiar digression via the early modern, where we find rather different conceptions of sameness and sexual difference. 
 Turning into a Woman 
 Does not lassitude succeed intercourse because of the quantity of seed lost? 
 &bquo;For a man is formed and torn out of a man&equo;. 
 See how much harm is done. 
 A whole man is torn out when the seed is lost in intercourse. 
 (Clement of Alexandria, Christ the Educator , 172 &mdash; 3) 
 In an influential it controversial essay, Thomas Laqueur has proposed that relatively recently in our history there occurred a radical reinterpretation of the female body. 
 An old and enduring model of sexual difference, developed most powerfully and resiliently by Galen in the second century AD, had stressed the homologous nature of male and female reproductive organs; women were said to have the same genitals as men, only inside rather than outside. 
 To be sure there were important differences: the male was more perfectly developed than the female because hotter; but these were differences conceived on a hierarchical, teleological model of sexual development. 
 In the eighteenth century this model gave way to another based on absolute differences of kind: 
 A biology of hierarchy grounded in a metaphysically prior &bquo;great chain of being&equo; gave way to a biology of incommensurability in which the relationship of men to women, like that of apples to oranges, was not given as one of equality or inequality but rather as a difference  whose meaning required interpretation and struggle. 
 Laqueur finds in the political, cultural, and economic transformations of the eighteenth century a context in which &bquo;the articulation of radical differences between the sexes became culturally imperative&equo;. 
 Further, in a world in which science 
 was increasingly viewed as providing insight into the fundamental truths of creation, in which nature as manifested in the unassailable reality of bones and organs was taken to be the only foundation of the moral order, a biology of incommensurability became the means by which such differences could be authoritatively represented. 
 (Laqueur, &bquo;Orgasm&equo;, 24, 35). 
 In the earlier theory man is separated from woman as different stages in a teleological development. 
 Here is a most revealing instance of the way a difference within the same, teleologically construed, can make a great deal of difference: in effect a difference of degree can be as real as  a difference of kind but in a different way: the lesser is inferior and thereby inimical in a way the antithetical cannot be, and the same becomes more ditferent than difference itself. 
 But never utterly &mdash; i.e. securely &mdash; other . 
 Perhaps this helps explain something noted by Laura Levine: in the numerous tracts attacking the Elizabethan and Jacobean theatre and its dress and gender transgressions, there is a fear that men dressing as women will lead to an erosion of masculinity itself. 
 Levine contends that these tracts, even as they confidently sermonize on the fixed nature of identity, especially gender identity as prescribed by God and signified through dress difference, display a deep anxiety that identity is not  fixed; that, underneath, the self is really nothing at all (&bquo;Men in Women's Clothing&equo;, 126 and 128). 
 Further, they feared that &bquo;doing&equo; what a woman does (on the stage and in women's clothes) leads to &bquo;being&equo; what a woman is; the most unmanageable anxiety is that there is no essentially masculine self (p. 1 36), and cross-dressing in women's clothes can lead to a man &bquo;turning into&equo; a woman. 
 Stephen Orgel discerns in the theatre of this time the fear that man's superior development could be reversed &mdash; &bquo;that men can turn into &mdash; or be turned into &mdash; women; or perhaps more exactly, can be turned back  into woman, losing the strength that enabled the male potential to be realized in the first place.&equo; 
 Perhaps what is at work here is a fear of the other as same not unlike the fascinated fear of the primitive in the notion of &bquo;going native&equo;: a metamorphosis into the radically other which is no more than an all too easily imagined regression into one's own &bquo;primitive&equo; past. 
 So we begin to understand the masculine fear in the early modern period of being effeminized &mdash; not , as might be the case today, by erotic contact with other men, but by excessive contact with women. 
 This too seems to have involved the fear of regression; in social terms the inferior who stands opposite one in the world, thereby confirming one's superiority, also stands behind one . 
 Man regresses into his other (his same), who says: frailty, thy name is man, thy same is woman. 
 In a bizarre and disavowed way this antiquated pseudo-scientific theory of male and female sexuality might usefully recall something remarked more recently by Gayle Rubin, namely that modern sexual difference theory, far from being an expression of natural differences, actually involves the suppression of natural similarities (&bquo;Traffic in Women&equo;, 179 &mdash; 80). 
 But it is not my intention to rehabilitate this theory,  or to suggest that it is allegorically preferable to current theories of sexual difference. 
 My argument does not even assume that it was a dominant way of thinking in earlier periods. 
 Rather I cite it here as a historical antecedent whose very strangeness alerts us to several facts relevant to what follows: first, and most obviously, that sexual difference is not a biological given so much as a complex ideological history; second, that current theories of sexual difference are of relatively recent origin, and quite probably still haunted by older views, including this one; third, it suggests that &bquo;before&equo; sexual difference the woman was once (and may still be) feared in a way in which the homosexual now is &mdash; feared, that is, not so much, or only, because of a radical otherness, as because of an interior resemblance presupposing a certain proximity; the woman then, as the homosexual in modern psychoanalytic discourse, is marked in terms of lesser or retarded development. 
 Sexual Difference, Homosexuality and Psychoanalysis 
 As Mandy Merck points out at the beginning of an acute and informative summary, in recent times the theory of sexual difference has exerted a profound influence on psychoanalytically inspired cultural analysis (&bquo;Difference and its Discontents&equo;, 2). 
 Recently the theoretical tide has turned against it. 
 Colin MacCabe puts it thus: 
 What is really problematic is that psychoanalysis produces a theory of identity &lsqb;i.e. sexual difference&rsqb; which does not allow for a genuine heterogeneity and contradiction in our diverse identifications. 
 It does not simply make the claim that one difference is more important than all the others but articulates all further identifications in terms of a primary sexual identification. 
 ( Theoretical Essays , 10) 
 It we further remark the way sexual difference is oft en presented within psychoanalysis as unavoidable and ineluctably fraught with pain, so much so in some cases that it warrants description as a tragic ontology, it becomes tempting to dismiss it as an expression of existential Angst  suitably dressed in pretentious intellectual rigour and elegant abstraction, and, as such (some might add), the epitome of psychoanalysis itself. 
 In fact, sexual difference theory is informed by, and responsive to, more than that; it intersects with other notions central to the psychoanalytic project. 
 Such notions impart to sexual difference theory its distinctive intellectual and existential charge. 
 I have in mind two  especially: the first involves what might be called the impossibility of desire, the second the notion of desire and/or identity as involving an ineluctable splitting. 
 Like other key notions in psychoanalysis, the sense of desire as a quest for an always impossible self-completion in or through the other has a long though oft en unrecognized history. 
 In this case Kaja Silverman has usefully remarked the importance, for Jacques Lacan's version of this argument, of Aristophanes' conception of the person as an original androgynous whole (in Plato's Symposium ). 
 The human subject is conceived in terms of an essential, intrinsic lack; it is a fragment of something larger and more primordial, whose existence is dominated by the desire to recover its missing complement ( The Subject of Semiotics , 152). 
 But the complement remains forever out of reach and desire thereby becomes, for Lacan, a kind of &bquo;derangement&equo;, with the subject &bquo;caught in the rails &mdash; eternally stretching forth towards the desire for something else  &mdash; of metonymy&equo; ( &Eacute;crits , 167). 
 But the subject is not only split in the sense of needing the other to complete itself; it is also split because its identity is actually informed by the other, by what it is not: 
 If the unconscious means anything whatsoever, it is that the relation of self and others, inner and outer, cannot be grasped as an interval between Polar and opposites  but rather as an irreducible dislocation of the subject in which the other inhabits the self as its condition of possibility. 
 (Weber, The Legend  of Freud , 32 &mdash; 3, his emphasis) 
 For Lacan desire itself becomes a splitting within the subject: &bquo;desire is neither the appetite for satisfaction, nor the demand for love, but the difference resulting from the subtraction of the first from the second, the very phenomenon of their splitting&equo; (Lacan, Feminine Sexuality , 81). 
 Recall that Lacan regards homosexuality as a definitive manifestation of this tragic ontology (above, Chapter 12). 
 As Lacan's invocation of metonymy suggests, such formulations are evidently influenced by the semiotic model, sometimes called the linguistic or, later, the deconstructive, turn to difference. 
 It sees meaning as always fundamentally incomplete because dependent on a potentially infinite relationship to what is ditferent or absent; completion of meaning is always thereby deferred. 
 Hence Jacques Derrida's influential concept of &bquo;diff&eacute;rance&equo; (translated in English as at once difference and deferral), a concept enabling us to &bquo;reconsider all the pairs of opposites  on which philosophy is constructed and on which our discourse lives, not in order to see opposition erase itself but to see what indicates that each of the terms must appear as the diff&eacute;rance  of the other, as the other different and deferred in the economy of the same&equo;. 
 Of &bquo;all the oppositions that furrow Freudian thought&equo; it can be said that &bquo;one is but the other different and deferred, one differing and deferring the other&equo; ( Margins of Philosophy , 17 &mdash; 18). 
 The potential of this conceptual theory for the psychoanalytic account of desire is nicely remarked by Gayatri Spivak: desire, she says, is a deconstructive structure, one that &bquo;forever differs from (we only desire what is not ourselves) and deters (desire is never fulfilled)&equo; ( Grammatology , p. ixxviii). 
 The influence of the semiotic model within psychoanalysis is important but, as we shall see, it is often incorporated into sexual difference theory in a form which manages to exclude what the model is especially sensitive to, namely the way oppositions which constitute meaning are fundamentally binary, yet cannot ultimately be contained in and by binary closure even as, in practice, the binary remains a fundamental principle of social and psychic ordering. 
 In Juliet Mitchell's account sexual difference becomes the archetypal split, and castration its symbol: 
 because human subjectivity cannot ultimately exist outside a division into one of two sexes, then it is castration that finally comes to symbolise this split&hellip;. 
 The trauma captured in splitting is that one isn't there; the same trauma that castration comes to symbolise is that one is incomplete; the trauma that can be lived over and over again in the endless by-ways of life's failures and imperfections. 
 (Revolution, 307) 
 Mitchell adds, &bquo;Bisexuality is a movement across a line, it is not  androgyny&equo; (p. 308, her emphasis). 
 Perhaps this tenet of psychoanalytic thought derives from the fact that, for Freud, &bquo; bisexuality is the coincidence of two heterosexual desires within a single psyche &hellip; within Freud's thesis of primary bisexuality, there is no homosexuality, and only opposites attract&equo; (Butler, Gender Trouble , 61, her emphasis). 
 Whatever, Mitchell's remark suggests how, even when recognized as a fact of culture rather than biology, sexual difference remains fairly absolute within psychoanalytic theory. 
 As in the Fall narrative, which it  resembles in more ways than one, there seems to be no going back; our original innocence, the wholeness of an original bisexuality, is never retrievable. 
 Sexuality is the Fall into desire as lack. 
 This leads some adherents of psychoanalysis, especially those of a Lacanian disposition, to regard sexual difference &mdash; or rather hetero/sexual difference as it should really be called &mdash; as both tragic and heroic. 
 Once again the psychoanalytic narrative echoes a theological one. 
 For Judith Butler this renders the Lacanian narrative &bquo;ideologically suspect&equo; in that it remains rooted in &bquo;a romanticization or, indeed, a religious idealization of &bquo;failure'&equo;, humility and limitation before the Law' ( Gender Trouble , 56). 
 This dimension of Lacan also finds a precedent in Freud: &bquo;the programme of becoming happy, which the pleasure principle imposes on us, cannot be fulfilled; yet we must not &mdash; indeed, we cannot &mdash; give up our efforts to bring it nearer to fulfilment by some means or other, (xii.271). 
 So the related notions of desire as lack, the impossibility of desire, and the desiring subject as ineluctably split have a history in Western thought older than psychoanalysis. 
 As I have argued in previous chapters, reconsidering that history helps us to reconsider psychoanalysis, especially the way it incorporates yet obscures the perverse dynamic. 
 Post-Freudian forms of sexual difference theory are not only largely ignorant of that pre-sexological, pre-psychoanalytic history; they even tend to obscure the significance and scope of Freud's own emphasis on the significance of perversion within sexual difference. 
 Thus the Lacanian account of the impossibility of desire often cites the following passage from Freud's &bquo;On the Universal Tendency to Debasement in the Sphere of Love&equo;: &bquo;It is my belief that, however strange it may sound, we must reckon with the possibility that something in the nature of the sexual instinct itself is unfavourable to the realization of complete satisfaction, (vii. 
 258). 
 But while Lacanian critics frequently invoke this passage, they less often consider Freud's extraordinary and provocative remarks in this same essay as to why  he thinks desire and satisfaction have become incommensurable. 
 He gives two possible reasons, both of which involve the repression of the perversions. 
 Because of the barrier against incest, the final object of the sexual instinct &bquo;is never any longer the original object but only a surrogate for it&hellip;. 
 When the original object of a wishful impulse has been lost as a result of repression, it is frequently represented by an endless series of substitute objects none of which, however, brings full satisfaction&equo; (vii. 
 258). 
 And, of the instinctual components necessarily repressed and sublimated in the service of culture, the coprophilic is one of the most significant, says Freud: &bquo;the  excremental is all too intimately and inseparably bound up with the sexual; the position of the genitals &mdash; inter urinas et faeces  &mdash; remains the decisive and unchangeable factor&equo; (vii. 
 258 &mdash; 9). 
 Freud singles out sadistic desires as a further group incompatible with civilization and requiring renunciation. 
 Yet the effect of the repression of such perversions always remains, and &bquo; can be detected in sexual activity in the form of nonsatisfaction &equo;, even while their sublimation leads, says Freud once again, &bquo;to the noblest cultural achievements&equo; (vii. 
 259, my emphasis). 
 So for Freud the lack inherent in normalized desire, its impossibility of satisfaction, is structured into sexual difference, and is a direct consequence of the repression of perverse desire. 
 And it perversion is, as we have argued (and in Freud's own terms), what potentially subverts sexual difference (Chapter 11), the silence of psychoanalytic advocates of sexual difference theory on this topic is both significant and damaging to their project. 
 The two interrelated psychoanalytic tenets just outlined suggest a radical instability in both identity and desire. 
 In an article arguing tor the importance of psychoanalysis for feminism, Jacqueline Rose cautions against a political appropriation of psychoanalysis which would leave behind some of its most challenging discoveries, especially of the disruptive power of the unconscious vis-&agrave;-vis  identity and sexual difference. 
 Here is Rose's own summary of a position persuasively argued throughout her work: 
 The unconscious constantly reveals the &bquo;failure&equo; of identity. 
 Because there is no continuity of psychic life, so there is no stability of sexual identity, no position for women (or for men) which is ever simply achieved. 
 Nor does psychoanalysis see such &bquo;failure&equo; as a special-case inability or an individual deviancy from the norm. 
 &bquo;Failure&equo; is not a moment to be regretted in a process of adaption, or development into normality, which ideally takes its course&hellip;. 
 Instead &bquo;failure&equo; is something endlessly repeated and relived moment by moment throughout our individual histories&hellip;. feminism's affinity with psychoanalysis rests above all, I would argue, with this recognition that there is a resistance to identity at the very heart of psychic life. 
 ( Sexuality in the Field of Vision , 90 &mdash; 1) 
 But again, what is often left out of such accounts of the unconscious, even as it is invoked as the prime destabilizer, is the importance of the perversions in precisely this respect: Freud insisted that what is operative from within the unconscious, producing this very instability, is repressed perversion. 
 Crucially, the psychoanalytic rationalization of sexual difference as a tragic split which in turn effects the failure of identity often goes along with an account of the alleged narcissistic limitations and failures of  homosexuality. 
 This returns us to the association of homosexuality with sameness remarked at the outset. 
 As we saw there, Segal and Irigaray have recently elaborated this view, but its origins are clearly in Freud whose early case-studies, as Mitchell observes, originate the idea that &bquo;the homosexual was choosing not another of the same sex, but himself in the guise of another&equo; ( Psychoanalysis and Feminism , 34; see e.g. Freud, ix. 
 198). 
 Irigaray's work is nuanced in ways oft en ignored not only by her critics but by those who appropriate it, especially those who consider her to have demonstrated that homosexuality represents the true nature of patriarchy; who believes that, as a sexual practice between the same, homosexuality becomes indicative of patriarchy's fundamental refusal or fear of difference. 
 As Jane Gallop puts it: 
 Irigaray has discovered that phallic sexual theory, male sexual science, is homosexual, a sexuality of sames, of identities, excluding otherness. 
 Heterosexuality, once it is exposed as an exchange of women between men, reveals itself as a mediated form of homosexuality. 
 All penetration&hellip; is thought according to the model of anal penetration. 
 The dry anus suffers pain; the penetrated is a humiliated man. 
 In short, Irigaray had allegedly discovered &bquo;the homosexual closed circuit&hellip; which underlies our supposed heterosexual culture&equo; (Gallop, Feminism and Psychoanalysis , 84 &mdash; 5). 
 One path of enquiry leads Gallop to repudiate this &bquo;homosexual economy&equo; and speculate thus: &bquo;I wish to speak of radical heterosexuality, a true openness and love for the heteros , the other, an intercourse between two modalities&hellip;. 
 And any relation between members of the same sex which allowed their difference, did not assimilate both to one fantasy, would be heterosexual.&equo; 
 But Gallop had doubts, or rather confesses an ambivalence: &bquo;But we cannot be sure that this radical notion of &bquo;heterosexuality'&equo; is not just an alibi for the comforting norm' (pp. 127 &mdash; 8). 
 More recently Gallop has remarked her suspicion of the wish to deny sexual difference because it &bquo;might be but another mode of denying women&equo;, adding: &bquo;I distrust male homosexuals because they choose men over women just as do our social and political institutions, but they too share in the struggle against bipolar gender constraints, against the compulsory choice of masculine or feminine&equo; ( Thinking through the Body , 1 13). 
 It is a testimony to the pervasiveness and tenacity of the homophobic tendencies of the psychoanalytic tradition that, despite the acute awareness on the part of feminists appropriating both Freud and Lacan that the writing of both contains anti-feminist tendencies, its homophobic dimensions are sometimes actively perpetuated in feminist accounts of  sexual difference theory. 
 This is acutely ironic in the light of Kenneth Lewes's recent argument to the effect that the psychoanalytic bias against male homosexuals derives from an initial gynaecophobic stance in psychoanalysis whereby &bquo;the fear and denigration of women which hover at the perimeter of analytic discourse become displaced onto the theory of male homosexuality&equo;. 
 Lewes contends that, whereas these gynaecophobic tendencies were from the start challenged by women analysts, the same could not occur in relation to the homophobia of the discipline since homosexuals were systematically excluded from it, with the result that &bquo;the psychoanalytic discourse on homosexuality has been and still is formulated by non-homosexuals about homosexuals&equo; ( The Psychoanalytic Theory of Male Homosexuality , 21, 237 &mdash; 8). 
 At the same time, and as we have already seen, &bquo;homophobia&equo; is an inadequate term to describe all this since what is at issue is not personal phobia so much as the recurrence in mutated form of structures integral to cultural identity and social formation. 
 That much is apparent from one further and final instance of the negative construction of homosexuality within a psychoanalytically informed account of sexual difference. 
 I refer to Julia Kristeva's somewhat obscure remarks about &bquo;the role that the pervert, with his invincible belief in the maternal phallus and his obstinate refusal to recognise the existence of the other sex , has been able to play in anti-semitism and the totalitarian movements that embrace it,. 
 Who exactly Kristeva means becomes even less clear as she adds: &bquo;Let us recall the fascist or social-fascist homosexual community (and all homosexual communities for whom there is no &bquo;other race'&equo;), and the fact that it is inevitably flanked by a community of viragos who have forgotten the war of the sexes and identity with the paternal Word or its serpent.&equo; 
 Problematic as sexual difference may be, there is no alternative: we must, continues Kristeva, &bquo;go on waging the war between the two races without respite, without a perverse denial of the abyss that marks sexual difference or a disillusioned mortification of the  division&equo;. 
 In her fuller and discerning reading of Kristeva, Judith Butler finds that lesbianism comes off pretty badly too; by implication Kristeva's theory &bquo;designates female homosexuality as a culturally unintelligible practice, inherently psychotic&equo;. 
 What Butler says of this account &mdash; namely that it &bquo;tells us more about the fantasies that a fearful heterosexual culture produces to defend against its own homosexual possibilities, than about lesbian experience itself&equo; ( Gender Trouble , 86 &mdash; 7) &mdash; might also be said more generally of the way homosexuality is conceptualized in sexual difference theory. 
 But it, as I have suggested, the structures of identity formation at work here are fundamental to our existing cultural forms, they cannot be considered as stemming only from the psychoanalytic tradition. 
 The concepts of difference and otherness, and the belief that sexual deviance leads to undifferentiation, have a philosophical and theological history, both of which antecede and influence psychoanalysis. 
 Otherness Philosophically Speaking: Roger Scruton 
 It is from an avowedly philosophical perspective that Roger Scruton announces &bquo;the major structural feature of perversion&equo; to be &bquo;the habit of finding a sexual release that avoids or abolishes the other , obliterating his embodiment with the obscene perception of his body&equo;; as such, believes Scruton, it is narcissistic and often solipsistic ( Sexual Desire , 289,343). 
 Scruton seeks to build an explicitly conservative sexual ethic on the Hegelian proposition that &bquo;the final end of every rational being is the building of the self &mdash; of a recognisable personal entity, which flourishes according to its own autonomous nature&equo; (p. 299). 
 This involves the recognition of the other as an end in himself (p. 301). 
 In gender terms this means that it is &bquo;precisely when most compelled to see yourself as  a woman or as  a man, &lsqb;that&rsqb; you are confronted with the mystery of the other &lsqb;sex&rsqb; who faces you from across an impassable moral divide&equo; (p. 306). 
 In this confrontation across the divide of gender one is compelled to put one's whole being at risk (p. 307). 
 Desire directed  across sexual difference, towards the other gender, elicits not its simulacrum (as in homosexuality) but its complement: &bquo;Male desire evokes the loyalty which neutralises its vagrant impulses; female desire evokes the conquering urge which overcomes its hesitations&equo; (p. 309). 
 Homosexuality is included as a perversion because it is denied this &bquo;fundamental experience&equo; of otherness-across-gender. 
 The homosexual &bquo;knows intimately in himself the generality that he finds in the other&equo;: &bquo;in the homosexual act I remain locked within my body, narcissistically contemplating in the other an excitement that is the mirror of my own&equo; (pp. 307, 310). 
 In normal or right sexuality, argues Scruton, we not only give recognition to the other's person in and through our desire tor him or her, we also accord them accountability and care in the process. 
 Among many possible objections, I shall note in passing just three, chosen because each indicates limitations which Scruton shares with other advocates of sexual difference theory. 
 It is ironic that by privileging sexual difference Scruton shows himself the victim of precisely the modern intensification of sexuality which in other ways he might regard as contributing to a legitimation of the perversions he repudiates. 
 This is further apparent from the way he makes broad social and ethical dimensions of human relations (accountability and care) the necessary  condition for normal or right sexuality. 
 In fact, there is no reason why (e.g.) homosexuals should not afford accountability and care to their partners, in the course of either a long relationship or a very short one. 
 But accountability and care no more have to be the absolute precondition, the ever-present animating ethic, of sexual relations, homosexual or otherwise, than they do of any other kind except in the obvious sense that care of some kind is the precondition of almost any shared social activity. 
 That such care may well characterize those activities which Scruton declares cannot possess it is suggested by Andrew Lumsden's appropriately passing  remark on the casual, anonymous sexual encounter: &bquo;for now I can only generalize: as I've known it, men are never so peaceful, so unviolent (physically and emotionally), so graceful with each other (no matter how &bquo;crude'&equo; the act) as they are &mdash; as we are &mdash; when content to take each other without the addition of names, or beds, or flats, or even of any clear impression of one-another's looks' ( Gay News , 235 (Mar. 1982), 17). 
 Second, simply in what Scruton classifies as perversions &mdash; masturbation, bestiality, necrophilia, paedophilia, sado-masochism, homosexuality, incest, fetishism &mdash; he shows himself to have accepted uncritically the sexological/Freudian classification of perversions as developed in the  nineteenth century.&equo; 
 Again he is taking over precisely the &bquo;modern&equo; definitions and oppositions, between the normal and pathological, the natural and unnatural, etc., which have been shown to be both confused and ideological in the narrow sense. 
 Third, Scruton reanimates the deep self as the defining principle of a normal sexuality. 
 His argument deploys the old jargon of authenticity, now combined with the jargon of otherness; despite his Hegelian framework, Scruton deploys this jargon as an exalted metaphor which does little more than bestow a spurious profundity on a normative sexual politics which is at heart timid, conservative, and deeply ignorant. 
 Mailer on Lawrence and Sexual Difference, or The &bquo;Full Rigours of the Fuck&equo; 
 The feminized male has always been suspect, be he the advocate of unisex, androgyny, or, now, the play of the post-modern. 
 Why so? 
 One reason might be that androgyny typically envisages a unity ostensibly beyond sexual difference, but in fact inseparable from it; androgyny especially has too often been a genderless transcendent which leaves sexual difference in place. 
 But conversely, as I have already remarked, when Juliet Mitchell insists that &bquo;bisexuality is a movement across a line, it is not  androgyny&equo;, she also leaves too much of sexual difference in place. 
 Both the androgynous evasion of sexual difference, and the psychoanalytic insistence on it, disavow the homoerotic knowledge of its other side (s ) and the perverse dynamic which so radically implicates masculine and feminine not only within each other but, much more disturbingly, with what each excludes. 
 This knowledge lurks around the feminized male, which is one reason why he tends to be rendered either safely fashionable, or denigrated. 
 Freud thought &bquo;the essentially repressed element is always what is feminine. 
 What men essentially repress is the paederastic element&equo;  (Mitchell, Revolution , 304). 
 It all depends of course on what is meant by &bquo;the feminine&equo;. 
 Surely this of all concepts, and especially in the context of the homoerotic, must not be essentialized. 
 Because they are so pervasive, and because their subordinate terms remain so powerfully denigrated, the erotics of active/passive should not be identified as coextensive with masculine/feminine, and should not be thought identical across the hetero/homosexual divide. 
 However, the association between homosexuality and femininity is not necessarily insulting to either; on the contrary, as Kaja Silverman shows, there are ways in which it might be just the reverse, especially when we contest the stereotypes of both. 
 This is what Silverman does, finding femininity centrally within male homosexuality, but in the process insisting that &bquo;we have barely begun to understand the full complexity of &bquo;femininity'&equo;, whether we locate that signifier at the site of woman, or at that of the homosexual man'. 
 Undoubtedly the perception of the homosexual as feminized remains strangely disturbing &mdash; the supreme symbol, in the eyes of those like Norman Mailer, of a range of deep failures including the demise of masculinity, the abdication of masculine power, the desire for self-destruction, and, beyond that, the loss of difference. 
 Exploring heterosexist fears of homoerotic passivity, Leo Bersani remarks some similarities between the contemporary representation of homosexuals in relation to AIDS, and the nineteenth-century representation of prostitutes in relation to venereal disease. 
 Both kinds of representation betray fears and fantasies about sexual passivity and sexual promiscuity: women then, and gay men now, are imagined to engage in a passive promiscuity which is really an unquenchable appetite for destruction; AIDS has &bquo;reinforced the heterosexual association of anal sex with a self-annihilation originally and primarily identified with the fantasmatic mystery of an insatiable, unstoppable female sexuality&equo;. 
 Bersani discerns in such associations the possibility of a seductive yet intolerable (i.e. unconscious) image of the male &bquo;unable to refuse the suicidal ecstasy of being a woman&equo;. 
 He further remarks how, even in cultures which do not regard sexual relations between men as unnatural or sinful, male sexual &bquo;passivity&equo; may be associated with inferiority, inadequacy, and even pathology. 
 Summarizing Foucault's account in volume ii of The History of Sexuality  of how in ancient Greece homosexual passivity was regarded with suspicion, even though  homosexuality as such was accepted and even glorified, Bersani concludes: &bquo; To be penetrated is to abdicate power &equo; (&bquo;Is the Rectum a Grave?, 222, 211 &mdash; 12, his emphasis). 
 For all its brilliant rhetoric and endearingly dishonest struggle to regain a masculine integrity, Norman Mailer's defence of D. H. Lawrence in The Prisoner of Sex  conveys finally a certain desperation in the face of apprehensions similar to those which Bersani explores. 
 But this desperation is not to be stereotyped; it is not so much the result of being a man, not even of being a &bquo;real&equo; man, but rather of being psychically and sexually locked into the fantasies and fears of sexual difference. 
 I shall be turning to Lawrence shortly; here it is Mailer's account of him which is intriguing. 
 For Mailer, Lawrence's greatness lies in part in his heroic struggle against his destiny, which was to be homosexual: &bquo;he had become a man by an act of will, he was bone and blood of the classic family stuff out of which homosexuals are made, he had lifted himself out of his natural destiny which was probably to have the sexual life of a woman&equo; (p. 154). 
 To repeat, the association between homosexuality and the sexual lite of a woman is not necessarily insulting to either; it is only that Mailer's denigrating version of it forewarns of the crassness of the version of sexual difference which constitutes both the origin and horizon of his vision, and once again indicates an intense apprehensiveness in the face of imagined male passivity, and the way it is oft en conceived in terms of a denigrated and denigrating femininity at once utterly alien to yet strangely inherent within the male. 
 Mailer apparently concurs with the belief he attributes to Lawrence, that &bquo;men and women can survive only it they reach the depths of their own sex down within themselves&equo; (p. 147). 
 Androgyny, or what he calls the &bquo;liberal supposition&equo; that it is good for men and women to become more and more alike, creates in Mailer an aversion, &bquo;a species of aesthetic nausea&equo; (pp. 134 &mdash; 5). 
 Relatedly, for him, the evils of our times are indicated in the way that, allegedly, the polymorphous perverse has come to prevail over procreation, contraception over conception, and the anus over the vagina &mdash; &bquo;as if the mark of a civilization dying should be a mountainous sense of excitement for the hole which presides over waste&equo; (p. 162). 
 Also definitive of that decline is the loss of sexual difference as epitomized in &mdash; no surprise &mdash; homosexuality: 
 Where a man can become more male and a woman more female by coming together in the full rigors of the fuck&hellip; homosexuals, it can be suggested, tend to pass their qualities over to one another, for there is no womb to mirror and return what is most forceful or attractive in each of them. 
 So the male gets more womanly and the queer absorbs the masculinity of the other. 
 (pp. 171 &mdash; 2; cf. p. 162) 
 Whereas prior to 1954 the male homosexual was for Mailer a rather facile symbol of evil (above, Chapter 3), now he epitomizes a more insidious and actual kind of evil: the undoing of otherness, and a drive towards undifferentiation echoing biblical &bquo;confusion&equo;. 
 The Masculine Dilemma: Wanting to Be What the Other Is 
 In The Masculine Dilemma  (1980), subtitled &bquo;A Psychology of Masculinity&equo;, Gregory Rochlin offers a different version of the homosexual male, but one which is once again in the service of defending an updated heterosexual masculinity, and its primacy within a sexual difference metaphysic. 
 Drawing on psychoanalysis, Rochlin &bquo;rewrites&equo; masculinity in a way which makes a virtue of what was hitherto thought of as, or experienced as, a defect: its much remarked insecurity. 
 His argument is as follows: a man's masculinity is indeed insecure; it is an endless trial, a &bquo;precariously held, endlessly tested, unstable condition&equo; (p. 91). 
 In this it is almost tragic: &bquo;the unique vulnerability to tailed expectations is the fatal flaw in the masculine ego&hellip; the testing of masculinity knows no bounds&hellip; to prove oneself remains a lifelong necessity&hellip;. 
 It gives rise to many of man's anxieties and failures as well as to his often extraordinary achievements&equo; (pp. x, xi). 
 The critique of masculinity which says, &bquo;for all your confidence you as man are insecure and afraid&equo;, is not repudiated but incorporated; man's insecurity is embraced as an enhancing vulnerability. 
 Rochlin appropriates for masculinity, albeit in a form so highly selective it might hardly be recognized, that sense of the inherent instability of identity which Lacanians and others have taken from psychoanalysis for feminism. 
 Rochlin &bquo;feminizes&equo; masculinity to just the degree required to rehabilitate it as the dominant term in the masculine/feminine binary, and he does this through the by now familiar move of positing homosexuality as the inadequate yet threatening third term. 
 Masculinity can be problematized, even feminized, so long as homosexuality remains as its defining other. 
 So, for Rochlin, the homosexual is a sexual coward who will not risk the competitiveness of male rivalry. 
 He quotes approvingly an anonymous &bquo;youth&equo; who believes that gay men have given up the battle between men: &bquo;they've submitted to men&hellip;. 
 They can't meet the  standards of manhood. 
 That takes incredibly high performance, competitiveness, winning all. 
 Being &bquo;gay'&equo; gets you out of the competition of manhood' (pp. 84 &mdash; 5). 
 So the confession of vulnerability does not involve a more thoughtful relationship to homosexuality; rather the reverse. 
 In fact Rochlin's theory of heterosexual masculinity remains dependent on a precise and hostile positioning of the homosexual vis-&agrave;-vis  the heterosexual male. 
 Once again, the male homosexual is someone who refuses to risk himself in relation to the other, but now the risk is not in relation to the opposite sex (as in Scruton and Mailer), but to the same sex as rival. 
 In this account homosexuals are essentially failed men, and the arbiters of what it takes to be a successful male are of course not women but other males. 
 It might be said that Rochlin is not to be taken seriously, being merely a popularizing psychologist. 
 From my point of view that is exactly why he should be taken seriously, and not only because of his apparent prestige. 
 However, it necessary, his argument can easily be traced back to Freud. 
 In &bquo;The Psychogenesis of a Case of Homosexuality in a Woman&equo; Freud announces a newly discovered &bquo;cause&equo; of homosexuality, what he calls &bquo;retiring in favour of someone else&equo;. 
 The idea is that the person turns homosexual as a way of avoiding competition, conflict, or tension with a significant other. 
 Freud cites one young man in relation to his father and another in relation to his twin, as well as the main case, a young woman in relation to her mother: &bquo;It, then, the girl became homosexual and left men to her mother (in other words &bquo;retired in favour of'&equo; her mother), she would hitherto remove something which had hitherto been partly responsible for her mother's dislike' (ix. 
 385; cf. 
 Tripp, Homosexual Matrix , 78 &mdash; 9, cited above, Chapter 1 2). 
 Perhaps the manifest intrinsic contusions which surface in each of the foregoing theories are enough to write them oft, and to show how the same/different metaphysic is nothing more than a potently confused, highly discriminating mixed metaphor. 
 But there is more to be discovered by thinking their confusions and discriminations to the surface, and to that end I consider one further &bquo;explanation&equo; of homosexuality along similar lines. 
 This one is cited in the text of a discussion printed in Girard's Things Hidden  and, though not by him, is offered in support of his general thesis that culture is organized in terms of mimesis and desire. 
 It is a thesis which includes the proposition that all sexual rivalry  is structurally homosexual'. 
 We are told the story of a man (unidentified, so for convenience I shall refer to him as X ) who, though &bquo;exclusively heterosexual&equo; had become interested in another younger man on the occasion of finding himself in a triangular relationship with him and his (i.e. the younger man's) fianc&eacute;e at a dinner party. 
 When the younger man eventually left his fianc&eacute;e for X , the latter completely lost interest in him. 
 The older man explains why: &bquo;Take my word for it &mdash; homosexuality is wanting to be what the other is&equo; (p. 337). 
 Apparently, for the &bquo;exclusively heterosexual&equo; X , homosexuality is not a submitting to another man but a competition with, a displacing of, him. 
 &bquo;I want to be in your place&equo; collapses temporarily into &bquo;I want you&equo;; identification merges with desire, which is then a desire to be/displace the male as other. 
 But only temporarily: once he has displaced the other vis-&agrave;-vis  the desired object, he loses interest. 
 So here is a contrast: whereas for Rochlin homosexuality is an opting out of masculine competition, for X  it is a direct expression of it; or, more exactly, homosexual desire is inseparable from and dependent upon mimetic rivalry between males. 
 But there are revealing similarities between the two explanations, quite apart from the tact that in both cases the &bquo;authority&equo; on homosexuality is an avowed heterosexual male, and one cited anonymously at that. 
 More significantly, in each case what is primary is the male &mdash; male rivalry. 
 Homosexuality is invoked to &bquo;explain' or ratify (rather than question) aspects of the male homosocial relationship. 
 The sexuality of Rochlin's youth is clearly governed &mdash; one might say overdetermined &mdash; by his relation to other males. 
 And when X  says homosexuality is wanting to be what the other is, the other is now not the other (opposite) sex, but the same sex, and X , as avowed heterosexual, has described his desire to displace the male. 
 To consider the rationale of such explanations is to suspect that, rather than homosexuality being a fear of the other (sex), heterosexual masculinity involves at least intense anxieties about, and probably fears of, the same (sex), and constructs/explains homosexuality in terms which project, disavow, and legitimate those anxieties. 
 This fear of the same, or of the proximity of the same, or of the threat of the same, structures the violence not only of the homosocial, but of sexual difference itself. 
 Kinds of Hating 
 I have outlined a handful of sexual difference theories wherein homosexuality is associated with, or is seen to be expressive of: (1) the true, negative, nature of patriarchy, (2) a negation of what is truly vital and creative in (heterosexual) desire, (3) anti-Semitism, totalitarianism, and  fascism, (4) an obliteration of the autonomy of the other, (5) anal negativity, solipsism, and sterility and de-creation, (6) the undifferentiation of a dying culture, (7) a cowardly refusal of homosocial rivalry, (8) the definitive expression of homosocial rivalry. 
 These accounts derive from diverse current perspectives which should not be conflated &mdash; psychoanalysis, philosophy, and what might be called the metaphysical vision of the cultural critic and creative writer. 
 But this very diversity renders their shared tendency to demonize homosexuality as a fear of difference, or, more actively, as a drive towards undifferentiation and de-creation, the more remarkable. 
 And in all of them homosexuality echoes Augustinian privation &mdash; the more pernicious for being deeply, inherently inadequate, a kind of non-being and inauthenticity: an inimical absence which provokes paranoia and on to which is projected the fear of difference inherent within sexual difference. 
 D. H. Lawrence and the Metaphysics of sexual Difference 
 All neurotics, and many others besides, take exception to the fact that &bquo; inter urinas et faeces nascimur  &lsqb;we are born between urine and faeces&rsqb;&equo;. 
 (freud, xii. 
 296) 
 Once again, via a somewhat backward chronology, I have left Lawrence's account of sexual difference until last. 
 This increasingly disregarded and often despised writer proves rather revealing of how the perverse dynamic disrupts theories of sexual difference like those just examined. 
 In three respects at least D. H. Lawrence's attitude to homosexuality was typical: first, he seems to have been able to accept it only in an idealized and spiritual form; as Paul Delany puts it, he wanted not a lover but a spiritual brother. 
 Second, in his writing he tends to present actual homosexuals (e.g. Loerke in Women in Love ) as decadent others who draw off that which for Lawrence complicates the ideal homoerotic brotherhood. 
 Third, his anxieties about homosexuality were conjoined with class antagonism. 
 His well-known hostility to the Bloomsbury group included a homophobic preoccupation with the sexuality of some of its members; in a letter to Bertrand Russell on 12 February 1915 he said: &bquo;The ordinary Englishman of the educated class goes to a woman now to masterbate &lsqb;sic&rsqb;  himself. 
 Because he is not going for discovery or new connection or progression, but only to repeat upon himself a  known reaction. 
 When this condition arrives, there is always Sodomy&equo; ( Letters , 285). 
 Again, homosexuality is thought of as a narcissistic repudiation of sexual difference. 
 From his study of Lawrence at that time, Paul Delany concludes that the writer had &bquo;strong homosexual impulses which he felt morally bound to repress&equo; ( Nightmare , 50). 
 The same letter also indicates how certain heterosexual anxieties structured in and by sexual difference are projected by Lawrence on to the homosexual, a move which his critics sometimes follow in trying to save him from the taint of homosexual desire. 
 Eugene Goodheart, tor instance, describes Birkin as suffering from a homosexual fear oft women. 
 This is quoted and endorsed by Meyers ( Homosexuality and Literature , 148), who goes on to describe Lawrence's Aaron's Rod  as possessing many components of &bquo;a homosexual novel&equo; including &bquo;an intense hatred and fear of women, who are characterised in two male gatherings as threatening, frightening and repulsive&equo;, and &bquo;a symbolically castrated hero who is afraid to let himself go in heterosexual love and runs away from his three women&equo; (p. 154). 
 Once more a misogyny produced internally to and largely by hetero/sexual difference is projected on to homosexuality. 
 But there is more to be said about Lawrence; much more than was usually said in the days when he was celebrated as a prophet of straight liberation, and more than is oft en said when he is castigated from the vantage point of contemporary sexual politics. 
 Lawrence audaciously sexualizes Western metaphysics. 
 His theories are well enough known for me to sketch them only briefly. 
 The emphasis falls repeatedly on the individual, the self which is a law unto itself. 
 Essentially, &bquo;the soul wishes to keep clean and whole. 
 The soul's deepest will is to preserve its own integrity, against the mind and the whole mass of disintegrating forces&equo; ( Studies in Classic American Literature , 185). 
 Lawrence also celebrates the &bquo;other&equo;, but often as a foil for the integrity of self; affirmation of one's own pure self is presented as the precondition for recognizing the other. 
 Especially the other of sexual difference. 
 Lawrence placed enormous emphasis on the duality of, and opposition between, the male and female principles: &bquo;except in infinity, everything of life is male or female, distinct&equo; ( Phoenix , 443). 
 In this broad sense, sexual difference was the fundamental principle of his  entire metaphysic, the terms in which its main absolutes, selfhood and wholeness, were realized. 
 If &bquo;the final aim of every living thing, creature, or being is the full achievement of itself&equo; ( Phoenix , 403) it can only do this through another &mdash; typically the other of sexual difference. 
 Ideally the theory encompasses the desire for both an integrity of self, and an integration with another. 
 But for Lawrence the two conflict and in ways which echo the psychoanalytic account of desire: 
 Why were we crucified into sex? 
 Why were we not left rounded off, and finished in ourselves, 
 As we began, 
 As he certainly began, so perfectly alone?&hellip; 
 The Cross, 
 The Wheel on which our silence first is broken, 
 Sex, which breaks up our integrity, our single inviolability, our deep silence, 
 Tearing a cry from us&hellip;. 
 That which is whole, torn asunder, 
 That which is in part, finding its whole again throughout the universe. 
 One resolution to the problem was for the other to submit to the one, the woman to the man, the weaker man to the stronger man. 
 For Lawrence submission to the integrity/mastery of another is an erotically charged solution to a primary metaphysical conflict which was always more than sexual. 
 The intensity of this erotic charge is only slightly less remarkable than its investment, a kind of reverse sublimation whereby neurosis is fantasized sexually as a potent purity inviting submission: &bquo;What do I care if he kills people? 
 His flame is young and clean&equo; ( The Plumed Serpent , 410). 
 But precisely because purity is invested with such a tremendous erotic charge, fears of &bquo;impurity&equo; remained insistent and corrosive, and in a perversely dynamic proximity disavowed along lines suggested by Freud's remarks at the beginning of this section, and in a passage from &bquo;Repression&equo; (191 5) worth citing again in this context: 
 the objects to which men give most preference, their ideals, proceed from the same perceptions and experiences as the objects which they most abhor, and&hellip; they were originally only distinguished from one another through slight modifications&hellip; 
 Indeed&hellip; it is possible for the original instinctual representative  to be split in two, one part undergoing repression, while the remainder, Precisely on account of this intimate connection , undergoes idealization (xi. 
 150, my emphasis). 
 In his essay &bquo;Pornography and Obscenity&equo; Lawrence invokes this idealization/abhorrence distinction between the sex functions and the excrementory functions: 
 &lsqb;they&rsqb; work so close together, yet they are, so to speak, utterly different in direction. 
 Sex is a creative flow, the excrementory flow is towards dissolution, de-creation&hellip;. 
 In the really healthy human being the distinction between the two is instant, our profoundest instincts are perhaps our instincts of opposition between the two flows. 
 But in the degraded human being the deep instincts have gone dead, and the two flows become identical. 
 (pp. 313&ndash;14) 
 As harmful as a mixing of the flows is masturbation. 
 Producing shame, anger, and futility, it is masturbation which, for Lawrence, constitutes the most pernicious evasion of otherness, becoming &bquo;perhaps the deepest and most dangerous cancer of our civilization&equo;, and &bquo;certainly the most dangerous sexual vice that a society can be afflicted with, in the long run&equo; (&bquo;Pornography&equo;, 3 17). 
 Masturbation symbolizes a wider social malaise rooted in solipsistic self-regard. 
 In a review essay written two years before &bquo;Pornography and Obscenity&equo;, Lawrence attacks the way we have (allegedly) come to think of ourselves in modern civilization. 
 He finds the masses obsessed by an abysmal social insanity, an aspect of which is the tendency of the individual to see himself as &bquo;a little absolute unto himself&equo;. 
 Whereas &bquo;the true self, in sex, would seek a meeting , would seek to meet the other&equo;, this being the &bquo;true flow&equo;, sexuality today is merely greedy, blind, selfseeking, and &bquo;therefore, since the thing sought is the same, the self, the mode of seeking is not very important. 
 Heterosexual, homosexual, narcissistic, normal, or incest, it is all the same thing&hellip;. 
 Every man, every woman just seeks his own self, her own self, in the sexual experience.&equo; 
 Such self-regard is the wider evil which masturbation epitomizes. 
 The solution is for people to get back into touch, to &bquo;utterly break the present great picture of a normal humanity&hellip; and fall again into true relatedness&equo; (&bquo;Review&equo;, 470 &mdash; 2). 
 In &bquo;Pornography and Obscenity&equo; Lawrence does not precisely equate homosexuality with the twin evils of masturbation and the excremental flow. 
 In tact, he allows that &bquo;even in homosexual intercourse&equo; there is a &bquo;give and take&equo; quite absent from the real evil, masturbation. 
 But elsewhere, as in Lawrence's attacks on the Bloomsbury group, homosexuality becomes symptomatic of cultural malaise rather as does masturbation here. 
 In particular it is seen to share masturbation's refusal of the other in favour of the self. 
 And via a now explicit association with anality, especially sodomy, homosexuality becomes a  paradigm of sterility and solipsism, while heterosexuality is regarded as the way back to a dynamic, creative encounter with the other: in the woman the man embraces &bquo;all that is not himself&equo; and from that embrace &bquo;comes every new action&equo; (quoted in Delany, Nightmare , 79). 
 Here is a valorization of the different/same binary similar to that already encountered in Gallop, Scruton, Mailer, and others. 
 In Lawrence's essays it goes along with that familiar stance of hard-earned adjustment whereby sickness is always someone else's problem &mdash; the masses, the modern world, women, homosexuals, whoever. 
 In his introduction to the privately printed edition of Pansies , for instance, Lawrence castigates Swift for his &bquo;gnashing insanity&equo;, his &bquo;insolent and sickly squeamish mind&equo;, at the thought that &bquo;Celia shits&equo;. 
 Lawrence feels like going back and saying to her &bquo;It's all right, don't take any notice of that mental lunatic&equo; (p. 304), thereby offering a new inflection of the erotic triangle: intervening between Swift and Celia, Lawrence displaces his own anal neurosis on to Swift while offering his healthy ideal self to Celia &mdash; or rather he seeks to become his ideal self in her eyes . 
 At such moments the narcissistic dimension of relating to otherness becomes apparent. 
 But for its full significance, and a rather more liberating version of it, we might recall Wilde's wonderful anecdote about Narcissus and the river as related by Gide: 
 When Narcissus died, the flowers of the field asked the river for some drops of water to weep for him. 
 &bquo;Oh!&equo; answered the river, &bquo;if all my drops of water were tears, I should not have enough to weep for Narcissus myself. 
 I loved him!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh!&equo; replied the flowers of the field, &bquo;how could you not have loved Narcissus? 
 He was beautiful&equo;. 
 &bquo;Was he beautiful?&equo; said the river. 
 &bquo;And who could know better than you? 
 Each day, leaning over your bank, he beheld his beauty in your water&hellip;, 
 Wilde paused for a moment&hellip; 
 &bquo;If I loved him, replied the river, &bquo;it was because, when he leaned over my water, I saw the reflection of my waters in his eyes.&equo; 
 ( Oscar Wilde , 2) 
 Lawrence's masquerade of adjustment involves a projection of his own fears, anxieties, and neurosis which, in the Swift/Celia case, is especially revealing because in the same breath he consciously repudiates the scapegoating process which partly comprises that projection (pp. 303 &mdash; 4). 
 But Lawrence dramatizes something else: if, within the construction of homosexuality as a fear or refusal of otherness, there may be a projection by the male heterosexual on to the homosexual of his fear of the woman as other , there may also be a disavowal of the heterosexual's fear of the homosexual as the same &mdash;  that is, a fear of those gender proximities and interconnections, including Lawrence's  opposed energy &bquo;flows&equo;, whose feared mutual implication compromises not only the ideology of sexual difference, but the cultural formations which it underwrites. 
 It is in this complicated sense that misogyny and homophobia once more interconnect, and otherness may be said to inhere within the same. 
 Lawrence remained too preoccupied with what in his adjusted mind he projected, disavowed, or consciously repudiated; homosexuality especially remained too fascinating for either his strenuous vision of psychic adjustment or his banal view of sexual difference as unity in opposition to remain unharassed by it. 
 In a letter to Henry Savage on 2 December 1913 he writes: &bquo;I should like to know why nearly every man that approaches greatness tends to homosexuality, whether he admits it or not&equo; ( Letters , 1 15). 
 This fascination with, and obvious susceptibility to, homosexual desire occasionally contributes to some brilliantly perverse writing wherein the idealization/abhorrence splitting described by Freud is reversed, and a metaphysic of absolute difference is desublimated into the cathected, dialectic proximity of the perverse dynamic. 
 The obvious way of approaching those moments in which this occurs is via Lawrence's astonishing description of intense, concealed homosexual desire in the suppressed prologue to Women in Love : 
 it was for men that he felt the hot, flushing, roused attraction which a man is supposed to feel for the other sex&hellip; the male physique had a fascination for him, and for the female physique he felt only a fondness&hellip; 
 In the street it was the men who roused him by their flesh and their manly, vigorous movement&hellip; 
 He love his friend, the beauty of whose manly limbs made him tremble with pleasure. 
 He wanted to caress him. 
 And then in his soul would succeed a sort of despair, because this passion for a man had recurred in him. 
 It was a deep misery to him. 
 And it would seem as if he had always loved men, always and only loved men. 
 And this was the greatest suffering to him. 
 This was the one and only secret he kept to himself, this secret of his passionate and sudden, spasmodic affinity for men he saw. 
 He kept this secret even from himself. 
 He knew what he felt, but he always kept the knowledge at bay. 
 (Phoenix II, 103&ndash;4, 107) 
 Lawrence also remained fascinated by anality, and in Women in Love  (ch. 23, &bquo;Excurse&equo;) there is that celebration of the potency of heterosexual anal intercourse where desire would, at the very least, seem to confuse his distinction between anality and sexuality proper: 
 It was a dark flood of electric passion she released from him, drew into herself. 
 She had established&hellip; a new current of passional electric energy&hellip;. 
 It was a  perfect passing away for both of them, and at the same time the most intolerable accession into being, the marvellous fullness of immediate gratification, overwhelming, outflooding from the source of the deepest life-force, the darkest, deepest, strangest life-source of the human body, at the back and base of the loins. 
 (pp. 353 &mdash; 4) 
 Meyers finds &bquo;The equation of the anus with the life source&hellip; an obscene and outrageous idea&equo; ( Homosexuality and Literature , 148) and concludes that Birkin is using Ursula as a homosexual substitute &mdash; this being even more perverse than homosexuality proper because (according to Clifford Allen in a book ominously titled Homosexuality: Its Nature, Causation and Treatment ) the anus in homosexual love symbolizes the vagina and &bquo;anal intercourse is only unconscious incestuous behaviour&equo; (p. 50, quoted by Meyers, Homosexuality and Literature , 178). 
 In so far as I understand the logic here, heterosexual sodomy is surrogate homosexuality and homosexual sodomy is surrogate heterosexuality &mdash; or rather surrogate heterosexual incestuous genital intercourse. 
 Perhaps such interpretations are intriguing not so much because of their rather desperate commitment to the metaphysical primacy of heterosexual genital intercourse &mdash; that is merely banal &mdash; but because they reveal the tortured cultural and psychic logic which that commitment entails. 
 The anal intercourse in chapter 16 of Lady Chatterley's Lover , though once ignored, has become even more notorious than that in Women in Love : 
 Though a little frightened, she let him have his way, and the reckless, shameless sensuality shook her to her foundations&hellip; 
 It was not really love&hellip;. 
 It was sensuality sharp and searing as fire, burning the soul to tinder. 
 Burning out the shames, the deepest, oldest shames, in the most secret places. 
 It cost her an effort to let him have his way and his will of her. 
 She had to be a passive, consenting thing, like a slave, a physical slave&hellip;. 
 She would have thought a woman would have died of shame. 
 Instead of which the shame died&hellip;. 
 There was nothing left to disguise or be ashamed of&hellip;. 
 But it took some getting at, the core of the physical jungle, the dark and deepest recess of organic shame. 
 The phallus alone could explore it. 
 And how he had pressed it on her! (pp. 258 &mdash; 9) 
 Should such passages lead us to say that Lawrence was a heterosexual sodomite or &bquo;repressed homosexual&equo;? 
 Neither: let us say rather that what is most significant about such passages is the way so much is  fantasized from the position of the woman (including anal ecstasy and, elsewhere, Lawrence's almost as notorious worship of the phallus), and in a voice which is at once blindingly heterosexist and desperately homoerotic . 
 At such moments he may be most  culpable vis-&agrave;-vis  a responsible sexual politics (lesbian, gay, and feminist), but most revealing about the &bquo;nature&equo; of sexual desire. 
 Further, if Lawrence's celebration of heterosexuality is dependent upon a repression of, a disavowal of, and a displacement on to, homosexuality, such passages are animated by a homoerotic desire consciously and artistically sublimated into heterosexuality . 
 By sublimation I mean here not the conversion of sexuality per se  into a higher, non-sexual aim, but the displacement of one kind of sexuality into another &mdash; or, more exactly (and this is the sense in which I still subscribe to Freud's notion), the contamination of a higher (i.e. socially approved) sexuality by a lower (i.e. proscribed) one. 
 And such displacement and contamination are made possible by that radical interconnectedness between the two which the lower knows and the higher disavows. 
 In short, Lawrence finds ecstasy not in heterosexuality per se  but its radical perversion, and he does so by reactivating the perverse dynamic at the heart of desire. 
 We might say that the narrator is being fucked by the same in the position of the other &mdash; a formulation intentionally ambiguous as to who exactly is in the position of the other, since it is both: the narrator is in the position of the woman being fucked by the other of woman (man).   
 PART 8 Transgressive Reinscriptions, Early Modern and Post-Modern  
 Subjectivity and Transgression 
 Part 1 explored how, in the post/modern period, issues of transgression and subjectivity are inextricably bound together. 
 The same is true of the earlier period, but with important differences which are oft en disregarded. 
 In English studies especially the modern and the early modern have been erroneously conflated. 
 In particular, essentialist conceptions of the self which took effective hold only in the Enlightenment, then to be subsequently developed within (for instance) Romanticism and modernism, have been retrospectively read into the early modern period. 
 Nosce Teipsum 
 Consider that great imperative of this period, nosce teipsum , know thyself. 
 Today, for critical theories as ditferent as Marxism and post/ modernism, know thy discursive formations: 
 In acquiring one's conception of the world one always belongs to a particular grouping which is that of all the social elements which share the same mode of thinking and acting&hellip;. 
 The starting-point of critical elaboration is the consciousness of what one really is, and is &bquo;knowing thyself&equo; as a product of the historical process to date which has deposited in you an infinity of traces, without leaving an inventory. 
 (Gramsci, Cultural Writings , 423) 
 But surely for the early moderns also: terminology apart, did not nosce teipsum  only ever mean something like that? 
 Is that not why Montaigne could say &bquo;the more I frequent and know myselfe&hellip; the less I understand myselfe&equo;; why also he discovers that &bquo;I have nothing to say entirely, simply, and with soliditie of my selfe without contusion, disorder, blending, mingling&hellip; 
 &equo; ( Essays , trans. 
 Florio, iii. 
 282, ii. 
 12) 
 Though generally appropriated by humanist criticism as a recognizable origin of itself, nosce teipsum  may nevertheless have something  crucial in common with the formulations of post-structuralism. 
 Of the few central beliefs uniting the various post-structuralisms (and connecting them with post/modernism) this is one of the most important: human identity is to be seen as constituted as well as constitutive; constituted (not determined) by, for example, the pre-existing structures of language and ideology, and by the material conditions of human existence. 
 Thus is the subject decentred, and subjectivity revealed as a kind of subjection &mdash; not the antithesis of social process but its focus. 
 In the early modern period also the individual was seen as constituted by and in relation to &mdash; even the effect of &mdash; a pre-existing order. 
 To know oneself was to know that order. 
 Consider Richard Hooker's declaration: &bquo;God hath his influence into the very essence of all things, without which influence of Deity supporting them their utter annihilation could not choose but follow&equo; ( Laws , ii. 
 226). 
 Or the commonplace with which Sir John Davies begins his Nosce Teipsum : God wrote the law directly into the hearts of our first parents. 
 Hooker concurs: the law of Reason, the universal law of mankind, is &bquo;imprinted&equo; in men's souls and &bquo;written in their hearts&equo; (i. 166, 228). 
 The biblical source is Jeremiah: &bquo;saith the Lord, I will put my law &lsqb;Torah&rsqb; in their inward parts, and write it in their hearts&equo; (31: 33). 
 Heart &lsqb;leb&rsqb; here signifies the seat of thought, not emotion, so is more akin to &bquo;mind&equo;; hence, to labour the analogy somewhat, law is written into identity and consciousness rather than heart in the modern sense. 
 When Montaigne and Bacon stress the determining power of social custom they are developing the same idea of an order prior to and determining of consciousness, though now of course with the crucial difference that it is a non-teleological order, historical rather than divine, material rather than metaphysical. 
 Obviously there are far-reaching differences between early modern metaphysics and post-structuralism. 
 For one thing the early modern view of identity as constituted (metaphysically) was also, and quite explicitly, a powerful metaphysic of social integration. 
 In other words, to be metaphysically identified was simultaneously to be socially positioned &mdash; the subject in relation to the prince, the woman in relation to the man, and so on. 
 Metaphysics here underpins a discursive formation of the subject, of subjection. 
 This link between subjectivity and subjection, which for the (political) post/modernist has to be disclosed before it can be disarticulated, is, by comparison, both assumed and manifestly endorsed in the Renaissance. 
 Another difference: within Renaissance metaphysics a constituted identity might nevertheless be essentially fixed  (e.g. the soul as divine creation) in a way the post/modernist would probably reject (identity is not only constructed but contingently so). 
 The Cognito: Augustine, Descartes, and Lacan 
 Would Hamlet have felt the delicious fascination of suicide if he hadn't had an audience, and lines to speak? 
 (Jean Genet, Prisoner of Love ) 
 The Cartesian cogito &mdash; cogito ergo sum  (I think therefore I am) &mdash; conventionally if somewhat simplistically marks a major point in the emergence of Western individualism. 
 More exactly, it is seen to mark a point in a process of transition from the idea of self as metaphysically constituted to the idea of self as an individuated, autonomous essence; self-consciousness rather than divine or natural law becomes constitutive of subjective identity. 
 As we saw in Chapter 9, Augustine gives a memorable earlier version of the Cartesian cogito : &bquo;Si enim fallor sum&equo; &mdash; if I am deceived, then I exist. 
 In contrast to Descartes's emphasis on a self-constituting autonomy born of certitude, Augustine's formulation registered man's uncertainty, and that inseparably from dependency upon a prior ordering of selfhood. 
 As part of his project of recasting psychoanalysis in post-structuralist terms, Jacques Lacan has rewritten the Cartesian cogito  in a way that might be seen as approximating more to Augustine's formulation than Descartes's: &bquo;I think where I am not, therefore I am where I do not think&equo;. 
 Augustine might have grasped the point of this formulation quickly enough, if only because of what he and Lacan share in common: a sense of identity as constituted rather than constitutive, an effect of the pre-existing. 
 Augustine would also have understood Lacan's invocation of Rimbaud: &bquo;Je est un autre&equo; (I is (an) other). 
 Of course, and again, the differences are considerable; after all, the unconscious, that which in psychoanalysis undermines conscious autonomy, and in relation to which Lacan rewrites the cogito , is a modern discovery. 
 A massive step forward from Descartes then, but also perhaps a step back to Augustine. 
 After all, it we were to ask which was the more metaphysical, divine law or the psychoanalytic unconscious, some might reply, &bquo;the unconscious, though not by much&equo;. 
 Whatever, I do not find it surprising that Lacan admired Augustine, and credits him with  foreshadowing psychoanalysis ( Ecrits , 20). 
 In discussing a different though related issue, Lacan observes that &bquo;the latest developments in modern thought on language&equo; are only a rediscovery of what was already known to Augustine, who &bquo;orients his entire dialectic around these three poles, error, mistake, ambiguity of speech&equo;. 
 This is especially significant given that, according to Lacan, &bquo;Every emission of speech is always, up to a certain point, under an inner necessity to err&equo; (Seminar , ii. 
 249, 260, 264; my emphasis). 
 Or, as Augustine might have put it, language is, of its (fallen) nature, always potentially perverse. 
 For sure then, the post/modern, in dismantling and displacing some of the ideological formations of the Enlightenment, Romanticism, and modernism, finds itself in a paradoxical but illuminating relationship with the early modern. 
 One way of putting this would be to say that with the deconstruction of these intervening cultural developments, we can see the early modern clearly once again. 
 This is emphatically not the claim I am making here. 
 For one thing, those intervening formulations have been profoundly determining of our own culture and consciousness, and their influence cannot be erased; even deconstructed, they continue to exert an influence. 
 It is not just that there survive undeconstructed residues of, say, Romanticism and modernism, or that the constructed forms echo still within the deconstructed (although they clearly do survive in these ways); it is also that they exert an influence in and as  their newly deconstructed state. 
 The recent past informs the post/modern, even or especially as the latter is changing our understanding of that past. 
 I would say rather that, both despite and because of the obvious and considerable differences, post/modernism is helping us to understand again what the early modern period already knew but in a quite different form: identity is essentially  informed by what it is not. 
 It also helps us to see that if (as was apparent in the early seventeenth century) identity is clearly constituted by the structures of power, of position, allegiance, and service, then any disturbance within, or of, identity could be as dangerous to that order as to the individual subject. 
 Hooker, in a now famous passage, asked: &bquo;see we not plainly that obedience of creatures unto the law of nature is the stay of the whole world?&equo; 
 ( Laws , i. 157). 
 Equally plainly, in this view disobedience is literally world-shattering; to transgress or deviate from the law of nature, to &bquo;fail, or swerve&equo; (i. 185) from one's allotted course, is a perversion which brings ruin not only to the transgressive agent, but to every other dependent entity. 
 The metaphysical construction of subjectivity is at once an admission and production of its disruptive potential, a disruption in and of the very terms of its construction. 
 It also suggests, paradoxically,  that the less autonomous individuality is thought to be, the more it might be marked by a potentially subversive agency. 
 But this is to anticipate the argument; for the moment I want only to observe that a conception of the self as socially and/or metaphysically constituted produces one idea of transgression, and that of the self as ideally (if not actually) unified and autonomous, quite another.  
 Early Modern: Cross-Dressing in Early Modern England 
 In Surpassing the Love of Men  Lillian Faderman records two separate cases of women in France in the sixteenth century who were punished tor using transvestite disguise and deploying dildos in their lesbian relations.&equo; 
 From one, modern, point of view, these women's transgression is suspect. 
 I am not referring to the conservative perspective which condemns sexual deviance per se , but to another viewpoint, one which might actually endorse deviance in principle, at least if it were seen as a quest for authentic selfhood of the kind explored in Chapter 3. 
 But here, precisely, is the problem; even (or especially) from this radical perspective, the women's behaviour is seen as inauthentic, not truly transgressive: in their use of men's clothing and the dildo they were trying to imitate precisely that masculine order which they should have been escaping or at least repudiating. 
 In short, their transgression was motivated by false consciousness. 
 That at any rate is how those who are viewed as their modern day counterparts are regarded by the heroine of Rubyfruit Jungle  (above, Chapter 3); and the anonymous interviewee cited by Esther Newton: &bquo;I hate games! 
 I hate role playing! 
 It's so ludicrous that certain lesbians, who despise men, become the exact replicas of them!&equo; 
 (&bquo;The Mythic Mannish Lesbian&equo;, 7). 
 But the question remains: why were those two Frenchwomen in the sixteenth century found so threatening? 
 One of them was sentenced to be burned alive, and the other hanged, punishments dictated, apparently, not by their sexuality as such but their transvestism and use of the dildo &mdash; at once, I want to suggest, appropriations of masculinity, inversions of it, and substitutions for it. 
 I have already explored in relation to Gide and others the kind of rebellion whose test they retrospectively failed, namely, transgression as a quest for authenticity: underpinning and endorsing the philosophy of individualism, it suggests that in defying a repressive social order we can dis-cover (and so be true  to) our real  selves. 
 For convenience of reference I shall call this idea of transgression humanist.  
 As I have tried to show, the significance for our culture of humanist transgression, this escape from repression into the affirmation of one's true self can hardly be overestimated. 
 But its prevalence has led us to misconceive both the significance and practice of transgression in the earlier modern period, and also in some of our own contemporary subcultures. 
 What intrigues me about that earlier period, especially its drama, is a mode of transgression which finds expression through the inversion and perversion of just those pre-existing categories and structures which its humanist counterpart seeks to transcend, to be liberated from; a mode of transgression which seeks not an escape from existing structures but rather a subversive reinscription within them, and in the process their dislocation or displacement. 
 I call this &bquo;transgressive reinscription&equo;, a concept elaborated shortly in relation to the transvestite. 
 Other examples in the Renaissance include the malcontent who haunts the very power structure which has alienated him, seeking reinscription within it but at the same time demystifying it, operating within and subverting it at the same time; the revengers whose actions constitute an even more violent bid for reinscription within the very society which has alienated and dispossessed them; the assertive women, the &bquo;women on top&equo; described by Natalie Zemon Davis who simultaneously appropriate, exploit, and undermine masculine discourse. 
 Humanist transgression in the name of authenticity has never been able to comprehend this other kind of transgression, that performed in the name of inversion, perversion, and reinscription. 
 Transgressive Mimesis: Faustus and Vagabonds 
 Stephen Greenblatt draws upon several of the containment arguments outlined above (Chapter 6) in his pioneering study Renaissance Self-Fashioning . 
 In this immensely rewarding contribution to Renaissance studies, he argues that Marlowe's heroes remain, in effect, contained. 
 Essentially, they remain embedded in what they oppose: &bquo;they simply reverse the paradigms and embrace what the society brands as evil. 
 In so doing, they imagine themselves set in diametrical opposition to their society where in fact they have unwittingly accepted its crucial structural elements.&equo; 
 In Faustus  for instance &bquo;the blasphemy pays homage to the power it insults&equo; (pp. 209, 212). 
 Greenblatt has in mind here that extraordinary moment when Faustus seals his pact with the devil by  uttering Christ's dying words on the cross: &bquo;consummatum est&equo;. 
 Faustus wilfully ends himself; he sells his soul to the devil. 
 Creation recoils; his blood congeals. 
 Via the expression of a perverse masochism, with its disturbing mix of abjection and arrogance, this act, in one sense the supreme antithesis of everything Christ died for &mdash; he died after all to save us all &mdash; is identified as Christlike. 
 Is not this transgression contained, the unintended reverence paid by the sacrilegious to the sacred? 
 Or is it rather a transgressive reinscription, a demonic perversion of the sacred? 
 What else, after all, was Christ in his death but the keenest image of abjection and arrogance, the epitome of that transgressive masochism which has played such an important part in making and unmaking our culture, not least in the figure of the martyr, and which figures over and again in the cultural depictions of the crucifix? 
 Via the dynamic of the perverse, Faustus violates Christianity in the name and image of Christ; assimilating Christ to his opposite he discloses that opposite within Christ. 
 Similarly, as I have argued elsewhere, this play collapses God into his antithesis, those contemporary secular tyrants who were legitimating their injustice in the name and image of God. 
 What we witness here is something resembling the Freudian proposition that the repressed returns via the very images, structures, and mechanisms of repression itself: the words which consummate the renewal of man, his salvation, these words return to signify the opposite of salvation which is damnation, and they signify also the desire which only damnation can acknowledge and which salvation must repress. 
 Consider another, quite different instance of transgressive reinscription. 
 The late G&aacute;0mini Salg&aacute;0do once described the vagabonds of the Elizabethan low-life pamphlets as follows: 
 Seen through the disapproving eyes of respectable citizens they were nothing but a disorderly and disorganized rabble, dropouts from the social ladder. 
 But seen from within, they appear to be like nothing so much as a mirror-image of the Elizabethan world picture: a little world, tightly organised into its own ranks and with its own rules, as rigid in its own way as the most elaborate protocol at court or ritual in church. 
 ( Cony-Catchers , 13) 
 From the respectable view, these rogues were merely the dregs of civilization &mdash; potentially dangerous, it is true, but in no way a part of  the true social order. 
 From another view they comprise a mirror-image of that order. 
 But if the second view is accurate do not the rogues become another clear instance of transgression contained, of a subculture which has internalized the structures and values of the dominant culture? 
 Are they not paradoxically reproducing the laws which exclude and oppress them, even as they seem to be escaping and subverting those laws? 
 Not exactly, because this very mimicry of the dominant, be it a literary trope or cultural actuality, involved a scandalous inversion. 
 In the words of one contemporary observer: &bquo;these cheaters turned the cat in the pan, giving to diverse vile patching shift s an honest and godly title, calling it by the name of law&hellip; to the destruction of the good labouring people&equo; (Salg&aacute;0do, Cony-Catchers , 15). 
 And feeding back through that inversion is an equally scandalous interrogation of the dominant order being mimicked; civil society is shown to be rooted in a like corruption. 
 If this subculture imitates the dominant from below, it also thereby employs a strategy which embarrasses the dominant. 
 Even as civil society endlessly displaces corruption from the social body as a whole on to its low life, the latter reveals both the original source and full extent of corruption within the dominant itself (pp. 16, 174). 
 Inversion becomes a kind of transgressive mimesis: the subculture, even as it imitates, reproducing itself in terms of its exclusion, also demystifies, producing a knowledge of the dominant which excludes it, this being a knowledge which the dominant has to suppress in order to rule. 
 Cross Dressing 
 We have seen already how the most significant senses of &bquo;perversion, in the early period do not define a sexual pathology in the modern sense. 
 As a divergence or deviation from, perversion was also a contradiction of. 
 Similarly, &bquo;inversion&equo; could signify reversal of position and/or reversal of direction, both being inimical to effective government and social control. 
 So it is worth recalling at the outset of this discussion that it is in these senses that the female cross-dresser of the early seventeenth century could be described as an &bquo;invert&equo; or &bquo;pervert&equo;, and hardly at all  in the sense of those words as coined and popularized by the nineteenth-century sexologists and, later, psychoanalysis. 
 We might also usefully recall that to cross is not only to traverse, but to mix (as in to crossbreed) and to contradict (as in to cross someone); also that cross-dressing potentially involves both inversion and displacement of gender binaries. 
 Again we are confronted with a system of control in part generating the terms, the concepts, and the space of its own negation. 
 The female transvestite was indeed a deeply disturbing figure in the early seventeenth century.&equo; 
 Certain cultural distinctions were breaking down and in the anxiety which this provoked we can read the effects of tar-reaching historical change. 
 As Lisa Jardine has recently reminded us, in the obsession with dress and what it signified socially, we witness contemporary tensions and struggles between classes, between residual and emergent cultures, between the mercantile order and what it was actually (or seemed to be) replacing, between rank and wealth, between innate and fiscal value ( Still Harping , 141 &mdash; 2, 1 50). 
 So before examining the challenge of the female transvestite, we need to consider the more general attitudes to dress and what it signified. 
 Contemporary anxieties found expression in two main kinds of attack: the one on the dress violations of the emergent (middle) class, the other on the insubordinate (female) sex. 
 William Perkins sets out the conventional position vis-&agrave;-vis  class. 
 Dress, he says, 
 must be answerable to our estate and dignitie, for distinction of order and degree in the societies of men. 
 This use of attire, stands by the very ordinance of God; who, as he hath not sorted all men to all places, so he will have men to fitte themselves and their attire, to the qualitie of their proper places, to put a difference betweene themselves and others&hellip; 
 By which it appeares, that many in these daies do greatly offend&hellip; 
 The Artificer commonly goes clad like the Yeoman: the Yeoman like the Gentleman: the Gentleman as the Nobleman: the Nobleman as the Prince: which bringeth great confusion, and utterly overturneth the order which God hath set in the states and conditions of men. 
 ( Pioneer Works , 210 &mdash; 11) 
 Dress underwrites not only class differences but national and racial ones also, and Perkins has harsh words for those who adopt the fashion of other countries: &bquo;this one sinne is so common among us, that it hath branded our English people with the blacke mark of the vainest and  most newfangled people under heaven&equo; (p. 211). 
 He also castigates those who use cosmetics &bquo;thereby making themselves seeme that which, indeede they are not&equo;, and practising what &bquo;is most abominable in the very light of nature, and much more by the light of Gods word&equo; (p. 214). 
 Accompanying the association between dress and class was that between dress and gender. 
 This is Stubbes: 
 Our apparel was given us as a sign distinctive to discern betwixt sex and sex, and therefore for one to wear the apparel of another sex, is to participate with the same, and to adulterate the verity of his own kind. 
 (Anatomy, sig. 
 &lsqb;F5&rsqb;) 
 Thus the ideology of gender difference was just as fundamental as that of class in securing the social order. 
 In fact patriarchy, class, and hierarchy all presupposed a law of gender difference which was at once divinely, naturally, and socially laid down, the law descending from the first through the second to the third. 
 As we shall see, it is against and (again) in terms of this metaphysic that dress violation occurred. 
 Not surprisingly then, class and gender anxieties interrelated. 
 In a letter of 25 January 1620 Sir John Chamberlain remarks a very significant event in the contemporary cross-dressing controversy: James I's instruction to the clergy to suppress women doing it. 
 The king is reported as having told the clergy that they must reproach the practice &bquo;vehemently and bitterly&equo;, and if this did not succeed, he would take further measures. 
 Chamberlain refers to this in the same breath as mentioning an argument between the Marquess Buckingham and Hamilton over &bquo;the selling of honours and abasing ancient nobility, by new advancements&equo;. 
 Class and sexual disruption suggest each other, and with this conclusion: &bquo;The truth is the world is very far out of order&equo; ( Letters , ii. 
 286 &mdash; 9). 
 Though Perkins, Stubbes, and Chamberlain hardly convey this, the controversy over dress was no less complex than the social shift s which provoked it. 
 No simple transgression/containment model was at work. 
 And nor can we reduce the controversy to a straightforward clash between the new and the old orders. 
 For one thing, as Jardine points out, while on the one hand the shift of wealth to the mercantile classes was leading to the break-up of the dress code, and enabling the socially mobile to appropriate, for purposes of inclusion, what were supposed to be signs of their exclusion, it was also the case that those who had &bquo;arrived&equo; socially often wanted to enforce the code against those who had not. 
 Further, Baldwin discerns in the controversy an overlap of  class anxieties and pragmatic political considerations &mdash; for example the wish to encourage home industries and discourage the buying of foreign goods ( Sumptuary Legislation , ch. 5, &bquo;The Reign of Elizabeth&equo;). 
 The situation was further complicated by those like Stubbes and Perkins who saw dress contusion as symptomatic of impending social collapse, and those like James I whose hatred of female cross-dressing introduced a misogynistic factor which antedated current social anxiety yet found a powerful focus in it. 
 To the modern reader the stipulated dress codes for different classes and persons of different prestige and status seem bizarre and impossibly complicated (see for instance those reprinted in Jardine, Still Harping , 143 &mdash; 4). 
 But their very strangeness also helps us see how transgression is produced by the measures taken to contain it: the more elaborate the classifications, the more opportunity there was to transgress, and, quite possibly, the greater the attraction of transgression. 
 Whatever, it eventually became impossible to ensure compliance. 
 Theatrical Transgression 
 A significant focus for the controversy was the theatre, which, like the transvestite, was seen both to epitomize and to promote contemporary forces of disruption in and through its involvement with cross-dressing. 
 There was, for example, the general cultural disturbance generated by the theatrical emphasis on artifice, disguise, and role-playing. 
 Its significance can be gauged in part by looking at the range of objections to the theatre as a place which subverted metaphysical fixity. 
 To begin with the players were seen to undermine the idea that one's identity and place were a function of what one essentially was &mdash; what God had made one. 
 The idea of a God-given nature and destiny had the corollary that nothing so essentially predetermined could or should ever change. 
 Constant change was worse still; in the words of one satirist, the scandal of the player was not so much that he disguised his real self in playing; rather he had no self apart from that which he was playing: &bquo;The Statute hath done wisely to acknowledge him a Rogue and errant, tor his chiefe essence is, A daily Counterfeit &hellip; 
 His &lsqb;profession&rsqb; is compounded of all Natures, all humours, all professions. 
 ''&equo; The association here of the player and the rogue is significant. 
 Both were itinerants and masterless men, sometimes both subjected to the same vagrancy  laws (alternatively the player might be a royal servant &mdash; an interesting opposition in itself). 
 They transgressed fixity not only because they were without fixed abode, but also because they lacked the identity which, in a hierarchical society, was essentially conferred by one's place in that society. 
 And there was a further link between rogues, masterless men, and the players; according to some observers the theatres quite literally brought them into association, being the place &bquo;for vagrant persons, Masterless men, thieves&hellip; contrivers of treason, and other idle and dangerous persons to meet together&equo; (Chambers, Elizabethan Stage , iv. 
 322). 
 Again we see the same anxiety: social stability depended crucially on people staying just as they were (identity), where they were (location), and doing what they always had done (calling). 
 When the rogue meets the player two lawless identities converge. 
 This concern with unfixed identity was not unique to the theatre; society and politics more generally contained a theatrical dimension, what Greenblatt calls &bquo;the theatricalisation of culture&equo;. 
 Renaissance courts involved theatricality in the sense of both disguise and histrionic self-presentation, while court manuals and rhetorical handbooks offered &bquo;an integrated rhetoric of the self, a model for the formation of an artificial identity&equo; ( Renaissance Self-Fashioning , 162). 
 And dissimulation was of course essential for the practice of realpolitik . 
 In the theatre was a model, indeed a sustained exploration, of the role-playing which was so important for social mobility, the appropriation and successful deployment of power. 
 It follows that the recurring emphasis within Elizabethan and Jacobean plays on life itself as a process of playing was not merely theatrical projection; the world as a stage, life as artifice, and so on; these were ideas which the theatre derived from, as well as conveyed to, its culture. 
 Louis Montrose points out a fascinating consequence of this: &bquo;If the world is a theatre and the theatre is an image of the world, then by reflecting upon its own artifice, the drama is holding the mirror up to nature&equo; (Montrose, &bquo;Purpose of Playing&equo;, 57). 
 Another, related, charge against the players is that in their dress violations they &mdash; again like the &bquo;street&equo; transvestites &mdash; transgressed the natural and fixed order of things by wilfully confusing distinctions which it was thought imperative should be kept distinct, especially within the categories of rank, class, and gender. 
 For menials to play those of a higher rank and breeding seemed a deep violation of the principle of fixed division on which civilization rested. 
 In Act v, Scene v, of Jonson's Volpone  Mosca enters dressed as a gentleman; it is a moment which might be seen to mark the arrival of the urban impostor, he or she who knows that mimicry and impersonation possess the  potential not just to deceive and usurp, but also to subvert social differentiation and identity itself: 
 MOSCA. 
 But what am I? 
 VOLPONE: 'Fore heav'n, a brave clarissimo ; thou becomest it! pity thou wert not born one. 
 MOSCA.If I hold My made one, 'twill be well. 
 (v. v. 2 &mdash; 5) 
 Mosca prevaricates beautifully. 
 It is a reply which is at once deferential and contemptuous, self-effacing and arrogant. 
 'Twill be well because he is not the real thing, never could be, and is not even now presuming to be; but conversely, 'twill be well because the imitation, the travesty, of the real thing can also usurp it and to all intents and purposes  become it. 
 What price then that metaphysical guarantee of social differentiation when it is so easily abolished in the confusion it was supposed to preempt and render impossible? 
 It is a concentrated, fleeting moment of ambiguity and irony (irony and ambiguity tending to be intrinsic to transgressive reinscription and alien to humanist transgression). 
 It is also a moment of appropriation in which there surfaces the play's underlying knowledge, at once exhilarating, ambivalent, appalling, and violent; a knowledge which incites yet also fears that riot of the perverse, the antisocial and the anti-natural which are Volpone . 
 Of course the power of superficial difference goes deep; when Volpone is discovered attempting to rape Celia he laments: &bquo;I am unmasked, unspirited, undone&equo; (iii. 
 vii. 
 277). 
 To be unmasked is  to be unspirited as well as undone. 
 To lose one's cover is to lose one's soul, to be undone in the sense of socially ruined and spiritually taken apart. 
 Can we attribute this perception entirely to Volpone's and Mosca's perversity? 
 Not exactly, if only because it is precisely at this point that Volpone  shows how the normal is parasitic upon the perverse. 
 To be sure we are seeing it in a grotesquely parodied form, but what leads to Celia being nearly raped is nothing less than the prevailing structures of patriarchal and heterosexual authority: it is after all her hitherto paranoidly jealous husband who has literally dragged her to Volpone's bed. 
 One further aspect of dress violation associated with the theatre also contravened divine and natural law: the abomination of boys dressing as girls. 
 For John Rainoldes the boy transvestite destroyed the fragile moral restraint containing an anarchic male sexuality; the boy incited his male audience into every kind of sexual excess. 
 Rainoldes seems to  have imagined adult male sexuality not just as anarchic, but as satanically polymorphous, capable of engaging in the forbidden with alarming ease. 
 So, in seeing the transvestite boy, the male member of the audience might be moved to lascivious thoughts about women, which then transfer to the boy himself. 
 (In the light of which it is pleasing to discover that in 1566, when Rainoldes was a 17-year-old student at Oxford, he acted the part of a female in a play composed tor Queen Elizabeth &mdash; see Paine, The Learned Men , 23). 
 Rainoldes apart, the transgressions associated with the boy players, be they actual or imagined, rendered the theatrical self-consciousness surrounding transvestism complex and shifting; it provoked questions teasingly unanswerable: for example &mdash; and this is a question which remains intriguing for us today &mdash; which, or how many, of the several gender identities embodied in any one figure are in play at any one time? 
 There were factors at play in the association of theatrical cross-dressing and sexual transgressions. 
 Not only did prostitutes frequent the theatre, but the street transvestite was sometimes associated with prostitution and possibly sodomy: Henriques notes a regulation dating from 1480 forbidding prostitutes to dress as men in public, and remarks: &bquo;This masquerading presumably would have meant an added inducement to sodomy&equo; ( Prostitution and Society , ii. 
 88). 
 It he is right, then stage transgressions seemed to have spoken to immediate temptations in diverse ways. 
 The Roaring girl and Hic Mulier  
 Middleton and Dekker's The Roaring Girl  (1608 &mdash; 11), a play with a transvestite hero/ine called Moll Cutpurse, and the 1620 pamphlet controversy over cross-dressing both include attacks on the fraudulence of masculinity and the exploitativeness of gender inequality. 
 In both play and pamphlet the contemporary sexual metaphysic is turned inside out: gender division is recognized not as a divinely sanctioned natural order, but as the contingent basis of an oppressive social order. 
 Correspondingly the representation of gender inversion generates an interrogation both of the sexual metaphysic and of th&eacute; social order. 
 Moll Cutpurse is variously described as one who &bquo;strays so from her kind/Nature repents she made her&equo; (i. ii. 
 211 &mdash; 12); who some say &bquo;is a  man/And some both man and woman&equo; (ii. 
 i. 190 &mdash; 1), and yet others that she is &bquo;a codpiece-daughter&equo; (ii. 
 ii. 
 89) 
 a thing 
 One knows not how to name: her birth began 
 Ere she was all made: 'tis woman more than man, 
 Man more than woman, and ( which to none can hap ) 
 The sun gives her two shadows to one shape 
 (i. ii. 
 128 &mdash; 33, my emphasis) 
 And yet this creature who so violates the natural order and traditional gender divisions by dressing as a man also does things better than a man: &bquo;I should draw first and prove the quicker man&equo;, she says (iv. 
 i. 76) &mdash; and she does. 
 In the process she attacks masculinity as a charade, asserting its failure in its own sexual terms (ii.i. 
 290 ff.), something which the language of the play echoes elsewhere, facetiously, but defensively too (cf. 
 II. 
 i. 326 ff.; ii. 
 ii. 
 75 ff.; iii. 
 i. 142 ff.). 
 Moll also otters what in this period is an exceptional awareness of the prostitute as someone sexually exploited because of economic and other kinds of social subjection: 
 In thee I defy all men, their worst hates, 
 And their best flatteries, all their golden witchcrafts, 
 With which they entangle the poor spirits of fools. 
 Distressed needlewomen and trade-fallen wives, 
 Fish that must needs bite or themselves be bitten, 
 Such hungry things as these may soon be took 
 With a worm fastened on a golden hook: 
 Those are the lecher's food, his prey, he watches 
 For quarrelling wedlocks, and poor shifting sisters. 
 (iii.i.90 &mdash; 8) 
 Recognizing all this, and being shown too where the power lies in this social order, the politics of inversion become persuasive, perhaps irresistible; this is Moll, about to thrash the predatory Laxton: &bquo;I scorn to prostitute myself to a man, /that can prostitute a man to me&equo; (iii. 
 i. 109 &mdash; 10). 
 Moll's denunciation of Laxton before she beats him up shows that the thrashing is partly in revenge for his not untypical masculine blend of misogyny and licentiousness (cf. ii. 
 ii. 
 252 &mdash; 5) to which of course the prostitute can indeed testify that it these things appear incompatible &mdash; isn't misogyny a kind of hatred, and licentiousness a kind of love, albeit a debased one? &mdash; in reality they go hand in hand. 
 It is in these ways that The Roaring Girl  begins to disclose how,  because of the complex connections between sexuality, gender, and class, and specifically between sexual and economic exploitation, economic and political anxieties can be displaced into the domain of the sexual and conversely, the sexual comes to possess enormous signifying power (though very different from that attributed to sexuality by the radical humanist). 
 As I have already remarked, the king himself intervened in 1620 to try to eliminate female transvestism. 
 He like many others at that time felt that female transvestites were usurping male authority. 
 This is indeed exactly what Moll does throughout the play, and especially when she beats up Laxton. 
 But perhaps more importantly the transvestite was contributing to a knowledge and a culture which undermined the discursive formations of authority itself, doing so through her perverse reinscription within those formations. 
 Similarly in the pamphlet controversy. 
 Hic Mulier, the voice of female transvestites in the most interesting pamphlet, Haec Vir  (1620), insists that gender difference is an effect of custom only. 
 Custom becomes the cause where once it was only the effect. 
 This inversion is also an instance of what was to become the classic move in ideological demystification: the metaphysical is displaced by, and then collapsed into, the social. 
 Shorn of its metaphysical sanction, law in the Renaissance was always in danger of losing its prescriptive power. 
 Nothing is more absurd, nothing more foolish, says Hic Mulier, than custom. 
 In tact, it is &bquo;an idiot&equo;. 
 The radical implications of this assertion can be gleaned from an observation of Montaigne's: &bquo;We may easily discern, that only custom makes that seem impossible unto us, which is not so&equo; ( Essays , trans. 
 Florio, i. 239). 
 Throughout the pamphlet Hic Mulier seems to be in sympathy with this remark of Montaigne's, but nowhere is her appropriation of the idea more challenging than in the way she dissolves both law and ideological fixity into a celebration of change and transformation, and, by implication, a celebration of her potential rather than her fixed nature: &bquo;Nor do I in my delight of change otherwise than as the whole world does&equo; (sig. 
 B1). 
 At a time when change was almost synonymous with evil, or at least decline, this was indeed provocative. 
 Hic Mulier is not only shameless but, as Sandra Clark has recently pointed out, she suggests that shame itself &bquo;is a concept framed by men to subordinate women to the dictates of arbitrary custom&equo; (&bquo;Controversy&equo;, 175). 
 Hic Mulier claims too that women are as reasonable as men. 
 And then comes the crucial claim: &bquo;We are as tree born as men, have as free election, and as tree spirits; we are compounded of like parts, and may with like liberty  make benefit of our creations&equo; (sig. 
 B3). 
 And it is a claim whose force in this instance comes through a demystification generated across inversion. 
 But consider now a misgiving voiced by Linda Woodbridge and shared by many others: &bquo;To me the one unsatisfying feature of the otherwise stimulating transvestite movement is that it had to be transvestite: Renaissance women so tar accepted the masculine rules of the game that they felt they had to look masculine to be &bquo;free''&equo; ( Women and the English Renaissance , 145). 
 For understandable reasons Woodbridge seems to prefer the &bquo;hermaphroditic vision&equo; (p. 145 and cf. p. 317). 
 The transvestite and the hermaphrodite: both were disturbing images; perhaps they are less so now. 
 Potentially the hermaphrodite dissolves gender difference and, at least in its associated idea of androgyny, has become acceptable. 
 Even in the Renaissance the figure could &bquo;symbolise the essential oneness of the sexes&equo; (p. 140), and, with reference back to Plato's Symposium , the recovery of an original lost unity (itself intrinsically sexual). 
 The idea remains alive today, of course; I have already referred to Kaja Silverman's observation that the notion of sexual identity as an original androgynous whole, similar to that projected by Aristophanes, is central to the psychoanalytic theories of Jacques Lacan. 
 But the transvestite? 
 S/he is a strange and disturbing figure still, though now for different reasons from in the Renaissance. 
 Isn't s/he a figure who has exchanged one kind of incompleteness for another? 
 If misgivings persist they are not exactly moral. 
 Isn't it rather that, as Woodbridge implies, the transvestite seems to be a victim of false consciousness, and by switching gender roles rather than dissolving them reinforces the very sexual division which s/he finds oppressive? 
  So the transvestite fails the test of humanist transgression. 
 But it the hermaphrodite threatens the binarism of gender through ambiguous unity, the female transvestite of the early seventeenth century positively disrupts that same scheme by usurping the master side of the opposition. 
 To invoke again the earlier distinction between different kinds of transgression, the transvestite represents a subversive reinscription within, rather than a transcendence of, an existing order, while the hermaphrodite is often appropriated as a symbol of just such a transcendence. 
 Essentially the assertive female cross-dresser inverted the metaphysics of difference: from being a divine law inscribed essentially in each of God's subjects and which knowledge of self would confirm, sexual identity and sexual difference are shifted irretrievably into the domain of custom, of the social, of that which can be contested. 
 Perhaps this is the mode of transgression denied to the hermaphrodite, at least to the extent that s/he is associated with the mythological, the presocial, the transcendent. 
 Containment Theory and Transvestism 
 What I have just offered have been partial readings of the Haec Vir  pamphlet and The Roaring Girl , partial not in the sense (at least this is not what I'm confessing) of being distortions of the texts, but rather readings that focus upon textual elements which can be correlated with oppositional cultural elements within Jacobean society, and consequently possible audience positions and reading responses. 
 But the representation of the transvestite in the pamphlet and the theatre is part of a cultural process whose complexity is worth exploring further. 
 The complexity I am concerned with is not that supposed intrinsic property of the text which politically motivated critics allegedly distort (in biased readings) and impartial critics transparently represent (in long readings). 
 It is the complexity which is first and foremost a social process, and within which the text was, and still is, implicated. 
 Viewing the text in this way raises the question of the containment of transgression, since both play and pamphlet have been seen to move toward a closure which contains &mdash; even eradicates &mdash; their challenging elements. 
 The Haec Vir  pamphlet ends, notoriously, with Hic Mulier declaring that women like her have only become masculine because men have become effeminate. 
 They have taken up men's cast-off garments in order to &bquo;support a difference, (sig. 
 C2) &mdash; in effect to maintain sexual difference itself. 
 And if men revert to being masculine, the Hic Mulier figure continues, women will once again become feminine and subordinate. 
 Actually this conclusion barely constitutes containment. 
 To see this  argument as somehow cancelling what went before is probably to interpret the pamphlet according to modern and anachronistic notions of authorial intention, character utterance, and textual unity (all three notions privileging what is said finally as being more truthful than what went before). 
 The Hic Mulier figure (an abstraction) is a vehicle for a variety of defences of the transvestite, radical and  conservative, and there is no good reason, given the genre, to privilege the one over the others as more truthful, more sincere, more representative, or to be dismayed that some of these arguments are incompatible with each other. 
 Presumably if the different defences had been split between several Hic Mulier figures the problem (for us) would disappear &mdash; again alerting us to certain, not necessarily appropriate, interpretative assumptions. 
 But it remains true that this culminating defence, conservative and apologetic as it is, still partakes of the same fundamental challenge to gender division as the other defences. 
 To state that gender difference can be and is being  maintained through cross-dressing and inversion is to maintain or imply the crucial claim even while apparently surrendering it: the difference in question is capable of working in terms of custom and culture (and is thereby contestable) rather than nature and divine law (which are immutable). 
 Within this apologetic (ironic?) defence then, sexual difference is sustained by the very inversion which divine law forbids, and the fact that it can be so sustained is simultaneously a repudiation of the claim that sexual difference is itself dictated by divine or natural law. 
 The submission ironically incorporates &mdash; contains &mdash; the original challenge. 
 The Roaring Girl  is a stronger instance of containment. 
 Right at the outset we are alerted to the tact that Mary Frith, the real-life cross-dresser on whom the play is based, is being given a more virtuous image than she in fact possessed (dedication, ll. 19 ff.; prologue, ll. 26 &mdash; 7). 
 For sure she creates disruption, signifies abnormality, and incites lewdness in others. 
 But she does not share the criminality of the real-life Frith who was apparently arrested several times, and variously recorded as being a bawd, thief, receiver, gang-leader, and whore; the character Moll Cutpurse definitely is not these things, and in the play-world is only falsely accused of being so. 
 So whereas the deviance of Mary Frith remained in certain respects implacably immoral and antisocial, in the figure of Moll Cutpurse that deviance is harnessed as the moral conscience of the selfsame society whose gender categories she transgresses. 
 More specifically, Frith/Moll is appropriated for a partial  critique of patriarchal law, sexual exploitation, and aristocratic culture. 
 She thereby also helps regenerate society and especially its ailing patriarchal basis: &bquo;MOLL. 
 Father and son, I ha&equo; done you simple service here' (v. ii. 
 206). 
 At the same time she remains &bquo;isolated from the very social structure which her courage and vitality have done so much to enliven and renew&equo; (Rose, &bquo;Women in Men's Clothing&equo;, 389 &mdash; 90). 
 In these respects Frith/Moll is represented in the tradition of the warrior woman and the folk figure of Long Meg of Westminster, both of whom distinguish true morality from false, the proper man from the braggart, and finally submit to the former (Shepherd, Amazons , esp. 
 70 &mdash; 2). 
 What this suggests is that if the demonizing of the deviant other leads to suppression and even extermination, the colonizing of the deviant involves an assimilation which re-forms, ethically and literally, even as it re-presents. 
 The play reconstitutes Mary Frith as Moll Cutpurse, who in turn is used to reconstitute a social order while remaining on its margins &mdash; reformed and reforming but not finally incorporated; hence Moll's stern yet haunting parting injunction to the assembled &bquo;gentlemen&equo; of the final scene: &bquo;I pursue no pity: /Follow the law&equo; (252 &mdash; 3). 
 In this case containment is not the reaction of power after, and in response to, the event of subversion. 
 Nor is subversion the ruse of power. 
 Rather subversion and containment are always in play, each an intrinsic dimension of social process and in a dynamic interrelationship which their binary conception misconstrues. 
 Thus containment can effect rather than defeat change (and this does not presuppose the desirability or otherwise of that change; it might be reaction or progress or, as in this play, complex elements of both with each differently appropriated for different audience positions). 
 Rather than seeing containment as that which pre-empts and defeats transgression we need to see both containment and transgression as potentially productive processes. 
 The Roaring Girl  presents a process in which containment of the deviant forms the basis of one social traction offering a critique of, and taking power trom, another. 
 In a more radical dynamic, containment, in the very process of repressing one kind of subversive knowledge, actually produces another. 
 It is to the latter process that I now turn.  
 Transvestism and Masculinity : Love's Cure 
 The most interesting theatrical containment of the transvestite challenge occurs in Fletcher's little-known Love's Cure  (1624?). 
 Indeed, one wonders if the play was written as a conservative response to the controversy, since it directly addresses the most challenging claim or implication of the radical transvestite, namely, that gender division and inequality are a consequence not of divine or natural law but of social custom. 
 The play centres on the severe cultural disturbance generated by the fact that Clara, a girl, has been brought up as a boy and wants to remain one, while her brother, Lucio, has been brought up as a girl which he wants to remain, despite the fact that society is now demanding that both return to their normal gender ascriptions. 
 It is a humorous situation and one played up as such. 
 But the play also acknowledges quite clearly that what is at stake is nothing less than the legitimacy of the whole social order, hinging as it does on a &bquo;naturally&equo; sanctioned law of sexual difference. 
 This is a play about the perversion of nature by culture (or &bquo;custom&equo; &mdash; i. ii. 
 47, ii. 
 ii. 
 95 &mdash; 7) with the eventual triumph of nature: &bquo;Nature (though long kept back) wil have her owne&equo; (iv. 
 iv. 
 61 &mdash; 2; cf. ii. 
 ii. 
 248 &mdash; 59, iv. 
 ii. 
 187 &mdash; 90, v. iii. 
 90 &mdash; 4). 
 The cultural conditioning of both Lucio and Clara seems to go deep. 
 Parents and others try yet fail to restore the children to their natural selves; the father, Alvarez, cries angrily: 
 Can strong habituall custome Work with such Magick on the mind, and manners In spight of sex and nature? (ii.ii. 140 &mdash; 2) 
 The answer is, apparently, yes. 
 But then nature succeeds where authority has failed; attraction to the opposite sex awakens the siblings' own &bquo;true&equo; natural instincts, and gender incongruities are resolved. 
 Clara switches from being aggressive to being acquiescent and Lucio does the reverse. 
 Right order prevails. 
 We might say that Love's Cure  produces transgression precisely in order to contain it, and in the most insidiously ideological way: the deviant desire which initially appeared to contradict nature is reconstituted by nature in accord with her (?) order. 
 Reconstituted, not repressed: deviant desire is effortlessly and internally transformed &mdash; not  forced &mdash; from the perverse to the natural. 
 However, in the process the very masculine code of honour which is affronted by Lucio's perverse failure of masculinity is shown to border on a perversity even more excessive than his. 
 It is as if containment, in reinstating nature over culture &mdash; that most fundamental and violent of binary oppositions &mdash; says too much about both. 
 Thus the effect of containment resembles the unintended power of the subordinates in this play who execute the commands of the powerful and of whom the Governor complains: 
 How men in high place, and authority Are in their lives and estimation wrong'd By their subordinate Ministers? yet such They cannot but imploy  (iv. 
 iii. 
 1 19 &mdash; 21, my emphasis) 
 Masculine sexuality is shown to be complex and unstably implicated within the whole social domain. 
 Either nature does not contain it or nature contains too much to be conceived any longer as natural. 
 What is especially fascinating about this text is that a rehabilitation of masculinity coexists with an ironic repudiation of it, and a critique of what might be called masculinity's cultural unconscious. 
 An urbane text, it nevertheless discloses a violent scenario &mdash; social, psychic, and sexual (what has sometimes been mistaken for decadence). 
 Most obviously and consciously there is the fact that Lucio's effeminacy, construed by Bobadillo as an affront to &bquo;heav'n, and nature, and thy Parents (ii. 
 ii. 
 22) &mdash; i.e. that powerful conjunction of divine, natural, and patriarchal law &mdash; actually embodies positive civilized virtues. 
 Lucio would, for example, willingly renounce the savage illogic whereby a bloody family feud is being perpetuated among new generations (ii. 
 ii. 
 44 ff.) and also the sword as instrument and symbol of male violence (ii. 
 iv. 
 84 ff.). 
 In return his father rages at him for his inability to become a &bquo;real&equo; man, and demands as the only acceptable proof that Lucio has regained his masculinity that he attack the very next man he sees and sexually assault the first woman (iv. 
 iii. 
 37 ff.). 
 Though conceived as an absolute, uncompromising ethical stand (&bquo;Lite's but a word, a shadow, a melting dreame, /Compar'd to essentiall, and eternall honour&equo; &mdash; v. iii. 
 124 &mdash; 5), masculine honour is also represented as straightforwardly stupid and barbaric. 
 Also, two of masculinity's basic characteristics, sexual prowess and violence, are shown to be inextricably related, as indicated for example by the conventional but still revealingly obsessive association of sword and phallus (e.g. at ii. 
 ii. 
 86 &mdash; 90 and v. iii. 
 194 &mdash; 6) and the ambiguity of &bquo;blood&equo;: at once sexual desire and what honour demands, literally, of the male opponent.  
 The internal critique is more searching still. 
 From the punning just mentioned we see that masculine sexuality is confirmed not only by women, passively, but also by other men, actively. 
 It is not so much that the culture of masculine honour is a sublimation of homosexuality,; rather masculine honour repeatedly incites what, heterosexually, it presupposes but cannot admit. 
 The differential status of men and women in confirming masculine sexuality is neatly demonstrated at the climax of the play, the arranged duel between Alvarez and Vitelli (seconded, respectively, by Lucio, now masculinized by falling in love, and Lamorall). 
 As they square up to each other the spouses of the first three men &bquo;Enter above&equo; and implore them not to fight. 
 Plea after plea fails. 
 &bquo;Are you men, or stone&equo; cries the Governor; &bquo;Men, and we'll prove it with our swords&equo; replies Alvarez (v. iii. 
 172 &mdash; 3). 
 And what honour dictates must occur between men &mdash; alliance/violence &mdash; simply overrides contrary honourable vows to women (162 &mdash; 4). 
 In tact, the women's pleas for peace only intensify the men's desire to fight, and to a sexual degree. 
 Within masculine sexuality the most significant other is the male &mdash; but it is a significance which presupposes, and is rehearsed in relation to, the female. 
 Thus when the women stop pleading for peace and resort instead to the threat of killing themselves it the fight proceeds, it is as if the currents of sexuality and violence, circulating between the men in a way which sustains sexual difference between male and female, are suddenly switched off; the threatened self-annihilation of the women is also a breaking of the circuit. 
 If they die, then the most necessary spectators and objects of masculine performance disappear. 
 But also, in this reductio ad absurdum  of masculine sexuality, men become redundant as the women threaten to perform phallic violence on themselves in the attempt to forestall male violence (Genevora to the duellists): &bquo;The first blow given betwixt you, sheathes these swords/In one anothers bosomes&equo; (177 &mdash; 8). 
 In an extraordinary speech masculinity is further shown to be rooted in a sexual violence performed inseparably against both men and women &mdash; (Vitelli to Clara): 
 When on this point, I have pearch'd thy father's soule, Ile tender thee this bloody reeking hand Drawne forth the bowels of that murtherer: If thou canst love me then, I'le marry thee, And for thy father lost, get thee a Sonne; On no condition else. 
 (104 &mdash; 9) 
 Literally, Vitelli will kill her father and replace him with a son born of her. 
 The object of the exercise is for Vitelli doubly to substitute himself  for Clara's father: first as her husband, then as himself in, and as the father of, her son. 
 But we can read/see much more in this speech. 
 Again, sword and phallus substitute for each other, but in a uniquely revealing way: not only is Vitelli's violence against Clara's father erotically identified with the sexual act performed &bquo;with&equo; her, but the disembowelment of him is aligned with her childbirth. 
 The hand he offers her is also the sword/phallus drawn reeking from the father's wounds. 
 It is a supreme displacement of the rival male via the very woman whom each struggles to possess, the one as father, the other as &bquo;lover&equo;. 
 Additionally, this promised disembowelment/birth will implicate Clara in Vitelli's violence without at all changing her status as its abject victim. 
 And of course the violence against her father is as sexual as the proposed sexual intercourse &bquo;with&equo; Clara is violent. 
 He fucks her and fucks him over. 
 This is not the first time that Vitelli has insisted to Clara that his sexual desire for her is conjoined with an equally strong desire to kill/ fuck her father (and, now, her brother): 
 He, whose tongue thus gratifies the daughter, And sister of his enemy, weares a Sword To rip the father and the brother up&hellip; 
 That my affections should promiscuously Dart love and hate at once, both worthily! (ii.ii.189 &mdash; 95) 
 Speaking of himself in the second person and now deploying the phallic innuendo of tongue as well as sword, Vitelli presents masculine sexuality as spectacle, again demanding and needing  the confirmation of his masculinity by an audience even as he conceives his masculinity in terms of spontaneous, self-generating desire and autonomous honour. 
 The opposite of honourable antagonism between men is honourable alliance, typically affirmed in the image and name of the brother. 
 But what are in one sense dramatically opposed kinds of relationship are in another simply alternative celebrations of masculinity. 
 Elsewhere in Beaumont and Fletcher's work valorous males similarly oscillate between honourable antagonism and honourable alliance, in an almost erotic state of arousal. 
 In both kinds of relationship men recognize and reinforce each other's sexuality in the triangle man &mdash; man &mdash; woman. 
 But even as men enter into relations of honourable alliance with each other, it is with an unspoken but ever-present understanding: &bquo;I don't desire you, I desire to be like you&equo;. 
 This repeated disavowal of direct desire in favour of imitative alliance is a crucial precondition of one kind of male bonding (what someone once called penises in parallel). 
 Anticipated  here is that always unstable disjunction between identification and desire upon which male bonding depends. 
 Strong Thighed Bargemen: The Erotics of Masculine Jealousy 
 Frequently in this period the representation of the man &mdash; man &mdash; woman triangle suggests that the desire which bonds men over women is as erotically invested for the men in relation to each other as for each of them in relation to the women. 
 In Beaumont and Fletcher's The Maid's Tragedy , Melantius, approving his sister's marriage to his best friend, tells her: &bquo;Sister, I joy to see you, and your choice/You look'd with my eyes when you took that man&equo; (i. ii. 
 107 &mdash; 8). 
 Another revealing recurrence in these plays is the way that male sexual jealousy, even as it is represented as obsessively heterosexual in its demands, produces eroticized images of the rival male which are inseparable from the denigration of the woman: 
 FERDINAND&hellip;. my imagination will carry me To see her in the shameful act of sin&hellip;. 
 Happily, with some strong thigh'd bargemen; Or one o'th' wood-yard, that can quoit the sledge Or toss the bar, or else some lovely squire That carries coals up to her privy lodgings&hellip;. 
 Go to, mistress! 
 &bquo;Tis not your whore's milk that shall quench my wildfire, But your whore's blood. 
 (John Webster, The Duchess of Malfi , ii. 
 v. 40 &mdash; 9) 
 In The Maid's Tragedy , when the King becomes sexually jealous of Amintor he too evokes his rival in a way which shows that the cult of masculine honour circulating in this court is ineradicably erotic (III. 
 i). 
 But should we describe this dynamic as homoerotic? 
 It certainly is erotic, but is perhaps better described, following Eve Sedgwick, as homosocial desire, if only, in the first instance, to avoid the easy but questionable assumption that what we witness here is the irruption of repressed homosexual desire as conceived by Freud. 
 This seems more like an eroticism created by rather than repressed by the social bond. 
 Even so, the question remains: why does the sexually jeaLous male envisage his rival so erotically? 
 Freud argues that the man who is sexually jealous of a woman would &bquo;not only feel pain about the woman  he loves and hatred of the man who is his rival, but also grief about the man, whom he loves unconsciously, and hatred of the woman as his rival&equo; (&bquo;Some Neurotic Mechanisms&equo;, x. 197 &mdash; 8). 
 This may indeed sometimes be so, but, as before, the early modern period may provide grounds for some cultural distinctions within and against the psychoanalytic project. 
 In Jacobean drama masculine identity requires masculine ratification. 
 At the same time, and within a heterosexual economy generally, there tends to be a profound separation between identification and desire, especially for males. 
 Thus the male is required to identify with other males but he is not allowed to desire them; indeed, identification with  should actually preclude desire for . 
 Conversely, those whom he is supposed to desire, and always in specified ways, namely women, he is discouraged from identifying with: that would equal effeminacy; so in relation to them desire for  precludes identification with. 
 For the sexually jealous male, the separate/d objects of identification and desire &mdash; the rival man and the faithless woman &mdash; have united actually  as a distorted counterpart of the forbidden  conjunction in the jealous subject between identification and desire. 
 Thus his erotic imagining of the usurping male is not the eruption of repressed homosexual desire so much as the fantasized, fearful convergence of identification and desire, precipitated by an actual convergence of their respective objects. 
 That scenario can be distinguished from another which may nevertheless overlap and converge with it: the necessary identifications of male bonding &mdash; &bquo;I desire to be like you&equo; &mdash; produce an intensity of admiration some of which just cannot help but transform into deviant desire for, rather than just honourable imitation of, &bquo;man's&equo; most significant other (i.e. man). 
 And it occurs so easily &mdash; almost passively &mdash; requiring little more than a relinquishing of the effort  of emulation, the erasure of &bquo; to be like &equo; and the surrender to what remains: &bquo; I desire&hellip; you &equo;; thus: &bquo; I desire (to be like) you &equo;. 
 Again, we can it we like describe this second scenario as homoerotic. 
 But it is like the first scenario in this: both kinds of eroticism are specific to male bonding, both occur within and against the very situations in which heterosexuality is most ardently pursued, and both are in part the consequence of heterosexual ardour. 
 To shift, as I have done in this consideration of Love's Cure , trom the transvestite to certain wider issues of desire, the &bquo;nature&equo; of masculinity, sexual jealousy, and the homoerotic, is only to follow one trajectory of transvestism itself in this period: in appropriating, inverting, and  substituting for masculinity, the female transvestite inevitably put masculinity itself &mdash; and sexual difference more generally &mdash; under scrutiny. 
 Further, in the attempted containment of transvestism ( Love's Cure ) masculinity and sexual difference are put in question in a very specific way: in the containment of one hostile knowledge another is inadvertently produced; suppression of an (in) subordinate deviance discloses other, equally disturbing deviations at the heart of the dominant; erotic deviations whose repression is a condition of domination in one of its most important forms: homosocial male bonding. 
 Finally, the transvestite challenge to masculinity and sexual difference works in terms of transgressive inversion and reinscription, not of transcendence, or the recovery of authentic selfhood. 
 &bquo;We &lsqb;i.e. women&rsqb; are as freeborn as men, have as tree election, and as free spirits&equo;, says the Hic Mulier figure, and she says it in drag . 
 Not then &mdash; to recall my point of departure in the previous chapter &mdash; knowing thyself, so much as knowing thy discursive formations &mdash; knowing them in the process of living but also inverting them; reinscribing oneself within, succumbing to, and demystifying them.  
 Post/Modern: On the Gay Sensibility, or the pervert's Revenge on Authenticity-Wilde, Genet, Orton, and Others 
 To be really modern one should have no soul. 
 (Wilde, &bquo;Maxims&equo;) 
 Will he force me to think that homosexuals have more imagination than the&hellip; others? 
 No, but they are more frequently called upon to exercise it. 
 (Andr&eacute; Gide, Journals , 1931) 
 The Elusive Homosexual Sensibility 
 Separately and in different ways, Susan Sontag and George Steiner have suggested that a (or &bquo;the&equo;) homosexual sensibility is a major influence in the formation of modern culture. 
 In 1964 Sontag wrote that &bquo;Jews and homosexuals are the outstanding creative minorities in contemporary urban culture. 
 Creative, that is, in the truest sense: they are creators of sensibilities. 
 The two pioneering forces of modern sensibility are Jewish moral seriousness and homosexual aestheticism and irony.&equo; 
 She seeks to substantiate this claim in the famous essay from which it is taken (&bquo;Notes on Camp&equo;, 290). 
 For Steiner homosexuality is it anything even more central to, and definitive of, the modern. 
 &bquo;Since about 1890&equo;, he believes, &bquo;homosexuality has played a vital part in Western culture.&equo; 
 Whereas &bquo;heterosexuality is the very essence of&hellip; classic realism&equo;, a &bquo;radical homosexuality&equo; figures in modernity, particularly in its self-referentiality and narcissism; indeed &bquo;homosexuality could be construed as a creative rejection of the philosophic and conventional realism, of the mundanity  and extroversion of classic and nineteenth century feeling&equo;. 
 Further, homosexuality in part made possible &bquo;that exercise in solipsism, that remorseless mockery of philistine common sense and bourgeois realism which is modern art&equo; (&bquo;Eros and Idiom&equo;, 115, 117, 118). 
 Steiner's association of homosexuality with narcissism, solipsism, and the refusal of referentiality obviously suggests reservations about both  modernism (as he conceives it) and the efficacy of the homosexual influence upon it, and it comes as no surprise that in his most recent book he launches a strong attack on the former. 
 Steiner now contends that two historical moments, the one epitomized in Mallarm&eacute;'s &bquo;disjunction of language from external reference&equo;, and the other in Rimbaud's &bquo;deconstruction of the self&equo; &mdash; je est un autre  (I is (an) other) &mdash; splinter the foundations of the Western tradition and precipitate it into the crisis of modernity. 
 Rimbaud would seem to be especially culpable since &bquo;the deconstructions of semantic forms, the destabilizations of meaning, as we have known them during the past decades, derive from Rimbaud's dissolution of the self&equo;. 
 Compared to these two cultural moments, &bquo;even the political revolutions and great wars in modern European history are, I would venture, of the surface&equo; ( Real Presences , 101, 94 &mdash; 6). 
 Steiner and Sontag are in a sense correct about the centrality of homosexuality to modern culture. 
 But the argument of this book is that its centrality is quite otherwise than they suggest. 
 Steiner's ludicrous generalizations stem in part from the very notion of defining cultures and history in terms of a sensibility. 
 Even a cursory look at gay history and culture suggests that the sweep and conclusions of his argument are questionable at virtually every turn, as indeed is the very notion of a homosexual sensibility. 
 Sontag's article at least has the virtue of tentativeness; it is in the form of notes (dedicated to Oscar Wilde), and acknowledges the difficulty of defining a sensibility, especially one as &bquo;fugitive&equo; as this (&bquo;Notes on Camp&equo;, 277). 
 But still questions abound: is this sensibility transcultural, or historically rooted in the (varying) histories of the representation of homosexuality? 
 Is it a direct expression of homosexuality, or an indirect expression of its repression and/or sublimation? 
 Is it defined in terms of the sexuality of (say) the individual or artist who expresses or possesses it &mdash; and does that mean that no nonhomosexual can possess/express it? 
 I shall suggest that there is a sense in which the very notion of a homosexual sensibility is a contradiction in terms. 
 I am interested in an aspect of it which exists, it at all, in terms of that contradiction &mdash; of a parodic critique of the essence of sensibility as conventionally understood. 
 Michel Foucault argues that in the modern period sex has become  definitive of the truth of our being (above, Chapter 14). 
 As such, sexuality in its normative forms constitutes a &bquo;truth&equo; connecting inextricably with other truths and norms not explicitly sexual. 
 This is a major reason why sexual deviance is found threatening: in deviating from normative truth and the &bquo;nature&equo; which underpins it, such deviance shifts and confuses the norms of truth and being throughout culture. 
 Wilde's transgressive aesthetic simultaneously confirmed and exploited this inextricable connection between the sexual and the (apparently) non-sexual, between sexual perversion and social subversion, and does so through Wilde's own version of that connection: &bquo;what paradox was to me in the sphere of thought, perversity became to me in the sphere of passion&equo; (Wilde, De Profundis , 466). 
 If I had to give a single criterion of that dubious category, the homosexual sensibility, it would be this connection between perversity and paradox &mdash; if only because it suggests why that sensibility does not exist as such. 
 As we have seen (Chapters 1 and 3), Wilde's transgressive aesthetic writes desire into a discourse of liberation inseparable from an inversion and displacement of dominant categories of subjective depth (the depth model). 
 It is from just these categories that notions of sensibility traditionally take their meaning. 
 Additionally for Wilde, perverse desire is not only an agency of displacement, it is partly constituted by that displacement and the transgressive aesthetic which informs it. 
 Just as in reverse discourse the categories of subordination are turned back upon the regimes of truth which disqualify, so this &bquo;other&equo; sensibility is in part affirmed as an inversion and absence of sensibility's traditional criteria. 
 Perverse desire is transvalued, socially, sexually, and aesthetically. 
 Dorian Gray  describes moments when &bquo;the passion for sin, or for what the world calls sin&equo; is utterly overwhelming 
 and conscience is either killed, or, if it lives at all, lives but to give rebellion its fascination, and disobedience its charm. 
 For all sins, as theologians weary not of reminding us, are sins of disobedience. 
 When that high spirit, that morningstar of evil, fell from heaven, it was as a rebel that he fell. 
 (p. 210) 
 Law and conscience are subjected to the perverse dynamic, being made to enable and intensify the rebellion they were supposed to prevent; likewise with Wilde's transgressive aesthetic in the realm of desire and culture. 
 Wilde lived an anarchic and a political homosexuality simultaneously. 
 Richard Ellmann describes him as &bquo;conducting, in the most civilized way, an anatomy of his society, and a radical reconsideration of its ethics&hellip;. 
 His greatness as a writer is partly the result of the enlargement of sympathy which he demanded for society's victims&equo; ( Oscar Wilde ,  p. xiv). 
 I agree, and this can stand as a cogent it incomplete description of what is meant by a political homosexuality. 
 But Wilde also fashioned his transgressive aesthetic into a celebration of anarchic deviance, and this is yet another factor which makes it difficult to identify the sensibility involved. 
 There is a positive desire to transgress and disrupt, and a destructiveness, even a running to one's own destruction, paradoxically creative. 
 Though in a different way, what we have seen to be true of Gide was also true of Wilde: &bquo;running foul of the law in his sexual life was a stimulus to thought on every subject&hellip;. 
 His new sexual direction liberated his art. 
 It also liberated his critical faculty&equo; (Ellmann, Oscar Wilde , 270). 
 Conformity angered and bored Wilde. 
 It is not clear which, the anger or the boredom, was thought to be the more insulting, but both were expressed as that arrogance for which he was often hated. 
 Yeats recalls receiving a letter from Lionel Johnson &bquo;denouncing Wilde with great bitterness&equo;; Johnson believed that Wilde got a &bquo;&bquo;sense of triumph and power, at every dinner-table he dominated, from the knowledge that he was guilty of that sin which, more than any other possible to man, would turn all those people against him if they but knew''&equo; (Yeats, Autobiographies , 285). 
 Maybe Johnson was paranoid; that does not stop him being correct. 
 Gide at the end of his life remarked that Wilde only began to live after dark as it were, away from most of those who knew him (So Be It , 27). 
 But the point here is that Wilde also lived in terms of the discrepancy between his &bquo;public&equo; and &bquo;private&equo; selves, and took pleasure from it &mdash; from having a sexual identity elsewhere at the same time as being socially &bquo;here&equo;. 
 The anarchic and the political, the anger and the boredom, are all active in Wilde's transgressive aesthetic, and most especially when the survival strategies of subordination &mdash; subterfuge, lying, evasion &mdash; are aesthetically transvalued into weapons of attack, but ever working obliquely through irony, ambiguity, mimicry, and impersonation. 
 Which brings us to camp, considered by some to be the essence of the homosexual sensibility, by others, both within and without gay culture, as virtually the opposite: the quintessence of an alienated, inadequate sensibility (above, Chapter 3). 
 The definition of camp is as elusive as the sensibility itself, one reason being simply that there are different kinds of camp. 
 I am concerned here with that mode of camp which undermines the categories which exclude it, and does so through parody and mimicry. 
 But not from the outside: this kind of camp undermines the depth model of identity from inside, being a kind of parody and mimicry which hollows out from within, making depth recede into its surfaces. 
 Rather than a direct repudiation of depth, there is a performance of it  to excess: depth is undermined by being taken to and beyond its own limits. 
 The masquerade of camp becomes less a self-concealment than a kind of attack, and untruth a virtue: many a young man, says Wilde, &bquo;starts with the natural gift of exaggeration which, if encouraged could flourish. 
 Unfortunately he usually comes to nothing, either falling into the bad habit of accuracy, or frequents the society of the aged and well informed&equo; (&bquo;Decay of Lying&equo;, 294). 
 Compare John Mitzel: &bquo;gay people are, I have learned, in the truest sense of the word, fabulous &hellip;. 
 The controlling agents of the status quo may know the power  of lies; dissident sub-cultures, however, are closer to knowing their value&equo; (cited in Bronski, Culture-Clash , 41). 
 The hollowing-out of the deep self is pure pleasure, a release from the subjective correlatives of dominant morality (normality, authenticity, etc.) &mdash; one reason why camp also mocks the Angst  -ridden spiritual emptiness which characterizes the existential lament. 
 Camp thereby negotiates some of the lived contradictions of subordination, simultaneously refashioning as a weapon of attack an oppressive identity inherited as  subordination, and hollowing out dominant formations responsible for that identity in the first instance. 
 So it is misleading to say that camp is  the gay sensibility; camp is an invasion and subversion of other sensibilities, and works via parody, pastiche, and exaggeration. 
 Jack Babuscio has suggested that the homosexual experience of passing for straight leads to a &bquo;heightened awareness and appreciation tor disguise, impersonation, the projection of personality, and the distinctions to be made between instinctive and theatrical behaviour&equo; (&bquo;Camp and the Gay Sensibility&equo;, 45). 
 Richard Dyer remarks, in relation to Babuscio, that the gay sensibility &bquo;holds together qualities that are elsewhere felt as antithetical: theatricality and authenticity&hellip; intensity and irony, a fierce assertion of extreme feeling with a deprecating sense of its absurdity&equo; ( Heavenly Bodies , 154). 
 I would add that camp is oft en also a turning of the second set of categories &mdash; theatricality, irony, and a sense of the absurdity of extreme feeling &mdash; onto the first, such that the latter &mdash; authenticity, intensity, the fierce assertion of extreme feeling &mdash; if they remain at all, do so in a transformed state. 
 In this respect camp, as Andrew Ross observes, anticipated many of the recent debates of sexual politics: &bquo;in fact, camp could be seen as a much earlier, highly coded way of addressing those questions about sexual difference which have engaged non-essentialist feminists in recent years&equo; ( No Respect , 161). 
 Camp integrates this aspect of gender with aesthetics; in a sense it renders gender a question of aesthetics. 
 Common in aesthetic involvement is the recognition that what seemed like mimetic realism is actually  an effect of convention, genre, form, or some other kind of artifice. 
 For some this is a moment of disappointment in which the real, the true, and the authentic are surrendered to, or contaminated by, the factitious and the contrived. 
 But camp comes to life around that recognition; it is situated at the point of emergence of the artificial from the real, culture from nature &mdash; or rather when and where the real collapses into artifice, nature into culture; camp restores vitality to artifice, and vice versa, deriving the artificial from, and feeding it back into or as, the real. 
 The reality is the pleasure of unreality. 
 And the primacy of fantasy: as the inheritor of a religious impulse, &bquo;modern&equo; sexual desire seeks to universalize and naturalize itself. 
 Camp knows and takes pleasure in the tact that desire is culturally relative, and never more so than when, in cathecting contemporary style, it mistakes itself, and the style, for the natural. 
 Camp is not the same as gender inversion, but it often connects with it, and with good reason. 
 Like the cross-dressing explored in the last chapter, gender inversion remains controversial because it allegedly only inverts, rather than displaces, the gender binary. 
 But again, in (historical) practice to invert may also be to displace. 
 Mario Mieli quotes an unnamed gay writer: &bquo;we &lsqb;gay men&rsqb; demand our &bquo;femininity'&equo;, the same thing that women reject, and at the same time  we declare that these roles are devoid of sense' ( Homosexuality and Liberation , 46). 
 An appropriate inversion becomes a deconstructive displacement. 
 So it is futile to try to define the homosexual sensibility according to the standards of conventional sensibility: first because the latter has sought to exclude the former; second because, in retaliation, the former has often worked to undermine the latter and, in the process, challenged the very nature of the aesthetic, fashioning in the process new and sometimes oppositional mutations of it. 
 The search for the nature of the distinctively gay sensibility can be productively redirected as an exploration of the limitations of the aesthetic as conventionally understood, especially the way it is said to transcend the socio-political, and used in support of the proposition that discrimination is the essence of culture. 
 Further, rather than seeking such a sensibility in an &bquo;inner condition&equo;, we might more usefully identify it outwardly and in relation to other strategies of survival and subversion, especially the masquerade of femininity, and the mimicry of the colonial subject. 
 What it might be found to share with the first is a simultaneous avoidance and acting out of the ambivalence which constitutes subordination, and a pushing of  that ambivalence to the point of transgressive insight and possibly reinscribed escape. 
 As for the colonial context, Homi Bhabha argues that here mimicry is both a strategy of colonial subjection &mdash; an appropriation, regulation, and reform of the other &mdash; and, potentially, a way of menacing colonial discourse in and through an inappropriate imitation by the native, one which reveals the normative structure of colonial control. 
 As such, mimicry becomes, in Bhabha's memorable phrase, &bquo;at once resemblance and menace&equo;. 
 Knowledge and Pleasure in Jean Genet 
 In so many respects utterly ditferent from Wilde, Genet nevertheless also subverts the depth model of identity via the perverse dynamic, and perhaps more so than any other writer since Wilde. 
 Like the latter, Genet inverts and subverts the surface/depth binary, confirming and exploiting the connections between the paradoxical and the perverse, and turning them against the regimes, heterosexual and otherwise, which outlaw the deviant. 
 Genet, also like Wilde, produces both anarchic pleasure and subversive knowledge inseparably. 
 Charles Marowitz once identified a crucial characteristic of Genet's work: 
 In perhaps one of the most shocking hypotheses ever put forward in the drama, Genet suggests that the only thing that distinguishes the sexual pervert who masquerades as priest, king, or hero from his legitimate social counterpart, is a certain timidity. 
 The sexual pervert lives his fantasies in private and is therefore harmless; whereas the social personages play out their roles in public. 
 (&bquo;The Revenge of Jean Genet&equo;, 173) 
 This facilitates and in part constitutes the challenge of the perverse: 
 the highest ideal in The Balcony  is for characters to attain that point of social definition at which others desire to impersonate them. 
 Reality corresponds to the density of one's artifice. 
 When a man achieves his highest reality he can serve as a fantasy for another man; and in a frightening Genetic turnabout, both then become equal. 
 (p. 173) 
 They become equal because fictions of selfhood are transvalued. 
 Genet said of himself: &bquo;Dehumanizing myself is my own most fundamental  tendency&equo; ( Our Lady , 82). 
 The transgressive drive in his work is not a quest for the authentic self, but almost the reverse: 
 The mechanism was somewhat as follows (I have used it since): to every charge brought against me, unjust though it be, from the bottom of my heart I shall answer yes. 
 Hardly had I uttered the word &mdash; or the phrase signifying it &mdash; than I felt within me the need to become what I had been accused of being&hellip;. 
 I owned to being the coward, traitor, thief and fairy they saw in me. 
 ( The Thief's Journal , 145) 
 To be sure, the characteristics of the transcendent self remain in play: to become what others saw him as being required great self-discipline &bquo;similar to spiritual exercises&equo;; eventually he aspires to a classical stoic independence of spirit, a kind of sainthood (p. 146). 
 But then in Our Lady of the Flowers  &bquo;the gesture of solitude that makes you sufficient unto yourself&equo; is not abstinence or retreat, but masturbation (p. 124). 
 Inversion and substitution are intensely narcissistic; despite that &mdash; or rather because of it, since Genet also transvalues narcissism &mdash; they extend tar beyond the self. 
 of Divine, the anti-hero/ine drag queen of Our Lady , it is said: 
 her carnal pleasures never made her fear the wrath of God, the scorn of Jesus, or the candied disgust of the Holy Virgin&hellip; for as soon as she recognized the presence within her of seeds of these fears (divine wrath, scorn, disgust), Divine made of her loves a god above God, Jesus, and the Holy Virgin, to whom they were submissive like everyone else. 
 (p. 138) 
 Here, the figures who act as transcendent foils to a mundane inauthenticity, abjection, and subjection are themselves brought low, made to submit to what they once subjected. 
 Notions of the freedom and autonomy of the self are at one and the same time inverted and used to pervert the ethical and metaphysical values which such a self is or was supposed to instantiate. 
 Authentic selfhood is denied and then reconstituted in a perverse, parodic form &mdash; and then perhaps denied again, transformed from other to same and then back to a (ditferent) other. 
 Genet reinscribes himself within the violent hierarchies of his oppression, installing himself there relentlessly to invert and pervert them. 
 He writes in Our Lady : &bquo;We are, after all, familiar enough with the tragedy of a certain feeling which is obliged to borrow its expression from the opposite feeling so as to escape from the myrmidons of the law. 
 It disguises itself in the trappings of its rival&equo; (p. 1 13). 
 Such incorporation facilitates a specific kind of transgressive reinscription. 
 As in this passage, Genet not only disguises himself in terms of the law, but internalizes the disguise. 
 What transpires is not the sacrilege which pays  testimony to the sacred (i.e. containment), but a sacrilege inscribed within the sacred. 
 Inside the church 
 the &lsqb;priest's&rsqb; sprinkler is always moist with a tiny droplet, like Alberto's prick which is stiff in the morning and which has just pissed. 
 The vaults and walls of the chapel of the Virgin are white-washed, and the Virgin has an apron as blue as a sailor's collar. 
 Facing the faithful, the altar is neatly arranged; facing God, it is a jumble of wood in the dust and spider webs. (p. 161) 
 In the description of the sprinkler and the apron, and especially the altar, the internalization of law (as disguise) results in this sacrilege within reverence, an intimacy with law which can blow apart its ideological effect (revealing the hidden side of the altar) &mdash; and with a strange knowing innocence strangely inseparable from that intimacy. 
 Orton's Black Camp 
 Joe Orton, so different again from Wilde or Genet, nevertheless shares their transgressive commitment to inversion and the critique of authenticity. 
 His What the Butler Saw  (1969) becomes a kind of orgy of cross-dressing, gender confusion, and hierarchical inversion. 
 It is also an angry repudiation of sexual repressiveness as enforced by the ideology of authentic, normal sexuality, now ratified by state law and the medical professions. 
 But once again anger works through irony, parody, and pastiche, and is held together not by a unified dramatic voice but by a stylistic blankness a kind of black camp. 
 Here, as in his and Halliwell's notorious defacement of library books (for which they were imprisoned), and in Orton's theory of montage, there is an anticipation of that effect of pastiche which Fredric Jameson identifies as a defining criterion of the post-modern: 
 Pastiche is, like parody, the imitation of a peculiar or unique style, the wearing of a stylistic mask, speech in a dead language: but it is a neutral practice of mimicry, without parody's ulterior motive, without the satirical impulse, without laughter, without that still latent feeling that there exists something normal  compared to which what is being imitated is rather comic. 
 pastiche is black parody, parody that has lost its humor. 
 (&bquo;Postmodernism and Consumer Society&equo;, 114) 
  The difference is that Orton's pastiche is  comic but in a way which interrogates rather than presupposes the norm. 
 As Jane Feuer points out, camp involves a kind of sensibility in which &bquo;blank mimicry and a critical edge may coexist&equo;, and thereby resembles that form of postmodern parody which Linda Hutcheon defines as a &bquo;repetition with critical distance that allows ironic signalling of difference at the very heart of similarity&equo;. 
 Thereby camp may also, either implicitly or directly, interrogate the norm which, according to Jameson, traditional parody assumes. 
 This is only one respect in which camp delights in the selfsame artifice which others distrust. 
 Orton's intention was to outrage. 
 Had he been alive he would doubtless have been delighted at the response of the leading conservative theatre critic to What the Butler Saw  (1969): &bquo;Orton's terrible obsession with perversion, which is regarded as having brought his life to an end and choked his very high talent, poisons the atmosphere of the play. 
 And what should have been a piece of gaily irresponsible nonsense becomes impregnated with evil.&equo; 
 Perhaps Hobson spoke truer than he knew, for the play is a kind of gay non-sense: 
 &lsqb;DR&rsqb; RANCE. 
 When Dr Prentice asked you to pose as a woman did he give a reason? 
 NICK. 
 No. 
 RANCE. 
 Didn't you consider his request strange? 
 NICK. 
 No. 
 RANCE. 
 Have you aided other men in their perverted follies? 
 NICK. 
 During my last term at school I was the slave of a corporal in the Welsh Fusiliers. 
 RANCE. 
 Were you never warned of the dangers inherent in such relationships? 
 NICK. 
 When he was posted abroad he gave me a copy of &bquo;The Way to Healthy Manhood&equo;. 
 By insisting on the arbitrariness and narrowness of gender roles, and that they are socially ascribed rather than naturally given, Orton expresses a central motif in the sexual politics of that time. 
 What the Butler Saw  becomes an orgy of confused and refused  gender identities: 
 GERALDINE &lsqb;dressed as a boy&rsqb;. 
 I must be a boy. 
 I like girls. 
 RANCE. 
 I can't quite follow the reasoning there. 
 PRENTICE. 
 Many men imagine their preference for women is, ipso facto , a proof of virility. 
 Cross-dressing leads to wholesale gender confusion, while Dr Rance's precisely inappropriate assumptions about madness, the natural, and &bquo;the order of things&equo; discredit the claims of psychiatry: 
 RANCE. 
 Were you present when Dr Prentice used this youth unnaturally? 
 NICK. 
 What is unnatural? 
 RANCE. 
 How disturbing the questions of the mad can be. 
 (To Nick &lsqb;disguised as a girl&rsqb;) Suppose I made an indecent suggestion to you? 
 If you agreed something might occur which, by and large, would be regarded as natural. 
 If, on the other hand, I approached this child &mdash; ( he smiles at  Geraldine &lsqb;disguised as a boy&rsqb;) &mdash; my action could result only in a gross violation of the order of things. 
 In the 1960s psychiatry was attacked for being a form of social policing which, with the aid of pseudo-scientific categories, mystified socially desirable behaviour as natural, and undesirable behaviour as the result of abnormal psychosexual development (a deviation from &bquo;The Way to Healthy Manhood&equo;). 
 R. D. Laing wrote in The Divided Self : 
 Psychiatry can so easily be a technique of brainwashing, of inducing behaviour that is adjusted, by (preferably) non-injurious torture&hellip;. 
 I would wish to emphasize that our &bquo;normal&equo; &bquo;adjusted&equo; state is too often the abdication of ecstasy, the betrayal of our true potentialities , that many of us are only too successful in acquiring a false self to adapt the false realities. 
 (p. 12, my emphasis) 
 Orton goes further than Laing, for his plays transgress accepted norms at every point yet refuse to replace them with &bquo;our true potentialities&equo;; Laing is still preoccupied with the authentic self, the repressed human essence. 
 Orton refuses that long-established kind of transgression which, in the very sincerity of its non-conformity, revalidates society's lapsed moral integrity. 
 As John Milton put it centuries before: &bquo;Men of most renowned vertu have sometimes by transgressing, most truly kept the law&equo; ( Tetrachordon, Prose Works , iv. 
 75). 
 A significant contemporary manifestation of that belief, and a vivid instance of how &bquo;modern&equo; sexuality became a surrogate religion, somewhere for an essentially religious notion of integrity to survive in a mutated and displaced form, was at the prosecution for obscenity of D. H. Lawrence's Lady Chatterley's Lover  (1960). 
 In that trial the author was defended on the grounds that he had to transgress moral respectability in order to be moral at a deeper, more authentic level dictated by personal conscience. 
 Even the indignation of satire might  assume the same moral perspective as that of the order being challenged, or at least an alternative to it. 
 But, as his diaries indicate, Orton's indignation was too anarchic to be recuperated in such terms. 
 In What the Butler Saw , sexuality, like language, becomes decentred and therefore radically contingent: it not only escapes from, but disorientates the medical and legal attempts to define and regulate it. 
 Not surprisingly, Orton's anarchic irresponsibility was thought by some to go too far, not just in what he actually did , but in the refusal in his work to confront established morality with an earnest moral alternative. 
 What we find instead is a kind of delinquent black camp. 
 In the article referred to at the outset, Susan Sontag remarks that camp &bquo;is a solvent of morality. 
 It neutralizes moral indignation, sponsors playfulness&equo; (&bquo;Notes on Camp&equo;, 275, 280, 290). 
 Orton's camp is indeed constituted by playfulness and it acts as a solvent of morality &mdash; but it does this to provoke rather than disarm moral indignation. 
 &bquo;No first night of the sixties was more volcanic than that of What the Butler Saw &equo;, says Orton's biographer, John Lahr; while Stanley Baxter, who played Dr Prentice, has recalled the &bquo;militant hate&equo; of the audience, some of whom &bquo;wanted to jump on the stage and kill us&equo; (Lahr, Prick Up Your Ears , 333 &mdash; 4). 
 Hostile Eroticism 
 As a style, and even more as a politics, the transgressive reinscriptions practised by such writers have proved controversial, especially when grounded in the celebration of a perverse inauthenticity disturbingly implicated in authenticity itself, as in Genet. 
 On the positive side there are those like Kate Millett who find in Genet's deviants a subversive inversion of dominant heterosexuality, especially its masculine component. 
 Thus inverted, these structures are shorn of their ideological legitimation; in effect the world of normality, beyond which Genet lives in exile, is ridiculed and contradicted in the very process of being imitated. 
 Genet's femininity for instance &bquo;is, as Sartre phrases it, a &bquo;hostile eroticism'&equo;, delighted to ridicule and betray the very myth of virility it pretends to serve' ( Sexual Politics , 18, 349). 
 All this means that, for Millett, Genet is &bquo;the only living male writer of first class literary gifts to have transcended the sexual myths of our era&equo; (p. 22). 
 Conversely, for Hans Mayer, Genet's commitment to inversion makes him deeply conservative: &bquo;Genet's books are the exact opposite of a  literature of indignation and rebellion. 
 The author has no intention of making accusations or unmasking society. 
 He is a true believer in the bourgeois order, not a critic.&equo; 
 More critical still are those like Walter Heist who conclude that Genet is pervaded with fascism (cited by Mayer, Outsiders , 225, who dissents from the view). 
 Certainly there is a crucial sense in which Genet presupposes what he would challenge: &bquo;I am steeped in an idea of property while I loot property. 
 I recreate the absent proprietor&equo;, he says in The Thief's Journal  (p. 129); and in a 1975 interview: &bquo;I would like the world, and pay attention to the way I'm saying it, I would like the world not to change so that I can be against the world&equo; ( Gay Sunshine Interviews , 79). 
 There is an ambivalence in Genet which his critic always misread and his defenders often overlook. 
 Such ambivalence often figures within transgressive reinscription, and is one reason why it rarely approximates to a straightforwardly &bquo;correct&equo; political attitude. 
 Consider two kinds of ambivalent transgressive reinscription within gay culture, camp and machismo. 
 As styles they are very different, virtual alternatives in tact. 
 But both have been regarded as politically reprehensible, camp because allegedly insulting to women, machismo because allegedly aping the masculinity oppressive of women (lesbian and straight) and gays. 
 Defenders of camp and machismo point out that they are parodic critiques &mdash; in the first case of what is allegedly insulted (femininity), in the second of what is allegedly aped (masculinity). 
 Certainly both gay camp and gay machismo can and do problematize femininity and masculinity as traditionally understood. 
 Thus Richard Dyer has argued of gay machismo that, by taking the traditional signs of masculinity and &bquo;eroticising them in a blatantly homosexual context, much mischief is done to the security with which &bquo;men'&equo; are defined in society, and by which their power is secured' (&bquo;Getting Over the Rainbow&equo;, 61). 
 Throughout Gender Trouble  Judith Butler offers &mdash; and tor, rather than against, feminism &mdash; a similar defence of practices like drag, cross-dressing, and, in lesbian culture, butch/femme sexual stylization. 
 She contests the view that these practices are &bquo;either degrading to women, in the case of drag and cross-dressing, or an uncritical appropriation of sex-role stereotyping from within the practice of heterosexuality, especially in the case of butch/femme lesbian identities&equo; (p. 137). 
 Thus she reads drag as playing with a threefold distinction: anatomical sex, gender identity, and gender performance:  
 If the anatomy of the performer is already distinct from the gender of the performer, and both of those are distinct from the gender of the performance, then the performance suggests a dissonance not only between sex and performance, but sex and gender, and gender and performance&hellip; 
 In imitating gender drag implicitly reveals the imitative structure of gender itself &mdash; as well as its contingency . 
 (p. 137) 
 Butler sees deviant sexualities more generally as involving this same process of denaturalizing, as parodic subversive repetitions which displace rather than consolidate heterosexual norms. 
 The parody of deviant sex, far from presupposing and ratifying an original natural sexuality, exposes it as a fiction. 
 Thus &bquo;gay is to straight not  as copy is to original, but, rather, as copy is to copy&equo; (p. 31). 
 Additionally, the parody encourages a &bquo;proliferation and subversive play of gendered meaning&equo; (p. 33). 
 Most controversially of all, this argument has been extended to sado-masochistic sexuality which, far from ratifying the &bquo;real&equo; violence of society, theatricalizes and demystifies it. 
 In certain respects this argument replays for a post/modern politics Wilde's transgressive aesthetic and the gay (anti) sensibility which it helped inaugurate. 
 It also resembles the strategy of the early modern female cross-dresser for whom sexual difference was not derived from natural and divine law, but produced by &bquo;custom&equo;, that is, culture. 
 Here then is a continuity between the early modern and the post/modern, one oft en overlooked when we concentrate on the differences in the way sexuality is conceptualized in the two periods. 
 But crucial differences remain, and it was because the early modern transvestite was not conceptualized in terms of a pathological sexual subjectivity &mdash; the modern &bquo;homosexual&equo; &mdash; that her transgression was regarded, albeit with paranoia, as more social than sexual. 
 The connections between gender and class were apparent enough in the early modern period, and if the transvestite was a pervert or invert it was precisely in the pre-sexological senses of these ideas; whether actually or only in the paranoid imagination of the dominant, she was regarded as upsetting the entire social domain, even when her sexual &bquo;orientation&equo; was not the issue. 
 So when it is argued today that the sexual deviant challenges sexual difference by denaturalizing it through parody, the realization of the early modern transvestite that both the deviant and the difference are effects of culture rather than nature is being revived and sophisticated. 
 But a residual effect of the &bquo;privatizing&equo; of sexuality, and in particular of the construction of sexual deviance as an identity, a pathology of being, rather than a kind of behaviour in principle open to all, is that the challenge to this construction often itself remains imprisoned by the public/private dichotomy. 
 So while the whole point of the argument,  and rightly, is that when gender is understood as culture rather than nature we see that gender is implicated in all aspects of culture, in practice the argument rarely gets oft the bed. 
 As we shall see shortly, the way out of the bedroom is via the wider cultures, rather than the specific sexual acts, of transgressive reinscription &mdash; for example, the writings of Wilde, Genet, and others, the subculture from which they emerge and help to form and transform. 
 First there is another objection to be considered: do deviant identities and sexualities really denaturalize through theatrical parody as straightforwardly as is sometimes suggested? 
 Leo Bersani thinks not, at least where camp and gay machismo are concerned. 
 He concedes a potentially subversive dimension to camp, but one inseparable from a more problematic and ambivalent relation to both femininity and women: 
 the gay male parody of a certain femininity, which, as others have argued, may itself be an elaborate social construct, is both a way of giving vent to the hostility toward women that probably afflicts every male (and which male heterosexuals have of course expressed in infinitely nastier and more effective ways) and  could paradoxically be thought of as helping to deconstruct that image for women themselves&hellip; 
 The gay male bitch desublimates and desexualizes a type of femininity glamorized by movie stars, whom he thus lovingly assassinates with his style. 
 Of the subversive claims for gay machismo, Bersani is even more sceptical, since he regards it as involving not a parodic repudiation of straight machismo, but a profound respect for it. 
 But, crucially, and this reminds us of Genet, Bersani locates a challenge inseparable from a certain ambivalence: if gay males threaten male heterosexual identity, it is not because they offer a detached parody of that identity, but rather because &bquo;from within their nearly mad identification with it, they never cease to feel the appeal of its being violated &equo; (&bquo;Is the Rectum a Grave?&equo;, 208 &mdash; 9, his emphasis). 
 Bersani arrives at this position because he sees gay male sexuality as enacting insights into sexuality per se  which heterosexual culture has to repress ruthlessly (above, Chapter 17). 
 The cultural dynamics of transgressive reinscription suggest how both positions are correct: identification with, and desire for, may coexist with parodic subversion of, since a culture is not reducible to the specific desires of the individuals comprising it &mdash; desires which anyway differ considerably &mdash; and even less to the &bquo;truth&equo; of desire itself. 
 Gay culture is in part constituted by a self-reflexive, ironic representation of desire itself, gay and straight, and of the objects of desire, again both gay and straight. 
 This is especially so of its involvement with masculinity. 
 In one and the same gay milieu one is likely to encounter identification with,  desire tor, and parodies of masculinity. 
 Among numerous other things, gay subcultures  (as opposed to the illusory &bquo;truth&equo; of a unitary homosexual desire ) include all three, and sometimes indistinguishably. 
 And it those subcultures discredit any notion of an essential or unitary gay desire, they also constitute a crucial enabling condition of transgressive reinscription. 
 More than that, they help constitute it. 
 This is why transgressive reinscription should not be understood in terms of discrete transgressive acts which &bquo;succeed&equo; or &bquo;fail&equo; in some immediate sense. 
 Reinscription is an oppositional practice which is also a perspective and language (sensibility?) constantly interpreting and re-presenting all sections of a culture including its dominant and subordinate fractions, its conventional (e.g. heterosexual) as well as deviant (e.g. homosexual) identities. 
 Butler remarks the importance of repetition  in the process of resistance and transformation: &bquo;The task is&hellip; to repeat and, through a radical proliferation of gender, to displace  the very gender norms that enable the repetition itself&equo; ( Gender Trouble , 148). 
 Certainly, but that displacement can only occur it if is also a struggle in and for representation &mdash; specifically, the representation of the repetition as  re-presentation/inversion/displacement of the norm. 
 In short, the displacing repetition still has to be culturally construed as such. 
 In the process the transgression and the norm are both re-presented. 
 And this, far from being a containment (transgression presupposing and thereby ratifying the norm it contravenes), is one condition of the norm's undoing. 
 Transgressive reinscription will always remain controversial, if only because it raises such disturbing questions about desire itself, making it profoundly social and thereby asking equally disturbing questions about culture, representation, and social process. 
 This is even more so when, as I have argued with homosexuality, so many dimensions of a culture have been displaced and/or condensed into the identity of the transgressor. 
 But then there is no transgression from the position of the subordinate that is not controversial; it is a virtually inevitable consequence of the disempowered mounting a challenge at all. 
 Thinking Transgressive Reinscription 
 Consider two similarities, the first between two post-structuralists whose work is in most other respects incompatible, the second between post-structuralism and the post/modern. 
 This is Foucault: 
 Rules are empty in themselves, violent and unfinalized; they are impersonal and can be bent to any purpose. 
 The successes of history belong to those who are capable of seizing these rules, to replace those who had used them, to disguise   themselves so as to pervert them, invert their meaning, and redirect them against those who had initially imposed them&hellip; so as to overcome the rulers through their own rules. 
 (Language, Counter-Memory, Practice , 151, my emphasis) 
 Elsewhere he writes: 
 There are no relations of power without resistances; the latter are all the more real and effective because they are formed right at the point where relations of power are exercised; resistance to power does not have to come from elsewhere to be real, nor is it inexorably frustrated through being the compatriot of power. 
 It exists all the more by being in the same place as power. 
 ( Power/ Knowledge , 142) 
 Now compare Foucault with Derrida: 
 Our discourse irreducibly belongs to the system of metaphysical oppositions. 
 The break with this structure of belonging can be announced only through a certain  organisation, a certain strategic  arrangement which, within the field of metaphysical opposition, uses the strengths of the field to turn its own stratagems against it, producing a force of dislocation that spreads itself throughout the entire system, fissuring it in every direction and thoroughly delimiting  it. 
 ( Writing and Difference , 20) 
 And then both Foucault and Derrida with Baudrillard: 
 a system is abolished only by pushing it into hyperlogic, by forcing it into an excessive practice which is equivalent to a brutal amortization&hellip; 
 A parody and a paradox: it is by their very inertia in the ways of the social laid out for them that the masses go beyond its logic and its limits, and destroy its whole edifice. 
 A destructive hypersimulation, a destructive hyperconformity&hellip; that has all the appearance of a victorious challenge &mdash; no one can measure the strength of this challenge&hellip; 
 There lies the genuine stake today, in this underhand, inescapable confrontation between the silent majority and the social imposed on them, in this hypersimulation reduplicating simulation and exterminating it according to its own logic &mdash; not in any class struggle nor in the molecular hodge-podge of desire-breaching minorities . 
 This revolution&hellip; proceeds by inertia, and not from a new and joyous negativity. 
 ( In the Shadow of the Silent Majorities , 46 &mdash; 7, 47 &mdash; 8, 49) 
 Transgressive reinscription: a turning back  upon something and a perverting of it typically it not exclusively through inversion and displacement. 
 The idea seems strange: is not transgression a liberation from, a moving beyond; a breaking out, perhaps even a progression? 
 As we saw in relation to Gide, even in a secularized philosophy of transgression, metaphors of transcendence abound. 
 In comparison, the  idea of turning back upon, or into, seems regressive &mdash; literally reactionary. 
 But transgressive reinscription appropriates reaction for resistance, thereby substituting agency for autonomy. 
 The early modern transvestite and the post/modern gay (anti) sensibility suggest some of the ways in which transgressive reinscriptions have been around for much longer than post-modernism has been fashionable. 
 There are of course others: such reinscription has worked via minimalist perversion &mdash; for instance, the complete defacement via minimum change as in the street graffito which blackens one tooth of the billboard toothpaste ad, or the MLA panel paper: &bquo;A thing of beauty is a boy forever&equo; &mdash; a difference of barely more (or less) than a single inverted letter). 
 Then there have been the more elaborate perversions which parody the sophistication of high art &mdash; Joe Orton's and Kenneth Halliwell's defacing of library books, Duchamp's moustache on Mona Lisa . 
 A principal medium of transgressive reinscription is fantasy &mdash; but again, not the fantasy of transcendence so much as the inherently perverse, transgressive reordering of fantasy's conventional opposite, the mundane. 
 Rosemary Jackson is surely right to remind us that &bquo;fantasy is not&hellip; transcendental. 
 It has to do with inverting elements of this world, re-combining its constitutive features.&equo; 
 Fantastic literature &bquo;does not introduce novelty, so much as uncover all that needs to remain hidden if the world is to be comfortably &bquo;known'&equo;&hellip; 
 As the term &bquo;paraxis'&equo; has already suggested, fantasy lies alongside the axis of the real&hellip; 
 This area, according to Freud, is one of concealed desire' ( Fantasy , 8, 65; see also p. 78). 
 Jackson quotes Freud's view that something has to be added to what is novel and unfamiliar to make it uncanny; this something is &bquo;nothing new or alien, but something which is familiar and old &mdash; established in the mind and become alienated from it through the process of repression&equo; (p. 66). 
 Fantasy may itself be a kind of transgressive reinscription, one presupposing a radical impurity in all identity, not excluding the transgressor's. 
 It knows too the impurity of transgressive desire, and most of all perhaps the impurity of dominant forms of identity, be they white, heterosexual, whatever. 
 The very impurity which the radical humanist seeks to transcend, only despairingly to rediscover at the very  centre of his or her being &mdash; this impurity, for the fantasies of transgressive reinscription, is not the ground of its failure but the material upon which it works. 
 This is partly the inevitable consequence of gender being socially constructed. 
 As many have observed, the recognition that gender is so constructed implies that it can be altered. 
 What is less often conceded or, if conceded, considered &mdash; Bersani being a significant exception &mdash; is that if gender is socially constituted so too is desire . 
 Desire is informed by the same oppressive constructions of gender that we would willingly dispense with. 
 Desire is of its &bquo;nature&equo; saturated by the social. 
 It is just this which allows subversive potential to parodic repetition but which also means that the parody will typically be inflected with the ambivalence I have described and, partly because of that ambivalence, oscillate between the political and the anarchic. 
 To liberate desire from oppression is not &mdash; could never be &mdash; a matter of resuming or regaining a desire/subjectivity as it existed prior to discrimination. 
 If oppression is imagined as a distortion of the self, then the lifting of oppression might be imagined to result in the self resuming its natural undistorted form. 
 But, even assuming, first, that the oppression has indeed been lifted, second, that we can speak of, and know, a time when that desire was ever free, and third, that we can speak meaningfully of a &bquo;natural&equo; or a &bquo;liberated&equo; desire (and my argument questions all three assumptions), even assuming all this, liberated desire would still always be different from its pre-oppression counterpart . 
 It will bear the history of that oppression, not necessarily as that which disables desire (though it may), but as desire itself. 
 All desire bears its histories, the desires of the exploited and the repressed no less than the desires of those who exploit and repress. 
 But differently in each case. 
 This is the subject of the next and final chapter. 
 The proposition that the history of sexual oppression will always inhere in the sexual desire of the oppressed, most powerfully in the form of self-oppression, confesses to tragedy. 
 There is truth in that, also in the proposition that in Western culture the &bquo;tragic vision&equo; has been one of the most powerful means of containing and sublimating desire. 
 But never completely: in turning back upon his or her own desire the deviant knows how to read the history within it. 
 Included there is a history of heterosexuality hardly known to itself.   
 PART 9 Beyond Sexual Difference  
 Desire and Difference 
 In Chapter 17 I considered how homosexuality has been construed within theories of sexual difference. 
 Beholden to an anatomically derived, heterosexually structured, and all-embracing dualism, such theories could only conceive of homosexuality as a disavowal of that very difference which is assumed to be fundamental to social, psychic, and sexual organization. 
 At the same time their insistence on otherness was found to be inseparable from a fear and disavowal of the same, or the proximate. 
 Further, one after another these theories either overlooked or actively disallowed the erotics of other kinds of difference; as Mandy Merck observes, in such theories &bquo;no non-genital differences (of race, class, age, etc) can signify such total Otherness, no genitally similar object can be legitimately eroticised&equo; (Merck, &bquo;Difference and its Discontents&equo;, 5 &mdash; 6). 
 But of course such differences have always been erotically invested, not least in lesbian and gay cultures. 
 So perhaps then we should displace sexual difference by cultural difference? 
 This could not exactly be a straight substitution: to attempt that would involve something like a category mistake. 
 The suggestion to be explored is rather that to think difference culturally rather than sexually might be both more illuminating and more liberating. 
 Attractive as that proposition has seemed in recent years, the form in which it has been pursued is fraught with difficulties. 
 Most significantly, an ahistorical, largely theoretical, emphasis on cultural difference remains limited. 
 As Ania Loomba puts it, in relation to colonialist studies, &bquo;the neglect of histories surrounding native insubordination either devalues or romanticises the latter, or worse, tends to read colonised subjects through linguistic or psychoanalytic theories which, for some of us at least, remain suspiciously and problematically shot through with ethnocentric assumptions whose transfer to all subalterns is unacceptable&equo; (&bquo;Overworlding&equo;, cited from manuscript). 
 Utopian Differences 
 No consideration of cultural and/or racial difference should ever neglect the sheer negativity, evil, and inferiority with which &bquo;the other&equo; has been conceived throughout history. 
 In the shadow of that history there is all the more to appreciate about the way progressive movements in our  time have turned things around, and begun positively to identify the difference of the other: &bquo;the emphasis on discontinuity, the celebration of difference and heterogeneity, and the assertion of plurality as opposed to reductive unities &mdash; these ideas have animated almost an entire generation of literary and cultural critics&equo; (Mohanty, &bquo;Us and Them&equo;, 56 &mdash; 7). 
 Such critics have attempted to conceive or represent the other in a way which does not replicate the repression and subjugation inherent in the traditional ways of so doing (p. 58). 
 Just one relevant instance is Roland Barthes's celebration of difference, so much difference in fact, as eventually to subvert repression itself, producing a concept of desire wherein there would be, for instance, not homosexuality but homosexualities &bquo;whose plural will baffle any constituted, centred discourse&equo; ( Roland Barthes , 69). 
 Far from being an endorsement of discrimination, an excess of difference would disarticulate its very terms. 
 The instance of homosexuality is not incidental here since &bquo;perverse, desire figures centrally in Barthes's influential theories of difference and textuality. 
 Like Wilde, Gide, and others, Barthes uses perverse desire to animate and inform his aesthetic and linguistic theories, and it is in terms of language and art that such strategies would in part operate. 
 In his inaugural lecture he imagines a utopian plurality of languages on which we would draw &bquo; according to the truth of desire &equo;: 
 This freedom is a luxury which every society should afford its citizens: as many languages as there are desires &mdash; a utopian proposition in that no society is yet ready to admit the plurality of desire. 
 That a language, whatever it be, not repress another; that the subject may know without remorse, without repression, the bliss of having at his disposal two kinds of language; that he may speak this or that, according to his perversions, not according to the Law. 
 ( Selected Writings , 467) 
 From within such a perspective sexuality comes to be understood relationally &mdash; not as the relations within sexual difference, but the relations between the sexual and the non-sexual as these have been both imagined and as they may now be radically envisioned. 
 To recover more for the domain of the non-sexual is related to a progressive sexual politics. 
 But the aim now is not necessarily to liberate sexuality (the sexual drive), but to eroticize the social while at the same time releasing it from the grip of sexuality especially as manifested in the ideology of sexual difference. 
 Such theories have been plausibly criticized for their romantic and Utopian strains, also for the way they echo and sometimes invoke a post-Freudian version of the polymorphous perverse. 
 But again, cultural context makes the crucial difference: the appropriation of the romantic, the utopian, and the polymorphous for what has  hitherto been marginal, and both demonized and repressed by the centre, and internalized as such at the margins, has quite different effects and implications trom, say, a more general (post/modern?) theory that &bquo;anything goes anywhere&equo;. 
 For one thing Barthes's perverse perspective on difference foregrounds a different history, one wherein there is no simple privileging of the marginal: the paradoxically perverse interrelationship between centre and margins, whereby the marginal returns to the centre in a way which disarticulates the centre/margin binary itself, is signified, in this instance, by Barthes inaugurating his professorship with a lecture on the significance of perversity vis-&agrave;-vis  language. 
 Barthes's vision is sometimes aligned with the post/modern. 
 &bquo;Postmodern knowledge&equo;, says Jean-Fran&ccedil;ois Lyotard, &bquo;refines our sensibility to difference and reinforces our ability to tolerate the incommensurable&equo; ( Postmodern Condition , p. xxv). 
 This is the urbane version of how to relate to the &bquo;other&equo;; it is what post/modernists aspire to in contrast to the negative, paranoid, fearful way of relating to the other which produces (for instance) misogyny, homophobia, racism, and xenophobia. 
 And as the antidote to such things it is devoutly to be wished. 
 Except that already it is not quite that simple, since the post-modern sophisticate is also the critic  of these other, negative ways of relating to the other; he or she is the one who diagnoses their social and psychic economies. 
 In the process the misogynist, the racist, and the homophobe, locked into a negative fear of their own others, have as such  become the negative others of the post-modern. 
 Perhaps it could not be otherwise, not ditferent. 
 I only mean to preface this discussion of cultural difference with an awkward question: in the world we have, is it possible for us &mdash; any of us &mdash; not  to have at least some inferior others? 
 It is a question that needs to be asked now that, in theoretical terms, the affirmation of difference has become almost a new orthodoxy. 
 Mohanty's warning that his celebration may involve a sentimental charity concealing a more fundamental indifference is timely. 
 So too is Homi Bhabha's scepticism about the way cultural theory uses the &bquo;Other&equo; to deconstruct &bquo;the epistemological &bquo;edge'&equo; of the West'; the problem being that &bquo;the &bquo;&bquo;Other'&equo; is cited, quoted, framed, illuminated, encased in the shot-reverse-shot strategy of a serial enlightenment' while at the same time losing &bquo;its power to signify, to negate, to initiate its  &bquo;&bquo;desire'&equo;, to split its &bquo;&bquo;sign'&equo; of identity, to establish its own institutional and oppositional discourse'. 
 Even as otherness is being affirmed it is also being foreclosed (&bquo;The Commitment to Theory&equo;, 16). 
 Interestingly, homosexuality has hardly ever been rehabilitated as a positive difference within and by those heterosexual discourses which have hitherto constructed it as negative other. 
 Progressives would willingly remove some of the stigma from homosexuality, and have often acknowledged the homosexual component within the heterosexually identified. 
 But this is typically the at once honest and evasive acknowledgement of a troubling presence/absence. 
 Put bluntly, to be identified positively, homosexuality usually has to be dissolved into the androgynous. 
 Or, alternatively, homosexuality might be called upon to loosen the rigid gender identities within heterosexuality: men are permitted a &bquo;feminine&equo; component and (though less oft en) women a &bquo;masculine&equo; one. 
 But such acknowledgements of the &bquo;other&equo; gender usually make for a fuller, more rounded, heterosexual identity. 
 H&eacute;l&eacute;ne Cixous is an exception in this respect, and it is interesting that she becomes so by almost reversing the psychoanalytically inspired account of homosexuality as involving a fear of difference/desire of the same. 
 Even though homosexuality as such  remains muted, subsumed into an &bquo;other bisexuality&equo;, it is here nevertheless explicitly and exceptionally identified as a creative  otherness: 
 This does not mean that in order to create you must be homosexual. 
 But there is no invention  possible, whether it be philosophical or poetic, without the presence in the inventing subject of an abundance of the other, of the diverse&hellip; there is no invention of other I's, no poetry, no fiction without a certain homosexuality (interplay therefore of bisexuality) making in me a crystallized work of my ultra subjectivities. 
 (Marks and de Courtivron (eds.), 
 New French Feminisms , 97) 
 Desiring the Different 
 The rarity of such positive conceptions of homosexuality within, or in relation to, otherness, is the more significant given that homosexuals have been among those who have literally (rather than metaphorically or theoretically) embraced the cultural and racial difference of the &bquo;other&equo;. 
 Kobena Mercer and Isaac Julien are right to emphasize that the complexity which arises at the junction of race and sexuality is something which &bquo;some people simply don't want to talk  about&equo;. 
 Of  the convergence of homosexuality and race, fewer still are prepared to speak, and those who have spoken have oft en done so in racist and/or homophobic terms &mdash; and that, as Mercer and Julien show, includes people in both the black and gay communities. 
 A constructive if brief discussion of the problematic convergence of race and homosexuality occurs in Dennis Altman's now twenty-year-old pioneering study, Homosexual Oppression and Liberation . 
 Altman discerns links between the oppression of blacks and of homosexuals, in the way that both are vulnerable to an internalization of their oppression. 
 He remarks that in America especially there has always been a strong cross-racial homosexual attraction less restrained by social barriers than its heterosexual counterpart; &bquo;the very furtiveness and outlaw status of the gayworld has led to its greater integration across colour lines&equo;. 
 Yet he refuses to sentimentalize the connection, recognizing that white homosexuals are not necessarily less racist than white heterosexuals, and that the cross-racial attraction in question may, tor both parties, be a consequence, rather than a repudiation, of their oppression. 
 He suggests that blacks have been &bquo;at one and the same time both more accepting of and more hostile towards homosexuality&equo;, and that the hostility has often been extreme &mdash; as in the case of Eldridge Cleaver's notorious attack on James Baldwin (Altman, Homosexual Oppression , esp. 
 192 &mdash; 207). 
 Despite this difficult history, crucial alliances have occurred. 
 The gay movement learned greatly from black analysis and black political experience, and it was possible in 1970 tor Huey Newton, joint founder of the Black Panther Party, to welcome alliance with the women's and gay movements. 
 In this he made the Black Panthers the first significant radical group to recognize gay liberation as a valid political movement, and did so in terms which provoked hostility from some in his own party: &bquo;maybe I'm injecting some of my prejudices by saying that &bquo;even a homosexual can be revolutionary'&equo;. 
 Quite the contrary, maybe a homosexual could be the most revolutionary' (Newton, quoted in Altman, Homosexual Oppression , 204; see also Genet in Leyland, Gay Sunshine Interviews ). 
 The relevance of this obscure, marginal history where race and homosexuality converge is once again being recognized. 
 Jonathan Ruthertord finds something strangely relevant for cultural politics in Britain in the 1990s in the cross-racial identifications of Lawrence of Arabia some seventy years before: &bquo;His identification with the Arabs and their culture displaced the centered position of his identity as a  white man. 
 The story is a compelling image of a postmodern world that is challenging so many of our own certainties and our cultural, sexual and political identities&equo; Identity , 9). 
 Rutherford cites Lawrence's own remark in The Seven Pillars of Wisdom  to the effect that this identification &bquo;quitted me of my English self, and let me look at the West and its conventions with new eyes: they destroyed it all for me&equo;. 
 Significantly Rutherford does not mention Lawrence's homosexuality although this is, as Kaja Silverman shows, a crucial determinant in all this. 
 Silverman explores the way Lawrence's homosexuality promotes an erotic identification which is itself crucial for his psychic participation in Arab nationalism; of how, in effect, he discovered himself within the Other. 
 More generally the case of T. E. Lawrence becomes an exemplary reminder that we are obliged &bquo;to approach history always through the refractions of desire and identification, and to read race and class insistently in relation to sexuality&equo; ( White Skin, Brown Masks , 4, 10, 12). 
 This is especially so with writers like Barthes and Genet, and Wilde and Gide before them, who, far from subordinating their outlawed sexuality to their radical politics or radical aesthetics, actively inform them with it. 
 Of course, there were and are risks in doing that. 
 From the vantage point of so-called post-liberation, we know only too well the political blindnesses of sexual desire, and how disastrous it can be to make sexuality the prime mover of a political vision. 
 That holds true in principle for any sexuality. 
 But, significantly, this is rarely if ever what those writers advocated. 
 Arguably the blinder kinds of sexual radicalism, wherein sexuality is made the prime political mover, have tended to be mainly heterosexual, and in the case of Wilhelm Reich, overtly homophobic. 
 What we learn from Wilde, Gide, Barthes, and others is that a conventionally understood politics which ignores sexual desire will quite possibly be as disastrous as one which makes that desire the prime mover &mdash; even, or especially, in the age of so-called post-liberation. 
 But also, it is not exactly that they bring sexuality to politics (it was always already there); rather deviant desire brings with it a different kind of political knowledge, and hence inflects both desire and politics differently.  
 Desire and Strangeness 
 In 1920 Gide recalls walking the streets of Biskra with Dr Bourget of Lausanne. 
 The latter does not like what he sees: &bquo;&bquo;Young men ought to be brought here to give them a horror of debauchery'&equo; exclaimed the worthy man, bursting with disgust.&equo; 
 Gide's response nicely if unawares repudiates the sexual-difference view of homosexuality as a solipsistic refusal of the other: &bquo;how little he knew of the human heart! &mdash; of mine at any rate&hellip; 
 Some people fall in love with what is like them; others with what is different. 
 I am among the latter. 
 Strangeness solicits me as much as familiarity repels&equo; ( If It Die , 253). 
 Seventy years on Michael Carson, writing of his own homosexual desire for the racially other, expresses a similar sentiment though now with a revealing, probably necessary, and certainly crucial distinction: &bquo;I have always been sexually attracted to foreigners. 
 Foreignness for me provided a difference that moved me in a way that sexual difference never did &equo; (&bquo;Home and Abroad&equo;, 44, my emphasis). 
 But perhaps this celebration of the exotic cultural/racial other is merely the counterpart of the racist's demonizing of the other? 
 Very possibly, and a remark of Michael Carson's explaining what it was that took him abroad in search of the other shows how the celebration may share the stereotypes of the demonized: 
 what I lacked was a foreign accent, almond eyes, straight or springy black hair, a black skin, a muscular physique, a mind full of difficult alphabets, a sense of rhythm, a pitiful history of slavery and oppression, and a massive member &mdash; though not necessarily in that order. 
 (&bquo;Home and Abroad&equo;, 44) 
 But Carson is also suggesting how the fantasized desire for the &bquo;other&equo; actually begins at home as a domestic projection; how fantasy is ineradicably social and, as such, susceptibility to stereotypes of all kinds, including racial and racist ones; how fantasy of and for the other exemplifies the mobilities of desire and identification. 
 And that certain lack at the heart of both desire and identification: what Carson actually finds in twenty years abroad is some oppressive sexual mores epitomized in the loveless fuck over the bonnet of a Chevy Impala. 
 And his article is about the corollary of discovering that the other begins at home, namely disenchantment: &bquo;almost twenty years later I am not convinced that sexual love between men exists in places like Saudi Arabia&equo; (p. 45). 
 Gide's experience, elsewhere and seventy years earlier, was very different, but, as we shall see, he too experiences the desire of the other as finally about disenchantment. 
 Perhaps then, and in a way which recalls Freud, Carson and Gide are also writing about the strange impossibility  of desire? 
 Whether their accounts confirm, coincide with, or can substitute for the psychoanalytic account of desire as lack is hard to say. 
 But Gide's account especially does suggest how the vision of desire as loss is strangely inseparable from both the blindness of desire and its capacity to know more than it wants. 
 Taking Boys Home 
 I began this book with Gide's chance encounter with Wilde in Algiers and, through Wilde, that momentous sexual encounter with Mohammed which profoundly changes Gide's life and profoundly influences his art. 
 I end it by returning to those encounters. 
 On that same visit to Algiers Gide befriends another Arab boy, Athman, and determines that he should accompany him when he returns to Paris. 
 Gide's mother, aided by others, fiercely resists the proposal; with unprecedented tenacity Gide rebels against his mother but eventually loses the battle. 
 Gide contends that he was virtually blackmailed into leaving Athman behind. 
 There is a memorable description of their parting: 
 When, on the third morning I looked for Athman to say goodbye to him, he was nowhere to be found and I had to leave without seeing him again. 
 I could not understand his absence; but suddenly, as I sat in the speeding train, a long way already from El Katara, I caught sight of his white burnous on the banks of the oued . 
 He was sitting there with his head in his hands; he did not rise when the train passed; he made no movement; he did not give a glance at the signs I made him; and for a long time as the train was carrying me away, I watched his little motionless, grief-stricken figure, lost in the desert, an image of my own despair. 
 ( If It Die , 296) 
 Gide had tried to persuade his mother, as he had persuaded himself, that bringing Athman to Paris was a &bquo;moral rescue&equo;, a question of the salvation of a boy through adoption. 
 Even so his mother was appalled; she thought &bquo;that the desert and solitude had turned my brain' (p. 293). 
 She told him that he would cover himself with ridicule by bringing the boy back. 
 After much argument Gide received a letter from a trusted household servant, Marie, who &bquo;swore she would leave the house on the day my &bquo;negro'&equo; came into it. 
 What would become of mamma without Marie? 
 I gave in; I had to' (p. 294). 
 Epitomized in this struggle over Athman, and especially in Gide's  correspondence with his mother, is a hesitant yet certain knowledge of how sexual discrimination relates inextricably to other kinds of discrimination. 
 In this one episode we find interconnections with race, class, colonialism, and (cultural) imperialism, and in ironic, domestic, tragically intricate ways: witness Gide finally capitulating to the class, racial, and cultural prejudices of his own culture, as voiced through his mother, who in turn speaks through her servant . 
 Discrimination descends through a hierarchy of the subordinate. 
 Or, more accurately, hierarchies , including those of class, race, and gender, and within each of which each subject is situated differently. 
 Discrimination works through the asymmetry of subject positioning, and the plurality of hierarchies, as well as the brute fact of inequality institutionalized in hierarchy itself. 
 That is partly what it means to speak of the interconnections of race, class, and gender. 
 It suggests too why establishing personal culpability is not the issue. 
 But since Gide has been criticized in this respect it is something which needs to be addressed. 
 In his personal relationships with Athman, and his political stance on colonial oppression, Gide could claim to have said and done more than most at that time. 
 Travels in the Congo  records his first-hand encounters with the brutalities of French colonialism. 
 In an entry for October 1925 he states his determination to find out their full extent, and to speak out against them ( Travels , 60). 
 One of his biographers, Justin O'Brien, says Gide's awakening to social consciousness began here, when he saw the people of the Congo exploited, beaten, and killed by whites intent on quick profits ( Portrait , 321). 
 On his return to France Gide succeeded in publicizing the injustices he had witnessed, with some effect at government level. 
 His later siding with communism was undoubtedly influenced by this journey. 
 Against that consider the following despicable episode which occurred during that same visit. 
 It concerned Lord Alfred Douglas who was on this occasion accompanied by Gide (but not Wilde, who had returned to England) and a boy called Ali with whom, according to Gide, Douglas was in love. 
 On discovering that Ali was also having an affair with a prostitute, Meriem, Douglas horse-whipped him: &bquo;his howls created a tumult among the people in the hotel&equo;. 
 Gide, who disliked Douglas, adds: &bquo;I heard this uproar, but considered it wiser not to intervene, and remained shut up in my room&equo; ( If It Die , 291). 
 Gide's account is at once critical and complicit and in a way inviting reflection. 
 In the escape from sexual oppression and sexual repression  individuals have often, like Gide, crossed divisions of class and race. 
 Potentially, both the experience of repression in their own culture, and the experience of cultural difference on the other side of the divides they cross, contribute to a critique of repression which includes, but also goes beyond, its sexual forms. 
 An identification consequent on a prior dislocation can make for a creative, empathetic partiality which is then the basis of a further identification and understanding of other kinds of discrimination. 
 I have shown how this is true of both Wilde and Gide. 
 At the same time they remained, as we all remain, implicated in other kinds of discrimination of which they and we, originally and subsequently, are the agents rather than the victims, or maybe both agents and victims. 
 If Douglas's brutality epitomizes racial, cultural, and sexual domination in its most callously direct form, Gide's self-description of remaining in the security of his room, considering it wiser not to intervene, becomes a resonant image of the hesitant complicities which most kinds of brutality and exploitation presuppose and in which most of us are implicated. 
 So desire for, and identification with, the cultural and racial other brings with it a complicated history. 
 Bronski, discussing the romanticizing of the non-Anglo by Edward Carpenter and others, declares: &bquo;the English fascination with the non-Anglo &mdash; and therefore more &bquo;primitive'&equo; and &bquo;&bquo;natural'&equo; &mdash; cultures&hellip; was also based in and inseparable from deeply rooted standards of white British racism and political and cultural imperialism' ( Culture-Clash , 26 &mdash; 7; see also p. 15 and Bakshi, &bquo;Homosexuality and Orientalism&equo;). 
 Edward Said's pioneering Orientalism  offered a searching analysis of this phenomenon. 
 With Gide and many others in mind, Said observes that virtually no European writer who wrote on or travelled to the Orient in the period after 1800 exempted himself or herself from a quest for sexual experience unobtainable in Europe: 
 What they looked for often &mdash; correctly I think &mdash; was a different type of sexuality, perhaps more libertine and less guilt-ridden; but even that quest, if repeated by enough people, could (and did) become as regulated and uniform as learning itself. 
 In time &bquo;Oriental sex&equo; was as standard a commodity as any other available in the mass culture. 
 (p. 190) 
 What makes the situation especially difficult in the case of homosexuality is that there are those who arm their homophobia by ignoring the first dimension described above &mdash; an exile which generates critique &mdash; insisting only on the second &mdash; the exile who flees one kind of discrimination only to reproduce others, and who is seen to do so in virtue of the alleged &bquo;predatory&equo; nature of the homosexual desire, now quintessentially defined as a desire to exploit the disadvantaged. 
 Decentring the Self in the Desire for the Other 
 For homosexuals more than most, the search for sexual freedom in the realm of the foreign has been inseparable from a repudiation of the &bquo;Western, culture responsible for their repression and oppression. 
 For some, as indeed for T. E. Lawrence, this entailed not just the rejection of a repressive social order, but a disidentification from it requiring nothing less than the relinquishing of the self as hitherto constituted and inhabited by that order. 
 In other words, precisely because of the Western integration of subjectivity and sexuality, deviant desire becomes also a refusal of certain kinds of subjectivity. 
 Of Pasolini's &bquo;growing passion for the Third World&equo; Enzo Siciliano says: &bquo;He had the idea that &bquo;Negritude&hellip; will be the way'&equo;. 
 One might say that in him an old cultural dream &mdash; exoticism &mdash; donned progressive clothes. 
 And it was true &mdash; progressivism was followed closely in his heart by the decadent enigmas of forgetfulness and oblivion' ( Pasolini , 263, 265). 
 As so often, &bquo;decadent&equo; is used here in a way evasive of what it gestures towards. 
 But the connection of transgressive desire with forgetfulness and oblivion is important and follows in a long tradition: religious, mystical, or romantic or some combination of all these. 
 It suggests too why the other of sexual fantasy may be stereotypical or two-dimensional in a way somehow at odds with the intensity and density of the desire which constructs it. 
 It also becomes an experience which indirectly registers the resilience of the individual's own immediate cultural past: forgetfulness and oblivion are the means of its escape, but become so in a way which register its continuing presence. 
 The case of Gide is once again exemplary. 
 I remarked in Chapter 1 his attraction to African landscapes as places where consciousness surrenders. 
 At the very end of his lite, writing again of the importance of how his experience as a homosexual had pushed him along the path of revolt, and recalling joyfully one of his lovers, Mala, Gide adds: 
 My most perfect memories of sensual delight are those enveloped in a landscape which absorbs it and in which I seem to be swallowed up. 
 In the one I have just  evoked of those transports with Mala, it is not only the beautiful swooning body of the child I see again, but the whole mysterious and fearful surrounding of the equatorial forest. 
 ( So Be It , 42, 126 &mdash; 7). 
 Such experiences of sexual liberation bear witness to the socially constructed &bquo;nature&equo; of identity with respect both to its contingency and its resilience: on the one hand the self can be and is experienced as radically different in the space of the other; on the other hand it the extinction of self is the precondition of passing into the ecstasy with and through the other, it is an extinction which has to be replayed over and again as a constitutive part of sexual ecstasy itself . 
 And if, as so oft en, ecstasy obliterates the specificity of the landscape which simultaneously enables and absorbs it, this is not only because ecstasy is of its nature blind; it is also because what we repudiate remains with us as partial blindness to what we embrace in its stead. 
 Those of Gide's travel journals published as Amyntas  are even more revealing of this process whereby loss of self becomes a discovery of self; both selves, the centred and the dispersed, being kept alive, both being necessary for the lyrical, unorthodox Western narrative which Gide maps on to the African landscape and his own illicit sexuality within it. 
 Amyntas: Desire and Loss  
 If ecstatic union with the other entails a liberating loss of inhibition and even loss of the self, by the very same token, it is then that desire may become most unaware of the plight of the other, especially when, as here, it is powerfully mediated through the pastoral genre. 
 Amyntas  is a pastoral narrative of self-redemption in relation to, in the desire for, and  in the space of, the other. 
 But just as the loss of self is the precondition for the discovery of a more &bquo;real&equo; because unconflicted, unrepressed self, so the precondition for pastoral sublimity is the loss of history, and once again the landscape which crystallizes desire, in such remarkable images, is also effaced by it: 
 i 
 &hellip; a child's laughter at the water's edge &mdash; then nothing, no misgivings, no thoughts&hellip; &mdash; What have I wanted until this day? 
 What had I feared?&hellip;  
 iii 
 &hellip; 
 The village stays the same: no one here wants more &mdash; no effort, no novelty. 
 Within these narrow lanes, no luxury compels such poverty to know itself. 
 v 
 &hellip; 
 Time passing here is innocent of hours, yet so perfect is our inoccupation that boredom becomes impossible. 
 vi 
 What have I sought till this day? 
 Why did I strive? 
 Now, oh now I know, outside of time, the garden where time comes to rest. 
 A tranquil country, sealed away&hellip; 
 Arcady! 
 I have found the place of peace. 
 x 
 &hellip; 
 No moving: Let time close over us like water&hellip; over this world, let the even surface of time close once again&hellip; 
 xi 
 &hellip; 
 Behind us, the patch of scorching crag that blocks the north winds; sometimes a cloud passes, a white tuft; hesitates, frays out until&hellip; absorbed by the blue air&hellip; 
 And ahead of us, nothing &mdash; the desert's variegated void. 
 xii 
 &hellip; 
 Here life is more voluptuous and more futile, and death itself less difficult. 
 (pp. 3 &mdash; 11) 
 It is not for long that death is less difficult, the histories of self and other lost, and consciousness unconflicted. 
 As the distilled purity of pastoral and the fullness of desire give way to the absences which constitute them, so the journals move towards disenchantment, the acknowledgement of loss, and a sense of the futility of returning in order to recover an original intensity of being: 
 six times I have returned to that country, demanding the past from the present, flogging my emotions, requiring of them, still, that freshness they once owed to novelty, and from year to year finding in my ageing desires rewards ever less vivid&hellip; 
 Nothing compares to the first contact. 
 (p. 1 15) 
 I have dreamed that I came back here &mdash; in twenty years. 
 I passed by, and was no longer recognised by anyone; the unknown children did not smile at me; and I dared not ask what had become of those I had known, whom I feared to recognise in these bent men exhausted by life. 
 (p. 141) 
 The narrative suggests a movement into time which is also a fall into knowledge and loss of innocence (p. 143). 
 Yet there are also brief moments of recovery, moments of gratified desire and a coming to life: &bquo;on this abandoned divan, I shall inhale for a long while still the earthy, vegetal smell which the faun left behind; then, in the morning, wakened at dawn, I shall fling myself into the delicious air&equo; (p. 104). 
 Occasionally he finds a transcendence of ardour, an equilibrium beyond desire &mdash; &bquo;the disappearance of desire and the renunciation of  everything&equo;, a time innocent of hours, a perfect inoccupation in which boredom becomes impossible, a coming to life which is a loss of consciousness: &bquo;I dissolve, I evaporate into blue air&equo;; a being alive in a world where &bquo;death itself is less difficult&equo; (pp. 101, 105, 107, 111). 
 The most extraordinary moments traverse conventional divisions, occurring both in Edenic gardens (pp. 112, 146 &mdash; 7) and the drug-induced languor in darkened recesses of caf&eacute;s: &bquo;to linger there&hellip; 
 Abd'el Kader, leaning toward me, points to the sole ornament on the white wall, hanging in the center &mdash; a hideous, shapeless, childishly daubed doll, and says in a whisper: &bquo;The Devil'&equo;. 
 Time trickled by' (p. 102). 
 The last travel journal ends with Gide back in Cuverville dreaming again of a loss of self &mdash; &bquo;to be rid of oneself, so that one blue breath, in which I am dissolved, might journey on&hellip;! &mdash; a dissolution which would redeem loss, but only by disavowing the recognition that what is most intensely desired is lost to the past. 
 Redemption and disavowal are not compatible and the final lines suggest the yet severer knowledge that desire is of its nature the desire for what is lost: 
 In Normandy's autumn, I dream of the desert spring&hellip; 
 The rattle of the palm fronds! 
 Almond trees humming with bees! 
 Hot winds, and the sugary savor of the air!&hellip; 
 The squalling north wind beats against my windows. 
 It has been raining for three days &mdash; Oh! how lovely the caravans were those evenings in Touggourt, when the sun was sinking into the salt. 
 (p. 155) 
 There is in these travel journals a movement towards the recognition that the most acute form of nostalgia is that which, in evoking the past as lost fullness, then faces it with the knowledge that the restless incompleteness felt so acutely now, in the present, was also a part of the imaginary fullness then; the truthfulness which aims to allay nostalgia only intensifies it. 
 Even with such insight it has to be said: we go to the exotic other to lose everything, including ourselves &mdash; everything that is but the privilege which enabled us to go in the first place. 
 That privilege needs to be understood in diverse ways. 
 Gide was, at least at that time, the sexual tourist of which Said and others have written, his opportunity to come and go enhanced by what is aptly if euphemistically called independent means. 
 His privilege and independence might further be seen to confer the trappings of a &bquo;humaneness&equo; which in truth was only a benign counterpart of the more brutal colonialism that appalled him. 
 Further, what kind of indifference to (cultural) difference made Gide so confident Athman could survive in Paris? 
 Was he really so unaware of those difficulties experienced by the person of colour in white European  culture &mdash; difficulties of which Frantz Fanon was to write so compellingly fifty years later in Black Skin, White Masks , and in relation to France specifically? 
 The destructive psychic and social conditions Fanon describes would have been compounded in the case of Athman. 
 It is all too revealing that, searching through the biographical work on Gide for further references to Athman in Europe, I came across hardly anything except the occasional derogatory, passing remark. 
 When Athman did re-emerge into visibility, it was once again as someone embroiled in the struggles of others, and, now along with Gide, subjected to the homophobic sneer. 
 Consider, for instance, how Rupert Croft-Cooke, out to discredit Gide's account of Wilde's seduction of him (Gide) into a confirmed homosexuality (above, Chapter 1), writes of Gide that he &bquo;picked up (among others) the Algerian boy prostitute Athman, who became known to other visiting Europeans, including Eug&egrave;ne Rouart and Francis Jammes and was brought to Paris by Henri Gh&eacute;on&equo;. 
 I would remark yet a further factor relevant to race and colonialism, one which raises again the always ambiguous status of the aesthetic, and inseparably from its achievements: Gide is in Africa as a writer discovering and nurturing a creativity of itself intrinsically exploitative. 
 In retrospect then it is the final remark in that poignant description of Athman by the river which is the most telling: &bquo;tor a long time as the train was carrying me away, I watched his little motionless, grief-stricken figure, lost in the desert, an image of my own despair &equo;. 
 It is an image encountered by Gide, but also projected by him, familiar and unforgettable as an evocation of the sadness which pervades the history of illicit love. 
 It is also an image which tells us that, it Gide's contribution to the liberation of the subjugated was as a writer, it is also true that he exemplified the writer's inevitably exploitative relation to the same, and that this exploitation persists as an aesthetic mode long after the blindness or impossibility of desire was acknowledged. 
 The &bquo;mature&equo; writer not only survives those renunciations, they help constitute his art, an art which will always finally take priority over the plight of the other even if, as was the case with Gide, it also succeeds in mitigating it. 
 But I would hope to reinscribe all of this knowledge within Gide's narratives of sexual liberation without surrendering or denying their affirmations &mdash; I was about to say tenderness &mdash; and to do that in part by acknowledging that it is a knowledge implicit in or enabled by Gide's  own transgressive crossing of some forbidden boundaries. 
 Here the example of Frantz Fanon becomes instructive. 
 Fanon: Race and Sexuality 
 Fanon's analysis of racism and &bquo;negrophobia&equo;, and his articulation of the predicament of the person of colour living in, or in relation to, white culture, is also instructive for understanding sexual discrimination, especially homophobia, and the predicament of the gay person living in, or in relation to, heterosexual culture. 
 My own study is indebted to Fanon's analysis of how discrimination is internalized psychically and perpetuated socially between  subordinated groups, classes, and races &mdash; what, in relation to the latter, he calls &bquo;the racial distribution of guilt&equo; ( Black Skin , 103); also to his realization of the way the demonizing of the other is, above all, a mercurial process of displacement and condensation, so fluid yet always with effects of a brutally material, actually violent kind. 
 Even so, there can be no facile equation of racist and sexual discrimination, and this for three main reasons which, even as they preclude that equation, emphasize the significance of those points at which race and sexuality interconnect, and the particular importance of Fanon's work in this respect. 
 First, as Mercer and Julien remind us, such an equivalence tends to obscure exactly those differences which need to be addressed if we are to understand not only each kind of discrimination separately but also their interconnections (&bquo;Race, Sexuality and Black Masculinity&equo;, 99 &mdash; 100). 
 Second, Fanon offers a kind of cultural critique which mostly pre-empts facile politics per se . 
 Homi Bhabha, in a significant essay arguing the urgent need to re-engage with Fanon in and for our own time, shows why. 
 Bhabha writes of how Fanon &bquo;speaks most effectively from the uncertain interstices of historical change: from the area of ambivalence between race and sexuality, out of an unresolved contradiction between culture and class; from deep within the struggle of psychic representation and social reality&equo; (foreword to Fanon, Black Skin, White Masks , p. ix). 
 It is from these uncertain interstices that there emerge Fanon's challenges to Enlightenment &bquo;Man&equo;, and indeed to the very idea of an essential human subject; Bhabha finds in Fanon a powerful and subversive sense of identity as involving a split, precarious, contradictory relation to the Other, the upshot of which is a radical ambivalence, destructive but also potentially empowering. 
 The third reason why there can lie no facile equation of racist and sexual discrimination via the appeal to Fanon concerns the place of  sexuality, especially homosexuality, in his own writing. 
 Fanon is surely right to stress the sexual component of racism, especially its destructive effects on (hetero) sexual relations across race. 
 He stresses also the white person's fear of and fascination with the imagined sexual potency of the negro: &bquo;For the majority of white men the Negro represents the sexual instinct (in its raw state). 
 The Negro is the incarnation of a genital potency beyond all moralities and prohibitions&equo; (pp. 1 59, 164, 177). 
 Also the ways in which, as a result, the negro &bquo;has been fixated in terms of the genital&equo; (pp. 157, 165), and the corresponding displacement on to the person of colour of inadequacies and fears intrinsic to the cultural  as distinct from natural formation of European sexuality (pp. 1 57, 165). 
 Despite all this, Fanon deploys some of the worst prejudices that psychoanalysis has been used to reinforce: &bquo;All the Negrophobic women I have known had abnormal sex lives&hellip; 
 And besides there was also an element of perversion, the persistence of infantile formations: God knows how &lsqb;blacks&rsqb; make love! 
 It must be terrifying.&equo; 
 Of the white woman's negrophobic fear of rape by the black man Fanon asks: &bquo;Basically does this fear  of rape not itself cry out for rape? 
 Just as there are faces that ask to be slapped, can one not speak of women who ask to be raped?&equo; 
 Fanon's apparent ignorance and misrepresentation of women and feminine sexuality has been remarked before; less so his equally problematic representation of homosexuality, and the way he slides from the one to the other: &bquo;the Negrophobic woman is in tact nothing but a putative sexual partner &mdash; just as the Negrophobic man is a repressed homosexual.&equo; 
 The homosexual is implicated all ways round, and according to some fairly crude psychoanalytic binaries. 
 So, whilst in the foregoing passage repressed  homosexuality is construed as a cause  of a violent and neurotic racism, elsewhere Fanon regards manifest  homosexuality as an effect  of the same neurotic racism, though now in a masochistic  rather than a sadistic  form, and especially the masochistic relation of the white man to the black man: &bquo;There are, for instance, men who go to &bquo;houses'&equo; in order to be beaten by negroes; passive homosexuals who insist on black partners' (pp. 158, 156, 177). 
 He attributes an implied or assumed absence of homosexuality in Martinique to the absence of the Oedipus complex in the Antilles. 
 Of certain transvestites there Fanon is anxious to assure the reader of their masculinity, and that they lead &bquo;normal sex lives&equo;. 
 He adds: &bquo;In Europe, on the other hand, I have known several Martinicans who became homosexuals, always passive. 
 But this was by no means a neurotic homosexuality: For them it was a means to a livelihood, as pimping is for others&equo; (p. 180). 
 Of the &bquo;Fault, Guilt, refusal of guilt, paranoia&equo;  which Fanon sees (surely correctly) as symptomatic of racism, he adds &bquo;one is back in homosexual territory&equo; (p. 183). 
 And in the process of contesting racist representations of the negro's &bquo;sensuality&equo; Fanon adds: &bquo;I have never been able, without revulsion, to hear a man  say of another man: &bquo;He is so sensual!'&equo; 
 I do not know what the sensuality of a man is. 
 Imagine a woman saying of another woman: She's so terribly desirable &mdash; she's darling' (p. 201). 
 In short, there are places in Fanon's writing where homosexuality is itself demonized as both a cause and an effect of the demonizing psychosexual organization of racism which Fanon elsewhere describes and analyses so compellingly. 
 Such constructions of homosexuality in relation to race and racism are not specific to Fanon. 
 The myth that homosexuality is &bquo;the white man's disease&equo; persists today in some black communities, especially in certain kinds of political radicalism and nationalism. 
 Cheryl Clarke cites from a leaflet distributed at a Black Liberation Movement meeting in 1981: &bquo;Revolutionary nationalists and genuine communists cannot uphold homosexuality in the leadership of the Black Liberation Movement&hellip; 
 Homosexuality is a genocidal practice&hellip; 
 Homosexuality does not birth new warriors for liberation&hellip; &lsqb;it&rsqb; is an accelerating threat to our survival as a people and as a nation.&equo; 
 Clarke further remarks how here too homophobia often connects with misogyny. 
 She also makes the crucial point that it is wrong to attribute it to the mass of black people, finding it most marked among some intellectual and political leaders, who also obscure the central roles played by lesbians and gays in black communities. 
 By contrast, says Clarke, the poor and working class within those communities have often been more accepting of those &bquo;who would be outcast by the ruling culture &mdash; many times to spite the white man, but mainly because the conditions of our lives have made us empathic&equo;. 
 The point made earlier about the potential empathy of the sexual outcast is here made in reverse &mdash; about a community in relation to him or her. 
 Those points of apparently incommensurable differences between groups, classes, nations, races, or whatever have been negotiated hesitantly and all too oft en anonymously by the outcasts and the deprived from either side. 
 These are fragile empathies, too important to be either romanticized or ignored. 
 Another difficulty concerns the relations between politics and what has been called &bquo;Black Macho&equo;. 
 Again, the homosexual perspective is revealing. 
 Jean Genet responded to an erotic charge in Arab and black masculinity inseparable from the recognition of its significance in a  culture of resistance and fight for liberation. 
 As we shall see shortly, this is another point of identification between the different, one which suggests that the masculinities of any culture, black, Arab, or white, cannot be grossed up as always and only homophobic. 
 But it this &bquo;assumption of&hellip; manhood&equo; (Fanon, Black Skin , 41) has constituted an agency of resistance &mdash; no small achievement when one recalls the crippling effects of domination and exploitation at the subjective level, effects which Fanon himself charts &mdash; it is one which perpetuates, in terms of sexual and gender relations, the very oppression being resisted at other levels. 
 There is an analogy here with working-class culture, black and white, where masculinity has also been a source of resistance, but once again at the expense of ratifying a larger exploitative framework for men as well as women. 
 As Jewelle Gomez has observed, homophobic prejudice is particularly dangerous for the black lesbian. 
 Hers is a vulnerable yet crucial role as negotiator between difference: typically she is one who refuses to outcast herself from the black community and family, because aware of its value and importance, yet by virtue of that same tact subjected within them to sexual discrimination: &bquo;we straddle the fence that says we cannot be uplifters of the race and lesbians at the same time&equo; (&bquo;Talking about It&equo;, 54). 
 Race and Humanism 
 The task Gomez envisages for the black lesbian returns us to radical humanism, and both Fanon and Gide as important points of reference. 
 Homi Bhabha finds that Fanon most profoundly evokes the colonial condition not in his yearning for &bquo;the total transformation of Man and Society&equo;, nor in his appeal to the human essence (though &bquo;he lapses into such a lament in his more existential moment&equo;), but in his understanding of the workings of &bquo;image and fantasy &mdash; those orders that figure transgressively on the borders of history and the unconscious&equo; (foreword to Fanon, Black Skin , p. xiii). 
 Perhaps the two interconnect more closely than this suggests &mdash; as they did with Gide. 
 Gide's narrative of a development from the desire for self-redemption in the space of the other, through the loss of self at the ecstatic height of this existential quest, to the unresolved sense of desire itself as a kind of loss, is amenable to a similar analysis; in Gide's case image and fantasy do indeed figure transgressively on the borders of history and the unconscious. 
 Even of that first ecstatic experience with Mohammed in 1895 he would write much later, &bquo;Every time since then that I have  sought after pleasure, it is the memory of that night I have pursued&equo; ( If It Die , 283). 
 Nevertheless, those &bquo;most perfect memories of sensual delight&equo; ( So Be It , 126 &mdash; 7) remained a strength, the impetus for a nonconformist humanism which, precisely because of its universalist aspirations, provides further identifications beyond sexuality. 
 In their humanism at least Fanon and Gide may be compared. 
 Bhabha is critical of Fanon's nonconformist humanism, especially its essentialist fantasies of the self and the yearning for total transformation which they partly enabled. 
 On the penultimate page of Black Skin, White Masks  Fanon declares that one of the things that he, the man of colour, wants is &bquo;that it be possible for me to discover and to love man, wherever he may be&equo;. 
 And he asks: 
 Why not the quite simple attempt to touch the other, to feel the other, to explain the other to myself? 
 Was my freedom not given to me then in order to build the world of the You? 
 At the conclusion of this study, I want the world to recognize, with me, the open door of every consciousness. 
 (pp. 23 1 &mdash; 2) 
 Homi Bhabha finds here an &bquo;existential humanism&hellip; as banal as it is beatific&equo;, adding: &bquo;there can be no reconciliation, no Hegelian &bquo;recognition'&equo;, no simple, sentimental promise of a humanistic &bquo;&bquo;world of the You''&equo; (pp. xx &mdash; xxi). 
 He suggests that such tendencies occur here as an overcompensation for the closed consciousness or &bquo;dual narcissism, to which Fanon attributes the depersonalization of colonial man; that &bquo;it is as it Fanon is fearful of his most radical insights&equo; (p. xx). 
 I would regard Fanon's humanism otherwise. 
 Certainly it is quite different from the timid and time-serving humanism all too familiar within &bquo;Eng. 
 Lit.&equo;. 
 More importantly, it is also utterly different from, and indeed envisioned in direct opposition to, the colonial history of humanism. 
 A reassessment of Fanon's humanism has become necessary for reasons similar to my reconsideration of Gide's and others' essentialism in sexual politics. 
 Benita Parry argues that the most influential recent analysis of colonialist discourse encounters certain problems inseparable from its anti-essentialism and anti-humanism; in particular its tendency has been to obscure &bquo;the role of the native as historical subject and combatant, possessor of an-other knowledge and producer of alternative traditions,, and to &bquo;limit native resistance to devices circumventing and interrogating colonial authority&equo; (Parry, &bquo;Problems&equo;, 34). 
 Parry sees the problem which Fanon addressed as precisely that of how to constitute self-identity in a way which validates native difference, and thereby empower the native to rebel. 
 In the process Fanon might be said  to have overestimated the extent to which, from subordination, it is possible to construct &bquo;a politically conscious, unified, revolutionary Self, standing in unmitigated opposition to the oppressor&equo; ( Problems , 30). 
 Or, put slightly differently, in imagining that self, he builds into it too much of the oppressor's culture &mdash; i.e. precisely that which needs to be destroyed. 
 Note how, in an utterly different context, we encounter again some of the same charges brought against Gide and others with their sexual essentialism. 
 But, as with them, so with Fanon: the criticisms underestimate the extent to which an oppositional humanism transforms in the process of appropriation. 
 Likewise with his existential emphasis, which closely relates to that humanism. 
 If, as Kobena Mercer suggests, white, middle-class sexual politics is over-preoccupied with the &bquo;self&equo;, and psychotherapy and psychology as its corollary (Mercer and Julien, &bquo;A Dossier&equo;, 123), Fanon offers an alternative whereby the existential dimension is rendered inextricably social, and on virtually every page. 
 The same existential emphasis made Fanon acutely aware that oppositional identities emerge not simply against, but from within, the terms of their oppression. 
 Thus Jean-Paul Sartre's dialectic relativizing of &bquo;Negritude&equo; (see below) is passionately reproached but not refuted. 
 Similarly, the self-evident fact that &bquo; the racist creates his inferior &equo; gives rise to a complex history, and the complex, ambivalent, conflicted identity of the subordinated ( Black Skin , 83). 
 So Fanon's oppositional humanism coexists with a demolition of one of the corner-stones of conventional humanism, the idea of a stable unified self. 
 Yet, crucially, this painful awareness of the historically constituted &bquo;nature&equo; of oppositional identities is not disavowed but itself reconstituted within and as  the humanist universal affirmation: &bquo;The negro is not. 
 Any more than the white man&equo; ( Black Skin , 93, 231). 
 This is one of the several moves whereby, for Fanon, &bquo;a native contest initially enunciated in the invader's language, culminates in a rejection of imperialism's signifying system&equo;. 
 As Parry adds, this is something which more recent colonialist discourse theory has not adequately considered (Parry, &bquo;Problems&equo;, 45). 
 Writing the preface to Fanon's The Wretched of the Earth  (1961) Jean-Paul Sartre remarked the violence and duplicity of European humanism in the colonial context; it had been, said Sartre, &bquo;nothing but an ideology of lies, a perfect justification for pillage; its honeyed words, its affectation of sensibility were only alibis for our aggressions&equo; (p. 21). 
 In the conclusion to that book Fanon himself put it thus: 
 Let us waste no time in sterile litanies and nauseating mimicry. 
 Leave this Europe where they are never done talking of Man, yet murder men everywhere  they find them, at the corner of every one of their own streets, in all corners of the globe. 
 for centuries they have stifled almost the whole of humanity in the name of a so-called spiritual experience. 
 (p. 251) 
 Against Mannoni's assertion to the contrary, Fanon insists that &bquo;European civilization and its best representatives are  responsible for colonial racism&equo; (p. 90, my italics). 
 Which means that the Third World's potential for transformation is crucially conditional on not  imitating or trying to &bquo;catch up with Europe&equo; (p. 252). 
 But, as The Wretched of the Earth  and Black Face, White Masks  both indicate, the social and psychic realities from which transformation will come are also those which require transformation; the dominant which the emergent contests always already informs the emergent; in short, there is no outside from which to make a totally new start. 
 For Fanon this means that, despite Europe's crimes, which will not and cannot be forgotten, the Third World's &bquo;new history of Man&equo; must &bquo;have regard to the sometimes prodigious theses which Europe has put forward&equo; since &bquo;all the elements of a solution to the great problems of humanity have, at different times, existed in European thought&equo; ( Wretched of the Earth , 253 &mdash; 4). 
 What is required in such a scenario is an insurrectionary appropriation so radical as to be also necessarily perverse: Fanon uses Hegel, Freud, and Sartre but in each case simultaneously contests and perverts fundamental principles of their thought. 
 Thus to have application to race the theories of Hegel and Freud must undergo radical critique and transformation; with some of Freud's followers, it is even the case of first having to discredit an overtly racist psychiatry (see e.g. Black Skin , 63, 138, 151 &mdash; 2, 220; Wretched of the Earth , 240 &mdash; 50). 
 So with humanism more generally and more radically: it is not to be imitated, not modified, not simply borrowed from or differently applied; rather, its appropriation and transformation is conditional upon its negation, the using of it destructively against itself. 
 What emerges from the space of humanism contradicts what once defined that space; in this sense Fanon can be said to have followed the path of the perverse: a negation of the dominant is made from a trajectory that emerged from it &mdash; a deviation from, which is also, simultaneously, a contradiction of. 
 The radical interconnectedness of culture is redeemed for a radical politics, and via transgressive reinscription. 
 This appropriation of European humanism was generous in a way inseparable from its shamelessness: the final manifesto of The Wretched of the Earth  makes it clear that the vision for a new humanity which emerges from the appropriation is undertaken on behalf of Europe  as well as the Third World. 
 But perhaps the generosity is best revealed in the anecdote rather than the manifesto: 
 At first thought it may seem strange that the anti-Semite's outlook should be related to that of the Negrophobe. 
 It was my philosophy professor, a native of the Antilles, who recalled the fact to me one day: &bquo;Whenever you hear anyone abuse the Jews, pay attention because he is talking about you&equo;. 
 And I found that he was universally right &mdash; by which I mean that I was answerable in my body and in my heart for what was done to my brother. 
 Later I realized that he meant, quite simply, an anti-Semite is inevitably anti-Negro. 
 ( Black Skin , 122) 
 Both The Wretched of the Earth  and Black Skin, White Masks  close with affirmations made in the knowledge of exactly what threatens them &mdash; that being, after all, what both books are about, and what powerfully pre-empts the charge of humanist sentimentality: &bquo;I can already see a white man and a black man hand in hand&equo; (Black Skin , 222). 
 Genet: &bquo;Risking a Sensibility&equo; 
 Obviously, the demonizing of the other is often inseparable from his or her exploitation. 
 But so too may be identification with the other, as Charles Marowitz implies when he describes Genet's The Blacks  as a play which champions blacks &bquo;not because they are socially downtrodden but because they personify two of &lsqb;Genet's&rsqb; favourite types: The Rebellious Outcast and The Splendid Primitive&hellip; 
 Genet uses the blacks, the way a man who has just emptied his revolver reaches for the knife at his side&equo; (&bquo;The Revenge of Jean Genet&equo;, 175). 
 Possibly, except that in homosexual culture it has rarely been, and certainly was not tor Genet, quite that simple. 
 Genet speaks of his own identifications across race and culture in an interview with Hubert Fichte in 1975:. 
 I was invited by two revolutionary movements, the Black Panthers and the Palestinians&hellip;. these two groups have a very strong erotic charge. 
 I wonder if I could have belonged to revolutionary movements, even if they were as just as &mdash; I find the panthers' movement and the Palestinians' movement to be very just &mdash; but this belonging, this sympathizing with them is at the same time dictated by the erotic charge which the Arab world in its totality or the black American world represents to me, to my sexuality. 
 Genet joined these movements because asked by them to do so. 
 But he made it clear that, in these identifications, desire and politics were inseparable. 
 That might plausibly be thought to take us no further than  Wilde in Algiers in 1895: &bquo;The beggars here have profiles, so the problem of poverty is easily solved&equo; (Wilde, More Letters , 129). 
 In Genet's case it produced among other things Prisoner of Love , a record of the time he spent with the Black Panthers's in the US and Palestinian soldiers in Jordan and Lebanon. 
 He began the book in 1983 and completed it shortly before he died, in 1986. 
 It is an extraordinary poetic meditation on desire, politics, loving, and dying. 
 In the same 1975 interview Genet declares that he had no choice but to identify with oppressed blacks since he too was black. 
 What such an identification involved becomes apparent in Prisoner  in a passage which renders the crucial difference not one of colour, yet by the same criterion reinstates the distinction between blacks and whites: &bquo;What separates us from the Blacks today is not so much the colour of our skin or the type of our hair as the phantom-ridden psyche we never see except when a Black lets fall some joking and to us cryptic phrase. 
 It not only seems cryptic; it is so. 
 The Blacks are obsessionally complicated about themselves. 
 They've turned their suffering into a resource&equo; (p. 46). 
 Throughout Prisoner  Genet again insists that his reasons for his identifications across race and culture were incorrigibly personal. 
 He says he completely failed to understand the Palestinian revolution (p. 3), that he could never completely identity with the nation or their movement (p. 90), that he participated for fun (p. 9), that his record of what happened is inaccurate (p. 19), that writing itself is a lie (p. 27) and memory unreliable (p. 39). 
 Even the revolution was unreal &mdash; &bquo;By agreeing to go first with the Panthers and then with the Palestinians, playing my role as a dreamer inside a dream, wasn't I just one more factor of unreality inside both movements?&equo; (p. 149). 
 But this is not exactly the blindness of desire, nor even the selective vision of fantasy. 
 First because in Prisoner  desire and fantasy seem transformed into nonsublimated social identification; as he puts it in relation to one group of black students in America, &bquo;while I never desired any particular person, I was all desire for the group as a whole. 
 But my desire was satisfied by the tact that they existed&equo; (cf. pp. 178 &mdash; 9). 
 Second because this is a kind of desire inseparable from an abundance of curiosity and attention; desire is curious, and attends in a way which renders desire itself an inappropriate word. 
 Genet is inclined to speak rather of a love which alters perception and complicates judgement, especially in relation to masculinity, and relations between men in the context of war and revolution. 
 A range of issues recur throughout Genet's book; I concentrate on masculinity only because of its problematic centrality in  contemporary considerations of race, homosexuality, and gender more generally, and because Genet's reflections on it often make other recent writing about it seem by comparison the simplistic and reductive pronouncements of a banal gender politics. 
 Genet regards the eroticism of the Black Panthers as manifest and inseparable from their politics and the challenge they presented to white America (pp. 259 &mdash; 60). 
 Moreover, despite their restraint, &bquo;the Black Panthers couldn't throw oft their mutual attraction. 
 Their movement consisted of magnetized bodies magnetizing one another.&equo; 
 As for the fedayeen, they &bquo;observed a smiling rigour. 
 But the eroticism was palpable. 
 I could sense its vibrations, though I wasn't bothered by it&equo; (p.126). 
 But this eroticism, and the masculinity of these men, frequently confounds the stereotypes. 
 Thus he says of Ali, a member of Fatah, &bquo;He knew I loved him, but it didn't make him the slightest bit arrogant. 
 It awakened his kindness&equo; (p. 267). 
 Genet speaks also of the kindness of the Panthers, which &bquo;brought me both real protection and education in affection&equo; (p. 83). 
 Different again is the dancing of the bedouin soldiers, at once chaste and erotic &mdash; &bquo;chaste because it takes place among men, mostly holding one another by the elbow or the forefinger&hellip; erotic because it takes place between men, and because it's performed before the ladies. 
 So which sex is it that burns with desire for an encounter that can never be?&equo; 
 In their dancing Genet detects a display, almost a confession, of the femininity that contrasted so strongly with their masculinity, and an acceptance of, even a desire for, annihilation. 
 Genet returns to this wish for death and martyrdom. 
 He is admiring of the soldiers' courage but not persuaded by their beliefs: training people to sacrifice themselves produces not altruism but a fascinated following of others to death not so much to help but merely to follow (p. 88). 
 And looking at the Palestinian revolution &bquo;trom a viewpoint higher than my own&equo; he regards it as ultimately a revolt reaching to the limits of Islam, a &bquo;calling for a revision, probably even a rejection, of a theology as soporific as a Breton cradle&equo; (p. 88). 
 Of the young Falangists, &bquo;something halfway between monks and hoodlums&equo;, singing of the Immaculate Conception and marching towards immortality: &bquo;I was enchanted. 
 I could calculate their cruelty from their stupidity&equo; (p. 32). 
 In others he finds both the impulse to self-sacrifice, and their masculinity, quite complex (p. 124). 
 One of the men who most attracts him, Mubarak, is also one whose sexuality is most self-conscious, withdrawn, and complicated; Mubarak's masculinity is itself strung out across difference: he is a Sudanese African in Asia, and fighting for a people whom he does not understand and who regard him with a racist  indifference (pp. 194 &mdash; 5); he speaks perfect French, but with a Parisian urban working-class accent. 
 Genet describes him as &bquo;so obviously both a pimp &mdash; a barracks or red-light district ponce &mdash; and a whore that I could never make out what he was doing among the fedayeen&equo; (p. 153). 
 Alternately ironic and sad, provocative and withdrawn, Mubarak shares Genet's gift for insightful reflection on the revolution and the socio-political forces at work within it and beyond. 
 He also exhibited a flirtatiousness aimed at everyone and everything, &bquo;a desire to charm &lsqb;which&rsqb; prevented him from being sufficiently implacable&equo; (pp. 152 &mdash; 3). 
 Yet later, after Mubarak's death, Genet discovers that he did not sleep with women or men; all of his sexuality was social: &bquo;the warmth of that voice had the shy yet imperious sureness of an erect penis stroking a beloved cheek. 
 In that too I saw him as an obvious heir to the boys of the old Paris suburbs&equo; (p. 143). 
 Perhaps that is also why Mubarak says, or at least why Genet recalls him saying, that if he wants his book ( Prisoner of Love ) to be read he must write it in &bquo;a voice that's sweet but inexorable&equo; (p. 151). 
 With the fedayeen, love always at once complicates and simplifies the narrative. 
 One of his most vivid memories is of three separate groups of fedayeen, each situated on a different hill, singing to each other just before dawn; it was a polyphony, &bquo;a great improvisation performed among the mountains, in the midst of danger&equo;, heedless of death, expressing and eliciting love (pp. 36 &mdash; 40). 
 Elsewhere Genet writes of a 19-year-old, washing the clothes of his friend who is shortly to go and fight, declaring that he loves the revolution and all the fedayeen, but his friend especially: &bquo;Yes. 
 It is love. 
 Do you think that at a time like this I am afraid of words?&hellip; if he dies tonight there will always be a gulf at my side, a gulf into which I must never fall&equo; (p. 87). 
 More than 200 pages later Genet writes &bquo;out of the crowd a glance swifter than a wink reveals two fedayeen as two lovers&hellip; 
 Chaste, but so close that if one of them is sad the laughter of the other immediately fills the void in him&equo; (p. 330). 
 These are Genet's reconstructions, and perhaps the gulf, the void, are his as well as the soldiers'. 
 If Genet is seduced by the magnanimity of the fedayeen, their selflessness, courage, humour, and love for each other, he is also perplexed and disillusioned by the inseparability of these qualities from an &bquo;underlying desire for self-slaughter, for glorious death if victory was impossible&equo; (pp. 271 &mdash; 2). 
 Surfacing from that perplexity, which is to say between, and sometimes within, the lyrical meditations on love, is the sense of a truly disturbing proximity of antagonists, most powerfully articulated in Genet's angry &bquo;fantasy&equo; of the palace and the shanty town:  
 one wonders which was real and which only a reflection. 
 Anyhow, if the Palace was the reflection and the shanty town the reality, the reflection of the reality was only to be found in the palace, and vice versa. 
 Getting to know the other, who's supposed to be wicked because he's the enemy, makes possible not only battle itself but also close bodily contact between the combatants and between their beliefs. 
 So each doctrine is sometimes the shadow and sometimes the equivalent of the other&hellip; 
 What sort of beauty is it these lads from the shanty town possess? 
 When they're still children a mother or a whore gives them a piece of broken mirror in which they trap a ray of the sun and reflect it into one of the Palace windows. 
 And by that open window, in the mirror, they discover bit by bit their faces and bodies. 
 (pp.58 &mdash; 62) 
 Regarding Difference 
 All the foregoing texts and histories suggest why theoretical or pseudopolitical gestures towards difference are inadequate. 
 As is (another recent development) separatist or essentialist &bquo;identity politics&equo; wherein one group seeks its own advantage at the expense, or ignorance, of others. 
 Still, I have no intention of prescribing a correct attitude towards difference, even less a correct theory of difference; I do not even know what the latter could possibly be. 
 My consideration of difference originated in a turn to history in order to repudiate one such theory &mdash; specifically, that which construed homosexuality as an embrace of the same because of a fear of the different. 
 It is a history which quite quickly produces that excess of difference which discredits the theory which ignored it but which also questions the theoretically facile celebration of difference per se . 
 My task has been to reconsider some of those complicated but always significant histories wherein differences conflict and converge as desire itself. 
 In doing so I wanted not to reduce, say, Gide's or Fanon's defence of difference to the limiting historical conditions of its articulation &mdash; the first as merely a sexual tourist, the second as developing a homophobic theory of Negrophobia. 
 Rather, I have wanted to recover the history of each in relation to the other, finding in the process that Gide understood more than most about desire for the different, Fanon more than most about the ambivalence of difference itself. 
 As for Genet, someone whose involvement with the different has variously been repudiated as fascist, racist, and anarchistic, his Prisoner of Love  is nothing less than an  affirmation of the love that Fanon envisaged and which has sometimes given the dissident their courage. 
 If I risk ending this long study of sexual dissidence by speaking of love it is without apology and simply to acknowledge its inspiration. 
 The Yeti 
 It was all the Yeti's doing when you come right down to it. 
 If it hadn't been for the Yeti, I'd never have met Malcolm McLaren or Johnie Rotten. 
 Pete Dawson was his real name but no one called him that At 15 he was six-feet tall, stroke for the rowing eight, and had loads of long hair. 
 He looked like a wild thing so we called him the Yeti. 
 We went to school together at St Clement Danes, an all-boys grammar school in West London, at the tail end of the period in which secondary education was split by the 11-plus into grammar schools for those who passed and secondary schools for the rest. 
 St. Clement Danes was an old-fashioned school which would have liked to have been more middle class than it was Unfortunately most of the kids came from the White City Estate  which is about as working class as you can get 
 As well as being a mate of Yeti's at school we worked together at Whiteleys, the department store in Queensway, on Thursday evenings after school and all day Saturday &mdash; for which we got paid the grand total of 36 shillings or &pound;1.80 today. 
 There was a whole gang of us who went out together at the weekends. 
 The particular Friday night when the Yeti sealed my fate, we went to an end-of-run party for the school play, Doctor Faustus  it was that year. 
 I'd worked on it as the slide projectionist One of the reasons we were all so keen on going to the party was that Faustus  was a joint production with the local girls school. 
 When you re at an all-boys school that is really important It s so hard to meet, let alone get off with, girls at an all-boys school. 
 Then, after the party we went along to see Man at The Lyceum. 
 It was an all-night show, the first I'd ever been to. 
 Ace were on the bill as well. 
 (It seemed &mdash; with Ace and Man &mdash; that the theme of the evening was Bands With Extremely Short Names.) 
 The bands started playing around 11 in the evening and, basically, people didn't go there for the music but to get a sleep if they lived too far out from central London to get home after the tubes had closed down for the night. 
 I remember standing at the back of The Lyceum and looking down at the crowd. 
 It looked like a bloody great sea of Afghan coats with tufts of long hair poking out from them. 
 (Before you ask no, I didn't have an Afghan coat,) There was nobody dancing or even moving very much. 
 The bar was shut. 
 And Man were playing. 
 They were OK in bursts but then they'd stand in on one of their boring, self-indulgent, 20-minute solos. 
 Not the most exciting of prospects maybe but even so, I was having a good time. 
 Then the Yeti suddenly produced all these blues &mdash; speed, amphetamine, call it what you like. 
 The rest of my mates steamed right into them. 
 But I didn't. 
 Not out of any idea that taking drugs was morally wrong but simply because I was already enjoying myself and didn't feel the need of any chemical additions to that enjoyment. 
 I hung around The Lyceum till early morning. 
 Then, when the show was over and it was time for everyone to wake up and go  home, they opened up the roof &mdash; the whole thing rolls back to one side. 
 It was one of those gorgeous early mornings when the sun has just risen but it's still dark enough to see the brightest stars. 
 We watched that for a bit, then took the first tube of the day round to a friend's place for a while. 
 Four or five of us were Whiteleys regulars so we all turned up there promptly for work. 
 But I was the only one who hadn't taken the blues. 
 It was a very old-fashioned store &mdash; which was hardly surprising as it was the first department store in London. 
 It certainly looked like it was. 
 There were a couple of things that I've never seen anywhere since, relics of Victorian engineering. 
 The service lift was water-powered. 
 Each time you wanted to go up or down you had to pull a chain. 
 It was like being in a loo that rose and fell. 
 The cash flow was regulated by an incredibly ancient compressed air system. 
 It must have been the last one left in London. 
 When someone bought something you put their money and their sales docket in a little aluminium container, placing it in a tube by your counter. 
 It would then whoosh straight off to the central cashiers' office. 
 There, they would check it off and whoosh it back to you with the customer's change and the docket stamped. 
 Basically, it was a late surviving example of 19th century employers' attitudes towards their staff: checking up on them all the time or they'd have their hands in the till, It was straight out of H.G. Wells' Mr Kipps . 
 That Saturday I was fine until the afternoon Then I began to feel totally spaced out. 
 Everyone else &mdash; because of the blues of course &mdash; was right as nine pence. 
 But I'd had no sleep and I was feeling it got worse. 
 I was really flagging. 
 I'd never felt that tired in my life. 
 I started to feel quite weird. 
 Suddenly the Yeti turned up in the men's department where I worked. 
 Here, Glen he said, you wont believe what's happened. 
 Some fucking idiot's cocking it right up. 
 They've been I putting the money into the tube and forgetting the dockets. 
 So they're up there in the cashiers' office trying to figure out where all the money's coming from. 
 It's total pandemonium up there. 
 The fucking idiot cocking it right up was yours truly of course. 
 I didn't hang around to take the blame, just worked that day out  and sloped off home. 
 I knew though that they'd work it out in the end so I was on the look-out for a new job. 
 A few days later I took a walk down the Kings Road, mostly searching for a pair of brothel creepers. 
 I'd been after a pair for ages. 
 I can't think why. 
 Maybe because the teddy boy fashion was just beginning to edge back in; it was around the time of Roxy Music's Spaceman Ted look. 
 Maybe it was because I'd seen Ronnie Lane of The Faces &mdash; who was my hero at that age &mdash; wearing a pair on TV. 
 Something as daft as that. 
 There I was strolling down the scrubby end of the Kings Road, mooching along. 
 Round the kink in the road after Beaufort Street market and there, on the right hand side, was a shop with a pair of creepers in the window 
 Let It Rock, it was called, Or maybe Too Fast To Live, Too Young To Die. 
 It had signs up for both so I never could work out which it was. 
 I walked inside and it was just like my granny's sitting room Not only did it sell teddy boy clothes but there was also a fifties radiogram and fifties wallpaper. 
 It was all put together with really good attention to detail. 
 Straightaway I thought; I need a job and this really looks like somewhere interesting to work. 
 As soon as I set foot in there, I knew that I had to be involved somehow. 
 So I asked them if they needed anyone to help out on Saturdays The guy behind the counter said, we do as it happens but you'll have to speak to Malcolm when he comes in. 
 Eventually this bloke turned up, the one he'd called Malcolm. 
 He was wearing some kind of rock &bquo;n&equo; roll suit, the sort of thing that Jerry Lee Lewis might have worn &mdash; or more likely the duds you'd see on a young country buck in one of those dreadful fifties US musicals like Carousel  or County Fair . 
 It was flecked cloth with zips down the side of the jacket &mdash; which looked absolutely horrible &mdash; and peg trousers. 
 At that time no one was wearing peg trousers. 
 He was selling teddy boy gear but what he was wearing &mdash; drecky as it was &mdash; had moved on beyond that into something new. 
 Before I even had a chance to talk to him he was all round the shop talking to everyone. 
 The strange thing was that he spoke to everybody with a different accent. 
 Sometimes posh sometimes  
 American. 
 What's up with this bloke? 
 I thought. 
 He can't seem to make up his mind who he is. 
 By the time he got to me his accent was thick Cockney, all &bquo;cor blimey&equo;. 
 He sounded like my granddad actually. 
 &bquo;Ere, what you bin doin' then, boy? he said. 
 Working at Whiteleys. 
 Whiteleys, eh? 
 That's where Brian Jones worked. 
 What else do you do? 
 I'm at school. 
 Why do you want to work here? 
 Well, I need a job. 
 And, as soon as I'd said that, I realised it was the wrong thing to have said. 
 What do you mean? he asked suspiciously. 
 Forget it, I said, For a moment I thought he was going to tell me to sling my hook. 
 Then he must have changed his mind. 
 Well, we do need someone, he said. 
 And that was that. 
 I was Malcolm McLaren's Saturday lad. 
 It wasn't that I was an amazing person or exactly the right guy for the job. 
 It was just that I happened to ask at the right moment. 
 They needed someone and I turned up asking. 
 The right face at the right time. 
 The bonus for me was that the money was so much better than Whiteleys, Instead of getting 36 bob for Thursday evening and all day Saturday, Malcolm paid me three pounds 10 shillings &mdash; almost twice as much &mdash; for the Saturday only. 
 Plus, while I had to get up at eight for Whiteleys. 
 I didn't have to get into Let It Rock until 11. 
 So I was well happy. 
 When I first started there I really felt like the proverbial spare prick at a wedding. 
 I turned up dressed in what I thought were my best clothes &mdash; a corduroy suit from Take Six with Oxford bags &agrave; la Trevor Eve in Shabby Tiger  which was on TV at the time Both of which were quite cool things to wear then. 
 Certainly nobody else at my school was wearing anything like that. 
 They were all into loon pants or being heavy duty skinheads. 
 But known. 
 The first day there I noticed all these queens waltzing in and out. 
 New experience for me, boy. 
 But I got talking to one of them and he told me he'd just come out of prison where he'd done  time for soliciting. 
 Blimy, I said, it must have for you in there. 
 Ooo no dear, he said. 
 All those rough men. 
 I loved it. 
 Quite an eye-opener for a 15-year-old grammar school boy from Kensal Green. 
 My parents called me Glen after the bandleader who took one too many cross-channel flights Swing was the music they'd grown up with and courted to. 
 So my name was a kind of tribute to their courtship. 
 My dad was a coach builder and my mum worked at the gas board. 
 We were never poor but it was no life of suburban luxury. 
 Respectable working class, that's the phrase they use about families like mine. 
 Reasonable jobs, best suit on Sundays and parlours as clean as operating theatres. 
 We had never moved, always living in the same place, 18 Ravensworth Road, Kensal Green A late Victorian artisan's house it was, a two-up-two-down with me and my parents on the top floor. 
 Bathtime meant filling a hot tin tub from kettles. 
 Downstairs in the other two rooms lived an Irish family. 
 We were always having rows with them about the back garden, territorial disputes over 15-square-feet of packed mud covered in cat shit. 
 My mother really looked down on them. 
 You know, she'd say, they cook their cabbage in the same water as the bacon. 
 Then, when I was 14, my dad bought the house. 
 Suddenly we had four rooms, a plumbed in bath and no poor Irish downstairs. 
 Kensal Green then was an old-fashioned, tight-knit working class community, the kind that had survived through thick and thin since Victoria was on the throne and that nowadays only exists in sociology textbooks and TV soaps. 
 A lot of our family lived in the same road. 
 Both my nan and my uncle Colin, my mum's brother, lived at number 28. 
 Them aside, though it was a small family. 
 Not only was I an only child but my dad's father was an orphan and my mum's family had been happy to get out of Kensal Town &mdash; which was a little down the road. 
 A real heavy duty place it was in those days  
 As I grew up in Kensal Green &mdash; which is just up the road from Ladbroke Grove &mdash; it became one of the areas the first wave of black immigrants came to. 
 Lots of West Indians. 
 Walk down the street and there was always Blue Beat coming out of a window. 
 We used to play football in the streets with the lead singer of The Skatalites &mdash; when we could entice him out. 
 I can't remember his name but he was something of a latecomer to the band. 
 They'd had their one hit with &bquo;Guns Of Navarone&equo; and he was the toaster by the time they were doing the small-time club circuit. 
 He lived in my mate Densil Alleyne's house. 
 Densil's mum let him a room. 
 We'd shout up from the street to him. 
 Hey, coming out to play football? 
 We never seemed to see anything strange in the fact that he was maybe 10 years older than us. 
 Alright, he'd shout back, soon as I'm finished with these two women now. 
 He d have these two hideous, fat, white women up there and when he'd finished he'd come down to play football in the street. 
 Always barefoot and with real hipster trousers which showed the cheeks of his bum. 
 It was a poor area. 
 Nobody had a flash car. 
 The best you saw were third-hand Morris Minors or &mdash; as we called them &mdash; Wogmobiles, Mark Two Zodiacs or Zephyrs with every conceivable extra. 
 Sun visors, whitewall tyres, furry dice hanging from the mirror, umpteen fog lamps, whiplash aerials, the whole bit. 
 Self-cleaning oven so far as I knew. 
 There was no major racial tension around but there was always a slight twist on the relationship with black people. 
 I was a little bit of a skinhead myself for a while. 
 I had the Sta Prest and I the short hair, and every party you went to it would be all Tamla and Blue Beat and ska. 
 But, although I heard that music, I never saw it as the kind of music I'd be involved in And that was because Kensal Green was a deprived place and the most deprived people were the blacks. 
 Terrible as it sounds, you didn't want to be associated with that deprivation It was a downer You wanted out There was no question of not liking blacks, it was a question of social standing. 
 If you wanted some, that wasn't the avenue to go down. 
 It had nothing to do with friendships though. 
 Phil Fearon, the soul singer, went to junior school with me. 
 I remember we all  went on a school trip to the Geffrye Museum of period furniture and costume in Hackney, East London. 
 They showed us a spinette and asked if anyone could play the piano. 
 Phil stepped right up and tinkled out Danger Man  and the theme from Robinson Crusoe . 
 (Years later, he came down to a jam with The Pistols when I thought we needed a keyboard player. 
 There was a funny atmosphere all the time he was there Then after he'd left, the other guys turned to me and said, what you doing bringing a sooty down?) 
 Another thing that cut me off from the other kids was going to the grammar school &mdash; and having to wear a bright green blazer every day. 
 There were quite a few Asian kids at the school but very few blacks &mdash; particularly few when you consider how black West London is. 
 Mikey Craig, from Culture Club, was one of the few. 
 I used to play football with him, Speedy Matlock, they used to call me. 
 I played full back, tearing up the wing &mdash; a right clogger, always kicking people in the air. 
 In fact it was something of a school for bass players. 
 Not only was there Mikey and myself but in the year above me was Gary Fraser, brother of Free's Andy Fraser, who played in Stray. 
 (The rest of Stray went to Christopher Wren &mdash; Steve and Paul's Alma Mater.) 
 That was the London of my childhood and youth. 
 A London that was still, 25 years after the event, recovering from the Second World War. 
 There were bomb sites around and a lot of it looked like something out of the Ealing comedies. 
 But this wasn't the London most people think of. 
 Mine wasn't the city of sophisticated, cosmopolitan life. 
 In some ways I might as well have been in the Outer Hebrides, Now everyone's got a car it's difficult to explain how isolated somewhere like Kensal Green used to be in those days. 
 It was a world unto itself, a working class community that existed quite separately from central London &mdash; which we thought of as Town, a totally different place. 
 It was only a few miles away but it seemed unimaginably distant. 
 Even Whiteleys. 
 That was at most a couple of miles up the road and no more than a few pence on the bus. 
 But to go there was to enter another world. 
 And Malcolm's shop, that was another universe.   
 Blind Lemon Matlock 
 Apart from liking London bands such as the Stones and the Kinks, for some reason I always had a working knowledge of the Small Faces. 
 I remember seeing them on Ready Steady go  and liking Ronnie Lane's smile. 
 Although I was really young I was struck by his attitude. 
 All bands smiled when they were on TV then. 
 But, while pop bands like The Tremeloes and The Searchers seemed to be smiling just because they were on TV and feeling famous, The Small Faces had much cooler smiles. 
 Their smiles were like a knowing wink: sussed and street-wise without being in the least dour or po-faced. 
 I cottoned on to that. 
 It wasn't so much a case of thinking: he looks a lovely chappie. 
 It was more now there's a cheeky chappie. 
 After that I went off music for a while. 
 Then one evening &mdash; I  must have been 12 or 13 at the time &mdash; we were driving back from visiting my nan in Kent. 
 The car was an old Morris Minor It didn't even have a radio fitted. 
 So we used to take a big old transistor with us and put it on the back shelf. 
 Every time the car went round a corner you had to turn the whole radio round to face a different way That was the only way you could get half-decent reception. 
 I was sitting there looking out of the window and suddenly this wonderful record came on. 
 It was &bquo;The Israelites&equo; by Desmond Dekker. 
 I kept on listening to the show. 
 It turned out to be the Mike Raven programme on Radio One. 
 He'd play all kinds of black music, everything from ska to soul and blues. 
 Strangely enough, I got into the blues. 
 He played one record I liked so much I decided to go out and buy it. 
 It was by Blind Lemon Jefferson. 
 A 13-year-old white kid living in Kensal Green going out to buy a Blind Lemon Jefferson album, I ask you! 
 The mates that I played football with were skinheads into Blue Beat while the girls were into that pop group The Love Affair. 
 They all went to the local comprehensive &mdash; which I wanted  to but, because I passed my 11-plus I got sent to the grammar instead. 
 That made me feel a bit of an outsider. 
 That bright green blazer we had to wear didn't help much either. 
 So, I suppose going out to buy Blind Lemon Jefferson was a deliberate search for something esoteric. 
 It was like finding my own identity by finding something different to like, something different to what all my friends liked. 
 But they didn't have the Blind Lemon album in the shop. 
 How about this instead? said the guy, showing me &bquo;The Story Of The Blues&equo;. 
 It had &bquo;Parchman Farm on it &mdash; country blues stuff &mdash; and city blues from the thirties like &bquo;Butterbeans&equo; and &bquo;Susie&equo;. 
 But it also went right up to the fifties. 
 Elmore James and Otis Spann, things like that. 
 I thought, hang on, this is more like it. 
 So I became the only bluesman in Kensal Green. 
 I already had a guitar. 
 &bquo;Guaranteed Not To Split&equo;, it said on it &mdash; which was just as well as much later I had the initial idea for &bquo;Anarchy&equo; while messing around on it. 
 I'd been given it when I was seven but I'd never learnt to play it. 
 Now I had the blues and playing it was suddenly all so easy  
 The blues really are elementary. 
 Three chords and you could play just about anything on the album. 
 I'd sit up in my room bashing out the blues like I was Blind Lemon Matlock. 
 Then, when I got fed up with that, I'd go downstairs and make a racket on the old upright piano my nan had lent us. 
 A lot of blokes say the reason they got into music in the first place was they thought it would be a great way of pulling women. 
 All those girls in the front row, that kind of thing. 
 But I reckon that's bravado on their part. 
 Most people in bands have quite similar backgrounds and I reckon a lot of them shared the same experience as I did. 
 And that idea never came into it. 
 Mostly, it was just a way of keeping myself occupied. 
 Going to grammar school really made me isolated It was only a couple of miles away from where I lived but that's a long way when you're only 11 &mdash; years-old and all your mates from junior school had gone to the local comprehensive round the corner. 
 Not only that &mdash; they also thought, because I'd gone to the grammar, that suddenly I was too snooty to be friends with them. 
 And, on top of that, all the new friends I made at the grammar lived out West, in Greenford or Ealing. 
 So, through no fault of my own, I was at a loose end quite a bit. 
 I felt ostracised quite honestly. 
 Starting to play music was a way round that It was a way of entertaining myself, passing the time. 
 No big mission, no feeling that I was going to change the world with my music. 
 That came later. 
 Around then I also got hold of a folk album by Pete Seeger and I remember being really struck by a track called &bquo;Goofing Off Suite&equo;. 
 I dug the idea of being free enough to just goof off from incessant maths homework. 
 Eventually I moved on from the blues, picking up on Ronnie Lane again, only by this time The Small Faces had become The Faces. 
 So, impressed by him, I got myself a bass guitar. 
 Which was absolutely stupid. 
 There is nothing worse than playing a bass guitar &mdash; without an amp because you can't afford one yet &mdash; all on your jack up in your bedroom. 
 The bass I had was awful as well. 
 A Rossetti. 
 I haven't seen one since. 
 The jack plug was soldered on &mdash; which meant you couldn't pull the lead out, you had to wrap the plug and lead  around the neck before you could put it away. 
 For me that meant wrapping it in a blue launderette bag which served as a case. 
 Some time later I got an amp as well It was as big a piece of junk as the bass &mdash; a Fenton Weill Mk II with a Goodman speaker, which is nothing but a cheap copy of the Ampeg Portaflex B15N. 
 (I sold it eventually &mdash; for 15 quid. 
 I was going on the school trip to the Norfolk Broads and needed some spending money.) 
 But, playing through the amp, I began to realise how daft it was sitting up in my bedroom by myself with it, trying to work my way through tunes. 
 I'm going to have to start playing with other people, I thought. 
 so I got together with a couple of blokes from school &bquo;Hold Your Head Up&equo; by Argent was in the charts at the time We'd play that again and again and again It was the only bass line I could play properly &mdash; because it's so simple, it's exactly the same all the way through. 
 We'd rehearse in the huts after school, having squared it with the music teacher. 
 The singer Steve Mariner, was a bloke in the choir with a really high voice who thought he was Jack The Lad. 
 You weren't allowed to smoke on school premises but he'd always light up while we were rehearsing. 
 One day, the Head of Sixth Form &mdash; a teacher called Don Palmer &mdash; came in and asked what we were doing. 
 He was obviously peeved that we'd squared it with the music teacher while he didn't know anything about it. 
 Anyway, Jack The Lad said, rehearsing, and blew smoke in his face. 
 The next day we were informed that we weren't allowed to use the huts again. 
 Jack The Lad, of course was right in the shit for smoking on school premises. 
 And that was the end of that band. 
 Except some time later there was a school dance. 
 Don Palmer asked if our band would play at it. 
 No, we said Why? 
 We're just not good enough we had nowhere to rehearse, you see. 
 That was basically spite, of course, but you always start as you mean to go on. 
 It was an odd period in music. 
 It was the time of progressive rock. 
 Led Zeppelin and Jethro Tull were meant to be a more intelligent kind of music which appealed to sixth formers, like me. 
 But they all looked like complete prats.  
 On the other hand, T. Rex might have looked really good but everything else about them was so na&iuml;ve and teenybopperish that you couldn't really admit to your mates that you liked them. 
 There just wasn't much British around that had an edge and at the same time looked good. 
 Just The Faces, maybe Slade and then Bowie really. 
 The biggest impact Bowie had on me was with his haircut. 
 I thought it was really something new. 
 I had shortish hair at the time. 
 Like all schools then there was a rule about long hair. 
 You were only allowed to have it down to just below the bottom of your ears &mdash; which looked absolutely daft. 
 I'd had enough of my hair looking like a toilet brush, so I always had it cut short &mdash; like Ronnie Lane's of course &mdash; which was less hassle. 
 Then came Bowie. 
 Straightaway I went off and had a bright red flash put in across the front of my hair. 
 When I got home my dad took one look at it and said, you look like a bleeding nancy boy. 
 He didn't talk to me for a week after that. 
 The next day in school all my mates started calling me Ginger. 
 Then came Pure Maths &mdash; with Don Palmer. 
 Not only had I had that run in with him over the rehearsals but he was also the fussiest teacher in the school when it came to long hair. 
 He stood there writing on the blackboard. 
 Then every now and again he'd turn round and stare at me, his mouth open, totally incredulous. 
 You could see his brain working I must be able to do something about this, he was thinking, but there was no rule against hair colour, only length. 
 I loved that, seeing him stuck for words. 
 It was like. 
 Gotcha. 
 I did my &bquo;O&equo; levels, and then my &bquo;A's but really I had no particular academic drive. 
 I never wanted to go to university although I do know, however, that my mum and dad always had it in the back of their minds that I would go. 
 But nor did I want to go out to work. 
 From somewhere I got the idea of going to art college I'm sure it was because I'd read about all the rock musicians who'd started their bands at art colleges &mdash; John Lennon and Keith Richards in particular. 
 I was interested in drawing but I never saw it as part of a potential career. 
 I went to art college for the music not for the art. 
 In fact, I only became a half decent painter after I got into art college.  
 Let it Rock 
 The particular premises that Let It Rock occupied had always been in the very vanguard of London fashion trends but working there wasn't as much of a shock as I thought it was going to be at first. 
 The way people looked was the most shocking thing. 
 They were all so done up and seemed so aloof., Yet, in fact they were really easy going and fine to get along with 
 I'm thinking of people like Jean Krell who co-ran Granny Takes A Trip the painter Humphrey Ocean and Bernard Rhodes the friend of Malcolm's who went on to manage The Clash. 
 They all came from similar backgrounds and, as like minds, they were all congregating at the same place for the same reasons. 
 They all used to hang out there and quite a scene had  developed Some of it had to do with it being the antithesis of the whole trash/sleaze thing that was going down at the start of the seventies. 
 Cockney Rebel had it a bit, and it was the time of the film Cabaret, The Rocky Horror Show  and Biba's nightclub on the roof of what used to be Derry and Toms Every other phrase in the newspapers seemed to be &bquo;Iounge lizard&equo;. 
 The cover of Bryan Ferry's second solo album &mdash; with him in a white tuxedo by a swimming pool &mdash; really sealed it. 
 That was what was supposedly chic. 
 Personally I thought it was a load of fucking cobblers and yet that was the swamp from which punk rock emerged. 
 You could tell that the real reason people came into the shop was to hang out. 
 Bernard Rhodes, for example, was always in the shop and he was always up for a chat I talked to him a lot and we struck up a rapport. 
 Bernie was seen as a bit of an oddball &mdash; although not by me &mdash; but he was very instrumental in getting The Pistols together, especially when Malcolm was away. 
 They'd been friends for some time when I first knew them but I didn't realise how long. 
 Bernie would always have it that he had known Malcolm since he was a mod in the sixties hanging out at &mdash; among other places &mdash; Eel Pie Island, where The Who and The Stones used to play. 
 I didn't believe him at first. 
 I thought he was having us on exaggerating &mdash; because there were always people hanging out, trying to crash Malcolm's scene. 
 But this time, it turns out he was telling the truth. 
 His line was that he'd lost contact with Malcolm because he could only stand to be with him for so long at a stretch. 
 Then he'd have to go off and do something else for a while before he could stomach being with him again. 
 They were like Little And Large in a way, but I never did work out which one was the straight man. 
 Bernie did one very important thing for The Pistols He made us focus our thoughts. 
 In the early days of the band, before John arrived, he'd beaver away at us in the pub, making us think through our attitudes We&equo; d be sitting there talking about music and he'd dive in. 
 Fucking hell, he'd say, you don't really like The Faces, do you? 
 Why? 
 And you'd have to think about it, then tell him. 
 But that was never enough. 
 Well then, he'd say, what don't  you like about them? 
 Well, Rod Stewart, he's a bit of a cunt. 
 Why  is he a cunt? 
 Bernie would go on and on at you like that, making you define and redefine your attitudes. 
 I remember having some really interesting discussions with him when we'd go and see a band somewhere. 
 All of us were checking new bands out the whole time. 
 For two reasons. 
 One, like any new band we were checking out the opposition. 
 Two, it was a strange time. 
 There was a rock &bquo;n&equo; roll vacuum. 
 We were looking for anybody who could help fill it. 
 There was almost a desperation about the way we'd try and fill our recreational time with something worthwhile. 
 There was always pub rock, in sweaty drinkers like The Kensington, The Torrington, The Hope And Anchor The Greyhound and The Nashville. 
 Mostly they were second-rate copies of the kind of American bar-room R&amp;B bands the members of these pub bands had seen in the days when they had a bit more going for them and had actually made it to the States one time in the late sixties or early seventies. 
 For the price of a pint, you could catch Bees Make Honey, Ducks Deluxe, The Tyla Gang or Brinsley Schwarz. 
 And many a night I spent at The Greyhound watching Brinsley Schwarz, diligently studying Nick Lowe's bass playing. 
 However, aside from the fact that their musicianship was pretty solid, these pub bands were still really mundane to a young kid looking further ahead. 
 Later there were bands like The Vibrators, The Stranglers and The Hammersmith Gorillas, horrors one and all, but pride of place in the pub rock pantheon went to Wilko Johnson's Dr Feelgood and the wonderfully esoteric Kilburn And The High Roads, featuring Ian Dury and kitted out courtesy of Let It Rock. 
 We were always out there looking for something new, trying to find any slight glimmer of someone with the same kind of ideas as us. 
 We'd go right out of our way in the search. 
 Once Bernie and I dragged right across town to a pub in the back of beyond in North London because we'd seen a gig advertised there featuring a band called The Teenage Rebels. 
 They were absolute rubbish. 
 They had no idea They were on a totally different wavelength from us. 
 We went looking for like-minds and found aliens. 
  Bernie went up to the singer after the show and said, we thought you were called The Teenage Rebels, yet you're not teenagers and you're certainly not rebellious. 
 That's the point, said the singer, we're rebelling against teenagers. 
 Bernie was speechless, for the first time since I'd known him. 
 Yet another wasted exercise, we thought. 
 Sometimes when we'd been out to clubs Bernie would give me a lift home to my parents', right out in Greenford where we'd moved just about the time I started keeping twilight hours. 
 Which was a right drag &mdash; Kensal Green was a quid cab ride from the West End which was within my pocket. 
 But Greenford was in Middlesex and many was the night I spent in the pissing rain having walked to Acton Town station to wait for the first train home in the morning. 
 And we'd sit there in the car for an hour or so, chatting through what we were trying to do. 
 It was like some kind of School Of Rock &bquo;n&equo; Roll. 
 Cor blimey Bernie, I said, you're just like my teacher. 
 I was half-joking, half-serious. 
 But he clammed up right after that. 
 If Bernie hadn't been around we would have been a band, and we would have been a good band but we wouldn't have been the  band. 
 He had a real ability for making people decide exactly what they were trying to say and do. 
 He put it all into practice with The Clash When he got Joe Strummer into The Clash he asked me what I thought of him. 
 He's alright, I said, but he's a bit old. 
 Don't you worry about that, said Bernie, I'll have 10 years off him. 
 And he was right, he did. 
 Next time I saw Joe he looked maybe not 10 years younger but certainly a totally different man and ready to rock. 
 What Bernie gave The Clash and us was an understanding of the importance of being clear-cut. 
 If you are, it's a real strength It's like going to buy a packet of peas. 
 you know exactly which brand you want, you go right to it without dithering around 
 Now this emphasis on focusing and honing everything right down to its simplest form can sound a bit like naked capitalism, treating rock &bquo;n&equo; roll as nothing more than a game. 
 But, if you want to be a success that s what you have to do. 
 You have to be really clear-cut about who you are and what you're trying to  achieve. 
 Bernie was wonderful at making us think all that through. 
 The shop was the hip place to hang out. 
 It was the temple for everyone who wanted to be involved in something that had nothing to do with what most people thought was &bquo;happening&equo; in that part of the seventies. 
 It was a world away from both glam rock and the soul boy look. 
 It was a place for people who wanted to stick their necks out. 
 Lots of people are fed up with the way their lives are headed but they don't often take the trouble to do anything about it. 
 Most of them just go with the flow, ending up as something like a gas fitter or a policeman. 
 Not that I have anything against gas fitters but I do think that to do what I did at 15 takes a bit more courage. 
 At that age everybody is down on you. 
 Your friends, your parents, your school, your peers, they all try and stop you going out into left field. 
 It's not a big deal in the scheme of things but you get an awful lot of hassle when all your mates are going to university, or start bringing home the bacon. 
 Meanwhile you don't feel that way inclined. 
 Suddenly it seems that only certain avenues are considered as suitable options for you. 
 So you're kicking against the pricks right from the start. 
 Just by opting for a more left field occupation you're putting yourself on the edge a bit It really does take a bit of bottle to do that and find your own way through the maze rather than just go with the flow. 
 All of which inevitably makes you more forward-looking. 
 Surprisingly, working in Malcolm's shop made me feel quite at home. 
 Not because I actually felt at home with all the &bquo;weirdos&equo; in there but because the shop really did look like my nan's house. 
 And that meant a lot to me at the time because all the paintings I was doing were subjects from my childhood years. 
 Not because I wanted to go back to my childhood but because I had a deep, healthy interest in finding out a bit more about what was happening while I was growing up. 
 As a film like Scandal , which dealt with the Profumo affair, might make young people go back and check out more about what  was happening in the early sixties, so I was doing the same in terms of the fifties. 
 I was really into checking out fifties style. 
 The general idea of the clothes was pretty well known: this was when Malcolm was selling updated versions of teddy boy clothes from the fifties. 
 When I started in the shop I was into digging out a bit more detail about it, finding out the kind of Arthur English-style kipper ties my granddad used to wear and the cars that were around then. 
 For example, I really liked the Jowett Javelin but by then they'd already pretty much disappeared. 
 About the only place you could see them was on the scrap heap. 
 So the very few that were still on the road I really treasured and appreciated seeing. 
 I was interested in all this for the simple reason that as something that takes your fancy passes you, you only get a glimpse. 
 Then, when you get the chance, you want to have a closer look and check it out. 
 Let It Rock did unbelievably good business Friday night or Saturday morning a lorry would turn up with a delivery of creepers &mdash; the very things that enticed me into the shop in the first place. 
 We'd stock up the shelves and by the middle of the afternoon all that would be left would be size 14s in puce and some size fives that maybe a girl would pop in and buy for a party just before we shut. 
 A lot of money was generated by that , I know. 
 Tommy Roberts used to phone me on a Saturday when I first started working there. 
 He'd been the man behind Mr Freedom, the shop that was the first place to sell T-shirts with slogans printed on them. 
 Nik Cohn, the writer, described him as, &bquo;an amiable fatman from Catford, a bit of a slag and conspicuously so but shrewd, funny and hard to dislike.&equo; 
 I can't improve on that. 
 At the time he'd just started City Lights, a new shop in Covent Garden. 
 This was well before it became a tourist attraction, when it was still a fruit and veg market. 
 Tommy's always been one step ahead. 
 Often one step too many for his own good. 
 He managed lan Dury before Dury was famous, and City Lights provided the suit that David Bowie wore on the cover of &bquo;Pin Ups&equo; and which people were forever coming into Let It Rock trying to get copied, much to Malcolm's chagrin. 
 Tommy'd ask me how much money we'd done that day. 
 I was the Saturday lad, he was  a mate of Malcolm's, what did I know? 
 So I'd tell him. 
 It was a grand or more each time. 
 Eventually Malcolm realised I was telling Tommy and put me wise about how fly fat slags from Catford can be. 
 Next time Tommy asked I kept my mouth shut. 
 Malcolm also slowly moved into made-to-measure tailoring, probably because of teddy boys coming in and asking for stuff to be made up. 
 Then he moved on from that, into what he called Alan Ladd suits. 
 They were pretty much the style of suits that people wear now &mdash; double-breasted with peg trousers &mdash; but then they were something of a revolution. 
 Like most of the clothes Malcolm sold they were beautifully made, of pale coloured gaberdine. 
 I always really wanted one but the trouble was they were 70 quid a pop, which I certainly couldn't afford on a Saturday lad's money &mdash; even the Saturday lad's money that Malcolm paid. 
 Another line was what he called his jazz suits. 
 They were made of City Gent-type striped cloth and had even more violently pegged trousers. 
 The jacket was very fitted and single-breasted, cutting in sharp at the waist &mdash; which made the trousers balloon right out. 
 It looked like something you might see in a photograph of black New Orleans in the thirties. 
 (Which is probably exactly where Malcolm got the idea from.) 
 It was nothing really radical in terms of modern design &mdash; even apart from Malcolm having adapted it from a picture &mdash; but it had great presence. 
 Like an awful lot of other things Malcolm worked on. 
 This is where I was first introduced to Paul Cook and Steve Jones, both of whom were regulars in the shop. 
 They'd get off the bus from West London there because they were such big Faces fans and Malcolm's shop was right next door to the home of the dandy fashion shop Granny Takes A Trip &mdash; a shop which had a Cadillac sticking out of its window &mdash; where The Faces and The Stones bought their clothes 
 Steve was a new face to me but Paul I already knew from playing football against him down at the Lillie Road recreation  ground. 
 There was a little five-a-side league there. 
 He was a good footballer and he always looked a bit weird with his striking blond hair However, there was something of a monkey-like mischievousness about him. 
 Whenever they came into the shop Steve'd be on about: where's the action? 
 Bernie got absolutely sick of him. 
 Blimey, he said, if that bloke asks where the action is one more time I really don't know what I'll do. 
 If we knew where the action was, do you think we'd be sitting around here? 
 I knew they had a band because Malcolm would talk to them about it. 
 How's it going? he asked one day. 
 Blinking Del, they said. 
 Del was Paul's brother-in-law and supposed to be their bass player. 
 He hardly ever turned up though and when he did &mdash; despite being married to Paul sister &mdash; he'd bring girls with him to bolster his ego. 
 Now he was someone whose only real interest in pop music was the girls in the front row. 
 Del just had to go, they told Malcolm. 
 We've got to find a new bass player. 
 Coincidentally I'd just told Malcolm that I was a bass player &mdash; although at this point I was only mucking around by myself at home &mdash; so Malcolm told them. 
 It was as simple as if they'd asked him if he knew a good plumber. 
 Again right face, right time. 
 We happened to meet up that very night, at The Marquee where we'd all gone to see Thin Lizzy. 
 Fancy a try-out with us? they said 
 Okay. 
 Then come down to Wally's tomorrow afternoon 
 Wally's real name was Warwick Nightingale resident of Hemlock Road, East Acton He had a Rod Stewart haircut, feather cut and shaggy, and mostly he'd dress in Granny Takes A Trip kind of clothes with maybe one thing added from Malcolm's shop, a pair of creepers perhaps. 
 He had the most disgusting rotten teeth and horn rim glasses with milk bottle lenses. 
 On a good day he looked like a mixture of Rod Stewart, Steve Jones and Buddy Holly. 
 He went to the same school as Steve and Paul, Christopher Wren. 
 One of the reasons they all became friends was that Wally's mum and dad didn't mind that he bunked off school all  the time. 
 Paul's house was always full of people and Steve didn't really have a home at all &mdash; when his mum remarried, his stepfather couldn't stand him and didn't want him around. 
 So, as far as I can work it out, they found it was cool to go round to Wally's and hang out, particularly as the school was only just round the corner from his place So they'd sit there doing very little and getting bored. 
 But, of course, the devil finds work for idle hands, and they began thieving, acquiring all manner of things but particularly musical equipment When they realised it was mostly too hot to sell they thought maybe it wasn't such a bad idea to learn how to play the stuff they had thieved. 
 Paul took up the drums, Steve sang and Wally became a guitarist, not a bad one either, very much in the Ron Wood school. 
 As they were so into The Faces they'd go down to Richmond. 
 to Sir John Mills' old house which Ron Wood had just bought. 
 Keith Richards used to stay in the little cottage at the bottom of Ron's garden. 
 Steve and others would get in there, rifle around it, have a go on one of Keith's guitars, nick a shirt and leave a little note saying, &bquo;Steve was here.&equo; 
 That was their fun of a Saturday night. 
 Wally was an odd bloke though. 
 I always thought he fancied himself as a bit like a character in a war film, The Dambusters , Bomber Harris maybe. 
 He was like the bloke who you saw right through the film overseeing the whole operation, just standing there sticking little pins into a map. 
 I could never really work out the basis of his friendship with Steve and Paul They were pretty street-wise while he was just odd. 
 Strange bedfellows. 
 But his parents' place in Hemlock Road was their base for a long time. 
 They'd go round there and have meetings over cups of tea. 
 It was there I first auditioned for the band. 
 His dad who was always popping in asking if anyone wanted to come down the pub &mdash; he was always off to the pub &mdash; also wrote the lyrics to our first song, &bquo;Scarface&equo; They were truly horrendous: &bquo;Scarface, scarface, scarred from ear to ear, Scarface, the girls don't even care. 
 Terrible. 
 We knew they had to go so we messed around with it. 
 In time to come, John would add some new words all about a bird he  knew who kept trying to commit suicide: &bquo;Blood on the ceiling blood on the walls, blood on the floor.&equo; 
 That wasn't the ticket either. 
 Finally Paul came up with an idea, &bquo;Did You No Wrong&equo;. 
 But we stuck with the same tune that Wally had come up with. 
 If you listen to &bquo;Did You No Wrong&equo;, you can hear The Faces influence. 
 It's a real Ron Wood lick which is what Wally was all about. 
 In those early days we were a real sub-Faces band, all Gibson guitars and plonking bass lines. 
 That was the common ground between us; the reason I got the job in the first place was because I could play The Faces' &bquo;Three Button Hand Me Down&equo;. 
 Wally was in the band a couple of years. 
 It was during that time we all learned to play properly. 
 It took a hell of a long time but learn we did. 
 The line-up was Paul on drums, me on bass, Wally on guitar and Steve singing. 
 Later on Steve got &mdash; what do I mean got, he stole it &mdash; another guitar and started playing as well as singing. 
 Gradually his playing became better than his singing. 
 The very first proper rehearsal I had with them was in the Covent Garden Community Centre. 
 Wally s dad was there, pissed as usual. 
 In fact, when he drove us home he was in such a state I had to get out of the van. 
 As we walked down towards the community centre they all stopped off somewhere to steal some cymbals. 
 I thought, fucking Ada who are this crowd? 
 After that we spent a lot of time practising in what later became Riverside Studios. 
 They belonged to Hammersmith Council who had bought them from the BBC for something like three million pounds. 
 Wally's dad had the contract to clear them out, sort out what could be sold off and junk the rest. 
 He gave us a set of keys and we started going there regularly setting it up nicely. 
 Paul was an apprentice electrician at Watneys brewery in Mortlake so he brought some barrels of beer along and we set up a proper bar. 
 It was a wonderful studio as well. 
 It had one of the best acoustic sound-dubbing rooms in Europe &mdash; they'd been fitted out some time in the thirties to be used for putting soundtracks on to movies. 
 When Steve and Paul brought in all their stolen gear, it looked like a right little Aladdin's cave.  
 It was down at Riverside that I had what you might call my first &bquo;exotic&equo; sexual experience. 
 Up until then I was still pretty na&iuml;ve when it came to affairs of the heart. 
 The woman was older than me, a certain rock star's girlfriend, an American who was in the shop all the time, obviously at a bit of a loose end while her boyfriend was touring. 
 One day in the shop she'd been waiting for Malcolm's girlfriend and partner, Vivienne Westwood &mdash; they'd been planning to go somewhere but Vivienne hadn't turned up, she'd phoned to tell this American girl that. 
 When she was on the phone to Vivienne she suddenly turned round and shouted, which one's Glen? 
 Me, why? 
 Vivienne said I should hang out with you for a while and then we can meet up with Malcolm later. 
 She came down to Riverside with me, watched as we rehearsed then followed me into the loo and gave me a blow job &mdash; something I just wasn't used to as a 17-year-old grammar school boy still living at home with his mum and dad. 
 Then I went back to rehearsing with the band while she sat around listening. 
 When it was all over we all squeezed into Steve's van and drove up to Dingwalls, the club in Camden. 
 It was a little Mini van that he ran around in saying it was for the band but really he had it because he thought it was &bquo;a good shagging mobile&equo; with just enough space in the back for &bquo;entertaining&equo;. 
 She never managed to meet up with Vivienne and, as there didn't seem to be much happening at Dingwalls, we decided to drive down to Brighton, all of us crammed into the back of the Mini van. 
 There was me and her, Wally, Malcolm and Paul. 
 Of course, when we got to Brighton there was nothing going on there either. 
 So we ended up staying the night at a hotel, The Majestic, the big one right on the sea front As usual Malcolm feigned being borassic so she ended up shelling out for two rooms. 
 Steve, Paul, Malcolm and Wally had one. 
 She and I had the other. 
 When we got to the room she went to pull the curtains. 
 Don't bother, I said, it's six floors up. 
 All that's out there is sea. 
 No one can see in. 
 So we went to bed. 
 Everything was fine except that when we were at it I did hear these funny noises coming from somewhere. 
  As I couldn't work out where they were coming from I ignored them. 
 Then, the next morning, Steve started giving me a pep talk, all this advice on how to fuck. 
 Don't do it like that, he said, do it like this. 
 I know, believe me, and you're doing it all wrong. 
 So, Mr Knowitall, I said, how do you know? 
 Because, he said, I had a look at you last night, didn't I. 
 It turned out that he'd inched along the parapet &mdash; a thin one about six inches wide &mdash; and had a good peek at us through the windows. 
 He was probably fed up with having to sleep four to a bed. 
 For a bit of fun before we went back to London we got a boat trip round the harbour. 
 Then, in the van on the way back, the American girl noticed Malcolm yawning. 
 Feeling tired? she said 
 Yeah, he said. 
 You don't sleep too well four to a bed. 
 So she pulled out a rolled up tenner and a small packet. 
 Here, she said, I've got some Charlie left. 
 Malcolm opened it up. 
 But there was nothing there. 
 The spray on the boat had got to it, more or less dissolving it all away. 
 After that I saw her maybe a couple of times. 
 I guess, looking back on it, I was her toy boy. 
 She was about 10 years older than me. 
 But nothing much came of it. 
 In fact, I gave her the bum's rush &mdash; although it was quite inadvertent. 
 A couple of weeks after Brighton she came into the shop, presuming we were going out together that evening &mdash; without having told me what she intended, I'd arranged to go and see a band with a mate from art college. 
 Bye, I said to her, got to go now. 
 I'd not been thinking of us as boyfriend and girlfriend, you see. 
 But one look at her face told me she had.   
 Sex 
 Suddenly Malcolm decided to change everything about the shop &mdash; name, stock, attitude. 
 It was to be Sex. 
 Fetishism. 
 Rubber clothes. 
 Things that no other fashion shop would dare sell. 
 What sparked the idea off, I really don't know. 
 I'm sure Malcolm and Vivienne had discussions but at that stage, I was just the Saturday lad. 
 They didn't make me part of their discussions. 
 Later I thought it through and decided a big part of it was that, although he was coining it from the teds, I think he felt he was seen &mdash; by his peers &mdash; as an artistic cretin. 
 All he was doing was catering to one particularly backward-looking group of people. 
 He and Vivienne were also probably fed up with the teds' meathead mentality. 
 Basically, they were forerunners of the skinhead attitudes which re-emerged in the mid-seventies. 
  They had the same right wing, racist hard-nut minds. 
 A bit more cultured, a bit more refined, a bit more genteel. 
 But they would kick your head in if you spilt their pint just the same. 
 They got fed up with that. 
 I think Malcolm saw it as a way of getting himself established, starting a shop and making a reputation. 
 But now it was time to move on. 
 Time for a change. 
 The first I knew about it was Malcolm going on about rubber. 
 This was around the time he first started seeing me as more than just an employee. 
 Once he'd found out that I was applying to go to art school he opened up quite a bit and we began to talk. 
 We're going to change this shop into Sex, he said Yeah, we're going to have these rubber clothes. 
 Maybe masks with zips in, 
 He had all these old catalogues from Soho sex shops which he'd go through, things like She And Me , pointing out what he was going to do. 
 Sex itself was a strong idea but it evolved quite slowly. 
 Malcolm wanted to create the most direct statement of what clothes were about. 
 OK, he said all clothes are basically a way of attracting the opposite sex. 
 So let's go with that. 
 It's debatable whether that statement is true or not but it was certainly pretty blatant. 
 As he realised it would, it had the impact of blatancy. 
 It was shocking and it brought him even more public and media attention. 
 But it pissed me off no end when he finally decided to change over because he shut up shop while he did it, leaving me with no Saturday job and no money. 
 So I used to call up quite regularly, asking how the refit was going. 
 Ar, boy, he'd say, nothing's happening yet. 
 Give us a call next week. 
 Finally he got so used to me calling that he asked me to come down and give them a hand fixing it up. 
 I helped do the Sex sign and put all this foam rubber on the walls which were then decorated with quotations from Alexand Trocchi, soft porn spray can graffiti from the &bquo;68 Paris student revolt. 
 Slogans like &bquo;Under the paving stone lies a beach&equo;; and prenez-vous ca que vous desire pour la realite . 
 (Funnily enough, years later in France I saw in the Orange branch of the Credit Agricole exactly the same slogan used to advertise personal loans.) 
 I saw the whole thing slowly take shape.  
 There was never a big overnight change. 
 It wasn't a case of a lorry-load of new stuff &mdash; all rubber and zips and suspender belts &mdash; turning up one day. 
 It appeared piecemeal because &mdash; despite the takings of a Saturday &mdash; they just didn't have the finance to cover that kind of operation. 
 There was no party or anything for the reopening. 
 One day it was just open again. 
 And all the old crowd returned They'd often come past the shop to see when it was going to open up again. 
 Fortunately, Vivienne had argued Malcolm out of one of his crazier ideas. 
 He wanted to have an intercom by the front door and only let people in by appointment. 
 This was mad. 
 Someone pointed out that it would stop passers-by popping in to buy something. 
 That got home to him He certainly wasn't going to miss the chance of making a few bob out of someone with money to spend. 
 As a 15-year-old still at school I wasn't too sure about it all. 
 I talked about it with my art teacher. 
 He knew I worked with Malcolm because he was one of the few teachers I could have a conversation with about something more than homework or football. 
 How's the shop going? he asked one week. 
 Well I said, they're getting into this rubber wear. 
 He looked a bit concerned. 
 Yeah, I said, I'm not too sure about it myself. 
 Well, he said, you don't have to work there you know. 
 I agreed but then thought, yes I do, what else have I got going for me? 
 Working there was my exit from the straight world. 
 Anyway there was nothing really sordid about what we sold. 
 It wasn't full of dildos like a Soho sex shop. 
 Mind you, we did get some funny people coming into the shop. 
 Because of all the rubber stuff, Malcolm had magazines like Rubber Monthly  knocking around. 
 Sometimes I'd have a flick through. 
 They'd be full of stories about Wimbledon Common for some reason. 
 We were there last weekend, they'd say, and the elements were against us, but we were snug from head to toe in our rubber suits. 
 The counter in the shop was a little kiosk with a till which stood slightly higher than the rest of the room. 
 One day a bloke came in wearing a rubber mac, a real Wimbledon Common regular by  the look of him. 
 He stood there in front of the counter asking the price of things. 
 These rubber tights, he said. 
 How much are they? 
 Ten pounds, I told him, noticing he had his hand in his pocket 
 And these rubber suspenders? 
 Fifteen pounds. 
 His eyeballs popped. 
 Fifteen pounds . 
 he screeched and rushed out of the shop. 
 He'd come his whack and there was this trail of spunk behind him all over the floor. 
 We always had trouble like that It was horrible You'd go into the changing rooms after someone had tried on some rubber tights and there'd be cum all over them. 
 Vivienne would pick them up and say, it's alright I'll just wash them down and put them back on the rack. 
 This was when Chris Spedding, the guitarist, started hanging out in the shop. 
 Partly he'd be in because he was really into leather himself and partly he was there because his girlfriend of the time, Nora &mdash; who now lives with Johnny Rotten &mdash; was in the shop just about every day. 
 For ages Bernie maintained he already knew her from somewhere but couldn't quite place it. 
 Eventually he remembered &mdash; he'd seen her hanging out with Jim Hendrix in the sixties. 
 So Nora went from Jimi to Chris to Rotten. 
 She was German and a right pain. 
 She'd come in, pick up a rubber skirt and say, half you ziss in one leetle size bigger? 
 I'd say, it's the only one we've got and we're not getting any more. 
 So she'd try it on and it wouldn't fit. 
 Two days later she'd be back, picking up the same rubber skirt and saying, half you got ziss in one leetle size bigger? 
 She was always in the shop. 
 I didn't twig at the time but really she just wanted to hang out in the shop and she was coming up with any old excuse she could find to be in there. 
 Spedding was just another person on the scene. 
 I wasn't really aware of who he was, he was just a kind of mate. 
 Steve and Paul were more in awe of him than me because of all his work with Roxy Music. 
 But, as far as I was concerned, he was just another rockabilly who'd park his flash motor out the front and seemed  to have more money than all the rest of us put together. 
 Malcolm was his friend too. 
 Apart from Nora and the weirdos we'd get people buying it for their girlfriends, as a laugh Some girls, those who were a bit more out there, would buy the rubber wear for themselves. 
 Others would buy it for a fancy dress party or a dare. 
 Also there were the people who'd been coming in to the shop when it was still Let It Rock. 
 As well as the teds there were always a few young art school types who were interested in the idea of teddy boy style. 
 They weren't so hidebound. 
 They didn't say, as the teds did, I can only wear a drape They'd mix it a bit, getting into biker stuff and cap-sleeved T-shirts. 
 Others were into the glam rock idea and liked the idea of Sex. 
 It was about this time that Vivienne began to get really evangelistic about it all. 
 Although the shop was a bit of an Aladdin's cave, something of a tot shop with all kinds of different clothes hanging around &mdash; some from Let It Rock, some from Sex &mdash; she really got into the idea of there being a party line. 
 Sometimes she'd lay right into somebody. 
 I remember one bloke who was part of a working class West London crowd that had been coming into the shop since the early days. 
 They'd started out as mods but gradually dritfed into fifties Americana and then the Alan Ladd suits. 
 A lot of them used to come in and religiously buy something every week. 
 They always had money because they left school early and went to work, mainly as builders and labourers. 
 They played hard as well. 
 They'd meet at The Roebuck, the same pub that everyone from the shop used, on Saturday lunchtime, then go down the Kings Road spending their money. 
 Which could be quite a bit as they all still lived at home with their mums and dads. 
 Some of them even made enough to run hot rod cars. 
 One of them came in, looked at the rubber gear and said, cor, I don't know about this any more, this is all a bit too weird for me. 
 He'd changed his way of dressing as well. 
 He'd been buying his clothes at Acme Attractions up the road &mdash; a stall which generally did exactly the same as Malcolm only six months later, and were quite open about it. 
 He had on what you'd now call a yuppie look &mdash; baggy trousers and braces.  
 When he started saying what he felt about the new clothes, Vivienne piled into him. 
 Oh you, you look like you should be in a fucking potting shed, she said. 
 Not in my shop. 
 If you don't like it, get out. 
 Working for Malcolm and Vivienne was like being in the army. 
 You felt as if you'd signed the Official Secrets Act. 
 There were all these agit prop politics that you had to toe the line about. 
 Fuck it, I often thought, it's only a fucking Saturday job. 
 Towards the end of my career in retailing, when we were gigging as a band, I was late quite a few times. 
 Once I got in well hungover at four in the afternoon when I should have been there at 11. 
 Well, Malcolm, I said I can't do this any more, it's quite obvious. 
 Vivienne got furious. 
 What's up with you? she said, don't you want to work here? 
 You realise it's a privilege to work here? 
 Of course I said yes because I needed the money. 
 But their attitude that you had to be part of their camp used to get to me. 
 It was just like the phrase that Thatcher was so fond of. 
 &bquo;One of us. 
 No bleeding difference between Thatcher and Westwood. 
 I never really got to know her She was the most obtuse person I ever met. 
 Once she told me about sending her kids to boarding school and asked me what I thought. 
 Well, I said, sounds like Stalag 13 to me. 
 Stalag what? 
 Stalag 13. 
 What do you mean? 
 Stalag 13 was a prisoner of war camp. 
 So? 
 Well, the school with its rules sounds like a POW camp. 
 (Plus I knew one of the kids was trying to escape all the time) It can't be much fun being locked up there It really sounds like a POW story. 
 What do you mean? she said At that point I gave up. 
 She was always in Malcolm's shadow. 
 They say that gentile women who marry Jewish men become more Jewish than Jews. 
 That's a good parallel for Vivienne and Malcolm. 
 He was a radical so she had to be even more radical. 
 Malcolm was impressive though. 
 You d find yourself copying him and his mannerisms. 
 When he first started selling peg trousers he developed a stance to show them off He'd bend his legs at the knee and stand half turned. 
 I found myself copying, as did everyone else who worked in the shop. 
 Not because we thought it was great but because it was just so infectious.  
 And it was so stupid. 
 I'd stand in the lunch queue at school in my pegs while everyone else was in these horrible big flares. 
 I'd adopt the Malcolm stance. 
 Far from looking cool I must have looked like I'd done a packet in my trousers. 
 People often remark on how alike John and Malcolm look these days. 
 Well, I'm sure John did pick up on certain mannerisms that Malcolm had, not deliberately but because Malcolm did that to people. 
 We were just in our early twenties by the time I left The Pistols, beginning to find our way in the world, starting to get more confidence. 
 It's not that Malcolm was a father-figure to us &mdash; as some have said &mdash; he was more like an elder brother who'd actually been out there in the world and done it so he had the confidence and experience. 
 So we looked up to him like that. 
 We'd hang out with him all the time. 
 He liked being with Steve and Paul because they were like his bit of rough. 
 He was a middle class radical who fancied the idea of being around two real street kids. 
 We'd drink in The Roebuck, just up the Kings Road from the shop every Saturday straight after work. 
 We'd sit around chatting for a bit then go on to whatever was happening that evening. 
 We'd go on to gigs or to parties or out to eat. 
 One time we went to The Last Resort in Fulham Road. 
 Malcolm was pissed and agreed to pay for everyone's meal. 
 He was never tightfisted but it wasn't often he was that generous. 
 So we all dived right in, me, Steve and Paul, and Wally. 
 We ordered so much we couldn't eat the last dish they brought us, couldn't even touch it. 
 Vivienne got really angry. 
 You're just being greedy, you lot, she shouted, your eyes are bigger than your bellies. 
 Fuck it, we thought, it's the first time Malcolm's splashed out and Vivienne's coming on at us like some kind of school maam, and Malcolm wasn't bothered, he was past caring. 
 On the other hand, Vivienne gave me an early insight into Malcolm's history. 
 As I was applying to art school I needed a reference so I told Vivienne that I thought I'd ask Malcolm, since he was my employer. 
 Oh no, she said, you don't want to ask Malcolm. 
 He's been thrown out of every art school in London and some that aren't.  
 Around that time I came across a dog-eared treatise on the 1968 student uprisings, in particular the LSE sit-in. 
 One day I was browsing through it in the shop. 
 Malcolm saw me and said, hey what are you reading, boy? 
 I showed him. 
 He smiled. 
 Oh, he said pretty casually, I'm in that. 
 He wouldn't say any more. 
 I had to find out for myself. 
 I read on paying great attention, trying to find out what he meant. 
 The only passage I could find which could have referred to him was a section describing a debate during the LSE sit-in when the students were deciding whether to break down a pair of iron gates which lead to the bursar's office. 
 The idea was they were after the records which the college held on all students. 
 They couldn't come to a decision so they put it to the vote when &mdash; as the book put it &mdash; a pair of bearded anarchists, one with flame red hair, appeared out of nowhere and took their decision for them, smashing down the gates with sledgehammers. 
 Malcolm and his old friend Jamie Reid? 
 Malcolm would neither confirm nor deny it. 
 From then on, I took more interest in him, looking at him as more than just my employer. 
 I began to understand him a little The rubber clothing, for example, I never saw as part of his own sexual fantasy world, but as part of the fascination he had with all secret worlds. 
 He saw rubber fetishism as one of the few remaining genuine underground cultures. 
 Simple as that And he always wanted to be in on any underground culture going. 
 He was like a kid making his camp under the dining room table with some blankets and pillows. 
 Everybody would be sitting there round the table having their Sunday dinner while down below them the kid would think he had the only important world to himself. 
 I always thought Malcolm was a bit like that kid. 
 For example, he wanted to be a member of as many clubs &mdash; of any description &mdash; as possible. 
 Give him an unknown society, any society, and he wanted in. 
 He'd take you to places like The Candy Box, just off Carnaby Street. 
 It opened at three o'clock in the morning, a club purely for hookers and people who worked in other clubs. 
 They'd go there after work for a drink and a few rock stars would turn up. 
 A real den of iniquity it's divided up into several little catacombs. 
 It's  absolutely horrible but Malcolm would insist on taking you there because it made him feel part of some secret society. 
 Both Vivienne and Malcolm were also very good at using people. 
 Malcolm was really into doing good window displays for the shop, often influenced by the ones Mr Green used to do for his Vince's Man's Shop in Soho &mdash; which was the first boutique ever, bringing faded blue denim and hipster trousers to the British public in the fifties. 
 Once we did a window together, just made a waste-paper basket out of chicken wire and hung shoes off it. 
 I had a day off and when I came back there was a big trophy sitting there in the shop. 
 Where did that come from? 
 I asked. 
 These people came in yesterday, he told me, who were judging a competition for the best window displays in the Kings Road. 
 And I won. 
 Not we won, you notice, but I won. 
 Thank you Malcolm. 
 They also really used me over the T-shirts which got them busted &mdash; and persuaded them to change the shop name from Sex to Seditionaries. 
 There were different sorts of T-shirts, each with an image and a slogan or comment on the status quo, some of which Malcolm designed and some of which were designed by Bernie and Malcolm together. 
 There were the cowboy ones &mdash; two rough riders facing each other with their enormous dicks hanging out in front of them like door handles with a caption. 
 There was the Cambridge Rapist in his mask with references to &bquo;A Hard Day's Night&equo; &mdash; the idea was to link it to the death of The Beatles' manager, Brian Epstein, during a supposed bout of homosexual S&amp;M. 
 And there was a third T-shirt, which featured a black bloke clutching a basketball, with his 12-inch, semi-erect dick hanging down like a Nigerian salami. 
 Muggins got the colour separations done for that at art school. 
 I felt a right prannet doing that. 
 Vivienne &mdash; with Bernie backing her up as Malcolm was in the States, having extended his visit after striking up a rapport with The New York Dolls at the time &mdash; talked me into doing it. 
 The trouble was, although they'd got me to do it &mdash; maybe because they knew it would save them money, or maybe because you can't get that kind of work done by your usual process shop &mdash; I didn't know how to do colour separations.  
 I knew what they were. 
 A photographic process which breaks a picture down into four colours &mdash; well, three colours plus black &mdash; and lots of little dots. 
 That's how all photographs are reproduced, be it for T-shirts or newspapers or books. 
 That I knew, 
 But I had no idea how to make them so I had to ask my tutor and show him the work. 
 He took a look at this picture of a black bloke with this dick practically touching his knees and said, Glen, fancy an extra tutorial one day soon? 
 So I kept telling Vivienne and Bernie that I'd lost the keys to my locker. 
 That way, I figured, I couldn't do the work. 
 Bernie laid right into me, telling me I was stupid for losing them. 
 Then Vivienne joined in and the three of us had a big slanging match. 
 Partly, I wasn't doing the work because I thought my tutor had decided I was a poof but, more importantly, I was dragging my feet because I wasn't keen on the work itself. 
 I told Vivienne I thought it was stupid, just childish. 
 It wasn't real outrage, it was cod outrage, like scribbling obscenities on the wall. 
 There was something fascist about it. 
 Quite what, I don't know. 
 I couldn't explain it very well at the time and I still can't. 
 But Vivienne came down on me like a dragon. 
 You, she said, you're a fascist. 
 I felt really used. 
 I was the one who had to take it to my tutor, not them. 
 It was all down to them thinking, oh, Glen's at art school, perhaps he can get it done for us. 
 Not being paid wasn't a problem; what was however was that I was being used for the donkey work without any consultation on the artistic side of it, And that was important to me. 
 When they did make up the T-shirts &mdash; as I backed down and did the separations &mdash; they got busted for sedition, which was an obscure act of whenever. 
 The actual person who got them busted was Alan Jones &mdash; not the artist but a gay guy on the scene, known as Leather And Bones Jones, a regular enough guy. 
 He got busted and they got done as well. 
 The thought of the bust always struck me as hilarious. 
 The idea of a regular Mr Plod seeing Leather And Bones walking down the road in his T-shirt and saying, here my lad, you're being seditious, come with me. 
 Malcolm got really paranoid, deciding that there was a conspiracy out to get him. 
 He decided to shift all the T-shirts. 
 As I had  a twelfth-hand Hillman Imp at the time I drove him down to his place in South London. 
 He'd just sold his jukebox so we had the back seat piled up with records from it. 
 Just as we were crossing Chelsea Bridge we were stopped by the police at a road block. 
 Christ, I thought, just my luck, no tax, bald tyre, I'm going to get done Malcolm saw it differently. 
 See, he said, I told you you shouldn't have come this way. 
 He didn't care about me. 
 But we both got out of it. 
 When the copper peered in the back and said, that's a lot of records, what are you going to do with them? 
 Paul, who was in the back, piped up, plain as anything, play them. 
 The copper said, oh yeah, right. 
 Having been made to look stupid, he let us go without even checking up on the tax or the tyre. 
 Or even getting to see the T-shirts. 
 Malcolm taught me things as well. 
 Things like how not to mouth off about any ideas you might have. 
 There's always people out there ready and willing to nick them. 
 People were always coming into the shop looking for things to copy. 
 Don Letts &mdash; who then worked for Acme Attractions and was until recently part of Big Audio Dynamite &mdash; was always in. 
 Which probably had something to do with the way that what we sold would reappear slightly  redone in Acme six months later. 
 We'd always have to be slinging people out. 
 They'd come in prowling around. 
 At first you'd think they were just looking but really they were turning things over and over in their hands to see how they were made and checking out the cut so they could rip them off. 
 The worst one I remember was a woman whose company had a small place in the rag trade ghetto round the back of Oxford Circus. 
 Malcolm had designed a very nice women's mac. 
 A real fifties style, it was made of very thin cir&eacute; and looked almost like a dress, with its circular skirt and stand-up collar. 
 It was like something that the B52s might have worn &mdash; half a dozen years later. 
 This woman's firm had totally ripped it off for one of the midmarket youth fashion houses. 
 And made a mint out of it. 
 Without paying a penny to Malcolm and Vivienne &mdash; whose idea it was. 
 Well sort of. 
 They probably ripped it off themselves from a  Hollywood still. 
 But that's not the point really. 
 Theirs was a fully-developed idea and garment. 
 Things like that made them really cagey, hence I was always having to lob people out of the shop if they looked like they were examining the clothes too closely. 
 And I certainly learned the value of keeping my mouth shut about any ideas I might have 
 That was probably another of the reasons why they became so obsessed with loyalty, with the idea that you were part of some &eacute;lite squad. 
 That obsession, if anything, became more in 
 The bondage suits, for instance, were based on the idea of the strait-jacket, with trousers to match. 
 Straps on the arms and legs could be fastened to restrict your movement. 
 They came in right at the end of the period I spent working there I never owned one myself &mdash; although I'd sometimes wear one in the shop I thought they were stupid. 
 How the fuck are you supposed to run for a bus in this was what I thought &mdash; a bit more down-to-earth than Malcolm and Vivienne. 
 Their attitude was, when you buy it you make a commitment to buying it and you wear it. 
 Which was another part of Vivienne's &bquo;One Of Us&equo; schtick. 
 If you weren't, fuck off. 
 But, even if you were, you had to buy the whole manifesto. 
 It never seemed to enter their minds that someone might like to buy a pair of trousers from Sex and a shirt from somewhere else. 
 You had to buy everything from them. 
 They were quite totalitarian in their own way. 
 I thought the Sex stuff was a bit weird but not so weird that I didn't want to get involved with it. 
 It was  interesting. 
 I was along for the ride. 
 I took from it what I liked &mdash; just as John later added safety pins to his jackets and T-shirts. 
 Which was how most people treated the shop. 
 They took from it what they felt they could handle &mdash; or wanted to handle, or could put to some use &mdash; and rejected the rest. 
 As far as I was concerned, the bits I rejected I just didn't bother with.   
 Peeping Steve 
 It was around this time that Nick Kent started coming down to rehearsals at Riverside. 
 He was the star writer on the NME  then and always in the shop because he was a Keith Richards clone and our shop was the last one n the Kings Road before Granny Takes A Trip &mdash; where all the Keith Richards clones bought their clothes. 
 Marty and Jean who ran Granny Takes A Trip were mates of Malcolm's and they all used to meet up after work in the pub Sometimes Nick would be there too and we got talking to him. 
 Malcolm used to court him. 
 As he was the NME  's star writer I guess Malcolm realised that once the band really started to get going, Nick would be able to help us out &mdash; whether he knew it or not. 
 Mind you, Malcolm did take the piss out of him as well, calling  him Troy Tempest in a leather jacket. 
 Probably because it was a way of roping him in for the future, Malcolm invited him down to a few rehearsals. 
 We, d jam, going through things like &bquo;I Can Feel The Fire&equo; from Ron Wood's solo album which was out around that time. 
 And we'd knock out things like &bquo;Slow Death&equo; by The Flamin' Groovies &mdash; who also used to come in the shop now and again when they were in town. 
 Then one day Malcolm said to me, what's going on with this Nick bloke and the band? 
 Not a lot really, he's come down and hacked through a couple of tunes with us. 
 You sure that's all there is? 
 He's been calling me up all hours of the day and night complaining about you guys especially Steve. 
 He reckons he's having to do all the work, write all the songs. 
 He says you lot can't play and it's getting to him, it's too much work for him to take on, what with his writing and everything. 
 So I had to go and put Nick straight, tell him that he wasn't even one of the band, just a mate who'd come and play with us every now and then. 
 I was still living with my parents at the time and I'd not long passed my driving test &mdash; with Bernie's assistance &mdash; so I borrowed my old man's Austin Cambridge one Sunday morning and drove over to Nick's. 
 I got there at what I thought was a reasonable hour, around midday. 
 When I found the right place it was a real hole. 
 A girl eventually answered the door. 
 She looked exactly like Nick, only female. 
 She had the same kind of eyes, a real pinned kind of look. 
 I didn't realise what that was all about till long after. 
 She said, come in, but Nick's not awake yet, go up to his room. 
 So I strode up there to have this man-to-man chat with Nick. 
 I really like Nick, I thought, how am I going to explain this? 
 I started right in by saying there must have been a bit of a misunderstanding. 
 He said, yeah, there has, which came as a great relief to me and we left it at that. 
 Fancy a drink then? he said. 
 A cup of coffee would be nice, I said. 
 He looked round the room and it was an absolute disaster area, stuff piled everywhere. 
 But there was no kitchen and he sure as hell was in no state to get up, so I was wondering where he was going to get something to drink from.  
 Eventually he reached into his bedside table. 
 Here it is, he said and pulled out a bottle of foul-looking medicine that could well have been the very stuff that Dr Jekyll used to turn himself into Mr Hyde. 
 It probably wasn't bubbling and smoking away like a witch's cauldron but I certainly remember it that way What was it? 
 Kaoline and morphine or some such brew apparently. 
 No thanks, Nick, I said. 
 I think I'll be getting home for my dinner Are we straight now then? 
 Yeah yeah. 
 We both knew what the other one meant but we never said it in so many words. 
 He didn't come down to rehearsals too much after that. 
 He was going out with Chrissie Hynde in those days. 
 The first time I remember seeing her was in The Roebuck. 
 Mike Smith, the singer and keyboard player in The Dave Clark Five, was having a quiet drink. 
 Chrissie knew who he was because she had a real background in screaming teeny bop stuff. 
 I didn't realise then that The Dave Clark Five had been that enormous in the States. 
 Chrissie shouted to him, oi, where are your Beatle boots then? and started bashing out the rhythm to &bquo;Glad All Over&equo; on the table. 
 Who's this? she said. 
 He got so embarrassed he turned round and scuttled out. 
 She didn't understand at all. 
 Shit, she said, I would have liked someone doing that if I were him. 
 That summer I thought I was going to be able to work in the shop full-time up until I started at St. Martin's School of Art in the autumn. 
 But Malcolm suddenly gave the job to Chrissie instead Because, I suppose, she was older and more rock &bquo;n&equo; roll with her leather jackets, whereas I was still at school and pretty straight. 
 But things started going a bit wrong before she could start. 
 One day she was hanging around the shop when Nick Kent followed her in, angry. 
 They'd had a row. 
 He took his belt off and started whacking Chrissie with it. 
 A bloke called Adrian happened to be in there as well. 
 A supposedly famous photographer in the sixties, he was now most famous for the farce and frequency of his suicide attempts. 
 Once he jumped from a roof and managed to land on the soft top of a passing van. 
 It merely broke his fall and carted him a couple of miles up the road. 
 But this day he was all action, stepping right up to Nick and thumping him hard. 
 Nick crawled away. 
 Adrian spent the next  hour nursing his fist and repeating over and over and over again, I hit him, I hit him, at last I've done something. 
 That was a quiet summer for the band. 
 Steve had been nicked and was in prison &mdash; Ashford Remand Centre &mdash; for a while. 
 He d been thieving again, of course, but it was no big deal really. 
 Certainly not compared to the time he got caught messing around on the roof of Battersea Power Station trying to nick the lead. 
 Someone saw him and called the police When they arrived he shimmied right to the very top of one of the chimneys. 
 A copper chased him up there. 
 When he caught Steve he asked him what he thought he was up to Well, said Steve, my mum and dad have split up. 
 She's moved in with another man who's an exboxer who knocks me around. 
 I've had enough of it and I wanted to be alone. 
 The police considered this and took him down to the station &mdash; for tea and sticky buns. 
 Because there was so little going on with the band I arranged to give myself a bit of a holiday. 
 A girl I was seeing pretty regularly had gone to France on an exchange visit to Tours I took a job for a couple of weeks in a lino warehouse with the idea of getting some money together 
 With the money I'd saved I went over to France, going straight to where she was staying in Tours. 
 The idea was that I'd go for a fortnight but when I got there she gave me the bum's rush so I spent a couple of miserable days in France and then hared it back to England. 
 When I got to London Chrissie was no longer working in the shop. 
 I think what happened was that Nick had been hanging around waiting to get hold of her. 
 Malcolm didn't think Chrissie being larruped with Nick's belt in his shop was good for business So I got the weekday job again. 
 Good old Nick, I thought, now I've got my old job back on direct account of him. 
 The Alex Harvey Band came into the shop quite a few times that summer, Chris Glenn, the bass player, bought his gold lurex socks from us. 
 Then, on one occasion, Malcolm happened to be around when they came in. 
 He took one look at them and said, what are those blokes doing here? 
 Get'em out. 
 Malcolm was really having a brainstorm. 
 I had to go over to them and say, I'm sorry but we're going  to have to close for a bit. 
 Perhaps you could come back tomorrow. 
 Fortunately, they were alright about it and sloped off. 
 I was used to suddenly closing up the shop anyway. 
 When Chelsea turned out on a Saturday afternoon, if we didn't lock the door, we had all the football fans in the shop trying to nick stuff and screaming obscenities. 
 So it was no skin off my nose, it was no big deal to shut up shop in the middle of the day. 
 But this was different. 
 Malcolm, I said, what was that all about? 
 Those blokes he said they were weird. 
 I reckon they're from the Inland Revenue. 
 Malcolm they're not. 
 How do you  know? he said, implying I was only the shop lad and what did I know? 
 I said, I know because they're The Sensational Alex Harvey Band. 
 The Sensational what band? he said. 
 The Sensational Alex Harvey Band. 
 They're a group. 
 They've been playing The Marquee every week. 
 They're really good actually. 
 You should come and see them 
 Are you sure? 
 Yeah. 
 Well, what do they want? 
 A pair of creepers maybe. 
 Or some socks. 
 Or a T-shirt. 
 Alright then, he said, but watch &bquo;em. 
 A couple of months later he did come to the Hammersmith Odeon with Bernie and me to see them play I could seethe relief on his face when he realised they really were a band. 
 That autumn, I started my foundation course at St Martins, which is in Charing Cross Road right opposite all the musical equipment shops in Denmark Street, London's Tin Pan Alley. 
 Because of that it was inevitable that sooner or later I would be delegated by Steve and Paul to fence some of the gear they'd purloined. 
 And they did delegate me, of course, handing me a guitar to get rid of. 
 I took it to a couple of shops who just weren't interested and then to Macaris who seemed to be interested in buying it but who were being a bit funny about it to me. 
 The bloke behind the counter said, look, I've just got to go and look up the year of manufacture, I'll be back in a couple of  minutes. 
 I've got to check the price. 
 He'd come back and make another excuse to keep me hanging around. 
 Then the young assistant started giving me funny looks, as if there was something up and I should know there was something up. 
 He couldn't actually tell me what was going on because that would put him in shtuck but he was trying to tip me the wink. 
 I realised I was going to be nicked. 
 I've never been nicked before, I thought, I wonder what it's like? 
 So I hung around and, sure enough, a few minutes later a squad car turned up all its lights flashing. 
 They handcuffed me. 
 You don't need to bother with them, I said, I won't run off. 
 Oh yes you will, they said. 
 Not stupid coppers are they? 
 But this time they were wrong. 
 I was really curious to know what it was like to have your collar felt. 
 I guess I was trying to earn a couple of lowlife brownie points, so I could catch up with Steve and Paul's criminal pedigree. 
 As it was right across the road from college everyone was hanging out the window to see what was happening. 
 All my mates, my tutor, everyone saw me bundled into the back of the squad car. 
 They took me to West End Central and, instead of telling them what had really happened, I gave them a story. 
 I said I'd bought it off a bloke in The Roebuck. 
 They swallowed it and said they were charging me with handling stolen goods. 
 Just like in TV cop shows there was a nice cop and a nasty cop. 
 The nice one &mdash; who was a dead ringer for the comp&egrave;re in Hi-Di-Hi  &mdash; came in and said, Well Glen, we've thought about it, we're not going to charge you with handling stolen goods. 
 Great, I thought. 
 No, we're going to charge you with theft. 
 If I plead guilty to that, I thought, I'll end up in the nick for the rest of my life. 
 But he told me that, in the eyes of the law, theft is actually a lesser charge than handling stolen goods If there weren't people handling stolen goods then nobody would nick things in the first place. 
 At least that's how they figured it and that's how he explained it to me. 
 I went up before the beak at Great Marlborough Street magistrates court. 
 Again they swallowed my story and gave me a year's conditional discharge. 
 Oh, I piped up, does that mean I  get off? 
 No it does not, young man, snapped the magistrate in no uncertain terms and explained how it all worked to me. 
 As I was leaving I made a big show of asking to see the guitar one more time. 
 I paid good money for that, I said, can't I just have a last go on it? 
 They let me have one last look and told me that it belonged to someone in another band &mdash; which made me feel really guilty. 
 Then they said, you're at art college, you must be able to draw, you could do a drawing of the gentleman in question you claim you bought the guitar from. 
 Maybe they meant it, maybe they were teasing. 
 They said that it was in everyone's interest that he got caught. 
 So I just made up a face, drew it for them. 
 Now luck would have it that my drawing was spot on for a guy who drank in The Roebuck. 
 Plus it turned out that he was a speed dealer. 
 The kids in the band whose guitar it really was set up a look-out in The Roebuck and, of course, they spotted him. 
 The dealer got more and more paranoid sitting there, noticing these two guys in the corner who kept looking at a bit of paper then at him, then having a bit of a conflab. 
 He got so paranoid he decided to leg it. 
 The kids immediately followed him thinking this was proof that he was the right guy. 
 Act guiltily and they'll judge you guilty As they started to follow him down the street he got more and more worried He broke into a run. 
 So they took off after him, caught him and gave him a hiding. 
 But, of course it was entirely the wrong bloke. 
 They should have been chasing Steve Jones. 
 Slowly we began to take the whole idea of the band more seriously. 
 We'd try and come up with ideas of what it was all about &mdash; sometimes prompted by Bernie, sometimes not. 
 For example, we decided to pay attention to the way we looked so we all had our hair cut short &mdash; except Wally &mdash; and took to wearing Hush Puppies and jeans, a kind of mod look &mdash; which was odd considering that Malcolm had a shop which specialised in teddy boy gear. 
 But what it shows is how, right from the earliest days, we were always much more than assembly line workers in Malcolm McLaren's dream factory.  
 Our next major step was to sort out a name. 
 Before I'd joined they'd called themselves Strand &mdash; after the Roxy Music song &bquo;Do The Strand &mdash; and The Swankers but both these names were well past their sell-by date by the time I arrived. 
 Yet, although we hadn't thought of a name, we'd started to fancy doing a couple of gigs and, of course, you can't do gigs without a name. 
 Our idea was that we should call ourselves The All Stars. 
 As it would only be a temporary name we felt it didn't really matter all that much what we should call ourselves 
 Malcolm was about to go to the States. 
 This was to be the visit on which he linked up with The New York Dolls. 
 Eventually he took over their management and put them into red patent leather suits, effectively driving the last nail into The Dolls&equo; coffin. 
 So it was Bernie we got talking to in the pub about a name for the band. 
 He was adamant. 
 No, no, no, no, no, he said, it's got to be the real thing, you've got to start out as you mean to go on Get it right from the beginning. 
 Get the correct name and stick with it. 
 Everything flows from there. 
 So that put the damper on gigs for a bit. 
 Some time before, Malcolm had come up with a list of half a dozen names. 
 The Damned was one. 
 Kid Gladlove was another. 
 A third was Cr&egrave;me De La Cr&egrave;me. 
 Blimey leave it out Malcolm, said Steve when he heard that one, that sounds more like some poncey wine bar. 
 And there was QT Jones And The Sex Pistols. 
 As well as the pun, I'm sure the reason Malcolm chose QT was that it was the postal code around where Steve &mdash; who was still the singer at this point &mdash; was staying. 
 The rest of the name was quite straightforward Pistols was a strong, hard word, not bad for a band's name. 
 Sex, of course, came from Malcolm's shop. 
 He was never shy of a bit of cross-promotion. 
 I'm also sure another influence was Disco Tex And His Sex-O-Lettes. 
 They had a big hit around the time and the shop was always full of these kids who were really into that gay, shallow disco &mdash; stuff like &bquo;The Hustle&equo;. 
 These kids would hang out in The Sombrero in Kensington High Street and Chagueramas in Covent Garden &mdash; which became The Roxy Club a couple of years later.  
 So we didn't think much of it as a name at first but while Malcolm was away in the States, we somehow came round to it and decided to go with it. 
 Sex Pistols it was. 
 We dropped the QT Jones bit and, by the time Malcolm came back, we were really quite up about it. 
 A lot happened around that time. 
 We got a name, we left Riverside and we slung Wally out of the band. 
 The three things which really set us up for John's arrival. 
 I got on quite well with Steve around that time You hungry? he said one day Come on then I'll treat you. 
 He took me to a pie and mash shop on Hammersmith Broadway. 
 I was starving so I had pie and mash twice He had double  pie and double  mash twice. 
 As we waddled, full as pillows, back to Riverside, I said, I thought you were skint. 
 Well, he said, I found this attach&eacute; case, see. 
 Yeah? 
 And it had a grand in it. 
 Steve was also a major factor in our leaving Riverside. 
 What happened was, when we'd go there to rehearse on a Friday night, he would disappear for an hour or so. 
 One week we decided to follow him to find out where he was sloping off to We found him on the roof ledge peering down at people in a car below. 
 As this was something of a lovers' lane, he had a good chance of catching a couple knobbing on the back seat And Steve, as I'd already found out for myself, always did like a bit of voyeurism. 
 Unfortunately, soon after that a copper spotted him doing his Peeping Tom bit, followed him inside the studios and looked very strangely at all this expensive gear lying around. 
 So we would have had to leave anyway, in case the cops started taking too close an interest in it. 
 But we also had to leave because we chucked Wally out of the band. 
 As the place was really his gig we couldn't use it without him We'd been talking about it for ages &mdash; and Bernie was always badgering us about it &mdash; but we'd not really done anything about it. 
 The crunch came when Malcolm returned from America. 
 He put his foot down straightaway. 
 I told you to sack Wally before I left, he said. 
 How come he's still in the band? 
 I won't have anything more to do with you lot till you give him the elbow. 
 Which we did.  
 I never really minded Wally. 
 When push came to shove, I stuck up for him. 
 Then Paul said, I don't know why you're sticking up for him, he's been trying to get you slung out on your ear for ages. 
 So that was it really. 
 Wally left the band. 
 He's a strange bloke though. 
 He still calls me up now and again. 
 Not long ago he was on the phone to me moaning about Paul saying, he won't give me the time of day. 
 Which, given the way Wally rambles on, is scarcely surprising. 
 Then he started on me, I made them what they are today, he said. 
 Without me The Pistols would have been nowhere. 
 I'm going to take them to court and sue them 
 What's all that about then Wally? 
 The group was all my idea. 
 Before they met me, Steve and Paul were just petty criminals, didn't know nothing about nothing. 
 I told'em what to do, I told'em. 
 What did you tell them Wally? 
 They used to nick things like shoes, bits of jewellery and cars. 
 Now, what's the good of nicking a car if you can't drive it and you've got to ditch it? 
 So I told'em. 
 Guitars. 
 That's what they should be nicking. 
 If it hadn't been for me they'd never have nicked any guitars and there would have been no group. 
 So you're going to stand up in front of a judge and say all that, are you, Wally? 
 No, not exactly. 
 With Wally out of the band we could really take it seriously. 
 But for a while we found it hard. 
 Without him we had to struggle along with just the three of us. 
 Steve was doing OK but he was finding it hard to play guitar at the same time as singing. 
 Not that he was playing any flash lead parts but to keep a strong rhythm part going and sing at the same time is rather like having to twiddle both your thumbs in opposite directions at the same time. 
 So we decided we had to look for a new singer.   
 I'll Kill You 
 I'll kill you, said John on the phone in his best whine. 
 It was the first rehearsal with the band and none of us had turned up. 
 we booked The Crunchy Frog which was a hippy commune/warehouse/community centre by the Thames in Rotherhithe down in South East London, but we couldn't be bothered to go. 
 We'd been using it for a while since we had to leave Riverside Studios, trying out a couple of new singers. 
 But all to no avail. 
 It was a bloody long way to go across London. 
 The last time I'd been there I nearly got caught bunking my fare. 
 Every time I changed trains there was a posse of London Underground inspectors, so I had to keep doubling back on myself. 
 It took me about three hours to get six stops. 
  So I decided to give it a miss that day. 
 I really don't fancy schlepping all the way down there. 
 Steve and Paul didn't bother either. 
 Only John and his mate, John Grey, turned up. 
 John never went anywhere by himself, there was always an entourage. 
 I was deputed to phone him up and apologise. 
 That's when he threatened to kill me. 
 But I cooled him out and he agreed to come along to a new rehearsal place that we'd found, The Rose And Crown in Wandsworth. 
 That's where we really started rehearsing together properly as the band. 
 Where we got the money to pay for it, I'm not quite sure. 
 Perhaps Malcolm coughed up. 
 He was certainly very keen that we have John in the band. 
 Or maybe we sold some of the gear. 
 There weren't that many rehearsal places around at that time which we could afford. 
 But this one was cheap so we booked a full week. 
 Our idea was that at last we could have a real go at it, make sure things worked out. 
 But they didn't work out. 
 The landlord had obviously decided he could make a lot of money out of this rehearsal room lark. 
 So he'd taken an upstairs room and divided it into six spaces, figuring he could charge &pound;1.50 an hour for each of them and really coin it in. 
 What he didn't understand was the nature of rock music. 
 It's loud. 
 And he hadn't put any sound-proofing in. 
 There were just hardboard partitions between the rehearsal rooms &mdash; cubicles really. 
 Nothing substantial enough to stop the noise going straight downstairs into the bars 
 Every time we struck a chord people would come tearing up from the bar to tell us to turn that fucking racket down. 
 And we'd say, we're paying good money for this. 
 Nothing really constructive got done there But it was where we first had a serious go at turning ourselves into a real band. 
 We weren't doing nine to five but we were working every afternoon for a week. 
 This new zeal was strange in a way because John wasn't really our idea, but Malcolm's. 
 John had turned up one day in the shop. 
 Malcolm, who had been told to look out for him by Steve, was impressed. 
 He arranged for us all to have a drink with him at The Roebuck. 
 We  trooped along and he more than likely brought his mate John Grey along with him. 
 He looked much the same as he did later, with a T-shirt and his 5000 volt haircut. 
 We had a few drinks and all thought he seemed a bit of a laugh so we asked him to come back to the shop with us and have a bit of a sing. 
 He was obviously nervous about it, but he came. 
 We put a few records on the jukebox and got him to mime along. 
 One of them, I remember, was Alice Cooper's &bquo;Eighteen&equo;. 
 He stood there, shouting along and flapping his arms round like an over-excited seagull. 
 He looked just like he did when we played real gigs. 
 He was John Rotten from that very first moment 
 But we still couldn't tell whether he could sing or not. 
 It was a funny situation. 
 He felt awkward and so he mostly just took the piss out of it to get through. 
 But we decided to try him out. 
 This guy is the one, Malcolm said, and we went along with him Who knows why? 
 It certainly took us a while to understand John's plus points. 
 When we first started with him, even when we were rehearsing properly with him, all we could think of was that he couldn't sing. 
 Malcolm's got us this singer, we kept saying to each other, and he can't sing, what is all this about? 
 What we didn't realise at the time was that one of the main reasons that Malcolm was so keen on John was that he was so like Richard Hell &mdash; who was one of Malcolm s mates in New York. 
 He was as near as dammit to being a stylistic carbon copy of Hell. 
 We knew Malcolm had been really impressed with Hell in New York because they kept up a correspondence. 
 And, at one point, Malcolm must have asked him if he'd consider coming over to join the band, because Hell wrote to us via him saying that it sounded interesting but that because money and visas would be a problem he just couldn't. 
 But, at that time, none of us had seen Hell in person We'd seen a picture of The Heartbreakers that Malcolm had brought back from New York &mdash; the one in which it was meant to look like they'd been shot in the heart but in fact looked like they d all had the same accident with a ketchup bottle. 
 But we hadn't seen him perform. 
 And when we did, we all thought: aha, John, now we see.  
 Another person we thought of using as a front man was Midge Ure &mdash; who I went on to work with straight after The Pistols, in The Rich Kids. 
 Malcolm also made that contact when he and Bernie went on a trip up north, searching round textile factories for old fifties cloth to use for making up zoot suits. 
 We had some extremely hot gear lying around so we asked them if they'd have a go at getting rid of it for us out of town where it maybe would have cooled down somewhat. 
 They ended up trying to sell a Marshall amp in Glasgow. 
 The shop they went into wouldn't have anything to do with it though. 
 They must have thought something was fishy. 
 They certainly must have thought Malcolm was fishy, dressed as he was in black leather from head to toe. 
 No one at that time in Glasgow had ever seen anything like it outside a porn mag. 
 Midge happened to be standing next to them in the shop where they got the bum's rush. 
 Canny Scot that he is, he guessed what was happening, followed them out of the shop and offered them a tenner for the amp. 
 Malcolm took note of the way he looked &mdash; with his hair all slicked back, a really avant-garde gesture in Glasgow when everyone else was in loon pants. 
 He told me about Midge when he got back to London and I called him from the shop one Saturday, telling him we'd be interested in him as a singer. 
 But he wasn't interested in us. 
 I would, he said, but I've got this thing called Slik just going. 
 So what made us persist with John? 
 It's difficult to say. 
 Maybe that very quickly he started coming up with lyrics and that he and I got on well right from the off, Well, not quite from the off. 
 To begin with, he thought I was as close to Steve and Paul as they were to each other &mdash; and they were like a single amoeba that won't let anyone else into its world. 
 But, once he realised that I was a bit apart from them, we started to get on well and wrote a lot together, coming up with new lyrics for &bquo;Did You No Wrong&equo; and beginning to find cover versions that would really establish our identity. 
 From Steve and Paul's point of view, I reckon they thought he was a real card and that it would be a big laugh having him around.  
 Certainly John's arrival changed our attitude. 
 Before he came along we'd mess around with songs like &bquo;Build Me Up Buttercup&equo;, with me fiddling around on a little clavinet that we'd found knocking around somewhere and Steve singing. 
 With John in the band we began to search out songs which were really us. 
 Quite soon we had enough songs for a set. 
 Some of which were cover versions that one or other of us had found. 
 Some of which were songs John and I had written together. 
 But we still always had a problem finding somewhere to rehearse. 
 We tried out The Roundhouse for a while, even interrupting a World Service broadcast which was going out live from somewhere else in the building while we were bashing through a rehearsal &mdash; probably our first public airing. 
 So that didn't last long. 
 We tried lots of rehearsal spaces but they were all a rip off and totally out of the way. 
 One day, flicking through the music papers like we did every Wednesday, I spotted an ad in the Melody Maker  for premises in Tin Pan Alley &mdash; Denmark Street. 
 I showed it to Malcolm and he said to call up and offer &pound;1000 blind. 
 So I called. 
 Here, I said, I think my mate's mad but he says to offer you &pound;1000 for your place without even seeing it. 
 And the bloke on the other end of the phone said, I think we could talk business. 
 Malcolm got right on the phone with him and sorted it out. 
 The bloke's name was Bill Collins, the father of Lewis Collins, star of The Professionals  TV show. 
 Bill had been a Beatles roadie and then became a manager, of The Mojos and Badfinger &mdash; which is how he came to be the owner of studios in Denmark Street. 
 Badfinger had worked out of the studios but the main guy topped himself in 1975 (to be followed by another in 1983) and Bill was left with a studio and no band. 
 His big thing though was his piano theory. 
 He'd been involved with bands all those years and could play a bit of music but he never quite got the hang of the idea of written music. 
 So whenever he tried to explain any musical idea he just couldn't make his bands understand. 
 The classic example of that happened with Badfinger. 
 They wrote a song called &bquo;Without You&equo;, which they recorded as a semi-rock song. 
 Bill's idea was that they should play it as a ballad  instead. 
 So he tried to show them on the piano. 
 But as he couldn't play it that well, he just couldn't get his ideas across. 
 Which was a dreadful shame. 
 They badly needed a hit at the time. 
 (And it was that lack of hits which probably helped bring about the suicides.) 
 They might have had one if Bill could have explained his idea because that's exactly what Harry Nilsson later did with the song, turned it into a big ballad and scored a number one hit with it. 
 So, frustrated by this inability to demonstrate his ideas, he developed an entire new musical theory. 
 It had no sharps or flats and was based on a six-line stave &mdash; instead of the five-line one which is usual for musical notation. 
 He then built a machine for the piano which had a series of lights which went on and off ensuring that you played the right note &mdash; without ever having to understand what a sharp or a flat was. 
 He tried to get it marketed or patented but he never succeeded. 
 Anyway Malcolm quickly agreed to the terms on the lease and Steve and I moved in, living there as well as using it as a rehearsal room. 
 It was a small outbuilding off Denmark Street, behind a Greek bookshop. 
 It looked like it had been built as a rag trade sweatshop at the turn of the century and was sandwiched between a musical equipment shop and The Tin Pan Alley Club &mdash; which was a notorious music biz drinking den. 
 Amongst other things, we were always finding used syringes that had been lobbed over the wall. 
 At the far end was St. Giles Church &mdash; which meant we never had an excuse for being late anywhere as the bells tolled the hour &mdash; and the quarters &mdash; right through the night 
 Inside there were two rooms, one on each floor, both the same size, about 20 feet by 15. 
 It was small and poky, the carpet stank of sweat from all the bands that had rehearsed there over the years, the floor was rotten and covered with fungus More unpleasant smells came from the toilet that didn't work and the leaking skylight which let in so much rain the whole place was always damp. 
 The windows had been bricked up as part of the soundproofing. 
 Squalid is the word. 
 Steve and I shared the one room upstairs and tried to do it up a bit. 
 We put in a new sink and Malcolm  bought us a Baby Belling cooker, one electric ring on which we could heat a an of beans very, very slowly. 
 We fixed it up as well as we could &mdash; which wasn't well but it did give us both somewhere to live away from our parents, a first real taste of independence. 
 and it meant we had a regular rehearsal space &mdash; which we used nearly every day. 
 Maybe we'd only do half an hour before sloping off but, bit by bit, we were able to put a set together. 
 Our first gig was all of one hundred yards down the road. 
 On November 6, 1975, we played support at St Martin's School of Art to a band called Bazooka Joe &mdash; which included a young man called Stuart Goddard, later to become Adam Ant and so obsessed by punk that he has an almost complete set of Seditionaries clothing. 
 We'd been moaning to Malcolm about wanting to play some gigs. 
 Alright then, he said, if you're so keen, why don't you go and find them yourselves? 
 I took him at his word. 
 At that point I'd just left St Martin's. 
 I'd finished my foundation year earlier that summer and, although I'd been offered a fulltime place &mdash; and grant &mdash; to do my Fine Art degree in painting, I blew it out. 
 I was proud of getting accepted, particularly at St Martin's because it was such a good art school, but Fine Art seemed a fast road to nowhere What kind of job can you get at the end of that? 
 Even if you become a great painter you end up being some rich man's lackey, sponsored and dabbled with &mdash; if you're lucky. 
 More likely you rot as a tutor in High Wycombe or somewhere like Hatherley School of Fine Art, teaching the talentless children of the rich. 
 When the band became serious, I thought this is a far more contemporary and interesting way to make an artistic statement. 
 So I packed in art school. 
 Which was stupid really. 
 And Vivienne kept telling me, I should have stayed on just for the grant. 
 Which is what Mick Jones of The Clash did. 
 He was at Hammersmith Art College. 
 He turned up the first day of the term, picked up his grant, bought a guitar with it and then disappeared &bquo;till the start of the next term and that term's grant cheque.  
 But it was because I'd been at St. Martin's that we got that first gig. 
 At the end of my foundation year I'd been voted in as Social Secretary, in charge of putting on all the shows there. 
 So I trooped down there and muscled us in on the Bazooka Joe gig. 
 Then, just before that gig, I went over to Central School of Art in Holborn and swung us another gig there. 
 I walked in through the door and, feeling a bit lost, I asked the first person I saw if he knew whether the Social Secretary was around. 
 Yeth, he said, I am. 
 This was Sebastian Conran, son of Terence Conran, who founded Habitat, and brother of designer Jasper Conran. 
 But the bloke next to him wasn't having any of that. 
 Yes, he said, we are, making it clear that they were joint social secretaries. 
 This was All McDowell who became a close friend of mine, founded i-D magazine and coined the phrase &bquo;Fuck Art: Let's Dance.&equo; 
 Why do you want the social sec? he asked. 
 I'm in a band and we're looking for a gig. 
 What's the name of the group? asked All. 
 The Sex Pistols. 
 Sebastian's eyes lit right up. 
 Oh yeth, he said, with a name like the Thex Pithtolth we must have you. 
 So I invited them to the gig at St Martin's. 
 Which was something of a racket, plus Bazooka Joe kept on pulling the plugs on us trying to get us off the stage. 
 And they were in the audience. 
 All was dressed up like Bud Flanagan for some reason almost drowning in a raccoon coat. 
 And he kept roaring with laughter all the way through the set &mdash; well, what we managed to do of it. 
 I really thought we'd blown it when I saw him cracking up. 
 But, in fact, he really liked us. 
 The Central gig was the first one where we were actually allowed to play our own set all the way through. 
 This time we were promoted to co-headliners, with Roogalator who were another of the big names on the pub rock circuit at the time. 
 As soon as we arrived, the bass player, Paul &bquo;Bassman&equo; Riley, took one look at us and came over with a proposition. 
 Instead of moving all the gear around, he said, how about if I borrow your bass cabinet?  
 OK, I said. 
 Er, he said, while we're about it, you couldn't lend me your bass as well, could you? 
 They were meant to be a pro group while we were just starting out. 
 Yet we were the ones with all the flash gear. 
 Which just shows you what a lot of stuff Steve had lifted for us. 
 The show itself was one of the best we ever played. 
 On the other hand though I was really drunk so maybe I only remember it that way John turned round to me at the end and said, I can't understand you All the people I know, when they get pissed, they start fights, whereas you just seem really happy 
 There you go, I thought, a solid illustration of the difference between John and myself. 
 All this time we were still trying to fix up Denmark Street so that it became vaguely comfortable. 
 We got so fed up with the leaking roof that we decided to try and mend it with some tar. 
 Steve had gone off somewhere so, to help me along, I nicked one of his black bombers, the capsules of speed he always had around. 
 He had a prescription for them, from an infamous doctor in Harley Street. 
 They were meant to be for his weight but I'm not sure I believe that. 
 I thought maybe he'd convinced Malcolm that he was overweight &mdash; which he wasn't &mdash; and Malcolm had this real thing about us looking the part. 
 So Malcolm sprang for the script. 
 And Steve got the free speed he was after. 
 Out of my box on this bomber, I remembered there was a bird I fancied at St. Martin's &mdash; Virginia. 
 So I went there and cornered her in the canteen and tried to chat her up for half an hour. 
 I was rabbiting and rabbiting and rabbiting as we drank our tea. 
 She quite obviously wasn't listening to a word of it. 
 Glen, she said, you alright, Glen? 
 It was a freezing cold day and I'd been sitting there in nothing but these dungarees that I'd been working on the roof in. 
 Never got anywhere with her, of course. 
 Steve was already there when I got back. 
 He looked at me really carefully and deliberately. 
 He got out his pills, tipped them out on the table and started counting them &mdash; which took absolutely ages because he never did count too well. 
 Just as he  got to the last one I said, by the way, I had one of those. 
 That's how it is between flat mates. 
 Because someone had tried &mdash; very badly &mdash; to soundproof the room, all the walls were covered with cork tiles which stood proud from the wall behind. 
 We took it all down in one day, helped by Steve's mothers' little helpers. 
 All that was left to do was a big hole in the wall by the sink that needed filling. 
 We decided to go to bed for the night. 
 We both got our heads down and then a scratching noise started up Steve is that you? 
 No, Glen is that you? 
 We turned the light on The room was full of funny little animals whizzing all over the floor. 
 Mice. 
 A squadron of them moving four abreast in perfect formation, frightened because we'd put the light on, scampering around trying to jump over the bed and the settee. 
 They'd been happy behind their cork and we'd torn down their cover. 
 Whooooah, Said Steve and dived under the covers. 
 We had to sleep like that. 
 I had to try and get a bit of kip on the crumbling sofa with a torch in one hand and a big bit of four by two in the other, ready to whack any of the mice if they came out to get us. 
 It was bad enough already sleeping there. 
 In fact, it was fucking horrible. 
 The roof leaked. 
 Every time it rained you had to move your bed. 
 And after that, of course, we couldn't get to sleep. 
 Every little noise we thought was another assault wave of killer mice. 
 &bquo;Ere Glen, said Steve, you asleep? 
 No, can't. 
 Me neither, Glen, you ever had a wank with a johnny on? 
 Can't say I have, Steve. 
 It's fucking great. 
 Mind you better than that is a loaf of bread. 
 Not sliced stuff though, none of that Wonderloaf lark. 
 It's got to be a good loaf of bread, like that one you buy down the road, the black one, that'll do. 
 Slice the top off and scoop a bit out from the middle. 
 Then fill it up with water from the kettle, Not boiling, mind, that could prove disastrous. 
 Just a nice kind of warm, room temperature slosh of water, that's what you need. 
 And you shag that. 
 It's fucking great. 
 The best thing of all though is&hellip; 
 Yeah?  
 Pound of liver with a slit in it. 
 Goodnight Steve. 
 We were so broke when we were living there that I'd buy a bar of Kit Kat in the morning, have two fingers of it for breakfast and the other two for dinner in the evening. 
 That's all I'd have to eat all day. 
 By this time I'd left St. Martins so there was no more grant. 
 I was having to survive on my dole money &mdash; which seemed to disappear the day I got it. 
 Kit Kats were about all I could afford. 
 Then we sussed out that bread and milk were delivered to the local restaurants really early. 
 So we'd wait up all night, follow the delivery van around and survive on the bread and milk we could swipe. 
 We complained to Malcolm, told him we were fed up with the mice and we didn't have enough money to eat properly. 
 (John, by the way, would always claim they were rats &mdash; with his usual sense of accuracy.) 
 So Malcolm went down Club Row market and bought us a cat and the most ridiculously horrible food &mdash; tins of sardines and those disgusting tinned plum tomatoes they used to try and make you eat at school. 
 There you go boys, he said, that'll do you 
 And he cooked us sardine soup. 
 It wasn't bad actually. 
 Cor, he said, this is almost like being an art student again. 
 But, that one banquet apart, it wasn't. 
 We were always  hungry. 
 One Sunday I was so fed up with living on Kit Kats that I called my mum. 
 How you going Glen? she said, Bit fed up actually, I'm hungry. 
 Come over son, there's a nice bit of Sunday dinner going here. 
 Naah, I said. 
 I can't make it, I've got to go and see a mate. 
 But that was an excuse. 
 Really my mouth was watering. 
 The truth was I really fancied going there but I didn't even have the money to bunk the tube. 
 All I needed was 10 pence &mdash; which was what you had to pay in those days if you said you came from the previous stop &mdash; but I didn't even have that. 
 We were always hungry and we were always broke. 
 It's not as though we weren't making money at the time either. 
 We were gigging and getting well paid for it. 
 When we did start playing proper gigs we got surprisingly good money. 
 We'd get  &pound;50 or &pound;60 a night &mdash; which might not sound like a lot but that's still what young bands get for the same gigs today. 
 In fact, a lot of bands starting out these days have to pay  to play their first gigs. 
 Which is a right liberty. 
 But we never saw any of that money. 
 It got to the stage where we didn't bother to ask what happened to it. 
 We didn't even think about it. 
 Only once did I get some money after a gig. 
 We'd played in St. Albans and I'd met a girl there, Claire, She was the Social Secretary at the college who'd booked us in to play. 
 Give us a quid, Malcolm, I said, so I can get home in the morning. 
 He gave me a fiver. 
 I couldn't believe my luck. 
 We went down to an awful Wimpy Bar opposite Chagueramas &mdash; which later became The Roxy. 
 In those days it was full of horrible camp types dancing to limp disco. 
 They were all sub- &bquo;Virginia Plain' characters with half a floorbrush on each shoulder. 
 It was supposed to look like they were wearing epaulettes but it never did. 
 That was the first time I'd had any money out of gigging in a year. 
 We played some strange old gigs in that period. 
 Andrew Logan's party, for instance, which got us our first press &mdash; a mention in an upmarket society fashion magazine. 
 The party was held at his flat which was a loft in a warehouse down by the river in Shad Thames on a wharf right next to Tower Bridge I'd never seen anywhere like it. 
 We had to take all the gear up in a hoist. 
 Then, when you got inside, you could see how this man had come to run something as bizarre as The Alternative Miss World &mdash; with its transvestites and concept artists. 
 Logan had done some of the designs for the old Biba department store in Kensington High Street and, when it closed down, he took all his work back to his flat. 
 His bedroom was the Sleeping Beauty scene he'd done for Biba's children's department and the kitchen area was full of artificial trees &mdash; which his party guests used to piss against. 
 I thought it was great. 
 Unsurprisingly, Steve looked around and said: bum bandits, all of 'em Come on, said Malcolm, be cool,  he's letting us play here. 
 But Steve really wasn't happy. 
 This wasn't his idea of a proper place for his band to play. 
 When we did get to play, the stage was a set that Logan had designed for a movie &mdash; the court scene in Derek Jarman's Sebastiane . 
 We played The Marquee for the first and only time supporting Eddie And The Hot Rods. 
 We were dreadful &mdash; but arrogant with it. 
 It was the first time we'd had proper monitors on stage &mdash; which meant it was the first time John heard his own voice. 
 And he didn't like what he heard So he trashed the monitors. 
 A terrible gig. 
 But also our first review. 
 Neil Spencer wrote about it in the New Musical Express  beneath the headline &bquo;Don't Look Over Your Shoulder, But The Sex Pistols Are Coming.&equo; 
 You can't play, a French tourist at the front shouted. 
 So what? 
 I shouted back. 
 Later Spencer chatted to us, asking about music. 
 We're not into music, we told him. 
 What are you into then? 
 Chaos. 
 We quickly found that few places would let us play so we started looking round for alternatives. 
 Malcolm had taken on an assistant by this time, Nils Stevenson. 
 He wanted to give Nils something to do to justify his position so he sent him out to hunt out unusual places for us to play. 
 Nils came up with El Paradise, a strip club in Soho's Brewer Street, It fitted. 
 The Sex Pistols plus strip club. 
 What could be more natural? 
 We took it over for a Sunday night, hiring it, promoting the gig ourselves, pushing out a lot of handbills. 
 And, on the day itself, we turned up early to sort out the club. 
 It was a tiny place &mdash; nothing more than a shop knocked through from the street at ground level, no more than 60 feet long At one end was a small bar &mdash; from which we sold orange juices on top of the counter with the booze tucked away underneath. 
 At the other end was a stage with footlights. 
 To one side was a row of lights which flickered on and off like something you'd get 
 the Palladium &mdash; a cheap trick to try and convince the punters that they were in somewhere far classier than was really the case.  
 And it stank. 
 It was absolutely filthy, horrible and scuzzy, with disgusting stains on the floor. 
 So &mdash; hard as it may be for some people to believe &mdash; we disinfected the whole place, sloshing the stuff everywhere. 
 When it came to show time, John started acting very oddly. 
 Either because he had the hump or because he thought it would make for a good show he started smashing the footlights one by one. 
 As he did this a Maltese feller started striding slowly but purposefully towards us from the back of the club. 
 We knew he was the owner of the club and &mdash; while he can't have been more than four-foot-nine inches tall &mdash; we knew that Soho was run by Maltese gangsters just like him. 
 He was built like a brick shithouse and he plonked himself down right in front of the stage. 
 He put one elbow on the stage itself and stared straight at John. 
 There was a fair crowd there but it was scarcely crowded: John couldn't have not noticed him. 
 But that's what he pretended. 
 for three numbers the Maltese heavy stared at him &mdash; while all his henchmen stood at the back of the club watching him watching John. 
 For three numbers John looked everywhere but at him. 
 Really, his point made &mdash; a kind of behave yourself young lad, or you will come to a sticky end &mdash; he stood up and wandered back to the bar. 
 It was also during this period that we had the strangest set of photographs taken of us, by Peter Christopherson who worked for a design company, Hipgnosis &mdash; whose offices were at the back of our Denmark Street HQ &mdash; and who later joined Throbbing Gristle, a band best known for tabloid spreads on their occult practices. 
 Their offices faced right on to our living quarters and they were always staring at us. 
 It got so bad we had to do the full old lady bit and put up net curtains. 
 Then one day the main guy who'd been peeking at us turned up and asked if he could take some pictures of us. 
 Malcolm said OK, but even he can't have had any idea what Christopherson intended. 
 Paul, he made up covered with bullet wounds. 
 Steve, he photographed in handcuffs. 
 John, he put in a straitjacket. 
 And  me, he took me round to the YMCA locker room and photographed me half dressed. 
 It was pretty obvious he was after making me look like a rent boy. 
 A very weird man &mdash; who, if The Pistols had stayed together, could have made a fortune flogging those snaps to a Sunday dreadful. 
 Apart from our regular rehearsals we often found ourselves at a loose end and would all troop round together. 
 One afternoon we were all wandering up Tottenham Court Road for some reason. 
 Maybe we were on our way to a cheap Indian self-service restaurant that Malcolm had introduced us to. 
 Maybe we were on our way to the Fender Soundhouse because Steve needed some new strings for his guitar. 
 About half way up Tottenham Court Road there was, and still is, a Scientology centre. 
 They have people hanging about outside on the pavement trying to entice gullible idiots in. 
 We had nothing much better to do so we all piled in. 
 They gave us a questionnaire each to fill in. 
 And the results really showed the four different characters in the band. 
 Well, three different characters really because Steve and Paul always kind of lumped themselves together. 
 They were like Fred Flintstone and Barney Rubble, that's how I used to think of them. 
 I went into another room to talk to a Scientology person. 
 He started telling me that I was an emotional cretin and to improve I'd have to pay them a load of money to get into their reading room &mdash; at &pound;10 an hour. 
 I said, hang on a minute, you haven't even read my questionnaire yet. 
 You're telling me all this guff and you haven't even read what I wrote. 
 I thought it was all a joke, you've really got to be some schmuck to fall for that one. 
 And I walked out 
 I hung around outside, waiting. 
 After a few minutes, Fred Flintstone and Barney Rubble emerged. 
 They were really worried. 
 They believed everything they d been told. 
 Straightaway Steve got on to Malcolm and told him they needed all this money to join up with Scientology. 
 Malcolm told him not to be so stupid. 
 For ages afterwards all these letters kept arriving at Denmark Street from the Scientologists. 
 They'd say things like, &bquo;Glen, you've been a really naughty boy. 
 You didn't turn up for a meeting two weeks ago.&equo; 
 Malcolm just used to screw them up and chuck them in the bin.  
 John, however, coined out of it. 
 he conned them into believing he was really into Scientology. 
 So they gave him a job. 
 And, as far as I can remember, he did it. 
 He went up there a couple of times and stood outside on the pavement forcing leaflets on people, trying to get them to come inside. 
 I said to him, don't you think it's morally wrong trying to con people like that, getting them to shell out all that money? 
 It's exploiting those who are least able to handle it. 
 He said, it's not my fault if people are stupid. 
 Iggy Pop had a similar attitude. 
 Years later I remember we were recording at Rockfield Studios. 
 We were all eating roast venison and at the same time discussing vegetarianism. 
 Jim (no one who knows him calls him Iggy) being Jim was squatting on the table stuffing everyone else's venison into his roll and eating it with his fingers. 
 The way I see it is this, he said, if animals weren't so stupid, they wouldn't get caught. 
 Just like John. 
 It was while we were at Denmark Street that the punk scene &mdash; as it would later be called &mdash; began to develop. 
 All of us would hang around together. 
 Not just The Pistols but others, like Mick Jones &mdash; who formed The Clash &mdash; and Tony James &mdash; who started Generation X. 
 On Fridays we'd often go to the Royal College of Art where they used to have these great shows which went on till three or four o'clock in the morning. 
 I knew about them because of being at art college and I took Steve and Paul down with me and introduced them to a scene they knew nothing about. 
 It was after one of those shows that I introduced Mick Jones to Joe Strummer for the first time. 
 A whole crowd of us were walking back to Denmark Street &mdash; me and Rat Scabies and Brian James &mdash; two founders of The Damned &mdash; and Mick Jones and some others. 
 We bumped into Strummer on the corner of Old Compton Street and Frith Street, just down the road from Ronnie Scott's. 
 Which was where Strummer was going. 
 What you doin'? he said. 
 I went to see this bloke play at Ronnie Scott's last night. 
 He was fucking great. 
 You should go. 
 In fact, he said if I wanted to bring along some mates, he'd get us all in free. 
 So we checked it out. 
 This being the early days of punk we looked like complete urchins. 
 So everyone working on the door at Ronnie's had a good laugh at us while Strummer was hustling to get us in. 
 Tom said if I brought some mates, he'd get us in.  
 Tom who? said the bloke on the door. 
 Tom Waits. 
 Oh, he said, but he did go off and fetch him. 
 And there was Tom Waits at the door, in this big Crombie coat. 
 Hey Joe! 
 What can I do for you? 
 Well, you said if I brought a couple of mates down you'd get us in. 
 Yeah, that should be OK. 
 How many of you are there? 
 We had a quick count up and there were about 10 of us. 
 Hey! said Tom, hang on there a minute. 
 He leant back against the door, opened this big overcoat and there, in the inside pocket, was a pint of Guinness with a perfect head on it. 
 He can't have put it there for effect because he didn't know who was going to be there. 
 He just happened  to have a pint of Guinness with a perfect head on it in his pocket. 
 Though how he managed it I don't know. 
 I've tried to do it endless times since but the drink just goes everywhere. 
 He stood there, reached into the coat, pulled out the pint, drank it all down in one go and nodded to the barman. 
 Hey! 
 Let the boys in. 
 And he was great. 
 Another person who was around the scene at the time was Chrissie Hynde who, after Malcolm's shop and writing for the NME , had really been scuffling around. 
 One night I remember, she knocked on the door at Denmark Street just as we were packing up. 
 The other guys all left and she walked out with me. 
 As we got to Tottenham Court Road &mdash; which is just round the corner &mdash; she spotted the Ann Summers sex shop there and said, hang on, let's just pop in there for a minute. 
 What are you going in there for? 
 I said. 
 To get a job. 
 It wasn't that she wanted to work in a sex shop but that she needed work of some kind. 
 She'd been writing for the NME , about David Cassidy and things like that but it must have been quite a struggle to get by. 
 She was an alien in the country with no dole to fall back on, didn't have much money. 
 So basically she was looking for a job. 
 Still, even though they didn't need any staff, I must admit I thought Ann Summers was a funny one to pick.  
 Paul was a big problem for a while. 
 John and I were on the dole. 
 Steve got by as best he knew how. 
 But Paul had a full-time job. 
 We were always putting pressure on him to jack it in. 
 We told him that this was a band for full-timers not part-timers. 
 He was an apprentice electrician at Watneys brewery in Mortlake. 
 As he'd nearly finished his apprenticeship, he was understandably loathe to pack it in. 
 He must have reckoned that having a back-up trade was always a handy thing when you're going into something as risky as the music business. 
 My dad certainly agreed with him. 
 He was always on at me to become a cab driver or something. 
 Just in case the music didn't work out. 
 But Paul didn't like to admit that this was the reason he didn't want to give up his day job. 
 So he created a smokescreen, making the excuse that he didn't think Steve was a good enough guitarist by himself and that we needed a second guitar. 
 Nothing but a diversionary tactic. 
 So we had to go through a whole charade of auditioning a second guitarist. 
 We put an ad in the Melody Maker  which read: Whizz Kid Guitarist. 
 Not older than 20. 
 Not worse looking than Johnny Thunders. 
 Auditioning. 
 Tin Pan Alley. 
 Ring 351 0764, 673 0855. 
 All these Herberts turned up. 
 The first bloke was late so, instead of waiting, we decided to go to the pub. 
 Just as we were leaving he turned up in the hallway. 
 He was Greek or something like that. 
 Definitely a bit of a bubble. 
 He had snakeskin boots and a matching snakeskin guitar case. 
 His shirt was undone to the waist, showing off a little gold shark's tooth on a chain and a Keith Richards-style scarf. 
 With him was a friend dressed exactly the same. 
 We walked straight past, pretending not to notice him, but he got hold of Malcolm and said, where's the audition? 
 You can't be for the audition, said Malcolm. 
 Why do you think that? said Mr Snakeskin. 
 Well, said Malcolm, did you read the ad? 
 Yes. 
 Well, you must have missed the bit where it said &bquo;not worse looking than Johnny Thunders,&equo; The poor bloke was completely crestfallen.  
 But it was mostly all like that. 
 People turn up for auditions who can't play at all. 
 You get used to it. 
 The only one who really could play was Steve New who was later in The Rich Kids with me. 
 He turned up for the audition with his art teacher, Rose, who he was dating at the time. 
 He told us he was 16 but really he was only 15. 
 Him apart though it was pretty much all no-hopers &mdash; nothing more than a total waste of time and a convenient way for Paul to take the pressure off himself. 
 So we took Steve New on as second guitarist. 
 But he was on a hiding to nothing really. 
 Jonesy was getting better by the minute on the guitar and the sound we were after had no space for the flash lead work that Steve could play so well. 
 So, after a month with two guitarists, we were back to being what we started out to be, a four-piece.  
 THE CONSERVATIVE RECORD 1979 &mdash; 1989 
 THAT governments do make a difference is an important presumption of free competitive elections. 
 Citizens choose between different teams of politicians and whichever one wins enacts the programme on which it campaigned. 
 In fact only about thirty or so states in the world today regularly hold competitive elections and of these only a small number provide an outcome in which one party forms the government. 
 Many changes of government in Britain do not usher in a new set of policies in most departments. 
 Over the long term continuity is more apparent than discontinuity. 
 Historians might say that in the twentieth century in Britain only the reforming administrations of 1906 and 1945 provided a major change in direction to be followed by administrations which consolidated the changes. 
 In the future historians are likely to regard the post-1979 Conservative governments as also having produced a change in direction, one which reversed the direction of previous post-war administrations. 
 The Impact of Parties 
 Political scientists have for some time tried to grapple with the question: what difference, if any, does party control of the government make to political outputs? 
 Does a government of the left, for example, produce policy outcomes which favour the working class and organized labour, and shift power from the private to the state sector? 
 Do administrations of the right pursue policies which have the opposite effects? 
 A difficulty with conducting this type of research is controlling for outside factors, for example, international recession, or war, or a disastrous crop failure. 
 And how does one deal with counterfactuals, that is, what might have happened in the absence of the control of government by the particular party? 
 Might another party have followed similar policies? 
 The burden of  many studies, subject to such qualifications, is that on balance political factors like party or ideology or electoral competitiveness do not matter much, compared to a country's level of economic development. 
 In Britain there has developed a learned debate about the impact of party on government. 
 One school, led by S. E. Finer, claims that the parties do make a difference and that, because parties have become more partisan, this is regrettable. 
 These critics point to the discontinuity which followed changes of government in the 1970s in such areas as industrial policy, incomes policy, secondary education, industrial relations and law. 
 They also claim that these discontinuities were aggravated by the more frequent turnover of party control in the government in the 1970s and the influence exercised in both parties by its more partisan groups. 
 Britain, it is suggested, suffers from an adversary form of Politics , in which a party formulates in opposition &mdash; largely for ideological and electorally opportunist reasons &mdash; the policies which are then carried into government. 
 A new government's efforts to undo much of its predecessor's work is damaging and disruptive. 
 This style, critics allege, is accentuated by Britain's two-party system and unfair (because disproportional) first past the post electoral system, which produces virtually full power for the government and virtual impotence for the opposition. 
 A different view has been advanced by Richard Rose. 
 Rose tried to test if there were big shifts in the economy, as posited by the adversary model, or continuities, regardless of changes in party control of government. 
 Evidence of continuity is what Rose calls, unhelpfully perhaps, a consensus model . 
 Between 1957 and 1979 he found that on such economic inputs as minimum lending rate, public-sector borrowing requirement, and public spending as a proportion of GDP and on economic outcomes such as inflation, unemployment, and growth, the record showed long-term secular trends, regardless of changes of government. 
 Something stronger than party was clearly at work. 
 There are many reasons for parties failing to produce intended changes in outcomes. 
 One may point to the ever-present pressures of interest groups and lobbies, international forces beyond the control of a national government, the advice of  permanent civil servants inherited commitments in policy and public expenditure, and the flow of so much routine in policy. 
 These are not necessarily forces for continuity but they may act as barriers to government attempts to impose a new line of policy. 
 One might also point to the fear among many politicians of electoral retribution if radical measures turn out to be unpopular. 
 On the other hand critics of the consensus within the Labour and the Conservative parties are more likely to point to the failures of political will, courage, persistence, and policy preparation by their respective leaderships as explanations for the convergence. 
 Changes in government have led to discontinuities in policy, but trends towards convergence have also occurred, despite the parties in office attempting to carry out different policies. 
 Between 1945 and 1975, for example, there was a change in government policy on prices and incomes every thirteen months on average and between 1958 and 1974 a change in corporation tax every two years on average. 
 In 1970 the new Conservative government reversed its predecessor's policies on the reorganization of secondary education, aid to industry, prices and incomes controls, and pensions. 
 In 1974 Labour introduced new policies for each of these, as well as for the EEC, housing finance, and trade union law. 
 Yet by the end of its term of office each government had moderated its original policies. 
 By 1973 the Conservatives had moved to a statutory prices and incomes policy and massive state intervention in industry; the reorganization of secondary schooling along comprehensive lines proceeded, albeit at a slower pace than under Labour, and the trade union legislation under the Industrial Relations Act was effectively non-operational. 
 By 1978 Britain, under Labour, was still in the EEC, the government had an incomes policy of sorts and had curbed the growth of public expenditure, and private education remained. 
 What is important to note, therefore, is that governments often abruptly or gradually change their policies, generally around the mid-term of Parliament, and that continuities occur in spite of the parties' starting out with different policies. 
 This convergence may have less to do with ideology than with political &bquo;learning&equo; and having to cope with unanticipated events. 
 The adversarial critique may explain the early stages of a government's record but Rose's  &bquo;moving consensus&equo; is more relevant to an understanding of the long-term trends. 
 The Conservative Record 
 Conservative ministers and many commentators claim that there has been something of a revolution in British politics in the 1980s. 
 Supporters and many critics agree that the old policy agenda has been turned upside down. 
 This chapter considers the record of governments since 1979 in four important areas; welfare, privatization, the economy, and industrial relations. 
 Although there have been more comprehensive examinations of the record of the governments, the above four policy areas are of interest because the Conservative government pledged itself to change the direction of policy in them. 
 They do represent, however, only a part of the record of the government and in some other areas, notably education and central-local government relations, there have been significant changes. 
 Welfare 
 The thinking of Conservative critics of the welfare state has been coloured by three broad influences. 
 One is that the cradle to grave provision of welfare, implicit in the Beveridge proposals, has proved to be too expensive and that the demand for welfare has grown faster than has the national income to pay for adequate comprehensive services and benefits. 
 The choice, according to such critics, has been either to increase taxes to cover the public spending for the services &mdash; which was contrary to the government's tax-cutting policies &mdash; or to reduce the scale of state provision of welfare. 
 The critics argued that some cut-back or restraint in spending or provision was necessary, both to fund tax cuts and allow for the concentration of resources on the most needy. 
 They were selectivists  rather than universalists  in their approach to welfare spending. 
 A second influence has been the judgement that too dominant a role for the state weakens the values of individual self-reliance, family and community solidarity, and private charity. 
 people should be encouraged to make provision for themselves and their families, and state support should provide  a safety net for the very poor, without stifling private initiative and self-help. 
 Some Conservatives also suspected that the welfare ethic &mdash; by removing the risks and disciplines of the market, providing a cushion for failures, and undermining incentives for the ambitious &mdash; weakened enterprise. 
 In 1981 the then Head of Mrs Thatcher's Policy Unit, Ferdinand Mount (author of the book, The Subversive Family) , set up a Family Policy Group, a committee of Cabinet ministers, with a remit to suggest ways for strengthening family life and promoting a sense of individual responsibility. 
 Among proposals which ministers made were more incentives for mothers to remain at home, education vouchers, curbs on the power of the professions, and greater encouragement for wealth creators. 
 But offsetting the above views was an awareness among party leaders that many welfare programmes, particularly old age pensions and the National Health Service, are very popular with voters. 
 In 1979 Mrs Thatcher made election pledges to increase old age pensions in line with inflation and to &bquo;protect&equo; the National Health Service, although she made no commitments about other areas. 
 Subsequently she and ministers boasted about their increased spending and claimed that the NHS is &bquo;safe with us&equo;.   
 For much of the 1980s there was also a growing concern among ministers about the mounting financial costs of the system. 
 Social security spending expanded greatly after 1979 (see Table 8. 1) partly because of the unexpected and sharp rise in unemployment and partly because of the increase in people of pensionable age. 
 By 1988 &mdash; 9 the total spending on social security was &pound;47.6 billion or 31 per cent of total public spending, up from 25 per cent in 1978 &mdash; 9. 
 Nearly half (43 per cent) of this total was spent on retirement pensions. 
 The other main categories of social security spending were family allowances (12.5 per cent), supplementary benefits (17.5 per cent), and national insurance spending on those suffering unemployment or industrial injury. 
 For a government intent on curbing the growth of public spending, social security presented a large target. 
 The Thatcher government, like Mr Heath's in 1970, promised to review existing policies to get greater value for money, eliminate fraud, and reduce waste. 
 The earnings-related supplements to benefits for the unemployed, the sick, and widows, and maternity benefit and injury benefit were abolished. 
 In 1980 the government raised various benefits, including those for the sick and the unemployed, by 5 per cent less than the current rate of inflation, though the abatement was restored in 1983 when the benefits were made subject to tax. 
 In 1981 it cut the link between earnings and unemployment benefits and uprated benefits in line with price rather than wage increases (which have been higher for much of the decade). 
 Treasury concern about the financial consequences of the long-term impact of the steady rise in welfare expenditure and a slow rate of economic growth remained. 
 The famous 1982 CPRS paper examined the options with a low future rate of economic growth and made radical proposals for cutting the state provision of welfare. 
 The contents of the paper apparently horrified some ministers and, under some pressure, Mrs Thatcher withdrew it from the Cabinet agenda. 
 But not everybody accepted its startling assumptions. 
 For ministers to talk in gloomy terms about the future pressures on public spending risked calling into question the effectiveness of their economic strategy. 
 There was other evidence that, with a moderate (2 to 3 per cent) rate of economic growth, the demographic trends  would not impose pressures on the public purse until 2020 and a crisis would occur only if the economy failed to grow by 2 per cent or more. 
 A major worry to Mrs Thatcher and the Treasury was the future of the State Earnings Related Pensions (SERPS) which had been established by the Labour government in 1975. 
 This had become operational in 1978, although full earnings-related pensions were not due to come into effect until 1998. 
 At the time of its introduction it was hailed as a measure which placed pensions above party politics and was accepted by the Conservative spokesmen of the day. 
 By 1985 approximately half of the work-force was in the state scheme and half in private schemes. 
 The actual pension that was to be provided, about a quarter of average earnings, was rather modest in comparison to the pensions provided in most other Western European states. 
 In 1984 the Social Services Secretary, Norman Fowler, appointed four review teams covering pensions, housing benefit, supplementary benefits, and child benefits. 
 The results were presented in June 1985 in a Green Paper, The Reform of Social Security (Cmnd. 9517). 
 The Green Paper's major suggestion for saving money in the short term was to cut housing benefit, so reducing expenditure by some &pound;500 million annually. 
 Its most controversial suggestion to cut the financial burden on the state was to phase out SERPS over the following three years. 
 The dependency ratio, that is the number of people of working age per pensioner, would improve from 2.76 in 1981 to 2.99 in 2000. 
 But the ratio would then fall sharply in the second and third decades of the twenty-first century. 
 Mrs Thatcher's own fears were revealed in an interview with the New York Times  in late January 1984 when she claimed that the long-term social security spending commitments were a financial &bquo;time-bomb&equo; for Britain. 
 By the second and third decades of the twenty-first century the pension commitments would probably involve a major burden upon a smaller number of taxpayers, who might not be prepared to carry it. 
 It was also well known that Mrs Thatcher preferred to have people buying their own private pension scheme; here was an area in which the state might be rolled back. 
 In Parliament, opposition spokesmen condemned the  proposals as an attack on the welfare state and a break with the consensus. 
 That was expected but much of the reaction from employers, welfare groups, and the pension industry as well as Tory back-benchers was also hostile. 
 Revised proposals were presented in a White Paper in December 1985. 
 These were enacted in 1986 although most did not come into operation until April 1988. 
 The most significant change from the Green Paper was that SERPS would not be abolished but scaled down; the proportion of earnings on which the pension would be based was reduced from 25 to 20 per cent. 
 Although most of the proposed changes in means-tested forms of support were confirmed the review would now realize only marginal financial savings. 
 The government had retreated: radical Thatcherism backed off from fundamental reform of the system. 
 The appointment of John Moore in 1987 as Secretary of State at the DHSS was seen by some as a signal that the welfare programme would receive a dose of Thatcherism. 
 Moore spoke about his determination to end &bquo;dependency&equo;, and drew on the work of the American Charles Murray, who was critical of many US welfare programmes. 
 Yet examination of the aggregate public spending figures on social security hardly justify charges of &bquo;an attack on the welfare state&equo;. 
 On the other hand, uprating many benefits in line with prices rather than earnings means that recipients have not shared as fully as others in the higher living standards achieved in the 1980s. 
 The government's strategy increasingly appears to be one not of reducing expenditure but of containing the rise in costs, targeting benefits on the most needy, and encouraging a redistribution of the burden to the private sector. 
 Child benefit has not been uprated annually since 1987. 
 From the academic year 1990 &mdash; 1 students will no longer be eligible for Housing Benefit, Supplementary Benefit, and Income Support. 
 In 1988 the government established a scheme of Income Support and a Social Fund to replace Supplementary Benefits. 
 Whereas the Supplementary Benefits Scheme had given grants to people to cover essential items, such as cooking utensils, the Fund replaced this with loans. 
 There have also been symbolic measures (such as restoring pay beds in NHS facilities), minor cuts (such as withdrawal of supplementary benefits in vacations for students), some marginal privatization (from 1986 employers  were made responsible for paying sickness benefit for the first 28 weeks of an employee's absence from work), tougher criteria (people have to be &bquo;actually seeking work&equo; to be entitled to receive unemployment benefit and since 1 988 housing benefit is paid to fewer households), and an increase in the numbers relying on private medical insurance (from 4 to 8 per cent since 1979). 
 But overwhelmingly the state is still the main provider of welfare: Britain has a welfare state. 
 The story of marginal change is not dissimilar in the health service. 
 For all the talk of &bquo;cuts&equo;, state spending on health has increased by nearly a third in real terms since 1979, and as a share of total public spending it has moved from 14 per cent in 1978 &mdash; 9 to 16 per cent in 1988 &mdash; 9. 
 However an increase is needed to take account of the growing number of elderly (heavy users of the NHS) and developments in health care technology, and increased spending has been more modest in some parts of the service, notably hospitals. 
 British health spending of 6 per cent of GDP is a smaller proportion than most other western states. 
 The government claims that total spending is larger in other western states because many have a larger private sector; in the United Kingdom it is just 0.8 per cent of total spending. 
 It wishes to promote more private health schemes although it has made clear that the NHS will remain a largely state-financed service. 
 The 1989 review of the NHS allowed tax relief for private health insurance for the over-60s but the rejection of other means of finance rules out any fundamental change in the near future. 
 The review abolished local authority representation in health service bodies, gave a greater role to the Audit Commission to ensure value for money, gave doctors budgets and linked a greater share of their salaries to the number of patients treated, and held out the possibility of hospitals &bquo;opting out&equo; and becoming self-governing. 
 But these largely managerial changes hardly amounted to a fundamental review; rather they were concerned to promote competition and value for money. 
 Over time the rhetoric of government spokesmen has changed to boasting of how much more manpower (doctors and nurses) and money is devoted to the NHS, compared to 1979. 
 The government's early arguments that &bquo;we can't afford it&equo; are less persuasive with the budget surplus accumulated in 1987  and 1988 and claims that tax cuts are better than greater state spending on social and health services have found fewer takers among the public (see below p. 297). 
 Privatization 
 The impact of the Thatcher government's new thinking has most obviously been felt in the privatization programme for the state-owned and state-provided services. 
 The programme covers both denationalization (or the sale of assets and shares owned by the state) and liberalization (or the relaxation or abolition of a service s statutory monopoly). 
 Perhaps in no other area of policy has the discontinuity between the present and previous governments been so marked. 
 Before 1979 the Conservative party had effectively acquiesced in most of the public ownership measures of earlier Labour governments. 
 Previous Conservative acts of denationalization, such as iron and steel after 1951 (later renationalized by Labour in 1967) and the sale of the Thomas Cook travel agency and Carlisle public houses under Mr Heath hardly refuted the broad continuity of post-war policy or Sir Keith Joseph's complaints about the ratchet effect in this area. 
 The privatization policy was consistent with the Prime Minister's beliefs that there should be a major diminution in state intervention in the economy and greater reliance on the free market. 
 The 1979 Conservative election manifesto claimed: &bquo;The balance of our society has been increasingly tilted in favour of the state at the expense of individual freedom&hellip; this election may be the last chance we have to reverse that process.&equo; 
 Mrs Thatcher also believed that the publicly owned industries were inefficient and an obstacle to the creation of a more dynamic and adaptive economy. 
 Apart from the Labour party and public-sector trade unions, the nationalized industries had few friends by 1979. 
 Opinion surveys showed that public ownership won few votes for Labour and that even many loyal supporters disapproved ofthe party's commitment to further nationalization. 
 Yet a large public sector appeared to be an almost inevitable part of the modern economy. 
 Even when industries were not state owned there were various other instruments by which government  actually exercised a large measure of control over the private sector. 
 Government was a major actor through its policies in the public sector, periodic controls on prices and incomes, legislation on industrial relations, policies for regional aid, and the location of firms and trade. 
 The Heath government had taken statutory controls over prices, incomes, and dividends and its 1972 Industry Act permitted large-scale state intervention in industry. 
 By 1979, after another spell of Labour government the nationalized industries accounted for 10 per cent of GDP, 15 per cent of national investment, and 8 per cent of employment. 
 The public sector itself accounted for some 30 per cent of employment. 
 Attempts to roll back the state in industry (as well as welfare) seemed a hopeless task. 
 Within the Conservative party, particularly among local activists and MPs, there had long been numerous critics of the nationalized industries and advocates of a more market-orientated economy. 
 A more political concern was the legacy of the 1970 &mdash; 4 government's experience with incomes policies and public-sector wages. 
 Both free collective bargaining and incomes policies were difficult to operate in a situation where there were powerful public-sector trade unions, conducting centralized wage bargaining and virtually monopolizing. key services. 
 In industries like coal, railways, and power the unions were in a very strong bargaining position. 
 In the mid-1960s wage bargaining in the public sector became more politicized and produced frequent confrontations with the central government, regardless of whether it had an incomes policy or not. 
 The leaked findings during 1978 of an internal report for the Conservative party noted that in the case of strikes in key services and industries the government would simply have to pay up. 
 The party did not want a repeat of the disastrous &bquo;Who Governs?&equo; election of 1974. 
 Many Conservative spokesmen paint a view of two sectors. 
 On the one hand, a private sector which allowed free entry of producers, was subject to competition, sought profits, and had to respond to consumers or else go bankrupt. 
 On the other side was the public sector, enjoying a monopolistic and low-risk position, responding to political rather than consumer preferences, and pre-empting investment funds from more productive areas. 
 Since 1979 the programme of privatization has been  defended with a mixture of ideological and pragmatic arguments. 
 One is that such policies produce an extension of economic freedom and, thereby, political freedom. 
 The nationalized industries, it is claimed, deprive the consumer of choice and limit the taxpayer's freedom to spend his money as he chooses because of the industry's monopoly position and reliance on state subsidies. 
 Critics also pointed to the lack of competition, absence of commercial disciplines (although ministers could set external finance limits and financial &bquo;targets&equo; for return on capital), and threat of bankruptcy. 
 Another criticism was of the poor performance of the nationalized industries, particularly the low pre-tax real rates of return on the capital employed. 
 In defence of the industries, however, one has to make an allowance for the social costs of policies (such as maintaining an uneconomic rail service for a community or loss-making plants in areas of high unemployment) and for decisions on pricing, investment, and employment which are shaped in part by the political calculations of the government of the day. 
 At times (for example, under Mr Heath) governments have abandoned economic pricing as part of an anti-inflation programme; at other times, notably over the price increases in gas between 1980 and 1982 when the Thatcher government each year raised prices 30 per cent above the current rate of inflation, above &bquo;economic&equo; pricing levels and what the board wished. 
 The vagueness of guidelines and frequent and inconsistent ministerial interventions were frustrating for management of nationalized boards. 
 The government therefore initially turned to privatization in large part as an answer to the &bquo;problem&equo; of the nationalized industries. 
 One minister commented in March 1982: &bquo;Look, we're bloody fed up with them. 
 They make huge losses, they have bolshie unions, they are feather-bedded. 
 It seems almost impossible to do anything with them; therefore, the view has grown, get rid of them.&equo; 
 &bquo;Getting rid&equo; meant selling to the private sector. 
 Earlier plans for tighter financial control and greater independence for management had not been successful. 
 There did not seem to be a half-way house between public and private ownership. 
 Some industries acquired chairmen with a reputation for cost-cutting and a tough stand on labour relations. 
  Ian MacGregor was appointed chairman of British Steel in 1980 and of British Coal in 1983, John King of British Airways, and Michael Edwardes of British Leyland. 
 The remit ofthe last two included plans to prepare BA and BL for a return to the private sector. 
 The privatization programme has been recognized as a major break with the mixed economy consensus. 
 The verdict of one admiring authority on the government's performance is that, &bquo;In doing so, it has achieved the largest transfer of property since the dissolution of the monasteries under Henry VIII, a transfer from the state to its citizens.&equo; 
 What is remarkable is how little political opposition there has been to the programme to date. 
 In spite of complaints by leaders of trade unions many of their members bought up the shares. 
 There were few strikes and in Parliament Labour's opposition was usually focused more on the &bquo;giveaway&equo; price at which shares were sold rather than on the principle of privatization. 
 Mr Kinnock has suggested that renationalization would not be a high priority for a future Labour government. 
 The government probably went further down this road than it had originally envisaged. 
 The 1979 manifesto had promised to restore to the private sector the recently nationalized aerospace and shipbuilding industries, sell off the shares in the National Enterprise Board and National Freight Corporation, and review the role of BNOC. 
 But by 1983 sales had been arranged for part of Britoil, Associated British Ports, Amersham International, shares in BP, and the NEB's shareholdings (Table 8.2). 
 These sales realized nearly &pound;1.8 billion. 
 The programme then developed a momentum of its own. 
 In the 1983 Parliament, Sealink, Jaguar, British Telecom, British Gas, and British Airways were all privatized. 
 In 1985 &mdash; 6 alone, the sale of the rest of Britoil, receipt of the second British Telecom payment, and the sale of British Airways raised over &pound;2.5 billion. 
 By 1988 the programme had shifted 600,000 jobs from the public to the private sector and reduced the nationalized industries' share of GDP to 6.5 per cent. 
 The latter will have lost the national telephone system, gas and steel industries, and the country's largest airline. 
 By 1990, it is planned that electricity and water, the core utilities, will also have been sold off. 
 Ministers claim that a fourth-term   Thatcher government would tackle the final two monuments of post-war nationalization &mdash; coal and railways. 
 Over time the original emphasis of the programme has broadened from increasing liberalization and competition to raising money for current spending. 
 In all, some &pound;24 billion had been raised from sales by the end of 1988. 
 Sales of state assets helped the government to reduce the public sector borrowing requirement. 
 There are, of course, various techniques of privatization. 
 In one case the government simply sold the whole enterprise to private investors such as Amersham International and the Atomic Energy Authority. 
 In another it sold a part of the whole enterprise by converting the public  corporation into Companies Act companies and selling half of the shares: it did this, for example, by reducing its stock in BP from 51 to 46 per cent in 1979, then to 39 per cent in 1981, and again to 31.7 per cent in 1984. 
 A third technique was to sell off a proportion of the whole operation, as it did with British Telecom, British Gas, British Aerospace, and Britoil; and British Rail was made to sell off its hotels. 
 A fourth was to sell the shares to the work-force, as happened with the National Freight Corporation. 
 In some key sales, such as British Gas and British Telecom, the government retained a share of the equity to protect the national interest. 
 Yet another method was to liberalize entry or remove restrictions on firms wanting to compete in the provision of a service in the public sector. 
 A number of local authorities, for example, put out refuse collection to private tender. 
 The privatization programme also covers schemes to promote deregulation and competition in the economy. 
 Within the state sector, the statutory public monopoly of electricity supply and express delivery service has been ended. 
 The 1980 Transport Act, by relaxing controls over licensing and fares, has increased competition on long-distance coach routes. 
 In January 1986 any operator was automatically licensed to run on any route outside London. 
 Between 1981 and 1983 the government created twenty-four so-called enterprise zones in economically depressed areas. 
 This provided a package of financial incentives and exemptions from various laws and regulations to encourage businesses to set up in the zones. 
 In 1984 six freeports were established in areas near airports or the sea at Liverpool, Birmingham, Cardiff, Southampton, Belfast, and Prestwick. 
 The policy of increasing the role of the market sector has extended to contracting out services in the National Health Service and local government and the removal of the monopoly powers of solicitors (over house sale conveyancing), or barristers appearing in the high court, opticians, and financial services via Big Bang in 1986. 
 There is no doubt about the political and economic significance of this programme. 
 It has redrawn the boundaries between the public and private sectors in favour of the latter and raised substantial sums for the Treasury. 
 Although rarely  stated by ministers as a reason for privatization, the funds could be used to finance tax cuts and/or current spending. 
 In other words, it was a way of easing the dilemma of choosing between tax cuts or more public spending. 
 Some of the claims made by government defenders of the programme are, however, questionable. 
 The sales have done little to increase competition: BT and British Gas retain their monopolistic position, although their pricing policies are subject to review by government appointed regulatory bodies. 
 Dunleavy and Rhodes have noted that privatization in these sections has, ironically, involved an increase  in regulation or re-regulation. 
 The electricity supply industry is to be broken up and sold. 
 Some of the more spectacular productivity gains (e.g. British Steel) have occurred prior to privatization. 
 Some observers also calculate that, if one takes account of the profits forgone from these enterprises in future years and sets them against the revenues raised now, the government may have sold the assets at too low a price. 
 Separate from but related to the programme of privatization of state-owned industries and deregulation was the scheme for the sale of local council houses. 
 The programme advances the traditional Tory theme of a &bquo;property-owning democracy&equo; and was started by the Heath government. 
 It was outlined in the Housing Act (1980), which gave council tenants with three years' residence the right to buy their properties at a substantial discount. 
 The discounts were extended by another Housing Act (1984). 
 By December 1988 over a million had purchased their properties. 
 The Economy 
 Arresting the cycle of the country's relative economic decline was the self proclaimed major task of the Thatcher revolution. 
 Conservative leaders claimed that by curbing the growth in public spending they would create the headroom for tax reductions which in turn would provide incentives and liberate the entrepreneurial energies of the British people. 
 By strictly controlling the money supply they would restore sound finance and squeeze inflation out of the system. 
 The government would not intervene in private sector wage bargaining but intended that its own example in the public sector plus strict control of the  money supply would encourage responsible wage bargaining. 
 Ministers also hoped that employers would cut out overmanning and root out inefficiency, even if this led to a temporary surge in unemployment. 
 Reducing the size of the public sector and number of regulations that hampered business would create the opportunity for the emergence of a more market-orientated economy. 
 Reforms of the internal practices of trade unions and legal changes in their status would provide opportunities for managers to regain authority and for the emergence of more &bquo;responsible&equo; and less &bquo;political&equo; trade unions. 
 Finally, by reducing the budget deficit and government borrowing they hoped to bring interest rates down. 
 The ultimate objectives of this strategy were of course no different from those of previous post-war governments. 
 All governments have wanted to strike a balance between the economic aims of low inflation, rapid economic growth, a surplus on the balance of payments, and full employment. 
 But, increasingly in the 1970s, governments were failing to achieve the objectives (see above, Chapter 6). 
 It is important to realize, however, that what some commentators have called the &bquo;new realism&equo; did not start in 1979. 
 Mr Callaghan's famous speech to the 1976 Labour party conference (subsequently cited in many Conservative party publications) admitted that governments could not spend their way into full employment; that way only led to more inflation and eventually more unemployment. 
 A squeeze on public spending, adoption of money supply targets, privatization (sale of BP shares in 1976), and the priority accorded to fighting inflation, even at a time of historically high unemployment, were all in place under Mr Callaghan. 
 (i) Inflation 
 Of all the economic variables inflation is the one that the Thatcher government has said it is able to control. 
 According to the Chancellor, Nigel Lawson, in his Mais Lecture in june 1984: &bquo;It is the conquest of inflation, not the pursuit of growth and employment, which is or should be the objective of macro-economic policy.&equo; 
 In many respects the &bquo;New Conservatism&equo; in Britain and the United States was born out of a reaction to the high inflation of the mid-1970s. 
 In the 1950s and 1960s the  annual rate of British price rises was modest by comparison with what was to follow in the 1970s. 
 Yet the average rate in Britain (4.1 per cent) between 1961 and 1970 was still higher than that in OECD countries (3.3 per cent). 
 In the years 1971 &mdash; 80 the gap widened to annual averages of 13.7 per cent and 9. o per cent respectively. 
 Reducing inflation was, until 1989, the government's greatest achievement on the economic front. 
 The increase in oil prices combined with the 1979 June budget's increase from 8 to 15 per cent in VAT on many goods and high wage rises helped to push inflation up to 21 per cent in May 1980. 
 In the second half of 1982, however, Britain's inflation rate fell to the OECD average of 5 per cent and then steadily declined to 2.5 per cent in July 1986, the lowest figure since 1967. 
 The reduction was helped by the strength of sterling which became increasingly attractive as an oil-backed currency. 
 Although exporters fairly complained that this made their goods less competitive in price, it helped to lower the cost of imports and thus the prices of foreign goods sold in Britain. 
 In 1987 Conservative ministers boasted of their success while still claiming that the conquest of inflation remained the first objective of policy. 
 According to the election manifesto: &bquo;There is no better yardstick of a party's fitness to govern than its attitude to inflation. 
 Nothing is so politically immoral as a party that ignores that yardstick.&equo; 
 After 1974 a growing number of Conservatives increasingly fastened upon the failure to control money sterling supply, M3 (notes and coins in circulation, with all deposits held by UK residents), as the main cause of inflation. 
 Monetarists claimed that there was a variable time-lag (of between eighteen months and two years) between an increase in money supply and the consequent price inflation and that the huge expansion in money supply (28 per cent in 1972, 27 per cent in 1973) caused the soaring inflation of 1974 &mdash; 5. 
 Politics joined with economics in the decline of incomes policy and the rise of monetarism as the appropriate weapon in the fight against inflation. 
 Monetarists argued that as long as the government refused to increase the money supply, even if unemployment was increasing, there could be no inflation. 
 Controlling and adhering to announced targets for money supply became a test of the government's will. 
 The announcement in the Medium Term Financial  Strategy (MTFS) in the 1980 budget of monetary targets &mdash; which would fall year by year (see Table 8.3) &mdash; was also regarded as a means of lowering the expectations of wage bargainers. 
 The &bquo;rational expectations&equo; school of monetarists argued that expectations of lower inflation would lead to a slow-down in the rise of wages, costs, and prices. 
 Yet the government's monetary policy was hardly successful in reducing inflation. 
 It had many difficulties in controlling M3, which proved to be an unreliable barometer. 
 An influential report by Professor Jurg Niehans in February 1981 argued that monetary policy was in fact excessively tight because the high interest rates were attracting foreign money to London and maintaining a high pound. 
 Difficulties in exercising control were also increased by the civil service dispute during 1980 and the increase in bank lending for mortgages. 
 Another measure, of &bquo;narrow&equo; money, was Mo, which covered cash, the banks' till money, and the Bank of England's operational cash, and the Chancellor set a target for this as well. 
 Table 8.3 shows that the government regularly exceeded its monetary targets. 
 The growth of M3 for 1980 &mdash; 1 (19.5 per cent) easily exceeded the planned 7 &mdash; 11 per cent, and between March 1980 and March 1984 M3 grew by 70 per cent, against its target 46 per cent. 
 By 1982 government spokesmen spoke less about money supply and were more concerned about monetary growth and the exchange rate. 
 In 1984 the target was concentrated on Mo, the narrower measure. 
 In the Lord Mayor's speech in London in November 1985 Nigel Lawson formally abandoned M3 and since 1987 gave more emphasis to broad money or M4 (which is M3 plus building society liabilities) though not setting a target range. 
 Monetarism was effectively abandoned. 
 Management of interest rates and the exchange rate were seen as more effective influences. 
 By 1989 monetarism was attracting more support, as Britain had one of the highest inflation figures in the European Community (8 per cent in April 1989). 
 M4 had expanded rapidly between 1986 and 1988. 
 (ii) Public spending 
 The government only gradually reduced the growth rate of public spending. 
 Control of spending was crucial to the  government's strategy because it wanted to cut governmental borrowing and taxes. 
 Yet in spite of several Cabinet meetings to make reductions, total spending actually increased in real terms and as a proportion of GDP. 
 Ironically, the government was widely criticized for making &bquo;cuts&equo;. 
 Cutting public spending has always been a politically divisive process for a government, as ministers in the major spending departments battle to protect their budgets. 
 In the post-war period the only previous cuts in public spending as a proportion of GDP were achieved by Labour in 1975 &mdash; 6 and 1977 &mdash; 8. 
 The Conservatives' original goal in opposition was to stabilize the total public spending figure in real terms at its 1977 level and for that total to fall as a share of GDP as the economy grew. 
 The MTFS made a deliberately modest assessment of future rates of economic growth (1 per cent per annum 1980 &mdash; 3). 
 In his 1979 budget Sir Geoffrey Howe claimed that in the past public spending had been based on falsely optimistic expectations about economic resources: &bquo;It is this falsely reassuring belief that somehow the resources will be found to permit an uninterrupted expansion of public expenditure that this government challenges. 
 In planning public expenditure it is better to be prudent and make a deliberately cautious assumption on the growth of future resources.&equo; 
 The MTFS in 1980 planned for a reduction in public spending of 5 per cent over the next four years; there was in fact an 8 per cent growth in real terms. 
 Given the party's pledges on pensions, defence, law and order, and other statutory commitments, particularly on social security, this meant that spending cuts would have to fall in a few areas, notably housing. 
 The increase was in large part caused by the   rising costs of social security, itself a consequence of the steep rise in unemployment, and the NATO commitment to boost defence spending by an extra 3 per cent per annum in real terms. 
 The failure to reverse the spending growth was a disappointing outcome for the advocates of cuts in the many bruising Cabinet battles over public spending between 1979 and 1982. 
 There have been marked shifts in spending between programmes since 1979. 
 It is worth noting, however, that the spending priorities have not been radically dissimilar from those planned by the outgoing Labour government, which also planned for cuts in spending on education and housing and an expansion in spending on defence, law and order, and social security. 
 Table 8. 1 above shows that between 1978 &mdash; 9 and 1988 &mdash; 9 there was a major and planned increase in real terms in spending on defence and law and order; spending on housing and industry were heavily cut, while on education (helped by a fall in numbers of school children) and on transport it stayed fairly constant. 
 For all the concern over the level of public spending the British share as a proportion of GDP in 1979 was only at the mid-point of most western states. 
 The Treasury fought and lost many spending battles in the first Thatcher administration; public spending increased from 39.5 per cent as a proportion of GDP, which the government inherited in 1979, to 42.5 per cent in 1984. 
 The record, until the middle of the decade, disappointed a number of Mrs Thatcher's more ambitious supporters. 
 According to The Times's  leader &bquo;What is Thatcherism Now?&equo; on 16 January 1984: 
 But none of this is the essence of Mrs Thatcher's problem which is rather that, on the essential questions of economic management, the government gives the impression either of having lost its momentum or of having decided that it must settle for something well short of what Mrs Thatcher seemed to promise in the way of reducing the size of the public sector and also the burden of taxation. 
 The reduction in unemployment and continued economic growth gradually helped the ratio to fall. 
 But it was only in 1988 &mdash; 9 that the ratio (excluding privatization receipts) fell back to that of ten years earlier.  
 (iii) Taxes 
 In line with the government's objective there was a reduction in the top (from 83 to 60 per cent) and standard rates of income tax (from 33 to 30 per cent) in the 1979 budget, and a shift to indirect taxes. 
 In that budget speech Sir Geoffrey Howe stated: &bquo;Our long-term aim should surely be to reduce the basic rate of income tax to no more than 25 per cent.&equo; 
 The same budget increased VAT from 8 to 1 5 per cent. 
 Later budgets reduced the rates of income tax further; in 1988 the top rate was cut to 40 per cent and the basic rate to 25 per cent. 
 However, claims that the government has reduced the &bquo;tax burden&equo; need to be heavily qualified. 
 The main shift has been from direct to indirect taxes. 
 In 1979 30 per cent of government revenue was raised by income tax; by 1989 the figure was 24 per cent. 
 Less &bquo;visible&equo; increases in VAT and employers' national insurance contributions offset the well-publicized cuts in income tax. 
 Overall total taxation, including corporate taxes, increased as a share of GDP from 33.1 per cent to 37.6 per cent in 1988 &mdash; 9. 
 The rise is largely accounted for by rising incomes and profits which bring more taxpayers and companies into higher tax brackets. 
 In total the tax position is not much different from 1979. 
 Britain's share of taxation as a proportion of GDP has remained in the middle for the range of OECD states. 
 (iv) Distribution 
 The final report of the Royal Commission on the Distribution of Income and Wealth drew attention to the stability in the distribution of income in the post-war period. 
 Some redistribution had occurred between 1938 and 1949, but if one ignores the top 1 per cent of income earners, there had been little change up to 1979. 
 Under the Conservative government, as noted, the tax system became less progressive, with the major reductions being made at the top end of the tax range and there were increases in national insurance and the nonprogressive indirect taxes. 
 The tax cuts for the top income earners, the increase in share prices over the decade, and the effects of the recession have sharpened economic differentials in the Thatcher period. 
 Although the Commission was dissolved  in 1979, the 1985 volume of Inland Revenue Annual Statistics found that between 1979 and 1983 the most wealthy 50 per cent of the adult population increased its share of total marketable wealth from 79 &mdash; 83 per cent to 80 &mdash; 4 per cent. 
 In the period 1979 &mdash; 87 the bottom 10 per cent of earners made net gains of 5 per cent, the top 1 o per cent gains of 28 per cent. 
 Analysis by the Institute for Fiscal Studies shows that richer households have benefited more than poorer ones from the government's tax and benefit changes. 
 Although most have gained, half of the total giveaway in terms of benefits and tax reductions has gone to the richest 10 per cent of households. 
 The single unemployed living on their own are the only group who have lost significantly from the changes &mdash; by an average of &pound;2.16 a week. 
 (v) Unemployment 
 The lifetime of the Thatcher governments has been dominated by large-scale unemployment. 
 The government inherited a figure of 5.4 per cent (1.2 million) for unemployment which by November 1983 had reached 12.7 per cent (3 million). 
 The rise in unemployment frustrated the government's spending plans, because of the rising costs of social security; it also undermined the credibility of the government's claims that its economic strategy was working and that economic recovery was around the corner. 
 Industrial output fell by over 11 per cent in the course of the 1979 &mdash; 83 Parliament, a performance worse than in other western states which also suffered from the recession. 
 The main damage was done in the first twelve months, when GDP fell by 3 per cent, industrial production by 9 per cent, and unemployment doubled to 2.5 million. 
 The government redefined the categories of unemployed in 1982 and 1983, for example, excluding men over 60, counting only those claiming benefits instead of those registered as unemployed (this change excluded mainly married women seeking work, but not entitled to benefit), and various training and employment schemes for young people kept perhaps another 600,000 off the unemployment list. 
 The figure peaked at 3.2 million, excluding school-leavers in June 1985. 
 Thereafter it steadily declined, month by month and in January 1989 fell below two million (Table 8.4).   
 (vi) Economic growth 
 Backed by North Sea oil the pound was an attractive currency on the international money market. 
 In spite of complaints by business about the pound's appreciation (in May 1979 its effective exchange rate was 81.3 per cent and in January 1982 it was 92 per cent of its 1975 rate) the government came to rely on a strong pound as part of its anti-inflation strategy. 
 Contrary to declarations that there was no government policy for sterling and that it would be left to the markets to decide, by late 1981 the government intervened to reverse a fall in the exchange rate, and raised base rate to 16 per cent. 
 It did the same again in January 1985; when the pound fell to &dollar;1.12 banks were instructed to raise interest rates by 1.5 per cent. 
 The record high interest rates were attractive to holders of sterling even though they were also damaging to business. 
 The exchange rate policy was highly damaging to manufacturing. 
 Alt has blamed oil for this appreciation, while other economists have blamed the government's tight money policies and high interest rates. 
 Industrial output fell by 11 per cent between the second quarter of 1 979 and the last quarter of 1982, and between 1979 and 1985 industry shed 1.5 million workers. 
 The balance of trade in manufacturing swung from a surplus of &pound;2.75 billion in 1979 to a deficit in 1984 of &pound;3.75 billion and the years 1983 and 1984 were the first time in history that Britain's  trade balance was in the red on manufactures. 
 Non-oil imports increased by an average of 4.5 per cent per annum from 1979, while non-oil exports increased by 1 per cent per annum. 
 Only in 1984 did non-oil output recover to its 1979 level. 
 Some decline of the manufacturing trade balance was probably inevitable, because of the advent of North Sea oil at a time of floating exchange rates and the increased appreciation of sterling. 
 But the loss of international competitiveness was much bigger in Britain between 1979 and 1981 than in other western states. 
 There have been claims of a productivity miracle in British manufacturing and that the &bquo;British disease&equo; has been banished. 
 There are problems in assessing these claims, in part because of disputes over the starting date &mdash; 1979, when Mrs Thatcher came to office, or 1981, the low point of the recession &mdash; and whether comparison is made with the 1970s or 1960s. 
 Over the period 1979 &mdash; 88 manufacturing output per head increased by 4.2 per cent, faster than the 1960s. 
 But for the whole economy the increase is only 1.9 per cent, better than the 1970s but lower than the 1960s. 
 At last British output per head is now up to the European average, largely because the latter has slowed down so much. 
 But Britain still has a huge gap to close on her major competitors. 
 In defence of their economic record, government spokesmen have claimed that from the second quarter of 1983 the numbers in employment increased and that more jobs were being created in Britain than in the rest of the EEC states taken together. 
 At first they pinned most of the blame for the loss of jobs on the trade unions and the international recession, and then on high wage settlements. 
 Lower wage settlements, claimed the Treasury and the Department of Employment, would help to price people back into jobs. 
 But real wages steadily increased in spite of recession and high unemployment. 
 As the government exceeded its monetary targets and unemployment soared, so critics in 1980 and 1981 waited for a U-turn, or a change in economic strategy. 
 But Mrs Thatcher was adamant about not reflating and this resolution, in spite of the sharply increased unemployment, was important in sustaining the government's credibility. 
 Particularly important in showing that the MTFS was serious was the 1981 budget when the Chancellor increased  taxes by &pound;5 billion, or 2 per cent of GNP, to protect his PSBR. 
 This was a major squeeze at a time of recession. 
 Maintaining the policy in face of previously unthinkable levels of unemployment became a test of &bquo;resolute leadership&equo;. 
 In the first four years it nearly halved the PSBR, or borrowing requirement, from 5 per cent of GDP in 1978 &mdash; 9 to 2.7 per cent in 1982 &mdash; 3 and Britain had a markedly tighter fiscal stance than her Western European neighbours. 
 In spite of the recession the PSBR continued to fall, though not as fast as had been forecast. 
 Industrial Relations 
 The mood of &bquo;time for a change&equo; was certainly felt in the area of industrial relations, particularly in relations between the government and trade unions. 
 Formal incomes policies and the &bquo;social contract&equo; approach were hardly politically credible after the 1979 winter's disruption, and many features of the trade unions were as unpopular as ever (such as the closed shop, unofficial strikes, close relations with the Labour party, and mass picketing). 
 Under Mrs Thatcher, Conservatives were more outspoken in blaming the unions for low productivity, overmanning, restrictive practices, and strikes, particularly in the public sector where the unions were often able to exploit their monopoly position. 
 Because the government abandoned any formal incomes policy there was less call for it to maintain close relations with union leaders. 
 The government hoped that strict control of the money supply and the government's stated unwillingness to rescue financially troubled firms would help to inculcate a more responsible outlook among wage bargainers. 
 In the public sector the government would give each department a cash-limited budget, including a &bquo;factor&equo; for pay; ministers claimed that workers, by pushing for &bquo;excessive&equo; wage rises which employers were unable to pass on in price increases, could price themselves out of jobs. 
 For the first two years, however, this strategy lay in ruins because of the consequences of accepting the &bquo;catching-up&equo; comparability awards of the Clegg Commission for public-sector pay. 
 The Clegg Commission was abolished in 1980 and eventually the government managed to squeeze down pay in the  public sector through its use of cash limits. 
 Rising unemployment and fear of job losses weakened the appeal of militants in the unions. 
 The government was the first to do without an incomes policy, and the absence of &bquo;norms&equo; or &bquo;targets&equo; for incomes in nearly twenty years helped to take the issue of wages out of politics. 
 On the grounds of preventing young workers' wages rising to a level which might price them out of work it scrapped the 1946 Fair Wages Resolution, which required compliance with minimum wage standards for firms trying to secure government and other contracts. 
 In 1985 it also reduced the number of Wages Councils affecting the pay of young workers. 
 The government also took the view that the law had a role to play in redressing the balance in bargaining between employers and unions. 
 In retrospect many Conservatives felt that the ill-fated 1971 Industrial Relations Act had been too ambitious and that the ground had not been adequately prepared for such a sweeping measure. 
 Before the 1979 election the party took advantage of the Winter of Discontent to toughen its manifesto proposals, promising to curtail flying pickets, or picketing away from the pickets' place of work, and provide funds for pre-strike ballots of union members and for the election of union officials. 
 The &bquo;step by step&equo; approach was reflected in the two Employment Acts of 1980 and 1982. 
 These restricted lawful picketing to the pickets' own place of work and removed the unions' legal immunities from civil actions, so making them liable for damages up to a certain limit where they were responsible for unlawful industrial action. 
 The 1980 Act removed the provisions of the Employment Protection Act which affected small businesses, by increasing the qualifying period for complaints of unfair dismissal. 
 The same Act also provided compensation for people unreasonably excluded or expelled from a union in a closed shop, and required that new closed shops in future should be approved by four-fifths of the workforce. 
 These provisions were strengthened in the 1982 Act which provided that no closed shop should be enforceable unless it had been approved by a clear majority of employees voting in a secret ballot. 
 It made trade unions (rather than just individual organizers of strikes) liable for damages arising from unlawful industrial actions. 
 It also gave employers legal remedies against  industrial action in which no dispute exists between employers and their own employees or which is not wholly or mainly about employment matters. 
 The 1984 Trade Union Act provided government funds for the regular election of trade union officials and for elections on whether unions should have a political fund. 
 It also required that industrial action be supported by union members in a pre-strike ballot if the union was to be exempt from civil action for damages arising from the dispute. 
 A third Employment Act (1988) removed various closed shop immunities, extended the number of union officials to be directly elected, now by postal ballot, and gave legal protection to members who suffered &bquo;unjustified&equo; discipline by a union (e.g. for refusing to support industrial action). 
 The government successfully pursued a &bquo;hands-off&equo; policy in industrial disputes. 
 In the first term of office, strikes at British Leyland, British Steel, and British Rail, and lengthy disruption by civil servants and health service workers failed to move ministers. 
 Workers at British Leyland and in the coal industry rejected the advice of union leaders to strike over wages or job losses. 
 Perhaps the only two successful threats of action were by the water-workers in 1983 and the NUM over the Coal Board's threat to close uneconomic pits in January 1981. 
 The twelve-month strike by the National Union of Mineworkers against pit closures ended in April 1985 in failure and with the NUM split. 
 The NUM's main trouble with the courts arose over actions brought by its own members on the grounds that the union had broken its own rules (over a pre-strike ballot) and for contempt. 
 The government managed to make its legislation &bquo;stick&equo;, in contrast to Mr Heath's experience, and has refuted the old &bquo;liberal&equo; view that the courts did not have a useful role to play in industrial relations. 
 The idea of unions balloting their members before taking industrial action took hold. 
 But most ballots endorsed proposals for industrial action and all of the union ballots held in 1985 on maintaining a political fund overwhelmingly endorsed the idea. 
 Although it was T U C policy for member unions to refuse government money for ballots, a number of unions defied it. 
 In 1985 the second largest union, the AUEW, was faced with the threat of expulsion from the TUC for breaking the policy. 
 The Electricians Union was  prepared to follow the AUEW and, already faced with the breakaway Democratic Miners' Union in Nottingham, the TUC was forced to find a face-saving formula to avert a possible split. 
 The electricians also incurred the displeasure of fellow trade union leaders by making no-strike agreements with employers, arranging private health care facilities for workers, and then secretly negotiating with the Murdoch press for jobs at the new Wapping plant. 
 They were expelled from the TUC in 1988 for the former. 
 In many respects the Thatcher years have been depressing for the trade unions. 
 The setbacks include mass unemployment, decline of Labour, loss of members, privatization of parts of the public sector, cash limits in much of the public sector, which limited opportunities for bargaining, government initiated incursions into their internal affairs, and minimal access to Whitehall. 
 In July 1987 Mr Lawson unilaterally announced a reduction in the meetings of the tripartite NEDC from ten to four meetings annually and in January 1989 the Secretary of State for Employment announced that the TUC would no longer be the sole body which could nominate trade unionists to the Training Commission and other official bodies. 
 Bargaining rights were weakened. 
 The Pay Research Unit for the civil service was abolished, as was pay bargaining for schoolteachers, and the role of Wage Councils was reduced. 
 In spite of threats of defiance, court-imposed fines were collected from the NUM, NGA, and Transport and General Workers' Union. 
 Union membership fell from over 13 million in 1979 to 10 million in 1986 (or from 54 per cent to 46 per cent of the work-force) and the main losers were the general unions in manufacturing. 
 Many analyses of the unions in the 1970s suggested that such political power as they possessed rested on their ability to defy incomes policies over time and veto (as In Place of Strife ) or render inoperable the policies or legislation which they did not like. 
 The Thatcher governments have gone a long way towards puncturing claims about the power of the unions. 
 They have not sought compromises with the unions over incomes policy or industrial relations; the unions are no longer an &bquo;estate of the realm&equo;. 
 The creation of the legal framework has ended the &bquo;voluntarist&equo; tradition that has dominated industrial relations in the twentieth century. 
 The heavy fines imposed on Sogat 82  in its 1986 dispute with News International showed that the unions' inability to carry out secondary or solidarity &bquo;blacking&equo; weakened their bargaining power. 
 At the same time the government did not push its reforms as far as some supporters wished; it did not, for example, place the onus on union members to contract in rather than out of paying the political levy and has done little to break down national wage bargaining which pays little attention to different local labour market conditions. 
 Conclusion 
 A problem with the presentation of the foregoing data is to assess the amount of responsibility that the government has for the policies. 
 After all, privatization, deregulation, tax cuts, falling capital markets, and reducing union power have been found in other states in the 1980s. 
 There have been four different interpretations of the economic record of the Thatcher government to date. 
 The first is that the policies have largely been implemented as intended and that they are bearing fruit. 
 The lower inflation and freer market, it is claimed, has generated an economic recovery. 
 In the years between 1982 and 1988 the economy grew at an average of nearly 3 per cent per year. 
 The large increase in unemployment, though regrettable and unexpected, is largely the responsibility of the trade unions for exacting high wage increases and overmanning in the past. 
 The second interpretation is that the economic outcomes, unfavourable  as well as favourable, have been a consequence of the government's policies. 
 For example, the massive recession between 1979 and 1981 was caused by too severe a financial squeeze. 
 According to Jackson &bquo;the recession of the 1980s was of the government's own making. 
 Overtight monetary and fiscal policies and the loss of overseas markets, due to an over-valued pound, resulted in an erosion of demand, falling investment, rising inventories, bankruptcies and an explosion in the numbers unemployed.&equo; 
 Some economists calculate that only a small part (perhaps a quarter) of the appreciation of the exchange rate is attributable to oil but that the government deliberately pushed up the exchange rate (which appreciated 40 per cent between 1979 and 1980) by raising domestic interest rates and thereby weakening industrial competitiveness.  
 A third interpretation is to say that the strategy has not been implemented and therefore the government is not fully responsible for the outcome. 
 Control of money supply (M3) has been erratic, and it has proved difficult to establish a relationship between the changes in M3 and the fall in inflation. 
 A final line of analysis insists that the government has made little difference, particularly on unemployment. 
 james Alt argues that the increase in supply of North Sea oil provided a major boost for sterling which in turn resulted in a loss of competitiveness for British goods and a consequent loss of manufacturing goods and employment. 
 Hence the major cause of unemployment lies outside the government's responsibility and a Labour government would not have made much difference. 
 The balance sheet for managing the economy is, not surprisingly, mixed. 
 Over the years 1982 to 1988, economic growth has averaged a respectable 2.5 per cent, close to the figure for the 1960s. 
 But this followed the sharp decline in 1980 and 1981; over the period 1979 &mdash; 85 the annual average growth rate has been 1.9 per cent about the same as most other OECD countries &mdash; without the benefit of North Sea oil. 
 There have been some impressive cases of increases in productivity, notably British Airways, British Leyland, and British Steel, which have shed workers, but it remains to be seen whether the improvement will be durable or a once-only case of firms shaking out the least efficient workers. 
 Business profits have increased from 3 per cent in 1979 to 1 o per cent in 1987. 
 Unemployment over the decade has been a disaster though the total has steadily fallen in the last two years. 
 The much praised reduction on inflation only brought Britain back into line with the OECD average and in 1989 was again above it. 
 By May 1989 inflation at over 8 per cent was at the same level as at the 1979 general election and unemployment, though falling, was higher than in 1979. 
 The weakening of trade union power in the 1980s has been due to the interaction of government legislation, the rise in unemployment, and technological change. 
 It is too soon yet to make a judgement about the relative importance of these different factors. 
 The government's legislation on industrial relations and trade unions has taken hold. 
 Here is an area where the balance of advantage has changed since 1979, from  union leaders to employers and managers and from the consultative role granted to the unions to one in which they are virtually ignored by the government. 
 The reduction in restrictive practices and number of strikes have been other gains. 
 Rising unemployment was important in producing the reductions in unions' members, funds, and militancy. 
 But the unions' unpopularity in the wake of the Winter of Discontent and Labour's electoral decline also weakened the movement. 
 The legislation has made the creation of new closed shops more difficult, has restricted definition of what are legal strikes, and has exposed union funds to claims against unlawful industrial action. 
 The growth of part-time, female, and self-employment, as well as the growth of the service sector has created groups which the unions have long found difficult to organize. 
 Privatization is another area in which the government has been more radical than was anticipated. 
 But there is a limit to the number of profitable assets which can be sold. 
 Revelations in February 1986 that the government was prepared to sell off British Leyland and Austin-Rover to American-owned companies provoked opposition from Conservative MPs in the affected constituencies which killed the proposals. 
 Opinion surveys suggest that both the trade union reforms and the early privatizations were popular with the voters. 
 The support for the status quo in these two areas had been &bquo;soft&equo;, with the public acquiescing because there appeared to be no politically workable alternative. 
 The planned private sales of the water and electricity industries in 1990, however, are unpopular with most voters and worry some Conservative back-benchers. 
 Some measures have &bquo;freed&equo; the economy for the operation of market forces. 
 They include the income tax cuts, union reforms, and ending exchange controls. 
 On the other hand Mrs Thatcher has jealously maintained tax reliefs for homeownership and private pensions (indeed, extended them for private health care for the over-60s) and privatization of gas and telephones have done little to increase competition. 
 The government has made minor cuts on welfare and some changes of a largely symbolic nature. 
 It has protected &bquo;real&equo; levels of spending on the NHS and welfare state, and attempts to contain social security expenditure were thwarted until 1986 by the massive rise in unemployment. 
 Although the government  has encouraged privatization at the edges of the health service and social security, the opportunity (presented by Mr Fowler's social security review and then the NHS review) to make a fundamental reform of the legacy of Beveridge was passed by. 
 Ministers have been worried about reactions among voters and among Conservative Mps and have so far shown little interest in pushing the more radical free-market policies advocated by the Adam Smith Institute and IEA. 
 By twentieth-century standards the Thatcher governments have been radical and successful &mdash; not only in winning elections but in achieving so much of what they intended. 
 In 1989 the government was still pressing on with further measures of privatization, reforming the legal profession and health service, resisting moves to greater integration within the European Community, and implementing the new system of local government finance and a reformed education system. 
 The experience is one to suggest an affirmative response to the question, &bquo;Do Parties Make a Difference?&equo;   
 MARGARET THATCHER: A MOBILIZING PRIME MINISTER 
 MRS THATCHER was the dominant figure in British politics in the 1980s. 
 She has already established a number of landmarks in political history and psephology: the first woman Prime Minister in any major western industrial state; the first leader since Lord Liverpool in the 1820s to win three elections in a row, and Prime Minister for the longest uninterrupted spell in the twentieth century. 
 Alone of twentieth-century prime Ministers her name has been given to a political &bquo;doctrine&equo; and undoubted political style. 
 She was the first British prime Minister to mount a sustained challenge to post-war consensus politics and, more than any other post-war Prime Minister, she is often regarded as a figure apart from her Cabinet. 
 The attention that she has received (particularly the hype surrounding her tenth anniversary in office in May 1989) can tempt one to react and downplay the importance, if not the existence, of Thatcherism. 
 Yet her role in altering the political balance in the Conservative party and directing the government has been so important that she merits discussion in her own right. 
 Mrs Thatcher provides a mobilizing style of political leadership. 
 In some respects it resembles the wartime leadership style of Lloyd George (1916 &mdash; 22) and Winston Churchill (1940 &mdash; 5). 
 This bold personal style distinguishes her, as it distinguished Lloyd George and Churchill, from other Prime Ministers. 
 But unlike them she did not come to office during a wartime emergency nor head a coalition government. 
 The political style of British political leaders has varied, broadly, between the mobilizing and the reconciling. 
 The mobilizer emphasizes taking decisions, task performance, and changing the status quo, whereas the reconciler is more concerned to maintain the consensus and cohesion of a group. 
 The former is mainly concerned with the achievement of goals, not overly  concerned about opposition and the costs of disturbance; the latter is more concerned to represent and respond to diverse interests and is willing to arrive at compromises, if necessary sacrificing policy goals. 
 The earlier chapters of this book have shown how events and a growing sense of disillusion with many old policies paved the way for a new approach. 
 But influential politicians were still required to push the new policies. 
 Mrs Thatcher has been such a figure and, in spite of reverses, she has animated and directed governments with a sense of political direction. 
 Chapters i and 4 examined, respectively, her political beliefs and how she came to the leadership of the Conservative party. 
 This chapter analyses her record as Prime Minister; in particular it examines her political style and role in relation to the Cabinet, Parliament, the Conservative party, and the public. 
 British Political Leadership 
 Britain is widely regarded as having a political system which scores high on political institutionalization and low on personal leadership. 
 Disciplined political parties and a system of parliamentary and Cabinet government have been conducive to a restrained, impersonal style of political leadership. 
 This style has been reinforced by the values of partisanship and collective leadership of the Cabinet. 
 Unlike France or the United States, the political head of state is not the focus of regime loyalty. 
 Personal leadership is less appropriate for a British Prime Minister who is a servant of the Crown. 
 Lloyd George and Winston Churchill were exceptions, but exceptions that proved the rule. 
 Both were in some respects political outsiders who came to power during a breakdown of &bquo;normal&equo; party politics and exercised a personal leadership at a time of national crisis. 
 British political science has little or no literature on political leadership. 
 In Britain we refer rather to the office of Prime Minister and his or her performance rather than national leadership or individual leaders. 
 The academic literature on the Prime Minister has given rise to one of the few serious debates in British political science; the idea of Prime Ministerial government versus that of Cabinet government. 
 The first view is associated with the late John Mackintosh and Richard  Crossman and is regarded as being a trend, regardless of incumbent. 
 The post-war period had seen the transformation &bquo;of Cabinet government into prime Ministerial government&equo;. 
 This view is reinforced by the mass media's tendency to personalize politics and by informal discussions of politics (for example, &bquo;Mrs Thatcher's Government,). 
 A rival interpretation points to the limits operating on any Prime Minister &mdash; for example, constraints of time, the greater departmental resources available to other Cabinet Ministers, and the premier's need to keep the Cabinet together, conciliate rivals, and manage the political party in parliament. 
 The British executive is collective and the Prime Minister's power is exercised in  and with  the Cabinet. 
 In addition, there are the inevitable pressures from the outside world, the difficulties of the British economy, and the various lobbies. 
 Limits on British government are limits on the Prime Minister. 
 Political Style 
 It is worth restating how radical  a leader Mrs Thatcher has been for the Conservative party. 
 She was an accidental leader and in some ways did &bquo;hijack&equo; the party. 
 Conservative leaders have traditionally been accommodating to the major interest and sought compromises. 
 After 1951 Winston Churchill and his Conservative successors protected the welfare state, maintained full employment, and conciliated the trade unions. 
 Mrs Thatcher, on the other hand, claimed that previous Tory leaders had agreed on the country's problems and what needed to be done &mdash; cutting public expenditure and direct taxation, reforming the unions, and restoring the incentives and financial disciplines of the free market &mdash; but failed to carry through the policies. 
 She saw herself as providing the political resolution that had been lacking hitherto. 
 Mr Heath's U-turn in 1972, shifting from free-market policies to a statutory prices and incomes policy and state intervention in industry, is a negative example for her. 
 By the mid-1970s collectivist policies and the constraints on government they represented were so deeply entrenched that a virtual counter-revolution was required. 
 Her image as a confrontational politician stems from her conviction that British politics had become an important, even  a decisive, battle of ideas. 
 Mrs Thatcher is one of the few senior politicians who takes pride in stating her political convictions and insists that policies should derive from a coherent set of principles. 
 Without such a starting point, she argues, a leader is at the mercy of events and unlikely to produce coherent policies. 
 When questioned in August 1978 by the present author about the basis of her political strategy, she replied: &bquo;My political beliefs&equo;. 
 An insight into Mrs Thatcher's character is conveyed by the kind of people with whom she feels comfortable. 
 She admires wealth-creators, entrepreneurs, and people who have taken a chance in the market rather than those who work in the public sector. 
 In her view the provision of resources for the public services depends largely on the efforts of the &bquo;doers&equo; and wealth-creators. 
 Yet the latter, she believes, are too often denigrated in the media and universities. 
 In contrast to the immediate post-war generation of Conservative leaders, Churchill, Eden, Butler, and Macmillan, she has little sense of guilt (&bquo;bourgeois guilt&equo; was the phrase she used in New York to the Institute of Economic Studies on 15 September 1975) for the unemployment of the 1930s. 
 But such feelings were important among a number of One Nation Tories in the 1950s. 
 Harold Macmillan, for example, never forgot his experience as an MP in the economically depressed north-east of England in the 1930s. 
 As Prime Minister he accepted the resignation of his Chancellor of the Exchequer in 1958 rather than agree to modest public expenditure cuts. 
 But in the 1970s few self-made first generation Conservative politicians had personal memories of the 1930s, or were any longer inclined to conciliate the trade unions and make the avoidance of unemployment the main goal of economic policy. 
 In public and private she is a relentless educator. 
 An important task of leadership, in her view, is to win the battle of ideas, and this is done by frequently expressing basic beliefs and principles. 
 She seems to revel in arguments and loses no opportunity to declare her political principles. 
 Initially Shadow Cabinet colleagues were worried by her view of politics as an ideological battle ground and by her disavowal of many cross bench attitudes (Chapter 1). 
 They feared that she would be seen as (indeed is ) abrasive and lacking compassion. 
 She is  famous for berating and lecturing people, ministers, civil servants, TUC delegations, and the House of Commons; &bquo;rubbish&equo; or &bquo;what mean?&equo; and other rude comments are annotated to civil servants' papers. 
 Phrases such as &bquo;TINA&equo; (&bquo;there is no alternative&equo;) in answer to critics of her economic policy, and &bquo;We want our money&equo; (&bquo;I cannot play Sister Bountiful to the Community&equo;) to her EEC partners over the perennial problem of Britain's budget payments, sum up the spirit of what she feels and argues. 
 The warrior image is also aided by her forceful style of speaking and assertive personality. 
 Her self-confidence and certainty make her overbearing in discussion. 
 More than one sceptical senior colleague has been admonished, &bquo;Don't tell me what; tell me how. 
 I know what.&equo; 
 It is as if political goals are what she decides and the role of ministers, civil servants, and advisers is to help implement them. 
 She is impatient at what she regards as generalities in memos from colleagues and civil servants &mdash; even when she agrees with them. 
 She wants advice about practical measures which can achieve objectives. 
 Even friends acknowledge that she approaches conversations as an intellectual exchange rather than as an opportunity to empathize; her invitations to colleagues to define their terms and to explain &bquo;precisely&equo; what they mean often disconcert the unprepared. 
 (Former schoolfriends recall an occasion when Mrs Thatcher, as a young MP, returned to her old school as chief speaker at a dinner for Old Girls, and corrected the headmistress, who was a classical scholar, on the pronunciation of her Latin.) 
 David Howell did not remember his time in Cabinet with much pleasure &mdash; &bquo;some arguments just left such acrimony and ill-feeling that I can't believe they really could have been enjoyable&hellip; 
 I think the general atmosphere in the government of which I was a member was that everything should start as an argument, continue as an argument and end as an argument.&equo; 
 Her frequent denunciations of high levels of taxation and public expenditure, of big government, and of the diminution of individual freedom and choice are passionate and deeply felt; they are expressed in attacks on the baneful, almost &bquo;immoral&equo;, effects of inflation and of governments which debase the currency, or borrow rather than &bquo;balance&equo; their income and expenditure.  
 For all the pejorative talk of her being an &bquo;ideologue&equo;, however, she is a practical Conservative. 
 She traces her beliefs back to her upbringing in Grantham and to the personal experiences of the 1970s, rather than books. 
 &bquo;We tried it then and look where it led us&equo;, is her view of previous bouts of big spending, reflation, and subsidies to troubled industries. 
 Colleagues are impressed (and sometimes alarmed) by her willingness to link large philosophical issues with day to day matters; for example, high state expenditure and taxation mean less for the ordinary citizens to spend as they choose. 
 She has boasted of her tendency to draw analogies between running the economy and a housewife's weekly budget (which many economists dismiss as pre-Keynesian, na&iuml;ve, and dangerous). 
 Some ministers were at first embarrassed at what they regarded as her &bquo;preaching&equo; and &bquo;moralizing&equo; but in the end accepted it as part of the Thatcher style. 
 Unlike Harold Wilson she did not, until the Westland imbroglio in 1986, have the reputation of a &bquo;fixer&equo;, compromiser, or manager in her Cabinet. 
 Indeed she once described herself as &bquo;the Cabinet rebel&equo;. 
 Discussions with colleagues and interviewers are often interrupted by rhetorical questions, &bquo;Do you see?&equo; or &bquo;Have I made that clear?&equo; 
 When taxed about her &bquo;bossy&equo; or &bquo;headmistressy&equo; role in the 1983 election she replied: &bquo;Yes, I do believe certain things very strongly. 
 Yes, I do believe in trying to persuade people that the things I believe in are the things they should follow&hellip; 
 I am far too old to change now.&equo; 
 Her own radicalism is clearly tilted against certain dominant institutions and interests. 
 On 18 January 1984 she told a gathering of parliamentary lobby journalists that she wished to be remembered for breaking the consensus and tackling traditionally &bquo;immune targets&equo;. 
 These included the trade unions, nationalized industries, local government and, surprisingly for a Conservative leader, the monopoly professions like the solicitors and opticians and, no doubt, the civil service and universities. 
 In the same speech she said that she wanted her government to be remembered as one &bquo;which decisively broke with a debilitating consensus of a paternalistic Government and a dependent people; which rejected the notion that the State is all powerful and the citizen is merely its beneficiary; which shattered the illusion that Government could somehow  substitute for individual performance&equo;. 
 Mrs Thatcher is also out of sympathy with thy previous Conservative leaders' looking for &bquo;deals&equo; with the major interests, conciliating the trade unions, and concerned to be &bquo;good Europeans&equo; at almost any cost. 
 She has offended previous Conservative leaders like Mr Heath and Lord Stockton (formerly Mr Macmillan). 
 The extent to which her policies and style have antagonized the universities was seen in the decisive vote by Oxford academics not to give the university's most famous female graduate an honorary degree in January 1985. 
 Leaders of the Church of England have also attacked the &bquo;hardness&equo; of the government, only to be dismissed in return as &bquo;cuckoos&equo; (see below, p. 289). 
 The image is of an aggressive radical tilting against many of the most powerful and conservative (even Tory) interests in British society. 
 Indeed, this is Mrs Thatcher's image of herself. 
 In a lengthy and revealing BBC radio interview on 17 December 1985 with Michael Charlton she defended her brand of Conservatism: 
 it is radical because at the time when l took over we needed to be radical. 
 It is populist&hellip; 
 I would say many of the things I've said strike a chord in the hearts of ordinary people. 
 Why? 
 Because they're British, because their character is independent, because they don't like to be shoved around, because they are prepared to take responsibility&hellip; 
 And for the &bquo;trimming&equo; of previous Conservative leaders she borrowed Kipling's words: &bquo;I don't spend a lifetime watching which way the cat jumps. 
 I know really which way I want the cat to go.&equo; 
 But this determination was coupled with a prudence and caution in deciding which battles to fight. 
 In foreign affairs she is only one national leader among many. 
 She compromised with China in agreeing to the return of Hong Kong to China in 1997 and with the Zimbabwean nationalists over the Rhodesian negotiations, when it became clear that she could not get her way. 
 In June 1989, isolated in the European Community and under pressure from Cabinet ministers, she agreed to set conditions for British entry to the EMS. 
 At home in February 1981 she gave way and provided money for twenty-three uneconomic coal pits to remain open, when faced with the  threat of a coal strike. 
 By 1984 the government, however, was prepared for a lengthy coal strike and refused to compromise. 
 In 1982 she disowned a CPRS paper, which suggested drastic cuts in the welfare state including some privatization of the NHS, when the Cabinet reacted negatively. 
 In other words, Mrs Thatcher is prepared to wait for opportunities. 
 Cabinet Management 
 The formal duties and responsibilities of the office of a British Prime Minister are not laid down in a constitution or statute. 
 Yet a Prime Minister does face certain persisting role demands &mdash; chairing the Cabinet, answering parliamentary questions, making appointments, and choosing the time for a dissolution of Parliament. 
 Although Asquith (Prime Minister 1908 &mdash; 16) exaggerated when he said, &bquo;The office of the Prime Minister is what its holder chooses and is able to make of it&equo;, the personality of a Prime Minister may give a distinctive character to his or her administration. 
 This is particularly the case with Mrs Thatcher. 
 Most recent Prime Ministers have usually presented themselves as representing a collective Cabinet viewpoint. 
 Mr Attlee, for example, saw his job as being &bquo;to collect the voices of the Cabinet&equo; and Mr Wilson compared his role as prime Minister at various times to a soccer &bquo;midfield sweeper&equo;, or the &bquo;the conductor of the orchestra&equo;. 
 The cases where Prime Ministers have tried to bypass the Cabinet on a major policy or acted without clear Cabinet support, as for example Neville Chamberlain's foreign policy in 1937 &mdash; 9 or Mr Wilson's attempted trade union reform in 1969, may have reinforced the principle. 
 Government in Britain is not presidential; it is a collective enterprise in which power is shared and for a beleaguered Prime Minister a power shared is a blame shared. 
 Mrs Thatcher has a clear view of her role as Prime Minister and sees herself as an activist rather than an arbitrator in Cabinet disputes or a spokesman for a collective Cabinet view. 
 There is a great difference between the Attlee concept and Thatcher's robust assertion of 1979: &bquo;It must be a conviction government. 
 As Prime Minister I could not waste time having any internal arguments&equo; or &bquo;Yes, I do drive through things which I believe in passionately &mdash; what else do you expect of a  Prime Minister? 
 I'm not here just to be Chairman, I'm here because I believe in things.&equo; 
 (Panorama, BBC TV 25 January 1988.) 
 Her job is to push Cabinet ministers &bquo;to do what is right&equo;; this involves reminding them of the Government's strategy laid down in the manifestos and combating what she regards as the inertia inherent in departments. 
 Given the government's commitment to control public expenditure and reduce taxation, her main troubles in the first term were with the major spending departments and with ministers who favoured some further reflation to ease unemployment. 
 In part, this was a consequence of her appointing some ministers who were sceptical of her economic strategy. 
 The most troublesome period concerned the budget in 1981, when Jim Prior, peter Walker, and Sir Ian Gilmour were so opposed to its deflationary thrust that they considered resigning. 
 Although they neither rebelled nor resigned, their disenchantment was soon widely known. 
 But the target of Mrs Thatcher's wrath was equally well known when the day after the budget in a public speech she said: &bquo;Now what really gets me is&hellip; that those who are most critical of the extra taxes are those who were most vociferous in demanding extra expenditure.&equo; 
 This was a remarkably public statement of a Prime Minister's resentment of colleagues. 
 Since then problems with colleagues have centred on particular issues such as Westland (1985 &mdash; 6), exchange rate policy (1988), and British entry to the exchange rate mechanism ofthe European Monetary System. 
 Mrs Thatcher has insisted on particular lines of policy, even over the doubts of the responsible department. 
 She has strong views on a wide range of issues. 
 Her own policy agenda, as King notes, has often been separate from that of the Cabinet or Conservative party. 
 British Prime Ministers do not have a department to administer. 
 The opportunity this gives an incumbent to take a broad view is useful if he or she has the resources to know what is going on. 
 The support staff is tiny in comparison with that of a Cabinet Minister or US President &mdash; about eighty staffworking in Downing Street of whom the great majority (about sixty) are clerical and secretarial staff, messengers, clerks, or administrators of the machine. 
 For all the talk of Prime Ministerial government, one must remember the unequal battle which any incumbent, when confronted by more than a score of powerful  departments, faces. 
 The Prime Minister lacks executive powers and has therefore to work with and through ministers who have executive powers vested in them collectively. 
 Number 10 Downing Street, in the words of a former Political Secretary of Mr Heath is &bquo;a house not an office&equo;. 
 Mrs Thatcher's Private Office consists of six fairly senior civil servants who help with official speeches and parliamentary business and liaise between herself and departmental ministers. 
 In addition, there is a Policy Unit of eight or nine political advisers. 
 This body was established by Harold Wilson in 1974 and has been retained by his successors. 
 Its members are political appointees and civil servants who contribute advice on policy and papers from other departments, liaise with the party, and help with speech writing. 
 They are particularly concerned to look for the policy and party political consequences of events and policies.John Hoskyns headed the Policy Unit until 1982. 
 Hoskyns had built up a computer company and been active in the Centre for policy Studies before joining Mrs Thatcher. 
 He was a vigorous proponent of policies of controlling the money supply, cutting public spending, and reducing the legal privileges of the unions. 
 He retired in 1982 in some frustration with the civil service before eventually becoming director-general of the Institute of Directors. 
 Ferdinand Mount, then the Political Editor of the weekly magazine Spectator , replaced him. 
 He was followed in January 1984 by John Redwood, a historian turned merchant banker, who in turn was succeeded by an academic economist Brian Griffiths. 
 In 1970 Mr Heath had established the Central Policy Review Staff to deal with the long-term strategy matters and provide briefs for the Cabinet as a whole. 
 Mrs Thatcher did not have much time for the body and abolished it after the election victory in 1983 &mdash; an example perhaps of her dislike for so-called &bquo;professional&equo; advice that purports to be above party politics. 
 She had already decided to strengthen her Policy Unit and some CPRS members were recruited to it. 
 Her reservations about the senior civil service as a whole were well known in advance. 
 In January 1981, worried over failures to control money supply, she recruited Professor Alan Walters from the United States to provide economic advice which was independent of that of the Bank of England and  Treasury. 
 In particular, she felt in need of somebody like Walters who could argue with these two bodies about control of the money supply. 
 Her disenchantment with the Foreign Office, already evident over Rhodesia and the EEC, came to a head during the Falklands War and she brought in Sir Anthony Parsons (who had impressed her during the war when he was ambassador to the United Nations) to advise on foreign affairs and appointed Roger Jackling to advise on defence. 
 This clutch of appointments, together with her post-Falklands dominance in the Cabinet, was widely seen as heralding the introduction of a Prime Minister's Department. 
 There were predictable objections from departments which did not want to have their own policy advice scrutinized by outside experts. 
 In fact no permanent institutional reform came from the moves, and soon after the 1983 election Parsons and Jackling left, the latter returning to the Ministry of Defence. 
 Professor Walters left in 1985 and returned in 1989. 
 The changes were more a reflection of her anti-establishment outlook and determination to shake up the civil service hierarchy. 
 Shortly after the abolition of the CPRS, Professor George Jones noted: &bquo;While she has been strengthening her own personal staff resources, she has weakened those at the disposal of her Cabinet colleagues for the performances of their collective deliberations by abolishing the CPRS. 
 So she has tipped the system a little away from collective to presidential government&equo;. 
 Jones adds, however, that &bquo;the tipping is only slight&equo;. 
 But her reliance on non-official advice could also have significant policy consequences. 
 Mrs Thatcher's speech at Bruges in September 1988 which set out the government's view of its relations with the European Community was drafted by her Private Secretary and foreign policy adviser, Charles Powell. 
 Its forceful statement of British sovereignty offended many in the Foreign Office, which is more communautaire . 
 Professor Walters has reinforced Mrs Thatcher's opposition to British entry to the European Monetary System (favoured by Sir Geoffrey Howe and Nigel Lawson) and to her Chancellor's policy in 1988 of managing the exchange rate to maintain downward pressure on inflation. 
 In 1988 and 1989 the Public divisions between the Prime Minister and her Chancellor were Politically and economically damaging.  
 The view that Britain was moving to Prime Ministerial government was largely encouraged by Mrs Thatcher's dominant personality, which became more marked following the Falklands war. 
 But there were other factors as well: her ruthless dismissal of Cabinet dissenters in 1981 and sacking of the Foreign Secretary in 1983, the abolition of the CPRS, her close involvement in the promotion of Permanent Secretaries and her tendency, by publicly expressing her own views on controversial issues, to pre-empt Cabinet discussions. 
 She has reduced the number of Cabinet and official Cabinet committee meetings, and fewer papers are distributed to the Cabinet &mdash; the very stuff of collective decision making. 
 She has relied more on her Policy Unit and ad hoc  groups, and intervened more in departments. 
 Mrs Thatcher is an activist Prime Minister and her Press Office is keen that she is seen as such. 
 &bquo;MAGGIE ACTS&equo; or &bquo;MAGGIE STEPS IN&equo; are familiar tabloid headlines as Mrs Thatcher convenes seminars of experts at Downing Street to cope with a pressing issue. 
 This has occurred with football violence, broadcasting, &bquo;green&equo; issues, schools, and the universities. 
 Yet this interventionism has not led to the creation of anything approaching an Executive Office. 
 Although there is a general trend for the private offices of many political heads of state to increase in size and influence, the British Prime Minister still appears to be less well endowed with this type of political support than leaders of most other states. 
 It is possible to argue that, compared to the staff available to previous Peacetime premiers, today's staff at Number 10 is actually smaller in relation to the greater burden of work. 
 Government decisions in Britain are made in the name ofthe Cabinet, in contrast to the United States where they are made in the name of the President. 
 The British Cabinet consists of most of the ruling party's political &bquo;heavyweights&equo;, politicians who have either an acknowledged expertise, political following, reputation, or are close to the Prime Minister. 
 Most of the twenty or so men and women in the Cabinet are well known to one another and have worked together over some years. 
 But most are also rivals for political promotion to a higher office and, ultimately, for the Prime Minister's job. 
 Two points are noteworthy about Mrs Thatcher's early appointments. 
 First, in making her appointments in 1975 to the  Consultative Committee or Shadow Cabinet, Mrs Thatcher displayed conciliatory traits in retaining so many of Mr Heath's appointees. 
 All but three had already served under Mr Heath. 
 Of the twenty original members it is likely that only two (Sir Keith Joseph and Airey Neave) voted for her on the first ballot for the leadershiP election in 1975. 
 A Shadow Cabinet containing senior figures like Lord Carrington, Whitelaw, Prior, Maudling, and Pym &mdash; most of whom had already achieved office under Mr Heath, were associated with his policies, and owed little to her &mdash; was hardly right-wing. 
 Although her appointments were made with an eye to preserving party unity as well as recognizing ability, Thatcherites &mdash; often young and lacking ministerial experience &mdash; were not obvious candidates for promotion at the time. 
 The second noteworthy feature is her initial caution in refusing to reshuffle spokesmen. 
 Most of the &bquo;Shadows&equo; remained in post for the four years of opposition. 
 Michael Heseltine was moved from Trade and Industry to Environment. 
 But, Apart from the dismissal of Reginald Maudling as Foreign Affairs Spokesman, the only important reshuffle followed John Davies's resignation on grounds of ill health from Foreign Affairs in November 1978. 
 Francis Pym assumed this post, Norman St John-Stevas replaced Pym as Leader of the House of Commons, and Mark Carlisle in turn took over Education from Mr Stevas. 
 All the spokesmen were appointed to the Cabinet in 1979, usually to departments which they had shadowed in opposition. 
 Mrs Thatcher, like Mr Heath before her, clearly regarded Opposition as a time of preparation for government. 
 However, continuity also meant that Mrs Thatcher was in a minority over some policy battles in the new Cabinet. 
 Some ministers were Openly disgruntled with her style of leadershiP and the Treasury's economic strategy. 
 There was a clear separation between the Cabinet and Mrs Thatcher in the minds of many Conservative activists and observers. 
 Many right-wing back-bench critics of the government (but supporters of Mrs Thatcher) could voice their criticism without including her and liked to present her as a political prisoner of Cabinet &bquo;Wets&equo;. 
 After a while, Mrs Thatcher herself, in coded language and indirect statements (through some of the Number 10 staff), may have provided encouragement for them. 
 But a  Prime Minister's power of appointment is not limited to the selection of ministers; equally important is the allocation to Particular posts. 
 Mrs Thatcher was careful on the whole to appoint her supporters to the important economic ministries. 
 Sir Keith JosePh went to Industry, Sir Geoffrey Howe and John Biffen to the Treasury, John Nott to Trade. 
 Such likely opponents of the economic strategy as Lord Carrington and Sir Ian Gilmour were banished to the Foreign Office while Francis Pym went to Defence. 
 She also ensured that she chaired the important Cabinet (later &bquo;EA&equo;) Committee on economic strategy and that it contained a majority who supported the economic strategy of herself and the Chancellor. 
 During the course of 1981 Mrs Thatcher dismissed a number of notable Cabinet dissenters (Stevas, Soames, Gilmour, and Carlisle), Mr Prior was moved to Northern Ireland, and Lord Carrington chose to resign in April 1982 in the wake of the House of Commons' criticism of the Foreign Office policy preceding the Argentine invasion of the Falklands. 
 By autumn 1981 afl the major economic ministries (Energy, Employment, Trade and Industry), apart from the Treasury, had new ministers. 
 The reshuffle was a notable display of Prime Ministerial power but perhaps also of her frustration with the original appointments. 
 In the new government of June 1983 the move to a more homogeneous Cabinet was continued. 
 Francis Pym, a sceptic with regard to economic strategy, was sacked. 
 In 1987 another sceptic, John Biffen, Leader of the House, and one who publicly called for a consolidation rather than extension of existing policies, was dismissed. 
 Earlier he had been described by Downing Street officials as only &bquo;a semi-detached member of the government&equo;. 
 There was promotion for Nigel Lawson, Leon Brittan, Cecil Parkinson, and Norman Tebbit. 
 All were younger middle-class or lower-middle-class meritocrats; they were tough-minded types of Conservatives, who supported Mrs Thatcher's policies, and owed their promotion to her. 
 Nicholas Edwards at the Welsh Office, George Younger at the Scottish Office, and Mrs Thatcher herself had remained in the same posts since May 1979. 
 With Lord Hailsham's retirement as Lord Chancellor in 1988, Mrs Thatcher alone had remained in the same post and only Peter Walker, George Younger, and Sir Geoffrey Howe had been in the Cabinet continuously.  
 Over time she gradually created a Cabinet whose members owed their promotion to her. 
 In 1979, the Cabinet of twentytwo contained only seven ministers (Edwards, St John-Stevas, Younger, Nott, Biffen, Carlisle, and Maude) who had not been in a previous Cabinet. 
 The leadership strata of the Conservative party in the 1980s has been shaped by Mrs Thatcher. 
 By January 1989 nineteen of her twenty-one Cabinet ministers owed their first preferment to her. 
 By this date, however, the political balance in the Cabinet had altered. 
 The results of the various appointments including the 1985 promotions of Douglas Hurd, Kenneth Baker, and Kenneth Clarke and the 1987 departures of Joseph and Tebbit gave the Cabinet a distinctly non-Thatcher look. 
 This was confirmed by the promotion of Chris Patten and the departures of Lord Young and John Moore in July 1989. 
 Apart from Nigel Lawson, Nicholas Ridley, Cecil Parkinson, and Sir Geoffrey Howe, it was difficult to think of other Cabinet ministers who would be regarded as economically &bquo;dry&equo; or ideologically &bquo;Thatcherite&equo;, and both Lawson and Sir Geoffrey had well-publicized differences of opinion with Mrs Thatcher. 
 Mrs Thatcher's style certainly contributed to the Cabinet divisions between 1979 and 1981 and again after 1987. 
 She has strong views on most issues and her propensity to express her views boldly at the outset of a Cabinet discussion, combined with a sometimes dismissive attitude towards opposing colleagues, tended to change the atmosphere and polarize Cabinet discussions. 
 This contrasted with the approach of some other Prime Ministers. 
 Attlee, Macmillan, Wilson, and Callaghan often waited for a policy line in Cabinet discussion to emerge before committing themselves. 
 They also regarded their influence as a finite resource to be husbanded, used on major issues, and not frittered away on minor skirmishes or issues on which they were likely to be in a minority in Cabinet. 
 Mr Attlee was careful to position himself with the majority view in Cabinet. 
 Mr Macmillan was, according to colleagues, prepared to give way with good grace when he could not carry the Cabinet. 
 He intervened on &bquo;big&equo; issues or government initiatives (such as applying for membership of the EEC, and incomes policy, defence, and foreign and Commonwealth matters). 
 Mr Heath was a directive leader of the Cabinet but  confined, his interest to a few areas (EEC, incomes policy, and Northern Ireland). 
 By contrast, Mrs Thatcher leads from the front, has views on most issues, and is quick to voice them. 
 After 1987 she publicly disagreed with policies of her Foreign Secretary and Chancellor. 
 For much of her first term the thrust of economic policy was regarded sceptically by many colleagues. 
 Monetarism was a particularly controversial policy and a number of colleagues argued for a reversal of strategy, as unemployment increased remorselessly and the government's popularity in opinion polls and by-elections slumped. 
 For some months in 1981 the Chancellor, Sir Geoffrey Howe, had lost the confidence of Cabinet colleagues. 
 Mrs Thatcher's public speeches contained thinly veiled warning messages to colleagues who doubted the strategy. 
 Statements such as &bquo;The Lady's not for turning&equo; and &bquo;Are we going to go back? 
 Hell, no, we've only just got here&equo; were directed at them. 
 In the first two years of office she had to give way to Cabinet pressure on pay rises for MPs, the scale of public spending cuts in November 1981, gas prices, the Rhodesian settlement, the compromise on the EEC budget (faced with the implicit resignation of Lord Carrington, who had negotiated it, if she did not accept) and, while Mr Prior was at Employment, action against trade union immunities and the closed shop. 
 She also had to bow to pressure from colleagues and permit Cabinet discussion of economic strategy in 1982 and to abandon Cabinet discussion in September 1982 of the paper from the Central Policy Review staff about the implications of the rising trend of public expenditure and its proposals for curbing welfare spending (see above p. 213). 
 It was a remarkable catalogue of rebuffs. 
 Her experience was not one which supported theories of the power of the Prime Minister. 
 She was also impatient with a number of departments for displaying less than whole-hearted devotion to her policies. 
 These included the Foreign Office (allegedly too pro-EEC and generally too prone to make diplomatic concessions at the cost of British interests), the Civil Service Department (too accommodating during the civil servants' pay strike in 1981), the Department of Employment (allegedly too &bquo;soft&equo; under Mr Prior), and Education (allegedly too sympathetic to the education lobbies). 
 Over time she appointed more congenial ministers  to run departments. 
 Her position, and that of the Treasury, was fortified by election successes and economic recovery. 
 But she has remained suspicious of departmental lines which resist changes, and her doubts about the Foreign Office have remained. 
 Whitehall departments have their own networks of interests, hierarchies of civil servants, attentive public and parliamentary groups, and specialist teams of mass media reporters. 
 As a consequence British Prime Ministers may have to work extremely hard to get them to change course. 
 They may intervene in the work of some departments but only at the cost of neglecting broad strategy and the work of others. 
 At the end of the day most departments have to be left alone to implement policies. 
 What is remarkable is that Mrs Thatcher has interfered in departmental matters to a greater degree than many of her predecessors. 
 She has busied herself in the promotion of senior civil servants (looking for people with energy and commitment) and regularly badgered departments about progress on particular policies &mdash; &bquo;like a dog after a bone&equo; an adviser claims. 
 She suspects that ministers are too often &bquo;captured&equo; by their civil servants. 
 Having won the Cabinet's acceptance ofthe economic strategy, she has been more concerned with implementation and this appears to have given a greater role to her Policy Unit, members of &bquo;think tanks&equo;, and ad hoc  groups of officials, advisers, and ministers. 
 It is interesting to study how Mrs Thatcher eventually came to dominate the Cabinet, bearing in mind that many Cabinet ministers in 1979 were not supporters of her economic strategy. 
 An examination of some of the reasons may provide an insight into the sources of a modern Prime Minister's power. 
 One tactic she has used is to decide matters outside the formal Cabinet, either in committees or in informal groups. 
 She also exploited her control of the agenda of Cabinet and powers to appoint members of Cabinet committees or groups and draw up their terms of reference. 
 The appointment of supporters on the Cabinet committee dealing with economic strategy has already been noted. 
 She chairs two of the most important ad hoc  Cabinet committees, OD, dealing with foreign affairs and Northern Ireland, and EA, covering economic strategy, privatization, trade union legislation, and the European Community  matters. 
 The reduction in the number of Cabinet meetings (45 &mdash; 50 per annum, about half of the post-war norm), and of Cabinet papers (60 &mdash; 70, or one-sixth of the figure in the 1950s), and the appointment of fewer Cabinet committees have reduced the opportunities for collective deliberation. 
 The purchase of the Trident Missiles programme by the government, for example, appears to have been effectively decided by a small group of Cabinet ministers, outside the Cabinet, in early 1981. 
 This involved a massive commitment of future financial resources, as well as deciding British defence policy for the rest of the century. 
 Once the Prime Minister and a few senior ministers had made up their minds, it then achieved what senior civil servants call &bquo;momentum&equo;. 
 The presentation of annual budgets is left to the Chancellor of the Exchequer, though he is careful to consult with the Prime Minister about the strategy and discuss changes beforehand with ministers whose departments are likely to be affected. 
 The final contents of the budget are only revealed to the Cabinet the day before the Chancellor presents it to the House of Commons, when it is too late for any major changes. 
 But two budgets &mdash; 1979, which included a doubling of the standard rate of VAT on many goods and services and 1981, which was severely deflationary at a time when over two million were out of work &mdash; shocked a number of Cabinet ministers. 
 They complained about being &bquo;bounced&equo; into accepting last-minute decisions, were widely reported in the media, and they forced Mrs Thatcher to agree to a Cabinet debate about the economic strategy. 
 However, they had little effect on changing it. 
 Finally, the decision to ban trade union membership for workers at the intelligence gathering centre (Government Communications Headquarters) at Cheltenham in 1984 was taken outside the Cabinet and Cabinet committees. 
 The decision was initially taken by Mrs Thatcher, Sir Geoffrey Howe (Foreign Secretary), and Michael Heseltine (Minister of Defence). 
 A few other ministers were involved at a later stage. 
 Yet, according to The Times  (7 February 1984), &bquo;The first most Cabinet ministers knew was when Sir Geoffrey Howe announced the decision in the Commons on January 25.&equo; 
 Many later policies &mdash; the poll tax, abolition of the GLC and metropolitan counties, and the health service review have all had a  similar Prime Ministerial push. 
 She is not unique in this. 
 It is the scale of her interest in the work of other departments and working with ad hoc  groups, that makes her distinctive. 
 Mrs Thatcher's position was also secure because the Cabinet &bquo;Wets&equo; were never a coherent group; the term mistakenly unified diverse critics. 
 Mr Prior, Mr Walker, and Sir Ian Gilmour opposed many of Mrs Thatcher's and the Chancellor's economic policies, and all three at some time seriously considered resignation over the 1981 budget. 
 But they differed over the emphasis they accorded to incomes policies, reflation, or tougher measures against the trade unions. 
 Willie (later Lord) Whitelaw was a loyal deputy. 
 He worked for compromises between the &bquo;Wets&equo; and Mrs Thatcher, but at the end always backed Mrs Thatcher. 
 His support was crucial. 
 The ministers who were dismissed seemed unlikely to lead backbench revolts. 
 But Peter Walker and Jim Prior, also well-known doubters, were retained (Prior until September 1984), no doubt for fear that they might prove troublesome on the back bench. 
 Outside the Cabinet the rejected Mr Heath became an even more isolated political figure. 
 It is very difficult today to imagine a Prime Minister in good health, being deposed by Cabinet colleagues. 
 The effort is likely to be politically disastrous, even if they can agree on a successor. 
 The above are all classic instruments by which a Prime Minister can outmanoeuvre the Cabinet. 
 The first two (deciding Cabinet membership and the members and agendas of committees) lie within the Prime Minister's control, while the third (events) and fourth (divisions among party dissenters) worked to her advantage. 
 There was also the undoubted increase in her personal self-confidence and stature as a result of the recapture of the Falklands and then the 1983 and 1987 election victories. 
 Mrs Thatcher's first government was plagued by leaks &mdash; a symptom of divisions and poor morale. 
 In so far as leaks advertise unhappiness about a line of policy they undermine the principle of collective responsibility, as well as the confidentiality of proceedings. 
 Although she has deplored leaks &mdash; and instituted more leak inquiries and prosecuted more civil servants for breaches of confidentiality than any of her predecessors her press office appears to have developed the technique  of leaking against fellow Cabinet ministers to a fine art. 
 Mr Prior frequently had reason to complain about hostile leaks from 10 Downing Street when he was in charge of Employment and then of Northern Ireland. 
 Francis Pym's dismissal from the office of Foreign Secretary was widely reported in advance during the 1983 general election; the dismissals of Patrick Jenkin at Environment and Peter Rees at the Treasury in September 1985 were extensively trailed over the summer; the same was true of Mr Biffen's dismissal in June 1987. 
 In the Westland affair her management of Cabinet was an issue, once it emerged that staff at Number 10 had connived with Leon Brittan's office to leak selections from a confidential letter from the Solicitor General to damage Mr Heseltine. 
 The high profile of her press officer Bernard Ingham and his disparaging remarks about Cabinet dissenters or ministers who are due to be sacked have angered some Conservatives. 
 Mr Biffen in 1989 compared the office to a &bquo;sewer&equo; and Mr Pym in 1983 spoke of &bquo;mischief-making by the Prime Minister's poisonous acolytes&equo;. 
 After the Cabinet reshuffle in July 1989 and her press office's rubbishing of the significance of the title deputy prime minister for Geoffrey Howe, Conservative back-benchers went out of their way to show their support for Sir Geoffrey Howe in the House of Commons. 
 Mrs Thatcher also has taken risks with collective responsibility. 
 Mr Whitelaw, as Home Secretary was furious at her applause for critics of his policies at the annual party conference. 
 Mr Prior, at the Department of Employment, was publicly reprimanded by her, and her dissatisfaction with particular policies is usually well known. 
 This public image has been important in fostering a perception of Mrs Thatcher as somebody apart from the Cabinet. 
 Mrs Thatcher's direct, even confrontational style of managing the Cabinet became an issue in the circumstances in which Michael Heseltine resigned in January 1986. 
 For a month there had been a damaging public dispute between Mr Heseltine, who backed a European Consortium bid to link with Westland, the British helicopter company, and Mr Brittan, the Trade and Industry minister, who favoured an American bid. 
 In the past, Mrs Thatcher had easily fended off challenges from Tory &bquo;wets&equo;. 
 When, however, internal opposition was determined, as Heseltine's was, the danger materialized. 
 In his resignation  press conference Michael Heseltine complained explicitly about Mrs Thatcher's style and performance as Prime Minister, claiming that she had acted unconstitutionally in refusing him permission to discuss the issue in Cabinet and in forbidding him to restate views he had publicly expressed in the past. 
 There is a long list of sacked ministers who have objected to her style. 
 Sir Ian Gilmour mourned &bquo;the downgrading of Cabinet government&equo;. 
 David Howell complained that in Cabinet there was &bquo;too much argument and not enough discussion&equo; and regretted the trend towards &bquo;a huge argument where tremendous battle lines will be drawn up and everyone will be hit on the head&equo;. 
 After the damaging Westland affair and the loss of two senior Cabinet ministers, there were even Conservatives who thought that it might be time to change the leader. 
 In its aftermath Mrs Thatcher apparently took greater care to consult the Cabinet more fully and was overruled by it on the proposed sale of British Leyland to the US-based General Motors. 
 After the 1987 general election victory complaints of high-handedness surfaced again. 
 Mr Biffen spoke of &bquo;Stalinism&equo;. 
 What was remarkable was the public display of her willingness to second-guess her most senior ministers, including the Home Secretary, on measures to combat football violence, the Chancellor on anti-inflation policy, and the Foreign Secretary on a wide range of issues. 
 As noted earlier Mrs Thatcher was virtually vetoing European policies favoured by her two most senior ministers. 
 This is not, &agrave; la Harold Wilson, a determination to outmanoeuvre the Cabinet almost as an end in itself. 
 Rather it reflects Mrs Thatcher's determination to gain space and capacity to achieve her policy objectives. 
 Parliament 
 Parliament is the arena in which British political leaders are recruited and it is difficult to think of a successful Prime Minister who has not been able to command the House of Commons. 
 Compared to political leaders in other states, British Prime Ministers spend a good deal of time in the legislature. 
 The lengthy period which most party leaders have already spent in Parliament before gaining office certainly gives them time and opportunity to acquire suitable skills. 
 The  parliamentary set pieces like Prime Minister's Question Time (each Tuesday and Thursday when the House of Commons is sitting) and the major debates are great tests for the Prime Minister. 
 At Question Time the Prime Minister is backed by the civil servants who brief her and try to anticipate supplementary questions. 
 Mrs Thatcher takes these sessions seriously and goes to enormous lengths to prepare for them. 
 The noisy exchanges in the House of Commons and her determination not to be shouted down by the opposition make her sound hectoring and strident. 
 John Cole, the Political Editor of the BBC, commented in February 1985: &bquo;To see the Prime Minister, arms akimbo or leaning far across the dispatch box to bellow into the microphone, is to recall a Belfast working-class politician&hellip; who boasted that his Ma could beat any woman in the street. 
 This lady's not for shouting down.&equo; 
 In the post-war period, foreign affairs and economic issues have tended to dominate the Prime Ministers' parliamentary attention. 
 Analysis of Prime Ministers' involvement in parliamentary debates shows that in the course of an average year they will participate in six debates and make six statements on policy, usually on the economy, foreign affairs, and government business. 
 Compared to earlier Prime Ministers, Mrs Thatcher makes fewer interventions in House of Commons debates and makes fewer set-piece speeches. 
 Involvement in these issue areas, together with the need to attend to management of the political party, means that she normally sees the Chief Whip, Foreign Secretary, and Chancellor of the Exchequer on political business more frequently than she does other Cabinet colleagues. 
 The Prime Minister is also the leader of a political party in Parliament. 
 In the British system, leadership of a major political party is the first requirement for being a Prime Minister. 
 A politician, however eminent or popular, who lacks that base will not reach or survive at the top. 
 A party leader who hopes to reach 10 Downing Street has to devote much time to party management, and policies and appointments have to be made with an eye on the reactions of party factions. 
 Of Conservative leaders in the twentieth century, A.J. Balfour (191 1), Austen Chamberlain (1922), Neville Chamberlain (1940), Sir Alec  Douglas-Home (1965), and Mr Heath (1975) were all eventually forced out of the leadership because of the lack of party support in Parliament; the last two as much because they had also lost general elections. 
 Party management in the Commons is left to the Whips, who rely on a mixture of patronage, appeals to party loyalty, and back-benchers' fears of letting the opposition into office to keep the party's majority intact. 
 For the Prime Minister and the Cabinet, carrying Parliament means, effectively, carrying their party's back-benchers. 
 Yet, her first government (1979 &mdash; 83) faced significant back-bench revolts on the proposed closed-shop amendment in the Employment Bill in 1980 and on unemployment benefit cuts in 1981, was defeated on proposed changes in immigration rules in 1981, and had to withdraw a proposal to impose a ceiling on local rates in the face of opposition. 
 Dissent increased in the 1983 Parliament, partly because of the government's larger majority, which enables rebels to dissent without jeopardizing the government. 
 Mrs Thatcher was rebuffed, again largely by her own backbenchers, over the choice of Speaker in 1983, MPs' pay, proposed housing benefit changes, rate support grant proposals, Britain's EEC contribution, and, most humiliating of all, over Sir Keith Joseph's plans to make major cuts in aid to students in higher education. 
 In July 1985 the government was nearly defeated in the Commons over a vote to reduce the Lord Chancellor's salary. 
 This was a Labour vote of censure on the government's acceptance of the proposals from the Top Salaries Review Board for large increases in the pay of senior public servants. 
 In April 1986 the government lost its Shops Bill, which had been designed to permit trading on Sunday. 
 A remarkable example of back-bench influence on the Prime Minister was seen in the resignation of Leon Brittan from Trade and Industry in the aftermath of Westland. 
 Mrs Thatcher had rebuffed suggestions that he resign and made it clear that he enjoyed her full confidence. 
 But it was vigorous criticism of him in the 1922 Committee by Tory back-benchers which convinced Brittan &mdash; and Mrs Thatcher &mdash; that he no longer enjoyed the confidence of the party in Parliament. 
 This was a hard period for the Prime Minister &mdash; she lost the confidence of senior colleagues, was widely regarded as an electoral liability  and lost battles in the Cabinet. 
 Within the first year of the 1987 Parliament a quarter of Conservative back-benchers rebelled against the government at least once. 
 There have been major rebellions against the imposition of charges for eye and dental tests, for an amendment to grade the poll tax according to ability to pay, and for the second reading of a private members' bill to liberalize the Official Secrets Act. 
 The divisions which accompanied Mrs Thatcher's election to the leadership in 1975 have, with one notable exception, faded. 
 Mr Heath, though lacking political influence, has remained a powerful defender of his own government's record &mdash; which Mrs Thatcher and some colleagues scorned. 
 His criticisms have become so predictable and strongly worded that they are counter-productive. 
 Mr Heath returned to the limelight in the Euro-election in June 1989. 
 He was bitterly critical of Mrs Thatcher's authoritarian leadership as well as her &bquo;negative&equo; attitude to the Community. 
 His views had some support in the party. 
 Over time, the wets who at one time favoured a change in economic policy virtually disappeared. 
 An attempt by Francis Pym and some thirty dissatisfied MPs in 1985 to form a Centre Forward group to press for such changes was short-lived. 
 The large number of Cabinet ministers who have resigned or been dismissed have not been a focus for dissent. 
 Mr Heseltine has been careful to support the government, while proclaiming a distinctive brand of Conservatism. 
 Another dismissed Cabinet minister, Mr Biffen is a frequent critic of Mrs Thatcher's tone and of the government's preference for tax cuts over greater spending on the social services. 
 But there is little organized dissent. 
 Mrs Thatcher has always realized that her power base lay with back-benchers and has tried to be accessible to them. 
 In opposition she particularly urged her front-bench spokesmen to be attentive to the party's back-bench committees relevant to their subjects. 
 In part the style is an acknowledgement of how she came to the leadership, and in part also a reaction to previous leaders. 
 Churchill, Eden, Macmillan, and Home had been political grandees; all emerged through the &bquo;magic circle, and not as a result of election by MPs. 
 Mr Heath was notorious for his remoteness from his back-benchers. 
 She also finds strong support among the party's grass roots. 
  Like many local constituency Conservative party officers, who are drawn from the professions and small business, Mrs Thatcher is self-made and does not come from one of the traditional Tory interests &mdash; business, land, or a political family. 
 Her open dislike of direct taxation, public spending, much of the public sector, and trade unions and her protective attitude to the tax reliefs for home-owners and investors and sympathy for farmers, small business, and the forces of law and order are all favourite Tory themes. 
 She has also proved more willing to allocate political honours to party workers than was Mr Heath who had been particularly niggardly in this regard. 
 Her invocation of themes and support for many policies favoured by the party's grass-roots supporters has made the party more radical. 
 She has given voice to those who thought that previous Conservative governments had been too tolerant or &bquo;defeatist&equo; about the unions, the welfare state, high taxation, and public spending, and too accommodating to other countries, particularly in the European Community and the Commonwealth. 
 This has been coupled with policies for a &bquo;strong&equo; state in defence and law and order, and more centralized control over local government spending and over secondary and higher education than any previous government has attempted. 
 She is unsympathetic to &bquo;liberal&equo; measures to promote more &bquo;open government&equo;, greater press freedom, or trade union rights for government employees engaged in defence and security activities. 
 In this sense she is not a libertarian. 
 The spirit of Mrs Thatcher and the new Conservatism has been well captured by a Marxist, Andrew Gamble: 
 The state is to be rolled back in some areas and rolled forward in others&hellip; 
 The real innovation of Thatcherism is the way it has linked traditional Conservative concern with the basis of authority in social institutions and the importance of internal order and external security, with a new emphasis upon free market exchange and the principles of the market order. 
 In foreign affairs Mrs Thatcher has proved to be something of a &bquo;little Englander&equo;. 
 In her early years as Prime Minister she largely left the negotiations over Rhodesia (Zimbabwe) and the EEC budget to the Foreign Office. 
 Her deep involvement in the Falklands war and determination to retain British sovereignty  over the islands has to be set against Britain's negotiated return of Hong Kong to China with effect from 1997 and refusal to support or condemn the US invasion of Grenada (part of the Commonwealth). 
 Indeed there is some evidence that only with the Argentine invasion of the Falklands and the deaths of British servicemen did the &bquo;Fortress Falklands&equo; policy emerge. 
 Britain has proved to be one of the least &bquo;community-minded&equo; members of the EEC and has for long been at odds with other states about the level of British contributions to the EEC budget. 
 Mrs Thatcher resisted attempts by Brussels to promote a Community-wide Social Charter, which she regarded as introducing &bquo;socialism by the back door&equo;. 
 She also resisted the wishes of senior ministers for Britain to set a date for entry to the EMS. 
 Her strong views on national sovereignty and limiting the competence of the European Community &mdash; at a time when moves to greater unity were gathering pace &mdash; placed Britain in a familiar minority of one. 
 Yet she did compromise over the budget at Fontainebleau in 1984, signed the Single European Act in 1986, and accepted the Delors proposals for budgeting and agriculture reform in 1988. 
 On Europe the pattern has been one of resistance to proposals but, in the end, accepting compromise. 
 Although enjoying a warm personal relationship with Mr Gorbachev, the American and West German wishes to promote disarmament on NATO short range missiles in 1989 have left her relatively isolated in the changed climate. 
 Her greater sympathy for the Atlantic connection over the European one is not widely shared by colleagues. 
 In 1989 she described the relationship as &bquo;paramount&equo;. 
 The close relationship was partly a consequence of her rapport with President Reagan, and is unlikely to be as close with President Bush. 
 Public Role and Image 
 British Prime Ministers are not popular figures (Table 9.1). 
 They are seen in a partisan perspective, a perception that limits the extent of their popular appeal. 
 Only for five years between 1945 and 1983 has approval for the Prime Minister exceeded that of his party by more than 10 per cent, and Harold Wilson, and Harold Macmillan are the only post-war premiers to have   retained the support of 50 per cent or more of the electorate for two successive years. 
 Mrs Thatcher's approval rating on Gallup fell to a record low of 28 per cent in October 1981. 
 Although the Falklands improved her standing, the approval ratings over her premiership are still lower than those for leaders in the 1950s and early 1960s. 
 Pre-Falklands, her average monthly approval score on Gallup was 36 per cent; after the war until June 1983 it was 47 per cent. 
 Thereafter it declined to pre-Falklands levels. 
 Political leaders, where they can be set apart from the party, may help to shape a party's image. 
 In Britain, however, they have a limited impact on voting behaviour. 
 In 1979 Labour decisively lost the election, although Mr Callaghan was more popular than Mrs Thatcher (and his party). 
 The traditional forces for voting, namely party loyalty and social class, though weakening, still depress the electoral impact of the personality of the leader. 
 Yet mass media coverage of general elections and parliamentary politics is highly personalized and concentrates on the party leaders. 
 General elections have become more presidential and the mass media virtually ignore the secondary party  leaders. 
 For the past quarter-century, the Prime Minister alone has regularly received more attention in The Times  than the three leading ministers together &mdash; the Foreign Secretary, Chancellor of the Exchequer, and Leader of the House of Commons. 
 Television and the popular press are even more likely to accentuate the pattern of The Times  reporting. 
 The imbalance in coverage stems partly from the Prime Minister's engagement in more newsworthy activities and partly from the fact that, as leader of the government, he or she is newsworthy. 
 He has many opportunities to personify the government or, strictly speaking, to be presented as its spokesman. 
 In the mass media, on foreign visits, and in Parliament, the Prime Minister is regarded as the authoritative spokesman for Cabinet policy. 
 Political coverage on television necessarily promotes leaders because it usually has time for only one item per party. 
 Mrs Thatcher was particularly prone, as opposition leader and early in her premiership, to &bquo;make policy&equo; in television and other interviews, almost committing her Cabinet in advance. 
 This has continued as Prime Minister. 
 Aided by her Press Officer, Bernard Ingham, the media more and more present government policies as Mrs Thatcher's. 
 Ministers have complained about &bquo;the Number 10 publicity machine&equo;. 
 Surveys indicate that Mrs Thatcher is not regarded as a warm or compassionate person. 
 But she has long scored highly on the qualities of being decisive, resolute, and principled, a perception helped by the Falklands war and the comparison until 1983 with Michael Foot, the Labour leader. 
 The Conservative election campaign slogan of &bquo;The Resolute Approach&equo; in 1983 leaned heavily on her image. 
 Not surprisingly, Mrs Thatcher has polarized public opinion more than other party leaders. 
 People are not indifferent; they either like or dislike her. 
 In the 1983 and 1987 elections many Conservative and Labour politicians reported the doorstep hostility to Mrs Thatcher, as well as the respect for her. 
 Her own perception of herself (courageous, persistent, and sticking to a course no matter how unpopular) is matched by the public perception, according to Gallup surveys on the personality images of various leading British politicians. 
 Table 9.2 shows that for nearly ten years now voters have agreed about her strength of personality and outspokenness. 
 But many also see   her as divisive, condescending, and a destructive force in politics. 
 The image of her as a &bquo;superwoman&equo; is also fuelled by eulogies in the sympathetic tabloid press, as well as the &bquo;devil theory&equo; of Labour politicians. 
 It is a tribute to the importance of her personality that her advisers have spent much time on her image. 
 They were originally concerned that she appeared too aggressive, shrill, and unsympathetic. 
 Before the 1979 election her public relations adviser, Gordon Reece, coached her to lower her voice, speak slowly, and present a &bquo;soft&equo; image and tried to arrange television interviews with relatively non-aggressive interviewers. 
 On the whole she has been more attentive to the requirements of the arts of self-presentation and the requirements of the mass media and public relations than other leaders like Heath, Callaghan, and Foot. 
 A recent study has documented the many ways in which Conservative spokesmen have tried to manage the media and been conscious of the image of the government and Mrs Thatcher. 
 The study concludes that &bquo;She has become a mistress of the pre-planned, carefully packaged appearance.&equo;. 
 The British Prime Minister is inevitably pushed to play a major public role &mdash; as head of the government in Parliament, as public spokesman for the government, as leader of the nation on visits abroad, and as chairman and summarizer of Cabinet discussions. 
 But compared, say, to a President of the United  States or France, the tasks of cultivating and presenting the Prime Minister's personality are probably less demanding. 
 On the other hand, tasks of party management and maintaining Cabinet cohesion are more insistent, though perhaps less so than for a German Chancellor or Italian Premier. 
 Conclusion 
 Mrs Thatcher has already proved herself a remarkable figure. 
 She has challenged certain long-established political assumptions: that a government could not be re-elected if it presided over a massive increase in unemployment; or that a government had to govern with the consent and co-operation of the major interests, particularly business and the unions. 
 Mrs Thatcher has successfully defied both beliefs. 
 Most British Prime Ministers and party leaders have gradually lost popularity over time and retired when their reputation was at a low point. 
 After a decade in office Mrs Thatcher was still an exception to this trend and was as popular as when she first became Prime Minister. 
 It is true that she has not always got her own way in Cabinet, particularly in the first years. 
 On a number of issues informed observers were able to distinguish her own preferences from those of most of her Cabinet, hardly a sign of successful political management. 
 Her remarkable statement in an interview, &bquo;I am the Cabinet rebel&equo; suggests that, if she gave a lead, she did not always have a majority of followers. 
 However the fact that she lost a few battles in Cabinet does not mean that she was not the dominant figure or that the Cabinet was supreme. 
 Reference was made earlier to the mobilizing  and reconciling  styles of leadership. 
 Effective political leaders have to take account of both role demands. 
 It is possible, however, to classify most British political leaders according to the relative importance they attach to these values. 
 In the inter-war years Stanley Baldwin and Ramsay MacDonald, by temperament and political conviction, were reconcilers. 
 They were relatively non-partisan and pursued policies which would least disturb the social fabric. 
 Gladstone. 
 Lloyd George, and Chamberlain were classic cases of mobilizers. 
 They were not respecters of party lines and the last two in particular were widely distrusted  among parliamentary colleagues. 
 The mobilizing style has a greater appeal when there is dissatisfaction with the status quo and a feeling that new policies are required. 
 There is little doubt that Mrs Thatcher belongs to the camp of the mobilizers. 
 She is impatient with the status quo and the traditional style of decision-making by compromising with the major interests. 
 She has repudiated policies associated with previous Conservative leaders and has divided public opinion. 
 She has been highly critical of many established institutions, such as the senior civil service, Foreign Office, Bank of England, universities, and local government. 
 She is also something of a populist. 
 Her views on capital punishment, immigration, and the trade unions resemble those of the right-wing tabloid press. 
 Yet, to a greater extent than other mobilizers, say, Joseph Chamberlain or Lloyd George, she has operated within the established political institutions of Parliament and party. 
 In Britain, the character of being a mobilizer or a reconciler is not related to being in any one party or being in opposition or government. 
 The movement between the two has often been cyclical, with one style breeding a reaction in favour of the other. 
 A leader may start out as a mobilizer but end as a conciliator. 
 In 1964 Mr Wilson presented himself as a radical figure, but by 1974 he was comparing himself to a family doctor, and hoped, in his own words, &bquo;to achieve&hellip; peace and quiet for the country&equo;. 
 Mr Heath in 1970 was also a radical leader and many of his policies were enacted in the face of bitter opposition in and out of Parliament. 
 Yet by October 1974 the once radical Mr Heath was espousing the cause of conciliation and national unity, arguing that the grave problems facing the country and the necessary mobilization of consent required a cross-party coalition. 
 Mrs Thatcher, however, has remained a mobilizer; she clearly regards herself as Heath plus, providing greater political will and persistence. 
 Talk of a policy U-turn or reversal, associated with Mr Heath from 1972 onwards, or of &bquo;ungovernability&equo;, so prevalent in the 1970s, has disappeared from the political vocabulary in Britain. 
 Mrs Thatcher prides herself on her reputation as an &bquo;Iron Lady&equo;. 
 But she is also reacting against a political &bquo;fixer&equo; style of leadership associated with the  Labour Prime Ministers Mr Wilson and Mr Callaghan in the mid-1970s. 
 Philip Williams has drawn a distinction between Labour party leaders who are Path-finders , who look for new solutions or try to lead the party in new directions, and stabilizers , who are concerned above all with preserving party unity. 
 Labour, with its well-entrenched factions, egalitarian values, myths about the sovereignty of the party Conference, and separation of powers between the National Executive, Conference, and parliamentary party, has required coalition building skills of a high order. 
 Both Wilson and Callaghan were determined to keep the fissiparous Labour party together. 
 They thought that this required the abandonment of any directive or heroic leadership and the careful balancing of rival right and left political factions in the Cabinet. 
 Critics inveighed against the fudging, the soothing formula, the trimming, and the unheroic style, all designed to keep the party together. 
 The success of the mobilizer is to be measured in the accomplishment of goals; conciliators are more interested in unity and consensus &mdash; even if it is directionless. 
 It is always difficult to assess the political significance of an individual leader. 
 One approach is to imagine different outcomes in the past and ask &bquo;what if?&equo; 
 For example, what if Mr Heath had won the February 1974 general election, as he nearly did, and carried on as Prime Minister? 
 What if Mr Whitelaw, the heir &mdash; apparent, had stood on the first leadership ballot in 1975 and won, as many think he would have? 
 Even to pose such questions reminds us that there was a large element of chance in the emergence of Mrs Thatcher. 
 Circumstances, or &bquo;luck&equo;, have also been important in her later career, particularly the outbursts of industrial unrest in 1979 which so damaged the Labour government, the divisions in the Labour party, the occurrence of the Falklands war in 1982, and the divided non-Conservative vote in the 1983 and 1987 elections. 
 It is reasonable to associate a number of distinctive policies with the presence of Mrs Thatcher &mdash; the economic strategy, attempts to contain the public sector, toleration of high unemployment, reduction in the powers of trade unions, privatization, the vigorous prosecution of the war in the Falklands, the community charge, education reforms, change in the civil service, and Britain's refusal to join the EMS. 
 A number of  Cabinet colleagues had doubts about all these policies and many would acknowledge that things would have been different without her. 
 It is doubtful that she has transformed the role of the Prime Minister in British politics. 
 The office is not highly institutionalized and she has not made changes in this respect. 
 Her significance as Prime Minister is that she has set an example; by pushing to the outer limits of her authority, making decisions with small groups of ministers and advisers, and closely involving herself in Whitehall promotions and the policies of departments, &bquo;the repertoire of Prime Ministerial tasks has been extended&equo;. 
 The very forcefulness with which Mrs Thatcher has projected her views and style, separate from those of her Cabinet, has also established a model of premiership. 
 It is one which, whether measured in terms of winning elections or carrying through policies, has been remarkably successful. 
 Thatcherism has been both a matter of style &mdash; combining impatience with much of the status quo and a relentless promotion of new attitudes &mdash; and policies. 
 Both Lloyd George and Churchill were helped by the fact that their style suited the temper of the times. 
 Historians may point to the downfall of Lloyd George in 1922 and Churchill in 1945; the achievements were recognized but declined in importance as the electorate responded to new issues. 
 Mrs Thatcher's achievements in taming the trade unions, reducing inflation, introducing privatization and more commercial values into the public sector, and recovering the Falklands gave scope for her adversary talents. 
 As past achievements are taken for granted and new challenges emerge, so voters may look for alternative leaders. 
 Mrs Thatcher's style of leadership has thrived on crises. 
 In such circumstances, the identification of an unpopular target &mdash; an Argentine General, Irish hunger strikers, or coal miners' leader Arthur Scargill &mdash; polarizes public opinion. 
 By being clearly against an unpopular figure, Mrs Thatcher has usually rallied public opinion to her side. 
 The same style is less suited to &bquo;normal&equo; politics or when the &bquo;enemy&equo; is less obviously unpopular. 
 The support she may win in the crisis, where minor disagreements are sunk in the face of a much disliked enemy, can evaporate in everyday disputes, where the Prime Minister's views must compete with many other acceptable views.  
 Historians are certain to acknowledge that she dominated the political landscape of the 1980s and a number of her policies will leave a mark in post-Thatcher Britain. 
 The success is even more remarkable when compared to her predecessors. 
 With the possible exception of Baldwin in 1937 no Prime Minister in the twentieth century has left office willingly and on a high note. 
 They have been overthrown (Asquith, Lloyd George), stepped down because of old age, ill health, or policy failures (Balfour, Bonar Law, MacDonald, Chamberlain, Churchill, Eden, Macmillan), or were repudiated by the voters (Attlee, Heath, Callaghan). 
 It remains to be seen how, and indeed whether, Mrs Thatcher is able to manage her departure from office.   
 THE REORDERING OF BRITISH POLITICS 
 THIS last chapter evaluates, under six headings, the significance of the Thatcher governments in post-war British politics. 
 First, it discusses the government's impact on the Conservative party: has it created a new Conservatism? 
 Second, it analyses the changed relationships between the government and major interests and pressure groups. 
 Third, it analyses the influence on the political agenda and public opinion; has it shifted either of them to the right? 
 Fourth, it compares the British experience with trends in other western states in the 1980s, has the so-called Thatcher revolution been no more than the British reflection of trends apparent elsewhere? 
 Fifth, it examines whether recent elections have produced a realignment in the party system; have three successive handsome election victories now made the Conservative party the natural majority party? 
 Finally, it assesses the impact of party government in Britain in the light of the Thatcher record. 
 A New Conservatism? 
 Politicians live by rhetoric. 
 They often use words as tools for influencing public opinion, exaggerating or belittling policy achievements and even substituting for them. 
 The Thatcher record since 1979 has been accompanied by a good deal of inflationary rhetoric from both supporters and critics. 
 Admirers claim that the Thatcher governments have vanquished much conventional wisdom of the 1970s, such as the idea that the British were &bquo;ungovernable&equo;, that the unions ran the country, or that there was a &bquo;British disease&equo;. 
 Instead, it is claimed, Britain's economic decline has been reversed; in the process much of the post-war consensus has been broken, and a good thing too. 
 On the other side, critics (including some Conservatives) claim that in their zeal to break the consensus the governments have destroyed much of manufacturing industry,  starved the welfare state of resources, and divided British society. 
 More detached observers suggest that in the next century historians may see Mrs Thatcher as a figure having no more long-term significance than Wilson, Heath, or Callaghan. 
 One sceptical commentator has reacted against the idea of there being something called &bquo;Thatcherism&equo;, by claiming that &bquo;both opponents and supporters of the administration have created more of a pattern from disconnected events and policies than is warranted&equo;. 
 One approach to debunking the distinctiveness of the Thatcher record is to argue that the post-1979 policies are merely a continuation of earlier trends, for example, of the early economic policies of Mr Heath's 1970 government or of the acceptance of monetary targets and abandonment of Keynesianism under the Callaghan &mdash; Healey regime in 1976. 
 There is, however, a distinction between the Thatcher policies and those of Mr Heath, which were short-lived, and those of Mr Callaghan and Mr Healey, which were reluctant, partly forced by outside pressures and largely confined to monetary targets and cuts in public spending. 
 To claim that the government's record since 1979 has been the product only of instinct or opportunism, displaying no coherence, is, I would suggest, to carry scepticism too far. 
 It is true that policy blueprints are rarely carried through perfectly. 
 Qualifications and amendments have to be made to the plans of the drawing-board as policy-makers confront changing circumstances. 
 Yet doubts about political patterns may be overdone and result in a denial of such phenomena as a New Deal in the United States in the 1930s, Gladstonian Liberalism in the late nineteenth century, or collectivist politics after 1945. 
 The setting of particularly high standards for uniformity and internal consistency makes it impossible to speak of the existence of almost any &bquo;ism&equo; in policy. 
 In terms of political style and policies there is something new and radical about the Conservative party under Mrs Thatcher. 
 The trade union reforms, the break with the &bquo;social partners&equo; approach in running the economy, the abolition of a tier of local government, the imposition of far-reaching central government controls over local government finance and policies and then the replacement of household rates by the community charge,  and the large-scale privatization, all mark a major departure from the conventions of post-war politics. 
 The reactions of such leading Conservative figures as Francis Pym, Sir Ian Gilmour, Edward Heath, Jim Prior, and the late Lord Stockton, show that Thatcherism has offended many traditional Conservatives. 
 Their criticism is not simply the embittered jealousy of defeated leaders; it represents a feeling of betrayal. 
 For most of its history the Conservative party has managed to avoid the factionalism of the Labour party. 
 The leadership of Mrs Thatcher and her repudiation of some of the policies associated with her Conservative predecessor certainly sharpened divisions among Conservative MPs in her first term of office. 
 Those MPs of a so-called &bquo;dry&equo; tendency have regarded the control of inflation via a tight rein on the money supply as the primary objective of a government's economic policy, favoured free-market policies and a reduction of state ownership and spending, and taken an authoritarian line on law and order and many social issues. 
 The so-called &bquo;wets&equo; favoured an interventionist role for government in the economy and were prepared to increase state spending to boost employment, even if this risked some increase in inflation. 
 But over time the Conservative party divisions on economic policy became less marked, partly because of electoral success and partly because unemployment has fallen steadily from June 1986. 
 It could fairly be said that Mrs Thatcher won the economic argument. 
 The simple division between &bquo;dry&equo; and &bquo;wet&equo; does not, however, do justice to the currents of opinion in the contemporary Conservative party. 
 One of the effects of the Thatcher decade has been to redefine the benchmark of divisions. 
 The new Tory right consists both of libertarians and traditionalist (or Burkeian) Tories. 
 These two groups agree on rejecting many economic policy prescriptions of the &bquo;wets&equo; but disagree on the role of the state. 
 Libertarians want a drastic reduction in the interventions of the state, not only in the economy but also as a social regulator, so that opportunities for both personal choice and the free-market economy are maximized. 
 Traditionalists, however, do not regard society as merely a gigantic market place and favour an authoritarian stand on many social issues, for example, on drugs, abortion, Sunday trading, and censorship. 
 Norman Tebbit's Disraeli  lecture in 1985 spelt out his distaste for the &bquo;valueless values of the permissive society&equo;, of the 1960s and 1970s &mdash; represented by legalized abortion and homosexuality, fewer constraints on what is portrayed in the media and theatre, and growing disrespect for authority. 
 By 1989 the largest Conservative back-bench group was the right-wing 92 Group. 
 A reading of Rhodes Boyson's Centre Forward  (1978) gives some idea of how the Conservative party's policies have shifted in the past decade. 
 Boyson, an outspoken Conservative MP for Brent North, is on the right wing of the party and propounds populist authoritarian policies &mdash; on law and order, education, trade unions, and patriotism. 
 In 1978 his views were shared by a small minority in the party. 
 Boyson looked forward in his book to a seven-day programme for the reconstruction of Britain. 
 The programme included: 
 (1) 
 sharply reduced rates of income tax and a top rate of 60 per cent; 
 (2) 
 government spending to be cut by 5 per cent annually in real terms for five years; 
 (3) 
 a substantial increase in police numbers and pay; 
 (4) 
 state welfare to be replaced by a scheme of payments and vouchers; 
 (5) 
 an end to exchange controls and allowing the pound to find its own level; 
 (6) 
 an end to the statutory monopoly of nationalized industries and all to be opened up to competition. 
 In 1978 these policies appeared far-fetched. 
 Yet by 1988 substantial progress had been made on all but items (2) and (4) of the agenda. 
 Some of Mrs Thatcher's critics claim that she is not a Conservative at all, at least not in the paternalist tradition of Disraeli and One Nation Conservatism. 
 The qualification is important. 
 Conservatism in Britain has been multifaceted but that tradition has been dominant. 
 Her supporters, however, claim that she has returned the party to the essential verities of sound money, lower rates of income tax, strong government, and rolling back government from areas where it has no useful role to play. 
 From this perspective it was Macmillan, Butler,  and their heirs who betrayed Conservatism, by compromising with social democracy. 
 The case against Mrs Thatcher as a Conservative includes her impatience with the status quo and her suspicion, indeed rejection, of so many traditions and institutions. 
 Much of the alleged wisdom that inheres in institutions and practice is part of what she has regarded as the flabby consensus that dragged the country down. 
 She has not approached the senior civil service, local authorities, universities, trade unions, BBC, Church of England, the legal and medical professions, and public corporations with the reverence &mdash; or at least respect &mdash; with which Burke recommended that we regard the work of our ancestors. 
 Sir Ian Gilmour, a member of Mrs Thatcher's Cabinet until his dismissal in 1981, has been the most articulate critic of the new Conservatism. 
 His views have been expressed in numerous speeches and newspaper articles and in two learned and witty books, Inside Right  and Britain Can Work . 
 He claims that Conservatism is &bquo;not an idea, still less is it a system of ideas&equo; and that the Conservative tradition is marked by &bquo;scepticism, a sense of the limitations of human reason, a rejection of abstraction or abstract doctrines, a distrust of systems and a belief in the importance of experience and circumstances&equo;. 
 He invokes Burke in his opposition to a priori politics and to the application of systematic and abstract schemes and policies. 
 Conservatives should not be rationalists. 
 The kind of ideological politics which he castigates as non-Conservative covers monetarism as well as Marxism. 
 Francis Pym, who was abruptly dismissed as Foreign Secretary in 1983, is another good exemplar of the old consensual Tory style. 
 He favours an approach which is &bquo;balanced&equo;, aware of different points of view, and he is critical of Mrs Thatcher's &bquo;&bquo;absolutist'&equo; style &mdash; absolutely in favour of one thing, absolutely against another'. 
 Lord Whitelaw, for long her Deputy Prime Minster, also embodied this kind of Conservatism &mdash; cautious, moderate, a classic One Nation Tory. 
 As the product of a privileged background, he surely represented the type of rich Conservative who was inhibited by what Mrs Thatcher once called &bquo;bourgeois guilt&equo; (see p. 246), and a directionless consensus. 
 In his memoirs he answers the charge: &bquo;Some Tories, like me, are criticised for this supposed failing (of  being patrician) which is said to lead to moral softness, in contrast with the toughness of those who have had to fight their way in life. 
 I am not ashamed to be regarded as sympathetic to the anxieties of those whom life appears to be treating harshly. 
 Nor do I accept that such feelings are a sign of weakness, provided that they are accompanied by an inner toughness where necessary and justified.&equo; 
 He told Brian Walden, in The  Sunday Times (16 April 1989), 'I don't pretend that I liked her because I didn't&hellip; 
 But I decided to force myself to try to get on with her. 
 I found her infuriating&hellip; she goes on and on and is determined to get her own way.&equo; 
 All three are the voices of the Tory grandees mourning the demise of their values under the shopkeeper's daughter. 
 In one significant sense, however, Mrs Thatcher has operated in the tradition of Conservative statesmanship. 
 Jim Bulpitt argues that an abiding interest of Conservative leaders has been the protection of the autonomy of the central government in matters which ministers regard as &bquo;high politics&equo;, such as defence, foreign affairs, and national economic policy. 
 Other issues &mdash; of &bquo;low politics&equo; &mdash; could be left to voluntary groups, the market, or local government. 
 By the 1970s, critics claimed that government had become &bquo;overloaded&equo; with responsibilities and popular expectations &mdash; such as maintaining full employment or delivering rising living standards. 
 In economic policy, of course, this autonomy of government had been further compromised by Mr Heath's search for agreement with the trade unions on incomes policy between 1972 and 1974 and by succeeding Labour governments. 
 The task therefore was to recover greater autonomy at the centre and limit the state's obligations to those that were essential and/or that it could carry out. 
 As already noted, the attraction of monetarism for the new Conservative leadership by 1979 was that it promised a method of controlling inflation by means, as it were, of an automatic pilot; there would be no need for government to compromise its authority with producer groups. 
 Strict control of the money supply and a curb on government borrowing would squeeze inflation out of the economy. 
 The government would not print the money to pay for inflationary wage deals. 
 Instead it would land trade unions and employers with the consequences of their decisions on  prices and pay. 
 Abandoning the commitment to full employment would restore autonomy to the centre. 
 According to Bulpitt, &bquo;in so far as monetarism was associated&hellip; with &bquo;arms' length&equo;, anti-corporatist government, then&hellip; the statecraft (of monetarism) must be viewed as less a radical break with the past and more as an attempt to reconstruct it'. 
 This view can be related to a number of outstanding features ofthe British political system. 
 Regardless of whether it is called a &bquo;top down&equo; model or an elective dictatorship, the formal concentration of political authority in Britain is remarkable. 
 A unitary system, the sovereignty of Parliament usually wielded by a one-party majority, Treasury control of national finance, the absence of a written constitution or a Bill of Rights which courts can use to challenge the government, and the idea that extra-parliamentary party organs are merely &bquo;handmaidens&equo; of the parliamentary party all bear witness to this centralization. 
 It has proved convenient for Conservatives and Labour parties and will probably continue to be so as long as one of them holds office. 
 The central issue in British politics has not been how to curb the elective dictatorship but how to capture it. 
 For all the Conservative talk of &bquo;rolling back the state&equo; there has been a remarkable centralization of decision-making since 1979. 
 To understand this, it is necessary to distinguish between the areas of defence, law and order, and social policy &mdash; where the motive of government policy appears to be the concentration of authority to build a &bquo;strong state&equo; &mdash; and full employment, incomes policy, industrial policy, and public ownership from which the government has withdrawn to create &bquo;a free economy&equo;. 
 What is significant is the extension since 1979 of the range of issues in the first category which the Conservative leadership regards as &bquo;high politics&equo;, that is, which it regards as being within its own sphere of decision-making. 
 In education, local government, and health the government has intervened and regulated on a large scale. 
 The Interests Disturbed 
 Traditionally, Conservatives have been respectful of the claims of voluntary groups, interests, and self-governing professions; these were Edmund Burke's celebrated &bquo;little platoons&equo;. 
 By  imposing new policies and challenging traditional methods of decision-making, however, the government has disturbed a number of interests. 
 In higher education, for example, the idea of the autonomy of the University Grants Committee (replaced in 1988 by the University Funding Council) as a buffer between the universities and the Department of Education and Science has been shattered and the Department has regularly intervened with advice to universities and polytechnics about subject areas which should have greater or less resources. 
 In secondary and primary education the government has imposed central pay bargaining on the school teacher unions, a contract of service and appraisals of performance on teachers, and a core curriculum. 
 The measures represent a major coup by central government against local government and the unions. 
 It massively increased the budget of the Manpower Services Commission, enabling it to play a dominant role in vocational education. 
 In the National Health Service the local element in policymaking has been weakened as the government has pushed for greater accountability of regional bodies to central government. 
 The Secretary of State for Health reviews proposals to promote efficiency with each Regional Health Authority chairman and the latter then meets the chairmen of the District Health Authorities to implement the policies, covering specific spending and manpower targets. 
 In 1989 the government's proposals for the reorganization of the NHS included the creation of an NHS &bquo;internal market&equo; in which GPs could shop around for health care, the establishment of a new management board, with most members drawn from industry, permission for hospitals to become self-governing and new contracts for GPs. 
 The 1983 Water Act reduced local authority representation on Regional Water Authorities and the new boards have fewer members, all of whom are now appointed by the Environment Minister. 
 As with education these interventions and the reduction in the role of producers and local government spokesmen have usually been made in the name of promoting value for money and increasing choice for consumers. 
 The search for efficiency and cost-cutting has resulted in greater centralization. 
 The most remarkable extension of central control has been in  the field of local government. 
 For long British Conservatives praised local government and voluntary groups as a check on an over-mighty (obviously Socialist) central government; such pluralism could also promote experimentation and diversity in policies. 
 The party, for example, has always opposed mandatory comprehensive secondary education, insisting that the choice be left to each local authority. 
 Labour, which wanted mandatory comprehensive schooling, was painted as the party of central control and uniformity. 
 Conservative defence of local government prevailed until the mid-1970s. 
 Thereafter, the growing concern over inflation, steep rises in household rates, growth of public spending, and the activities of left-wing Labour authorities led the Conservatives to search for economy. 
 This culminated in the imposition of far-reaching controls. 
 The containment of public spending has won out over local choice; reducing the state in this area has meant central government rolling back the local state. 
 The erosion of consensus politics overtook local government as it did many other areas of public life. 
 In Manchester, Liverpool, the Greater London Council, and some London boroughs left-wing Labour authorities sought to implement local socialism and use the town hall to challenge Thatcherite Whitehall. 
 Local defiance of central government policies and rejection of its ultimate authority overturned traditional conventions of central-local relations. 
 Increases in spending, grants, and support for anti-racist, pro-Sinn Fein, and pro-gay-lesbian policies enraged right-wing Conservatives and the tabloid press. 
 The label loony left councils stuck and was used to discredit much of local government in general. 
 There also developed a right-wing Conservative critique of local government. 
 So often, it was claimed, local government was not the voice of the local community &mdash; election turnouts were derisory, elections were fought on national rather than local issues, and many voters were council employees (with, therefore, a vested interest in greater spending), council house tenants (with an interest in subsidized rents), or were not ratepayers at all. 
 Many of the services provided were quasi-monopolistic and poor. 
 The high spending, high rating left-wing councils drove away business, exacerbated the economic decline of inner cities, and frustrated the enterprise policies of the government. 
  Increasingly the Thatcher governments became the protector of the ratepayer rather than the defender of local democracy. 
 According to one commentator Thatcherite decentralization embraced a new &bquo;ratepayer democracy&equo;: 
 Local government itself was seen as being as much in need or a rolling back of its frontiers as was central government, in order that economic individualism might have greater room for action. 
 Ratepayer democracy&hellip; implied less local government, with fewer services to provide since some of them could be handed over to the private sector, to the supposed benefit of consumers and ratepayers alike. 
 The attempt to &bquo;discipline&equo; certain offending local authorities involved the government in many political and legal battles, the passage of several Acts of Parliament, and, ultimately, the creation of a radically reshaped system of local government. 
 In the 1980 Local Government Planning and Land Act the government took powers to decide the spending totals of each local authority. 
 When this failed to contain local spending sufficiently, volume targets were introduced together with penalties in the form of loss of central government grant if local authorities exceeded their targets. 
 In response defiant authorities, invariably Labour controlled, raised the extra money from household and business rates. 
 Having tried and failed to control spending the government then decided to control local revenue. 
 The 1982 Local Government Finance Act abolished the right of authorities to set a supplementary rate and the 1984 Rates Act empowered the government to limit the spending and rates of centrally defined overspending authorities. 
 Finally, in some frustration, in 1988 the rating system was abolished for England and Wales and a community charge introduced, to take effect in 1990 &mdash; 1 (introduced a year earlier in Scotland). 
 Whereas only about a third of local residents paid full rates, most adults will pay the charge. 
 By restoring the link between voting and taxation, the government hopes that voters will punish &bquo;wasteful&equo; or &bquo;high-spending&equo; councils. 
 In 1985 legislation was also passed to abolish the GLC and the metropolitan counties (all of which were Labour controlled). 
 By 1987 Britain was the only European state without a directly elected capital city authority. 
 Some commentators on the left take a more explicitly political  view of the central-local government trends since 1979 and suggest that they are part of a deliberate larger attempted restructuring of relations between state and society. 
 The abolition of rates fulfils an ambition of Mrs Thatcher's dating back to 1974. 
 But the interventions, each one usually more radical than the last, were more a sign of growing frustration at the centre. 
 Critics on the left claim that the police and education services have become part of the strategy of state control and regulation. 
 This has been combined with such measures as the privatization of local housing and other services, central control over local spending and revenue, and forcing local authority direct labour organizations into the market place. 
 Urban development corporations (UDCS), were established, dominated by private business, to promote the regeneration of inner cities and bypass local authorities. 
 In education and housing the government has limited the role of local government. 
 The centralization from above, and decentralization to markets and consumers below, has weakened local government. 
 The effects of large-scale unemployment and changes in the laws affecting trade unions have sapped militancy on the shop floor. 
 The National Graphical Association incurred four contempt fines totalling &pound;675,000 and eventual sequestration of its funds before it called off its illegal picketing (under the 1980 Act) against Mr Eddie Shah's publishing company in 1983. 
 The National Union of Mineworkers also had to pay heavy fines and suffer sequestration. 
 In 1986 Sogat 82 was fined and had its entire assets sequestrated because of its illegal disruption of the distribution of Rupert Murdoch's News International newspapers. 
 Mrs Thatcher's governments were determined to cut the unions down in size and, for all the incremental nature of the legislation, prepared the ground in advance. 
 Class analysis alone is inadequate for an understanding of the policies of Thatcherism, for it has also disturbed a number of middle-class interests. 
 The ending of the monopoly of solicitors over house sales conveyancing and of opticians over the sale of spectacles has already been noted. 
 A Conservative attack on such solid middle-class professions is unprecedented. 
 The pace has increased in the government's third term of office. 
 Tenure for university staff has been abolished. 
 In 1989 it was  planned that doctors would have to work to new contracts, under which their pay would be more clearly related to the number of patients. 
 There are also government proposals for the reorganization of the legal profession. 
 Barristers will no longer have the exclusive right of audience before higher courts; any lawyer possessing an &bquo;advocacy certificate&equo; will be able to appear. 
 In 1989 the proposals were being bitterly resisted by doctors and lawyers. 
 Equally notable has been the worsening relationship with leaders of the Church of England &mdash; for so long known as the Tory party at prayer. 
 Some bishops, notably Jenkins of Durham, Sheppard of Liverpool, and Hapgood of York, have spoken out about deprivation in the inner cities, the miners' strike, and the need for government to show a greater compassion for, and understanding of, the poor. 
 According to the Bishop of Durham, &bquo;This Government also seems to be indifferent to poverty and powerlessness. 
 The financial measures consistently improved the lot of the already better off while worsening that of the badly off&hellip; such a Government cannot promote community.&equo; 
 According to the Archbishop of Canterbury, &bquo;There seems to be a movement from consensus to confrontation and also a growing scale of confrontation.&equo; 
 The archbishop also called, in a newspaper interview in November 1984, for &bquo;leadership in our national life which will unite and not divide the nation&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;That's not an attack on the government.&equo; 
 Later, in December 1985, the Archbishop of Canterbury's committee on the inner cities presented its report, Life in the City . 
 This contained many proposals for the regeneration of these areas, including greater central government expenditure, which ran counter to the government's ideas. 
 The report was immediately dismissed as &bquo;Marxist&equo; by a government spokesman and criticized with varying degrees of vigour by many Conservatives. 
 These attacks in turn have been met by forceful rebuttals from Conservative back-benchers and from the Prime Minister herself. 
 The Tory critics object that the Church is peddling left-wing politics as a religious message, while failing to assert moral values. 
 Mrs Thatcher in 1988 addressed the General Assembly of the Church of Scotland and quoted St Paul: &bquo;If a man shall not work &mdash; he shall not eat.&equo;  
 Relations between the government and senior civil service also have been uneasy. 
 Some might regard the frequent leaks of sensitive government documents as a consequence of this tension. 
 Mrs Thatcher also appears to have intervened more directly than previous Prime Ministers in the promotion of Permanent Secretaries, preferring less senior and &bquo;obvious&equo; candidates on the grounds that they were impatient with the status quo and not &bquo;defeatist&equo;. 
 Some have accused Mrs Thatcher of applying tests of political loyalty in making appointments. 
 In fact she has favoured &bquo;doers&equo;. 
 Mrs Thatcher has been fortunate in that retirements of several senior personnel in the early 1980s gave her the opportunity to influence promotions; there were thirteen appointments as Permanent Secretary in 1982 alone and she has had a hand in appointing the great majority of Permanent and Assistant Permanent Secretaries since 1979. 
 The traditional &bquo;trade-off&equo; for the secure tenure of senior British civil servants has been that they are anonymous and politically impartial. 
 To some degree the impartiality has depended on there being a large measure of policy agreement and continuity between the parties in government. 
 The doubts of some pre-war Labour leaders that the civil service would actually co-operate with a radical Labour government were largely laid to rest by the experience of the Attlee government. 
 But radicals in both parties who favoured radical changes, either to the left or to the right, have frequently condemned the civil service as the embodiment of an above-party consensus favouring continuity of policy. 
 Sir John Hoskyns, a former head of Mrs Thatcher's Policy Unit, has called for a radical reform of the government system if the effort to transform the economy is to succeed. 
 He urged the appointment of more outsiders to top positions in the civil service and of officials and ministers who were committed to radical change. 
 A rejection of this approach was voiced by Lord Bancroft, head of the civil service until 1981. 
 In a lecture in 1983 he argued that a civil servant who could answer &bquo;yes&equo; to the question &bquo;Is he one of us?&equo; should retire and become a party politician. 
 Whether it was the abandonment in 1981 of established procedures for settling the pay and conditions of civil servants, abolition of the Civil Service Department in the  same year, deterioration of levels of pay relative to the private sector, efficiency scrutinies in departments in search of savings, attempts to limit index-linked pensions, or the reduction in numbers of staff, there was no doubting Mrs Thatcher's hostility to much of the ethos of the civil service. 
 In 1989 the government was preparing to implement The Next Steps  under which many departments carrying out executive functions would be converted into independent agencies. 
 Her government, by its clear breach with many previous policies and early derision of the higher civil service, has placed a double strain on the traditional relationship. 
 She has been willing to look outside the civil service for advice on policy &mdash; to various &bquo;think tanks&equo; and individuals who have often reinforced her scepticism about traditional departmental policy views. 
 The new emphasis is on management skills and giving value for money. 
 The decision in January 1985 of the Oxford University Congregation to vote by a margin of more than 2 to 1 against awarding its most famous daughter an honorary degree is another mark of the emotions she raises among other established &eacute;lites. 
 Opponents resented the cuts in university funding and complained that the government was hostile to higher education, particularly to studies of the humanities, which fostered a critical spirit of enquiry. 
 The &bquo;utilitarian&equo; policy of shifting the balance in higher education to vocational, business, and technological subjects concerned many university leaders; it was memorably dismissed by Enoch Powell as &bquo;barbarism&equo;. 
 Mrs Thatcher, and the attitudes that she presents, were a challenge to many established ways in the universities. 
 Hugo Young (&bquo;Why the Dons Showed They've Learnt the New Politics&equo;, Guardian , 4 February 1985) appreciated this side of Mrs Thatcher and its relevance to the question of the honorary degree. 
 He commented: 
 Far from being a blot on her tenth anniversary as Conservative leader, the withholding of the doctorate perfectly crystallised the cultural change that she has wrought&hellip; 
 She has been as ready as the Labour party to apply political criteria when making appointments to bodies like the health authorities and nationalised industries. 
 She praises the risk takers, wealth creators, people who are frequently from modest backgrounds and who may not even have been at a university. 
 Witness the speech at Newcastle on 23 March 1985, when she attacked her clerical and academic critics: 
 And nowhere is this attitude &lsqb;opposition to wealth creation&rsqb; more marked than in the cloister and common room. 
 What these critics apparently can't stomach is that wealth creators have a tendency to acquire wealth in the process of creating it for others. 
 She continued: 
 They didn't speak with Oxford accents. 
 They hadn't got what people call the &bquo;right connections&equo;, they had just one thing in common. 
 They were men of action. 
 Her desire to break with traditional policies has also involved a rupture with many traditional Tory interests and leaders. 
 Before their deaths both Lord Butler and Lord Stockton, formerly Harold Macmillan, frequently made clear their distaste for the government's policies. 
 These eminent figures from the age of consensus felt that Mrs Thatcher was betraying their &bquo;One Nation&equo; legacy. 
 Although leader of the Conservative party she is pre-eminently an anti-establishment figure. 
 It is interesting that her famous question &bquo;Is he one of us?&equo; has usually been asked about fellow-Conservatives. 
 One mark of a radical government is its politicization of hitherto relatively non-political areas. 
 The list is long: the government's decision in August 1985 to lean on the BBC Board of Governors not to show a Real Lives  programme featuring interviews with terrorists in Northern Ireland; its prohibition of broadcasts with terrorist groups in Northern Ireland; its prosecution of newspapers which revealed the contents of the Spycatcher  book of memoirs by a retired MI5 agent, Peter Wright; its robust dismissal of the dissenting views of senior figures in the Church of England, senior civil servants, and university spokesmen; its appointments to various quangos and nationalized industries; and its controls on local government. 
 All may have emulated some actions of previous British governments. 
 But the broad package of interventions and centralization over such a long period of time surely outstrips  that carried out by any previous government. 
 In many ways it is a classic case of adversary politics. 
 In so far as the actions since 1979 have politicized areas hitherto relatively immune to such considerations they provide pretexts for a future Labour government to intervene in these spheres. 
 Another casualty of Thatcherism has been what Whitehall calls The Great and the Good', those who often staffed the Royal Commissions and committees of inquiry. 
 The G and G were an embodiment of the old consensus. 
 They were largely drawn from academe, retired mandarins, and BBC governors; they were often political centrists and cross-benchers who had a belief in disinterested enquiry and collecting and weighing evidence. 
 They were schooled in &bquo;squaring interests&equo; and coming up with acceptable compromises. 
 Harold Wilson appointed so many commissions that he brought the system into discredit. 
 There is some merit in Mrs Thatcher's claim that too often Royal Commissions were appointed largely to avoid decisions or to postpone necessary tough action: she has not appointed one Royal Commission in her ten years in office. 
 After all, she knows what is to be done. 
 Her preferred method has been to make policies with small working parties, drawn from sympathetic ministers and members of her Policy Unit and &bquo;think tanks&equo;, as with the introduction of the poll tax, the health service review, and some of the education reforms. 
 Peter Hennessy has called the old G and G &bquo;the lost tribe of British public life&equo;. 
 How does one reconcile this record with the Burkeian respect for structures and institutions which mediate relations between the citizen and the state? 
 In the 1980s Conservatives have been more likely to evaluate the mediating institutions according to whether or not they are in the public sector. 
 If they are &mdash; including public-sector trade unions, local government, local authority schools and housing, and various quangoes &mdash; then they attract little sympathy and people have to be liberated from them. 
 Hence the encouragement for voluntary schools, City Technology Colleges, and for schools and hospitals to &bquo;opt out&equo;; inducements for universities to be less dependent on state finance; promotion of council house sales and housing action trusts. 
 It is also interesting to note how relations have worsened with a number of &eacute;lite institutions which have been identified  with paternalist and consensual values &mdash; universities, the Church of England, the senior civil service, the BBC and One Nation Conservatism. 
 These were committed to a balanced or cross-bench political outlook and have been uneasy with the Prime Minister's zeal, certainty, and forcefulness. 
 It is now commonplace to say that the Thatcher governments have had to be highly interventionist in order to extend the market, increase the rights of consumers, and reduce producer power. 
 It has reduced the claims that groups are able to make on the state. 
 Reliance on monetarism rather than incomes policy meant that the government no longer had to compromise its authority in making social contracts and wages policies with producer groups, particularly the unions. 
 The public sector of the economy has been rolled back and strikes in the public sector have been resisted. 
 Another tactic has been to give greater scope to consumers vis-&agrave;-vis  public sector groups. 
 Schools and housing associations can opt out of local authority control. 
 A greater voice has been given to parents, governors, and head teachers in state schools and to GPs and patients in the health service. 
 Trade union members have been given more say via pre-strike ballots, regular elections of their officials, and votes on the unions' political levy. 
 Many nationalized industries, which long posed problems for governments, not least in pay negotiations, were floated to the private sector. 
 The losers have been local authorities, trade unions, health authorities, and nationalized industries. 
 The net effect of these measures has been to give greater autonomy to the central government. 
 Public Opinion 
 What effect has the government had on the public mood? 
 One has to recall that a major objective of Mrs Thatcher's government has been to change public opinion, not least about the role of government itself. 
 Mrs Thatcher has said that if economics is the means, then changing hearts and minds is the goal. 
 One might think that such an ambition &mdash; no less than the forging of a cultural revolution &mdash; is most unconservative. 
 Yet this is a natural task for Margaret Thatcher; she relishes proclaiming Thatcherite values and telling people which policies are morally right and which are morally wrong. 
 Indeed the long-term  success of free-market policies depends on a change in public mood. 
 In Zurich in 1977, Mrs Thatcher said: 
 In our philosophy the purpose of the life of the individual is not to be the servant of the state and its objectives but to make the best of his talents and qualities. 
 The sense of being self reliant, of playing a role within the family, or owning one's own property, of paying one's way, are all part or the spiritual ballast which maintains responsible citizenship&hellip; 
 The speeches of ministers have reiterated the themes that it is not the job of government to solve as many problems as previously, that ministers should be more attentive to the interests of taxpayers when spending public money, that &bquo;real&equo; jobs will be created and sustained not by government subsidy but by workers making goods which people will buy, that the criterion of &bquo;value for money&equo; be applied to public-sector activities, and that the private sector should be encouraged because it creates the wealth which the public sector requires. 
 Conservative spokesmen have said that people should reduce their expectations of what government can do and that economic improvements would depend largely on the action of people themselves. 
 In a word, the dependency culture should be replaced by an enterprise one. 
 In shifting responsibility from government to the people: &bquo;The Thatcher government has adopted a novel approach. 
 It has tried to change the question&equo;. 
 By the end of the year, in an interview with the Financial Times , Mrs Thatcher suggested that a third successive Tory election win would fulfil her aim of &bquo;Killing off Socialism&equo;. 
 Surveys suggest that the government has had some success. 
 A MORI poll (April 1989) for a BBC programme, Thatcher's Children , found that among young voters (15 &mdash; 28) aspirations were distinctly bourgeois. 
 Their ambitions were to own their own homes and have private pensions. 
 A remarkable 40 per cent wanted to run their own business and a quarter expected to do so. 
 In 1979 and in 1983 there was clear electoral support for several Conservative policies, even among many Labour voters. 
 On such issues as public ownership, legal curbs on the trade unions, defence, council house sales, and restricting the range of welfare benefits, a majority of Labour voters disagreed with their party's policies. 
 By 1989 Labour had shifted its  policies on many of these issues. 
 In this sense we may talk of there being a shift to the right, even where this is not reflected in voting for the Conservative party. 
 There has also been a change in mood about nationalization. 
 The 1964 British Election Survey found that just over half (51 per cent) were satisfied with the status quo, and supporters of further nationalization outnumbered denationalizers by 28 to 21 per cent. 
 By 1979, however, the survey found that there had been a major shift in support for privatization and public opinion remained in favour of further privatization in 1983, and probably reflected a positive response to the Thatcher policies. 
 By 1987, however, most voters, supported the (changed) status quo and were opposed to plans to privatize electricity and water. 
 Surveys have reported heavy support for the trade union reforms introduced by the Conservative government since 1979 and show that profit-making is still socially acceptable and that people endorse the principle that wage increases must be earned by firms selling their goods at a profit. 
 In terms of ideology also, the Conservatives are well placed. 
 In 1983, for example, Gallup found that of voters who placed themselves on the political left and right, 22 per cent placed themselves at various ranges of the left end of the scale (from &bquo;far&equo; to &bquo;slightly&equo; left), 51 per cent placed themselves on the right, and 13 per cent regarded themselves as middle of the road. 
 In 1987, the respective figures had changed to 28 per cent, 45 per cent, and 9 per cent. 
 Although there had been a 6 per cent swing from &bquo;right&equo; to &bquo;left&equo; between the two elections the former were still in a clear majority. 
 Many Tory party cheer-leaders boast that there has been a cultural revolution. 
 Conservative electoral landslides, extension of home ownership, reductions in trade union membership and power, and the rise of white-collar employment, entrepreneurship, and self-employment all seem to be powerful indicators of this change. 
 On the other side sceptics point out that the Conservative share of the vote in the 1983 and 1987 elections is below that in the 1960s and they point to the several opinion surveys which show that popular support for collective values remains high. 
 In spite of undoubted social and economic changes there has been no revolution in values. 
 As a careful analysis of the data   states, &bquo;Quite simply there has been no Thatcherite transformation of attitudes or behaviour among the British public. 
 If anything the British have edged further away from Thatcher's position as the decade has progressed&equo;. 
 Notwithstanding the re-election of Mrs Thatcher in 1983 and 1987, a clear majority of voters have favoured increased taxes to pay for greater expenditure on services such as health, education, and welfare, over tax cutting and programme cutting (Table 10.1). 
 Since 1979 the balance has moved steadily against tax cutting in favour of more spending on education and the NHS. 
 In May 1979 spenders and tax-cutters were equal (34 per cent); by May 1987 the spenders outnumbered the cutters by more than 5 to 1 (61 to 12 per cent). 
 The results have not been dissimilar when Gallup has asked whether voters preferred a cut in local rates if this meant a reduction in local services  or an extension of the services even if this involved an increase in rates. 
 In 1977, before Mrs Thatcher came to power, Gallup found that 33 per cent of voters thought that if people were poor this was probably due to their own lack of effort. 
 By March 1985 the figure had fallen to 21 per cent. 
 The proportion blaming poverty on &bquo;circumstances&equo; rather than fecklessness rose from 30 to 49 per cent between the two dates. 
 The same survey found that three-quarters of the electorate felt that money and welfare should be more evenly distributed in Britain. 
 Over time the proportion preferring &bquo;caring&equo; to &bquo;tough&equo; policies has increased by one-third and the &bquo;carers&equo; are now in a substantial majority. 
 The 1983 British Election Survey also found a change over recent years in favour of &bquo;liberal&equo; social policies. 
 Although support for some of the liberal values is confined to a minority, it is a growing one. 
 For example, between 1966 and 1983 support for abolition of the death penalty increased from 18 to 37 per cent (support for its retention or restoration fell from 82 to 63 per cent). 
 A similar shift occurred on attitudes to policies which promote equal opportunities for women and ethnic minorities and the provision of abortion on the National Health Service. 
 In all three cases there has been a marked increase in the proportion who favour the more liberal status quo. 
 Public opinion has shifted to the right over the past decade on one component of collectivism &mdash; nationalization &mdash; and in a more liberal direction on another, state provision of welfare and social policies (for similar trends elsewhere, see below). 
 If anything, the surveys suggest that the public mood was at its most Thatcherite and right-wing in the second half of the 1970s. 
 This divorce between the two elements is particularly marked among the salariat &mdash; the well-educated members ofthe professions and management &mdash; which has grown most in the past twenty years. 
 The shift to a more &bquo;liberal&equo; view on social issues and disarmament is probably due to the growth of this group and the expansion of higher education. 
 A decade has not made the concept of Thatcherism attractive to the British people. 
 According to Gallup (April 1989) the term Thatcherism has negative connotations for most people. 
 MORI (April 1989) found widespread support for the idea of a    society which placed collective over individual values (Table 10.2). 
 Surveys of attitudes to so-called Thatcherite ideas (for example, a government sticking to its principles, however unpopular; not consulting with the major economic interests; and the government's inability to do much about unemployment) found that, on average, Thatcherite supporters (40 per cent) were outnumbered by opponents (47 per cent). 
 Table 10.3 shows a further swing away from Thatcherite ideas towards caring and consensus government between 1983 and 1987. 
 It is as if the public recognizes that society has changed over the decade but does not much like what sees.   
 The burden of the survey findings seems clear and is rather disheartening for the Thatcher project. 
 But some qualifications are in order. 
 What are many of these questions measuring and how significant is the data, say as a guide to behaviour or as an influence on voting? 
 Huge majorities apparently prefer reducing unemployment to fighting inflation. 
 Yet what do we then make of a Gallup finding (21 &mdash; 6 May 1987) that, when asked to choose between inflation and unemployment as the greater threat to them and their families, 49 per cent chose inflation and only 43 per cent unemployment? 
 Similarly, for all the huge majorities claiming to prefer more government spending, even if this involves paying more taxes, what does one make of the finding that voters, when asked which mattered more to themselves  and their families, &bquo;more public spending or tax cuts?&equo;, a majority preferred the tax cuts (Marplan, March 1987). 
 Gallup has found widespread dissatisfaction with the quality of society. 
 People are seen as being more selfish, aggressive, and less tolerant and happy than was the case a decade ago. 
 But, surprisingly, when individuals were asked whether they felt this about themselves only tiny minorities admitted to such a feeling. 
 Survey questions pitched at a general level may elicit what respondents regard as socially approved values. 
 Similarly worded questions over time have to take account of changes in the topics under question. 
 Surveys since 1979 show that trade unions have become less feared and that there is less support for further privatization. 
 On both topics, however, the status quo has changed radically compared to 1979. 
 Unions have lost powers and the numbers of disputes has declined; similarly the public sector has been reduced in size. 
 The data might be read as a backhanded success for the Thatcher government. 
 As the concerns of 1979 &mdash; high taxation, trade union power, nationalization, and inflation &mdash; have become less salient, so there is less support for radical policies to deal with them. 
 As economic satisfactions have increased, so the scope for dissatisfaction on social issues may also have increased. 
 A New Middle Ground 
 There have been many claims that Mrs Thatcher has shifted the agenda of British politics. 
 On the political left a journal like  Marxism Today  claims that there has been an underlying and probably permanent shift to anti-socialist values. 
 Again, Andrew Gamble is worth quoting: 
 Whatever the fate of the Thatcher government, the New Right will survive it. 
 In its impact on British politics and economic policy it has already been remarkably successful. 
 The traditional post-war argument between different kinds of interventionism has been replaced by a much broader debate. 
 The 1983 and 1987 Gallup election surveys showed that voters across all parties agreed on many goals of government. 
 This is significant, given that many commentators in 1983 thought that the policies of the Conservative and Labour parties were further apart than at any time over the previous thirty years. 
 Richard Rose's review of the Gallup survey on twenty political issues found that majorities of voters for all three parties agree with each other on more than two-thirds of all issues, that most Alliance voters agree with the national majority on nineteen of twenty issues, and that most Conservative and Labour voters with the majority on seventeen of twenty issues. 
 Moreover this level of inter-party agreement has persisted since 1970. 
 Even in 1987 voters did not expect the return of a Labour or Conservative government to make a significant difference. 
 According to Gallup, voters expected that, on twelve issues, a change of government would produce different outcomes only on those affecting trade union powers and nationalization. 
 There is also wide support for the mixed economy &mdash; a private enterprise economy, subject to government controls &mdash; as well as for state provision of welfare services. 
 The roles of government and state are viewed neither in the negative terms of Mrs Thatcher nor in the positive terms of Labour's left wing. 
 For all the talk about a new consensus and a new realism, however, a number of issues remain open. 
 How is the free-market economy to be reconciled with continued large-scale tax concessions for house mortgages and private pensions? 
 How durable, for example, will be the changes in industry, elimination of many restrictive work practices, productivity pains, decline of labour militancy, and reassertion of managerial authority? 
 In 1989 the British economy was again at the wrong  end of league tables for having relatively high levels of inflation, interest rates, and a trade gap. 
 Some critics suggested that many of the old problems of the British economy had returned. 
 Yet if talk of permanent or irreversible changes may be too bold, the Thatcher government has created a new agenda, one which a successor government will find difficult to reverse. 
 It is difficult to imagine that there will be a return to the status quo ante regarding the closed shop, trade union immunities and pre-strike ballots, the right of council house tenants to buy their own homes (over a million former council tenants have made such purchases), and the position of former nationalized industries. 
 Millions of voters have acquired a stake in the wider ownership of shares and homes and a voice in union affairs. 
 Similarly, sustained government rhetoric about getting value for money from programmes and protecting the interest of taxpayers will probably leave a mark. 
 Since 1979 there has been a loss of over 1.5 million manufacturing jobs; by 1987 manufacturing accounted for only 22 per cent of the British workforce, &bquo;a figure more typical of countries with large fishing or agricultural sectors&equo;. 
 That decline, when coupled with the abolition of Labour party strongholds in local government in London and the metropolitan counties, reduced employment in the nationalized industries and public sector (down from 29.4 per cent of the workforce in 1979 to 26.9 per cent in 1985) and a lower number of trade unionists and council tenants, means that a future Labour government will start from a much weaker position in terms of promoting its traditional objectives of public ownership, trade union bargaining rights, and collectivism. 
 There is also some evidence that Mrs Thatcher has attracted a particular electoral constituency. 
 That section of the middle class which includes shopkeepers, foremen, and the small and self-employed businessmen &mdash; the petit bourgeois  &mdash; has turned strongly to the party since she became leader. 
 By 1974 many of these people had become disillusioned with the Heath government. 
 Yet a survey study of the 1983 election found that this section of the electorate was the most right-wing of all on issue questions about privatization, incentives versus equality, trade union rights, and comprehensive schools, and that over 70 per cent of them voted Conservative in the election. 
 The  Conservative electorate in the 1980s contains two significant groups. 
 With 36 per cent of the manual workers' vote in 1987 the party's share of the working-class vote was the highest for any post-war election. 
 It was higher still in what Crewe calls the &bquo;new working class&equo; &mdash; workers living in the south, owning their own homes, employed in the private sector and not in trade unions. 
 The second group is concentrated among a particular section of the middle class &mdash; those in the private rather than the public sector, and among those who are not graduates. 
 Some of the new thinking may already be common ground. 
 The fine print of the speeches of Labour leaders and party policy documents has changed during the 1980s. 
 The party now accepts Britain's membership of the European Community and in the 1989 Euro-elections claimed to be the party of &bquo;good Europeans&equo;. 
 It has turned away from old style nationalization and is more willing to admit the need for enterprise and a role for markets. 
 The party leadership has also accepted the case for state aid for regular elections of trade union officials by members, pre-strike ballots, and the sale of council houses to tenants. 
 The 1989 policy review has made it clear that complete renationalization of privatized industries will not be a high priority for a future Labour government, that direct taxation will not be increased for those on average and slightly above average incomes, and that it is &bquo;concerned&equo; about law and order. 
 It has also abandoned unilateralism and refuses to promise that a Labour government will rid Britain of nuclear weapons in the lifetime of the government. 
 Compared to 1983, let alone 1979, Labour appears to be more aware of a changed electorate, one which is not largely poor, unemployed, in trade unions, working in heavy manufacturing, or living in council houses. 
 A test of a shift in the central ground of politics is the extent to which the opposite party accepts, however reluctantly and implicitly, the new ideas. 
 On this test, Thatcherism has achieved a partial success. 
 A by-product of Labour leaders' responsiveness to the new thinking may be that the party relieves itself of some commitments which have been electoral liabilities in the past. 
 So far the leadership's reaction to the 1983 and 1987 defeats has differed from that to such earlier decisive election defeats in 1931, 1951, 1970, and 1979. 
 Those defeats unleashed bitter internal conflicts  and, except for 1951, a shift to the left on policy. 
 The parliamentary leadership was usually assailed by the left for having failed to carry out socialist policies and having compromised with capitalism when in government. 
 Since 1983 the leadership, having read the election defeats as a repudiation of left-wing policies, has been more concerned to reassure the electorate and attract the millions of &bquo;missing&equo; Labour voters. 
 Militant Tendency in Liverpool and elsewhere, Mr Scargill of the NUM and Tony Benn have been lashed by the leadership as the unacceptable face of Labour and all have been marginalized in the party. 
 Among more radical monetarists and free marketeers there remains disappointment that the government had not done more to shift the middle ground. 
 Such critics want bolder measures to cut taxation and state spending. 
 In education radicals welcome the introduction of the assisted places scheme, CTCs, proposals for opting out, and increase in places on school governing boards for parents, but seek further reforms to erode the dominance of the state and extend parental choice. 
 A scheme of school vouchers was considered and abandoned although a scheme for loans in higher education is to be introduced. 
 No action has been taken to trim tax relief for pension contributions or house mortgages (although the Treasury has ended the entitlement to tax relief for two mortgages on one property and has maintained a limit of &pound;30,000 on mortgages entitled to tax relief). 
 In December 1985 the long-awaited Fowler review of the State Earnings Related Pension Scheme (SERPS) produced only a reduction in the pension benefits rather than an abolition of the scheme (it is worth noting, however, that the encouragement to leave SERPS for private schemes has had some success; by mid-1989 over one million people had left). 
 On the NHS, for all the managerial changes and efficiency campaigns, Mrs Thatcher has made clear that it will remain a largely state-financed service. 
 Finally, the much-heralded Medium Term Financial Strategy (see p. 228) and monetarism were cast aside. 
 In October 1984 Nigel Lawson's Mansion House speech formally abandoned a specific range for the M3 measure of the money supply. 
 The Chancellor made clear that henceforth he would rely more on the narrower definition of money, Mo, and  maintain a high exchange rate (and high interest rates) to dampen inflation. 
 In fact money supply grew rapidly and by 1989 inflation was over 8 per cent. 
 Some right-wing critics of the Conservative government have argued that the partial success in changing attitudes was reflected in the failure of government to be more radical in cutting the levels of taxation and public spending and the size of the public sector. 
 Here is a critique of the Thatcher record from a different perspective than that of the left or of the centre. 
 An editorial in The Times , a firm supporter of Thatcherite policies, could ask on 3 May 1985: &bquo;If these obstructions to a society, based on enterprise and shorn of its collectivist illusions, cannot be dismantled in six years, what evidence is there that twelve years will be any better?&equo; 
 The paper claimed that the government had failed to make more progress in changing attitudes because so many beneficiaries of the tax state were opinionformers and hostile to the government's goals and to free enterprise. 
 The beneficiaries included teachers in higher education, bureaucrats, trade union leaders, welfare organizers, and leaders of public corporations. 
 Critics pointed to the government's fear of losing votes among middle-class interests and to the power of particular lobbies. 
 According to a disappointed editorial in The Economist  (15 June 1985) history would judge the Thatcher government as only an averagely wet Tory administration'. 
 The Times  again complained about the government's loss of radical purpose. 
 In an editorial on 2 November 1985, headlined &bquo;Unfinished Business&equo;, it asked &bquo;whether the structures and institutions of British life have been so shaken by six years of Mrs Thatcher that they can no longer fall back into their old ways &mdash; or whether more shaking is needed?&equo; 
 It answered: &bquo;More shaking is still needed&equo;. 
 This view was shared by most of the lobbies and opinion-forming groups discussed in Chapters 3 and 4. 
 Their view was that the government lacked a clear strategy in its second term. 
 By May 1989, however, many of these critics had come round to praise the continued radicalism of the Thatcher government, in education, tax cuts, and further measures of privatization.  
 An International Shift 
 Many of the trends in British politics in the 1980s have had counterparts in other western states. 
 From the mid-1970s the slow-down in economic growth and rising inflation sapped the confidence of policy-makers in demand management. 
 Strict control of the money supply seemed to be linked to low rates of inflation in Switzerland and West Germany. 
 As many western states simultaneously suffered sharp increases in levels of unemployment and prices, concern grew over the growing costs of government welfare programmes, many of which were linked by statute to changes in price levels. 
 The overall cost of welfare programmes in Western Europe was rising by an average of 7 per cent per annum in the 1970s, while the economy was growing by an average of 3.5 per cent. 
 Double-digit inflation and the growth in the costs of public policy at a rate faster than that of the economy posed obvious problems. 
 The success in California of Proposition 13 in 1978 was paralleled by similar tax backlash movements in Denmark and the swing to the political right in Britain, Sweden, and Norway. 
 Not surprisingly the above trends have raised greater electoral and ideological difficulties for the political parties of the left. 
 Parties associated with policies of increasing taxation and growing public expenditure appeared to be less popular at the ballot box. 
 Many of the political values and supporters (particularly public-sector workers and welfare lobbies) of left-wing parties have favoured public spending and looked to governments as problem-solvers. 
 However policy-makers' overriding concern with inflation and the calculations about likely reactions of financial markets to inflation-risking economic policies (notably in Britain in 1976, France in 1982 &mdash; 3, and Australia in 1984) have forced advocates of state spending on to the defensive. 
 Policies of economic redistribution to the less well off met with resistance from skilled workers at a time of low economic growth. 
 A problem for many parties of the left in the era of slow growth was to reconcile high public spending and greater social and economic equality with the reluctance of many workers to pay heavier taxes. 
 In Britain, West Germany, and Scandinavia in the 1970s there was a steady reduction in working-class support for parties of the left.  
 Politically there has been a shift to, or confirmation of, right-dominated governments for much of the 1980s in West Germany, Britain, USA, Denmark, the Netherlands, Belgium, Canada, and Japan. 
 In the United States the long dominant Democratic New Deal electoral coalition, which Franklin Roosevelt created out of the white south and the industrial working-class, has been in retreat. 
 The Democratic party has won the presidency only once out of the last six elections since 1964. 
 The nomination of weak candidates has been a factor. 
 But the party has also lost out because of the salience of race (which encouraged the white south to defect to the Republicans), embourgeoisement of the working class, and the Social Issue (concern about the rise of the anti-Vietnam war protest movement in the 1970s and the assertiveness and challenges to traditional values by various minority groups). 
 President Reagan, like Margaret Thatcher, was a product of the concern in the 1970s over the economy, big spending programmes, social indiscipline, and, for the USA, military decline. 
 It was Reagan, but it could have been Thatcher, who said in 1981, &bquo;Government is not the solution to our problems. 
 Government is the problem.&equo; 
 The litany of tax reductions, spending cuts, high defence spending, and, until the advent of Mr Gorbachev, anti-Soviet rhetoric, dominated Reagan's (and Thatcher's) administration. 
 In Denmark the normal pattern of Social Democratic government was disturbed by the emergence in 1982 of a four-party centre-right coalition, headed by a Conservative Prime Minister &mdash; the first since 1905. 
 In Norway the multi-party system was further fragmented by the 1972 referendum on Norway's membership of the European Community. 
 Since 1973 there has been a steady increase in electoral support for the Conservative party which dominated centre-right coalition governments in the early 1980s. 
 In Sweden the Social Democrats were ousted from power in 1976 after forty-five years in office by an alliance of &bquo;bourgeois&equo; parties, although they returned to office in 1982. 
 Yet the ideas of deregulation, limits to taxation, and budget-cutting have been accepted even by governments of the left in France, Spain, Australia, and New Zealand. 
 Perhaps the most dramatic reactions against central state planning and a willingness to experiment with market forces have been seen  in China, the USSR, Poland, and Hungary. 
 By the end of the 1980s central economic planning was in retreat, even in its heartland. 
 It is possible to discern some international trends in economic policy. 
 One has been a pursuit of &bquo;prudent&equo; finance and curbing inflation. 
 The new package includes cutting income taxes, particularly the high marginal rates, containing public spending, &bquo;privatizing&equo; state assets (although Britain has gone further than any other state in this) and reducing loss-making activities among state enterprises. 
 In Austria there have been sales by the holding company for state companies, Obesterreichissche Industrien, and in Sweden also. 
 The socialist government in Spain has partly privatized state industries, including Iberia Airlines. 
 In France there has been partial privatization of banking, industrial, and insurance groups. 
 Another plank has been the encouragement of the private sector by deregulation (particularly in Britain and the United States), especially in transport, tax deductions for investment, and packages of incentives for small business. 
 As in Britain this qualified support for the free market has been accompanied by measures for a stronger stance in defence and law and order (which have increased their shares in public spending in most Western European states). 
 A final trend has been the attempt to contain the growth in welfare and social security spending. 
 Social security accounts for about a third of total public spending in most western states. 
 It has been an obvious target for economy-minded governments. 
 For example, Norway imposed a freeze on social security benefits and West Germany made all student grants repayable to the government, increased contributions to pension and sickness benefit, and delayed rises in pensions. 
 Denmark has made cuts in employment and sickness benefits and France required hospital patients to contribute towards non-medical services and uprated welfare benefits in line with current inflation rather than the higher level of the previous year. 
 Governments everywhere have tried to educate voters about the dilemma of the tax burden and state spending. 
 In spite of such cuts total social security spending continued to increase as a proportion of GDP &mdash; by an average of 5 per cent in real terms &mdash; in OECD states between 1975 and 1985. 
 For all  the talk of a tax backlash and attempts to cut state spending on welfare the irony is that both are now higher as shares of GDP in all OECD states compared with 1975 or 1980. 
 Some of the rise has been prompted by the increased unemployment and rising pension and health demands of the growing army of the over-65s. 
 Perhaps the main achievement of the political right has been to slow down the rate of growth in public spending and to identify some of it as &bquo;wasteful&equo;. 
 Tax cutting may also have passed its peak. 
 In Norway and Denmark electoral support for anti-tax parties has declined, while opinion surveys in the United States and Britain show that tax-cutting has become a minority cause, compared to support for spending on social programmes. 
 Since 1978 most tax-cutting referendums in the United States have been defeated. 
 There has been a general shift to less visible forms of taxation such as payroll (or national insurance) and indirect taxes. 
 As in the case of Britain one has to tread carefully in arguing that public opinion has moved to the right in other states in the past decade. 
 In spite of the overwhelming popularity of Ronald Reagan, surveys show that the American public consistently refused to support many of his programmes. 
 On social and moral issues, such as school prayers, the Equal Rights Amendment (for women), and abortion, the &bquo;hard&equo; positions of Reagan and the Moral Majority were in a minority. 
 The majority of voters also favoured cuts in the defence budget and level or increased Spending on domestic education and health programmes. 
 Americans liked Reagan's personality and his handling of the economy and foreign policy, but they did not endorse Reaganism. 
 In Scandinavia the shift to the right has been more complex. 
 In Norway and Denmark there continue to be high levels of popular support for state-provided welfare but there has been a marked and sustained shift against state control and intervention in the economy. 
 In Sweden, however, approval for the welfare and economic interventionist aspects of collectivism has remained high. 
 The broad picture is not dissimilar from the British reaction to Thatcherism. 
 In spite of the shift to the political right there remains widespread support for state-funded programmes in education and health and for those which are targeted at the poor and the old. 
 In other words, there is extensive support in Britain and many other  western states for government welfare and economic programmes which help the &bquo;deserving&equo; poor, and are also thought to be credible and realistic. 
 Opinion surveys show attitudes that run across the old left &mdash; right divide. 
 There is approval ofthe free market for wealth creation and many of the economic policies this entails. 
 But there is also widespread support for state or collective provision of welfare even over tax cuts. 
 The right-wing reaction has been half successful, repudiating Keynes but not Beveridge. 
 It is difficult to assess whether these trends will produce a lasting shift in the middle ground. 
 Will they develop incrementally along existing lines or will there be a change cyclically to something resembling the old consensus? 
 At Present it appears that advocates of big spending programmes, expanding the public sector, inflation-risking policies, and increasing state control over the economy are in a minority. 
 The vocabulary of many young leaders of left-wing parties in Western Europe &mdash; Kinnock, Gonzales, Rocard, Rau &mdash; refers to a &bquo;servant&equo; or &bquo;opportunity&equo; state, dismisses throwing money at problems as a solution, and promises to provide incentives for free enterprise. 
 In debates over the Labour party's policy review in 1989, Mr Kinnock countered complaints from his left wing that he was propping up capitalism with the claim that Labour's task was to make the market work more efficiently and justly. 
 So much for Clause IV. 
 The &bquo;new realism&equo; of the left is more willing to acknowledge the limits of public spending and the need to encourage entrepreneurship. 
 a Changing Party System 
 The 1983 and 1987 general elections were interesting for psephological as well as for political reasons. 
 Despite presiding over large-scale unemployment the Conservatives were returned to office by huge majorities. 
 Although it is already fashionable to explain away the scale of the election successes &mdash; by such factors as the Falklands, Foot, Benn, and an inept Labour campaign in 1983, and prosperity and the disproportional electoral system in 1987 &mdash; the results marked a further stage in the decline of the Labour party. 
 By the next general election (say 1 991) the Conservatives will have been in  office for sixteen of the twenty-one years since 1970. 
 After the 1987 election there was speculation that Britain had moved into an era of one-party politics or a predominantly one-party system. 
 The Conservatives have been a long way ahead of Labour not just in seats (an arbitrary effect of the electoral system) but also in votes. 
 Between 1950 and 1979 neither Labour nor Conservative ever had as much as 55 per cent ofthe combined two-party vote. 
 But in the 1983 and 1987 elections the Conservatives averaged nearly 60 per cent and led Labour by 14.8 per cent and 11.5 per cent of the votes respectively in the two elections. 
 Opposition in Parliament in the 1980s came more effectively from Conservative dissidents and the House of Lords than the Labour party. 
 Not since the 1930s has the party system been so one-sided in Parliament. 
 One must always be wary of extrapolating from present trends to the future in electoral matters, as in others. 
 The 1959 election defeat and the growing embourgeoisement of the working class were thought to spell future electoral ruin for Labour. 
 The conditional projections made in 1969 by David Butler and Donald Stokes about the differential fertility &mdash; death rates between the social classes, combined with the transmission of political loyalties from parents to children &mdash; appeared to make Labour a natural majority party. 
 The first projection was immediately disconfirmed by Labour winning the 1964 and 1966 elections and the second was undone by the 1970 election and has been destroyed by the last three general elections. 
 A telling statistic in a recent election study by Rose and McAllister is that, whereas in 196480 per cent of those who came from homes in which both parents were Labour voters themselves voted for the party, by 1983 the proportion from such backgrounds which still voted Labour had dropped to 45 Per cent.   
 The loss of working-class support for Labour is the outstanding feature of post-war electoral sociology in Britain. 
 The &bquo;new&equo; affluent working class was clearly Conservative in 1983, and was so again in 1987. 
 Ivor Crewe has drawn attention to the political significance of the more important social trends: twice as many manual workers are now in the private sector as in the public sector; there are far more home-owners than council tenants among them, and nearly as many live in the south as in the north and Scotland combined. 
 Moreover, these trends are likely to increase (aided by the Conservative government) as a result of privatization, council house sales, and the growth of home-ownership and the southward drift of population. 
 The &bquo;traditional working class&equo; is Britain's newest minority and it is far too small by itself to elect a Labour government. 
 Few general elections or administrations map out a new agenda. 
 Yet such a change can happen. 
 A different set of policies, perhaps sustained over two or three elections, may force the defeated party to reconsider its strategy if it wants to remain electorally competitive. 
 The adaptation of the Conservative party to the post-war Labour party initiatives is one example. 
 The acceptance of the New Deal by many Republicans in the United States and the adoption of the social market approach and formal abandonment of Marxism by West Germany's Social Democrats are others. 
 In the last two cases, decisive and successive election defeats convinced the party leaders that the centre of electoral opinion had moved away for them. 
 Parties adopt or disavow policies not only to win forthcoming elections but also as a response to past electoral outcomes. 
 An election may also be a realigning one in that it produces a long-term shift in the balance of support between the parties, perhaps installing one as the new majority. 
 The 1983 election, although a significant Conservative success, was not a realigning one, nor one necessarily presaging a long spell of Conservative rule. 
 Prosperity was an important factor for many Conservative voters in 1983 and 1987; such votes are instrumental and conditional. 
 Public opinion, though skewed to the right on many issues, has not moved further right between 1979 and 1989, and may actually have moved in a contrary direction. 
 The proportion of voters identifying with the Conservative  party is about the same as in 1964 (although Labour's fall has been steep) and the party's share of the vote in 1983 and 1987 was actually slightly less than in 1979. 
 It profited handsomely from the division of the non-Conservative vote between Labour and Alliance, and from the exaggerating effects of the British electoral system; compared to 1979, a decline of 1.5 per cent in share of the vote had produced a trebling of the government's overall majority in seats from 44 to 144 in 1983 and to 100 in 1987. 
 The 1980s has been a decade of three-party politics. 
 The emergence of the Alliance posed the most formidable third-party challenge to the Labour/Conservative duopoly since the multi-partyism of the 1920s. 
 Indeed the distribution of votes across the three parties in 1983 bears a striking resemblance to the elections of 1923 and of 1929 (Table 10.4). 
 Talk of a realignment on the centre-left of the spectrum has a long history. 
 It seemed more credible in the 1980s with the emergence of the Alliance and Labour's electoral collapse. 
 The widespread agreement across the electorate on many issues increases the possibilities for voters to shop around the political parties, as well as for the political parties to attract voters who are not traditional supporters. 
 The electoral system has been a barrier to realignment. 
 Labour in the north of Britain and the Conservatives in the south have so many safe seats that they can suffer a loss of popular votes without this being translated into an equivalent loss of seats. 
 The proportions differed only slightly in the 1987 general election. 
 In 1983 the Conservatives gained 85 per cent of the seats in Southern England for 50 per cent of the votes, Labour 55 per cent of the seats in Northern England for 37 per cent of the vote. 
 The Alliance had no such electoral stronghold. 
 Surveys showed that its support, like that for the Liberals, was diffuse but shallow and lacked distinctive issue bases or social constituencies, apart from a following in the well-educated professional groups. 
 Mr Kinnock, however, has moved Labour back to the centre and since 1987 the two former Alliance parties have been in disarray. 
 For all the turbulence and excitement that erupted with the Gang of Four's break with Labour in 1981, Britain looked as much a two-party system at the end of the decade as it did in 1980. 
 The Alliance route to a realignment of the party  system is dead. 
 The great opportunity for Labour is that it will again be the main repository of anti-Conservative votes. 
 The significant electoral battleground in the future is likely to be the middle class or non-manual working class, simply because of its size. 
 Even if at the next general election Labour does better than ever before in attracting working-class support, say 80 per cent of the working class, it still would not have a majority of the vote. 
 Labour's problem is that its core constituency in the manual working class has steadily declined over the years. 
 The growth of private home-ownership and car-ownership, reduction in the number of voters dependent on council housing, expansion of self-employment (up from 1.9 million to 3 million between 1979 and 1989) and of employment in the private sector, and a fall in the public-sector employment, may also work against the party. 
 The Conservative government has not of course been passive in the process of restructuring the social bases of electoral choice. 
 Between 1979 and 1989 the reduction in public-sector employment, extension of private home-ownership (up from 55 per cent to 65 per cent) and share-ownership (up from 7 per cent to 22 per cent), increasing scope for private provision of services, and run-down of trade union membership (down from 54 per cent to 46 per cent of the workforce) have all been government objectives. 
 None of these trends in social and economic structure and party identification mean that Labour can never win again, nor that the Conservatives are sure to win. 
 Research suggests that many manual workers who have bought shares in the privatized firms and industries or purchased council houses were already Conservative voters. 
 But in so far as such voters may have their partisanship reinforced the trends do present a major hurdle to the election of a Labour government. 
 Comparison with the fortunes of the left in Western Europe are encouraging for Labour, but also chastening. 
 In the recessionary 1970s, most governments were turned out at elections or saw their share of electoral support fall. 
 The misery index (the combined percentages of unemployment and inflation) reached new heights. 
 Although there has been some shift in the 1980s to the political right in the United States and West Germany, the socialist share of the vote has hardly changed over the two decades in Austria, Scandinavia, West Germany,  and Italy. 
 It has increased substantially in France and Spain, and Labour governments have been re-elected in New Zealand and Australia. 
 Only in Britain has the fall in popular support for the left been substantial. 
 Indeed the scale of decline for such a major party is virtually unparalleled in any other state in post-war Western Europe. 
 The good news for Labour from a comparative survey is that such features as wider home ownership, affluence, and the embourgeoisement  of the working class are not necessarily electorally adverse. 
 Political behaviour is not shaped exclusively by social forces. 
 Democratic socialist parties can still thrive in prosperous societies as the examples of Sweden and France prove. 
 It is worth adding that, compared to some other socialist parties, Labour has not been handicapped by the opposition or suspicion of a powerful Catholic Church (as in some Western European states), or divided by a powerful Communist movement in party politics and in trade unions (as in France and Italy). 
 Moreover, because of the first-past-the-post electoral system and the predominantly two-party system, it has been one of the few parties of the left able to form a government on its own. 
 Elsewhere socialist parties have had to compete in multiparty and proportional electoral systems and usually share power in government. 
 The question that such analysis then suggests is: why has Labour done so badly? 
 Perhaps other parties, simply because they have lacked the British Labour party's advantages, have necessarily had to be more adaptable and willing to make alliances. 
 Left governments in Australia, New Zealand, France, and Spain have pursued a series of economic and social policies that are not dissimilar from those that Mrs Thatcher's government has pursued since 1979. 
 Conclusion 
 The rhetoric of party politics, particularly at election time, is often adversarial and absolutist in tone. 
 The introduction of new men and new women promises a new beginning. 
 Edward Heath, in his first speech to a Conservative party conference as Prime Minister in 1970, claimed: &bquo;We were returned to office to change the course and the history of this nation &mdash; nothing less.&equo; 
 In each election manifesto between 1970 and 1983, Labour  promised a &bquo;fundamental and irreversible shift in the balance of power and wealth to working people&equo;. 
 In a foreword to the 1979 Conservative election manifesto, Mrs Thatcher suggested that the election might be the last chance voters had to reverse the extension of state power at the expense of the individual. 
 In 1983 she spoke of the general election providing a &bquo;choice&equo; between two ways of life; before the 1987 election she spoke of the election as the opportunity to &bquo;kill off&equo; left-wing socialism. 
 The controversy surrounding the overall record of the Thatcher administration suggests that it has had a major impact. 
 On the political left, the government is regularly reviled for running down the welfare state, smashing the trade unions, and waging class war. 
 &bquo;The most reactionary government this century&equo; is merely a mild form of left-wing rhetoric. 
 Some of Mrs Thatcher's &bquo;cheerleaders&equo; in the party and popular press see her as having achieved a virtual revolution in British politics, restoring the authority of government, putting the trade unions in their place, taming a greedy and parasitic public sector, and regaining a greater freedom of choice for people in many areas. 
 The case of the 1979 &mdash; 83 administration seems to support Richard Rose s claims about the weakness of party government. 
 The gloomy trends of macro-economic indicators of economic growth, inflation, unemployment, and public spending over the period were in line with those for earlier governments. 
 Such factors, however, are only partly under the control of government. 
 The significant discontinuities elsewhere support the thesis of adversary politics. 
 These include the reduction in the legal immunities and rights of trade unions, rejection of formal incomes policy, and the tripartite style of decisionmaking, according priority to the abatement of inflation, even with unemployment at over three million, privatization of state industries and services, changes in the framework in which many public services are carried out, interventions in local government structure and imposition of far-reaching controls over its finance, changes in the welfare state, and open hostility to the civil service and large parts of the public sector. 
 The government has challenged many of the assumptions of several participants and commentators on British politics.  
 The more one looks back on the record the more one is impressed by the role of Mrs Thatcher as a dominant figure and as an illustration of the power of the Prime Minister. 
 Chapter 3 explored the various critiques of social democratic values and policies and the suggested policy alternatives. 
 The critiques and the alternative policies found an audience because of a number of worrying developments in the mid-1970s (Chapter 5), independently of the campaigns of Sir Keith Joseph and Mrs Thatcher. 
 We are not claiming that personal leadership is all important but rather that Mrs Thatcher's personality and policies enabled her to take advantage of the constellation of events and ideas. 
 This is the more remarkable in view of the lukewarm support some of the policies have had in the Cabinet and party. 
 Over time she has retained her ideological commitment, and the shortcomings as well as the successes of her government record are invoked by her as reasons to press on with the original strategy. 
 She has clearly set a lead in a number of areas, pushing radical ideas and reforms (see Chapter 9). 
 Although the discontinuity in economic policy from the Heath Cabinet (1972 &mdash; 4) is remarkable, there has been only one dissenting resignation from her Cabinet, partly on grounds of her style as well as policy (that of Mr Heseltine over Westland in January 1986). 
 Previous great reforming administrations &mdash; notably the Liberals (1906) and Labour (1945) &mdash; did not retain their parliamentary majorities for long. 
 Both had been returned by huge majorities, having long been out of office. 
 Both rapidly alienated many groups and the Liberal majority was extinguished by 1910 and Labour's by 1951. 
 Most British governments have been worn down by failures (particularly economic), scandals, lack of purpose, and electoral boredom. 
 Mrs Thatcher's governments have not only won elections but retained their drive. 
 Mrs Thatcher still tells interviewers and staff that &bquo;There is much more to do&equo;. 
 If there is a time to sew and a time to reap, the latter has not yet arrived. 
 But radical governments depend in large measure on opportunities &mdash; for example, an inept political opposition or a crisis &mdash; and have to catch a mood. 
 In due course, they will suffer from the mood of &bquo;time for a change&equo;, either to consolidate or reverse policies, or from the rise of new issues. 
 The impact of the  Thatcher years can only be fully assessed in the future. 
 What is clear, however, is that she dominated the content and style of British politics in the 1980s and shaped the politics of the post-Thatcher era.  
 Vernon Bogdanor Brasenose College, Oxford  
 1931 Revisited: The Constitutional Aspects 
 Reginald Bassett's 1931: Political Crisis , published in 1958, was the first attempt to look at the events of 1931 free from contemporary preconceptions. 
 An anonymous reviewer of the book in the Times Literary Supplement  declared: &bquo;If a student of British politics were to demand some precepts to guide his researches, the compiler would have little difficulty about the first and most significant maxim in the creed. 
 For surely it is true that whosoever will understand British politics before all things it is necessary that he comprehend the events of 1931.' 
 But today, over thirty years after Bassett's book appeared, is there anything new to say about 1931? 
 At that time there were hardly any scholarly accounts of the period in question. 
 The only really important biography was that of George V by Harold Nicolson, which had been published in 1952; the more recent biography by Kenneth Rose adds hardly anything to it. 
 Yet, as I shall try to show, Nicolson's account is far too discreet, and obscures some of the most important features of the crisis. 
 Since Bassett's book was published, biographies of most of the main protagonists have appeared: but, with one exception, they shed much less light on the crisis than might have been imagined. 
 The exception is David Marquand's splendid biography of Ramsay MacDonald, which is at its best when dealing with 1931. 
 Indeed, Marquand gives us perhaps as much detail about the events of August-October 1931 as we are ever likely to need.  
 There are a number of biographies of Stanley Baldwin, the Conservative leader; but none of them really casts much light on his attitude to the crisis. 
 The same is true of the various biographies of Lloyd George &mdash; although, no doubt, when John Grigg's multi-volume Life reaches 1931 it will illuminate much that has hitherto remained obscure; likewise, in the case of Lloyd George's great enemy, Neville Chamberlain, we have to await the completion of David Dilks's biography. 
 Professor Bernard Wasserstein of Brandeis University is shortly to publish a new biography of Herbert Samuel, who was, in effect, leader of the Liberal party for the crucial months of 1931, during Lloyd George's illness, and a central figure in the crisis. 
 A more detailed life of Lord Reading, Liberal leader in the House of Lords and an important actor in the events of 1931, would be of great value. 
 A thorough and detailed biography of Arthur Henderson is also badly needed; the recent short studies by F. M. Leventhal and Chris Wrigley add little, at least in so far as the events of 1931 are concerned. 
 There is, however, a valuable article by Andrew Thorpe on Henderson's attitude to the crisis. 
 More has been written on the party history of the period. 
 There is Robert Skidelsky's history of the second Labour government and Stuart Ball's excellent account of the Conservative party in opposition, a book which casts an enormous amount of light on the inner life of the party. 
 There is no equivalent history of the Liberal party during this period. 
 The three main works &mdash; by Trevor Wilson, Roy Douglas, and Chris Cook &mdash; are all rather slight when they come to tackle the complexities of the Liberal attitude during the crisis. 
 There is however, an excellent Cambridge Ph.D. 
 thesis by Philip Williamson. 
 But even these valuable works share one major deficiency. 
 They tend to conclude their account with the formation of the National Government, giving ensuing events &mdash; in particular, the decision of the National Government to go to the country as a National Government &mdash; fairly perfunctory treatment; and this despite the fact that, as Ball rightly claims, &bquo;The radical restructuring of British politics after 1931 lies not in the events of 13&ndash;28 August, but in the changing attitudes within the National Government   during September and October 1931.' 
 D. J. Wrench is one of the few to have considered in any detail what happened after the National Government was formed. 
 Yet the really important decisions, affecting the whole shape of politics in the 1930s, were those made in September and October 1931; it was these decisions, and not the formation of the National Government itself, which were to determine the configuration of party politics for the rest of the decade. 
 Even beyond these deficiencies in the existing literature, there remain two large gaps to be filled. 
 The first calls for psephological analysis, using modern statistical techniques, of the 1931 general election. 
 In 1958, Reginald Bassett lamented the fact &bquo;that no study of the General Election of 1931 was made at the time on the lines of the extremely useful studies of the 1945 and subsequent General Elections sponsored by Nuffield College&equo;. 
 There is at present only one study, and that unpublished. 
 The second and more important lack is that of any real constitutional analysis of the crisis. 
 The virtual demise of modern constitutional history as a subject of study has meant that there has been hardly any analysis of the major constitutional questions which arise out of the crisis &mdash; what role did the king play, what are the relative rights of the Prime Minister vis-&agrave;-vis  his Cabinet, what is the relative importance of party and of the &bquo;national interest&equo;, and what justification can there be for a peacetime coalition government? 
 The first step towards understanding the crisis of 1931 is to distinguish between different types of coalition government. 
 This is not easy to do since most historians persist in speaking of &bquo; The  National Government&equo; as if the same sort of government ruled from 1931 to 1940. 
 Yet this is quite erroneous. 
 The historian should distinguish between three different types of coalition government, or three National Governments. 
 The first National Government, the government which forms the focal point of most historical writing on the crisis, followed the collapse of the Labour government in August 1931. 
 It was conceived of by all those who participated in it not as a coalition government as generally understood, but as a temporary, emergency government, formed for a single limited  purpose: to balance the budget through drastic economies and increases in taxation. 
 In October, however, the National Government decided to appeal to the country as a National Government, and the second National Government which followed the election was a very different animal. 
 It was a genuine, albeit unbalanced, coalition between separate political elements, in particular between the Conservatives and their allies, the National Labour party and the Simonite Liberal Nationals, and the Liberal party, led by Sir Herbert Samuel. 
 The third National Government followed upon the resignation of the Liberal ministers and of the free trader, Snowden, in September 1932, after which it became little more than a Conservative government, with the adhesion of a few ex-Labour and Liberal politicians, all owing their seats to an electoral pact with the Conservatives. 
 It was this government which ruled Britain until May 1940, when yet another coalition, led by Churchill &mdash; a genuine all-party coalition &mdash; governed Britain until 1945, when there was a return to party politics and alternating governments. 
 The first National Government was not intended to be a coalition government in the normal sense of the term. 
 It was something very rarely seen in Britain, or in other democracies: an emergency government &mdash; or, in Hoare's words, &bquo;an emergency Committee of public Safety&equo;, formed for a specific purpose, and intended to last for a specific period of time. 
 It was clearly proposed not as a permanent arrangement, but as a temporary measure of co-operation between different individuals, who, it was hoped, would be supported by their parties. 
 The second National Government, by contrast, resulted from a general election in which it had inflicted a massive defeat on the Labour party. 
 It was clearly not an all-party government, yet, until September 1932 at least, it was something more than a mere Conservative front. 
 True, the Liberal Nationals were becoming indistinguishable from the Conservatives, while National Labour was too small to be able to exert very much influence upon the massed ranks of Conservatives, although the prestige of the Prime Minister, Ramsay MacDonald, gave it &mdash; as Marquand shows &mdash; an influence far greater than its mere numbers would have warranted. 
 The sole genuinely non-Conservative and independent element in the government was the Liberals, led by Sir Herbert Samuel. 
 A party supporting the government, yet differing from most of the other members of it in one specific particular: its opposition to the tariff. 
 This conflict between tariff reformers and free traders was to lead to the &bquo;agreement to differ&equo; convention in January 1932, and the resignation of the Liberals from the government in September 1932; but, until they resigned, the National Government was a  genuine coalition in the sense in which that term is used on the continent: a government comprising independent yet conflicting elements allied together, a government within which party conflict was not superseded but rather contained &mdash; in short, a power-sharing government, albeit a seriously unbalanced one. 
 The third National Government, after the resignation of the Liberal ministers, was hardly a coalition &mdash; although again Marquand shows that the non-Conservatives retained more influence upon it than their numbers alone would suggest. 
 Yet these non-Conservative elements &mdash; the Liberal Nationals and National Labour &mdash; were becoming more and more adjuncts to the Conservative party, and they owed their seats entirely to the willingness of the Conservatives not to oppose them in the constituencies. 
 The attempt to build up a separate National Labour Party proved a dismal failure, while the Liberal Nationals continued as pensioners of the Conservative party until finally merging with them &mdash; as the Liberal Unionists had done previously &mdash; in 1966. 
 This third National Government, like the Conservative-Liberal Unionist coalition of 1895&ndash;1905, was the type of coalition government with which British history is much more familiar: a coalition between one major party and a fragment from another which has broken off because it disagrees with one of its parent party's central tenets &mdash; in 1886 Home Rule, in 1931 unwillingness to reduce unemployment benefit on the part of Labour and unwillingness to tamper with free trade in the case of the Liberals. 
 The third National Government was not a power-sharing coalition, but a coalition which led to party fusion. 
 The reason why so many books and articles on the 1931 crisis end with the formation of the first National Government is that their authors are still obsessed by the time-worn and stale debates about Ramsay MacDonald's supposed &bquo;betrayal&equo; of Labour, about a hypothetical &bquo;plot&equo;, and about the &bquo;bankers&equo; ramp'. 
 Hardly any of the studies of the crisis go on to consider why the National Government broke the specific pledges upon which it had been formed and went to the country as a government in an election which bore some considerable resemblance to the &bquo;coupon election&equo; of 1918. 
 And yet it was the second National Government, not the first, which really determined the politics of the 1930s. 
 Had the National Government stuck to its professed intentions and dissolved, after about six weeks, into its component parts, with the ensuing general election bring fought by the parties, the political landscape might not have been changed as much as in fact it was. 
 It seems important, therefore, to try to establish how the decision to fight the election came about. 
 For it was the general election of 1931 which so drastically altered the balance of parties in the House of Commons as to give the politics of the 1930s its special character. 
 This article analyses the constitutional aspects behind the formation of the first and second National Governments, examining in particular the role  of the king in the formation of the two governments &mdash; a role which, as will be seen, was rather more important than is usually thought. 
 The key to the formation of the first National Government lies in the parliamentary arithmetic facing the second Labour government as it sought to implement its programme of economies in August 1931. 
 Labour was the largest party with 288 MPs; the Conservatives, who had gained more votes than Labour in the 1929 general election, were, nevertheless, only the second largest party with, by 1931, 262 MPs; and the Liberals had fifty-nine MPs. 
 There were a further ten independents and five MPs who owed allegiance to Sir Oswald Mosley's short-lived New party, formed after Mosley's defection from Labour in February 1931. 
 It followed, therefore, that if the Labour Government was to secure acceptance of its economic package, it had to secure the support of MPs from either the Liberal or the Conservative party. 
 This obvious feature of the parliamentary arithmetic is ignored by many writers on the 1931 crisis. 
 They consider, sometimes in fairly abstract terms, the kinds of policies which Labour might have adopted, without asking whether such policies had any chance of securing parliamentary support. 
 A policy of Keynesian expansion, for example, whatever its merits, had no chance whatever of gaining majority support in the conditions of August 1931. 
 Nor would adoption of a tariff obviate the need for economies, given that the Conservatives insisted upon severe retrenchment, whether combined with a tariff or not. 
 The Labour Cabinet was, it is clear, united in its view that the budget had to be balanced. 
 What it could not agree on was how  the budget was to be balanced; and it was this disagreement that led to the break-up of the government. 
 It is sometimes said that the dissident minority in the Cabinet, led by Henderson, were not willing to accept cuts in unemployment benefit. 
 That is not strictly true. 
 They were willing to accept a cut in transitional benefit which would have had the effect of &bquo;throwing at least some of those receiving transitional benefit upon public assistance&equo;, while Henderson pressed hard for a &bquo;premium&equo;, a flat deduction of 1s. a week from all unemployment benefits. 
 What the dissidents objected to was a cut in the standard rate of benefit. 
 The whole Cabinet agreed that there should be a cut in the amount that the unemployed were receiving; where they disagreed was in whether this should include a cut in the standard rate of benefit. 
 The opposition parties, however, were unwilling to accept any programme of economies which did not involve a cut in the standard rate of  benefit. 
 As the Labour dissidents in the Cabinet recognized, they did not have the power &mdash; they were a minority in the Cabinet as well as in the Commons &mdash; to avoid such a cut; all that they could do was to ensure that it was not a Labour  government which imposed it. 
 Those commentators who blame Labour for not pursuing an alternative set of more socially just proposals in the conditions of August 1931 ought rather to blame the electorate for not giving Labour sufficient support to form a majority government in 1929. 
 In a minority situation, some form of power-sharing &mdash; even if it did not necessarily involve coalition &mdash; was inevitable. 
 Parliamentary arithmetic dictated, therefore, that Labour would have to produce a package which was acceptable to at least one of the opposition parties. 
 This the Cabinet was unable to achieve. 
 The question then arose of what alternative government was available. 
 Such a government had to be able to carry a programme of economies through the House of Commons: this immediately ruled out the possibility of a Labour minority government led by Henderson, as suggested by Moodie in an otherwise illuminating article. 
 It was quite clear that Henderson, the leader of the dissident minority in the Cabinet, had no chance whatever of producing a programme which could secure the support of a Commons majority. 
 If, therefore, the King had turned to Henderson after MacDonald had proffered his resignation, or had sought the views of Labour Privy Counsellors as suggested by Herbert Morrison, he could have been accused of wasting valuable time. 
 In the existing conditions of financial crisis, it was essential for a government to be formed which could ensure a parliamentary majority in support of the economy measures so that they could pass the Commons. 
 Without some grasp of this basic requirement it is impossible to understand what followed. 
 How, then, did the first National Government come about? 
 No serious historian today accepts the theory that it was the result of a plot or conspiracy; almost all agree that it followed, almost by accident rather than design, from the confused events of 19&ndash;24 August. 
 Nevertheless, the idea of a National Government had been in the air for some time before its actual formation. 
 There were, broadly, two interrelated reasons for this, the first relating to Britain's economic and Imperial difficulties, the second to the internal dissension in all three parties, a symptom perhaps of the need for a realignment of political parties. 
 The serious economic problems facing Britain following the slump of 1929, and the seeming inability of any one  party to offer a way out, together with the parliamentary deadlock, led many to ask whether a combination of like-minded politicians from different parties might not prove better suited to resolving Britain's problems than any single-party government. 
 The idea of a National Government, as Philip Williamson shows in his thesis, was common currency among businessmen and opinion-formers well before the financial crisis of August 1931; furthermore, one of those most sympathetic to the call for a National Government was the King. 
 In October 1930, ten months before the first National Government was formed, Sir Arthur Balfour, an industrialist and a member of the Economic Advisory Council, wrote to Ramsay MacDonald, saying that he had been forced to the conclusion: That our industrial and commercial economic situation is steadily deteriorating and if this continues, in a few months time, we shall be on the verge of a debacle. 
 The steps which will have to be taken are, in my view, so grave, that it becomes a question whether any one party can carry them through, and whether some form of Coalition Government is not imperative to meet the crisis which is rapidly developing. 
 Balfour called for drastic economies, to include a reduction in unemployment benefit and the imposition of a revenue tariff on manufactured goods. 
 He concluded by stating that he had been &bquo;compelled to trench on political questions as well as economic &mdash; because I feel we are approaching a situation that is so grave that it compares with the War, when we were compelled to act together in self-defence&equo;. 
 The King's Private Secretary, Lord Stamfordham, wrote to MacDonald to say that the King was &bquo;profoundly impressed with Sir Arthur Balfour's letter to you &mdash; his review of the critical condition of affairs will, in His Majesty's opinion, bring home to his Ministers that the time has come when even emergency measures may be necessary in order to avert a calamity which, as Sir Arthur Balfour states, is not altogether incompatible with that of the Great War. 
 It was on the King's suggestion to MacDonald that the Cabinet considered including in the Speech from the Throne in October 1930 a plea to &bquo;all sections of parliament&equo; to &bquo;unite&equo; in treating unemployment &bquo;on national as distinct from party lines&equo;. 
 Another proponent of a National Government was Major-General Jack Seely, a former Liberal minister. 
 In October and December 1930 he held two  dinners to promote the idea, the guests including Ramsay MacDonald, Lloyd George, Lord Reading, Winston Churchill, and Sir Robert Horne. 
 At the first dinner, on 29 October, a letter, prepared by Seely, was read out. 
 It began: &bquo;I can imagine a wise and well-informed man, quite aloof from any political party, saying to our little gathering: &bquo;The Country and the Empire are in three tangles, which the ordinary process of disputation followed by a General Election in this country cannot unravel.&equo; 
 The first tangle was the economy. 
 To cut the dole was, in Seely's view, essential, but &bquo;this tangle cannot be unravelled by any one party, or even any two, because if opposed by the third they would lose the Election and the evil would continue.&equo; 
 The second tangle lay in Imperial economics. 
 A majority for Imperial preference in a general election would be of little use from the Dominion point of view, since it was &bquo;obvious that the whole system might be capsized in a year or two. 
 As a consequence, whatever the result the Dominions would be disappointed and disgruntled. 
 They would say, not without truth, &bquo;Britain claims to be head of the Empire, but cannot make up her own mind.&equo; 
 The third and final tangle was India. 
 &bquo;Here again a General Election in this Country, with the solution of the Indian problem as an issue, would settle nothing. 
 A small majority either way would encourage the discontented elements to further disorder.&equo; 
 &equo; Be it observed, therefore,&equo; Seely concluded his diagnosis, &bquo;that in these three vital matters, which taken together create an emergency greater than any through which this country has passed for centuries, no solution can be found unless all three parties combine to solve them.&equo; 
 Seely's solutions were, in fact, not too dissimilar from those eventually adopted by the National Government &mdash; a cut in the dole with acceptance of the principle of work or maintenance, a 10 per cent revenue tariff, and settlement of the Indian question on the lines of the Simon Commission. 
 Before this dinner took place, Seely sent a copy of his letter to the King. 
 The reply, from Stamfordham, said that the letter had been forwarded to the Sovereign, &bquo;but added on his own account &bquo;I wish you every success in your efforts.' 
 Shortly afterwards, in March 1931, Stamfordham died. 
 His successor was Sir Clive Wigram, who in June 1931 attended another dinner, this time given by a South African millionaire, Sir Abe Bailey, to promote the National Government conception. 
 Among the other guests were again MacDonald and Churchill, now joined by Leo Amery and Herbert Samuel. 
 In August 1931, Wigram wrote to Sir Horace Rumbold, the British Ambassador to Germany, regretting that  no single Party is going to face the music of reducing wages and cutting down the dole. 
 What we require is a National Emergency Government, but no two men I meet can agree how this can be formed. 
 Neither Ramsay MacDonald nor Baldwin will agree to serve under the other. 
 Lloyd George is out of the running for some time and I suppose Herbert Samuel will act as leader in the House of Commons. 
 A neutral head of proved ability who would command the confidence of the Nation is hard to find. 
 On 11 July 1931, with financial crisis looming as the value of the German mark threatened to collapse, Wigram wrote to the King: 
 If a crash comes in Germany we shall have a financial situation something like that at the outbreak of war, and there will be a demand for a moratorium all round. 
 A Minority Government will hardly be able to deal with the situation, and it is quite possible that Your Majesty might be asked to approve of a National Government. 
 The idea of a National Government, then, had implanted itself in the mind of the King, and in that of his closest adviser, as a possible solution to the economic crisis which many felt to be imminent. 
 But it was in the air for a second reason also: for one striking feature of the years 1929&ndash;31 was that all three parties were deeply divided. 
 Indeed, the divisions within the parties were arguably more fundamental than those between them. 
 &bquo;The internal dissension in the three parties,&equo; wrote Beatrice Webb in her diary, &bquo;each party finding its bitterest enemies among its own members or ci-devant  members, would be ludicrous if it were not a sinister symptom of the decadent disrupture of British public opinion, owing to lack of faith either in the present order or in any consistent and comprehensive principles of reconstruction.' 
 The Labour government found itself under pressure from three directions: from the left wing, largely concentrated in the ILP; from the TUC, which, under the leadership of Citrine and Bevin, was coming to a new view of the causes of unemployment, one based upon the writings of John Maynard Keynes; and from Sir Oswald Mosley and his supporters. 
 Of the three, the TUC was to prove the most serious challenge to the government's chances of survival. 
 The Conservatives. 
 too, found themselves split after their unexpected defeat in 1929, and Baldwin's leadership came under severe  attack from no fewer than four different directions. 
 first, there were the press lords, Beaverbrook and Rothermere. 
 To call them swine, Baldwin told Sir Cuthbert Headlam in February 1930, &bquo;was to libel a very decent, clean animal&equo;. 
 Second, and more threatening, there was grass-roots discontent at Baldwin's indolent approach to the tasks of opposition. 
 These two forms of dissent coalesced in the demand for a stronger approach to the Tory nostrum of tariff reform. 
 In addition, trouble threatened from the mercurial figure of Winston Churchill, who had resigned from the Shadow Cabinet in January 1931 in protest at Baldwin's acceptance of eventual self-government for India, an issue which threatened to be an explosive one for the Conservative party, since it allied Churchill to the fourth source of discontent: the Diehard element, also strongly represented amongst the grass roots of the party. 
 The Liberals, also, by August 1931 were beginning to crumble. 
 Lloyd George's attempt to wrest the initiative for his party by a bold espousal of Keynesian economics had failed in the 1929 general election. 
 His strategy of seeking an accommodation with Labour was bitterly opposed by many Liberals. 
 In March 1931, Sir john Simon spoke of socialism as &bquo;a poisonous doctrine&equo; and declared that he would not close his mind to tariffs as a method of dealing with the economic crisis. 
 In June 1931, Simon and two other prominent Liberals resigned the parliamentary whip. 
 It was generally believed that they were proposing to seek an electoral pact with the Conservatives, so as to ensure that they would hold their seats against what was expected to be a Conservative landslide at the next general election. 
 The uncertain nature of political alignments in these years made it inevitable, then, that a National Government would come under serious consideration as a remedy for Britain's ills. 
 Yet, unless a real emergency should occur, it was difficult to see how such a government might be brought about. 
 The idea of a National Government was primarily an idea of the political centre and right: there was hardly any support for it in the Labour party &mdash; except from Mosley, and he was moving rapidly to the right. 
 Nor could leaders of the Conservative party offer active support for the idea, for it implied lack of confidence in the leadership of Baldwin no less than in that of MacDonald. 
 The Conservatives, Baldwin declared in a speech in December 1930, were the true National party, and so those who sought a National Government should support the Conservatives. 
 Besides, a National Government might well involve abandoning the Tory principle of protection, and Baldwin, under pressure from the protectionists, was unwilling to form a government with free traders. 
 In July 1931 he declared that he could not &bquo;work with anyone except on the ground that he believes in the guarding of our home market and the development of our Imperial market  as absolute essentials&equo;. 
 &bquo;I could not help recalling,&equo; Sir Maurice Hankey, the Cabinet Secretary, wrote in his diary in September, &bquo;that on the last day of Parliament Mr. Baldwin had walked across the yard outside &lsqb;the House of Commons&rsqb; and had said &bquo;I will do everything I can to help the Government in making economies, but I will not enter a Coalition Government.' 
 Neville Chamberlain, often regarded as the architect of the National Government, confessed, in July 1931, &bquo;I myself hate the idea and hope it won't come to pass&equo;; nevertheless, he admitted that a National Government might come about as a result of the financial crisis. 
 When the crisis did  occur, however, the first reaction of the Conservative leadership was to ensure that Labour took full responsibility. 
 Coalition, Baldwin told Chamberlain, &bquo;must of course be stamped on&equo;; he went on to say &bquo;that if R.M. did approach him he would reply that there was no occasion for a Coalition. 
 Let R.M. consult him if there was any difficulty and he would support him in any steps necessary for the national interest.' 
 When the crisis broke, Baldwin showed annoyance at having his holiday in France interrupted, and deputed Chamberlain to act for him, giving him full powers but no instructions. 
 From France, Baldwin wrote to Chamberlain: 
 I think in the long view it is all to the good that the government have to look after their own chickens as they come home to roost, and get a lot of the dirt cleared before we come in. 
 To have the consequences of their finance exposed &mdash; and acknowledged before the world &mdash; within four months of their budget will be a wonderful lesson. 
 P.S. We must not forget on the platform that the Liberals are just as responsible as the government for this crisis: indeed more so, for their assistance was voluntary. 
 They have deliberately supported the government (which they were not obliged to do) as being the less of two evils. 
 Thus, despite widespread support for a National Government, there was little idea of how such a government might be brought about; and little support for it among those who really mattered. 
 the party leaders. 
 The idea, indeed, was supported more by those on the fringes of political life than by those at the centre.  
 When the Labour Cabinet, in August 1931, failed to agree on an economy programme, Ramsay MacDonald, in his own words, &bquo;strove hard and took great risks in being responsible for the delay, to keep the Government in, because no National Government of any kind is the sort of thing that I should support of my own free choice.' 
 By Sunday 23 August, however, it was clear that agreement might well not be possible. 
 MacDonald saw the King at 10.30 a.m. and told him, as he recorded in his diary, 
 that after to-night I might be of no further use, &amp; should resign with the whole Cabinet. 
 He asked if I would advise him to send for Henderson, I said &bquo;No&equo;, which he said relieved him. 
 I advised him in the meantime to send for the leaders of the other two parties &amp; have them report position from their points of view. 
 He said he would &amp; would advise them strongly to support me. 
 I explained my hopeless Parlty. position if there were any resignations. 
 He said that he believed I was the only person who could carry the country through. 
 I said that did I share his belief I should not contemplate what I do, but that I did not share it. 
 A number of comments must be made upon this remarkable passage. 
 The first is that, contrary to what is implied in Harold Nicolson's biography, Sir Herbert Samuel, who saw the King shortly after noon, was not the first to make the suggestion that there should be a National Government: the first suggestion came from the King himself. 
 For the King not only told MacDonald that he would see the other party leaders, but said that he &bquo;would advise them strongly to support&equo; him. 
 MacDonald's reply &mdash; &bquo;I explained my hopeless parlty. position if there were any resignations&equo; &mdash; is a clear indication that he found the idea of a National Government distasteful; indeed, that his position was likely to be &bquo;hopeless&equo;. 
 The King, however, undeterred by this, told the Prime Minister that he believed that he was the only person who could carry the country through'. 
 MacDonald's reply, that he did not share that belief, is, again, an indication that he did not wish to remain as Prime Minister if his government collapsed. 
 The King hoped next to see Baldwin, but the Conservative leader could not be found: he was, ironically, lunching with Geoffrey Dawson, the editor of The Times, and discussing Cabinet appointments &mdash; something he found easier to do with Dawson than with his party colleagues. 
 The King therefore saw Samuel before Baldwin; and Samuel gave the advice which the Sovereign wanted to hear, namely that if MacDonald proved unable to carry his Cabinet, the best solution to the crisis would be a National Government, led by MacDonald, &bquo;unless he found that he could not carry  with him a sufficient number of his colleagues&equo;. 
 This significant qualification is omitted by Nicolson. 
 Baldwin finally arrived at the Palace at 3.00 p.m. 
 Instead of being asked, as he must have hoped, whether he would be willing to form a government, he was instead asked whether he would be prepared to serve in a National Government under MacDonald. 
 This was a question to which, for a patriotic Conservative leader, there could be only one answer. 
 The King's actions in August 1931 are sometimes defended with the argument that he was merely acting on the advice of the party leaders. 
 But the course of these interviews shows that no party leader was unequivocally in favour of a National Government led by MacDonald, in the event of the Labour government collapsing. 
 MacDonald said that he &bquo;might be of no further use, &amp; should resign with the whole Cabinet&equo;; the night before his interview with the King, Baldwin had gone to Neville Chamberlain's house in Eaton Square, and &bquo;hoped and prayed that he might not have to join a National Government&equo;; even after his interview with the King. 
 Baldwin reported to his colleagues that MacDonald was likely to resign and that &bquo;H.M. 
 sends for S.B. tomorrow&equo;. 
 Of the three who offered advice to the King, Samuel was the only one who favoured a National Government (and then only with qualifications) were the Labour government to collapse. 
 Samuel was not, of course, a party leader, and there is no way of knowing what advice Lloyd George would have given had he been fit. 
 What we do know is that Lloyd George, despite his public stance of support for the National Government, thought, in private, that it had been a mistake for the Liberals to join it. 
 On the day the National Government was formed, Sylvester, Lloyd George's secretary, asked him: &bquo;Are you in or out of this?&equo; 
 He replied: &bquo;I am keeping outside. 
 I would not take office under MacDonald, and yet it would have been impossible to have refused. 
 I am glad, therefore, that it has happened thus.' 
 Tweed, the Liberal election agent, &bquo;knew&hellip; that it was not illness or the tedium of a long convalescence which kept him out, but that his heart was not in it and that confronted with the serried ranks of vested interests which compose this new Government, his sympathies were as always with the bottom dogs&hellip;' 
 Nevertheless, despite the fact that a National Government led by MacDonald was the preferred choice of at most one of the three party leaders, the King now knew that both Baldwin and Samuel would be prepared to  serve under MacDonald, were the latter willing to continue as Prime Minister. 
 MacDonald himself, however, appeared determined to resign. 
 After the meeting of the Cabinet held that same Sunday evening, when it became apparent that agreement could not be reached on the economy package, MacDonald, on his way to the palace, told Sir Ernest Harvey, the Deputy Governor of the Bank of England: &bquo;I am off to the Palace to throw in my hand.' 
 But when MacDonald saw the King again at 10.20 p.m., to report that he &bquo;had no alternative than to tender the resignation of the Cabinet&equo;, the King &bquo;impressed on the Prime Minister that he was the only man to lead the country through this crisis and hoped he would reconsider the situation. 
 His Majesty told him that the Conservatives and Liberals would support him in restoring the confidence of foreigners in the financial stability of the country&equo;. 
 MacDonald was not convinced. 
 At a meeting with Opposition leaders in 10 Downing Street later that night, he appeared resistant to Chamberlain's pleas that he remain. 
 Baldwin, significantly, remained silent. 
 The next morning, Monday 24 August, the King held, at MacDonald's request, a conference at Buckingham Palace between the Prime Minister. 
 Baldwin and Samuel. 
 At this conference, the King gave the three party leaders a virtual instruction that they should form a National Government under MacDonald's leadership. 
 The memorandum of the King's Private Secretary, Wigram, is explicit on this point. 
 At 10 AM the King held a Conference at Buckingham Palace at which the Prime Minister, Baldwin and Samuel were present. 
 At the beginning, His Majesty impressed upon them that before they left the Palace some communiqu&eacute; must be issued, which would no longer keep the country and the world in suspense. 
 The Prime Minister said that he had the resignation of his Cabinet in his pocket, but the King replied that he trusted there was no question of the Prime Minister's resignation: the leaders of the three Parties must get together and come to some arrangement. 
 His Majesty hoped that the Prime Minister, with the colleagues who remained faithful to him, would help in the formation of a National Government, which the King was sure would be supported by the Conservatives and the Liberals. 
 The King assured the Prime Minister that, remaining at his post, his position and reputation would be much more enhanced than if he surrendered the government of the country at such a crisis. 
 The King, then, was not merely the facilitator of the National Government, but the instigator of it. 
 Three times he had made it clear to MacDonald that he did not wish to accept his resignation &mdash; on the morning of Sunday 23 August, when he told MacDonald that he would &bquo;advise them  (the other two party leaders) strongly to support (him)&equo;; at 10.20 p.m. on the evening of the same day, after the Cabinet meeting, when the King &bquo;impressed upon the Prime Minister that he was the only man to lead the country through this crisis and hoped that he would reconsider the situation&equo;; and at the Buckingham Palace conference itself. 
 Had the King simply accepted MacDonald's resignation, either there would have been no National Government, or, if there had been, it would not have been led by MacDonald. 
 Sir Clive Wigram's memorandum of the Buckingham Palace Conference makes it clear that the National Government was formed on quite specific conditions. 
 Baldwin and Samuel said that they were willing to serve under the Prime Minister and render all help possible to carry on the Government as a National Emergency Government until an emergency bill or bills had been passed by Parliament, which would restore once more British credit and the confidence of foreigners. 
 After that they would expect His Majesty to grant a dissolution. 
 To this course the King agreed. 
 During the Election the National Government would remain in being, though of course each Party would fight the Election on its own lines. 
 These conditions are rendered more precise in a memorandum written by Sir Herbert Samuel at the Conference, after George V had withdrawn. 
 1. 
 National Government to be formed to deal with the present financial emergency. 
 2. 
 It will not be a Coalition in the ordinary sense of the term but a co-operation of individuals. 
 3. 
 When the emergency is dealt with the Government's work will have finished and parties will return to their ordinary positions. 
 4. 
 The economies and imposts shall be equitable and shall generally follow the lines of the suggestions attached, designed to enable a loan to be raised in New York and Paris. 
 5. 
 The election which may follow the end of the Government will not be fought by the Government but by the parties. 
 6. 
 If there is any legislation which it is necessary to pass for special departmental or other reasons, and is generally accepted by the different parties, it may be undertaken. 
 7. 
 The Cabinet shall be reduced to a minimum. 
 At the final Cabinet meeting of the Labour government, held at 12 noon on 24 August, shortly after MacDonald had agreed to lead a National Government, he said:  
 The proposal was that His Majesty would invite certain individuals as individuals to take upon their shoulders the burden of carrying on the Government and Mr. Baldwin and Mr. Samuel ( sic ) had stated that they were prepared to act accordingly&hellip; the Administration would not exist for a period longer than was necessary to dispose of the emergency, and when that purpose was achieved the political parties would resume their respective positions. 
 The Administration would not be a Coalition Government in the usual sense of the term, but a Government of co-operation for this one purpose. 
 It had been agreed that at the General Election which would follow the end of the emergency period, there would no &bquo;coupons&equo;, pacts or other Party arrangements. 
 In a letter written to the junior ministers the same day he reiterated this theme: 
 The Government that has been formed is not a Coalition but a co-operation between individuals who are banded together to avoid the disaster. 
 No parties are involved in it, and as soon as the country gets on an even keel again, the Government will cease to exist. 
 And Baldwin, in a press statement issued on the same day, stated that 
 The National Government had been allotted a definite task, and on its completion it is understood that Parliament should be dissolved as soon as circumstances permit, and that each of the parties should be left free to place its policy before the electors for their approval. 
 By this means no party will be called upon to sacrifice any of the principles in which it believes. 
 The conditions set out by Samuel were intended to distance the National Government from the Lloyd George coalition which had cast its shadow across the politics of the 1920s. 
 Most of those involved in the formation of the National Government had in fact been prominent opponents of Lloyd George in the past. 
 Samuel and Maclean had been prominent in the Asquithian wing of the Liberal Party while Baldwin, Hoare, and Neville Chamberlain had been the leaders of the Conservative anti-coalitionists in 1922. 
 &bquo;As we have said several times in the last few days,&equo; Hoare wrote to Neville Chamberlain on 31 August, &bquo;we had some great good luck in the absence of Winston and L.G.' Having destroyed one coalition, Baldwin had no intention of entering another. 
 MacDonald also had condemned the Lloyd George coalition as corrupt and unprincipled and had been a major beneficiary of its fall. 
 The conditions laid down were therefore designed to differentiate the National Government from the Lloyd George coalition, and to make it clear that the National Government was not intended, as the  Lloyd George coalition had been, to lead to a permanent realignment of the party system. 
 Rather, the analogy was perhaps with the 1915 coalition, a government supported by the Liberal, Conservative, and Labour parties with definite but limited wartime objectives. 
 Similarly, those who formed the National Government believed that it was National in the sense that its objective &mdash; balancing the budget &mdash; was shared by all parties. 
 For the minority in the Labour Cabinet who opposed the cut in the standard rate of benefit had divided the Labour government, not on the question of whether the budget should be balanced, but, so they claimed, on the subordinate question of how  the budget should be balanced. 
 It was not long before the dynamics of politics made such niceties quite irrelevant, The bulk of the Labour party came out in opposition, not only to the National Government, but to any economies, even those which the Labour Cabinet had agreed. 
 On the Conservative side, calls for an election were soon heard. 
 The first Conservative to utter this call was not, as A. J. P. Taylor has said, Churchill, but Lord Hailsham; Attorney-General and Lord Chancellor in Baldwin's 1924&ndash;9 Conservative government, Hailsham was excluded from the National Government as unacceptable to National Labour, on account of his role in piloting the 1927 Trades Disputes Act through Parliament, and (along with Leo Amery) to the Samuelite Liberals, on account of his support for tariffs. 
 Hailsham, in an article in the Daily Express , of 3 September, called for an election, to be fought on party lines, with the aim of securing a Conservative majority for protection, The government, Hailsham said, should hurry up to complete the purpose for which it was formed, namely the balancing of the budget, and then go to the country on party lines. 
 The unanimity of the Conservative party in supporting Baldwin's decision to join the National Government has masked the existence of growing backbench resentment on the part of protectionists. 
 Enjoying widespread support in the constituencies, the supporters of the tariff threatened to become a danger to Baldwin's leadership &mdash; as they had been during the 1929&ndash;31 period. 
 On the day the National Government was formed, William Ormsby-Gore, the new postmaster General, wrote to Baldwin; 
 I am a little alarmed over the prospects of another Coalition&hellip; 
 Even if it is absolutely essential to have one to prune expenditure I hope you will get a free hand to have a dissolution in the autumn as we cannot recover any revenue or any industry now without a tariff&hellip; 
 We can carry protection in the country at an early general election if the position is not seriously compromised by coalition with  
 Liberal Free Traders. 
 And we want nothing which will tend to rehabilitate the fallen fortunes of the Liberal Party in the country. 
 I mistrust a twister like Herbert Samuel. 
 Amery wrote in his diary on 25 August: &bquo;Milner once remarked to me in South Africa about the Cabinet of his day, how difficult it was to keep a lot of empty sacks standing up straight&hellip;. 
 After two years of bingeing up Baldwin and bringing Neville along to find that even Neville loses his head, and sells the pass in the first fortnight of serious crisis.&equo; 
 At a Conservative party meeting on 28 August, Amery noted that Horne &bquo;on the whole agrees with me that we have got into a considerable mess and that the great thing is to extricate our people as soon as possible,&equo; while Hailsham in his speech &bquo;supported entirely what had been done but trusted that it would not last longer than two months &mdash; whereat loud cheers&equo;. 
 On 30 August, Amery was saying how glad he was that Hailsham was outside the government; &bquo;I can look to him as an ally in helping to bring the thing to a conclusion reasonably soon.&equo; 
 The next day, Beaverbrook (who, with Amery, had been among those who had helped bring down the Lloyd George coalition in 1922) &bquo;strongly urged&equo; Amery &bquo;to work closely with Hailsham both to keep the positive campaign going and decide when the critical moment should come for putting an end to the Coalition&equo;. 
 On 8 September, Churchill, hitherto a free trader, spoke in the Commons, expressing doubts about the wisdom of joining the National Government, and urging an early election fought on tariffs; &bquo;An audacious rollicking speech,&equo; commented Amery, &bquo;by no means pleasing to the Front Bench.' 
 These were considerations that could not be ignored by a Conservative leader, Austen Chamberlain had been toppled in 1922 because he had not withdrawn from an unpopular coalition in time; and one of the motives for the destruction of the Lloyd George coalition was a desire to replace it by a protectionist government. 
 Over fifty years later in 1975, another Conservative leader, Edward Heath, was to be overthrown, in part because, in March 1974, he had proposed a coalition with the Liberals and, in October 1974, he had proposed a government of national unity, Thus, among Conservatives, the motives for an election were clear: for those left out of the government, the desire to secure a Conservative majority for protection; for the leadership, a desire to reunite the party, and simple self-preservation. 
 It was, however, Geoffrey Dawson, editor of The Times, who, in an editorial on 16 September, was the first to suggest that the National Government itself, and not the parties separately, should make an appeal to the country &bquo;on a broad programme of reconstruction which will include a tariff&equo;. 
 Dawson wrote this editorial after discussing the idea with Baldwin  and MacDonald, both of whom he had found to be &bquo;receptive&equo;. 
 Within the Cabinet, it was, paradoxically, Snowden &mdash; usually regarded as a sea-green incorruptible on the issue of free trade &mdash; who, overcome by hatred of Labour and a desire to smash his old party, appeared to relish the idea of an early election in which Labour would go down to defeat. 
 In the budget debate on 15 September, he addressed Dalton: 
 The Honourable member concluded his speech with a challenge. 
 He wants a general election. 
 He dues not want it more earnestly than I do. 
 I have noticed this during the last two or three days that I have been sitting here, being able for the first time in this House, to see the faces of my old associates, I have admired the way in which they have cheered to keep their spirits up, and I have admired those who have done that knowing &mdash; knowing &mdash; that only a few weeks, possibly, remain, before the place that knows them now will know them no more. 
 Snowden, unlike Samuel, was willing to agree in late September to a prohibitive tariff on luxury goods. 
 On 26 September, before the Cabinet had seriously begun to consider whether an election should be called, Snowden declared that an early election could not be avoided; and on 2 October, Neville Chamberlain noted in his diary, &bquo;Snowden expressed strongly the view that imports must be controlled&equo;. 
 There is some evidence that it was Snowden who suggested the formula of the &bquo;doctor's mandate&equo;, at a Cabinet meeting on 5 October, under which the component parts of the National Government were each to issue their own manifestos, with a separate personal appeal from the Prime Minister, According to Neville Chamberlain, &bquo;Snowden&hellip; produced the suggestion that the Prime Minister should issue his own manifesto asking for a free hand &lsqb;i.e. on tariffs&rsqb; and the two Party leaders should each issue their own programmes and to our astonishment this was at once accepted by the Liberals, ' Amery, who perhaps got the information from Chamberlain, wrote in his diary on 6 October, &bquo;Apparently when the deadlock seemed most complete Snowden suggested that the PM should issue his own manifesto, each of the other party leaders issuing theirs.' 
 Tom Jones, whose source was Lothian, also said that the formula was Snowden's. 
 It is ironic that, after the National majority had been safely won, and shown itself, as might have been predicted, protectionist, Snowden reverted to the role of stubborn free trader, and gave currency to  the view of MacDonald as a feeble halfwit, without principles or dignity, Yet MacDonald, although no doctrinaire free trader, had fought harder to reach a formula that the Liberals, Snowden's free trade allies, could accept than Snowden himself had done. 
 Yet for the National Government to fight the election as a government, rather than on party lines, was a clear breach of the undertakings which had been made at the time of its formation. 
 The King was, in a sense, the guardian of this agreement, and it might have been expected that he would remind the party leaders of it. 
 On the contrary; he took the view that a continuation of the National Government was in the best interests of the country. 
 When MacDonald told him on 29 September that he was having difficulty finding a formula which could unite his colleagues, George V 
 impressed upon the Prime Minister that the country had to be saved and that there should be a combination of all decent minded politicians towards this end. 
 Party differences should be sunk. 
 If a Socialist Government came into power and carried out their extravagant promises to the electorate, this country would be finished. 
 The King was sure that the present Prime Minister was the only man who could save the country and His Majesty himself was prepared to support him&hellip; 
 The King throughout was in favour of an Election and the Prime Minister when he left certainly seemed more courageous and more firm in his conviction that a General Election was necessary. 
 On 2 October the King saw Samuel, the leading recalcitrant in the Cabinet, 
 and found that he had hardened his views and was most obstructive and unhelpful. 
 His Majesty appealed to him as a Statesman and as one who had been a Minister of the Crown to place before everything the present dangerous situation of the country, Sir Herbert replied that he and his party were just as patriotic as the Conservatives: the country would be in far greater danger from Tariffs &mdash; price of food stuffs would rise, there would be strikes and outbreaks all over the country. 
 He would be a traitor to his cause if he sold the pass now. 
 Sir Herbert suggested that Henderson, the leader of the Opposition, should be approached to join the National Party, which was not a National one at present: In short his attitude was to oppose any National Appeal and to be mischievous. 
 On 3 October &bquo;the King told the Prime Minister that he must at all costs find the solution himself, and His Majesty would refuse to accept his resignation. 
 He must be more patient and brace himself up to realise that he was the only person who could tackle the present chaotic state of affairs,' This was the fourth time the King had told MacDonald that he would not accept his resignation.  
 There were certainly strong arguments in favour of the course which the King adopted. 
 It was clear that the dominant element in his government, that is, the Conservatives, were determined upon an election. 
 Moreover, MacDonald was in principle in favour of an election, but unable to secure agreement upon a formula which could reconcile protectionists and free traders up to the very last moment. 
 The King could reasonably take the view that he was doing no more than exercising the right to encourage, one of Bagehot's famous trinity of rights, and that he was encouraging his Prime Minister in achieving his aims, rather than pressing MacDonald to adopt a course which was unwelcome to him. 
 Moreover, there was a case for suggesting that the change of ministry in August required the endorsement of the electorate. 
 This was the argument voiced by The Times  on 8 October: &bquo;The working of parliamentary institutions, of democratic responsibility, and of constitutional practice, demands it.&equo; 
 And, since the King had played some part in securing the formation of the National Government in August, the election would, in a sense, validate the King's action as well, &bquo;Of course you are going to vote,&equo; the King said to Sir Maurice Hankey, the Cabinet Secretary, on 2 October, before the Cabinet had alighted upon the doctor's mandate formula which made the election possible. 
 When Hankey explained that, since the war, he had &bquo;rather made a point of not voting&equo;, to emphasize his detachment from Party politics, the King replied, &bquo;But this time it is different. 
 I want the National Government to get every vote possible.&equo; 
 When he confirmed to Hankey that this was a &bquo;command&equo;, the latter replied; &bquo;Very well, Sire. 
 Your Majesty can claim to have canvassed one vote for the National Government.' 
 Behind this exchange &mdash; which perhaps need not be taken too seriously &mdash; there lies the fear that a victory for the Labour party in a general election would constitute a repudiation of the King's actions in August, To the extent that the National Government was formed through the agency of the King, a repudiation of the National Government could be conceived of as a repudiation of the King. 
 So it was that the agreement on which the first National Government was formed was ignored by the King, who granted a dissolution under conditions which broke both the letter and the spirit of the agreement. 
 It may be argued that the King had a special responsibility to preserve the agreement, in that, in a country such as Britain without a codified constitution, there is no reference point, no pouvoir neutre , over and above the exigencies of party politics. 
 Only the King, therefore, could defend the agreement. 
 He did not do so. 
 Indeed, he put pressure on Sir Herbert Samuel to abandon its terms. 
 Despite the arguments in favour of the course which the King adopted, his encouragement to MacDonald to hold the government  together and to fight the election as a government had quite momentous consequences for the politics of the 1930s. 
 Although the King's intentions were not partisan, the consequences were such as to offer very considerable benefit to the Conservative party. 
 The 1931 general election gave the Conservatives a huge overall majority in the House of Commons, enabling them to pursue their tariff policy with little hindrance. 
 The announcement of the election itself drew together the various elements in the Conservative party, and validated Baldwin's decision to enter the National Government. 
 From 1931, threats to his leadership disappeared, Moreover, because the Conservatives took with them into the National coalition elements of the Liberal and Labour parties, the party competition of the 1930s became seriously unbalanced, the left being too shattered and divided to offer effective opposition. 
 The effect of this election on the other parties was disastrous. 
 While it served to reconcile warring elements in the Conservative party, in the other parties it prevented any such reconciliation. 
 In particular it widened the gap between Labour and National Labour, and made it quite impossible for any reunion to take place. 
 For the Liberals, the election meant a breach between the party and its leader, Lloyd George, Indeed, it meant the end of Lloyd George's connection with the Liberal party. 
 He refused to allow the party access to his fund, and partly for this reason the Liberals were forced to accept a drastic reduction in the number of candidatures, from 513 in 1929 to 112 in 1931, The condition of the Liberals was far more serious than that of Labour, for the Liberal party was beginning to lose its sense of identity and purpose (and has still not fully recovered it). 
 Once the party had shown itself, in the 1929&ndash;31 Parliament, unwilling to support Lloyd George's programme of national reconciliation, it had no answer to the question: What did the Liberal party stand for? 
 Its only rallying cry remained free trade; and yet it was clear that the 1931 election would result in a protectionist majority. 
 The seeming gains made by the Liberals in the negotiations before the Cabinet agreed to an election &mdash; that there should be no joint manifesto, and no pledge to introduce tariffs, merely an impartial inquiry &mdash; turned out (as might have been expected) to be worthless. 
 The squabbling in Cabinet over the formula on which the National Government was to fight the election was, in reality, a form of shadow-boxing: for, whatever the formula, it would be interpreted by those who had the power to interpret it, that is, the Conservative and protectionist majority. 
 Lloyd George, himself perfectly willing to countenance departures from free trade in his 1918&ndash;22 Coalition, now argued that free trade was best defended through a vote for the Labour  Party. 
 The 1931 general election was the last election until that of February 1974 at which the electoral performance of the Liberals was of significance to the two major parties. 
 In agreeing to fight the election as part of the National Government, the Liberal party abdicated from its role as a major participant in the political system. 
 Because they were losing their sense of identity, the Liberals were split three ways by the 1931 election &mdash; into Simonites, Samuelites, and the Lloyd George family group, The first group advocated co-operation, culminating in a merger, with the Conservatives; the second sought to preserve an independent Liberal party; the third sought co-operation with Labour. 
 So also the french Radicals in the Fourth Republic were to splinter in all directions, participating in governments of both left and right. 
 The Liberal party could no more than the Radicals answer the fundamental question of whether, with political liberalism and universal suffrage achieved, there remained a distinctive philosophy of liberalism which could differentiate the Liberals from other political parties. 
 Between 1929 and the formation of the second National Government after the general election, the Liberal party had been a genuine participant in the political system and the other parties had to consider carefully what its reactions might be. 
 During the course of the 1929&ndash;31 government, MacDonald gradually appreciated that the hopes which he had entertained during the 1920s of eliminating the Liberals and winning over the whole of the progressive vote for the Labour party could not be achieved. 
 It was for this reason that he felt compelled to offer the Liberals the alternative vote, an electoral system which would have the effect of entrenching the third party as part of the political system. 
 The events between the formation of the first National Government and the general election, however, turned what had been an incipient three-party system into an unbalanced two-party system in which the Conservatives, reinforced by defectors from the Liberal and Labour parties, the Liberal Nationals, and National Labour party, were the obvious beneficiaries. 
 It was the general election, then, and not the formation of the first National Government, that was the crucial event in the politics of the 1930s. 
 The King was involved in the decisions precipitating both events. 
 In recent years there has been considerable discussion of the role of the Sovereign in the eventuality of a hung Parliament, such as that of 1929&ndash;31, and the general conclusion has been that her role is essentially a passive one. 
 Yet  both in the formation of the National Government and in the decision that it would fight the election as a government the King played an important, perhaps a crucial role. 
 That was in fact the private view of Harold Nicolson, although he did not allow it to be expressed in his official biography of George V. In an unpublished section of his diaries, he writes of his interview with Queen Mary on 21 March 1949, &bquo;I talked to her about the 1931 crisis and said that I was convinced the King had been a determinant influence on that occasion, &bquo;Yes certainly; he certainly was,' 
 It is perhaps futile to ask the question, were the King's actions constitutional? 
 In a country without a codified constitution, it is hardly possible to give a definitive answer. 
 If one asks the further question, were the King's actions wise?, one's answer is likely to be all too heavily conditioned by hindsight, by the views one takes of the later politics of the 1930s, of the restoration of a two-party system, and of the decline of the Liberal Party. 
 The historian, perhaps, can do little more than echo Disraeli's pregnant remark in Sybil , Book IV, Chapter I: &bquo;when parties are in the present state of equality, the Sovereign is no longer a mere pageant.&equo; 
 DAVID R. DEVEREUX Kings College London and Canisius College  
 British Planning for Postwar Civil Aviation 1942&ndash;1945 
 A Study in Anglo-American Rivalry 
 One of the least-known aspects of British planning for the postwar world relates to the field of civil aviation. 
 The British realized during the war years that they could never reap the benefits of the expected postwar boom in international civil aviation without a coherent national programme that would enable Britain to compete on equal terms with the United States. 
 This issue was first raised as early as 1941, and by 1943&ndash;4 had become a subject of major concern for the British government, aware that unless rules were laid down in advance, the United States would use its enormous wealth, undamaged industrial capability, and the advantages obtained during the war years to drive Britain and other countries off the international air routes. 
 As one authority has put it, &bquo;competition for air routes, services and traffic was not unlike the &bquo;scramble&equo; for Africa in the late 19th century'. 
 In 1943&ndash;4, the British attempted to devise a Commonwealth approach to civil aviation policy as a way of countering US influence. 
 Civil aviation, along with monetary and tariff policies, control over Middle East oil, and the continuation of Britain's rubber trade, was a subject of considerable Anglo-American rivalry in terms of protectionism versus competition that was not resolved until the postwar period. 
 This conflict was a symptom of Britain's relative decline as a world power, and was characterized by its attempts to retain something of its former position through the Commonwealth and Empire. 
 This article suggests that the  British hoped to create an international civil aviation environment favourable to their interests, but were unable to do so because of American opposition. 
 They also embarked on an ambitious national scheme that was designed to place Britain at the forefront of the postwar civil aviation market. 
 British air travel before the war had largely been in the hands of two companies, British Airways for European services and Imperial Airways for services further afield. 
 Both functioned with a degree of official support, especially in the form of mail contracts, but proved themselves to be unprofitable in the face of subsidized foreign competition. 
 In 1939, after several years of study, the Conservative government attempted to reorganize the rather inefficient operation of the two airlines and to encourage more competition. 
 The result was a single national airline that was to be the so-called &bquo;chosen instrument&equo; for British air services: British Overseas Airways Corporation (BOAC). 
 However, with the immediate advent of the war, BOAC never had a chance to establish commercial operations on any scale, and quickly found itself used by the Air Ministry (its overseeing body, also in control of the Royal Air Force) for military transport duties and ferry and communication services. 
 Its role was downgraded even further when the Royal Air force's Transport Command was formed in 1943, using largely American-built transport aircraft. 
 This latter point was perhaps the greatest concern for Britain's aviation planners as the war went on. 
 One stipulation of Lend-Lease agreements signed in 1941&ndash;2 was that Britain should concentrate on the production of fighter and bomber aircraft for the war effort; its transport needs would be met by American aircraft. 
 While this made eminent sense for production efficiency in wartime, it was very much apparent to the British that this would give the United States a natural advantage when the war ended. 
 The Americans would have thousands of surplus transport aircraft that could be turned to civil use, and a well-developed transport aircraft industry; the British, on the other hand, would have virtually none. 
 This fear of American inroads into areas that Britain used to control effortlessly was not confined to civil aviation; the British also resented the activity of US oil companies in the Middle East, and US attempts to break into the British-dominated international rubber market and the sterling bloc. 
 With Britain's security in its greatest peril, American support was bought at the price of much of Britain's long-developed overseas economic power. 
 The British were especially angered by the rapidly enhanced role of the premier American overseas air carrier, Pan American Airways (PAA) as a  result of the war. 
 Under the chairmanship of Juan Trippe PAA had rapidly increased its position in the 1930s, enjoying a monopoly on US flights across the Pacific to Japan and China, into Latin America, and over to Britain. 
 Under a 1937 agreement, PAA was allowed to operate two flights a week to the UK: it continued to do this during the war years, unmatched by BOAC. 
 Pan American, like its counterpart Imperial Airways, enjoyed government backing through mail contracts and its powerful political influence in the capital. 
 Unlike Imperial Airways' successor, BOAC, which was a nationalized company and used by the British government during the war, Pan American was able to use its private enterprise and political influence to expand its services dramatically. 
 In 1941, Pan American began a Brazil-West Africa-Cairo service with British permission, intended mainly as a supply route for Allied forces, and necessitating the construction by Pan American of appropriate airports in British and French colonial territory, A new company, Pan American Air Ferries, was created to operate the service, which connected with Pan American's existing network in Latin America. 
 Although the British needed this route to support Egypt, many of them saw Pan American as opportunistic and poised to exploit its advantage in the postwar years. 
 Air Marshal Sir Arthur Tedder, RAF commander in Egypt, wrote that &bquo;the cloven hoof of Pan American &lsqb;is&rsqb; now well to the fore&equo;, and called BOAC's attitude &bquo;hopelessly defeatist&equo;, Pan American was making inroads in Africa and the Middle East that BOAC might never be able to match. 
 To the British, the US company embodied &bquo;the idea and methods of the East India Company and the chartered corporations of Africa. 
 Their aims will be economic, their ambitions to enjoy commercial power without responsibility.' 
 Pan American's privileged position, and the British government's perceived failure to assist BOAC's own position, were so strongly resented by the British company that all but one of its directors resigned in protest in March 1943. 
 With the conduct of hostilities the paramount concern for both the USA and Britain, civil aviation remained a minor issue in the early years of the war. 
 Nevertheless, the British were looking towards the war's end and the possible shape of civil aviation even before the United States entered the conflict. 
 In August 1941, an interdepartmental committee was formed under the chairmanship of Sir Francis Shelmerdine of the Air Ministry to survey the whole field of aviation and to make recommendations for peacetime. 
 Although an interim report was submitted in May 1942, after  which Shelmerdine was replaced as chairman by Lord Finlay, the committee's main recommendations became the plank of British civil aviation policy for the next three years. 
 The Shelmerdine Committee concluded that international civil aviation should be internationalized and placed under an international authority. 
 This conclusion was based upon the general perception that pre-1939 aviation was overly competitive and unregulated, and subject to vicious throat-cutting in the national interest. 
 Countries had used subsidies to further the interests of their national companies, and Britain had found it difficult to compete in this arena. 
 Internationalization, it was believed, would alleviate the problem. 
 The Finlay Committee which followed up the Shelmerdine report was charged with looking at ways of bringing about internationalization, and how the issue should be raised with the Dominions, the USA, and the USSR. 
 The Committee reported in December 1942, by which time it had become a part of the larger Cabinet Committee on Reconstruction problems. 
 The Finlay Report discussed Pan American's route structure and rapid wartime expansion under the guise of military service. 
 It was acknowledged that Pan American would lobby strenuously in Washington to avoid inter-nationalization, which would be a threat to its dominant position. 
 The Finlay Committee urged the full internationalization of civil aviation at war's end, and failing that, internationalization among European countries and their dependencies. 
 Operations should be run by a highly centralized unitary body which would provide services on the trunk routes of the world. 
 The timing of such an arrangement would be crucial if adverse American reaction was to be avoided; it was believed that the first approaches should be to the Dominions, followed by the USA, USSR, and China, culminating in a full international conference. 
 The British government adopted the report as official policy, and pursued a diplomatic approach to the problem over the next two years. 
 Meanwhile, in 1942 another committee was at work on Britain's postwar civil aviation policy, but with a different focus: the aircraft themselves. 
 This side of the issue was entrusted to Lord Brabazon of Tara, whose committee was invited to make recommendations on the types of aircraft that Britain should produce for the postwar period. 
 The committee reported in February 1943 in very alarming language that there would be nothing left for the British postwar aircraft industry unless something were done at once. 
 The British aircraft industry was expected to shrink to only a fifth of its existing size, giving the USA an enormous head start. 
 Work on civil versions of the Halifax bomber, York military transport (itself a derivative of the Lancaster  bomber), and Shetland flying boat was needed to stave off the decline. 
 More importantly, however, the Brabazon Committee listed five main categories of aircraft for which brand new types were needed if Britain was to compete effectively with the United States. 
 Of these, the first, Type 1, was the most important; it was to be a large multi-engine landplane capable of flying from London to New York non-stop. 
 This was the aircraft intended to meet American competition head-on. 
 Type 2 was a two-engine landplane for European services, and Type 3 a four-engine aircraft for the Empire trunk routes. 
 Type 4 was the most innovative and intriguing: a pure jet transport aircraft for the North Atlantic service. 
 Finally, Type 5 was a small aircraft for local services in the UK and the colonies. 
 This radical and sweeping blueprint for Britain's peacetime civil aviation industry was considered by the War Cabinet on 25 February 1943. 
 The Cabinet accepted the recommendation that a substantial British aircraft industry was required to hold off competition, and should be developed with more than just the Empire in mind; also the premise that work on new aircraft should proceed under government direction, with the Treasury accepting responsibility for new types. 
 This was the first sign of the real importance Britain was to accord civil aviation, viewing it as an essential component of the country's postwar recovery. 
 Although Britain was forced by circumstances to continue devoting the bulk of its resources to military aircraft production, work did begin on the specifications and design for the postwar civil transports. 
 It was recognized by all concerned that it would take at least three and more likely five years for any of the Brabazon types to come into production, so work also proceeded on interim types that could hold the gap until the newer types were in service. 
 Britain had virtually no civil aircraft otherwise, and various designs were evolved by A. V. Roe and Handley Page based on their Lancaster and Halifax bombers. 
 The Brabazon Committee, working with the Air Ministry and the Ministry of Aircraft Production, also began to oversee the design of the new types that it had recommended. 
 Work, however, proceeded slowly because of the demands of war. 
 The most spectacular of the new aircraft was the Type 1. 
 Under the Brabazon recommendations, the aircraft would have six to eight piston or reciprocating engines, possibly replaced by gas turbine engines if available, and a pressurized cabin, and be capable of flying 5,000 miles non-stop at 275 miles per hour. 
 Its design and construction were handed to the Bristol Aircraft Company, which designated it model 167. 
 Bristol proceeded with  the aircraft's design, and had a mock-up prototype completed by the end of the war. 
 However, some of the problems that were to haunt the postwar aviation industry had already begun to appear. 
 By November 1944, only the Bristol 167 and the Type 2 aircraft, the twin-engine Airspeed 67, had gone much past the preliminary design stage, and the Brabazon Committee warned that the five new types would face obsolescence if their development were not speeded up. 
 Part of the problem was the less than perfect relationship between the Air Ministry and BOAC, which would have to operate the new aircraft. 
 BOAC clearly had profit on its mind, and wanted its requirements incorporated into the new designs, but these were only partially met. 
 In October 1944, Lord Knollys, the BOAC chairman, told a meeting held in the Ministry of Aircraft production that the Brabazon Type 3 would be the airline's &bquo;bread and butter&equo; aircraft for Empire routes, carrying twenty-five sleepers or forty to forty-five day passengers. 
 It was to be a four-engine aircraft, possibly with gas turbines, with a range of 2,750 miles. 
 This aircraft subsequently underwent numerous design changes before it was incorporated into the Type 4 jet aircraft, which enjoyed later fame as the DeHavilland Comet. 
 The Bristol 167 was to be Britain's great new advance on American types such as the Lockheed Constellation and Douglas DC-6, which did not have the range to fly the Atlantic non-stop. 
 It was also to be the largest aircraft ever built in Britain. 
 However, even by the end of the war, the design had run into serious difficulties. 
 Sir William Hildred, who as Director-General at the new Ministry of Civil Aviation was Britain's senior civil servant in charge of aviation, told a meeting in September 1945 that he had lost interest in the Bristol 167 because its undercarriage width of 93 feet was wider than any runway then in existence, and two prototypes were estimated to cost &pound;7 million. 
 Worst of all, BOAC, the type's only possible operator, had also lost interest in it. 
 The Bristol aircraft was eventually completed as an experimental airplane under the name Bristol Brabazon. 
 Despite its immense size, it was severely underpowered: by the late 1940s, with BOAC refusing to use it and with no other customer, the project became an expensive white elephant and was ultimately scrapped by the succeeding Conservative government. 
 The issue of internationalization remained the government's first priority in aviation policy, because only this would allow Britain to compete on equal terms with the USA. 
 Following the report of the Finlay Committee, a sub-committee of the Cabinet Committee on Reconstruction Problems was  appointed, consisting of Lord Jowitt (Minister without Portfolio and Chairman), Sir Kingsley Wood (Chancellor of the Exchequer), Sir Stafford Cripps (Minister of Aircraft production), and Sir Archibald Sinclair (Secretary of State for Air). 
 The sub-committee agreed on the need for an effective UK civil aviation programme, and that the USA should be approached on the issue of internationalization. 
 As US agreement on inter-nationalization was considered unlikely, Britain would also prepare to operate in a Europe- or Commonwealth-centred system. 
 To study the recommendations of the Finlay Committee on how to bring about internationalization, another official committee was created under the chairmanship of Sir Alan Barlow of the Air Ministry. 
 Finlay had recommended four alternatives: full internationalization, a European plus dependencies system, an Empire only system, or international regulation. 
 The Barlow Committee recommended full internationalization without the reservation of internal services (i.e. even domestic flights would fall under international authority). 
 As this was considered unlikely to succeed because, of US opposition, a European and dependencies system was considered second best. 
 Commonwealth representatives were first told of British thinking on the subject of civil aviation at a meeting chaired by Deputy Prime Minister Clement Attlee in February 1943. 
 Anthony Eden, the Foreign Secretary, asked them to what extent the full internationalization of civil aviation was possible. 
 Australia, New Zealand, and South Africa supported inter-nationalization with US involvement, but if this were not possible, they preferred a Commonwealth or European arrangement. 
 This was substantially in line with British thinking. 
 Canada, influenced by the importance of air links with the USA, favoured full consultation with the Americans before any arrangement was finalized. 
 The meeting agreed only that no decisions would be taken until Dominion government opinion had been consulted. 
 The representatives met again on 29 March to consider the Finlay and Shelmerdine reports, and Stanley Bruce, the Australian High Commissioner, stated that the USA and USSR should be approached immediately on the subject of civil aviation. 
 The reports were then sent to the Dominion and Indian governments. 
 It was finally decided on 15 June that there should be a Commonwealth statement on civil aviation, and although Australia and South Africa favoured Commonwealth consultation ahead of time, Canada was wary of offending the USA. 
 For this reason, when asked to host a Commonwealth conference in Ottawa, the Canadian government  agreed only on the condition that the USA was also invited, to avoid charges of &bquo;ganging up&equo;. 
 Nevertheless, the British were intent on obtaining Commonwealth agreement before approaching the USA. 
 Lord Cranborne, the Lord Privy Seal, was given authority to plan for civil aviation discussions. 
 British and Canadian representatives held talks in Quebec in August 1943, and the British believed the Canadians were afraid of powerful US influence on any meeting of Commonwealth representatives before  an international conference. 
 Finally, Britain proposed a meeting of Commonwealth representatives in London, which Canada agreed to attend, in October 1943. 
 A strong force in the discussions was the Canadian-born Lord Beaverbrook, who had now replaced Cranborne as Lord Privy Seal. 
 The Canadian representative at the talks was the equally formidable C. D. Howe, the Minister of Munitions. 
 The meetings produced wide-ranging agreement on the need for full co-operation on operation of the Empire air routes. 
 There was also general agreement that there should be an international authority operating on the lines of a domestic regulatory board, with the power to regulate routes, arbitrate in disputes, and set technical standards. 
 perhaps even more importantly, the Commonwealth representatives agreed on four &bquo;freedoms&equo; of the air that would form the basis of an international settlement: the right of innocent passage over sovereign territory; the right to land for non-traffic purposes (i.e. refuelling, repairs, and emergencies); the right to land passengers, mail, and freight from the airline's country of origin; and the right to pick up passengers, mail, and freight for passage to the airline's country of origin. 
 The conference's report was approved by the War Cabinet on 27 October 1943, and Beaverbrook was given leave to proceed to Washington when the timing for such a meeting seemed propitious. 
 Beaverbrook noted in November that no conference with the USA would be possible until after the presidential election one year later. 
 He was acutely aware of the power of the airlines, especially Pan American, in Congress and in the administration, and he wanted to choose his ground carefully. 
 In that same month, the British embassy in Washington sent an assessment of US attitudes. 
 It believed that the USA wanted a round-the-world air route with access to all countries including the Soviet Union, China, the Middle East, and Africa, as well as the British Commonwealth and Empire. 
 The USA would dislike any bilateral agreements that discriminated against a third country, the embassy believed, and was suspicious of  &bquo;all-red&equo; routes. 
 They would likely want to retain the use of airfields built during the war in the Caribbean, South America, Africa, the Middle and far East, and the Pacific, but would also likely agree to the four freedoms enunciated at the October 1943 Commonwealth conference. 
 Canada had already told the US embassy in Ottawa about the results of the London talks, and in February 1944 sent the State Department a draft 23-page convention for use in the proposed international conference. 
 It summarized the Commonwealth conclusions on an international authority with the ability to divide routes and services fairly. 
 At the same time Beaverbrook told the House of Lords of Britain's willingness to attend an international conference on civil aviation. 
 Aware of American dislike of centralized control, he confined his remarks to generalities about open trade welding nations together for mutual benefit. 
 As noted above, Pan American Airways and its chairman, Juan Trippe, had the ear of Congress and president Roosevelt, and fed fears of British dominance in the air. 
 It is quite true that the Americans were at least as worried about the British as the British were about them, but for very different reasons. 
 The Americans were intimidated by the possible British routes allowed by Commonwealth and Empire airfields the world over. 
 They therefore had no wish to be restricted by British manoeuvring for postwar influence, and were unsympathetic to British demands for international control. 
 Roosevelt, like Churchill, saw the significance of postwar civil aviation, and believed in free and open competition. 
 However, he was suspicious of Juan Trippe's attempts to keep a monopoly on US overseas air services. 
 At a meeting at the White House in November 1943, he told Assistant Secretary of State Adolf Berle, Under Secretary of State Edward Stettinius, and others that no single airline should dominate American airline services, and favoured a sectoral distribution of routes, of which Pan American would have some of the best. 
 This led to a decision by the Civil Aeronautics Board in 1945 to distribute routes in the Pacific, Latin America, and Europe to various other American airlines, some of which continue today. 
 Active planning and discussion of an international conference occupied the early months of 1944. 
 Britain wanted to hold a preliminary meeting of the Dominions along with the USA, and the Americans wanted to invite the  Soviets. 
 Finally, it became clear that no preliminary conference would be possible without widening the discussions unduly, and it seemed best to hold bilateral discussions first. 
 On 21 February 1944, the British sent a draft agenda of their thinking on civil aviation to the State Department. 
 They wanted to discuss an international authority at the preliminary meetings, and detailed twelve possible roles for it. 
 John Winant, the US ambassador in Britain, wrote on 28 February that this reflected Britain's concern with security rather than with &bquo;commercial enterprise&equo;; &bquo;It also reflects the British apprehension that they may be swamped competitively by US aviation and their consequent desire to guarantee themselves a percentage, even though small, of the available business.&equo; 
 They might even try to consider intra-Empire trade as internal routes, or cabotage, Winant wrote. 
 With the decision to scrap multilateral preliminary talks, the USA decided to send Assistant Secretary of State Adolf Berle, who was in charge of civil aviation matters, to Canada and Britain for bilateral talks. 
 It was clear that the USA wanted no international control of commercial operations and would accept it only in the realm of technical standards. 
 Berle met with Canadian officials at the end of March 1944, and told them that he liked their draft convention, but considered it a long-term rather than an immediate possibility. 
 He then went on to London, to hold talks with Beaverbrook and other Air Ministry officials. 
 Berle and Beaverbrook came to quick agreement on the need for the USA and UK to standardize technical aspects of aviation, and on a definition of &bquo;cabotage&equo; as traffic between the metropolitan power and its possessions, for example, the USA and Hawaii, or Britain and its colonies (but not the Dominions or India). 
 The main areas of disagreement were over the economic control of aviation on the North Atlantic. 
 Beaverbrook insisted that the volume of traffic must also be under international control; this Berle vigorously opposed. 
 Beaverbrook then presented the final draft of the October 1943 Commonwealth conference on civil aviation, with its four &bquo;freedoms&equo; of the air, Berle accepted this as a reasonable basis for negotiation. 
 Beaverbrook considered it an achievement that the USA and UK had settled on the 1943 draft as a formula for future negotiations, but US ambassador John Winant, at lunch with Churchill, Berle, and Beaverbrook, thought the Prime Minister wanted the Lord Privy Seal to &bquo;soft-pedal&equo; the internationalization aspect so as not to offend the USA. 
 In any case, the British hoped for an American-British-Dominions agreement that could be used as a basis on which to invite other countries to a conference.  
 In order to prepare further for the forthcoming conference, the Commonwealth Prime Ministers were told of the US-UK discussions at their meeting in May 1944. 
 Britain still hoped that a Commonwealth front could be achieved, with considerable internal control of Empire air routes. 
 The Air Ministry proposed a single corporation as a holding company for services between the UK and India, Australia, and New Zealand. 
 It would be controlled by the four countries on the lines of BOAC, and would be overseen by an Empire council. 
 Beaverbrook told a meeting of the Commonwealth Prime Ministers on 10 May about his discussions with Berle the previous month, and that he hoped for Commonwealth agreement before  an international conference. 
 Canada's Mackenzie King, always the most suspicious of British motives, said that each country should develop the routes important to it, and there should not be a single Commonwealth body to control aviation. 
 However, he did agree that there should be an international authority, as long as it included the USA. 
 All the Commonwealth Prime Ministers agreed that a full international conference should be called. 
 The British insistence on the international control of frequencies and routes remained the main point of contention between the US and Commonwealth positions. 
 Beaverbrook reiterated this position to Berle when the two met on 21 July. 
 Although Beaverbrook felt that specific routes could be discussed, the British and Canadians backed away from this when the USA proposed discussion of the North Atlantic route in September. 
 Both insisted that any bilateral talks should wait until after the international conference, for which a date had at last been set: President Roosevelt issued a statement on 4 September inviting the nations of the world to a conference on international civil aviation to be held in Chicago in November. 
 With the conference at last on the calendar, the various countries began preparatory activities to enhance their bargaining positions. 
 Ambassador Winant reported from London that the British were increasingly uneasy over the fundamental difference in attitude towards international control that existed between themselves and the USA. 
 They were also worried that the USA would go ahead and plan a postwar aviation policy before they could even begin one. 
 Berle met Michael Wright, counsellor at the British embassy in Washington, on 21 October, and Wright talked of a &bquo;head-on collision&equo; of US and British policies. 
 Some half-way point would have to be found, Wright said, which Berle believed was British policy all along.  
 However, the British were indeed very worried about a potential US victory and the opening of the skies to unbridled competition. 
 Their preparations took several forms. 
 The first was yet another Commonwealth meeting, to prepare a broad policy among the powerful Commonwealth countries that would help to offset the massive US influence over the Latin American countries. 
 The talks, held on 23&ndash;30 October in Montreal, produced total agreement on the need for an international authority to administer civil aviation, or, if that was not possible, a regional operators' conference. 
 Australia and New Zealand even wanted to go as far as the international operation of aircraft on trunk routes. 
 Only Canada, concerned as ever about US reaction, had reservations, insisting that any such body should not be too centralized, and that routes should be decided through interim bilateral agreements. 
 Canada also proposed an escalator clause for an airline to increase services if its aircraft were more than 65 per cent full. 
 This was rejected by the other Commonwealth countries and Britain because it would allow the USA to gain an unbeatable advantage. 
 The countries also agreed on the need for jointly operated trunk routes, and to the creation of a Commonwealth Air Transport Council to oversee Imperial air services. 
 In addition to securing Commonwealth support for their position, the British sought to consolidate their own aviation policy into some definable form, something which had eluded them for several years. 
 It had been decided in July 1944 that the Cabinet Committee on post-War Civil Aviation should be wound up and replaced by a Minister responsible specifically for this area of policy. 
 There was also pressure for a whole ministry responsible for civil aviation, but this was strongly resisted by the Air Ministry. 
 On 9 October, it was announced that Lord Swinton, a leading Conservative and former minister-resident in West Africa, would be made Minister of Civil Aviation. 
 Churchill believed that Britain needed a minister of Cabinet rank to carry out properly the forthcoming negotiations. 
 One of Swinton's first duties was to oversee the presentation of the new British White Paper on civil aviation, Cmd. 6561, which was circulated to Cabinet that month. 
 The paper spoke in general terms about the lack of prewar co-operation, except on technical matters, and the need for some form of international collaboration to eliminate wasteful competition. 
 It proposed an international convention on air transport under the auspices of an international authority. 
 This was the policy the British intended to  pursue at Chicago, much to US chagrin. 
 They would press for the international allocation of quotas, as well as mail and air freight, and expected some Commonwealth and European support. 
 Swinton left for Chicago, where he held talks with Adolf Berle on the first day of the conference. 
 Here, he reiterated the British position based on the new White paper with &bquo;bluntness&equo;; he told Berle he was not prepared to discuss routes, but could discuss the principles of a civil aviation convention and the equitable division of traffic. 
 Berle offered the American objections to international control, insisting that the British proposals amounted to a 50&ndash;50 division of traffic on the North Atlantic route. 
 It was clear that the lines were drawn and that the two countries would have to compromise or find allies if the conference was not to degenerate into a complete fiasco. 
 The British War Cabinet even went so far as to create a special committee to guide Swinton during the talks. 
 It was chaired by the ubiquitous Beaverbrook, and consisted of Lords Cranborne and Leathers (Secretary of State for Dominion Affairs and Minister of Transport, respectively), Sir Stafford Cripps (Minister for Aircraft Production), and Sir Archibald Sinclair (Secretary of State for Air). 
 The Chicago Civil Aviation Conference of 1944 is rarely discussed today, but it established the forms and organizations that have governed postwar civil aviation to this day. 
 Aviation before the war had been considered by most countries, especially the imperial powers, as an important tool of government policy. 
 Airlines had been used to link parts of empires together, regardless of economic cost, and the principle of the state and state airlines working together was well established. 
 By the time of the Chicago conference, &bquo;many nations felt that the primary objectives of international airlines were political and military and that economic and other objectives were only of secondary importance&equo;. 
 Only the United States had no state airline, and believed that airways should be open to free market capitalism: &bquo;In general, the Chicago conference can be described&hellip; as an attempt by the United States to capitalise on its overwhelmingly strong bargaining position in international aviation by securing for itself a near monopoly of long-haul air transport.' 
 The Chicago discussions were attended by fifty-one countries, many of which were still under German or Japanese occupation, so the proceedings were dominated by the USA, Britain, and the Commonwealth (the USSR  backed out at the last minute). 
 The USA held to its position of open airways, with an international body having only a consultative role; but it withheld the right for airlines to operate from any American point. 
 This was its strongest bargaining position. 
 At the opposite extreme, Australia and New Zealand wanted an international authority to operate the main trunk routes and aircraft, one moreover that would become an agency of the proposed United Nations. 
 This was quickly rejected by the conference, and the two countries moved towards the more moderate British and Canadian positions, which spoke in more general terms about an international authority and quotas on routes and frequencies. 
 Although discussion on other matters, such as technical standards and the creation of an international authority to oversee them, proceeded easily, the question of economic control remained insoluble. 
 The British used the four &bquo;freedoms&equo; agreed at the Commonwealth meeting in October 1943 as the basis for discussion, but refused to consider a US proposal for a fifth freedom: the right to pick up passengers, mail, and freight at intermediate stops not in the country of origin of the airline or its ultimate destination. 
 The British and other European countries knew that this would allow US airlines to fly from the USA, pick up passengers in Britain or in Europe, and fly on to any other destination, which would mean complete US domination of civil aviation. 
 The British Cabinet committee, meeting on 14 November, turned down the US idea, proposing instead a 50&ndash;50 division of frequency of traffic on the North Atlantic; but the following day it decided that the fifth freedom should be accepted, subject to safeguards. 
 This appeared to offer a real chance of a final agreement on the most difficult point, until on 18 November Adolf Berle proposed all five freedoms, with an escalator clause allowing an airline to increase its agreed number of flights if its planes were more than 65 per cent full. 
 This new proposal was completely unacceptable to Beaverbrook, who wanted to give a simple &bquo;no&equo; answer. 
 This produced complete deadlock in the conference, which now went to the highest governmental level, showing the importance attached to the matter by both the USA and the UK. 
 President Roosevelt wired Churchill on 21 November that both sides had compromised, but the UK insisted on restricting the number of aircraft irrespective of the amount of traffic: &bquo;This seems to me a form of strangulation,&equo; he wrote, and he asked Churchill not to let the conference collapse. 
 Churchill replied the following day that an agreement had already been reached until Berle had introduced new proposals on 18 November. 
 This was unacceptable, and he suggested finalizing  the technical agreements if the issue of services could not be resolved at that time. 
 Roosevelt telegraphed again that British insistence on traffic only between certain points was not realistic, and that the economic viability of services depended on being able to pick up intermediate traffic. 
 This showed clearly the American concern with economics versus the British concern with preserving a political and strategic position on the airways. 
 Roosevelt sent a note to Ambassador Winant two days later saying: &bquo;please take the following message personally to Winston and convince him that he has got to come through. 
 You will understand how important it is that he does,&equo; The message was that if there was no agreement at Chicago, Congress might not be in a mood to furnish further British Lend-Lease requirements. 
 Under this threat, Churchill sent a long reply on 28 November, explaining why Britain could not accept Berle's proposals. 
 He reiterated that the USA had a huge advantage in aircraft, and a combination of the escalator clause with fifth freedom rights &bquo;would enable American aircraft to carry most of the traffic between the UK and the Dominions of India and all foreign countries, as well as between all nations of the Commonwealth&equo;. 
 He then asked for an adjournment of the conference if agreement was not possible. 
 Berle hoped to have the British blamed for breaking up the conference, as he knew he had the support of the Latin American states and some European countries. 
 In his opinion, the British had supported the fifth freedom before 18 November and then refused to accept it. 
 Berle also was not impressed with Swinton, who always pleaded that he was bound by instructions from London: &bquo;Swinton is ill-prepared&hellip; he also tends to be arrogant and inflexible.' 
 With the conference appearing doomed to collapse over the issue of the fifth freedom, Canada made a last-ditch effort to save the situation by proposing the first four freedoms, and one weekly round-trip flight that could be increased under an escalator clause of 65 per cent capacity and over. 
 Intermediate stops (that is, those affected by the fifth freedom) would be decided by the international body. 
 This so-called &bquo;Canadian compromise&equo; was admired by the delegates for its intent, but both the USA and Britain rejected it, the USA insisting on the fifth freedom, but with the possibility of opting out. 
 for their part, the British did not see the Canadian proposal as much of a compromise, and indeed seemed already to have given up on the conference. 
 Lord Swinton rejected both the American and Canadian positions. 
 Beaverbrook and Churchill agreed with him that Britain had  compromised enough and the issue of economic control of air routes could be decided later. 
 Although the Chicago conference failed to resolve the basic difference in viewpoint between Britain and the USA, it did produce significant achievements. 
 A Provisional International Civil Aviation Organization (PICAO) was created, with its seat in Montreal, to become a permanent organization when more than half the Chicago delegates had ratified the appropriate convention. 
 This was accomplished in 1947. 
 A whole series of technical agreements were also signed; these were placed under the auspices of the PICAO, and form the technical basis for all civil aviation. 
 A transit agreement granting the first two freedoms (the right to overfly territory and to land to refuel and in emergencies) was quickly ratified and remains in force today. 
 A US proposal for a transport agreement based on all five freedoms was accepted by only sixteen of the attending countries, and never took effect; the USA itself abandoned the idea in 1946. 
 Berle told Roosevelt in his official report on the conference that despite its failure to decide the main issue (for which he blamed Swinton and Beaverbrook), a great deal had been achieved, and positions were made known: &bquo;A substantial beginning has been made to opening the air for commerce. 
 It is not too much to say that we entered the conference in the law and atmosphere of the 17th century and we came out with a fair prospect of 20th century conditions.' 
 Swinton's report to the British government was somewhat different in tone. 
 He called the selection of the Interim Council of the PICAO a &bquo;travesty&equo;. 
 There had been no agreement on the main issues of contention, but (aside from Canada) the Empire was with Britain, he said. 
 Commonwealth performance during the conference had been magnificent, and valuable contacts made with other powers. 
 Swinton believed that the UK had left the conference on good ground because US demands had been so unlimited. 
 He noted that the USA was already in search of bilateral aviation agreements, with the aim of obtaining air rights on a piecemeal basis, and he advocated that the UK should do the same. 
 On 9&ndash;10 December Commonwealth delegates from Chicago moved on to Montreal, where they announced the formation of the Commonwealth Air Transport Council, a forum for the exchange of views and co-ordination of air operations. 
 It was to be based on the British proposals in Chicago. 
 There was also agreement to set up a co-operative Britain-Australia-New Zealand-Canada trans-Pacific service, making an &bquo;all-red&equo; round-the-world service a possibility. 
 Further Commonwealth talks were held in London in  late December at which various parallel services were agreed to link Britain with India, Australia, and New Zealand (by BOAC and QANTAS), and with South Africa (BOAC and South African Airways). 
 Under these services, revenues would be shared among the participating companies. 
 This scheme showed that the British intended to pursue a more centralized aviation service within the Commonwealth, very much at odds with the American &bquo;open skies&equo; policy. 
 The new parallel services began in May 1945, with Avro Lancastrians (converted Lancaster bombers) flying the long route via India to Australia and New Zealand. 
 Britain succeeded in creating a Commonwealth &bquo;special relationship&equo; in civil aviation after 1945 which compensated in part for its inability to obtain international approval for a more regulated global system. 
 As the war ended and BOAC prepared to resume regular commercial services with whatever aircraft it could obtain, the issues unresolved at Chicago continued to haunt British planners. 
 Pan American intended to resume its twice-weekly service to Britain as permitted under the 1937 agreement, which immediately caused anxiety at BOAC. 
 American bilateral agreements that permitted fifth freedom rights especially alarmed the British, as they believed that the United States would be able to scoop up the best routes in a piecemeal fashion. 
 An American agreement with Ireland was especially irksome to Churchill. 
 As the Americans hoped to obtain substantial rights in the Middle East, the British took the opportunity to use their influence in those countries and warn the governments about what wide American penetration of their air services would mean. 
 This created something of a diplomatic flurry between London and Washington, as the Americans sought assurances that the British were not trying to sabotage their plans. 
 The British, of course, denied any such thing. 
 Early in 1945, the Coalition Government began consideration of the structure of British postwar civil aviation. 
 Lord Swinton presented a paper to Cabinet on 24 January arguing that Britain should have three airline companies: the nationalized BOAC for long-haul overseas services; a company responsible for services to Europe; and another one for services to South America. 
 A company called British Latin American Airlines had been registered in february 1944 by five British shipping companies with interests in South America. 
 Swinton proposed that BOAC and interested railway companies should operate the European airline, and BOAC and the shipping companies the South American airline. 
 Lord Knollys, chairman of BOAC, was not particularly pleased with these proposals, nor were other  members of the Cabinet. 
 Sir Archibald Sinclair, the Secretary of State for Air, thought there should be only one company, and Lord Beaverbrook stated that free enterprise should have the widest possible scope in the operation of the companies. 
 As a sign of the future, Ernest Bevin, Minister of Labour, and one of the senior Labour Party ministers, said his party had rather different views on the matter, but would accept the general proposals for the time being. 
 Despite the opposition of the Air Staff, which labelled the post of Minister of Civil Aviation separate from the Air Ministry &bquo;disastrous&equo;, the War Cabinet decided in January 1945 to place BOAC and civil aviation under their own ministry, to be headed by the incumbent Minister of Civil Aviation. 
 This was accomplished quickly and the appropriate legislation was passed by Parliament in April. 
 Swinton's idea for three companies was also presented to parliament in a White Paper, but the general election of July 1945 brought Labour to power before any of the wartime government's plans could be implemented. 
 The Labour party's plans to nationalize British civil aviation were based both on their general policy for the nationalization of industry, and on a desire to avoid the haphazard market of the years before 1939. 
 The new government intended to treat aviation as part of its overall restructuring of the British economy. 
 However, the basic structure of three national airlines as proposed in the Swinton plan was retained. 
 A Cabinet Civil Aviation Committee was created under the chairmanship of Lord Addison, the new Secretary of State for Dominion Affairs. 
 It advised the Cabinet to continue with bilateral international agreements until a permanent international authority was created, to nationalize the country's airfields, and to allow up to 20 per cent private capital in the European and South American companies. 
 Lord Winster, the new Minister of Civil Aviation, wrote in an annex to Addison's paper that the government should retain at least some private investment in the airlines to profit from their interest and experience. 
 The Cabinet, meeting on 18 October, was unable to decide whether it was preferable to retain some private investment, as the Civil Aviation Committee recommended, or to proceed to complete nationalization. 
 Within days, the civil aviation group of the Parliamentary Labour party sent a memorandum to Cabinet arguing for the complete nationalization of the European and South American companies. 
 It argued that state ownership was party policy, and that the limited private capital contemplated would provide little real incentive for investment. 
 On 26 October, the  Cabinet decided to nationalize the three British airlines. 
 Finally, in December 1945, the Ministry of Civil Aviation's White paper on British air services, Cmd. 6712, which set down the new government's aviation policy, was submitted to the Cabinet by Lord Winster. 
 It called for a national plan, with the full co-operation of Commonwealth governments. 
 UK air transport would be under national control, but with three separate companies: the existing BOAC, for services to the Empire and Commonwealth, North America, Middle and Far East, and Pacific; a new British European Airways (BEA); and British South American Airways (BSAA). 
 The Boards of Directors of each airline would be appointed by the Cabinet, and their profits and losses would be borne by the Exchequer. 
 All airfields in the country (with the exception of small private aerodromes) would be nationalized, and the government would continue with the development of new aircraft as recommended by the Brabazon Committee. 
 The new Civil Aviation Bill was passed by Parliament in August 1946. 
 As the British moved to create a new regime for their airlines after the war, the outstanding unresolved issue from the Chicago conference remained: the need for an Anglo-American air transport agreement. 
 As noted above, the USA pursued bilateral rights with many European, Latin American, and Middle Eastern countries, using the so-called &bquo;Chicago form&equo; and in all cases insisting on fifth freedom rights. 
 The British attempted on occasion to forestall this, provoking considerable anger in Washington. 
 Anglo-American talks were held in London on 24 August 1945 in an effort to break the deadlock, but were unsuccessful. 
 In British eyes, the Americans remained &bquo;intensely nationalistic&equo;. 
 Finally, in the latter months of 1945, as Britain tried to obtain a massive loan from the USA to remain financially solvent, a conference was arranged for January 1946 in Bermuda. 
 The Bermuda talks not only resulted in an agreement for air transportation between the two most important civil aviation powers, but provided the pattern by which all other bilateral agreements on civil aviation were arranged. 
 The talks proceeded quickly, without the complex formulae on frequencies and capacity that had characterized the Chicago talks. 
 Instead, each airline was to be allowed to use its discretion as to frequency and capacity within reasonable grounds. 
 Britain agreed to allow fifth freedom traffic through specific airports. 
 In effect, the Bermuda talks produced a gentlemen's agreement that neither country's airlines would take unfair advantage of the market. 
 The British had retreated so far from the position  they had held at Chicago that Sir William Hildred and Sir Henry Self, in charge of the British delegation, were afraid that they would be overruled by the Air Ministry and BOAC. 
 To ensure that they were not, US Secretary of State James Byrnes sent a message to Ambassador Winant in London that the USA was satisfied with the Bermuda agreement and a quick signature &bquo;would contribute materially toward a favourable recognition in Congress to the loan agreement&equo;. 
 The Bermuda discussions were brought before the British Cabinet on 4 February; Lord Winster said that the talks were only preliminary, but the Americans were treating them as a final agreement. 
 As such, he could not recommend the draft agreement that had emerged from the conversations. 
 Hugh Dalton, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, said an agreement would have a powerful effect on the crucial loan negotiations, and was probably as much as could be achieved. 
 Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin agreed. 
 However, both the president of the Board of Trade, Sir Stafford Cripps, and the Dominions Secretary, Lord Addison, thought that the fifth freedom clause went against policy as agreed with the Commonwealth. 
 The issue was then referred to the Cabinet's Civil Aviation Committee for further consideration. 
 The Civil Aviation Committee met the next day and challenged two parts of the draft agreement that the Americans had inserted: the right of civil aircraft to use the US-leased bases in the Caribbean and Atlantic, and the right of US airlines to &bquo;change gauge&equo; in Britain, that is, switch to smaller aircraft for flights going on as part of the fifth freedom. 
 The Committee opposed these as giving the US airlines an added advantage. 
 The USA quickly dropped these clauses to meet the British objections, and the final act was ready for signature on 11 February. 
 The British Cabinet also gave its approval on that date. 
 The Bermuda agreement settled the Anglo-American civil aviation dispute on amicable terms. 
 It made airline rates subject to review by each government, permitted each country fifth freedom rights in the other, subject to adjustment, and referred disagreements to the PICAO. 
 Among the various routes that were agreed upon were US routes via London to the Middle East and South Asia, and through Hong Kong. 
 Britain was allowed to use New York and Miami for flights to the Caribbean, and Honolulu for Pacific flights. 
 The obvious success of the Bermuda agreement was shown by the issue of a joint statement in September 1946 that the Bermuda wording would be the basis for all future bilateral air agreements signed by each country. 
 It represented the single biggest step towards the creation of the international air agreements of today.  
 Ultimately, the British could not win the battle for civil aviation after 1945 because their economic performance and uncompetitive aircraft industry were outclassed by the size and strength of the American competition. 
 Nevertheless, civil aviation was correctly perceived by the British and Americans alike as an area of enormous growth after 1945. 
 Hence, each made great efforts to achieve a dominant position. 
 for the British, this meant state-owned airlines flying state-developed aircraft operating on agreed internationally controlled routes and frequencies. 
 The USA was in the opposite camp, fighting for complete free enterprise for airlines (except in situations in which US airlines were subject to foreign discrimination) and open access to all countries. 
 Naturally, the position of each country derived from its perceived view of the postwar scene: in an open environment US airlines and aircraft could not lose, whereas Britain would be driven from the air. 
 That the British eventually accepted the American view in most details shows that they had largely subsumed the aviation issue in the larger question of economic viability, and used aviation as a quid pro quo  for the American loan. 
 The British acceptance of the US position in most respects at Bermuda reflected both its final abandonment of internationalization, and the realization that Britain, too, could benefit from the fifth freedom. 
 In an era when numerous refuelling stops were still a necessity, any additional traffic that could be obtained was an advantage. 
 British flights to the Caribbean and South America, and across the Pacific, could now use American airports and pick up traffic there. 
 Although the British airlines would not match the American competition for several years after the war, British aircraft were able to recapture some ground in the 1950s, especially when the new Brabazon types came into production. 
 Despite many early problems, aircraft such as the Comet and the Britannia proved to be the equal of their US competitors, and in some ways were even more advanced. 
 For the British, then, the picture was not ultimately as black as it appeared to be in 1945. for their part, the Americans viewed the British with considerable suspicion, and harboured their traditional fears of being outmanoeuvred. 
 Britain's apparent ability to rally Commonwealth support at Chicago, and subsequent development of a Commonwealth airline system that differed substantially in form from the Bermuda agreement, seemed to the Americans to be evidence of Britain's continued world power. 
 The fact that Britain could use air bases and airports in its territory throughout the world was perceived in Washington as an enormous advantage, and contributed to the American insistence on free and open competition. 
 The Americans did not perceive the true weakness of Britain's position until the British loan request in 1945, and then were able to use that to their advantage. 
 In the end, the Bermuda agreement satisfied the concerns of both countries, and its landmark status was shown by its widespread imitation thereafter. 
 JIM TOMLINSON Brunel University  
 The Attlee Government and the Balance of Payments, 1945&ndash;1951 
 In The Future of Socialism  &mdash; and in a classic revisionist sentence &mdash; Anthony Crosland argued that democratic socialists, instead of fussing about &bquo;glaring and conspicuous evils, squalor and injustice and distressed areas&hellip; have to fuss about the balance of payments, and incentives, and higher productivity&equo;. 
 Whatever the implications of this view for socialist ideology, it was certainly a priority forced upon the Attlee governments. 
 Those administrations faced biennial balance-of-payments crises of great severity which shaped their whole approach to economic policy-making. 
 The balance of payments in the period immediately after the Second World War cannot be treated as a simple economic constraint, imposing inescapable policy responses. 
 It was not simply a matter of exporting enough to pay for necessary imports, as contemporary economic propaganda often suggested. 
 It also involved a very substantial outflow of government expenditure abroad, as well as foreign investment. 
 Equally, the responses to this problem were not pre-ordained by the state of the economy, and the choice among those responses had a number of highly significant political as well as economic ramifications.  
 Given this broad context, the purposes of this article are threefold: to outline some of the complexities of the payments situation in the period 1945&ndash;51; to discuss some of the military expenditure and foreign policy aspects of that situation, and how these were debated at this time; and, finally, to examine one of the most politically problematic aspects of balance-of-payments policy in this period: its impact on the sterling area in general and the colonies in particular. 
 What was the balance-of-payments problem in this period? 
 Clearly the legacy of the war was a huge current account deficit, with exports in 1945 at only 30 per cent of their prewar level (imports 60 per cent), and shipping earnings substantially diminished. 
 On capital account, around a quarter of prewar foreign investments had been sold, and very large debts accumulated in the form of sterling balances. 
 No wonder, then, that at the cessation of Lend-Lease, which had until VJ Day bridged the gap in the British accounts, Keynes could talk of a &bquo;financial Dunkirk&equo;. 
 While the problems of the overall balance of payments hardly came as a surprise (though the speed with which Lend-Lease ended did  come as a shock), the problem of the dollar was less readily anticipated. 
 For most of the 1940s the core difficulty from the British point of view was the dollar shortage, which was the key to the reserve position. 
 plainly the wartime legacy mightily constrained the policy options of the Attlee government. 
 Any government would have been likely in such a situation to control imports, promote exports, and in the meantime borrow. 
 Nevertheless, there was still considerable scope for policy to affect the situation, as is clearly apparent from Table 1. 
 The balance-of-payments problem plainly cannot be reduced to one of &bquo;how to pay for essential imports&equo;. 
 A significant part of the problem was related on the one hand to the scale of government overseas expenditure (government current transactions), and on the other to the scale of capital exports. 
 Both of these (though in different ways) were strongly connected to policy decisions taken by the Labour government which are discussed below.   
 Table 2 gives some details of the dollar balance. 
 It shows that while the UK was in deep deficit in trade with the dollar area, in most years this was added to significantly by the deficit of the rest of the sterling area (broadly speaking, the Dominions minus Canada, plus the colonies, plus a few other countries like Iraq). 
 Gold (which was, of course, substitutable for dollars) was obtainable on a limited scale by trade within the sterling area from South Africa. 
 The huge loss of dollars under &bquo;other transactions&equo; in 1947   reflects the short-lived abolition of controls over access to dollars in that year. 
 The scale of Britain's overseas government expenditure was a source of intense debate at the time, and has remained a source of criticism of the Attlee government's policies. 
 Was this a case of folie de grandeur , in which Britain's economic recovery was sacrificed to anachronistic (and unsocialist?) attempts to retain a great power stance in the world? 
 This was certainly how Keynes saw it in one of his last memoranda, in February 1946. 
 In this paper Keynes argued that imports were being efficiently controlled and were close to the minimum for essentials. 
 The problem lay elsewhere: 
 The current and prospective demands upon us for political and military expenditure overseas have already gone far beyond the figure which can, on any hypothesis, be sustained&hellip; 
 It would not be a source of comfort to the hardpressed British public if they were to become aware that (reckoning our overseas statistics globally not a single bean of substance for themselves or of capital equipment for British manufacturers is likely to be left over from the American credit; and that we shall require, on balance, the whole of it, and, unless we change our ways, much more to feed and sustain Allies, liberated territories and ex-enemies, to maintain our military prestige overseas, and, generally speaking to cut a dash in the world considerably above our means. 
 The figures on those commitments, which Keynes called &bquo;extremely shocking&equo;, are given in Table 3. 
 Keynes's was by no means a lone voice criticizing the extent of government commitments overseas, The (unpublished) Economic Survey for 1946, the Balance of payments Working party, and the Bank of England all expressed grave doubts on this score. 
 The figures in Table 4 show how many of these responsibilities were eventually reduced, prior to the Korean War, but much more slowly than Keynes and others called for. 
 The table makes it clear that the bulk of overseas government expenditure was incurred within the rest of the sterling area (RSA), and did not therefore add directly  to the dollar problem. 
 But this is misleading in the sense that much of this expenditure did generate purchasing power in recipient countries, which led to    demand for dollar goods, demand which was not effectively curtailed by the exchange controls. 
 (This point will be returned to below.)  
 The debate on overseas government expenditure in the crucial period leading up to the sterling crisis of 1947 can be characterized, in broad terms, as a battle between Dalton and Attlee on the one side, and Bevin and the service chiefs on the other. 
 However, Attlee's position was a complex one: he was more ready than anyone to criticize strategic arguments used to justify such expenditure, but was never willing to push the arguments to the extent of causing a serious rift with Bevin, who was perhaps the key minister in the government after Attlee.  
 When Keynes's memorandum was discussed in Cabinet in February 1946, defence expenditure for 1946/7 had already been cut by 14 per cent. 
 But there was a marked reluctance to accept that the situation was as serious as Keynes portrayed it (a portrayal broadly supported by a paper from the Balance of payments Working party). 
 While there was a general recognition that the matter demanded further discussion, only Dalton urged support for the general thrust of Keynes's paper. 
 Bevin said little directly on the issue, except to stress the political problems of a rapid withdrawal from the Dutch East Indies and the need to consult the Chiefs of Staff. 
 Attlee proposed further debate in the Defence Committee, while stressing the impossibility of any immediate withdrawal of British forces from India, Indonesia, or Palestine. 
 Most of the key decisions on military and political expenditure overseas in this period seem to have been taken in the Defence Committee, and simply endorsed by the Cabinet. 
 The division in Cabinet between Dalton plus Attlee (plus, occasionally, Morrison) versus Bevin and the Chiefs of Staff, supported by A. V. Alexander, the Minister of Defence, was reflected in the Defence Committee's first meeting on 11 January 1946, when Dalton and Attlee queried the level of British forces around the world, and Bevin and the defence chiefs defended that level. 
 In this and succeeding meetings the focus of attention was primarily on the manpower involved in the armed forces, with some discussion of the public expenditure costs. 
 There was, at this stage and in this forum, no discussion of the direct foreign exchange costs of those overseas commitments. 
 Attlee was not content simply to urge the need for economies. 
 He also challenged the central premise of the service chiefs' and Bevin's argument: the belief that the Mediterranean was absolutely crucial to Britain s international position. 
 He &bquo;hoped that the strategic assumption that it was vital to us to keep open the Mediterranean and that in fact we could, should be re-examined. 
 He did not see how we could possibly do so under modern conditions.' 
 The ensuing debate encapsulates much of importance in the evolution of overseas expenditure in the early years of the Attlee government. 
 Bevin, in response to Attlee's scepticism about Britain's Mediterranean posture, argued that the stability of the area was enormously important to prevent war. 
 At the same time he tried to make an economic case for expenditure in that area: &bquo;Moreover, from the trade point of view, this area was probably worth between one and one and a half million employed men to  this country. 
 If we lost our political influence in this area we should suffer a great economic setback.' 
 The debate was later joined at greater length, following circulation of memoranda by Attlee, Bevin, and the Chiefs of Staff. 
 Bullock has described the paper by Attlee as &bquo;amongst the most radical produced by a British Prime Minister in Office&equo;. 
 Attlee attacked the very basis of the perception that the Mediterranean was crucial to Britain in time of war, arguing that with the development of air power the resources needed to protect sea routes from Gibraltar to Suez would be impossible to find. 
 He further argued that no conceivable military strength in the area could defend access to oil resources against attack from the north (i.e. the USSR). 
 The Suez route to Australia could be replaced by the Cape route or via the Panama Canal. 
 He saw the attachment to the Middle East by Britain as &bquo;sentimental&equo;, and wanted to redefine Britain as the easterly extension of a strategic area based in the USA, rather than a power looking eastwards through the Mediterranean to India and beyond. 
 Bevin's response was implicitly to accept the strategic vulnerability of the Middle East in wartime, but to argue that Britain's presence in that area was crucial to its role as a great political  power. 
 Bevin did not accept Attlee's idea of resiting Britain's main base in Africa, but he did share in a developing view that Africa should play a much greater role in Britain's imperial policy, especially because of its (alleged) economic potential. 
 The Chiefs of Staff focused on the strategic arguments for the British presence in the Middle East. 
 The basic contention of their paper was that if Britain did not dominate an area, the Russians would. 
 This general doctrine applied particularly to the Middle East because: (1) it lay on the route of any Soviet expansion into Africa; (2) it could provide bases for a Soviet role in Africa; (3) it formed a forward position for the defence of South Africa and India; (4) it was a base for bombing the Soviet Union; and (5) it was an area crucial for its oil resources. 
 These papers were debated inconclusively at the Defence Committee meeting on 5 April 1946; further inconclusive discussion followed on 27 May 1946 and again on 19 July. 
 At the second of these meetings Attlee stressed that the strategic arguments about the Middle East were not valid because no country would be willing to grant bases for military action, and  all Britain would achieve would be to pose a needless and pointless threat to the Soviet Union. 
 He argued that access to oil resources could be secured by negotiation with the Russians. 
 Against this the Chiefs of Staff reiterated their view of the strategic importance of the Middle East and the belief that the area must be dominated either by Britain or the Soviet Union. 
 These arguments rumbled on into 1947. 
 But by March that year the Chiefs of Staff were recording a victory for their view of the Middle East, and were arguing that this implied that Britain must hang on to the right to return to bases in Egypt, even in the absence of agreement. 
 Although nowhere recorded in the public documents, the reason for Attlee's climbdown on this central issue for Britain's postwar overseas policy stance was a threat from the Chiefs of Staff to resign if the Prime Minister persisted in his criticisms. 
 A number of points may be made about this debate. 
 First, it is apparent how little the foreign Office and Chiefs of Staff were concerned with the problems of the British economy. 
 As far as the Foreign Office was concerned, postwar economic problems were transient. 
 This view is summarized in a memorandum sent to embassies abroad by the Foreign Office early in 1945, arguing for a necessary linkage of diplomatic commitments to economic strength, but going on to state that Britain's looming economic problems were likely to be temporary: &bquo;It must, however, be stressed that, given skill and good fortune, our financial difficulties will be acute only during the immediate post-war years. 
 There are sound reasons for hoping that they will be a temporary phenomenon, for this country possesses all the skill and resources required to recover a dominating place in the economic world.' 
 There is little to suggest that this view changed, at least until the sterling crisis of 1947. 
 Similarly, the Chiefs of Staff showed little appreciation of the economic context. 
 Attlee chided them for ignoring any notion of what the country could afford in suggesting armed forces levels, and for suggesting that cutting spending on the armed forces to &pound;700 million would virtually immobilize them. 
 Alexander seems to have shared this insouciant attitude to the economic problem, arguing at one stage that there should not be a problem of competition for manpower between civilian and military uses as &bquo;a slight increase in productivity&equo; would solve the manpower gap.  
 The Chiefs of Staff also seem to have been strikingly narrow in their strategic vision, disregarding the political and diplomatic problems arising from Britain's role in the Middle East. 
 In their view, if strategic necessity were established, local sentiment could ultimately be set aside. 
 Bevin and the Foreign Office were on occasion more sensitive to this issue &mdash; but in Bevin's case this produced the bizarre proposal to hang on in the Middle East from a base in inhospitable (but British) territory 2,000 miles from the Suez Canal, Even Bullock is forced to concede that Bevin was &bquo;obsessed&equo; with the Middle East, an obsession he never seems to have lost. 
 Looking at the question from an economic standpoint, the key justification for a continued British presence in the Middle East was access to oil. 
 It follows that the key issue is the extent to which there was (or was believed to be) a significant Soviet threat to those supplies, especially in southern Iran. 
 In fact, the evidence suggests that at the time of the great debates over defence and the Middle East in 1946 Britain had a realistic view of Soviet intentions in this area &mdash; that they fundamentally consisted in a determination to secure access to oil concessions in northern  Iran. 
 This view, which had been accepted by Britain at an earlier date, was reiterated by the Ministry of Fuel and power to the Defence Committee in 1946. 
 If the foreign and defence policy-makers may be accused of insufficient attention to the economic aspects of their policies, it is far from clear that the economic arguments were pressed in a manner most likely to bring about a re-assessment of overseas commitments. 
 Despite the memorandum by Keynes referred to above, the foreign exchange aspect of overseas government expenditure was conspicuously absent from the debate in the Defence Committee from its beginnings in 1946 right through to August 1947, by which time it may be argued that the damage had largely already been done. 
 In a memorandum in that month of crisis the Ministry of Defence apparently for the first time addressed the issue of the foreign exchange costs of existing policy, in response to the claim by the Chancellor of the Exchequer at the end of July that Britain's overseas military  expenditure was running at &pound;140 million p.a. 
 It argued that of the half million British troops overseas, 200,000 were in areas that did not create a foreign currency liability, and of the rest few were in areas requiring direct dollar expenditure; &bquo;it follows that the contribution to be made to the balance of  payments problem by the withdrawal of troops in overseas theatres will be strictly limited, will apply only to those areas when there is at present a currency obligation, and will produce little or no direct dollar saving.' 
 This argument seems to have had some effect, for while the Chancellor of the Exchequer was asked to look more closely at the dollar costs of overseas forces, the Defence Ministry's view that no further cuts in forces should be sought was accepted. 
 At one level the Ministry of Defence argument about the dollar costs of overseas expenditure was not absurd. 
 Most of the expenditure was outside the dollar area, and did not give rise to immediate dollar payments. 
 But, other things being equal, such financial transfers would ultimately lead to a real transfer of resources to the recipients of expenditure. 
 If the consequence were a rise in imports of dollar goods then a significant impact on the sterling area's reserves of dollars and gold would be felt. 
 In conditions of general &bquo;dollar shortage&equo; the effects were likely to be significant. 
 In addition, the effects of overseas political and military expenditure were not exhausted by the more or less direct effects on the balance of payments but obviously also involved tying up substantial numbers of men in the armed forces and the supply industries. 
 In fact, the debate about Britain's military expenditure (home and overseas) in this period was largely conducted in terms of manpower targets, a legacy of the war which was continued by the Labour government as an important &bquo;planning&equo; device. 
 Hence most of the pressure on the armed forces to reduce their activities took the form of persistent downward revision of the numbers of men (and rather limited numbers of women) allocated to them. 
 The reduction in numbers was still startlingly small &mdash; for example, even after  the convertibility crisis of 1947 had led to a further downward revision of the targets for 31 March 1948, there were still 937,000 in uniform, supported by 350,000 in supplying industries. 
 (At 1 July 1947 there were approximately half a million troops overseas.) 
 Dalton was fond of contrasting these numbers with the half million total troops thought likely to be necessary in peacetime by the war-time Coalition Government. 
 The other way in which the economic aspects of military expenditure were presented was in the form of the public expenditure costs. 
 However, this was definitely secondary to the manpower approach, though again Dalton liked to contrast actual levels of expenditure with the &pound;500 million which the Coalition had thought likely to be necessary in peacetime,  pointing out in early 1947 that the current level of expenditure at over &pound;800 million meant 2s. in the pound extra on the income tax in comparison with the Coalition figure. 
 The debate about overseas government expenditure may be seen as in one sense straightforward &mdash; an unsurprising clash of departmental interests, which, given the political weight of the participants, led only to a gradual though cumulative reduction in commitments. 
 Until the 1947 crisis drove home the extent of Britain's overseas payments difficulties Bevin and the Chiefs of Staff were able to defend their programmes quite successfully. 
 The advocates of a more rapid rundown were hampered by the domination of the debate by manpower figures, which led the issue away from the balance of payments. 
 proponents of more rapid reductions in overseas expenditure also tended to fall into the trap of contrasting such expenditure with expenditure on imported consumption goods. 
 The problem was commonly posed as guns versus butter, or, in the case of Keynes's original memorandum, overseas troops versus the bacon ration. 
 Defenders of the scale of British commitments, then and more recently, have thus been able to ignore the extent to which not only consumption but also production and productive efficiency were inhibited by the dollar shortage &mdash; both directly, by restricting currency available for imported capital equipment, and indirectly, by diverting domestic output of such equipment into dollar markets. 
 Finally on this aspect of the problem, there is the question of Germany. 
 In the immediate postwar period Germany constituted the single most important drain on the dollar. 
 This was an unintended consequence of Britain's successful attempt to occupy the most industrialized and populous part of Germany. 
 In other words, to a degree the burden of Germany on the balance of payments was in part the result of Britain's &bquo;great power&equo; posture, and not just the consequence of the military pattern that emerged in the conquest of Germany. 
 Unfortunately for the British government, this occupation zone was unexpectedly severed from its traditional sources of food in the east, and being unable to feed itself became reliant on supplies of food from dollar areas. 
 The position was rectified only slowly, the USA taking on first part and then, by the end of 1947, the whole of the burden.  
 Very different was the issue of foreign investment. 
 While the scale of British overseas commitments was widely debated in parliament and in the Labour party, as well as within the government, the scale of foreign investment and its key role in the overall balance-of-payments position was little known and therefore largely unremarked. 
 While an earlier generation of writers had noted this feature of the period, it was not until the recent work of Cairncross that the significance of this outflow was realized. 
 partly this was because the current account deficit appears much smaller in current (1980s) data than it was thought to be by contemporaries; mainly, it would seem, because the invisible position was actually much better than was then realized. 
 Retrospectively we know that capital outflow took place on a very large scale, amounting to &pound;1,500 million in 1947&ndash;9, well in excess of the receipts from the US loan. 
 In 1947 alone the figure was &pound;643 million: 
 Given the straits to which the British economy was reduced in 1947, when it was necessary to ration even bread and potatoes, an outflow of capital equal to about 8 per cent of national income and nearly equal to total net domestic capital formation (including stock-building) is a very extraordinary event. 
 It was certainly not the purpose for which the American and Canadian loans were procured. 
 How did this bizarre situation come about? 
 The brief answer might be that it was an unintended consequence of a largely implicit and undebated policy decision. 
 The policy decision was to maintain the sterling area, above all in its 1940 form as a zone of exchange control. 
 This meant no controls on foreign investment within that zone, and the unplanned outcome of this was a huge capital outflow from Britain to the sterling area as London rediscovered its traditional predilection for investing in the &bquo;white Commonwealth&equo;. 
 However, as with military expenditure, the effects were not limited to the sterling area: capital inflows allowed much larger demands on the dollar pool by recipient countries. 
 (And this is to ignore the possibility of &bquo;leakage&equo; into dollars of sterling via weaknesses in the control mechanisms &mdash; a point returned to below.) 
 When it is said that the continuation of the sterling area was an &bquo;implicit&equo; decision (in sharp contrast to the debates on overseas expenditure) the point being made is that this continuation was not the result, it would seem, of any debate within the Attlee government. 
 Aspects of sterling's position as an international currency, notably the sterling balances, were, of course, vigorously discussed in the war period, above all as the result of US  pressure to reduce them. 
 And this did raise the whole issue of the future of the sterling area. 
 But what is striking about these debates is the shared assumption that the area was a &bquo;good thing&equo; for Britain. 
 The point at issue was how best to secure its future. 
 I have found no evidence that at any stage anyone said &bquo;what is this Sterling Area, and is it obviously a good thing for Britain?&equo; 
 Typically, the sterling area was assumed a &bquo;good thing&equo;, the justification of which needed only to be made to foreigners (especially Americans). 
 The major economic argument for the area was as a way of expanding the zone of multilateral trade in the short run, and as a source of &bquo;highly beneficial trading and banking relations&equo;. 
 While such a view is not absurd, it hardly touches on the issues which would have to be addressed for any overall assessment. 
 Though the authorities do not seem to have been aware of the scale and significance of capital flows within the sterling area, they were aware that the exchange controls in that area were not all that London hoped. 
 For example, a major recipient of capital from the UK in this period, Australia, had notoriously &bquo;leaky&equo; controls &mdash; in 1947&ndash;8 it was supposed to spend &dollar;80 million and spent &dollar;200 million. 
 part of the reason was technical &mdash; the lack of an effective administrative apparatus &mdash; but in addition there was a clear political hostility in several countries to London's control of decision-making on the allocation of gold and dollars. 
 There were some attempts at consultation, notably with Commonwealth finance ministers in 1947 and 1949, but the relationship is perhaps symbolized by the fact that the RSA countries were not consulted on devaluation in 1949, simply informed of the decision a day or two before it took place. 
 The precise distribution of this outflow of foreign investment is shrouded in mystery. 
 Conan suggests that Australia may have received &pound;550 million from Britain in the period 1945&ndash;51, South Africa perhaps &pound;400 million over the same period. 
 Cairncross, citing other figures from the 1950s, suggests a comparable figure for South Africa, but a much lower figure for Australia. 
 Whatever the details it seems clear that: (1) except in the case of   
 India, little of the capital flows took the form of a rundown of sterling balances; (2) most of the investment flow was to the &bquo;white Commonwealth&equo;, especially South Africa; and (3) the colonies saw net disinvestment. 
 Each of these points requires some comment. 
 On sterling balances, the pattern was one where some countries ran down their balances significantly, while others accumulated more. 
 The aggregate of outstanding balances fluctuated quite violently, falling sharply especially in 1947, but for 1945&ndash;51 as a whole it fell by only &pound;70 million. 
 The main country to draw down its balances was India, the main countries to accumulate balances were the colonies, with the white Commonwealth falling in between. 
 In the event, the sterling balances were much less of a problem  from London's point of view than was commonly anticipated when the scale of their wartime accumulation was first discussed in the mid-1940s. 
 Secondly, the huge flow of British investment into South Africa was directed especially into gold-mining expansion. 
 The consequences of this investment for the sterling area were complex, as South Africa was, of course, the world's major gold producer. 
 But in the early postwar years its import surplus was so large that despite expanded gold exports it was a net drawer on the sterling pool, until it left the pool at the end of 1947. 
 In 1947 the Treasury did raise the question of excluding South Africa (and India) from the sterling area because of the effect of their behaviour on the reserve position, but this was ultimately rejected. 
 In 1947 it was agreed to impose exchange control on exports of capital to South Africa, but this was not pursued when these flows ceased in 1948. 
 Despite the costs of South Africa to the sterling area in this period, Labour was determined to preserve good relations with that country, in order to avoid both break-up of the Commonwealth and disruption of the perceived strategic centrality of South Africa to military policy. 
 This friendly stance was little affected by the Nationalist victory in 1948. 
 While London did not consult the Dominions much on financial matters (though it made a public ploy of doing so) it lacked the political will or administrative means to make the rigorous control of dollar imports practised in the UK effective in those countries. 
 As on other occasions, Imperial sentiment was a weak basis for a key part of British policy. 
 Perhaps the oddest consequence of the evolution of the sterling area as a zone for British balance-of-payments policy was the relationship which developed with the colonies, Treating the sterling area as one bloc meant, logically, maximizing dollar receipts for the area as a whole and minimizing dollar debits. 
 Such a policy could be applied much more effectively to colonial territories, where British control of trade and payments was well grounded. 
 The colonies as a group quickly emerged as a key element in British strategy because they were net dollar earners (basically because of Malayan rubber and West African products such as cocoa) and could be made so on a bigger scale by a number of policy devices. 
 The result of this was that net disinvestment in the colonies took place under the Labour  government: inflows of funds were about &pound;40 million, while sterling balances grew by &pound;160 million. 
 This outcome was not the consequence of any direct intention to exploit the colonies. 
 Rather, it followed from the notion that the economic development of Britain and of the colonies was interdependent and complementary, and that what was good for Britain was good for the colonies. 
 This implied a division of labour between manufacturing in the UK, and raw material and food production in the colonies, a doctrine which the Colonial Office broadly accepted, in line with its lack of sympathy with colonial industrialization as likely to be socially and politically disruptive. 
 Thus the Treasury faced little opposition to its policies on the basis that the sterling area was in any way harmful to the interests of the colonies. 
 More controversial was the manner in which Britain turned the terms of trade in its favour and directly squeezed the incomes of colonial producers by bulk purchasing of colonial products at below world prices. 
 This caused disquiet amongst Colonial officials and prompted Creech Jones, the Colonial Secretary in the later years of the Labour government, to circulate a memorandum to the Cabinet in early 1947 in which he said: &bquo;I know full well how important it is that our overseas payments should be kept as low as they possibly can be, but I cannot believe that this justifies a course which is contrary to our declared policy in regard both to Colonial and to commercial matters and contrary also to the policy which has long been pursued by the Labour Party.&equo; 
 But in the face of Treasury and Ministry of Food objections, nothing came of this. 
 Treasury policy, especially from late 1947, was to badger the colonies to provide data on which a rigorous system of dollar exchange control could be imposed, a system which was imposed from December 1947. 
 This was coupled to a policy of discouraging as far as possible even British imports into the colonies on the grounds that this would divert Britain's exports from dollar to soft currency areas like the colonies,&equo; and hence the accumulation of colonial sterling  balances. 
 This policy, which was very much stimulated by the convertibility crisis in 1947, was tightened up even further at the time of the next sterling crisis in 1949. 
 Colonial dollar imports fell from &dollar;376 million in 1947 to &dollar;355 million the following year, and to &dollar;260 million in 1949. 
 By early 1950, following renewed cuts, the annual rate was down to around &dollar;170 million. 
 The balance-of-payments crisis, in combination with fears of Russian expansionism, created a growing Labour interest in the Empire in general and Africa in particular. 
 The possibility of increased dollar receipts was coupled with a belief that Africa could be a strategic centre for British power, untainted by the nationalism which had eroded British power in Asia. 
 The search for dollars led to grandiose plans for African economic development, most famously the groundnuts scheme, though that was not the only madcap project to surface in this period. 
 The contribution of such schemes to dollar receipts and colonial development alike was more or less zero. 
 The ruthless pursuit of dollars in the colonies exacerbated political tensions, and probably hastened the rise of African nationalism. 
 As Fieldhouse has argued, 
 The ironical and fundamental point is that during these post-war years, when international demand for tropical commodities for the first time since 1921 really justified vast investments in the Colonies; when the Colonies had a huge back-log of demand for essential equipment; when at last the British government was equipped with power to give or lend considerable sums to top up what the Colonies could afford to invest from their own accumulating surplus; and when. 
 finally, a new political awareness was making Colonial populations more than ever critical of their relationship with the metropolis, Britain, for the first time in her modern Imperial history, was literally unable to deliver the goods. 
 As a result of the sterling area policy, Britain not only failed to deliver the goods but actively and blatantly exploited colonial producers. 
 In 1952 A. R. Conan wrote: &bquo;When all factors are taken into account, there seems some evidence to support the view that the balance of payments of the U.K. after the war might be considered fundamentally more satisfactory than in 1939.&equo; 
 This may be a little exaggerated, but it makes the point quite  nicely that the commodity position of British trade recovered strikingly well after 1945 &mdash; essential imports could readily be paid for by exports plus the American loan remarkably quickly after the war's end. 
 The underlying balance-of-payments problems stemmed essentially from the scale of government overseas expenditure and foreign investment, these amounting to more than eight times the aggregate current account deficit for 1946&ndash;50 (see Table 1). 
 On overseas government expenditure Attlee fought a campaign with what has been called an &bquo;impressive&equo;&equo; Little Englander' pragmatism' which, however, ran against the rocks of Bevin and the Chiefs of Staff. 
 Nevertheless, and no doubt too slowly, illusions of grandeur were slowly given up and Britain's incapacity to live with the superpowers was to a degree accepted. 
 Arguably more important in the long run was the illusion of grandeur in the monetary field. 
 Apart from acting as a zone for maximizing non-dollar trade, the sterling area under Labour had two main effects. 
 It facilitated Britain's surprisingly rapid re-emergence as a major capital exporter, and it provided a framework for a major squeeze on the colonies. 
 The second of these aspects has emerged only relatively recently in the published literature on the postwar Labour government, but it is now a commonplace, certainly among Imperial and colonial historians. 
 It is strange but perhaps explicable mixture of a compelling desire to rescue the British economy with a Fabian paternalism which saw a &bquo;natural&equo; path to colonial development in the expansion of traditional (dollar-earning) commodity production. 
 Fieldhouse drives the point home when he argues that &bquo;between 1945 and 1951 Britain exploited those dependencies that were politically unable to defend their own interests in more ways and with more serious consequences than at any time since overseas colonies were established&equo;. 
 This was, he argues, &bquo;social imperialism in an extreme form&equo;. 
 &bquo;Social imperialism&equo; suggests that the main beneficiaries of this policy were British consumers, and indeed one writer has gone so far as to argue a direct link to the Attlee government's social reforms: &bquo;The nationalisations, medical provision and expansion of education so magnanimously legislated by the Labour Ministry were largely achieved because the Bank of England  kept the Sterling Area show on the road.' 
 But plainly this is to ignore the extent to which the immediate beneficiaries of the sterling area were the Dominions rather than British citizens, a point neatly summarized by Table 5. 
 In the longer run the accentuation of the sterling area policy, and its apparent success, especially in the explosion of colonial dollar-earning from the time of the Korean War commodity boom, re-established the pound as a major currency, a role which seemed unlikely in 1945. 
 Thus what Strange calls sterling's role as a &bquo;negotiated&equo; currency &mdash; a top currency on the slide, which has to be constantly defended &mdash; emerged enormously strengthened from the Attlee period, and this must be seen as a major part of the legacy of that government. 
 The Attlee governments were faced with a complexity of economic and political problems which should perhaps spare them, above all modern British governments, the condescension of posterity. 
 Nevertheless, given that those governments left such an enduring legacy, the limits of their policy appraisal need to be stressed. 
 There is little sign that the government was able to find the time or the inclination to assess sceptically the framework within which balance-of-payments policy was conducted. 
 Reductions in overseas government expenditure took place, but reluctantly and more gradually than now seems desirable. 
 However, the more fundamental issue (in the long run) of sterling and the associated question of the role of the City of London seem to have been little discussed. 
 In other words, Labour's &bquo;pragmatic&equo; response to the recurrent payments crisis tended to enhance the taken-for-granted desirability of sterling's role as a world currency. 
 When policy was seen to be hurting the colonies, some protested; but even the many who accepted that Britain's relations with its colonies were unsatisfactory saw this as a relatively minor blemish on an otherwise desirable system. 
 In this Crosland was typical. 
 In his book Britain's Economic Problem , which was almost all about the balance of payments, he accurately outlines the broad trends in the balance of payments described above, and the extent to which the sterling area relied on the colonies. 
 But his response was merely to press for a greater supply of British goods to those colonies to reduce their sterling balances. 
 The broader questions of Britain's role as a capital exporter, and the role (economic and political) of the City linked to the status of the pound, are all neglected. 
 Despite its important success in managing the balance of payments in the short run, this must count as a significant failure of policy for a democratic socialist government.  
 E. H. H. GREEN University of Reading  
 The Strange Death of Tory England 
 Conservatism . 
 By Ted Honderich. 
 London: Hamish Hamilton, 1990, pp. 255. 
 ISBN 0-241-12999-0. &pound;15.99. 
 English Conservatism since the Reformation , By R. Eccleshall. 
 London: Allen &amp; Unwin, 1990, pp. x + 254. 
 ISBN 0-04-445773-1. &pound;9.99 (pbk). 
 Conservatism and Collectivism, 1880&ndash;1914 . 
 By M. Fforde. 
 Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press, 1990, pp. ix + 222. 
 ISBN 0-7486-0319-2. &pound;25.00. 
 For Party or Country. 
 Nationalism and the Dilemmas of Popular Conservatism in Edwardian England . 
 By F. Coetzee. 
 Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990, pp. viii + 221. 
 ISBN 0-19-506238-8. &pound;32.00. 
 Leopold Marse and the National Review . 
 By John A. Hutcheson jun. 
 New York and London; Garland, 1989, pp. xx + 500. 
 ISBN 0-8240-7818-7. &pound;25.00. 
 The Modernization of Conservative Politics: The Diaries and Letters of William Bridgeman 1904&ndash;1935 . 
 Edited by P. Williamson. 
 London: The Historians Press, 1988. pp. x + 270. 
 ISBN 0-9508900-4-9. &pound;20.00. 
 The British Conservative party has been the most successful political party of the modern era. 
 The Conservatives have been in Government, either alone or in coalitions dominated by their party, for sixty-seven of the past 100 years, and their share of the vote at general elections has rarely fallen below 40 per cent. 
 No other party of the right operating within a mass electoral system has equalled this achievement, and in recent years the only institution which has matched the Conservatives in terms of the monotonous regularity of their success is Liverpool Football Club. 
 The enduring appeal of the Conservatives is undoubtedly one of the most important political phenomena of the twentieth century: and yet both the party as an institution and the nature of British Conservatism remain relatively under-studied. 
 It is true that during Margaret Thatcher's tenure of the Conservative leadership the social basis of the Conservative parliamentary party, the nature of its constituency, and the conflicting philosophies of the &bquo;new&equo;  and &bquo;old&equo; right provided the subject matter for a wealth of publications. 
 However, the attention lavished on the Conservative party, and especially on the Conservative Party's ideas, in the past few years has only served to emphasize the relative neglect of Conservative history and Conservative thought before Mrs Thatcher. 
 Furthermore, this lack of a detailed history of Conservatism has handicapped the study of Thatcherism itself, for the absence of a clear historical perspective has ensured that, in spite of the proliferation of literature, the ideological origins of the Thatcherite Revolution remain obscure. 
 The historiography of the post-Disraelian Conservative party is strikingly sparse when compared to the volume of work devoted to its opponents. 
 Lord Blake's now revised 1968 Ford Lectures provide an introduction to the late nineteenth and twentieth century party, but their aim was to provide a sketch, not a comprehensive study. 
 The Longman Group's semi-official history of the party will doubtless provide the basic starting-point for scholars of twentieth century Conservatism for years to come, but to date it offers still only a largely introductory, if more detailed, survey of the Conservative party in the first three decades of this century. 
 The Conservative hegemony of the interwar years still awaits an adequate explanation, and the Conservative dominance between 1951 and 1964 &mdash; Harold Wilson's &bquo;thirteen years of Tory misrule&equo; &mdash; has escaped the white heat of historical investigation. 
 The one area of Conservative history which has flourished is political biography, but the danger of this is a tendency to reduce the history of the Conservative Party to a history of personalities and to avoid any analysis of Conservatism in terms of structures, interests and ideas. 
 If the Conservative Party generally has suffered from neglect, the Edwardian Conservatives have suffered most. 
 In spite of a number of important publications in the early 1980s which sought to take Edwardian Conservatism seriously, notably the work of Geoffrey Searle, Alan Sykes, and Gregory Phillips, the Conservative party remained the Cinderella of  Edwardian historiography, languishing in the shadows while its ugly sisters, the Liberal and Labour parties, hogged the limelight. 
 In some respects this imbalance was understandable. 
 The fact that after the Great War the Liberal party went into decline and the Labour party emerged as a governmental party seemed to indicate that the most interesting developments must have been taking place on the left of British politics, even before the war. 
 But the excitement generated by this debate tended to obscure the fact that the party experiencing the most obvious difficulties before 1914 was the Conservative party. 
 Whatever view one takes of the electoral fortunes of the Liberal and Labour Parties before 1914, the Conservative party was clearly losing &mdash; three general election defeats in a row and no significant signs of an electoral revival. 
 There may or may not have been divisions of opinion in the ranks of the progressive Alliance, but the Conservatives were all too evidently engaged in fratricidal strife. 
 Moreover, the whole raison d'&ecirc;tre  of the Conservative party seemed under threat. 
 As self-professed guardians of the Empire and Britain's national greatness the Conservatives had to face up to Britain's relative decline as an imperial and economic power. 
 As the party of property the Conservatives had to cope with an electorate dominated by the propertyless, the advent of British socialism and the apparent threat to property posed by a reform-minded Liberal party. 
 If J. A. Hobson was justified in speaking of a &bquo;crisis of Liberalism&equo; in 1909, it is equally if not more justified to think of the Edwardian period in terms of a &bquo;crisis of Conservatism&equo;. 
 The history of the Edwardian Conservatives sums up many of the problems associated with the history of the party. 
 If one contrasts the history of British Conservatism in the early twentieth century with the history of the British left &mdash; or, indeed, the German right &mdash; in the same period one can only be struck by the discrepancy in the volume and nature of the scholarship produced. 
 While there have been important pioneering studies, the hinterland of the Edwardian Conservative party and its ideological structures remain to be explored. 
 By way of comparison, both the British left and the German right have been well mapped in terms of their social constituencies, the social geography of their electoral support, and their organizational structures. 
 In addition, the subtle nuances of British socialist and Liberal ideas have been charted in detail, while similar care has been taken by those historians who have surveyed the rich and varied political ideologies of the right in Wilhelmine Germany. 
 For the Edwardian  Conservatives in particular, and British Conservatism in general, similar attention has been desirable for some time. 
 It is thus to be welcomed that a number of studies have appeared which examine the nature of the early twentieth century Conservative party and which stress the importance of Conservative ideas in understanding the Party's development during its period of crisis. 
 Equally it is to be welcomed that two major attempts have been made to address the general nature of Conservative ideology. 
 Robert Eccleshall and Ted Honderich have provided one very important service to students of British Conservatism. 
 In spite of the work of Noel O'Sullivan, W. H. Greenleaf, and Anthony Quinton the notion has persisted that Conservatism is not an ideology. 
 This notion has been central to Conservative self-presentation from the emergence of Conservatism in its modern form in the early nineteenth century, and it has found particular favour in the writings of some of the most eloquent spokesmen of twentieth century Conservatism. 
 Thus in the 1920s Walter Elliot argued that Conservatism was based on -an observation of life and not a priori  reasoning', while more recently Sir Ian Gilmour declared that Conservatism is &bquo;not an ideology or a doctrine&equo;. 
 That Conservatives have been keen to sustain this argument should have sounded alarm bells for scholars of Conservatism, but the only alarming thing has been a tendency to accept this concept of Conservatism almost at face value. 
 That the semi-official history of the party should have eschewed discussion of Conservatism as an ideology is not surprising, but a prominent British Marxist scholar has conceded that &bquo;the Tory tradition is not best understood as a tradition of ideas&equo; and the introduction to a recent collection of essays on Edwardian Conservatism  also accepts that &bquo;Conservatism is not an ideology, but a frame of mind, an outlook, a general approach&equo;. 
 Eccleshall and Honderich, however, will have none of this, and they lay to rest, it is to be hoped for good, the idea of Conservatism as a &bquo;non-ideology&equo;. 
 Together they illustrate that, even if it is true that Conservatism harbours &bquo;a distrust of the purely intellectual approach in politics&equo;, this in itself is an ideological position with important implications in terms of both the theory and practice of Conservatism, and  Honderich concludes that &bquo;the commodious proposition that Conservatives only have and only favour factual beliefs which have passed the test of time, are empirical and so on, and hence are untheoretical in various senses&hellip; needs to be delivered, if necessary by private contractors, to the rubbish heap of history&equo;. 
 Eccleshall and Honderich find common cause in a desire to establish the ideological nature of Conservative thought, but apart from this their approaches to the study of Conservativism are very different. 
 Honderich's book is a great disappointment. 
 His method is straightforward enough: examining what he takes to be the central claims and assumptions of Conservative political philosophy, he proceeds to dismantle them one by one and, having demonstrated to his satisfaction that no Conservative tenet can withstand analytical criticism, declares that &bquo;Conservatism&hellip; has, in the end, nothing to say for itself&equo;. 
 There are a number of problems with this approach. 
 Addressing Honderich's work on its own terms, one must question whether he demonstrates the complete vacuity of Conservative thinking. 
 To take one example, Honderich's dismissal of the notion of &bquo;intellectual imperfection&equo;, which Anthony Quinton has described as the pivot of Conservative thought, is based on a very partial rehearsal of the concept. 
 It may be the case, as Honderich states, that the Conservative notion of &bquo;intellectual imperfection&equo; &mdash; the idea that people's rational faculties are necessarily inadequate to grasp the complexities of social development, and that there are dangers in using abstract reasoning as a guide for social and political behaviour &mdash; does not mean, as some Conservatives have claimed, that Conservatism is atheoretical. 
 However, this fails to explore the limits of the imperfectionist case; in particular, Honderich underrates the most important twentieth century formulation of the notion of imperfection. 
 In his critique of rationalism in politics Michael Oakeshott drew a distinction between two forms of human knowledge: &bquo;technique&equo;, that is, skills which can be taught or acquired from manuals; and &bquo;practical&equo;, by which is meant things like judgement or artistry. 
 For Oakeshott the &bquo;rationalist&equo; error is the equation of reason which technique, and thus the problem is not the use of reason in politics as such but a misidentification of what constitutes reason. 
 As a result of seeing part of knowledge as the whole, &bquo;rationalists&equo;, Oakeshott contends, over-estimate their abilities to define and solve problems, whereas reason proper indicates the need for caution in assessing the scope of human capability. 
 Whether or not one agrees with Oakeshott's position, it represents a sophisticated defence of the  imperfectionist argument for a &bquo;limited politics&equo;, and it certainly warrants more consideration than Honderich provides. 
 As an analytical philosopher Honderich is keen to explore the logic of Conservatism and to demonstrate that it has none, but at the same time he engages with the history of Conservative ideas. 
 Unfortunately the two things do not harmonize. 
 The difficulty here is best demonstrated when Honderich, analyzing the notion that Conservatism is a &bquo;defence of the familiar&equo;, argues that if this were central to Conservatism &bquo;we should have a mystery on our hands, the mystery of how an egregious idiocy could have become a large political tradition&equo;. 
 Leaving aside the particular case, Honderich's statement illustrates the problem of trying to blend the study of logic with the history of ideas. 
 For a philosopher, whether an idea is logical or illogical is very important, but for an historian of ideas this concern is of relatively little significance. 
 To argue over the logic or truth of an idea in absolute terms is to explore the nature of belief itself, but for an historian of ideas what is most interesting is &bquo;who held a particular belief at a particular time and what needs it fulfilled for them. 
 It may well be the case that an egregious idiocy has formed the basis of a political tradition &mdash; examples of this are plentiful &mdash; but ridiculing an historical phenomenon does not explain it. 
 The net result of Honderich's weakness as an historian of ideas is that his book slips into confusion. 
 Conservatism  is a polemic against Conservatism and more particularly Thatcherism, but Honderich's own work raises the question as to whether the two are related. 
 Describing his arrival in Britain in 1959, Honderich states that he &bquo;came from a decent place to join a nation of decency&hellip; (when) the decency of England&hellip; was&hellip; still in a kind of ascendancy&equo;. 
 Since 1979 there has been, in Honderich's view, a &bquo;decay of decency&equo; for which the Conservative Party, and in particular the influence of the &bquo;lumpen intelligentsia&equo; of the new right, have been responsible. 
 According to Honderich, if people find Britain a harsh place in the 1990s then Conservatism is to blame. 
 Setting aside the polemical aspects of his argument, Honderich's thesis boils down to three points. 
 The first is that British society and the role of government are radically different now from what they were thirty years ago. 
 The second is that these differences are the product of the influence of the &bquo;new right&equo; and its emphasis on market freedoms as the basis of civil and political liberty. 
 The third is that the new right and Conservatism are one and the same. 
 It is doubtful whether many would dispute Honderich's first two points. 
 However, Honderich himself throws up difficulties with regard to his third point, in that Conservatism must have been at least partly responsible for the &bquo;decent&equo; society he found when  he arrived in Britain thirty years ago. 
 In 1959 the Conservative Party had been in power for eight years, but &bquo;decency&equo; appears to have been safe in their hands. 
 Ignoring once again Honderich's polemical language, there is an important problem here: namely, how is it that Conservatism can be responsible for what everyone agrees are two very different governmental strategies informed by two very different social philosophies? 
 On the one hand, it could just be that Conservatism has changed. 
 On the other hand, there is the possibility that one of the differing patterns of ideas may not be Conservatism. 
 This last point never occurs to Honderich, who equates Conservatism with the new right. 
 Yet it is worth noting that one of the most influential works in the canon of the new right, Friedrich Hayek's The Constitution of Liberty , ends with a chapter entitled &bquo;Why I am not a Conservative&equo;. 
 If Honderich had paid attention to clues like this he could have subjected the credentials of the new right to closer scrutiny and interrogated the development of Conservative thought with much greater sensitivity. 
 But Honderich is too busy allocating guilt to be discriminating in his investigations, with the usual result that one cannot be sure if the right people have been convicted. 
 Robert Eccleshall has fewer pretensions than Ted Honderich but his book is much more coherent. 
 The structure of English Conservatism since the Restoration  has the outward appearance of a &bquo;central text&equo; for an undergraduate special subject in British Conservatism, in that the book is split into six conceptual and period sections, each of which contains an interpretative essay followed by extracts from contemporary sources. 
 In principle this format has much to recommend it, but in this case the practice has not been successful. 
 The problem lies with the documents, which are too short to be of real value. 
 It would have been more sensible to reduce the period span of the book, especially as Eccleshall himself acknowledges that Conservatism in its recognizably &bquo;modern&equo; form did not emerge until the early nineteenth century. 
 The additional space thus provided would not only have allowed the reproduction of documents of a useful length, but would also have avoided anomalies such as the absence of any statements by the Third Marquis of Salisbury, Stanley Baldwin, Walter Elliot, Noel Skelton, the &bquo;Mannheim Group&equo;, and other leading Conservative politicians and publicists of the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries. 
 Any collection of documents is necessarily selective, but this one does seem to be marked by some significant absentees. 
 An alternative to shortening the period scope would be to expand the work to two volumes, the first to cover the period c.1660&ndash;1832 and the second the period from 1832 to the present day. 
 Either  approach would allow a greater integration of analysis and documents, and would certainly make the book more useful as a standard text. 
 An additional benefit of expanding Eccleshall's book would be that he could extend his interpretative essays, which contain important and subtle reflections on the nature of Conservatism. 
 Throughout the book Eccleshall demonstrates an impressive authority and ease with his sources as he ransacks 300 years of Conservative thought to discover the meaning of Conservatism. 
 The result of this search is that Eccleshall finds the lemma of Conservatism in &bquo;a particular conception of the political order&equo;. 
 Conservatism, he argues, is essentially &bquo;the persistent image of society as a command structure in which the responsibilities of leadership can be exercised within the framework of a strong State&equo;, and it is this &bquo;that distinguishes English Conservatism from rival ideologies&equo;. 
 This stress on authority and hierarchy is, Eccleshall contends, understandable given that &bquo;from Restoration absolutism to the Thatcherite preoccupation with law and order Conservatives have always been fearful of social indiscipline&equo;. 
 But if Conservatives have always been agreed on the main danger they face, and have always agreed on the basic  means to combat it, they have not, Eccleshall argues, always been agreed on the precise manner of exercising authority and maintaining social discipline. 
 According to Eccleshall the Conservative Party, like Faust, has always been able to declare &bquo;Two souls together live in my breast&equo;, with the philosophy of a strong, paternalist authority competing with the notion of a strong, non-interventionist authority. 
 Here Eccleshall's analysis is identical to that of W. H. Greenleaf, who has also identified a long-standing division between &bquo;libertarian&equo; and &bquo;paternalist&equo; Conservatives. 
 Such a frame of reference clearly allows space within Conservatism for the &bquo;new right&equo; and &bquo;Thatcherism&equo;. 
 The Thatcherite stress on social discipline and the &bquo;strong state&equo; provides the link to the central Conservative tradition, while the accent on market economics simply establishes Thatcherism as an expression of the &bquo;libertarian&equo; strand of that tradition. 
 Eccleshall's argument is very neat, but it is not entirely convincing. 
 To begin with, there is more than a hint of circularity about Eccleshall's definition of Conservatism. 
 In effect he seems to be saying that Conservatism seeks to preserve social discipline through the maintenance of authority, and that therefore it stresses authority and social discipline. 
 Even if one discounts this problem, there is the question as to whether the tradition of authority and concern with social discipline is sufficient in itself to define Conservatism and to distinguish it from other ideologies. 
 Most  governments in the old Eastern Bloc were concerned with social discipline, and they also stressed the importance of authority wielded through a strong state, but it would be wrong to see them as Conservative. 
 In defining an ideology, the claims which seek to legitimate political and social authority are surely as important as the notion of authority itself. 
 Conservatism, like any other ideology, has to justify its conception of authority and social discipline in terms of a claim to possess superior political wisdom, and it is the manner and nature of this claim that defines the essence of Conservatism. 
 At this point it is difficult not to be drawn back towards the work of Anthony Quinton, who has provided a helpful model of the basic Conservative claims to political wisdom. 
 As stated above, Quinton presents the notion of &bquo;intellectual imperfection&equo; as the organizing principle of British Conservatism, but he also identifies three other concepts as essential to Conservative thought. 
 The first is traditionalism , by which is meant that Conservatives have an attachment to established customs and institutions, and, as a corollary, a hostility to &bquo;sudden, precipitate and revolutionary change&equo;. 
 The second is organicism : that is, Conservatives regard society as &bquo;a unitary, natural growth, an organized living whole not a mechanical aggregate&equo;, which in turn implies that they are resistant to arguments which reduce society to component parts like classes or atomistic individuals. 
 finally, Conservatism is characterized by political scepticism , or the belief that &bquo;political wisdom&hellip; is not to be found in the theoretical speculations of isolated thinkers&equo;. 
 To date no one has produced a more succinct or more plausible definition of Conservatism, and certainly neither Honderich nor Eccleshall has provided an adequate alternative. 
 In fact it seems to this reviewer that Quinton's framework offers essential support for Eccleshall's vision of Conservatism, in that the axioms Quinton describes provide for a specifically Conservative conception of political authority and social discipline. 
 If one accepts that Quinton offers a more comprehensive formulation of Conservatism than Eccleshall, then Thatcherism's credentials must be checked again. 
 Eccleshall himself implicitly acknowledges this problem, for he notes at one point that Thatcherism's characteristics &mdash; &bquo;its mixture of abrasively theoretical market economics, uncompromising anti-egalitarianism and fervent patriotism&equo; &mdash; are hardly &bquo;the ingredients of what Oakeshottians judge to be authentic Conservatism&equo;. 
 For Eccleshall, Oakeshottians and other imperfectionist-minded Conservatives fail to acknowledge their point of contact with a different strain of Conservatism, namely the common conception of authority. 
 But if this, as suggested above, is insufficient to  identify Conservatism then the &bquo;Oakeshottians&equo; and their imperfectionist allies may be correct in seeing the new right and Thatcherism as alien ideological territory. 
 One possible means of reconciling the new right and Thatcherism to the Conservative tradition would be to abandon the emphasis on &bquo;authority&equo; and emphasize the duality of Conservative thought in terms of the &bquo;libertarian'/&equo; paternalist' divide. 
 But at this juncture another major problem emerges, in that it is very difficult to demonstrate that there is an established libertarian Conservative tradition with which Thatcherism and the new right can be matched. 
 Eccleshall argues that libertarian Conservatism was alive and well in the work of Edmund Burke and in the &bquo;Liberal Toryism&equo; which reached its apogee during the premiership of Sir Robert Peel. 
 Yet, as recent work on political economy in the late eighteenth century has shown, it is difficult to establish Adam Smith, let alone Burke, as a &bquo;free marketeer&equo; in anything like the modern sense. 
 The conception of state-civil society relations which informed Burke's (and Smith's) thought was highly complex, and certainly Burke was too much of an &bquo;organicist&equo; to have accepted the Thatcherite idea that society does not exist and that individuals and their families are the basic units of consideration. 
 It is equally difficult to present the &bquo;Liberal Toryism&equo; of the 1820s or Sir Robert Peel's economic liberalism as precursors of &bquo;libertarian&equo; Conservatism. 
 Lord Liverpool was many things, but he was not a clear-cut individualist, and his concept of limited politics was distinct from that associated with laissez-faire  liberal economics. 
 Peel's stance in relation to economic liberalism seems more promising, but in terms of his relationship to the Conservative canon two things are worthy of note: first, Peel's espousal of liberal economics resulted in the bulk of the Conservative Party deserting him; and second, the most authoritative appraisal of Peel's career has concluded that &bquo;Peel was not the founder of the Conservative party but was the progenitor of Gladstonian Liberalism&equo;. 
 The attempt to locate &bquo;libertarian&equo; Conservatism in the late eighteenth or early nineteenth century seems implausible. 
 Eccleshall appears to be on stronger ground when he looks to the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries for evidence of libertarian Conservatism. 
 Here he finds organizations like the Liberty and property Defence League (LPDL) and The British Constitutional Association (BCA), and individuals like Lord Wemyss, Herbert Spencer, A. V. Dicey, and Ernest Benn, all committed to individualism and all found supporting the political right. 
 Eccleshall also finds backing here from one of the recent histories of  the late Victorian and Edwardian Conservative Party. 
 The work of Matthew Fforde appears to offer an historical lifeline to those, like Eccleshall, who would present Thatcherism in terms of an established tradition of libertarian Conservative thought. 
 In Conservatism and Collectivism  Fforde argues that between 1880 and 1914 the Conservative party was faced by a rising tide of collectivist opinion and collectivist legislation. 
 Confronting explicitly collectivist opponents for the first time, the Conservative party, so Fforde contends, stressed the values of the free market, turned to the classical economists to justify non-intervention, and revealed themselves to be doctrinally committed to individualism. 
 With regard to the Tory hierarchy Salisbury, Balfour, and even the supposedly dirigiste  -minded Alfred Milner and Joseph Chamberlain, are seen as staunch anti-collectivists. 
 Equally important, Fforde finds a commitment to the market economy and laissez-faire  embedded in the party's grass roots, and in particular in the outlook of the most traditional Conservative interest, the land. 
 In this respect Fforde believes that individualism was not just a particular strand of the Conservative tradition, but was the Conservative tradition, and that &bquo;Tory Centrism, anti-capitalism, or paternalist interventionism&equo; are &bquo;phantoms of the historiographical imagination&equo;. 
 If Fforde is correct, integrating Thatcherism into the Conservative tradition is not a problem. 
 But the assumptions which underpin Fforde's work are highly questionable and often bizarre. 
 and ultimately he presents a misleading portrait of the Edwardian Conservative party and British political development in general. 
 The first major problem with Fforde's work is that it equates collectivism with socialism, which is as historically wrong as it is jejune. 
 If Fforde was describing the phenomenon whereby late Victorian and Edwardian commentators frequently used both terms to describe anti-individualism, this would be justifiable. 
 But Fforde, unlike the late Victorians and Edwardians, fails to distinguish between socialism as a political movement and &bquo;socialism&equo; as a contemporary synonym for state intervention. 
 Thus Fforde describes Thatcherism as a revolt against a &bquo;culture of Collectivism&equo; and quotes uncritically Sir Keith Joseph's remark about the need to clear away &bquo;the vast bulk of the accumulating detritus of Socialism&equo;. 
 This is all logical enough given Fforde's conviction that collectivism comes from &bquo;areas other than the British Conservative party&equo;, but Fforde seems to forget that the Conservatives were in power for fifty-five of the 100 years from the dawn of collectivism to the edge of Thatcherism, and must, therefore, have been at least partly responsible for some of Keith Joseph's &bquo;detritus&equo;. 
 To get round this uncomfortable fact Fforde would have to argue either that all collectivist legislation emanated from governments of the left, or that all Conservative governments before 1979 were in some way not truly Conservative. 
 This latter option appears to have some attraction for Fforde, for in his conclusion he seems to agree with the Thatcherite premise  that pre-1979 Conservatives, by accommodating themselves to collectivist reforms rather than reversing them, abandoned their principles and surrendered to the so-called &bquo;ratchet&equo; effect of creeping socialism. 
 That Fforde accepts some key Thatcherite assumptions is evident, but in many respects his work, like Thatcherism itself, is reminiscent of an earlier intellectual tradition, in that the more one reads his work the more one thinks of A. V. Dicey. 
 Fforde locates the &bquo;rise of collectivism&equo; in the last quarter of the nineteenth century, equates collectivism with socialism, and views collectivism as symptomatic of the triumph of &bquo;materialism&equo;. 
 All of this has a distinctly Diceyesque ring, for in the introduction to the 1913 edition of his Law and Public Opinion  Dicey portrayed any extension of state activity as &bquo;socialist&equo;, and denounced the welfare collectivism of the &bquo;new liberalism&equo; as an attempt to &bquo;bribe&equo; the electorate with state benefits. 
 However, Fforde's acceptance of Dicey's basic agenda reveals the weakness of his central argument, a weakness which is confirmed by his comment that the LPDL, an organization with which Dicey had close links, &bquo;espoused the pure milk of Conservative orthodoxy&equo;. 
 Fforde's error (and Eccleshall makes the same mistake) is simply that the &bquo;orthodoxy&equo; which Dicey and his friends in the LPDL espoused was not Conservatism but classical mid-Victorian Liberalism. 
 It is true that Dicey, the LPDL, and later the BCA, allied themselves with the Conservative party, but this was not because they considered themselves Conservatives. 
 For men like Dicey, Auberon Herbert, Lord Wemyss, and St Joe Strachey alliance with the Conservatives was the product of disgust with a Liberal Party which, in their eyes, had abandoned Liberalism. 
 They had no great love for Conservatism, but, given the tenor of Liberal politics, saw the Conservative party as the last hope in a struggle to preserve their own brand of Liberalism. 
 Moreover, in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, it was a hope that was disappointed. 
 Lord Salisbury espoused and practised a limited politics, but it would be reductionist to equate this with the doctrinaire non-interventionism preached by the LPDL. 
 In fact Salisbury poured scorn on Lord Wemyss &mdash; &bquo;the great prophet of North Berwick Law&equo; &mdash; and insisted that interventionist legislation had to be considered on the merits of the measure in question. 
 Likewise, Wemyss had few kind things to say about Salisbury, and on more than one occasion denounced him as a &bquo;socialist&equo; for  enacting measures like free education in rural districts and the Workmen's Compensation Act. 
 However, for Wemyss, Dicey, and the individualist groups Lord Salisbury was a paragon of virtue and restraint compared to the Edwardian Conservative party. 
 Between Salisbury's retirement in 1902 and the outbreak of the Great War the individualist associations, their spokesmen, and their ideas were relegated even further to the margins of Conservative politics: only two Conservatives of note allied themselves with the individualist groups, while Dicey came to regard the Conservative party as collectivist Quislings. 
 Fforde seeks to deny this, but at this stage his interpretation of events begins to become increasingly eccentric. 
 Fforde highlights a key difficulty for his argument by pointing out that in the debates about the issue which dominated Edwardian Conservatism &mdash; tariff reform &mdash; the Conservative Party developed a language which &bquo;employed a great deal of anti- laissez faire  rhetoric and espoused policies which involved state expansion&equo;. 
 Fforde acknowledges that all this appears to invalidate the central theme of his book. 
 But not so (we are told): Conservative advocates of tariffs and social reforms like old age pensions, wages councils, regulation of sweated trades were, Fforde argues, simply engaged in &bquo;principled opportunism&equo;; this was &bquo;not Collectivist Conservatism but expedient Conservatism&equo;, and to see it as otherwise would be to allow oneself to be &bquo;misled by manufactured appearances' or what Fforde describes elsewhere as the gap between &bquo;professed stance and true intention&equo;. 
 The implications of this argument are astonishing. 
 The effort which the Conservative party put into developing a positive alternative to the new liberal collectivism was, apparently, all a gigantic fraud, a disguise for the individualist principles which Conservatives held in private. 
 If this was really the case then surely those Conservatives given to disguising themselves in this manner could have saved their party a lot of grief by letting the opponents of their &bquo;professed stance&equo; into the secret of their &bquo;true intention&equo;. 
 Fforde makes much of the importance of archives and private correspondence as the means to discover &bquo;true intentions&equo;, so why did Austen Chamberlain not simply drop Hugh Cecil a note to let him know that his speeches in favour of tariffs and pensions were all a put-up job? 
 In his zeal to demonstrate that the Conservatives were committed individualists Fforde refuses to accept that there may have been real disagreements within the party. 
 Ultimately Fforde's book is marred by the quirky and sometimes absurd approach he adopts. 
 Yet his work is not without redeeming features. 
 By default he alerts us to the fact that it was the late nineteenth and early  twentieth centuries that saw individualist arguments gravitate to the political right and become, however marginally at first, a vocabulary and strategy available to the Conservative party. 
 Fforde also establishes an important point by underlining the importance of land reform to late Victorian and Edwardian debates. 
 He exaggerates when he speaks of a &bquo;deafening silence, from historians on the land question, but he makes a strong case for placing the land issue near the centre of any sound historical analysis of the period. 
 In a stimulating analysis of the Conservative response to the Land Campaign of 1912&ndash;14, Fforde demonstrates how frightened the Conservatives were of Lloyd George's initiative. 
 The fear was justifiable. 
 In the 1910 general election the Conservatives&equo; main gains had been in the counties generally and the southern counties in particular. 
 The Land Campaign, or so it seemed to the Conservatives, threatened to wipe out those gains at a time when the party showed no signs of an electoral recovery elsewhere. 
 The Conservatives' desperation to devise a counter-programme for the land, and the disagreements it provoked, demonstrate the degree of confusion which still existed in the Conservative ranks and the immense problems they still faced before the &bquo;rampant omnibus&equo; of the Great War rescued them by running down their opponents. 
 It is a pity that Fforde's determination to present the Conservative party as decided individualists prevented him from exploring the confusion in the Conservative ranks indicated by his evidence. 
 If disputes within the party over policy and doctrine were one symptom of Conservative confusion, another was the &bquo;legion of leagues&equo; which appeared in the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, when it seemed that hardly a year went by without the founding of some new right-wing association. 
 The main aim of Franz Coetzee's intriguing study For Party or Country  is to explain this phenomenon through an examination of the outlook and activities of three of the larger groups: the Navy League (NL), the Tariff Reform League (TRL), and the Anti-Socialist Union (ASU). 
 In terms of the history of these organizations as institutions Coetzee's work is unlikely to be surpassed. 
 He examines their foundation, their funding, their social constituency, and their organizational structure in detail, and in the process disposes of a number of myths and conventional wisdoms. 
 For example, Cortzee shows that contemporary tales of the &bquo;tariff reform millions, are not borne out by the relatively impoverished state of the Tariff Reform  League, and he demonstrates that the variety of industries and economic activities which were represented in the TRL defy any attempt to produce a simple definition of its interest base. 
 On issues like this Coetzee's sensitivity and grasp of detail are shown to good effect: but with regard to the broader historical significance of these organizations he is less assured, and he leaves untouched some of the more important questions raised by his work. 
 The leitmotif of Coetzee's book, as suggested by his title, is that the organizations he has studied faced an ongoing dilemma: whether to function as adjuncts of the Conservative party or to claim that their aims were &bquo;national&equo; and therefore &bquo;above party&equo;. 
 In fact, as Coetzee demonstrates, the personnel of the TRL, the NL, and the ASU were predominantly Conservative, and in this respect their claim to be &bquo;non-party&equo; was always weak. 
 Yet Coetzee also makes clear that, for two reasons, the &bquo;non-party&equo; idea should be taken seriously. 
 First, it caused the groups some significant problems. 
 The NL especially suffered a major split because of its refusal after 1906 to endorse Conservative candidates. 
 The rival, splinter organization which emerged as a result, the Imperial Maritime League (IML), claimed that any serious Navalist had to support the Conservatives, irrespective of the fact that individual Liberal candidates were &bquo;sound&equo; on naval questions, on the grounds that collectively the Liberals were against and the Conservatives in favour of a big Navy. 
 In the end the NL did become demonstrably pro-Conservative and saw off the IML challenge, but divisions like this played their part in ensuring that the British Navy League was never as large or influential as its German counterpart. 
 The second reason for taking the &bquo;non-party&equo; claim seriously is that the various Leagues &mdash; and not just the three studied by Coetzee &mdash; were frequently critical of the Conservative party and expressed strong reservations about the effectiveness of the Conservatives as a political force. 
 Coetzee, describing the leagues as part of a Conservative effort to get to grips with mass politics and the &bquo;new religion&equo; of socialism, explains the timing of their appearance on the grounds that prior to the 1890s &bquo;the Conservatives had no need of recourse to such pressure groups because they already possessed access to institutions adequate for the defence of their interests within the existing sociopolitical framework&equo;. 
 In other words, the Conservative party, and its propertied core constituency, became interested in new forms of appeal and organization when it became apparent that the political reliability and social stability of the lower orders could no longer be ensured by traditional methods of social and political control. 
 This is to describe the &bquo;legion of leagues&equo; from the top down, identifying them as part of a new &bquo;technique of rule&equo; through which the Conservative party attempted to confront a new form of politics and a novel political threat. 
 Another way of viewing them,  however, is from the bottom up: as expressions of concern about the ability of the Conservative party adequately to meet the new challenges. 
 That there should have been a Navy League, a Tariff Reform League, and an Anti-Socialist Union filled with Conservatives was an indication that there were many Conservative supporters who felt that the Conservative party was not doing its job properly. 
 There were occasions when the leagues were of great help to the Conservatives, but their relationship to the party was often ambivalent and sometimes hostile, and it was not always easy to control their activities. 
 It is one of the many strengths of Coetzee's work that he recognizes the disruptive potential of the new organizations, but he concludes that ultimately they were of benefit to the Conservatives. 
 It was not just that they helped out at the occasional by-election, but that they &bquo;pointed to new sources of support whose eventual accommodation, and to new issues whose eventual resolution, would ultimately modify the party itself and help equip it for the challenges of post-war politics&equo;. 
 As a result of his research into the social constituency of the leagues, Coetzee presents them as one of the means whereby the Conservative party broadened its support amongst the middle-class and crucial lower-middle-class voters, thus assisting its development from &bquo;a loose conglomeration of agrarian interests to the predominant party of government in urban, industrial Britain'. 
 If Coetzee is right, and his argument is powerful, then this could help to explain one particularly important aspect of post-1914 politics: the failure of British Fascism. 
 It is here that Coetzee's work suffers from the lack of a more ambitious comparative framework, Coetzee's work on the Conservative leagues is similar to Geoffrey Eley's analysis of the German &bquo;radical right&equo; before 1914. 
 Eley noted that the German radical nationalist leagues were not tools of the ruling elite but were critical of the ability of &bquo;the politics of notables&equo; to confront internal and external threats to Germany and German propertied interests. 
 As a consequence, Eley argued, the political right in Germany was disintegrating even before 1914. 
 After 1918 this problem became even more pronounced, and the absence of a mainstream &bquo;Conservative&equo; Party, capable of unifying a fragmented German bourgeoisie and alleviating its fears, was a key factor in creating the political space for the rise of the Nazis. 
 What Coetzee's work suggests, and it is a pity he does not pursue this point fully, is that in Britain before 1914 the potential fragmentation of the political right was contained. 
 Groups like the NL, the TRL, and the ASU were, in the end, either too loyal to or too dependent upon the Conservative party to break away. 
 The Conservative  Party was thus preserved intact, and the fact that it was able to provide a rallying point for the middle and lower middle classes was arguably one of the main bulwarks against political extremism in the 1920s and 1930s. 
 At this juncture a codicil must be inserted. 
 The above argument is predicated on Coetzee's assumption that the disruptive potential of the new organizations had been contained and that the &bquo;crisis of Conservatism&equo; was over before 1914. 
 Yet it is not obvious that this was the case. 
 Between 1912 and 1914 the Conservative Party was distinctly unsettled. 
 Disgruntled Conservative agriculturalists and imperialists resented Bonar Law's dropping of the &bquo;food taxes&equo; in the winter of 1912&ndash;13, and although he survived the initial furore sparked by this decision it was not clear that the ill feeling had been fully dissipated or his leadership wholly secured. 
 As noted by Fforde, the question of how to respond to the Land Campaign threw the Conservatives into fresh disagreements, and there was no sign that the party, Having abandoned much of its 1910 election platform, was capable of agreeing upon a new one. 
 In many ways the Conservatives' descent towards violence over the Ulster question, and Bonar Law's &bquo;new style&equo;. 
 which seemed to consist mainly of abusing Asquith, were symptomatic of the party's inability to discover a real sense of direction. 
 Most important of all, there was the electoral problem. 
 If anything the Land Campaign and the Liberal plan to abolish plural voting before a possible 1915 general election offered the prospect of another Conservative defeat, and the Conservatives themselves were almost certain this would be the case. 
 Had the Conservatives lost another general election they might have lost credibility as a potential party of government, and this could well have damaged their role as the integrating force of the political right. 
 As it happened, the Great War intervened and provided the Conservatives with an opportunity to confirm what had been an uncertain trend towards a reshaping and consolidation of the right. 
 In this respect, just as many historians have stressed the importance of the Great War in the decline of the Liberal Party. 
 One should be aware that it may well have played an equally significant role in saving the Conservative Party from disintegration. 
 The careers of Leopold Maxse and W. C. Bridgeman exemplify the changing fortunes and outlook of the Conservative Party before and after 1914. 
 John A. Hutcheson's scholarly and thoughtful biography of Maxse ends in 1914. 
 Seventeen years before Maxse's death, but if this seems odd it is understandable, for Maxse was at the height of his powers before 1914 and a negligible figure thereafter. 
 Some historians, including Hutcheson. 
 Have seen in Leo Maxse the epitome of the &bquo;radical right&equo; in Britain before 1914 &mdash; radical right' being taken to mean &bquo;extreme&equo; right or some kind of proto-Fascism on the continental model. 
 Perhaps the most important evidence  adduced for Maxse's radical right outlook is the fact that he tended to lapse into what Richard Hofstadter saw as the chief characteristic of such politics, namely a &bquo;paranoid style&equo;. 
 The most obvious expression of this was Maxse's &bquo;radical plutocracy&equo; enquiry, launched in the wake of the Marconi scandal, when he came close to depicting the Asquith government as tools of a shadowy &bquo;cosmopolitan finance&equo;. 
 Maxse's quasi-obsession with corruption in high places was, however, part of his more general suspicion of the closed world of Westminster politics. 
 Rather like the &bquo;high politics&equo; school of historians, Maxse believed that once inside Westminster politicians tended, with a few exceptions, to &bquo;go native&equo; and become interested solely in their own advancement inside this exclusive club. 
 Maxse's attacks on &bquo;Mandarins&equo;, &bquo;Mugwumps&equo;, and &bquo;Tadpoles and Tapers&equo; were a regular feature of his editorials. 
 He tended to blame many of the ills of the Conservative Party on the &bquo;self-serving&equo; apparatchiks of Conservative Central Office, and many of the ills of the country on the &bquo;petty-fogging&equo; of parliamentary life. 
 These jibes at &bquo;the old gang&equo;, a phrase Maxse used frequently, are of course reminiscent of Oswald Mosley, and on occasion Maxse did veer towards a rather Fascistic &bquo;Caesarism&equo;, calling for &bquo;a Leader&equo; to save the nation. 
 However, if one compares Maxse's views with those expressed by W. C. Bridgeman an interesting picture emerges. 
 Bridgeman was, according to his obituary, &bquo;an admirable type of the English country gentleman&hellip; (who) did much&hellip; for the Church, for education, especially in rural districts, for the Navy&hellip;, for agriculture&hellip; and for sport, particularly for his favourite game of cricket&equo;. 
 In other words, as Philip Williamson's excellent edition of his diary and letters demonstrates. 
 Bridgeman was a man of impeccable Conservative credentials. 
 Yet it was Bridgeman who, at the special National Union Conference in July 1906, seconded Maxse's motion calling for the reform of Conservative Central Office, a motion which stemmed directly from Maxse's &bquo;paranoid&equo; view of the obstructiveness of the Party mandarins towards the tariff campaign. 
 Moreover, Bridgeman justified his actions to Balfour in terms which Maxse would have approved, arguing that Balfour seemed to be &bquo;surrounded by men who are not in touch with the mass of the Party&equo;, complaining of &bquo;the extraordinary difference in perspective which party questions assume inside the House from that presented by them to the man in the street&equo; and voicing suspicions about the secrecy of Parliamentary procedures such as &bquo;the pourparlers of the whips of both sides&equo;.  
 The similarity of outlook which marked the views of Maxse, a man who Hutcheson shows to have been, temperamentally if not socially, a quintessential outsider, and Bridgeman, the quintessential insider, is significant. 
 Clearly something strange was happening to the Edwardian Conservative party: but does one need to label it as a flirtation with &bquo;proto-Fascism&equo;? 
 The frustrations which Bridgeman and Maxse expressed towards the party hierarchy were the product of their belief that the leadership was not responding adequately to the party's &bquo;crisis&equo;, and in particular not accepting the kind of programme which could bring the party back to power. 
 for Maxse, Bridgeman, and the great majority of Conservatives between 1906 and 1910, the party, if it was to be popular, needed to embrace tariff reform and the gamut of policies with which it was linked, such as social reform and land reform. 
 Maxse's launch of his successful &bquo;B&lsqb;alfour&rsqb; M&lsqb;ust&rsqb; G&lsqb;o&rsqb;&equo; campaign of 1911 was a response to Balfour's &bquo;betrayal&equo; of the tariff programme by his &bquo;Referendum&equo; pledge. 
 Likewise, Maxse turned on Bonar Law when he ditched the &bquo;food taxes&equo; from the tariff programme, and again did not find himself alone in voicing criticism of the new Tory leader. 
 Where Maxse did find himself more or less isolated was in allowing his frustrations to lead him, along with Willoughby de Broke, to consider the formation of an alternative party of the right. 
 Here otherwise close associates like Bridgeman and F. E. Smith distanced themselves from Maxse, while another committed tariff reformer, his fellow editor and friend H. A. Gwynne, pointedly told him that &bquo;for good or evil&equo;, the Conservative party was &bquo;the only weapon we have with which to achieve our purpose and help on the causes which both you and I have strongly at heart&hellip; and anything that tends to disorganize it or to destroy the efficiency of that weapon seems to me to postpone the fulfilment of our desires&hellip; 
 In the end Maxse's impatience with and apparent willingness to consider abandoning established institutions meant that he stretched his Conservative credentials to breaking-point, and it is important to note that when at his most extreme Maxse was most isolated. 
 In this sense it was Maxse's radical Conservatism and not his more dangerous notions that brought him so close to the hub of Conservative politics in the decade before 1914. 
 That the views of Edwardian Conservatives elided so easily with those expressed by such a maverick as Maxse is evidence of how threatened the Conservatives felt and how far they were prepared to use a radical voice to pursue Conservative ends. 
 That they were not prepared to countenance Maxse at his most radical confirms that those ends were indeed Conservative. 
 If it was the Conservative Party's circumstances that gave Maxse's brand of radical Conservatism its appeal, it was also the change in the party's  circumstances wrought by the war which relegated Maxse to the margins of Conservative politics. 
 The most eloquent witness to this fact is Maxse's old ally Bridgeman. 
 Having become a Whip in the Asquith coalition, Bridgeman told Maxse in July 1916: 
 don't obsess yourself with the idea that none of them (Unionist MPs) understand the view of the man in the street&hellip; there is plenty of soundness in the party inside the House&hellip; and, easy as it is to call everyone inside Parliamentarians, and to assume that everyone outside are the only judges&hellip; you will have to get inside before you realize the difficulties of the situation, or the value of the cool-headed men who still represent the Unionist party in the House, and remain independent of Cabinet influence&hellip; 
 To dismiss this comment simply as Bridgeman being a poacher turned gamekeeper would be to miss the point, which is that the war had allowed the Conservatives to become gamekeepers again, whereas from 1902 to 1914 there had been genuine concern that they might be permanently banished from the estates of power. 
 Bridgeman's remark was thus symptomatic of renewed Conservative confidence. 
 With the party having re-entered the corridors of power through a side door, and with the Liberals beginning to divide over the conduct of the war, the Conservatives&equo; prewar fears had been dissipated. 
 Radical Conservatism had been the product of Conservative powerlessness and despair, and it receded with the onset of Conservative power and hope. 
 The Edwardian &bquo;crisis of Conservatism&equo; and the Conservatives' wartime recovery offer the chance for a brief historical assessment of the ideological origins of the Thatcherite revolution. 
 In the late nineteenth century Lord Salisbury had pursued a successful defensive war of manoeuvre to divide and defeat his Party's opponents. 
 The trick was to portray one's chief opponent as sectional, driven by class envy, and a danger to social and economic stability, and thereby to provoke a defensive coalition against him. 
 In the decade before the Great War this strategy had collapsed in the face of a solid anti-Conservative front, causing confusion in the Conservative ranks. 
 The initial result was that the Conservatives had sought to counter the collectivist strategy of progressivism with a collectivism of their own, while individualist arguments had been relegated to the margins of Conservative politics. 
 Indeed, the only serious alternative to the radical, collectivist strategy that was canvassed was a reassembled &bquo;Salisbury approach&equo;, based on a defensive rather than counter-offensive strategy. 
 Almost unnoticed this emerged in 1908, at the Manchester North-West by-election. 
 Here, in the home of free-trade Liberalism, the Conservatives secured a remarkable result with an election campaign fought against the &bquo;socialist&equo; taxation  policies of the Liberal government. 
 The significance of this result and the strategy deployed were lost in the political &bquo;noise&equo; created by other Conservative by-election victories won that year by committed radical Conservatives, and by the general Conservative confusion of the late Edwardian years. 
 Arguably, however, the implications of the Manchester North-West result were to become more apparent in the long term. 
 The Conservative strategy which emerged after the Great War, tentatively in the coalition years but powerfully under Baldwin, was a blend of the basic Salisbury recipe with added &bquo;Manchester North-West&equo;. 
 In the 1880s Salisbury's &bquo;enemy&equo; had been &bquo;radical Liberalism&equo; and his aim to bring over the Whigs and &bquo;Villa&equo; Liberals. 
 In the 1920s the enemy was Labour and the aim was to encourage the desertion of the middle and lower middle classes and the &bquo;black-coated&equo; workers who had once been the foot-soldiers of Liberalism. 
 In this sense the Liberal divisions during and after the war, and the ending of the progressive Alliance, provided the political space for a new Salisbury-style strategy. 
 Crucial to this development was that the war, by increasing the number of taxpayers and creating a fear of inflation among the equally increased number of small savers, offered important opportunities for a party that could pose as the defender of low taxes, low public expenditure, and monetary rectitude. 
 It was against this backdrop that the individualist liberal economics of Spencer, Dicey, the LPDL, and the BCA moved towards the centre of the Conservative Party's thinking, as economic liberalism and the minimal state became attractive in terms of consolidating a coalition against a Labour party presented as high taxers and high spenders. 
 It is thus from the 1920s that one can realistically chart a conflict in the Conservative party between a libertarian-individualist tendency and a paternalist-collectivist tendency. 
 In the interwar years the hard edges of a market-orientated Conservative Party strategy were softened, first by the avuncular consensus politics of Baldwin, and then by the virtual collapse of the market itself. 
 After the Second World War the economic prosperity brought by the long postwar boom, and the apparent popularity of the Attlee government's welfare reforms, allowed the paternalist orientations of Eden, Butler, and Macmillan to flourish, attenuated by the &bquo;stops&equo; forced by Britain's ongoing balance-of-payments problem. 
 In 1961, however, Macmillan's Conservative Government was forced to confront the underlying  weaknesses of British economic performance, and, as the Cabinet debated various strategies, the Prime Minister noted the emergence of &bquo;a rather interesting and quite deep divergence of view between Ministers, really corresponding to whether they had old Whig, Liberal, laissez-faire  traditions, or Tory opinions, paternalists and not afraid of a little dirigism . 
 With the Edwardian figure of Macmillan as leader of the party and the government, a man who had begun his career by advocating a dirigiste  stance against the liberal economic tendencies of the Baldwin-Chamberlain era, the Conservatives looked to an interventionist strategy to stave off political and economic reversals. 
 But by the 1970s, with the interventionist approach associated with both electoral and economic failure, the adherents of the &bquo;Whig, Liberal, laissez faire &equo; strategy had seized the initiative. 
 Nor were the adherents of this strategy reticent about their heritage, with one Thatcherite Cabinet Minister acknowledging in 1982, &bquo;I am a nineteenth century Liberal. 
 So is Mrs Thatcher. 
 That's what this Government is all about.' 
 A Conservative government had emerged that the Liberty and Property Defence League could well have called its own, but as a consequence it was a government that had very little to do with Conservatism.  
 PAUL ADDISON University of Edinburgh  
 The Intellectual Origins of the Keynesian Revolution 
 The Keynesian Revolution in the Making 1924&ndash;1936 . 
 By Peter Clarke. 
 Oxford: Clarendon Paperbacks, 1990, pp. 368. 
 ISBN 0-19-820219-9. &pound;12.95. 
 The rise and fall of Keynesian social democracy is one of the central problems of twentieth century British history. 
 But as a whole it has yet to be cracked. 
 Biographies of Keynes, and the writings of economists and economic historians, are indispensable to an understanding of the subject. 
 But in the final analysis it is a question of political history, which only the political historians can resolve. 
 Important contributions have already been made by David Marquand, Keith Middlemas, and Robert Skidelsky. 
 Now Peter Clarke has identified another hole at the centre of Keynesian studies. 
 The aim of his book is to explain historically the intellectual origins of the &bquo;Keynesian revolution&equo;. 
 The Keynesian revolution is usually dated to the publication of the General Theory  in 1936. 
 But obviously the revolution had been some time in the making. 
 In Dr Clarke's view, the origins can be traced back to 1924, when Keynes published an article advocating &bquo;a drastic remedy&equo; for unemployment. 
 There followed a debate over economic policy in which the principal protagonists &mdash; though many others joined in &mdash; were Keynes on the one hand and the Treasury on the other. 
 They clashed in 1925 over the return to the gold standard and again in 1928&ndash;9 over Lloyd George's proposals for loan-financed public works. 
 The battle of wits between them again featured prominently in the proceedings of the Macmillan Committee under the second Labour government. 
 the argument was continuous and as it developed both sides changed their positions. 
 But it was Keynes who possessed the greater mobility and fire-power and in the end he succeeded in shifting the argument on to theoretical grounds of his own choosing. 
 Such was the origin of the General Theory . 
 The interwar debate over economic policy has, of course, been extensively researched in recent years, and Keynes's contributions are well  documented. 
 But the dynamics of his thinking have never been easy to explain. 
 So changeable in his opinions was Keynes that many of his contemporaries were baffled, or wrote him off as mentally erratic. 
 For quite legitimate reasons, later commentators have often left the problem aside. 
 Economic historians have been more interested in assessing the outcome or potential of his policies than their origins. 
 Economists and historians of ideas have concentrated on the systematic elements in his thought and created somewhat abstract models of Keynesian theory and belief. 
 Ideas expressed at many different periods, or in many different contexts, have been assembled into a definitive world view. 
 The political historian, raised from the cradle to insist on the importance of chronology and context, would rather think in terms of intellectual biography. 
 But political historians are often rather ignorant of economics. 
 Where Keynes is concerned, they have long recognized his importance as an inspiration between the wars for a certain type of progressive, Lib-Lab politics: but few could pass an examination in Keynesian theory. 
 Dr Clarke is a political historian, and in a sense a political historian of the old school. 
 But he has made it his business to master the terminology of the economic debate, and applied to the problem an elegant and sophisticated technique of intellectual biography. 
 The result is a work of great erudition and originality, in which economic issues are explained with technical authority and literary grace. 
 Readers may still find, as I do, that some of the economic debate is unintelligible. 
 But they should draw comfort from the knowledge that the economists involved often found it hard to understand one another. 
 In Dr Clarke's analysis, context and intention hold the keys to the history of ideas. 
 It is therefore crucial to distinguish the three overlapping contexts in which the argument over economic policy was formulated: politics, policy, and theory. 
 At various times Keynes operated on all three levels, and moved easily from one to another. 
 From 1924 to 1930, Dr Clarke maintains, he was mainly concerned with politics and policy, and tried to coordinate the two in a pincer movement on the Treasury. 
 In politics he was a &bquo;new Liberal&equo; allied with Lloyd George. 
 In policy he was a critic of dear money and an advocate of public works. 
 Yet in both respects he was notable for a quicksilver opportunism of mind, adapting his arguments to the circumstances of the hour. 
 His economic theorizing, which remained at this period within the framework of neo-classical doctrine, was driven by policy considerations. 
 But then came a turning-point. 
 The financial and political crises of 1931 led Keynes to re-order his priorities: theory took the place of policy in the driving-seat. 
 Whereas, therefore, his Treatise on Money  (1930) has been accounted for along &bquo;externalist&equo; lines, as the response to a political context, the General Theory  of 1936 is best understood in &bquo;internalist&equo; terms, as the outcome of a process of intellectual discovery.  
 How convincing is this &bquo;story of an argument&equo;? 
 Dr Clarke maintains that in the 1920s Keynes was primarily a political animal. 
 The radicalism of his campaign for state investment owed nothing to latent dissent over economic theory, for neo-classical economics could accommodate public works and Keynes himself remained on orthodox disciple of Marshall. 
 Nor was Keynes prompted by the return to gold at the prewar parity, for this event occurred after his campaign for &bquo;national development&equo; had begun. 
 All this is extremely helpful and clearly points towards a political explanation. 
 But there may be some disagreement over the way in which Dr Clarke formulates this. 
 In his view, Keynes's entry into the arena was the result of his commitment to the new Liberalism. 
 Keynes's adherence to the Liberal party in the 1920s is a matter of record, and historians of Liberalism have been eager to assimilate him to the great tradition. 
 But what kind of Liberal was he? 
 A Liberal ideologue, or an intellectual aristocrat sailing under a flag of convenience? 
 While Keynes's ideas overlapped with Liberalism, his philosophy taught him that all political principles were expedients to be adopted or discarded on ethical grounds. 
 Keynes, therefore, subscribed to Liberalism as the best available option, but from a position of inner detachment. 
 In his own sphere, Keynes was as great an adventurer as Lloyd George in his, and I doubt whether the old Liberalism or the new was entirely safe in his hands. 
 Of course it can be argued that since he adopted the Liberal cause in the 1920s, he was practically at one with Liberalism, and that is all that matters. 
 But if so I am not wholly convinced that he adopted the new Liberalism. 
 Michael Freeden's criticisms on this score are still pertinent. 
 perhaps the truth is that in the field of economic policy, Keynes's preference for a managed economy aligned him with the new Liberals: hence the handsome tribute he paid to J. A. Hobson, in spite of the fact that he regarded him as mistaken. 
 But in his belief that economic efficiency must if necessary take priority over social justice, Keynes lacked the left-Liberal vision of a new moral order in society, More than half of Dr Clarke's book is devoted to the debate over economic policy between 1928 and 1930. 
 This is a story of intricate intellectual manoeuvre in a clamorously political context. 
 The main effect is to revise our understanding of both Keynes and the Treasury. 
 It is no secret that Keynes was a highly intuitive thinker who often changed his mind: in 1930 he defended the gold standard, which he had previously attacked, and in 1931 he abandoned the principle of free trade, which he had previously upheld. 
 Dr Clarke's painstaking scrutiny of the record now shows that Keynes was even more changeable than we thought. 
 But he also offers an explanation. 
 Keynes was intuitively convinced that public works would lift Britain out of the depression. 
 But he was still at an experimental stage of his thinking, and this enabled his political opportunism to come into play. 
 In  the general election campaign of 1929 the Liberals were challenged by the Conservatives to explain where the money would come from. 
 Keynes improvised the answers, and changed them as he went along. 
 When he sat down again after the election to resume his theoretical work, The Treatise on Money , he found that his theory had changed. 
 In Keynes's view, the great imperative was public works. 
 If he could win support for domestic expansion by coupling it with other proposals, he was only too eager to do so. 
 The appointment by the incoming Labour government of the Macmillan Committee, of which Keynes was a member, gave him another chance to carry through his revolution in policy. 
 In his evidence to the Committee, Keynes identified seven possible classes of remedy for depression, and assured his colleagues that practically all of them were of some value. 
 Keynes was trying to create a consensus around public works and his adoption of protection in the autumn of 1930 was almost certainly an attempt to enlist the support of the growing tariff lobby. 
 Dr Clarke's analysis of the proceedings of the Macmillan Committee, which occupies five chapters out of thirteen, is outstanding. 
 Keynes figures as a brilliant operator in committee, flexible in his tactics and sweetly reasonable in argument. 
 He is often pictured as an outsider battling against entrenched orthodoxies. 
 Dr Clarke shows him as an insider addressing officials and economists of many shades of opinion, including some whose position was close to his own. 
 Historians used to attribute a fixed economic dogma to the Treasury: &bquo;the Treasury view&equo;. 
 But recent research has modified this judgement and Dr Clarke carries the revision further. 
 Treasury dogma as commonly understood held that state investment inevitably crowded out an equal volume of private investment, and was therefore incapable of increasing employment. 
 But it now appears that in this form the &bquo;Treasury view&equo; was a transient formula. 
 Dr Clarke has discovered a hitherto unreleased file on the Treasury response to public works in 1928&ndash;9. 
 This shows that when Churchill first asked his officials to brief him on the subject, R. G. Hawtrey replied that public works would indeed increase employment, provided they were linked to an expansion of credit. 
 But there was in fact no need for public works, since cheap money would have the same effect by increasing private investment. 
 Hawtrey, then, showed some affinity with Keynes. 
 The Treasury view as proclaimed in 1929 was the work of Leith-Ross and others, and did not long survive the political circumstances of its birth &mdash; a split in the Cabinet over employment policy. 
 By 1930, when Sir Richard Hopkins gave evidence on behalf of the Treasury to the Macmillan Committee, the &bquo;crowding out&equo; theory had been quietly dropped and replaced by an insistence on the administrative difficulties involved. 
 The Labour government, then, was not wholly the prisoner of dogma. 
 (It may still have been the prisoner of vested interests, but that is another  matter.) 
 As long as Keynes pitched his arguments for credit expansion within the bounds of orthodoxy, he dominated the proceedings of the Committee and achieved a degree of consensus. 
 Stamp, for example, was sympathetic. 
 Pigou shared Keynes's analysis of the disequilibrium between savings and investment, and was prepared to endorse public works. 
 But there was still an underlying divergence of opinion over one major issue. 
 Pigou, Henderson, and Stamp all emphasized the importance of cuts in the cost of wages. 
 While accepting that wage cuts were theoretically advisable, Keynes at first argued that they should only be attempted as a last resort, after all other remedies had failed. 
 But with his &bquo;eclectic and protean opportunism&equo;, he went on to recommend a revenue tariff as a wage cut in disguise. 
 Dr Clarke brings powerful evidence to bear in support of his contention that 1931 marked a watershed in Keynes's development. 
 Within a few months, every plank of his excessively clever platform collapsed. 
 The Labour government broke up and the report of the Macmillan Committee sank without trace. 
 The Liberal party disintegrated a second time. 
 The abandonment of the gold standard and the devaluation of sterling removed the theoretical justification which the Treatise  supplied for public works in a period when bank rate was too high for purposes of domestic equilibrium. 
 In explaining the sequence of thought which led Keynes to the General Theory , Dr Clarke has taken full advantage of recently discovered sources, including students' notes of Keynes's lectures at Cambridge. 
 But he has also incorporated, and indeed revised, much recent analysis by economists. 
 I must leave it to economists to say how much they have learnt from his account, or where they would disagree with it. 
 from the point of view of history, including economic history, this is by far the best analysis we have of the genesis of the General Theory . 
 The suspicion that Keynes picked up his ideas from R. F. Kahn or other members of the &bquo;Cambridge circus&equo; is laid to rest, and his intuitive leap into the theory of effective demand dated to the summer of 1932. 
 Among all the illuminations I would raise only one general query. 
 According to Dr Clarke, the Treatise  was mainly a political invention, while the General Theory  was mainly an intellectual one. 
 But does this distinction really work? 
 Firstly it is clear that whatever contingencies entered into the writing of the Treatise , Keynes himself intended it as a major contribution to economic theory, free-standing and internally valid in all circumstances. 
 Hence the fact that his fellow economists, who regarded it as mistaken, were at great pains to refute it on theoretical grounds. 
 It would surely be difficult to prove that the terms of the theory were prescribed by political requirements. 
 True, Dr Clarke might well reply, but the Treatise  was an attempt to resolve theoretically an urgent political problem: the same could not plausibly be said of the General Theory . 
 But surely it could. 
 Keynes began work on it during the worst year of the slump, under a government  which had slammed the door on his favourite project of public works. 
 The non-socialist critics of the National Government were desperate for a constructive alternative. 
 Why, then, is it necessary to depict Keynes as shifting, after 1931, from politics or policy to theory? 
 Surely it would be more accurate to say that he shifted from one theory to another, and that both formulations had their external, political aspect? 
 In his closing chapter, Dr Clarke reflects on the rise and fall of Keynesian politics since 1936. 
 Again the distinctions between theory, policy, and politics serve him well. 
 The insights of the theory, he believes, are still valid: market forces do not guarantee the full use of resources. 
 But policies must vary and change with circumstances. 
 Keynes's own policies have often been misrepresented: in the 1930s, for example, he was well aware of the structural problems of British industry, and did not believe that unemployment could be reduced much below 12 per cent. 
 In the Second World War he seems to have thought that 5 per cent would be a reasonable target for postwar policy. 
 Keynes might well have disapproved of the &bquo;Keynesianism, of the postwar politicians, but runaway inflation nevertheless led to a successful monetarist assault on Keynesian theory. 
 Dr Clarke contends that while Keynesianism was overthrown on the pretext that it did not &bquo;work&equo;, the collapse was political rather than theoretical. 
 Under Mrs Thatcher, the Conservatives rediscovered the fact, well known to the National Government, that mass unemployment was no barrier to electoral success. 
 The only objective sense in which monetarism worked better than Keynesianism was the electoral one: the &bquo;strong bargainers in all classes&equo; were content for the economy to run at well below capacity. 
 Dr Clarke's conclusion invites much speculation about current and future trends. 
 But it also draws attention to another gap in the history of Keynesianism. 
 Why was full employment a political imperative between 1944 and 1975? 
 What were the relationships between the politics, policy, and theory of Keynesianism in its golden age? 
 Was the fiscal constitution corrupted and if so was it by Keynesianism or by corporatism? 
 Economic historians have begun to explore the issues, but the political historians have yet to master them. 
 Now that Dr Clarke has written a first-class book on the origins of the Keynesian revolution, we must hope that he will write another on the consequences.  
 REVIEWS 
 Road to Divorce: England 1530&ndash;1987 . 
 By Lawrence Stone. 
 Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1990, pp. 460, &pound;19.95. 
 ISBN 0-19-822651-9. 
 This book has a symbiotic relationship with Professor Stone's earlier volume, The Family, Sex and Marriage in England 1500&ndash;1800 , drawing heavily as it does on the idea of the emergence of affective individualism in family relationships and its link to the rise in marital unhappiness during both the eighteenth and the twentieth centuries. 
 But the focus of this volume is the law of marriage and divorce, which Professor Stone feels has been sorely neglected by historians of the family. 
 His account is intended to provide the structural and analytical framework for two companion volumes ( Uncertain Unions  and Broken Lives ) which will give more illustration of the making and breaking of marriage. 
 &bquo;Bringing the law back in&equo; is a worthy and important endeavour; as Stone notes, the story of the control of marriage in England is radically different from that in France largely because of its different state structure. 
 But difficult questions are raised as to the nature of the relationship between law and behaviour. 
 The core of the book focuses on the period between 1660 and 1857, when legal divorce was exceedingly rare and confined to the privileged. 
 The full extent of marital breakdown is of course very hard to assess, and Roderick Phillips has argued convincingly that while divorce might breed divorce, it does not necessarily breed marital breakdown.&equo; 
 The really significant change in divorce, in terms of both law and behaviour, has taken place in the twentieth century; and as Stone devotes only forty of his 422 pages to a consideration of the period after 1857, he essentially precludes an answer to the question he poses, namely, why divorce has become as common as taxes and death. 
 The story of marriage and divorce law is extremely complicated. 
 Stone's account is comprehensive and authoritative, relying on an extensive exploration of court records. 
 He concludes that &bquo;it is not too strong to say that the marriage law as it operated in practice in England from the fourteenth to the nineteenth centuries was a mess&equo; (p. 135). 
 For much of the period he discusses, it was far from easy to prove whether a couple was legally married at all. 
 Prior to the 1753 Marriage Act, the state made few serious attempts to suppress either contract marriage, which consisted of a verbal promise, or clandestine marriage, which involved a religious ritual and witnesses but which did not conform to the dictates of canon law. 
 Both were attractive because of their greater privacy and cheapness.  
 Divorce procedures prove similarly hard to unravel. 
 Among the poor who had no property, desertion was the informal answer to marital unhappiness and was practised on an unknown scale until the Second World War: certainly, eighteenth and nineteenth century poor law officials often expressed concern at the number of deserted wives drawing relief. 
 Only since the 1960s have virtually all those separating also divorced. 
 Among the propertied, private separations were much more common than judicial separations and, according to Stone, represent a &bquo;remarkable example of how an officially non-divorcing society can devise its own quasi-legal instruments to cope with the fact of irremediable marital breakdowns&equo; (p. 182). 
 Judicial separation by the ecclesiastical courts, which did not give a licence to remarry. 
 And full Parliamentary divorce, which did, accounted for only a handful of divorces. 
 The 1857 Divorce Act, which removed divorce from church jurisdiction, did not result in a rapid increase in the divorce rate. 
 Stone's analysis of the legislation provides a valuable corrective to those who have argued that it represented a revolutionary change. 
 Rather, it first, made full divorce somewhat easier and cheaper, opening it up to the upper middle class, second, made judicial separation more expensive and more rare; and third, continued to deny the poor access to either. 
 One of the major strengths of the book is to show the importance of both the vested interests of lawyers and the keen competition between the ecclesiastical and common law courts in determining the nature of legal practice and reform. 
 With regard to marriage, eighteenth century canon law, which recognized marriage based on verbal contract, found itself in conflict with common law, which denied the validity of such marriages as far as property was concerned. 
 In both marriage and divorce law, much of the legal story concerns the way in which the common law captured tracts of territory from the church courts. 
 Breach of promise suits, which allowed individuals to sue for damages if they had been injured by unenforceable marriage contracts and which became increasingly popular in the nineteenth century, provide one example of this development. 
 Cases alleging &bquo;criminal conversation&equo;, which begin as a means of giving compensation to the husband for a lover's access to his wife and ending (by the late eighteenth century) as a necessary prerequisite for full divorce by Act of Parliament, provide another. 
 Stone is utterly convincing in his argument that the 1857 Divorce Act had nothing to do with perceived changes in the economic conditions of the labouring poor during early industrialization and everything to do with lawyers' determination to do something about the chaotic state of the law. 
 In concentrating all matrimonial legislation in a new secular High Court in London, the Act also represented the success of common and equity lawyers in capturing full control of matrimonial litigation. 
 To explain the nature of legal change Stone offers a model that suggests first, that clients revealed the gap between current values and the law; second, that this was followed by the attempt of lawyers and judges to narrow the gap, often by inventing legal fictions or effectively changing the law by judicial re-interpretation (the changing definition of legal cruelty provides one example of this); and third, that all this culminated eventually in legal change when the &bquo;level of duplicity and hypocrisy became intolerable to law lords and legislators alike&equo; (pp. 19&ndash;20). 
 This model, which echoes that used by Oliver MacDonagh to explain the growth in nineteenth century government, relies on a high degree of consonance in the wishes of lawyers and their  clients, a not unreasonable assumption given the limited access to divorce in Stone's period. 
 But it is not a model that holds up for the twentieth century, when liberalization of the divorce law was not a matter of last resort but was rather always proposed as a means of strengthening the institution of marriage (by permitting those &bquo;living in sin&equo; to remarry); when opinion shifted with dramatic speed, for example between the conservative recommendations of the 1956 Royal Commission on Divorce and the endorsement of profound liberalization given a mere ten years later by both the Law Commission and the Church of England; and when the change in views of key institutions such as the Church of England were as important as those of lawyers. 
 The permission given by the 1969 Act for no-fault divorce was driven as much by a profound rethinking of the sources of morality by clerical and academic opinion as by the determined pursuit of individual self-interest on the part of either the population at large or lawyers in particular. 
 But this is not something that Stone tackles. 
 His chapter on the post-1857 situation is confined to a charting exercise in which the context provided is often misleading (married women's participation in the labour market did not rise rapidly in the interwar years), and in which the facts are sometimes shaky (not all working-class women were opposed to divorce in the early part of the century; the Women's Co-operative Guild gave evidence to the 1909 Royal Commission in favour of it). 
 Stone might not have much to say about the past hundred years, but the shadow of the present undoubtedly hangs over the book. 
 In The Family, Sex and Marriage  he was careful to retain an open mind on affective individualism, emphasizing first that it was not necessarily the way of the future, family change not being linear, and second, that it did not necessarily result in greater happiness than other forms of family organization. 
 In Road to Divorce , he is much closer to concluding that affective individualism is a &bquo;Bad Thing&equo;. 
 In his final chapter, he notes that the 1956 Royal Commission on Divorce identified what he feels &bquo;may perhaps be the most important influence of all in driving up the divorce rate, namely the idealization of the individual pursuit of self-gratification and personal pleasure at the expense of a sense of reciprocal obligations and duties towards helpless dependents, such as children, and, our society as a whole&equo; (pp 403&ndash;4). 
 Stone shows no awareness of the place of the Royal Commission's recommendations within the politics of the postwar debate on the disintegration of the family, which was almost as much a preoccupation of the 1940s and early 1950s (the Commission was set up in 1952) as it was during the 1980s. 
 The Commission's point accords with the development of Stone's own views about the perils of affective individualism and finds a prominent place in the opening theoretical section to the book. 
 While Stone struggles to keep open the question as to whether more divorce produces an increase in the sum of human happiness, he is obviously uneasy about the way in which divorce has become a routine and largely administrative process. 
 But this preoccupation can do little to illuminate the long period of non-divorce and tends in the end to convey a linear development, implied also by the title of the book, notwithstanding Stone's concern to stress the variability in the meanings of divorce, marriage, and morality. 
 Meanings are crucial to understanding how England lived with chaotic marriage and no divorce for so long before changing the rules governing personal relation-ships decisively. 
 However, there is surprisingly little in this book on what marriage and divorce meant to the men and women involved. 
 There are several references to  the importance commentators attached to the relationship between the stability of the family and that of the state, which is certainly crucial to explaining the long reluctance to reform the divorce law. 
 As late as the 1900s, Mrs Humphry Ward, the best-selling Victorian novelist and leading anti-suffragist, stressed that marriage had to be regarded as a necessary discipline, for if husbands and wives could not resolve their differences what hope remained for the larger polity? 
 The battles over divorce during the period covered by Stone were about the licence to remarry, that is, about the formal recognition that it was possible fully to dissolve the marital contract. 
 In the twentieth century the battles have been over quite different issues and in the courts the hitherto ancillary matters of child custody and maintenance have come to the fore. 
 But this does not help much in understanding what marriage meant to men and to women in different social classes at different points in time and what in their minds justified separation. 
 Ellen Ross's work has shown that among working-class Edwardians the marriage contract entailed a precise understanding of duties and obligations regarding maintenance (on the part of the husband) and household management (on the part of the wife), but little by way of intimacy or romantic love.&equo; 
 It is not part of Stone's business to look at the condition of working people, but the illustrations in the book reveal very little about the thought styles that the privileged brought to marriage and divorce. 
 Of course, it is hard to know much of women's thinking because they are so rarely represented in the source material; for example, having no legal personality in common law, they were forced to remain silent in &bquo;crim. con.&equo; actions. 
 However, to some extent the neglect of such important issues of the difference in the meaning of marriage and divorce to men and women, the contradictions in the thinking and behaviour of the two sexes, and the negotiation of their positions has something to do with another presentist shadow: that of feminism. 
 Stone is anxious to stress that women did not want divorce, which is largely true of the period he concentrates on, although the picture becomes much more complicated in the twentieth century. 
 Articulate middle-class women in the nineteenth century were certainly more concerned with gaining increased autonomy and control &mdash; over children and property &mdash; within marriage, than with access to divorce. 
 This may be set alongside their widespread suspicion of birth control and was undoubtedly strongly related to the very limited alternatives to marriage open to them. 
 Stone also emphasizes the extent to which women accepted the double moral standard. 
 Thus in his account women become passive and sometimes even willing victims. 
 The illustrations are replete with husbands who forced wives to wear chastity belts or even sewed up their labia. 
 Stone seems to think that feminist history would insist on an active campaigning role for women, and this unfortunately causes him also to dismiss the significance of gender as a category for historical analysis on the grounds that it comes with too much &bquo;ideological baggage&equo; (p. 12, n. 19). 
 This is a pity, for arguably an appreciation of both the importance of the social construction of feminity and masculinity and the extent to which fundamental concepts are gendered is necessary before the process by which men and women's  thinking about marriage and divorce can be understood. 
 Without this we are left with little more than the old rather &bquo;Whiggish&equo; account of how reasonable men gradually came to perceive women's ills. 
 Thus Caroline Norton, who was the subject of a trumped up crim. con. suit and who lost the custody of her children, is portrayed as a simple victim, albeit in her case not a passive one. 
 In contrast, Mary Poovey's recent account of the Norton case emphasizes the way in which the ideological separation of spheres both generated and depended on an arrangement of social and property relations that positioned women as moral superiors and economic dependents. 
 She suggests that in the 1850s divorce became the &bquo;solution&equo; to the threat of a Married Women's Property Act (not achieved until the last quarter of the nineteenth century), which would have threatened &bquo;the symbolic economy that depended on and institutionalized (such) binary oppositions&equo;. 
 Similarly, A. James Hammerton's analysis of the Victorian law of matrimonial cruelty also demonstrates the complex and different ways in which men and women drew on ideas of patriarchal and companionate marriage. 
 Once permitted and enabled (chiefly by virtue of legal aid) to petition for divorce, women have done so in ever-increasing numbers. 
 Stone is not alone in noting the &bquo;discrepancy&equo; (p. 420) between this and the apparent economic drawbacks of divorce for women (the increase in divorce has been one of the major factors contributing to the &bquo;feminization of poverty&equo;). 
 The temptation for some present-day commentators has been to conclude that it is in women's &bquo;real&equo; interests to limit divorce. 
 Stone does not go this far, although he cannot resist quoting an Irish opponent of divorce during the referendum campaign of 1986 to the effect that &bquo;a woman voting for divorce is like a turkey voting for Christmas&equo; (p. 420). 
 Women's seemingly paradoxical behaviour merely drives home the point that there are profound contradictions and complexities of position to be unravelled before we can get further in our understanding of the road to divorce. 
 JANE LEWIS 
 Empire and Sexuality: The British Experience . 
 By Ronald Hyam. 
 Manchester University press, pp. 192, 1990, &pound;35. 0 7190 2504 4. 
 This useful and sensible book is written in the belief that historians cannot properly understand the dynamics of British imperial expansion without taking account of the sexual attitudes and expectations of the men who have administered British overseas possessions since the eighteenth century. 
 Hyam believes that the sexual activities of imperialist manpower have been erased from the historical record, or else written about in stereotyped ways which had little to do with reality, and that we are therefore left with an incomplete understanding of the colonial experience. 
 Books about colonialists are usually very different from those about, say writers: they are written by different kinds of authors, ask different kinds of questions, are couched in  a different style. 
 Empire and Sexuality  brings some of the insights and analysis which are now conventional in literary biography to the history of British imperialism. 
 Drawing on a wide range of primary and published sources, it chronicles 200 years of British antics in imperial bedrooms. 
 Hyam examines such subjects as sexual exploitation under slavery, sexual coercion in convict settlements. 
 The use of catamites in mining compounds, the vindictive obtuseness of Christian missionary influence, changing attitudes to miscegenation and concubinage, the varieties of brothel culture across the world. 
 The fashion of male circumcision that began in the 1890s, and a wide range of related subjects. 
 He also scrutinizes the sexual acts, fears, and fantasies of selected soldiers and administrators in a way which is revealing both of their personal dynamics and of their working conditions. 
 Some of Hyam's most impressive passages describe male bisexuality: in many of the cultures which the British conquered or governed, sexual relations between men carried none of the odium or guilt to which they were subject in the United Kingdom (particularly from the 1890s), and he has unearthed much evidence of cheerful, matter-of-fact but discreetly conducted sexual relations between British men overseas. 
 His most important theme is the way in which, uniquely among imperial powers, British concepts of masculinity &mdash; not least as fostered in public schools &mdash; had been redefined by 1914 in the perceived interest of imperial administrative efficiency &bquo;to mean not sexual prowess and maturity, but sexual restraint&equo;. 
 The Colonial Office Circular of 1909 to its employees on &bquo;immoral relations with native women, is shown to be a crucial development which involved &bquo;a massive and indeed revolutionary intrusion of public authority into the private lives of official classes overseas&equo;. 
 Hyam also deplores the recent &bquo;willingness of Third World governments to adopt the peculiar Purity laws and conventions of Britain in the 1880s as if they represented ultimate truths about human civilisation&equo;. 
 Hyam writes in the easy, tolerant manner of a man of the world, to use an old-fashioned phrase which seems appropriate in this context. 
 His text is singularly free from psychobabble, refreshingly unpatronizing, and &mdash; unlike most other historians of sexuality &mdash; he seeks neither to bludgeon nor to manipulate his readers. 
 He has some severe but convincing strictures on the impoverished and distorted contribution of feminist studies to his subject. 
 Given the extent of his researches, some of his conclusions are muted; but this calm, humane book, with its provocative ideas and lively squibs, is exemplary of its kind. 
 University of Reading  R.T.P. Davenport-Hines 
 British Intelligence in the Second World War , Vol. 4: Security and Counter-Intelligence. 
 By F. H. Hinsley and C. A. G. Simkins. 
 London: HMSO, 1990, pp. xii + 408, &pound;15.95. 
 ISBN 0-11-630954-7. 
 This book has an unpromising genesis. 
 Completed some time ago, the government then held up its publication when the Spycatcher  affair erupted, so that it could not be accused of double standards in trying to ban Wright's book while giving Hinsley's the nod. 
 There are vast differences between the two, of course; but not all of them  are to the latter's credit. 
 In a nutshell, Hinsley is infinitely more trustworthy than Wright, but more shackled. 
 Wright &mdash; so long as he remained in exile &mdash; could write what he liked. 
 Hinsley is bound by all kinds of rules about what he can and cannot reveal, in the &bquo;national interest&equo;, of which the authorities are the sole arbiters. 
 He also cannot cite the sources for many of the bits he is allowed to reveal, with the result that they cannot be independently checked. 
 This flies in the face of the most fundamental principles of the historian's &mdash; or indeed any scholarly &mdash; profession. 
 The result is a deeply flawed book in many ways, though useful, to a limited extent, in others. 
 It deals with the domestic intelligence front. 
 This is usually regarded as the most sensitive aspect of secret service work. 
 There is a long tradition in Britain of hostility to &bquo;political espionage&equo;, some of which surfaces in this book. 
 In 1921, for example, we find the police warning against setting up a &bquo;continental system of domestic espionage&equo; in Britain (p. 6) Even SIS, which had designs on MI5 in 1945, shied away from the latter's counter-subversive functions, so as not to be &bquo;associated with the idea of an internal Gestapo, (p. 177) No wonder governments are nervous of too much openness in this area. 
 The reason why the present government nevertheless eventually sanctioned this book is that it mainly covers the war years, when the secret services were inevitably more widely tolerated than at other times. 
 The chief task of MI5 between 1939 and 1945 was to counter German espionage and sabotage in Britain and the empire. 
 No one could cavil with that, either then, or in historical retrospect. 
 The other factor making for openness is that MI5's record for this period seems on the whole to be creditable. 
 It started off badly &mdash; in April 1940 Norman Birkett spoke of &bquo;gross mistakes and pathological stupidities in connexion with its internment policy (p. 39) &mdash; but it got better. 
 Its master stroke was its &bquo;double cross system&equo;, whereby it turned enemy spies into double agents, working for the British and feeding false information back. 
 There is a great deal about this here. 
 Much of it has been known before, from the account published by J. C. Masterman &mdash; one of the MI5 men concerned &mdash; in 1972. 
 Masterman claimed that by this means Britain &bquo;actively ran and controlled the German espionage system in this country&equo; Readers of the present book will be interested to know whether Professor Hinsley corroborated this. 
 He does in general, though he also knocks some gilt off the gingerbread by pointing out how easy it all was. 
 Some German agents must have stood out like sore thumbs (One, codenamed &bquo;Garbo&equo;, could never figure out English pounds, shillings, and pence, and once reported back to Berlin from Glasgow that there were men there &bquo;who would do anything for a litre of wine&equo; (p. 112).) 
 In Berlin the Abwehr organization was pitifully inept (pp. 280&ndash;1). 
 Nevertheless, MI5 could be justly proud of &bquo;double cross&equo;. 
 It was a clever wheeze, great fun to work, and it probably succeeded in neutralizing the German espionage threat. 
 This is intriguing and entertaining, but not very new. 
 More interesting to the historian are this book's accounts of MI5's activities on the counter-subversive front &mdash; chiefly against the British Fascists, the Communist Party of Great Britain, and the Peace Pledge Union &mdash; and of its interminable behind-the-scenes wrangles with other government agencies, especially SIS. 
 The former is enlightening, if somewhat bland. 
 Partly due to the ban placed on the authors' disclosing anything about &bquo;intelligence techniques&equo; (p. x), which has been rigidly enforced. 
 The latter is fascinating, especially  in the glimpses it occasionally gives of the general principles and priorities which informed MI5's work, and the unease these aroused in some quarters. 
 This is the best aspect of the book. 
 The worst is its omissions. 
 Some of these are breathtaking. 
 The most outrageous concerns one of its joint authors. 
 Historians, like politicians, should declare their interests. 
 C. A. G. Simkins does not. 
 He is an &bquo;insider&equo;: an ex-member of MI5, rising to deputy director; but you could not tell that from this book. 
 The title-page describes him simply as a Scholar of New College, Oxford and a Barrister at Law. 
 That smacks of what he and his co-author themselves describe (p. 244) as suppressio veri , at the very least. 
 Other omissions are nearly as serious. 
 For example, scarcely any names are mentioned: just seven of acknowledged wartime MI5 personnel in all. 
 Some of the most famous MI5 officers and agents are entirely ignored. 
 One is Maxwell Knight, the head of M(5)b (counter-subversion) and probably the best-known MI5 officer ever (apart from Hollis, Wright, and Blunt), who gets no credit at all. 
 This inevitably makes MI5 seem impersonal, and hides the varied character traits and prejudices which contributed so much to its ethos and efficiency (or lack of it). 
 This is a serious distortion. 
 Recruitment policies are not touched on, with one brief prewar exception (p. 10), which means that we are kept in ignorance of the kinds of men and women (reputedly mostly Oxbridge dons) who augmented MI5's strength and clearly had a great impact on its whole character and competence at the beginning of the war. 
 The problem of fascist sympathies among the ranks of MI5 at the outset of the war is entirely ignored, as is the removal in 1940 of its founder and director, Sir Vernon Kell, which may or may not have been connected with that issue. 
 A number of well-known and controversial incidents involving the security services &mdash; among them the Benjamin Greene affair, the Hess mission, and the Tyler Kent case &mdash; are either omitted altogether or merely mentioned in passing. 
 And anyone wanting enlightenment on Soviet penetration in the war years will be sorely disappointed in this book. 
 The known &bquo;moles&equo; are passed over completely. 
 Maxwell Knight's famous paper about KGB infiltration, &bquo;The Comintern is Not Dead&equo;, which Roger Hollis apparently shelved, is ignored. 
 There is no mention of the doubts which (probably unworthily) still surround the name of Hollis himself. 
 It is as if none of these problems and controversies ever existed. 
 Perhaps they did not. 
 Could they all be inventions, disinformation planted on gullible amateur spy-writers by the KGB? 
 If so, we should be told. 
 This book, therefore, is good and probably reliable as far as it goes. 
 For this we have to thank Professor Hinsley, a highly respected and trustworthy historian, who would not allow deceptions to appear under his name. 
 Subjects which could not be mentioned without deception, because of the insufferable restraints to which he is subject, are consequently omitted entirely. 
 The effect is rather like a newspaper carrying blank columns where items have been banned. 
 It has advantages. 
 For the authorities, it ensures that only a relatively sanitized version of events gets out; for the authors, it means that they do not have to perjure themselves, and has the additional benefit that the gaps &mdash; and consequently the restraints under which they have had to work &mdash; are obvious to their readers. 
 But there are also drawbacks. 
 The gaps are bound to undermine trust and arouse suspicions. 
 That hurts the authorities. 
 For historians the drawback is that the gaps appear at just about every point where there  is something they would like to know. 
 This is the main fault of the book. 
 It contains some fascinating material, but not on the central issues of twentieth century British secret service history. 
 For that you have to read between its lines. 
 And that, of course, is fraught with dangers. 
 University of Hull  BERNARD PORTER 
 Troubled Days of Peace: Mountbatten and South East Asia Command, 1945&ndash;46 . 
 By Peter Dennis. 
 Manchester: Manchester University Press, &pound;13.95, 1990, PP. 270. 
 ISBN 0-7190-2258-4. 
 In July 1945 the boundaries of Mountbatten's South East Asia Command were extended to include the Netherlands East Indies and the southern part of Indochina as well as the original Burma, Siam, Malaya, Singapore, and Sumatra. 
 Almost as soon as this decision was taken the atom bombs fell on Hiroshima and Nagasaki and the Japanese surrendered. 
 The task facing the Supreme Commander changed abruptly and fundamentally but became no easier. 
 His empire now stretched over one and a half million square miles of war-shattered Asia, with a population of some 128 million, many of them starving or, at least, severely undernourished. 
 Scattered all over his territories were 738,000 Japanese; in theory a defeated army but in most cases still armed and either potentially dangerous or the only organized force capable of keeping chaos at bay. 
 As widely scattered were over a hundred thousand prisoners of war or internees, who had to be tracked down, liberated, and succoured. 
 Mountbatten's post-surrender tasks were first, to ensure that the Japanese were disarmed and repatriated; second, to rescue the prisoners of war; and third, to restore law and order and maintain it until civilian authority could be restored. 
 The first two tasks, though hideously difficult, were at least relatively straightforward; the third posed the problem which is at the heart of Peter Dennis's book: whose law was to be restored and what civilian authority should take over? 
 In so far as Whitehall had considered these matters it had been vaguely assumed that a status quo ante  would be established and the Dutch in the Netherlands East Indies, the French in Indochina, and the Colonial Office in Burma and Malaya would resume their rightful sway. 
 The Americans had different views, but they had deliberately distanced themselves from the area. 
 Only gradually did it dawn on those responsible that vigorous and determined nationalist organizations had grown up in the shadow of the Japanese, that these movements had flourished exceedingly in the vacuum left by the collapse of Japanese power, and that if the colonial regimes were to be reconstituted it could only be by force. 
 Mountbatten's personal view was that the new nationalist movements should be appeased rather than suppressed and that the old colonial powers should settle for the best deal that they could get, pledging independence in the near future and thus, he hoped, preserving the greater part of their economic advantages. 
 In Burma, where he had only the British Colonial Office and colonial administrators to deal with, he was more or less able to have his way. 
 Elsewhere it was different. 
 &bquo;I can assure you,&equo; he told Tom Driberg, &bquo;that if I was left as free a hand in French  Indochina and the Netherlands East Indies as I was left in Burma, I could solve both these problems by the same methods; though it is heartbreaking to have to leave the political control to other nations when we are really in military control.&equo; 
 Given the singularly uncertain nature of the &bquo;military control&equo; which British forces in fact exercised at the time, one can sympathize with Mr Dennis when he remarks that &bquo;this display of self-assurance can only be described as breathtaking&equo;. 
 When one views the subsequent history of Vietnam, and Indonesia, however, it does not seem extravagant to claim that Mountbatten could hardly have made as bad a job of it if he had been left to his own devices. 
 In Indochina matters were taken out of his control by the precipitancy of his own local commander, General Gracey, who involved his forces in a defence of French interests far beyond that envisaged in his instructions. 
 One difficulty for Mountbatten was that the Foreign Secretary, Ernest Bevin, took a view of the situation closer to that of Gracey than that of the Supreme Commander: &bquo;Bevin is behaving like the worst conservative diehard,&equo; wrote Edwina Mountbatten in another context. 
 Undaunted Mountbatten battled on, but he could do little to prevent the fait accompli  that led eventually to Dien Bien Phu. 
 In the Netherlands East Indies he did more to promote his point of view. 
 &bquo;Bold, not to negotiate with the nationalists; as the outrage was felt exclusively by the Dutch it is doubtful whether Mountbatten would have resented the description. 
 He had little success, however, in his efforts to persuade the Dutch that Sukarno was a man with whom they could do business and found himself a reluctant pig in the middle, reviled by one side as a fascist imperialist and by the other as an irresponsible revolutionary. 
 This, therefore, is a chronicle of failure, though a gallant failure and of a project engaged in with the best of intentions. 
 Peter Dennis attaches rather more weight than seems wise to the embittered and somewhat impressionistic recollections of General Christison, but his account of events is balanced and fair. 
 He does justice to Mountbatten's considerable failings but also to his still more considerable qualities. 
 Lucid, intelligent, and shrewd, this is a most useful contribution to a fascinating but little-studied period of history. 
 PHILIP ZIEGLER 
 The British Part in the Korean War , vol. 1: A Distant Obligation. 
 By Anthony Farrar-Hockley. 
 London: HMSO, 1990, pp. 522, &pound;35. 
 ISBN 0-11-630953-9. 
 The Commonwealth Armies and the Korean War . 
 By Jeffrey Grey. 
 Manchester: Manchester University Press, 1988, pp. 244, &pound;12.95. 
 ISBN 0 &mdash; 7190-2770-5. 
 With the publication of the Foreign Relations of the United States  volumes on the Korean War and the release of the British documents it was evident that Britain had played a major role in the important decisions taken in the early stages of the war, and in particular the decision to change the aim of the operation from being merely  to repel the aggressor north of the 38th parallel to that of achieving a unified Korea. 
 The naval support given immediately by Britain for the Korean operation was seen by the Foreign Office as a useful demonstration of Britain's &bquo;capacity to act as a world power with the support of the Commonwealth, and of its quickness to move when action rather than words are necessary&equo;. 
 From Washington the British ambassador, Sir Oliver Franks, reported that in Korea the American government and people had &bquo;instinctively followed their high destiny in the world&equo;. 
 But Americans felt lonely: Britain should offer to send land forces to reassure them. 
 The Chiefs of Staff did not want to do this, and the Defence Committee was worried lest the Korean conflict should divert attention from other danger-spots in Asia and blind Britain to the risk to which it was exposed in Europe. 
 But by the end of July 1950 the need for Anglo-American solidarity outweighed the military disadvantages, and the Cabinet agreed to the formulation of a brigade group to operate in Korea under American command. 
 Following General Douglas MacArthur's initial victories the change in the nature of the Korean operation was very much a British initiative. 
 On 21 September Prime Minister Clement Attlee informed Foreign Secretary Ernest Bevin, then in New York, that he favoured a declaration from the United Nations that it would take responsibility for the rehabilitation of the whole country. 
 Bevin agreed with Attlee about the need to forestall the Russians, and took the initiative in drafting a resolution for the General Assembly authorizing the crossing of the 38th parallel with a view to establishing a unified, independent, and democratic government of all Korea. 
 Bevin was much concerned that the revolution of allied public feeling after Truman's confused press statement of 30 November 1950 about the possible use of nuclear weapons in Korea had compelled the President to retract it and &bquo;thus weakened the deterrent effect of our possession of the atomic weapon&equo;. 
 In the official history Anthony Farrar-Hockley argues that &bquo;Mr Attlee and Mr Bevin were the policy makers&equo;. 
 He suggests that the two leaders were &bquo;commonly influenced by historical factors in their responses to events in Korea during that summer and autumn of 1950&equo;. 
 They saw a frustrated Stalin, foiled in his attempts to extend Russian power into northern, western, and southern Europe by the alliance of the European democracies and the United States. 
 Farrar-Hockley attributes the British intervention to an anti-appeasement mindset, worries about American isolationism, and concern for &bquo;adherence to the charter of the United Nations to prevent its decline into the impotence of the League of Nations&equo; (p. 203). 
 In discussing the question of the possible use of the atomic bomb, Farrar-Hockley concludes that it is unlikely that the bombs could have been used in Korea without prior consultation, as &bquo;honour and American political interest would have combined to militate against such a course&equo; (p. 386). 
 This official history is lavishly produced, profusely illustrated with maps and well-chosen photographs, and quotes extensively from a selection of the British documents &mdash; indeed, seems to reproduce some of them in full in the text &mdash; as well as vividly recounting the actual fighting. 
 It constitutes an important work of reference. 
 A further dimension of British policy in the Korean War is examined by Jeffrey Grey of the Historical Research Section of the Department of Foreign Affairs, Canberra: the influence of the Commonwealth. 
 He restricts himself to an account of the ground forces, so there is no coverage of the role played by the South African air force, for instance, and perhaps the distinction drawn by Britain at the outset of the  war between the old Dominions and the members of the new Commonwealth which it regarded as a security risk could have been more strongly emphasized. 
 But in the end Grey does venture the overall generalization that &bquo;the experience in the Korean War demonstrated again the conflict between Dominion aspirations and increasing independence in policy formulation, and the British desire to maintain their status as a great power by drawing on the resources of the Dominions in &bquo;friendly cooperation,&equo; while at the same time arrogating to themselves the benefits which accrued from such association' (p. 185). 
 University College of Wales, Aberystwyth  RITCHIE OVENDALE 
 BOOK TWO 
 text omitted 
 Two 
 His eagerness made her, suddenly, want to be intelligent again. 
 Under his dynamic tutelage she started reading &mdash; not the literature of her childhood, but hard politics, sociology, philosophy, ideas, and experimental fiction. 
 To please him she learned to talk about what she read and what she thought. 
 He was, and she forced herself to remember this with gratitude, one of the best talkers she had ever met; funny and fast. 
 Passionate, and unashamed. 
 A man who could and would talk the hind legs back on to an injured donkey, provided it had decent proletarian credentials. 
 They had all learned from him; she and Lisa still spoke, stylistically, as he had taught them to. 
 He had set his mark on them. 
 Where was he now? 
 Phoebe lying on her bed in her mother's house in north London, asked herself with a sudden rush of nostalgia. 
 In what corner of what foreign field did he still keep the faith, further the revolution, wake up his current lover at three in the morning to discuss the delicate interweavings of class and race. 
 She could not bear to think that he had taken all that pure wrathful zeal into marketing or insurance broking. 
 Occasionally she half hoped to see him again, she would find herself watching faces rising towards her on the escalator of the Tube and wonder what she would feel if one of those faces were suddenly to be his. 
 Where had they all gone, those extraordinary skinny left-wing men, who had bullied their girl-friends into the Women's Movement and been surprised when the hand with which they had so kindly offered freedom had been bitten so damn hard? 
 Nearly twenty years later Phoebe still found it hard to suppress a little vindictive chuckle at the looks of growing shock on Jim's face -Jim and Lisa's Jonathan and Sue's Alan &mdash; when they discovered that their righteousness was not enough. 
 Their women, far from being grateful, turned on them, snarling, in late night conversations telling them to shut up; far from setting them free to work for the Revolution, their women demanded that they take emotional responsibility and also clean the loos. 
 And finally, only a year or so later, turned them out of house and home &mdash; put them on the street, as women who failed to be properly grateful to the fathers had been put for centuries. 
 But even as she chuckled, Phoebe knew now that this was not fair. 
 There had been a time, a brief time, a glorious dawn, when despite her growing awareness of her own sexual failure, despite her anger and frustration, despite her own laziness and lack of commitment, there had been a time when she had been happy and hopeful and joyous. 
 It had not, as it turned out, been Jim that had made the happiness for her, but the house itself. 
 However he, with his determined hands and determined nose, had been her way in. 
 She did not know where he was now and she did not really care, but he had probably been the most influential person in her life: her handsome prince and Maggie's father. 
 He had given her that household, a little society, warming itself in its own glow of virtue, insulating itself from the big bad world; but within its own limits it had been open and supportive. 
 She had, during that year, woken some mornings giddy with courage and boldness, excited and certain. 
 Motivated. 
 It had been, however briefly, a time when her body and her mind had fitted together so tidily and wholely that, waking up one morning and deciding that it was time to go back to Oxford and visit her mother, was neither traumatic nor casual, but straightforward. 
 She had discussed it with her family; hugged Lisa and Sue, kissed Jim, left home, and taken the tube to Acton where she stuck out her thumb on the edge of the A40 on a smiling spring day and gone home. 
 Had that, she wondered now, been a mistake? 
 A kindly lorry driver on his way to North Wales, chatting of his own daughter and his home, had dropped her at the roundabout at the top of the Banbury Road at about lunch-time. 
 She had walked down through suburban Summertown, taking her time but without reluctance; watching the tidiness of the shoppers and the smartness of the shops with something akin to smugness - how little energy and vitality they had, compared to her own shopping street, with its untidy market atmosphere permeating even the Safeways and Boots which had tried to raise their modern, never-had-it-so-good fa&ccedil;ades in challenge to the poverty and squalor, and had failed. 
 Two blocks away from the house of her childhood it suddenly occurred to her that her mother might have left, that there might be strangers in the hallway, a different set of curtains hanging at the windows; her father's study might have been turned into a playroom for a new generation of North Oxford children, so different from herself in her prim Clark's T-bar sandals that she would not be able to recognise her own infancy in theirs. 
 It would be too humiliating to have to contact her mother through her publishers or her employers. 
 How could one ring a bell on a house door in respectable places like this and say, 
 &bquo;Excuse me does my mother live here?&equo; 
 That was the stuff of melodrama, and now she was back in Oxford she knew she was somewhere, somehow, still too middle-class, too much her father's daughter, to want that. 
 This was leafy north Oxford, this was the pace of security. 
 This was the corner to which she had tottered, her mother holding her on white leather reins, her legs encased in knitted leggings whose scratchiness she could still remember. 
 This was the street along which she had run, a skinny and excited ten-year-old, to boast to her father that she was the only girl who had made it to the next round of the chess competition. 
 This was the pavement along which, awkward and gawky, she had struggled to find a graceful, even a comfortable, way of carrying her cello to and from her chamber music group. 
 She hesitated at the corner, reluctant almost to discover that she was now, as of this moment, completely lost in the world, and for the first time she asked herself clearly why she had decided to come here. 
 This was not home. 
 Home was in Peckham, in the shabby house whose light spilled each evening out onto the street. 
 Family was Jim and the others; family was her women's group and squabbling at two-thirty in the morning about whether women could be said to constitute a separate class because they had a separate relation to the mode of production, while still making each other coffee and giving each other hugs. 
 And love was standing outside the local supermarket collecting signatures for the campaign to keep Family Allowance as a separate benefit. 
 She had forsaken her people and her father's house, and had, like every other well-brought-up girl, established her own household and she should cleave only unto it, forsaking all others so long as she should live. 
 She did not know why she had come. 
 Not certainly to reassure her mother, but&hellip; to boast of her new self! 
 To show off? 
 And then the moment had passed, and tall and tanned and fit in the sunshine she had walked down the green street with the gardens either side of her, and had known by an instinctive glance that her mother still lived there, that nothing had changed. 
 She rang the doorbell, listened to the silence within and felt a moment of panic. 
 Then she laughed at herself, with an edge of self-mocking irony. 
 All her self-righteousness had failed to inform her that her mother, a hardy professional, was certainly still at work in the city that she had left behind her. 
 They had probably passed each other on the road. 
 She went back to the corner and across to the nearby pub, where she sat sipping beer, munching a cheese sandwich, and waiting. 
 She had waited all afternoon &mdash; later sitting in the garden and reading. 
 When the sun moved round she too had moved to the doorstep, her sleeves rolled up and concentrating half on the book and half on the remembered scene until her mother had arrived, walking up the street where they had both walked so many times before. 
 That had been the moment of her undoing. 
 Her mother had got older, fatter and sadder. 
 Phoebe felt an enormous, and unwelcome, surge of pity, of compassion and caring; and with it guilt. 
 In one swoop the feeling swallowed her up and she had never got rid of it since. 
 She saw in Rachel's face three years of loss and loneliness; she saw too the simpler anger that Rachel would never dare to express. 
 And to cover up the dreadfulness of the moment, the pain of the knowledge that Rachel had become old, alone, and friendless, she had giggled and said something about having lost her key. 
 She felt the deep need in Rachel's hug, and responded to it, but it was Rachel's need not her own. 
 She was furious. 
 Her fury made her aggressive and she attacked. 
 She was mean and horrible to her mother, snide, self-righteous and unkind. 
 Only in her anger could she drown out the dark shadow that pity and guilt had cast over her. 
 She hated herself for it, and went on and on, convinced that her only defence was to make Rachel throw her out again, and Rachel refused to be provoked. 
 Finally Rachel responded and Phoebe had forgotten in her wanderings just how bloody clever Rachel was. 
 How well she could keep control and use words and manipulate their meanings and score points. 
 It was this ruthless clarity and brightness that she had run away from. 
 She, Phoebe told herself, did not play those stupid games any more, she was direct and straightforward. 
 But her mouth motored on and what came out was simply, and childishly, rude. 
 Phoebe felt foolish. 
 Rachel seemed able to absorb everything that Phoebe tried. 
 She was calm and sweet and later insisted on taking Phoebe out to dinner at some fancy little pseudo-Bohemian bistro. 
 Then to her final and total humiliation Phoebe found that she was actually having a good time; she was enjoying her mother and her mother's easy authority and charm. 
 Her  mother, she thought with a most annoying pride, who was one of the few genuinely creative women scientists around and in whose success, were it anyone except her mother's, she would be rejoicing. 
 She went to bed in her own room, still full of pictures and possessions that had belonged to a previous and vanished Phoebe. 
 She curled up in the position she had slept in as a child; and realised with a sinking heart that it was not only the most comfortable way of being in bed, but it was also one that you could not adopt in company. 
 She thought that she never wanted to sleep with Jim again, that the bonds of love were snares and that she must at all costs leave as early as possible the next morning and never come back. 
 She had a clear and frightening premonition that she would not be able to manage it. 
 Perhaps if she had not got pregnant&hellip; perhaps they could have pulled it off. 
 Perhaps not. 
 Now she no longer knew. 
 She found it hard to remember with any precision exactly what had happened next. 
 She remembered a little of the acrimony, of the mounting bitterness within the house, of their winter of discontent, which was so much part of and not part of the winter outside, and the miners' strike. 
 But the light no longer poured out of their house and onto the street; the power cuts, although they supported them passionately, cut off their power somewhere. 
 Jim and Jonathan especially were never there, and the arguments about washing up versus serving the revolution lost their gaiety and became mean-mouthed. 
 Alan and Sue moved out, went north to do something else. 
 Phoebe had not seen Alan since, though Sue had moved back again briefly later that winter, saddened and distressed by Alan's disaffection. 
 She had been part of a long stream of women who had come and gone swiftly, lives collapsing in one area as they gained power and certainty in another. 
 Suddenly there were too many women realising that their happiness had to be taken at the expense of their men's &mdash; men who had promised so much and could not now deliver the goods; just like her father five years before. 
 Lisa and Phoebe shared the painful knowledge that they had been conning themselves as well as their men. 
 How had a Conservative Government happened? 
 Where were the golden days which Paris and Chicago and Grosvenor Square had promised them? 
 In the meantime, the miners represented hope for all of them, but within the giddy cycle of excitements they were all edgy with new fears and old illusions. 
 After Sue and Alan left, Lisa and Phoebe had invited their neighbour Jo and her lover Sophie to come and share the house with them. 
 Jim and Jonathan had been away, picketing and pamphleteering in Reading, had simply been not available, and Jo's squat had been suddenly repossessed and it did not occur to any of the women that the boys would mind. 
 Sophie moreover actually had a job, had an income, which was beginning to be something of a pressing issue, inflation and the changing climate began to bite into their indifferent superiority to the outside world and they had given no thought as to how to fight that. 
 Then the boys, as it turned out, minded bitterly having Jo and Sophie. 
 Since, on principle, they could not say that lesbianism made them nervous and that the complex new demands made on them scared them, they found more underhand and aggressive ways of expressing their resentments. 
 The women outnumbered them and plotted together. 
 Having the other two women in the house taught Lisa something new about herself; she and Jonathan stopped sleeping together, which left them all short of space. 
 Phoebe felt betrayed by Lisa's desertion. 
 She and Jim talked together secretly about leaving the house and going off to somewhere &bquo;more committed&equo;, but Phoebe could not bring herself to give up the only home she knew of, could not bring herself to choose absolutely Jim's commitments over the women's commitments. 
 Jim did not seem to be there enough for them to talk it through and neither of them had any money. 
 The women were there, there talking, struggling, excited, engaged and angry. 
 Jim got fed-up coming home, weary and sensing that things were going increasingly wrong, to find the women talking late into the night, ignoring him, even asking him to go away, to go to his own room, to mind his own business. 
 They fought. 
 Jim was better at that than Phoebe was, and inside herself she sulked. 
 He was actually far more articulate, better informed. 
 She had no clarity to toss in his face as he tossed &bquo;bourgeois deviation&equo; and Engels in hers. 
 At first, after their early fights, Phoebe would work on making peace, leave the women to be with him, offer herself in ever more elaborate rituals, but after a while repetition made this boring. 
 Phoebe ceased even to bother to calm him down, to open herself to him. 
 After months of weeping and shouting and apologising, she did not care enough. 
 Sometimes they fought and sometimes they fucked and there seemed little difference between the two. 
 The house was escalatingly filthy and anarchic. 
 It was not fun any more. 
 The miners were defeated and so were they. 
 And somehow in that cold and confused spring, somewhere in some loveless and last sexual act, Phoebe got pregnant. 
 By the time she realised what had happened, Jim had departed. 
 Packed his bags and gone. 
 It had in the end been a spectacular departure; Phoebe's final fling with overpowering emotion. 
 He had told her that he had started sleeping with someone else, a &bquo;real woman&equo;, he had said rashly. 
 And although, now, twenty years later, she could understand his hurt and confusion and desire for revenge, then it had hit her squarely in all the areas she was most vulnerable. 
 She had quite literally thrown herself at him, she had bitten him in the neck so hard that he had bled, she had scratched his face and torn his clothes. 
 A new ferocious Phoebe, a Phoebe for one brief glorious moment allied to all those mad bad women, Jael and Charlotte Cordet and Boadicea; to Lilith and the Greek Furies and the terrifying armies of the Amazons. 
 But he would not fight back. 
 &bquo;For heaven's sake, Bea,&equo; he said, &bquo;grow up.&equo; 
 She knew that if he wanted to he could have killed her; without apparent effort he held off her attack once the first shock had past. 
 His reasoned calm defeated her. 
 She looked only stupid. 
 A stupid child in a tantrum. 
 A child whose father had never allowed the tantrums, who had held rational behaviour out as the price of his love. 
 There was no space anywhere, even here, even in this free world, she thought, which they had so boldly created, for wildness. 
 All that got you was humiliation. 
 Jim had stomped downstairs wiping the blood off his face with a handkerchief and later it had been Jo and Lisa who had packed his bags and told him never to come back to the house. 
 When she realised that she was pregnant, her one clear emotion was that he should not know. 
 She would never allow him a reason to pity her again, to hold her in contempt. 
 It was one of the more simple reasons why she denied the pregnancy, even to herself, for so long. 
 Now her memory refused the whole thing; simply refused to countenance the next few months. 
 Phoebe could remember no details, could recall only with an effort that was profitless, the numbing passivity that had fallen on her. 
 She had never convinced herself of the reality of her pregnancy, she had never done anything about it. 
 She kept the pregnancy to herself &mdash; or rather kept it from herself, and from everyone else, for too long. 
 Now, quite suddenly, Phoebe was wide awake again. 
 She sat bolt upright in her bed and said aloud, 
 &bquo;Damn,&equo; and then, &bquo;damn, damn, damn.&equo; 
 She was meant to be thinking about happy things. 
 She was meant to be persuading herself that life was worth living. 
 Why was she so damn slow? 
 Why had she not made connections between the secrecy, the silent, passively gloomy, growing of Maggie inside herself and this new, equally secret, growth? 
 Why had she not made the connection and what, in any case, was the connection? 
 She lay down on her back again, almost smelling the sharp odour of the whisky; just awake enough to resist it, just sleepy enough not to make the climb out into the cold worth it, and felt numb with fear. 
 Lying there she was aware for the first time that night of Maggie above her and Rachel below her; both, she imagined, sleeping sweetly, and again the grinding weight of compassion and guilt swept over her. 
 She cannot mother her child and she cannot mother her mother; everything she did inclined towards death. 
 What would happen to these two women who had done nothing to deserve her evil body and heart between them, what would happen to them when she was dead? 
 Had she simply had Maggie so that someone, somewhere, would have to love her and take care of her? 
 At one level, of course, it had worked, because throughout her pregnancy Rachel had been carefully and systematically nice to her. 
 Rachel would appear, warm and generous, with smiles and a determination to be friendly and tolerant. 
 Rachel had been, apparently, more relieved that Phoebe should be an unmarried mother than that she should have to have Jim as a sson-in-law. 
 Lisa, who had first noticed this oddity in Rachel, had found it hilarious, had even teased Rachel about it directly. 
 But Phoebe had felt a harsh jealousy that she did not like in herself when she realised how well Lisa and Rachel got on: she did not want that. 
 She wanted somehow to have her mother for herself, but only so that she could reject her herself. 
 She did not want Lisa to have any part of Rachel, and she did not want Rachel to have any part of Phoebe. 
 Almost in tears, Phoebe took her breast in her hand and squeezed and banged at it until it hurt. 
 In the pain there was both forgetfulness and satisfaction, just as there had been when Maggie was born. 
 Her labour, at least, stood out sharp and clear. 
 The pregnancy itself was lost in a fog. 
 There had been the long drift through cold spring into hot summer; the long sinking into the mercies and bossiness of her friends and thence into the arms of the medical profession; the final humiliation of accepting, because she was too inert to refuse, money from Rachel. 
 She remembered indistinctly the sense of her body being gradually taken over and pumped full of something that was not Phoebe. 
 She had experienced mounting terror at the thought of a new role in which she would certainly prove a failure &mdash; a woman who could not do her work, could not save her father, could not love her mother, could not satisfy her man, was most unlikely to make any sort of mother. 
 Then rising like dawn from the mist, the pain was utterly and entirely real. 
 So, with it, was the focused love of her friends. 
 They had not approved of the baby; they had thought Phoebe negligent at best for getting pregnant and not taking appropriate action; they had chivvied her through the later months of her pregnancy with a mixture of indulgence and irritation, cross both that she was pregnant and that she wasn't taking it seriously. 
 Lisa and Jo had taken her to clinics, booked her in with midwives, read up on birth technology, warned her about smoking; and all with an air of adult exasperation towards a wayward child. 
 But when the pain came they were there. 
 A little scared, since they were then all very young and had believed the stuff about painless childbirth, and a little over-excited by their own courage and naughtiness, but completely present for her &mdash; not as grown-ups to a child, but as women. 
 It was in the pain that she found their love and tested it and found it so true that the bond would never break. 
 A night, a nightmare of pain. 
 A night, a nightdream of love. 
 Inseparable. 
 A period of almost literally climbing the walls, turning away from the world and kneeling up, holding the end of the iron hospital bed, and Lisa's hand firmly on the pain, firmly on the small of her back pressing, pressing, pressing away the pain and the fear, keeping her in contact. 
 A long plateau in which the never-ending surrealism of pain muted down into boredom and there was Jo laughing bravely, veiling her fear and doing great lines from Gone with the Wind  in a deplorably bad imitation of a southern black accent. 
 Staying was the point; they stayed there with her and that enabled her to stay there with them. 
 And even then her flesh would not give up its alien growth without a struggle. 
 She went down too far, too far into the riding waves of pain, deep under water and drowning. 
 The midwife muttered her spells, and from far away Phoebe could hear voices calling her, siren voices that called her back to the pain and the reality. 
 Not angry but loving calls, which the midwife tried to hush because she had never encountered young women who could yell abuse so lovingly;, 
 &bquo;Bea, you goddam asshole, just try. 
 Lazy bitch.&equo; 
 Phoebe, knowing the strength and command of Lisa, was comforted and, in some other place, almost amused to hear the midwife shocked, ordering Lisa to be more gentle. 
 There was no gentleness like Lisa's fierce love; and she tried to respond to that while another darker voice called her to unconsciousness and silence. 
 In the end she saw the giant fish-hooks come down down into her and she thought they would haul her out of the depths, but they did not. 
 They had not come to rescue her, but the child whom Phoebe would not let be born. 
 Forceps hurt. 
 Then suddenly everyone was no longer concerned for her as she lay there, but for another woman; a tiny fierce woman whose fault it had all not been and Lisa's gigantic, striding power melted into softness, soppy for the baby. 
 &bquo;Ah, Bea, look &mdash; just look.&equo; 
 But she had turned her face to the wall. 
 Guilt and exhaustion is what she had felt for the next year. 
 Everyone adored Maggie. 
 She had seen that instantly the next afternoon; in Rachel's eyes she recognised the same melting joy as she had seen in Lisa's. 
 And she loved Maggie, too: how could one not? 
 How could one fail to love a small person so infinitely resolute to follow her own path? 
 How could one not admire a woman so clear as to her needs that she did not care whose flesh she carved her way through, who did not care whose sleep she shattered in the small hours of the dawn? 
 How could one refuse tenderness to someone so frail and tiny, to someone whose bones one could break with the flick of wrist, to someone who greeted one with smiles and later whoops of purest delight, who wept if one left them, and would die if one neglected them? 
 But she, who had run fifteen thousand miles to find her freedom, she who had driven Jim out of the house rather than wash his dirty teacups, was now a slave to someone who never washed their cups, who was never interested in her ideas, who never wanted to talk, hear, understand, sympathise, who hurt one's body as no one had ever hurt it before and who chained one forever to mountains, not just of washing-up, but of washing itself. 
 The launderette was two and a half blocks from the house; probably less than three hundred yards. 
 Six nappies, even wet ones, did not weigh that much, and there were others who were willing to help. 
 In the launderette it was warm and cosy; here Maggie made friends and fans and she had inconsequential conversations which mysteriously made her a member of the local community in a way she had never been when she had been fighting for the area's well-being. 
 None the less, throughout the autumn and the cold winter that followed, those three hundred yards became three hundred years each and every time, the sign of her defeat, the sign of her capture &mdash; she felt herself a wild animal tamed and she devoted herself to Maggie with what appeared to be maternal passion mainly because she felt guilty at her lack of joy in it. 
 Maggie, it quickly emerged, induced a turning of mood in the rest of them. 
 Rachel was kinder and gentler towards her than she had ever been before; but she also required Phoebe to take responsibility for the baby, to be a good mother, to take heed for the morrow. 
 Phoebe could accept that, it was how grandmothers were meant to be, but when she turned to her friends, looking for guidance and inspiration, she did not find it. 
 When it came to childraising, although they were libertarian towards the baby, they seemed conservative towards Phoebe's needs: demand feeding and endless devotion seemed to be required of her. 
 &bquo;You're behaving like a goddam husband,&equo; she said sulkily one night. 
 Lisa looked startled, but was stern. 
 &bquo;I'm beginning to feel like one,&equo; she said. 
 Lisa had got a proper job at last, as though tired of waiting for the Revolution. 
 &bquo;Look, Bea, I feel like a shit as a matter of fact, but I can't live like this -. 
 This little ghetto, where feelings are the most important thing in the world. 
 I want to get out there. 
 I want a decent job, I want to do something useful, and something interesting. 
 I'm not and I never have been a hippy, I can't just &bquo;hang out&equo; any more. 
 That bit is over now.&equo; 
 Phoebe felt accused, felt useless. 
 She also felt worn out, oppressed by the cold scruffiness of the house, and the energy of her friends. 
 She tried making friends with other women who had children, exploring ways of shared childcare; but faith was not enough, they were bogged down by impossible travel arrangements, endless irresponsibility and hopeless public transport. 
 She had no money. 
 Rachel proposed an alternative. 
 Rachel wanted to move to London, and thought that perhaps they could share a house. 
 &bquo;Not share it, Phoebe, split it. 
 You'd be independent and I could babysit for Maggie. 
 You could get out more, it would be good for you, darling.&equo; 
 Phoebe said to Lisa, &bquo;if I go and live with her it will be the end. 
 I'm a sucker for middle-class comforts. 
 I'm not tough enough to toe the line.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh Bea,&equo; said Lisa affectionately, &bquo;Don't be such a puritan.&equo; 
 Lisa adored Rachel, which frequently made Phoebe cross. 
 Lisa however was full of her own schemes. 
 She had gone to work first for a radical magazine, perched in a cramped office behind Kings Cross. 
 When she had acquired a range of basic editing skills she started looking round for what to do with them. 
 Soon she aligned herself with a small group of women who wanted to break into publishing. 
 &bquo;We need to control it Bea; why should those fat cats get rich off our books?&equo; 
 &bquo;What books? 
 Shiny hardbacks for middle-class feminists. 
 Masses of American theory and no socialism.&equo; 
 &bquo;We could do better, then. 
 What books do we need?&equo; 
 Phoebe was seduced suddenly. 
 &bquo;Well, some decent history for one thing, I suppose. 
 And some fiction; women must be writing better books than they seem to be publishing.&equo; 
 &bquo;There you are, you see. 
 You, the Women's Movement, on the street and in the home, need me!&equo; 
 They forgot briefly that they were having a fight; instead they had a happy half-hour of fantasy about what books they could write and read and live with. 
 Phoebe said finally, &bquo;OK, OK. 
 But we'll all be so busy reading all this wonderful stuff, and learning from the big bad world about how to market it, that we won't have time to do anything else.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; said Lisa, &bquo;I never thought that the Women's Liberation Movement would be spread by word, rather than action, but that is how it is.&equo; 
 &bquo;Only if we let it be.&equo; 
 &bquo;No there are skills; we need those skills.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll have to wear a skirt to the office.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be silly.&equo; 
 Lisa had a good degree from some northern university and had little trouble finding herself a job in a proper publishing house &mdash; 'Biding my time,&equo; she said laughing. 
 &bquo;You wait.&equo; 
 What Phoebe had realised quickly was that Lisa liked working. 
 Lisa had a passion for working. 
 And at first it was nice because there was more money coming into the house, and they could feed the gas monster and have hot water and fires. 
 But Lisa had less time for her, and was meeting new people, refining a way of living that even a year ago she would have claimed to despise. 
 Phoebe could not, try as she might, despise it for her, because it was so obviously making Lisa happy; while she, clinging to a nostalgic and increasingly sentimental vision of the household, was patently not happy, not useful, and not passionate. 
 She felt envious, but unable to change. 
 She could not find in herself any source of passion. 
 Jo and Sophie were working too. 
 Phoebe began to feel like a housewife. 
 There she was, ably supported by active and intelligent people while she sat at home feeling cold and tired and guilty. 
 That winter Maggie did not nourish. 
 She seemed little and mingy, pale and tight. 
 She coughed, and when her nose was plugged up it was difficult for her to suck properly; she cried to be fed all through the night and Phoebe got more and more tired, more and more passive and despairing and guilty.  
 In the spring, almost without knowing how it happened, she accepted Rachel's invitation to go and live with her in the new house she was buying in London. 
 The day she moved in she knew she had been defeated, that love, love for her mother and for her daughter, had defeated her. 
 The passion she had tried to feel for feminism was not enough, it did not give her enough strength to stand up for herself against the demands of these two women who wanted her, needed her and demanded her. 
 Even Lisa thought the move was a good idea. 
 Phoebe was now wide awake again and irritated with herself. 
 She did not feel she was doing very well in her attempt to persuade herself that her life was full of joys and worth living. 
 Without turning on the light she sat up and reached for her bottle and glass, faintly alarmed to discover she could find them both by feel alone. 
 Her friends did not think of her as a drunk and Rachel would be truly shocked if she knew about the long nights of insomnia and secret alcohol. 
 She was shocked herself, but that shock was muted by the greater shock of realising that even now she was not certain that she would keep the appointment she had made for the morning. 
 Shocked and ashamed. 
 Of course, the fourteen years since she had moved into the Bayswater house had not been years of unremitting misery and depression. 
 Soon after they had moved in Maggie and she, too, had begun to thrive. 
 Rachel was undeniably wonderful with the baby; and took such joy from having Maggie with her that it was impossible for even Phoebe to feel much guilt about the times when she was free. 
 As Maggie became more settled, and ate and slept better, Phoebe's own health and energy returned, and with it a determination to get some sort of job and pay for her own keep. 
 Oddly she never felt the least guilt in accepting money from Rachel to help her bring up Maggie. 
 She had scrambled through the middle years of the decade. 
 At first she had scraped a more or less adequate living as a free-lance journalist. 
 She did not require a lot of money, would indeed have despised it. 
 She was only half aware that Rachel was heavily subsidising her rent, because she was living in a part of London and a sort of house so different from her friends that she had no easy comparisons. 
 Feminism was, briefly, news, and women feature writers were welcome. 
 Phoebe was good at looking into things, she discovered; never brilliant, but perfectly competent. 
 Then for a couple of years she helped set up a women's bookshop and caf&eacute; run on high but unmanageable collective principles. 
 Initially it seemed quite exciting to her, but she quickly realised that she was unable to care with the intensity felt by the other members of the group. 
 She did not believe that it was going to change the world or that every minute detail was worth the drama and emotionalism that the others seemed to want to pour into it. 
 Maggie became an excuse to leave the endless collective meetings early. 
 Afterwards she knew that she had tried, but had not triad very hard. 
 She had not tried hard enough because she did not care enough. 
 She resigned finally from the co-operative over a minor political skirmish about which rooms in the shop would be open to men. 
 She felt a superficial moral righteousness and a profound fear about her own boredom. 
 Both her mother and Lisa had been cross with her; they both had felt she ought to settle down. 
 She felt infantilised by them, but also felt bitterly that they were not fair, and she was bored and frightened at the thought of remaining bored all her life. 
 She went vaguely back to occasional journalism and found it increasingly difficult to sleep in the evenings and get up in the mornings. 
 One evening Rachel invited her to dinner, to meet some old family friends who had recently retired from academia and moved to London. 
 Rachel and Phoebe did not often invite each other to formal meals, although they often ate together with Maggie. 
 Rachel's friends had, as usual, been charming. 
 They remembered Phoebe from Oxford days, and she could not fail to notice their thinly veiled compassion for Rachel that her brilliant daughter should have turned out so odd, so unsatisfactory. 
 Somehow, somewhere, she got the impression that they were congratulating themselves on Martin and Rachel's failure; on their very irresponsible approach to Phoebe's education. 
 They were obviously delighted to be able to use Phoebe to prove their conviction that child stars burn out if they are not raised to be as dull as anyone else's children. 
 Had they been jealous, thirty years ago in Oxford, of the young Phoebe's special status? 
 Phoebe now wondered, with an inner smile, remembering the evening when, aged about twelve, the master of her father's college had rearranged the high table to make her his senior guest. 
 Certainly they now boasted insistently of the marital bliss of their daughter and the solid Civil Service progress of their son. 
 She felt more at her ease realising that long ago had they had probably minded bitterly that the Petheringtons' little daughter had been so much more extraordinary than their own. 
 She felt furious on her father's behalf and oddly compassionate on her mother's. 
 In inviting her Rachel had proclaimed the absolute acceptability to her of her daughter even though she knew that Rachel did not feel this. 
 Because feeling grateful towards Rachel made her uncomfortable, she turned her attention to the other guests, a couple of solid neighbours whose grandchildren played in Kensington Gardens with Maggie during the holiday visits. 
 The mixture of gratitude and discomfort made Phoebe unusually charming and civil. 
 The husband, a gentle and kindly man, had recently had a minor stroke. 
 His doctor had told him to ease up. 
 He confided to Phoebe that what made him sad was his garden. 
 &bquo;Planned it for years to give me pleasure in my retirement and now it's just getting into a mess. 
 Amy won't do it and I can't find anyone even to come in and keep it tidy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can't, Graham, not won't,&equo; said his wife. 
 &bquo;I know, dear,&equo; said Graham and they exchanged a pair of smiles so sweet and affectionate that Phoebe, despite herself, suddenly liked them. 
 But the Oxford guest said, &bquo;You'd think with all this unemployment&hellip; there seem to be an extraordinary number of people around who don't want to work.&equo; 
 He gave Phoebe a sly look. 
 She really only said it to annoy these old friends of her mother's. 
 She said, &bquo;I'm free-lance; any job is a job. 
 I'm reasonably fit. 
 If you'll teach me I'll come and work for you a few hours a week.&equo; 
 Amy smiled and said, &bquo;It's hardly the job for a socialist-feminist revolutionary, Phoebe. 
 Tidying up rich people's gardens.&equo; 
 At any other time Phoebe would have thought she was being mocked and taken offence. 
 Now, dazzled, she realised that Amy was in fact praising Phoebe's commitments, on her side rather than on the side of the pompous arrogant ex-professor. 
 She grinned back. 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 We could call it community work, couldn't we.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, indeed. 
 Or rehabilitation for old age pensioners.&equo; 
 Graham joined in, &bquo;I'll find out what the union rates are tomorrow. 
 TGWU?&equo; 
 Even Rachel was willing to share the subterranean joke. 
 She broke off her conversation and said, 
 &bquo;Better make it NUPE, Phoebe, much more radical.&equo; 
 &bquo;But worse paid.&equo; 
 &bquo;Anyway,&equo; said Graham, &bquo;I do draw the line at being described as &bquo;public&equo;. 
 Perhaps I shall ask the farm workers' union. 
 They're bound to have the lowest rates.&equo; 
 &bquo;And no London weighting,&equo; added Amy. 
 &bquo;True,&equo; said Phoebe, &bquo;but I'd probably get to be a Union Official immediately, owing to the lack of competition in the Bayswater Chapel, and then Graham would have to give me endless paid hours off to attend to Union Business.&equo; 
 Rachel said courteously to her other guests, &bquo;Any suggestions then? 
 What do the rest of us pay our servants these days? 
 Twelve pounds a year and a free uniform?&equo; 
 The professor's wife said something about how difficult and expensive it was to get a good cleaning woman, and the professor responded uneasily, insensitively, aware that he was not getting the respect he was used to in his Senior Common Room. 
 He started blustering about the general election and an end to the inflationary spiral. 
 But when Graham left later, with something of the earlier benignity still binding him and Phoebe together, he had asked, 
 &bquo;Were you serious?&equo; 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 &bquo;I can't tell you how grateful I'd be.&equo; 
 &bquo;No need. 
 Shall I come about eleven next Wednesday?&equo; 
 So by a collusive accident Phoebe had become a gardener. 
 Not all at once of course. 
 At first she had just worked a couple of hours a week for Graham. 
 What had surprised her was how much she enjoyed it. 
 Graham was not just a kind elderly man, he was a passionate and knowledgeable gardener. 
 He wanted her to do more than dig and weed. 
 He wanted her to be interested. 
 Soon she realised that he was singing her praises to his friends, because other similar garden owners rang her up and asked her if she could do a few hours for them too. 
 In her bedroom now, sipping her whisky, she acknowledged for the first time in her life that if she had to make a list of the happy times, it would properly have to include the hours she had spent with Graham in his garden. 
 When he died six years later he left her all his gardening books: not just the technical instruction manuals, but coffee-table picture books, historical studies and a collection of exquisite, hand-tinted Victorian flower drawings, and a Beatrix Potter original which, she now knew, would keep Maggie in shoes for the rest of her childhood if Phoebe could have brought herself to sell it. 
 It was the first personal bequest she had ever received, and the first time in years that she had cried. 
 About six months after the dinner party she realised that, for the first time in her life, she had turned down a decent journalistic commission in order to start work for a crazy old lady off Ladbroke Grove, whose garden specialised in old roses, and who was insistent about sterilising soil before new plantings. 
 A few months after that she had said to Rachel, 
 &bquo;Mummy, I'm thinking of going back to college.&equo; 
 She shut her heart firmly against the look of incredulous joy that lit Rachel's face. 
 &bquo;Really, Phoebe? 
 Where are you going?&equo; 
 &bquo;Capel Hill, I should think.&equo; 
 &bquo;Capel Hill?&equo; 
 And, then after a pause, in which she saw Rachel's joy cancelled out by fear, &bquo;Is that in America?&equo; 
 She had almost laughed. 
 That was a plot against Rachel she had never thought of, to take up maths again but to do it in the USA. 
 That would show the old bag. 
 It was too late now though. 
 &bquo;No, it's in Enfield. 
 I want to be a gardener. 
 You do City and Guilds and those things there, and then the Council will employ you. 
 GLC or DoE, or the Royal Parks people.&equo; 
 Rachel had been nonplussed. 
 Even now a ten-year-older Phoebe could not suppress her amusement. 
 Rachel had wanted her to settle down to something, Rachel had wanted her to get some proper qualifications and chose a career. 
 She had done so; Rachel had not known how to handle it then, and still did not know ten years later. 
 The memory of her own amusement encouraged Phoebe suddenly. 
 There, she had been happy in Pakistan; she had been happy in the Peckham house at least for the first year; she had been happy working for Graham; she'd been enthusiastically interested at college and during the first two years after she had qualified; she had been completely delighted when she had got the job she now had: a tenants' association garden in a dreadful estate in Hackney, but where she, with a community group, had planned the garden from scratch and had made a small desert blossom like a rose. 
 All right then, she thought, her courage high, she had also been extremely happy while she was having her affair with Tom. 
 It had simply been fun, the sort of fun she had with her women friends, except that she had also desired him, and he her. 
 It had been splendidly undemanding; because of his family, she did not see him more than a few times a month, always meetings snatched at short notice and with absolutely no expectation from him that she would be available. 
 Apart from the holiday in Italy, they had not spent a whole night together more than half a dozen times in two years, and never at her home; always when they could find excuses for them both to be in other cities. 
 Before she knew him she had never stayed in real hotels with private bathrooms taken for granted, and coloured TVs and room service for all guests. 
 She had met him at one of those dinner parties which had now become the nexus of her social life, replacing conferences and meetings, although few of the individuals had changed. 
 One of those dinner parties which she loved and mocked almost equally, where people envy each other their success while feeling faintly guilty about their own. 
 Friendship networks so old and intimate that the differences and difficulties could collapse into wild mirth at any instant, or could flare into fights which, however vicious at the time, would not actually change anything nor prevent her and all her friends coming together again soon after, at identical but different pine kitchen tables, scattered in a loose lop-sided circle around central London. 
 The detached, amused part of Phoebe sometimes thought that her main feeling at these parties was a wish that she, and everyone else too, would dare to improve the quality of the wine, but they were all too self-consciously afraid of being mistaken for Yuppies, despite the fact they were mostly a little too old and slightly too poor. 
 Property prices and psychoanalysis were mentioned shyly, rather as Rachel might mention sex, but once in the air everyone turned out to be immensely knowledgeable about both, as well as about the contemporary cinema, the wickedness of Thatcher's government and the perils of current educational reforms. 
 Those that had children struggled desperately to keep them within the state school system and also to see the frequent failures of others to succeed in this as being somehow a rather nasty disease, with compassion and sorrow the appropriate response, rather than the fierce bell-like anger they would all have produced reflexively only ten years before. 
 Another part of Phoebe hated herself for this cynical internal grin, because these were her friends and she was indubitably one of them, and could not imagine being otherwise. 
 She and Tom had met because they had had a playful debate about whether and in what sense you could say that coal pre-dated miners. 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; said Phoebe, showing off a little, &bquo;miners come before coal. 
 That's what Engels is trying to say, all that stuff about there not being mines and machinery in Siberia, where the natural circumstances ought to favour it, but only in England.&equo; 
 Tom grinned an enormous grin across the table and said, &bquo;You're cheating, because a) what are your natural circumstances if it's not the very existence of coal, b) I don't believe Engels said it at all and, c) even if he did, that doesn't make it true because he was working with an outmoded scientific model. 
 New physics and astronomy have done for all that. 
 In the beginning there was carbon, and after several generations of Super Novae there was the solar system and then there were a whole lot of trees and they all fell down plonk into bogs and got turned into coal, and that led to the dinosaurs and that led to the mammals and that led to humans and that led to the miners.&equo; 
 Phoebe was impressed; she laughed with pleasure and said, &bquo;And it's all in God's purpose and plan, eh? 
 Then he got peevish and decided on a rain storm and the dinosaurs were so overgrown that they wouldn't fit into the ark so the flood destroyed them all. 
 Seriously, coal doesn't exist outside of a market condition, OK? and you can't have a market condition without someone to extract the damn stuff. 
 Hence, miners first, coal second. 
 QED.&equo; 
 They looked at each other quizzically, trying to decide how much emotion the other was prepared to invest in this. 
 Did they really want to argue? 
 Clearly they each believed there was a real issue, and that the other was intelligent enough to pursue it. 
 Phoebe decided to give it a go. 
 She gave him a tentative smile, suggesting, she hoped, her pleasure in the game and drew a breath, when he said. 
 &bquo;Oh my God, I know who you are. 
 It's that let's-get-on-with-it expression. 
 Hell.&equo; 
 She was totally baffled. 
 Please, not Goa in 1969, she thought. 
 Please, let it not be some man she had slept with and now could not even remember ever having seen before in her life. 
 He had attracted the attention of the rest of the table. 
 He was suffused with laughter. 
 &bquo;This woman is the first woman who ever beat me at chess. 
 In Cambridge, twenty years ago. 
 You cannot imagine how furious I was. 
 She made the first breach in my armourplating of male superiority. 
 Where the hell have you been ever since? 
 I have a debt to pay off and I still want to beat you.&equo; 
 &bquo;You would now. 
 I haven't played for years.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good. 
 You have changed though, that sweet little fringe and those neat pearl earrings.&equo; 
 He smiled, &bquo;It's OK, you don't have to pretend you remember me; this instant recall is but an outward symbol of the soul-scarring effect you had on me. 
 I was just one of those Tweedledum and Tweedledee corduroy-jacket-wearing chess buffs who hung around the club. 
 Women were rather more conspicuous. 
 Why did you stop playing?&equo; 
 &bquo;A long story,&equo; she said, &bquo;I'll tell you sometime.&equo; 
 She heard the invitation, the promise of a future, in her voice and was surprised. 
 However when the party broke up and he offered her a lift home, she was quick to negotiate secretly with her hostess for her bike to remain unmentioned in the stairwell until she came back the next day to collect it. 
 He drove well and efficiently. 
 She watched his profile in the dark car and it pleased her, soft floppy hair and a decent nose. 
 He seemed relaxed and simple. 
 They chatted impersonally about the dinner and how they each came to know their hosts. 
 When he stopped outside her house he said, 
 &bquo;We must meet again. 
 We've got unfinished business, you and I.&equo; 
 &bquo;Chess or miners?&equo; 
 &bquo;Both.&equo; 
 &bquo;You could come in now and have some coffee.&equo; 
 &bquo;Unfortunately I have to get home. 
 But I'll come another time, please.&equo; 
 &bquo;Come on Saturday afternoon? 
 We can play chess and I could probably correct your anti-materialist views on the coal industry in a matter of moments.&equo; 
 He laughed, &bquo;Mine anti-materialist? 
 Mine are materialist; yours are mystical-Marxism, the opiate of the middle classes. 
 Actually I can't come on Saturday, I have family commitments. 
 What about one evening next week?&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you married?&equo; she asked him abruptly. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; he said, &bquo;do you mind?&equo; 
 &bquo;Funnily enough, I think I do. 
 I suppose your wife doesn't understand you.&equo; 
 &bquo;On the contrary, she understands me very well and I'm still free to play chess.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank God for that,&equo; she laughed. 
 &bquo;Come next Wednesday if you can. 
 You can meet my daughter.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you divorced?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; she said, and watched a tiny nervous flicker on his face. 
 &bquo;I'm only not divorced because I was never married. 
 I have a delightful little bastard who can chaperone a long-delayed revenge match.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're on.&equo; 
 She opened the door of the car and climbed out. 
 She knew perfectly well she was going to make love to him sometime, so there did not seem to be any hurry. 
 She waved happily as he drove off. 
 He beat her easily at chess the following week, but when he came again she had been thinking and remembering. 
 After a long game in the kitchen which ended in a draw, they went upstairs and made love. 
 He was undemanding, unemotional, light-hearted and pleasing to her. 
 Once Phoebe had started playing chess regularly again she realised she could probably have become considerably better than him quite quickly, but she did not want that enough to work on it. 
 They played together a couple of evenings every month, but after that first time by mutual consent they never made love in her house, any more than they did in his. 
 He and 
 Maggie got on well and he was calmly nice to Rachel. 
 Phoebe tried to build up a little guilt about his wife but failed to do so. 
 Because she never had to be his lover in front of Maggie or Rachel she had no need to worry about that either. 
 Occasionally she could see a gleam in Rachel's eye, as though she might suddenly ask him if his intentions were honourable, but for the first time in her life she learned to be grateful for her mother's good manners. 
 He was fun. 
 He would turn up at her garden with a picnic in the late afternoons, laying out a white cloth, champagne and strawberries under the shadow of the tower block and the bemused scrutiny of the local youth. 
 He would stay for just an hour or so and then gather up the equipment and disappear. 
 When he was working out of London she would join him. 
 She saw more of England driving with him in his car, or walking through cities while he attended to business, then she ever had before. 
 He planned carefully so that there was always time and no panic. 
 And she loved his body, the astringent unsweaty cleverness of it, that gave with delight and asked for so little back. 
 Their Italian holiday had been different, a tiny golden time, snatched out of nowhere and more than either of them deserved. 
 Last spring he had said, 
 &bquo;I have to be in Rome for six weeks. 
 It'll be so hot I thought I might rent a place in the country, but it might be a waste of money. 
 Julia and the kids are going to her parents in Cumbria. 
 What do you think?&equo; 
 Phoebe went skiing early every spring. 
 She had learned as a girl and given herself a week's holiday for a thirtieth birthday present. 
 The extreme delight of it had almost shocked her; it was her one personal extravagance. 
 Now she thought that she could give it up for three weeks in the Italian sun. 
 &bquo;I don't see why not.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bring Maggie,&equo; he said, &bquo;she'll love it. 
 I'll find you somewhere with a pool.&equo; 
 &bquo;Tom, can I afford that?&equo; 
 &bquo;I shouldn't think so,&equo; he said, &bquo;not all of it, but I need it too and can write if off as expenses.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cor,&equo; she mocked in her best cockney accent, &bquo;kept woman now, Phoebe Petherington, you ought to be ashamed of yourself.&equo; 
 He seemed to find that adequate gratitude. 
 So he found them a tiny cottage just south of Orvieto, in the grounds of the villa of some Italian friends of his who had departed for the northern mountains, a villa with a pool and a shady veranda along one side and an unspeakably romantic view down the steep hillside towards the floating cathedral. 
 She had taken Maggie off to the sunshine. 
 She had not travelled for pleasure since she had come home from her long sojourn and she had wiped out of her memory the simple delights of hot sun and cheap wine. 
 She had risen at dawn each day, when the sky was still apricot-coloured and swum naked and alone as the sun rose. 
 She had lain with Maggie beside the swimming pool and had let her whole body soak up the sun. 
 Tom spent the weekends with them and drove up many afternoons from Rome to dine with them and stay overnight. 
 He took them for drives, showing her the extraordinary beauties of Umbria. 
 It was hot and gentle; Maggie was playful and contented. 
 One day she would remember forever. 
 It had been another perfect morning. 
 She had woken earlier even than usual, with Tom beside her, sleeping contentedly and openly on his back. 
 Knowing it impossible to sleep again, she had lain there for a while and listened to the silence of sleep throughout the house. 
 Then she got up, half cross to be awake when other people were still sleeping and half pleased with the intensity of quiet and peace. 
 Downstairs she made herself a cup of coffee and carried it out onto the patio and drank it at the table, smoked a loose-rolled sweet Italian cigarette, and watched the coming of the dawn. 
 She had swum, very conscious of the water, cooler after the night, swallowing her into itself and the darkness retreating before the splashes of her arms and legs. 
 The sky would begin to change from grey to silver gilt, then peach, but still the sun did not rise. 
 After swimming she had felt completely alive and glad to be awake and have this time of her own, which had been a gift to her from Tom and Maggie. 
 She had gone for a walk up the road, beside a field of sunflowers, and although the sun had not yet risen she could sense the whole field turning away from her and each flower raising its face towards the eastern hills over which the sun would shortly leap. 
 She had felt the whole silent movement of that field, each straining golden head, instinctively, blindly, passionately turning towards the light. 
 And equally instinctively, she had turned with them, leaving the road and taking a cart track along the upper side of the field. 
 Above her the fields rose steeply, rough grass and scattered olive trees, which in that light looked immovably ancient and grotesque. 
 Below her the muttering sunflowers continued their ghostly and invisible movement. 
 Suddenly, the track fell away sharply, in front of her feet, and she felt before she saw the expanded horizon. 
 She had looked up; and like the sunflowers she was facing right into the heart of the brightness which preceded the sun. 
 The eastern mountains looked black and shapely, silhouetted against that great apricot-coloured fire. 
 She had been on the very edge of the steep hills which surround the basin in which Orvieto sits; and the basin itself was alive and moving, swirling with smoke, with smoky white mists which filled it almost to the brim. 
 Then and there the sun rose abruptly and she could see the city bright and sunlit, floating on the mists, a magic city of mediaeval romance. 
 That sleeping peaceful beauty had been almost too much for her. 
 Only a couple of days before Maggie had pointed out how the great cathedral dominated the city, like the spines along a dragon's back, while the other buildings lay in a rough sprawl. 
 She had laughed then at the vivid imagination of the child, but now for a brief moment she saw the city as Maggie saw it, basking in the first rays of the sun and oblivious to the dangerous mist below that might suck it in before it could wake up and take wing against the now blue blue sky. 
 Then far away, only emphasising the silence, a cock had crowed, shrill and certain. 
 With both laughter and irritation Phoebe had returned to consciousness ironically amused at how nature could behave with such excessive romanticism. 
 But the day had insisted on playing itself out in the idyllic pastoral mode. 
 Tom, when he woke later had insisted that they should absorb some culture, had chivvied them both into his car and driven them first to the Villa Lante. 
 &bquo;You'll love the garden, Bea,&equo; he insisted when she had looked longingly, lazily, at the swimming pool. 
 &bquo;It's one of my favourites. 
 It was built by a series of cardinals as a hunting lodge.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't like those high Renaissance gardens much,&equo; she said, though unaggressively. 
 &bquo;There are never enough flowers, only designs. 
 And I'm meant to be on holiday. 
 Gardens are work for me, not leisure.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll like this one,&equo; he said firmly, &bquo;partly because of the water; it all flows downwards, the whole garden works its way downwards. 
 And also you'll like it because the house had to be split into two separate halves &mdash; the garden takes priority over domestic comfort. 
 And also you'll like it because the cardinal who designed it was a practical joker and built in all sorts of extremely infantile jokes so that he could spray water onto his innocent friends while they were eating their dinner or trying to watch little masques. 
 You will like it very much.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that an order?&equo; she teased him, but indicated her consent by beginning to search for her shoes. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he said, hugging her, &bquo;It's a present.&equo; 
 She laughed and accepted his gift. 
 And he had been right. 
 She did like the garden, its delicate wit and gentle scale. 
 They had walked up the worn stone staircase, arm in arm, with their beautiful girl child dancing around them. 
 And Phoebe was so relaxed that it actually amused her to realise that everyone who saw them would assume they were a boring married couple, English middle-class tourists. 
 Afterwards they had eaten lunch and then despite the heat had started home. 
 Then on the way back he had suddenly turned to Maggie and said, 
 &bquo;That was a garden for your mother, now I have one for you.&equo; 
 He wouldn't tell them anything more, but drove by tiny back roads, through impossibly steep villages to the grotesque gardens of Bomarzo. 
 He had scarcely known Maggie, could not have known that he could not have chosen a better treat than this mysterious park, with its vast statues carved out of the living rock: the huge-mouthed cave with its mighty teeth, the vast stone giant, his shoulders visible through bushes a hundred yards away, half hidden in greenery; and above all, the great carved stone dragon with its broken wings, and wild Chinese eyes. 
 The three of them entered a place outside time, on a day of such stillness and heat. 
 Later that evening they had been sitting in a restaurant and Maggie had looked at Tom and said, her delicate face and long neck almost visibly aquiver with pleasure, 
 &bquo;Thank you.&equo; 
 &bquo;What for?&equo; he had looked almost startled by her vehemence. 
 &bquo;For the nicest day in my whole life.&equo; 
 Phoebe, her body content and her mind rested, had heard her daughter without a flicker of guilt, or envy, simply with affection. 
 Would she have enjoyed him so much if she had thought the whole thing permanent? she asked herself sternly now, sitting up in bed and shaking off the poppy and mandragora effect that thinking about that summer had on her. 
 Would she even have started the relationship if she had not been reasonably certain that in the end he would not leave his wife? 
 Perhaps not, but she did not care. 
 Who had been the loser? 
 On paper, she had; and perhaps his wife. 
 He had, in the classic language of such things, had his cake and eaten it too. 
 But what was she supposed to have lost? 
 Nothing that mattered to her. 
 That, of course, had been the rub. 
 She had not cared enough. 
 He told her so at the very end. 
 Just after Christmas she had travelled up to Birmingham after work one evening, to spend the night with him. 
 The weather had been bitter, she had been tired and stiff. 
 Sitting on the train she had suddenly thought that it was not worth it. 
 She could have been at home, warm and snug. 
 She could have been at Lisa's house, laughing. 
 She could have been alone with in dark shadow in her breast, nourishing it quietly and secretly. 
 But Tom and she would go skiing at the end of the month. 
 It would not be damp and she would not be so weary. 
 She tried to jolly herself into enthusiasm. 
 Their moods did not meet that night. 
 He was ebullient, excitable, verbal, and passionate. 
 &bquo;I'm tired, Tom.&equo; 
 &bquo;My sweet love, you're tired a great deal too often. 
 Are you well?&equo; 
 The tide of her secret lapped around her; soon she would be too tired all of the time. 
 Soon she would lie down in the arms of a stronger lover than Tom would ever be and fall asleep. 
 The thought of being so discovered made her careful. 
 She put her arms round his neck and said, &bquo;Come to bed and hold me tight.&equo; 
 Hopefully as well as affectionately, he did so; undressing her as she lay on the too-large hotel bed and stroking her shoulders and upper arms. 
 He never ceased to be amazed by her physical strength. 
 &bquo;Why don't you look muscly?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've told you. 
 These are real muscles, not the detachable falsies you get in the gym.&equo; 
 She was rather proud of herself and could not suppress the smug tone of voice. 
 He smiled. 
 &bquo;Real breasts too. 
 No detachable falsies these.&equo; 
 If he had been less aroused he wouldn't have done it; if he had been more aroused he wouldn't have noticed. 
 He ran his hand half playfully, half seductively round her left breast and then stopped. 
 The whole room stopped. 
 Her whole life stopped. 
 His hand felt rigid, and then his thumb moved delicately. 
 &bquo;Don't,&equo; she said sharply, and sat up. 
 &bquo;Darling,&equo; he said. 
 He reached out to her but she did not move into the offered harbour of his arms. 
 &bquo;Why didn't you tell me?&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose because I didn't want you to know.&equo; 
 &bquo;What does your doctor say? 
 What are you doing about it?&equo; 
 She couldn't think of a lie quick enough. 
 He just stared at her. 
 &bquo;Are you insane?&equo; 
 After another long silence he said, 
 &bquo;Bea&hellip; 
 I'll leave Julia. 
 I'll come and live with you. 
 Please.&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that why you didn't tell me, because you were thinking of me, of her&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 I didn't tell you because I knew we'd have a scene like this and I don't like it. 
 &bquo;Of course we're having a scene like this. 
 I love you, Bea, you know that.&equo; 
 He tried to lighten his mood, grinning at her like a schoolboy, &bquo;Apart from anything else we could make love at breakfast-time, lunch-time and tea-time.&equo; 
 He had found out her secret and she hated him. 
 She said, &bquo;Apart from anything else I can't imagine any sex worth giving up tea-time for.&equo; 
 As soon as she had said it she knew that it was true and that made her sadder and crosser. 
 But he looked so hurt that she tried to make a joke of it, 
 &bquo;You know me. 
 I adore crumpets; and I loathe romanticism and that &bquo;all for love and the world well lost&equo; stuff. 
 I've loved you because I like relationships to be comfortable and not too much hard work, and sex to be civilised. 
 I prefer doing the crossword puzzle anyway. 
 You've never made scenes and I don't want them.&equo; 
 But although they both tried to smile still, neither of them failed to notice the past tense she had used for the word &bquo;love&equo;. 
 &bquo;You'll never want anything of me, will you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, not dramas, and miserable marriage breakups and guilt and scenes and deathbed proclamations certainly,&equo; she had replied. 
 &bquo;Nor have you wanted them from me, You'd never have stayed around so long if I'd pushed you about.&equo; 
 He had not quite known what he wanted to say. 
 He had not wanted a drama, demands, excitement, but he had somewhere wanted her at least to complain that he did not. 
 He said almost sulkily, &bquo;I've been behaving badly for two years, and you know it, and you don't even mind.&equo; 
 She knew what he meant, but she would not help him out. 
 She was not going to have a fight with him. 
 She would see&ndash; him occasionally for the rest of her life, and she wanted to be able to chat to him, invite him for more games of chess, more visits to historic gardens. 
 She would never make love to him again, though. 
 She did not care enough. 
 She kissed the balding patch on the back of his head as she clambered off the bed and went to the fridge to pour them both a drink. 
 &bquo;You don't care, do you?&equo; he said with amazement. 
 &bquo;I don't mean just about me; I mean you really don't care whether you live or die. 
 I can't cope with that. 
 You just don't care enough.&equo; 
 They did not say that it was over, neither of them. 
 They did not need to. 
 She went on the skiing holiday he had paid for and accepted his excuse about his daughter's measles without a moment's hesitation. 
 She had thought it would be a pity not to have him around any longer: Rachel and Maggie both liked him and she had not told either of them about his wife. 
 She preferred such a relationship to a more driving one. 
 She had always known she was devoid of passion: she worked at her garden and talked to her friends. 
 It was all she would ever have. 
 She missed him, and missed the companionable secrecy of their relationship, but she was not miserable about it. 
 She was more miserable about not being miserable. 
 She felt her inability to demand anything from him, to need to demand anything from him, was a mark of failure. 
 She would have liked to fall in love with him. 
 And instead she had fallen in love with her own tumour. 
 &bquo;You must be insane,&equo; he had said, and she was. 
 All love was folly; a grand passion was madness. 
 This was a love worth dying for, at last. 
 And all these pleasures, these frail joys that her most stringent discipline over the last couple of night-time hours had summoned up for her memory, they were simply not enough. 
 They were not worth living for. 
 Her mother had once told her scornfully about a crazy book produced on the contemporary new wave of evolutionary theory: a book which abandoned Darwin and returned to his predecessor, Lamark. 
 Or rather, as Rachel had been at pains to point out, a misunderstanding of Lamark's theory of learned characteristics being inherited. 
 The author of the book had argued that evolution was a product of desire: a wingless animal, unconsciously, wants to fly &mdash; it wills a wing, a pair or wings, or a longer neck to reach the trees, or swifter legs to escape its predators. 
 It is this will which is inherited. 
 The book claimed that cancer and other deformities were mistaken wills, were new organs to meet new needs dreamed up in the deep unconscious, and that therefore they should be treated not with surgery but with interest and affection &mdash; humanity was limiting its potential by cutting out the tumours, blasting the cells. 
 Phoebe, like her mother, did not believe a word of it, but part of her knew it was true. 
 She had wanted to fall in love, she had willed it, and her body had produced the lover, close to her heart, fed by her own blood, watered by own needy greedy wanting. 
 Secret and adored. 
 She knew it was not sane. 
 She knew it was insane and dangerous, what she was doing. 
 She knew it so clearly that three weeks ago she had made an appointment to take her breast lump to a doctor. 
 But she had done it in a very peculiar way: she had booked in to a private Well Woman Clinic under an assumed name. 
 The appointment was now for tomorrow. 
 She was amazed at herself, but she had done it, and now in the early hours of the morning she did not know if, even so, she would go. 
 Who was he, this dark and secret lover who had inflamed her with so great a passion? 
 Was he Death astride his dark charger, was Death the moment of consummation, the moment of glory? 
 &bquo;Tell me,&equo; she commanded herself, &bquo;tell me what is going on. 
 What is this certainty?&equo; 
 She was in a new place where she had never been before. 
 She had run off with her lover to a new country which was strange and beautiful and dangerous. 
 In this new place there was an orgasmic sweetness in the thought of dying. 
 She was pierced to the heart and made alive with the consciousness of passion, of love, of choice&hellip; 
 She had found a sweet lover where there had been no love. 
 The patterns were broken because she had broken them. 
 This love was a new pattern, a new Catastrophe Theory and she was happy in its embrace. 
 She wanted the world to go away and let her live with her lover in a secret palace, give herself over to his embrace, to be beyond responsibility and care and hard work and sanity. 
 Her hand was caressing her own breast now, probing with such delicacy, feeling the hard resistance, the anger of her lover. 
 Soon, soon if she has the courage, it will not matter, mt will be too late for anyone to protest, to come to her with sensible and sound advice. 
 Soon, soon her lover will take over her whole body forcing his way deeper than any lover before &mdash; not just into her vagina, or, like Jim's sperm, further in to her womb. 
 This lover will penetrate every corner of her body, her lymph nodes, her spine, her lungs, kidneys, liver, brain. 
 This lover will be irresistible and she will be taken over entirely by him. 
 She has only to consent, to be passive, to welcome him and he will take her home, will welcome her into his kingdom and his kingdom will be her flesh. 
 But she did not consent. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; she said aloud. 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; he asked sweetly. 
 She wanted to say, &bquo;Because of Maggie and Rachel and Lisa and the garden and duty and sunshine,&equo; but alone in the darkness she did not believe in any of that. 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Suddenly, overpoweringly, she needed her mother, she needed to be taken in her mother's arms, like a little child and to be held there. 
 &bquo;It's four o'clock in the morning,&equo; she told herself. 
 &bquo;You cannot wake up an old lady just to listen to your insane and morbid fantasies.&equo; 
 But she knew that this was more important. 
 She had never asked Rachel for anything. 
 It was difficult. 
 Rachel was not an easy person to go to with such a strange and garbled fear. 
 Rachel would try to be rational and calm. 
 Rachel would not want to hear. 
 But it was not to Rachel that she would go, but to her mummy. 
 She turned the light on and got out of bed. 
 She was shaking with fear. 
 The moment she spoke to Rachel the die would be cast, and she would have to go along the road of sensible health planning and operations and anxieties and reality. 
 She would have say goodbye to passion and secret joy. 
 She put her knickers on, and almost smiled, because even now she would not go to Rachel without them. 
 She walked over to her door, practising the sentences with which she would wake Rachel. 
 &bquo;Mummy, wake up and listen to me.&equo; 
 When her hand was on her doorknob she paused; the call of the dark was so strong, it slowed her movements down. 
 He was calling her. 
 Promising her. 
 She wavered. 
 Her hand tightened on the handle and she pushed down on it. 
 Then she heard an enormous crash, a bomb exploding somewhere very near, a great roar of shattering glass and, after a moment's stillness, screaming, ear-splitting, horrible screaming, from just over her head. 
 Three 
 Maggie's room, her own place, had been made for her the summer she was eight by Phoebe, Paul and Uncle Wong. 
 Lisa had helped and Rachel had encouraged. 
 Even now Maggie remembered the making of it as a time of rare delight: when all the people of her life came together and did something for her. 
 The result of such a burst of love and energy from such an assortment of individuals was inevitably extraordinary. 
 It was a magical room, carved out of the attic and reached only by a wrought-iron spiral staircase which Paul had rescued from some abandoned church. 
 High above the house the room floated lightly. 
 The ceiling sloped down tightly to the floor, making dark shadowy edges which were well nigh impossible to clean, and three odd narrow passages ran to the three dormer windows, which cast odd blocks of light into the main spaces of the room. 
 But there was also a huge skylight, facing both ways and divided across the middle only by the roofbeam of the house itself. 
 By day light flooded the room and by night darkness, because no one had ever worked out a satisfactory way of curtaining these great expanses. 
 Phoebe continually meant to buy blinds, blinds that would be ingeniously fitted into little runnels either side of the glass slopes, but it was one of those domestic chores that she had never managed to complete. 
 Maggie now slept on a low bed draped with a Chinese spread covered in dancing dragons and spinning suns, exactly underneath the centre of these windows, and on clear nights the moon rode over her head, and the clouds, illuminated a sickly yellow by the vastness of the city, would race past. 
 Because there had never truly been enough height and the angle of the ceiling was so acute, nothing was ever quite symmetrical and balanced, and cupboards and wall space were eccentric and fortuitous. 
 Maggie clung to the privacy of her room, as small children do to their teddy bears; she never invited her friends there, preferring to contain them in the large sitting-room below. 
 This was her place, her secret place; hers and Fenna's. 
 The first night she had slept there she had known. 
 It had taken only a little practice to discover how to lie there, flat on her back, and slowly, with great care, peel away the roof beam and open back the two vast panes of glass. 
 Even from the beginning she had lain naked and adoring under the moon and Fenna could come and go as easily as the clouds did. 
 Fenna is Maggie's dragon. 
 Fenna is the one purely joyful thing in Maggie's life. 
 Fenna is flame and fire. 
 Fenna moves at night. 
 Fenna is flame and fire, and moves on the wings of the night that are dragon-wings, to dance with taloned claws and mock at hopes of safety. 
 Fenna is the dark force of the imagination as well as its golden dancing; Fenna is chaos as well as order, and brings, on fiery dragon breath, the full danger of the chasm. 
 Maggie and Fenna belong to each other. 
 For Maggie, this is the primal sentence. 
 Not the first words spoken, but from before the surfacing of memory she has known this. 
 It is her first self-conscious sentence. 
 It is the sentence around which she has shaped her identity. 
 To deny it is therefore impossible. 
 To break it down is extremely difficult. 
 Dangerous. 
 The words will remain, indubitably. 
 &bquo;Maggie&equo;, &bquo;Fenna&equo;. 
 There is no question about them. 
 And &bquo;each&equo; and &bquo;other&equo;. 
 &bquo;To&equo; as well. 
 Maggie feels no doubt about that: so small a word, so small and so necessary a word is bound to survive, to slip through the net of destruction that she and Fenna &mdash; no, that she herself, alone &mdash; will loose on the cold sky tonight. 
 But &bquo;belong&equo; &mdash; she is fearful that for her at least the word may explode, may vanish in a puff of smoke as delicate as the smoke that trickles from Fenna's nostrils when he is asleep; as delicate as the fronds of smoke that drift mysteriously from the end of Phoebe's cigarette when she gestures impatiently in conversation. 
 Maggie might no longer belong, to anything or anyone, if she did not belong to Fenna. 
 Fenna accompanied Maggie into consciousness. 
 There must have been a time before Fenna, just as there must have been a time before words, but Maggie cannot not conceive of either. 
 How could it have felt to be lonely and dumb? 
 But at the same time Maggie was still young enough to hold two or more things in her mind, clear and contradictory. 
 Her mind, like the women in her house, was still laid down in strata, each virtually impermeable to the others. 
 All this about Fenna was entirely true, but she would not have said it, would not have known how to shape such sentences. 
 If she were asked where Fenna had come from she would have told a quite different story: the story of the arrival of Fenna. 
 Her Uncle Wong, her grandmother's friend, who was now under a shadow so deep that without being told, Maggie knew she must not mention his name, her beloved Uncle Wong had given her Fenna. 
 When she had been about five he had come to stay, returning from Hong Kong and, like other wise men from the east, he came bearing gifts. 
 He had given her an egg; an orange egg about four inches long and made, of all things, of soap. 
 She had felt disappointment waiting to pounce, but swiftly he had assured her it was a magic egg, that if she washed with it carefully it would hatch. 
 She had for nearly a month washed fanatically, with all the clarity and determination of which five-year-olds are capable. 
 After about two weeks, long cracks had developed in the egg, lines of longitude. 
 Even so young Maggie was not a child to cheat; it did not occur to her to prise the egg open, only to stay longer in the bath and to forget to take the soap out of the water, when she climbed out herself, pink and skinny. 
 At last, from the thin end of the egg, a rounded point appeared, and, three evenings later, in the bath, the egg had suddenly split in half. 
 Encased in the soap was a tiny green dragon. 
 In one hand she held half the soap with the embedded dragon in high relief, its tiny green wings minutely scaled, its long head thrusting forward and its tail descending to the soft nobble which had first appeared. 
 And in the other hand was the orange soap holding the shadow of a dragon, the clear and perfect indentation of a three-inch-long green plastic dragon. 
 After the careful brooding, she had hatched a dream. 
 That was Fenna. 
 She had shown him with pride to both her mother and grandmother and had carried him to bed more deeply satisfied than at any time since she had been weaned from Phoebe's now forgotten breasts. 
 For the next few days she had carried the tiny dragon everywhere. 
 And then she had, as children do, lost him. 
 To comfort her desolation and guilt Rachel had told her about the Mongolian desert, where she had been as a little girl, hardly older than Maggie was now, to look for dragons, which she called dinosaurs, and where years later Russian palaeontologists had found the great fossil eggs in which the sleeping baby dinosaurs could still be seen. 
 She told Maggie about the palace of the Princess Tang Li, north of Beijing, which she had visited with her own beautiful mother, Maggie's great-grandmother. 
 In that-place there had been intricate gardens, where water wheels turned musically and water lilies bloomed moon-white, and giant goldfish floated under them. 
 And there had been green and gold and scarlet dragons painted on every wall and woven into every silk hanging. 
 There had been stone dragons, and jade dragons so delicate that they disintegrated at a puff of breath. 
 There had been copper dragons and dragons painted on porcelain so fine that light filtered through them and their colours seemed to change as you looked. 
 China, Rachel had told Maggie, was the place for dragons, where it was hot, and where in the villages great paper ones were paraded with veneration. 
 And being as usual in the mood to get things right she told her a Chinese dragon story. 
 Rachel's Dragon Story 
 This is a Chinese story, Maggie, and in China they used to understand dragons better than here in Europe. 
 Once upon a time there was a man who thought he could be a dragon-master. 
 He was a scholar and for many years studied to learn the ways of dragons; he was proud but not stupid, and he learned all that the books could teach him, and then he set off on a long journey and captured two baby dragons and brought them home as pets. 
 He had learned everything that dragons need, but he had not understood any of it. 
 He built his dragons a garden, the most beautiful garden in the world, and although he surrounded it with an iron wall which he believed they would not cross, he made the wall beautiful for them, lavish with filigree work and sweet with hanging plants. 
 He built them a pagoda of solid jade and embellished it with precious gems &mdash; not realising that to grow up a dragon must accumulate its own hoard, must steal it from Emperors and princes. 
 He had a pond dug for them, so pretty and sweet, surrounded by bullrushes with a delicate arched bridge and floating with water lilies &mdash; Not realising that a real dragon needs a whole ocean to sport in, needs the spume of the white capped waves, needs the great storms and clanging icebergs, needs the coral islands of the southern seas, needs the dark rains and winds and currents to make its blood flow green and its whiskers curl ferociously. 
 The scholar fed his pet dragons on the choicest tit-bits, bringing them rump steaks of the purest virgins and a daily supply of swallows' flesh &mdash; not realising that such things, for true dragons, are treats, are after-dinner delicacies and no more a fit diet than endless chocolates would be for you. 
 As you can imagine, his pet dragons did not grow very large, but they did grow lazy and fat and tame. 
 And then one night, one bright and starlit night, a true free dragon came by to pay a call. 
 He looked down on the pretty garden and saw the two of them snoring there, their front claws tucked neatly under their chins which rested on silk cushions and their tails dipped tidily into the pond whose waters did not stir enough to move their dreams to wildness. 
 The great dragon was angry but courteous, and he woke them up in as mannerly a way as he knew how. 
 Immediately they invited him to join them, singing in their slightly squeaky voices of the charms and luxury of their lifestyle. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; cried the great dragon, his deep brass-gonged voice ringing out and causing several of the gems to tinkle off the jade pagoda. 
 &bquo;What! 
 Come down and snooze in a garden when I am a dragon, an ocean-lurking, sky-flying free dragon; when the mother wind that keeps the world spinning caresses my scales as I fly across the moon and bring warnings and hopes to the fiery heart of the world; when I can dance aloft at dawn, so that the rising sun turns my every scale to a pure diamond and the tides and rhythms of the oceans slow down in delight. 
 Have you gone insane?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; they answered a little sheepishly, &bquo;this is so much cosier.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cosy! 
 Do you call yourselves dragons? 
 What of your great calling? 
 Your dragonish duties; your dignity and pride?&equo; 
 &bquo;But we cannot escape,&equo; they whined. 
 &bquo;See, he has imprisoned us inside an iron wall. 
 You see we are real dragons; all dragons dread iron.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dread, yes,&equo; he replied, &bquo;but fear can be defeated. 
 Come on out, you miserable cowards.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, no, thank you,&equo; they both said hastily. 
 &bquo;It might hurt our Lord's feelings. 
 And he does look after us so well; we are truly comfortable and urge you to try it.&equo; 
 The great dragon snorted a cloud of fire, and gonged back at them, &bquo;Stay then, you foolish worms. 
 I came to help you escape and you have insulted me, me and all true free dragons with your petty invitation. 
 I'll leave you to your fate, but I warn you, tame dragons never come to any good. 
 Just wait and see.&equo; 
 And he roared away into the night, the rough scales on his throat catching the breeze of his anger and making a hissing hum as he vanished. 
 But he was right. 
 For soon enough their scholarly owner grew bored with his dragon studies &mdash; as well he might since his samples were such Poring dragons &mdash; and decided to investigate the secrets of the turbine jet engine instead. 
 Of course he needed to finance so improbable a research programme, so he sold his dragons to an Emperor, who had them minced up and served to him garnished with spit-roasted swallows' tongues, at one of his less important banquets. 
 And Maggie had giggled and had indeed been comforted. 
 To comfort Maggie's desolation and guilt at the loss of her little dragon, Phoebe had suggested that the dragon, having gained his strength from her love, had flown away. 
 Being for once in the mood to get things right, Phoebe had brought home from the library a book about dragonflies. 
 Not a children's book at all, but a modern illustrated coffee-table book with careful, delicate photographs. 
 As a child she had not had time for many fairy stories and did not now know them to tell to her daughter again, but instead she showed her the pictures. 
 First the ugly lumpy larvae, the precision closeups showing its undershot jaw as it chomped its way through its subaqueous world. 
 Then the tight cysts, not unlike Maggie's soap egg, glued onto the reed stalks, and swelling, swelling, splitting until finally the pictures captured the moment when the dragonfly broke from the chrysalis, crawled desperately up the reed stem and unfolded its glorious wings in the sunshine, spreading them out to harden, to firm up, to set, to grow strong. 
 It was shimmering, incandescent, as the colours deepened and the long blue-black tail unfurled and stiffened until it gained the strength to fly. 
 &bquo;Perhaps you were the sun for your little dragon; and now she is strong enough, she wants to be free.&equo; 
 &bquo;He,&equo; said Maggie obstinately, and with unusual tenderness, Phoebe did not contradict her. 
 Thus Maggie was comforted. 
 And that night, from these gifts, Maggie had resurrected Fenna. 
 Using the solid material of history and science she had recreated, restored, raised up Fenna in her imagination and he had never gone away. 
 For ten years he had been her constant companion. 
 Now, arriving in the safety of her own room, Maggie undressed, folding her clothes and putting them away with an unusual neatness for a fifteen year-old. 
 In her case this was a consequence of living with two women like Phoebe and Rachel. 
 Phoebe loathed housekeeping so profoundly that she felt guilty about it and always did it with a disciplined and joyless rigour, expecting everyone else to do so too. 
 Rachel, on the other hand, thought that tidiness was simply a moral necessity, along with generosity, thoughtfulness, good manners and clarity. 
 Phoebe, who might have been a slut, had in fact become exactly the opposite &mdash; she had not time or patience or tolerance for anyone she considered to be exploiting the manual work of other women. 
 Since Rachel had sneaked her Mrs Gordon into Phoebe's half of the house, misunderstanding and not caring about Phoebe's impotent fury, Phoebe had become even more rigorous about Maggie's tidiness. 
 The mess in the kitchen was typical of neither of them, and should have announced to them both the distress of the other. 
 The fact that they had not fought about it should have announced their despair. 
 Maggie had never bothered to resist their reasoning, and she folded her clothes partly from the natural instinct of obedience, and partly because she had never been entirely sure that these external appendages did indeed belong to her, Maggie Petherington, or if perhaps they were loans from the mysterious outer world; loans that would doubtless be called in some day. 
 She undressed without turning the light on. 
 She was not afraid of the dark, because when she was very little Maggie had had the last few scales of Fenna's tail to suck on while she fell asleep. 
 The scales across Fenna's shoulders and haunches were as large as dinner plates, and thick, heavy and dry &mdash; they changed colour in different lights, from dull pewter through to a dark red, the colour of dried blood, or the murky green of the lower waters of the Amazon River. 
 When they were wet from rain or swimming in the oceans, the light might catch on some deep oil in them and they would glimmer shadowy rainbows of colour, like oil spills on a road. 
 The scales on Fenna's belly were as large, but softer &mdash; pastelled reflections of his back, glimmering in pearly tones: oyster, and creamy-grey like dawn, or pollen yellows and dusty pinks. 
 But the scales down Fenna's tail grew gradually smaller and smaller, the darker shades of his back and the paler shades of his underside blending together, and at the very tip, small as a child's thumb, they were minute and a shade that, when she tried to match it to paint sample cards was usually called eau de nil . 
 She had sucked comfort with the distant vibration of Fenna's breathing rumbling down to his tail tip, and he had spun stories for her and woven them into dreams. 
 Fenna's Bedtime Story 
 This is an old story, Maggie, even by the datings of dragon lore. 
 Times have changed and now courageous young men on noble horses come out to kill us with their spears. 
 In this bright new world there is no place for the dragon: no one wants the shadow, wants the dark magic which is as old as the caves in the hills where we dwell. 
 It is not easy to kill a dragon, but it can be done, and there are many handy manuals to teach an aspiring hero the tricks of his trade. 
 It is much much harder to tame a dragon, to embrace a dragon, and to love and accept the darkness and the fear. 
 There are no manuals for this struggle, for it can only be done by those who have pure hearts and sharp wits and the wisdom to know themselves. 
 Once upon a time, long long ago and far far away, out in the dreamlands, there was another Margaret just like you. 
 I do not know whether we dragons loved her or hated her; her will was like iron, as fast clad as our scaled hides, but her heart was like a songbird in the morning and she was as lovely as the lilies of the field. 
 They say she lived at Antioch in Pisidia during the reign of the Emperor Diocletian. 
 Her father was a magician; he knew something of the old magic, but he turned it against the little people to whom it belonged, and demanded their money, their livestock and even their children to appease the gods with rivers of blood. 
 But Margaret laughed at him, and when she heard about a new God who sacrificed only himself, and gave bread and sweet wine to the people, she became a Christian. 
 All magicians can be tested by laughter because corruption cannot stand mockery; and when his daughter laughed at him he drove her out into the wilderness, and she lived in the wilderness with the wild beasts and angels ministered to her. 
 Hunting one day, Olybrius, the grand governor of Antioch, saw her and seeing her innocence and her loveliness he was jealous and immediately wanted to destroy both. 
 So he had her captured and brought to his palace. 
 He wanted to marry her, but she laughed at him too, and said she had already made her choices and they did not include giving up her God and replacing him with a somewhat vulgar and certainly brutal man. 
 Not surprisingly he was livid, and having failed to realise that those who laugh easily do not fear easily, he tried several means of torture to get her to consent. 
 It says a great deal about the natural stupidity of tyrants that, having discovered that torture works extremely effectively in intellectual or political cases, they immediately assume that it will work as well in the inspiring of desire in young women. 
 By and large it does not, and it certainly did not in Margaret's case: she merely laughed all the more, and sang the taunting hymns of her new faith, about how tyrants would be put down from their thrones and the humble and the meek raised up. 
 Then Olybrius' fury flared and even the ground shook in fear. 
 Deep deep in a limestone cave where the stalagmites grow less than an inch a century, but still tower so high as to humble the cathedrals of the surface, the shaking fear of the ground woke a dreaming dragon. 
 Called by Olybrius' anger, the dragon rushed on crimson wings, down from its home in the cold north. 
 The flame from its mouth passed over the western lands like a comet and woke millennial longings in the hearts of Roman legionaries, who eked out their twenty years of cold service dreaming of victories and of eating fresh figs under the olive trees of home. 
 The dragon homed in on Olybrius' wrath, which called him across the continent. 
 Cross at being so abruptly awoken from his sleep, he spotted Margaret and licked his great lips with glee. 
 Virgin flesh was not so easily come upon in those days; and a virgin garnished with terror was an unexpected breakfast treat after his long sleep. 
 He swooped across the market square in Antioch, while the crowd fell back appalled, and opening his huge mouth, like a salmon to a fly, snapped Margaret up. 
 Without missing a wing beat, he bore her high above the city and flew on. 
 He was just shifting this succulent morsel in his mouth before grinding her bones, when he heard an extraordinary sound; he heard a gurgle of laughter. 
 So shocked was he, and flying so fast, that he gulped and swallowed her whole. 
 And now both fear and joy fell upon the dragon. 
 He flew on, his great red and gold wings beating the sun-filled Mediterranean air, his huge scarlet tongue hanging out of his mouth in a desperate effort to cool down and not blow out any smoke and flames. 
 And when they were over the blue Aegean sea, many miles from Antioch, he circled widely, descended, and alighted on a small mountainous island, on soft green grass beside a grove of apple trees. 
 When the dragon had flighted across the market place of Antioch, and Margaret had found herself swept up between the huge teeth, she had laughed like a child at the brief glance she had had of the panic around her; she had laughed from the pure unexpectedness of her escape and at the terrified way the mighty Olybrius had nearly swallowed his moustaches. 
 But now in the belly of the monster she learned what fear was. 
 Inside the great dragon it was very hot and very uncomfortable; it was also very noisy, since the dragon's stomach rumbled like a volcano. 
 The dragon's internal boiler was situated very near to its stomach, and since he was making tremendous efforts to cool down, there were also terrifying hissing and grinding sounds. 
 But more: Margaret had been brought up in a household where true magic had been corrupted for profit and was therefore rightly feared as dangerous. 
 She knew, without any consolation, that she was at the mercy of everything which was most ancient and fearful. 
 The terror of death was upon her and, sensing this, the dragon's appetite awoke again. 
 The walls of the cavern where Margaret was sitting began to ooze with digestive juices, pungent with the smell of sulphur, and the quicklime of the morgue. 
 The acid began to eat away at the edge of her tunic, the bottom strands of her curly hair. 
 She longed for a weapon, for even a hairpin, and knowing that she did not have one, she knew too that she was totally defenceless, unarmed and alone. 
 She could feel the great flight of the dragon and sensed that she was high in air and travelling fast towards the sunset; she could feel the great muscles of the dragon's wings send ripplings down the stomach walls and she gave herself over to death. 
 And in the moment that she laid herself open to dying she heard the whispery voices of the wild beasts in the wilderness: 
 &bquo;Yeah, though I take the wings of morning and fly to the uttermost ends of the sea, yet thou art with me.&equo; 
 It was true, she knew, that dragons were huge and fierce and wild and mysterious; but it was also true, as she also knew, that not everything that was huge and fierce and wild and mysterious was necessarily evil, necessarily wanted to kill you. 
 Her God had made the dark at the same moment as the light. 
 He had made the shadow, the wildness and the passion. 
 Nightingales sing only in the dark. 
 In the dark there are new joys. 
 The dragon was the same as her wild longings, her fierce and stubborn courage, her desire to fly. 
 Then she felt the great gliding swoop, the downward hover and the bump as the dragon landed. 
 In a still moment of total blackness she could feel the sinewed strength, the velvet softness of the dragon's tripes. 
 &bquo;At least,&equo; she thought, &bquo;I will die touching something beautiful.&equo; 
 Her heart soared as she realised that this was a new adventure, an adventure through darkness into the greater darkness which might, just might, be even more beautiful than the slow throbbing of living blood, richer in iron than the veins of any mine, passing through mighty arteries, driven by the rhythmic pounding of the great beast's heart. 
 So she waited eagerly. 
 Suddenly far above her head she saw a little shaft of light. 
 It grew until it was a window and out through the window she could see down a long tunnel; and beyond that the sun shining and the mountains rising over the fruit trees. 
 Wider and wider, the dragon was opening its mouth. 
 He wanted her to come out. 
 It was a scary journey, scrabbling over that slippery great red tongue and passing through a great hall of teeth and palate, each pillar taller than she was and as sharp as a knife. 
 Stepping out on to grass she turned and knew that she was one of the few in all history and legend who could safely look a dragon in the eye. 
 So she did. 
 &bquo;Thank you,&equo; she said. 
 The dragon was ashamed. 
 &bquo;I wanted to kill you, but I could not.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; said Margaret laughing, &bquo;I wanted to kill you too, but I could not either.&equo; 
 The dragon heaved a huge sigh of relief and politely turned his head to let out a huge smoky belch; then he settled down for a dragon-like snooze. 
 Margaret kissed the side of his cheek and went to gather daisies in the grass and make a daisy chain to lead her new friend and spectacular pet through all the illuminated and flower strewn pages of Christian manuscripts. 
 Maggie had fallen asleep rejoicing. 
 So now Maggie was not afraid of the dark, even though the great windows exposed her to the full moon and turned her own skin white and pearly &mdash; a reflection of reflected light. 
 That light came originally from the same source as Fenna's fire, from the heart of the golden star, from the sun itself &mdash; but it was light crashing around space at speeds which defy relativity, rolling like waves, bouncing like particles, rebounding off the dead desert of the cold moon and hurled thence, down through nearly a quarter of a million miles, forced through the steadily slowly moving liquid molecules of solid glass which made the windows. 
 Maggie lay there on her back, stiff, formal, upon the great silken swirls of her Chinese bedspread, her feet tidily together, her arms spread wide, cruciform, and her rib cage rendered elongated and tortured by the moon shadows. 
 The moon was at her feet and she was clothed by the sun and so she waited. 
 By a strong act of will she kept the roof on her room. 
 She would not allow it to open up and expose her directly to the moon, and to the distant but approaching dragon. 
 Fenna, by all the ancient laws, could not come to her until she invited him; but he could, and did, will her to invite him, and the will of dragons is strong. 
 Once upon a time Fenna had brooded on a hoard for so many years and with such desire that it had quickened and grown, diamonds breeding and bringing up their young under his weight. 
 The unimaginable heat and weight of Fenna had pressed the ooze in the cave, pressed so hotly and heavily that the molecules of mud were squeezed apart, breaking up into carbon atoms and hydrogen atoms, and his weight had compressed the carbon atoms into diamond crystals, and more and more diamonds until his hoard was a lure to garish youths, who had toiled up to his cave and exchanged riddles and blows with him, but when he had fixed them with his ancient evil little eyes, they retreated abashed to sing his praises. 
 The force, the weight and heat of Fenna's will was no small thing, and Maggie had never before tried to resist it. 
 Nor was resisting enough. 
 It was only the beginning. 
 But St Margaret of Antioch had been swallowed up by a dragon too, and she had climbed out again, fresh and free, to become the matron saint of women in childbirth. 
 This gave her hope, for it was nothing less than a re-birth that Maggie was aiming for. 
 Maggie would not close her eyes, because that would be cheating, but she shortened her focus so that it rested precisely on the window-panes, and although they were not dirty and the moonbeams seemed to shine straight through them, they were there. 
 If she fixed her focus with enough concentration she could envisage the invisible barrier. 
 All she knew of self and love she knew through Fenna, and now she had to send him away. 
 Suddenly, lost in misery, she could not even remember why. 
 Lying on the bed, naked and waiting, Maggie lost her nerve. 
 She knew that she could not do it alone. 
 But surely she owed her beloved that honour at least, the honour of single combat, which is a dragon's privilege. 
 You do not go out after a dragon with hounds and huntsmen; nor with gangs of labourers to dig pits and set fires and lay traps. 
 No, you polish your armour till it gleams, you sharpen your lance and you mount your white charger, you raise your banner, you bid farewell to the grieving city, where the crowd stands in terror and hope at your preparations and your parting. 
 Then you ride out alone, across the springing grass all beset with tiny jewel-like flowers; you ride up the rushy mountains and down the rushy glens and come to the mouth of the dragon's cave. 
 Then you draw your sword, wave it over your head and call the dragon out. 
 Some dragons banter words with you, more devious and less answerable than the Sphynx herself; they spin word games which you must not play, and then in the end they come out and fight like men, until you can plunge your spear into the soft white spot where their plated armour is thin. 
 Maggie was tempted to that particular plot, for the story had been told that way so many times, and it is very hard, at moments of crisis, to re-cast the language and the shape of old stories. 
 But she had lived with a dragon for over ten years, and she had lived in a house filled with strong women, so she knew that there was something very wrong with that scenario. 
 In the first place, she did not plan to kill Fenna, although she recognised that he might die of grief or loneliness. 
 In the second place she was naked not armed, she was lying not riding, and she was the heroine not the hero. 
 This was a new battle. 
 Moreover the young hero was never alone; he always had a pure process, waiting for him, holding the thread of life which would protect him from the flames and the teeth and the dark belly of the monster. 
 It is women who have to go alone; whose lovers do not have the patience to wait at home and pray for them. 
 Maggie however had no intention of doing this alone. 
 Her courage returned. 
 This time she was not going to permit Fenna a re-run of the old plot; this time she was indeed going to make a brand new story; her own story. 
 She knew her own limitations. 
 She had been brought up by clear-thinking women. 
 The effort of thinking up a new way to tackle a dragon, a beloved dragon, daunted her for a minute. 
 Her doubts came back. 
 She allowed her steady gaze to flicker from the glass which she had been holding firm. 
 Immediately and frighteningly she could feel Fenna's will power. 
 She honestly could not hold him off alone. 
 Then her eyes fell briefly on the painting her grandmother had given her. 
 In the picture, St Margaret held her power over her dragon steadily and calmly. 
 She had not killed him, she was leading him away from the open mouth of the cave and towards the distant city. 
 Her holy obstinacy, her sulky refusal to bend her stubborn head to emperors, fathers, lovers, or dragons had proved strong enough to conquer even the need to kill. 
 Inspired, Maggie called on St Margaret for aid. 
 St Margaret had passed several dreary centuries in heaven; people very seldom sought her intercession nowadays, and then it tended to be superstitious old women with sentimental requests. 
 Since the Second Vatican Council she had even been removed from the Universal Canon, by ignorant prelates who &mdash; full of their scientific and rationalist approach to the institutions of sanctity &mdash; insisted she had never existed. 
 Since the beginning of the modernist theological era, she had not even had the once-yearly chore of taking her urn and collecting up the incense and imprecations put up, however formalistically, for her own feast day. 
 In the middle ages Margaret had had a wonderful time; women had understood then that it was not to other mothers that you turn in childbirth, it is to those women who have lived it, who have been down between the dragon's teeth, have travelled the dragons' pathways and have lurked in the dark and boiling belly of pain, have been chewed and digested and emerged. 
 It is free virgins whom women need in childbirth. 
 She had been busy and useful day and night. 
 But nowadays they call on new and brasher saints, whom St Margaret had not even met &mdash; Saints Epidura and Psychoprophilaxia. 
 So St Margaret had sat in her empty court feeling neglected for decades. 
 Now she heard Maggie's intercession with delight. 
 Another tangled virgin called on her for help against a dragon, called on her though she had thought that her time was past and the dragons had all departed. 
 With a smile so radiant that the light in heaven itself sparkled, she leapt into action. 
 And, down below, laid out there on her bed, Maggie felt the full strength and joy of a bored woman given something useful to do flowing through to her. 
 St Margaret held the dragon's will by the power of her own legend. 
 Fenna knew both fear and respect. 
 The old passionate story had come between him and Maggie, and he trembled and retreated. 
 Poised between Maggie and Fenna, St Margaret took her stand. 
 She plucked a great hank of silk thread from the girdle of her spinsterhood; tied one end of it to the wedding ring of her virginity and, looping the two ends of the hank over either wrist, spread her hands and invited Maggie to take the other end and wind a neat ball. 
 Maggie, who had never learned such useful arts from either of the women who had brought her up, had to be shown what was required, but soon the smooth rhythm of one woman winding and the other co-operating by swinging her hands in and out as the thread unwound, pleased and comforted her. 
 Soon Maggie held a golden ball of thread and St Margaret had one end of it firmly attached to her finger. 
 Freed, thus, from the weight of the dragon's will, and safely assured of being able to get home again Maggie turned her mind to her own task and went travelling down into the labyrinth of memory and desire. 
 Just as Maggie could not remember a time before there was Fenna, and a time before there was the big house and the three women living in it, so she could not remember a time when there was not the constant tug of tension between her grandmother and her mother. 
 She could remember though the time when she realised that she must, for love of them both, never let them know that she was aware of it. 
 It was that night that Fenna had taught her to fly. 
 She had been eight. 
 She had already known, half consciously, that she liked her grandmother better than she liked her mother, and loved her mother more fiercely than she loved her grandmother. 
 Rachel always had been safer, Rachel's adoration was guaranteed, secure and clear. 
 When Maggie had hugged Rachel as a child, her small arms stretching wide to reach round her bum, Maggie had been able to feel the solidness of her, the deep-grounded certainty that Rachel exuded. 
 When Rachel looked at someone, she saw what was there to see. 
 No one else could look at things the straightforward way that Rachel looked at things. 
 Maggie trusted that, trusted the clear steadiness, the certainty that Rachel would do what she said; and what she had said, and went on saying quietly, calmly, efficiently, was that she loved Maggie. 
 She paid attention. 
 At eight Maggie had not known that her grandmother was famous, but she had seen that people had something in their manner when they looked at Rachel; later she learned that something was respect. 
 Rachel deserved respect. 
 If there were games to be played or work to be done or stories to be read it was always to Rachel that she would turn; Rachel who went out and came in when she said she would and said &bquo;yes&equo; or &bquo;no&equo;, not from whim or temper, but with authority. 
 Rachel was as safe as a rock. 
 Phoebe was different. 
 Maggie could not depend on Phoebe and knew that she would not. 
 But it was Phoebe that she wanted. 
 Phoebe was unreasonable and distant and dangerous. 
 Phoebe had too short a fuse, and it was impossible to guess how she would be, each meeting had to be gauged with care, and it had always been so. 
 She could not be certain that Phoebe wanted her and needed her. 
 Maggie knew all about Phoebe's restless unhappiness, her discontent. 
 She did not know if she herself were a part, a cause of it. 
 She wanted Phoebe to concentrate on her. 
 She wanted Phoebe's long bold stare, so different from Rachel's serene regard - more dangerous, more challenging. 
 She wanted Phoebe to feel passionate about her. 
 She needed Rachel to stay alive, but she needed Phoebe to be alive. 
 She knew the tension that existed between Rachel and Phoebe. 
 She could sometimes experience it as a physical thing &mdash; a slender cord strung between the two of them, as though they each held one end, and she, she had to balance on that tight rope, poised and tricky. 
 She had to perform for them with the spotlight on her and she knew that no trick would be good enough. 
 If she danced without a safety net Rachel would find her foolish, and if she refused to attempt a wild and abandoned triple somersault with twirls and flourishes, Phoebe would not notice. 
 It was easier really to learn to fly. 
 That day when she was eight she had disappeared, or as Rachel tried patiently to call it, wandered off. 
 They told her over and over again that she must not do it, but she couldn't help it. 
 Usually she could not remember why she had wandered off. 
 Neither of them seemed to realise that she never planned it. 
 Just somehow, somewhere between the sweet shop and her house, between home and school, between tea-time and bath-time, she would lose concentration. 
 Something would attract her &mdash; a cloud, a flower, a fat lady on the street- and she would drift away from the track unthinkingly. 
 She knew that her grown-ups were frightened and she did not want them to be frightened, but she also knew that Fenna was a mightier protection than all their loving care could ever be. 
 She could walk safely in the forest of city streets and that no harm could touch her. 
 She would just wander off; and then later she would come to, wondering where she was and remembering that they would be angry with her again. 
 That day she had wandered off between leaving her mother's kitchen and arriving in her grandmother's sitting-room. 
 She was supposed to do this, unless it was raining, by going out the front door and down the area steps, rather than through her grandmother's bedroom. 
 There seemed hardly time for anyone to wander off, but wander she had, and she had come to swinging happily on a swing in the park playground. 
 As soon as she realised what had happened she had jumped down guiltily and run home. 
 There was only one big road to cross, but it had a zebra crossing and she had been road-safe at Phoebe's insistence for years. 
 But she was scared of their anger &mdash; not their anger with her, but with each other, so she ran. 
 Arriving, she saw that the front door was still open: perhaps she had not been gone long, perhaps they had not yet missed her. 
 She skipped up the steps and into the house. 
 She could not have failed to hear them. 
 Rachel was saying, &bquo;It's not naughtiness. 
 I agree she has to learn, I agree she can't go on like this, but it isn't naughtiness. 
 She's&hellip; 
 I don't know, can't you see?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Mummy,&equo; Phoebe sounded rough, cross. 
 Maggie was too young to hear that as anxiety. 
 &bquo;For God's sake, you know that isn't the point. 
 The point is that you muddle her, you muddle her up. 
 I'm not surprised she has to get out sometimes. 
 I'm not bloody surprised. 
 I wish I could.&equo; 
 There was a pause. 
 The grown-ups were above her in the stairwell. 
 They were in neither half of the house, but in a space that did not really exist for Maggie, who never asked herself which half the house was whose, since the whole house was, for her, theirs. 
 She could sense that Rachel was being careful; after the pause Rachel said, very calmly and reasonably: 
 &bquo;Are you sure it's me that muddles her? 
 I think it's partly you. 
 You stand against everything I tell her, obstinately and in her hearing, you give me no support, but as soon as it's convenient to you, you pack her off back downstairs.&equo; 
 &bquo;She's my child.&equo; 
 &bquo;I never contest that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, you do.&equo; 
 Maggie, down below, knew that Rachel had bitten her tongue before she had snapped out &bquo;Oh no I don't&equo;. 
 Rachel was horribly sensible if you tried to fight with her. 
 She was so horribly sensible that it could drive you, as Maggie knew it was now driving Phoebe, into complete tantrums and screaming, because Rachel would not share that part of the argument. 
 It was not fair. 
 She could feel her mother s irritation rise to balance the calmness that her grandmother threw over the fight. 
 &bquo;I can't cope with all this any more,&equo; said Phoebe, and there was a screech in her voice. 
 &bquo;If we have any more of this nonsense, we're going to have to move. 
 I shall take her away; I shall take her abroad and that's final.&equo; 
 Maggie knew, even as she heard it, that Phoebe did not mean anything of the sort; it was the kind of thing that Rachel dragged you into saying. 
 Then Maggie heard what she did not want to hear; she heard Rachel, who was always so controlled, so strong, so clear, she heard Rachel whimpering, begging, 
 &bquo;No, Phoebe please. 
 Please. 
 Perhaps you're right, perhaps I do interfere. 
 I'll try. 
 I'll try.&equo; 
 She heard her Phoebe sounding ugly and fierce. 
 &bquo;You'd bloody better.&equo; 
 And Maggie whisked herself down the stairs, out of the house and fifty yards along the street. 
 She approached her home again, and entered noisily and tearfully. 
 She took the punishments meted out to her without a murmur. 
 Then, curled up in bed that night, she told Fenna that she must not do it anymore, she must not wander off, he must not let her. 
 She must never ever do anything that might make them fight. 
 She had to be careful and clever. 
 So Fenna taught her how to fly. 
 She would never forget the first time, balanced high on the steep roof of the house, huddled from the wind against the chimney-stack, Fenna's great shadow hovering over her, although Fenna had surely not been so hugely vast then as he was now, his shadow had not obliterated the stars, threatening their very existence. 
 She had been joyful and terrified and Fenna had urged her to trust him. 
 &bquo;Trust, leap, jump, trust,&equo; he had commanded her. 
 And she had leapt. 
 Caught in an eddy of storm, she had feared herself falling; and then between her and the ground below there had been a stillness. 
 She had found herself in the safe nook between Fenna's sail-like wing and the crenellated and fantastic fortress of his spine. 
 But she was not resting in the hollow, she was floating in it. 
 She was flying, just within the still pocket of air, but enough to know that she had the power. 
 Fenna's mightier flying, inside which she had her little flight, lifted her up, higher and higher. 
 Then poised above the shining city, among the burning stars, Fenna had paused, dropped one great wing, tilted over, tipped her away from his side and she had flown free. 
 They had danced on the night winds through the dark hours and before dawn she had flown safely home, filled with a new and fierce joy which was the warmth of Fenna's fiery breath and the width and grace of freedom from gravity. 
 It was also another burden of secrecy. 
 When she had been a tiny child, and Fenna had still been a small, manageable and undemanding dragon she had, often spoken of him, to her mother who had grinned, to her grandmother who had smiled, and to her schoolteachers and friends, who had laughed indulgently. 
 But as she and he both grew, people smiled less often and Fenna himself began to insist on secrecy and darkness. 
 A child who was not allowed to wander off to the park, would certainly not be allowed to fly off to the planets. 
 But by keeping him secret she had given him too much power. 
 Now here, lying on her bed while St Margaret held his dragon power in check, Maggie knew she had indulged Fenna too long, that she had fed him and petted him into overweening size and pride. 
 Now he even dared to challenge his maker. 
 His maker, she repeated to herself firmly; she was his maker, and he had no existence without her, without her consent and her will and her passion. 
 But although she said it she could not be certain that it was true. 
 She could not be certain that she wanted it to be true. 
 For he had given her gifts beyond dreaming. 
 Fenna had given her freedom and power and joy; she would not call those things illusions, because without them there was nothing worth having in her life. 
 She did not know if she could live without him. 
 What could be the point of life without that great sweeping tail that could scatter the stars across the sky, without the dark rumbling tenderness when they slept together after their soaring adventures. 
 Could she live without magic and intimacy? 
 But she would have those things for ever; she would have them in her head, in her memories and her dreams, and no one could take that away from her. 
 It was time to put away childish things. 
 She must remember them, but not brood on them. 
 She must move forward. 
 She must look at two other things, hard and solid, so that she would be strong for the battle ahead. 
 It was getting harder and harder to pretend to be ordinary. 
 When she had been little it had been easy, and now it was not. 
 When she had been little, temporary lapses and been easily passed over. 
 Her early school reports were peppered with comments, complimentary or judgemental, depending on the teacher: &bquo;Margaret has a very active imagination&equo;, &bquo;Margaret must learn not to go off into day-dreams&equo;, &bquo;Margaret does not yet seem to have learned the difference between fact and fiction&equo;. 
 But while these were unfortunate, and inclined to make Rachel crumple up her forehead and lecture her on the scientific method and the importance of mental clarity, there was no real danger in such remarks. 
 They were just little signs warning her that she had failed to keep Fenna the perfect secret that he had to be. 
 When she had been little, once Fenna had taught her how to fly so that she no longer went wandering off, there had been very little time when she had been left alone. 
 The night-time, the time after she had been tucked up in bed, that was the proper time for Fenna, for flying and dreams. 
 When she had become a teenager however, she had more time alone, and when she was alone it was so much harder to remember. 
 She flew more and more, like this last evening. 
 It had not been fully dark when she had been flying. 
 It had certainly been risky, landing in the tree round the corner. 
 She had been lucky so far; she had not yet been caught, not yet been dragged off to some shrink and asked for explanations. 
 She was even lucky in a way that her mother never paid any real attention. 
 If they found out&hellip; if they found out, Phoebe and Rachel would tear each other apart, and her with them; it they found out, Fenna would be lethally furious. 
 It was too dangerous. 
 It had to stop. 
 The more she flew, the more irresistible it was; like a drug, an addiction. 
 She knew she was doing it more and more, taking more and more risks. 
 Sometimes it was as though the risk and the pleasure had grown together, nourishing each other. 
 But&hellip; at school less than a month ago she had lost her temper with her maths teacher. 
 She hated her maths teacher anyway, and that dislike was fuelled by Phoebe's frequently repeated conviction that the woman was a moron and taught not mathematics but &bquo;sums&equo;, a subject apparently lower on Phoebe's scale of values than home economics and office skills: 
 &bquo;You've got a bloody calculator,&equo; Phoebe would yell, &bquo;she ought to be teaching you to think.&equo; 
 The maths teacher hated Maggie too, because one Parents' Evening Phoebe had turned up in overalls and working boots. 
 She did not look like anyone else's mother. 
 Everyone else's mother came in neat and respectful skirts, and were accompanied by neat and respectful fathers who sought wisdom and understanding from the teachers. 
 Not Phoebe. 
 Maggie thought Phoebe did it deliberately; Phoebe was normally rather well-dressed in a casual sort of way, and had the best fitting proper designer jeans and lovely hand-knitted posh jumpers; she had plenty of skirts and frequently wore them. 
 But she had to turn up at Maggie's school in her working clothes. 
 When Maggie tried to tell Phoebe about her gruelling embarrassment Phoebe just laughed and told her she was turning into a bourgeois little creep and should perhaps be taking domestic science and dress-making. 
 &bquo;It's called Textiles nowadays,&equo; muttered Maggie furiously, knowing that this was irrelevant. 
 Maggie knew that many of her school-friends admired Phoebe; they thought she was rather splendid, especially since they had all got into ecology, but this did not help Maggie. 
 It was not enough that Phoebe should turn up looking like a manual worker &mdash; ('But, for God's sake, Maggie, I am  a manual worker') &mdash; and wearing a button on her overalls which said &bquo;This facility is under threat from rate-capping,&equo; which made boys on buses make obscene jokes; she also had to take on the maths teacher. 
 The maths teacher had been, Maggie knew, contemptuous and rude and sexist, but Maggie felt that Phoebe should have put up with it for her sake. 
 Phoebe was selfish. 
 She certainly did not, in the vast school hall, in front of two hundred other parents, in a very loud voice, need  to tell the maths teacher that she was a moron and incompetent to boot. 
 She did not need, while wearing boots with the mud still on them, to give the teacher an advanced lesson in maths. 
 At the top of her voice. 
 Nor to tell her that it was women like her who prevented girls doing well in sciences. 
 Nor that the reason she had sent Maggie to an all-girls' school was not to protect her from evil-minded youths, but to protect her from the sort of teaching that she seemed to be getting. 
 Maggie had wanted to die. 
 At the same time she had fiercely wanted to be proud of Phoebe, to support Phoebe's admirable fight on her behalf. 
 She had felt trapped by the old mesh of loyalty and shame. 
 Phoebe, in fairness, could not have known that the maths teacher, shamed in public, should take to hating Maggie with a spiteful glee, though she would probably not have cared if she had. 
 Maggie had dealt with that as best she could, taking it quietly and never complaining about the minor injustices which a teacher can inflict &mdash; work returned because of untidiness, petty sarcasms, rigorous enforcement of minor school rules. 
 Then, one day, she had lost her temper, completely, suddenly and, even to herself, shockingly. 
 Maggie had been amazed at her own fury, rocked by the power of Fenna within her, breaking through the cool disdain she tried always to preserve in front of this loathsome woman. 
 Twenty minutes later she found herself inside the Head's office, white and trembling, so obviously terrified that the Head herself was taken aback. 
 Maggie knew the source of her own fear: in her anger she had so nearly, so very nearly, launched herself into the air, growling a dragon's fury, sparks flying not from her eyes but from her mouth, raining blows from above, hovering over the teacher like St Michael over the devil. 
 And if she had&hellip; 
 If she had, all hell would have broken loose. 
 Fenna would never have forgiven her. 
 Fenna would have killed her. 
 She would have been locked up in a mental hospital, or alternatively taken off for parapsychological testing and Rachel would have been unforgiving. 
 Rachel believed that mechanistic science could explain all phenomena, even those of the heart and soul; Rachel would never have forgiven her, the last place of safety and affection would have been taken away. 
 Fenna had become too powerful. 
 Maggie did not want to be a crazy person. 
 She wanted now, at any price, to be able to sit in the rooms of young women who could be her friends and not feel that she was travelling in territory stranger than the night caves that were Fenna's home. 
 She wanted life to be like it had been earlier that evening. 
 She wanted to be able to sit there and be like them, to sit there and sip Coke and not to have to worry about whether she would laugh at the right moments. 
 She just wanted to be free of the burden of her own special powers. 
 What was appropriate and necessary at eight, was inappropriate and dangerous at fifteen. 
 She was stuck. 
 Stuck in too many ways. 
 As she lay there on her bed Maggie suddenly raised her arms, breaking the iconic cruciform of her pose, and ran her hands over her naked chest. 
 She was fifteen. 
 She knew that she should have breasts, that she should be menstruating; that, judging from the giggled conversations of her friends, she should have at least wanted to find out about love and sex. 
 One more guilty secret that Maggie felt obliged to keep from everyone was the deep fear and disgust that she felt at the thought of sexuality. 
 That was Fenna. 
 Fenna did not want her to menstruate, Fenna would not allow her to desire. 
 She was not just Fenna's friend and child, his daughter of delight. 
 She was also Fenna's hoard; and Fenna had kept from her until too late the awful, consuming greed and jealousy that, from before the dawn of time, all dragons have had about their hoards. 
 Dragons can lie for dark centuries brooding over their treasures, bedding down on frozen flames that will never see the light of day. 
 Dragons love virgins, but they hate the creamy smell of female desire that will bring the young men to their caves, to steal and kill. 
 Princes on white chargers are like bloodhounds, over mountain ranges and mighty oceans they can scent the whiff of virginal longing and are drawn to it like wasps to jam jars. 
 The wise dragon so captivates his maiden that she never even has a second for longing, that she turns not from him to stare out across the wide meadows and lakes of adolescence. 
 Now at last Maggie had realised that something had gone wrong. 
 The power of flight, the companionship of joy and dream had been bought at too high a price. 
 Fenna did not want her to bleed, and because Fenna did not want it, she had not wanted it either. 
 Taught by Fenna's crafty and ancient wisdom she had learned well the deft turns of deceit. 
 It was easier for her than for many, for she had always lived in two kitchens, under the different and Indifferent ministrations of two cooks. 
 She knew she ought to be furious that her mother had apparently not noticed that she did not bleed, that she did not eat, but until recently she had always been grateful. 
 Now she felt that she could have used Phoebe in her struggle with Fenna. 
 Phoebe lived in a totally other world, a world she could not even begin to penetrate, a calm world of profound indifference, which is not the world that Maggie lived in, nor the one she wanted to live in. 
 Often she was afraid that when she sent Fenna away she would become like her mother, that there would be nothing, nothing left. 
 She had realised from when she was a tiny child that Phoebe did not love her as she loved Phoebe, and as other mothers loved their lovely daughters. 
 Loved by Fenna and by Rachel it had never occurred to her to consider herself unlovable, but now she needed a counter-weight in the real world, and her mother would never be that for her. 
 Her mother would not come into the arena with her, strip naked for combat, risk her life and her neutrality for Maggie, and Maggie recognised that tonight with a new sadness. 
 She knew that if Phoebe needed her, if she could even imagine that Phoebe might ever need her, she would have no problem, no problem at all, dealing with Fenna. 
 That evening, as her mother had stood at the kitchen door with the shadow of future old age lurking behind her, she had felt for the first time what it was to be a grown-up, what it was that she was missing in the never-never land of Fenna's spell. 
 But Phoebe had not wanted her there, had not wanted her love and concern and caring. 
 She had to face the fact that Phoebe was not, not then and not at any time, going to pull Maggie out from the night-time and into the daylight of loving and needing. 
 Phoebe was not going to devour her in love and thus keep her safe from the great fangs and wraths of Fenna. 
 Who, then? 
 There was her grandmother, solid and real, who could offer her stories nearly as miraculous as those that Fenna told her and which would have the miraculous ponderousness of fact. 
 If she took her problem to Rachel, Rachel would listen and she would be on Maggie's side. 
 She would be willing to try, but Rachel was not able to understand about Fenna. 
 Rachel hated Fenna. 
 She walked too firmly in the world of the day, of science. 
 No one, not even Fenna, could actually stand up against Rachel when she had once got the bit between her teeth: she was better at the game of controlling, containing, winning, than anyone else that Maggie knew. 
 She was very strong. 
 But Rachel stood against the powers of myth and imagination. 
 That, Maggie knew, was why Rachel was so unhappy now. 
 Maggie had known, for months, that something was wrong with Rachel. 
 When she looked at her grandmother with the sharp eyes that Fenna could lend her, she would see that solid outline waver, dissolve, crumble. 
 At first she had thought with a shock of fear that it was old age, that old age was like silicon, water-soluble, it flowed into you and as you dried out, it hardened, recasting you in blurred shapes and muted tones. 
 But now&equo; she thought that it was not that, but something worse; Rachel, who had always known things, did not know them properly any more. 
 Rachel was in trouble deeper than her own; Rachel needed her help this time. 
 She could not ask Rachel to help her. 
 There was only herself. 
 This battle must be fought by herself alone, and if she lost, she would lose alone. 
 Then, almost magically, as she realised this, something stirred inside her and that something was excitement and courage. 
 The same glorious sensation as she had felt that instant when, poised on the highest diving-board, she had known that this time she really did dare, that moment of poise and thrill before the free-fall. 
 She clenched her fists, spread eagled her arms and legs and called, exultantly, to St Margaret that she was ready. 
 And St Margaret, her cheeks glowing with the realisation of her strength, the knowledge that she indeed held the great dragon at bay while this new young warrior prepared herself for combat, felt a moment of disappointment, anticipating a return to the boredom of heaven. 
 She almost offered herself for the fight, the surrogate, the already-victorious. 
 But she looked down through the glass skylight and recognised in Maggie's cropped hair and long white body the same contours that she had seen in that other virgin warrior whom she had inspired into battle. 
 This was a new Joan: another of these modern women with their new language and new dreams who could follow where she had led, if she were generous enough to let them fight their own battles. 
 So she removed her right hand from the glass skylight and placed it instead over her left finger with the ring and the thread. 
 Then she withdrew her will from Fenna, leaving the dragon free to go or come as he would. 
 Fenna came. 
 Maggie had braced herself against Fenna's wrath, but dragons are deeply wily, they are tempters used to souls far more subtle than any fifteen-year-old child can be. 
 They have lent forms and skills even to the great serpent who beguiled Eve, who swallowed Jonah and who wrestled in the wilderness with the young man from Nazareth. 
 Fenna did not come wrathful now, Fenna came sweet. 
 Came again as the little dragon of her infancy. 
 He slipped through the skylight and sat at her feet, small like a baby, sweet like a beloved puppy. 
 He sat and looked at her, and licked her toes with such a gathered pure tenderness, such a chuckled tickliness, that it was heartbreaking. 
 Fenna came offering now only love, huge steady love and joy and that seemed the hardest thing to resist. 
 And then there was a harder one. 
 Fenna came sad. 
 Fenna shows those great scaled flanks, untouched for centuries, uncaressed, unloved. 
 Dragons dry out easily, their scales turning dusty and arid. 
 The great Dust Bowl which Maggie has seen only from the air, was once the long flank, the turning of the armpit of a dragon greater than Fenna, the great dragon laid out across the world its tail cooled by the oceans of the Antarctic and its breath, no longer fire, turned to ice around its head in the most northerly places of the globe. 
 Fenna cried out to Maggie, &bquo;Need, need, want. 
 They have told you lies. 
 There is no evil, there is only dragon.&equo; 
 Fenna said, &bquo;I need you.&equo; 
 Fenna came full of love and sorrow and joy. 
 Maggie was too surprised, too taken aback to resist him. 
 Like all the maidens, in all the stories, half seduced and half petrified, she consented to Fenna's plans and he swept her high on his great wings and bore her away over the roofs of London and higher and higher cavorting and caracolling through the star-spun night. 
 Now, as from the times of childhood, she rode Fenna, seated in the deep hollow of the meeting place of scaled neck, veined wing and rising battlement of spine; a throne protected from the great gale of his flight, as safe as the rocky cradle secures the foetal child, leaning back towards the bumpy spine as she had leant before, she gave herself over to their journey. 
 Now the Thames was a thread of silver below them, and Fenna flew as he had never flown before. 
 The Mediterranean was a bowl of dark green glittered with lights too tiny to count. 
 They were sweeping over the ancient continent of Africa, the everlasting wastelands of the desert no more than a patch on a great patchwork quilt. 
 Fenna dived low over southern Africa, where his shadow presence in the night would simply meet with old dreams and young magic, and he plunged into the dancing spume of Mosi oa Tunya , &bquo;the smoke that thunders&equo;, now called the Victoria Falls. 
 Their deafening boom tossed up lunar rainbows; and Fenna gave them to Maggie for playthings and they dissolved in dark brightness between her fingers. 
 The huge clean moon stood at her right hand, lemon-yellow and patterned with shadow. 
 Before her marvelled eyes the Southern Cross lifted itself off the horizon and hung glowing, silent and fierce. 
 Now they were too high to see the great waves of the southern Atlantic carry the whales on their singing pilgrimages. 
 Two hundred miles from land the fierce Amazon river stained the dark water darker, red with the silt it carries down from the secret jungles and mountains of the New World. 
 The Andes, serried like dragons' teeth, sparkled as the sun rose behind them, chasing them eastwards across a peach-coloured ocean dotted with green islands. 
 Now Fenna rose, higher and higher, and, holding all his power for one sharp second of perfect concentration, revealed to Maggie the crazy onrushing of the galaxy where everything spins through space so fast that the observer is locked in stillness. 
 For one blinding moment she knew absolutely that Galileo should have died for his truth, and yet had also been right to retract because he had still not known one particle of the whole. 
 For, as the speed of light rushed down upon her, she heard, in the untimeable pause between the upbeat of Fenna's wings and their down swoop, she heard the singing of the spheres, the harmony of the universe which turns, turns, turns in the atom and in the infinite and is unmoved in its own movement and is all one single force. 
 Now, in the dream influence of the moon, Fenna told Maggie to look down on all the kingdoms of the world, and across China she saw the snaking of the Great Wall. 
 On the southern side she saw the mandarin silks of the beginnings of civilisation and the huge courage of the Long March; and on the other, to the north, the eternal silence of the greatest desolation. 
 She looked on north, north, north, through desert and tundra, to the unbroken cruel peace of the polar seas. 
 And Fenna awaited her thanks for a journey so beautiful and so unique, the gifts that only he could offer her. 
 Maggie was ready to give him the glory, to return to him and stay with him forever. 
 Then she heard, barely a distant whisper, but clearly, her mother's voice telling her that the Great Wall of China is the only human-made object that can be identified from the surface of the moon. 
 She heard her grandmother informing her that out there, in that Mongolian vastness, was &bquo;The Dragon's Tomb&equo; where her own great-grandfather had gone to find the dinosaur eggs. 
 Empowered by their voices, she drew a deep breath and, scarcely audible in that vast space where they were floating, she said, &bquo;Fenna, it's over, go away.&equo; 
 Fenna laughed, an ancient laugh, a sweet summer thunder laugh that echoed off the dancing planets. 
 When he had done laughing, he told her, 
 &bquo;I do not believe you.&equo; 
 He told her that she would not be able to let go of him, that his power was deep, deep in her bones and she was bound to him for ever. 
 &bquo;Fenna,&equo; she told him, &bquo;please. 
 I know I cannot go unless you let me, please let me go. 
 I love you. 
 But it is too much. 
 Let me go.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; roared Fenna. 
 &bquo;No. 
 No. 
 No.&equo; 
 And now the anger Maggie had feared was loosed. 
 The great flames poured from his mouth, rivers of fire across the cold darkness of space. 
 The comets that streaked the skies and scared the ancients were powered by Fenna's breath. 
 The meteors that burned out the dinosaurs two hundred million years ago were the gouts of flame and phlegm from Fenna's nostrils. 
 His flailing tail swept down a third of the stars of heaven and cast them on the earth. 
 The great City of Babylon was fallen, fallen before his fury. 
 The lost island of Atlantis was swallowed up in his wrath. 
 The roots of the World Tree were shaken by his writhings, and the old Gods stirred and marched out to Ragnarok. 
 In the epicentre of the maelstrom, with the moon at her feet and crowned with the stars was Maggie, surprisingly unmoved. 
 &bquo;Fenna,&equo; she told him sternly, &bquo;I can out-tantrum you. 
 You may be a dragon, but I am a child. 
 I am just a little girl, I haven't even started my periods yet and little girls can tantrum louder and then can sulk deeper than anything else in the universe. 
 That is my power and you have strengthened it in me.&equo; 
 In speaking, in making conscious the secret hidden power of little girls, Maggie became a woman. 
 Fenna wanted nothing from the woman. 
 It was the child he had desired. 
 Fenna loved Maggie, and knowing that all was lost and love had departed, that she had betrayed their long friendship, that she had asserted herself over his mastery, he howled and, dropping his shoulder, hurled her out of her safe nest and into the immensity of space. 
 She fell. 
 She fell. 
 She fell as Lucifer, the ancient dragon, had fallen first, long long ago before the creation of the world. 
 The ancient race memory of that fall stirred in Fenna's marrow and he was appalled. 
 He was broken with compassion as he watched her crashing like a falling star, pulled by gravity and centripetal forces towards the consummation of the sun and in a moment of weakness he relaxed his will. 
 There was space then for her free-fall to be guided, even as Lucifer's had been guided, across the vast vacuity, down to a home prepared for him by his enemy. 
 Now Maggie learned that falling and flying were different and the difference was fear. 
 In the naked fear of falling in a space so huge that she did not know whether she was falling up or down, inward or outward, she met a fear so great that it burned away forever all the other fears. 
 The fears of sex, of adulthood, of life; the fears that Rachel and Phoebe would tear her apart, the fears that they would not; the fears of love and hatred. 
 She would never be frightened of them ever again, 
 All her little fears were burned away in the great fear, the fear of ceasing to be, of falling falling falling and never landing. 
 Knowing that fear, she abandoned all pride and she called into the darkness for someone to come and rescue her. 
 She called on her mother to leave the little green park, leave neutrality and passivity, and come to her aid; she called on her grandmother to leave the grand study, to leave scientific fact and come out here and save her. 
 She called to St Margaret and St Joan and to all the women who have fought the burning and conquered the dragon. 
 She called to Hermione and Joanna and all the girls who had gone already along the paths she had rejected, called to them to wait for her and place their steady walking boots on solid earth to catch her. 
 And still she fell and fell. 
 Because she has called, they can answer. 
 St Margaret tugged firmly on her thread. 
 Maggie felt it in her hand, frail, attenuated, overstretched, but tautened by the love and knowledge of all the women. 
 It would lead her safely home. 
 She, too, could afford compassion, even as she fell; compassion and wisdom. 
 She cried out suddenly into the enormous silence. 
 She cried, 
 &bquo;Fenna, go to Rachel, go to Rachel!&equo; 
 Rachel is the crone, she knew as she spun downwards. 
 Rachel is the one grown old and weary. 
 Rachel needs, Fenna needs, they need each other. 
 The moon is turning, Now is a new moment. 
 Go to Rachel, the barren one, and fill her with the harvest of fire. 
 &bquo;Fenna, I command you. 
 Go to Rachel.&equo; 
 Then Maggie followed the thread back through the atmosphere barrier. 
 She was blasted by the friction of re-entry, scorched by her wild rush through particles and atoms of welcoming air, hurled through the orbiting phase. 
 She crashed through the glass of her own skylight. 
 In a shower of diamonds, in a dust cloud of shattered stars, in a bee swarm of broken glass, battered and bleeding, she was hurled face downward onto her own mattress and she lay there and screamed with fear and relief. 
 BOOK THREE 
 How much energy and time we wasted in all our endless love tragedies and their complications! 
 But it was also we who taught ourselves and those younger than we that love is not the most important thing in a woman's life. 
 And that if she must choose between love and work, she should never hesitate: it is work, a woman's own creative work, that gives her the only real satisfaction and makes her life worth living. 
 Alexandra Kollontai 
 One 
 Because they were both already awake and on their feet it took neither Phoebe nor Rachel long to reach Maggie's room. 
 Phoebe being younger, fitter, and a storey and a half nearer was first. 
 Barefoot and in a panic, she missed the bottom step of the wrought-iron spiral staircase, stubbing her toe and grazing her right shin. 
 Maggie was still screaming above her and she did not even notice until later that her own blood was added to the devastation of Maggie's attic. 
 Picking herself up, she shouted, 
 &bquo;Coming, darling!&equo; 
 But she did not pause to listen for an answer. 
 Seconds later she shoulder-charged the door, and found herself in an eerie moonlit room where she could distinguish nothing, except the deafening howls which seemed to reverberate off the walls. 
 Disoriented, she could not for an instant even locate her daughter. 
 She groped for the light switch, but could not find it. 
 All those years ago they had thoughtfully placed it unusually low on the wall to make it easy for the child Maggie had then been to reach. 
 It was about the height of Phoebe's thigh and, after a flustered second, she remembered that decision with an instant clarity. 
 The electrician had been very irritated by their insistence. 
 And even while she remembered, she was also scared by the mystery of the moonlight, by the disorientation and, above all by her daughter's screams. 
 They seemed to her unearthly; a new combination of loss, pain and fear: they were howls she would have made herself only half-an-hour before, if she had known how. 
 Then the brighter light of electricity drove out the ghostly moonbeams and she saw only her daughter, her child, flat out on her bed, naked, apparently bedecked in diamonds and rubies, a fierce tattoo of glass and blood. 
 &bquo;Christ!&equo; she said, and the next moment, forgetful of her own safety, she had Maggie in her arms, shushing and soothing as she had never in her life done before. 
 Outside Phoebe's open bedroom door Rachel paused, wondering if her daughter had heard the explosion and responded to it. 
 Then she became aware of the noises of Phoebe's ascent. 
 Despite her anxiety she registered both the relief that Phoebe should have acted so promptly and a tiny flicker of jealousy, which she quickly quashed. 
 She was panting, she realised, and hung for a moment on the newel post of the spiral stairs and waited for her heartbeat to calm down. 
 Maggie's screams died suddenly into moans, and she knew her darling was safe. 
 She even considered a discreet retreat to her own lair, but recognised that she lacked such disinterested nobility. 
 With her hand on the iron banister, she started to pull herself towards the rooftops. 
 The scene that greeted her at the top was already less frightening than it had been when Phoebe arrived. 
 The light was on and Phoebe was sitting on the bed with Maggie's arms wrapped convulsively around her, her scarlet and sparkling body thus partly hidden from her grandmother. 
 Rachel was, though, more able to take in the ruin of the room than Phoebe had been. 
 The great skylight had shattered. 
 All the other windows on both sides of the room had imploded. 
 The great metal roof-tree which held the house together had bent inwards as though from some giant's blow, and listening, Rachel could hear tiles still slithering down the slope and crashing into the street forty feet below. 
 They would have the fire brigade round in a few moments if the external noise had been as loud as the internal one. 
 Rachel even thought of going down to Phoebe's bed room and using her phone to reassure the outside world, and protect themselves from its invasion. 
 But before she could move, Phoebe looked up, saw her and said, 
 &bquo;Mummy.&equo; 
 The appeal was stronger than Phoebe had ever made before. 
 The years reeled back, her old saggy breasts seemed to respond and she crossed the room without realising it, wrapping both her children in the Chinese spread and taking them into her arms like a mediaeval St Anne with Virgin and Child. 
 For a silent moment the three of them sat there. 
 Abruptly the full moon passed across the gaping wound in their roof and no longer shone directly into the room. 
 The neon quality vanished and they were all together as one flesh with three faces. 
 Released from the spell, Rachel took a deep breath and knew her duty. 
 She said, with a rigorous assumption of calm and maturity. 
 &bquo;Whatever is happening here?&equo; 
 Phoebe looked up and smiled with simple gratitude before she said, 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 Maggie, darling, what happened?&equo; 
 Maggie's sobs were becoming more natural, but she still had her arms tight round Phoebe's neck and her head pressed against Phoebe's breast and her voice was muffled. 
 &bquo;I fell. 
 He dropped me and I fell.&equo; 
 The two adults looked at each other. 
 She was shocked? 
 Still dreaming? 
 Phoebe looked to Rachel for help, and Rachel was frightened. 
 Panic, though, would not help, she told herself. 
 &bquo;It's too cold in here,&equo; she said, &bquo;Maggie, darling, do you think you can get up, because even your mother cannot carry you down those stairs, you're too big. 
 And I don't think this room is safe for the moment. 
 Is she badly hurt?&equo; she asked Phoebe. 
 Together they gently uncovered the child and inspected her. 
 There were still splinters of glass gleaming on Maggie's shoulders and high flat breasts. 
 There was a longer gash on her right elbow and a bruise forming at the top of her arm. 
 Both of them noticed with shock how alarmingly thin she was, frail to the point of vanishing. 
 She was shaking all over but seemed miraculously free from serious injury. 
 Rachel offered her her dressing-gown, but Maggie seemed to want to keep the Chinese silk around her. 
 Phoebe lifted her to her feet and they started towards the door. 
 At that moment Rachel heard the electronic siren of a fire engine. 
 &bquo;Maggie,&equo; she said firmly, &bquo;I'm sorry to make you do this but you have to. 
 You have to decide, right now, do you want to go to the hospital or stay here?&equo; 
 &bquo;Stay, please,&equo; said Maggie; now she was on her feet she was returning to them rapidly. 
 &bquo;Please.&equo; 
 Then she added, &bquo;I'm OK, honest.&equo; 
 Rachel and Phoebe exchanged half-smiles. 
 Rachel said, 
 &bquo;Phoebe, I'll go deal with the authorities. 
 They'd probably better check that the whole place isn't falling down and I'm afraid they'll want to see Maggie, but I'll get rid of them. 
 Take her to the kitchen and try and wash some of that glass out.&equo; 
 Phoebe was suddenly grateful for her mother's calm and decision; if anyone could get rid of the London fire brigade it would be Rachel. 
 Suddenly Rachel leant over and kissed Phoebe quite gently on the cheek, and then she turned and led the way downstairs. 
 Maggie did not want to take her arms away from Phoebe, she needed to be held. 
 Phoebe was both gentle and firm. 
 In the light of kitchen she sat Maggie down and started to brush gently at her shoulders, but after a minute or so she said, 
 &bquo;I think the shower would work better; let's go to the bathroom.&equo; 
 She made Maggie kneel down and lean her head over the bathtub, just as she had when Maggie had to have her hair washed as a little child. 
 Under the warm water and the delicate probing of Phoebe's fingers, Maggie relaxed. 
 After a few moments she was saying very natural and quite irritable &bquo;ouches&equo; when Phoebe prodded too hard. 
 They could hear Rachel's commanding voice out on the landing, showing the firemen up to Maggie's room. 
 Quite suddenly Maggie giggled and, imitating Lisa's voice, said, 
 &bquo;Good old dinosaur.&equo; 
 Her release from tension released Phoebe's fears. 
 Suddenly it was she who was shaking and crying, 
 &bquo;Oh Christ, my darling, I thought you were dead. 
 I've never been so frightened in my life.&equo; 
 She wanted to be as mature and sensible as Rachel was, she wanted to be reassuring and maternal and all she could do was cling to Maggie and sob and sob. 
 Now it was Maggie, soaking wet and still oozing blood who turned and took Phoebe in her arms. 
 &bquo;Mummy, Mummy, it's all right. 
 I'm all right. 
 I'm OK.&equo; 
 Cuddling her mother, petting her, she felt almost exultant. 
 The two of them clung together, soggily, hugging closer and closer until Rachel knocked on the door and asked them to come out. 
 Phoebe wrapped Maggie in her towel and called Rachel to come and hold her while she found them both some clothes. 
 The two women passed in the doorway and exchanged glances of pure gratitude. 
 In her room Phoebe pulled on her jeans and a shirt, and snatched up a thick pullover and the bottom half of her track suit for Maggie. 
 Then suddenly she changed her mind and reached into her wardrobe for a new pair of tight stretchy ski trousers that she had hardly worn. 
 Maggie was a very young woman, she thought that if she had to face a gang of young firemen she would be more comfortable in something smart. 
 She was amused at herself for thinking of it, but saw, back in the bathroom, that Maggie appreciated the thought. 
 Rachel, perfectly dignified in her dressing-gown, made the firemen cups of tea. 
 Maggie sat huddled on a kitchen chair and Phoebe held her hand. 
 Under Rachel's serene autocracy the firemen agreed that there was nothing much to be done now, that the house seemed safe enough but they should not use the attic until someone &bquo;from the department&equo; had been and inspected it the next day. 
 And finally Rachel swept them from the kitchen and down the stairs, chatting amiably as she went. 
 Phoebe offered Maggie a cup of hot chocolate, and ten minutes later Rachel returned smiling and quoting, 
 &bquo;They took peculiar pains to souse 
 the pictures up and down the house; 
 until Mathilda's aunt succeeded 
 in showing them they were not needed. 
 And even then she had to pay 
 to get the men to go away.&equo; 
 Both Phoebe and Maggie smiled warmly, remembering the frequent readings from Belloc with which Rachel had edified their childhood. 
 Phoebe made all three of them hot chocolate. 
 Later, Phoebe tucked Maggie into her own bed. 
 She kissed her tenderly, then grinned and said, 
 &bquo;I tell you what, you can take tomorrow off school.&equo; 
 Maggie seemed safe, warm, relaxed, sleepy. 
 Then she opened her eyes and said, 
 &bquo;Mummy, can I have my St Margaret picture?&equo; 
 &bquo;Now?&equo; 
 &bquo;Please.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course you can, sweetie.&equo; 
 She climbed the stairs to get it, crunched her way across the glass-strewn room, feeling a strong rush of her earlier panic, and unhooked the painting from the wall. 
 It was quite small and she could hold it easily between her hands. 
 It had hung in Maggie's bedroom for as long as Phoebe could remember: she had not looked at it properly for years. 
 Now, with it in her hands, she knew absolutely that it was not a worthless Victorian copy, as Rachel had once told her. 
 It was very old. 
 The virgin saint was leading the dragon on a slim gold chain across a field of flowers towards a distant and elaborate city; she had a thin white face and an expression of nonchalance, almost tedium. 
 It was a strong talisman for a little girl, for a young woman. 
 Phoebe smiled, and allowed herself an unusual and agreeable start of gratitude to Rachel, not just for her consistent kindness to Maggie, but also, freshly, for her generosity and understanding towards herself. 
 She found Rachel still in the kitchen, looking old and weary. 
 She was sitting at the table with her chocolate cooling in the mug between her hands. 
 She raised her head when Phoebe came in. 
 She thought how strained and tired her daughter looked. 
 &bquo;Sit down, Phoebe, I'll warm some more milk for you.&equo; 
 Phoebe let her. 
 Outside the sky was turning pale. 
 It was morning. 
 Looking at each other with a new respect, they both wanted to say something to mark the importance of this dawn. 
 They were both too tired. 
 Two 
 Maggie woke up. 
 The pale April sunshine flooded the room, but it was different from usual. 
 She felt the change unconsciously, and with it an unaccustomed warmth. 
 Dozily she felt her arm ache. 
 Then the whole night flooded back into her memory, and she realised her loneliness and desolation. 
 Instinctively she sought through the whole cosmos for Fenna, and knew she would not find him. 
 There was nothing there, except the comfortable warmth. 
 She opened her eyes and was aware of being in her mother's bed, where she had not been for over ten years. 
 Phoebe was still asleep beside her, curled up and with her back close to her daughter's: Maggie enjoyed the moment of comfort, adding it dreamily to the shadow that was also there. 
 She felt strange. 
 She was still wearing Phoebe's trousers and jersey. 
 Perhaps that was why&hellip; surely she had not wetted herself? 
 She reached down with her finger and drew it out covered in blood. 
 A simple adolescent embarrassment flamed her face: she had ruined her mother's new, and pale blue, trousers. 
 She was frightened that Phoebe would respond to this news with excessive enthusiasm, congratulate her, want to celebrate in some humiliating way, even ring her friends and tell them. 
 She sat bolt upright, and there to greet her was St Margaret serenely leading the tamed dragon towards the city. 
 Encouraged, Maggie prodded Phoebe. 
 &bquo;Mummy, I'm bleeding.&equo; 
 Phoebe woke up quickly, as though she had been waiting for Maggie's summons, but not quickly enough. 
 &bquo;More glass, darling?&equo; she enquired without turning over. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; cried Maggie, &bquo;and Mummy, I've messed up your new trousers.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; said Phoebe, who now understood, &bquo;it doesn't matter, they'll wash.&equo; 
 Then, hearing something more distressed in Maggie's voice, she became maternally reassuring. 
 &bquo;It's probably last night, Maggie; a shock can easily change your cycle.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't have a cycle,&equo; said Maggie crossly, feeling that her mother ought to have known. 
 &bquo;This is my first time.&equo; 
 &bquo;Christ!&equo; 
 Phoebe sat up immediately and then, overwhelmed with hangover, tiredness and surprise, flopped down again abruptly. 
 It made them both giggle. 
 For a while they lay there, recouping their dailiness, setting up this soft laughter against the horror of the night, close and easy together. 
 Then, businesslike, they faced the day. 
 Phoebe dealt with Maggie's immediate needs and took her trousers off to soak in the bathroom. 
 &bquo;You'd better put on one of my tracksuits, we're not meant to go up to your room until they've sent someone to inspect it or something,&equo; she called on her way to the kitchen. 
 She slung the milk saucepan casually on top of the other unwashed dishes in the sink, unbothered now by the mess, aware that Rachel had seen it all last night and had said nothing. 
 She put on the kettle, craving her morning cup of coffee. 
 Soon Maggie joined her, and made toast. 
 Still floppy from giggling they were careful to avoid catching each other's eye, but there was warmth and repose enough there to set against the hardness of the day's demands. 
 Rachel woke in her own room, tired- and uncomfortable. 
 She was too old, she told herself, for all these midnight cavortings. 
 She turned herself over in her bed, and snuggled down for an extra, self-indulgent and rare hour of sleep. 
 But her eye caught her bedside alarm clock and she pulled herself properly into wakefulness. 
 All her temptations had dissolved the moment she had heard Maggie say, 
 &bquo;I fell. 
 He dropped me and I fell.&equo; 
 The final quiet half-hour in the kitchen with Phoebe had only made her conscious of what she had then known was now necessary. 
 She did not like what her life demanded of her, but she knew painfully and absolutely that the moment for truth had come. 
 So this last time she wanted to be in her office, correct and professional at the right time. 
 The board meeting was at four o'clock, but she had paperwork to do and she must at least speak to Clare before then. 
 She lumbered out of bed, reached for the too recently removed dressing-gown and took herself off to her bathroom. 
 A little later, neatly dressed in tweed suit and cashmere jersey she climbed the stairs to Phoebe's flat. 
 She had expected to find them both still in bed, and was surprised by the noises from the kitchen, but she poked her head round the door and saw Maggie sitting at the kitchen table eating Weetabix in a reassuringly healthy way. 
 She could sense the goodwill between the two of them, and it encouraged her. 
 She crossed the kitchen and kissed Maggie on the head, 
 &bquo;Are you all right, my darling?&equo; and then, almost surprising herself, she passed on and kissed Phoebe too. 
 &bquo;And you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, thank you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, if everyone is all right, I think I had better go into the office today. 
 I have something very important that I ought to do.&equo; 
 Phoebe was surprised; she had somehow thought that after Rachel's sterling conduct of the night before, she would now take charge, go on looking after them all, manage everything for them and leave her free to walk the road that she had to walk. 
 But in her mother's kiss she had learned something of the importance of whatever it was that Rachel had to do. 
 Her mother so seldom asked her for anything, she realised with a jolt. 
 It was she, Phoebe, herself, who imposed all those expectations upon herself, not her mother. 
 Now in some obscure way Rachel was asking for something, for help, for reassurance, for permission. 
 &bquo;Of course we can manage,&equo; she said and grinning added, &bquo;I'm a big girl now.&equo; 
 Then suddenly that was not enough. 
 She returned her mother's kiss and said, &bquo;Good luck.&equo; 
 Rachel was used to being the tallest woman in a room. 
 She seldom remembered that Phoebe was actually taller than she was. 
 Now she could feel the solid muscle of her daughter's arms and she wanted to lean against her and draw comfort and strength; but she pulled away and looked at Phoebe with that straight, clear, appraising look that was her hallmark. 
 She did not ask any questions. 
 She said goodbye to Maggie and then, just as she was leaving the kitchen, she looked directly at Phoebe and added, 
 &bquo;Good luck yourself.&equo; 
 Then she went down the stairs, collected her satchel and left the house by Phoebe's front door. 
 Phoebe and Maggie had a trying and tiresome morning. 
 The fire brigade reappeared, bringing them some council inspector, who obviously wanted to evacuate the house. 
 They probed and measured and cross-questioned Phoebe in the most condescending manner, made worse by the fact that they clearly did not have a clue as to what might have happened. 
 Phoebe wanted to scream with temper, or indulge in wicked and vicious sarcasm. 
 At the same time she was certain that Maggie did not want to have to cope with that. 
 She bit her lip and kept her peace, and even made them cups of tea with the same grace that her mother had demonstrated in the dark hours of the night. 
 Maggie kept catching her eye with an expression of knowing amusement, but at the same time she obviously hated having these men stomping through her every possession and destroying any remaining magic in her secret chamber. 
 Finally the men gave up, grudgingly admitted that the room was safe, and left muttering about &bquo;freak accidents&equo; and &bquo;acts of God&equo;. 
 They recommended a glazier, a brush and an insurance claim. 
 Phoebe thanked them wearily. 
 She and Maggie brushed the room out as best they could and the glazier arrived with an enormous sheet of polythene for the roof. 
 He set to work steadily on replacing the panes of the side windows. 
 Phoebe went back to the kitchen, heated up some tinned soup and made tuna fish sandwiches. 
 Then she called Maggie. 
 Their shared tiredness was too great; they could not replace the goodwill of the morning. 
 They sat limply messing with the food. 
 But Phoebe knew that she must act. 
 &bquo;Maggie darling, I don't have a clue what happened last night, but I think you do.&equo; 
 Maggie looked unattractively sly, sulky and fearful all at once, but Phoebe doggedly pushed on. 
 &bquo;Darling, I'm not going to ask anything about it, but there is something I have to know. 
 Is the house really safe now?&equo; 
 &bquo;I think so.&equo; 
 Maggie looked away from her mother, &bquo;Yes. 
 The house is quite safe.&equo; 
 Phoebe held her breath. 
 She could feel Maggie's distress; Maggie needed more than to have her care about the house. 
 More, but not too much more. 
 &bquo;And you, darling, are you safe?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes,&equo; said Maggie with such bleak sincerity that Phoebe knew she must go on. 
 She must keep her appointment at the clinic at all possible costs. 
 &bquo;In that case I want to go out this afternoon and do something. 
 Something important.&equo; 
 Maggie only repeated her question of the night before, &bquo;Are you OK, Mummy?&equo; 
 But now, it was a time for truth and Phoebe said, &bquo;No. 
 No, I'm not OK. 
 But I want to be. 
 That's what I'm going out for. 
 &bquo;It's to do with getting better, getting OK.&equo; 
 And Maggie came round the table and standing over Phoebe gave her a long silent hug. 
 Meanwhile Rachel had taken a taxi to the museum; she had entered by the back door and exchanged a smile with the doorkeeper. 
 She crossed the dinosaur gallery, carefully averting her eyes from her own display, unlocked the solid door and arrived in the security and peace of her own office. 
 Deliberately she sat herself down at her desk and examined her post. 
 Carefully she opened the drawer where the two copies of her paper lay and took them out. 
 She started to read and for a moment lost her rigid self-consciousness in admiring delight at her own writing, its clarity and generosity. 
 After a while, though, she pulled herself together and, leaving one copy on her desk, took the other down to the secretarial room and asked if someone could run her off two more copies, ideally before the board meeting. 
 Rachel was popular among the stall, always courteous and concerned and never asking for the impossible except with great charm and self-deprecation. 
 She got an enthusiastic response, &bquo;Of course, Mrs Petherington, I can stay in through my lunch-break if need be. 
 I'll see to it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you so much, I would really appreciate it. 
 I'm just sorry that I didn't give it to you sooner. 
 It was very stupid of me.&equo; 
 She went back to her own office and sat down at her desk again. 
 She put her elbows on the desk and rested her head in her hands. 
 She had seldom felt so old or so tired or so wretched. 
 Then she picked up her internal telephone and, very civilly, asked Clare if she could spare her half an hour or so &mdash; yes, before the meeting; yes, as soon as possible. 
 For the ten minutes before Clare arrived she leaned back and looked around her with a sense almost of satisfaction. 
 She had burned her boats. 
 The interview with Clare was very trying. 
 Clare was at first protective and maternal, then weepy and emotional, and finally, when the implications of what Rachel was doing became clear to her, she was furious. 
 &bquo;You can't. 
 You absolutely cannot do this to me. 
 It was you that taught me to be a Darwinist, a decent gradualist. 
 How many times have I heard you? 
 You can't rat on that and give all those American lunatics &mdash; and I'm quoting you &mdash; this kind of support. 
 You can't.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can,&equo; said Rachel stubbornly. 
 &bquo;No, you can't. 
 I don't mean all this, here,&equo; she jabbed at Rachel's typescript with an irritable finger, her face looked blotchy and plainer than ever, &bquo;this bit about your blasted reconstruction. 
 All that's fine with me; I've known the bloody thing was wrong for ages anyway. 
 We can take it down; we ought to take it down really. 
 But you don't have to rush off to the other extreme. 
 Are you crazy?&equo; 
 &bquo;Clare, read it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I have read it. 
 I don't mean here, this version necessarily, but you're not the only person in the world who keeps up with the wider literature, you know. 
 I read it all the time. 
 And if you really want to know what I think, it's that you Cretaceous people are insanely arrogant. 
 You can't solve one little corner, one little technical hiccup so you'll throw a hundred years of decent work out the window and replace it with sci-fi fantasies. 
 Your time-scale is all wrong. 
 For heaven's sake, Rachel, look at the fossil record as a whole. 
 Not just your little bitsy corner. 
 There's more going on than just the Cretaceous collapse. 
 What about archaeopteryx ? 
 And my therapsids? 
 You don't have to do this.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I'm going to,&equo; said Rachel. 
 She was too exhausted, too weary to argue it out with her now, but she was also excited. 
 Now Clare had abandoned her respectful kindness it would be fun to fight with her. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; she said reasonably, &bquo;you haven't even read the paper properly yet. 
 Take it away and read it, and we'll talk it through if you are still not convinced. 
 But I am convinced and I'm going to tell the board so today. 
 I only wanted to tell you first so you could save yourself this sort of scene in front of them. 
 I owed it to you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you,&equo; snorted Clare in as ungrateful a manner as she could manage, swept her copy contemptuously off the desk, and stalked out of the room with a moderately successful attempt at dignity. 
 Rachel allowed herself a brief smile at such youthfulness. 
 Then she sat down to write a letter to an old friend, the editor of her chosen journal. 
 She pointed out to him the attraction of publishing so surprising a paper and urged him to do it as quickly as possible. 
 It was a charming letter, a well-managed mixture of humility and boastfulness, and she sent it down to be typed with a feeling of smugness. 
 She realised that she still had fifteen minutes before the meeting was due to start and on an impulse she rang Paul. 
 She needed someone to rejoice with her. 
 He was out. 
 She had neither the energy nor the time to feel irritated; instead she took out her pen again and reached for a sheet of the museum's paper. 
 My dear Paul, in ten minutes I am going to tell my board that I have become a convert to Catastrophe Theory. 
 Poor dinosaurs. 
 Now I am in urgent need of a tutor in such matters as the shadow star Nemesis, the irridium level and other such metaphysical absurdities. 
 I hope you are up to the job. 
 Please ring soon. 
 Love, Rachel. 
 &bquo;That'll get him,&equo; she said aloud, and grinned. 
 Contrary to her usual habit, she rang for a motorbike messenger. 
 She put the sheet of paper in an envelope, addressed it clearly, added the word &bquo;Urgent&equo; and carried it down to the office, where she left it for collection and received instead the original and the photostats of her article. 
 Then, quite calmly, she proceeded to her meeting. 
 As soon as she entered the room she knew that Clare had already been telling tales; or at least complaining to her colleagues. 
 What had she said? 
 &bquo;The old bag has gone completely batty.&equo; 
 &bquo;Besotted by that silly queer over at Imperial.&equo; 
 &bquo;How are we going to get her out of here? 
 It's too embarrassing.&equo; 
 Or even, Rachel wondered, &bquo;You've got to say this for the old girl, she does keep on trying.&equo; 
 She could sense the excitement and the nervousness, the sudden lull in the conversation as she entered. 
 She thought someone might ask her questions, but she was saved by the arrival of their director. 
 He was a dour middle-aged man, who feared he was a failure and compensated himself with an excessively professorial beard and a punctiliously formal manner. 
 For nearly two hours he worked his way through his agenda, more administration and finance today than scientific exploration. 
 He was, apparently, completely insensitive to the frisson of curiosity and tension in the younger members of his staff. 
 Rachel relaxed, grateful, and gave her usual careful consideration to the matters before the meeting; calmly ploughing through the minutiae and bureaucratic red tape of museum management, making the sort of useful contributions that she had made at any such meeting in the last twenty years. 
 Finally the Director brought the whole thing to a close; he pulled his papers towards him, preparatory to getting up and said, 
 &bquo;Any other business?&equo; in an off-hand and discouraging tone. 
 But Rachel was not discouraged. 
 &bquo;I have, Henry; I'm going to have to ask for a complete and urgent reorganisation of the dinosaur gallery.&equo; 
 &bquo;Huh?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm afraid so. 
 I have become convinced that our whole approach is hopelessly unscientific, in fact wrong, and particularly that my own reconstruction is so fundamentally flawed that we really don't have the right to be displaying it anywhere except in a Disneyland type of amusement park.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rachel!&equo; 
 &bquo;It is a bit embarrassing, isn't it? 
 I'm sorry, Henry, but I have written a paper, which I'm planning to send to Tom Haines, which more or less says precisely this. 
 Clare has seen it, although she probably hasn't had time to read it fully. 
 And although she seems to disagree with its overall drift, she tells me she's in complete accord with my views on what she called my &bquo;blasted reconstruction&equo;.&equo; 
 Let that be a lesson to you, Clare, she thought, to lose your temper and try me with your emotional immaturity. 
 She was buoyed up suddenly on the wave of amazement and admiration that she could feel enveloping her from across the whole room. 
 She was pleased with herself and her own calm style. 
 She had not thought she had this much spunk left in her. 
 She smiled at them all and added, 
 &bquo;Clare has a copy of the paper now, and I have brought in a couple of extra copies; so perhaps the dinosaur people, at least, might like to have a look at it and see what they think. 
 You'll probably want to talk about it without the embarrassment of having me here to listen. 
 But don't dilly-dally for too long; once it's published we are all going to look a little risible if we have made no adjustments to what is after all known as being predominantly my own design of gallery. 
 Also, I am a bit older than the rest of you, but you can perhaps understand that I don't want to drop dead without a proper and public recantation. 
 Since I'm technically retired I can't say that I'll resign if you disagree with my request &mdash; and particularly that we should remove my reconstruction as quickly as is feasible, but I do feel it that strongly and I shall publish whatever you decide.&equo; 
 Suddenly she wanted to put her head down on the big table and howl with misery. 
 She pushed back her chair and stood up abruptly; she was terrified that she would sway, topple and crash to the ground. 
 And then she heard her mother's voice. 
 Even though she had learned so recently that this was not the authentic voice of her mother, the intellectual knowledge had changed nothing, nothing, and perhaps it never did. 
 Now her mother's voice called to her, telling her to act like a lady. 
 All through her childhood she had resented the voice, had resented her mother. 
 Now she thought &bquo;Mother&equo; deliberately, summoning up from a deep centre the bossy voice which had haunted her and with it a sweet softness, older still and loving. 
 In the strength of that voice she was able to gather up her papers, push them into her satchel, and leave the room with perfect dignity. 
 She made it back to her office and sank into her chair; but after a few minutes she sat up, combed her hair and decided to go home. 
 Just as she was reaching for her jacket the phone rang, and without thinking she answered it. 
 &bquo;Hello.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rachel?&equo; 
 &bquo;Paul.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rachel, what is all this? 
 I get in from a dull lunch and find your urgent communication on my desk. 
 What are you up to?&equo; 
 &bquo;You can read, Paul. 
 I suppose it was Smit and van der Kaars in the end.&equo; 
 And Paul himself and Maggie and Fenna, but she would not try to tell him that. 
 &bquo;I've written a paper; a recantation you might call it. 
 I think Tom Haines will publish it&hellip; he'd be best, don't you think? 
 I mean the whole thing is wrong, the reconstruction, the theory behind it. 
 So I supposed I'd better tell my board about it and I did this afternoon. 
 Clare is out for my blood of course, poor thing, but I couldn't really help that. 
 I thought I'd better get it sorted out before I died.&equo; 
 &bquo;And you just got up in front of Henry and those pipsqueaks in your department and said, &bquo;Sorry and all that, old chaps, but I've been wrong all my life and led you into error and wickedness&equo;?&equo; 
 &bquo;More or less.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rachel, you are amazing. 
 That's the bravest thing I have ever heard of. 
 Can I come round this evening with a bottle of champagne?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, that would be very nice. 
 Thank you. 
 I should warn you, though, we're in a bit of chaos at home. 
 The roof fell in last night.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 Suddenly she could almost hear her mother giggling. 
 She could hear her mother's distant laughter and her voice saying faintly, &bquo;Rachel, do stop showing off.&equo; 
 More immediately she could hear Paul's resounding, 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;The roof, dear. 
 You know what that is. 
 It fell in, caved in rather. 
 Maggie's skylight smashed. 
 But we're all fine.&equo; 
 &bquo;But Rachel, why? 
 I mean why did it cave in or whatever.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well I haven't heard the official report because I had to go to my board meeting, but if you ask me, Maggie's dragon did it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rachel, are you drunk?&equo; 
 There was a pause, and suddenly Paul laughed, &bquo;Have I ever told you, Rachel, that I adore you? 
 You are the most extraordinary and wonderful woman I have ever encountered, and I shall make it a magnum of champagne. 
 I love you.&equo; 
 When she put the phone down she felt fizzy with excitement, but with his smiling voice cut off, the feeling did not last. 
 Instead she felt very, very tired. 
 Then she knew that she needed not to sneak out by the convenient back exit, but to leave through the front entrance, trusting its outrageous, ostentatious vulgarity to reassure and comfort her. 
 And thus it was, that February evening, that she came to be standing at the top of the monumental sweep of the staircase, under the huge doorway, pausing for a moment, offering tribute to herself and all her gods. 
 Meanwhile Phoebe had taken a shower, found some clean knickers, mounted her bicycle and ridden off to her appointment at the clinic. 
 Even as she chained her bike up she noticed three different taxis drawing up and depositing their customers. 
 Hers was the only bicycle attached to these particularly well-painted railings, and her soul cringed. 
 Despite all her resolution, she paused outside the plate-glass doorway and looked around guiltily. 
 The chances of any of her acquaintance passing at this moment and noting that she, Phoebe Petherington, was entering the evil portals of a private hospital, were, she admitted, so small as to be risible, but that did not allay her shame. 
 She slunk covertly through the entrance. 
 Her sense of inadequacy escalated rapidly; not only was the receptionist extremely pretty, she was also immaculately dressed, well-mannered, and had perfectly clean, shell-like little fingernails. 
 She said, &bquo;Can I help you?&equo; as though she meant it. 
 Phoebe, on the other hand, suddenly could not remember what false name she had given when she made the appointment. 
 She stumbled over the words, muttered and blushed, her duplicity and stupidity so abundantly clear to her that she was surprised that the charming young woman did not immediately leap to her feet, denounce her as an impostor and throw her out onto the street again. 
 She almost wished she would. 
 Then the luxury of the place reached out and embraced her. 
 It was the stuff of her darkest fantasies, her most secret longings. 
 Well-manicured hands took her jacket respectfully, offered her a seat, brought her coffee in a china cup with a saucer. 
 She was asked discreet questions about private health insurance and, in the face of her disclaimers, equally civil ones about her credit cards. 
 She was led away into a crisp-looking cell where she was measured and weighed; a careful, polite pair of hands found a vein in her strong arm and removed a vial of her blood. 
 Someone took her blood pressure and remarked on how healthy it was. 
 She could not restrain a flash of pride in her physical fitness; all the nurses were smaller than she was and, although they were prettier, she felt her dignity and certainty returning. 
 She had imagined that the doctor would be male; she had looked forward to it even, a chance to pit herself against him, to resist, to overcome; but when she was finally ushered into the consulting room she was greeted by a woman younger than herself. 
 This shocked her suddenly, shook her back into the real world and changed the entire course of the interview. 
 It was no longer a fantasy, a ritual extension of the dark dreams of her night times, in which the doctor was to play out some version of her lost father, an ally against the demands of the women in her life. 
 This was real; Maggie and Rachel deserved that reality. 
 So sharp was her sense of the rules having changed that she was shocked to see the name Mary Hunter at the top of the card in the doctor's hand. 
 Only simple embarrassment prevented her from correcting it. 
 &bquo;You're a remarkably fit woman, aren't you, Mrs Hunter?&equo; said the smiling doctor. 
 &bquo;What do you do for a living?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm a gardener,&equo; Phoebe said, and felt a simple pride in the fact. 
 This proved stronger than her irritation at the surprise in the young doctor's face. 
 Clearly well-spoken female gardeners were not the usual client&egrave;le of this hospital. 
 They plodded through the whole range of routine questions. 
 Long before they reached the relevant section. 
 Phoebe had decided she was going to lie about the amount she drank. 
 She had not come here for that; it was another problem that she must take on, but not now, not here. 
 Then, as instructed, she removed her clothes and lay out on the couch. 
 Glancing down, her toes seemed miles away, disembodied, belonging to someone else. 
 It was this moment that she had come for. 
 The doctor was rubbing her hands, probably to warm them, but it looked like a gesture of glee and greed. 
 Phoebe hated her with a brief clear flame of anger. 
 This was the avenging angel who would steal her lover away from her. 
 And at the same moment she had the shattering thought that perhaps she had imagined the whole thing. 
 There would be no lump. 
 The doctor would feel her breasts, find nothing, smile and send her off to deal with a new, an incurable bitterness. 
 The doctor, still chatting away, put her stethoscope in her ears and listened to Phoebe's chest and heart, then had her sit up and tapped her back. 
 Phoebe felt the tension prickling her belly as she lay down again. 
 The doctor, whatever her politics and morals, had lovely skilful hands, which Phoebe could not but admire. 
 She made the vaginal examination comfortable and smooth. 
 &bquo;Now breasts,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Do you do your own self-examinations?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sometimes,&equo; muttered Phoebe; she was not going to tell this woman that for the last six months she had done practically nothing else. 
 &bquo;You ought to, you know; I'll show you how afterwards.&equo; 
 Her hands were warm and competent. 
 Phoebe liked the sensation and was terrified. 
 The doctor started with her right breast; circled it tenderly, skilled fingers pushing against the flesh; in some different context, Phoebe thought, it could be very sexy, this slow gentle probing, dispassionate but intimate. 
 The doctor smiled quietly, reached for her pad and made a note; she smiled, walked round the foot of the high couch and came up towards Phoebe left-hand side. 
 Phoebe could feel her own heard beating. 
 The doctor ran her hands round again, with the same disinterested precision. 
 Phoebe knew when she had reached the lump, but the fingers went on circling, and then probing her armpit. 
 Time slowed down, Phoebe wanted this moment to go on for ever, this calm moment before the storm. 
 Eventually the doctor's fingers came back again, back to where the lump was. 
 Phoebe opened her eyes and saw the abstracted professional look in the doctor's face; attentive not to Phoebe but to the lump, to the breast itself. 
 As it should be. 
 And then the doctor caught her eye. 
 She began a reassuring smile and then stopped abruptly. 
 &bquo;You knew, didn't you?&equo; 
 Her eyes widened and she looked angry. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Phoebe, because it was too late now for untruths or pretences. 
 &bquo;You must be insane.&equo; 
 The doctor seemed almost embarrassed by her own outburst, but Phoebe was relieved. 
 It was a clear diagnosis, the same as Tom's. 
 Better that than discretion and gentle kindliness. 
 She did not want to have the news broken to her carefully. 
 &bquo;Go and have the mammogram and then come back and talk to me.&equo; 
 In her fantasies Phoebe had somehow assumed that the mammogram would be visible. 
 One afternoon she had lurked in the medical bookshop at the top of Gower Street and looked at glowing colour plates of carcinomas. 
 She tried to tell herself that she had come here today to be cured, to return to the cold world of normality; but in another part of her mind she had dreamed of this meeting, the apotheosis of the love affair. 
 She would raise her lamp and view the lover that she herself had grown, even if this meant that she must lose him for ever. 
 She had fantasised the meeting: she would be lying naked and on some screen in front of her she would see, pulsing and radiant, her own dark lover and his home place. 
 There would be her breast filled with veins and glands, the source of Maggie's milk and much of her own sexual pleasure, all pink and red and living, and there, in the heart of it, would be &mdash; green and gold and sparkling &mdash; the bright egg of her dreams. 
 However the mammogram room was cold and scientific. 
 There was no doctor, no magic seer to give her the golden branch and lead her into the underworld, only yet another pretty young woman, the radiological technician. 
 Phoebe had to stand on the cold and excessively clean linoleum floor, far away from the fitted carpets and deep leather chairs of the waiting area. 
 The radiologist apologetically but firmly positioned Phoebe in front of a ferocious-looking machine; she took Phoebe's arms and stretched them forward into an awkward position. 
 The tie of the white gown she had been given to wear caught in her hair and pulled it. 
 Phoebe jerked away and the radiologist only just managed to suppress her irritation. 
 They started the ugly dance again. 
 Once she had got Phoebe back where she wanted her, the radiographer manhandled Phoebe's breasts, without interest, between two cold plates. 
 These were clamped together, squashing her breasts flat, pulling at the skin of her underarms. 
 It hurt. 
 It hurt, not unbearably but sharply, and under that pressure the last of Phoebe's passion was squeezed out. 
 Under her bare toes the floor felt real and solid, and although she was lonely and sad she knew she was going to choose to return to the real and solid world. 
 Politeness alone made her go back to see the doctor, and listen to her almost stern advice. 
 This was not Phoebe's place and she knew quite simply that tomorrow morning she would go to see her own GP and organize the necessary hospital visit. 
 Maggie needed her, Rachel needed her, and she had no other choice; passion was not to be part of her calling. 
 The old mistake made in a bathroom in Oxford twenty years before had fixed her course and all she could do was to walk it. 
 Just before leaving the consulting room she knew that she had one thing left to do and it was important. 
 &bquo;There's something else I should tell you,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I gave you a false name. 
 I am really called Phoebe Petherington. 
 That is my name.&equo; 
 She knew the doctor thought she was a lunatic, but as she would never see her again, it did not matter now as much as the truth. 
 She paid her bill to the efficient receptionist and left the hospital. 
 Leaving the clinic she realised suddenly that she wanted to go to her garden. 
 It was an impulse she did not question. 
 She mounted her bike and pedalled eastwards. 
 Halfway there she remembered Maggie and stopped to telephone her. 
 But the first kiosk only took cards, and she did not have one and the next kiosk was broken. 
 She gave up and rode on. 
 This was important. 
 Maggie was safe. 
 But when she reached the vicinity of her garden she was seized with a sudden embarrassment. 
 She had not even phoned them that morning to explain her absence. 
 And she did not want to talk to anyone. 
 Quickly she decided not to go into the garden; instead she would climb the nearby tower block and see her garden from above. 
 And thus it was that she came to be, that February evening, standing at the top of the tower block staircase, leaning against the wall and panting a little from her climb, pausing for a moment and thinking gloomy thoughts about life and death. 
 Meanwhile Maggie stayed sitting at the kitchen table. 
 Slowly and without thinking she ate all the tuna fish and mayonnaise her mother had prepared. 
 She also finished the loaf of bread. 
 Later she dug about in the fridge; and although the result was depressing, she did find and consume two pots of yoghurt, a hunk of cheese and a slice of ham which had begun to curl up at its edges. 
 She felt sick, but was relieved to feel something: the weight of the food in her stomach did something to counteract the sense of unreality that afflicted her. 
 Her brain was foggy and muffled. 
 She might have sat all afternoon, nibbling and stuporous, exhausted but not sleepy; but the glazier finally came down from the upper floor, cheerfully announcing that all was now right and tight and he would be on his way. 
 Maggie could tell that he would have liked to stop for a chat, that he felt sorry for her left on her own, but she lacked either her grandmother's grace or her mother's energy, so she did not offer him tea. 
 When he had gone, she dragged herself up the iron staircase to her own room. 
 &bquo;The room had lost its magic: instead of the great sheet of clear sky overhead there were subdued shadows; the polythene letting in less light than the glass. 
 The whole place smelled of putty and turpentine, and the crash had shaken down not only stars of glass, but also dust and grime. 
 Most of the glass had been removed, but the dirt had not, clouding the air and deadening the surfaces. 
 Her picture and her silk quilt had been carried down below in the chaos of last night and she did not have the energy to seek them out. 
 Phoebe had also, that morning, borne away all her bedding and some of her clothes to shake the glass out of them. 
 The room now looked like what it was: an attic, the keeping-place for forgotten treasures, the home of the dead. 
 It did not matter to her anyway. 
 She tried lying down on the bare mattress, but the whole place felt cold and close. 
 After a bit she got up again and crept down to her mother's room. 
 That too lacked the warmth and comfort of the morning, though her picture was still on the mantelpiece. 
 Her stomach ached dully but distractingly. 
 She knew not whether from eating too much or from her period. 
 Fenna might have given her both appetite and menstruation in his parting, but neither of them seemed as though they were worth the effort. 
 She wanted to cry and even that did not seem worth the effort. 
 She curled up on her mother's bed, pulled the duvet over her and lay there, inert. 
 She had seen and noticed this despondency, this weightedness, in her mother. 
 Once she had assumed it was somehow her mother's fault. 
 Out there the whole cosmos rolled and sang, out there the stars had danced and sung when Fenna called to them. 
 On stormy nights it had been exhilarating to fly in the teeth of the wind. 
 Hard to steer, to balance, to float, she had learned instead to consent; to cast herself onto the wind and learn the whole length and depth and height of its strength, and in perfect relaxation, the stern corseting of gravity left far below, her whole body had been open to power and loveliness. 
 She had thought that if her mother had learned to consent, to let go, to be filled, then Phoebe's passivity and disinterest would drop off like a cloak and she too could be naked with joy and love. 
 Now, coiled here, she thought it was not Phoebe's fault, it was the dullness of being an adult; it was the natural flavour of the world once one had said goodbye to childhood. 
 It might be necessary but it was not fun, and nothing would ever be fun again. 
 On a conservative reckoning she would have to live at least another fifty years in this bland and dreary universe. 
 She could of course, she thought with that sudden burst of adolescent enthusiasm, not live. 
 She held the idea of death briefly between her hands; but noticed how fast her mind darted away and took up sentimental pictures of her funeral, of her mother's and grandmother's distress, of her friends. 
 She knew she would not cheat and take that option, and she could think of no other. 
 The swift burst of curiosity and eagerness flickered out. 
 She just lay there, not thinking, or even feeling, anything. 
 The phone rang. 
 She pulled the duvet over her head and ignored it. 
 The phone went on ringing, and finally, irritated, she stumbled off the bed and picked up the receiver from the floor where Phoebe usually left the phone. 
 &bquo;Hello,&equo; she said in what she hoped was a dignified version of annoyance. 
 The caller seemed oblivious. 
 &bquo;Maggie! how are you; Are you OK? 
 Where have you been?&equo; 
 It was Hermione, genuinely concerned because she had not been at school; someone who had missed her. 
 Her spirits rose a little, 
 &bquo;I'm fine.&equo; 
 &bquo;But what happened to you?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, listen, this totally weird thing happened last night. 
 There was I, sweetly asleep, and suddenly the roof collapsed on top of me.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;Really.&equo; 
 And suddenly it could be a story, a funny story that was making Hermione laugh. 
 Suddenly she knew how to do this, this chatting and joking and telling her life, sharing it, warming herself from the fire of affection she had lit in her friend. 
 Distantly she remembered that she had never understood the art of it, had to work on it, conscious and struggling all the time. 
 Now, her head emptied of Fenna, it flowed out smooth and bubbling, almost unnoticed. 
 This was Hermione, this was her friend. 
 After a while she said, &bquo;How was school, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, moan.&equo; 
 &bquo;No I meant really, did we get masses of homework?&equo; 
 &bquo;If you came over I could give you all the assignments.&equo; 
 They laughed, the transparency of their own schemes delighting them. 
 They didn't do many subjects together and were only in the same group for French and history. 
 Their grown-ups however, who might well, in the middle of their GCSE year, object to a Monday evening of socialising, would not know these things. 
 &bquo;I can't be late,&equo; said Hermione dutifully, &bquo;I really have got that gruesome geography project to hand in. 
 I know what, let's do it now. 
 I'll meet you in the park, you know the gate at the top of Gloucester Road, that's about equal for both of us. 
 We'll hang about or something&hellip; my mother's out, I'll leave her a note.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aye, aye, Captain,&equo; said Maggie, &bquo;so's mine.&equo; 
 &bquo;Keep some of the broken glass for Mrs Fish's break-time coffee. 
 We can grind it during the lunch break tomorrow. 
 See you in half an hour, then?&equo; 
 Laughing, Maggie hung up. 
 After a moment she realised that she would have to change; there was no way she was going out to meet Hermione in her mother's elderly and considerably over-large tracksuit. 
 As she ran up to her room she was, for the first time in her life, actively grateful to Phoebe and Rachel for their absolute laws of tidiness. 
 Her clothes, neatly in their cupboards and drawers were not ruined or dirty after the catastrophe. 
 If it had happened to anyone else, to any of her friends, half their garments would now be lying under glass or dust around the floor. 
 But it could not have happened to anyone else, she was almost forgetting that this had not been exactly a freak accident in the way that everyone thought. 
 Not everyone. 
 Her mother had known. 
 Sort of. 
 She felt a tiny moment of pride: this was an accident that her power had brought about and Phoebe knew it. 
 Perhaps Rachel did too, or would do when she had had time to work it out. 
 Even if it was the last thing she was ever able to do, Phoebe would have known it, and would have to notice her now. 
 Phoebe had obviously needed her reassurance that the house was safe. 
 Her elation took her into her clothes, back to the kitchen to leave Phoebe a scrawled memo, and out of the front door. 
 It carried her into the park and only wavered when she saw the playground. 
 Then suddenly the park looked so different, filled not with dragons dancing but with ordinary people, and she was just one of them. 
 Over the next two hundred yards she slowed down again, her misery and inertia crowding back upon her, her loneliness embracing her. 
 Until at the top of the hill, despite spotting Hermione's black hair and bright red jacket down below her, she came to a stop. 
 And thus it was that she came to be, on that February evening, poised at the very crown of the hill in Kensington Gardens, looking down the hill, with her back to Bayswater and home and trembling with the fear that she had at last grown up. 
 Three 
 After a couple of minutes Phoebe recovered her breath; she pushed herself off the wall with her hands and went through the stairwell doorway into the green-painted corridor. 
 She walked along the passage and came, as she had planned, to the window which made the end wall of that floor. 
 She was poised now over her garden and could see the whole of it, laid out like a little world, from her great height. 
 She had created it from the chaos, she was its God. 
 She leaned against the window, resting her forehead on the glass, enjoying its cool smoothness. 
 She felt her own tiredness. 
 And why should it hurt so much, be so unutterably wearisome, to say goodbye to death, to the dark passion that had consumed her? 
 There was nothing left now, but to grow old, but to grow old and take on the burden of her mother growing even older. 
 To give up the burden of Maggie getting older. 
 To acknowledge that she could not and never would ask Maggie for the mothering that she would give to her own mother. 
 To accept finally and irrevocably that there was no romance in her life, that romance was a deep killer, a consuming passion and that she was too tough a woman to be consumed. 
 And there was nothing. 
 She leaned more heavily against the window and stared unseeing at her park below. 
 She would offer her breast as a blood sacrifice for life and in that moment of despair she had no doubt at all but that death would accept it and she would have to live. 
 Lopsided, belonging not to herself and her inner love, but to doctors and chemotherapy and the loss of all her hair. 
 The tears, of self-pity and self-loss, welled in her eyes. 
 As she raised a hand to wipe them away she noticed how deeply the dirt had eaten into her fingernails, so that they were not, and so long as she worked never would be, pink and sweet and shell-like. 
 When she raised them the rest of the way she held them not to her streaming eyes, but to her ears, listening intently for the sound of the sea. 
 But she did not hear the sound of the sea, she heard instead the sound of the earth. 
 The earth on her fingers spoke to her, spoke to her of sowing in tears and reaping with joy; of dying and growing. 
 The earth on her fingers sung to her and she could hear the rhythm of the seasons, the wobbling journey of her planet through space, which gave the earth its sides and turns, and within that there were the smaller rhythms of her rake, of her tractor engine, of her trowel and of her brain. 
 Her eyes were clear of tears; she looked from a great height down into the park and saw its order and its beauty so determinedly brought forth. 
 She saw, coming out of the hut and walking across towards the gate, Pete and Sammy, two of her youth volunteers. 
 She could not help but pause in her misery to be proud of the fact that, without her supervision, they had been at work in the garden. 
 As she watched, Sammy threw a casual playful punch at Pete's shoulder and, fooling, Pete fainted away and bounced back. 
 They were playing like children, and she could be a child too and play with them and the garden would mother her &mdash; a stern and demanding mother, but with moments of perfect attentiveness. 
 Her park knew she was up there watching and waiting over it, and it tossed off a loving welcoming wave; it &mdash; the tractor, the boys and the bulbs in the earth &mdash; knew she had chosen for them and was coming back to them. 
 Of course there was still love, there was healthy, growing love and its name was called Work. 
 She had fallen in love with it so slowly and gently and sweetly that she had never noticed it had happened. 
 The park, unlikely though it might seem, was not a job, not a political ideology, not a way of filling in the weary hours until she was old enough to retire, not even something to spite her mother with once and for all while she accepted everything else from her. 
 It had been all those things, it had started as all those things, but now it was work and love. 
 She saw her work laid out there in the garden, all the muscled cold wet harshness of it; all the labour and the ingrained resistance to working, and she thanked her mother, who had given her this thing. 
 This knowledge that in the end everything must crumble but a woman's work is her rock and her shield, a strong fortress, a faithful lover. 
 This enormous gift that, despite all the trying things that went with it, Phoebe had received; this capacity to look at a thing and know that, because it must be done, it is the doing of it that brings freedom and salvation. 
 She remembered something. 
 &bquo;If a woman must choose between love and work, she should never hesitate.&equo; 
 She could not remember where it came from, but she muttered the line to herself, and the mutter took root in her stomach, grew and blossomed into an enormous belly laugh. 
 Maggie saw Hermione shake exasperated shoulders and suddenly feared that she might walk away. 
 The fear propelled her out of her stillness and she ran down the hill. 
 It was almost like flying, this running downhill towards a friend who might vanish if she delayed. 
 Lightness and truth came to her with the wind's speed. 
 &bquo;Hermione,&equo; she said, once they had greeted each other, &bquo;there is something I want to tell you; it is sort of a secret.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh Lord,&equo; said Hermione grinning. 
 &bquo;Who is he?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's not that at all,&equo; said Maggie, but now she was nervous again. 
 Nervous but steadfast. 
 &bquo;It's about what really happened to our roof last night. 
 Let's go and sit on some bench.&equo; 
 They sat on a bench in the Flower Walk, the beautifully tended beds laid out for them and all the tulips listening attentively, and Maggie broke the rule of her lifetime and told Hermione about Fenna. 
 In the telling it became neither nightmare nor obsession, but a beautiful tale, the stuff of dreams and fairy stories, and Hermione heard it all with tenderness and pleasure while the sun set and the dusk gathered thickly around them. 
 Afterwards they stood up slowly, not wanting to part from such intimacy, but beginning to feel chilly now the warmth of the story was over. 
 They looked so beautiful, together, black and gold. 
 And then suddenly, not black and gold but gold and silver. 
 Hermione was glowing radiant in the dusk, an intense silver light, vibrantly running in the tight curls of her hair like neon, in the soft pinker palms of her hands like candlelight, in her eyes and teeth like electricity, and across all her whole skin like fluorescence. 
 Maggie was almost fearful. 
 &bquo;It's all right,&equo; said Hermione softly, smiling, amused. 
 &bquo;I'm radiant. 
 When I was little I learned to swim in the ponds of the Romney Marshes, behind Dungeness. 
 The water was radioactive. 
 I'm irradiated. 
 Whenever my atoms get excited they glow. 
 They're glowing for you and your dragon.&equo; 
 &bquo;Does it hurt?&equo; asked Maggie, trembling with awe and joy. 
 Hermione grinned. 
 &bquo;Wait and see,&equo; she said and to both their surprises she turned and put her arms on Maggie's shoulders. 
 After a moment Maggie too began, faintly, pearly, to glow. 
 &bquo;You can give it away, magic,&equo; said Hermione, giggling. 
 &bquo;If you give it away it comes back in its own good time, like that dreadful assembly hymn, you know&hellip; and &bquo;you end up having more&equo;.&equo; 
 This is what my mother meant, thought Maggie, this is what she meant and meant to give me. 
 The two of them were overcome with giggles, shaken by their own senseless amusement. 
 They were floppy with laughter, leaning against each other and passing the magic atoms backward and forwards like little kids playing clapping games in the cement playgrounds of primary schools. 
 Maggie scraped the radiant atoms off Hermione's arms and juggled them in the air, but she was giggling too much and kept missing the rhythm. 
 They collapsed into each other's arms and at that moment a group of callow youths stomped past, bigger than the girls and ferocious looking. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; said one of them, &bquo;what have we got here? 
 Looks like a couple of little dykes to me.&equo; 
 They might have been frightened, or offended, but they were laughing too much. 
 &bquo;Don't wormy about it,&equo; said Hermione, cheeky in her hilarity. 
 &bquo;It's probably just a phase we're going through.&equo; 
 The boys grinned a little sheepishly, acknowledging her courage. 
 &bquo;It's all right,&equo; says Maggie, perfectly clear, her bell sounding again uncracked and certain as she had feared it never would. 
 &bquo;My grandmother says that a normal evolutionary phase can last two hundred million years.&equo; 
 Rachel was very tired and paused now on the monumental steps of her museum. 
 She would just have to cling to her professional integrity as she had done for fifty years, and she would, as she had always tried to, make that sufficient. 
 The pose, the swagger, the moment of pride was solitary, an indulgence for herself alone, and there would be nothing more. 
 She would go home. 
 And it was high time she retired. 
 She shook herself slightly and took a final look down the proud granite staircase towards the traffic. 
 Then, running her eyes along the row of plane trees, she suddenly noticed, for the first time, that a medium-sized dragon was sitting in the upper branches of a particularly fine plane tree and munching a green leaf. 
 It's back was a dull pewter colour, with a paler underbelly, but the tip of its tail was eau de nil  and looked soft and delicate. 
 The dragon looked directly at her. 
 Its ancient and mischievous eyes were almost tender. 
 The smoke furled dreamily from its navy blue nostrils and wafted gently into the evening, almost indistinguishable from the exhaust fumes of the cars below it. 
 She had never seen a dragon before, and now she nearly exploded with joy. 
 For someone over seventy her descent of that great staircase was as good as a frolic; her satchel swung wildly round merrily bumping her large bottom, her sensible suede shoes skippetty-hopped like the finest quality glass slippers, while her honest tweed skirt flirted up her legs in order to give her long beige knickers their first sight of the sunshine in quarter of a century. 
 By the time she reached the bottom the dragon had vanished, but this, far from mattering, only added to her amusement. 
 Quite suddenly she felt a generous relief, as though she'd given science and herself new hope of heaven, and set out through the gathering dark, home, home across the dragon-haunted park. 
 Sir Adrian Cadbury  
 Born: Birmingham, 1929. 
 Educated: Eton; King's College, Cambridge. 
 Sir Adrian Cadbury is chairman of Cadbury Schweppes plc. 
 He joined Cadbury Brothers Ltd in 1952 and became chairman in 1956. 
 After the merger between Cadbury and Schweppes he succeeded Lord Watkinson as Chairman of the combined company at the end of 1974. 
 He wads knighted for his services to industry in 1977. 
 He is a director of the Bank of England and of IBM UK Holdings Ltd, and chairman of Pro Ned, an organisation that encourages the appointment of non-executive directors to company boards. 
 He also heads the CBI Business Education Task Force. 
 He is chancellor of the University of Aston in Birmingham, a trustee of the Bournville Village Trust and president of the 
 Birmingham Chamber of Industry and Commerce. 
 He was made a freeman of the City of Birmingham in 1982. 
 Sir Adrian Cadbury is not one of those who subscribes to the popular theory that a truly professional manager can take over the helm of any type of business with only a superficial knowledge of the nuts and bolts. 
 I'm very sceptical of the ability to shift from managing a bank to managing a steel mill, for example. 
 I have grave doubts about that. 
 I think it is essential to understand the key factors for success or failure in your type of business and I'm not convinced you can do that without actually understanding the process in some detail. 
  For that reason, Sir Adrian looks back with gratitude on the job-rotation policy that was an integral part of basic training when he joined the family firm after coming down from Cambridge in 1952. 
 He found the experience of working in a wide variety of company departments invaluable and believes it held him in good stead when he reached the higher echelons of management. 
 There was a strict system of career development at Cadbury's in those days. 
 About six other Cambridge graduates joined the firm with Sir Adrian and they were put under the protective wing of the head of the employment department, who guided their career progression. 
 It was a firm edict of company policy that all new recruits with management potential should undergo the experience of working temporarily in as many company departments as possible. 
 I spent the first eighteen months working in all the factory departments, so I started with a good knowledge of precisely how the product was made and did all the jobs that then existed in the production of confectionery. 
 Everyone did some time in the factory. 
 I did longer than most and it had the advantage that, given there was much greater stability of employment then, I got to know a very large number of people. 
 He next moved on to the buying office, a very important department in a company such as Cadbury's where the skilful purchase of the ingredients that go into the products can have a crucial impact on the viability of the business. 
 Sir Adrian found this work fascinating and would have been perfectly happy at the time to have made it his long-standing job. 
 But the company's rotation policy dictated that he should be moved &bquo;rather abruptly&equo; into the wages department, where he played a role in setting and negotiating piece rates. 
 We had a large factory at Bournville employing about ten thousand people and there were a great many incentive payment schemes, so that became my job. 
 I hadn't asked to do it, but in fact found it very interesting and that took me as a result into trade union negotiations and finally into becoming personnel director. 
  As he progressed in the company, Sir Adrian also spent time out in the field selling. 
 All of us who were not on the sales and marketing side spent a day a month selling. 
 We were given a sales territory. 
 So for the rest of the month I was in charge of wages, piece rates, training, negotiations and all the rest of it, and then one day a month I was regularly calling on the same customers in Bloomsbury and I was collecting money, selling the goods and so on, which I think was a very important part of my continued training. 
 This varied experience served to convince Sir Adrian that no top executive can really be successful without an in-depth understanding of the finer points of a company's operations. 
 I worry about what was certainly a facet of the past in this country &mdash; a view that you could be a professional director of dozens of companies. 
 All of that to me smacks of a lack of appreciation of the need to understand a business thoroughly, where you're going to be involved in making major decisions. 
 I also think it's a question of being able to provide, certainly at the top of a company, a sense of direction and I find it hard to see how you can have an absolutely clear sense of direction unless you yourself are able to assess the essentials as you see them for success in your particular trade. 
 The basic grounding that all new management recruits underwent on joining Cadbury's helped to ensure that each of them obtained this innate understanding. 
 Members of the Cadbury family did not escape this strict initial training. 
 There was no automatic ticket to senior management. 
 We were a big family, so there were never any guarantees that members of the family would progress. 
 The arrangement was that they were happy for members of the family to come into the business and, in a sense, find their own level. 
 What is perhaps unusual for a family business was that we had members of the family at very different levels  in the company. 
 One of my cousins was a senior foreman by the grading of the day. 
 Another was a sales manager. 
 The one who was the senior foreman never moved beyond that grade. 
 In fact, Sir Adrian had no preconceived ideas about the sort of career he would follow when he came down from Cambridge with a degree in economics. 
 It was perhaps a foregone conclusion that he would go into the family firm founded by his great-grandfather, John Cadbury, in 1824, although he had two tempting offers from outside industry when he had completed his degree. 
 One offer he describes as &bquo;managing quite a lot of money&equo; and the other was a partnership in a substantial firm of solicitors. 
 He rejected them both in favour of joining the family firm, but he was vague about the specific role he would play. 
 It was a conscious choice that I wanted to go into the company, but I didn't have a clear view as to what particular part of the business I was interested in. 
 It just seemed like an interesting challenge. 
 At that time it was very much more of a family firm than it is now. 
 It was then called Cadbury Brothers. 
 The title of the holding company was The British Cocoa and Chocolate Company and my father was the chairman. 
 There were a number of other members of the family on the board. 
 The economic climate in Britain was very different then to what it is today. 
 Sir Adrian believes that today young people aspiring to careers in industry should seriously think about setting up their own small firms. 
 But there was no such enterprise culture in Britain in those days. 
 Very few of my contemporaries thought of starting up on their own. 
 So it seemed a fairly straightforward move to go and work for the family firm. 
 It was an entirely different climate from today. 
 Food was still rationed and it was very much a question of making the best use of available resources and we had absolutely unlimited demand &mdash; a very false situation as it turned out when you think about what happened to British industry afterwards. 
  One of the qualities Sir Adrian came to regard as essential as he gained experience of the family firm and aspired to become chairman of Cadbury Schweppes plc was integrity. 
 &bquo;I don't see how you can expect people to follow your lead, to trust you, to commit themselves to the business unless they believe that all of these things are dear to your heart.&equo; 
 He is more hesitant, however, about including an aptitude for leadership among the prerequisites for a successful captain of industry. 
 I'm always a little cautious about leadership, because I'm never absolutely certain what it means. 
 There is a connotation to leadership that needs perhaps getting out of the way. 
 The real question, it seems to me, is the sense of direction a leader has. 
 It doesn't seem the slightest use having leadership if you're leading in the wrong direction. 
 Sir Adrian cites the example of the army commander who leads his troops over the top of the trenches when it might have been more prudent to stay put. 
 Reckless heroism, very clearly, is not the sort of quality he admires. 
 He doesn't entirely dismiss leadership as a meaningless term, however. 
 &bquo;I totally accept that what you need is the ability to get people to believe in the vision that you put forward of the company, to accept it and to be willing to work towards it. 
 That does seem to me to be important.&equo; 
 Sir Adrian seems unhappy with the idea of drawing up a vast catalogue of top management attributes and is more inclined to the view that being a good senior executive is something gleaned from hard experience. 
 Although he is a thoughtful person, who loves to put his ideas down on paper in the form of articles for such august publications as the Harvard Business Review , he suspects that labels are attached to management practices in hindsight rather than as objectives executives set out to master. 
 He is sceptical about the plethora of management books that deaf in &bquo;grand abstractions&equo;. 
 He is not convinced that having read them aspiring managers can go away and teach themselves to be good leaders. 
 He believes, rather, that such abilities are acquired through a steady upward progression within a company. 
 There has to be a period of simply understanding how  things work; then graduating to some degree of management control. 
 I'm not sure you can jump from there to the strategy of the business. 
 I don't think you can miss out any of the intervening stages of progression. 
 Given that Sir Adrian places so much store by integrity in top management, he views the apparent decline in business morals with some concern. 
 I believe in the end that one of the casualties of taking short cuts and losing integrity is that you will not get good people coming into the business. 
 At the end of the day, that is what it all turns on. 
 If companies such as our own can be successful while maintaining standards I think we will attract people who will get something worthwhile out of a business career. 
 Sir Adrian attributes the moral decline largely to pressure brought about by a faster-pace world, particularly in the City where salary levels have become inflated beyond all recognition and where greed can easily take precedence over ethical practice. 
 I think the pressures have changed enormously since I started work. 
 The big change is that literally the market place is now global. 
 This seems to me to be an enormous change. 
 Curiously, it was actually very slow to happen in the financial services markets. 
 They protected themselves for a long time. 
 Now suddenly it's happened, so you get a lot of new people coming in. 
 You get an abrupt rise in the size of firms. 
 It's very difficult then to exercise the same kind of partnership control which traditionally those firms had. 
 So you get a breakdown in the structure. 
 That is a direct result of the sudden increase in competition and the consequent expansion of the range of services and the size of firms in order to respond to it. 
 You see the same thing in our kind of business, but we've really been operating in international markets for much longer and it's a slower process. 
 You can see it in our trade obviously in the way in which companies have  amalgamated and merged and grown. 
 The size of the players has changed. 
 We have to try to make ourselves more efficient and to accept change, but there are certain things we should hang on to. 
 Rapid changes in the market place put a great strain on top management to ensure a company is keeping pace and is sufficiently aware of what is happening around the world. 
 Sir Adrian believes it is very much the responsibility of a captain of industry to take the lead in such matters and to define the sort of company you want to become. 
 &bquo;It's very difficult to do because if you aren't careful you just write down a series of platitudes, but I think that a statement of aims and beliefs is very necessary even if it does look platitudinous.&equo; 
 Since the war, Cadbury Schweppes has undergone two fundamental rethinks about the strategy it should adopt. 
 One was in 1969 when the original firm of Cadbury merged with Schweppes, a merger that changed the whole character of the company. 
 A more recent reappraisal took place in the early 1980s when the decision was taken to shed the foods side of the business and concentrate on the confectionery and soft drinks divisions. 
 Operating in an international market, what you do is dictated by the moves your competitors in the confectionery and soft drinks markets are making. 
 Against that background, we decided to switch direction. 
 We had previously gone for a somewhat broader base to the business for perfectly good reasons. 
 Developing the food side of the business was a way of making better use of the Cadbury brand. 
 We had an asset in the Cadbury brand, so we spread it across biscuits, cakes and a range of other products. 
 We were getting more mileage out of an asset we already owned and it gave the business a wider base to cope with fluctuations in any part of it. 
 But it became clear that was not the way to hold our own against companies like Coca-Cola and Pepsi-Cola, or Mars on the confectionery side. 
 Our resources were too widely deployed, which gave us stability, but lost us a competitive edge. 
 So there came a point when it made sense to change that particular balance. 
  Such major changes of strategy aren't made without sacrifices, and the consequent upheavals took a certain toll at Cadbury's, not least of which was the need to reduce the work-force. 
 This is an issue that is close to Sir Adrian's heart. 
 Having devoted much of his career to the personnel function and having been an ardent advocate of participative management, he talks about such problems with an obvious depth of feeling. 
 He has no hesitation in saying that the most difficult aspects of management for him are those that involve making decisions about people, whether it be a question of promotion, demotion or making somebody redundant. 
 &bquo;Of all business decisions, these are the most worrying,&equo; he maintains. 
 &bquo;You can't be certain you're right and there is the greatest temptation to put them off and not to take them. 
 And obviously you worry about the consequences for the individuals concerned.&equo; 
 Sir Adrian does feel, however, that companies can take measures to reduce the hardships that redundancy inevitably brings. 
 There are ways in which you can soften it. 
 We did in fact get through a very major reduction at Bournville without any forced redundancies. 
 We did it simply by foreseeing the situation and starting the rundown early enough by stopping recruitment. 
 What you need to do is to involve people so they know what has to be done and plan it as far ahead as possible to minimise the impact. 
 But having said that, you have to close sites and obviously that does lead to hardship. 
 What Sir Adrian is absolutely certain about is that top managers need to be decisive and should not push issues under the rug in the hope they will solve themselves. 
 One of the most difficult decisions he was faced with in recent years was whether or not to sell the foods business, particularly as it involved disposing of Cadbury's Cocoa, the product with which his great-grandfather launched the company. 
 It was a traumatic moment for the chairman. 
 It also epitomises the complexity of business decisions that top managers have to take and the many issues that have to be weighed in the balance before reaching a conclusion. 
 And after that, the implementation of the decision can be equally difficult.  
 The first decision was clearly whether it made sense to concentrate all our resources behind the two core businesses, without foods. 
 We kicked that around and in the end, I'm absolutely certain rightly, decided it was better to concentrate our resources. 
 There was then the decision about what should happen to the foods division. 
 We had the possibility both of a management buy-out and of interest from outside the company. 
 This presented Sir Adrian and his top management team with a dilemma. 
 There is a widely held view among many business experts that selling off a business to a management buy-out team is the easy way out and is not in the best interests of a company's shareholders. 
 We had to weigh up the bid which the managers put forward against outside bids and they're never in exactly the same terms. 
 So, in a sense, you're comparing apples with pears. 
 We agonised over the decision before selling to the management and I'm absolutely convinced with hindsight that the decision was not only right in people terms but it was also the right business decision for the shareholders as well. 
 Part of the deal with the management buy-out team was an option on ten per cent of the new company when it came to the market, no equivalent of which was possible under the terms of any of the outside bids. 
 The buy-out company &mdash; premier Brands &mdash; has since been doing well and Sir Adrian is confident Cadbury's shareholders will have nothing to complain about when the new company does eventually go to the market. 
 The decision top management took has been vindicated, but there was some criticism, particularly from City analysts, at the time it was taken. 
 Stressing the complexity of such business decisions, 
 Sir Adrian points out: &bquo;It isn't a question of just saying it's A or B. There are any number of stations between A and B you have to examine.&equo; 
 Sir Adrian doesn't profess to have any special technique for making up his mind over difficult decisions as some top executives do. 
 He returns to his familiar theme of the need to study issues in depth and to do all the necessary homework. 
 &bquo;All you  can do is study the situation as thoroughly as you can and be clear as to what the issues are and who is going to be affected by the decision. 
 The essential thing is that you should do the homework as thoroughly as you can.&equo; 
 He does, however, condemn procrastination. 
 Having done that you have to make up your mind and the great sin, it seems to me, is to put decisions off. 
 One of the things I worry about considerably is that I feel a lot of well-meaning people bring pressure to bear on companies not  to take decisions. 
 If you go back to the time United Biscuits felt they had to close their Liverpool factory, the bishops up in Liverpool marched on Hector Laing and tried to persuade him to put the decision off. 
 They meant well, but the easiest thing in the world to do is to put difficult decisions off. 
 That really is the primrose path. 
 I don't think the people who advocate these policies understand that you have every wish to put the decision off. 
 Nothing would be pleasanter than not having to make people redundant, not having to close a factory, but your job is to take the decisions when you have assessed the evidence as carefully as you can and not to shirk them. 
 Sir Adrian is a staunch believer in decisions based on logical analysis, rather than the gut feeling some entrepreneurs prefer to act upon. 
 I would find it very hard to follow gut feel if I could not put forward arguments on two sides of a sheet of paper as to why it was the right decision. 
 I like to think things through. 
 I like, before coming to a decision, to get the arguments down on paper and it seems to me if you can't then convince yourself or anybody else that what you propose is logically right, it doesn't much matter what your gut's doing. 
 Bournville, the community that has grown up around Cadbury's Birmingham factory, is widely regarded as a company town, although from its foundation it has been open to people who do not work for the company and only a minority of the residents now have any link with Cadbury's. 
 But having spent all  his career in a family business, Sir Adrian has inevitably given a lot of thought to the responsibility a company should have for the community in which it operates. 
 He nevertheless finds it difficult to define, because there is such a thin dividing line between paternalism and being a good corporate citizen. 
 It seems to me you have to start from the fact that your role in the community is to produce goods and services which people want. 
 That's your prime task, which in the end you have to come back to. 
 If you don't do that efficiently then you are not doing a good job for the community. 
 Then you have the problem of reconciling that with other duties, such as your legal duties which tend to lag behind best practice. 
 He believes that each company needs to set its own targets for being a good corporate citizen, which can range from how much money should be donated to charities to making senior executives available for secondment to advise small businesses. 
 In one sense, businesses are licensed by the community to operate and you have to work within the terms of the licence, which tend to change. 
 You have to keep in tune with the changes. 
 After all, it wasn't that long ago that it was quite acceptable to belch smoke over the countryside. 
 The responsibility can be defined differently at different periods of time. 
 It's very easy within our own company to see the stages that Cadbury has gone through. 
 My grandfather built the village in 1895 &mdash; not as a company town. 
 It was open to everybody, but clearly it was convenient for people working in the place. 
 He built it for a very simple reason. 
 Not because he wanted to set up a model village, but because he saw that with the employment he was generating at Bournville out in the Worcestershire countryside, speculative builders would come in and put up very inferior dwellings if he didn't take a hand. 
 So he bought the land around the factory, and the village now covers one thousand acres. 
 But it was with a very clear purpose. 
 It was to prevent bad development and to show that you could build decent houses with gardens at  rents people could afford and also that you could develop a community, which is why he was never in favour of a company town. 
 He set the village up as a separate body even then under a charitable trust, which it continues to be to this day. 
 Obviously the gap between the two has grown through time. 
 In those days, Cadbury's saw it as part of its social responsibility to provide training and education for the workers it recruited. 
 When Sir Adrian joined the company it was compulsory for all young people up to the age of eighteen to spend a day a week at the company's continuation college. 
 That seemed to me to be a perfectly proper use of what the company had to offer. 
 It meant we got good recruits. 
 Now the world has changed. 
 In the early 1960s it became clear that compulsory continuing education was actually becoming a hindrance to recruitment. 
 Fewer people were coming forward to take jobs because they didn't like having to go to school. 
 So continuing education became voluntary and therefore the dividing line between what is paternalistic or not is constantly shifting. 
 There is no doubt in Sir Adrian's mind that it is more demanding today being a top executive than it used to be. 
 Running a large company has become far more complex, which is aggravated by the rapid pace of change, in his view. 
 But he believes that there are developments around the corner that could bring a lot of changes for the better, not least of them, technological changes. 
 He believes such innovations as &bquo;distance working&equo;, which will enable people to operate from home &bquo;instead of having to converge on places in order to work&equo;, will offer all kinds of promise for improving some of the less agreeable aspects of a business career. 
 He fondly hopes that in the meantime talented managers won't be deterred from seeking to take on top jobs because of the greater demands. 
 &bquo;It seems to me that people who worry about their responsibilities and mind about the consequences of their actions should be prepared to take senior jobs. 
 It would be a very sad day if that wasn't the case.&equo; 
 He believes that talk of the so-called &bquo;post-industrial society&equo;  is raising some unnecessary fears that may be causing some talented managers to have second thoughts about aspiring to a top job. 
 Like a lot of top executives in manufacturing industries, he believes the repercussions of a predicted major shift towards the service industries to be grossly exaggerated. 
 &bquo;I'm sceptical about what post-industrial means. 
 It sounds suspiciously like getting everything without working for it. 
 I think the fundamentals will stay the same.&equo; 
 He does accept, however, that automation will continue to eat away at jobs and leave top executives with agonisingly difficult decisions and that this is bound to make their jobs more stressful. 
 He believes it will call for a fundamental rethink about the way that work is structured. 
 I think there will be far more job-sharing. 
 I think people, if they have any sense, will work shorter hours. 
 Some will follow the example of Arthur C. Clarke, who has retired to Sri Lanka, because he says he can work better there, can enjoy the environment and is just as close to his numerous correspondents as if he were in America. 
 Sir Adrian utterly rejects the definition of work as full-time employment. 
 He fervently believes we must all become accustomed to more flexible lives in which work, education and training are all intermingled. 
 Most of us will be working part time and voluntary work will be considered work just as much as paid work and in that way we can distribute the enormous amount of work that needs to be done more evenly. 
 It's absurd really to say that because of automation there is less and less work when you see how much there is that needs doing in the community. 
 I think we will balance work and leisure in a totally different way. 
 Sir Adrian personally believes there is a lot of satisfaction to be derived from being a top executive, although he spurns the more visible trappings of success. 
 &bquo;I have no interest in fast cars. 
 I don't have a yacht or a second home,&equo; he points out. 
 His pleasure comes from a different source: &bquo;I am obviously very conscious of what  my forebears achieved and therefore it matters to me that the business has survived, remained independent and has grown.&equo; 
 He has tried hard to balance his managerial duties with outside interests and not to allow himself to become too much of a workaholic. 
 But that has led to him becoming involved in an &bquo;appalling number&equo; of outside bodies, in addition to being chancellor of Aston University and a trustee of the Bournville village. 
 &bquo;If I were to go to only one meeting a year for each of them, it would still be more than one a week,&equo; he confesses, admitting that it is one of his greatest weaknesses. 
 He writes most of his articles at home, however. 
 &bquo;I may not be as much with my family as I should be, but at least I am at home,&equo; he reasons. 
 His love of writing, he believes, stems from his analytical training at university. 
 &bquo;I like thinking something through and then setting it down on paper. 
 It puts my mind at rest. 
 I feel I have worked it out of my system.&equo; 
 There may be similar reasons for his love of gardening. 
 &bquo;I think I've got a tidy mind,&equo; he volunteers. 
 He used to be a keen sportsman in his younger days and rowed for England. 
 He still takes an active interest in Henley Regatta, where he is a steward. 
 &bquo;I need to do physical work in fact&equo;, he says. 
 Most of the outside organisations he is involved with are based in the Midlands. 
 &bquo;I get satisfaction from being able to be involved in a number of activities in the part of the world where 
 I live and have my roots.&equo; 
 His three children have all made their own way in the world, preferring not to join the family firm. 
 But what advice would he pass on to any young person with their sights set on a career in industry? 
 I would tell them that they should study something in depth and really understand it. 
 I don't think it matters much what you study, but I think to do so is very important in terms of promoting the power to think about issues. 
 I wouldn't be too worried whether people do that at university or not. 
 The idea that we should divide our lives into three parts &mdash; education/full-time work/retirement &mdash; seems to me to be absurd. 
 The ability to return to education at later stages in one's life is something that is very important and I hope will  be encouraged. 
 Nevertheless, I would advocate studying some subject in depth, not necessarily as an undergraduate, so that you can feel you have really mastered it at some stage in your career. 
 I believe you should understand the mechanics and the principles of the business you want to take up, whether it's a profession or a service or manufacturing. 
 The only thing I would add is that you need to find out what you are good at; you need to find out what it is you can contribute which other people can't and that is something which only you can find out for yourself. 
 Sir Terence Conran  
 Born.: London, 1931. 
 Educated.: Bryanston School, Dorset; the Central School of Art and Design, London. 
 Sir Terence Conran is chairman and thief executive of Storehouse plc, the &pound;1.5bn retailing group formed when British Home Stores merged with Habitat Mothercare in January 1986. 
 The group employs some 33,000 people and has over 950 outlets, excluding franchises. 
 Conran was one of the designers involved in the Festival of Britain in 1951. 
 He set up as a freelance industrial designer making furniture from a basement studio in 1952. 
 In 1956 the Conran Design Group was added, now one of the largest design organisations in Europe. 
 He began his retailing career in 1964 when he founded Habitat, a chain of stores selling well-designed modern furniture and furnishings. 
 In October 1981 be floated the company on the Stock Exchange and four months later be merged Habitat with Mothercare, the world's largest chain of stores catering for the needs of mothers and babies, and became chairman of the Habitat Mothercare Group plc. 
 In April 1983 this group acquired Heal &amp; Son, the long-established and well-known furnishers. 
 In September 1983 Habitat Mothercare embarked on a joint publishing venture with Octopus Books plc under the name of Conran Octopus Ltd. 
 A range of books has been launched which reflects his design philosophy and style. 
 In September 1983 Habitat Mothercare joined with merchant bankers Morgan Grenfell to purchase the Richard Shops chain. 
 Three years later Storehouse acquired Morgan Grenfell's fortyeight per cent stake in Richards. 
 In June 1985 Habitat Mothercare, in conjunction with a major French insurance company, acquired the  majority shareholding in the French retailing company, FNAC. 
 In April 1987, Storehouse plc, in a joint venture with the Pamplemousse Clothing Company, opened seven Anonymous stores in the London area, selling stylish fashions for the eighteen-to thirty-year-old woman. 
 In December 1987, Storehouse balanced its women's fashion business with the purchase of Blazer, the successful menswear chain specialising in classic English style. 
 In 1983, Conran was presented with The Royal Society of Arts Bicentenary Medal, awarded to designers who have &bquo;exerted an exceptional influence in promoting art and design in British industry&equo;. 
 He received his knighthood in the 1983 Queen's New Year's Honours List. 
 &bquo;Did it ever occur to you that everything in this world has had to be designed?&equo; asks Sir Terence Conran, pausing for the significance of his question to sink in. 
 There is a hint of impatience in the tone of his voice. 
 He is clearly rather tired of preaching the design gospel when it has been evident to him for many years the fundamental role it plays in good business practice. 
 Ever since Conran converted a struggling furniture-manufacturing business into a unique chain of retail shops called Habitat and set in motion a high-street revolution, good design has been at the core of everything he has done. 
 It has taken the rest of industry in this country a remarkably long time to come around to his viewpoint, but it is finally looking as though the penny has dropped. 
 Until fairly recently I don't think people have understood the design process or what it can do for the success of their companies. 
 Design is about the way a product not only looks, but also functions, and for anybody in manufacturing industry or retailing to say they don't take an interest in it would be perfectly ludicrous, because at the end of the day it is design that causes a product either to be successful or unsuccessful. 
 There is nothing manufactured by man that has not been designed, because whether it's a Rolls-Royce engine or a piece of printed paper, there's always a decision to be made  not only about what it's going to look like but about how it is going to be made and how it is going to operate. 
 That is what design is. 
 Everybody's been doing it, but they've not thought about it as a design process and they have not usually brought people with design skills into the team to make these things happen better. 
 Everybody obviously can design something. 
 We are designers simply in the way we write our name on a piece of paper. 
 It may be unconscious, but we've made a decision at some stage about how it's going to be. 
 So in my view design is absolutely fundamental and at the very core of most businesses. 
 Conran, whose own highly successful application of design to a flourishing business speaks for itself, explodes the myth that it is a mystical process, largely to do with aesthetic qualities dreamed up by artistic types with a special vision denied to most of us. 
 In his view, design is ninety-eight per cent commonsense and two per cent a magic ingredient to do with aesthetics. 
 Some would say that Habitat used the two per cent to great effect in creating a unique style of goods that appealed to the popular taste. 
 But Conran claims that it was the application of the commonsense element of design that was primarily responsible for the retail group's eventual runaway success. 
 It was, he maintains, the complete reversal in the manufacturer-retailer relationship where design is concerned that brought about the high-street revolution for which Habitat was largely responsible. 
 The great change that has occurred is that retailers no longer go out into the market place and buy what is offered to them by manufacturers. 
 They go now with a much greater knowledge of their customers to manufacturers and say: &bquo;We want our products to be made like this for us and we want them to be our products.&equo; 
 In other words, they're taking a lot of the task that used to be given to manufacturers away from them and so manufacturers today are not by and large so concerned with manufacturing brands which are their own and will sit on retailers' shelves as with providing a product for a retailer who wants to construct his own brand. 
 Conran has been steeped in design from his early years. 
 He  trained at the Central School of Art and Design, but never graduated, joining instead a group of frustrated designers, which included such budding innovationists as Mary Quant and Laura Ashley, who, like Conran himself, were eventually to become household names. 
 Conran ran a caf&eacute; selling 4p bowls of soup and a King's Road coffee bar to help raise the capital to start up his own furniture-manufacturing business, which turned out products similar to those found in Habitat shops today. 
 He first ventured into retailing in 1964 because he was so disenchanted with the way his furniture was being displayed in the shops to which he supplied. 
 It was often buried away among Regency reproduction furniture in shops which were empty most of the time. 
 One spring Conran went on a tour of sixty shops which sold his furniture. 
 He was appalled by the lack of imagination and innovation in the way the furniture was displayed. 
 To show the trade how furniture should be displayed he opened his first Habitat in the Fulham Road in London. 
 But first he analysed what was wrong with the established shops. 
 &bquo;People buy furniture infrequently and therefore go into the shop very rarely. 
 That's why they are nearly always empty,&equo; he explained in an interview with Your Business  magazine in 1984. 
 We asked ourselves what we could do to make the shops busy. 
 The answer was to sell other things in the same style: china, lighting, textiles, rugs and kitchenware. 
 But we had no idea it would become a chain of shops. 
 It was the moment when there was new interest in cooking in this country, but nowhere to buy kitchen equipment. 
 So we went to France to this huge warehouse in Les Halles. 
 There were stacks of things being sold to the French restaurant trade which were perfect for us. 
 But we were so hopelessly na&iuml;ve we didn't realise we were buying at retail prices. 
 All we got was a small discount because we bought such a huge quantity. 
 Despite such na&iuml;vety, the concept that was to give Habitat a unique position in Britain's retailing trade was born. 
 Conran had launched a business empire that was eventually to employ thirty-three thousand people. 
 The growth was far from meteoric, however. 
 After an unsuccessful merger with Ryman, the office  equipment chain, Conran bought back the Habitat name and shops. 
 The 1970s were the boom years. 
 His empire mushroomed across Britain, France and the USA. 
 It went public in 1981. 
 Months later it merged with the considerably larger Mothercare chain in a reverse take-over. 
 The upmarket London furniture store Heals, fashion chain Richard Shops and finally British Home Stores were absorbed into the group, which eventually became known as the Storehouse group. 
 It is rare in British industry for a designer to become the head of such a large business, and Conran can sometimes appear defensive about the unusual position in which he finds himself. 
 He argues that if anyone questions the suitability of a designer as a captain of industry it displays the lack of understanding about the true nature of design that has plagued this country for many years. 
 He maintains that the same rational decisionmaking process that applies to any design project applies equally to running a business. 
 Arriving at a design for a new product, he insists, entails seeking marketing advice, weighing up how the product is going to be made and manufactured, understanding the cost elements and how it is going to be sold and presented to the customer. 
 &bquo;The majority of a designer's work is simply a rational process. 
 Therefore, why shouldn't a rational person be able to head a company, just the same as a figures man, who is also a rational person?&equo; 
 Conran also disputes the suggestion that it must be difficult for a man so wrapped up in design to divorce himself from detailed involvement in the creative process in order to tackle the numerous other tasks that befall a captain of industry. 
 A designer involved in any industrial process is involved with a team of people. 
 He's involved with the buying side of the business, the marketing side, the production side and probably the advertising side. 
 As chairman of this group, I obviously have financial people, accountants, treasury people, lawyers, personnel people, property people and so on who all make part of a team. 
 It's a different sort of team, but it's a team. 
 So I am used to that process of working as a team and to delegating responsibility to the team and then of course monitoring and checking the results of the team. 
  Conran is convinced, too, that his experience of manufacturing in the early days has stood him in good stead as head of a retailing empire. 
 He first decided to go into manufacturing because when he finished his design training in the early 1980s there were few jobs available simply because in those days industry, by and large, saw no call for designers. 
 Fortunately for Conran, he had attended the sort of public school &bquo;which had taught me a lot of practical skills&equo;. 
 Going into manufacturing for himself, therefore, was something that came fairly easy to him and for most of the 1950s he built up a substantial furniture business. 
 I thinks the manufacturing experience I had was very important, because it enabled me to see things from the manufacturer's point of view, which many retailers haven't done. 
 Retailers have a tendency to be quite selfish people wanting more and more of a product that is selling well, but cancelling an order and telling you to go away and solve your own problems when there's a product that isn't selling well. 
 Being able to see both points of view has helped me in doing what we are trying to do, namely having things made specially for us and creating our own brands. 
 Conran's transition from manufacturing to retailing was a gradual process. 
 After he pulled out of the Ryman operation, however, he left manufacturing for good. 
 I was quite sorry to do so because I liked the manufacturing process very much indeed, but I don't believe you can be both a manufacturer and a retailer. 
 You can only be one or the other because the whole business of supply and demand is so complex. 
 When I became chairman of Hepworths, it had its own clothing plant and it either produced too much or not enough of the right quality at the right price at the right time. 
 There's always an argument between your own manufacturing company and the retailing side. 
 Another problem is that if you're trying to deal with other manufacturers in the way that we do, where we have this extremely close relationship and they are very reliant on our forward forecasts of volume, they feel if you have  your own manufacturing plant that you would always give preference to it in bad times and the other suppliers would be the people to suffer if sales declined. 
 The relationship when manufacturing and retailing are in the same company never seems to be a healthy one and I think there are many examples of that. 
 Leaving manufacturing behind enabled Conran to concentrate on retailing and position his company at the vanguard of the high-street revolution. 
 I suppose we were the first people in the 1960s to target our market and bring to people things that were well designed at an affordable price. 
 We probably opened a lot of people's eyes. 
 It is extraordinary that it took so long for the importance of this to be realised in Britain. 
 We were a tiny fumbling company for ten years before anybody took any notice of us. 
 Today, I think people would say that a lot of what we did in those early days has been influential in the general brightening up of the high streets in this country. 
 Having proved the value of a design-led business, Conran saw the logic of applying the same approach to other retail companies that had perhaps got left behind in the high-street revolution. 
 The take-over of Mothercare, despite the fact it was three times the size of Habitat, seemed to make a lot of sense. 
 The mother and baby specialist retail chain had been very successful in identifying a gap in the market and had filled it very efficiently, but it lacked the flair and creative genius that Conran had brought to Habitat and was losing business as a consequence. 
 The reason it was suffering a decline was because its product was no longer meeting the aspirations of the young mums in this country, and while other companies were improving their product ranges Mothercare had become stuck in a groove, because the very competent man who ran it really didn't know how to go about improving the product. 
 He had no skills as a designer. 
 He knew how to get a product that was decent and rather unexciting on to the shop floor, but when it became necessary to add more  to that product and to innovate in design terms, he didn't know how to go about it. 
 We had very little experience in clothing design at that stage, although we had run a small experiment with Habitat called Clothes Line. 
 But we knew how to bring our design skills into Mothercare, because the design process is very much the same for graphics design or engineering design or for fashion design. 
 It's just a question of finding the right people to bring in and form a fashion-design group. 
 This we did and very soon improved the Mothercare product range with sparkling results. 
 It took us three years to do it, but we changed the face of Mothercare and doubled the profits. 
 Conran was undaunted by the size of the acquisition. 
 Organisationally, Mothercare was solidly run with all its management systems working well. 
 It had simply lost its way in terms of product innovation, the area in which Habitat had demonstrated itself to be supreme. 
 In addition, Conran's company had by now developed some advanced management systems of its own. 
 In the early 1970s, Habitat was the first retailing company to install electronic point of sale systems (EPOS) in its stock control department for the automatic replenishment of stocks. 
 The idea was just beginning to catch on in America and we knew that it was going to become the  way that retailing companies were run. 
 So here was a company run by designers, as people might like to criticise us, putting in the most forward-thinking advanced systems for controlling stock, because it was the logical thing to do &mdash; the common-sense thing to do. 
 Provided you choose the right companies to work with and employ the right people to do it, you can get the right results. 
 It doesn't always go so smoothly. 
 In 1987 there was a complete breakdown of a computerised distribution system in Mothercare, which had been installed by a leading group of experts. 
 We made the mistake of not having enough of our own practical management to check that they were doing the right thing. 
 You should never assume that because they are  the world's greatest experts on retail warehousing that the job can be left entirely to them. 
 You've always got to have it checked out. 
 My favourite cartoon is of a businessman standing in Wall Street selling boxes of matches and around his neck is a placard which says: &bquo;I left it all to expert advice.&equo; 
 It's a very salutary lesson. 
 Employ the right experts, but check it all the time. 
 In the autumn of 1987, Conran ran into a potentially more serious stumbling block to his plans. 
 The Storehouse group suddenly became the target of unwelcome take-over bids, first from Mountleigh, an ambitious property group, and then from Benlox, a &pound;45m group, twenty-three per cent owned by Egyptian financier Ashraf Marwan, and advised by the enfant terrible  of merchant banking, peter Earl of Inficorp Earl, part of Tamwood. 
 There were also rumours that newspaper tycoon Robert Maxwell was showing more than a passing interest in Storehouse. 
 Conran found himself beleaguered and somewhat bemused as to why his group should suddenly be the focal point of so many would-be suitors. 
 His theory about the most likely cause of all the furore is an interesting reflection on the recent workings of the City of London. 
 I think it's a perfect example of rumour feeding on rumour, that once something gets into the market place it causes all sorts of entrepreneurial people out there to think there's an opportunity they ought not to miss. 
 The City is going through a very muddled stage at the moment &mdash; post-Big Bang &mdash; forgetting some of its traditional commonsense. 
 I don't want to sound dog-in-the-manger about it, but we have performed reasonably well in quite a difficult retail climate, but a view was put around that the individual companies in the Storehouse group were worth more separately than as a group. 
 popular theory now decrees that small specialist retail companies get a higher stock-market rating than the big conglomerates, so the latest fashion is for Sock Shops, Body Shops, whatever it is, with very high p/Es, while larger organisations get a lower rating because they are a group. 
 In fact, the centre of Storehouse is very small. 
 It's about  thirty people, really that of a very small central overhead, certainly when spread around a company with &pound;1.8bn of sales. 
 Also, we have something that is very unique and that is a design group that provides a design service at arm's length to each of the operating companies. 
 They buy from it and the design group has to look after its own destiny and its own profitability. 
 So what's happening is a lot of rumour out there and a lot of people who think that this is a wonderful opportunity to make ten per cent on the deal. 
 The rumours were further fuelled by a general statement Conran had previously made about the responsibilities of a group chairman when talking to a journalist. 
 He had said that it was the duty of any chairman to refer an offer that came from a reputable source to his board and shareholders. 
 That had been wrongly interpreted to mean that Conran was actively seeking a suitor. 
 The lesson Conran has learned is never to make general statements to the press that can be quoted out of context and always to keep a weather eye on the latest fads in the City. 
 But in fact there appears to be little a company chairman can do other than try to ride out the fashion of the moment. 
 Conran suspects that the current vogue for de-mergers will eventually turn full circle and there will be a return to the times when it was thought that, 
 a collection of targeted retail companies supported by a strong central management core actually is a good thing rather than a bad thing. 
 At one time the City had an enormous enthusiasm for mergers. 
 We were quite a good example with Habitat merging with Mothercare and then taking on Richard Shops, Heals and eventually BHS, all done extremely amicably. 
 We are very likely to see the cycle coming back again. 
 Conran cites the time when Habitat and other leading British-Based retail groups were first entering overseas markets and had a struggle to make profits as another example of the fickle behaviour of City investors. 
 It became the common view that any British retailer attempting to expand abroad  signalled a deterioration in its fortunes, with the consequent lack of interest from the City. 
 The City very soon changed its tune, however, when the retailers in the fullness of time proved the wisdom of venturing into overseas markets and ultimately returned good profits. 
 The lesson is to stick with what you really believe in. 
 Keep on looking at it all the time. 
 Be aware of what is happening all over the world, but for goodness sake don't allow the market &mdash; by which I mean the City &mdash; to guide the destiny of your company. 
 Conran acknowledges that in the face of-City rumour it is important for a group such as his to communicate to the outside world what its overall strategy is and to spell out the logic of its master plan &mdash; something he feels Storehouse might have done to better effect prior to becoming besieged by unwelcome take-over bids. 
 The job of communicating is very important indeed and maybe one of our problems is that we have been doing so much within the business that we are not ready to communicate to the outside world that it perhaps doesn't understand sufficiently what our targets are. 
 You have got to keep the analysts and the institutions on your side and let them know what you're proposing. 
 The problem is that if one of the projects you tell them about goes wrong, as inevitably it will, they're inclined to hold it against you. 
 Conran admits that he derives little satisfaction from having to fight off unwelcome suitors. 
 I find it very depressing because it takes me away from the constructive side of the business and into being a sort of financial PR and being defensive. 
 I'm bad at being defensive. 
 I don't enjoy it. 
 It's not a role that I welcome, although I try hard as a responsible chairman of the group to do the job as well as I possibly can. 
 There are moments of amusement in it. 
 I suppose my main concern in all this is that we employ thirty-three thousand people and their  lives are being considerably upset by this activity and I feel 
 I am fighting for them as much as for the shareholders. 
 The Storehouse chairman feels far more at home leading the expansion of the group he has built up so assiduously. 
 He believes it still has a long way to go. 
 I don't believe there is such a thing as being able to stop a business in its tracks and say that's far enough. 
 I think there has always got to be for any executive &mdash; and for any employee for that matter &mdash; new challenges, new frontiers to keep them enthused. 
 They can't go on making the same widget day after day. 
 There's got to be development and opportunities. 
 Conran has never allowed his job to become mere routine and there is no doubt in his mind about the satisfaction he has derived from building up a business empire. 
 I suppose the appeal to me has been making things happen and changing things and feeling quite British about it and proud of what in my very small way I have been able to do in this country and being able to export that abroad and make it a success there. 
 So there's a certain amount of nationalist pride. 
 There were also many years of frustration in my youth when the business was very small and I was bubbling with ideas, bubbling with energy and desperate to get things to happen but couldn't in the very dull environment of the 1950s and early 1960s. 
 So I feel a terrific relief and release that in the latter part of my business life I've been really able to make things happen at a considerable speed. 
 Surprisingly, the turning point that saw a struggling business transformed into a trendsetting group that has become a household name can be traced back to a Dutch merchant banker, who persuaded Conran to widen his horizons. 
 British merchant banks had failed to see the enormous unfulfilled potential in Habitat and tended to regard it as one of those here-today, gone-tomorrow phenomena. 
 However, the Dutchman, with shrewd insight, saw  great prospects for Habitat and persuaded Conran that in order to grow big he had to think big. 
 When the opportunity to acquire Mothercare arose, the Dutchman encouraged Conran to seize it with both hands. 
 &bquo;It just needed somebody to say: &bquo;Don't be so humble. 
 You are really much better than you think you are.&equo; 
 He opened our eyes to a lot of opportunities.&equo; 
 With widening horizons, it was inevitable that Conran would turn his attention to expansion abroad. 
 When he was looking to expand into Scotland, Britain was on the verge of joining the Common Market, a move Conran, a staunch European at the time, embraced with great enthusiasm. 
 &bquo;The problems of distribution and the various changes that we had to make to establish ourselves in Scotland made me think that if I just swung the compass I'd land up in Paris.&equo; 
 By coincidence, a manager who spoke good French and understood the French market place had just been recruited. 
 Conran asked this manager to carry out a feasibility study, the result of which convinced him that Habitat should move into France, a country for which he has always had a great fondness. 
 The group's expansion into the US market was not quite so smooth. 
 The City took a dim view of what it regarded as the inordinate amount of time it took for the group to return a profit there. 
 But Conran had decided not to soft-pedal in the US and had made up his mind to make a big splash immediately, which required large investments which it took years to recoup. 
 You can adopt two lines of approach when you start a new business. 
 You can either be very timid and start in a small way, building it up gradually and expecting to make a profit in the first year. 
 Or you can say: I've researched it, I know the idea is right, I'm going to go in big and I'm going to have to sustain four or five years of losses before I turn it into a profit. 
 The trouble about starting a very small business is that it's difficult to do things of any great originality, because you don't have the buying power or maybe the manufacturing base to really get the thing off the ground. 
 That's what I did when I started my furniture business, building it up gradually from a crude workshop and it took a hell of a long time. 
 I didn't get anywhere very fast, but when you are confident and you know the  market is there it is inevitable, because of the heavy initial investment, that you're going to make substantial losses in the early years. 
 That's the view we've always taken in expanding abroad. 
 We're prepared to sustain losses for several years while we get it going. 
 While tastes differ from country to country, good design is universal, in Conran's view. 
 The functional qualities of a product are very much the same everywhere and transcend most boundaries. 
 To insure against peculiarities of taste, the Storehouse group has always put its overseas ventures under the control of local managers who tailor the businesses to suit national idiosyncrasies. 
 Mistakes are not always avoided, however. 
 When Habitat decided to launch its incredibly successful range of glass tableware in the US, it expected to take the American market by storm. 
 It had overlooked the fact, however, that the Americans tend to be more generous when pouring drinks and like to add large ice cubes to their favourite tipple. 
 The British-made glasses were simply too small to accommodate American tastes. 
 Conversely, Habitat flew in the face of expert opinion when it introduced pack-flat furniture on to the American market. 
 The pack-flat furniture had been invented recognising that younger people had become more mobile and often did not have the time to wait around at home for furniture deliveries. 
 The pack-flat furniture was easy to transport and could be assembled at home. 
 Habitat was advised that the Americans would never take to this peculiar British invention. 
 But after Habitat set about educating them to the advantages of the idea, the Americans adopted it with tremendous enthusiasm. 
 Habitat is an old hand at changing habits of a lifetime. 
 It was the first company to introduce duvets in both the UK and the US. 
 Few would have dared to predict in the late 1960s that duvets would ever catch on in this country, but today it would be hard to find a British household that doesn't have one. 
 The Habitat-Mothercare group reduced the risk of offending against local custom when it entered the Japanese market by operating a franchise through an established Japanese retail group called Siebu. 
 The main problem was that all the furniture had to be scaled down to suit the smaller stature of the Japanese and to fit their smaller homes.  
 Perhaps surprisingly, Conran's management style and operating methods have changed little in the light of his vast experience. 
 I suppose the most recent lesson is that if you merge with a company you don't have the same opportunities for changing its culture as you do if it's a take-over. 
 If it's a take-over, you are the boss from day one. 
 If it's a merger there's a gradual shifting of the sands until it finds its own level. 
 I think perhaps in the Habitat-Mothercare-BHS merger things have taken rather longer to settle down than they might have done if it had been a take-over. 
 There are also a lot of advantages in acquisition accountancy which can provide a sort of beer mat for the first years while you are trying to put the businesses together, and of course we didn't have these in the merger. 
 We had merger accountancy rather than take-over accountancy. 
 Absorbing a merged company into the group presents Conran with one of his most difficult management tasks. 
 The most difficult aspect of a merger is trying to put a team together of people who come from different business cultures and trying to adjust them to a different end. 
 It is a question of trying to get them to learn each other's good qualities and to recognise their own bad qualities. 
 I can't say it's something I've found easy to do. 
 Sometimes it works and sometimes it doesn't. 
 We had a big management shakeup in BHS when I could see that certain people were just not going to change their spots. 
 Although they were perfectly competent people and good at their jobs, they were never going to become part of the new culture which we have been trying to design for the Storehouse group. 
 So they left the business. 
 I find that a very difficult situation, because I can see the merits in most people. 
 Most senior executives in a business have got plenty of good qualities. 
 The problem is assessing whether they are going to change or not and I suppose I get criticised for being too tolerant at times. 
 I like to give people a very fair chance. 
 When people seem to be falling down, I like to give them the opportunity to  right themselves. 
 If they can't do that they simply have to go. 
 I certainly wouldn't go into a new business and make instant decisions about who has got to go. 
 I would try and get people to work as a team together and then when it obviously isn't going to work properly, only then would I make the decision. 
 Some people probably think I take too long to decide such matters, but I can demonstrate to them that sometimes by giving people a reasonable length of time to adjust they come through with flying colours. 
 I particularly try and develop an atmosphere of autonomy in the subsidiary companies where they feel they are part of a team and can look across at the other companies and can see admirable things going on. 
 It's a rather bad analogy, but I like to think of them as first-division football teams with their own particular qualities. 
 You let them play against one another and sometimes you transfer a player from one club to another, so that it builds up a mutual admiration society. 
 Conran is first and foremost an entrepreneur, who lives up magnificently to his own definition of what such a person should be: someone who takes risks after carefully assessing the opportunities available to him. 
 He does not believe that Britain lacks for entrepreneurs, but he is concerned that many of them do not do their homework well enough. 
 I remember once being on the board of a risk capital company when the Business Expansion Scheme first came in. 
 There were hundreds of companies coming to us for funds and they were meant to be writing their business plans properly and cogently. 
 I was absolutely horrified at the number of flaws you could very quickly find in reading one of these papers for half an hour. 
 Their thinking was coloured about how they were going to make their million and be launched on the USM. 
 They were all aspiring entrepreneurs, but so few of them had an original idea. 
 I think the most important thing is to try and find that gap in the market that is not well trodden by a lot of other people &mdash; to find something which you can do which is different from all the rest of them.  
 There's no point in just joining a mass of people who are simply competing with one another. 
 One of the reasons we developed a design-led retail business, offering our own unique products, was because we saw we could distance ourselves from other retailers who were just selling manufacturers' products and discounting them and getting into constant competitive battles. 
 It's difficult to be an entrepreneur, I believe, by simply following a well-trodden path. 
 Conran never really switches off from work, because he surrounds himself by objects that are beautifully designed. 
 He drives a Porsche, because apart from being a car that operates in harmony with man, in Conran's view, it is also beautiful to behold. 
 &bquo;I've always driven a Porsche ever since I could afford one. 
 I'm one of the original Yuppies, I suppose. 
 It's a beautiful car, beautifully engineered and a great pleasure to drive. 
 The actual process of driving yourself in a Porsche makes you feel good.&equo; 
 His main hobby is to take derelict old buildings and convert them into habitable homes that are monuments to the Conran design credo. 
 He has two such homes in France, one in provence, which he visits frequently. 
 He has recently completed a book on all the aspects of France he loves so much. 
 In the heart of the English countryside he runs a workshop where four craftsmen turn out fine furniture. 
 It is a hobby he has taken up with two main aims in mind: &bquo;Firstly, it keeps my hand in as far as manufacturing is concerned and secondly I like to see this small bit of entrepreneuralism on my doorstep. 
 I find it very relaxing.&equo; 
 Conran doesn't see anything ostentatious about owning four homes. 
 I have to have a home in London because I live and work here. 
 I like being in the country very much indeed. 
 My real home is in the country near Hungerford. 
 I love being in France and I recently bought an old barn there and took great pleasure in rebuilding it and making a garden. 
 It's not essential for me to have four houses. 
 In many ways I would prefer to live in one place, but taking old and derelict houses and making them relive again is a source of enjoyment to me. 
 Although Conran is very conscious of what he buys and surrounds himself with, he has not allowed his love of good design to become a fetish. 
 He applies the same pragmatic attitude to design in his leisure-time pursuits as he does to the working environment. 
 For example, he does not seek out chic restaurants that are the haunt of the artistic set. 
 He is more likely to enjoy going to a restaurant that has good traditional furnishings that are well designed in their own terms. 
 What I am anxious to do is to find things that are not cynically made. 
 It is the cynicism in the design process that offends me; the suggestion that there's no point in designing anything special for the working classes because they don't have any taste. 
 People's taste is created not by their genes but by what they're offered in the shops. 
 If they're offered, as they have been for years and years ever since the industrial revolution, things that have been cynically designed for the working classes, is it surprising that we have a nation of people who are supposed to have no visual standards? 
 It is only when people are shown and offered things that excite their brains and imagination that standards go up. 
 When the British started to go out of Britain and go abroad for their holidays their eyes were opened. 
 They started to eat different food, see different clothes and furniture in the shops and different houses and their perspective widened. 
 Sir John Cuckney  
 Born: Murree, India, 1925. 
 Educated.: Shrewsbury; St Andrew's University. 
 Sir John Cuckney is chairman of 3i Group plc and Royal Insurance plc and a former chairman of Westland Group plc; deputy chairman of TI Group plc; a director of Brixton Estate plc and a former director of Midland Bank plc. 
 After service with the Royal Northumberland Fusiliers in World War N, he was attached to the War Office until 1957. 
 Since then he has held directorships of various industrial and financial companies, including Standard Industrial Group (director 
 1959&ndash;66, managing director 1966&ndash;70), Standard Industrial Trust (chairman 1966&ndash;70) and Lazard Bros &dollar; Company (currently a member of the board). 
 He was chairman of Brooke Bond Group plc from 1981 to 1984,; chairman of John Brown plc from 1983 to 1986 and chairman of Thomas Cook Group Ltd from 1974 to 1987. 
 In the public sector, he was chairman of the Mersey Docks and Harbour Board (1970&ndash;72); the Port of London Authority (1977&ndash;79); the Building Economic Development Committee (Little Neddy) (1976&ndash;90) and International Military Services Ltd (owned by the Ministry of Defence from 1974 to 1985. 
 In 1972 he was appointed chief executive (second permanent secretary) to set up the Property Services Agency at the Department of the Environment and held that position until his appointment as chairman of the Crown Agents for Overseas Governments and Administrations in 1974, which he held until 1978. 
 He was chairman of the International Maritime Bureau (of the International Chamber of Commerce) from 1981 to 1985. 
 He is a freeman of the City of London. 
 He received his knighthood in the 1979 Birthday Honours List and in 1980  was elected an Elder Brother and a Member of the Court of Trinity House. 
 Sir John Cuckney's career has embraced a fascinating mix of public- and private-sector service, a combination he has always found very appealing. 
 Even after deciding to put public service behind him and concentrate on the private sector, he has never quite seemed able to escape involvement with government. 
 A classic example was when he found himself at the centre of media and national attention after taking over the chairmanship of the troubled Westland Group in June 1985. 
 He set about drawing up a rescue plan amid a political storm that resulted in the resignation of two cabinet ministers. 
 But possibly because of his broad experience of both the public and private sectors, Cuckney rode out the storm calmly. 
 Once the Prime Minister had declared that Westland's problems were a private-sector matter and not something that should be unduly influenced by government issues, his priorities became abundantly clear. 
 Cuckney's longest stint in government service lasted for about ten years. 
 After World War N, during which he served in the army with the Royal Northumberland Fusiliers, he was attached to the War Office. 
 But by 1957 he had become disenchanted with government service and decided it was time to join the private sector. 
 &bquo;In the mid-1950s I found public service very restrictive. 
 I wanted the greater freedom which obtains in the private sector.&equo; 
 He went to work for an organisation that combined the roles of an issuing house and a conglomerate. 
 The two sides of the business were interrelated and operated in parallel. 
 The issuing house was active in turning small- and medium-sized firms into public companies. 
 At the same time, an industrial holding company was being built up by acquiring firms which, for various reasons, were unsuitable for turning into public companies. 
 In 1970 an opportunity came Cuckney's way which offered the kind of unusual challenge he has always relished. 
 He was invited to become chairman of the Mersey Docks and Harbour Board, which fell into the grey area between the public and private sector for which Sir John has always found special fascination. 
  It also faced him with the need to untangle a financial crisis, a task that has frequently occupied him in his career. 
 It was an interesting problem. 
 The Mersey Docks and Harbour Board was a public-trust authority which was becoming rapidly insolvent, yet there was no way in law in which it could go into liquidation. 
 The only type of receiver who could be appointed was a receiver of rates who has no control over assets and no management control which a receiver normally has. 
 It had an active business operation side and Seaforth &mdash; the container port &mdash; was still being built. 
 So it presented a mix of business operations of a rather specialised type, but also a classic area of interface between the public and private sector. 
 As a public-trust authority with central government funds committed to it through the Harbour Act, it needed a private bill to get its constitution altered. 
 So there was a parliamentary battle. 
 It was a mix of problems that I very much like. 
 After this, Cuckney again found himself drawn to public service. 
 he became a second permanent secretary in the Department of the Environment during Edward Heath's administration. 
 His somewhat thankless task was to attempt to introduce private-sector techniques into the Civil Service by setting up the Property Services Agency. 
 It had a very ill-fated start in that some of the original ideas of establishing it as an independent agency with a trading fund were thwarted at the last moment. 
 It remained an integral part of a government department but with an attempt to try to introduce accountable management and run it in a businesslike fashion. 
 It was called a departmental agency, but the constraints of trying to be fully integrated with a major department like the Department of the Environment meant that the theoretical freedom to manage, which it had started off with, very quickly disappeared. 
 After two years, Cuckney left to become chairman of the Crown Agents, another organisation that was encountering fairly major  financial difficulties. 
 And again, it was an organisation with a blurred constitution. 
 Central government's responsibility for it was not at all clear. 
 It moved into banking and property development just ahead of the secondary banking crisis. 
 It was still fulfilling its traditional functions of looking after overseas governments and acting as a purchasing agency for them &mdash; and indeed it did administer World Bank and British Government overseas development loans. 
 It took Cuckney four years to overcome the financial crisis he encountered when he took over the Crown Agents in 1974. 
 Towards the end of this period he also became chairman of the Port of London Authority. 
 But by the latter part of the 1970s he experienced an irresistible urge to return to the private sector and he had a very clear idea of how he would go about it. 
 Going back into the private sector I was very keen to become a pluralist. 
 I didn't want to be totally dependent on any one source of income or any one group. 
 I think the most attractive feature of being a pluralist is the independence it gives and that has certainly been borne out in my experience. 
 I very deliberately wanted a mix of interests. 
 On leaving the Crown Agents he became a director of Midland Bank and chairman of Thomas Cook, which Midland Bank owned, and he became a director and subsequently chairman of Brooke Bond and a director and subsequently chairman of Royal Insurance. 
 After eight years in the public sector, Cuckney was more than ready to become involved with private industry, but he firmly believes more top executives in the UK ought to join the traffic between the two sectors. 
 &bquo;The movement you often see exhibited in France where people move very frequently from the public to the private sector and back again is something which I wish happened more often here.&equo; 
 But Cuckney does not find it easy to put his finger on the  fundamental differences between operating in the two sectors. 
 There are, of course, differences and I've often wondered what is the most significant difference. 
 As a permanent secretary in the Department of the Environment I was an accounting officer, which meant as a civil servant I was responsible directly to parliament, which also meant I regularly had to go before the Public Accounts Committee. 
 Shortly after I left the public sector again, I was invited to chair a seminar at the Civil Service Staff College at Sunningdale comparing being an accounting officer in the Civil Service and being chairman of a public company and appearing before an annual general meeting. 
 It was a very interesting comparison one was forced to make. 
 The most fundamental difference to me has always been that the private sector is so much more dynamic &mdash; the rate of change is so great. 
 Of course, there are changes in the public sector, changes in organisation &mdash; indeed government finds it an almost irresistible temptation to tinker with its machinery, merge departments, break them up and give them new titles. 
 But despite all that, there is a great stolidity; there is a great security-cum-fairly rigid structure supporting the Civil Service &mdash; and necessarily so. 
 It needs to have continuity and stability but in the private sector the real difference is the incredible rate of change in the market place. 
 The external factors affecting your business are constantly changing and you have in order to survive to adapt to these external changes. 
 It's a nice idea that in business or banking you can go through a period of &bquo;consolidation&equo;, but it seldom works out that way. 
 The more dynamic pace of change in the private sector is something that appeals to Cuckney. 
 I like the challenge that you've got to identify changes ni the externals and you need to take initiatives. 
 Nobody is going to tell you what to do. 
 You've got to make your own judgements and assessments. 
 If you are involved in a business with overseas investments &mdash; and more and more businesses have to think in global market terms &mdash; you need  to be conscious of the very rapidly changing international scene. 
 The international political and economical scene is rarely stable. 
 If you're interested in current affairs, as I am, they have a very direct impact on your business. 
 It was perhaps ironic that having decided to dedicate the rest of his career to the private sector that Cuckney became caught up in a major government row when he took over as chairman of Westland Group. 
 The UK's only helicopter manufacturer was on the brink of insolvency. 
 There was a shortfall in orders to carry the company into the 1990s &mdash; the famous &bquo;black hole&equo; &mdash; and it was vastly overmanned for the amount of work that was likely to come its way in the immediate future. 
 In 1985 Westland was making losses of &pound;95m on a turnover of &pound;308m and its future looked bleak. 
 Quite clearly, an urgent rescue plan was needed. 
 At one point it looked as though the helicopter operator and entrepreneur Alan Bristow would come to the company's rescue, but when he changed his mind there was a crisis of confidence. 
 Westland became the centre of a political storm between Michael Heseltine, then Defence Minister, and Leon Brittan, Secretary of State for Trade and Industry, over the form the rescue package should take. 
 Heseltine was anxious to set up a link between Westland and a consortium of European helicopter companies, whereas the DTI was adamant the company should make up its own mind. 
 There was a lot of emotive talk about the UK's only helicopter company selling out to the Americans, but in the event the Sikorsky-Fiat minority involvement won the day and Heseltine resigned from the government. 
 The political storm disguised the fundamental problems facing Westland which Cuckney, as chairman, and chief executive Hugh Stewart set about tackling. 
 The work-force was pruned by two thousand people and a new management structure was introduced to reduce Westland's dependence on helicopter sales and place greater emphasis on new technologies and components for the aerospace industry. 
 In hindsight, it's difficult to understand what all the furore was about, since Sikorsky only took a minority stake in Westland, but at the height of the storm Cuckney found himself in the unwelcome glare of national publicity. 
 It's an experience he is glad to put behind him.  
 Westland was a unique situation, hopefully never to be repeated. 
 One began recognising at the outset, of course, that there was an important relationship to government in that government was the main customer, the main purchaser of the product. 
 One also had links with government to the extent that the DTI provided launch aid for civil helicopter developments and the Ministry of Defence partfinanced development aid for helicopters, or improvements to them, for defence purposes. 
 So one started at Westland knowing you were going to have two major government involvements. 
 When you're in a defence industry that is inevitable. 
 There were fundamental differences between these two government departments &mdash; between two ministers &mdash; and Westland was piggy-in-the-middle, which was a very costly and unfortunate experience. 
 The important issue for me as chairman throughout that period was to remember that once the Prime Minister had said that Westland was a private-sector problem which must be solved by private-sector measures and techniques, one's interests were obviously the shareholders, the employees, the customers and the banks, since the company was heavily indebted. 
 One was not then justified in thinking and functioning in terms of what might be in the national interest, what might ultimately be a desirable development for NATO strategy or defence strategy. 
 It was rather a more specific and harsher problem which, to put it bluntly, was to survive as Westland was drifting on to the rocks of insolvency. 
 We knew in 1985 that when we made our preliminary announcement of our results for the previous financial year that we would become technically insolvent. 
 So the main thrust of all one's efforts was to try and save the company as a corporate entity and secure the interests of the employees, the shareholders and the banks. 
 Confining his attention to private-sector issues, Cuckney was in no doubt about what his priorities were. 
 Divorced of all the political drama, the issue was reasonably straightforward &mdash; which rescue plan offered Westland the best prospects of survival? 
 It was of little consequence which quarter it came from.  
 There was a lot of misunderstanding about the European-American argument. 
 As far as the company was concerned, as one drifted nearer to insolvency, any rescuer who appeared would have been welcome provided we'd been absolutely assured at the critical time when the loss of &pound;92m was announced that a rescue was legally binding, underwritten and in place. 
 What was attractive about the American consortium approach &mdash; and I must emphasise that it was never a take-over bid, Sikorsky's stake is only eight per cent &mdash; was firstly, we had worked with Sikorsky on and off for forty years. 
 But of overriding importance was the sheer professionalism of the American participation. 
 United Technologies (Sikorsky's parent group) came to take part in what developed into a contested capital reconstruction with a proxy battle. 
 They came armed with batteries of attorneys, British and American, merchant bank and investment bank advisers and the way in which their participation developed was immensely thorough. 
 One had greater faith on the day that one would be assured of their support &mdash; and incidentally the negotiations with the banks were fairly difficult. 
 The European consortium did not appear to us to be particularly cohesive in their aims and objectives. 
 It was less clear what their ultimate intentions were for the company. 
 One had a fairly strong feeling that part of their motivation was negative, in that it was to exclude the American participation, rather than positive &mdash; to build up the company. 
 The experience underlined for Cuckney the importance of having clear goals in a crisis and being determined not to waver from the chosen course of action: 
 I think you have to be extremely clear-minded and unemotional about what your objectives are and if it is a public company you must remember the paramount importance of the owners of the business &mdash; the shareholders. 
 I had, as it happens, had experience just before Westland of another very well-known public company &mdash; John Brown &mdash; which had encountered difficulties. 
 As chairman, I had been involved in its capital reconstruction and ultimate sale to  Trafalgar House. 
 What was interesting about that was that at the time John Brown got into financial difficulties the banks and institutional shareholders took a tough but very constructive view that it was worth helping the company through a reconstruction rather than forcing it into liquidation, which had been an attitude prevalent some years earlier. 
 It was in fact my experience of working with the banks and institutions for the recapitalisation and reconstruction of John Brown which led me to think that the City is much maligned over its attitudes to industry and the accusation of short-termism is not justified. 
 The institutions and banks had been immensely supportive in helping save the company. 
 When I was approached over Westland, it was by some of the banks and institutions that had been involved in the John Brown affair. 
 One of my reasons for becoming involved in Westland was that I felt in some respects that I owed them something. 
 Cuckney has never found it difficult switching from the public to the private sector, or vice versa. 
 He has found the management problems in each sector to be remarkably similar. 
 &bquo;There is a lot of common ground &mdash; the same causes for companies and organisations encountering difficulties, but of course the solutions have to be tailor-made to a particular industry or company culture., A sound organisation structure helps to overcome many operational problems, in Cuckney's view. 
 It is extremely important that you have an organisation structure that is clearly understood and then you should not keep altering it. 
 That can be very destructive. 
 But I think you have to recognise that there is no ideal organisation structure, whatever the arguments are for centralisation, decentralisation, functionalisation, regionalisation, for a line-management or matrix-management approach. 
 What really matters are the personal relationships within the structure. 
 There will always be imperfections and they can only be overcome by personal relationships. 
 I think there are enough common factors in management, including the role of chairman, that apply to all or most businesses, such as the need for careful succession planning,  the need for developing a strategy or a corporate plan. 
 When I say corporate plan, I don't necessarily mean you have to live with it rigidly. 
 Putting it at its simplest it should be at least a clear mission statement which the whole organisation understands. 
 I also think that apart from the corporate plan, the strategy and the mission statement, you really do need to give some vision about the future of your company and a vision in which those working with you can share. 
 You can usually tell an organisation that has a clear corporate plan but very little vision about the future. 
 The lack of vision is reflected in the atmosphere among the staff and all the employees. 
 Cuckney also feels that a top executive needs to set an example by being something of an entrepreneurial risk-taker. 
 There's a need for an entrepreneurial spirit. 
 After all, in the whole of the private sector there is a need for innovation; there is a need sometimes for diversification, although that can be a dangerous area; there is a need for a sensitive but effective response to the changing market place. 
 All of that is going to involve risk-taking. 
 Cuckney does not believe that the qualities needed to be an effective chairman of a financial institution such as 3i (Investors in Industry) are that different to those required to oversee a manufacturing company. 
 He is not even convinced that the head of a financial institution needs to be all that numerate. 
 I think the really critical issue is to understand the concepts behind the particular forms of financing which are used. 
 People do tend, I think rather superficially, to concentrate on figures and relationships between the figures, whereas what really matters is the concept behind them and I think a financier could be somebody who is awfully bad at arithmetic, but does understand the concepts. 
 Cuckney is chairman of 3i, which claims to be the largest venture-capital organisation in the world. 
 It was established in 1945 as the Industrial, Commercial and Financial Corporation to  try to ensure that British industry had access to sufficient funds to feed its long-term growth. 
 Using funds raised in public capital markets all over the world, 3i is a major force in the provision of share and loan capital to unquoted British companies. 
 Owned since its formation by the clearing banks (eighty-five per cent) and the Bank of England (fifteen per cent), it represents a commercially successful, City-based initiative to help meet British industry's long-term capital requirements. 
 Since 1945, 3i has supported over nine thousand companies. 
 It provided over &pound;500m in capital in 1987 to nine hundred businesses. 
 It invests in all the major points of change in the life of a company, from start-ups through to flotation. 
 In a typical year it supports some three hundred brand new or very young ventures. 
 Its total assets are over &pound;2bn. 
 What 3i has done is demonstrate that the clearing banks in the UK have collectively over forty years ensured that there is access to long-term development capital for British industry. 
 It is a living example which shows that the accusations of short-termism levelled against the City are really not valid &mdash; certainly in this respect. 
 What has been achieved by 3i over the years is a very clear demonstration that the banking system has done a lot to help the growth of small and medium-sized businesses. 
 Cuckney challenges the view that there are vast sums of money locked up in pension funds floating around the City that could be diverted towards helping struggling small firms to grow. 
 I don't think the market place is ill-organised. 
 I don't think there is any shortage of venture capital or money to back good propositions. 
 What there is a shortage of is good propositions which are realistically priced and properly thought through and presented. 
 The 3i chairman is convinced that an enterprise economy does now genuinely exist in Britain. 
 One can see it by the numbers of new business start-ups; also by the number of failures which does show there is  some healthy risk-taking. 
 I think one sees it by the change in the structure of big business, by so many management buy-outs and the realisation that size is not everything; large companies concentrating more on their core businesses and getting rid of peripheral businesses and spending more on research and development in supporting core businesses. 
 I think there is a dynamic movement in the structure of industry and in the geographic location of industry, the move away from some of the old traditional steel and coal mining and heavy industries into service industries and electronics, which does very clearly demonstrate that an enterprise economy does now exist. 
 Cuckney was attracted to the chairmanship of 3i because it is an organisation that has an interesting mix of expertise, 
 not only of financially trained and financially innovative people, but it also has a strong contingent of industrial advisers. 
 It's an organisation I have always recognised provides a facility to commerce and industry which I think is highly desirable &mdash; that is a facility to take a long-term view. 
 It's an essential feature of 3i that the positions it takes are long term. 
 It has been a shareholder for a very long time in some private companies and I think we've become known to be a supportive shareholder. 
 We certainly were with British Caledonian. 
 More recently 3i has become involved in the fashionable technique of &bquo;buy-ins&equo;, where teams of successful managers are headhunted from larger companies to run smaller struggling firms and turn then around. 
 Cuckney regards such managerial mobility as healthy. 
 I see no objections at all to it. 
 I think the development of buy-ins and management buy-outs, spin-outs, and all that kind of thing are a good indication of adjustment and adaptation to changes in industry. 
 One of the factors common to businesses that have fallen on hard times is an inability to adapt and change and a failure to recognise that the market place is changing around them. 
 I think there is  always going to be this element in business. 
 It's rather like pond life &mdash; little tadpoles eating even smaller ones and bigger ones eating them. 
 I think that movement is essential. 
 One of the major changes industry had to adapt to in the autumn of 1987 was the stock-market slump that sent share prices plummeting. 
 Cuckney does not believe the crash was the result of any fundamental change in the structure of national economies, but he does suggest that it signals the fact that greater volatility in global markets is here to stay. 
 I think we in Europe have been a bit slow to recognise that we are in a totally new era. 
 With all the new techniques now available, such as twenty-four hour trading and the global marketing of securities, we have been a bit slow to adapt to changes that are now going to be permanent. 
 A domestic market that becomes part of an international market is going to be subjected to the effects of changes which might otherwise have been more slow in coming &mdash; or wouldn't have immediately affected it. 
 All this has coincided perhaps with some inevitable over-optimism. 
 There have been some rather unrealistic valuations being put on businesses. 
 But I think the critical issue of Black Monday and what's happened since is that this is a very major change in the nature of the market place, but not in the underlying economies of countries, especially the UK. 
 I think we will continue to have a degree of volatility in markets we've not experienced previously and I think the way the market maker has to interpret his role now is such that we will never get the sort of fine tuning that the old jobbing system could provide. 
 With so much more volatility in markets, it is perhaps inevitable that greater stress will be put on senior executives as they strive to adapt to, and cope with, ever faster changes. 
 The ability to deal with crisis is something Cuckney has cultivated over the years. 
 During the Westland episode my worry beads got red hot on occasions, but I think each time you go through a  corporate crisis of some sort, you'd be silly if you haven't learned from the previous ones. 
 I think it's terribly important in an organisational crisis to remember that the crisis aspect of it, the critical nature of it, is something you've got to put to one side. 
 You've got to get on and deal with the problem and forget it's a crisis. 
 I think if you don't do that, you'll very easily become over-influenced at the time by the fact that it is a crisis you're dealing with. 
 You should treat it as a straightforward job of work and get on with it. 
 In any crisis, my greatest support is a clean sheet of paper and a pencil and the telephone off the hook. 
 I think it is absolutely essential that you are extremely clear-minded on your objectives and you're extremely clear-minded on your order of priorities, remembering the prime aim is to serve the shareholders and their interests. 
 Sir Monty Finniston  
 Born: Glasgow, 1912. 
 Educated.: University of Strathclyde (formerly the Royal College of Science and Technology). 
 Sir Monty Finniston is a former chairman of the British Steel Corporation and now runs his own company, H.M. 
 Finniston, in London. 
 He began his business career in 1948 when he became chief metallurgist at the United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority at Harwell. 
 In January 1959 he joined C.A. Parsons as managing director of its subsidiary, International Research and Development 
 Company, the largest sponsored research organisation in the U K. 
 He was chairman of the organisation from 1969 to 1977. 
 In 1967 he was appointed deputy chairman of the nationalised British Steel Corporation and in 1971 took on the additional responsibility of chief executive. 
 He relinquished both posts in 
 1973 when he became chairman of the corporation for a period of three years. 
 In 1976 he joined Sears Holdings Ltd as a director and Sears Engineering Ltd as chairman. 
 He resigned from Sears in October 1979 prior to setting up his own company in 1980. 
 He is chairman of a number of companies, including K.C.A. Drilling plc, Sherwood International Ltd, Industrial Technology Securities Ltd, and Mullholland Ltd. 
 His directorships include that of Cluff Oil plc, British Nutrition Foundation, Caledonian Heritable Estates and Combined Capital Ltd. 
 He is chairman of the Council of the Scottish Business School, the Prison Reform Trust and the Scottish Enterprise Foundation. 
 He is president of a number of business-related associations, including the Industrial Building Bureau, the Industrial Marketing Research Association, the Institute of Mechanical &dollar; General  
 Technician Engineers, the Engineering Industries Association, the British Export Houses Association and the Society of Environmental Engineers. 
 He is chancellor of Stirling University and a freeman of the City of London. 
 Sir Monty Finniston entered the industrial arena relatively late in life. 
 He was already fifty-five years old when he took up his first corporate post, as technical director of C.A. Parsons, manufacturers of electrical generators, transformers and turbines. 
 A research scientist by profession and temperament, he had spent all his previous career &bquo;never more than ten yards away from a laboratory&equo;. 
 Once he had made the switch, however, Finniston tackled his successive responsibilities with great relish, including the awesome task of reorganising the British Steel Corporation, which at the time was 260,000 strong. 
 Stark though the contrast must have been, Sir Monty explains the transfer from the closeted laboratory life to the public glare of big business with simple logic: 
 I didn't think I was being very original any longer and I was basically administering. 
 If you're administering, you might as well administer something that is new and challenging rather than doing something I had been doing all my life. 
 It happens to many scientists. 
 His first challenge was to take charge of a nuclear research centre for C. A. Parsons, which at the time employed 350 graduates and trained scientists, but for which there was little work. 
 Finniston converted it into a major international research organisation that still exists today. 
 But his horizons were dramatically broadened when he joined British Steel and was asked by the late Lord Melchett, who was then chairman, to reorganise the fourteen widely dispersed companies that had been put into the same melting pot under the nationalisation programme. 
 It took Finniston a year to complete the task. 
 That taught me a lot about how you actually get people to  operate within a hierarchical structure. 
 It was a fundamental reorganisation, because fourteen private companies working in rivalry with one another is quite a different thing from fourteen companies being merged into a single corporation with a single objective. 
 The experience caused Finniston to do some thinking about people and their relationship to organisations. 
 McKinsey, the leading management consulting group, which advised on the restructuring, held the firm view that people should always fulfil the specifications of the job. 
 It rejected any idea that an organisation should ever be created to suit the individual characteristics of people. 
 Finniston questions whether this approach can be adopted slavishly. 
 This philosophy obviously works in some cases when it is an established function like an accountant. 
 But on many occasions you've got talented people who just don't fill the job specifications, but whose qualities, put to an objective agreed by everybody, are valuable beyond measure. 
 After completing the restructuring of British Steel, Finniston was asked to draw up the group's first corporate plan. 
 It formed the basis of the ten-year development programme that was submitted to the government in 1973. 
 The project involved an in-depth analysis of British Steel's operating units to examine how they stood against international competition. 
 Finniston made some startling discoveries. 
 When I joined the company it had fifty-eight blast furnaces, the largest of which produced 2,750 tons a day. 
 The smallest blast furnace the Japanese were building then produced 10,000 tons a day. 
 So we had to make radical changes. 
 We didn't need fifty-eight blast furnaces. 
 It only called for eight at the most. 
 It was a mammoth task, but Finniston considers that his scientific background fitted him well for the challenge. 
 Scientific training makes you think rationally and logically.  
 To start with you have to deal with every problem rationally. 
 That forms the basis of your planning. 
 Then you have to say that, of course, the world is not a rational place. 
 It's got all kinds of people and all kinds of situations you didn't take into account and you couldn't take into account. 
 The money you have at your disposal, for example.To do the task requires X amount of pounds, but you've only got X minus something. 
 Then you have to modify the base to suit particular circumstances. 
 The implementation of the rationalisation programme left a lasting impression on Finniston which was to influence his future operating style. 
 The original 260,000 employees have since been whittled down to 50,000 and Sir Monty is a little resentful that he is probably most remembered for setting that radical rundown in motion. 
 His was not an enviable duty. 
 In rationalising the corporation and giving it the equipment that would allow it to compete with rivals, particularly foreign rivals, I had to have a capital programme. 
 The capital programme, as in all manufacturing industries, required a reduction in manpower. 
 Productivity had to go up and this was going to be achieved through the introduction of new capital rather than the introduction of new labour. 
 I became chief executive in 1971 and I then became responsible for the implementation of the plan. 
 It was quite clear to me that 260,000 people would be reduced very substantially and that for every person who was made redundant in British Steel, seven people were affected &mdash; another three in the family, plus the people serving that family in the shops and in other ways. 
 Finniston pauses for an ironical chuckle as he recollects the weight of responsibility placed upon his shoulders at the time. 
 &bquo;So there I was, responsible for nearly two million people in a way. 
 That's a big chunk of the population and I worried about the hardship that I was causing as a result of what was really a commercial decision.&equo; 
 He first began to think about the repercussions of such hard commercial decisions in 1971, and by the time that he 65 became chairman of British Steel upon the untimely death of Lord Melchett he had formulated a way to ease the hardship. 
 He set up an organisation called BSC Industry, which had the prime task of counselling redundant steel workers, retraining them and helping them to redirect their careers and, in many instances, set up their own small businesses. 
 It was a positive answer to an appalling problem that has since been copied in different forms by many other industries. 
 At the time it was revolutionary approach. 
 Finniston proudly describes it &bquo;as the first essay in caring capitalism that I know of.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you take Ebbw Vale as an example, where we rendered 2,500 people redundant in a very close community, we got 1,500 people back to work again within eighteen months by the start-up of nineteen companies. 
 We did that without any financial help from the government of the day.&equo; 
 The experience made Finniston aware of the needs of people when making major corporate decisions. 
 I became very much more conscious of people, because when you're a scientist you're dealing with inanimate matter, unless you're a biologist. 
 Inanimate matter doesn't answer back and if you get fed up with what you're doing you throw it down the sink or get rid of it. 
 But you can't do that with people. 
 They are the only appreciating asset you have in business. 
 All the other assets disappear; you write them off. 
 You depreciate them every year. 
 In five years a machine is counted as nothing in the balance sheet, but people count and age makes them more experienced, gives them better judgement &mdash; if they're capable of learning, which most people are. 
 In addition to the people aspects of a business, Finniston also had to pick up fairly swiftly a keen understanding of commercial factors, such as pricing. 
 He dismisses the popular theory of the need to price according to what the market will bear. 
 That's a stupid phrase actually. 
 How do you know what the market will bear? 
 Do you hold a wet finger up to the wind and say that's it or do you calculate what it is? 
 There are many difficult commercial decisions. 
 How much do you  produce in advance? 
 How can you gauge what a market's worth? 
 Never mind the home market, what about the foreign market? 
 How do you go into competition with people? 
 How do you get over protectionism? 
 Finniston admits that being plunged into the deep end of commercial decisions he inevitably made mistakes in the early stages, although he is not prepared to take the blame entirely. 
 &bquo;If the mistakes had been that obvious there were people around me to tell me where I had gone wrong, but they didn't. 
 So perhaps they would have made the same mistakes as well., He believes his most serious mistake was wanting to get things done in a hurry. 
 In hindsight he wishes he had been more patient, particularly with the twenty-nine different unions he had to deal with at British Steel. 
 I tried to get the trade unions into a form which made my managerial activities easier rather than trying to let them find a consensus between themselves. 
 But I was in a hurry to get things done. 
 I think patience is very important, particularly with people. 
 Of course it conflicts with the commercial urgency of producing something or gaining a new market. 
 You've got to balance the urgency of the situation against the patience required to do it. 
 Finniston is in no doubt that making decisions and seeing them implemented properly are the most important aspects of a chairman's job. 
 He was once asked what he considered the function of a chairman to be and he gave a three-part answer: 
 First the chairman must be quite clear what the objectives of the company are. 
 It doesn't matter what size the company is, whether it's in manufacturing or services. 
 He's got to say this is what he's trying to do in order to gain what it is he's trying to gain. 
 The objectives must be quite clear. 
 Every year after I became chairman of British Steel we set aside one board meeting at which the objectives of the organisation were raised. 
 We never changed them very much, because we knew the path we were on, but we consciously spoke about them.  
 Secondly, having decided the objective, make quite sure you've got the resources to meet it &mdash; that means in manpower, money, in machines and in markets. 
 There's no point in idealising a policy and never being in a position to achieve it. 
 It's much better in those circumstances to reduce the objective. 
 Then thirdly, make quite sure the objective is implemented properly, so you have to monitor. 
 You don't monitor day in and day out, hanging over the shoulders of individuals but periodically you go in and question why people are not meeting deadlines they've agreed to. 
 Finniston also believes that choosing a good successor is an important duty of a chairman, but as chairman of a nationalised industry he was in no position to do so. 
 The former steel boss recalls that he was able to assimilate the theoretical aspects of senior management very quickly and implement them in an almost academic fashion. 
 But he found there was nothing academic about dealing with people and with the unions, because &bquo;established institutions have their dogmas and their attitudes are frozen rigid.&equo; 
 He picked up a few tricks of the trade as he progressed. 
 In union negotiations, for example, I always found that if you had a heart to heart with the opposition, the single leader, you could probably gain something. 
 At some stage, informal contacts can be very effective. 
 They can't be informal to start with. 
 People have got to define where they stand &mdash; on both sides. 
 A case in point was a series of devastating strikes that Finniston had to weather at British Steel in 1974. 
 The corporation was sustaining appalling production losses and Finniston wrote to each of the trade unions suggesting that they meet on the neutral territory of a Heathrow hotel. 
 He gave the union leaders the opportunity to tell him in a forthright manner where they thought he was going wrong with his policies and he in turn did some pretty plain talking about what he saw as their shortcomings. 
 The idea was so successful in defusing the explosive situation that the meetings continued to be held at six-monthly intervals.  
 The special relationship Finniston forged between top management and the work-force at British Steel is epitomised by the fact that he was given farewell parties by each of the seven major steelworks when he came to leave the corporation at the end of ten years. 
 That was something he took great pride in. 
 In many respects, Finniston was ahead of his time in the management policies he adopted during the period he was chairman of British Steel but he stresses that commercial strategy without enlightened personnel policies can never be successful. 
 I don't think if you just consider products or a market in the abstract that you can be ahead of your time. 
 That's not the kind of vision that distinguishes people. 
 It's when at the end of your career you can say that you have benefitted some part of society, if not all of society, that you can say you have done well. 
 Finniston's greatest disappointment during his time at British Steel was that he never succeeded in persuading the unions to form a single group to simplify negotiations. 
 &bquo;It made it unnecessarily complex having to deal with so many.&equo; 
 But he was never overawed by the sheer scale of the task he undertook. 
 &bquo;That never worried me. 
 I've never worried about large orders of magnitude. 
 Problem solving is quite independent of the magnitude of the figures. 
 It just means you have to think more carefully, that's all.&equo; 
 Creativity is an essential prerequisite of running a company successfully, in Finniston's estimation, and in 1978 he outlined the elements of creative management to a gathering of The Royal Society of Arts. 
 It would be hard to improve on his observations today: 
 Creative management is about creative managers. 
 What then makes a creative manager? 
 Basically, he must be endowed with or develop certain characteristics of character. 
 He must have the will to engage in management as a changing, improving exercise benefitting his company, those responsible to him and for him. 
 He must have courage  since there will be many obstacles to the achievement of his objectives.  
 He must be resilient  since he must recover when there are setbacks. 
 He must be patient  since there is no instant creativity and implementation takes time. 
 He must be critical of himself  &mdash; and others &mdash; since in a changing world he must constantly be questioning his methods, his direction and the administration of his responsibilities. 
 He must be thoughtful  since lack of thought is probably responsible for most of the world's difficulties. 
 He must be communicative  since he has to work with or through other people. 
 He must be educated  with professional expertise, not just in a specialist discipline but with a general knowledge of the disciplines which bear on management, to allow communication with other contributors to the industrial activity of the company or organisation. 
 He must learn to delegate , encouraging those responsible to him by placing responsibility and authority on them as part of their career education. 
 And he must be aware of people  since he is not only concerned with the technical standing of machines but also with the physical and mental health of his operators. 
 The paragon of all these virtues is a rare animal &mdash; but thankfully is not extinct and hopefully will continue to breed. 
 Finniston still puts great store in these qualities today and he believes they equally apply to any kind of company or organisation. 
 I don't think what you run makes any difference, because I've run companies of very diverse natures and the principles that apply to British Steel at one end apply equally to a small company at the other end of the scale. 
 What I would most strongly suggest as the conditioning factor is the people you have to work with. 
 This determines everything. 
 That's why you can have two people who are going to occupy the same position and you'll treat them quite differently, because of the different characters. 
 There are some people who know  best all the time. 
 They may have other qualities which are worthwhile having, but trying to get them to change their minds requires one kind of approach. 
 There are other people who only work by consensus, but once they've agreed to something they'll do it very effectively. 
 That requires a different approach. 
 Finding people and educating and training them without them being aware that it's being done is very important. 
 The former steel boss takes the view that any intelligent manager can learn the technicalities of a new industry reasonably quickly. 
 It didn't take him long to master the basics of what British Steel was all about and he has been just as versatile in acquiring an understanding of a diverse range of other businesses, from computers and oil drilling to knitwear machines. 
 The art, according to Finniston, is to ask intelligent questions and look for inconsistencies. 
 By phrasing questions in different ways, inconsistencies are exposed without the need for having a detailed knowledge of a particular technique. 
 There is one area of management, however, that Sir Monty has changed his view on as a result of greater experience. 
 I used to believe it was possible to make forecasts &mdash; market forecasts in particular &mdash; which were likely to be accurate. 
 I no longer believe solely in figures. 
 I believe in sensitivity analyses and I believe in ranges. 
 But I've come to the conclusion that these are sometimes a bit astrological, particularly if you're in a competitive situation. 
 You've got to know what your rivals are doing. 
 Finniston cites Japan as a vivid example. 
 I know Japan is the country everyone points to, but it is the favourite one because it happens to show all the deficiencies of forecasting and combatting rivalry that are available. 
 In 1951 the Japanese produced only 6 million tons of steel and in that same year the British steel industry produced 15 million tons. 
 In 1981 &mdash; thirty years later &mdash; the Japanese were producing over 100 million tons and we were still producing only 15 million tons. 
 You've  got to ask yourself what they had that we didn't have. 
 Or what did they do we should have done? 
 It wasn't because we didn't have the talent. 
 It's not because we couldn't have done it. 
 The country didn't have the will to do it and the politicians didn't have the will to do it. 
 Finniston firmly believes that a lack of training and inadequate educational facilities are two of the major stumbling blocks to industrial efficiency in Britain. 
 He cites some statistics from two recent reports to support his argument: 
 Of all the people who call themselves managers or are designated managers in Japan or the US, eighty-five per cent have a degree qualification. 
 The figure in this country is twenty-four per cent. 
 In the US, West Germany and Japan five full days every year are devoted to off-the job training for every manager. 
 In this country it's less than one day. 
 Now I'm quite happy to argue we're twice as good as the Japanese, but I'm not prepared to claim we're four times as good, which is what these figures suggest. 
 Finniston also believes that there should be a greater element of entrepreneurship in all types of businesses. 
 He points out wryly that &bquo;entrepreneur&equo; is a French term and that there is no equivalent word in the English language. 
 A literal translation would be &bquo;undertaker&equo;, which doesn't have quite the right ring! 
 He contends that the whole of the business world is, 
 a risk-taking business. 
 The term, enterprise, really is a four-letter word &mdash; RISK. 
 But we play safe. 
 Take this craze for making everyone a shareholder. 
 The bulk of investors put money into gilts. 
 But putting money into small new firms, where the failure rate is pretty high and great risks are being taken, that's what enterprise is all about. 
 Today, Finniston runs his own small firm (small by comparison with British Steel at any rate), but at least fifty per cent of his time is now taken up with interests outside the corporate world. 
 He is chancellor of Stirling University and spends a lot of time going around lecturing at universities and schools. 
 He has been  chairman for ten years of the Scottish Business School, which comprises the business studies departments of the Universities of Glasgow, Strathclyde, Edinburgh, Heriot Watt and Stirling. 
 He is president of three technical societies and is deeply involved in inner-city problems. 
 He is a founder member of the Prison Reform Trust. 
 When they're young most people look naturally to their own selfish ambitions. 
 If they're married, they look to improve their lot and that of their family. 
 But after you reach a certain stage in life &mdash; I'd put it somewhere between forty-five and fifty-five &mdash; you suddenly feel you are as secure as you can be and you really ought to give something back to society. 
 There's an old Jewish phrase which I think is worth repeating. 
 It says: &bquo;If I am not for myself, who will be for me?&equo; 
 That's the voice of selfishness and ambition and personal interest. 
 It's the voice of the entrepreneur incidentally. 
 But then the saying adds: &bquo;If I am only for myself, what am I?&equo; 
 I think that's the voice of conscience and the voice of charity and the voice of doing something for the general good. 
 It's a very interesting phrase and was thought up four thousand years ago. 
 Finniston maintains there is inescapable evidence that the corporate world has become more selfish and self-seeking. 
 I think people go out to make a fast buck without worrying about the consequences. 
 Who is affected is not their concern. 
 The concern for the people for whom you are responsible by being given a position of influence and power and authority has gone. 
 The Golden Handshake, the Golden Hello and Big Bang and the whizz kids have changed all that. 
 Finniston believes that the enterprise culture that has been fostered by the present government has to some extent fuelled a disregard for social responsibility. 
 Encouraging enterprise is a good thing in many respects, but enterprise has been defined in people's minds as looking  after your self-interest. 
 How can you be satisfied with the economic state of a country when there are three million unemployed? 
 Never mind if there are a few who don't want to work. 
 People keep telling me hundreds and thousands of them don't want to work, but I never meet any of them. 
 By definition, if there are hundreds and thousands of them, I must meet one or two of them as I go around, but I never do. 
 Morality, Sir Monty points out, is an integral part of a society's culture at any given time in its history, and in his view our moral conditions have changed radically. 
 &bquo;People don't feel ashamed these days even when they have been caught out,&equo; he suggests in a tone of disbelief. 
 The people who set the standards are no longer the older generation, the people who have lived their lives and come to some judgement on what life is all about. 
 It's now the younger people, the people who make fortunes, like Richard Branson of Virgin, or even tennis stars, who set the standards. 
 Extraordinary! 
 On the other hand, Finniston feels that the younger generation is having a favourable impact on the need to rid Britain of the &bquo;them and us&equo; syndrome that has plagued industry for so long and been at the root of so many of its ills. 
 The next generation which is taking over the reins of industry is a generation who were not brought up in the same milieu that I was brought up in. 
 I think they are becoming more conscious that the world is not right. 
 They are arguing that it is not fair to have the &bquo;haves&equo; and the &bquo;have-nots&equo;; it's not fair to have a north and south divide. 
 It takes time for this to develop and for people to recognise that they are partly responsible. 
 Finniston takes issue, however, with the view that the next generation of managers will find themselves working within a post-industrial society, where manufacturing industry has largely given way to a dependence on the service industries. 
 He  dismisses the whole concept of the post-industrial society as &bquo;an economists, gimmick&equo;. 
 Economists in particular don't distinguish between the creation of wealth, which nowadays can be provided in large measure by machines, and the creation of employment, which in large measure requires other policies. 
 We are a country of very poor natural resources and our standard of living depends upon high imports &mdash; it shouldn't but it does. 
 These imports have to be paid for and what is interesting &mdash; and why manufacturing is vital to us &mdash; is that over the past hundred years, if not longer, seventy per cent of these imports have been paid for by the export of British manufactured goods. 
 That's the important thing. 
 Finniston is convinced that too much emphasis is being placed on earnings from so-called &bquo;invisible&equo; exports. 
 They, too, are subject to great competition, he argues. 
 &bquo;The Japanese are coming in through &bquo;Big Bang&equo;&equo;. 
 We're small. 
 If you take the largest ten banks in the world, there's not a single British bank among them. 
 The first bank that comes into the ratings is NatWest or Barclays at number fifteen.&equo; 
 Finniston's thesis is that the creation of wealth should come before the creation of employment, 
 because it is the creation of wealth that creates employment, not in the thing that is creating the wealth but in other things. 
 You recirculate it through taxation and through individual wealth. 
 You can't afford the service industries unless you've got a good manufacturing base. 
 I'm only talking about this country. 
 If you lived in America or some of these other places where there's natural wealth under foot, like Saudi Arabia, that's a different matter. 
 But the only appreciating resource that we've got is the talents and skills of the people to design, to manufacture, to produce and provide a service. 
 Finniston's own skills have certainly made an enormous contribution to the industrial growth of Britain. 
 He seems to have sought very little in return, apart from the satisfaction of knowing, in his own words, that he has &bquo;benefitted society&equo;. 
 He has very few of  the traditional trappings of the successful captain of industry. 
 &bquo;I live a good life. 
 I've been happily married to the same woman for fifty-odd years. 
 I've got a nice apartment. 
 I've never owned a house. 
 I've always owned apartments because I was born in a tenement in Glasgow and I like flat-life., If he has one regret it is that government never saw fit to offer him another major job as challenging as his chairmanship of British Steel when he gave it up in 1976. 
 He confides that he would have liked to have &bquo;taken a crack at another big public objective,. 
 He was requested by Prime Minister James Callaghan to head a commission that looked into the future of the engineering profession in Britain, which kept him occupied for two and a half years. 
 The resulting report, Engineering our Future  brought about a minor revolution in the profession. 
 But Finniston still harbours the belief that the wealth of experience he acquired during his ten years at British Steel could have been put to better service for the nation. 
 He is now, however, imparting that experience to the managers of tomorrow by his active involvement in a whole range of educational pursuits. 
 Even in his mid-seventies, Finniston is showing no sign of flagging in his boundless energy or in the missionary zeal with which he preaches the gospel that a healthy industrial economy is in the best interests of society as a whole.  
 Sir Robert Haslam  
 Born.: Bolton, Lancashire, 1923. 
 Educated.: Bolton School; Birmingham University. 
 Sir Robert Haslam was appointed chairman of British Coal (formerly the National Coal Board) in September 1986. 
 He had been deputy chairman and chairman-designate since November 1985. 
 He is a former chairman of the British Steel Corporation and of Tate &dollar; Lyle plc. 
 A graduate of Birmingham University, where he took a BSc in coal-mining, he joined Manchester Collieries Ltd, in 1944. 
 He qualified for his colliery manager's certificate in 1947 and is one of the longest-serving members of the Institute of Mining Engineers. 
 In January 1947, the colliery company became part of the North Western Division of the newly formed National Coal Board. 
 Later in 1947 he joined the Nobel Division of Imperial Chemical Industries as a mining engineer specialising in explosives for the mining, quarrying and oil-prospecting industries. 
 For the next ten years he travelled the world, visiting and working in mines and quarries in every continent. 
 Subsequently, he had wide general management experience in three ICI divisions, becoming chairman of ICI Fibres, a main board director, personnel director and deputy chairman. 
 He is also a director of the Bank of England, a governor of the National Institute of Economic &dollar; Social Research, a governor of Henley Management College, chairman of Manchester Business School and an advisory director of Unilever. 
 He is a former chairman of the Nationalised Industries Chairmen's Group. 
 He has also been a non-executive chairman of Cable &dollar; Wireless, chairman of the North American Advisor), Group, chairman of the Man-made Fibre Producers Committee and chairman of the European Synthetic Fibre Manufacturers.  
 He was made a freeman of the City of London in March 1985. 
 There have been a number of significant turning points in the career of Sir Robert Haslam, which he describes as &bquo;negative accidents&equo;, but which turned out to have very positive results. 
 It was, for example, a sheer fluke that he began his career as a mining engineer with Manchester Collieries Ltd. 
 He had aimed to go to Cambridge to read geography, but failed the Latin entrance examination it was necessary to take in those days. 
 In the event, he was accepted at Birmingham University, but just before he arrived he was informed that the geography department had been closed down because of austerity measures brought in during World War N. He therefore decided to read geology instead, but shortly afterwards he received notification that this department was also to be closed. 
 The next best option was to take a BSc degree in coal-mining &mdash; and that was how he ended up becoming a mining engineer instead of a teacher, which in all probability is the career he would have followed if he had managed to fulfil his original goal of studying geography. 
 Forty years later, after an enormously varied industrial career that has seen Haslam running a diverse range of businesses and involved in a wide variety of functions, from selling to personnel, events have turned full circle. 
 His early days underground working alongside miners on the coal-face have imbued him with a special rapport with the thousands of miners he now oversees as chairman of British Coal. 
 I worked in the coal mines for three years to obtain my colliery manager's certificate. 
 As part of the training programme, you had to spend this period underground, of which eighteen months had to be spent on the coal face and during that time you did lots of jobs that mineworkers did. 
 At times it seemed a bit strange to have a university degree and be working so physically hard but in many ways those three years were a very good period. 
 In particular, Haslam found the camaraderie he experienced working alongside mineworkers extremely rewarding.  
 It was rather like being in the army on active service. 
 The human relationships are very intense and therefore the learning curve is accelerated. 
 I learned a great deal during that formative period about what made people tick and one saw what life was really like. 
 Even though as a graduate I was something of an oddity, I was absorbed into the background after a time and people treated me as one of them. 
 They behaved towards me as they would to anyone else and I found it a very valuable exposure. 
 Above all, it taught Haslam the &bquo;common touch&equo;. 
 As he recalls: &bquo;You had to be able to tangle with fairly tough and earthy, but likeable and well-meaning, people.&equo; 
 He stayed in digs in a colliery village at the time and found it equally possible to integrate easily into the local community. 
 He detected no atmosphere of &bquo;them and us&equo;, though he suspects that in similar circumstances today it might be a different story. 
 He had been promised that once he had obtained his colliery manager's certificate, he would be made an assistant manager. 
 He received his certificate in July 1947 but the British coal industry had been nationalised in January of that year and his new bosses told him that in the changed circumstances they would not be able to carry out the undertaking he had been given. 
 The disappointment Haslam inevitably felt at being let down in this way led to a second turning point in his career and one of those &bquo;negative accidents&equo; that ultimately proved to have a positive outcome. 
 He went to a local pub in the mining village where he was staying to drown his sorrows and found himself sitting next to a stranger who remarked on his dejected demeanour. 
 It turned out that the stranger worked for ICI and he told Haslam that Britain's major chemical company was looking for mining engineers. 
 Three days later Haslam was being interviewed for a job at ICI and he was offered the chance to become a technical services engineer in the Nobel Division, an offer he snapped up immediately. 
 The job involved visiting mining camps, quarries and oilfields all over the world selling explosives and it gave Haslam his first taste of the excitement of travel, something that has remained with him all his life.  
 It wasn't really a management job. 
 You operated very much as a self-contained individual. 
 There were very few major countries I didn't visit during that time and travel was nothing like as easy as it is now. 
 Going to South America, it would take you at least thirty-six hours to get to Lima, for example, in some clapped-out old aircraft. 
 We had trips in those days that took as long as three months which not many people would undertake now. 
 It was not all fun and games. 
 I used to spend a lot of time in demanding places like the Andes and in remote parts of Africa. 
 He was eventually put in charge of the twenty people comprising the explosives technical services department and got his first taste of real management. 
 After four years in the explosives division, his management potential had been spotted and moves were made to launch him on a management development programme of rotation to broaden his experience. 
 He was offered a job on the production side, which would have entailed being a works superintendent. 
 Not realising the long-term strategy behind the offer, Haslam turned it down, regarding it as an inferior job for someone with his mining engineering skills. 
 He suspects that a black mark went firmly down against his name for turning down the job and when he was later asked to become personnel manager for that division of ICI he was left in no doubt that it was an offer he should not refuse. 
 I was told that there wasn't going to be any nonsense like last time. 
 I was going to be moved whether I liked it or not. 
 In those days you could be a glorious amateur. 
 You didn't have to be highly professional and experienced like a personnel manager has to be today. 
 Everything was much freer. 
 you could use commonsense much more. 
 You weren't so bound by rules, legislation, case law or anything like that. 
 Although Haslam's lack of experience was no real handicap at a time when inspired amateurism prevailed, he did not face an easy task. 
 During the years of World War N and for some time afterwards there had been a heavy demand for commercial and military explosives but by 1960 when Haslam was made personnel  director of the Nobel Division of ICI the demand, particularly for military explosives, had dropped dramatically. 
 It led to a period of sharp retrenchment and redundancies, a situation that at the time was very foreign to ICi which had been accustomed to unrestricted expansion in practically everything it undertook. 
 Having never had to face a situation of wholesale redundancies in the past, ICI's policies for dealing with them were out of date and inadequate. 
 I was about thirty-four when I was made personnel director of the Nobel Division. 
 I was only in that post for two years, but during that period we closed a lot of works. 
 In the process we helped to reshape the whole of ICI's redundancy policy and the terms under which people left the company. 
 Although the terms have continued to be remoulded and made more sophisticated, they basically emanate from that period. 
 It was a very difficult period, because whereas retrenchment and redundancy are now something employees understand and accept, this was the first time it had ever happened in ICI since the war. 
 People couldn't believe it. 
 It was essentially confined to our division. 
 We were a pioneer of a necessary but very undesirable kind of activity. 
 Haslam learned the hard way how to handle such a traumatic situation and how to some extent to play God when it became necessary to select the people who had to go. 
 There are basically two kinds of redundancies. 
 One is where you shut a works and everybody's in the same boat. 
 That is an easier situation to handle. 
 We always tried in ICI to offer people jobs elsewhere in the company whenever we could. 
 The more difficult situation is where you have to apply some measure of selectivity. 
 The question of people's status and their standing in the community can thereby be undermined. 
 The lesson Haslam learned from his ICI experience was that wherever possible redundancy should be on a voluntary basis if the trauma were to be kept to a minimum.  
 So long as people can walk out of a room and say they have decided to leave on their terms, they retain their dignity. 
 People argue that by adopting a voluntary approach you lose the good and the bad. 
 It's primarily a matter of how you do the counselling as to who you lose. 
 I'm not saying you may not lose a few good people but on balance it's worth that sacrifice rather than pursue an enforced redundancy policy. 
 Having to make hard decisions involving people is the only thing that gives Haslam sleepless nights. 
 I don't worry about business in the money sense. 
 I do worry about having to retire or remove somebody, particularly somebody close to me. 
 I think that's the most difficult aspect of management. 
 But you should never take the easy option. 
 So often in my life, where I've made a mistake, it has been by taking the soft option. 
 If you rationalise it by saying I don't want a row because I've got so much on my plate, it usually bounces back at you, often in an amplified form. 
 If you cut corners just for a quiet life, you'll have trouble. 
 It just builds up. 
 The next phase of Haslam's career was a totally different experience. 
 He was plunged into the commercial side of the business, first as deputy regional sales manager for ICI's Southern Region and later &mdash; in 1963 &mdash; as commercial director of the Plastics Division. 
 In those days sales of all ICI products were regionalised, a system he felt had shortcomings. 
 He was a member of a working party which caused ICI to switch to a new approach under which each division took direct control of its own sales. 
 It was as a result of this new approach that Haslam found himself in the Plastics Division, a more glamorous part of ICI, in contrast to the Nobel Division he had recently left. 
 At about that time, plastics was one of two ICI divisions that had been selected to come under the scrutiny of McKinsey, the famous management consulting group. 
 The consultants recommended that the Plastics Division be broken up into four groups, each with its own director. 
 As a result, Haslam inherited what was then the plastic-film group, which was at an embryonic stage of development. 
 But  the business was growing very rapidly and expanding abroad. 
 Haslam soon found himself in a position of having to make entrepreneurial decisions of staggering proportions. 
 In those days, ICI had a sabbatical system and the chairman of my division went away for nearly four months. 
 At this stage we were selling about three thousand tons of polyester film a year and my two closest lieutenants, my planning and marketing colleagues, persuaded me we should double the size of the plant at Dumfries in Scotland and that we should build another plant in Europe. 
 We put these two expansion proposals through the ICI board while the divisional chairman was away. 
 When he returned, he sent for me and said I must be stark crazy. 
 He pointed out that we were then selling three thousand tons of the product and had sanctioned plans to build plants for twelve thousand tons. 
 Well, I went off on holiday to Switzerland and on the way back I suddenly thought: Oh my God, what have I done? 
 I went up to Scotland where by now they had dug the hole for this second plant and it looked absolutely enormous. 
 I began to get cold feet, but these other two guys were totally positive and they were absolutely right. 
 Those two plants came on stream at a time when we needed all the capacity they could provide. 
 It was a period of risk-taking and setting horizons for growth rates which were different to anything I had experienced before. 
 By now Haslam was firmly on the management ladder at ICI and his broad experience of a wide variety of jobs and functions under the company's rotation scheme was clearly paying dividends. 
 People often feel a sense of frustration that they are not moving up quickly enough when they join ICI. 
 You have to go through a sort of incubation period while people weigh you up. 
 You are not conscious of them weighing you up, but they do. 
 The chances are that during the first eight or nine years you may appear to be treading water in the process of proving yourself. 
 You can have the finest degree in the world, but at the end of the day you are judged as an  individual and on your performance and them things begin to happen. 
 Some people in ICI still come up by one functional channel and reach the top, but most emerging people get the management development treatment rather like I did. 
 Running the film group for ICI gave Haslam particular pleasure because it was the first time he had ever been fully in charge of a business, which he found very challenging. 
 When he was promoted to deputy chairman of the Plastics Division in 1966 he remained in charge of the film group. 
 But plastics as a whole had started to hit bad times. 
 Sales of polythene and PVC, which had been two of ICI's mainstay products, had suddenly plummeted. 
 it was a similar story when Haslam moved to become deputy chairman of ICI Fibres in 1969 with the intention that he would soon take over as chairman. 
 Fibres had been one of ICI's big money spinners, but by the time Haslam joined the division nylon was already making a loss and polyester was about to collapse, having been a &bquo;jewel in the crown&equo;. 
 As the patents had run out on many ICI fibre Products, so competitors had jumped on the bandwagon and started building plants at a frenzied pace. 
 The inevitable result was over-capacity in the market place followed by a vicious price war. 
 It was a foregone conclusion that Haslam would for the second time in his career find himself &bquo;pitch-forked&equo; into a retrenchment programme. 
 This time it was on a much larger scale. 
 The fibres division was an international business with plants in West Germany, Canada, the US, South Africa and Australia. 
 When he took over ICI Fibres it employed around twenty-seven thousand people in Europe. 
 He eventually whittled it down to eighteen thousand and his successors have since reduced the number even more dramatically. 
 The impact of such a major reversal has left an indelible mark on Haslam's memory. 
 In two years we went from a &pound;32m profit, which I suppose in current rates would be in the region of &pound;150m, to a &pound;14m loss. 
 So in two years flat, after riding on the crest of a wave, people who had been cock of the walk in ICI suddenly found themselves at the bottom of the league. 
 This was a time when Haslam learned the subtle art of keeping  up appearances despite the fact that the world seemed to be collapsing all around him. 
 The most important thing was just physically keeping up the morale. 
 I had almost consciously to go out of the house in the morning with a smile fixed on my face, keep it on and breathe an air of absolute confidence when I was feeling anything but that way inclined. 
 It was vital to give the impression at any rate that I and my board colleagues were in control of affairs and that we had a clear strategy that somehow was going to restore our business to its former glory. 
 Haslam believes this experience taught him the need to recognise that many products follow a predictable life cycle. 
 First you have a unique product which has a highly profitable phase, but this frequently comes to an abrupt stop. 
 Patent protection falls away and competitors can't wait to get in. 
 Everybody thinks they can grab five per cent of everybody else's market without actually losing any of their own. 
 So everyone expands rapidly and these collective misjudgements create a disaster situation. 
 It doesn't matter who's running the show. 
 Anybody who pretends they can buck these trends is under an illusion. 
 You can only affect them peripherally. 
 The momentum is there and it's like trying to change the course of a battleship. 
 The important thing is to recognise that it is happening and take the relevant action. 
 It can take up to ten years to readjust to this new market situation. 
 By then the product will have reverted to being a reasonable business again &mdash; but not in a glamorous way as in the first phase. 
 It becomes a &bquo;cash cow&equo; business in that you generate a lot of money from existing assets, with minimum investment. 
 The repercussions of such a turbulent period are not all disadvantageous, however. 
 Haslam recalls a time when Sir Peter Allen, then the ICI main board director responsible for plastics, predicted at a small dinner party at the ICI guest house  at Welwyn Garden City that the market price for polythene would drop from the current 4s a pound to 1s 6d a pound within six months. 
 Everyone laughed it off as a typical piece of board-room exaggeration. 
 But Allen was only wrong in that the price collapsed suddenly to ls a pound. 
 This, however, had the effect of dramatically expanding the market for polythene. 
 It immediately became economical to use polythene for all kinds of products, like plastic bags, which nobody had ever contemplated previously. 
 A host of new opportunities were opened up, once again revitalising the market. 
 Haslam points oui that such experiences demand a great deal of positive thinking. 
 It's a period of facing up to radically new cost levels. 
 That means you've not only got to economise in manpower; you've got to bring new technology to bear on the problem. 
 Inevitably, too, you will need to build more economical large-scale production units to meet the great new opportunities which have opened up. 
 Another danger Haslam warns about is the complacency that comes from being a successful innovator. 
 &bquo;ICI has been the first in the field with major products, such as polyester fibre and polythene. 
 My impression is that if you invent something, you tend to have a built-in arrogance. 
 You have a sort of halo around your head.&equo; 
 But Haslam points out that the competitor who takes up the new technology when the patents expire does not suffer from this halo effect. 
 Its only aim is to knock the market leader off the pedestal. 
 The Japanese, of course, are past-masters at this. 
 The more you make the running in this critical phase, the more you need to become sensitive to future technological and quality advances, because if you don't the other guy is going to leap-frog you. 
 You can never rest on your laurels. 
 After having been in the thick of the battle for a number of years, Haslam found the transition to main board director in 1974 somewhat difficult to adjust to. 
 After running a substantial  international fibres business, it came as something of a cultural shock to find himself sitting in ICI's headquarters with only a secretary to command. 
 He became the product director on the board for both paints and fibres and also territorial director for 
 India and Pakistan, but he had to work in each case through the chief executive who was charged with running the business. 
 Haslam found this a rather passive role compared to running a business himself, so when he was asked to become ICI's personnel director he jumped at the opportunity to tackle a job which appeared to have a higher executive content. 
 It meant, too, that he would have some troops of his own again. 
 By this time the personnel function in ICI had ceased to be the domain of inspired amateurs. 
 Haslam was backed up by a four-man team of senior colleagues, all of whom were highly professional. 
 One was responsible for industrial relations and union negotiations. 
 Another looked after the monthly staff employees. 
 A third was entirely concerned with management development and career planning and the fourth acted as a one-man think-tank, whose task was to advise on how ICI's personnel policies should evolve in future. 
 It did not bother Haslam that he had to rely to a large degree on the expertise of others to perform his own job well. 
 I think the art of moving around as I have done in my career into different products and functions and into various industries is the ability to sum up quickly your close colleagues. 
 You can never hope to achieve the professionalism of those who have been in a single business all their lives and hence you need quickly to get to know those whose opinions you can trust. 
 These may not always be the people who sparkle a great deal because they often have a maverick quality. 
 If you are to move about in the senior echelons of industry, this is an important ability to develop. 
 Some people arc incredibly reactive. 
 They get into discussion with a neighbour on Concorde going to New York and when they get back they say they've got the finest idea since sliced bread. 
 Such colleagues tend to be great achievers, but you have to restrain their worst excesses. 
 I've seen quite brilliant people in ICI who throw off sparkling ideas like an emery wheel, but only one in ten of their ideas is likely to  be viable. 
 On the other hand, other people display a great sense of diffidence but often have admirable ideas which they are reluctant to reveal. 
 Such people need drawing out. 
 Haslam paints the picture of a corporate impresario who recognises the various talents and skills of those around him and orchestrates events so that these talents may be used to the greatest benefit of the enterprise. 
 But he pinpoints another factor that influences the way the players perform together &mdash; company culture. 
 People talk about the role of chairman or chief executive as though these are clear definitive roles. 
 These can be very variable depending on the culture of the company. 
 for example, ICI doesn't have a chief executive and operates on a consensus basis with the chairman acting as a primus inter pares . 
 We rarely took a vote sitting around the board table. 
 If there was a strong majority in favour of a particular action, we would go to great lengths to persuade the minority of the error of their ways. 
 Many other companies have a more autocratic culture in that the chairman and chief executive will have a disproportionate say in what happens. 
 &bquo;The other board members will expect to have their say, but at the end of the day they expect, and accept, that the chairman should decide.&equo; 
 The next phase of Haslam's career was one where he moved about from company to company rather than from function to function. 
 While serving as deputy chairman of ICI he became ill and was advised to take life a little more quietly. 
 He therefore took on the chairmanship of Tate &dollar; Lyle on a part-time basis. 
 That was as much as he felt he could cope with for a while, but he was soon to be &bquo;prevailed upon by government&equo; to become chairman of British Steel in double harness with the Tate &dollar; Lyle job. 
 I thought at the time it was a crazy thing to agree to and early events seemed to confirm this. 
 In the end, it worked out very much better than expected, essentially because the two companies had outstanding chief executives, both of  whom eventually succeeded me as chairman. 
 But it was still very difficult, because every day I was in London I was moving from one business to the other and they could not have been more different in character. 
 It was a particularly testing time at British Steel as we were still engaged in the major retrenchment exercise and we also had the very difficult task of keeping the steel mills operating during the miners' strike. 
 It was during this time, moving from one company to another, that Haslam learned the true meaning of what it is to be an adaptable manager. 
 These companies all had able and high-calibre people who knew their respective businesses very well, but his objective was to inject his own ideas into the decision-making process in the hope that this would produce an added beneficial dimension. 
 &bquo;Many companies, however successful, tend to be somewhat inbred and for this reason people often welcome an injection of new thinking into their affairs.&equo; 
 Whereas Haslam has found that a detached outside perspective has proved to be valuable in several of the companies he has served as a board member, his early intimate knowledge of the coal industry was equally beneficial when he was asked to become chairman of British Coal, bringing his career full circle. 
 It's amazing, even after a forty-year gap, that I feel I still have a rapport with most mineworkers because of my early days in the industry. 
 I can also listen to a conversation between mining engineers and understand ninety-five per cent of it, even after all these years. 
 They've got a particular jargon. 
 Very occasionally a new phrase disconcertingly emerges which I have never heard before. 
 Haslam's exposure to the worldwide business scene nevertheless gives him an extra dimension with which to tackle the British Coal job. 
 The combination of a broad industrial experience and a close understanding of how the typical mineworker views life gave him the confidence to take on a responsibility which a less courageous man might well have ducked. 
 In a way this job at British Coal is a particularly gruelling  one. 
 The other side of the coin is that it is very satisfying and rewarding because it stretches me in every possible way. 
 You've really got to be able to play all the keys on the piano on this one. 
 It's enjoyable but inevitably has some masochistic undertones! 
 Haslam admits that being the focal point of all the national publicity that inevitably surrounds the British coal industry is not something that he relishes. 
 I don't find that easy and never will. 
 I find TV particularly demanding, but it's almost impossible to avoid it. 
 I feel reasonably relaxed if I am interviewed on my own ground, but find TV stations rather stressful and alien situations. 
 With somebody like Mr Scargill, I think you've got to make yourself as available to the media as you can. 
 L think most people felt that during the early stages of the miners, strike the British Coal balance with Scargill was not strong enough. 
 It's not a thing I'm particularly good at, but I do try to put over our viewpoint. 
 As far as the perks of the job are concerned, Haslam looks back at his ICI days with a certain amount of nostalgia. 
 He travelled widely in those days, often accompanied by his wife, and they lived for two years in the United States where he was responsible for ICI's affairs in North and South America. 
 Life as the head of 
 British Coal is a lot less glamorous. 
 Going to Blackpool or Scarborough is now an adventure. 
 I get jet-lag flying to Manchester! 
 My wife and i feel somewhat denied. 
 Obviously I can go to the US or China to see mining practices there if I choose to, but it's not easy to get away. 
 I feel more tied down than I've ever been before. 
 Haslam also feels deprived of some of the cultural facilities that were available to him during his ICI days for entertaining customers and associates. 
 Like most major private-sector companies ICI has facilities reserved for it at many of the events that dominate the social calendar, such as Glyndebourne, Ascot and Wimbledon. 
 There are no such privileges for the senior  executives of a nationalised industry like British Coal. 
 &bquo;I am dependent on people with whom I have been associated in the past inviting me and I must say they could not have been more gracious.&equo; 
 Despite such curbs on his social life, Haslam rarely spends an evening at home during the week. 
 He is in such demand as a speaker that he has had to make a rule that he will no longer accept invitations to functions that are unconnected with the coal industry. 
 The biggest problem is containing the number of speeches you have to give, because despite the fact the industry has contracted, all the institutions that relate to our industry are still flourishing. 
 A lot of people retire from industry and spend a great deal of effort on these activities. 
 So the demands on your time to speak at a wide range of institution meetings and dinner functions are legion. 
 Although Haslam has been obliged to cut back on business travel, he and his wife still do a fair amount of travel for personal pleasure and grab as many long weekends as they can to get away from it all, making flying visits to the Mediterranean. 
 They have both been occasional golfers, which they still enjoy when on holiday in Spain or Portugal. 
 But although they live on the edge of Wentworth Golf Course, Lady Haslam prefers gardening when at home. 
 Looking back on his varied career, Haslam is somewhat guarded about passing on any pet theories on how to manage at the top. 
 If his successor at British Coal were appointed from within the corporation he considers that it would be impertinent to tell him how the job should be done. 
 He does, however, have some general advice for anyone coming into British Coal from the outside. 
 In this industry you've got to be very much an &bquo;open-door&equo; person. 
 You've got to be prepared to listen to a lot of varied opinions about many difficult problems, assess the people who give you those opinions and at the end of the day you've got to be very decisive and determined. 
 If I analyse the bosses I've worked for, the ones who irritated  me the most were the ones who were indecisive and who constantly asked for more information just to delay making a decision. 
 When you are appointed a chairman of a nationalised industry, you are given clear objectives by your Secretary of State, and you have to see that your immediate colleagues and indeed the whole team are aware of, and are striving to achieve, these objectives. 
 In both British Coal and British Steel I have been enormously impressed by the ability and dedication of my colleagues, particularly when one recognises the totally inadequate rewards they receive in comparison with their opposite numbers in the private sector. 
 Sadly, despite recently introduced performance bonus schemes, this gap is still widening. 
 It is important to create, as I've tried to do at British Coal, a sense of challenge. 
 If I look back on the people who have led me very well in the past, it was those who were able to create and sustain just such a sense of challenge. 
 When I was in the Nobel Division of ICI, the chairman was one of the most diminutive of men. 
 He was about five-feet tall, but he had an enormous ability to make you feel that you had been given a real challenge and it seemed all-important to discharge it to his satisfaction and he was equally praising of your achievement. 
 This is true leadership. 
 You've got to be very conscious too of people's personal problems and relationships. 
 It is particularly important, whatever their preoccupations, that managers find time to discuss and help with such problems. 
 In terms of the business they probably don't matter a great deal, but it's very important if you're going to develop the right team spirit. 
 Sir Hector Laing  
 Born: Edinburgh, 1923. 
 Educated: Loretto School, Scotland; Jesus College, Cambridge. 
 Sir Hector Laing is chairman of United Biscuits (Holdings) plc, a company capitalised at &pound;1.4 bn that employs thirty thousand people and produces five billion food packets every year &mdash; the equivalent to one for every person on earth. 
 He was knighted in the 1978 New Year's Honours List. 
 He joined the family firm of McVitie &dollar; Price in 1947 and became chairman in 1963. 
 He was appointed managing director of United Biscuits in 1964 and took over as chairman in 1972. 
 He is a director of the Bank of England and of Exon Corporation Inc. 
 He is chairman of Business in the Community both in Scotland and England, and is joint-chairman of the Per Cent Club, a group of companies that pledge a proportion of their income to the community. 
 He is governor of the National Institute of Economic and Social Research and a member of the Council for Industry &dollar; Higher Education. 
 From 1977 to 1979 he was chairman of the Food &dollar; Drink Industries Council. 
 He is joint-treasurer of the Conservative Party. 
 There was never a time in Sir Hector Laing's life when it ever occurred to him to work for any other company than the family business, originally called McVitie &dollar; Price and now known as United Biscuits. 
 He was steeped in the business from an early age. 
 When only five years old, he used to go into the bakery with his father before school just for fun. 
 He and his brother would take delight in cutting out oat cakes. 
 At school he did  &bquo;extraordinarily badly&equo; by his own admission and he also failed to obtain a degree in agriculture at Cambridge University, but with his sights firmly fixed on a career in the family business, such academic shortcomings represented no real handicap. 
 He served with the 3rd Battalion of the Scots Guards during the war, but finally, in 1947, he was able to fulfil his long-cherished ambition to savour company life. 
 From the very first day I enjoyed it. 
 There was no doubt in my mind what I would do and I've never regretted going into the business because we've seen it grow enormously. 
 When I joined the company it was capitalised at about &pound;4m and it is now capitalised at about &pound;1.4bn. 
 That has all been great fun. 
 Laing could have added that it is also now a company that employs tens of thousands of people and produces a phenomenal amount of food snacks. 
 It is best known for its mouth-watering digestive biscuits, but some staggering statistics graphically illustrate the incredible production rate at United Biscuits. 
 It produces five billion food packets every year; that's one for every single person on earth. 
 Each week the company produces biscuits equivalent in weight to 1,200 elephants. 
 If the group's total annual output in biscuits were laid edge to edge, they would stretch twice to the moon and back, or forty-eight times around the equator. 
 The United Biscuit's chairman could never have guessed in his early days with the firm that it would grow into such a huge food manufacturer. 
 Then, it only commanded a small proportion of the UK biscuit market. 
 He started by doing stints in the three main factories in London, Manchester and Edinburgh, often working very long hours. 
 For a period, he worked in the Manchester factory from 3am until 5pm, going to bed at 7pm so he could get up in time for the next day's duty. 
 He regards this somewhat gruelling routine as having been a vital part of his training. 
 Part of the advice one would want to give to any young person today is to thoroughly know your business by working on the factory floor. 
 I came to understand fully about making biscuits and if you make things right you  have a chance of selling them &mdash; as the Japanese have amply demonstrated. 
 If you fail to make them right, then all the marketing and computers in the world won't help you. 
 Laing is convinced that businesses which are run by people who have little understanding of the products being made are ultimately doomed to failure. 
 I think the shoemaker should stick to his last. 
 Most of the conglomerates which were made up of a disparate collection of businesses have failed. 
 The best businesses over a long period of time have been the ones with a single thrust. 
 Ours happens to be food. 
 It's a wider range of food than when we started, which was only in biscuits. 
 If you can sell biscuits, you can probably sell crisps, but it doesn't mean to say that if you can sell these you can sell dresses or bicycles. 
 Although Laing started at the bottom of the ladder, he admits that the fact he and his brother inherited control of the business early on in their careers helped them to climb the hierarchy rather swiftly. 
 He took over the firm with some very clear ambitions. 
 In those days it was common for industrialists to go to the United States to learn how major companies should best be run. 
 The Americans were setting the pace. 
 Laing wanted to make such a good job of the London factory that the reverse would be the case &mdash; that the Americans would want to cross the Atlantic to inspect the exemplary way the British ran things. 
 Secondly, I wanted to create a factory where nobody would ever have to do any physical work. 
 We achieved both goals. 
 From 1953 to 1964 we built up that factory into perhaps the second largest of its kind in the world and certainly the largest and best in Europe. 
 Laing's desire to reduce physical exertion stemmed from personal experience during his early days on the shop floor. 
 &bquo;When I started I was carrying flour sacks on my back, digging fat out of boxes, syrup out of barrels, that sort of thing. 
 We were the first to automate all that.&equo; 
 He acknowledges, however, that striving for automation brings other problems in its wake.  
 It tends to make life a bit dull at work and we've tried to come to terms with that. 
 It also has implications in terms of the number of jobs, in that you need far fewer people. 
 When I started it was about two hundred people per ton and now we produce five tons an hour with three people. 
 So it displaces people. 
 On the other hand, if you're making something the world wants, by making it as the lowest cost supplier, you can usually expand your work-force. 
 But even if you can't you have to be the lowest cost supplier if you possibly can. 
 When you are, you've got a good business. 
 A number of key people influenced Laing during his early impressionable years in the company. 
 One was his grandfather, whom he describes as, 
 a compassionate employer &mdash; compassionate by those days' standards, not by today's standards. 
 So one set out with a policy of having good human relations and my friendship with Marcus Sieff (now president of Marks &dollar; Spencer) dating back to 1953 has also had an influence. 
 I think we both recognised early on &mdash; perhaps he before me &mdash; the importance of good human relations and our policies have, I believe, been beneficial to both our businesses. 
 Another mentor Laing remembers with affection was George Miller, who was the sales manager at the London factory, who taught him how important it was to have &bquo;a main thrust&equo; in a business. 
 In our case that was to make a very short list of high-quality biscuits. 
 Before the war, that factory had made 384 different biscuits. 
 We cut it to four and those four are still our major selling products and the foundation of our business. 
 I learned a lot from him and his ability to see what had gone wrong from a sales point of view. 
 Someone who possibly had more influence on Laing than anyone else was the late Sir Douglas Crawford, formerly chairman of Wm Crawford &dollar; Sons, which became part of United Biscuits in 1962 when Sir Douglas became vice-chairman until his  retirement in 1974. 
 Laing thought very highly of Sir Douglas, whom he saw as &bquo;a man of great integrity and absolutely straightforward&equo;. 
 Crawford taught Laing &bquo;the value of low cunning and lovable dimness!&equo; 
 Laing has striven hard over the years to implement the enlightened human relations policies he first learned from his grandfather. 
 He has, for example, adopted a single-status policy at United Biscuits, which, among other things, ensures that the same company pension scheme applies equally to top management and the rank and file. 
 I think you have to look after people both at work and when they retire and we inflation-proofed our pension scheme during the whole of that pretty dreadful time when inflation was running at over twenty per cent. 
 We try to see that conditions at work are such that if I, to make it personal, was working in a particular factory, I would find them as congenial as they could reasonably be. 
 I think if one looks at life and says: &bquo;If I was doing that job, what are the conditions I would like to work in?&equo;, and then put them into operation, people will probably think it's about right. 
 Laing has never felt that being a compassionate employer has been at odds with doing the right thing commercially. 
 Even when it is necessary to close down factories it can be done with compassion, in his view. 
 &bquo;You've got to have a work-force that believes in you. 
 Therefore, you've got to give it leadership and you've got to be seen. 
 I think a business can hardly fail if it's got that sort of spirit. 
 If the work-force is working against you, it can hardly win.&equo; 
 These beliefs were put to the test when United Biscuits was obliged to close one of its main factories in Liverpool. 
 It was a ghastly thing to have to do &mdash; in Liverpool of all places. 
 We took four years to do it, partly so people would get accustomed to the idea, and it was fantastic that during those four years people worked at least as hard and as well as they had in the previous four. 
 We tried every way to find them alternative jobs. 
  The pending closure fell foul of the Church, however, and Laing was confronted with a deputation of protesting bishops. 
 They said what I was doing was terrible and in a way, from the people's point of view, it was. 
 But we employ thirty thousand people and therefore one has to look after the majority, however hard it may be on a relatively few &mdash; one thousand people in that particular case. 
 But it's not something one enjoys doing. 
 In Laing's opinion, a manager becomes increasingly sensitive to the needs of others as he gets older and more experienced. 
 When one is young and brash &mdash; and I think I was brash &mdash; one is inclined to brush people aside because you know what you want and you are determined to get it, whereas when one has seen some of the problems of the world, I think one is probably more tolerant. 
 Motivating employees is another issue to which Laing has given much thought. 
 &bquo;Choose people well, train them well, give them their heads, but you have to monitor their performance as well,, he advises. 
 &bquo;I'm a great delegator, but it is important to delegate to those who are capable of carrying through the task and you must have a good report-back system.&equo; 
 Communicating well to the troops is another important aspect of senior management, in Laing's opinion. 
 He cites the example shown by Viscount Montgomery in World War N. Laing, who fought under the famous military leader, recalls that the troops always had great confidence in him because he was very visible. 
 He told us what he was going to do and we knew some people were going to get killed, but that's just life. 
 It's the same with closing a factory. 
 Some are going to have to go. 
 But if you see the top man around the business you are able to look him in the eye and tell whether you can trust him or not. 
 Laing has applied the Montgomery approach to business. 
 We employ 30,000 people in the UK business and I speak  to 15,000 of them every year in groups of 200 or less, because I think the Japanese have shown what good human relations can achieve. 
 Too many managers in this country want to sit in their offices and write memos. 
 If people can see that you know your job, that you work probably harder than they do, that you communicate with them and tell them what you're doing, they will respect you. 
 They may not like you, but they will respect you and they will work well for you. 
 Laing has developed some rather unconventional methods for communicating to his troops. 
 He used to go around with a jug of orange juice to drum home to people that it is impossible to earn more unless more is produced. 
 I used to pour the orange juice, which represented the added value in our products, into four separate glasses. 
 I poured 70 per cent of it into a glass representing the wages paid to those of us who work in the business, 20 per cent into a glass representing what was ploughed back by way of reinvestment in plant and machinery, 5 per cent into a glass representing dividends and 5 per cent into a glass representing tax. 
 What I tried to teach people was that if we didn't increase the added value, but took more of it and put it in our pockets, the only place we could take it from was the glass marked reinvestment and that makes people unemployed quicker than anything &mdash; and permanently. 
 I think perhaps on the whole people understand that better than they used to. 
 He maintains there are no short cuts to managing effectively. 
 &bquo;The work-force can pick out a fraud very easily or someone who's just glossing things over. 
 It's much better to look people in the eye and tell them the truth.&equo; 
 In Laing's view, getting to the top in management by climbing up through the ranks is fifty per cent luck, but when the opportunities present themselves, they have to be grasped, and that often requires courage. 
 The person who never takes risks never achieves anything in his view. 
 One of his favourite sayings is that:  
 The man who never makes a mistake works for somebody who does. 
 There's got to be an element of the entrepreneur. 
 You've got to be ambitious, not necessarily for yourself, but for your company to be among the best in the world and you've got to strive to get it there. 
 You've got to ensure that your products are really first class and you have to have first-class people at every level. 
 Then you have a first-class business. 
 Laing has never had any problems about getting to grips with long-term strategy. 
 It is not always possible to give adequate thought to the future when caught up in the day-to-day running of an operation, but if you live the business, as Sir Hector unashamedly does, there are always less hectic times to mull over major issues. 
 He tends to ponder on such weighty matters in the bath or while gardening. 
 One of the issues that called for more profound thought than usual was the direction United Biscuits should take after its products had come to command the lion's share of the market and couldn't be expected to squeeze out many more sales. 
 When I started we only had about five per cent of the biscuit trade. 
 We now have close on fifty per cent. 
 When you saw that happening you realised you had to go into other things. 
 The other thing that is important is that I don't think you can get anything on the cheap. 
 Therefore, if you really want to move the business forward and make it a great business, you've got to live it. 
 I tell the young people joining us that the great division in their lives, if they climb in the business, is the division between the company and their family. 
 If they're not very careful, the family will lose out every time and that causes a lot of problems in our society. 
 I think you've got to be fair about how much time you give the family. 
 I ask nobody to work seven days a week or twelve hours a day, except in very limited periods when we all have to. 
 Laing has often been accused of being a workaholic himself, but he denies it. 
 He has an understanding with his wife that weekends are sacrosanct and the couple always enjoy six weeks'  holiday together every year. 
 &bquo;That's not to say when you're gardening or on holiday that the wheels stop turning and you don't have any ideas.&equo; 
 Laing's favourite technique for resolving major business problems is to &bquo;chew things over&equo;. 
 Unlike many top executives, he doesn't believe in committing thorny issues to paper. 
 He prefers instead to hold meetings with his colleagues and to talk things through until a solution emerges. 
 I will sometimes arrange to discuss things on three successive Mondays, for example, or three successive months perhaps, because you never have to take a quick decision in a business, and out of the talking with people who respond to your way of working the right answer very often comes &mdash; the decisions mostly take themselves. 
 One of the few occasions that United Biscuits ever took a hasty decision was when it bought a company in Spain at a time when it felt under pressure to expand into Europe. 
 It was before Spain had joined the Common Market and United Biscuits' efforts to acquire a suitable company in one of the EEC countries had come to nought. 
 Laing admits that the Spanish company was bought out of desperation and it cost United Biscuits dearly. 
 We regretted the decision for the next ten years. 
 It taught me the lesson that you should never do something because you feel you've got to. 
 You should wait until the right opportunity comes along. 
 You should look for the right company if you're intending to buy one, the right situation in the right country and then move quickly. 
 But don't just jump in because you feel you've got to. 
 The top executive who is constantly looking ahead rather than backwards will rarely steer his company into a tight corner, in Laing's view. 
 He suggests the top man should repeatedly be asking himself: &bquo;What if&hellip;?&equo; 
 Because if you don't say &bquo;What if?&equo; you'll be saying: &bquo;If only&hellip;&equo; 
 Laing points out that this approach generates a lot of ideas, many of which will be worthless, as happens in a brainstorming session. 
 But, he maintains, if you don't throw up a lot of worthless ideas you are unlikely to come up with sensible ones either.  
 Laing pauses to collect his thoughts when considering what was perhaps the most difficult decision of his long career. 
 He eventually concludes that it involved another acquisition &mdash; this time the American firm of Keebler in 1974. 
 We paid over &dollar;50m for it, and that, for a small British company in those days going into a market where British companies hadn't been notably successful, was seen as a very big commitment. 
 Our shares plummeted because the City felt we had taken a great risk. 
 But it turned out to be one of the most marvellous things we ever did. 
 It has done so much for us. 
 Not only has it made a very good profit, but getting a bit of the American ethos into the business has been a good thing as well. 
 He was, however, disappointed when in 1985 a planned merger with the Imperial Group failed to go ahead. 
 The merger would have resulted in by far and away Britain's largest food company and placed it among the world league of major food groups, capitalised at around &pound;5bn. 
 But the grand design was torpedoed when Lord Hanson made a bid for Imperial that shareholders found impossible to resist. 
 The government also intervened on the grounds that a small part of the proposed merger, relating to the crisp business, contravened the monopolies law. 
 The idea behind trying to get together with Imperial was to create a world-size food company with, as it happened, tobacco money to back it up, because the cashflow from tobacco is much more than the tobacco business actually requires to sustain it. 
 I was going to be chairman and chief executive and Bob Clarke, my chief executive, was going to run the food side. 
 That seemed to me to be a nice balance &mdash; good for our shareholders, good for our company and good for the country, as I saw it. 
 Laing does not blame the shareholders for opting for the Hanson offer. 
 But as far as Great Britain Ltd was concerned and building a food industry that would have a major part to play  in China and Brazil and other developing countries, I was sorry the shareholders took the view that they did. 
 What I do criticise is the City taking a short-term view. 
 I find it galling that they seem to keep looking for jam today. 
 We are not going to establish British companies across Europe, let alone across the world, if our monopolies legislation disallows mergers of major companies within one industry &mdash; the only way they are going to be strong enough to do it. 
 The problem is compounded when we allow our leading businesses &mdash; Rowntree and perhaps Cadbury's and others &mdash; to be bought up by foreign predators so that our muscle is destroyed. 
 Anyone running a major company in Britain today needs to be keenly aware of the international scene in Laing's opinion. 
 We are only fifty million people in this country and if you're going to run a decent-size business at all, you need to be looking at the horizon. 
 This may sound harsh, but it seems to me that when we lost our empire our eyes came down from the horizon and looked at our feet. 
 Since 1979 we have just begun to have confidence in ourselves to raise our eyes to the horizon again. 
 If we had paid more attention to what the Japanese were doing we would perhaps not be so subject to their products as we are. 
 Laing broadens his horizons by travelling a lot and by taking part in a large number of outside activities. 
 &bquo;I think you should get to know as many people as you can the further up the business you are,&equo; he says. 
 He travels to the US at least once a month and enjoys getting out and about. 
 &bquo;I travel in comfort,&equo; he adds to explain why he finds it less of a hassle than many businessmen. 
 &bquo;I travel first class and I take Concorde whenever I can. 
 I think it's important to keep your eyes open. 
 It's not enough to say  that things can be done differently or better. 
 You have to see them first hand. 
 I suppose it's called &bquo;Management by Walking About&equo;.&equo; 
 As a director of the Bank of England, Laing, who confesses that finance has never been his strong point, broadens his horizons on  the economic front. 
 While he could equally get the information from other sources, he finds that &bquo;going there every week, you hear about what's going on, which is a great help.&equo; 
 Laing has some strong convictions about the role major companies should play in the community as a whole. 
 He is chairman of Business in the Community and of the Scottish BIC, an organisation that supports enterprise agencies and arranges the secondment of experienced senior executives to fledgling small firms. 
 He believes that the financial support companies give to charitable works can, and should, be quantified. 
 To do something concrete in this direction, Laing hit on the idea of forming what he wanted to call the One Per Cent Club, all the corporate members of which would pledge one per cent of their UK pre-tax income to the community. 
 Unable to persuade other firms to commit to such a specific amount, he arrived at a compromise by forming the Per Cent Club, which has 120 corporate members giving not less than a half per cent of their annual UK pre-tax income to the community. 
 United Biscuits have pledged a one per cent contribution, which in 1988 amounted to &pound;1m. 
 Critics of the idea argue that companies can achieve the same purpose by paying out good dividends, but Laing questions whether much of this money finds its way back into the community. 
 When I was a youngster much charitable giving came from wealthy families. 
 As they became progressively more heavily taxed, that responsibility, instead of going to companies, went to government and government has been seen to do it very badly. 
 So we are now getting it back into the corporate sector. 
 Laing feels strongly that the chief executive of a company should define, as he has done at United Biscuits, exactly what its responsibilities to the community are. 
 He should make it known within the company that this is one of his priorities, that the whole board supports it and that a percentage of the profits should be devoted to it. 
 Not only do we do that at United Biscuits, we also second one manager for every two thousand employees. 
 So we've got  fifteen to sixteen managers seconded to various bodies in this country that need help. 
 Laing rejects the view held by some people that managers from major corporations are unsuitable for giving advice to small firms because they live in two different worlds. 
 If you take one of our accountants who might spend a day a month with a small business, the fact that the business is small and we're big doesn't matter at all. 
 The governing factors, whether it be marketing or computers or finance, are the same for a big or small company. 
 The scale of the problems will be different, but a chap who can run ICI, if he can be bothered to help a small business, will do it very well from his experience. 
 Laing accepts that to some extent he was born with a silver spoon in his mouth. 
 &bquo;I've never had a money worry,&equo; he admits in all honesty, 
 and of course that's very lucky, but it's also a responsibility. 
 It's what you do with the money that counts. 
 In a lot of families, if you've plenty of money when you're young you question the necessity of work. 
 My ethos was I've got a lot of money, but I've got to look after the people as far as I can who have helped to produce it and I am going to make it grow bigger for our successors. 
 The oak tree has got to grow all the time. 
 &bquo;That probably sounds pompous,&equo; adds Laing apologetically, reflecting on what he had just said. 
 &bquo;I love our business and I take great pride in it. 
 I was lucky being a major shareholder. 
 Of course my salary is important to me, but it doesn't give me my life style. 
 That has come from the family.&equo; 
 Inheriting wealth has not led Laing into a flamboyant lifestyle by any means. 
 His two concessions to luxury appear to be a passion for fast cars &mdash; he is the proud owner of a turbo-Bentley &mdash; and a 5,000 acre estate in Scotland. 
 Apart from that, his life is devoid of ostentation. 
 &bquo;What my wife and I really like doing are the very simple things, like gardening and walking,&equo; he adds. 
  &bquo;We go abroad for a week or ten days every year, but I think we have a very simple life compared with many. 
 We don't have luxury yachts or go to expensive hotels all the time.&equo; 
 Laing also has very modest tastes in food. 
 He favours the plain dishes when eating at home, such as a plate of mince, sardines, spaghetti or bacon and eggs. 
 &bquo;But every now and again it's jolly nice to go out and have an absolutely top-class meal in a super restaurant,&equo; he adds with relish. 
 Laing acknowledges that the up-and-coming generation of managers are faced with a much faster-paced world than operated in most of his life, but he is not convinced it is any more difficult to be an executive today than in the past. 
 He points to the fact that the Atlantic can now be crossed in three and a half hours as indisputable evidence that the pace has hotted up, but in his view, the next generation will assimilate such changes. 
 It's interesting that if you have a machine wrapping biscuits at 50 a minute and it is increased to 70 a minute, the operators who have been doing it at 50 find it very difficult to adapt, but the new operators who come in at 70 cope with it easily. 
 It's just like young people today dealing with computers. 
 They are all growing up with the computer effortlessly. 
 The United Biscuits chairman is, however, concerned that today's executive finds himself working in a business environment that appears to be in danger of moral decline. 
 He recently drew up an ethics policy for United Biscuits, which he expects all his managers to endorse, because &bquo;as a business becomes bigger and bigger &mdash; we now have operations in Japan, America and Belgium as well as the UK &mdash; I think the family ethics drawn up by the founders can gradually get eroded or watered down.&equo; 
 Another concern of Laing's is the shift from private to institutional shareholders. 
 Fund managers are intent on doing their best for their funds and have no interest whatsoever in the businesses they invest in or the people who are producing the profits. 
 I am not saying this is universal, of course, but I think the pressure from the City on industry to maximise profits tends to make them take short cuts. 
 One reason I have written  this code of ethics is that no one has to take short cuts ever. 
 You have to keep the City informed about what's going on, but I think you can run a business &mdash; and I hope we do &mdash; to the highest moral standards whether it's today or in the 1900s. 
 Laing feels the problem is exacerbated by the tendency today for the corporate world to live in the short term. 
 In the UK and the US a company's financial performance is judged at quarterly intervals. 
 Laing believes that countries like Japan and West Germany which take a more long-term attitude to performance are less subjected to such pressures. 
 I believe in a competitive world, but at the same time I think we have got to be laying sound foundations for future growth and if we are constantly pressured into satisfying stock-market expectations, which are short-term, or under threat of take-over, we will not be investing enough for the long-term development of our businesses. 
 Laing is convinced that the future generation of managers need have no fear of what lays in store from the so-called post-industrial society. 
 He simply doesn't believe in it. 
 &bquo;I've heard it said that we are going to be a service economy. 
 Well, we can't be a service economy because that doesn't actually make anything.&equo; 
 Rather, Laing believes the UK has got to reassert itself as a manufacturing economy. 
 Make what the world wants and the world will come for it. 
 Look at the mess British Steel got into. 
 It's now one of the best steel companies in the world. 
 The errors we made in the 1960s and 1970s can, and are, being corrected. 
 OK, give it ten years and perhaps only 20 per cent will be producing what 60 per cent or 70 per cent were twenty-five years ago. 
 We can go on producing more and more with less and less people. 
 I can see the day when our London factory will be totally automatic. 
 This, Laing believes, will demand an entirely different approach to work with the emphasis on flexibility.  
 I'm going to say something which the Church won't like &mdash; and I go to church every Sunday. 
 Our plants have got to work seven days a week, but with people working a four-day week. 
 Or you can forget the week as a unit of work altogether and you can say: &bquo;I will contract you for a certain number of hours.&equo; 
 The company has then got to say: &bquo;If you want to take three months&equo; holiday, good luck to you provided the contracted hours are worked.&equo; 
 The plants have got to keep going, but I think we can make working hours much more flexible. 
 Laing would also like to see a fundamental reappraisal of the way unions operate. 
 &bquo;1 would like to see the union structure changed totally,&equo; he says uncompromisingly. 
 We don't want trades  unions, we want unions. 
 The food industry should have one union, just like in Japan and West Germany &mdash; and then totally flexible hours. 
 I think you could play so many tunes on it that not only would we be producing much more efficiently and economically, but people could have a better quality of life too. 
 Giving employees a greater say in how their companies operate could be an important step towards such a goal, but Laing is opposed to the appointment of worker directors, as is the practice in Scandinavia. 
 &bquo;I think everybody who joins a company in any capacity should, if he's got the capability, be able to reach board level. 
 But I don't think you should just appoint somebody and say he's a worker director. 
 I just don't believe in that.&equo; 
 Laing firmly believes, however, in assisted share purchase and profit-sharing schemes, which give all employees the opportunity to share in a company's financial achievements. 
 He also maintains that if the brain drain is to be halted there needs to be an upward hike in salaries in Britain. 
 While he considers that salaries in the City have grown out of all proportion, he is convinced that corporate managers are falling behind in the remuneration they receive. 
 If we want to keep the best scientists and the best engineers in this country, we'd better do two things: we'd better attract  them with good pay and we'd better train them right and give them the proper facilities. 
 As we become richer as a country we shall be able to do all these things. 
 We did get damn poor, you know. 
 Laing still has one outstanding ambition before he retires. 
 Having seen United Biscuits &bquo;gain a toehold in Brazil&equo;, he would like to see the company expand into China. 
 He faces the prospect of retirement with the same level-headed commonsense approach with which he has tackled most of the issues that have confronted him in his long career. 
 I have been in the company forty years. 
 I've been chief executive and/or chairman for twenty-five years and the tendency is to think you're indispensable and you have to stay on until you're seventy-five, as some people do. 
 I think one wants to go at a time when people still want you to stay, rather than stay until people want you to go. 
 If you've been pretty dominant in a company I don't think you know when that time has actually arrived. 
 So I shall go when people rather wished I stayed in a way. 
 But it's your responsibility to see that your successors are properly groomed to take over. 
 But there's no question of Laing fading completely from the corporate scene. 
 I'm not going to sit back and watch TV. 
 In retirement I hope my company will provide me with an office and a secretary, so that I can go on contributing to society from my experience. 
 I would like to work on lots of things in the inner cities and the community. 
 Sir Austin Pearce 
 Born: Plymouth, Devon, 1921. 
 Educated: Devonport High School. 
 Birmingham University. 
 Sir Austin Pearce is a former chairman of Esso Petroleum Co and British Aerospace. 
 He was knighted in 1980. 
 He joined AGWI Petroleum Co, later to become Esso, in 1945 as a technical assistant at Fawley Refinery. 
 He became managing director of Esso in 1968 and was chairman from 1972 to 1980. 
 He was president of the Institute of Petroleum from 1968 to 1970 and president of the UK Petroleum Industries Association from 1979 to 1980. 
 In 1976 he became a member of the organising committee charged with the responsibility of welding a disparate group of UK aircraft companies into the nationalised British Aerospace group. 
 Four years later, as chairman of BAe, he was asked by the government to prepare the group for privatisation. 
 From 1982 to 1983, he was president of the Society of British Aerospace Companies. 
 He is vice-chairman of the Royal Bank of Scotland and was chairman of Williams &dollar; Glyn's Bank from 1983 to 1985. 
 He is chairman of Oxford Instruments Group and a nonexecutive director of Pearl Group, Jaguar and Smiths Industries. 
 He was a member of the President's Advisory Committee of the Confederation of British Industry from 1982 to 1988 and is currently a member of the Takeover Panel. 
 In addition, he is chairman of the trustees of the Science museum and pro-chancellor of Surrey University. 
 Someone once asked Sir Austin Pearce when he first decided to become chairman of Esso. 
 He answered that it was when the job  was offered to him. 
 His entire career in industry seems to have been a series of opportunities seized with relish. 
 Not for him the carefully charted route to the top. 
 &bquo;If I'm given a challenge I have to have a go at it,&equo; he admits, reflecting on the guiding principles that have taken him to the top of two major industries. 
 &bquo;I've had a number of opportunities and taking them, particularly in the oil industry, has sometimes been a desperate gamble.&equo; 
 His eyes light up at the recollection of some of the challenges he has tackled that would have daunted the more faint-hearted. 
 There was one classic occasion when the flare went out at Fawley refinery. 
 It burned at the top of a 25Oft stack and we tried all sorts of things to get it to light again. 
 In the end there was only one way of doing it and that was climbing up there with a match and a long piece of wire. 
 A fitter and I went up and did just that. 
 I wouldn't do it today. 
 Just think what could have happened. 
 It could have turned us into a cinder. 
 When he retired as chairman of British Aerospace in the summer of 1987, Pearce had spent forty-two years in industry, all but ten weeks in management, which must make him something of an authority on the subject. 
 He also underwent the unique experience of being asked by successive governments to take a hand in both the nationalisation of British Aerospace and its subsequent return to the private sector. 
 He has thus learned what qualities are necessary to run a business both under the bureaucratic yoke of government red tape and in the cut and thrust of the world of international competition. 
 Yet he started his career with a very modest ambition. 
 In his last year at Devonport High School in Plymouth he set himself the aim of finding a job which would earn him &pound;5 a week, because up to that time, his father, a Westcountryman, had never achieved such a princely sum. 
 It seemed to Pearce that the best way to gain his goal was to go into the Civil Service, which was the career that most of the more successful pupils from his school tended ti follow. 
 &bquo;I was under pressure from my grandfather to become a teacher and that's the last thing I wanted to be. 
 I knew quite a number of people who had gone into the Civil Service and it seemed a good thing to get into.&equo;  
 Ironically, fate intervened and he never did make that his career, which is probably just as well, since when he was given the task many years later of steering British Aerospace into the private sector he crossed swords with more than a few civil servants and didn't have a lot of time for them. 
 The reason he never became one himself is very simple. 
 Germany marched into Poland on his eighteenth birthday and the Civil Service entrance examination he was scheduled to take was cancelled. 
 He was then left with two alternatives &mdash; going into the forces or to university. 
 He was advised by his teacher to choose the latter and it was suggested that he should go to Oxford and read chemistry. 
 He applied for, and won, several scholarships, but was particularly attracted to a scholarship in oil engineering that was on offer from Birmingham University. 
 His teachers at his Plymouth school threw scorn on the idea of going to a redbrick university when he could have chosen Oxford, but he felt a strong pull towards oil engineering and displayed the stubborn streak that was later to characterise his industrial career. 
 I read oil engineering which was primarily on the production side and out of a course of thirteen, I was the only one who was interested in the chemical side of it &mdash; the refining side. 
 I just loved the idea of being able to use my chemistry in the design side of things. 
 The two things just clicked. 
 His research work at the university's petroleum warfare department led indirectly to him joining Esso, and within weeks he was faced with one of the many challenges that were to punctuate his rise to the top of the industry. 
 Because of the nature of his studies he was sent to work at the Esso refinery at Fawley. 
 &bquo;I joined the refinery straight from university, never having been anywhere near the place before, and within ten weeks I was actually in charge of my own shift. 
 I was certainly plunged into the deep end.&equo; 
 But he couldn't resist the challenge. 
 The way people tackle things is very much the influence of their background and each will achieve things in different ways. 
 I suppose one of the key factors of my whole industrial career has been that if an opportunity comes up, I grab it.  
 It could be argued that on occasions I've taken on things which probably I haven't done as well out of financially as I might have done if I'd done something else. 
 But to me the excitement of the job is so much that if something comes along, I don't think twice. 
 Accepting the refinery job meant that Pearce was able to exceed his &pound;5 a week goal by &pound;1, but it was still a meagre wage for the amount of responsibility he shouldered. 
 In 1945 I was paid &pound;6 a week. 
 I had a PhD. 
 I was in charge of a refinery on my own. 
 I was the lowest paid person on the refinery. 
 But the experience I had was fantastic and it didn't take long before my salary was considerably more than that. 
 If I hadn't taken that opportunity I'm sure I would never have done the things I later did in the refinery business. 
 He had no burning ambition to climb to the upper reaches of management in those early days, however. 
 He recalls vividly being told shortly after he took the job at Fawley refinery that an Esso director would be calling to see him. 
 He had to ask what exactly a director was. 
 But the lessons he learned from those formative years were to stand him in good stead later on when he was to understand what it meant to be a director from first-hand experience. 
 When I was put in charge of the start-up at Fawley at the ripe old age of twenty-nine most of my team were people who were twenty years older than I was and being on shift with a lot of operating people taught me the problems and the realisation that I could learn a hell of a lot from them &mdash; the realisation that the chap on the shop floor usually knows far more about what's going on than management does. 
 It also taught him the importance of training. 
 He discovered that learning could be a two-way process. 
 He had a lot to learn about operating methods from the people on the shop floor, but he could also pass on to them the fruits of his university education. 
 He discovered, for example, that laboratory technicians at Fawley were carrying out chemical tests without really  understanding what it was they were doing. 
 Pearce offered to fill in the gaps in their knowledge. 
 At about 2am I used to go up to the lab. 
 It was a quiet time and I would sit these fellows down for half an hour and take them through what they were doing. 
 They were then prepared to help me. 
 I was green at my job and some of them had been around twenty-five to thirty years doing this sort of work. 
 I learned an awful lot from them. 
 Pearce is convinced the experience of those early years had important universal lessons of which any young graduate entering industry today ought to take heed. 
 I believe any young graduate would get an awful lot of value from working with people on the shop floor. 
 A lot of people today say it's not necessary. 
 I'm afraid we have a lot of people in top management today whose background is such that they don't really get involved with people on the shop floor. 
 I'm talking in the manufacturing sense. 
 Of course a lot of industries today are changing and they don't have as many people on the shop floor anyway and you have many more people who are systems analysts and people like that. 
 But I think it s very important top management should get to know some of the problems those people have too, because if they're not doing it right, the company could be in trouble. 
 But this depends very much on your personality. 
 Some people are very good at it; some people aren't. 
 Some people communicate easily; some don't. 
 In some respects, you have to determine what your strong characteristics are and then use them. 
 In Pearce's experience it is easy for top management to become remote from the shop floor and lose contact with the centre of operations. 
 It's just the pressure you work under. 
 The things you have to do make it progressively more and more difficult for you to really get around and see what's going on in your factories. 
 Take British Aerospace with its twenty different locations.  
 Each of them requires a complete day out to go and visit them and it's very difficult to find a complete day because there are so many other things, so many other demands on your time. 
 I would have loved to have spent more time out there where the action is, but it just wasn't practical. 
 Pearce nevertheless made a point of visiting every single British Aerospace factory at one time or another during his seven years as chairman, some of them more than once. 
 As Pearce progressed in his career, he found that there was a discernible shift in his management priorities. 
 As a refinery supervisor or a supervisor out in one of the British Aerospace factories, you have to get things out that day. 
 There, you're concentrating on getting the job done. 
 It's much more of a hands-on style. 
 The further up the line you get, the longer your time horizon becomes. 
 As a chairman, I didn't have to worry about finding a particular part to put in a piece of kit to make it work. 
 But I did have to worry about whether we were going to have the cash flow in ten years' time to make sure that the parts can be paid for so the chap on the shop floor can stick the thing together. 
 Pearce considers that one of the main priorities of any top executive should be to develop the managers under him. 
 One of his great disappointments at British Aerospace, he confesses, was that: 
 I was not successful in getting the system going as I would really have liked. 
 This was because there are so many old Spanish customs within the company and rigidities of thinking which take a hell of a lot of changing when you're talking about people. 
 Since I've understood what management was about &mdash; I suppose that must have been back in the early 1950s &mdash; I've had the philosophy that if I go into a job I must do it better than the bloke who's been doing it before me. 
 I've also adopted the philosophy that I must develop somebody to do my job better than I have done it. 
 I don't always succeed in doing that. 
  Pearce could have done with more than the seven years he had at British Aerospace to achieve the kind of management culture he would have liked to have bequeathed to the company. 
 But he has little hesitation in declaring that his successor as chairman of Esso has done a better job than he was able to achieve. 
 Unashamedly blowing his own trumpet, he also considers that many of the people he selected for management roles in Esso are doing a better job than the people before them. 
 &bquo;They're better trained, better educated. 
 They have many more management techniques, which we didn't have &mdash; which we've given them &mdash; and of course they've got new ideas coming along as well., Pearce's own progression within Esso was a series of the grasped opportunities he talks about enthusiastically. 
 He next became assistant refinery manager and was then promoted to general manager over the head of a friend and colleague who was ten years older. 
 There was a momentary hesitation while he considered the implications, but it was one of the many challenges he couldn't let go. 
 He held the job for five years and became heavily involved in building Esso's Milford Haven refinery and the new Irish refinery. 
 Then one day he was sent for by the refining director and given twenty-four hours to make up his mind about a posting to the United States. 
 He had been earmarked for senior management and his posting to the US was intended to serve a double purpose. 
 It would give the American parent group a chance to examine his potential at close quarters and at the same time he would be able to undergo some training to prepare him for the more elevated positions he was destined to occupy in future. 
 Despite the domestic chaos caused from being given such short notice, Pearce again rose to the challenge and had moved with his family to the US within six weeks. 
 But he found that the job that awaited him there was several rungs lower than the job he had been holding down in the UK. 
 He astounded his American masters by demanding that they give him a more worthwhile job or he would be on his way home. 
 He ended up as a departmental head with two other jobs besides. 
 When he returned to the UK he was eventually appointed to the board, but not, as might have been expected, in charge of the refinery side of the business. 
 He was made responsible for marine operations, an area of the business totally new to him.  
 Pearce pauses for reflection when asked to define the qualities which took him to the top with such apparent ease. 
 But he seems to have no doubts about his answer: 
 I think there's got to be determination, consistency, the ability to listen to other people and then make your mind up and stick to it. 
 You can do that in a variety of ways. 
 Some people would do it in a very extrovert way. 
 That's not my way of doing it. 
 I prefer to work quietly behind the scenes. 
 Usually, I know exactly what I want, but it is much better if you can get other people to do it and let them take the credit. 
 I think I can say that during my career most of the things I've decided ought to be done, I've got done, but I've done them in very different ways to other people and sometimes I've been criticised for not going out and grabbing the headlines. 
 That's not me. 
 Engineering change through quiet persuasion nevertheless requires clear-cut goals and a strong sense of direction. 
 Pearce lists these as two important qualities for a top manager together with being able to look at a problem and see the two or three key factors. 
 &bquo;You have to say &bquo;to hell with the rest of it; that's what you've got to deal with&equo;.&equo; 
 This was precisely the approach Pearce adopted when he was asked by the Conservative Government to become chairman of British Aerospace in 1980 to prepare it for privatisation. 
 Ironically, five years earlier he had been asked by Eric Varley, the Labour Government's Energy Secretary, to serve on the committee for overseeing the nationalisation of the company. 
 He was very clear in his mind, however, about what steps needed to be taken to make the company fit for the private sector. 
 &bquo;One was we had to take an international outlook rather than being a purely British company. 
 The other was trying to find a mechanism to sell more., Another example of the ability to see the wood from the trees can be drawn from the time he was asked to take charge of Esso's marine operations. 
 When I took on the marine operations every ship had a fiftyfour man crew and it seemed to me that this was inefficient,  so I did a trip on a ship and I came back quite convinced you could actually run a ship with twenty-one men. 
 You also had to maintain things, so I came up with the figure of thirty-one. 
 Everyone in the whole marine department just threw up their hands in horror and told me I was crazy, I didn't know the first thing about ships, the whole marine fleet would fall apart. 
 I also wanted to get the organisation out of London down to Fawley, which is where you have the ships. 
 You can't get many into London! 
 Again, by exercising his powers of persuasion and sticking to his guns, Pearce's view prevailed and he succeeded in both aims. 
 I suppose I've been lucky with my training, having been an engineer. 
 I could look at all these things and say that's just not the right way to do it. 
 It would be better for doing it this way. 
 And you've got to be stubborn. 
 There's no question about it. 
 Part of the reason Pearce decided to accept the request to head up British Aerospace was that he had been thirty-five years with Esso, eight as chairman. 
 He welcomed the opportunity to move to a British company and he felt in any case that eight years was probably long enough at the top of any major company. 
 That, in his view, is long enough to be able to come up with new ideas and see them implemented. 
 After that, a top executive tends to get stale, in Pearce's opinion, because &bquo;you're seeing the same problems coming up for the second, third or even fourth time and you begin to think you've done it all before. 
 But you haven't because the world's changed.&equo; 
 He was advised not to overstay his tenure at the head of Esso in unusual circumstances. 
 It happened while he was still managing director of the company in charge of the fleet. 
 A new tanker, the Esso Northumbria , the first of its kind, was being launched by Princess Anne at her first public engagement. 
 When the ceremony was over, Pearce was the last to leave the boatyard at Newcastle. 
 He climbed into the bus that was taking him and the company's guests back to the hotel and he sat next to someone he did not recognise in the only seat left vacant. 
 This person turned to him and asked how old he was. 
 Pearce  said he was forty-nine. 
 The stranger predicted Pearce would be chairman by the time he was fifty. 
 Pearce expressed surprise and said that this was the first he had heard of it. 
 The stranger asked him to promise one thing: &bquo;Don't stay in the job for more than ten years, because you'll get stale. 
 You won't be doing a good thing either for yourself or your company.&equo; 
 The man who offered this piece of advice turned out to be Lord Cole, who was chairman of Unilever at the time and went on to be chairman of Rolls-Royce and several other major companies. 
 Pearce laughs heartily at the recollection. 
 But he has heeded the advice. 
 As a general rule ten years is long enough, but of course it depends on the individual and it depends on the company too. 
 If you are running your own company which you own and have built up from scratch you have a different approach to somebody like myself who's a professional manager. 
 That's what I am, let's face it. 
 It doesn't matter whether I like it or not; it's a fact of life. 
 I didn't own the companies I worked for. 
 I've got a few shares in British Aerospace, but nobody would notice if I sold them all. 
 Pearce believes a professional manager can be equally successful at running a variety of companies, but he needs to be selective about the switches he makes. 
 I could switch from oil, which has a chemical background, to the chemical industry. 
 I think I could go to the food industry or to the brewing industry. 
 I'm an engineer by training, so I could move into something like British Aerospace. 
 But could I switch to be chairman of Burtons, for example? 
 That's a very different sort of activity. 
 It's possible but it would not be a very natural switch. 
 Pearce's switch to British Aerospace was helped by the fact that he had been a non-executive director of the aerospace company for three years prior to the move. 
 But being a nationalised company the chairman's salary was fixed and the &pound;80,000 annual remuneration Pearce was receiving as chairman of Esso was cut in half overnight. 
 He did have the advantage,  however, of pursuing a single specific goal &mdash; that of taking the company through privatisation. 
 Although he had helped to set up British Aerospace as a nationalised company, he was convinced it could not take on the huge rival plane-makers in the United States unless it was unfettered from government control. 
 Basically, my objective was to ensure that British Aerospace stayed in business somehow. 
 I had agreed with the necessity of BAC and Hawker Siddeley being put together in one company, but having a nationalised company that involved a lot of civil servants and politicians was a ghastly inefficient way of doing things. 
 A lot of people involved, a number of ministers and most of the civil servants, were delightful people, very charming people, but they weren't trained to run an organisation. 
 They didn't think in the right way. 
 It was unfair to them, quite frankly. 
 There were quite a few battles before Pearce got British Aerospace on the road to privatisation, particularly with civil servants and &bquo;officials who were not really responsible, but tended to sit on the sidelines criticising and always coming up with a reason why you couldn't do anything.&equo; 
 Positive thinking is another cause Pearce has always tried to promote. 
 If you produce a proposal, the first thing a lot of British engineers will do is tell you what's wrong with it. 
 That, I regret, is a British characteristic. 
 I wish they would adopt the positive principle of looking at something and seeing the good in it &mdash; seeing how it can be improved by building up the positive aspects. 
 The British engineer tends to look at something and knock it down. 
 Pearce also met with a considerable degree of resistance from within British Aerospace in his efforts to steer it through privatisation. 
 There were individual factory loyalties and there were divisional loyalties and it had been a pretty cosy relationship between the organisation and the Ministry of Defence. 
 So  why destroy it? 
 It's very important for a chairman or chief executive to recognise that the world is going to change. 
 A lot of people just think by definition the world is going to carry on as it is today, but it doesn't. 
 You've got to try and guess what's going to happen in three, four or five years' time. 
 The chairman of a company like British Aerospace has to anticipate change on a global scale. 
 He has to look at everything from an international perspective. 
 For Pearce, with his strong belief in personal contacts, that has meant a lot of travel to different parts of the world. 
 It has also meant visiting customers worldwide, but he admits that his greatest pleasure came from meeting the company's own employees around the globe. 
 I had to meet customers and politicians and people like that, but the greatest thrill for me is meeting our own people, letting then know we hadn't forgotten them and getting ideas from them, hearing what they think about the company and things like that. 
 That involved a fair amount of travel. 
 I don't enjoy getting from point A to point B. The last place I want to go to is an airport. 
 Getting the right balance in life is important to Pearce. 
 He has always been careful to balance his busy executive life with a strong interest in extramural activities. 
 He has been particularly keen on educational pursuits. 
 He is pro-chancellor of the University of Surrey and chairman of the trustees of the Science Museum in South Kensington. 
 He believes that industrialists have a lot to offer academic institutions in helping them to manage their resources. 
 All the universities today are under enormous pressure financially. 
 The government's giving them less and less to work with. 
 It's a question of giving them help in areas where they may not traditionally have had expertise. 
 As far as the Science Museum is concerned it's a question of helping it with the whole game of raising finance and all the other things they have to do. 
 One of the things museums are going to have to do in future is take over their buildings.  
 Curators are not used to coping with that. 
 They don't have a clue what maintenance of buildings is all about. 
 The PSA has always done it in the past. 
 Now they've got to do it for themselves. 
 They don't know where to start. 
 Pearce has found that his involvement in so many outside bodies has helped to broaden his knowledge and outlook. 
 In his Esso days he was invited to join the board of Williams &dollar; Glyn. 
 He found that it opened a window on the City that he would otherwise never have had. 
 It meant he could go and talk to the governor of the Bank of England and the chairmen of any of the clearing banks whenever he felt the need. 
 When he was approached to run British Aerospace the government insisted he should give up the directorship of W&dollar;G, but Pearce, displaying his usual resolve, wouldn't hear of it. 
 He felt the contact was so invaluable that he was prepared to turn down the job at the head of one of the UK's premier blue-chip companies if it meant making such a sacrifice. 
 Pearce is not convinced that it is any tougher to be a top executive today than in the past, despite the faster pace and greater complexity of modern business activities. 
 You've got to deal with different problems, there's no question about that. 
 They're on a worldwide scale rather than a national scale, but you have to recognise that there are only so many hours in the day in which you can be efficient. 
 Therefore you've got to be selective in what you do and you've got to be the right person to deal with those things, of course. 
 And you have to be updated periodically, more so than in the past. 
 Nor does Pearce believe up-and-coming managers should be put off by the apparent decline in moral standards of business. 
 He believes standards have only slipped in the case of a few companies, but that the press tends to seize on these examples and blow them up out of all proportion. 
 He asserts that in the majority of businesses the moral standards have improved very significantly. 
 But the media only pick out the failures, because that's what  we as readers want to read. 
 You can blame the media, but really you ought to blame the readers. 
 No matter where you are, there are always a few black sheep. 
 The snag today is that those black sheep will create much bigger problems than they could in the past. 
 What specific advice would Pearce pass on to the next generation of senior executives? 
 Make damn sure you've got the right people in the right place, so they do the work rather than you. 
 You've got to concentrate on financial control, on your customer and on your people. 
 These are the three main areas. 
 Anita Roddick  
 Born: Littlehampton, Sussex, 1942. 
 Educated.: Worthing High School for Girls,; Bath College of Education. 
 Anita Roddick is managing director of The Body Shop International plc, a group of more than three hundred cosmetic shops in thirty-three countries, stretching from the Arctic Circle to Australia. 
 The company claims to have a larger presence abroad than any other British retailer, trading in thirteen different languages. 
 Roddick experienced her first taste of trading as a child while serving in the family caf&eacute; in Littlehampton in Sussex, which is now the centre of her worldwide retailing empire. 
 Before going into the cosmetic business she was a teacher, and worked for the United Nations in Geneva. 
 It was while travelling around the world for the UN that she first became impressed with the simple forms of cosmetics made from natural ingredients used by remote communities. 
 When she returned to the UK, however, she entered into the restaurant and hotel business with her husband Gordon. 
 Looking for a less demanding occupation, she opened the first Body Shop in a tiny premises in a back street of Brighton in 1976, selling fifteen different products in plastic bottles with hand-written labels. 
 She set up the business with a &pound;4,000 bank loan and shortage of capital persuaded her to expand through franchising. 
 The decision set in motion a chain reaction that was to become an international phenomenon &mdash; hundreds of shops, all a mirror image of her original concept no matter where in the world they are located. 
 The Body Shop went public in 1984 and the company's shares have consistently dazzled City analysts with their high performance. 
 As one leading business magazine put it.: &bquo;Body Shop's star in the City is not so much rising as super-glued to the roof  of the firmament.&equo; 
 The same magazine declared The Body Shop the second fastest growing medium-sized business in Britain in a survey of two hundred firms. 
 This is particularly remarkable when it is considered that Roddick has made no acquisitions and has no major plans for diversification. 
 She was awarded the OBE in the 1988 New Year's Honours List. 
 Anita Roddick has made a virtue of flying in the face of business convention. 
 She seems to thrive on heretical statements and swimming against the tide: &bquo;I look at what the cosmetic trade is doing and walk in the opposite direction,&equo; she declares with the kind of outspoken defiance that has made her a retailing legend in the decade it took her to turn The Body Shop into a worldwide phenomenon. 
 She once summed up to a gathering of marketing specialists the extent of her success, which earned The Body Shop the award of business of the year in 1987: 
 We produce over three hundred products in well over three hundred shops from the Arctic Circle to Adelaide, covering thirty-one countries and thirteen languages, without once diluting our image. 
 We've done this with humour, intelligence, a sense of joy, magic and fun, which have always been our essential ingredients. 
 In achieving this remarkable success, Roddick has always been scornful of traditional business credos. 
 She refuses to be part of the general cosmetic industry hype. 
 She will make no extravagant claims for her skin- and hair-care products, all derived from natural ingredients. 
 There is no room in her vocabulary for terms like &bquo;nourishing cream&equo;, because &bquo;only food nourishes&equo;. 
 She has never had to advertise any of her products because &bquo;the shops and the product are the best advertisement&equo;. 
 Her success speaks for itself. 
 She has never hired anyone with a business-school education, because she believes such people are too rigid in their outlook. 
 She has set up her own training school because she found conventional training schemes offered no scope for the  kind of message she wants to get across. 
 She has even formed her own film and video group because she finds most training films &bquo;a yawn a minute&equo;. 
 She has trodden her own distinctive path guided by her mission to make The Body Shop &bquo;the most honest cosmetic company in the world&equo; because she could find no shining example in the retailing industry from which to draw inspiration. 
 For me there are no modern-day heroes in the retailing world. 
 I have come across not one company which incorporates the pursuit of honest profits with social awareness, which provides a vision for themselves and their workers. 
 I have met no retailing captain of industry who makes my blood sing. 
 Retailing itself has taught me nothing. 
 I see tired executives in tired systems. 
 These huge corporations are dying of boredom caused by the inertia of giantism. 
 This is a fate Roddick has avoided by operating most of her shops under a franchise system. 
 It was a route she chose originally because she did not have enough capital to expand at the rate business demanded. 
 But she has no intention of changing course now as she believes that, run as separate entities, the shops remain manageable and provide a strong incentive to succeed for the franchisees. 
 She nevertheless keeps a tight control on the products, the shop displays, training and the operating style of the shops. 
 There is, for example, an unwritten clause insisting that franchisees must agree to adopt a community project. 
 In this way, all the shops reflect Roddick's concern for the environment and her insistence that private wealth should be used for public good. 
 It is all part of Roddick's determination to imbue retailing with a higher status in society. 
 This is something she feels strongly about and she tends to become even more animated than usual when trying to articulate her philosophy. 
 A torrent of words pour out as thoughts race around in her head, vying with each other for verbal expression. 
 She basically lays the blame for the low status retailing enjoys today at the door of the education system. 
 A former teacher, she speaks with some authority on the subject.  
 Some of the most important social changes and some of the greatest philanthropists in the last century were in the field of retailing and yet they are not our heroes. 
 It's not part of our culture; it's not written up in the history books. 
 One of the reasons is that people in this country don't value labour. 
 They talk about it as an expenditure and not as an investment. 
 They are always quibbling about the amount they are prepared to pay their staff while drawing enormous salaries for themselves. 
 People forget that their staff are their front-line consumers. 
 Roddick cossets her staff. 
 They get free samples because their opinions about the products are highly valued. 
 There's a suggestion box at every till. 
 They are also given share options. 
 Training includes courses in sociology and in urban survival. 
 She justifies this by pointing out that there are three thousand young women working in town centres around the country, whose welfare is paramount to her. 
 She even invites AIDS sufferers to come and talk to them. 
 What Roddick is at most pains to demonstrate is that honesty and commercialism can make compatible bedfellows. 
 Indeed, she would argue that her forthright and uncompromising approach is a vital element of her success. 
 The cosmetic industry is bizarre because it is run by men who create needs that don't exist, making women feel incredibly dissatisfied with their bodies. 
 They have this extraordinary belief that all women want is hope and promise. 
 They've got this absolute obsession with not telling the truth, which is bizarre because some of the products they make are actually good. 
 But to me it's innately dishonest to make claims that a cream that is basically oil and water is going to take grief and stress and fifty years of living in the sun off your face. 
 It's nonsense. 
 Roddick attributes her entrepreneurial flair and her individualism to her upbringing. 
 She was one of four children born to Italian immigrants. 
 She helped in the family caf&eacute; at the Sussex seaside resort of Littlehampton, which is still the base for her worldwide empire of retailing outlets. 
 She has fond memories of the caf&eacute;,  which was a popular meeting place for a large number of local children. 
 &bquo;We had the first juke-box in the town after the war, the first knickerbocker glories and the first Pepsi-Colas.&equo; 
 But it wasn't an easy life, particularly as her father died while she was still quite young. 
 Coming from a first-generation immigrant family there was a strongly defined work ethic and after my father died heavy responsibility was thrust upon us. 
 All of the children had to contribute and to some extent we lost our childhood. 
 We didn't have time to play on the beach or in the streets with the other kids. 
 I didn't know it then but I was receiving subliminal training for later business life. 
 I was always surrounded by strong images &mdash; the image of the caf&eacute;, how it looked and the service it provided. 
 We kids either had to serve behind the ice-cream counter or wait on the tables. 
 One of the most important aspects is that we saw ourselves as town traders &mdash; that magical area where buyer and seller come together. 
 One of the bizarre things I find today is that England doesn't really like traders. 
 They're very happy with manufacturing, but the selling of the product and the trading is not quite the right thing to do. 
 They think it's a bit infra dig . 
 But Roddick did not immediately turn her trading experience into entrepreneurial endeavour when she grew up. 
 Typical of immigrants, her parents were anxious that she should do better than they and persuaded her to take up teaching as a profession. 
 Roddick did not offer any resistance, because at the time she was a frustrated actress and she felt teaching English and history to a class of forty kids at a local secondary school was the next best thing to acting. 
 It wasn't a hardship because good teaching is theatre. 
 I learned how to create atmosphere so that the classroom was a visual delight. 
 I always did things differently. 
 Friday afternoons I did a course in aesthetics and I was allowed to paint the classroom &mdash; an old Nissen hut &mdash; black and red. 
 I couldn't believe that anyone could live their life and not be surrounded by brilliant objects and colours. 
 I always taught  my history lessons with the most relevant music. 
 So if we were talking about the Middle Ages we had Gregorian chants, or if we were doing the First World War we had First-world-war songs. 
 Everywhere I went my individuality was encouraged. 
 Roddick is convinced her own schooling was also influential in forming her attitudes to life and the business world. 
 She failed her eleven-plus and ended up at a local secondary modern school, which turned out to be a blessing in disguise. 
 It was the first secondary modern school in the area to introduce O-level courses and the young Roddick was one of twenty girls specially selected to participate in the experiment. 
 &bquo;So right from an early age I was told I was special. 
 I had the best schooling in the world. 
 It was magic.&equo; 
 Prior to becoming a teacher, Roddick decided she wanted to see something of the world. 
 &bquo;I thought the intelligent thing to do was to go away and work for two years and then come back and teach. 
 Where do you go in the 1960s? 
 You go to Paris to suffer.&equo; 
 She worked in the Paris office of the New York Herald Tribune  for a while and later she went to Switzerland to work for the International Labour Office of the United Nations. 
 Her confidence and conviction that she was somebody special served her well when she applied for the UN job. 
 Although she had never had any secretarial training, she had the nerve to apply for one of the most eagerly sought-after positions in Europe. 
 Asked what her typing speed was, she bluntly replied: &bquo;Hit and miss and the use of a rubber.&equo; 
 She gave a similarly flippant answer when inquiries were made about her shorthand skills: &bquo;Longhand and memory,&equo; was her answer. 
 &bquo;Then I said what I can  do &mdash; organise, put twenty-four hours in a day and I'm energetic. 
 I just sold myself.&equo; 
 Even at that early stage in her career, Roddick knew she was different and she cultivated it. 
 She finds it hard to explain why, but ponders that it may have something to do with the religious faith she grew up with. 
 It was a sort of Catholic stab against death, I suppose. 
 You try to defy death all the time when you've had a Catholic upbringing, because it's just so awful. 
 I suppose it's striving  for immortality, just being different, making your mark. 
 I lived in a town called Littlehampton. 
 All it needed was a bit of tumbleweed to make it seem more deserted than it really was and I used to just fight against that dissatisfaction. 
 My friends at sixteen were getting married or getting pregnant. 
 I just wanted something more than that. 
 It was while travelling around the world that the seeds of her future calling were first sown. 
 Courtesy of the UN, which paid her a handsome tax-free salary, she travelled widely, visiting exotic spots like Polynesia, Mauritius and the New Hebrides. 
 She spent time with remote island communities and observed the simple but effective way they lived their lives. 
 &bquo;1 just lived as they did and watched how they groomed themselves without any cosmetic aids. 
 Their skin was wonderful and their hair beautifully clean.&equo; 
 She watched Polynesians scoop up untreated cocoa butter and apply it directly to their skins and felt the smooth texture the skin consequently acquired. 
 Today, Roddick spends about two months a year travelling the world, picking up tips about natural ingredients to go into her products. 
 Cocoa butter is now an important ingredient in her skin-care products, for example. 
 She has also observed Sri Lankans using pineapple as a skin cleanser and later discovered that the natural enzymes present in the fruit act on the skin to remove dead cells, making it an effective cleanser. 
 We can learn from women in other societies. 
 They know that these well-tried and tested ways work, and do not need a scientist or advertising agency to sell them. 
 You only have to look at what they use. 
 Very often it is a plant which grows readily at hand. 
 There are more than 200,00 known plant species in the world and it is said we have learned to use only 2,500 of them. 
 It is the marriage of traditional wisdom and knowledge of raw ingredients with modern research that makes The Body Shop products innovative and effective. 
 But the idea for The Body Shop did not take root immediately. 
 By the time she returned from travelling the world, she was in her mid-twenties. 
 She fell in love, married and opened a restaurant  with her husband Gordon. 
 Looking back on it, Roddick believes that too was a good training ground for future developments. 
 Terence Conran once said to me: &bquo;the reason why you and I do things well is because we had our apprenticeship in restaurants,&equo; and I actually think that's a very valid point, because you've got twenty planks to the one function of actually serving food. 
 You've got to order, you've got to prepare, you've got to have the right environment &mdash; the character of the place &mdash; and you've got to sell what you're offering, for example. 
 The original plan was that Anita would do the cooking and her husband would serve the customers, but she did not enjoy being behind the scenes and eventually taught Gordon to be a fine cook while she spent her time out front chatting up the customers. 
 After two years, however, Gordon too got the wanderlust urge and planned a horse-back ride from South America to New York that would take him two years. 
 Anita encouraged him to go and decided that while he was away, running a shop would be a less demanding occupation than working all hours in a restaurant. 
 It had occurred to her that most products came in a variety of sizes and offered a wide choice, but she felt the cosmetic trade was too dictatorial about what the customer should buy. 
 She envisaged a shop where cleansing lotions would be displayed in simple bottles of all shapes and sizes and which would contain the natural ingredients she had come across during her trips to remote communities. 
 Personal experience, Roddick maintains, is the best market research there is. 
 You can't just pull ideas out of the air. 
 You've got to find out what irritates you, annoys you to death and then translate that into a business. 
 What irritates me about going shopping in any supermarket is having to bag my own goods up. 
 Why isn't there somebody there to bag them for me and create a service? 
 Starting with a bank loan of &pound;4,000, Roddick had no time to sit down in the early years and draw up a grandiose mission of  what her organisation should set out to achieve. 
 The first, and crucial, goal was survival. 
 Reality says that if you set up a store and you're undercapitalised, you're going to go bust. 
 The reason you do it usually is because if you don't succeed you're not going to eat. 
 So you put in all the hours God gives you. 
 You pray that you'll make enough to pay the rates and the petrol for the car. 
 That's your apprenticeship. 
 My apprenticeship was in a shop for a year working and adapting and changing and getting an understanding of it all. 
 Also, learning to be obsessive about detail. 
 It's the detail that matters. 
 The success of The Body Shop grew out of an almost na&iuml;ve belief in herself and sheer hard work. 
 Having been told I was special from a very young age, you believe everything is possible, but I also knew that you got nothing unless you worked hard. 
 We were protected by not really knowing the risks. 
 We worked hard, therefore we survived. 
 We didn't know what the risk factors were. 
 We didn't have any understanding of the business colleges. 
 In fact, I would suggest that anybody who has one ounce of individuality should never go to a business school &mdash; and I've said this often at Cranfield and London &mdash; because you're structured by academics who measure you in the science of business. 
 They use a business language that is so predictable and going out and doing it is not part of the course. 
 Lack of academic training does not appear to have been a handicap for Roddick. 
 The Body Shop expanded rapidly under the franchise system. 
 Roddick merely called it &bquo;self-financing&equo;, because she didn't have the capital to do it any other way. 
 &bquo;We just went in and did everything for everybody. 
 We helped with putting up the shelves and we filled all the bottles in each shop. 
 Everyone did their own labelling., As a result of this approach, a strong camaraderie developed between the Roddicks and the franchisees they selected to help spread their business philosophy. 
 They found themselves working alongside like-minded young people with similar values to  their own. 
 Roddick describes herself and her husband as &bquo;children of the 1960s&equo;. 
 They had both been ardent followers of such causes as Shelter, Freedom from Hunger and the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament, the popular issues of the day for caring people with deep moral convictions. 
 As her business empire grew, Roddick was left with little time to participate actively in such environmental causes as Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace, with which her own convictions were closely aligned. 
 But she made certain that her great concern for environmental issues were built into her business philosophy. 
 For example, The Body Shop was the first company in Britain to use jojoba oil, which is obtained from a desert plant, in cosmetics. 
 The plant oil closely resembles sperm-whale oil, which has been used in cosmetics for many years. 
 Her way of supporting Greenpeace's campaign to save the whale was to demonstrate that there are always substitutes to be found in nature and that there is no commercial excuse for hunting an endangered species out of existence. 
 There are, in fact, other powerful reasons for making jojoba a universal substitute for whale oil. 
 It can be grown on some of the poorest land in the world, which is totally unsuitable for conventional crops, and in regions where people have no work and are living in poverty. 
 Roddick has pledged herself and her organisation to &bquo;increasing public awareness of the qualities of jojoba oil and to lead the way by using it extensively, so helping both people and whales.&equo; 
 This enlightened approach came as a natural product of Roddick's values and her philosophy of life. 
 It wasn't until she had successfully launched The Body Shop on to the Unlisted Securities Market that she began to examine the direction in which the business was going and to start articulating its mission in a definitive way. 
 She suddenly realised she had passed from the survival phase to a phase where she could see that The Body Shop had become a retailing institution that was going from strength to strength. 
 This left her asking herself how she should direct her success and what her responsibilities to society were. 
 Instead of letting our success lead us into a fat-cat mentality, it led us much more strongly and much faster into a mentality of asking what are we going to do with it. 
 Everybody's shop was making a lot of money and we just couldn't bear the  thought of us all getting like the rest of the industry. 
 I was learning very fast to walk in the opposite direction. 
 There was just one yardstick. 
 Whatever the cosmetics industry was doing, do the opposite. 
 It worked well. 
 One of the main outcomes of all this introspection was the setting up of an environmental and communities department to translate Roddick's beliefs and concerns into practical projects. 
 The Body Shop as a group joined Friends of the Earth and pursued such policies as using recycled paper for packaging. 
 But more importantly, as far as Roddick is concerned, each franchised outlet is required to take on a community project in its area, which she believes gives the young women in the organisation additional status and helps them to realise that everybody has the ability to change the world for the better. 
 But none of the employees are expected to take on extra duties after a hard day in the shop. 
 All the projects are undertaken within working hours. 
 Each franchisee decides their own project. 
 There is no question of coercion. 
 But Roddick sees her expanding retailing network as a means to spread her own deep beliefs about the environment and Third World issues, educating both employees and customers. 
 She sees the whole process as a self-perpetuating cycle. 
 Ingredients obtained from the Third World, providing work and sustenance to underprivileged societies, go into products which are sold to the more fortunate, the profits of which go into her educational programme aimed at making people more aware of the critical issues of our times. 
 We're the only company I know that puts issues like acid rain, waste and pollution as shop-window issues to educate our customers. 
 In a way, we've almost come full circle back to what I was trained to do, which is teaching. 
 We have half a million kids coming into our shops every week. 
 Just to sell them a product without educating them to challenge and to care about the ingredients that go into those products would be wrong. 
 They should be constantly asking why a bottle is the shape it is and whether the ingredients come from a whale or from a natural substance of which there is great abundance. 
 The cosmetics industry  is an irrelevant industry. 
 It is not a life and death industry, so it is a joyous task to create more relevancy. 
 Typical of the kind of community projects The Body Shop undertakes is one run in collaboration with the Brighton Health Authority. 
 Part-time workers, recruited through the Manpower Services Commission, are being trained to provide a regular massage service for elderly and psychiatric patients. 
 It has also become involved in the Work-out scheme in London, which aims to help the young unemployed take an active approach to life. 
 Body Shop staff adopt a young unemployed person on a one-to-one basis, helping with job applications, for example. 
 Attempts are also being made to set up community-run Body Shops in inner urban areas, such as Brixton. 
 Roddick's determination to use private profit for public good has now reached some of the remotest parts of the world. 
 She has launched a number of Third World projects, which she often discovers during her two months abroad each year. 
 One of her latest projects is to set up a paper-making plant in Nepal. 
 The paper will be processed from pineapple and banana leaves, under the initial guidance of a Canadian crafts specialist. 
 Roddick plans to use the paper so produced for wrapping Body Shop products. 
 There's a similar plan to make paper from water hyacinth in Bangladesh. 
 The water hyacinth grows in profusion and tends to choke up the local rivers. 
 So the project will have the double benefit of clearing the rivers and at the same time creating a saleable product. 
 In southern India The Body Shop has provided the means to set up a boys' town for destitute youngsters. 
 They are taught rural crafts and how to make products, such as foot rollers and Christmas cards, which are sold in The Body Shops. 
 The money from the sale of the products is put into a trust fund, so that when the youngsters leave at the age of sixteen to make their own way in the world they have the means to purchase a flock of sheep or a horse and cart, giving them a vital start in whatever activity they take up. 
 Any additional revenue goes into funding more boys' towns. 
 So far three thousand jobs have been created under the scheme. 
 Roddick has never found that her commercial and philanthropic interests clash. 
 She refused to listen to the Jeremiahs who  predicted she would have to change her operating style once her company came under the scrutiny of the Stock Exchange. 
 I have learned a lot in the last few years. 
 There are a hell of a lot of myths perpetrated in this industry. 
 They say when you go on to the Stock Market you should be worried because you can lose your strength. 
 It's just not true. 
 If you're doing well, the Stock Market leaves you alone and what's even better, if you're doing terrifically well, as we are, they listen to you. 
 They spend more and more time trying to study how we work and how we do things. 
 The second myth says that the bigger you get, the less communication you have. 
 That's nonsense. 
 We've invested an enormous amount in communications at all levels &mdash; our training school, a newsletter, videos, and so on &mdash; and it works. 
 Nor is Roddick fearful that she will be unable to ensure that the most suitable people are recruited to join The Body Shop as it continues to grow at such a fast pace. 
 She points out that there are five thousand people on the waiting list wanting to take up a Body Shop franchise and that it takes three years before any of them succeed. 
 &bquo;Unless you're absolutely obsessed you don't get a look in.&equo; 
 Applicants also have to undergo strict vetting, which includes an offbeat questionnaire. 
 Roddick calls it the Marcel Proust questionnaire and it asks such unlikely questions as: How would you like to die? 
 What's your favourite flower? 
 Who's your heroine in history or who's your hero in poetry? 
 Roddick claims that the answers to such bizarre questions tend to be very revealing and she can usually judge whether an applicant is going to be somebody who is on her wavelength and with whom she can comfortably work. 
 In fact, Roddick has managed to achieve an astonishing uniformity with her worldwide network of shops. 
 Wherever you are, each is a mirror image of all the others. 
 We've got stores in the Arctic Circle, we've got shops literally in the desert in the Middle East and we've got them in Hong Kong and Singapore and they're all the same &mdash; and they all work. 
 I think the interesting fact is we're not seen  as an English company. 
 We're seen as cross-cultural with a product range with international ingredients. 
 Roddick has also resisted suggestions that she should diversify into other quite different product lines such as clothing and leisure centres. 
 &bquo;All I want to do is to do what I'm doing, but do it better.&equo; 
 The main pleasure Roddick derives from her success is, 
 the ability to effect change for the better. 
 There's power in money, but it's not often been utilised for good. 
 I've never seen private greed translate to public benefit ever. 
 There are two things I work on now. 
 Because we're successful, we're listened to. 
 Because we're humane, we're watched &mdash; and they're still watching us because they can't believe that you can develop one without losing the other. 
 All you have to do is commit yourself to it. 
 The one thing I can't stand is cynicism. 
 It's so soulless and inert. 
 It changes nothing; it's a disease of the old. 
 Private wealth certainly doesn't appear to have been translated into personal greed where Roddick is concerned. 
 She rarely indulges herself. 
 The pace of business growth is such that she finds very few spare moments for leisure-time activities. 
 &bquo;For me work is more fun than fun and the one thing I was never trained for was leisure.&equo; 
 What she most relishes about no longer having to worry about where the money to pay the rates is coming from is that it gives her the freedom to be creative. 
 &bquo;Money is never the motivator,&equo; she insists.  
 Chiefs Without a Tribe 
 In the bright sunshine each September in central Africa, the ngwazi  (conqueror) Dr Kamuzu Banda, Life President and over eighty years old, has addressed 20,000 members of the women's federation of Malawi for no less than three hours. 
 His words, spoken in English, are translated into Chinyanja. 
 At relevant moments Dr Banda waves his fly whisk. 
 When the oratory is finished the ladies begin dancing on the floor of the arena; after some time the Ngwazi  descends to join the dancing, fly whisk waving merrily, and for at least an hour joins in the celebration. 
 Dr Banda, abroad for more than forty years during the colonial period, has a very paternalistic view of the way Malawi should be run. 
 His regime calls for great personal reverence for himself, as Life President and elder and brooks no serious dissent on grounds of personality or policy. 
 An early attempt by ex-ministers to overthrow Banda in 1964 ended in total failure; three high-ranking party members disappeared in a car crash in 1982. 
 An early contestant for the role of heir apparent, Aleke Banda, a minister in the 1960s, was restricted to his village for several years before being partially rehabilitated only to fall in disgrace again in the mid 1980s. 
 Dr Banda is on record as saying:  
 Everything is my business. 
 Everything. 
 The state of education, the state of our economy, the state of our agriculture, the state of our transport, everything is my business. 
 Map 5 Africa today and African peoples 
 Dr Banda's approach has had considerable success. 
 Malawi has not been debilitated by localism, and experienced considerable economic growth in the 1960s and 1970s with a strong agricultural performance and an unusually effective civil service. 
 The economic problems experienced in the 1980s are largely due to the destabilizing impact of the civil war in Mozambique. 
 Nonetheless, the authoritarian nature of the regime has won it many enemies both inside and outside the country, creating an atmosphere of suspicion and intrigue amongst the educated elite. 
 Furthermore, there is no sign that Dr Banda will be able to engineer a smooth and lasting transition to a leader with widespread popular support, and he thus endangers the achievements of his regime. 
 Malawi's experience illustrates fundamental problems in the complex interweaving of traditional and modern values which coexist in Africa. 
 There are three areas in which the political characteristics of pre-colonial societies can be identified in the contemporary situation. 
 First, that the loyalty of most rural and many urban people is still to tribe rather than nation; second, in the continuous drift towards authoritarian systems of government; and, third, in the failure to resolve peacefully a system of succession of heads of state. 
 We shall examine these in turn, relating them to specific national situations. 
 NATIONALISM vs LOCALISM 
 In most African countries the prime loyalty of the majority of people continues to be the extended family and its clan, and ultimately the tribe as the &bquo;widening out of the family&equo;. 
 So localism is a Major political reality, and the tendency towards localism has been stronger than the tendency towards a national identity. 
 The contradiction between the two could be seen in the nationalist movements which paved the way for independence, in which there was a constant tension between the attempt to build a genuine nationalist movement and the tendency for support to be delivered on a tribal basis. 
 Nigeria 
 Nigeria provides a striking example of this process at work. 
 The first party to campaign for independence was the National Council of Nigeria and the Cameroons (NCNC) founded by Dr Namdi Azikiwe in 1945. 
 The name of its newspaper, The West African Pilot , clearly indicated the all-Nigerian and even all-West African nature of its objectives. 
 In the following six years the NCNC succeeded in attracting a good deal of support amongst the Yoruba of western Nigeria. 
 However, by 1951 tension between Yoruba and Ibo outside the party, Yoruba objections to Dr Azikiwe's leadership, and the weakness of political organization within the west, led to the establishment of the Yoruba-dominated &bquo;Action group&equo; by Chief Obafemi Awolowo. 
 The Northern People's Congress (NPC) led by a schoolteacher, Tafawa Balewa, and backed by the northern Emirates, was also founded at this time, early enough to fight elections held in 1952. 
 Any attempt to build a truly all-Nigerian party since the failure of Azikiwe's pioneering initiative has fallen foul of the rivalry between the major tribal groups. 
 This rivalry, reflected in the conflicts between the successor political parties, and the interest groups they represent, has continued to be the main engine of Nigerian politics to the present time. 
 It was not satisfactorily accommodated by the new constitution introduced for the 1979 election, as indicated by the return to military rule in 1984. 
 It is the key to the attempts of General Babangida, Nigerian head of state in 1989, to restrict to two the number of parties allowed to fight the proposed 1991 general election &mdash; in theory in order to prevent excessive faction fighting based on ethnic groups. 
 Zambia: the KK carousel 
 In Zambia, although it has a population at least ten times smaller than that of Nigeria, localism has also been the prime concern of domestic politics. 
 The concessions and trade-offs which have come to form the main content of Zambian politics have proved fatally debilitating, even though the skill with which they have been orchestrated by President Kenneth Kaunda (KK) has ensured that Zambia is one of the least oppressive societies in Africa. 
 Nationalist politics in Zambia were initiated in 1951 under the banner of the Northern Rhodesian African National Congress (ANC &mdash; but not to be confused with the present-day ANC) led by Harry Nkumbula, from the Ila people of southern Zambia. 
 The ANC at that time had very close links to the African Mine Workers' Union, the largest group of whose members were Bemba, but which included members of tribes from all over Zambia, as well as from Tanganyika and Nyasaland. 
 At this time localism had not yet become a threat. 
 The ANC led the fight against the formation of the Central African Federation, but failed to prevent its establishment in 1954. 
 Nkumbula's lack of vigour in attacking the Federation, once established, and in supporting participation in the elections for the Legislative Council in 1958 led to the breakaway from the ANC of Kaunda, Simon Kapwepwe and others who set up the United National Independence Party (UNIP) in 1959. 
 It was UNIP which eventually took control of the first independent government winning, in January 1964, fifty-five seats to the ANC's ten. 
 It was clear that the ANC would, from then on, be a minority party relying heavily on local support in the Southern Province. 
 Kaunda's commitment to a multi- or non-tribal society eventually alienated Kapwepwe whose support base lay much more firmly amongst the Bemba. 
 By 1971, the tension was so great that Kapwepwe broke with Kaunda and formed the United People's Party (UPP) which depended on a flimsy alliance between the Bemba and other tribal groups who at that time felt they were out in the political cold. 
 In elections held at the end of 1971, the UPP won only one seat, Kapwepwe's own. 
 It was then banned in February 1972, and a one-party state declared. 
 Kapwepwe and 123 supporters were detained, although Kapwepwe himself was released ten months later. 
 In 1974 the remaining ANC MPs were allowed to join UNIP, as was Kapwepwe in September 1978. 
 Since that time Kaunda has operated an unending game of musical chairs between tribal interest groups. 
 At one level this has enabled him to achieve the considerable feat of maintaining reasonably stable government for more than twenty years. 
 He has, however, paid a very high price for living with the politics of localism. 
 For tensions between regional factions within the party have constantly subordinated a consensus on development policy to the struggle for power. 
 In the UNIP contest for the 1979 presidential nomination, when both Kapwepwe and Nkumbula challenged him, Kaunda showed that he was not prepared to tolerate any real alternative to himself, even when the bid came from the two most experienced politicians in the country. 
 The consequent reactions, both at grass roots level in increasing lawlessness exemplified by the Mushala Gang, a guerilla group in the north-west, and among the elite in a coup attempt organized by Edward Shamwana, a well known Lusaka lawyer, were typical reactions to a regime which was seen as protecting vested interests from below and being inefficient and bureaucratic from above. 
 In 1988 there were no contestants other than Kaunda for the party's presidential nomination, since Nalumino Mundia, a veteran of the independence struggle, withdrew, being unable to secure Bemba support. 
 Living with localism and the drift to an authoritarian system created a dangerous impasse in Zambian society, and left it singularly ill-equipped to deal with its economic collapse in the late 1980s. 
 Localism has thus continued to be a reality in Nigeria and Zambia and has conflicted with attempts to build a national identity and a national politics. 
 However, there are important cases, particularly Senegal and Tanzania, where the tendency towards a national identity has been more important than localism, which is not to say that the conflict has not existed. 
 In Tanzania, for example, localism among the waChagga and waHaya is potentially as strong as among any of the major tribes of Zambia. 
 It has, however, been contained by an environment in which President Nyerere's political leadership promoted a strong national ideology, and in which, for reasons which lie in Tanzania's nineteenth-century history (including both the replacement of traditional authority by trader barons and the unity achieved among some peoples in resisting German colonialism) localism has been much less strong than among many African peoples. 
 This history gave Tanzania a lingua franca  (kiSwahili) which was common to most parts of the country, and so the local identity which comes from language runs in parallel with a national identity also based on language. 
 THE DRIFT TOWARDS AUTHORITARIANISM 
 The second facet of continuity from pre-colonial times is the authoritarian nature of most African governments. 
 In Chapter 3 it was argued that pre-colonial society was indeed authoritarian, and that this expressed itself in a great stress on the conformity of the individual, and on a hierarchy of relationships between young and old, between chiefs and people and between men and women. 
 In the course of the colonial period, the outward form of these relationships underwent great changes to become, in some cases, almost unrecognizable. 
 The changes did not, however, alter the underlying assumptions about the need for authority, or create a climate in which individual dissent, as in the Anglo-Saxon tradition, was considered necessary to the health of the body politic. 
 Uganda: kingdoms at war 
 In some cases there has been a close relationship between the strength of localism and the tendency towards authoritarian government. 
 This is particularly true in Uganda where the British-derived constitution was premised on a uniquely complex attempt to reconcile the interests of the four historic kingdoms, including Bunyoro and Buganda, with the new nation. 
 This attempt was a reaction to the experience of the British in Uganda in the 1950s. 
 Thus the last British Governor, Sir Andrew Cohen, favoured in 1952 the approach which Milton Obote tried to make work after 1966: 
 the future of Uganda must lie in a unitary form of central Government on parliamentary lines covering the whole country&hellip; 
 The Protectorate is too small to grow into a series of separate units of Government, even if these are federated together. 
 He looked forward to the development of the country 
 by a central Government of the Protectorate as a whole with no part of the country dominating any other part but all working together for the good of the whole Protectorate and the progress of its people. 
 Cohen, however, found it impossible to make this approach work as a result of a confrontation with the kabaka  in 1953, and by 1955 Buganda had confirmed its special constitutional status within Uganda, a status which was if anything reinforced in the independence constitution of 1962. 
 This arrangement was made to work, albeit with increasing tension, between 1962 and 1966. 
 In the first two years of this period President Milton Obote's party, the United People's Congress (UPC) formed a coalition with the Kabaka Yekka (KY) Party whose support was entirely drawn from the Buganda people, and whose ultimate loyalty was to the kabaka  who was also appointed President of Uganda. 
 By October 1964 in the complex shifting sands of Ugandan parliamentary politics this alignment changed to one in which Obote felt strong enough to break his alliance with the kabaka , with whom he moved into a position of open enmity. 
 In 1966 he instigated a military attack led by Idi Amin on the kabaka's  palace and made the arrangements to terminate the other three traditional kingships of Uganda. 
 These events were the culmination of a process which ended the attempt to accommodate localism into the political structure through very complex constitutional arrangements. 
 As the people of Uganda retained strong local loyalties, the arrangements could only be replaced by the type of authoritarian regime which Obote now introduced. 
 Its hallmark was a Machiavellian juggling with army cliques, revolving mainly around the role of Idi Amin and Oyite-Ojok as rival claimants to the position of head of the army. 
 It was hardly surprising that this should result in the coup of January 1971 in which Amin overthrew Obote while he was absent abroad. 
 Nor was it surprising that after the apparently mindless brutality of the Amin years, Obote's eventual return to power in 1980 was characterized by the continuing dominance of the army as the real force in Ugandan politics, supporting a parliamentary facade of no real legitimacy. 
 In this situation, between 1982 and 1985 the army could pursue a civil war with the Buganda of whom 150,000 were killed in the Luweru Triangle, which forms the heartland of Buganda. 
 These events ultimately led to the second overthrow of Obote by Yoreveni Museveni in 1985. 
 In Uganda, the apparent impossibility of integrating localism with an effective central government, and the consequent reliance on military authority, has had tragic consequences: civil strife or open war was prevalent from at least 1971 until 1986. 
 The last British government in Uganda, initially seeking an integrated state in recognition of local realities, was forced to contrive a more or less federal one. 
 The tensions involved in trying to make that quasi-federal arrangement work proved too great for Obote. 
 He became increasingly authoritarian and reliant upon the army, which in turn led to the eight years of Amin's rule, the Tanzanian invasion, Obote's second government and ultimately the civil war in which Museveni took power. 
 Today it remains to be seen whether Museveni's essentially centralist approach will be more successful than its predecessors. 
 Tanzania 
 Tanzania, in spite of the national rhetoric inspired by President Julius Nyerere, was also essentially authoritarian during Nyerere's presidency. 
 This is true even though the ruling party &mdash; initially the Tanganyika African National Union (TANU) and since 1972 the Chama Cha Mapunduzi (CCM) &mdash; has always accepted a system of primary elections to select parliamentary candidates. 
 In the four general elections held since independence the turnover of MPs has been as much as 50 per cent. 
 In contrast the authoritarian nature of Tanzanian politics can more usefully be measured by the number of political detainees which exceeded several hundred in the mid 1970s or in terms of the degree of pressure brought to bear on the rural population from 1974 to 1978. 
 It is also true at a more subtle level in that Nyerere, perhaps the finest political debater in Africa land responsible for the first translation of Shakespeare's Julius Caesar into kiSwahili), left himself with no-one to debate with, at least until he left the presidency to be party chairman in 1985. 
 His survival over the years since independence in 1961 does not alter the fact that the discussion of real policy choices in a public manner has hardly ever occurred. 
 This is not to say that the National Executive Committee of the ruling party allows Nyerere total control of the party and therefore of government policy; in fact there have always been a number of important policy issues which Nyerere has had to argue through the NEC and which he has not always won. 
 One such issue since the Union of Tanganyika and Zanzibar in 1964 has been the degree of influence of leading Zanzibari politicians in the affairs of the mainland government and party, and the status of Zanzibar in general. 
 Another, in the late 1960s, was the position of the Ruvuma Development Association (RDA), a group of seven villages near Songea in the extreme south-western corner of Tanzania which grouped themselves in an association of mutual support designed to foster their development and which were ultimately compulsorily disbanded in 1969. 
 However, none of the major stages in Tanzania's development as a centralized socialist state were publicly discussed in any way which made open debate possible. 
 The three major steps were first, the nationalizations which followed the Arusha Declaration in 1967; second, the takeover by government of the wholesale distribution system (largely Indian-owned) in 1971; and thirdly, the compulsory villagization programme of 1974&ndash;8, affecting the physical location of the homes of at least 5 million people. 
 The extent of opposition to the Arusha Declaration and its associated &bquo;leadership code&equo; is indicated by the desertion of Nyerere's closest colleague, Oscar Kambona, who fled Tanzania in 1967. 
 The take-over of the wholesale distribution system was strongly resisted by the responsible minister, A.M. Babu, and was implemented directly by the President's office. 
 On a trumped-up charge of assassinating the first President of Zanzibar, Abeid Karume, Babu was held in detention from 1971 to 1978. 
 Even more significant at the grass roots level was the reversal of government policy on self-help villages, christened ujamaa  villages (which in kiSwahili means familihood). 
 Nyerere was arguing right up to, and beyond the date of the dissolution of the RDA that ujamaa  villages must govern themselves. 
 In a paper entitled &bquo;Freedom and Development&equo; published in dctober 1968 and adopted by the NEC later that month he said: 
 No one can be forced into an ujamaa village, and no official &mdash; at any level &mdash; can go and tell the members of an ujamaa village what they should do together, and what they should continue to do as individual farmers. 
 No official of the Government or Party can go to an ujamaa village and tell the members what they must grow&hellip; for if these things happen &mdash; that is, if an outsider gives such instructions and enforces them &mdash; then it will no longer be an ujamaa village! 
 Developments in Tanzania in the mid 1970s were, however, to end in the direct contradiction of this injunction, a contradiction which is at the heart of Tanzania's tendency towards an authoritarian state. 
 By 1972 party leaders and Nyerere himself became disillusioned with the lack of progress in implementing ujamaa  on a voluntary basis, and in a dramatic switch of policy in 1973 it was decreed that all Tanzanians should live in such a village by 1976. 
 In the course of the next three years over 5 million small farmers moved from individual farms to larger settlements, often including several hundred families. 
 The number of people in ujamaa  villages by the late 1970s was officially estimated to be 10 million, although many of these were already living in their existing communities which were simply renamed ujamaa . 
 Nonetheless, the movement was a vast operation, unparalleled in pre- or post-independence Africa. 
 Initially it was assumed that the objective would be for the villages to farm on a communal basis. 
 In practice, by 1975, the resistance to this approach proved so great that settlement was the real objective, with the justification that farming families could be supported in every way &mdash; agriculturally, medically and educationally &mdash; much more effectively on a group basis. 
 The important point is not the long-term justification, or lack of it, of the resettlement programme but the very authoritarian manner of its conception and implementation. 
 The experience confirmed Tanzania as a society in which key decisions were made by the president, sometimes in consultation with a few individuals and sometimes not, for implementation by an elite of party workers and civil servants. 
 In the general election of 1970 there had, for instance, been no discussion of the settlement issue; it had been assumed that ujamaa  would continue to be a voluntary movement. 
 It was as if the president decided to will Tanzania into becoming a socialist community of rural producers living in harmony with themselves and the soil, and was prepared to devote the whole machinery of the state to turning his will into reality. 
 Individuals in the party and the government came to use the situation in whatever way they could to optimize their own position, ranging from exercising the increased power which district and regional officials now had over the citizenry, to carrying out routine tasks perfunctorily while acquiring a significant income from black market activities. 
 By the late 1980s there were new divisions in Tanzanian society with a clear split between pragmatists and socialists. 
 The former wished to see a revived private sector, the latter wished to preserve the institutional and economic status quo. 
 Beneath these divisions on policy lay deeper divisions based on economic and financial self-interest, with the prestige of Nyerere as party chairman adding weight to the argument for the status quo. 
 In some cases, as in relations between the mainland and Zanzibar, this could be decisive. 
 In other areas Nyerere's influence was more circumspect, but it was successful in maintaining the myth of Tanzania, at least for domestic consumption, as a country committed to building socialism in the long term. 
 Nyerere's reputation as an individual remains high and was reinforced by his decision to resign as president in late 1985. 
 It has never been doubted by the Tanzanian public that his aims were genuine, nor been considered that he sought to enrich himself. 
 In this sense the very high &bquo;yes&equo; votes he achieved in the four presidential elections since independence have been genuine, but should not be mistaken for support for specific policies, and still less for support for other leaders at either the local or national level. 
 THE CONTINUING PROBLEM OF SUCCESSION 
 We have seen that localism and the drift to increasingly authoritarian government have been major problems even for Africa's more successful leaders, and have been disastrous in other cases such as Uganda and Nigeria. 
 Both these factors interrelate with a third major political dilemma: the succession to political leadership. 
 Since 1960, of the 41 sub-Saharan African states there has only been one smooth constitutional transfer of real power from one elected leader to another, i.e. in Senegal in 1981. 
 In 1990 it is not clear whether in late 1987 Julius Nyerere's decision to renew his term as party chairman in Tanzania is compatible with a smooth transition of power from himself to President Mwinyi or to anyone else. 
 There have been three significant cases of the smooth transfer of power from the death of a civilian head of state to his successor. 
 In each case, Liberia in 1971, Kenya in 1979, and Botswana in 1980, the transfer was to existing vice-presidents. 
 In four cases, Ghana in 1976 and 1979, Nigeria in 1980 and Sudan in 1987, military regimes have held elections which have returned civilian governments to power but in all four cases a coup has reinstated a military head of state. 
 As with the continuing strength of localism and authoritarian government, the roots of the succession problem lie not only in the fragility of the new states, but also in the legacy of pre-colonial societies. 
 Chapter 3 showed for the most part that traditional society had an arbitrary approach to the problem typified by suicide (as with the Banyankole), &bquo;snuffing out&equo; (as with the Nyakyusa and Ngonde) or violent change (as with the Shilluk). 
 Constitutional change through the popular will, or even the long wait for a head of state's death, are not concepts with deep roots in African society. 
 Kenya after Kenyatta 
 The acute political problems raised by the succession issue can be seen particularly clearly in the experience of Kenya, Cameroun and Senegal. 
 In the case of Kenya, Kenyatta's age of almost seventy at the time of independence in 1964 meant that the succession issue was alive from the start. 
 For the Kikuyu the success of the struggle for independence in Kenya lay in the combination of Kenyatta's political activities and in the effectiveness of Mau Mau in eroding settler confidence. 
 But there were other political figures at work in Kenya during the 1950s. 
 These included Tom Mboya and Oginga Odinga, both Luo, albeit from different parts of Luo-land, both having made major contributions to the independence movement (Odinga amongst the Luo and Mboya within and outside the trade union movement), and in 1961 both were founder members of KANU. 
 At independence, the two were relatively young &mdash; Mboya in his early thirties, and Odinga in his forties &mdash; and could have expected to be considered as candidates for the presidency in the years to come. 
 In the mid 1960s a dominant group of Kikuyu, who were close to the Kenyatta family, determined that neither Odinga nor Mboya would come close to the presidency. 
 This group included the veteran politician Mbiyu Koinange, who had participated in missions to the British Colonial Secretary in the early 1950s, and Dr Njoroge Mungai, then a minister in the Kenyatta government. 
 In 1966, in the one and only internal KANU election to be held between independence and Kenyatta's death in 1978, Odinga was ousted from the position of vice-president of the party and so from that of the Republic. 
 At the same time maximum uncertainty was built into the party constitution with the introduction of eight vice-presidential posts. 
 The government however continued with just one vice-president and within a few months this post was held by Daniel Arap Moi, a non-Kikuyu who, despite being a member of the Legislative Council, had not been prominent in nationalist politics. 
 Tom Mboya had supported these moves, not least perhaps because of his long-standing animosity towards Odinga, but in doing so sowed the seeds of his own downfall. 
 He was murdered in 1969 and his assassin did not hesitate to put the blame on the &bquo;big men&equo;. 
 By this time Odinga had formed his own party, the KPU (Kenya People's Union), but following an incident in Kenyatta's presence at Kisumu he was jailed in October 1969 and the KPU banned. 
 The struggle for the succession now lay more narrowly between Kikuyu claimants and Vice-president Moi. 
 The existing constitution stipulated that in the event of the president's death, the vice-president must act in place of the president for the ninety days which would elapse before an election could be held. 
 In order to ensure that the succession passed to the right Kikuyu clan, an organization by the name of GEMA (Gikuyu, Embu and Meru Association) was formed under the leadership of Njenga Karume: 
 Although ostensibly a welfare organisation Gema was in fact a political party within KANU with Kiambu as its nerve centre, but with political retainers throughout the Republic among every tribe. 
 GEMA organized and led the &bquo;Change the Constitution&equo; movement which had as its objective the prevention of the vice-president taking power in an interim period before an election, and which came to dominate party politics in the mid 1970s. 
 Having failed in its objective, and having incurred the apparent disapproval of Kenyatta in the process, GEMA tried to persuade Kibaki (the technocratic Minister of Finance) to stand as vice-president against Moi in the abortive party elections of 1977. 
 He declined, although a member of GEMA, and stood for the post of national chairman. 
 The death of Kenyatta in 1978, with no constitutional change accomplished, left the way open for Daniel Arap Moi to take over the presidency and to be confirmed in a national election as president within three months. 
 However, in practice this was only achieved as a result of the very public support of Kibaki and of Charles Njonjo the influential Attorney General (working against the interests of the founders of GEMA), a triumvirate which was itself to break apart with the public humiliation of Njonjo at judicial hearings in 1984. 
 Although the transition from Kenyatta to Moi was nominally smooth, it was in fact the culmination of a battle for power which had lasted for 12 years. 
 During its course two major contestants had been eliminated, one by assassination and one by detention, and party politics in Kenya had become obsessed with the struggle between personalities and the rival power of different Kikuyu clans. 
 Its side effects, at least in the popular mind, included two other assassinations, those of the popular reformist MP, J.M. Kariuki, and Pia Gama Pinto, an Asian lawyer who frequently wrote radical speeches for Odinga. 
 The problem of succession had by no means been solved, and certainly not in a way that could be used as a precedent for the future. 
 Subsequently, President Moi has consolidated his position in such a way that it has become difficult, if not impossible, for anyone to challenge his position by constitutional means. 
 In the March 1988 general election, voters were obliged to queue publicly behind their preferred candidates in the nomination process, and after the election the government initiated discussion of the abolition of the secret ballot. 
 Cameroun: qui governe? 
 Cameroun provides another example of a country whose stability was seriously jeopardized by a major crisis over the succession to the presidency. 
 The conflict between ex-President Ahmadu Ahidjo and President Paul Biya culminated in 1984 in a bloody battle for the presidential palace and the presidency itself. 
 For twenty years from 1961 Ahidjo had relative success in maintaining stability in Cameroun, and by the late 1970s the country was experiencing high rates of growth. 
 During this period, Ahidjo had a series of prime ministers on the French model. 
 The last was Paul Biya who between 1973 and 1979, as minister responsible for the economy, had been one of the chief architects of Cameroun's successful development strategy. 
 It was his success in this role which made him an obvious choice for prime minister, an essentially &bquo;managerial&equo; post. 
 Ahidjo decided in 1981 that for reasons of health, he would step down from the presidency but remain chairman of the ruling party, the Union Nationale Camerounaise (UNC). 
 In 1982 the presidency was constitutionally assumed by Biya who continued his drive to &bquo;modernize&equo; the economy. 
 However, by mid 1983 Ahidjo evidently regretted his decision and sought to exercise control, partly from Monaco, over the government from his position as party chairman. 
 The subsequent tension between the two men created an atmosphere in which there were two attempted coups in 1983, both emanating from sections of the army loyal to Ahidjo. 
 By the end of the year, Biya felt strong enough to force a showdown with Ahidjo and the latter lost the position of party chairman while still abroad. 
 Ahidjo did not subsequently return to Cameroun, and in the presidential election of January 1984 Biya received a &bquo;yes&equo; vote of over 90 per cent, which most Camerounians considered to be a genuine indication of his underlying support. 
 The following month he publicly waived the death sentence hanging over the organizers of the second coup attempt of 1983. 
 This was, however, to be the prelude to an even more serious attempt on his life by members of the Presidential Guard supported by other army units, and working with certain key civilians of the &bquo;systeme Ahidjo&equo;. 
 The attempted coup was eventually suppressed by the loyal Army command. 
 The retribution for which the army called was uncompromising and included the shooting of hundreds of soldiers and some civilians which only further increased the tension in the country. 
 Paul Biya did not appear in public for over six months, and his position has never fully recovered in spite of winning a new term in the March 1988 presidential election. 
 While Cameroun's economic activity returned to normal within a few months, the experience of the three attempted coups, and particularly of the last, undermined the sense of renewal which Paul Biya's elevation to the presidency had achieved. 
 Cameroun's tendency towards a secretive, police-dominated state, which had initially been developed in response to a regional rebellion in the 1960s, was strengthened, whereas most Camerounians had hoped to see it reversed. 
 The struggle over the succession between Ahidjo and Biya, in spite of its curious circumstances, had only served to emphasize that the succession problem remained alive and unresolved. 
 Senegal: the academician at work 
 The most important conscious attempt to solve the succession problem was made by Leopold Senghor in Senegal, who successfully handed over the presidency to Abdou Diop in 1980 after the re-introduction of a multi-party system in 1977. 
 Senghor himself had spent much of the 1930s after graduating from university as a teacher and well known poet in France. 
 He was therefore more than at home in French culture, he was an important participant in its development, assimilating it (as he reputedly said) rather than being assimilated by it. 
 As a deputy from Senegal to the French National Assembly from 1945 onwards, he was an experienced participant in multi-party politics, always deeply concerned with the interchange between the French and the African world view. 
 In 1984 he was elected to the very distinguished position of member of the Academie Francaise, bastion of French culture. 
 When Senegal achieved self-government in 1958, and full independence in 1960, Senghor presided over a one-party state but one in which public debate was more widespread than in most of Africa. 
 His sophisticated perception of the long-term problems of Senegalese politics, however, led him in 1977 to &bquo;invite&equo; the formation of three new parties &mdash; liberal democratic, social democratic, and left/Marxist. 
 Party groupings along these lines were indeed formed and fought a general election in 1978. 
 These were respectively, the Parti Democratique Senegalais (PDS), Senghor's own Union Progressiste Senegalais (UPS) renamed Parti Socialiste (PS), and the Parti Africa d'Independence (PAI). 
 The outcome for party politics was healthy: the PS won 82 per cent of the vote; the PDS won 17 per cent; and the PAI won just 1 per cent of the vote. 
 In this election, Senghor himself was elected to a third seven-year term as president. 
 In fact it must have always been his intention, after this grand restructuring to retire, and in 1980 the PS elected Diop to be party president. 
 Senghor has retired entirely from Senegalese national and party politics and lives partly in France, although disagreements between himself and Diop have subsequently been recorded. 
 In retrospect, it appears that Senghor's strategy was first to reconfirm that his party and its policies continued to have support from the Senegalese people, by giving them real alternatives, and then to enable a young and clearly competent successor to take over the leadership of both the party and the government. 
 An integral part of this strategy was to establish parties which had support from several or all of Senegal's ethnic groups, by adopting the proportional representation system of election, and avoiding the close identity of an elected delegate with one geographical constituency. 
 The Senegalese political system has continued to be robust in spite of the country's current grave economic problems, and in spite of secessionist pressures in the Casimance, the area of Senegal south of the Gambia. 
 However, in the February 1988 elections the presidential candidate of the PDS, the main opposition party &mdash; Abdoulaye Wade &mdash; made public allegations of vote rigging, and was imprisoned before the results were declared. 
 After the official count, he was shown to have won 25 per cent of the vote, and later released though he was not allowed, at least temporarily, to take up his seat in Parliament. 
 Nonetheless, the Senegalese system has dealt with the succession problem impressively, and sustained a multi-party tradition which allows a wide range of opinion to be expressed in public, and in doing so has avoided the most acute problems of localism. 
 The reasons for this relative success certainly run deeper than Leopold Senghor's personality. 
 There are at least two special features of Senegal's political inheritance which make it unique in Africa. 
 The first of these is the fact that France's contact with Senegal was long and deep. 
 The first French post at St Louis was established as early as 1638. 
 The residents of St Louis and the other three major towns on the coast (Rufisque, Goree and Dakar) were granted full French citizenship in 1916, and from then until independence had full voting rights in French national elections. 
 Two years earlier, on a more limited franchise, the first Senegalese deputy, Blaise Diagne, had been elected to the French National Assembly and had rapidly become a junior minister. 
 The second special factor has been the role played by the Murid Brotherhood, an Islamic movement founded in the first decade of the twentieth century by Amadu Bamba, which has played a key political role in delivering support first for the French colonial authorities and later for the governments of independent Senegal. 
 The Brotherhood has immense economic power which was at first based on its control of the ground-nut trade but later on a diversified portfolio of business interests, many of them urban. 
 Even in contemporary Senegal the laws of the state are only observed in the territory of the Murid following the assent of its shaikh, Abdoul Khadre. 
 Thus Senghor was able to build a political regime which was not only founded on a democratic tradition two generations old, but also had to accommodate a major countervailing influence to that of the state in the form of the Brotherhood. 
 TOMORROW'S MEN 
 The efforts of African leaders to build a new political system within their countries in the last twenty-five years have not for the most part been successful. 
 They have nearly always fallen foul of the three enemies: of localism, of the drift to authoritarian government, and of the failure to deal with the succession issue. 
 Individual leaders have succeeded in dealing with one of the three problems: Nyerere has defeated localism, Kenyatta maintained a relatively liberal state, Senghor managed a peaceful succession. 
 None has yet managed to deal decisively with two, and still less with all three of the problems. 
 Nyerere, if he manages the full handover of not only governmental power but also party power, may achieve the distinction of dealing with two of the problems. 
 The Ghanaian novelist, Kwasi Armah, gave the title The Beautiful Ones Are Not Yet Born  to a novel he published in 1969. 
 Its message was that Africa had not yet produced a generation of political leaders capable of providing the leadership it needs. 
 Chinua Achebe's novel, Anthills of the Savannah  published in 1987 suggested that such leadership had still not emerged almost twenty years later. 
 It seems likely that the &bquo;beautyful ones&equo; will only emerge when and if the second generation of authoritarian leaders are challenged by the growth of countervailing forces to that of the state. 
 The example of Senegal shows the crucial role which such forces can play, and their potential growth elsewhere is discussed further in Chapter 12. 
 The Politics of Development 
 &bquo;Seek ye first the political kingdom&equo; said Kwame Nkrumah, and nearly all African Heads of State have done exactly that in the last quarter of a century. 
 Economics has usually been subordinate to politics, and politics have generally been dominated by localism and authoritarianism, the latter being reflected in a view that &bquo;big&equo; government was best. 
 If, as Kamuzu Banda says &bquo;Everything is my business, everything&equo;, then the arm of government has had to stretch far and deep into the economy. 
 Even in a country such as Ivory Coast, generally regarded as in the capitalist camp, government has been the decisive player in the economy not only as policymaker but also as holder of equity capital. 
 Most post-independence governments had, at one level, a commitment to an economic transformation with several components. 
 The first was a reduction in their country's dependence on the export of primary commodities (whether agricultural or mineral) to an unstable world market. 
 This was to be achieved partly by diversifying exports, but more significantly by creating local industries to manufacture goods that had previously been imported. 
 The second component was to create educational and health services as rapidly as possible for as many people as possible, and the third was to achieve some fairer distribution of income between expatriate companies and individuals, and the local indigenous population. 
 PLANS OR LEAPS? 
 In the 1960s and 1970s most governments set up economic planning organizations which reflected these objectives. 
 The development plans which they produced in the first decade of independence were for the most part competent, well thought out and well presented. 
 They owed something to European social democracy, including the French experience of planning, and something to the planning experience of other parts of the developing world, notably India. 
 However, the priorities of government manifested on a day-to-day basis frequently ignored the longer-term priorities nominally established in the plans. 
 This was sometimes the result of dramatic political decisions (&bquo;great leaps forward&equo;) to transform the pattern of economic ownership, sometimes the outcome of political rivalry leading to civil strife or war, and sometimes the result of the attraction of prestige projects. 
 Leading individuals within governments frequently had a different set of objectives to those which their governments nominally espoused. 
 These centred on personal power and wealth and were manifest in Nigeria, for example, by 1966 when the first military coup was staged. 
 General Obasanjo's biography of his friend Chukwuma Nzeogu, the organizer of the coup, makes it very clear that the objective of the coup leaders was to create a government no longer dominated by these values. 
 They had also become evident in Zimbabwe by 1989, when the ten-year-old government was rocked by a series of corruption scandals and five Cabinet members were obliged to resign. 
 But corruption is only a partial explanation of some of the key strategic decisions taken by the governments. 
 Chapter 7 discussed the three major changes in economic strategy undertaken in Tanzania from 1967 to 1975. 
 These were far more significant than any item projected in the development plans. 
 In Zambia and Uganda, similar unplanned leaps were carried out between 1968 and 1970, placing a large number of private businesses in the public sector. 
 In Zambia the government took a controlling interest in twenty-six foreign-owned companies in 1968, and acquired a major stake in the two giant copper mining companies in 1969. 
 By 1973 this measure was considered inadequate and the government took total control of the mining companies. 
 In Uganda the nationalizations were to extend to the import and export business, although President Milton Obote in his first presidency was ousted by General Amin before being able to implement the programme. 
 Inevitably, priorities also shifted as a result of civil strife, which has been of fundamental importance to at least twelve of sub-Saharan Africa's forty-one countries. 
 Major civil conflicts lasting several years &mdash; other than the wars of liberation and their aftermath in the former Portuguese territories &mdash; have taken place in Nigeria. 
 Chad, Sudan, Ethiopia, Zaire, Uganda, and Somalia. 
 In some cases such strife has proved to be recurrent over twenty years, as in Zaire, Sudan, and Burundi and in others more or less endemic, as in Chad and Uganda and in Ethiopia in its fight to contain Eritrea. 
 In all cases the strife has fundamentally weakened central governments, diverting both energy and money away from development issues to the domestic conflicts which assume overwhelming importance. 
 Putting aside these cases of major civil strife it is possible to discern some consistency in the pattern of apparently arbitrary economic decisions taken by governments, whether or not in the form of &bquo;great leaps&equo;. 
 The dominant thread has been a key role for the state in both the accumulation and distribution of wealth echoing the role of pre-colonial states such as Asante, Buganda and UrOzwi discussed in Chapter 4. 
 This has not extended to the maintenance of capital assets once established, and of infrastructure such as roads, railways, and buildings. 
 Government has gauged its success much more by the number of new investments, than by the efficiency with which existing investments are maintained and serviced. 
 In 1977 Tanzania received thirty-five new diesel engines for the railway system under aid provided by Canada; by 1982 seventeen of these were out of order and by 1988 rolling stock problems had reduced the once-daily service on the Chinese-built railway to Zambia (opened in 1976) to just twice-weekly. 
 Sudan's greatest economic asset since the 1920s has been the Gezira Scheme, comprising nearly 2 million acres under irrigation, growing a variety of cash crops, notably cotton. 
 By the late 1960s the emphasis of government policy was on the creation of new irrigation complexes, covering an additional million acres at a time when Gezira was experiencing major problems of productivity. 
 Average cotton yields fell by as much as forty per cent in the course of the 1970s. 
 This declining productivity was largely due to salination in the Gezira canals, a by-product of declining standards of management. 
 As a result, the running costs of Gezira became a burden on the Sudanese government budget, while the scheme made a declining contribution to exports. 
 There are countless examples from most African countries of a similar negligence of completed investments, although some of this is a by-product of the nature of development aid, as we shall see in Chapter 11. 
 Hard top roads, built in the 1960s, in countries as different as Tanzania and Cameroun have needed total reconstruction in the 1980s. 
 PRESTIGE PROJECTS 
 An equally explicit consequence of the emphasis on the role of the state has been the number of prestige projects associated with the promotion of the individual personality of the head of state. 
 In Chapter 3 pre-colonial chiefs were characterized as &bquo;the mystical and religious heads, the divine symbol of their people's health and welfare&equo;. 
 There can be no doubt that in many African states this status has been consciously sought by leaders who have promoted it through the nature of their public appearances and prestige investments. 
 This has been most dramatic in the case of &bquo;Emperor&equo; Bokassa of the Central African Republic, but equally consistent in the cases of Houphouet Boigny, Banda and Mobutu. 
 The list of prestige projects to which governments committed themselves is long, ranging from magnificent presidential palaces in such countries as Liberia, Cameroun and Gabon, to whole capital cities as in Malawi, Tanzania and Nigeria. 
 Hosting the Organization of African Unity became a prestige project in itself, as several countries (including Ghana and Gabon) built massive facilities to host the annual meeting, or as in the case of Togo, to attract the OAU's permanent secretariat away from Addis Ababa. 
 The latter bid failed. 
 President Houphouet Boigny of Ivory Coast's plan to construct a church larger than St Peter's in Rome at his birthplace at Yameossouko is perhaps the most dramatic of all. 
 Linked to this persistent emphasis on the head of state as a quasi-mystical individual has been a countervailing disregard for the opinions and practices of village communities, except as the means of export revenue and, where tribal links justify it, as a source of political support. 
 This disregard is reinforced not only by long-standing attitudes to authority, but also by the more recent divide between those with and without formal education. 
 It appears to be even more prevalent in &bquo;socialist&equo; states than in &bquo;capitalist&equo; states: the compulsory movement to ujamaa  villages in Tanzania in 1975 would have been impossible in a society which genuinely respected peasant opinion. 
 This is equally true for the government of Ethiopia's attempt to move at least one million people, frequently by force, from the northern districts to the west of the country between 1985 and 1987. 
 It can also be seen in the efforts of the Frelimo government in Mozambique to build a system of communal villages which according to Samora Machel, the first president of independent Mozambique, would: 
 constitute the spinal column of the forces of development in the countryside&hellip; in the collective life the immense creative initiative of the people will be liberated. 
 Politically &lsqb;the villages&rsqb; will be the instrument for the realisation of worker power in government, defence, production etc&hellip; we know that dispersed and disorganised we &lsqb;the workers&rsqb; will never exercise power. 
 By 1978, 1500 such villages had been created incorporating about a million people. 
 The nucleus of each village was for the most part made up of the Frelimo guerillas who had fought in the liberation struggle. 
 By 1980 it was clear that such villages were doing little to improve the lot of their members, whose livelihood now depended on their effective integration into the cash economy. 
 By 1983, although the weaknesses of the programme were increasingly acknowledged within the party, the government's response was to resort to more authoritarian methods of &bquo;policing&equo; the villages. 
 Some of the practices of the colonial state were re-introduced, including corporal punishment, and some of those elected to village councils were rejected on the grounds that they had held positions under the previous regime. 
 The villagization programme was an expensive allocation of development resources, as well as a political disaster. 
 It certainly assisted in the development of Renamo in the 1980s as a terrorist group in opposition to government, albeit supported by South Africa. 
 CENTRALIZING THE ECONOMY 
 More specific economic policies, which have been widely discussed in recent years, fit within this tendency towards an autocratic state. 
 These include exchange rates, agricultural pricing, and attitudes to the local and international private sector. 
 The question of over-valued exchange rates &mdash; which minimize the cost of &bquo;imports&equo; but also minimize the value of exports in local currency &mdash; has been highly controversial in recent years between African governments and major aid donors such as the World Bank. 
 Most of the structural adjustment programmes (SAP) now in place have involved a significant exchange rate adjustment, which has had the effect of cheapening local currencies in relation to harder international currencies, in a number of cases by a factor of three or four within two to three years. 
 The over-valuation was, and frequently is, to the advantage of the urban sector in general and the government sector in particular. 
 For a given outlay of local currency it has ensured a higher value of imports than would have been available under a market valuation of the currency. 
 As a consequence, government has been able to expand the sphere of its operations at the expense of the peasant farmers whose primary produce formed the bulk of exports. 
 For instance, under a market valuation of exchange rates Tanzania's coffee producers would have received a significantly higher farmgate price when expressed in local currency, and their capacity to save and invest would have been higher. 
 Yet these coffee producers were primarily waChagga from Kilimanjaro or waHaya from Bukoba, on Lake Victoria. 
 Government was particularly anxious that neither group should retain the relative economic dominance which it had acquired during the colonial period, and exchange rate management was one means by which this dominance could be restrained. 
 In fact, in Tanzania in 1984 farmgate prices for a mix of agricultural products using estimated market exchange rates were only 20 per cent of export prices. 
 The effect of exchange rate policy has been reinforced by agricultural pricing policy. 
 Marketing Boards have been an instrument favoured by most African governments as a means of ensuring that farmers have an outlet for their crops, and that urban consumers pay for basic foodstuffs at a controlled, often subsidized, price. 
 Consequently, such marketing boards have frequently found themselves in a price squeeze, unable to offer a price high enough to producers, but only able to sell to consumers at a loss. 
 As a result they have also been trapped into importing food, an operation with considerable potential for losses, although ameliorated by exchange rate policy. 
 In many countries this process had a cumulative impact throughout the 1970s so that by the end of that decade the difference between the price paid to farmers for a crop and the price charged to distributors was highly inequitable. 
 In the 1980s there has been an important adjustment in both exchange rates and agricultural pricing policy largely as a result of pressure from international aid agencies. 
 However the extent to which governments are really committed to these policies is an open question, discussed in Chapters 11 and 12. 
 THE FOREIGN INVESTOR: FRIEND OR FOE? 
 The attitudes of governments to private foreign investors and to the local private sector have always been complex and varied. 
 With a few exceptions, such as Liberia under Tubman and Tolbert, and Gabon under Bongo, foreign investors have been regarded with feelings of wariness or hostility. 
 Attitudes to local investors from immigrant communities, such as Lebanese and Syrians in west Africa and Indians in east Africa, whether or not they were citizens, have frequently been equally wary. 
 Attitudes to the indigenous African private sector have obviously been more favourable and many indigenous businessmen have prospered, particularly as clients and customers of the government. 
 However, such favoured treatment has often been restricted to individuals from tribes linked to the government of the day. 
 It is not surprising that at independence most governments identified the international companies from the former colonial power as potential agents of neo-colonialism, who could not be trusted to operate with the interests of African countries at heart. 
 Indeed in cases where such companies had a vital stake, as with the British South Africa Union Mini&egrave;re in Zaire they were seen to behave badly at the very point at which their host countries became independent. 
 Thus the BSA attempted to extort over &pound;20 million from the new government of Zambia in 1964 in exchange for its mineral rights, but was ultimately forced to accept &pound;4 million. 
 In 1961 Union Mini&egrave;re made a naked bid to split off Katanga from the rest of Zaire. 
 In the early 1970s the cynical and exploitative role of multinational companies appeared to be confirmed as it became clear that Shell and BP, the latter half-owned by the British government, were the principal source of oil supplies to the outlawed Smith regime of Rhodesia. 
 Such dramatic examples of commercial self-interest were not in reality offset by the more representative efforts of companies such as Unilever, Mitchell Cotts and Booker McConnell in English-speaking Africa, or CFAO in French-speaking Africa who had invested on a long term basis for relatively modest returns. 
 The dominant position these companies occupied in the economy was sufficient for their position to be questioned. 
 A survey of the 1320 companies registered in Nigeria in 1970 indicated that 400 were wholly foreign-owned, including nearly all of the largest. 
 In the same year in Kenya it has been estimated that African citizens and government institutions owned only about 5 per cent of corporate assets. 
 Consequently, relations between African countries and international companies were for twenty years characterized by a battle to take some degree of national control. 
 Strategies for control have included the compulsory sale of 51 per cent of the share capital in the businesses nationalized by Tanzania's Arusha Declaration in 1967, the compulsory sale of the majority of share capital by all large companies in Nigeria from 1974 to 1977, and the &bquo;creeping sale&equo; of 20 per cent of issued share capital in the Ivory Coast required from 1975 onwards (achieved by issuing new equity). 
 In Tanzania, Julius Nyerere commented, &bquo;Our purpose was primarily a political purpose; it was an extension of the political control which the Tanzanian people secured in 1961.&equo; 
 The objective of the other forms of nationalization was clearly similar and the effect of each of them has been to reduce foreign ownership in the corporate sector to a relatively modest level. 
 In Ivory Coast the transfer of ownership has been essentially from the foreign private investor to the local private investor: government remains the owner of 50 per cent of corporate capital (as it has been since the 1960s) and the foreign investors' share has been reduced to 30 per cent, with the local private sector taking the remainder. 
 In Nigeria the foreign investors' share is now about 20 per cent, with the bulk of the remainder held in the Nigerian private sector; the localization legislation created over one million individual shareholders. 
 In the aftermath of the Arusha Declaration, the value of corporate assets held by the state in Tanzania increased sevenfold from financial years 1970/1 to 1977/8. 
 The consequences of this creation of a large, government-owned, or parastatal sector, were expensive. 
 First, in many cases the previous foreign owners of those companies which passed into local ownership, either private or state, were invited to continue as managers for which they received a management fee. 
 As often as not this was fixed and not related to the performance of the company. 
 Thus previous foreign shareholders received not only some (albeit frequently delayed) compensation for the shares sold, but also a reliable annual income. 
 In the 1980s payments of this kind, and for related royalties and patents, have come to equal about 40 per cent of the income in dividends which accrues to foreign investors and they are usually given priority in payment over dividends. 
 In Nigeria they averaged about &dollar;200 million per year between 1981 and 1986. 
 Second, in the cases where the previous management was not invited to stay on, or declined to do so, lower levels of efficiency in management have proved disastrously expensive. 
 Such management has been recruited from a combination of civil servants with little or no commercial experience, individuals with limited commercial experience in, for instance, the co-operative movement, individuals with experience in foreign-owned enterprises but at a low level, or even ex-politicians. 
 Such management has been particularly subject to political pressure in support of localism, both from central government and from regional and district governments. 
 THE STATE IN BUSINESS 
 The inadequacies of management in state enterprises have been described in dramatic terms by several Nigerian academic observers, one of whom wrote in 1974 that the reasons for the poor performance of the state-owned sector could be seen in the words of one observer &bquo;in the over centralization of authority&hellip; inspired by sheer love of power&equo; or by another: 
 in unwise policy decisions; in day to day ineptness in running the enterprises; in illicit government transfer payments in construction and purchase contracts and through every other imaginable channel; in the use of contractor finance and suppliers' credits to finance the venality of state officials; and in overburdened and unrealistic capital structures. 
 Such a management style was by no means typical of Nigeria alone. 
 Direct theft from the parastatal system was common in Tanzania by the 1980s. 
 Thus in 1988 the Tanzanian Parliamentary Public Accounts Committee reported that about &dollar;5 million had been taken in 1987 in the form of &bquo;outright theft&equo; from parastatal companies. 
 If there is a prevailing thread in the history of these state-owned enterprises it is the constant under-assessment of risk &mdash; of the lack of imported materials to supply a manufacturing process, of failure in the supply of inputs ranging from petrol to fertilizer, of farming communities not producing the cash crops to keep a processing plant in operation, and of failing to find competent management for complex operations. 
 Even when meaningful financial rates of return were calculated, and proved to be low, but just in excess of the cost of borrowing, decisions were taken to implement projects as a result of pressure for action. 
 This risk negligence also affected the choice of technology: projects which appeared to achieve high levels of production rapidly by using advanced technology would be preferred to those which achieved them more slowly by using more appropriate technology. 
 In fact, government-owned companies, far from providing support to national revenues, became a major drain upon them as is apparent from the following summary from the government's own Economic Survey of 1982 of the state of Tanzania's state-owned textile mills: 
 The combined output of the five largest textile factories, namely the Friendship Textile Mill, Mwatex, Mutex, Kiltex and Sunguratex was only 67.2 million sq. 
 metres of cloth, compared to their total installed capacity of 152 million square metres. 
 Capacity utilisation for these five factories is thus only 44.2 per cent. 
 The output of the Mwatex Mill was only 4.8 million sq.metres compared to the existing capacity for the mill of 45 million sq.metres. 
 The mill experienced an acute power problem during the year following the breakdown of its four generators, grinding the mill to a complete halt between October 1982 and March 1983. 
 Even after repair works on the generators had been done, only two of them operated satisfactorily forcing the factory to work on only two shifts instead of the usual three. 
 Mutex also experienced power problems and shortage of spare parts, while shortage of fuel oil used in the boilers affected both Mutex and Mwatex. 
 The Kiltex mill in Dar es salaam closed temporarily due to lack of water and shortage of spare parts, while the Arusha Mill could not operate to full capacity because polyester yarn could not be imported in sufficient quantities. 
 Sunguratex experienced inadequate and intermittent water supplies and shortage of spare parts while Blanket manufacturers was mainly affected by non-availability of spare parts for its ageing machinery. 
 This is a description of an industrial disaster seldom experienced in peacetime conditions. 
 In this situation it is very difficult to &bquo;rehabilitate&equo; companies since the depreciated assets of these and similar businesses are virtually worthless. 
 By the late 1970s the state sector had become not only a harbour of inefficiency, as in many &bquo;developed&equo; countries, but also a greenhouse of the hybrid values emerging in Africa many of which were inimical to efficient methods of low-cost production. 
 CITIZEN ENTREPRENEURS 
 Promotion of the state-owned sector has generally gone hand in hand with promotion of the indigenous, i.e. African, private sector, although in &bquo;socialist&equo; countries the scope of the latter has sometimes been consciously restricted. 
 In 1966 Nkrumah said that 
 if he permitted African businessmen to grow &lsqb;they&rsqb; will grow to the extent of becoming a rival power to his and the party's prestige, and he would do anything to stop it. 
 If socialist regimes have been reluctant to promote indigenous businessmen for this reason, most regimes have sought to curtail the role of the immigrant groups who had played a key role in the economy in the colonial period. 
 In the early 1960s many of these groups had the basic financial strength and business experience to move into manufacturing. 
 However, if Kenya the result of these policies was, for instance, that &bquo;the local Asian bourgeoisie was really placed in a category of foreign investor.&equo; 
 In Uganda (a country whose modern sector had been largely built by Indian entrepreneurs) Milton Obote inserted a clause in the new Republican Constitution in 1966 which restricted the ownership of &bquo;land, property or business, in certain areas to &bquo;citizens of African blood&equo;. 
 Six years later Idi Amin expelled the whole Asian community. 
 In Tanzania the Asians suffered attrition in stages as the combined effects of the Arusha Declaration and the nationalization of both private houses and wholesale trade &bquo;cut them off at the knees&equo; as Nyerere expressed it. 
 While this attitude of hostility to immigrant groups was less severe in west Africa it certainly played a role in Ghana from Nkrumah's period, and in Nigeria as a result of the &bquo;localization&equo; decree of 1974. 
 It has also been seen in a more subtle form in the moves in Sierra Leone in the 1970s and Liberia in the 1980s by the &bquo;truly indigenous&equo; or tribal population to take economic power away from the creole population which had been active in trading and business for more than a century. 
 This has been the principal objective of President Doe of Liberia, himself of tribal origin. 
 It has been a less serious factor in the French-speaking countries where European traders and shopkeepers continue to operate small businesses, although these could be periodically subject to local political pressures including arbitrary taxation. 
 In contrast, in countries as distinct as Nigeria and Zambia, governments have supported the indigenous African entrepreneurs who benefited from these restraints on their potential competitors by a range of credit facilities and the judicious allocation of contracts. 
 These allowed many former civil servants to enter business (notably in Zambia) and many of the established traders of west Africa (most dramatically in Nigeria) to move from commerce into production. 
 In theory, each of these has the capacity to know to be a medium and even large scale business, and to take on the corporate giants in the course of time. 
 In practice, this has very seldom happened except when a local business has accepted a very dependent relationship with an outside investor. 
 These limitations will be discussed in more detail in Chapter 10. 
 THE PRICE 
 In spite of the prevalence of economic planning in the 1960s and 1970s, it is doubtful whether a development policy has existed in most of Africa in the last twenty-five years. 
 Rather, the critical determinant of economic policy has been the hidden or not so hidden hand of political priorities. 
 Those priorities have reflected politicians' prime concern: to centralize economic power in the hands of the government in a way which matched the centralization of political power as expressed through the one-party state. 
 In the agricultural sector, the self-interest of the state has led to policies which have favoured distorted exchange rates, consistently favouring government and the urban population at the expense of the incomes of rural families, and ultimately at the expense of marketed production. 
 Giant and inefficient marketing boards have had the opposite effect of their nominal purpose, and have further squeezed farmers' margins. 
 The voices of rural families have seldom been heard in effective protest, and least of all in socialist states such as Tanzania and Mozambique, each of which have compelled large chunks of their rural population to live in communal villages against their will. 
 The process of centralization has involved governments in taking a major stake in investments which were previously foreign-owned. 
 While justified in reaction to the dominance of foreign investment at the time of independence, it has proved to be a very expensive strategy. 
 Ownership has sometimes been transferred into local hands (private or state) while the original owners have continued as managers on a financial basis which has frequently been unrelated to their performance. 
 Where ownership has been transferred without continuity of management the levels of inefficiency experienced have often been disastrous, setting up a vicious spiral of underperformance. 
 While the truly indigenous private sector has been assisted in various ways to play a greater role in the national economy, this has often been at the expense of immigrant communities, who have rights of citizenship based on birth. 
 This process has diminished the role which experienced local skills and capital could have played, and even the allocation of opportunities to the indigenous entrepreneur has seldom been fairhanded, and free of localism and corruption. 
 Four of Africa's most talented peoples &mdash; the Ibo, the Bamilike, the waChagga and the Bugunda &mdash; have all had their innovative talents circumscribed for many years. 
 Putting the &bquo;political kingdom&equo; first has been expensive and is now self-evidently an expense which Africa can no longer afford. 
 The Elusive Surplus 
 The real heroes of agriculture in Africa are the pioneers who down the centuries have brought new crops or cattle to their own or other communities. 
 The story recalled in Chapter 2 of a stranger named Chipimbi who came to live amongst the Lamba of Zambia, and brought them seeds of maize, sorghum and groundnuts, was one such hero. 
 His fellows include those who brought bananas from the Indian Ocean coast to the highlands of east Africa, those who brought cassava from the Atlantic coast of Angola to the forests of Zaire, and those who first trekked the hump-backed Zebu cattle down the valley of the Nile. 
 In every case where such innovations proved lasting, it was because they adapted well to the specific environment of the farmers. 
 Frequently, they were the key to the constant moving frontier of the Bantu expansion. 
 However, for every successful adoption of a new crop or new variety of crop it is certain that there were many more failed attempts at innovation, for the African physical environment places many difficulties in the path of farmers. 
 Rainfall is uncertain and varied &mdash; drought years may be as many as one in five; many soils are eroded and soil quality may vary within as little space as a hectare; even small-scale irrigation may be ineffective as high levels of &bquo;run-off&equo; prevent the efficient use of water. 
 The first cultivators in Africa, as in all parts of the world, would farm a field for a few years and then, when its fertility began to drop, move on to an adjacent, or occasionally distant, area where high yields could be maintained for a similar period. 
 When land became scarce farmers could move back to land that they, or their fathers had already cultivated. 
 The length of the period of cultivation in this bush/fallow cycle depended on the quality of the soils, the requirement of the crops for nutrients, and on whether fertility was supplemented by cattle manure from the farmers' own livestock. 
 As a result, it could vary from one to four or five years, with fallow periods of four to twenty years, the greater periods being common in the equatorial forests. 
 FEEDING THE PEOPLE 
 In some cases new crops and local innovation made quite high levels of population density possible, and reduced the necessary fallow period to only one or two years. 
 These cases included the waChagga on Kilimanjaro, the Ibo in eastern Nigeria, the Bamilike of western Cameroun, as well as smaller groups such as the waKara who inhabit an island on Lake Victoria and the waTengo in hill country in south-west Tanzania. 
 One of the first written descriptions of the waChagga system is that of Sir Harry Johnston in 1894: 
 They mostly excel in their industry &mdash; the skill with which they irrigate their terraced hillsides with tiny runnels of water shows a considerable advancement in agriculture. 
 Their time is constantly spent in tilling the soil, manuring it with ashes, raking and hoeing it with wooden hoes. 
 This system was probably capable of supporting about 400 people per square mile. 
 The similarly complex system developed by the waTengo was based on a pattern in which grass, weeds and crop refuse were composted in Pits which were retained in both cropping and fallow periods. 
 This very effectively conserved run-off and avoided water logging. 
 Both these mountainside systems had been developed as a response to communities being forced by hostile forces (the Masai in the case of the waChagga, and the Nguni in the case of the waTengo) to live in a restricted area. 
 The experience of the waKara is rather different. 
 here, the pressure of population growth within the confines of a small island of only 29 square miles led to the development of an innovatory, intensive system based on very effective soil conservation techniques &mdash; including the integration of fodder and arable crops and livestock. 
 The waKara farmed on the basis of a three-year rotation of bullrush millet, groundbeans and sorghum. 
 During this three-year period they applied two dressings of farmyard manure and in the intervening year they applied an indigenous legume crop as green manure. 
 This system enabled them to maintain an exceptionally dense population, on the best principles of fertility conservation. 
 The waKara were not exceptional in combining the ownership of livestock with crop production, but they were exceptional in integrating the two. 
 Other African communities, such as the Lozi on the Barotse floodplain in western Zambia, and, on a smaller scale the Yoruba in western Nigeria, maintained livestock herds which were essentially secondary to their crop production, providing manure for crops on an ad hoc  basis. 
 The true pastoralists, such as the Fulani, the Dinka of southern Sudan and the Masai of the east African plains were in a different category. 
 They were primarily dependent on their cattle for subsistence &mdash; particularly from milk and blood &mdash; though in some cases also planted short-season sorghum or millet as a supplement. 
 They might make an incidental contribution to crop production by agreeing to graze their herds over settled farmers' land once it had been harvested. 
 Further, the size of their herds could rise and fall dramatically depending upon the incidence of livestock diseases such as foot-and-mouth and rinderpest. 
 In the 1880s, the large herds of the kingdom of Karagwe in western Tanzania were severely depleted by rinderpest, and did not recover for several decades. 
 Thus the agricultural systems of pre-colonial Africa were in a delicate balance with the environment, and sometimes with each other. 
 They supported a total population estimated at about 100 million, which remained more or less static from 1600 to 1850 &mdash; or about 5 people per square mile of cultivable land. 
 Although innovation in particular cases had fostered very high population densities, it was the absence of population growth resulting from both the slave trade and the incidence of disease that provided little general incentive to intensify systems which were an adequate response to the difficulties of the environment. 
 IMPERIAL INTERVENTION 
 Before the First World War the impact of the new colonial governments on this pattern of agriculture was extremely limited. 
 Their primary emphasis was on the development of large-scale commercial agriculture &mdash; either through large, corporate-owned estates (as with oil palm in Zaire, coffee, and bananas in Cameroun, and cotton in Sudan), through individual settlers (as in Kenya, Zimbabwe and Zambia), or through both (as in Tanzania and Cameroun). 
 Sometimes this went hand in hand with the development of small-scale agriculture, although the circumstances in which this occurred varied greatly. 
 Sometimes, as with cotton in Zaire, Chad and Tanzania such planting was compulsory; sometimes, as with cocoa in Ghana, coffee in Cameroun and cotton in Uganda and Sudan it was voluntary. 
 However in these years the total area of land devoted to such cash Crops by smallholders was minuscule in relation to the total area in production, and had little impact on the bush/fallow system as it had been traditionally practised. 
 In the 1920s and 1930s there was a change of policy within the colonial powers which placed greater importance on the need for African colonies to be financially self-supporting. 
 A much stronger emphasis on all forms of export agriculture, particularly through smallholder production, was one way of achieving this. 
 Production of cotton in Uganda grew from 20,000 bales in 1920 to 400,000 in 1935; exports of palm oil from Zaire grew from 40,000 tonnes in 1915 to 150,000 tonnes in 1935. 
 These dramatic increases in production intensified during or after World War Two: in Nigeria groundnut production tripled between 1938 and 1948; in Uganda coffee production also tripled in the 1950s; in Zaire there were 800,000 cotton growers by 1950. 
 As the total area allocated to these crops increased, so the amount of time and land which a family could devote to food crop production for its own consumption often diminished. 
 Yet, from the inter-war years, as medical services spread, the total population of Africa began to rise sharply. 
 Between 1921 and 1944 the population of Kenya grew from 2.3 million to 3.8 million, and annual rates of growth of more than 2 per cent became the norm across most of the continent. 
 Average population densities doubled between 1900 and 1960. 
 The introduction of cash crops and an increasing population acted together to increase pressure on the land significantly, in specific cases even to critical levels, such as in Ruanda and in the &bquo;reserves&equo; of Kenya and Zimbabwe. 
 By 1970, about 20 per cent of the land in cultivation was down to export crops. 
 Where large numbers of livestock existed, the introduction of modern veterinary services also reduced the mortality rate of cattle. 
 The response of cattle owners was to increase the total numbers in their herd, rather than to maintain a smaller herd with lower mortality levels. 
 Where such cattle were owned by cultivators, as in Sukumaland in Tanzania, this also increased pressure on the land available for farming. 
 W.H. Allan, once director of agriculture in Northern Rhodesia and the author of a definitive work on change in decade the land area planted to cotton increased from 67,000 hectares to 170,000 hectares, and fears grew of a long-term decline in fertility. 
 A tough and wide-ranging conservation programme was introduced as an anti-famine measure. 
 Farmers were required to make &bquo;tie ridges&equo; which conserved moisture within the soil, to manure a certain proportion of their fields, and to plant a specified minimum acreage of cotton and cassava. 
 This campaign, however, was never fully effective. 
 The second approach was the attempt to create a new class of &bquo;master farmer&equo;. 
 Such individuals were to be the standard-bearers of an agricultural revolution based on a farming system which overcame the limitations of African soils by the scientific rotation of crops and their integration with livestock. 
 The aim was confirmed for Malawi, for instance, in a 1958 report which stated: 
 It is Government's aim to create a class of full time professional farmers with sufficient land to provide a reasonable standard of living and, as a corollary, gradually to squeeze the subsistence cultivator off the land into full time alternative employment&hellip; the Master Farmers Scheme was designed to create and develop such farmers. 
 Schemes of this kind enjoyed success only on a limited front. 
 An &bquo;improved farmer&equo; scheme in northern Nigeria achieved an average intake of 1,900 farmers a year from 1945 to 1955, with a failure rate of only 20 per cent. 
 However such farmers were necessarily exceptions within a farming community where shortening bush/fallow cycles were retained; they did not provide a solution to the underlying problem. 
 One of the most far reaching attempts within the third approach &mdash; the resettlement of large numbers of small farmers on newly defined farms &mdash; was in Zaire. 
 There the Belgian administration developed a system of &bquo;paysannats&equo; based on a crop rotation with n specially demarcated strips. 
 These were subdivided into smaller fields and a cropping rotation devised with the objective of moving production up and down the length of the strip. 
 A sufficient proportion of the strip was in fallow at any one time to ensure that yields were, in theory, maintained over a fifteen or twenty year period. 
 Separate designs were evolved for the very different conditions of forest and savannah. 
 In the former, the key cash crop was oil palm, and in the latter cotton. 
 The first paysannat was established in 1936 and the example, with adjustments, was subsequently widely followed. 
 By 1954, about 1.5 million hectares were under the system, divided between nearly 170,000 farming families. 
 By 1960, progress had been made towards establishing half a million family units. 
 One of the administrators of the scheme summarized its objective as being to 
 replace unorganized extensive agriculture, which often entails the irremediable destruction of natural wealth, by an agriculture which will become progressively intensive, at the same time assuring the continuing fertility of the soils. 
 The key to the paysannat concept, as indicated here, was that it would become more intensive over time. 
 It was recognized that the integration of some kind of livestock farming with crops would ultimately be desirable. 
 It was strongly supported in the 1950s by the companies who purchased the cotton grown as a cash crop in the savannah, because it appeared to be the most effective way to reverse the declining fertility and falling yields which had become apparent by that time. 
 The development of the system spanned more than twenty years and achieved a degree of success in terms of its defined objectives. 
 It was unpopular politically, as it involved a good deal of compulsion, and did not survive the chaos of independence. 
 However, it was probably the most serious attempt made in colonial Africa to adapt the traditional bush/fallow system to changing economic circumstances and, if sustained, might have provided technical answers to problems which still prove elusive. 
 Only in the 1980s has large-scale scientific work on bush/fallow rotation in the forest belt been revived, at the International Institute of Tropical Agriculture (ITA) in Nigeria. 
 A successful initiative 
 A further, far reaching initiative within this approach was made in Kenya immediately after the Mau Mau Emergency of 1954&ndash;7. 
 The situation in the Kikuyu areas of Kenya had become particularly acute by the 1950s as a result of the re-allocation from 1910 onwards of over 7 million acres of land to private European settlers. 
 Kikuyu farmers had traditionally farmed several plots which were within easy walking distance but had different characteristics of altitude and soil type. 
 Following the death of a land owner, his land would be divided between his sons; as the population increased the fragmentation which resulted from this approach became increasingly serious. 
 The introduction of cash crops in the 1930s further reduced the amount of land available for food production. 
 In Meru District by 1950 there was an average of five fragments per cultivator; the maximum was twenty-two. 
 The outermost fragments were as much as 20 miles apart. 
 It was the Mau Mau conflict itself which forced the government to recognize the need to increase the productivity of the Kikuyu areas, and it was the same conflict which facilitated the means. 
 However, the plan for this far-reaching land reform, drawn up by Roger Swynnerton of the Agricultural Department, was imaginative and effective. 
 It envisaged the consolidation of the scattered plots into farms of 7 to 10 acres, supporting an average household of six to eight people. 
 Such farms were to be carefully laid out by agricultural officers on the basis of an arable/grass ley rotation, including appropriate cash crops such as coffee and pyretheum. 
 Following consolidation, farmers would have irrevocable freehold tenure to their land. 
 The work was to be completed over the whole country in fifteen years. 
 In the District of Kiambu alone, over 500,000 fragmented plots were consolidated into 50,000 farms between 1956 and 1960. 
 Such a far reaching change could ultimately only have been achieved with general Kikuyu support. 
 By 1960 the process had achieved its own momentum so that 
 most European officers felt that they were no longer pushing out ideas and standards; in large measures the people themselves had seen the benefits and were doing it themselves. 
 The success of this approach was reflected in a threefold increase in marketed output from 1953 to 1962 in the areas where land reform had been implemented, without a matching decline in the productivity of food crops. 
 Since that time the productivity of the top 20 per cent of farmers has been sustained with a continuous record of technical improvement; about 40 per cent have maintained a level of productivity which enables them to generate an acceptable income; and a further 40 per cent have continued to produce enough for their own household's subsistence requirements. 
 Of these three policies adopted by colonial governments to deal with the acute pressure on land, the Kenyan example of land reform was the most successful, and the one whose benefits lasted well beyond independence. 
 Nonetheless, whatever success was achieved within these programmes it was not enough to change the general picture of an agricultural system which could only expand production by having access to more land. 
 The practices of livestock owners had not changed significantly with the spread of veterinary services and they too required more land. 
 In 1960, looking at sub-saharan Africa as a whole, such land was still densities were still only about 77 per square mile of cultivable land, or 3 hectares per head. 
 Much of this land was uninhabited, and for a variety of reasons ranging from the incidence of tsetse fly to the competing claims of different clans, farmers were reluctant to move into it. 
 The agricultural legacy of the colonial period was sometimes a modified form of shifting cultivation, sometimes a form of settled agriculture which tended to deplete the fertility of the soil. 
 The adaptability of African farmers was not in doubt, but whether they would be given the means to expand production to meet growing urban and international markets was an open question. 
 THE RUSH FOR GROWTH 
 Most newly independent governments were attracted to an agricultural strategy which thrust aside the supposed limitations of the existing agricultural system and adopted various forms of &bquo;transformation&equo; approach. 
 In some cases this included a continued emphasis on an elite group of master farmers; in others it included the development of settlement schemes where a concentration of supporting services were supposed to create a group of commercial, if small-scale, farmers; in others it included the development of large government-owned estates, managed by parastatal companies as described in Chapter 8. 
 With some exceptions, the transformation approach has not been successful. 
 The reasons for this include both the design of the projects &mdash; ranging from the crops selected to the land to which people have moved &mdash; and the quality of their management. 
 In the 1960s and 1970s these problems were consistently underrated by governments. 
 The most dramatic examples of this approach have included the massive resettlement schemes in Tanzania and Mozambique in the 1970s, and in Ethiopia in the mid 1980s. 
 In each case the consequences of moving a million or more people, in the case of Tanzania, at least five million, were hardly recognized before the operations began. 
 In Tanzania in the early 1980s, 90 per cent of agricultural production in the resettled villages was still geared to subsistence consumption and there had been no long-term increase in the productivity of the farmers involved. 
 Whatever resources were devoted to the transformation approach, the bulk of agricultural production continued to come from the millions of small farming families who were adjusting their forms of production only slowly. 
 In some cases they received support from government services for the first time. 
 In Zambia, the provision of hybrid maize seed, fertiliser and marketing services to small-scale farmers dated from the mid 1960s; in Kenya the provision of such services was extended for the first time in the 1960s well beyond the Kikuyu. 
 The response was erratic. 
 The local physical environment was not always well matched to these inputs. 
 Unjustified financial risk could be incurred by using fertiliser in an area of erratic rainfall; the labour required on cash crops could conflict with the labour required on food crops. 
 These dangers were matched to the inefficiency of the marketing boards which in most countries were supposed to buy the crop, and to the pricing policies discussed in Chapter 8 which until the mid 1980s consistently worked against the interests of small farmers. 
 As a result, the majority of farmers continued to concentrate their efforts on the production of food for their own families, rather than for the market. 
 Between 1960 and 1980 the total acreage devoted to food production in Africa increased from about 70 million hectares to about 100 million, or about 2.5 per cent per year, sufficient to sustain a population increase of about 2.7 per cent. 
 Yet during the same period the acreage devoted to export crops grew from only 15.5 million hectares to 17.2 million; of the seven major export crops the production volume of only three: tea, cotton and tobacco, increased. 
 Livestock owners continued to manage their herds primarily as a means of survival and a bank of wealth rather than to maximize the number of animals they marketed. 
 Africa's trade in cereals was seriously skewed. 
 She might, as in 1986&ndash;7, have to import 8 million tonnes of cereals, amounting to about 40 per cent of urban consumption, or, as in 1988/9 have a surplus of 3 million tonnes which could not be transported, and thus sold, to deficit countries. 
 Within this overall picture one approach, when well managed, appeared to combine the potential of commercial large-scale management with the potential of small farmers to achieve an increase in productivity. 
 A number of projects have been successful in which the supply of inputs and the marketing of the product are managed on a commercial basis while the bulk of production comes from small farmers. 
 These include the Smallholder Coffee Authority in Malawi, which supports 4,000 growers, the Mumias Sugar Company in Kenya which supports 30,000 growers, and the Kenya Tea Development Authority, which through a network of forty factories, supports over 150,000 small farmers. 
 All of these are projects in which the government holds a controlling interest and in which it has a strong commercial partner. 
 In each of these cases the majority of farmers have less than 1 hectare under the relevant crop, but most achieve levels of income well in excess of their neighbours who remain outside the projects. 
 Sometimes this success is at the expense of food production, but more often an increase in productivity is achieved across all crops. 
 While projects of this kind can be very impressive they cannot hope to generate an increase in output from the mass of small scale farmers, as their requirement for scarce, high level management is too great. 
 THE CURRENT REALITY 
 The last thirty years have not therefore established precedents for the future. 
 The rural population is growing at over 2 per cent per year and densities are increasing. 
 The underlying position remains one in which most of the rural population i.e. three quarters of the total, is able to feed itself adequately, but has neither the surplus labour nor the technology to make big strides in productivity. 
 The erratic performance of organizations which are supposed to support farmers, such as input supply companies and marketing boards, only exacerbates the situation. 
 Although some farmers are  adopting more intensive systems of production this is not yet at a fast enough rate to generate the large increases in marketed output necessary to feed the towns, where the population is growing at over 6 per cent per year. 
 Areas of critical population density continue to co-exist with areas which are relatively under-populated. 
 In a wide band of west Africa, from Dakar to Kano including the &bquo;sahelian&equo; and &bquo;sudanian&equo; zones, the total population in 1980 was about 30 million at an average  of 17 people per square kilometre. 
 Forty per cent of the people live in only 6 per cent of the total area, and densities rise to 100 per square kilometre. 
 To the south of this zone, where tree cover becomes more dense in the Guinea-savannah, population densities are particularly low and there is plenty of scope for inward migration. 
 This is occurring spontaneously, but not at a rate which significantly affects the dense clusters further north. 
 Such situations are replicated elsewhere: even in Tanzania, with its 24 million people, as much as one-third of the cultivable area is under-populated. 
 The facts that much farmed land falls short of its potential and that in large areas of Africa population levels are low, do not alter the fact that innovators in the tradition of Chipimbi continue to succeed in achieving important increases in productivity. 
 On a farm two miles from Ngaoundere, in northern Cameroun, Alhaji Hamayadji Giwa cultivates, with the support of his two wives, three hectares of sweet potatoes, bananas and ground-nuts. 
 The sweet potatoes are all of a specific variety, namely TIB 1, which is the product of breeding work carried out at IITA in Nigeria in the 1970s. 
 The yield of TIB 1 is three to four times greater than that of the local variety of sweet potato and Giwa is able to market about 60 tons of sweet potatoes per year. 
 Maintaining production at this level is back-breaking work. 
 However, the farm is one of the main sources of supply to the Ngaoundere market and use of TIB 1 has enabled Giwa to become an affluent &bquo;yeoman&equo; farmer. 
 More modest, but important, increases in the productivity of another root crop, cassava, have also been achieved by thousands of small farmers in western Nigeria. 
 Here, too, the cassava variety is the result of breeding work at IITA which has been available to farmers since 1978. 
 Ten years later in Oyo State, which has a total of about 100,000 farming families, nearly half of the land area had been planted with the new variety which out-yields the local varieties by about 25 per cent. 
 As 60 per cent of the cassava grown in this area is marketed in towns, a yield increase even of this order of magnitude has had a positive impact on urban food supplies. 
 An even greater sustained impact on productivity has occurred amongst the thousands of small farmers in the former reserve areas of Zimbabwe. 
 Here, the introduction of the hybrid maize variety SR 52 has had a dramatic effect on yields of maize. 
 From 1979, when the hybrids were distributed on a wide scale, to 1985 yields almost doubled. 
 As production increased farmers had a growing surplus over their household requirements and sold an increasing proportion of their crop, reaching 60 per cent in 1985 and in 1988, and accounting for half of the national marketed production. 
 Successes of this kind occur where technology, the potential of the farming system, and the market allow it. 
 In some areas these factors have to be reinforced by the provision of seasonal credit to enable farmers to adopt an innovation. 
 Thus in northern Nigeria there has been a long-established practice of Hausa farmers purchasing immature beef cattle at the end of the harvesting season, and feeding them on maize stalks and other crop residues during the dry season, before marketing them at the end of six months. 
 Space on the farm, and lack of finance, restricted the practice to an average of one beefcattle per farmer. 
 From 1976 credit was made available specifically for this purpose and farmers were encouraged to hold more than one animal, and to build stalls and improve feeding materials. 
 Within five years there were over 4000 smallholders participating in the scheme, and their marketed output had increased by nearly three times over previous levels. 
 In this case a strategy of building and strengthening an existing practice had combined with organizational arrangements to increase small farmers' output. 
 FOOD FOR THE FUTURE 
 The objectives of farmers in the future will be first, to continue feeding their families and second to take advantage of the expanding urban market. 
 Exports are likely to rank only as a third objective. 
 Whether they can increase production at a rate which allows urban markets to be fed and exports to be maintained depends on several factors. 
 Production systems will have to be intensified in ways which do not deplete fertility; areas which are now under-populated will have to be used more productively; the organizations which serve small farmers, including relevant agricultural research institutes, will have to be strengthened; and finally, agricultural prices will have to be maintained at a level which provides an incentive. 
 Important policy changes have been adopted by governments in agriculture in the late 1980s as a response to the relative failure of the preceding twenty-five years. 
 These have frequently been made in response to pressure from major international aid donors. 
 The most substantive changes have been considerable upward adjustments in prices paid to farmers, which have had a positive effect on output. 
 It is doubtful, however, whether the changes implemented to date constitute an adequate boost towards achieving a continuous increase in marketed surpluses. 
 The great majority of farmers continue to use minimal quantities of fertiliser although fertility is being depleted; few governments are tackling the question of the use of their under-populated areas on a systematic basis; the organizations which serve small farmers have cut back their operations in response to budgetary pressures and in response to the pressure for privatization; the frequently competent staff of national agricultural research bodies are everywhere starved of funds for transport and field labour. 
 Those countries which had the best record of increasing productivity in the 1960s and 1970s, such as Kenya and Cameroun, are no longer maintaining their momentum. 
 Irrigation has been shown to have potential on a relatively small scale, but cannot be a solution for the mass of farmers. 
 In spite of this, innovation by individuals and communities of farmers in Africa will continue, and for the most part will enable rural families to maintain themselves at a reasonable level of nutrition. 
 Food supplies to the one third of the population, or 230 million people, who will be living in towns by the year 2000 will be uneven, and a continued dependence on imports, if they can be financed, is likely. 
 The labour which rural families can devote to export crops will not grow significantly as a proportion of the total and &mdash; except where export crops have a very high value, as in the case of horticulture &mdash; they will grow only slowly, if at all. 
 Artisans and Entrepreneurs: the Industrial Dilemma 
 Pre-colonial Africa did not lack entrepreneurs who managed trading companies, in some cases stretching well beyond contemporary national frontiers, and which had the capacity to invest profits from trade in production. 
 As shown in Chapter 4, from medieval times gold was being exported from the Shona-speaking kingdoms centred at Great Zimbabwe through Arab traders at Sofala in Mozambique. 
 The trade was sufficiently profitable for the Portuguese to take over Sofala in the early sixteenth century, and their written accounts confirm that the export cargoes were brought to the coast by African representatives of the Shona king or monomutapa . 
 In West Africa trade with the Mediterranean coast and Cairo was continuous from medieval times. 
 The west African goldfields of Mali and Songhay probably produced about one-third of the gold in circulation in late medieval Europe.i Leading merchants of the city-states of the savannah maintained important trading links to the north. 
 For instance, Malam Yaroh of Zinder in Niger maintained his own agents on the north African coast in the mid-nineteenth century. 
 This network was so well developed that when Captain Hugh Clapperton &bquo;discovered&equo; Kano in 1824 he was able to obtain cash from a local merchant in return for a bill of exchange on the British consul at Tripoli. 
 Seventy years later the cloth merchants of Kano, who &bquo;put out&equo; yarn for weaving and organized the dyeing and marketing of the cloth, were exporting as far afield as Alexandria across the desert and Brazil across the sea. 
 A single currency zone had operated in the Islamic states of the central savannah since the eighteenth century. 
 Further south, the coastal merchants of west Africa had been trading with Europe for several centuries. 
 Such activities were by no means limited to the slave trade. 
 Cash crops were exported from early in the nineteenth century, such as ground-nuts from the Gambia in the 1830s, and oil palm and rubber from Ghana from the 1870s and 1890s respectively. 
 The middlemen who organized supplies of these crops for European traders were not only accumulators of capital but also invested in new opportunities, such as that created by the demand for cocoa in the 1890s. 
 It was the Akwapim people of southern Ghana, exposed to centuries of trading with Europe, who had the capital in the 1890s to hire porters and clear the forest in order to plant cocoa. 
 In Nigeria in the same decade the first cocoa plantations were established by the African traders of Lagos, such as J.K. Coker, using pods from Fernando Po. 
 Thus the pattern of accumulation of capital from trade for subsequent investment in production which was so important in late eighteenth-century Britain had had its roots in Africa before the colonial period. 
 However, such dynamic and far-sighted traders and producers did not operate in a context which was generally favourable to the development of wage-paid labour or the accumulation of capital. 
 Chapter 3 described the web of relationships of pre-colonial societies in which kinship was the prime determinant of obligation and responsibility. 
 Where large scale production existed it was carried out by slaves, as was the case with gold mining in the Asante kingdom. 
 Among the few exceptions were the cocoa planters of Akwapim. 
 In east Africa wage-paid labour was confined almost entirely to entrep&ocirc;t ports such as Mombasa and Zanzibar. 
 Limits to the individual accumulation of capital were also set by, for instance, the Asante state whose long distance trade was shared between state merchants and wealthy private traders. 
 The latter were not fully independent because 
 the State both harassed the wealthy commoner with unpredictable exactions when he was alive and claimed a large proportion of his self acquired movable property when he died. 
 This was so severe a problem that in the early twentieth century a petitioner to the asantehene  protested against such death duties and said they had 
 brought the downfall of the Asante nation and for this reason they had to bury their money underground so that more money was hidden underground than on the earth. 
 The decay of older loyalties with the onset of the colonial era provided a new social context in which these limitations on entrepreneurs no longer applied. 
 It may, however, be argued that there were deeper reasons for the relative weakness of African entrepreneurs at this time, that is, the absence of the kind of &bquo;worldly asceticism&equo; which Weber described as the key to European capitalism. 
 In contrast 
 the norm was certainly frank enjoyment of pleasure amidst a life often harsh and insecure. 
 This hedonistic pragmatism is to be seen moulded for ever in the rolls of fat around the necks of the bronze and terracottaheads from Ife. 
 This of course was less true of the Islamic societies of the savannah which were periodically the subject of reform movements, with a strong ascetic bent, and of recurring significance in the twentieth century. 
 In this century Christianity, too, would produce reform movements in which values close to those of the protestant ethic prevailed. 
 THE ERA OF THE MULTINATiONALS 
 Capitalist activity in the nineteenth century, for the reasons discussed above, was mainly associated with new types of activity, such as cocoa production or mineral mining, whether these were in the hands of European or African entrepreneurs. 
 This was in the context of a world trading system geared to the industrial needs of Europe: as these intensified, the required scale of production in Africa gave an overwhelming advantage to the Europeans, with their store of skills and technology. 
 The opportunity was seized by European trading houses such as Lever Brothers, Union Miniere, the British-South Africa Company, and Lebanese, Syrian and Indian merchants. 
 The total real value of exports from a selection of seven African countries rose three and half times from 1907 to 1928, a further five times from 1928 to 1959 and a further four times from 1959 to 1982. 
 Nearly all exported products were primary commodities such as palm oil and cocoa, or copper and gold. 
 The associated investment in production and marketing gave the trading houses commanding positions within African economies. 
 In 1982 the total stock of that investment in Africa was estimated at about &dollar;13 billion, with over half of it still concentrated in the production and export of primary commodities. 
 Since 1976, the flow of new investment has been very modest, and in some years negative. 
 Where there has been new investment it has been financed largely from income generated in Africa and re-invested locally. 
 Consequently, companies from the old colonial powers of Britain and France continue to own about 30 per cent of the stock of foreign investments, with the USA and Japan owning another 50 per cent. 
 In many countries this still gives the foreign investor a position of significance. 
 In both Nigeria and Kenya, for example, foreign investment probably generates about one-fifth of Gross National Product. 
 In these cases individual companies such as BAT in Kenya, Unilever in Kenya and Nigeria, Elf in Gabon, and CFAO in a number of francophone countries are operating at levels of sophistication which have no indigenous counterpart. 
 The processes in use have frequently been heavily dependent on imports, with only a modest local added value, and have been sustained by relatively high levels of protection. 
 During the colonial period the response of African entrepreneurs to the growing presence of these large companies was varied. 
 In the interstices of the system, particularly in west Africa, the older, established, trading families in cities such as Kano and newcomers to the commercial sector played a significant role. 
 In the Islamic communities of the savannah religious reformation tended to reinforce entrepreneurial skill, as demonstrated by the Murid Brotherhood in Senegal and in the development of the &bquo;Reformed Tijianiya&equo; (a more fundamentalist and anti-colonial Islamic movement) which also originated in Senegal but spread through much of the savannah in the 1930s. 
 In central Africa influential movements such as Jehovah's Witnesses were attractive to those who sought to set themselves apart and to adopt a puritan lifestyle. 
 THE INFORMAL SECTOR 
 With some exceptions, the role of individuals influenced by these movements was very limited throughout the colonial period. 
 At independence governments for the most part gave them preference over entrepreneurs from immigrant groups. 
 Such preference as often as not excluded entrepreneurs from tribal groups out of favour with the government of the day, such as the Ibo, Bamilike, waGanda, and waChagga. 
 Nonetheless, members of these communities and many others have developed small-scale enterprises in the informal sector which continue to grow in range and number. 
 Such enterprises now account for more than 60 per cent of industrial employment in countries as far apart as Ghana and Tanzania; more than half of them are located in small towns and villages, and the extended family is their most important source of labour; they contribute at least a quarter of total manufacturing output; and typically they employ between one and ten workers. 
 An informal producer is always difficult to define but it is used here to describe an owner or an employee of a small-scale enterprise comprising less than ten people, operating from an impermanent site, under an ill-defined registration and tax scheme. 
 Within this sector there is a vast range of experience and competence. 
 In Ethiopia, as in India, the role of the informal producer is not distinct from the mainstream of the economy, but is in fact a key part of it, producing for instance the home-spun cloth worn by most Ethiopian women. 
 In the larger cities of Nigeria traditional clothes and the more basic household goods all continue to be made by local artisans. 
 When imported cloth became more difficult to obtain from the mid 1980s tailors and seamstresses reverted to using a higher proportion of home-spun cloth woven on handlooms. 
 In Ghana at Suame Magazine in the city of Kumasi, about 5,000 craftsmen operating in makeshift sheds, in small garages, and in workshops, offer a complete repair service to Ghana's fleet of ageing vehicles, all suffering badly from a ten-year shortage of spare parts. 
 In Nairobi, most oil cans used in the routine servicing of vehicles are re-cycled to hold oil wicks dipped in paraffin as a main source of domestic light for both urban and rural homes. 
 In west Africa such small-scale entrepreneurs have long been tolerated, though seldom actively encouraged. 
 The economy of a city of 2 million people, such as Ibadan, has grown on the back of this kind of enterprise. 
 Modern corporate businesses are few and licences for small-scale repair shops and petty street traders provide a major share of city revenue. 
 In contrast, in the European-style cities of east and central Africa such as Nairobi, Lusaka and Harare, the informals have frequently been hounded out of their preferred locations. 
 In Lusaka, small-scale enterprise takes place mainly in the shanty towns three or four miles from the city centre. 
 In Nairobi, the origins of the several thousand metal workers who produce tin trunks, paraffin lamps, braziers, household utensils and agricultural tools on open sites, lie in both pre-colonial blacksmithing activities, and in Kenya's immigrant Indian communities, particularly the Sikhs and Bohras. 
 The Sikhs were the main source of artisan skills as European-style buildings sprang up in Kenya from 1900 onwards. 
 By the inter-war years such Sikh artisans had a number of Kenyan assistants adopting their skills; by the 1950s the Sikhs were moving on to the role of investor and entrepreneur in both construction and industry, leaving the way clear for their former assistants to take on the role of artisan. 
 But employment in the building trade is notoriously irregular, and such artisans alternate self-employment with wage-paid work on the building sites. 
 The significance of the older pre-colonial blacksmith tradition is illustrated in cases from Nairobi brought to light by Kenneth King who examined the origins and experience of Nairobi informals in the early 1970s. 
 He describes the case of Mutang'ang'i one of the leading informals who at that time made foreguards for bicycles, bicycle stands and cutting machines using a series of hand-built metalworking machines which he had designed and built himself. 
 He was the grandson of a traditional Kikuyu smith who made spears and knives in the late nineteenth century in a small village about twenty miles from Nairobi. 
 He had initially made braziers and water carriers on the estate of a European settler, who had persuaded him to manufacture in addition chisels and hammers. 
 Later, after four years in detention during the Mau Mau Emergency, he worked for an Indian workshop in Nairobi establishing himself as the pioneer manufacturer of bicycle carriers and foreguards. 
 In the next fifteen years he effectively trained about forty others, including several step-brothers. 
 They have been the nucleus of several hundred self-employed artisans manufacturing these bicycle attachments who can be seen on open sites across Nairobi. 
 Faced with competition from his own prot&eacute;g&eacute;s, Mutang'ang'i himself moved his product line to a more specifically agricultural market: maize stalk cutters, fence post nail machines and hand shears. 
 Observation of the range of products being made in the late 1980s by Nairobi's jua kali  artisans &mdash; those who work under the &bquo;hot sun&equo; &mdash; confirm that Mutang'ang'i's story is far from unique. 
 Product differentiation and improvement has been occurring steadily over the years and now includes metal and wooden window frames, doors, storage tanks, household furniture, beds, as well as a much improved range of braziers, and tin trunks. 
 A good third of the stock of any hardware retail shop in Nairobi is now derived from this source. 
 Kenya's one formal window frame manufacturer has been forced to move into a completely different business as the jua kali  producers have been able to dominate the market with a product which is of equal quality but considerably cheaper. 
 A welding machine designed and produced by jua kalis  is beginning to compete with the conventional, imported Japanese product. 
 The individual work histories of Mutang'ang'i's original forty trainees include as many different jobs as were held by Mutang'ang'i himself, since the informal sector is typified by a very high turnover. 
 Its members move in and out of employment, and in and out of Nairobi itself, at a very fast rate. 
 In the 1950s and 1960s this ensured the rapid dissemination of such skills into towns and villages all over Kenya, and this process is being constantly reinforced. 
 What are the links between such informals and modern industry &mdash; not only in Kenya but elsewhere in Africa? 
 First, many of the materials with which they work, such as scrap metal, textile waste, and timber, are recycled, often illicitly, from large scale industry. 
 Second, many informals continue to work in the formal sector for several months at a time. 
 Third, much of the construction industry depends on formal companies subcontracting at least half of a total work programme to informals, many of whom in turn use tools produced by other jua kali  artisans. 
 These factors suggest that an increase in turnover in the formal sector will ensure a reflected increase in turnover in the informal sector. 
 However, these links do not form a cohesive whole, and there are weaknesses in the development of the informal sector which have tended to disguise its potential. 
 In practice, many though not all informals have no security of tenure over the site on which they work, have very few means of tying their small workforce to the enterprise for more than a few months, and may run out of their supply of recycled materials (from the formal sector) at any moment. 
 Faced with this level of uncertainty, the response of employers within the sector has been to invest as much of their profits as possible in land or housing, if possible in their home area or within the city, if tenure is reasonably secure. 
 One measure of the weakness of such enterprise is that it would be extremely difficult to ensure, across such a wide range, the quality control necessary for the export market outside Africa. 
 So, while product development has been impressive, and confirms a certain level of re-investment, it does not usually lead to development of medium-sized businesses with tangible assets. 
 Furthermore, although the sector is generating profits which in turn increase the national stock of capital, this is mainly in housing and land, and not in manufacturing capacity. 
 FORMALIZING THE INFORMALS 
 Can this be changed? 
 The Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto in his book, The Other Path , argues that such change can be brought about in the Latin American context by legalizing the informals. 
 He sees the range of legal and bureaucratic constraints upon them as being the main limitation on their developing into self-sustaining businesses. 
 This argument is partly valid in the African context: Mutang'ang'i was periodically obliged to remove his metal cutting machines from his worksite in Nairobi. 
 On the other hand, a systematic survey by the International Labour Organization has shown that, in a sample of ten African countries, 40 per cent of informal sector enterprises pay some form of tax or registration fee, implying a degree of recognition by government. 
 By the late 1980s no African government could afford to neglect the significance of the sector for the employment of the hundreds of thousands of primary and secondary school leavers who were joining the labour market each year, and most were making policy statements which indicated some support for it. 
 However, it was also proving difficult to discard old attitudes. 
 In Kenya, a member of a research institute, with a brief to find technology relevant to both formals and informals, could still describe the latter as mainly &bquo;layabouts&equo; in 1989. 
 Despite the 1974&ndash;8 Kenya Development Plan stating &bquo;there has been some counter productive harassment of these enterprises, which will be promptly ended&equo;, in 1989 a complete informal vehicle maintenance site was abruptly closed down by the city government. 
 In Nigeria, on the other hand, the National Open Apprenticeship Scheme is attempting to support forms of apprenticeship which have been traditional in the Nigerian informal sector, by seeking to upgrade their quality and supplement them with classroom training. 
 If initiatives of this kind are sustained, and matched by measures which increase the informals' security once they are in business, the sector can certainly gather greater strength and has the potential to generate jobs almost as fast as the urban population grows, but at very low levels of income, and in the form of enterprises where investment and technology is minimal. 
 With exceptions, this is not a training ground for larger-scale entrepreneurs. 
 In fact one of the striking characteristics of the history of Africa's informals during the last three decades is how few of them have managed to launch genuine large-scale businesses, capable of competing with the foreign-owned or -managed enterprises which are still so critical in many countries. 
 Most of the exceptions to this pattern are in Nigeria where several large scale Nigerian-owned businesses have developed with a turnover measured in tens of millions of dollars. 
 NIGERIA: CRADLE OF ENTREPRENEURS? 
 A series of studies of such businessmen have been conducted by Nigerian scholars, and these are particularly significant given the fact that Nigeria accounts for one third of &bquo;value added&equo; in manufacturing in sub-Saharan Africa as a whole (excluding South Africa). 
 Elsewhere, Africa's leading industrialists tend to be the chairmen or directors of companies which are owned or managed by multinational companies. 
 The Nigerian studies throw doubt on whether these businesses are really self-sustaining, or revolve too heavily round the personality of their founder. 
 They identify a failure to concentrate on taking a large market share for one product; in contrast they describe a preference for entering a new market before the full potential of the current one is reached. 
 Of course, there is some justification for this: competition is intense and the Nigerian public's purchasing power low, and so returns may be higher from launching a new product in a different market. 
 A technical explanation of this kind however does not account for the continuing one-man-band nature of many such businesses, which prevents growth for organizational as well as market reasons. 
 In a survey carried out in the mid 1960s of 419 businesses in western Nigeria, 74 per cent said that &bquo;partnerships or joint ventures were difficult or undesirable because of financial untrustworthiness&equo;. 
 Individuals among them went on to say: 
 &mdash; The spirit of cheating reigns supreme amongst us; &mdash; Honesty is still wanting amongst the indigenous businessmen; &mdash; Most of our businessmen are not honest. 
 In Ghana one-man proprietorships characterized 75 per cent of larger, locally-owned firms in the late 1960s. 
 The most notable exceptions to this pattern are found in Kano where a 1975 study showed that nineteen of Nigeria's twenty largest industrial companies were located. 
 This may be attributed to the fact that the city's traders were not swamped by the growth of the larger British companies during the colonial period, that among the merchant families involved in the kola nut trade, two generations were common, and that merchant families in Kano were particularly successful from the early 1960s at forming links with overseas companies, not least with those from the Far East. 
 It may also have been connected with the recurring impact in Kano of the Islamic &bquo;ascetic&equo; movements, particularly current in commercial circles. 
 However the situation found in Kano was not typical of west Africa or even of Nigeria, and the one-man-band was and is the predominant theme. 
 While it has been suggested that the absence of a cadre of professional managers is a major explanation for this situation, the real reasons almost certainly lie closer to the psychology of the entrepreneurs themselves. 
 Few of them in Nigeria, as elsewhere, have more than ten years of schooling. 
 Therefore older rural values relating to power and status, and especially the ability to redistribute patronage, predominate. 
 Consequently, the criteria of &bquo;profit maximization&equo; and &bquo;efficiency of management&equo; are frequently not critical. 
 Whether more and better schooling would in the short run produce a larger group of efficient entrepreneurs, capable of making individual businesses more competitive, is an open question. 
 Akeredolu-ale, one of the Nigerian analysts of local entrepreneur, writing in 1975 saw deeper problems: 
 Private indigenous entrepreneurs in Nigeria are still to cultivate the discipline of conserving more than they consume of their trade surplus and of re-investing such surpluses to expand the firm. 
 Very limited entrepreneurial ambitions, conspicuous consumption and a tendency to spread their thin investments over many ventures &lsqb;the &bquo;group of companies&equo; mentality&rsqb;, a tendency&hellip; to only scratch the surface of innovation, the aversion to teaming up with others, all these and other motivational factors are likely to continue to limit the growth of Nigerian enterprises even in those spheres which are exclusively reserved to them and to postpone the day when they may hope to take over the higher reaches of enterprise. 
 In his earlier analysis in 1969 of Nigerian businessmen, Kilby reached similar conclusions: 
 While Yoruba and Ibo patterns of status mobility based on achieved wealth provide a strong incentive to establish a business enterprise as a means of obtaining high social status, once established there are no antecedent roles conferring respect for efficient managerial performance. 
 On the contrary, because conspicuous leisure is the principal manifestation of superior status, the carrying out of supervisory functions&hellip; represents a socially degrading activity&hellip; 
 These descriptions of the prospects for Nigerian entrepreneurs are hardly encouraging. 
 If, however, they were too pessimistic this should have been belied in the subsequent years since the Nigerian Indigenization Decree of 1972, implemented from February 1974, which reserved twenty-six activities in large-scale industry exclusively for Nigerian ownership; foreign companies operating in these businesses had to sell out. 
 The results of this measure were that 50 per cent of total manufacturing activity (measured by value added) was left entirely in Nigerian hands. 
 While there was certainly an increase in the output of these businesses in the prosperous years of the late 1970s it is doubtful if they did more than keep pace with the fast growth rate for the manufacturing sector as a whole, estimated by the World Bank to be 12 per cent from 1970 to 1982. 
 Further, they certainly did not succeed in swimming against the deep tide of recession which engulfed Nigeria from 1983 onwards. 
 In theory, during this period their potential to adapt technology to source inputs locally (as had occurred in Biafra during the civil war), rather than to import them might have given them a competitive edge over the large manufacturing companies managed and partly owned from overseas. 
 In practice, the description of the potential of their businesses made by Akeredolu-Ale and Kilby proved to be substantially valid. 
 The time span which is likely to be required for a generation of more effective large-scale entrepreneurs to evolve is considerable. 
 One of the problems for those entrepreneurs, and other corporate managers, who do seek to act as professional industrialists is that the context in which they operate is dominated by the values described in earlier chapters. 
 For instance, the manager of an airline, however committed he may be to an efficient seat reservation system, may be obliged to withdraw seats already allocated in favour of a minister and his train of attendants. 
 Another entrepreneur establishing a sack-making factory with limited protection, may find a relative of the president given a licence to import freely the same product. 
 Alhaji Abbo is a former truck driver who has successfully developed a 3,000 hectare maize farm and oil extraction plant in northern Cameroun. 
 In 1989 he was obliged to move out of his house to live on the farm in order to avoid the pressure to entertain visiting dignitaries on behalf of local politicians. 
 Thus whether the would-be efficient entrepreneur rises from the informal sector or parachutes into a larger-scale enterprise with a degree from an international business school, he will frequently be trapped into the same style of running a business as the Nigerian enterpreneurs described above. 
 SMALL IS STILL BEAUTIFUL 
 Entrepreneurs in pre-colonial Africa were effective in articulating trading relationships between Africa and the rest of the world, and in developing the productive activities which generated the trade. 
 The colonial period ushered in an era of foreign investment which gave the large scale trading houses of Europe a hold on the development of local economies allowing little room for Africa's entrepreneurs to develop their skills. 
 In spite of the nationalizations of the 1960s and 1970s the stock of capital of foreign investors continues to generate about one-fifth of Africa's gross national product. 
 The many and varied attempts by governments both to take over foreign assets and to set up new state-owned businesses, have seldom been successful. 
 While state-owned and foreign businesses have held the centre of the stage for three decades, tens of thousands of informal sector artisans have been producing a range of goods for use in households, agriculture, transport and construction. 
 Over time, these have both adapted their technologies and developed many new product lines. 
 They have not existed independently of formal industry, but have drawn skills and materials from it. 
 But the constraints on their existence implied by operating from open waste land or shacks have created a situation where they have little security, and the owners of such enterprises are discouraged from reinvesting a high proportion of their profits back into the business. 
 Nevertheless, this sector has the potential to generate employment at a rate close to the rate of growth of the urban population, but at very low levels of income. 
 One of the weaknesses of most African economies is an absence of large-scale entrepreneurs running manufacturing businesses, whether they have emerged from the informal sector or been trained by the corporate sector. 
 The studies from Nigeria suggest that this failure may be as much to do with the character and personality traits of the generation of entrepreneurs who developed their businesses in the 1960s. 
 It is certain that even those entrepreneurs and managers who seek to act as professional industrialists have to operate in an environment which is hostile to them, and in which the pursuit of marginal returns is an uphill struggle. 
 Thus at a time when Africa needs to industrialize, to create both exports and jobs, a review of the last thirty years shows how difficult this task has been and will be. 
 A good part of the difficulty is derived directly from the structure of social and cultural values discussed earlier in this book. 
 These are responsible for both the &bquo;power and status&equo; motivation ascribed to Nigerian entrepreneurs, and for the centralizing tendency of governments which until recently have frequently been hostile to the informals. 
 Among the many constraints on Africa's attempts at industrialization, the factors deriving from Africa's pre-colonial social structure must be deemed among the most important. 
 The Aid Machine 
 The two World Bank men, one German and one British, strode across the tarmac in the steaming heat of Dar es salaam. 
 Clearly men with a purpose, their well-ironed tropical suits and ties contrasted with the colourful informality of the other passengers and the rest of the airport crowd &mdash; the men in body length kanzas  or open neck shirts, and women in black buibuis  stretching from their heads to below their knees or in multi-coloured kitenge  dresses proclaiming variants on the theme of Uhuru na Mwalimu . 
 The Bank men, their first-class tickets ensuring a place at the front of the queue for immigration formalities, wasted no time in getting through the airport and were quickly ferried by car along the narrow road into the city. 
 Within an hour of arrival they were closeted with the permanent secretary, the most senior civil servant, of the Ministry of Agriculture mapping out the ground for a loan from the World Bank to Tanzania which would put &dollar;25 million into livestock production, turning ranching and the export of beef into a major national industry. 
 This was an ambitious objective, but it was 1971 and Robert McNamara had been President of the World Bank for three years, long enough to begin to realize his goal of a leap forward in Bank lending that would take it from &dollar;1.1 billion in 1967 to &dollar;11.4 billion in 1980, his last year in office. 
 Only such a leap could have spawned the dynamic activity of the Bank staffers in the field in the early and mid 1970s. 
 The two-man team arriving to promote the concept of a large-scale loan for livestock production in Tanzania in 1971 was a manifestation of McNamara's bold and almost visionary objectives. 
 Their tough activism contrasted with the Ministry of Agriculture's considerable suspicion of the Bank's motives, doubts about whether the government could possibly meet all the conditions of lending that the Bank would require, and sheer reluctance to organize all the preparatory technical studies that would form a part of project preparation. 
 The civil servants' reluctance would be resolved by a ministerial directive that the project must be supported &mdash; some action was always better than none, the project would have an impact in several regions, if it worked it would boost exports and create employment. 
 The snag lay in the price of meat, the Bank wanting it raised to choke off local demand and free meat for export, the government wanting it held at its current low level to keep urban meat-eaters happy. 
 Having flagged the issue and fired the interest of the minister, the Bank duo returned to the cooler, more workman-like atmosphere of life in Nairobi almost certain that sooner or later a project would go to the Bank board, and that it would almost certainly be approved. 
 In fact it took another two years for the project to be fully studied, for the government to support its formal submission to the World Bank, for the Bank's board to approve it and for the first tranche of funds to flow. 
 The project was highly imaginative, building on a commercial ranching project which already existed. 
 It envisaged the development of other commercial ranches (albeit government-owned); the provision of credit to a selection of pastoral cattle keepers (for water supplies, improved grazing and other facilities); a great improvement in the system by which cattle were transported from grazing areas to abattoirs; and the re-equipment and expansion of the existing export meat-packing plant. 
 In framing the loan agreement both the government and the Bank had formally agreed that high-powered international management of the meat plants and ranches was necessary to success, that pastoral cattle keepers should be given title to their land (an innovation), and that the meat price should be raised, thus restraining urban demand. 
 By the late 1970s, however, it was clear that the project had failed in nearly all of its objectives. 
 At one level the reasons were not difficult to see: although government initially fulfilled the conditions of the loan, in hiring management and adjusting prices, it later backed out of the commitment. 
 Contracts were shortened and meat prices restrained; the meat plant was nationalized and the export distribution channel lost; the issue of land tenure for pastoralists became submerged in the much bigger ujamaa  re-settlement programme of 1975; and livestock buying at markets was taken out of the hands of the traditional Somali buyers and for the most part placed in the hands of state agents. 
 But this is not the whole story. 
 The failure was not just one of execution, nor even one of mistaken concept; it was more the product of a profound ambivalence in the relationship between the World Bank and the government. 
 This was matched by a further ambivalence in the relationship between the government and the livestock owners, supposed to be the ultimate beneficiaries of the project. 
 For the project to be successful it was essential for each stool of the tripod which supported it &mdash; the government, the livestock owners and the Bank &mdash; to have an equal commitment to its success and to perceive the project in roughly the same terms. 
 In fact, no such harmony of view existed. 
 The government saw it as a means to increase the resources under its control; those few livestock owners who were aware of the project saw it as a means to acquire more stock and supplies of water, but with no thought of selling more of their animals; the Bank saw it as an intervention which would initiate a commercial livestock industry in Tanzania, a means of increasing resource utilization and exports. 
 Such differences in emphasis and even objective were the fatal flaw in the project, a flaw which saddled Tanzania with a &dollar;17 million commitment to repay the Bank's soft loan wing, the International Development Agency (IDA). 
 Today the majority of Tanzania's current total debt of &dollar;5 billion consists of obligations contracted in many similar projects financed by a wide variety of donors, many of which have similar ambiguities surrounding them. 
 DO BORROWERS HAVE A STRATEGY? 
 Such ambiguities are not unique to Tanzania but run right through relationships between development agencies and African governments. 
 Chapter 3 argued that ambiguity was an underlying characteristic of African society. 
 Historically, this was driven by a complex web of lineage lines in which one set of loyalties was hedged against another. 
 Today, when facing the outside world, the strategy of senior civil servants is also frequently one of hedging; programmes are often put up to three donors simultaneously, so that the influence of one can be offset against the influence of another. 
 As a result, African governments seldom have a concerted strategy for dealing with donors. 
 This is confirmed by the fact that there are very few serious statements about aid made by senior Africans on behalf of their country, or their region. 
 A ridiculous proportion of the public debate on aid takes place exclusively within the donor countries, and is generated by articles written mainly by western and Third World academic observers. 
 It is as if those who know aid best from the viewpoint of the recipients fear that an outspoken critique will turn off the tap rather than improve the quality of the flow. 
 Not even Julius Nyerere's collected speeches, which range across almost every aspect of the problem of development, contain a serious reflection on the role of aid in Tanzania or Africa in general. 
 The reports of international commissions such as that of Brandt do not make up for this gap. 
 Since aid is becoming more, not less, important in Africa there is a crying need for a more outspoken analysis of the problem, not only from the recipients' point of view, but by the recipients themselves. 
 These kinds of problems were not envisaged in the seminal work of economists such as Walt Rostow, writing in the 1950s, and Hollis Chenery, writing in the 1960s, whose work played a key role in justifying the early stages of development assistance. 
 At that time, economic thinking on development was very much influenced by the success of the Marshall Plan in financing the rehabilitation of Europe, and by the effect of parallel U.S. aid to Japan. 
 Rostow's Stages of Economic Growth  identified a key role for external concessionary finance, i.e. to increase the rate of investment without reducing the level of domestic consumption. 
 Given certain other conditions such as a high rate of growth in at least one manufacturing sector and a favourable institutional environment, an increase in the rate of net investment from say 5 to 10 per cent of national income could put a country on the path to self-sustaining growth. 
 The underlying assumption was that, if other factors were reasonably favourable, capital formation and exports would within, say, a generation reach the level where concessional finance was no longer necessary. 
 The African experience has not justified this assumption. 
 In the 1980s, aggregate Gross Domestic Product (GDP) has been roughly static, and per capita GDP has been falling at a time when net aid flows have been rising. 
 The reasons for this should not be obscured by the fact that the short term objectives of aid have undergone several changes over the last thirty years. 
 Most notably these have included, first, a concern with income distribution and the need to combat &bquo;absolute&equo; poverty, triggered by McNamara in 1973; and second, the need to finance the trade deficits, and consequent &bquo;adjustment&equo;, of the many African countries for whom the second oil price rise of 1979 was a near fatal blow. 
 The IMF, the World Bank and bilateral national aid donors have all allocated an increasing proportion of their annual commitments to lending of this type. 
 In the case of the World Bank, this proportion was as high as 30 per cent of total loans to Africa approved in 1988. 
 Such changes in the target areas of lending not only make its impact more difficult to assess, but have not yet led to a sustained improvement in the rate of economic growth achieved by recipient countries. 
 Nevertheless, in-flows of aid have been increasing. 
 In 1970 they totalled &dollar;1.0 billion, in 1978 &dollar;4.7 billion and in 1987 &dollar;11.1 billion. 
 It can be argued that the increase rather than the reduction in the need for aid is due to a series of weaknesses in its composition and nature. 
 It can also be argued that the economists' justification for aid has never been its real rationale, but that political considerations of strategic security by the donors have conditioned its distribution and nature, in some cases even allowing military support to be classified as aid. 
 However, the quality of economic decision-making in most African countries over the last thirty years suggests that this is inextricably linked to the relative failure of aid. 
 The important role which larger donors have come to play in &bquo;supporting&equo; African economies has not prevented governments from retaining their entrenched political priorities. 
 To make matters more complicated, where aid programmes have sought to channel funds to small-scale farmers, or small businesses, the real priorities of the target beneficiaries have seldom been identical to those of the donor or the government. 
 Even so, donors have also used aid to pursue their selfinterest regardless of whether or not it was compatible with that of the recipient. 
 This has led to the tying of aid to a large extent to inappropriate or unduly expensive goods from the donor's country, to sharp annual variations in the volume of aid flows and to a lack of commitment to real coordination with other donors. 
 Thus, in examining the more specific factors which have contributed to the aid machine's lack of success, it is frequently the case that both donor and recipient carry a part of the responsibility. 
 These issues will be discussed below. 
 A POOR MATCH 
 There is plenty of opportunity for the general sense of ambiguity discussed above to manifest itself at the level of individual projects. 
 There are often three related questions: do recipient governments really want the project? do the target beneficiaries (such as smallholders) within the country really want the project? do the donor(s), the recipient government and the beneficiaries expect roughly the same from the project? 
 The environment within which projects have been planned and executed has frequently allowed these questions to remain unanswered in reality, if not on the paper on which loan agreements are written. 
 It was created in good part by the situation in the 1970s when a poor match developed between the pressure to lend from donors, and the administrative ability of the borrowing countries to &bquo;receive&equo;. 
 Overwhelmed by the number of donors pushing their desire to lend, recipient governments were frequently unable to sort out their own priorities in a meaningful way. 
 This is hardly surprising. 
 In the early 1980s Kenya was trying to cope with 600 projects from 60 donors; and even a mini-country such as Lesotho was dealing with 321 projects from 61 donors. 
 The gap between the willingness to lend and the capacity to receive is partly due to the fact that the majority of donors have country lending, or granting, targets. 
 The staff members they deploy in the field to identify projects are under pressure from their senior management to turn such targets into reality. 
 Working within an embassy office or the regional office of a multilateral bank it is not difficult for donors' staff to come up with a list of potential projects which can be presented to a recipient country's ministry of finance for discussion. 
 Overworked officials in finance ministries rarely reject a whole list of potential projects; they are much more likely to identify a few priorities at random, and pass on the donor to the line ministry, hoping for the best if and when the project is financed. 
 Once a project is on a donor's priority list it takes on a life of its own, and may become unstoppable. 
 Only a very few civil servants within the recipient government understand what the project is really about. 
 Numerous conditions may be attached to the donor's disbursement of funds, such as the allocation of manpower to the project, or a change in pricing policy. 
 Once the loan agreement is signed the donor may have a much more precise view of these conditions than the recipient, especially at the level of the line staff who are actually supposed to manage the project. 
 As the donor becomes more and more concerned at lack of action the recipient country staff become more and more dubious that the project is really in their national interest, and may even start discussions with another whose conditions may be perceived as less onerous. 
 To these dilemmas must be added the differing perceptions of a project by potential beneficiaries such as farmers and small-scale businessmen. 
 In an agricultural project farmers have to understand the potential benefits of the inputs (say, fertiliser and seed) financed by the project, to find them relevant, and to be sure that their produce will find a market, before committing themselves to participation. 
 In many agricultural projects this has not been the case. 
 The irrigation schemes in the Sudan, including the Gezira project, provide an example of a case where a poor response from tenant farmers, for a variety of reasons, has consistently dogged the major rehabilitation projects financed by the World Bank and other donors in the early 1980s. 
 There are many projects where farmers have seen potential benefits from a project, but where these have not been the same as those anticipated by the project designers. 
 Thus in integrated rural development projects, such as those financed by the World Bank in many Nigerian states in the 1970s, fertiliser ear-marked for cash crops was frequently spread on food crops. 
 In livestock projects credit designed for fencing and water supplies has been channelled into domestic buildings, for which similar materials are required. 
 In projects designed to support small (and larger-scale) entrepreneurs various forms of &bquo;leakage&equo; are frequent: credit funds ear-marked for a particular purpose are deployed for entirely different purposes, or for the purchase of domestic assets. 
 The frustrations for the donor arising from these differences of perception and interest are great. 
 But even when they are recognized, his options are limited. 
 To cancel a project is to set back a country's loan or grant programme and perhaps risk political problems between recipient and donor. 
 Consequently, changes in project objectives are much more frequent than cancellations. 
 The World Bank's 1985 review of project performance indicated that &bquo;only 42 per cent of its projects were implemented as agreed, and 58 per cent were changed significantly during the implementation process&equo;. 
 Even changes of objective within the period in which funds are being disbursed may still leave pressure for additional change, especially if there is a ministerial reshuffle. 
 In an attempt to try to contain the pressure for such changes donors adopted in the 1970s a strategy of establishing semi-autonomous project units, which were nominally attached to national ministries, but in fact were more or less independent of them. 
 In Juba, southern Sudan, the agricultural rehabilitation project jointly financed by the British government and the World Bank in 1978 had an annual budget in excess of that of the Ministry of Agriculture of the regional government. 
 Such project &bquo;islands&equo; created additional suspicion within recipient governments and the approach has been largely abandoned. 
 The problems described above will not be easily resolved. 
 The ambivalence surrounding project aid is likely to continue. 
 The situation will only improve if first, recipient governments are able to allocate a higher proportion of the time of capable civil servants to the allocation of in-coming aid; second, if donor governments and agencies dovetail their country lending programmes more closely with the medium-term budgetary plans of the recipient countries; and third, if recipient governments are more careful in interpreting the priorities of their own small farmers and other small-scale producers. 
 The move away from project loans and towards structural adjustment loans in the 1980s does not diminish the main thrust of this argument. 
 The main aim of these more recent loans is to assist governments in making major policy changes (such as abolishing price controls and freeing interest rates) and creating new institutional arrangements (such as privatising government-owned companies). 
 Such changes may receive support from cabinet ministers and senior civil servants, but may also be accepted not from conviction but from necessity; nominal support is essential to ensure finance for a minimum quantity of imports. 
 Even if they are accepted from conviction, perhaps more often the case than political statements would imply, major vested interests have to be combatted to implement them. 
 Some of this comes from urban consumers, concerned with rising food prices, or trade unions concerned with falling real wages. 
 Some of the opposition to liberalization may come from multinational companies used to low interest rates and to a protected local market. 
 Faced with such effective local opposition civil servants in charge of delivering on policy conditions may indeed feel ambivalent about the desirability of an individual structural adjustment loan. 
 SWITCHING RESOURCES 
 Some of the ambivalence shown by recipient countries towards aid is explained by its utility as a means of freeing local resources to finance projects which otherwise might get squeezed out, but which might have important political attractions. 
 Donors frequently finance projects, or chunks of government expenditure such as part of the health service, to which recipient countries would in any case have to give a high priority, and this relieves government of that particular commitment. 
 Revenue can then be switched to other items, such as military hardware, or so-called prestige projects. 
 Only a minority of African countries spend a high proportion of their annual government expenditure on defence &mdash; as much as 19 per cent in Burkina Faso and 13 per cent in Tanzania in 1986. 
 It is difficult to believe that many of the prestige projects discussed in Chapter 8 would have been contemplated in the absence of the very high volumes of aid reaching countries for other, more mundane, purposes. 
 More difficult to determine is the extent to which aid has freed resources for consumption, and so done little to increase investment levels in the manner envisaged by Rostow or Chenery. 
 In fact the extent to which this happens, and to which aid itself directly finances consumption, for instance paying the salaries of local staff, has been a matter of controversy among economists. 
 Keith Griffin is one who takes an extreme position believing that 
 aid is essentially a substitute for saving and&hellip; a large fraction of foreign capital is used to increase consumption rather than investment. 
 This statement is clearly true in the context of food aid. 
 In 1986, 40 per cent of the nearly 9 million tons of cereals imported by Africa was financed under food aid projects, at a cost to donors of approximately &dollar;0.5 billion. 
 In fact it is now widely recognized that some consumption expenditure of this type, in so far as it combats malnutrition, should be considered as equivalent to investment. 
 But consumption does not directly create capital assets whether financed internally or externally, and investment levels in most countries have not risen significantly as a proportion of GDP in Africa over the last twenty years, and reMain 6 or 7 per cent lower than in both the rest of the developing world and in the industrialized world. 
 During this period, domestic savings rates have fallen significantly (with some exceptions such as Kenya and Cameroun) and therefore the inevitable diversion of some aid finance from investment to consumption is accentuating a negative trend, however necessary it may be in years of famine and drought. 
 TEA MONEY 
 Corruption is always a two-way process. 
 The mushrooming of aid budgets in the 1970s turned aid into a fairly important source of business for some small and medium-sized companies in Europe and elsewhere, indicated by the formation of pressure groups in many European Community (EC) countries to ensure that an increased proportion of national aid budgets ended up in the hands of that country's exporters. 
 In Britain, the Confederation of British Industry (CBI) regularly convenes seminars and conferences on this topic. 
 In the 1970s, this kind of pressure led to the prevalence of an increasing pool of funds allocated to soft or mixed commercial credits, which some EC governments were able to describe as aid. 
 Much of this now forms part of Africa's stock of debt as the recipient countries have been unable to service their export credits, and has become a burden on the export credit guarantee agencies of the EC governments. 
 In fact export credits form 37 per cent of the total stock of African debt. 
 Recipient countries have, however, generally played the leading role in the process of allocating contracts between suppliers, whether of equipment, contracting services or consultancy services. 
 This process has regularly been the subject of corruption as civil servants or ministers connected with the award of the tender have sought backhanders for themselves and their associates. 
 Projects financed by multilateral agencies, such as the World Bank, were and are far from immune from this process. 
 While the bidding for contracts may nominally be through international competitive bidding arrangements between suppliers and members of a government, the award may in practice be carried out in ways which make it impossible for the Bank and other donors to police it. 
 Such arrangements have to be seen in a wider context. 
 Corruption is now largely acknowledged as an actual or past practice. 
 President Houphouet Boigny, of Ivory Coast, is on record as saying that a minister who cannot enrich himself is not worth his salt. 
 President Mobutu of Zaire has publicly objected to not being acknowledged as the seventh richest man in the world. 
 There is a good argument for presenting these forms of corruption as consistent with past African practice, in which the chiefs position was acknowledged in tribute, as was the eighteenth-century practice in Europe, and nineteenth-century practice in the USA. 
 However, they are difficult to defend in the context of aid when cultural values are different in donor countries and recipient countries, and when public opinion in the donor countries perceives aid as having a moral justification. 
 Even more importantly, they obviously lead to bad, poorly planned projects perhaps with inadequate or inappropriate equipment. 
 A significant, though not decisive, part of the low return to aid projects in Africa can be attributed to corruption in the award of contracts. 
 Such corruption has played some part in building up the funds held in international bank accounts or other forms of investment by African citizens, recently estimated to total &dollar;20 billion between 1974 and 1985. 
 These examples of ambiguity, of the switching of resources, and of corruption explain some of the failures of aid which can be attributed primarily to the recipients. 
 Other explanations of failure are more clearly attributable to donors. 
 These include lack of co-ordination, volatility in aid flows, the serving of the national interest of donors (particularly through its tying to national suppliers), ineffective evaluation, and the assumption of greater wisdom. 
 WORKING TOGETHER 
 The numbers of projects and donors in individual countries is a source of confusion for which donors themselves are almost entirely responsible. 
 Even the World Bank regularly despatches different missions to an individual country unaware of each others' presence, or who may meet by accident in a permanent secretary's outer office. 
 The consequences for the country, especially in the many cases where the recipient government is not able to sort out the resultant confusion, can at worst be disastrous. 
 There is, for example, the problem of matching finance in local currency, which governments are generally required to commit to each donor-assisted project. 
 In effect governments take on a commitment to support a part of the costs of several hundred projects at any one time, such &bquo;counterpart funding&equo; in countries like Kenya or Tanzania frequently amounts to a nominal commitment of about &dollar;200 million per year. 
 In reality it becomes almost impossible to find this amount in the budget, and projects have to limp along on an underfunded basis or with the overseas donor financing an increasing proportion of the total costs. 
 Commitments to matching finance are seldom adequately analyzed, and although the recipient governments may carry a good deal of the responsibility for this, donors are also at fault in assuming that the counter-part funds for their projects will have priority. 
 A second dimension to real co-ordination involves only the donors, whose policies outside the aid arena may conflict with those within it. 
 The most crucial example of this is trade policy, for access to markets in the industrialized world may be critical to a recipient country's export programme. 
 Thus the EC remains highly sensitive to the origins of garments made up within African countries when the woven fabric is imported from elsewhere, and may reject such imports on the grounds that they are not wholly manufactured within the exporting country. 
 Another example is the need for co-ordination between national aid agencies and national export credit agencies, where the latter may be seeking to guarantee finance for, say, a large steel mill which is clearly out of line with national development priorities agreed in different agencies between the donors and recipient governments. 
 PEAKS AND TROUGHS 
 Volatility in aid flows is notoriously difficult from the recipient's point of view, and the US Congress has made American aid a dangerously-poisoned chalice to the recipients. 
 Short-term changes in the volume of flows to a particular country can ruin the effectiveness of a particular programme or project. 
 For example: 
 US aid commitments to Zimbabwe began at &dollar;24m at Independence in 1980, rose to &dollar;84m in 1982, fell to &dollar;59m in 1984 and were set to fall well below &dollar;20m in early 1986 prior to a decision in September 1986 to cancel all future aid programmes&hellip; 
 US aid to Sudan stood at &dollar;64m in 1981, rising to &dollar;121m in 1984; in 1986 total US military and economic aid to Sudan stood at &dollar;158m prior to total suspension in late February with only &dollar;50m of food aid being disbursed following Sudan's developing relations with Libya. 
 The ability of donors to turn off the tap is often cherished as a means of enforcing economic discipline, or more specifically the sets of policies now associated with structural adjustment. 
 However the &bquo;correct&equo; economic policies are at best subjective and in any case other political considerations frequently come into play. 
 As effective economic policy can hardly be judged in less than a three year period, and political affiliation is also a long-term question, it seems entirely reasonable that aid should be committed over a three year period. 
 PROMOTING THE DONOR 
 Given the political rationale lying behind these sharp changes in the volume of aid directed to particular countries, it is clear that the promotion of the donors' perceived national self-interest is closely bound up with aid. 
 Nearly 80 per cent of French and British aid, excluding that which is channelled through multilateral organizations, is given to their former colonies. 
 A very high proportion of nearly all industrialized countries' aid is tied to their own goods or personnel. 
 On average this is about 33 per cent, although it ranges up to about 60 per cent in the case of Italy, and is over 40 per cent for Britain, France and the United States. 
 Detailed studies of the cost of such tied aid have indicated that the resultant prices to the recipient country are typically 20 per cent more than they would have been if the country had a free choice in its supplier. 
 While tying is not necessarily incompatible with the fundamental economic objectives of aid, it reduces its potential benefit to the extent that goods are over-priced, or that they are less appropriate &mdash; and sometimes much less appropriate &mdash; for the job. 
 SELF-ASSESSMENT 
 Criticism of aid from both left and right, particularly in recent years, has led to the establishment of evaluation units within most of the major donor agencies. 
 The assessments made by these units, frequently based on the work of so-called objective consultants, are increasingly available in edited form. 
 As with other institutional innovations in the aid field, the World Bank has been the most consistent, and perhaps rigorous, of self-assessors publishing an annual review of in-house project audits. 
 Taking the donor agencies as a whole, about 9,000 evaluations of individual projects have been made since 1970, probably accounting for about 12 per cent of all projects launched since that time. 
 Although this would normally be an adequate sample, the results are much less significant than they appear, even were they to point conclusively in one direction, which they do not. 
 Projects need to be assessed over time; there are very few whose benefits can be seriously assessed in less than ten years, and a period of fifteen to twenty years would be more meaningful. 
 On this basis the rural development projects which became fashionable among most donors in the 1970s, and which were supposed to have a direct impact on the rural poor, are only now coming to the stage where a meaningful evaluation can be conducted. 
 Yet the World Bank has conducted and published project audits on average seven years after the first disbursement of funds, and three years after the final year of disbursement. 
 This is too short a time frame to be meaningful. 
 The assessment of structural adjustment loans is even more problematic than the assessment of rural development projects. 
 There are any number of reasons why such loans may be successes or failures, which go well beyond the conditions for the disbursement of the loans. 
 For instance, if an economy grows at 5 per cent per year following a two-year disbursement of a structural adjustment loan, if the international price for the country's commodity exports has risen by at least 5 per cent in the same period of time, can the loan be regarded as justified? 
 Conversely, if state-owned companies have been offered for privatization but few bidders have come forward, is this a &bquo;failure&equo; if the firms continue as loss makers in the public sector? 
 The analysis of a group of such SAP projects will be meaningful only in about ten years after they became fashionable &mdash; that is in about 1995. 
 While the factors of time and the sheer difficulty of analysis partly explain the relative failure of donors to provide a meaningful public assessment of aid programmes, they do not explain the cumulative inadequacy of the results which are available to date. 
 First, there are inherent limitations in looking only at individual projects, which do not pick up some of the key problems discussed above, such as fungibility and co-ordination. 
 It is more appropriate to examine the impact of aid programmes and projects in aggregate on a particular country. 
 Pioneering work of this kind is quite recent. 
 A study commissioned by member governments of the World Bank in 1985 conducted seven such case studies. 
 Similar studies of five countries were carried out for USAID in 1983. 
 Taking these and studies commissioned by donors in countries where they are the predominant donor into account, it appears that only about ten African aid recipients have been studied in this way. 
 Reviewing national programmes, however, raises key and difficult questions for both donors (why did they not co-operate more effectively?) and recipients (how could they justify a range of prestige projects? why are they more dependant on aid than ever?) 
 Yet without such country reviews the performance of aid will not improve more than marginally. 
 Second, few of the evaluations discuss the donors' own role in promoting some of the weaknesses in project design. 
 A classic case is the pressure brought to bear by the World Bank in agriculture in the 1970s in support of island projects, the efficiency of which would be ensured by hiving them off from executing ministries, and appointing expatriate (mainly European) managers to run them. 
 The duplication and friction thus created was palpable. 
 The World Bank has subsequently identified this as a major weakness in the design of projects, but has not acknowledged its own role as the prime engineer of the approach. 
 The unsatisfactory nature of project evaluation work and the inconclusive lessons which can be drawn from it provide little justification for the donor &bquo;omniscience&equo; which continues to characterize their negotiations with recipients. 
 There is no suggestion of possible error of self-doubt when World Bank missions meet a fifty-year-old permanent secretary in a Ministry of Finance, even if he has been receiving similar missions, offering rather different policy prescriptions, for the previous twenty years. 
 Donors, including the EC and the World Bank, have been trying to persuade the Kenyan government to privatize grain marketing since 1984. 
 There is good reason to ask to whom can the assets of the grain marketing board be sold? 
 Yet the World Bank has continued to press this issue, at one stage moving the permanent secretary in the president's office to angrily rebuke the young leader of the Bank's team, and to the president himself being moved to recount to the team the Biblical story of the seven fat and seven lean years. 
 There are no easy answers to African development, and an appropriate degree of humility on the part of donors is a necessary condition for developing a serious dialogue with recipient governments. 
 PUMP PRIMER OR DRIP FEED? 
 The confidence displayed by the World Bank men and other donors in the early 1970s has clearly not fulfilled its promise. 
 Neither Africa nor the donors carry the prime responsibility for this. 
 The premise on which the donors worked was that large amounts of capital could be absorbed by small African countries because their need for productive investment was demonstrably high. 
 It would seek to twist Government's arm to ensure that appropriate management was bought in. 
 The premise on which African governments worked was that if capital could not be had on highly concessional terms it was better to accept it on terms more or less defined by the donors. 
 These compromises on both sides left important issues of policy, and responsibilities for execution, unresolved. 
 Supervision teams from the donors frequently laid bare basic differences in the perception of projects. 
 However, when these differences were revealed it was difficult to know which side feared cancelling the project most &mdash; ironically it might be the donor with its vested interest in a cumulative increase in annual disbursements, rather than the government with several hundred projects of which at least a half could be in the same state. 
 The move to lending in the 1980s for &bquo;adjustment&equo;, and away from projects, has replaced a set of conditions closely tied to projects with a set tied to broader conditions affecting a whole economy, or large sectors within it. 
 This has not removed the scope for profound disagreement about the relevance of such conditions. 
 The problems of &bquo;switching resources&equo; and corruption have to be added to the issue of a basic ambiguity. 
 In the first case aid has frequently freed government revenue for purposes very different to those the donors would support (a new presidential palace, a larger army, a new capital city); in the second case corruption has affected the allocation of contracts in ways which damage project execution. 
 The donors are at fault on the issues of coordination, volatility, tying of aid to a donor country's goods and blinkered evaluation of the impact of aid as a whole. 
 The evident conclusion is that the policy basis on which aid has been given to Africa has not been fulfilled. 
 Aid is now essential to Africa as any kind of external finance is essential: it is a means of paying for imports which would otherwise not be bought, about half of which are capital goods necessary for the maintenance of assets, badly depreciated after years of neglect. 
 This seldom adds up to a coherent investment plan, but may be more simply described as a way of keeping things going until better days arrive. 
 We cannot confuse the kind of economic drip-feed which aid has become with its bold objectives as originally conceived; self-sustaining growth is a mirage which is now more elusive than ever. 
 The Prospects for Progress 
 Africa is now littered with the discarded blueprints of the last quarter of a century. 
 These have ranged from the emotional, continent-wide vision of Kwame Nkrumah (&bquo;Africa must unite&equo;), to Julius Nyerere's target of &bquo;socialism in one country&equo;, to the hard boiled &bquo;Africa needs Europe&equo; school of Houphouet Boigny and Kenyatta. 
 Each of these visions has left its own particular legacy, some transparently more successful than others, but all falling short of their original promise. 
 There are still visionaries in Africa, even on the grand scale, but they are increasingly on the sidelines of political life. 
 Contemporary blueprints focus on the next three years, and their targets are modest, if not downright pessimistic. 
 This book has concentrated on the political and social values of Africa today, and traced their evolution over more than a century. 
 It has also shown that they are only a part of the explanation of Africa's problems; a difficult agricultural base, the inequalities of the world trading system, the sometimes exploitative role of multinational companies have also had a major part to play. 
 However, the relevance of these technical, physical and economic problems to development is discussed infinitely more frequently than the political and social context in which they are found. 
 Leading African civil servants entrusted with the day-to-day execution of policy over the last twenty years know that these are not necessarily the major problems. 
 Philip Ndegwa is a highly respected former governor of the Central Bank of Kenya. 
 In 1986 he wrote: 
 There is no magic in the process of economic and social development of nations which enables instant transformation. 
 Development can only be achieved over time, and more often than not along a difficult path. 
 This is because&hellip; the process of development involves not only the production of more goods and services but also the transformation of the society itself, including the establishment of new institutions, social systems, rules and values. 
 &hellip; This means that the social traditions, values and attitudes which exist in any society cannot be brushed aside. 
 The open discussion of these issues in Africa is difficult, since they reach into the heart of political life. 
 Furthermore, their policy implications may be quite limited since they define the environment, and condition people's behaviour within it, but are frequently outside the area of influence of planners, civil servants and aid-donors. 
 Nonetheless, they have to be embraced as a first step in understanding the limits to where Africa may be in another twenty-five or even fifty years. 
 THE CURRENT POLITICAL DYNAMIC 
 Economic recovery is not at the top of the political agenda in African countries today. 
 It is secondary to the political priorities of preserving specific presidents in power and the patronage system associated with them. 
 These priorities imply, on the domestic front, the attempt to maintain a continuing powerful role for the state, the economic dominance of a fairly small elite and an indifference to the welfare of rural peasant farmers, complicated as this may be by political loyalties to certain tribal groups. 
 In relation to the outside world they imply a wariness to foreign investors, and an ambivalence to foreign aid in so far as investors and aid donors may undermine the autonomy of the government. 
 The result is that major segments of the population &mdash; sometimes a majority, sometimes a minority &mdash; will continue to experience a sense of deprivation, and to be in permanent opposition to the government. 
 The Ibos in Nigeria and the Bamilike in Cameroun are both groups who in the 1950s and 1960s respectively made a bid for predominant national power; they failed, and continue to feel excluded from the political mainstream of their countries. 
 The identity of such marginal groups has sometimes changed, as presidents change: the Kikuyu were &bquo;in&equo; under Kenyatta and are &bquo;out&equo; under President Moi; the Bemba were &bquo;in&equo; under President Kaunda in the 1960s, but have been &bquo;out&equo; since Simon Kapwepwe broke away in 1971. 
 A sense of deprivation of a different kind continues to smoulder amongst the immigrant groups of Indian, Lebanese and Europeans, especially in Kenya and Zimbabwe, who feel that their economic position may be attacked, or re-attacked, at any time. 
 Though not in permanent opposition, their loyalty to the government of the day is shallow. 
 This sense of deprivation has spilled over into civil conflict or war a sufficient number of times for it to be a continuing threat, or an on-going reality as in Chad, Sudan, Ethiopia, Burundi, Uganda and Somalia. 
 The civil war between Renamo guerillas and the government in Mozambique also reflects this sense of deprivation &mdash; Renamo has been particularly strong amongst the Makonde of the north, who were most affected by the communal village programme of the 1970s. 
 In Angola the support for Jonas Savimbi's UNITA has been stronger amongst the Ovimbundu people of the central plateau than amongst the rest of the population. 
 While civil conflicts of this kind should diminish in the next twenty-five years as African states mature, they will not disappear. 
 For what is now at stake is not the acceptance of the artificial boundaries imposed by the colonial powers, but the distribution of opportunity within them. 
 No African country has managed to escape from the pattern of its past history, but in the late 1980s certain common characteristics can be seen among the more successful countries, notably Kenya, Cameroun and Botswana. 
 First, the leadership has been consistently tough and pragmatic. 
 Kenyatta and Ahidjo were nationalists first, and localists second although both went to great lengths to secure their political base amongst their own ethnic group. 
 In the 1960s Kenyatta manipulated sales of formerly white-owned land and businesses in such a way as to create a new class of Kenyan capitalists to replace the old white capitalists, in a no-nonsense determination to both preserve the private sector and to transfer its ownership into African hands. 
 This was the decisive factor in determining Kenya's subsequent political and economic direction. 
 In the early 1960s Ahidjo considered that he faced two key problems in Cameroun: first, preventing the economic hegemony of the Bamilike; and second, preventing a breakdown between the English- and French-speaking parts of the country. 
 He tackled the first by systematically awarding government contracts to northern businessmen (former traders) from his own area of Garoua and the second by insisting that schools and the civil service must be bilingual, a policy which has been extremely successful. 
 These policies were pursued with great determination and consistency, and Ahidjo was remarkably successful in holding Cameroun, with its 300 recognized languages, together. 
 This success was built on a medieval system of security and detention which caused numerous &bquo;disappearances&equo;. 
 The second characteristic of these more successful countries follows from the first: government has been strong, and has continued to function. 
 A necessary condition of this is that there has been sufficient money to enable it to function (barely true for instance in Zaire, and parts of Nigeria and Tanzania in the 1980s), and that civil strife has been contained, sometimes ruthlessly. 
 Ensuring sufficient money to finance the government machine has been a by-product of the third characteristic: maintaining savings and investment, which in all three cases (Kenya, Cameroun and Botswana) have risen substantially since 1960, to about 25 per cent of the output of the economy in 1986. 
 This is because government has never lost sight of the primacy of production, and has been able to avoid excessive borrowing to pay for it &mdash; in Cameroun because of the availability of oil, and in Kenya as a result of the low-key transfer of assets into African hands without any disruption in production. 
 In Botswana, government has consistently decided to live with the mining companies, rather than nationalize them or even seek to control them. 
 Instead it has, for instance, taken a &dollar;400 million shareholding (6 per cent of issued share capital) in the traded stock of DeBeers Consolidated the diamond marketing company, and two seats on DeBeers' Board, thus indirectly giving it a shareholding in the giant Anglo-American mining house. 
 The fourth characteristic of each of the three countries is that they have had the luck to avoid the worst of the droughts which have badly affected agriculture and hydro-electric power supplies in many African countries in the 1970s and 1980s. 
 While the north of Cameroun has been badly affected, its key productive areas lie in the high rainfall zones of the western highlands; in Kenya the old colonial rule-of-thumb that one year in five will be a year of drought has been sustained, and lean years have been followed by bumper crops. 
 In Botswana, the negative effects of low rainfall years are offset by the consequent increased sale of livestock, much of which is exported to high-value EC markets, since Botswana's urban meat-eating population is small. 
 Do these three relatively successful countries provide any kind of signpost to the rest of Africa? 
 The answer can be only a muted &bquo;yes&equo; since the economic foundations of most African countries, and the size and distribution of their population is very different to the situation prevailing in the early 1960s. 
 Most countries now have to build on an economy in which the productive assets are very run down, and even more importantly, in which a political consensus remains elusive. 
 THE INDIVIDUAL FUTURE 
 An awareness of politics grows out of individuals' perception of the world around them, and earlier in this book some of the main contributing factors to an African perception of the world, notwithstanding Africa's great diversity, were sketched. 
 The political future will largely depend on how these perceptions develop, and it is not impossible to gauge that development. 
 At the level of the individual the following trends are likely. 
 First, much more variety and less conformity and subservience in individual views. 
 Respect for elders, already severely weakened, will further diminish. 
 In the rural areas, family and tribal loyalties will continue to be important and religion and superstition will continue to play a major role. 
 In the urban areas, where a third of Africa's population will soon live, tribal loyalties will for the most part diminish, but will for many years exist in parallel with other loyalties. 
 These loyalties are increasingly to a myriad of individual community groups and associations, concerned with religion, education, savings and credit, trade and various forms of self-help. 
 Sometimes they are organized on a tribal basis, sometimes they embrace people from a number of different tribes. 
 They cut across class and gender, though women's groups almost certainly out-number those of the men. 
 Trade unions play a part within these associations but, since their function is nearly entirely within the formal sector &mdash; which employs only a small proportion of the population &mdash; they play a relatively minor role. 
 Purely tribal loyalties will eventually be neither more nor less than the regional loyalties of Europe, of the Scots to Scotland or the Bavarians to Bavaria. 
 They will last longest where tribal life has always been urban, for instance amongst the Asante in Kumasi, or the Yoruba in Ibadan. 
 Commitment not only to the extended family but also to the nuclear, two-parent family will diminish as men fail to adjust to the aspirations of educated women, and more women follow the long-established practice in coastal west Africa of running their own households. 
 As tribal culture weakens, status and power will come to be less connected with an outward demonstration of wealth, and this may pave the way for a more powerful generation of entrepreneurs as specific commercial objectives come to supersede those of status. 
 THE ECONOMIC FUTURE 
 The key to future economic growth in Africa lies in the markets which are being created as towns and cities expand. 
 Most estimates suggest that such urban centres are growing at five or six per cent a year. 
 At this rate a third of the population will be living in towns by the year 2000. 
 Such concentrations of population are frequently regarded as a burden on food supplies, and as a factor likely to worsen the balance of payments as consumer goods and food are sucked in from abroad, either openly or clandestinely. 
 In fact, the individual migrants who participate in this urban migration manage to generate income which is more attractive to them than the income they would have earned by remaining in the rural areas. 
 Furthermore, the goods they consume, from food to furniture, are either currently produced by informal sector artisans, or have the potential to be produced in this way. 
 In a great city like Ibadan a flour made from cassava, known as gari, is the basic foodstuff and armies of hard working women perform the task of transforming the cassava into gari ; clothes and basic furniture, as discussed in Chapter 10, are all made by local artisans. 
 The result of the migration process is therefore a steady increase in the demand for purchased  products, since most rural families will grow their own food, and make much of their domestic equipment. 
 The value of this market today is probably about &dollar;30 billion per year; by the year 2000 it will be &dollar;70 billion. 
 The ability of small-scale producers, whether farmers or artisans, to meet this market has become much clearer in the economic conditions of the 1980s. 
 The rural community has produced more food than ever before, although not yet enough. 
 Significant shifts of production have occurred from export crops, such as coffee and cocoa, to food crops for the domestic market, and the trend towards such shifts is likely to continue. 
 This can be seen in countries as different as Tanzania and Cameroun. 
 An expansion of production will also come from the use of land which is now sparsely populated. 
 Artisans will develop their ability to diversify their products and achieve limited improvements in their technology. 
 As the urban economy grows the official export of primary agricultural commodities will increase only at a very modest rate, if at all. 
 The principal characteristic of African economies in the next fifty years will then be an urban market which will in aggregate be very valuable but will have a low income per head. 
 This market will be appropriate to the skills and operating style of both the farmers and artisans who will meet its demands. 
 For the most part, the scale of production will not expand into larger-scale corporate enterprises because of the cultural factors which make larger-scale business organization difficult throughout Africa. 
 The output of such small-scale producers will not only be sold on local markets but also across national frontiers. 
 Cross-border trade in both foodstuffs and consumer goods is a growing phenomenon, though still largely unrecorded and outside the influence of official regional economic associations, such as the Preferential Trade Area, which now nominally embraces seventeen countries of central and east Africa. 
 Inside this framework the existing modern sector may well struggle for survival. 
 Large-scale, publicly-owned enterprises will breathe their last gasp and wither away well before the state which spawned them. 
 Large-scale, private businesses in manufacturing, geared to relatively high-value consumer products, will find little room for expansion as the incomes of most urban consumers continue to be very modest. 
 This situation will not prove attractive to multinational companies or other sources of off-shore private investment, and the current trend towards disinvestment is likely to continue. 
 Projects where a specific commodity is in international demand will prove an exception to this; such demand may prove to be strongest in other parts of the developing world, particularly Asia. 
 In general multinationals will be on the defensive, and they will seek to minimize their risk by continuing to negotiate management and royalty contracts which guarantee a minimum income. 
 This will leave entrepreneurs from local minority communities in a strong position as the owners of existing fairly well managed productive assets, and as the suppliers of intermediate goods to small-scale producers. 
 In those countries where there is no political backlash against them, such entrepreneurs are likely to continue to be key players in the domestic economy. 
 In this situation it will be difficult to generate manufactured or processed exports since the expertise to produce competitively for international markets will be in short supply, though some countries such as Zimbabwe will be able to build on their existing export base. 
 The unfavourable prospect for exports is perhaps the most damaging of Africa's economic weaknesses since it implies continued dependence on unstable, and on the whole, unfavourable commodity markets. 
 Behind this instability lies the simple fact that for many commodities such as coffee and ground-nuts, demand in the industrialized world with its stable population has probably reached saturation point. 
 These developments will continue to leave governments in an increasingly exposed position. 
 The difficulties of collecting taxes from millions of small-scale urban and rural producers wilt ensure that revenues continue to be inadequate in relation to the expectation of services such as universal primary and secondary education, health services, and transportation. 
 An increasing proportion of these services will be provided by local communities on a fee-paying basis. 
 Such groups are also likely to reinforce their existing role in the mobilization of savings, and it will be in mutual savings organizations, rather than formal financial institutions, that small-scale producers will find access to credit. 
 As a result of the limited increase in exports most governments will continue to experience serious balance of payments difficulties, although in some countries sometimes offset by earnings from minerals such as oil and diamonds. 
 Nonetheless, unofficial exports between neighbouring countries are likely to continue to increase, but to go largely unrecorded. 
 Economies will gradually become more interdependent, particularly between food deficit and food surplus countries, and the migration of labour between countries is likely to increase. 
 THE POLITICAL FUTURE 
 The growth of this economy of small-scale urban production will, over fifty years, change the face of African politics. 
 The prevalence of many countervailing centres of influence to government, in the form of local associations will in the long-term make it increasingly difficult for governments to concentrate all power in their hands. 
 Thus the regime of one-party states, nearly always achieved at considerable cost to those out of sympathy with the dominant party, will cause increasing resentment. 
 As a greater range of individual views prevails, so the poverty of policy choices made by a virtually self-selected group of politicians will become less and less acceptable. 
 However, the response of governments is likely to be more and more dogmatic, and be driven by considerations of &bquo;security&equo;; there will be little willingness by those in power to defer to differing views even when these are held by a majority. 
 Current experience from countries as diverse as Kenya and Mozambique confirms this. 
 In 1988 the Kenyan government openly considered abolishing the secret ballot in order to dissuade opposition voters from declaring their position. 
 For ten years Frelimo, the ruling party in Mozambique, has operated a system by which party members are publicly elected by each community in a manner which effectively rules out those who may have opposing views. 
 In the 1988 elections to the National Assembly in Cameroun, the two alternative lists of candidates, under a proportional representation system, were consistently doctored to make them indistinguishable from each other. 
 The basis of support for this pattern of continued authoritarian government will become less localist, simply because of the size of the urban population, and because tribal identities will continue to break down in an urban environment. 
 In rural areas politics will continue to be highly localist, but the tribal connotations of localism will gradually be reduced. 
 For some time threats to governments will continue to come primarily from those already close to power. 
 As with the pre-colonial chitumukulu  of the Bemba, heads of state will fear members of their senior council more than the dispossessed of the shanty town or the rural hamlet. 
 Neither will they hand over power gracefully to an elected successor; the transfer of power will continue to be an abrasive, coup-ridden business. 
 To the public at large faith in the political process, already at a low ebb, will diminish further. 
 Strong individual faith in Islam and Christianity will provide an outlet for social energies rejected by formal politics. 
 Since women's role in politics will be restricted by the same male attitudes which militate against equality in the home, the Christian churches will continue to be particularly attractive to them. 
 With Islam, however, there will be important links between the strength of the mosques and the political complexion of government, as has always existed between the Murid Brotherhood and the government of Senegal, and as the introduction of Sharia Law in Sudan in 1983, and the strength of fundamentalist movements in northern Nigeria indicates. 
 Eventually, as has already occurred with Islam in some countries, these countervailing centres of power will challenge governments and sometimes gain control over them. 
 Changes in these attitudes and practices will be the result of a long political process which will certainly take more than a century to work out, and even then will probably compress the time which it took Europe to work through comparable processes. 
 Democratization will come gradually as the new urban interest groups flex their muscles as alternative centres of power. 
 In this respect Nigeria may be the key reference point, because its enormous population of more than 100 million will continue to force it into constitutional experiments, because its press has seldom been effectively muzzled, and because its leaders have never acquired the absolute power of many neighbouring heads of state. 
 The uneven course of this process of political evolution, and the fact that neighbouring countries will be at different stages within it, will continue to make official regional co-operation between countries very difficult. 
 So long as a head of state &mdash; and thus his circle of patronage &mdash; can change quite unexpectedly, multi-country regional groupings will have to overcome major political as well as economic problems. 
 In southern Africa, such regional groups will do little to counteract the internal political frailty of the countries in the area, and as a result South Africa will have plenty of opportunity to pursue malevolent policies of destabilization if it chooses to do so. 
 IMPLICATIONS FOR AFRICA'S DONORS 
 The aid programme, as it has developed over the last thirty years, has failed in terms of its original objective, i.e. the promotion of a pattern of economic growth in which the injection of external finance on soft terms was no longer necessary. 
 Together with the credits provided by export credit agencies, much of it for military hardware, this policy has culminated in the late 1980s in the accumulation of a mountain of debt which cannot be serviced on the original schedule of payments. 
 The underlying causes of Africa's economic weakness imply that the current pattern of structural adjustment lending will also not break the cycle of dependency on aid. 
 The latter has become a form of economic drip-feed of dubious value to the patient, although it has maintained economic activity at a higher level than would otherwise be the case. 
 Should donors continue to lend? 
 Recognition by creditor institutions and governments of the impracticability of Africa servicing its accumulated debt has led to very significant rescheduling arrangements since 1985. 
 In that year about 21 per cent of all Africa's earnings from exports were accounted for by payment of principal and interest on debt; by 1987 the figure had fallen to 14 per cent and was likely to decrease further. 
 This has cleared the way for a re-appraisal of aid policies. 
 Aid has created such artificial divisions within what should be normal national programmes of health care or agriculture that it now obstructs the development of such programmes on a country-wide basis. 
 It would be much more constructive for a consortium of donors to sit down with governments and review their need for aid finance over, say, the next three-year period. 
 Such a review would cover the direction of government policy in all important areas of the economy, including its view of the role of the private sector. 
 If the consortium agreed to support the overall programme funds would be given, on an agreed schedule, providing the strategies were retained. 
 They would not be tied to the goods of donor countries, and all funds from national sources should be in the form of grants (already the case for a majority of donors). 
 It would be far more useful to Africa to have a smaller amount of total aid on this basis, than to retain the present system where thinking and strategy is dominated by donors, to the extent that national governments have almost lost control over public initiatives in their own countries. 
 THE INTERNAL STRUGGLE 
 It is likely that Africa is now moving into a phase in which the rest of the world is less interested in her affairs. 
 The problem of servicing debt is already, in practice, less severe than it was in the early and mid 1980s. 
 Relaxation of the international cold war has meant that military intervention by powerful countries from either the western or eastern blocs &mdash; from Cuba to France &mdash; will be much less frequent. 
 Even South Africa may decide that the returns from supporting such organizations as Renamo in Mozambique are extremely slim. 
 Africa will, then, be thrown increasingly inward on herself, and have increasingly less reason to blame the rest of the world for her problems. 
 These will only be resolved in the course of an internal struggle, which will eventually produce governments neither more nor less enlightened than, for instance, those which have ruled over western Europe for the last five hundred years. 
 In the course of this struggle African governments will deal harshly with their opposition, keep power at the centre, and entertain corruption as a normality. 
 While advised to look outwards, and open their economies to trade and investment, they will feel compelled to look inwards as the competition on international markets appears unequal. 
 Attempts by both India and China to open their economies in the 1980s have resulted in a tug-of-war between their economic liberals and economic conservatives, which shows every sign of ending either in stalemate or in a victory for the conservatives. 
 If these richly-endowed giants of the developing world are barely equal to the task of liberalization, Africa is much less equipped for the challenge, and much less prepared to face it. 
 She can only equip herself to face the world from a secure position when she has developed an internal strength which will come from the accumulation of power by centres of growth which lie far outside the existing bureaucracies of government, party and presidential palace. 
 Then out will go the difficult legacies of hierarchial government, clan loyalties, arbitrary succession and the adjustment to a money-based, urban-led culture. 
 In this way, in as little as a hundred years, Africa's doubts about herself &mdash; now so prevalent &mdash; may finally be removed. 
 As he weakened, Moran became afraid of his daughters. 
 This once powerful man was so implanted in their lives that they had never really left Great Meadow, in spite of jobs and marriages and children and houses of their own in Dublin and London. 
 Now they could not let him slip away. 
 &bquo;You'll have to shape up, Daddy. 
 You can't go on like this. 
 You're giving us no help. 
 We can't get you better on our own.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who cares? 
 Who cares anyhow?&equo; 
 &bquo;We care. 
 We all care very much.&equo; 
 They all came at Christmas. 
 After Christmas, Mona, the one girl who had not married, came every weekend from Dublin. 
 Sometimes Sheila got away from her family to come with her and she drove down for a few hours as well as now and again in the middle of the week. 
 The air fare from London was too expensive for Maggie to come regularly. 
 Michael, their younger brother, had promised to come from London at Easter but Luke, the eldest, still would not come. 
 All three girls planned to come to revive Monaghan Day. 
 They had to explain to their stepmother Rose what Monaghan Day was. 
 She had never heard of it in all her time in the house. 
 The end-of-February fair in Mohill was Monaghan Day. 
 McQuaid came every year to the house on Monaghan Day. 
 He and Moran had fought in the same flying column in the war. 
 McQuaid always drank a bottle of whiskey in the house when he came. 
 &bquo;If we could revive Monaghan Day for Daddy it could help to start him back to himself. 
 Monaghan Day meant the world to him once.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sure Daddy was far from delighted to see a bottle of whiskey drank in the house,&equo; Rose was doubtful about the whole idea. 
 &bquo;He never minded McQuaid drinking the whiskey. 
 You wouldn't get McQuaid to the house without whiskey.&equo; 
 They clung so tenaciously to the idea that Rose felt she couldn't stand in their way. 
 Moran was not to be told. 
 They wanted it to come as a sudden surprise &mdash; jolt. 
 Against all reason they felt it could turn his slow decline around like a Lourdes' miracle. 
 Forgotten was the fearful nail-biting exercise Monaghan Day had always been for the whole house; with distance it had become large, heroic, blood-mystical, something from which the impossible could be snatched. 
 Maggie flew over from London on the morning of the Day. 
 Mona and Sheila met her at Dublin Airport and the three sisters drove to Great Meadow in Mona's car. 
 They did not hurry. 
 With the years they had drawn closer. 
 Apart, they could be breathtakingly sharp on the others' shortcomings but together their individual selves gathered into something very close to a single presence. 
 On the tides of Dublin or London they were hardly more than specks of froth but together they were the aristocratic Morans of Great Meadow, a completed world, Moran's daughters. 
 Each scrap of news any one of them had about themselves or their immediate family &mdash; child, husband, dog, cat, Bendix dishwasher, a new dress or pair of shoes, the price of every article they bought &mdash; was as fascinating to each other as if it were their very own; and any little thing out of Great Meadow was pure binding. 
 Together they were the opposite of women who will nod and nod as they pretend to listen to another, waiting for the first pause of breath to muscle in with the growing pains and glories of their own house, the impatience showing on their faces as they wait. 
 Mullingar was passed and they felt they had hardly said a word to one another. 
 At the hotel in Longford they broke the journey to have tea and sandwiches, and just as the winter light began to fail they were turning in the open gate under the poisonous yew tree. 
 In spite of their wish to make the visit a surprise, Rose had told Moran they were arriving. 
 &bquo;They must think I'm on the way out.&equo; 
 &bquo;The opposite,&equo; she reassured. 
 &bquo;But they think you should be getting far better.&equo; 
 &bquo;How can they all manage to get away together like that?&equo; 
 &bquo;It must have fallen that way. 
 Isn't it worth getting dressed up for once?&equo; 
 &bquo;Who cares now anyhow?&equo; he said automatically but changed into his brown suit. 
 His face was flushed with excitement when they came. 
 In their nervousness they offered at once the gifts they had brought: tea, fruit, duty-free whiskey &mdash; &bquo;It'll be useful to have in the house even if nobody drinks it and we might need a glass&equo; &mdash; a printed silk headscarf, thick fur gloves. 
 &bquo;What did you want to bring anything to me for?&equo; 
 He always disliked having to accept presents. 
 &bquo;You were complaining at Christmas that your hands were always cold, Daddy.&equo; 
 As if to turn attention away from the continual coldness of his hands, he pulled on the gloves comically and pretended to grope about the room with them like a blind man. 
 &bquo;The gloves are only for when you go out. 
 I'm afraid all this excitement is going to your head, Daddy.&equo; 
 Rose, laughing, took the gloves away as he pretended to need them to wear about the house. 
 &bquo;I haven't discovered yet what brought out all the troops,&equo; he said when the laughing stopped. 
 &bquo;Don't you remember the day it is? 
 Monaghan Day! 
 The day when McQuaid always used to come from the fair in Mohill and we had to make the big tea.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's that got to do with anything?&equo; just as he resented gifts he resented any dredging up of the past. 
 He demanded that the continuing present he felt his life to be should not be shadowed or challenged. 
 &bquo;We thought it was as good an excuse as any and we were all able to get away at the same time. 
 So here we are.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was a poor excuse then. 
 McQuaid was a drunken blackguard who was with me in the war. 
 I felt sorry for him. 
 If I didn't give him a square meal on Monaghan Day he'd drink himself stupid in Mohill.&equo; 
 &bquo;They've come all this way to see you and is that all the welcome they get,&equo; Rose chided gently. 
 &bquo;Who cares about poor McQuaid, God rest him, he's long gone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who cares about anything now anyhow?&equo; he demanded. 
 &bquo;We care. 
 We care very much. 
 We love you.&equo; 
 &bquo;God help your wits then. 
 Pay no attention to me. 
 I wrote to that older brother of yours, &bquo;My capabilities are of little matter now&equo;, but I suppose I might be as well off writing to myself for all the answer I'm likely to get.&equo; 
 He went silent and dark and withdrew into himself, the two thumbs rotating about one another as he sat in the car chair by the fire. 
 A quick glance between Rose and the girls was enough for them to know that it was better to make no mention of their elder brother. 
 They began to busy themselves cheerfully with preparations for the meal, one or other of them constantly trying to engage Moran with this small thing or that, until he was drawn by their uncanny tact into the general cheerfulness. 
 When they finally sat down to the meal it was Moran himself who brought McQuaid back into the day. 
 &bquo;McQuaid wasn't a bad sort but he was misfortunate with the drink. 
 The interesting thing about him is that he was one of those people who always turn out to be lucky no matter what they do. 
 When he started to buy he knew nothing about cattle. 
 Yet he made a fortune. 
 Those people always get on better in the world than decent men.&equo; 
 &bquo;His great hour was when he dressed up as the newspaper boy and went to meet the train,&equo; Sheila said tentatively. 
 She had heard it every year on Monaghan Day for years but she was unsure if Moran would allow any talk of the war. 
 He generally went stone-silent whenever it was mentioned. 
 &bquo;He was lucky in that too and he had no nerves.&equo; 
 &bquo;He always said you were the whole brains of the column. 
 That everything they ever went into was planned by you, down to the last detail,&equo; Mona was emboldened to add. 
 &bquo;I'd gone to school longer than the others. 
 To the Latin school in Moyne. 
 I could read maps, calculate distances. 
 You'd never think it but McQuaid, like many of the others, was more or less illiterate though he could add and subtract quick enough when it concerned his pocket. 
 It was easy to get the name of brains in those days.&equo; 
 As if he suddenly wanted to return the girls' favour on this Monaghan Day, he spoke to them openly about the war for the first time in their lives. 
 &bquo;The English didn't seem to know right what they were doing. 
 I think they were just going through the motions of what had worked before. 
 Look at the train business. 
 Imagine having a brass band meet a colonel in the middle of the bogs with the whole countryside up in arms. 
 A child wouldn't do it. 
 &bquo;Don't let anybody fool you. 
 It was a bad business. 
 We didn't shoot at women and children like the Tans but we were a bunch of killers. 
 We got very good but there was hardly a week when some of us wasn't killed. 
 Of the twenty-two men in the original column only seven were alive at the Truce. 
 We were never sure we'd be alive from one day to the next. 
 Don't let them pull wool over your eyes. 
 The war was the cold, the wet, standing to your neck in a drain for a whole night with bloodhounds on your trail, not knowing how you could manage the next step toward the end of a long march. 
 That was the war: not when the band played and a bloody politician stepped forward to put flowers on the ground. 
 &bquo;What did we get for it? 
 A country, if you'd believe them. 
 Some of our own johnnies in the top jobs instead of a few Englishmen. 
 More than half of my own family work in England. 
 What was it all for? 
 The whole thing was a cod.&equo; 
 &bquo;They say you should have gone to the very top in the army after the war but you were stopped. 
 McQuaid always said they set out to stop you,&equo; Sheila said with borrowed vehemence. 
 &bquo;I was stopped all right but it wasn't as simple as poor McQuaid made out. 
 In an army in peacetime you have to arselick and know the right people if you want to get on. 
 I was never any good at getting on with people. 
 You should all know that by now,&equo; he said half humorously. 
 There were tears in the girls' eyes as they tried to smile back. 
 Rose was quiet and watchful. 
 &bquo;For people like McQuaid and myself the war was the best part of our lives. 
 Things were never so simple and clear again. 
 I think we never rightly got the hang of it afterwards. 
 It was better if it had never happened. 
 Tired now. 
 You were all great girls to travel such distances to see one sick old man.&equo; 
 He took his beads from the small purse. 
 They hung loose from his hand. 
 &bquo;Anyhow it no longer matters to you or to me, but whoever has the last laugh in the whole business is going to have to spend a hell of a length of time laughing. 
 We  have to try to work as best we can and pray .&equo; 
 He looked so strained and tired that they offered to say the Rosary in his room but he brushed the offer aside. 
 He knelt as erect as ever at the table. 
 &bquo;Thou, O Lord, wilt open my lips,&equo; he called. 
 When he came to the Dedication he paused as if searching. 
 Then, in a sudden flash that he was sometimes capable of, he acknowledged his daughters' continuing goodwill and love, love that usually he seemed inherently unable to return. 
 &bquo;Tonight we offer up this Holy Rosary for the repose of the soul of James McQuaid.&equo; 
 When the prayers were ended the three girls kissed him goodnight in turn, and Rose went with him to their room. 
 The girls started to wash up and tidy; very soon the litter of the evening was cleared away, the room made ready for breakfast. 
 When Rose saw the table already set for morning, she said, &bquo;If you were around for too long I'd be spoiled rotten. 
 I don't know what anybody else is having but I'm going to be bad tonight and have a cigarette and hot whiskey. 
 You all took Daddy out of himself tonight. 
 That all of you managed to come meant the world to Daddy.&equo; 
 The next morning they were idling in the luxury of a long breakfast, enjoying the chatting in the warmth of the room, the tussocks in the white field outside the window stiff with frost, the only green grass the huge dark circles under the cypress trees, when a single shotgun blast came from the front room. 
 They looked at one another in fear, moving quickly as one person to the room. 
 He was standing at the open window in his pyjamas, the shotgun in his hand, staring out at the front field where the black splash of a jackdaw lay on the white ground beneath the ash tree. 
 &bquo;Are you all right, Daddy?&equo; they called out. 
 When it was clear that he was, Rose cried, &bquo;You frightened the life out of us, Daddy.&equo; 
 &bquo;That bloody bird has been annoying me for days.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll get your death of cold standing there at the open window,&equo; Maggie complained and Rose brought the window down. 
 &bquo;You didn't miss anyhow.&equo; 
 Rose was intent on laughing away the incongruity of the situation. 
 &bquo;I don't think Daddy ever missed,&equo; Mona said. 
 &bquo;The closest I ever got to any man was when I had him in the sights of the rifle and I never missed.&equo; 
 The voice was so absent and tired that it took some of the chill from the words. 
 He allowed Rose to take the gun away but not before he had removed the empty shell. 
 He dressed and had breakfast with them at the table. 
 The gun was returned to its usual place in the comer of the room and no more mention was made of the dead jackdaw. 
 &bquo;Tired again,&equo; he said simply after an hour and went back to his room. 
 Maggie was taking a plane to London that night and Sheila and Mona were driving her to the airport. 
 The two girls would not be back till the following weekend. 
 Moran stood with Rose in the doorway watching the car drive away. 
 He waved weakly after the car but he did not speak as Rose shut the door and they turned back into the house. 
 Monaghan Day had revived nothing but a weak fanciful ghost of what had been. 
 After Easter and many other alarms, when none of the girls was able to be in Great Meadow, Rose had her sister buy a brown Franciscan habit in the town. 
 In spite of the hush and emptiness of the house, the two women smuggled the habit in like thieves and later that evening Rose hid it among her most intimate articles of clothing in a part of the wardrobe that Moran never opened. 
 The attempt to revive Monaghan Day was a gesture as weak as a couple who marry in order to try to retrieve a lost relationship, the mind having changed the hard actual fact into what was comfortable to feel. 
 On the last Monaghan Day that McQuaid came to the house Moran was on edge as he waited for him as he had been on edge every Monaghan Day, the only day in the year that McQuaid came to Great Meadow. 
 Since morning he had been in and out of the kitchen where Maggie and Mona were cleaning and tidying and preparing for the big meal. 
 Though Maggie was eighteen, tall and attractive, she was still as much in awe of Moran as when she had been a child. 
 Mona, two years younger, was the more likely to clash with him, but this day she agreed to be ruled by Maggie's acquiescence. 
 Sheila, a year younger still, was too self-centred and bright ever to challenge authority on poor ground and she pretended to be sick in order to escape the tension of the day. 
 Alone, the two girls were playful as they went about their tasks, mischievous at times, even carefully boisterous; but as soon as their father came in they would sink into a beseeching drabness, cower as close to being invisible as they could. 
 &bquo;How do the lamb chops look?&equo; he demanded again. 
 &bquo;Are these the best lamb chops you could get? 
 Haven't I told you time in and time out never &mdash; never &mdash; to get lamb chops anywhere but from Kavanagh's? 
 Has everything to be drummed in a hundred times? 
 God, why is nothing ever made clear in this house? 
 Everything has to be dragged out of everybody.&equo; 
 &bquo;Kavanagh said the steak wasn't great but that the lamb was good,&equo; Maggie added but Moran was already on his way out again, muttering that not even simple things were made clear in this house and if simple things couldn't be made clear how was a person ever to get from one day to the next in this world. 
 The two girls were quiet for a long time after the door closed; then suddenly, unaccountably, they started to push one another, boisterously mimicking Moran: &bquo;God, O God, what did I do to deserve such a crowd? 
 Gawd, O Gawd, not even the simple things are made clear,&equo; falling into chairs laughing. 
 A loud imperious knocking came on the tongued boards of the ceiling in the middle of the rowdy relief. 
 They stopped to listen and as they did the knocking stopped. 
 &bquo;She's no more sick than my big toe. 
 Whenever there's a whiff of trouble she takes to her bed with the asthma. 
 She has books and sweets hidden up there,&equo; Mona said. 
 They waited in silence until the knocking resumed, insistent and angry. 
 &bquo;Boohoo!&equo; they responded. 
 &bquo;Boohoo! 
 Boohoo! 
 Boohoo!&equo; 
 The knocking made the boards of the ceiling tremble. 
 She was using a boot or shoe. 
 &bquo;Boohoo!&equo; they echoed. 
 &bquo;Boohoo! 
 Boohoo!&equo; 
 The stairs creaked. 
 In a moment Sheila stood angrily framed in the doorway. 
 &bquo;I've been knocking for ages and all ye do is laugh up at me.&equo; 
 &bquo;We never heard. 
 We'd laugh up at nobody.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ye heard only too well. 
 I'm going to tell Daddy on the pair of ye.&equo; 
 &bquo;Boohoo!&equo; they repeated. 
 &bquo;You think I'm joking. 
 You'll pay for this before it's over.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you want?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sick and you won't even bring up a drink.&equo; 
 They gave her a jug of barley water and a clean glass. 
 &bquo;You know what day it is and McQuaid is coming from the mart. 
 He's in and out like a devil. 
 You can't expect us to dance attendance up the stairs as well. 
 If he comes in and sees you like that in the door he'll have something to say,&equo; Maggie said but Sheila slipped back upstairs before she finished. 
 They draped the starched white tablecloth over the big deal table. 
 The room was wonderfully warm, the hotplate of the stove glowing a faint orange. 
 They began to set the table, growing relaxed and easy, enjoying the formality of the room, when Moran came in again from the fields. 
 This time he stood in the centre of the room, plainly unsure as to what had brought him in, his eye searching around for something to fasten on, like someone in mid-speech forgetting what they had to say. 
 &bquo;Is everything all right?&equo; 
 &bquo;Everything is all right, Daddy.&equo; 
 No sooner had the door closed than Mona, released from the tension of his presence, let slip a plate from her hands. 
 They stood watching dumbly in horrible fascination after it shattered. 
 Quickly they swept up the pieces and hid them away, wondering how they would replace the plate without being found out. 
 &bquo;Don't worry,&equo; Maggie comforted Mona who was still pale with shock. 
 &bquo;We'll find some way round it.&equo; 
 They were too sick at heart to mimic or mock this mood away. 
 Anything broken had to be hidden until it could be replaced or forgotten. 
 Outside it was cold but there was no rain. 
 It was always cold on Monaghan Day, the traditional day poor farmers sold their winter stock and the rich farmers bought them for fattening. 
 Moran was neither rich nor poor but his hatred and fear of poverty was as fierce as his fear of illness which meant that he would never be poor but that he and all around him would live as if they were paupers. 
 Moran had no work in the fields but still he stayed outside in the cold, looking at hedges, examining walls, counting cattle. 
 He was too excited to be able to stay indoors. 
 As the light began to fail he retreated into the shelter of the fir plantation to watch the road for McQuaid's car. 
 If McQuaid had a big order to fill he mightn't come till after dark. 
 The light was almost gone when the white Mercedes came slowly along the road and turned into the open gate under the yew tree. 
 Moran did not move even after the car stopped. 
 In fact, he instinctively stepped backwards into the plantation as the car door was thrown open. 
 Without moving he watched McQuaid struggle from the car and then stand leaning on the open door as if waiting for someone to appear. 
 He could have called out from where he stood but he did not. 
 McQuaid slammed the car door and walked towards the house. 
 Not until he was several minutes within the house did Moran leave the plantation. 
 He came slowly and deliberately across the fields to the back door. 
 Though he had lived for weeks for this hour he now felt a wild surge of resentment towards McQuaid as he came into his own house. 
 McQuaid was seated in the armchair by the fire. 
 His powerful trunk and huge belly filled the chair and the yellow cattleman's boots were laced halfway up the stout legs. 
 He did not rise from the chair or acknowledge Moran's entrance in any way except to direct the flirting banter he was having with the girls to Moran. 
 &bquo;These girls are blooming. 
 You better have your orchards well fenced or you'll be out of apples by October.&equo; 
 The words were said with such good humour and aggressive sureness that it would have been impossible to take offence. 
 Moran hardly heard; all resentment left him as quickly as it had come: McQuaid was here and it was Monaghan Day. 
 &bquo;Michael.&equo; 
 McQuaid reached out of the chair and took Moran's hand in a firm grip. 
 &bquo;Jimmy.&equo; 
 Moran responded with the same simplicity. 
 &bquo;Have you been here long?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not long. 
 I had a fine talk with these girls. 
 They are great girls.&equo; 
 Moran walked across to the curtained press where he kept medicines and took out a glass and a full bottle of Redbreast. 
 He poured out a large measure of the whiskey and brought it to McQuaid. 
 Maggie placed a jug of spring water on the table. 
 &bquo;Say when,&equo; Moran poured the water into the glass. 
 McQuaid held out the glass until it was three-quarters full. 
 &bquo;You'll need it after the mart,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;I don't need it but I'll do much better than that. 
 I'll enjoy it. 
 Good luck everybody.&equo; 
 &bquo;How did it go?&equo; 
 Moran asked with a heartiness that didn't suit him. 
 &bquo;The same as every other Monaghan Day,&equo; McQuaid said. 
 &bquo;Was it good or bad?&equo; 
 Moran continued. 
 &bquo;It was neither good nor bad. 
 It was money. 
 All the farmers think their cattle are special but all I ever see is money. 
 If a beast is around or below a certain sum of money I buy. 
 If it goes over that I'm out.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've often watched you in the past and wondered how you know exactly the right time to enter the bidding, the right time to leave,&equo; Moran praised. 
 His fascination with McQuaid's mastery of his own world was boyish. 
 He had never been able to deal with the outside. 
 All his dealings had been with himself and that larger self of family which had been thrown together by marriage or accident: he had never been able to go out from his shell of self. 
 &bquo;I don't know how I know that,&equo; McQuaid said. 
 &bquo;All I know is that it cost me a lot of money to learn.&equo; 
 The girls had the freshly cut bread, butter and milk on the table. 
 The lamb chops sizzled as they were dropped into the big pan. 
 The sausages, black pudding, bacon, halves of tomatoes were added soon after to the sides of the pan. 
 The eggs were fried in a smaller pan. 
 Mona scalded the large teapot and set it to brew. 
 The two girls were silent as they cooked and when they had to speak to one another spoke in quick, urgent whispers. 
 This looks like a meal fit for a king. 
 It makes me want to roll up my sleeves,&equo; McQuaid said in praise and plain enjoyment at the prospect of it as the plates were put on the table. 
 He finished his glass of whiskey with a flourish before rising from the chair. 
 The two men ate in silence, with relish, waited on by the two girls. 
 As soon as McQuaid pushed his empty plate contentedly aside he said, &bquo;These are great girls but where are the missing soldiers?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sheila is upstairs with a cold,&equo; Maggie pointed to the ceiling. 
 &bquo;And Michael is gone to our aunt in the mountains for a week.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where's Luke then?&equo; 
 The girls looked from McQuaid to Moran and back to McQuaid again but they did not speak. 
 &bquo;We don't know where he is,&equo; Moran said reluctantly. 
 He particularly disliked parting with information about the house. 
 &bquo;You couldn't open your mouth in this house before he left but he'd be down your throat.&equo; 
 &bquo;If I know you I'd warrant he was given his money's worth,&equo; McQuaid laughed gently and when Moran didn't answer he added, &bquo;The young will have their way, Michael. 
 Anyhow I always liked Luke. 
 He is very straight and manly.&equo; 
 &bquo;I respect all my children equally,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;How are your lads?&equo; 
 &bquo;You know they're all married now. 
 I don't see much of them unless they want something and they don't see much of me. 
 They're good lads though. 
 They work long hours.&equo; 
 &bquo;And the good lady?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, the old dosey's all right. 
 She needs plenty of shouting at or she'd go to sleep on her feet.&equo; 
 They had married young and their three sons married young as well. 
 They lived alone now in the big cattle dealer's house with the white railing in the middle of fields. 
 He was seldom in the house except to eat or sleep and when he was all he ever did was yell, &bquo;Get the tea. 
 polish the boots. 
 kick out that bloody cat. 
 Get me a stud. 
 Where's the fucking collar?&equo; 
 &bquo;In a minute, Jimmy. 
 Coming. 
 On the way. 
 It's here in my very hand,&equo; his wife would race and flurry and call. 
 Then he would be gone for days. 
 She would spoil her cats, read library books and tend her garden and the riotous rockery of flowers along the south wall of the house that he encouraged the cattle to eat. 
 After days of peace the door would crash open: &bquo;There's six men here with lorries. 
 Put on the kettle. 
 Set the table. 
 Get hopping. 
 Put wheels under yourself. 
 We're fucking starving!&equo; 
 There was never a hint of a blow. 
 So persistent was the language that it had become no more remarkable than just another wayward manner of speaking and their sons paid so little attention to it that it might well have been one of the many private languages of love. 
 The dishes had been washed and put away. 
 Mona went to join Sheila upstairs. 
 Maggie was going visiting. 
 Another night Moran would have questioned her but not tonight. 
 Years ago Moran loaned McQuaid money when he had started in the cattle business but now McQuaid was the richer and more powerful man and they saw little of one another. 
 They came together once a year to slip back into what McQuaid said were the days of their glory. 
 Moran was too complicated to let anybody know what he thought of anything. 
 Moran had commanded a column in the war. 
 McQuaid had been his lieutenant. 
 From year to year they used the same handrails to go down into the past: lifting the cartwheel at the crossroads, the drilling sessions by the river, the first ambush, marching at night between the safe houses, the different characters in the houses, the food, the girls&hellip; 
 The interrogation of William Taylor the spy and his execution by the light of a paraffin lantern among his own cattle in the byre. 
 The Tans had swarmed over the countryside looking for them after the execution. 
 They had lived for a while in holes cut in the turf banks. 
 The place was watched night and day. 
 Once the British soldiers came on Mary Duignan when she was bringing them tea and sandwiches. 
 The Duignans were so naturally pale-faced that Mary showed no sign that anything was other than normal and she continued to bring tea and sandwiches to men working on a further turf bank. 
 Seeing the British soldiers, the startled men sat and ate though they had just risen from a complete meal. 
 &bquo;Mary was a topper,&equo; McQuaid said with emotion. 
 &bquo;Only for Mary that day our goose was cooked. 
 She was a bloody genius to think of giving the food to the men on the bank. 
 She's married to a carpenter in Dublin now. 
 She has several children.&equo; 
 Moran poured more whiskey into the empty glass. 
 &bquo;Are you sure you won't chance a drop?&equo; 
 McQuaid raised his glass. 
 &bquo;It's no fun drinking on your own.&equo; 
 &bquo;I couldn't handle it,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;You know that. 
 I had to give it up. 
 Now I couldn't look at it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I shouldn't have asked you then.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't mind. 
 I don't mind at all.&equo; 
 The reminiscing continued &mdash; the deaths of friends, one man marching alone through the night, the terrible hard labour it was for some men to die, night marches from one safe house to another, the rain, the wet, the damp, the cold of waiting for an ambush in one place for hours. 
 &bquo;We had them on the run by then. 
 They were afraid to venture out except in convoys.&equo; 
 &bquo;People who would have spat in our faces three years before were now clapping our backs. 
 They were falling over one another to get on the winning side.&equo; 
 &bquo;Many of them who had pensions and medals and jobs later couldn't tell one end of a gun from the other. 
 Many of the men who had actually fought got nothing. 
 An early grave or the emigrant ship. 
 Sometimes I get sick when I see what I fought for,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;It makes no sense your not taking the IRA pension. 
 You earned it. 
 You could still have it in the morning,&equo; McQuaid said. 
 &bquo;I'd throw it in their teeth,&equo; Moran clenched and unclenched his hands as he spoke. 
 &bquo;I never question the colour of any man's money. 
 If I'm offered it I take it,&equo; but Moran was too consumed to respond and McQuaid went on. 
 &bquo;Then it began to get easier. 
 We hadn't to hide any longer. 
 One hot day I remember leaving guns and clothes along the river bank and swimming without a stitch on. 
 Another Sunday we went trolling, dragging an otter behind the boat. 
 Then they tried to bring in the general.&equo; 
 &bquo;He wasn't a general. 
 He was a trumped-up colonel.&equo; 
 &bquo;Whatever he was we settled his hash,&equo; McQuaid gloated. 
 &bquo;You had a great head on you the way you thought the plan through from beginning to end. 
 You've been wasted ever since.&equo; 
 &bquo;Without you it would never have worked. 
 You were as cool as if you were out for a stroll,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;You could plan. 
 You worked it out from beginning to end. 
 None of the rest of us had that kind of head.&equo; 
 &bquo;We had spies. 
 We had men in the town for weeks. 
 They were bringing the big fellow in on the three o'clock train. 
 They were going to put on the big show. 
 They had a band and a guard of honour outside the station, their backs to a row of railwaymen's cottages. 
 They never checked the cottages.&equo; 
 &bquo;They wouldn't have found us anyhow.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nibs McGovern met that train every day with his trolley to pick up the papers and the Boland loaves that the shops got for special customers. 
 He was such a fixture that no one noticed him any more. 
 It fell into our hands.&equo; 
 &bquo;Looking back on it the plan couldn't have been simpler but we must have rehearsed it forty times. 
 We all slipped into town after dark. 
 Only Tommy Flood, the solicitor's clerk, gave any trouble.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then we nabbed Nibs,&equo; McQuaid laughed. 
 &bquo;just as he was getting ready to go out on the town. 
 We were lucky there as well. 
 Nibs didn't go to any one pub in particular. 
 Nibs was no trouble. 
 He could think quick enough when he had to. 
 We gave him whiskey and hadn't to tie him up till the morning and that was only for his own good.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then there was the waiting,&equo; Moran said violently. 
 &bquo;I'll never forget it. 
 Dressed up in Nibs's gear,&equo; McQuaid said. 
 &bquo;The clothes were fit to stand up on their own, they were that stiff with dust and grease. 
 The waiting was terrible. 
 It's like getting old. 
 Nothing happens and then the whole bloody thing is on top of you before you know it. 
 The Tommies marching to the station. 
 The band. 
 Sound of the train getting closer and before I knew it I was out on that street pushing the trolley. 
 The wheels were so loose I was afraid they'd fall off. 
 The one thing we never thought of was to check the wheels. 
 The overcoat was buttoned over the gun and the grenade. 
 Even in the middle of summer Nibs wore that overcoat.&equo; 
 &bquo;I had the stopwatch on you from behind one of the windows. 
 I followed every step. 
 I was afraid you'd get to the slope too soon. 
 I was afraid you could run into our fire if you got too far up on the slope.&equo; 
 &bquo;The gates were closed. 
 The train came puffing in. 
 The fucking band struck up &bquo;God Save the King&equo;. 
 There were three fir trees beside the platform. 
 They said they never grew right because of the smoke and steam. 
 The sergeant major was shouting. 
 They were all standing to attention. 
 The colonel or general or whatever he was came down the platform. 
 There was another officer with him holding a sword upright. 
 I kept pushing the trolley, praying to Jesus the bloody wheels wouldn't come loose. 
 No one even looked at me or the trolley. 
 The pair came along inspecting the troops. 
 The one holding the sword was young. 
 The colonel was a big stoutish man with red eyebrows. 
 All I remember thinking of as I pushed the trolley and looked at the red face and eyebrows was, My friend, you are about to take the longest journey a man ever takes in this life. 
 He took the full blast. 
 The other man was still holding the sword upright as he went down. 
 I pulled the pin out of the grenade. 
 The line of soldiers was still half standing to attention when I went through them. 
 I hadn't to use the revolver. 
 As soon as I got to the other side of the bank I threw myself down and started to roll.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's all I was watching for. 
 As soon as I saw you go down I gave the order to fire,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;Some of them were still standing to attention as they fell. 
 They hadn't a clue where the fire was coming from. 
 Then a few soldiers up at the goods store fired into their own men.&equo; 
 &bquo;By the time I rolled to the bottom of the slope I could see the steady fire coming from the windows. 
 I waited to get my breath before cutting across the road. 
 I don't think I was fired on once. 
 The first thing I did when I got behind the houses was to get out of Nibs's clothes.&equo; 
 &bquo;They were beginning to fire back from behind the station. 
 Michael Sweeney was hit in the shoulder. 
 I gave the order to file out. 
 Myles Reilly and McDermott stayed at the windows. 
 They were our two best riflemen. 
 When we got to Donoghue's Cross the road was cut and trees knocked. 
 We waited for Reilly and McDermott at the cross. 
 Then we split up, half of us for the safe houses round the lakes and the rest of us headed into the mountains. 
 We mightn't have bothered.&equo; 
 &bquo;They were afraid to put their heads out and when they did they came in a whole convoy, shooting at women and children.&equo; 
 &bquo;They were never the same again,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;News of it spread throughout the whole country.&equo; 
 &bquo;You had a great head on you, Michael.&equo; 
 &bquo;Only for you it couldn't have come to anything.&equo; 
 &bquo;I remember clearer than yesterday his eyebrows. 
 Not often you see an Englishman with red eyebrows. 
 I had so much time to look at him I can hardly believe it still, pushing the trolley, standing up in Nibs's clothes. 
 I had already loosened the overcoat and was thinking as I looked at him, This very minute you are going on the longest journey a man ever takes and you haven't a frigging clue. 
 Then I fired.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was watching you with the stopwatch.&equo; 
 &bquo;We didn't have to split up that day. 
 They were afraid of their shite to come out of the towns. 
 The country was ours again. 
 Next we had the Treaty. 
 Then we fought one another.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look where it brought us. 
 Look at the country now. 
 Run by a crowd of small-minded gangsters out for their own good. 
 It was better if it never had happened.&equo; 
 &bquo;I couldn't agree with that,&equo; McQuaid said. 
 &bquo;The country is ours now anyhow. 
 Maybe the next crowd will be better than this mixture of druids and crooks that we're stuck with.&equo; 
 &bquo;Leave the priests out of it,&equo; Moran said sharply. 
 &bquo;I'll leave nobody out of it. 
 They all got on our backs.&equo; 
 Moran did not answer. 
 An angry brooding silence filled the room. 
 McQuaid felt for the authority he had slowly made his own over the years, an authority that had outgrown Moran &bquo;s. 
 He would not move. 
 Moran rose and went outside. 
 McQuaid did not respond to him in any way when he came in again. 
 When Maggie returned she found them locked in the strained silence. 
 Beforehand she had combed her hair by the light of the flashlamp, smoothed and rearranged her clothes but even if she hadn't Moran would not have noticed this evening. 
 At once, in the silence, she began to make tea and sandwiches. 
 Mona came down from upstairs and after whispering with Maggie disappeared again upstairs with a small jug of milk and some sandwiches. 
 At last, out of the silence, Moran noticed McQuaid's glass was empty and attempted to pour him more whiskey. 
 &bquo;Cap it,&equo; McQuaid said and covered his glass with his hand. 
 &bquo;There were years when you were able for most of the bottle.&equo; 
 &bquo;Those years are gone. 
 We'll have the tea Maggie is making.&equo; 
 Reluctantly Moran screwed the cap back on the bottle and returned it behind the curtains of the medicine press. 
 The tone in which Cap it  had been said smarted like a cut. 
 &bquo;Do you remember Eddie McIniff in Maguire's garden on night watch?&equo; 
 McQuaid asked. 
 &bquo;He could see all the roads from Maguire's garden. 
 We were watching in case the Tans would try to infiltrate the lakes at night. 
 Eddie used to shoot a lot of duck and could stand like a stone. 
 One of the Maguire girls Ellie or Molly, I think it was Molly, they were all fine looking, tall women &mdash; came out to do her morning business and hunkered down under an apple tree a few feet away from Eddie. 
 All Eddie did was to wait a bit and then lean over without a sound and lay the gun barrel across her back cheeks. 
 I'd love to have seen her face when she jumped,&equo; McQuaid laughed out loud. 
 &bquo;There must be nothing colder on a bare arse than a gun barrel that was out all night.&equo; 
 Moran did not laugh. 
 He looked helpless with the weight of his own disapproval. 
 His two thumbs rotated about one another as they always did when he was agitated and looking for a way to strike. 
 &bquo;McIniff was blackguard enough to do that but you'd think that at least he'd be ashamed to tell it.&equo; 
 &bquo;What was it but fun?&equo; 
 McQuaid brushed the criticism aside. 
 &bquo;Didn't you have something to do with one of those Maguire girls? 
 The rest of us had to scrape and scrounge for the girls, Michael, but whatever you had they always fell into your hands like ripe plums.&equo; 
 &bquo;That was all talk,&equo; Moran said, angry as ever at any baring of the inviolate secrecy he instinctively kept around himself. 
 &bquo;Your father was a hard man for the women in his day,&equo; McQuaid said addressing the two girls. 
 &bquo;I think Mr McQuaid does himself less than credit with that talk,&equo; Moran said with quiet dignity. 
 &bquo;There's even rumours that you're courting again. 
 Are you thinking of taking the plunge, Michael?&equo; 
 Moran held a pointed silence. 
 The girls brought tea and sandwiches. 
 &bquo;Ah, these girls will make some man happy,&equo; McQuaid said. 
 &bquo;But you're a brave man, Michael. 
 If anything were to happen to my old dosey I'm afraid I'd live out my days in peace.&equo; 
 The girls were able to laugh openly at last without any risk. 
 The idea of the fat old cattle dealer emerging as a romantic possibility was so preposterous that even Moran smiled. 
 &bquo;I'd take that pension, Michael. 
 You earned it. 
 Take what they'll give you. 
 Never question the colour of money.&equo; 
 The talk turned to easier waters as they drank tea. 
 &bquo;I've got on without it long enough. 
 Why should I take it from them now?&equo; 
 It was plain from the blustering way he spoke that he wasn't so sure. 
 &bquo;It never did me no harm. 
 There were times when I was starting in at the cattle that it stood between me and the road. 
 It doesn't make much difference now but a hell of a sight of worse things come through the letterbox at the end of every month.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was thinking of taking it,&equo; Moran admitted. 
 &bquo;Wouldn't it buy something for the girls here or put someone through school even if you didn't want to take it for yourself? 
 You should have taken it years ago. 
 In this world you don't exist without money. 
 And there might never be another world.&equo; 
 McQuaid could not resist this hit at Moran's religiosity. 
 &bquo;Man proposes&hellip;&equo; 
 Moran said darkly. 
 &bquo;And God stays out of it,&equo; McQuaid twisted round the old saw. 
 The girls had washed and put away the cups and plates, covered the few squares of sandwiches that remained with a damp cloth. 
 &bquo;Mr McQuaid's room is ready,&equo; Maggie said as they prepared to take their leave for the night. 
 &bquo;The bed is aired.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I forgot,&equo; McQuaid said hastily. 
 &bquo;I have to be hitting the road any minute now. 
 I should have told you earlier but it must have slipped the old mind.&equo; 
 Moran did not protest. 
 Covertly, leaning far back in his chair, he watched McQuaid from under hooded eyelids: in all the years they had been coming together on Monaghan Day McQuaid had always spent the night in the house. 
 &bquo;I told my old lady I'd be home,&equo; McQuaid lied as he rose. 
 &bquo;Otherwise she'd have gone over to one of the boys. 
 She gets afraid on her own in the house at night.&equo; 
 Having waited long enough to see if they were needed, the two girls went up to Moran and kissed him on the lips as they did every night. 
 &bquo;Good night, Mr McQuaid,&equo; they offered their hand. 
 &bquo;That was a great meal. 
 Ye are a great pair of girls. 
 If you ever get up our way call in to see my old lassie,&equo; he took and held their hands. 
 &bquo;Good night, Mr McQuaid,&equo; they repeated awkwardly before leaving the two men alone. 
 McQuaid sat down but almost immediately rose again. 
 As on all the other Monaghan Days stretching far back he had come intending to stay the night. 
 Tonight a growing irritation at Moran's compulsion to dominate, to have everything on his own terms or not at all, had hardened into a sudden decision to overturn the years and quit the house at once. 
 As soon as Moran saw McQuaid on his feet again he knew the evening, all the evenings, were about to be broken up and he withdrew back into himself. 
 He would neither plead with him to stay nor help him with his leaving. 
 As soon as McQuaid met Moran's domination of the evening with this sudden violence he was anxious to be conciliatory. 
 &bquo;Well, thanks for the meal and evening, Michael. 
 It was a great evening.&equo; 
 For a time it seemed that Moran might choose to remain seated and force McQuaid to make his own way out of the house. 
 When he did rise in the chair it was slowly and grudgingly and he followed McQuaid out into the stone hallway as if he were finding it difficult to walk or move. 
 He held his hand on the door's edge in the darkness of the hallway. 
 &bquo;Good luck, Michael,&equo; the old cattle dealer said a last time but Moran made no answer in the darkness. 
 A brief moon between clouds outside sharpened the lines of boxwood that led to the wooden gate. 
 McQuaid walked heavily and firmly to the gate. 
 He did not bother to shut it, letting it swing open behind him. 
 After opening the door of the Mercedes he leaned on its edge to clear his throat and spit on the yellow path. 
 &bquo;Some people just cannot bear to come in second,&equo; he said loudly enough to be heard before getting into the car, reversing it round and driving away. 
 Moran stood holding the edge of the door until the headlights disappeared and he closed the door without shutting the iron gate at the road or the small wooden gate leaning against the boxwood. 
 In a cold fury he stood and sat about for a long time within, twice changing from chair to chair. 
 After years he had lost his oldest and best friend but in a way he had always despised friendship; families were what mattered, more particularly that larger version of himself &mdash; his  family; and while seated in the same scheming fury he saw each individual member gradually slipping away out of his reach. 
 Yes, they would eventually all go. 
 He would be alone. 
 That he could not stand. 
 He saw with bitter lucidity that he would marry Rose Brady now. 
 As with so many things, no sooner had he taken the idea to himself than he began to resent it passionately. 
 McQuaid had either struck true by pure chance or had picked up reliable gossip at the Mohill Fair. 
 Rose Brady had come home from Glasgow to nurse her father and stayed on irresolutely after his death, one day stretching into days. 
 She could go back to the Rosenblooms, to the big house outside Glasgow where she had lived as one of the family for twelve years. 
 Mrs Rosenbloom had written that they all wanted her back but still she stayed with her mother and brother in the farmhouse above the small lake, the poor rock-strewn lower slopes of the mountain rising towards Arigna beyond. 
 Sometimes in the evenings she had too strong a sense of being locked into the life of the farmhouse, even with the door continuously open on the summer yard, her brother away in the fields, her mother stumbling about the place with buckets, leaning on the table or the back of a chair whenever she stood to talk. 
 One evening, as an excuse to get out of the house, she went with a letter to the post office. 
 To her surprise the small room of the post office was full of people waiting for the evening mail. 
 They all turned towards her when she entered and way was made for her to go up to the counter. 
 People whose own names she was no long certain of called out her name and she smiled and nodded by way of general response. 
 The post office was owned by two white-haired sisters, Annie and Lizzie, far out cousins of her own, and Annie stamped the envelope for her, postmarked it and dropped it in the calico bag on the counter. 
 &bquo;You're still with us, Rose?&equo; 
 &bquo;Still here, Annie. 
 You've a big crowd this evening.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's for the mail van. 
 You might as well wait yourself to see if there's anything for the house.&equo; 
 In turn she moved aside to allow someone else room at the counter and found herself standing beside Moran. 
 She knew him well by sight but she had never spoken with him before. 
 &bquo;I was very sorry about your father,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I know that,&equo; she gave the formal response. 
 He had been a widower for many years, she knew. 
 He had been an army officer once and there had been trouble that caused him to leave the army. 
 Often she had passed the stone house where he lived with his children, some of whom must now be grown. 
 She had heard dark mutterings about him but after a few minutes of talking with him she was ready to put it down to common envy. 
 She found him attentive, intelligent, even charming, but with a distinct sense of separateness and pride that she found refreshingly unlike any of the other local men she had known. 
 When the mail van pulled up outside, the hum of talk about them went silent. 
 The driver dumped the mail bag on the counter, lifting the sealed bag without speaking a word. 
 Annie opened the bag. 
 As soon as she started to go through the bundle of letters, all Moran's attention was fixed on the sorting. 
 He ignored Rose completely. 
 From being the centre of his attention one moment all of a sudden she ceased to exist. 
 His whole life seemed to hang on each letter in Annie's hand, his eyes following it until she handed it into the crowd or placed it on a pile to one side and then he would fix on the next letter and the next. 
 The tension was such that she felt sudden relief as they went out of the small room into the air. 
 &bquo;Were you expecting an important letter?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he laughed. 
 &bquo;What makes you think that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I just wondered.&equo; 
 &bquo;I come nearly every evening for the post. 
 It gets you out of the place. 
 It saves wondering the next day whether Jimmy Lynch will bring anything to the house or not.&equo; 
 The bicycle she wheeled left thin tracks in the pale dust that covered the road. 
 At the crossroads beside the bridge they parted. 
 &bquo;I suppose we'll be losing you again before too long,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'm not sure when I'll go back,&equo; she answered. 
 She was in her late thirties, lean and strong, too neat and plain of feature ever to have been beautiful but her large grey eyes were intelligent and full of wilfulness and energy. 
 As soon as she got home she couldn't resist bringing up Moran's name. 
 &bquo;They say he's no ornament,&equo; her mother said carefully. 
 &bquo;I was talking to him in the post office.&equo; 
 She saw her mother look at her sharply. 
 &bquo;They say he's one sort of person when he's out in the open among people &mdash; he can be very sweet &mdash; but that he's a different sort of person altogether behind the walls of his own house.&equo; 
 &bquo;People talk too much about other people round here. 
 Often the talk is just ignorant malice.&equo; 
 Her true instinct was always to work behind the usual social frameworks: family, connections, position, conventions, those established forms that can be used like weapons when they are mastered. 
 Behind them she could work with a charm and singleness of attention that became so smooth as to be chilling, except for the friendliness of her large grey eyes. 
 The Rosenblooms had long known that they could take her with them anywhere in society. 
 These skills she could not use with Moran. 
 Her interest was too great. 
 She had too little time. 
 There was too much of the outlaw about him that held its own fascination. 
 Painfully and in the open she had to make all the running. 
 She came to the post office the next evening, and the next, buying tea and a comb of honey from Lizzie the first evening, posting a letter at Annie's counter on the Friday, waiting till the mail was sorted, each time managing to leave the post office alone with Moran. 
 They stood talking a long time at the crossroads before separating but he didn't offer to see her over the weekend. 
 She was able to conceal her restlessness, the pacing about, her dream of a different beginning to a new life, her impatience with the old shapes that she had used for too long; she was not young and was old enough to foresee failure. 
 She was able to will her longing into an unexamined haze but she could not stay away from the post office on Monday. 
 Once she appeared regularly others could observe her. 
 Annie and Lizzie were friendly with Moran. 
 They often discussed his family together and how hard it was for a single man to bring up children alone. 
 Soon they began to greet Rose's evening presence in their small clean-scrubbed room with sarcasm. 
 This unseemly chase after love was viewed with a hostile, overall amusement, for &bquo;love&equo; had left Annie and Lizzie &mdash; and many far younger &mdash; long behind and it was valued like jaundice. 
 This courting dance seemed to them a grotesque parody. 
 Crossing the road to water the bed of dahlias and moon daisies and nasturtiums she kept on the grass margin across the road from her door at the beginning of the village, Mrs Reynolds paused to watch Rose make her way round by the bridge to the post office and muttered venomously, &bquo;There's no fool like an old fool', as if confronting the worst part of her own nature. 
 In the two bars, and on the bridge and football field where the men gathered in the evening, there were the coarse shouts of &bquo;Sink log! 
 All find their way to the dirty hollow &bquo;, followed by cheers that echoed out like firing. 
 In the full face of the ridicule she went to the post office evening after evening, ridicule she willed not to see or notice. 
 &bquo;Are you expecting some important letter, Rose?&equo; her mother inquired anxiously. 
 &bquo;No, Mother. 
 It just takes me out of the house for an hour or two.&equo; 
 Then her married sister arrived at the house with news of her real reason for going each evening to the post office. 
 &bquo;You'd think she'd have more sense at her age. 
 She'll just become a laughing stock if she's not that already.&equo; 
 &bquo;I hear you're seeing Mr Moran at the post office,&equo; her mother ventured delicately. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 He goes there every evening.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wouldn't be too bothered about him. 
 And besides he has a large family of his own already.&equo; 
 &bquo;We're just friends, Mother,&equo; she gave that little laugh and smiled the charming smile that hid the pure will. 
 &bquo;All we ever talk about is his children. 
 He is very worried about them.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd be careful if I were you, Rose. 
 It doesn't need much to start people talking.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then let them talk.&equo; 
 Yet Moran made no move towards her, promised nothing, gave no hint of any reciprocation of interest, lent her no support. 
 All he did was remain at the point where they first met. 
 He neither went towards her nor withdrew and she saw it could not go on like that. 
 One evening as they were forced to shelter from a sudden shower under the thick line of sycamores, she said, &bquo;You should call to the house some evening, Michael. 
 I know they'd like to meet you.&equo; 
 &bquo;You know how hard it is to get away, Rose.&equo; 
 &bquo;Still, you know you're welcome,&equo; she smiled and left him and he was not surprised when she did not come to the post office the next evening or the evening after. 
 He knew that he would have to go to her if he wanted her. 
 As a young man he had been pursued by many women; that he secretly despised them did not lessen his attractiveness but in later years his large family and increasing years had hung about him with a weight as great as any deformity: but he would never risk exposing himself as Rose had. 
 Rose Brady's attention had been as unexpected as it had been sudden and welcome. 
 It was as if she had fallen out of a generous sky. 
 She was much younger than he, strong, not unpleasant to look at. 
 He had reason to suspect that she had saved money and his life could glow again in the concentration of her attention. 
 It was unlikely that such luck would fall his way again no matter how long he waited. 
 That same week he told Maggie out of the blue that he wanted to see her alone. 
 With great nervousness and alarm she followed him to his room. 
 &bquo;There's something very important that concerns all the family that I want to discuss seriously.&equo; 
 He felt garbed in the robes of responsibility and consequence as he spoke. 
 &bquo;What would you think if I were to bring someone new into the family?&equo; 
 Maggie looked quickly at him but without comprehension. 
 &bquo;If I was to fill your mother's place &mdash; the Lord have mercy on her soul &mdash; with someone new,&equo; he amended. 
 &bquo;If I were to marry again.&equo; 
 Whether it was the sudden mention of her mother or the whole emotional portentousness with which he had charged the scene Maggie burst out sobbing. 
 This continued for a long time during which he shuffled his feet uncomfortably, controlling his immediate impulse to shout at her to be quiet. 
 After a while she discovered that she could hide comfortably behind the shelter of sobbing. 
 &bquo;A woman would be able to help you in ways that I can't,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There's only so much any man can do on his own.&equo; 
 &bquo;Whatever you think, Daddy.&equo; 
 She knew that whatever she said would be irrelevant anyhow. 
 &bquo;You think it would be for the best then?&equo; 
 He was impatient now to conclude the whole scene. 
 &bquo;If you think it's for the best, Daddy.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know it'll be for the best. 
 I wouldn't even think of it for a minute if it wasn't best for everybody. 
 After all these years it'll be a real house and home again. 
 It'll be a place that will always be there for you to come back to.&equo; 
 She could not wait to tell Sheila and Mona. 
 Both girls thought she was joking at first but when she recounted word for word the interview she had had with Moran they exploded into wild laughter. 
 They did not tell their younger brother. 
 Though they loved him as if he were their own child they left him out of all things that mattered in the running of the house. 
 Who is she?&equo; 
 They asked when they were quiet again. 
 &bquo;It must be Miss Brady that's home from Glasgow.&equo; 
 &bquo;She'd never have him.&equo; 
 &bquo;They say she's wild after him. 
 She goes every evening to the post,&equo; and they began to laugh again at what they saw as a mocking mirror of their own flowering. 
 Moran took the small blue Ford out of the shed after Mass on Sunday, tested the engine and tyres, then washed the car down, dried it and waxed it till it shone. 
 At three o'clock he drove the four miles to Rose Brady's house. 
 The lane into the house was narrow and winding with too many gates so he parked the car on the wide grass margin beside the platform for the creamery cans. 
 The car could not be seen from the house because of the shelter of trees. 
 He walked slowly down the lane, enjoying the feel of the pressed brown suit he so seldom wore, this new excitement midst the humdrum of his life. 
 It was as if he were going to the edge again of something fresh and new. 
 Rose saw him at the heavy red gate of the yard. 
 So intense was her relief at seeing him come that she stood stock-still in the doorway. 
 As relief spread to pure pleasure she waved and came towards him across the yard like a young girl. 
 She was already by his side before she thought of how her face and hair must look. 
 She had gone through bad days. 
 In the evenings, with painful vividness, she had seen the small congregation in the post office, the mail van crossing the bridge, Annie sorting the letters, the stretch of empty road to the sycamores where they had stopped to talk. 
 Such was the restlessness of her longing to go there that she had had to struggle to stick to her resolve. 
 She could not go. 
 She had given signs enough, perhaps too many, and she could only wait. 
 Now he had come to her. 
 Though her mother disliked him the custom of hospitality was too strict to allow any self-expression or unpleasantness. 
 Her brother he had met before and the two men talked about the year's haysaving and the price they expected for sheep and wool and cattle. 
 A white cloth was spread on the table, homemade bread and jam, a fresh apple tart. 
 Tea was made. 
 He praised the bread and the blackcurrant jam. 
 &bquo;The garden is choked every year with blackcurrants. 
 The birds get most of them. 
 Your girls should come here to pick them next summer.&equo; 
 &bquo;That would be too much,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If the girls don't pick them they'll just waste in the grass or go with the birds,&equo; the mother said as amiably as she could. 
 &bquo;Are you interested in football?&equo; her brother asked. 
 &bquo;Not so much but it's nice to see a good match.&equo; 
 &bquo;Would you like to hear the end of the game then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure I would,&equo; and her brother turned on the Sunday game he had been listening to when Moran entered the yard. 
 After ten minutes or so it seemed to end satisfactorily. 
 Moran was unassertive and attentive in the few minutes they discussed the game afterwards. 
 &bquo;Now that I've eaten and drunk my fill it's time for me to beat away,&equo; he said after about an hour. 
 Rose's mother and brother shook his hand politely. 
 She got a cardigan and walked him all the way out the lane. 
 Above them rose the poor fields, littered with rock and gorse, the lower slopes of the mountain. 
 Below the lane was the small lake ringed with reeds. 
 &bquo;Are there fish in the lake?&equo; 
 &bquo;There used to be plenty &mdash; small perch, and pike, and eel &mdash; but they never seemed to grow to any size.&equo; 
 When they went through the first gate at the bottom of the hill they were out of people's eyes for the first time since they had met. 
 There were just the whitehorn and brier of the hedges, the green ridge of the lane inside the wheel tracks, the wild strawberries starting to darken on the banks. 
 &bquo;Was I all right in the house?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;You were perfect. 
 You could not have been better. 
 It was lovely that you came,&equo; and she took his hand and raised her mouth eagerly to his as he bent to kiss her for the first time. 
 &bquo;I'm not used to going out,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You'll have to come to meet my crowd now.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd love to meet them.&equo; 
 &bquo;One of these evenings I'll arrange it. 
 I hope they'll know how to show manners.&equo; 
 Responsibility visibly descended on him again as he walked. 
 &bquo;I didn't know you had a car,&equo; she said with surprise when they reached the road. 
 &bquo;I don't take it out very often but it's nice to have, to know that you can go anywhere you want if you feel like it.&equo; 
 Secretly she exulted that he had the car. 
 It was just one more sign of his separateness from the people around who would buy a cow or a few more fields. 
 In these parts a car was prized more than flowers or an orchard or a herb garden: it was the symbol of pure luxury. 
 She walked slowly back down the lane, savouring the rich peace, the strength she felt. 
 This narrow lane was dear to her. 
 Sleepless in Scotland she had walked it many times in her mind. 
 The wild strawberries, the wiry grasses, the black fruit of the vetches on the banks were all dear presences. 
 Out of the many false starts her life had made she felt they were witnessing this pure beginning that she would seize and make true. 
 No longer, exposed and vulnerable, would she have to chase and harry after happiness. 
 From a given and confident position she would now be able to move outwards. 
 &bquo;Where's Tom?&equo; she noticed her brothers absence as soon as she got back to the house. 
 &bquo;He said he was going over to O'Neill's for an hour.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't meet him on the lane.&equo; 
 &bquo;He must have just gone over the fields.&equo; 
 After a long silence the mother said, &bquo;That was a bit of a surprise visit.&equo; 
 &bquo;I asked him to call if he was ever this way. 
 Did you like him at all?&equo; 
 &bquo;If he suits you I'm sure he suits me. 
 He has a large family.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't see how that can be held against him.&equo; 
 &bquo;You used to have many admirers,&equo; the mother changed. 
 &bquo;The admirers are all gone.&equo; 
 Both women were glad to let the conversation drop. 
 They would not change. 
 She did not go to the post office the next evening or the next. 
 No longer had she the ache of longing for that stretch of white road leading round to the sycamores. 
 By coming to the house on Sunday Moran had made that stretch of road like all roads. 
 She would go on the day she judged best. 
 She did not want to appear either too eager or too casual. 
 All her nervousness came back as she approached the post office just ahead of the mail van. 
 The small room was full. 
 Moran was there and smiled on her and spoke. 
 Whether Annie and Lizzie had heard of the Sunday visit or had marked her absence wasn't clear but they appeared almost conciliatory compared to previous days. 
 She did notice too that Moran was more carelessly dressed than she remembered and hadn't shaved for at least a day. 
 It was as if he were truculently stating that he had gone as far towards her as he was prepared to go. 
 Outside the post office he made no apology for the roughness of his appearance but he was as friendly and charming as he had always been. 
 &bquo;There's a concert in the hall on Sunday. 
 It'd be easier if we met my troops for the first time at the concert,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Then you can come to the house any time you want to afterwards.&equo; 
 &bquo;Whatever you think is best.&equo; 
 She was glad to do whatever he wished. 
 On Saturday night at the end of the Rosary Moran said, &bquo;I want to offer a final prayer to God that He may guide your father on the right course,&equo; and they all knew, even to the boy Michael, to what he was referring. 
 &bquo;There's a very special person I want you to meet at the concert tomorrow. 
 I hope you'll all like her. 
 She's Miss Brady,&equo; he told them as soon as they rose from their knees. 
 They made vague general noises about how glad they would be to meet her. 
 &bquo;I want everybody dressed in their best clothes,&equo; Moran demanded. 
 Sunday evening the girls were shining and the boy wore his blue Confirmation suit with black shoes. 
 They were all excited and a little ashamed. 
 They had seen Miss Brady in the distance at Mass but they had never met her. 
 At the hill beyond the village he gave them money. 
 &bquo;Go up to the front row and keep two chairs,&equo; he directed and then left them. 
 Though the hall was almost empty they weren't forward enough to go into the very front seats so they entered the seats three rows back, claiming two extra chairs with folded coats. 
 They knew all the people entering the hall, and those that occupied seats close to them smiled and spoke to them. 
 They felt nervous and compromised. 
 They were even more uncomfortable when their father entered with Rose just as the full hall was waiting for the curtain to go up. 
 With extreme slowness Moran walked Rose to the seats. 
 The girls suffered agonies of exposure as they waited for them to reach their seats. 
 Slowly and solemnly Moran introduced Rose to each member of the family in turn. 
 The small group became more the centre of attention than the stage itself. 
 Rose's tact was never more evident. 
 If she was nervous it remained hidden and in a few minutes she had put each of the sisters completely at ease, their shame and apprehension gone. 
 The concert was amateur. 
 A group of girls decked with medals danced. 
 A blue-suited man sang. 
 An old man played several airs on an accordion. 
 The drama society put on a short comic sketch. 
 As all the performers were either related to or known to the audience each act was greeted with loud and equal applause. 
 At the interval Rose nodded and smiled to the people about her. 
 Moran made no gesture, did not even look around him. 
 At the end of the concert he took the four children back to Great Meadow. 
 Rose sat in the front seat. 
 At the house he invited Rose in but she refused with the excuse that it was too late. 
 As she said goodnight to them in turn she managed by some technique of charm or pure personality to convey to each of them that they were important to her in their own light. 
 They left her feeling completely enclosed in a warm glow of attention and to Moran's repeated questions over the next days were able to say genuinely how much they liked her. 
 In fact, the response was so uniform and repetitious that it started to irritate him before long. 
 Rose wished that they could be married quickly but now that there was nothing in the way of it Moran grew cautious and evasive. 
 She saw the way it was and moved differently. 
 An invitation through Moran brought the three girls and the boy to her house for a long Sunday. 
 As it came through Rose he encouraged it as much as he would have discouraged visits to any other neighbouring house. 
 She showed them the small lake in its ring of reeds, took them to the first slopes of the mountain, rigged up a fishing rod for Michael and took him to the part of the lake she used to fish as a girl, and soon he was shouting out in glee as he missed the ravenous little perch or swung them out over his head on to the bank. 
 Rose's mother showed the girls the house and the fowl and farm animals, including a pet goat who wouldn't let Rose milk her unless she sprayed herself with a perfume that the mother used. 
 They were given a sumptuous tea and invited back any time they felt like coming. 
 Within a few weeks they were regular visitors. 
 As Moran encouraged them they could go without guilt. 
 To leave the ever-present tension of Great Meadow was like shedding stiff, formal clothes or kicking off pinching shoes. 
 Old Mrs Brady never took to Moran but she grew very fond of the children. 
 Until she won their trust their manners were deferential, identical to the old-fashioned manners of her own youth. 
 They were always eager to help or run messages and she enjoyed making tea and cakes for them. 
 Rose, with the same tact as she had brought them to the house, was careful to absent herself from these occasions as much as possible. 
 She sent them alone with sandwiches and drinks to where her brother worked in the fields and he too grew glad of their quiet company in the empty fields. 
 In a few months Rose's home place and Moran's house were almost interwoven. 
 Half-jokingly, but with a certain edge, Moran said that Great Meadow was so deserted that he himself might have to remove himself before long to her house. 
 No one was ever able to see quite how it had all been managed. 
 Rose's tact was so masterful that she resembled certain people who are so deeply read that they can play with all ideas without ever listing books. 
 &bquo;What do you think of Rose marrying your father?&equo; the old woman grew confident enough one day to ask Maggie in her good-humoured, forceful way. 
 &bquo;We're glad.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you sure you don't mind?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, we're glad.&equo; 
 &bquo;People say he used beat ye.&equo; 
 &bquo;People said that because Daddy never let us mix with them.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did he not beat ye?&equo; 
 &bquo;No&hellip; now and again when we were bold, but like any house.&equo; 
 Shame as much as love prompted the denial. 
 &bquo;How is it that your brother left and never came home?&equo; 
 &bquo;Daddy and Luke could never get on. 
 They were too alike,&equo; and when Maggie began to cry Rose's mother saw that she had pressed too hard. 
 &bquo;She'd have been better with someone nearer her own age,&equo; the old woman murmured to herself. 
 &bquo;She had many admirers. 
 Many admirers. 
 Many admirers. 
 I don't understand it at all.&equo; 
 Maggie brushed away her tears as she listened. 
 She thought the mutterings were comical. 
 To her both Rose and Moran looked equally old. 
 Rose's mother was not reassured by Maggie's answers but she liked her and didn't want to endanger their young presences about the house. 
 Michael had become her favourite. 
 He was the least inhibited. 
 He would chatter away egotistically to her for hours. 
 Sometimes she would give him money on the sly and he would help her with chores. 
 Often they would quarrel and he would stay away from the house for a while; but he was never able to stay away for long. 
 When he would return, the two would feel even closer than before the quarrel and they would soon be moving about the yard together, chatting away. 
 For all her encouragement to them to come at any time to her house, Rose herself was wary of calling at Great Meadow. 
 Whenever she did she never stayed for long. 
 When Moran pressed her to come for the Christmas dinner, she refused. 
 &bquo;It wouldn't look right to be out of my own house on Christmas Day,&equo; she answered; that they were not yet married was left unsaid. 
 &bquo;I'll come some time early on St Stephen's Day,&equo; she said instead. 
 The girls wished that Rose could be with them on Christmas Day. 
 As always, it was a very long day to get through. 
 Moran ate alone in front of the big sideboard mirror, waited on apprehensively by the girls. 
 After he had eaten, they had their own dinner at the side table. 
 It was the first Christmas anybody had even been absent and Moran seemed to be painfully aware of Luke's absence. 
 &bquo;You'd think he'd come for the Christmas or even write but never a word, no thought for anybody except himself,&equo; and it cast a deep shadow when they tried to imagine what kind of space enclosed Luke in England during the same hour, but they weren't able to imagine it. 
 It was too much like facing darkness. 
 Afterwards the radio was played. 
 The Rosary was said. 
 The pack of cards was taken out. 
 Everybody made for their beds early. 
 It was a gladness to slip down into the sheets knowing the day had ended. 
 The next morning Rose came in with presents. 
 She had bought a silk tie for Moran, blouses and deep plum-coloured sweaters for the girls, a pair of white football boots for Michael. 
 Because of his dislike of gifts, the girls watched carefully how Moran would receive the silk tie. 
 &bquo;Thanks, Rose,&equo; he said and placed it on top of the radio. 
 &bquo;Don't you like it?&equo; 
 She smiled a little, taken aback by the spareness of the response. 
 &bquo;It cost far too much and is far too grand for an old fellow like me.&equo; 
 The response was positively exuberant. 
 Just as Rose was preparing to leave, the wren-boys arrived on the Arigna coal lorry. 
 There must have been twenty men on the back of the lorry in masks and carnival costumes. 
 With the money they gathered from different houses, they bought ham, loaves and butter, lemonade, whiskey and half-barrels of porter to hold a big dance in Kirkwood's barn that night. 
 Everyone around was invited. 
 As soon as they came into the house a melodeon started to play and two fiddles took up in perfect tune; then bagpipes played alone. 
 Young men danced Rose Brady and the girls round the kitchen. 
 There were whoops and cheers, mock kissing attempts, challenges to put names on the masked faces and then a song. 
 &bquo;The two of you will have to come to the Major's tonight,&equo; the man who gathered the money said. 
 &bquo;Maybe we will,&equo; Moran responded. 
 &bquo;Maybe we will.&equo; 
 Moran gave them a pound, Rose took a red ten-shilling note from her handbag and they left in the same whirl as they had entered, dancing and singing all the way out to the lorry. 
 An eerie silence descended over the house as the lorry left for the next house. 
 &bquo;Are we going to the dance?&equo; 
 Rose asked Moran as she left. 
 &bquo;What would be seen there but the same old crowd making fools of themselves?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's Christmas.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you want to go?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd like to very much.&equo; 
 He went reluctantly. 
 There was an air of great jollity and freedom, even of outright licence, at the wren-boys' dance in Kirkwood's barn. 
 Moran didn't feel easy. 
 The air of friendliness was the kind that he disliked most. 
 The wren-boys who had gone from house to house on the lorry all day were now scrubbed and combed, playing away cheerfully on raised planks. 
 Even though there was a sharp frost outside, couples could be seen stealing away from the dance and returning a half-hour or so later, always a little crestfallen until they had danced again, danced their way back into good cheer. 
 Moran hardly spoke to anybody and reacted roughly to any jostling as he danced with Rose on the warped floor. 
 Rose was anxious, feeling that he had lived in the stone house with too much responsibility for too long. 
 He had not been able to go out and be at ease with people. 
 What she did not know was that Moran, with his good looks and military fame, had once been king of these barn dances and now that he had neither youth nor fame would not take a lesser place. 
 He would not take part at all. 
 Rose had come to the dance to claim their place as a couple among the people in this loose, Christmas carnival. 
 She was determined to remain. 
 She smiled and chatted with everybody around her. 
 She took tea. 
 She danced with neighbours and men she had gone to school with. 
 She forced Moran to dance and by the night's end she was worn out by the single effort. 
 He had given her no help throughout the night but it did not lessen her love. 
 In the car, leaning her head on his consenting but exasperated shoulder, she said, &bquo;We don't have to be like the rest of the people round here. 
 We don't have to go out together for years. 
 There's nothing in the way of our getting married, and I love you, Michael.&equo; 
 &bquo;When do you want to get married?&equo; 
 &bquo;This year. 
 Before the summer. 
 If there was something in our way it would be different.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's the children to consider.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd not be in the way of the children. 
 I could only be of help.&equo; 
 &bquo;When do you want to be married then?&equo; 
 &bquo;We have nothing to stop us before Lent.&equo; 
 &bquo;It'd be too rushed,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It'll have to be after Lent.&equo; 
 &bquo;The week after Easter then.&equo; 
 She set the time and was too happy to notice that he was more like a man listening to a door close than one going towards his joy. 
 &bquo;We'll have the wedding breakfast in the Royal. 
 There won't be need to invite many,&equo; she proposed carefully some days later. 
 &bquo;I don't want anything in an hotel.&equo; 
 &bquo;We have to have some place for a reception,&equo; she argued. 
 &bquo;Haven't we two houses of our own?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't think they'd like that at home. 
 As soon as I mentioned an Easter wedding they brought up the Royal.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Bradys don't have that much money to scatter at the Royal Hotel.&equo; 
 &bquo;They don't mind that. 
 It's just one day.&equo; 
 &bquo;There'll be no hotels. 
 We are too old and poor for that.&equo; 
 &bquo;It'll be thought strange. 
 Everybody does it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Because everybody goes and jumps in the river is no reason why we have to go and jump in the same river.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know that what you say makes sense, love,&equo; she placed her hand on his arm. 
 &bquo;They'll not like it at home. 
 They'll not understand. 
 Can't we go to the Royal for them?&equo; 
 &bquo;Let them start to understand,&equo; he said as he took her hand in a playful threat. 
 &bquo;We can always have ham and tea and whiskey for anybody that wants it in our house. 
 That way we'll have less travelling to do afterwards.&equo; 
 As a play it was close to perfect. 
 The honour of the reception always fell to the family of the bride. 
 It would not do for it to take place in Moran's house and Moran would not go to a hotel. 
 The Bradys would have to agree to hold it in their house or not at all. 
 Eventually Rose persuaded them to hold the reception in the house. 
 They did not like it, argued against it &mdash; argued against the whole match &mdash; but she held firm. 
 There would be fewer people to cope with that way, and she wasn't young any longer. 
 The night before the wedding the girls hardly slept at all and they did not chatter to one another as they usually did until they found sleep. 
 In the morning their father would be married. 
 Another woman would come back with him into the house. 
 It did not matter that it was the Rose they had grown to like. 
 The life they had come to know so well for so long as it slipped by changelessly would be irrevocably altered: it was like a death or a wounding and brought all the wonder and fear and awe of change. 
 Each of their own lives would have to take up another uncertain beginning. 
 Moran himself slept fitfully beside their brother. 
 Now and again he would reach a hand over to the boy but he slept deeply through the night. 
 It would be his last night of sleep in the room. 
 The small boxroom with a single bed was already prepared. 
 Tomorrow night Rose would lie in the boy's place. 
 When he did wake, Moran reached his hand across to the coarse shirt over the shoulder and gently began to knead the muscles. 
 &bquo;It's the last time we'll wake in the morning together.&equo; 
 &bquo;The last time,&equo; the boy repeated uncertainly. 
 &bquo;You know what day it is?&equo; 
 &bquo;Your wedding day.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's the end of one life. 
 The beginning of a different life. 
 I believe it's in the best interest of all the family. 
 We can only pray and hope it'll turn out for the best.&equo; 
 The boy was always more uncomfortable with these essays in tenderness than any sudden harshness. 
 He sat up immediately in the bed to listen. 
 &bquo;They're up,&equo; he announced. 
 &bquo;They're all up. 
 Do you want me to draw the curtain, Daddy?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 Not yet,&equo; Moran said but the boy had already drawn free from the kneading hand and was struggling into his clothes. 
 He closed the door softly behind him and was gone without another word. 
 Moran lay on in bed till very late. 
 One of the girls had to come to the door to call him. 
 &bquo;Your clothes is aired and ready, Daddy. 
 It's time to get up.&equo; 
 He came in in his old trousers and nightshirt. 
 They were already dressed for the wedding, wearing little bits of borrowed fineries they were afraid he would notice. 
 The boy was wearing his blue suit, shining black shoes, white shirt and blue tie and his fair hair was oiled. 
 The kettle was boiling and Maggie poured the water into the basin in front of the shaving mirror. 
 He failed to notice the borrowed things that the girls wore, looking around him instead in dumb bafflement: it was a wedding day, a shining moment in his life, and, except for the dressed children, it could be any ordinary day. 
 His clothes were draped on the back of a chair in front of the fire. 
 The clothes horse was drawn up. 
 The steaming water was waiting in the basin before the mirror. 
 He felt a low cry of frustration against the inadequacy of life break silently within, and ripple out. 
 &bquo;What time is it?&equo; he demanded fiercely. 
 &bquo;It's just ten, Daddy. 
 There's only an hour till the Mass.&equo; 
 &bquo;I think I know it takes an hour to get from ten to eleven.&equo; 
 The sarcasm seemed to relieve him a little and he took the black strop of leather from its nail and opened the razor. 
 The blade flashed as it was drawn over the leather. 
 He lathered and started to shave. 
 They all fixed in a pure tenseness of watching as he shaved but he did not cut himself. 
 He washed and towelled himself dry. 
 &bquo;Your uncle didn't put in an appearance yet?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, there's no sign of him.&equo; 
 When he started to dress in front of the fire the two older girls turned away and when he looked for a collar stud the boy ran to attend. 
 Once Maggie caught a glimpse of him in the shaving mirror, trouserless but with his shirt and socks on and in spite of her fear she was tempted to laugh. 
 Trouserless men looked absurd in socks. 
 He dressed with great care. 
 He had refused to buy any new clothes for the wedding but the brown suit had been brushed and pressed. 
 The white shirt was starched and the shoes shone. 
 He went back to the shaving mirror to comb his hair and when he had finished he pushed a folded handkerchief into his sleeve with quiet satisfaction. 
 &bquo;Of course, that uncle of yours didn't have the manners to write, never mind the decency to come; but I've long learned never to expect anything from an ass but a kick.&equo; 
 The increasing nervousness showed in his voice. 
 &bquo;I don't know why people can't write a note.&equo; 
 They were all dressed. 
 There was nothing to do but wait for their uncle. 
 Moran had decided that they would go to the church in their uncle's big old car. 
 They hadn't seen him in months. 
 Moran had written to him and assumed that he would come. 
 Several times Moran went to the front door to look towards the road. 
 He changed his handkerchief from his left sleeve to his right. 
 &bquo;I should have learned by now never to rely on anybody.&equo; 
 &bquo;He must have got a puncture,&equo; Michael offered. 
 &bquo;You'd think he'd allow for that on a day the like of this.&equo; 
 &bquo;He might never have thought&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;You can rely on that. 
 The man's head was designed to keep his ears apart. 
 Anyhow we can't wait much longer.&equo; 
 He went out and started the small blue Ford, backed it out of the shed and left the engine running. 
 &bquo;We better be going. 
 We can't wait about like this any longer. 
 God, O God, did you ever see such people!&equo; 
 They all crammed into the car. 
 &bquo;You'd think people would have heed, but no heed, never any heed, no care for anybody else,&equo; he complained as he drove; but before the bridge he startled them by driving the car into the space in front of McCabe's and announcing that they would walk the rest of the way through the village. 
 &bquo;We're early. 
 This way we'll meet the man on his bloody way if he's coming.&equo; 
 Michael sniggered behind Moran as soon as they were on the road together but it drew such a quelling look from Maggie that he went quiet. 
 All the girls were deeply ashamed. 
 No one had ever seen a bride or groom walk to their wedding; even the very poor found a car for that day and in the old days they had gone by trap or sidecar. 
 Fortunately the bridge was empty as was the long road of sycamores to the church in its dark evergreens. 
 After crossing the bridge Moran checked his watch and to their infinite relief started to walk quickly. 
 They wished their uncle would come and they could vanish into the huge car but no motor could be heard in the direction from which he would come. 
 They walked on in silence. 
 It had not rained for a week and the white dust of the road started to dull the shine of all the shoes. 
 At the end of the long road Reynolds' was the first house they had to pass and they started to cringe into themselves behind Moran even before they got to the little hedge of privet above the whitewashed stones. 
 Mrs Reynolds was in the doorway, almost ready herself to go to the wedding &mdash; she never missed a wedding or a funeral &mdash; but seeing the procession that approached withdrew back into the shadows of the room to observe better the old cockerel go by followed by his dismayed pullets. 
 &bquo;And the bloody madman is walking to his own wedding with all the children,&equo; she said, more in sympathy with the children than in laughter. 
 Each step seemed to take an age as they passed the forge. 
 Only the boy looked at the two men sledging a length of iron on the outside anvil. 
 Then they had to brace themselves to pass the few people standing along the church wall. 
 None of them looked up as they passed. 
 Moran did not turn to speak. 
 There were curious villagers waiting for the wedding to begin in the back seats of the church but they did not look to left or right. 
 All the children blessed themselves from the fount and went straight up to the altar. 
 It was like the beginning of healing to get into their seats and kneel beside Moran, no longer exposed. 
 None of the bride's party had come yet. 
 The priest came through the sacristy door in soutane and surplice and Moran went up to the rails. 
 &bquo;The best man hasn't come. 
 Would the boy do?&equo; 
 Moran asked. 
 They both looked towards Michael. 
 &bquo;He's a bit young,&equo; the priest said. 
 &bquo;We can get one of the bride's brothers to stand in.&equo; 
 Then a car was heard pulling up at the gate; either the bridal car or their uncle had come. 
 All turned to look back at the door as the footsteps approached on the flagstones. 
 The relief showed instantly on their faces as the small round figure of their uncle filled the doorway. 
 He hurried up the aisle of the church, showing his palms by way of apology when he reached his place. 
 There were dirt and grease stains on both palms with bits of grass stuck to the grease. 
 &bquo;I thought you'd never get here,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;I got broke down,&equo; he whispered apologetically as he slipped in beside Moran, putting his oily hand on the head of one of the girls. 
 From the altar the priest nodded a smile of recognition to the best man. 
 Finally Rose's family filled into the pew across the aisle and Rose came behind on her brother's arm. 
 There was no music. 
 The priest beckoned Moran forward. 
 He motioned to them when to kneel, to stand, to be seated, when to take the ring, the gold and silver, to &bquo;repeat these words after me'. 
 A sister of Rose's sobbed briefly. 
 The girls' eyes filled with tears. 
 A man in the side-chapel took photos. 
 The bride and groom returned together to the front seat for the nuptial Mass. 
 Everybody except the best man went to the rails for Holy Communion. 
 Outside, in the clear day, as the couple stood beneath the bell rope, a small box of confetti was thrown. 
 They stood together, separately, and then in groups for photos that one of Rose's sisters took, headstones and evergreens rising out of the background of thick laurel. 
 The uncle's car was an old Ford V8 with enormous fins and there was more than enough room for all of them in the back. 
 The bride and bridegroom rode in front. 
 &bquo;You gave us all a start,&equo; Rose said happily. 
 &bquo;For a few minutes our hearts were in our mouths. 
 We thought you weren't coming but it's wonderful you got here.&equo; 
 &bquo;I got this puncture. 
 She just went flat,&equo; he turned his grease stained hands upwards again on the wheel as he drove. 
 &bquo;You'll have hot water for them as soon as we get to the house.&equo; 
 &bquo;You must have left it very tight to get here so late,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;You never think you'll get anything.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course nobody ever thinks. 
 That goes without saying.&equo; 
 &bquo;Everything is fine now. 
 Their uncle got here and that is all that matters,&equo; Rose smoothed, turning to chat to the girls in the back. 
 The car was too large for the lane so they walked in. 
 The April Saturday was mild, with just the faintest threat of showers. 
 Everywhere in the low briers and hedgerows was the clatter and singing of small birds. 
 The little lake below the house was still ringed with its winter reeds, the colour of rained-on wheat. 
 Everybody waited to eat until the priest arrived. 
 He was the only one to risk his small car on the lane. 
 He would have to leave early on a sick call, he said. 
 There were no letters or telegrams to be read out. 
 The priest, with folded hands and closed eyes, recited Grace, and the meal began: soup served by a daughter of the same sister of Rose's who had been taking the photos; chicken and ham, with salad. 
 The wedding cake was cut. 
 The priest made a short speech praising the families and the outstanding simplicity of the wedding feast. 
 There was too much emphasis nowadays on show, on Rolls-Royces and big hotels, wasteful, expensive display. 
 It was pleasant to see people returning to the old ways, he said. 
 There was wine and whiskey and beer for the toast. 
 The best man said he wasn't used to speeches, he nearly hadn't arrived at all himself, but he just wanted to thank Father here for all he had done and the people of the bride here for this feast and all the trouble they had gone to, and then he proposed the toast. 
 The brother who had given Rose away responded even more briefly and soon afterwards the priest left. 
 Gradually the wedding breakfast was breaking up. 
 One of Rose's tall silent brothers went around the tables with a bottle of wine and a bottle of whiskey but they drank sparingly. 
 When the best man cleared his throat and announced that he was going to fix the puncture he had before leaving, all Moran's children followed him out to the road and stood around as he got levers and patches and solution. 
 When he came back to the house he refused to take a chair or a drink. 
 &bquo;I better be making a start. 
 I have a run to do yet this evening.&equo; 
 &bquo;We might as well go with you so,&equo; Moran said and Rose got up eagerly. 
 She had all her going-away things packed. 
 The remaining things she could come back for any day. 
 Her mother and sisters and brothers all embraced her but she showed no emotion. 
 The whole household walked them out to the big Ford at the end of the lane. 
 They embraced Rose a second time and everybody shook hands. 
 At the bridge Moran and Rose changed to their own small blue car and the uncle drove the children home. 
 He waited at the house until the bride and groom arrived but he could not be persuaded to enter the house. 
 The whole of Rose's family walked back down the lane to their house in silence. 
 &bquo;She had many admirers,&equo; the old mother said as they neared the house in a tone of puzzlement and of mourning. 
 &bquo;Many admirers&hellip; 
 Many admirers&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing could stop her. 
 She was determined on it. 
 Now it's her life,&equo; her married sister said gently. 
 &bquo;I hope she'll be lucky,&equo; the wife of one of the brothers said without any feeling. 
 The four tall brothers walked in stooped silence but their wives chatted agreeably. 
 A daughter held the mother's hand in sympathy. 
 When they entered the house one of the brothers reached for the bottle of whiskey and poured four large glasses for the first time that day. 
 They were a very close family but in the years to come no gathering or wedding, not even simple gatherings, was ever held in any one of their houses. 
 They went to big hotels as if determined never again to experience anything like this house wedding in all their mortal lives. 
 Neither Rose nor Moran ever attended any of the gatherings. 
 They were never invited. 
 They would not have gone if they were. 
 &bquo;I don't know about anybody else but I'd love a nice hot cup of tea,&equo; Rose said as soon as they were all in the house. 
 At once she set a tone that would not be easily wrested from her. 
 Moran watched in silence. 
 All the girls helped her to get the fire going, spread the tablecloth, put out the cups and plates, laughing and whispering and bustling about as they showed her the places and secrets of the kitchen, the room that was now her room. 
 There was a touch of hysteria in the frantic busyness. 
 Their exaggeration of the small tasks betrayed that they were more involved with Moran than in what they were doing. 
 Sometimes they would accidentally bring it to crisis by letting a plate or cup smash on the floor. 
 As they showed her the house, Rose seemed to enter completely into the terrible awareness of Moran now sitting in the car chair meditatively rotating his thumbs about one another. 
 On this his wedding day he seemed strangely at peace. 
 It was as if he needed this quality of attention to be fixed upon him in order to be completely silent. 
 During the entire day he felt a violent, dissatisfied feeling that his whole life was taking place in front of his eyes without anything at all taking place. 
 Distances were walked. 
 Words were said. 
 Rings were exchanged. 
 The party moved from church to house. 
 All seemed a kind of mockery. 
 It was as if nothing at all had happened. 
 He was tired of wrestling with it, brooding about it, sometimes looking at his bride's back with violent puzzlement; but now, surrounded by this covert attention, he was glad to let it go: he would take tea like a lord with his family. 
 Was there milk enough or a little too much in his tea? 
 They could add more tea once he had taken a few sips. 
 He didn't take sugar any more. 
 Would he have the plain bread or the bread with the blackcurrant jam or a piece of the apple tart? 
 &bquo;The tea was all right,&equo; he protested and they knew he was far from displeased. 
 &bquo;It'll do for the man it is for. 
 I've already eaten enough today to do a man for a week. 
 I'd explode if I was to put as much as one morsel more in my mouth.&equo; 
 Rose and the girls smiled as the tea and the plates circled around him. 
 They were already conspirators. 
 They were mastered and yet they were controlling together what they were mastered by. 
 &bquo;Thanks,&equo; he put his cup away. 
 &bquo;I'll go out to the fields for a few hours to try to work off some of this.&equo; 
 He changed into his old clothes and left. 
 They washed and dried the cups and plates and put them away. 
 A quiet that was close to let-down replaced the wild bustle of the preparation but they were enjoying each other's company, the animal comfort of other presences, banishment of loneliness. 
 Outside, Moran thinned several small ash trees from the hedge that ran along the foot of the orchard. 
 He liked mechanical things and he was pleased that the chainsaw he had had to dismantle several times in the past seemed to run perfectly. 
 &bquo;It must have been the timing that was out all along.&equo; 
 The felling, trimming, cutting, absorbed him completely and because of the ferocity of the running chain it demanded his undivided attention. 
 Michael followed him out and helped pile the waste branches into heaps for burning and then they stacked the scattered lengths of the firewood. 
 Inside, the girls showed Rose all over the house. 
 After that she began to tell them a little about her life in Scotland, particularly her life with the Rosenblooms. 
 &bquo;Sometimes at the weekend Mr Rosenbloom would come and ask me to iron his shirts. 
 He had hundreds of shirts and why he ever wanted me  to iron them I'll never know. 
 Mrs Rosenbloom nearly always found out about it and she would be mad that he had taken me from my work with the children. 
 There'd be a battle royal all morning. 
 After lunch he'd go into the city and come back with a whole armful of roses, the price of many shirts.&equo; 
 &bquo;Would she be satisfied with that?&equo; the girls demanded greedily. 
 &bquo;She'd hold out for a while but it would always be made up after he came back with the roses. 
 He'd swear of course that he'd never again steal me from my proper duties with the children. 
 She'd cut and arrange the roses. 
 They'd dress up then and go out to dinner to some restaurant, laughing and talking together as if nothing at all had happened.&equo; 
 &bquo;What would they be talking about, Rose?&equo; 
 &bquo;About what they'd eat that evening in the restaurant and what wines they'd drink. 
 You would wonder how they could eat at all after the amount of time they spent talking about food.&equo; 
 When Moran came in from the field with Michael he was in high good humour. 
 &bquo;This man and me are after slaughtering a few trees out there.&equo; 
 Even the way he hung his hat was expansive, drawing the whole room in. 
 The girls knew how soon this mood could change if it was not fully entered into. 
 &bquo;I'm fit to tackle a live child again,&equo; he joked as they prepared to eat. 
 &bquo;Now Michael, that's hardly necessary,&equo; Rose scolded gently. 
 &bquo;It might not be but it's the godalmighty truth,&equo; he asserted so playfully back that the whole table laughed. 
 After the tea he suggested that they play cards, already shuffling the cards he took from the sill. 
 They played Twenty-one; the scores were kept on the inside of a Lyons Green Label tea packet. 
 Moran was the best player and mostly won but that night he attributed his winnings to the cards he had been dealt. 
 They knelt to the Rosary. 
 Moran began, &bquo;Thou, O Lord, wilt open my lips,&equo; as he began every evening. 
 There was a pause when he ended the First Mystery. 
 All their eyes were turned on Rose but she, with just a glance at Moran, took up the Second Mystery as if she had been saying it with them all the nights of their lives. 
 After the prayers they went up in turn and kissed Moran and then Rose who returned their kisses warmly, and they slipped away to their rooms. 
 The boy was going to the boxroom and was clearly excited at possessing a room of his own for the first time. 
 He too kissed Rose. 
 Rose and Moran sat on alone in the room. 
 They were not silent but only spoke after long intervals and what they said did not carry to the upstairs rooms. 
 When the couple did go to their bedroom the girls became even more wide awake than before. 
 They tried not to breathe as they listened. 
 They were too nervous and frightened of life to react to or put into words the sounds they heard from the room where their father was sleeping with Rose. 
 Rose was up at seven the next morning, an hour before the house usually stirred. 
 When the girls came down they found the room already warm, the fire lit, the kettle steaming. 
 Rose was preparing to bring Moran a mug of tea. 
 &bquo;Daddy wouldn't hear of having his breakfast in bed,&equo; she said with a small engaging laugh. 
 &bquo;But he might as well have this before getting up.&equo; 
 She made an enormous difference in the house. 
 Since their mother's death it had been run by Maggie, with bits of help from Mona and Sheila. 
 At first their mother's sister had come from time to time but she and Moran had quarrelled. 
 He was not interested in food other than it should not cost too much and wasn't raw. 
 The girls had never been taught to cook or housekeep. 
 They could cook vegetables and meat simply, deal with eggs and bacon and porridge, and they were able to bake and housekeep, learning as they went along. 
 They didn't need to know much more. 
 Rose changed everything. 
 She was able to organize her day so that even though she seemed to be less harassed than Maggie the meals were always delicious and on time. 
 Then she began to clean and paint the house room by room. 
 Moran complained about the unnecessary disturbance though it was the cost that he was secretly worried by. 
 She pointed out that the plaster would soon fall away without paint. 
 Whenever he complained too much about cost she went and bought what she needed with her own money. 
 That he disliked even more. 
 In the end he always gave what she asked but he resented the giving. 
 She did not seem to mind and she was inordinately careful. 
 &bquo;You know Daddy,&equo; she would laugh defensively with the girls. 
 All the children helped her redecorate the house. 
 When it was done the whole house had acquired a new pleasantness and comfort. 
 Even Moran had to admit it though he dismissed it as well by saying that it would have done well enough for the likes of him as it had been. 
 What was also clear was that the house's need of Maggie had disappeared. 
 Rose brought this up very gently to Moran. 
 &bquo;She'll have a roof over her head as long as I'm above ground,&equo; he responded aggressively. 
 &bquo;She'll have that as long as I'm here too but I think she should have more.&equo; 
 &bquo;What more does she want?&equo; 
 &bquo;She's almost nineteen. 
 The day is gone when a girl waits around till some man needs a wife. 
 She should have the protection of some work.&equo; 
 &bquo;What job of any good would she get here? 
 She left school at fourteen. 
 She wasn't all that good at school either.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's a shortage of nurses in England. 
 I always regretted I never trained. 
 I've spoken to her and she's interested.&equo; 
 &bquo;You were very quick off the mark, weren't you? 
 A lot of our people go wrong in England.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was there for a while,&equo; she said pointedly but she was careful not to press too much. 
 She had heard already from the girls how Luke had tried to get Maggie to go to England to learn nursing against Moran's fierce opposition, how their older brother and Moran had fought, and when Maggie yielded to Moran and stayed, Luke had gone on his own without telling his father. 
 She waited until Moran himself had to come to talk about Maggie. 
 Sheila and Mona were at the convent secondary school, Michael was finishing national school. 
 Maggie had so little to do during the day that she spent much of the time chatting and gossiping with Rose. 
 She would pretend to be busy whenever she heard Moran come. 
 &bquo;Daddy hates to see anybody sitting down doing nothing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Poor Daddy,&equo; Rose would smile with affection after he had gone again. 
 Moran began to see how little Maggie had to do in the house and that she needed money for dances and clothes now. 
 He suspected Rose was letting her have some of her own money. 
 &bquo;Do you still think that Maggie should go to England to nurse?&equo; he asked eventually. 
 &bquo;I do. 
 She'd always have something to fall back on. 
 You never know what is going to happen in a life. 
 It's a profession.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 I was very much against it when that brother of hers wanted her to go. 
 Of course he wasn't interested in what was good or bad for the girls. 
 He was doing it against me.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm far from against you, you know that. 
 I want it for her own good. 
 This place will always be here for her to come home to as long as I breathe.&equo; 
 Because of the shortages of girls for nursing, many ads were appearing in the daily papers. 
 Rose helped Maggie to write away for the forms and then to fill in the forms when they came. 
 To Moran's surprise she was accepted for training by five hospitals. 
 The whole house sat down after the Rosary one evening to pick the hospital she would go to. 
 They chose the London Hospital because a few people from around were already working there. 
 After they had reached that decision Michael began to cry and would not be consoled. 
 &bquo;They'll all be gone soon,&equo; he said to their humorous questioning. 
 &bquo;It's awful. 
 It's not fair.&equo; 
 When Rose suggested that they write to Luke to ask him to meet Maggie off the train when she got to London Moran was furious. 
 &bquo;Didn't the hospital say they'd have her met?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's her brother. 
 It'd be natural for him to meet Maggie.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's not a natural bone in that gentleman's body. 
 I wrote him several times and all the answer I ever got was I'm well-here-and-I-hope-you-are-well-there. 
 Is that natural after all the years of bringing him up?&equo; 
 &bquo;These things happen in families and then they pass,&equo; Rose said quietly. 
 &bquo;An accident happens or a wedding. 
 People are forced back together again. 
 I know how you feel, Daddy, but maybe it is better not to take too strong a stand. 
 Things are always changing. 
 You never know how they'll turn out. 
 If you do the generous thing, then you can't be blamed.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can be blamed. 
 Make no mistake about that. 
 In this case I can always be blamed.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know it is hard but it's better to try to ignore what is said against you. 
 If you can ignore it then you'll know that you have nothing to blame yourself for. 
 Do nothing in a hurry.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you want me to do?&equo; 
 &bquo;I think it'd be better if you  wrote him,&equo; Rose suggested. 
 &bquo;I'll probably just earn another kick in the teeth but I'll do it none the less.&equo; 
 Moran spent a long time composing the letter. 
 He could not resist adding recrimination. 
 Luke answered the letter by telegram. 
 Seldom a telegram came and nobody liked to see one come to a house. 
 The small green envelope with the harp generally came with news of sudden death. 
 Moran's high-strung nervousness, which was usually concealed by slow, deliberate movements, was all on show as he looked about him like an animal in unknown territory and tore open the envelope. 
 When he read DELIGHTED TO MEET MAGGIE STOP LOVE STOP LUKE he had to struggle to contain himself. 
 He was barely able to conceal his fury until after he paid the postman whom he walked all the way out to the iron gate. 
 &bquo;Maybe he just sent the telegram and a letter will come after a few days,&equo; Maggie tried to soothe. 
 &bquo;No letter will come. 
 It leaves me like a right fool out in the bloody open.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know how you can say that, Daddy. 
 You did everything decent,&equo; Rose said. 
 &bquo;Why in the name of the Saviour do you have to put your ignorance on full display,&equo; he turned on her. 
 &bquo;You don't know the first thing about the business, woman.&equo; 
 That the telegram was formally polite and completely ignored his own attack infuriated Moran. 
 After he had read it aloud he crumpled the note up in his fist and thrust it into the fire as if the very sight of it was hateful. 
 &bquo;Well, at least you'll have someone to meet you at Euston,&equo; Rose said softly to Maggie who already knew that she would be met. 
 &bquo;Of course he'll meet her. 
 He'll meet her to try to turn her against me,&equo; shouted Moran. 
 &bquo;He was polite enough,&equo; Rose suggested. 
 &bquo;What do you know about it? 
 What in hell do you know about anything?&equo; 
 He swept his hat from the dresser and crushed it on his head and went outside as if he might break down the doors in his way. 
 Soon they heard the sharp, swift sounds of the axe as he started to split lengths of branches into firewood. 
 She stood stunned. 
 He had never spoken to her like that before. 
 In the spreading lull she looked towards the others. 
 They had all been there when Moran read out the telegram. 
 part of her expected to find them laughing at his wild reaction beyond all sense and to return her to the blessed normal but when she looked around only Maggie stood in the room. 
 The others had slipped away like ghosts. 
 Maggie was kneading currants through dough in a glass bowl on the sideboard, as absorbed in the kneading as if all of her life were passing through the pale dough. 
 &bquo;Where have they all disappeared to all of a sudden, Maggie?&equo; 
 &bquo;They must have gone out,&equo; Maggie looked up from the dough with intense attention. 
 &bquo;I thought I might find them laughing at poor Daddy,&equo; Rose said, allowing her own shock and fear to ease out in the nervous laughter, but Maggie's face remained pale and serious. 
 &bquo;I don't know what happened to Daddy,&equo; Rose said. 
 &bquo;Sometimes he gets like that.&equo; 
 &bquo;I never saw him so upset.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's not been like that for a long time.&equo; 
 &bquo;Was he often like that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Before, but not for a long time now,&equo; Maggie admitted reluctantly and Rose did not want to learn any more. 
 She had already more than she wanted to deal with. 
 In the silence the sound of the sledge could be heard thudding on stones from one of the near fields. 
 He had already abandoned the timber. 
 Often when talking with the girls she had noticed that whenever Moran entered the room silence and deadness would fall on them; and if he was eating alone or working in the room setting the teeth of a saw, putting a handle in a broken spade on a wet day, taking apart the lighting plant that never seemed to run properly for long &mdash; they always tried to slip away. 
 If they had to stay they moved about the place like shadows. 
 Only when they dropped or rattled something, the startled way they would look towards Moran, did the nervous tension of what it took to glide about so silently show. 
 Rose had noticed this and she had put it down to the awe and respect in which the man she so loved was held, and she was loath to see differently now. 
 She had chosen Moran, had married him against convention and her family. 
 All her vanity was in question. 
 The violence Moran had turned on her she chose to ignore, to let her own resentment drop and to join the girls as they stole about so that their presences would never challenge his. 
 He came in very late, wary, watchful. 
 The cheerfulness with which Rose greeted him he met with a deep reserve. 
 She was unprepared for it and her nervousness increased tenfold as she bustled about to get his tea. 
 Sheila and Mona were writing at side tables; Michael was kneeling at the big armchair, a book between his elbows, as if in prayer, a position he sometimes used for studying. 
 All three looked up gravely to acknowledge their father's presence; but, sensing his mood at once, they buried themselves again in their school work. 
 &bquo;Where's Maggie?&equo; he demanded. 
 &bquo;She went to visit some friends in the village.&equo; 
 &bquo;She seems always to be on the tramp these days.&equo; 
 &bquo;She's going around mostly saying goodbye to people.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sure she'll be missed,&equo; he said acidly. 
 Rose poured him his tea. 
 The table was covered with a spotless cloth. 
 As he ate and drank she found herself chattering away to him out of nervousness, a stream of things that went through her head, the small happenings of a day. 
 She talked out of confusions: fear, insecurity, love. 
 Her instinct told her she should not be talking but she could not stop. 
 He made several brusque, impatient movements at the table but still she could not stop. 
 Then he turned round the chair in a fit of hatred. 
 The children were listening though they kept their eyes intently fixed on their school books. 
 &bquo;Did you ever listen carefully to yourself, Rose?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If you listened a bit more carefully to yourself I think you might talk a lot less.&equo; 
 She looked like someone who had been struck without warning but she did not try to run or cry out. 
 She stood still for a long moment that seemed to the others to grow into an age. 
 Then, abjectly, as if engaged in reflection that gave back only its own dullness, she completed the tasks she had been doing and, without saying a word to the expectant children, left the room. 
 &bquo;Where are you going, Rose?&equo; he asked in a tone that told her that he knew he had gone too far but she continued on her way. 
 It galled him to have to sit impotently in silence; worse still, that it had been witnessed. 
 They kept their heads down in their books though they had long ceased to study, unwilling to catch his eye or even to breathe loudly. 
 All they had ever been able to do in the face of violence was to bend to it. 
 Moran sat for a long time. 
 When he could stand the silence no longer he went briskly into the other room. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Rose,&equo; they heard him say. 
 They were able to hear clearly though he had closed the door. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Rose,&equo; he had to say again. 
 &bquo;I lost my temper.&equo; 
 After a pause they thought would never end they heard, &bquo;I want to be alone,&equo; clear as a single bell note, free of all self-assertiveness. 
 He stayed on in the room but there was nothing he could do but withdraw. 
 When he came back he sat beside the litter of his meal on the table among the three children not quite knowing what to do with himself. 
 Then he took a pencil and paper and started to tot up all the monies he presently held against the expenses he had. 
 He spent a long time over these calculations and they appeared to soothe him. 
 &bquo;We might as well say the Rosary now,&equo; he announced when he put pencil and paper away, taking out his beads and letting them dangle loudly. 
 They put away their exercises and took out their beads. 
 &bquo;Leave the doors open in case Rose wants to hear,&equo; he said to the boy. 
 Michael opened both doors to the room. 
 He paused at the bedroom door but the vague shape amid the bedclothes did not speak or stir. 
 At the Second Glorious Mystery Moran paused. 
 Sometimes if there was an illness in the house the sick person would join in the prayers through the open doors but when the silence was not broken he nodded to Mona and she took up Rose's Decade. 
 After the Rosary, Mona and Sheila made tea and they all slipped away early. 
 Moran sat on alone in the room. 
 He was so engrossed in himself that he was startled by the sound of the back door opening just after midnight. 
 Maggie was even more startled to find him alone when she came in and instantly relieved that she hadn't allowed the boy who had seen her home from the village further than the road gate. 
 &bquo;You're very late,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The concert wasn't over till after eleven.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you say your prayers on the way home?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, Daddy. 
 I'll say them as soon as I go upstairs.&equo; 
 &bquo;Be careful not to wake the crowd that has to go to school in the morning.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll be careful. 
 Good night, Daddy.&equo; 
 As on every night, she went up to him and kissed him on the lips. 
 He sat on alone until all unease was lost in a luxury of self-absorption. 
 The fire had died. 
 He felt stiff when he got up from the chair and turned out the light and groped his way through the still open doorway to the bed, shedding his clothes on to the floor. 
 When he got into bed he turned his back energetically to Rose. 
 She rose even earlier than usual next morning. 
 Usually she enjoyed the tasks of morning but this morning she was grateful above all mornings for the constancy of the small demanding chores: to shake out the fire, scatter the ashes on the grass outside, to feel the stoked fire warm the room. 
 She set the table and began breakfast. 
 When the three appeared for school they were wary of her at first but she was able to summon sufficient energy to disguise her lack of it and they were completely at ease before they left for school. 
 When Moran eventually appeared he did not speak but fussed excessively as he put on socks and boots. 
 She did not help him. 
 &bquo;I suppose I should be sorry,&equo; he said at length. 
 &bquo;It was very hard what you said.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was upset over that telegram my beloved son sent. 
 It was as if I didn't even exist.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know, but what you said was still hard.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well then, I'm sorry.&equo; 
 It was all she demanded and immediately she brightened. 
 &bquo;Its all right, Michael. 
 I know it's not easy.&equo; 
 She looked at him with love. 
 Though they were alone they did not embrace or kiss. 
 That belonged to darkness and the night. 
 &bquo;Do you know what I think, Rose? 
 We get too cooped up here sometimes. 
 Why don't we just go away for the day?&equo; 
 &bquo;Where would we go to?&equo; 
 &bquo;We can drive anywhere we want to drive to. 
 That's the great thing about having a car. 
 All we have to do is back it out of the shed and go .&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you think you can spare the day?&equo; 
 She was still careful. 
 &bquo;It's bad if we can't take one day off,&equo; he said laughingly. 
 He was happy now, relieved, pleased with himself, ready to be indulgent. 
 He backed the Ford out of the shed and faced it to the road. 
 Maggie had risen and was taking breakfast when he came in. 
 &bquo;Is there anything you want, Daddy?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not a thing in the wide world, thanks be to God.&equo; 
 She was relieved to hear the tone. 
 &bquo;You'll have the whole place to yourself today. 
 Rose and myself are away for the day.&equo; 
 &bquo;When do you think you'll be back, Daddy?&equo; 
 Rose had left out his brown suit and shirt and tie and socks and he had started to dress. 
 &bquo;We'll be back when you see us. 
 We'll be back before night anyhow,&equo; he said as he tucked his shirt into his trousers, hoisting them round his hips. 
 &bquo;I'm holding everybody up,&equo; Rose fussed self-effacingly. 
 She looked well, even stylish in a discreet way, in her tweed suit and white blouse. 
 &bquo;Daddy looks wonderful. 
 I hope I'm not too much of a disgrace,&equo; she laughed nervously, moving her hands and features in one clear plea to please. 
 &bquo;You look lovely, Rose. 
 You look like a lady,&equo; Maggie said. 
 &bquo;I'm bound to be taken for the chauffeur,&equo; he laughed out, mispronouncing the word with relish but he was not corrected as he hoped. 
 &bquo;There'd never be a fear of that,&equo; she said with feeling. 
 They set off together in the small car, Rose's girlish smiles and waves only accentuating the picture of the happy couple going on a whole day's outing alone together. 
 Maggie watched the car turn carefully out into the main road and then she went and closed the gate under the big yew tree. 
 Moran drove purposefully. 
 The car crossed the shallow racing river in Boyle, passed the grey walls of the roofless monastery, and it kept on the main road leading across the Curlews. 
 Rose hadn't asked him where they were driving to; she didn't care anyhow: it was enough to be with him in the day. 
 &bquo;O'Neill and O'Donnell crossed here with cannon and horses on the way to Kinsale in one night,&equo; he told her as the car was climbing into the low mountains. 
 &bquo;They were able to cross because the black frost made the ground hard as rock that night.&equo; 
 He seemed to relax more after he had spoken, to be less fixedly focused on the empty road. 
 &bquo;I suppose some of your own nights when you were on the run were not unlike that,&equo; she ventured into what they had never spoken of. 
 &bquo;No. 
 They were different,&equo; he said not unkindly but it was clear he didn't want to talk about those nights. 
 &bquo;Would you like to go to Strandhill? 
 When the children were young we went there every year.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd love to see the ocean,&equo; she said. 
 She didn't care where she went or what she saw as long as he was pleased and she was with him. 
 Now most of her pleasure and all of her pain flowed through him. 
 For her there was always a strange excitement in his presence of something about to happen. 
 Nothing was ever still. 
 She felt inordinately grateful when he behaved normally. 
 &bquo;That's the calm sea,&equo; he pointed out the inlet that ran to Ballysadare as they came along the narrow twisting road into Strandhill. 
 &bquo;We all used to swim there. 
 It's more private and safe. 
 The rough sea at the front is dangerous. 
 There was hardly a summer that three or four weren't drownded.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was very good of you to take them to the sea. 
 Hardly anybody else about except the schoolteachers ever thought of taking their children to the sea.&equo; 
 &bquo;I always tried to do the best or what I thought was best. 
 It is not easy to know sometimes. 
 When you think you're right that is the very time it'll fly back in your teeth. 
 Luke wouldn't come to the sea in the finish.&equo; 
 &bquo;All boys growing up get that way,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;We had to stop selling the turf then,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;What turf?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;We took a lorry load of turf for our own fire and sold the rest in bags door to door.&equo; 
 He pointed out the pebbled street in front of park's Guest House where they had first stayed and a bungalow they had taken between the church and the golf links. 
 &bquo;We sold the turf from there. 
 It paid for the entire holiday. 
 There was a great take on it. 
 That whole summer was wet. 
 Everybody wanted a fire because of the rain. 
 We made money on that holiday.&equo; 
 There were only two other cars at the front and they rolled to a stop alongside the plinth on which the antique cannon stood pointing out to sea like some deep-chested mongrel. 
 They sat for a long time in silence watching the Atlantic crash down on the empty shore. 
 &bquo;We haven't come to the sea in three years. 
 I suppose that's how you get old. 
 You find yourself not doing a whole lot of things you once did without a thought.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're not old,&equo; Rose said. 
 &bquo;The mileage is up,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You can't turn it back.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wasn't sure what you'd want to do,&equo; Rose said with the utmost caution, &bquo;and I brought a flask of tea and sandwiches just in case.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's great.&equo; 
 He had been dreading having to look for a place for lunch. 
 He knew no cheap place here any more and he would have to search one out like a blind man. 
 &bquo;We can go anywhere we want to afterwards,&equo; he added in case he was appearing stingy. 
 Rose opened the flask, spreading the sandwiches on the dashboard. 
 &bquo;Bless us, O Lord, and these Thy gifts&hellip;&equo; 
 He ate and drank with relish, pointing out a fishing boat leaving Sligo harbour, remarking how Rosses point across the bay had safe bathing while here you couldn't stand in the water without feeling the currents pushing the sand out from under your feet. 
 &bquo;But it's dull at the old point, Rose. 
 The waves there are small even in a storm. 
 Here you get the real feel of the ocean. 
 That's what I always used to say to the troops.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a wonderful place,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I feel like a new man,&equo; he said as she put the flask away and combed the crumbs from the dashboard into her cupped hand. 
 They both took up together, &bquo;We give Thee thanks, O Almighty God, for all Thy bounty which we have received through Christ Our Lord who liveth and reigneth world without end, amen.&equo; 
 Cheerfully they got out of the car into the open day and went down the rocks to the strand and then out to the tideline. 
 They walked along the tide's edge for a mile. 
 Rose picked some sea shells and rounded stones and Moran put bits of dilsk in his pocket. 
 They turned back before reaching the roofless church in the middle of the old graveyard out on the edge of land. 
 &bquo;The locals still bury there,&equo; he told her. 
 They came back along the path that threaded a way between the sand dunes. 
 Some bees were already crawling on the early clover. 
 &bquo;This place will have a lot of tents and caravans and people in a month's time.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's nicer walking here than on the strand. 
 There's a lovely spring in the turf.&equo; 
 &bquo;Except you have to watch for the rabbit holes. 
 You could twist an ankle like nobody's business.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aren't we lucky to have met and to have this whole day to ourselves and the sea and the sky,&equo; Rose said enthusiastically. 
 &bquo;It's our life,&equo; he said harshly. 
 She looked at him carefully. 
 He was changing less predictably than the tide. 
 Soon he would need to vent the anger she felt already gathering, and she was the nearest person. 
 Her life was bound up completely with this man she so loved and whose darkness she feared. 
 They should go home before the whole day was about them in ruins. 
 &bquo;Maybe we should go to one of the hotels for tea or icecream?&equo; he asked fretfully, as if somehow sensing her withdrawal. 
 As if to point out that they were not entirely alone, a man with a white terrier came towards them from behind the sandhills. 
 He carried a pale bone which he kept throwing out into the dune for the terrier to retrieve. 
 Without speaking he lifted his cap as they passed. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; she said firmly. 
 &bquo;I think we should go home. 
 It's easy to spoil the day by trying to do too much.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you sure, Rose?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm certain.&equo; 
 &bquo;We must do this more often, Rose,&equo; he said as he backed the Ford out from the ornamental cannon. 
 There were now four people on the long wide stretch of strand. 
 They looked small and black against the width of rushing water and pale sand. 
 &bquo;We can but of course it won't be as easy for us to get away once Maggie is gone,&equo; she said it in a pleasant way that sometimes humoured him and sometimes could put his teeth on edge. 
 This time it seemed to please him. 
 He would not have liked it if she seemed to be saying that they could get away any time they wanted to. 
 Anything easy and pleasant aroused deep suspicion and people enjoying themselves were usually less inclined to pay attention to others. 
 Before the marriage Maggie had been little more than a drudge round the house. 
 Rose set her free. 
 She saw that she had pretty clothes like other girls her age and a little money of her own for going out. 
 She listened to the stories of small triumphs brought back from the dances. 
 Maggie had never received so much attention. 
 With this new confidence she went willingly out to Moran in the fields. 
 She helped him with chores, gathering branches or rounding up cattle, or just stayed to keep him company while he worked. 
 Soon she was leaving and it was easy for him to be charming. 
 He never scolded except in passing fits of irritation. 
 His instinct was to draw her closer to him. 
 &bquo;Life is a peculiar venture,&equo; he was fond of saying. 
 &bquo;You never know how low or high you'll go. 
 No matter how you rise in the world never look down on another. 
 That way you can never go far wrong.&equo; 
 &bquo;Daddy is great,&equo; Maggie said with pride when she came in. 
 Rose remained silent but the pleasure showed in her features. 
 &bquo;When he's nice he can be that way,&equo; Mona looked up gravely from her school work. 
 &bquo;It'd be even nicer if he was always that way,&equo; Sheila added tartly. 
 &bquo;Maybe we are not always that good ourselves if we look closer,&equo; Rose countered quickly. 
 Michael looked up from where he knelt on the floor in front of the old armchair, his books spread out on the chair. 
 When he discovered their attention was not on him he went back to his books. 
 On Maggie's last night in the house Rose gave a little party. 
 The night before she had stayed out late saying goodbye to all her friends. 
 Her last night belonged to the house. 
 Moran said the Rosary early, at the end of which he added a prayer for the girl's safekeeping in the world she was about to enter. 
 He said it with a heavy emphasis which brought them all close to tears but the mood was soon scattered by all the joyful preparations Rose had planned. 
 Bowls of the clear chicken soup they loved were put on the table. 
 A roast chicken followed, with pale stuffing, a hot gravy and masses of floury roast potatoes. 
 Lemonade was poured into glasses and the meal was toasted. 
 &bquo;This is America at home,&equo; Moran boasted. 
 Bowls of trifle followed. 
 &bquo;We'll burst!&equo; 
 He and everybody were happy. 
 Rose wanted to leave the washing-up for morning but the girls insisted on getting it over with. 
 Then they played cards until stifled yawns and missed tricks told them that tiredness was now king. 
 The three who had to go to school in the morning went to bed. 
 After a decent interval Maggie followed them. 
 &bquo;You'll have a long day tomorrow,&equo; Rose encouraged. 
 &bquo;God bless you and keep you safe,&equo; Moran said. 
 Maggie looked at him with the light of love as she kissed him good night. 
 He was her first man, her father, as she faced for London and the further opening of her life. 
 The next day on the platform of the little station he was very fine. 
 He dressed carefully in the brown suit he had been married in and he bought the ticket with quiet authority. 
 As he wasn't friendly with anyone present he had no occasion to speak to others waiting about on the white gravel. 
 Rose knew many of the people on the platform even though she had spent half her life in Scotland and she responded to each greeting with warmth, careful to watch that her friendliness did not grate on Moran. 
 Maggie was silent. 
 She too, in spite of the dances and concerts they had been attending lately, knew far fewer people at the station than Rose. 
 Maggie looked on this isolation he had built up around them as distinction and strength. 
 In her heart she felt that Rose was a little common in knowing so many people. 
 Moran stood erect and apart on the platform, totally separate as he gazed at the hill across the tracks where the stationmaster's brown horse and a few cattle and sheep grazed. 
 Rose kept touching Maggie as they waited, sometimes kneading her shoulder and arm. 
 &bquo;Look at the fine girl we have. 
 You need have no fear facing the world,&equo; as if she were already clearly seeing her happiness and her children in the fullness of the years. 
 As the diesel train came in and people were already picking up suitcases from the platform Moran turned and kissed her as if it were a last good night to all the nights she had come to him. 
 &bquo;Remember, the house you left will always be your house. 
 While Rose and I are here you'll have one home that you can always come back to.&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll be looking out for you,&equo; Rose said as they kissed. 
 Maggie wept. 
 As the train pulled out of the station she searched back for Moran's face among the crowd and found it and waved. 
 &bquo;Do you think that gentleman will meet her?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course he'll meet her. 
 He's not going to let her wander round London on her own. 
 He's her brother.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wish I could be as certain but I asked the hospital to meet her as well just in case. 
 If for no other reason, he'll probably meet her just to get back at me.&equo; 
 Even on very wet days Moran seldom hung about the house. 
 He had converted one of the outhouses into a sort of workshop where he tinkered with a collection of small engines, antique lighting plants and water pumps that he had bought for next to nothing at country auctions over the years. 
 He had neither the patience nor method to understand properly how they worked and he would not bow to any instruction other than his own perusal of certain manuals and textbooks. 
 Quite often though, through various hit-and-miss applications, he would get one of the engines running. 
 Then he would be very happy, his natural energy spreading that happiness out to everything around him. 
 Rose shared those sort of days with him even more extravagantly than if the days had been her own. 
 There were many other days when nothing would work for him and every space on the long blackened workbench would be covered with a confusion of parts. 
 Those days Rose dreaded and fretted through and it was a kind of peace to turn to the two girls and the boy. 
 She had won them over completely. 
 They would chat away to her about their day until they got down to the schoolwork. 
 Both girls were exceptionally good at school and fond of study. 
 In their earlier years schoolwork had been a haven. 
 They felt safe and protected when they studied. 
 Michael too was good at school but only did the minimum of study. 
 After less than a half-hour of sitting alone he would grow restless, scatter his books untidily about the table and disappear outside. 
 &bquo;Are you finished so soon?&equo; 
 Rose would call teasingly but he would have gone with a slam of the door. 
 &bquo;If he's finished you'd think he'd have the manners not to leave the table in such a mess,&equo; the girls would grumble; but they or Rose would always put his books away. 
 Though tall and strong for his age he had no liking for hard physical work and he was slow to give Moran any help on the land. 
 He had several pets: a grey cat Maria, Shep the sheepdog who went everywhere with him over the fields, several birds including a lame pigeon that he loved to tease Maria with; and one spring he reared a wild duck from the egg of an abandoned nest and was upset for weeks after the October day it finally flew away. 
 Rose started a small flower garden in front of the house soon after coming and there he could often be found, at first helping Rose, then taking over and extending the garden across the footpath until all the green inside the thorn hedge was alive with colour: little beds of forget-me-nots and sweet william, rows of wallflowers that gave out their fragrance in the evenings, formal lilies and roses. 
 His way with birds and animals seemed to go out to all flowers and plants, too. 
 This both amused and irritated Moran. 
 &bquo;I suppose one of these days you'll be getting yourself a skirt.&equo; 
 &bquo;Trousers are far handier,&equo; he was able to smile it aside. 
 &bquo;If you grew something like carrots it'd make some sense. 
 It'll be a long time before you'd eat any of those flowers.&equo; 
 &bquo;They're fun to look at.&equo; 
 &bquo;Looking won't get you far in this world,&equo; Moran said. 
 But hidden in the boy's answering nod was an equal contempt for Moran's work, which he regarded as nothing short of voluntary slavery. 
 Brought up from infancy by a screen of girls, and now growing confidently in Rose's shade, he escaped the fear of Moran. 
 After Maggie went away Moran took up his old habit of going to the post office. 
 As he no longer wrote to relatives or old war comrades, he explained stiffly, &bquo;I'm expecting word from my daughter in London. 
 Young people abroad can be quite heedless nowadays.&equo; 
 Evening after evening passed by without Annie the postmistress finding a letter for him in the grey bag the mail van brought in. 
 Eventually when the letter came in its blue envelope with the pious SAG printed across the seal, the hands so firm holding a gun or tool shook as he took it. 
 Annie was annoyed by the abrupt way he turned away and went out. 
 Outside on the footpath he stood like a stone reading the letter. 
 people leaving the post office spoke to him but he did not hear. 
 When at last he moved away he still combed through the letter as he walked. 
 By the time he got to the house he knew each phrase by heart. 
 &bquo;She stirred herself at last and wrote,&equo; he said as he handed Rose the letter. 
 &bquo;She'd have a lot to get used to at first,&equo; Rose said absently as she scanned through the letter. 
 Luke had met her at Euston. 
 They had gone to the hospital by the Underground. 
 All the student nurses each had a small room with a desk and bed in the nurses' home. 
 There were several Irish girls in the class and two girls from near Ballymote. 
 She was just beginning to get used to the wards and the classes. 
 There was a big park with a lake not far from the hospital. 
 Last Sunday Luke had come out. 
 They had gone to the park. 
 Boats were for hire by the hour and they had rowed on the lake. 
 Afterwards they had tea in a wooden caf&eacute; beside the lake. 
 She sent lots of love and a whole line of kisses. 
 &bquo;You'd think after all that that she'd say what his lordship was actually doing in London.&equo; 
 &bquo;Still, he met her and went to see her on Sunday.&equo; 
 &bquo;He'd do that. 
 Yes. 
 He'd do that all right.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe she didn't get round to asking him much about himself yet,&equo; Rose said just to break the brooding silence. 
 &bquo;Maggie may be slow but she's not that slow,&equo; he said impatiently. 
 &bquo;Your man warned her not to say anything about what he is doing. 
 That's why she wrote nothing.&equo; 
 Carelessly he let a page of newspaper fall on the cement beside the table and spilled his beads from the small purse into his palm. 
 He prayed absentmindedly, never able to fall into the even, sleepy drone and hum of &bquo;Our Father&equo; and &bquo;Hail Mary'. 
 He even made a number of slips and repetitions that on a different evening he would have been quick to reprimand in others. 
 Before he had put his beads away he was in search of pen and paper and spent till late writing to Maggie. 
 He had a clean, bare style; when writing he seemed to be able to slip the burden of his personality as he could never do face to face. 
 The three children had gone to bed and Rose was waiting by the fire by the time he was satisfied enough with what he had written to seal the envelope. 
 With Maggie in London, Sheila and Mona had more light to themselves and were better able to come into their own. 
 Sheila was more than good at school, impulsive and assertive, yet she withdrew into a shell at a hint of opposition. 
 After school Rose loved to draw her out, to tease out of her reckless opinions and to watch her quick mind wheel and tack as she strained to defend what was usually insupportable. 
 Mona was quiet, hardworking and extremely stubborn, anxious to be agreeable; but once she took up a position &mdash; or got caught in one &mdash; she was obstinately immovable and this had often brought her into conflict with Moran. 
 Rose's coming to the house had smoothed their lives and allowed them to concentrate everything on school and study, which, above all, they saw as a way out of the house and into a life of their own. 
 Eventually a letter arrived from London in response to Moran's exasperated inquiries about his elder son. 
 The information could hardly have been more ordinary. 
 Maggie had seen him nearly every day at first. 
 Now she saw him much less. 
 When he first came, he had worked on various building sites. 
 Now he worked in offices of the Gas Board, and was studying accountancy, mostly at night, though the Board gave him one day off each week to attend classes. 
 Also he had become friendly with a Cockney man, older than he, who had been a french polisher and who now sold reproduction furniture to antique shops from a van. 
 He mentioned some plan they had of buying old houses and converting them into flats for sale. 
 &bquo;You see, it didn't take him long to find the riff-raff,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;He seems to be working hard enough and studying,&equo; Rose tried to reassure him as always from a careful distance. 
 &bquo;He'd do that all right but look at what he's getting mixed up &bquo;It may be just talk,&equo; she ventured edgily. 
 &bquo;How does anything start but in talk?&equo; 
 Outwardly it had been the easiest and quietest of times that the house had ever known but the unease did not go away. 
 Increasingly Moran could be seen in the fields staring idly at some task he should be completing. 
 The fierce rush of hay was over. 
 The apples were ripening on the trees in the garden. 
 Their eyes were turning towards winter. 
 Rose was beginning to go regularly again to her mother's house. 
 The cane basket on the handlebars of her bicycle was always full on leaving the house and full again with things from her mother's house when she came back. 
 &bquo;I see there's hardly a day nowadays that Rose doesn't go to her relations,&equo; Moran said to Sheila and Mona one Saturday they brought him a flask of tea into the fields. 
 &bquo;She seldom goes empty-handed.&equo; 
 Rose had asked them to take the flask out to him at four. 
 They knew she took bread to her mother, jam she had made from the blackcurrants at the foot of the garden but the basket always came back heavy with fresh eggs, a bunch of carrots from the bog, plums that they loved, sweet hard yellow apples. 
 &bquo;We don't know,&equo; Sheila answered carefully. 
 &bquo;How do you not know? 
 Haven't you both eyes in your heads?&equo; 
 &bquo;She brings things back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Only stuff they'd have to throw out otherwise!&equo; 
 They knew that the accusation was untrue. 
 They remained obstinately silent, abject looking as well, the camouflage they had learned to use for safekeeping. 
 &bquo;Would you like us to tie the sheaves, Daddy?&equo; 
 Mona asked. 
 &bquo;That'd be a great push,&equo; he said. 
 All the girls were skilled at farm work, work they had done since they were very young. 
 Quickly the rows were gathered into sheaves and tied. 
 They loved the sound of swishing the sheaves made as they were stooked, the clash of the tresses of hard grain against grain, the sight of the rich ears of corn leaning delicately out on the shoulders of the stooks. 
 &bquo;That was great,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;What's left is only trimming. 
 I can do that myself. 
 I am sure ye have books,&equo; he added with unusual thoughtfulness. 
 &bquo;Thanks, Daddy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thanks yourselves.&equo; 
 And then he added, &bquo;We could get on topping without her.&equo; 
 It was not so much that she took things from the house &mdash; though his racial fear of the poorhouse or famine was deep &mdash; but that she left the house at all. 
 Any constant going out to another house was a threat. 
 In small things it showed. 
 The shaving water was boiling. 
 Did she want to scald the face off a man? 
 God, O God, O God, did she not know anything? 
 Look at the holes in these socks. 
 &bquo;Where, O God, is that woman now? 
 Has a whole army to be sent out to search for you whenever you're needed? 
 She did not try to defend herself. 
 &bquo;Coming, Daddy. 
 Coming,&equo; she would call, often arriving breathless. 
 Not once did she protest at the unfairness. 
 She seemed willing to go to almost any length to appease, lull his irritation to rest, contain all the exasperation by taking it within herself. 
 This usually redoubled it. 
 He seemed intent now on pushing to see how far he could go and she appeared willing to give way in everything in order to pacify. 
 The children were deeply ashamed: &bquo;He used to be like that when Luke was here, Rose; only it was worse.&equo; 
 &bquo;These flare-ups happen in every family. 
 It is easy to exaggerate. 
 I'm sure Daddy never meant any harm. 
 These things can be taken too much to heart.&equo; 
 She would not hear the accusation. 
 &bquo;It's true what Mona says.&equo; 
 &bquo;Now, these things can be exaggerated out of all proportion. 
 Daddy may act like that &mdash; none of us are all that good &mdash; but he never means it. 
 I know how much he loves everybody in the house.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's just not fair.&equo; 
 &bquo;You should know you'll not change your father now and he means everything for the best for the whole house,&equo; she argued forcibly but the strain was showing on her own drawn, anxious features. 
 Then one evening as she was tidying up the room he said as quietly as if he were taking rifle aim, &bquo;There's no need for you to go turning the whole place upside down. 
 We managed well enough before you ever came round the place.&equo; 
 She did not try to answer or to turn it aside. 
 It was again as if she had been struck, her hands barely moving along the surface of the dresser she had been wiping clean of dust, her head going low, and when she finished she went to put the damp cloth carefully beside the sink, moving a simmering saucepan from the hotplate. 
 Such was the slowness and enclosedness of all her movements that the girls instinctively looked up from their school books to follow her closely. 
 Moran watched every move under cover of reading the newspaper. 
 Then, with the same shocking slowness, without a word, without looking at anyone, she went to the door, opened it, and let it close softly behind her. 
 They heard her open and close the bedroom door likewise. 
 There was complete silence. 
 Moran rattled the newspaper a few times but by the time he could look around the three children were locked back into their school books. 
 After a while Moran tired of looking at the newspapers and went outside though it was almost night. 
 &bquo;What happened?&equo; 
 Michael asked laughingly, hoping to make light of what had taken place. 
 &bquo;Rose went to bed,&equo; Mona answered without looking up from her books and though the boy thought about it for a while he did not ask anything further. 
 When Moran came back he was even more restless. 
 He went through the newspaper again. 
 Then he got pen and writing pad and sat at the table. 
 He deliberated for a long time in front of the pad, and then suddenly rose and put it away without writing anything. 
 &bquo;We better say the prayers,&equo; he said, taking his beads from the leather purse. 
 As they prepared to kneel he added, &bquo;Open the doors in case Rose wants to hear.&equo; 
 Mona went and opened both doors. 
 At the bedroom door she called softly, &bquo;Rose, we're starting the Rosary.&equo; 
 But not even a whisper came from the room. 
 Mona came in. 
 &bquo;The doors are open,&equo; and took her place without looking at anyone. 
 &bquo;Thou, O Lord, wilt open my lips.&equo; 
 &bquo;And my tongue shall announce Thy praise,&equo; their response was like a muted echo. 
 The doors stayed open but no murmur came from the other room. 
 Moran paused after the First Decade. 
 Rose always recited the Second Decade but when no sound whatever came from the room he nodded severely to Mona to begin. 
 On the completion of the circle, Moran again had to recite the Last Decade. 
 &bquo;Will we shut the doors, Daddy?&equo; 
 Mona asked nervously after they rose from their knees. 
 &bquo;What does it matter whether they are open or shut?&equo; he said and the doors remained open. 
 As soon as they finished with their books the two girls made him tea. 
 Rose always made tea at this hour. 
 Immediately after they tidied and washed up, they went to kiss Moran good night and slipped away to their rooms. 
 He sat for more than an hour alone before dragging himself to the room, shutting the doors loudly behind him as he went. 
 He did not speak in the room, allowing his clothes to fall on to the floor in the darkness, waiting for some stir or sign from Rose, but the only sound in the room was the brushing of his own clothes falling in the darkness. 
 &bquo;Are you awake at all there, Rose?&equo; he whispered before reaching out to pull aside the bedclothes. 
 She did not answer at first but moved or turned. 
 &bquo;I'm awake,&equo; she said at last in a voice strained with hurt. 
 &bquo;I'll have to go away from here.&equo; 
 &bquo;I never heard such nonsense,&equo; he blustered. 
 &bquo;Are you taking everything up as serious as some of the other people in the house? 
 Does every move have to be Judgement Day?&equo; 
 &bquo;I was told I was no use in the house. 
 I couldn't go on living in a place where I was no use,&equo; she spoke with the quietness and desperate authority of someone who had discovered they could give up no more ground and live. 
 &bquo;God, O God. 
 Has everything to be taken like this? 
 I never meant anything like that. 
 The whole world knows that the house was never run right until you came. 
 A blind man could see that the children think the earth of you. 
 They'd cry their eyes out if they heard even a whisper of this silly talk.&equo; 
 &bquo;It didn't sound silly to me. 
 It sounded as if it was meant. 
 I'll have to go back to Glasgow and take up my life there again.&equo; 
 &bquo;God, can't a man say anything in his own house without it being taken up wrong?&equo; and the quarrel circled about the two positions until he reached and took her in his arms. 
 She neither yielded to him nor attempted to pull away. 
 &bquo;I love you dearly and I love the house but I couldn't live here if I am not wanted.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought we'd finished with that for ever.&equo; 
 He was restless by her side, clenching and unclenching his hands. 
 He had been checked. 
 Instead of recognition, all that the quarrel had incurred was a deepening blindness. 
 He now knew less about her than the day they had first met in the post office, standing beside one another on the scrubbed hollow boards, waiting for the evening mail van to come. 
 Mona and Sheila rose earlier than usual the next morning. 
 They had heard noises of someone rising very early and felt apprehensive. 
 They weren't sure if they would find Rose there at all or what way they would find her if they did. 
 They were taken aback to find her smiling and totally at ease. 
 The room was already warm and the furniture shone as if all the pieces had been gone over with a damp cloth. 
 &bquo;You are all up a bit before your time. 
 You could have stolen another few minutes,&equo; she said as if the evening had never happened. 
 She poured their tea and sat with a cup of her own by the fire, chatting away as easily as she did every morning. 
 &bquo;No danger of your brother ever getting up too early,&equo; she said and went to call Michael. 
 When he came into the room, sleepy and rubbing his eyes, he too stared as if not able to believe how like all other mornings the morning was. 
 Nothing seemed to have changed. 
 Moran stayed in bed until late that day, disappearing silently into the fields after eating. 
 When the children came back from school they found that still nothing had changed. 
 Moran was in a rage about tools and a barrow that had been left out in the rain and complained about how much money was being wasted heedlessly about the house all the time. 
 &bquo;Why does he always have to go on like that?&equo; 
 Sheila was emboldened from what she saw the night before to ask Rose when Moran had gone out again. 
 &bquo;Daddy worries. 
 He worries a great deal about the house.&equo; 
 Rose said it with such empathy that all criticism was stopped. 
 All they could do was to look at her but no one could read Rose's face and they turned back to their books. 
 They were only weeks away from the examinations halls. 
 So much work still had to be done, so much work had to be gone over again. 
 The chance-throw of the exam would almost certainly determine the quality of much of the rest of their lives. 
 Sheila especially had dreams of university. 
 Much could be won, a great deal more could be lost, and there was always England. 
 At this time Moran ordered an enormous load of lime that blocked the avenue. 
 To cut down on expense he did not get the big factory spreaders but started to spread it himself with tractor and shovel. 
 For days he backed the little transport box into the huge mound and went up and down the fields in lines, stopping the tractor every few yards to scatter the lime, tossing each shovelful on the wind for the white dust to be blown out over the grass. 
 No matter how carefully he sliced each shovelful in an arc out on the wind, there were certain unpredictable gusts that lifted the grains and blew them back towards the tractor so that by evening his clothes were filthy with lime, his face and hands as white as chalk, accentuating the inflamed red round his eyes. 
 The theatrical paleness of his face and hands pleased him. 
 &bquo;I'm a boody man,&equo; he pretended to chase Rose and the children with his old charm. 
 Rose was delighted, the clowning bringing relief back into the house after the hidden battle. 
 It would never be over but Rose's place in the house could never be attacked or threatened again. 
 &bquo;I'm a boody man. 
 I'm a boody man,&equo; he made playful sallies to left and right while everybody pretended to back away, shouting and laughing. 
 As the days went by and the busy little transport box seemed to be making only slow way into the huge heap of lime, he no longer eased it out on the blade of the shovel for the wind to take it but scattered it anywhere out of sight, anywhere to be rid of it. 
 More often because of his impatience, it blew back in his face, dusting him all over. 
 Each night he would be more red-eyed, hardly able to drag his feet with tiredness, his face caked white with lime, lime in his eyes and ears and nostrils, his throat dry, lime thick through his hair and clothes and when he sat down to the table he felt as if he were eating lime. 
 The blindman's buff of &bquo;I'm the boody man&equo; was gone and they served his tiredness with careful silence. 
 Rose bent over him with pure attention. 
 &bquo;Do you think it will rain?&equo; he asked Rose. 
 The forecast is for the same dry hard weather for days.&equo; 
 &bquo;If it rains,&equo; he said gloomily, &bquo;if it rains that heap will set like mixed concrete and we'll never be rid of it'; and though there was no sign of a break in the weather he covered the slowly diminishing heap at night with clear plastic, weighted down with stones. 
 The girls were now too close to their exam, too anxious to do more than lift their faces to him, but out of the tiredness and filth of lime he could be seen looking often at their heads bent over the lamplit pages in what looked close to melancholy and sunken reflection. 
 &bquo;I was in the eighth class in Moyne,&equo; he said and named four boys in the same class. 
 &bquo;It was as far as you could go in Moyne. 
 I was there for two years. 
 All the others went on to be priests. 
 Joe Brady became a Bishop in Colorado. 
 He died two years ago. 
 I used to write to him till then. 
 You couldn't go further than the eighth class without going on to be a priest.&equo; 
 &bquo;Even if you had money?&equo; 
 Rose asked. 
 &bquo;No one had money round Moyne,&equo; he smiled, aching with tiredness, filthy and white with lime. 
 &bquo;We were all good in the eighth class in Moyne but I was the best in maths.&equo; 
 He named the others who shone in different subjects. 
 &bquo;They all went on to be priests and then the Troubles started and I left too. 
 Strange, to this day I have never met a priest who wasn't afraid to die. 
 I could never make head or tails of that. 
 It flew in the face of everything.&equo; 
 &bquo;If it had been a different time you'd have been a doctor or an engineer,&equo; Rose said. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't have been a doctor,&equo; he shivered with tiredness, ill at ease by the very suggestion of a shape other than his own. 
 &bquo;These lassies will be worn out with all this study,&equo; Moran changed. 
 &bquo;No, Daddy. 
 We're just going over something again for the exam.&equo; 
 &bquo;We've had good weather for weeks now. 
 You're all day inside in school. 
 You should take your books into the fresh air.&equo; 
 He returned to it again and again, the good weather held and they were compelled eventually to go outside. 
 They went to Oakport Woods, leaving their bicycles at the big iron gate, and walking with their books over the grass to the belt of trees along Oakport Lake. 
 The late May sun burned overhead. 
 It would be cool and dark within the wood and there was a cold spring. 
 &bquo;I don't know why he had to rout us out. 
 We have wasted all this time getting here. 
 We'd study better at home,&equo; Sheila complained crossing the fields. 
 &bquo;That's him,&equo; Mona answered. 
 &bquo;He&equo; s never content with things the way they are.&equo; 
 They passed the delicate white blossoms of wild cherry, Sheila striding along in angry resentment, Mona following in her shadow. 
 The light of water showed through the tree trunks as they drew close to the narrow wood along the lake but once on the fringe of the trees they lost all resentment at the sight of the thick floor of bluebells beneath the trees. 
 To advance further into the wood was to trample on the colour blue. 
 &bquo;There must be thousands.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's millions!&equo; 
 Their feet left clear tracks through the floor of bluebells as if on dark snow, the soft stems crushing to pulp under their feet. 
 At the well they left their books and went down to the shore. 
 The water was still. 
 Summer had not yet replaced the wheaten reeds of winter with green along the edges. 
 Out in the lake the gulls wheeled and scolded above their young on the pile of reeds ringed with rocks that formed Seagull Island. 
 There was no boat any longer in Nutley's boathouse. 
 Some boards had been torn from the side and its black paint of tar had turned pale. 
 &bquo;I don't like this place,&equo; Sheila said. 
 &bquo;Do you remember when we used to go with Daddy in the boat on Saturdays?&equo; 
 &bquo;How could I forget!&equo; 
 Sheila said derisively. 
 Before getting down to their books they searched out a hollow straw and leaned flat across the spring to drink the water which was famed for its coldness. 
 It was as if by drinking from the cold spring they were hoping to appease some spirit of the place so that it wouldn't turn unfriendly to their studies; but they could not settle as they tried to read and make notes. 
 A fly landed on a nose. 
 A pure white butterfly tossed about in the light on the edge of the lake. 
 Bees were moving about on the bluebells. 
 A wren or robin scrambled about in a clump of thorns and seemed to be scolding. 
 &bquo;This is a joke,&equo; Sheila closed her book. 
 &bquo;I can't take in a word here. 
 I'm going home. 
 What can he say? 
 It's too close to the exam to waste time.&equo; 
 &bquo;He can't say that we didn't make an attempt.&equo; 
 Mona too was glad to leave. 
 &bquo;We should have known better,&equo; came the exasperated response. 
 Even Sheila grew a little afraid as they drew close to the house. 
 Coming home so early might seem to be confronting Moran. 
 &bquo;You are almost back before you left.&equo; 
 He met them at the gate and was smiling. 
 &bquo;There's nothing like the lake and the open air for powdering through the lessons.&equo; 
 &bquo;We got nothing done, Daddy.&equo; 
 Sheila hung her head despondently low. 
 &bquo;I'm surprised. 
 I thought when I saw the pair of you coming that you had just raced through everything,&equo; Moran laughed. 
 There was no reason to be afraid; on the contrary, he was delighted. 
 &bquo;There were too many things to look at, Daddy,&equo; Mona said apologetically. 
 &bquo;Ye are making excuses now,&equo; he teased. 
 &bquo;You're just no good and weren't able to make yourselves get down to it.&equo; 
 After they had gone in and resumed their grind in the usual places, Rose came out to him and said gently, &bquo;You were terrible, Daddy, to make them go down to the lake.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's so terrible about it?&equo; he laughed, still in good humour. 
 &bquo;It's fresh air, isn't it? 
 They need to be rooted out of themselves from time to time. 
 All work and no play makes jack a dull boy. 
 They'll appreciate the inside of the house far better now.&equo; 
 This small disturbance did not deflect them for long. 
 They read and reread, often looking quite abstracted, memorizing passages silently, their eyes far off; and when ideas eluded or baffled them they would turn to one another for help, each sister seeming to draw strength and comfort from the other's closeness. 
 Moran felt so outside their circle of concentration that he had to resort to tiptoeing into the room in an exaggerated parody of someone trying to enter unheard but his only audience was the boy, and that not often, and laughter only lifted the girls' heads from their books for a forgotten moment. 
 Each of these clear days of scattered apple and white pear tree blossom moved inexorably towards the first day when they set out without books and came home in the evening showing the pink or blue papers they had tested themselves against in the examination hall. 
 &bquo;How do you think you did?&equo; 
 Moran was waiting anxiously to ask each evening. 
 &bquo;We don't know, Daddy. 
 The nun thinks we didn't do too bad.&equo; 
 &bquo;Never mind. 
 We'll always have enough to eat here anyhow,&equo; he said, feeling vulnerable in the face of the power that rested in the hands of the outside. 
 Then, suddenly, the exams were over. 
 They could put their books away. 
 But, instead of the freedom and ease they had longed for, all they felt was emptiness where once all was tension and work. 
 They had to pass idle days of waiting that stretched ahead to an eternity of weeks in August. 
 &bquo;You don't have to worry about anything,&equo; Moran said constantly. 
 &bquo;You don't have to worry about a single thing.&equo; 
 In early July the waiting was broken by the excitement of Maggie coming home for the first time since she had left for London. 
 She was coming home for three whole weeks and by the time she left for London again the exam results would be nearly due. 
 Rose had already started to paint the main room of the house during the first exam. 
 The freed girls helped her finish it, scrub tables and chairs. 
 The old furniture was left outside in the sun to air. 
 They scrubbed white the boards of the floor and the old brown flagstones of the hallway took on a damp glow. 
 Michael's front garden was beautiful with stock, beds of sweet William and marigolds that took greedily the sun from the other flowers &mdash; pansies, roses and lilies. 
 Moran washed and polished the car, even cleared rusted machinery from around the house. 
 He was more excited than anyone else and continually cracked jokes. 
 On the arrival day he considered going to meet Maggie in Carrick but he was afraid that he might miss her and decided to go to Boyle. 
 He left alone before the train reached Carrick. 
 Against Rose's chidings he went in his old working clothes as if, perversely, to deny that the day was special in any way. 
 &bquo;She'll have to take me as she finds me. 
 She's back in the country now.&equo; 
 After he left everyone was glued to the clock. 
 &bquo;The train is coming into Carrick!&equo; 
 The waiting silence was broken by, &bquo;I'd say the train is leaving Carrick now,&equo; and they all went to the fields behind the house to catch a glimpse of the train as it passed. 
 They heard the diesel engine, the quick rattle of the wheels on rails and then the caterpillar of carriages that rose above the stone walls, the small windows flashing in the sun as they were quickly drawn across their view and gone. 
 Then they all moved to the front of the house to watch the road and wait. 
 They were so intent on watching every car that they failed to pick up Moran's until it was turning slowly in the gate under the yew tree. 
 Moran looked stern and self-conscious as he drove up the short avenue. 
 Maggie burst into tears at the sight of the house and the small familiar crowd waiting for her outside the wooden gate of the garden. 
 Everyone embraced blindly and kissed one by one. 
 &bquo;You are such a handsome one now,&equo; Rose looked her up and down with pleasure. 
 &bquo;What do you think of an old fellow like myself turning up to meet such a grand lassie?&equo; 
 Rose laughed and there was a general scramble to carry the baggage into the house. 
 In the house Maggie unpacked the presents she brought: a brilliant red woollen scarf for Rose, a brown V-necked pullover for Moran; Sheila and Mona were handed silken headscarves and Michael a saffron tie to go with his hair. 
 She also brought him seeds with pictures of the flowers on the packets. 
 &bquo;Do you think they will grow here?&equo; he asked, impressed that they had come all the way from London. 
 A big box of soft-centred chocolates was handed round. 
 Tea was made. 
 She was the centre of the table. 
 They asked her greedily about London. 
 &bquo;What's Luke like now?&equo; 
 Sheila burst out. 
 Silence fell at once. 
 Everyone looked towards Moran who held his own pained silence. 
 &bquo;He's just the same,&equo; Maggie said and continued on about the nurses' home while Sheila bit her tongue. 
 Such was the excitement and focus on Maggie that in spite of Rose's care to draw him into the conversation Moran began to feel out of it and grew bored. 
 &bquo;I think it's time to say the Rosary,&equo; he said earlier than usual, taking out his beads. 
 They put newspapers down and knelt. 
 This night Moran enunciated each repetitious word with a slow clarity and force as if the very dwelling on suffering, death and human supplication would scatter all flimsy vanities of a greater world; and the muted responses giving back their acceptance of human servitude did not improve his humour. 
 The coughing, the rustling of the newspapers, the rasp of coat buttons on table or chair exasperated his brooding. 
 The high spirits round the tea table had gone. 
 Then, like a shoal of fish moving within a net, Rose and the girls started to clear the table, to brush away crumbs, to wash, to dry, to return each thing to its own place, all done with a muted energy; whispers, jokes, little scolding asides &mdash; &bquo;No, that goes in the other place&equo; or reminisce how they had made the same mistake before in order to soften any harshness in the scold, bending low in apologetic laughter. 
 Ingratiating smiles and words were threaded in and out of the whole whirl of busyness. 
 Amid it all was their constant awareness of Moran's watching presence, sharpening everything they did with the danger of letting something fall and break and bring the weight of his disapproval into the small chain. 
 All their movements were based more on habit and instinct and fear than any real threat but none the less it was an actual physical state. 
 They would wash up the same way even if they were not watched. 
 As looking down from great heights brings the urge to fall and end the terror of falling, so his very watching put pressure on them to make a slip as they dried and stacked the plates and cups. 
 There were several alarms, bringing laughing giggles of relief when they came to nothing. 
 Then they quietly washed and dried their own hands and returned to the general room. 
 Moran sat on, brooding in the car chair, his thumbs idly revolving around one another. 
 &bquo;I think we should have a cup of tea,&equo; Rose said with jollying encouragement towards Moran but when he only looked back out at her she just continued talking as she got kettle and teapot. 
 &bquo;Maggie will want an early night. 
 I know how tired she must be after the journey. 
 That night boat is the worst of all, and the waiting.&equo; 
 Whether it was the suggestion or pure tiredness Maggie was yawning as if in her support. 
 The girls rose late the following morning. 
 Moran had gone out already into the fields. 
 During the long luxurious breakfast Maggie told Rose and Sheila and Mona more details of her life in London than she was able to the night before &mdash; the parties, the dances, the different bands and singers, the boys she met, her girlfriends. 
 Rose had her own girlhood in Glasgow to share. 
 Mona and Sheila were so poised on the edge of their own lives that they listened as if hearing about the living stream they were about to enter. 
 After the long breakfast the three girls went out to visit Moran in the fields. 
 They had worked so hard as children in the fields that each field and tree had become a dear presence, especially the hedges. 
 Maggie looked for the old damson tree by McCabe's, the crab and wild cherry. 
 The sky overhead was cloudless. 
 No wind stirred. 
 Small birds flitted in the shade of the branches and bees were crawling over the red and white clover. 
 They found Moran by the sound of malleting. 
 He was replacing broken stakes in a barbed-wire fence in one of the meadows. 
 The sight of his daughters in sleeveless dresses was relief from the lonely tedium of the work. 
 &bquo;I'm planning to knock this meadow before the evening is out,&equo; he told them before they left and joked, &bquo;You'll have to harden your hands before you leave.&equo; 
 &bquo;They are not that soft, Daddy.&equo; 
 As they walked away from him through the greenness, the pale blue above them, Maggie said, her voice thick with emotion, &bquo;Daddy is just lovely when he's like that.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's nobody who can hold a candle to him,&equo; Mona added. 
 The girls in their different ways wanted to gather their father and the whole, true, heartbreaking day into their arms. 
 By evening Moran's mood had completely turned again. 
 He changed his boots and clothes in downcast silence and ate without speaking. 
 Whatever was bothering him was gnawing at him as he ate. 
 They knew him so well that everyone fell into a hush and appeared to move around him on tiptoes. 
 &bquo;Do you ever see that brother of yours at all?&equo; he asked without looking up as he finished, drawing his chair roughly back from the table. 
 &bquo;I do but not all that much.&equo; 
 &bquo;How do you mean not all that much?&equo; 
 &bquo;He met me at the station&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;God, don't you think I know that?&equo; 
 &bquo;He came out to the hospital every weekend after I first came but since then it's only every so often he comes out. 
 Once I met him in the West End and we went to the pictures.&equo; 
 Maggie wanted to please and pacify him on this her holiday at any cost. 
 &bquo;How does he look?&equo; 
 &bquo;He looks fine. 
 He looks no different than when he was here.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you mention when you wrote that he is in with some Cockney riff-raff?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's something to do with converting old houses. 
 I'm not certain what it is.&equo; 
 &bquo;Believe me, he wouldn't tell what it is.&equo; 
 &bquo;He goes to night school though,&equo; she defended uneasily. 
 &bquo;Doing what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Accountancy. 
 He'll be qualified before too long.&equo; 
 &bquo;Does he ask about us at all?&equo; 
 &bquo;He asks if we have any news.&equo; 
 &bquo;Does he ever talk about coming home?&equo; 
 &bquo;And did he not send any word to anybody when he knew you were coming home?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 He sent word. 
 He wishes everybody the best.&equo; 
 &bquo;God, I don't know what's wrong with this house,&equo; Moran rose, preparing to go out. 
 &bquo;Getting information from anybody is like trying to extract teeth.&equo; 
 &bquo;We don't know any more than that,&equo; Maggie protested to Rose after he had gone. 
 &bquo;I told Daddy everything we know about Luke.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't worry,&equo; Rose hushed. 
 &bquo;Daddy's like that. 
 He takes all these things far too seriously.&equo; 
 When he came in for the night some hours later he was still agitated and fretting. 
 &bquo;I don't know,&equo; he said as he sat to the table. 
 &bquo;I don't know what I did to deserve it. 
 I don't know why things can't be the same in this house as in every other house in the country. 
 I don't know why it is always me  that has to be singled out.&equo; 
 Rose fussed discreetly around him but he could not remain the centre of attention for long. 
 Maggie was going to a dance and she was taking Mona and Sheila. 
 All three girls were dressing and their youthful excitement pulsed through the house. 
 Rose too was caught up in the preparations. 
 &bquo;Be careful,&equo; Moran advised when he kissed each of them in turn as they were ready to leave. 
 Be careful never to do anything to let yourselves or the house down.&equo; 
 &bquo;We'd never do that, Daddy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Enjoy yourselves,&equo; Rose advised them simply. 
 After they had gone a complete silence that only reflected itself settled down like lead and was broken only by the sound of Moran removing his boots to go to bed early. 
 The next morning the girls woke to the incessant clatter of the mowing arm circling the big meadow. 
 Moran had started to mow. 
 All hands would be needed. 
 Whatever leisure the holidays had promised was now ended. 
 The whole house would be consumed by the fever of haytime, the fear of broken weather until every wisp was won. 
 &bquo;The big meadow is down. 
 It'll be all hands on deck from now on,&equo; Moran told the girls as they sat over a late breakfast. 
 He was happy and relieved that the first part of the mowing was completed without any breakage. 
 &bquo;It'll be great if the rain keeps off,&equo; Rose said. 
 &bquo;It might take the edge off the dancing,&equo; Moran teased. 
 &bquo;You'll be too tired to dance tonight anyhow.&equo; 
 &bquo;That might not be a bit of harm!&equo; they smiled back. 
 As soon as the dew had been burned off the grass, the whole house was in the hayfield, shaking out the heavy tangled lumps of grass the tedder had missed with the fork, raking what was light in from the edges. 
 Towards evening, when the grass started to take on the dry crackle of hay, it was as if the small handshakings were springing up in the meadow. 
 The weather did not look like breaking. 
 Moran put the mowing arm back on the tractor and cut the second and third meadows. 
 They had most of the big meadow up by nightfall. 
 By then every muscle ached, and it was with deep gratitude that they turned at last to drag their feet towards the house. 
 &bquo;There'll surely be no dancing tonight.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can say that twice over.&equo; 
 They were stiff as boards the next morning. 
 When they moved, every muscle ached but by midday they were in the fields again. 
 Rose and Michael brought tea and sandwiches out to the field. 
 Moran was either mowing a new field or tossing the field ahead of them with the tedder but he joined the band of girls under the shade of one of the big beeches when Rose came with the basket and can. 
 &bquo;It can't be helped, it must be done,&equo; he said after they had eaten and rested. 
 Rose gathered up what was left of the sandwiches of tinned salmon and sardines. 
 The girls rose stiffly in the green shade and turned to the sunlit meadow. 
 Maggie and Mona were good workers. 
 They worked silently, hardly ever looking up. 
 Sheila hated the work. 
 She complained of blisters on her hale glaring days they worked away like this, too tired and stiff at night to want to go anywhere but to bed. 
 They had all the hay won except the final meadow when the weather broke. 
 The girls never thought they would lift their faces to the rain in gratitude. 
 They watched it waste the meadows for the whole day. 
 &bquo;To hell with it. 
 We're safe now anyhow. 
 If we don't get the last meadow itself it will do for bedding. 
 Only for the whole lot of you we'd not be near that far on,&equo; Moran was able to praise. 
 &bquo;It was for nothing, Daddy.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was everything. 
 Alone we might be nothing. 
 Together we can do anything.&equo; 
 Rose put down a big fire against the depression of the constant rain. 
 Everybody in the house loved to move in the warmth and luxury of it, to look out from the bright room at the rain spilling steadily down between the trees. 
 When they moved away from the fire to the outer rooms the steady constant drip of rain from the eaves in the silence was like peace falling. 
 Now they could dance with a clear conscience. 
 The big regatta dances in the huge grey tent down by the quay in Carrick were just beginning but there were so few days left of the holiday that Maggie preferred to spend them about the house chatting with Rose or her sisters around the fire or talking with Michael out in the front garden among his flowerbeds; and sometimes during long breaks in the rain they would go out to where Moran was tidying up in the meadows. 
 By the time Maggie had to go back to London they had never felt closer in warmth, even happiness. 
 The closeness was as strong as the pull of their own lives; they lost the pain of individuality within its protection. 
 In London or Dublin the girls would look back to the house for healing. 
 The remembered light on the empty hayfields would grow magical, the green shade of the beeches would give out a delicious coolness as they tasted again the sardines between slices of bread: when they were away the house would become the summer light and shade above their whole lives. 
 &bquo;If we don't do well in the exam, if we don't get anything here,&equo; Sheila blurted out, as they said goodbye outside the front garden while Moran waited with the engine running to drive Maggie to the station, &bquo;you may see us in London soon enough.&equo; 
 Such was their anxiety during the two days that were left before the exam results were due that Mona and Sheila found it hard to eat or sleep. 
 &bquo;Waiting is the worst,&equo; Rose said sympathetically as she saw them struggling with food. 
 &bquo;Once you see what's in the envelopes everything will be all right.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 I don't know,&equo; Sheila said impatiently. 
 &bquo;They might be dreadful.&equo; 
 &bquo;No they won't. 
 Nothing is so bad as having to imagine.&equo; 
 So as not to have to watch the empty road for the postman on the day that the results were due each girl went separately deep into the fields but they weren't able to stay alone for long; and each time they came back to the road it was still empty. 
 When at last they did see him coming they had to follow his slow path from the road, watch him lean his bicycle carefully against the wall under the yew and plod slowly up between the two rows of boxwood. 
 Moran who had been watching as anxiously as the two girls met him at the wooden gate. 
 They stood chatting across the gate for what seemed an age until Moran faced the house with the two envelopes tantalizingly held out. 
 Unable to stand it any longer, Sheila went up to him and before he had time to react seized both envelopes, feverishly tearing open her own and handing the other to Mona, who appeared almost unable to take it. 
 Mona watched Sheila more devour than read the results. 
 Moran was so taken aback by the way Sheila had seized the envelope from his hand that he stood in amazement. 
 &bquo;They're good! 
 They're more than I ever thought&hellip; 
 Read them.&equo; 
 Without knowing quite what she was doing she thrust them roughly towards Moran. 
 &bquo;Why haven't you even opened yours?&equo; 
 She turned to Mona. 
 She took the letter from her hands and opened it. 
 &bquo;You've done great too,&equo; she hugged her sister and they wheeled one another round on the garden path until the flowerbeds were in danger. 
 Both girls had done well but Sheila had done brilliantly. 
 &bquo;This is great,&equo; Rose said. 
 &bquo;We're very proud.&equo; 
 Moran, reacting to the exhibition of high spirits, said firmly, &bquo;I think we'll have to consider everything.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean consider ?&equo; 
 Sheila's voice quavered. 
 &bquo;We'll have to consider where it will all lead to,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;And what we can afford. 
 Making too much fuss of anything never brings luck.&equo; 
 But in spite of his words there was a fusliza,&equo; Tilda said as we walked back slowly along the path of Robina's scruffy garden bordered by dark, unclipped shrubs. 
 &bquo;That woman is back &mdash; I know it. 
 She will kill Eliza next!&equo; 
 And Tilda wept, in the ragged long grass of her aunt's back garden. 
 I thought, at first, of Jean Hastie and of summoning her down to deal with this. 
 Jean, surely, had been here at the time of the murder. 
 Jean alone had evidence of Dr Crane's last meeting with Eliza. 
 Again, I realized I needed evidence myself if I were to risk cals about their success. 
 They had done so well that the convent put photographs of the two girls in the local paper. 
 Moran came back from the post office to tell them that Annie and Lizzie had been singing their praises. 
 &bquo;I told them it was nothing. 
 What else had the girls to do but study? 
 Anybody could do it who got their chance. 
 They nearly beat me,&equo; he said to the whole house, much pleased with what he had said. 
 The girls looked at him with wide-eyed hurt. 
 They felt that he had let them down in front of others. 
 &bquo;They'll think that you are running down your own children.&equo; 
 Rose articulated what they felt. 
 &bquo;If I was to praise the girls in the post office, being Irish they would have  to cut them down to size,&equo; Moran argued. 
 &bquo;Since I didn't give them any praise, Annie and Lizzie had to do the praising instead. 
 That way they think twice as much of the girls than if I had praised them myself.&equo; 
 He was very pleased with his own astuteness. 
 &bquo;It would have been better if he had praised us no matter what anyone said,&equo; Sheila said when the girls were alone with Rose, disappointed that he had failed to support them in public no matter what his intentions were. 
 &bquo;Well, that's the way Daddy is,&equo; Rose argued. 
 &bquo;He probably thought that's what would please you most. 
 He's so proud of you all. 
 He thought that he might do you harm if he allowed it to show.&equo; 
 The solid offer of a place in the Department of Lands came for Mona and a similar job in the Department of Finance for Sheila. 
 The offers came among a number of other lesser positions that the girls had applied for. 
 &bquo;To those that have shall be given too much. 
 To those that have nothing shall be given a kick in the arse,&equo; Moran responded to the luxury of the choices. 
 He assumed both girls would take the civil service jobs. 
 Then a scholarship to university came in for Sheila. 
 Suddenly the whole world was wide open to her. 
 &bquo;I'm saying nothing. 
 I want to stand in nobody's way. 
 She has to make up her own mind. 
 Tonight we'll all have to pray for her guidance,&equo; Moran said. 
 She played with the choices during the remaining days allowed her, knowing in her heart that she would be forced to take the safe path into the civil service. 
 She went to the convent for advice. 
 Sister Oliver pressed her to grasp her chance and go to university. 
 Sheila argued the hesitations and objections she already felt surrounded by, which were, essentially, Moran's lack of support but the nun pressed her to think about it. 
 &bquo;I was talking to Sister Oliver. 
 She wants me to forget about the civil service and to go to university,&equo; she said as soon as she got home. 
 &bquo;Go to university?&equo; 
 Moran repeated. 
 &bquo;I won the scholarships,&equo; she asserted spiritedly. 
 &bquo;Would the scholarships pay for everything?&equo; 
 &bquo;They'd pay for most of it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where would the rest come from?&equo; 
 &bquo;I could work during the holidays.&equo; 
 She felt under great pressure. 
 &bquo;What would you study at university?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd like to do medicine.&equo; 
 &bquo;How long would that take?&equo; 
 &bquo;The most of seven years.&equo; 
 &bquo;Physician heal thyself,&equo; he muttered in a half-overheard aside and went out. 
 Sheila could not have desired a worse profession. 
 It was the priest and doctor and not the guerrilla fighters who had emerged as the bigwigs in the country Moran had fought for. 
 For his own daughter to lay claim to such a position was an intolerable affront. 
 At least the priest had to pay for his position with celibacy and prayer. 
 The doctor took the full brunt of Moran's resentment. 
 Sheila withdrew into angry silence. 
 There were moments when she thought of looking for outside help but there was really no one she could turn to. 
 Maggie had barely enough to live on. 
 She considered writing to Luke in London &mdash; she had even taken notepaper out &mdash; but realized that it would be directly confronting Moran. 
 She could not bring herself to do it. 
 Throughout, Moran did not attempt to influence Sheila directly but his withdrawal of support was total. 
 After two days Sheila announced truculently, &bquo;I'm not going to the university. 
 I'll take the civil service.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't want to stand in your way, that's why I said nothing but I can't help thinking it is closer to your measure.&equo; 
 &bquo;How?&equo; 
 Her anger brought out his own aggression. 
 &bquo;How, what? 
 How, pig, is it?&equo; he demanded. 
 &bquo;What do you mean, Daddy? 
 I didn't understand what you said, that's all,&equo; she was quick to change but she refused to withdraw. 
 &bquo;You'd understand quick enough if you wanted to. 
 You know the old saying there's none more deaf than those who do not want to hear.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sorry. 
 I just didn't understand, Daddy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Going for medicine is a fairly tall order, isn't it? 
 Even with scholarships it takes money. 
 I consider all my family equal. 
 I don't like to see a single one trying to outdistance another.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't say anything like that. 
 I just said what I'd like to do,&equo; she said brokenly, with bitterness. 
 &bquo;That's right. 
 Blame me because the world isn't perfect,&equo; Moran complained equally bitterly. 
 &bquo;Blame, blame. 
 No matter what you do. 
 Blame is all you get in this family.&equo; 
 Mona stayed out of the turmoil. 
 She was on her certain way into the civil service from the beginning. 
 Full of hidden violence, she was unnaturally acquiescent, fearful that her own unyieldingness would be exposed and its consequences violent. 
 Once Sheila was securely set towards the civil service as well, as if out of weakness or guilt Moran began courting her with vague, tentative offers; if she were desperate to go to university they could still look into ways of how it could be managed and they would try to manage it somehow no matter how hard it was. 
 She refused. 
 She knew the offers would disappear again the very moment she tried to take them up. 
 The week before they were going to Dublin he went with the two girls and Rose to Boles in the town. 
 &bquo;You must get what you want. 
 You have to be able to hold your heads as high as anybody else in Dublin. 
 Get the good stuff. 
 The Morans are too poor to afford cheap shoes. 
 There will be money after us when we are gone.&equo; 
 Rose did not take him at his word. 
 She spent carefully. 
 You didn't spend half enough when you got the chance,&equo; he said when he saw the bill. 
 He was plainly suffering because he had denied Sheila her chance of university but he could not have acted in any other way, perhaps through race fear of the poorhouse or plain temperament. 
 &bquo;Don't worry, Daddy,&equo; Mona said. 
 &bquo;You did everything you could for us. 
 You did far too much.&equo; 
 Sheila nodded in vigorous agreement. 
 That evening, after Sheila and Mona had left for Dublin, Michael said resentfully, &bquo;They're all gone now.&equo; 
 After Luke and then Maggie had left for London there were still enough people to dull the heartache and emptiness but now that all the girls had gone it was as if the whole house had been cleaned. 
 &bquo;It's not fair.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's life, I'm afraid, Michael,&equo; Rose said. 
 &bquo;How will they fare without us?&equo; his face was soft with tears. 
 &bquo;How will we fare without them?&equo; 
 Rose said. 
 &bquo;They'll manage, please God. 
 We all have to manage somehow.&equo; 
 &bquo;They shouldn't all be gone.&equo; 
 Moran looked from his son's face to his wife's but his own remained expressionless. 
 When he got up from his chair he was already spilling the beads from their black purse into his palm. 
 &bquo;We'd be better if we'd say our prayers.&equo; 
 The newspapers were put down, the chairs dragged into place but there was so much space on the floor that the three kneeling figures, Moran erect at the table, Rose and Michael bent at the chairs, looked scattered and far apart. 
 There was an uneasy pause, as if waiting for Mona, at the beginning of the Third Mystery. 
 Moran hurried into the Fourth. 
 Rose too was hesitant as she started the Fifth Mystery. 
 A wind was swirling round the house, sometimes gusting in the chimney, and there was an increasing sense of fear as the trees stirred in the storm outside when the prayers ended. 
 For the first time the house seemed a frail defence against all that beat around it. 
 The prayers had done nothing to dispel the sense of night and stirring trees outside, the splattering of rain on the glass. 
 As Moran solemnly replaced his beads in the purse Michael complained again. 
 &bquo;The house feels awful with everybody gone.&equo; 
 Rose looked from Moran to the boy and back again to Moran and held her peace. 
 &bquo;They're gone anyhow,&equo; Moran said. 
 &bquo;They have good jobs. 
 I'll expect they'll be sending us money before long. 
 We'll all be rolling,&equo; Moran said half-jokingly; and as Michael started to sob he touched his thick curly hair. 
 &bquo;They've mollied you for far too long. 
 You'll have to grow up and fight your corner.&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll make tea. 
 There's fruit cake as well as bread and jam. 
 I'm worn out with all the go of the last days,&equo; Rose said. 
 After Rose and the boy had gone to bed he sat on his own by the raked fire, sitting motionless, staring down at the floor. 
 When he did get up to go to the room he looked like someone who had lost the train of thought he had set out on and had emptied himself into blankness, aware only that he was still somehow present. 
 SHARK NUDGES 200lb 
 A 198 lb porbeagle shark gave David Proudfoot a terrific 45 minute battle during a boat session off Dunnet Head in Scotland. 
 David first tried a cod bait on a size 10/0 hook and wire trace after a shark attacked a cod being brought aboard Clair Calder's Scrabster-based charter boat Karen. 
 The Janetstown, Thurso, environmental health officer was broken twice after two short fights and stepped up to a 70 lb wire trace with 10 feet of 200 lb nylon as a rubbing leader and baited up with a 1 lb coalfish deadbait on a size 8/0 hook. 
 Five minutes after letting the freelined bait drift off in the tide the big shark struck. 
 Within ten minutes the shark was visible but it then set off on a strong deep dive taking 100 yards of line despite a heavy drag setting. 
 &bquo;For 25 minutes it was difficult to see who was going to be exhausted first,&equo; said David, 36, Caithness SAA secretary. 
 &bull; John Watson had a hectic morning's had a hectic morning's pike fishing topped by this 26 lb 8 oz specimen from a south Norfolk lake. 
 The Norwich civil servant thought the trip would be a complete waste of time after arriving to find the lake completely frozen over but the pike fed furiously for three hours. 
 &bquo;I managed to get two rods out but had to sink the line below the water to avoid the ice which was being blown towards me,&equo; said John. 
 &bquo;The first time the buzzer went I thought it was the ice but it was a 16 lb pike. 
 &bquo;The rod with the smelt on soon went again and I did not realise how big the fish was and steered it around the swim for a minute to break the ice. 
 &bquo;Only when it was in the net did I realise what size it was and it weighed 26 ob 8 oz,&equo; added John who went on to bank five other pike, two of 8 lb 8 oz, and others of 10 lb, 11lb and 14 lb. 
 The biggest specimen was landed on two size 8 trebles to 12 lb line. 
 MAIL BOX 
 &bull; MORE than &pound;1,000 in prizes is up for grabs in the British All-comers Championships at Tynemouth this Sunday, February 17. 
 Details from Dave Higgins on 091 252 4695. 
 PASS EXAM OR YOU DON'T GET A LICENCE! 
 Fish experts' move to introduce test shocks angling. 
 Radical proposals to restrict rod licences to those who have passed an angling test have been handed to the Sports Council review panel by the Institute of Fisheries Management. 
 The IFM looked at similar systems in Germany and Czechoslovakia before making the suggestions which would also see the launch of a mjor training scheme for new anglers. 
 The IFM says an angling test should at first be voluntary but perhaps become compulsory in the future with anglers losing their licence for breaking a code of practice. 
 Sources close to the panel say the recommndations are unlikely to be introduced. 
 But elements of the IFM case have attracted the support of some angling bodies. 
 National Anglers' Council chief Peter Tombleson welcomed the emphasis on training but is sceptical about any compulsory test. 
 &bquo;We run a proficiency award scheme and would like that to continue because there ought to be an award for young anglers in particular to show they are not just good anglers but caring conservationists as well,&equo; said Peter. 
 &bquo;We support the Institute in their proposals but not when it comes to making something compulsory which we find simply turns people against it.&equo; 
 Adult anglers in Germany must take evening classes and pass a multiple choice test before they can get their rod licence. 
 To fish without a licence is illegal and anglers may pay up to &pound;30 for training which covers everything from fish diseases to different kinds of aquatic weed. 
 National Federation of Anglers president Dave Bird has given the idea the thumbs-down. 
 &bquo;Whilst the German idea looks very attractive the NFA have examined it and believe in this country it would be impractical,&equo; he said. 
 The recommendations have received a mixed welcome from the Angling Foundation. 
 AF boss Dr Bruno Broughton said: &bquo;There is nothing wrong with the bulk of the IFM proposals but forcing people to qualify before being allowed to go fishing is over the top.&equo; 
 &bquo;That sort of route would be impractical but it might help solve the exessses that a small minority of anglers get up to.&equo; 
 Also included in the IFM recommendations are a national angling centre with teaching facilities and offices and continuing the use of Anglers Consultative Associations but with a wider range of representaion of angling interests. 
 &bquo;The idea is that anglers should be far more aware of the resource they are using and it should be the job of the IFM to teach them more about the fish,&equo; said IFM official Robin Templeton. 
 &bquo;As a starting point we would like to see some sort of voluntary test similar to the German system which would then give anglers a discount on the cost of a licence if they passed,&equo; added Robin. 
 COVER PICTURE 
 The 24 lb 7 oz pike on the cover gave Doncaster council worker Andy Tate a terrific battle at a Lincolnshire stillwater after being fooled by a paternostered roach bait. 
 The specimen bored straight into a weed bed and Pike Anglers' Club member Andy fought the fish for 15 minutes before beating it with size 8 trebles to 11 lb line. 
 &bull;Les Aves smashed the South Essex Specimen Group record with this terrific 3 lb 4 oz roach from the Hampshire Avon at Fordingbridge. 
 Builder Les, from Aldershot, Hampshire, went in search of a big roach after banking a 27 lb 1 oz pike earlier in the season but his efforts had produced only chub until this capture. 
 &bquo;When I arrived at the river I wasn't at all sure I was doing the right thing because the water temperature was 4.1 degrees Centigrade and the air temperature was 1.8 degrees,&equo; said Les. 
 &bquo;It wasn't long before I had my first bite which was a 3 lb 7 oz chub. 
 I had two more chub in quick succession to 2 lb 14 oz and then the last bite of the day produced this roach &mdash; what a fish!&equo; 
 Les, 46, made the great capture using maggots on a size 18 hook fished with a feeder on 3 lb line with 1.5 lb bottom. 
 The fish earns our &pound;40 Predator Baits big fish picture of the week award. 
 &bull;Self-employed sales rep Dean /verbar; Lomas put in a night at a lake near his Sheffield home to bank this 22 lb mirror carp. 
 The specimen mopped up a boilie on a size 6 hook to 8 lb line. 
 The session also yielded a 19 lb 3 oz leather carp. 
 MAGIC FOR MICK 
 Two 5 lb chub from same swim. 
 Mike Dinnigan didn't allow the frosty weather to stop his fishing and landed two 5 lb plus chub from the same swim. 
 The National Association of Specialisht Anglers member put in a couple of days on the River Swale at Topcliffe in North Yorkshire to take six chub over 4 lb, including specimens of 5 lb 13 oz and 5 lb 12 oz. 
 &bquo;The river had been ten feet up the previous week and I thing the chub had been pushed into the swim,&equo; said Mick, 33. 
 &bquo;But it also meant a lot of brances had been washed down and the river has a lot of snags anyway. 
 &bquo;The line just went solid with the 5 ob 13 oz fish see-sawing around a snag and I was sure the line would go. 
 A similar thing happened with the 5 lb 12 oz fish but I had luck on my side.&equo; 
 Both chub smashed the Bramley, South Yorkshire angler's previous personal best and the biggest specimen measured an impressive 23 inches. 
 All the chub fell for quivertipped bread flake link legered on a size 8 hook to 4 lb line. 
 Chadwell Heath, Essex engineer David Williams visited a London AA stretch of the River Thames near Goring in Oxfordshire to bank a hat trick of big chub. 
 David, 29, included specimens of 5 lb 10 oz, 5 lb 3 oz and 4 lb 10 oz in one session with the biggest fish setting a new personal best. 
 &bquo;I had just one fish from the swim the week before but this time had five botes and took four fish,&equo; said David. 
 The chub fell for double bronze maggot on a swimfeeder rig, 3 lb main line, 2 lb bottom and 14 hook. 
 CLUBS TO TACKLE THE MINK MENACE 
 An emergency meeting has been called for clubs leasing stretches of the Macclesfield Canal in a bid to find a solution to an increasing mink problem. 
 Clubs with water between Congleton and Kidscrobe are to thrash out the best way of removing the mink which have spiralled in numbers. 
 British Waterways and the Ministry of Agriculture have been approached by fishing clubs in the region to help rid them of the menace which is depleting fish stocks in the canal. 
 With more than 30 different sightings of mink in a recent five hour match at Kidsgrove and Scholar Green, anglers have agreed the time is right to remove the killers 
 BW's chief fisheries officer Tom Leatherland said: &bquo;Until this week I had no idea that the mink problem was so great on the Macclesfield Canal, the most northerly point we have had the animals reported to us. 
 &bquo;Mink are unnecessary killers and have a habit of decimating fish stocks if left to breed at the side of fisheries, so I will help the local clubs to get rid of them as soon as I can,&equo; he added. 
 The battle to rid the canal of mink is being organised by Mow Cop AC secretary Phil Carr who put out an appear for other clubs with a mink problem to contact him. 
 So far 11 clubs have agreed to meet at the Nelson Pub in Brownlees on February 20. 
 BW, MAFF and the National Rivers Authority have also been invited. 
 MAIL BOX 
 &bull; Neville Fickling is guest speaker at the next Pike Anglers' Club Lea Valley meeting on Tuesday, February 26 at Chestnut FC in Theobalds Lane, starting at 8pm. 
 Dead Fish frozen into oil-hit Grand Union 
 Anglers discovered dead fish frozen into the Grand Union Canal when they arrived for a major match. 
 But the stench of diesel oil gave away the fact that the fish had not been killed by the bad weather. 
 Now British Waterways fishing experts are to investigate the deaths at West Drayton on the outskirts of West London. 
 Browns team member Stuart Redman, from East London, one of the first to discover the dead Fish, said: &bquo;It was an awful sight, the canal was frozen over and a carp of 10 lb, bream to 2 lb, roach and a tench were lying dead on top. 
 &bquo;Anglers broke the ice to fish and diesel bubbled up to the surface. 
 It absolutely stank. 
 &bquo;The match went ahead though and the catches were obviously low from the polluted stretch. 
 &bquo;When I got home I called the NRA freephone pollution number and I was told it was too dark and cold for anyone to go down and somebody would be there first thing in the morning. 
 &bquo;They haven't been in touch with me since so I'm wondering what they're going to do about it,&equo; said Stuart. 
 Trev's Browning skipper Tony Marti said: &bquo;We fished a Super League practise session last September and we saw an oil slick coming down the canal then. 
 &bquo;I called the NRA and they sent someone down to soak up the oil from the surface with sheets of foam. 
 They told me they'd found the source and they were going to prosecute the offender. 
 &bquo;During the latest match anglers found the fish dotted along the stretch frozen in the green-oil-based ice. 
 I have a feeling it's coming from the same source. 
 It's been going on for long enough and I think something should be done about it,&equo; he added. 
 British Waterways fisheries officer John Ellis said: &bquo;The pollution is news to me. 
 I shall have to investigate the matter with the NRA. 
 &bquo;I'm surprised they haven't told me. 
 But I can assure you appropriate action will be taken when we have found the guilty party&hellip;&equo; 
 NRA Thames Region spokeswoman Sharon Bolton said: &bquo;We had a call late on Sunday night and it was too dark to do anything so we went down on Monday morning and although there was evidence of oil there was not a sufficient amount for concern. 
 &bquo;Regarding the September issue, we are positive the matter is not connected and we are still gathering evidence to prosecute the culprit,&equo; she added. 
 Postie delivers giant roach 
 Postman Anthony Creed is determined to smash the 3 lb roach barrier and he's already well on his way after landing a 2 lb 12 oz beauty from a private stretch of the Hampshire Avon. 
 A change pf tactics and a cast towards the middle of the river provided the specimen during freezing cold conditions. 
 Anthony said: &bquo;It was my first fish over 2 lb. 
 My previous best was 1 lb lighter. 
 I fish most weekends and I don't mind what I catch, I'll fish for anything, so this fish was a real bonus. 
 &bquo;It had been a quiet day and I had only caught a few small dace and then my rod thumped round. 
 I thought it was a big chub and was surprised to see the red fins when it surfaced. 
 Legered double maggot on a size 14 hook to 1.5 lb line worked for Anthony, 50, from Bournemouth, Dorset. 
 MAIL BOX 
 London's Raven AC have rescheduled their 250 peg Keith Record Memorial on the Regents Canal for this Sunday, February 17. 
 Details from Mac McEndoo on 081 743 3381 or 081 904 4988 (evenings). 
 FISH OF THE WEEK CONTEST 
 How to enter 
 If you hook a specimen fish in 1991 then make sure you tell the Mail. 
 Our Fish of the Week contest offers superb prizes from the best selling DAM range and it's easy to enter. 
 Complete the form (below left) and post it to our Newsdesk immediately. 
 A copy of the rules is available (send SAE) but the Editors decision is final on all matters. 
 No correspondence will be entered into concerning adjudications. 
 The star prizes 
 COARSE 
 TWO WINNERS &mdash; Quick CD 142 Match reel plus 100 metres of Tectan 3.1 lb line. 
 the reel features carbon body, push button spool with line clip, stern drag. 
 Auto manual internal trip bale. 
 Silent anti-reverse, folding handle, hook retainer. 
 Weight 335gm. 
 Gear ratio 4.8:1. 
 Damyl Tectan 3.1 &bquo;lb line has a 0.12mm diameter and excellent knot-strength. 
 SEA 
 TWO WINNERS &mdash; Quick Fighter 60 fixed spool. 
 One of the best selling reels of its type. 
 A no-nonsense, metal bodied model capable of swallowing 225 metres of 20 lb line. 
 Gear ratio 4.4:1. 
 Front drag and skirted spool. 
 PLUS bulk spool containing 760 yards of 15 lb Damyl Surfer mono. 
 &bull; Kenny Gates and Mark Fitzwalters had a frantic battle with these mirror carp after getting takes within 30 seconds of each other from the same swim at Old Hall Lake in their home county of Essex. 
 The Harold Hill pair used almost identical methods to lure the mirrors with Kenny (right) taking a 21 lb 6 oz specimen and Mark a 21 lb 4 oz fish. 
 Both used home-made boilies with 8 lb line and Silkworm hook length. 
 Kenny used a size 8 hook and Mark a size 8 bent pattern. 
 WASTE PLAN SPARKS WORRY FOR THE EDEN 
 An angling club has condemned plans for a hazardous waste storage site on the banks of the River Eden. 
 The treatment station, for Alco Waste Management, is to be built alongside the river on Carlisle's Willowholme Industrial Estate. 
 It will deal with a range of industrial chemicals and toxic substances from around the county and anglers fear the river could be hit by a major pollution. 
 The Eden was contaminated with ammonia in 1987 by Express Dairies who were recently forced to pay &pound;113,000 in compensation following action by the Anglers' Cooperative Association. 
 Tommy Graham, Carlisle AA secretary, said: &bquo;We do not object to the company, it is the location that is going to cause problems. 
 &bquo;If the river is contaminated with toxic waste then there is every possibility all river life would be killed off for generations.&equo; 
 The association's concerns have been backed by the National Rivers Authority who said in a letter: &bquo;The site and building is on the flood plane of the River Eden and the flooding of the area and the building cannot be discounted.&equo; 
 But Carlisle city planners say the site presents no danger to the river because strict conditions will ensure waste products are handled correctly and they have given the go-ahead to the scheme. 
 &bull; Lake Windermere in Cumbria is becoming a health hazard because of raw sewage and litter, experts have warned. 
 It is the victim of too many boats discharging effluent straight into the water according to lake ranger Tony Hill in his annual report. 
 He claims the lake, which holds good pike, perch, trout and char, smells of sewage in warm weather and its shores are strewn with condoms and sanitary towels. 
 Lake District Planning Board chairman Robert Addison, agreed with the report and described the current state of the lake as &bquo;appalling&equo;. 
 &bull; A Welsh angling club has issued posters warning possible polluters that the River Taff and its tributaries are not a rubbish site. 
 Merthyr Tyfil AA are concerned thousands of fish could die because of continual pollution, particularly from factories. 
 The posters will be sent to companies calling on them to be more careful. 
 ELECTRO FISHING FINE 
 A fisheries consultant has been fined &pound;500 by Ely magistrates for electro fishing a lake without National Rivers Authority permission. 
 David Quelch of Buntingford, Herefordshire, admitted using the device to remove fish at a pit in Haddenham, Cambridgeshire without consent but claimed he was carrying out a health check on behalf of the owners. 
 Quelch claimed he had verbal consent from the NRA. 
 But checks by officers showed permission had not been granted. 
 Mr Quelch was ordered to pay &pound;150 costs on top of &pound;400 for using the device and &pound;100 for removing fish. 
 NRA Anglian Region spokeswoman Nina Miller said: &bquo;We hope this case will act as a deterrent to anyone thinking of doing something similar. 
 &bquo;Electro-fishing can be dangerous to both the user and the fish if they are not experienced.&equo; 
 ACTION REPLAY 
 DOUBLE FEEDING GETS A QUICKER RESPONSE 
 The River Nene around Peterborough has really come on form for roach in the last few months, despite the weather, with double-figure hauls of quality fish commonplace. 
 Nene regular and local matchman Alan Dean, an Oundle team member for five years, has notched up a succession of competition placings on the river, including runner-up this season in the Nene Team Championships. 
 We joined Alan on a &pound;1.50 day ticket stretch to check out his winning methods. 
 9.10am 
 The weather has not been kind to the river in recent weeks and today is no exception. 
 I have decided to fish permanent peg 458 at the Orton upstream stetch of the Nene, near Peterborough, a consistently productive area, even when the fishing's hard. 
 The water is a muddy brown colour, fining down after heavy rains, and three continuous nights of hard frost have frozen the margins. 
 Flow on this stretch is usually sluggish but today, with the extra water, the flow is much quicker but I should still be able to use a waggler. 
 9.30am 
 I have set up a Mormark Microlite 13 foot float rod, a Shimano 2500S reel loaded with 2 lb Maxima coupled with a 1.5 lb Double Strength hook length. 
 To save time I make up my float rigs beforehand and put them on pole winders. 
 This rig includes a home-made peacock waggler, with a sarcandas reed insert. 
 It will be fished with 2AAA and 1BB bulk locking shot with three No.6s grouped at half depth with a No.6 and a No.8 spread equally between the bulk and the hook. 
 The rig is about ten feet long and is attached by a blood know to the main reel line. 
 9.45am 
 I always take a lot of care plumbing the depth, and even though I know this peg well, I will plumb it again. 
 The depth is about six foot along the middle, which is the line I will fish, hoping to catch roach to 12 oz. 
 My single bronze maggot bait on a size 20 Kamasan B510 barbless hook is set to trip through the swim one inch off the bottom to stop it dragging in any rubbish. 
 My first fish after 15 minutes is a 2 oz roach. 
 10.05am 
 The state of the river and a temperature barely above freezing means it is going to be hard today but I will still feed about a dozen maggots when I cast in, and them the same again when the float is halfway down the swim. 
 This double feeding is used to get the fish to respond quicker. 
 A little skimmer bream is my fourth fish of the day and the first I have had to net. 
 Now I know there are some fish willing to feed I will cut down my feed rate to a dozen maggots only when I cast in. 
 10.20am 
 I have been missing a lot of bites and assuming they are false takes &mdash; probably on the shoe &mdash; I will replace the No.8 with a No.12 Styl, hoping to eliminate the problem. 
 I will also introduce a few grains of hemp into the swim along with the maggots to try and bring the bigger dish onto the feed. 
 The main reason for fishing the middle line of the river today is that with a head wind it is the safest distance for me to be able to loosefeed easily. 
 11.05am 
 This is my best fish so far, a 10 oz roach. 
 Unfortunately, after a shower of icy rain the temperature has dropped even lower and I am finding it very difficult to move my fingers, they are so numb. 
 11.50am 
 Although it is winter time I am not afraid to move my bait higher in the water to keep in touch with the fish. 
 Some anglers add depth to their rigs to take more fish but I have found on the Nene shallowing up can bring better results. 
 I have altered the depth consistently during the day and have tempted some fish almost two feet off the bottom. 
 12.40pm 
 Although the fish are feeding, it has been spasmodic which could mean there is a pike in the swim. 
 It is a common problem along this stretch containing such a fine head of roach but the lulls in the catch rate rarely last longer than ten minutes. 
 2.15pm 
 After I introduced the hemp earlier the fish seemed to go off the feed so I only introduced it for four or five casts. 
 To see if the fish are interested now, because they are still interested in bronze maggot, I will put a grain on the hook. 
 The float shoots under with the hemp, and a 6 oz. roach comes to the net. 
 2.30pm. 
 I have taken a couple more roach to hemp and reckon i have about 14 lb in the net. 
 Time to go home to a warm fire. 
 This is excellent sport in these conditions. 
 I can only wonder at the fish that would have been caught when the river had fully fined down. 
 ANDY LITTLE'S CARP WORLD 
 Advice spot special 
 ALTERNATIVES TO THE HAIR 
 My club control a water I have been carp fishing for the last three seasons and have just imposed a hair rig ban. 
 I cannot understand this as I cannot see any detrimental effect on the carp. 
 What do you think? 
 Can you suggest alternatives to the hair to use in conjunction with quite hard boilies? 
 J. H. Wootton. 
 Hampshire. 
 It is difficult to understand the politics within some controlling bodies without knowing all the details and it is difficult for me to comment. 
 One can only assume that your club committee have the welfare of both the fishery and your fish at heart which we should not knock. 
 However, I have certainly not experienced damage caused by hair rig fishing to any carp in the last decade. 
 It may be it is not the hair itself but possible the style of fishing associated that could be the problem. 
 The hair rig has been a great leveller of angling ability and because on most waters it is self-hooking this can often lead to complacency on the angler's part. 
 No longer does he have to hover over the rod trying to strike at the slightest movement. 
 Lack of takes may induce him to wander and do a complete tour of the lake whilst his rods are still &bquo;fishing&equo;. 
 I am sure this would only be a minority but it is always the minority that spoil it for the majority. 
 Looking at it from the club's point of view I can see how this ban arose in a situation like this. 
 As for rigs other than the hair for boilie fishing there are of course plenty of alternatives. 
 I would suggest some sort of exposed hook set up and here are three of my favourites. 
 1. 
 A side-hooked boilie. 
 With this set-up the hook to bait ratio needs to be the equivalent of about a size 10 fished with a 14 mm boilie. 
 Always try to expose as much of the hook as possible but without risking the boilie parting from the hook during the cast. 
 It is just a matter of lightly pushing the point of the hook into the skin of the boilie by about one eighth of an inch. 
 The boilie is then rotated round the bend so it comes to rest half way along the shank. 
 A chemically sharpened hook with this set-up will give you a greater percentage of pricked fish as the carp draws the bait in and then ejects. 
 Variation 
 I like to use a Drennan Super Specialist pattern in these circumstances, the size 10s are quite a tough hook and with the thick wire gauge relative to the size of the hook they retain the boilie very well. 
 2. 
 A variation on the same theme, the top mounted boilie utilises the same pattern of hook and bait to hook size ratio. 
 I find this set-up more useful in weedy swims as the boilie protects the point of the hook. 
 It is also very good with a buoyant or pop-up boilie set-up and for long range work casts slightly better than the side-hooked option. 
 3. 
 The eye-mounted bolt rig. 
 This was my most productive rig prior to the hair and I have used it since on waters where the hair has been banned. 
 It works best with a large fine wire hook. 
 Originally I used the Match Blues, unfortunately these are very difficult to get hold of these days. 
 I now opt for a Gamakatsu 6318. 
 This does not have such a wide gape as the March Blues but is still relatively long in the shank. 
 This means you can still get the whole of the bend and point of the hook completely clear of the boilie. 
 The size of hook to bait ratio changes dramatically. 
 With the same 14 mm bait I will now be using a size 4 and possibly a size 2. 
 The idea is to present as much of the hook out of the bait as possible to ensure maximum contact with the carp's mouth. 
 This set-up needs to be fished with quite a heavy lead of 2 oz plus and a short hook link of between five and seven inches. 
 Although these rigs will probably be slightly less successful than the hair they will still be consistent catchers but a little bit more attention needs to be paid to ensure that the bait is correctly mounted. 
 Sorting out the biggies 
 I am having problems selecting the larger fish in my water where the average run of the mill fish are between 2 lb an 4 lb. 
 There are some good double but I haven't caught them. 
 W.D. 
 Gloucester 
 On this type of water it can become the luck of the draw with so many small fish out numbering the larger carp and it is difficult to be selective. 
 The bigger fish will turn up haphazardly to almost anyone. 
 There always appears to be great competition for food on these waters and very often it is just a case of the more successful angler reducing the odds against catching the larger fish. 
 I know W.D. 
 has experienced the same thing as we all have. 
 He is merrily accumulating a large bag of smaller fish when Fred Smith comes along with inadequate tackle, throws a lump of luncheon meat in the margins and lands the largest fish in the lake. 
 I am afraid this will always happen. 
 On some waters you can gain a degree of selectability by using harder and larger diameter baits. 
 For instance it could be a good idea to introduce your free boilies at 12 mm or 15 mm and use hook baits of 18 mm, 20 mm or maybe even 22 mm. 
 This will not stop you catching the smaller fish but it may swing the odds in your favour of selecting one or two of the larger fish. 
 When the greed factor of competition feeding is present the smaller fish will more readily take the easier to handle smaller baits giving the larger baits a little more time to intercept one of the better fish. 
 Sweetcorn, chickpeas or maples may well be the going bait and it could then be an advantage to fish a couple of very large jumbo tiger nuts of half a brazil nut over the top of the baited area. 
 The one thing that does not seem to work in these situations is to use a large pop-up fished over the bed of baits. 
 I think this is because the pop-up is much more noticeable and less selective. 
 I remember only too well trying to beat the smaller fish in a French lake by using three 18 mm diameter pop-ups on the air. 
 This failed and actually caught more than a single 18 mm bottom bait. 
 I was staggered they managed to get such a large mouthful in a relatively small mouth! 
 ABOVE: Ben Weaver hooked this 19 lb 2 oz specimen in the nick of time &mdash; a few moments later gale force winds made fishing impossible. 
 Ben, 13, from Sheffield, and his father Alan made an early start to bait up a north Nottinghamshire lake with fish flavoured boilies and Ben landed the common on a size 8 hook hair rig. 
 BELOW: England international sea angler Mick Toomer ended his hunt for a 30 lb plus pike with this terrific 30 lb 6 oz specimen from a home counties lake. 
 Mick, who has taken a number of 20 lb pike from Essex waters this winter, travelled further afield from his Basildon home and fished a Predator Baits' frozen mackerel on 11 lb line and two size 8 barbless trebles. 
 BONNER'S THE MAN TO WATCH 
 by Colin Mitchell 
 The Kamasan Matchman of the Year race is heading for its tightest-ever show-down with at least half a dozen anglers in the hunt for the most sought-after title. 
 Long time leader Dave Berrow hasn't scored since November and his 43 point haul is now just three in front of former title winner Dave Harrell and four ahead of inform Denis Bonner. 
 And it's Daiwa Trentman Denis who is the angler all of the front runners fear in the run up to the end of the season. 
 The Geordie who moved from Newcastle to Nottingham so he could regularly fish the Trent is rated by Frank Barlow as one of the country's best float anglers &mdash; and accolades don't come much higher than that! 
 But Dave Harrell, the Walsall angler who won the Matchman of the Year title two years ago, also admitted: &bquo;Denis is red hot at the moment and I think he is definitely the one to beat. 
 &bquo;I've had a touch of the Dave Berrow's recently and just can't score points. 
 Mind you, I've been keeping up the ice dance so all the canals are frozen and he can't get a match to fish,&equo; joked Dave, who runs Midlands Angling Products. 
 Harrell now plans to search out his matches carefully in a determined bid to re-capture the title. 
 If he does, he will join former England man John Dean as the only person to ever win the award twice. 
 Dave Berrow, who has had committments to his Browing Starlets side which has cost him the chance to fish some possible points earning events, admits that the draw bag hasn't been kind to him for quite a while. 
 &bquo;Having been so close to winning the title in the past few years I thought this was going to be my chance but the draws have just dried up and I can't seem to get near fish,&equo; said Dave from Hednesford, Staffordshire. 
 Current Matchman of the Year John Allerton has made a late surge up the tale to eighth position and although he is always a danger the Tri-Cast Barnsley's star's run may be just too late to make the very top. 
 Tyne to Trent move paid off 
 Denis Bonner's rise to the top has been meteoric. 
 It has taken him just five and a half years to make his mark in the big time. 
 When he moved from Newcastle-upon-Tyne to Nottingham he made the journey down the A1 for better fishing and the chance to learn from big name anglers. 
 &bquo;But it's all gone past my wildest dream,&equo; said Denis, 39, who has the full support of wife Lynn and three youngsters. 
 &bquo;You can't help but learn from people like Wayne Swinscoe and Frank Barlow and other great anglers who live in this area. 
 Everything has gone right since we came here,&equo; said Denis who now has Wayne Swinscoe as a neighbour and occasional drinking partner. 
 The Avon, Severn and Trent are all likely to feature in Denis' matches for the rest of the season, although he is likely to stay away from events close to home where the meat has become the number one bait. 
 LEFT: Painter and decorator Kevin Barton latched into this early 2 lb 14 oz plaice during a session at Lepestone Point in Hampshire. 
 Kevin, from Lymington, also beached flounder to 1 lb 12 oz using ragworm on a size 2 hook to 15 lb line. 
 The specimen was taken from the eastern side of the sandbar just as the tide began to ebb and came the day after Kevin had taken a 2 lb 8 oz flounder from the same spot. 
 RIGHT: This 22 lb 8 oz pike set a new personal best for police officer Paul May during a session at a West London pit. 
 Paul, 27, from Hanworth, Middlesex, spent a blank five hours at the water and had just changed swims when the pike took a float fished trout on 12 lb line with size 8 barbless trebles. 
 Fishing partner Mark Chambers landed a personal best 18 lb 4 oz pike. 
 Bob Gledhill's Sea Gossip 
 Now Who's Primitive? 
 Aren't freshwater anglers a funny lot? 
 I heard over the weekend of a terrible fuss because one club member was proposing to use an echo sounder to help locate fish on a lake. 
 It seems the member is also a keen saltwater angler and normally carries the sounder on his boat for hunting cod. 
 Because he wanted to use it to locate carp and pike he was getting some fiery abuse. 
 It was not the boat aspect of his idea, rowing boats are permitted on the lake, but some of the club members are saying echo sounders are unsporting. 
 There was even a muttering that the echo pulses could frighten or harm fish. 
 The latest outcome is there is move to ban the use of electronics on the lake. 
 And they tell us sea fishing is primitive in its thinking. 
 THE DANGERS OF FISHING FOR TIDDLERS 
 A match planned at Seabrook in Kent next month will use the controversial system of counting undersisized fish towards the final result. 
 The idea is that while undersized fish will still be returned, their capture will earn a consolation point for the captor. 
 Setting aside this particular match and looking at the idea on a broader basis, I see a rough ride ahead if the idea spreads. 
 Its roots come from the Continent, where many shore matches reward the capture of undersized fish. 
 They have to, because years of pillaging have made sizeable fish from the shore hard to find in places like France, Belgium and Holland. 
 I know from bitter experience there is nothing more frustrating that to keep catching fish that just miss the line when the fellow next to you only gets one, but its nose nudges over the line. 
 That is down to little else but bad luck. 
 The situation hasn't been helped by the downward spiral of the quality of our native shore fishing coupled with an upward tweaking of many minimum size limits. 
 Dabs, flounder and whiting are three species that are often caught in great numbers from the shore yet often fail to make the measure. 
 In team fishing it can be demoralising when the score sheet says you have contributed nothing, while the truth is you have fished your heart out, caught several fish but they missed the mark. 
 The danger is tne new system could encourage the deliberate fishing for small fish. 
 It may well become obvious that more can be gained from tiny hooks and tiny fish than using more orthodox tackle and regarding undersize fish as as nuisance. 
 That would make match fishing from the beach into a farce and would be guaranteed to drive away competitors even more than the current poor fishing. 
 The amount of small fish that swim behing the breaker is enormous. 
 Whenever I pull a shrimp net there are scores of little fish caught. 
 But the greatest dilemma would be the matter of how small a fish is eligible for weighing in? 
 Using a pole, fixed line, size 24 hook and wisp of fish or half a harbour rag it would be possible to catch fish an inch long one after another. 
 Should there be a lower limit for undersize fish? 
 Then, how long before somebody proposes giving points for undersized fish that did not make the undersize fish measure? 
 Navigator price is bearing up. 
 There must be hundreds, maybe thousands, of sea anglers who have fitted a Decca-receiving navigator to their own boat. 
 With sets like the Navstar 2000D and the Decca Mark IV costing &pound;560 they are within the reach of many serious boat anglers. 
 Yet anyone who has been using one in the last few months will know, the accuracy of the sets in winter can be very poor. 
 I regularly get total signal failure and if I followed some of the compass courses displayed I would never be heard of again. 
 This is not the case with the new satellite system called GPS. 
 This give almost unfailing accuracy no matter what the weather conditions. 
 The problem with GPS is that like all new gadgets, the companies are wanting to recover development costs as quickly as possible and they are very expensive. 
 The first sets a few months ago were well over &pound;2000 which would put them out of the range of all private and a lot of charter boats. 
 Competition and mass production is now changing that. 
 The Earls Court Boat Show last month saw the launching of a GPS set called the Pronav for &pound;1,495, including VAT, and other sets have begun to tumble in price. 
 My local electronics dealer tells me he is confident that there will be GPS under &pound;1,000 within six months and then the real price war will begin as the manufacturer battle it out for the lucrative yacht market. 
 Wyre Boat Club 
 A lead story in Bob Gledhill's column headlined &bquo;Beware of Non-Fishing Bureaucrats&equo; (November 24 issue) criticised one of local boat clubs for failing to invest in electric winches and described the committee as &bquo;armchair rulers.&equo; 
 It was claimed that the chairman never went fishing and did not own his boat. 
 No club was named in the piece but Wyre Boat Angling Club have complained to Angler's Mail that they recognized themselves as the targets of Bob's attack &mdash; and say his comments are inaccurate, totally unjustified and reflect solely a minority view. 
 The club fear that other anglers in their area have also recognised the Wyre Boat Angling Club from the article. 
 Wyre anglers, including members of the committee, voted at their annual meeting last March to purchase an electric winch at a cost of &pound;285. 
 The club states that all major financial decisions, other than those connected with the day to day running of the club, are put to the membership for approval. 
 The chairman of Wyre has his own boat and goes fishing on a regular basis. 
 Other members of the committee, together with the general membership, also fish as often as possible when weather and tide allow. 
 Angler's Mail and Bob recognise that the criticisms were not fair and withdraw them with apologies to the Wyre Boat Angling Club. 
 ZANDER EAT INTO CLUB'S MATCHES by Sue Will 
 A zander explosion in the Coventry Canal is forcing anglers to cancel matches and seek alternative venues. 
 Nuneaton AC scrapped plans to keep a match booking on the canal when the predators threatened to ruin their 80 peg Open. 
 Official Alan Grimshaw said: &bquo;The present zander problem prompted us to cancel the match. 
 &bquo;There's a lot of zander throughout the canal and I think we'll be leaving it until next season before we reschedule the match,&equo; he said. 
 Roger Pimlott, secretary of controlling club Coventry DAC, said: &bquo;The zander in the Hartshill stretch are a new problem. 
 Although it has been electrofished I believe it's not an efficient method of removing the smaller fish in the 4&ndash;5 oz bracket. 
 &bquo;British Waterways assure me something will be done about it. 
 Obviously we lose money if clubs start cancelling matches but we are fortunate to have alternative waters,&equo; said Roger. 
 BW's fisheries officer Keith Fisher said: &bquo;I don't understand why Nuneaton cancelled their match. 
 We electro-fished the 3.5 mile stretch from Hartshill to Nuneaton and only found four zander. 
 We discovered plenty of small fish. 
 &bquo;We promised Coventry we'll have a look at the stretch again before the zander spawn in April. 
 The only thing I can suggest is there's a small pocket of fish causing the problem. 
 &bquo;We are planning to electrofish the North Oxford junction later this month but it really depends on the weather. 
 &bquo;We have visited Hawkesbury Junction twice now, once in November when we caught 256 zander and in December we removed just 14. 
 We are hopeful these figures show the numbers are reducing but it's hard to say for sure. 
 &bquo;We only electrofished four miles of the open ended canal and it's possible the fish could have survived and moved in the 20 mile stretch before the locks. 
 If we are controlling them we shall restock the venue with small fish,&equo; he added. 
 Thieves Take League Details 
 Sundridge Super League North East Division Two organiser John Davis has issued an urgent appeal for team captains to contact him after thieves stole his car containing all of his tackle and league details. 
 The car, a VW Golf, was parked outside a friend's house in Otley, West Yorkshire, and later recovered in nearby Shipley with all the contents missing. 
 The teams who should contact him are Big Waters, Middlesbrough, Kingfishers, Firpac, Horbury MG, Tackle Box Cleethorpes, Drax, Driffield, Beverley, Saltaire, Scunthorpe, Ryburn and Barnsley. 
 His numbers are: 0943 467203 (day) and 0943 463283 (evening). 
 Thanks my son 
 Warehouseman Lee Seary is secretly glad his six-year old son became tired while playing a pike &mdash; because he took over and landed a personal best 27 lb specimen. 
 Lee, 32, from Waltham Abbey, Essex, was getting ready to pack up after a biteless morning when his self-cocking float carrying a half mackerel slid away. 
 &bquo;I hit the fish and stright away though it was a good one, but my son Tony has never caught a pike so I handed him the rod,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;He played it into the side but it powered off again and he complained that his arms were hurting, so I took the rod back from him and landed the fish,&equo; he added. 
 Banking 
 The pike was beaten on 10 lb line at a gravel pit near Chestnut, Hertfordshire. 
 Portsmouth AC member Pete Tann went on a roach fishing trip to the Hampshire Avon at Fordingbridge and ended up banking a 23 ob pike. 
 Pete got fed up with the slow roach sport and decided to switch to a spinner. 
 Hastings, Sussex angler Martin Hemsley float legered a sprat in 20 feet of water at his local Buckshole Reservoir to catch the largest pike from the water for several years. 
 The 22 lb 4 oz specimen was landed on a single size 8 treble to 9 lb line. 
 Chris Clark on shorefishing. 
 Safety must come first 
 The modern trend of using crimps for holding hooks lengths in position has produced a number of worrying implications. 
 The real danger of these rigs was hammered home recently during a small Open match which saw me ducking for shelter. 
 I had just left the shelter of my brolly as a pout started to rattle my rod tip when a 5 oz sinker ripped a hole through my brolly. 
 The trace from a chap 20 yards up the beach had snapped in half as full power was applied to a pendulum cast. 
 For a few seconds I was left shell shocked but I was quickly brought to my senses after seeing the broken rig. 
 All the right components had been used for a power casting rig, 60 lb main trace line, heavy duty swivels along with good links. 
 But all this had been wasted by some heavy handed crimping. 
 The crimps had been used to hold in position the three small swivels that connect to the hook lengths. 
 The main problem when using crimps is you can't actually see whether any damage has been done to the main line when the pressure is applied to the crimp. 
 If this process is done with a proper crimping tool there is very little chance of serious damage, although in this case it seemed by the damage done to the line that a normal pair of pliers had been used. 
 With such a tool it only needs a little extra pressure to severely weaken the main trace line. 
 To make matters worse the angler was using a rig he had bought from his local tackle shop. 
 Over the last few years there has been a dramatic increase in the number of rigs available from shops. 
 Many meet the strictest safety standards but there are a few exceptions. 
 Economics play a major role in dictating a rig's safety. 
 Constructing terminal tackle of this nature is a time consuming occupation although there are a few that try to cut corners to maximise profits. 
 You cna't blame tackle shops and manufacturers for trying to streamline their production, but when other angler's safety is put at risk questions must be asked. 
 It's far better to spend a few extra minutes making a trace 100 per cent safe, even if it means putting a few extra pence into the finished product. 
 The Point of Bulk Buying 
 There's a considerable saving in buying hooks in bulk but only a small percentage of anglers make use of this facility. 
 For the angler who only makes a few sorties a year it makes sense to buy hooks in smaller units like packets of ten. 
 Packaging and handling charges do not come cheap, so what's the point of paying for ten plastic packets along with the extra labour when you could buy one box containing 100 hooks and save up to 33 per cent? 
 Most of the popular brands are available in larger units. 
 Storage is one stumbling block, hooks quickly deteriorate once they have been exposed to saltwater spray. 
 A simple solution is to use an old film canister and carry just a few hooks leaving the open box at home out of harm's way. 
 Top Beach Marks Hill Head, Hampshire. 
 Location 
 At the mouth of Southampton Water between Lee-on-Solent and Stubbington, Hill Head is popular with match anglers. 
 There is easy access along the whole venue. 
 Potential 
 Flounder are the principle species taken from this shallow venue although bass, eels, pout, rockling, plaice and the odd cod do show. 
 A large sandbar is uncovered on low water Springs just north west of the nature reserve which is a prime area for larger species over low water. 
 Flounder show during January and February with day sessions best. 
 As darkness falls just the odd rockling and pouting are left. 
 March is slow although flounder start to return as April approoaches, but many are in poor condition. 
 The odd plaice show throughout May along with bass and a few early silver eel. 
 The flounder population is also on the increase. 
 Bait robbing crabs appear during June, July and August when night tides produce quality eels with pout and the odd bass. 
 Flounder become the number one during September and October. 
 Eels, pout, bass and the odd sole figure on night tides. 
 Throughout November and December a few big cod can be taken over low water from the end of the sandbar on night tides. 
 Bass will figure from the point with a few double-figure fish. 
 Baits 
 The tide retreats several hundred yards during Springs uncovering large shellfish and bait beds along the entire venue. 
 Rag, lugworm, whites, peeler crabs, whelks, shrimps, cockles and even odd razor-fish can be collected. 
 There's also a good head of clams which are collected commercially over bigger tides. 
 Ragworm is the principal flounder bait with the exception of May and June when peeler crab will produce. 
 Peeler also works for pout, eels and the big cod. 
 A small live freelined pout is ideal for specimen bass. 
 Tides 
 The last three hours of the flood and the first two hours of the ebb are the prime feeding periods for flatties. 
 On the end of the sandbars the first two hours of the flood are best. 
 The bigger the tide the better the action. 
 There is a fair amount of tidal movement but 5 oz plain leads are the order of the day. 
 Breakaway-type sinkers are only used during rough conditions. 
 Weather 
 Calm conditions produce the best founder action. 
 A good chop is needed for other species. 
 The better cod are taken from the sandbar when the water is coloured. 
 Tackle and Tactics 
 Distance casting is rarely needed and a 50 yard job is more than adequate for flounder. 
 The bass and eels often feed at extremely close range. 
 A good thump is beneficial when cod fishing. 
 Standard two up and one down rigs armed with size two Aberdeens set the trend for flatties, eels, pout and rockling. 
 Codding calls for two hook rigs armed with Cox and Rawle 3/0 crab hooks. 
 Bass fishing with live baits calls for a fairly light spinning rod along with a fixed spool reel loaded with 15 lb line straight through. 
 The best action is at night. 
 These fish often feed within 20 yards of the beach and the slightest light reflection will spook them. 
 New man at the top 
 John Freestone is tne new Irish international manager following Bill Lawler's resignation due to ill health. 
 Bill had held the position for two years and saw the team achieve two of their best-ever results, sevenths in the last two World Championships. 
 Self-employed John, 48, from Dublin said: &bquo;I've been in the international scene for the past few years. 
 I worked beside Bill and when he had to resign it seemed appropriate for me to step forward. 
 &bquo;I hope fo carry on Bill's good work and keep things ticking over. 
 We have a good crew and don't expect any radical changes. 
 We're looking hopefully towards a win in the future,&equo; he said. 
 Team member Jack Tinsdale said: &bquo;John was Bill's right-hand man and has put a lot of time into the team. 
 He was appointed provisionally for one year by the National Coarse Fish of Ireland Committee.&equo; 
 CANAL SWIMS LOST AFTER GUN THREAT 
 Anglers have lost two sections of the Royal Military Canal in Kent after threats from angry house-holders &mdash; including one armed with a shotgun. 
 As reported exclusively in Angler's Mail, Kent-based Ashford AS gave up 12 miles of the canal after 88 years tenancy because of a long-running row with the National Rivers Authority's Southern region. 
 Now the club has revealed that major access problems culminated in one house-holder standing in his garden with a shotgun to put anglers off fishing near his house. 
 &bquo;For several years householders have been very anti to anglers at both the Ham street and Ruckinge ends of the water,&equo; said Robin Wadham. 
 &bquo;An NRA bailiff was bitten by a Newfoundland dog and during the Division Three National on the canal this year one man tried to stop anglers and spectators passing through his garden. 
 &bquo;He came out of his house with a shotgun and a dog and we had to call the police. 
 &bquo;These were very serious situations which we wanted cleared up by the NRA but they refused to do anything about it.&equo; 
 The problems arise from a legal peculiarity where the towpath is owned by householders but the fishing rights by the NRA. 
 In effect, Ashford were given rights to fish from the gardens but had difficulties even attempting to pass through to other swims they leased. 
 &bquo;The NRA would just not respond to the access problems while we had the lease,&equo; said Robin. 
 Now two small sections including one swim in each will not be included in any new lease. 
 NRA Southern region official Dr Binny Buckley said: &bquo;There are two freehold properties which own the land but the fishing rights actually belong to us. 
 &bquo;In future there will be no access through these gardens but it is only two swims and the rest of the canal can be accessed via other routes. 
 Book to Benefit ACA 
 Top specimen anglers have clubbed toogether to produce a book to boost the pollution fighting Anglers Co-operative Association's funds. 
 Printed by the Oxford Illustrated Press the Book of the Perch is a series of instructural chapters. 
 Among the contributors are Barrie Rickards, Vic Bellars, Tony Miles, Ken Whitehead, Archie Braddock, John Bailey and Dick Walker, with the widow's permission. 
 It is edited by Perch Fishers Club founder members Steve Burke and Pete Rogers. 
 Steve Burke said: &bquo;One hundred per cent of funds raised will go to the ACA. 
 We expect to raise many thousands of pounds and are hoping it will run into a second edition and provide the ACA with money well into the future.&equo; 
 ACA director Allen Edwards said: &bquo;It is extremely good news. 
 &bquo;On behalf of the association I would like to say how much we appreciate all their hard work and this very positive support. 
 The book will cost &pound;20 and is due to be released in the near future. 
 Further details from Steve Burke on 0233 732272. 
 Flounder go mad in Dorset 
 Dorset's Poole harbour has produced the most consistent run of specimen flounder for years with local rods bagging fish to 3 lb 10 oz during night sessions. 
 Local Gary Austin landed a 3 lb 2 oz 8 drm flattie during a Flounder League match and then topped it with a 3 lb 10 oz specimen while pleasure fishing. 
 Both flounder came from the Evening Hill shore mark to ragworm fished in just six feet of water on a size 2 hook to 15 lb line. 
 The Flounder League also produced a 3 lb 6 oz 12 drm fish for Southborne's Nich Edwards and a 2 ob 14 oz flattie for Reg Clough from Bowerchalk. 
 Ragworm was again the successful bait fished over the extensive lugworm beds at Evening Hill. 
 The same approach also brought a 3 lb 7 oz 8 drm flounder for Andy Stevens from Bournemouth. 
 &bull; Bradford specimen hunter Eddie Harrison banked this 2 lb 2 oz roach during a session on the Rive Aire in the Keighley area on a day when everyone else was blanking. 
 Eddie baited the swim with mashed bread and legered bread flake on a size 14 hook with 2 lb hook length and 3 lb main line to make the capture and added a small chub later in the session. 
 &bull;Surrey Elite Specimen Group member Derek Hack, 36, banked an impressive brace of double-figure pike from a Sussex river topped by this 26 lb 8 oz specimen. 
 A small float fished rudd bait on a size 8 hook to 15 lb line tempted the predator which was followed by another of 16 lb 8 oz an hour later for Derek, a tailor from Send, Woking, Surrey. 
 FRANK BARLOW'S WEEKLY REPORT 
 ALL CHANGE BUT I'M STILL IN THE MONEY 
 Saturday 
 What a nice change. 
 Last week there I was moaning about just two fish in three matches and this week I had more than 200 in two outings. 
 With the canal bank out of sorts, Tony Hanson ran a match on his club's water at Redhill Lock on the Soar. 
 This used to be one of my lucky venues and I have some real nice memories of bagging sessions and wads of notes. 
 But what a surprise when I got there. 
 It was so different even the weir had been removed which means the river at this point is some three feet shallower than when I last fished it. 
 I drew a peg in the bend which I had drawn some years before and knew there were a few fish there and decided on one rig only &mdash; the pole. 
 It was ten foot deep and I fished at 11 metres with a shortish line to get good control. 
 After a slow first hour I started to get a few better fish, roach and skimmers. 
 Then a nice roach of about 1 lb showed up. 
 I was doing quite well but knew I was well behind Tony the organiser who was bagging on the stick float. 
 I needed something special to pull this one out of the fire. 
 Well, it must have been my day as with half an hour to go I had just got to the end of my swim when the float buried and the elastic shot out. 
 This was a real proper 'un. 
 For ten minutes I never saw my float as the fish cruised up and down. 
 Eventually, it tired and came to the pan. 
 A lovely big fat rubber dub which went 3 lb 8 oz. 
 As the whistle went I thought it could now be a bit close. 
 I packed up and went to follow the scales and 7 lb was the top until it came to Tony who weighed 10 lb dead. 
 Then his son, Sam, weighed 2 lb. 
 We all reckon that being as the prize for lowest weight was a year on the Cambridge Diet he fished without any bait at all on the hook. 
 My old mate, Malc Bassford, had 3 lb next to me &mdash; he is definitely getting better as that is his best weight since he bagged up on the River Cam 20 years ago. 
 Then it was my turn &mdash; 10 lb 7 oz. 
 I had just beaten Tony thanks to that lucky chub. 
 There were several weights over 5 lb and it was nice to see plenty of fish caught for a change. 
 There's another one there next week so I'll probably be there again. 
 Good sport down the ice holes 
 SUNDAY 
 We had Liverpool superstar Frank Holden for company as we travelled down to the Twenty Foot river near March. 
 What a keen lad is Frank, leaving the &bquo;Pool at 5 am to come to our house and then all the way down there. 
 That's how I used to be until I had my brain overhaused last year. 
 What a shock when we arrived. 
 All that way and it was frozen solid. 
 An even bigger shock was in store when the organisers set to and began breaking out a peg for everyone. 
 That's what I call looking after your punters. 
 There was only one peg that was ice-free and I predicted that if anything was caught at all that peg would be the last to produce. 
 That always seems to happen when you break the ice. 
 The hole I drew was about nine metres out and I fished it with that length of pole and a short line. 
 Starting on the bread I had six small roach straight away, not a bad start under these Arctic conditions. 
 But at the next peg different things were happening. 
 There sat Tydd Gote superstar Paul Smith. 
 Now he is known best for writing and talking a good match. 
 Well, trust him to save his lifetime best performance until he draws next to me. 
 Every fish he got seemed to be a good 'un. 
 I was getting more fish than him but couldn't get the quality despite trying every bait in the book. 
 He was too far away from me to see what he was catching on. 
 When I shouted to enquire about his successful bait all he said was: Anything I put on. 
 Up yours, I thought and got my head down to extract everything I could. 
 I caught all through and finished with 7 lb 4oz but that was no match for Paul who took 9 lb 12 oz to the scales. 
 A marvellous weight under severe conditions, a real nice set of fish with roach of 1 lb 8 oz. 
 I was happy with second while Frank the Scouse was fifth with 5 lb 6 oz. 
 Our Dean drew the ice-free peg and never caught for the first hour, as I predicted. 
 He finished with 5 lb. 
 Paul told afterwards he had caught some of the quality fish on hemp seed. 
 That's the only bait I didn't have but, who would have thought that with ice about? 
 Probably only the Tydd Goter. 
 A final word of praise for organiser Bob Fitzjohn, for getting the match off the ground. 
 That was a feat in itself and his third-placed 6 lb 15 oz was just reward for his effort. 
 London AA Shield Preview 
 Match of Mystery 
 Two of London's top match teams head off on a magic mystery tour this Sunday with the historic London AA Shield as their goal. 
 Neither Brunswick Brothers AS from Docklands or Tile Kiln AS from Hackney will have a clue where the venue for the match is until they actually arrive. 
 The referee for this year is Defiant Mobile's Billy Waldron who can choose the venue from any river, canal, lake or reservoir. 
 And just to make things really tough the matches are rovers with each angler sent off one at a time to pick his swim, putting the emphasis on reading the water. 
 The two six man teams board a coach in the early hours of Sunday and can be driven around for hours before arriving at the venue of the referee's choice. 
 The match is often held on the Lea, Thames or Grand Union Canal and the bad weather will obviously play some part in that decision this season. 
 The organisers claim the format teaches lessons that stay with the anglers forever and top names like Dave and Mick Vincent, Andy Love, Keith Arthur, Jimmy Randell and Ray Mumford all graduated through Shield matches. 
 The forerunners of current Division One National champions Trev's Browning, Trev's Terrapins, have been winners of the Shield in the past. 
 Brunswick Brothers are the favourites to take the three foot high solver shield and join an elite band of four clubs who have won the competition three or more times since the first final in 1903. 
 Team captain Peter Blyth will be going for a hat trick of wins as captain &mdash; all with different teams. 
 Peter led both Tottenham Angling Centre and Jubilee AS to victory and has experienced men like former Essex County boss Dennis Salmon and Division Four National runner-up Dave Dunstone to call on. 
 Tile Kiln are in the final for the first time in 35 years of trying and include Brian Gladden, twice previous winner of the Shield with Defiant Mobile and Duke of Wellington, and former Defiant captain Billy Jones.  
 Mail Slough British Legion AS raised &pound;1,042 towards a hydrotherapy pool for the Wrexham Park Hospital, Buckinghamshire with their annual Chas Collins Trophy charity match on the Thames at Staines. 
 FRESH AIRE 
 The Aire and Calder Navigation has been stocked with 30,000 small fish released below Fish Ponds Lock south of Leeds &mdash; and it's set to receive more. 
 The General Purposes Committee of Leeds DASA linked arms with the Fisheries Management Committee to complete a netting operation on a private stillwater. 
 Leeds were given the fish by a benefactor, their task was to remove the many small roach and skimmer bream. 
 British Waterways have also topped up stocks in the same watercourse below Thwaites Mill. 
 They recently introduced 2,500 roach and a further 5,000 fish are in the pipeline. 
 GIANT COD FROM THE DEEP 
 A superb 44 lb cod has been caught by Penarth charter skipper Charlie Debaene just half an hour off the coast. 
 The brilliant specimen is one of the biggest ever boated off South Wales and came from the same mark which yielded Charlie a 33 lb 8 oz cod three years ago. 
 Charlie, 50, battled for 35 minutes to beat the specimen which was hooked in 70 feet of water half a mile off Stout Point near Aberthaw, Mid-Glamorgan. 
 The skipper of the Lady Hamilton also had to cope with a bird's nest on his reel halfway through the fight and had to strip off yards of line before he could resume the battle. 
 &bquo;The was just a small knock on the rod and I went for it,&equo; said Charlie, from Newport. 
 &bquo;At first I thought I'd hooked a tree because it felt so solid. 
 The fish made several deep dives and I began to wonder who would give up first, me or the cod. 
 The great specimen took a big bunch of ragworm tipped off with squid on a size 6/0 hook and was eventually brought aboard on 18 lb line. 
 Another big cod fell to Cardiff quantity surveyor Steve Williams on his first-ever fishing trip. 
 The 32-year old boated a 30 lb 8 oz specimen on lug and squid cocktail aboard Danny Williams' Swansea craft Lady Gail. 
 Carlisle sales rep Ian Cass made the short journey to top shore mark Balcary Point in south west Scotland to catch a 22 lb 8 oz cod. 
 Ian, 39, fished a bunch of lugworm on a size 4/0 hook to tempt the cod which was beached on 15 lb line. 
 Just Reward 
 Charity fundraiser Robbie Robertson has been awarded a trophy to mark his record-breaking marathon wheelchair journey from John O'Groats to Land's End. 
 Robbie, the National Federation of Anglers' disabled co-ordinator, raised around &pound;22,000 for charity from last June's trip. 
 He was awarded the Griffin Trophy in a ceremony at Torquay, Devon, to mark his achievement which provided a bus for a Sussex school for the physically disabled and around &pound;8,000 for the NFA's Ron Shirley Memorial Fund. 
 Trout get a jacuzzi 
 Trout in the River Wye at Loudwater, Buckinghamshire, are to get a touch of the high life with the building of a new jacuzzi-style weir. 
 The weir will be the second of its kind on the river and was designed by the National Rivers Authority to keep gravel spawning beds clear of silt. 
 The weir is formed of stones which shoot fine sprays of water up through the gravel on the river bed in a similar fashion to a jacuzzi. 
 Area fisheries officer Vaughan Lewis said: &bquo;The Wye has a healthy trout population but silting up of the river bed can be a problem. 
 &bquo;The new weir should provide a clean area which will encourage spawning.&equo; 
 The weir is the latest in a series of improvements on the Wye which have included the creation of reed beds, tree planting and habitat improvements to protect the native crawfish. 
 DOUBLE BLOW FOR ANGLERS 
 Midlands anglers are fuming over two rulings made by local councils which have struck a double blow to fishing in the Warwickshire region. 
 BLOW ONE: One of the best winter hotspots on the Warwickshire Avon has been lost to anglers following a decision by Stratford-On-Avon District Council amenities committee to ban fishing opposite the Hilton Hotel in the town. 
 BLOW TWO: Nuneaton and Bedworth Borough Council threw out plans to allow fishing on park lakes in the area. 
 &bquo;These are typical stupid decisions by anti-angling politicians,&equo; stormed Rugby tackle dealer and former National Champion Dave Burr. 
 &bquo;In the space of a couple of days local politicians have succeeded in dashing the hopes of thousands of anglers, and I feel it is just the thin end of the wedge. 
 &bquo;In this area angling seems to have been lumped together with bloodsports and some members of these councils vote automatically against anything that could benefit local fishing. 
 &bquo;In Stratford in particular, there is a hard core that hate anglers and they seem to be able to sway the rest of the council at voting time. 
 &bquo;I wonder if these councillors realise that anglers are among the people who vote them in in the first place, and who they are supposed to serve?,&equo; he asked. 
 Dave added the Nuneaton area was starved of good fisheries, and that the only choice for locals who don't wish to travel is a couple of stetches of canal. 
 The Nuneaton and Bedworth Council claimed it had received letters of protest from residents opposed to a trial scheme to allow fishing on three lakes in the borough. 
 Councillors were told anglers spoiled the enjoyment of members of the public who liked to stroll around the lakes, and labour councillor Owen Granfield expressed concern over the environmental impact of stocking fish into park lakes. 
 Meanwhile, at Stratford, the district council banned fishing on the popular 300-yard stretch of the Avon just above the swan sanctuary following complaints from nearby residents. 
 One, Yvonne Morgan, said anglers on the riverbank were an invasion of her privacy and claimed she had been subjected to abuse and foul language. 
 MAIL BOX 
 The West Sussex region of the Carp Anglers' Association have two meeting in Bognor Regis on Friday, March 29 and Saturday April 13. 
 Details from Simon Lee on 0243 824608. 
 Three meetings of the Carp Society's East London and Essex region have been arranged for March 28, April 25 and May 30 at the PTA club, Parr Road, East Ham. 
 Details from Danny Regan on 081 552 3795. 
 &bull; This 33 lb 12 oz pike was the result of a two year campaign at a Nottinghamshire gravel pit by Mansfield miner David Dare. 
 David, 38, with his brother Andy and fishing partners Kev Berry and Robin Clark have spent dozens of hours trying to take a big predator from the water. 
 It all came right for David when he legered a sardine on size 8 barbless trebles to a 20 lb wire trace and 12 lb line. 
 &bquo;I had my only run of the day at approximately 11 am and after setting the hooks I had a slow, dogged fight for about five minutes before netting the fish at the second attempt,&equo; said Dave. 
 The personal best pike measured a massive 45 inches with a girth of 24 inches and was returned alive. 
 Four share 172 lb pike haul 
 A small East Anglian stillwater yielded 172 lb of pike for four anglers from Heacham, Norfolk. 
 Bricklayers Trevor and Paul Framlingham, Cedric Hipkin and plumber Chris Palmer had 30 fish and lost another 12, using fish baits on 10 lb line in a 100 yard stretch of water. 
 Southern Ireland Match Guide 
 FESTIVAL PAYOUTS TOP &pound;15,000 
 The stakes are big in Southern Ireland's Close Season match fixtures. 
 The chance to fish against some of the biggest names in match angling and beat them can be too hard to resist, and the rewards are high. 
 Prize monies for this year's festivals look set to top &pound;15,000. 
 Festivals aren't only about fishing, most feature an after match disco and for the less energetic there's pool, darts competitions and singalongs in the local bar. 
 Venues for the 1991 events cover a whole range of waters from canal to rivers to lakes and results year after year confirm the Irish fish hhave no respect for big reputations. 
 Bream often have the biggest price on their heads but roach, rudd and hefty tench can provide a healthy bonus. 
 Feeder and float tactics are equally productive, and catches are likely to top 100 lb with 200 lb possible from waters like the Shannon. 
 THE MAJOR DATES 
 MARCH 29&ndash;31: Castleblaney Easter Festival. 
 Feeder and maggot expected to provide the winner in this two day event on Lough Muckno, County Monaghan. 
 Three man team and individual, plenty of prizes each day and overall. 
 Lots of roach and hybrids, 50&ndash;60 lb a good weight. 
 Limited to 51 anglers. 
 Leisure Angling sole selling agents, package deals from &pound;99. 
 Telephone Leisure Angling on 051 734 5200. 
 APRIL 22&ndash;26: Bailieborough Spring Festival, County Cavan, organised by Leisure Angling. 
 Likely to be a feeder match, with big weights. 
 Roach and bream the target, 60 lb plus needed to win depending on bream. 
 Plenty of prizes, team and individual contests. 
 APRIL 28: Edenderry Open, County Offaly. 
 On the Grand Canal, bream expected but good back up weights of roach, rudd and hybrids possible. 
 Pole and maggot should win. 
 25 lb to 30 lb a good weight. 
 Also Opens here on July 28 and August 18. 
 MAY 4&ndash;11: Farney Festival, County Monaghan. 
 Expected to attract top names. 
 Carrickmacross has a reputation for double-figure bream, but there is good mixed sport. 
 Feeder and maggot and pole should score. 
 60 lb plus a good weight. 
 MAY 5&ndash;9: Prosperous Festival, County Kildare. 
 Attractive match for disabled anglers with easy access. 
 On the Grand Canal with bream and rudd mainly to pole and maggot. 
 Should yield 35 lb plus nets. 
 MAY 13&ndash;17: Galway Angling Festival. 
 New event sponsored by Flanagan's Travel boasts &pound;1,000 in prize money plus pools and trophies. 
 Fished over three days on the prolific rivers and lakes around Galway, bumper catches expected. 
 Large shoals of roach, bream and hybrids likely with 100 lb plus nets possible. 
 Pleasure bags have topped 300 lb. 
 Details from Glanagans on 0203 597000. 
 MAY 18&ndash;25: Ballinasloe Festival, County Galway. 
 Excellent social event and good fishing. 
 River Suck bream around 5 lb, with 50 lb plus needed to win, probably on the feeder. 
 MAY 19&ndash;24: Ballybay Festival. 
 Will be won with bream, possibly 100 lb plus. 
 Limited to 60 pegs and very popular. 
 Features lake fishing for mixed species, 4 lb to 5 lb bream the target. 
 MAY 27&ndash;31: Fermoy Festival. 
 A hit with stick float anglers but could be won on the pole or waggler. 
 River Blackwater's roach and dace the target. 
 Top weight around 60 lb. 
 Team and individual event. 
 JUNE 29 &mdash; JULY 6: Athlone International Festival. 
 Fished on the Meadows and Burgess Park stretches of the prolific River Shannon. 
 100 lb plus bream haul expected each day. 
 Limited to 80 anglers. 
 Team and individual events. 
 JULY 28 &mdash; AUGUST 3: Belturbet Festival. 
 Three figure weights possible. 
 Fished mainly on the Erne, bream and roach on the pole and feeder. 
 JULY 31 &mdash; AUGUST 7: Arva Festival, Cavan Feeder orientated festival fished on lakes should produce good catches of bream, roach and hybrids. 
 SEPTEMBER 1&ndash;7: Drunconrath Festival, County Meath. 
 All methods productive. 
 Fished on lakes in the Drunconrath area. 
 Pole, waggler and feeder could score. 
 Bream and roach expected but big tench and hybrids can boost catches. 
 Target 60 lb. 
 SEPTEMBER 10&ndash;15: King of Clubs Championship, County Cavan. 
 Premier event with over &pound;10,000 in prize money plus pools and trophies worth an extra &pound;6,000. 
 Limited to 180 anglers. 
 SEPTEMBER 14&ndash;21: Monaghan Paris Championships, County Monaghan. 
 Organised by Leisure Angling. 
 Fished on Lough Muckno for bream, roach and hybrids in expected nets to 70 lb. 
 Two and a half tons of fish taken in last year's event. 
 About &pound;6,000 of offer. 
 Further details from Leisure Angling. 
 SEPTEMBER 15&ndash;21: Carrick-on-Shannon Festival, Leitrim. 
 A good entry expected with pegging on a new stretch of the River Shannon and Lough Bran. 
 Bream expected to feeder, 100 lb plus bags possible. 
 SEPTEMBER 21&ndash;28: Cootehill Festival, Cavan. 
 Top class lake fishing, bream likely to feature in winning weight which could be in three figures. 
 Individual and team event. 
 OCTOBER 23&ndash;27: King of the Shannon, Athlone, Westmeath. 
 Big catches possible, 200 lb bream nets recorded. 
 Worm a favourite with feeder for shoaled up bream. 
 Shannon should be in top form for this event. 
 Limited to 80 anglers. 
 Anglers World are planning a Southern Ireland Festival for October, venue and date to be confirmed in the next few weeks. 
 Details from Martin Founds on 0246 221717. 
 Shannon Holidays of Chesham, Buckinghamshire are organising coach trips to Southern Ireland incorporating sea and coarse matches from April 27. 
 The trips will be to the Clare Lakelands and Shannon. 
 Accommodation will overlook Lough Derg. 
 Contests will be staged on the Shannon for rudd and bream. 
 Pleasure fishing will be available. 
 Prizes include free holildays and trophies. 
 Details from 0494 772728. 
 Northamptonshire's Cliff Smart's Angling Holidays are offering up to &pound;500 in prize money for winners of certian angling festivals if you book through them. 
 The festivals include Cootehill, Carrick, Arva, Belturbet, Athlone, Fermoy, Ballinasloe, Prosperous and Farney. 
 Details from 0536 724226 or 725453. 
 RIVER REPORTS 
 ANGLIAN 
 Ancholme. 
 Patchy and unpredictable. 
 Cadney one of the few bright spots. 
 Main sport for small roach plus perch and ruffe. 
 Maggot on pole or waggler. 
 Lower Great Ouse. 
 Roach the main target, fish to 1 lb 4 oz in match returns nearing 20 lb at Ten Mile Bank. 
 Limited bream activity below Lark Outfall, fish to 3 lb through to Littleport Bridge. 
 Catches of 10 lb possible. 
 Opposite the old beet factory at Ely, roach to 8 oz in catches from 6&ndash;10 lb. 
 Cut-Off Channel patchy, although roach nearing 2 lb in pleasure nets to 14 lb at Hilgay Bridge. 
 Odd bream to 4 lb. 
 Relief Channel patchy. 
 Middle Level Drains. 
 Frost and hearby snow reduced fishing. 
 Twenty Foot at Hobbs Lot Bridge gave pleasure catches to 10 lb with roach to 8 oz, and match returns to 8 lb. 
 Old Nene in March around Wigston Bridge offers roach to 1 lb in nets to 10 lb. 
 Roach at Priory Sluice. 
 Odd tench to 2 lb from clear stretches. 
 Nene. 
 Much harder. 
 Some reasonable nets of roach possible along the upper river from Thrapston to Wansford with waggler best. 
 Chub in Peterborough section, fish to 4 lb 8 oz at Alwalton and Milton. 
 Small maggot feeder fished against far bank best. 
 There should be some reasonable roach catches possible from just above Milton Bridge and downstream to Orton Weir, but below the weir poor. 
 Peterborough Embankment roach to 8 oz fair sport around the new road bridge. 
 Norfolk Broads and Rivers. 
 Most venues iced-up and sport generally poor. 
 Try upper, fast flowing reaches and millpools. 
 Upper Wensum above Norwich for chub to 4 lb, odd roach and dace, mostly between Hellesdon and Norwich ring road. 
 Waveney in the Bungay area for chub to 5 lb. 
 Tiday Wensum through Norwich in form for small roach, dace and bream in weights to 12 lb. 
 Middle of the day best period, maggot or caster top baits. 
 Tiday Yare at Thorpe, Thitlingham and Brundall offers fair sport. 
 Head for tidal boatyard dykes and basins when thaw sets in, as excellent sport expected. 
 Waveney at Beccles, the upper Thirne between Martham and Potter Heigham, the Bure at Weoxham and Horning and the Wensum and Yare in the Norwich to Buckenham area all recommended for roach and bream. 
 Few pike showing, but an improvement expected. 
 Welland. 
 Dace and chub around Stamford and Deeping St James, with catches of small roach and skimmers possible in Spalding town. 
 Wide river around Crowland poor. 
 One or two big bream, including fish over 8 lb. 
 Witham. 
 Before snow, the area below Bardney Bridge was fishing well for roach to 14 oz in midweek hauls to 13 lb. 
 Waggler or pole with bronze maggot best. 
 Southrey good, lots of roach nets around 6&ndash;7 lb with 15 lb possible. 
 Waggler and bronze maggot best. 
 Pound length inconsistent, but can produce weights to 9 lb. 
 Tattershall Bridge area good for mainly snall roach to pole or waggler. 
 The 320s near Skirth Outfall best for 5&ndash;6 lb nets. 
 Jimmy's Hill in excellent form, with 420&ndash;440 the best pegs for 15 lb bags. 
 All drains, including the Hobhold and Bargate, frozen. 
 Expect a few small roach and skimmers on pole and squatts when after the thaw. 
 NORTHUMBRIAN 
 Tees. 
 River in sparkling form before cold weather. 
 Nellies Beck on the tidal could produce decent dace and roach, but tide critical. 
 Chub the mainstay upriver, with bread top bait. 
 Over Dinsdale for nets to almost 40 lb and Croft for swimfeeder nets to 16 lb. 
 Grayling in upper reaches, some pike around Darlington. 
 Tyne. 
 Dace nets to 6 lb from the Wylam area. 
 Feeder aend maggot most productive. 
 Slacker swims best. 
 Once snow thaws, expect poor sport. 
 Wear. 
 Pegs from Lumley Bridge to the day at Chester-le-Street most productive for dace. 
 Fish tend to be small. 
 Stick float and maggot best. 
 Durham Ice Rink fair for dace and roach plus the odd grayling. 
 NORTHWEST 
 Bridgewater Canal. 
 Odd skimmer and some roach fron Warrington water to ice breakers before the deep freeze. 
 Bloodworm took 2&ndash;3 lb catches at Trafford park. 
 Leeds-Liverpool Canal. 
 Good bags of roach to punched bread from Parbold and Dover Lock on Leigh Arm before worst conditions. 
 Roach and perch in 6&ndash;7 lb bags on caster along Leigh branch and Common Lane. 
 Skimmers, roach and small perch from most Liverpool sections but pike active. 
 Plugs took fish to 16 lb plus numerous jacks at Brewery Land bridge. 
 Ribble. 
 Grim, with only a handful of swims producing modest bags of 2 to 2 lb 8 oz chub on feeder. 
 Best avoided until normal conditions. 
 Macclesfield Canal. 
 Slow, even before ice, with small roach and perch. 
 Should revive quicker than most waters once thaw sets in. 
 Shropshire Union Canal. 
 Most sections frozen but prospects good. 
 Most anglers are concentrating on the Tiverton and Beeston sections where roach and skimmers are taking punched bread and gozzer. 
 Chriselton similar, but the usually prolific Church Eaton a major disappointment. 
 Trent and Mersey Canal. 
 Match bags to 2 lb on pinkie or punched bread before total ice cover. 
 Weaver. 
 Carp to 12 lb on boilies off boatyear before sub-zero temperatures. 
 Some small roach but patchy. 
 All species showing from Northwich town centre, but no quality fish. 
 Moving stretches yielded big roach in nets to 15 lb to stick float and maggot. 
 SEVERN TRENT 
 Severn. 
 Snow, water and severe frosts hit sport although still some action with grayling in upper reaches. 
 Roach to stick float and maggot at Shrewsbury, with the chance of bonus chub. 
 Odd chub to swimfeeder, maggot or bread at Ironbridge. 
 Chub at Bridgnorth on milder days. 
 Action at Bewdley mainly from deeper, slow swims for chub and roach. 
 Roach to 2 lb 8 oz at Stourport plus some dace, with float and single maggot best. 
 Top swims below Mucky Meadow. 
 Holdt Fleet for some roach, bream possible from deep swims. 
 Roach target at Bevere, mixed catches from Grimley and Hallow. 
 Worcester chub tightly shoaled on Cleve Lode, where 35 lb possible. 
 Few anglers bothering at Tewkesbury. 
 TEME. 
 Cold and little activity. 
 Few fish moving apart from small grayling to floatfished maggot. 
 Some chub at Ashford Carbonel, in mild spells and from deeper swims. 
 TRENT. 
 Fishing reasonable despite sub zero temperatures. 
 Very clear and fish tightly shoaled. 
 Long Higgin fished well for chub in the Manvers Field on long range feeder and maggot. 
 Pegs nine to 12 best. 
 Chub to 4 lb. 
 Parkside for lots of roach from the bend to stick and maggot but bream and chub dominate matches. 
 Burton Joyce gave a few big roach catches. 
 Chub and meat baits have taken over for all the major weights. 
 Waggler and meat best for weights to 30 lbs. 
 Gunthorpe with the exception of the first ten pegs which are giving 10 to 15 lb of roach the rest appear devoid of fish, Shelford for fish around Stoke Ferry land end and pleasure anglers getting 30 lb plus nets on stick and maggot. 
 Meat also scoring but weights not reaching 25 lb. 
 Caythorpe hard, odd catches on meat and 10 lb on maggot feeder. 
 Neward Dyke hard with few fish apart from the A46 bridge and Red Bridge section. 
 Winthorpe nets to 10 lb on stick and pole and similar catches on maggot feeder. 
 15 lb a brilliant weight. 
 Holme Marsh patchy, a draw below 30 prefered or blank a possibility. 
 Warwickshire Avon. 
 Dace and chub mainstay with roach hard to tempt. 
 Small chub at Warwick, fish to 2 lb at Hampton Lucy. 
 Some good chub on Lido sections at Stratford. 
 Waggler best. 
 Double-figure chub catches possible from above weir at Marlcliffe. 
 Quiet at Bidford, but short spells of action with chub and roach around midday at Welford. 
 Chub at Twyford, best action on top pegs and island swims. 
 Evesham best swims around bridge for chub to waggler and maggot. 
 Hampton Ferry lower swims best, bream could show on pegs in the low 30s. 
 Warmer weather needed to bring bream back on in Swans Neck area. 
 SOUTHERN 
 Arun. 
 Roach at Swan Meadow to waggler and maggot. 
 Railway Bridge area most productive with chub from Rother mouth on pole and maggot. 
 Stopham produced roach and skimmers on waggler and maggot. 
 Fish shoaled tightly above bridge. 
 Medway. 
 East Peckham, Farleigh, Marming, and Stilstead for chub on waggler and maggot. 
 Maidstone and Tovil for roach and dace on pole and maggot. 
 Rother. 
 Bodiam for roach on bread punch and pole. 
 Skimmers and roach at Newenden on pole and maggot. 
 Iden Bridge and Star Lock produced roach on waggler and maggot. 
 Royal Military Canal. 
 Iden stretch for small fish on pole and maggot in the deeper water by lock. 
 Kenardington and Warehorne for roach and odd bream on pole and caster. 
 Hythe for roach on bread punch and waggler. 
 Stour. 
 Grove Ferry only consistent area. 
 Bream and roach showing off the Ferry Boards and Boatyard stretches to stick float or feeder. 
 SOUTH WEST/WESSEX 
 Bristol Avon. 
 Heavy snow falls will affect sport, but river has been fishing well with good catches of dace and roach from Conham, especially around the footbridge and Boardmill. 
 Chequers fishing well off the boats and around the lone tree. 
 Jackie Whites for chub from the blockhouse, with one or two good roach bags around the outfall. 
 Crane for plenty of small fish from the bottom end, and some good nets of roach from the Ashtip Field. 
 New fence area for one or two good nets of chub. 
 Bittern Brook fishing well for chub and roach. 
 Swineford second field producing chub and a few good roach. 
 Kelston for good nets of roach, chub, perch and odd bream from pegs below the weir. 
 The sink peg and the point above for decent nets of roach. 
 Saltford slow in the trees, just the odd chub and roach. 
 Newbridge straight fishing well for roach and chub. 
 Rotork for good nets of chub from the toytown area. 
 Bath free water very good, plenty of small fish. 
 Bathford slow, pegs around the railway bridge best. 
 Warley poor, just odd chub. 
 Claverton manor field best, chub showing on the bend. 
 Limpley Stoke sewer outfall producing bream., with some chub throughout. 
 Avoncliffe very poor except for feature pegs. 
 Barton Farm and Chippenham slow. 
 Kellaways worth a try for chub. 
 Lacock good on the deep, fast glides with plenty of roach, chub and dace. 
 Melksham's Black Bridge producing some good nets of chub. 
 Christian Malford and Sutton Benger on form for roach plus occasional chub. 
 Brue. 
 Best of south west waters at the moment. 
 Good bags of roach and chub around Pompales Bridge and Blackhatches Weir. 
 Chub to 4 lb to bread or cheese on lead, maggot on float. 
 Dorset Stour. 
 Good bags of roach, bream and chub throughout. 
 Throop fishery giving up to 15 chub a sitting, including fish to 5 lb. 
 Bolder Weir for 11 chub a sitting, inlcluding fish to 5 lb. 
 Bolder Weir for 11 chub to 5 lb 2 oz. 
 Horsebeach for chub to 4 lb 8 oz. 
 School bridge area for chub to 5 lb. 
 Bottom boundary for mixed nets to 40 lb of bream and roach. 
 Barbel Corner gave chub, bream and smaller species. 
 Hampshire Avon. 
 Lifelands above weir for bags to 30 lb of roach and dace. 
 Red and white maggot top bait. 
 Pike to 17 lb 2 oz showing. 
 Kings Stream for good bags of dace and roach on trotted maggot. 
 Pike to 15 lb 2 oz. 
 Fordingbridge Park for good roach nets plus odd chub and dace. 
 Roach to 2 lb 2 oz reported. 
 Local Dave Swallow took a 5 lb 4 oz chub on trotted bread flake. 
 Bickley Millstream on form for bags of dace, small chub and odd better fish behind the industrial estate. 
 Huntspill, Exeter Canal, King's Sedgemoor Drain, Tiverton and Kennet and Avon Canals. 
 Frozen with little prospect of any sport. 
 Parrett. 
 Best catches from deeper water below Langport town bridge. 
 Fishing well for roach. 
 Above the bridge a few chub taken on waggler. 
 Fish to 1 lb 8 oz. 
 Taunton-Bridgwater Canal. 
 Around the locks, such as Mansell, a few small fish taken in clearer water to bread punch or pinkie. 
 Tone. 
 Only small fish showing in Newbridge area. 
 Fishing very hard. 
 Bronze maggot with waggler or stick best bet. 
 THAMES 
 Grand Union Canal. 
 Ice-breaking brought reasonable results at Berkhamsted, with roach, small skimmers and gudgeon. 
 Areas close to locks best. 
 Sewage outfall at Bourne End producing odd skimmers along with quality roach. 
 Sticklebacks and minnows a problem here and at Lady Capels. 
 Chub possible from the wides, booms and pegs near the Motorway bridge. 
 Most pounds frozen from Watford to London. 
 Odd sheltered parts of Regents arm ice free and have produced small roach catches to 3 lb. 
 Uxbridge flowing sections produced a few good roach to maggot. 
 Lea. 
 St. Margarets for fair roach and perch sport. 
 Bloodworm on the long pole top method. 
 Crown quiet, best chances of fish from the bridge up to the start of the conkers. 
 Meadow terrible. 
 Most of navigation from Wormley to Tottenham frozen. 
 Cooks Ferry and Stonebridge for a few small fish to bloodworm through the ice. 
 Odd quality roach and dace below Tottenham to float and maggot. 
 Mole. 
 Reasonable bet for some sport, chub main quarry in low temperatures with several double-figure bags recorded in one match on North Bank, Dorking. 
 Roach and dace not showing. 
 Steep banks dangerous with snow. 
 Thames. 
 Kelmscot and Radcot slow and patchy. 
 Pleasure anglers getting odd chub to big legered baits or maggot feeder. 
 Few small fish. 
 Oxford pleasure anglers getting good chub to legered bread flake. 
 Roach patchy. 
 Reading slow. 
 Windsor hard, pleasure anglers catching just odd chub. 
 Staines chub showing downstream towards Penton Hook, one angler has 12 to 3 lb 8 oz. 
 Chertsey and Laleham for odd chub to swim feedered maggot at Laleham. 
 Molesey and Kingston slow, only odd small fish. 
 Tiday usually safe for small fish but dace shoals not showing in cold weather. 
 Open match won with less than 2 lb. 
 Wey. 
 Godalming slow. 
 Pleasure anglers getting odd chub to big baits on leger. 
 Guildford midweek anglers had odd chub, match won with 6 lb, three chub. 
 Long pole holding back maggots good. 
 Bowers poor, less than 4 lb to win matches. 
 Woking improved and main river match won with 16 lb 8 oz. 
 During same match one angler had five bream for 12 ob 8 oz on legered bread flake. 
 Wet Navigation. 
 Mostly frozen over. 
 Expected to be unfishable for some time. 
 WALES 
 Dee. 
 Desperate from the Crook O'Dea to the Earls Eye with many dry nets. 
 Better returns from Farndon with dace. 
 Quality roach boosting returns in Chester, legered bronze maggot best. 
 Lugg. 
 At normal level but cold and clear. 
 Chub the main feeders and legered meat took a few fish to 4 lb at Mardon, Lugg Mill, Longworth Mill and Mordiford. 
 A few swims on the Frome at Lugwardine are turning up dace and odd chub. 
 Monmouthshire Canal. 
 Frozen throughout and fishing is impossible. 
 Monnow. 
 Sport poor in the cold, clear river. 
 Some chub below Vauxhall bridge in Monmouth. 
 Roach being taken from swims just above the by pass bridge. 
 Taff. 
 Despite the cold, river is fishing well. 
 Roach nets to double-figures at Halley Park and chub to 3 lb just above and below Western Avenue bridge. 
 A few dace at Black Weir. 
 Roach to 1 lb from the tidal around Canton Bridge. 
 Wye. 
 Low, clear and cold and sport patchy. 
 Heavy falls of snow will result in more cold water. 
 Prospects aren't good. 
 Graying the most reliable feeders on the upper river, fish to 1 lb 8 oz around Builth Wells, Llyswen and Erwood. 
 Chub to legered cheese paste and some pike to deadbaits. 
 Dace hard to find, even the Llynfi tributary at Glasbury is giving little. 
 The deep and steady Belmont stretch at Hereford gave good sport with dace from the pumphouse down to the town bridge. 
 Downstream, the Bartensham section is turning up some good roach. 
 Chub to 4 lb at Ross and matches won with over 20 lb of dace at Symonds Yat. 
 The bottom of this water is fishing well for roach. 
 Newport anglers Tony Croome and Ken Middle shared a 100 lb haul of fish to 1 lb 8 oz from an 11 foot deep swim in front of the Saracens Head. 
 YORKSHIRE 
 Aire. 
 Chub upstream of Keighley. 
 Bread best bait in Skipton area and good chub expected from Carleton reaches along with specimen roach. 
 Chub shoaled downstream of Kildwick Bridge, maggot took fair nets near the bridge. 
 Chub around Sutton Beck end and at top end of Steeton. 
 Bread and wasp grubs for good chub nets just above Steeton Bridge and around Silsden beck end. 
 Chub also at top end of Utley near the Ellpots, maggot favoured. 
 Small chub released at Utley failed to show. 
 Pike at Stocksbridge, try spinners. 
 Roach and small chub on the Roberts Park stretch at Saltaire. 
 Roach south of Leeds, good nets to caster upstream of Thwaits weir at Stourton. 
 Bream below South Accommodation bridge in Hunslet. 
 Good roach nets from First Avenue stretch at Rothwell. 
 Aire and Calder Navigation. 
 Newly-opened to anglers, and early reports encouraging. 
 Roach to 1 lb-plus and some decent hauls of skimmers from Goole railway bridge. 
 Rawcliffe bridge and behind Southfields Reservoirs. 
 Maggot taking the fish on pole. 
 Calder. 
 Brighouse for roach around Cooper Bridge to coloured maggots. 
 Legered worm for chub near the bridge. 
 Chub also near the island on the Wakefield Road section. 
 Odd bream on the Anchor Pit stetch. 
 Roach slow, best nets from Lillands Farm. 
 Derwent. 
 Graying around Yedingham. 
 Dace and pike at Crambe. 
 Swimfeeder tactics with maggot and wasp grubs took small chub above Stamford Weir. 
 Dace near the Viaduct downstream of Stamford Bridge, also pike. 
 Wasp grubs for chub and casters for roach at Scoreby and Kexby. 
 Jack pike downstream of Elvington dam. 
 Big pike around Thorganby. 
 Hull. 
 Roach plentiful at Beverly shipyard, with several over 1 lb 4 oz. 
 Leger and trotting tactics best. 
 Bream from pegs upstream of the shipyard, including odd specimens to 7 lb 8 oz. 
 Market Weighton Canal. 
 Level and colour good. 
 Ice expected to last some time, but look for a few skimmers and perch at Newport on pole and maggot. 
 Pike also active. 
 Nidd. 
 Grayling in the Pateley Bridge area. 
 Big shoals of grayling at Ripley and below Sawmills weir at Scotton, also chub. 
 Dace above Sawmills weir to maggot. 
 Wasp grub and maggot for chub on Chapmans and at Goldsborough. 
 Chub and bream at Cowthorpe. 
 Roach at Hunsinngore, bread flake for the specimens. 
 Dace and pike at Tockwith. 
 Dace near Hammerton railway bridge. 
 Ouse System. 
 Roach at Dunsforth between the Jungle and the Crow Tres. 
 Specimen chub expected in the Ferry Field and off the sandbed upstream of the stump to caster and bread. 
 Chub in the Little Fields and Sandersons. 
 Big shoal of roach at top end of Aldward. 
 Try meat for chub near Aldward Bridge. 
 Roach around the Willow Garth at Hunders Lodge. 
 Bungalows at Hunters for chub, and odd bream. 
 Roach and bog chub at Linton and Widdington. 
 Roach at Fulford, Palace and Middlethorpe Ings. 
 Skimmers and roach to maggot feeder at Acaster. 
 Selby Canal. 
 Little activity as canal is iced over. 
 Moderate catches of roach, chub to 2 lb and skimmers possible from Selby town lengths. 
 Maggot on wagglers or pole best. 
 Stainforth and Keadby Canal. 
 Keadby Basin in reasonable form for skimmers and chub, but generally hard and fairly unrewarding. 
 Mauds Bridge and Thorne lengths reasonable. 
 Swale. 
 Grayling around Catterick to maggot. 
 Bread and lobworms for chub at Swainby and Maunby. 
 Bread and cheese for chub at Pick Holl and Holme. 
 Wasp grubs for chub at Baldersby. 
 Chub to maggot around Skipton Bridge, try big baits. 
 Dace and roach on the Salmon Hall stretch but chub main target to big baits. 
 Roach and dace on Listers upstream of Topcliffe weir. 
 Chub below Asenby road bridge to maggot. 
 Dace and small chub at Fawdington also pike which could show at Thornton Bridge and near Brafferton Bridge, Helperby. 
 Ure. 
 Chub around ripon. 
 Caster best below Military Bridge. 
 Chub below North Bridge to maggot and caster, try bread around Hewick bridge for chub. 
 Roach at Bishop Monkton, pike around the canal mouth. 
 Maggot wad wasp grubs for bumper chub nets at Brampton. 
 Double-figure roach nets from Roecliffe around the A1 roadbridge upstream of Boroughbridge. 
 Quality chub on Roecliffe bottom. 
 Last season bream could show around Whitchips drain at Langthorpe. 
 Wharfe. 
 Dace and roach upstream of Wetherby weir on day ticket water. 
 Roach and big bream on the Grange stretch below A1 road bridge at Wetherby, also grayling. 
 Caster for roach below Boston Spa road bridge. 
 Dace in match nets at Smaws Ings along with chub, odd bream and pike. 
 Roach late showing at Smaws. 
 SEASCENE 
 WALES 
 Beach fishing from Swansea to Ogmore very poor and codling still hard to find. 
 Flounder caught at Gower and from the Loughor estuary where fish to over 2 lb taken. 
 At Mumbles only pouting and rockling. 
 Codling and small conger from Port Talbot breakwater and Sker Beach. 
 Odd cod from Porthcawl Pier and at Newton Point. 
 Boat sport quiet but big cod starting to show. 
 Best so far a 30 lb 8 oz fish from the boat Lady Gail. 
 Ogmore to Barry beach sport hit rock bottom. 
 Two club contests at Boveton Beach produced nothing and just a few codling from the whole stretch of beach. 
 Better chance of fish at Barry Docks where flounder and pouting taken on light tackle. 
 Boat fishing patchy, but odd big cod reported, best 44 lb aboard the Lady Hamilton off Aberthow. 
 Flounder to 1 lb the main species at Redwick, St Brides and Rumney. 
 Cardiff foreshore turned up a few conger and codling. 
 Penarth Pier worth a try for pouting, flounder and occasional just-sizeable codling. 
 Cardiff and Penarth charter boats took a few cod to 14 lb. 
 Local boats Michele and Leah James also took thornback ray to 12 lb and spotted ray to 5 lb. 
 Eastern winds have brought what had been fair sport back to a normal level for the time of year. 
 Only the off flounder left on the north bank at Portmadoc with no reports from the estuary. 
 Some nice dabs to 1 lb from the golf course beach at Harlech. 
 Rockling, dabs, odd flounder and school bass at night over the sandbanks at Llandanwg. 
 Flounder from the river mouth at Dalar to 1 lb 13 oz on razorfish. 
 Open beach marks at Dyffryn and Talybont have seen little angling activity with just the odd dab and rockling. 
 Barmouth north beach for dogs and dabs over high water. 
 No reports of flounder from the Nawddach estuary which has probably seen its worst for the species for more than ten years. 
 Towyn north beach good for dogfish but flounder and dabs reported from the southern section at Penllyn and the rifle range. 
 Rockling and odd dabs at Borth. 
 Some good whiting to 1 lb at Aberarth but few in number. 
 Unconfirmed reports of rays to 3 lb 8 oz from Aberporth rocks. 
 Day tides at Mwnt for dogfish. 
 School bass at night from the surf at Tresaith. 
 Just the odd flounder in the outer channels of the Teifi estuary. 
 A boat trip from Pensarn gave only small thornback and dogfish. 
 Whiting thin on the ground which is most unusual at this time. 
 Merseyside quiet with small codling, whiting and a few dabs the mainstay. 
 One or two sizeable codling at Seaforth and the One O'Clock Gun. 
 Dee estuary at Mostyn and Talacre disappointing, probably due to snow water. 
 Colwyn Bay and Llandudno for undersized codling, a few whiting and odd dab. 
 Boat sport off Rhos and Conway patchy, some days offering whiting to 2 lb and large dabs. 
 A lot of small codling in the Menai Straits, plus a few dabs to 1 lb at Port Dinorwic and Beaumaris. 
 Caim and Whitebeach for whiting, dabs and a few dogs. 
 Llan Carw whiting to 1 lb 8 oz with dogs, small pollack and a codling to 3 lb 8 oz. 
 Holyhead Breakwater, Chair Rock and Treaddur Bay yielding occasional cod to 7 lb. 
 Whiting to 1 lb and flats from the rocks at Ty Croes. 
 Dinas Dinlle for small codling and a few whiting. 
 SOUTH EAST 
 A combination of east winds and sub zero temperatures made shore and boat fishing difficult throughout the region although there is still the chance of odd big cod. 
 Main shore sport along the North Kent coast with flounder, harbour rag and king ragworm the tip baits. 
 Best areas include Shorne Fort at Gravesend and Rushenden Bay at Sheerness. 
 Occasional codling from the Broadstairs chalk ledges of stone and Dumpton Gap to peeler crab at night. 
 Ramsgate undercliff promenades and piers offer founder and rockling. 
 Boats fishing the Goodwins Sands can expect codling, thornback ray, whiting and dabs. 
 At Sandwich Bay plenty of small pout and dabs. 
 Odd codling to 3 lb at Sandown over low water. 
 Deal Pier for odd codling at night, best 3 lb 14 oz to Richard Tunnicliff. 
 Deal and Dover boats found a few codling at Fan Bay and other inshore marks. 
 Best taken aboard the boats Growler and Mariner 11 at 7 lb. 
 Pout, whiting, dabs and odd dogfish made up bags. 
 Dover Breakwater offered flounder, dabs and small pout with the inside wall best. 
 Dover's town beach for flounder. 
 At Folkestone some decent dabs from the pier over high water. 
 Folkestone boats struggled with only occasional codling inshore although the odd 20 lb fish still taken. 
 Seabrook and Hythe beaches for flounder, dabs and pout with razorfish best for the flounder. 
 Hythe Range to Redoubt Wall for dabs, pout and rockling. 
 Dungeness beach yielded dabs to black lugworm. 
 High water in the evenings best. 
 Dengemarsh for pout, whiting dabs and flounder. 
 Dungeness boats produced cod to 15 lb with dogs, pout and whiting. 
 SOUTHWEST 
 Intense commercial netting of wrecks has made life difficult for offshore charter skippers and anglers. 
 Few fish of note taken. 
 The reefs in deep water off Devon and Cornwall are fairly clear and have given steady sport. 
 Top fish a tremendous 37 lb ling from the Hands Deeps. 
 The specimen is believed to be a rough ground record for the south west. 
 Loads of ling between 10&ndash;20 lb with medium-weight pollack and good whiting. 
 Shore anglers enjoying one of the best flounder seasons ever. 
 Every tidal waterway in the region continues to give number of fish to 4 lb. 
 The Plym has never fished so well and enthusiasts report catches of up to eight fish per session with a high percentage of 2 lb plus specimens. 
 Best area for the small boat angler is the Exe near the Dawlish Warren spit. 
 Large numbers of flounder expected to stay in the rivers and estuaries until later this month. 
 Cornwall's Atlantic coast good for whiting and excellent bags of fish to 1 lb 12 oz after dark. 
 Cod to 9 lb with the best catches from Baggy Point along the coast to Ilfracombe and on to Coombe Martin. 
 Severe cold conditions could lead to a big increase in cod numbers. 
 Good coalfish available at many places. 
 WEST SCOTLAND 
 Lochryan shore sport poor with only a few dogfish from Old House Point and Lefnol. 
 Worm baits picked up a few small coalfish, codling and whiting. 
 Portpatrick rock marks gave occasional codling but mostly small coalfish and pollack. 
 Mull of Galloway rock marks for dogfish, small codling and coalfish. 
 Best results around East and West Tarbet. 
 Isle of Whithorn rocks produced catches of dogfish to 20 lb. 
 Worm baits tempted small codling, coalfish and whiting. 
 Best results from the eastern side of the Isle around Cairn Head up to Garlieston. 
 Worm baits tempted undersize codling and whiting from Borgue rock marks. 
 Ross and Borness for occasional sizeable whiting and small coalies. 
 Kirkcudbright Bay for codling during rough conditions with the Senwick shoreline for up to four codling to 3 lb a session. 
 Worm baits also tempted a few whiting and coalfish. 
 Marks around Torrs Point and Gypsy Point for decent catches of codling to 4 lb. 
 Whiting, coalfish and a few dabs to worm. 
 Abbey Burnfoot fished well over low water on night tides for a few decent codling. 
 Rascarell marks for odd cod to 10 lb along with whiting and dabs. 
 Worm best bait. 
 Balcary flat rock and point produced a few cod to 28 lb. 
 Big lugworm or lug and squid codktails took most fish. 
 Colvend and Rockcliffe coast gave cod to 16 lb. 
 NORTH WEST 
 Rough seas hit boat fishing off Walney Island and Barrow anglers unable to get out anywhere except in the Roa Channel where they found a few small codling and dabs. 
 Shore fishing in the north of the county moderate. 
 Some codling from the north promenade end of Maryport at night, best over high water. 
 Grasslot Beach also gave some fish during calmer conditions. 
 During south westerlies nice codling taken in the shelter of Maryport Pier. 
 Not much from Siddick or Flimby either high or low water. 
 Harrington rocks best at low water for odd big fish. 
 Poor in the estuaries in the northern half of Morecambe Bay and not much prospect of improvement. 
 Fleetwood charter boats able to fish the edges of the bay during unsettled weather but only found dabs and whiting. 
 Odd codling from the dumper buoy area. 
 Shore fishing at Fleetwood patchy, a few good fish over low water from Rossall area at night. 
 Conditions good for cod at Cleveleys and Norbreck at low water. 
 Beach capable of bigger cod in the next few weeks. 
 Cod of 14 lb and 11 lb at Anchorsholme over low water. 
 EAST 
 Kings Lynn to Southwold gave few flatfish and catches are very poor. 
 Odd codling at Trimingham and Mundesley, plus Yarmouth South Beach. 
 Harbour rag and lug top flattie baits. 
 Little prospects of boats getting out. 
 Southwold to Brightlingsea poor with flounder and dabs plus occasional sole and plaice from estuaries. 
 Boats taking occasional thornback ray, but cod scarce. 
 Orford and Aldeburgh deep water marks best. 
 Small pout, rockling, dabs and whiting from Felixstowe Pier. 
 Tilbury to Foulness boat sport poor, only dabs and flounder for most anglers in the Thames estuary. 
 Numbers of flounder and some large dabs from Thorpe Bay and Westcliff. 
 Dabs and flounder from the stem of Southend Pier, with undersized whiting a nuisance from the extension. 
 Sprat shoals concentrated in the Thames estuary.  
 Cornwall's Hands Deep Reef, a haven for the specimen hunter, yielded its biggest ling ever to Graham Andrews skipper of the Plymouth-based boat Franjo, when he boated this 37 lb giant. 
 The short session on the mid-tide paid dividends for the fish is believed to be a rough ground record for the south west. 
 NORTH EAST 
 Little boat activity in heavy seas and cold winds and shore anglers had better results. 
 Beadness Sker produced cod into double-figures on lug and frozen crab. 
 Bigger tides yielding best fish from marks halfway along. 
 Hauxley and Hadston beaches for cod to 8 lb, best results at high tide. 
 Bog Hole at Newbiggin gave John Bohill victory in the Shiremoor Open with three cod for 15 lb. 
 Newbiggin Promenade at high water produced good results, mainly cod to lug and mussel. 
 Lyneburn cod to 10 lb, mainly to lug and rag with razorfish a good alternative. 
 Sandy Bay for good bags of codling, mainly to lug and mussel. 
 some anglers had seven fish. 
 Cambois North Hole for cod to 6 lb and a few coalfish on frozen crab. 
 Whitley Bay beach for cod to 5 lb in heavy tides. 
 River Wear poor and upriver marks around the A19 road bridge best for flounder on a variety of baits. 
 Sunderland's Roker Pier produced odd codling, and a few coalfish. 
 Seaham area for a few codling in the harbour and from the Green Wall. 
 Colliery beaches produced some sizeable codling, although they are out numbered by undersized fish. 
 Horden and Easington best by night and Blackhall worth a try at the turn of the tide. 
 Crimdon produced a few good codling, but only at low water. 
 Hartlepool's Heugh Pier the only worthwhile mark in the area, although catches are small. 
 Redcar for some reasonable codling from East Scars. 
 South Gare offers a variety of small fish. 
 Some better fish at Skinningrove, with the turn of the tide best. 
 Whitby south rocks for sizeable codling, with the pier worth a try in rough conditions. 
 Commercial netting blamed for lack of cod on the Holderness coast. 
 Ulrome, Skipsea, Dimlington and Easington produced cod to 5 lb on lug or rag. 
 ENGLISH CHANNEL 
 Boat anglers out from Lyme Regis had varied action with an 18 lb turbot the most noticable specimen. 
 Weymouth boats took a number of rays from the Adamant Bank while marks just off Portland produced dogfish, pout, conger and occasional cod. 
 Chesil Beach gave dabs, pout and small whiting during daylight with odd dogfish at night. 
 Very little from Portland rock marks with the exception of Church Ope cove where odd cod and coalfish landed. 
 A few pout and small flounder from Swanage Beach at night, a 6 lb 2 oz bass also reported. 
 Quality flounder from the lower reaches of Poole harbour. 
 A league contest produced fish of 3 lb 6 oz, 3 lb 2 oz and 2 lb 14 oz. 
 Poole boat anglers found the going tough with just odd pout, dogfish, whiting and occasional cod. 
 Bournemouth beaches produced odd flounder at night with pout, rockling and flatfish at Friars Cliff. 
 Night sessions most productive. 
 Sandbars at Hurst Castle provided limited action during night sessions with small dabs, flounder and pout. 
 A few late cod from deep water at Lepe while flounder and odd plaice taken from the Stone Point section. 
 Lymington DSFC member Kevin Barton took a 2 lb 14 oz plaice along with half a dozen flounder in one session. 
 Calshot Beach produced flounder while sport slowing at Southampton Water. 
 Boats heading out past the Needles found just odd cod along with a few whiting, rays, pout and dogfish. 
 Marks in the Western Solent yielded odd double-figure cod from the Sowley section, Bramble Bank area also produced a few specimens. 
 Flounder from the River Medina, Bembridge and Yarmoutn harbours also produced odd flatties. 
 Beaches along the Western Wight produced limited action with Chale having the edge for pout and odd dogfish. 
 Stretch of beach between Fishbourne and Ryde Pier offered good flounder at night with odd dabs at Seaview. 
 Small pout and rockling at Sandown during night sessions. 
 Ventor boat anglers found odd cod, whiting and doogfish. 
 Langley Point and White Horses producing a few whiting and dabs to black lug. 
 Day sessions best. 
 Boats restricted to inshore but little feeding. 
 Cold snap hit Portsmouth sport. 
 Eastney and Hayling beaches quidt, although flounder and place have started to move inshore. 
 Ragworm and limpet top baits. 
 Langstone and Portsmouth harbours best bet for a few flounder, with Eastern Roadd, Porchester and the Oyster Beds top areas. 
 Hillhead for a few founder by day. 
 Gilkicker and Browndown yielding a few pout and dabs after dark. 
 Boat anglers at Dean Tail, The Nab and marks around the Isle of Wight had some whiting, pout, dogs and the occasional cod. 
 First run of plaice and some sizable dabs from Hayling Bay out to Dean Tail and along to the blocks at Southsea Pier. 
 Ragworm and spoon or beads best. 
 BRISTOL CHANNEL 
 Shore sport in the Avon area still poor but plenty of small codling and occasional dab from Portishead and Clevedon. 
 Most other marks only produced tiny codling. 
 Boats took one or two cod from deeper water but generally poor. 
 Odd cod to 10 lb from Hinckley Point to Kilve over low water but mainly small codling and whiting. 
 Burnham boat anglers enjoyed good sport with cod and a few dogfish and rays. 
 Watchet, Minehead and Porlock boats poor and several trips were fishless. 
 EAST SCOTLAND 
 Boat fishing poor and Berwick and Eyemouth craft report as few as four fish per trip. 
 Highly coloured water blamed for poor results. 
 Shore anglers fared better. 
 Peterhead area on song. 
 Pier produced cod to 4 lb on mussel and lug. 
 Arbroath cliffs produced cod to 5 lb on lug and rag when conditions allowed. 
 During heavy conditions, Arbroath Breakwater fished well. 
 Buckhaven and Dysart producing good catches of codling to 4 lb to lug and rag. 
 Weedy areas best. 
 Back of the swimming pool at North Berwick produced cod to 6 lb 8 oz., although a lot of fish lost in heavy weed.  
 This flounder brace earned Teignmouth, south Devon, angler Roy Repton first prize in last week's Anglers Mail Fish of the Week contest. 
 Roy beached the specimens of 4 lb 4 oz and 3 lb 6 oz during a session on the River Exe at Starcross to smash Teignmouth SAS's outer area shore-caught best. 
 Both fell to peeler crab on a 1/0 hook to 15 lb line to give Roy a unique double &mdash; before Christmas he took a 4 lb 7 oz flounder from the Exe to set a new best for his club's inner area record. 
 Junior Mail by Sue Will 
 WHAT A START! 
 Young Richard Kirk wasn't content with a fine 7 lb 2 oz bream when he ventured out with his dad on his first ever fishing trip &mdash; he went on to bank ten others to 6 lb! 
 The Liverpool youngster, who's only six years old, offered a caster, maggot and worm cocktail over a bed of hemp and groundbait and also caught other bream between 5 and 6 lb from the private Cheshire lake. 
 Richard, from Mossley Hill, cast 25 yards out into six feet of water and used a 2 lb hook length and 5 lb main line. 
 Windy conditions didn't stop the fish feeding at Long Load drainage channel at Martock in Somerset, as Matthew Lee discovered when he tempted a 5 lb 4 oz bream from the venue. 
 Matthew, 15, from nearby Montacute, touch legered double maggot on a size 16 hook to 5 lb line for the personal best fish plus two roach to 1 lb. 
 &bquo;The rod was really rocking on the rest and it was very difficult to see the bites. 
 &bquo;When I struck the bream tore off downstream and dragged me into some weeds but I eventually got it to the bankside,&equo; said Matthew. 
 Greedy pike was personal best 
 Oxfordshire youngster Ddavid Harrison had a battle on his hands when he hooked a 24 lb 5 oz pike on his first cast of the day at a local lake. 
 The big predator snapped up David's trout bait within seconds of it hitting the water under an over hanging willow tree. 
 &bquo;The pike slowly took line off the spool, I struck and then a 15 minute fight began,&equo; said David, 15, from Fyfield, near Abingdon. 
 &bquo;It took me three attempts to land the fish but eventually I managed to bring it in to the bank and my mate Paul scooped the net under it. 
 I was amazed, it's the biggest pike I've ever caught,&equo; said David who legered his trout bait on a size 8 hook to a 20 lb trace and 10 lb line. 
 James Rainbow fished his first ever pike session last week and caught the fish of a lifetime &mdash; a beauty of 24 lb 8 oz. 
 James, 15, from Stanford-le-Hope, Essex, trailed a plug in the ice cold water at Swanscombe Farm Trout and Coarse Fishery, Kent, and landed the fish on size 8 trebles to 6 lb line. 
 A 20 lb 10 oz pike from the Hampshire Avon near his home at Fordingbridge smashed Joshua Searl's previous best by 7 lb 8 oz. 
 Joshua, seven, landed the pike following a five minute fight after it had taken a dead dace to 15 lb line. 
 Middie Masters 
 There's 20 great prizes on offer each month in the Middy Masters contest, including top tackle items, a trophy, plus the chance to win &pound;300. 
 Entry forms should be available from your local tackle shop but if there's a problem telephone me on 071 261 6025 or write with details of your course catch. 
 We need to know your name, age, address and telephone number, the species caught, weight, tackle used and any further details of capture together with the venue. 
 Photographs would be appreciated. 
 You must be under 16. 
 Post your entries to Middy Masters, Angler's Mail, IPC Magazines, King's Reach Tower, Stamford Street, London SE1 9LS. 
 &bull;Wolverhampton teen-ager Lee Collings has got plenty to smile about &mdash;the carp he's holding is a personal best 19 lb mirror taken from a Shropshire syndicate lake. 
 Bait presentation wasn't easy for Lee, 15, as he cast a home-made boilie on a size 6 hook to an 8 lb hook length and 10 lb line into the wind. 
 &bquo;I managed to punch my boilie out to the edge of a gravel bar about 60 yeards out, but I had to play the fish towards the top as I brought it in because there are a lot of boulders on the bottom,&equo; explained Lee. 
 Chris Ogborne's Trout Beat 
 Saved by the rain! 
 If I had been asked at Christmas whether my home waters of Chew and Blagdon would be full by opening day, the answer would have been an emphatic no. 
 The lakes were at their lowest levels for 20 years, and Chew was lower than I can ever remember. 
 Yet in six weeks things have changed. 
 The Bristol area had over two inches of rainfall in two days during the first week of January, and that was followed by one of the wettest and stormiest periods for some time. 
 The region went from a drought order to having almost too much rain, and all in the period of two weeks. 
 It underlines just how anglers depend on the weather. 
 Over the last 30 years I have kept a fairly meticulous diary, and this includes not just fishing detail but an accurate record of the conditions. 
 The reason for this is that so much of the guesswork can be removed, certain weather conditions demand certain tactics. 
 In turn, these tactics demand certain fly patterns, and by relating it all together, I can predict, with surprising accuracy, the flies I'm likely to need on any particular combination of wind and weather. 
 Once you get into the diary habit, it really is no chore. 
 I now keep it going through the winter. 
 This is useful, because by comparing previous drought years like 1976, you can draw a lot of conclusions. 
 This year, it's almost uncanny how the conditions are a mirror-match for last year. 
 The January gales are the same, as are the floods and heavy rain. 
 Water levels are coming up at exactly the same speed, and Chew and Blagdon are even being visited by the same migrant wildfowl. 
 All this detail is directly relevant to the fishing. 
 For instance, the frost levels are critical. 
 Apart from the brief cold spell in late November, we have had very few hard frosts. 
 This is good news, because now water levels all over the country are rising so fast, it means the banks will be spared from the scouring effects of a hard winter. 
 This is also good for fly life in the coming season, all those eggs are now safely under a protecting layer of water. 
 Prolonged cold spells on reasonably full lakes are not a bad thing. 
 Few lakes or reservoirs start to warm up until late March, and the deeper ones are normally cold well into May. 
 The shallow bays may be a degree or two warmer, and are always the first place to look in the early days, but the deeps will stay cold until real strength returns to the sun. 
 Fish normally seek out the warmer shallows, and if there are a few days of sunshine before opening day then you will know where to choose on the bank. 
 At the moment, most reservoirs are filling fast. 
 In November and December last year the water tables across the land were depleted, but the majority have now been replenished. 
 Any rainfall now will just run straight into the lakes, and it really does look as though all the main waters will be at top level for Spring. 
 The rivers, too, will have a good flush through, removing a lot of the silt that built up during the drought. 
 I predict with some confidence that Chew and Blagdon will be at top levels for the start of the 1991 angling year. 
 The newly-flooded margins will be attractive to the fish in the first few days, until the sudden influx of size ten waders make them wary. 
 The great thing about having the lakes at top level is there is so much bank to choose from, and we are almost spoilt for choice. 
 This is not the case when the level is even just a few feet down. 
 For my money it can rain as much as it likes in the coming weeks. 
 I visited one of my favourite Wessex waters recently, Sutton Bingham near Yeovil. 
 This is a scaled-down version of Blaggdon, and has always been one of my early-season pilgrimages. 
 No matter how bad the weather, you can always find some sheltered stretches, and there is normally the bonus of seeing some of the first swallows and martins of the year as well. 
 It's a rather special feeling to stretch out on the bank, with a cup of coffee warming chilled fingers, and to know six months of the season is before you. 
 Apart from winter fishing, this is the first real outing of the year, and always a super ritual for my father and myself. 
 As February turns to March, I watch the evening weather forecists with increasing interest. 
 The pattern of weather systems is fascinating, and I try to predict the sport on opening day on the strength of them. 
 The one thing we all dread is high winds. 
 In such conditions, all the sheltered spots get overcrowded, and there is usually too much colour in the water. 
 Early season winds are cold and take away much of the pleasure. 
 Maybe we shall have one of those text book days of gentle ripple, high cloud and blue sky. 
 Even if we don't, I rather suspect we shall all be there! 
 HELPLINE 
 If you've a course fishing problem write to Dave Coster at Helpline, Angler's Mail, Kings Reach Tower, Stamford St., London, SE1 9LS. 
 Slippery Solution 
 I have a Matchman Hooktier which tends to put kinks in the hook length, especially when I use very fine lines. 
 Can this be prevented? 
 This problem is common with fine lines when you tie any type of knot which entails pulling the line above the hook to tighten up the knot. 
 Unfortunately this is the case with hooktiers. 
 My solution, as I do not use a machine for tying my hooks, is to tie reverse knots which do not put undue pressure on the section of line which ends up immediately above the hook. 
 The knot is tightened by pulling the end of hook length which is eventually trimmed off. 
 There are ways to get round your hooktier problem. 
 First, look at the make of line you are using. 
 Some brands tie better than others, having a more slippery surface. 
 One good example I recently reviewed in Angler's Mail was the Toray hook length monofilament from Normark. 
 Another possibility is to lubricate the line before you attempt the knot. 
 This helps to avoid the kinking up problem. 
 You can wet the line or spray it with a silicone floatant. 
 When tightening hook knots, pull the line very slowly &mdash; this helps to prevent heat from friction, which can so easily damage fine diameter monofilament. 
 Drift-Beating Shot Pattern 
 I am having difficulty holding a large waggler still on a 11 foot deep lake when it's windy. 
 Short of switching to a leger what can I do? 
 M.B. Suffolk. 
 This angler has tried going quite heavy down the line with three No. 6 shot, setting the tackle three feet over depth. 
 The problem is I don't know where he has been placing these shot. 
 The first adjustment I would make would be to try positioning the three to six No. 6 shot at one inch gaps, starting ten inches from the hook as in diagram A. 
 This loses a slight degree of sensitivity by not having a dropper shot but usually does the trick of holding the float stationary. 
 Several shot lying on the bottom act better as a brake if set slightly apart from each other. 
 This strung shotting technique often requires you to fish two or three feet overdepth. 
 It's a case of pushing the float up until it holds and doesn't drag under. 
 Another good way of beating drift in this depth of water is to fish a bottom end slider. 
 (Diagram B). 
 With a slider it is possible to fish a much larger grouping of bulk shot well below the drifting layers of water. 
 This is often enough to stabilise a big float rig. 
 If this tactic fails then I'm afraid you'll have to resort to the leger. 
 Cold Weather Blues 
 I fish a lake stock with commons, mirrors, crucians and roach. 
 During the warmer months I averaged at least 15 common carp in a five hour session but this winter two sessions were biteless. 
 I tried all the baits which worked earlier in the season and varied my approach. 
 Is the colder weather affecting sport? 
 A.B. 
 Berkshire 
 Stillwaters are often more difficult during the winter, particularly if the water goes clear. 
 In many cases you have to lower your expectations accordingly. 
 Some venues will respond in a limited way, others may not. 
 It is mainly a case of less feed and smaller hook baits to tempt bites. 
 Baits need to be anchored well on the bottom and left for long periods and leger tactics are more likely to succeed than the float. 
 Stillwater fish are often found in deepish water when the weather is cold and this may entail a longer cast. 
 Rather than risking poor accuracy with your loose feed or grondbait, an open end feeder can prove more effective at long range. 
 Another important winter consideration is the time of day you fish. 
 In your letter you said two four hour sessions failed to pull a response. 
 Perhaps you missed the short period in which the fish were feeding? 
 This can vary water by water, but often the last two or three hours of daylight are crucial and can bring a short burst of action after all else has failed. 
 Benefits of dyed reed floats 
 A few years ago you wrote about the merits of sarkandas reed as a waggler material. 
 Instead of painting the reed you dyed it, to reduce weight. 
 Can you tell me how to do this and if you need to varnish it? 
 R.H. London 
 I make up a bath of dye to treat the sarkandas before cutting the reed to the required lengths. 
 The dye is green chysoidine powder mixed with methylated spirits, two tablespoons of dye to one litre of spirits. 
 Pour about two inches of this mixture into a shallow tray and submerge 50 or so lengths of reed at a time. 
 After 30 minutes the dyes will have completely penetrated the reed which is then dried out on sheets of newspaper for several days. 
 The end result is a lovely camouflaged effect, but more importantly the dye has roughened up the normally smooth surface of the reed, which will now take a good varnish that will not chip off. 
 I use Aiken Hi Coat which gives a waterproof satin finish. 
 I do not advocate using a glossy varnish, because it tends to give false readings as you try to shot the float down. 
 My reason for dyeing, rather than painting these floats is because they will take more shotting. 
 The finish is also more permanent and does not upset the float's balance. 
 One final word of caution, be careful when handling chrysoidine. 
 Protect your hands with rubber gloves because it can be a dangerous substance in such a concentrated form. 
 Once the reed has dried, it is advisable to put the gloves back on again, so any excess powder on the surfact can be wiped away, before you start forming your floats. 
 MATCHMAIL 
 All starred contests are qualifiers in the Kamasan matchmen of the year series 
 TRENT CHUBB SPREE 
 Only 17 anglers turned up for Sunday's Notts AA Open on the Trent at Shelford so a match was organised downstream at East Bridgeford where there was a stunning result. 
 The top nine anglers had a total of 205 lb 5 oz of chub and the top three returned more than 35 lb. 
 Leading the way was Pete Palmer (Daiwa Trentmen) with 46&ndash;8&ndash;0 of chub taken on steak fished on a 14 hook beneath a waggler at the end peg. 
 Team mate Steve Clark was runner-up with 37&ndash;15&ndash;0 of chub from peg seven, also on steak, and the same bait gave Roy Toulson (Notts Fed) 35&ndash;6&ndash;0. 
 Others: Steve Draper (Daiwa Trentmen) 26&ndash;11&ndash;0; Brian Richmond (Notts AA) 19&ndash;8&ndash;0; D. Richmond (Notts AA) 13&ndash;6&ndash;0. 
 Roy Toulson was among the fish on Saturday was well when he landed 43 chub for 40&ndash;8&ndash;0 in the Notts Fed Open at Burton Joyce. 
 The match organiser had a 2 lb chub first cast and continued with steak under his 5AAA waggler four rod lengths out at the top of the road stretch. 
 Runner-up Keith Noble (R and R Sports) also float fished steak on a 14 hook along the road side and had 20&ndash;11&ndash;0 to beat in-form Sean Stenton (Daiwa Goldthorpe) who had 15&ndash;5&ndash;0 in the 36 pegger. 
 Others: Jess King (Smithies Browning); F. Ashworth (Stainforth) 10&ndash;15&ndash;0; Pete Hamilton (Olympic I. Walton) 10&ndash;2&ndash;0. 
 Sirhowy. 
 Ice covered much of the River Frome at Lugwardine and only two anglers caught fish in the 30 plus entry Sirhowy Open. 
 Glen Robson (Tredegar) was in a deep bend opposite the Longworth Mill barn and fished over depth with a stick float and single maggot on a 20 hook for a dozen dace weighing 2&ndash;0&ndash;0. 
 The only other weigher was Tredegar teenager Ward Draper with 0&ndash;1&ndash;0. 
 Cardiff Nomads 
 The Dock Feeder Canal at Cardiff was gin clear and cold and the only angler to catch more than 1 lb was Pontypridd tackle dealer Neil Scott. 
 Pegged near where the canal enters the East Dock the Cariff Nomad quivertipped pinkie on a size 22 hook to catch 20 small roach totalling 1&ndash;1&ndash;0. 
 Cardiff painter and decorator Ken Hornsey was drawn alongside the Tyndall Street road bridge and flicked a small bomb under the bridge for six roach on a pinkie-baited size 22 hook to finish second with 0&ndash;5&ndash;0. 
 Cardiff's former World Champion Clive Branson was third with half a dozen small roach weighing 0&ndash;4&ndash;0 on quivertipped pinkie. 
 Keighley 
 Floating ice and bankside snowdrifts couldn't stop 24 hard anglers taking part in the Keighley Open on the Aire where Ian Dawson (Leeds Anglers World) had 14&ndash;15&ndash;0. 
 He finished the armchair upstream of Steeton Bridge with float and maggot for six chub. 
 Steve Fairbourn (Keighley) was runner-up from close by with five chub on legered bread for 15&ndash;10&ndash;0. 
 Others: Harry Kenny (Keighley) 8&ndash;15&ndash;0; A. Lavelle (Keighley) 8&ndash;5&ndash;0; Calum Evans (Idle and Thackley) 2&ndash;15&ndash;0. 
 Leeds Shimano 
 It was a struggle for bites in the Leeds Shimano Open on the Aire at Leeds where anglers had to dodge floating ice. 
 Bob Hirst (Daiwa Goldthorpe) fished caster and pole four above Twaites weir for five roach worth 2&ndash;11&ndash;0. 
 Others: Tony Webster (Mirfield Angling) 1&ndash;1&ndash;0; Stan Jeffreys (Leeds Shimano) 0&ndash;9&ndash;8. 
 Abbey Hulton 
 Even a three inch covering on the Caldon Canal at Stoke failed to stop a hastily arranged match won by Paul Hart (Abbey Hulton) with 24 gudgeon for 0&ndash;5&ndash;8. 
 He fished a three metre pole rig with bloodworm at the rear of Hanley Park. 
 Others: John Wild (Stone Rowleys) 0&ndash;4&ndash;0; Steve Lowndes (Ash Bank) 0&ndash;2&ndash;12. 
 Bitter taste for Salt 
 Brian Salt (Rists) could have won the Kidsgrove Open on the Trent and Mersey Canal if he hadn't missed his keepnet with an 8 oz roach. 
 Instead, Richard Crane (PMG Central) won with 1&ndash;7&ndash;8 from the warm water stretch. 
 He pole fished pinkies at eight metres for a dozen small roach to 5 oz. 
 Brian had to settle for second with three roach taken on caster for 1&ndash;1&ndash;0. 
 Others: Mick Clewes (Norsec) 0&ndash;11&ndash;8; Nigel Boulton (PMG Central) 0&ndash;11&ndash;0. 
 Bream was a good start 
 Blizzards didn't stop 100 anglers taking part in the Leeds Daiwa League on the Ouse where the best weights came from Hunters Lodge. 
 Steve Raper (Punyettas) had a 4 lb bream in the first ten minutes opposite the bungalows and continued on the feeder with caster for roach that lifted him to 11&ndash;10&ndash;0. 
 John Atkinson (Psycho) fished maggot under a slider near the winner for 10&ndash;13&ndash;0. 
 Others: Ron Wilkinson (Yarm) 9&ndash;12&ndash;0; Bernard Guy (Ouse Five) 8&ndash;2&ndash;0. 
 Brian Ware (Psycho) 6&ndash;9&ndash;0. 
 Teams on day: Psycho 20&ndash;10&ndash;0; Yarm 14&ndash;4&ndash;0; Punyettas 13&ndash;11&ndash;8. 
 Float fishing was virtually impossible at Hunters Lodge for the Leeds Saturday series won by Stan Haigh (Leeds Anglers World) with 20 small roach for 4&ndash;1&ndash;8. 
 He fished single maggot on the bomb opposite the Ouse-Ure signpost. 
 Others: Pete Wheatley (Stanley Vickers) 3&ndash;0&ndash;0; Nick Chaffer (Leeds Anglers World) 2&ndash;15&ndash;0; Dave Armitage (Brighouse) and Martin Thorpe (Glen) both 2&ndash;11&ndash;8. 
 Knee deep snow meant poor catches in the Snape Open on the Swale at Salmon Hall Farm. 
 Mike Simpson (Stanley Vickers) stick floated maggot near the willow in the bottom field for small roach, dace and gudgeon for a winning 1&ndash;11&ndash;0. 
 Others: Mark Calvert (Stanley Vickers) 1&ndash;6&ndash;8; Martin Henstock (Ripon) 1&ndash;2&ndash;8; J. Roberts and S. Suggitt (both Snape) both 0&ndash;14&ndash;0. 
 Wotsits 
 Freezing rod rings made it hard work in the Wotsits Open on the Trent at Long Higgin where Simon Roff (Tri-Cast Barnsley) fished the feeder at long range for three chub to 4 lb 4 oz in a winning 9&ndash;3&ndash;8. 
 Others: Chris Skinner (Home and Dry) 7&ndash;10&ndash;0; Ian Bowman (Niddmen) 5&ndash;14&ndash;0; Jim Leach (Tri-Cast Barnsley) and Dennis Dring (Anglers World) both 3&ndash;14&ndash;0 
 &pound;70 roach 
 The Lea below Pymmes Brook outfall at Leabridge Road was ice-free and 21 anglers braved conditions to fish a hastily-arranged Tottenham Angling sweepstake. 
 All the money was paid out in sections which resulted in winner Danny Fung (Hertford Tackle) taking home &pound;70 for his single 1 oz roach on pole and bloodworm. 
 Pete Vasey (Trev's Browning) was second with 0&ndash;0&ndash;4, the same weight as equal third men Paul Burrough (Tottenham Angling) and Peter Jordan (Hertford Tackle) but with two sticklebacks to their one each. 
 Paul Burrough was the happiest, as his was the only fish caught in his section, resulting in him scooping the same cash as the winner. 
 Coventry 
 One ice-breaker went over the top on the Oxford Canal at Nell's Bridge on Saturday and plunged neck deep into freezing water 
 But he scrambled out and fished through the 30-entry Coventry Open. 
 Surprisingly, nobody had a dry net. 
 Dick Ashby (Banbury Castaways) won with 150 gudgeon and small perch to short pole and blood worm for 2&ndash;10&ndash;8, just ahead of team mate Derek Cullip who caught 2&ndash;8&ndash;8 of small fish on the same method. 
 Others: Mark Lichtenberg (Trev's Browning) 1&ndash;15&ndash;0; S. Maddocks (Milton Keynes) 1&ndash;11&ndash;8. 
 Conham 
 The Briston Avaon at Conham was in perfect condition despite the cosd and match organiser Dave Haines (Briston Sensas) topped the 30-strong field with 6&ndash;8&ndash;0. 
 Pegged just below the footbridge, Dave caught small dace steadily on waggler and maggot to head off Pete Sivell (Avon Angling). 
 Staked just above the footbridge, Pete also plumped for wagger and maggot and caught chub. 
 Others: Gary Bowden (Bristol Sensas) 4&ndash;6&ndash;0; Dick Hodges (Golden Carp 4&ndash;2&ndash;0; Graham Beavor (Avon Angling) 3&ndash;9&ndash;0. 
 Trowbridge 
 Only 13 anglers braved the Bristol Avon at Staverton, and it was unlucky for ren who dry netted. 
 Ian Stanier (Trowbridge) won with three chub for 6&ndash;14&ndash;0 on float fished maggot, clear of clubmate Adrain Parrish on 3&ndash;14&ndash;0 and Dave Baker (Bradford) 0&ndash;15&ndash;0. 
 Massey 
 Sunday's Massey Ferguson Open on the Grand Union Canal at Rowington attracted 35 competitors who used axes, bricks and anything else heavy to break the three inch thick ice. 
 The match was restricted to three hours, and Jeff Sparks (Massey Ferguson) won using bloodworm on the near ledge. 
 He fished a three-metre whip to take gudgeon steadily, and adding a few small perch for 2&ndash;11&ndash;8. 
 It was all gudgeon for Geoff Stanley (Coventry Casters) who used bloodworm to tempt 2&ndash;2&ndash;0. 
 Norman Baker (Massey Ferguson) slipped into the shallow canal while ice breaking, but ended third with 2&ndash;1&ndash;8 of gudgeon to the short pole. 
 Others: Alan Powell (Massey Ferguson) 1&ndash;15&ndash;0. 
 Middleton 
 The Middleton Open was transferred from the iced solid Erewash Canal at Ilkeston to the warm water-boosted Beeston Canal, where all 13 competitors had fish. 
 Host club member Dave Amber won with 4&ndash;8&ndash;0 of small chub. 
 taken on long pole alternating between maggot and caster. 
 Frank Barlow (Wotsits) filled second with 2&ndash;10&ndash;0 of small roach on caster, ahead of Clilff Adcock (Nottingham Deaf) on 2&ndash;3&ndash;0. 
 Izaak Walton 
 Alan Round finished way ahead of the field in a hastily-arranged Olympic IWAA Sweepstake on the Staffs Worcester Canal at Farmdown Road. 
 The experienced towpath angler put together his winning 7&ndash;14&ndash;0 of gudgeon and perch on bloodworm from a peg near the road bridge. 
 Sean Ashby (Browning Starlets) was pegged in the same area and his 3&ndash;13&ndash;4 catch was made up of gudgeon, roach and perch. 
 Olympic I. Walton skipper Alan Chatfield's 3&ndash;13&ndash;0 catch was made up of gudgeon from a peg near the salt works to beat Robin Tooth (Team Uniprint) with 3&ndash;5&ndash;4 of gudgeon. 
 Thames frozen bank to bank 
 The Thames at Abingdon was barely fishable for the Mick's Tackle Open with the bottom areas of the March length frozen over for the full 50 yard width. 
 Pete Brownlow (Dells) won with 5&ndash;7&ndash;0 of roach to 12 oz and small skimmers on case feeder and liquidise bread, fishing opposite the Anchor pub. 
 Paul Glenfield's remarkable run on the river continued when he was runner-up with a 4 lb 8 oz chub and a few bits taken on bread. 
 Others: Rob Spurett (Mick's) 1&ndash;15&ndash;0; Gary Dallimore (Sundridge) 1&ndash;13&ndash;0. 
 Hottest Action Was On the Phone! 
 Organiser Pete Simmonds had more than 150 phone calls on Friday from anglers either cancelling or making bookings for Saturday's Sabrina Open on the Severn. 
 Other anglers were desperately seeking tickets in a Kamasan points qualifier. 
 The event finally went ahead and Pete removed all surplus pegs from the quarry and county ground at Shrewsbury leaving many of competitors with double pegs. 
 More than 40 competitors blanked and iced rod rigs were a major problem. 
 Paul Davis (Shrewsbury Bait Centre) took 14 roach to waggler and maggot from three pegs below Posthill Bridge to win the four-hour event with 6&ndash;0&ndash;0. 
 A single 3&ndash;2&ndash;0 chub to legered maggot from the next occupied below the winner took Jeff Perrin (Shakespeare) into second and helped him to forth in the Kamasan Matchman of the Year table. 
 Simon Christian (Jacksons Tipton Match) was opposite the tennis court at the bottom of the quarry and used a mini-feeder to locate enough maggot-tempted roach to clinch third on 3&ndash;1&ndash;0. 
 Others: Pete Simmonds (Sabrina) 1&ndash;2&ndash;0; Chris Dennis (Stoke) 1&ndash;1&ndash;0; Tony Lloyd (Shrewsbury Bait Centre) 0&ndash;14&ndash;0. 
 Boats got match underway 
 Patshull Park Lake was ice free on Saturday but completely frozen on Sunday so two motor boats were used to break up the half inch thick ice for two hours. 
 One boat was holed three times and despite baling had taken in a foot of water when beached. 
 The other boat remained out during the match to keep the fishing areas clear. 
 Len Miller (West End) drawn near the Burnt Oak, picked up roach at intervals presenting a single maggot under a six metre pole to win with 4&ndash;14&ndash;0. 
 Two pegs away, Phil Rhodes (West End) used a six metre pole to tackle the deepest swim in the match length, and took 4&ndash;12&ndash;12 of roach for second. 
 Brian Gamston (West End) on the Lodge Bay platform took his all-roach 4&ndash;12&ndash;8 to maggot under the pole. 
 Others: Joe Brennan (Nige Williams Tackle) 4&ndash;7&ndash;0; Mick Edwards (Springfield) 4&ndash;3&ndash;10. 
 Winter Leagues 
 Hemsworth. 
 Newark Dyke just above Crankley POint provided some lively action with chub making up bumper weights. 
 Barry Newton (South Kirkby) led a string of couble-figure weights with 18&ndash;8&ndash;8 of small chub to maggot feeder. 
 Club colleague Phil Iveson had a similar catch for 15&ndash;11&ndash;0. 
 Others: Baill Wade (Wakefield A) 13&ndash;15&ndash;8; R. Goy (Ferrybridge) 12&ndash;8&ndash;0; P. Reynolds (Wakefield B) 12&ndash;2&ndash;8. 
 Teams: South Kirby 79; Featherstone 73; Crown Silstar 68. 
 League: Featherstone 4; South Kirby 7; Youngers 16. 
 Swindon Angling Centre. 
 Geoff Wilson (Tameside Normans) won through in a tight finish on an icebound Bridgewater Canal around Broadheath. 
 Two skimmers to pole and bloodworm tactics made up the bulk of his 4&ndash;1&ndash;3 winning weight, pipping England international Alan McAtee (Elton Tackle) on 3&ndash;13&ndash;8. 
 Others: Chris Frazer (Swindon Angling Centre) 3&ndash;10&ndash;12; Graham Broughton (Elton Tackle) 3&ndash;5&ndash;3. 
 Teams: Highfield Blue 92; Highfield Green 91; Izaak Walton 85; tameside Normans 84. 
 League: Highfield Green 274; Tameside Normans Red 267; Izaak Walton A 264; Highfield Blue 256; Elton Tackle Red 239. 
 York. 
 Roach dominated catches from the snow covered banks of the River Ouse below York. 
 Roger Flude (Bishopthorpe B) fished maggot on a slider rig at the bottom of Middlethorpe Ings to take 5&ndash;2&ndash;8 of roach for victory. 
 Phil Blood (Monroe UK) legered bread flake from a feeder also at Middlethorpe for 4&ndash;-7&ndash;0 of roach. 
 Others: Andy Harvey (Legionaires) 4&ndash;0&ndash;8; Tim Harrison (Leeds Anglers World) 3&ndash;1&ndash;8. 
 Teams: Leeds Anglers World 10&ndash;7&ndash;0; Legionaires 10&ndash;6&ndash;0; South Bank 9&ndash;14&ndash;0. 
 League: Mitre Pets 55; Legionaires 53; South Bank 52. 
 LONDON AA. 
 The final round on the Grand Union Canal at Broadmead Bridge was fished by 26 competiors who had to smash through ice up to six inches thick. 
 Peter Vasey (Trev's Browning) had three roach on pole and bread punch for victory with 0&ndash;4&ndash;0. 
 Others: Steve Davis (A1 Shimano) 0&ndash;3&ndash;0; Derek Seymour (Trev's Browning) 0&ndash;2&ndash;12. 
 A1 Shimano's Bill Bullock won the league with 0&ndash;2&ndash;8, enough for fourth on the day to bring his earnings from the series to almost &pound;500. 
 ROD AND GUN. 
 The River Severn at Shrewsbury was frozen solid in places and some anglers found fish hard to come by. 
 Richard Duke (Bridgnorth) put together a match-winning catch of rudd weighing 4&ndash;8&ndash;8 from the &bquo;slab&equo; peg on the county ground using stick float and maggot. 
 Team mate Steve Wilkinson was runner-up with a 2&ndash;10&ndash;4 of roach on the straight leger from a peg below the suspension bridge in the quarry. 
 Others: Been Beecham (Dawley B) 2&ndash;1&ndash;0; Clive Wheldon (Corbetts Aces) 1&ndash;2&ndash;12. 
 Teams: Bridnorth 55; Dawley B 44; Corbetts Aces 43; Rod and Gun 36. 
 League: Rod and Gun 5; Bridnorth 6; Corbetts Aces 7; Dawley B 7; Harris's Raiders 8; The Best 8. 
 RUGELEY. 
 With one leg to fish three teams are level at the top. 
 The latest round on the Church Bridge length of the Trent and Mersey Canal at Rugeley saw Steve Collins (Team Uniprint) gain his best win to date with 4&ndash;5&ndash;10 of ruffe to beat his team mate, Tony Keeling, on 3&ndash;3&ndash;4. 
 Others: Terry Ballinger (Rugeley MG All Stars) 3&ndash;0&ndash;15; Perry Follows (Team Uniprint) 2&ndash;9&ndash;4. 
 Teams: Rugeley MG All Stars and Team Uniprint tied for first with Rugeley MG Blue third. 
 League: Rugeley MG All Stars, Team Uniprint and Rugeley MG Blue all 8 points; Rugeley and Brereton. 
 13 LUCKY FOR JOHN 
 Clevedon Veals skipper Ray Bazeley had only planned for a small squad outing after their first choice match on the Nene at Peterborough was cancelled. 
 But word got around and by 9am some 30 anglers had gathered in the Little Chef at Bath, prompting a sweepstake on the local Bristol Avon. 
 The deep stretch at Bath fished well, and John Amato (Bristol Sensas) landed 13 chub on waggler-fished maggots for 12&ndash;6&ndash;0 and victory. 
 John ran his float down to the inside stantion of the old railway bridge. 
 Dave Lewis (Avon Angling) netted 10&ndash;6&ndash;8 of chub and roach on pole fished maggot. 
 Pete Sivell (Avon Angling) made it three frame places in successive matches with 8&ndash;13&ndash;0 for third. 
 Others: Chris Cotterell (Clevedon Veals) 8&ndash;4&ndash;0; Steve Robinson (Avon Angling) 6&ndash;8&ndash;0. 
 Rugeley 
 The Rugeley Open on the Trent and Mersey Canal at Mossley went ahead after ice-breaking operation, although the attendance was kept down by poor road conditions. 
 But Dave Hargreaves (Chase Social) was the only angler to put together any amount of bites. 
 His finished with 2&ndash;7&ndash;0 of grudgeon. 
 Others: Mark Capewell (Carthys) 0&ndash;7&ndash;2; Graham Ward (Chase Social) 0&ndash;3&ndash;11. 
 Middle Hours Were Crucial 
 The Humberside winter league was cancelled as not all the teams turned up but the anglers left arranged an Open on the Trent at Caythorpe. 
 The river was clear and sport patchy with big bream and chub dominating results. 
 Malcolm Bailey (Shimano Goole) won at peg 126, taking seven bream in the second and third hours for 20&ndash;4&ndash;8 on maggot feeder. 
 Team mate Paul Cannon drew peg 81 and took four decent chub for 12&ndash;8&ndash;0 and second, two falling to maggot feeder and two on lobworm and straight lead. 
 Bradford Mustad Viking Jack Ferguson was next with four bream for 10&ndash;13&ndash;0 on maggot feeder, again fished well out. 
 Others: Andy Kirk (Anglers World) 8&ndash;12&ndash;0; Adrian Broomhead (Shimano Goole) 5&ndash;14&ndash;0; John Illingworth (Bradford Mustadd Vikings) 5&ndash;2&ndash;0. 
 MIDWEEK 
 Watford Tackle Lady Chapels on the Grand Union Canal came out of its recent dolddrums and gave almost half the field in the Watford Tackle midweek Open at least one chub. 
 Despite flurries of snow, Steve Spooner (Olympus Outdoor World) got four chubb on quivertipped maggot and caster at peg 75 for 8&ndash;5&ndash;8. 
 Dave Boyd (VOrtex) used similar tactics two pegs away for three decent skimmers and a chub totalling 5&ndash;14&ndash;8. 
 KC-Dorking The third and final match in the KC-Dorking midweek mini-series was won by Chris Nicholl (Studio) who had ten chub on pole and bronze maggot from the Tank Traps for 13&ndash;13&ndash;0. 
 Runner-up Wally Eisenger (Guilford) had 10&ndash;0&ndash;0 of dace on waggler and maggot from a peg on the Stepping Stones, close to third man Kevvin Gaywood (KC Angling) who also caught dace for 9&ndash;2&ndash;0. 
 Julian Morley (Leatherhead Apollo) managed a couple of decent chub plus roach for 8&ndash;7&ndash;0 and fourth. 
 Tony Llelliot (Polegate) scooped &pound;250 for overall victory in the series. 
 Shrewsbury Bait The high numbers on the quarry length were the pegs to draw in Wednesday's Shrewsbury Bait Centre Open on the River Severn. 
 John Harris (Team Northendon) made his long journey from Lancashire pay with 6&ndash;13&ndash;0 of roach to 12 oz from peg 99. 
 Fishing waggler and maggot with a 22 hook to 1 lb bottom, John took most of his fish in the opening two hours to finish clear of in-form Howard Williams (Buckley) who had 5&ndash;6&ndash;0 at the next peg down. 
 Others: Chris Perry (Mohmar) 4&ndash;7&ndash;0; &pound;Barry Cooper (Shrewsbury Bait Centre) 2&ndash;2&ndash;0; Dave Harrell (Midland Angling Products) 1&ndash;15&ndash;0. 
 Fosters Tackle The 42 hardy anglers who braved the worst of Thursday's blizzards found bites scarce on the Severn at Stourport. 
 Brian Rigby (AFS) was the only man to crack double-figures, taking 18 chub on waggler and double maggot from peg 29 on the Lyttleeton water for 12&ndash;0&ndash;0 worth &pound;160. 
 Bob Ginster (GM Trophies) alternated waggler and stickfloat for 6&ndash;12&ndash;0 of roach to clinch second from peg 33 on Severnside. 
 Others: Pete Rice (Shakespeare Aquarians) 4&ndash;12&ndash;0; Brian Bennett (Evesham) 4&ndash;2&ndash;0; Dave Edwards (Birmingham AA) 3&ndash;4&ndash;0; Dave Harell (Midland Angling Products) 3&ndash;1&ndash;10. 
 Twyford Farm Pete Sivell (Avon Angling) won the Twyford Country Centre midweek Open with 13 chub for 15&ndash;3&ndash;0. 
 Drawn peg 110, Pete tripped bottom with waggler and maggot to head off Southam hotelier Dave McKay who had a similar net totalling 10&ndash;5&ndash;0 two pegs away. 
 Others: Stuart Kearsey (Newlands) 5&ndash;12&ndash;8; Ken Gibbons (Welford) 3&ndash;6&ndash;0; Stuart Gottfried (Twyford) 3&ndash;4&ndash;0. 
 Grayling Saved the Day 
 Fifty-three hardy anglers turned out in Arctic-like conditions for the Matlock Open on the River Derwent at Matlock and Neil Atkins (Belper) won the &pound;100 first prize with 11&ndash;13&ndash;0 of grayling. 
 He was pegged just below the pumphouse in Matlock Park and worked with pole and rod and line with maggot in a very shallow peg. 
 Anglers Mail columnist Frank Barlow (Wotsits Tackle) drew right opposite a pub but some bites on stick float and maggots kept him rooted to his box and he finished runner-up with 11&ndash;7&ndash;0 of grayling. 
 Others: P. Reeves (Mansfield) 8&ndash;11&ndash;0; Graham Gibbons (Wotsits Tackle) 7&ndash;11&ndash;0; D. Spencer (Matlock) 6&ndash;13&ndash;8; S. Wildsmith (Derby Anglers Corner) 6&ndash;12&ndash;0. 
 Matlock have another Open this Sunday on the same venue. 
 Details from John Spencer on 0629 583619. 
 Well Organised 
 Bad road conditions drastically cut the attendance for the Derby AA Open on the popular Trent and Mersey Canal at Shardlow where match organiser John Humphries (Wednesbury Tackle) topped the scores with 3&ndash;5&ndash;4 of gudgeon and perch. 
 He fished bloodworm and a three metre whip from a peg near the greenhousees and after a blank first hour and a half eventually caught around 100 fish. 
 Sean Ashby (Browning Starlets) was runner-up at the next peg with an almost identical net of fish weighing 3&ndash;3&ndash;8. 
 Others: Adam Barlow (Barlow's Tackle) 1&ndash;1&ndash;12; S. Daniels (Fenton Artwork) 0&ndash;6&ndash;0. 
 WEATHER TAKES ITS TOLL &mdash; Where snow and ice hit the weekend match programme 
 Yorkshire Access problems caused the cancellation of many matches in Yorkshire and the north east. 
 They included the Ripon event on the Ure, Heacy Woollen winter league on the Brighouse Canal, Three Counties league on Newark Dyke, Idle and Thackley Open on the Swale and the Bradford No. 1 on the Nidd. 
 The Allerton Bywater and Halkon Hunt matches were called off because of the ice as was the Doncaster event on the Idle where the river was frozen bank to bank. 
 The Selby Canal was iced and the Winter Warmers match was switched to the River Aire swhere conditions were so bad only organiser Billy Harrison turned out! 
 The Ritz winter league and other events on the ice-bound River Ancholme were cancelled. 
 North West North West match angling almost came to a total halt at the weekend with virtually all major matches called off. 
 Arguments started on some fisheries when match organisers and pleasure anglers tried to fish venues usually left for freelance angling. 
 The Dee at Chester was fishable but the only action was from 40 cormorants who have taken up residence above the weir. 
 Hardly a fish has been caught here for three weeks but the birds had had roach and dace up to 8 oz. 
 The Dane gave some chub to float fished maggot but the margins of the river were frozen. 
 Water discharged from Daresbury Power Station into the Bridgewater Canal kept the Goosberry Hollow to Norton Station stretch fishable and there were catches of up to 30 small roach and the odd skimmer bream. 
 St Helens AA had enough room for 20 anglers at Carr Mill Dam between the ice but not a fish was caught in the Sunday sweep. 
 South West/Wales Both divisions of the South Wales winter league were cancelled when heavy snow made travelling almost impossible. 
 Organiser Alan Solomon hopes to slot in the postponed round on the River Wye around Hereford on Sunday, March 10. 
 Parts of the Bristol Avon were iced over, resulting in the cancellation of the Bradford-On-Avon Open. 
 The Bridgwater match on the Taunton-Bridgwater Canal was another casualty. 
 South No major match survived the south's big freeze including events on the Thames. 
 Cookham cancelled their match on the river because of poor weather and although the waterway at Maidenhead was fishable the match had to be cancelled because of frozen banks. 
 The Shiplake Open on the Thames was a victim because the lock cuts were frozen and the main river was a mass of ice floes. 
 The Basingstoke Canal at Claycart had around three inches of ice which led to the cancellation of the HBCAA Open and there was two and a half inches of ice on the Oxford Canal which led to the scrapping of the Banbury Open. 
 At Woking, snow heaped on the banks of the Wey made the river unfishable for the Open. 
 Matches at Goldsworth Park Lake and Badshot Lea Lakes were also called off becuase of ice. 
 West Midlands The West Midlands week-end match programme collapsed under a carpet of snow and ice. 
 Alcester, Twyford, Whitmore Reans and Dutton Opens went first on the the Avon, canals and Earlswood lakes soon followed by the Kidderminster and Warwich matches. 
 The Rugby winter league and Daiwa Gordon League matches were also cancelled. 
 At Hampton Ferry the Saturday match was cancelled but with a milder day the Sunday event was still going ahead Saturday night. 
 But the organisers found the Avon water frozen early Sunday morning so this event also joined the list of casualties. 
 Most matches went ahead in the central Midlands although road and bank conditions were bad which lead to low turnouts. 
 Two of the bigger matches were cancelled, the Bass National squad Open on the Trent at Burton a victim because of the road conditions. 
 The CT Peper Sales Open, which was also a sell-out, had to be cancelled, ironically because of car parking problems. 
 The Staffs-Worcs Canal was frozen but heavy snow in the car parks made access impossible. 
 East Midlands There was a complete cancellation of the match programme in the eastern counties. 
 The following Opens were cancelled as the venues were completely frozen: Ely Beet, Ouse, Ely; Stamford Welland, Welland, Stamford; Biggleswade, Hitchin, Ivel, Tempsford; Kettering Thrapston, Nene, Thrapston; Vauxhall, Ouse, Radwell; Littleport, Ouse, Littleport; Waterbeach, Cam, Hatleys Wash; Whittlesey, Cock Bank Drain, Coates; Peterborough DAA, Nene; Long Buckby, Grand Union Canal, Buckby Wharf. 
 The Daiwa League and Walton Opens on the Trent at Muskham were called off because of dangerous bankside conditions, as was the van den Eynde event at Long Eaton. 
 The Cotmanhay Open on the Erewash Canal had to be called off because of ice. 
 The Witham was frozen from bank to bank from Lincoln to Boston. 
 The only free places were where the swans have been. 
 The Tackle Box league and Boston Open were both scrapped. 
 Barclay's Brokers match on the Upper Hobhole at Lade Bank was cancelled. 
 The River Bain, a popular running water venue was frozen solid as were the Bargate and West Fen Drains. 
 An RAF match on Wednesday on the Witham was won by Neil Parkinson with around 40 roach, ruff and gudgeon for 1 lb 8 oz. 
 Change left Chris near 60 lb 
 A change of tactics provided Chris Worthington (JCB) with 34 chub for a winning 59&ndash;14&ndash;0 in the Burton Mutual Open on the in-form River Dove at Tutbury. 
 Ledgered bread failed to catch for the first hour but a switch to three bronze maggot on a size 14 hook presented over the far side found chub to 2 lb 8 oz from peg one. 
 Terry Newton (Derby) used waggler and maggot on peg 40 for second with an all-chub 48&ndash;10&ndash;0. 
 Others: Dave Heely (Derby) 14&ndash;12&ndash;0; Ken Smith (Derby) 10&ndash;12&ndash;0. 
 Square 
 Kevin Garvey (Warley Encon) drew on one of the two warm water outfalls and won the 27 peg Square Open on the Lifford Canal with 6&ndash;4&ndash;12. 
 He fished caster on a nine metre pole for mainly roach. 
 Steve Pierpoint (Shakespeare) took small carp and roach on pole and pinkie from the other outfall for second. 
 Billy Neath (Crown) had a single 2&ndash;2&ndash;0 carp for third. 
 His son Jason (Browning Starlets) and organiser Terry Morris (Clive Smith MG) both had 1&ndash;2&ndash;0. 
 No place like home 
 Horse and Jockey AC match secretary Mick Dryers had an unusual Sunday morning &mdash; he spent it at home for the first time in two years. 
 Mick called off his club's Open on the Coventry Canal due to four inches of ice. 
 The sell-out South Leicestershire Canal Championships on the Grand Union between Daddington and Foxton was another casualty. 
 Organisers hope to fish the match before the season ends. 
 Knaresborough 
 Martin Dodsworth (Knaresborough) stick floated maggot during a heavy snow storm to win his club's match on the Nidd. 
 He drew below the sawmills at Scotton to take 6&ndash;6&ndash;0 of grayling. 
 Others: Eddie McEvoyh 2&ndash;8&ndash;8; Ray Fletcher 0&ndash;8&ndash;12. 
 Match News 
 Irish Festival is Back 
 The Athlone Angling Festival is back after a two year absence caused by the problem of Irish fishing licences and the death of orgaaniser Sean Egan. 
 Now, with support from local industry and Liverpool-based holiday specialists Leisure Angling, the festival has been resurrected carrying a IR&pound;5,000 purse. 
 The match will take place from July 1&ndash;5, believed to be the ideal time for sport on the River Shannon, which has produced ton-up bream hauls in past festivals. 
 The King of the Shannon is officially on too, following on from the Cootehill Championship on September 29 to October 1. 
 Further information on these events and the Castleblaney Easter Festival, the Monaghan Pairs and Bailieboro events are listed on Keisure Angling's match information sheet on 051 734 2344. 
 Carry on fishing! 
 Exeter DAA have announced dates for their popular matches on the Exeter Canal between March and June &mdash; the time of year when most matchmen hang up their poles. 
 Taking advantage of the no close season ruling on south west stillwaters, the first 160 peg event takes place on Sunday March 17. 
 Subsequent matches are on &dollar;March 31, April 14 and April 28 before the highlight of their calendar, the Ashford Slating and Tiling Classic, on Sunday May 26. 
 Tickets for the Opens are &pound;10, with entry &pound;30 for the big-money Classic, which promises &pound;1,500 to the winner down to &pound;100 for seventh, and 16 &pound;50 section prizes. 
 Tickets from Mike Hosgood on 0392 211360. 
 A teams of four match will be held on May 12, tickets &pound;50 from Terry Barrell on 0392 77445, 
 Draw for all the matches is 8&ndash;9am at the Countess Wear Lodge Hotel, Exeter. 
 Sundridge London and South East Division One competitors Stows Match Group are on the hunt for new anglers to boost their squad. 
 The Staines, Middlesex, based side fish Division Four of the NFA Nationals this year and the Thames Valley Winter League. 
 Anyone interested should telephone captain Ken Wheeler on 0784 469448 or vice captain Tony Yianni on 081 570 8970. 
 The Sundridge Super League North West Division One are holding a meeting on February 27 to fix venues for next season's campaign. 
 Captains should contact Barry Smith on 0282 864513 to confirm their attendance. 
 Frozen Stiff 
 But Ian and John rescue struggling specimens Two carp anglers braved the coldest temperatures for four years to rescue fish from a leaking West Midlands canal. 
 Ian Elmore and John Whitwich, from Walsall, were horrified to see dozens of specimen tench and big carp struggling in just ten inches of water when they visited engineering works on the Park Hall stetch of the Rushall Canal near Walsall. 
 The hardy pair transferred 30 lb of tench to 6 lb, 12 pike to 8 lb and three double-figure carp last Wednesday night in temperatures to minus eight degrees Centigrade. 
 They took the fish to an unaffected stretch of canal 150 yards away and realising bigger fish were still distressed returned on Thurday to finish the job. 
 Their second rescue included roach, pike, tench and a 17 lb 2 oz mirror carp. 
 &bquo;We only went there to see what British Waterways were doing,&equo; said Ian. 
 &bquo;The fish were really distressed and could not avoid bashing into each other with the water level so low. 
 &bquo;If we had lost the four big carp, sport on the canal would have been ruined. 
 &bquo;It was absolutely freezing and by the time we got the fish to the deeper water the carp sacks were frozen,&equo; added Ian who also broke two landing nets during the rescue. 
 British Waterways lowered the water in the section by ten inches while laying a sewage pipe underneath the canal and say a further drop in levels was caused by a leaking paddle on a lock gate. 
 &bquo;The water level fell by two feet or so during the night,&equo; said fisheries officer Keith Fisher. 
 &bquo;As far as we are aware there were no fish in distress when we returned to work on the Thursday morning and the canal was refilled with two feet of water.&equo; 
 &bquo;We have also put planks in front of the paddle to ensure it does not happen again.&equo;  
 Perchfishers member Richard Frissen, 31, banked his fourth perch over 3 lb with this 3 lb 2 oz specimen from a Surrey club water. 
 Farnborough, Hampshire driver Richard paternostered a rudd bait on 6 trebles to 6lb line. 
 LEAGUE CHAMPIONS' FINAL 
 Oxford Canal, Keyford to Northbrook preview by Tom Legge 
 Feeding's the key to &pound;1,000 cheque 
 Fifteen successful match outfits will be keeping their fingers crossed that a quick thaw is on its way before the weekend. 
 That's because the Sundridge Super League Champions match is due to take place on the Oxford Canal between Heyford Station and Northbrook Lock on Sunday. 
 All the teams have won their division of the Sundrige this season, and six will be doing battle in the top flight of their respective regions next year. 
 Any one of them would love to take away the &pound;1,000 winner's cheque, won last year by Bristol Amalgamation, but first they'll have to beat the other hopefuls on what could be a bumper match. 
 The Super League's Southern semi-final canal match was fished at Northbrook last month and produced two double-figure hauls of quality roach, dace and perch plus a gudgeon catch topping 7 lb. 
 Since then, an incredible 27 lb 9 oz of roach was brought to the scales in an Oxford Open from a peg in Northbrook spinney. 
 But Oxford match secretary Steve Pipkin, who is pegging the length, reckons the team who can best sort out a method for the small fish will win on the day. 
 &bquo;The key is knowing the area to fish in your peg and feeding it correctly. 
 Gudgeon are the chief target as they certainly weigh better than the little perch and tiny silver fish,&equo; said Steve. 
 &bquo;If the canal thaws and colours up, then the bigger fish should show more. 
 In the clear conditions, anglers have been spotting many of the venue's double-figure carp but they'ree not feeding,&equo; he added. 
 Coventry Albatros, winners of the West Midlands Division Two, are tipped to do well, along with the powerful Team Robbos, victors in the London and South-East Division One. 
 Lancastrians Star, Clive Smith MG of Birmingham and Nott AA are also teams to watch. 
 All competing teams should report to the Dashwood Arms, Kirtlington at 8am., bringing with them an accurate set of scales. 
 The team who draws peg one will be responsible for weighing in their section, with peg two assisting as section stewards. 
 The match will be fished in all but the severest of conditions &mdash; the Oxford has a reputation for producing fish even when ice-breaking is necessary. 
 But road conditions for travelling teams must also be taken into account, and for this reason a decision on whether the match will go ahead will be taken on Thursday February 14) at 12 noon. 
 Captains only can telephone Tom Legge on 071 261 5998 after that deadline to confirm the match will be fished.  
 This 11 lb plus net taken by Trev's Browning's Derek Young was second in the Sundrige semi final on the Oxford Canal 
 Dave Berrow with the 7 lb gudgeon net taken from Northampton last month 
 Preface 
 Marxism has recently become for anthropologists a new source of obscurity as a result of recent work which is difficult and barbarously phrased. 
 On the other hand anthropological topics, which have always had a major place in Marxism, are often just as difficult as Marxist writings to understand and evaluate for those with a more general interest. 
 Neither of these problems seems insurmountable, and it is the purpose of this book to explain the history of the developing relationship between Marxism and anthropology, in a way which the non-specialist should find accessible, as well as to contribute something to ongoing debates. 
 Any technical term used here, whether from Marxism or anthropology, is explained in the body of the text, and the index will enable the reader to refer back to these explanation. 
 Because this book is part of a series, I have concentrated mainly on those topics which principally concern pre-capitalist and pre-feudal societies. 
 It does not seem to me that a reader principally interested in capitalism, or imperialism, or the theories of such Marxist writers as Althusser or Gramsci would turn to a book such as this, and so I have kept discussion of these topics to a minimum. 
 I would like to thank the following for valuable comments on a part or the whole of an earlier draft: S. Day, A. Gell, El Gellner, P. Loizos, J. Parry, A. Papataxiarchis, and S. Roberts. 
 M.B. 
 Anthropology and the Work of Marx and Engels 
 The area of study in the social sciences which has gone under the name of anthropology in English-speaking countries has traditionally concentrated on primitive peoples. 
 Anthropology as an organized subject goes back to the mid-nineteenth century &lsqb;Fortes 1969:6, following Kroeber&rsqb; and was closely associated with the study of evolution. 
 Cultural and social anthropology was then concerned with the evolution of human society and culture. 
 Inevitably the early history of anthropology became closely allied to the history of Darwinian evolutionary theory and many controversies which now seem obscure relate to the burning debates surrounding the concept of natural selection. 
 None the less, anthropology soon became an independent academic study, first by amateurs, and later by university researchers. 
 In time, academic anthropology became less directly associated with evolutionary ideas, and it tried to establish itself as a respectable, if not conservative, branch of the social sciences. 
 How then did this apolitical, academic subject come to play such an important part in the development of Marxism? 
 Marx was, as Engels stressed in his funeral oration, first and foremost a revolutionary, and so the importance which he attached to the study of pre-literate peoples, the traditional field of anthropology, might at first seem strange. 
 In fact, his intense interest, an interest which he passed on to Engels and other revolutionary Marxists, is neither accidental nor peripheral: it is one indication of the difference between Marx's thought and that of other revolutionaries, whether his predecessors or his contemporaries. 
 It is one indication of why he has had such a unique influence on the history of mankind. 
 Marx was not the first to denounce the wretched condition of the working class in capitalist countries, nor was he the first to point out the apparent anomaly that those who produced the wealth, the workers, were the poorest while those who were apparently useless drones, the capitalists and their associates,  were the richest. 
 However, he was the first who did not under estimate the power and the complexity of the system which had produced such a state of affairs. 
 Because of this, Marx took as one of his main tasks the understanding of how this system came into being, and this was in order to discover why this system had such power of the minds of those who operated it, whether exploiters or exploited. 
 This is what made Marx so different from his socialist contemporaries. 
 At the same time as he was engaged in more political work, Marx attempted to rewrite the history of mankind for the use of the oppressed, so that they would be able to understand the nature of the oppression to which they were subjected, and how it had come about. 
 For Marx this historical work was also political, because he believed that understanding the workers' condition through the study of history would enable them the better to fight it. 
 Anthropology had a place in this scheme because for Marx it was the study of the early history of mankind. 
 This rewriting of history was not so much a matter of starting again, but of making use, for a new purpose, of knowledge which was already available, whether in the work of philosophers like Hegel, economists like Ricardo, biologists like Darwin, or anthropologists. 
 This new use meant a severe criticism of the earlier knowledge, since Marx believed that the studies he was using had originally been made for exactly the opposite purpose to his; they had been made in order to justify the oppression which Marx say as the core of the capitalist system. 
 This was particularly true, Marx felt, of economists, but he was to show that it was also true of some anthropologists. 
 Naturally Marx started by explaining the historical mechanism and inner working of the social system which dominated the condition of the working class at the time when he wrote on capitalism. 
 This is where he devoted most of his energies. 
 However, in order to expose the nature of capitalism, Marx first had to show that capitalism is not based on some eternal immutable truth, as presented by economists, but is the product of a long history. 
 For example, the law of supply and demand, as it operated in nineteenth-century England, he argues, was not simply a matter of eternal logic, nor were such rights as that of private property self-evident truths, but rather they were the product of particular historical circumstances. 
 Those circumstances had brought about the capitalist system and had also created the concepts on which it was based. 
 In showing capitalism and capitalist values to be the  creation of a moment of history Marx negated the transcendental claim of capitalism to be the only possible natural system for civilized man, and in this way challenged the basic precepts of capitalism. 
 Marx's challenge to capitalism therefore took the general form of demonstrating the general forces which govern the history of man, and demonstrating how historical processes produce systems of institutions and ideas os such complexity that their origin can only be discovered with great theoretical effort and by examination of the historical evidence. 
 That is what led Marx to history and then to anthropology as, in the course of his work, he pushed his analyses ever further backwards in the evolution of human society. 
 In part Marx say this task as paralleling what had been done by Darwin for biological evolution. 
 In this Marx was similar to many of his contemporaries, such as Spencer or Comte, but he was also very different from them, for he did not believe that the same laws apply to biological evolution as apply to human societies. 
 Above all he differed from them because his purpose was always primarily political. 
 Because Marx and Engels saw the reanalysis of history and anthropology as and essential part of their political activity, they gave ever-growing importance to the study and understanding of pre-capitalist societies. 
 As this work proceeded they began to include discussions of ever-earlier periods, and therefore they moved more and more into the field of anthropology. 
 At first in The German Ideology  and The Communist Manifesto , both relatively early works, their interest mainly concentrated on feudalism, the period in European history which comes immediately before capitalism. 
 At this stage they hardly mention tribal society. 
 By 1858, however, ten years after The Manifesto , their historical horizon had already been pushed further back. 
 Marx was then preparing the elaborate drafts for Capital , which have been published in English under the title Grundrisse  &lsqb;1973&rsqb;, or Foundations , an important part of which forms a separate book in English under the title Pre-Capitalist Economic Formations . 
 This contains a much lengthier and more important consideration of tribal social organization, as well as of classical and oriental societies. 
 From then on, the references to pre-capitalist systems become more and more numerous in the work of Marx and Engels, but it was really from 1880 on, when Marx was shown the work of the American anthropologist Lewis Henry Morgan that he and Engels gave a major place to the study of tribal societies. 
  Marx's last three years, and much of Engels's work from then on, almost seem to be dominated by anthropological concerns. 
 We know in part of this intensive study of the work of anthropologists from Marx's notes, published by L. Krader under the title The Ethnological Notebooks of Karl Marx  &lsqb;1972&rsqb;. 
 This work, however, only really came to fruition in Engels's famous book The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State , a book which although written after Marx's death was extensively based on his notes. 
 This book, discussed in detail in the next chapter, follows in part the work of Lewis Henry Morgan. 
 It incorporates information about pre-literate society into the wider theoretical edifice which Engels and Marx had been building all their lives. 
 It is the first Marxist book in which anthropological data predominate. 
 Anthropology thus played a central role in the development of Marxism but it would be totally misleading to think of Marx and Engels as early anthropologists. 
 This is because the anthropology which they used and reinterpreted was part of a much wider work which went beyond and across any disciplinary boundaries. 
 There is no barrier between Marx's and Engels's anthropology and their history, nor is there a barrier between their history and anthropology taken together and their politics. 
 In order to understand the significance of the anthropological work they used, therefore, we must ask, what was the role of this work in the wider context of their writings and politics? 
 Why were they interested in those topics which they chose to emphasize, and why did the work of certain authors, especially that of Lewis Henry Morgan, gain such prominence in their thinking? 
 In order to answer this last question it is necessary to look briefly at the type of anthropological work available to Marx and Engels at the time they were writing. 
 Marx's and Engels's search for theories of the evolution of society was not difficult in the latter half of the nineteenth century. 
 Anthropology has in fact developed as the science of the evolution of human society and many early anthropological works take the form of natural histories of mankind. 
 These histories, it was believed, could be constructed by looking at the available information on primitive peoples, past and present, whether from archaeological remains, from classical accounts of early institutions, such as those given by Tacitus concerning the German tribes of Roman times, or early Greece and Rome themselves, or, most importantly, from the reports of travellers, explorers,  colonists and missionaries, describing contemporary primitives. 
 These reports amassed in Europe in ever-increasing numbers from the sixteenth century on. 
 One of the first such histories was written by the French writer and philosopher Montesquieu in the middle of the eighteenth century under the title The Spirit of the Laws . 
 This was an attempt to explain the evolution of law in terms of the nature of government, which itself was explained by a variety of other factors, such as climate and population density. 
 Montesquieu's own work was not entirely new since it was based on classical models, but it started a growing tradition both in France and in the other main centre of the eighteenth-century Enlightenment, Scotland. 
 From the first, these universal histories represented both scientific advances and political and religious challenges. 
 That was because they tended to imply that beliefs, laws, and principles were not based on eternal unchanging principles but were aspects of the type of society in which they occurred. 
 Furthermore because these societies change and evolve it was natural that morals and laws should also change according to the social and economic system. 
 This tradition of writing natural histories of human societies continued to develop with individual and idiosyncratic additions throughout the nineteenth century in a number of different countries. 
 From 1860 on, however, a dramatic increase in the number of such works occurred; a veritable explosion of major publications took place which owed a great deal to the excitement aroused by The Origin of Species . 
 It is in the light of these publications and the furore caused by Darwinian evolutionary theories in general that Marx's and Engels's historical work on pre-capitalist societies must be seen. 
 Indeed, Marx saw his work very much in this light and at one time proposed to dedicate Capital  to Darwin, who refused, horrified as he already was by the religious and political repercussions of what he had written. 
 For Marx, however, these political and religious implications were what was central. 
 Evolutionary theory gave a natural origin to human institutions instead of the supernatural origin which was the received and legally sanctioned view in much of nineteenth-century Europe, and if institutions and ideas had a natural historical origin they could be changed in changing conditions. 
 The theory of natural selection meant that natural species could be explained in terms of the conditions necessary for their survival, and it seemed a small further step to explaining human  social systems in such terms; that is, in terms of the ways by which human beings gained their livelihood and reproduced. 
 This was very much the implication which was drawn from Darwin's work by those anthropologists who published immediately after The Origin of Species , so that they enthusiastically talked of natural selection and the survival of the fittest in their outlines of human history. 
 Marx's attitude is more complex. 
 On the one hand Marx saw Darwinism as a materialist explanation of man, and he sought theories of the evolution of human societies which similarly explained the process in terms of the changing nature of human production and reproduction. 
 This evolution of human society could explain what mechanisms had produced the ideas, principles, and processes which governed capitalism, why these had come about, why they had strength, and, ultimately, where their weakness was. 
 On the other hand, if Marx, like most of the anthropologists of his time, saw the study of human society as the continuation of biological evolution, he did not, as they did, believe that human historical processes were the same as the processes of natural selection. 
 Throughout his work Marx stresses how different man is from animals, because he acts in terms of ideas and concepts which are formed in his mind, and therefore human history is of a different kind to natural history. 
 Marx pours scorn on eighteenth- and nineteenth-century philosophers, such as the utilitarians, who believed that ideas and values had no real significance but were a mere reflection of natural conditions. 
 For Marx, as for Hegel and Kant, the German philosophers who greatly influenced him, ideas could not be brushed aside and the unique character of humans as thinking animals was central to all his work. 
 This meant that Marx had to develop a theory which recognized the intellectual nature of man, but which &mdash; and in this he was different from Hegel and Kant, who did not believe that there could ultimately be a material origin to ideas &mdash; could account for the peculiar history of mankind and for the growth of ideas and their power in natural terms. 
 The answer which Marx gave to this problem resembles that given later by Durkheim. 
 Marx concluded that the purely abstract philosophical debates which had characterized such discussions, in Germany, at least, were fruitless. 
 Rather, Marx argued, the nature of man could only be revealed by seeing man in society, in history, and in politics. 
 There was no point imagining him  outside of his context, because out of this context he was not, in any useful sense, man. 
 Marx's attitude to the numerous anthropological works which came out between 1860 and 1880 was therefore in part one of shared enthusiasm for evolutionary theory, but also in part one of suspicion. 
 This suspicion had two causes: he felt that many of the anthropologists underrated the significance of thought, and secondly he suspected the political motives of at least some of them. 
 In 1861 two books were combined, both of which influenced Marx and Engels. 
 The first was a study by the British lawyer Sir Henry Maine called Ancient Law . 
 This examines the development of classical and early Indian law in terms of the famous generalization that law and, by implication, society evolves from &bquo;status to contract&equo;. 
 In early societies relationships between people are governed by such things as their gender, their age, and their family relationships (these Maine called status relations), while in more advanced societies they are governed by contractual arrangements which are not concerned with the status of those involved, but only with the matter which brings the individuals together. 
 Marx accepted this general point implicitly though he nowhere discussed it in full &lsqb;Krader, 1972:36&rsqb; and it was to offer a framework to much of his later writing. 
 He was later to become suspicious of Maine's motives, however, as he was to see in the glorification of contract a subtle justification of the legal institutions of capitalism, and he was to seen in Maine's insistence on the primacy of the monogamous family an attempt to prove that this institution was beyond historical change. 
 In the same year the Swiss scholar, J. J. Bachofen, published Das Mutterrecht , (Mother Right), a book showing that matriliny, the tracing of descent through women, and matriarchy, the dominance of women in society, as well as the cult of female goddesses, preceded the patriarchy and the patriliny we find in Biblical and Classical societies. 
 This idea was accepted with varying degrees of caution by many nineteenth-century anthropologists and ultimately was wholly endorsed by Engels, who, in the preface to the fourth edition of The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State , gave warm praise to Bachofen. 
 Bachofen and Maine were soon followed by J. F. McLennan, a Scotsman whose work in part coincided with that of Bachofen and Maine but which developed much more the study of kinship systems. 
  This focus on kinship had an influence on both Marx and Engels which culminated in their enthusiasm for Lewis Henry Morgan whose two principal books had a decisive effect on their later work. 
 Morgan was an American lawyer whose involvement in anthropological theory was gradual, originating in his political and ethnographic interest in American Indians. 
 He realized the importance of kinship systems for the Indians and how for them most social relationships were seen in terms of who was the child of whom and who was married to whom. 
 His fascination with these systematic orderings of society by kinship was such that he undertook a massive comparison and classification of as many systems of kinship terms as he could find from around the world, terms such as &bquo;cousin&equo;, &bquo;uncle&equo;, etc. 
 This immense task formed the basis of his first major work: Systems of Consanguinity and Affinity of the Human Family  &lsqb;1870&rsqb; and was incorporated in his later and much more ambitious book Ancient Society  &lsqb;1877&rsqb;, which established a series of stages through which mankind was supposed to have proceeded. 
 These stages were based on productive technology. 
 For example, hunters and gatherers were placed low while irrigating cultivators were placed high, then these activities were linked directly with such institutions as rules concerning property, the status of women, the type of government, and the kinship system. 
 In this, Ancient Society  resembled the other evolutionary schemes for the history of mankind which we have just noted. 
 However, Ancient Society  also differed from earlier work because of the high quality of the scholarly work on which it was based, because of the sympathy of the writer for primitives, and because it not only defined stages but in many cases suggested mechanisms which explained why one stage should change to another. 
 This last element, perhaps more than any other, is crucial for understanding why Marx and Engels attached so much more importance to the work of Morgan than they did to the work of the other evolutionist anthropologists whom they read. 
 Morgan seems to suggest, however tentatively, reasons why one stage should change into another, in the idea that the processes of evolution themselves lead to the destruction of the stages they produced. 
 This theory came close to some of the central ideas which Marx had developed for capitalism. 
 Marx's exposition of capitalism was not just an attempt to  show its nature and its temporary character, it also showed how capitalism has an inner dynamic which brings about its development, its fruition, and ultimately its destruction. 
 All of Marx's and Engels's work attempts to isolate dynamic processes implies in the social forms which they were studying. 
 Marx argues in many places, but most clearly in the Preface to the Critique of Political Economy , that the source of the destruction of the capitalist system would come from the fact that the social system which itself had been created in order to work the factories and markets of capitalism would become increasingly incompatible with the technological requirements of these factories and markets, and that ultimately this incompatibility would lead to revolution. 
 This theory was elaborated at length by Marx for capitalism but he also assumed that similar phenomena would occur in non-capitalist systems. 
 Morgan was the only one of the nineteenth-century anthropologists who, like Marx, was interested in what led to the transformation of one social system into another, and in what led to the breakup of past systems. 
 The reason Morgan sees for the passage of society from one stage to another &mdash; and this is what is most stressed by Engels in his restatement of Morgan's theory in The Origin  &mdash; is a social break due too the fact that the various subsystems stop working in gear, and come into conflict with each other. 
 At such a point, the system implied by the technology of production &mdash; the kinship system, the system of property allocation, the political system, and the State &mdash; come into contradiction with each other, and in this way lead to the end of one stage and the appearance of another. 
 For example, when discussing the passage from matriliny to patriliny, Engels &lsqb;p. 119&rsqb; echoes Morgan's formulation in the following way:s &bquo;Thus, on the one hand, in proportion as wealth increased (as a result of the domestication of animals) it made the man's position in the family more important than the woman's, and on the other hand created an impulse to exploit this strengthened position in order to overthrow, in favour of his children, the traditional order of inheritance. 
 This, however, was impossible so long as descent was reckoned according to mother right. 
 Mother right, therefore, had to be overthrown&equo;. 
 Here we have the notion that as the system of technology (the domestication of animals and the formation of herds) develops, it becomes incompatible with the social system, especially the system of inheritance and familial authority, This growing incompatibility,  or contradiction, then leads to a revolutionary change in the social system, in this case the change to father right, a system which according to Morgan and Engels was better adapted to pastoralism. 
 Engels and Marx therefore saw in Morgan's ideas about the passage from one stage to another a confirmation of their general theory of social change. 
 This is perhaps the most important reason why Marx and Engels concentrated so much on Morgan's work, and by and large accepted the main lines of his account of the early history of mankind. 
 Morgan's work offered to Marx and Engels the early history of the processes which led to the creation of capitalism. 
 It also enabled them to show that the same processes had governed history from the earliest time and that a science of history was therefore possible. 
 Anthropology and the work of Morgan were harnessed to the political task of rewriting history. 
 There was another political task to which anthropology was put in the work of Marx, and for this the writings of Morgan also proved particularly appropriate. 
 The use of anthropology which we have already noted can be called historical. 
 Marx and Engels were interested in primitive cultures because they wanted to construct a general history and theory of society in order to explain the coming to be of capitalism. 
 The second way in which they use anthropological material we can call &bquo;rhetorical&equo;. 
 They wanted examples and cases to show that the institutions of capitalism are historically specific and therefore changeable; in order to demonstrate this they looked for examples of institutions which were as different from those of capitalism as possible. 
 In order to find examples of such an antithetical state of affairs they naturally turned to primitive society, as they assumed, like many before and after them, that these societies would offer illustrations of systems as totally different to those they knew as could be found anywhere. 
 For example, given the great emphasis on the family and monogamy in Victorian England they were delighted when they found in the work of anthropologists a statement that there had been societies with sexual freedom and no notion of the family. 
 This second and logically distinct, rhetorical use of anthropological material is never completely separate from the historical use, and the mixture of the two became, as we shall see, the source of many problems. 
 The rhetorical use of anthropology inevitably involved Marx and Engels in a search of the anthropological literature for examples  of opposites to the institutions of capitalism. 
 Since their work focused on certain topics it was natural that they particularly looked for evidence relating to these topics, and as examples of the rhetorical use of anthropology three such central topics can be noted here in a preliminary way. 
 These are the relationships existing between people engaged in the process of production, &bquo;the relations of production&equo;, property and the family. 
 Marx's work in Capital  is focused on the nature of the social relationship which existed between workers and capitalists: the capitalist relations of production. 
 Marx stressed the apparently impersonal nature of this relation in capitalism. 
 It is as if labour is a thing which comes naturally on the market and then inevitably is bought and sold according to the laws of supply and demand. 
 In this way of looking at the economy, wages seem to be determined by forces as inevitable as mathematics, and if wages were low this was no doubt unfortunate, but there was nothing anybody could do about it, any more than it would be possible to change the laws of gravity. 
 Marx's whole work was an attempt to show that this image was false; that there was nothing inevitable about all this, but rather that this apparent powerlessness of the worker to determine the wage was the product of the distribution of property and especially of the distribution of the ownership of such things as land, machines, tools, etc. 
 The capitalist system implied a monopoly of these &bquo;means of production&equo; in the hands of the few, so that the workers had no alternative but to work for the capitalist and on his terms in order to survive. 
 There was nothing inevitable or god given about this unequal distribution, and it is that which produced the impersonal free labour market and the exploitation. 
 The relations of capitalists and workers were therefore the product of a specific state of affairs, the ownership which had arisen in history and was not inevitable, or given in the laws of logic. 
 One obvious was of demonstrating that this system was a specific historical product was to show that it was not always so, and Marx and Engels turned to history and anthropology to demonstrate this. 
 Marx referred throughout his work to other systems than the capitalist system, especially those which he knew from the history of Europe to have preceded capitalism; systems such as feudalism, where the relation of production was characterized by the personal relation of the feudal lord and his  serf and a relation of subordination which came from the lord's control of the land. 
 Similarly, Marx was interested in slavery and in the classical Indian and Chinese social systems, or in those systems where the ties of local community are all important. 
 All these examples enabled Marx to show that the relations between those involved in the process of production can be extremely varied and need not be the depersonalized capitalist ones. 
 Rather Marx and Engels sought to show how social relations are themselves the product of the social system in which they occur, of the way the material conditions of existence are organized and regulated, a system which is itself the product of history or of the particular stage of evolution. 
 It is in this general perspective, aimed at demonstrating the link between the relations of production and the nature of the systems in which they were located, that Marx and Engels turned to the available anthropological information on pre-literate people. 
 They assumed that since these were the most distant from the capitalist system they would manifest the most different social relations of production. 
 They found confirmation of this in the one fact that nearly all nineteenth-century anthropologists were agreed upon, that what characterized primitives (if not perhaps the most primitive) was the predominance of kinship ties as the organizing principle of society. 
 In those societies, argues the anthropologists, people related to each other had obligations to each other, solely because they could trace links through parenthood or marriage. 
 It is this conclusion, which, with many modifications, many anthropologists would still accept, which made kinship so important for Marx and Engels. 
 Kinship, they believed, would contrast with the relations of production found in capitalist systems. 
 It seemed to Marx that nothing could be more different than kinship relations and relations in the labour market. 
 This is because kinship links are strongly morally and socially charged, while those between worker and employer are impersonal, because kinship implies reciprocal rights and duties while the capitalist has all the rights and the worker all the duties, because kinship links cannot be broken at will while those of the labour market can, and because, as Marx and Engels wrongly believed, kinship links are egalitarian and non-exploitative; that is, they do not involve one group of people living on the back of another. 
 This view of kinship as an opposite to capitalist relations of production explains the vivid interest with which Marx and  Engels examined the work of such anthropologists as Bachofen, McLennan, and Maine, who were all concerned with this topic; but above all it explains once again why Morgan should have been so important for them, since he above all was the expert on kinship. 
 Marx's and Engels's first concern with anthropological material was therefore to show the variety that exists in the nature of social relations, and the historical peculiarity of a society where one group of people treat others only in respect of the labour they provide, labour which then can be bought and sold as though it was any other useful article. 
 The search for counter-examples led them to the history of the family and of the primitive local community which they saw as kinship based. 
 There, they argued, &bquo;the social structure is&hellip; limited to an extension of the family&equo;. 
 Having reached this conclusion Marx and Engels then realized that if kinship was the system which organized primitive societies, then, kinship in these societies, had to be completely different from what it was in capitalist society. 
 This was because, throughout the work of the founders of Marxism, a central idea is that everything in capitalism is linked to the capitalist relations of production, and that therefore the family under capitalism is a capitalist phenomenon. 
 This was to be demonstrated in the same way as the arbitrariness of capital relations of production by showing that in totally different systems the family was totally different. 
 In the same way, therefore, as they had turned to primitives for finding the opposite of capitalist relations of production, they turned to them for a form of family which was the opposite of the capitalist family. 
 They thus found particularly congenial the work of those anthropologists such as Bachofen, and again Morgan, who saw primitive kinship as almost a total reversal of the family as they knew it. 
 They therefore accepted views of early kinship which represented it as a system where women were superior to men, where sex was unrestricted, and where the private and isolation of the group formed by parents and children was replaced by the commonality of a much larger undivided group. 
 The third example of the rhetorical use of anthropology by Marx and Engels concerns a topic linked to relations of production and the family: the nature of property. 
 Marx's analysis of capitalism shows that the system of exploitation of workers by capitalists appears inevitable because of a previous concentration of the means of production in the hands of the capitalists. 
 So, as they had done with the relations of production, Marx and Engels tried  to show that this state of affairs was not inevitable, but the product of a specific historical development. 
 They tried to show that the very notion of private property, far from being an &bquo;inalienable right&equo; as it was stated to be in the American constitution, was, in fact, itself a product of certain unique economic, technical, and social conditions, and it was therefore reasonable to expect that this notion, like others, would be superseded when the associated relations of production changed. 
 Marx's and Engels's work on pre-capitalist systems is largely taken up with showing the indissoluble link between the type of property and the type of relations of production. 
 The demonstration of the evolution and the transformations of types of property is as central to their work as the demonstration of the evolution of relations of production. 
 In the first of their works which deals with this topic at any length, The German Ideology , written in 1846, they state on page 43: &bquo;The various stages of development in the division of labour are just so many different forms of ownership, i.e. the existing stage in the division of labour determines also the relations of individuals to one another with reference to the material, instrument and product of labour.&equo; 
 However, equally important for Marx was the demonstration of a correlation between private property and exploitation. 
 Exploitation for Marx is the process by which a group of people are deprived of the full value of their labour so that what they have lost becomes a surplus for another group who obtain this element. 
 Capitalists exploit the workers by depriving them of this surplus value and they do this because of the nature of property in capitalist societies, where the means of production are controlled by the capitalist. 
 In such a situation the worker is at the mercy of the capitalist and is therefore exploited. 
 This central role for private property has a long history in European thought and goes back to the eighteenth-century notion of the social contract. 
 Such writers as the English philosopher Locke had argues that the security of private property was an essential prerequisite for the evolutionary progress of society and increasing human happiness. 
 He, and others like him, were answered by Rousseau, who argues that the social contract which established private property was really the origin of exploitation and had to be replaced by a new social contract. 
 Marx in many ways was the heir of the tradition which goes back to Rousseau and much of his work is concerned with demonstrating  why private property equals exploitation. 
 However, in order to answer those who had argued that without private property society was impossible, Marx looked for examples of a society without private property, again an opposite society, which would therefore also be without exploitation. 
 For this he turned again to Morgan. 
 Morgan's work was particularly suitable for this demonstration. 
 In fact, Marx and Engels did not have much choice among anthropologists because most of them were heirs to the philosophical tradition which went back to Locke and which glorified private property. 
 This was not the case with Morgan who seemed to have been more influenced by the Rousseauean tradition and who viewed the institution of private property with some misgivings. 
 In any case Morgan's work contained the statement that primitive society was totally without private property, yet organized. 
 It gave the best possible example that could be found for a rhetorical approach to the question of property. 
 It is easy, therefore, once again, to seen why Marx and Engels greeted Morgan's work with such enthusiasm, and in particular why they took his side in a major controversy that arose in anthropology between him and McLennan. 
 Morgan asserted, and McLennan denied, the existence of a first stage of society when social life was undifferentiated, when marriage did not exist, and when above all, private property did not occur. 
 For Marx and Engels the existence of such a stage, or something like it, seemed essential in order to show fully the purely artificial and relative nature of both relations of production and private property in capitalism. 
 In other words, Morgan's theories in this field once again fulfilled perfectly the rhetorical requirement for the demonstration of a totally opposite system to that of nineteenth-century Europe. 
 Marx and Engels therefore asked two things of anthropology. 
 First they looked to it for some confirmation that the general principles of history which they saw at work in capitalism had always been operative. 
 Secondly, they looked to anthropology to supply them with examples of contrastive, even opposite, systems of institutions to those of nineteenth-century capitalism. 
 They found material for both these purposes in the work of many anthropologists, but on the whole the writings of Morgan seemed best suited to this twin task. 
 Both these purposes are quite legitimate. 
 It stands to reason that if one is claiming to have discovered universal historical laws  these should apply to very different societies. 
 It is a sign of Marx's and Engels's intellectual courage that they put these laws to the test by seeing whether they accorded with what was then known about early cultures. 
 It is also perfectly valid to use data about other cultures to show that, because these cultures work on other principles than the principles which govern our society, the principles are historically specific and not universal and unchangeable. 
 There is however a problem, if one is trying to do both these things at the same time. 
 In the first case one is trying to stress the unity of human history, in the other, one is trying to show the diversity and discontinuity of human history. 
 This conflict led Marx, and especially Engels, to a disastrous attempt to combine both approaches by arguing that there really had been an early stage in human history which was a mirror image of capitalism. 
 This early state was not constructed from proper historical evidence of any kind. 
 Because of its incorporation into the &bquo;history&equo; of mankind it led to totally fallacious ideas which even today unwittingly mislead many Marxists. 
 In this type of mistaken fabrication of early history, by the construction of an opposite to the present, Marx and Engels were following many other writers of their time but, as we shall see, because of the nature of their theory, this was particularly harmful in their case. 
 This early stage in the history of mankind appears in The Origin  as characterized mainly by what it does not have. 
 In this time there were no individual families, there was no private property, there was not marriage, there was no exploitation, there was no inequality of any kind even between men and women, since, before the coming of private property women were, if anything, superior. 
 In pointing out that the specific forms of marriage, family, property, and gender relations which existed in their time had not always existed, Marx and Engels were completely right, but in arguing positively that these things were totally absent in primitive society, they were, as we shall see, almost totally wrong. 
 The problem with such a misrepresentation was much more significant than a mere historical mistake. 
 A mistake could, after all, have been fairly simply corrected when knowledge about these societies improved. 
 The difficulty lay in the fact that what characterized their view of primitive society was that it was classless and free of exploitation, while the Marxist theory of society is built around the idea of class. 
 As a result, Marx and  Engels were not only wrong about this early stage in the history of mankind, but they also left themselves unable to deal with it theoretically. 
 Marx's theory about what causes the historical process has been very widely discussed and we shall return to it again and again in this book, but even at this stage a simple account of it must be given. 
 Marx believed that the history of human societies was to be explained first of all by the nature of man as an animal who had to obtain a living from his geographical environment, which meant not only staying alive, but also being able to look after one's offspring until they could look after themselves. 
 Marx, however, realized that the need to make a living could never directly explain what human beings do, nor could it account for the complexity of human history itself. 
 This was because human beings worked things out in their minds in terms of concepts and moral rules, and these concepts and rules were not things the individual made for himself on the spur of the moment. 
 One can only understand how things are in terms of concepts in the first place, so in a sense the concepts came first since natural conditions only gain significance in terms of the way one had learned to see them. 
 Furthermore the way one sees things, and the values one holds, are not an individualist matter, but something that is shared with other people in a society. 
 Because of this Marx concluded that it was wrong to see ideas and values simply as adaptations of the individual to natural conditions, as some eighteenthand nineteenth-century philosophers seemed to believe. 
 Society always came before the individual and determined what he thought he wanted. 
 This did not mean that ideas and values came from some supernatural source, but it did mean that they came from the history of society, not the history of the individual. 
 Society produces ideas and values in a complex historical way which Marx and other Marxists have attempted to define. 
 By and large Marx say two different processes going on side by side. 
 The first process is in part an aspect of the interaction of men grouped together in a society and engaged in production. 
 This process leads to concepts, ideas, valued, and institutions, which, although they are not the direct result of individual production, are the indirect product of the process of production undertaken as a social task. 
 The second process is an aspect of the fact that history also involves the development of exploitation, or the domination  of one group by another so that the dominant group cam appropriate to itself the surplus value obtained from the labour of the other. 
 The relation of classes in capitalist society is for Marx the most obvious example of this process. 
 The development of exploitation also leads to the formation of ideas, concepts, values, and institutions, but these, unlike those produced by the first process, are geared to operating exploitation, and involve giving the appearance of legitimacy to exploitation, as well as hiding its true nature from the exploited. 
 This second process Marx and Engels call &bquo;ideology&equo;. 
 Marx sees the process of production of concepts, values, and institutions, as extremely complex. 
 This complexity explains why the system of concepts and of values has no direct relationship with the process of production; the two don't fit. 
 This lack of fit is the product of the historical process of class formation, and it also has historical implications. 
 Marx envisages moments when the social system will accord with the technological system; but at other times it will enter into contradiction with it, leading to revolutionary changes. 
 This continually recurring disharmony Marx attributes to the nature of class relations, and it is this which produces the forward movement of history. 
 The key to history and the key to the way Marx saw the relationship between ideas, values, and the economic processes of production is, therefore, the exploitative nature of class relations. 
 As a result of the central place of class in Marxist theory, as soon as Marxists argue that primitive societies are without class they are left with very little to say about these societies which is in any way distinctive. 
 As we shall see, most of the writing of Marx concerning primitive societies are of the historical type and argue that these societies are class societies. 
 They therefore do not run into this difficulty. 
 For example, in The Communist Manifesto  Marx and Engels had written: &bquo;The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles.&equo; 
 But Engels, in later editions, added a footnote to this sentence stating that this remark does not apply to all human history but only to written  history. 
 This was because by then he had written The Origin  where he had argued that primitive society was classless, on the evidence he had obtained from Morgan. 
 This view was the product of the rhetorical use of anthropology masquerading as history, and is in fact wrong. 
  At the same time that Engels argued that primitive societies were classless, he inevitably argued that the complex and subtle theory of history which he and Marx had developed just did not apply to these societies. 
 He states this quite explicitly in several of his works and in particular in The Origin &hellip; 
 This conclusion, based on the fusion between rhetorical and historical use of anthropology in Marxism, left Marxists with almost no adequate analytical  tools for dealing with primitive societies. 
 Marx's theory of change was based on the growing contradiction that arose in society between the technological side of production and the social system with which it was associated. 
 This contradiction was due to the increasing tension between classes, caused by the development of the technology. 
 If primitive societies were classless, this whole process could obviously not take place, and so the theory of social change did not apply to them. 
 Similarly, Marx's theory by which he explained in part the historical formation of concepts, ideas, values, and institutions as a result of the legitimation of exploitation, (that is, ideology), was inapplicable to societies without exploitation. 
 Again, by having imagined wrongly that primitive societies were classless, Engels denied Marxists the use of the general sociological tools which had been developed in Marx's work. 
 As a result many Marxists, including Engels himself, fell back onto simple utilitarian explanations when they were dealing with these societies, one of the types of explanation which Marx had vigorously rejected. 
 This type of simplistic explanation of primitive societies has dogged Marxist anthropology since Engels's time. 
 In a sense, Marxists stopped being Marxist when they turned to primitive society. 
 As a result many Marxists have had to look outside Marxism to explain primitive societies, so they often imported theories of history from the anthropologists whom they used as sources. 
 In later chapters we shall see Marxist writers borrowing fundamental theoretical notions, not just from Morgan, but also from others, such as the British anthropologist Taylor, and the German anthropologist Ratzel, and taking on these writers' simple-minded theories of history in spite of the fact that they were influenced by philosophical positions totally foreign to Marxism. 
 These theories seem na&iuml;ve when compared with the explanations Marxists reserve for capitalist societies. 
 In fact they are no more adequate for primitive societies than they would have been for any others. 
 The history of Marxist anthropology since The Origin  has, as a  result, been the difficult, painful, and incomplete recovery of Marxism for pre-capitalist social formations, and the story of this process is what we shall consider in the second half of this book. 
 This recovery has been made necessary because, as we have seen, the rhetorical and historical use of anthropology got so disastrously mixed up in the work of the founders and produced a false picture of the idyllic classless community which was later termed primitive communism and then got further confused with the type of society the Marxists were trying to construct in the future.  
 Marx and Engels on Anthropology 
 Having seen the general place of anthropological material in Marx and Engels's writing, we can now look in a little more detail at particular works and their contents. 
 Since the anthropological material forms an organic whole with the writings of Marx and Engels, and is important for everything they wrote, a somewhat arbitrary selection needs to be made of what to examine in detail. 
 We shall therefore only look  at some of the writings we could have considered, and concentrate on those works which contain a large proportion of anthropological discussion. 
 The German Ideology, 1846  The first book where Marx and Engels include in their political writings a thorough analysis of the evolution of society and of pre-capitalist social formations is The German Ideology . 
 It was a long book which attempted to define Marx's and Engels's position vis-&agrave;-vis  a whole range of contemporary socialist philosophers. 
 It was not in fact published during Marx's or Engels's lifetime. 
 Only the first part of this work is much read nowadays and that is what is discussed here. 
 The German Ideology  is often seen with the Theses on Feuerbach , which was written just before it, as forming together the first formulation of Marxism. 
 In many ways these books are the continuation of both Marx's and Engels's earlier work. 
 Most important for our concern here is the way The German Ideology  is the culmination of Marx's critical discussion of the place and significance of the State. 
 For Hegel, the philosopher who up to that time had most influenced Marx, the idea of the State was a major force in history and the true source of justice. 
 This view was then modified by the &bquo;young Hegelians&equo;, a group of radical followers and critics of Hegel who argues that it was only the reformed or purified State which could be the source of a just society. 
 Marx carried the criticism of Hegel's position much further, and he is equally critical of the young Hegelians. 
 He argues that, far from the State being the prime mover of history, the State itself is simply an aspect of a particular type of society. 
  What Marx meant by a particular society was an organization of people making a living together. 
 In this perspective political reform of the State was therefore largely irrelevant since what had to be reformed was the complex order of which the State and law were only epiphenomena. 
 By arguing this, Marx therefore redefined the task of the revolutionary. 
 There was no point in being a mere political reformer intent on changing laws and state institutions to make social conditions better. 
 This would be pointless since the State was not the cause of the unjust social system but simply its effect. 
 What was necessary was instead to become a reformer of the very inner basis of society. 
 This fundamental difference with the position of earlier radicals required theoretical analysis in two areas. 
 First of all &bquo;society&equo;, as distinct from the State, had to be isolated and analysed, and secondly an attempt had to be made at understanding the evolution of society, since only then would it be possible to understand under what circumstances the State evolved and what its historical significance was. 
 These were the tasks first attempted in The German Ideology . 
 The first task consisted of formulating a view of society which was based on principles different from the traditional ones, according to which societies could be typified in terms of their administrative organization by using such terms as &bquo;democracy&equo; or &bquo;monarchy&equo;. 
 If we talked of society in these terms, Marx argued, we could never appreciate that the phenomena to which the terms referred were themselves only the product of a more fundamental social process. 
 In order to bypass this traditional way of seeing society, Marx turned away from administrative and political organization and tried to see society in different, more fundamental terms. 
 He argued that society is at bottom a system of organization for producing the goods on which people depend for their life. 
 For Marx and Engels society was to be analysed in terms of the social organization of production, which in The German Ideology  they called the division of labour. 
 After this had been analysed, they then, and only then, went on to consider how this basic process was linked with ideas and values, such as justice and law, and with institutions, such as property and the State. 
 The new theoretical starting point which such a study implied became the basis of all their work, and it is the central characteristic of their anthropology. 
 It also implied, however, a further difference from the earlier studies of societies concentrating on political institutions and laws. 
 People living in a particular society  must be aware of their laws and institutions since they have to obey them. 
 This meant that what the social scientist was doing in building up a picture of the political society was systematizing people's conscious  perceptions into a system. 
 On the other hand, people do not have to be conscious of the system of production as such. 
 They have to make the system work, of course, but in order to do this, they do not have to be conscious of its nature. 
 Indeed, Marx argued that in most cases, because the social system is based on exploitation, people have to be consciously unaware of the basis of society if they are to continue working it. 
 Because of this, a Marxist theoretical construction of the social system implied that one should start by ignoring people's beliefs and ideas and by looking at who produces what and who gets what is produced. 
 This is completely different from what people might believe  are the contributions made to production by different groups in society and what people might believe  are the principles of production. 
 Society viewed as a system for production and distribution, conceived of independently of the actors' representations or justifications of the system, is what was later called the &bquo;social formation&equo;. 
 Only after the social formation had been constructed could the evaluation of the role of institutions and values be undertaken in terms of the place of these consciously-realized phenomena in its working. 
 The significance of using this starting point, outside of the actors' consciousness, cannot be exaggerated, because it set Marx, Engels, and other Marxists on an analytical course which was fundamentally different from other social analysts of their time, and which to a certain extent still distinguishes Marxist analyses from many others. 
 The first task of working out a method whereby society can be apprehended as a social system for the organization of production, rather than as a structure of consciously realized institutions, is only sketched out in The German Ideology , but it was to be developed in all of Marx's later work, and it culminated in the analysis of capitalism contained in the three volumes of Capital . 
 The same preliminary character is also found in the other task which Marx's redefinition of the aim of social analysis required. 
 Not only did Marx and Engels require tools for seeing society in a new way, they also needed to understand under what circumstances this newly defined system produced the institutions which  other social scientists had studied. 
 Neither could the evolutions of these institutions in themselves explain anything, since, in the perspective outlined above, these were mere side effects of a more fundamental order. 
 What had to be understood was the process which led to the evolution of society seen in this new light. 
 In order to do this, Marx and Engels turned to historical and anthropological information about past societies. 
 Here also their task was to understand history not in terms of the evolution of institutions, but in terms of the evolution of society as they had redefined it. 
 This meant that, although they could turn to the work of historians and anthropologists, they had to reinterpret that work in their own way. 
 It is this task which began Marx's and Engels's study and analysis of anthropological works. 
 The evolutionary sequence for the history of mankind which is sketched out in The German Ideology  is patchy and in some respects inconsistent, but the main features emerge clearly. 
 The first stage in the history of mankind is one which is itself subdivided into three substages. 
 These correspond &lsqb;1&rsqb; to hunting and fishing, &lsqb;2&rsqb; to the rearing of animals and &lsqb;3&rsqb; to simple agriculture &lsqb;p. 44&rsqb;. 
 The authors are not particularly interested in this technology of production but in how this progression implies an increasing division of labour which alters the nature of social relations. 
 At first, social organization is limited to the family, it is therefore dominated by kinship, and property is communal. 
 The family, however, already contains within itself the seeds of latent exploitation in the ability of the male head to control the labour of women and children &lsqb;p. 52&rsqb;. 
 This inequality, argue Marx and Engels, implies a form of private property, because exclusion from the means of production (private property) and compulsion of the labour of others, are one and the same thing. 
 This idea, that private property and exploitation are just two sides of the same coin, is a central proposition of Marxist theory and is clearly expressed here. 
 Making the means of production into private property leads to exploitation, for if people have no access to the means of production they are at the mercy of those who do. 
 The embryonic inequality and private property in the family continues to develop through time as the head of the family becomes more a patriarchal family chieftain (the lineage elder of modern anthropology) controlling the labour of the other members of the lineage. 
 Finally, in a further stage of development, the inequality within the family develops into slavery which is already  &bquo;latent in the family&equo;. 
 This stage is reached not just as a result of the increasing complexity of the productive technology, in this case the development of agriculture, but because agriculture implies a growth in population density, an intensification of social intercourse, and an increased division of labour. 
 The division of labour here is a notion used in part to express the fact that with more complex technology one gets more specialization in society, however for Marx and Engels such differentiation also always implies inequality. 
 In this idea Marx and Engels are different from earlier writers such as Adam Smith, or later writers such as Durkheim, who say nothing necessarily inegalitarian in the division of labour. 
 The tribal stage, with its three subdivisions, is itself followed by one of two alternatives: either by the stage of the city state or be feudalism. 
 Which of these two occurs seems to depend, for Marx and Engels, on population density. 
 They thus explain the rise of feudalism in Europe and the corresponding absence of city states as due to the fact that &bquo;the different starting point was determined by the sparseness of the population at that time&equo; &lsqb;p. 45&rsqb;. 
 By contrast the ancient or classical stage, which was characterized by the city states of antiquity, arose as a result of several tribes coming together to form a city. 
 In the city state although communal property continues as the dominant form of property, private property also takes a hold, because the &bquo;class relation between citizens and slaves which had appeared before, is now completely developed&equo;. 
 As before, exploitation and private property are seen as aspects of the same thing. 
 As the city state continues to develop, private ownership becomes more and more concentrated in the hands of some of the citizens, but the division this give rise to does not lead to the formation of classes among the freemen because they remain united against the slaves. 
 The relation of slaves and freemen is, however, for Marx and Engels a true class relation. 
 More important for them is the other alternative which can follow the first primitive stage: feudalism. 
 This is the system which they see as having replaced the Roman Empire in Europe. 
 For Marx and Engels feudalism was based on a kind of dispersed slavery &mdash; serfdom &mdash; and therefore was really not all that different from the social system of the ancient city states. 
 The one big difference lies in the fundamentally rural character of feudalism. 
 This meant that the cities which ultimately grew up within this  rural society were of a different character from the surrounding countryside. 
 While with the ancient city state there was a unity between town and country, since country settlements were really extensions of the city both in the type of economic activity which took place there and in the principles of social organization in the two places, this was not so under feudalism. 
 The difference led to an important conflict between town and country. 
 At first the freemen of both town and country had an organization and a type of property which still retained something of the communal as well as something of the private, but in the town a radical transformation was taking place. 
 This transformation was due first to the influx of runaway serfs into the towns which meant that labourers free from the personal ties of feudalism, but having no access to the means of production, became a dependent and exploitable group which was to become the proletariat. 
 The proletariat are &bquo;free&equo; labourers in the sense that they can sell their labour to whoever will employ them, but are not free to do anything but  sell their labour, since they have no access to the means of production: land, tools, workshops, raw materials. 
 In a sense this &bquo;freedom&equo; is in fact total dependence and subordination to those who do control the means of production. 
 This dependence contrasts with the dependence of serfs or slaves in being non-personal and non-permanent. 
 The contrast between the total but impersonal dependence of the proletariat and the personal dependence of the slave was an idea which Marx was to continue to develop in most of his later work. 
 It is another of the key elements of his social analysis. 
 Later Marx was to argue that the slave is in a sense less badly off than the &bquo;free&equo; labourer because the slave master has an interest in the health and welfare of the slave, since he owns him, but the capitalist has no such interest in his workers. 
 Associated with the growth of the proletariat in the towns of feudal times were other processes which together led to the concentration of the means of production in ever-fewer hands, a process which ultimately led to the capitalism of the nineteenth century. 
 The important place of the analysis of the transition to capitalism in The German Ideology  reminds us once again of the primarily political purpose of the anthropological and historical analysis. 
 Although the discussion of this process is beyond the scope of this book we must not forget that the whole outline of history is sketched in The German Ideology  for two purposes and  not for itself. 
 The first such purpose is to show how capitalism and its institutions have been produced by history and how it will therefore be destroyed by history. 
 The second purpose is to show how the beliefs and values which organize our society are produced by the history of the social formation. 
 This second purpose is dealt with not only in the brief account of evolution outlined above but by a philosophical discussion of the production of ideas in history which it is equally essential to understand for apprehending the Marxist attitude to history and anthropology. 
 The starting point of this philosophical discussion is a rejection of the theories, such as those of Hegel and the young Hegelians, which saw ideas and institutions as the source of history, as though these existed apart from the natural processes of human production and reproduction. 
 Marx and Engels argues that we must understand ideas as products of people engaged in this natural process and see the production of ideas as an aspect of the general enterprise of making a living from nature. 
 This is the position known as materialism; it is opposed to idealism which, in a broad sense, sees the basis of human existence as abstract spiritual concepts whose origin cannot be explained by natural circumstances. 
 Idealism has a long history in philosophy, going back at least to the Irish philosopher Berkeley, and it is sometimes attributed, as it was by Marx, to Plato. 
 Marx's and Engels's rejection of idealism, however, is qualified in that they also reject the crude materialism which they saw manifested in the work of such writers as the German socialist Feuerbach. 
 If it is natural conditions of existence which are the basis of human history, this does not mean that human society and concepts are simply an automatic product or reflection of physical existence, as Feuerback and other &bquo;vulgar&equo; materialists seem to imply. 
 Marx's and Engels's position is always something of a balancing act between idealism and crude or &bquo;vulgar&equo; materialism and this is nowhere better illustrated than in The German Ideology  and the Theses on Feuerbach . 
 Human existence, for Marx and Engels, occurs in terms of people's concepts, which are incorporated in their mode of life and their subjective experience, but it is from man's interaction with nature and from the history of this interaction that these ideas, beliefs, and values are created in the first place. 
 The argument runs like this: at any particular time people apprehend natural material circumstances through their ideas, and they  therefore act in terms of these ideas, beliefs, and values. 
 Therefore, in history it is not nature and technology which makes human society but it is man himself, who in terms of his already existing ideas and values, makes his own history, as he encounters nature and the problems it poses. 
 These already existing ideas and values are, however, themselves the product of previous encounters and answers to the challenge of nature. 
 This means that the relation of ideas and practical problems can only be understood as part of the process of history. 
 Ideas and concepts held by people are not therefore simply a reflection of how nature is at any particular time; they are the historical product of the need to organize society so that human beings in society can produce and reproduce. 
 Ideas and concepts may thus be in fact misleading as to the real condition of existence; they are not the reflection  of the economic system but the product of a complex historical process of changing adaptation. 
 An illustration of the complex relationship, envisaged by Marx and Engels, between ideas and the process of production is offered by one of their central concerns: the representation of labour. 
 According to them the capitalist representation of labour, the idea that labour is a thing which can be bought and sold, came about as a result of certain economic and technical developments in medieval towns. 
 Later this representation was adopted as the dominant idea of what labour is, since such a concept makes the exploitation of people in capitalism possible. 
 Though this idea was ultimately caused by economic and technical developments, and is in fact a misrepresentation of social relations, the idea is real enough to the people concerned. 
 They see labour as something which can be bought and sold and, for them, that is all there is to it; when they use that idea of labour they are unaware of and unconcerned with what has caused it. 
 Because of this their actions are in terms of their concept of labour and this idea of labour is therefore in itself an important causative factor in history. 
 Similarly the attempt to reveal the falsity of this representation of labour by examining the history of its development is part of a revolutionary activity since it challenges the unquestionability of the dominant representation. 
 Marx's and Engels's materialism is thus not the denial of the importance of ideas, concepts, and values for people, like the materialism of Feuerbach, but an assertion that ideas ultimately have a material origin in the real conditions of existence, a history  which consists in a complicated interplay and conflict of different factors, some directly material, some mental (though material in origin). 
 This interplay and this conflict are the driving forces of history/ they are a process which Marx referred to by the word &bquo;dialectic&equo;. 
 &bquo;Dialectic&equo; is a term which he borrows from Hegel but which he uses in a very different sense to Hegel's. 
 Using the term &bquo;dialectic&equo; means that the process of movement which characterizes human history is not a smooth development but a development caused by conflicts and contradictions which lead to temporary resolutions, like two people arguing with each other. 
 It is by this process of conflict and contradiction, caused by a multiplicity of factors all arising from the natural conditions of existence, that history proceeds to the human condition and human ideas current at a particular moment. 
 In this way Marx and Engels give us an alternative to the idealist philosophies which they reject. 
 Yet their theory does not underestimate either the power of ideas of the complexity of the process of their historical production. 
 Indeed a great part of The German Ideology  is concerned with this process, which Marx and Engels discuss under the label of the origin of &bquo;consciousness&equo;. 
 Their use of the word &bquo;consciousness&equo; refers to the system of meaning through which we apprehend the world, as well as the ideas, opinions and beliefs which we are aware of holding. 
 The two things are not the same, and, although Marx and Engels are not very clear, they do attempt to distinguish them. 
 As we saw above, for them one of the commonest mistakes of the crude materialism which they criticize is to think that men deal with the world simply as it is; as it would be defined by physics or biology. 
 This is not so, they argue, because we apprehend the world through a system of meaning which we have learned from others and of which language is an essential part. 
 That does not mean that ideas and language come first. 
 &bquo;Life is not determined by consciousness but consciousness by life&equo;. 
 &lsqb;P.47.&rsqb; 
 Consciousness, which is indissolubly linked to language, is itself a social product. 
 It is moulded by the interaction of men together in history and by their dealing with nature, i.e. with plants, animals, their environment, and their own bodies. 
 This process of interaction is for Marx and Engels both a source of conceptualization and also of a sort of natural religion, at least in the earlier stages of evolution. 
 However for the periods they are concerned with, this first process is not all; as the relation of man to nature becomes  more complex through more advanced technology, they see another process coming into play. 
 Improved technology, according to Marx and Engels, leads to greater division of labour which leads to greater inequality and to private property and greater social differentiation. 
 Now, since consciousness is adapted to the practical needs of society and that society divides into subsocieties which have a different type of existence, it follows that these different subsocieties develop their own consciousness. 
 In more complex societies and especially under capitalism these different sections of society &mdash; classes &mdash; dispose of different power, and because of this the dominant class is able to impose its own consciousness on the whole of society. 
 As a result there ceases to exist unalloyed the direct feedback, characteristic of primitive societies, between natural conditions and consciousness. 
 The consciousness of the dominant class is adapted to the need of operating the domination of this class. 
 It is not an adaptation of society as a whole, and, Marx and Engels argue, it therefore has to hide the exploitation on which the dominant class relies. 
 In this sense this imposed consciousness is a false consciousness for those who are dominated, since it serves the purposes of the superiors but not of the inferiors. 
 It hides from the inferiors the sources of domination and the process by which this has come about. 
 False consciousness is usually referred to by Marx by the term &bquo;ideology&equo; and that is how the word will be used in this book. 
 The word &bquo;ideology&equo; is, however, also sometimes used to simply mean the system of concepts and ideas in general. 
 The muddle that these two uses of the word cause is in part Marx's and Engels's fault because when they are talking about society based on communal property, that is, before false consciousness arises, they mean by ideology the total process of cognition including language, political ideas, social rules, etc., but when they are talking of class society where false consciousness is present they seem to mean by ideology something much more restricted: moral, political, and religious ideas and values. 
 They do not discuss clearly whether in class society they consider all aspects of cognition to be moulded by false consciousness or only certain aspects. 
 They are, however, quite clear that the State and the apparatus of the State, especially law, are some of the tools of the dominant class, and are therefore primes examples of false consciousness. 
 Because of this, political ideas in class societies, ideas such as the sovereignty of the State  and the particular idea of justice embodied in law, are all manifestations of the imposition of the consciousness of the dominant class, because they facilitate and hide class exploitation. 
 It is in this context that Marx and Engels finally turn the tables on the ideas of philosophers who, like Hegel, had argued about the primacy of ideas, especially the idea of the State, as though these ideas had formed the processes of history rather than the other way round. 
 What Marx and Engels show is that since these ideas are examples of ideology, attributing to them causal primacy amounts to making them unquestionable, and to making the social order which they legitimate and organize &mdash; capitalism &mdash; free from possible challenge. 
 The very philosophy of the Hegelians is therefore not a challenge to society but a way of making such challenge unthinkable. 
 It is not a theory of history but a product of history designed to serve the purposes of the ruling class. 
 It is a prime example of ideology. 
 The German Ideology  is one of the main works where Marx and Engels developed an evolutionary theory for political ends, and it raises a whole range of questions, some of which, like that of the rise of false consciousness or ideology, they never treated systematically again. 
 The book in other ways also reflects how little they had yet formulated a detailed evolutionary history of society. 
 For the tribal stage, in particular, they base themselves only on the vaguest generalization as gathered probably from philosophical treatises. 
 The German Ideology  makes no detailed references to specific studies of primitive societies or to the work of anthropologist. 
 Even the references to classical antiquity and feudalism remain vague and unspecific, although it is clear that, unlike their discussion of tribal society, these are based on much greater knowledge, obtained largely from the classical education they both shared. 
 The German Ideology  represents, therefore, a first foray into anthropology, which is important more because of its attempt to isolate such general problems as the relation between property and the State, the growth of consciousness, and the way material circumstances produce mental concepts than for specific formulations about the nature of pre-capitalist systems or the way the evolution of society had taken place. 
 This Marx and Engels were to attempt to do in more detail in their subsequent works. 
 Most generally,  The German Ideology  is important as a turning point. 
 Here Marx and Engels decided that the understanding of  man depends on the understanding of men in society and history, not on understanding philosophical controversy Pre-Capitalist Economic Formations, 1857&ndash;8  The next work of Marx and Engels, after The German Ideology , to discuss the history of human society was The Communist Manifesto  of 1848. 
 Of course this famous pamphlet was a much more practical political publication than The German Ideology  and it was written at a time of tremendous political ferment. 
 It is not surprising that the references to the past it contains are very brief. 
 Nevertheless, in the first part of The Manifesto  there is renewed reference to the evolution of society. 
 The central point of the system outlined in The German Ideology  is spelled out particularly clearly: &bquo;The history of all hitherto existing society is the history of class struggles. 
 Freeman and slave, patrician and plebeian, lord and serf, guildmaster and journeyman, in a word oppressor and oppressed, stood in constant opposition to one another, carried on an uninterrupted, now hidden, now open fight, a fight that each time ended either in a revolutionary reconstruction of society at large, or in the common ruin of the contending classes.&equo; 
 In contrast to The German Ideology  reference to the tribal stage has been dropped but the centrality of class struggle remains. 
 The emphasis on revolution as ending every stage is, also, much more definitely stated than in earlier works. 
 The most important aspect of these passing remarks in The Communist Manifesto  however, have, already been discussed in the previous chapter. 
 That is, they make crystal clear something which is implied in The German Ideology , that the history of mankind is governed by the same processes in all times, and that the main one of these processes is class conflict. 
 After The Communist Manifesto , the next elaboration of the overall evolutionary scheme of the history of pre-capitalist society comes in preliminary works by Marx, usually known as Grundrisse , written in 1858, ten years after The Manifesto . 
 In the interval much had happened to Marx and he was by then an exile in London in a place and a situation where inevitably he was more remote from the centres of political action. 
 As a result his writing becomes less concerned with immediate political concerns and he had more time for reading and research. 
 He was therefore  able to expand his studies in the way that was ultimately to produce Capital , his main theoretical work. 
 Grundrisse  consists of a series of notebooks which were never finally prepared for publication and are therefore somewhat untidy and unsystematic. 
 They contain much expansion, however, of the ideas found in the more finished work of that period: the three volumes of Capital  and the short Preface to a Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy . 
 The most significant part of Grundrisse  for our subject is that part which has been published separately in English under the title Pre-Capitalist Economic Formations  together with a very valuable introduction by the historian E. Hobsbawm. 
 Formen , as these notebooks are often called, offers the background to two of the most famous remarks in the whole of Marx's work. 
 The first is the remark in Volume I of Capital  that &bquo;commodity exchange (a necessary prerequisite to capitalism) begins where community life ends&equo;. 
 The second is the statement of a clear evolutionary sequence in the Preface to a Contribution to the Critique of Political Economy , the work where Marx expresses &lsqb;p. 83&rsqb; most coherently his theory of history: &bquo;In broad outlines Asiatic, ancient, feudal and modern bourgeois modes of production can be designated as progressive epochs in the economic formation of society&equo;. 
 If the evolutionary scheme given in the Preface  seems absolutely clear and definite, this is not the picture which emerges from the less systematic Formen . 
 As in The German Ideology , we seem to start with a similar early evolutionary stage which is roughly described as &bquo;tribal&equo; and which in itself divided into three. 
 The first substage of the tribal stage is hunting, of which Marx tells us practically nothing. 
 It is intimately linked to the second substage, pastoralism, which, Marx believed, following the accepted view of the time &mdash; itself much influenced by Biblical sources &mdash; always preceded agriculture. 
 Some sort of property already exists with pastoralism, Marx tells us, although he modifies this elsewhere &lsqb;p. 69&rsqb;. 
 This property is, however, not conceptualized as something in itself (a kind of mystical link between people and things as it is with fully developed private property) because it remains only an aspect of the social relations of which the tribe consists. 
 &bquo;Property therefore means belonging to a tribe,&equo; &lsqb;p. 90&rsqb; and even then it is not land which is property with pastoralists. 
 &bquo;What is appropriated  and reproduced  is here only the herd and not the soil which is always  used in temporary commonalty wherever the tribe breaks its wanderings.&equo; &lsqb;p. 89.&rsqb; 
 With settled agriculture the situation is somewhat different in that land becomes communal property, especially because of the need to defend it from &bquo;other tribes&equo;. 
 We are not dealing any more with temporary commonality but with permanent commonality. 
 However, what concerns Marx most is to show just how different this type of communal property is to private property under capitalism. 
 While under capitalism the owning and accumulating of property is seen as the aim of life, in tribal conditions property is simple seen as a necessary pre-condition of life and social relations. 
 Being a member of a tribe and a kinsman to the other members of the tribe automatically implies having access to the means of production controlled by the community. 
 The object of production under such circumstances is not to accumulate property but to make possible the continuation of the individual in society, since only as a member of society can one find meaning in human existence. 
 This point is of course another criticism of the individualist philosophies of utilitarians and of economists who saw early man as a kind of Robinson Crusoe trying to interact with nature in isolation and according to ideas and institutions which he had created on the spot. 
 The central concern of Formen  is to understand what social relations and institutions can be like when they are not moulded by capitalism. 
 Marx is continually facing a problem which is very familiar to anthropologists: how to express a different system with a vocabulary which is inevitably moulded to the institutions of the society in which it is normally used. 
 This can be seen throughout Formen  in his struggles with the word &bquo;property&equo;, but that is only a beginning. 
 What Marx is trying to construct in his imagination is what it would be to exist in such a different type of society. 
 Under capitalism the market and the desire to accumulate wealth appear to be a sufficient basis for social interaction and for regulating communal life; things and impersonal economic mechanisms have replaced people's commitment to each other while &bquo;the ancient conception in which man always appears (in however narrowly national, religious or political a definition) as the aim of production, seems very much more exalted that the modern world in which production is the aim of man and wealth the aim of production&equo; &lsqb;p. 84&rsqb;. 
 The attempt to grasp this difference and to put it into words is a  recurrent theme of Formen , especially because the secondary theme is to understand the contradiction which arises when the two opposed conceptions of man occur in the same society in periods of transition. 
 This is crucial because Marx was to go on to argue that capitalism grew out of one such combination in feudalism. 
 In Formen  Marx is mainly concerned with other contradictory combinations of incompatible social principles. 
 The first such combination to be considered is one which he calls the &bquo;Germanic&equo; mode of production, (&bquo;mode of production&equo;, in this work, meaning social evolutionary stage). 
 It is not clear how it differs from the third tribal substage associated with settled agriculture. 
 The Germanic mode of production is characterized by a society made up of largely independent family groups, each of which forms a basic and complete productive unit. 
 These independent family groups come together in assemblies for such things as war, religion, and the settlement of disputes, but they do not really form an organic whole. 
 The Germanic tribe is therefore based on shared locality rather than kinship, but it consists of a collection of kinship units each with access to a territory, thus &bquo;individual landed property (of the different families) does not appear as a contradictory form of communal landed property, nor as mediated by the community but the other way round. 
 The community exists only in the mutual relation of the individual landowners as such.&equo; 
 &lsqb;P. 80 modified.&rsqb; 
 What Marx wants to stress here is that although Germanic tribes form quite large groups of people they do not form any kind of community with communal property, as was the case in the ancient city states; they are merely ad hoc  agglomerates. 
 This is particularly significant for Marx since it means that the communal principle does not fully come into conflict with the interests of individual constitutive families as it did in the ancient city, a contradiction which ultimately led to further developments. 
 This Germanic organization remains extremely vague in Formen  and the reason seems to come from the paucity and dubiousness of Marx's sources for the construction of this mode of production. 
 In The German Ideology  Marx had used Tacitus as his source for tribal German society, but by the time of Formen  he became influenced by the nationalist and romantic nineteenth-century tradition of German historiography, a tradition which was to influence him even more later on, and which was to have a dramatic and harmful effect on Engels. 
 This tradition stressed how true   Germanic society was still to be found in the organization of ancient local communities. 
 It was egalitarian and free from the weakening and divisive influence of the Roman world and of urban society. 
 Within the local community it had survived during the Middle Ages and even to a certain extent right up to the nineteenth century, in spite of a foreign overlay of feudal institutions coming from western and southern Europe. 
 This romantic view of the Germanic commune had an unconscious effect on Marx and led him to follow those German historians who were trying to reconstruct an old system which they say as smothered by a newer one. 
 Whatever the historical value of such a procedure, and it was slight, it inevitably produced a rather shadowy type of society owing more to nationalist imagination than to recorded facts. 
 A similar romantic nationalist tradition was also developing in Russia and it too seems to have influenced Marx. 
 As a result, as Hobsbawm points out, Marx seems to half suggest the existence of yet another mode of production &mdash; the Slavonic. 
 On this Marx has almost nothing to say. 
 The rather dubious sources for these two modes of production explains the fact that the German and the Slavonic (if there is one) are characterized by a name demoting an ethnic or linguistic group and not a relation of production, as it the case for the capitalist mode of production. 
 This procedure goes against Marx's general practice of characterizing modes of production as systems irrespective of place and people. 
 In any case, neither the Germanic nor the Slavonic mode of production was of much significance for Marx's and Engels's later work, and the same is true for most Marxist studies. 
 As does The German Ideology , Formen  makes ample reference to the ancient or classical type of society based on the city state. 
 Here again the main focus is the contradiction between communal property and the growth of individual property. 
 This includes a discussion of slave labour which both echoes The German Ideology  and foreshadows the discussion to be found in Capital . 
 Again as in The German Ideology  we have an elaborate consideration of the growth of classes in ancient Rome and the differentiation between plebeians and patricians. 
 Marx in this section was strongly influenced by the great German historian Niebuhr, who he quotes, but there is little more development of the ideas outlined in The German Ideology . 
 The one clear innovation in Formen , however, is the introduction  of another type of social system variously referred to as the Asiatic, or oriental mode of production. 
 This stage is also mentioned in several other works by Marx, above all in Capital . 
 This innovation is especially significant as it suggests that Marx did not believe there was necessarily one set scheme of evolution which applied for the whole of mankind, the view which was held implicitly by most of Marx's contemporaries. 
 They believed that peoples had to go from one stage to another with mechanical regularity and in predictable order. 
 Whether Marx held such a view or not has had great importance for later Marxist polemics, and we shall return to this question. 
 The introduction of the Asiatic mode of production in Formen  shows well that Marx remained flexible throughout his work when he came across new information. 
 Not only was Marx willing to accept that historical development might have followed several different lines in different places but it also shows that he was always revising his ideas. 
 In particular the reader of Marx's works must get the feeling that he gradually became aware of the overly Eurocentric character of the earlier schemas he had espoused in such works as The German Ideology . 
 As his work progressed he read more and more about non-European societies and modified his general historical views accordingly. 
 What he considered essential was the systematic relationship between the organization of production, the development of classes, and the type of property which he was sketching out in Formen , not any particular version of human history. 
 In the case of the Asiatic mode of production the source of the information which led him to introduce this new type of society is well documented. 
 In the period between the writing of The German Ideology  and Capital , Marx made a living in great part by contributing articles to a radical American newspaper, The New York Daily Tribune . 
 These articles were commentaries on world affairs and, given the events of the time, they often concerned the colonial activities of European powers, principally Britain. 
 Marx therefore concerned himself extensively with what was happening in China, Indonesia, and India. 
 Writing these articles increased Marx's interest in the nature of these societies and it is clear that he read widely, especially about India. 
 This interest is something which he continued to the end of his life, as witnessed by his increasing knowledge of India and to a lesser extent of China. 
 By the time Marx wrote Formen  he had not yet read Maine and  Phear, who were to influence him later, but he had read descriptive accounts of Indian and Indonesian village life and history, especially in Sir Thomas Raffles, History of Java  &lsqb;1817&rsqb;, M. Wilks, Historical Sketches of the South of India  &lsqb;1810&ndash;17&rsqb;, and G. Campbell, Modern India  &lsqb;1852&rsqb;, all of which are quoted in Capital . 
 (See the discussion of Marx's sources in L. Krader, The Asiatic Mode of Production  &lsqb;1975&rsqb;.) 
 To this information about Asia Marx added knowledge of the Inca which he had gathered from Prescott's famous study, The Conquest of Peru , a remarkable book which came out in 1847 and whose instant fame had a dramatic impact on nineteenth-century thought. 
 Marx, like his contemporaries, seems to have been much struck by the description of a huge empire run without the aid of literacy but held together by a mixture of ruthless military power and religion. 
 Generally he seems to have synthesized the Inca to the oriental data, and he used information from Prescott to explain the working of the &bquo;Asiatic&equo; mode of production. 
 The Asiatic mode of production is characterized by the importance of the State and the place of the State in the conceptualization of property. 
 The Asiatic system consists of separate units; local communities which hold land communally in much the same way as tribal communities or the constituent units of the classical and feudal systems were believed by Marx to do. 
 What differentiates the Asiatic system is that while in the ancient or feudal systems the community sees itself as a fundamental unit and as the holder of its common property, in the oriental case it does not. 
 The individual communities consider the State as the true owner of the land they cultivate in common. 
 This means that although the State is an external, exploitative body it is not seen as such by the people who, on the contrary, see it as a kind of beneficent organism which &bquo;gives&equo; them the land on which they depend. 
 In such circumstances it is not surprising that the State is actually worshipped either in the person of a ruler or in a god which it incarnates. 
 The ruler appears &bquo;as the father of all the numerous and other lesser communities&equo; &lsqb;p. 69&rsqb;. 
 Because the ruler takes on such an exalted role, his power is unchallengeable and he is therefore a despot. 
 In this way the local communities can continue as collective organic wholes yet their continuing existence does not challenge, as it would in other systems, the external dictatorial force of the State. 
 What Marx was trying to do in constructing the Asiatic system  was to reconcile, on the one hand the reports of the strength of the village communities which characterized many of the accounts of Asian villages and which was manifested in their apparent ability to act organically, for example in the close co-operation and mutual reasonableness required in irrigated agriculture, and, on the other hand, a traditional view of the despotism of oriental rulers, a view which dominated European pictures of the Orient, at least since the time of Montesquieu. 
 Marx's theory is an attempt to accept both types of accounts of the Orient and to explain the apparent unity of states often made up of previously independent units which nevertheless co-operated in great communal works such as road building (among the Inca) and large-scale irrigation (in Asia). 
 According to Marx's theory the many different units were willing to unite and contribute their labour to work for the despot because this appeared, not as working for him, but as working for &bquo;the higher unity&equo;, which, they wrongly believed, was the source of their continued existence. 
 In this way, because the despot has taken onto himself the attributes of the community, work &mdash; which was in fact done for him &mdash; appeared as work by him, and he appeared as the creator of wealth for the community. 
 This theory of the Asiatic mode of production is complicated and subtle; it is hardly elaborated in Formen  but it is fascinating in that it foreshadows a central concept in Capital . 
 In Capital  Marx argues that as a result of the peculiar history of capitalism, the capitalist, who is really a parasite on the workers, is represented as though he were the opposite; as the source of production and the benefactor of the workers. 
 This is because, in the image of the world created by capitalism, the ability to supply capital is seen as enabling production to take place and as giving a wage to workers who would otherwise starve, while in fact it is really the capitalist who depends on the worker. 
 This &bquo;inverted causation&equo; as it has been called, which is a major element of Marxist theory, is to be found in the theory of Asiatic production, in that the subjects of the Asiatic despot are made to believe that they can live because of the blessing of the god-king, the true guardian and shepherd of the community, while really it is he who is living off them. 
 Another important aspect of Marx's notion of the Asiatic mode of production is that it offers an explanation of what he saw as the surprising stability of Asian states. 
 In his writings on the colonial situation in China and India, Marx was puzzled by the fact that, although both these countries seemed to have reached a  higher state of civilization than Europe in earlier times, they were in his time being overtaken by Europe, as the colonial conquests showed. 
 Why had these Asiatic societies stopped developing and allowed these conquests to take place? 
 The idea of the unchanging east was widespread in eighteenth- and nineteenth-century thought and it seems that Marx accepted this view, although it has subsequently been shown to be misleading. 
 This unchangeability was particularly puzzling for Marx since the basis of his writing on pre-capitalist society was, as we have seen, the contradiction between communal and private property and between the social systems these implies. 
 In his discussion of the ancient city states, as in his discussion of feudalism, the contradiction between these two systems had been identified as the driving force of change. 
 How then was it possible that a similar contradiction in the social formation of India, China, and Peru had not led to similar development? 
 The problem raised by this theoretical paradox was of significance not only for these particular instances, however important they were in themselves; it was in fact a challenge to the whole theoretical edifice which Marx and Engels were constructing. 
 Marx found the answer to this problem in his belief that, in the Asiatic system, the community is not broken up by the growth of private property and internal differentiation, as happens in classical city states or in feudalism, because the integrity of the community is maintained centrally by the State itself. 
 Because the State represents the essence of the community, in people's minds, it is in the interests of the State to maintain the communities, and not to destroy them, as is the case in the feudal system. 
 This means that the State helps the community in resisting the amassing of wealth in the hands of a few members, because of the disruptive implication of such a process. 
 This maintains the stability of the local communities since the disruptive process of class formation is halted &mdash; a stability which contrasts sharply with the political flux and intrigue of the court. 
 This point Marx made much more explicitly in Capital , Book &bquo;&lsqb;378&ndash;9&rsqb;: &bquo;The simplicity of the productive organism in these self-sufficient communities &mdash; which continually reproduce their kind, and, if destroyed by chance, reconstruct themselves in the same locality and under the same name &mdash; this simplicity unlocks for us the mystery of the unchangeableness of Asiatic society, which contrasts so strongly with the perpetual dissolutions and reconstructions of Asiatic states.&equo; 
 Because the communities are so stable in relation to a centre which is largely  in their imagination, it matters little whether in fact the real centre is itself actually in turmoil. 
 &bquo;Thus the structure of the economic elements of the society (the local communities) remains unaffected by the ups and downs in the political weather.&equo; 
 &lsqb;P. 392&rsqb; Formen  contains many of the elements of Marx's evolutionary theory concerning pre-capitalist systems, and it also contains much about the more immediate origins of capitalism. 
 None the less the overall evolutionary picture remains vague. 
 Hobsbawm sees the main theme as a mapping of various alternative evolutionary routes in the history of mankind. 
 Other writers see it in a much more systematic unilineal sequence. 
 I personally doubt whether any clear evolutionary picture would emerge if we were to base ourselves simply on Formen . 
 The reason is not simply the preliminary nature of the manuscript. 
 Rather, the reason is that, in Formen , Marx was not principally concerned with establishing an evolutionary sequence, as Engels was to do later on, and as he himself briefly attempted in the Preface to a Critique of the Political Economy . 
 The notebooks from which Formen  comes form the part of Grundrisse  concerned with the understanding of capitalism. 
 The central core of Formen  is really an attempt to answer fundamental preliminary questions for Marx's theory of capital: what is property when it is not property as visualized in the particular formulation of capitalism? 
 How are social relations visualized and operated when they are not moulded by the impersonal ideology of capitalism? 
 In The German Ideology , Marx had hypothesized that the concepts with which, in capitalist society, we understand such things as the State, law, and property are moulded for the purpose of domination. 
 Once this had been established, the aim of Marx's work was to break through this veil of ideology. 
 Then, in Capital , Marx attempts to break through and out of the veil of economic ideology, and he does this by showing that the way the economy is usually talked about hides the real basis of society and served to maintain the exploitation on which it rests. 
 In order to show this Marx explains the simultaneous growth of both the ideology and the social system of capitalism. 
 Capital  is thus not only a political critique of society but it is also a criticism of the terms in which the economy was discussed at the time when he wrote, and a demonstration that these terms are moulded to the purposes of the system they pretend to analyse. 
 This is cone in part by an analysis of history and this is the technique that is using in Formen . 
 In the case of Formen , Marx is trying to break through the  capitalist concept of property. 
 In many ways he is only partly successful. 
 We have noted some contradictions in his attempt and we shall return to others. 
 The problem seems to be in part that the sheer imaginative effort of thinking about totally different systems on the basis of very sketchy information is too great. 
 The other problem is terminological and is a problem familiar to anthropologists. 
 It is the problem of talking in our own terms about systems based on other rationales than our own, adapted as these terms are to our own system. 
 Marx tries to get away from the idea of private property when discussing pre-capitalist social systems by using the phrase &bquo;appropriation of nature&equo; but in doing so he uses a word with the same root as &bquo;property&equo;. 
 Marx's concern in Formen  with defining two types of existence and two types of property is, however, not limited to establishing a contrast. 
 This is not the focus of these notebooks, and in that they are very different from The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State . 
 Marx is concerned here with the dynamic  implication of the contradiction of combining two systems. 
 Already in The German Ideology , and even more in Capital , Marx saw the forward movement of history as due to the conflict between private property and communal property. 
 In Formen  Marx is also considering under what circumstances this conflict is made inoperative, hence his consideration of the Asiatic mode of production and the Germanic mode of production. 
 In many ways these are constructed simply as a qualification to his general theory of history. 
 If this anthropological effort is what emerges most clearly from the Formen , we must not forget that it is here, as in all Marx's work, for a political purpose. 
 First of all, it is, as we have seen, part of the theoretical study of the emergence of capitalism, a historical study which serves to reveal its nature. 
 Secondly, it is an attempt to understand historically the formative relationships between class structure, political institutions, and property, as they operate in time. 
 This is not just an academic concern but part of the work of understanding how and when capitalism will change and be overcome. 
 There is a third political aim which emerges from Formen , and which is clearer here than in any other of Marx's writings. 
 Marx seems to be answering unnamed conservative critics who would argue that if you do not have private property and the politico-legal framework to ensure its enjoyment you will have chaos;  people would lose all incentive to produce, there would be no law except the law of the strongest, the economy could not be organized, there would be no individual security, murder and theft would be the order of the day. 
 This point of view was of course almost universally accepted in the nineteenth century, and is repeated endlessly. 
 It is a point of view which is still prevalent. 
 By contrast, Marx shows that other systems, working on different assumptions, can exist, and this for him implies that future change to a radically different social system is therefore also possible. 
 If society in all its aspects has always been in a state of flux, it is highly unlikely that this process will end at any particular time. 
 Here we return to property again, since what Marx seems to be stressing above all, in his discussion of other systems, is that, without the particular formulation of private property which dominates capitalist institutions, an ordered life is still possible. 
 Production does not stop when it stops being an end in itself. 
 People do work without the institutional system of capitalism and they are assured of a reasonable livelihood. 
 This conclusion, very obvious to historians and anthropologists, was a dramatic and difficult point to put over in a society which rejected this possibility as one of the first principles. 
 The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State, 1884  Formen  is the most detailed discussion of pre-capitalist society in Marx's mature work and it really cannot be understood except as a part of the background for the more fully completed works Marx was either planning or did wrote, especially Capital . 
 Capital  refers again and again to the themes of Formen . 
 The famous Chapter 5 of the first book, which deals with the transformation of labour from a stage where it is a &bquo;part of life&equo; to a stage under capitalism when it takes on the imaginary form of a thing separate from the labourer, when it can be bought and sold, is worked out in Formen , in the discussion of tribal, oriental, and ancient societies which it contains. 
 None the less it is clear that Marx felt that before he could complete a book on pre-capitalist societies, he had to find out much more about these societies and their transformations. 
 The last years of his life seem to have been largely given over to this task. 
 During this last period, Marx made detailed studies of the work of historians and lawyers who discussed traditional peasant communities, whether in Europe or Asia, and above all he  studied the work of contemporary anthropologists who discussed primitive societies. 
 One reason for this increase in interest on the part of Marx is the wealth of new publications and theories which followed the assimilation by anthropologists of Darwin's discoveries. 
 The other reason is more political. 
 From about 1864 on, much of Marx's time and energy was spent in connection with the setting up of the international association of working men, the first International. 
 As an indirect result of this association's stormy history, Marx came across socialist revolutionaries from parts of the world about which he know relatively little. 
 One of these areas was Russia, especially because the interest that his work had aroused there made him consider the previously unthinkable possibility of a communist revolution occurring in that country. 
 Marx's ideas about Russia have for obvious reasons been discussed extensively, but this has significance for Marx's anthropology in two ways. 
 The first is that the possibility of a revolution occurring in a country where capitalism was poorly developed made him aware of the problem of setting up too rigid a sequence for human evolution. 
 Clearly, if a communist revolution was to take place in a country like Russia, the historical stage marked by capitalism would in great part have been skipped. 
 Did this mean that the historical sequence so far set up had to be modified to accommodate much more variety, and was the specifically European focus of the scheme in some way too parochial? 
 The second way in which the discussion of Russia is significant for the relation of Marxism and anthropology is that Marx's interest in traditional peasant communities became less theoretical and more practical, as he considered the possibility of the Russian peasant commune becoming a base for a future revolution. 
 This concern was linked with Marx's anthropological work, as made clear in a famous letter to the Russian socialist Vera Zasulich. 
 In the second draft of this letter Marx says: &bquo;the archaic formation of society reveals a number of different types which characterise different and successive epochs. 
 The Russian village community belongs to the youngest type in this chain,&equo; &lsqb;Hobsbawm, 142&ndash;3&rsqb;, and in the same letter Marx goes on to refer to an &bquo;all American author&equo; as one of his authorities for such a statement. 
 This author was Lewis Henry Morgan, and Marx's reference to him in such a letter shows how his concern with anthropology was becoming central. 
  Marx's concern with anthropology towards the end of his life thus blended, as always, the political and the scholarly. 
 His detailed study of the writing of anthropologists was clearly intended to be the basis of a future publication. 
 In fact his death made this unrealizable, although Engels's book, The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State , based as it is on Marx's notes, was intended to be the one that Marx was unable to write. 
 Because Marx never did write this anthropological work, it is futile to speculate too much on how his position would have been different from that of Engels. 
 We do know what came from Marx in The Origin  because we possess Marx's notes on some of the anthropological works he examined, and these notes contain passages later incorporated into Engels's book. 
 The notes are mainly extracts and comments on Morgan's Ancient Society , H. S. Maine's Lectures on the Early History of Institutions , which deals in large part with Irish history, J. B. Phear's The Aryan Village in India and Ceylon , and The Origin of Civilization  by Sir John Lubbock. 
 It is also clear from the notebooks that Marx had read much more widely than that. 
 These notes are largely extracts and only contain a limited amount of comment. 
 They have been admirably edited by L. Krader. 
 In spite of their inevitably unsatisfactory character they reveal a number of points of importance. 
 First of all, one of the most striking aspects of the notes is the interest Marx shows in detailed ethnographic description. 
 It is remarkable how this interest extends even to topics which do not seem related to the main themes of his studies. 
 Secondly, the notes show Marx's enthusiasm for the work of Morgan. 
 This is especially noticeable in that Marx is highly critical of Maine, Phear, and Lubbock wherever any of these three express ideas which conflict with Morgan's views. 
 He is especially critical of their views about the historical primacy of group marriage and the gens (see below), because they were all three in different ways followers of Morgan's rival, McLennan. 
 They refused to accept Morgan's assertion that the gens and group marriage were characteristic of the earlier human societies. 
 The gens was the communal group which Marx, following Morgan, considered as ante-dating all known history. 
 It is clear that for Marx the &bquo;discovery&equo; of the gens was probably the most important of Morgan's contribution to anthropology. 
 The gens for Morgan is a grouping within which marriage is communal and where children  and wives are pooled. 
 It is a group based on matrilineal descent, which means that one belongs to the group because one's mother belonged to it and not because of the identity of the father, since this cannot be known. 
 The gens for Morgan is the source from which both later kinship systems and later political systems evolved. 
 For Marx, what was most important in the gens is that it was a group based totally on communal principles, where individuality and selfishness did not exist and where private property had not begun to appear. 
 While Morgan is especially interested in the gens as a stage in the history of kinship which predates the appearance of the family, and which shows that matrilineal descent preceded patrilineal descent, Marx stresses rather its significance as proof of the existence of organizing principles (especially as regards property) which were opposite to those of capitalism. 
 Marx seems to suggest that the gens can actually co-exist with de-facto  familial groupings and stable sexual relationships, but these familial groupings are not the basis of political and economic organization, and so the &bquo;constitution&equo; of the tribe remains communal. 
 This is what matters for Marx, and he seems cautious about the primitive promiscuity hypothesized by Morgan. 
 It is a position which, interestingly enough, is much more acceptable to modern anthropology that to that of Morgan and Engels, who both stress emphatically the sexual aspect of the gens. 
 Marx's main quarrel with writers such as Maine is that they see the communal aspect of the descent group as growing out of the expansion of the family. 
 For Maine, as the family expands into a descent group, the property it held before on an individual basis becomes communal property simply because the descent group is a &bquo;larger family&equo;. 
 Marx therefore sees Maine as arguing that private property is the original form of appropriation and that communal property is a later development. 
 Marx sees such an argument as a subtle legitimation of private property as it existed in his time, because it made it basic to human nature. 
 In arguing against the notion that the family is the origin of society, Marx and Engels reverse what they had argued in their previous writing, but Maine's version of the argument, which gives priority to private property, is even more opposed to their general position, and so it is not surprising that they reject Maine in favour of Morgan. 
 By doing this Marx committed, it not himself, at least Engels and many Marxists, to a particular view of the evolution of  kinship which was disastrously wrong. 
 However, he may well have made the wrong choice for the right reason. 
 That is because, even though Maine might have been a better guide than Morgan concerning the evolution of kinship, Morgan was a much better guide than Maine concerning the evolution of property. 
 As Marx rightly comments in his notebook, Maine seems unable to imagine property in terms other than the legal terms which his training had given him. 
 This discussion of the primacy of communal property is a point central to Marx's whole work, and the pleasure he gained in its confirmation in the work of Morgan seems to me to be the only really clear element to emerge from the notebooks. 
 I would, however, refer the reader who wants to know more to Krader's excellent introduction. 
 Engels's The Origin of the Family, Private Property and the State  was published in 1884, the year after Marx's death, and &lsqb;on p. 71&rsqb; the preface to the first edition begins thus: &bquo;The following chapters are, in a sense, the execution of a bequest&equo;. 
 Engels saw the book as being what Marx would have written had he lived, and wherever possible he uses quotations from Marx's notebooks. 
 The book is in great part a &bquo;presentation&equo; of Morgan's &bquo;Ancient Society&equo;, but as Engels points out there is much in it which goes beyond Morgan, in terms both of documentation and interpretation. 
 One very significant change from Morgan we can attribute to Marx. 
 Morgan's work is divided into four parts: &lsqb;1&rsqb; The growth of intelligence through inventions and discoveries, which deals in great part with agricultural technology; &lsqb;2&rsqb; the growth of the idea of government, which is mainly a discussion of descent groups and how they ultimately give way to state organization, particularly the Roman state; &lsqb;3&rsqb; the growth of the idea of the family, largely a discussion of types of marriage and types of kinship terminology; and finally &lsqb;4&rsqb; the growth of the idea of property. 
 Marx in his notes changes this order and brings the discussion of property forward into the discussion of descent groups and family organization, while he keeps the discussion of the rise of the State till last. 
 This new order accords with the logic of Marx's thinking, as we have seen it in all the works we have discussed so far. 
 It also forms the basis of the organization of Engels's book. 
 If Engles's book seems in many important ways to follow the lead of Marx's later works there are also some differences. 
 One such difference is largely a matter of emphasis but it seems to me  of significance. 
 In the notebooks, Marx explains the difference in nature  between the descent group, (the gens) and the family. 
 The family in early times for Marx belongs to the private domain, rather than to the public and political. 
 Only after a time do the principles on which the family is based &mdash; private property and slavery &mdash; come into conflict with the community and its commonality; this occurs only when the family begins to move into the political domain. 
 Marx focuses on the dynamic implications of the conflicting principles which the simultaneous existence of the two institutions, family and descent group, implies. 
 He is less interested in the evolutionary sequence of Morgan, which stresses the matrilineal gens and the nuclear family as two different stages. 
 What matters for him is the conflict which arises from their combination. 
 Engels, by contrast, follows Morgan much more closely, not only in terms of Morgan's schemes but also in terms of Morgan's emphasis. 
 An overall difference of impression between Marx's notes and Engels's book is that in the case of the notebooks Morgan's framework is totally subordinated to Marx's wider concerns, while in Engels's book we get the impression that Morgan, for great chunks of the book, actually takes over Engels. 
 This leads Engels to enthusiastically participate in rather technical debates such as the significance of kinship terminology, or the details of Australian Aboriginal society, details which Marx had largely left alone. 
 This is somewhat ironical in that, as we shall see, it is Engels's anthropological enthusiasm and his trust in Morgan which has been the source of many of the points in his work which appear now as unacceptable to anthropologists and which have been the cause of some of the most damaging objections to his theories. 
 Overall Engels seems to go much further in this enthusiasm for Morgan than the generally vague impression we get from Marx. 
 Marx uses Morgan principally as a source about exotic societies. 
 He does note, in the letter to Zasulich, Morgan's hope for a future society, which would abandon the obsession with private property, but at the same time he makes it clear that he rightly does not consider Morgan a socialist or a revolutionary. 
 Engels, on the other hand, states in the preface to the first edition of The Origin  that &bquo;Morgan in his own way had discovered afresh in America the materialistic conception of history, discovered by Marx forty years ago, and in his comparison of barbarism and civilization it had led him, in the main points, to the same conclusions as Marx'  &lsqb;p. 71&rsqb;. 
 This is high praise indeed from Engels but there is no hint in any of Marx's own writing of that degree of endorsement for Morgan's theoretical position. 
 The Origin  falls into three parts. 
 The first, represented by Chapter 1, deals with technological evolution. 
 The second, represented by Chapter 2, the longest chapter in the book, deals with the development of the family and kinship systems, while the third, Chapters 3&ndash;4, deals with the evolution of the State. 
 It is the first and second parts which follow Morgan most closely. 
 The first part lists three stages of human evolution from the earliest to the most recent: savagery, barbarism, and civilization. 
 In this classification Morgan, and Engels after him, were following a very widely accepted schema of their time which, as we have seen, had already been used, albeit somewhat differently, by Marx. 
 Savagery itself was again subdivided into three substages. 
 First, there was a lower substage of savagery characterized by the gathering of wild plants and honey. 
 Secondly, there was a middle substage characterized by fishing and the introduction of fire, and thirdly an upper substage characterized by hunting and improved tools. 
 Barbarism, similarly, is divided into three substages but in this case the stages are not seen as universal, since according to Engels, they differed in the old and the new world. 
 The lower substage of barbarism is common and is marked by the discovery of pottery, but the middle substage is marked by agriculture and the domestication of plants in the new world, and by pastoralism and the domestication of animals in the old. 
 The upper substage is marked by the discovery of iron smelting and the invention of alphabetic writing. 
 It is the substage to which the Homeric poems belong. 
 This first part of the book, although it follows Morgan closely, also reflects Marx's and Engels's earlier schemes, apart from the distinction between the evolution in the Eastern and Western hemispheres. 
 The next chapter, dealing with the history of marriage, is, however, totally new. 
 There is nothing like it in either The German Ideology  or Formen . 
 In this second part Engels not only follows Morgan's sequence, he follows Morgan's method concerning three key points. 
 The first method is one which Morgan shared with all of his contemporaries. 
 He thought that if people such as the Iroquois of North America practised a particular type of agriculture it could be assumed that their institutions were the same as those of long  dead prehistoric peoples who had a similar level of technology. 
 This meant that although the Iroquois might be observed contemporaneously with nineteenth-century European society, they could, none the less, be considered as a source of information about European society several thousand years before. 
 The second method was more peculiar to Morgan and was to be the source of many controversies in his time. 
 Morgan's interest in anthropology had begun when he noticed the systematic pattern created by the totality of the terms used to refer to relatives and kinsmen. 
 These patterns varied from language to language, but only a limited number of such patterns seemed to occur, so that the same pattern of kinship terminology was found among totally unrelated peoples speaking totally unrelated languages. 
 Morgan was not interested in the terms for themselves but in the principles which they seemed to reveal when they were put together. 
 For example, he would have been interested in the fact that the English word &bquo;uncle&equo; can be used in speaking both of one's mother's brother and one's father's brother while in Swedish, for instance, two different words are used. 
 Furthermore, Morgan was interested in the patterns which kinship terms create, not just for themselves, but because he believed they reflected the system of marriage with which they had originally been used. 
 If in a particular language a woman referred to a large number of men other than her husband by the same term as the one she used for her husband, this implied, for Morgan and Engels, that in an earlier stage of this system, a woman would have been wife to all of these men. 
 Similarly if in a language a woman referred to her son by the same term as she used for the son of her sister, this showed that the system of terms developed at a time when the two sisters would have been co-wives of the same man or men. 
 This combination of system of kin terms and marriage is referred to in Engels's book as the system of &bquo;consanguinity&equo;. 
 For Engels, therefore, the study of systems of kin terms revealed previously existing systems of consanguinity and could be used as evidence for the history of kinship and social organization. 
 The third method Engels accepted from Morgan concerned the idea that, although systems of kinship terms were first moulded by systems of marriage, the kin terms did not change as easily as the system of marriage. 
 This meant that systems of kin terms often reflected, not the present state of affairs, but the previous one. 
 By looking at the kinship terms of a society one could therefore know  by this means what had been the previous kinship system, practised in the past by the people concerned. 
 By the use of these three methods Morgan believed he had the means with which to discover the history of marriage in human societies. 
 After studying large numbers of systems of kinship terms and placing them in an evolutionary sequence, partly in terms of their characteristics, partly in terms of the technological level reached by the societies from which they originated, Morgan felt confident that he had discovered a governing tendency in the history of human marriage: as social evolution progressed, the number of legitimate sexual partners a man or a woman could have diminished progressively, finally producing monogamy &mdash; the permanent union of one man and one woman. 
 This also meant that at the opposite pole of this evolutionary sequence there had existed a stage which was the exact opposite, a stage when men or women paired freely with whoever they took a fancy to, irrespective of any rules or regulations. 
 Even the rule of incest, Morgan and Engels argues, was a subsequent innovation. 
 The first stage became of central importance for the work of both Morgan and Engels. 
 Neither Morgan nor Engels denied that he had no direct evidence at all for this first primeval stage of total promiscuity. 
 Engels discusses certain objections to Morgan's scheme, especially the presence of long-term pairing among animals, but he argues that such evidence from non-human animals is irrelevant to human systems. 
 (Actually his dismissal of this type of evidence as not being relevant to institutions is one many anthropologists would agree with.) 
 The first stage however remains nothing more than an extrapolation from the overall pattern of evolution Morgan believed he had discovered. 
 The evidence for the next higher stage is not entirely absent but, in this case, it is indirect. 
 This stage, according to Morgan and Engels, is marked by the limiting of pairing to one generation only. 
 Sexual relations between generations become incestuous, but sexual relations within the same generation are totally free. 
 The evidence for this is the system of kinship terms which Morgan found in various parts of the world. 
 One such example given is Polynesia, and the evidence depends on the fact that in Polynesian kinship terminology, only differences of generation and sex are recognized, so that all males of the generation directly preceding one's own are referred to by one and the same word, which was  glossed by Morgan as &bquo;father&equo;; similarly, all females of this same generation are referred to one term, which can be glossed as &bquo;mother&equo;. 
 It was on the basis of this kind of observation that Morgan decided that there once existed in Polynesia a social order when sexual relations within one generation were so unspecific that all men of the ascending generation were &bquo;fathers&equo; and all women of the ascending generation were &bquo;mothers&equo;. 
 This was because no-one could be sure who exactly within this group begot him. 
 According to the theory, the people who used such a system of terms did not themselves, however, practise such a type of marriage but actually practices the next stage. 
 This was because according to Morgan kin terms lag behind. 
 As a result, the evidence for this second stage in the history of marriage depends entirely on the two assumptions which we have already noted. 
 One that patterns of kin terms indicate types of marriage, and second, that the presence of such a pattern is a guide to a previous  state of affairs. 
 The Polynesians, according to this way of seeing things, had a system of kinship terms, which indicated, not the marriage system which they practised, but the marriage system which they had practised in the past. 
 The system of marriage which the Polynesians actually  practised was, Morgan, and therefore Engels, believed, more advanced or, in other words, more restrictive, and represented the third stage in the evolution of marriage. 
 This was a system in which, not only were members of one's own generation the only legitimate sexual partners, but not even all of these, since people who were descendants of the same ancestors would not marry. 
 These co-descendants of one's ancestors considered themselves as brothers and sisters and would not marry each other but only members of another similar group of co-descendants. 
 As a result all the men of one group would marry all the women of another. 
 Group marriages would therefore occur when one group married another. 
 One of the results of group marriage was that people shared amongst themselves a large number of spouses. 
 Even though one was a long way from primitive promiscuity, binding individual marriage had not yet appeared. 
 The evidence for this stage, Morgan and Engels believed, was stronger than for the first two stages. 
 First, and as before, there was evidence of this stage from kinship terminologies. 
 The terminologies  which demonstrated the existence of this stage, again did not come from those people who were believed to practise the associated form of marriage. 
 Once more it was the terms used by people such as the Iroquois, who were believed to have moved on from this stage, who provided the evidence for its previous existence. 
 Secondly, this third stage, was also vouched for by much more direct evidence. 
 Morgan and Engels believed that there were several peoples who still practices group marriage. 
 Engels, especially in subsequent editions of The Origin , was keen to incorporate new evidence for contemporary practises of what he believed was group marriage. 
 For example, he did this by quoting two anthropologists, Fison and Howitt, who wrote about Australian Aborigines in terms which could be construed as meaning that large groups of men married large groups of women. 
 This third stage in the history of marriage was of crucial importance for The Origin . 
 This is because the group of people descended from a common ancestor, which married as a group another group, was the famous gens . 
 For Marx and Engels the gens was the typical communal unit containing no internal differentiation as regards property or wives. 
 It was the community in its purest form, the antithesis to the divisive individualism of capitalism. 
 Its existence demonstrated for Engels that Marx had been right in arguing that commonality was the oldest form of social existence. 
 The fact that, for Morgan at least, this commonality extended to spouses only added spice to the whole picture. 
 The absence of individual marriages led Morgan to the view that in such a society a person must belong to the gens of the mother, not the gens of the father, because with such a system of marriage you could never be sure who your father was. 
 The gens had therefore to be a matrilineal group; that is, a group to which you belong by claiming descent in the female line. 
 Furthermore, Engles and Morgan believed that matriliny had another, more important implication; that is, it implied matriarchy or rule by women. 
 In stressing this, Engels was clearly strongly influenced not only by Morgan by also by Bachofen whom he praised in this preface to the book. 
 Both Bachofen and Morgan believed that, since you belonged to the group by virtue of being your mother's son, women in such a system must have a particularly high status. 
 Engels, however, does not completely follow Bachofen in the belief that at this stage women were actually superior to men. 
 What Engels stresses is that women were not inferior. 
  The assertion of the existence of the totally communal gens at an early stage in the history of mankind was what drew Marx and Engels to Morgan. 
 They were so enthusiastic in the demonstration of the primacy of communal property and equality that they had no difficulty in taking in from Morgan much baggage which seems pretty unrelated to their previous concern; for example, such ideas as matriliny or the significance of kinship terminology. 
 More important, however, is the central fact that in the elevation of the place of the gens in their system, they consummated the fatal union between what we have called their rhetorical  and their historical  use of anthropology. 
 In the previous chapter we saw how anthropology was sometimes used by them to show the historical particularity of institutions which under capitalism were represented as eternal. 
 Thus, quite justifiably, Marx and Engels used anthropological examples to show that private property or the State is not a necessary institution for human beings. 
 For this purpose Marx and Engels had to show just how different  primitive societies were from the type of society their readers knew. 
 However, when they were discussing the historical development which led to capitalism, as they do in The German Ideology  and Formen , they stress, by contrast, the continuity  in structure between different stages and the universality of the historical process. 
 On the other hand, the stage represented by the gens in The Origin , a stage which owes something to Morgan and something to Engels, represents the coming together of the rhetorical and the historical. 
 The gens is there to demonstrate the possibility of a totally  communal classless stage based on totally different  principles to those of capitalism, but which, Engels claims, actually represents a state of affairs which had existed, and for which there is historical evidence. 
 In fact, as we shall see, this evidence has proved largely illusory, but the presentation of the gens stage as a real historical one presents Engels right from the first with the theoretical difficulties which were to plague Marxist anthropology afterwards. 
 The problem is that, as we have seen, the Marxist theory of society depends on a contradiction between conflicting principles and on a conflict between different classes. 
 This means that when Engels postulated a pre-class stage when there were no conflicting principles and everything was sweetness and light, he had no Marxist way by which to explain historical change. 
 This had not been so with the earliest stages as drawn in The German Ideology   or Formen  because even here Marx talks of &bquo;slavery being inherent in the family&equo; and the universality of class relations. 
 When Engles therefore tries to explain the passage from the second stage to the gens stage he has no theoretical tools to deal with this, and he lamely has to echo Morgan and to explain the passage in Darwinian terms dealing with natural selection. 
 According to this theory the earlier generational pairing was abandoned because it led to so much inbreeding that people who practised the gens system were genetically more fit for natural selection and therefore survived better. 
 Such an explanation, quite apart from being completely wrong, is extraordinary in the light of the fact that both Marx and Engels warn throughout their work that biological models are inappropriate to human societies. 
 What it does show, is just how much of a theoretical problem Engels had made for himself in creating this highly problematical gens stage of history where there were no divisions of any kind. 
 The stage of the matrilineal gens was associated by Morgan and Engels with the higher stage of savagery. 
 The passage to the next stages was, however, to be governed by totally different principles. 
 In fact it is the passage out of the gens stage which is the subject matter of the book. 
 This is the origin  of the family, private property and the State. 
 The first factor to bring about the overthrow of the gens and all it stood for was the appearance within the &bquo;gentle constitution&equo; (the gens stage) of the pairing family. 
 This occurred during the lower stages of barbarism. 
 The pairing family was an uninstitutionalized de facto  long-term association of a man and a woman. 
 At first the pairing family co-existed fairly easily with the gens, because it was not a formal organized institution as was the gens, and so the implications of the gens for such things as property and politics remained unchallenged. 
 The pairing family differed from the monogamy of later states in that it was not a legally binding institution. 
 It could be, and often was, ended at will by either party. 
 The pairing family had been brought about, so Engels and Morgan believed, by women wishing for a little permanence in their domestic arrangements. 
 Because of this, if it involved binding, it was more a case of binding the man rather than the woman. 
 In this respect it contrasted with the institution of monogamy. 
 Because it was an impermanent unofficial arrangement, the pairing family held no property and at first presented no  threat to the communally held property of the gens. 
 The pairing family as such was of little organizational importance; it was a temporary, private arrangement. 
 For Engels its significance lies in the fact that it was seen as the basis of what was to be the most dramatic change in the history of mankind. 
 This was the simultaneous introduction of several indissolubly linked institutions: monogamy (which later gave rise to polyandry and polygamy), the nuclear family, private property (the property of the nuclear family), the change in the rule of descent from the female line to the male line, the subordination and humiliation of women, and the State. 
 This dramatic change was caused both by the presence of the pairing family and by the introduction of herding and agriculture. 
 These new techniques brought about an increase in the things which people needed to control for production, especially land, herds, tools, and even the slaves who became of importance at this stage. 
 These things, therefore, became little by little private property. 
 This new, private property would be, according to Engels and Morgan, in the hands of men, unlike the communal property of the gens, which was controlled by women, since they controlled the gens; this was because Engels believed since men would be responsible for production at this stage it was natural that they would control what was necessary for production. 
 Men were therefore the first people with private property and soon they wanted to pass on this property to their children. 
 This was impossible, Engels tells us, so long as descent was reckoned in the female line, because he believed inheritance and group membership always went hand in hand. 
 Descent was traced in the female line because when pairing was temporary and informal, it was not possible to reckon it in any other way, as one could only be sure of the identity of the mother of the child, not that of the father. 
 The whole gentile constitution made the transference of private property from father to son impossible. 
 In order to succeed in their desire to pass on their property to their children, men first introduced the rule of monogamy and thus brought about the first great change. 
 Through monogamy, men obtained a sexual monopoly over individual women by which they ensured that the children of these women were their own. 
 Having done that, the men were then able to change the system of descent from matriliny to patriliny. 
 Sons were able to inherit their father's private property. 
 The result of this dramatic change was the nuclear family. 
 The second major effect of the introduction of private property occurred, according to Engels, as an indirect result of the change to patriliny, a state which he did not clearly distinguish from patriarchy. 
 This was that women became subordinated economically because the men gained control of the means of production, and so &bquo;while the husband became the bourgeois the wife represented the proletariat&equo; &lsqb;p. 137&rsqb;. 
 As a further result women were subordinated sexually, because the change to patriliny and monogamy restricted the sexual freedom of the woman, in that it was essential for the man to know he was the father of her children. 
 Monogamy did not, however, simultaneously restrict the sexual freedom of the men, in spite of a pretence otherwise, since men had nothing to lose through philandering. 
 The origin of the family is therefore the same as the origin of private property, and the origin of the family is the same as the origin of the subordination and exploitation of women. 
 This origin is monogamy. 
 The overthrow of the gentile constitution, which occurred as a result of technological changes, and as a result of the presence of the pairing family, is, according to Engels, the beginning of history as understood by Marx: the exploitation of one class by another and the resulting class struggles. 
 At this point in the history of the evolution of mankind The Origin  rejoins The German Ideology  and Formen , although it continues to consider the themes of the family and the position of women in a way that had not been done before. 
 Having shown how the advent to monogamy leads to the subjugation of women, Engels follows their increasing humiliation either as prisoners, as in ancient Athens, or as prostitutes. 
 Prostitutes became necessary as a result of monogamy since, as we noted, monogamy both forbids sexual freedom in wives and encourages it in husbands. 
 Monogamy also leads to marriages being part of property deals among the ruling classes since marriage becomes part of the process of securing heirs to private property, and once marriage is seen as a matter of passing on property, it rapidly takes on that form exclusively among the propertied classes. 
 Among them, argues Engels, women's wishes and happiness become subjugated to the needs of maintaining the ownership of the means of production within the dominant class. 
 In these ruling classes the destiny of women is thus supremely unhappy. 
 Marriage is one of the elements which leads to the formation and the maintenance of the inequality between classes and it does this at the expense of  women. 
 Institutions such as polygamy are seen by Engels as mere variants on the institution of monogamy. 
 They are simply cases of men accumulating several women who themselves are in the same situation as monogamous wives. 
 (It is interesting that in arguing that polygamy grows out of monogamy Engels was reversing the evolutionary sequence as most anthropologists of his time saw it.) 
 Finally Engels turns to the future of marriage and this is seen in terms of past evolution. 
 The depraved state of women in monogamy, associated as it is with private property and capitalism, will according to him, be replaced when capitalism is overthrown. 
 Then a new kind of family will arise, one which is not based on the exploitation of one sex by another. 
 This exploitation will disappear since, as we have seen, its basis is private property which itself will be abolished. 
 Monogamy as a legal tie, tying women, will die, and both sexes will be equally free to establish long-lasting bonds and, if these prove unsuitable, to break them. 
 In this way Engels shows, through this complex history of human marriage, the historical basis of the present state of affairs. 
 He shows how the treatment of sex is linked to wider political and economic considerations and therefore how changes in the political economic system will change even that apparently most private of institutions, marriage. 
 The Origin  shows that the position of women and the family, as it existed in Engels's time, not an unchallengeable datum, based on eternal principles, but the temporary product of the period, a product which will and must be overthrown. 
 The second half of the book shows that this is also so for the State, a concept which for many, especially Hegel, was no less holy and fundamental than the family. 
 &bquo;The state&equo;, says Engels, &bquo;&hellip; has not existed from all eternity. 
 There have been societies which have managed without a notion of the state and state power.&equo; 
 &lsqb;P. 232.&rsqb; 
 Engels's discussion of the State in The Origin  divides into three parts. 
 The first part consists of an evolutionary analysis describing under what conditions the State arises. 
 This is mainly to be found in the last chapter of the book. 
 The second part is an attempt to debunk the then generally accepted view that there was something unique, mysterious, almost supernatural in the rise of the European notions of politics. 
 This Engels does by showing that the Greek and Roman states, the &bquo;sacred&equo; sources of the European ideal, were based on principles which can also be seen in embryo among  much less prestigious peoples, the American Indians. 
 This is dealt with in Chapters 3, 4, 5, and 6. 
 The third part of Engels's discussion explains why, in spite of the presence of the State in medieval Europe, some islands of communal organization could and did remain. 
 This is explained in terms of the nature of the Germanic invasions which brought about the destruction of the Roman Empire and is dealt with in Chapters 7 and 8. 
 The outline of the evolutionary theory of the State in The Origin  is one we are already familiar with from the earlier writings of Marx and Engels, but it is expanded here with new information from Morgan. 
 The main point of Engels's and Morgan's argument is that, once again, the State has the same  origin as the family, private property, and class division, or in other words the overthrow of the gens. 
 Engels stresses the contrast between the political nature of the gens and the State. 
 The gens is a group of people who act together on an egalitarian and communal basis. 
 &bquo;All are equal and free &mdash; the women included.&equo; 
 &lsqb;P. 159.&rsqb; 
 Its leaders are temporary and subject to the will of the people. 
 Individual gens are linked with one another, in that their ancestors are thought of as related, thereby creating an obligation between the members of these gens. 
 These links are moral and involve no subordination. 
 Groups of gens related in this way from phratries and phratries may be linked one to another in a similar fashion to form tribes. 
 Furthermore gens and phratries are linked to other gens and phratries through ties of marriage. 
 This is a result of the rule which forbids marriage within the gens and so forces the creation of marriage ties between gens. 
 Because of the presence of all these links, there is order in such a system, even though it is a type of &bquo;society which still 'has' no state&equo; &lsqb;p. 188&rsqb; and no classes. 
 This conclusion enables Engels to make again one of the most important point in The German Ideology . 
 The two terms &bquo;society&equo; and &bquo;State&equo; are not, as many political philosophers had assumed, synonymous. 
 Order can exist without the State. 
 The political implications of this are obvious: the State is not necessary for peace, whose basis must be found elsewhere. 
 There is for Engels, however, an intermediary state between the State and the gens. 
 This was the situation which Morgan described for the Iroquois when several tribes get together, not any more on the basis of kinship or marriage, but on the basis of confederacy. 
 This was exemplified by the league of the Iroquois which Morgan had studied in detail. 
 For both Engels and Morgan  the league typified a general political stage, and Engels argued that it could be found elsewhere in many parts of the world. 
 By then, however, the stage was set for the rise of the true State. 
 The equality of the gentile constitution was threatened by private property, exploitation, monogamy, and the nuclear family. 
 This process as we have seen, leads to the break of community and the formation of classes. 
 The State then becomes necessary because in The Origin  as in the other works it is revealed as being one of the mechanisms for ensuring the continuing domination of the higher classes. 
 In this way The Origin  demonstrates a complete tie-up between politics, economics, kinship, and gender roles, and this view of all the different aspects of society as an essential whole is what gives The Origin  its power. 
 Perhaps the most significant fact about Engels's book is that the word &bquo;origin&equo; is in the singular. 
 For him there is one origin to phenomena we tend to think of as distinct: private property, the family, the State. 
 The State is the result of the disorder brought about by inequality and private property and it is the means by which this inequality and private property is maintained. 
 Engels re-echoes The German Ideology  in showing that far from the State being the repository of justice, it is the repository of exploitation, but here he does this by use of genuine anthropological materials. 
 According to Engels the State only develops with the full elaboration of classes, and it is the tool of the ruling class enforcing its will on those whom it oppresses. 
 This is a crucial proposition which we have already noted and which will be discussed again later in this book. 
 It is by means of this idea that the State is linked with the earlier part of the origin of kinship and marriage. 
 Classes and private property grow out of the family and together these various factors lead to the break-up of the gens. 
 This destruction is, therefore, not only the origin of private property, not only the origin of the family, monogamy, and the oppression of women, it is also the origin of the State. 
 The second part of this second half of The Origin  deals with Greece and Rome and in many ways again follows what Marx and Engels had written previously. 
 What is new however is the suggestion, which at the time of writing must have appeared as the height of impertinence, that the Greek and Roman states originated in much the same kind of confederation as the Iroquois. 
 In this way Engels asserts the generality of the principles discussed, but also he explains the importance of what he believed were  remains of gentile principles in the organization of Greece and Rome. 
 (He does admit however that these remains were &mdash; in historical times at least &mdash; linked to patrilineal groups; rather odd inheritors of the principles of the matrilineal gens.) 
 Two other general points also emerge from the discussion of Greece and Rome. 
 The first is that it shows well the distinction Engels makes between general principles &mdash; in this case the dissolution of communal organization and the rise of class &mdash; and specific cases. 
 Engels does not pretend that the histories of Greece, Rome, and the Iroquois are identical. 
 What he states is that the dame general principles govern their development, although conditions were so different that these principles had considerably different effects in the different cases. 
 The second general point is that the discussion on Greece and Rome shows that Engels thought that the general scheme of social causation developed by Marx for capitalism applied to pre-capitalist formations, so long as these were past the gens stages. 
 This is the scheme according to which material conditions give rise to class relations which at first develop in direct response to these material conditions. 
 Then the logic of the social system and the antagonism of classes continues to develop so that ultimately it destroys itself and the material conditions which brought it about. 
 Rome and Greece, for Engels, develop classes (slaves) in response to the development of agricultural techniques and the growth of manufacturing, both of which cause an increase in the division of labour. 
 The division of classes, however, goes on increasing and it finally undermines the society in which it had arisen. 
 Engels says of the Greeks: &bquo;The downfall of Athens was not caused by democracy as the European lickspittle historians assert to flatter their princes, but by slavery, which banned the labour of free citizens.&equo; 
 &lsqb;P. 181.&rsqb; 
 Thus for the period after &bquo;the origin&equo; Engels returns to Marxist orthodoxy: &bquo;Here we shall need Marx's Capital  as much as Morgan's book.&equo; 
 &lsqb;P. 217.&rsqb; 
 This is because the demise of capitalism which Marx prophesies in Capital  takes the same form as the demise of Greece and Rome, according to Engels. 
 The class system created to operate the new economy in both the case of capitalism and ancient society leads to such opposition, exploitation, and contradiction that the system for which it was created collapses. 
 This downfall opens the way for a new social system in both cases. 
  The third part of the second half of the book mainly concerns the Germanic tribes which invaded and finally overthrew the Roman empire. 
 Engels here, as elsewhere, is clearly influenced by the romantic nationalist tradition of nineteenth-century historians, and the praise which he lavishes on these groups, as well as the labelling of them as &bquo;German&equo;, is probably misplaces. 
 On page 215 he does, however, to put some distance between himself and the racist overtones of this tradition: &bquo;But what was the mysterious magic by which the Germans breathed new life into a dying Europe? 
 Was it some miraculous power innate in the German race, such as our chauvinist historians romance about? 
 Not a bit of it. 
 The Germans, especially at that time, were a highly gifted Aryan tribe in the full vigour of development. 
 It was not however their specific national qualities which rejuvenated Europe, but simply their barbarism, their gentile constitution.&equo; 
 Engels's argument is clear: the Germans were able to vanquish the Romans because their society was not so internally corrupted by class. 
 At the same time it shows that Engels did not always believe that &bquo;higher&equo; stages always followed upon lower ones. 
 The main point, however, of the section on the Germanic tribes is a discussion of the nature of feudalism, and this is little different from that found in The German Ideology . 
 Engels, like Marx, was particularly interested in the historical significance of traditional communities which might have retained, in much later historical periods, something of their &bquo;gentile&equo; constitution. 
 In that he was much influenced by contemporary historians: Kovalesky and Maurer. 
 This interest ultimately led him to write a separate work on the topic, Die Mark . 
 This side of his work we cannot discuss here since it would best be dealt with in a book concerned with history and Marxism. 
 We have enough to do in evaluating Marx's and Engels's use of anthropology and this is the task of the next chapter. 
 The Present-Day Standing of Marx's and Engels' Anthropology 
 Before continuing with the history of Marx's and Engels's ideas in our field until the present, we must first examine how these ideas stand in the light of modern developments in anthropology. 
 Since their work covered such a vast range of subjects, it is necessary to limit the discussion to topics which have arisen within the traditional limits of anthropology, and to leave to other studies an examination of Marx's and Engels's views of such periods as feudalism or ancient Greece and Rome, since these fall more under the orbit of historical studies. 
 Some other topics, such as the discussion of the Asiatic mode of production and the notion of ideology, will also be left to other parts of the book. 
 We must first consider one of Marx's and Engels's fundamental notions, the idea that human history goes through certain ordered stages. 
 Marx and Engels and, for that matter, Morgan and their other sources, were in no way peculiar in this belief; they were representatives of a current of opinion that was almost universally accepted by the end of the nineteenth-century. 
 Since then, however, this fundamental premise has come under attack in a variety of ways and it is true to say that &bquo;evolutionism&equo; is considered unacceptable by most modern Western anthropologists. 
 What this rejection consists in, however, is less than clear. 
 It may consist in a rejection of the specific schemes or lines of evolution propounded by nineteenth-century authors. 
 It may consist in a rejection of the notion that there are identifiable stages, or that talking of stages is a useful way of visualizing evolution. 
 It may involve a rejection of the idea of evolution altogether. 
 Unfortunately many modern anthropologists are very vague as to which of these different objections they are making when they object to &bquo;evolutionism&equo; in general. 
 The most fundamental objection consists in the view that human history is not governed by any general laws at all, or at least by any universal laws, and that the attempt to construct an all-embracing history of mankind is therefore futile. 
 Among the  writers who have advocated such a view are the great American anthropologist Boas and some of his pupils, and also, for somewhat different reasons, the British anthropologist Evans-Pritchard. 
 These authors stress the uniqueness of each and every different culture and the unexpectedness of history. 
 Their position will be considered in Chapters 5 and 6. 
 It is in fact only rarely openly acknowledged by other anthropologists, though the blanket rejection of evolution which is to be found in the work of many seems to imply. 
 Rather, modern anthropologists tend to attack the specific evolutionary sequences in the work of the earlier writers &mdash; often, as we shall see, with good reason &mdash; and they also criticize the notion of stages. 
 To talk of human history as going through stages implies that there is an unavoidable link-up between technological systems, political systems, economic systems, kinship systems, etc. 
 In fact recent findings make this kind of view untenable, as we will see below. 
 In any case, as anthropologists have learned more and more about different societies, they have found ever-greater difficulty in putting into any one list of stages the variety of forms of human society which modern research has revealed. 
 The kinds of stages which we have found in the work of Marx and Engels seem now to most anthropologists much too moulded to European history, even taking into account the modifications which, as we saw, were gradually incorporated in their work to handle their growing knowledge of non-European societies. 
 This Eurocentrism was inevitable at a time when in Europe only European history was at all well known, and Marx's and Engels's &bquo;general&equo; stages often read like little more than a generalized history of western Europe. 
 Eurocentrism seems however much less excusable in the work of modern historians who, following in Marx's and Engels's footsteps, still seem to consider the examples they used sufficient to generalize about human history (Anderson, 1974). 
 When these &bquo;stages&equo; have been used to identify societies outside Europe the result has often been misleading. 
 For example, Goody and others have argued that the labelling of pre-colonial West African states as &bquo;feudal&equo; has obscured the all-important fact that the control of the ruling class did not operate through the control of land, and that therefore Marx's ideas cannot be used directly for these societies. 
 (Goody, 1971, ch. 
 II.) 
 This is one example among many. 
 Another objection to the notion of &bquo;stages&equo; is due to the same problem. 
 It consists in pointing out the fact that, as soon as we use the stages as a type of classification, we find we have more  doubtful borderline cases than typical ones, because of the great variation of social systems in history in different parts of the world. 
 Most modern Western anthropologists, therefore, reject both the nineteenth-century evolutionary sequences and the notion of stages, but this of course is not a rejection of evolution itself. 
 None the less many writers seem to imply that it is, and as a result their position is unclear. 
 They do not for the most part take a position like that of Boas and Evans-Pritchard which rejects the very notion that there are general laws governing human history; and if they do not, it would seem that they too are driving, however cautiously, towards an understanding of human history in general, in other words toward a theory of human evolution. 
 Because this is so, I do not believe that their position is as different from that of nineteenth-century anthropologists and Marx and Engels as they would like us to believe, if we were to take their rejection of &bquo;evolutionism&equo; at its face value. 
 It must be said however, that they are infinitely more cautious than their predecessors, and on the whole with good reason. 
 We shall return to this largely negative and vague theoretical attitude on the part of modern Western anthropologists, but it is accompanied by much more definite and often more valuable criticism of earlier schemes, such as those used by Marx and Engels. 
 It is with these criticisms that we shall deal now. 
 In The Origin , and already as far back as The German Ideology , Marx and Engels followed their contemporaries in believing that the history of mankind usually went through the same sequence of technological improvement. 
 The sequence, by and large, went like this: first gathering of plants and small animals, second fishing, third hunting, fourth pottery, fifth pastoralism, sixth agriculture, seventh metalworking. 
 There are now several elements of this sequence which are clearly unacceptable. 
 First, gathering, hunting, and fishing do not represent clearly different technological stages but always occur together so long as the environment permits the combination. 
 The archaeological records of man show these three activities normally co-existing (Lee and DeVore, 1964). 
 On the other hand all modern anthropologists and archaeologists would agree with the view that for a very long period of history mankind has existed solely by hunting, fishing, and gathering, and that such a technological stage always precedes domestication of plants and animals. 
 The next stage in the sequence is also problematic. 
 Marx  Engels, as well as many of their contemporaries, believed that pastoralism predated agriculture. 
 They apparently originally got the idea from a book by W. Cooke Taylor, The Natural History of Society in the Barbarous and Civilized State, 1840 , which Marx read in 1851 (Krader, 1972:90). 
 This is clearly wrong: if anything, the evidence is all the other way (Ucko and Dimbleby, 1969); in most cases agriculture preceded herding. 
 How far Marx and Engels were wedded to the idea is not clear and Engels did note that this sequence did not apply to the New World. 
 Their idea of the origin of private property was, however, intimately linked with the importance of the ownership of herds. 
 In The Origin  the development of herding was a major turning point. 
 By contrast, most modern prehistorians would stress, as the major turning point, the dramatic importance of the domestication of plants and  animals, the &bquo;neolithic revolution&equo;. 
 This is still seen as one of the most important events in the history of mankind. 
 Modern prehistorians do not any more attach such importance to the introduction of pottery, which cannot be clearly correlated with such things as agriculture. 
 The importance which Engels attributed to this came entirely from his anthropological sources and really reflects an old-fashioned type of archaeology obsessed with material remains rather than with the general way of life. 
 This attitude, on the part of their sources, is basically foreign to Marx's and Engels's overall work, and one feels they would have been more at home with the work of more modern prehistorians. 
 Indeed they seem to have foreshadowed later work by attaching such primary importance to domestication. 
 Another more important criticism of Marx's and Engels's technological sequences comes from the fact that they give the impression that progression through these technological stages was an inevitable progression from lower to higher. 
 Although overall this view is still widely held, it is possible to point to several cases of reversal when, for example, agriculturalists reverted to hunting and gathering. 
 It can be argues, however, that Engels and Marx did not rule out such a possibility themselves, as is suggested by the discussion of the success of the Germanic tribes in overthrowing Rome, a case when people with a lower technology replaced a society based on a higher stage. 
 There is however an important general point at issue here. 
 It is possible to read some of the writings of Marx and Engels as suggesting a mechanical succession of stages, following one after  the other, or it is possible to seen in their work, concentrating on other passages, a less determinist view of progress. 
 I believe that both views of their writing are justified in that they seem to have oscillated between these two poles and such oscillations are noted in several places in this book. 
 None the less, irrespective of what their position might be, modern anthropology would reject the view that the progress of technology is totally irreversible, although the sequence of technological progress Marx and Engels took over from their anthropological sources is still, by and large, acceptable. 
 The problem with their evolutionary sequence does not lie so much with what they say about technology as what they saw this technology as implying. 
 Before we examine these problems one important question of method must be noted. 
 Marx and Engels, like all their contemporaries, including anthropologists and archaeologists and Morgan in particular, felt that information gained about contemporary peoples whose life depended on a simple technology was valid for understanding the social institutions of prehistoric populations who had relied on a similar technology. 
 For example, if the Bushmen of the Kalahari, who live by hunting and gathering, accord a high status to women this, it was assumed, must also have been true of the hunters and gatherers of prehistoric times. 
 This way of reasoning is, however, problematic for a number of reasons. 
 The first is that the history of the Kalahari Bushmen is just as long as those of technologically more advanced people of today, and so they are not representative of an &bquo;earlier period&equo; in the history of mankind. 
 Their society may have, and most probably has, changed radically and often since the time when hunters and gatherers roamed Europe. 
 The second difficulty is that, although the Kalahari Bushmen may have a similar technology to European prehistoric hunters and gatherers, their economic situation is very different. 
 The Bushmen have been pushed back from much richer regions into the most inhospitable areas of Africa by other more technologically advanced peoples with whose enmity they still have continually to reckon. 
 By contrast the prehistoric men of Europe were settled in the most fertile and advantageous areas of the country and did not have to fear more technologically advanced enemies. 
 Their lives were therefore presumably very much easier and different from that of Bushmen. 
 Because of this fundamental difference it is difficult to know whether we can rely on information about  contemporaries to tell us about prehistoric peoples in the way that is often done still today and was done universally in Marx's and Engels's time. 
 The significance of the objections we have just noted is much more important than might at first appear. 
 These objections imply that technology cannot be a guide to other aspects of society, or in other words that there is no inevitable association between technology and other aspects of society. 
 This qualification applies as much to the work of writers such as Morgan as to his critics. 
 They all believed that several corresponding processes could be identified, especially in the field of kinship, which went automatically in parallel with technological evolution. 
 We are now ready to examine in detail the assumptions in Marx's and Engels's work concerning the evolution of social aspects of human society. 
 First we shall look at the theories in their work concerning the evolution of kinship and marriage. 
 This means that we should pay special attention to The Origin , since this is where the matter is discussed extensively. 
 The evolution of kinship, marriage, and the status of women is a particularly revealing theme of this work. 
 That is because it is an area where Marx and Engels, misled by Morgan, went most wrong, yet where at the same time they made the best use of anthropology. 
 The explanation behind that paradox is once again the problem of the two uses of anthropology in their work. 
 The rhetorical use they made of anthropologists' ideas as a source for a criticism of the society of their time, especially as a criticism of the way institutions such as the family, marriage, and the status of women were seen as unchangeable and eternally fixed, is one which seems totally justified to present-day anthropologists. 
 However as an account of the actual historical evolution of kinship, their use of anthropology was disastrous, thanks largely to Morgan. 
 We shall first have to look at this &bquo;historical&equo; side of things before turning to the positive &bquo;rhetorical&equo; side of their work. 
 First we must once again concern ourselves with method and examine two assumptions which Engels took over from Morgan concerning the significance of kinship terms. 
 The first such assumption is the belief that the pattern of kinship terms reveals the marriage system. 
 As we have seen, this was a key point for Morgan because all his evidence about kinship came from kinship terms. 
 In the tendency of certain systems of kinship terms to group large numbers of people under words which he translated  as &bquo;father&equo; or &bquo;mother&equo; lay his proof for the existence of the communal marriages on which his theory of the evolution of the family, in general, and of the gens, in particular, rested. 
 This idea of Morgan's is far from ridiculous. 
 It ultimately relies on the notion that we order our world through the categorical distinctions of our language. 
 According to such a theory, if we, in English, call both our mother's brother and our father's brother by the same term &mdash; &bquo;uncle&equo; &mdash; it is because these two relatives are, to us, the same &bquo;kind&equo; of relative, and that probably the fact that we use the one word causes us to see them in that way. 
 In another language where mother's brothers and father's brothers are referred to by different words we would see them as different kinds of relatives. 
 This general view is still often held by anthropologists and has been repeatedly advocated by, among others, the British anthropologist E. R. Leach, for example, in his article &bquo;Concerning Trobriand Clans and the Kinship Category Tapu&equo; Leach, 1958&rsqb;. 
 The opposite view, that of Morgan's contemporary, McLennan &mdash; a view derided by Morgan, Marx, and Engels &mdash; sees kinship terms as having no social significance at all. 
 It is a view which, by contrast with that of Morgan and Engels, is, as far as I know, totally abandoned. 
 The general consensus now would be that, even if systems of kinship terms are closely linked to social systems, the link is not as simple as Morgan Made out. 
 The fact that several types of relatives can be called by the same term does not mean that they cannot be distinguished. 
 The fact that we call both our mother's brother and father's brother by the same term does not mean that we are unaware of the fact that we are related to them in different ways or that we cannot express this difference by using such phrases as &bquo;my uncle on my mother's side&equo;. 
 This is just the same for systems like the Polynesian one, discussed by Engels, where large numbers of people can referred to by the same term as one's father. 
 In such a system one can say &bquo;my own&equo; or &bquo;my true father&equo; and this is often done. 
 In this way people using such a terminology may distinguish the role of father from that of father's brother. 
 There is therefore no reason to believe that in such a system these two relatives are equally my mother's husband or that they both have similar sexual rights over my mother. 
 The pattern revealed by kinship terms cannot therefore be used as evidence of marriage systems in the way that Morgan believed. 
 This crucial element in Morgan's evidence is an illusion and there is not the slightest shred of evidence that those  societies where large numbers of people can be referred to by the terms for parent are societies where marriage is either more or less individualistic. 
 There is no correlation at all between the number of types of relatives that are called by the same word and the number of legitimate sexual partners in marriage. 
 Equally problematic is Morgan's other assumption: that systems of kinship terms change less easily than marriage systems, and that kinship terms can serve as an indication of what the marriage system was like in the past. 
 In some ways this principle is contradictory to the assumption, discussed above, that there is a match between terminology and marriage systems. 
 The idea that there is something of a lag between terminology and social system is interesting and there does indeed sometimes seem to be this type of gap. 
 For example, a group of people I studied in Madagascar changed their marriage system in response to changing economic circumstances but did not adjust their kinship terminology &lsqb;Bloch, 1975&rsqb;. 
 This time lag, however, dies not always occur, as I show in the same study, and we are not in a situation to make the kind of general assumption made by Morgan and Engels. 
 We can say that the relationship between marriage system and terminology is itself highly variable and so too is the way they interact on each other. 
 Because of this, the system of kinship terms is not valid evidence of what the marriage system was in the past, and Morgan's and Engels's assumptions, which rely on such an inference, cannot be accepted. 
 As a result much of the evidence for the evolution of kinship in The Origin  is irrelevant. 
 So, leaving aside for a moment the difficult question of whether to accept the kind of association between kinship system and technological level postulated by Morgan, Marx, and Engels, it is not surprising that modern anthropology reveals no such association between technology and kinship terms . 
 For example, the Eskimos, who as hunters and fishermen are right at the bottom of Marx's and Engels's technological scale, have a kinship terminology which does not classify relatives any more than the English system does &mdash; a sign for Morgan of the presence of monogamy &mdash; while the Malays, who have possessed for a very long time highly advanced agricultural techniques, use a kinship terminology which Morgan and Engels associated with the earliest stages of evolution. 
 Engels does introduce into The Origin  some types of evidence for early family forms other than terminology. 
 For example, in the  fourth edition of The Origin  he introduced evidence of group marriages occurring among the Australian Aborigines. 
 Unfortunately this type of evidence is also misleading, for two reasons. 
 First, Engels believed that his source, the writers Fison and Howitt, provided independent evidence of group marriage, while in fact they too were enthusiastic supporters of Morgan's theories. 
 Secondly, even though group weddings do occur, for example among people like the Samburu of East Africa, where traditionally all the young men of the same age group married on the same day a group of girls, this does not mean that the marriages are any less individual affairs for having been celebrated all at the same time. 
 The young man who has been married at the same time as his peers does not share his wife with them nor do the wives share their husbands. 
 This is the type of evidence which misled Engels into believing that communal marriage actually survived &lsqb;Spencer, 1965&rsqb;. 
 Having dealt with the methodological preliminaries, we can now turn to the evolutionary scheme for kinship systems presented in The Origin . 
 The first stage in the scheme was that of total primitive promiscuity. 
 It is one for which, as we have seen, neither Morgan nor Engels presented any evidence. 
 This is still the situation today. 
 We now know much more about surviving hunters and gatherers than was known in Morgan's day and, although sexual unions among them may in some cases be very unstable, in others they are not. 
 Furthermore, the high instability of marriage which does occur is not in any way unique to them. 
 A further stage in the scheme is much more interesting: this is the stage of the communal gens. 
 The main aspect of the gens which interested Engels's and Marx was it communal character, the ways it was internally undifferentiated and the way it held property as well as people and children in common. 
 In stressing this aspect, Marx and Engles were basing themselves in great part on the excellent description that Morgan had supplied for the matrilineal descent groups of the Iroquois, and, in his stress on the community aspect of descent groups, Morgan has been in many ways supported by later work. 
 Anthropologists such as Fortes, the foremost authority on the subject, &lsqb;Fortes, 1953; 1963&rsqb; have stressed the extraordinary unity of some descent groups and their communal control of property, as the key element of social organization of the peoples among which they occur. 
 &bquo;When we  turn to Morgan's discussion of this aspect of the gens we must admit that it brilliantly anticipates modern accounts,&equo; Fortes states. 
 Morgan, Marx, and Engels were therefore right in stressing the corporate, non-individualistic aspect of gens. 
 This was the evidence which Marx and Engels required in order to show that society has not always been based on private property held by isolated nuclear families. 
 This was their central point and they found evidence to support it which has stood the test of time. 
 Unfortunately both Marx and Engels, in their enthusiasm for this confirmation of their theory, also took over from Morgan's work on the gens several totally unsupportable assumptions which are in fact quite unnecessary for what they were trying to argue. 
 The first point that one would want to make in criticism of the gens theory is that, even if descent groups such as the Iroquois gens appear as undifferentiated communities from the point of view of an outsider, this is not so from the point of view of the member of a gens. 
 The land of a descent group is said to belong to the group as a whole and an outsider to the group does not have a right to cultivation inside the group territory when a member of the gens does so already. 
 This, however, does not mean that there are no further levels of distinction inside the group or that an individual member or a particular family within the gens may not have privileged access to a part of the gens territory. 
 There is a lot of evidence that such internal restrictions occur in all the accounts of descent groups amassed by anthropologists. 
 Admittedly if the component family abandons its claim to the land this will revert to the commonality but that does not mean that there are no such claims in normal circumstances. 
 In other words, a declaration of common ownership of the land of the gens does not imply free and equal access to all within the gens. 
 Marx, in particular, had already noted this fact in several places, but he explained the phenomenon of internal division as a transitional one; as evidence of a stage in which private property and individual families were coming in and undermining the communal descent group. 
 A problem with this point of view is that there is in fact no evidence of descent groups having ever  existed without these two levels and it seems difficult to treat all documented cases as transitions from a stage for which there is no evidence. 
 In any case, the contradiction which Marx stresses very largely disappears when we realize that it is a matter of the context in which claim to land is expressed. 
 From the point of  view of the outsider the descent group appears as undifferentiated and this will be expressed by statements of the commonality of the resources of claim while, from the point of view of the insider dealing with other insiders the descent group appears highly differentiated. 
 There is however an implied point in the discussion of the gens which, I believe, is justified in all societies principally organized by descent group (though not necessarily all societies where descent groups merely occur as one among many other social institutions). 
 In such societies one does not find internal differentiation based on differential wealth, and if such differentiation appears to develop, it is resisted. 
 This means that in a very general way there is a contradiction between class organization and descent groups, and that this contradiction is actually perceived, though not in theoretical terms, by the members of societies based on descent groups. 
 The exaggeration or over-simplification of the notion of commonality within the gens as regards ownership of property is also apparent in the discussion of kinship and this led equally to a fundamental misunderstanding. 
 In part Morgan believed that, in systems based on descent groups, spouses were held in common because, in such a society, people often talk of wives or husbands as &bquo;having been married to such and such a gens&equo;. 
 There are indeed certain aspects of the marriage system of such societies which support this point of view. 
 For example, a woman married to a man of a particular descent group may well be passed on to another man of her husband's descent group at his death. 
 This, however, does not mean that she is the wife of all the men of the descent group at the same time. 
 Again one must distinguish the point of view of the outsider and the insider. 
 From the outside people may say she has married into such and such a descent group but this does not mean that she is also not at the same time the wife of a particular man. 
 The communal and the familial are not necessarily in opposition &mdash; they are matters of levels, and although at certain times Marx seems to see this, at others he does not and Engels never does. 
 This is because of their legitimate keenness to stress the presence of a communal principle in the history of mankind. 
 None the less the fact remains that the presence of descent groups tells us nothing directly about domestic organization. 
 There is, however, yet another way in which modern anthropologists  could agree with Marx, Engels, and Morgan concerning the &bquo;group&equo; aspect of marriage. 
 All would stress that our view of marriage as a private alliance concerning almost exclusively two people is totally inappropriate for most non-capitalist societies, especially those based on descent groups. 
 In these societies marriages involve alliances between groups, often of a political character, and as such they are initiated and organized by the leaders of the groups concerned rather than by the future couple. 
 Similarly, in these societies a large number of people on both the bride's and the groom's side are involved in an obligatory exchange of property of major significance. 
 In this sense all anthropologists would agree that such marriages are primarily group concerns. 
 Marx in the notebooks is opposed to McLennan, Maine, Phear, and other who disagreed with Morgan over the commonality of the gens, principally because they saw society growing out of the individual monogamous family with its private property. 
 As a result, because they saw descent groups as enlarged families, something which Marx and Engels had themselves done in The German Ideology , but which they later emphatically rejected, Marx saw writers such as Maine arguing that monogamy, the subjugation of women, the nuclear family and private property were ineluctable basic principles in the nature of man. 
 Marx saw this point of view as legitimizing the institutions on which nineteenth-century capitalist society was built. 
 By contrast, Marx saw in Morgan's emphasis on the primacy of the matrilineal gens a challenge to these principles. 
 In this matter of the nature of the gens (descent group) further research has actually proved both sides of the controversy right. 
 As we saw, most modern anthropologists would, like Morgan, stress the corporate character of descent groups and would agree that these groups cannot be understood as large families &lsqb;Fortes, 1953&rsqb;, but they would also stress that some kind of individual domestic unit seems to normally exist in societies with descent groups. 
 In certain other ways Morgan misled Marx and Engels more irredeemably. 
 Morgan believed that the only true descent groups were matrilineal, and that matrilineal descent groups &mdash; gens &mdash; were fundamentally different in organization from systems where descent was reckoned in the male line. 
 In patrilineal descent groups, he argued, the individual family and  private property were prominent and the communal principle already moribund. 
 In fact, there seems no difference between patrilineal and matrilineal groups in this respect. 
 What matters, as Morgan, Marx, and Engels rightly stress, is the corporate organization of descent groups, but these descent groups are just as corporate whether descent is reckoned patrilineally or matrilineally. 
 The reason Morgan gave to explain why corporate descent groups were organized matrilineally was that since there were no individual unions within such groups one could never be sure of the identity of one's father. 
 This state of gens promiscuity is, however, imaginary and so the reasoning is irrelevant. 
 Similarly, there is no reason to believe that matriliny preceded patriliny. 
 This idea was very widespread in the nineteenth century for a variety of reasons. 
 Morgan found confirmation of it in the fact that the people he had studied in most detail &mdash; the Iroquois &mdash; happened to be matrilineal. 
 There is no evidence, however, for thinking that, in general, people who reckon descent in the male line reckoned it in the female line before. 
 This hypothesis was for a long time a subject of much contention in anthropology and is not even now entirely laid to rest, but the meagre historical record we possess cannot possibly support such an assertion. 
 The pre-existence of matriliny was important for Engels because he wrongly believed that matriliny, as opposed to patriliny, was associated with communal corporate descent groups. 
 It was also important for him because he believed that matriliny, the reckoning of group membership in terms of who one's mother was, was associated with a high status for women. 
 This whole question is of importance not only because it was so central to Engels's book but also because The Origin  has rightly been considered a major contribution to the feminist tradition. 
 Two aspects of Morgan's discussion of this question, a discussion that was almost as radical as that of Engels, must be distinguished, first the proposition that people with simple technology accord a high status to women, and second, that matriliny implies a high status for women. 
 The first assumption originated in the fact that because Morgan had made a special study of the Iroquois, where the status of women is comparatively high, he assumed uncritically that this high status would be found among other people at a similar level of technological advancement. 
 This is just not so. 
 For example, had  Morgan worked among the peoples of New Guinea, whose technological level he would have considered similar, he would have reached a totally different conclusion. 
 Secondly, Morgan gives the impression that there was a direct link between reckoning descent in the female line and high status for women. 
 This association has become further emphasized by writers who have muddled the words &bquo;matriliny&equo; &mdash; descent through the female line &mdash; and &bquo;matriarchy&equo; &mdash; rule by women. 
 In fact there is no direct link between the status of women and the reckoning of descent in one line or another. 
 Even if one belongs to a group because of who one's mother was and not because of who one's father was, this in no ways implies that women have particularly high (or low) status in that group. 
 It is not difficult to give many examples of societies where membership of descent groups is gained through women and where membership of descent groups is gained through women and where the status of women is comparatively low. 
 Again this would, by and large, be true of most of the matrilineal societies of New Guinea where, by most reckoning, the status of women would be considered lower than in many of the patrilineal societies of West Africa. 
 Descent and the status of women may not be entirely independent but they do not co-vary in the simple way suggested by Morgan. 
 We now must turn to another general assumption made in The Origin , the assumption that there is a correlation between technology and kinship system. 
 One of the key assumptions of Morgan and Engels was that the shift from matriliny to patriliny was in some ways linked with the introduction of herding and, subsequently, agriculture. 
 It they had been right, matrilineal society would tend to have a lower level of technological development while patrilineal societies would have a higher level. 
 In fact modern anthropological research shows that there is no such correlation. 
 The kind of situation which we find in most of West Africa, where side by side there are patrilineal peoples and matrilineal with identical technological achievements, occurs again and again in many other parts of the world. 
 In any case, many of the peoples with the simplest technology, such as the hunters and gatherers of Africa and Asia, are neither patrilineal nor matrilineal, and do not form descent groups of any type. 
 There is also no obvious correlation between level of technology and type of marriage. 
 Monogamy, to take a case particularly important to Engels, is equally found among hunters and gatherers such as the Eskimos, primitive cultivators such as  the Dayaks of Borneo, or among the industrialized North Americans. 
 Finally, since there is no simple correlation between high status for women and matriliny and since there is no simple connection between matriliny and type of technology, it follows that there is no simple connection between primitive technology and high status for women. 
 Among living hunters and gatherers, women may have a comparatively high status as amongst the Mbuti of Africa, or a comparatively low status among most Australian Aborigines 
 The issue is far more complicated and it is only fair to note that we have not reached a stage of knowledge when we can easily say what explains the status of women among the different peoples of the world. 
 The status of women has several aspects which themselves do not go simple together. 
 By and large the evidence which Engels and his contemporaries saw as significant of the high status of women in primitive societies is often wrong or does not signify what it was believed to mean. 
 As Engels noted, women contribute differentially to the processes of production in different types of society but the contribution of women in the production of the most important goods of the society does not necessarily give them a high status as he thought. 
 Among the pastoralists of East Africa women produce most of the foodstuffs through agriculture, but only cattle, cared for by men, are defined as the really important and noble product, and in fact women's dominant productive contribution is given as an excuse for their social devaluation as low creatures unconcerned with the aesthetic and political value of pastoralism. 
 Again in the New Guinea Highlands, women are the main agents in producing both agricultural products and the most valuable possession &mdash; pigs &mdash; but then, in the view of these people, what really matters is not production, but large-scale, ceremonial exchanges and the significance of women's role in production is once more ideologically denied. 
 Another feature which Engels, following Bachofen, believed was indicative of the high status of women in societies with simple technology was the fact that some such people worship female gods. 
 This, however, is no indication that they have a particularly high opinion of the spiritual contribution of women. 
 In any case the worship of female goddesses is neither characteristic nor common among hunters and gatherers. 
  There is also a certain problem in taking women's freedom to dispose of their own sexuality as an indicator of their influence and power in general, as is tacitly suggested by both Morgan and Engels. 
 Although this freedom offers a better indicator than such things as matriliny or the worship goddesses, it also is not a clear indicator of the political and economic power, in spite of Engels's belief to the contrary. 
 For example, the women among some of the peoples of the west of Madagascar have great freedom in choosing their sexual partners, yet they are totally insignificant in the administering of political and economic matters. 
 Overall most anthropologists would probably see indirect connection between all the factors which Engels considered, but these interrelations must remain much more problematic and ambiguous than they might seem at first, and the general conclusions which Engels sought in the work of Morgan are not possible. 
 The specific history of the evolution of kinship, marriage, and the status of women outlined after Morgan is thus almost altogether untenable. 
 The fault clearly lies with Morgan, but Marx and especially Engels seem on the whole to have been surprisingly uncritical of their source. 
 The reason lies once again in the central fact that the main concern of The Origin  was political not historical. 
 We must never forget that the history of kinship presented there is primarily a criticism of capitalist society and that Marx and Engels were not attempting to set themselves up as anthropologists. 
 As such, as a rhetorical critique of capitalist society, their account serves admirably and this use of anthropology in The Origin  echoes many recent anthropologists. 
 First let us consider the issue of marriage and the family. 
 Engels argued, and this is a fundamental aspect of his work that has become obscured in the discussion over whether there ever were such things as primitive promiscuity or group marriage, against those who asserted that monogamous marriage and the type of family that was associated with it was a universally valid ideal of man, irrespective of social or cultural context. 
 The family and marriage, in the particular form that it took in Victorian times, was, for the great majority of Engels's contemporaries a sacred, eternal, and unchallengeable institution. 
 By contrast Engels's position was that the family, as it was known in his time,  had not always existed in that form, that marriage as it was known at that time had also not always existed. 
 Marriage and the family were therefore not unquestionable institutions, independent of history and society, they were linked to the economic system, to the political system, to the class system. 
 This central &bquo;rhetorical&equo; point is one that would be wholeheartedly endorsed by most modern anthropologists. 
 Anthropologists have been at pains to stress the variety  of accepted institutional arrangements which regulate the relations between the sexes in different societies. 
 How far unions are binding, how far they are exclusive, how long they last, whether they bind men and women equally, whether sexual unions are public or merely private matters, whether the recognition of unions is inevitably linked with the legitimation of children &mdash; all these questions and many more are so variable that many anthropologists would argue that is not possible to give a valid universal definition of marriage &lsqb;Leach, 1961&rsqb;. 
 Furthermore, all anthropologists would agree with Engels that the type of marriage and the type of family are linked directly to a whole range of other political and economic institutions, which explain and correlate the variation. 
 For modern anthropologists, quite as much as for Marx and Engels, forms of family and marriage are integral parts of the social system and co-vary with the overall system. 
 This therefore means that when the social system changes so will the nature of marriage and the family. 
 An implication, of course, is not only that marriage and the family have taken a great variety of forms, but that when political and economic conditions change in the future they will continue to change. 
 This Engels emphatically asserted in The Origin  when he argues that communism would mean the end of the family as we know it and the liberation of women. 
 It was, at the time, a most dramatically revolutionary and shocking statement. 
 Even though the specific predictions of Engels might not be endorsed by modern anthropologists they would nearly all subscribe to the general thesis that as political and economic conditions change, so will marriage and the family change, and this conclusion is apparently still seen as shocking. 
 When in 1967 E. R. Leach made exactly the same point on the BBC, there was a national uproar with bishops and pundits of all kinds fulminating in the newspapers against the impiety of the idea, in much the same way that they had done against Engels almost a hundred  years before. 
 This is the central point of the chapter on the family in The Origin . 
 Engels is saying that the family and marriage have not always been as they are now. 
 These two institutions have a history, and they are therefore specific to a particular time and type of society and, as time passes and society goes on changing, as it always has, these institutions will change. 
 Furthermore, Engels argues, marriage and the family &mdash; these ideas which Victorians thought of as peculiarly linked with private life and as having nothing to do with political and economic life &mdash; are in reality intimately associated with it. 
 The type of family and marriage which they operated was not given in the nature of man or in other supernatural and suprahistorical sources, but in the economic and political circumstances of their time, in this case by capitalism. 
 The long history of marriage and the family we are given in The Origin  if first and foremost to show that the family and marriage do  have a history. 
 This was the point which was most politically explosive, and this was the point which has been the cause of the greatest revilement of the book to this day. 
 Interestingly enough, it is also a point with which all serious anthropologists and historians would now agree, although they would perhaps hesitate to spell out, as Engels and Leach have done, its implication. 
 Engels's general argument concerning marriage and the family applies to his discussion of the status of women, and again his position seems very much in advance of his time. 
 Apart from the specific history of the status of women that Engels was proposing, he was again stressing that the status of women is not an independent fact, perhaps explained by transcendental ideas concerning the nature of men and women, but rather that men's and women's ideas about women were all aspects of a much wider system which included the whole political economy and its internal logic. 
 This Engels demonstrated brilliantly in his analysis of the position of women in capitalist society. 
 The point that the position of women is not an independent factor, a simple enough point in itself, but one often explicitly refused and, more commonly, implicitly ignored, is again one which most anthropologists would now entirely support, even though they rarely acknowledge Engels's work. 
 The status of women is part of an organic totality and is linked, as Engels argued it was linked, with the nature of labour, the nature of property, even the nature of descent. 
 However it is linked to these things because they and it  are part of a complex whole, and this rules out the simple correlations between two elements which Engels sought to establish in his &bquo;historical&equo; discussion. 
 The second point concerning the position of women which anthropologists would almost universally endorse follows from the first. 
 Because the status of women is inextricably linked to a complex politico-economic system, it, and the ideas connected with it, change in response to changes in the system as a whole. 
 The position of women that Engels found when he was writing was therefore seen by him as the product of a moment of history. 
 The position of women has changed radically and would therefore continue to change. 
 This revolutionary conclusion, which is perhaps the most important for the general reader of The Origin , is one easily supported by modern anthropologists although they might disagree with him about what exactly will happen when the change comes or even whether this kind of change can be predicted. 
 In the previous section we have examined Marx's and Engels's views about the evolution of the family. 
 This section deals with an examination of their views of early political evolution, principally in the light of the theory in The Origin , but also in their other writings. 
 The main element of this discussion again comes from Morgan and concerns the description of what he calls the &bquo;gentile constitution&equo;. 
 This is a political system based on descent groups and the kinship and marriage ties that link them. 
 In this, Morgan foreshadows in a most amazing way the understanding of what have since been called &bquo;acephalus lineage systems&equo;. 
 The description and demonstration of the working of such systems has always been considered a major advance in anthropological theory and is usually traced to the publication in 1940 of African Political Systems  by M. Fortes and E. E. Evans-Pritchard with their respective discussions of the Tallensi of West Africa and the Nuer of East Africa. 
 Fortes, however, when later reviewing the work of Morgan, handsomely acknowledges the extent to which he had been foreshadowed by Morgan &lsqb;Fortes, 1969&rsqb;, first in terms of his analysis of the way these acephalus systems work, and secondly in his understanding of the way that the continuing existence of politically active descent groups poses a threat to the organization and stability of the State. 
 This last point is politically most important for Engels since he uses it to show how the development of the State implies the destruction of the egalitarian  and communally-based gens: a proof of the Marxist view of the State as fundamentally a class institution, a view first developed in The German Ideology . 
 Engles stresses another point also later to be emphasized by Fortes and Evans-Pritchard in African Political Systems . 
 The existence of &bquo;the gentile constitution&equo; shows that order can exist without the State. 
 This possibility ran counter to much nineteenth-century political theory, which stressed that the State was the only guarantor of personal safety. 
 Yet the fact that many primitive peoples regulate interpersonal relations with a fair degree of predictability and humanity, without the help of a centralized political system, is one that most anthropologists would now endorse; however, unlike Engels, they do this without pointing out the political implications of such an observation. 
 For Engels, by contrast, the possibility revealed by the gentile constitution was a major guarantee that the Marxist vision of the withering away of the State in a future communist society was not a recipe for chaos, as was argued by his opponents. 
 The correlation which Morgan and Engels make between very simple agriculture and herding and the gentile constitution is a rare example of a proposition of this kind which has held up fairly well in the light of recent research. 
 With several modifications, such varied anthropologists as D. Forde &lsqb;1948&rsqb;, M. Fortes&rsqb; 1953&rsqb;, and M. Sahlins &lsqb;1961&rsqb; have given support to the view that segmentary systems, the modern anthropological equivalent of Morgan's &bquo;gentile systems&equo;, seem to occur in societies with similar technologies and they are by and large of the type postulated in The Origin . 
 There is therefore very much in Engels's discussion of existing political organization which is still acceptable; however, recent anthropological work makes it clear that if something like the notion of the gentile constitution is to be retained, the concept would have to be broadened to include a much greater variety of such systems than was, or could have been, envisaged by the founders of Marxism. 
 First of all, Fortes and Evans-Pritchard pointed out that the descent groups of segmentary society may be either matrilineal or patrilineal, not just matrilineal, as Morgan believed. 
 With some modification, this view, expressed in African Political Systems , is generally accepted, Recent research would broaden even further the category and also include systems where descent groups are linked one to another by marriage,  rather than by believed common descent. 
 Such systems can be illustrated by the case of the Kachins of Burma, examined in a famous study by Leach &lsqb;1954&rsqb;. 
 There also exist cases where the constituent groups of gentile constitutions are not really based either on patrilineal or matrilineal descent, but on a mixture of kinship and locality. 
 The various &bquo;Dayak&equo; societies of Borneo are an example. 
 This greater variety than that envisaged by Morgan or Engels does certainly modify the picture. 
 On the whole, however, their ideas concerning the political organization of descent-group society, what they call the &bquo;gentile constitution&equo;, are surprisingly modern and helpful and seem supported by more recent findings. 
 The next stage in Morgan's and Engels's scheme for the evolution of political systems is characterized by confederations of different tribes. 
 Morgan, whom Engels followed, was once again basing himself on his studies of the Iroquois. 
 Morgan still remains the main authority on the Iroquois, but the real problem for the general theory is that confederations of the Iroquois type are not found in many places. 
 Making the confederacy a &bquo;stage&equo; is therefore highly misleading since this gives the impression that we are dealing with a recurrent phenomenon. 
 It is also unquestionably misleading to assume, as Engels does, that such a stage must have occurred as a precursor to the emergence of the State in Greece or Rome. 
 The discussion of the gentile constitution and of the confederacy are however, intended by Marx and Engels as a preliminary to their theory of the origin of the State, and for this again they made much use of Morgan's work. 
 The State for Engels and Marx was as we saw, a tool by which the dominant class maintained its position. 
 According to this theory the State therefore arises with the appearance of classes. 
 This is an extremely bold theory, but in the present stage of historical and anthropological knowledge it is not possible to say whether Marx of Engels were clearly wrong, as they were over primitive promiscuity, or by and large right, as they were over the gentile constitution. 
 One problem is a matter of definition. 
 Some Marxist anthropologists have argued that units which do not contain classes are not true states, and of course, in these cases, by definition there cannot be classless states. 
 If, on the other hand, any centralized system with a single head, controlling a defined territory, is called a state, it is then possible to give examples of &bquo;states&equo; where no  obvious dominant class exists. 
 Of course, in such cases, rulers tend to have different life-styles from their subjects, but what is at issue is that they do not have a privileged access to property, especially to the means of production, an essential element of Marx's and Engels's definition of a class. 
 Examples of such &bquo;classless&equo; states would include some of the central African states of the nineteenth century, such as the Bemba of Zambia. 
 Some anthropologists would counter these examples by arguing that there actually are class-like phenomena in such states (Terray, 1975), by pointing out the difference in access to the means of production between elders and juniors and men and women, but even if this argument is accepted it gives little support to the general theory in that such &bquo;class&equo; differences also occur in clearly stateless societies. 
 Equally damaging to the overall theory of the origin of the State is the fact that there seem to be examples of stateless societies with much less problematic classes. 
 An example of such a system would be the Tuareg of North Africa where a ruling class controls large numbers of slaves but where no centralized authority existed traditionally. 
 The present situation concerning the question, under which circumstances do states arise, is that in all honesty most anthropologists would hesitate to generalize. 
 The few examples of state formation which have been studied in detail are all significantly different in important respects. 
 A number of different theories concerning the necessary prerequisites for the State have been proposed by anthropologists. 
 They stress such things as population density, circumscription in a small area, conquest by outsiders of the diffusion of the idea of divine kingship. 
 None is satisfactory but none really corresponds to Morgan's, Engels's and Marx's theory, with the possible exception of that presented by M. Fried, an American anthropologist, who argues that stratification, is at least, a &bquo;necessary pre-condition&equo; of the State &lsqb;Fried, 1967&rsqb;. 
 If Marx's and Engels's hypothesis concerning the origin of the State must remain questionable, their theory seems more important for understanding the way existing states actually work. 
 For a long time the dominant view in anthropology was that the State was a beneficial institution. 
 Even Morgan took this view. 
 He is much more positive about the introduction of the State than Engels. 
 What anthropologists stressed was that the State brought  safety for the individual, peace, and the rule of law. 
 This is a major theme in the work of the American anthropologist Lowie and the British anthropologist, Radcliffe-Brown. 
 A similar, pro-State position is implied in the way several anthropologists have stressed the potential of state organization for bringing about large-scale public works, such are irrigation or communications networks. 
 Though there is little doubt that all these aspects of the State are valuable and important, it has also become clear that they can form the basis of a very one-sided picture. 
 Recent work by several anthropologists has stressed, by contrast, the State's previously over-looked role as an exploitative mechanism, and this work has in most cases been influenced by Marxism &lsqb;e.g. Terray, 1977; Bloch 1977&rsqb;. 
 For example, J. Goody has argued that West African states grew up as a result of monopoly control, by a small group of people, of military technology, which he terms the &bquo;means of destruction&equo;. 
 He argues that this control enables a group of conquerors to subdue and dominate those who do not have access to such technology. 
 Such a view is easily reconciled with Marxist theory, as has been pointed out by E. Terray &lsqb;Terray, 1977a&rsqb;. 
 In a similar vein there has recently been a whole range of studies of pre-industrial states by anthropologists, largely in terns of class analysis. 
 One of the first examples if the study of the Inca state by M&eacute;traux &lsqb;1969&rsqb;. 
 It is therefore rather more as a tool for the analysis of the nature and functioning of states than as a theory of the emergence of the State that Marx's and Engels's views are still acceptable to present-day anthropologists. 
 We now turn to two aspects of Marx's and Engels's anthropological theory which are more directly central to their critique of capitalism than those topics discussed so far; the evolution of labour and property. 
 The discussion of these two topics is not limited to The Origin  but is a major theme in all of Marx's and Engels's work. 
 The history of the evolution of labour is, from The German Ideology  on, linked with a discussion of the increased division of labour, which itself is linked with increasing technological complexity. 
 Increased division of labour, it is stated, leads to a change in the nature of production, from production for use to production for exchange. 
 The division of labour, Marx and Engels argue in The German Ideology , is the basis of this transformation in the nature of labour and property which ultimately  lays the foundations of capitalism. 
 The division of labour is closely linked with exploitation in all the works considered here, and its development is usually associated with the growth of slavery, which, together with serfdom, is seen as an intermediary step towards the development of the &bquo;free&equo; labour of capitalism. 
 Many aspects of the evolutionary scheme which Marx and Engels present would now be unacceptable to anthropologists. 
 First of all their assumption that in simple societies technology explains satisfactorily the division of labour is untenable. 
 Among many groups of hunters and gatherers, we commonly find an elaborate and unequal division of labour, especially between men and women, which the technology in no way causes. 
 In fact, in these cases the division of labour seems to be the product  of the exploitation of women by men, rather than its cause. 
 Thus, among South American hunters and gatherers, women are actively excluded from hunting large animals, an occasional but highly valued activity, but, on the other hand, they are expected to supply the basis of daily sustenance through gathering of vegetable products, an activity which men affect to despise, but which is far more time consuming, and infinitely more important for subsistence. 
 There is no reason in the nature of the technology itself why men should not gather fruits, berries, and roots, and consequently no reason why they should spend so much less time in productive activities. 
 The reason for this is that women are forced to carry on the main productive activity by themselves because of their subjection. 
 A final twist is given to this situation; the fact that women do all of this work is often given as an explanation of their inferiority. 
 Another assumption made by Marx throughout his work is that higher technology increases the total leisure time available. 
 This assumption was universally accepted until recently by prehistorian and anthropologists, but has been refuted in recent studies of hunters and gatherers. 
 This work surprisingly shows that leisure time actually diminishes as productive technology advances; whether this is because of population increases or because of the rise of an exploitative class is not clear. 
 None the less, this unexpected finding requires many modifications to assumptions which are often made concerning the implications of improved technology, and which are included in Marx's and Engels's work. 
 Equally important for our evaluation of their theory of labour is  the different view of exchange held by modern anthropology and Marx and Engels. 
 For them increasing material exchange was seen, as it was by other economists of their time, as arising from improved technology and greater specialization. 
 There is in fact no doubt that specialization does lead to greater exchange, but anthropologists have become aware of the importance of a different type of material exchange, which is in no way related to technology or specialization. 
 This type of exchange is often called by anthropologists gift exchange. 
 Such exchanges take place not because people need to obtain what they do not produce but in order to demonstrate and maintain social links, often of an egalitarian kind. 
 In this way, people such as the Trobrianders of the Pacific, made famous by Malinowshi, spend a great deal of their energy producing goods of no practical value, mainly elaborate pieces of jewellery, for no other purpose than to exchange them with neighbours, and thereby maintain peaceful social relations. 
 In many ways societies such as the Trobrianders' are obsessed with exchange, but with a form of exchange of a totally different nature to that envisaged by Marx and most economists. 
 The presence of this impractical exchange means that modern anthropologists see exchange as more fundamental to social relations than Marx and Engels did. 
 The fundamental Marxist contrast between production for use and production for exchange, as well as the assumption that increasing exchange is correlated with technological specialization, needs fundamental reworking. 
 This rethinking is even more necessary for the assumption that the growth of exchange implies greater inequality. 
 Indeed the type of ceremonial gift exchange to which we have referred seems to be based on egalitarian notions of reciprocity and sharing. 
 Furthermore even exchange resulting from economic specialization does not, in itself, seem to be necessarily correlated with inequalities, as Marx and Engels believed. 
 There are many examples of institutionalized exchanges of goods between peoples, who specialize in different things, which seem to have no hierarchical implications. 
 This would be true, for instance, of the trading that took place in pre-colonial times between different tribes of Australian Aborigines, and there are many other examples. 
 None the less the general point which underlies Marx's concept of production for use, as opposed to production for exchange, seems, in spite of the objections just considered, a fundamental  advance which has yet to be fully appreciated. 
 Marx was pointing out that the capitalist assumption that what motivates man everywhere and for all time is the search for profit, is totally misleading and is itself a product of capitalism. 
 In other societies the accumulation of wealth and profit may be much less relevant. 
 People might aim to be remembered as ancestors by the continuation of their descent group, to have freedom from domination by others, or to have power for themselves, not profit. 
 In this Marx has been proved by subsequent anthropology to be quite right, and many anthropologists would argue that the attribution of the profit motive to people who do not have it has been the greatest hindrance to an understanding of pre-capitalist societies. 
 Marx's recognition of the specificity of motives under capitalism should have alerted us to this problem. 
 Marx's and Engels's views about slavery should also be modified in the light of more recent work. 
 These views were very strongly influenced by the case of Greece and Rome. 
 Like most of their contemporaries, Marx and Engels assumed that there was something inevitable about the concurrence of slavery and a particular type of economy or technology. 
 Recent work makes us much less confident that any such clear correlation is possible. 
 For example, some hunting and gathering peoples, who according to their scheme would not be expected to have slavery, seem to have had large numbers of slaves. 
 This is the case for some of the North American Indians of the West Coast. 
 By contrast, on the other side of the equator, there are societies, such as some of the traditional pre-colonial Southern African states which though they have pastoralism and agriculture, do not seem to have had slavery. 
 We are not yet in a position, therefore, to replace Marx's and Engels's view with a clear alternative specifying under what conditions a society based on slavery is likely to occur, but similarly we cannot accept Marx's and Engels's theory fully. 
 The evidence is too complex and too little work has been done. 
 Perhaps the only facts that seem to be emerging on this topic are the following two: first, slavery is rare among hunters and gatherers, and, secondly, it occurs most often among pastoralists &lsqb;Goody, 1980&rsqb;. 
 Even these two conclusions need to be treated with great caution. 
 By contrast, some of Marx's and Engels's views on slavery, views which owed much to the classical historians whom they  used as their sources, still seem to hold up extremely well. 
 Their link-up of slavery with forms of domination within the family is well documented in traditional systems of slavery such as are found in many parts of Africa. 
 There, as Marx had noted, slaves are often classed with women and children and are often obtained in order to be adopted by people without descendants. 
 Equally important is the distinction Marx repeatedly draws between the occurrence of small-scale &bquo;domestic&equo; slavery and whole societies based on the exploitation of slaves, such as was the case for Greece and Rome, and the insistence that these two cases should be kept separate. 
 This fruitful distinction is possible because here as elsewhere Marx and Engels are not bound in their analysis simply by legal forms; they look at the social system as a whole. 
 If they had just looked at the laws governing slavery, as had done both their contemporaries and more recent social scientists, they would have been unable to distinguish between slavery as a minor and rare form of exploitation, on the one hand, supplying occasional domestic and sexual luxuries, and slavery as the basis of whole economies, on the other hand, where most of production is carried out by slave labour. 
 This is because it is quite possible that the laws in both cases may be much the same. 
 It is because Marx and Engels look not just at the laws but at the nature of relations of production within a whole system that this fundamental and analytically fruitful difference shows up with such great prominence in their work. 
 This difference between the two types of slavery and the passage from one stage to the other is one which has been stressed again and again by anthropologists &lsqb;Goody, 1980; Bloch, 1980&rsqb;. 
 Finally, the difference in the nature of slavery and wage labour which Marx and Engels discussed in many places has formed the basis of all recent discussion on the subject. 
 Marx argued throughout Capital  that although slaves might be more at the mercy of the whims and fancies of their owners than wage workers, it was at least in the interest of the owner to ensure the minimum welfare of his slaves, since they were his property. 
 The employer of wage labour, by contrast, did not need to have this concern with the welfare of his workers. 
 This means that where labour is plentiful slavery is unnecessarily &bquo;expensive&equo;. 
 Marx is therefore able to explain the end of slavery as being due to the fact that wage workers actually were cheaper to use than slaves. 
 This bold hypothesis would still be accepted by many anthropologists  and historians, and even those who have tried to refute it are still working within its framework. 
 The discussion of the evolution of labour given by Marx and Engels is, as we have seen, open on several general and specific points. 
 Overall, however, it has stood the test of time surprisingly well when we consider how little information on pre-capitalist systems they disposed of. 
 The reason for their success seems to me to be less due to their perceptiveness concerning pre-capitalist conditions than due to the depth of their analysis of the nature of labour under capitalism. 
 A very large part of Marx's work was intended to show how the particular form and representation of labour under capitalism was an extraordinary fantasy. 
 labour appeared to have a separate existence from the life of the labourer and thus appeared as an alien object. 
 This, Marx pointed out, was as unfounded as a belief in fairies. 
 Yet people acted as though there was such a thing  and this illusion was essential both for the working of capitalism and for the acceptability of the exploitation on which capitalism was based. 
 Marx in his early writing was much interested in how the illusion of religion comes about, but in his later writing he seems to have lost interest in religion. 
 The reason is that he began to seen the economic concepts on which the society of his time was based, such concepts as value, price, property, and above all, labour, as the nineteenth-century equivalent of religion. 
 Concepts like labour organized life in much the same way as the notion of God had done in the Middle Ages, and it had as little material reference. 
 Capital  is a work almost entirely dedicated to understanding the fantastic nature of such concepts of labour, and to understanding what conditions this type of concept comes about. 
 For the purposes of this second task, Marx uses information on how the concepts are visualized in other system, hence his use of anthropology and history. 
 He also tries to reconstruct the history of representations in a completely different way. 
 He tries to imagine  the process by demystifying himself, in other words, by ridding himself of the fantastic in the notion of labour, and by trying to see what it would  be like without the strange construction of the system of his time. 
 In the case of labour, Marx was extraordinarily successful. 
 He imagined labour as it would be, had it not been formulated by capitalism, and say that it would then be merely an aspect  of  the total business of living, unseparated from such activities as recreation, consumption, family life: that it would be just part of existence. 
 This in fact seems to be very much the situation which anthropologists have found in pre-capitalist systems, and this was the case with the Malagasy people I studied. 
 In such societies labour is so little thought of as a special separate type of activity that there is no word which in any way corresponds to what we with our language, moulded by the history of capitalism, mean by labour. 
 The life of a subsistence farmer simple does not accord with our notion of labour. 
 For example, we cannot answer such questions as at what time does a rural Malagasy begin work and at what time does he or she end it? 
 There is no break between getting up, washing, husking rice for breakfast, eating the breakfast, making basket work, stopping to chat, going out to cultivate the kitchen garden, mending household objects and tools, going to the field, fishing for crayfish in a nearby stream, swimming there, herding the cattle, playing a musical instrument, etc. 
 All these are part of living, all these activities are totally intertwined, and there is no possibility of separating them into work and leisure. 
 This point has been shown again and again; it is clear from the excellent descriptions of production activities which we have of peoples such as the Tikopia of Polynesia described by Firth &lsqb;1939&rsqb; or of the Bemba of Africa by Audrey Richards &lsqb;1939&rsqb;. 
 These societies and many others support completely Marx's central point: that the conceptualization of productive activity is totally integrated with other social relations in pre-capitalist societies and that the sharp boundary we draw between labour and other activities is absent. 
 In this respect, Marx's anthropology seems amazingly ahead of his time. 
 The full theoretical significance of this idea has only been demonstrated recently by anthropologists who have turned again to Marx in order to find a framework in which to place their observations &lsqb;Gedelier, 1977&rsqb;. 
 Much of the same sorts of observations as apply to Marx's and Engels's notion concerning labour also apply to their discussions of property. 
 Although throughout Marx's and Engels's work reference to property is so extensive that it is impossible to take them all into account, a general pattern emerges. 
 They believed that there had been a stage when there was no individual property; that is, when no ownership continued beyond the time of use. 
 This stage was followed by the introduction of individual  ownership and this was followed by a few people gradually monopolizing the ownership of the means of production. 
 Of course, Marx and Engels focused most on this late stage, since they saw it as the cause of the rise of capitalism. 
 However, in order to show the &bquo;historical&equo; nature of this state of affairs they had to stress the existence of previous stages when private property was absent. 
 This idea has often been ridiculed by anthropologists who point out that there is no record or suggestion that there ever was, or ever could be, a stage of total sharing and total freedom of access by everybody at any time to anything. 
 Indeed it is difficult to imagine such a state of affairs, but in fact Marx, especially in Formen  makes it quite clear that this is not what he meant at all; it is only under the influence of Morgan in The Origin  that Engels might possible by construed to have implied something so unlikely. 
 Throughout Marx's work he stresses, as he had done for labour, the fantastic nature of the capitalist concept of property, the fantastic notion that there is something of our personality in the things or places we own. 
 Having pointed out the peculiarity and arbitrariness of this notion he then assumes that, in other  systems, the relation of man to his material environment is visualized differently . 
 In that he has been thoroughly supported by the anthropological evidence, although the nature of these other systems has proved often much more complex that he had imagined. 
 The general consensus among modern anthropologists is that we too should get away from the notion of private property as we know it, when we analyse the economic system of pre-literate peoples, but instead talk of a multiplicity of rights of different types. 
 Thus, in such societies, people may have rights of temporary use, rights to exclude foreigners, rights to claim something if they particularly need it. 
 Nevertheless, all these types of rights contrast fundamentally with the &bquo;once-and-for-all&equo; rights vested in an individual that we think of as private property. 
 This difference is all the more complete in that different rights in the same thing or place may be and usually are held by different people or different groups of people in those societies. 
 Marx was therefore quite right in stressing the historical peculiarity of private property. 
 He also comes very close to describing what anthropologists have actually found is the case as regards property in pre-capitalist systems. 
 Above all he was right in arguing as he did in Formen  that the absence of &bquo;private  property&equo; in no way implies &bquo;the law of the jungle&equo;. 
 In all this work, Marx, and to a lesser extent, Engels, foreshadow later anthropology and even run into the same technical difficulties concerning what term to use for pre-capitalist property systems, thereby showing how close they are to modern scholars. 
 The attempt to understand and to find suitable words for these different types of property is one that is still going on in anthropology and is proving extremely difficult &lsqb;Goodenough, 1951; Goody, 1962; Gluckman, 1965; Bloch, 1975&rsqb;. 
 In another fundamental respect, Marx's general view is also well borne out. 
 The complete ownership by individuals of the means of production, especially land, is, as he predicted, totally unknown in the traditional societies that anthropologists have studied. 
 It only occurs as a result of the incorporation of these societies into capitalist systems. 
 The difference to which he was drawing our attention, therefore, remains a fundamental one between the types of society Marx was distinguishing by this means. 
 We have seen how Marx's and Engels's ideas about pre-capitalist societies have been either supported or invalidated by subsequent knowledge. 
 As is to be expected, the story is a mixed one. 
 If their ideas about the evolution of kinship seem almost entirely obsolete the same is not true of their ideas about property or the evolution of the State although, in these areas too, many modifications are necessary. 
 In one way, however, it is misleading to evaluate the significance of their work on these subjects by how right or how wrong is the evolutionary sequence they describe. 
 Their purpose was quite clear and was quite different. 
 Neither Marx nor Engels considered himself to be historian or anthropologist. 
 They used the work of anthropologists and historians which was available, and on the whole they used this work very judiciously. 
 Inevitably, however, they took over many factual and theoretical shortcomings from the anthropologists on whom they relied and most of the problems we have seen in their work they inherited from their sources. 
 The reason why they turned to anthropology and history had more to do with their analysis of capitalism than with a concern with pre-capitalist societies for themselves. 
 They were seeking throughout their work to show that the concepts on which the edifice of capitalism was built, the concepts of the State, of property, of the nature of men and women, of marriage, of the  family, of labour, of trade, and of capital itself, were not unshakeable givens based on such ahistorical phenomena as the nature of man, or logic, or god. 
 Rather, they argued, these concepts, which appeared as eternal, were really the product of the history of the system they maintained. 
 The anthropological excursion which they undertook was there to show the arbitrariness, the contextual, relative nature of these concepts. 
 Only when these concepts and their false permanence had been penetrated could an acceptable analysis of politics by possible. 
 What mattered to Marx and Engels was therefore not so much the specific history which had produced these concepts, but the fact that they had a history at all, that the concepts were dependent on the type of society and economy in which they occurred. 
 This idea was totally foreign and repugnant tot he accepted view of their time and this is probably still largely so today. 
 In spite of this the idea that marriage, the family, property, the State etc. are merely temporal, transitory institutions, the product of a particular social system, is an idea which all modern anthropologists would accept even if many would hesitate to broadcast it. 
 Indeed the conclusion that such diverse aspects of society as religion, kinship, politics, and economics form a linked whole has been one of the touchstones of modern anthropology. 
 Marx and Engels were probably the first to demonstrate this so emphatically. 
 It was be demonstrating this wholeness that they were able to show that when one side of this whole changes, so will the other. 
 This central point in Marx's and Engels's work has been on the whole supported by later anthropological work. 
 No modern anthropologist doubts the uncomfortably revolutionary conclusion that all aspects of society form a whole and that none is independent of the moment of history characterized by this transitory, all-embracing system. 
 They might not, however, follow Marx and Engels in their conclusion that the system on which their own society is based will therefore also be overthrown, but it is difficult to seen how such a conclusion can be avoided. 
 The Direct Successors of Marx and Engels 
 Looking back at the works of Marx and Engels so far examined we can see that these leave a fairly clear picture concerning some topics, and major uncertainties concerning others. 
 First, all of these works follow the perspective outlined in The German Ideology  and look at human societies as systems organizing production and reproduction rather than as institutional structures. 
 This is the fundamental starting point of all Marxist studies of society. 
 The anthropological concerns with which Marx's and Engels's work deal in the clearest fashion concern such matters as the evolution of property, the evolution of forms of labour, and the growth of the State. 
 In these three areas there is a clear development in the various works considered in the previous chapters, and these different studied build on each other. 
 Property changes in nature as private property is introduced, and this type of property becomes the foundation of capitalist exploitation. 
 Labour changes from being at a stage where it has not yet become a thing in itself and is merely an aspect of social life, to a stage when although still an aspect of social life it involves exploitation, i.e. slavery and serfdom, to a third stage when labour has become mysteriously represented as a thing and is used for a different kind of exploitation. 
 The State is seen as developing as class differentiation increases, because it is one of the tools by which a dominant class maintains itself. 
 On these three topics the various works are all agreed apart from minor variations. 
 There are, however, other questions to which the different works give apparently different answers. 
 The first such questions arises over the specific status of the evolutionary sequence which is being put forward. 
 Although in all the three books considered there is some evolutionary scheme, when we take them together it is clear that Marx and Engels were very willing to modify the overall picture whenever they obtained new information. 
 This new information was, not surprisingly, usually about non-western European societies, about which they  clearly felt more unsure. 
 For example, when Marx learnt about India, China, and Peru, he introduced his oriental or Asiatic stage. 
 When Marx and Engels learnt more about primitive societies, as a result of reading Morgan and other anthropologists, they revised their views in that area. 
 We therefore get an overall impression of relative flexibility. 
 It is also clear that in some places, Marx at least, seems willing to envisage qualifications which are even more fundamental; for example, that there might be more than one line of evolution. 
 This we have seen do in Formen . 
 The overall flexibility which is clear when we take the three works together seems to be much less evident when we look at The Origin  by itself. 
 There Engels more or less tells us that the scheme presented is not likely to be changed by new discoveries. 
 He also presents us with a fairly strict unilineal theory of evolution, (if we forget about the difference between the New and the Old Worlds). 
 The other area of doubt concerns a question whether the same laws of historical development apply to the whole history of mankind or whether different, simpler laws apply to primitive societies. 
 This, as we have noted, is closely linked to the question whether something like classes have always existed, because the Marxist theory of history centres around the notion of class. 
 If, as Engels assumes in The Origin , primitive societies contained no inequality, then it would follow, according to Marxist thought, that a different, simpler theory of history would apply for these societies. 
 If, on the other hand, something like classes had always existed, as assumed in The German Ideology , the first edition of The Communist Manifesto , and Formen , then the principles developed by Marx in Capital  could be made to apply to all societies. 
 What this difference meant was that, according to the earlier works, the same complex relation between ideas, institutions, relations of productions, and technology applied to all societies, while, according to The Origin , a different theory applied to primitive societies. 
 In these, according to Engels, ideas and institutions were merely a direct reflection of economy and technology. 
 INTRODUCTION 
 The hotel in Oslo was grim. 
 The man behind the desk eyed us suspiciously, heavy rucsacs on tired shoulders, pinched faces from the frozen air. 
 He pushed a book towards me, and raised an eyebrow as I signed my name. 
 I wondered if this might have been from surprise over the fact that I could write, but it was just one of a fair catalogue of mannerisms he had to offer. 
 He took a wrist-rupturing key from a rack and shuffled around to our side of the desk. 
 We followed him in silence up a flight of stairs to a corridor too dark for eyes to pick out its furthest point. 
 &bquo;That's the bathroom,&equo; he said, vaguely indicating a door to the right behind which, we were to discover, an array of ancient pipework gurgled and glugged. 
 He opened our room. 
 It was long enough to need a semaphore to signal from one end to the other, dark enough so you would never have seen the flags, and so narrow we had to squeeze past  the single bed by the door to reach the open land before the next one. 
 It had just one redeeming feature. 
 It was cheap. 
 map: The European Arctic 
 Nathan moodily poked the bed, hiked down to the window and stared out at the night, then came back and sat on a seat in no-man's land. 
 &bquo;OK?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 A dumb question really. 
 he gave me a thin smile and shrugged. 
 It was not what he had in mind. 
 Nathan had just turned teenager and we were in North Wales for his birthday. 
 Being a lazy lad, much given to the idea of rising late when given half a chance, he had delayed his arrival in the world until 1 January. 
 It had been only a few hours, but that was enough to ensure that birthdays would always fall on public holidays and the correct number of hours could therefore be spent languishing. 
 We had languished yesterday. 
 Today we were in the Ogwen valley, in indifferent weather, wondering what to do. 
 A big peak was out of the question; it was a little too late, a little too wet and miserable. 
 It was a day for fingering duvets in Capel Curig or Betws, but Nathan, though difficult to start on cold mornings, was active once moving and would find that too dull. 
 We parked downhill from the cottage and ambled over to the top of the falls. 
 I started climbing down, without too much in mind, and Nathan followed. 
 We went down a hundred feet, perhaps a bit more. 
 We moved in closer to the stream and, attracted by something (though now I have no idea what) I went to the stream edge. 
 I ducked under a large rock and stepped forward. 
 Planting a booted foot securely on a rock in the stream, I stood up. 
 It is difficult to know what of the next few seconds I remember, or have pieced together, or have been told by Nathan. 
 I think I heard a loud, but muffled thump. 
 I do remember fighting to stay balanced on the rock and not  managing it, I do remember that when the world came back into focus I could not see out of my left eye. 
 The Polar Cathedral and Storskarfjell from Troms&oslash; 
 Nathan had watched while I went under the rock, had been surprised when I vigorously stood up and had stood transfixed as I gently pitched forwards off the rock. 
 Within seconds the blood from the gash that once been the left side of my head had poured all over the side of my face and filled up my left eye; so that was why I could not see. 
 He started to pour cold water over me, in part to staunch the blood, in part to revive me. 
 He got me out of the stream and a bit further back from the drop to our right. 
 He sat me down. 
 The wound bled enough to turn the semi-still pool in front of us red, but the cold water eventually stopped it. 
 Nathan helped me to my feet and very cautiously picked a way up through the boulders and small crags towards the road. 
 He led on the easy bits, followed and pushed on the worse sections. 
 We reached the road. 
 Nathan took my keys, brought the first aid kit from the car, and broke open some antiseptic wipes to attend to the cut. 
 Only when he had to stare straight into it did he flinch; it was not, his face said, a pretty sight. 
 He offered to drive the car, but I was not convinced that was a good idea. 
 He offered to stop someone, but I was feeling a bit better. 
 My head didn't hurt at all, although it did feel a bit light. 
 It was my neck that hurt. 
 I drove to the hospital in Bangor with Nathan watching the road intently and hanging on to the handbrake. 
 When they tried to take me away he explained, politely, that he was staying with me. 
 They shaved off my hair and sewed up my head. 
 The stuck needles in me and wheeled me in and out of X-ray rooms peering inside for evidence of the impacted fracture they were sure I had. 
 And through it all he stayed. 
 He was not saying much, but he was being there. 
 We agreed, after it was over &mdash; after the stitches (a large number) had been removed &mdash; that he had shown he was good enough now to go on a big trip. 
 He had stood in the queue at Heathrow, a very new Condor on his back, eyeing others who were obviously preparing to go to warmer places than we were. 
 He was a mountaineer. 
 The big boots, the gaudy anorak, the heavy rucsac. 
 This was definitely the way to live. 
 But not, he might now have added, if it meant staying in crumby hotels in places like Oslo. 
 I had needed to break our journey north int he capital to see someone in the tourist board's head office. 
 We could not do the trip in and out of the town in time to catch the last plane that evening, so we were condemned to this place and an early flight. 
 We dumped our kit and went out to find somewhere to eat. 
 Oslo is very much a capital city. 
 Go to the right places and there will be a big railway station or a billboard full of flickering neon lights. 
 It is pleasant in the port area, impressive near the castle, interesting at Bygd&oslash;y where the Viking ships are displayed on part of the large and excellent museum complex. 
 It is also, as with other capitals, impersonal, lonely and vaguely hostile. 
 There was the same combination that I had seen before:  collected in groups that seemed threatening because you were not part of them, and between these bright areas black, empty alleys full of odd forebodings. 
 Nathan Sale above Tromsdalen 
 Our search for something to eat led us up these darkly menacing alleys. 
 It was freezing &mdash; literally &mdash; so after a not-too-exhaustive search we settled for a place that was warm and, as it turned out, very good. 
 Nathan cheered up a touch when he had eaten his way through half the menu, and was even able to smile at the prospect of spending the night in our corridor-like room. 
 Sleep came to the distant noise of a ship's siren, blown once, but echoing, a long way off. 
 Breakfast was forgettable, but it didn't matter by then. 
 Nathan had not been on enough flights to be anything but excited, and he was going north of the Arctic Circle for the first time. 
 We took off on time, but we had unknowingly booked on to the milk run. 
 We stopped at Trondheim and Bod&oslash;, and then at Bardufoss. 
 On every leg they gave us a cheese roll and several cups of coffee, and by the time we took off for the third time we were wearing a rut in the carpet down the aisle to the tail-end gents. 
 The weather worsened the further north we went, and by the time we crossed the Circle it was snowing. 
 Nathan peered through the thick flakes at the wagon that serviced the plane at every stop. 
 It was always the same shape and size, built, it seemed, solely for the transportation of cheese rolls. 
 On its side, in Gothic letters, was written &bquo;Dog Bladder&equo; &mdash; a strange name. 
 What did they put in the coffee that made it such a diuretic? 
 A day or two later we were enlightened &mdash; Dagbladdet  is the name of the daily paper. 
 We took off on the last leg for Troms&oslash;. 
 The snow was falling thickly and poured past the window in blizzard proportions as the plane hurled itself into the Arctic night. 
 Nathan was awestruck with the audacity of it all, but when he turned to tell me how impressed he was I was asleep. 
 Nothing his old man did in the rest of the trip came close to commanding such respect as falling asleep during that take-off. 
 He saw it as indicating the travel weariness of the great adventurer. 
 In reality I was bored to distraction by the journey. 
 As we approached Troms&oslash; the snow grew thicker and Nathan asked, as casually as he could manage, whether they would clear the runway. 
 No, I told him, we'll land on the ice. 
 He gave me a pityingly look. 
 We taxied in close to the runway and were all pushed down the exit ladder to make a sprint for the terminal building; no automatic concertinaed walkways here. 
 We started out into the snow and stepped on to the ice-covered apron; that soon took the look off Nathan's face. 
 I was grateful when the rucsacs appeared on the carousel;  Troms7  was a full jacket cooler than Oslo had been. 
 Next day saw us in Tr&oslash;msdalen. 
 Nathan had not been prepared for the bus trip into and out of the town and the long walk through the snow to a campsite either. 
 But he had performed well. 
 The day dawned grey and cold, but the snow had stopped. 
 At this time of year, mid-Autumn, the snow has usually not arrived in Troms&oslash; and it is possible for you to have the hills to yourself in Tromsdalen or, better, in Lyngen, but this year there was already a metre of the stuff down at sea level. 
 During the days that followed our plans to backpack up into the hills had to be curtailed because of the weather, but to compensate there was the pleasure of watching Nathan explore the Arctic. 
 He edged down some unsafe planking in the harbour to poke his hand into the ocean and recoiled with the cold of it. 
 He peered into its depths amazed at the clarity. 
 He tried making snowballs as he had in Britain only to find that in these low temperatures he was left with a handful of flour-like snow that simply blew away when he threw it. 
 He looked for the pole Star on nights so intensely black that you almost had to touch your limbs to make sure they were still there. 
 He was staggered that he had to look almost straight up to find it. 
 We climbed Storskarfjell on a long and hard day that started before the sun came up and finished long after it had gone down. 
 It was memorable for the endless grind in one gully where the snow was waist-deep and we had to swim upwards, and for the point where we emerged on to the easterly ridge with views to Lyngen, and a wind that had bared the slopes and put our teeth on edge. 
 The plateau we crossed before the final pyramid was hostile, the snow wind-beaten to a hard, glittering crust that squeaked at the approach of our boots and then gave a satisfying crunch as we went through it. 
 We put on crampons for a steep section, Nathan all excitement at this new level of experience and commitment. 
 Then it was over, and with the end came that sense of anti-climax because tops are never as perfect as they should  be, nor the last few steps as brilliantly conceived or executed. 
 The view is never as good as it ought to be. 
 And you still have to go down. 
 Down was reversing the route until a bold decision to descend through trees was taken, a decision that in retrospect seemed debatable. 
 The maddening way-finding kept us interested, which did postpone the onset of real tiredness. 
 The way was down this slope, then crash through those low pine branches, then round the top of that steep bit, then over there &mdash; I think. 
 The coffee back at our base was good, the meal cooked from the sleeping bag the better for being so. 
 Tomorrow was another day. 
 We did our best in weather that got worse the longer we stayed. 
 One day's effort failed in a blizzard that was so thick route-finding became impossible. 
 We stopped and built a makeshift shelter to get away, as best we could, from snow that filtered its way through every opening to produce melt water that trickled coldly over us. 
 I made tea, my ungloved hand sticking to the Trangia when I tried to move it from its snowdrift. 
 The blizzard was worse now, and what little light made its way between the flakes was failing. 
 In a brief lull we moved quickly down to the river and followed it back down the valley. 
 On our last afternoon we went back to Troms&oslash; to see a man about a dog. 
 To be precise to see a man about a good number of sledge dogs. 
 That night we stayed in the town as our flight was too early the next day to get to the airport from the good country to the south. 
 We treated ourselves to a reindeer steak, then went for a last walk over the bridge towards the polar Cathedral. 
 The sky was clearer than it had been for a week, and massive, but hardly elegant, Storskarfjell stood out like a white tent. 
 Nathan kicked snow off the bridge, watching it explode in orange light as it swept past the navigation lights on the bridge supports. 
 Troms&oslash; was huddled and silent below and he took a long time over his last look.  
 ICELAND 
 In the strictest sense of the word Iceland is not a &bquo;Arctic&equo; country; the Circle nicks only the northern tip of the isle of Grimsey and so leaves the main island in a sub-Arctic no man's land. 
 The pilot of a plane Tony and I shared with a bunch of drunks en route  to Akureyri once told a very poor story. 
 No one in Iceland ever wanted to cross the Circle he said, except for one man, the vicar of Grimsey. 
 The Circle went through the middle of his bed, he told us, so he had a reason for crossing it every night. 
 But it was, as I said, a poor story and I won't trouble you with it. 
 Iceland has about forty per cent of the land area of the UK, but a population of only 250,000. 
 The great majority live in Reykjavik or a couple of towns close to it, and that leaves the country wonderfully bare, especially in the centre &mdash; what remains of the population is concentrated on the coast, where the chief occupations of fishing and farming are best practised. 
 The centre is vast and uninhabited. 
 It is also difficult for access. 
 The Icelandic road system is remarkable, with a continuous coastal road and numerous side roads, even if the majority are gravel rather than tarmac. 
 Each isolated farm has electricity, a newish car or two and is full of gadgets and gizmos. 
 The economics of the country are a disaster. 
 Iceland was discovered in the tenth century by Viking seafarers from the Scandinavian mainland. 
 The discoverer &mdash; reputedly Ingolfur Arnarson after whom a fine peak near &THORN;ingvellir and Ing&oacute;lfsh&ouml;fdi is named &mdash; called the country &bquo;Iceland&equo; because of the ice he found there; this created the first half-truth about the islands of the north. 
 Iceland is actually very green. 
 The next country to be discovered, Greenland, is actually very icy. 
 Even today   
 map &mdash; Iceland 
 Viking influence is deep-seated, especially in naming, where the old Norse method of patronymics is used. 
 A child's surname is the father's first name with son (for a boy) or d&oacute;ttir  (for a girl) added. 
 Our friend P&eacute;tur Bj&ouml;rnsson (P&eacute;tur, son of Bj&ouml;rn) has a lovely blonde daughter Marta, who speaks no English and talked to me all night when we were last there in a glorious mixture of Icelandic and sign language. 
 Her name is Marta P&eacute;tursd&ouml;ttir. 
 In a family of four, with a boy and a girl, there will be four different surnames. 
 The Icelanders have a fine attitude towards their country. 
 The majority of the population &mdash; which has one of the world's longest average life expectancies &mdash; are active in one or more outdoor activities, with walking and horse riding especially popular. 
 (Riding is a fine way of seeing the interior of the country, and the high-stepping Icelandic horses are tireless over the difficult terrain.) 
 This love for their land is refreshing &mdash; they consistently enthuse about their country rather than being swift to bad-mouth it &mdash; and it is also reflected in their desire to protect large areas from exploitation. 
 It is easy to assume that with so limited a population and tourists numbering a fraction of those who head for the sun, protection of the countryside is straightforward. 
 Still, there are some areas that are &bquo;better&equo; than others, and these need special care. 
 Iceland has, therefore, a surprisingly large number of National parks and nature reserves with regulations that must be observed by all visitors. 
 Each of these parks has its own appeal; Skaftafell and M&yacute;vatn are favourites, while &THORN;ingvellir is historically important. 
 The lesser-known areas are also very good &mdash; Herdubreid, around the very dangerous mountain of the same name and the Askja volcanic area; Hornstrandir at the extreme north-west tip, beyond Drangaj&ouml;kull, an area of superb walking and bird cliffs; and J&ouml;kuls&aacute;rglj&uacute;fur, to the east of Akureyri. 
 All air travel to Iceland is through Keflavik airport, about fifty kilometres from Reykjavik, a beautiful modern terminal, and one of very few where duty free is available on arrival. 
 Once in the country there is a good system of internal flights and buses.  
 SUMMER &mdash; NW ICELAND 
 Keflavik is one of the best air terminals in the world, an old plane hanging above the excellent facilities. 
 The journey to Reykjavik is not so good, and, although it is along a very reasonable road, it can be a bit daunting for the newcomer. 
 First you go past an array of AWACS planes, wondering whether you are actually allowed to see such things. 
 In the UK it is easy to form the impression that if you tried to get a closer look at something like this someone in a uniform would break both of your legs. 
 Beyond the planes you have the sea to the left, and to the right the surface of the moon an endless lava field with sharp brown rocks and occasional patches of greenery. 
 Desolation. 
 If you have a weak stomach you may wonder why you bothered to come at all. 
 I sat at the front of the coach, next to the driver. 
 He had a punk haircut and used his right knee to drive down the middle of the road. 
 His right hand caressed the gear stick while his left hand constantly fiddled with the knobs on the radio cassette, ensuring that the coach was flooded with, continuous stream of heavy metal. 
 Just as you were getting to like a track he would tune it out periodically, a vehicle would come the other way, its lights flashing furiously. 
 The punk would turn to me with a conspiratorial grin &mdash; hey, man, it's you and me against the world, eh? &mdash; then shift the bus across with his knee. 
 The furious lights would flash past and we would move into the middle again. 
 The coach dropped me at the Loflei&dstrok;3ir, a palatial hotel. 
 The closest I will ever come to staying there is when I pass through it to reach the stop for the buses into town. 
 My next flight is from Reykjavik airport. 
 Many a visitor has been embarrassed by the fact that Reykjavik airport is different from Keflavik. 
 I can see the town airport from where I am, indeed I can touch its tarmac with a digit thrust through the chain-link fence &mdash; all that separates it from the Loflei&dstrok;3ir &mdash; but to get from here to there is not so easy, and involves taking a bus into town and back out again or taking a taxi. 
 You could walk of course. 
 By fence climbing and tarmac crossing it is 400 metres to the terminal building; by the allowed route round it is five miles. 
 I take a taxi since my next flight leaves in an hour. 
 The taxi driver speaks no English and I spend a fraught moment or two wondering whether he has understood that I don't want to go to Keflavik, but after the shorter tour of Reykjavik we arrive. 
 I now discover that he speaks English numbers, as the bill is near perfectly pronounced. 
 for all that he has no words he then asks in the most eloquent and elegant way for a tip. 
 It is a really  virtuouso  performance &mdash; can I put the tip down on my tax form as &bquo;entertainment'? &mdash; and I am reminded of R2D2, the smaller robot in the Star Wars  films. 
 Although he only chirped, peedled and burped, he had the best lines in the film. 
 The next flight is northward, to &Iacute;safj&ouml;rdur, a rough ride, with the uplift over the highlands and the sea throwing the little plane about. 
 Across the aisle from me a young boy is telling his mother that he doesn't like it. 
 My Icelandic only runs to &bquo;coffee, please,&equo; but I can tell the essence of his story from the colour of his face. 
 His mother is less than willing to be involved, ignoring him in favour of the in-flight mag &mdash; an in-depth article on drainage ditch construction in the Middle East is far more interesting to her than her child's welfare. 
 At length the little lad grabs her sleeve and becomes insistent, and she is only just in time with the sick bag. 
 Pity, I thought after the performance, it might have done her good if he'd missed. 
 At journey's end she folded over the top of the bag and thoughtfully replaced it behind the netting on the back of the seat in front. 
 All in all I was glad she did not live next door to me. 
 The landing was one of the more memorable moments of my life. 
 The plane flew up the fjord, which seemed so narrow that the mountains were on both wing tips at the same time. 
 Having reached the end it went up on one wing, round through 180 &deg; in the space of fifty metres, and plummetted out of the sky on to the tarmac. 
 It was  an interesting airport, the first one I had visited where, in order to get the planes to land and take off, they have to go and shift the seals off the runway. 
 The town of Isafj&ouml;rdur is on the far side of the fjord, a long way from the town, and reached by a bus ride past the first fish-drying frame you will see in this part of the island. 
 But I was not going for a bus ride, I was looking for the gents. 
 Travelling with Nathan, my son, when he was young, we occasionally stopped at motorway service areas. 
 In the gents of these there would sometimes be those urinals &mdash; you know the ones, shaped like a maiden's hand &mdash; with one positioned for kids ten centimetres up the wall and not sixty centimetres up like the rest. 
 Nathan hated them because they implied that he was terribly little and when you are  terribly little you don't want the world to keep pointing it out to you at every opportunity. 
 He was really pleased when he graduated to the bigger ones. 
 At this airport the pottery was the same, but it was placed so high up the wall that I was on tiptoe and firing upwards. 
 I know that having a seventy-eight-centimetre leg makes me shorter than average, but Jesus. 
 I beat a heavy retreat: what I did not want to do was find out what the locals were like. 
 Men who could use these things comfortably would have to be three metres tall, and when they came I really didn't want to be there. 
 From Isafj&ouml;rdur the best way to explore Iceland's north-west is to jump on one of Ernir Air's mail planes. 
 Ernir has the contract to deliver the post and fly planes out every morning. 
 You get on and fly to somewhere that takes your fancy, the airline being quite willing to take the odd traveller with his rucsac. 
 Once off you walk over the mountains to the next town, and over again to another. 
 As soon as you have had enough you wait until the plane arrives, going on to newer ground or back for a return flight to the bright lights of Reykjavik. 
 It is an elegant way to travel, much better than waiting for the buses which, at this time of year, seem to come every other Tuesday. 
 Later, at Reykjavik, I was chatting to somebody, telling them about the Ernir flights. 
 Ah yes, they said, the man in charge up there is a legend for landing his plane in appalling conditions and absolutely ridiculous places. 
 Stories abound of his having landed on a handkerchief in blizzards in order to take people to hospital or to bring in desperately needed supplies. 
 I mentioned that the man I had spoken to had an old check suit and a limp. 
 That was almost certainly him, I was told. 
 Did he get the limp in a flying accident on one of his stupendous runs, I asked. 
 Oh, no, they said, He fell off the roof when retiling it. 
 When I arrived in &THORN;ingeyri I was expecting this, the second-biggest town in the area, to be a place worth seeing. 
 It had a church and a garage which sold Mars bars. 
 It had a handful of houses and that as &THORN;ingeyri. 
 Unimpressed, I went down to the edge of the fjord to find somewhere to camp. 
 Nearby the sea terns and eider ducks were nesting, the ducks beautifully camouflaged, sitting tight as long as they could, then moving quickly to reveal eggs of a gorgeous sage green looking so warm in their nest of breast feathers that it made me long for the comforts of my sleeping bag. 
 The eggs were not pure poetry though, and many of  them had lines and streaks of yellow duck shit across their smooth surfaces. 
 Footprints on Hattersdallfjall, north-west Iceland 
 I pitched the tent back from the sea, close to a river. 
 The view from my chosen balcony was superb. 
 Medadalur is wide and flanked by peaks that are proudly pointed. 
 The last of the winter snow was melting off the steep slopes, but the flatter areas and the passes still seemed to be well covered. 
 I decided to go for a walk westward along the side of the fjord. 
 So far it has been calm, but now the wind is picking up and white-topped grey waves move across the fjord. 
 The road goes through a small hamlet where there is a pond, a few square metres of tired water with a few pieces of rusty iron breaking its surface. 
 The land beside the pond looks tired too, the grass burnt by the frosts and ice of winter, the bare earth looking cold and wind-thrashed. 
 Two horses in a nearby field come towards me, curious about this thing in brightly coloured clothes. 
 Clearly there is little traffic on this road. 
 Further on two men on horses say &bquo;hello' to me and one of them, hearing my English reply, stops to talk. 
 He asks where I am going. 
 I tell him Dynjandi &mdash; the local name for the waterfall that most visitors to Iceland would recognise as Fjallfoss &mdash; and he thinks a little. 
 It is possible, he tells me, that the pass over the mountain to the falls will be open now, but he is not sure. 
 Certainly it was not open two days ago. 
 The weather this winter has been very harsh with a lot of snow and wind. 
 In view of the fact that I am walking this is somewhat academic, but it gives us a point of contact. 
 I ask if they know anything about the snowy owl. 
 When I arrived in the airport I had seen the local paper which reported the sighting of one near Isafj&ouml;rdur. 
 Yes, the man has heard about it. 
 It was sighted near Bolungarvik, the other side of Isafj&ouml;rdur from here, but, who knows? 
 These  birds fly far. 
 I ask if they are frequent visitors. 
 Oh no. 
 If they were that common they would not be on page one of the paper. 
 He laughs. 
 It is a fair point. 
 Me&dstrok;3adulur, north-west Iceland 
 We talk a little more, about the eider ducks and the weather, then the two men ride off. 
 They would look incongruous, like far-flung gouchos, were it not for their high-stepping Icelandic ponies. 
 They keep to the road and ride with amazingly straight backs. 
 I watch as they disappear down the road, then turn and walk through the hamlet which seems completely free of people. 
 Beyond, the road becomes pot-holed &mdash; it was only gravel at its best &mdash; as it continues to a headland where it is blocked by a rock fall. 
 I go up on to the headland where there are huge cliffs shot with crevices and water streams down the walls from melting snow. 
 The whole place is a shambles of falling rock, soft shaly rock, slaty rock; everything has been split apart by erosion. 
 It is an interesting place to stand and watch rocks falling; all the time I am there I hear them crashing down. 
 I am stopped by an unstable-looking scree slope. 
 When I walk on it the whole thing starts to move and I am soon covered in the grey dust I am stirring up; it fills my nostrils and triggers a memory that links the smell with rock climbing. 
 I recall a day when I was new to the sport and I recall too the smell when lightning struck the limestone cliff on which I was climbing. 
 Whether it is the memory of ancient insecurities, or the real threat of new ones I do not know, but I decide to go back. 
 Discretion would appear to be &bquo;the better part&equo;; about fifty to sixty metres down from me on the right are some very steep &mdash; probably vertical &mdash; cliffs falling the last thirteen to seventeen metres into the sea and I have no desire to ride an avalanche down. 
 Back at the tent it is getting late, so I set up the Trangia and cook myself a meal. 
 It feels cold: I had hoped for spring but what I am finding is winter. 
 I eat the meal inside the tent to get away from the wind, and even there I need an extra jacket. 
 The wind drops slightly as I am making myself another cup of tea and I like the idea of going out to watch the sun go down. 
 I take a camera and sit on the edge of the water. 
 A vee of geese goes over, one goose honking at the setting sun. 
 It is one in the morning before the sun finally disappears and I am left with twilight rather than lowlight. 
 I edge back to the tent, I feel lonely, desperately lonely, and it's not just being alone that is doing it. 
 It is many things &mdash; the lethargy of the travel, and all that space. 
 In one direction only a little earthy bank separates me from the edge of the ocean, while in the other the valley goes back for miles and miles. 
 It goes back for ever . 
 Once I catch a glimpse of the light of a car or maybe a tractor a long way up the valley, and this sees to make my isolation even more profound. 
 Most of the time this isolation is what I seek, but today I just feel lonely. 
 I make hot chocolate so that I can sleep more easily and as I sip it I am suddenly overcome with weariness. 
 I crawl into my sleeping bag and curl up in a tight ball. 
 When I wake the air is full of the sound of curlews. 
 It would be nice to see gyrfalcon and sea eagle, king eider and divers, but it is the sound of the curlew that is the call of the wild. 
 All the blues have gone away. 
 The morning is grey and windy, but I can see all the way up the valley. 
 I breakfast quickly, drinking several cups of tea, knowing that in this wind I need to avoid dehydration on the grind over the pass. 
 It takes a long time to reach Dynjandi, but the weather improves as the day wears on, leaving me with wonderful views across the Arnarfj&ouml;r&dstrok;3ur, its far peaks wreathed in clouds. 
 As the sun dips low the clouds bounce refracted red light off their bases. 
 it hurries across the sea towards me, in the way that only light can, making the water turn brown and pink, making its wave ends sparkle and flash. 
 At the water's edge snipe rise and trill, while on the valley side there are wheatears and redwings. 
 A quick search reveals one female redwing on a nest in the short scrubby beech-like bushes on the leeward side of a stream cutting. 
 Dynjandi is almost frozen at its sides, the light brilliantly reflected from the rivulets of snow and ice. 
 I sit near the fjord's edge and wonder whether to continue south towards Latrabjarg or whether to return north towards Drangaj&ouml;kull. 
 In the end the decision is made by the snowy owl. 
 I know it is unlikely that I will see it, but just the thought that I might is enough. 
 Next morning over breakfast I decide to go back into &THORN;ingeyri to catch a plane back to &Iacute;safj&ouml;&dstrok;3ur in the hope that I can get a boat or bus from there. 
 This means retracing my steps for a mile or so, but the country is wild and beautiful, full of new things to see. 
 I start up the hill towards D&yacute;rafj&ouml;&dstrok;3ur but before I reach the top I am treated to some Icelandic weather. 
 In this country they say that if you don't like the weather all you have to do is   wait five minutes and it will get better. 
 By the same token, if it is good you only have to wait five minutes and it will get worse. 
 A storm arrives from the west, the snow falling so thickly in a few minutes that I fear I will lose my way. 
 The temperature rises with the cloud cover, and the snow underfoot becomes wet and soft, making progress difficult and tiring. 
 I move to my left, knowing that there is a road there somewhere &mdash; it is always best to avoid roads, but it is even better to be able to see where you are. 
 The storm is terrible now, the snow thicker, the visibility worse. 
 I fall into the occasional thigh-deep drift and expend a great deal of effort in escaping. 
 Life is becoming bleak. 
 Eider duck next, D&yacute;rafj&ouml;dur, north-west Iceland 
 Red-necked phalarope, near H&ouml;fn 
 Harlequin duck, M&yacute;vatn 
 Eventually I reach the road and follow it to its top, surprised by how close I was to the summit of the pass. 
 At the top, just off to the left, is a hut, placed there, I assume, to help struggling people like me. 
 I gratefully go in. 
 There are candles and a gas cylinder. 
 It is a place to be warm, a place to be dry, a place to hang up my jacket and to pull faces at the storm outside. 
 I assemble my Trangia and cook food, avoiding the almost overwhelming temptation to use the gas cylinder. 
 Some day, someone will be in greater need than me. 
 The hut seems the ideal place to stay the night if the storm holds, but I am not sure if I am allowed to: it is full of instructions which are all written in Icelandic. 
 Next morning dawns bright and clear; the storm has blown itself out in the night. 
 Icelandic weather is really buggering me about, I decide, and conditions are now near perfect except for the metre of soft snow that lies over everything in sight. 
 I make it down to &THORN;ingeyri in time to hear the good news that the plane has gone. 
 No matter. 
 A local man offers to ferry me across the fjord and I am soon on the way to Holt. 
 There is no real news there of the owl, but someone suggests that I try the hills above N&uacute;pur where there has been much activity lately. 
 &bquo;Activity' seems to be one car &mdash; all I see as I meander my way through the hills above the lonely hamlet of N&uacute;pur. beyond it is the biggest fish-drying frame I have so far seen, with overflow fish hung on a wire fence alongside. 
 Some of these have fallen off and are blowing around, suffering, it would appear, from a tragic case of neglect. 
 I put one or two out of their misery by introducing them to a cup of coffee and my insides, not necessarily in that order. 
 It is like eating cardboard, and tastes about as good. 
 In the hills that side a long valley on the way to S&aelig;bol there is another emergency hut. 
 I contemplate a hut-to-hut tour of north-west Iceland. 
 Outside this one there is a lone snow bunting pecking mournfully at a muddy patch of shingle that is all that shows through the snow. 
 The bunting is the only bird I see all day. 
 By nightfall I am fed up with the search and determined to leave tomorrow for at least one day on Drangaj&ouml;kull. 
 Starting early, I traverse the long ridge of hills that separates me from Isafj&ouml;rdur, arriving late in the afternoon. 
 The road from the town that goes east towards Drangaj&ouml;kull has collapsed and no buses or lorries can get through. 
 I try for a boat. 
 Fraganes , a good way of getting to the more remote spots &mdash; it makes an eleven-hour round trip regularly, several times each week &mdash; &mdash; has gone, and no one is going my way. 
 I stay local for a night, then climb the ridge above the far side of the fjord, making for Hest&ouml;fjordur and a view of the big glacier. 
 Snow conditions are perfect, and so is the view to Drangaj&ouml;kull. 
 On Hestfj&ouml;rdur a diver &mdash; &mdash; probably Great Northern &mdash; sculls away across the water as I approach. 
 It is not enough to make me forget that the owl remains elsewhere.   
 Fish drying, Flateyri, north-west Iceland 
 THE TOURIST ROUND 
 The bus that goes east from Reykjavik can be used to visit the better-known and most important sites. 
 But before you go that way &mdash; real joy lies at the end of each bus trip to the east -it is compulsory, or so you might think, to visit &THORN;ingvellir. 
 The site has a special significance for Icelanders, whose independence has been compromised on several occasions over the years. 
 In World War II there were Allied landings here. 
 The Icelanders protested, not because they supported the cause of Facisim or German expansion &mdash; given the choice they would doubtless have stood with the Norwegians, fellow Vikings &mdash; but because they were not asked to choose. 
 The Allies arrived one day by boat and threatened dire consequences if their wishes did not rapidly become the law of the land. 
 Today there is a US air base at Keflavik. 
 Indeed, until recently the flight that took you to Iceland landed at the base itself rather than on &bquo;real' Icelandic soil. 
 Go any day to the Blue Lagoon, a  curious place of billowing steam clouds and science-fiction B-movie film-set machinery, and the place will be filled with Americans, all of them covered in sulphur when they emerge. 
 The Icelandic attitude to the new usurpers is ambivalent. 
 &bquo;Not sure that I want the Americans, fairly certain I want their dollars.' 
 To a people with such a tenuous hold on real freedom &mdash; one puff at the fish export market from the US would blow Iceland away &mdash; roots are important. 
 Therefore &THORN;ingvellir is important. 
 It is the site of the oldest parliament in the world. 
 Iceland was a democracy while white Americans were still Poles or Irish, still several dozens of generations from crossing the Atlantic. 
 (Isn't it even the case that it was an Icelandic Viking who discovered America? 
 And isn't it also true that he kept fairly quiet about it?) &THORN;ingvellir is a curious place. 
 What the tourists come to see is a raised dais of grass hemmed in by a retaining wall. 
 Behind, a stiff Icelandic flag waves in the breeze. 
 As a thrilling spectacle it has little to offer, but as a powerful totem it is almost unique in its place in European and western culture. 
 Site of the world's oldest parliament, &THORN;ingvellir 
 To reach the dais from the windswept coach park the tourists file down a narrow gorge before negotiating a series of ladders and bridges. 
 Few of those disgorged from the solitary coach on the day that we were there noticed the gorge, yet it is spectacular in a way that the dais is not; a volcanic fissure and a geological feature of startling proportions and beauty. 
 If you follow it along from the historical site it leads you to a perfect waterfall, and then to a point where flat grass lies between the vertical gorge sides. 
 The walls here can be negotiated for a view of the Icelandic interior &mdash; &mdash; stunning wildness and extent. 
 We travelled east on a fine, clear morning, heading towards Gullfoss, the golden waterfall. 
 The first Arctic fox I had ever seen watched me as I arrived at Gullfoss late at night, then turned and headed off with its huge tail laid out behind it. 
 The waterfall takes your breath away when first you see it. 
 Its vast volume of water pours into a huge cleft in the earth that is thirty-three, metres deep and in some places only thirty-three metres wide; a long, parallel-sided cleft that becomes a gorge or even a canyon. 
 The river that makes the falls runs down towards us, hitting the cleft at right-angles. first there is a series of rapids where beautiful mists of water hang above white horses that gallop over rocks, then the water disappears into the cleft. 
 The spray from the falls is so dense that you cannot peer into it and you must rely on logic to believe that it is the same water that makes the river that snakes along the gorge a few hundred metres away. 
 In the spray perpetual rainbows are fixed in position as though their unseen feet were nailed to the base of the cleft. 
 Tony and I were alone at Gullfoss. 
 Alone, and exhilarated by the noise, the spray and the view &mdash; &mdash; and also by the fact that we were not ankle-deep in wrinkled cans and other crap, or being persuaded to buy Gullfossburgers by bright neon signs. 
 Nothing was there to compete with this wonder of the natural world. 
 We camped upriver from the falls, stalling the leap into the chasm of some of the water by boiling it on the Trangia and making it into Earl Grey tea. 
 I did not sleep well that night: it had been a great day and the call of the wild kept me nervous and excited. 
 Tony, most unusually, was already up and hard at work with his camera when I emerged  to sniff the morning air. 
 the sky was a beautiful blue, the sun in just the right position for the rainbows to come out of the cleft in exactly the right position photographically. 
 I made tea for him as he worked, watching a vee of geese heading for the interior as the kettle boiled. 
 For three hours we worked and drank, worked and ate, worked and packed. 
 And in all of that time we had Gullfoss to ourselves. 
 Gullfoss &mdash; a detail of the centre of the falls 
 Geysir is more what the tourist from Western Europe, or America &mdash; is used to, with its hotel and constructed pathways. 
 Yet for all it is more visitor-orientated it really is very low-key. 
 The hotel is elegant and modern, but it does not have a bolted-on section where you can buy spoons with &bquo;Present from Geysir&equo; written on them. 
 There is a garage/caf&eacute; where souvenirs of a kind can be bought but only a very good marketing man could   come up with something stunning from a spot where most of the time nothing is happening. 
 Gullfoss in winter 
 Gullfoss in summer 
 The constructed path is to help keep visitors off the basalt pavements which are delicate and fragile, taking aeons to create and seconds to destroy. 
 Follow it &mdash; it is an Orange Brick Road, which proves how close you can come to a real advertising coup without quite getting it right: I wonder if the caf&eacute; serves 6-Up &mdash; and it will lead you to the Great Geysir. 
 This is the daddy of all geysirs, the one that gave its name to the (now better-known) hot-water spouts elsewhere in the world. 
 Sadly, it no longer spouts, or if it does it has a frequency measured in years. 
 Interest lies with its small brother, Strokkur . 
 This does erupt, but not to a defined time schedule. 
 Stand close and you can watch the hot water of last time's spray pouring back into the spout hole. 
 The whole area, a thicker, stronger basalt pavement, is funnel-shaped and the water pours back into the central hole that has been emptied to a depth of three or more metres. 
 I am not precise on depth because there is no great temptation to hang over the hole and peer down. 
 When the water has almost filled the hole, to perhaps a foot or so below the top, there is an audible pause in the proceedings. 
 The water level drops and then, woosh , up it all comes, first rising like a column &mdash; at this stage it looks like a vaguely blue shaggy ink cap toadstool &mdash; then blasting itself apart in a flourish of steam. 
 Stand close enough to see the column form and you will probably be pelted with near-boiling water. 
 Other than Strokkur  the Geysir site is a little disappointing. 
 There are bubbling pools and mud that goes gloop  but there is nothing to compare with Kr&iacute;suv&iacute;k or Hverager&dstrok;3i. 
 Kr&iacute;suv&iacute;k is south and slightly west of Reykjavik, reached by a road across a beautiful lava field and through valleys that are almost civilized, or by a fine walk that takes these valleys and continues along a ridge above the bird-filled lake of Kle&iacute;farvatn. 
 The Kr&iacute;suv&iacute;k pools are not signed, either on the road or when you get there. 
 If you do not know they are there, or if you do not know where they are, you will miss them. 
 The site offers only one clue &mdash; a continuously blowing steam hole that in the right weather is visible from the road. 
 You will be alone when you arrive, almost certainly. 
 Duck boards will take you past a hot waterfall towards the blow hole. 
 Pass on the windward side if you don't want a hot bath, and you will reach an area of incredible beauty. 
 Sulphur and soil have combined to produce colours of Van Goghian purity. 
 Things go hiss and glug . 
 At one point a whole area steams gently so that the visitor can view the sun through a vapoury haze. 
 By contrast, Hverager&dstrok;3i &mdash; &bquo;Hurdy Gurdy Land' to Tony and I, as the real pronunciation is a jawbreaker &mdash; is an upper-class thermal area. 
 Genteel pools of startling transparency lie quietly amid small, measured, tidy heaps of yellow and orange soils. 
 Mud pools wait until you are looking the other way before plopping discreetly. 
 I felt that if I looked back early the mud pool would blush and say &bquo;pardon&equo;. 
 A pipeline meanders among the springs, collecting steam for distribution to rows of neat houses. 
 Iceland's horticultural college is here, the steam heating its greenhouses. 
 The tourist literature speaks of banana trees, but the singular of the noun &bquo;tree&equo; would be better employed. 
 It is certainly not a good idea to arrive hoping to fill a basket, or even a hand (unless you know an employee) with greenhouse fruit. 
 Beyond Geysir there is lazy travelling. 
 In Selfoss the assistant in the chemist's tries to sell us surgical spirit when we ask for meths and there is a pantomime while Tony explains to her, in best sign language, that what he wants is spirit for a Trangia. 
 Watching him perform is like watching charades. 
 Two words. 
 The whole thing. 
 You want to pour it? 
 No, no. 
 You want to rub it on your buttocks? 
 No. 
 Sounds like&hellip; 
 I am reminded of the time when we were leaving Italy after a while in the Dolomites and spent all our Italian cash in the last caf&eacute; making a phone call, only to find that the caf&eacute; owner was adding a surcharge to the bill. 
 She wanted another 35p (about two hundred million lire) and was insistent. 
 One lad with us, a genuine Cockney, finished up by explaining to this (probably normally) mild-mannered Italian who spoke no English at all that we couldn't pay because we were &bquo;borassic&equo;. 
 I remember thinking that use of rhyming slang was going to help clear matters up in no time. 
 The assistant fetched a man from the back &mdash; please can I see the male assistant to explain what I want? &mdash; who nodded gravely. 
 Raudspirit , he said. 
 Seljalandsfoss is a ponytail of a waterfall throwing itself clear of the rim of its cliff to look like a 1950s American college girl shaking her head. 
 for just that reason Seljalandsfoss is best viewed from the side, unlike most other waterfalls. 
 Sk&oacute;gafoss is a sixty-seven metre monster, so wide and so tall,  and so much falling in a single sweep that clouds of spray are produced. 
 Tony sends me forward into the spray. 
 It will make a lovely picture he yells at me above the crashing noise. 
 I go forward, reluctantly. 
 Periodically I pause and look back. 
 Each time he waves me forward. 
 It is, he assures me when I get back, a really good shot. 
 I am delighted for him. 
 I am also wet through. 
 Beyond the big waterfall is a desert of black sand, then lava fields, the black and red-brown lumps dotted with a whitish lichen, then another lava field where the lichenous moss is bright green. 
 The moss looks soft and springy, like the moss of the UK, but is hard and rough and dry like tinder. 
 We camped in the official site at Skaftafell. 
 The thought of doing so appalled us, but there are regulations. 
 We are aware that those who follow us may be judged by our behaviour, and exploration of wilderness areas brings responsibilities as well as pleasures. 
 As we erected the tent Tony became wistful again. 
 Many years ago Tony came to Iceland as a raw teenage cyclist. 
 While I came to the Arctic when I realized that climbing, my first love, was losing its appeal, Tony was born to the area, loving it, one might believe, even before he saw his first photograph of it. 
 His trip here was a homecoming, and there were times when I could see in his eyes that he was reliving his first memories. 
 That first trip was a bold move. 
 The Cod War  was less than popular. 
 To get over the problem he sometimes insisted that he was Welsh, claiming that the Welsh disliked the English as much as the Icelanders. 
 It doesn't sound like much of a cover story to me, and I prefer the idea that the locals thought Tony was just an eccentric who should not be allowed near sharp objects. 
 At the time of his trip he was such a novelty that he was featured in several Reykjavik newspapers, and treated with great hospitality wherever he went. 
 He even managed to bring a touch of real culture to the island, having arrived with tea (leaves not  bags) and a teapot. 
 He told me the story again as we sat in the campsite in Skaftafell. 
 Then he told me about his climb up Iceland's highest mountain. 
 Sk&oacute;gafoss 
 My first view of Hvannadalshn&uacute;kur was from the plane as I flew into H&ouml;fn from Reykjavik. 
 In those days the final link in the Iceland circle road had not been made and I needed a plane, bound for Fagurh&oacute;lsm&yacute;ri, to reach the National park. 
 I arrived at Skaftafell to find several groups of campers, all wild-eyed outdoor types, I suppose not unlike me. 
 It was nice to be with others; I had just had three weeks on my tod with company only in Reykjavik campsite. 
 The only other official  site I used was in Isafj&ouml;rdur but in the first week of June, at minus five degrees, I had been alone. 
 Strokkur erupting, Geysir 
 Strokkur, Geysir 
 The other campers were good company and we all had a good laugh. 
 &bquo;Would you like to join us on a walk?&equo; they asked. 
 The casual conversation turned to panic on my part. 
 &bquo;We're going up Hvannadalshn&uacute;kur&hellip;&equo; 
 I had never been on a glacier before. 
 Could I make it? 
 It was nearly 2,200 metres and from sea level. 
 Ben Nevis was a long drag; Snowdon is less than half the height and there you cheat by starting at 300 metres. 
 And, unlike cycling, there is no freewheeling downhill. 
 Was I fit enough? 
 Would my cycling shoes grip on the ice? 
 So many questions flashed through my mind. 
 What am I to do? 
 But, yes, I was fit-I had, after all, cycled 22,500 kilometres last year and had walked the Pennine Way the year before. 
 Anyway, what the hell? 
 This was the chance of a lifetime. 
 Before I could think any more my mouth had decided. 
 I was going. 
 That afternoon I went to the caf&eacute; at Fagurh&oacute;lsm&yacute;ri and bought a pair of Tuf workman boots. 
 They didn't have my size but they would be OK. 
 They would have to be OK. 
 I was going to make it. 
 The others had paid a lot of money to go on this guided trip. 
 Their package included walks around the Skaftafell area and, should the weather allow,  a climb of Hvannadalshn&uacute;kur. 
 After five days' walking they were obviously all fit and experienced. 
 They were a group of twelve, mainly Icelandic, but with two Norwegians and a Canadian, and now joined by an English cyclist who pretended, when convenient, to be Welsh, The intended route was up the south-west side of the &Ouml;r&aelig;faj&ouml;kull, the glacier being climbed during the night, although in June the sun only barely dips below the northern horizon at midnight. 
 Even so, I was assured, the sun being low and behind the mountains would allow a firm crust to develop on top of the snow; there is nothing worse than deep, soft, wet snow. 
 We left the campsite at ten in the evening, the party reduced because a few thought they wouldn't make it, in a bus rescued from a St Trinians film set. 
 Although Iceland had changed some years before to driving on the right, the bus which was well past its sell-by date &mdash; was right-hand drive; the first bit of England I had seen for three weeks. 
 Thankfully we left it behind at Sandfell, a small isolated ruin about half-way down the road to Hof. 
 Our guide was there to meet us, his silver hair outshone only by the enormity of his rucsac containing about twenty-five flags on long poles. 
 Were we marking out a soccer pitch? 
 I had never been walking with flags before. 
 This was more power for the cause &mdash; these people use tea bags and drive on the wrong side of the road, they hang fish on clothes lines and then eat them dry. 
 Hot water pool, Hverager&dstrok;3i 
 Descending from the summit of Hvannadalsh&uacute;kur 
 The climb to the snowline was not pleasant, and I was haunted by memories of the boredom of Ben Nevis's path, even though here there was no path. 
 Neither was there Wendy, a girl in my form (it had been a school trip) who had legs that never quit, long legs, the type rampant fell men dream of. 
 She made the ascent of Nevis a pleasure, but now I was grown up and Wendyless. 
 I had also become a cyclist. 
 I remembered again why I preferred my bike: when you are shattered you can get off and walk. 
 Here I was shattered and there was no alternative. 
 Rocks splintered by centuries of cyclic thaws crumbled under my boots. 
 Our way was up to one of the few glacier tongues that wasn't too steep and broken up by crevasses. 
 &bquo;If we climb high on the rock we can then drop to flatter ice.&equo; 
 How I longed for this, inspired by the word &bquo;flatter.&equo; 
 I hate steep, relentless climbs, especially at two in the morning in low cloud. 
 Two young lads from Hafnarfj&ouml;dur, a small fishing village near Reykjavik, were going like loonies. 
 I decided to keep a low profile, after all I was a guest. 
 And I hadn't paid. 
 Anyway, I could go no faster, being the slow-starter, long-distance plodder type. 
 Helgi, the guide, laughed at them. 
 &bquo;You watch them tire,&equo; he said to me, &bquo;those youngsters can't pace themselves. 
 It is a long, long way.&equo; 
 Well thank you Helgi for those words of encouragement. 
 And why was he confiding this dire information to me? 
 Couldn't he see I was knackered? 
 The ice eventually came, small snow fields at first leading to the vastness of the great glacier. pleasure was dawning and so was the sun. 
 The snow, hard snow, was easy to walk on. 
 The slopes were gentle and convex like the outer optic of a huge fish-eye lens. 
 The sun rose magnificently over one of these slopes, warm hues glistening off the windswept, spiky blue ice. 
 Being anchor man, the one at the back of the rope, and because we were walking directly into the sun, I delighted in the shadows of those in front. 
 The light danced about, we were above the thin cloud line and suddenly my pains had gone. 
 Oh, how I love the light. 
 Am I all there? 
 Why am I moved by such simple things? 
 The obvious was now explained. 
 Helgi dumped the flags and revealed all &mdash; he had some farming to do and was going back! 
 Was this guy real? 
 A guide that didn't. 
 He insisted it was simple &mdash; go in that direction and plant the flags at regular intervals. 
 If the wind blows and snow fills your footprints the safe way between the crevasses will be lost. 
 The flags they tell you where to go, you see? 
 OK? 
 He left, and we were left confused. 
 The morning sun compensated for our loss by offering inspiration. 
 The Icelanders had seen precious little sun that summer and peeling noses were instant and plentiful. 
 Handkerchiefs held in place by the nose clips of sunglasses alleviated some of the worst effects but the speed of burning was staggering. 
 For me it was paradise; I was already brown. 
 Glacier walking is a piece of cake; well this bit was, with rolling hills of dazzling serenity. 
 Crevasses were walked around or jumped over, and those of any size were given respectful avoidance. 
 Wow, I was enjoying this. 
 It was not comparable to cycling, in fact it was so different that comparison was a nonsense. 
 The youngsters were also enthusiastic, but tiring, their antics and extreme youth catching up on them. 
 To help I now  had three rucsacs on my back. 
 I am not really a hero, they were only small daysacks, but my fitness surprised me. 
 Mars bars, a rip-off at three times the UK price, taken at regular intervals, got us there. 
 The final peak stands quite proud of the regular ice and we pondered the way up. 
 Large caves guarded by huge icicles, some fifteen feet tall, sheltered us from the wind as we ate lunch and did some more pondering. 
 Without an ice axe and with only borrowed instep crampons my climbing ability was somewhat limited, and this was not the place to take risks. 
 But who could get this far and not just push it a little bit? 
 So, still roped from the crevasse fields, we gingerly crawled to the top. 
 The clouds that were with us on the climb had gone, opening the way to spectacular views, views helped by the air being free of dust and haze. 
 There were views to the sea, views west towards Reykjavik, in fact views in every direction, as long as it was down. 
 I was on top of the world. 
 The Selfoss chemist's raudspirit  was awful. 
 It spat a worrisome mixture of steam and flame out periodically and covered the bottom of the pans with black ooze, a treacly goo that got itself on to my pile jacket and put me in good humour for an hour or so. 
 I washed the jacket. 
 Overnight there was a frost and it went hard and crinkly. 
 Tony offered to make breakfast, an event so rare that there was a chance parliament would reconvene at &THORN;ingvellir. 
 He manufactured a concoction of such awesome vileness that it defies, even now, reasonable description. 
 It bore a marked resemblance to something that had already been eaten once before. 
 I made an excuse and settled for tea and muesli. 
 Tony went back to his past trip again, this time concentrating on the visual aspects of an air stewardess. 
 The memory was triggered by talk of a young woman I had met on one trip who showed me Dyrh&oacute;l&aelig;y and the sea pinnacles of Reynisdrangar near Vik. 
 She was at pains to tell me &mdash; several times &mdash; that her male friends were divided into two groups. 
 There were &bquo;friends&equo;, with a small &bquo;f&equo;, people, like me, whose company was interesting and pleasant but who were just casual acquaintances. 
 Then there were &bquo;friends&equo; with a big &bquo;F&equo; who were lovers. 
 I had been greatly amused, although I think I should not have been. 
 Tony was equally amused at the story, and wondered whether there was a third group, too, of &bquo;FRIENDS&equo; with a big &bquo;F&equo;, big &bquo;R&equo;, big &bquo;I&equo; and big &bquo;ENDS&equo;. 
 Our trip had been timed to coincide with nesting, although the birds were confused by the late spring and many had not yet started to build. 
 Nevertheless, on such a good day we decided to visit Ing&oacute;lfsh&ouml;fdi. 
 We gratefully accepted a lift to the nearby village of Fag&uacute;rholsm&yacute;ri. 
 Tony assured me that there was a supermarket in the village, which seemed unlikely in a place that had less than ten houses, but turned out to be almost true &mdash; &mdash; the garage sold bits and pieces. 
 As he said (and not for the first time), you can't beat a bit of local knowledge. 
 We had a coffee, bought some reinforcements, deciding to leave the skyr  that we had both become addicted to until later, turned south and headed for the sea. 
 Ing&oacute;lfsh&ouml;fdi is an island about six or seven kilometres off-shore, but separated from the mainland by a saltwater lagoon rather than by open sea. 
 Between us and the lagoon a number of rivers made their way seaward. 
 As we crossed ground that became increasingly boggy, the vegetation increasingly salt-spattered and sparse, Tony began to enthuse on the likelihood of our seeing geese and red-necked phalaropes. 
 I was more interested in how we were going to reach the sea, and in how we were going to cross it. 
 The reaching was straightforward enough: at the first river we took off our boots, rolled up our trousers to mid-thigh and, dividing about thirty kilograms of photographic and emergency equipment between us, waded across. 
 It was icy-cold, and soon numbed both feet and legs into submission. 
 By the time we had crossed two more we had decided to stop drying our feet and re-booting after each one, and set off across the bogs in bare feet. 
 We saw no phalaropes, but did find, quite by chance, the nest of a pink-footed goose. 
 The goose was sitting on eggs and flew off as we approached. 
 That worried us as there were several great skuas working the sky above the bog, and we spent some time waiting for the goose to return before setting off again. 
 The sea lagoon turned out to vary in depth from a few inches to a couple of feet. 
 Beneath the water the sand was, not surprisingly, the sinking, knackering type. 
 Mid-way, after a long, hard time, we stopped for a rest &mdash; at least, as much of a rest as you can get standing in knee-deep water unable to put down your rucsac. 
 Ultimately we escaped the cold, sticky grasp of sand   and sea, only to be faced by three miles of sand on its own. 
 The sand was not golden-brown and sun-kissed. 
 This being Iceland it was black, jet-black weathered lava, and was kissed only by a light breeze coming off the glacier. 
 As it is occasionally covered by the sea this sand is not compact so that at times we could walk fairly comfortably, but at other times we sank in unexpectedly, which broke up our rhythm and made us tired and frustrated. 
 Finally, after a desert journey of Lawrencian proportions &mdash; or so it seemed &mdash; we reached the base of Ing&oacute;lfsh&ouml;fdi. 
 En route to Ing&oacute;lfsh&ouml;f&dstrok;3i 
 Puffin, Ing&oacute;lsh&ouml;f&dstrok;3i 
 Ptarmigan, M&yacute;vatn 
 The island, in truth little more than a detached headland, is about seventy metres high, and progress on to it is by way of one of many gullies filled with sand. 
 This sand was dry, but climbing a 70-metre high-angled sand dune is not easy. 
 In fact it is downright unfriendly and I was very pleased to be at the top. 
 Pleased, that is, until I discovered that I had forgotten to bring the tea bags &mdash; the subsequent &bquo;Well, why didn't you bring them then's, &bquo;Why is it always my fault's reminded me of the Quentin Crisp line that marriage was impossible for him because he could not have tolerated an endless succession of mornings when the first words he heard were, &bquo;And another thing&equo; &mdash; and that there were no birds. 
 I lug the kitchen sink and assorted extras &mdash; but no tea bags, Tony points out &mdash; to this island to look at birds and what do I find? 
 And so on. 
 We crossed to the seaward, as opposed to the lagoonward side, where there are 70-metre cliffs. 
 Interestingly, it was not, as is usual, the noise that told us we were approaching a large nesting cliff, but an almost overpowering smell of guano . 
 The cliff on Ing&oacute;lfsh&ouml;f&dstrok;3i is the only sea cliff for miles. 
 There are several inland cliffs, but these are too far from the sea for auks and gulls, and so the whole, and large, sea bird population of this part of Iceland is concentrated on to this one cliff. 
 The result is that every ledge, from those that would take a small tent to those that a modern rock  climber would blanch to see, is packed with birds. 
 To add to this confusion the steep-angled grass above is riddled with puffin burrows; later in our stay we found that attempts to move tripods closer to the edge put us in real danger of disappearing downwards, compete with the odd half-acre of apparently stable cliff top. 
 The black sand beach, Ing&oacute;fsh&ouml;f&dstrok;3i 
 The sun came out and it grew warm on this sheltered side of the island. 
 We had been led to expect all the guillemots, but there were no black guillemots either on the ledges or in the sea. 
 There were commons, some of them bridled, and there were also Br&uuml;nnich's. 
 There were plenty of kittiwakes, but on closer inspection some of them turned out to be Icelandic gulls. 
 We saw no razorbills, which was a surprise, and the few little auks we saw were all out on the water, but the puffins made up for the loss. 
 Never before have I seen puffins that are so red, so yellow, so black. 
 In the high-angled sun the feet of some reflected the light so that their breasts appeared red too. 
 We put Tony's tripod close to the cliff edge, wishing that we had a rope when each of us fell into unexpected crevasses in the cliff-top grass. 
 I retreated to leave the master to it and lay happily in the sun. 
 It really was difficult to believe that we could be so far north. 
 Surely this must be the UK &mdash; kittiwakes, puffins and guillemots. 
 And that small bird there must be a&hellip; snow bunting. 
 It was a pair, in fact, doing a little late courting, and then, just to push the point home, a great skua floated into sight. 
 Tony finished his work and we set off back towards the sea. 
 I went a little ahead, drawn towards a huge black sand dune on the island's top. 
 The dune offered the definitive photograph of Iceland, its top an absolutely flawless surface of jet-black lava sand and, behind it, Vatnaj&ouml;kull, even bigger, and glowing white and pink in the evening sun. 
 So taken was I with this vision of perfect Iceland that I did not realise that I had walked into a skua colony, not, that is, until one fearless great skua hit me. 
 Whatever he hit me with, feet or wings, it hurt and almost knocked me off balance. 
 For as long as it took me to get out of range, several birds used me for bombing practice, coming so close on occasions that ducking was a necessity rather than a flamboyant gesture. 
 Tony enjoyed it all hugely. 
 After that there was just the gully to descend, the sinking sand to cross, the sea to wade and the bog to hop. 
 As we hopped we saw grey phalaropes, inquisitive little birds seemingly unbothered by our presence, happily showing themselves now that there was insufficient light to film them. 
 After a night during which vengeful wind pushed rain through flysheet and tent, spraying our sleeping bags, we were joined by Ann and John, friends of Tony. 
 Their chief interest was in walking rather than in birds, so we compromised with a day that started near Svartifoss, a waterfall that tumbles between black basalt columns. 
 Beyond, the ground became awkwardly mixed. 
 At first there was semi-cultivated land covered with tufted grass. 
 The rusting remains of an old piece of farm machinery were evidence of some Icelander breaking his back to extract a living from the land. 
 And, it would seem, failing. 
 There is an area where the micro-ecology changes rapidly, so that almost with every pace there is new vegetation clinging precariously to the spare soil. 
 Then there is that saturated semi-peat that is often underfoot in the island, especially on the middle ground. 
 Here, though, even the higher ground was wet, so that the difficulty of making progress barely relented until we reached the snow. 
 There had been no real objective, except a vague idea that if conditions were good Hvannadalshn&uacute;kur might as well be climbed. 
 But we were barely half-way before clouds crept down the high peaks to threaten us with rain or sleet. 
 The temperature rose a little and the snow became impossible; at every step we had to haul our legs out of deep holes. 
 We stopped. 
 from here Skeidar&aacute;rsandur, an unusual feature when seen from ground level, becomes even more extraordinary. 
 There are square miles of shifting, sinking sand where the normally clean-cut edge between sea and land has become blurred. 
 In the opposite direction, above us and to the left, was a high serac-edged glacial wall with, far below it, a run-out &mdash; a broad, lethargic river the colour of putty. 
 We retreated, crossing a ridge of the mountain to reach a glacial tongue of &Ouml;raf&aelig;j&ouml;kull. 
 From far above the glacier looked like modern art, a canvas of grey-white curiously etched with black lines that appeared random at first sight, but in which a symmetry could at length be discerned. 
 We used the tongue in its lower reaches, where it licked land close to the edge of the Skaftafell site. 
 For our latest companions this was a new experience, but the glacier was benign and they were confident, unhurried walkers who found pleasure rather than  because of the crevasses or steep, unstable cliffs. 
 Here the problem was the muck. 
 All glaciers are dirty where they end with that sticky paste of ground-up rock. 
 But this was dreadful, threatening to cover everything and to get inside it too. 
 We were pleased to reach the river and the ground beyond. 
 On the way to the camp we passed a boulder where Tony and I competed for rock climbing idiot of the evening. 
 Tony jumped from high up, landed heavily and pulled a face. 
 In the years we have been going to the Arctic (at least one summer and one winter trip now for as long as I can remember), we have acquired odd niggles. 
 Each of us carries an unreliable ankle for instance, and Tony had just given his a jolt. 
 He eased it back to the site. 
 When morning came he was in pain and not best pleased. 
 An easy day was called for, using the new car &mdash; what luxury! &mdash; to visit the northern hemisphere's largest great skua colony. 
 I tried to cheer him up with memories of the last time his ankle was hurting, when we slept in a sheep herder's cave &mdash; lined with graffiti that was centuries old &mdash; on the way from Landmannalaugar to the coast near Vik. 
 The country in the south had been really weird, with mushrooms of crumbling lava and wide flat rivers to cross, and it had rained for days, which had added to the general air of unreality as these features kept emerging from the mist. 
 He did not respond. 
 The skua colony turned out to be impressive, with few eggs but a host of great and Arctic skuas all intent on protecting their chosen nest site at all costs. 
 Such dedication was admirable, as was the aerial ability of the birds, which wheeled and dived, pulled up over our heads, wheeled and dived again. 
 Tony limped along with his tripod sticking two feet out of the top of his rucsac to protect his head. 
 We left the birds in peace, moving on to a river and lake site that offered Tony better angles for his camera. 
 He was finding walking a chore so we left him, following the river inland towards its glacial snout source. 
 We searched for kilometres &mdash; it seemed &mdash; to find a crossing point, eventually reaching a lake and being forced to cross at a place that was nowhere near as good as a dozen we had passed and dismissed as unsuitable. 
 The glacier beyond was dirty and torturous, but we trekked down it to reach a sandspill outfall. 
 The river we had crossed was to our left and was not, as we first thought, melt water from the spout; that formed a river to our right. 
 We trekked across the wet sand towards Tony on the far bank ahead of us. 
 By the time we reached Tony it was obvious we would never find a crossing point. 
 He was hugely amused by it, the more so as we paced up and down in exasperation. 
 Finally, sensing that we were on a loser and not keen on the mile-long trek back to the crossing point, I took off boots and socks and walked into the fast-flowing stream. 
 I had expected it to be cold but it surprised me with a suddenness that wrenched my breath away. 
 The river bottom was ridged sand, a difficult and unkind footing, that combined with the cold and the rush to make me want to go fast while forcing me to go slow. 
 I teetered across, on the edge of tipping up, a tightrope walk between panic and despair. 
 Tony caught it all on film. 
 J&ouml;kuls&aacute;rl&oacute;n is a beautiful place. 
 Close to the sea Brei&dstrok;3amerkurj&ouml;kull, a broad flat snout of Vatnaj&ouml;kull, dies into this lake, the melt water exiting along a wide, fast channel into the sea. 
 On the southern side there is a tern colony, and the birds hover above our heads like noisy butterflies while we pad carefully between groups of their precious eggs. 
 In the lake seals surface and stare. 
 The glacier ends in a cliff that calves small icebergs that head seaward, grind to a halt when they hit the sand base of the river and dissolve in tears at the indignity of it all. 
 By Svalbard or Greenland standards the bergs are small, but they are nice enough in their setting, the stranded ones, sculpted by wind, sun, and rain, are brilliant blue on their shadowed sides. 
 Along at the river's mouth, at the standing wave formed where the incoming sea and outgoing melt water meet, a flock of terns hover and dive like gnats in the summer air. 
 Each surfaces from its dive with what looks like a sand eel. 
 Among the cloud of terns a solitary Arctic skua spins and wheels, selecting an individual bird and pursuing it to try to persuade it &mdash; bully it &mdash; to drop its catch. 
 The tern is swift, turning tightly among the flock to avoid the pirate. 
 The skua is astonishingly agile for so big a bird, but cannot keep up among the throng and gives up. 
 four or five times as I watch the skua tries and each time it fails. 
 It would surely take less effort to catch a fish itself. 
 Back at the campsite beside the iceberg lake Ann and John have made tea (much to Tony's disgust, since he is mainly a coffee man). 
 Earl Grey never seemed such a decent chap, and we laze back to  enjoy his brew. 
 It is foul. 
 After a few moments we realize why. 
 The tidal reach of the sea fills the lake so that at all times the water is brackish. 
 There is a resigned look from Ann and Tony, but John and I (the more English pair?) take ice axes and haul a small berg ashore, beating lumps off it for the tea. 
 The Trangia looks good with ice clumps poking out of its kettle. 
 And the tea tastes even better. 
 Next day I am taken to H&ouml;fn to catch a plane back to Reykjavik, leaving the others to continue to M&yuml;vatn and the north. 
 On the way red-necked phalaropes at last show themselves, tame, almost friendly birds that come towards the camera. 
 They are nothing like the divers we have tried to photograph and largely failed to capture because of their timidity. 
 Tony surprises an oncoming motorist by assuming a position that leaves his legs on the gravel road but takes the rest of him down among the lake-side vegetation. 
 It is an amazing sight, the more so for being a waste of time. 
 On our side of the road, where the water is within a metre of the gravel edge, the phalaropes have come within spitting distance for a better look. 
 H&ouml;fn is a straggling village &mdash; aren't they all? &mdash; &mdash; with a row of brightly-coloured ships in the harbour and a fine memorial out on a headland. 
 Of the town itself I remember only two things. 
 One was a small caf&eacute; that sold pizza and chips for less than the small fortune we expected, and served by a girl friendlier than we could have hoped for. 
 The second thing was&hellip; 
 I can't remember the second thing. 
 The plane lifted off but the weather did not and I was denied a view of Vatnaj&ouml;kull and the central plateau. 
 Below and behind Ann, John and Tony moved east and north. 
 Tony takes up the journey. 
 I remember the desert crossing, vividly. 
 The dust storms made my new bike very dirty. 
 Now, many  years later, I am in the luxury of a hire car. 
 Luxury? 
 I think not in truth. 
 It is very tedious, although it does minimize the more boring distances, allowing detailed exploration, by boot, of the areas of greater interest. 
 Having been forced out of the eastern fjords in endless rainswept misery we headed for M&yacute;vatn, Go&dstrok;afoss and Akureyri, three attractions in the north of Iceland. 
 The route to Dettifoss, the greatest waterfall in Europe (fifty metres high and enormous in volume) was still closed, and perhaps will not open this year due to the extraordinarily long and hard winter. 
 True four-wheel drive vehicles or those with time for a 30-kilometre trek could have probably made it, but we, having neither time nor lockable differentials, carried on across the edge of M&yacute;vatns&ouml;r&aelig;fi, a huge featureless desert of lava and ash fields. 
 A desperate place. 
 The surface of Skaftafellsj&ouml;kull from Kristinart&iacute;ndar 
 Civilization is once again reached, the steam jets from prolific geothermal activities like flagpoles bending in the wind. 
 This is the area of M&yacute;vatn famous in the guidebooks for everything except the bleeding obvious &mdash; the stench. 
 N&aacute;mafjall is a yellow mountain, offer (to those of no nose) stupendous views of the whole M&yacute;vatn area. 
 But first we make a stop at the east foot of the hills, a highly active area of slimy, bubbling sulphur pits. 
 There are memories you never forget &mdash; and they are revolting memories &mdash; and here they come again. 
 On my solo bike trip I spent two nights and a day in the Reykjahli&dstrok;3 campsite thunderbox after a visit here. 
 My insides were coming out. 
 This time I got out of the car and felt my stomach heave again. 
 Reflex action? 
 John accused me of wimpish behaviour, so we did the tourist bit around the pits. 
 Blurps and blops emit gases, and the smell is devastating. 
 I'm  the wimp?   
 Lava formations, M&yacute;vatn 
 Where are you going John? 
 &bquo;I'm just going,&equo; he said, his face the colour of the ground &mdash; yellow. 
 Some poor Dutch guy was being ordered by his woman to stand right in the steamy fumes for a photo. 
 Jesus, love is&hellip; having to stand in a sulphur plume? 
 Not bloody likely. 
 It was time to leave. 
 I couldn't take any more. 
 Ahead the round-Iceland ring road (sorry, rubble trail) leads to a newish geothermal power station called Krafla, generating steam from subterranean heat. 
 This area is active. 
 One impressive crater, Viti &mdash; the name means hell &mdash; &mdash; some 300 metres in diameter, was formed on 17 May 1724 as part of a five-year eruption. 
 The area last saw eruptions in 1975 and 1954: perhaps it's time to go. 
 Access to Viti is through the power station grounds and on to the road's end, although with the late spring the road was just another snow field. 
 The power station was unlike any I had previously seen. 
 There was the same turbine house, but there were also huge plastic multi-coloured geodesic domes covering steam taps, pipes leaking noxious gas and a general weirdness. 
 M&yacute;vatn is over the hill, past more vile-smelling industrial delights. 
 Some hero has at last heard our cry and painted a blue sky. 
 It had been a long time since we last saw one of those, so we bought ice cream, sat in the sun and wrote postcards at the Reykjahlid shop. 
 Life can be good on the tourist trail. 
 Close by are the famous Dimmuborgir, Grj&oacute;tagj&aacute;  and St&oacute;ragj&aacute; underground hot springs. 
 On my last visit I swam in the Grj&oacute;tagj&aacute; pools &mdash; a true delight for someone so young and so unused to mixed nude dipping. 
 Geothermal activities have so increased in recent years that these baths are now closed; they are too hot, too dangerous. 
 Even access is not encouraged, and the tracks leading to the caverns are also closed. 
 Instead we did the trail just south of Reykjahlid, climbing a lava mound overlooking the great lake. 
 The warmth was stupendous, the east and north of Iceland enjoying some amazing summer temperatures, over 20&deg;C and climbing. 
 M&yacute;vatn itself is famous for its peculiar lava formations and its birds. 
 Only a very disinterested idiot could miss, and be unimpressed by, either. 
 John and Ann (although Ann to a lesser extent) were close contenders as they actively tried to get a tan. 
 I went to do some work, attempting to photograph some ducks and mergansers that were sheltering from the sun. 
 They steadfastly refused to come anywhere near close enough. 
 But I am long on stamina and waited for a red-breasted merganser aimlessly doing nothing under the cliff on which lay the dozing duo. 
 patiently, even more so than usual, I wished it out of the shade. 
 A 60th at full bore is a bit dicey with a 500mm lens hand held in a stagnant bog. 
 Come out in the open you, you&hellip; delightful, beautiful&hellip; that's it. 
 Sulphur pits, M&yacute;vatn 
 &bquo;DO YOU WANT SOME TEA, TONE?&equo; 
 The shout terrified the bird as well as me, and I captured whitish streaks just discernible on an   otherwise blank Kodachrome. 
 I was soaked from lying in manky bog-like horrids, stalking some half-witted bird around lava lagoons, and John asked if I want tea. 
 Of course I bloody well did. 
 It was a delicious, if small, compensation. 
 Bubbling mud pit, M&yacute;vatn 
 Go&dstrok;3afoss 
 The south-west outflow of M&yacute;vatn was more successful. 
 Harlequin ducks were enjoying the rapids and sun, toing and froing, preening and looking most elegant, and I was enjoying myself, crawling commando-style at the water's edge, despite the odd passer-by's curious gaze. 
 Strange people, tourists. 
 Despite my luck with the Harlequin ducks the Barrow's goldeneyes declined to come close enough and I had still not got a good shot when, with reluctance, we left M&yacute;atn. 
 It was sad to go, but Godafoss was waiting to be photographed in the evening sun. 
 I thought the land beside the &bquo;Fall of the Gods&equo; would make a good campsite, and it did. 
 I spent a long time photographing the falls, taken with their grace. 
 They are not particularly high, but very elegant and their remote location makes a visit a must. 
 The falls were in good fettle for the shots, with a lot of spring melt water and plenty of ptarmigan (for us, &bquo;chainsaws&equo;, because of their call). 
 They were in unusual plumage. 
 In the mating season the male usually has a striking red-orange eyebrow, but these were still nearly all white although it was already June. 
 We ate well and watched yet another super sunset, a pastime any northern traveller will soon develop, the acute angle of the sun giving hours of once-off enjoyment. 
 At times like these, while I am watching a midnight sunset or sunrise, I shed a tear for those poor campers putting up with long hours of dark in the Himalayas or the like. 
 But then, we are all different. 
 A quick bit of mental maths told me that 4.30am was the ideal time for photographs; then the sun would fill the natural arc of Godafoss with light, a low, warm-coloured morning delight. 
 My schoolboy physics reminded me that the sun would be well below the magic 42 &deg;, the limit of its elevation that will create &mdash; from the waterfall's mist &mdash; a single refraction rainbow. 
 It should be very good. 
 It probably was, but we didn't get up; we aren't completely stupid. 
 Akureyri is the capital of North Iceland with a population of about 14,000, with, amongst other  attractions, three memorial museums and List&dstrok;3urinn, a public park and botanical garden with various types of trees and over 400 Icelandic plants. 
 My immediate interest is the pool. 
 Every town in Iceland has a swimming pool, usually geothermally heated and part of social normality. 
 Swimming in open-air hot bathwater in view of ice-topped peaks is different, wonderfully different &mdash; cleansing, relaxing and just good. 
 At the edge there are usually secondary pools where hot water, up to 45 &deg;C in some cases, will drain you away, assuming you can even get into the water. 
 I close my eyes and forget the world. 
 Tomorrow it is on to Reykjavik and another trip will be over. 
 Tomorrow. 
 Just after midnight on 23 January 1973 a 2 kilometre-long fissure opened to the east of Heim&aelig;y, the town on the island of the same name, the largest of Vestmann&aelig;yjar (the Westmann Islands) off Iceland's southern edge. 
 From the fissure poured lava, blood-red lava glowing like the fires of hell in the night. 
 Most, but not all, of the islanders retreated to the mainland, returning five months later to discover that their island had grown by over a square mile and that nearly half the town had been destroyed. 
 The statistics of the eruption are outstanding. 
 Over one and a half million cubic metres of ash were swept out of what remained of the town. 
 The new land comprised 240 million cubic metres of lava which had spewed out at 1,100 &deg;C (2,012&deg;F) and was cooled by dowsing with six million tons of sea water in an effort to halt its relentless drive. 
 There are two volcanoes today, Eldfell having been created by the 1973 eruption and joining Helgafell to create a twin pair of cones to the south-east of the new town. 
 Helgafell is a disappointment. 
 From afar it looks like the classical volcanic cone and it is with a mounting sense of excitement that I climb the last section of loose lava gravel and sharp, welded lava rock. 
 A snow bunting twitters away to my left, laughing &mdash; as it turns out &mdash; at what is about to happen next, when I find that the volcanic dish is shallow and filled with grass and wind-blown rubbish. 
 The view however, is spectacular, taking in most of the fifteen islands of the Westmann archipelago. 
 An incongruous panorama dial names the islands, except Surtsey. 
 The eye is inevitably drawn to this huge Dundee cake, the world's newest land, born after a four-year gestation that started in 1963. 
 Northward, the edges of Eldfell are startlingly coloured with the browns, reds and oranges of burnt rock. 
 The warmth of the sub-lava magna can still be felt through the feet. 
 Dig down &mdash; use a stick, not your hand &mdash; for a foot or so and drop in a piece of paper. 
 It chars, turns black and crinkles. 
 Smoke wisps up and then it explodes in flames. 
 I wish, silently, that I had my Trangia. 
 Oh, to boil a kettle on red-hot rock. 
 The walk back to the town through the new lava fields is strange. 
 Weird shapes abound, here a Red Indian profile, there a church steeple. 
 The journey through the lava forest ends at the town, a fish-smelling old port, seedy and in need of a coat of paint, yet vibrant and friendly. 
 Beyond, the huge sea cliffs of the northern edge of Heim&aelig;y form a sharp ridge that offers an airy walk. 
 In spring those cliffs are alive with auks and gulls, and my favourite bird, the gannet. 
 On a sea of evening light P&aacute;ll Helgason steers his boat towards the sun, poking it between stacks and through arches, sometimes into gaps that leave me thinking I can touch the rock walls on either side. 
 Here and there the ropes of egg and bird collectors flap against the cliffs. 
 P&aacute;ll tells me that no one catches puffin any more, not since the government tried to tax the hunt. 
 But every eating house in town has puffin on the menu, I say, where do they come from? 
 Who knows? he asks with a grin. 
 As we head back towards Heim&aelig;y I watch the last of the light tinkering with the wave-tops. 
 I have seen photographs of orca, both still and movie, close-up and underwater, but nothing prepares me for the sight of a real one that scythes out of the water 100 metres or so away from the boat. 
 There is a triangular fin and the arch of a back. 
 It is a lazy movement but in an instant it is gone. 
 In that instant the power and grace of the animal is evident. 
 It is an awesome sight. 
 P&aacute;ll tells me he once had his boat in the centre of a leaping school of orca. 
 In Norway, I tell him, the orca is called spekkhogger , flesh ripper. 
 He smiles. 
 That night we eat puffin, just to be sociable. 
 It is dark red with the crumbling consistency of pig's liver. 
 I expect it to taste mildly fishy or, perhaps, mildly gamey. 
 It is neither. 
 It is vile.  
 WINTER 
 From an early age Haflor Ferdinandson has been in love with 4WD vehicles. 
 He bought one as soon as his bank balance could survive the impact of bringing all that fancy engineering from Japan to Iceland and immediately set about modifying it to suit his own very special requirements. 
 Soon, he became the first man to drive on an Icelandic glacier. 
 Today he has also become the first man to drive across Langj&ouml;kull, and the first to drive across Drangaj&ouml;kull. 
 His newest toy, a Toyota Land Cruiser with Gumbo Monster Mudder tyres so big that oxygen is required when you reach your seat, has CB, a radio telephone, an anenometer and a Loran radar set fixed in to transmitters on Greenland, Iceland and Norway. 
 It can accurately tell him where he is to the nearest ten metres or so. 
 Hafpor is a big man, nearly two metres tall and   weighing over 100 kilograms. 
 He is immensely strong, but also shyly gentle and has great sense of humour. 
 He decided to put up with Tony and I in order to support our attempt to cross the interior plateau in winter, using ski parachutes to help our progress. 
 Hafpor's truck 
 Upskiing in the &THORN;ingvellir National Park 
 So we sat in the swimming pool in Reykjavik knowing that outside we had all the food, all the clothing, the skis, the chutes. 
 Everything. 
 But we also had the attendant holding the door for us as we came out of the changing room because the wind was threatening to tear it off its hinges, as well as relentlessly trying to move the deep end up to the shallow end. 
 In the Icelandic centre the weather was worse, with snow drifting to over seven metres, and temperatures down around &mdash; 2O&deg;C ( &mdash; -4&deg;F) to act as a good prelude to wind-chill calculations. 
 Our pool was the middle of three small heated tubs and had a jet spray to it, a powerful  jacuzzi  that relaxed our minds as well as our bodies. 
 We talked and gradually came to a decision that was quite contrary to the one we had held when we hauled ourselves out of our clothes a half-hour before. 
 Then it had all been defeat and misery. 
 Now it was still defeat &mdash; well, you have to be realistic &mdash; but cheerfulness. 
 We would give it a go. 
 What was the worst that could happen? 
 Failure? 
 If you travel in the Arctic you must never expect to succeed every time. 
 Worse? 
 No chance, not with Haflor's truck. 
 The journey had been impressively straightforward to date. 
 We were intending to reach Hveravellir, now about thirty kilometres away, to be dropped there and to get out. 
 We had stopped in Geysir for diesel and here it was, only three in the morning and we were half-way from the end of the road. 
 progress was occasionally slow but the big driver was coaxing the big wheels gently over and through the snow. 
 Tony and I shared the navigation seat, and right now I was in the back, warm, comfortable and dozing gently. 
 I was brought rudely back to the real world by Tony's tripod coming off the top of the pile of clatch (odds and ends) piled up above the seat and hitting me on the head as the truck lurched to a halt, diving itself into a drift of deep snow. 
 Hafpor eased us forward again. 
 Yawn, settle down again. 
 But not this time. 
 This time there was no relief. 
 Hafpor tried hard, but eventually admitted defeat and asked us if we would walk a little. 
 Five minutes later Tony and I were trudging  through deep snow, wishing we had spared the time to search out the snow shoes and wondering whether there had ever been a previous occasion in Iceland when the approach of a car had been heralded by walkers. 
 All we needed was a red flag to warn the locals that we might be about to frighten the horses. 
 We walked for a mile or so, easily outpacing the vehicle which was soon just a pair of yellow lights back down the valley. 
 We stopped. 
 My nose had long since lost all feeling and I massaged it back into life. 
 Tony gave me his thoughts on the situation &mdash; about how pleased he was to be wandering around at four in the morning, in the pitch black, in deep snow, in the cold, in the wind. 
 I told him I was pissed off too. 
 We lounged about and waited. 
 The wind was worse now and Hafpor's anenometer was showing gusts to 60 kph. 
 It only worked when he was stationary, but that was often. 
 By the time his ready smile reached us we were glad to see him and retreated to try to get warm and ask a few questions. 
 There was, he said, a bridge about 300 metres away. 
 If we could get to that things would be easier on the far side. 
 So we got out and walked again. 
 We walked 300 metres, then another 300, then several more. 
 By the time we had walked half a dozen or more lots of 300 metres, we were losing enthusiasm. 
 Tony offered to walk back towards the vehicle, now a long way off, and left me to think about it all. 
 To my left the shallow ridge that formed an edge of the valley rose up to finish at a shallow bump. 
 It looked a reasonable enough distance, so I made my way towards it. 
 The snow improved as the slope steepened and I made good time up the 100 metres to the ridge top and along to the &bquo;summit&equo;. 
 I sat down on its rounded hump. 
 The wind was still banging away, but there was an inner calm that was at variance with the agitation I had felt below. 
 It may not have been sensible to climb alone up here at this time in these conditions, but it was little enough, and that straightforward. 
 In exchange I had a view over the wide, flat-bottomed valley, a view that dissolved into the fish-fin ridge on the far side. 
 To my other side the ridge tumbled away from below my hump. 
 Below in the valley the yellow lights of Hafpor's truck jiggled up and down with his frantic efforts to ease it through the snow. 
 Any noise it made was lost in the wind. 
 Speaking of the wind, it was getting stronger and I was getting colder. 
 Time for a little activity. 
 Back at the truck all was despondency in the gathering gloom. 
 We abandoned the attempt to reach Hveravellir, accepted that the weather and conditions were against us and retreated back down the valley towards civilization. 
 Morning found us at Gullfoss hastily trying to organize sleeping and eating. 
 It was hours now since we had last eaten, hours more since there had been any sleep. 
 Outside the wind grew even more savage and we cut short the one doomed attempt to raise the tent, retreating to the truck for a few minutes of poor slumber. 
 I woke stiff and cold, feeling as though I had been scrunched up like a paper bag. 
 We decided to walk to the waterfall to see what Gullfoss, well known to us in the summer, had to offer in winter. 
 The snow had drifted deep over the path that has been carved down to the chasm and we soon lost it, progressing by kicking steps into the hard snow. 
 Above the chasms we stopped and I kicked out a shelf for the camera bags. 
 Tony stomped past, stopped and peered into the chasm, setting up a shot. 
 He turned back towards me, opened his mouth to speak and was gone. 
 His feet had slipped from the kicked steps and he was sliding down a water slope that ended, abruptly, at the chasm about twenty-five metres below. 
 The square toe-cap of his Lundhag caught in the snow about two metres down. 
 He teetered backwards, got close to toppling over, fell back into the snow, looked up and hissed Jesus  through clenched teeth. 
 He kicked good steps and we thought about it. 
 A couple more feet and even if the toe had caught he would have gone over backwards. 
 Then it would have been twenty-five metres of snow slide and a final trip down a thirty-metre vertical chasm into a mix of ice and ice-cold water. 
 The Gullfoss gorge is &mdash; certainly in winter &mdash; a stopper. 
 We would have fished Tony out two or three kilometres down after the water had knocked him around a bit, and given him a dreadful bootful since he was wearing his Lundhags. 
 &bquo;Jesus,&equo; he whispered again when he reached me. 
 &bquo;We'll go,&equo; I said, and we did. 
 &bquo;What would you have done if I'd gone down?&equo; he asked when we were back on level ground. 
 &bquo;Put the Bronica in my rucsac and claimed it went down with you.' 
 Still, it sobered us a bit, and after we had taken several more shots we decided that we needed some sleep, to try to get our minds back in gear. 
 Hafpor said he knew of a little hotel, and would  we like to go there? 
 Silly question. 
 Offered a free bed and nosebag, Tony is there like a rat up a drainpipe. 
 So we slept well, in a warm room with sheets, with a loo and a shower, and water that smelt of sulphur. 
 Good place, Iceland, you can spend lots of cash on accommodation and finish up smelling like a boiled egg. 
 The following morning the room looked as though an expedition had broken out in it, so we fought all the bits back into the sacs, smiled sweetly at the girl on reception and left. 
 Outside the wind had had its cutting edge dulled &mdash; possibly against the bones of my shoulders &mdash; and was wimpering miserably around the building, occasionally offering an aggressive bark. 
 We leaned against the woodwork, noting that it needed a coat of paint. 
 The receptionist, we decided, definitely needed a coat of looking at. 
 Hafpor arrived. 
 He took us to the &THORN;ingvellir National park where the clouds parted and the sun shone on square kilometres of snow that was so clean and pure it made me weep for all the time we had lost on the trip, and for the pleasure of being where I wanted to be. 
 Tony and I unpacked the Upski parachutes that we had so lovingly tended all the way from the UK. 
 John White, loaner of the kit, had given Tony all the instruction we possessed on how to use them. 
 The lesson had been given in a lay-by near Kendal on a soaking wet afternoon in February with an audience of coach-trippers on day release from the Satanic Mills. 
 The lesson had started at 2.30 and finished at 2.38 with both instructor and pupil wet through and hacked off. 
 Tony gave me the benefit of his wisdom as we stood on the edge of a mile-wide snow field and waved goodbye to Hafpor. 
 See you on the other side, we called. 
 Could be a long walk. 
 My lesson lasted about half the time of Tony's, terminating as he was explaining the purpose of the deadman's handle to me when a gust filled his chute and hauled him off in fine style. 
 I adjusted the position of my skis, laid out the chute lines, hauled in the centre cord a little, clipped the controller into my climbing harness, thought about it a bit, hauled the lines up to give the nylon a bit of air, closed my eyes and gritted my teeth. 
 After a few hundred metres the pleasure overcame the apprehension. 
 God, this is the way to travel. 
 The chute is a perfect dish hovering a metre or so above the snow and hauling me downwind at a speed that would be unthinkable on Nordic skis. 
 We go up a long, but steepish, slope and pause to catch our breath and share the experience. 
 After only half an hour we can tack left and right &mdash; a must in general, as going downwind puts the canopy between you and the way ahead giving you no chance of avoiding rocks and ruts &mdash; so that we can move almost anywhere in an arc that is up to 45 degrees on either side of the wind. 
 John had claimed it was just possible to go backwards (as it were), but you must talk to him about that. 
 Suffice it to say that if the wind is going your way, get yourself a pair of skis &mdash; which must have a metal edge, and a fixed-heel binding &mdash; and a chute. 
 We were carrying light loads because it was our last day but we averaged about 25kph with ease, and for a long while. 
 At the far side we used Hafpor's truck to speed-check us, and in the light wind were easily making 45kph. 
 Given a fair blow much higher speeds must be just as easy. 
 After a while you lean back and enjoy the ride, letting the canopy haul directly from your waist to release all strain on the arms. 
 The legs and knees take a belt &mdash; &mdash; you are, after all, suffering most of the strains of downhill skiing and for longer at a stretch &mdash; but the distance travelled more than makes up for that. 
 By the time we were packing the chutes we were both hooked and planning another trip. 
 It is amazing what one good day will do.   
 SCANDINAVIA 
 Map &mdash; Mainland Scandinavia 
 Technically, Scandinavia covers only the four mainland countries of Norway, Sweden, Finland and Denmark, even though most people also add Viking Iceland to the list. 
 Of the four mainland countries, three have land above the Arctic Circle, and Norway is the most important of these. 
 Norway is a long thin country, only about fifteen kilometres wide near Narvik and Fauske, yet 1,800 kilometres from nose to toe measured along the crow-flying line. 
 This is easy enough, but measuring along the coastline requires a very  long ruler indeed. 
 Norway, excluding Svalbard, is a third as big again as the UK with a population of only four million, most of whom live in Oslo, a fine city with one of the best museum complexes in Europe. 
 All visitors to Oslo should see the Viking ships at least and Arctic travellers should make a point of going to the Fram  museum, which pays homage to one of the most remarkable men and expeditions in the history of polar exploration. 
 Between 1893 and 1896 Fridtjof Nansen attempted to reach the North Pole by deliberately entombing his ship, Fram , in the ice near Ostrova Novo Sibirskiye (the New Siberian Islands). 
 Nansen, an excellent scientist, had realised that the polar ice drifted from east to west and reasoned that if he chose his entry point correctly the ice would tow his ship over the pole and release it near Canada. 
 He and his men spent three winters trapped in the ice, but sadly the drift was south as well as west and the ship was released north of Svalbard having reached a point no closer than several hundred miles from the pole. 
 North of the Arctic Circle Norway has some fine mountainous country and Finnmark, an expanse of flatter tundra that offers a very different and, in winter, a very cold trip. 
 East of Troms&oslash;, the &bquo;capital&equo; of Arctic Norway, is Lyngen, a superb area of jagged peaks that is near paradise for the climber in winter. 
 Southward the &Oslash;vre Dividal National park offers excellent treks in both summer and winter. 
 further east, the border area with Russia is an interesting area, particularly within the &Oslash;vre Pasvik National Park where the quiet visitor can see brown bear and elk. 
 Sweden is a larger country than Norway with a compact Arctic region dominated by a mountain chain that runs along its western edge, near the border with Norway. 
 This chain includes Kebnekaise at 2,111 metres, the highest mountain in the Scandinavian Arctic. 
 (There are higher mountains in southern Norway and in other parts of the Arctic, including Iceland.) 
 The peak can be climbed as part of Kungsleden , the King's Route, an excellent if over-populated route and one of the very few waymarked trails in the Arctic. 
 The route starts at Ammarn&auml;s, south of the Circle, and traverses the Peljekaise National park. 
 It skirts the Sareks National park to the east, reaches Kebnekaise and ends at Abisko. 
 Abisko lies on a lake and near a National park that is famous for its animal and bird life and its woods of birch and pine. 
 The southern mountain parks of S&ouml;dra Storfj&auml;llet, Sareks and Padjelanta have a limited flora and fauna, but some fine rugged scenery. 
 Sareks is especially good, but is difficult to reach and explore. 
 Further east, Arctic Sweden is flatter and less inspiring, although the Muddus National Park between Jokkmokk and Malmberget has fine forest and marshland. 
 Elsewhere these plains are home to the great grey owl and the shy brown bear. 
 Arctic Finland, in contrast to both Norway and Sweden, is flat, a vast tundra forest with lakes that is ideal country for the pulka-pulling skier but a little less inspiring for the walker. 
 Organized ski treks exist, their routes following set trails with accommodation en route . 
 One, the Border-Border Trek, is claimed to be the world's longest ski trek. 
 It goes from Tornio, near the Swedish border, to Kuusamo near the border with the USSR. 
 The fit and competent should cross the 360 kilometres in about seven days. 
 Other treks cross the two fine Arctic National Parks, Uhro Kekkonen to the east, and Lemmenjoki park in the north, a park that links with the &Oslash;vre Anarjokka Park that lies in Norway, to the east of Kautokeino, capital of Norwegian Lappland. 
 The capital of Finnish Lappland is Rovaniemi, home of Father Christmas &mdash; or so it is said &mdash; and a town that easily overcomes the embarrassment of having everything but the airport lying south of the Arctic Circle. 
 To the north-east of the town is the Pyh&auml;tunturi park, another fine unspoilt forest area. 
 Elsewhere, the Malla Park near Kilpisj&auml;rvi is famous for its flora, and walkers can reach the three-countries stone, where the three Arctic Scandinavian countries meet at a single spot.  
 SUMMER &mdash; LAPPLAND 
 Many years ago Tony and I sat drinking coffee and swapping experiences. 
 Tony had just returned from Iceland, his epic cycle tour, and I was back from Switzerland, buoyed up by time spent working at the Research Station on the Jungfraujoch. 
 I told him about the sunsets, when the Jungfrau had turned pink and I was the only person on the Aletsch. 
 He told me about the Icelandic landscapes, harsh yet wondrous, of the coloured rocks in Landmannalaugar and the emptiness. 
 Time we did something together, I suggested. 
 He agreed, but we had some difficulty in deciding what. 
 My conversion to the Arctic was still a little while away. 
 I talked of Via Ferrata and Alta Vie, he talked of Lofoten and the Padjelanta park. 
 Ultimately it was decided that we would try Kungsleden , the long-distance footpath through Arctic Sweden. 
 I could tell he was keen from the fact that he didn't mention it again for a couple of years. 
 We went here and there, but Kungsleden  lay fallow. 
 Until 1985 that is. 
 At the time I almost lived up to my nickname, Bone &mdash; close to Tone, and closer still to bone idle. 
 This idea of a walk that was twice the length of the Pennine Way &mdash; or so Dick said &mdash; sounded horrid. 
 I'm a cyclist;  four weeks of tramping with a rucsac would crease me. 
 The nickname was also used by those laughing at my structure &mdash; totally devoid of superfluous fat, so that any backpack was uncomfortable. 
 As Dick often pointed out, he had seen more flesh on a wooden leg, and more fat on the breakfast bacon. 
 Today rucsacs can be delightful to carry, a world apart from my heap of the 1960s, but in those days I really did not like backpacking. 
 I stayed quiet. 
 In the mid-1980s it was trendy to ATB (all-terrain bike) up famous mountains. 
 The purpose of such deeds seemed obscure &mdash; why carry a bike up a mountain only to have to push it down again? 
 Mountains are for walking, ATBs are for paths and tracks. 
 At the time I was writing for Bicycle Times  and one day Dick's Arctic footpath came to mind. 
 Why not see if ATBs were any good for real  wilderness touring? 
 Why not cycle up Kungsleden? 
 I could knock up some lightweight special frames and do a positive test on their value. 
 Pete, the editor of the magazine, and Dick were both keen. 
 We met and a plan was conceived: Pete and Dick would get the next round in, then organise the logistics of food, route and transport. 
 I just had to supply three bikes. 
 Easy. 
 Maps of Lappland were fingered and any snippets of information gathered. 
 I begged and was rewarded. 
 Reynolds, manufacturers of quality bicycle tubing, came up with some special stuff. 
 The bikes had to survive a six-week tour in total wilderness, with fifty kilograms of camping gear, and they must  not break. 
 They didn't. 
 The final creations weighed a mere ten kilograms, about the same as a top-class racing bike and about half the weight of most ATBs. 
 Information, even from the Scandinavian tourist boards, was difficult to obtain. 
 You are cycling through Lappland? 
 It cannot be done. 
 You must have a sprocket loose. 
 We carried on and eventually devised a plan. 
 It took about a year to organize, partly because the idea blossomed in the summer, too late for that year; it is not the sort of place to go cycling in the winter. 
 Just in time, Dick developed a viral nasty that made him lethargic. 
 I couldn't see the difference, but his vet insisted he wasn't fit enough, even when summer came. 
 His disappointment at missing out added to the way the illness was making him feel. 
 His absence necessitated some quick adjustments to strategy. 
 We continued with our three-man tent, a Phoenix Phor-3, and I must say, the extra space was much appreciated on several occasions, not least on 6 August when it snowed all day and I thrashed Pete at cards. 
 The final plan deviated from the original and we decided to go from Sulitjelma in Norway to Abisko, at the top of Kungsleden , in Sweden. 
 This allowed relatively easy access from Bod&oslash;, the start of Kungsleden  (Ammarn&auml;s) being a sod of a place to reach. 
 Because of a combination of so many unknowns, we, or should I say they &mdash; Pete and Dick did all the work, I just made the bikes &mdash; made  a total cock-up of ability and distance. 
 One stretch took three overnights where the great plan allowed just one. 
 But so what? 
 We had five more weeks and there was definitely no rush. 
 There was nothing to rush for and nowhere to rush to. 
 Staloluokta, our first place of rest, is an oasis of delight. 
 Four days from the nearest tarmac discourages the average vandal, factory unit or traffic warden. 
 On the southern shores of Virihaure, a huge lake rimmed by glaciers and  wildnerness , is this stunningly simple Lappish community. 
 Although it boasts little in the way of modern conveniences, it offers many services: mountain hut, camping area and thunderbox, basic shop &mdash; in truth very basic and equally expensive &mdash; bakery, fish, fish and more fish, church and pure honesty. 
 Aches and anxieties are dissolved in the bastu , the village sauna. 
 To the mountain people this  daily pleasure is a social event where visiting travellers are welcome, but experiencing the bastu  requires some tough decisions. 
 The heat can be intense for those not used to saunas, so intense breathing becomes difficult. 
 Some of the local hard cases delight in the sadistic pleasure of ousting strangers by continually watering the stones, Relief waits outside, but it is a masochistic type of relief &mdash; icy-fresh river water that is cold beyond belief. 
 Between the two lies a jetty, home to millions of razor-sharp fangs waiting just for you, and your delicate, softened-up softer than usual, parts. 
 You know where I mean. 
 After leaving the hut, hesitation is not  recommended. 
 The thermal shock is, by comparison, bliss. 
 The Lappish church, Staloluokta, Sweden 
 The Lappish church, Staloluokta, Sweden 
 A real mountain bastu  is one of those experiences not to be missed, and all you could want after a hard day's toil, a wonderful relaxant. 
 However, becoming accustomed to the Scandinavian way takes some adjustment. 
 Nudity to them is a much more relaxed affair. 
 We Brits are terribly prudish and you may be, as I was, a little uneasy at first. 
 Not to worry; the welcome and conversation soon takes over as you mix with the whole village: small kids, their little old grannies, Lappish reindeer herdsmen and the odd Swedish blonde. 
 I was worried about the latter but I can assure you here that there is little cause for concern. 
 The thermal shock of zero degrees water is so intense no one can tell how pleased you are to see them. 
 Another rarity at Staloluokta is the church, even to a heathen like me. 
 Its charm lies in its basic simplicity, a hemispherical structure of birch trunks, wind-proofed around the outside with turf bricks. 
 In contrast, light comes through triple-glazed window units (those bloody salesmen get everywhere). 
 On the floor birch twigs and greenery are over-carpeted with reindeer furs. 
 A wood fire in the centre adds to the warmth, the smoke exiting, together with yet more of those mosquitos, through a central hole in the roof. 
 It was a well-attended service, families coming both from the village and down from the hills. 
 The minister strummed on a guitar to the wailing and life felt wonderful. 
 The praise was complete and we all departed, the minister helicoptering off to the high mountains to give worship to the farmers herding their stock. 
 It was a peaceful day. 
 The journey so far had been an eye-opener. 
 The mountain range along the border between Norway and Sweden is wild and wonderful with 2,000-metre peaks soaring over seemingly endless glaciers with romantic names like Bl&aring;mannsisen and Salajekna. 
 I totally lost myself in the remoteness. 
 The Sorjus pass, 1,000 metres high, gives (relatively) good access to Lappland from civilisation. 
 Just down there is Sweden, we concluded in amazement. 
 We had decided this part would be tough, and for once we were right. 
 One steep 330-metre climb had to be done twice in order to lift all the gear. 
 Karrimor had made two special rucsacs, the bike's top tube clamping on to the reinforced cover flap so that the whole bike sat across your back. 
 putting your head through the main-frame triangle, or carrying the bike over your shoulder is uncomfortable in the extreme. 
 My method, although no good in woods, is comfortable and keeps the centre of gravity close to your back. 
 The pannier bags normally stay on, but this climb came only one day into the trip and with a fortnight's food on board I couldn't even lift my bike. 
 After eating most of the load the method is wonderful and wholeheartedly recommended. 
 Our journey was now planned as downhill all the way to Vietas, some six days away. 
 It was pretty good, but we left the rugged mountains with mixed feelings. 
 The vast openness of Lappland may be less spectacular but the trails are flatter, well-trodden and rideable, sometimes. 
 One thing we knew for sure &mdash; beyond here was the unknown, and it looked big. 
 The outflow of S&aring;rj&aring;sjaure ( jaure  is Swedish for lake), at its eastern end, forms a spectacular waterfall, the spectacle being the volume rather than the length of descent. 
 The backdrop of the lake and the distant Sorjusjokka glacier is breathtaking, helped by the fluffy puffs of cloud stuck to the sky. 
 I like it here. 
 Last night we camped a metre short of the border, a beautiful spot between the upper and lower Sorjus lakes. 
 It was a time to dry out, three days of solid rain having dampened all but our spirits, and to finish our excess of the other kind of spirits before attempting to cross the border. 
 The border is spectacularly unimpressive. 
 A small cairn is the only evidence, making passports a waste of time. 
 Never mind, maybe later I will get a Swedish stamp to add to my collection. 
 Our evening meal was disturbed by a lone walker, a young German lad, extremely knowledgeable and pleasant. 
 He walked by night and slept by day, the midday sun being too hot for him. 
 It was a novel idea and one we appreciated later when the weather improved. 
 He was reluctant to admit his nationality, and usually claimed  he was Austrian to save any possible embarrassments of the truth. 
 He too had discovered that the Nordic people have long memories. 
 He sampled some of Pete's brew and continued his walk. 
 At the time Pete was fifty, making the challenge of his biking this wilderness more meaningful than my personal quest. 
 He had brought with him a wealth of experience and he shared many a story of his love of the outdoors. 
 In practical terms an experienced camper is obvious; there is no need to issue orders, each knows what has to be done and when, without debate. 
 Arriving at a suitable pitching site, I would erect the tent and Pete would fetch water and have a brew ready by the time we piled in. 
 His kitchen area was out of bounds to me at cook times so I was forced to use the (extremely useful) rear door of the tent. 
 Tidiness is not a fetish but a necessity in a confined space. 
 I would win no prizes for being tidy, but the main aggravation was the fact that we had, between us, eight identical black Karrimor pannier bags. 
 Never, ever was the item you desperately needed in the first bag, second bag&hellip; 
 Pete's cooking was obviously the result of many hours over a hot Trangia. 
 His pride in being able to cook three hot meals a day for two of us, on just one litre of meths in six days, was shattered when one pensioner told us that two weeks was more her time scale for such a luxurious amount of fuel. 
 They exchanged recipes like a pair of old women and we departed. 
 Food was mainly dehydrated but Pete would pep up meals by mixing in spices and niceties he kept in redundant Kodak film cans. 
 On miserable days when both of us were low, he would delve into the depths of a pannier and give me a mini Mars bar or some peanuts. 
 The old man looked after me well. 
 There were many obstacles to tax our resolve and our language. 
 Bridgeless rivers were waded, often several times, back and fro until all the kit was safely across. 
 Sometimes we had to rope up, sometimes we were frozen numb. 
 Snow fields were ploughed through and ice cliffs were given absolute respect. 
 Rain that made Scotland seem like the Sahara was no sweat, but the midget trees! 
 They were even worse than the mosquitos. 
 You can, up to a point (and we did up to that point), protect yourself against them with jungle gels and mustard gases, but the trees give no mercy and there are hours of them between Staddajakkstugorna, a mountain hut on the side of Kapasluoppal, and Staloluokta. 
 Walkers with rucsacs have created a path through these Arctic forests, a highway that reflects the profile of a backpacker &mdash; narrow around the legs and very wide around the rucsac. 
 A bicycle is not profiled the same and the pannier bags were constantly grabbed, causing many a rude word. 
 Progress was very slow, so slow we were genuinely concerned about the possibility of getting much further. 
 We had no idea how much of Lappland was covered with these nasties. 
 Luckily it turned out to be an isolated incident but we had nightmares about a recurrence. 
 A similar problem occurs on bridges, wire rope and wood affairs that swing, like a worn-out bra strap, in the slightest breeze. 
 The smaller bridges offered just a single plank of wood, too narrow to cycle across and too narrow to push the bike from the side. 
 A tight rope act is required but this is restricted by the near-vertical suspension cables. 
 Oh God, not another; perhaps it will be easier to wade the river, but then again perhaps not&hellip; 
 Carrying a tent where mountain huts are prolific may seem an unnecessary burden, but it allows total flexibility and we soon discovered the   benefits of camping where we chose. 
 The huts are predominantly in valleys near rivers, and invariably the local area was swarming with mosquitos. 
 Camping high, between the huts, we enjoyed insect-freeing breezes and spectacular night views of the midnight sun. 
 We weren't alone in having such ideas; many Swedes prefer this philosophy because it also gets you away from the Germans. 
 No matter how hard you try, they always beat you to the huts. 
 The waterfall at the exit of S&aring;rsj&aring;sjaure, S&aring;rj&aring;sjaurestugan, Sweden 
 Isolation and wilderness travel require a special attitude to life. 
 Decisions can have alarming consequences and non-decisions can be fatal. 
 Choice of company is desperately important. 
 Can you share the same confines, for long periods of time, and where does your tolerance level lie? 
 Group  travel can relieve some of these pressures but it can also result in &bquo;ganging up&equo;, for the silliest of reasons. 
 Unlike the kids in Lord of the Flies  we had no real problems, but the remoteness does make me anti-social. 
 Both Pete and I found mountain huts overwhelming. 
 It was like being in a supermarket during late-night shopping, with that overpowering sensation that you are losing your space. 
 The occasional meeting of a backpacker on the trail was different, and friendly words were always exchanged. 
 Weather, where to pitch and where to fish are typically topical. 
 One meeting half-way across a stream led to a drinking session. 
 I spied a &bquo;Backpackers Club&equo; sweatshirt. 
 Are you English? 
 I enquired. 
 Oh no, I run the Dutch section of the club. 
 Well, I explained, the old codger with me is one of the founder members. 
 He'll be along in a minute. 
 The nearest bank was headed for, and out came their supply of local moonshine. 
 It tasted far worse than I imagine my four-day-old socks would &mdash; a memorable moment remembered for the wrong reason, not least for the expression of anguish on Pete's face as the brew hit his tonsils. 
 On the spongs of the Padjelanta National Park, Sweden 
 Most impressive was the number of retired people we met backpacking. 
 They came mainly from Stockholm or, at least, southern Sweden and most had been trudging these paths for decades. 
 They seemed to know everything and anything about the area: the names of butterflies and Arctic flowers  flooded out from their memory banks. 
 One fellow told me, apologetically, that he and his wife only did ten to fifteen kilometres daily these days. 
 He added quickly that there was no hurry any more. 
 Don't apologise; I think that is fantastic and I hope &mdash; I pray &mdash; I am able to enjoy a similar style of retirement. 
 Also notable was the number of fathers and sons out together, for perhaps three weeks with a tiny pack of basic provisions &mdash; a tent, survival knife and a fishing rod. 
 This is country where it is easy to live off the land, or out of the rivers, and to learn about life. 
 Mountain hut, Norway 
 Most encounters started in the same way, with a question about the bikes. 
 &bquo;Why the bikes?&equo; 
 &bquo;Why do you carry such loads on your back?&equo; was our most popular response. 
 It's easy to push a bike and it belts downhill. 
 The truth is that uphill the extra weight made it a little harder than walking, but the weight was not directly on my back, a fact that I appreciated. 
 We could push our laden bikes at a roughly typical walking pace up passes. 
 On the flat life was in our favour and we left most walkers behind. 
 Downhill we were in a different league. 
 On one occasion, on a 300-metre climb from the spectacular bridge over the H&auml;rrakalou, a green, algae-filled river that drains a huge area of the Sarek National Park, we were accompanied by two fit Dutch lads, who maintained a similar pace. 
 On the descent that followed, leading to L&aring;ddej&aring;kk&aring;stugan &mdash; stugan  is hut &mdash; about six kilometres, we beat them down by forty-five minutes, freewheeling all the way. 
 Mountain bikes are good. 
 The going was often helped, considerably, by spongs , wooden walkways built over boggy areas by the Lappish people. 
 The quality of these &bquo;roads' varies with their age, the newest three-plank spongs  allowing us to maintain incredible speeds. 
 However, occasionally the spongs  also bridge ravines making for brave crossings especially when you have no idea of their quality. 
 The spongs  are home to another source of interest &mdash; food &mdash; if you are desperate and very quick, because lemming live beneath them. 
 They are boring, grey-coloured, hamster-like devices that scurry away at the first sound of our Michelin Interroutes; I suppose I would leg it too if some mad giant was riding his bike over my roof. 
 What I would have given for a sesame bap. 
 Dehydrated packet breakfast, dinner and supper drives me potty. 
 The trails of Padjelanta are not that tough, which is ideal for our bikes. 
 We are now getting close to the flanks of Akka, a seven-peaked mountain that has been visible for four or five days. 
 Now I can understand why travellers rave about its obviousness. 
 We camped about five kilometres north of L&aring;ddej&aring;kk&aring;stugan on the open moors by a stream that thundered towards the distant watershed from Virihaure. 
 Coffee was followed by yet another sunset, the best possible after-dinner entertainment. 
 More stories, more coffee and another try with Pete's transistor radio. 
 We have tried to use it before but the mountain reception is far from good. 
 I am going to tell Roy Plumley's successor where he can stick the one luxury he allowed us to bring. 
 The only programme our free-with-petrol tranny would pick up was Soviet propaganda, in English, late at night. 
 In desperation we dug a hole, a big hole, in the depths of the night &mdash; brilliant sunshine at one in the morning &mdash; put the radio on full and buried it. 
 That shut it up. 
 We didn't make Abisko, chickening out as the weather worsened and the forecasts began to sound even more dire. 
 At last we had reached a road that led to a place called Ritjemjokk where we telephoned home and did all the civilized things in life; like sitting on a loo seat, for a long time.   
 Ninety-year-old Lapp, Sweden 
 From Ritjemjokk our maps and information showed ferry routes along Sitasjaure to the Norwegian border. 
 This was an alternative route we had considered in planning so we were dismayed by fresh news. 
 The boats are there to serve Lappish communities, or rather they were  there. 
 Sweden has gone anti-nuclear in its power-generating policy and consequently vast hydro-power stations have been built in the northern lake areas for reasons better known to themselves, the Swedes made no provision for salmon runs so the huge lakes are now devoid of fish and the Lapps have left. 
 The ferries have left too. 
 Controversy is rife this year, the first summer after Chernobyl. 
 This is radioactive reindeer and salmon country. 
 The Lappish diet is restricted to these basic foods and the result has been both anger and concern. 
 However, the Lappish people are more concerned about the plight of their traditional fishing waters, the loss of which is forever, much longer than it takes contamination from Russia to decay. 
 The Lappish understand that the levels of radioactivity will eventually decay; they are far from happy about the fall-out but it is secondary to their fish problem. 
 But this is not news. 
 Did you see any post-Chernobyl documentary about the lifetime plight of the salmon lakes? 
 I didn't either, but then anti-hydro protesting is not vogue in these &bquo;green&equo; times. 
 Our chief problem is where to go from here. 
 We have three basic alternatives. 
 One, to bike up Kungsleden  to Abisko and get wet; two, to cycle 600 kilometres around the road via Kiruna and Abisko to Narvik for our journey home; or three, hire a plane to take us somewhere else. 
 At this stage we had discovered that Kungsleden  is a motorway for German &bquo;Pennine-wayers&equo;. 
 No thanks, that's not for me; I'm even more of a recluse now. 
 So we hired the fiskflug , a float plane used to take fish from Lappish settlements to market and the outside  world. 
 Negotiations complete, we sardined our dismantled bikes into the Cessna. 
 Up, up and away, through the valleys to the north end of Sitasjaure and just into Norway once again. 
 On the rocks of Muokkeris, Sweden 
 The contrast was stark, an area devoid of anything green, or so it seemed from the air. 
 On landing we saw that small flowers and dying orchids line the rubble road, but the landscape was dominated by huge folds of dark grey rocks. 
 They resembled whales lined up outside the headmaster's office &mdash; huge humps sprawled over many kilometres. 
 They made a pleasant change, their undulations much easier to negotiate than the bogs of Sweden. 
 Here it was even possible to freewheel at speed without the risk of the front wheel submerging into a pool of smelly black moss. 
 Time and terrain allowed some short walking, the mountains being steep, yet rounded, firm rock with interesting views. 
 It was time for reflection: are these mountain the answer was yes, to both questions. 
 There were times when the bikes were a pain but, also times when they were of great benefit. 
 On the whole the trip so far was a success. 
 We had cycled on the road from Bod&oslash; to Fauske and on the Sulitjelma; pushed the bikes over to Sorjusjaure; ridden and swum our way to Staloluokta within the Padjelanta National Park; and then thrashed our way on the faster tracks through Arasluokuoktastugorna, L&aring;ddej&aring;kk&aring;stugana and Kisurisstugan to Akkastugorna and a ferry to Ritjemokk, before cycling by road to Vietas; and gone by plane to Sitastugan at the north-west end of Sitasjaure. 
 We had covered large distances both on-road and off the road, totally independent of public transport. 
 The physical and mental experience had made us healthier people and proof of the excitement and joy of the trip is that I have now become one of the greatest bores on mountain biking in the Swedish Arctic.   
 Midnight, seen from a sleeping bag, Sweden 
 At last we were back in the mountains. 
 Sadly, the forecasts came true, with sleet and snow making views vanish forever. 
 Kungsleden  must be hell in these conditions. 
 We escaped just in time and it was downhill all the way to Narvik. 
 The hydrofoil left Narvik in the early evening bound for Svolv&aelig;r, on what turned out to be one of the loveliest journeys I have ever taken. 
 The day was idyllic, with clear blue skies and temperatures up in the shirt-sleeves. 
 Our &bquo;bus of the sea&equo; was off, skimming the waves and rearranging the dancing patterns of the evening light. 
 We were travelling along the Lofoten Wall, an apt description for the mountains protecting this huge sea fjord. 
 The mountains hang everywhere, big vertical peaks just waiting to be climbed. 
 perhaps next time. 
 Lofoten is a small group of islands sticking out off Arctic Norway rather like the Outer Hebrides do off Scotland. 
 I've heard they are quite beautiful, and I hope so. 
 I hope too that this weather holds. 
 To our right, off the tip of Tjedloya, sea eagles bask in the sun, a great pack of them. 
 They look mean. 
 Oblivious to us swanning by, they show no emotions, unlike me, all full of excitement at so many and so close. 
 Later that evening, after a brief stop at L&oslash;dingen, the Arctic light was once again tantalising. 
 Four Spanish lads tried their best to explain why they had returned. 
 It is the sun, they said; it is  such a different sun, so much more beautiful than ours, cooler yet with more warmth. 
 I can sympathize; I have often struggled to get this difficult explanation across. 
 The mountains around Svolv&aelig;r are spiky and big. 
 The back light from the day's end made them even more dramatic and the sea was on fire. 
 Rings of mist were forming as the temperature dropped around the peaks. 
 That's a two-thousandths at f11; where is all this light coming from? 
 I just don't believe how fantastic it is. 
 This is going to be a good trip. 
 Fishing boat, Lofoten 
 My first sight of a Lofoten fishing port was on a small island off Svolv&aelig;r. 
 The hydrofoil entered the harbour, revealing the characteristic wooden docks, with brightly-painted buildings sticking out the fjord on spidery sticks. 
 Behind there are vertical cliffs, a dynamic backdrop dwarfing the harbour to insignificance. 
 And this place is hardly on the map. 
 I was sad to leave the boat, we had made many friends despite the trip being only a few hours long. 
 It was a good day and Svolv&aelig;r looked rather a special place, but we were now tired and a campsite was priority. 
 Kabelv&aring;g campsite is a few kilometres beyond the village, on the flanks of a charming little beach and remarkably civilized. 
 Campers are welcome to use communal kitchens and dining rooms, and there are washing facilities for both us and our clothes, each of which are in need. 
 I haven't been to an organized campsite for    perhaps fifteen years, so all this is new to me. 
 I do not know what to do and sneak looks at everyone else, while the &bquo;real&equo; campers pause to stare as we sit on Karrimats eating supper. 
 We soon learn that the huts give relief from yet more mosquitos, but compared to central Lappland insects these are either timid or full-up. 
 Get yourself a Tony Oliver! 
 Reine, Lofoten 
 Boats at Nusfj&ouml;rd, Lofoten 
 Evening light over the salmon pens, Svolv&aelig;r, Lofoten 
 The Arctic Ocean near Bod&oslash; 
 Evening over Kirkefjorden 
 Lofoten is the most beautiful place I have known, yet I find it one of the most difficult places to write about. 
 Clich&eacute;s and superlatives are rampant in the log that I kept on the trip. 
 What do you say when you actually go beyond the realms of astonishment, amazement and incredibility? 
 Each day there was a new sight and each day I was pushing the ability of these words to cope with my thoughts. 
 Every bend reveals another staggering visual feast and it is all to do with the light, the dynamic mountain ridges, the pure white sandy beaches and the undisturbed peace. 
 Each day is too short. 
 There is so much to see, even though it is all basically made of the same ingredients. 
 Perhaps I am abnormal in my endless fetish for light and patterns, but I don't give a damn. 
 The most beautiful evening (perhaps of my life) was on Flakstadoya. 
 Pete and I took an afternoon ferry from Leknes to Napp, and sweltered the bikes over an unnamed pass to Vareid. 
 We were on the south side of a small sea fjord, the head of which formed a junction for the road to Nusfjord. 
 The setting sun &mdash; it was now mid-August, so the sun just dipped below the horizon &mdash; would round the headland of Flakstad village and dance over some tiny skerries off the shore. 
 We were only a metre from the only road, but the number of cars that passed was easily beaten by the number of coffees drunk. 
 Yet another master meal was prepared by le chef , Pete, and we ate and drank, and watched an incredible show of lights, all of it free and just for us. 
 Divers worked around the fjord and we did absolutely nothing, and said almost less. 
 Speech wasn't necessary; we were both absorbed, miles away, perhaps with loved ones, perhaps&hellip; well, who cares? 
 Ten o'clock, time for a swim in the Arctic Ocean &mdash; well described as bracing &mdash; more coffee and then more sky watching. 
 The sun slipped over Flakstad church and the light show began. 
 Even after the sun vanished, amazement continued. 
 Flakstad was drowning in mist, backlit from the northern sky. 
 We fell asleep wondering what we might be missing. 
 Arctic sunsets can last many hours; I once watched one sun take four hours to touch the sea, and then it immediately started into reverse and rose again. 
 In equatorial areas the sun drops like a lead brick into the sea, light to dark taking only minutes. 
 Here the sun, if you stand still all day, will just circle the sky around you. 
 Unless it's raining of course&hellip; 
 Henningsv&aelig;r, Nusfjord, Reine are all the way the picture postcards show them, and a great deal more besides. 
 The fishing villages only come alive for the season when frantic fleets of boats fill their harbours to the brim. 
 for the winter traveller the climate is harsh, very cold, very windy and very close to the sea. 
 A nasty combination. 
 Now, in summer, the attitude is relaxed. 
 Henningsv&aelig;r is so quiet, and the sun so warming that a beer is absolutely necessary in a rather super establishment. 
 The locals have obviously never tried a good pint of 6X; how can they drink this stuff? 
 And it's &pound;3 a glass. 
 On the other hand, food in caf&eacute;s is excellent value. 
 Whilst suffering another scorching day, we sought refuge in the eating house at Rambert. 
 There was no menu; you simply asked for what you wanted. 
 The hostess suggested plaice, a less common fish for these areas, and not a particular favourite with my palate. 
 We settled for salmon &mdash; bloody salmon again &mdash; which arrived as three huge steaks complete with white sauce, carrots and new potatoes. 
 We then had a bowl of fruit salad, and there was change from the price of a glass of beer. 
 This left me staggered as well as very satisfied. 
 Reine is phenomenal. 
 It is said to be the most photographed village in Norway. 
 I find this hard to believe; it sees little good weather and the trigger-happy Japanese and American tourists are down south. 
 But forget all that, this place is exquisite. 
 Little red huts stick out in the sea, the backdrop is spiky Snowdon-sized mountains straight up, and the place is deserted. 
 The surrounding hills offer fine walking, scrambling and technical climbing. 
 (Take care in planning a walking tour: one guy we talked to came across an impossible cliff which required a two-day detour.) 
 Reine was our base for several days. 
 from it we cycled to the end of the road, a village called &Aring;; yes, just the one letter. 
 There are, apparently, three such places in the world and I wonder how the others compare in magnificence. 
 From here, the southernmost tip of Moskenes Penninsula, we took some fine walks. 
 The most spectacular of our walks was from Reine itself. 
 One of the joys of touring unusual  places is the variety of accommodation. 
 Like most of the fishing villages, Reine offers summer travellers the use of the vacated fishing huts, called rorbus . 
 Rechristened &bquo;Rambos&equo;, a reflection of their basic and rugged form, they offered us refuge from a rare rainstorm, and gave us a safe place to store excess baggage. 
 We left the rorbu  and attacked one of the 1,000-metre peaks overlooking the village. 
 A long climb through short vegetation was not helped by my taking my mountain bike. 
 I had come to Lofoten to photograph these beasts in real mountains for my forthcoming catalogue, so I pushed away. 
 The shots were going to look terrific, but this was ridiculous &mdash; the very thing I had been cynical about and did not wish to do I was doing; carrying a bike both up and down a mountain. 
 What a waste of time. 
 The view over Reine, Hamn&ouml;y and Kirkefjorden from the top of the climb is incredible, making an unreal backdrop for my equally fantastic work of art. 
 Right, a roll of K25 I think. 
 Where the hell is my film? 
 Christ, I've forgotten it, it's back in the rorbu . 
 I can see the hut down there, just a tiny pimple. 
 Four hours of hell for nought. 
 Pete finds this hilarious; he has been dying to get his own back for various things for ages and this comes close to the perfect opportunity. 
 I am quite a pleader at times and this occasion surpassed all previous pleads imaginable. 
 Pete had a roll of Ektachrome 200 and a Gold 100 print film. 
 Hobson's choice really, so I had both. 
 After the photo session we ate and sunbathed naked, taking advantage of the amazing heat and the warm breeze that kept away the mozzies. 
 Who will ever believe that I lay there, stripped naked, 1,000 metres up on top of a hill that is 300 kilometres north of the Arctic Circle? 
 It was a beautiful place. 
 Below, fishing boats and floating buses ploughed the fjord and seas. 
 The only other noise was from huge bumble-bees, flying like World War II plans, with a low drone that dropped even lower as they shot over my nose. 
 They turned out to be totally placid; just as well, since they are the size of hornets. 
 At five o'clock we wandered back; after all, it might get dark in fifteen days' time. 
 Each time we crossed the causeway over to the tiny island of Reine, we paused and photographed. 
 The view is as good as anyone could hope, yet each time it is different. 
 The sun on its endless tour round and round the sky gives shadows and hues of infinite variety. 
 If you don't like the lighting, wait, calculate your required angle of sunlight, and return. 
 The morning sun gives direct brilliance, while evening's afterglows offer backlighting and romance. 
 We left Reine with many memories and hopes of correctly exposed emulsion. 
 However, new things were to come as we departed on the tiny ferry to V&aelig;r&oslash;y, the penultimate island in the Lofoten chain. 
 Only R&oslash;st lay further out to sea. 
 R&oslash;st is actually a small group of islets rather than a single island, and a haven for birds in the spring. 
 In summer the attraction wasn't so strong and we settled for V&aelig;r&oslash;y. 
 The ferry arrived on Saturday evening and we instantly agreed to stay on the boat and to go elsewhere. 
 Saturday night is racing   cars up and down the eight miles of road, the nearest policeman being, perhaps, a whole day away. 
 We later learned that car ferries only arrived some ten years before and the novelty of owning, polishing and servicing cars has not yet been outgrown. 
 There are four taxi-cabs and on average each house has two cars outside. 
 All very well, you might say, but there is nowhere to bloody well go . 
 Two cyclists seemed fair game to these pissed idiots so we took off for the hills, only a small range but, we were to discover, quite beautiful. 
 Kvalvik, Lofoten 
 The north-west-facing ridge walk was simply stunning, with wonderful views in all directions. 
 Down towards the town humps of moraines gave a moonscape appearance whilst back toward Moskenes huge rocks were glistening with cormorants. 
 Towards R&oslash;st the sea was a silver reflector, whilst the sky darkened, an Arctic trick we now knew well. 
 The islets themselves thrust upwards, a mass of weird shapes. 
 We ambled with a young German couple to the peak of V&aelig;r&oslash;y, some 650 metres directly above an inaccessible golden beach. 
 There was nothing but height; no fence, no warning of the impending &mdash; once-off &mdash; leap, nothing. 
 One hell of a place; without words, we concluded V&aelig;r&oslash;y was something else. 
 ferry timetables forced a quick visit, but it allowed two good days' walking. 
 A third to the far hill range would have been ideal, but something must always be left undone, as an excuse for a speedy return.   
 Aerial view of Reine, Kvalvik and Hamn&ouml;y, Lofoten 
 SEA-KAYAK 
 It is high summer, although in the UK only the temperature of the rain would confirm summer rather than autumn to the blindfolded visitor. 
 Tony and I sit in the departure lounge of Heathrow wondering, yet again, how to fill the time between now and take-off. 
 Flying still excites me with that curious mixture of fear &mdash; knowing the plane has the aerodynamics of a brick once the forward thrust is lost &mdash; and the knowledge that at the other end of the journey there will be new sounds and smells and things to look at. 
 It pumps me so full of adrenalin that I pace in and out of duty-free shops, toilets, coffee shops, anything. 
 Tony closes his eyes and gives the appearance of nonchalance. 
 I am, he tells me, a bloody awful traveller, full of worries about missing flights, losing tickets and the like. 
 Why, he asks, can't I be more like him, calm, assured? 
 And full of bullshit? 
 I ask. 
 Heathrow has, at least, the marginal advantage of being civilized, in that the cattle are gently shifted from one place to another rather than being herded anonymously. 
 Once, at Milan airport, we were herded to the gate and corralled in an area almost big enough for half of us, then shifted to a bus with six seats and standing room for forty, in which the one hundred and twenty of us stood and waited for the idiot who always arrives twenty minutes late despite having been called ten times and being the subject of an Interpol missing persons search. 
 So we would not overheat they thoughtfully left the doors of the bus open. 
 Outside there was snow in the wind and the temperature was dropping. 
 After a few minutes it was the same inside. 
 After half an hour the bus started and moved us seventy metres, to the nearest plane, the one we could have walked to, with less effort and staying warmer. 
 They got us off and the bus disappeared, but there was still a reason why we could not board &mdash; they never let on what it was &mdash; &mdash; and we stood on the tarmac for a long time before being herded to the back entrance. 
 There the lucky ones among us were allowed half-way up the steps before being halted and held in position for twenty minutes while, I assume, the stewardess disentangled herself from more pressing engagements and tidied herself in readiness. 
 The wind blew and the snow fell, but it didn't matter. 
 The engines were just up there and their noise prevented us from thinking about how miserable it all might be. 
 Today we were close enough to the front of the plane to have a newspaper in English, and not have to settle for one printed in a strange dialect of Latvian (or whatever it is that they use for those that are always left at the end). 
 We are held briefly at the runway apron, and then we are off. 
 The excitement rises with the plane but soon it is just another flight. 
 Tony and I contemplate the likelihood that on this Scandinavian plane we will have one of those stewardesses you see in the adverts &mdash; &mdash; all blonde hair and curves. 
 Ours has a face like a welder's bench and sounds like the Swedish chef in The Muppet Show . 
 Ah, well. 
 My paper tells me that a dispute over pay between the leading British manufacturer of seaside rock and his chief sugar boiler has left the latter jobless and the former with umpteen sticks of rocks bearing the legend Mean Bastard  all the way through. 
 I show the snippet to Tony and the resulting peals of laughter from the pair of us bring disapproving stares from all over the plane. 
 There we are, in Lundhags, a Swedish boot that is wonderful for its purpose but looks like a refugee prop from a Boris Karloff Frankenstein  film, and oddly coloured clothes, rolling about. 
 It just isn't right is it Doris, I mean to say&hellip; 
 The alterations in progress when we were last at Fornebu, Oslo's airport, are now completed and we follow the new sign to baggage reclaim. 
 Round the first corner is a corridor hundreds of metres long with a sign at its end pointing left. 
 We go left into another corridor equally long and then left into yet another. 
 Clearly, in order to save some money, the carousel has been set up in downtown Oslo, about ten kilometres away. 
 We arrive exhausted, haul in our rucsacs, check in again and hike back along the corridor to the airport. 
 Two hours later I am mentioning to Tony that I have been to Troms&oslash; airport more times than I have to Gatwick. 
 Not that he is interested. 
 It is raining in Troms&oslash;. 
 The sky is the colour of  lead shot, with the Arctic Ocean dark and morose below it. 
 I lean against the window of the bus and watch the raindrops spatter down, just as I must have done when I was a kid. 
 Tony sits pensively next to me playing with his films. 
 He does that a lot. 
 This RS1000, he informs me, has already been to the Arctic about six times. 
 Deep joy. 
 We are grateful for a flysheet-pitch-first tent in the Tromsdalen campsite and as we work speedily on its erection, the man in the camp reception hut watches us through the windows. 
 I imagine he is impressed and that he will invite us for a coffee after, but when I look again he is gone. 
 I peer into the rain for a glimpse of Storskarfjell, but it is all wet misery to the south. 
 We discuss the merits of lighting the Trangia, decide that as nobody is watching, a coffee in the camp caf&eacute; will be OK. 
 Later we go to sleep with the noise of rain on the flysheet, that noise that is at one time both infuriating because it means that tomorrow's enjoyment may be curtailed, and soothing in a strange way. 
 The day dawns bright but still cloudy. 
 A night wind has blown the rain away, leaving behind pale grey rather than heavy grey clouds with, between them, enough blue to make a pair of sailor's trousers &mdash; as my mother would say. 
 We sort kit, hanging the tent up in a tree to dry and pouring the rucsacs out on to a Karrimat. 
 I have brought water-purifying tablets which has Tony perplexed. 
 Usually we are melting snow or ice so we don't bother, but this trip could see us near stagnant water. 
 He shrugs. 
 I tell him that a friend who is even now in the Karakoram had been told that in Pakistan it was advisable to double the suggested dose of tablets and then to boil the water for twenty minutes. 
 That should, it was suggested, reduce the likelihood of any problems by about fifty per cent. 
 Tony is amazed that anyone should want to go there at all. 
 Why, he asks, don't they just pour the water on the floor and machine-gun it? 
 Tony's devotion to the Arctic is single-minded. 
 I have tried once or twice to get him to the big hills, or to the Dolomites, but he sees no reason to waste time that could be spent in Norway or Greenland. 
 The last time, when I suggested a climb of Ararat, he asked where it was. 
 Turkey, I said. 
 He considered for a long time. 
 No, he said at length. 
 Why not? 
 I asked. 
 They eat a lot of foreign food there, he said. 
 In Troms&oslash; Tony searched out a coin so he can call Christine to report the fact that another interesting trip is about to start. 
 I stare at the Ocean. 
 It is still clear, still wonderful. 
 I poke a finger into it; still cold. 
 Later that day we are at Belvik loading sea-kayaks into the ferry for Vengs&oslash;ya. 
 With us are four members of the local sea-kayaking club who have agreed to act as guides and mentors for our first couple of days. 
 Tor Edgar is a giant man peering out shyly from behind glasses bequeathed by John Lennon. 
 His shoulders suggest he can paddle all day. 
 He can. 
 He is not much of a talker; a longish sentence for him is um , his standard reply to most questions. 
 Eventually, when he has decided that we wish to learn and that we love the Ocean as much as he does, he teaches us things that it is important to know. 
 Leila, his girlfriend, has John Lennon's other pair of glasses, but behind her pair are sparkling eyes set in a face that is always cheerful. 
 She is a teacher of primary school kids and decides, probably rightly, that these two English boys are really only ten years of age and should be treated as such. 
 Don't forget your paddle, Tony. 
 And what will you do if it rains and you haven't got your anorak on the deck, Dick? 
 Sorry, miss, I didn't think. 
 That's your problem, always has been&hellip; 
 Per Ivar &mdash; and woe to him who shortens it; just like Odd-Knut, he wants you to say his name properly &mdash; is blond and cheerful, ashamed of his English (God knows why, in comparison to our Norwegian), and shy of the camera. 
 Bianca, sitting boldly upright in her kayak Svalbard , is suspicious of us and aggressively protective of Norway and all things Norwegian. 
 By the time she is leaving us she is wondering why she came. 
 The sun shines on the ferry as we do the last of the packing, The kayaks have lifted snouts and two holes, one at each end, closed and sealed by hard rubber covers. 
 Into these we store kit; rather like trying to push a piano through a thirty-centimetre hole. 
 The hard bits that will not go are tied to the deck fore and aft of the paddler. 
 I contemplate the thought of days spent looking along the length of Tony's tripod bag. 
 As the ferry nears Vengs&oslash;ya I talk to Tor about our chances of seeing an orca, a killer whale. 
 During our last dog sledge trip I had talked of my love of whales to Odd-Knut. 
 He tells me that a girlfriend of his was fishing, with her mother, from a rowing boat in the fjord near Troms&oslash; one day. 
 As dusk fell they decided to go in. 
 Odd-Knut's girlfriend lowered her oar into the water and it hit  something hard. 
 When she looked over the side in surprise, to her horror a huge orca surfaced just a metre away. 
 It turned lazily around and peered at her. 
 This eye contact unnerved the girl and sent the mother near hysterical, but having decided that they either meant no harm or, alternatively, that they were no good for eating, the orca lost interest and left. 
 I should be so lucky as to get that close. 
 Um, said Tor, but then went on to explain that only a week or two before he had been within a hundred metres or so of a school of orca. 
 Was he afraid? 
 Um, he said, thought a little and then said no, he didn't think he had been afraid. 
 Um, I said. 
 The inhabitants of Vengs&oslash;ya &mdash; or, at least, those near the ferry quay &mdash; watch us struggle on-shore with the kayaks with that curious air of pity, fear and interest I have seen before. 
 These people are going paddling on the Ocean. 
 Children wrestle to free their hands from their parents; Mummy, please let me go and throw stones at the idiots. 
 One comes and stands next to Tony, watching as   he secures the last bit to his boat. 
 Hello, says Tony, affably, how are you? 
 The kid grows wide-eyed; Mummy, mummy, the idiots talk all funny. 
 Vengs&ouml;ya 
 Campsite, Vengs&ouml;ya 
 I learned to canoe years ago when three of us put borrowed boats in the water at Glasbury and pulled them out, finally, several days later at Tintern, having gone down the Wye. 
 for many hours on day one the river seemed amazingly narrow, one bank of it always being on the front end of my canoe. 
 By the time I reached Tintern I could go in straight lines easily and had a right wrist the size of a tennis ball that was painful to touch and crackled ominously when I flexed it. 
 I hope that it was all good practice for the sea. 
 There is, true enough, no bank to poke into &mdash; get round the first headland and the next bank is the shore of Svalbard &mdash; but it would still be a good idea to be able to go in a straight line. 
 How do you do this? 
 Tony whispered as we carried our boats to the sea. 
 Calmly and quietly I suggested. 
 Sea-kayaks are unstable in comparison to river canoes I decide. 
 I ask Tor what the survival time is in the sea at this time of year. 
 He eyes me, thinking that, although I might have done a few things in the Arctic, I am still a tiny lad without any fat; he decides that it will be just a few minutes. 
 Comforting. 
 The Arctic Ocean from this distance, about a metre from eyes to surface, is even more wonderful than it seemed in Troms&oslash;. 
 It is so clear that to look into it takes your breath away: there is no sense of depth and the rocks could be two or twenty metres away. 
 When I was a kid I loved the seashore for its mix of beautiful, subtle colours and strong smells. 
 I recall how disappointed I was in the morning to discover that the pebbles I had collected so lovingly the evening before were just a pile of dull stones now that they had dried and were away from the beach. 
 Still, that discovery never stopped me from making another collection of the glistening best ones that same night. 
 Here the rocks and pebbles on the Ocean's floor are the same glistening colours, permanently etched because they can never dry. 
 The sea is calm, but such ripples as there are flick the light from the sun about and refract the view of the pebbles so that staring over the edge of the kayak is like peeing into a kaleidoscope over whose speed of rotation you have no control. 
 Often I find that I am many hundreds of metres behind the party when I escape from the trance of pattern-watching and childhood recall. 
 I paddle quickly, aware too that the Ocean's cold has gnawed its way uncomfortably through the thin GRP of the kayak and into my poorly protected flesh Tony waits for me, to point out a small brown luck that is lurking among some rocks to our right. 
 We paddle over to investigate. 
 It is a female eider, duller and browner now that the mating season &mdash; for which she did not, in any case, dress up &mdash; is over. 
 With her there is another bird which at first and with excitement we take for a king eider, but closer inspection reveals it to be an immature eider drake still paddling along near his mother. 
 Ahead and to our right a head breaks the surface. 
 The seal, too far away to be identified with certainty but probably a grey, peers myopically and is gone. 
 I suppress an evil wish that an orca will be drawn in by this moving lunchbox of an animal. 
 We round a headland and I am behind again because of staring downwards and then towards the horizon, willing an orca to break surface. 
 It is late and the sea is a little rougher so Tor decides to head for a sheltered inlet that he knows. 
 The inlet is an almost perfect semi-circle backed by huge cliffs whose vegetation-hung rocks defy their position. 
 How can it be that here, on a north-facing cliff, with nothing between it and the North pole and situated more than 300 kilometres north of the Arctic Circle, the vegetation can look like that. 
 A few hundred metres off-shore we congregate so that Tor can explain the best way of going ashore. 
 It is straightforward &mdash; you paddle like hell straight at the beach and with luck and strength can get the boat far enough up to ensure dry feet when you get out. 
 It works too. 
 Tony and I drag our boats up the beach and head off to the rocks, our balance oddly disturbed by the many hours afloat. 
 The  vegation  turns out to be more sparse than we had imagined. 
 It comprises stunted birch trees in the main, each tree with a mass of leaves. 
 I am puzzled. 
 Surely here, with day-long sunshine, there is no need for so many, and surely they just add to heat and water losses? 
 Under the trees there is a luxuriant mass of grass and moss beneath which numerous streams flow. 
 We discover this when we try to walk towards the cliffs, our progress hindered by the occasional disappearing foot and accompanying staccato shout of Shit ! 
 We camp Lappish style in a lavvu  that Tor, he of the wall-to-wall shoulders, has paddled here on his deck. 
 He has also brought a paraffin pressure stove (though if Optimus or Primus I am not sure)   of such proportions that correct plumbing would allow it to centrally heat a sizeable town. 
 I fetch water &mdash; an easy job, just grab a kettle, head for the cliffs and fill from the first stream you fall in &mdash; and offer it to Tor. 
 Almost by return I get a mug of tea. 
 Sea Kayak 
 We eat bread and the marvellous brown Norwegian cheese that looks and tastes like fudge. 
 The best is made from goat's milk, although the goat-cow milk mix offers a smoother taste. 
 I cut the cheese with the Lappish knife I acquired last time out; it has a 25-centimetre blade and can open cans, cut fire-wood and generally keep misery at bay. 
 Tor is impressed. 
 He takes it and examines it keenly. 
 Um, he says, and goes on to explain that in Norway a small, useless knife sometimes seen about the person of hunters and campers who have little idea is known as a &bquo;mouse castrator&equo;. 
 Our knife, he decides, does not fall into that category. 
 Later we all climb to the top of the cliffs behind the bay, an arduous scramble up step, stream-washed scree. 
 At the top, perhaps three hundred  metres or so above the camp, the view is phenomenal. 
 flat-topped Sandoya rears up out of the sea, with, behind it, the tent-like shape of S&oslash;r-Fugl&oslash;ya, a bird reserve. 
 Per Ivar tells me his mother comes from Sand&oslash;ya. 
 Life there was hard, especially in winter and today no one over-winters on the island, islanders preferring to fish and farm in summer and to retreat to the comforts of Troms&oslash; in winter. 
 I suggest that it is sad that a way of life that is so ancient is ending, but Per Ivar is less convinced. 
 It is easy to be romantic about a way of life at one remove. 
 Maybe if I was on Sand&oslash;ya when winter came, when the sun went in for two or three months, when all the water froze, when ice covered the ground and fishing was a risky business of frozen fingers and ears, on water in which survival was measured in seconds, I would be less romantic about it. 
 Probably I would be more convinced that Troms&oslash;, with its snug wooden houses, its thick air-spaced double glazing, its heating systems, its hot water from the tap, its colour televisions and supermarkets, was not just a retreat from reality. 
 Sea Kayaking, Kaldfjorden 
 The Norwegians choose a long ridge walk to go  back to the camp and by the time they have arrived, Tony and I have decided to take the kayaks out on to the Ocean. 
 Tor looks at his watch. 
 It is approaching midnight, but he agrees it is a fine idea. 
 Minutes later we are heading for a small island group north of Vengs&oslash;ya, to round that and head on for the next. 
 The trip is one of the most beautiful I have known. 
 The sun is setting now, midnight sun ending a few weeks before, but it only disappears for an hour and even then it leaves behind its mark of golden twilight. 
 I sit on the first island to photograph the kayaks heading north into the last of the sun, then refloat again to join them. 
 The low-angle light smears colours, so that the Ocean is uniformly dark brown. 
 Above, the sky is yellow and yellow-orange, a thin band of cloud on fire with the red of the dying sun. 
 S&ouml;-Fugl&ouml;ya and Sand&ouml;ya from Vengs&ouml;ya 
 The Ocean is calm, so calm you could believe it to be lacquered wood rather than water and that if you were in a hurry you could leave the boat and walk to shore. 
 The sun disappears, leaving behind its glow on the horizon as if the colour is in my head, burnt in by gazing too long at the red sphere. 
 We stop paddling and rock very gently. 
 Tony paddles over; the dripping water from his paddle ends, and the suck of water into the holes they leave behind are the only sounds for miles. 
 We talk, using the hushed tones you would reserve for a furtive conversation in church. 
 Time passes. 
 I gaze at the island, a dark mass against the still-light sky. 
 The highest point on Vengs&oslash;ya, a little over two thousand feet above the Ocean's surface, suddenly turns pink. 
 Not green or brown, but pink. 
 We watch, and the pink spreads downwards as the sun rises behind us. 
 We are in the wrong position to see the flash of light as the sun erupts again, settling instead for seeing it emerge from behind the northward island as we paddle slowly in. 
 I try to sleep, but cannot, and go for a walk along the shore and on to a ridge from where S&oslash;r-Fugl&oslash;ya is thrown into relief by the blinding sun. 
 Life is a privilege. 
 The privilege lasts through a good period of fine weather. 
 We paddle on seas the green of cat's eyes, and seas as clear as mountain streams. 
 We are watched by seals. 
 We see through jellyfish that are ghostly pale blue outlines in the water. 
 One day we see not one, nor even one pair, but two pairs of sea eagles lift off from the cliffs under which we are paddling. 
 One bird drifts overhead and I swear it is gazing at my quill-like yellow boat as I am gazing at its white tail. 
 Black guillemots ( teiste  in Norwegian) dive and disappear as we approach. 
 A shoal of fish jumps out of the sea, a sight to quicken the heart as Tor says this often happens when the fish are being chased by orca. 
 But there is no orca. 
 The fine weather brings out butterflies &mdash; something else to surprise the infrequent Arctic traveller &mdash; &mdash; and mosquitos with jaws like drills. 
 For days after we are all victims to the angry itching bumps they leave all over us. 
 They drive me to distraction: at first I refuse to fight back, on the grounds that life is sacred and it is not their fault that they are mosquitos, but I eventually join in the swatting that punctuates the quiet every so often. 
 It is, I decide, not my fault either that I am a human being who does not want to be eaten alive. 
 During one meal I swat one off my arm and ask Tor if he knows what was the last thing that went through the mozzie's mind. 
 Leila helps translate this for me as she, but not he, understands the colloquialism. 
 No, he admits, when he understands, what? 
 His ass, I suggest, wondering how the bluntness of the joke will go down. 
 The taciturn Tor falls off his log and eventually complains of painful stomach muscles. 
 All over north Norway now this characteristic English reply is a trade mark of those who know the mighty Tor. 
 Finally, we make for home, heading past Vengs&oslash;ya towards the mainland. 
 All morning it has been calm but now we are threatened by a storm that has been brewing out to the west. 
 It hurls itself around the island and in seconds the sea is alive, ugly waves crashing over the boats, white horses flicking over the surface on the hooves of the wind. 
 The sea worsens, the waves rising in height, and to add to the misery a sleety rain starts to emerge from the wind. 
 Unable to stop paddling for fear of capsizing, Tony and I cannot put on our anoraks and within a few minutes we are soaked by the freezing combination of sea and rain. 
 My glasses are creased by running water and I can no longer see past the end of the boat. 
 I ask Tor, who has come across to see how I am coping, if this is normal, a guarded, off-the-cuff way of informing him that I am shit-scared and would like the weather to change. 
 It is, he says, pretty bad. 
 Can it get worse and still be survivable? 
 Yes, he says, he has known it a little worse, but not much. 
 It is rough, he says, very bad. 
 He is glad, he says, it is not too far.     
 Sunset 
 Loading the kayaks at Belvik 
 Midnight launch 
 Not too far is about eight kilometres, a distance that takes us well over an hour, although time is irrelevant. 
 We are paddling at 45 degrees to the sea so on every wave the paddle must be just so to stop the boat going over. 
 It is a wearying business, and I find myself thinking again and again of the lecture I went to on surviving in dangerous situations. 
 The lecturer gave his definition of stress &mdash; a sense of impending incontinence. 
 Never before today have I realized that the man was offering a Great Truth. 
 Tor suggests we try to stop in the small bay where we will touch the mainland. 
 If we can go ashore we can have coffee and Tony and I can put on our anoraks. 
 Sounds good to me. 
 As we near the bay, Tony and I draw level. 
 How is it going, can you see yourself going all the way? 
 Well, I take every wave as it comes, Brian. 
 But they do win through. 
 The lads done well. 
 Getting ashore is tricky, with the sea threatening to destroy the boats on the boulders at the edge. 
 I haul my kayak up with what seems to be the last of my strength. 
 I am soaked, cold and not a little lacking in enthusiasm for the next try. 
 Tor goes off to a cottage up the hill from the bay and comes back disconsolate, having been told to &bquo;piss off&equo; by the occupants who were robbed last week and are not in any mood to offer the traditional Norwegian hospitality to a motley collection of bedraggled canoeists. 
 All the matches are wet, so we cram down a few handfuls of cheese and boiled sweets. 
 We change into drier &mdash; not dry &mdash; kit and go again. 
 The storm abates a bit, and there is no problem in reaching our start point. 
 Taking the boats out of the water and loading them on the cars is a chore. 
 Then everything must go in plastic bags so the car doesn't get wet. 
 Leila drives, a remarkable performance given that we are so wet and steaming that she must peer through condensation thick enough to carve. 
 She has, she says, only enough petrol to reach the first garage. 
 It is closed.  
 WINTER &mdash; SLEDGING 
 &bquo;Good afternoon, ladies and gentlemen, this is the captain speaking. 
 We are flying at a height of 11,000 metres and at a speed of just under 750kph. 
 We expect to be landing in Oslo in about fifty minutes. 
 It is a good day in Oslo. 
 The temperature is 2&deg;C (36&deg;F) and it is raining&equo;. 
 No one seemed to think this an out of place remark, but the three of us fell about. 
 Tony and I had organized a dog sledging trip which we hoped would take us from Dividal in northern Norway through Sweden and into Finland. 
 After his good showing the previous autumn Nathan was coming too. 
 He and Tony got on well: they started arguing over whether it was better to have two bits of black pudding rather than two sausages in the terminal caf&eacute;, and when that battle was over they started another about who was going to have the window seat on the plane. 
 Tony's meal was a revelation &mdash; solid cholesterol from first forkful to last. 
 It brought a new meaning to the phrase &bquo;terminal breakfast.' 
 At Oslo the performance of transferring the kit was an epic. 
 Tony's cameras were in three largish bags and each of us had a very large rucsac. 
 In addition there was a roll bag that our &bquo;tidy&equo; stuff was going in. 
 We were a two-trolley group. 
 Tony was bearded for the trip. 
 Having decided that he was very unlikely to shave for next sixteen or so days he wanted his beard to be at the past-scratch stage when he arrived. 
 I had my Arctic haircut, long and rat's-nested. 
 Nathan had needed no special arrangements: when very well dressed he looks scruffy &mdash; I suppose it must be a gift; it is certainly true that he couldn't give it away &mdash; and today he was not very well dressed. 
 We were, therefore, a to-be-avoided, two-trolley group. 
 Mothers kept their children away from us, and were grateful when we had checked in and gone for a coffee. 
 Troms&oslash; had no more snow than we had seen in the autumn, but it was colder. 
 It was a raw cold too, the cold of being close to the ocean, a wet cold &mdash; &mdash; if that is not a contradiction for a temperature down around &mdash; -12&deg;C (10&deg;F). 
 It was a shrug the shoulders, sink the hands deep in the pockets and be fed up about the running nose cold. 
 It was too late to go to the campsite, or even to get a bus out of town, so we stopped at a hotel where they worried about us and charged too much for Coke. 
 We rang our dog man, Odd-Knut Thoresen, and told him we had arrived. 
 We had not yet met Odd-Knut, but his voice was friendly and competent. 
 He knocked on the door of the room I was sharing with Nathan while I was repacking kit. 
 Nat let him in and went to fetch Tony who appeared wearing a pair of boxer shorts and a big smile. 
 It turned out that he had locked himself out of his room which was likely to be embarrassing as I, for one, was not about to go down to reception for a key for him. 
 Odd-Knut had a Viking shock of blond hair, but little other resemblance to the Hollywood Norseman. 
 He was slight and short-sighted, with a gentle smile that belied an amazing toughness and an ability to withstand cold that was to beggar our belief. 
 He eyed Nathan suspiciously, clearly wondering whether he would survive the trip, but gave a reassuring &bquo;impressed&equo; look when Nat told him about our trip over Tromsdalen. 
 We went for a coffee and Odd-Knut explained his ideas for the trip. 
 He would pick us up tomorrow early and we could help buy some last bits and pieces. 
 Then we could go to his place and learn to sledge. 
 The day after it was off to Rostadalen to start. 
 We asked about going into Finland but he shook his head. 
 Rabies had reached southern Finland and there was an embargo on crossborder dog movements. 
 True, the disease would sooner or later reach Norway after travelling up through Finland, but the Norwegian government had decided to stall it as long as possible. 
 Who could blame them? 
 Odd-Knut &mdash; whose English was good enough to know that he did not want us to call him &bquo;Odd&equo; &mdash; suggested that he could leave us near the Finnish border and we could ski or walk the last bit. 
 We talked about the wildlife of the area and what we might see. 
 Odd-Knut smiled at us. 
 Later we were to learn that if you travel with two dozen sledge dogs you see no wildlife. 
 We drank coffee and talked some more. 
 Odd-Knut rolled a thin cigarette and poured himself yet  another coffee. 
 Tony bought him a whisky and then bought him another. 
 Outside the caf&eacute; the night sky was filled with the pale light of a ripening moon, invisible from here except as a shimmer on the quiet ocean. 
 Several months later, Nathan wrote up his dog sledging trip for a school project. 
 He was having some trouble with one section. 
 He was describing Odd-Knut's Volvo which arrived the next morning, the like of which I have yet to see again. 
 It was an estate, the hatch door being held down by gravity. 
 There were sections of smooth plate occasionally between the dents and here and there paint of an ancient Volvo hue showed through a patina of decrepitude. 
 Nathan thought hard and finally wrote that the Volvo was &bquo;old and depressed&equo;. 
 I can't improve on that. 
 We loaded our kit into the car and went into the town. 
 Odd-Knut dropped us off so that he could go and get the last of his dog food. 
 I casually wondered whether this meant 50 tins of Pedigree Chum and then ambled off after Tony who was being shown the Arctic Ocean by Nathan. 
 Tony set up his tripod in a snow drift and started to contemplate a shot, so we left him to it and visited the town's Polar Museum. 
 It was an intriguing place, full of photos of early explorers and of Roald Amundsen, who left Troms&oslash; for his Arctic nemesis. 
 Nathan was intrigued by a polar bear trap used when the Norwegians saw the big white bear as target rather than as tourist attraction. 
 The trap was hideously unpleasant and, probably, equally hideously effective. 
 Elsewhere there was a reconstructed hut which came alive with sound when you walked through a hidden beam. 
 There were dog howls, wind howls and ice creaks. 
 The suggestion was that Arctic travel was a miserable journey into a land of cold and fear. 
 Odd-Knut picked us up again and we went off to buy him and Tony some beer, available in Norway only at government alcohol shops. 
 Then he took us to the university where a friend of his, an Englishman, was studying the local bird life. 
 He was a fascinating man who shared with us some of his delight in Arctic birds and animals. 
 As he spoke I noticed, over his shoulder and out of his study window, a large grey bird go past, moving quickly with the wind. 
 I asked him what it might have been; after all, if he was an expert on the local birds then he ought to know. 
 He looked puzzled and for a better description. 
 Well, I said, it was about so long &mdash; hands out at just beyond shoulder width &mdash; and about this much across the wings &mdash; hands now indicating a fair wingspan of several feet &mdash; and it was grey, well, greyish. 
 He shook his head. 
 No, no that didn't fit the description of anything we had ever seen or heard about. 
 Was I sure it wasn't white? 
 No, grey. 
 And that big? 
 Yes, perhaps even a little bigger. 
 He shook his head again. 
 The others joined in the story. 
 Was I sure I had seen it at all? 
 Of course I was. 
 Well, perhaps&hellip; and so on. 
 In the end, to draw matters to an unhappy conclusion they all agreed that it had probably been a bin liner. 
 Odd-Knut Thoresen was the Troms&oslash; dog collector and owner of the local dog hotel. 
 In midwinter &mdash; it was the first week of February &mdash; there were few dogs in his compounds, although there was one large, affable-looking but wholly terrified cat. 
 Outside, doing their best to frighten the cat spitless with their howling, were fifty sledge dogs, each chained to a kennel, well separated to stop their most frequent game, that of tearing lumps out of each other. 
 We called them huskies, as you might expect, but Odd-Knut was not happy with the name. 
 They were a cross-breed, Alaskan and Greenland. 
 Since Greenland dogs were always dogs not huskies he preferred that name. 
 The Siberian animals, beautiful silvery creatures I had worked with once before in Switzerland, were huskies. 
 He took us inside and introduced us to Kjell-Arne, a lanky, shy youth who worked for him and was told to make coffee, and Tove, the kennel girl. 
 Her moon-shaped face was always split with a smile, even when she was scooping up dog turds with a device the handle of which was at least two feet shorter than I would have wanted it to be. 
 We were shown our sledges. 
 Not for us the tourist sledge of the one- or two-day package visitor, a short contraption, more tea tray than means of transport. 
 Our sledges were long and sleek, with pine-resined or PTFE runners and compartments of wood and nylon for our kit. 
 First we will learn to harness the dogs, said Odd-Knut. 
 He took off his shoes, climbed into a chair, rolled a cigarette and poured himself a coffee. 
 We waited. 
 And three hours later we were still waiting. 
 The best time of day to ride sledges is at night, and shifting Odd-Knut in daylight needed explosives. 
 Nathan turned the conversation to the bear trap in the museum, asking Odd-Knut if he had seen it, and soon we were talking about the killing of   film on seal killing had been shown, an indictment of the Norwegian sealers. 
 Odd-Knut said that the locals, many of whom were in the fishing and related trades, were incensed. 
 They insisted that the film had been shot in Canada in 1957, despite what the voice-over said. 
 On Norwegian ships, if someone was a bad killer they would be locked in the holds, they said. 
 If Lindberg was to come to Troms&oslash; he would be hung from a lamp-post, probably by his balls. 
 This last comment was the only one I could feel was definitely true. 
 View west from Bl&aring;mannen on Kval&ouml;y near Troms&oslash; 
 The conversation drifted to whaling, where the Norwegian record also seemed lacking in compassion and common sense. 
 Odd-Knut found that record harder to defend, and ultimately gave up trying. 
 To lighten the proceedings he told us of an incident some years ago when there had still been a whaling station in the town. 
 A group of Germans &mdash; &bquo;fat Germans&equo;, he insisted &mdash; was being shown around when an ancient whale carcass, blown big on decay gas pressure, exploded. 
 The visitors were covered from head to foot in over-ripe whale bits. 
 With great glee Odd-Knut told us that the fat Germans showered ten times every day for a week and still reeked of rotten whale. 
 This was not the first time I had noticed the old enmity of the Norwegians for the Germans. 
 Once, I had inadvertently called Nordic skiing langlauf  and had been lucky to escape alive. 
 Old memories die hard, especially in a town like Troms&oslash; which was home to a large contingent of the German navy. 
 Tirpitz  lies at the bottom of the local fjord, and every year the local diving club goes down to it on New Year's Day to retrieve a handful of bits guaranteed to fuel the old fires for another year. 
 Odd-Knut showed us a video of the Iditarod, intriguing for what it didn't tell you which, as it turned out, was quite a lot. 
 He told us about the longest race in Norway; he had taken part and had done very well, finishing very close to the front of the &bquo;amateur&equo; racers (as opposed to those who race dogs for a living). 
 Norwegian television had followed the big race the previous year and about 100 kilometres from its end had stopped the leader to interview him. 
 The man was not wanting to be interviewed, but such is the power of television that he had to agree. 
 They did a take, and then another. 
 It was cold and the man's dogs lay down to rest and stay warm. 
 By the time the interview was over the dogs were all asleep and refused to wake up. 
 The sledger shouted and kicked, he  cursed the dogs and swore at the television crew The dogs slept on and the race went past him. 
 Odd-Knut explained the theory of dog sledging. 
 Keep your lines straight and taut and your dogs will go faster. 
 Keep one eye on them at all times to avoid problems. 
 If one stops for a piss the rest might catch up and if they do they will either fall straight over him so that you finish with a ball of dogs that will take forever to unwind, or they will take lumps out of him. 
 When feeding your dogs don't hand them their meat or they might take it from your elbow down. 
 When your dogs are eating it is not a good idea to pat them; if they think you are trying to take their food they will defend it with your life. 
 It was sobering. 
 At the front the sledge has a semi-circle of lathed wood hinged to it. 
 This piece allows the dog line the tow line &mdash; to operate in a different plane to the sledge and also absorbs some of shock of towing. 
 Each dog is attached to the tow line twice. 
 To get the sledge ready you anchor it firmly; this is vital because once you have attached your first dog he will start to tow and the whole shooting match will be long gone by the time you get back with your second dog. 
 To fix the sledge you use the snow hook, shaped like a double fish hook but about a foot long and wide. 
 You use this both to anchor the sledge during a trip, by stamping it into the snow, and at the start of each day to hold the sledge, by clunking it on to a tree trunk. 
 Having anchored your sledge you fix your tow line to the front hinge piece, using a karabiner. 
 The snow hook is actually on the end of the tow line so that in the unlikely event of the karabiner unhooking &mdash; as it did once on me &mdash; &mdash; the hook stays close to you giving you an outside chance of holding on to the team. 
 Next you take a lead dog and put on its harness of padded nylon; this goes over the head and the front legs poke through stitched loops. 
 Down the dog's back runs a nylon tape with a small karabiner at its ends, which hooks on to a tug line that is crimped on to the tow line. 
 Both tow line and tug line are wire encased in nylon; if they were just nylon the dogs would chew through them. 
 After the dog is clipped to the tug line it is clipped to a neck line so that it is held tight in position relative to the tow line. 
 If you are running with one lead dog then it attaches to both the front tug lines and has no neck line. 
 If you are running with two lead dogs then you clip one on each of the front tug lines, and neck line them together. 
 Now you attach your lead dog to a tree, or the sledge in front, or anything to keep your tow line taut. 
 If you forget, as you turn to go for another dog the lead dog, being a friendly creature, will come with you. 
 It will probably then go round the other side of the sledge and might even go over the snow hook line. 
 Give him thirty seconds and you will have knitting. 
 After your lead dogs are guyed out you attach the next pair, the point dogs. 
 there could be several pairs of these. 
 On one part of our trip Odd-Knut, for all sorts of reasons, ran with eight dogs. 
 Finally you attach your closest dogs, the wheel dog pair. 
 Now you are ready to go. 
 Now comes the dodgy part. 
 But we are still drinking coffee in a dog kennel. 
 The evening wears on and we all shuffle impatiently. 
 Suddenly Odd-Knut gets up and asks if we would like to go dog sledging. 
 We dress up like bit-part players in an epic on Scott and go out into the night where the air bites clean and deep, and the snow crunches in that beautiful cold way. 
 After the horror stories about the dogs I hesitate to go near my first one, but with us they are just big balls of fur. 
 They are chained separately only to keep them clear of each other. 
 I move in on a twenty-kilogram monster, all bark and paws. 
 Nice doggy, good doggy . 
 Doggy leaps up on me and tries to wash my face with a tongue like a coarse bastard file. 
 It bone breaths all over me. 
 Jesus, what does he feed them on? 
 That was 'orrible. 
 The dog seems anxious to get the harness on; indeed, all through the trip the dogs are always keen to pull and seem miserable when they are tied off for the night. 
 Between us we harness two teams and go out with one of us sitting in a sledge driven by Tove, one on the back of Odd-Knut's Sno-Go snow scooter, and the other tentatively riding the second sledge. 
 With a team in front, life is easier as the dogs follow and all we have to do is keep the tow line taut and holler the occasional encouraging word, as much to each other as to the dogs. 
 Riding in the sledge is an experience. 
 Encased in pile and nylon, hoods drawn tight, it would be easy to forget the world in a welter of sensations, were it not for the running commentary that Tove keeps up. 
 &bquo;Hold on to the sledge rails here &mdash; keep a loose grip or your hands get tired &mdash; try not to keep your foot on the brake (a miniature snow hook held off the snow by an elasticated octopus grip) or your   other leg will get tired &mdash; don't shout too much at the dogs or they get confused &mdash; the occasional quiet word is helpful &mdash; on downhills brake gently if you need to so that the line stays tight.' 
 And there is much more advice that I did not take in, except that later I remember it when a new situation arises. 
 For the moment I am concentrating mostly on the fact that I am riding under the Arctic sky, a very black sky, heavily overcast, being pulled across the ice by a team of dogs. 
 They are silent. 
 Only during a stop do they howl or yelp, as the frustration of inactivity gets to them. 
 They are moving at good speed &mdash; we are on one of Odd-Knut's prepared training runs &mdash; perhaps topping 30kph on the level sections. 
 When you are held in tight beneath the sledge's nylon coverall   that feels very quick. 
 Occasionally the front of the sledge runner, about 2 or 3 metres in front of me, hits a hummock of snow and my face is thwacked by a handful of icy flour. 
 I spit it out and flick it from my eyes. 
 It adds to the exhilaration, bringing a smile rather than a frown. 
 Next backwards comes a waft of dog fart. 
 In the days that follow we learn about this smell, which varies from ugh ! and a turn of the head to really gut-wrenching. 
 Tonight it is just another sensation. 
 Sledge dog 
 Taiga 
 Dawn sledging, Rostadalen 
 When it is my turn on the sledge the experience is incomparable. 
 Not like learning to drive a car, not even like riding a horse. 
 There is a sense of isolation from the rest of the world, a sense of the power in the dogs, and a wonderful feeling of being in control, but only just. 
 It is perhaps like being on top of a big wave in a canoe or on a surfboard, but to try to describe it is to fail. 
 The following day we packed Odd-Knut's depressed Volvo. 
 On its roof there were four sledges &mdash; three ordinary ones for the three of us, and a monster for Odd-Knut, built, it seemed to us, to carry everything including the proverbial. 
 In the back of the car was our kit. 
 The overspill (considerable) was packed into what space was left on the roof (inadequate). 
 Hooked up at the back was a double-decker dog carrier, each deck having four holes to a side, giving a total of sixteen holes. 
 Twelve of these were packed with two dogs in each, two dozen dogs. 
 I was not looking forward to the packing. 
 The second row of holes was at chest level. 
 Hands up those wanting to lift a twenty-kilogram dog into a 25-centimetre hole a that height. 
 In fact, the dogs could not wait to get in. 
 Each time we went for another animal all those left howled and fought their chains to get close to us so as not to be left behind. 
 As we collected a dog it would lurch towards the car, the rest falling silent in their disappointment. 
 Our only problem was with the doubling up. 
 Get the wrong number two dog in with a number one and the cuddly koala in your arms turned into megatooth. 
 We filled the spare holes with harnesses. 
 As I loaded them in there was a sharp reminder of the night before. 
 The harness stank of dog, that unpleasant smell which big-dog owners never seem to notice in their own house. 
 Here it was again, but so strong as to be an insult to the word stench. 
 Later during the trip I noticed that one morning the smell hadn't registered with me. 
 I took me a while to cotton on. 
 By then everything I wore smelled of it too. 
 With 500 kilograms of dog, about the same quantity of dog food, sledges and kit, plus the four of us on board, we made our way out of Odd Knut's drive. 
 The main road was ice-covered. 
 Why not? 
 Everything else was. 
 Odd-Knut had studded tyres and Alain Prost delusions. 
 Tony sat in the front. 
 He was used to this sort of thing, he drives a big motorbike. 
 When we went round the first corner at about 90kph Tony went very quiet. 
 It was a long trip, not helped by a tyre that cried &bquo;enough!&equo; in the middle of nowhere and required changing &mdash; a job made more difficult by the fact that Odd-Knut had no spare &mdash; but ultimately we arrived at the entrance to Rostadalen. 
 The snow was so deep we could make no progress, so we went around into Dividal instead. 
 It was late when we finally eased our stiff limbs into the night. 
 The sky was clear, the stars were beautiful and the snow creaked underfoot. 
 Our breath made huge clouds of steam which hid our faces as we talked, and we hopped about and shrugged elaborately to ward off the penetrating fingers of cold that probed at our necks and hands. 
 The sledges came down first and were loaded with tents, dog food and our kit. 
 The dogs grew noisy with excitement, and each wire door was now filled with the pressed muzzle of an anxious face. 
 Carefully we laid out the tow lines and attached our snow hooks, Tony to one roadside fence post, me to another, Nathan to the bumper of Odd-Knut's car. 
 Odd-Knut was ahead of us, so that nothing would stop him being first away. 
 The unpacking of the car and the packing and preparing of sledges took a long time. 
 It was dark, and all the fiddly jobs like clipping in the dogs or tying kit on to the sledges meant taking off gloves. 
 After just a minute or so, especially if we were handling metal, we would need to stop and huff on to frozen fingers, standing around with pained expressions while circulation returned. 
 During one such stop I looked up. 
 In the lead-up to the trip I had been telling Nat about the Northern Lights and how wonderful they were. 
 Now the sky above Dividal was filled with the most glorious Lights I had ever seen, a shimmering waterfall of green light. 
 &bquo;Nat, look.&equo; 
 I pointed up. 
 He stopped packing rucsacs on to his sledge and looked. 
 He did not say a word, just stared at the sky. 
 For once, the product had turned out to be even better than the advert. 
 Tony and Odd-Knut stopped work too, and there was a silent time,  broken only by Tony's mad rush to find his camera and tripod. 
 We had chosen our visit to coincide with the full moon, but it also coincided with a period of maximum solar flare activity, and on every clear night the Lights treated us to a spectacular show in green and red. 
 As we watched, a man arrived on a snow scooter and he and Odd-Knut talked long and quietly. 
 When he left Odd-Knut told us he was Lappish, and that when asked if the trail to our campsite was piled high with snow he had said yes it was, but that he would break it for us if we were willing to pay. 
 Odd-Knut, not willing to spend our money and not inspired by his attitude, declined. 
 In that case the Lapp had said he would do it for a few drinks if we had any with us. 
 Odd-Knut agreed, but only if the bottle was found tomorrow rather than today. 
 The Lapp shrugged and left. 
 Odd-Knut did not know if he would break trail. 
 The next day the Lapp arrived for his drink, but we had seen no evidence of a trail. 
 At last everything was ready. 
 At close to midnight, when the three of us were already tired, Odd-Knut slipped his snow hook and was gone, so fast I was stunned. 
 Tony, over to my right, shouted something to me, released his hook and was gone. 
 My dogs were straining against the sledge now and yelping as if badly hurt. 
 I took hold of the snow hook, but to release it meant hauling in some slack on the line. 
 The five dogs on the other end of it were not impressed with the idea of going backwards and battle was joined. 
 There was a loud whoaa ! to my left and Nathan shot past. 
 He shouted something at me or at his dogs, I don't even now know which, and was gone into the night. 
 My dogs were frantic, and so was I, I hauled one last time, the line came back two centimetres, the hook came free and the dogs roared away. 
 from standstill to top speed was, it seemed, instant, with me fighting to stay in balance as the sledge buckled over the rough trail. 
 The journey started easily enough, the way going up a track that in summer is an unsurfaced road used by tourists. 
 Soon the going became very rough, with deep snow that constantly stopped Odd-Knut's dogs. 
 Frequently we stopped, turned and went back for another try to the left or right Our order did not change, with Odd-Knut out in front, then Tony and Nathan, and me bringing the line to an end. 
 At the back, sometimes out of sight of the others, I became engrossed in my own problems. 
 I was tired, very tired. 
 I was also sick and tired. 
 Sick and tired of stopping and starting, of going up banks only to go down them again, of being whacked in the face by the branches of trees that the dogs ran under, and of not knowing where we were going or why. 
 Why were we in this bloody forest anyway? 
 Why did we not just stop and camp? 
 Up front Tony was asking the same questions. 
 We were in the forest to try to get less deep snow, he was told; we were going to a campsite that Odd-Knut had prepared. 
 Nat turned and shouted this garbled message to me and I hooked my dogs to a tree and went forward to talk to him. 
 In the light of my head torch I could see that Nat was grey-faced with fatigue, his eyelids drooping, his mouth surrounded by frost that he had not had the strength to wipe away. 
 Snow from the trees had fallen all over us and his arms and shoulders were covered in a white dust that sparkled in the light from my lamp. 
 I could not see his feet as snow ploughed up from his brake when he had last stepped on it reached to about mid-calf. 
 I was appalled. 
 What right had I to bring him here and to inflict this sort of suffering on him? 
 Are you OK? 
 I asked. 
 He smiled. 
 fine, he said, this is great isn't it? 
 His face lit up suddenly, he wiped his mouth and shook his feet free of the snow cocoon. 
 Back there, he said, did you see me go over that bump? 
 I went right up in the air. 
 I could have held him tight and told him I was proud of him and that I loved him just for being there, but he would have struggled free. 
 So I settled for dusting off his shoulder and giving it a quick squeeze. 
 He smiled again, and then was gone, off in pursuit of Tony who had started moving again. 
 By the time I am ready to move again everyone has gone. 
 The dogs follow the trail, so there is no problem, but it does mean that I miss seeing the sudden three metre drop that we go down to reach a frozen river. 
 The bottom is reached with a mind-numbing crash that jars every bone, but at least this thaws out my brain. 
 We follow the river, very easy going, and then leave it to go uphill through very deep snow that means we have to push the sledges rather than ride them. 
 The country is more open here, with fewer trees and flatter ground. 
 Ahead I can see that Odd-Knut has stopped and is off his sledge. 
 Tony stops too. 
 Oh Christ, not more delay. 
 But no. 
 In the centre of the clearing where they have stopped is a Red Indian wigwam, the one  Odd-Knut erected a few days before. 
 We have arrived. 
 I look at my watch. 
 It is just past three in the morning, and the journey here has taken a little over three hours. 
 I am dog-tired, as are the dogs. 
 My legs are stiff with inactivity and cold and my breath freezes in front of me to obscure the view. 
 It is groaningly cold, possibly as low as &mdash; -225&deg;C ( &mdash; -13&deg;F), although we cannot be sure as Tony's thermometer is buried under a mound of tackle. 
 We unharness the dogs and attach them to a chain that Odd-Knut fastens between two trees. 
 Even when they are off the sledges the dogs are kept apart. 
 OK, says Odd-Knut, we must pitch the other tent and get some food. 
 When we have the chance we will camp Lappish style, with lavvus , the wigwam tents made of birch poles and reindeer skins, but tonight we are using a modern lavvu  of canvas and aluminium poles. 
 Tony and I dig a platform for the tent, lowering the snow by about seventy centimetres to give us a nice protective wall. 
 The lavvu  goes up, the canvas at the bottom held down by shovelled snow. 
 While we do this Nathan is off cutting birch twigs. 
 Odd-Knut has given him a hunting knife, and pointed him at the trees. 
 I go over to help and find him upright but asleep, his head against the trunk of a tree, the knife, evil-looking with a thirty-centimetre blade, half held in his hand. 
 I wake him gently. 
 We cut small branches between us and these are laid on the floor of the tent. 
 Next on go reindeer skins, then our own Karrimats and sleeping bags. 
 Nathan needs to be helped from his shell clothing he is so tired, but we insist he must stay awake to eat. 
 Tony and I cut wood while Odd-Knut erects a wood-burning stove in the tent. 
 The fire is soon going and we have tea and eat  something &mdash; God knows what. 
 Nathan is propped up against a rucsac with a cup, plate and two glazed eyes. 
 He eats mechanically, because we say he must. 
 He finishes and asks if he can sleep now. 
 I say yes and he keels over, being asleep before his head reaches the floor, his shoulders and arms still out of the bag. 
 I ease him into it and then make for my own. 
 I assume I must have made it because when the noise of movement outside wakes me four hours later that is where I am. 
 Lappish lavvu 
 The lavvu  is a shambles; everywhere there is clothing, the nylon stiff with cold. 
 Nat's Dachsteins, dropped on a piece of exposed ground, are frozen solidly to it, have to be prised free, and will need to be thawed over the stove. 
 Words are exchanged, and there is a tense moment or two. 
 Tony, ever sensible, ever the peacemaker, suggests that we were all tired, still are, and it might all look better after a cup of tea. 
 He hands me a billy and suggests I get some snow for water and a few twigs to start the fire. 
 He also suggests that it might be a good idea if we move one at a time to avoid a ridiculous crush in the tent; I should get up and move out, then he will get up and start the fire, then Nathan can get up last. 
 Agreed. 
 Getting up is purgatory. 
 I have slept in a full set of thermal underwear, but the cold gets to me as soon as I leave the bag. 
 I hastily dress, but there is limit to how fast you can put on two or three layers of clothes. 
 Outside Odd-Knut is feeding the dogs in miserable weather. 
 It is not snowing, but there is enough wind to be chilling and the day is grey and misty, so I get little sense of where the camp is, with visibility only a few tens of metres. 
 I collect snow and start off for the nearest dead tree with the big knife and an axe. 
 I come back with an armful of dead birch to find Tony digging films out of a snowdrift near the tent. 
 He takes the wood and disappears back into the tent. 
 I amble over to Odd-Knut to ask a few dumb questions. 
 He answers patiently. 
 Breakfast is tea and muesli, the muesli made  with hot water and milk powder. 
 Nathan gets and goes off in search of somewhere quiet, clutching a toilet roll and anxious anticipations. 
 Odd-Knut makes coffee using the method we have become familiar with &mdash; chuck the coffee in a pot, add snow to taste, boil on the stove, when empty add coffee and/or snow as necessary. 
 After the third filling it was a treacly mixture that certainly woke you up. 
 Nathan returns, suggesting that you need to be in a sheltered spot for minimum discomfort; he thinks that constipation is to be feared almost as much as the wind. 
 Tony asks him whether he dug a hole, but he says no need, the stuff just melts its way down. 
 Odd-Knut is much amused by all this talk, and tells us that in Greenland the sledge dogs will eat it if they can get at it. 
 Will they really? 
 Avoiding a tree 
 Odd-Knut produces a bottle of Wolf's paw, a local spirit drink, and offers it around. 
 As the nondrinker I get first go (why?) and it takes my breath away. 
 Tony tries and with his eyes watering declares it a good noggin. 
 Thankfully Nat declines. 
 We tidy the tent, sort our kit and the light starts to fade. 
 Odd-Knut thinks that it might be best to make a night trip with empty sledges, returning to the camp, especially as a friend of his is likely to arrive for the night. 
 We all agree. 
 More tea is drunk, food is eaten. 
 We stretch out in the lavvu  which is pleasantly warm now after a day of the stove being ablaze. 
 Odd-Knut's friend Tom-Frode arrives, a perpetually smiling man with hands like dinner plates. 
 It is past nine by the time we start to harness the dogs, and the sky is a little clearer, the temperature a little cooler. 
 Again, when we move off the speed startles me. 
 Apparently, the tow given to old whalers by a harpooned whale was known as the &bquo;Nantucket Sleighride&equo;; I haul back on the line, release the snow hook and take a similar ride. 
 We move through a band of forest and then start to climb steeply, going up over 300 metres at a good steady speed. 
 Nathan is behind this time which means I can have the occasional shouted conversation with Tony. 
 This is fantastic, he shouts. 
 This is unreal, he continues. 
 No one will ever believe us. 
 He's right. 
 It is fantastic. 
 Under the Arctic night sky we are going gentle uphill without effort, hauled by dogs whose only noise is a gently effort-driven panting. 
 The whole thing does seem unreal. 
 It is so far removed, not only from my normal run of experience, but from anything I have ever done that it seems beyond the realms of reality, a fantasy production, a dream come true. 
 A far shout calls me back to truth. 
 Behind me Nathan is having problems, his wooden runners sticking in the snow and causing him to go slowly. 
 We wait, he catches up and we go on again. 
 Again he falls back and at the top of the climb we wait again. 
 Below us the forest of Dividal is visible. 
 It is an illusion that the Arctic is dark in winter. 
 The snow is so white that it reflects any available light. 
 Above us there is a full moon and the light that is forcing its way between the clouds is quite sufficient to provide a picture. 
 The picture is in black and white &mdash; there is never enough night light for colours to emerge &mdash; and this adds to the unreal quality. 
 Far below us now is a hurricane lamp that Odd-Knut has hung from a tree knowing it would be visible from the hill. 
 Nathan arrives and Odd-Knut inspects his runners. 
 They need a touch of resin he decides, but as he has none it will have to wait until we get back to the camp. 
 To save time we hitch Nat's sledge to a tree, distribute his dogs among the three of us and put Nathan in my sledge. 
 He is not pleased. 
 With Nathan on board my dogs move more slowly, and we trail off from the others as we climb up above the tree line. 
 The clouds clear and the moonlight sparkles on the snow. 
 Ahead, as they swing away from me, the other sledges look like commas on the writing paper of the snow. 
 The temperature falls and Nathan pulls the nylon sledge cover up over his head, peering out through a narrow slit so as not to miss anything. 
 Tom-Frode, Odd-Knut and Tony wait for us to arrive. 
 Tom has to get back tomorrow, so Odd-Knut decides to circle the peak ahead and rejoin our outward trail to pick up Nat's sledge on the way back. 
 I let Nat have my dogs and sit in with Tony. 
 Odd-Knut lifts his snow hook out of the snow and with a swish is gone. 
 We follow. 
 From within the cover the ride is impressive; closer to the ground, I can hear thumps and bangs as well as the runners hiss. 
 I can hear the dogs panting ahead and occasionally I am flurried by snow kicked up from a runner. 
 Tony talks to his dogs all the time, a hup, hup  here, a go, Brussie  there, and he shouts down to me too. 
 We pause again and swap passenger so that Nathan takes Tony round the edge of the peak into a long and narrow, and steep valley. 
 The wind is whistling up this and within seconds my face is frozen. 
 It is so cold I am going numb. 
 We stop to cover our faces with our  balaclavas, haul in the drawstrings on our anoraks and clamp snow goggles over our eyes. 
 Because I wear glasses, there is a slight air gap and soon my eyes are watering with the cold. 
 The wind-chill temperature that night must have been way below the &mdash; -25&deg;C ( &mdash; -13&deg;F) of the air temperature. 
 It was a biting cold that almost turned the pleasure of the riding into a chore, or a want for it to end. 
 Back at Nathan's sledge he is too cold to be bothered to ride again so we hoist it on to Odd-Knut's sledge and ride on. 
 Nathan and I bring up the rear, and soon we are alone, with Nathan buried beneath the nylon sledge cover. 
 We are going down towards the forest and the Arctic night is awesome. 
 The trees and mountain ridges have a magnificent stark beauty. 
 And it is so quiet. 
 The dogs never bark on the move, so there is no noise but that of runner on snow, and it is a warm, comforting sound that amplifies the silence. 
 My goggles ice up at regular intervals and I wipe them with my glove, afraid that I will miss the trail a groundless fear as the dogs follow the pack scent. 
 The trail goes steeply down and the speed increases, and I let go of the sledge rail to wipe my goggles &mdash; a fatal move. 
 The sledge bucks on an uneven hummock and throws me off. 
 I hold on with one hand, landing in a fast-moving heap that upsets the sledge's balance. 
 It turns on to its side and as I cling on for dear life I hear a startled cry from Nathan. 
 Cocooned in the nylon sack, from which he could escape only with difficulty, he is suddenly on his side heading downhill at speed. 
 He struggles to escape, alternating shouts of Stop ! at the dogs and shouts to me to see if I am still on board. 
 Odd-Knut said that you must never let go of the sledge, I say again and again to myself as I am pulled through snow heaps and ruts. 
 Something bangs hard into me and my arm is almost wrenched free, but eventually the dogs stop, no longer interested in dragging the overturned sledge and me. 
 Nathan and I are quite alone, many miles from civilization and, apparently, lost, the wind having blown snow across the tracks ahead suggests that we just let the dogs lead us towards the others, a well-reasoned idea that works perfectly. 
 By the time we meet Odd-Knut coming back to find us we are only a few hundred metres from the camp. 
 The Arctic dawn is stunningly beautiful. 
 One day Tony gets up to watch and witnesses one of the few times when the sun travels across a blue, cloudless sky. 
 It moves slowly, wearily and as if to ensure that you understand that it is tired; it goes only a few degrees above the horizon, making a long, low arc. 
 Even its light is tired, a pale yellowy-orange, nothing like the vibrant light of the south where the tireless sun goes high and stays high. 
 Tony is entranced. 
 The low angle means that all shadows &mdash; ours, the dogs', the trees' &mdash; are long and ghostly across the ice, and the orange light wraps itself around everything so that all things seem to be part of one thing. 
 He shoots tree stumps and furrows in the snow. 
 He shoots the dog's paws, too hairy and with huge hooked nails, yellow, hard and shiny. 
 Eventually he turns to me smiling broadly. 
 That's another roll finished, he says. 
 God this is great. 
 We leave base camp on a day that is grey and oppressive, the air full of snow. 
 packing is miserable, nothing is the right shape to fit the sledges. 
 How did we get it all here? 
 Odd-Knut discovers that his dogs have been hauling a full, 5-litre can of chain-saw oil around. 
 This amuses him greatly. 
 It is as well the dogs do not speak English. 
 Wiggen, one of my wheel dog pair, a monster of a dog weighing nearly thirty-five kilograms, jumps all over me as I go for him. 
 Yesterday I fed him the bony scraps from my reindeer stew and he is now mine for ever. 
 Thankfully, he has seen this simple act as one of friendship rather than for what it really is &mdash; I am afraid of him and I want him on my side. 
 He paws at me, licks me, nuzzles me and I talk back. 
 Harnessing the dogs is routine now, with Wiggen, with them all, a mixture of soft words and cold fingers. 
 We are ready. 
 Odd-Knut slips his hook and we head for Sweden and some Lappish people he knows. 
 It is the first pull of the day so we all know what to expect. 
 Odd-Knut feeds the dogs on a high-fat, high-protein mix of cow's stomach and other offal, fish, blood and oil. 
 With the first morning pull the dogs become so excited that they shit within metres. 
 The output is an evil treacle, black and vile. 
 When you see it coming &mdash; remember that they do everything on the move &mdash; you jump on to the runner on the opposite side from the dog, take a deep breath and hope the runner won't kick it up. 
 Even the dogs don't like it and will avoid the mixture from the dog in front at all costs. 
 Tony always says that you can tell a happy motorcyclist by the flies on his teeth. 
 His latest joke is that you can tell a happy musher by the dog shit on his teeth. 
 I remember this and smile, clamping my mouth shut as Wiggen goes into action.     
 Dawn, Dividal 
 We pause while Odd-Knut peers at his map and then ahead into the greyness. 
 The stop sets one dog off barking and others join in. 
 Since I gave Wiggen the reindeer he runs with his tail up, happy to be part of my team. 
 I notice, in a matter of fact way, that before he wuffs his gruff, low wuff, Wiggen's ass contracts. 
 Jesus, he's sucking in air at the back and wuffing it out at the front. 
 Now, he half turns and looks my way, love for the reindeer bones in his eyes and woofs merrily at me. 
 No hi-fi speaker maker has ever come up with a woofer that low and resonant. 
 We are off again. 
 We take a frozen river for a long way, a bumpy ride that keeps you concentrating, and when we eventually come off it, there is a lone tree that the dogs pull towards despite our efforts. 
 One by one the dogs on the left of the trace anoint it, the ones on the right going frantic in their efforts to reach it. 
 Later in the trip we pass, lone Nordic skier. 
 The man jabs his left ski down as Odd-Knut goes by, gets the ski between dog and trace and is hauled over and forwards. 
 He falls in a heap, and as they pass every dog on the right of the line raises a leg and pees on him. 
 The Lapps are a curious people, pragmatic almost to the point of unfriendliness. 
 If you can't eat it or, better, drink it then they don't want it. 
 Odd-Knut tells us that in Troms&oslash; there was a notice on the only bit of grass in the town. 
 It said &bquo;do not go on the grass&equo;, translated literally from the Norwegian &mdash; somehow the story doesn't work so well in English. 
 One day a policeman stopped a Lapp who was striding across it. 
 I am not going on it, said the Lapp, I am coming off it. 
 End of discussion. 
 One Lapp shows me his reindeer skin boots, and shrugs when I ask him why the toes curl up. 
 Because they do. 
 In early winter, when the first snows come, he wears socks in the boots, but when it gets cold he takes them off and replaces them with grass. 
 The grass is harvested in summer from the bogs at the edges of lakes, and smashed flat with a knife butt. 
 It is very warm, he tells me, but you must replace it when it is wet. 
 The following day, in a temperature down around &mdash; 2O&deg;C ( &mdash; -4&deg;F), I am wearing loop-stitch socks and Lundhags, and he is wearing reindeer skin boots and grass. 
 The boots are finished with a long, broad ribbon that is wrapped around the ankle, being raised to go over the join of boot and trouser if there is a danger of wet snow going down inside. 
 Nathan asks how many reindeer the Lapp has and is rewarded with a piercing look. 
 Odd-Knut tells us that to ask a Lapp that question is like asking an Englishman how much money he has in the bank. 
 There has been a move by the Norwegian government to try to tax the Lapps on the basis of reindeer numbers, and almost overnight the Arctic was denuded of animals, at least on paper. 
 Our man is not poor though. 
 He has a snow scooter, and enough cash to hire a boat twice a year to move his reindeer on to an island. 
 We never have a satisfactory explanation of where it comes from. 
 Old women knit and sew outside their lavvus , bare-handed even in this temperature; one, with fat, gnarled hands, uses no gloves all day. 
 It is, we hear, one of the worst winters on record, with heavy autumn rain saturating the ground and early winter cold &mdash; the cold and snow that caught Nathan and I in Tromsdalen &mdash; causing the ground to freeze early. 
 The consequence is that the reindeer feed is buried not only under a metre or more of snow, which the reindeer can cope with, pawing away at it to reach the lichen that is reindeer moss, but under many inches of solid ice. 
 The animals cannot always break through this, and they struggle away, pawing and moving in frustration, pawing and moving again. 
 Two kilometres or so away, over the Swedish border, the conditions are worse and these Swedish Lapps have come over to find better feed. 
 This should  make no difference with the Lapps, the Same (pronounced Sam-ay) as they now wish to be called, being all one race. 
 In fact, there is considerable aggravation, with the Norwegian Lapps complaining to the government, and demanding that the police be moved in to catch and deport the interlopers. 
 There is talk of night-time raids between groups, or harsh words and harsh actions. 
 Later in the year, when we visit the area again, we heard that the Swedish Lapps had fenced off an area of the Dividal National Park, with over five kilometres of wire. 
 The incensed Norwegian Lapps called in the authorities, who had to hire a helicopter to go in and confiscate the wire. 
 The Swedes were moved out, but were back the following day. 
 The day after that they hired their own helicopter, landed in the local village, repossessed their wire, flew it back in and re-erected it. 
 And how much does it cost to hire a helicopter for a day? 
 I lie in my sleeping bag, listening to the shuffling of reindeer hooves, and thinking this over. 
  Conventional wisdom tells us that it is the lure of civilization that breaks up the old life, Trom&oslash;'s video games and bars pulling the Lappish kids down out of the forest into the town. 
 What about the effect of such arbitrary things as country borders on the way of life? 
 Here in a land where you expect Lapp to fight Norwegian for the privilege of staying Lappish, Lapp was fighting Lapp for the privilege of being Norwegian rather than Swedish. 
 We leave, saddened by the plight and determined to come for longer the next time, to stay through a winter and spring, to find out what that old woman had really been up to holding that white sheet up to the Northern Lights. 
 They give me a reindeer hood that they assure me will be warmer than my silk and fleece and wool. 
 They do not give me a carved wooden cup though, something we all covet. 
 You must make your own if you are to be a Lapp. 
 We move on next day over hard packed snow that has been wind-blown into flutes and columns. 
 This is the most beautiful place I have ever been, a land of snow that is so fresh and clean that to ride over it seems criminal. 
 I try to ride last so I can stop now and then to be alone, to look back and be glad that I have been able to come this way, but Tony has the feeling too and has bagged the back spot for the morning run. 
 We ride a long way and in late afternoon (sun time rather than clock time, which has long ceased to be important to us) we stop for coffee so that Odd-Knut can work out a route. 
 He wants to go back to the base camp before we push on towards Finland. 
 There is a problem that way, as he cannot take his dogs over the border. 
 Technically that offers no problem, as there is no border in the accepted sense between Norway, Sweden or Finland, but rabies has reached southern Finland and Norway has placed a restriction on dogs coming back. 
 We have no problem going in, but if we are caught or seen then Odd-Knut will not be allowed to bring his dogs back without a lengthy and expensive quarantine. 
 He wants to get us close enough so we can ski over the border, but needs find a road so he can field the dogs before collecting us. 
 He pores over a map while I collect wood for a fire and Nathan digs out a seat for us all. 
 Tony announces that he is off for a crumble, an expression that has taken his fancy and replaced the computerese of going for a &bquo;system dump.&equo; 
 Relentlessly, every day, he tells us when, presumably fearful that we will follow him, camera in hand. 
 He comes back as Odd-Knut starts making the fire. 
 He uses the conventional method for these parts. 
 Not for him the Baden-Powell approach of rubbing two Boy Scouts together; he liberally douses the twigs with paraffin and throws in a match. 
 If it looks good he throws on more wood, if it looks bad he throws on more paraffin. 
 Blackie, his lead dog, watches passively. 
 I wonder if she has yet worked out that for every douse she has to pull less load; probably not, or she would be pissing on the wood. 
 She has, after all, pissed on everything else all day. 
 Odd-Knut collects a kettle of snow and has settled into Nathan's seat with a roll-up. 
 I sit down too. 
 The smoke blows in my eyes making them water and sting, so I get up, move and freeze my ass off sitting beyond the smoke in the wind up the valley. 
 I move again and try to write some notes, but it is cold enough to freeze the ballpoint off my biro. 
 Tony measures the temperature and tells me it is warming up. 
 No it isn't. 
 Give me that thing, it must be wrong. 
 Why doesn't it have a mark on it for absolute brass monkeys? 
 I sit disconsolate in the snow. 
 This place isn't beautiful, it's miserable &mdash; bloody cold, bloody windy and no I don't want any bloody smoked reindeer. 
 Tony brings me a cup of coffee and tells me that the tracks we crossed a while back were, Odd-Knut says, jarv  or wolverine. 
 I have to admit grudgingly that this is interesting, and I trudge up the path with Tony just behind. 
 Why is it only me that gets the rats? 
 What keeps this bastard so cheerful? 
 Then I remember that time when the tent blew down in the snowstorm and his sleeping bag went in the slush. 
 That didn't cheer him up. 
 And there was that other time when&hellip; 
 My mood improves. 
 By the time we get to the jarv  tracks I am over it, putting it down to a poor night's sleep and a wearing day that have combined so that I am feeling the cold more than I normally do. 
 The tracks are indeed of jarv , a shy, elusive animal that neither Tony nor I have ever seen. 
 Odd-Knut has never seen one either, but that is less of a surprise as the noise and smell of his dogs frighten most animals away long before he spots them. 
 Later in the day we spot the tracks of elk (what the Americans and Canadians call &bquo;moose&equo;, although, as might be expected, theirs are bigger). 
 We move on, with me grabbing the back spot. 
 Rayo, who is running lead for me today in harness with Kaisa, gets her leg caught up in the trace. 
 I see it happen but wait, hoping that as usual she   will jump out from it, but it just gets worse and she slows almost to a stop. 
 The wind picks up some snow, or it is snowing gently, as I snow hook the dogs to sort her out. 
 Hey, good dog Rayo, have you got your leg caught? 
 There, there it's OK. 
 And I untangle the mess. 
 Kaisa, bored by the proceedings, takes advantage of the slack trace and goes over to have a look at a tree. 
 I let off the snow hook, Rayo heads for the tree, Kaisa leaps out of the way, Sunniva follows her round and it's back to knitting in seconds. 
 It takes me many minutes to sort it out, as each released dog shows marked enthusiasm for getting tangled up again. 
 The snow is much worse as I finally move out, and the only consolation for the time it has taken is being alone, and arriving late so that the others have already begun on the tent and wood collecting. 
 Evening near Liggafjellet 
 Full moon above Liggafjellet 
 Odd-Knut calls for a volunteer to help feed the dogs in the gathering storm and I don't step back quickly enough. 
 The dog food comes in frozen slabs that must be cut up with a felling axe. 
 Normally we heat it first and add biscuit so that the dogs have a warm, mixed meal, but tonight Odd-Knut is considering giving it to them frozen to save time. 
 Finally his conscience gets the better of him and we break out the large billy from his sledge and light another fire in the lea of a sledge. 
 It is miserable work as the snow is now falling thickly, the wind blowing hard. 
 We put on the billy and head for a coffee and warm, pausing at the tent entrance to brush off the snow that is heaped on our jackets and hoods. 
 Tony and Nathan have made tea and soup and we have some before going out to feed the first batch of dogs. 
 They feed from steel bowls that must be filled by dipping. 
 It is a gloves-off job to avoid getting them soaking wet and the combination of cold steel, snow and wind, and wet dog food is bad for the fingers. 
 While the first group of dogs feeds &mdash; it takes just a few seconds for them to finish the bowls, right down to the lick clean &mdash; I huff on my fingers, more hopefully than knowingly. 
 By the time we have fed the second and, thank God, final group of a dozen we are frozen. 
 Back in the tent there is more soup, coffee and a hunk of smoked lamb that goes down well. 
 Tony finds several packets of banana custard that is hot and sweet; it tastes bloody awful and neither Tony nor I like it, none the less he fights me for the last helping. 
 More tea, then more coffee. 
 I have a headache and am concerned that the wind has dehydrated me; it is so important to pour liquid down in the Arctic, especially in winter. 
 We drink some more, eat some more. 
 The stove warms the tent up and we become drowsy, and oblivious to the storm outside. 
 By the time I am curled up in my bag I am totally content, warm and well fed, exhausted but not wanting to sleep for fear of missing these moments of happiness. 
 The tent is warm, and I have taken everything off, even though it has been the norm to sleep in our thermals and a pile fibre hood. 
 What a day. 
 I wake suddenly in the night, aware of the others breathing and the wind banging the tent fabric. 
 I need a pee. 
 If only I hadn't had that last cup of hot chocolate. 
 I lie still hoping that I will be able to fall back to sleep, but knowing it is a waste of time. 
 Slowly I get out of the bag. 
 It is perishing in the tent, but I can't be bothered to dress &mdash; it will only take a moment, I tell myself. 
 I open the tent door, already cold. 
 I leap outside into the snow,  stand ankle deep in the snow and strain frantically at the same time trying to remember which direction I am pointing so that I can give instructions about where not to get the snow for tomorrow's tea. 
 I start to shiver. 
 The wind howls through the trees, the wind chill temperature must be low, and I have no clothes on. 
 High speed sledging, S&ouml;rdalen 
 No clothes on, do you hear? 
 I am cold. 
 COLD. 
 Give me a c, give me an o&hellip; 
 By the time I am back in the tent I am on the borderline, cold enough to wake Tony with disjointed movements. 
 OK? he asks. 
 Yeah, OK. 
 And into the bag and who cares if I'm wet. 
 It takes a long time to warm up, a very long time, but then I sleep as though practising for death. 
 The storm rages through what is left of the night. 
 Lavvus  have a hole in the top to let smoke from the wood fire out. 
 The modern version we are using has the same hole, and our wood-burning stove has a pipe that goes through it, while the rest of it is closed with a cowl that is a bitch to fix. 
 Last night in the cold and dark we failed to fix it properly again, and when I wake up there is snow all over us and our kit. 
 I look sideways at Nathan who is lying motionless in a bag covered by an inch of snow. 
 The snow has penetrated everywhere, hiding gloves and socks, filling boots, even packing five centimetres of itself into the stove. 
 Tony and I get up as quickly as we can, brushing the snow free from clothes before putting them on so that it will not melt with the heat from our bodies. 
 We tell Nat to stay where he is, brushing the snow from his bag to try to minimize how wet it will be. 
 The advantage of the temperature being so low &mdash; although it has risen several degrees with the cloud over &mdash; is that the snow is like dry flour and brushes off easily. 
 It was late when we woke, and by the time we have cleared up the mess it is later still. 
 Working outside is difficult in the fresh snow and when the wind picks up again we admit defeat and agree that we will stay another night. 
 We fix the cowl in the twilight and prepare the evening meal. 
 Nathan goes outside with the kettle, anxious for some activity, having spent most of the day inside. 
 We turn in, with the wind picking up even stronger and threatening to blow the lavvu  away. 
 The rearrangement of the kit has pushed me close to the side, and just above my face the fabric cracks and bangs in the wind. 
 Far away we can hear the noise of the wind forcing its way up some narrow gully then bursting free to hurl itself across the plateau we crossed yesterday. 
 Tony tells us about his lone stay in the Westmann Islands off Iceland when I had to leave four days earlier than him. 
 The wind blew down the tents of the other lads he had joined in camping on an apparently sheltered spot in a hollow above the sea. 
 Tony sat it out &mdash; in my tent I feel obliged to tell him &mdash; listening for the noise of a train, a noise that meant the wind was coming up the defile between him and the sea. 
 He counted the seconds, one, two, three, four, and then it hit the tent with a fury that he had never known, he inside in his sleeping bag with his feet braced against the dome pole facing the onslaught. 
 He painted a vivid picture of apprehension and tiredness. 
 His storm lasted two and half days, leaving him ragged and with only enough energy to get to the airport to be ready for the first flight out. 
 Nathan asks me if our storm will last two or more days. 
 I say no, and hope that he doesn't realize that I really have no idea. 
 Tony takes the hint and decides not to wax equally lyrical about the Svalbard storm that kept everyone in the tent for seventy-two hours, unable to go out for anything . 
 Thank God for dome tents with two bays: you collect snow from one end for tea, pass it through the middle-man, and then deposit it at the other end. 
 Next morning the worst is over. 
 Outside there are scudding clouds, but they are high up and the sun occasionally breaks through. 
 Down here there is a metre of snow on the windward side of the lavvu , and I fall over a small rucsac that had disappeared. 
 Well, Nathan, you have survived your first Arctic storm. 
 Not so bad really, eh? 
 Go and fill the kettle to celebrate. 
 We pack and move on, the dogs finding it difficult to move in the fresh snow. 
 In desperation Odd-Knut suggests we go down on to a frozen lake, Devdisvatn, the Lake of the Dead Man. 
 It is an ancient Lappish name, and Odd-Knut is not sure of its origin. 
 There is, he says, an old Lappish church near its eastern edge; he has never seen it but he has been told of it by an old Lapp who lives near the lakes western edge. 
 Perhaps we go and take a look? 
 Sure, anything is better than manhandling the sledges through waist-deep snow. 
 The lake has been swept clean of snow by the wind, the sweepings making a huge bank on our side that we have to negotiate. 
 It is topped by a wind-blown crust that almost holds our weight as we descend. 
 The ride across the lake gives us our  best sledging for days, but the search for the ruin is hopeless, an endless toing and froing among trees and too-deep snow. 
 The last remnant of the storm hits us, thick snow blotting out the view of anything, so reluctantly we call a halt and go back down on to the lake. 
 The snow stops and Odd-Knut suggests we try a little fishing. 
 Fired by his own enthusiasm, he stops his sledge and gets out a huge snow drill, like a brace and bit but capable of boring a twenty centimetre hole. 
 Nathan grabs the drill: this will be great for his project. 
 He and Odd-Knut shovel away the snow to reach the ice, making a large hole about a metre deep, and Nathan jumps in and starts to brace and bit with enthusiasm. 
 The ice is thick and he is a good deal less enthusiastic when the tip breaks through. 
 What Odd-Knut has not told him is that the water under the ice is pressurized, and it wells up out of the hole. 
 Nathan is now experienced enough to know that wet feet and the Arctic are a poor mix and is out of the hole like a rabbit. 
 The water pours on until a few inches has collected in the bottom. 
 Odd-Knut rigs a fishing line and offers it to me. 
 He seems to think that it is fair that I should have first crack since I am the one who has carried the worms about for the last umpteen days. 
 On the first day Odd-Knut gave me a tobacco tin of worms and told me to keep them warm, and they have travelled the Arctic inside my second layer of clothing ever since, even sharing my sleeping bag at night-time. 
 Now their time has come. 
 And a bloody good job too. 
 My opinion has always been that fishermen, at least those who fish to catch and return, are on a par with the hunting fraternity. 
 Killing things for fun seems to me to be so immoral as to warrant no discussion at all. 
 It is wrong, end of conversation. 
 As a result I undergo a bout of conscience, taking the short rod only when Odd-Knut assures me that we will eat whatever we catch, and that we will probably not catch anything. 
 Odd-Knut smokes a pensive roll-up, I fish, Tony photographs, Nathan wanders off with a shovel and ice drill. 
 My father, a Desert Rat, tells me that in the North African campaign you never asked a man with a shovel where he was going, so I let Nat go. 
 Soon he is digging like a whirling dervish, the impressive show ending with another frantic leap. 
 Ice fishing, I find, is as cold as anything I have ever tried in the Arctic, and after a few minutes of unproductive ass-freezing I pack it in. 
 Tony has a go and I mooch over to see how Nat is faring. 
 Badly. 
 We freeze and drown worms for a few more minutes. 
 A sudden snow flurry gives Nathan his first-ever view &mdash; if that is not a contradiction in terms &mdash; of a white-out. 
 The two of us stand next to his second hole unable to distinguish sky and lake and cut off from the other pair. 
 It lasts an impressive minute or two, then whirls away. 
 We pack in the fishing; Odd-Knut pronounces the last of the worms dead and suggests we all come back for another go in April. 
 If only we could. 
 We camp, and to compensate for the fishing Odd-Knut suggests he will cook us another of his specialities, bl&aring;b&aelig;rsuppe , a fish stew. 
 He disappears to collect the ingredients from his sledge, &bquo;Tony and I start feeding the dogs, and Nathan decides to show Odd-Knut an English dish &mdash; pancakes. 
 Odd-Knut has given him some eggs that turn out to be frozen. 
 Nat tells Tony, expecting sympathy and assistance. 
 He gets neither. 
 When he has thawed his ingredients Nat cooks the way he dug the snow hole &mdash; frantically. 
 Odd-Knut's soup is incredible, a mixture of different fish and shellfish. 
 When the meal is over we notice that the sky is clearing; now there is enough cloud-free sky to show that the Northern Lights are out. 
 We drink coffee outside, leaning against trees to watch the free show. 
 The Lights are a shimmering green waterfall that grows in intensity, then dies slowly to be replaced by a separate show in another part of the sky. 
 There it is a plaited rope, moving sinuously. 
 The colour is very bright, and occasionally there is a splash of red, rarer, at the edges. 
 We watch for a long time, Tony catching the show on camera, then notice that the temperature has plummeted with the clearing of the sky and turn in. 
 During the night I hear the harsh squeal of a fox, a long way off, answered by a staccato bark from one of the dogs. 
 The bark starts them all off and they howl at the moon for a few minutes. 
 Odd-Knut calls out sharply and they fall silent. 
 In the morning there is a centimetre of ice on the tent pole to the side of my head, probably from my breath while I slept. 
 Outside the weather is beautiful, blue sky and rising sun. 
 We decide to go for a ride on the lake and rush to harness the dogs. 
 Use Rayo as your lead dog today, Odd-Knut tells me. 
 OK, I say, which one is Rayo? 
 She is next to Kala. 
 Thanks Odd-Knut, thanks a lot, which one is Kala? 
 I hope that he will not say that Kala is the one next to Rayo. 
 He doesn't. 
 We ride across the lake on one of the best trips we have had. 
 The lake is flat, its hard crust free of  fresh snow. 
 The weather is perfect and we are now experienced enough mushers to be able to enjoy the high speeds without anxiety. 
 Venstre , Rayo. 
 H&oslash;yre , Rayo. 
 Go left, go right. 
 So good am I that I turn round on the runners to photograph Tony. 
 The sledge hits a bump and I am off, using my camera as a snow hook. 
 So much for experience. 
 Tony races past, laughing his head off. 
 Give us a lift, you miserable bastard. 
 Ho, ho&hellip; 
 They field my dogs and we ride on. 
 Odd-Knut finds a steep up-slope where a river joins the lake and we play for a bit going up and down steep slopes. 
 When we ride away from the river Odd-Knut stops sharply. 
 The river has curved round and Odd-Knut has drawn up a few metres from the edge of a very steep drop. 
 We investigate. 
 There is a wind-blown cornice of about one and a half metres overhanging a sheer drop of about eight metres. 
 I ask Odd-Knut if sledgers often go over cornices. 
 Again he misses the answer &mdash; which is, of course, &bquo;No, only once, &mdash; and says with a grave look that usually the dogs see it even in poor visibility, but in white-outs it has been known. 
 We call in on Odd-Knut's Lappish acquaintance &mdash; &mdash; not &bquo;friend&equo;, because the Lapps rarely make real friends with non-Lapps. 
 He lives in a glorious wooden hut with several equally attractive out-buildings. 
 In a small enclosure three reindeer sniff the air, detect dog, either from the dogs themselves deliberately left many yards away, or from our clothing, and shuffle nervously as we approach. 
 Nathan, anxious for a closer look, goes over and the animals go mad. 
 We call him back. 
 The Lapp speaks no English and we have a stilted conversation through Odd-Knut. 
 Yes, it is a  bad winter, the worst he has seen in sixty-five years of herding reindeer here. 
 Sixty-five years? 
 How old is he? 
 He is seventy-nine. 
 Good God, he looks about fifty. 
 He has a straight back and huge arms that betray a phenomenal strength. 
 When he walks with us he is out ahead, large, confident strides. 
 How does he feel about the Swedish Lapps? 
 He shrugs. 
 How can the reindeer tell which is Norway and which is Sweden? 
 It is the animals that come here, and the Lapps just follow. 
 So he is happy to see his Swedish brothers here? 
 Well, he understands that those Norwegian Lapps that are closer to the border than he is might not be so keen. 
 Norwegian Lapps? 
 Does he not just see Lapps? 
 Don't they all talk the same language? 
 He changes the subject awkwardly. 
 Would we like some smoked reindeer (not that you can make good smoked meat now, not with all the air pollution, the acid rain and the like from the UK). 
 I ask what the charming little wooden shed down the track is for &mdash; tools and things? 
 No, he says, it is the toilet. 
 That's a hell of a way to go, I say. 
 True, he says, but it is a fine place for the smell. 
 Ice fishing 
 Tony has been outside photographing the Lapp's hut and comes in raving about its beauty and position. 
 Ask him if he would like me to send him a print of his hut, Odd-Knut. 
 The Lapp is puzzled. 
 What would he do with it? 
 He could put it on the wall here, explains Tony. 
 The man is still puzzled. 
 He says something to Odd-Knut who turns to Tony. 
 He asks, explains Odd-Knut, why, should he want a picture of his hut on the wall when he can go outside and look at it? 
 Tony, looks at me, for once lost for words. 
 We talk some more. 
 I am intrigued by this old man who seems so unimpressed by everything we find attractive and interesting. 
 Reindeer? 
 You eat them. 
 A frozen lake? 
 A nuisance if you want to eat fish. 
 A good-looking dog? 
 A dog is just a dog. 
 It is not that he doesn't care, just that his sense of values are different &mdash; not better, not worse, just different. 
 Outside the light is fading. 
 A flock of Siberian tits twitters away above us. 
 Tony and I pause to watch. 
 Not until now have we realized how much we had missed birds. 
 On the drive back to the camp one of Odd-Knut's lead dogs, Stig, trips in a dark section of woodland. 
 The point dogs catch him and one of them nips him on the leg &mdash; take that  for being more popular with the boss. 
 By the time we get back to the tent Stig is limping badly and when Odd-Knut looks he finds he is bleeding profusely. 
 Odd-Knut fetches his first aid kit, and I get ours. 
 Odd-Knut muzzles the dog with a piece of trace line, ties its front and back legs together and lies it on its side. 
 The wind has picked up a bit, and there is a light snow falling. 
 We turn a sledge on to its side for shelter, and by the light from our head torches we examine the wound. 
 It is long and deep, the flesh pulled off the meat. 
 I clean it out with antiseptic wipes, passing them to Nathan to finish the job when Stig starts to buck and fight. 
 I hold him down, Nathan operates the most stable of the head torches, Odd-Knut operates the needle and thread and Tony takes the photographs. 
 The stitching takes a long time and hurts Stig a lot more than it hurts the rest  of us. 
 I wonder whether the cold is much of an anaesthetic. 
 Apparently not. 
 Operating on Stig in a blizzard 
 Stig after the blizzard 
 In the tent that night we eat smoked trout and Odd-Knut tells us that the previous year there was a fight on his team and after it was over and the dogs were moving again he saw blood on the snow. 
 He stopped the team and found that Brusie, now Tony's lead dog, had a serious stomach wound, one of her teats having been almost torn off. 
 He fought to staunch the blood and stitch the wound, with the dog slipping towards unconsciousness. 
 Finally her eyes turned grey and rolled, and Odd-Knut thought she was dead. 
 He worked to revive her and eventually she recovered enough to be wrapped and put on the sledge. 
 Exhausted, Odd-Knut cut short his trip and went home. 
 He was met by Kjell-Arne, his kennel boy, who told him that when he was eating his lunch he heard the noise of a dog scratching against the door. 
 He went out, but there was nothing there, just the rest of the dogs on their chains. 
 He went back in, but the noise started once more. 
 Again Kjell-Arne went outside, this time checking everywhere for a dog off its chain or a stray. 
 There was no dog anywhere. 
 He became very nervous, and was glad to see Odd-Knut come home. 
 Odd-Knut asked what time it had been when Kjell-Arne heard the noise. 
 It was at exactly the time when Odd-Knut feared Brusie was dying, as she became unconscious. 
 The next day Stig, kept away from the other dogs on a separate chain, but not under cover, is stiff-legged and looking mournful. 
 He gets an extra ration from Odd-Knut, who is clearly worried about him. 
 Stig was due to lead in the Finnm&aring;rrks L&oslash;pet , Europe's longest sledge dog race. 
 The Iditarod is closed to most European mushers as there is rabies in Alaska, so Odd-Knut is hoping to break into the top five of the European one, and the loss of Stig will be a serious blow. 
 All day Stig rides on the sledge, a real sledge dog. 
 He is upset at the lack of activity and howls appallingly, but when Odd-Knut tries him on the trace he is clearly crippled and in pain. 
 It is four months before Stig is well enough to walk properly, and by then winter is over and the race has passed, with Odd-Knut making the top ten but no higher because of the loss. 
 Stig makes a full recovery which is some compensation. 
 Our ride with Stig is the last ride we make. 
 The loss of the dog means that we cut short our projected trip north, and go down into Dividalen, to the south. 
 We go the long way; who knows how long it will be before we come this way again? 
 The last sunset is orange and yellow, then shades of purple. 
 I see the way the snow is kicked up off the paws of the dogs, the way their breath explodes around their heads. 
 We round a corner and the way goes downhill steeply into the valley. 
 The last of the light is directly ahead, painted sky between dark hills. 
 The descent is never-ending &mdash; I am glad &mdash; until Tony comes towards me. 
 Hitch to the sign over there, he points, Odd-Knut is arranging for a car. 
 The dogs howl and whine at first, then realize that they have finished for the day. 
 It is all over.   
 Crossing a frozen lake 
 BEING DRAWN TO AN IMAGE 
 Guy Brett 
 Why do certain images matter to one, and why is the desire to answer this question as involuntary as the response itself? 
 Why does it seem important that the answer should have some &bquo;objective&equo; quality about it, an insight into history, society, knowledge, rather than point to a merely personal obsession? 
 The American film-maker Maya Deren says somewhere that &bquo;response should always precede analysis&equo;, a remark which sounds as if it was made as an artist's challenge to academic dryness and formalism. 
 But is not the response and the analysis actually part of the same phenomenon, whether it results in an exclamation (&bquo;how beautiful! ') or a new &bquo;reading&equo;? 
 The recourse to books, documents, or sources, underscores a perception which is somehow already in the air. 
 The effort to recapture art's &bquo;history&equo; is always entangled with the desire to remake its identity and meaning as part of contemporary struggles. 
 This article comes out of the familiar experience of being drawn to a particular image, or set of images, without at first knowing why, and the attempt to account for this feeling. 
 Looking intermittently at the so-called colonial art of Latin America in churches, museums, private collections and books, I became magnetised by the figures of angels. 
 They are extraordinarily resplendent. 
 They have a material splendour in their dress. 
 The spiritual (or is it the psychic?) intensity of their presence goes together with a marvellous air of freedom and delicacy. 
 They have a tendency to expand, to fill the picture space. 
 If the angel is already a hybrid (a human with wings), the Latin American angels seem to incorporate further incongruities into this composite of the human and the supernatural which hints at further, latent meanings. 
 I knew that these paintings were produced for the Spanish in the decades after their conquest of Latin America, and represented the christianising of the old centres of Inca culture, in Peru and Bolivia especially. 
 I knew that in the main they were painted by Indian and mestizo artists at the command of the Europeans. 
 It lodged in my mind to try and answer the question as to whether there was something special about the depiction of angels in post-conquest art, and if so, what it could be. 
 I didn't make a systematic study but I occasionally followed up clues if I came across references in books and catalogues. 
 I soon learned that the theme of angels was one of the most popular in the paintings produced by indigenous artists for the complex iconographic programmes of the churches and missions established by the Spanish after the conquest. 
 This word &bquo;popular&equo; is of course problematic and will be returned to a little later. 
 All colonial painting began in a process of copying. 
 Indian artists were obliged, or forced, to abandon their own forms of representation and learn the European way. 
 But after a period of sheer copying, some themes took off. 
 Some developed differently in the American context. 
 Why did angels especially flourish? 
 As I investigated further, it seemed to become clear that if this question could be answered it could only be in a complex way. 
 These paintings, in other words, could only be read as the site of a complex play of forces. 
 They were not simply transcriptions of the power of the conquerors and the coercive force with which they attempted to annihilate the existing culture and beliefs of the Indians and impose Christianity. 
 Nor, obviously, were they a simple expression of Indian resistance to this assault. 
 In some way they were both these things at once. 
 The more I looked into it the more the paintings seemed to go beyond simple unitary ideas of authorship and meaning. 
 The Peruvian art historian Luis Enrique Tord has written: 
 The Spanish conquest of the Inca empire had a profound impact on many aspects of Indian society, but by far the most serious blows suffered by the Andean peoples were administered by the Church. 
 The efforts of priests and missionaries to eradicate the Indians' ancestral beliefs produced profound emotional disturbances as well as great changes in their conception of the world. 
 To enforce conformity to the new orthodoxy, the Spaniards instituted ecclesiastical visitas , or inspections intended to extirpate the idolatory that persisted long after the conquest. 
 In the sphere of art the range of subjects and genres permitted by the church was extremely narrow, only in fact religious paintings and portraits. 
 At that time after the conquest there was effectively no &bquo;thought&equo; (recorded discourse) outside the religious framework and institutions. 
 The first university in Peru, for example, was founded by the Dominicans. 
 Painting was from the beginning one of the most important instruments of conquest in the sphere of thinking, the mind. 
 In the earliest years of their missionary efforts Dr Tord writes: 
 the friars discovered that the Indians were deeply impressed by sacred images created with the newest artistic techniques brought from the Old World&hellip; 
 Those images were first seen in the catechisms, Bibles, books of hours, and hymnals used to convert the Indians and direct their worship. 
 &bquo;The Archangel Raphael&equo;, by a follower of Luis de Riano, Cuzco School c. 1640. 
 Oil on canvas, 65&ins; x 42&ins;. 
 Convento de San Francisco, La Paz. 
 The Jesuits brought over their leading painter in Europe in the late sixteenth century, the Italian Bernardo Bitti, to live and work in Cuzco. 
 A school of painting grew up in Cuzco which became the leading centre of the production of paintings south of Mexico and exported paintings and painters to many other parts of the continent including remote areas. 
 Leopoldo Castedo, the Spanish-Chilean art historian writes: 
 Of forty-seven painters documented in Cuzco during the period, thirty-five were Indians, seven criollos or mestizos, four Spaniards, and one Italian. 
 This list does not include the great number of Indians who remained anonymous&hellip;. 
 The similes usually used to describe the stylistic  hybrid produced over the years by the Cuzco painters &mdash; the &bquo;melding&equo;, or &bquo;blending&equo;, or the &bquo;intricate amalgamation&equo; of European and indigenous traditions to produce an art of &bquo;Byzantine richness and splendour&equo; &mdash; obviously belies the violence of events. 
 These phrases do, however, have the ring of truth in an aesthetic sense &mdash; or rather there was an aesthetic process involved which had to some extent its own story. 
 This was manifested not only in the precise, artistic and critical response by Indian peoples to European paintings, but also in connoisseurship within the colonising ranks. 
 A blossoming of the arts followed the rebuilding of Cuzco after the catastrophic earthquake of 1650, partly due to the arrival of Bishop Manuel de Mollinedo y Angulo. 
 His collection included two El Grecos, and other outstanding Spanish pictures, and he sponsored Indian painters like Diego Quispe Tito, as well as sculptors, architects and jewellers. 
 Sometimes the coercion and oppression is  felt directly in the paintings: for example, in images of Saint Isidore, a rather obscure Spanish saint vastly amplified in the New World as the patron of labourers, who is shown to carry a small bag of coca leaves as the Indian peasants and miners did, and do, to chew to combat hunger and fatigue. 
 Castedo points this out. 
 He also shows that images of Santiago (St James) staying the moors  were often changed to Santiago slaying the Indians . 
 Indian painters would in this case be painting an image showing the Church's and the State's warning to Indians who contemplated rebellion, as many did. 
 And occasionally, as, for example, during or around the time of the rebellion led by Tupac Amaru II in 1780, an image would appear of explicit resistance to colonialism. 
 In the somewhat unlikely context of the Pelican History of Art (the relevant volume is Art and Architecture in Spain and Portugal and their American Dominions 1500&ndash;1800 ), an anonymous painting is described which shows America: 
 nursing Spanish noble boys. 
 Negroes and mestizos are pressing around her throne, while nude Indian children weep abandoned. 
 Two richly dressed Indian couples present their gifts in a beautiful park crowded with different animals. 
 The legend says: Where in the world has one seen what one sees here&hellip; 
 Her own sons lie groaning and she suckles strangers. 
 The images of angels are much more ambiguous and capable of different interpretations (this could, of course, be said of the angel theme generally as it recurs in the history of art, and in various guises across different cultures). 
 It is not hard to find documentary evidence for the Church's deliberate use of the angel theme as an instrument of conversion. 
 The Bolivian art historian Teresa Gisbert writes that the Councils of Lima, which were responsible for questions of orthodoxy in the Viceroyalty: &bquo;sought to attract Indians to the new faith by the use of images which would be especially appealing to them.' 
 Why were angels appealing to them? 
 In the Pelican History, Martin Soria tentatively puts forward the theory that angels were popular because &bquo;they replaced similar messengers in pre-conquest beliefs&equo;. 
 Teresa Gisbert produces evidence to show that Diego Quispe Tito's series of paintings of the zodiac for the Cathedral of Cuzco was commissioned in order to counteract the traditional indigenous worship of the stars and were intended to aid in Christianising the Indians of the Andes. 
 And she suggests that the angels, especially the series of angels, could have a similar purpose, to &bquo;replace worship of celestial phenomena with the theologically acceptable cult of the angels&equo;. 
 So apparently they were &bquo;popular&equo;, for different reasons, with both Christian and native American, with oppressor and oppressed. 
 It is as if you could read in them simultaneously transcriptions of inducement, threat, coercion, protection, solace, yearning and resistance. 
 Does this explain their complex expressivity? 
 For the same quality can be interpreted differently according to one's point of view, one's experience, and one's feelings. 
 Protection  can mean Defence of the Faith, i.e. of Christianity, or it can mean the adoption and identification of a &bquo;guardian spirit&equo;, who will watch over your life-journey, a universal, but at the same time very individual and personal desire, expressed in most religions and cultures. 
 Looking at the angel's image you can dream, ask for what you want. 
 The angel, with its brilliantly opulent but light clothing, its mobility, its freedom from hierarchical placing in the pictorial composition, and its bisexuality, is an intimate image of enablement. 
 Among the images of angels is a genre apparently unique to South America, even to the Andes, the Angels with Guns. 
 This was also a very popular subject (one church inventory for 1748, for example, lists 36 pictures of armed angels). 
 Julia P. Herzberg, who calls these pictures &bquo;representations of winged  beings at once military, aristocratic and religious, gives this explanation of their raison d'&ecirc;tre:  
 Paintings of angels with guns appeared at a time when the religious orders were confronted with the stubborn persistence of pre-conquest religion amongst their Indian charges. 
 Immense problems remained not merely in the campaign to destroy Indian idols, but in teaching and reinforcing the principles of the new faith. 
 Sermons and catechisms were of course the primary means of conversion, but images of angels with guns were useful symbols of important teachings of the church. 
 The Spaniards conquered the Incas with both the Cross and the arquebus. 
 The key to understanding the religious function of these images is found in the gun motif. 
 Firearms, unknown to the Indians at the time of the conquest, seemed a frightening manifestation of the supernatural, for they &bquo;fled out of fear when there was a blare of trumpets, the roar of arquebuses and artillery&equo;. 
 The firearm in an angel's hands must have had a powerful impact on Indian converts. 
 But since guns were also used defensively, the images functioned symbolically as reminders of the protection offered to those who embraced Christianity. 
 The image of the angel with a gun served a secular as well as a religious function by emphasising the lesson that the Church and the Spanish colonial r&eacute;gime were united in their goal to christianize the Indians. 
 The military aspect of the crusade is subliminally suggested by the gentle figure who handles his firing weapon in varied positions which recall those of a fighting force. 
 In speaking about the angels' clothing, Herzberg continues: 
 Far more important than the military aspects of the angel's costumes are the explicit references to the high social status of both Spanish colonial gentlemen and Inca royalty. 
 Richly brocaded fabrics, ribbons, and lace characterize the opulent viceregal dress of the 17th century. 
 The gentlemen-aristocratic nature of angels with guns is defined by their elegant dress, which relates them directly to the ruling viceregal aristocracy. 
 A key phrase here seems to me to be &bquo;gentle figure who handles his firing weapon&equo;. 
 Although the technical military details of loading and handling the gun and so on, of the angel paintings, is very precise &mdash; taken in fact from a Flemish military manual of 1607 &mdash; the &bquo;common soldier&equo; of the image in the manual is not retained: he becomes the gorgeous aristocrat. 
 The non-aggressive angel-like  pose, is of course extremely seductive, which makes the threat of force oblique, only implied, as if a beautiful face was being laid over the ugly face of violent coercion. 
 Are these pictures simply transcriptions of power, in which the hard approach is mixed with the soft, and the Church is allied with the State (and in this case hinting as well, not just at the foreigner's domination of the native inhabitants but also at class conflict within colonial society, since the angel is a m&eacute;lange of Spanish and Inca aristocracies)? 
 Perhaps. 
 But again they seem to me more enigmatic, more multiple &mdash; images full of aesthetic tensions. 
 Can one again make a conflation between domination and rebellion in the image, an expression of both the Church/State and the Indian wishes? 
 Leopoldo Castedo writes: 
 The prestige of the armed archangel was and is still very great. 
 In mestizo architectural decoration of the 18th century, the archangel brandishing the flaming sword had a prominent place (particularly fine examples are in the Cathedral of Puno and San Lorenzo, in Potosi); and in the traditional diablada boliviana  (Bolivian devil play), a religious drama, the Archangel Michael defeats &lsqb;&hellip;&rsqb; the Devil of the Seven Masks. 
 In 1950, in a curious or consistent coincidence ( as Castedo Pointedly calls it  &dollar;, Pope Pius XII declared the Archangel Michael patron of police &mdash; a decision that may well diminish the archangel's prestige in Latin America. 
 &bquo;Archangel with Gun&equo;, by an anonymous painter of the Cuzco School, early 18th century. 
 Oil on canvas, 63 1/4&ins; x 39 1/2&ins;. 
 Museo de Arte, Lima. 
 &bquo;Archangel with Gun&equo;, by the Master of Calamarca (Jos&eacute; Lopez du los Rios?) 
 Lake Titicaca School, c. 1684. 
 Oil on canvas, 63 5/8&ins; x 46 1/2&ins;. 
 Museo Nacional de Arte, La Paz. 
 Aside from dealing, as I have been doing, with one of the major subjects and themes of Cuzco painting, an inventory could be made of ways in which painters departed from European models, or from academic notions of excellence. 
 There are peripheral insertions, like borders of flowers, or tropical birds which populate the background landscapes of many religious paintings. 
 Or survivals at the level of colour: liking for flat and intense colours, local earth and vegetable dyes, which may go all the way back to the ancient textile traditions such as that of the Paracas culture in Peru. 
 Also, intensification of the colours in the angels' wings as compared with Europe. 
 These questions were not merely &bquo;academic&equo;. 
 Disputes among Spanish and Indian painters themselves, in some ways antecedents of all subsequent debates around &bquo;indigenism&equo;, go back to the early days in Cuzco. 
 In 1688 the Cuzco guild of painters split. 
 The immediate reason seems to have been that Indian painters working for some of the Spanish and criollo masters complained of mistreatment. 
 The Spanish admitted their guilt but no agreement could be reached and the two sides moved apart. 
 The Spanish guild tightened its European rules of style. 
 The Indian painters lost contact with European developments and, according to Teresa Gisbert, &bquo;sought inspiration both in the old styles and in their own tastes and traditions&equo;, a mixture of ornamental stylisation with observation of the reality around them. 
 Their religious pictures, she writes, &bquo;belong to an archaic world &lsqb;&hellip; &dollar; who viewed the religious realm as something &bquo;different&equo; from mundane reality.' 
 The argument so far has been intended to put forward the possibility that an art work or image could be official and coercive, and unofficial and subversive, all at the same time. 
 The example I have given is by no means the only one that exists. 
 The  same process has been documented in other situations where a people have been conquered, colonised and their cultural beliefs assaulted. 
 Eduardo Mondlane found that African carvers in nineteenth-century and early twentieth-century Mozambique had made their own use of Christian themes imposed by priests and missionaries: 
 When a &lsqb;makonde&rsqb; sculptor departs from the stereotype &lsqb;&hellip; &dollar; this is nearly always because an element of doubt or defiance has been worked into it; a madonna is given a demon to hold instead of the Christ Child; a priest is represented with the feet of a wild animal, a piet&agrave; becomes a study not of sorrow but of revenge, with the mother raising a spear over the body of her dead son. 
 Magazine advertisement, featuring a painting by Botero. 
 Such images may startlingly demonstrate the general truth that the meaning of a work cannot simply be equated with its subject. 
 But particularly intriguing is the phenomenon of syncretisation itself, as an artistic  process, and its relationship to meaning: the process whereby something new is created that cannot simply be reduced to either side of two antagonistic forces, or returned to a former &bquo;purity&equo;. 
 A new &bquo;in-between&equo; is created. 
 This is especially true in the context of Latin America where this kind of duality and fusion has been a feature of culture from the time of the conquest right up until today &mdash; both on the popular and the intellectual level. 
 &bquo;Latin America is such a syncretic, eccentric, disjointed fusion of European, Amerindian and Afro-Caribbean culture,&equo; in the words of the Mexican artist Guillermo Gomez-Pe&ntilde;a. 
 Or, as the Chilean painter Juan Davila recently put it: &bquo;You take something of yourself, something of the conqueror&equo;. 
 In both cases these are intellectuals talking about their own work by linking it with a process continually taking place at a popular level and in everyday life. 
 Today, the image of the angel is still alive, and still in contention; it has by no means been merely consigned to the museum. 
 It is still a part of contemporary power struggles. 
 On the one hand it has appeared as a focus for resistance. 
 The militant angel appeared, for example, in wall paintings in Haiti during the shortlived popular uprising for food and democracy of 1986. 
 The extraordinarily effective popular figure of the masked Superbarrio, who emerged spontaneously to lead the movement to demand the provision of proper housing in the aftermath of the disastrous Mexican earthquake of 1986, surely appeals to memories of the angel-enabler, along with references to Mexican popular masked wrestling heroes and perhaps to Superman. 
 At the same time, the armed angel is continually reproduced as a figure of folklore, a naive stereotype of Latin America, typically exploited in the paintings of Fernando Botero, the highest selling Latin American artist in the world today. 
 His shallow humour trades in, but misses the actual drama and sensibility of that hybrid fusion of the aristocratic and the popular which took place all those years ago in Cuzco.  
 Symbolic angel lances a Tonton Macoute on a mural in Port-au-Prince, Haiti, 1989. 
 Photo by Pablo Butcher. 
 An Inca Warrior in the guise of the Archangel Michael with a flaming sword. 
 Stone carving in a church at Potosi, Bolivia, 18th century. 
 &bquo;Popular culture is not what is technically called folklore, but the popular language of permanent historical rebellion.&equo; 
 This sentence, by the Brazilian film-maker Glauber Rocha, written at the turn of the 1970s, clearly identifies a form of expression with a mass of oppressed people whose experience has been continuous over at least four centuries. 
 And Glauber also implies that the forms and images in which this experience is expressed are not fixed but open and changing. 
 The sentence comes from an essay called Eztetyke du R&ecirc;ve , an eccentric spelling of Esth&eacute;tique du R&ecirc;ve  (&bquo;Aesthetic of the Dream') in which, building on the idea that &bquo;the dream is the only right which cannot be forbidden&equo;, Glauber Rocha described how he had come to realise the revolutionary importance of the mystical in Latin American popular culture. 
 It was the only way of contesting that &bquo;bourgeois reason&equo; which, for him, was as much a feature of left-wing political programmes as it was of traditional colonial domination. 
 In his 1965 article, &bquo;Aesthetic of Hunger&equo;, enormously influential on Third World cinema and art, Glauber felt he had given &bquo;the measure of my rational understanding of poverty&equo;. 
 By 1971 he was saying that, as artists: 
 We must touch, by communion, the vital point of poverty which is its mysticism. 
 This mysticism is the only language which transcends the rational schema of oppression. 
 The role of the angel as an intermediary between the human and the mystical world, and its elaborate beautifying as a vehicle of the dream, would seem to tie in closely with Glauber's identification of a continuing thread of psychological resistance in Latin American culture. 
 The writer would like to express his appreciation of the art historical studies of Teresa Gisbert, Leopoldo Castedo, Julia P. Herzberg and dr Luis Enrique Tord, to which he has been deeply indebted in writing this article .  
 &bquo;HER DRESS HANGS HERE': DE-FROCKING THE KAHLO CULT 
 Oriana Baddeley 
 The 1990s have witnessed a shift in the art establishment's attitudes towards art produced outside of its traditional parameters. 
 The work of previously marginalised artists has become an area of rich speculation among art dealers priced out of the &bquo;modern masters&equo; market. 
 Almost every year has witnessed the discovery of new artistic terrain &mdash; graffiti art, Soviet art, Australian art, the art of Latin America. 
 The major auction houses have moved with the times and have found new ways of selling works which in both form and content would have proved an unstable investment a decade ago. 
 The current status of the work of the Mexican painter Frida Kahlo is a dramatic example of this change. 
 Once known primarily as the wife of Diego Rivera, her reputation outside of Mexico now far supercedes his: since 1919, sale room estimates of her work have risen from &dollar;40,000 to over &dollar;1 million, and in 1990 a work by Kahlo broke all records at Sotheby's New York for a Latin American artist. 
 The enormous rise in the economic value of her work has developed in tandem with the increased critical and popular response to her particular blend of naive style and incisive content. 
 While the first wave of popular interest arose with the 1982 Whitechapel exhibition instigated by Laura Mulvey and Peter Wollen, it was the publication of Hayden Herrera's biography of Kahlo in 1983 which has led to her current cult status. 
 Since that date she has been the subject of TV documentaries, a feature film (&bquo;Frida&equo; by Paul Leduc), a stage play, numerous publications and the inspiration for designer clothing. 
 In May 1989 Elle  magazine ran a 16 page feature on Frida Kahlo as the &bquo;spirit of Mexico&equo; (Fig. 1), while in Vogue  (Feb. 1990) there was a 10 page interpretation of &bquo;the romance of Frida Kahlo's Mexico&equo; (Fig. 2). 
 Almost as a logical outcome of this media blitz, it emerged in the summer of 1990 that Madonna, already a devotee of Kahlo's work, was commissioning a screenplay based on Kahlo's life.  
 Fig. 1. 
 Elle Magazine , May 1989, p. 18&ndash;19. 
 As with most artists who have become mythical personalities in the popular imagination, such attention has focused primarily on the anecdotal and tragic details of Kahlo's admittedly fascinating life. 
 The passionate obsession with her husband Diego Rivera, her flamboyant appearance, but most of all her physical and emotional pain have come to dominate responses to her work. 
 While Kahlo's art helped her to deal with the vicissitudes of her life, for most audiences it is her life story which allows access to her art. 
 In this one can draw obvious parallels to the appeal of Van Gogh, a traditionally popular artist recently made fashionable by the media attention generated during the centennial of his death. 
 The archetypal dropout/spiritualist became an appropriate icon for the sixties revival of 1990's long hot summer. 
 Yet despite the iconic status of Van Gogh's &bquo;tragic&equo; life, it is the appearance of his work by which he is ultimately signified, his thick impasto brush-stroke, his vibrant yellows, the urgency of his creative drive. 
 In the case of Kahlo the popular image is of the artist herself, the characteristic brows, the elaborate hair, the Mexican costume (Fig. 3). 
 It is primarily her appearance, not the formal language of her art, that has graced the pages of Elle  and Vogue  magazines. 
 The Elle  feature transposed the &bquo;Kahlo style&equo; to Kahlo lookalikes in contemporary clothing balanced around segments of Herrera's biography of  the artist. 
 In the later Vogue  piece only the style remained as the far more overtly sexual, Kahloesque models lounged and pouted in their &bquo;Mexican&equo; interiors. 
 There is a poignant irony in the way clothing, which on one level served to hide Kahlo's broken body, falls or is lifted by the model to reveal a luxuriantly perfect physique (Fig. 4). 
 The visual references in the two magazines are as much from photos of the artist as from her work. 
 In both features she is also seen to embody a wider set of assumptions about Mexico itself; exotic, passionate, yet constantly struggling against pain and deceit. 
 While Elle, Vogue  and subsequently The Independent  (Fig. 5), stressed different facets of Kahlo's public persona, they all shared the emphasis on &bquo;her&equo;, as an encapsulisation of stereotypical images of Mexico, rather than her work. 
 It is her body as the canvas, her appearance as art. 
 The art of self-expression becomes self-expression as art. 
 Fig. 2. 
 Vogue , February 1990, p. 130&ndash;1. 
 Fig. 3. 
 Elle Magazine , May 1989, p. 28. 
 Of course, the line between art and life is a particularly hard one to draw in Kahlo's case. 
 The majority of her work is self portraiture; her aesthetic concerns grew from her fascination with the falsity of appearance. 
 Dressing up, role playing and masquerade form the conceptual basis of Kahlo's work. 
 In Self-Portrait with Cropped Hair  (1944) (Fig. 6), she paints herself wearing Rivera's suit, challenging traditional expectations of femininity and attempting to appropriate his authority (while simultaneously) threatening castration). 
 More disturbingly, in The Mask  (1945) (Fig. 7), she throws doubt on too straightforward a reading of her self-portraits as revealing of her inner emotions. 
 Where does the mask fall: Does not the ritual repetition of those familiar features &bquo;mask&equo; far more than it uncovers? 
 There is, however, an inevitable logic to the appropriation of her meticulously constructed image, a process which the artist was mocking as early as 1933: &bquo;&hellip; some of the gringa women are imitating me and trying to dress &bquo;a la Mexicana&equo;, but the poor souls only look like cabbages and to tell you the naked truth they look absolutely impossible.' 
 The &bquo;impossibility&equo; stemmed from the failure of such followers to recognise the symbolic importance of Kahlo's choice of clothing, a failure also intrinsic to her recent magazine appearances. 
 The particularities of post-revolutionary Mexico are frequently subsumed by the decorativeness of the ethnic, by the generalised attractiveness of the radical avant-garde. 
 For Kahlo, however, choosing to don the costume of the Tehuana, as for example in Tree of Hope  (1946) (Fig. 8), was to embody a powerful icon of cultural identity. 
 Mexican Indian dress is extraordinarily diverse and by and large geographically specific, varying from region to  region. 
 The Tehuana dress is by no means the most decorative variant or the closest to pre-Hispanic forms of clothing. 
 It is the mythology surrounding the women wearers of the costume which directed Kahlo's choice. 
 The ostensibly matriarchal society of Tehuantepec led to the adoption of the Tehuana, in post-revolutionary Mexico, as the image of the strong Indian woman; the undefeated counterpart to the despised &bquo;Chingada&equo;, who, conversely is the female embodiment of Mexico's hybrid post-conquest culture. 
 In a culture where sexual metaphors are frequently used to convey racial and political conflict, the Tehuana represents that aspect of Mexico's indigenous tradition unbowed by centuries of colonial and male rule. 
 Kahlo's adoption of Tehuana dress, while being an attractive disguise of what she saw as a less than perfect body, asserted both a feminist and an anti-colonialist position. 
 Fig. 4. 
 Vogue , February 1990, p. 138. 
 Fig. 5. 
 The Independent on Sunday , 8th April 1990, p. 37. 
 In Kahlo's work there is a powerful mix of these discourses, yet her role as an archetypal woman painter has come to dominate responses to her work. 
 It is through her emergence as a cult painter of the feminist movement of the 1970s that her current reputation has evolved. 
 Her work almost perfectly illustrates debates as to the nature of traditional exclusions of a woman's art. 
 The fascination with functions of the body, the analogies between artistic  and physical creative processes, self-portraiture used to reveal the female body as the site of patriarchal aesthetic discourse; all of these mirror the concerns of many women painters of the 1980s. 
 Fig. 6 . 
 Frida Kahlo: Self-portrait with cropped hair , 1940, 40x27.9 cm. 
 Museum of Modern Art, New York. 
 Fig. 7. 
 Frida Kahlo: The Mask , 1945, 40x30.5 cm. 
 Coll. 
 Dolores Olmeda. 
 Fig. 8 . 
 Frida Kahlo: The Tree of Hope , 1946, 55.9x40.6 cm. 
 Coll. 
 Isidore Ducasse Fine Arts Inc. 
 In their formal language, Kahlo's works are exemplary of certain feminist arguments; the adoption of the decorative, the intimate and non-fine art mediums reveals the restrictive nature of traditional definitions of &bquo;high art&equo;. 
 This &bquo;appropriateness&equo; of Kahlo's aesthetic to contemporary debate has tended to remove her work from its historical context, to stress the collective and the cross-cultural. 
 Although this is not in itself to be dismissed as a tactic, it has diminished the complexity of Kahlo's achievement as a specifically Mexican painter, operating within the particularities of her historical moment. 
 More problematic is the way in which such a dislocation has led to the acceptance of her &bquo;Mexicanness&equo; as mere decoration of the essentially feminist themes of her work, thereby defusing a substantial part of the art described by Breton as a &bquo;ribbon round a bomb&equo;. 
 It is the ribbon that runs through the pages of Vogue , the glossy surface of the images in direct opposition to a work such as Kahlo's The Suicide of Dorothy Hale  (1939) (Fig. 9). 
 In this painting, a memorial to a woman's tragic death is transformed into an indictment of the culture which destroyed her. 
 Hale's suicide became a poignant metaphor for the oppressive nature of the social values of New York and North America in general. 
 The story behind Hale's death was one with which Kahlo obviously identified, and within which dress formed an important symbolic function. 
 Before jumping from the window of her apartment, Hale had dressed meticulously in her most flattering dress, the corsage of yellow roses a gift from a male admirer. 
 In Kahlo's painting, the figure falls from the fantasy world she has inhabited to the harsh bloodspattered reality of the street, literally coming down to earth. 
 Hale's eyes stare knowingly at the viewer, a human sacrifice to an alienated and consumerist culture. 
 The horizontality of her fallen body is juxtaposed to the vertical thrust of the apartment building. 
 She leaps from an architectural monument to a phallocentric world. 
 Although destroyed, she has also escaped. 
 The painting, dedicated to Hale's mother, was commissioned by a mutual friend of Kahlo and Dorothy Hale, the managing editor of Vanity Fair , Clare Boothe Luce. 
 The painting was agreed to by Luce in part to recompense for what she saw as her misjudgment of her dead friend. 
 Having lent Hale money to pay her rent she had been angered to discover her spending enormous sums on an haute-couture dress, and refused to turn up to what, in retrospect, became Hale's farewell party. 
 Later it was revealed that the money had come from a different source. 
 A male friend had tried to dissuade Hale from seeking a much needed job and had given her a thousand dollars to buy &bquo;the most beautiful dress in New York&equo;, telling her that what she needed was to find a rich husband. 
 On one level this work deals with a generalised &bquo;woman's experience&equo;, yet the metaphorical power of Dorothy Hale's dress derives from Kahlo's use of clothing in her own self-portraits. 
 Dress not only covers and decorates the body but instils in the wearer its own characteristic strengths and weaknesses. 
 Hale's black velvet dress is cursed because it represents the values of the &bquo;Gringolandia&equo; so hated by Kahlo. 
 In those paintings where Kahlo wears European dress she is passive, weak and unable to control her own destiny, but in the Tehuana costume she is strong, powerful, hopeful. 
 Unclothed, her body becomes yet more vulnerable, but as Jean Franco states: 
 The unclothed body is not a &bquo;self but a socialised body, a body that is opened by instruments, technologized, wounded, its organs displayed to the outside world. 
 The &bquo;inner&equo; Frida is controlled by modern society far more than the clothed Frida, who often marks her deviation from the norm by defiantly returning the gaze of the viewer. 
 Kahlo's naked body becomes not just the tortured self of her personal biography but a visual counterpart to the injured and defiled manifestations of Mexico's colonised past: La Llorona &bquo;the weeping woman&equo; of popular myth and La Chingada, the raped and abused mother described in Paz's The Labyrinth of Solitude . 
 Descended from an Aztec mother goddess, Llorona is a long-suffering mother figure, symbolic in a wider sense of the trauma of the  Spanish invasion. 
 Driven mad with grief by the loss of her child, she is thought to wander the streets weeping and crying out a ghostly memory of the pre-Conquest past. 
 At its most simple, La Chingada, as the mother of Mestizo culture is &bquo;the Mother forcibly opened, violated or deceived&equo;. 
 The female soil possessed and misused by the masculine force of the Spanish invaders. 
 The Indian Mexico raped and abused by the conquistador yet bearing his bastard child. 
 The rhetoric of the Tehuana opposes the nihilism of traditional feminisations of colonial trauma, and asserts the potential of a dignified cultural resistance. 
 Fig 9 . 
 Frida Kahlo: The Suicide of Dorothy Hale , 1939, 58.1x47.5 cm. 
 Phoenix Art Museum, Arizona. 
 A major, though often ignored, work by Kahlo demonstrates the cultural politics underlying her art. 
 My Dress Hangs There  (1939) (Fig. 10) is one of the artist&equo; s most formally adventurous works, mixing photographic collage with paint to produce a critique of North American culture. 
 Kahlo does not appear in the work, her Tehuana costume hangs empty in the centre of the composition, suspended between a toilet bowl and a golfing trophy. 
 On one level My Dress&hellip;  is a coda to Self-Portrait on the Borderline  (1932) (Fig. 11) of the previous year. 
 This small painting on metal, in the style of a Catholic votive image, shows the artist poised between the technological inhumanity of a capitalist North America and the archaic fertility of Mexico. 
 Interwoven with these images are subtler references to the metaphorical borderlines which separate Latin American culture from that of Europe and North America. 
 This is done by a series of juxtapositions; the past versus the present; female nature versus masculine technology; growth versus exploitation; and in its very material presence, the traditions of fine art versus the popular. 
 At the same time the ambivalence of her own, and modern Mexico's position is manifested in the figure of the artist. 
 The paper flag of her homeland is contrasted to the modernity of the cigarette held in her other hand. 
 The red and green of the Aztec necklace links it compositionally with the indigenous plants to the &bquo;south&equo; of the painting, the pink colonial-style dress tonally blending with the skyscrapers to the &bquo;north&equo;. 
 My Dress &hellip; again suggests a conflict, but the ambivalence is gone. 
  Nature has been banished, technology and its concomitant values reign over a harshly masculine world. 
 Three elements refer to the female presence, all of them dealing with an essential lack. 
 The empty dress, a peeling poster of Mae West and in the far distance the Statue of Liberty. 
 Fig. 10 . 
 Frida Kahlo: My Dress Hangs There , 1933, 46x50 cm, estate of dr. 
 Leo Eloesser. 
 Although occasionally humorous, the work presents a bleak view of urban alienation. 
 The Church, Wall Street, and Industry are joined by a network of telephone lines, forming a remorsely inhuman environment. 
 Beneath this man-made mechanism of oppression are the people, literally distanced from their surroundings by Kahlo's use of photo-collage. 
 In the forefront of this scene flutters the dress, incongruously vibrant despite its suggestion of loss. 
 Dislocated from its political context, it hangs like a pi&ntilde;ata  above the teeming streets of the city; decorative yet potentially explosive. 
 There is no place &bquo;there&equo; for the values the Tehuana dress represents, its folds are given meaning by Kahlo's search for a cultural identity. 
 Within the confines of the painting it becomes a silent emblem of protest, a reminder of political alternatives. 
 The physicality so characteristic of Kahlo's work is missing, no flesh, no blood, just the tawdriness of the peeling poster and the hollow reminder of lost Liberty. 
 The inter-relationship of body and dress so self-consciously referred to in many of Kahlo's most polemical works (Fig. 12) has been strangely inverted by her current popularity. 
 Her &bquo;Mexicanness&equo; has become a stylistic gloss, decorative, colourful, pretty, even individualistic. 
 The colonised body which Kahlo clothed in revolutionary idealism has lost its function as a symbol of nationhood becoming instead an icon of female suffering. 
 What is obscured by this process is that it was through clothing, in both art and life, that Kahlo attempted to redress the wrongs of history.   
 Fig. 11 . 
 Frida Kahlo: Self-Portrait on the Border , 1932, 33x45.8 cm. 
 Coll. 
 Mr &amp; Mrs Manuel Reyero. 
 Fig. 12 . 
 Frida Kahlo: The Two Fridas , 1939, 173.5x173 cm. 
 Museo de Arte Moderno, Mexico D.F. 
 SURREALISING THE BAROQUE: MEXICO'S SPANISH HERITAGE AND THE WORK OF ALBERTO GIRONELLA 
 Valerie Fraser 
 It is a truism to say that that which cannot be readily classified will tend to be overlooked. 
 In Art History the rehabilitation of artists and bodies of work which have been overlooked has been going on since Vasari made such a good job of classifying Florentine art that all other art in Italy and beyond has had to be defined, at least until this century, and at some level even now, in relation to Vasari's classifications, or at least in relation to the model of stylistic evolution which he outlined. 
 Non-Italian artists, non-Italian preoccupations, women artists, artists working in media other than Vasari's chosen painting, sculpture and architecture, non-Western art and so on: critics have been busy reviewing such areas and, in so doing, producing new categories and classifications. 
 Latin American art has been undergoing such a review both from within Latin America itself and from elsewhere, with several exhibitions and books on the subject in the last few years in Europe and the US. 
 That there should be an issue of the Oxford Art Journal  devoted to Latin American art is itself testimony to the success of such efforts. 
 But new categories can in turn prove to be exclusive. 
 Within the field of Latin American art as a whole there are still many individual artists who have not received the attention they deserve because their work does not seem to fit into any larger pattern. 
 In the case of the work of the Mexican Alberto Gironella, the reason would seem to be precisely because of his insistent concentration on art of a very different category &mdash; that of Spain during the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, particularly court portraiture. 
 Among the more comprehensive books on twentieth-century Mexican art in recent years, Shifra Goldman only mentions him in passing, Luis Cardoza y Arag&oacute;n says little more than that Gironella &bquo;escapes him&equo;, and Ida Rodriguez Prampolini dismisses him from her discussion of Mexican surrealism as an &bquo;international&equo; artist, more closely related to Spain than to Mexico. 
 When he has inspired sympathetic coverage, the results tend to be not so much an exposition of Gironella's achievements but belong to that particular branch of literature which uses works of art as a starting point for literary excursus. 
 Octavio Paz's elegant essay is the prime example, where despite some insightful remarks he uses Gironella's work to make general observations about the creative role of the critic, for example, or for digressive flourishes on Spanish culture. 
 When they met in Paris in 1963, Breton hailed him as a surrealist, but in a recent interview Gironella disclaimed so tidy a classification, saying he is as much a baroque artist as a surrealist. 
 In fact, although there are both surreal and baroque elements in his work, Gironella prefers to call it mestizo&equo;, a term which has often had negative, racist overtones but which has been acclaimed in this century, especially in Mexico, as a positive value, indeed the  distinguishing feature of Mexican culture: the rich and fruitful mixture of the European with the indigenous American. 
 This rather simple notion, that there is one single Mexican culture, problematic principally because it tends to valorize the European over the indigenous and to ignore the diversity, and richness of the latter, but also, conversely, because it excludes or denigrates the more purely European aspects of the culture. 
 Nevertheless it seems to me that Gironella is right, or that he is right in so far as he is using &bquo;mestizo&equo; to claim for his work a Mexican, not a European identity. 
 He is probably also right when he says that he is only seen as a Spanish  artist because his interest lies in Spanish art, instead of in French art &bquo;like everyone else': in other words, within the accepted categories there is no room for a Mexican who is interested in Spanish art.' 
 My purpose in what follows is to try to place him within a Mexican context. 
 Gironella's subject matter is the acclaimed artistic masterpieces of the Spanish past which he reworks in various ways, most dramatically into ironic altars assembled from a variety of painted, sculpted and ready-made elements (Fig. 1). 
 Favoured subjects are court portraiture, and allegorical images of death, decay and the transience of life, usually handled with the blackest of black humour. 
 Favoured artists are Goya and his predecessors in the Golden Age &mdash; &mdash; El Greco, Pereda, Vald&eacute;s Leal and above all Vel&aacute;zquez. 
 It is worth emphasising that the period spanned by the lives of El Greco and Vel&aacute;zquez saw in Latin America the consolidation of colonial government and of the Christian church, the establishment of the Spanish language and of European culture, the introduction of new methods of exploitation of people and resources. 
 Goya's life, on the other hand, coincides with the decline and ultimate collapse of the Empire; Spanish rule in America had been overthrown by the time of his death in 1828. 
 In other words, these artists lived during Latin  American's formative years. 
  the work of the artists who interpreted their historical reality on to canvas, but the importance in Latin America of the art itself should not be underestimated, particularly the iconography of the monarchy. 
 Vel&aacute;zquez's name, for example, would have been familiar to very few Mexicans in the seventeenth century, but as the only artist authorised to execute likenesses of the King his official portraits of Philip IV and the innumerable engravings after them would have been well known. 
 A painting by his contemporary, Juan Bautista Maino, The Recapture of Bahia , of 1635, represents the recapture of the harbour of Bahia in Brazil (then under Spanish control) from the Dutch in 1625. 
 (Fig. 2) While an injured man is tended in the foreground, the Dutch forces to the right kneel in homage before an allegorical tapestried portrait of Philip IV. 
 This is a highly unusual painting in a number of ways, not least because no such royal portrait could ever have existed, including as it does, and on almost equal status with the king, the figure of his ambitious minister the Count-Duke of Olivares. 
 Nevertheless, on special occasions the Spanish authorities in America would certainly have erected large representations of the king in this manner, as objects of semi-religious devotion. 
 On the death of a member of the royal family elaborate catafalques were constructed in cathedrals throughout the Empire and the deceased mourned in effigy. 
 Paintings and prints were distributed to colonial officials for display in much the same way as British embassies are provided with an official photographic portrait of the Queen. 
 In other words, the focus of Gironella's attention is neither historically nor iconographically arbitrary, although in some ways his reworkings of the paintings of others could be seen to be simply an extension of a fairly conventional activity. 
 Within the Western tradition of art we tend to take it for granted that much can be learned from the study of the art of the past and, traditionally, copying from the works of the Great Masters was one of a young student's most important tasks. 
 This activity, this dependence on the art of the past, is not, in itself, ideologically highly-charged. 
 Reynolds may have admired and borrowed from Michelangelo, and while this could be said to represent, perhaps, a long-standing tradition of cultural domination &mdash; or the domination in England of the Italianate tastes of the English upper classes &mdash; it would be a mistake to make too much of this. 
 In the case of Latin America it is more complex. 
 Historically the relationship between Latin America and Europe is not only one of cultural domination of the former by the latter, but of political and economic domination. 
 While the obvious colonial ties have been broken, the power still lies elsewhere. 
 The sources of domination have in some ways simply broadened to include the US, japan, and international capitalism. 
 Within the art world the problem remains that the production of art in Latin America, from a student's training to the art market, is rooted firmly in the European tradition, while to compound the difficulties, few Latin American museums can boast any examples of European, North American or even non-national art at all. 
 Everything conspires to exacerbate the situation: conventional art education teaches an art-historical line of descent through the successive achievements of the Great Masters, but such works are unavailable in Latin America except in the form of often poor-quality reproductions. 
 In this sense things have not changed much since the seventeenth century. 
 Gironella always seems acutely aware of these issues. 
 For him the reworking of familiar images is not simply a matter of drawing attention to the way in which mass-reproduction numbs the optic nerves, by shocking the spectator with a moustached Mona Lisa, but rather, using a peculiar blend of both iconoclasm and  a sort of wry homage, of investigating the power of certain images, particularly those which have national resonance. 
 In this sense his Habsburg and Bourbon portraits are not dissimilar to Jasper Johns' American flag series, except of course that the flag, whatever individuals may think of it, is unquestionably American, the lineage is clear. 
 The connecting threads between the Spanish  monarchy and colonial Mexico, between Spanish artists and Mexican, between past and present, are tangled or broken. 
 Within Spanish art itself, on the other hand, the line is almost too simple: Goya was intensely aware of Vel&aacute;zquez, Picasso of both, but for Gironella the problem is not just that Picasso could be seen to have inserted himself into the next place in the sequence but that as a Mexican an unequivocal position in any such art-historical lineage is utterly unattainable. 
 Fig. 1 . 
 Alberto Gironella, Lot y sus hijas  (Lot and his Daughters), 1984-1987; retable, 303 x 241.5 x 30 cms, collection of the artist. 
 Photograph: Jorge Pablo de Aguinaco, courtesy Galeria OMR, Mexico. 
 Gironella was born in Mexico City in 1929. 
 His rather was Catalan; he had come to Mexico as a young man and worked in his brother-in-law's grocery shop. 
 He later set up his own business importing groceries from Europe, particularly from Spain. 
 His mother was Yucatecan, a mestiza from M&eacute;rida, but she was &bquo;catalanised&equo;, as Gironella put it, by his father and grandmother; in other words a jointly Eurocentric upbringing, but, perhaps significantly, without personal contact with Europe until his first visit to Paris in 1960. 
 He absorbed European culture through nineteenth-century French novels, and through the literature of sixteenth and seventeenth-century Spain, the Spanish cultural Golden Age. 
 His major literary enterprise, as a student at the Universidad Nacional Aut&oacute;noma in 1951, was the invention of a bad Golden Age poet whom he named Tiburcio Esquirla. 
 His later artistic inventions display the same fascination with the possibilities of getting inside the skin of another era. 
 Through his efforts in this direction he effectively mocks much that is dear to scholars, historians, literary critics and art historians, especially the concept of a clear chronological sequence: his answer to the problem of how a Mexican can &bquo;belong&equo; to the dynasty of European art is, as it were, to invade it retrospectively. 
 The decisive move from literature to painting came in 1952. 
 Gironella seems to have been very confident about the change, as in the same year he was instrumental, together with Vlady and H&eacute;ctor Xavier, in establishing a new art gallery in Mexico City, the Galeria Prisse. 
 This quickly emerged as one of the most avant-garde of the new Mexican galleries, and the locus of a group of young artists, including Jos&eacute; Luis Cuevas, who &bquo;with no fixed programme and no common plastic language, &lsqb;&hellip;&rsqb; were united only by the desire for change&equo;. 
 Their discontent at this time was principally with the social realism of the muralist school but, even at this early date, there was unease with the propaganda emanating from the US that Abstract Expressionism was  the only possible alternative. 
 Gironella's solution was entirely individual: to focus on the art of the European past, looming large as it did in Latin American consciousness regardless of how often it had been declared dead and buried by Europeans. 
 Fig. 2 . 
 Juan Bautista de Maino, The Recapture of Bahia , 1635, oil on canvas. 
 Madrid, Prado. 
 His artistic career began with a series of paintings based on the thirteenth-century sculpture of the elegant countess of Uta on the fa&ccedil;ade of Naumburg cathedral, a photograph of which had been lent to him by the young artist Vlady, but in the late fifties he turned his attention to Spanish art. 
 His early choice of subject set the tone for his later work &mdash; &mdash; Goya's Queen Maria Luisa, and Vel&aacute;zquez's portrait of the dwarf Francisco Lezcano (Fig. 3) &mdash; in other words, great Spanish artists' handling of their arrogant, ugly, bizarre or idiotic sitters. 
 He subjected both to repeated analysis, ending up with a version of Maria Luisa in which she is transformed into a sharp-beaked, staring owl, and of Francisco Lezcano in which he has metamorphosed into a dog. 
 In both, Gironella is exploring the characters of the sitters as suggested in their portraits rather than the formal, painterly qualities. 
 Is Vel&aacute;zquez's Francisco Lezcano simple-minded, or is his expression one of aloofness and distance? 
 Gironella has said he was drawn to this painting because Lezcano is holding some playing cards, so his disconcertingly direct gaze is inviting us in to test our wits and/or our luck against him. 
 Queen Maria Luisa, wife of Charles IV, an unlovely, clever, deceitful and immensely powerful woman, is metamorphosed into a barn-owl, a lechuza , a word which in Spanish also means an ugly hag or a procuress. 
 Gironella's first direct encounter with Vel&aacute;zquez was at an exhibition of his work at the Metropolitan Museum in New York in 1959. 
 Amongst the works on view was the one to which he has returned most often &mdash; the portrait of Queen Mariana of Austria, second wife of Philip IV, painted in 1652 (Fig. 4). 
 This painting has become a veritable obsession and he has returned to it repeatedly over the past thirty years. 
 It is a full-length portrait showing the young queen very formally dressed, in a stiff conventional pose, looking out at the spectator. 
 She wears a gigantic wig decorated with feathers and red bows, the shape of which echoes that of the wide skirt. 
 One arm rests on the farthingale of the skirt, the hand very delicately holding a large white scarf; the other hand rests on a chair back. 
 In the earliest versions, which date from 1959 &mdash; 60, Gironella turns her into a sort of rag doll; perhaps never more than a well-dressed shell, she is now simply a collage of fragments of coarse, torn cloth that appear to be pasted  down with thick smears of paint (Fig. 5). 
 These early half-length versions, like close-up details of the original, also investigate compositional qualities, the slight angle of the torso to the picture plane and the relationship of head and wig to shoulders, as well as emphasising features which are to become increasingly fetishised in subsequent renderings &mdash; the massive wig, for example. 
 And in the second version he introduces a three-dimensional hand not, as in the Vel&aacute;zquez with the fingers straight and limp, but drawn up into an uneasy gesture, that claws at her skirt rather than rests against it. 
 The hand and the wig are to become identifying features, often used in isolation or in conjunction with elements from other pictures. 
 They become relics, like the dismembered remains of Catholic saints that are boxed up and dispersed around Christendom to provide individual churches with the Church's authority. 
 Fig. 3 . 
 Vel&aacute;quez, Francisco Lezcano  or El Nino de Vallecas  (The Child of Vallecas), 1637, oil on canvas, 107 x 83 cms. 
 Madrid, Prado. 
 Fig. 4 . 
 Vel&aacute;quez, Queen Mariana , 1652, oil on canvas, 231 x 131 cms. 
 Madrid, Prado. 
 In The Black Queen  of 1961, Mariana has more substance than in the early collages of rags, and so, being more tangible, is more a victim, of Gironella, of time, of historical circumstances (Fig. 6). 
 In this full-length version Gironella places her square to the picture plane, a crucial adjustment which changes the tone from that of the formality of the original into one of helplessness. 
 Moving from her external trappings to her internal structure, he represents her as a sort of wooden skeleton. 
 At her breast, instead of a gold rosette, she wears a brass bell and a series of wheels and cogs, apparently parts of an old-fashioned, manually operated lift. 
 She is like a mechanical musical doll that will perform a ponderous dance when someone turns the dial. 
 She is also black. 
 In particular, the uplifted, unseeing face, and the hand, now even more tense and strained, are modelled in three dimensions and painted shiny black. 
 She is, of course, a parody of her pale, former Habsburg self, but Gironella's title, La Reina Negra , suggests a range of different resonances, as indeed it does in English. 
 She is a piece in an international game of chess; she is gloomy and melancholic; she is also, rather more strongly than in English, unlucky, wretched, doomed. 
 But conversely, in Latin America, negra  or neqrita  are often used as terms of affection. 
 As if to ensure, however, that we cannot interpret this work as a declaration of Gironella, s ideas about race and colour in Mexico, there exists another version, almost identical but for the fact that this is a white  queen.  
 Fig. 5 . 
 Alberto Gironella, Reina Mariana , 1960, oil and collage on canvas, 100 x 80 cms. 
 Collection of Maurice Reims, Paris. 
 Photograph, courtesy Galeria OMR, Mexico. 
 Fig. 6 . 
 Alberto Gironella, Reina Negra  (Black Queen), 1961, mixed media on canvas, 108 x 120 cms. 
 Private Collection. 
 In the following year she is reincarnated, but into wood, not flesh and blood: she becomes furniture, a cross between a throne and a commode, her mask-like head and rigid hand fixed to the chair back, her wig suggested by curly iron coat hooks and carved wooden scrolls and flourishes. 
 In one version, the space beneath the seat contains a small, stuffed cayman and, as this is the equivalent of the space beneath her skirts, there are obvious psycho-sexual overtones. 
 In another there is in fact no seat as such, rather like a monk's misericord, a chair that is not a chair (Fig. 7). 
 Again her heart is represented by the mechanism from an old lift: she goes up and down as others will her. 
 The origins of Gironella's peculiar assemblages lie in his childhood. 
 His earliest memories are of stacks of colourful imported tins, boxes, bottles and packets of the family grocery business, and of the paraphernalia of popular Catholicism, which would have included reliquaries and tabernacles, retables combining paintings and sculpture, altars decorated with damask cloth, candles, flowers and ex votos  of an often intensely personal nature. 
 He recalls building himself private altars of chocolate wrappers and tin cans. 
 The packaging of imported products has continued to fascinate him, for intrinsic qualities &mdash; &mdash; the names, the colours and the designs &mdash; but also no doubt because of the way products from far away have been integrated into the domestic Mexican environment. 
 Such products are known by the general term ultramarinos , &bquo;from across the ocean&equo;, and to emphasise that Mariana herself is also an ultramarina , she is often accompanied in Gironella's tableaux by tins of sardines. 
 There are connections here too with Spanish Golden Age painting which, as Gironella himself has observed, often looks very smelly . 
 The picaresque literature of the period is also very preoccupied with food and drink. 
 But it is not just the strong smells of food, but the metaphorical smells of corruption and moral and social decay which are suggested by the inclusion of such items in his work. 
 And where the tins of fish are juxtaposed with fragments of Mariana's body the evocation is also of death and putrefaction, perhaps also of coarse jokes about the distinctive &bquo;fishy&equo; smell of vaginal secretions. 
 Gironella's choice of Vel&aacute;quez's Mariana as the basis for so many of his works is worth considering in more detail. 
 First, to develop the idea of the punning associations already referred to in relation to the term ultramarinos , there is the pleasing assonance between the name of this earthly Queen Mariana, and that of Maria, Queen of Heaven. 
 The Virgin has always been more popular than Christ in the New World; indeed in the sixteenth century certain churchmen had argued that while the East was the domain of Christ, the newly discovered West was that of his mother. 
 Once in America, however, Maria soon fragments into numerous different Marias, each with her own distinctive attributes. 
 In Mexico, during the Wars of Independence the Virgin of Guadalupe protected the nationalist forces while the Spaniards placed their trust in the Virgen de los Remedios. 
 Gironella's many versions of Vel&aacute;zquez's Mariana similarly fragment her into different roles &mdash; queen, woman, icon, cadaver, carnival figure, victim, aggressor. 
 There is a third sister in this euphonious family: Marina, the baptised name of Malinche, mistress of Cort&egrave;z, through whose good offices and linguistic skills Mexico was conquered both for the Virgin Maria, and for Marina's royal ancestors. 
 Marina is the original and ultimate traitor to her people, but as mother of the first mestizo she is also the mother of modern Mexico. 
 Mariana herself is remembered more as a name on a family tree than as a person. 
 Wife of Philip IV, she was also his niece; she had been betrothed to his son Baltasar Carlos but on his death at seventeen the King (her uncle) married her himself, and the only surviving son of this union was the cretinous Charles II, last of the Habsburg line. 
 She is also remembered because she was painted by Vel&aacute;zquez,  although this is not unrelated to the family tree. 
 Vel&aacute;zquez shaped the public image of this family for his own and for all subsequent generations, investing them with an extraordinary pictorial power and stability. 
 His portraits must in turn be considered an important constituent in their power, as compensation for their more corporeal weaknesses. 
 With hindsight it perhaps seems strange that one of the indisputably greatest figures in the whole of Western art devoted the better part of his life to sell-advancement, and to painting the King, his family, and their attendant dogs, dwarves and sycophants Certainly the irony of this, together with the fact that this inbred family of often considerable mental as well as physical fragility should have controlled the destiny of so vast an empire, is not lost on Gironella. 
 fig. 7 . 
 Alberto Gironella, Reina Mariana , 1962, object. 
 Private collection. 
 We can read into Las Meninas  such a view of the Habsburgs (Fig. 8): Philip IV and Mariana are merely reflections, living in a world of grotesquerie and make-believe; a tiny princess dressed as an adult with a skirt so stiff it makes her look as if she is on wheels, surrounded by curtseying maids, a dwarf, a midget, a huge dog with the ability to sleep through anything, and a great artist, aloof and all-powerful. 
 Such a view is of course anachronistic, but this is exactly the attraction of Gironella's reworkings &mdash; he can present us with shifting visions of the art of the past, from within and from without, exploiting contrary responses, period eye and  innocent eye. 
 Not surprisingly Gironella has returned over and again to aspects of Las Meninas  and in particular to the portrait of the artist himself, the insider, the fawning courtier, the creator of icons. 
 Festin in Palacio  is one of Gironella's latter-day altarpieces, and a digest of elements from three paintings &mdash; Queen Mariana, Las Meninas  and the portrait of the dwarf Francisco Lezcano, popularly known as El Ni&ntilde;o de Vallecas  (Fig. 9). 
 In the lower register, on the altar frontal, the tilted head of Lezcano leers at us while, boxed up alongside, a disembodied head and a hand are presented as relics of Queen Mariana while above Vel&aacute;zquez himself, palette in hand, seems to fade into a dog. 
 On the altar table itself, in front of a piece of red damask, lies a large, realistically-modelled dog. 
 This is the dog from the foreground of Las Meninas , but here awake and ready for action, the centre of attraction and, apparently, the object of devotion. 
 The implications of Festin in Palacio  are realised in a particularly horrific version of Queen Mariana of 1963, Perro devorando a la Reina Mariana  (Dog devouring Queen Mariana) where she is set upon by hunting dogs who tear at her blood-red head gear (Fig. 10). 
 During the conquest of the Caribbean the Spaniards trained packs of such dogs to kill Indians and so to wipe out whole villages. 
 Here history is inverted: Mariana, Queen of the American Empire, is devoured by her own hounds. 
 But no simple anti-colonial reading of Gironella's work is possible, precisely because to denounce the  
 Fig. 8 . 
 Vel&aacute;zquez, Las Meninas , 1656, oil on canvas, 318 x 276 cms. 
 Madrid, Prado. 
 Fig. 9 . 
 Alberto Gironella, Festin in Palacio , 1958, retable, 251 x 174 x 60.5 cms. 
 Collection Maria Rodriquez de Reyero, Mexico. 
 Photograph, courtesy Galeria OMR, Mexico. 
 Spanish past is to deny many of the elements which go to make up modern Mexico. 
 The Queen of Yokes  is a good example in its complexity and range of reference (Fig. 11). 
 Here again Mariana is pinned out flat, composed of disparate elements. 
 Her wig is made up of bottle tops, left over from ordinary twentieth-century life, trodden into the dirt underfoot, pressed on to noticeboards. 
 The majority are painted yellow, the colour of the bottle tops on Superior , a light Mexican beer famous for its slogan &bquo;la rubia que todos quieren&equo; &bquo;the blonde which everybody loves/wants&equo;, reducing Mariana to that Latin American clich&eacute;, the accessible, desirable, blonde foreign female. 
 Her expression here is a mixture of naivet&eacute; and anxiety. 
 Her carved wooden bodice suggests popular Mexican crafts, and particularly the calaveras , animated skeletons which make up her rib cage. 
 These are the central feature of the Day of the Dead celebrations in Mexico, but then again skulls and skeletons are commonly used as emblems of the transience of life in seventeenth-century Spanish painting. 
 The gourd-breasts and the leather-thonged sorcerer's switch can be seen as referring to indigenous culture, as can the snakes' heads with which the yokes of her skirt appear to terminate. 
 The inclusion of these wooden yokes, the yugos  of verbal associations and pun. 
 The word Yugo  in Spanish, as in English, evokes different ideas: el yuqo  colonial, el yugo matrimonial and el yugo de la iglesia , the colonial yoke, and the yokes of marriage and of the church, and all of these are implied here. 
 Mariana is yoked in an arranged marriage to her uncle, Philip IV; she, as representative of the Spanish crown, is also a representative of the colonial and religious yokes which bound Mexico to Spain. 
 The motif of the yoke was originally the emblem of Isabella of Castile, Mariana's distant predecessor, who had been responsible for sending Columbus on his first transatlantic voyage in 1492; in other words she had been responsible for initiating the whole colonial process (Fig. 12). 
 In the present century the combined emblems of Isabella's yoke ( Y  for Ysabella) and her husband Ferdinand's arrows ( Flechas ) were expropriated by the Falangists in an attempt to claim some historical legitimacy. 
 In other words, verbally and visually the emblem of the yoke has strong resonances in Spain and Mexico. 
 But it is important that here the yokes are inverted: Mariana and the ties with Spain she represents have been transformed, translated into Mexican, into the  complexities of the mestizo Mexican present. 
 She is an essential but individually helpless cog in the colonial machine; she is pinned out like a pre-columbian sacrificial victim, bruised and blood-stained; she is a religious icon, like a popular image of the Virgin Maria; she is a mannikin from some popular religious festival. 
 Fig. 10 . 
 Alberto Gironella, Perro devorando a la Reina Mariana  (Dog devouring Queen Mariana), 1963, painting/object. 
 No longer extant. 
 Fig. 11 . 
 Alberto Gironella, La Reina de los yugos  (The Queen of the Yokes), 1975&ndash;1981, oil and collage on canvas, 240 x 180 cms. 
 Collection of Luis Felipe de Valle, Mexico. 
 Photograph: Bob Schalkwijk, courtesy of Galeria OMR, Mexico. 
 It is worth stressing the differences between Gironella's treatment of the art of the Spanish past and that of Picasso. 
 Picasso's extensive series of variations on Las Meninas  was produced in 1957, but even if Gironella knew of them when he himself began to work on versions of Vel&aacute;zquez (which is highly unlikely, as Picasso's paintings were not exhibited until 1959); even though their interest in the art of the past at that point in their careers was for both, perhaps, a rejection of abstraction; and even though both can in some way be defined as exiled from their Spanish roots, as outsiders looking in &mdash; &mdash; yet the results are widely divergent. 
 Picasso's paintings are principally explorations of, or developments of matters internal to Las Meninas:  the light, the perspective, the angle of Mariana's head, the bobbing handmaids, echoed, for example, in the paintings of pigeons bobbing on his window sill, and so on. 
 In one version, for example, the odd position of Nicolas Pertusato's hands is rationalised by the addition of a piano. 
 Gironella is far removed from such light humour. 
 Edouard Jaguer, when comparing the two, rather acidly remarks that &bquo;despite all the irritating virtuosity&equo; of Picasso's rendering of Delacroix or Manet or Vel&aacute;zquez, in the end they are one-dimensional. 
 Gironella is of course also interested in the formal qualities of these works, but it is the subject matter, the content, which really holds his imagination. 
 Drawn to the fact-is-stranger-than-fiction aspects of Spanish history, Gironella found in Vel&aacute;quez's portraits a perfect starting point for a detailed investigation of the contradictions which go to make up modern Mexico. 
 His preoccupations are unusual (if not unique, as he claims) but they are unquestionably engendered by the search for a cultural identity which lies behind so much of Latin America's greatest artistic and literary creations. 
 Ambivalence towards European culture, doubts about the possibilities of finding an authentic voice, a restless search for confidence and self-esteem, these are among the many bitter fruits of colonial rule in Latin America. 
 In 1921, Siqueiros had urged artists to &bquo;avoid those lamentable archaeological reconstructions&equo; (&bquo;Indianism&equo;, &bquo;Primitivism&equo;, &bquo;Americanism') but he had also warned against the use of &bquo;archaic motifs&equo; from the old masters of European art &bquo;which for us would be exotic&equo;; instead his advice was to study the arts of both, learning from the &bquo;constructive base&equo;, the &bquo;great sincerity&equo;, of the latter, and the &bquo;synthetic energy&equo; of the former, to combine the &bquo;lost values&equo; of the past with new values to produce an art appropriate to modern America. 
 It may not be quite what Siqueiros envisaged, but Gironella's is an authentically Mexican solution.   
 Fig. 12 . 
 Arrows and yoke emblem of Ferdinand and Isabella, the Catholic Kings from Casa de Las Conchas, Salamanca, 1483. 
 Previous Convictions 
 Paul Wood 
 Against Postmodernism: A Marxist Critique, Alex Callinicos, Polity Press in association with Basil Blackwell, Oxford, 1989. pp. 207, ISBN 0 &mdash; 7456 &mdash; 0614 &mdash; 8. &pound;8.95. 
 What is it that makes this substantial book produce, mixed-in with its rewards and knowledge, a depressing effect? 
 Does it matter? 
 Callinicos' own apology about publishing yet another study of an over-worked subject notwithstanding, it remains an important contemporary debate. 
 It isn't that; the more so since Callinicos' contribution contains a significantly original dimension. 
 Despite its fashionable subject the book is in no sense routine. 
 Uncritical testimonials to the postmodern's attractions are ten a penny, and conservative denunciations thereof not much scarcer. 
 This study has the distinction of being both critical and radical, essentially turning the tables on advocates of the postmodern and reading their rhetoric as symptomatic of a conservative milieu's interests in a period of overall stagnation. 
 It is &bquo;of course&equo; unlikely that Callinicos' criticism will cut much ice with those whose substantial career investments lie in one or another of the postmodern's corners: movementist politics, the radical academy, post this-ism and that-ism, a variety of well-upholstered &bquo;dissenting&equo; niches from both the dominant culture and traditional opposition to it. 
 Too much is at stake for a book dedicated to proving the continuing value of classical Marxism to dislodge them. 
 Maybe this is one reason for depression, then: that the book's well-wrought arguments will not exercise those whose ideology it dissects. 
 This indeed has already happened. 
 Callinicos' Marxism has been repelled from the ramparts of pluralism for being&hellip; well, Marxist. 
 It leads to the Gulag, you know, and is patriarchal to boot (translation: Marx had a beard). 
 Given that Callinicos' book is difficult, and given the probability that despite the seriousness of its argument it is unlikely to be widely debated, I will firstly offer an interpretation of what I think its main themes are, and what they are not. 
 In the first place, as the title makes plain, if offers a searching criticism of the claim that we are living in a postmodern epoch, and the consequence of that claim, that the culture and politics appropriate to such an epoch are structurally different from those of the preceding &mdash; and now past &mdash; Modern one. 
 Callinicos' criticism of the &bquo;postmodern&equo; hypothesis contains a range of emphases, the three principal ones of which are: First: advocates of the postmodern in art (which attains uncommon prominence in so far as the &bquo;postmodern&equo; is powerfully underwritten by a claimed distinction from Modernism), tend to misread the modern and arrogate its defining characteristics to their own period. 
 The main ones of these are: the ordering concept of &bquo;doubling&equo; &mdash; &mdash; double coding, the laying of one text over or against another; the relationship to historical codes of representation; and the relationship to popular codes of representation. 
 Callinicos is able to set the claims of such postmodern advocates as Charles Jencks and Linda Hutcheon against an analysis of Modernism (predicated largely on that of Eugene Lunn) in order to demonstrate that the latter is a good deal more complex in respect of its characteristic conceptions of the subject, expression, reflexion etc, than the former are wont to have it. 
 This is so to the extent that the claim for a structurally distinct postmodernist mode of signification breaks down in the face of a variety of historical avant-garde practices ranging across Europe from London to Vienna and Moscow in the hands of such as Eliot, Joyce, the Cubists, Surrealists and others (including, somewhat surprisingly, Kokoschka). 
 A further set of more qualified &mdash; or at least less wholesale &mdash; more ambiguous claims are then encountered, by authors such as Lyotard, Jameson and Lash. 
 These include: the postmodern as a tendency within the modern; a notion of the &bquo;sublime&equo; and postmodernism's related freedom from dependence on the concept of totality; a distinction between the postmodern conceived in terms of the externalised and impersonal as against a view of the modern as characterised by the internal and &bquo;impressionist&equo;; and a claim that it is the characteristic of the postmodern to signify figurally rather than discursively (?). 
 Callinicos' conclusion to these arguments is that despite their efforts, built around a claimed contrast of the postmodern either with or within Modernism, these authors have produced only &bquo;mutually and often internally inconsistent accounts&equo; of the &bquo;postmodern&equo;, manifesting an &bquo;inability to come up with a plausible and coherent account of its distinguishing characteristics&equo; (p. 28). 
 It is in fact Callinicos' later claim that, rather than occupying a qualitatively distinct position, &bquo;late capitalist culture represents a continuation of trends operative throughout this century&equo; (p. 53). 
 The second main emphasis of Callinicos' critique is aimed at the philosophy most frequently regarded as underpinning claims for the distinction of a postmodern culture, viz. poststructuralism. 
 Drawing on  his own previous work, as well as that of Dews and Habermas, the main thrust is initially to connect both &bquo;wings&equo; of poststructuralism &mdash; the &bquo;textualist&equo; strand associated with Derrida, and the &bquo;contextualist/historical strand identified principally with Foucault &mdash; to the Nietzschean philosophical tradition; and then to isolate the most common problems attributed to that tradition to which, a fortiori , post-structuralism succumbs. 
 These concern: the subject; the issue of how critical resistance to dominant codes ever develops in the absence of an adequate conception of the subject; and, perhaps most fundamentally, the traditional problem facing any philosophy seeking to reduce knowledge to interests tout court , of using rational argument to prove the limits on rationality. 
 This is the densest, yet at the same time one of the most persuasive sections of the book, wherein a variety of arguments drawn from the analytic tradition are deployed against Nietzsche's lineage: Quine and Davidson on a theory of meaning both holistic and realist &mdash; demonstrating that there are more ways out of atomism and the myths of the given than Saussure's; and an anti-relativist notion of truth as a &bquo;regulative ideal&equo; derived from Tarski, Popper and Lakatos. 
 There is no space here, central though it is to Callinicos' argument as a whole, to do other than note how this perspective is then deployed not only to counter poststructuralism but also significantly to modify the position of its main critic, Habermas. 
 If Foucault and Derrida are taken to task for their Nietzschean lineage, Habermas' main weakness is deemed to lie in his Kantianism, manifest in a formalist &bquo;metaethics&equo;, and his conception of &bquo;communicative rationality&equo; grounded in the consensual account of meaning offered by speech-act theory &mdash; and as such likewise vulnerable to Davidson, as well as to Wittgenstein. 
 In essence then, at this philosophical level, Callinicos is marrying historical materialism and analytical philosophy, as it were Marx and Wittgenstein, in order to defeat a range of new and old Idealisms: principally that tradition, dismissive of Enlightenment rationalism, descending from Nietzsche via Heidegger to a bathetic end in Lyotard and Baudrillard. 
 Compelling as it is, however, this strategy does not form the conclusion of Callinicos' case. 
 The third main emphasis in his critique of the concept of the postmodern is to attempt to explain the hold exercised by a demonstrably deficient theory of culture and its dependence on a fundamentally irrationalist philosophy: which is to say he offers a politics of the postmodern. 
 There are two pillars to this account: the emergence in the post-war period, and more particularly in the last two decades, of a mass social layer analysable under the rubric of a new middle class &mdash; though internally much differentiated as well as distinct from a traditional petite bourgeoisie in respect of its structured &bquo;overconsumptionism&equo;. 
 And secondly, the defeat of the last major challenge to the system associated with the overdetermined name of &bquo;1968&equo; but finally petering out in the mid-1970s. 
 The latter is primary; the emergence, or at least acceleration, of the former a consequence of measures adopted by newly confident conservative states to cope with the re-entry of the world system into a succession of capitalist crises after the exhaustion of the Long Boom. 
 This kind of argument reads well in Callinicos' hands, but it is worth reminding ourselves of the unattractive reality to which it bears witness. 
 A real tragedy has taken place. 
 If one only takes educational institutions such as universities and colleges, let alone the world outside, the emancipatory impulse of the sixties and early seventies has been turned inside out. 
 What began as a compelling rejection of a straitjacketing orthodoxy made its criticism in terms of a materialist demand that the socio-political locale of culture be addressed, in the face of an institutionalised aversion to any such examination conducted under a self-serving misrepresentation of the autonomy of art. 
 This stance has now been inverted by a puritanical moralising clerisy which virtually polices conduct and enquiry in the name of a postmodern triptych &mdash; as Terry Eagleton has put it &mdash; of class and race and gender. 
 What amounts to a fear of art, perpetrated under a false rhetoric of care and defence of the marginalised now dominates everything this oxymoronic &bquo;radical orthodoxy&equo; touches. 
 And it touches a lot. 
 Making all due allowance for the return of historical tragedy as farce, watching this soporific monolith of the virtuous rise out of the debris of a liberating movement is akin to nothing so much as witnessing Bureaucracy emerge from the ashes of Revolution. 
 It is one of Callinicos' main concerns to relate the constellation of ideas and cultural practices trading under a conception of the postmodern condition to an inadequate and escapist politics: the claim, as one of his own critics has had it, that &bquo;the conditions that sustain oppression can be altered piecemeal&equo; (Patton, cited, p. 85). 
 Callinicos mordantly comments on the descent &bquo;from revolutionary groupuscule to single-issue campaigns and then to social democracy&equo;. 
 In sum then, while acknowledging the stature of some elements of this constellation, such as the historical aspects of Foucault's work or the critical &eacute;lan of Fredric Jameson (not to mention the giant figure of Habermas), Callinicos develops a root and branch assault on claims for the cultural distinction of the &bquo;postmodern&equo;, for the conceptual adequacy of its theoretical base, and above all for the deleterious political consequences of adherence to it. 
 So far so good; or one might almost say, so unproblematic. 
 Callinicos mobilises as powerful a body of argument and evidence as is readily conceivable against a variety of contemporary critics and theorists whose claims he sees, with justice, as a trahison des clercs . 
 Thus far there is something almost conventional about the book's stance. 
 It is possible &mdash; just &mdash; to imagine a relatively orthodox artist,  critic or historian appreciating the demolition of postmodernism (if not the evidence of late capitalism's corruption and decay). 
 But this is not  the argument's main thrust; and it is this rather elusive second aspect which gives the book its definitive character. 
 &bquo;Elusive&equo; isn't quite the word, however. 
 It is more a matter of approaching the book's arguments from within a milieu of relatively academic contemporary art theory and being unable to see the wood for the trees. 
 For the concomitant of Callinicos' critique of postmodernism is not, as it would be in half a hundred other cases, the defence of modernism. 
 For one thing, Callinicos goes out of his way to establish that the intellectual tradition he is concerned to critique is itself most fruitfully read, not as an articulation of a qualitatively new postmodernism, but an instance of a Modernist-type response. 
 Thus: &bquo;poststructuralism &lsqb;&hellip; &dollar; the philosophical expression of Modernism, whose characteristic themes were indeed announced by Nietzsche&equo; (p. 6); Nietzsche's &bquo;system of ideas&equo; is &bquo;in many respects a philosophical articulation of the main themes of Modernism&equo; (p. 67). 
 Callinicos is concerned to give weight to the proposition advanced by Franco Moretti in respect of Carl Schmitt, that it is not the task of Marxism to defend Modernism as if its devices were &bquo;inherently subversive of the existing social order&equo; (p. 48). 
 The point is that for Callinicos, Nietzschean thought is an instance of Romantic anti-capitalism: that form of refusal of the implications of capitalist modernity which has been present virtually since the birth of that condition, described by Michael Lowy as &bquo;opposition to capitalism in the name of pre-capitalist values&equo; (cited p. 67). 
 The consequence of this is that Modernism too must be a form of romantic anti-capitalism, and as such one-sided and vulnerable. 
 The principal weakness of both the modernist tradition proper, and indeed of Nietzsche himself is, for Callinicos, their aestheticism. 
 It is as well to be clear on this. 
 Callinicos' defence of classical Marxism, of historical materialism, is in the first instance deployed against a postmodernism which has come to proclaim the death of the grand narrative of emancipation and the need for a new form of politics not constructed along the lines of the traditional left. 
 This defence of Marxism carries over, however, to a critique of Modernism itself: not merely for the fact that Nietzsche attaches &bquo;importance&equo; to art but for the further claim ascribed to him, and therefore to Modernism itself, that &bquo;the nature of aesthetic experience contains in nuce  the form of understanding proper to the world itself (p. 66). 
 In the end, that is, Callinicos pits historical materialism against not merely postmodernism but, following the logic that the latter is indistinguishable from Modernism properly conceived, against Modernism itself. 
 Drawing largely on the Marshall Berman/Perry Anderson debate, and thereby making of Modernism the characteristic expression of the experience of modernity, itself conceived as a response to capitalist modernisation, Callinicos seems to want to claim in essence that both the former are partial in respect of the fact of this last. 
 Weber's conceptualisation of the modern as a process of structural differentiation is, I think, seen to be echoed in Modernist claims for the specificity of art. 
 Both are then held to be deficient relative to Marx's conception of a &bquo;mode of production&equo; within  which differentiation can be understood, made intelligible and ultimately accountable to a materialistically grounded ethics of emancipation rooted in a conception of a &bquo;complex&equo; totality. 
 It is in connection with this perspective that Callinicos was concerned to deny the common conflation by postmodernists of Modernism with the Enlightenment. 
 From his point of view, Modernism as a sub-species of romantic anti-capitalism is one partial moment in the rejection of the consequences of Enlightenment properly understood: understood, that is, in terms of a Marxism which is itself held out as the genuine heir to the Enlightenment narrative of emancipation and  its romantic critique. 
 Here lies the root of Callinicos, project &mdash; the buttressing of Marxism as the &bquo;true radicalisation&equo; of the Enlightenment; and here I suspect lies also his ultimate discomfort with Modernism &mdash; prone as it is to slip the leash of a guiding politics and dance under the less biddable star of the Aesthetic. 
 At this point Callinicos has to be careful: it is one thing to dismiss the claims of a rootless postmodernism, wandering naked except for its designer trainers across the face of a barren late capitalism. 
 It is quite another also to offer a wholesale refutation of Modernism. 
 And Callinicos is aware of this: &bquo;Is not the general tendency of this analysis similar to Luk&aacute;cs' celebrated denunciation of Modernism as &bquo;aesthetically appealing, but decadent&equo;? (p. 53). 
 For fairly obvious reasons, mostly no doubt connected with the spectre of Zhdanov and Socialist Realism (but also I suspect because of a more subterranean philosophical linkage between Callinicos' endorsement of Althusser's &bquo;complex totality&equo; against Luk&aacute;cs' &bquo;expressive totality&equo; and the political voluntarism which it informed in the early twenties), Callinicos has to answer: No. 
 This begins to be interesting, and it is I think the originary focus of that sense of misgiving with which I began. 
 If I have been primarily expository hitherto (and I have been because I believe Callinicos' book to be the best on this subject that we have) I will now begin to turn to criticism; or at least to trying to ventilate that reservation which, faced by Callinicos, certainty, will not be stilled. 
 In a sense it doesn't matter if Callinicos' defence of Marxism is registered or not by the legion of Post-isms and -ists which form the undergrowth of contemporary cultural politics. 
 They will wither at the first frosts anyway, if they come; and if they don't&hellip; 
 But with his placement of Modernism in the lineage of Nietzsche, and as such at odds with Marx  and Freud as the real motors of that &bquo;true radicalisation of the Enlightenment&equo; (p. 120) which is the only way ahead, something more serious is at stake. 
 To backtrack a little, the case is perhaps not so monolithic as I have implied: for which we have to return to the detail of Callinicos' &bquo;No&equo; to Luk&aacute;cs. 
 On the one hand &mdash; and this is a point to which I shall return &mdash; there is a dual claim against Luk&aacute;cs' evolutionism (to the effect that different levels of a social formation are relatively autonomous: crudely, if bourgeois society is decadent this does not necessarily mean, as Luk&aacute;cs thought it did, that its art is too), and in favour of the possibility of being able to pass a positive &bquo;aesthetic judgement&equo; upon a particular work however questionable the general category under which it has been produced (a position related to Brecht's polemic against Luk&aacute;cs). 
 More empirically however, on the other hand, and drawing upon the work of Peter B&uuml;rger, Callinicos accepts the case for Modernism having contained a critical moment &mdash; a &bquo;protest against the capitalist society to which it is in complex ways related&equo; (p. 53). 
 This is principally indexed to the claimed historical transformation of Modernism into a series of engaged avant-gardes dedicated not to the aestheticisation of life, but to the integration of art into life. 
 As B&uuml;rger has it: &bquo;Aestheticism had made the distance from the praxis of life the content of works. 
 The business of the new configuration was different: art &bquo;transferred to the praxis of life&equo; &mdash; not however &bquo;to integrate art into this praxis&equo; but &bquo;the attempt to organise a new life praxis from a basis in art&equo; (cited p. 54). 
 The &bquo;avant-garde&equo; here means, of course, constructivism, surrealism and a range of Weimar practices grouped by Callinicos somewhat misleadingly under the label &bquo;Neue Sachlichkeit&equo;. 
 Just how remote this stance in fact is from the aesthetic is a matter for further debate, but it is perhaps worth interpolating that the implied valorisation of the products of these engaged avant-gardes as a function of their engagement is defeasible. 
 Contra Buchloh et al ., 
 as well as Callinicos, there is nothing as far as art (as distinct from culture or politics) is concerned which will a priori  privilege a Tatlin made in revolutionary Petrograd from a Matisse painted in a hotel bedroom on the Riviera &mdash; Benjamin on technique notwithstanding (don't forget: Benjamin owned a Klee). 
 Be that as it may, these avant-gardes are held to have a &bquo;distinctive character&equo; which resides in their &bquo;seeking to abolish the separation between art and life&equo;. 
 For Callinicos this is &bquo;unquestionable&equo;; as is the fact that the shift is enabled by the Bolshevik revolution of 1917. 
 (These arguments owe much to Perry Anderson's location of the tripartite enabling conditions of the Modern movement as: a decrepit academicism; the presence of new technologies; and &bquo;the imaginative proximity of social revolution&equo;.) 
 For Callinicos it is October which made the vision of social transformation &bquo;concrete&equo;. 
 The downside of this, so to speak, is that the defeat of October's aspirations also marks the avant-garde's defeat. 
 &bquo;Between them Stalinism and Nazism destroyed the avant garde. 
 The political defeats of the 1930s &bquo;shipwreck&equo; the avant-garde, and furthermore, through a kind of extension (since one assumes Anderson's tripartite conjuncture fuelled even those Modernist forms which did not quite take the transformatory step into engaged avant-gardism) come to determine &bquo;the more general exhaustion of Modernism&equo;. 
 The end of the Second World War is marked by the incipient commodification of social life, and as such &bquo;the disintegration of the Modernist conjuncture&equo; (pp. 60 &mdash; 1). 
 The problem then begins to stand clear and I shall now have to be brief and schematic. 
 Callinicos drives a coach and horses through postmodernism; well and good. 
 But the roads on which he drives it also go through most of the art produced in the last half century &mdash; shall we say for the sake of convenience, since the death of Trotsky; or in a more apt frame of reference, since Guernica ? 
 I will simply have to state the case dogmatically, but: this is untenable. 
 All of Callinicos' philosophical sophistication and matchless political experience evaporate in the face of the art of his own lifetime. 
 Aside from the fact that he doesn't actually discuss it in any detail, there is little more than a disappointed huffing and puffing at the exhaustion of the avant-garde's shock value (backed up by a particularly crass quotation from Peter B&uuml;rger about Duchamp's readymades) and some utterly routine panting over the outlandish prices being currently paid for Van Goghs &mdash; plus a quotation from a sub-Warholian Manhattan &bquo;artist&equo; answering an art magazine questionnaire with a few smart remarks about business and producing art for the market. 
 As if this were adequate to underwrite a claim for the avant-garde's loss of critical virtue. 
 In an extraordinary passage towards the end of the book, amplified in discussion at Marxism 90 in a debate specifically convened to discuss Modernism and Postmodernism, Callinicos described his experience of walking around an art gallery: &bquo;I have often been struck by the tedium that overcomes one while walking through a gallery of twentieth-century painting arranged in chronological order as one moves from the excitement of the early part of the century to the desperate and all too frequently sterile iconoclasm of recent artists' (p. 161). 
 The specifics aren't clear, but the contextual indications are that this would include American art from say, Pollock to Andr&eacute;, not to mention a range of contemporary work on commodification stemming from Warhol. 
 All of which says more about Callinicos, and the limits on his knowledge and interests, than it does about the work. 
 Whither Brecht now, on the lure of the good old days; not to mention the nostalgia laid at the door of romantic anti-capitalism? 
 I shall conclude briefly. 
 The point is I think that the argument from here can go two ways. 
 The first response is that it doesn't matter very much. 
  Callinicos, defence of Marxism is erudite and compelling, and the fact that he runs out of steam over post-war art is of less moment than the fact that he takes the range of issues seriously enough to discuss them at all. 
 Most sociologists, economists and politicians, after all, don't get that far. 
 The second road is however rockier; and it is an undecided question whether its implications are depressing and frightening, or challenging and exhilarating. 
 Callinicos is very careful to say, in at least two places in the book, that aesthetic judgement as to the value of a work of art is at least relatively independent of the cultural and philosophical critique of the bases from which it proceeds. 
 Thus, in his discussion of Modernism relative to Luk&aacute;cs and Brecht: &bquo;to highlight the fact that Modernism shares with Romanticism a &bquo;subjectified occasionalism, is not thereby to pass a negative aesthetic judgement on the works of art grouped together under the former label. 
 Brecht's polemic (i.e. against Luk&aacute;cs) &lsqb;&hellip;&rsqb; retains all its force today&equo; (p. 53). 
 And again &aacute; propos  Postmodernism: &bquo;Nor does the argument set out in this section imply the dismissal of all recent works &mdash; including those described as &bquo;Postmodern&equo; &mdash; &mdash; as worthless rubbish. 
 Good art can be produced in an immense variety of different conditions&equo; (p. 161). 
 This magnanimity is precisely the problem. 
 The traffic is all one way. 
 Callinicos appears to think that he can detect &bquo;aesthetic merit&equo; from the position given to him by his politics; politics, writ large, as embodying an ethics and a philosophy, is the active force. 
 Thus post-Second World War art is as it is &mdash; &mdash; with an &bquo;emphasis on the autonomous and abstract work of art&equo; (p. 154) &mdash; allegedly because of the &bquo;effects&equo; of the stabilisation and extension of capitalism. 
 Cause and effect: what took place was a &bquo;flight into abstraction&equo;. 
 This is a language, a world view, a form of life perhaps, wherein one of the principal reasons for according praise to a type of art is that it is able to give voice to a politics; Bolshevism in the main case, though as Callinicos acknowledges, one of the salient points about Modernism was its &bquo;ambiguity, its capacity to express a variety of different political positions&equo;; that is, when it was not engaged on its more usual &bquo;flight from politics&equo; (p. 161). 
 Art, it seems, is the perpetual recidivist, always ducking back into the aesthetic as soon as vigilant life averts its gaze. 
 When times are bad and reactionary commodification sets in, the deleterious upshot is &bquo;the recuperation of the avant-garde for art&equo; (p. 157). 
 When things are on the up and the lodestar of a transformatory politics shines bright, so too does &bquo;the avant-garde project of overcoming the separation of art and life&equo; (p. 171). 
 In this perspective it seems that Callinicos can only mean relatively little with his disclaimers about good art. 
 The individual &bquo;good&equo; work might get thrown up, however unpropitious the circumstance. 
 But it can only be a quirk; and the force of its &bquo;goodness&equo; is strictly limited and circumscribed. 
 Only once, in a fleeting reference to Matisse is there a sense of the boot being on the other foot, of art offering a sense of liberation from social ideology. 
 But even this is done in the name of a supposed &bquo;immediate sensuous charge&equo; rather than any more extended critical capacity of art or the aesthetic. 
 Of course, the whole thrust of the historic avant-garde, and particularly its celebration here, lies in its being associated with a liberation from bourgeois ideology; but this is not quite the same as having your revolutionary commitments tested by your aesthetic judgement. 
 For by far the greater part, the aesthetic is bracketed in the name of a robust historical materialism. 
 And there is no room for doubt as to which is the tail, and which the dog. 
 Walter Benjamin once implied something rather different. 
 Speaking against social realism in &bquo;The Author as Producer&equo;, he identifies a work's &bquo;political tendency&equo; and its &bquo;literary tendency&equo;. 
 The relationship he postulates is not one-way traffic; it is dialectical. 
 A work &bquo;can only be politically correct if it is also literarily correct&equo;. 
 I take this to mean that there is an equality, a reciprocity between the aesthetic and the political such that an aesthetic dimension or response can give the lie to a political claim. 
 The point of Benjamin's article seems to be to decentre the political, or at least to subject it to test, to remove those making claims for their political correctness from their habitual position of judge and jury: such that the art can, in principle, sort out the politics, and not just vice versa. 
 It is this, in the end, which I find disquieting about Callinicos' book. 
 Not the vapidity of the postmodern which it reveals. 
 But the way in which the very limits of its historical materialism (which I take to be the most developed statement of the case available in English) put back on the agenda questions one had considered closed. 
 The critique of Nietzsche's apocalyptic aestheticism, with its injunction to build your dwelling on the slopes of Vesuvius, just cannot be reduced to the clich&eacute; about Baudrillard fiddling while Rome burns with which the book closes. 
 (Is it anyway such a bad thing to make music while Atlantis sinks and cities evaporate? 
 At least you would have to be a doctor to say so, and not a politician or an academic.) 
 A requirement to minimise, even to trivialise the aesthetic &mdash; one might almost say, a fear of the aesthetic &mdash; is the hollowness at the heart of historical materialism as it is defended here. 
 There is obviously a problem concerning the subjective dimension of the aesthetic. 
 But a tame aesthetic is no friend of historical materialism. 
 Art has to be more than an ornament, or a reinforcement. 
 There has to be the possibility that the politics can be put at risk by the aesthetics, or the relationship as well as each of its components will be inert. 
 An unpredictable aesthetic, it could be said, is a requirement of an historical materialism adequate to its political task. 
 If the aesthetic is genuinely to  have reciprocal leverage upon the political, certain problems have to be faced. 
 For example, what goes on when looking at, say, a Matisse in an art gallery. 
 It is easy to say that the time spent considering the Matisse is time better spent than that spent considering a Gerasimov, let alone a Bouguereau. 
 (It is a terminal problem with the race n'class n'gender triptych that all these transactions are equivalently sociological.) 
 But what of time spent otherwise? 
 How to adjudicate? 
 The problem of course goes inescapably to a notion of the quality of experience (though what we are calling the aesthetic here is not, or not only, a question of intensity). 
 The relationship between, say, reading an article in Socialist Review  on the bureaucracy's pursuit of revenge on Arthur Scargill, and what it is that can be got from staring at Rembrandt's nose in a late self-portrait just is open. 
 One is not a priori  more important than the other. 
 Which is also to say that it is not the case that there is no connection, or that a category mistake is involved in the mere comparison. 
 The information about Arthur should bear upon how one regards the Rembrandt. 
 But the way Rembrandt's nose is worked should equally provide a corrective to rhetoric or elision in the writing on bureaucracy. 
 Which is to say, the political commentary is a form of writing. 
 Or, to use an unfashionable term in these linguistic days, of thought. 
 And it is of the utmost importance to realise that the pragmatic answer to these questions is itself what makes the revolution never happen. 
 Which latter is not however to say that &bquo;correct thinking&equo; overturns society. 
 Thought and organisation, or aesthetics and politics, must circle each other warily, the one never letting the other out of its sight. 
 The abyss which all this opens up is, perhaps, terrifying before it is &bquo;depressing&equo;. 
 I have mentioned Walter Benjamin here. 
 Callinicos concludes his book by invoking the memory of Benjamin to the effect that socialist revolution in the form of an irruption into history is the secular vehicle of a redemption hitherto conceivable only in mystic terms. 
 For Callinicos it is a belief in this possibility, and that alone, which remainders melancholy and irony &mdash; that is to say, Modernism &mdash; as an adequate response to modern life. 
 It is the consequence &mdash; presumably unintended &mdash; of his argument, however, that it demonstrates so irrevocably how much this is a matter of commitment and as such beyond the reach of proof. 
 One could say that the pressing question is how it is possible to live, rather than what teleology to adopt; or at least that the latter does not sort the former out. 
 Benjamin remarked, tellingly, that it is less a question of what a man's beliefs are than the kind of man those beliefs make of him. 
 This is no less an aesthetic matter than a political one. 
 Callinicos, in his haste to counter aestheticism, reduces the aesthetic. 
 He has to. 
 Yet the aesthetic will not be reduced. 
 It is not the means to an end conceived elsewhere: but an &bquo;as if&equo;, no less substantial than the as if  of revolution itself. 
 Value, you say? 
 Pushkin eating cherries before a duel; Lenin working day in day out on Iskra; one sentence or a newspaper (the point is of course, not one without the other); Benjamin on the requirement to denature your work &bquo;like ethyl alcohol&equo; lest it be of use to the other side. 
 For revolutions may occur, but the belief that they will does not of itself ensure a better lived life. 
 As to truth and beauty &mdash; the truth can doubtless be  beautiful, though it need not be. 
 Certain kinds of one-way traffic, certain kinds of one-way street, are in the end not hard to negotiate. 
 Their avoidance may be more difficult by far. 
 And there is always the possibility &mdash; the necessity? &mdash; that beauty can be its own truth. 
 Like taking poison on the border.  
 THE ART OF SCIENCE 
 GEOFFREY CANTOR 
 The Science of Art: Optical Themes in Western Art from Brunelleschi to Seurat, Martin Kemp, Yale University Press, New Haven and London, 1990. pp. viii &mdash; 375; 554 black and white illustrations &mdash; 16 colour plates. 
 ISBN 0 &mdash; 300 &mdash; 04337 &mdash; 6. &pound;49. 
 In a heady essay written over thirty years ago, Giorgio de Santillana argued that some of the key ideas of the Scientific Renaissance were to be traced to developments in the arts. 
 In particular, the idea of space was transformed from the Aristotelian conception &mdash; a &bquo;tidy arrangement of a simple multiplicity of things, not unlike, let us say, the shipping department of SearsRoebuck-&mdash; into &bquo;a matrix for infinite potential complexities and states and tensions&equo;. 
 The main innovators of this transformation were not scientists but artists, especially Alberti, Brunelleschi and Leonardo, who created on their canvases and in their architecture and treatises a new conception of space. 
 When I first encountered de Santillana's paper in the late 1960s I found it both fascinating and suggestive. 
 Its attraction arose principally from its iconoclastic message, for de Santillana explained one of the key conceptual innovations in the rise of modern science in terms that challenged the assumptions of my teachers in the history of science. 
 They had argued that the new ideas about space and motion had arisen from an intellectual and, to a much lesser extent, empirical critique of the preceding, largely Anstotelian, notions. 
 Discussion of this transformation was confined to the great tradition of philosopher-scientists beginning with Aristotle, continuing with medieval authors, such as Oresme and Jordanus, and ending with Kepler, Galileo, Descartes and, of course, Newton. 
 De Santillana offered a very different account of the new ideas of space and a different cast of actors. 
 Most importantly, he claimed that the new science was not the progeny of earlier science but the outgrowth of developments in the practical arts. 
 In his account the history of art and the history of science were intrinsically linked: in the late 1960s this was an heretical claim to most historians of science (and probably many historians of art). 
 Although sympathetic to this heresy I found myself intoxicated but also somewhat inhibited by de Santillana's impressionistic style. 
 However exciting his paper, his thesis seemed in danger of crumbling if it were reworked into a conventional historical discourse. 
 In the book under review, Martin Kemp reexamines the art-science relationship with much care and circumspection. 
 His style is lucid and he emerges as an honest broker who judiciously weighs the historical evidence. 
 He has an impressive command of the literature of both art and optical science across much of Europe and over a span of four centuries. 
 In contrast to de Santillana's uninterrupted thirty pages of text, Kemp's thesis is amply illustrated with several hundred plates, including many of his own line drawings showing artists' deployment of visual angles, vanishing points, etc. 
 The reader is led gently through the history of art and the details of optical science to appreciate their interrelationship. 
 Albeit less impressionistic and insightful, Kemp's analysis is of broader scope and greater clarity than de Santillana's. 
 Kemp identifies optics as a topic of common concern to both art and science. 
 (In a sequel he proposes to pursue the role of anatomy and natural history in the history of art.) 
 Of the many interweaving strands within this extensive topic he concentrates primarily on the way artists have deployed scientific ideas and instruments &mdash; these connections constitute &bquo;the science of art&equo; of his title &mdash; &mdash; while he also encompasses a number of related themes. 
 The science of art, claims Kemp, has not been adequately appreciated by art historians and to begin to rectify the situation he strives to demonstrate that &bquo;there were special kinds of affinity between the central intellectual and observational concerns in the visual arts and the sciences, in European history between the Renaissance and the nineteenth century (p. 1). 
 In the first of the book's three sections Kemp examines the theory and practice of perspective from Brunelleschi to Turner. 
 The second section, which is less focused and less easy to characterise, contains discussion of perspective machines and other technical aids as well as theories of perception. 
 The final section is concerned with the theory and depiction of colour. 
 In the first section one of Kemp's main themes is the relationship between theoria and praxis. 
 Renaissance artists confronting the problem of portraying spatial arrangement, responded by developing linear perspective. 
 The initial emphasis was on praxis. 
 Following the first crude attempts by Giotto, Lorenzetti and others, Brunelleschi got it right. 
 Then, in the mid-1430s, Alberti the theorist codified the system. 
 The basic rules of linear perspective were now accessible to any artist. 
 Theoria could influence praxis. 
 The relation between the theory and practice of  perspective over the next four centuries is examined in detail. 
 Textbooks flourished making the rules of perspective available to aspiring artists. 
 Codifiers produced ever more elaborate schemes for the depiction of spatial arrangements, often thereby rendering their work incomprehensible to the practising artist. 
 Artists, architects and draughtsmen experimented with the new schemes since the theory of perspective offered exciting possibilities to depict the spatial relations between bodies. 
 Thus the eye could be subjected to precise &bquo;reality&equo;, or it could be repositioned, led, titillated or deceived. 
 Some of the most fascinating material in this book is provided by the uses of perspective to create illusions &mdash; such as Mantegna's Camera degli Sposi (1465 &mdash; 74) and Pozzo's dome of San Ignazio (1685). 
 Moreover, Kemp hints at the diverse uses of perspective which offer a rich commentary on European history. 
 In the third and final section of the book Kemp addresses the use and theory of colours. 
 He argues that in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries many artists adopted versions of the Aristotelian theory which asserted that colours are a mixture of black and white in different proportions. 
 They also often used constructively the analogy between colours and the harmonic scale. 
 However, Newton's theory of light and colours, first published in 1672 and extended in his Opticks  (1704), provided a new direction for colour theorists. 
 In opposition to Aristotle et al , Newton showed with his prism that white light is a mixture of its composite colours. 
 Moreover, in the Opticks  he identified seven colours in the spectrum and described a circle divided into seven segments that could be used to account for colour mixing. 
 Newton's views were subsequently both elaborated and criticised. 
 Colour circles became ever more elaborate and orientated towards the practice of colour-mixing &mdash; witness those of Moses Harris (c. 1770) and Michel-Lug&egrave;ne Chevreul (1839). 
 Louis Castel exploited the analogy between light and sound with his &bquo;Ocular clavichord&equo; and Goethe explored subjective colours. 
 For their part artists were experimenting and drawing on the insights provided by the colour theorists. 
 Delacroix took Chevreul seriously. 
 Turner, always alive to new ideas, responded creatively to both Harris and Goethe. 
 Seurat paid close attention to both Helmholtz's Handbook of Physiological Optics  (1867) and Ogden Rood's Modern Chromatics  (1879) which, in turn, was based on James Clerk Maxwell's three-colour theory of vision. 
 Such a brief summary does not do justice to the detail and complexity of Kemp's argument. 
 Optics provides a superb locus for examining the art-science relationship since optical problems, theories and constructions were integral to both science and art. 
 To admit that much is not to foreclose the question of defining that relationship since a nuanced understanding requires the command of historical detail that Kemp provides. 
 Viewed from the late twentieth century and the widespread acceptance of the &bquo;two cultures&equo;, the search for affinities between art and science possesses particular significance for the historian. 
 Yet, by viewing history in this manner Kemp encounters an historiographical difficulty that he never satisfactorily resolves. 
 This problem surfaces even in his introduction in which he states that his concern is to show how artists &bquo;consciously aspired towards goals that we would now regard  as scientific in a broad sense&equo; (p. 1). 
 Part of this passage has been italicised to draw attention to the somewhat presentist presupposition that underpins much of this book. 
 In qualifying &bquo;scientific&equo; by &bquo;in a broad sense&equo; Kemp shows that he is aware of this problem. 
 However, the presentist influence is all too pervasive. 
 His frequent appeals to &bquo;scientific concepts&equo; and &bquo;scientific ideas&equo; often presuppose an unambiguous definition of science and one that is atemporal. 
 The difficulty is most apparent when discussing the Renaissance since by hypostatising science and art as two separate and separable activities Kemp is framing a problem that did not exist for the historical actors. 
 Take the example of Brunelleschi who, according to Kemp, introduced &bquo;scientific consistency&equo; into his use of perspective (p. 14). 
 The phrase suggests that Brunelleschi was engaging in an activity other than art. 
 Was he doing science? 
 And if so, would he and his contemporaries have recognised that in pursuing this consistency he was doing science, not art? 
 Again, how were science and art demarcated in the early fifteenth century &mdash; &mdash; socially, intellectually and institutionally? 
 Kemp's difficulty in defining &bquo;science&equo; and &bquo;art&equo; is not confined to his discussion of the earlier period. 
 For example, in his appraisal of the eighteenth century he uses &bquo;scientific&equo; and &bquo;Newtonian&equo; as predicates to create the impression of an hypostasised activity which stood separate from art and other aspects of Western culture, including philosophy. 
 Thus we are told that Brook Taylor, the author of the first major British work on perspective (1715), was &bquo;a professional Newtonian scientist&equo; (p. 287). 
 Although Taylor was active in the Royal Society, both predicates misrepresent this English gentleman who wrote extensively on mathematics and religion. 
 Likewise, owing to his over-rigid use of categories, Kemp characterises David Brewster, the most eulogistic of Newton's nineteenth-century biographers, as an &bquo;anti-Newtonian&equo; (p. 300). 
 A related and equally significant problem arises from Kemp's search for causal historical relations between science and art. 
 Questions of historical influence feature prominently in this study. 
 Kemp frequently provides details of superficial social acquaintance between scientists and artists and refers to their reading habits. 
 This is, in one sense, unobjectionable and Kemp rightly weighs the evidence for influence circumspectly. 
 However, the very preoccupation with identifying causal influences begs more fundamental questions about whether contemporaries shared intellectual assumptions. 
  For example, the Scientific Revolution of the seventeenth century was constituted not only by the new theories of Descartes, Galileo and Newton but also by new ways of experiencing the world, interacting with it and thinking about it. 
 According to this claim, the mores of the eighteenth century were radically different from the sixteenth. 
 Yet this difference is somewhat obscured in Kemp's analysis by his concern to explicate the details of numerous perspective schemes and the techniques employed by artists. 
 He thereby pays less attention than he might to interpreting the science of art as a cultural phenomenon. 
 Ideological and philosophical issues receive inadequate attention and yet these could have helped define the common context (or, perhaps, the contrasting contexts) in which art and science were pursued. 
 Again, Kemp's subject raises important questions about the structure and function of institutions which he only engages parenthetically. 
 More generally, a less causal and more structural approach might have been fruitful in illuminating the historical conditioning of the science of art. 
 Another example of a terminological difficulty arises in the section in which Kemp briefly examines the relation between perspective and eighteenth-century theories of perception. 
 Unfortunately he predicates his discussion on the contrast between &bquo;empiricists&equo; and &bquo;nativists&equo;, a distinction he soon recognises as inadequate. 
 In the light of Kemp's historiography, it is not surprising that he concludes that ideas about perception (which were often explicitly discussed by &bquo;scientists&equo; and &bquo;philosophers') had little impact on artists (p. 237). 
 While he has usefully identified theories of perception as an aspect of the science of art, they deserve a more eclectic and sustained analysis. 
 Let me therefore mention briefly some further dimensions of the subject. 
 Many artists, scientists and philosophers engaged the question of whether linear (or any other) perspective provides the true account of how we perceive. 
 For some authors perspective provides both the laws of perception and also the key to the true and rational representation of objects. 
 Learn perspective and you can imitate nature precisely. 
 However, many artists seriously questioned this wisdom. 
 In their art they combined perspective with drawing &bquo;by eye&equo;; they instinctively knew when to follow the rules and when to break them. 
 This, for Kemp, is an important clue to the success of Vel&aacute;zquez and Turner for whom perspective was a useful servant but a poor master. 
 But artists were not alone in considering and debating the truth and limitations of perspective. 
 A related point on which most (but not all) physical scientists (or, more appropriately, natural philosophers) of the seventeenth century would have agreed, was the primacy of mathematics in analysing the physical universe. 
 Their reasons for adopting this view differed somewhat, but we can take Galileo's position as not atypical. 
 Echoing Plato, Galileo claimed that God had created the world according to mathematical proportions. 
 This implied that only in the sphere of the mathematical sciences can the human intellect attain knowledge that is as objective and as certain as it is known to the divine mind. 
 Through mathematics truth and reality could be laid bare and appearances transcended. 
 This metaphysical commitment came under scrutiny not only from those artists who refused to be limited by the laws of perspective but also from &bquo;scientists&equo; and &bquo;philosophers&equo;. 
 One of the most forceful attacks was by George Berkeley in his An Essay Towards a New Theory of Vision  (1709). 
 Here Berkeley argued strenuously against the view that we judge the distance of objects by means of lines and angles. 
 Although most commentators have claimed that Berkeley's principal opponent was Descartes, whom he cited as an example only in the second (1710) edition, he was more generally denying the widely-received assumption that we see according to the laws of geometry &mdash; this assumption being central to the perspectivist tradition. 
 (Berkeley was familiar with perspective machines, one of which he described in a later work.) 
 Instead, Berkeley sought to show that we learn to judge the distance, magnitude and situation of objects. 
 This controversial book was widely discussed but whether it was read by artists I leave to further research. 
 Berkeley was not alone in questioning whether geometrical methods are adequate to account for visual perception since there was a large literature on the subject by &bquo;scientists&equo; and, as Kemp shows, artists also frequently commented on it. 
 One of the leading problems in this area was the horizontal moon illusion: the moon appears larger near the horizon than in its zenith. 
 Since Ptolemy tried to solve this problem in the second century, it has been on the agenda of theorists of perception and is still, I understand, not fully resolved. 
 In the eighteenth century it was one of the main test cases for the dominance of geometry. 
 Attacks on geometrically-based theories of vision (together with the deployment of such examples as the horizontal moon illusion) provide a theme of common concern to artists, scientists and philosophers and deserve further analysis than Kemp offers. 
 If there are aspects of the science of art that Kemp fails to engage adequately, the scope of this book is nevertheless very impressive and a number of the issues he discusses impinge on my concerns as an historian of science. 
 Let me allude to two of these issues. 
 In the history of science theoria has usually been accorded far greater importance than praxis. 
 The general view has been that theoria is the engine driving the historical development of science and that praxis is merely the application of theoria. 
 Although some historians, often Marxists, have rejected this consensus, only recently have aspects of praxis, such as laboratory skills, been subjected to close and sustained study. 
 In this respect the  historian of science has much to learn from an art historian like Kemp. 
 Moreover, the analysis of skills provides a common topic of research for both art and science historians. 
 The second issue concerns the art-science relationship which Kemp analyses through the history of perspective and of colour. 
 The latter case is the more straightforward since he presents the impact of Newton's theory of coloured light as radically reorientating this area. 
 With perspective, the key figures of the Scientific Revolution are presented as the heirs to developments in art. 
 For example, we encounter Galileo as a bit-player who corresponded with Lodovico Cigoli over his lunar and sunspot observations. 
 More particularly, Galileo used standard perspective procedures in accounting for the foreshortening of the spots which he claimed in 1613 were on the surface of the sun. 
 Unfortunately Kepler receives even less attention. 
 Yet in 1600 Kepler made important contributions to optical science, especially to the theory of image formation. 
 Kepler's concern with the formation of images was a response to a practical problem. 
 He noticed that when viewed with a camera obscura the image of the sun was too large but this enlargement was not explained by existing theory. 
 Instead, he conceived every illuminated point being the source of rays spreading in all directions; a bundle of these rays (rather than a single ray) pass through the hole in a camera obscura (or the pupil of the eye). 
 Thus the image is enlarged owing to the finite size of the hole. 
 In his resolution of the problem Kepler represented his rays by strings. 
 For example, in ascertaining the image of a book on a distant plane, he adopted a procedure familiar to artists for almost a century. 
 He used a stretched string to plot ray paths that just grazed the book in their transit from the source of the screen. 
 This method of repeatedly deploying a stretched string to plot the light rays and thus ascertain selected points on an image was incorporated into the perspective machines described by Leonardo and D&uuml;rer. 
 While the example of Kepler illustrates the influence of artistic practice on a &bquo;scientist&equo; (which is not Kemp's primary concern), discussion of this instance would have enhanced considerably the author's argument that both the theory and practice of perspective were significant resources for the Scientific Revolution of the seventeenth century. 
 He also argues that, in its turn, the Scientific Revolution had some effect on the visual arts. 
 Military engineers, who were also often mathematicians, such as Simon Stevin and Girard Desargues, contributed significantly to the subject of perspective. 
 Newton is portrayed as influencing eighteenth-century perspective in an unspecified manner, although his effect on colour theory is seen as considerable. 
 However, on Kemp's account few artists took notice of the philosophical, mathematical and scientific innovations of Descartes and Kepler. 
 By the eighteenth century there was a considerable parting of the ways since the more erudite mathematical treatises on perspective, such as those by Lambert and Monge, were of no use to the practising artist. 
 Even optical instruments, such as perspective machines, the camera obscura and the camera lucida, were used sparingly. 
 It appears that once science gained its independent identity, scientists and artists used perspective for increasingly different purposes. 
 As with de Santillana's innovatory essay Kemp's book not only offers new ways of understanding the history of science and the history of art but it also raises a host of historical and historiographical questions. 
 These questions in turn suggest further lines of research that deserve serious attention by historians of both science and art. 
 Kemp has performed a valuable service in opening up this area. 
 I hope other historians will now follow his lead.  
 ON THE PASSAGE OF A FEW PEOPLE: SITUATIONIST NOSTALGIA 
 PETER SMITH 
 An endless adventure&hellip; an endless passion&hellip; an endless banquet. 
 A Situationist Scrapbook, edited by Iwona Blazwick in consultation with Mark Francis, Peter Wollen and Malcolm Imrie, Verso/ ICA Publications, London, 1989. 96 pp. 
 ISBN 0 &mdash; 8691 &mdash; 983 &mdash; 8. &pound;10.95. (sandpaperback) 
 On the Passage of a Few People Through a Brief Moment in Time. 
 The Situationist International 1957 &mdash; 1972, edited by Elisabeth Sussman, The MIT Press/ICA, Boston, Massachusetts, 1989, 200 pp. 
 ISBN 0860919838. &pound;19.95. 
 I 
 These books are both related to the exhibition On The Passage of a Few People Through a Brief Period of Time  presented at the Mus&eacute;e national d'art moderne-Centre Georges Pompidou, the Institute of Contemporary Arts in London, and the Institute of Contemporary Art in Boston, Massachusetts during 1989 &mdash; 90. 
 The exhibition was conceived and realised by Mark Francis and Peter Wollen with Paul Herv&eacute; Parsy. 
 Francis and Wollen have also contributed articles (one each) both of which appear in both books as introductory statements on the Situationist International. 
 Both books are anthologies of materials by a large number of contributors. 
 Their titles invoke the Situationists' rhetorical use of long and rhapsodic titles. 
 They also denote deliberate obfuscations deriving from Dada and Surrealism. 
 On the Passage of a Few People Through a Brief Moment in Time  (henceforth &bquo;the Boston text') is a film title used by Guy Debord in 1959. 
 The Situationist Scrapbook  includes only two synoptical essays, the rest being made up of a selection of documents produced in various parts of Europe and Britain from the fifties to the eighties, some of which predate the founding of the Situationist International (henceforth the &bquo;SI'). 
 These are followed by documents relating to the SI in Britain which include Ralph Rumney's Psychogeographic Map of Venice  (1957), and brief statements by Mich&egrave;le Bernstein which appear in the British press in the 1950s and 1960s. 
 The greater part of the Scrapbook largely consists of what the editor identifies as &bquo;the British inheritance&equo; which covers the period from 1966 &mdash; 1988. 
 The book is therefore very much an account of the movement's influence in Britain. 
 The Boston text relates more exclusively to the movement itself and includes, along with historical material, a brief statement by Mark Francis which is intended to justify and explain the motives behind the exhibition (the Situationists did not give the event their blessings and none of the past members participated in its planning). 
 &bquo;What we have sought to do&equo;, claims Francis speaking for the organisers of the exhibition, &bquo;is not to reconstruct time past but to expose to the light things that have run the risk of acquiring the patina of nostalgia and the glamour of neglect.&equo; 
 If this statement betrays a certain uneasiness it is perhaps not surprising given the subversive status of the Situationist project and their condemnation of the art world. 
 Francis also implies, somewhat unconvincingly, that the event was conceived in a spirit of Potlatch and accepts the Lettrist belief in the legitimate use of plagiarism. 
 The Lettrists and the Situationists had used &bquo;pre-existing elements&equo; for their own ends, and so the editors of the Boston text and the curators of On the Passage  have, they feel, a certain entitlement to do the same. 
 This legitimation in turn is related to the principle of d&eacute;tournement , a term which had been coined initially by the Lettrists for their neo-Dadaist practice of cannibalising pre-existent materials (in the manner of Duchamp's LHOOQ ) with subversive intent. 
 My view of the exhibition and these complementary texts is that they seem for the most part to lack the critical motivation and the dialectical irony of the Situationists. 
 They are normative representations, reverential in tone, recuperative in effect and the ideological positions which they reflect are conveniently distanced from those of the SI. 
 Self-evidently these texts are strikingly different from original materials issued by the SI in the sense that they have the status of copyrighted property and have been funded by organisations which in the past may have supported progressive art but which do not sound like the champions of revolutionary causes. 
 The Boston text, for example, is published with the assistance of the Getty Grant Program, Massachusetts Council of the Arts and the Humanities, and additional funding is provided by the Lila Wallace Reader's Digest Fund (the benefactor of the American Wing at the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York). 
 The Scrapbook is also variously supported by Association Fran&ccedil;aise d'Action Artistique, the Ministry of Culture, Copenhagen, the Instituo Banco San Paulo of Turin, Becks Bier, to name some of the backers, and also by the furtively named Friends of the Situationist International, whoever they are! 
 More prosaically, the sandpaper cover (which, like the Jorn/Debord text M&eacute;moires  of  1959, is meant to damage your other books) was donated by English Abrasives and Chemicals Ltd. 
 One of the first &bquo;political&equo; statements in the Boston text is the copyright restriction notice. 
 It appears a few lines away from the plagiarised title of the book. 
 The proscription is, of course, a legal convention which we would normally take for granted, but is, in this context, inconsistent with the SI anti-copyright policy and, in the light of the Lautr&eacute;amont axiom: &bquo;Plagiarism is necessary &mdash; progress implies it,&equo; which Francis cites on page 19, is an unintended irony. 
 The Boston text is more obviously an exhibition catalogue, if only because it includes a &bquo;checklist&equo; of the exhibition, which, ignoring the problematic identity of some of the works, distinguishes between works of art and other items (books, tracts, pamphlets, etc.) and also carefully identifies the status of individual exhibits by signifying their producer's relationship to the formally identified Situationist group. 
 There is another category for Situationist wannabees, which was an additional and problematical area of both books and the exhibition. 
 Some of the materials in this area seemed to have the purpose of padding out the exhibition, whilst at the same time fulfilling the traditional function of consolidating the achievements of the founding group whose significance it was the purpose of the exhibition to celebrate. 
 Francis identifies the stages of the SI narrative as a chronological trajectory corresponding to (i) the Experimental Laboratory period; (ii) the detonator period (which refers to Debord's boast that he provided the explosive machinery that ignited in May 1968); (iii) the Fallout period after the SI disbanded in 1972. 
 These stages provide the logic for the &bquo;diachronic structure&equo; of the exhibition. 
 In the Fallout section are included artists, writers and others &bquo;who all had (sic) some contact with the SI&equo;. 
 Periodisation and classification present some difficulties which Wollen hints at when he comments on &bquo;the &bquo;simulationist&equo; art boom of the eighties and its debt to the dry husks of Situationist thought&equo;. 
 It is to be regretted that neither of these books examine the pluralism of the &bquo;simulationist&equo; period. 
 To the extent that the Situationists raised questions about cultural hierarchies and the &bquo;supersession&equo; of art, how should we judge the Fallout period? 
 The notion of progression is clearly important in assessing this work, especially as the temptation to isolate, or even dismiss, it as an epiphenomenon of the SI is strong. 
 The materials displayed in the exhibition and reproduced in the Fallout section of the Scrapbook no doubt express ideas about which strong convictions are held. 
 What are these convictions, and why are they not articulated? 
 Why were the exhibits left to speak for themselves? 
 It seems extraordinary that, given the political fervour of the Paris-based SI fraction in its post-Lettrist phase, the exhibition should have been so solemnly organised with little regard to Debord's caveat on auteurism and his contempt for the art market. 
 Whatever objectives the organisers might have had, the exhibition turned out to be a quite normative curatorial project. 
 The contradiction is perhaps a familiar one. 
 As Debord has commented: &bquo;This society signs a peace treaty with its most outspoken enemies by giving them a spot in the spectacle.' 
 It is noteworthy that the Situationists have produced nothing in the way of new projects for these texts, nor for the exhibition. 
 Predictably they kept their distance. 
 At the centre of the re-grouped SI in 1961 Bernstein and Debord refused any separation between artistic and political activity. 
 It was at this time that Asgerjorn resigned his membership of the SI, although he continued to finance it through the sale of his paintings which were increasingly in demand in the 1960s. 
 Thus re-grouped, the SI increased their political activity, eliminating all artistic production except in terms of agitational forms which meant, essentially, the use of d&eacute;tourn&eacute;  illustrations in their publications. 
 The article by Wollen is an important piece of research and a major contribution to both anthologies. 
 Despite its usefulness as an introduction to the subject, it does, however, judiciously avoid overt criticism of its subject and devotes little analysis to the SI in its mature phase. 
 Nevertheless, Wollen presents a lucid account of the movement in its formative period and makes an interesting case for Andr&eacute; Breton as a figure of some distinction in French intellectual history. 
 He also traces the Hegelian, and Luk&aacute;csian influences on leftist theories in France in the heightened intellectual atmosphere after the Liberation which provided the aesthetic and political context for the Situationists. 
 Apart from Wollen's historical and theoretical essay, the other major contribution in the Boston text is Thomas Y. Levin's &bquo;Dismantling the Spectacle: The Cinema of Guy Debord&equo;. 
 This is again a comprehensive and thoroughly investigated article and is probably the first extended account of Situationist cinema in English. 
 Levin makes a special case for Debord as a film-maker whose aim was to contribute to the ultimate destruction of cinema as a spectacularist medium. 
 Debord's cinema for Levin is a paradigmatic vehicle for the movement's &bquo;destructive creativity&equo;. 
 The main purpose of Levin's article, however, is to reclaim Debord for the aesthetic discourse of avant-garde cinema. 
 For example, he identifies Debord as the source of Godard's innovations: &bquo;Indeed, well over a decade before Godard's Vent d'Est , Debord was producing a revolutionary, materialist &bquo;counter-cinema&equo;.&equo; 
 Not having seen Debord's films (he refused screenings at the ICA in London), Levin's arguments are in one sense untestable; nevertheless the article is not without difficulties. 
 Defensively, he observes what he considers to be Debord's virtues and comments on the latter's avoidance of, as he puts it: &bquo;the various pitfalls &mdash; formalist essentialism, aestheticist myopia,  politically naive fetishism of reflexivity, and so on, typical of certain avant-garde practices linked to radical political agendas.&equo; 
 Nevertheless, Debord's place within a reified history of &bquo;political modernism&equo; is assured, more by virtue of what is claimed for the work than by its testing in public &mdash; Levin admits that screenings have been rare, especially outside France. 
 Both the personality and the work remain famously obscure in a way which seems almost contrived. 
 Further to this, Levin claims that Debord &bquo;does not disparage pleasure&equo; and yet argues elsewhere in the essay that his films deliberately refuse to make concessions to the viewer. 
 An example of this is the early Lettrist film Hurlement en faveur de Sade , with its long periods of blank screen and extended silences. 
 As far as one can assess the merit of Levin's text in relation to its subject, it seems somewhat implausible that Debord can be all the things for which he is proclaimed. 
 Whatever defence is mounted, it is clear that these films, for Levin, exist as auratic objects, and Debord their auraticised progenitor. 
 Hence the mythologisation of Debord by Levin, and others, has a significant bearing upon the reception of his work. 
 His remoteness and the scandal and intrigue associated with the SI have significantly contributed to the enhancement of the movement's reputation. 
 Levin's essay, interesting though it is, achieves little more than assimilating Debord into the spectacularised history of the avant-garde cinema. 
 His hero-worship results in him reiterating the same claims that the cin&eacute;aste makes for himself. 
 In the opening sequence of Hurlement , as Levin notes, Debord provides the audience with a reference to a cinematic tradition in which his own work is putatively situated. 
 The tradition includes &bquo;great landmarks&equo; in film history from early &bquo;genre classics, (Levin's term), Expressionist, Dada, Soviet cinema of the 1920s, Surrealist, Chaplin, Lettrist and last, but not least, Debord. 
 Situationist cinema is therefore important, indeed, self-important, not least because it provides &bquo;an alternative sort of cinematic activity, incompatible with the economy of the spectacle&equo;. 
 Levin earnestly considers Situationist film to be an effective oppositional practice. 
 One of the attractions for Levin is the persistency with which Debord, like the Dadaists before him, continued to explore the medium, whilst contributing to its eventual destruction. 
 Moreover, Levin claims that the Situationists never lost sight of their own contradictions, &bquo;by consenting to act in  culture&equo; as a precondition of their co-existence in the present order. 
 Nevertheless, cinema ultimately retains a relative autonomy in Levin's tribute. 
 It is like Hegel's notion of the beautiful soul which denounces the world from which it has withdrawn to avoid having to recognise the extent of its participation in its disorder. 
 Debord, as a film-maker, and Levin, as his apologist, take refuge in the transcendental space of autonomy where meanings have the illusion of self-regulation and independence of the totality they represent. 
 Debord takes up his place (certainly in Levin's account) within the lineage of modern masters with its attendant construction of patriarchy, distinction and causal succession. 
 In Levin's essay, avant-garde cinema is assimilated into the wider discourse of Modernist art despite their material and institutional differences. 
 One of the pitfalls of this is that different audiences and different modes of consumption are contingencies largely ignored. 
 Debord's apparent contempt for audiences has its counterpart in Levin's emphasis upon origination and prestige as paradigms of his cultural history. 
 The blurring of art and film histories leads Levin into the murky waters of Situationist discourse on art. 
 Suffice it to say that this discourse is generalising and intemperate, and lacks depth and clarity. 
 Debord, for example, proclaims: &bquo;The critical position later elaborated by the Situationists has shown that the suppression and realization of art are inseparable aspects of a single supersession of art.' 
 There is some sense in this comment which may well explain the position of the Situationists at a particular conjunction, but it is a sense which would also explain earlier avant-garde trends in art (if not cinema) since, say, Futurism. 
 Moreover, the notion of art's &bquo;single supersession&equo;, an histrionic claim, would benefit from some kind of historical and theoretical contextualisation. 
 It sounds important but in fact is an impenetrable statement. 
 Further clarification might also be required as to how the Situationist negation of art (and cinema) related to the wider sphere of cultural-political struggle. 
 The critique of art as an institution is continuous with earlier formations (including early Surrealism and Russian Constructivism), but Levin remains unclear in his definition of Debord's avant-gardism. 
 For Luk&aacute;cs and Adorno the concept of the avant-garde was a touchstone: for the one it was negative and decadent, for the other positive and progressive. 
 In Levin's account of Debord, his subject appears to hold both positions at once. 
 More specifically, on the issue of cultural hierarchies and class relations the Situationists tried to distance themselves from bourgeois notions of progress and their equivalence in the neo-avant-garde of the post-war period. 
 The SI thus rejected &bquo;mechanical becoming, with its notions of progress, merit and causal succession&equo;. 
 This statement reflects the resistance of the SI to piecemeal historicism out of which lineages are made, but in Levin's history the independent achievements of Debord as a film-maker eventually collapses into it. 
 In fairness it has to be said that Levin tries to isolate Debord from a purely formal Modernism, and from naive realism (the politics of the signified). 
 He does this by proclaiming, a &bquo;third avant-garde&equo;, which avoids the major pitfalls (of the &bquo;two avant-gardes') and secures some theoretical authority for Debord. 
 However, because this is not adequately related to the political ideals of the SI there is no analysis of the projected  means (theoretical or practical) by which the sublation of art in the praxis of life might be achieved. 
 The reverential tone of Levin's text poses a problem which the movement's survivors, I imagine, would be quick to condemn. 
 It is, in short, uncritical in the sense of failing to site Debord's films within an adequate theoretical discourse. 
 Levin objectifies his subject through the use of an argument which leaves the SI unexplained as a revolutionary organisation with the potentiality of reflecting, by its own methods, a radical social transformation. 
 What he provides is the missing chapter in the secret history of the cinema, the missing link between Berlin Dada and postmodernism. 
 As with other contributors, exaggerated claims are made for d&eacute;tournement  (the communication which contains its own critique), firstly because it was an inheritance from Cubism and Dada, and secondly, because, as the exhibition shows, its deployment by &bquo;pro-situs&equo; has made of it a commonplace, popularised in punk fanzines, and &bquo;Biff&equo; postcards etc. 
 The Situationists' activities within the cultural sphere constituted an attempt to create a unified range of activities which functioned as a radical critique of the conventional boundaries between specialisations embedded in the institutions, practices and agencies of modern life. 
 The fragmented appearance of their work, especially its Lettrist phase, their repudiation of conventional skills and scholarly manners (evidenced in their use of personal insults) have been absorbed by subcultural milieux and in due course adapted by the culture industries. 
 The influence of the Situationists is clearly demonstrated (if overstated) in these books. 
 If the historical trajectory of the Scrapbook is followed (SI through Fluxus, Heatwave, King Mob, Jamie Reid, Vivienne Westwood, and the Sex Pistols) the Situationist role for the intellectual as an informed but passionate critic gives way to philistine incitements to violence (typified by King Mob in Britain, the Motherfuckers in the USA, and also indirectly the punk phenomenon) but more commonly a laidback and philosophically weak critique of everyday life. 
 The political and philosophical origins of Situationist thought to a large degree derives from Marx's critique of alienation and commodity fetishism, Luk&aacute;cs's development of this critique, and the Marxist-existentialism of Sartre and Henri Lefebvre. 
 The rejection of liberal democracy and bureaucratic Marxism led the Situationists away from dominant political organisations and towards libertarian and syndicalist influences. 
 The ideas of Anton Pannekoek which emerged with the publication of his Workers' Council  after World War One provided a ready-made model of a non-hierarchical political system. 
 The simple faith conveyed in Pannekoek's treatise recalls earlier utopian writing, and contrasts with the strident and acerbic tone of Situationist writing. 
 With the exception of Wollen, the contributors to the Scrapbook and the Boston text convey little concern for the forms of political organisation espoused by the Situationists, and it is perhaps symptomatic of their interest in the SI as a purely aesthetic phenomenon. 
 The SI clearly endeavoured to produce a revolutionary critique of modern life, and towards this end devised a convulsive rhetoric and an inventive vocabulary. 
 The revival of interest in its ideas might be explained by this, rather than by its standing as a political organisation. 
 The remoteness of the movement from working-class experience guaranteed the survival of its bohemian image. 
 Its re-emergence as spectacle relates more visibly to its cult status and the nostalgic allure of fifties Paris; a marginalised and dissolute existence in the company of exotic friends and of romantic places with beautiful names. 
 The Boston text reproduces old photographs of founding members. 
 The gamine looks of Bernstein and the neatness of Debord have an aesthetic relevance which signifies a rather vague, but nevertheless compelling, reason for their inclusion in the text. 
 They are not merely documentation. 
 They are in fact significant elements in the story of &bquo;Situationism&equo; which is the subtext of the book. 
 The political reticence evident in these volumes is indicated by a degree of randomness in the choice of materials and by implication a commitment to the more &bquo;expressive&equo; or irrationalist side of their work. 
 It is, for example, revealing that there is no indication in either book of the Situationist commitment to political struggles in the Third World and their critique of imperialism. 
 The introductions in both books are anodyne and brief. 
 The historical significance of the SI is not questioned, and the importance of the movement is asserted largely on the basis of aesthetic innovations which derive from the Lettrist period prior to the founding of the SI. 
 D&eacute;tournement  and d&eacute;rive  (drifting) are thus reclaimed in terms of their contemporary relevance, or rather for the extent to which they influenced punk and the camp and erudite artistic radicalism which exploited it. 
 With the exception of Levin's extended analysis of film, neither the products nor any specific agitations of the Situationists and their epigones are subject to critical reassessment. 
 The short commentaries and comic imagery in the British section of the Scrapbook are largely printed ephemera with unserious political pretensions. 
 Some of it is amusing, some of it pretentious drivel. 
 Clearly much of the material is unsupportable and there is a sense in which this is self-evident in that the Scrapbook is styled as an &bquo;anti-document&equo; which, like the films of Debord, is co-extensive with the equally unsupportable and qualitatively diminished world to which it relates. 
 The temptation is to view these publications and the exhibition as a proliferation of surfaces which are in a sense pretty vacant reminders that despite the essentially teleological nature of the Situationist project, it is now immobilised and its documents merely a contribution to culture as the spectacular remains of an abandoned revolutionary ideal. 
 The  tendency is to ignore value distinctions and to undermine qualitative difference so that popular and high art genres are presented side by side in a unified space or text. 
 There is of course an inside knowledge which makes this &bquo;coherent&equo; for those in possession of it. 
 This presupposes the same audience separations, the same hierarchies, the same educational and class difference as before. 
 Frank Mort has commented on this kind of separation between the new intellectuals who are happy and confident to mix genre and ignore qualitative and semantic difference &bquo;because they already know the map of Western culture&equo; and are distinct from those &bquo;who do not carry with them those levels of cultural capital.&equo; 
 He adds to this: &bquo;In that sense postmodern discourse with its relativism, its denial of grand narratives and its refusal of questions of value, is a world tailor-made for the new metropolitan intellectual cadres.' 
 It therefore seems that &bquo;in a purely negative way&equo; the silence over the question of meaning in the Boston text and in the Scrapbook is perhaps not surprising &mdash; &mdash; it is an historically appropriate response to the disappearance of the SI. 
 &bquo;There is a sorrow in the Zeitgeist&equo; bemoans Lyotard, an inappropriateness in the metaphor of the &bquo;avant-garde&equo;, and consequently a kind of absurdity attaching to the belief in art as a prefiguration of a global collectivist future. 
 That sorrow hangs over the discontinued struggles of the SI. 
 The belligerence of their message and the violence of their appeal to negation and revolt is now passed over in silence and their works appear as if they were blank sheets to the privileged audiences of the present day. 
 II 
 What I have argued so far is that the Situationists are ill-served by these publications, and that this is partly due to the influence of a certain pessimism which haunts contemporary cultural politics. 
 What I want to argue now is that there is a sense in which the symptom of this pessimism exist in the movement itself. 
 The Situationists were idealists in the sense that they perceived themselves apart from the spectacle, always managing to be &bquo;other-than-spectacular&equo;, as Levin puts it, so that this became a pre-condition of Situationist practice. 
 Their self-image was that of the chosen few for whom the spectacle provided an inexhaustible supply of objects (and people) to hate, and whilst the apparent ease with which they targeted and disposed of their opposition often made good copy (the endless adventure, the scandal, etc.), there is a sense in which the hectoring tone of their documents became repetitive and wearisome. 
 The effusions of Vaneigem have an air of mystical revelation which is even more intense in recent publications. 
 Debord's political fatigue is less evident but his filmwork has finished and he refuses to permit distribution and screening of his work in this medium. 
 Bernstein is now a journalist and works for a French newspaper. 
 There are, I think, just three statements which count as unequivocally critical comments on SI in the Scrapbook. 
 They appear in the documents section and therefore do not, we may take it, represent the views of the editors. 
 Firstly, Art &amp; Language's piece &bquo;Ralph the Situationist&equo; expresses considerable misgivings about the Situationist project: &bquo;The texts are effectively incorrigible and self insulating&hellip;&equo;; &bquo;&hellip; bland incoherence &mdash; a self-contradictory absurdity &mdash; a moral ground to give up reading and remembering&hellip;&equo;, and so on. 
 Whatever gave Francis, or whoever it was, the idea that Art &dollar; Language had anything to do with the Situationists? 
 On what basis is this reference made? 
 There is no evidence of SI influence in their work, which has quite different intellectual roots, and the article itself leaves no doubt as to the extent of their disapprobation. 
 Furthermore, the inclusion of three early works by the group in the exhibition (dating from the late sixties) reveals a kind of make believe idea about an A &dollar; L/SI connection. 
 There was no such connection. 
 As late as 1970 members of A &dollar; L, to my knowledge, had never heard of Debord, and if they had were not the least bit interested. 
 The arbitrary inclusion of artworks in the exhibition is further evidence of a curatorial effort to construct a narrative of &bquo;situationism&equo;. 
 The case for Merz, Pistoletto and Buren may be different, but it is not unreasonable to expect a rationale for the proclaimed indebtedness of Arte Povera and Conceptual Art to the Situationists. 
 Nowhere in these publications are these connections argued for: they are merely dogmatically asserted. 
 Given the withering contempt expressed by the Situationists for &bquo;prositus&equo;, one shudders to think what Debord et al . 
 are going to make of the &bquo;quasi-situationists&equo; discovered in America by Elisabeth Sussmann. 
 On the basis of her understanding, it appears that any artist in the USA who uses the conventions of the mass media in such a way as to produce a critique of the media (and I can think of a good many) is veritably a &bquo;quasi-situationist&equo;. 
 The desire to create a pseudo-history of the movement's afterlife may be good for business, and may have provided extra material for the book (I refer to the Boston text, see pp. 10&ndash;13) but it is not in keeping with the purer aims of the Situationists outlined elsewhere in these and other texts. 
 The second critical comment I came across in the Scrapbook was George Steiner's statement from the Sunday Times  in 1967. 
 Steiner accepted that the Situationists had identified and accurately described the emptiness of everyday life and even accepts their pleas for subversion, but was very sour about what he described as the &bquo;depressingly banal&equo; prescriptions of Debord and the &bquo;turgid creed&equo; of Vaneigem. 
 Christopher Gray, one of the small number of English members of the SI, is the third commentator I found to be not entirely sympathetic. 
 His comments come from an anthology of Situationist writings he edited in 1974. 
 Gray's comments evoke a kind of mystical disenchantment with the movement  which he found to be too focused on an intellectual critique of society. 
 &bquo;There was&equo;, he complains, &bquo;no concern whatever with either emotions or the body. 
 The SI thought you just had to show how the nightmare worked and everyone would wake up. 
 Their quest was for the perfect formula.' 
 The history of the SI is in some ways a struggle for recognition (despite Debord's evasions) sustained by a radically negative critique which ultimately failed to find a middle way between Hegelian metaphysics and the dynamics of political organisation in the pursuit of its utopian objectives. 
 The declamatory style of writing (which now seems dated) too often obscured the probity of the Situationist's critique of the alienating and manipulative effects of late capitalism and its creation of pseudo-needs. 
 The movement's critique proclaimed a uniqueness and originality for its discoveries to which it was never entitled and which served only to reinforce the self-deluding image of its own power and influence in the world. 
 Anti-authoritarian leftism and the critique of bureaucratic socialism had of course been well established before the foundation of the SI in 1957. 
 The rejection of trade unionism was a common demand amongst anarchists and libertarian socialists. 
 At the end of her life Rosa Luxembourg called for the abolishment of trade unions and promoted the view that workers' councils were essential organisations in the establishment of socialism. 
 More generally the idea of the inseparability of cultural and political revolution has a long history within the libertarian tradition with its roots in revolutionary Romanticism. 
 The more direct inspiration for the Situationists was the Dada-Lettrist connection which provided the aesthetic and political basis for their adoption of non-cognitive methods of expression (such as automatism, chance and other depersonalising techniques of production) and also led to the definition of some key terms in their vocabulary. 
 The critique of scientific socialism and economism has a major place in Marxist debate in the twentieth century. 
 The Situationists, contribution to this was negligible. 
 The Frankfurt School's Marxian approach to cultural criticism, and production and the social effects of technology and the culture industries pre-dates the writings of Debord, and yet, despite its relative lack of revolutionary fervour remains a far more wide-ranging and thoroughgoing critique of the field. 
 The conjunction of passion and knowledge, of libertarianism and planning, of feeling and thought are conventional oppositions in post-Enlightenment thought which have also bedevilled Marxism. 
 The more orthodox theorists in this tradition have preserved this separation along the lines of a Romanticist/Utilitarian split. 
 Others have sought a reconciliation of the positions that these terms represent, and there is an abundance of literature which examines this relationship in advance of the Situationists. 
 If the Situationist project is flawed, as I believe it is, it is not because antecedent theories of libertarians, Marxists and Council Communists are ignored by them, but rather because they lacked the will to build on this tradition a systematic utopianism consisting of critique and plausible projections into the future. 
 Like the Surrealists before them, their transcendence of alienation remains abstractly utopian. 
 Despite revolutionary zeal, or perhaps because of it, they sought immediate compensations for the miseries of daily life, and spontaneous methods of attack which they mistook for political strategy. 
 The Situationists' strategy consisted of an exploratory utopianism &mdash; a kind of heuristic projection of a future society. 
 Raymond Williams has remarked that the danger of the heuristic utopia is that it &bquo;can settle into isolated and sentimental desire, a means of living with alienation&equo;. 
 Another Surrealist inheritance which distances Situationists from the more radical utopians is their blanket condemnation of work. 
 &bquo;Never work!&equo; announced the Surrealists. 
 It is an amusing quip (especially for those with private means) and makes joyful and nonsensical graffiti. 
 But what does it mean? 
 Obviously it is an incitement to refusal, and an indictment of alienated labour. 
 The refusal is as understandable as it is naive, but seems to constitute at the same time what amounts to an abnegation of intellectual curiosity about human needs. 
 Its political inflexion contests the middle-class work ethic which is the main purpose of its message. 
 The aristocracy, for its part, has never needed to be convinced of the importance of not working. 
 For other theorists such as William Morris, the concept of work is not considered negatively. 
 Indeed; for Morris and other Marxists the nature of work necessarily changes in the process of social transformation. 
 Marx defined labour as &bquo;human sensuous activity&equo;. 
 Luk&aacute;cs claimed that labour became the model for any social practice. 
 The plea for an understanding of &bquo;totality&equo; in Situationist writing derives from Luk&aacute;cs and Marx whose critique of &bquo;separation&equo; is directed exactly at the work/leisure distinction. 
 Asger Jorn's interest in folk cultures and tribal societies which lacked a notion of &bquo;art&equo; as a distinct intellectual practice separated from the common culture, was based on an understanding of the extent to which the spheres of art and work have become conflicting practices within bourgeois relations of production. 
 Despite this the common tendency in SI writing on most forms of directed or purposeful activity (other than agitation or &bquo;destructive creativity') is negative. 
 The aristocratic disdain for manual labour has its counterpart in the Situationist&equo; attitude to the working class considered as the moronised victims of the spectacle. 
 In contrast the Situationists' notion of pleasure is a negation of work in almost every sense of the word &mdash; a kind of involuntary idleness in the land of Cockaigne. 
 Their notion of pleasure is indistinguishable from a sixties Zeitgeist. 
 Its meaning is inadequately theorised and remains largely at the  level of common sense, a crude alternative to the repressive order of work. 
 Now that Situationist texts are widely available (and with these publications adding to the list) it is ironic that they seem less crucial than they once did. 
 Their appeal in the past was partly attributable to the popular texture of some aspects of the writing, its accessibility and its festive and irreverent politics. 
 These writings appealed essentially to a generation of students bored with academic life and attracted by the street credibility of the Situationists, and often provided students with the dubious pleasure of being flattered and insulted at the same time. 
 The Situationist lifestyle (in so far as it could be imagined) had some influence on the hippy sub-culture in the late sixties and punk ideology in the seventies in Britain. 
 Situationist influence was more menacingly felt in France especially in the universities, although it has to be said that their influence upon the events of May 1968 has been exaggerated. 
 For the most part, however, the legacy of the movement remained less obviously political, and restricted in its appeal to fairly specific audiences in the cultural milieu and especially the visual arts. 
 Indeed, the extent to which the Situationist influence has flourished in the spheres of art and popular culture is noteworthy and contrasts with the absence of the movement's influence in other domains. 
 The uneven profile of the Situationist group and its existential fragmentation together with the eclectic and impromptu formal character of the artefacts they produced, as I have suggested above, make it an ideal type for the postmodernist critic. 
 The Situationists' rejection of the classical model of left-wing monumentalism, and their apparent lack of commitment to the historical overview or the grand narrative is consistent with postmodernism. 
 Moreover, the freedom with which they juxtapose theory and humour, and plagiarise for artistic effect suggests strong affinity with the postmodern. 
 The decline of the meta-narrative in favour of aphoristic models of philosophical expression (following Feuerbach and Nietzche) has been the favoured form of the Situationists. 
 The fact that Baudrillard's name has been linked with the Situationists should not be held against them. 
 Nevertheless, the de-Marxisation of their project by him and the &bquo;death of the social&equo; which he has announced should alert us to the doubts raised by Raymond Williams on the issue of certain types of Utopianism. 
 The concept of the spectacle is an effective term which now has a wide currency, but perhaps only in a sense which approximates its use by the Situationists. 
 The historical period which has seen its political devaluation is one in which political optimism has become unfashionable, which perhaps is one way of explaining the retrospective or merely historicist character of the Situationist exhibition, and the books I have reviewed. 
 We have seen a shift from the utopianism of the 1960s to a culture of nostalgia and, as with the more dystopian elements in postmodernism, the exhibition and the books which accompany it look backward in a search for appearances as if they were compensatory fantasies substituting for a forgotten dream.   
 Introduction  
 &bquo;Women hold up half the sky&equo; 
 &bquo;People come to a new country, they start a new life; but the past they can't forget it. 
 They bring it with them memories, attitudes and relationships.&equo; 
 That is what Shahida, a woman from Lahore, told me. 
 To give a full picture of this past is a daunting task, not within the scope of this book. 
 But the attitudes and relationships which haunt the present &mdash; what are they and how did they dominate in the past? 
 And which past? 
 The women in this book fall essentially into two groups &mdash; those who come directly from certain peasant societies of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh and those whose families migrated from the same peasant backgrounds first to East Africa and then to Britain. 
 Women of the first group are in many ways utterly dissimilar from each other, differing in language, religion and customs (see tables 1 and 2), but their roles in the peasant societies they have come from have a lot in common. 
 It is these roles and how they were established that 1 shall describe in this chapter. 
 The Pakistani village of Mohinuddinpur was described to me by Shamim, a woman who now lives in Bradford. 
 Our whole village is made up of our Biradiri  (brethren). 
 All the people there are our brothers and sisters and relations so there are very few strangers around and women don't have to wear Burkhas . 
 Anyway, Burkha  or no Burkha , one has to work, cutting the fodder, cleaning out the cowsheds, working in the fields at harvest time and then cooking and cleaning &mdash; and so many other tasks. 
 Shamim's village is like many others from which Pakistani immigrants have come to Britain. 
 They represent a peasant society, not, as the clich&eacute; has it, impenetrable or unchanging, but one extremely sensitive to internal change and outside influences, one where economic survival determines life styles and attitudes. 
 beneath the details of everyday life which Shamin describes is a feudal economy where small farmers scratch out a living from day to day, where one false step can mean falling into debt or mortgaging one's land without hope of recovery and where one rebellious individual can place the entire economic unit, the joint family, at risk. 
 The economy of these villages &mdash; in Mirpur, Jhelum or in East Punjab across the Indo-Pakistan border (see Table 1 &amp;and map) &mdash; has been feudal for centuries. 
 But it is a feudalism where inequalities and poverty have been intensified by British colonialism and which has in the last thirty-seven years since independence been in a state of flux caused by the varying stages of capitalism which reach out to it from the towns and cities of the Indian sub-continent. 
 But colonialism, the tensions caused by a feudal economy's reaction to capitalism and finally the effects of capitalism itself have all been imposed on a social structure which can be traced much further back. 
 It is a structure essentially tribal in Pakistan, caste-based in India, which, though distorted several times over by a changing economy, still retains some of its concepts (including that of the position of women) in their original form. 
 The role of women is determined by this earlier social structure and the economic influences it faces. 
 How did successive economic regimes affect for instance, the lives of people in the villages of India? 
 In the province of Punjab the most important economic change of the nineteenth century came with British colonialism. 
 Before Punjab came under British rule in 1849 the peasants had had a right to farm the land but had not owned it, in the sense of being able to sell it off. 
 The British established individual property rights and, with these rights, a new cash tax called land revenue. 
 The peasants who cultivated the land became its owners and proprietors and a new law of inheritance was established by which when a man died his land was equally divided among his sons. 
 The land revenue tax (at first as much as a third of a peasant's gross yearly produce) had to be paid no matter how bad the harvest or how impoverished the family became as a result. 
 In addition the fact that it had to be paid in cash meant that the farmers had to sell their crop to the grain-dealer and then often enough borrow money from the money lender. 
 In East Punjab these were usually the same man, almost invariably a Brahmin by caste. 
 In this way the British created the situation of the small farmer, destroyed him by taxation, and raised on his back a new exploiting class, the money lenders. 
 Because the money lenders were usually Brahmis, the effect of colonialism was to strengthen the caste system and place it firmly on a class basis. 
 The farms, small to start with and made even smaller as time went on by the system of inheritance, were extremely vulnerable to natural disaster. 
 One small drought would be enough to drive a farming family into debt. 
 Often enough the farmer ended up an owner-tenant with his land mortgaged to the money lender. 
 After that there was little point in investing money or effort into the land because there was no chance of financial recovery. 
 In this life of stress there was only one source of hope &mdash; having sons. 
 A family with many sons could farm its land successfully without the burden of paying farm workers and could if necessary send a son to work in the nearest town or city to earn money to pay back debts or to buy more land. 
 Without sons there was no hope of survival. 
 Why sons and not daughters? 
 Because the social structure in the villages was one based on patriarchal families, where the daughter is invariably given away in marriage, and where, because a woman's chief economic role is as a producer of labour power (her sons) she is not considered of any real economic value before she is married. 
 This system, with its total sexual division of work, is mirrored (not caused) by the religious prescriptions for male and female roles. 
 In both Islam and Hinduism the woman's role is domestic and decreed to be so. 
 (For example Manu the lawgiver recommended to Hindu society more than twelve centuries ago that &bquo;the chief function of a woman is to give birth, nurse those who are born and attend daily duties' or &bquo;A girl must be married before she attains puberty and after she is married she must be kept busy looking after elders, cooking, cleaning, keeping accounts and saving money and of course doing Dharma ). 
 Naturally these rules were and still are interpreted for the economic convenience of society. 
 In general the work in the fields is done by men; women usually harvest only lighter crops, tend the animals and do the fatiguing work of cooking and carrying food to the fields for their men (in other words servicing labour). 
 But more than anything else women produce the labour force &mdash; sons. 
 A man's role is thus within his control. 
 He has to work hard in the fields. 
 He may fail as a result of natural disasters but no one can blame him for that. 
 But a woman's success or otherwise is not within her control. 
 It is a matter of chance. 
 She might not be able to produce the required number of sons or she might produce only daughters or she might even be childless. 
 She is encouraged by religion, mythology and custom to produce sons. 
 A new daughter-in-law is greeted by her mother-in-law with the blessing &bquo;May you have seven sons&equo; or urged formally to &bquo;bathe in milk and you'll have lots of sons&equo;. 
 But what if she fails? 
 Society responds with oppression, which it justifies by again invoking myths, scriptures (quoted or misquoted) and proverbs, some ancient and some only a few years old, thrown up by the needs of everyday life. 
 A woman with many daughters and no sons is considered not only unfortunate but a carrier of misfortune. 
 A woman with no children may well be regarded as a witch who must be ostracised and barred from celebrations. 
 As a result women themselves might well come to believe (incorrectly) that &bquo;it is written in the Guru Nanak's Granth Sahib  (the holy book of the Sikhs) that if you have bad Karma  you have more girls than boys&equo;. 
 The most important and uncontrollable factor in this peasant society occurs then in a woman's body. 
 The result is that religion and superstition centre their attention on the womb in an effort to explain away in terms of &bquo;morality&equo; what remains unexplained and unacceptable in terms of fact. 
 Morality and religion open the door to oppression but in focusing so sharply on the woman's role they make her the central symbol of the culture. 
 She is the link between economic survival and the meaning of life, between economic security and emotional security. 
 Her role is at the heart, the core of the civilisation. 
 That is why she is kept in her place, if necessary by the most brutal oppression. 
 If she rebels, the society itself may be overthrown. 
 This impossible linking role, this almost schizophrenic position which a woman has to defend is reflected over and over again at different times and in many aspects of her life. 
 Her birth is almost invariably a disappointment to her family (because it is not a son who has been born). 
 But soon these feelings change to love and affection. 
 She often becomes very close to her parents, particularly her mother. 
 However, when she gets married and goes to live in her parents-in-law's home, her father and mother hardly ever visit her. 
 If a Muslim, she usually marries a cousin who lives in the same village so at least the surroundings are familiar to her; but among Hindus and Sikhs the husband's family nearly always live in a different village (because a woman must marry outside her kin). 
 The bride's parents are by tradition not permitted to accept the hospitality of her in-laws. 
 In parts of Punjab they must not spend even a single night in their village. 
 A Sikh woman from Jullunder, recently arrived in Britain, described what her feelings had been when her daughter got married six years ago. 
 &bquo;Yes, I wished I could see her. 
 I felt so sad but if I had gone there and seen her, how would I have felt? 
 At home she was a queen, I never liked her to do the heavy jobs. 
 There she is a slave. 
 I know, because my life was the same. 
 But to see her like that would hurt my feelings and hurt our Izzat  (pride).&equo; 
 This Izzat  can also be translated as honour, self-respect and sometimes plain male ego. 
 It is a quality basic to the emotional life of Punjab. 
 It is essentially male but it is women's lives and actions which affect it most. 
 A woman can have Izzat but it is not her own &mdash; it is her husband's or father's. 
 Her Izzat  is a reflection of the male pride of the family as a whole. 
 Farda, a girl from Jhelum, told me: 
 If a man has a daughter she must be properly dressed, married at a reasonable age, taught to behave modestly in the presence of strangers. 
 All these things are related to the Izzat of the girl &mdash; saving her Izzat (and through that their own Izzat) is perhaps the greatest responsibility of her parents or guardian. 
 Because people don't want this responsibility they prefer having sons. 
 The joint or extended family is the peasant economic unit essential for survival. 
 Izzat serves as its identity and gives it continuity and &bquo;worth&equo;. 
 Since the same concept occurs in an even stronger form among groups like the Pathans who still retain their tribal structure, it is possible that this particular form of family identity originated in the strife- and tension-ridden relationships between Muslim tribes. 
 It remains overshadowed by tension and the fear of violence and humiliation. 
 (It is in this sense a quality which is likely to be inflamed in the racism of British society.) 
 When a girl gets married her parents are traditionally considered to be in a humiliating position vis &aacute; vis her parents-in-law. 
 They forfeit the right to stand up against them. 
 It is thus recognised that in her parents-in-law's home a girl is completely vulnerable and any resentment against her parents may be taken out on her. 
 As time passes the new bride is expected to take on the identity of her new family, making her subjugation complete. 
 A woman belongs to the men in her own family, then to the men in her husband's family, but never, never to herself. 
 A Punjabi Hindu wedding song sung by women while the bride and groom walk seven times round the wedding fire expresses this quite clearly: 
 Here she takes the first round, 
 Her grandfather's granddaughter. 
 Here she takes the second round, 
 Her maternal uncle's maternal niece. 
 Here she takes the third round, 
 Her father's elder brother's daughter. 
 Here she takes the fourth round 
 Her father's own daughter. 
 Here she takes the fifth round 
 Her father's younger brother's niece. 
 Here she takes the sixth round, 
 Her brother's sister. 
 Here she takes the seventh round 
 And lo! the darling becomes alien. 
 (From Oscar Lewis: Village Life in Northern India , Random House, New York, 1958) 
 In peasant societies outside Punjab &mdash; in Gujerat or Bangladesh &mdash; Izzat does not exist in quite the same form but the role of the woman remains almost identical. 
 There too her parents who love her so much and suffer so much when she leaves their family feel indebted to her parents-in-law. 
 There too she is never considered a significant contributor to the economic needs of the family (because labour power is not equated with real economic value) and there too, among the farming castes, her most important economic roles are the production and servicing of labour. 
 If the Hindus and Sikhs of Punjab have taken over the concept of Izzat from the Muslims, the Muslims and Sikhs have adopted the dowry system from the Hindus. 
 In India, dowry taking has long been forbidden by law but it persists strongly even in the cities. 
 In the villages the amounts given as a dowry vary from area to area and community to community, but within any community they depend on the status of the bridegroom and his family. 
 The relationship between the size of a dowry and status makes the dowry system easily adaptable to a class society, which means that as the economies of the villages move unevenly towards capitalism the dowry system remains of vital significance both as an essential accompaniment to and a reflection of this change. 
 For parents, the dowry system is yet another reason why having daughters may mean financial ruin. 
 The dowry system has sometimes been considered as an effect of the sexual division of labour where, although women do some of the heaviest work (servicing labour and producing it), these roles are considered less important than those of men. 
 Another obvious effect of this segregation of roles is the existence of sexual hierarchies within the community. 
 &bquo;Men have authority over women because Allah  has made one superior to the other, and because they spend their wealth to maintain them&equo; says the Koran . 
 But in Indian and Pakistani joint families, things are not so simple. 
 There is a rigid hierarchy but it is not just a sexual hierarchy. 
 A woman does, as she gets older, achieve a certain status in the joint family, particularly if she has had sons. 
 Younger men must show their respect for her and obey her. 
 She can treat younger women or women without status (like her husband's widowed sisters) as she likes. 
 When finally she becomes a mother-in-law she is entitled to tyrannise her daughter-in-law, reminding her that &bquo;I have suffered in my time now it is your turn&equo;. 
 To serve and suffer is considered not only a woman's lot but right . 
 If a woman is suffering things are as they should be. 
 But even in the most oppressive family and community women do have one consolation &mdash; each other's company and affection. 
 The warmth which sisters and sisters-in-law may show for one another can cushion a woman against the harshness of her life. 
 The importance of this love and its physical demonstration is acknowledged in ceremonies and rituals all over the Indian sub-continent. 
 In Muslim families, for example, it is the women in the family who are the chief mourners if someone dies. 
 They are the ones, too, who celebrate a birth. 
 In each case women from neighbouring and related families come to mourn or rejoice with them. 
 The support they give may sometimes be formal, but it is never sterile or mechanical (as it often is in industrial societies). 
 For example, when the forty days of mourning a death are over and the women in the family who have foregone food or combing their hair can start a normal life again, it is their female friends and sisters who cook for them and comb and oil their hair. 
 These relationships, and the position of the woman as symbolic of her culture, are mutually reinforcing. 
 But the role of the woman, both cultural and economic, is constantly being shaped and shifted by economic and structural forces &mdash; those of colonialism and capitalism for example. 
 It is possible to understand this by looking in some detail at a specific village. 
 Such studies are rare, but luckily one exists of an area from which emigration to Britain has occurred (Mamdani: The Myth of Population Control , Monthly Review Press, 1972). 
 The village is Manupur in the Ludhiana district of East Punjab. 
 The life of the farming families here has been harsh for hundreds of years but this harshness has been intensified by the laws on land inheritance and land revenue introduced by the British, which have already been described. 
 By the 1920s Manupur, like so many other villages in Punjab, was dominated by the moneylending class who were Brahmins by caste. 
 After World War I, 50 per cent of the land was mortgaged to moneylenders by owner-tenant farmers. 
 These farmers had no money for improving agricultural methods and no motivation either because they realised that &bquo;however beneficial any methods of agricultural technology were in the abstract, the benefits reaped from the improved methods would go to the money lender and not the tiller&equo; (Mamdani, The Myth of Population Control ). 
 After India became independent in 1947 certain legal and financial reforms were instituted in Punjab. 
 But until the early fifties Manupur, like many other villages, was hardly affected by them. 
 The reason was that none of these reforms shifted the balance of power within the social structure of the village. 
 The peasant producer remained subservient to the money lender and the economy remained unchanged. 
 Agricultural technology was available but not relevant to life in Manupur. 
 Finally, in the 1950s and 60s, new systems of rural credit were established in the district of Ludhiana which did appreciably alter the balance of power in Manupur. 
 A system of government loans was made available to all farmers which could be used not only to purchase tube wells, chemical fertilisers and wheat seeds but to repay debts. 
 This system, together with the introduction of a new type of wheat which gave three times the previous yields, began at last to change the methods of farming in Manupur. 
 Agricultural methods become more scientific and the outside world, with its fertilisers and machines, suddenly became either accessible or at least worth thinking about. 
 Farmers with reasonable sized holdings were in a matter of years freed from the stranglehold of money lenders. 
 The Brahmins who, thanks to the British, had been not merely a caste but a class, declined in economic status, and a new bourgeoisie appeared consisting of better-off farming families. 
 While a changed social structure was a pre-requisite to technological change, technological advances, once they began, further affected the caste structure of the village. 
 Previously Manupur had been divided into a number of well-defined hereditary and hierarchically ordered groups or castes whose jobs, social status and economic relationships (i.e. the share they got of their own and each other's profits) were pre-determined by tradition. 
 Now, with technological changes, a number of traditional jobs, particularly those of low caste people, became obsolete. 
 For example, because many farming families were able to afford sewing machines, the women in these families began to make all the clothes their families needed, thus increasing their already heavy work load but at the same time putting the Darzi  or tailor-caste workers out of employment. 
 Finally many people of this caste had to find other non-traditional occupations. 
 Many low caste people who had previously been craft workers turned to farm work, and as farmworkers they had to be paid not in the old feudal terms but an amount definitely related to the work they did. 
 Labour, in other words, had become a commodity and capitalist relationships had been established in Manupur. 
 Among the &bquo;lower caste&equo; people, the woman's role had always been rather different from her role in the farming castes; now &bquo;lower caste&equo; women worked increasingly in the fields alongside the men and this led, according to Mamdani, to &bquo;a radical change&hellip; in the attitude towards girl children&hellip; low caste families do not look upon the birth of a girl with the disfavour they used to&equo; &mdash; though &bquo;to a certain extent the disfavour persists because the girl will marry and emigrate precisely when she has reached the age of greatest productivity&equo;. 
 But these social and technological changes hardly brought a more leisurely or carefree life to the farming families (who were later to be emigrants to Britain, see Table I). 
 Production even on the smallest holdings had trebled and the work load had soared. 
 Sons were needed &mdash; more and more sons. 
 Without them production costs would rise because farmworkers would have to be employed and paid. 
 Without sons, making a living out of the land would once again be impossible. 
 The need to survive, which always dictates the moral standards of society, once more underlined the role of the women. 
 The effect of capitalism on the women of farming families was therefore to trap them even further in their role as producers of labour power and to intensify the feeling which men and women of these families had experienced for so long that &bquo;Life itself is work&equo;. 
 Leisure was something people never planned for or thought about. 
 The land which they had loved and tended for so many generations &mdash; to survive off this land was the aim of their lives, the justification for all struggles. 
 It was because of this that &bquo;rest is possible only when fatigue demands it. 
 There are no weekends, every day is a potential workday&hellip; rains may interrupt the activities of the men&hellip; but not of the women. 
 In fact when a woman's husband is at home he demands much more and her work is increased. 
 The major interruption to her work is pregnancy&equo; (Mandani). 
 But what is it like to go from one pregnancy to the next &mdash; going on having more and more children? 
 By the age of thirty or thirty-five a woman is old and exhausted, her body bloated, her face showing the pain and suffering of her life. 
 Fathers, husbands and fathers-in-law are the direct tyrants of this society but their own lives are not much easier. 
 They are brutalised by the hard and constant struggle to survive. 
 For example, the son who is chosen by his family to go and earn money in a town and city may achieve a certain status in the joint family &mdash; he has been chosen, after all, for his abilities and strength of mind &mdash; but he has to suffer months, even years, of separation from his wife and loss of all contact with those who love him. 
 In the city he is just another casual labourer working at the lowest level of urban employment. 
 He can be tossed back into unemployment when he is no longer required. 
 In the Indian sub-continent the cities have colonised the villages and the rural communities have gradually been eroded until (ideally for industrial capitalism) nothing remains but a pool of reserve labour which can be drawn upon as and when it is needed. 
 But capitalism, after Indian independence, was (in so far as its effects on the rural population were concerned) merely following along the paths established by British colonialism and British capitalism. 
 Having transferred the wealth of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh to the &bquo;mother country&equo; Britain had left these countries at independence with a large labour force and no capital to make it productive. 
 (It was because of this that people from the impoverished villages who sought work in the towns didn't always find it.) 
 As a result workers could be drawn from the Indian sub-continent whenever they were required by Britain. 
 Effectively this happened in two stages &mdash; the first in the 1920s and 30s when British colonialism wanted to create an intermediate class in East African countries, and the second after World War II when Britain in common with other Western European countries was faced with a chronic shortage of labour. 
 The people who emigrated in the first stage were mainly farming families from the state of Gujerat (see map) and craft-workers from Punjab, while those who came directly to Britain in the 1950s and 60s were mainly farming families from Gujerat and the Indian and Pakistani areas of Punjab. 
 There were also smaller groups of higher and lower caste people from these areas and in addition there were people from the villages of Sylhet, a district of Bangladesh. 
 What I have described so far relates in general to the lives of women in the peasant communities in many parts of the Indian sub-continent, but the details I have given mainly concern women in East and West Punjab. 
 In Gujerat these details do not always apply because the structures of communities are rather different. 
 Rather than categorise these structures I shall describe briefly just one community, the Patels, and by tracing the changes in their dowry system, follow the changes in the position of Patel women. 
 The Patel community was said to have been founded around 1700, when six brothers from Persia settled in six villages in the fertile Charotar region of Gujerat. 
 Each brother brought with him a full retinue of staff &mdash;&mdash; artisans, labourers, shoemakers and so on &mdash;&mdash; in fact all the elements of the Hindu caste system. 
 The six villages (they are now small towns) each had the same structure. 
 The landowners lived centrally, and around them, in concentric circles as it were, lived the working people. 
 All the people in these villages called themselves Patels but they were divided into clans which corresponded quite closely with the Hindu caste system. 
 The six brothers' direct descendants were called the che gaon ki gor  (six village clan) and similarly the artisans and their descendants were the twelve village clan, the labourers were the twenty four village clan and right near the bottom of the caste hierarchy came the shoemakers with their clan of &bquo;several&equo; villages. 
 People usually married within their own clan, and the caste system was thus maintained in the same hereditary form as in most other parts of India. 
 However, as elsewhere in India, with colonialism came the economic decay of the villages. 
 In the 1920s and 30s men were forced to migrate to towns to find work. 
 In the Patel villages the men who emigrated were mainly those from lower status groups because they were least likely to have land. 
 There was as a result a shortage of marriageable young men among the lower Patels. 
 This problem was solved in a manner which would be considered quite unconventional in other parts of India. 
 Lower Patel girls married higher Patel boys but on condition that their parents paid vast dowries to acknowledge the rise in status of their daughters. 
 (In contrast, in other parts of India inter-caste marriages are thoroughly disapproved of.) 
 These marriages of lower Patel girls to higher Patel boys became vast affairs, with the girl's family being forced to spend enormous sums on sweets and also give large amounts of gold to the boy's family. 
 Not surprisingly, the position of the Patel woman changed for the worse. 
 In lower Patel families the birth of many daughters began to be regarded as a disaster. 
 When the Patels emigrated to East Africa the dowry system was continued and exaggerated there. 
 Gold became more easily available in African countries and the Patels became more and more gold-orientated as a community. 
 East African Patels often went home to Gujerat to marry, and the women, with their vast dowries, almost invariably married higher Patels. 
 Status, and effectively caste, was thus being bought at vast prices. 
 In the 1950s and 60s dowries in India went down generally because gold was controlled, but not so in East Africa, where dowries rose as though they would never stop. 
 In fact they didn't stop until the next step in Patel emigration &mdash; their expulsion from East Africa. 
 Perhaps it was institutions like the dowry system which made the East African Asian Patels status conscious, or maybe they used the dowry with such enthusiasm because they had become so preoccupied with status as a result of their role in East Africa. 
 Either way, the position of women reflected by the dowry system was consistent with the Asians' new petit-bourgeois role in East Africa. 
 In their villages of origin the women had been regarded as contributing less to the economic position of the family than the men, but they had at least been recognised as crucial to the economic life of the community. 
 In East Africa this changed completely. 
 As with the middle classes of Victorian England or the British colonials in India and Africa, one or two men working could maintain a large family in comfort. 
 The women began increasingly to be regarded as possessions of their families. 
 The marriage of a son was a way of adding to a family's wealth, and a woman's role was to display this wealth through her clothes, manner and life style. 
 The birth of a son was welcomed now for traditional reasons (for example, among Hindus the son plays an essential part in the cremation ceremony) and because he would bring home a vast dowry when he married, but no longer so much because he would be a new worker for the joint family. 
 As far as the British were concerned, Asian emigration to East African countries was extremely successful. 
 A rigid class system was established, and soon an urbanised and caste- and status-conscious bourgeoise was established which would keep the lower orders under control without demanding too much from the colonisers. 
 In the 1950s and 60s, when Britain itself needed workers, it seemed obvious to turn again to the vast army of labour which waited in the colonies and ex-colonies, and whose situation itself had been created by colonialism. 
 This was how the wave of post-war emigration from Punjab, Gujerat and Bangladesh began. 
 Men came in response to the direct demand for labour. 
 Throughout the 1950s the size of work they were able to find was determined by economic growth and the legacy of colonial attitudes. 
 While many indigenous workers moved up into better-paid, pleasanter and more skilled jobs, the immigrants were left the dirty, hard and low-paid work in the foundries and textile mills, as transport or catering workers or in sweat shops and small factories thrown up by the post-war boom. 
 &bquo;Everyone made money on the immigrant worker &mdash; from the big-time capitalist to the slum landlord &mdash; from exploiting his colour, his customs, his culture. 
 He himself had cost the country nothing. 
 He had been paid for by his country of origin &mdash; reared and raised as capitalist underdevelopment had willed it for the labour markets of Europe.&equo; 
 (A. Sivanandan, &bquo;Race, Class and the State&equo; in Race &dollar; Class , Summer 1976.) 
 But it was this very exploitation &mdash; the fact, for example, that immigrant workers had to live in the deprived and decaying areas of big cities because of the proximity of their jobs to these areas, which led to their being regarded increasingly as undesirable. 
 Immigration to Britain, a country of net emigration (which means that more people emigrate from it than immigrate to it) did not in itself throw up social problems but it served to highlight social deprivation. 
 Racism became more and more intense and finally there were major eruptions in the race riots of 1958. 
 Up to this point the only political significance of racism had been that it provided a divided work force for employers. 
 But after the race riots it was seen as something which the state would have both to cater for and take control of. 
 In addition the economy was no longer so desperately short of workers. 
 Accordingly two sets of legislation were introduced in the 1960s: the Race Relations Act, which maintained the liberal facade of the state and which, though so weak as to be almost useless in practice, had as a basis the assumption that black people were a part of the community and needed to be protected from racial prejudice: in contrast, and much more effective, were the Immigration Acts, which themselves discriminated against black workers. 
 The 1962 Commonwealth Immigrants Act brought in a voucher system for the entry of Commonwealth citizens and distinguished between skilled and unskilled workers. 
 This was followed by a White Paper in 1965 which discontinued vouchers for unskilled black workers though unskilled white workers were still being admitted in large numbers. 
 These immigration laws established two important principles of future immigration policy. 
 Firstly that Britain would never end immigration altogether (even if it ended black immigration), because if it did so the economy might not survive its periodic labour shortages. 
 An immigrant labour force would always be needed as a buffer to absorb the shocks of alternating booms and recessions. 
 And secondly that in the interests of &bquo;racial harmony&equo; the government would itself discriminate against black people and make this discrimination legal. 
 Thus the Immigration Acts, beginning with the 1962 Act &bquo;took discrimination out of the market place and gave it the sanction of the state. 
 It made racism respectable and clinical by institutionalising it. 
 In doing so it also increased the social and political consequences of racism&equo; (A. Sivanandan, &bquo;Race, Class and the State&equo;). 
 In Asian women's lives this institutionalised racism and its social consequences are of extreme importance. 
 Apart from anything else, it was the indirect effect of these that first brought women from the Indian sub-continent to Britain. 
 In the case of Sikh women it was the day-to-day racism which their husbands faced in Britain which indirectly brought them to Britain; with Pakistanis and Bangladeshis it was the racism of Britain's Immigration laws. 
 When Sikh men came to Britain in the fifties it was with the hope of making some money (usually to buy more land for the family farm) and returning. 
 Once here, the racism they faced in employment often forced them to turn to starting their own business as a means of livelihood. 
 (This meant borrowing money and suffering a lot of hardships; but they thought it would be worth it, because it would mean they could not be so easily discriminated against.) 
 However, businesses take time to build up and, having built them up, and an accompanying status in the all-male Sikh society, they were reluctant to leave, and gradually more and more men started sending for their wives. 
 Mirpuri and Bangladeshi women came to Britain mainly as a result of immigration control. 
 Before the 1965 Immigration Act, Mirpuri and Bengali families would send their sons to England for a few months or a few years at a time. 
 An elder brother would come to Britain, return, and be replaced by a younger brother &mdash; and so on. 
 The Immigration Acts with their strict control of entry made frequent trips to and from Britain impossible. 
 Finally, the men who were here had no choice but to stay on, send for their wives and settle in Britain. 
 Having indirectly and inadvertently brought Asian women to Britain, the racism of the state and the racism of British society now defines the wider position of Asian women in this country &mdash; as the lowest paid and most exploited workers, or as the wives and daughters of such workers &mdash; an unstable and unacceptable situation full of conflict and contradictions. 
 Inside their families, too, their roles are in a state of flux, with the past, the peasant past, the tribal past, the colonial past each with its own particular prescription for the woman's role constantly intruding into the present. 
 Out of these multiple fields of conflict the future of Asian women in Britain is being resolved. 
 ISOLATION 
 &bquo;I have a burning fever &mdash; feel me, sister, feel me&equo; 
 I have been married now almost twenty five years. 
 We lived in Gulabganj (in Sylhet). 
 My daughter married there. 
 I have a little grandson. 
 It was after the boy was born that I came to live in London. 
 I came with my thirteen-year-old son to join my husband who had lived here for many, many years. 
 It took some time to get entry, there were delays, long sessions of questioning and trouble with certificates but in the end it was sorted out and we got on a plane in April 1974. 
 When we arrived&hellip; you ask me how I felt, sister&hellip; bad, I felt bad &mdash; to leave them all, everyone back in the village. 
 My husband had come to collect us at the airport and we came back here in a minicar. 
 Did I expect it to be like this? 
 No, tell me how could I? 
 After all I had never been here before, there was no means of knowing. 
 1 used to be sad. 
 I used to cry, not knowing anyone or anything, missing my home&hellip; 
 To live in one room after living in a country where houses are so open. 
 It was hard, very hard. 
 Rezia Begum is forty one. 
 She lives in a street near Russell Square. 
 There is no bell on the door. 
 To get in I and the friend who is taking me hammer and hammer on the door, shout over and over again in Bengali &bquo;It's us, it's us, let us in&equo;. 
 These precautions are essential because of the danger of racial attacks. 
 Finally Rezia throws the keys down from an upstairs window. 
 Inside, the whole house slopes to the right, the stairs are unwashed, the walls are peeling, the door of a broken WC stands open. 
 We go up several flights of stairs to the room where Rezia lives with her husband and son. 
 It isn't large; two wide beds almost fill it. 
 There is almost no other furniture. 
 Clothes hang on a line at one side of the room. 
 In one corner is a gas ring, in another a table with some school books on it. 
 The room is tidy, a few pictures decorate the walls. 
 Rezia spends almost all her time in this room. 
 She rarely goes out and has never been beyond the street she lives in on her own. 
 She speaks no English and knows hardly anyone. 
 In her first year in Britain no one visited her. 
 Her husband is a restaurant worker. 
 He is out all day from 11 am. to midnight. 
 Where does he work, I ask. 
 &bquo;I don't know the place. 
 I have never been there. 
 I don't know the name or address except that it is a club of some sort. 
 He never really talks about his work. 
 There isn't the time.&equo; 
 The isolation and emptiness of Rezia's life is typical of what many Asian women in Britain face. 
 Those who have come from a joint family in India, Pakistan or Bangladesh to live alone with their husbands in Britain suffer most. 
 Zubeida, a woman in her thirties, described to me her experiences of twelve years ago. 
 I had a proxy marriage on the telephone. 
 My husband was here and he was a great friend of my uncle so my uncle arranged it all. 
 &hellip; We stayed first in Colindale. 
 My husband was an accountant. 
 He was very handsome and he was very good to me. 
 But one thing about our Asian men is that they think it a matter of pride that their women must not go out to work. 
 But the problem for us is one of loneliness. 
 At least if a woman goes out to work she can escape that &mdash; her mind is occupied, she does not long so much for her home in Pakistan. 
 When I first came my husband did not want me to go out to work. 
 It is true there was a lot of housework but I used to be very lonely. 
 Everyday I used to cry. 
 I missed my parents; I longed for my home and my sisters. 
 In Pakistan they used to be my constant companions. 
 I used to cry till my husband came home at five o'clock. 
 Only on Saturdays and Sundays was I happy. 
 I would make a really nice dinner, get ready and dress up. 
 My husband would take me to a cinema. 
 It was called the Scala. 
 I was always waiting for Saturday. 
 In these lonely hours, sitting in Brick Lane in the East End or Lamb Lane in Bradford, vivid memories come flooding in from the past, from the life before this semi-existence. 
 Our house is open, as most houses in Sylhet are. 
 It is made of earth and bamboo but it is beautiful. 
 A straw thatch covers the main part, then there are verandahs and a courtyard. 
 On moonlight nights, we, the women, used to sit there and talk or sing and prepare and eat Pan  (betel leaf). 
 The busiest time of the year is the rice harvest, if the crop is good that is. 
 There used to be a lot of work. 
 I and other girls and women, we'd work the Dhenki , husking the rice, or sometimes we'd go to the fields carrying tobacco and food for my brothers-in-law and cousins who were working there. 
 Occasionally we'd harvest the lighter crops, like sweet potatoes or chillis. 
 Then the rainy season would come. 
 When the rains come to my country the clusters of houses are like islands. 
 Here and there a tall Tal  tree (a kind of palm) stands out, all else is submerged. 
 When I was a young girl I and my sisters would get a boat and slip away, visiting friends from island to island. 
 Of course the elders didn't like it, they thought we were tomboys, but we loved it &mdash; the sound of the water, the rocking and splashing&hellip;. 
 Sometimes at night, the music of boatmen would come floating up, blown by the waves and wind, a flute playing the music of the river. 
 Why, why did I ever leave my home? 
 In London it is 4 pm. 
 Outside the evening is drawing in already. 
 Rezia is waiting for her son to come home from school. 
 She is worried about him. 
 About a month ago he was severely beaten up by a gang of white boys on the way back from school. 
 They used to bully him and tease him; then one day on his way back from school they attacked him. 
 The next day he and another Bengali boy who lives near by chose another way home, hoping to escape the attackers. 
 But the gang found out and followed him here. 
 Just as my son entered our room I could see them, seven or eight hefty white boys entering through the door downstairs. 
 We could hear them coming up the stairs right to our door and then shouting and hammering on it. 
 I got up and quietly bolted the door. 
 We kept very still inside and in the end we could hear them slowly going down the stairs and going away. 
 After that I did not want my son to go to school but in the end some Bengali men in the area took it up with the Headmaster and since then there has been no trouble. 
 A community worker who helped the family told me: 
 We took it up with the Education Officer who asked for information about the family. 
 I told them I know them well, their son is not the type who just gets in fights. 
 When it was taken up with the Headmaster he said that the boy's name was not on the roll, they did not know of him. 
 We felt he was trying to avoid the whole issue. 
 Anyway in the end he and the Education Officer did take some action to control the bullies and since then there has been no trouble. 
 But just think if the family had not been in touch with the Bengali Action Group or with any community workers, what sort of state of fear they'd live in. 
 And there are many families like that. 
 The police? &mdash; who would call them, these families don't have telephones. 
 And even if they are called they hardly ever come in time. 
 Many other women I spoke to told me that for protection from racial attacks it was essential to have Asian neighbours. 
 Calling the police had proved again and again to be useless. 
 During the racial violence of summer 1976, a housewife from Newham told me: 
 It was just an ordinary evening. 
 I had done all the cooking and was waiting for my husband to come home. 
 Suddenly I heard a loud scream and rushed to the front door. 
 Half a dozen white teenagers were beating someone up. 
 There was blood on the pavement. 
 I couldn't see who it was at first, then I realised it was my husband. 
 He was unconscious on the ground. 
 They were kicking and beating him. 
 I screamed for help. 
 The neighbours rushed out and we beat off the thugs with sticks and broom handles. 
 We called the police and ambulance but it was a long time before the police arrived. 
 They went to see my husband in hospital and asked him to see them when he came out. 
 But when he did they showed no interest at all, they just said the officer concerned was not there. 
 They made no attempt to catch the thugs. 
 This family had Asian neighbours. 
 Below is the story of a Bengali family in the East End who did not ( Guardian  6.6.77): 
 In Shadwell Gardens, by Cable Street there is a large block of council flats. 
 On the ground floor my interpreter from the Bengali Housing Association led the way into a small, bare flat inhabited by a Bengali widow with three children of six, eight and nine. 
 Last Saturday night they were watching television. 
 They had just had the windows repaired from the last volley of stones. 
 Fists started hammering on their windows. 
 They turned the lights out and sat in fear. 
 They heard sounds in the kitchen: breaking glass, sounds of unknown things coming into their home. 
 Peeking around the kitchen door, they saw rubbish being emptied from dustbins into their home. 
 Then a stone came through the living room window. 
 The widow gathered her children and ran out of the front door seeking protection from another Bengali family thirty yards across the court. 
 There were about thirty people waiting for them as they left their home. 
 The bruises on the neck and face and legs of the widow and her children were still livid on the brown skin as they recounted how they had run a gauntlet of fists and kicks and curses of their neighbours. 
 Yelling in Bengali for help, they reached the door of the other family. 
 One of its sons came out and tried to help them inside. 
 He was pulled into the court and beaten on the face. 
 He stood beside the broken glass of his front door as he described how the white neighbours &mdash; assisted by two West Indian girls &mdash; hauled him into the court and beat him. 
 The bruises and lumps were still fresh and unhealed on his face. 
 The police arrived three hours later, by which time the seige of the Bengali homes had ended&hellip; 
 Bengali families in the East End feel they have no protection and that they must begin to protect themselves. 
 They say that the police could stop the violence overnight if the Special Patrol Group was assigned to patrol the area, or if the Home Office made it sufficiently clear that this kind of activity must stop. 
 One of the fears of the Bengali community is that the new Conservative administration of the GLC will not honour a private agreement reached with the Labour GLC in 1976, for quick and emergency relocation of harassed Asian families. 
 If these fears prove justified, it won't be the first time Asian families would be forced through deliberate government policies to live in terrifying isolation. 
 Right from the early 1960s the attitude of local authorities and housing departments has been that &bquo;ghettos&equo; must be avoided at all costs, and even a handful of Asian families can make an area into a ghetto. 
 (Councillor Harry Doran, Newham, reported in the Newham Recorder , May 1976 &mdash; &bquo;The estate is becoming a ghetto. 
 Only eight floors (of a tower block) are without an immigrant family&equo;.) 
 When in 1972 the Uganda Asians started coming to Britain, the government's Uganda Resettlement Board operated a deliberate policy of dispersal. 
 Refugee families in obvious distress were discouraged and often prevented from joining their relations and Asian friends in Britain by the Board's refusal of all aid to them if they settled in areas with significant Asian populations. 
 This has led to situations like that described in A Job Well Done ? by Helene Middleweek and Michael Ward, a report prepared on behalf of the Co-ordination Committee for the Welfare of Evacuees from Uganda, of a family consisting of mother, father and thirteen-year-old son, where neither of the parents spoke any English and the father was almost paralysed. 
 They were settled in a remote area of Ross and Cromarty in Scotland, twenty miles from the nearest Asian family. 
 Isolation is seen from the outside as a result of women not speaking English, or of their being forced to stay at home for cultural reasons. 
 But it is much more than this. 
 It is a state of mind, one of shock and withdrawal. 
 Weakened by the separation from their families, suffering often the loss of mother, sisters and close friends, these Asian women find themselves in a strange unknown society. 
 The realisation that this is a racist society, a society which wishes them dead for the colour of their skin, accentuates their loneliness, and their isolation in turn makes it harder for them to fight against racism. 
 Living in the conditions I have described can cause the strongest personalities to sink into depression. 
 For pregnant women, or those who have just had babies, the pressures are sometimes so great that they become mentally disturbed. 
 Post-natal depression is said to be common among immigrant women generally. 
 Among Asians it affects particularly those who are separated from their families. 
 Indigenous British women affected by post-natal depression are often single mothers or those whose husbands or boyfriends don't give them the care and affection or help they need in this new stage of their life. 
 For Asian women, separation from their families can cause the same torment. 
 Often these women, sometimes as young as seventeen or eighteen, suffer alone, no one except their husbands knows about them, or cares. 
 Occasionally they are referred to hospitals, but the treatment they receive sometimes serves only to underline their isolation. 
 A London hospital allowed me to visit one of their patients. 
 She was Manisha, a Muslim girl of twenty from Sylhet, and had just had her second child. 
 She had been having fits of anger, and had been neglecting her children, I was told. 
 She was being treated at home at that time. 
 A community nurse was visiting her so that she wouldn't get too lonely and depressed. 
 This nurse, I was surprised to discover, was a man. 
 He seemed a very pleasant person but he spoke no Bengali. 
 In fact he said to me &bquo;You could be quite useful, you know, you could help me get through to her.&equo; 
 We went to see Manisha one winter afternoon. 
 The nurse had brought along a male friend of his. 
 Manisha lived in a council flat in a decrepit estate. 
 Garbage littered the outside; a very old white woman hobbled slowly on crutches into a downstairs flat. 
 As we entered the building a white woman leaning from a balcony screamed a stream of abuse. 
 We went up to the second floor and knocked at Manisha's flat. 
 For a long time there was no sound inside, then the door opened. 
 A Bengali girl, absurdly young, stood there holding a baby in her arms. 
 She didn't look at us, didn't answer when I spoke in Bengali. 
 Finally, still silent, she turned and led us into the main room. 
 She left us there a few minutes, then, coming to the door, beckoned me to the next room. 
 There at last she began to speak. 
 This is how I remember it. 
 My head aches all the time. 
 I have a burning fever &mdash; feel me sister, feel me. 
 Inside me sometimes is such anger, anger with my babies, with my husband, with the whole of my life. 
 Then suddenly I am panic-stricken. 
 My head feels as though it is on fire. 
 It started when I got home from hospital after having my baby. 
 My husband gave me the news that my father had died back in the village. 
 Now, thinking of them, how do I feel&hellip; 
 Late, late at night my husband comes home. 
 He loves the babies. 
 He is a good husband, but what can he do? 
 And what can I do? 
 How can I live, sister, how can I live! 
 In the next room the nurse and his friend were playing with Manisha's older child. 
 What was it that Manisha was missing so desperately? 
 Ranu, a Sylheti woman in her late twenties, told me of the enveloping love and care a woman with her first or second child can receive in Bangladesh. 
 If a girl is lucky and her parents are alive, she goes to her mother's house for the last few months of her pregnancy and about the first three months of the baby's life. 
 There she gets a lot of love and care. 
 She is asked &bquo;What would you like to eat? 
 What do you fancy?&equo; 
 All the time she is looked after. 
 The whole matter of pregnancy is one of celebration. 
 When the baby is born it is an occasion of joy for the whole family. 
 The naming ceremony is so lovely. 
 It is held when the baby is seven days old. 
 A new dress is bought for it and a new sari for the mother. 
 There is feasting and singing till late at night. 
 The women and young girls gather and sing songs. 
 Garlands of turmeric and garlic are worn to ward off evil spirits. 
 That's when the name is chosen. 
 The Maulvi  of course selects a formal Arabic name, but the celebration I am telling you about involves choosing a name to call the child by. 
 Suggestions are asked for from the family and friends all over the village. 
 Then a new cane Kulo  (tray for dusting rice) is taken, a big one with pictures woven into it perhaps, and the names are written on it in ink. 
 Candles are placed by each name. 
 The name which burns the longest is chosen. 
 The same ceremony is held for the birth of a boy or a girl. 
 Of course it is considered better to have a boy, but the birth of a girl is celebrated with the same joy by the women in the family. 
 We sit together eating pan  and singing. 
 Some of us might be young unmarried girls, others aged ladies of 40 or 50. 
 There are so many jokes, so much laughter. 
 People look so funny eating pan  and singing. 
 The men don't take much part. 
 They may come and have a look at the baby, but the singing, the gathering together at night &mdash; it is all women. 
 The songs are simple songs which are rarely written down. 
 They are about the lives of women in Bengal. 
 Back in London, what is available to mentally disturbed women who are treated in hospital? 
 I cannot make generalisations without a far more detailed study of hospitals. 
 But it is worth mentioning what a very experienced and established psychiatrist told me about his work when I interviewed him. 
 When I asked how he communicated with Bengali patients who spoke no English he said &bquo;I have no trouble in communicating with them because I learned pidgin English in the army.&equo; 
 What were the main illnesses people suffered from? 
 I asked. 
 He replied: 
 Well, at certain times we have had a large number of Bengali patients. 
 In fact at one time before the Pakistan-Bangladesh war there were so many that we called this form of depression Pakistani Syndrome. 
 The symptoms were bleary eyes, pain in the head, loss of weight, sleeplessness, and for the men impotency. 
 We gave electric treatment. 
 Some had it twice. 
 But if they came more than once their friends usually sent them home. 
 After two bouts they go home; they don't recover. 
 During the war it was better. 
 There were very few patients. 
 The war took people's minds off things. 
 Now again there is less psychiatry because people are afraid of losing their jobs. 
 Living conditions don't affect them. 
 They do adapt, they are jolly and supportive. 
 As for the women, he said, they suffered from the same sort of things &mdash; depression and sometimes guilt. 
 He told me of one case he had had of a woman in her early twenties. 
 Her own family were in Bangladesh. 
 Her husband, a restaurant owner, was almost twice her age and diabetic. 
 She was acutely depressed and had a pain in the back of her neck. 
 He had treated her for several months using her husband as an interpreter &mdash; as though her husband were an objective witness to her depression. 
 He told me: 
 It took me time to find out what was wrong but eventually I sorted it out. 
 The patient had been living before she came to London on the outskirts of a town in Bangladesh. 
 She never wore the veil. 
 One day an older woman who wore the veil cursed her and accused her of being loose. 
 This curse resulted in guilt, because in a way you see it was true. 
 She was loose. 
 For example every day when the came to see me she wore a beautiful new sari. 
 I found this account sad but also rather revealing. 
 It showed not only a lot of racism and sexist vanity on the part of the psychiatrist but ignorance about the way of life of his patient. 
 That young girl hardly out of her teens, married to an ailing elderly man, probably never went out of the house apart from these visits to the hospital. 
 Being well-off (the wife of a restaurant owner), she had many beautiful saris. 
 Wearing a different one every time she went out would be only normal, particularly since a sari does not have to be washed as frequently as a dress because it is not worn next to the skin. 
 To get a more general view of how the Health Service departments treat their Asian women patients, I asked social workers in different parts of London what their experiences had been in dealing with hospitals, Health Visitors and Area Health Authorities. 
 They told me that there were serious everyday problems which arose because the needs of Asian patients were being ignored. 
 There is, for example, a general absence of interpreters in hospitals even in areas with high immigrant populations. 
 Some terrifying situations occur as a result. 
 There was the case, for example, of a five-year-old boy who was taken to hospital vomiting violently and with a high temperature. 
 It was two days before medical staff found out what his distraught parents were trying to tell them &mdash; that he had swallowed the contents of a tin of paint. 
 The hospital staff I spoke to were almost without exception complacent on the subject of interpreters. 
 In one hospital in an area with a large proportion of Bangladeshis, the Hospital Secretary told me &bquo;We rarely need interpreters but we have a list of members of staff who speak various foreign languages&equo; &mdash; for Bengali there was a porter and a cook &mdash; both male. 
 In Wandsworth the attitude of the Area Health Authority and of Health Visitors was described to me by Geeta Amin, a social worker with Wandsworth Community Relations Council. 
 We wanted to do a research project on the reasons for the low take-up of Health Clinics and Health Services by Asian women. 
 It seemed to be a very important project but the Area Health Authority felt it would be &bquo;unethical&equo;. 
 There is a complete lack of understanding, and that goes right the way through the Health Service&hellip; 
 I have been giving a series of seminars on nutrition and the Asian family to Health Visitors. 
 I have been telling them about the different sensitivity which Asian women have to their babies and the fact that you can't just go up to an Asian woman with the diet leaflet and say you should be giving your baby Cod Liver Oil, because 90 per cent of Asians in Wandsworth are vegetarians. 
 But one faces a continuous battle with these Health Visitors. 
 You go to a seminar and say &bquo;Listen, they don't eat this kind of thing!&equo; 
 But their attitude remains the same &mdash; &bquo;Well we treat them all the same whether they are Asian or English&equo;. 
 That is the fundamental policy of all social services &mdash; &bquo;We treat them all the same. 
 We don't see any difference. 
 If we can tell an English mother to do that we'll tell an Asian mother to do that.&equo; 
 Something which shows the Area Health Authority policy is their refusal to have any special facilities for Asian women. 
 They complain that Asian women don't attend clinics for mother's groups and discussions. 
 But they are not interested in the reasons for it, in the sort of alienation which Asian women feel at these groups. 
 We suggested a special Asian mother's group to discuss health problems. 
 They said &bquo;We can't have anything of the sort, we don't run separate facilities for Asians, and not only that, we are not going to allow you to use the Health Clinic for anything that is solely for Asians.&equo; 
 Hashmat Ara Begum, a community worker in the Borough of Camden told me that she too had come across the most contemptuous attitudes among Health Visitors. 
 She said that they seemed to regard Asian women as ignorant and stupid people who neglected their children. 
 She explained why Bangladeshi women sometimes found it difficult to look after their children in Britain. 
 What young mothers suffer from more than almost anything else is having constant responsibility for their children. 
 In Bangladesh children under the age of five or six are looked after by the whole family. 
 All the children in the joint family are looked after together. 
 They are taken to the pond for a bath perhaps by one daughter-in-law, and she baths them all. 
 Then they all come in and sit down to eat. 
 Perhaps the youngest daughter-in-law has cooked the meal. 
 Another woman feeds them. 
 As for playing, children play out of doors with natural objects. 
 Here people say that Asian children don't play with toys. 
 In Bangladesh they don't need toys. 
 They make their own simple things &mdash; models and castles out of mud, dolls with red earth and leaves. 
 Being out of doors means they are not always cooped up in one room with their mothers. 
 In the afternoon or evening they love to hear Rupkotha  (fairy tales). 
 Maybe there is a favourite aunt, she tells them these stories. 
 But at night when they get sleepy they always go to their mother and sleep in her embrace. 
 But other women do help a lot, in fact they have such strong relationships with the child that it is not uncommon for them to be called Big Mother or Small Mother. 
 Here, in Britain, the attitude of women is quite different; they may say why should another woman look after my baby or even touch my baby. 
 Snatched from the security and love of their sisters in the joint family, Bengali women in Britain often find themselves forced into total emotional dependence on their husbands. 
 For many it is a strange and difficult experience, one which people who have always lived in a nuclear family find hard to understand. 
 In fact their feelings and the vast emotional adjustment they have to make are perhaps best explained to nuclear family dwellers by considering the reverse transplant from nuclear to joint family. 
 For Asian women coming to join their husbands in Britain the experience is if anything more bewildering; first, the change is permanent: then, often enough there are also the problems of racism and poverty. 
 But how do those western women feel, for example, who having lived with their Indian husbands in Britain for years, are suddenly thrust into the bosom of the joint family, even temporarily. 
 This is how Janet described her three-month visit to her husband's family in an Indian village in Bihar: 
 I found it really hard when I was left totally to the women's company&hellip; 
 One of the things I didn't like too much was the terrific hullabaloo the women made about menstruation, the way they would sit sighing in a corner and all the other women would make a fuss over them. 
 As a feminist I wanted these women to stop having what seemed to me to be silly attitudes&hellip; 
 They were terribly puzzled by me. 
 They often asked me if I had a baby in my tummy because they saw no evidence of my menstruation&hellip; 
 These women don't have a role of status or power in society. 
 So when they are sick, especially women's things, they make the most of it. 
 For example, during pregnancy and just after you are queen for ten or eleven months. 
 When I was sick I experienced a eat deal of love and consideration. 
 But I found I could communicate better with men. 
 One particular uncle, he showed such warmth that a western man would find it very hard to show. 
 With the women it was less easy. 
 They often stroked and embraced each other and me. 
 I could sense their warmth and desire to please but I didn't know how to respond. 
 A lot of the day they sat round the oven talking. 
 I would attempt to do something like peeling potatoes with one of those footknives. 
 This would be a source of pleasure to them. 
 But often I hated spending time with them. 
 It was frighteningly boring. 
 While it is true that village women in India have little power or status in society as a whole, Janet misunderstands what lies behind the caring and &bquo;fussing&equo;. 
 It is not as she thinks a desire to &bquo;make the most of it&equo;, to somehow claim importance, but rather a recognition that in this oppressive society women need the care and emotional support of other women. 
 Often Asian women coming from joint families in the Indian subcontinent to join their husbands in Britain do succeed in making the necessary emotional adjustment, but for many of them it takes months if not years; for some coping with the total emotional dependence on the husband alone is just not possible. 
 I do not mean of course that there is no tradition of love in marriage. 
 The oldest stories in Indian mythology are after all love stories, accounts of the relationships of lovers, and specifically of married couples. 
 The same is true of Urdu poetry. 
 In the villages of Bangladesh the folk-songs, even the tapestries women make, tell stories of love and romance. 
 What I do mean is that although most women do hope for a happy and loving relationship with their husbands, the attainment of this is not the purpose of marriage. 
 The role of marriage which acts as a conservative force, is economic and childbearing, and the knowledge of this role hangs like a dark shadow over any possible relationships. 
 For the girl, marriage does not then symbolise a heightened or new relationship with a man. 
 It means instead the end of childhood and freedom, the beginning of a new life as a slave and chattel at the bottom of a hierarchy in someone else's family. 
 &bquo;One day,&equo; as one Pakistani girl in Bradford said, &bquo;I was a child playing out of doors, the next I was a married woman with a life full of work.&equo; 
 To symbolise her new life, her new role defined for her by the male rule-makers of society, a girl may even be given a new name on marriage. 
 For village women in Punjab, Bengal or Gujerat, there is usually only one source of comfort in their new life &mdash; the presence of other women &mdash; to love them, caress them, sing songs with them and soothe their sorrows. 
 In Britain, for these women who live alone with their husbands, this comfort is lacking, the afternoon hour spent lying on a bed chatting with their sisters-in-law, combing and oiling each other's hair, is replaced by empty hours sitting by the heater in some grey suburb. 
 Often their husbands are much older than them, not so much for traditional reasons as because men settled in Britain are considered of higher status and class and therefore, being more desirable as sons-in-law, they can find young brides. 
 As one Bengali girl bitterly commented: &bquo;You may have wondered why among Sylheti families in this area (King's Cross) the man is often horribly old with a crooked face while his wife is a young girl of astonishing beauty. 
 That's because parents in Sylhet seem to think it is a big deal, a real status symbol to get a Biliti Bor  (a bridegroom from England).&equo; 
 Another woman told me about how Sylheti men returned to the village to find a bride: &bquo;After years in England they suddenly decide to marry a village girl. 
 They go, in their smart suits and ties, back to the village. 
 The villagers hold them in awe and think of them as men of the world. 
 People don't know about London. 
 Don't know what a rotten life their daughter will have.&equo; 
 Often the men marry girls not only younger but of a higher social class than their own in Sylhet. 
 Back in London in the Sylheti community, having a young, good-looking wife from a comparatively high class is in turn a status symbol. 
 The next step, which only the most well-off men such as restaurant owners can afford, is keeping this wife in semi-purdah &mdash; in other words sentencing her to solitary confinement. 
 This greed for status reinforces the wife's role as child-bearing domestic slave or chattel, and spoils for ever the chance of a real relationship. 
 Any error on her part, however small, and he may remind her that he can go back to Bangladesh and marry again. 
 Any gynaecological illness, even a Caesarian operation, and he may regard her as unfit for sex and therefore useless: and he will go back to Bangladesh and marry again. 
 Two Bengali women in their twenties told me of many women they knew, and knew of, who were thus stranded. 
 &bquo;After that&equo; said one of them &bquo;how can there he any love between husband and wife. 
 The husband, loving him, looking after him is regarded by us as a duty. 
 He may be like a banana tree or a coconut tree, half human in appearance, revolting in every way, but caring for him is still a woman's duty if he's her husband. 
 At home (in Bangladesh) we can balance it out in our minds because of all the love and happiness we can get from the women in the family. 
 Here, all that is in the past we yearn for.&equo; 
 THE FAMILY 
 &bquo;A part of myself&hellip; which gives me so much pain&equo; 
 &bquo;My family is like a part of myself, of my body; if I cut it off I could die. 
 But it is a part which gives me so much pain that sometimes I can't bear it &mdash; can't bear it at all.&equo; 
 Asian women come from many different language groups, practise at least three main religions and have come to Britain in varied patterns of migration but ask them about their family life and the similarity of their experience stands out like the skeleton in an X-ray. 
 Their lives are dominated by three main concepts &mdash; the male ego whose nurturing, preserving and boosting is considered of vital importance; a sense of hierarchy which is considered synonymous with the existence of the family; and finally the closeness of relationships &mdash; the bonds which provide consolation. 
 These three concepts were also basic to women's lives in the villages of India, Pakistan and Bangladesh; they were principles essential to the societies they lived in. 
 In Britain these principles are still present but meaningless, their very irrelevance making their upholders all the more determined and aggressive. 
 The structures and sizes of Asian families in Britain vary, depending to a certain extent on their regional background in the Indian subcontinent. 
 Among Sikhs, for example, many of the first male immigrants arrived in the 1950s, by the 60s they had been joined by their wives and children and by the 70s many of them had brought their elderly parents. 
 These large families &mdash; two or three brothers, their wives and children and their parents &mdash; usually live in one house. 
 Among Mirpuri Muslims, in most cases the family consists of husband and wife, their children, and a network of cousins living not necessarily in one house but in one neighbourhood, as in the Lamb Lane area of Bradford. 
 Among Bangladeshis, often enough it is a husband and wife and their sons of various ages, the daughters being left with the joint family in Bangladesh which from there casts its light and shadow on the lives of Bengali women in Britain. 
 As for the Gujeratis from East Africa, in many cases the whole joint family has been transplanted into Britain, from young babies even to great grandmothers. 
 The whole joint family is on the scene, bearing the onslaught of British society and groaning with agony as a result groaning on the one hand because of the intense racism and poverty it faces and on the other because of the confusions caused by the irrelevance in Britain of its most valued concepts. 
 There are of course other groups of Asian immigrants, Punjabis from East Africa, urban immigrants from towns like Delhi and so on. 
 But I will not mention here every group or Asian immigrants in Britain, nor analyse every family structure, but present what the Asian women I spoke to told me about their feelings and situations. 
 Here I shall try to describe certain aspects of family life for three main groups of women &mdash; Punjabi and Pathan Muslims from Pakistan, Sikhs from India and Gujerati Hindus from East Africa. 
 It is often said that Muslim men think it a matter of pride that their women shouldn't work. 
 If it is thought that this is one of the pleasanter, more protective aspects of male chauvinism, this is mistaken. 
 &bquo;Work&equo; in this statement does not include housework, ill-paid home sewing or the heavy work of carrying food to the fields in Pakistan. 
 What Muslim men don't like is for their women to work outside the home, potentially in the company of strange men. 
 But to ascribe this to male chauvinism wouldn't be accurate either. 
 These attitudes are created by Izzat , the sensitive and many-faceted male family identity which can change as the situation demands it &mdash; from family pride to honour to self respect, and sometimes to pure male ego. 
 Predictably, it is women who can place Izzat most easily at risk. 
 In the villages of Pakistan, a woman working outside her home does not usually come across men unrelated to her and because of this, group or family identity is not endangered. 
 As Farda, a girl from the Jhelum area told me, &bquo;in the village everyone is our Biradiri  (brethren). 
 So women don't need to wear Burkhas  to avoid being seen by strange men. 
 But in towns, even in small towns it is not the same. 
 People from different families live and work in the same area and as a result women are forced into Burkhas .&equo; 
 For this reason urban women in Pakistan only rarely work outside the home. 
 Salima a woman from a small provincial town told me: 
 If a girl has a job, relatives and neighbours start saying of their family &mdash; &bquo;What kind of people are they, have they no Izzat  to make their daughter work?&equo; 
 If she is an educated girl you might think there would be careers open to her but only three are available &mdash; teacher, doctor or nurse (although even nursing is disapproved of). 
 If she is a teacher in a girl's school and even one man is employed there, people start saying there is a man there among the women. 
 If she has to deal with him at all, even quite briefly, people start saying &bquo;She's always talking to that man, &mdash; who knows why she has so much to say.&equo; 
 So you see it isn't easy for a woman to keep a job. 
 However, despite this, in Britain 21 per cent of Muslim women do work outside the home. 
 It is because, as Salima, herself a factory worker, explained to me &bquo;the money is needed and not only that, there is a feeling among some people that what you do in Britain doesn't really count.&equo; 
 But Izzat, with its centuries long history, its emotional pull towards India and Pakistan, is not so easily dealt with. 
 Rational arguments and the need for money may keep it submerged but from time to time it is so inflamed that it can no longer be suppressed. 
 It surfaces, bringing feelings of humiliation and chagrin and causing conflict in the family. 
 British society serves in fact to keep Izzat alive. 
 The contempt for Asian culture, the constant shadow of racial hostility and the disregard for family and group identity provide an atmosphere in which Izzat is constantly at risk and therefore is constantly charged and recharged. 
 As a result the women suffer; they are made the scapegoats of damaged Izzat. 
 It is they, after all, who have always been the symbols of their culture and traditionally it is at their slightest touch that the delicate flower of Izzat can shrivel. 
 In Britain Izzat faces a whole new range of threats. 
 Should girls brought up in Britain be allowed to go on to further education? 
 Should they be allowed to take jobs? 
 Can their marriages be delayed? 
 Each one of these issues can be regarded in orthodox families as having an effect on Izzat. 
 Often they are questions on which the hierarchy of the family (in so far as it exists in Britain) has to be consulted. 
 And their group view is frequently more conservative than that of any one member. 
 The group gives support to those whose Izzat has been injured and suggests repressive remedies. 
 The women who face this repression have no such support. 
 The Pathan community in Bradford provides many such examples of community and family interaction where the net result is the oppression of women. 
 In Bradford the Pathans live mainly in extended families in large houses in the Hanover Square area. 
 The married women are rarely to be seen outside. 
 When they visit their friends they travel by back alleys from house to house. 
 To that extent their village life in Pakistan is mirrored in Bradford. 
 But they have children &mdash; daughters who go to school in Britain. 
 What happens when these daughters grow up? 
 This case was described to me by Hamida Kazi, a community worker in Bradford. 
 I had a case of a Pathan family where the husband used to beat his wife all the time. 
 There was nowhere on her body which wasn't black with bruises. 
 Even her eyes had blood on them. 
 &bquo;Even if I am sleeping,&equo; she told me &bquo;at 12 o'clock at night he comes and pulls the quilt off and starts beating me&equo;. 
 I asked why? 
 Was she a bad cook? 
 She said &bquo;No, he likes my cooking and I keep the house very tidy.&equo; 
 It is a sort of cultural conflict which must have been going on in the husband's mind. 
 Pathans are very very orthodox and sometimes religious fanatics. 
 This couple have four or five kids and their eldest daughter is about seventeen. 
 She is very beautiful and intelligent. 
 She is doing &bquo;O&equo; levels and wants to do &bquo;A&equo; levels. 
 He wants her to get married instead. 
 He thinks she should go to Pakistan because if she doesn't she'll get her own way. 
 One day he stabbed his wife in the hand. 
 His ten-year-old son got so frightened he ran and called the police. 
 The police came and he was taken away. 
 The underlying cause of all this was the girl's future. 
 When I went to see the family, the mother was very rational and calm and the girl told me: &bquo;there must be millions like me, Mrs Kazi. 
 I want to be a social worker so I could do something for these girls.&equo; 
 The father was remanded in custody for one week. 
 The police inspector told me: &bquo;When he comes out he'll probably go straight home and attack her.&equo; 
 So I tried my best and managed to get a council house for her to move into. 
 I asked her to move out at once. 
 But after I left, all the people from the Pathan community came to see her. 
 They forced her not to accept the house. 
 They told her that if she did they would outcast her. 
 That was too much of a price to pay. 
 She told me what they had said &mdash; that it is a loss of honour, &bquo;It is disrespectful to your husband.&equo; 
 I said &bquo;Where the hell were they when he was beating you? 
 Isn't it disrespectful for man to beat his wife?&equo; 
 The answer to that of course is &bquo;no&equo;; because honour, pride and ego are always assumed to be male. 
 Married women may sometimes feel that they share the Izzat of their family but they are aware that in reality Izzat belongs to the men of the family. 
 A wife's role is to nurture this Izzat and bring up her children so that they too understand and respect it. 
 It was here presumably that the Pathan woman had erred. 
 But to succeed in this particular role is if anything more difficult in Britain than it was in Pakistan. 
 Often a mother can understand her daughter's needs, if not in detail at least in broad terms, and at the same time she knows that these needs are in conflict with traditional honour and respectability. 
 What it is like for a daughter in these circumstances is described by Afshan Begum (a young Muslim woman who grew up in Britain) in her thesis Adolescent Muslim girls in British Schools . 
 The relationship between the Muslim girl and her mother is a very important one. 
 Often on coming from school tired, she takes consolation in the fact that her mother seems content and happy in her role &mdash; maybe there is a chance she will be too&hellip; parents often have few outside contacts&hellip; the mother especially tries to obtain most of her emotional satisfaction from her children. 
 The demands on the children are increased if the father spends a great deal of his leisure time with his men friends&hellip; 
 Girls often become very close to their mothers, consequently the last thing they want to do is to bring any form of unhappiness to their lives. 
 For a Muslim girl trapped in this situation, running away from home is only a painful last resort: 
 She has to think of her younger sisters, her father may clamp down on what little freedom they had previously. 
 Not only will her mother feel immense unhappiness about the action her daughter has taken but there is also the chance that her father may take unpleasant measures and throw harsh accusations at her for not having brought up her daughter properly. 
 It will be considered her mother's fault not only by her husband but by the community also. 
 Family honour and pride, which are so easily upset by a woman's actions, are far less easily affected by a man's errors. 
 A married man's promiscuity, for example, leaves his family Izzat in impeccable condition. 
 Many of the Muslim women I spoke to told me that their husbands were unfaithful to them usually with white women (see for example p. 123 of &bquo;Sisters in Struggle&equo;). 
 This letter written to the Daily Jang , an established Urdu newspaper printed in Britain, shows how the family responds to a man's promiscuity. 
 I am twenty years old and have been educated in Britain. 
 At eighteen I had taken three &bquo;O&equo; levels and 2 &bquo;A&equo; levels in secretarial subjects. 
 I very much wanted to continue with my studies but had to get married in accordance with my parents' wishes. 
 A few months after my marriage, I was told by my in-laws that, following the teachings of Islam, I would have to obey them in every way. 
 This meant that I couldn't lead my own life at all; when I complained about this to my husband he laughed it off. 
 Later I found out that my husband was being unfaithful to me. 
 When I spoke about this problem to my parents-in-law they only laughed. 
 Eventually, when I was sure of my husband's adultery, I left him, taking my one-year-old daughter. 
 Though I respect the teachings of Islam I don't understand how there can be one law for men and another for women. 
 While I was supposed to be at the beck and call of not only my husband but even his parents, his going around with other women was just taken for granted. 
 In contrast, if a married woman were unfaithful to her husband she might have to die for Izzat to be restored. 
 Once Izzat is tainted a woman can do very little about it. 
 In Pakistan, family feuds are fought out between men. 
 They drag on from generation to generation and emigration to Britain makes very little difference. 
 The women watch in silence or, as chattels, suffer the consequences. 
 Take the experience of Jamila, a girl from a very rural part of Azad Kashmir. 
 Her family had come to Bradford when she was about fourteen. 
 At sixteen they had her married to a cousin who lived about a mile away. 
 Soon after, her husband's family in Pakistan and her own family there were torn apart by a feud. 
 Someone had backed out of a marriage and family honour had been damaged. 
 Word of the feud arrived in Britain with astonishing speed. 
 There were beatings up in Bradford and brawls in Accrington. 
 At the time Jamila had been married, her husband's brother had also been married to a girl named Zahira. 
 The four of them lived in one house with the father of the two men. 
 After the feud he refused to allow Jamila to visit her parents. 
 She used to spend her whole day locked in a basement room with her sister-in-law and the four young children they had between them. 
 The husbands worked upstairs in the shop the family owned. 
 A friend who used to visit them occasionally told me what conditions were like: 
 It was very damp in the cellar. 
 They sat by the fire all the time. 
 It was not that they were there as a punishment, just that the cellar was their living room (a common arrangement in the back-to-backs of Bradford where most Asian families live). 
 Jamila said that her husband was a good man, he didn't beat her, but she was unhappy because she was never allowed out to visit her parents and brother and sister. 
 Most of the day Jamila and Zahira chatted to each other. 
 Sometimes they knitted beautiful cardigans with patterns similar to fair-isle. 
 But they were depressed and demoralised. 
 They did the cooking between them, but the food was meagre and monotonous. 
 The kitchen was a stone room off the cellar. 
 It was very cold and damp and was completely under the house with no windows. 
 It had an ancient cooker and sink. 
 There was a high wall round the house and there was a yard. 
 Jamila and Zahira were allowed into the yard to hang their washing but they couldn't sit there chatting. 
 They were lucky because they had each other. 
 They seemed devoted to each other. 
 Their main pleasure seemed to be in the beautiful garments they made for each other and for their children. 
 Making clothes for each other is a traditional pleasure for Pakistani women. 
 It is a physical demonstration of the closeness of the joint family. 
 In Britain, Pakistani women continue to enthuse over the fashions in Salwar Kamiz  which reach London from Pakistan, usually via Bradford. 
 What is often dismissed rather contemptuously as baggy trousers and tunic by English people exists in fact in a variety of styles. 
 Older Kashmiri women stick to the traditional Kashmiri form where the Kamiz  (or the Kurta  as it is called in Kashmir) is rather long, usually with a distinct waist, and the trousers are full, almost bulbous, with a deep and stiff cuff at the ankle. 
 Teenage girls or young wives like Jamila and Zahira try out the new fashions coming in from Pakistan. 
 What was the latest style to arrive in London, I asked three young Muslim women from Mirpur who live in a North London suburb. 
 &bquo;Just now,&equo; they told me &bquo;it is the Garara  (trousers which flare from just above the knee) and quite a short Kamiz  to go with it and of course a Dupatta  (a long light scarf) in georgette in an exactly matching colour&equo;. 
 These three were lighthearted girls, always laughing and joking together in loud, unselfconscious voices. 
 Each was the sister-in-law of the other and they lived in suburban semis on adjacent streets. 
 Fazila and Salima attended English classes but Ruksana was forbidden to by her father-in-law who thought she had too much to do in the house. 
 She was in fact not only a housewife but a homeworker, sewing blouses at 35p a piece. 
 She made between 70 and 90 blouses a week which, despite the low rate of pay, compares well with what she might have got as a part-time worker in a sweat shop, the most likely alternative. 
 &bquo;If I get lonely,&equo; she told me &bquo;I ring up Fazila and Salima and they come and help me with my sewing.&equo; 
 I had arranged to meet them at Salima's house, but when I got there she told me that the other two were at Ruksana's place. 
 She would take me there but could I wait while she changed her clothes. 
 When she returned she was dressed in plain creamy pink trousers flared all the way, a short Kamiz  of the same colour but with a pattern of small gold stars and a matching Dupatta . 
 The Kamiz  material was called Rathkirani or queen of the night. 
 Any young woman may enjoy following the latest fashions, but for Pakistani women there is a difference in their attitude to clothes. 
 Unlike western fashion clothes, whose form and variations are dependent on business interests, these Pakistani garments are created especially for the wearer by a joint effort of the women of the family. 
 They are enjoyed in a sense by the whole family. 
 This is a characteristic of all Indian cultures. 
 In my own family in India, often enough saris are bought for me by my father or mother. 
 I wear them for my own enjoyment but equally for theirs. 
 A young woman going to buy material for her Salwar Kamiz in Bradford or Newham would almost invariably be accompanied by her mother or husband or cousin or at least a friend. 
 They would go to an Indian or Pakistani shop, since the sort of cloth needed is not easily available in ordinary department stores. 
 You don't go in and say &mdash; I want three yards of this. 
 You talk to the man you are buying it from and he really takes trouble over you. 
 You can take your time, touch the material, hold it up against you, take it to the door and look at it. 
 They don't think you are going to steal it, and they never tell your children off if they touch things or run in and out of the hanging displays. 
 When you have bought the material, if you own a machine you make it up with help from everyone else in your family. 
 Gina Skelton, an English school teacher, described to me how women in a traditional Muslim family made a Kamiz for her. 
 I had some material and they said they would make it up into a Kamiz for me, so next time I went there I took along a garment that fitted me. 
 We laid it out on the floor and they measured it up. 
 The two girls who were near my age cut the material. 
 They asked me how I wanted the neck and slits. 
 Everyone took an interest. 
 The mother watched, the little sister watched and the men came in now and then and offered advice. 
 Salwar Kamiz is like a national dress of Punjab, worn both by the Muslims of Pakistan and Hindus and Sikhs of East Punjab in India. 
 There are differences of style and certain colours are favoured by one group more than by the others but these differences are small. 
 The symbolic meaning of the clothes is the same for all Punjabis. 
 The Dupatta (or Chunni  as Hindus and Sikhs call it) is the most obviously symbolic part of a woman's clothes. 
 Its function is basically to cover a woman's hair and hide the shape of her breasts but it can be worn in a variety of ways, draped round the top half of her body and head, folded over her chest and hanging over her shoulders or loosely placed round her neck. 
 The way she wears it shows to the righteous and inquisitive observers always present in Asian communities just how modest she is. 
 In Pakistan, &bquo;if you see a girl with her Dupatta pushed up and her limbs in a relaxed position, standing and talking to boys, people passing will go on staring and start whispering among themselves &mdash; &bquo;Where is her modesty!&equo; or, &bquo;what is going on there!&equo; 
 They'll turn their heads and stare.&equo; 
 In Britain the attitude remains the same but the Dupatta is not quite so essential. 
 Sometimes it has to be abandoned for convenience or because of a changed lifestyle. 
 As Sabra, a woman in her forties, told me &bquo;If I go out I usually do have my Dupatta round me, but at work I can't wear it in case it gets caught up in the machines, so I just wear a scarf on my head when I leave the house &mdash; something is needed to save one's Izzat&equo;. 
 Wearing a Dupatta over one's head is also a sign of respect for elders (and for God: a Sikh woman entering a Gurdwara  (Sikh temple) always covers her head with a Dupatta). 
 A new bride is expected to cover her head in the presence of her parents-in-law and older brothers-in-law. 
 Whether she does this or not depends, in Britain, on her own personality and on the attitude of her parents-in-law. 
 Many women I spoke to hardly bothered with a Dupatta indoors while others told me in whispers that they wore it only because their mothers-in-law insisted. 
 The clothes people wear always have a symbolic value but for Asian women this symbolism is extremely formalised. 
 Clothes are made with the family's approval and love but also so that women can look as their families wish to see them &mdash; modest, maternal, self-effacing, or just beautiful on their terms. 
 In addition, clothes must help a woman to fulfil her special roles. 
 One of these roles, given to Asian women by their families and communities, is to be the upholders and preservers of &bquo;our culture&equo;. 
 So what happens if a woman wishes to have her own identity and wear clothes which she alone has chosen? 
 All too often the loving relationships turn bitter, the easy relaxed atmosphere around the subject of clothes becomes one of anger and outrage. 
 It is obvious that more than modesty is at stake. 
 For example, certain materials such as denim and corduroy are considered by orthodox Muslims as unpleasant western stuff, unsuitable for women's clothing. 
 And even outfits which are quite unrevealing can be thoroughly disapproved of. 
 A Sikh girl from Newham, who had bought some clothes with her own money told me how her family had reacted. 
 The first time I wore jeans I didn't dare wear them with a sweater. 
 So I bought a long top, which came well below my hips, to wear with them. 
 I was really scared, the atmosphere became very stiff but nobody said anything. 
 In the evening my mother said &bquo;I don't like these clothes but you can do what you like. 
 You have changed so much, you are a different person from what you used to be.&equo; 
 Another reaction, just as common, was described to me by a Sikh girl from Birmingham: 
 I had bought a pair of trousers and a T-shirt when I had been shopping with a friend. 
 For a long time I just could not face wearing them at home. 
 Then one day I thought I must. 
 I put them on in the afternoon; my mother became very silent. 
 When my father came home all the anger seemed to burst out. 
 He said &bquo;You are never to wear those clothes or I'll throw you out of the house myself.&equo; 
 For the girls this is only one side of the picture. 
 On the other is the atmosphere in schools, with its contempt of anything Indian or Pakistani, which impresses on them that western dress is superior to anything Asian. 
 For parents too (particularly for Sikh parents) there is another aspect of their lives which controls their behaviour in these circumstances. 
 It is the position their family occupies in the hierarchy of their particular community in Britain. 
 Families may be placed high in these hierarchies for a variety of reasons &mdash; because they have brought with them the high status they had in their villages, because they have acquired status by helping new families settle here in the fifties and sixties and kept them in a state of perennial obligation, because they have gone up in class and (as a Sikh woman in Newham told me) &bquo;claim status by pretending to be ultra-devout and criticising others who are less so.&equo; 
 Families with a high status can, if they wish, be free of many traditional restrictions. 
 They are less afraid of what the community will say. 
 But if your family is at the bottom or middle of the community hierarchy it is under constant critical scrutiny and the women particularly have to conform (see Chapter 7). 
 What it is like being married into a &bquo;low status&equo; family in the Midlands was described to me by Surjeet, a teacher in her early twenties who had grown up in Britain. 
 Anything western was frowned upon, so I thought I'd give it a bit of time before I got into my trousers and things. 
 I have never worn Chunni  over my head so I just wore it round my neck. 
 Their mother (i.e. Surjeet's mother-in-law) kept asking me to wear it over my head. 
 I thought after a few times she'll stop and she'll accept it. 
 Then school started and I couldn't wear pyamas  to school so I wore my trousers and tops&hellip; when they saw them they (the other wives) said &bquo;Oh! that won't do! 
 You'll have to wear long tops. 
 If you are wearing trousers you'll have to wear a long top so it doesn't show anything.&equo; 
 But I hadn't brought anything like that with me, all my things were jumpers, so I thought &mdash; let them get used to it. 
 After a few days the eldest brother told me to come. 
 Everybody was around, everybody could hear him. 
 He said &bquo;In future you'll wear pyamas  and Kamiz to school, and I have heard that you don't cover your head, though you have been asked to. 
 When you go to school you will wear a scarf over your hair and you will be taken there every morning by your husband.&equo; 
 I couldn't do anything. 
 The next day I had to wear a long Kamiz over my trousers and have a scarf covering my head &mdash; can you imagine going to school like that&hellip; 
 I refused to be taken to school, but every morning before I left, the other wives would come and put make-up all over my face &mdash;&mdash; bright red lipstick and things. 
 I hate bright colours and never wear make-up but they would not listen. 
 I used to rub it off on the way to school. 
 Why are certain Sikh families so keen on their women wearing make-up (in contrast to Gujerati and Muslim families where western make-up is frowned upon)? 
 It seemed to be a sign of status. 
 One Sikh woman in Southall told me &bquo;My husband likes me to use make-up and I myself like it too. 
 It is a sign of being modern and coming from a good family.&equo; 
 The word &bquo;modern&equo; used in Hindi or Punjabi does not have its English meaning, nor does it mean liberated or even progressive. 
 Among Punjabis in Delhi who are often from the same peasant background as Punjabi immigrants to Britain a &bquo;modern lady&equo; is a &bquo;respectable&equo; urban middle-class woman. 
 And among Punjabi peasants in Britain this Indian urban middle-class smartness, not westernisation, is the thing to aim for. 
 Sikhs also have a special attitude towards saris. 
 Saris are seen as a sign of the wearer being progressive. 
 Women from orthodox families told me that they were not allowed to wear them. 
 One woman who wanted to wear a sari had been told by her husband &bquo;who do you think you are &mdash; Mrs Gandhi? 
 In future you'll stick to Salwar Kamiz as you have always done.&equo; 
 Hierarchy in Asian joint families depends on age and sex but the Sikh women I spoke to all told me that in their families the disciplinarians and rulers were always men. 
 Older women might influence decisions but they could never make them, nor could Hindu and Jain families where the women themselves can sometimes be tyrants over their daughters-in-law, sisters-in-law and even younger brothers-in-law, see p. 118 Chapter 7.) 
 Sikhism is a comparatively new religion and is meant to be a religion of reform which rejects both the caste system and the oppression of women. 
 But in practise, in India, Sikh communities have seized both these concepts and exploited them to the full. 
 In Britain, caste is not really relevant in the same way, it usually gives rise only to petty jealousy (except where intermarriage is concerned). 
 But the women continue to suffer a degrading subjugation. 
 For example after their early years in Britain, Sikh women were allowed to go to work but even after all these years of earning a wage they rarely make, or are consulted about, decisions made about money. 
 After listening to my Sikh sisters' accounts of their lives and relationships and the sensitive Izzat of their men I had the feeling that for Sikhs Izzat is not pride or honour &mdash; it is male ego, pure and simple. 
 But male egos differ. 
 Muslim ones tend to shrivel up at the thought of their women going out to work. 
 Sikh ones have learned to live with the reality of this on their own terms, while Gujerati Hindu male egos appear in general not to suffer from this particular weakness at all. 
 A majority of Gujerati women, particularly those from East Africa, do work or look for work outside the home. 
 In fact, despite the links between the Hindu and Muslim ways of life in the Indian subcontinent, there is no exact analogy for Izzat among Hindus. 
 There is reputation, one's good name and so on, but these are extensions or corollaries of Izzat rather than the thing itself. 
 Most Gujeratis in Britain are from East Africa and have come as refugees, often with large sections of their extended family. 
 The most important controlling factor in these families is not the male ego but hierarchy. 
 However in Britain, with most adult members of the family earning a wage and with working life being separate from family life, hierarchy becomes a very weak concept. 
 In India, Pakistan and East Africa the elders of a family (in-laws, husbands, older cousins, uncles and aunts) did have real power. 
 They had economic power because they had control of the family money; and they had psychological power because the entire outside world was made up of similar families (in East Africa the Africans were socially invisible to Asians) which respected and supported the concept of hierarchy. 
 In Britain, with more adults in the family earning their own wage, this economic power has gone. 
 The psychological power is eroded because although the community can still disapprove of you and make you an outcast if you defy the hierarchy, beyond the community is the world of English people &mdash; an unfriendly world, but it does exist. 
 The elders of these families &mdash; often in a pitiable condition themselves since, being old, they suffer most from being refugees &mdash; are thrown into utter confusion at their powerlessness. 
 They respond with their age-old weapons &mdash; by trying to order their daughters-in-law about, taking away their jewellery, making their lives impossible with hundreds of petty rules, forcing sons and daughters who oppose them into arranged marriages, and, more than anything else, trying to get hold of every pay packet which is brought home. 
 Girls of fourteen and fifteen described to me these conflicts in their own families. 
 Sharmi told me: 
 It was like this &mdash; my uncle and my father came to Britain first and my uncle gave his pay packet to my father, who is older. 
 He used to keep about half of the pay back for himself. 
 If he wanted more he used to get it. 
 When my grandparents came over, the next pay packet from my uncle and my father went straight to my grandfather. 
 He would give &pound;5 to my mum for all the cooking and &pound;5 to my father and &pound;5 to my uncle. 
 When my uncle got married, they started treating my Kaki  (aunt) badly. 
 They would order her about like they did my mum. 
 In the end she had a divorce because she couldn't stand it. 
 (Divorce here means that the uncle and aunt left the grandparents' house and started living separately.) 
 My mum stuck it out. 
 Then my third uncle got married. 
 In the first few weeks they treated his wife nicely. 
 Then they took her pay packet away; they would give her only &pound;5 and she had to go to her sisters and borrow money for her clothes and things. 
 Then after two or three months she had had enough so she didn't give her pay packet in at all. 
 Then the trouble really started! 
 My grandparents really hated her. 
 Now my uncle and aunt have moved out and so have we. 
 We just couldn't stick it. 
 So my grandparents live alone. 
 It was after we left them that my father opened his own bank account. 
 Not all families live in this complete unit. 
 In the family Shanta married into, the head of the family was her husband's cousin, and it was he who made the rules: 
 I kept my job for three months after I was married. 
 All the money I earned in that period my husband's cousin took away from me. 
 He gave me 50p at a time for my fares and lunch. 
 Sometimes I had to manage on that for a week. 
 Sometimes two weeks. 
 Most days I'd go without food till I came home to cook the evening meal. 
 If I asked for money from my husband he would talk of all the expenses, of how much it cost the family to keep me. 
 I asked him why he had decided to marry me. 
 Hadn't he realised that if he married a girl she had to eat? 
 That cousin and his wife were against me and my husband was frightened of them. 
 His cousin would say that I was no good, that a girl who had lost her father like me could never be any good. 
 When I came home late after working overtime they'd say, &bquo;she is not a good woman we must not keep her in our house.&equo; 
 At the same time they wanted the money which I earned. 
 I used to work in a factory making toy guns. 
 These are not exceptional &bquo;cases&equo;. 
 After all, most of the Gujerati women I spoke to I met through English classes they attended, through workmates and mutual friends, not through social workers and community workers. 
 Gujerati families which live as joint families in Britain and do not have, or have never had, this strict but uneasy hierarchy must be few and far between. 
 The women I spoke to were almost always subsidiary wage earners; the money they brought in was essential for survival but was not the main wage of the family and their jobs were often far more unpleasant than their husband's. 
 Many of them were sweat-shop workers, for example, while the men in their families might have white collar jobs or be shopkeepers. 
 In most cases these families are poor, but they have brought with them the petit-bourgeois values of financially better-off days, and this has led to an apparently unquenchable materialism. 
 This materialism also means that the traditional tyrants, the parents-in-law, are being increasingly regarded by married couples as burdens. 
 They have lost their power and thus their position. 
 In some cases these old people have actually been thrown out, something unheard of in India. 
 Where do these old people go? 
 (More often than not they are women, since many elderly male refugees from East African have died within a few years of coming to Britain.) 
 Their future is very bleak. 
 The way one such woman was treated by the local services department was described in an interview with an Asian social worker (quoted from &bquo;Some Aspects of Social Policy Affecting Asian Women in Britain&equo; by Geeta Amin, presented at the U.K. Asian Women's Conference July 1977): 
 Sometimes I found the odd social worker somewhat racist or maybe so ignorant that he appeared racist. 
 For example, there was a case of an elderly lady, Mrs X, who was living with her son and daughter-in-law. 
 Her son had told her to leave his house. 
 She eventually found her way to the social services department. 
 At first the social worker appeared willing and helpful. 
 He asked my advice and I said she should be found suitable private accommodation. 
 Because of her isolation and loneliness Mrs X (age 68) started visiting the office every week until accommodation was arranged. 
 Once I heard the social worker say quite seriously &bquo;Bloody Paki why doesn't she go home?&equo; 
 The same social worker eventually, quite inappropriately, arranged Part 3 accommodation for Mrs X and they placed her in a residential old people's home. 
 Mrs X stayed there two days and came out. 
 She didn't like it because no one spoke to her and she couldn't eat the food. 
 The social worker complained bitterly about the fact that Mrs X had left the home, and told her off. 
 Mrs X had no idea what she had done wrong &mdash; I eventually came to know of this situation and arranged accommodation with an Asian family. 
 The Gujerati community is fully aware of cases like that of Mrs X. Scandals such as hers are everybody's business, but while in India or East Africa such situations would not have been tolerated, and sons would be forced to take their mothers back, in Britain the community looks on in fascinated horror but does nothing. 
 Perhaps people realise that in England these women are ultimately powerless, so they feel there is no point in helping them, or perhaps they think that the sons are to a certain extent justified, or may be it is just a matter of people not having the time or energy to do anything about it. 
 Perhaps it is a sort of demoralisation, not surprising considering the misfortunes which have wracked the East Asian communities now in Britain &mdash; first their years of suffering associated with their expulsion from Africa, then their experiences at the hands of racist British authorities who tried to keep them out of Britain, and finally the day-to-day racism which they have faced in Britain as refugees. 
 They have come through it all with courage and resilience but the community support structures have been ruptured and have not yet been re-established &mdash; and perhaps never will be in the same way. 
 The women who spoke to me often had an intense nostalgia for East Africa. 
 &bquo;I have known such a life&hellip; the days seemed to be longer, the air sweeter than it can ever be in England&hellip; 
 I had servants who did everything. 
 I used to be proud. 
 We had servants. 
 Here it is we who are servants.&equo; 
 For some of them their changed lives had brought a realisation of what their roles as women had been in the past. 
 In East Africa many of us had servants &mdash; in many homes even children were left with African &bquo;boys&equo;. 
 The women had nothing to do but flaunt their prosperity. 
 The house was left to servants. 
 The ladies would visit one another, sometimes getting together to cook delicacies in vast quantities, helping each other with the minute tasks of the home. 
 That was what life was like. 
 When they went out women would flaunt the prosperity of their families. 
 Here, in Britain too, some people try to do that, though for most of us it isn't easy since we have no prosperity. 
 Still you do see it. 
 If you go to Wembley on Saturday morning you will see women with wide Jari  bordered saris with gold embroidery, with necklaces and bangles &mdash; all gold &mdash; and of course they don't wear a coat because the full splendour of their clothes must be revealed &mdash; on their feet a pair of decorative Chappals  &mdash; however cold it might be. 
 They are not bothered about the weather or the customs of the country they are in. 
 Their personalities and identities? 
 The question does not arise. 
 They are possessions and their husbands think that is as it should be. 
 That is how it was in East Africa, after all. 
 Their husbands think that it is natural for a wife to go out and flaunt her husband's prosperity and her family's worth &mdash; that is their tiny horizon. 
 That happiness has some other meaning, other sources, is not recognised. 
 It is true these bright galleons do sail on the high streets of Wembley on Saturday afternoons, and some will continue to do so for many years to come &mdash; but not all. 
 Those who will continue to do so will be there of their own free will as status bearers of the nuclear family, a role common enough among English women, but not as possessions. 
 Because that role is finished now for East African women. 
 They have begun a new life as workers. 
 As for the Gujerati joint family it looks as though nothing can save it now. 
 When nuclear family segments break off from the joint family for one reason or another, the values of the joint family nevertheless continue to plague them. 
 The maintaining of the male ego in perfect condition remains an essential activity of the nuclear family. 
 For example when, as a journalist, I visited couples in their homes to ask about local events, my conversations with women would often be interrupted by their husbands holding up their hands in the direction of their wives and saying in the most matter of fact way &bquo;Be quiet,&equo; and then turning to me and saying &bquo;There is no point in asking my wife. 
 She does not know. 
 She is not educated.&equo; 
 In most cases these wives were literate and well informed, but they would smile politely and agree with their husbands. 
 When I spoke to some of these women alone much later I asked them why Asian women often reacted like this; their answers were that it was good for a man's Izzat. 
 At the same time the wife's role was to serve, and this modest withdrawal was as it were a part of the service. 
 Even in the nuclear family, women told me that certain jobs should never be done by a man, they were not Izzat wali kam  (i.e. jobs of honour) or they were not manly, and predictably these tasks included almost all household chores. 
 The question of a couple being happy or unhappy did not really seem to arise. 
 But a marriage could be smooth and peaceful, and many were, as long as the man carried out his duties towards his wife and a woman was submissive to her husband. 
 As a Muslim woman from Jhelum explained to me, in Islam a man can marry four times but according to Islam it is his duty to look after each of his wives and treat them honourably. 
 &bquo;My husband has married only once,&equo; she told me &bquo;but he has forgotten that he has any duties.&equo; 
 An East African Asian Hindu women told me about a man's responsibilities (her husband was carrying them out very successfully, she said) &bquo;I think it is a man's fault if his wife is backward. 
 It is a man's responsibility to educate himself but also to educate his wife and children.&equo; 
 Only a few women were on equal terms with their husbands and they recognised their relationships as exceptional. 
 One of them, a Sikh woman in her late forties, encouraged me to write about those duties which a husband should fulfil. 
 &bquo;It is up to a man,&equo; she said &bquo;to make a marriage a source of peace or misery, because the man has power; our women usually have none.&equo; 
 Of her own marriage she said &bquo;Sometimes I forget that we are husband and wife. 
 We can say anything to each other. 
 We are so close so equal. 
 We seem just like two friends.&equo; 
 WORK OUTSIDE THE HOME 
 &bquo;Next time I won't cry, I'll make you cry&equo; 
 We had a shop in Nairobi and came here when we got our vouchers in 1971. 
 After coming here I worked for four months in a sweet factory in Stratford. 
 The work was very hard and we were paid only &pound;13 a week. 
 We had to make a ring out of peanut dough. 
 You were paid depending on how many trayfuls you were able to make, 24 or 28. 
 But I could never really make enough. 
 One day I had an argument with the forelady. 
 She said &bquo;You must work faster or it won't do!&equo; 
 I said &bquo;These hands I have got, they are hands not a machine!&equo; 
 Then she said &bquo;I won't have you answering back, you will be given your cards, you'll be sacked.&equo; 
 I said &bquo;O.K., I can only work as much as I can physically, no more.&equo; 
 So she said &bquo;We'll throw you out.&equo; 
 After that for some months I was unemployed. 
 Then I got a job in a laundry. 
 Asian women are the worst off of all British workers. 
 They are at the bottom of the heap. 
 They come unprepared, easy victims to unscrupulous employers. 
 They don't know the language so their choice of jobs is limited to the worst and least skilled; they don't know their rights so they can be intimidated, they don't have much information about other, better off workers so they can be paid poverty-line wages. 
 They are black so they need not be treated even like women, but more like animals. 
 And if they ever ask for help against their employers, their chances of getting it are usually (despite Grunwick, see later in this chapter) known to be small. 
 Neither their husbands and families, nor white trade unionists nor middle-class Asians are keen to help them. 
 For middle-class Asians their working-class sisters do not really exist. 
 At a recent meeting of middle-class Asian women gathered to organise a conference of Asian women in Britain, I mentioned the word working-class. 
 &bquo;What does it mean?&equo; one of these exquisitely saried ladies asked with a slight transatlantic drawl, &bquo;surely in this day and age we all work. 
 We don't live on unearned income or own stocks and shares.&equo; 
 Several others agreed with her. 
 Among Indians and Pakistanis, they told me rather severely, there is no class system as there is among English people. 
 One tentative voice asked if I meant &bquo;deprived women like those of the East End&equo;, but this too was slapped down by others &mdash; &bquo;in these days of inflation, aren't we all deprived?&equo; 
 After visiting the cool, elegant (suburban) drawing rooms of rich Asians one might wonder just how these women are materially deprived. 
 They may, as in the case of Mrs H- &mdash;, have an Asian woman servant to do &bquo;all the kitchen work, cleaning the pantry, fridge, floors and preparing all the Nashta  and everything.&equo; 
 In the last ten years, Mrs H. tells me, she has always had a servant, because without one, social duties, cooking, and housework, even with the most up-to-date equipment, proved too exhausting. 
 For the house (cleaning) I have somebody else. 
 Formerly I had an English couple who used to come every day, that lasted seven or eight years then they got too old. 
 Now I have a girl who comes from &mdash; Indonesia? 
 No, Philippines, that's it! 
 She has two days off from her family where she's working, so she comes those two days. 
 Now my children are grown up so I don't need constant help. 
 The proportion of Asian women in Britain who are as well-off as Mrs H. is minute, but they are often the ones who are prominent on race-relations bodies and community relations sub-committees. 
 It is they who hold dialogue with establishment spokesmen, sitting side by side with white experts and a few Asian men on the &bquo;problems&equo; and &bquo;needs&equo; of Asian women. 
 They rarely cross the paths of working-class Asians except in the course of their occasional investigations. 
 Their lives are rarely laid side by side for comparison with those of working women &mdash; women like Shahida or Prabhaben (Chapter 7) who work all day in laundries, component factories and sweat-shops &bquo;till my feet are like bricks and my arms aching&hellip; at night it used to be agony till I fell asleep.&equo; 
 In the brief moments of respite they get they sometimes wonder, like Champaben, a homeworker; 
 Is this what life is for, is this why my parents brought me up with so much love and care? 
 Ask them if they are working-class or middle-class, and they tell you &bquo;This is our fate, sister, to work, to slave, in Pakistan too some of us had to do the hard, hard work on the fields. 
 Here it is a different kind of work, we are more lonely and in some ways the work is harder, but for us women as you know, life itself is very hard&hellip; 
 Yes, maybe there are some women who don't have to work, their husbands are well off and love them, but they often stay indoors all day and that is not nice. 
 Women with servants in Britain? 
 Really? 
 Are there such women? 
 It must be so since you say. 
 I have never seen them. 
 For Asian women wage labour is a new experience, both baffling and exciting. 
 Baffling because it is all so new and strange, and exciting because it brings the first hint, the first distant suggestion that for women an independent economic identity is possible. 
 Asian women who are wage earners fall into three main groups &mdash; homeworkers, shop assistants and secretaries, and factory and sweat-shop workers. 
 In this chapter I shall write only about women in the last group and their position in the British labour market since very little has been written about them. 
 Before they came to Britain, Asian women from a peasant background were agricultural workers doing as much work on the land as men did. 
 But they did not earn a separate wage, they lived in effect in a mainly cashless society. 
 This society seemed self-contained; those who felt exploited could easily identify the enemy &mdash; the landlord or money lender. 
 Whatever organisation was possible at village level was usually directed against him. 
 The idea of comparing wages did not arise because (in the small holdings of Punjab, for example) the question of wages hardly ever arose. 
 When people from this background find themselves in the middle of an industrial set-up, it is not easy for them to adjust their values or frames of reference, just as people from an industrial society, used to individual wages and jobs, would feel confused if suddenly thrust into a peasant society. 
 Surinder, a Sikh woman, explained to me what it had been like coming to Britain in the sixties and finding a job in a sweat-shop soon after. 
 It used to be amazing at the end of the week to be paid, to have money in your hand for the work you had done. 
 It was very little money really, but to me in those days it seemed like a lot. 
 Money in this society means quite different things and that really hit me. 
 At home, money meant food or perhaps, if one had saved a lot, more land, but here the shops were full of the most amazing commodities and getting money at the end of the week seemed to suggest that these things were within one's reach. 
 For a long time I never realised how badly paid and overworked I was, but what made me feel bad in those days was the rudeness and lack of respect with which I and other Asian women were treated by the supervisors. 
 Now I have begun to understand, bad pay, rotten conditions and this insufferable contempt shown to us, it is a part of the same picture. 
 What makes this understanding, this adjustment even more difficult are the immense problems of everyday life in Britain &mdash; how to get to work, how to sign your name and so on. 
 But once these hurdles are overcome, women soon stop harking back to their village background and comparing everything with it. 
 The next stage is when they begin to think of themselves as workers in Britain and compare their lives with those of other workers, black and white. 
 More and more women from a peasant background are now reaching this stage &mdash; a fact which can't be ignored by employers. 
 The &bquo;docile&equo;, easily exploited workforce is gradually becoming more defiant and angry. 
 As a personnel manager in a Bradford mill put it &bquo;Asian ladies are so well behaved. 
 They have no complaints, they complete their training period very accurately and they are really good. 
 We are very happy to have them. 
 But lately these ladies in the Spinning department, they seem to be rather odd. 
 They can be rude. 
 It concerns me because it is unusual for an Asian lady to be rude, to answer back, to be a chatter-box.&equo; 
 If that is the case with ex-peasants, these &bquo;reactions from experience&equo; for women from an urban background, say from Kenya, are different. 
 They have never worked before outside their home or family shop but the concepts of a commercial society are quite familiar to them. 
 Those of them from East Africa were, before they came here, middle-class or lower middle-class. 
 Because of this, their expectations are often higher. 
 They know nothing about the means of organising, nor are they particularly militant, but they see quickly and quite clearly that they are being exploited. 
 Prabhaben, a woman in her thirties, described to me the conditions at the laundry where she works. 
 (For the full interview with Prabhaben, see Chapter 7, &bquo;Sisters in Struggle&equo;.) 
 Of about 50 employees, 40 are Asian women. 
 You ask about discrimination? 
 There is a colour bar, that is for certain. 
 First the pay; Indians get less. 
 Oh yes, the whites get more. 
 We get &pound;28 a week whether we are sitting at a machine all day or operating heavy presses. 
 The white women get &pound;32. 
 Upstairs where the machines are it is terribly hot. 
 It is very difficult to work there. 
 Almost all the workers upstairs are women, there are only two men and they are pensioners. 
 The women's salary is very low. 
 The pay in laundries is very poor, they can't afford to pay more, that is what they say. 
 In many ways I am better off than the others, I work downstairs. 
 Upstairs the women suffer, they really suffer. 
 They are paid low salaries and everything is worse for them, they have to face the insults of supervisors. 
 These supervisors are all English women. 
 The trouble is that in Britain our women are expected to behave like servants, and we are not used to behaving like servants and we can't. 
 But if we behave normally like saying a few words to each other, the supervisors start shouting and harassing us. 
 Or if they go to the toilet and take just a little longer. 
 Of course white women do that too but the supervisors don't notice them. 
 They complain about us Indians to the manager. 
 Our women suffer so much, but usually they don't come out and complain. 
 They don't know English but it is more than that. 
 It is that all your life you have been soft and this treatment shocks and stuns you. 
 But one or two of us have begun to speak up. 
 Veena who lives in Manor House, she is good. 
 She doesn't take any rubbish and there are one or two others like her. 
 At Prabhaben's laundry there is no union. 
 That is the norm in the small workplaces which employ Asian women. 
 Conditions in these places are often not only uncomfortable but unsafe. 
 The factory inspectorate has never heard of their existence. 
 These work-places belong to two main types of firms &mdash; largish firms in traditionally low wage industries such as laundries or electrical component factories or sweet factories, or sweat-shops &mdash; where the employer may be a family firm or a self-made man, fiercely anti-union, determined to compete with bigger firms if necessary, by exploiting his workers. 
 As far as personalities are concerned, the second type of employer is frequently the sort of man who forms the backbone of the ultra-right in Britain and is usually a racist in the most extreme and overt sense. 
 The work offered is often seasonal, like making Christmas decorations or making and packing anything from toy guns to cheap electric heaters. 
 The attitude to the Asian women employed is that they should be hired and fired as needed. 
 Before Asian women began working in large numbers, their jobs were done by Asian men or white women. 
 Even now, many factories employ varying proportions of these two other groups alongside Asian women, but a white man would almost never work in such a place except as a supervisor. 
 Spiralynx (1933) is a bedding factory in East London. 
 The factory, in Russell Road, Canning Town, was acquired in the 1940s by Montague Goodman, the managing director of MG Furniture Reproductions Ltd, a small factory in South Hackney. 
 He also acquired factories in Hanbury Street and Rowland Street, E1, and obtained the patent for manufacturing spiral linked mattresses. 
 In the 1950s and 60s he took over or formed a number of firms &mdash; Sun Resta Ltd, Multi Resta Ltd, Sleepy Valley Ltd etc, and one, Multi Spring Ltd in Mitcham Surrey, which according to its headed note paper are &bquo;contractors to HM Government&equo;. 
 Government bodies and local authorities are prohibited by legislation from dealing with companies paying below the agreed minimum wage. 
 But the existence of a group where the products from one factory may be marketed in another allows for the possibility of products being internally sold. 
 Between 1968 and 1970 the factories from Hanbury Street and Rowland Street were transferred to Russell Road, Canning Town. 
 By 1975 80% of the workforce were Asian and 15% were women. 
 The conditions inside the factory were described in a report by the Newham Careers Office made on 17 October 1975: 
 I can only say I was shocked and disgusted by the conditions in the factory, which were seen to constitute definite health and safety hazards. 
 All the machines were archaic with no proper safeguards, e.g. guillotines, spring-making machines and other similar machines with a cutting edge had no automatic stopping device. 
 In the metal and spring-making department the floor was littered with pieces of metal, coils of wire and shavings; the surface of the floor was greasy and the premises generally filthy. 
 The machines in the spring department gave off choking fumes and a grey pall seemed to hang over the department&hellip; about 90 per cent of the work force are coloured, many of whom cannot speak English. 
 I counted only six white workers in the factory, half of which seemed to be of below average intelligence. 
 The total work force equals 150, it was noted that the workers all looked rather miserable and depressed and the working atmosphere was not at all pleasant. 
 I was not allowed to speak to the workers&hellip; it seems that their trade union membership is not allowed by the management. 
 What kind of people constitute the management of Spiralynx? 
 David Goodman, son of Monty and also a director, gave this account in an interview (conducted by the staff of Canning Town Community Development Project) in January 1975. 
 &bquo;I am talking of people of our calibre; two or three men, a couple of hundred staff, good solid firms that normally don't go bankrupt&hellip; 
 They live out their business lives well, never become millionaires but they are solid citizens.&equo; 
 Since 1964 the Furniture unions have tried three times to organise the workers of Spiralynx; each time a small number of workers have joined a union, the management have found out and workers have been dissuaded from joining. 
 In the last attempt, in 1975, what made unionisation especially difficult was that, although most of the workers were then Asians, they spoke different languages. 
 The workforce was in fact exceptionally fragmented. 
 These attempts at unionisation failed completely. 
 In fact the main lessons of these attempts seems to be to those outside Spiralynx &mdash; that organising from the outside is impossible. 
 Workers in a place like Spiralynx can only be organised if there is an explosion of anger and discontent inside the factory strong enough for a large number of workers to take a stand, at the risk of losing their own jobs. 
 It is only after this that the supporting role of outside sympathisers can be useful. 
 The attitude of outside well-wishers has too often been like that of a left-wing friend of mine who asked in the early days of the Grunwick strike &bquo;Who is doing the organising there?&equo; &mdash; as though the workers were just so much raw material waiting to be organised. 
 No one, least of all Asian women workers themselves, would claim that they are highly militant or strong. 
 What they have been in the past, in the face of their grim working lives, is resilient. 
 They have refused to despair, accepting quite stoically what they have been given. 
 Now this stoicism is changing. 
 Partly it is changing because women are getting more familiar with the industrial scene and partly because of the tremendous impact and influence of the strike at Grunwick Photoprocessing. 
 That strike has proved for always that Asian women workers can be strong, resourceful and courageous, that they can stand up, face the world and demand their rights. 
 In Britain there has for many years been a sub-proletariat, a sub-class of the working class who are far worse off than the main body, consisting of sweat-shop workers and homeworkers, people who are treated by employers as though they have no rights at all. 
 Before Asian immigrants came to Britain, these jobs were done by previous waves of immigrants in certain areas (like the East End of London). 
 But elsewhere in the country in general they were usually done by indigenous working-class women whose mothers had often had similar jobs before them. 
 Now that Asian women have taken over their positions, they move upwards, even though only slightly upwards, in the labour hierarchy. 
 But this means more than just one group replacing another. 
 The change is a tremendous one. 
 At the bottom of the hierarchy of the production structure, where spirits are assumed to be crushed, have come a new army of workers &mdash; fresh, vivacious and increasingly angry. 
 Their expectations are high because many of them have, until recently, had a middle-class life and outlook (ie. the East African Asians) and because, unlike the British working class, they have not been ground down and prepared for their jobs by the British education system. 
 Apart from this, their race, and often their language, gives them a solidarity which white workers can only rarely achieve. 
 If they win their battles, as one trade union organiser put it (while describing Grunwick) &bquo;it will be a new dimension in trade union activity&equo;. 
 In other words it would mean that battles could be won which people have previously thought could not even be fought. 
 At this lowest level of British industry it is almost as though struggles are not expected to occur, let alone be won. 
 Trade unions, it they are involved at all, are not meant to be militant. 
 This is because of the structure of trade unions themselves in Britain. 
 They are a concession, a compromise between workers and employers and an accepted unit in the capitalist structure. 
 Not surprisingly, the unions or union branches of the most powerful workers (ie. those who have the greatest effect on capital) are in general the strongest. 
 The unions or union branches organising workers less crucial to capital are weaker, till at the lowest stage of trade union structure the union becomes just a formality. 
 It is never expected to take up demands or make a real effort to change conditions. 
 In fact it often acts just as a damper, the first hurdle workers have to overcome. 
 (Dozens of of strikes of black workers illustrate this; for details see issues of the magazine Race Today .) 
 It isn't often that unions have taken up issues such as racial or sex discrimination or unfair dismissal, and when workers have come out on strike they have usually been slow and reluctant to make these strikes official. 
 But while union hierarchy is crucial in the amount of support workers get, it is counterbalanced by another important factor, the political complexion of the union branch at local level. 
 Take the cases of two well-known strikes involving women &mdash; the strikes at Trico and at Electrolux. 
 The first received full support of the trade union, the second did not. 
 The reason was that at Trico the district committee (which in the engineering union structure is a very important body) was dominated by the left while at Electrolux it was controlled by the right. 
 Obviously the same is true on the question of racism. 
 Branches dominated by the left are less likely to be racialist, but unfortunately in many areas with large immigrant populations, like Leicester and Loughborough, the important union bureaucracies are controlled by the right wing. 
 In these areas, for black workers, conventional industrial struggles must be preceded by a battle with the racists in the trade union. 
 That is what happened at both Imperial Typewriters in Leicester and at Mansfield Hosiery in Loughborough. 
 Imperial Typewriters was a large firm, but again, like Grunwick, Spiralynx and so many others, marginal to British capital. 
 Conditions there were the sort with which Asian women everywhere in Britain are familiar. 
 Two aspects were described by women workers interviewed in Race Today : 
 I assemble motors in the store department. 
 When I first started work here I had to make 14 motors per hour. 
 But then they raised the target to 16 then to 18 and so on. 
 Now it is 22. 
 To work at that speed we can't even drink a cup of tea. 
 We have no official tea break but sometimes one of us goes out and gets tea for the others. 
 But then if the foreman sees, he starts complaining about us in front of all the other workers, and even the supervisor, saying we always waste time and talk too much. 
 Anyway, we didn't complain about that. 
 We complained to them about the target. 
 We all said 22 is too high. 
 However hard we work we can never make more than that &mdash; and unless we make more we don't get any bonus. 
 But on top of that if we make less than 22, say 20 or 21, they cut some money from our basic pay&hellip; 
 We are mostly Asians in our section, but our shop steward is a white woman. 
 She doesn't care and the union doesn't care. 
 I pay 11p a week to be a member of the union but I really think it is a waste of hard earned money. 
 Don't get me wrong. 
 I am not against unions but our union is no different from management. 
 I went to our shop steward one day and explained that the 22 target was too high. 
 I also told her that the supervisor had asked us to oil our own machines that morning. 
 Normally our machines are oiled before we come in. 
 I told her that oiling was not our job and that management was always trying to make us do more work for the same pay. 
 She told me not to make a fuss over such a small thing. 
 That is the kind of shop steward she is. 
 This is why we must have our own shop stewards. 
 In this factory there are 1100 of us and yet we only have one Asian shop steward. 
 It doesn't make sense, does it?&hellip; this way we are not represented at all. 
 Finally on 1 May 1974, while other workers in Leicester were demonstrating their militancy with May Day strikes, 39 Asian workers walked out of section 61 at Imperial Typewriters. 
 Of these 39, 27 were women. 
 They had worked at assembling parts into complete typewriters. 
 The women were being paid &pound;18 a week on piece work, the men &pound;25. 
 In addition they were supposed to receive bonus rates after the daily target of 200 machines a day. 
 The company policy had been to speed up the line and the rate of production. 
 The workers in section 61 were angry because they felt, firstly, that the quotas of production allocated to white workers were unfair compared with the quota allocated to them; secondly, because conditions of work were different for Asian workers &mdash; their washing times, lunch breaks and toilet breaks were restricted; and thirdly because, although most of the workers were Asians, the union branch had an overwhelmingly white shop steward's committee (there was only one Asian shop steward) which was not only uninterested in their struggles but actively opposed to them. 
 In the course of their demands to Reg Weaver, the t&amp;gwu factory convenor, the workers from section 61 found out that although they were being paid bonuses on a target of 200 or more they were in fact entitled to bonuses on 168 (an agreement which dated back to 1972 and would have meant &pound;4 a week extra). 
 Within 2 days, 500 more workers joined the 39 people from section 61. 
 They demanded an end to the use of racism by management to divide workers. 
 They called for democratic elections in the trade unions. 
 They stood by their demands for back-dated bonus payments. 
 The company's response was to issue notice to the original 40 that if they didn't return to work they'd all be sacked. 
 In this period the trade union branch's attitude is best expressed by the trade union negotiator himself &mdash; George Bromley JP. 
 &bquo;The workers have not followed the proper dispute procedures, they have no legitimate grievances and it is difficult to know what they want.&equo; 
 Later Bromley spoke to Radio Leicester about the management at Imperial Typewriters, Asian women and race generally: 
 The Imperial management, they are not American-style management at all. 
 I've no brief for management and by and large I don't find many managements very efficient, but I'll say this, Imperial Typewriter management are soft and if we have got a case we have no difficulty in winning it, no difficulty&hellip; 
 Let us take the question of the ladies' toilets which you asked me about. 
 Now this is a reputable firm there are plenty of Factory Acts. 
 No company stops people going to the toilet. 
 This is so ludicrous it is laughable in modern times. 
 What happens here is that if a white lady wants to go to the toilet and she's working on a line, she doesn't ask anyone's permission, she just gets up &mdash; out she goes, powders her nose, has a cigarette, whatever they do &mdash; then comes back. 
 Nobody bothers. 
 Back on the line she goes and work continues. 
 Now some of these Asian ladies, I feel sorry for them, they are strangers, they don't know much about industrial life, they have led a very sheltered life, you know, and when they go to the toilet they go together. 
 If there are 38 of them on the line, 38 go together for ten minutes and then, of course, the line stops. 
 That's when the foreman begins to go in to hook them out. 
 It's not that he wants to stop them going to the toilet, we've got to persuade these people to do it on a stagger basis&hellip; 
 I feel sorry for people that are dumped into a civilisation such as ours and they are taking the sticky end of the stick in these low-rated factories. 
 Because they are semi-skilled they are low rated but they have got to learn to fit in with our ways you know. 
 We haven't got to fit in with theirs. 
 And the way they have been acting, that means they will close factories and people won't employ them &mdash; that's all. 
 The Imperial Typewriters strike was seen by many people as a defeat. 
 The strikers returned to work having won few concessions. 
 But for the women involved it was also a kind of victory. 
 One of them, Shardha Behn, described her feelings in an interview just after the strike (Race Today , Sept 1974): 
 The first day I got back to work, my foreman asked me what I had gained in the last twelve weeks. 
 He was making fun of me I know. 
 But I told him that I had lost a lot of money but had gained a lot of things. 
 I told him I had learnt how to fight against him for a start. 
 I told him he couldn't push me around any more like a football from one job to another. 
 I told him I now knew many things I didn't know before. 
 In the past when I used to get less money in my wage packet I used to start crying at once. 
 I didn't know what else to do. 
 I told the foreman, &bquo;Next time I won't cry, I'll make you cry.&equo; 
 The strike at Imperial Typewriters demonstrated clearly the conflict between the trade union bureaucracy and black workers. 
 Three years later the TUC attitude to black workers, and more specifically black women workers, was shown by its lack of action on such simple and bland recommendations (from the Camden Council for Community Relations) as that the trade union movement should press for compulsory language training at work (ie. in the employer's time, not after hours) or co-operate &bquo;more positively&equo; in agreeing to English classes where the management has taken the initiative, or that there should be &bquo;more positive participation in supporting any industrial action taken by minority group workers in their fight to achieve equal opportunity&equo;. 
 As a Race Today  editorial (in October 1974) put it, &bquo;the section to benefit most from the trade unions are white men over the age of thirty-five. 
 Nowhere is this as clearly illustrated as in the struggles of black workers and in the way in which white workers have aligned themselves with the bureaucracy.&equo; 
 That is still true in 1978. 
 In fact, in many factories all over Britain white workers are not only on the side of trade union bureaucracy but often on the side of the management against their black workmates. 
 But there has been an important exception. 
 In the most important strike of 1976 and 1977 the rank and file of the labour movement have demonstrated their support of black workers. 
 The strike at Grunwick Photoprocessing is exceptional in many ways. 
 Not only are the men and women involved people of remarkable courage and strength, but unlike Imperial Typewriters or Spiralynx it is a strike of black workers in an area well known for its tradition of left wing trade union organisation. 
 Jack Dromey of Brent Trades Council told me: Willesden and Stonebridge (in NW London) used to be known in the 30s as Red Willesden and Red Stonebridge. 
 They have a long tradition of solid trade union organisation. 
 Industrially the area is dominated by light engineering and manufacturing in the major industrial estates of Park Royal, part of East Acton, Wembley trading estate, East Lane Wembley and a number of independent factories scattered throughout the borough. 
 Outside of Dagenham and East London, the home of Fords, it is the biggest centre of industry left in London. 
 A number of the large employers have gone over the last ten or fifteen years but there are still very large industrial complexes. 
 For example, in Park Royal you get traditional strongholds of trade union movement like Park Royal vehicles, which, together with AECs in Southall, is the centre of bus building for British Leyland. 
 Also Brent East has the highest concentration of immigrants of any parliamentary constituency in the country. 
 Not only black immigrants but Irish immigrants as well. 
 You get a number of convenors and shop stewards who are Asian, West Indian or Irish. 
 It is unlike East London, where over the last ten or twenty years the heart has been torn out of manufacturing industry in the docks and with it has gone traditional working-class organisation. 
 Grunwick Photoprocessing could be any factory employing Asians in any part of Britain. 
 In 1973&ndash;74 the firm made a profit of &pound;26,719 after tax; the starting pay of some of the workers was &pound;28 for a 40-hour week. 
 The majority of the 440 workers were Asians. 
 George Ward has described the working conditions in the mail order room up until the move to Dollis Hill in 1976: 
 Conditions at Station House were also far from perfect. 
 The building had no air-conditioning apart from the computer suite itself and since it was almost completely sheathed in plate glass the heat in the summer was almost intolerable. 
 We did not even have our own lavatories; our employees had to go outside our part of the building to use communal facilities. 
 We soon found that some of them were using this for various extra-curricular activities. 
 Complaints were made to us about certain members of our staff (who, incidentally, no longer work for us) going into unoccupied floors to make love. 
 When this came to light we insisted for a few days that employees should seek permission to leave the company premises. 
 This was the origin of the myth that workers had to put their hands up to go to the lavatory. 
 The Scarman Enquiry reported of the physical conditions in the Dollis Hill premises in which the mail order department then moved, that &bquo;save for the mischance with the air-conditioning in a hot summer&equo;, they were &bquo;excellent&equo;. 
 In the early days of the strike Jayaben Desai, perhaps Britain's best known Asian trade unionist, described to me what it had been like when she came to work at Grunwick in the mail order department: 
 At the Dollis Hill factory the conditions were the same as elsewhere at Grunwick. 
 On two sides there were offices for the management and they can watch you and the supervisor or foreman can watch you as well. 
 He moves round and keeps an eye. 
 Everyone would be paid a different wage so no one knew what anyone else was getting. 
 And to encourage people to work they would make them fill in a job-sheet saying how many forms they had booked in. 
 There were occasions when someone did a large number, and they would bring the job-sheet round and show the others and say &bquo;She has done so many, you also must.&equo; 
 Of course the young girls, they sometimes started off very enthusiastic and perhaps did do quite a lot without realising the implications and effect of it but the older women often had trouble keeping up. 
 The older women found it a terrible strain. 
 The Scarman Report commented on the turnover of staff in the mail order department in 1976: &bquo;many of the immigrant workers did not stay for very long: the threat of dismissal must have been an anxiety for many in the workforce. 
 In the period 1 April 1976 to 20 August 1976, 32 left the mail order department. 
 Of these 21 left of their own accord for reasons ranging from incompatibility to pregnancy. 
 11 (3 of them students) were dismissed. 
 During this period the strength of the department was 102. 
 An extrapolation of these figures would indicate an annual turnover of staff from the department as high as 100% &mdash; a disquieting percentage even after allowance for the various factors which may accelerate change in a predominantly female workforce.&equo; 
 Mrs Desai continued: 
 I used to tell my husband about all these problems. 
 He is a union member and he was aware of all the advantages of belonging to a union but somehow for a long time it never occurred to me how to get it all started, how it was possible. 
 Then my job was at one stage to clear payments and complaints. 
 In the evening when the booking and despatch department would start packing up to go, so would I and no one asked me not to. 
 Then one day the foreman came and said &bquo;Mrs Desai, why have you packed up?&equo; 
 I said &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 There was work left over, it is true, but there often was. 
 There was often just too much for me to finish on my own. 
 The foreman said &bquo;Who asked you to pack up?&equo; 
 I said &bquo;No one ever asks me.&equo; 
 He couldn't answer, but the second-in-command at the place appeared and said &bquo;Mrs Desai, I have some work for you.&equo; 
 I said &bquo;I know that, you have your work but I have my work too. 
 I want to know what all the fuss is about. 
 Nobody has told me before to pack up, why are you bringing it up today?&equo; 
 He had no answer, but in the meantime the manager appeared and asked me to come into the office. 
 I thought that I would go in and explain the whole thing to him and explain that there was no point in creating trouble unnecessarily. 
 But before I could say anything he started to shout at me, saying &bquo;Mrs Desai, you can't talk back to me or to Mr Diffy or Mr Mike.&equo; 
 I said &bquo;I am here to tell you something but if you don't want to listen to me I am not going to listen to you either.&equo; 
 He said &bquo;Mrs Desai, don't point at me.&equo; 
 I said &bquo;If you point at me I can point at you.&equo; 
 He said &bquo;I warn you.&equo; 
 I said &bquo;I don't want your warning. 
 I am going to leave this job. 
 I have worked loyally, shown you respect, but I too expect to be treated with respect. 
 You bring me into the office to shout at me and I can't say anything. 
 I just have to listen, I am not going to stand this.&equo; 
 I went out where the rest of the staff were working and I told them &bquo;I am leaving. 
 You all know very well what the management are doing. 
 This has happened to me today, it will happen to you tomorrow. 
 You have to wake up.&equo; 
 I told the manager, &bquo;You misjudge people, you think they are daft. 
 But they are not. 
 Some have problems, some because of their circumstances are working here. 
 But I am not like that. 
 You can't treat me like that. 
 I will prove it to you.&equo; 
 I walked out and my son Sunil was behind me &mdash; he walked out too. 
 That afternoon they had already sacked one boy and four others had walked out in support. 
 I didn't know much about it. 
 But when I walked out I saw them standing outside. 
 They were thinking of doing some violence, they were so angry. 
 I saw them standing in a crowd; they told me &bquo;We want to prove something, show them something.&equo; 
 I said &bquo;You can't prove anything by violence. 
 You need a concrete plan. 
 Otherwise you'll just hurt yourself and end up in jail. 
 Nothing will change.&equo; 
 I suggested forming a union. 
 They asked me, how? 
 I said I didn't know either but between us all we could find out. 
 We all agreed on that. 
 It was Friday, 20 August 1976. 
 On Monday we arrived at the factory with placards we had made demanding a union. 
 We thought, specially the boys, that placards and a demonstration were important. 
 We stood outside the factory and asked workers entering to sign a petition demanding a union. 
 Then went to the Citizen's Advice Bureau (CAB) at Wembley, as my husband had suggested, and asked them for information about how to join a union. 
 It was soon after that that we contacted APEX and the Willesden Law Centre, and got in touch with Jack Dromey. 
 At that stage, says Jack Dromey, the law centre's representative on the Strike Committee: 
 They were as green as grass, they were like a bunch of lost chickens outside the coop. 
 They were so green that they were going to the CAB to find out about unions. 
 Now to be honest if they had come to us first we would have got them into another union the t&amp;gwu or ACTT but having said that, one thing we should knock on the head straight away. 
 Some people have said that if they joined the t&amp;g or ACTT the strike would have been over much quicker. 
 I don't believe it. 
 I don't believe that with any union this company would have been cracked any quicker. 
 Anyway they were in contact with APEX and then they came to see us, that was on a Monday, the same day there were mass meetings at Chapter Road and Cobbold Road. 
 On Tuesday they all got together in the Trades and Labour Hall and they were very excited at that stage. 
 There was a tremendous release of tension, particularly for the people, the women who had been permanent workers as opposed to the students. 
 It was a tremendous relief for them to take a stand in the way they had done. 
 But taking this stand was not easy, particularly for the women. 
 There were at Grunwick a group of exceptional women, women of great dignity and strength of personality like Jayaben Desai and Kalaben Patel who although in no sense &bquo;westernised&equo; had rejected traditional attitudes that women should be submissive and passive. 
 It was they who formed the core of the strikers, persuading and supporting other weaker women. 
 They visited the homes of the women, talked to husbands, fathers and fathers-in-law who did not want them to take part in any struggle, and they urged the women themselves to assert themselves. 
 This was a tremendous task because, as Jayahen Desai told me: 
 Our Gujerati women are often weak, weakened by the acceptance that their life must revolve round dressing up, housework, wearing jewellery and other things like that. 
 Often it does not occur to them that they can speak up, raise their voices in front of people. 
 Personally I don't think it is traditions which are weighing them down but the fact that they have no support at home. 
 Their husbands don't want them to do anything which is not passive, and in the end women end up believing the same. 
 In my case, for example, my husband gives me every help. 
 If I can't read or understand something in the paper he discusses it with me &mdash; about what is happening in the country or the community or about what politics can mean. 
 Few husbands treat their wives like that. 
 All too often husbands actually prevented their wives from coming to the picket line and there were cases where parents-in-law forced women to go on working for the sort of reasons described in Chapter 6. 
 Apart from the purely oppressive aspect &mdash; that these people felt that women must be seen and not heard, that taking part in an industrial struggle was not right for a woman &mdash; there was the undeniable fact that in these families money was desperately needed. 
 Most of them were refugees from East Africa living in substandard conditions and paying exorbitant rents; for them a second income was desperately needed, and going on strike seemed a dangerous business. 
 But the women were changing as well. 
 As Mahmood, the secretary of the strike committee, put it in the tenth month of the strike: &bquo;When the women first joined Grunwick they were just like ordinary women. 
 But now many of them can stand up in front of the gate and talk back to the managing director. 
 If he swears, swear back at him. 
 They can face it, which they wouldn't do before. 
 &bquo;They had come a long way from a meeting in the very early days when Sunil Desai, Jayaben's son and then secretary of the strike committee, had suggested that the men do the picketing and the women make the tea. 
 But according to both Jayaben and Jack Dromey, it was established from that very meeting onwards that the women must play an equal role. 
 Every delegation sent out by the strikers to talk to workers at other factories consisted of two men and two women. 
 I asked Mahmood whether he thought the attitude of the male strikers towards the women had changed at all. 
 He said &bquo;Not all of them have changed. 
 Some of the people who are more involved, like myself, have realised that women are playing as important a role as the men. 
 But on the whole I don't think that most of the men have changed their ideas or attitude that much.&equo; 
 Did they feel that women couldn't be militant? 
 &bquo;No, it is not that, they can see that women are more militant than the men, doing more work on the picket line. 
 But as far as their ideas of women in society goes it hasn't changed &mdash; that women should stay home and do the cooking.&equo; 
 Why was it, I asked Mahmood, that although a majority of workers at Grunwick were women the strike committee consisted (till then) mainly of men? 
 His answer was: 
 The only reason is that we are younger and we have more freedom, we can do what we like. 
 At 2 or 3 hours notice we may have to go to Manchester; the women can't do that. 
 We could go up there and be there a week. 
 The women can't do that, those who are married because they are married and those who are not married because they are not married. 
 Though if you give them enough notice they can do almost anything&hellip; 
 In their personal freedom I wouldn't say they are free like English girls but they are up to a point. 
 When the strike started they were completely different. 
 Since as Jack Droney put it, Brent, with its left-wing trade unionists, &bquo;was a bloody good place for the Grunwick strike to happen&equo;, one might expect that the union involved had given the strikers not only support but increased impetus in their struggles, but members of the strike committee certainly did not feel this to be so. 
 Mahmood told me (at the end of May 1977): 
 As far as APEX is concerned they are OK up to a point but they just want to follow the legal procedures and we want them to take some kind of militant action. 
 At the start we asked them to approach the Union of Post Office Workers (UPW) to cut off the mail to Grunwick but they wouldn't do that either. 
 They were always very slow in responding. 
 They always want to follow legal procedures up to a point, when even they realised that without some kind of help from other unions they were not going to win this strike. 
 We had to push them all the time, all the time. 
 The legal procedures APEX had suggested consisted of approaching the government conciliation body ACAS (Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service) which operates within the Employment Protection Act and was a part of the Social Contract. 
 It was the Grunwick dispute which was to show conclusively the effectiveness of ACAS, hailed till then as &bquo;a concession to the workers&equo;. 
 The activities of ACAS were as follows: On 31 August 1976 they approached the Grunwick management to start conciliation and were immediately rebuffed. 
 On 4 November the management, by then under pressure (for reasons unconnected with APEX or ACAS), agreed that ACAS should ballot the workers on whether they wanted union recognition. 
 On 26 November Grunwick again refused to cooperate with ACAS if sacked workers were balloted. 
 On 20 December ACAS decided to go ahead with the balloting, though Grunwick refused to supply the names and addresses of those working. 
 On 2 February ACAS published a draft report and finally in March 1977, six months after they first came on the scene, they published the full report on Grunwick recommending recognition of APEX. 
 That was the end of the ACAS story because Grunwick flatly and legally refused to accept its recommendations. 
 In June 1977 the Strike Committee had finally had enough of these bureaucratic manipulations forced on them by APEX. 
 They decided to call upon the support of the rank and file of the labour movement. 
 A week of action began on 13 June with a mass picket, at which 84 people were arrested and there was large scale police violence. 
 In the next few weeks the size of the picket increased, reaching 2,500 on 23 June. 
 Police injuries, 243 in August 1977 (according to Merlyn Rees, Home Secretary), continually made headlines but in fact about three times as many pickets were injured. 
 According to a Willesden doctor quoted in Time Out  (12&ndash;18 August) &bquo;Two types of injury are particularly common: the first is a result of testicles being grabbed by the police. 
 The second is a result of women having their breasts grabbed.&equo; 
 These injuries went in general unreported in the media. 
 for example, BBC Television on the evening of the 11 July Day of Action, and the papers next morning, were full of pictures of injured policemen, but the pickets who were injured were hardly mentioned, although among them was a man who had had an epileptic fit, a woman who had collapsed at the rear entrance to the factory and two Yorkshire miners who had to be carried away by their friends. 
 Not only was there overwhelming support on the picket line (from trade unionists and from many feminists who identified with the women's movement rather than any particular trade union) but on 15 June local postal workers at Cricklewood started a boycott of Grunwick mail. 
 Because Grunwick was a mail order photoprocessing plant it was totally dependent on postal services. 
 At that stage victory for the strikers seemed a matter of weeks if not days. 
 It was this very situation &mdash; one where the workers themselves could take control of the struggle, organise and demand on their own behalf &mdash; which was not acceptable as far as the trade union bureaucracy and leadership were concerned. 
 On the one hand the dispute was escalating through mass action into a head-on dispute with the government and employers; on the other hand, the trade union leadership with their job of negotiating (or compromising) between the workers and the bosses were becoming redundant. 
 Their reaction was predictable. 
 On 23 June, Roy Grantham, General Secretary of APEX, called for a limit of 500 on the number of pickets, and on 24 June, the TUC issued the following statement: 
 It would be a tragedy if the use of violence or any confusion introduced by irregular elements on the picket lines were to divide and deflect the support given by responsible trade unionists all over the country aimed at achieving an early and a peaceful solution to this problem. 
 Trade unionists cannot condone the use of violence in this or any industrial dispute situation. 
 At the same time, the TUC repeats its concern at allegations of unnecessary use of force by police against bona fide  pickets. 
 As the Socialist Challenge pamphlet The Battle of Grunwick  commented, &bquo;it was not made clear whether the TUC condoned the use of &bquo;unnecessary force&equo; against non bona fide  pickets or whether it thought the police were justified in using necessary force. 
 What was made clear was the TUC's opinion that the control of the dispute must remain firmly in the hands of the APEX executive. 
 The statement went on to give full support to APEX's decision to limit the number of pickets; the TUC wished to stress to all trade unionists that any action by them should be at the union's official request. 
 No action should be taken without contacting APEX Head Office at Wimbledon. 
 (There was no mention of contacting the strike committee at Brent).&equo; 
 The TUC edict was followed on 5 July by action against the Cricklewood sorters &mdash; they were laid off by the Post Office management and threatened with the withdrawal of strike pay by the Union of Post Office Workers and as a result were forced to go back to handling Grunwick mail. 
 (Eventually these postal workers were to be fined up to &pound;500 for disobeying union orders, while on the same occasion members who had disobeyed strike instructions elsewhere were fined much smaller sums). 
 The government responded to the unacceptable strength of the mass picket by setting up a Court of Enquiry (under Lord Justice Scarman) while at the same time condemning the &bquo;violence&equo; of the pickets. 
 Merlyn Rees visited the Grunwick police line on 27 June and commented &bquo;I learnt in Northern Ireland that operational control must be left in the hands of the police.&equo; 
 The aim of the mass picket had been to pressurise trade union leaders to cut off essential supplies to the factory. 
 It would have been an illegal boycott, but was seen by the strikers as essential for victory. 
 However, the TUC was careful to keep well away from the whole issue of such a boycott and the Court of Enquiry now provided them with yet another excuse to defer any further action. 
 When the Scarman Enquiry finally reported on 25 August, their recommendations &mdash; in favour of union recognition and reinstatement of the strikers &mdash; were, like the ACAS report, duly and legally ignored by the Grunwick management. 
 Like the ACAS report, the Scarman report sank without a trace but it had already fulfilled its function that of sapping the strength and momentum of the struggle. 
 Six days later the TUC Congress finally called weakly for &bquo;practical aid&equo; to the strikers but refused to commit itself to cutting off supplies. 
 On 22 November four members of the strike committee (among them two women, Jayaben Desai and Yasu Patel) went on hunger strike outside the headquarters of the Trade Union Congress in London. 
 They were immediately suspended from APEX and had their strike pay taken away. 
 To the strikers this last step on the part of the union bureaucracy was in line with the rest of their action. 
 When asked, just after they had ended their hunger strike, what impact it had had on the TUC Jayaben Desai replied (quoted from Race and Class , Winter 1977): 
 It had no impact. 
 Oh they (the TUC) talk &mdash; they make rules and regulations; we can't make any hunger strike, we can't make any demonstration, we can't make any mass picket, can't do anything. 
 Now it means they are going to tie the workers' hands, and we shall have no chance to do anything. 
 It means it will apply to everybody, not just to Grunwick strikers. 
 Q. How do you feel about your temporary suspension from APEX because of the hunger strike  
 It is a very bad thing. 
 The union views itself like management. 
 There's no democracy there, its strikers have no right to do anything. 
 The union says that we have to accept everything that they say. 
 We are the real fighters, the ones who come out of the company to fight for our rights. 
 But the union just look on us as if we are employed by them. 
 They have done the same thing to us as Ward did &mdash; they suspended us. 
 And now we have to fight to be reinstated in the union and then also to be reinstated in the company&equo;. 
 The trade union leadership remained unmoved but to quote Race and Class  (Winter 1977): 
 Where indeed can they move to? 
 Their &bquo;procedures&equo; &mdash; ACAS, tribunals, industrial courts of enquiry have been revealed as powerless and inadequate. 
 To support the strikers effectively, which is their duty and responsibility, would entail breaking the law, or at least risk doing so. 
 Rut this is ruled out on a number of counts. 
 Such potential law breaking would threaten the deal between the Labour government and the unions &mdash; an agreement whose stability is crucial to government policy and the government's continued existence. 
 For the trade unions to buck existing laws (eg. to cut off supplies to the factory) would involve them in a political struggle they do not have the strength or will to win &mdash; against the government, against the employers, against &bquo;public opinion&equo;. 
 The only alternative, in the face of their own inability to act, is to get the government to fight for them &mdash; through demanding laws  to back up current procedures. 
 But this goes against all trade union traditions: invoking laws and the courts has been seen as an infringement of worker's freedom of action and power of collective bargaining. 
 Also, whilst trade union leaders might want or need laws to strengthen procedures or &bquo;conciliation&equo;, this might well rebound, since the management side of the dispute supported by the misnamed National Association for Freedom (NAF), will also be pressing for laws &mdash; but to curtail workers' rights. 
 NAF, Grunwick boss George Ward and the mass media have succeeded in shifting the emphasis of the dispute away from the right to join a union and the treatment of black workers to a debate on the tools of working-class struggle generally; the closed shop and the picket&hellip;. 
 Black workers in this dispute have learned that because of their lack of numbers they alone cannot defeat their employers. 
 They need the rank and file of the working class, which, through trade union structures and traditions has been acclimatised away from mass action. 
 It is precisely because black workers have been kept away from these structures that they are now at the forefront of what has become one of the most political dispute in industrial history. 
 As this book goes to press, ACAS are said to be &bquo;trying again&equo;. 
 The Grunwick dispute is still nominally dragging on. 
 But such is the treacherous role of the trade union leadership that the victory over Grunwick management which had once seemed so near is now likely never to be realised. 
 But the strikers who have fought over so many months with so much courage and strength have achieved another kind of victory &mdash; they have exposed once and for all the myth of the TUC's solidarity with exploited workers and in the process of doing so they have redefined the methods and outlook of industrial struggle. 
 The lesson of the Imperial Typewriters dispute had been (to quote the Asian workers strike committee statement): 
 Our struggle has taught us also that black workers must never for a moment entertain the thought of separate black unions. 
 They must join the existing unions and fight through them. 
 Where the unions fail in their duties to black workers they must be challenged to stand up for their rights. 
 The union is an organisation of all workers, regardless of race, colour or sex. 
 Right now the trade union movement in Britain is functioning as a white man's union and this must be challenged. 
 In challenging this we believe in the unity of the working class. 
 This unity must be solidly established in deed and not only in words. 
 It is the main task of the trade union movement to create this unity. 
 At Grunwick this unity of the working class was achieved. 
 Hundreds of trade unionists came day after day to support the Grunwick strikers on the picket line. 
 But in the end it wasn't enough because they hadn't the courage to confront and defy the handful of men who control the trade union bureaucracy. 
 The white working class had been weakened by their dependence on these leaders. 
 They had grown unaccustomed to using their power of collective action. 
 To remedy this weakness that is the next task before the labour movement. 
 Passages omitted as part of a settlement agreement following on from legal proceedings brought by George Ward of Grunwick's in 1984. 
 IMMIGRATION 
 In Britain the most brutal, and wide ranging racism which occurs day after day is not the work of fascist minority parties but of Her Majesty's Government. 
 It is the racism written into, and demanded by, Britain's immigration laws. 
 New black immigration has long ago been stopped, but any black man or woman who wants to bring dependants over, or be visited by relatives from home, is now afraid of what these people will have to suffer. 
 English family relationships are said to be less strong than those of Asians, but most English people would be deeply shocked if their grandmother or grandfather, coming to visit them, or their young brother or sister, was held in detention by people with quasi-police powers, accused of lying and then sent back; or if their husband or wife, coming to join them after a long separation, was further delayed for years and then told that they were not the people they claimed to be and hence had no right to come at all. 
 But that is just what is happening to black people coming to Britain as dependants and visitors. 
 As for the women, the government seems not to regard them as human beings at all, unless as in the days of the British Empire the fact that they are women can be used to deny them basic rights or torture them in special ways. 
 Take the case of Shanaz Begum. 
 In March 1977, at the age of sixteen, she had come from her village in a remote part of Pakistan to marry a cousin who had settled in Britain for many years. 
 When she arrived at Heathrow airport, Immigration Officers interrogated her. 
 They claimed that she was not yet sixteen and so could not marry and hence had no right to be here. 
 She was taken to Harmondsworth detention centre and locked up. 
 She had been there about a week when I learnt of her arrival through a friend and went to visit her. 
 Her relations were keen that I should meet her, perhaps because they hoped in desperation that I might be able to help her. 
 Unfortunately I could do nothing at all. 
 Harmondsworth detention centre is in an arid wasteland of motorways and outposts of the air terminals past Heathrow airport. 
 It is a part of the grim complex called Government Buildings. 
 To enter you must ring a bell, which sounds like a fire alarm and summons the Securicor men who guard the building and whom it is a criminal offence to &bquo;obstruct in execution of the Immigration Act&equo;. 
 Opposite the front door a notice warns &bquo;No food, alcohol or cameras.&equo; 
 Inside is a long, uncarpeted prison-like corridor with bedrooms on either side of it, a television lounge which is furnished in the drabbest possible manner and a recreation room which contains nothing but a few wooden chairs and tables. 
 There is also a yard where one could at one time sit and look at the adjacent buildings through the barbed wire. 
 But the barbed wire has now been boarded up, presumably because the detainees must neither look out nor be seen from outside. 
 In this detention centre, contemptuous and inhuman attitudes have hardened into set rules. 
 The bedrooms are kept locked from 9 am. to 9 pm. 
 Often even young children can't have a comfortable nap during the day. 
 If you are taken to Harmondsworth after a long journey and several hours of interrogation by Immigration Officers, there is nowhere for you to lie down and rest. 
 And when you do finally get to bed, you can't lock yourself in and you may be woken up at any time of the night on any pretext. 
 Securicor guards and Immigration Officers can treat people as they wish. 
 In 1975 a securicor guard at Harmondsworth told me (as I wrote in an article in the Guardian) &bquo;Sometimes in this place people are naughty and we have to lock them in.&equo; 
 What does being naughty mean? 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;Abusing us, being violent, trying to break out,&equo; he told me. 
 But sobbing your heart out also counts as being naughty, which is what Demetroulla Karaiskou (a Cypriot girl) was locked up for. 
 She had come to visit her sister for the third year running and, as on the three previous occasions, hoped to stay for a month. 
 But her third visit came a little after the Cyprus coup, when British Immigration officers started suspecting all Cypriots of being potential immigrants. 
 Then again you may be taken from the detention centre to Pentonville Prison and locked up there if you complain. 
 That is what happened to Owais Jeevanjee, a nineteen-year-old Asian with a British passport. 
 He had complained about the way a mother and her child were being treated at Harmondsworth. 
 During 1975 and 1976 the detention centres would often get crowded. 
 Harmondsworth, which normally holds about forty men, women and children, would sometimes have up to four cots per small room. 
 In 1977, work on an extension had begun. 
 It was to provide, I was told, an extra wing for female detainees. 
 Obviously the government intends to hold a larger number of women in detention in the future. 
 It was in this prison that I met Shanaz. 
 She was sitting at a table in the recreation room with her relatives round her. 
 She was startlingly beautiful, with proud elegant Kashmiri features and eyes so sensitive and expressive that the pain and humiliation she had suffered struck me, too, like a knife. 
 She wore her bridal clothes and jewellery: this was how her mother had sent her, for the first time, from her home, taking care that every detail of her ornaments should be perfect hoping, praying that she would be happy. 
 But things went wrong right from the moment she landed in Britain. 
 Although in law a female fianc&eacute;e can enter Britain quite freely (without an entry certificate) she had been held up, questioned again and again, and late in the evening she had been given a sexual examination by officials who she thought might be doctors. 
 &bquo;There were two of them,&equo; she said, &bquo;both men, one of them was white, the other was probably a Pakistani. 
 He spoke Urdu. 
 He taunted me, asking me if I knew what was going to happen to me on my wedding night. 
 Later they told me that the examination had shown that I was not yet sixteen and that I was to be sent back on the next flight.&equo; 
 Shanaz's relations asked their MP to intervene, and while he made representations to the Minister with special responsibility for Immigration (Shirley Summerskill, Britain's representative at the United Nations Status of Women Conference) she was kept in detention. 
 After a few weeks the final &mdash; and expected &mdash; decision was made and Shanaz was sent back to Pakistan, frightened and uncertain about the future. 
 Shanaz was not alone in suffering the humiliation of unnecessary sexual examination. 
 Even during her time at Harmondsworth there were other women who had the same experiences. 
 In fact it seemed that at that time (early 1977) sexual examination had become common practice at Heathrow Immigration Department, apparently carried out at the whim of the officials. 
 I was told by Mary Dines, former General Secretary of the Joint Council for the Welfare of Immigrants, that, in the past, &bquo;it was a fairly frequent occurrence that these young girls, straight from their grandmothers' houses, would be taken to Holloway prison, their pubic hair shaved off, and examined for VD.&equo; 
 Most of these girls were not fianc&eacute;es but daughters, come to join their parents; the internal examinations were used to claim that they were too old to come as dependants. 
 There were cases where parents disowned a daughter because the medical report stated that she was not a virgin. 
 But the frequency with which women were thus brutalised depended not on the category of entrant they fell into but on whether Immigration Officers wanted to use these methods, and on the attitude of the Minister responsible. 
 Under the Summerskill regime it seems that officials can indulge in any sort of brutality they like. 
 Summerskill's predecessor, Alex Lyon, exercised a different kind of control. 
 Racism was not wiped out when Lyon was minister, on the contrary some of the worst cases of human suffering at the hands of Immigration Officers occurred in his regime, but he did occasionally act with some humanity. 
 He regarded himself as a liberal and a &bquo;friend of black people&equo;. 
 If representations were made to him, by, for example, MPs, about specific cases, Lyon often intervened to help the people involved. 
 In his own words he was seeking to get immigration control on a basis where it was firm but where it was administered with some degree of compassion for the individual case&equo;. 
 But if you want to be humane you don't last long as Minister with Special Responsibility for Immigration because the policies you have to carry out are so inhumane. 
 Lyon was sacked soon after Callaghan became Prime Minister. 
 The net outcome of his days in office were that about two hundred of the cases which were brought to his attention were treated with regard for human dignity, but the law affecting the rights of dependants and visitors was not changed (except for one fairly minor aspect: in 1974 the sexually discriminatory &bquo;Husbands Rule&equo; was changed to allow women born or settled in Britain to have their foreign husbands here with them). 
 Even now people can be excluded or detained literally because an Immigration Officer says he is &bquo;not satisfied&equo; about the person's intentions. 
 Even now for a Pakistani, Indian or Bangladeshi woman waiting to join her husband in Britain it is not a matter of getting a ticket and boarding a plane. 
 She must wait months, if not years, for an interview with an Entry Clearance Officer at a British diplomatic mission on the Indian subcontinent, go through endless interrogations about such subjects as the colour of the family's goat or the number of rooms in the house she lives in or how many guests there were at the wedding and what happened on the wedding night. 
 Other members of her family are also asked the same questions, and if there is the slightest discrepancy it can be used as proof that she is not the person she claims to be. 
 The women I spoke to who had been through the whole procedure told me of the many exhausting visits they had had to make to the British Embassies and High Commissions, of the atmosphere of contempt at these places, of the pettiness of the Entry Clearance Officers (ECOs) and interpreters, and the rude and unreasonable questions they had had to answer. 
 They told me that sexual examination is a routine part of the entry certificate procedure at British Diplomatic missions in the Indian subcontinent. 
 When I asked Alex Lyon about this in an interview in early 1976 his answer was: 
 They do have a medical examination as part of the process of coming here and in the course of that medical examination it is sometimes disclosed that a woman is or is not a virgin, and that is sometimes noted on the medical report and from time to time some ECO's have used that piece of evidence in making a decision about the relationship of the wife; I have always condemned it and by and large it does not happen. 
 Q. Do you approve of a woman having to have a vaginal examination as apart of the routine medical examination to enter Britain ? 
 A. The fact of the matter is that medical examination is carried out to see if they have any communicable disease. 
 If they do, it is thought unwise to allow them to come and settle in this country by and large. 
 If they had a communicable disease and it entailed investigating the vagina to find out, then I suppose the doctor is entitled to do that. 
 This firm statement of principle looks even more impressive when one considers that white women entering Britain are not subjected to these examinations. 
 But it is not enough to single out this or that Minister, or even the officials responsible. 
 The reasons for the brutality and racism which are displayed every day at the ports of entry in Britain and at the British High Commissions in the Indian subcontinent are the laws themselves &mdash; laws which are seen as essential to wider government policy and which though blatantly racist (in fact they would not stand up before the Race Relations Act) were each introduced as a contribution to good community relations. 
 In the last fifteen years successive laws have provided a continuing escalation in racism, irrespective of the government which brought them in. 
 In fact Labour governments (in 1965 and 68) have been at pains to prove that they are just as good at keeping out the blacks as the Tories. 
 Right from the beginning the Immigration Laws have been an attack on black people as workers. 
 They are designed not only to keep out black people but to try and intimidate black workers already in Britain and make it harder for them to claim their basic human rights. 
 The 1971 Act finally put an end to black people settling in Britain by putting all incoming Commonwealth Citizens on a par with &bquo;aliens&equo;. 
 Aliens have long been the most vulnerable section of the British workforce. 
 They are subject to a work permit system which ties them to one job and makes them dependent on their employers' goodwill to continue their stay in Britain. 
 They are also denied the statutory right to bring their dependants or claim supplementary benefits. 
 If they lose their jobs, instead of going on the dole they have to leave the country. 
 The government had long preferred these white &bquo;aliens&equo; (with these low social costs) to Commonwealth immigrants (for example in 1969 the number of work permits issued to aliens was 67,788 compared to 3,512 vouchers for Commonwealth citizens). 
 The 1971 Immigration Act means that if any new Commonwealth immigrants are admitted to Britain it will be on these exploitative and precarious terms. 
 The 1971 Act has also added new conditions which further weaken black workers &mdash; people can now be deported on grounds of &bquo;general undesirability&equo;, and &bquo;illegal immigrants&equo; can be removed without a hearing. 
 The Act has also vastly increased the powers of Immigration Officers. 
 They can operate anywhere in the country and can arrest &bquo;illegal immigrants&equo; on suspicion and without a warrant. 
 There have been several cases in the last few years in which police and Immigration Officers have raided factories and taken workers away. 
 In refusing people admission at the airport, Immigration Officers have to obtain the approval of an Inspector in direct contact with the Home Office. 
 But as an ex-Immigration Officer told the magazine Race Today  (June 1973) &bquo;If you don't show a good record in refusing people it is thought you are not doing your job properly.&equo; 
 Having created a viciously oppressive system of laws and rules, the government has found the right sort of people to operate it. 
 That Immigration Officers should be National Front members may seem utterly wrong to some people but not to the Home Office. 
 When it was discovered that a member of the Immigration Department was in the National Front his seniors merely glossed over it, saying that he was not a permanent member and in any case it did not affect the way he carried out his duties. 
 But what is it like to face Immigration Officers when you come to Britain for the first time, not knowing the language, uncertain about the future? 
 This is what happened to Zahira Galiara, a girl of eighteen from Bardoli, a village near Bombay. 
 In January 1976 she had an arranged marriage to a cousin Aszal who had settled in Britain and on October 20 that year the couple arrived in Britain. 
 They arrived at 1 pm. and were held up by Immigration Officers. 
 Aszal had all the documents required from a returning immigrant, but he was questioned for four hours and made to wait for four hours and then told he could go. 
 But Zahira was told she had no right to enter, because although the couple had a marriage certificate she had no entry certificate. 
 She was heavily pregnant but she was questioned and made to wait for the next twelve hours without food or water. 
 Aszal refused to leave her until, he says, at 1 a.m. they were told that she had to go to a detention centre where men were not allowed. 
 They were also told that at 10 o'clock next morning she would be put on a plane back to India. 
 Zahira was taken by car to Harmondsworth detention centre. 
 &bquo;I was taken to a room which I had to share with three others, two Indian women and one black man,&equo; she told me. 
 &bquo;I just lay there, completely exhausted. 
 I could not sleep and the pains started.&equo; 
 In the morning Zahira had quite severe labour pains. 
 She was taken to Queens' Building detention centre at the airport where Aszal was waiting for her. 
 They asked to see a doctor and Zahira was taken to another part of the building where, she says, she was superficially examined by a doctor and a nurse. 
 Although she speaks no English, Aszal was not allowed to accompany her. 
 The doctor's opinion was that she was fit to travel. 
 The Galiaras were told that she would be put on a plane at 3.30 pm. 
 &bquo;When she came back from the doctor, she was crying in pain,&equo; says Aszal Galiara. 
 &bquo;But the immigration officials and security men just laughed and said she was pretending because she didn't want to be sent back.&equo; 
 Zahira's pains increased and she was screaming uncontrollably. 
 Aszal says that he tried to call a doctor or an ambulance from the public telephone but was prevented from doing so by the guards. 
 Only when the baby's head began to emerge from the womb was a doctor sent for. 
 &bquo;By the time he arrived,&equo; says Aszal, &bquo;the baby was half out, the only people to help were an Indian cleaning woman and myself.&equo; 
 Zahira and her baby were finally taken to Ashford hospital. 
 But the baby, a girl, was premature and, according to the hospital, born with abnormalities.&equo; 
 She died soon after. 
 Zahira was eventually given permission to stay on in Britain. 
 Was it all really necessary? 
 It could hardly have been the result of an error. 
 Immigration Officers could see that Zahira was pregnant and, whether or not they thought the baby's birth imminent, they could hear her screaming in pain. 
 Also, according to Aszal, they said they did not doubt that she was his wife. 
 The Galiaras were told that all the trouble was caused by the fact that she had no entry certificate, but that does not explain the inhuman treatment she received. 
 The waiting period for Entry Certificates at the British Consulate in Bombay is more than a year. 
 But why are entry certificates so essential for Asian wives and children who have a right to enter Britain? 
 White immigrants from the Irish republic, EEC countries and even from Rhodesia come in with no such bureaucratic barriers. 
 In response to the article on Zahira's experiences which I wrote in the Guardian  I got, in addition to the usual sick and abusive letters from racists, a number of letters from English women who sympathised with Zahira. 
 Most of them enclosed letters to be forwarded to her. 
 Their sentiments were all very similar, and this letter from Lincolnshire expresses them quite clearly: 
 I can hardly believe that anyone should behave so cruelly and insensitively to any woman expecting a baby, especially to one like you, almost alone in a strange land. 
 Of course you will grieve for the loss of your child, but I hope you will soon find out how caring and considerate people usually are of a woman in these circumstances. 
 Please do not judge us all by these ignorant officials. 
 A kind thought, but one which suggests that the &bquo;fault&equo; lies with the &bquo;ignorant&equo; official and no one else, that the whole affair was an exceptional accident rather than one product of a carefully constructed machinery which demands these attitudes in its operators. 
 And in addition, since the writer disassociates herself and most &bquo;caring and considerate people&equo; from the people who caused Zahira's experiences, it suggests that nothing need be done to change the set-up which resulted in her tragic experience, that citizens whose government is racist and oppressive are in no way responsible for its policies. 
 What I have described so far applies to people direct from the Indian sub-continent. 
 Those from East Africa are mainly British Citizens. 
 They faced the 1968 Immigration Act. 
 The purpose of this Act was to deny them their right, as British citizens, to enter Britain. 
 It was the first official declaration that British passports mean nothing if their owners are black. 
 Of course this was all achieved without using the words black and white. 
 The Act divided holders of British passport into two categories &mdash; those who had &bquo;substantial connection&equo; with the UK, who could enter Britain without restriction, who were almost all white, and those who could not. 
 Having been denied their statutory right as British citizens to enter Britain, those East African Asians who were actually being kicked out of East Africa were offered the chance to queue for quota vouchers for entry to Britain. 
 A limited number of these vouchers were issued each year. 
 What it meant in human terms was that black UK citizens excluded from their own country (Britain) were and still are being forced to live in countries where they have no right to live or work. 
 Many have become ill and destitute, and those who have tried to enter Britain without a voucher have found themselves being shuttlecocked in and out of Britain or kept in prison. 
 As Ian Macdonald points out in The New Immigration Law  (Butterworths, 1972): 
 The International Commission of Jurists criticised the 1968 Act at the time of its passing as being in violation of international law. 
 The existence of the Act would be a clear violation of the third protocol (not ratified by the UK) to the European Convention on human rights, which provides in article 3 that no one shall be deprived of the right to enter the territory of which he is a national. 
 This undoubtedly prevents Britain ratifying the protocol; in addition the operation of the Act would appear to infringe certain articles of the existing European Convention&hellip; 
 Yet despite all of this, the Immigration Act 1971 continues, albeit in a different form, the system of control instituted by the 1968 Act. 
 In fact, in regard to whom it allowed free entry into Britain, the 1971 Act differed mainly in the words used. 
 Again, it avoided the words black and white but it classified people as patrials and non-patrials; in general terms, patrials, who can come and go as they wish, are almost always white; non-patrials are almost never white. 
 Now the Green Paper on Nationality, effectively a first draft of the law on nationality which is to be introduced in 1978, confirms that the same concepts are to be retained. 
 In the future, we are told, citizenship of the UK and colonies is to be abolished. 
 It will be replaced by two new categories &mdash; British Citizenship and British Overseas Citizenship. 
 &bquo;The dividing line,&equo; writes Ann Dummett in British Nationality Law, a Briefing paper on the Government's Green Paper , &bquo;between the two is to be almost exactly the same as the line which under the 1971 Immigration Act separates UK and colonies citizens with a right of entry to the UK (patrials) from those citizens who are subject to immigration control (non-patrials).&equo; 
 In future, British citizens will have the right to enter the UK; British overseas citizens will not. 
 Among the groups of people who would become British Overseas citizens as soon as the law comes into force would be citizens of the UK and colonies who are living in present and former colonies and do not have British-born ancestors. 
 This would include East African Asians who have been kept out of Britain all these years, and possibly the more recently arrived East African Asians in Britain. 
 The residence period for a British Overseas Citizen to qualify as a British Citizen has not yet been specified, nor have the rights, if any, of British citizens already living in Britain. 
 These people will have no right to enter Britain and no right either to work or vote in Britain or elsewhere. 
 Their children will in many cases be born stateless (unless they happen to be born in a country where birth confers the right of citizenship). 
 At present British single mothers cannot pass on their citizenship to children born abroad, nor can married women pass on their citizenship to children from abroad with non-UK fathers. 
 Both these points will be remedied if the proposals of the Green Paper are accepted. 
 But married women who are British Overseas citizens will have very few such rights. 
 This is in line with immigration laws which have been blatantly sexually discriminatory against black women. 
 For example, the 1971 Act prevents single mothers from bringing their children into Britain unless they can prove sole responsibility; and a woman can never be regarded a &bquo;head of a household&equo; unless her husband is mentally or physically handicapped. 
 These laws, with their impersonal jargon, may seem disconnected from reality, but in fact they are a far more destructive attack on black people than any activities of the National Front. 
 They have destroyed hundreds of lives &mdash; of the women separated for ever from their husbands, of young children forcibly kept from their mothers and old parents left in isolation because they don't qualify as dependants. 
 It is these laws which have been used to humiliate tired and defenceless visitors, to deport workers without even a hearing, to lock innocent people in prison and brand them criminals, and to provide employers with a work-force made powerless through legislation. 
 As for the position of Asian women, the immigration laws show the government's attitude &mdash; that there is no need even to pretend that they are equal. 
 The implication in all the sexually discriminatory immigration laws (continued long after the introduction of the Sex Discrimination Act in 1975) is that women are slaves and chattels in their communities, and the government sees no reason why it should treat them as anything else. 
 Married women's passports have hardly any value. 
 Even if they are British citizens, they simply do not qualify to settle in Britain if their husbands are non-UK passport holders. 
 They are expected to go and live in their husbands' countries. 
 Their parents, brothers, and sisters may all be in Britain but they are still being excluded. 
 If at all, they are allowed in only as temporary visitors. 
 They could never bring their husbands, because to do so, they would have to be considered as a head of a household, something which, as I have said earlier, no woman can be unless her husband is dead, or mentally or physically incapacitated. 
 As for their children, they would not be allowed to live in Britain for any length of time, and while they were here they would be prevented from attending school. 
 This is how one woman, Feroza, described her experience. 
 Her sister was present during the interview. 
 Originally I was from Uganda. 
 I don't know if it was my hard luck or what, but I married a Pakistani. 
 I had gone for further studies to Pakistan and I got married there. 
 When I got married I was only seventeen and my husband was twenty-one. 
 I wanted to marry him. 
 My parents explained to me, Pakistan is too far from this country (Uganda), you are not used to their ways, but I didn't listen to them. 
 We are Muslims and my husband is my cousin, so from the point of view of tradition it is all right for me to marry him. 
 After my marriage I used to go to Africa every one and a half years or so. 
 My parents, brothers and sisters were all in Africa. 
 The last time I went there was in 1968; after that I couldn't go there because I was a British citizen. 
 My family moved to Britain, and because of the distance and the expense I could not visit them. 
 For seven years I didn't see them. 
 There was such loneliness. 
 I had nobody of my own in Pakistan. 
 We lived in Rakant near Rawalpindi. 
 Before my marriage I used to be very active and very talkative but after my marriage, when I went to Pakistan &mdash; there you have to wear the Burkha . 
 I had never worn that thing before. 
 After my marriage I realised that I would have to use it, put it on whenever I went out. 
 We lived with my in-laws, and in their house even girls as young as my daughter (12) have to use it. 
 Her sister said: &bquo;She was born in Uganda, brought up and educated there. 
 It is difficult to change yourself.&equo; 
 Feroza continued: 
 I didn't say anything to my in-laws or my husband. 
 I thought l'd absorb myself in all these things. 
 But it didn't work. 
 I started losing weight. 
 When I left Uganda, my weight was 135 pounds, but in one year only 100 pounds were left, only bones were there. 
 Now after seven years separation I have come to see my family. 
 And when I saw all of them after such a long time I didn't like to go back again, really I didn't want to at all. 
 But the problem is that the government won't allow my children to go to school. 
 I have brought them with me but I can't just keep them at home. 
 They went to school in Pakistan. 
 I don't know what to do with them. 
 I am a British citizen but the Home Office don't want me to stay on here in spite of that. 
 The day I left Uganda my troubles started. 
 I was only sixteen then. 
 From that day to now, thirteen years, I haven't had any peace. 
 All that peace I left in Uganda&hellip; 
 When I left Uganda after my marriage, my mum told me, never write anything to me about your troubles because you didn't listen to us. 
 It is all up to you &mdash; and I decided that I was never going to say anything to her because I had done it all on my own. 
 And my elder brother, he had told me the same thing &mdash; &bquo;Babi, you are not listening to us so we are not responsible for anything.&equo; 
 I was seventeen then so I said &bquo;That's fine. 
 I don't care&equo;. 
 I was very talkative before marriage but after marriage I don't know what happened to me. 
 I became so quiet and lonely and sometimes I didn't even want to see my husband (after my daughter was born and when she was a baby). 
 My in-laws never asked me how I was. 
 I tried to accept their ways and that affected me. 
 Her sister said: 
 The thing is her marriage was against her in-laws' wishes and against my parents'. 
 She couldn't turn either way for help because she knew the answer would be &bquo;it is your own fault&equo;. 
 So she left it all to herself and tried to carry on but it was too much for her. 
 Now she has come to us. 
 If she can stay, if her husband is allowed to join her, she can start a new life, with people who love her&hellip; 
 Her in-laws don't accept her. 
 The grudge is there and always will be. 
 There is no point staying on there then, is there? 
 If the husband is nice that's good but that's not enough, not all the time. 
 You need other people. 
 Feroza (wiping her eyes) said: &bquo;These tears come out all the time.&equo; 
 Her sister continued: 
 In Pakistan the boys are so very obedient to their families. 
 All right, they say, a wife is a wife after all, but when it comes to a parents' decision&hellip; 
 If the parents say your wife should do this or should not do that, the boy listens to his parents. 
 For a couple to live apart from the in-laws in a village in Pakistan would be almost impossible. 
 Feroza continued: 
 There was almost no time of day when we could be together alone. 
 It took me a few months to realise that my life was changed completely. 
 In Uganda I used to wear very beautiful clothes but after my daughter's birth I don't know what happened to me. 
 Do you understand what I am trying to tell you, that I was filled with distaste for everything? 
 I didn't like anything, I felt like going away somewhere where no one would see me, not even my husband, I wanted to escape from my life itself. 
 When I had lived in Uganda I was the first daughter, after five boys, my parents and brothers, they really loved me, they hardly refused me anything. 
 But after marriage it was so different. 
 I used to wonder why nothing I did was right. 
 You know the Burkha , at first I couldn't wear it, I had never worn it before. 
 Two or three times I fell down when I was wearing it, that was outside in the market place. 
 I fell down. 
 A grown woman falling down! 
 I was overcome with shame. 
 I thought, what has happened to me! 
 What have I done with my life! 
 Then I stopped going out. 
 It was better not to go out than to go and fall down. 
 At home the attitude of my parents-in-law was that I was from outside Pakistan, so I must be very independent &mdash; although I never showed my independence. 
 I was seventeen then and I loved my husband with so much intensity. 
 It is not a good age to assess people or things. 
 But my husband always thought that my in-laws were good to me, because they never criticised me in his presence, He had told them beforehand &bquo;I know this girl, what she is like, so I don't want to hear anything about her from you. 
 You mustn't ever try to talk to me about her or I'll leave the home.&equo; 
 Many wives complain to their husbands about petty things which happen during the day, but I never did. 
 Even when I felt really bad I would keep quiet, and this affected my body. 
 I became very weak, I could not sleep or feel any hunger or desire to speak to anyone. 
 In Uganda I had always been keen on the latest styles, trying new clothes from week to week. 
 I had so many clothes but my mother never said no to more. 
 I was always keen on dressing up and going out to meet my friends. 
 In Pakistan all that changed, all I wanted was the bed on which to lie alone. 
 I used to wear a bra the same size as my mother's, size 40 it used to be, but I just seemed to dry up completely. 
 My clothes hung on me as though they had been draped on a piece of wood. 
 Gradually I lost the courage to speak out about anything or to question anyone; I started suffering from palpitations. 
 My heart would suddenly start beating very fast as though my life was beating out of me. 
 It lasted only 3 or 4 seconds. 
 It started happening about once a fortnight, then about once a week. 
 In the end I got to the state when it might happen three or four times a day. 
 Since I came to England it has got much less. 
 My husband's family, although they are educated, &mdash; one of my brothers-in-law is a barrister and another is an engineer &mdash; they are still very narrow-minded about women. 
 They didn't want me to wear saris. 
 It is not that I wore sleeveless blouses they were always long sleeved and not Choli's  either but even then they disliked it. 
 So I just folded my saris and put them away. 
 When I left Uganda, people used to wear tight pyamas and Kamiz, but these too they did not approve of. 
 So I gave them up, gave them all up. 
 But in my mind I suffered. 
 I couldn't help remembering the pleasure I had had in my clothes, how keen my mother had been on my wearing them, how we had often designed them and chosen them together and my mother had made most of them. 
 To go back to Pakistan again &mdash; it would be like dying. 
 And when I think of my daughters growing up in that atmosphere, in that society, I feel I must try to avoid it if in any way I can. 
 But I cannot live without my husband. 
 I love him so much I cannot ever imagine leaving him. 
 He was the first man I ever really looked at. 
 Now every minute of the day I miss him. 
 I am stricken with memories of him. 
 He is prepared to come to Britain and live with me here but I do not know if he will be allowed. 
 I am prepared to wait if I know that in the end he'll be let in, but in the meantime I just want them to allow my children to attend school. 
 When I see other children going to school I feel so depressed and disturbed, my girl is indoors all day. 
 When I took her to a school for admission they sent us to the Education department. 
 I have been there three times, but each time they say I must go back to the Home Office and try to get my daughter a visa for longer than a six months' stay in Britain; otherwise she cannot be admitted to school. 
 We have been in Britain more than a year now, so the Home Office has extended her visa, but each time they extend it it is only by three months or six months so that she is never eligible for school. 
 All this trouble they are giving us despite the fact that I have a UK passport. 
 If I am forced because of this to return &mdash; what then? 
 But I don't even want to think about that, because if I do I begin to hate everything. 
 I am afraid that one day I'll come to hate even my brothers and sisters. 
 My hands become cold, my body becomes cold. 
 Some months after I spoke to Feroza I learnt that she had had to return to Pakistan. 
 She had received the news that her husband was seriously ill and she and her children had rushed back to be with him. 
 It is unlikely that she will be allowed into Britain again, even as a visitor. 
 SCHOOL LIFE 
 &bquo;Don't you understand English or are you just stupid&equo; 
 I asked a girl of twelve what she thought was the most important thing to stress in my book? 
 She answered &mdash; &bquo;The way people are treated! 
 The way everyone is treated in this country.&equo; 
 Schooldays are said to be the happiest days in your life but for Asian children in Britain they are often the harshest. 
 Their pre-school life is often more sheltered than it is for white children. 
 They may be deprived of skills and they may receive less stimulation than, say, middle-class English children, but inside the Asian family they get plenty of security and love. 
 At five they are then pushed into an environment where the language is new, the rules incomprehensible and where, unless it is a predominantly Asian area, they are made to realise that they belong to a special category &mdash; Asian. 
 And being an Asian is almost always made out to be a disadvantage. 
 The structure of primary education in Britain is implicitly racist &mdash; in the books used, the curriculum, the teachers' attitudes. 
 But discussion of racism is taboo. 
 When I asked the headmistress of a junior school my daughter had been attending about the racist remarks children at the school had been making her answer was well-meaning and typical: &bquo;Asking them to say thank you and please or asking them not to swear is one thing but asking them not to say &bquo;nigger&equo; or &bquo;wog&equo; or &bquo;black people stink&equo; is quite another. 
 A discussion of these things would only make the atmosphere worse.&equo; 
 There are  teachers who try to take a strong anti-racist line but they are exceptions, often fighting a lone and unsuccessful battle against the racism of the school system. 
 Meanwhile, the majority of their colleagues prefer not to talk either about their own attitudes to race or about racism in their schools. 
 Since in general &bquo;politics&equo; should not be discussed in school, it is easy for teachers to claim that they have no strong opinions about subjects like, say, the National Front. 
 Often their private &bquo;non-political&equo; opinion is that the National Front are to be condemned as extremists; but since what the National Front is extreme about is racism, this implies that it is all right to be moderately racist. 
 A reluctance to take a stand about racism, in fact indifference to it, has been shown again and again by head teachers. 
 In December 1977 the Headmistress of St Anselm's School in Canterbury, one of Britain's leading Roman Catholic Comprehensives, allowed a teacher who was a National Front candidate to continue in her post alter she had promised that her National Front views would not affect her treatment to black pupils. 
 As for the National Union of Teachers, they rejected a motion at their annual conference calling for the exclusion of National Front members from school teaching. 
 Perhaps if the National Front had been excluded, the racism they stand for would have had to be faced up to, &bquo;making it worse&equo; for those very genteel people in charge of education. 
 But for Asian children, racism is impossible to ignore. 
 School, with its white figures of authority, its totally foreign values and judgements, comes as a shock. 
 After the initial effects of this wear off, children begin to realise their own and their parents' position. 
 The rules of the education system, such as bussing and the reception class system (see later in this chapter), are only implicitly racist, but the way Asian children are actually treated in school is often quite overtly so. 
 When a child gets out of line in assembly and the teacher shouts &bquo;Don't you understand English or are you just stupid&equo;, or when Indian parents who do come to speak to teachers are laughed at or rebuffed, children both black and white learn just how Indians are thought of by people who matter. 
 What these children face is a kind of colonial experience which they are far too young to fight against. 
 The children under eleven I spoke to almost invariably had a sense of inferiority similar to that of a colonised people. 
 They were ashamed of anything Indian. 
 They disowned their food and their language and in some cases even their Indian first names. 
 A few tried to make even their skin as inconspicuous as possible as white as possible. 
 Interview with girl of nine from Southall : 
 Q. Would you like to go to India? 
 A. No, I wouldn't. 
 Q. Why not? 
 A. I don't think it is nice in India because sometimes when you come from India you get black. 
 Q. You don't want to get black? 
 A. No. 
 Q. Why not? 
 A. (touching her face) Because if someone's black, if you touch them in the face you might think your face might get black. 
 It may be catching. 
 (Although the caste system in India has led to the attitude that it is more attractive to be light skinned than dark, this extreme fear of getting black does not exist in India or Pakistan.) 
 A teacher, again in a Southall primary school, told of an &bquo;amusing&equo; incident when an Indian girl of ten was reduced to tears when she had to go out in the sun in the summer term. 
 She was afraid of becoming black. 
 This apparent rejection of one's race is often accompanied by a desire not to stand out, not to cause trouble, to tip-toe about hoping nobody will notice you. 
 Why? because this is not your country, because the British have done you a favour by letting you in. 
 It is an attitude which is known among adults too. 
 A Sikh Conservative Councillor &mdash; Mr Mangat &mdash; expressed it quite clearly in 1973: &bquo;The best hope for Sikhs in this country lies in abandoning the turban and making themselves as inconspicuous as possible. 
 It would damage community relations and hinder the process of acceptance and integration if Sikhs looked conspicuous in the street.&equo; 
 (quoted by Geeta Amin in her D.Tech.Hons thesis Asian Women in Southall, Political and Social Situation ). 
 In Southall now, particularly since the murder in summer 1976 of a young man, Gurdeep Singh Chaggar, by racist thugs, few Asian adults even think about integration, let alone want it. 
 But young children continue to absorb these racist opinions and their corrupting values. 
 Interview with Indian girl of nine who was born here and has never been to India : 
 Q. Do you think there are too many Indians in Southall? 
 A. Yes. 
 Q. Why? 
 A. Because every time I walk somewhere I see lots of Indians. 
 Q. Would you prefer to see English people? 
 A. Yes. 
 Q. Why A. Sometimes I think where I walk is India. 
 Interview with Indian girl, eight years old : 
 Q. Are there too many Indians in Southall? 
 A. Yes. 
 Q. Why? 
 A. Suppose there is some shop, right. 
 An English man owns it, an Indian man comes and buys it, right. 
 With too many Indians all the Indians are getting spoilt, they start to do stealing and all. 
 Classically racist opinions &mdash; from Indian children! 
 For an Asian child growing up in Britain there is a choice. 
 Either you stand outside your community, see them as non-Indians see them, which means, often enough, identifying with racist opinion, or you learn to hate people who say these things. 
 Many children are caught in between. 
 They lead a double life, on the surface passive, even servile, but inside they suffer. 
 In spring 1974 I was able to interview about 30 Asian, West Indian and English children between the ages of 8 and 11. 
 They were on an outing from school &mdash; a day of activities organised by Scope Southall, an independent community organisation. 
 I interviewed them individually and in a separate room. 
 They were happy, relaxed children and seemed keen to talk to me about themselves. 
 But when certain subjects were mentioned the Asian kids became silent, hesitant. 
 One of these subjects was food. 
 Q. What is your favourite food? 
 A. (long pause) Don't know how to say it in English. 
 Q. Tell me in Gujerati. 
 A. (in almost a whisper) Vatatebeda . 
 ( With a little encouragement they tended to become more confident :) Q. What is your favourite food? 
 A. (uncertainly) I like chapatti and lentils. 
 Q. Dal , you mean. 
 A. Yes! 
 And I like Gobi ki Sabji  and chips and fish, that's all. 
 The day's activities included a slide show of photographs taken in and around Southall. 
 When pictures of Indian sweet shops were shown, the English and West Indian children present sneered and made vomiting noises while the Asians watched in silent embarrassment. 
 That Asian children are teased about their food may not seem very important in itself, but it does rather lead to the thought &mdash; if people eat food which is thought of as disgusting and unclean what are these people like? 
 And it provides a cover for racist fantasies such as these comments of primary school teachers &mdash; &bquo;Southall stinks of curry&equo; or &bquo;I am always sneezing when I come here. 
 It must be the curry.&equo; 
 Children understand the true meaning of these remarks. 
 An Indian girl of ten said: &bquo;Some people think we've made Southall look horrible. 
 We've made all our horrible Indian food and that.&equo; 
 Only a minority of teachers I spoke to were interested in the way of life of their Asian pupils and an even smaller number knew anything about it. 
 This lack of interest goes right through the educational system, In Ealing for example (an area where a high proportion of the population is Asian) not one school had facilities for teaching Asian languages. 
 Of course an Asian child here must learn English, but must she or he forget their own language in order to learn English? 
 A girl of ten told me that children in her school were punished if they spoke in their own language. 
 An Indian teacher said that in his school Asian children's names were almost invariably mispronounced. 
 But when in one class he had taken the register and pronounced their names correctly, there had been some laughter from non-Indian children (who were a minority in the class) but floods of embarrassed giggles from Asian children, who seemed to prefer their names to be mispronounced in school. 
 Indian language and Indian food are seen by whites as inferior, but religion is slightly different. 
 It is seen not as a racial characteristic but as identical with race. 
 Jesus is seen as British and belonging to the British. 
 One English girl of nine asked me &bquo;Coloured people believe in our God, but do you Indians believe in him or do you have a God of your own?&equo; 
 Religious instruction in most schools is not really conducive to respect for non-Christian religions. 
 Children in primary school are often told stories from the Old Testament. 
 Whether these are presented as interesting old stories or as moralistic and relevant fables depends on the attitude of the head teacher. 
 Teachers often choose to stress that the &bquo;baddies&equo; in these stories are &bquo;idol-worshippers&equo;. 
 And everyone knows that such &bquo;idol-worshippers&equo; abound in the &bquo;East&equo;. 
 I spoke to Sikh and Hindu children in Southall and none of them had been withdrawn from religious education lessons. 
 Some children from Hindu families even attended Sunday school, mainly because there was nothing much else to do at weekends. 
 An Indian girl of ten said: 
 I used to go to Sunday school but I don't go any more. 
 If you went to Sunday school every week you could go to the seaside free. 
 But if you miss only two or three weeks then you pay a little money &mdash; 23p, I think it is. 
 I used to go to Sunday school all the time before and they said I could go free. 
 Then I began to go to the temple and I didn't go to Sunday school any more, because I had been to the seaside lots and lots of times &mdash; the same one every time. 
 &bquo;English&equo; prayers were seen by these Asian children (mainly Sikhs and Hindus) as innocuous, even in some cases enjoyable, but not of any emotional significance. 
 They often seemed to feel that &bquo;Indian&equo; prayers didn't belong in the world of school. 
 Only one child, a Sikh girl of ten, had attempted to say non-Christian prayers in school. 
 Q. Are you religious? 
 Do you say prayers? 
 A. Yes, in assembly while they say it in English I do the other one. 
 We have to say the English one and I hate saying da-da-da so I make my own one, an Indian prayer and say it. 
 Q. What do the others say about that? 
 A. They don't like it. 
 One day we had a fight and they told Miss. 
 Miss said it was all right for me to say my own prayer. 
 Me and Karin, my friend, we do that. 
 Muslim children in general have a slightly different attitude to religious education in school. 
 This is because of two main differences between Islam and Hinduism or Sikhism. 
 Firstly Muslims (like Christians and unlike Hindus) have set prayers which should be said during the day, so that Christian prayers can be regarded as a threat or at least an alternative to Islam, and secondly, while Hindu and Sikh parents often regard Christian prayers for their children as so much water off a duck's back, Muslims, again like Christians or religious Jews, object to any other religious influence on their children. 
 Because of this, when Muslim children are not withdrawn from religious education lessons it is usually because the parents are not aware of these lessons. 
 &bquo;Religious identification,&equo; writes Afshan Begum in her thesis Adolescent Muslim girls in British Schools , &bquo;is generally much stronger among Muslims.&equo; 
 But according to a report Education and Single Sex Schools  (compiled by the union of Muslim organisations in the UK), quoted by Afshan Begum: 
 &hellip; an extremely small number of Muslim children have been withdrawn from religious education and morning worship in the past. 
 Although the Act (sec. 25, 1944 Education Act) would seem to give parents and pupils the right to practise a religion other than that (Christianity), in general there is little or no provision made in school for any kind of peripatetic Muslim teacher to give lessons in Islam. 
 Children between eight and twelve seem too young to fight against cultural racism in school; it is as though they are almost stunned into accepting the inferiority with which white society has labelled them. 
 But at twelve their feelings seem to change. 
 It is not that racism vanishes &mdash; in fact it intensifies and violence increases, but most children start to face up to it at this point, and their &bquo;inferiority&equo; usually clears away. 
 After all, when racism takes the form of violence, they can't fail to recognise it as an attack on themselves, and part of a value system they cannot go along with. 
 Also, with puberty, children, especially girls, begin to develop their own sense of identity. 
 Previously their view of Britain was conditioned by their parents' expectations. 
 Now they can reject these and look back more objectively at the implicitly racist atmosphere of their primary school days. 
 In Southall bussing and reception classes go on through secondary school. 
 Geeta Amin and I have described some of the effects of reception class in secondary schools as they were in 1974 ( Guardian  15 Aug. 1974): 
 When immigrant children first enter the borough they are sent, if the education department has any doubts about their English, to an assessment centre, and from there a large proportion of them are channelled into reception classes. 
 They stay in the reception classes for a period of up to three years, after which they are usually dropped into the lowest streams of the schools to which the classes are attached&hellip; 
 East African Asian children are sent for assessment even when they speak fluent English&hellip; 
 The fact that reception classes are lumped with the remedial department sharpens the image which English children have of them. 
 The class, located as it usually is in a prefabricated hut at the bottom of the school garden, is seen as inferior. 
 We were told by English boys that reception classes were &bquo;like Junior schools with pictures on the walls&equo; and that the work done in them was not really serious. 
 The boys could see that in reception classes, as in the all-in village school of a few generations ago, only one teacher taught all subjects to children between twelve and sixteen. 
 This was taken as proof that the class was inferior to, and separate from, the main school. 
 According to teachers, the school was divided into three social groups, which didn't mix: English children, Indian children in the main school, and reception class children. 
 In the frequent racial fights, reception class children are usually the targets. 
 When reception class children fight back, schools take drastic measures to avoid clashes. 
 In two Northolt schools, for example, Indian children were sent home half an hour early every day last term. 
 This meant they missed virtually a whole period every day. 
 Reception class children involved in fights have also been moved to schools outside the area &bquo;for their own safety&equo;, we were told by teachers. 
 The children's version was &bquo;they were chucked out because they fought back.&equo; 
 The position of Asian children in secondary schools in and around Southall is made worse by bussing. 
 They are literally outsiders in the schools they attend, miles away from their homes. 
 Their gathering for the bus ride home is often the occasion for a racial attack. 
 In October 1975 a Pakistani boy of fifteen was killed by a gang of white boys at a bus stop. 
 The anger among Asian teenagers which Geeta and I noticed in 1974 has of course since then led to Asian boys hitting back. 
 For them the role of victim of white gangs is over. 
 But now there is a new kind of racial violence in schools &mdash; girls attacking girls. 
 Girls of twelve to fifteen I spoke to in Harlesden said that the worst aspect of their lives was the bullying and racism they faced in school. 
 Sharmi (twelve) said: 
 They call you Paki, things like that, and if you answer back then you are really in serious trouble. 
 Then they get their friends on you, they beat you up. 
 If you report it, that's worse still! 
 None of the Indian girls complain, because they are afraid of being beaten up, so none of them go up to the headmaster and complain. 
 In schools in this area, the girls told me there were three social groups, West Indian, English and Irish, and Asian. 
 &bquo;There is hostility between West Indians and English,&equo; they told me, &bquo;they don't mix much, they keep apart, though sometimes there are fights. 
 But attacks on Asian girls are much more common.&equo; 
 Quite apart from the violence, the girls told me it was difficult to be friendly with white girls. 
 Sharda (fifteen) said: 
 They usually talk about their boyfriends; we haven't got any to talk about. 
 If they talk about their homes, their homes are completely different from ours. 
 We accept what they say, but if we talk about our homes &mdash; my mum said this or I cooked this &mdash; they hardly understand what we are saying. 
 We have to explain every single thing. 
 They want to know how or what for, about every thing, then at the end they say &bquo;Rubbish!&equo; and they tease and tell other people. 
 We eat with our fingers &mdash; they think that is dirty and disgusting. 
 Relations with West Indian girls seemed no better. 
 Tara, a fourteen-year-old, told me of a sequence of events which, her friends agreed, was hardly an exception: 
 A girl in my class, just because one coloured girl doesn't like her everybody gangs up against her. 
 They used to really flatten her down. 
 Now they don't talk to her. 
 Nobody talks to her. 
 Before, every time there was games they would kick her and everything. 
 When she complained, she'd had it. 
 She had to stay off school for two or three weeks. 
 However Sharda had a close friend who was West Indian and she had discussed with her the reasons why Asian girls were so frequently attacked and bullied: 
 I have a Jamaican friend, she says there should be no difference if someone is West Indian, Indian or African, we are all black. 
 She says that we Indians are not &bquo;strict&equo; enough. 
 She says &bquo;If a coloured girl tells you off, you are a grown-up, you should give it back.&equo; 
 I say &bquo;I might be the only one, while she has five friends.&equo; 
 That's the trouble, Indians are just one on their own. 
 But coloured girls, they make a gang and defend each other or beat others up&hellip; 
 If only we could be like that! 
 Then things would change. 
 West Indians never went to self-defence classes but they can still beat us up. 
 It is co-operation with each other that is most important. 
 It is also very difficult to get. 
 Sometimes I myself am not sure if I could do it. 
 If I saw an Indian girl being beaten up, I might just watch or walk away. 
 My Jamaican friend, if she saw a coloured girl being beaten, she would run to help her. 
 Even if she doesn't know her, hasn't seen her before. 
 East African Asians told me that West Indians sometimes behave as though they are superior to Asians, because Asians are religious or because Asians can't speak English well. 
 However, an Asian community worker in North London told me &bquo;West Indian children are only reacting to the insufferable cultural superiority that Asians feel. 
 Indian culture is a big barrier and they make it more so by always thinking they are superior.&equo; 
 Both these opinions were repeated to me by many people and both seemed likely to be true. 
 In addition, as one white secondary school teacher told me &bquo;It is a matter of style. 
 In the eyes of children, West Indians have it and Asians don't. 
 When a West Indian boy walks in, the girls look up; they don't do that for an Asian. 
 In our school there is no doubt there is a hierarchy. 
 The West Indians are at the top and the Asians are at the bottom.&equo; 
 But a more powerful reason for conflict than all these is the British education system itself, with its essentially ethnocentric curriculum, its apathy, its built-in attitude that Western culture is the only culture and its pervasive mockery of people who are &bquo;different&equo;. 
 It is a system insidious but extremely powerful, where pupils may end up learning quite a lot about the way of life in ancient Rome and Greece but nothing about the way of life of their fellow pupils who are black. 
 It is a system where a reasonably educated person would have heard of Homer but never of Kalidas, of Ibsen but rarely of Tagore, of Joan of Arc but not of the Rani of Jhansi (another woman who took arms to try to drive the British out of her country), of Goethe but not of his contemporary the great Urdu poet Mirza Ghalib. 
 This ignoring of non-European high culture and history may not seem important, but it is a part of the same ethos which permits the everyday culture of Asian life to be stamped on so viciously in schools. 
 This is what a small thing, cooking a few Indian dishes in a Willesden school, led to. 
 Sharmi told me the story: 
 Mrs X- &mdash; (a teacher) used to like Indian food and there were quite a few Indian girls in the class, so in two or three lessons in the cookery class they made Indian food. 
 They made chapattis and everything. 
 They brought some things from home as well. 
 Mrs. X said &bquo;I don't mind if you use my pots and pans&equo;. 
 Then after two lessons some second year girls came over. 
 They said &bquo;It stinks, it's disgusting, it's horrible stuff!&equo;&hellip; 
 When they say directly to you it stinks or something like that, you get hurt inside of you. 
 People start crying. 
 They really start crying. 
 It is not a pretty sight to see people so hurt. 
 So after it happened a few times our teacher said &bquo;We won't have cooking like this any more.&equo; 
 She stopped cooking. 
 She said &bquo;there'll be no cooking except the things I have to teach &mdash; things like cakes. 
 The girls I spoke to rarely discussed their problems at school with their parents. 
 Their mothers, they told me, often complained when they didn't want to take any food to school for their lunch. 
 But even that had not been discussed in detail at home. 
 The reason was that as a result of bullying some Asian children were afraid to eat Indian food at school. 
 It is only in cases of the most violent attacks that parents get to know what has been happening because, as the girls told me &bquo;we don't like to worry them about it. 
 They have enough problems without this.&equo; 
 Or &bquo;in our house we don't like to talk about racism, everyone is tired in the evenings and we don't like to talk about it.&equo; 
 Or &bquo;my parents are not educated, they won't understand.&equo; 
 At the back of their minds many girls feel that perhaps, even if they told their parents, they would fail to understand, or take in a situation so different from their own educational experiences. 
 Girls from orthodox Muslim and Sikh families feel this most strongly; they also fear that through some misunderstanding their parents might try to withdraw them from school altogether, cutting off their lifeline to the outside world. 
 Some of these girls whose families have come from rural areas in Azad Kashmir or Mirpur feel that their parents allow them to go to school only because in Britain it would be illegal for them to remain at home. 
 To criticise the school system in these circumstances would be not only pointless but risky. 
 Asian parents' attitudes to their daughter's education vary tremendously with their religion, background in Pakistan or India, and, of course, with the people involved. 
 The progressives, like their contemporaries in towns and cities in India, frequently have hopes and dreams for their daughters' academic success. 
 Often they plan out careers for these girls without even consulting them. 
 This is how Meena, a Gujerati Hindu girl whose family come from Bombay, described her parents' attitudes: 
 My parents, and most Asian parents, they live for their children. 
 Everything they do is for their children. 
 They have so many hopes and dreams for their children's future. 
 When it doesn't come out the way they want it to, that is when they get most hurt I think&hellip; 
 They wanted me to be a secretary and they wanted my sister to be a doctor or something medical. 
 I don't know why they decided it that way. 
 When we went to visit relations my dad would say &bquo;She is going to be a doctor and she is going to be a secretary.&equo; 
 It turned out to be nearly the opposite (laughs). 
 My sister is a secretary and I am studying biology. 
 It's funny really, now he doesn't say a word. 
 Parents confirmed these attitudes. 
 A woman from Nairobi who is a laundry worker in North London but whose husband works in a bank told me about her daughter. 
 &bquo;She is really intelligent and she is going to make something of her life, I know. 
 She is very good at her studies and we want her to be a teacher. 
 I think she'll succeed.&equo; 
 In contrast to this, among Muslim families, particularly those from a peasant background, the daughter's education is considered irrelevant. 
 In extreme cases, say of a family from the remote rural areas of Azad Kashmir, if the mother has just had a baby, it is known for daughters of twelve to stay at home from school for weeks, do all the cooking, look after the younger children and generally run the home. 
 Between these two poles of urban progressive Gujerati families and Muslim peasant families fall the majority of situations, where the parents do not show much interest in their daughter's school life and try and restrict her if she wants to enter higher education. 
 For Muslim parents, whether peasant or urban in background, their daughter's education in Britain is fraught with conflict between the demands of the school system and the requirements of Islam. 
 According to the Koran, for example, women and girls must always cover their arms and legs. 
 This makes the wearing of school uniform difficult. 
 To add to the confusion the old-fashioned but still prevalent school ethics dictate that girls in trousers are somehow &bquo;rude&equo;. 
 At least if there is a uniform a rule is seen to exist, but it is in schools where there is no uniform but where girls are prevented from wearing trousers that the greatest conflict can arise. 
 Take the case of Essex Junior School in Newham described in Spare Rib  issue 55: 
 At the beginning of the school year, Mr Bailey, the head teacher, would remind the staff about various rules at the school and he would also give us his view about clothes. 
 He didn't want female teachers or pupils to wear trousers &mdash; the teachers because it is &bquo;unladylike and unprofessional&equo; and the girls for &bquo;reasons of hygiene&equo;, says Cathy Pemberton, an ex-teacher from Essex Junior School in Newham. 
 The girls are mainly Asians (Muslims and Sikhs). 
 If they come in trousers they are warned or made to take them off. 
 Wearing trousers is more than a fashion choice for them, it is a religious requirement. 
 So they spend their time changing into and out of trousers &mdash; at assembly, at every playtime, at lunchtime and when they go home. 
 Parents who questioned what appears to be an unwritten regulation have been told in each case that they are the only ones not co-operating&hellip; 
 Edward Bailey commented &bquo;There is no rule against girls&equo; wearing trousers and anyone who says there is is guilty of libel.&equo; 
 Meanwhile more religious Muslim parents are saying that the answer to it all is single sex schools. 
 In Bradford it was just such issues which gave impetus to the demand for single sex schools. 
 Orthodox Muslim parents felt that the schools were making an almost deliberate attempt to obstruct them in their efforts to bring up their daughters as Muslims. 
 While local authorities and Muslim groups in Bradford squabbled over the rights and wrongs of the matter, and the press reported with relish the &bquo;grotesque&equo; attitudes of Muslim parents, no one really asked the daughters what they thought about it. 
 But on the specific question of &bquo;showing&equo; one's legs, after talking to Muslim girls in Bradford and London I feel convinced that they share the views of their parents. 
 Dilip Hiro in his book Black British, White British  looks briefly at the subject. 
 He quotes a young Pakistani woman recalling her schooldays, when she had to change for swimming and showers: &bquo;I was surprised at the English girls who simply used to stand there and change. 
 They didn't seem to be embarrassed, whereas I used to try and hide everything and felt conscious of myself.&equo; 
 According to Hiro, &bquo;the explanation of this difference of attitudes lies in the variation between the home environment of the Asian and English children. 
 Mehtab, for instance, had never seen her mother or father sunbathing in the back garden. 
 Nor had she ever seen her mother expose her breasts or even legs, at home. 
 She had therefore grown up subconsciously feeling that nakedness was undesirable, even immoral.&equo; 
 When I asked a Pakistani woman in her forties about this interpretation, she said: 
 It is true but it is not the full reason. 
 You can say religion forbids us to show our legs. 
 You can say we are not used to it because our parents never sunbathed. 
 But deeper than all this are the values of our society. 
 You see we think that for a woman Sharam  (shame or shyness) itself is honour. 
 It can be a woman's pride because it reflects her purity and sensitiveness. 
 In a sense Sharam  is the complement of Izzat . 
 It is common in one form or another to all Indo-Pakistani cultures. 
 Its effects can vary from never looking a man in the eye or never arguing with a man, to wearing a Burkha . 
 Few women brought up in India can truthfully say that they have never felt Sharam . 
 For the unwary it is a feeling as infectious as embarrassment or flirtatiousness. 
 It can be very enjoyable, amusing and romantic (because it means that a relationship with a man must deepen through glances, smiles and phrases with hidden meanings). 
 But inevitably it robs women of their strength and power and cramps their personality. 
 Since Sharam  in its extreme Muslim form is the antithesis of openness and frankness, to preserve it, no information about the body should be openly available to a woman. 
 This has brought Islam once again into direct confrontation with the British school system. 
 Most of the Pakistani mothers I asked were against sex education in school. 
 Rifat, a woman in her late thirties with an urban background in Pakistan, told me: 
 I don't think they should learn about these things at such an early age. 
 In Pakistan, when girls go to school or college, they learn about it from their friends. 
 Those who don't learn that way? 
 Well, they find out after marriage. 
 But here my fourteen-year-old daughter was shown a film about it in school. 
 She was shocked, stunned by it all. 
 She was deeply embarrassed and ashamed. 
 For a woman Sharam  is such a precious quality&hellip; 
 Now eight or nine-year-olds are being taught about periods in schools. 
 For us it was when we finally got a period that we learned about it. 
 Our mothers explained. 
 My daughter also didn't know about it till she had it in school. 
 If you get to know about these things at an early age you lose your shame and shyness. 
 You have all the knowledge, and all the choices are available, and the trouble is that with all this knowledge a child does not know what to do, how to make a decision. 
 Rifat's opinions were shared by many others, Hindu, Muslim and Sikh, but her family in Pakistan must have been exceptionally reticent about sex. 
 Ruksana's comments about sex education in the joint family were more typical: 
 For a girl not to know about periods before she has them? 
 That must be rather upsetting. 
 In our family my cousins and I knew well beforehand because there were always slightly older sisters and cousins who told us&hellip; 
 About sex? 
 Yes, that too. 
 I knew all about it in theory because I had a young Bhabi  and she used to tell her friends about her experiences and I used to overhear (laughs). 
 In our family we always learn from each other. 
 Once an Asian girl has finished school, whether she is Hindu, Muslim or Sikh, the threat or prospect of marriage begins to loom over her, casting a blight over her chances of further education. 
 Once again Hindu girls from an urban background are most likely to study or at least to continue their courses after marriage, but for Muslim and Sikh girls higher education can rarely be achieved without a struggle. 
 However good they might be as students, their families feel that marriage is infinitely preferable to a college career. 
 This is not only because marriage is thought more important but because higher education is dangerous. 
 In orthodox families, educated women are seen as destructive and potentially immoral, and an educated daughter is a source of scandal and potential family dishonour. 
 Jaswinder Kaur, a Sikh girl from such a family, described, in Oppression of South Asian Women  Vol I, 1977, what she had to go through to get to college: 
 I had a most successful career at school. 
 I tried hard at school because I was most happy there &mdash; not at home where girls are not allowed to go out even with their female friends. 
 My parents still don't know what course I am pursuing at a college of education. 
 My headmaster and a teacher, after a long struggle, managed to convince my Papa that it was in my best interest to pursue such a training. 
 Although he said a resigned &bquo;Yes&equo; to them, I was told by him I would never reach college. 
 He threatened me with this throughout the examination period and until the day I actually left home. 
 My eldest brother, who is quite &bquo;westernised&equo;, took me to college. 
 It was a fight but now that I am at college you can believe I am the happiest girl around here. 
 Academic work has always meant freedom for me. 
 It may be the only way in which I get what I want in my life. 
 It is quite revolutionary that I have left home to attend college. 
 The only reason a Sikh girl is allowed to do that is when she goes to her in-laws after marriage. 
 Any scandal I may commit in my period out of my home would seriously affect my younger brothers and sisters. 
 My father would clamp down on their education &mdash; their only means of freedom. 
 Worst of all, my family would be ostracised socially (see chapter on &bquo;Adolescence and Marriage&equo; from the Sikh community. 
 How could I commit such an offence when I really do love my parents so much? 
 Muslim girls face the same harsh oppression. 
 As Afshan Begum explains in her thesis &bquo;In many cases parents expect that the girl will, whenever they demand, give up everything (e.g. a course in further education or training or a career) and submit without question to a marriage they have arranged for her&hellip; these hidden cases which no one gets to hear about are the real tragedies.&equo; 
 Those girls who attempt to escape are found in a few days. 
 They have few outside contacts and white society is uncaring and often hostile towards them. 
 Afshan Begum writes: 
 In one case I know of, two friends resolved to escape because they had heard their parents &bquo;scheming&equo; of such marriages in the near future. 
 They were found after two days with the help of the police and brought home. 
 On coming home, one, because of psychological stress and the consequences of not having resolved anything, preferred not to face the future &mdash; and therefore took an overdose. 
 Ironically enough, on recovery her parents were gentler with her and began gradually to compromise to a certain extent, and now she is at a college of further education. 
 The other girl was not so lucky, her attempted escape accelerated the plans for her marriage. 
 In yet another case quoted by Afshan, the girl went to ask the help of someone regarded as a community leader. 
 This man took her back to her family without any mention, leave alone discussion, of the dilemma which confronted her. 
 &bquo;It seems,&equo; writes Afshan &bquo;that these people as well as the parents refuse to acknowledge that a problem of this nature exists.&equo; 
 The subject itself is taboo in many Muslim families, perhaps because Muslim parents regard it (as do the white media) as a choice between two life styles &mdash; one Asian and one British. 
 But Afshan says the problem is not that, but one of how to keep one life style without rejecting the other, or, as Meena, the girl from Acton put it &bquo;I never regard myself as English. 
 I am an Indian in every way. 
 It is just that I want to be free.&equo; 
 Remember the Capri? 
 Vauxhall and Volkswagen do 
 Calibra takes on Corrado in battle of the affordable coupes 
 FIRST TEST 
 Five-speed automatic Mercedes SL 
 All the new cars at the Paris show 
 THIS WEEK 
 News More clues to Bugatti's supercar 4 
 Paris motor show French revelations 8 
 Analysis Why current cars lack concept car flair 17 
 Arrivals Rebirth of VW Polo range 18 
 Sport Which Merc driver will win WSPC title? 20 
 Your View Diary columnist under fire 26 
 England and Germany coupe final Calibra versus Corrado 32 
 Our Heroes Mind-blowing Bentley R 38 
 Formula for failure The worst F1 racing cars 42 
 GREAT BRITISH SPORTS CARS Austin Healey 3000 and AC Cobra: 60's flare for he-men 48 
 Road Test: Mercedes 300SL-24 Five-speed Automatic 54 
 Alpine duel Dodge Spirit versus Vauxhall Carlton 62 
 Heroes The man who put the quality in Cadillac 69 
 Running Report Metro: dented but not daunted 71 
 DATABASE Info 73, How Much 74, How Fast 80 
 CLASSIFIED 38 pages of new and used cars for sale, 85  
 American dream on trial, p62 
 Mercedes 300SL-24 road test, p54 
 THIS WEEK NEWS 
 Bugatti &mdash; more supercar clues 
 Less than a year from launch, the Bugatti 110 is slowly emerging from the shadows. 
 Two weeks after the first ever pictures were snatched from Bugatti's promotional video by Autocar &amp; Motor  's Italian editor Luca Ciferri (3 October), the first photographs of the car in the flesh have appeared. 
 Taken at its first test session at Michelin's Clermont Ferrand test track, they show the car still under heavy disguise but revealing some of the characteristics that should give it a place among the great supercars. 
 None of the surface panels is visible in either this or the photograph taken from the video screen. 
 What is  apparent, though, is the car's form and its size: closer to a Porsche 911 than the mechanically similar Lamborghini Diablo. 
 Those factors were dictated by the new Bugatti's founder and ex-technical director Paolo Stanzani (who left the company two months ago after his unsuccessful takeover bid) and Marcello Gandini of Lamborghini Countach fame, who was finally chosen to design the exterior. 
 The heart of the new Bugatti had to be radical to match its nimble frame. 
 For Stanzani that meant a compact engine and an all-composite chassis. 
 Consequently the car you see in the photograph is powered by one of the neatest engines around &mdash; a five  -valve per cylinder V12 with no fewer than four turbochargers to make up for its relatively small, 3.5-litre capacity. 
 All four wheels are driven. 
 Stanzani was also responsible for the involvement of the French aerospace company, Aerospatiale, which has lent its considerable expertise with carbon-fibre and Kevlar to the project. 
 The result is a lightweight chassis, engineered to cater for any changes in the mechanical specification. 
 Bugatti has been using the Clermont Ferrand race track in central France for development work, courtesy of the circuit's owner, Michelin. 
 The French tyre manufacturer has a key role to play in the Bugatti, and is developing the world's first ultra-high performance tyre specifically for four-wheel drive supercars. 
 With these photographs as a reference point we can expect a traditional Gandini shape when we see the car on 15 September next year, the 110th anniversary of Ettore Bugatti's birth. 
 A Formula 1-style wing is obviously part of the package &mdash; it's important enough to the prototype's aerodynamics for it not to be excluded from its testing programme. 
 But beyond that it's fair to speculate on a shape closer to the Countach than the Testarossa, making use of juxtaposed flat planes for impact rather than  subtly  of line. 
 Gandini isn't alone in designing the car, though. 
 There is a Bertone version on the cards and it's believed both Pininfarina and ItalDesign have also put forward proposals. 
 Giugiaro's ItalDesign has already shown its idea with the ID 90, unveiled in Turin earlier this year. 
 The aerodynamic development is clearly not confined to the bodywork. 
 The photographs reveal substantially-sized twin venturi tunnels underneath, which suggest this is the most ambitious attempt yet to convert grand prix ground-effect to road use. 
 The purpose served by the two massive exhaust cowlings is less clear, but it's unlikely Bugatti would test them if they were for styling reasons only. 
 Between now and next September the remaining mysteries of the Bugatti's size and specification will be solved. 
 But every scrap of information paints a picture of an all-time great motor car.  
 The still from Bugatti's own video 
 Carbon-fibre and Kevlar chassis 
 V12, 550 bhp&hellip; 
 Mitsubishi takes on BMW 535i in UK 
 Mitsubishi's challenger to the BMW 535i, the Sigma, goes on sale in the UK next March after receiving its first airing at the Paris motor show. 
 But only 300 of the comprehensively equipped models will be available in 1991, selling for around &pound;26,000 apiece. 
 The Sigma (above) has a 0.5ins higher roofline, and door pillars and window frames to European taste, unlike its sister Diamante model, which is already on sale in Japan where it has a six-month waiting list. 
 The front-wheel-drive Sigma is powered by twin-cam multi-point fuel-injected 3-litre 24-valve V6 engine, producing 202bhp and giving claimed performance of 140mph and a sub-eight second 0&ndash;60mph time. 
 For the UK, it will have a four-speed automatic gearbox only, and in-phase four-wheel steering, leather seats and air conditioning. 
 The car's platform and mechanicals are based loosely around the HSRII concept car displayed at the Birmingham and Paris motor shows. 
 At the forefront is a traction control system. 
 The system has what Mitsubishi claims to be the world's first &bquo;trace&equo; control device on a production car, which operates to prevent understeer from building up, allowing the driver safely to negotiate a bend. 
 Trace is designed principally for high-friction, metalled roads, where it predicts probable cornering forces based on the steering angle, engine speed and amount of grip available. 
 It then adjusts the engine speed accordingly via second throttle. 
 There is also a slippage control which automatically cuts power if the wheels begin to spin under harsh acceleration. 
 All this is linked to four-wheel steering and ESC adaptive suspension, which adjusts its settings to limit body roll and optimise tyre grip during cornering. 
 To complete the package, anti-lock brakes are standard. 
 Sigma is the car with which Mitsubishi hopes to claim a slice of the lucrative high-specification performance-saloon market where the BMW 535i holds court. 
 Mitsubishi is also hoping to sell a lower-spec Sigma in the UK &mdash; but only if it can secure the cars from the factory in Japan, and  negotiate an increase in its UK import quota. 
 Mitsubishi's Nagoya works are already flat-out supplying Diamantes and the Dodge Stealth/Mitsubishi Starion GTO models with which it shares its platform and mechanicals. 
 Slotting in about &pound;4000 above the top-spec Galant &mdash; the &pound;17,699 2.0 GTi coupe &mdash; the Sigma would come without the 24-valve cylinder head, 4ws, adaptive suspension and leather interior. 
 It would also have a manual gearbox. 
 The automatic Sigma arrives in the UK next March, kicking off an exciting year for Mitsubishi. 
 Its next generation Space Wagon is due in Japan next month, badged for the home market as the Chariot, while the Shogun replacement makes its debut in Japan next February as the Pajero. 
 Both will be in Britain within the next 14 months, and the firm is planning further UK launches, including a smaller sports-utility vehicle. 
 DISPATCHES 
 UNITED KINGDOM 
 Russell Bray 
 &bull; Fewer visitors than ever attended the recent British International Motor Show in Birmingham. 
 The current poor economic climate has been blamed for total admissions of only 420,000 people, some 300,000 down on the 1988 total and the lowest figure since the show moved to the National Exhibition Centre from London in 1978. 
 &bull; Jaguar and GKN's joint venture car components plant under construction at Telford, Shropshire, has been approved for a European Investment Bank loan of &pound;20 million. 
 This will equal half the cost of the factory, which should be up to full production of body panels by the end of next year. 
 &bull; Friends of the Earth has slated new European standards for the control of diesel vehicle emissions as &bquo;too weak&equo;. 
 The controls apply only to new oil-burners and the environmental pressure group say they simply bring Europe into line with standards set in the US 13 years ago. 
 JAPAN 
 Peter Nunn 
 &bull; Mazda has set up a research and development team to investigate ways of cutting its car's full consumption by one-fifth by 1995. 
 Weight-saving by the increased use of aluminium for engine and suspension components is believed to be a high priority. 
 &bull; Car sales in Japan levelled off in September after months of continued growth. 
 Total registrations, excluding mini vehicles, rose by only 0.3 per cent on last year to total sales of 503,977, leaving industry-watchers speculating on a market decline. 
 &bull; The Japanese motoring industry is meanwhile considering if it should slow down its expansion into the luxury car market, due to the Gulf crisis hitting fuel prices. 
 California outlaws exhaust emissions 
 California is to introduce vehicle emission standards even tougher than the stringent levels already proposed for 1997. 
 They could have a profound effect upon the motor industry worldwide, since the standards can be met only with use of electric cars and alternative fuels. 
 Although primarily motivated by the need to combat localised smog the new standards will also reduce problems of carbon dioxide &mdash; the main &bquo;greenhouse&equo; gas. 
 Approximately two million cars are sold each year in California &mdash; about the same number as registered annually in the UK. 
 The new standards demand that by 1998 at least two per cent (40,000) of all new cars must emit no smog-producing gases at all, which means in effect that they must be powered by electricity. 
 By the year 2003, 10 per cent (200,000) must come into that category. 
 Over the next 13 years, the regulations set out to achieve a 70 per cent cut in hydrocarbon emissions. 
 The US motor industry is known to be sceptical over whether the timescale proposed for the new emission levels can be met. 
 A spokesman for General Motors in Detroit said: &bquo;We will need to develop advanced new technologies to meet the regulations.&equo; 
 He also confirmed that the decision had already been taken to produce the &bquo;Impact&equo; electric car (above), first revealed at this year's Geneva motor show, although a firm launch date has yet to be decided. 
 Wet-road accidents &bquo;halved&equo; 
 A programme designed to improve the skid-resistance of Britain's roads is cutting wet-road accidents by up to 50 per cent in some places, says the Transport and Road Research Laboratory. 
 An anti-skid road surface, unique to the UK, was introduced in early 1988. 
 At the same time a fleet of lorries equipped with a device called SCRIM (Sideways Force Coefficient Routine Investigation Machine) began a three-year programme of monitoring the skidding resistance of Britain's major roads. 
 So far, two-thirds of Britain's trunk-roads have been checked. 
 It was expected that identifying and resurfacing slippery roads would reduce skidding accidents by 1800 a year. 
 Preliminary figures now suggest this is an under-estimate. 
 IN BRIEF 
 Road deaths increased  in the UK by six percent to 1250 in the second quarter of 1990 compared to the same period for last year. 
 Both road traffic and the overall casualty rate per passenger mile went up by one per cent. 
 High-performance driving lessons  for newly-qualified drivers have been started by the Tyro Driving Centre of Swindon, Wiltshire, using a dual-control Vauxhall Astra GTE 16v. 
 Motorway instruction is part of the course. 
 Mazda is to set up a centre  in Belgium to train staff in sales and after-sales service. 
 It will be specially tailored to the needs of European markets and customers. 
 Volvo has won a safety award  for its innovative integrated child seat fitted to all new 900-series saloons. 
 Last year Volvo also won the Prince Michael Road Safety Award for safety belt tensioners that operate automatically in a collision, and its 700-series car was declared the safest in an accident following crash-testing in 199 different vehicles by the American Highway Loss Data Institute. 
 Tougher driving tests  start next April, when candidates will be judged also on their ability to reverse into a tight parking space. 
 It's the first change since the L-test started in 1935. 
 Protruding parking bump sensors  that sound a warning when they nudge another car have been launched as an accessory to help drivers squeeze into tight parking spaces. 
 The Parkit is an arrangement of four flexible, pressure-sensitive probes fitted proud of bumpers, linked to an in-car alarm. 
 Jaguar Cars has made two appointments  as part of plans to expand its range of vehicles and treble output by the year 2000. 
 Product engineering director Jim Randle now takes the role of director of vehicle and concepts engineering, and Clive Ennos becomes director of product engineering. 
 Sign of hope for car sales 
 The plunge in new car sales in Britain finally showed signs of bottoming out in September. 
 If this continues, the emotive two-million barrier for the year could still be broken, though last year's 2.3 million record will take some beating. 
 &bquo;It seems to depend on how much credit people can afford, and at the moment it is just not enough for a new car,&equo; said one high-street main dealer. 
 Speaking at the British International Motor Show, Ford of Britain chairman, Derek Barron, predicted 2.02 million sales for 1990. 
 There is a huge pent-up demand for new cars, he said. 
 According to the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, new car sales last month totalled 153,595, a fall of 10.56 per cent on September 1989. 
 Sales for the first nine months of the year, at 1,698,221, are now 11.52 per cent behind the same period last year. 
 Importers are being hard hit in some cases, with the total share of the market down from 59.94 per cent a year ago to 55.45 per cent last month. 
 The Volkswagen-Audi group took a heavy fall with sales  down from 1194 to 6943 . 
 Even worse hit was Nissan, with September sales down by nearly a half from 11,871 to 6058. 
 FSO sold just 99 cars compared with 480 in the same month last year. 
 Ford retained market leadership with its share up from a lowly 20 per cent last September to 25 per cent &mdash; a volume increase from 34,421 to 38,445. 
 Vauxhall just held on to second spot ahead of Rover with 24,376 sales to Rover's 23,251. 
 Both volumes were down, but Rover raised its market share by half a per cent to 15.41 per cent. 
 Peugeot saw a fall, despite pushing 205 and 405 ranges into the top 10 best sellers for the month. 
 Honda accepts solar challenge 
 Honda will enter November's 1864-mile World Solar Challenge in Australia with the futuristic single-seat prototype, pictured above, designed and created by young technicians at Honda's Tochigi R&amp;D base in Japan. 
 The Solar Car, standing 225.6 ins long, 78.4ins wide and 39.4ins tall, runs on three wheels and is said to better 75mph. 
 Its body is made from a mixture of carbon-fibre and Nomex honeycomb, and boasts a Cd less than 0.12. 
 It bears an uncanny resemblance to GM's victorious Sunraycer of two years ago. 
 Banks of single-crystal silicon solar cells embedded on its upper body flank can generate up to 1.4kW of power, according to Honda. 
 These in turn are supported by an array of lightweight silver oxide/zinc storage batteries, which store energy provided by the solar cells and provide back-up power for when the sun is not shining or the car faces a gradient. 
 The car weighs just 308lb. 
 Normally, the Solar Car's small, brushless DC motor puts out 1.2kW, although ultimately output can reach 4.5kW. 
 The motor drives the car's single rear wheel by means of a chain. 
 There are 43 cars scheduled to take part in the second World Solar Challenge, which runs from Darwin on Australia's northern coast down to Adelaide in the south, using public roads.  
 Solar energy is converted by cells on the Solar Car's flanks to drive its electric motor and recharge its back-up batteries. 
 Claimed top speed 75mph 
 Vitara gains doors to beat US laws 
 Prompted by the tough new laws that penalise the import of two-door sports off-roaders, Suzuki has added two extra doors to its Vitara sports/utility off-roader in Japan. 
 The extra doors are neatly grafted onto the existing Vitara shell. 
 Called the Nomade, the newcomer sits on a stretched 98ins wheelbase and stands 16in longer than the original vehicle with an overall length of 156ins. 
 Standard Vitara width of 64ins remains unchanged, but height is increased slightly to 67ins. 
 Despite the extra size and weight of the new body, Suzuki has decided to retain the Vitara's existing sohc 16-valve engine with EFi, which, in Japanese tune, pumps out 100bhp at 6000rpm. 
 The Nomade will be sold in the US as both a Suzuki and through General Motors' US imports network Geo. 
 It's due to join the three-model Vitara line-up in the UK by the middle of next year. 
 Nomade prices in Japan &mdash; Y1.788 million to Y1.916 million (&pound;6878 to &pound;7411) &mdash; point to a UK price in the region of &pound;10,000-&pound;11,500. 
  Peter Nunn   
 The Vitara has grown to accommodate extra doors 
 DISPATCHES 
 FRANCE 
 Edouard Seidler 
 &bull; The Renault/Volvo link-up has been officially sealed. 
 Volvo now owns 20 per cent of Renault's car division, with the French company owning 25 per cent of Volvo Cars and 10 per cent of AB Volvo. 
 Both firms have taken a 45 per cent stake in each other's truck business. 
 &bull; Renault Trucks chairman Jean-Pierre Capron, tipped as a possible successor to Renault boss Raymond Levy, joins the management group. 
 Secretary general Patrick Faure is to replace Paul Percie du Sert as sales manager. 
 There's also rumour that Levy may head a future Renault-Volvo holding company after he retires in July 1992. 
 &bull; Police in Paris gave out more than 170,000 driving offence tickets last year with some 78,000 for signal violations, 24,000 fines for motorcyclists riding without helmets, 2300 for speeding and 3500 for drink-driving. 
 UNITED STATES 
 John McCormick 
 &bull; Lotus's US arm is pricing its Esprit Turbo race car replicas at &dollar;125,000 (&pound;65,800). 
 Twenty of the specially equipped Esprits are to be sold by US dealers this autumn. 
 The cars, built to capitalise on Lotus's recent US racing success, will come with a roll cage, racing wheels and tyres, racing suspension settings, six-point seat harnesses and basic instrumentation. 
 Lotus Esprit Turbos won four of the first seven races in the SCCA Escort series this season. 
 &bull; A US Government study reveals that car makers in the US have made little or no gains in fuel economy ratings for 1991 models. 
 The latest figures show the average mpg of 28.1 is the same as it was in 1987. 
 The most economical car in the US is the Geo Metro XFi, which gets 53mpg in town and 58mpg on the motorway. 
 Lamborghini's Diablo brings up the rear with 9 and 14mpg respectively. 
 PARIS SHOW 
 France stands its ground 
 Bold concept cars from Renault and Citroen were the stars at the Paris motor show along with Mercedes' new 500E Q-car. 
 But glamour couldn't drown out the tough talk from French car chiefs on the threat from Japan. 
 Report by Michael Harvey and Peter Robinson, photography by Stan Papior 
 What the Paris show lacked in new cars, it made up for with intrigue and imagination, personality and politics. 
 With but two new cars on show &mdash; the mighty Mercedes 500E and the technologically overdosed Mitsubishi Sigma &mdash; Paris seemed set to play a soft second fiddle to Birmingham's show. 
 But when you put Peugeot's boss Jacques Calvet, Renault's chief Raymond Levy and Giovanni Agnelli, head of Fiat, together you're bound to get fireworks. 
 The pops and bangs going off around the Porte de Versailles  last week signalled a European industry in panic as the date for free access to the European market by the Japanese gets ever closer. 
 That date is especially important for those Japanese cars built on what Levy described as &bquo;the Japanese aircraft carrier that is the UK, and which is pointed towards continental Europe&equo;. 
 Faced with the prospect of Nissan's Washington plant in the UK training its sights on the mainland and upping exports to as much as 70 per cent of production &mdash; that's 140,000 cars a year by 1992 &mdash; the two most powerful men in French industry locked themselves behind doors and decided then and there to up the ante in the fight against the Japanese. 
 Levy and Calvet, both long-time advocates of a five-year acclimatisation period for Europe after 1992, are thought to have agreed to press the European Commission to deny the Japanese unhindered access to Europe until 2002, and only then if it's reciprocated. 
 With over 60 per cent of the French market tied up between them, the Peugeot-Citroen group and Renault could be forgiven for thinking they had little to worry about. 
 That's the way it looked out in the halls as they each displayed a show car as bright as any we've seen since Tokyo last year. 
 Renault in particular looked in good health despite its slight slip in the market this year. 
 It was a spirit summed up not by the hoards of identically painted Clios or the new 16-valve Chamade (both in the UK next spring) but by Laguna, the electric-blue and polished-silver roadster show car. 
 Its design team, led by Renault's gushing and charming design director Patrick le Quement, could not have been better pleased. 
 &bquo;We will have the marketing men here next week asking people what they think,&equo; said le Quement. 
 &bquo;And I hope they like it &mdash; Laguna is the look of the new generation of Renaults &mdash; cars designed with passion and excitement.&equo; 
 That's a look we'll see emerging from the dull, old chrysalis that was Renault design in the '70s and '80s, when it takes the wraps off its first really new-age car in two years' time. 
 And that car &mdash; the 21 replacement &mdash; is being designed by an Englishman, Anthony Grade &mdash; of the  Grades. 
 There was another Briton, a Welshman to be precise, involved in Laguna. 
 Ian Matthews (see separate story), a Royal College of Art graduate, designed the nifty interior, including its clever seat cushions that roll under themselves to shorten the reach without altering legroom. 
 Laguna is a near-certain bet to make it to production in some form. 
 Renault is the European leader in short-series production &mdash; look at Alpine's GTA and Matra's Espace &mdash; and the Laguna will come under Alpine's charge after the show. 
 What will emerge from Alpine may not have the sprint car look, nor the integral tonneau or open-to-the-elements driving position but it will have most of Laguna's mechanicals. 
 That means a modified 2-litre Renault 21 Turbo engine, double wishbone suspension and a chassis le Quement said was designed not as a chassis &bquo;but as a handling&equo; ( sic ). 
 He's got a lot on his mind right now, not least how Renault's going to cope with a future hand-in-hand relationship with Volvo. 
 The arrangement was formally signed just a week before the show. 
 The two companies' more obvious synergies, claims le Quement, extend to design and he's already given free access to Renault's Billancourt design centre to all Volvo's senior designers. 
 He won't have to go to the two language schools being set up by Volvo and Renault in France and Sweden to teach English to engineers and designers; le Quement was educated at a public school in England. 
 He will also have to start thinking about a partnership with Skoda before long, too, provided Renault gets its way in Czechoslovakia. 
 It won't be a question of Skoda building old R5s and R18s. 
 &bquo;The future for Eastern Europe,&equo; he said, &bquo;is not in last year's Western cars.&equo; 
 Across the way in the main hall dominated by Renault and Peugeot/Citroen was Activa II, a big handsome XM coupe built just for show, but thought to be the type of car BMW should have built instead of the 850i. 
 It's a rehash of the first Activa's super-sensitive hydractive suspension, the XM floorpan and a coupe body complete with built-in memories of the glorious Maserati-engined SM. 
 Citroen's design director Art Blakeslee thought the company had done the right thing with Activa II. 
 &bquo;We wanted to build a car that had a rational  development from a production car,&equo; said Blakeslee. 
 &bquo;We've now got to see if people like it enough for us to want to even think about building something like it.&equo; 
 That's not the official company line. 
 The overlords at Citroen say it's just a show car, but with Peugeot and Citroen able endlessly to vary the mix of 605s and XMs that come  of  the shared line at Sochoux, a third model, an XM coupe, is not an impossibility. 
 If it does end up in the museum however, Blakeslee said that the co-operation of advanced design, advanced engineering and production engineering departments on the Activa II will pave the way for more efficient Japanese-style simultaneous engineering to fight off the Orientals, whenever Monsieur Calvet allows them to arrive. 
 Calvet was in spectacular form at Paris, calling for an immediate rethink on Japanese access to Europe and outlining a five-point plan: that no new transplants be established in Europe; that those in existence have outputs capped; that quotas be maintained between 1992 and 2002 and continued after that if the Japanese don't play ball; that overall European penetration levels should stay at 10 per cent from the East and that France could keep its three per cent quota; and finally, that all Japanese cars, no matter where they're built, should be included in calculations, and the EC should assist automotive industry investment. 
 Not everyone shared Calvet's fear. 
 Speaking at the launch of the Mercedes 500E, chairman Werner Neifer was succinct. 
 &bquo;Japan is our biggest export market and we have seen what protectionism has done for the US automotive industry.&equo; 
 The understated 500E Mercedes saloon stole production car honours at Paris, that is if you believe the Porsche &mdash; which will build the car &mdash; definition of production: 12 cars a day, 2400 a year. 
 Built in left-hand-drive form only, a mere 125 a year of the 155mph saloon will reach the UK, starting around mid-year at a price expected to be close to &pound;52,000. 
 Longer intake pipes for the now microchip-controlled injection system means the 5-litre, 32-valve V8 develops 354lb ft of torque, up 22lb ft, though maximum power of 326bhp remains unchanged. 
 Mercedes' traction control system is standard. 
 Even with the four-speed automatic, the 3740lb four-seater can reach 60mph in 6.1 seconds, to make the 500E quicker even than the 500SL. 
 New 8J&times;16ins alloy wheels, under subtly flared wheelarches, distinguishing the 500E from other W124s. 
 We saw Mitsubishi's Sigma &mdash; albeit with a different roofline and a Diamante badge &mdash; last year in Tokyo, but Paris was the &bquo;Europeanised&equo; version's EC debut and the only other new production car here. 
 The first of the UK's 300 cars arrives in March next year with a &pound;26,000 price tag. 
 With demand for the Diamante and the Starion GTO/Dodge Stealth so high &mdash; they share platforms and mechanicals &mdash; the UK gets only one version, but it comes loaded with goodies. 
 The 3-litre 24-valve V6 will drive the front wheels exclusively through a four-speed auto 'box, but fitted with traction control with steering-angle input, four-wheel steer and adaptive damping. 
 It's the first four, maybe five, new cars that Mitsubishi will launch in the UK next year, including new Spacewagons and Shoguns. 
 Ferrari chose to hide its two-pedal Mondial on component supplier Valeo's stand in the faint hope of convincing people its clutchless transmission was no more than a experimental engineering car. 
 In fact it will be optional on Mondials by mid 1991. 
 The transmission uses the existing gearbox and gear lever, and retains the exposed gate operating via an electrically controlled clutch that regulates the speed of the change via the position of the accelerator pedal. 
 So effective is the system that 0.2 secs is shaved from the car's 0&ndash;60mph time. 
 Initially Ferrari estimates 25 per cent of Mondials will be ordered with the clutch, but during 1992 plans to make it available for the 348, too. 
 Xavier de la Chapelle was quietly enjoying his first Paris show as the new boss of MVS, now called Venturi &mdash; once the name of the car. 
 But his happy demeanour isn't likely to last, because not only has he got the move to a new premises in Nantes to handle, along with the updating of the 300 coupe and convertibles he'll build next year to use Renault's up-and-coming 24-valve V6, he's also got the De la Chapelle Parcours in his hands. 
 The Parcours is  monsterous , the size of a Rolls-Royce Silver Spur with room for seven or eight, powered along in executive comfort by a Mercedes-Benz 32-valve V8. 
 Production plans &mdash; such as they are &mdash; call for five of the tube-framed, composite-bodied Parcours to be built next year for research, development and type approval, and for annual production after that to run around 100 cars a year. 
 Meanwhile, another Frenchman, Parisian florist Patrick Veyrat, despairing of finding a no-compromise sports car, decided to build his own. 
 The result is a mid-engined sports racing car for the road that borrows its styling from the Pininfarina Mythos. 
 Powered by a standard 200bhp Alfa V6, the Veyrat 630VS has been designed by French race car manufacturer, Arc, and uses a rose-jointed, double-wishbone suspension and both carbon-fibre and riveted alloy panels. 
 The two prototypes on display weigh just 1870lb. 
 Veyrat promises that by the time the first of 20 &pound;40,000 sports cars are built by June 1001, weight will still be under 2000lb and acceleration electrifying. 
 At the other end of the scale GM's long-expressed desire to achieve significant sales of its US cars in Europe has finally settled down to more realistic levels. 
 Sales of the 20 US models imported &mdash; from a total US range of 125 &mdash; are expected to reach just over 20,000 this year, rising to 30,000 in 1991, and reaching 50,000 by 1994, half the levels first forecast. 
 GM's top-selling models are the Chevrolet Beretta and Corsica and Pontiac Trans-Sport. 
 Chrysler, meanwhile, is having more success with its Cherokee 4wd and Voyager minibus ranges and expects to move 50,000 cars in 1990, followed by a modest increase next year. 
 Giugiaro continues to dominate Seat's future product plans, giving the company the Latin feel deemed essential by the bosses at VW. 
 The versatility of his latest concept car, the Proto C &mdash; an easily converted coupe, cabrio, dune-buggy or speedster &mdash; attempts to extend the egg-shaped Proto T design theme to a front or 4wd sports car. 
 Seat claims the C is a feasible exercise and is seriously considering production with engines ranging from a 1-litre four to a six with 200bhp. 
 But the chances of Paris opening the decade with a momentous show were always dashed when the Germans held back the three most significant new cars still due this year &mdash; the new Audi 100 and BMW 3-series in a matter of weeks and the Mercedes S-Class by months. 
 In fairness none of them appeared at the Berlin show that began only two days after Paris, a show signalling a new frontier for the German manufacturers, who may just, in 10 years' time, give the French as much to think about as the Japanese do.  
 Renault set show alight with electric-blue Laguna concept sports car (above), complemented by Citroen's Activa II (far left). 
 Understated Mercedes 500E (left) made debut 
 Mitsubishi Sigma (right) joined 500E (below) as only production car debuts. 
 Sigma hits UK in March, costing &pound;26,000. 
 Clio convertible study (above) made by EBS, which also converts R5s 
 Renault design boss, Patrick le Quement, poses proudly by his team's brightest creation, the Laguna (left). 
 Laguna borrows 21 Turbo's 2-litre unit along with double-wishbone suspension 
 Laguna will join GTA Le Mans (right) on Alpine's production line if car gets go-ahead. 
 Renault Clio (below) sat alongside 16-valve Chamade (bottom), both due in UK next spring 
 Venturi has busy time ahead with Renault's planned V6 to fit into convertible (above) and launch of huge eight-seater Parcours (right) with its 32-valve Merc V8 
 US MPVs are enjoying moderate success in Europe with GM's Pontiac Trans-Sport (above) and Chrysler's Voyager (left). 
 GM has radically revised its sales targets 
 Giugiaro (above) designs Seat's future with Proto C concept car (left), which can be a coupe, cabrio, dune-buggy or speedster. 
 Seat also claims a 4wd sports car is possible 
 Ferrari hid Mondial with clutchless transmission on Valeo stand (right). 
 Destined also for 348 (below right) in 1992? 
 Fiat boss Agnelli (below). 
 Veyrat (bottom) sports prototype weighs just 1870lb 
 Head-hunting 
 Richard Feast goes in search of the motor industry big wigs making an appearance at the Paris show 
 You can tell the heavy hitters at these international shows by the sizes of their entourages. 
 The bigger the wig, the longer the retinue of courtiers. 
 The Paris show's clear champion was the urbane Giovanni Agnelli, attended by most of Fiat's commissioned officers. 
 By contrast, local lads Raymond Levy of Renault and Jacques Calvet of Peugeot (on left) seemed almost provincial princes. 
 Calvet did, however, score bonus marks for his anti-Japan/Britain tirade. 
 Few other company executives were in the running, not even the cigar-chomping Lee Iacocca of Chrysler. 
 He's usually good value for a bit of earthy wisdom and wit but managed to miss his own press conference this time. 
 Pehr Gyllenhammar, the Volvo group's head honcho, is a rare show visitor. 
 But he consummately ad-libbed his way through a largely secret press meeting, attended by Lennart Jeansson, now one month into his new job as president of Volvo Car Corporation. 
 Werner Niefer, the top man at Mercedes-Benz, was on hand but otherwise, German industry chiefs were thinner on the ground than usual with the unification celebrations in Berlin. 
 Paris may have slipped behind Birmingham in the calendar this year but it hardly seemed to matter. 
 It remains a glittering international occasion. 
 Busy industry bosses seem to prefer the cosmopolitan chaos of Paris to the charms of Birmingham. 
 DISPATCHES 
 &bull; Chrysler again wheeled out its &bquo;two-cars-in-one&equo; concept, the Plymouth Voyager, complete with its display, splitting and joining, splitting and joining. 
 It did it all day, or nearly. 
 &bquo;It's done six Auto shows, and 26 stops on Iacocca's '90s tour and its never failed once,&equo; said its minder. 
 &bquo;That is until the BBC came along.&equo; 
 &bull; Not everybody liked the Renault Laguna. 
 One leading designer said he liked it when he saw the front, until he realised the &bquo;front&equo; was the back. 
 &bull; After the actions of one manufacturer to offer some comfort to tired hacks at Birmingham two weeks ago (Mitsubishi's &bquo;Survival Kit&equo; included &bquo;electronically tested articles&equo;) the Paris show organisers offered some after-shave as part of the press kit. 
 What next? 
 A Brian Ferry record and a smoking jacket? 
 &bull; Logistics worthy of the Ninth Army's move to the Gulf saw all the stands arrive, intact with exhibits at Paris having left Birmingham straight after the show closed there on Sunday night. 
 Some manufacturers, however, played safe and dug out old stands from the attic. 
 Some displays were three-years old but the general feeling was never again. 
 &bull; Heuliez, specialist manufacturer of buses, coaches, ambulances and original equipment sunroofs, had two pretty little concept cars to promote the group's design and prototype-build facility. 
 The Scarabee d'Or is based on the upcoming AX 4wd and, says Heuliez, is a homage to the first crossing of the Sahara, led by Andre Citroen in December 1922. 
 The little convertible is joined by another, fixed-head version, the Ag&aacute;des. 
 The new company also showed a new formula for a race car based around the 2-litre, four-cylinder, 16-valve engines that nearly all the big manufacturers have (See sports news). 
 DISPATCHES 
 &bull; Alberto Fava, general manager of Fiat, launched Operazione Valora  at Paris, a response to Fiat's falling domestic market share. 
 The plan amounts to substantial price cuts, aimed at Ford's Fiesta, which has achieved record sales in Italy. 
 Fiat has improved equipment levels across the board and a 1.1 Uno now casts what the 1-litre used to cost. 
 So far, only Italy is involved but there's a plan to widen the operation to other European countries. 
 &bull; Tom Matano, father of the MX-5 and head of Mazda's Californian design studio, echoed the thoughts of many when he said of Citroen's Activa II: &bquo;That's what the BMW 850i should have looked like.&equo; 
 &bull; Chrysler's vice-president of Internal Operations, Joey Cappy, claims Chrysler is in a &bquo;strong cash position&equo; and will spend &pound;8.25 billion on new products over the next five years. 
 &bull; A former Ford designer, and the man responsible for the trend-setting Sierra and Scorpio, on the new Escort, &bquo;What do you want me to say? 
 It's a timid design, a commercial product, but no more than that.&equo; 
 &bull; Asked about rumours of his apparently imminent move from his position as managing director of Lotus, Michael Kimberley suggested we ask GM Europe president Bob Eaton, who has responsibility for the sports car maker. 
 &bquo;He's there for as long as he wants to be,&equo; said Eaton. 
 &bquo;And I'm not moving&equo;, said Kimberley. 
 &bull; Far from displaying its &bquo;import fighting&equo; Saturn, GM revealed it currently has no plans to sell the car in Europe because it would probably grab sales away from Opel and Vauxhall. 
 &bull; Mercedes has announced a formal co-operation with tuners AMG. 
 Following its failure to buy the company, Mercedes has announced that all AMG cars and accessories can be ordered through its dealers. 
 ANALYSIS 
 Hooray for the lean times! 
 Our new world industry correspondent, Richard Feast, casts a critical eye over recent motor show offerings, and concludes that Japan's &bquo;lean&equo; production methods give them the opportunity to offer imaginative and stimulating new models 
 Looking at all the brightest and best on display in Birmingham, I was reminded of some comments made in the early '80s by the late Gordon Brown, then head of design for GM's European passenger cars. 
 I had suggested all cars would inevitably look the same, as rival designers struggled to meet the same constraints dictated by safety requirements and ever-better fuel economy. 
 More accommodation had to be packaged into smaller shapes, air flows had to be optimised, and weights had to be reduced. 
 Brown didn't see it that way. 
 The designer's job had only just begun, he said. 
 He mentioned the many shapes created by nature, pointing out how different all birds are even though they are all subject to the same aerodynamic rules. 
 Similarly, there are thousands of fish varieties, all subject to the same laws of hydrodynamics. 
 He was right, of course. 
 But what Brown had overlooked was the First Rule of the Conventional Car Maker: sell as many of the same cars as you can in order to make the most money for the least expenditure. 
 The car makers call it economies of scale. 
 Thus the modern saloon and hatchback has to be all things to all people. 
 Its design must offend no one, appeal to both sexes and all ages, social groups, nationalities. 
 In the process, it loses individuality. 
 The introduction of the Ford Sierra was a turning point. 
 When Ford replaced the upright (and well loved) Cortina with the rounded (and alien) Sierra, it was forced to spend a fortune on advertising and promotion to establish it in the market. 
 Ford was tooled up to produce Sierra in meganumbers, but the car's then-unusual shape put off many potential customers. 
 In the end, Sierra proved a success. 
 But it proved an expensive success, and in these straitened times, everybody is playing safe. 
 To use Gordon Brown's analogy, we are being offered sparrows and sticklebacks. 
 The new cars at Birmingham, and at this week's Paris show, boast a sterility of design that even transcends generations. 
 The all-new Sparrow Mk3, on which the company has invested so much, looks indistinguishable to the layman from the Mk2, which was little changed from the Mk1. 
 But there is hope. 
 It comes from Japan, and has been identified in a forthcoming book, The machine that changed the world. 
 In it, authors James Womack, Daniel Jones and Daniel Roos, writing as a team representing the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, coin the term &bquo;lean&equo; production. 
 It is set to become one of the buzz-words of the '90s. 
 Lean production, with its emphasis on team work, responsibility, flexibility and quality, embraces everything from research and development to design, manufacturing, component supplies and distribution. 
 Using lean production, the authors found the Japanese required just over half the engineering time, half the number of people, and only two-thirds the lead time as their European rivals to produce similar cars. 
 With lean production, they say, Japanese manufacturers more of less doubled the number of models they offered between 1982 and the '90s, at the same time replacing them every four years. 
 By contrast, western manufactures spent the '80s living off the volume generated by their existing models and their once-a-decade replacements. 
 Lean production has enabled Japanese manufactures to move into niches previously denied them. 
 It has produced luxury cars such as the Lexus and Nissan Infiniti, affordable sports cars &mdash; the Mazda MX-5 and Honda CRX &mdash; mean machines &mdash; Nissan 300ZX and Mitsubishi 3000GT &mdash; and a supercar, the Honda NSX. 
 Nissan has taken the whole thing one step further with its series of weird and cute limited production models. 
 Be-1, Pao and S-Cargo, made in small volumes and sold in Japan at premiums over the Micra model on which they are based, may not be to everyone's taste. 
 They are unashamedly retro in their appeal, but they could equally be futuristic. 
 Or just different. 
 Whatever the merits of their looks, enough customers loved them for them to be sold out. 
 And they have done wonders for improving Nissan's stodgy old image in Japan. 
 It is lean production at its meanest. 
 It is also the sort of competitive edge that wins customers &mdash; and makes competitors uncomfortable. 
 There is a growing band of buyers who want something more distinctive and who are prepared to pay extra for it. 
 For buyers, that rarity would be assured by total production of only 20,000 compared with 2 million for the model on which it is based. 
 The sooner car maker take this development seriously, the happier the car buyer will be. 
 The scope is endless. 
 What about a stylised Anglia built off the new Ford Escort/Orion? 
 A Saab 96-like model off the platform of the Vauxhall Astra? 
 A 90's version of the Morris Minor using the latest Metro as a starting point? 
 If Nissan can do it, why can't other car makers?  
 VW's striking Futura concept car (left) can even park itself, but all public will get is efficient but mundane Golf MkIII (right) 
 THIS WEEK ARRIVALS 
 Polo moves in on &bquo;hot&equo; brigade 
 Despite being only a facelift of the current range, the new Polo manages to lose its tired old image &mdash; and it comes not a moment too soon, says Andrew Frankel 
 The Volkswagen Polo has been reborn. 
 No longer is it the slow, old relative of a young family of quick and strong cars. 
 It may have been ignored since 1981 and left to make do with just two small engines (and thus no way of cashing in on the ever-increasing popularity of the hot supermini in Britain) but all that's changed now. 
 Heading the attack by the restyled and mechanically tweaked Polos is the supercharged G40 packing a 113bhp punch aimed squarely at the Peugeot 205GTi's jaw. 
 And if it really will do 122mph and manage 0&ndash;62mph in 8.6 secs, it's going to hurt. 
 But from November until the G40 arrives here next May, performance devotees will have the 75bhp Polo GT to sample. 
 This uses the same 1272cc engine as the G40 but without the unique G-lader blower. 
 With fuel injection and a catalytic  convertor  (which will be standard on all petrol-engined Polos) Volkswagen claims 12.1secs for the 0&ndash;62mph dash and a top whack of 107mph. 
 Not enough to worry the likes of the 85bhp Citroen AX GT perhaps, but more than competition for the 75bhp Metro GTa. 
 Mechanically the entry level Polos remain the same, bar the adoption of fuel injection. 
 These comprise a 55bhp version of the 1272cc engine and, below that, a short-stroke 1043cc unit giving out 45bhp. 
 There's also a 48bhp, 1398cc diesel engine, but VW has yet to decide when to introduce it to the UK, although September 1991 looks the most likely time. 
 Three body styles &mdash; hatchback, coupe and saloon &mdash; will be imported, although the hatch will remain the volume seller, followed closely by the coupe, the only body fitted with the G40 engine. 
 The saloon, which only has two doors and is not sold in Germany, will account for just a tiny fraction of the 37,000 cars Volkswagen intends to export to Britain during 1991. 
 What's clear is that the Polo is not the all-new supermini Volkswagen would have you believe. 
 The styling has been rounded off at each end and VW house-style rectangular headlights have been fitted. 
 But seen in profile all the body shapes look similar to the outgoing models. 
 Under the skin, the same MacPherson strut front and semi-trailing arm rear suspension is found, albeit with revised spring rates, and even the G40 engine was seen in extremely limited numbers as part of a VW feasibility study back in 1987. 
 Still, although many would argue that the exterior changes have robbed the Polo of its identity and turned it into yet another Eurobland shopping car, at least it no longer looks dated. 
 Aerodynamics have also been improved by 10 per cent, although the overall Cd is still an unimpressive 0.35. 
 The biggest visible improvement is inside. 
 In place of the bland old dashboard there is a new instrument binnacle presenting clear, unambiguous information with real style. 
 Gone, too, are the cheap sliding lever controls for the ventilation. 
 In their place comes attractive rotary dials while the rest of the ancillary switches are similarly sourced from the Passat. 
 A quick blast in the G40 is enough to confirm its place in the junior hot-hatch line up. 
 Subjectively it feels every bit as fast as its maker claims, but what really impresses is the torque. 
 The way it explodes from a standing start suggests that other manufacturers plying multi-valve routes to high specific outputs should at least take a look at this alternative means of forced induction. 
 110lb ft of torque at 4400rpm may not sound like much, but in reality the G40 is so near this peak figure from idle to red line that the overall effect is much more impressive than a car that makes you wait until the revcounter is half-way round its scale before it gets going. 
 Given the unpleasant blare of the G40 motor, though, it's just as well it delivers such strong performance low down as prolonged exposure to high revs is tiresome and uncomfortable. 
 The chassis has mixed abilities, too. 
 Wearing 175/60 Continental tyres, it has nothing like the grip of a 205 GTi, nor does it have the Peugeot's steering feel. 
 Yet, if nothing else, it is an enthusiastic cornerer. 
 Once you're used to the lack of feel coming through the rim of the steering wheel, you can chuck the G40 into a corner, stabilise the understeer with a balanced throttle and belt round, gradually turning the power back on as the exit opens up. 
 What the suspension revisions have achieved is a fine ride. 
 We were invited to drive the cars in west Germany where the smooth road surface always flatters cars' suspensions, but even when we nipped into what used to be east Germany and drove on roads that did not seem to have been maintained since the war, the G40's bump suppression was admirable. 
 Even when the surface degenerated into an irregularly cobbled dirt track, the G40's composure was  unflabbable . 
 It also emerged without a squeak or rattle, which confirms that VW's solid construction standards still lead the field. 
 The Polo GT is less pleasing. 
 Like the G40, it impresses with its throttle response and low-rev urge, but while the supercharged car is merely annoyingly noisy at speed, the GT brings a headache. 
 Its biggest problem is a resounding thrum at 4000&ndash;4500 rpm that booms around the cabin. 
 Unfortunately this coincides exactly with its ideal cruising speed. 
 On slightly narrower 165/65 section tyres it seems to grip almost as well as the G40, while its steering seems, if anything, a tad sharper. 
 But perhaps it would be better to save some money and plump for the 55bhp CL version instead. 
 That avoids the high-rev histrionics of the GT through a quieter engine and longer gearing, making it a much more relaxing car to drive long-distance. 
 It also lacks the rear anti-roll bar of the GT and, with taller 155/70 tyres, its ride is even more accomplished as a result. 
 VW has high hopes for the Polo in this country. 
 Despite competing in a market that is shrinking fast, it reckons the extra appeal of the GT and G40 should increase 1991 sales by 7000 over the 30,000 sold last year. 
 For those looking for traditional VW strengths such as build quality, ergonomics, a fine driving position and finish, it should suit well. 
 But if you are looking for a 21st century Polo, you will have to wait at least three years until the genuinely all-new one. 
 Until then the Polo is no more than a worthy evolution of a familiar species and merely addresses the most urgent problems that nearly 10 years of standing still have created. 
 At last, six years after the Peugeot 205GTi, there is a sporting Polo, with better aerodynamics and a modern interior. 
 VW has yet to finalise specification and prices for the Polos, but it has said they will cost much the same as the models they replace. 
 So expect around &pound;6000 for the most basic 1-litre car rising to around &pound;9000 for a GT model. 
 In an effort to increase Coupe sales, this traditionally more expensive bodyshape will now cost the same as the hatchback. 
 No indication has yet been given of the price of the G40, but it will need to retail for less than &pound;11,000 to keep the GTi in touch.  
 Profile reveals that new Polo owes much to old car; driving position good, as is rear entry with low lip; GT engine gives 75bhp 
 Switchgear is much improved; G40 engine packs 113bhp punch 
 THIS WEEK SPORT 
 WSPC 
 Mass clinches Mexico finale 
 The Schlesser/Baldi Mercedes was disqualified but Jochen Mass was on hand. 
 Quentin Spurring reports, photographs by Bryn Williams/ Words and Pictures 
 The finale of the 1990 World Sports-Prototype Championship, in Mexico City on Sunday, was a spectacular, topsy-turvy affair. 
 Jaguar and Nissan, as if to celebrate the swansong of their turbocars, threw caution to the winds, and took the fight to Mercedes-Benz with devil-may-care enthusiasm. 
 The drivers of the all-conquering Silver Arrows had to work very, very hard to overcome these challenges but the race was decided by an extraordinary series of mishaps that befell this normally super-slick team. 
 Jochen Mass, after a fine middle shift by his co-driver Michael Schumacher, was leading the race by 42secs with 15 laps to go, when a sudden rain shower sent the drivers scurrying to the pits for grooved tyres. 
 Mass, the most accomplished veteran of Sportscar racing, was just passing the pits entrance when the slight drizzle turned into a downpour: he had a torrid time out there on Autodromo Hermanos Rodriguez, spending almost 3 minutes slithering around to the pits. 
 Mauro Baldi in the other Mercedes was more fortunate. 
 He stopped at the first opportunity, and emerged with a lead of 45secs. 
 Mass drove his heart out in an effort to make amends for what he regarded as his mistake but Baldi was 21secs ahead at the finish. 
 He seemed to have clinched a seventh victory with his partner, Jean-Louis Schlesser, putting the icing on the cake of their shared world championship. 
 Half an hour after the finish the stewards disqualified the Schlesser/Baldi Mercedes on the grounds that it had been given a tenth of a litre more than its 246-litre fuel allowance. 
 Mass's mistake had been overshadowed by the tiniest error by his rival's pit crew. 
 &bquo;OK, I understand that rules are rules,&equo; commented the surprised and generous victor. 
 &bquo;But it isn't fair that two drivers can race hard for almost three hours, and then be disqualified because a mechanic took a microsecond too long to close a valve.&equo; 
 Mass was being diplomatic: the hand on the refuelling rig was that of team boss Peter Sauber. 
 The final irony was that it was unnecessary, anyway. 
 In post-race scrutineering it was revealed that the car had 25 litres of fuel left in the tank. 
 This was the first time this season that the number one Mercedes, which suffered all weekend from a curious instability on the bumpiest section of the 2.75 mile track, did not start a WSPC race from the front row. 
 The &bquo;nervousness&equo; of the Schlesser/Baldi Mercedes persisted into race day. 
 After Brundle's Jaguar took off like a scalded cat, it was Mass who hunted it down, and soon engaged it in a lurid battle. 
 Several times he had the nose of his car in front, only to be thwarted by some brave late-braking by the Jaguar man. 
 Finally, on the sixth lap, Mass got around Brundle at the end of the long pits straight, and gave him an old-fashioned chop as he turned into Moises Solona Corner. 
 Baldi, who had been watching the show, now tried to find a way around the Jaguar for himself. 
 It took him 14 more laps before he could squeeze alongside Brundle, and run him wheel-to-wheel through the same right-left-right triple turn. 
 Brundle chose this moment to come into the pits. 
 For a while, his V6 had been misfiring, the voltage (and power output) dropping. 
 A new battery was fitted and Brundle continued, but only the driver was charging. 
 In the handover to Jan Lammers, another new battery was fitted, and then another in an unscheduled stop. 
 This time, the electrical system was dead when Lammers tried to restart the engine. 
 All the while, Julian Bailey had been maintaining a strong, gritty pursuit with the Nissan, and he was only 7secs behind Baldi's second-placed Mercedes when he made his fuel stop early on lap 31. 
 After the second Mercedes had stopped, Schlesser emerged from a shorter pitstop 8secs in front of Schumacher. 
 But it was the Nissan, Mark Blundell at the wheel, that now headed the field. 
 And Blundell put on a great performance, fending off the Mercedes until both were caught by Schumacher. 
 In the general confusion of a heady battle the German F3 champion demoted Schlesser to third. 
 Schlesser, in fact, was in trouble. 
 During the opening shift, Baldi had found the car suffering from a worsening front-end vibration. 
 It transpired that the left side of the nose splitter  has  been damaged, perhaps when Baldi had clipped Brundle's Jaguar in one of his passing attempts, perhaps as a result of &bquo;trapped&equo; vibration from a high-speed engine misfire. 
 Whatever: three laps into Schlesser's shift, the splitter broke. 
 The handling became worse, and the airflow was impaired, so that Schlesser's water temperature began to rise. 
 Reluctantly, he dropped his pace. 
 Schumacher, setting the fastest lap of the race in the process, finally got past Blundell just before half-distance. 
 As the Nissan driver concentrated on bringing his car into the fuel window, prior to the final handover to Bailey, Schlesser also caught him in spite of his reduced performance. 
 After the second fuel stops, Mass resumed with a lead of 52secs over Baldi, with Bailey another 27 secs down and under threat from the Jaguar of Andy Wallace and Davy Jones. 
 Wallace, in fact, now closed down the Nissan, and had just taken third position when the rain fell. 
 Like Mass, both men were caught out. 
 Like several other drivers, they spun almost in unison, but it was the Nissan that made it back to the pits first. 
 Over the last few laps of the race, with all the cars on wet-weather tyres and racing in a steady drizzle, Bailey lost more ground to both the Mercedes. 
 He finished the race, nevertheless, still more than 20secs ahead of the Jaguar. 
 After a determined drive from Gianfranco Brancatelli and an unwell Kenneth Acheson, the other Nissan came home fourth, &bquo;Branca&equo; having been stranded on the grid when the V8 would not start, therefore starting dead last. 
 Joest Racing's factory Porsches were fifth and sixth. 
 Hans Stuck having survived an uncharacteristic spin during the rain with the car he shared with Jonathan Palmer. 
 Keke Rosberg and Jean-Pierre Jabouille, to their delight, secured a finish for the new Peugeot in its second race. 
 The little V10 car was hardly competitive at the 6000ft altitude, but one of the highlights of the weekend was Rosberg's all-out qualifying lap, only three seconds away from pole. 
 Probably with only about 430bhp at his disposal, this was an astonishing performance by Rosberg. 
 In the race, the 905 was delayed by tyre, ignition and handling problems but, after Rosberg had revelled in the rain, it was there at the finish, 13th.   
 Nissan of Bailey and Blundell put up a strong challenge and took second (above left). 
 Wallace and Jones gave Jaguar a deserved third, two laps behind the winner 
 Caught on slick tyres on a wet track, Mass seemed to have blown it (above) but No 1 Merc was disqualified for fuel infringement. 
 Peugeot finished 13th 
 Prost-Mansell rift continues 
 Alain Prost launched into a new attack on team-mate Nigel Mansell after the Spanish Grand Prix last week. 
 Far from moderating his condemnation of Mansell's start-line performance in Estoril the previous week, the world champion stuck to his allegation that Mansell had deliberately tried to push him off the track. 
 Despite Mansell's denials, technical data leaked from Ferrari sources appear to support Prost's contentions. 
 Among the most important evidence to emerge from analysis of Mansell's start are that his Ferrari was not lined up straight and telemetry on the Ferrari indicated that he had fiercely defended his position, turning right twice to close out Prost. 
 Mansell's reaction in Spain was forthright. 
 &bquo;When the red light changed, I gave it a big welly-full. 
 I lit my tyres up and went sideways. 
 &bquo;I admitted all this last week. 
 Straight after I got out of my car I went to Alain to apologise but he didn't want to accept. 
 That's his prerogative. 
 And I accept that he might have been upset but there are no polemics, so why destroy a great victory? 
 I won the race, I took three points from McLaren and from Ayrton Senna.&equo; 
 Last week Prost admitted that his reaction to the incident in Portugal had been perhaps &bquo;slightly exaggerated.&equo; 
 &bull; Announcing his decision to &bquo;unretire&equo; himself and return to the Williams team next year, Nigel Mansell issued a wordy statement which posed many more questions than it answered. 
 Explaining his decision, he originally felt that he &bquo;would be very unlikely ever to have available the full weight of a team and a manufacturer to give me what should be a reasonable opportunity (to win the championship).&equo; 
 However, he seems to have overlooked the fact that Ferrari gave him two race wins last year and that the Scuderia's tally of six victories this year is four more than Williams was able to score. 
 Van de Poele strengthens F1 claim 
 Eric Van de Poele scored a timely win in the penultimate round of the F3000 championship, reinforcing his claims for an F1 drive with the Modena Lamborghini team. 
 Despite qualifying sixth, the Reynard driver made a superb start and was in second place by the first corner, taking the lead from Gianni Morbidelli's Lola by the end of the lap. 
 As the circuit dried, he stopped for slicks and was not threatened until held up when lapping tail-enders. 
 New F3000 champion Erik Comas closed in but spun when trying to lap Andrew Gilbert Scott. 
 Comas recovered, although he was further delayed by Damon Hill, to finish second ahead of Morbidelli. 
 The remaining points went to Tamburini, Apicella and Bartels. 
 IN BRIEF 
 Martin Brundle will return  to F1 next year as number one driver with Brabham, the team he left at the end of 1989 to join the Jaguar WSPC team. 
 Mika Hakkinen won the final  round of the British F3 Championship at Silverstone, beating Christian Fittipaldi and Steve Robertson after early leader Mika Salo retired. 
 Victory fell to Robb Gravett  in the last race of this year's Esso British Touring Car Championship. 
 The series winner forced his way past rival Andy Rouse four laps from the finish. 
 &bquo;Rubbish&equo; is how Ron Dennis  described our recent report that Ayrton Senna had demanded a personal motorhome and other perks from McLaren in 1991. 
 &bquo;It made Ayrton, in my opinion, look very cheap,&equo; said the McLaren chief. 
 &bquo;And if there's one thing he's not, it's cheap&hellip;&equo; 
 Gerhard Berger escaped  unhurt from a heavy accident while testing tyres at Estoril last week. 
 A carbon-fibre brake disc shattered as he slowed from high speed, and his McLaren crashed into a guard rail. 
 Two of the Williams  F1 team's senior personalities will be leaving at the end of the year. 
 Team manager Michael Cane and commercial executive Colin Cordy have become partners in a Formula 3000 team to be based in South Oxfordshire. 
 Now that Ferrari  is virtually certain to stay with Goodyear in 1992, Pirelli is courting Benneton with promises of &bquo;exclusive&equo; tyres that would not be available to other &bquo;customer&equo; teams. 
 Minardi F1 driver  Paulo Barilla, who took his drive from Spain's Luis Perez Sala at last year's Japanese Grand Prix, has himself been displaced exactly one year later. 
 Ferrari test driver Gianni Morbidelli, 22, is expected to get Barilla's place in the last two grand prix of the season. 
 Comas signed by Ligier 
 Newly-crowned Formula 3000 champion Erik Comas is to be Thierry Boutsen's team-mate at Ligier next year. 
 Comas has become the most successful driver in the history of the F3000. 
 With six wins from the last 12 F3000 races, Comas has shown great coolness under fire. 
 The technological details of the 1991 Ligier-Lamborghini V12-powered chassis have yet to be decided. 
 The chassis will be designed by Anglo-Brazilian Ricardo Divila, but Guy Ligier received a major disappointment recently when ex-Tyrrell aerodynamicist Jean-Claude Migeot turned down an attractive offer. 
 &bull; Also confirmed for 1991: Frenchman Eric Bernard and Japan's Aguri Suzuki will stay with Larrousse. 
 New racing formula mooted at Paris 
 French coach builder Heuliez used this week's Paris show to propose a new international sports car Formula &mdash; SP2. 
 SP2 is for single-seater &mdash; Cam Am-style &mdash; cars with 2-litre 16-valve engines, turbocharged to produce 4000bhp. 
 Heuliez believes that enough major car makers have such engines in production for the series to become a success on a European, and, eventually, a worldwide basis. 
 The car displayed in Paris (above) had a Heuliez-developed turbocharged version of Renault's 16-valve 2-litre, but all the major European manufacturers &mdash; Fiat, Volkswagen, Peugeot, Ford, General Motors and Mercedes &mdash; have similar units. 
 And although turbocharging is proposed, a limiting pop-off valve would restrict power to 400bhp. 
 The chassis in Heuliez's first SP2 car, dubbed the SP2 WR, is made from honeycombed aluminium and uses double wishbone suspension all round. 
 The cast-iron disc brakes work with four-pot calipers and it rides on 10ins rims at the front and 14ins at the rear. 
 The engine drives through a Hewland DGB 'box. 
 The whole mechanical package is fully enclosed in composite bodywork and weighs in at 121lb. 
 The pretty green-and-white single-seater is 181ins long and 72ins wide &mdash; about the size of an F3000 car &mdash; although its weight is more on par with an F1 car. 
 Safari Rally debut for Nissan Sunny 
 Nissan will enter the four-wheel-drive turbocharged rally age with its Sunny GTI-R. 
 It plans a four-event world championship programme for 1991, starting on its happy hunting ground, the Safari Rally. 
 Still devoid of a current top-line superstar as a number one driver, it plans to contest these rallies with its test driver Stig Blomqvist, gaining full experience for a full championship season in 1992. 
 Shown recently in full Group A form in Japan, the 2-litre Sunny GTI-R (right) will feature the smallest bodywork in top class rallying and, at 230bhp, the most powerful engine in its class in production form. 
 Few details of the Group A specification car have been announced, but most of its assets are expected to stem from the basic design rather than special tuning. 
 The most important design features are a large intercooler (mounted horizontally atop the engine) and the four throttle valve chambers with straight inlet porting. 
 Disadvantages may be the restricted size of the wheels (14ins are standard, 16ins for competition) and the short wheelbase (2340mm). 
 A major change in Nissan's plans is the intention to run the whole rally programme from Britain. 
 Previously, it has developed its cars in Japan and delegated the competition activities to each country. 
  Martin Holmes  
 Englishmen triumph in Toohey's 1000 
 Englishmen Win Percy and Allan Grice defied the odds to take victory in Australia's most famous motor race, the Toohey's 1000. 
 Their Holden Racing Team (HRT) Commodore V8, which the pundits claimed was dated and slow, outlasted a pack of Ford Sierras and a Nissan Skyline GT-R to take the flag a mere 15sec ahead of Paul Radisich and Jeff Allam, driving Dick Johnson's second Shell Sierra Cosworth. 
 Larry Perkins and Tomas Mezera underlined the Holden's newfound competitiveness by finishing third, after being held in the pit lane when the race was under a yellow flag/pace car caution. 
 Peter Brock and Andy Rouse fought back to fourth place, following an incorrect tyre choice and tardy pit stops early on in the race. 
 The key to the Commodore's success was their ability to run reliably and quickly for the full 621 miles. 
 The HRT team &mdash; owned by Tom Walkinshaw and managed by Percy &mdash; became national heroes as the first to win Bathurst in an Australian car since 1987, when Peter Brock was awarded victory after the first and second-placed Texaco Sierras were excluded. 
  Ewen Page   
 THIS WEEK DIARY 
 Eoin Young 
 &bquo;I wonder what happened to all the sanctimonious talk about putting his family first?&equo; 
 It was the luck of the Irish that saved Martin Donnelly. 
 FISA technical man, Charlie Whiting, said it all: &bquo;Martin survived an unsurvivable accident.&equo; 
 It was the most horrifying incident I have ever seen in motor racing. 
 One minute the press room was abuzz with conversation in a variety of tongues, and the next minute it was hushed into a stunned, dumb silence. 
 There on the television monitors was a body lying alone in the middle of the track with his seat still strapped to him like a pilot's parachute pack. 
 It could have been a motorcycle crash. 
 No machine was visible. 
 Donnelly lay like a rag doll for minutes. 
 You can appreciate now that he was unconscious, but in those minutes it looked more terminal. 
 Only later, when we saw the photographs, did we appreciate that Donnelly must have been magicked out of the car at the precise millisecond when the car exploded on impact. 
 A millisecond before and he would have been trapped. 
 A millisecond later doesn't bear considering. 
 Coming just two races after Derek Warwick's phenomenal escape at Monza, Donnelly's accident inevitably brought comparison. 
 On both occasions a Lotus failed to negotiate a fast right-hander. 
 Donnelly was reckoned to be doing 150mph in sixth gear when he plunged off the road. 
 Whiting said the wreckage stopped from that speed in 20 metres and Donnelly was thrown a further 20 metres down the track. 
 Did the car do its job if it was totally destroyed? 
 Harvey Postlethwaite at Tyrrell felt that it did if the driver survived. 
 Williams designer Patrick Head said the car had absorbed 25 times the energy of the 20mph control crash tests each F1 car has to be put through. 
 All the legislation in the world couldn't have coped with an accident of such violence. 
 So Nigel Mansell has made a grand prix comeback without ever having left. 
 I wonder what happened to all the sanctimonious talk about putting his family first for the first time in his life? 
 I was really impressed with that when he told a handful of us after the British Grand Prix that he was retiring at the end of the season. 
 A measure of the man, I thought. 
 Does this mean that his family now takes second place again? 
 Is this a &pound;500,000-a-month ego trip, with Williams in pursuit of the world title that, on present form, seems can only be won by a McLaren-Honda or a Ferrari &mdash; or, more to the point, by Ayrton Senna or Alain Prost? 
 Or has this whole summer for Mansell been a fabrication of what he really felt, a means of getting out of his Ferrari contract by saying he was quitting and then holding Williams to ransom after they had backed themselves into a corner? 
 He did, after all, on two different occasions (Silverstone and Monza) summon us to say that there was no way he would race in F1 in 1991&hellip; and now he is. 
 The Barley Mow tends to be an instant poll of opinion on matters motor racing, and before the Spanish Grand Prix when a Mansell comeback was mooted, one regular announced that he hoped it was true because Nigel was the most exciting British driver anyone could remember. 
 &bquo;If only he'd keep his mouth shut when he gets out of the car and stop whingeing. 
 When he's in the car he's magic. 
 I mean, we all want  to love him, don't we? 
 It's just that he makes it so damn difficult. 
 But then there's the money, I suppose. 
 That's six million  pounds he's getting for a year!&equo; 
 In the cynical world of F1, we tend to accept the number of noughts as a driver's way of keeping score, but the local bricklayer has an acute realisation of what he could afford to buy with &pound;6,000,000! 
 James Hunt was the last British world champion and, after the Mansell comeback announcement, he said: &bquo;At least Williams knows the animal and how to control it. 
 At Ferrari it waited for him to put a foot wrong and there was blood all over the walls.&equo; 
 Hunt thinks Mansell has done the right thing in signing with Williams. 
 &bquo;Ferrari, with Prost and Alesi as a suppressed number two, has no  chance. 
 Nigel has put himself in the right place, and there's no doubt about that.&equo; 
 But I wonder how long the honeymoon will last? 
 When he left Williams for Ferrari, I remember Frank Williams reminiscing at his annual press luncheon that he had fond memories of Alan Jones and Keke Rosberg, but that it would be some time before he had similar memories of Nigel. 
 If you fancy owning the nose cone of Alain Prost's Ferrari, a piston and con-rod from the engine of Jean Alesi's Tyrrell or a steering wheel from Ayrton Senna's Marlboro-McLaren, you should really be at Jackie Stewart's special charity auction of motor sport memorabilia, which is raising funds for the Scottish Dyslexia Trust Fund. 
 It's called &bquo;Ford's Evening with Jackie Stewart and Friends&equo; and Christie's is starting the auction at 7pm on 17 October in George Watsons College, Colinton Road, Edinburgh. 
 There are also paintings and prints by Arthur Benjamins, photographs by Jesse Alexander and Michael Cooper, a couple of Jackie's trophies (second in the 1967 Belgian Grand Prix, second in an F2 race). 
 Rob Walker's pitboard from the 1969 Monaco Grand Prix, various helmets and team uniforms, a Brabham rear wing and an airbox engine-cover from a 1990 Footwork Arrows described as &bquo;slightly damaged&equo; with a letter of authenticity from team boss Jack Oliver. 
 The most unusual item offered in the auction is the special lightweight wrist-brace which Jackie wore after he broke a bone in his wrist in an F2 race at Jarama. 
 He was wearing this brace when he won the 1966 German and Dutch grands prix in the Tyrrell Matra.  
 Is the Mansell comeback saga just water off our Nige's back as he prepares to celebrate his &pound;6 million salary with Williams-Renault? 
 THIS WEEK YOUR VIEW 
 YOUNG COUPLE 
 I was surprised to read A Robertson criticising Eoin Young's Diary column as being boring (&bquo;Your View&equo;, 3 October). 
 It is something I would certainly not agree with and neither would my wife, who always makes that page her first piece of reading when Autocar &amp; Motor  arrives. 
 So before leaping to his defence I waited until another column appeared, which I have tried to read in a less partisan manner. 
 Once again, though, he made the usual pithy Formula 1 comments coupled with amusing anecdotes from the IOM historic jolly, making for a well-balanced, interesting page. 
 No, no Mr Editor, Young must stay! 
  John Aley John Aley Racing Suffolk  
 More Young 
 Please take no notice of the letter from A Robertson. 
 Eoin Young's Diary is the most interesting feature in your magazine &mdash; indeed it is sometimes the only  interesting feature! 
  NF Robinson Ammanford Dyfed  
 Less Young 
 A Robertson is absolutely right. 
 Eoin Young's Diary is  heavy going. 
 Just because the guy can drop names we have all heard of and used to know Bruce McLaren doesn't give him the right to bore us every week. 
 Of course I'm being most unfair, but that's a reader's prerogative. 
 Give Shaun Campbell the column. 
 He is the most entertaining writer on your staff. 
  Peter Herbert Richmond North Yorkshire  
 Hard Knocks 
 Your report on the Escort LX (3 October) must be one of the most peculiar pieces of motoring journalism ever published. 
 What comes through very clearly is that your testers have a very strong anti-Ford, anti-Escort bias. 
 They are nevertheless honest enough to praise the good points of the car but are unable to concede that these points add up to a first-class package. 
 &bull; 
 Among all the knocking your road testers admitted: 
 &bull; Top speed not bad in its class &bull; 0&ndash;60 and 30&ndash;70 times respectable &bull; Well-chosen ratios, change reasonably light &bull; Light, well-cushioned clutch, snatch-free driveline &bull; Generously shod, plenty of grip, corners with composure &bull; Understeers mildly, positions with encouraging precision &bull; Strong, fade-free stopping from high speed &bull; Instruments clear and straightforward &bull; Visibility good &bull; Main controls well placed &bull; Heating and ventilation work well &bull; Decently relaxed as a cruiser 
 This adds up to more good marks than most cars get. 
 If other aspects, such as the seating, draw some criticism (in my opinion justified), well its competitors have their faults too. 
 You should not draw the snide comment that &bquo;average cars are bought by average people &mdash; it can't fail.&equo; 
 This bitchy and unworthy remark tells average people like me far more about the writers than the car. 
 I would suggest they look long and hard at the report they have written and even longer and harder in the mirror. 
 They might be surprised and a little ashamed. 
 Usual disclaimers about having any connections with Ford. 
  R Smith Braunton Devon  
 The point we sought to make, Mr Smith, was that it was ludicrous to assume &mdash; as Ford has &mdash; that millions of people aspire to nothing better than an average car, and to note that the master marketeers will probably get away with peddling mediocrity yet again. 
 It wasn't an attack on Mr Average but the arrogance of Mr Ford. 
 To describe the Escort, as Ford does in its current television ad campaign, as the car that breaks the law of averages sinks the art of cynicism to new and deplorable depths. 
 No one's saying the Escort 1.4LX is a bad car, just dreary and run-of-the-mill &mdash; road test ed. 
 &hellip; 
 HOLLOW NOISE 
 Please don't let the dismay of the pro-Ford lobby colour your judgement in future road tests. 
 It is a scientific fact that empty vessels make the most noise. 
 Your issue of 29 August was the sort that subscriptions are made of. 
  M Duffin Sandy Bedfordshire  
 SPORTING CHOICE 
 In your article on the Jaguar XK120 and Frazer Nash le Mans Replica (&bquo;Great British Sports Cars&equo;, 19 September) you describe the Jaguar as being cheap, costing the equivalent of &pound;16,282 at today's prices. 
 So why, when choosing a &bquo;soul mate&equo;, do you rush to the pedestal on which you place all foreign cars? 
 &bquo;Porsche 944 Cabrio: an honest answer to the XK120.&equo; 
 Why not look at British  first? 
 A truly honest answer to the XK120 today is my 1990 TVR S2, listed at &pound;16,645. 
 This is near enough to the XK120 at today's prices and really cheap in relation to the competition. 
 0&ndash;60mph in 6.8 secs, top speed 136mph &mdash; near enough to the Porsche? 
 Look also at the TVR Griffith at &pound;22,000: 0&ndash;60mph in 4.9secs and a top speed of 150mph limited by its aerodynamically inefficient but superbly designed drophead. 
 I haven't even mentioned the styling, handling, roadholding and build quality. 
  T Smith Rowlands Gill Tyne &amp; Wear  
 Turn to this week's Great British Sports Cars, Mr Smith. 
 You'll find we name the TVRs as &bquo;soul mates&equo; to the Austin-Healey 3000 and AC Cobra &mdash; ed 
 Write to : Autocar &amp; Motor Readers' Letters, 38&ndash;42 Hampton Road, Teddington, Middlesex TW11 OJE or fax 081&ndash;943 5653 
 The editor is not bound to agree with readers' opinions and reserves the right to edit letters 
 Vauxhall Calibra-vs-VW Corrado G60 
 motorshow STAR comparison 
 Coupes are back with a vengeance, great to look at and better to drive. 
 None epitomises this spirit better than Volkswagen's Corrado, here in supercharged G60 form, but Vauxhall's super-sleek 16-valve Calibra is looking like a strong contender for the crown. 
 Over demanding Welsh roads, Martin Vincent referees a showdown between the two. 
 Photography by Peter Burn 
 Just as you thought the coupe for the masses had receded into a misty-eyed memory of metallic-blue Ford Capris and diamond-white Opel Mantas, along comes the Calibra; a practical yet sleek four-seater to set the high-mileage rep's heart alike. 
 At last, a sensible coupe with terrific looks and a main car-maker's badge to make it acceptable to the company accountant and accessible to the ordinary man or woman. 
 After years on the back-burner, the volume-selling coupe looks set for a comeback. 
 But although the sensationally styled Calibra sets the trend, it is by no means the only exponent of the field. 
 The Toyota Celica 2.0 GT, the Audi Coupe, and the Volkswagen Corrado are already making inroads to the UK market. 
 Of these, the most accomplished performer is the Corrado, available in both 16v and, with supercharger, in 160bhp G60 form. 
 What better way to test the mettle of the new Calibra 16v than to pitch it directly against the class best, VW's Corrado G60? 
 The Calibra range starts at a shade under &pound;15,000 but, to attain the level of performance suggested by the aerodynamic styling, the 16-valve 2-litre engine is a must. 
 This develops a lusty 150bhp, but costs &pound;17,595. 
 The Corrado in 16-valve, &pound;16,991 form might seem its obvious rival, but to match performances more closely the G60 Corrado, armed with 160 force-fed horses, is the closer rival. 
 It costs a whopping &pound;19,907 and is currently on offer only as a left-hooker, although right-hand drive will be available towards the end of the year. 
 Park the two coupes together and, despite the disparity in cost, it is the Calibra that exudes more class and style. 
 The Corrado undoubtedly has an endearing and individual appearance with neat, crisp lines, but its dumpy proportions are at odds with a price normally associated with 3-litre executive saloons. 
 PERFORMANCE AND ECONOMY 
 The cars use different methods of producing horsepower. 
 Vauxhall's contender takes the twin-camshaft, fuel-injection, multi-valve route but, unlike so many others, this 16-valver doesn't fall into the trap of developing all of its power at high revs. 
 This one, first seen in the Astra 16v, has a generous spread of torque, although its peak of 145lb ft is fairly high at 4800rpm. 
 A catalytic converter drops power from 156bhp to 150bhp at 6000rpm. 
 Nothing innovative here; just well-proven techniques kept in check by a sophisticated electronic management system to control the ignition and multi-point fuel injection. 
 VW's route to a high specific output for the Corrado G60 is unusual but effective. 
 The use of a supercharger to compress the air and fuel mixture is hardly new: the concept is almost as old as the motor car itself. 
 But modern refinements and materials have brought about a resurgence of the supercharger, making it a credible alternative to the turbo. 
 The Corrado's supercharger sits alongside the transversely mounted engine and is belt-driven off the crankshaft pulley at 1.66 times engine speed. 
 Pressurised air then passes through an intercooler to reduce the charge temperature and hence increase its density on its way to the inlet manifold. 
 The 1781cc four is a development of the Golf GTi's eight-valve unit with digital engine management and multi-point fuel injection. 
 Even with the standard-fit catalyst, the G60 engine develops 160bhp at 5600rpm, and a thumping 166lb ft of torque at 4000rpm, with more than 130lb ft available between 2000 and 6000rpm. 
 As the blower is engine-driven, boost is always on hand, so response is much faster than with a turbocharger. 
 But responsive as the G60's engine is, it lacks the immediacy of the Calibra's and emits a distant but characteristic whine from the compressor. 
 The Calibra 16v is more vocal, though, even unpleasantly so at times, and it lacks the inherent smoothness of the VW's four at high engine speeds. 
 But while the G60 engine is electronically strangled at 6200rpm, the Calibra 16v is willing to go all the way to 7000rpm. 
 Sharp tugs at the Calibra's wheel show that torque steer is definitely present when going hard through the lower gears. 
 The Corrado is decidedly less prone to this. 
 Drive one straight after the other and it is hard to tell which is quicker. 
 The Corrado not only has a little more power and torque, it also benefits from about 170lb less bulk. 
 In its credit, the Calibra slices through the air more cleanly with its 0.29Cd drag factor. 
 Truth is, the two cars are just about equally matched when it comes to acceleration in each gear. 
 In some increments the Calibra shows the way, while in others the Corrado shows the Vauxhall a lead-free tailpipe. 
 Both engines are extremely tractable, but the Calibra pulls hardest from ultra-low revs and beyond 4000rpm, while the Corrado wins through at the top end and lower-mid range. 
 Going hard through the gears places the Corrado some way behind the Calibra's sparkling showing. 
 Like the Golf, whose floorpan and front-suspension layout the Corrado shares, getting off the line is no problem, but there is too much space between second and third ratios, allowing the close-ratio Calibra to take the honours. 
 The Calibra 16v gets from rest to 60mph in 8.1secs and on to 100mph in 22secs, but the Corrado G60 can manage only 8.9secs to 60mph and falls a disappointing two seconds behind by 100mph. 
 That vital second and third-gear shortfall shows up most graphically in the 30&ndash;70mph increment: Corrado manages only 8.8secs, Calibra records just 7.5secs. 
 Flat out, both these coupes are fast enough. 
 Each achieves 137mph on Millbrook's bowl which means they'll nudge 140 on the straight. 
 Use all the Corrado's ample performance and the lead-free fuel flows through the intakes at the rate of around 22mpg, and this shows little sign of improvement even when driven more gently. 
 The Calibra's average of 25.5mpg is rather more encouraging, and the 14-gallon tank capacity offers a better range than the Corrado's 12.1 gallons. 
 HANDLING AND RIDE 
 The Corrado and Calibra share a basically similar suspension design &mdash; MacPherson struts at the front, trailing arms at the rear and driven front wheels &mdash; but you certainly wouldn't guess it on the road. 
 In their handling characteristics they could scarcely be more different. 
 The Corrado's chassis is first class, but watch it attacking a series of bends and it's hard to understand why. 
 It seems incomprehensible that a chassis with such a marked front weight-bias and an inside-rear tyre that can jump six inches clear of the ground can also provide such superlative behaviour. 
 And yet the driver isn't aware of these acrobatics from behind the wheel. 
 The fact is, the Corrado is one of the very best front-drive chassis around. 
 A Lotus Elan provides more grip and a Peugeot 309GTi offers more communicative steering, but for a combination of fine throttle adjustability, knife-edged balance, the ability to stay accurately on line, and high levels of security &mdash; cut the throttle sharply and it won't suddenly swap ends &mdash; there's little to touch the Corrado. 
 In the face of such prowess, Vauxhall's sleek coupe can only come second. 
 At brisk cornering speeds the Calibra behaves in typical front-drive fashion. 
 The front pushes wide on a steady throttle and the rears will only slide out if the power is cut suddenly on the faster curves. 
 But the agility and balance that should be there in such a fine-looking coupe are missing. 
 Not that the Calibra falls behind in all chassis dynamics. 
 It grips better than the Corrado on the fast sweepers, but, on tight and bumpy lower-gear corners, the VW leaves the Calibra scrabbling to get a grip on the road surface. 
 The Corrado also comes out on top for its firm and consistent braking &mdash; the Calibra's pedal has an excess of free travel before anything happens &mdash; but the overly heavy servo action loses the VW some points. 
 Both have anti-lock brakes as standard. 
 Also standard on both cars is power steering, perhaps a touch too heavy on the G60, a touch too light and rubbery on the Calibra. 
 But both are acceptably direct, although the Corrado's steering has pinpoint accuracy. 
 It's a shame, then, that its gearchange is coarse and sloppy. 
 In contrast, the Calibra's is light and quick, although the clutch action could be more progressive. 
 No one expects limousine-comfort from a 137mph coupe but, even so, you don't get much ride absorbency with either car. 
 Undoubtedly the more controlled damping comes from the Corrado, which copes admirably with undulations at speed, but show it some sharper bumps and, like the Calibra, it jolts and shudders through the shell. 
 Low-speed ride is jittery on both cars. 
 AT THE WHEEL 
 Sit behind the wheel of the Calibra and it could easily be mistaken for a Cavalier GSi. 
 That's not a bad thing, for the Cavalier has earned high praise for its instrument clarity and logical placement of controls. 
 The seats are excellent too, with support where it's needed and basically good driving position, adjustable for height. 
 Legroom is generous, and headroom reasonably good. 
 The smaller Corrado certainly shows its size once you're seated. 
 Close proximity to the body sides, the roof and the front screen makes it feel crowded, but there is actually plenty of legroom, and like the Calibra, a roomy footwell with space to rest the left foot (though don't forget the test car is in left-hand-drive form). 
 The instruments don't have the same clarity as the Calibra's and some of the Corrado's switches are masked by the wheel. 
 The seats aren't as comfortable as the Calibra's either, and the base height adjustment is restricted to the rear of the cushion only. 
 Despite the high trim-quality of each of these coupes, the sombre colours and black facia panels of their interiors make the cabins appear smaller than they actually are. 
 The Calibra's large glass area and greater interior space does lessen this effect, though, and also provides excellent all-round vision. 
 Visibility in the Corrado is obstructed by the broad C-pillars and high rear &mdash; made even higher by an electrically-raised spoiler. 
 The lights, too, appear dimmer than the Calibra's. 
 The Vauxhall's ventilation system offers a plentiful supply of air &mdash; better than the Corrado's &mdash; provided the fan is switched on. 
 COMFORT AND SPACE 
 For long-distance cruising, the Calibra is the better choice, if only because it has a more absorbent and quieter motorway ride. 
 Some tyre tumble exists, but it's not as obtrusive as on the Corrado, which also suffers from considerable ride harshness on coarse surfaces. 
 Wind roar is virtually absent on the Calibra but is the most prominent noise source on the Corrado. 
 But the Corrado turns the tables and outshines the Calibra in its unobtrusive engine, betrayed as much by the soft whine of the blower than the engine note itself. 
 Vauxhall could learn a few tricks here, the cacophony from the 16-valver becoming tiresome when the engine's full rev range is explored. 
 What's so unusual about the Calibra is that it isn't merely a two-plus-two, it's a full four-seater. 
 Furthermore, even a six-foot rear passenger should have no trouble finding enough leg and headroom, and access to the back presents no problems. 
 The Corrado also impresses in its rear passenger-space. 
 It still counts as a four-seater, but it's not in the same league as the Calibra for rear room where head and legroom are restricted. 
 The Corrado's no match for the Calibra's large and flat luggage space either because its spare wheel intrudes, but it is marginally easier to load then the Calibra, which has a very high loading lip. 
 FINISH AND EQUIPMENT 
 No quibbles on the finish of either car. 
 Fine build-quality is evident throughout the Calibra and the Corrado. 
 Paint finishes, panel fit and interior fit and finish are all of a standard expected from this price range. 
 The Corrado feels subjectively as though it is screwed together just a little more tightly but neither car suffers from rattles or shakes. 
 As expected, the level of standard equipment on both is high &mdash; alloy wheels, electric sunroof, power windows, mirrors and steering, central locking, a radio-cassette and anti-lock brakes. 
 The Corrado also has a multi-function computer, while the Calibra has a no-cost option of metallic paint. 
 VERDICT 
 So which is best? 
 In pure driving terms, the winner has to be the Corrado. 
 Its chassis offers terrific handling balance, great traction matched to positive brakes and accurate steering. 
 It feels like a thoroughbred coupe. 
 But the Corrado's victory is far from being so clear cut in other areas. 
 In refinement, equipment and build quality there's little to choose between the two, while Vauxhall's head-turner outshines the more expensive Corrado in more humdrum aspects, such as passenger and luggage space, and its motorway ride. 
 Add an engine which offers significantly better straight-line performance than the Corrado's and the balance starts to tip in favour of the Calibra. 
 Overall, the Calibra has to be the safer choice, but the more seductive charms of the Corrado G60 will woo the hearts of those who appreciate driving a great-handling car.  
 GMs wind-cheating coupe is more than a pretty face. 
 Sombre interior roomy enough to seat four comfortably but interior styling lacks charisma. 
 Seats supportive, instruments easy to assimilate, controls convenient. 
 Easy to live with 
 Corrado G60 is visibly smaller than Calibra but neat and trim lines exude presence. 
 Gloomy interior can feel claustrophobic, front legroom is plentiful but cramped in the rear. 
 Steering can be a little heavy and gearchange is sloppy 
 Vauxhall 16-valve four loses out on power to supercharged VW engine, but matches its 137mph. 
 Both have folding rear seats but Calibra wins on load space. 
 Our Heroes 
 PART THREE Luxury saloon  
 BENTLEY TURBO R 
 In the third part of the series in which our road testers name the cars they rate as the best, the ultimate in luxury saloons comes to the fore. 
 Those worthy of a runners-up slot are over the page, but this is the car that's second to none &mdash; the Bentley Turbo R 
 HELL FOR LEATHER 
 The Bentley Turbo R isn't so much a hero as the entire cavalry. 
 It knows how to charge. 
 Zero to sixty takes 6.5secs and a BMW 750i to the cleaners. 
 Top speed is an improbable 143mph. 
 Improbable because compared to the plump, leather-lined Bentley, a barn door has the frontal area of a postage stamp. 
 When this wall-nosed behemoth travels at speed through Kent, leaves get blown off trees in East Sussex. 
 Its hugeness is heroic &mdash; the Turbo R has a real  indomitable presence born of high breeding and an even higher bonnet line, a benign arrogance few tarmac-vacuuming supercars can compete with. 
 And, because its aristocratic bloodline is implicit, it doesn't have to shout or pretend: the Blower Bentley is all studied understatement and coolness of brow. 
 That's what gives the car such a delicious duality of character. 
 It's a hell-raiser with 24-carat cuff-links and rounded vowels, it's a freshly squeezed orange juice with a large shot of vodka &mdash; and like a Mickey Finn, the beauty of the Bentley is that you don't know quite what you've let yourself in for. 
 In both cases, you swallow hard. 
 The precedent for a Bentley imbued with the genuine bulldog spirit was created as long ago as 1982 by the Mulsanne Turbo, the first red-blooded carriage to roll out of Crewe for decades. 
 Far from being just another Rolls-Royce clone with winged &bquo;B&equo; badges, the Mulsanne went straight back to the first act where raw performance and driving reward shared equal billing with cossetting comfort and refinement. 
 Weighing the best part of two-and-a-half tonnes, the Mulsanne Turbo had enough puff to twist the speedo needle almost off the scale (a true 135mph) and drop the 0&ndash;60mph time to around 7secs. 
 But the Mulsanne's successor, the Turbo R, was faster still. 
 Moreover, it had acquired the suspension and tyres to cope with the jumbo output generated by its turbocharged 6.7-litre V8 &mdash; in excess of 320bhp and 400lb ft of tree-toppling torque. 
 Fuel injection and anti-lock brakes were duly introduced, followed, in 1989, by an intercooler, Bosch MK Jetronic fuel injection and ignition and a heavy duty THM 400 three-speed automatic transmission. 
 Now, at &pound;108,994, the Turbo R has adaptive damping to allow crisper handling without spoiling the fluid &bquo;magic carpet&equo; ride Bentley customers continue to demand. 
 That's the version we've yet to test, but memories of the 1988 Turbo R remain vivid and potent. 
 Recollection of the day it visited Millbrook is especially spine-chilling. 
 On the trip there, the Bentley showed us why its cabin is one of the most pleasant and relaxing automotive environments in existence. 
 Leather, so luxurious you find yourself wondering whether it could really have come from a cow, finds its perfect match in glossy burr walnut. 
 You know people have worried over this car. 
 The stitching is neat, but not too  neat &mdash; that human touch, again &mdash; and there's the smell; the subtle but fragrant aroma of high-grade hide is almost as seductive as the whiff of crisp &pound;50 notes. 
 All this tasteful opulence sets off the large-armchair electrically adjustable seats to a tee. 
 The driving position can be tailored to perfection by purring motors that raise, lower and recline with hair-breadth precision. 
 You sit high in any case and it's just as well &mdash; you need to be able to see the big car's extremities. 
 Yet threading the Turbo R through traffic is never a problem. 
 Other cars keep out of your way and the steering, though very light, is sensibly geared and very accurate. 
 On the open road, it's no use pretending that the Bentley handles with the agility of a Porsche. 
 Grip and balance are remarkable for such a heavy car but this isn't one to hustle down country lanes. 
 That said, if the beefy Bentley is far from wieldy, neither is it cumbersome. 
 Nor heavy of foot. 
 Burbling with a low, sonorous suggestion of vast latent power, the Bentley's bluff nose inched into position at the beginning of Millbrook's acceleration straight. 
 Given the gun, it lifted all of six inches as if to sniff the wind, the massively muscled V8 growling expensively. 
 With its occupants pushed firmly back into their seats, the Turbo R thumped a hole in the air and lunged for the far horizon, covering the quarter-mile in a staggering 14.8secs on the way. 
 But then the Turbo R is an outrageous concoction of sledgehammer performance and sybaritic luxury &mdash; the world's most dignified and prestigious hot-rod. 
 It's larger than life in every way. 
 A hero. 
 We're big fans. 
 BENTLEY TURBO R 
 Price: &pound;108,994 0&ndash;60mph: 6.5secs 30&ndash;70mph: 6.1secs 30&ndash;50 in 4th: 2.4secs Top Speed: 143mph Overall MPG: 15.1 Citation: For putting the fight back into Bentley and creating a form of transport that wants for nothing at all   
 Turbo R has brought fight back to winged &bquo;B&equo;. 
 Mixed with exquisitely luxurious leather and walnut interior is enough raw performance and driving reward to take your breath away 
 The RUNNERS-UP 
 That the Bentley Turbo R has withstood the challengers here speaks for its ability. 
 Even if these luxury saloons couldn't steal the Bentley R's crown, each has much to commend it 
 JAGUAR XJ6 4.0 
 The XJ6 is a great saloon that's become better over the years. 
 With the 4-litre version of the 24-valve AJ6 straight-six, however, the range has hit an all-time high. 
 With 235bhp and 285lb ft of torque, it delivers a top speed of 139mph and 0&ndash;60mph acceleration of 8.3secs. 
 The electronically-controlled four-speed automatic ZF gearbox makes the most of the engine's vitality, especially in &bquo;sport&equo; mode. 
 Slightly less willing to react is a chassis afflicted by over-light steering that lacks feel. 
 But it takes a lot to ruffle an XJ6. 
 And the ride is an object lesson in suppleness and elimination of vibration. 
 For its elegance, performance, comfort and refinement, the XJ6 4.0 is a hard car to beat at any price. 
 It currently costs &pound;25,200 in basic form and is therefore one of the great bargains. 
 Price: &pound;25,200 0&ndash;60mph: 8.3secs 30&ndash;70mph: 7.3secs 30&ndash;50 in 4th: 3.0secs Top Speed: 139mph Overall mpg: 18.5 
 AUDI V8 
 This unofficial &bquo;Mk II&equo; V8 is much more than the flagship saloon Audi wanted from the start and a fitting testament to a decade of technological advancement. 
 The V8 contains every engineering innovation Audi has made in that time: four-wheel drive, Procon-Ten, galvanised bodywork, flush glass, multi-valve combustion and an exhaust catalyst. 
 Its 3.5-litre quad-cam V8 delivers a hefty 250bhp and 251lb ft of torque and, thanks to the V8's sleek shape, a top speed of 144mph. 
 A 0&ndash;60mph time of 9.0secs is slightly disappointing but 0&ndash;100mph in 22.0secs gives a better clue to its ground-covering potential. 
 At least it does when you consider the Audi's terrific grip and handling, tireless brakes and great refinement. 
 But when it comes down to it, the V8 is more a car for drivers than passengers. 
 Its chassis is almost too  good. 
 Price: &pound;40,333 0&ndash;60mph: 9.0secs 30&ndash;70mph: 7.7secs 30&ndash;50 in 4th: 3.2secs Top speed: 144mph Overall mpg: 15.3 
 RANGE ROVER 3.9 SE 
 Twenty years old, the Range Rover is still the only serious off-roader that makes a convincing alternative to a luxury saloon. 
 The move to 3.9 litres means more power, a better spread of torque and a more sympathetic match for the ZF four-speed automatic transmission. 
 Equally impressive is the standard-fit (on the SE) Wabco anti-lock brakes, which provide superb, progressive braking. 
 With permanent four-wheel drive and fairly compliant long-travel suspension, handling is tremendously secure and predictable. 
 Ride quality benefits from the set-up, too, possessing the sort of bump absorption and suppleness rarely experienced outside a luxury saloon &mdash; no other off-roader comes close. 
 The SE is well equipped, roomy and comfortable &mdash; worth every penny. 
 Price: &pound;31,949 0&ndash;60mph: 11.3secs 30&ndash;70mph: 11.5secs 30&ndash;50 in 4th: 5.2secs Top speed: 108mph Overall mpg: 14.6 
 LEXUS LS 400 
 Lexus by Toyota, that is. 
 This is the Japanese giant's exhaustively researched and meticulously executed &bquo;best shot&equo; at luxury saloon design &mdash; a car which seeks to be the best, and very nearly succeeds. 
 Put bluntly, the Lexus has the smoothest and most refined drivetrain in existence. 
 The rear-drive V8 is quick, with a top speed of 147mph and 0&ndash;60mph acceleration of 8.3secs. 
 It has tremendous grip, failsafe handling and a ride of exceptional quality. 
 Its cabin is roomy and well-planned and full of equipment. 
 Whichever way you cut it, the Lexus seems only one step away from world domination. 
 The only let-downs are cabin styling which looks as if it was lifted directly from the Corolla and an overall lack of identity. 
 But then you don't build character overnight. 
 Price: &pound;34,250 0&ndash;60mph: 8.3secs 30&ndash;70mph: 7.1secs 30&ndash;50 in 4th: n/a Top Speed: 147mph Overall MPG: 19.7 
 MERCEDES-BENZ 420SE 
 All right, it's looking a little dated now; the steering wheel is absurdly large, even by Mercedes' standards, and someone else makes a smoother, quieter V8. 
 But the Merc 420Se, due to be replaced by the new S-class, can still take on all comers and hold its own. 
 Over-large steering wheel notwithstanding, its controls, instruments, heating and ventilation system, and driving position simply show how it should be done. 
 Its dynamics are exemplary, too. 
 While the top speed of 135mph is a little off the pace, the 0&ndash;60mph time of 7.6secs is well ahead. 
 Its 4.2-litre V8 is a little more vocal than some, but the noise it makes is more interesting. 
 nor can you poke holes in the handling or ride. 
 If the 420SE is this good, how good is its replacement going to be? 
 It must be giving BMW and Jaguar designers sleepless nights. 
 Price: &pound;37,430 0&ndash;60mph: 7.6secs 30&ndash;70mph: 6.7secs 30&ndash;50 in 4th: 3.7secs Top Speed: 135mph Overall MPG: 18.4 
 FORMULA FLOP 
 For every great Formula 1 car there are as many that never rise above mediocre and a heroic handful for which even that aspiration is too high. 
 Shaun Campbell surveys the back of the grid for grand prix racing's biggest failures. 
 It's the end of life as we know it. 
 Arguable the strongest-ever candidate for the title of the world's least-successful Formula 1 car, the Life L190/1 with its radical W12 engine, has passed into the history books where it will be fortunate to make more than a footnote. 
 The Life didn't just fail, it failed spectacularly. 
 It didn't just fail to qualify, it failed to pre-qualify. 
 Most of the time it failed to make it out of the pit lane. 
 in Hungary it produced one of the performances, completing five laps in pre-qualifying, the best of which was 23.5secs slower than Thierry Boutsen's pole winning time. 
 The only surprising thing about the Life was the scale of its failure. 
 Nobody expected it to be competitive but it had been thought that any team serious enough to build and enter a grand prix car should be competent enough to make it last more than five consecutive laps. 
 Similar thoughts must have passed through the minds of spectators when the V16 BRM made its long-awaited race debut at Silverstone's International Trophy in August 1950. 
 Hopes and expectations were high; Britain was desperate for a car that could compete at the top level with Alfa Romeo and Ferrari, and BRM, with the backing of British industry, was the car to do it. 
 It didn't turn up for practice and so many questions were asked that the race organisers pinned a notice on the control room window saying: &bquo;We have NO news of the BRM.&equo; 
 On race day, after all-night working at the factory, a solitary car turned up and the stewards gave special permission for driver Raymond Sommer to do three exploratory laps. 
 Then, in front of a crowd that included the Duke of Edinburgh, the transmission failed on the start-line. 
 As the mechanics wheeled it away, contemptuous spectators threw pennies at it. 
 Just about everybody drove the BRM at some stage, even Fangio. 
 But the supercharged 1.5-litre V16 engine was all wailing noise and no go. 
 Stirling Moss remarked that it had six gears but needed 16, from which you can gather that it was a bit on the peaky side. 
 Fifth place in the 1951 British Grand Prix, with Raymond Mays at the wheel, was the best the BRM ever achieved in a world championship event. 
 At the end of that year the formula changed and the V16's time had passed. 
 Memories of the 16-cylinder engine disaster must have faded at BRM by the mid '60s when the company embarked on another ambitious project. 
 The H16 engine was designed for the 3-litre formula that came into effect in 1966 and was developed from mating a pair of the 1.5-litre V8s that had been so successful in the preceding years. 
 The H16 was undeniably powerful and, like its '50s heir, made a glorious noise. 
 It was also heavy, complex and woefully unreliable. 
 It did manage one win, though, but that was in the back of Jim Clarke's Lotus 43. 
 BRM scrapped it at the end of 1967. 
 Throughout the '60s it seemed Lotus could do no wrong. 
 After a couple of unsuccessful front-engined designs in the late '50s, Colin Chapman turned out a series of fabulously successful cars that dominated the decade. 
 Until the Lotus 63, that is. 
 The 63 was one of a handful of four-wheel-drive cars that saw brief service in 1969 before they were parked in at the end of the blind alley into which their manufacturers had ventured. 
 The 63 made its debut at the Dutch Grand Prix, driven by John Miles, Lotus's regular drivers Graham Hill and Jochen Rindt refusing to have anything to do with it. 
 Miles qualified 12th (out of 13, grids were smaller then) and retired after two laps. 
 At the next race it was entrusted to Jo Bonnier, a likeable Swede who had won his one and only grand prix 10 years before. 
 Bonnier qualified 17th out of 18 &mdash; the only slower car being a 4wd Matra &mdash; and retired on lap 7. 
 In Germany the privilege of driving it was handed to Mario Andretti who crashed it on the first lap. 
 Rindt then crashed it in practice for the Canadian race and flatly refused to drive it again. 
 it made its last appearance at Watkins Glen &mdash; a reluctant Andretti again at the wheel &mdash; and failed to shine even in the wet conditions of practice. 
 it retired on the fourth lap. 
 Lotus had another go at four-wheel drive the following year, this time with gas turbine power The dramatically wedged-shaped 56B was a development of the car that had come within a whisker of tinning the 1968 Indy 500. 
 But there was a world of difference between the American ovals and the European road tracks, as the drivers soon discovered. 
 its dismal career ended with eighth place at Monza in 1971, Emerson Fittipaldi driving. 
 Lotus's next disaster came in 1974 with the Lotus 76, the car designed to replace the magnificent 72. 
 The 76 was a fascinating package of new ideas from the winkle-picker nose to the biplane rear wing and with an electro-hydraulic clutch in between which the driver operated by depressing a small button on the top of the gear lever. 
 It was meant to allow the driver the freedom to use his left foot for braking but the system was taken off the car at the end of the first practice session in its first race, the South African Grand Prix. 
 Drivers Ronnie Peterson and Jacky Ickx weren't convinced by the car's handling characteristics, so unconvinced they collided at the first corner. 
 By mid-season Lotus had given up and gone back to the 72. 
 The ground-effects revolution, pioneered by Chapman with the Lotus 78 and 79 designs, produced its own family of flops. 
 Mario Andretti, who won the 1978 world championship with the 79, boasted that the new car, the 80, would make his former charge look like a double-decker bus. 
 As Harvey Postlethwaite, now Tyrrell's chief designer, remarked at the time: &bquo;If you're slightly out in your calculations, then you're completely wrong.&equo; 
 Lotus was slightly out and the 80 was an unmitigated disaster. 
 McLaren jumped on the ground-effects bandwagon with the M28, reasoning that the bigger the ground-effects area, the better the car would be. 
 After just three races the team gave up and started to work on something smaller and lighter. 
 Arrows produced the A2 &mdash; a weird-looking device which was promptly tagged &bquo;the doodlebug&equo;. 
 It nosed dived into oblivion. 
 Ferrari profited from these ground-effects catastrophes with a relatively conventional car, the 312T4 that gave Jody Scheckter the 1979 world championship. 
 Its replacement, the similar-looking 312T5, was not so fortunate. 
 Villeneuve and Scheckter managed to score just eight points between them during the 1980 season and the reigning world champion failed even to qualify for one race. 
 It was the end of the flat-12 Ferrari engine and the end of Scheckter's driving career. 
 But Ferrari has always blown hot and cold. 
 In 1961 the shark-nose 156 was almost unbeatable; in 1952 it was almost undrivable. 
 A huge row in the Modena camp resulted in half the team &mdash; including drivers Phil Hill and Giancarlo Baghetti &mdash; walking out and forming ATS (Automobili Turismo e Sport). 
 Designed by Carlo Chiti, later to build some explosively temperamental F1 engines for Alfa Romeo, the ATS cars made their debut at the 1963 Belgian Grand Prix. 
 They qualified 17th and 20th and were both out of the race within 15 laps. 
 The same thing happened in Holland and ATS gave the next three races a miss to try to fix the problems. 
 At Monza Phil Hill finished seventh, seven laps behind the winner. 
 And that was the highlight. 
 Most motor racing fans remember the March 721X, which the ambitious young team was confident would change the face of F1. 
 It was instrumental in bringing the young Niki Lauda into the public eye when he dismissed it as rubbish after a handful of laps. 
 Lauda had it right, March had it entirely wrong. 
 But who remembers the Shannon-Climax? 
 Its one and only race was 1966 British Grand Prix where Trevor Taylor lined it up on 18th place on the grid and retired during the very first lap. 
 Perhaps the chaps at Life shouldn't despair. 
 If Lotus, Ferrari, McLaren and Brabham (remember the carpet-slipper BT55? 
 Gordon Murray certainly wishes he didn't) can produce flops, then there's no reason in the world why they shouldn't.  
 Left: the Life L190/1, also known as the Life DNPQ. 
 Slightly less competitive than a Hillman Hunter and a good deal less reliable it has yet to race. 
 A switch to Judd V8 power has not improved it 
 From second top to bottom: a quartet of flops from Lotus. 
 4wd Lotus 63 of 1969 &mdash; an unmitigated disaster. 
 Gas turbine 56B with Jumbo jet handling. 
 Type 76 failed to replaced 72. 80 flattered to deceive 
 Top and above left: V16 BRM was the victim of too hopeful publicity. 
 It looked and sounded great but rarely ran long enough to satisfy a wide variety of drivers. 
 H16 BRM (above) was too heavy and complex 
 Right: 4wd Matra MS84 defied even Jackie Stewart's ability to make it competitive. 
 Below: Ferrari 312T5 looked spectacular in the hands of Villeneuve and Scheckter but the other cars were quicker without the histrionics 
 Above: Arrows A2 &bquo;doodlebug&equo; was one of 1979's great ground-effects disasters. 
 It wasn't the only one. 
 Right: John Watson struggled manfully with oversized M28 McLaren but its career was shortlived 
 Right: Shannon-Cimax of 1966, Trevor Taylor driving, had a race career of one lap. 
 Below right: Brabham BT55 used lie-flat BMW turbo and was knee-high to a grasshopper, but was never half as fast as it looked 
 Right and above: March 721X was short, squat, dumpy and painfully slow. 
 Below right: ATS of 1963 was born out of a Ferrari breakaway group but only managed to finish one race 
 GREAT BRITISH SPORTS CARS 
 MASTERS OF THE UNIVERSE 
 The he-man was spoilt for sports car choice in the mid '60s but when it came to the crunch he would probably have gone for either the Austin Healey or the AC Cobra. 
 Brian Laban dons his chest wig and flexes the huge muscles of Britain's ultimate sports cars 
 In 1954 Carroll Shelby and Donald Healey went record breaking together at Bonneville and set a string of records with various versions of Healey's 100 and 100S sports cars. 
 In 1955 Shelby raced a works Austin-Healey in the Carrera Panamericana &mdash; and came close to assuming the title of the late Carroll Shelby when a huge accident destroyed his car and put him out of circulation for several months. 
 Shelby soon went back to racing, of course, and more than any other American driver up to that date he bridged the gap between European and American racing cultures. 
 His greatest achievement was winning at Le Mans for Aston Martin in 1959, but his racing career was ended soon afterwards by a recurrence of childhood heart problems. 
 With or without heart trouble, Shelby wasn't a man to settle for a dull life. 
 Having given up racing, he kept himself in the thick of things through his Goodyear racing-tyre distributorship and by opening a racing school at Riverside. 
 He also found time to pursue another ambition, to build a world-beating US sports car to &bquo;whip Ferrari's ass&equo;. 
 Shelby didn't like Ferrari; like plenty of others before and after, he had experienced at first hand Enzo Ferrari's withering contempt for lesser mortals. 
 He wasn't even the first to tell Ferrari he'd be back one day with a car to beat him, but the laconic Texan did have a more-than-usually colourful way of putting it. 
 In the end he did it too, when he won the 1965 manufacturer's championship for GT cars with his Shelby Daytona coupes. 
 The Daytona was a version of Shelby's sports car dream. 
 Ferrari aside, he did love European sports cars. 
 His first ever race was in an MG-based special; he'd also raced Jaguars and Astons, Ferraris and Maseratis &mdash; and Healeys. 
 A large chunk of his early career was spent trying to tame a series of fearsome Cadillac-powered Allards, and his own sports car idea basically revolved around putting chap but ample US V8 power into a light and well-mannered European chassis. 
 In 1961 he finally pulled a deal together with the Ford Motor Co and AC Cars Ltd, and early in 1962 the Cobra was born. 
 Its engine was American, its assembly was completed in America, it wouldn't have happened without Shelby's American dream, but underneath it all the Shelby AC Cobra was a British a sports car as you could wish to see. 
 The AC contact wasn't Shelby's first; he'd been hawking his sports car plans around since the late '50s and among the people he'd contacted with a view to building his hybrid had been his good friend Donald Healey. 
 What's more, Healey himself would have loved to build Shelby's car but the stultifyingly conservative BMC management that was Healey's patron just didn't want to know. 
 I could have stayed an interesting union, but the Healey stayed a Healey and the Cobra was an AC. 
 In many ways they have much in common. 
 They're both conventional, old school sports cars with plenty of power up front, not much in the middle and drive to the back. 
 They're both from a generation that used separate chassis and bodies; the Healey has a boxed cruciform frame and steel and aluminium body, the Cobra an even simpler tubular ladder and that stunningly beautiful all-aluminium shell. 
 The Healey has independent suspension at the front, by coil springs, wishbones, and old-fashioned lever-arm dampers, and a non-independent live-axle at the back, with half-elliptic springs and a Panhard rod. 
 The Cobra is independent all round with lower wishbones, top links formed by transverse leaf springs and telescopic dampers. 
 They're both muscle cars. 
 The six-cylinder Healey was always known as one of the bigger-engined he-man British sports cars of its generation; the Cobra, with its lightweight, cast-iron &bquo;small-block&equo; Ford V8, the classic example of the adage &bquo;there's no substitute for cubic inches.&equo; 
 In a way they were both already dinosaurs by the mid '60s, as legislation began to put more emphasis on efficiency and sophistication than on simplicity and brute force. 
 The Cobra had only been around since 1962, but the Ace, on which it was based, dated back to 1953, when it had been launched at Earls Court. 
 That was the same year in which the first of the classic Austin-Healey line, the four cylinder 100&ndash;4 went into production, having been adopted by Austin from a Healey design shown at the previous year's show. 
 By 1964, when John Chatham's pleasingly original example tested here was built, the &bquo;big&equo; Healey had reached 3000 MkIII designation, with 2012cc in-line six-cylinder BMCC series power; in early 1965, the &bquo;small&equo; Cobra &mdash; like John Atkins' beautifully prepared and much-raced JA11 &mdash; had a 289cu ins (4.7-litre) Ford V8 (in place of the 260 with which the car was launched) and the original worm-and-sector. 
 But it still had transverse-leaf springing. 
 The &bquo;mass-produced&equo; Healey wasn't exactly a limo, but it was a bit bigger on creature comforts than the steadfastly spartan, hand-built Cobra. 
 In fact the 3000 MkIII had gone the way of many a sports car in its dotage and started to take on a softer aspect. 
 In June 1964, The Autocar  's testers remarked, &bquo;In its appointments the Austin-Healey 3000 MkIII is now more or a touring car than a sports car. 
 The new panel design and the trim are attractive, almost luxurious&hellip; 
 The &bquo;traditional&equo; British love of wood has extended to this Healey and the dashboard has walnut veneer on its two outer panels&hellip; 
 There are spaces in the console for a radio and loudspeaker&hellip; and a non-locking glovebox on the transmission tunnel, with a padded top to form an armrest for driver or passenger. 
 two small seats for children are fitted in the back, and an adult, sitting sideways, could be packed in for short trips&hellip; 
 Now that winding windows are fitted and a hardtop is offered, BMC ought to provide locks for the doors&hellip;&equo; 
 In that final respect, the Healey was like the Cobra, but the Cobra didn't even have external door handles, just simple pulls inside which you reach in to open. 
 There was no space for two small children or one transversely-mounted adult, not a trace of walnut, and if you wanted to listen to a radio in a Cobra you'd have needed speakers that wouldn't have disgraced a heavy-metal band. 
 In November 1965 we accepted the spartan layout with good grace: &bquo;Climbing into the cockpit, one recalls vivid memories of the old Ace, and very little seems changed. 
 There is rather less footroom because of the wider transmission tunnel, with nowhere to rest the left foot, and one is faced by a very full instrument panel.&equo; 
 We also noted that &bquo;several other aspects of the Cobra seem dated and rather crude by today's standards&hellip; 
 Plastic side-screens form part of the weather protection, with the rear half sliding forwards for ventilation. 
 The hood is a fairly flimsy affair which does not look particularly rainproof.&equo; 
 If the Healey was better appointed, it has perhaps dated more. 
 A wooden dash, manual window winder and plenty of chrome trim look pretty quaint now, and there's no missing the period feel. 
 Even in 1964 we commented, &bquo;For as long as many of us care to remember there has been a big Healey in the price lists. 
 The car has been through several variations of engine size, but now like an ageing but still beautiful dowager, repeated facelifts can no longer wholly hide the ravages of time and progress.&equo; 
 The Cobra on the other hand is almost timeless, not just because of its uncluttered and stunningly beautiful looks, but also because there really isn't enough to date &mdash; just minimum trim, two leather-covered bucket seats, soft door pockets and a dashboard full of instruments. 
 It allows a relatively modern driving position with straighter arms than the slightly foreshortened and big-wheeled Healey, but the stubby gear lever and handbrake lever down on the central tunnel are very similar car to car. 
 There's nothing daunting about the Healey. 
 It's comfortable, if a bit cramped, and this final model (which survived until 1967) was the most refined of the lot but also the most powerful and the fastest. 
 It's an interesting mix of gentility and potency. 
 We started our 1964 test with the words: &bquo;Sun-capped Dolomites and the distant roar and squeal of one of the works rally cars scrambling its way up the Gavia Pass &mdash; this is perhaps the image that some people have of the big Austin-Healey at work. 
 But there is a world of difference between those frequent winners, the former spartan works rally cars, and the over-the-counter product of today.&equo; 
 True, but the 1964 road car was no sluggard. 
 With bigger carbs and a new camshaft, power improved from 137bhp at 4750rpm to 148bhp at 5250rpm, and torque from 158 to 165lb ft at 3500rpm. 
 It was only a cast-iron lump with pushrod valvegear, of course, and with no pretensions to be anything more exotic; even in 1964 we observed that &bquo;although this comparatively unsophisticated six-cylinder engine must now be very near the end of its development, it seems to have gained in flexibility and is virtually free from any temperament.&equo; 
 That's the secret; the big Healey is just an uncomplicated, user-friendly car with little cleverness but lots of heart. 
 It's easy to drive, quick enough to be fun, with the reassurance of solid, almost farmyard engineering under the skin to remove any worries about making it work for a living. 
 Its six isn't a BMW six &mdash; not smooth and eager, but more stolid and insistent, bigger on torque than on power and with no special desire to rev more than it has to. 
 In 1964 we reported: &bquo;The big Healey's take-off from standstill is impressive. 
 Without tyre squeal or wheelspin, it reached 30mph in 3.4, 40 in 4.8, 60 in 9.8 and 100 in 25.7secs. 
 At maximum revs, 5250rpm in this case, the combined noise of the engine, cooling fan, unsilenced carburettor intakes and exhaust reaches almost Grand Prix levels and on the maximum speed runs the scream of wind round the windows and hood adds to the din.&equo; 
 We didn't say, but we might well have thought, that that was what a sports car ought to be. 
 Then, as now, we had a car fitted with the optional Laycock overdrive, operating on third and top; then as now it emphasised the low-speed/high-gear flexibility but did show up a big gap between second and third &mdash; a gap of over 30mph in maxima. 
 The gearchange is short and easy, but not very quick, and the overdrive is a handy second string. 
 Our top speed was recorded in overdrive top, at 121mph &mdash; 10mph more than in direct top. 
 That's still a fair maximum for this car, and even with a lot of miles under its belt since it had any major attention (and a tendency to hang-up slightly in second gear) it will still pull 12.2secs to 60mph. 
 Its handling and ride are decidedly &bquo;period&equo;, but ultra-safe and bags of fun. 
 They're justification for the &bquo;he-man&equo; tag, with heavy everything at low speeds and not much more than a token lightening up as you press on harder, but not so heavy as to wipe out the sports car's essential touch of delicacy. 
 The big mass up front guarantees initial understeer and the ample power to the back promises the balancing availability of power oversteer. it's very chuckable, but the harsh ride makes it sensitive to bumps and changes of surface in mid bend, and you have to be quick with the wheel-twirling to keep up on slippery surfaces. 
 Disc and drum brakes give good stopping power considering the car weighs over 2600lb at the kerb. 
 A Cobra is a bit different. 
 Any abilities as a road car are largely coincidental to its abilities as a racer. 
 Back in the early '60s, that's how Shelby contrived it, and although the majority of Cobras were  road cars, that doesn't alter the fact that they're all racers under the skin. 
 Make no mistake, a Cobra, even a &bquo;small&equo; Cobra and even at 26 years old, is still awesome. 
 Beneath the graceful, almost sensual lines is a fearsome, sledgehammer power that has been described as &bquo;just this side of reality.&equo; 
 The opening paragraph of The Autocar  's November 1965 test of a privately owned car (to much the same spec as our example) read: &bquo;Few readers indeed will get this far before turning to the data page which follows, for the name of AC Cobra is synonymous with performance. 
 There they will have seen the steepest acceleration graph we have ever plotted, with it 0&ndash;100mph time of only 14secs and an elapsed time for the standing quarter-mile of 13.9secs.&equo; 
 We reported 0&ndash;60mph in 5.5secs, and 0&ndash;120 in only 23.2secs. 
 Even more astonishing were the intermediate figures: &bquo;It is important to realise just how phenomenally fast these are. 
 First gear, for example, gives over 60mph without exceeding 6000rpm, and around the peak of the torque curve a 20mph increase takes less than 2secs. 
 Corresponding times for the same band in second take only 0.5secs or so more, and even by using third they are barely lengthened by 1sec. 
 For all practical purposes in traffic it does not matter which gear is engaged and there is never any lack of overtaking power.&equo; 
 Our third gear figures in 1965 included 30&ndash;50, 40&ndash;60 and 50&ndash;70 each in 3.4secs; even in top the same increments were despatched in between 4.1 and 4.3secs; 80&ndash;100mph and 90&ndash;110mph occupied 4.5 secs and 6.8secs in third, or 5.4 and 6.1 in top, underlining the Cobra's staggering flexibility. 
 They were remarkable figures then, but almost 25 years on we beat them fairly handsomely, in a car which, although in a pretty healthy stage of tune (probably around 350bhp), has nothing that any Cobra owner couldn't have bought over the counter, and which is still perfectly  useable  on the road in small doses. 
 Well, for once a 25-year-old test with the fastest figures this magazine had ever produced at the time seems positively understated when you come face to face with the reality. 
 JA II impresses first with how tiny it looks for a car with such a monstrous reputation, second for the sheer physical intensity of the power when the Ford V8 crashes into life. 
 This isn't the velvet-glove power of a Ferrari or a Lamborghini, not even the more base power of a V8 such as Aston make, it is the bad-boy rumble of the hot-rodder's art &mdash; lots in, lots out, speed costs money, how fast do you want to go? 
 The tickover burbles and barks, but blip the throttle and the whole car twists with the torque reaction and the birds fly out of the trees. 
 It revs like a turbine and sounds like a locomotive. 
 it turns the skin on your arms to gooseflesh. 
 At Millbrook, JA 11 recorded 5.2secs to 60mph, 11.5 to 100mph and only 17.4 to two miles a minute. 
 The 30&ndash;60 time in third was just adrift of 1965 at 3.6secs, but the next three increments, right up to 60&ndash;80, each required only 3.3secs. 
 It isn't just the figures, it's the intensity, the uncomplicated brutality of it all. 
 At any speed, in any gear on the mile straight there is enough power to bury you hard into the thin bucket seats; every quick-fire gearchange though the massively solid Borg-Warner 'box kicks at the back end. 
 Our hard-chasing Mercedes 300 24v photographic car was never more than a rapidly disappearing spot in the Cobra's mirror. 
 We are talking major league performance here, even in 1990; in 1965 nothing road legal would even look at a Cobra in a straight line. 
 And don't believe all you think you've heard about a Cobra being undrivable in anything but  a straight line either. 
 It demands respect, and it demands commitment, but it does the job amazingly well for a car on transverse cart springs and a chassis that's based on what looks no more than two parallel lengths of drainpipe. 
 It may be a clich&eacute;, but the compactness, the lack of weight, abundance and responsiveness of power, massively powerful brakes and rigidity of suspension all add up to a car that feels very much like a big kart. 
 In 1965 we described the suspension as &bquo;very firm, with a distinctly Vintage harshness and lots of jolts and jars. 
 Rough patches of road taken slowly caused parts of the body structure to creak and groan. 
 There is no scuttle shake nor visible signs of flexing anywhere, however, and the tubular chassis is tremendously rigid.&equo; 
 After 25 years of hard use, JA 11 still has little or no creaking nor scuttle shaking on any reasonable surface and it is both light and delightfully precise. 
 Much as we found originally, it handles quite neutrally at modest speeds, understeers progressively beyond that, but always has the power to boot the tail away. 
 lifting off suddenly in mid-bend isn't such a good idea either &mdash; in short you just have to be aware all the time of how much power you have in so little car. 
 In fact you're unlikely to forget it. 
 Where the Healey is a fairly civilised blend of high-speed tourer and sporting pedigree, comfortable enough for long-distance continental holidays as well as for Sunday afternoon thrashes through the countryside, the Cobra is just a beast. 
 It assaults you with raw power, deafens you with engine and wind noise, roasts you in the stark cockpit. 
 Our two original conclusions ran: &bquo;Despite some dated features, the big Healey is still terrific fun to drive. 
 Tractable, capable of an immense amount of hard work with reasonable economy, it will have its devotees long after production has ceased.&equo; 
 And of the Cobra, &bquo;There can be no denying that the Cobra is an extremely exciting car to drive, or even passenger in. 
 The acceleration is sensational and very similar to taking off in a piston-engined aircraft with open cockpit. 
 In much the same way, nearly all creature comforts must be sacrificed for performance &mdash; a condition which is worth it most of the time, but very occasionally not. 
 It is a fine-weather car for clear skies, open roads and a life away from it all. 
 Part of its sorcery lies in its ability to instil the same exhilaration from a short run up the road on a Sunday morning, but most of it comes from that aggressive thrust of power that is always more than enough for any driving situation.&equo; 
 We were absolutely right in both cases. 
 Long live the sports car.  
 They don't build them like this any more &mdash; Healey (top), Cobra (above) 
 Healey cabin dominated by large steering wheel 
 Cobra interior starkly simple although seats were leather trimmed 
 No doubt about rev limit from clear Healey instrumentation 
 Cobra driver is faced with impressive array of instruments 
 2.9 litre Healey produced 148bhp at 5250rpm and 165lb ft at 3500rpm 
 By 1964 Healey was at the end of its development, but still loved 
 4.7litre Ford V8 gave AC Cobra stunning performance 
 AC Badge now Ford-owned, but where's the true successor 
 WHAT PRICE PERFORMANCE? 
 The performance-per-pound ratio was probably higher in the '60s than at any other time 
 If you can remember the start of BBC2, Prince Edward being born, the first issue of The Sun , and Harold Wilson becoming Prime Minister, you can remember 1964. 
 Martin Luther King won the Nobel Peace Prize and Nelson Mandela was jailed for life; Winston Churchill was 90 but the only fighting on the beaches was between the Mods and Rockers. 
 It was also the year in which the train robbers were sentenced and France and England agreed to the principle of a Channel Tunnel. 
 A 1964 pound would be worth &pound;8.96 today, so the &pound;1228.46 for our Austin-Healey (including overdrive, wire wheels, heater, telescopic steering column and seat belts) equates to &pound;11,006. 
 That's close to the bargain-basement Reliant Scimitar 1400 at &pound;10,950, less then the next contender, the &pound;12,185 Caterham 1.6 GT, and handsomely undercutting any other mainstream sports car. 
 The working man's 47.7 hours a week in 1964 should have earned him &pound;18.11 (say &pound;162 a week now), but MPs were about to become markedly better off than that as Mr Wilson increased their salaries from &pound;1750 to &pound;3250 per annum (&pound;29,120). 
 Inflation was only 4.8 per cent, but the pound was in serious trouble at the end of the year, as the bank rate went from 6 per cent to 7 per cent &mdash; described as &bquo;crisis level&equo;. 
 Budget increases nudged a pint of beer up to 10&frac12;p and 20 cigarettes to 24p. 
 A year later, in the year of the Beeching Report on the railways and the abolition of the death penalty in Britain, the pound had shifted to the equivalent of &pound;8.56 today, so &pound;2732.24 for a 289 Cobra means &pound;23,388 in 1990. 
 Even forgetting the fact that the Cobra was the fastest accelerating car you could buy at the time, that only puts it between the &pound;21,620 Elan SE and the entry level &pound;26,400 Excel SE, close to the &pound;22,363 Morgan plus eight and even closer to the &pound;23,526 Toyota Supra Turbo. 
 You might have had a slightly harder time finding the money in 1965 than in 1964, though. 
 Wages edged up to an average of &pound;19.58, and the bank rate came down to 6 per cent, but mortgages went up from 6 to 6&amp;1/4%. 
 A house that cost &pound;5500 to build typically cost a council tenant &pound;3.18 a week, a mortgage payer &pound;6.37 a week and someone with a private landlord &pound;10.09 a week. 
 Car tax went from &pound;15 to &pound;17.50. 
 1964 was the year of the Tokyo Olympics, where Abebe Bikila set a world record for the marathon in 2hrs 12mins 11.2secs and Ken Matthews of Great Britain won the 20km walk in 1hr 29mins 34.0secs. 
 Donald Campbell raised both land and water speed marks during 1964, the former to 403.1mph in July and the latter to 276.3mph on New Years Eve. 
 By October, Art Arfons had taken the land speed mark (not wheel-driven but official) to 544.1mph. 
 Faster still was the air-speed record of 1666mph set by Col Mosolov of the USSR in 1962, the rocket-powered X-15's speed of 4104mph in the same year, and Jacqueline Cochran's 1964 women's air speed record of 1429mph in a Lockhead Starfighter. 
 By the end of 1965, the land mark was over 600mph &mdash; at 600.6mph by Craig Breedlove, and in May Col Stephens of the USA had raised the air speed record to 2070mph. 
 At the other end of the scale a 12-year-old South African girl, Karen Muir, gave us a new 110m backstroke swimming record in 68.7secs &mdash; and Britain's motorways were given a 70mph &bquo;experimental&equo; speed limit.  
 Record-breaking, highly modified Healey at Bonneville, 1954 
 Craig Breedlove broke 600mph with Spirit of America in 1965 
 X-15 rocket-powered aircraft, launched from Boeing B-51 &bquo;mother ship&equo; screams through the sky on its way to a top speed of 4104mph 
 SOUL MATES 
 What would Healey and Cobra owners be driving today? 
 By the mid '60s the heyday of the hairy-chested open sports car was coming to an end, surviving only on an uneasy and temporary truce with the law-makers and the environmentalist lobby. 
 The big Healey was on its way out through simple old age and the &bquo;small&equo; Cobra was being superseded by the even more brutal 427 as Selby fought aerodynamic mediocrity with good old-fashioned cubic inches. 
 Of the 655 &bquo;leaf-spring&equo; Cobras built (including the 75 original 260s), only 61 were officially listed as being for European consumption, and of course not even all of those were for Britain. 
 Of the rest, over 500 are listed as road cars, so the thought of the Cobra purely as a racer is something of a myth. 
 it existed, in reality, because Ford needed something special to tempt people into their showrooms and Shelby was in the right place at the right time to provide it. 
 Equally, not all the big Healeys were Alpine Rally competitors or howling club racers, and British as the car was, the majority of the 17,700 or so MkIIIs that completed the series also went to the US, where the sun shone a bit more often. 
 Unfortunately, it was the same reliance on that market that also killed it, as BMC realised it couldn't economically meet the new US emissions and safety requirements of the late '60s. 
 That's why sports cars went through such doldrums for so many years too, and shy we think of the sudden plethora of &bquo;traditional&equo; small sports cars as a sports car &bquo;revival&equo;. 
 It is, but it doesn't include too many cars on the hue of the Healey and the Cobra. 
 Big and simple are the essence, not big and luxurious or small and sophisticated, which counts out everything from Aston Martin Volante to Lotus's Elan. 
 They were a lot of car for the money, too, remember, with character and a few of the rough edges that are inevitable with a true specialist car. 
 Both take some following, and the Cobra in particular will probably never be repeated &mdash; not even with the Viper, which seems to be losing its fangs even before it's born. 
 If you want the same philosophy, stay in Britain and do your shopping for both cars in the same place, in Blackpool. 
 TVR's &pound;17,699 2.9-litre S3 is a fine reminder of the big Healey philosophy and the new 3.9-litre Griffith, if it matches its claimed 148mph and 0&ndash;60 in 4.9seconds, could be a fine poor-man's Cobra.  
 Big Healey made its reputation as a rally car &mdash; here shown on 1963 Alpine rally &mdash; but most cars were sold to the US 
 TVR S3: 2.9-litre Ford V6 engine gives Healey-type affordable appeal 
 TVR Griffith: untested but claimed 0&ndash;60 in 4.9secs very Cobra-like 
 TEST EXTRA 
 Mercedes-Benz 300SL-24 5-speed auto 
 This SL comes with the world's first five-speed automatic gearbox but fails to live up to its high price and long waiting list 
 Price &pound;63,390 Top Speed 134mph 0&ndash;60 8.6secs MPG 19.2 
 For Fine ride/handling balance, ergonomics, hood design  Against Cramped interior, unexciting performance, steering, price  
 Only Mercedes-Benz could charge &pound;50,800 for a car that is comprehensively outperformed by a Vauxhall Calibra 2.0i 16v, costing &pound;33,550 less, and still call it a sports car. 
 Truth is, of course, the 300SL-24 is much more tourer than sports car. 
 For although its twin-cam, straight-six 2960cc engine develops an impressive 231bhp at 6300rpm and 201lb ft of torque at 4600rpm, it has 3954lb of car to propel, giving it a power to weight ration of 129bhp/ton &mdash; unremarkable even by hot-hatch standards. 
 A Peugeot 205GTi 1.9, for instance, manages 143bhp/ton. 
 Every car that can conceivably pose as opposition to the Mercedes is faster. 
 And most are cheaper. 
 These include the  
 Part of the &pound;11,000 worth of extras Mercedes specified for the test car was the world's first production five-speed automatic gearbox, costing a surprisingly reasonable &pound;685.35. 
 Details of how it works can be found in the technical focus, but suffice to say the overall gearing remains the same as the four-speed &bquo;box, with direct drive on fourth. 
 The extra ratio is geared to give a whopping 28.9mph/1000rpm, which allows a lazy 2770rpm at 80mpg. 
 In fact it won't even pull its red line in fourth, the 134mph maximum occurring a whisker under the 6300rpm power peak. 
 In fifth it's no faster, and given that Mercedes reckons it should reach 143mph, this is a disappointing result. 
 But you could argue that an extra 9mph on top speed is irrelevant on our increasingly crowded roads and that acceleration is what matters. 
 And here the SL fails to match its maker's claim of 8.3secs for the 0&ndash;60 dash, managing a consistent 8.6secs instead. 
 Still, for an automatic car weighing nigh on two tons in test trim, that's not bad. 
 Better still is the way it sweeps through the quarter-mile in 17.7secs and reaches 100mph in 22.8secs. 
 Impressive for its weight and power, if not for its price. 
 Thankfully, the engine and gearbox make a great double act. 
 Exceptionally smooth, the 24-valve six is near silent at low revs, yet snarls convincingly if gunned. 
 This creates a feeling of urgency that is cultivated by the gearbox, which has ratios close enough to support a seamless aural attack all the way from standstill until fifth is selected at something over 130mph. 
 Which is just as well, for the engine is happiest on full throttle. 
 At gentler velocities it has a distinct, almost lethargic &bquo;off cam&equo; feel to its power delivery and you usually find yourself kicking down a ratio to access proper power. 
 This, unfortunately, shows up the flaw in an otherwise excellent gearbox. 
 Regardless of whether you select economy, which lets you kick down one gear, or sport, which selects as low a gear as possible on request, there is always a marked hesitation before the lower cog is engaged. 
 This stands out in stark contrast to the four-speed 'box in the 500SL we tested last December. 
 That changed gear the split second you required it. 
 In less frenetic driving, though, the 300SL-24's gearbox rarely gets it wrong. 
 Part-throttle upshifts can be detected on the revcounter, but rarely from any jerk in the driveline. 
 Even if you are accelerating solidly through the gears, it waits until the needle has kissed the red line before a slick and quick upchange allows the surge to continue unabated. 
 Apart from the obvious advantage of quieter touring brought by the fifth ratio, the five-speed 'box also seems to have done the SL's fuel consumption no small favour. 
 Overall its exclusively lead-free diet was consumed at the rate of 10.2mpg, even with a thirsty catalyst as standard. 
 While that may not sound brilliant for the performance, it should be borne in mind that the 300E-24 saloon, weighing the best part of 500lb less and with a four-speed automatic 'box, achieved 18.8mpg while on test. 
 Indeed, the SL's overall economy would have been better still had it not taken an unusually dim view of performance testing, its consumption plunging to just 14.4mpg while at Millbrook. 
 Any owner could reasonably expect over 20mpg all the time, with the touring consumption target of 23.1mpg well within reach. 
 At that rate it should manage over 400 miles between petrol stations. 
 It's hard to believe that a car as heavy as the SL can generate such massive grip, yet retain an admirably accomplished ride. 
 Part of the credit must go to the 225/55 Dunlops, the remainder to the multi-link rear suspension. 
 On dry roads the most any sane drive will usually experience is lateral g-forces as the SL corners. 
 Even in the wet, it was almost impossible to get the test car's tail moving as it was fitted with Mercedes' Anti-Skid Control (German acronym ASR), which works like anti-lock brakes but in reverse. 
 If a wheel starts to spin, the brake attached to it squeezes just enough to keep it in check while the engine throttles back. 
 This does not produce the same effects as lifting the accelerator altogether; it just maintains a balanced throttle. 
 On the hole, ASR works very well and will undoubtedly help keep SLs out of the panel beaters. 
 However, it does also remove any chance of adjusting your line with the accelerator, causing artificially strong understeer that builds up as soon as the ASR exclamation mark lights up in the speedometer. 
 That's a shame, for it is obvious, just from how eagerly it will push its tail out if you cut the power, that the chassis has a rare agility. 
 Unfortunately, as we found with the 500SL, the steering fails to meet the standards set by the rest of the chassis. 
 Although it is direct, there is not enough feel or weight to give a proper impression of how much grip is left. 
 Mercedes has achieved sports-car adhesion with a comfort many luxury saloon makers would envy. 
 Regardless of road conditions, the SL always feels firm, but thanks to excellent damping, it can still dismiss ridges and pot holes with consummate ease. 
 There is not the faintest trace of float or wallow over the fastest crests or in the steepest dips; the body just maintains constant ride height throughout giving a feeling of invincible security. 
 However, we would advise that the &pound;3123 worth of adaptive damping which arrived with the test car has little useful effect. 
 The impression of protection given by the chassis is backed up by tireless brakes, which despite the huge weight needed to be slowed, dealt with our fade test with ease. 
 One tester described the SL's cabin as &bquo;implausibly close to perfection&equo;, and for drivers under six foot, that is exactly right. 
 The seats, which won a major design award before the SL even went on sale, appear to be rather flat, but support your back and thighs well. 
 But finding an ideal seat position is impossible if you are much over six foot, as you will never be able to get the front seat back far enough. 
 In a Mercedes, a marque known for providing an almost absurd amount of legroom for its drivers, this is a bad fault. 
 Otherwise you are pampered like only a Mercedes driver can be. 
 Pitting the hood down is a joy to watch. 
 All you have to do is press and hold down a button. 
 In under half a minute of whirring and clicking, the hood has unlocked itself and been folded away in its casing behind the back seats. 
 Raising it is just as simple. 
 The hard-top even uses the same mechanisms and can be attached or removed in a similar time. 
 This, however, is a two-person operation as the roof is too heavy and cumbersome for one. 
 Even with the extra switches required to operate the options available on the SL, the ergonomics never seem cluttered or complicated. 
 Everything is where you'd like it to be and the instruments, in particular, cram a wealth of information to one well-packaged and easily read display. 
 There is no escaping, though that for a two-plus-two grand tourer, the SL is cramped. 
 Even drivers of average height will need the seat so far back as to make it impossible to see directly behind. 
 With the hood or hard-top in place, accessing the tiny rear compartment requires an undignified clamber through a small gap, which is hardly in keeping with the car's suave image. 
 With the hood down you can lower the windows and go in over the top, but even this is far from ideal. 
 In effect, the SL is a three-seater, but headroom is excellent. 
 High-speed, hood-down progress is only to be undertaken with all windows up as otherwise the wind whips round the side and into the cabin. 
 Do that and &mdash; if you can forgive the incessant roar from the tyres &mdash; progress is fairly fuss-free up to the legal limit. 
 If you go much faster than that it gets windy very quickly, although the heater can still turn the cabin into blast furnace. 
 With the hood up, it's not as quiet as you might expect even though the canopy is water and air-tight. 
 Only with the hard-top in place does it behave like a Mercedes is meant to. 
 To look at and to drive it, it could be a graceful new coupe. 
 Naturally you expect to find the highest quality construction in the world in a Mercedes, but the 500SL we tested had numerous faults that we thought &bquo;undermined Mercedes' quality image and appearance&equo;. 
 We are happy to report no such troubles with the 300SL-24 which felt rock solid throughout the test. 
 Overall the impression given by the materials chosen for the cabin is pleasing without managing to be friendly. 
 You might expect air conditioning, leather seats and at least a stereo when you pay over &pound;50,000 for a car, but not if it's a Mercedes you're buying. 
 Alloy wheels, anti-lock brakes, electrics for the hood, windows, mirrors and central locking are all standard, but you can spend many thousands on extras that ought to be included in the list price. 
 Our car cost in excess of &pound;61,000. 
 The public's imagination has been captured by the SL. 
 Regardless of model, the waiting list is at least three years long. 
 In many ways it's worth the wait. 
 It remains faithful to the 36-year-old concept behind the SL, but takes it onto a higher plane altogether. 
 Yet we can not recommend the 300SL-24, even with it's clever gearbox. 
 The reason is that we have driven the 500SL, which in its most basic form, is actually fractionally cheaper than the fully loaded 300SL-24. 
 It also gets to 60mph in 5.9secs and is artificially restricted to 157mph. 
 It has a better gearbox, an engine that is simply in a different class and actually lives up to the promise made by its sleek shape. 
 For all its undoubted talents, chief of which are its chassis, cabin and controls, the 300SL-24 fails to do the same. 
 When the Jaguar XJ-S V12 Convertible is available now, for a saving of almost &pound;10,000 over the 300SL-224's basic price, it's clear the 300SL-24 is too slow, too expensive and too far away.  
 Mercedes SL can be provoked into oversteer if you cut the power in a bend (above&mdash; but, with ASR traction control as fitted to test car, all that's really on offer is artificially strong understeer (right). 
 SL's cabin is superb (below right) with uncluttered ergonomics and clear display 
 The 24-valve 3-litre (left) has impressive 231bhp power and 201lb ft torque but is does have to propel nearly 4000lb of car. 
 Fortunately, it is smooth and well-matched to five-speed automatic gearbox (below), which has close ratios that allow revs to stay high and keep straight-six engine &bquo;on cam&equo; 
 TECHNICAL FOCUS 
 The new five-speed automatic gearbox , designated &bquo;W5A030&equo; and developed for Mercedes' six-cylinder engines, is ingenious most of all for its simplicity. 
 The raison d'&ecirc;tre  for W5A030 in the first place was that Mercedes' transmission engineers prefer continuously variable transmission to anything else. 
 But at the moment, CVT technology extends only to low-torque applications. 
 The gearbox is a development of the existing four-speed unit used on six-cylinder engines. 
 An extra planetary gear  set on the end, together with a new rear casing, provides the extra, overdriven ratio. 
 Fourth is direct drive. 
 Mercedes explains that the biggest problem in developing the five-speed unit is the necessity to reduce mechanical and hydraulic losses  to a lower level than had been achieved previously. 
 one of the major problems engineers face is that the gearbox casing acts like a giant thermometer bowl, and as the oil heats up and expands, the level in the gearbox rises in a four-speed unit by 20 to 30mm. 
 The five-speed has a special chamber in the rear casing accessed by a valve which opens when the oil temperature reaches 90deg C. Up to 550cc of oil is bled off into the chamber, which means the increase in depth in the main casing is reduced to 15 to 20mm. 
 Additional components comprise an extra electro-hydraulic control valve  to actuate fourth-to-fifth and fifth-to-fourth shifts and the extra gear set itself. 
 But at 80mm longer than the four-speed, overall length is still no greater than that of other makes of four-speed automatic transmissions, maintains Mercedes. 
 The total weight of 165.4lb is also equivalent to most four-speed 'boxes. 
 This transmission, which can handle up to 221lb ft torque, is definitely the shape of things to come at Mercedes, and in the next two years it is likely that all six-cylinder Mercedes cars will be equipped with it. 
 Market demand for it has been much higher than expected and there isn't the manufacturing capacity to build both four and five-speeds for the same application. 
 The V8, think the engineers, can live with the four-speed and, anyway, this gearbox wouldn't be strong enough. 
 But, in the mid '90s when Mercedes reviews its transmissions (in service since 1979), we might see a complete move across to five-speed automatics. 
 PASSING THE BUCKS 
 Chrysler says the Dodge Spirit R/T is the fastest saloon the US can offer, and next year it will be coming to Europe. 
 On paper it has the price, performance and specification to worry a car as good as the Vauxhall Carlton GSi 3000 24v. 
 On the Alpine passes, as Peter Robinson discovered, it's a different matter 
 It was only high in the European Alps, on the 7992ft Furka Pass, to the accompaniment of a frenzy of wheelspin, turbo lag, understeer and a violently pulsating brake pedal triggered by an anti-lock device working overtime, that the American challenge began to fade. 
 But then Detroit roads were never like this. 
 How could Chrysler's engineers have predicted &bquo;the fastest saloon built in North America&equo; &mdash; the 1991 Dodge Spirit R/T &mdash; would be tested on such challenging roads, roads where demands upon brakes, traction, handling, engine performance and suspension control are paramount? 
 Instead of the expansive, though often rough, Michigan highways of Motown, US, we quickly, sometimes dramatically, threaded our way up a narrow zig-zagging ribbon of blacktop that would probe the credentials of any car, regardless of its origins. 
 We'd taken the swiftly accelerating Spirit away from the homespun drag races of Woodward Avenue, hoping Chrysler's hype on for the R/T was well founded. 
 Instead, we'd uncovered, one by one, the inherent flaws that tarnish Dodge's brave attempt at building a Euro-style sporting saloon. 
 Here, on demanding mountain roads, the yawning gaps between gear ratios made it difficult to keep the engine spinning above the ideal 4000rpm. 
 Misjudge a change point, drop much below 3500rpm and the engine felt flat, even sluggish, as it waited for the turbo to come on strong again. 
 here, the lack of adequate damping revealed itself in float and wallow, and excessive body roll that exposed serious defects in the seats. 
 Here, the front wheels scrabbled for grip, slithering across a hairpin as the turbo power overtook the capacity of the American Michelin tyres to transfer such substantial clout to the ground. 
 Here, the lack of refinement in the drive train, the sudden jerks and snatches from the engine, combined unhappily with all the car's other short-comings. 
 The Spirit was exciting to drive&hellip; but never for any of the right reasons. 
 And here, we began to wonder aloud if it wouldn't be preferable, in the long term interests of America's domestic car makers, to leave the planned invasion of Europe to MPVs, luxury cars and convertibles. 
 Given Chrysler's claims for the 1991 Dodge Spirit R/T &mdash; and the fact that the company is giving serious consideration to selling the R/T in six key European markets (Germany, Belgium, Holland, Switzerland, Austria and France) from late 1991 &mdash; we felt it only appropriate to test the Spirit against one of Europe's finest sporting saloons, on the kinds of roads such a car is expected to master. 
 Surely not too much to ask of a model that, by its makers' own assertion, is aimed at &bquo;performance and handling enthusiasts&equo;. 
 Until we came to the Furka I'd been impressed by the Spirit R/T, surprised by the agility of its handling, the sensitivity and accuracy of its power-assisted rack-and-pinion steering, the breadth of the uninterrupted acceleration from its powerful turbocharged engine, the lightness of the controls and the quality of the gearchange. 
 Could it be, I mused, as I snuggled down into the Dodge's heavily bolstered bucket seat on the autostrada running north of Milan to Switzerland, that Detroit has finally built a competent, European-style sporting saloon? 
 A quick glance at the specifications that Detroit's idea of a '90s performance saloon has more in common with current European thinking than the muscle-bound 7-litre American V8's of the '60s and '70s. 
 That's a good start. 
 Front-drive, a 2.2-litre 16-valve in-line four developing an impressive 225bhp, four-wheel disc brakes with an optional anti-lock device and compact dimensions by usual US standards could easily be the routine outline for a French, Swedish, perhaps even German four-door performance saloon. 
 What better weapon to determine the Dodge's real prowess than Vauxhall's Carlton GSi 3000 24v &mdash; in left-hand-drive Opel-badged form &mdash; an instant favourite with Autocar &amp; Motor  's road testers and a value-for-money benchmark among sporting saloons. 
 At around &dollar;18,265 (approx &pound;10,000) the Spirit's 0&ndash;60mph time of 6.8secs and top speed of 143mph make it &bquo;one of the world's fastest production sedans&equo; according to Chrysler, and exceptional value in the US, where it is expected to compete against Ford's &dollar;22,000 (&pound;12,000) Taurus SHO. 
 Prices change when cars cross the Atlantic and the Dodge is expected to cost around DM42,000&ndash;43,000 (&pound;19,000) in Germany. 
 But that's more the price of a Cavalier 16v 4x4 than a Carlton 24v, so the Dodge still represents terrific value. 
 Heavily based on a slightly stretched platform from Chrysler's ubiquitous K-car, the Mexican-built Spirit R/T is a boxy four-door, elongated at either end so that it appears rather narrower than its 68.1ins width conveys. 
 Our test car, fresh from the US long-lead release, was finished in a monotonous, overwhelming red that extends to all but some chrome brightwork and black frames around the windows. 
 Cast alloy wheels and supplementary lights in a deep bumper can't hide the Spirit's pedestrian, upright styling origins, nor its bluff aerodynamics. 
 Chrysler went to GM-owned Lotus to help develop its first multi-valve engine, although it's based on an existing Chrysler four. 
 Lotus was responsible for the alloy cylinder head, pistons and intake and exhaust manifolds, while Chrysler engineers developed all other elements. 
 A conventional, water-cooled Garrett TB03 turbo helps generate more than 100bhp per litre &mdash; the highest specific output ever from a Chrysler production engine. 
 The 2.2-litre four produces 225bhp at 6000rpm and 210lb ft of torque at 4800rpm. 
 Chrysler claims a broad and flat torque curve between 2800 and 5000rpm, so it's a disappointment the engine doesn't drive in this manner. 
 A Getrag gearset for the five-speed manual 'box is fitted into the existing case, while suspension changes follow a predictable route with increased spring rates front and rear, firmer valving for the dampers and a large rear anti-roll bar. 
 Tyres are upgraded to American-made 205/60R15 Michelins. 
 Vauxhall's Carlton also follows the multi-valve route to transform the performance, but of course forsakes the turbo in favour of a large-capacity six-cylinder engine. 
 Despite the disparity in execution the result is surprisingly similar. 
 On paper, the Dodge has a 10 per cent power advantage, with maximum torque developed 800rpm lower in the rev range. 
 Yet it is the Vauxhall that feels more potent low down. 
 Both engines are entirely tractable but, for all the clever engineering dedicated to overcoming a four-valve engine's propensity to high revs, neither feels especially lively until the tacho needle hits 3500&ndash;4000rpm. 
 Both require frequent use of the gearbox if they are to live up to expectations. 
 Wind the Dodge right out to the 6500rpm red line &mdash; there's a cut-out at 6700rpm &mdash; and the engine stays on boost, the widely spaced gear ratios are disguised and acceleration is impressive enough, without ever feeling as energetic or gutsy as the Vauxhall's. 
 On paper the Spirit has a tiny advantage to 60mph &mdash; 6.8 versus 7.0secs &mdash; but the Vauxhall's performance is more accessible. 
 The Dodge is slightly ahead on fuel consumption &mdash; 22.2 compared with 18.9mpg &mdash; but it has a much smaller tank capacity. 
 Mid-region performance is strong and acceleration only begins to tail off above 120mph, but the Chrysler engine lacks ultimate finesse at high revs, becoming noisy and slightly strained, while the power delivery is too often spoiled by a hesitation or jerk after a sudden lift-off or application of power. 
 yet the gear change itself is quicker and lighter than the long throw, rubbery device that spoils the Vauxhall. 
 The Dodge's clutch is also smoother in action and far lighter. 
 Tall gearing means the Spirit is impressively quiet at legal speeds, the isolation of the cabin from road noise being outstanding by European standards. 
 Only wind noise above 80mph from the A-pillars and exterior mirrors intrudes on the solitude of motorway driving. 
 Our Vauxhall suffered from an annoying fifth gear whine on a trailing throttle but the engine's hard-edged yet effortless snarl as it wound out to the 6600rpm cut-out is a far more satisfying sound than the Chrysler four. 
 If the power-assisted rack-and-pinion steering seems excessively light at low speeds its directness, with a mere 2.5-turns lock to lock, makes you wonder whatever happened to the so-called &bquo;sneeze factor&equo; (ie forgiving low gearing) that was once considered essential in American cars. 
 The Spirit's steering is sharp and super-sensitive, requiring no more than finger-tip control, in stark contrast to the Vauxhall that always feels meaty and firm, yet with a touch of on-centre slack. 
 The trade-off is a shortage of feel and increase in weight when driving quickly. 
 It's not until the front tyres are struggling for adhesion, and screaming in anguish as the nose slithers round, that the Dodge's steering imparts any sensation of what's happening down at road level. 
 Instead of the tiny inputs required in motorway driving and even on minor roads, extend the R/T and you quickly discover there's a rapid build up in understeer and loss of chassis composure, even before the road surface deteriorates. 
 Just as the Spirit loses its way the harder you drive, so the Carlton is elevated to a higher level. 
 Through a fast sweeping corner, taken, say, in third gear at 80mph, the Vauxhall is noticeably quicker by as much as 10mph. 
 Its handling is far more predictable and involving, partly at least because its rear-drive layout encourages the loading-up of the outside tyres. 
 The Dodge stays flat enough but only because the tyres aren't capable of generating the lateral forces of the Vauxhall. 
 The taut Vauxhall suspension translates to a ride that's always firm, whereas the Dodge's softer springs give a more supple if less controlled ride. 
 The same applies to the brakes. 
 In normal usage the Dodge stops acceptably, the spongy pedal and &bquo;grabbing&equo; only occurring under duress, while the Vauxhall's brakes feel mushy but are stronger and more consistent in their behaviour. 
 At least the Dodge gets a proper set of circular analogue instruments. 
 The Vauxhall (remember it's actually an Opel) suffers from ugly digital gauges that are often hard to interpret and a digital speedometer that only reads in even numbers. 
 The interiors of both reflect their mundane origins but the longer and higher Vauxhall has more comfortable seats and greater space. 
 Standard equipment on the Dodge includes air conditioning, cruise control and a four-speaker sound system, but the bulky plastic dashboard is garish by European standards. 
 It's hard to see Chrysler making serious inroads into the European sporting saloon market with the Dodge Spirit R/T. 
 Like so many American cars the Spirit is a seven-tenths machine. 
 Drive it in smooth roads at regulated speeds and it makes an earnest, even laudable attempt at portraying an enthusiast's machine. 
 All the right ingredients seem to be there: so it's easy enough to persuade yourself the sharp steering, smooth increase in turbo power in the mid-range, quick-shifting gear change and body-hugging seats imply something of a breakthrough by Detroit. 
 Sadly, such is not the case. 
 The Dodge's superficial abilities simply crumble as speeds rise and road conditions become more challenging. 
 Five hundred quick miles over the Alps in tandem with a thoroughbred rival proved just how far Chrysler has still to go to building an effective contender.  
 Carlton's handling improves with speed, and it's the quickest through bends. 
 24-valve straight-six is good for low-end potency; seats are better and interior more roomy than American's; digital facia is awful 
 Opel-badged Carlton GSi 3000 24v is clearly ahead of Spirit R/T on the Furka pass (main picture). 
 Carlton (left above) is a benchmark European sporting saloon. 
 Dodge (left) is unmistakably American in styling 
 Dodge corners very flat though composure is quickly lost. 
 Engine is powerful but suffers typical turbo lag problems; cabin is well-equipped but seats give insufficient support when cornering hard; garish dash is saved by decent instruments 
 HEROES 
 Peter Robinson 
 &bquo;Leland claimed that 250 parts in his cars were made to tolerances of one-thousandth of an inch&equo; 
 Henry Martyn Leland was a perfectionist, a white-bearded, bible-quoting genius who created two of America's finest cars &mdash; Cadillac and Lincoln &mdash; only to lose both empires and die bitter and disillusioned. 
 Leland's secret of success was bringing a gun-maker's insistence on accuracy and precision to the production of car components. 
 At the turn of the century, most car parts were built individually and items such as pistons and con-rods were fitted together with files and emery cloth. 
 While the results worked, it made replacements almost impossible. 
 Leland realised that precise work equated to a better product at a lower cost. 
 He'd worked for firearms makers Springfield and Samuel Colt before beginning his own company in 1890, and knew that identical parts could be made to a standard that meant they were interchangeable. 
 After Oldsmobile's factory burned down in 1901, Ransom E Olds was forced to turn to contractors for the assembly of his single cylinder engine, and gave Leland the opportunity to prove his theory. 
 Using nothing more than precision machining methods, and without any change to dimensions or specifications, small machine tool maker Leland and Faulconer increased engine output by 23 per cent. 
 The Cadillac Automobile Company was formed in 902 out of the remnants of one of Henry Ford's early attempts at building cars, and the company's backers turned to Leland for help. 
 Leland's firm made the engines, transmissions and steering gear and Cadillac went from building two cars in 1902 to producing 1895 in the year between March 1903 and March 1904. 
 On Christmas Eve, 1904, Leland took over management of the company and merged his business to create the Cadillac Motor Car Company. 
 Over the next seven years Cadillac built up a reputation as a quality car maker and, in 1906, released the four-cylinder Model L. At &dollar;5000, it was six times the price of the single-cylinder runabout and as well made as any car in the world. 
 Leland claimed that 250 parts in his cars were made to tolerances of one-thousandth of an inch. 
 Cadillac's UK importer was aware of Leland's achievement, and looking for a way to prove the car's craftsmanship. 
 At the time most car makers claimed their parts were interchangeable. 
 Cadillac knew otherwise and suggested the RAC take three identical cars from its showroom, strip them down and scramble the parts. 
 The cars would then be rebuilt. 
 Intrigued by the idea the RAC drew up some rules and submitted them to other car manufacturers. 
 there were no takers, so Cadillac decided to accept its own challenge. 
 From eight Cadillacs in the London showroom, three were selected and driven to Brooklands to give each car 50 miles on the clock before they were dismantled. 
 On 2 March 1908, all the wheels and mudguards were removed, the engines dismantled and the bits piled into a heap. 
 The RAC removed 89 parts from the stack and asked for replacements from the spares stock. 
 Most people expected failure. 
 It had been calculated that a uniformity of two-thousandths of an inch was an unheard-of standard of accuracy &mdash; except at Cadillac. 
 When the three cars were reassembled they had different coloured wheels and mudguards. 
 Most observers just laughed and gave the cars no chance of starting. 
 The first two Cadillacs started with but one pull of the crank handle, the third took two turns. 
 The cars were then each driven 500 miles at Brooklands without adjustment of any kind, averaging 34mph. 
 The Dewar Challenge Trophy &mdash; awarded for the most meritorious performance of the year in any trial under the Long-Distance Trials Regulations &mdash; was presented to Cadillac that year, the first time the trophy had been won by a US car maker. 
 After lengthy negotiations, which kept raising the price, an over-extended General Motors paid &dollar;4.5 million for Cadillac in 1909, and then used the good name of Leland and Cadillac to borrow more money to expand its empire further. 
 Leland and this son Wilfred continued to work for the company. 
 In 1910 a friend was killed crank-starting a Cadillac. 
 Leland vowed to find some way of preventing such accidents. 
 Turning to Charles Kettering, who'd invented an electric motor small enough to power a National Cash Register, Leland asked if something similar could be adapted to the internal combustion engine. 
 The sceptics at GM reckoned it could never work &mdash; the motor would overheat and no battery could store enough energy to turn over a car's engine. 
 Working with Cadillac engineers, Kettering created the starter motor, using the flywheel to turn over the engine. 
 The starter motor worked perfectly and soon became a much sought-after Cadillac feature quickly adopted by all car makers. 
 The marque won another Dewar Trophy in 1912. 
 When the US entered World War I in April 1917, Leland suggested to GM it should begin building aircraft engines. 
 William Durant, who ran GM, didn't want to be involved in the war effort and ordered the Lelands not t proceed with the idea. 
 Leland and his son went off to Washington to see if it was possible to win a contract from the Government to manufacture engines on their own. 
 Given the assurance that it would, they returned to Detroit, resigned from GM and formed the Lincoln Motor Company. 
 Henry Leland was 74 when he won a contract to supply Liberty engines, with no more than his technical know-how, reputation and a factory site as collateral. 
 Lincoln built 6500 Liberty engines and employed 6000 people by the end of the war. 
 Ironically, Cadillac also started building the same engines soon after Leland started Lincoln. 
 Unlike GM, the young company had no car-making base to fall back on, so it started afresh. 
 When the first Lincoln was delivered in September 1920, the dealers held orders for 1000 cars. 
 Unfortunately the styling, by Leland's son-in-law resembled a pre=war Cadillac, though the quality of its 60deg V8 engine was obvious. 
 Leland's insistence on excellence meant production slowed to 400 cars per month &mdash; far too low a figure to be profitable. 
 The other directors wanted Lincoln to go into receivership. 
 While the Lelands were attempting to raise additional money, Lincoln was hit by a tax bill for &dollar;4.5 million &mdash; but it was too late. 
 Lincoln went into receivership and was put up for sale on 4 February, 1922. 
 The same day Henry Ford paid &dollar;8 million for the company, a price set by the presiding judge. 
 Leland claimed his company was worth over &dollar;16 million: 3407 Lincolns had been built and 241 remained in the plant at the time of the sale. 
 The Lelands stayed to carry on their work but friction quickly developed and, four months after the take-over the Lelands quit. 
 Henry Leland claimed Henry Ford had promised to reimburse all Lincoln's original creditors and shareholders. 
 Henry Ford maintained no such agreement existed. 
 Leland fought the case through the courts before giving up in September 1931, just six months before he died. 
 The Cadillac and Lincoln battle to be the top US luxury car continues today.  
 Henry Leland (standing on right) and Henry Ford (on left) witness sons Edsel (sitting on left) and Wilfred signing the &dollar;8 million takeover of Lincoln Motor Company. 
 Friction caused Lelands to quit soon after 
 RUNNING REPORT 
 DENTED PRIDE 
 Niggling faults and some rear end damage have not spoilt the Metro 1.1S for Mark Harrop 
 First it was the clutch, then came the brakes, and now its the seats. 
 Our Metro has not been a particularly healthy child and its latest illness is a pair of prematurely-worn front seats, the only set with such a problem in the whole of the UK. 
 At least that's what we've been told by the seat-cover suppliers, Courtaulds Textiles, which produces the terribly natty &bquo;Renaissance&equo; decor for Rover's new Metro. 
 No sooner had Courtaulds read the comments by our Metro's previous keeper, Jill Stanton &mdash; that the material had developed &bquo;bobbly sweater syndrome&equo; (25 July) than they were inspecting the offending objects with microscopes and pronouncing themselves shocked and baffled. 
 They had checked similar seats that had been subjected to the rough and tumble of Metropolitan Police life, and ones that had supported over 70,000 miles, and they were all right as rain. 
 So into the garage the car went to have the seats changed &mdash; under warranty, of course &mdash; and the &bquo;bad&equo; pair couriered to Courtaulds for full forensic examination, results of which will be known by the next Running Report. 
 The operation took no more than 10 minutes and, once again, was carried out courteously and efficiently by Brunt and Davies, my wallet staying firmly in my pocket. 
 I say once again because they are getting getting used to the sight of G939 BKV. 
 At 3500 miles into the Metro's life, the Rover dealer had to sort out a badly slipping clutch and, a few miles later, replace the brake pads in a effort to cure the soggy feel of the originals. 
 And now a third major part has had to be changed. 
 This does not bode well for Rover's bright new star, maybe, but what helps the car's cause enormously is the quality of the back-up that Rover has obviously insisted on. 
 This was confirmed only a few days ago when yet another visit to the garage became necessary, this time through no fault of the Metro's. 
 Some swine had bashed the offside rear three-quarter in a very clumsy attempt to park behind me. 
 The driver's morals were obviously of the same low standard as his/her driving, as no apology or name and address was left. 
 I decided to seek the damage estimate at a dealership other than Brunt and Davies and was pleased to find a choice of three, all close by. 
 I was even more pleased to find that all of them could see me almost immediately, and the one I chose inspected the car as soon as I arrived and had the quote dropped through my letterbox the next morning. 
 The &pound;200 estimate soon knocked the smile off my face, though, and I hope the guilty party is having trouble sleeping at night. 
 What looks like a fairly minor scrape would cost me the best part of a planned skiing trip at Christmas to repair if this wasn't a company car. 
 These tiresome but, one hopes, isolated problems aside, our Metro 1.1S is still running like a dream. 
 Indeed, the quality feel of the car, the ease and enjoyment of driving it, and the handling and ride rewards that its Hydragas suspension offers make it all too simple to overlook the problems. 
 The 1.1-litre K series engine seems to improve with every mile, providing smooth and enthusiastic performance at low revs or high speeds, and proving an ideal partner for the five-speed gearbox, which is a sheer delight to use. 
 Add this to steering that is not too heavy when parking and direct and communicative at speed, and a chassis that irons out most road imperfections but still allows great cornering balance, and the Metro is rarely unsuited to a journey, whether motorway or A-road, long or short. 
 Unless, that is, you are either over six foot or want to take more than one friend with you. 
 With the seat right back to fit my legs in, rear legroom is virtually non-existent, and being and tall and friendly chap ( sic ), this is far from ideal. 
 I have to bend my head forward to squeeze in. 
 My eyes then focus directly between the top of the windscreen and the roof, and if I'm at the front at traffic lights, I feel like Ayrton Senna would if you blindfolded him and put him on pole position. 
 I simply can't see the lights. 
 Forget the amber gamblers, I'm fast becoming a fully fledged red and green gambler, too. 
 The view through the small rear mirror is rather limited, as Jill Stanton has mentioned before, and the manual wing mirrors are so stiff that trying to fine-tune them is like trying to thread a needle wearing boxing gloves. 
 Full marks though for the clarity of all the instruments, the relationship of the controls, pedals and wheel &mdash; although this is a little too offset for some &mdash; and the rattle-free interior. 
 The tyres are wearing well, fuel economy is improving and it has needed no extra oil since its 6000-mile service, which cost a reasonable &pound;17.48. 
 I couldn't imagine a little car with a luxury big-car feel until I drove the Metro. 
 Road test editor David Vivian was spot on when he described the car as &bquo;quite simply a revelation.&equo; 
 This car &bquo;wears its Rover badge with pride&equo; was the verdict of the first road test, and with nearly 7000 miles having been added to the car wince then, our 1.1S has substantiated that statement convincingly. 
 I only wish I was shorter. 
 DATABASE 
 Market Update 
 Toyota has increased prices  by between 3.5 and four per cent on most models. 
 The 2.4 litre diesel Landcruiser and Corollas are up one per cent, while the Starlet, (the GL is the only model available) is up &pound;260 to &pound;7860. 
 The 2-litre MR2 range now starts at &pound;14,505, up from &pound;14,001, the entry-level Carina 1.6XL saloon is &pound;10,280 at &pound;349 increase and the Celica GT is &pound;17,925, up by &pound;624. 
 Unaffected are Supras, the 4.2-litre Landcruiser and the &pound;18,099 Previa. 
 Mazda's MX-5 hard-top  costs &pound;1145. 
 The glass-fibre reinforced resin top has a heated screen, cloth-lined interior and courtesy light. 
 The Mazda's hard-top is made by TWR of Oxford and affixes using the catches for the soft-top. 
 Lada prices went up  by three per cent on 1 October making their cheapest car, the Riva 1300SEL saloon, &pound;3275. 
 The Samara 1300SL 3 door is up &pound;154 to &pound;1549 and the Niva 4wd now costs &pound;7049. 
 The Russian manufacturer's most expensive model, the Niva 4wd Cossack, goes up from &pound;8395 to &pound;8649. 
 Alfa Romeo has introduced  a 2.5 litre V6 engine for the 75, but dropped both 188bhp versions &mdash; the V6 and Veloce. 
 The &pound;17,315 V6 Cloverleaf has 192bhp, and a catalytic converter is standard-fit. 
 Equipment includes a limited-slip differential, power steering, tinted glass, central locking and alloy wheels. 
 The sunroof and air conditioning are cost extras. 
 The price pitches the 75 V6 Cloverleaf close to the 2-litre 164 Twin Spark Lusso, which costs &pound;17,560. 
 Insurance ratings for the Nissan  Primera will be one higher than for equivalent Sierra and Cavalier models. 
 The 1.6-litre Primeras rank in group five and the 2-litre fuel-injected models in group six, according to the Association of British Insurers. 
  Peter Burgess   
 Mazda MX-5's hard-top costs &pound;1145 
 How Fast, How Good 
 IMPORTANT INFORMATION: 
 This is how the Autocar &amp; Motor  How Fast, How Good data has been derived: 30&ndash;70mph indicates overtaking ability and is measured through the gears; 30&ndash;50mph is recorded in top gear (or fourth in the case of five-speed manual gearbox models); 50&ndash;70 mph is recorded in top. 
 Overall consumption is that recorded during the test period, while touring mpg is based on official Government economy figures &mdash; 50 per cent of urban cycle, plus 25 per cent each of 56 mph and 75 mph steady speed cycles. 
 Reprinting of results, in whole or in part, is forbidden except by permission of the publisher. 
 &bull; Denotes models no longer on sale in the form tested 
 BENTLEY IS BACK! 
 New Continental: the &bquo;ultimate&equo; coupe 
 &pound;60,000 WIN A PEUGEOT COMPETITION STARTS INSIDE 
 Full test NEW BMW 325i 
 THIS WEEK 
 Geneva Show Nothing succeeds like excess 4 
 News Anti-Japanese pressure builds 13 
 Bentley is Back And now more than just a badge 16 
 Analysis What we want from this year's budget 20 
 Competition Win a Peugeot 205XS 24 
 US Grand Prix Full report on the season opener 28 
 Sport Revealing the defending Group C Merc 33 
 Arrivals Volvo's spirited but dated 940 SE Turbo 36 
 Arrivals Never judge a Toyota Paseo by its cover 39 
 Road Test: BMW 325i SE A change of direction for BMW 48 
 Signing Off Tony Rudd looks back over his brilliant career 56 
 A Weighty Problem And why composites may be the solution 60 
 Secondhand Spotlight Five grand buys you a 4wd family car 62 
 Escort Revisited Can it really be as duff as we said it was? 64 
 Great Concept Cars The stunning Dino Berlinetta Speciale 70 
 Master Stroke Golf G60 Limited &mdash; the greatest Golf yet 76 
 Angry Young Man Hope springs eternal in Cambridge 79 
 Running Report Car of the year Renault Clio joins the fleet 81 
 DATABASE Info 83, How Much 84, How Fast 90 
 CLASSIFIED 29 pages of new and used cars for sale, 94  
 Full report on the Geneva show, p4 
 BMW 325i SE: different from its predecessor but is it better? 
 See p48 
 THIS WEEK GENEVA SHOW 
 No excuses needed 
 Excellence at any price was the theme of the Geneva show, with the new Mercedes S-class and Bentley's Continental R leading the field in a no-holds-barred battle to steal the spotlight. 
 Report by Michael Harvey and Peter Robinson 
 On the Mercedes-Benz stand all was quiet contemplation and sober judgements as the world's automotive sages basked in a recyclable, CFC-free attempt at justifying a double-glazed, 408bhp V12 monolith weighing more than two tonnes, 17ft long and called the new Mercedes S-class. 
 On the stand of Rolls-Royce and Bentley, however, no excuses were being made for the reawakening of one of Britain's best known and loved marques from 40 years of savage badge engineering. 
 As the unashamedly extravagant Continental R in the most outrageous shade of red majestically revolved on the stand to an upbeat and immensely loud recording of &bquo;Land Of Hope And Glory&equo; the last thing on anyone's mind was how the CFCs in the air conditioning were going to rip the ozone to pieces. 
 Two very different ways of launching two of the most uncommon cars you will ever see and at one of the most difficult times ever to hit the motor industry. 
 Difficult for bread-and-butter manufacturers, never mind the makers of cars so far off the scale (up to &pound;80,000 for the 600SEL Merc and twice that for the Bentley) that by any rational thinking they belong to a different era altogether &mdash; one without recession, a war just over and all the current uncertainties. 
 Were they irrelevant or, worse, irresponsible? 
 Or did the 1991 Geneva show provide the cheer we all needed? 
 If it's the latter then there was plenty more at the show to warm any enthusiast's heart. 
 You had to look hard to find a car that didn't boast an &pound;80,000-plus price sticker, plus a 200mph-plus top speed or, as was usually the case, both. 
 Those that were there seemed intended as no more than second or even third-string playthings for those untouched by the recession. 
 Of all the hard-hit member states, it was good old Blighty that had the most to shout about, not least because here was a good old-fashioned, honest-to-goodness motor show surprise. 
 And at a quarter to twelve last Tuesday, Bentley made the most of it. 
 Its first new-car launch for 10 years, and the first new shape to be badged solely as a Bentley since the Continental R-type of 1952, was launched with a fanfare that almost out-Victored Victor Gauntlett. 
 This time he had less to shout about on his Aston Martin stand &mdash; just the new two-plus-two Volante with the lower hood line. 
 His big bang comes at the NEC show in 1992 with the 530bhp twin-supercharged Vantage &mdash; but as a Bentley fan he was beaming nonetheless. 
 Gauntlett has already ordered his Continental R &mdash; in British Racing Green, of course. 
 Rolls-Royce will be hoping there are more where he came from. 
 At &pound;160,000 the Continental R is the most expensive British production car ever. 
 Chairman Peter Ward is confident of selling 280 a year, split between the UK, the US and European and Pacific markets. 
 The dealers, said Ward, are &bquo;ecstatic with the price&equo; and, even at a time when speculating on cars has fallen flat, steps were being taken to ensure that only genuine customers had their &pound;20,000 deposits accepted. 
 What's more, there's a strict limit of one car per customer. 
 Deliveries start at the end of this year. 
 Ward sees the 145mph car, which evolved out of the Project 90 Geneva show car of 1985, as &bquo;the finest sporting coupe in the world&equo;, with a real four-seat cabin. 
 This is seen as crucial in attracting people away from the current crop of cramped top-of-the-range coupes &mdash; essential if the car is not simply to draw existing Bentley customers from the Turbo R. 
 The decision to show the car was taken last November, not long after Rolls-Royce insisted that an introduction was still several years away. 
 Ward doesn't admit it, but faced with declining sales and lay-offs at Crewe the Continental R is the confidence booster the company needs. 
 No sign of the Cosworth four-valve heads for the turbocharged V8, though &mdash; at least not yet. 
 Ward is cagey: &bquo;The current engine meets all emissions requirements and we are happy with it. 
 We are not changing it.&equo; 
 And with what is still quaintly described as &bquo;sufficient power&equo; Ward is convinced of the new car's credentials: &bquo;I am sure the Continental R can stand shoulder to shoulder with anything else we have ever built.&equo; 
 (Full technical description on page 16). 
 Few would doubt that the same is being said at Mercedes. 
 In appearance, the slab-sided yet undoubtedly highly effective new S-class disguises its massive bulk. 
 In light colours especially the &bquo;short&equo; wheelbase version could almost pass for a successor to the mid-range W124. 
 The S-class arrives in the UK in September, at prices that reflect the increased equipment levels but still make the departing model look positively reasonable. 
 You'll get little change from &pound;40,000 for the 300SE, the 500SE is expected to sell for around &pound;60,000 while the flagship 600SEL (the short wheelbase model won't be sold in Britain) is expected to be close to &pound;80,000 &mdash; &pound;22,500 more than the rival 750iL BMW. 
 Less apparent on Mercedes' stand &mdash; and consequently ignored by most show visitors &mdash; was a prototype 190 electric car. 
 Developed in conjunction with AEG (another Daimler Benz company) and the UK Beta Research organisation from Derby, the 190 uses high-energy sodium nickel chloride batteries that have a life of five years or 35,000 miles &mdash; four times that of normal lead-acid batteries. 
 As if the S-class's might and the electric 190's ingenuity weren't enough, the 500SL turned up with the superb 500E wheels, looking more covetable than ever. 
 Waiting in the wings is the C112 supercar, powered, we now believe, by the new V12 engine and set to make its first public appearance at the Frankfurt show in September. 
 In the ever more intense rivalry between Mercedes and BMW, that should have been a blast big enough to silence the boys from Munich. 
 On the contrary, BMW &mdash; which is to celebrate its 75th anniversary soon &mdash; greeted the announcement of the S-class with undisguised glee while sitting back to count record orders for its new 3-series and boast about production figures for its V12 &mdash; now running at 80 per day when the original target had been 10 to 15. 
 Even so, there was no avoiding the fact that the S-class completely overshadowed BMW's somewhat unconvincing attempts to steal some glory from the newcomer by adding some of its technical highlights &mdash; double glazing, self-shutting doors and parking proximity sensors &mdash; to its 750iL's options list. 
 BMW's engineering director, Wolfgang Reitzle, didn't take too well to suggestions that the up-specification of the 750iL (in the UK this autumn) was a sign of panic. 
 &bquo;It's got nothing to do with rivalry. 
 It's the suppliers. 
 They are asked to develop the double glazing for Mercedes on a non-exclusive basis and they offer it to us,&equo; says Reitzle. 
 &bquo;And why do you think Mercedes developed a V12 engine?&equo; 
 BMW was rather less sensitive about the other V12 BMW engine on display, in the Giorgetto Giugiaro-designed Nazca M12 mid-engined supercar &mdash; the best car from Italdesign in years. 
 It was a big drawcard for almost everyone at the show, and none more so that Reitzle and his boss, von Kuenheim. 
 Like most at the top of the business, Reitzle wasn't going to go on the record either openly praising or criticising Giugiaro. 
 He knows better than that, and anyway he is rumoured to be paying the Italian genius a lot of money for his one-box design vision that forms part of BMW's long-rumoured MPV programme. 
 On the M12, all Reitzle would say was: &bquo;I cannot predict the future for that car. 
 For that you will have to speak to Mr Giugiaro.&equo; 
 Giugiaro didn't say much either, but enough to give hope that this stunning-looking M1 successor will become available. 
 It's easy to see why Reitzle was impressed. 
 Giugiaro had taken the unusual step of displaying a chassis too, letting the world see the high standard of carbon-fibre work in his monocoque, the cockpit-adjustable anti-roll bars and the massive 14ins drilled racing disc brakes. 
 It's odd by current supercar standards because as BMW's 300bhp V12 engine was never meant to be a stressed item &mdash; it is carried in a subframe sling &mdash; but otherwise it looks like it could be built tomorrow. 
 The last truly impressive Giugiaro car &mdash; the 1988 Aztec &mdash; has just gone into production for the Japanese market at &pound;500,000. 
 Giugiaro says the Nazca would be less. 
 Taking notes on the Nazca were Gordon Murray and Peter Stevens of McLaren Cars. 
 Three weeks ago McLaren announced that its ultimate supercar, the F1, which we will see at this show next year, will also be powered by a BMW V12 &mdash; a six-litre Motorsports unit. 
 You get the feeling that BMW likes the attention it's getting in this area &mdash; plenty of supercar glory by association without getting its environmentally friendly hands dirty. 
 &bquo;We could build a supercar today if we wanted to, but we have other priorities right now. 
 Supplying engines to projects like this lets us compete with the supercars and avoid all the complicated polemics they create,&equo; said Reitzle. 
 Pininfarina, just across the aisle from Italdesign, is crying out for Vauxhall to take a similar level of interest in its Lotus Carlton-powered Chronos, making a second show appearance but this time as a fully engineered runner. 
 With its removeable roof stored in the roof it looked great, but the word from Pininfarina and General Motors Europe was not promising. 
 Alfa Romeo had a now-you-see-it, now-you-don't glass roof on its 164-based Proteo coupe, but a production future here is altogether more promising. 
 The Proteo has been engineered with a view to taking over from the SZ after Zagato builds the 1000th car late next year. 
 Powered by a 24-valve version of the 164's three-litre V6 and driven at all four corners via a thinking electronic centre coupling, it's a car that Alfa says it would sell for &pound;75,000. 
 Its appealing rakish shape is Alfa's own work, under the guidance of Walter Da Silva, who in the past has been wrongly credited as the designer of the SZ. 
 The body, with its trademark Alfa knife swage and tiny headlamps, is built in a mixture of steel and Kevlar and features a beautifully effective roadster option: touch a button and the roof glass and rear windows drop beneath a complicated rear lid. 
 Nobody, including Da Silva and managing director Giovan Battista Razzeli, would say it would go into production, but &bquo;we had the courage to build the SZ&equo; was Da Silva's slightly encouraging line. 
 If it's courage it takes to put sports cars and coupes into production then the product planners at Mazda deserve a medal. 
 A year after the MX-5 arrived in the UK, Mazda had another niche car to present &mdash; the V6 engined but (unexpectedly) modestly powered MX-3. 
 The MX-3, at 166ins long, is more a Volkswagen Corrado rival than the anticipated threat to the Honda CRX. 
 Its design drew very mixed responses, the styling being criticised for its hotchpotch of elements from the MX-5 (taillights) to the current Toyota Celica (rear hatch) and even Nissan's 100NX (nose and headlights). 
 As a result, the coupe's front and rear look rather as if they were designed by different committees. 
 Europe is expected to get 1200 cars a month, which seems an achievable target if the expected &pound;15,000 price is right for the V6. 
 If there was disappointment at the 136bhp produced by the 24-valve 1.8-litre V6, the news that the 2.5-litre version &mdash; destined first for the next 626 &mdash; slots straight in appeased those who wanted to view the MX-3 as a low cost substitute for Porsche's 944. 
 Towards the other end of the coupe market was Honda's Legend Coupe, making its European debut with its sister saloon. 
 With only a V6 under the bonnet &mdash; albeit an all new 3.2-litre 204bhp unit &mdash; driving the front wheels, Honda clearly isn't playing Mercedes' game. 
 Nevertheless, it has taken more than just a pinch of the new S-class's style with its first real attempt at a grille, cut down into the front bumper. 
 Both versions will be in the UK this April, with the saloon looking to tempt everything up to Lexus buyers with an all-in price of around &pound;28,000 and the coupe out on its own at around &pound;30,000. 
 Mitsubishi faces a busy year in the UK too. 
 It's only just launched the Sigma but is already pressing Japan for more volume, and pretty soon will have the new-generation Shoguns. 
 Thanks to import restrictions, the new range won't help Mitsubishi sell any more than 1990's record of 3700 Shoguns (with the changeover, 3000 is this year's likely figure) but with a significant price rise likely the dealers will be happy. 
 The new four-model range sees the end of the old 2.6-litre four. 
 The only petrol engine now available is the 155bhp three-litre V6. 
 The new range jumps in price from around &pound;19,000 for a short-wheelbase, three-door turbo diesel to &pound;25,000 for a long-wheelbase five-door V6. 
 The current range runs from &pound;16,000 to &pound;20,000. 
 The Shogun, certainly the short-wheelbase Chelsea Farmer's version, will face some stiff competition later this year from an unfamiliar source &mdash; Vauxhall. 
 The recreational vehicles &mdash; Vauxhall is sensitive about calling them off-roaders &mdash; are familiar; in Japan and in the US they're the short-wheelbase Isuzu Amigo and the long-wheelbase five-door Rodeo, but in the UK they're to be the Vauxhall Frontera Sport and Frontera respectively. 
 Built in Luton at IBC and with a range of European Vauxhall and Opel engines that take local content to 80 per cent, they'll be in about half of Vauxhall's dealers with prices just up on the Suzuki Vitara for the Sport and just below the Isuzu Trooper and old Shogun for the five-door Across Europe, GM is optimistic it can sell 40,000 and has capacity for another 10,000 should Europe's fastest-growing market segment require it. 
 Even Volkswagen was getting in on the act with its two concept Varios (see separate story), which could bring four-wheel-drive recreational motoring to a much wider audience. 
 Of more direct significance was the debut in the Passat of VW's VR6 &bquo;in-line-vee&equo; 2.8-litre engine. 
 Research director Ulrich Seiffert was anxious to put an end to rumours that the engine had been delayed by chronic friction and vibration problems. 
 &bquo;The engine has always been on schedule, our engineers just started talking about it too soon. 
 There has been a slight redesign of the ancillaries for crash protection reasons and we've increased capacities to get more power, but otherwise it has been developed perfectly,&equo; said Seiffert. 
 The first production versions of Audi's Cabriolet were on show, although it doesn't go on sale until April/May in Germany and the UK launch has been delayed until summer 1992, when it's expected to be priced at about &pound;25,000. 
 Released with the five-cylinder 133bhp engine only, other powerplants will become available. 
 Two new engines were added to the 100 range &mdash; a 115bhp two-litre petrol and 82bhp 2.4-litre diesel. 
 The rumoured turbo diesel is still some months away. 
 British buyers get their first glimpse of the new 100, in V6 form, at the end of April. 
 Against all expectations, the S2 Coupe has become the most popular of all the Coupes, accounting for a quarter of total production. 
 This is a big year for Audi. 
 In addition to numerous 100 variants, including a proper estate, Frankfurt will see the new 80/90 and a 230bhp turbocharged 20-valve petrol engine tied to a new six-speed gearbox that's also due in the S2 to create the real  Quattro replacement. 
 Across the floor from Audi, Ford was making much ado of its standard anti-lock brakes on all cars sold in Switzerland, a policy Ford says is being evaluated for the UK. 
 The only new product on the stand was the RA2000 Escort, which now won't be in the UK until November after what Ford described as an &bquo;unfinished development programme&equo; slowed things down. 
 It now seems that the RS2000's 16-valve Dagenham-built engine will feature in that car only. 
 It's not going into the current Sierra or 1993's CDW27 Sierra replacement. 
 The endlessly fertile mind of Franco Sbarro came up with a two-seater, V12 mid-engined sports car whose body is mounted on the engine/gearbox unit, central beam chassis and suspension by six hydraulic links. 
 The hydraulics, in theory, separate the chassis from the body to provide firm suspension yet a comfortable ride. 
 Sbarro compared the links to hydraulic jacks that allow the body height to be changed to vary ride comfort without affecting the way the suspension functions. 
 It's difficult to know who's the bigger dreamer, Franco Sbarro or Willy Koenig, who is convinced he'll find 30 buyers for his 236mph, &pound;700,000 C62 Porsche-engined, Porsche 926 race-car clone. 
 Thankfully, it seems that the charming Claudio Zampolli, who, two years ago, brought the first prototype Cizeta to Geneva, is dreaming no longer. 
 After the show had ended, the black Cizeta on display was off to the company's first client in Singapore, who'll be &dollar;630,000 lighter for the privilege of owning the world's only V16-engined production car. 
 Another three will be built this year and a further 10 a year later. 
 Zampolli summed up the curiously optimistic mood the industry found itself in, post-war, at Geneva: &bquo;You know,&equo; he said, &bquo;during the war I took three orders for the car. 
 From Arabs.&equo;  
 Surprise announcement of Bentley Continental (top) stole thunder from Giugiaro's striking V12 Nazca (above) 
 Reactions to Mercedes S-class were mixed 
 Keenly priced UK-built Vauxhall Frontera is set to shake up UK recreational market from this November 
 New generation Shogun will be costly, but Mitsubishi is confident of its success 
 The two-litre 148bhp Fiat Tipo 16v is on its way at last 
 New generation Shogun will be costly, but Mitsubishi is confident of its success 
 Facelifted Alpine A610&hellip; 
 &hellip; and Espace both pack new Renault V6 powerplant 
 Alfa Proteo, better looking than the SZ and every bit as likely to make production 
 Audi cabrio for summer '92 
 Ford's Escort RS2000 
 Pininfarina's Chronos now a runner, but not a goer 
 The unbalanced design of Mazda's MX-3 didn't live up to the promise of its unique 1.8-litre V6 specification 
 BMW aped Mercedes with this double-glazed 750iL 
 New Honda Legend twins arrive in the UK in April 
 Wacky shape of Volkswagen's two Varios the work of students, but tidies up in-house by VW's own team 
 Hyundai Lantra another convincing car from Korea 
 &pound;700,000 will buy you a road-going 962 from Koenig 
 &bquo;Twin-chassis&equo; Sbarro 
 First &dollar;630,000 production Cizeta V16 is on its way to a customer in Singapore 
 Italian exotica, Tokyo style 
 The 200mph club looked alive and well at Geneva with the arrival of the production Cizeta V16T, priced at a staggering &dollar;630,000 (&pound;330,000), and the debut of a brand new company, Art &amp; Tech Torino, sister company to the Japanese design consultancy in Tokyo. 
 The key man of the new venture is Ryoji Yamazaki, a 42-year-old who is not only financing the project through his business activities in Japan but is also acting as chief designer. 
 At Geneva the company showed the Sogna (in plaster model form only), a two-seat mid-engined sports car with very aggressive Bertone-like lines. 
 The first running prototype is expected in September and will be powered by the 455bhp 5.2-litre V12 engine from the Lamborghini Countach. 
 Art &amp; Tech has outlined an extremely ambitious programme that calls for three different mid-engined sports car to be produced. 
 The Sogna, which in Italian means &bquo;let you dream&equo;, will be built in very small numbers and it's still not clear where the powerplant will come from. 
 Yamazaki says it will be a V12 and that he's talking to three companies. 
 Of the second and third models even less is known. 
 And there's talk of a fourth model. 
 apparently a full four-seat mid-engined coupe, something so complicated from the styling and weight balance point of view that it's never been satisfactorily achieved before. 
 Yamazaki seems unconcerned by the fact that he's taking on problems that have defeated many who should have known better. 
  Luca Ciferri   
 A supercar designed and built in Turin, but by the Japanese, the Art &amp; Tech Sogna looked the part 
 DISPATCHES 
 &bull; One senior Mercedes-Benz executive admitted the vulgar V12 badge on the C-pillar of the S-class was a triumph of marketing over design and quickly added that it was a delete option intended for the Japanese and Americans. 
 &bull; As Mercedes basked in the splendour of its opulent new S-class, the collective verdict of rival designers was decidedly less positive. 
 &bquo;It's a nothing car, well done but still a nothing car,&equo; claimed one highly talented young British designer. 
 &bquo;The grille is purely chintzy,&equo; maintained a colleague. 
 Another, senior designer from a German competitor (not BMW) stated: &bquo;I like the crinkled leather on the doors&equo;, but could find nothing about the exterior to praise: &bquo;It's design stagnation; from some angles it looks like a Lincoln.&equo; 
 All agreed it wasn't &bquo;a designer's car&equo; but a pragmatic commercial shape that may well look imposing outside a posh hotel but will never win any design awards. 
 Wolfgang Reitzle, BMW's head engineer, was more generous: &bquo;It's just right for Mercedes. 
 It's a well made car.&equo; 
 &bull; Estimates of the number of journalists at the S-class release varied between 600 to 700. 
 Many admitted to having a doze through a meaningless movie presentation that talked more of light and energy, love and space than the car. 
 &bull; BMW Chairman Eberhard von Kuenheim squashed reports that the BMW-McLaren link might lead the company back to F1 racing when McLaren's contract with Honda runs out. 
 &bquo;F1 is a fantastic way to spend money,&equo; he said, adding that a full F1 programme costs between &dollar;60m and &dollar;100m a year. 
 In Germany's socially responsible political climate he sees F1 as only &bquo;helping to destroy our reputation&equo;. 
 He left no doubts about BMW's position: &bquo;We will not go back to F1.&equo; 
 The great kit-car revival 
 The Mercedes and Bentley may have been the show stars; elsewhere, though, son of beach buggy was making a comeback. 
 Volkswagen's Vario I and Vario II were much more interesting than their wacky bodywork would suggest. 
 Their true significance is their separate platform chassis, which VW is prepared to sell to the world's specialist kit car builders with service back-up. 
 They have been in limbo since the demise of the Beetle chassis, reduced to fitting air dams and wide wheels on to standard car bodies. 
 You want a '90s beach buggy? 
 A sports car, a pick-up, a retro car? 
 All these, and more, will be possible on the basis of the Vario's strengthened 4wd Golf Syncro chassis. 
 Doors, roof and windows are thrown out. 
 What remains is a platform with an extra 95 pounds of stiffening, all the hard points and mechanical components. 
 The only limitation is the bodybuilder's imagination. 
 Martin D Volke, whose Volke company built the two prototypes in only three months, says the chassis and Syncro transmission is good for up to 500 horsepower. 
 He estimates the chassis could go into production within a year. 
 The project came to a head a year ago, when Ulrich Seifert, VW's head of research, and Herbert Schaefer, VW's design chief, commissioned the designs from Switzerland's Art Centre College. 
 The result could herald the revival of the dormant kit car industry. 
  Richard Feast   
 The Varios' platform, from the 4wd Golf Syncro, is a gift to latter-day beach buggy builders everywhere 
 DISPATCHES 
 &bull; At least one of the &dollar;630,000 Cizetas will be coming to Britain this year &mdash; to be crashed. 
 MIRA is to host the test in order for Cizeta to get certification to sell the world's only V16 production car in new markets &mdash; including Britain. 
 It's unlikely to be a public crash test&hellip; 
 &bull;  Beleagurered  Porsche is considering a plan by engineering chief Ulrich Bez to downgrade future equipment levels to make cars lighter &mdash; and faster. 
 Alas, we are not able to report how much cheaper the cars would be if all the current goodies decamped to the options list. 
 &bull; The world's only &bquo;racing&equo; car with indicators and door-locks, the TWR-developed Jaguar XJR-15, may be driveable on public roads even more easily then we thought. 
 Unconfirmed reports suggest TWR is working on a road kit that will include air conditioning and drop-down windows. 
 &bull; Ropeable Lotus dealers in the US were after Lotus boss Michael Kimberley's blood after the Lotus-badged Bertone Emotion made its debut at the Detroit show earlier this year. 
 The stunning mid-engined car &mdash; apparently the result of a hush-hush deal with Bertone that Kimberley neglected to inform the dealers about &mdash; was seen rather more as the new Esprit than a design exercise. 
 The result was that the dealers didn't take too many orders for the &bquo;old&equo; car. 
 &bull; Meanwhile, the bloodletting at Lotus continues. 
 Latest to leave Hethel is Chris Peacock, parts and service director. 
 &bull; VAG UK managing director Richard Ide predicted that this month will be seen as the point where car sales in Britain turned and began to pick up. 
 &bquo;I feel better about the market now than I have for a long time,&equo; he said. 
 NEWS 
 February car sales plunge 
 UK new cars sales plunged by nearly 26 per cent in February in what was described by a spokesman for the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders as &bquo;the biggest month-on-month February drop I can remember.&equo; 
 Only 124,342 cars were sold last month &mdash; the lowest February figure since 1982 says the SMMT. 
 Jobs are being shed as the industry fights to cope with recession at home and abroad, although the prospect of a continued fall in interest rates is starting to bolster confidence. 
 &bquo;February is only a short month, so it is not going to have a devastating effect on figures, and there are now signs that the recession is bottoming out, which has to be good for the industry,&equo; a spokesman said. 
 Rover Group recorded its highest market share for seven months, at 16.29 per cent, but its sales were down 3725 to 20,260. 
 Market leader Ford marginally increased its share to 25.08 per cent with 31,184 registrations &mdash; a drop of more than 10,000 compared with February 1990. 
 Vauxhall held on to second spot with 21,679 sales (down 6994). 
 Luxury and performance car manufacturers were hard hit. 
 Porsche sold 88 cars last month (down from 320), while Jaguar sales dropped 48.8 per cent. 
 The top-selling car last month was the Ford Fiesta, which displaced the Vauxhall Cavalier. 
 Total sales for the first two months of 1991 at 287,876 were nearly 23 per cent down on the same period in 1990.  
 VW chief changes his tune on free trade 
 Anti-Japanese feeling in Europe grew at last week's Geneva show when VW chairman Carl Hahn, who was previously in favour of free trade, nailed his colours firmly to anti-Japanese campaigner Jacques Calvet's mast. 
 Calvet, chairman of the PSA Group, launched his most savage attack on European free trade policy at last year's Paris show. 
 His five-point plan, which included a 10-year transitional period and the inclusion of UK-built Japanese cars in quotas, now has the backing of Hahn. 
 Ford Chairman Lyndsay Halstead and General Motors Europe chairman Robert Eaton also backed the plan for a transitional period. 
 In Tokyo, MITI, the Japanese ministry for trade and industry, indicated that it would not approve attempts by Japanese manufacturers to make up for shortfalls in US exports to Europe. 
 Exports to EC countries increased 12.9 per cent in January compared with January 1990. 
 Asked about the reasons for his apparent about face, Hahn said: &bquo;You're always learning and I think in the past our view was wrong. 
 You have to learn from your mistakes. 
 Free trade has worked in Germany, but less well in the US. 
 In creating a single market we have to make sure we give equal opportunities to everyone, and not just create a jamboree for the Japanese.&equo; 
 Another industry chief reiterating his position at Geneva was Fiat SpA chairman Gianni Agnelli, who said that Japanese penetration would be limited to 15 to 18 per cent for a transitional period, and after that all restrictions should be dropped. 
 &bquo;Free trade is, after all, a big advantage to our customers,&equo; he said. 
 The harmony between Europe's big six &mdash; VW, Fiat, PSA, Renault, GM and Ford &mdash; looks more likely than ever to persuade the commission to go for a transitional period longer than three to five years. 
 Luca Ciferri  
 Carl Hahn: &bquo;I think in the past our view was wrong. 
 You have to learn from your mistakes&equo; 
 IN BRIEF 
 Ford has announced the price  of its Scorpio 24v, which is powered by a 195bhp Cosworth-developed 2.9-litre V6. 
 It will sell for &pound;26,800 including VAT and car tax, with a four-speed automatic transmission, air conditioning, anti-lock brakes and a limited slip differential as standard. 
 Mazda's parent company , MCL, has set up a new company, Kia (UK) Ltd, to market the Mazda 121-based Kia Pride hatchback (see Autocar &amp; Motor, 27 February). 
 The operation will be headed by Jeff Davies, former managing director of FSO Cars. 
 The longest-ever Land Rover  was supplied last week to Eastern Electricity for overhead maintenance work. 
 Based on a Defender 130, it is 21ft long and features permanent six-wheel drive. 
 The British Motor Industry Heritage Trust  is appealing for drawings, sketches and artefacts relating to the companies that amalgamated to form the Rover Group. 
 Managing director Peter Mitchell said: &bquo;We feel that our museum would be the most desirable place to keep this material, for the benefit of future generations.&equo; 
 A three-year unlimited-mileage warranty  has been introduced by Daihatsu on all its new vehicles. 
 The end of the Gulf war  has prompted Rover Group to increase exports of its cars. 
 Rover currently exports about 30 per cent of its production, and models like the 200, 400 and Land Rover Discovery have been particularly well received abroad. 
 MPs Roger King and Sir Hal Miller  are backing a campaign by Lucas to persuade the government to introduce policies to persuade more motorists to switch to &bquo;greener&equo; diesel-powered cars. 
 Airbag option for Volvo 400 
 Volvo claims its 400-series saloons, hatchbacks and coupes will be the first mid-price cars available with an airbag option from later this month. 
 The Volvo Supplemental Restraint System will offer a driver's side airbag as well as front and seat-belt pre-tensioners. 
 The full system is priced at &pound;715, although pre-tensioners can be specified on their own for &pound;125.  
 Volvos get airbag option 
 High-power 2.5-litre V6 from Cosworth 
 Cosworth Engineering has unveiled an all-new high-power V6 engine. 
 The 2.5-litre 90deg six, which was recently shown at Detroit's Society of Engineers show, produces a hefty 7500rpm and 184lb ft of torque at 5000rpm. 
 The all-alloy 24-valve twin-cam engine is described by Cosworth as being of the &bquo;high-efficiency&equo; type, and follows the &bquo;modular&equo; theory &mdash; meaning that the basic design could suit anything from the three-cylinder unit to a V12. 
 Using its patented Low Pressure Casting technique, Cosworth has been able to incorporate a high degree of stiffness in the compact unit. 
 As a result, it will be suitable for both longitudinal or transverse settings, and can sit low in a chassis. 
 No manufacturer has yet committed itself to using the Cosworth engine, which is expected to be fully ready for production by June. 
 However, the company is confident that customers will soon be lining up. 
 John Hancock, executive design engineer for the Engines Group division of Cosworth, said the engine received a lot of attention at the show in Detroit: &bquo;We've talked to a wide range of people who might want to use it, or derivatives of it,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It's designed to suit a production level of anything between 5000 and 20,000 units per year. 
 But if a customer wanted more than that, the design could be adapted.&equo; 
 Details include a method of improving breathing by using an additional throttle valve in each inlet port. 
 It features main bearing caps that don't have to be individually matched to the block &mdash; something that could make the production process of any engine much easier. 
 The most interesting feature of all, though, is the hollow balancer shaft doubling as a crankcase breather, which removes oil from crankcase fumes by centrifugal force.  
 Cosworth is seeking customers for its 226bhp V6 
 New Audi 100 priced for big sales increase 
 Audi's new 100 makes its showroom debut in May at prices no more than four to five per cent higher than the current range. 
 4 The revamped line-up will initially be topped by the all-new 174bhp 2.8-litre V6 model. 
 Later in the year the 135mph 2.8E will be topped by a turbocharged version, using Audi's 2.3-litre, 20-valve five-cylinder engine. 
 It will produce 230bhp and will be mated to a six-speed gearbox. 
 Audi hopes to achieve high sales by keeping the price increase modest, which suggests the new range will run from around &pound;17,000 for the 2.0E to &pound;26,000 for the Turbo quattro. 
 The company aims to nearly quadruple sales compared with the outgoing model. 
 &bquo;We intend to sell 12,000 units in a full year,&equo; a spokesman said.  
 Audi hopes its keen pricing will increase sales of new 100 four-fold over those achieved with the old model 
 DISPATCHES 
 JAPAN 
 Peter Nunn 
 &bull; Rover Japan will launch the Metro and Discovery in Japan this year. 
 It is considering badging the Metro 1.4 as the Rover 100. 
 &bull; New car sales dropped again in February, for the fourth consecutive month. 
 The Japanese Automobile Dealers Association says new car sales slumped 4.5 per cent over January 1990 to 474,160 units. 
 The biggest decline has been in the 1.3 to two-litre sector. 
 &bull; Space Runner is tipped to be the name Mitsubishi will use for its appealing new people carrier, which is due in the UK this year. 
 &bull; Porsche AG has opened a Tokyo office to function initially as an administration centre. 
 But the office will eventually be upgraded and formalised as Porsche Engineering. 
 FRANCE 
 Edouard Seidler 
 &bull; PSA's R&amp;D department is reportedly working on two new high-power engines &mdash; a V8 developing 250bhp and a 16-valve 2.1-litre turbo unit with 200bhp, slated for a future sporting Citroen ZX. 
 The turbo diesels in the XM and 605 are due to be uprated from 110 to 130bhp. 
 &bull; Renault chief Raymond Levy says he is hesitant to conclude the present Renault-Mitsubishi-Volvo talks before the post-1992 level of Japanese imports to Europe is decided. 
 &bull; Police say that cars are being stolen to be resold in car-starved east European countries. 
 To begin with, thieves went for the likes of Golf GTis and BMWs, but now bread-and-butter cars are also being taken. 
 &bull; Matra is developing what has been described as a &bquo;four-wheel motorcycle&equo;, using Clio 16-valve power. 
 The project is aimed at younger drivers who want totally open motoring but don't feel safe on two wheels. 
 ANALYSIS 
 At last! 
 The Bentley that's more than just a badge 
 The launch of the all-new Continental R marks a big step in Rolls-Royce's plan to forge a distinct, sporting image for Bentley. 
 For the first time in nearly 40 years Bentley has a shape to call its own. 
 By Tony Lewin 
 &bquo;We must build the finest sporting coupe in the world,&equo; exhorted Rolls-Royce chief executive Peter Ward some four years ago. 
 The decision came soon after Bentley's Project 90, a styling exercise designed to test customer reaction, proved &bquo;quite a remarkable success&equo; when displayed at the 1985 Geneva show. 
 The warm reception given to Project 90, designed by John Heffernan and Ken Greenley, provided positive proof to Ward that he was on the right track in his long-term strategy of building a separate and much stronger image for the Bentley marque. 
 Bentley, he argued, should forge its own identity by introducing sporting models unique to the winged &bquo;B&equo; badge. 
 Rolls-Royce, meanwhile, would concentrate on what it did best &mdash; building the most luxurious cars in the world. 
 The launch of the new Continental R at this week's Geneva show is perhaps the most important step to date in the unfolding of Ward's strategy for Bentley. 
 It's the first time Bentley has had an all-new shape to itself for almost two generations &mdash; since 1952, in fact, when the first of the R-type Continentals was launched in limited numbers and initially for export only. 
 That car, evolving through successive S1, S2 and S3 incarnations, became a major success for Bentley and did much to establish the tradition of a two-door, four-seater coupe in the group's model policy. 
 The direction of Bentley's evolution became clear with the launch of the Mulsanne Turbo R, which, with its huge power and improved suspension, at last re-established the marque's engineering credibility and its standing with younger and more enthusiastic owner-drivers. 
 The success of the strategy is again evident in the mushrooming if the Bentley brand's share of the overall Rolls Royce group registrations from six per cent in 1982 (when the original Mulsanne Turbo was announced) to virtually 50 per cent in 1989. 
 Bentley customers are younger but no less affluent than typical Rolls-Royce buyers; they must presumably be looked upon as good investments because they are more likely to make a repeat purchase than their Rolls-Royce counterparts. 
 While the process of evolving an all-new and unique Bentley coupe began as early as 1984 with the commissioning of design studies and quarter-scale models, work did not begin in earnest until 1986 when experience from the Turbo R and other developments was available. 
 Producing a coupe derivative, even in the limited numbers envisaged by Bentley with the Continental R, is not as easy as it used to be. 
 It was decided at an early stage that future designs could no longer be coach-built on separate custom-made chassis, as was the case with the now-deleted Bentley Continental and Rolls-Royce Corniche coupes (which still exist as convertibles), but would have to be built on the regular production lines at Crewe alongside the conventional monocoque four-door saloon models. 
 Rolls-Royce's model cycle of 15-plus years also posed something of a problem when it came to deciding tactics with the new car. 
 &bquo;With our lengthy product cycle, there was no solution but to develop a very special coupe for Bentley and for Bentley alone,&equo; Ward says. 
 &bquo;It had to be a truly British shape,&equo; echoes engineering director Mike Dunn. 
 &bquo;Preoccupation with Cd values has led to the boring shapes we have become all too familiar with.&equo; 
 The engineering brief was to achieve a 10 per cent gain in performance over the already rapid Turbo R, implying a top speed target of well over 150mph and 0&ndash;60mph acceleration in just over six seconds &mdash; a tough task, even allowing for the aerodynamic gains in the switch to the coupe shape, in a vehicle weighing at least two-and-a-half tons. 
 The broader objectives were to provide a vehicle that was fun to drive, docile in traffic, quiet and refined and a comfortable four-seater. 
 In the event, minor engineering work to the existing twin-catalyst 6.7-litre pushrod V8 has succeeded in achieving the desired results. 
 A new Bosch K-Motronic fuel injection and engine management system provides greater efficiency and the Continental's less restricted engine bay allows a cleaner-breathing inlet system to increase power over the mighty 333bhp of the Turbo R, though by what margin Rolls-Royce is unwilling to disclose. 
 A conservative estimate is that power must have grown by about 30bhp; in any case, this figure is likely to be overtaken soon when the four-valve cylinder heads known to have been developed by sister company Cosworth are installed in the car. 
 The transmission has undergone a major change to a four-speed unit, sourced from General Motors, and has been provided with the now-obligatory sports and economy programmes, plus a winter mode which allows the system to start off in second gear. 
 Third provides direct drive and fourth an overdrive, driving through a new two-piece propshaft to a 3.07:1 rear axle. 
 This gives a boost-regulated top speed of 145mph and 0&ndash;60mph acceleration in a claimed 6.6secs. 
 The maximum speed restriction is surprising considering that ZR-rated 255/60x16 Avon Turbospeed tyres are already standard equipment; it is possible that the company wants to leave space for higher-performance versions still to come. 
 Chassis details follow the broad principles laid down by the Turbo R, with three-stage electronically controlled dampers serving what is basically a MacPherson strut front and semi-trailing arm rear suspension geometry. 
 The steering and braking systems are power-assisted rack and pinion and all-round ventilated discs as before and overall dimensions, dictated by the saloon's 120.5ins wheelbase, are again comparable at 210ins long and 80.5ins wide. 
 Those figures make the steel-bodied Continental R a leviathan by modern standards. 
 Amusingly, the car is so big that when the team was doing the full-size tape and paint drawings, the normal rolls were not long enough. 
 Yet thanks to details such as recessed wipers and near-flush glazing, Heffernan and Greenley's achievement of a 0.365 Cd is a creditable one, especially as the traditional Bentley radiator grille and twinned seven-inch headlamps have been retained. 
 Much attention was paid to the precise angling of this key element in the Continental R's body concept: it comes across in the metal as very much better proportioned than the photographs suggest. 
 The only questionable ingredient in the package is the blistered rear wheel arch treatment, reminiscent of the outgoing Honda Legend Coupe. 
 Little short of a revolution has taken place inside the cabin, with the traditional Rolls/Bentley facia being superseded by a more modern arrangement siting the bulk of the instruments directly in front of the driver. 
 A full-length central console makes an appearance, too, carrying components such as an Alpine radio/cassette system and controls for the CD autochanger cleverly mounted in the central armrest. 
 The rear end of the console can be detached in order to transform the two individual rear seats into a bench accommodating three. 
 No less a transformation has been undergone by the front seats, which now enjoy much better lateral support, thanks to substantial side bolsters, and have electronic memory adjustment for reach, height, tilt and lumbar support. 
 Heating elements are also standard. 
 But perhaps the most welcome change of all is the resiting of the automatic transmission selector lever from the steering column to the central console; Rolls-Royce's famed electronic control is retained, though. 
 Unusually, the switch from standard to sports transmission modes is achieved via a button on the lever itself. 
 Additional equipment includes remote control central door locking linked to high-security locks and an alarm system, an optional driver's side airbag and a high-level rear spotlight. 
 Two new colours have been added to Bentley's paint box exclusively for the Continental: the Racing Red of the Geneva show and Ming Blue. 
 Production of the Continental R will begin in November, with only 70 units being allocated to each of Rolls-Royce's four main territories &mdash; the UK, the United States, Europe and the Far East &mdash; in the first year. 
 The likely &pound;160,000-plus list price will of course narrow the clientele down somewhat, but particular attention will still be paid to circumvent any speculative purchasers. 
 Initial reports from dealers seem to indicate there will be a lot more potential takers than there will be cars. 
 The 12 dealers we spoke to had 54 orders between them. 
 &bquo;All customers will be very thoroughly vetted,&equo; says marketing director Malcolm Hart. 
 &bquo;Even our most loyal customers will be limited to a single car each.&equo;  
 For the first time since 1952 Bentley has an all-new shape to itself with the massive Continental R coupe. 
 Performance is 10 per cent better than that of Turbo R 
 A revolution has taken place in the cockpit; the facia is modern with full-length console, and the seats are now heavily bolstered. 
 Transmission selector has moved from steering column to console 
 The budget the motorists want 
 Everyone has their idea of what Chancellor Norman Lamont should bring the motorist on Tuesday. 
 David Sutherland canvasses some alternative budgets 
 What news will Chancellor Norman Lamont have for the motorist when he rises in the House of Commons next Tuesday to deliver his budget speech? 
 With the country now in recession and the drop in new car sales accelerating quickly, Lamont has few options. 
 In the boom years of the mid '80s the motorist was, like the drinker and smoker, a convenient source of government revenue. 
 The car market was strong enough to absorb extra duties. 
 However, to further &bquo;soak&equo; the motorist and the company car driver would be risky. 
 The motor trade is still in a very precarious state, with many dealers just treading water and others going bust. 
 Any fiscal measures dampening demand for new cars will only increase unemployment in the motor trade. 
 Lamont may attempt to lay down an encouraging market for the industry. 
 With the Gulf war over and interest rates drifting down, he may feel that a further half per cent interest rate cut coinciding with the budget will put the motor industry and its customers in a more confident mood. 
 However, Lamont will almost certainly announce a further increase in tax liability on company cars. 
 Last year it was increased by 20 per cent across the three engine capacity bands &mdash; double the inflation rate. 
 For instance, after 1990's budget an employee earning &pound;17,500 per year and driving a Vauxhall Cavalier 2.0 faced tax of &pound;700, an &pound;87.50 increase. 
 The &pound;50,000-per-year managing director driving a Mercedes-Benz had to pay &pound;3320, an increase of &pound;500. 
 Analysts agree that Lamont has plenty of scope before he comes anywhere near equating tax on company cars with the true value of the benefit. 
 To buy and run the above mentioned Cavalier and Mercedes-Benz, the two drivers would have to earn an extra &pound;4900 and &pound;10,916 respectively (the calculations being based on cost-per-mile figures from industry analysts). 
 This year the Treasury rumour mill has been working overtime. 
 Some reports quoting &bquo;sources close to the Treasury&equo; speak of swinging increases in tax liability on company cars over two litres. 
 Other rumours even say that the Chancellor will impose higher purchase taxes or increased VAT on large cars, as is the case in some European countries. 
 But it is more likely that Treasury officials are just sounding out reaction to possible measures. 
 The Chancellor may decide to encourage greater use of diesel: however, he has only limited scope for any price differentiation between DERV and petrol, for since December diesel has actually been 10 pence per gallon more expensive than unleaded petrol. 
 It costs approximately &pound;1.95 per gallon, unleaded &pound;1.85. 
 All new cars throughout the EC will have to be fitted with catalysts by the end of 1992, so the Chancellor may feel he has room to make a political gesture and grant tax incentives on catalysed cars until that date. 
 Incentives already exist in Germany, the Netherlands, Belgium, Denmark and Greece. 
 These are the possibilities, but what measures should next Tuesday's budget contain? 
 To find out we asked a number of interested parties for their own budget proposals. 
 LABOUR PARTY 
 According to the opposition Treasury spokesman Chris Smith, MP for Islington South, big cars would come under heavy pressure from a Labour Chancellor. 
 He said: &bquo;We would want to discourage the needless use of big gas guzzlers. 
 We would consider a graded road tax system, probably with a two-litre threshold.&equo; 
 Smith conceded that higher taxes on big cars would have a harmful effect on the UK's motor industry, hurting Jaguar in particular, which is already suffering a severe fall in demand. 
 But he quoted a survey that reported that 51 per cent of all company cars were imported. 
 Labour would introduce green measures. 
 Smith said: &bquo;We would remove VAT form the price of a catalyst option, and would also reduce car tax by &pound;50 on catalysed cars.&equo; 
 Labour would continue to increase the tax liability on company cars ahead of the inflation rate. 
 INDUSTRY ANALYST 
 Garel Rhys, professor of motor industry economics at Cardiff University, believes the motor industry needs a boost, and suggests that car tax should be cut from approximately 10 per cent to 5 per cent. 
 Rhys considers it unwise to attempt radically to alter taxes on large cars, as proposed by Labour: &bquo;You can't just decimate the luxury car trade,&equo; he says, &bquo;Most big cars may well come from Germany but you have to consider how it would affect the dealer network.&equo; 
 However, Rhys firmly believes that some regulation on the use of large cars would be prudent through increased petrol duty. 
 He points out that petrol is now very cheap: if, in real terms, it were to be the equivalent price of a decade ago it would cost over &pound;4 a gallon. 
 And he supports the long-floated idea that road tax should be scrapped, with the equivalent revenue drawn from petrol duty. 
 THE MOTOR INDUSTRY 
 Car manufacturers are represented by the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, and not surprisingly the SMMT has observed sharply declining car sales with alarm. 
 It also points out that while the UK is enjoying something of an export boom the industry needs to stimulate home sales to allow for continued export investment. 
 The SMMT is also unhappy about the amount of motor tax paid by the motor industry and motorists. 
 It points out that in 1989 government revenue was &pound;18.1 billion, made up of &pound;2.9 billion from road tax, &pound;1.5 billion from car tax, &pound;5 billion from VAT and &pound;8.7 billion from fuel taxes. 
 During the same period the government gave the motorist just &pound;3.8 back in road building. 
 The SMMT calls for the total abolition of car tax, which it says would bring car prices into line with those in Europe. 
 It does not propose any significant environmental measures, but it does suggest a lower duty on diesel. 
 It also calls for a higher price threshold for company car tax. 
 Car dealers are bearing the brunt of the recession, and their representative body, the Retail Motor Industry Federation, calls for the abolition of car tax. 
 It points out that this was introduced as a &bquo;temporary measure&equo; in 1973. 
 But the RMIF wants car tax taken out over five years to prevent residuals being hit. 
 THE MOTORIST 
 Clearly drivers want motoring to be cheaper, but the largest motoring organisation, the Automobile Association, puts forward strong environmental proposals in its budget submission. 
 It advises the Chancellor to encourage environmentally cleaner cars rather than taxing cars more punitively to restrict their use. 
 It calls for the abolition of car tax on catalysed cars, and a 20 pence per gallon difference between leaded and unleaded fuel. 
 It wants a reduction in diesel fuel duty plus a lower level of road tax on diesel cars. 
 Despite the general belief among cost analysts that the tax on company cars currently does not equate to the benefit, the AA says there should be no further increase. 
 The AA also argues that company cars promote lower exhaust pollution levels. 
 ENVIRONMENTALISTS 
 Friends of the Earth proposes a dozen green taxes, three of which would directly affect the motorist, It calls for abolition of road tax, but for the price of petrol to be raised to what it was in real terms in 1975. 
 The extra revenue would then be spent on public transport. 
 All corporate tax relief on company cars would be phased out, and new cars sold without catalysts would attract higher taxes. 
 &bquo;It is scandalous that only a tiny fraction of cars in the UK have catalysts fitted. 
 Drivers of cars without should pay more,&equo; say FoE.  
 Chancellor Norman Lamont: likely to raise tax liability on company cars in the budget 
 Value of benefit of company cars still far exceeds tax 
 WIN ONE OF THE BEST OF 1991 
 THIS WEEK: A PEUGEOT 205XS WORTH &pound;9725 
 The Peugeot 205XS doesn't carry a &bquo;GT&equo; badge &mdash; but it deserves to. 
 The 1360cc 85bhp all-alloy engine is free-revving yet willing in the mid range and, combined with a close-spaced, slick-shifting five-speed gearbox, makes for a car that loves to be driven hard but which is equally at home trickling through town. 
 The 205's chassis has achieved almost legendary status. 
 On 165/70 SR13 Michelins, the 205XS has excellent grip nd handles in a very neutral fashion. 
 The steering is unassisted, but that's no hardship. 
 As with all 205s, the balance and steering response of the XS don't come at the expense of an uncompromising ride. 
 The suspension is quite firm but well-controlled and remains supple at lower speeds, too. 
 On the motorway there's no tyre roar and very little wind noise and, provided the revs aren't allowed to stray far beyond the 5000rpm mark, engine noise doesn't penetrate the cabin too much. 
 Maximum power is developed at a rather elevated 6400rpm and a steady 70mph sees the engine spinning at 4000rpm, right on the torque peak. 
 The result is that overtaking needs less gearchanging than you might imagine. 
 But despite overall overall gearing that's clearly designed with performance in mind, an overall fuel consumption of 32.6mpg shows that the 205XS is still impressively frugal. 
 Eight years after its launch, the 205 remains among the front-runners at the top of the small hatchback class. 
 Its timeless shape and impressive dynamics are reflected across the range and, as a value-for-money package that's still terrific fun to drive, the 205XS takes some beating. 
 Indeed, the little Peugeot has achieved something close to cult status, a point highlighted by the eye-catching TV commercial for the XS. 
 &bull; Like all new Peugeots, this 205XS comes with free membership of the AA and, subject to restrictions (see Rules &amp; Regulations) will be taxed and insured by the AA. 
 Membership means that you can call on the AA's swift and efficient service 24 hours a day, 365 days a year. 
 For peace of mind motoring, join the world's largest motoring organisation. 
 Phone free on 0800 919595 between 9am and 5pm any day of the week, call in at any AA shop or approach any of the AA sales team. 
 THE COMPETITION 
 Autocar &amp; Motor , Britain's best motoring magazine, is giving away a range of stunning Peugeots, taxed and with full AA membership, plus a VIP trip to watch 1982 world champion Keke Rosberg drive the fabulous new Peugeot 905 in the World Sportscar Championship at Silverstone on 19 May. 
 All you have to do is follow the simple steps in the &bquo;how to enter&equo; box. 
 Each week's competitions will be judged separately. 
 HOW TO ENTER 
 Hidden in the word square are the names of more than 30 makes or models of cars. 
 They may be vertical, horizontal, diagonal or even spelt backwards but all are in a straight line. 
 a) Circle all the words you can find in the word square, count them and fill in your total in the space on the form. 
 b) Complete the tie-breaker slogan. 
 c) Fill in your personal details. 
 d) Cut out the coupon on this page and attach to the correct space on the entry form. 
 e) You may enter for all five competitions but remember, you will need the coupon printed in each week's issue of Autocar &amp; Motor . 
 f) If you miss a copy, please send &pound;2.50 per issue to Haymarket Reprints, PO Box 200, Abingdon, Oxon. 
 OX14 3FG. 
 They will send the issue by return. 
 g) Send the entry form, including the marked-up word square, with the appropriate coupon attached to Autocar &amp; Motor , Win a Peugeot, 38&ndash;42 Hampton Road, Teddington, Middlesex. 
 TW11 0JE. 
 The closing date is 19 April, 1991. 
 RULES &amp; REGULATIONS 
 1 The competition is open to all residents of the UK over the age of 18 holding current UK full driving licences, other than employees (and their families) of Haymarket Magazines Ltd, Peugeot, the AA or their agents. 
 2 All entries must be received by 19 April, 1991. 
 Responsibility cannot be accepted for entries lost or damaged in the post or offered for delivery insufficiently stamped. 
 Damaged, defaced or illegible entries will be disqualified. 
 3 Each week's prizes will be awarded to those entrants who have found the greatest number of car words in the square. 
 In the case of a tie, the prize will be awarded to the person who, in the opinion of the judges, has completed the most apt and original tie-breaker. 
 4 All entries will be judged by a panel of judges appointed by Haymarket Motoring Publications Ltd. 5 The judges' decision will be final and no correspondence will be entered into. 
 But out of or in connection with the competition, the decision of Haymarket Motoring Publications Ltd will be legally binding. 
 6 Entries will become the property of Haymarket Motoring Publications Ltd. 7 It is a condition of entry that the rules of the competition are accepted as final and that competitors agree to be bound by the rules. 
 8 No entrant may win more than one prize. 
 9 No cash alternative will be offered. 
 10 All prize winners will be notified by post. 
 11 The winning solutions and the names and counties of the prize winners will be announced in the 8 May issue of Autocar &amp; Motor . 
 12 Entrants may submit as many entries as they wish, provided each entry is accompanied by the specified proof of purchase coupon. 
 13 AA insurance is fully comprehensive for one calendar up to a premium value of &pound;500. 
 Restrictions due to driving record, age or other reason may apply. 
 14 The prizes are defined as: Week 1 &mdash; Peugeot 205XS; Week 2 &mdash; Peugeot 309GTi; Week 3 &mdash; a VIP trip, to Silverstone; Week 4 &mdash; Peugeot 405SRi; Week 5 &mdash; Peugeot 605SV1  
 Cut out this coupon and affix to space on entry form 
 US G.P. 
 The champion comes out punching 
 Senna's rivals in will have to look much more convincing than they did in Phoenix if the Brazilian is to be kept from winning his third title, reports Maurice Hamilton 
 By the time they had reached the end of Jefferson Street for the first time, the US Grand Prix was all over. 
 Ayrton Senna was in the lead and that's where he would stay for the rest of the afternoon. 
 His McLaren-Honda, which had not turned a wheel until two days before, did not miss a beat. 
 You would have thought there might be a problem of some sort: just a small failure perhaps; something which would suggest that all was not well within the house of the world champions; something which would give the rest a smidgeon of hope for the remainder of the season. 
 Forget it. 
 This was as crushing a demonstration as we have seen from Senna and McLaren-Honda. 
 It was a brilliant display of this team's ability to cope with the difficulties imposed by introducing a new chassis and engine. 
 The only familiar elements were the driver and the team structure &mdash; and both performed faultlessly. 
 As usual. 
 There was talk before the start of the competition having become more intense; of the gap between McLaren and the rest having been reduced to the point where we might have a race on our hands. 
 That may turn out to be the case as the likes of Ferrari, Williams-Renault and Benetton-Ford get into their stride later in the season, but on the streets of Phoenix, Senna had no trouble in scoring his 27th win. 
 It brings him into joint second place with Jackie Stewart in the league table of grand prix victories, but there is still some way to go before Senna matches the 44 won by Alain Prost, the man the media love Senna to hate. 
 They started from the front row on Sunday, Senna having produced his usual stunning lap to take pole, Prost following through in the Ferrari with a lap notable for its customary smoothness and precision. 
 The local television station made much of the rivalry between these two, but, in the event, Prost never got close enough to even suggest the onset of further controversy. 
 By the end of the first lap, Senna led by 1.8secs. 
 By the end of lap five, the gap was 4.1secs. 
 During the practice, Prost had been impressed by both the McLaren and the Williams and his worst fears were confirmed as Senna pulled inexorably away and the multi-coloured Williams of Nigel Mansell began to move about in Prost's mirrors. 
 Mansell had started from the outside of the second row after a troubled two days with the new car. 
 During a slow lap on Friday, the first day of practice, Mansell had gone off line slightly and it was enough to have the Williams slide into a tyre barrier and snap off the right-hand suspension. 
 There were also problems with the semi-automatic gearbox and a broken constant-velocity joint, so much so that Mansell was eased into fourth place on the grid by a very impressive lap from his team mate. 
 Riccardo Patrese is the number two driver in the Williams team but, throughout the weekend, he drove with great aggression. 
 It was as though he had a point to prove. 
 On the first lap, the Italian veteran was edged into fifth place by Jean Alesi's Ferrari and, for the next 30 minutes, he had to work hard to win the place back. 
 He succeeded on lap 17 and immediately closed on Mansell who, in turn, was continuing to harass Prost. 
 This was something of bonus for the Williams since it had learned next to nothing during practice thanks to niggling problems associated with a new car. 
 On lap 21, it seemed it might have a niggling problem with its drivers as Patrese made a serious lunge down the inside and Mansell made an equally serious attempt to stop him. 
 Patrese left his braking too late and shot straight into the escape road, narrowly missing his team-mate as Mansell took avoiding action. 
 There was no hint of bitterness afterwards. 
 But it could be an interesting relationship as the season progresses. 
 Patrese, having dropped to sixth, hauled himself back into contention, passing Berger and Alesi (again) and was in second place as the pit stops began. 
 Clearly, the Williams-Renault was on the pace even though gearbox trouble would eventually account for both drivers, Patrese's departure being the more dramatic of the two. 
 The gearbox selected neutral as Patrese went through a quick left-hander, a problem which he could have coped with had the mechanism not decided to offer him, without warning, second gear half-way through. 
 The Williams locked its rear wheels, spun and stalled on the racing line &mdash; just out of the sight of those following. 
 Two cars managed to avoid him, but Roberto Moreno, holding a steady fourth in the Benetton, ran straight into the front of the Williams, doing serious damage to both. 
 The incident occurred on lap 50, by which time Mansell had already ground to a halt with no gears. 
 All of the Goodyear teams had chosen the softest race tyre available in the hope that the could run non-stop. 
 Prost, 27secs behind Senna, changed tyres on lap 45 and the news was quickly relayed to Senna. 
 Deciding that his lead was comfortable enough to make a precautionary stop, Senna came in at the end of lap 48. 
 Whereas Prost had been delayed as the Ferrari mechanics fiddled with the right-rear wheel, Senna's stop went like clockwork. 
 He was at a standstill for just 7.5secs and returned with his lead still intact. 
 All that stood in the way of victory was a touch of bad luck. 
 And, the way things had been going for Gerhard Berger, it was perhaps no surprise that it should be his McLaren which would suffer that fate. 
 Berger was seventh on the grid, this the result of being too cautious with one set of qualifying tyres and too forceful with the other. 
 At no point throughout the weekend did he seem at ease in the new car, his driving lacking the urgent but dramatically effective style seen in the past. 
 Stuck behind Patrese, Berger had to cope with high water temperatures and a loss of power until a fuel pump failure caused retirement on lap 37. 
 Berger watched the race for a while and it was tempting to speculate on his thoughts as the cars of his former employer, Ferrari, screamed by in second and third places, Alesi keeping a respectful distance behind his team leader. 
 On Friday, though, Alesi had been the top man as he claimed the overnight pole, but he lost any chance of keeping it with a wall-bashing incident, which came as no surprise to anyone who had watched his outrageously extrovert efforts. 
 Alesi's had been the first leading car to stop during the race and the merit in changing tyres became clear when he immediately set the fastest lap of the race. 
 As the race headed towards the final 10 laps, he was in second place, but under serious pressure from Piquet's Benetton and the fast-approaching Ferrari of his team-mate. 
 What happened next was tailor-made for the crafty Prost. 
 Powering onto the straight, Alesi lost control briefly. 
 Piquet, having to swing wide, then pulled alongside but Prost, without losing any momentum at all, passed them both. 
 It was the perfect opportunist move although, in the end, it would be made largely irrelevant by Alesi's retirement with a broken gearbox. 
 Prost's second place was never likely to be challenged as Piquet struggled to find grip form his Pirellis. 
 The tyre choice had been largely dictated by a very encouraging performance when Piquet ran with the car in race trim on Saturday. 
 It was hot then but on the race day it was cloudy and cool. 
 The drop in temperature made all the difference and the tyres chosen were too hard. 
 Indeed, at the end of 81 laps, they were scarcely worn at all. 
 Neither Tyrrell driver stopped and, while the brown paint scheme did little to flatter the Honda-powered cars, it was reliability that mattered most, Stefano Modena and Satoru Nakajima taking fourth and fifth places. 
 But perhaps the greatest personal satisfaction was earned by Gerard Larrousse as he watched Aguri Suzuki finish sixth in the Larrousse-Lola and poke a championship point in the eye of those who had recently stripped the French team of its hard-won rewards from last year. 
 Now, of course, with every race counting towards the championship, points earned on a Sunday afternoon matter like never before. 
 The race through the streets of Phoenix is not a useful guide to a car's potential on more conventional circuits, but the US Grand Prix did prove that McLaren and Honda have emerged from the winter stronger than ever. 
 Perhaps the rest will catch up in Brazil; perhaps the McLaren-Honda will be lacking on faster circuits. 
 But, regardless of the future, Senna already has 10 points under his belt. 
 And you had the impression he knew that would be the case as he raced down Jefferson Avenue for the first time.  
 Left: new Honda V12 performed faultlessly for Senna to score easy victory. 
 Right, from the top: Benetton chose wrong Pirelli tyres but Piquet drove steadily for third place. 
 Andrea de Cesaris reads the bad news, he failed to pre-qualify the new Jordan. 
 Second on the grid, second in the race, but Prost and the Ferrari were no match for Senna. 
 Patrese out-qualified team-leader Mansell and drove a storming race until gearbox failure caused a retirement crash 
 Mansell's return to Williams ended with gearbox failure before half the distance (above left). 
 Betrand Gachot brought the new Jordan to 10th place (left). 
 Tyrrell-Hondas were reliable, Modena took fourth (right) 
 Encouraging start for the new combinations 
 The new  recuruits  &mdash; and there are many this season &mdash; handled themselves with distinction in such difficult surroundings. 
 Not only did Nicola Larini manage to bring the new Modena-Lamborghini through pre-qualifying and then into the race, he gave the new team more than it had thought possible by finishing seventh, albeit three laps behind. 
 There were impressive performances from the Judd-powered Dallaras until Emanuele Pirro and JJ Lehto retired with gearbox and clutch problems respectively. 
 Martin Brundle put the Brabham-Yamaha into 12th place on the grid &mdash; despite not having the benefit of special fuel for qualifying and a rev limit of 12,000rpm as opposed to the 13,000rpm-plus enjoyed by other V12 users. 
 The new combination was running at the finish after a lengthy stop for repairs to damaged rear suspension. 
 Mika Hakkinen did a superb job for the under-financed Lotus team, the young Finn impressing everyone with his mature and confident approach after stepping up from Formula 3. 
 The Ilmor engines ran faultlessly (any problems were associated with ancillary failures) despite the Leyton House team having a weekend made difficult by and act of sabotage on Friday evening and damage to one car when Mauricio Gugelmin hit the wall during practice. 
 And the Jordan team, despite the initial disappointment of losing Andrea de Cesaris when the Italian missed a gear and caused an engine failure during pre-qualifying, showed its capacity to be part of Formula 1. 
 Bertrand Gachot had not raced for over a year, but his relative inexperience did not show as he began to attack Suzuki's Lola in the race's later stages. 
 Gachot then spun after running over some debris from the Patrese/Moreno incident and the subsequent tyre stop cost him time. 
 He was eventually classified tenth even though engine failure to the Ford HB V8 had brought his race to a halt six laps from the end. 
 The old order may not have changed at the front but there are encouraging signs for the future further down the field.  
 Larini impressed for Lambourghini 
 SPORT 
 GRAND PRIX DISPATCHES 
 PHOENIX 
 Maurice Hamilton 
 &bull; Williams was due to carry out urgent tests in England in a bid to trace and cure the gearbox problems evident in Phoenix. 
 &bull; The Phoenix city authority has announced it may relinquish financial involvement in the grand prix next year and seek an independent promoter. 
 Bernie Ecclestone, however, feels guardedly optimistic, &bquo;It always takes a long time to get an F1 race up and running in the US,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We have an option to stage races here in 1992 and '93 and I am hopeful we will be able to continue in both these years.&equo; 
 &bull; Long Beach Grand Prix founder Chris Pook arrived in Phoenix to show off elaborate plans for a purpose-built, multi-disciplinary stadium which is scheduled to be built near Dallas next year. 
 FISA has been invited to design its F1 circuit within the complex and it is Pook's belief that it will provide a permanent home &bquo;for one of the grands prix in the US&equo;. 
 &bull; The mayor of Phoenix said he was encouraged by the positive response to the grand prix from the city. 
 He judged the size of the crowd at about 35,000 &mdash; small by standards elsewhere but an improvement over attendance figures for the past two years. 
 &bull; Phil Hill was honoured by the race organisers to mark the world title the American diver won 30 years ago. 
 &bull; A new signal at the start of the race told drivers that the red light would come on in five seconds. 
 The intention was to assist drivers on the front few rows, who can spend up to 90 seconds waiting for the rest of the grid to form. 
 '91 Silver Arrow heralds Merc F1 
 Mercedes last week announced the car with which it will defend its world sportscar crown and begin preparations for an F1 assault. 
 An insider said last week: &bquo;If the new flat-12 3.5-litre engine in the car will run reliably at 17,000rpm, then we'll go ahead and build a V12 version for F1.&equo; 
 Our source indicated that Niki Lauda, F1 world champion in 1975, 1977 and 1984, will be appointed to manage the F1 team and that the car will run without sponsors. 
 The new Group C car, the C291, carries nothing over from last year's dominant C11 and packs an all-new 3.5-litre flat 12 to comply with new regulations governing the renamed World Sportscar Championship. 
 Again the work of Peter Sauber, the C291 is built entirely from synthetics. 
 It features radiators mounted on the side, not the nose, of the car and this, in conjunction with the flat 12, allows a massive ground effect venturi section. 
 The new purpose-built engine and gearbox features a central power take-off and the flat 12 is of a monobloc design. 
 The gearbox is operated via a push-pull selector which does away with a conventional gate. 
 Mercedes also announced that Briton Jonathan Palmer would join the team's extra drivers at Le Mans in June. 
 The series starts on 14 April.  
 Silver Arrow (left) is all new for 1991. 
 A 3.5-litre flat 12 provides the power 
 Prost hits out at FISA disciplinary rules 
 Alain Prost has expressed considerable concern that FISA's strict new rules on driver discipline might result in ostensibly innocent racing manoeuvres attracting draconian penalties during the 1991 world championship season. 
 &bquo;Although there are several people sitting on the FISA Commission whom I like and respect, none of them has ever done any serious motor racing,&equo; he warned. 
 &bquo;As a driver who is generally considered as being more level-headed than most, I want to know whether there is any danger of me being banned for two months if I have an accident here at Phoenix. 
 Consequently, I am quite concerned about this Commission.&equo; 
 Gerhard Berger echoed this concern, pointing out that FISA would have to be very careful in its application of the new driver discipline regulations to avoid creating boring races. 
 &bquo;If a driver knows that any attempt to overtake the car ahead of him will risk a fine or disqualification, then he will not try,&equo; the Austrian said. 
 &bquo;With normally aspirated engines, sometimes the difference in power output between competing cars is only around five brake horsepower. 
 That makes passing very difficult.&equo; 
 Berger also recalled last year's Mexico Grand Prix, in which he and Nigel Mansell became embroiled in a tremendous battle during the closing stages of the race. 
 &bquo;We touched wheels and nearly went off the road,&equo; he grinned. 
 &bquo;And afterwards, Jean-Marie Balestre came over to congratulate me on a fantastic race. 
 &bquo;But now I am concerned that he might have a different response this year!&equo;  
 Prost (right) is worried that he could be penalised for being involved in ostensibly innocent race clashes 
 &bquo;Pirate&equo; Indy car race prompts FISA threat 
 Goodyear was among a group of major companies threatened with worldwide suspension from motor sport by FISA president Jean-Marie Balestre as a penalty for supporting next Sunday's &bquo;pirate&equo; Indycar race at Surfers Paradise in Australia. 
 At a press conference in Phoenix, Balestre initially hinted at a conciliatory line in the dispute between CART and FISA, but then came out with the stern suspension threat, which also encompassed Indycar engine makers Cosworth and Ilmor. 
 Paddock opinion agreed that it was ludicrous to imagine that Goodyear would be banned from international racing, a move that would destroy F1 at a stroke. 
 Mercifully, Balestre subsequently retracted the ban on Goodyear, but emphasized that Cosworth and Ilmor would face serious sanctions. 
 Ilmor's Mario Ilien responded to the apparent inconsistency of these threats by pointing out that Fiat did not appear to be included in the ban &mdash; even though it has an official Alfa Romeo CART team, operated by Patrick Racing, competing in the Surfers event. 
 Mario and Michael Andretti were passing through Phoenix en route to the Australian event, confident that the drivers would not be debarred from applying for FISA international licences. 
 &bquo;I will not be applying for a FISA licence until after the Surfers race,&equo; said Mario, &bquo;and I don't  forsee  any problems. 
 Drivers are professionals who are employed to race where their teams compete and I don't think they would be penalised for doing their jobs.&equo;  
 Indycar teams and suppliers are still taking part in next weekend's &bquo;pirate&equo; race in Australia, despite FISA's threat to ban them from all international motorsport 
 Sainz easy winner in Portugal 
 Carlos Sainz's victory for Toyota on the Rally of Portugal last week gives him a 13-point lead in the world championship. 
 His main opposition came from Lancia's Didier Auriol and Miki Biasion, who finished second and third. 
 The anticipated challenge from Ford's Sierra Cosworths ended when all three drivers made mistakes on the first sodden day, leaving Subaru and Mazda to fill out the top placings. 
 Full report next week.  
 Sainz: still dominant 
 Senna buries the hatchet 
 Ayrton Senna struck a cautiously conciliatory note in Phoenix last Thursday on the eve of first practice for the opening F1 race of the year. 
 Many regarded his words as perhaps signalling that his feud with Alain Prost &mdash; fuelled to boiling point after their collision at Suzuka last October &mdash; may be cooling slightly. 
 &bquo;He is one of the best,&equo; stated the Brazilian unequivocally. 
 &bquo;His record speaks for itself. 
 But apart from our passion for the sport, we share nothing on a personal level. 
 We come from different backgrounds, from the point of view of our upbringing and our education, and approach our racing in different ways.&equo; 
 Perhaps predictably, Senna was not in full support of the new point-scoring system, in which all 16 races count towards the title. 
 In 1988, the Brazilian won his first title when the &bquo;11 out of 16&equo; rule applied, despite Prost having a higher gross total. 
 &bquo;I don't think it is the right system,&equo; he insisted. 
 &bquo;Eleven races might not be the optimum number, but a compromise between the two would probably produce a better system. 
 With 16 races counting, a chance engine failure or a stone through the radiator could decide the outcome of the championship. 
 The system should allow for some unexpected failures, which are out of the drivers' control, to occur.&equo;  
 Senna: conciliatory tone 
 IN BRIEF 
 Toyota has begun testing  its normally aspirated V10 WSC engine. 
 The engine ran in Japan last month in a development chassis based on last year's turbocar. 
 The definitive chassis, designed by Englishman Tony Southgate, is expected to make its debut in the last two WSC races this year. 
 Vern Schuppan , not content with building 50 road-going Porsche 962s, will run two rebodied, all-synthetic 962s at Le Mans this year with chassis lifted directly from the road car. 
 West Surrey Racing , Britain's most successful F3 team, has announced it will run Ralt chassis for its new drivers &mdash; Jordi Gene, Rubens Barrichello and Pedro Diniz &mdash; in this year's British F3 championship. 
 Previous WSR drivers include Jonathan Palmer and Ayrton Senna. 
 The Safari Rally  will feature eight A-seeded drivers. 
 Backing up world champion Carlos Sainz in the Toyota team will be Bjorn Waldegard and Mikael Ericsson, while Lancia will have Juha Kankkunen, Jorge Recalde and Miki Biasion. 
 Most interest will centre on the performance of the  Nisan  Sunnys driven by Stig Blomqvist and David Llewellin. 
 Tom Sneva, a former winner  of the Indianapolis 500 but out of a drive in CART racing this year, entered the Formula 3 support race at Phoenix. 
 The American was forced to withdraw because of engine failure. 
 Julian Bailey, despite failing to qualify  his Lotus 102B at Phoenix, is understood to be prepared to commit himself to Lotus for the entire season &mdash; if Martin Donnelly isn't fit enough to race &mdash; backed by a personal investment of up to &pound;75,000, earned during two years with the Group C Nissan team. 
 &bquo;I'm not yet 30 and I've still got plenty of time to earn more money,&equo; he shrugged. 
 &bquo;But I would hate to get to 40 and look back, thinking: &bquo;I wish I'd given it my best shot&equo;.&equo; 
 ARRIVALS 
 Volvo Turbo: now less taxing 
 A simple turbocharging job turns the lethargic twin-litre 940 SE into a spirited performer designed to stay the right side of the company car tax. 
 By John Simister 
 Volvo's turbocharged big saloon has always been a bit of a maverick. 
 Square-cut and staid to behold, it packs a potent punch quite at odds with its looks. 
 Today's 940 Turbo fits that description as comfortably as the old 740 Turbo did. 
 Now, however, there are not one but two turbocharged 940s. 
 The existing 2.3-litre, 165bhp, all-bells-and-whistles 940 Turbo is joined by a new, turbo-boosted version of the two-litre 940 SE. 
 This latest derivative is a cheaper and tamer Turbo, true, but as it comes under the two vital company car tax breaks points (2000cc and &pound;19,250), its role is clear. 
 Making a 940 SE into a 940 SE Turbo couldn't be simpler. 
 The engine itself is unchanged internally, even to the extent of keeping the normally aspirated version's highish compression ratio. 
 The rest of the car is regular SE too, apart from the four-speed plus overdrive gearbox, borrowed from the 2.3-litre car, in place of the standard SE's five-speed item, which can't cope with the turbo's muscle. 
 So all that's involved is bolting a turbocharger, sourced from either Garrett AiResearch or Volvo's Japanese affiliate, Mitsubishi, to a redesigned exhaust manifold and adding new intake plumbing, including a large intercooler. 
 The turbocharger is water cooled and its vanes are small to keep inertia down. 
 This helps it to spin up to speed quickly, which reduces turbo lag and improves that all-important mid-range response, although at the expense of outright potency. 
 But then terrific top-end power and tarmac-scorching standing starts were not on the design team's agenda. 
 Flying in the face of today's ubiquitous  electronickery , the turbocharger uses nothing more than a simple spring-loaded wastegate to regulate boost, which is never allowed to build too high in deference to the engine's life expectancy. 
 Should the wastegate jam shut, the Bosch LH-Jetronic fuel injection senses an excess of intake air for the engine speed and throttle opening and cuts the fuel supply. 
 Outputs rise from the standard SE's lacklustre 111bhp and 117lb ft of torque to a much healthier 155bhp at 5500rpm and 169lb ft of torque at 3600rpm. 
 You pay &pound;870 for the extra muscle, taking the SE's price from &pound;17,475 to &pound;18,345 (or from &pound;18575 to &pound;19,245 for the estate). 
 This seems a very fair deal, for the transformation is pretty dramatic. 
 Volvo's two-litre B200 engine had always been smoother than the bigger-bore 2.3, but it made no more than an adequate job of hauling the corpulent 940. 
 The turbo engine's pull is no better at very low revs, but once the boost gauge's needle awakens, the 940 surges forward very satisfactorily. 
 It's a good, plumb torque curve, which makes for easy overtaking and fewer gearchanges. 
 Naturally, outright performance is also much improved. 
 To reach 62mph from standstill needs 9.6secs instead of 12, while the maximum speed climbs from 112mph to 126mph. 
 These figures &mdash; achieved with a standard fit catalyst, remember &mdash; make the Volvo one of the quickest cars in its class. 
 But all is not perfect. 
 There's an irritating &bquo;zizz&equo; from the engine when revved vigorously, and the overdrive gearbox shifts less sweetly than the five-speeder. 
 The overdrive is a bit anachronistic, too, and calls for deft clutchwork if you are to avoid a jerk and a thump. 
 Is Volvo the last car maker to use an add-on overdrive? 
 It's hard to think of another. 
 Anachronisms abound elsewhere, too. 
 Take the live rear axle: it betrays its presence when pulling away from test, when the driveline vibrates gently, and over uneven secondary roads, when the high unsprung weight makes the ride restless. 
 Still, the handling is quite fun in a predictable, laid-back, rear-wheel-drive way. 
 You'd never call the 940 incisive; it's not a car to be rushed into a direction change. 
 But it's unerringly steady when you're pressing on, and lurches slightly less ponderously into a tight bend than does its more sophisticated (and independently sprung) 960 24v sister. 
 It takes a slippery road to make the Volvo wag its tail; over-exuberance with the throttle otherwise does nothing more than make the inside rear wheel spin the power away. 
 The transformations that made the 740 into the 940 &mdash; a more rounded rump with a bigger boot, a more modern, 960-like facia, bigger brakes and more front headroom &mdash; are all worthwhile, and the 940 SE Turbo is solid, well built, generously equipped and decently rapid. 
 No doubt it will suit company car users down to the ground. 
 But this does not disguise its dated feel in a world of more advanced and dynamic designs.  
 Interior is unchanged from standard 940 SE, as is dash save for the giveaway turbo boost gauge. 
 Styling is less square cut than predecessor's but still pretty ponderous compared with others in the class. 
 Big Volvo is well made and the finish is good 
 Paseo flatters to deceive 
 Toyota's Paseo coupe is cute and excellent value for money, but it lacks sparkle. 
 Peter Nunn tries it in Japan 
 If looks could kill, the Toyota Paseo would pass as a deadly weapon. 
 This has to be one of the slickest cars Japan has yet made. 
 The sporty 1.5-litre twin-cam coupe, known on the home market as the Cynos, is gunning straight for the Honda CRX and Nissan NX coupe &mdash; but not in the UK, because exports to this country aren't planned. 
 Overlook the oddball Cynos badge on the back (Cynos is derived from cynosure, or centre of attention) and the cute rear-drive Toyota coupe has plenty going for it. 
 It's snug, sexy and exceptional value for money at a basic Y1.07 million to Y1.331 million. 
 On the road, though, it'll come to a lot more than that. 
 But it's still able to undercut the CRX by a useful margin. 
 While the price is a strong ace on the Paseo pack, most people will already be sold on its looks. 
 Some recent Toyotas have had strong US design input, but not the Paseo. 
 Even though California will be one of its major markets, everything was done in Japan. 
 Based on the 93.7ins platform of the new three-door Tercel, the Paseo is roughly the same size as the CRX, but more practical. 
 It is a genuine two-plus-two, with a set of rear seats you can actually use. 
 The Paseo also has a conventional, if shallow, boot. 
 With a length of 163.2ins, width of 64.8ins and height of 50.9ins, interior space is inevitably snug. 
 But there's plenty of seat adjustment and the driving position is faultless. 
 However, the shallow roofline means no sunroof, much less the targa roof of an MR2. 
 Interior presentation, as well as general fit and finish, is as good as you would expect from Toyota. 
 The dash, in particular, is very well done, with clear gauges and logical controls. 
 What you don't expect is the level of NVH from the drivetrain and suspension. 
 It isn't serious enough to spoil your enjoyment of the car but is hard to understand from a company that spent millions developing the Lexus, the car that banished noise, vibration and harshness. 
 As you drive, this NVH manifests itself in the form of tiny vibrations fed back through the steering wheel and the gruff, uninspiring sounds from the SE-FHE engine. 
 The Paseo simply isn't as refined as it should be, although some elements of the equation, such as the smooth, light manual shift and positive clutch, are as good as you'll find anywhere and make it a doddle to drive. 
 When it comes to the expected sporty performance and handling, the Paseo again falls short of the mark. 
 Its 115bhp 1496cc engine, first seen in the Sera, is responsive to the throttle but otherwise shows little sparkle. 
 It revs to the 7400rpm red line, but the driver is usually forced to change up a good 2500rpm before then because it's all starting to get noisy. 
 While flexibility is impressive enough, an estimated 0&ndash;60mph time of 9secs makes the Paseo only modestly quick. 
 The suspension settings are stiffer than they are on the Tercel, and with the option of Toyota's TEMS electronic damping the spec sounds good. 
 But once more the Paseo flatters to deceive. 
 The chassis seems to be set up more for stability than agility. 
 So while the Paseo feel safe and secure through corners, you long for the poise and quick reflexes of a CRX. 
 Better news is that torque steer is almost non-existent and the level of grip from the (optional) 185/60 R14 82H Bridgestone Potenzas is high. 
 Understeer and roll are well contained, but for the enthusiast driver the Paseo's dull turn-in and bland steering are disappointing. 
 A car of mixed abilities, the Paseo combines head-turning looks with a bargain price. 
 While those are powerful arguments, more speed, extra refinement and sharper handling would put it right on the pace.  
 Rear-drive Paseo's looks are its best feature. 
 Interior is snug but seats four at a pinch. 
 Twin-cam lacks sparkle and refinement 
 DIARY 
 Eoin Young 
 &bquo;I told him about his man Modena at 40&ndash;1. 
 Suddenly he had time to chat&equo; 
 The tipsters and sporting gentlemen who frequent the stables and have the inside running from the horse's mouth as well as from the trainers and jockeys suggest that if you are seeking a handsome return on an investment you should sell your house and put the money on Alain Prost to win the world championship this year. 
 The smart-money crowd is saying that the revised scoring &mdash; with every race counting for title points &mdash; is tailor-made for this French Ferrari driver, who now has a more-than-willing helper in Jean Alesi to look after the business of returning the Ferrari compliment to Senna and allowing Prost to go about his business unencumbered by Brazilians wishing to use his piece of road. 
 Bookmakers Ladbrokes are catching up with the odds on races on four wheels instead of four legs and offering odds on Senna (11&ndash;8) and Prost (7&ndash;4) for the world championship during the week the cars were being loaded for the opening grand prix in Phoenix. 
 Alesi and Mansell were 8&ndash;1, Berger 9&ndash;1, Piquet 14, Patrese 20, Moreno 25, Modena 40, Boutsen 50, Comas and Gachot 66 and Capelli and Gugelmin 80&ndash;1. 
 Which may not rank the outsiders in the eyes of the Ladbrokes odds-maker, but if they look over the fence they will certainly be able to see the outsiders from where they have been placed. 
 Since I had collected a handsome pay-out from Ladbrokes a year earlier with money on Alesi I thought it only fair to 'phone Ken Tyrrell and tell him the odds. 
 He said he was very busy. 
 Then I told him about his man Modena at 40&ndash;1. 
 Suddenly he had time to chat. 
 Minutes later he 'phoned back and asked how to place a bet because he'd never done it before. 
 The Mastermind television quiz game turned its attention to Formula 1 motor racing when Michael Swartz took it as his specialised subject recently. 
 As the Young family regularly pits its wits against the Mastermind contenders with spectacular lack of success most Sundays, I was expected to do better than usual. 
 I flunked the first question: &bquo;On which circuit was the first Formula 1 world championship event held?&equo; 
 I just knew it would be a trick question to start the contest and was desperately groping for a trick answer when Swartz said &bquo;Silverstone&equo; and scored his opening point. 
 I am ashamed to admit that I scored 11 and Martin Swartz scored 17. 
 Perhaps he'd like a week penning this column. 
 In 1950 the Alfa Romeo team drivers were known as &bquo;The Three Fs&equo; &mdash; Fangio, Farina and who was the third? 
 Fagioli. 
 Who was the official winner of the 1976 British Grand Prix after James Hunt was disqualified? 
 Lauda. 
 Three teams in 1969 raced four-wheel drive &mdash; Lotus, Tyrrell-Matra and who was the third? 
 I said McLaren and Swartz said Cosworth which was close but wrong. 
 In 1961, which driver won the first grand prix he entered? 
 Obviously another trick question and I was still fumbling with words when Swartz said &bquo;Baghetti&equo;. 
 No wonder he did better than me. 
 I was in the hotel room next door to Baghetti at Rheims that year and yet I couldn't find his name to score a point in a quiz 30 years later! 
 At Martin Brundle's lunch in London I discovered that Maurice Hamilton had been the Mastermind question-setter and he reported that if I thought answering them was hard, he had found setting them a good deal harder. 
 He wasn't allowed to use one question because the quizmasters said it was impossible to prove the exactness of the answer. 
 I can't see what all the fuss was about. 
 There were three world champions with brothers who raced on Formula 1 &mdash; Emerson Fittipaldi, Jody Scheckter and which other champion? 
 Give up? 
 Thought you would. 
 The answer is Jackie Stewart, whose elder brother Jimmy drove a Cooper-Bristol in the 1953 British Grand Prix. 
 He was the youngest driver in the field, qualified on the fifth row and was up to sixth place with 10 laps to go as leading British driver in a British car when he crashed at Copse, escaping unhurt. 
 Martin Brundle speaks with the disarming honesty of an F1 driver who is buying lunch in a private room at Au Jardin des Gourmets for a dozen pressmen on the day the Gulf war ended and a week before the F1 season started. 
 The impression I have is that once the Brabham-taming begins he won't have time to speak to us again, never mind buy lunches. 
 &bquo;The car looks fantastic,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;But then they all say that at this time of year, don't they?&equo; 
 Brundle enthuses over the potential of the Yamaha engine and the Japanese connection as a whole. 
 &bquo;It looks as though Japan is where we're going to get our chances from.&equo; 
 he says, using the royal &bquo;we&equo; to encompass the British drivers and teams. 
 &bquo;We're never going to get financial help in Britain.&equo; 
 The Yamaha is good but not wonderful at present. 
 Great torque, good mid-range power, but needs more at the top end. 
 Yamaha should take solace from the thought that Senna was bitching about the power of the new V12 Honda, later saying he had been misquoted and that there was &bquo;nothing fundamentally wrong&equo; with the new Honda. 
 To echo Brundle: &bquo;But they all say that at this time of year, don't they?&equo; 
 What Brundle does do well is enthuse, but then I suppose that's his car salesman training back home. 
 He says they have a few pounds to trim off the engine but that will be achieved by Imola. 
 And he is personally trim and fit. 
 &bquo;Last time I was this fit I was captaining the under-16s at King's Lynn Grammar School.&equo;  
 Ken Tyrrell &mdash; anxiously awaiting a call from his bookmaker? 
 YOUR VIEW 
 PRICE IS RIGHT IN US 
 Your article on underpriced US cars (&bquo;Underpriced and over there&equo;, 13 February) fails to mention the considerable difference in prices for Japanese cars UK and US supplied. 
 If one compares the prices, less UK taxes and US state and federal taxes, the picture becomes much clearer. 
 For example: Nissan 300ZX Turbo &pound;27,600 (UK), &pound;17,590 (US); Toyota MR2 &pound;11,900 (I+UK), &pound;7570 (US); Mazda MX-5 &pound;11,920 (UK), &pound;7585 (US); Honda NSX &pound;41,600 (UK), &pound;32,500 (US). 
 If one shops around, sizeable discounts are available on the above list prices. 
 I was offered a 300ZX Turbo for &pound;16,250 and an MR2 for &pound;6600. 
 I eventually bought an MX-5 with hard-top, limited slip diff, air conditioning and option package A for &pound;8000, some &pound;6000 less than a tax-free UK-supplied car of the same specification. 
 I was offered immediate delivery on a Corvette ZR-1 for &pound;30,500 (manufacturer's list price). 
 In fact, the only cars now attracting a dealer premium are the NSX and Mitsubishi 3000 GT VR-4 and I don't expect that will last. 
 It really is a buyer's market at the moment. 
 It cost me &pound;300 for insurance and shipping my MX-5 to Amsterdam on a roll-on ferry out of Brunswick, Georgia. 
 No doubt the Japanese can justify their prices, but as much as I like their sports cars, I would never consider buying any of their cars in the UK. 
  Capt R Rackham Amsterdam Holland  
 CATALYSTS FOR F1 
 I read with interest the article &bquo;F1 changes change nothing&equo; (13 February) in which Harvey Postlethwaite puts forward the idea of knocking 50bhp off the output of Formula 1 engines to keep races competitive. 
 Pump petrol is also said not to be favoured by oil companies; instead, they prefer toxic additives to exotic petrochemical cocktails to give their teams power while keeping inside the 101 RON limits. 
 Rather than make changes to aerodynamic efficiency to reduce speeds, why not go the whole hog and kill two birds with one stone? 
 The format of German touring car racing calls for all cars to run with catalytic converters. 
 There are pre- and post-race emission checks to see that all is well with the systems fitted. 
 If the format was adopted by F1, with the addition of &bquo;pump petrol&equo;, engine outputs would be reduced due to exhaust back pressure and lower RON rating &mdash; say 98 RON super unleaded. 
 This would slow F1 &mdash; at least to begin with &mdash; and show the Green movement that F1 is not as anti-environmental as it claims. 
 These changes would have another effect, too. 
 Catalytic converter technology would be forced to advance at a much improved rate, showing that F1 does indeed improve motoring in general. 
 It would undoubtedly cost a lot on money to implement in the short run, as would some of the more conventional changes proposed by that Frenchman who claims to run the sport with an impartial hand. 
 I would be most interested in what readers and teams think of these ideas for a progressive solution to a vexing problem. 
  Adrian Knight Peterborough Cambs  
 FRENCH FANCY 
 Mr Seewonauth (&bquo;Your view&equo;, 20 February) criticised PSA boss Jacques Calvet for his warnings about the future of the European car industry. 
 Having owned three Citroens and a Renault, I am greatly impressed with the quality of French cars. 
 Unfortunately, though, Japanese marketing has driven these companies out of the US market. 
 The Japanese produce bland, artless copies of European products, totally without character: they have never given us a car like a Citroen. 
 Quality? 
 The Orientals are masters of the art of the illusion of quality, nice fit and finish of trim, while employing cost-cutting techniques deep inside the car where they are not readily apparent. 
 Europeans should heed Mr Calvet's warnings if it is not already too late. 
 When the Orientals have a UK market share that justifies their building factories on your soil, you will gradually see their way of life coming into your homes. 
 It has happened here in the US. 
 And finally, when some day Mr Seewonauth sees a new MG roadster which is a decapitated Honda Civic, will he finally realise that something wonderful has been lost for ever? 
  P Michael Riffert Lititz Pennsylvania United States  
 KNOW YOUR WHINE 
 On your long-term test of the Citroen XM 24v (27 February), David Vivian comments on a &bquo;curious high-pitched whine&equo; instead of the usual starting noises. 
 My Fiat Panda has a similar ignition fault which I have diagnosed to be a disengaged starter motor. 
 I would have thought someone of Mr Vivian's experience would have thought of this. 
  A S N Warwick Liverpool  
 I am fully aware of what a disengaged starter motor sounds like, Mr Warwick. 
 This whine was higher pitched and considerably more curious &mdash; David Vivian 
 FRENCH DEFEAT 
 In your road test of the Peugeot 605 SRdt (20 February) you comment that the only car to give it a run for its money is the Citroen XM. 
 This is strangely at variance with your own published figures: Peugeot 605 SRdt 33.3mpg overall, 0&ndash;60mph in 12.8secs, top speed 114mph; Citroen 2.0SD 32mpg, 12.4secs and 116mph; Rover 825D 36.2mpg, 11.7secs, 116mph. 
 Assuming that the only rational purpose of buying a diesel rather than a petrol-engined car is to save fuel, the Rover walks all over both Frenchmen! 
  John Irving Knowle Warwickshire  
 CALIBRA CHALLENGE 
 With reference to your test extra on the Vauxhall Calibra 4x4 (20 February), you omit to mention its most prestigious rival, the Mitsubishi Galant 4x4. 
 As a Mitsubishi dealer, I'd remind you that this car won the 1989 Lombard RAC Rally and came a close second last year. 
 Also available in coupe form, it offers four doors, superior equipment levels and a substantially lower price. 
 &bquo;No rival four-wheel-drive coupe can offer more passenger comfort&equo; &mdash; the Galant offers more rear legroom and  headroom, with the added advantage of own-door access. 
 Nice try, but no comment. 
  Bruce Robinson Norjac Lancs  
 V8 FOR NEW 800? 
 Concerning fitting an eight-cylinder engine to the new Rover 800, would it be technically feasible to use two K-series blocks side by side? 
 Together they would from a longitudinal engine. 
 Would such an engine fit in the new car's engine bay? 
 Would there be power loss problems? 
 I got the idea, of course, from the BMW and Mercedes V12 engines. 
  B S Chima Sunderland  
 Rover has never denied the K-series could be &bquo;modulised&equo;, and there is a long-standing plan to build a K6 engine based on two of the aborted three-cylinder Ks. 
 However, a V8 would be too much for the Rover 800's front-drive chassis &mdash; news ed 
 NO SMOKE WITHOUT FIRE 
 I would be in favour of making it illegal to smoke while driving. 
 It is amazing how often one sees a smoker tugging at his or her steering wheel with one hand while the other seeks to introduce the lighted item to those waiting lips. 
 And then there are all those empty packets discarded out of the window onto Britain's already polluted streets. 
 These people are a danger to themselves and others, are a downright public nuisance and their habits (when conducted in the course of driving) should be legislated against. 
  T J Ingram Aberdeen  
 OVEN-READY KIT CAR 
 &bquo;Whodunnit?&equo; you ask on page 38 of the 20 February issue. 
 Well, I think it's pretty obvious. 
 You forgot to cover up the Anglia Television badge on the front end! 
 That's the giveaway. 
 Lotus, being in the Anglia region, has found a new sponsor and has been able, at last, to bring out its long-awaited cheap saloon &mdash; the Flan. 
 The idea of previewing it at Sainsbury's was an an excellent PR ploy as this is certainly its new &bquo;oven-ready kit car&equo; obtainable in a small, easy-to-carry pack from the freezer department. 
 Two minutes in the microwave and you have a full size saloon car ready to drive away. 
 I think the one you show may have risen a bit too much&hellip; 
  Jeff Rix Hitchin Herts  
 ELEMENTARY 
 What's the big mystery? 
 I'd even say it looks like a Mazda, notwithstanding Rover 214 wheel covers. 
 Anyway, the number plate gives the game away. 
 KM is a Kent registration number and all recent Mazda demonstrators have borne the letters AKM as the concessionaires are based in Tunbridge Wells. 
  I Merrick East Grinstead Sussex  
 CALLING ALL JAGUARS 
 I would like to ask your readers for help. 
 I am looking for photographs, from 1926 to the present day, of ladies or family groups in period dress together with cars, if possible Jaguar cars. 
 The photographs are required to form part of a static fashion show that will include a 10-set period dress display, comprising both photographs and mannequins. 
 The show forms part of our Jaguar Spectacular '91 on 12 May. 
 Both photographs and negatives should be supplied for enlargement purposes. 
 All will be returned to the senders after use. 
 Thank you in anticipation. 
  Philip Livings Chatham Grammar School for Boys Holcombe Maidstone Road Chatham Kent ME4 6JB  
 PATENTLY OBVIOUS 
 I must respectfully correct Peter Robinson's Heroes article (27 February). 
 Karl Benz was granted patent number 37435 on 29 January 1886, and not 1888 as was stated. 
 I'm sure this was a typing error but it did confuse an excellent article. 
  Roger H King President The Mercedes-Benz Club  
 WHAT'S THE 159 CLUB? 
 Can any of your more senior readers help me? 
 I have a car badge belonging to the 159 Motor Club but do not know what the club is, or was, and have been unable to find out. 
 The badge looks to be from the '50s. 
 Any ideas, please? 
  Peter Johnson London N1  
 Write to:  Autocar &amp; Motor Readers' Letters, 38&ndash;42 Hampton Road, Teddington, Middlesex TW11 OJE or fax 081&ndash;943 5653. 
 The editor is not bound to agree with readers' opinions and reserves the right to edit letters. 
 ARCHIVES 
 16 March 1928: &bquo;Probably no department of motoring is so useful to the community as racing,&equo; said Sir William Joynson-Hicks, the Home Secretary and chief custodian of the 20mph speed limit, on the occasion of the luncheon for Captain Malcolm Campbell on his return from America, where he travelled faster than any man has succeeded in doing on land. 
 (The Speediest Motoring, The Autocar) 
 18 March 1972: A warning that the proposed US safety and emission control regulations could spell the death of the American car industry has come from BMW's new Munich sales director, Bob Lutz. 
 He revealed that BMW is prepared to withdraw from the US rather than face the economic suicide such regulations would bring. 
 (Motorweek, Motor) 
 17 March 1984: Half the charisma of the Countach is what happens at journey's end. 
 To arrive somewhere in it is to take a shortcut to celebrity; park it, and you create an instant tourist attraction. 
 Some ask if they can sit in the driver's seat. 
 Others merely want to look at the engine. 
 The witty ones ask what it's like to fly. 
 (Feature Test, Motor) 
 15 March 1986: A Ford takeover of Austin Rover would have been good for Britain, according to a top Ford executive. 
 Although the British Government ruled out the prospect of the US company buying Austin Rover, within days of it leaking out that talks had been taking place, Bob Lutz, Ford of Europe chairman, said: &bquo;I honestly believe it would have been best for Britain.&equo; 
 (News Week, Motor) 
 14 March 1990: Was this new-age motoring? 
 The buzz at Geneva last week was about smaller cars, wholesale commitment to environmental protection and rationalised, merged conglomerates. 
 Ford placed enormous faith in its tiny Zig and Zag concept cars and so did GM with its Impact electric two-seater. 
 (Geneva generates new change, Autocar &amp; Motor) 
 Next Week 
 What is the greatest car of all time? 
 The candidates are numerous and varied &mdash; from the Model T Ford to the Porsche 911. 
 We've consulted the leading names in the motor industry and racked our own brains to come up with the definitive answer to one of the ultimate pub arguments. 
 The Renault Clio is this year's European Car of the Year but the award hasn't always been a guarantee of outstanding sales success. 
 Has the little hatchback got what it takes to succeed in one of Europe's toughest markets? 
 Read our full road test to find out. 
 Ford came within a whisker of pulling off one of motorsport's biggest upsets in January when the seven-speed Sierra Cosworth 4x4 of Francois Delecour and Ann Chantal Pauwels almost won the Monte Carlo Rally. 
 We drive the car that's reckoned to the capable of 0&ndash;60mph in less than 4secs and talk to the driver/navigator partnership that rattled the established names in international rallying. 
 Eberhard von Kuenheim is the longest-serving chairman of any car manufacturer. 
 For more than two decades he has led BMW, building it up into one of the industry's most respected and successful marques. 
 In an exclusive interview, Richard Feast discovers that his reputation for straight, sometimes controversial, talking is not exaggerated. 
 ROAD TEST 
 BMW 325iSE 
 More than just a facelift for BMW's most important model, the new 3-series marks a fundamental change of direction 
 For Fabulous engine/driveline, great grip, excellent ride  Against Poor packaging, patchy finish, sanitised handling  
 For those who thought BMW's master plan was to make one car in three different sizes, the new 3-series must be a perplexing product. 
 No double takes are necessary to distinguish the small Bee Emm from its virtually cloned big brothers, the 5 and 7-series. 
 On the contrary, its broad grille and hooded headlamps project something approaching alternative thinking on the way to express the famous Munich car maker's identity. 
 The tail styling, however, is demure to the point of anonymity; aesthetic continuity with the Five and Seven is eschewed for an overtly sober, slightly dainty look. 
 And in profile, the new 3-series has a more steeply raked windscreen, shorter front overhang and stubbier tail than any previous BMW saloon. 
 Whether you like it or not, this is a different look. 
 Then again, perhaps a scaled down 5-series would have been too predictable. 
 If any car needs to be a clear-cut BMW &bquo;statement&equo;, it's the 3-series. 
 This is crucial for the mass-market mover, the car which last year accounted for 59 per cent of all the BMWs sold in the UK. 
 BMW isn't saying which part of the new range will sell best (the smart money is on the 318i). 
 but there is little question that the 325i SE tested here (an estimated &pound;22,995) will set the standard. 
 More aerodynamic than before, with reduced front and rear lift, the new shape has its practical advantages. 
 But of equal interest must be the 5ins longer wheelbase, Z1-style rear suspension and new 24-valve twin-cam version of the previous model's 2.5-litre straight six. 
 Peak power is up a useful 20bhp to 189bhp at 5900rpm while torque receives a similar hike to 177lb ft at 4700rpm. 
 PERFORMANCE AND ECONOMY 
 The 325i is now a genuinely fast car. 
 It needs neither the approbation of ace tuner Alpina nor the motivation of an M-power badge to crack 140mph &mdash; 141&ndash;3mph on the Millbrook bowl is around 10mph faster than the old 325i could manage &mdash; or sprint from rest to 60mph in a sizzling 7.3secs. 
 A 0&ndash;100mph time of 19.2secs and standing kilometre return of 28.3secs, achieved with little apparent strain and the full co-operation of a lightning-quick gearshift, set the seal on the new car's cracking performance credentials. 
 In the two-litre to 2.5-litre saloon ranks, only the &pound;27,060 turbocharged Ford Sierra RS Cosworth 4x4 (144mph and 6.6secs) is notably more rapid. 
 In fourth gear, the 325i takes 7.3secs to cover 30 to 50mph &mdash; respectable but effectively matched by the Vauxhall Cavalier 2000GSi's 7.4secs. 
 In fifth, though the 50&ndash;70mph increment consumes just 9.7 secs, which clearly puts the Cavalier in its place (10.6secs) and presses even the turbocharged Saab 900 Carlsson's 9.1secs. 
 For a normally aspirated 2.5, the 325i's showing against the clock is complete and impressive. 
 But to judge the BMW's performance by figures alone, good as they are, would be a travesty. 
 The 24-valve straight six M50 unit is a simply gorgeous thing to see, with throttle response sharp enough to draw blood, urge aplenty for safe fourth-gear overtaking, a cultured yet appealingly guttural engine note and the kind of smoothness that makes you question the worth of even a good V12. 
 The engine's natural urgency is efficiently harnessed by closely stacked intermediate ratios and a manageable 22.5mph/1000rpm in fifth, which strikes an almost perfect compromise between flexibility and refinement. 
 Just as delectable is the light, slick and superbly swift gearchange, an almost sublimely progressive clutch action and as taut a driveline as you'll encounter; driving the 325i in traffic could hardly be easier. 
 In these areas, BMW has never done better. 
 Where it should have tried harder, however, is with taming mechanical noise levels. 
 The 24-valve engine is appreciably noisier that its 12-valve predecessor and although it invariably sounds good, its insistence can be a little wearing. 
 Our overall consumption of 26.6mpg is a fine result given the zest with which the 325i performs and its relatively short intermediate gearing, though the best return of 27.9mpg suggests that some feather-footed tactics aren't as effective as some might expect. 
 Even so, a significantly bigger tank than before (14.3 against 12.1 gallons) has pushed the range up to a very respectable 386 miles, based on a touring consumption of 27.0mpg. 
 Only unleaded petrol is allowed. 
 HANDLING AND RIDE 
 As before, the 325i's front suspension is by struts, coil-springs and an anti-roll bar. 
 At the back, however, the old semi-trailing arm set-up is replaced with what BMW calls a &bquo;central pull-rod axle&equo; &mdash; essentially the multi-link arrangement with centrally mounted longitudinal link used to great effect on BMW's now-defunct Z1 sports car. 
 BMW claims that this far more sophisticated (and, no doubt, expensive) rear suspension finally lays to rest the spectre of lift-off oversteer which has so bedevilled the 3-series over the years &mdash; albeit to a much lesser degree with the outgoing model which, in Sport form at least, we found to be well balanced and responsive rather than inherently tail happy. 
 Indeed, first impression tells you that the new car's chassis feels a little less sharp and agile than its predecessor's. 
 Subtle, wrist-generated steering inputs don't do as much. 
 The steering is slightly heavier but more damped, too. 
 Feel is still good but communicated in less specific terms. 
 At modest speeds, everything feels just a little inert and aloof. 
 Press harder and it becomes obvious that front-end bite and turn-in are actually very good. 
 Grip isn't merely better than the old car's, it's of a different order. 
 But, and it's a big but, what the enthusiastic driver would once have interpreted as an enjoyable adjustable cornering balance has been squeezed out of existence. 
 This one understeers by degrees in direct ratio to speed. 
 Mostly the understeer is mild but, in the dry at least, it seldom gives way to a genuinely neutral stance. 
 Even in the wet, quelling the chassis' instinct to run wide requires concertedly judicious throttle juggling. 
 And when oversteer does come you'd better be ready for it because it happens suddenly and rather messily. 
 An academic point, maybe, but it underlines a key difference in character and ability between new and old. 
 On a more positive note, the new car covers ground with a sense of stability and security all drivers should appreciate and drivers of the previous 325i could only dream about. 
 It simply goes round corners faster. 
 Also impressive is the suspension's immunity to mid-bend bumps. 
 It's particularly good at dismissing small pock marks and ridges. 
 More generally, the ride is very good. 
 An initial impression of firmness tends to disguise just how hard the suspension is working. 
 In fact, the long-travel springing is quite soft but taut damping exerts exemplary control. 
 Only where deep undulations coincide with a bend is there a hint of diagonal pitching, but this is more of an observation than a criticism. 
 On the road, the all-disc plus anti-lock braking is powerful, progressive and firm under foot though, surprisingly, the car felt slightly unstable when braking hard from 120mph-plus during the Millbrook acceleration runs. 
 Freedom from fade was complete. 
 AT THE WHEEL 
 The new 325i's cabin is less adventurous than its exterior, but only just. 
 Gone is the rather conservative &bquo;up-and-down&equo; architecture of the previous model's facia, replaced by a full-blown exposition of the currently fashionable (especially with the Japanese) organic look with its attendant curves and soft edges. 
 At least, this is the case for the driver, who gets a sexy wrap-around binnacle containing all the controls, dials and readouts he needs. 
 All the front-seat passenger has to look at is a fussily styled and poorly fitting glovebox, but more of this later. 
 Ergonomically, the layout is hard to fault but the space allocated for the otherwise clear and attractive instrumentation seems to have shrunk &mdash; it would have been far better to have the computer readout under the dials instead of the heater controls &mdash; and we question the need for such extravagantly styled air vents. 
 Most of our testers considered the driving position and seats close to perfect, but a couple of the taller specimens would have appreciated some sort of steering wheel adjustment to play off comfort against a clear view of the instruments. 
 COMFORT AND SPACE 
 More than most, BMW is very careful not to tread on its own toes when it comes to cabin size. 
 Working under the not unreasonable assumption that since all its saloons are equally good to drive, size does matter, the last thing it wants to do is create a miracle of packaging at the expense of an ostensibly bigger model. 
 Thus it is that the new 3-series gets a modest extra inch of legroom and stays conspicuously smaller than the far from roomy 5-series. 
 Were not the BMW's closest rival. 
 the Mercedes 190, also so deficient in this department, Munich's thinking on this subject might be different. 
 But, as it is, the 325i scrapes by as a comfortable four-seater with the proviso that four tall occupants will have to come to a front/rear legroom compromise that wouldn't even need to think about in a Peugeot 405. 
 Headroom isn't such a problem, though, and actual rear seat comfort is very good. 
 The boot is decently sized, too, and internal stowage space is generous. 
 FINISH AND EQUIPMENT 
 There are those who would tell you that BMW's reputation for first-class finish has been on thin ice for some time but, until now, we've seen little evidence to substantiate the claim. 
 If our test car is anything to go by, though, the cracks might be beginning to show. 
 The paintwork on the back of the bootlid looked decidedly patchy and certainly not up to the high standard on the rest of the car. 
 Inside, the glovebox lid didn't fit properly, with a much bigger gap on one side than the other. 
 Moreover, the quality of much of the facia and control plastic was rather hard and crudely textured. 
 That said, the car felt extremely solid and well screwed together, exterior panel gaps were uniformly narrow and even and all the doors shut with a satisfying &bquo;thunk&equo;. 
 Not famed for generosity when drawing up standard equipment lists, BMW has nevertheless seen fit to provide the SE with power steering, alloy wheels, electric front windows, central locking and tinted glass. 
 There's no radio, though, just the pre-fit kit, with six speakers. 
 VERDICT 
 Although all the early indications were that the new 3-series was very much an evolutionary product, getting to know the 325i has convinced us otherwise. 
 In many ways, it's the most radical BMW you can buy, with styling that, for the time being, bucks the house style, a chassis that refuses to oversteer and a facia that follows a trend instead of setting one. 
 In our opinion, the driveline is the best BMW has yet made and, despite the change of dynamic emphasis, it's impossible not to derive great pleasure from this alone. 
 Having said all of that, there are disappointments. 
 One is the patchy finish of our test car (atypical we hope), another the lack of rear legroom. 
 More important than either of these is what the 325i has lost. 
 We took the opportunity to drive the outgoing model while we had the new one and were left in no doubt about which was the driver's car. 
 For all its grip and stability, the new model simply isn't as much fun. 
 But that, as they say, is the price of progress. 
 TECHNICAL FOCUS 
 The &bquo;central arm&equo; feature of the rear suspension describes the function of the front longitudinal arm mount as the central point or &bquo;pole&equo; of the axle. 
 In other words, it's the spherical centre of the axes or intersecting lines that the track control arms move along on the inward and outward strokes of the springs. 
 Because of their angle and length, the two track control arms keep the toe-in position of the arms consistent and allow specific changes in camber as a function of wheel action. 
 As cornering acceleration increases, the increasing castor of the outer wheel and the substantial elasticity of the front longitudinal arm bearing point support the car against side forces. 
 This increasing castor thus compensates for any inclination of the car on the rear axle. 
 This &bquo;elastokinematic&equo; response is also claimed to help stability when the car undergoes longitudinal accelerations, such as under heavy application of the brakes, by creating a larger castor angle.  
 Front-end bite and turn-in are very good, and grip is excellent, but the adjustable cornering balance of the previous 3-series has been lost in pursuit of a more stable, secure chassis. 
 The new 325i goes round corners faster as a result. 
 Styling outside and inside distinguishes it from big brothers 
 Gone is the &bquo;up-and-down&equo; look of the previous 3-series in favour of a fashionably organic style. 
 The layout of dials and instruments is hard to fault ergonomically. 
 Not so rear legroom, which, despite an extra inch, still forces those in front to compromise to make it a comfortable four-seater 
 With the 24-valve straight six M50 engine, the 325i is now a genuinely fast car. 
 The figures say 189bhp at 5900rpm and 177lb ft of torque at 4700rpm; your senses say V12-style smoothness, plenty of urge and sharp throttle response. 
 At the other end, the boot offers a decent amount of space 
 THE RIVALS 
 BMW 325i 
 This is not the &bquo;safe&equo; 325i some were expecting. 
 Its styling is deliberately different, its cabin surprisingly derivative, its dynamic character a complete about face. 
 What hasn't changed is the world-beating excellence of the driveline, enhanced by the extra bite of the 24-valve engine. 
 Equipment is modest for the money but ability isn't. 
 AUDI 90 QUATTRO SPORT 20vi 
 For all its fine engineering and good design, the Audi 90 20v quattro offers rather less than meets the eye. 
 Where it's good it's very good indeed and all-wheel drive at this price as an obvious advantage. 
 But the 90 is a rather patchy package. 
 Neither pleasingly accelerative nor particularly sporting, it just about passes as a sporting saloon. 
 MERCEDES 190E 2.6i 
 Very much the unsung hero of Mercedes' 190 range, the six-cylinder 2.6 has none of the cosmetic bravura that distinguishes the 2.5&ndash;16 from its lesser stablemates. 
 But looks can deceive: the 2.6 (even as an automatic) is good for 130mph and 0&ndash;60mph in 8.3 secs. 
 Engine rivals BMW's for smoothness and chassis is very good. 
 Underrated. 
 PEUGEOT 405 Mi16i 
 One of Peugeot's undoubted triumphs, the 405 Mi16 is close to being the perfectly judged front-wheel-drive sports saloon. 
 Cornering adjustability verges on the sensational, providing huge entertainment, though the brakes are oversensitive. 
 Top speed of 132mph and 0&ndash;60mph in 8.0secs are competitive but cheaper 405 SRi is better value. 
 SAAB 900 CARLSSONi 
 The Carlsson doesn't accelerate quite as hard as you might expect (0&ndash;60mph in 8.8secs), but its top speed of 131mph looks healthy enough. 
 Its chassis dishes out 200bhp efficiently enough but betrays its age with indifferent grip and a very firm ride. 
 That said, it's enjoyably &bquo;chuckable&equo; and very well made. 
 An acquired taste, maybe, but worth considering. 
 VAUXHALL CAVALIER GSi 2000 16vi 
 Unlike its all-drive namesake, the front-drive GSi 16v is all excitement and very little finesse with wheelspin and torque steer aplenty. 
 Cat-equipped two-litre 16-valve engine sounds even more potent than it is but gives good economy. 
 In steady-state cornering, chassis has bags of grip but a lumpy ride. 
 Not bad value but too rough around the edges. 
 SIGNING OFF 
 From Rolls-Royce through BRM and on to Lotus, Tony Rudd's colourful 53-year career has been a monument to engineering brilliance. 
 Now, in the month of his retirement, he finds time to share his story with Mark Hughes 
 Tony Rudd retires this month after a distinguished career spanning 53 years &mdash; 13 at Rolls-Royce, 18 at BRM and 22 at Lotus. 
 His engineering brilliance has taken him from being Rolls-Royce's &bquo;infant prodigy&equo; to Lotus' &bquo;grand old man&equo;, with a sheaf of important achievements along the way. 
 Three stand out. 
 More than anyone else, he was responsible for transforming BRM from motor racing's laughing stock into the efficient outfit that won the world championship in 1962. 
 His thinking over many years lead to his innovative Lotus 78, the car that pioneered F1's ground effect era, and his creative energy over the past 10 years has been instrumental in galvanising Lotus, once a car maker with a fragile future, into an engineering consultancy of huge standing worldwide. 
 Rudd's passion for engineering goes back to childhood, and particularly to one &bquo;action-packed weekend&equo; when, as an eight-year-old, he stayed with his maiden aunt in London. 
 She took him to the Science Museum and gave him an encyclopaedia, which explained how the internal combustion engine worked &mdash; &bquo;I was intrigued immensely&equo;. 
 A family link with Bira and Chula, the racing Siamese princes, pushed his interest towards motor racing. 
 Both of them wrote to him at school, and Rudd remembers selling the foreign stamps off their letters to buy The Autocar . 
 After he told them about this, they sent one letter from Siam covered with stamps: &bquo;Those would have kept me in The Autocar  for ever, but I couldn't bear to part with the envelope.&equo; 
 Chula took Rudd to various pre-war motor races, and he spent his school holidays at the White Mouse garage in Hammersmith, helping to clean their ERAs and absorbing the atmosphere. 
 &bquo;I learned a lot from Chula about running a racing team,&equo; says Rudd. 
 &bquo;He taught me that you could win without having the fastest car, by tactics and organisation. 
 He was in the same mould as Neubauer, the Mercedes manager: not flamboyant, but an ice-cold organiser, logical and rational. 
 Bira was never the same when he drove without Chula.&equo; 
 From school, Rudd joined Rolls-Royce in 1938 as an apprentice in the motor car division, seeing this as a stepping stone towards an ambition that was already formed. 
 He wanted to be chief engineer of Aston Martin. 
 He admired the company's pre-war products &mdash; efficient little sports cars with something of the modern Lotus spirit about them &mdash; more than any other car, and for a long time he used Astons on the road. 
 Rudd spent 13 years with Rolls-Royce. 
 His apprenticeship took him through various parts of the motor car division until the outbreak of war, when he was transferred to the aviation side to make crankshafts and camshafts for Merlin engines. 
 In 1942 he was picked out by Alec Harvey-Bailey (later to become a senior Rolls-Royce figure and a good friend) to join the defect investigation department, analysing war-service failures in Merlin, Griffon and Vulture engines. 
 By 1944, aged 21, he was head of this important department. 
 After the war, Rudd had little to do with Rolls-Royce's automotive activities other than occasionally borrowing prototype Bentleys to clock up miles for durability programmes. 
 As assistant manager of powerplant quality, he was caught up in Rolls-Royce's efforts to penetrate the civil aircraft business with the Merlin. 
 But disenchantment set in because the outdated Merlin (used for the Avro Tudor and Canadair Four) clearly had little future, and the more rewarding prospect of a senior job on the new Dart engine (destined for the Vickers Viscount) kept being thwarted by delays to the project. 
 Feeling frustrated, he took the offer, in 1951, of a three-month posting to BRM, which was having trouble with the Rolls-Royce supercharger on its V16 engine. 
 Towards the and of his stint, he filled a gap in the team for the Italian GP at Monza &mdash; and saw at first hand one of BRM's famous fiascos. 
 Both V16s were withdrawn because of a gearbox problem in practice. 
 &bquo;I stayed at Monza after the race to run a test programme,&equo; says Rudd, &bquo;and learned a great deal while Piero Taruffi, Stirling Moss and Ken Wharton drove the car, I remembered Freddie Dixon's observations, in his book on building Rileys, about sorting out suspension and chassis stiffness, so I followed some of his ideas because of Moss's complaints about the diabolical steering. 
 I found I could force the steering wheel a quarter of a turn and flex all sorts of things, like the casting for the gearbox mounting.&equo; 
 Rudd's temporary job evolved into a full-time role as a &bquo;sort of chief mechanic running the racing shop at Folkingham&equo;, and soon after he married Pam, a girl from Bourne. 
 His influence at BRM increased, the job growing to encompass engine development after Sir Alfred Owen (of Rubery Owen) bought the team from the ERM Trust in 1952. 
 Rudd got along well with Sir Alfred, in time developing immense respect for him. 
 The high spot of the V16 period came in 1953 at Albi, where BRM should have won convincingly but for the immense torque of the engines destroying the tyres. 
 Among many poor performances was the Chichester Cup, a wet race at Goodwood in which Reg Parnell's V16, its ridiculous torque curve and dreadful roadholding proving to be a hopeless combination on a slippery track, was humbled by an unsupercharged two-litre Maserati driven by Baron de Graffenreid. 
 &bquo;Sir Alfred was at Goodwood that day,&equo; says Rudd, &bquo;and asked me why de Graffenreid was blowing us off. 
 I gave him a lecture about how the car was too heavy, going on about power-to-weight ratios. 
 Finally, after Wharton's crash at Albi, Sir Alfred told Raymond Mays and Pater Berthon that BRM should build a smaller, lighter car. 
 Since I had raised the issue, I was to go and make it &mdash; which didn't please Berthon. 
 &bquo;So we made the V16 MkII using my oval-section tube as the basis. 
 The car was a lot shorter and 4cwt lighter. 
 It wasn't quite chalk and string on the garage floor because I had a drawing board at Folkingham, but the tin-bashers and fitters would look over my shoulder and make parts as I drew them. 
 The MkII was a bit better, but not much.&equo; 
 From the end of 1952 the V16 was eligible only for Formule Libre  races because of revised F1 rules. 
 It ran in MkII guise from 1954 to 1955, but its six wins all came at insignificant domestic races. 
 BRM's F1 return had to wait until the new two-litre P25 was ready for its first full season in 1956. 
 Rudd designed the chassis, calling it his &bquo;overstressed skin car&equo;. 
 It could be regarded as the original monocoque, because it used a lightweight structure of four small-diameter steel tubes and a stressed aluminium skin. 
 Despite drivers of the calibre of Mike Hawthorn and Tony Brooks, 1956 was a disastrous season as the cars failed repeatedly, with persistent valve problems and difficult handling. 
 The four-cylinder engine was more reliable in 1957, but BRM took a long time to realise that the P25's air strut suspension &mdash; carried over from the V16 &mdash; was the cause of its savage oversteer. 
 Engaged as consultants, Alec Issigonis and Alex Moulton half solved the problem by changing the rear suspension, but it took another outsider to put BRM on the right track. 
 &bquo;Colin Chapman went straight to the point,&equo; remembers Rudd. 
 &bquo;He told us to throw away the air strut front suspension &mdash; coil springs, telescopic dampers and a lowered roll centre were what we needed. 
 Suddenly we had a half-decent car. 
 &bquo;This was my first professional association with Chapman, but I already knew him. 
 There had once been a row at Goodwood when the scrutineers rejected Colin's car because it didn't have a fireproof bulkhead. 
 He went away and fitted a piece of cardboard painted silver. 
 Quite why this put the scrutineers in a dilemma I don't know, but they asked me to protest to get them off the hook. 
 I told them to do their own dirty work. 
 Chunky heard about his and we became friends.&equo; 
 Although the P25 was by then quite good, Rudd realised that the front suspension could be tweaked still further. 
 He formed the idea early in 1958 that a new front end with very unequal length wishbones would stop the roll centre moving about. 
 He waited until Berthon &mdash; with whom Rudd had never seen eye to eye &mdash; took a holiday and grafted a new front end on to Jean Behra's car. 
 Berthon was livid at one of his cars being butchered but had to acknowledge that it handled better. 
 &bquo;I bet Behra that he would put the car on pole at Monaco in 1958,&equo; says Rudd, &bquo;and he did. 
 I immediately considered myself God's gift to suspension design, on the basis of this one lucky fluke. 
 So when, in 1959, it was decided to build a mid-engined car, I was violently affronted that Berthon and his staff at Bourne would design it, and not me at Folkingham. 
 Knowing of my discontent, Alec Harvey-Bailey suggested that I should return to Rolls-Royce, perhaps as chief quality engineer, or head of the service department &mdash; both good jobs. 
 I half-did the deal.&equo; 
 BRM's first rear-engined car, the Type 48, turned out to be a pig, Graham Hill recording in his autobiography that &bquo;the car would suddenly take a dive and dart straight into the infield out of control&equo;. 
 While he mulled over his future, Rudd gradually sorted out the handling so that by July 1960 the Type 48 was good enough for Hill to put in a brilliant performance in the British Grand Prix, clawing his way into the lead after losing a third of a lap through stalling on the grid. 
 Rudd's spirit was returning. 
 &bquo;After that race,&equo; he says, &bquo;I met Alec Harvey-Bailey by the side of the road near Silverstone and told him I would stay with BRM. 
 Then Sir Alfred pulled in in his Bentley and promised me a free hand to design a car that worked. 
 Which is how the type 56, the car with the upswept stack-pipes came into being. 
 &bquo;This did not endear me to certain people at BRM. 
 I had a little pirate operation, which is not the way to make friends or win races. 
 I had my ideas worked out by the time I left for the 1960&ndash;61 Tasman series, and on the 24-hour flight to New Zealand I sat with a slide rule and drew the car as a pin-jointed structure, stressed it and arrived at all the tube sizes.&equo; 
 Testing revealed the car's promise, but BRM's future looked rockier than ever in 1961. 
 Sir Alfred had spent enough of Rubery Owen's profits and was impatient for success; BRM would be closed down if it failed to win races in 1962. 
 The Sir Alfred's brother, Ernest, discovered that the 1962 budget had been spent before the season had started&hellip; 
 There was a huge row within the Owen family and for a while it looked as if the plug would be pulled immediately. 
 Only when Sir Alfred enlisted the help of his sister, Jean Stanley (wife of Louis) was BRM able to proceed for the 1962 season. 
 She promised her support on the condition that Mays and Berthon were sidelined and Rudd was given his chance. 
 So Rudd was appointed team manager and chief engineer for the season. 
 It was to be the happiest year of his career &mdash; the year when BRM finally came good and won the world championship with Graham Hill. 
 &bquo;It was touch and go financially,&equo; says Rudd. 
 &bquo;My first event in charge was at Goodwood &mdash; the race where Stirling Moss crashed &mdash; and I had no money. 
 Nothing. 
 But Graham won, so I could pay the wages from the prize money. 
 Both cars blew up at Aintree, but the start money saw us through. 
 All the stack-pipes fell off in the Daily Express Trophy at Silverstone, but Graham won again and that race carried a lot of money. 
 We won for a third time at Zandvoort, the first grand prix of the season: apart from the prize money, that moved us up a scale on the start money and suddenly I could see our way through the rest of the season. 
 &bquo;Graham led from the first lap to the 97th at Monaco, and then ran out of oil. 
 At Rouen the fuel filters were so good that they took all the dye out of the fuel and became clogged, so we only finished second. 
 We were second again in a non-championship race at Reims, where I indulged in my habit of lurking at corners taking pictures of the front suspension. 
 &bquo;One shot showed a problem with the lever arms on the roll bar, so we had new ones made for the British Grand Prix at Aintree. 
 They arrived after practice, but, like a fool, I put them on untried for the race. 
 They made the front roll bar so much stiffer that the cars understeered out of the race with the front tyres worn out. 
 We were still leading the championship, but it was becoming fraught. 
 &bquo;After that I told Sir Alfred of my plans for a monocoque car for the next season, and got a sour letter back saying we had to win another grand prix before we talked about anything. 
 Soon Graham won the German Grand Prix, so that was grand. 
 Then at Monza, with modified combustion chambers, Graham and Ritchie Ginther finished first and second with pole position and fastest lap too &mdash; the lot. 
 &bquo;Shortly after that I met Ernest Owen in London at a big Rubery Owen function. 
 We were well on top by then, but he still expected something to go wrong &mdash; he bet his Rolls that we'd lose the title. 
 &bquo;Graham took second place at Watkins Glen before we went to South Africa for the last race. 
 We had a row with Lucas there because they had fitted fuel injection to Jimmy Clark's Lotus, despite promising us exclusive use for the season if we persevered with it. 
 As it turned out, Jimmy raced his carburettor car because he preferred it, and led until the Climax blew up. 
 Graham's win was his fourth and there we were &mdash; the music hall joke &mdash; as champions.&equo; 
 Rudd designed his monocoque car for 1963 &mdash; &bquo;it had clever tricks like inboard variable race suspension, but it was a dog&equo; &mdash; and also he found himself committed by Sir Alfred to building a Le Mans car powered by Rover's gas turbine. 
 The project produced a successful demonstration run at the Le Mans 24 Hours, despite the imposition of a ridiculous timetable which gave BRM only 10 days to build the car. 
 A couple of grand prix wins came in 1963 and two more the following year before another highly successful season in 1965 saw three victories and a string of second places for Jackie Stewart and Hill. 
 But for Clark's six wins, BRM might have had another world title. 
 It marked the end of a terrific F1 period for BRM throughout the 1.5-litre years. 
 Rudd admits that he made a big mistake in designing an H16 engine, a layout previously used only in aviation, for the new three-litre formula in 1966. 
 Knowing that BRM's 1.5-litre V8 engine had been superior to the Climax, Rudd took the existing proportions to create an engine twice as big and with two crankshafts. 
 It gave enough power, but was far too complicated and weighed 500lb against the Brabham Repco V8's 300lb. 
 &bquo;A number of things contributed to the end of my spell with BRM,&equo; says Rudd. 
 &bquo;Mike Spence's death at Indy in 1968 knocked the stuffing out of me. 
 I was also becoming frustrated with the time I had to spend on commercial projects at BRM. 
 Sir Alfred was in love with the Cosworth idea of making engines for other people, but I felt we had to restore our position in F1 first. 
 We were at loggerheads. 
 &bquo;My disillusion deepened during 1969, and by then Chapman had offered me a job. 
 Sir Alfred's interest was declining and Louis Stanley, his brother-in-law, was playing a bigger part. 
 Big Lou hired John Surtees and offered him the whole of my &pound;27,000 budget for drivers, leaving nothing for Jackie Oliver. 
 Surtees was a good choice, but I never got to know him the way I did Graham Hill, Jackie Stewart and Pedro Rodriguez. 
 My enthusiasm was ebbing away. 
 &bquo;A huge argument at Zandvoort finished it. 
 I had been planning to go to the Nurburgring for testing the day after the race, but I was told to return to the factory and stop the new car I was building. 
 It was a proper &bquo;wing&equo; car. 
 I met Chapman on his way to the Zandvoort prize-giving and said I'd take the job &mdash; basically to turn Lotus into an engine manufacturer &mdash; if it was still available. 
 Big Lou came out with a story that I'd been fired &mdash; but I resigned.&equo; 
 Rudd arrived as a powertrain engineering manager at Lotus, producing Elans, Renault-engined Europas and Plus 25s at a rate of 90 a week but selling only 30 a week, largely because of terrible quality problems. 
 Rudd's job was to complete Lotus's new two-litre engine and set up the plant to make it. 
 By 1973 it was in production and selling at a good profit to Jensen for the new Jensen-Healey. 
 Chapman's great move up-market with the Elite/Eclat/Esprit family was already germinating when Rudd came to Hethel. 
 He remembers writing a document outlining the new range of M50 (Elite), M51 (a front-engined four-seater V8), M70 (a wedge-shaped mid-engined car that became the Esprit) and M71 (a mid-engined V8). 
 Before the four-cylinder half of this plan came to fruition, Rudd, now engineering director, hired a new recruit from Jaguar &mdash; &bquo;a bright young man called Mike Kimberley&equo; &mdash; to head up vehicle engineering and lead the team that put the existing twin-cam engine in the Europa. 
 The new four-cylinder engine &mdash; the one that still powers the Excel and the Esprit &mdash; was dreadfully unreliable at first, but went quite well by the time the Elite was launched. 
 Rudd also had a hand in the Giugiaro-designed Esprit that appeared in 1975, but by this time, as group engineering director, he had wide responsibilities for production cars, racing cars and Chapman's new boat-building venture. 
 Wanting Rudd to apply his mind to motor racing again, Chapman gave him his famous 27-page handwritten list of &bquo;things he needed to know for F1&equo;. 
 Rudd developed his junked BRM &bquo;wing&equo; car ideas and beavered away at Ketteringham Hall with his think tank &mdash; a team that included Peter Wright, an ex-BRM colleague who fathered active suspension &mdash; to produce the F1 Lotus 78. 
 One of the all-time great racing innovations, it conquered all in 1978 to create F1's &bquo;ground effect&equo; era. 
 Rudd was then &bquo;left in a corner&equo; designing the new four-litre Lotus V8, and also produced an outline of a turbine Le Mans car that would use a Rolls-Royce Gem engine and be built with Essex sponsorship. 
 Nothing happened with the turbine, but the V8 got as far as running in prototype form in the James Bond Esprit, which Rudd used as his personal car for a time. 
 The V8 was put on ice when Lotus went through one of its regular periods of financial cramp in 1981 &mdash; but a few years later its key features were sold to GM in the shape of the LT5 engine for the Corvette ZR1. 
 Lotus's engineering consultancy began to take off in 1981 under Rudd's guidance. 
 Nurturing this side of the business &mdash; with dramatic success &mdash; has occupied most of his time for the past 10 years. 
 But for its profitability and burgeoning client list, GM would never have taken over and the new Elan might still be an idea waiting for the cash to build it. 
 &bquo;The engineering side grew very quickly at first,&equo; says Rudd. 
 &bquo;We picked up some customer projects &mdash; like the Metro Turbo and some Toyota work &mdash; and had a nice little business ticking away. 
 Soon we were making more money than the car company was losing. 
 I remember Chapman was amazed when I told him we might make a million profit in 1982. 
 Within a fortnight he was dead.&equo; 
 The landmark of the post-Chapman era was the GM stake in 1986. 
 Prior to this, when David Wickins was in control, Rudd had played a key part in drawing Lotus to GM's attention. 
 A copy of a paper he had given to the British Association on &bquo;The car of the future&equo; led to his being summoned to Detroit, and to a commission to design and build it. 
 That car became the Corvette Indy &mdash; a sensational prototype with a mid-mounted LT5 turbo engine, four-wheel drive, active suspension, and a &bquo;twin-chassis&equo; structure. 
 With so many of Lotus Engineering's successes having to remain secret, the Corvette Indy stands as the company's most compelling advertisement. 
 Rudd bows out of Lotus with other fascinating projects under his belt, many yet to appear. 
 The need for confidentiality means that even he &mdash; a man who likes to tell it how it really is &mdash; clams up about the twilight of his career. 
 One day, perhaps, these commercial sensitivities will have receded into history and there will be a postscript to add.  
 Not the retiring type: Tony Rudd's outspokenness and engineering prowess ensured an eventful career with some significant names in motoring 
 From the top: Rudd at the Italian GP in 1962 as BRM's team manager and chief engineer; BRM's flawed H16 of 1966; BRM V16 of the early '50s, Rudd in suit 
 Rudd with the interim two-litre P261 in 1966 (top); Stewart and Spence await the start of Belgian GP. 
 Graham Hill on his way to victory at Goodwood in 1962, BRM's best year (left). 
 Opposite page top: P48 MkII with stopgap Climax V8. 
 Bottom: Lotus four-litre V8 which eventually went to GM for Corvette 
 A WEIGHTY PROBLEM 
 The use of composite materials, such as carbon fibre and Kevlar, to save weight has become part and parcel of racing car production. 
 Away from the race track, however, composites have been confined to the specialist manufacturer, with the major car makers playing a waiting game. 
 But increasing tooling-up costs for pressed steel may change that, reports Keith Howard 
 Simplificate and add lightness was the design philosophy attributed to that acknowledged genius of car design, Colin Chapman. 
 You can criticise the grammar, but the logic is irrefutable. 
 All other things being equal, a lighter car will accelerate harder, brake more easily and handle better than its heavier equivalent. 
 That's why there are minimum weight limits for racing cars. 
 But the trend in the motor industry at large has been in quite the opposite direction to the Chapman philosophy; cars have not become lighter over the years but noticeably heavier and more complex. 
 Slimming may be a theme of our age, but apparently not where the automobile is concerned. 
 Reversing this trend, if it is to be reversed, cannot be achieved by a new minimalism. 
 No one &mdash; apart from the buyer of a stripped-out Porsche special, perhaps &mdash; is going to accept weight savings achieved by reducing a car to its bare, spartan, noisy essentials. 
 So weight has to be shed within the car's structure without sacrificing crash-worthiness or noise levels. 
 Composite materials provide the obvious solution. 
 Composites, as every motor racing fan knows, combine light weight with immense strength &mdash; just ask Gerhard Berger, Derek Warwick or Martin Donnelly. 
 But they are also a world away from the technology the major car manufacturers know best &mdash; the cutting, press-forming, welding and painting of metal. 
 It will take more than the prospect of weight savings to prompt them to abandon this safe method. 
 From where might the motivation come? 
 According to Lotus associate director Albert Adams &mdash; a world authority on composites and the man who, 30 years ago, was told by Chapman to &bquo;learn all about glass-fibre&equo; &mdash; it could be from the escalating costs of tooling up for pressed-steel car production. 
 To make the point, he cites the example of the latest Ford Fiesta, the tooling costs for which were a massive &pound;700million. 
 Composite technology, suitably developed for mass production, might offer considerable savings on this investment. 
 But what are composites exactly, and how far are they from mass-production reality? 
 A composite is any material made up of two or more distinct elements. 
 Reinforced concrete is an example, and is not as irrelevant to motorised transport as you might think. 
 Concrete hulls, reinforced with glass-fibre rather than steel, have been used in boat building for many years. 
 In the aerospace and motor industry contexts, composites use different components but deploy them to similar ends. 
 Light, high tensile strength fibres confer stiffness and strength to a polymer resin that binds them into a rigid three-dimensional form. 
 The idea is a relatively new one to engineering but certainly not to planet earth: collagen, keratin, chitin and cellulose are some of nature's strong fibres and make possible everything from bones and lobster carapaces to giant sequoias. 
 From the references to glass-fibre and resin you will gather that GRP &mdash; glass-fibre reinforced plastic or glass-fibre reinforced polymer &mdash; is a composite. 
 What's more it's one that, contrary to composites' up-to-the-minute image, has a long history in the specialist motor industry. 
 Glass-fibre remains an inexpensive and effective reinforcement material, but in recent years it has been upstaged by Kevlar and carbon fibre, two stronger but more costly materials that owe their high profile largely to their use in formula racing cars. 
 They make possible composite materials which, weight for weight, are very much stiffer than metals; or, stiffness for stiffness, considerably lighter (see panel). 
 The ultimate composite materials capitalise on the inherent strength and lightness of reinforced resins by deploying them in a sandwich construction. 
 As the name suggests, this consists of two slices and a filling &mdash; or, in engineering terminology, two skins and a core. 
 Fibre/resin composite is used for the skins, which confer most of the sandwich's rigidity; the core is merely a light but compressively stiff intermediary that keeps the two skins apart. 
 It can be as utilitarian as the rigid polyurethane foam commonly used in the reinforcement of GRP bodyshells, or as elegant as the aluminium or Nomex honeycombs employed in pukka aerospace sandwich materials (as seen recently through holes in the wings of Tornado jets involved in the Gulf conflict). 
 Honeycomb sandwich materials represent the ultimate in low weight and high stiffness, and have revolutionised aircraft and racing car design. 
 But their relevance to large-scale car manufacture is minimal. 
 Fabricating a complex structure from them is a skilled and lengthy process, one that can be beyond even small, specialist marques &mdash; as Panther discovered with the ill-fated Solo. 
 Aerospace manufacturers and racing car constructors can afford the necessary time and trouble; the car majors cannot. 
 For a glimpse of how composite materials might make the transition to mass production, you need to look at innovations like the VARI (vacuum-assisted resin injection) process developed by Lotus. 
 This method dispenses with the old image of workers laboriously laying down layers of fibre in a mould and adding resin by brush. 
 Instead, the fibre is first place dry between male and female moulds, which are drawn together by vacuum, and then the resin is injected. 
 If required, the fibre can first be wrapped around a pre-shaped rigid foam core, to produce a sandwich construction. 
 VARI is not a new process &mdash; Lotus first used it to make Elite bodies in 1974. 
 But it continues to be developed, and each refinement makes it simpler and speedier. 
 The latest innovations, used in the production of Elan panels, are Fibreform &mdash; a patented process that allows the mat to be pre-formed, outside the mould, into the required shape &mdash; and nickel-plated moulds, which improve surface finish and allow heat to be applied to speed curing. 
 Curing time nevertheless remains one of the barriers to composites' mass production, even though, as Lotus's Albert Adams is quick to point out, what comes out of a steel press is far from being a complete car body. 
 Steel panels have to be fabricated separately, with size limitations set by platen size and press tonnage, and then welded together. 
 All of which takes time. 
 Composite bodies can be fabricated in fewer, larger components, and that makes curing time less of a drawback than it appears. 
 Still, the car majors are playing a waiting game. 
 They dabble in composites, and keep a weather eye on the developments made by the small specialists. 
 It will take irrefutable economic arguments, and a leap of faith, before any of them is prepared to abandon steel for reinforced plastic. 
 STRONG FIBRES 
 Three types of fibre reinforcement are commonly used in composites: glass-fibre, Kevlar and carbon fibre. 
 All three combine the properties if high tensile modulus and low density, but to different degrees. 
 As the bar chart below shows, carbon fibre has the highest modulus-to-density ratio, followed by Kevlar and then glass. 
 All three have a higher tensile modulus, weight for weight, than steel, aluminium, magnesium or titanium: 
 These figures are for the fibres alone. 
 In composite form the tensile modulus is reduced, but the modulus-to-density ratios for carbon fibre and Kevlar nevertheless remain markedly superior to those of the common engineering materials. 
 The bar chart below shows the figures for unidirectional composites, in which the fibres are all aligned in the same direction. 
 These are the strongest, but only along the axis of the fibres; like wood, they are much stiffer along the grain than across. 
 In composites where the fibres are bidirectional or in the form of a chopped mat, the ratio of modulus to density is reduced, but the composite is stiff in all directions. 
 In practice the superiority of composites can be even greater than these figures suggest. 
 For example, the flexural (bending) stiffness of a flat panel is proportional to the cube of its thickness. 
 On an equal mass comparison, this further favours the composites because their low densities allow much greater panel thickness. 
 The ranking of the fibres' modulus/density ratios is reflected in their relative costs, glass-fibre being the cheapest and carbon fibre the most expensive: 
 The price of Kevlar will reduce as it becomes more widely used, whereas carbon fibre is so energy-consumptive to manufacture that the likelihood is it will always be too costly for anything other than specialised use in the car industry.  
 Lotus's VARI process does away with laborious hand lay-up of fibres (above) 
 The ill-fated Panther Solo was an example of how the lengthy process of fabricating complex composite structures can present difficulties for even specialist marques 
 Lotus Elan body panels use a production process called Fibreform, which is a refinement of the VARI process first used to make Elite bodies in 1974 
 SECONDHAND spotlight 
 FOUR-RUNNER FOR &pound;5000 
 One of the pioneers of the four-wheel-drive family saloon market, the Sierra 4x4, is now one of the best bargains around, offering strong performance and secure handling at a fair price. 
 Graham Nash locates a good example in Glasgow 
 With the awful storms of late February still fresh in most people's minds, those with four-wheel-drive cars must have found the extra traction a godsend. 
 While most of use were struggling to stay on the roads, the all-wheel-drive cars swanned along with barely a feather ruffled. 
 We're not likely to experience such treacherous driving conditions many more times this year, but the benefits of all-wheel drive in the wet or dry are still undeniable. 
 In search of a bargain 4wd family car, the choice is fairly limited. 
 In fact, there is only one car that has been around long enough to have reached an affordable price on the secondhand market &mdash; the Ford Sierra XR4x4 2.8i. 
 The XR was the first of Ford's new 4x4 generation, and by the standards of today's rivals is a touch agricultural. 
 The Ferguson-developed 4wd system, which directs power between the front and rear wheels in a fixed 34/66 per cent ratio, is effective and durable but hardly state of the art. 
 Scouring the dealers in a still slushy Scotland, I came across a 1985 B-plate model on offer for &pound;4995 at Alex Ritchie Motors of 43 Nithsdale Street &mdash; south of the Clyde in real Taggart country. 
 The car had been washed but not valeted and its general condition suggested that the 58,160 mileage was genuine &mdash; something that the decidedly patchy service history was unable to confirm (the vehicle arrived at Ritchie Motors without a service book). 
 No sign of any crash repair damage was evident in the bodywork, panel alignment was good and the diamond white paintwork looked blemish-free until closer inspection revealed the truth. 
 Sales director Sandy Ritchie pointed out the repainted sills, which were peppered and chipped when the car was acquired. 
 The touching up had been well managed but elsewhere there remained a few patches of exposed metal requiring attention &mdash; just above the bumper on the front offside wing, inside the wheelarch of the same wing and around the radiator duct. 
 None of this was structural but it detracted from the overall impression nevertheless. 
 The same close-quarters examination confirmed that the underside in general, and the exhaust system in particular, were in good order but the front tyres were only marginally legal and needed replacing. 
 The rear tyres had a comfortable level of tread left and the seven-spoke alloy wheels were unmarked. 
 Beneath a surface grubbiness inside, the seats, carpets and trim were in excellent condition. 
 I also checked that the electrically powered bits and pieces were operating properly. 
 The central locking didn't secure or unlock the front passenger door and all the locks felt rather stiff and gritty. 
 Both electric front windows worked, albeit with a degree of sloth and a slight graunching. 
 Similarly, the door mirrors worked but not with any great precision. 
 Tributes were largely unknown to Ford's injected Cologne V6, but it is a worthy enough trooper. 
 It never exactly whistles while it works &mdash; if anything, it wheezes in its upper reaches &mdash; but its torquey character and outright power endow the Sierra with a fleet turn of foot, particularly in the lower gears. 
 I was unable to detect any knocking from the drive-shafts, protests from the power steering or &bquo;pulling&equo; from the brakes. 
 But in the cabin, the parcel tray bounced and the instrument binnacle zizzed. 
 The original XR's gearbox was never a strong point. 
 Clean changes were possible given a little patience, but moving from first to second was reminiscent of shovelling coal &mdash; sometime the lever slid into place, sometimes it jarred my whole body. 
 Double declutching helped a little. 
 The clutch itself, though typically abrupt, didn't slip at all and gave no cause for concern during the drive. 
 The suspension was much as I remembered it, crashing a bit over poor surfaces but generally sounding worse than it actually felt. 
 If my heart was set on buying a Sierra XR4x4, &pound;5000 for the Ritchie Motors offering would be sorely tempting. 
 The car was pretty sound in most respects &mdash; well used but not abused &mdash; and the existing faults would, the dealership assured me, be rectified before it found a new owner. 
 However, the lack of any service history is a major drawback when buying a six-year-old car with a greater than average degree of mechanical complexity. 
 In the end, I would have to move on from this example to examine other XRs on offer around Glasgow. 
 But it would be possible that I might end up back at Ritchie Motors. 
 What the trade says 
 Sierras have a reputation for being tough and the four-wheel-drive versions are the toughest of all. 
 They have always had a certain macho image and reasonable new prices have ensured that residual values are sensible. 
 Early 2.8-litre cars are perhaps the best value around, particularly those with high mileage. 
 You can't get 4wd handling and muscular performance at anything like the low prices these cars fetch on the used car market. 
 The rear-wheel-drive XR4i, which preceded the XR4x4, is now a minor classic in the making and is in fact a far superior performer to the 4x4. 
 Prices for the XR4i have hardened dramatically and the best examples are starting to rise a little in value. 
 Sheer weight of numbers will ensure that the XR4x4 does not follow this trend and will always be available cheaply. 
 Anyone looking for refinement and smoothness would be well advised to look elsewhere because these cars are mechanically harsh and lumpy with a mighty thirst when extended. 
 Superb build quality and a good specification are bonus points and 100,000 miles or more can be expected from well-maintained examples. 
 Auctions are a good source of supply because many companies run them and then dispose of sound examples in the sale ring. 
 A full service history is essential and mechanical repair can be expensive, so shop around for the top examples. 
 The durability of these cars makes them a prime target for clockers and is another reason to insist on up-to-date service schedules. 
 Now fitted with the superior 2.9-litre engine, the latest cars will depreciate heavily in the first year &mdash; 48 per cent falls are the norm. 
 The rate of depreciation slows down significantly in the second and third years but still runs at around 20 per cent a year. 
 The lack of a complete service history makes the white 1986 C-reg car we tested too expensive in retail terms. 
 A mileage of 58,000 was credible and the car was clean and honest, but similar cars are available for between &pound;4000 and &pound;45000 around the country. 
 It would make around &pound;35000 at auction and there is no doubt that this is where the best value can be had. 
 XR4x4 hunters would be well advised to look for cars with anti-lock brakes and metallic paint. 
 These options do not have any additional value on five-year-old cars but they do enhance their saleability. 
 John Coates  
 Secondhand Sierra XR4x4s are generally good value for money, providing strong performance and plenty of grip for less than &pound;5000. 
 Ferguson-type front-wheel drive system seems agricultural by today's standards but is durable and still effective 
 ESCORT REVISITED 
 Is it really as duff as we said? 
 A lot has happened in the seven months since Ford unveiled its new Escort range &mdash; and not much of it in accordance with its &pound;1 billion master plan. 
 On the introduction of the latest S variant, editor Bob Murray assesses the range anew 
 Our most controversial cover last year showed a photograph of a red car going around a Swiss hairpin, with the headline &bquo;Ford's new Escort meets its rivals&equo;, and then, underlined in red, &bquo;&hellip; and loses&equo;. 
 You will surely remember the debate on the letters pages through September, as those with us and those against us spelled out their views. 
 What you won't know, unless you work for Ford, is just how high up the hierarchy our criticisms went, and how hard they hit. 
 There was what seemed to be an endless round of meetings to discuss our coverage, with Ford personnel up to and including European vice-presidents. 
 To pillory a car like the Escort &mdash; and it is Britain's single most important model &mdash; is plainly asking for trouble. 
 Especially when, as with Autocar &amp; Motor , you're the first to report the facts, and you report them loudly. 
 Subsequent Escort reports from around Europe have said everything that we said on 29 August 1990. 
 But pretty soon into the new model's life it was clear that adverse press reaction was far from Ford's biggest worry. 
 The bold claim that all models were to be available from day one quickly fell flat. 
 The estate and cabriolet, and some versions of the Orion, hit the streets months behind schedule. 
 In response to our criticisms, production of all 1.4-litre models was stopped so that front anti-roll bars could be fitted, a debacle not unknown to Ford. 
 There were production problems early on too, which cost as many as 500 cars a day at the Halewood plant. 
 Even when the new models were being produced they didn't always get to the dealers: a dispute at Toleman, which distributes Fords, caused vast stockpiles. 
 And when they did get out, the response from the all-important fleets was lukewarm and enthusiasm from private buyers greatly tempered by the general sales collapse of December and January. 
 It wasn't exactly a copybook launch, though by no means was everything within Ford's control. 
 An advertising campaign that went on about the law of averages didn't seem to help when much of the press criticism rounded on the Escort as exactly a car for Mr Average. 
 Even Ford's pricing policy rebounded. 
 The old Escorts went up more than 12 per cent last year, the last rise coming just a couple of weeks before the introduction of the new model. 
 This allowed the company to crow about the new models that cost no more than the old &mdash; a favourite Ford device but by no means exclusive to the blue oval badge. 
 But in the market at that time the ploy was far from enough to make the new models seem like bargains. 
 Action came at price rise time in January, when Ford upgraded all LX Escort/Orion equipment and introduced a new L model &mdash; in effect an LX at the old price. 
 You expect such tactics with cars nearing the end of their life, not with models just months old. 
 The result of all this was that the Escort languished in some unfamiliar positions in the top 10 sales chart. 
 There was a marketing push in December that took it to third spot but by January the Escort was back to fifth position, behind even the aged Vauxhall Astra. 
 The Orion &mdash; much more a separate car in the new range and the subject of a strong advertising campaign of its own &mdash; took ninth position. 
 Few doubt that the Escort/Orion will eventually be this country's best seller, as yet more new versions are introduced and the new Zeta engine becomes available from the end of this year. 
 What we will never know is what price Ford will have to pay to get it to the top spot. 
 That's for the future. 
 What of the Escort/Orion today? 
 Seven months after Peter Robinson and I penned those damning words, have we cause to change our opinion? 
 Do the engines still lack refinement? 
 Are the seats still meagre, the gearchange notchy, the brake pedal spongy and the steering slow and vague? 
 Is the ride still inconsistent and the handling uninspiring at best and unwieldy at worst? 
 In seven months, has the &bquo;anti-driver's car&equo; grown into something more competitive? 
 ESCORT S 
 This side of the cabriolet, the new S is the one Escort that needs drivers on its side. 
 S is meant to stand for sporting but perhaps not too sporting, since both the RS2000 and Escort Cosworth are still to be put on sale. 
 The S was introduced at the end of January &mdash; and was thus not part of our driving story last August &mdash; but the ingredients are familiar enough. 
 The injected 108bhp 1.6-litre CVH engine, five-speed manual gearbox and three-door body are blended with uprated springs and dampers, 185/60 low-profile tyres and steel wheels with plastic trims and body changes that extend to a black rear spoiler and body colour bumper sections. 
 Plus there is an excellent range of luxury equipment as standard: power windows and mirrors (also heated), central locking, sunroof, heated front screen, heated washer jets, RDS stereo and sports steering wheel. 
 Impressive, but appropriate? 
 No, not by a long chalk. 
 I have thought long and hard about this, and even now hesitate before saying it. 
 I reckon you'd have to look long and hard through the history of the hot hatch to find a more unconvincing sporting package for your money &mdash; a hefty &pound;10,990 in standard form. 
 Add options and you are left with a total of &pound;13,190, which is the most ludicrously optimistic price I've heard for ages. 
 Bear in mind that, even for that amount, you get standard Escort seats, which don't locate the driver properly in an LX let alone the S. Neither do you get an adjustable steering column. 
 The extra goes on power steering (again, any Escort suffers badly without it), alloy wheels, anti-lock brakes, catalytic converter, body kit and a paint choice other than white or red. 
 The S that Ford chose to show off to the press was understandably a fully loaded one. 
 It was also very new, having covered just 774 miles &mdash; a key factor in the quality of any 1.6 CVH engine. 
 Even with so many miles under its belt the injected 108bhp engine is never truly competitively smooth and quiet, but this young engine was quite intolerable, its overall lack of refinement evident the moment you fired it up. 
 The mechanical harshness intrudes throughout the rev range, accompanied at low speeds by a bass exhaust which is the only sign of any sporting character, but not a very convincing one. 
 Nor is there anything remotely convincing about its performance; there is a feeling of some urgency from 4000rpm but the power stops as suddenly as it starts so that the 6500rpm red line is a merely a figment of someone's imagination. 
 The mechanical frenzy has to be experienced to be believed, accompanied in the test car by a horrible dashboard resonance in mid-range. 
 Ford claims 0&ndash;60mph in 9.8secs and a top speed of 116mph, so plainly your money can buy a lot more performance as well as refinement in a sporting hatchback. 
 Overall I thought the gearchange acceptable but, as with all models, with a very notchy feel and an unpleasant stickiness coming out of fifth. 
 Again, the opposition offers far slicker changes. 
 The brake pedal likewise; when fitted with anti-lock brakes, pedal response is woefully mushy. 
 True to current Ford form, there is no shortage of roadholding &mdash; but exploiting it is another matter. 
 A major culprit is the moulded seat, which simply doesn't locate the driver anywhere near positively enough to complement the fine grip from the Pirelli P600s. 
 We know that Rod Mansfield of Ford's SVE (now engineering director at Aston Martin) fought a battle to get decently shaped seats in the SVE-developed cabrio, and a huge difference to that car they make. 
 The S is crying out for them. 
 Word from Ford is that better seats are on their way this year. 
 The new S suspension works well. 
 It offers a firm, well-controlled ride that's a little noisy at low speed and thumps a bit over potholes, but it's far from bone-shaking. 
 But this good control, plus the fine grip and limited body roll, are badly let down in the driver appeal stakes by the steering. 
 The optional power system should be considered essential, if only to avoid the seriously slow (4.6 turns lock to lock, and vague with it) manual steering that's listed as standard. 
 In its favour, the power system is well weighted and geared, with a much more manageable three turns across the good turning circle. 
 This last point doesn't translate into ideal accuracy and agility, however, for apart from its detached feel it suffers a slow-motion response. 
 This makes the car feel tardy in quick manoeuvres and exacerbates the variable-ratio's less-than-linear response through fast sweepers. 
 Too often the car feels lurchy, with accurate placement largely a matter of guesswork. 
 Ford plainly has the experience, the people and the resources to put together a much better sporting hatch than this, even at the S's potentially appealing, and no doubt profitable, junior GTi level. 
 But this car has the hand of the marketing department all over it, not the engineers and certainly not SVE. 
 Against assorted sporting Peugeots, Volkswagens and Rovers, some of which cost less than the S depending on specification, Ford's newcomer wouldn't stand a ghost of a chance and you don't need a back-to-back group test to confirm it. 
 ESCORT 1.4 GLX 
 Fire up the 1.4 after any 1.6, even a well run-in example, and it's immediately plain that the smaller capacity, carburetted CVH is smoother and quieter, with noise, vibration and harshness levels that at least border on the acceptable. 
 A result is that despite the reduced power &mdash; 73bhp against 108 &mdash; the car gets along briskly enough without feeling quite so strained. 
 There are other anomalies with supposedly superior models, too. 
 The GLX I drove, again fully loaded with options including anti-lock brakes, had a firm brake pedal and Ford's cleverly adjusting steering column &mdash; two items the S could certainly do with. 
 But not the manual steering, which again has such an effect on the driving character of the car that it is impossible to overlook. 
 This is steering that manages the seemingly impossible: to be bad just about everywhere. 
 In town it requires vast amounts of arm-flailing lock but is never what you could call light. 
 In the country, it loads up and goes inert at the first sign of a corner. 
 There's no accurate communication through the rim, no sense of confidence in placing the car. 
 With the anti-roll bar up front, the car rolls less than it used to and has a jigglier low-speed ride, but it's true to say that on all models I drove the quality of ride was largely good. 
 But has the anti-roll bar sapped roadholding? 
 It felt like it in the GLX, with what can only be described as feeble front-end grip, resulting in premature and excessive understeer. 
 But bearing in mind the people Ford says the car is aimed at, the greatest surprise is just how cumbersome and unwieldy it feels on everyday journeys. 
 Some eastern European cars do it better. 
 ORION 1.6i GHIA 
 A fairly absorbent if sometimes rather bouncy ride, excellent driving position, fine equipment including a first-rate CD sound system, stronger-feeling bodyshell and good boot and cabin space allow the Orion to make a much more positive impression. 
 It is streets ahead of the cobbled-together old model. 
 You can find other good things too, even if it is only a matter of degrees. 
 Body roll is well contained, grip is strong (though not up to S levels) and there is a progressive feeling to the handling that the S lacks. 
 With these comfort-orientated suspension settings, the steering does a serviceable job, without the slight nervousness of the stiffer S. 
 At &pound;13,000 plus options (like the CD), this is, short of the cabrio, the Escort/Orion flagship &mdash; thank heavens it has as much going for it as it does. 
 The downside is a familiar one: notchy and sticky gearchange, mushy brake pedal, rough and vocal engine (this one had done 4000 miles yet would still not rev to the red line), wind noise at speed and, of course, the seats. 
 When the new seats arrive, the Ghia and the S will be the first to get them. 
 So, it's okay by the standards of the rest of the range, but what about when faced with the real world? 
 Again, you don't need a twin test to know that the gap in ability, build and luxury feel between the Orion and the Rover 416 is a substantial one. 
 ESCORT 1.6 GHIA ESTATE 
 Generally regarded as the best looker of the bunch, the estate has a lot more going for it besides. 
 Here is an attractive, well-packaged car in a market woefully short of contenders. 
 The Escort estate is guaranteed a following, and overall it will be deserved. 
 In Ghia form it's a well trimmed and equipped car, but more than this there's a dynamic cohesion to it: somewhere along the line someone got the handling, ride and steering working in harmony rather than against each other. 
 Undoubtedly a major factor here is the 5ins longer wheelbase and wider front and rear tracks. 
 For a load carrier, the ride is level and smooth when unladen. 
 Changing direction won't exactly bring out the Mansell in you but the power steering &mdash; in theory the same as that fitted to the others &mdash; reacts swiftly and smoothly, and understeer is significantly less than that of the 1.4 GLX. 
 There's not a world of difference between the carb 1.6 fitted to this estate and the injected version: 90bhp against 108 and no vast difference in refinement, which of course says far more about the injected engine. 
 So here, too, is a noisy engine, but in this application its workmanlike character is not inappropriate. 
 The test car I drove had a serious wind noise problem, which will not be the first time Ford has heard that about the Escort, but it otherwise came across as well conceived &mdash; it's easy to load and has a completely flat floor with rear seats folded &mdash; and competent. 
 Even likeable. 
 ESCORT CABRIO 
 The top of the range, &pound;15,290 convertible certainly has a likeable side, as our road test has already made plain. 
 Driving it again, alongside the rest of the range, this is immediately, but somewhat intangibly, the nicest Escort to drive, with by no means all the attraction being to do with the convertible top, itself an extremely effective design. 
 It's said the engine is the same as any injected 1.6 but in this car it feels torquier, much smoother, more eager and quieter, though this could be as a result of top-down wind roar. 
 But even that's far from unacceptable. 
 In short, it could be a different engine &mdash; until you go in search of the red line, when things still get frenetic. 
 Even against the estate, the ride/handling/steering/braking package is by far the most convincing, as you would expect given SVE's involvement. 
 It's not an easy one to get right either, with the greatly different torsional character of a convertible. 
 Certainly here is the only Escort variant with a degree of throttle steering available; a responsive  chassis. 
 And this, along with a firm, well-damped ride and &mdash; hooray hooray! &mdash; properly shaped seats, means a driving experience of vastly different character from the others. 
 It's far from fast and there is some body shake over very rough roads. 
 There again, I would say that top down in this country it is fast enough, and what shake there is certainly is not accompanied by any rattles or &bquo;looseness&equo;. 
 It grips strongly, steers reliably and the brakes have bite. 
 You could have fun in this car. 
 Seven months on, how I wish the same could be said for the rest. 
 Seven months on, how I wish I could say that the Escort/Orion range is at least going in the right direction . 
 My feeling now after driving them all again is that the direction, the aspirations of the range, are as middle of the road as ever. 
 Seven months on, Ford people are admitting as much, just as the clever among them are no longer feigning surprise at our conclusions. 
 The question now is, what will they do to improve matters?  
 Top: Escort and Orion line-up &mdash; not all came at once as Ford promised. 
 Left: Escort S is sporty but unconvincing, and far too expensive when fully loaded 
 The S feels to have the stamp of Ford's marketing, rather than engineering, department on it. 
 Against its rivals in a comparison test, it wouldn't stand a chance 
 Orion 1.6i Ghia offers fine equipment level, including a first-rate CD sound system. 
 When the improved seats arrive, the Ghia, along with the S, will get them first 
 Cabrio is the nicest model to drive &mdash; engine seems quieter and more eager here and the seats are well shaped. 
 Soft-top is simple and effective. 
 You could have fun in this car 
 Right: the 1.4-litre carburetted CVH engine in the GLX is quieter and smoother than any in the 1.6 range. 
 Car rolls less than it used to but roadholding seems to have suffered 
 THE GREAT CONCEPT  CARS 
 THE DAWN OF THE DINO 
 Few concept cars have proved as significant and trend-setting as Pininfarina's Dino Berlinetta Speciale, introduced to universal acclaim at the 1965 Paris motor show. 
 Luca Ciferri remembers the car that presaged the immortal Ferrari Dino and which still influences the design of today's sports cars 
 How do you imagine a contemporary Ferrari road car? 
 Painted red, of course, with sinuous front wings that curve above the wheelarches, a recessed bonnet, a short roof tapering into a long, descending C-pillar and a vast engine cover terminating with a flat rear. 
 And you can't fail but to think of the air intakes starting in the rear part of the door and merging into the rear wing, whether they're straked, like the Testarossa's and 348's, or finely sculpted like the 328's. 
 These are the design clues that spell &bquo;Ferrari&equo; to the countless thousands of sports enthusiasts around the world. 
 And all are derived from one Pininfarina concept car &mdash; the Dino Berlinetta Speciale &mdash; which made its debut more than a quarter of a century ago at the 1965 Paris show. 
 &bquo;This prototype occupies a special place in Pininfarina history.&equo; 
 Those are the words of Lorenzo Ramaciotti, Pininfarina's chief designer. 
 &bquo;Due to a series of fortuitous circumstances it embodies unique aesthetic, technical and even sentimental values. 
 It was the official debut of the Dino family on the show circuit and Maranello's first mid-engined car not conceived exclusively for racing. 
 The mechanicals were taken from a race car, the Dino 206P, which competed in the European hillclimb championship (a prestigious series in the 60s) but the bodywork, despite its motor show boldness, previewed a road car application. 
 And it was the first public result attributable to the second generation at Pininfarina, Pinin's son Sergio and his brother-in-law, Renzo Carli.&equo; 
 Sergio Pininfarina himself takes up the story behind this amazing concept car. 
 &bquo;At the Paris show in 1965 we started the complete story of the Pininfarina-designed mid-engined V6 Dinos and V8 Ferraris. 
 The Dino Berlinetta Speciale was the first; the 348tb is the most recent.&equo; 
 But what were the revolutionary contents of the Speciale? 
 Today, it still looks interesting but far from being a perfectly balanced shape. 
 &bquo;It was a sharp break with tradition,&equo; explains Ramaciotti, &bquo;without throwing the design rule book completely out of the window. 
 &bquo;For years we had been trying to lower and streamline the bonnets of front-engined cars and the mid-engined configuration allowed us to obtain an extremely low nose, deeply recessed between sculpted front wings that sloped down to the headlights, which were contained in a plexiglass fairing to continue the line. 
 The air intake scoops, destined to become a typical Ferrari feature, appeared on the doors and rear wings, crossed by a chrome bar which acted as the door handle. 
 The idea, one that's been adopted many times since, was to &bquo;camouflage&equo; the door handle so it didn't interfere with the body lines. 
 &bquo;To balance the sizeable front wings, the sweep of the rear wings was slightly marked on the flanks. 
 The car had an extremely small glasshouse with a sharply raked wraparound windscreen and a minute roof. 
 The engine compartment had to be outside the cockpit for acoustic and thermal insulation so we introduced a vertical backlight for good rear visibility and blended it into the fins sloping down from the roof, which gave a certain lightness to the rear pillars, This solution has become a constant feature on all Pininfarina Ferraris up to the Testarossa. 
 &bquo;The rear was characterised by slightly excessive overhang &mdash; needed to accommodate the spare wheel and gearbox &mdash; terminating in a slightly recessed, clipped surface that reiterated the current thinking of Ferrari competition cars, enriched by the shaped light clusters and fine louvres. 
 The interior, austere and functional, refined the colour scheme and the instrumentation of the racing Dinos without loading it down with unwanted bric-a-brac.&equo; 
 Ramaciotti is not just one of Europe's finest car designers (the stunning Mythos concept car was the result of his boyhood dreams) but he is also considered one of the best analysts of design in the business. 
 His words explain clearly where the Dino Berlinetta Speciale was radically different to the established exotic car shapes of the mid '60s. 
 At that time Ferrari was still producing the somewhat bland (by comparison) 330GT, the 500 Superfast and the 275GTB/GTS. 
 Lamborghini was still at the 350GT stage, the Miura was to come later. 
 And Porsche was launching a new generation of rear-engined sports cars &mdash; the 911. 
 Sergio Pininfarina has no doubts about the significance of the Dino Berlinetta Speciale. 
 &bquo;It was more that just successful,&equo; he says today, looking back on what many consider his finest work. 
 &bquo;It was a genuine trend-setter. 
 We were able to lower the nose to improve visibility and to reduce the height of the whole car because we no longer had to worry about having the exhaust pipes running under the passenger compartment. 
 This allowed us to revolutionise the balance of height and width. 
 But the mid-engined layout did give us all kinds of new problems; rear visibility, thermal and acoustic insulation of the passenger compartment, engine ventilation. 
 Sometimes the necessity to solve technical problems obliges you to rethink a project starting from a completely new point. 
 Faced with these challenges we almost had  to come up with something that broke with the past. 
 &bquo;When my father, six months before his death, saw the car for the first time at the Paris show &mdash; where he decided to go even though his health was not good &mdash; he fell in love with it immediately. 
 &bquo;This car is like my nephew,&equo; he said, &bquo;because it is the daughter of my sons.&equo; 
 &bquo;We, the second generation of Pininfarina, had given him great joy and pride. 
 I think the Dino Berlinetta Speciale, together with the Cisitalia my father created in 1947, are the Pininfarina cars that represented the most significant milestones in car design.&equo; 
 Today, the Dino Berlinetta Speciale remains a fascinating design, aggressive without being just a road-going version of a racing Ferrari and rich in class and atmosphere like all the outstanding Pininfarina designs. 
 The front wings, softly moulded to follow the profile of the large wheels, still looks terrific. 
 The boxed-off tail is now considered a fairly standard feature but it was a daring innovation in the mid-60s. 
 The sole Dino Berlinetta Speciale is now part of the permanent collection of the Le Mans car museum in France, a fitting place for a car that drew its design inspiration from the first mid-engined Ferrari sports racing cars and which shocked the world at Paris more than a quarter of a century ago.  
 Don't be fooled by the Bertone reflection on the bonnet; the Dino Berlinetta Speciale was unmistakeably a Pininfarina car 
 Dino creator Sergio Pininfarina (left), son of company founder Battista (right) 
 Above: second of the Dinos, the Berlinetta GT of 1966. 
 Below: preliminary sketches, final show version in top left corner 
 Unlike many contemporary concept cars, the Dino was eminently practical, even featuring a full-size spare wheel 
 FATHER OF THE FAMILY 
 Virtually every mid-engined Ferrari built since the mid '60s &mdash; from the original 206 Dino to the awesome F40 &mdash; owes its inspiration to the Dino Berlinetta Speciale concept car 
 The seed was sown in Paris but it was two years later, in Turin, when the first production car, the Dino 206GT, was introduced. 
 There was also an intermediate step &mdash; the Dino Berlinetta GT of 1966 &mdash; but this was never intended to go into full production. 
 The feeling of the original concept survived in these two evolutions but the more provocative of the original features were toned down and more integrated. 
 The front wings were less exaggerated, the rear overhang shorter and the tail a little taller. 
 The glass surfaces became more important, especially in side view, giving the production car a more balanced feel. 
 The air intake scoops took their final shape; the chrome trim that divided it longitudinally in the first two cars was finally eliminated. 
 The headlamps became two circular projectors housed in the wings and covered by plexiglass shells. 
 Proof positive of the enduring shape of the design came in 1969 when the original two-litre V6 was replaced by a 2.4-litre unit, the model designation changing to 246 as a result. 
 The only styling change was to the headlamps with the plexiglass shells removed. 
 Three years later came the 246GTS, the targa version, which looked substantially different because the elimination of the roof meant a strong roll bar had to be housed behind the seats. 
 The second window disappeared and the metal surface that took its place was optically softened by a group of three small air intakes. 
 At the 1975 Paris show, exactly 10 years after the Dino Berlinetta Speciale was unveiled, the 308GTB, the most successful Ferrari ever, made its debut. 
 It was a logical evolution of the Dino family but the adoption of the three-litre V8 engine in place of the V6 meant the end of the Dino name, although it features on Pininfarina's original styling model of the 308. 
 In the 308 the side view became more balanced to reflect the increased importance of the rear end with its new engine. 
 A long, sleek C-pillar gave the car a more muscular look and the side scoops became bigger and wider. 
 The front end, continually revised in the Dino range, was tidied up again, this time with pop-up headlamps, deleting the sole styling detail that dated back to the late '50s and early '60s. 
 Several version of the 308 were produced, including the GTS targa version and the 1977 Coupe Speciale Pininfarina &mdash; a study to improve aerodynamics which also housed wider tyres under enlarged aluminium wings. 
 In 1982 Ferrari launched the 208 Turbo (made mainly for the Italian market and powered by a two-litre turbocharged V8) and, more recently have come the ultimate developments of the original theme &mdash; the 288GTO and the F40. 
 The GTO, conceived to revive memories of one of Maranello's greatest cars, the 1962 250GTO, was, from a design point of view, the Coupe Speciale Pininfarina painted Ferrari red. 
 Only the rear pillar changed, having an external cover that lifted from the rear window surface to create a big air intake in order to ventilate the engine compartment, made extremely hot by the addition of the turbo. 
 Even the F40 shows a distinct family resemblance, although the lines were sharpened and simplified. 
 But all these great Ferraris grew out of one concept car, the Dino Berlinetta Speciale. 
 Look at the new 348 and try to imagine, step by step, year after year, how you should update the design features of the Berlinetta Speciale to make it more contemporary. 
 It's a fair bet you would end up with something very close to the 348. 
 &bquo;It's a process that's very simple to explain when it's done,&equo; smiles Ramaciotti, &bquo;but extremely difficult to achieve.&equo;  
 Production Dinos on display, targa GTS in the foreground (above left) 
 Ferrari F40, the ultimate development of the Dino theme; elegant 308 (below) 
 RIVALS AND CONTEMPORARIES 
 Before the Berlinetta Speciale most sports cars still had the engine in the front. 
 Things would never be the same again 
 If you were looking to buy a high-performance sports car in 1965, what would you have chosen? 
 The mid '60s were a turning point in sports car design, marking the virtual end of the front-engined sports cars in place of the new mid-engined models of which the Dino Berlinetta Speciale was one of the pioneers. 
 Until Pininfarina revealed his masterpiece, Ferrari was sticking resolutely with front-engined cars of which the most interesting was the 275GTB/GTS, although it didn't feature the most exciting shape. 
 The best-looking Ferrari of that era was the 250LM, the competition car that dominated long distance sports car racing until the arrival of the Ford GT40. 
 The 250LM demonstrated conclusively that the mid-engined configuration was the way ahead. 
 Lamborghini was still producing the 350GT, an interesting car technically but not in the front line of design innovation. 
 The revolutionary mid-engined (and transversely-mounted) Miura was yet to come and didn't make its debut until the Turin show of 1966. 
 Maserati was still producing the elegant, but already old-fashioned, Sebring, introduced in 1963 and, in 1966, produced the Ghibli, perhaps the final swan-song of the classic front-engined two-plus-twos. 
 De Tomaso's Vallelunga deserves the same remark as the Lamborghini 350GT &mdash; good mechanicals, insignificant shape. 
 The mid-engined Maserati was in the pipeline but still one year away. 
 At the same time there were rumbles of revolution at Porsche. 
 The 356 series was about to die and in its stead was coming the 911. 
 For Porsche, the 911 holds the same place as the Dino Berlinetta Speciale does for Ferrari &mdash; a marvellous design that could be continually updated and evolved. 
 US design was offering the evergreen Chevrolet Corvette but the most interesting car coming out of the US &mdash; via Britain&mdash; was the Ford GT40, originally a Lola design. 
 Both Nuccio Bertone and Marcello Gandini honestly admit the influence of the GT40 on the Lamborghini Miura. 
 Racing car design was fundamental to the most advanced road cars of the mid '60s. 
 Never before and, perhaps not until the Group C inspired supercars of the late '80s and early '90a have race and road car design been so closely linked.  
 Lamborghini Miura, Maserati Ghibli and designers Gandini and Giugiaro 
 Ford GT40 and Porsche 911 
 Master stroke 
 Lusty performance and razor-sharp handling are hallmarks of the Golf G60 Limited, a VW Motorsport special that rolls all of VW's best bits into one package. 
 Mark Harrop is impressed 
 Volkswagen has made 70 people very happy. 
 That's the number of lucky motorists the Wolfsburg manufacturer has equipped with the Golf G60 Limited, a car that was the subject of over 1000 enquiries when it was announced to dealers in Germany last year but only had a production run of 70. 
 Conceived as a challenge for VW's increasingly active motorsport division, it is a car whose sum is even greater than its parts. 
 And that's a particularly praiseworthy feat when you consider the set of parts the Limited boasts. 
 From the VW stock cupboard have come such mouthwatering delights as the suspension and gearbox from the Group A Rallye Golf, the four-wheel drive system from the Syncro and a supercharger for VW's well-known 16-valve 1.8-litre engine. 
 In this guise, a Limited driver will discover 210bhp beneath his right foot &mdash; enough to make this the fastest production Volkswagen ever &mdash; and, thanks to the clever syncro system, more than ample traction to make use of it. 
 What you will really love, though, is the buckets of low-down torque that the G-lader blower and intercooler create. 
 Not for you the deathly quiet below 4000rpm of normal 16-valves, or the back-busting thrust of a turbocharger. 
 Instead, from as low as 1000rpm you can bury your foot in the firewall and watch the front of the car gobble up ever larger amounts of tarmac. 
 The Limited gathers speed like a snowball down a hill and will continue to pump you faster and faster towards the horizon, reaching its peak power in each gear just 300rpm short of the engine's 6800rpm red line. 
 In a straight line, admittedly, the Limited doesn't quite set your pulse on fire like an Integrale 16v; subjectively, the Lancia's 200bhp two-litre unit seems to provide much more firepower. 
 Sure enough, at the track the computer reveals that the Delta breaks the 0&ndash;60mph barrier in 6.3secs, half a second quicker than the Golf. 
 At the quarter-mile post the Limited is only 0.3secs shy of the Integrale's 14.9secs, but the VW's better aerodynamics and 20.9mph per 100rpm gearing in fifth allow it to fly to an impressive 139mph top speed and leave the Lancia flailing in its wake. 
 There's even more ammunition for the Limited driver to unload in the performance-over-a-pint discussion at the local pub. 
 The car's tremendous torque proves invaluable when it comes to overtaking; it leaps the fourth-gear 30&ndash;50mph increment in just 6.5secs. 
 That's well over a second quicker than the Integrale, just under a second in front of Ford's Sapphire Cosworth 4x4 and neck and neck with BMW's masterful M5. 
 The Golf is certainly man enough to rub shoulders with some pretty demanding company. 
 Show these cars a twisty, wet A-road, though, and the Limited transforms from man to He-man. 
 It'd be a brave person who would be against the Golf romping out the other end in front. 
 The Limited's ability to stick to the tarmac, or, more importantly, the areas of tarmac you've  chosen, is simply awesome. 
 Barrel into a tight corner, clip the apex with your foot planted to the floor and the Golf will attack the exit with almost indecent haste and staggering security. 
 Better still in these wet spring months, a liberal dousing of rain will do little to affect the Limited's progress. 
 The key to exploiting the car's handling prowess is to keep on the gas. 
 That way the syncro system will be pumping power to all four bits of rubber as you throw yourself into corners with all the wild confidence of a kiddie in a bouncy castle. 
 Enter the same bend with a trailing throttle, however, and the story is quite different &mdash; the syncro system reverts to supplying only the front wheels as in normal driving. 
 Push towards the limits of the tyres' adhesion, though, and you provoke little more than mild understeer and a screech of protest from the Continental Sport Contact 195/50 VR15 rubber. 
 Only on a long, fast bend can the tail be persuaded to step out, and then only under strong provocation and with little drama, as the drivetrain begins to feed the power rearwards. 
 This level of ability is matched by the performance of the brakes. 
 With anti-lock as standard, they respond smoothly and effectively to instruction and show no signs of fade during repeated hard stopping. 
 From the command centre, it is only the steering's tendency to provide a slightly blurred picture of events at the front wheels that interrupts an otherwise masterful flow of information. 
 But when you consider this in the context of its well-weighted precision and speed, it gives little cause for complaint. 
 The five-speed gearbox, borrowed from the Passat, is less inspiring. 
 Stirring the cogs quickly is hindered by a notchy change, and a quick second to third change will easily beat the synchromesh. 
 Pick your slots with care, however, and tread carefully on the throttle and you can move swiftly through the ratios, making the most of the lusty engine. 
 For a car with such razor-sharp handling, the Limited's ability to keep the lumps and bumps of the road away from the car's occupants is surprisingly good. 
 Its only weak spot is in coping with bigger potholes, which send a jarring crash through the bodyshell. 
 Overall, though, the Limited probably rides as well as, if not better than, a Golf GTi. 
 Inside the cabin, the Golf is now looking fairly outdated but the instruments are still easy to use and effective, four adults can be carried in reasonable comfort and the huge boot will swallow more than enough for a weekend away. 
 You also get black leather upholstery, electric windows all round, sunroof, central locking, stylish gunmetal grey paint and attractive BBS spoked alloy wheels. 
 These last items are the only giveaway to the car's ferocious ability. 
 It would otherwise pass for a much more lowly Golf and is the antithesis of the fire-breathing extravagance of the Integrale 16v &mdash; very handy when it comes to the boys in blue. 
 The Limited's Q-car appeal and superb under-the-skin dynamism proves to be an irresistible combination. 
 The 26-valve GTi pales into insignificance against this car and it's difficult to see how the three-door Rallye road car could convincingly better this Golf stablemate. 
 In the wake of the Rallye's poor showing on the world rally circuit, the Limited's success will be something of a boost to VW's Motorsport division. 
 What's more, this car will certainly not be the last hot road car development to roll out of the factory. 
 Just for starters there is the Corrado, the forthcoming MkIII Golf, the G40 Polo and the new VR6 engine to play with. 
 If the outstanding quality of the Limited is any guide, the Motorsport team is going to be bringing many more smiles to people's faces. 
 Figures taken at 7744 miles by our own staff at the Lotus group proving ground, Millbrook. 
 All Autocar &amp; Motor  test results are subject to world copyright and may not be reproduced without the editor's written permission.  
 Blown 16v engine is terrifically torquey 
 VW Motorsport's badging is discreet 
 Limited is left-hand drive, take it or leave it. 
 Leather is part of the up-spec package 
 Handling is flawless and grip staggering; 4wd system rewards press-on driving 
 ANGRY YOUNG MAN 
 Shaun Campbell 
 &bquo;We talked about fun and cars when I was beginning to think they were no longer synonymous&equo; 
 You didn't have to be an angry young man to look around the car industry over the past few weeks and despair of ever hearing any good news. 
 Everywhere you looked, the world of cars seemed to be touching upon affairs of great import. 
 And they were universally depressing. 
 I was thinking about his while stuck in a traffic jam the other day. 
 There's nothing unusual about clogged up roads in London, but this was the school half-term holidays &mdash; usually a haven of relatively clear tarmac, a glorious window of opportunity to leave home for the office a quarter of an hour later. 
 No anxious mums watching the clock, no tearaway teachers in a hurry, no fractious dinner ladies with their minds on lumpy custard. 
 But this particular traffic jam wasn't caused by a Scania shedding its load, sewer repairs or slight confusion about exactly which way one should negotiate the Wandsworth one-way system. 
 It was caused by the IRA, which had chosen that week to leave a couple of bombs on British Rail mainline stations. 
 With no trains running, people turned to their cars and you can hardly blame them. 
 Now, I'd rather be sitting in a car than standing on a crowded platform, but there wasn't much in the way of light relief on the radio. 
 Oil, that most precious of natural resources, the stuff which makes the wheels of industry turn, was at that moment being set ablaze to pollute the skies or pumped into the Gulf to pollute the seas. 
 For reasons best known to the fuel companies, the Gulf crisis never turned into an oil crisis, although petrol prices generally leap up and down quicker than a Tory backbencher during a Neil Kinnock speech if a dealer on the Amsterdam spot market so much as sneezes over his computer screen. 
 But you couldn't feel smug about filling up your tank with unleaded while all that was going on. 
 If you turned to domestic politics, the news was no better. 
 It was all economic recession, bankruptcies and lay-offs, words which disguise the hundreds, perhaps thousands, of personal tragedies of unemployment and dashed hopes. 
 Far too many of these were in the motor industry. 
 If you're the sort of person who thinks that Parliamentary democracy is a reasonably important thing, you couldn't take much pleasure from the findings of the enquiry into the way Rover was sold off. 
 The pragmatists will point out that Rover still exists, that it's in (mainly) British hands and that the current generation of new Rovers is the best in living memory. 
 But, if that's the case, why was the deal handled in such a sly and back-handed manner? 
 And by a minister who was never elected? 
 In the midst of this unrelenting wave of depression, I found myself, dressed in a borrowed dinner jacket, on the M11 headed for Cambridge, where I was about to make my first (and last) appearance as an after-dinner speaker. 
 The Cambridge University Automobile Club had clearly fallen on hard times, too. 
 I was intimidated by the whole idea of Cambridge. 
 Everybody I met would surely be either fabulously wealthy, extremely intelligent or both. 
 When I was at university (actually a rather seedy teacher training college in south-east London) nobody could afford to run a car. 
 One's grant disappeared into a bottomless sea of cigarettes and beer with hardly enough left over for the books we were meant to read. 
 But it wasn't like I'd imagined &mdash; except for the long silences when I'd been hoping for laughs. 
 They didn't drive around in their fathers' cast-off Rollers; they pooled their resources, picked up a MkII escort for a hundred notes at an auction and took it in turns to drive it round a disused airfield practising handbrake turns until the car cried enough. 
 They organised 12-car rallies around the Cambridge Fens, asking every local resident for permission to hold the event and then, when the snow caused the event to be called off, they did the same thing again. 
 And when the nightmare of the after-dinner speech was over, we went to the bar and had a proper conversation about cars. 
 Like, how do you get maximum performance for minimum money? 
 You buy an old Alfasud, that's how. 
 Or possibly a clapped-out Lancia Delta. 
 Some of them argued the merits of various French cars. 
 One student had a Citroen Visa, which I immediately assumed was the GTi version &mdash; Peugeot 205 kit in a Peugeot 104 chassis &mdash; and the sort of lukewarm hatch I can just about afford now. 
 The student in question put me straight by pointing out it was a Visa 10E he was running. 
 We talked about Hillman Avengers, 850cc Minis that screamed for help at speeds above 60mph and the importance of remembering that the Alfasud's handbrake operates the front, rather than the rear wheels. 
 We talked about how fast you can make a 1.1 MkII Escort run when it's only firing on three cylinders and how to make it run on three cylinders when it wants to run on just two. 
 We talked about what a bitch of a job it is to change a radiator on a Mini. 
 We talked about how Morris Marinas make the wrong noises, Fiat Stradas make the right noises and Triumph Heralds that make no noise at all because the big end is buggered. 
 We talked about having some fun with cars at a time when I was beginning to think the two were no longer synonymous. 
 This wasn't a bunch of Hooray Henrys with more money than sense. 
 Some were deadly serious about working in the car industry. 
 One was about to start work in the engineering department of Rover and was already cute enough to know what you should and shouldn't say to a journalist, especially when it comes to forthcoming developments of the K-series engine. 
 Another was hopeful of joining Ford &mdash; he took me to task for this magazine's criticisms of the new Escort. 
 And a third, whose immaculate dinner jacket couldn't conceal hands scarred and stained from rebuilding a Mini Cooper, wanted to become the world's first professional classic rally driver. 
 I hope he makes it. 
 They advised me of the best route to take home &mdash; and by the best they meant the most fun, not the quickest. 
 Roads with unexpected humpback bridges, tightening-radius corners and reasonably free of police and radar traps. 
 And they made it clear that I was extremely fortunate to be doing the job I do. 
 They're right, of course. 
 Journalism often means long hours but it's better than working. 
 And angry young men are just older men who haven't grown up and can only see one side of the coin.  
 The true face of motoring, Cambridge University style: checking out tired old motors at auctions 
 RUNNING REPORT 
 FRENCH BREED 
 Renault's Clio is a big hit in France, but will the Brits buy it? 
 Mark Bishop is running one 
 The Renault Clio won the 1991 European Car of the Year award last November. 
 At the time it was not available in the UK, and its critical acclaim came mainly from Continental motoring journalists. 
 Is the Clio a pan-European standards-setter in the supermini class, or does its Gallic charm lose its appeal this side of the Channel? 
 I'm running one on our long-term fleet to see. 
 Renault plans to target the 1.4 RT version at long-distance travellers, reckoning that its spacious interior, high equipment and trim levels and supple ride will enable the top-spec Clio to rival bigger cars for commuting. 
 As someone who lives just outside Brighton and commutes to Autocar &amp; Motor  's office on the outskirts of Teddington, West London, it's fitting that I should be the Clio's new keeper. 
 My journey should also ensure that the Clio clocks up the miles quickly, helping readers to gauge the French supermini's durability. 
 For, as Renault itself has admitted (&bquo;Three men and a car company&equo;, Autocar &amp; Motor , 20 February) the French maker's reputation for quality was a tad patchy before the 19 was introduced two years ago. 
 H375 DRV arrived on a cold, wet night, and my first impression was of the prodigious efficacy of the three-speed heater/demister. 
 I doubt that many cars &mdash; except, perhaps, for James May's Fiesta RS Turbo, which has a heated front screen &mdash; could have dispatched windscreen condensation any quicker. 
 Scanning the interior, I was impressed by the high quality of the trim and dash. 
 But where was all the switchgear? 
 The column stalks are fine: indicators, lights and horn on the left, wipers on the right. 
 But the hazard warnings, rear fog lights and rear screen demister are an arm's length away, obscured by the steering wheel, while the switch for the front fogs is hidden above my right knee. 
 The pedals, too, seem to have been located by someone who has yet to discover the science of ergonomics. 
 While the steering wheel is offset to the left, the pedals are positioned to the right. 
 The brake and clutch are too close together for my modest size sevens, and there's a huge foot-rest where I would normally expect a clutch pedal. 
 These grumbles aside, the Clio is an easily driven, user-friendly car. 
 It has started first time without exception so far, and pulls smoothly when cold. 
 The steering is light &mdash; although at almost four turns lock-to-lock, wheel-twirling can be a chore in town. 
 The clutch is light and progressive, and brakes are firm and the gearbox is quick and efficient. 
 My previous car was a direct competitor to the Clio, namely the new Rover Metro in 1.4-litre guise, and I can't help making comparisons. 
 The biggest area where the Renault scores is comfort and equipment. 
 I find the seats just as comfortable as the highly acclaimed Rover items, while rear passengers enjoy greater legroom. 
 For the same price &mdash; around nine grand &mdash; standard equipment is better, including remote-control central locking and a sunroof. 
 Renault is right about the Clio's ride. 
 It's superb. 
 Not even the yawning chasms in the road caused by freeze-thaw action during the recent cold spell can upset it. 
 The Metro set the class standard in this area; the Clio narrowly surpasses it, thanks to its longer wheelbase. 
 Noise levels are low at motorway speeds &mdash; the result of a class-leading 0.32 drag coefficient, narrow 165/65 R13 tyres and a fairly high fifth gear. 
 So, as a relaxing small car for long-distance cruising, it's great. 
 Trouble is, I still wonder whether it's going to be a match for the Metro because so far one thing seems to be missing &mdash; fun. 
 The engine may be  be  smooth, refined and flexible in its mid-range, but for a cross-country sprint it's asthmatic. 
 Peak power is delivered at 5750rpm, well into the &bquo;warning zone&equo; and only 750rpm short of the point where the rev-limiter cuts in. 
 Not that many drivers will want to push it that far; beyond 4000rpm the 1.4 Energy unit is distinctly thrashy. 
 Despite anti-roll bars front and rear the Clio leans quickly in bends, and by Renault standards the steering is low geared and not as communicative as the Renault 5's. 
 There's not the character or eagerness of that car, or indeed the Metro. 
 In a sense, such comparisons are unfair. 
 The Renault does not claim to be sporty; rather, it is a refined, comfortable cruiser. 
 Certainly it's one small car which I can drive for several hours at a stretch and step out feeling refreshed. 
 It's also stunningly economical. 
 With a long journey ahead of me every morning and evening, I don't hang about, and this is the first petrol-engined car I've used that has given me over 45mpg on a run. 
 I've also fallen in love with the stereo. 
 Renault is working hard to improve the quality of its products, and I must say the panel fit and finish on H375 DRV impress me. 
 Our black-and-white picture does not really do justice to its chameleon-like metallic paintwork, which seems to appear as green, silver or blue according to the light. 
 In fact, says Renault, it's Emerald Green. 
 The Clio reaches us in perfect condition, excepting a few scuffs on the steel wheel trims. 
 At the time of going to press, Renault UK had yet to agree prices with France for the Clio range. 
 But if an interim price guide the company's press office supplied us with proves accurate, our 1.4RT is very keenly priced for its high specification and impressive build quality, at around &pound;8650. 
 DATABASE 
 Market Update 
 Prices of the Citroen AX and BX were increased from the end of February by an average of 3.5 per cent. 
 The entry-level AX, the 10E three-door, is now &pound;5550 (up &pound;60), with the TGE and TGD models getting a radio/cassette as part of the standard equipment. 
 The budget BX 14TE has been dropped from the lists, but the &pound;8390 BX St Tropez fills the gap at the bottom of the range. 
 Seat UK's strategic move away from advertising its cars as cheap and cheerful, and towards the &bquo;quality driven consumer&equo;, hasn't prevented the Spanish manufacturer from continuing to launch ultra-cheap models on to the market. 
 The latest is the Ibiza 900 Designer, priced at &pound;5199 in three-door form, or &pound;5487 for the five-door. 
 Rover has introduced yet another special-edition Mini. 
 The latest, the &bquo;Nordic Blue metallic&equo; Neon, is based on the City with the addition of inevitable graphics, plus chrome bumpers and door handles. 
 The Neon also gets full-width wheel trims, passenger door mirror and opening rear quarterlights, while inside there's velour trim and a better stereo. 
 The price is &pound;5570, &pound;575 more than the City. 
 Ford has made an attempt to plug the gap left by the XR3i in its time-honoured fashion of producing an interim S-specification Escort. 
 The new model gets sports suspension, 185/60x14 tyres and XR3i engine. 
 Equipment includes power front windows, heated windscreen and washers, electric mirrors, sunroof, velour interior and sports steering wheel. 
 The cost is &pound;10,990. 
 Vauxhall can be expected to start a flurry of limited-edition Astras in the lead-up to the new model's launch in September. 
 First to come is the Expression, based on the hatchback Merit in either metallic blue or pearlescent red. 
 It gets the 1.4-litre engine, five-speed gearbox, cross-spoke alloys and a sunroof. 
 Inside there's a unique cloth trim. 
 Price is &pound;9060, or &pound;9370 for the five-door. 
 Peter Burgess  
 Astra Expression: first of many? 
 How Fast, How Good 
 IMPORTANT INFORMATION: 
 This is how the Autocar &amp; Motor  How Fast, How Good data has been derived: 30&ndash;70mph indicates overtaking ability and is measured in top gear (or fourth in the case of five-speed manual gearboxes); 50&ndash;70mph is recorded in top. 
 Overall consumption is that recorded during the test period, while touring mpg is based on official Government economy figures &mdash; 50 per cent of urban cycle, plus 25 per cent each of 56mph and 75mph steady speed cycles. 
 Reprinting of results, in whole or in part, is forbidden except by permission of the publisher. 
 &bull; Denotes models no longer on sale in the form tested 
 Commercialism and Violence 
 IT is becoming commonplace to think of sport as a &bquo;leisure industry&equo;. 
 In recent years there have certainly been dramatic moves to open sport up to the forces of the market. 
 The maximum wage and the retain-and-transfer system in football, and the distinction between gentlemen and players in cricket has been scrapped. 
 Tennis also abandoned the amateur and professional labels and simply called all competitors &bquo;players&equo; from 1967. 
 Most recently a change of heart on the part of the athletics authorities now enables Top competitors To earn very large sums which are held in &bquo;trust funds&equo;. 
 This technicality permits athletes to remain &bquo;amateurs&equo;. 
 Only Rugby Union holds out against the commercial tide despite widespread speculation about covert payments to players. 
 Cricket, The game of the British amateur par excellence , is now sponsored by tobacco firms and insurance companies whilst footballers advertise everything from double-glazing to Guinness on their shirts. 
 The football League was recently sponsored by a Japanese camera manufacturer whose name had to be repeated when publishing or broadcasting results. 
 A newspaper and now a bank have since taken over. 
 In return for media coverage and the &bquo;clean&equo; image of sport, sponsors are prepared to provide big injections of cash. 
 This new rush to make profits from sport provides a contemporary context against which to measure the earlier degree of commercialization. 
 To what extent were large profits made from spectator sports and what kind of earnings and working conditions could a professional sportsman expect? 
 What role have newspapers, the radio, and television played in sport? 
 This leads us to the composition and behaviour of sports crowds, especially at football matches and the current debate about the reasons for hooliganism. 
 How far are money and the media responsible for the misbehaviour of football supporters? 
 Or is aggression leading to violence endemic in sport and sports spectators? competent, phlegmatic Englishman reading the Oxford Book of Greek Verse  while organizing supplies and technical support with a minimum of fuss. 
 There was still hope for Britain if the old qualities of stoicism and the knack of handling &bquo;native&equo; races could be combined with the scientific and management skills needed in the modern world. 
 Another sporting triumph followed hard upon the conquest of Everest and gave added reassurance to the nation, especially those steeped in the amateur spirit for whom the demolition of English professional football by Puskas and the Hungarians was not a matter for much regret. 
 On 6 May 1954 at the small Iffley Road stadium in Oxford, Roger Bannister, a medical student at the University, broke The four-minute mile with the help of a couple of friends, Chris Brasher and Christopher Chataway. 
 Despite the apparent informality of the occasion, this was no glorious undergraduate fluke. 
 The sub-four-minute mile was a superbly planned and executed achievement. 
 The record was broken by scientific training and pacing in which two first-class athletes sacrificed themselves to permit Bannister to break the record. 
 A blend of the old virtues and the new, which the public seemed to understand and appreciate, united these two very different achievements. 
 Bannister and Hunt gave the English hope for the future within the British Isles and more importantly in the wider post-imperial world. 
 Not since a bony young Yorkshireman, Len Hutton, batted into a third day in August 1938 against Bradman's Australia to pass the Don's record score for a test match had the British known such transcendent moments of self-belief through sport. 
 Hutton, later to become the first professional captain of England and knighted in 1956, joined the ranks of those who had to embody the hopes and expectations of an England creaking under the weight of its industrial and imperial past, but whose sense of destiny was still quite strong. 
 SHAREHOLDERs AND PROFESSIONALS 
 Professionalism was the limited form through which amateurs permitted market forces to enter the world of sport. 
 There was a long-standing tradition of professionalism, which centred around jockeys and pugilists for the most part. 
 Sporting gentlemen of the pre-Victorian period saw no harm in making money through playing games so long as this was a matter of gambling; nor did they mind mixing with others of a lower class, who derived the bulk of their income in this way, provided distinctions of birth were recognized and preserved. 
 Peers played cricket with the Hampshire farmers of Hambledon without needing to designate their status officially as &bquo;gentlemen&equo; or &bquo;players&equo;. 
 Yet in Victorian Britain the alliance of wealth and birth formed in the public schools infused sport with a new idealism whilst simultaneously segregating the &eacute;lite from members of the lower classes taking the same form of exercise. 
 What were the implications of this for the process of commercialization? 
 More striking than the provision of popular entertainment for profit was the remarkable degree to which the landed interest, the liberal professions, and even sections of the business community itself excluded commercial forces from sport. 
 The rule of sport by amateurs kept capitalism at bay in British sport. 
 All sports came to make sharp distinctions between those who received payment and those who did not. 
 Some amateur associations went as far as legal prosecution to prevent any payment or pro fit being derived from the activities they controlled. 
 Of those sports where payment was permitted, there was little concession to the creation of a free market. 
 footballers were hedged around by restrictions on personal mobility and income whilst the residence qualifications for county cricketers prevented a cricketing equivalent of the football transfer system. 
 Even the breakaway &bquo;Northern Union&equo; required rugby players to have a source of income outside of the game and paid them in principle for &bquo;broken time&equo;. 
 The historical hostility to commercialism among the ruling bodies of sport is indisputable. 
 Yet there were areas of commercial penetration. 
 Sport certainly responded to the demand of the urban worker for entertainment. 
 Professional football is the obvious case. 
 With hundreds of thousands of paying spectators each week, with rising transfer fees, and the registration of clubs as limited liability companies surely it is reasonable to conclude that professional football was &bquo;a business&equo;? 
 Plausible as this may sound, the proposition is flawed; the organization of football, for example, was quite unlike that of the music-hall or the cinema. 
 Spectator sport may have been partially commercialized but it never became a capitalist leisure enterprise. 
 Careful research by Tony Mason, Wray Vamplew, and others has uncovered the financial structure of football from company records. 
 Professional clubs formed themselves into limited liability companies not to speculate in the entertainment business but to make legally secure the cost of providing facilities. 
 It was not just a matter of handling gate-money and paying the players. 
 More important was the status of loans raised to buy or rent land and erect a stadium. 
 Even this was hardly big business. 
 The initial sums were often quite modest as football clubs tend to grow gradually, first drawing crowds on a casual basis and then fencing in a field and charging admission; from this point a wooden stand might be built and earth piled up into which steps could be cut. 
 Fulham even invited the public to dump their refuse in the ground in order to erect rudimentary terracing and so, I am told, did Stirling Albion. 
 Purpose-built stadia generally followed from club success rather than being built speculatively in the hope of profit. 
 There was no &bquo;futures market&equo; in football. 
 Between 1889 and 1910 fifty-eight clubs moved into new grounds, though there was often continuity of land use in the sense that, at least 35 out of the current league grounds were recreational or sporting grounds in some form before the clubs moved in&equo;. 
 Club directors were cautious and strictly functional in their building plans. 
 Archibald Leitch, a mechanical engineer from Glasgow, provided the standard design for stadia with three open sides and a two-tier grandstand running the length of one of the longer sides of the rectangle. 
 Much as their fans loved them for all their quirks, the aesthetics and comfort of a ground did not cross the mind of many football directors. 
 They did not seek to attract new customers by the excellence of their pitches or facilities as music-hall proprietors did through the plushness and extravagance of their theatres. 
 Building and running a stadium that would hold tens of thousands of spectators was an expensive business and not usually a profitable one. 
 Only six out of sixty-two leading clubs paid their shareholders any dividend in the season 1908&ndash;9 and they were restricted by the FA from paying a dividend of more than 5 per cent. 
 &bquo;No one who is out for a business return would look at football shares,&equo; commented a leading sporting paper. 
 &bquo;Hundreds &lsqb;of shareholders&rsqb; have for years maintained guarantees at banks&equo;, continued the article, &bquo;and thousands have helped to create clubs by taking shares without hope of seeing their money back or any return on it.&equo; 
 The same was broadly true of Scotland. 
 Only Rangers and Celtic made much money &mdash; hence the original meaning of The term &bquo;The Old firm&equo; &mdash; and Celtic was pledged To donate to Catholic charities. 
 The small annual profits of the Edinburgh and Dundee clubs were interspersed with losses and no dividends were distributed to shareholders. 
 There were odd cases of profiteering such as the rental and catering concession held by Mears at Chelsea, but these were the exceptions that proved the rule. 
 When &bquo;King John&equo; Houlding, a self-made brewer and prominent local Tory, tried to use his position on the Everton board to jack up the rent paid to him by The club, There was a shareholders' revolt and Houlding eventually left the club to form Liverpool FC. 
 Profiteering was morally unacceptable to most Everton shareholders; this was even true of business men like Hartley, the jam-maker, and Hudson, The soap-manufacturer. 
 When there were contractors to be handed out directors may have tried to help one another, but that can hardly have been a sufficient reason for buying up large blocks of shares. 
 Although there was no direct financial incentive for The purchase of shares, the bulk of those who took them up were involved in business. 
 Of 740 directors of football clubs from 1888&ndash;1915 that have been traced there were only forty-two skilled manual workers and a mere four unskilled. 
 Similarly there were only thirty-two &bquo;gentlemen&equo;. 
 Manufacturers and managers, wholesale and retail, financial and commercial businesses, the building trade and the food and drink trade made up approximately two-thirds of the group. 
 Naturally directors tended to be drawn from the larger shareholders. 
 The thirty-four English clubs examined by Tony Mason were mostly run by smallish groups of substantial shareholders, though shareholding was sometimes quite widely distributed as in the case of Woolwich Arsenal with 900 manual workers holding shares in 1893. 
 In Sheffield a small, interconnected group of industrialists dominated football, passing down their directorships from father to son like family property. 
 Many directors continued in office long after they could hope to participate effectively. 
 Alderman Wardley of Sheffield Wednesday remained a director until he was over ninety. 
 Attendance at AGMs was small and directors were returned unopposed. 
 At West Ham the club was run by two families involved locally in business on a modest scale. 
 As they controlled an absolute majority of shares, the club was effectively closed. 
 No new members of the board were elected, though the odd family friend was co-opted from time to time. 
 Vamplew suggests shareholding was rather more democratically distributed in Scotland with skilled manual workers making up 19.1 per cent of shareholders in twenty-three clubs up to 1916. 
 Publicans were still the most important occupational group, holding between them almost a third (31.2 per cent) of all shares. 
 Perhaps a stake in a popular club would give profitable returns indirectly through the sale of drink. 
 The degree to which publicans &bquo;invested&equo; for this reason in football is unknown but the pecuniary advantage at first sight seems doubtful. 
 There was all the difference in the world between meeting a retired sporting hero behind the bar and meeting a shareholder or even a director. 
 Probably publicans were just carrying on an old tradition of involvement in popular sports. 
 Being a major shareholder or a director was rather like holding some honorific office within the community; it brought its own private and social satisfactions which could not be measured financially. 
 Publicans were frequently men of working-class origin, who sought prosperity without leaving their community. 
 They had a certain prestige within the neighbourhood and influence within the world of football was part of this process of &bquo;making good&equo;. 
 Similar feelings influenced middle-class shareholders and directors too. 
 Investment in soccer offered a sense of self-importance and pride at running an organization around which so much local interest was centred; the club made you &bquo;someone&equo; in the town, a big fish in a small pool. 
 Arnold Bennett caught this splendidly in the story of Denry Machin, an ambitious and well-off young councillor, who brought back a local footballing hero to the town at his own expense. 
 &bquo;Two days later a letter appeared in the Signal  (signed &bquo;Fiat Justitia&equo;) suggesting that Denry, as some reward for his public spirit, ought to be the next mayor of Bursley.&equo; 
 When he was duly elected, Machin merely remarked to his wife &bquo;You'll be mayoress to the youngest mayor&hellip; 
 And it's cost me, including hotel and travelling expenses, eight hundred and eleven pounds six and sevenpence&equo; (the cost of the transfer fee from York). 
 Such was the &bquo;psychic capital&equo; to be earned from investing in football. 
 If football was a business, it was a very peculiar one. 
 Clubs did not compete with one another to attract larger crowds by reducing their prices. 
 Nor did they make any serious efforts to derive income from a huge fixed asset, which was used for only a few hours a week. 
 Even the payment of players was regulated in such a way as to prevent clubs competing in a free market for talent. 
 As the game became more popular in the 1880s lack of regulation enabled the best footballers to play clubs off against one another and bid up their own wages. 
 It was to stop this that amateurs within the FA, who disliked professionalism in principle, were willing to accept it in practice. 
 Professionalism was legalised partly in order to place a limit on the bargaining power of players. 
 &bquo;Clubs who employ paid men will be only too glad to possess a strong authority over them&equo; was how the Athletic News  put it. 
 Hence the acceptance of professionalism did not set up a free market in football but bound players legally to one club and determined the maximum wage that could be paid to them. 
 The Football League was a kind of non-pro fit-making cartel in which the power of the largest clubs was limited by the smallest. 
 This was just as the amateurs of the FA thought it should be. 
 Nor were there frustrated breakaway movements from a handful of top clubs. 
 For they could still buy the best players through club transfers and were in a position to provide small additional incentives to players without increasing their wage-bill. 
 Cricket was even less open to the winds of free competition. 
 County cricket made little concession to spectators. 
 Amateurs wanted to get off to the country for the weekend rather than performing for the benefit of playing spectators. 
 &bquo;The amateurs in the two teams went out grouse-shooting during the morning&equo;, disclosed one account of Surrey against Derbyshire at Glossop in 1902. 
 The professionals sat around waiting for the gentlemen to return before the match was called off. 
 The interests of the crowd were simply not considered. 
 The English &bquo;national&equo; game was largely played at times when the English nation was otherwise engaged. 
 &bquo;Cricket&equo;, remarked Pelham Warner sternly, &bquo;is not a circus, and it would be far better that it should be driven back to the village green&hellip; than yield a jot to the petulant demands of the spectator.&equo; 
 County matches frequently produced dull play and drawn games. 
 But there was no question of any of the first-class counties being relegated for poor results. 
 County clubs were financed partly through gate-money and partly from the subscriptions of members. 
 The idea of being part of the &bquo;county&equo; was socially appealing. 
 County membership was not quite the same as holding a season-ticket for a Football League club. 
 Kent and Yorkshire even refused to recruit from outside of their territorial frontiers. 
 Wearing the county tie was a mark of modest social distinction and with that went the responsibility of meeting debts and subsidizing the side. 
 In 1937 county cricket was estimated to have lost &pound;30,000. 
 The losses of individual counties were relatively small and every four years the visit of the Australians helped to replenish the kitty. 
 Titled county presidents were also of great value. 
 Patronage did not die out with industrialization; it lived on through the honorific offices of county clubs and national bodies. 
 ln Derbyshire Will Taylor, the county secretary, would do his sums at the end of the season before phoning the Duke of Devonshire at Chatsworth. 
 &bquo;Now then, Taylor, what's the damage this time?&equo; the Duke would ask and on being told he would briskly reply &bquo;Cheque in post tomorrow. 
 Good day to ye.&equo; 
 Crowds had begun to fall from a first-day county average of almost 15,000 in the 1890s to under 10,000 between 1906 and 1914. 
 The relative failure of cricket as a popular spectacle lay &bquo;in the deliberate refusal of its administrators to modernize. 
 Cricket, in essence, stifled itself by remaining too true to its pre-industrial origins.&equo; 
 Lack of an alternative summer team sport protected cricket between the wars and it benefited from a brief post-1945 resurgence in numbers, but then numbers fell so dramatically that by 1965 they stood at about a third of the post-1945 years. 
 It was the imminent collapse of the county game which finally pushed the men of Lord's towards a more businesslike and consumer-conscious outlook. 
 Until recently both football and cricket administrators simply took the loyalty of the crowds for granted. 
 Average attendances in the First Division doubled between the Edwardian period and the 1930s. 
 Approximately 30,000 was the average crowd in the season 1937&ndash;8 and cup games often attracted double this number. 
 ln Glasgow a Rangers-Celtic cup-tie in 1937 attracted a crowd of almost 150,000. 
 The tragedy at Bolton in 1946, in which thirty-three were killed and 400 injured, was the result of admitting 85,000 fans with more clambering over walls or vaulting the turnstiles. 
 The demand from the public for football was so great, the FA and the League had no need to &bquo;sell&equo; the game. 
 Instead of profiting from the enormous interest in gambling on football results through the &bquo;pools&equo; system, the FA's puritanism led to a futile and absurd confrontation in 1936, which involved the withholding of fixture lists to frustrate the pools companies. 
 The hostility of the FA arose not just from a lack of commercial sense but from a more profound belief that gambling was wrong. 
 Elements of a morally uplifting &bquo;rational recreation&equo; tradition survived in football despite the payment of players. 
 The gambling issue underlined the central fact that professionalism and commercialism were not synonymous. 
 Of course, there were some economic changes during the century spanning the formation of the FA and the ending of the maximum wage. 
 In the inter-war years, for example, transfer fees rose dramatically, the job of manager was defined, and revenue from advertising came to be more important. 
 Herbert Chapman, the manager of Arsenal, proved to be the prototype. 
 These changes, which were limited to the big club sides, will be examined later in relation to media interest in sport. 
 For the moment let us take a look at the fortunes of the professionals, mostly unsung and unremembered, who played cricket or football for pay. 
 &bquo;Obedient servants&equo; they have been called, and that for the most part is just what they were. 
 Until very recently professional sportsmen have been regarded by directors as skilled workmen; footballers' incomes were not calculated in the same way as transfer fees according to market value but in relation to what other working-class men could expect to earn. 
 By such standards both footballers and cricketers, provided they were among the minority who avoided injury and played in the first team, were quite well off for a few years. 
 They were paid about double what a skilled man could expect for a fifty-hour week in return for working part-time at something that they enjoyed. 
 Spectators were not surprisingly unsympathetic to the rare protests of professionals about the maximum wage and the retain-and-transfer system. 
 Their employers were quick to stoke up popular envy through the press if players even temporarily forgot their good fortune. 
 Yet both professional footballers and cricketers were subjected to unreasonable restrictions and working practices. 
 In most cases they gained very little financially from their employment. 
 ln cricket there were very few opportunities with only fifteen first-class counties and the Lancashire League sides, who had only one full professional per team. 
 Professional batsmen were frequently in competition with &bquo;gentlemen&equo; who did not charge for their services in the conventional manner. 
 County cricketers were paid for the summer and only the best were given a reduced wage to see them through the winter. 
 Of twenty-four professionals retained by Lancashire in 1899, seventeen were paid &pound;3 a week as a basic wage during the season with the remainder getting less. 
 All received reduced winter wages with eleven given nothing at all. 
 Match fees and bonuses for winning pushed up the wages of the best players, but travel and hotel expenses had to be met out of the &pound;5 or &pound;6 payment for away games. 
 Most significant for a county player was the opportunity to have a benefit match. 
 This was not done for players with less than ten years' service and a longer period was usually required. 
 Benefits were notoriously unreliable. 
 If a player was granted a good fixture, if the weather held fair, and if the player was popular with the supporters, a good sum might be raised. 
 Mandle's calculation of an average benefit of &pound;816 in the 1890s indicates a threefold increase since the 1860s, and would have been enough perhaps to start a man off in a small business. 
 The &bquo;benefit&equo; was in fact a deferred payment, which both tied a player to a single club and was of no value to those who through loss of form or injury were not able to serve the county for a long enough period. 
 Bobby Abel, the son of a cockney lamplighter from Rotherhithe, played for Surrey from 1881 to 1904. 
 At the time only &bquo;W.G.&equo; had made more first-class runs than the &bquo;Little Guv'nor&equo; with his 32,669. 
 &bquo;He gathers runs like blackberries everywhere he goes&equo;, said C. B. Fry. 
 With his cap pulled down over one eye and the crowds shouting &bquo;Go to it little &bquo;un&equo;, he was a stalwart of Surrey and England. 
 Had he not been followed as a Surrey opener by Jack Hobbs, then perhaps he would be better known to posterity. 
 He was a dedicated professional, who claimed &bquo;I sacrifice everything for cricket, never stop out late and always take the greatest care of myself.&equo; 
 Whenever he was out he set himself the task &bquo;to study how and why until I discovered how I should have played the ball that beat me&equo;. 
 Abel was granted a benefit in 1895 after fourteen years with the club and took the Surrey-Yorkshire game. 
 The Bank Holiday fixture was habitually requested and refused for benefit matches and the stand receipts were also withheld. 
 Abel managed to make &pound;730, which helped to develop a sports shop beside the Oval, though this later failed and he was rescued from penury by a public appeal launched by the Daily Mail  after the First World War. 
 Players like Abel of international calibre were increasingly resentful of the special payments made to famous amateurs. 
 Grace openly demanded payment of &pound;20 a match from Gloucester and more for Test matches; Wisden  could only comment that &bquo;nice customs curtsey to great kings&equo;. 
 At Surrey the &bquo;amateur&equo; W. W. Read was employed as &bquo;assistant secretary&equo; to the club for &pound;250 a year &mdash; a post he relinquished when he ceased to play. 
 Entry fees to the Stock Exchange were put up by members of the Surrey committee in the late nineteenth century to help impecunious gentleman-cricketers. 
 Harry Wood, a professional for twenty years with Surrey and along with Abel one of three who went &bquo;on strike&equo; in 1896 demanding a &pound;20 match fee to play the Australians, left the game a bitter man. 
 He believed that if &bquo;1 had played cricket as a &bquo;gentleman&equo; I should have made sufficient out of my &bquo;expenses&equo; to retire by now.&equo; 
 This was probably an exaggeration, though the resentment was understandable. 
 Amateurs always claimed that (W.G. apart) only legitimate hotel and travelling expenses were met, though &bquo;testimonials, were sometimes arranged to give the gentleman a decent send-off. 
 Grace notoriously pocketed &pound;9,000 from his second testimonial while more modestly W. W. Read managed a respectable &pound;1,000 from a Surrey vs. 
 England fixture specially resurrected for him. 
 Then there were the sheer indignities of a professional cricketer's life &mdash; the separate entrances, changing facilities, menial jobs to do around the club, even the placing of the man's initials after his surname to signify servile status. 
 When Kent played Surrey in 1890 a fine spread was laid on for the gentlemen but the professionals &bquo;were left to shift for themselves, and thought themselves lucky to get a bit of bread and cheese&equo;. 
 Even the otherwise haughty Surrey committee was moved to complain about this lack of common courtesy, though naturally they did not go so far as to suggest meals should be taken in common. 
 The Middlesex secretary of the Edwardian years, who was also secretary of the MCC, Sir Francis Lacey, mixed a curt politeness with public condescension in his treatment of the professional staff. 
 At the start of each season he would stand with his chief clerk at the gate of Lord's with &bquo;a pile of contracts on heavy blue legal paper, everyone tied with a piece of pink ribbon. 
 As each cricketer stepped forward he would refer to the man by his surname and say, &bquo;Here's your contract and here's your first day's wages, and I hope you've wintered well.&equo; 
 Not even the most distinguished professionals were treated any differently, including &bquo;Patsy&equo; Hendren, who after Jack Hobbs made more first-class centuries than any other player. 
 Patsy's brother Dennis also played for the club and did not appreciate the secretary's habitual greeting: &bquo;with me bleedin&equo; ribs pokin&equo; out of me skin, breakin&equo; me neck to get at that six and eight&equo; (the initial sum dispensed by the Secretary), Dennis Hendren had not wintered well&equo; and did not believe Middlesex looked after its players out of season. 
 Wally Hammond took over from Hobbs as the Great Man of English cricket. 
 He played his first match at the age of 17 for Gloucester in 1920 and continued until after the Second World War. 
 He was the supreme all-rounder &mdash; the best since Grace &mdash; but with a self-confessed &bquo;allergy&equo; to publicity which perhaps led his reputation to suffer after his retirement. 
 Hammond changed his status from professional to amateur partly through taking a directorship of a tyre company in 1938 &mdash; he liked to drive fast cars &mdash; and was then selected to captain England. 
 He was the first ex-professional to be so honoured. 
 His career neatly illustrates the expanding commercial possibilities for famous sportsmen outside the field of play. 
 Taking money for playing still disqualified a man for the highest honours in amateur eyes, but profiting from sporting fame indirectly through directorships did not. 
 The subordinate status of professionals lasted a very long time indeed. 
 When the distinction was abandoned in 1963 some old &bquo;players&equo; steeped in traditions of the game even mourned its passing. 
 Most professionals were a deferential, biddable lot. 
 The ending of what amounted to class segregation was less a matter of the democratic spirit of professionals finally asserting itself than of the decline of the amateur. 
 A combination of higher taxation and more rigorous academic standards led to a dearth of first-class amateurs. 
 Gentlemen had to take their fortunes and their education more seriously. 
 Even Oxbridge men had less time and money to spare. 
 Things had changed since the 1920s when Lionel Hedges, a Tonbridge and Kent cricketer and Oxford blue, had dismissed &bquo;a seedy looking middle-aged gentleman &lsqb;who&rsqb; called on him on the morning of a match. 
 Imagining him to be a reporter, Lionel said to him brusquely, &bquo;I have nothing to say to you.&equo; 
 The man tried to expostulate but Lionel repeated, &bquo;I have nothing to say to you.&equo; 
 It only afterwards transpired that the seedy man was not a reporter but his tutor, with whom he was not otherwise acquainted.&equo; 
 After the Second World War the comfortable, leisured life cushioned with a decent income from stocks and shares was hit both by inflation and the liquidation of Britain's foreign assets. 
 When Keynes had talked of the &bquo;euthanasia of the rentier&equo; he had not been thinking of cricket, but the MCC had to face the reality of the decline of the leisured classes. 
 From 175 out of 450 county cricketers in 1949 the number of amateurs fell to 72 out of 370 in 1961. 
 It was becoming difficult to put together a Gentlemen's eleven worthy of the name. 
 So Lord's decided that all men should henceforth be &bquo;cricketers&equo; and the Gentlemen and Players fixture was duly abandoned. 
 By this time professional cricketers' earnings had fallen behind average manual wages. 
 Cricketers were no longer even financially privileged workers and there was no representative body to fight for them until the Cricketers' Association was formed in 1968. 
 Since then their incomes, though still relatively low, have improved somewhat. 
 The benefit has remained crucial to the county cricketer, and with assiduous planning and work the sums raised from them have gone up dramatically. 
 Cyril Washbrook's &pound;14,000 in 1948 remained a record until the early 1970s. 
 Nowadays the holding of dances, raffles, and pub talks along with the fixture has pushed up the sums enormously, although if inflation and house prices are taken into account even &pound;50,000 or over is hardly a fortune for a man who has to find a job and keep a family. 
 Professional footballers fared little better than cricketers and were less likely to be able to pursue their occupation for as long. 
 On the other hand, there were many more openings for footballers than cricketers. 
 There were 448 players registered with the Football League in 1891 but this figure rose to around 5,000 by the Edwardian period. 
 During the 1890s the FA left wages to the discretion of individual clubs, but there were complaints that top players were able to use this freedom to extract large sums from the directors despite their contractual bondage to a particular club. 
 Moreover, poorer clubs were anxious not to find themselves in a wages-auction with richer ones and the FA finally set a &pound;4 a week maximum in 1900, which was raised in 1909 to &pound;5 for senior professionals with a club. 
 Although well above the best wages of a skilled man, it was neither market-determined nor received by all registered professionals. 
 Wage regulation applied only at the upper limit. 
 There was no &bquo;minimum wage&equo; and clubs tended to take on large numbers of hopefuls at low rates. 
 Vamplew has worked out that almost half of the players registered with First Division clubs in 1910 never played a League match. 
 Many players retained part-time jobs or worked odd shifts at the pit. 
 Of twenty-eight new signings for Aston Villa in 1893&ndash;4 half never played and only one continued with the club for more than three seasons. 
 The same seems to have been true of other clubs. 
 Most working men claimed to know someone who had once been given a trial or had been &bquo;on the books&equo; of a club for a spell. 
 Wages rose with inflation after the war to &pound;8 a week but only a minority of players on a club's books received this. 
 Of full-time professionals playing for a major club like Sheffield United in 1934&ndash;5 only four out of twenty-one were on the maximum wage. 
 Benefits for long-serving players were discretionary and unlike cricket were subject to tax. 
 This, of course, is only the official, public side of the story. 
 The extent to which the maximum wage was regularly breached is difficult to determine. 
 Naturally, players and directors did not want to broadcast systematic evasion of FA rules. 
 For most players in the lower divisions the issue simply did not arise. 
 They would have been only too happy to accept the maximum. 
 But in the commanding heights of the First Division with huge crowds and ambitious directors, there is no doubt that incentives were given to players. 
 One way of evading restrictions was to find sinecure posts for good players; one man was given the job of checking the advertising posters for the club, though the most common trick was for club directors, who were often substantial employers, to find part-time or simply bogus jobs for which payment was made. 
 Another ruse was to offer houses at low rent or for sale, or to offer signing-on fees far in excess of the &pound;10 theoretically permitted by the FA. 
 Old cars were sold to clubs at inflated prices and on one occasion a player sold his dog to a director. 
 From time to time the authorities got wind of these breaches of regulations and punished clubs, but they did not regularly inspect the books and revelations of extra payments tended to emerge as a result of other inquiries. 
 Such was the case at Manchester City in 1905&ndash;6. 
 Billy Meredith, the &bquo;Prince of Dribblers&equo; and the club captain, was suspended for a season for attempting to offer a bribe to an Aston Villa player. 
 Meredith at first proclaimed his innocence but friction between the player and the club led to further disclosures. 
 Meredith claimed he had offered the bribe on behalf of the manager and that the players were to be offered a team bonus of &pound;100 if they won the League. 
 An FA investigation revealed that the club had regularly breached the maximum wage restrictions in the season 1904&ndash;5. 
 As a result seventeen players were suspended for six months, fined a total of &pound;900, and forbidden to play for the club again. 
 Two directors were suspended for a year and the chairman and manager banned from football for good. 
 The FA was determined to set an example, but here the difference between the largely amateur FA and the Football League was important. 
 The League was controlled by the club chairmen, some of whom were undoubtedly also involved in making extra payments. 
 The supreme irony of the Manchester City affair was that several rival clubs, notably Manchester United, signed the suspended players, offering substantial signing-on fees (contrary to FA rules) as well as a transfer fee to the club. 
 Billy Meredith and Herbert Burgess, the &bquo;Mighty Atom&equo; as the fans called him went to Manchester United along with Jimmy Bannister, Meredith's partner in City's attack. 
 Presumably they were offered inducements to sign and paid over the odds when they helped to win the League championship for City's rivals two years later. 
 There seems little doubt that the richest clubs went on evading the maximum wage regulation. 
 As the FA handed over control of this aspect of the game to the League, it was not likely that club chairmen would encourage investigations that might damage themselves. 
 The memoirs of great inter-war players like Dixie Dean, Tommy Lawton, and Stanley Matthews politely skate over the issue, but a Manchester United player in the 1920s recalled a telling incident involving the club captain, Frank Barson. 
 Barson's powers of tackling and leadership were so highly regarded that United had paid &pound;5,000 &mdash; a huge fee at the time, especially for a defender &mdash; for his transfer from Aston Villa in 1922. 
 When the former blacksmith from Barnsley &bquo;walked into the United dressing-room, he would put a hand on to a shelf in search of a package before he took his coat off. 
 In the package was the few bob he got extra, because he was half the team. 
 One day, there was no package and he said to the trainer, &bquo;Where's the doin's? 
 I'm not taking my bloody coat off till I get it.&equo; 
 That illegal payments to players in the top clubs was widespread and continued throughout the period of the maximum wage emerged from evidence of overpayment by Sunderland in the 1950s submitted anonymously to discredit the chairman, Bill Ditchburn, a wealthy local business man, who used to go out to buy fish and chips in his pink-and-mauve Rolls-Royce. 
 Ditchburn covered up the extra payments through a hugely inflated figure for the purchase of straw to protect the turf from frost. 
 He was barred for life from the game and angrily hired his own team of detectives to collect evidence to prove that all the other major clubs were also evading the regulations. 
 This &bquo;evidence&equo; was never published but he persisted in his belief that his only crime was that he was found out. 
 Trevor Ford, the aggressive Welsh centre-forward, who had been signed for Sunderland as part of Ditchburn's lavish spending programme (earning Sunderland the name of &bquo;The Bank of England club&equo;), confirmed that abuse of the system was widespread in the First Division. 
 Most professionals, however, did not have the market value nor did their clubs have the resources to behave like this. 
 Just how hard a school professional football was emerges from Ward and Alister's imaginative oral history of Barnsley between 1953 and 1959. 
 The club had thirty in its youth squad in 1951 and there was competition even to get a game for the fourth team. 
 Despite relegation to the Third Division the club kept a playing staff of thirty-eight, twenty-five of whom came from the Barnsley area and were almost all miners or the sons of miners. 
 Even first-team players had odd jobs and reserves often worked shifts at the pit or elsewhere. 
 Johnny Kelly, an established player, ingeniously devised his own brand of detergent, which he mixed up in his bath at home and delivered in an old van with the registration number AGE 100. 
 Clubs such as this were rather like workshops with the old pros as time-served tradesmen who expected the young apprentices to clean their boots and learn their trade. 
 These lads were often touchingly na&iuml;ve. 
 Away games gave working-class youths their first taste of comfortable living. 
 Many had never stayed at a hotel or even had a cheap meal away from home. 
 When one youngster was asked by a waitress what he wanted for &bquo;a sweet&equo;, he replied &bquo;a Nuttall's Minto&equo;. 
 What became of most professionals after their brief sojourn in the game? 
 Their lack of other skills or a decent education often pushed them into routine manual labour, though jobs within football did increase between the wars. 
 The most successful players certainly did well; Stanley Matthews had a hotel in Blackpool and Jackie Milburn, the folk-hero of Tyneside, ran a coach firm. 
 But they were exceptional. 
 Of the eleven who won the Cup for Manchester United in 1948, most of whom were internationals and all in the first rank of senior professionals, five went into football coaching and management, three ran newsagents' shops (customers presumably enjoyed discussing the sports headlines with men who had once made them), two worked in factories, and one became a night-telephonist. 
 Only one of the five who stayed in football was able to keep his position within the game until retirement. 
 Even Johnny Carey, the club captain and reckoned to be the most versatile player of all time (he had played in ten positions for United including goalkeeper), finished his working life modestly in the treasurer's office of Trafford Borough Council after having gone the way of all managers in the grip of impatient and often ignorant directors. 
 Such were the small gains to be made from a playing career at the very top. 
 Ordinary club professionals had far fewer opportunities. 
 A few like Hughie Gallacher, the marvellous centre-forward for Newcastle and Scotland in the 1920s, could never adjust to the sudden loss of fame and took their own life. 
 But there were probably a great many more who simply took advantage of too many of the free pints they were offered too often and slipped into alcoholism. 
 It was hard to be a hero one day and a &bquo;has-been&equo; the next. 
 Arthur Hopcraft's The football Man  evokes perfectly the life of the footballer at the fag-end of England's industrial heyday as men like Nat Lofthouse, the son of a coal-man from Bolton and a &bquo;Bevin Boy&equo; in the war, led the England attack in the tradition of big, fearless centre-forwards. 
 In the 1940s and early 1950s football remained the ruling passion of working men without cars and televisions, whose world still revolved around the communal life of the works, the pub, and the match. 
 Derek Dooley, the young Sheffield Wednesday centre-forward who scored forty-six goals in his team's Second Division championship victory in 1951&ndash;2, was the kind of hero every northern boy dreamed of becoming. 
 His father was a steel-worker. 
 He had often been out of work during the boy &bquo;s early years in the west of Sheffield &bquo;where the city meanders in a smokey, greasy straggle of workshops into Rotherham&equo;. 
 The son learned his football in a shared backyard or on &bquo;patches of grit and oily grass, hemmed in by the crouched streets, with the rusty swings and roundabouts, which creaked under a cafuffle of ragged children. 
 Jackets made goal-posts, and: &bquo;If you went down you got up with a lump of a cinder in your knee.&equo; 
 School football matches were desperately hard-fought, especially when the secondary modern had a chance to beat the grammar school. 
 This was no place for the frail ball player. 
 Hardness was cultivated and admired. 
 Hopeful youngsters clashed with old timers playing out their last few seasons in the reserve leagues, which were as competitive as the first-team games and often a lot tougher. 
 And so Derek Dooley went to Sheffield Wednesday at seventeen and a half, his local team, until a clash with an advancing goalkeeper forced the immediate amputation of his leg in February 1953. 
 He had not even had a full season in the First Division. 
 Dooley's personal tragedy was so awful &mdash; he was so young and talented and he took the blow with such heroic, idiotic stoicism (&bquo;It's my one regret that the ball didn't finish in the net&equo;) &mdash; that a substantial sum was raised for him and he later went to work for the club. 
 Happily it was rare to be as unfortunate as Dooley on the field, but few were able to make a good career in the game. 
 Many were called but few were chosen. 
 The history of the Players' Union has only intermittently been a struggle against wage and transfer controls. 
 More central to the ordinary professional was the question of compensation for injury. 
 This was the issue which brought the Professional Footballers' Association, founded in 1907 after several earlier false starts, into immediate conflict with the FA and the League. 
 The PFA appealed on behalf of injured players to the courts under the terms of the Workmen's Compensation Act of 1906. 
 When the FA protested, they received a splendid rebuff to the effect that the PFA could not be expected &bquo;to regard seriously the opinion that a football player forfeits a common legal right on entering into a professional engagement with a football club&equo;. 
 The PFA urged players not to sign new contracts until this principle was accepted and several of the leading sides such as Manchester United and Newcastle United, where Colin Veitch's energetic organization and articulate socialism briefly seems to have radicalized the players, went on strike. 
 Possibly the widening class-consciousness of militant trade unionism within the Edwardian working class, especially considering the number of players from mining origins, may also have helped encourage this flurry of &bquo;industrial&equo; action. 
 Threats from the FA, however, forced 800 of the 1,200 members of the PFA to resign. 
 A truce was eventually agreed by which players would first present any injury claims to the FA itself and a small increase in the maximum wage and a bonus system were introduced. 
 The PFA challenged the retain-and-transfer system in the courts and lost in 1912, to which was added the indignity of needing financial help from the League to pay the costs of the case. 
 The real weakness of any players' union lay in the difficulty of maintaining solidarity amongst its members. 
 Competition was so intense for team-places that managers could isolate activists. 
 The constant supply of optimistic youngsters meant that those who became bitter or critical as they got older could be quietly dropped. 
 Hence the PFA concentrated on making small gains. 
 It did not challenge the essentials of the system between the wars but concentrated on edging up the maximum wage and stressing the benefits of belonging to a mutual aid society for sickness or injury. 
 There were about 2,000 members by 1939 and after 1945 the &bquo;friendly society&equo; dimension was further strengthened by the taking out of an expensive private insurance scheme for players, which absorbed half of the income of the Association. 
 Anger over their failure to benefit from increased television revenue combined with the falling value of the maximum wage of &pound;20 in relation to average industrial earnings led to a new surge of militancy in the 1950s. 
 Professionals' self-esteem had been founded upon being at the top of the manual wages pyramid. 
 Then there was the emergence of Jimmy Hill, a Fulham player with a grammar school education and a father in the Stock Exchange, as an articulate and shrewd spokesman for the players. 
 Strike action to remove the maximum wage in 1960 was promised. 
 The threat was enough this time. 
 Public opinion, carefully managed by Hill, favoured the players and some of the top clubs, who had never liked the system, were worried about the growing tendency of the very best professionals to leave the country to play in Italy and elsewhere. 
 So the maximum wage was scrapped but freedom of contract and mobility was harder to get. 
 George Eastham backed by the PFA took Newcastle United to court for &bquo;unjustifiable restraint on trade&equo; and won the case, although significantly the logical implications of the judgement in respect of full freedom of contract for players was resisted by the Football League for nearly another twenty years. 
 Those who think the modern footballer's life is a round of &bquo;boutiques, blow-waves and BMWs&equo; (as the Sun  might put it) should read Eamon Dunphy's Only a Game ? 
 In a genre noted for its shoddiness and sensationalism, this playing memoir of a season with Millwall in the mid-1970s stands out as a truthful and often painful account of the player's lot. 
 Dunphy, an Irish international, was better off than most, but the awful uncertainty of the job, the fear of failure or injury, were always present. 
 There was the public humiliation of being dropped from the side; the autocratic style of managers, who were themselves as afraid and insecure as their players; the refusal to let good players use their natural talent to play, forcing them through repetitive training &bquo;systems&equo; and na&iuml;ve &bquo;game plans&equo;; the petty jealousies of the players, their hierarchies, and childish pranks; the fear of the new signing, who has to be included at the expense of an old friend; the view of a match from &bquo;the inside&equo; when you know a team-mate does not want the ball but wants it to look as if you will not give it to him. 
 As the team faces relegation to the Third Division, Charlton offers Dunphy a job but his house is tied to Millwall. 
 The Charlton house is 
 terrible. 
 A real slum&hellip; 
 And then it hit me, and I really got frightened&hellip; 
 I felt really vulnerable. 
 I've got nothing. 
 No money, no security, no trade, no home&hellip; 
 All I had to bargain with was my own little bit of skill, which really, when you compare it with a carpenter's skill, or a plumber's skill, is intangible. 
 They can make chairs, mend the loo. 
 But a footballer? 
 A Second or Third Division footballer is expendable. 
 You can be easily done without. 
 He felt he had to go. 
 He would probably have been forced out anyway, as several of his friends had been. 
 It was better to go first from choice. 
 &bquo;I persuaded him &lsqb;the Millwall manager&rsqb; that he had had eight years out of me, and I had nothing to show for it. 
 That they weren't having to give me a testimonial, which I would be entitled to soon, and were making a profit on my sale.&equo; 
 He finally agreed to sell Dunphy to Charlton. 
 Other entertainers on the wane can often fall back on a &bquo;club circuit&equo;, musicians and dancers can sometimes coach others, but there are few openings for the ex-footballer. 
 They cannot teach sport in schools. 
 They may pay a high price for their few years of glory with injury problems in later life and will probably never enjoy the relative prosperity of their first working years again. 
 There were, of course, other professional sportsmen besides cricketers and footballers. 
 What of them? 
 The greatest track athlete of the late nineteenth century was Walter George. 
 He turned professional in 1885 having won everything from the half-mile to the ten-mile AAA's events. 
 Thirty thousand spectators turned up at Lillie Bridge in London to see him run the mile against William Cummings of Paisley and in the return match George's time of 4 min. 12.75 sec. was not beaten in Britain for forty-nine years. 
 That his name is scarcely known today is a testament to the power of the amateur establishment to make a professional an &bquo;unperson&equo;. 
 This pedestrian tradition of foot-racing for cups and prize-money survived, especially in Scotland. 
 When Dixie Dean was on holiday in Ayr, he noticed that a professional sprint was to be held and entered it as an outsider and won; he thereby not only demonstrated the outstanding athletic abilities of top footballers (Matthews was also a fine athlete), but underlined the survival of the old pedestrian traditions at the new resorts catering for working-class holiday-makers. 
 The Powderhall stadium in Edinburgh was the top venue for professional athletics, though competitors could not make a living by running alone. 
 Pedestrianism remained a source of extra money for good runners, who were willing to sacrifice the more socially prestigious amateur laurels. 
 Men did not get rich through running as they did through boxing. 
 Next to football, boxing was probably the most important working-class spectator sport. 
 With the establishment of the British Boxing Board of Control in 1929 boxing was freed from the private control of the gentlemen of the National Sporting Club, and despite the dominance of the United States, especially in the heavier weights, boxing remained an extremely popular professional sport. 
 There were around a thousand registered fighters in the 1940s, but the number fell steadily in the 1950s and 1960s as working-class affluence softened inner-city boys brought up to fight out of hunger and the sheer hardness of street life. 
 In Jimmy Wilde, the world flyweight champion from 1916, Britain produced one of the very greatest boxers of all time. 
 He was defeated only four times in a long career, &bquo;retiring with a fortune of &pound;70,000, almost all of which was promptly lost for him&equo;. 
 Wilde was a Welshman as were two other of the great Edwardian boxers, Freddie Welsh, the lightweight champion of Britain in 1909, and Jim Driscoll, the world bantamweight champion who ended his days &bquo;Wandering around the pubs of London, penniless, and dying at 44&equo;. 
 Boxers fought an enormous number of contests by modern standards to satisfy a working-class public who wanted to see regular bouts. 
 Wilde fought 864. 
 Len Harvey, the leading middleweight in the inter-war years, fought 412 contests. 
 Jack Matthews, the &bquo;Fighting Barber&equo; and father of Stanley, fought 350 bouts losing only nine times without winning a championship title. 
 Jack &bquo;Kid&equo; Berg, who grew up in the East End ghetto, fought his way up from the streets to a world welterweight title in the tradition of oppressed racial minorities. 
 Jewish boxers were an important part of the London sporting scene. 
 Irish Catholics in Glasgow grew up in a similarly hostile environment. 
 Benny Lynch, the world flyweight champion from 1935 to 1938, was their folk-hero. 
 Born in the Gorbals, he learned boxing in a Catholic youth club and by fighting on the street-corners. 
 He toured round the boxing-booths of the summer fairgrounds like other &bquo;has-beens&equo; or &bquo;hopefuls&equo;. 
 The &bquo;small halls&equo; put on weekly programmes of fights for small purses. 
 Paddy Reilly, a friend of Lynch's, once claimed to have had five ten-round fights in a week. 
 Alex Farries, another Glaswegian contemporary, lost count of the number. 
 On one occasion he went to Dundee where the promoter knocked down his purse from &pound;4 to &pound;2. 10s. because he had come on his motor bike rather than on the train. 
 For this he fought a hard ten-round contest. 
 He collapsed with a dangerous fever and inflammation when he got back to Glasgow. 
 When Farries fought Benny Lynch for &pound;5 at the Eldorado at Leith, the two Glaswegians cheerfully came home together on the train. 
 In the West of Scotland, South Wales, and Fast London &mdash; all areas of significantly high immigration &mdash; professional boxing was followed with a fierce passion and local fighters were folk-heroes. 
 In Belfast from 1931 to 1938 a total of 800 twice-weekly boxing-programmes were put on by &bquo;Ma Copley&equo;, who first organized fights in the open air and then set up a boxing hall at Chapel Fields. 
 Threepence bought a night's boxing at &bquo;the Nursery&equo; as this training-ground for fighters was known. 
 They were a tough crowd who drew fighters from quite far afield. 
 Scotsmen, Englishmen, and Welshmen joined with local fighters like Spider Kelly, Jackie Quinn, and Rinty Monaghan to slug it out for a few pounds. 
 American dominance of the top weights has unduly obscured the vitality of our own fighting tradition at the lower divisions. 
 Despite the growing protests of the medical establishment, boxing still thrives at the championship level. 
 Black immigration, recession, and the enormous purses which television can provide have meant there remain a ready supply of men willing to risk brain damage in the ring. 
 Public reaction to boxing is now ambivalent. 
 As a display of complete athleticism a great boxing match is a supreme sporting event, the purest expression of skill, strength, and courage. 
 But it is undoubtedly dangerous and often cruel, stirring not so much the boxers but the crowds who watch them to a pitch of savagery quite incompatible with the notion that boxing is &bquo;the noble art of self-defence&equo;. 
 The moral opposition to boxing in the late twentieth century, which is essentially a continuation of an old Nonconformist hostility bolstered by science, is weakened by the popularity of men like Henry Cooper: 'Enry, the Londoner, the decent, gentle bruiser, who almost knocked out one of the greatest heavyweights of all time, but now prospers as a TV celebrity playing golf for charity or advertising deodorants. 
 Boxing is certainly a business; great fortunes are made and more are kept than before. 
 Boxers fight less and earn more. 
 This may be accounted a kind of progress and helps to assuage the liberal moral conscience. 
 Wrestlers were a breed apart. 
 They were more akin to circus performers than to more conventional professional sportsmen. 
 Mass Observation  made a quite careful study of this new spectator fad in Bolton in the late 1930s. 
 A wrestling stadium was opened in 1933 by a former amateur wrestler and publican to show &bquo;free style&equo; wrestling from the USA with its commercial flamboyance and parodies of &bquo;good&equo; and &bquo;bad&equo; sportsmanship. 
 Out of a sample of 300 men a third had attended wrestling. 
 &bquo;Thrill&equo; was the most frequent motive for attending but &bquo;humour&equo; was also frequently cited &mdash; if the wrestlers went in for too much close holding choruses of &bquo;Kiss me sergeant &bquo;and &bquo;What blue eyes you've got&equo; would strike up. 
 &bquo;Rough stuff, of the half-simulated sort that has diverted modern television audiences, was popular from the start. 
 Third round P &mdash; again beats gong, rushes at B &mdash; puts B's head over the rope and then lifts middle rope over part of his neck. 
 B &mdash; cannot get loose and seems to be choking and the crowd are on their feet yelling and waving their hands &mdash; the referee helped by both seconds manages to extricate B &mdash; but P &mdash; grabs him, a quick aeroplane spin, gets him with his left hand round the shoulder, right hand through his left, swings him three times round in the air and pins him with his shoulders on the floor for the count of three. 
 Boos and Boos and one or three cheering in the 6d . 
 stands. 
 M.C. announces first fall to P &mdash; in 2 minutes 50 secs. of the third round. 
 B &mdash; can scarcely rise, the referee is in a fit of temper, attacks P &mdash; with stool, P &mdash; chases him round ring &mdash; gong goes for the 4th round &mdash; P &mdash; still has stool so B &mdash; picks up the water bowl and with a terrific bang lands it on P's head. 
 P &mdash; drops almost unconscious. 
 B &mdash; jumps at him, Jack the referee drops on stomach to count but is fast between wrestlers and can't be seen and he manages to free himself, and counts 1 2 3 very quickly. 
 Second fall to B &mdash;. 
 Observer asks his neighbour how he enjoyed it. 
 &bquo;I can &bquo;t tell you proper &mdash; I can &bquo;t believe my own bloody eyes.&equo; 
 Such were the pleasures of a night of &bquo;dirty&equo; wrestling. 
 Footballers, cricketers, and boxers were the most numerous of professional sportsmen, but the best-known, especially in the late nineteenth century &bquo;were jockeys. 
 Their own earnings were fabulous and they could make money for their followers as well. 
 Tom Cannon was paid &pound;15,000 simply as a retainer in the 1880s and Vamplew has calculated that the best riders in the period 1870&ndash;1914 might earn &pound;75,000 in their careers. 
 Most famous of all was Fred Archer. 
 &bquo;Crowds would block a street simply to see Archer leave a hotel and take a cab; when he married in January 1883, special trains were laid on to bring the cheering crowds to Newmarket and Cambridge. 
 &bquo;His marriage ended tragically in the early death of his wife and a year later he shot himself. 
 &bquo;Hardly anything could cause a more widespread and painful sensation&equo;, wrote The Times , &bquo;the news of his death has come with a sense of shock and almost personal loss to millions.&equo; 
 The top dozen or so jockeys would expect to ride over half the winners in a season. 
 The profession was extremely hard to break into and to maintain a very low weight required constant vigilance and self-discipline. 
 Archer was said to have become especially depressive when starving himself to make the required weight. 
 Most stable-lads would have counted themselves lucky even to get a ride let alone to win a race. 
 Much of this remains true today. 
 Racing is a major source of continuity in British sport. 
 The aristocracy has kept a tight grip on &bquo;the sport of kings&equo; and the British royal family have kept a close eye on the Turf &mdash; the present Queen is a fine judge of a horse. 
 Gordon Richards, champion jockey twenty-six times between 1925 and 1952, surpassed Fred Archer's annual record of 246 winners set in 1885 with 259 in 1933 and then 269 in 1947. 
 He got a knighthood as well as a fortune for his pains &mdash; the first professional sportsman to do so. 
 Lester Piggott, his brilliant successor from the 1960s to the 1980s, was driven by such a desperate, obsessive need for wealth and security that he was sent to prison for persistently defrauding the Inland Revenue of its share of his millions. 
 Tennis and golf were similarly skewed towards a handful of great competitors. 
 From the inter-war years a small number of tennis professionals played tournaments in the United States. 
 Most of the outstanding men who first made their name in the amateur game, turned professional &mdash; Tilden, Perry, Budge, Gonzales &bquo;Sedgman, Trabert, and then Rosewall, Hoad, and finally Rod Laver. 
 Yet the bulk of competitive play continued to be amateur until the late 1960s. 
 Golf employed a far larger number of professionals but these men were rarely tournament competitors. 
 Until the 1950s there were few tournaments with substantial amounts of prize-money. 
 Golf professionals sold equipment, gave lessons, and sometimes helped to look after the course. 
 The &bquo;pro&equo; remained a servant of the club in a little &bquo;shop&equo; on the fringes of the premises. 
 Those who earned their living from the game in tournament play were few and far between. 
 Around the turn of the century there had been the great triumvirate of Braid, Vardon, and Taylor but American dominance was established between the wars in the shape of Walter Hagen, who won the Open four times, and Gene Sarazen. 
 Only one amateur could break the stranglehold of the professionals but Bobby Jones, who in 1930 took the British and American amateur and open titles in a unique Grand Slam, was an American. 
 Henry Cotton, who won the Open in 1934 and 1937 and then again in 1948 kept up British hopes. 
 Thereafter Bobby Locke of South Africa and Peter Thomson of Australia dominated the British professional game alongside American entrants for the Open for twenty years after the Second World War. 
 From their Edwardian dominance of golf and tennis, the British slipped back to the second rank. 
 Our amateurs were simply not dedicated enough to win at a world level. 
 It was not just a question of climate as the British sometimes liked to think. 
 Certainly Americans and Australians could play sport for more of the year but they did so in a more positive, meritocratic context where success was admired and recognized for its own sake. 
 Until recently social barriers both kept the working-class out of suburban sports and decreed that being a professional was a kind of elevated manual labour and not a proper or respectable career for a middle-class man. 
 Hence our shortage of great players. 
 PRESS, TELEVISION, AND PROFIT 
 Although professionalism was restricted and most governing sports bodies held themselves aloof from the pursuit of profit, the impression remains that sport soon became part of a &bquo;leisure, industry catering for the needs of a new kind of urban consumer. 
 Spectator sport in this respect seems to be a part of a wider system of entertainment&equo; which embraced the music-hall and the cinema, the record industry &bquo;and the dance-hall. 
 The growth of the popular press, which could bring news of the latest entertainment to the breakfast tables of the nation, clearly has played a crucial role in defining sport as part of a commercialized mass culture. 
 But when and how did this happen? 
 The enormous success of televised sport within the last twenty years has certainly been decisive in turning matches into &bquo;media events&equo; and in attracting commercial investment at unprecedented levels. 
 But this is all quite new and it does not follow that previous generations of advertisers were as enthusiastic about sport. 
 The progress of sport as a &bquo;commodity&equo; either to be sold to the media in its own right or to be used in order to sell other products was slower and more halting than might be imagined. 
 The press have played a major part in popularizing spectator sport and sustaining interest in it, but it is misleading to think of professional football, for example, as having been created or manufactured by the media. 
 The press reflected the living culture of the people; it could influence opinion and reinforce existing attitudes but it did not create new forms of entertainment and rarely attempted to alter the habits or loyalties of its readership. 
 The links between sport, the media &bquo;and big business &bquo;which are now so important, have taken a long time to forge. 
 Sport had always been a prominent source of news in its own right. 
 The early sporting papers such as Bell's Life in London  existed to give news of forthcoming events and descriptions of recent ones &bquo;mostly races and prize-fights. 
 The Sporting Magazine  was more interested in hunting and published the literary work of &bquo;Nimrod&equo; and Surtees along with more conventional reporting of sports events. 
 These papers were not so much creating a new market as servicing an established public interest. 
 This responsiveness of the specialist press to popular tastes remained extremely important throughout the nineteenth century as modern organized sports came into being. 
 The Sporting Life , which was essentially a racing-paper, had a circulation of 300,000 by the 1880s and the Athletic News , a weekly journal begun from Manchester in 1875, which concentrated on providing a wide range of football match reports &bquo;was soon claiming 100 &bquo;000. 
 In Scotland the Scottish Athletic Journal  was started in 1882 coming out on Fridays for 2d. and was soon selling 20 &bquo;000 copies. 
 It merged six years later with the Scottish Umpire  to form Scottish Sport , which appeared twice weekly at 1d. and claimed a circulation of 43,000. 
 But competition was fierce and the Scottish Referee , costing only a halfpenny and appearing on Monday afternoons with the reports of the weekend's activities, soon put in a challenge. 
 &bquo;The Specials&equo;, the Saturday night sporting press which reported in detail the performances of local teams, spread rapidly. 
 There were only four such papers in the 1880s, but eighteen in the 1890s and after 1900 they were ubiquitous &mdash; &bquo;as much a part of the cultural scene as the gas-lamp and the fish-and-chip shop&equo;. 
 In Scotland the &bquo;white&equo; edition of the Evening News  competed with the &bquo;green-of the Evening Citizen  and the &bquo;pink &bquo;of the Evening Times . 
 On late Saturday afternoons, at the corner the kerb is covered with men who stand with their backs to the light, intently reading in a pink newspaper full of poetical reporting and results &bquo;noted an observer of Glasgow in 1901. 
 The habit of reading the &bquo;football special&equo; died hard. 
 Even after radio reporting of results began between the wars, the &bquo;pink'uns&equo; and &bquo;green'uns&equo; kept their readers. 
 There were dialect pieces and local banter along with information on how a particular local player had performed a couple of hundred miles away. 
 In Barnsley in the early 1950s men were even seen reading the &bquo;green'un&equo; over their partner's shoulder as they mechanically steered the wife around the ballroom on a Saturday night. 
 At first football was not so much the creature of the mass press as the source of new specialist newspapers. 
 But the technology that permitted the almost immediate availability of match results and reports meant that sport came to occupy a larger place in the daily national press. 
 Coverage, however&equo; was patchy and varied. 
 The Times  gave prominence to cricket but thought the FA Cup Final in 1914 &bquo;of comparatively little interest except to the Lancashire working classes&equo; (the game was between Liverpool and Burnley). 
 Of greater interest to The Times  was the attendance of the King at the match for the first time and the fact that a cuckoo had been heard in the vicinity of the Crystal Palace. 
 More popular papers, however, like Reynold's News  were starting to give football ample coverage from the mid-1880s. 
 From ten match reports in 1882 there were twenty-five in 1886 for Association football. 
 The Sunday Chronicle  contained sports reports from its inception in 1885. 
 The popular daily press in the Edwardian years began to give quite a prominent place to sport. 
 The &bquo;sports page&equo; at the back of the paper established itself, though the emphasis remained on results and reports rather than background gossip and speculation about future selections. 
 Observers of inner-city youth noted that along with smoking and clothes, talking about sport was the main amusement of lads on the street-corner. 
 Football was their chief interest but they also followed cricket. 
 The new literacy arising from compulsory elementary education meant that boys could read about a sport which was organized in a way that made it difficult to watch regularly. 
 A London observer remarked that &bquo;the fortunes of the Surrey team are followed with that breathless and extravagant interest which demands a copy of every edition of the Star &equo;. 
 In Birmingham &bquo;the evening papers are eagerly read each night, and scores of boys who never play themselves are able to name at any time the runs made by prominent cricketers&hellip; and in seasons like the present &bquo;discuss readily and ably the claims of the individual members of the Australian team to be considered really worthy exponents of the game&equo;. 
 From the 1920s sports reporting and photography was accepted as a crucial and specialized component of popular journalism. 
 Significantly, the Athletic News , which had provided splendid weekly coverage, fell from its 170,000 circulation and disappeared as an independent title in 1931. 
 The daily national press took up the cause of sport with a vengeance. 
 Taking their lead from the &bquo;gee-whizzers&equo; of American journalism, a more colourful, gossipy style of writing took over from the rather self-consciously poetic late Victorian style with its &bquo;hapless custodians&equo; and &bquo;leather spheroids&equo;. 
 There was more team speculation and more dressing-room chat, especially in the popular Sunday papers, whose circulation rose enormously between the wars. 
 The People , which boasted &bquo;four pages of sport&equo;, sold 600,000 copies in 1924 and 4,600 &bquo;000 in 1946. 
 By 1950 it was devoting over a third of its space to sport with particular emphasis on football. 
 The People  even financed a year-long secret investigation of football in the early 1960s which brought to light a gambling-ring betting on the results of two or three games, which they &bquo;fixed&equo; by bribing players. 
 The search for soccer stories occupied a new breed of journalist &mdash; men like Alan Hoby, the self-styled &bquo;Man Who Knows&equo;, or the &bquo;Man Who Knows F &mdash; All&equo; as he was known to some of his readers. 
 The News of the World  with its phenomenal eight million circulation, the Daily Mail , and the Daily Express  all gave increasing space to sport. 
 Sports writing, especially match reporting, was an &bquo;art&equo; in itself. 
 Inflated language sometimes enlivened a dull game but most match reports were glib and full of clich&eacute;s. 
 Inside forwards would &bquo;turn on a sixpence&equo;; a centre-forward would &bquo;rise like a salmon&equo; and so on. 
 The habit of reading the paper backwards even spread to the quality press. 
 Neville Cardus gained a devoted following for his lyrical cricket writing as well as his musical reviews for the Manchester Guardian  between the wars. 
 The Times  could also be counted upon for lengthy discussion of cricket and Rugby Union, both from specialist reporters and from their readers through the institution of the Letters Page which became an important forum for influential discussion of these games. 
 The sensationalist side of sports reporting has gone from strength to strength in the popular press since the advent of television. 
 What happens off the pitch is the stuff of the sports pages &mdash; team rows, family rows, drink, and sex. 
 A recent critic complained about the &bquo;clich&eacute;s, the daft, ghosted &bquo;star names&equo; columns, the silly photos (remember Ian Botham as &bquo;Rambo&equo;?), the creation of heroes and villains, the concentration on the star or the result of the moment, the search for conflict, the trivialization of sporting women, the insularity (beyond Dover, forget it), the emphasis on spectating rather than participating, the dearth of analysis, the marginal treatment of those who don't quite &bquo;make it&equo;. 
 The &bquo;quality&equo; press aside, this seems a fair verdict on the tabloids. 
 The recent Sunday Sport  contains little but topless models and sports gossip. 
 Yet the power of the press within sport has until recently been severely circumscribed. 
 Journalists could whip up public indignation but cricket and football authorities were singularly unresponsive to press influence apart from The Times . 
 The educated amateur, whose organizational influence remained so strong, rarely listened to journalists. 
 Moreover, club directors were tolerably insulated from outside pressure. 
 They could not avoid criticism but they could usually ignore it. 
 And a few, like J. J. Bentley, a former chairman of Manchester United, had a financial stake in the press themselves. 
 Until the 1950s, at least, the press tended to react to events in the sporting world rather than &bquo;create&equo; them. 
 The FA were brusque with Fleet Street, often hardly bothering to organize press conferences or explain themselves. 
 When they took their stand against gambling on the football pools by refusing to release the fixture-lists in advance, they incurred the wrath of the press as well as the pools promoters. 
 Here Herbert Chapman stands apart. 
 He was ahead of his time and set the pattern for the post-war development of soccer as a &bquo;media event&equo;. 
 Chapman, a Yorkshireman, had not had much success as a player, but he shone as a manager, first with Huddersfield and then with Arsenal, where he had a salary of &pound;2,000 a year and wrote a column for the Sunday Express  into the bargain. 
 Chapman made real efforts to shape the image of his team in the press and encouraged his players to promote themselves in public. 
 He was usually available for comment and did not talk down to journalists. 
 He used his generous transfer funds to the maximum advantage both to secure great players and to create a &bquo;star&equo; image for the club. 
 Despite his flair and populism, he was a cautious man who took great comfort from the fact that his son had not become a footballer but was securely settled in the middle class as a solicitor. 
 Significantly, his successor was not a football player at all but a journalist who got to know the Arsenal chairman while working as a society correspondent for the New York Herald . 
 The major professional influence in his career, he later claimed, was meeting the publicity agents for Buffalo Bill's Wild West Show and seeing how the Americans managed the media. 
 He became one of the first football commentators on radio, copying the urgent, excitable American style of the &bquo;gee-whizzers&equo;, earning himself the nickname of &bquo;By Jove&equo; Allison on the way. 
 If Allison's style was a little out of place in the sober, earnest world of Reith's BBC in the 1920s, sport itself proved an immediate success at the Corporation. 
 In fact, broadcasting, first through radio and then even more dramatically on television &bquo;has been the single most important influence on the development of sport in this century. 
 The number of radio licences rose from two to eight million between 1926 and 1939 with 71 per cent of all households having a wireless by the Second World War. 
 The first sports broadcast, ironically at the suggestion of the Daily Mail , was of a fight between Kid Lewis and Georges Carpentier in 1922. 
 Sport came to have an important place in the BBC canon of &bquo;good&equo; entertainment, though boxing did not meet with full official approval. 
 The aim of the new Director-General was to promote sport as well as Christianity. 
 Reith was the true successor of the Victorian headmaster, rapidly establishing a range of sporting events which the BBC in its capacity as the sole arbiter of airways deemed to be of national  significance. 
 A few big events joined the list of approved patriotic &bquo;moments&equo; like Remembrance Day &mdash; the Wembley crowd even sang &bquo;Abide With Me&equo; &mdash; and in Reith's words permitted the British people to be &bquo;present equally at functions and ceremonials upon which national sentiment is consecrated&equo;. 
 Test cricket, Rugby internationals, the Derby, and the Cup Final were established favourites. 
 The annual rowing contest between the two ancient universities was a great London event with many ordinary families taking sides and wearing favours but it was hardly a matter of &bquo;national&equo; concern until the BBC included the Boat Race in the select band of truly British events. 
 &bquo;Look how that's come to the fore,&equo; remarked a Bristol listener, &bquo;we never used to know anything about it and now there's many wouldn't miss it.&equo; 
 Seventy per cent of the audience panel of a BBC survey in 1939 listened to the Boat Race followed by 51 per cent for boxing, 50 per cent for soccer, and 50 per cent for cricket; soccer and boxing were predictably the favourites of the working-class respondents but the 34 per cent overall interest in Wimbledon was a clear indication that hitherto bourgeois sports were broadening their appeal. 
 The BBC under Reith placed great emphasis on control from the centre and from above; the BBC was an openly &eacute;litist institution which &bquo;knew best&equo; what the public needed and suppressed regional variations and creativity. 
 Local sporting traditions were ignored in favour of a handful of sports which were singled out as worthy of national broadcasting. 
 Gerald Cock, head of Outside Broadcasting, led a team of technicians who increasingly brought live sport into the home. 
 Sports commentators had what many came to consider the most enviable job in the world; they had the best seats for the best events in return for talking about what they loved anyway. 
 This, at least, is how many people saw the job, though few understood the difficulties involved. 
 &bquo;It is easier to make a commentator into a temporary expert than a true expert into a commentator&equo;, wrote the Daily Dispatch . 
 It was from the ranks of Oxbridge enthusiasts that these commentators were mostly drawn. 
 George Allison has already been mentioned, but even better known were Howard Marshall, the Test match commentator, Freddie Grisewood, later to chair &bquo;Any Questions&equo;, and Colonel Wakeham on rugby. 
 Best known of all was John Snagge. 
 Though he did other broadcasts, Snagge was particularly fond of the Boat Race, which he made his own for forty years. 
 In 1951 &bquo;he was so excited that all he could say was &bquo;It's a desperately close race &mdash; I can't quite see from here who is ahead &mdash; it's either Oxford or Cambridge&equo;. 
 Sports reporting certainly had its difficulties for the live commentator, who might be held up to ridicule for a lapse of sense or grammar in the heat of the moment. 
 David Coleman has unwittingly given his name to this tradition of sporting gaffe published mercilessly in Private Eye , of which Murray Walker's &bquo;this car is absolutely unique, except for the one behind, which is identical&equo; must stand for the many. 
 Maybe the commentator's lot is not such a happy one after all. 
 Interviewing the likes of Lester Piggott or notoriously inarticulate footballers whose only comment on scoring a hat-trick is &bquo;I'm over the moon&equo; or &bquo;I just hit it into the back of the net, Brian&equo; cannot be the simplest of tasks. 
 Commentators are a maligned lot and deserve some credit for disseminating enthusiasm for sport on a hitherto unimagined scale. 
 This was a two-way process. 
 Coverage of sport certainly helped popularize the otherwise earnest BBC. 
 Manufacturers could play on the excitement of a commentary to sell their sets. 
 &bquo;Tense with excitement&hellip; thrilled. 
 Almost seeing the game, ss clearly does he hear it. 
 Can you wonder that he shouts?&equo; 
 (The illustration shows a man getting out of his armchair yelling &bquo;Shoot, Man, Shoot!&equo;) 
 This excitement, the copy-writer continues, is brought into the home courtesy of &bquo;the new Pye Portable&hellip; glorious in tone, generous in volume, comprehensive in range of reception&equo;. 
 Sport spread from the stands and into the home with the Cup Final as the sporting highlight of the year reaching a female audience for the first time. 
 Writing in the Radio Times  in 1930, the novelist Winifred Holtby, feminist and friend of Vera Brittain, recalled listening to her first football commentary: 
 I was excited. 
 I had not, I have not to this day, the remotest notion of what they were all doing. 
 But I know that I was excited. 
 No one could listen with cold blood and sluggish pulses to the quickening crescendo of the roar preceding the final shout of &bquo;Goal!&equo; 
 I wanted more goals. 
 I didn't care who shot them. 
 I didn't know who shot them. 
 I didn't know who was playing or what they were playing, or where, or why. 
 But I wanted to feel my spine tickle and my pulses beat, and my hair stir gently at the roots with suspense as that voice cried out from somewhere near our drawing room curtains. 
 &bquo;Now he's got it. 
 It's coming close on the right wing. 
 I can't see for a moment because of the crowd. 
 Ah, there it is now, he's got it. 
 Jarvis has it. 
 Jarvis has it. 
 Goal!&equo; 
 Judging by this description that breathless voice probably belonged to none other than &bquo;By Jove&equo; Allison. 
 The national dimension to sports reporting and the search for heroes could be a source of anxiety and even distress to the more reticent sportsman. 
 When Jack Hobbs was approaching W. G. Grace's record for the number of first-class centuries the massive attention of the press actually caused him a brief loss of form. 
 But there was another profitable side to the coin. 
 Despite his shyness and natural modesty, Hobbs was willing to capitalize on his fame. 
 He endorsed &mdash; not without payment for some, though not all &mdash; fountain-pens, cricket-bats and equipment, cocoa, total abstinence, chocolate, and soft drinks. 
 He was filmed, interviewed, and provided with &bquo;ghosts&equo; who helped him to &bquo;write&equo; nine books, one of them a thriller called The Test Match  Surprise which was something of a best seller in the sixpenny &bquo;Readers' Library&equo; ss popular in Woolworth's in the 1920s. 
 Hobbs did better than his soccer counterpart, Dixie Dean, whose goal-scoring achievements were so famous for a decade from 1927. 
 He was used to advertise Players' cigarettes but was not even paid a proper fee. 
 &bquo;Dixie&equo; &mdash; a nickname said to derive from his swarthy complexion and curly black hair &mdash; preferred to augment his income by making bets with bookmakers on the basis of the number of goals he could score in a game (one goal was evens, two goals 5&ndash;2, and three 10- 1), Sportsmen, especially footballers, had since the 1880s been used on cigarette cards as free advertising for a brand. 
 Clubs were better placed than inexperienced individuals to profit from advertising, which began to expand the commercial potential of sport in the 1930s. 
 The Cup finalists of 1934 promoted brands of trousers, shoe-polish, and Shredded Wheat. 
 Manchester City gave their endorsement to a new model of radio. 
 Yet by the standards of current advertising and sponsorship the sums involved and the use made of sport by advertisers was paltry. 
 It was not enough to be the best in the world at your chosen sport, as Joe Davis found to his cost. 
 Golf and tennis had an exclusive image (good for selling cars) but snooker, the most popular indoor sport, had a seedy side which discouraged advertisers. 
 The new world snooker champion was aware of the commercial potential of his title, but was unable to persuade companies to comply with his desire to endorse their products. 
 &bquo;I tried eye-lotions and hair-lotions, shirtmakers and shoe-makers without eliciting the slightest flicker of interest. 
 The only contract for endorsing a product I obtained in those days was for Churchman's cigarettes.&equo; 
 Television more than anything else has transformed the image of the professional sportsman or woman from the skilled artisan (&bquo;master of their craft&equo;) to the dubious cinematic status of &bquo;star&equo;, or currently &bquo;superstar&equo; or &bquo;megastar&equo; as show-business hyperbole infects sport. 
 Newsreel coverage of sport paved the way for this. 
 Snappy, short news sequences certainly helped promote some of the big names but this was on a small scale in comparison with the United States where a few outstanding sportsmen became Hollywood stars. 
 However, it was the advent of television which really transformed sportsmen. 
 The &bquo;TV revolution&equo; started modestly enough with small screens and black-and-white pictures, which were not able to follow a match with the fluency, play-backs, close-ups, and other techniques that have made sport increasingly a &bquo;televisual&equo; phenomenon of late. 
 Football was used as a way of encouraging working people to buy or hire televisions in the 1950s with the slogan &bquo;When they are talking about the big match on TV will you have to remain silent?&equo; 
 Television offered either live coverage or by editing down the best moments presented a particularly dramatic version of events. 
 A series of specialist sports programmes culminated in the setting up of &bquo;Sportsview&equo; in 1954, a half-hour mid-week programme which interviewed personalities &mdash; Mike Hawthorn, Stirling Moss, and Danny Blanchflower featured in October 1954 &mdash; as well as giving previews of top events. 
 Peter Dimmock was the genial presenter and a powerful expansionist force in BBC sport, heading a list of commentators which included such familiar names as Harry Carpenter, Kenneth Wolstenholme, Henry Longhurst, John Arlott, Brian Johnston, Peter West, and David Coleman among others. 
 A few, like Cliff Michelmore, went on to bigger things. 
 But most have stayed and worn well, reassuring and fixed points in an otherwise changing landscape. 
 The &bquo;Beeb&equo; has been kind to its commentators &mdash; thirty years is a long time in television &mdash; and they in turn have served it well, adjusting cleverly to the growing informality of broadcasting without ever quite forgetting the august institution in which &bquo;they serve&equo;. 
 The BBC believe that no one does sport as well as they do &mdash; and they may be right. 
 The popular press could not compete and has been pushed more and more into the &bquo;human interest&equo; dimension, interviewing friends and relations of players, stoking up dressing-room feuds and seizing upon the sex lives of the young, virile, and wayward. 
 This pressure from within the media was reinforced by other social changes. 
 Rising real incomes, especially for the young, minimal unemployment, and greater personal freedom from into which sportsmen, especially footballers, were to find an important place. 
 George Best, a thin teenager from Belfast, whose dribbling skills made him into a star with Manchester United and the darling of the sports and gossip columns epitomized the new era. 
 Alex James in the 1930s had not been averse to appearing at the odd night-club, but Best's moves were tracked by a posse of desperate journalists as he went from bed to boutique, from discoth&egrave;que to dressing-room. 
 Next to the Beatles and Mick Jagger he was probably the best-known teenage &bquo;pin up&equo;. 
 The footballer as sex symbol was not exactly new &mdash; Dixie Dean had been the subject of female interest and cited in at least one paternity suit &mdash; but the avidity of the press for salacious gossip and the relentless pursuit of young footballers, who were suddenly rich and emotionally immature, was new. 
 Players certainly gained in terms of rising wages, advertising, and other sources of income, but at the highest level they often found there were new stresses to cope with as they were &bquo;declassed&equo; and lost touch with their old communities. 
 Television has had as profound an effect on contemporary sport as the railway or the popular press had on Victorian sport. 
 For television is not a &bquo;neutral&equo; provider of images or a mere facilitator, it has increasingly determined the manner in which high performance sport is played and presented to the public. 
 In the early 1950s no more than 10 per cent of households had a television. 
 By the late 1960s only 10 per cent did not. 
 Not having a television was odd &mdash; the product either of extreme deprivation or self-conscious intellectualism. 
 From the beginning sport was extremely popular with those who ran television. 
 The reason is not hard to find. 
 Sport was both cheap and successful. 
 It was &bquo;good television&equo; and there were virtually no production costs in a sports broadcast in comparison with making a play or a documentary feature. 
 A fee was paid to the ruling body and in the early years these were very low indeed. 
 Huge audiences could be entertained at relatively little cost. 
 Currently sport occupies a quarter of the BBC's own production and 17 per cent of its total output, though the fees for broadcasting have risen by as much or more than a thousandfold for certain sports like tennis and golf. 
 Swimming is still cheap but athletics is getting more expensive. 
 The physicality of sport, its speed and grace, along with the emotional intensity of victory and defeat are supremely visual. 
 But this is not all. 
 Sport has a crucial further attraction. 
 It is &bquo;live&equo; entertainment at a time when more and more television is pre-recorded and packaged, and even recorded events can sustain uncertainty of outcome if the result is unknown to the viewer. 
 An episode of the highly successful TV comedy The Likely Lads  was based entirely on the two working-class Geordie protagonists not  being told the result of a recorded game. 
 Video technology has made this a frequent topic of male sporting conversation. 
 Sport offers spontaneity which, combined with ever more sophisticated technology, allows a viewer to watch a game from many different angles, moving in for a close-up on the agonized or exultant face of the athlete, or panning back for a shot of the pitch, track, or the seashore during an Open golf championship. 
 In football, rugby, or cricket the ability to stop the frame at the crucial moment or play-back a sequence, which has come recently with the development of video, has actually placed the viewer and the commentator in a better position to make a decision than the unfortunate referee or umpire. 
 Television is the means through which the bulk of the public &bquo;takes part&equo; in sport. 
 Only 14 per cent of a recent sample of the population, who declared themselves to be &bquo;very interested in soccer&equo;, actually played the game or were members of clubs, though 98 per cent watched it on television. 
 Football has been transformed for most of those who follow it from a Saturday afternoon activity in all weathers to a Saturday night home entertainment. 
 Full-length games are edited down to show the highlights in a way which sometimes irritates the purist. 
 The subtleties of the contest &mdash; running off the ball, watching an individual contest between two players rather than following the ball around through the camera lens &mdash; may be sacrificed but these failings have not deterred the audience. 
 The football authorities have debated endlessly about the impact of these changes on their game. 
 Clearly television is not the only reason for falling gates &mdash; affluence and a consequently greater variety of choice in entertainment, a desire to participate in physical exercise rather than watch, hooliganism, suburban family-centredness, and feminism are other factors all pulling more or less in the direction of declining live attendance. 
 Banning TV coverage might lose important revenues without bringing back the crowds. 
 Most probably the solution in the longer term will be a switch to the American pattern, which stresses quality over quantity. 
 This might mean co-opting the top Scottish clubs into a &bquo;British&equo; premier league &mdash; still a horrifying prospect to most Scots. 
 However things turn out the geography of football based on the Industrial Revolution seems likely to change in favour of a small &bquo;super league&equo; which will take high earnings from a &bquo;live&equo; national TV audience. 
 In effect this is already starting to happen through television concentration on a few top clubs with only a brief nod in the direction of the rest. 
 The football authorities have not been the only ones to agonize over the impact of television on sport. 
 There have been the predictable complaints that people increasingly prefer to watch than to play, that we are producing a generation of armchair athletes. 
 Recent social research has dismissed such speculation. 
 Television may have made inroads on the number of live spectators but, if anything, it has encouraged a greater degree of participation in a far wider range of activities. 
 There has been a huge expansion of golf, for example, the attractions of which were brought home to the general public through the televising of tournaments. 
 Even Association football has grown at the grass roots with a further 2,000 clubs affiliating to the FA in the second half of the 1970s to make up a total of almost 40,000. 
 So participation in sport is increasing although women, the old, the unskilled, and those without private transport are still under-represented. 
 Watching on TV and taking part are not so much mutually exclusive as part of a balanced human cycle of passive and active involvement. 
 Recently television has contributed dramatically to the rejuvenation of particular sports, most notably darts and snooker. 
 The medium is particularly well suited to close-up shots and the viewer can make his assessment of the situation from behind the player's arm. 
 When Joe Davis finally retired in 1964 he said &bquo;snooker has no future&equo;. 
 Yet only twenty years later the Crucible Theatre in Sheffield was the focus of the attention of around twenty million viewers as Steve Davis was defeated on the final ball of the final frame by Dennis Taylor, who became the world champion in what The Times  (won over to &bquo;popular culture&equo; under its antipodean ownership) declared to be a &bquo;heart-stopping&equo; match. 
 Snooker has been reborn through colour television. 
 What began as an attempt to diversify and cater for minority interests on BBC 2 turned into an extraordinary national obsession. 
 Snooker players clash not just as players but as personalities with their own quirks, style, and personal feuds &mdash; Alex Higgins &bquo;The Hurricane&equo; or Jimmy White &bquo;The Tooting Tearaway&equo; set against the inscrutable, trance-like calmness of Steve Davis or Cliff Thorburn, or the bantering and benign Dennis Taylor and Willie Thorne; all the &bquo;lads&equo; are part of an immensely lucrative media &bquo;hype&equo; carefully planned by a professional promoter-cum-accountant. 
 &bquo;Whispering&equo; Ted Lowe was suddenly a celebrity with murmured thoughts about the difficulty of &bquo;a long pink against the nap into the top pocket&equo;. 
 A similar process is also taking place in darts led by an exuberant Geordie commentator with a Cambridge History degree. 
 Rugby, in particular, has its &bquo;characters&equo; &mdash; Eddie Waring, a favourite with a generation of impressionists, brought the banter of the Yorkshire terraces into the commentary-box; Bill Maclaren is the embodiment of Borders rugby &mdash; firm, crackling along, supremely direct, enthusiastic and decent, a yeoman of Scotland. 
 Appropriately enough, he is a schoolmaster and not a full-time professional commentator. 
 Picking the select few to make the transition from a successful playing career in football to television reporting has become a minor entertainment in itself. 
 Football now has Bob Wilson of Arsenal and Emlyn Hughes of Liverpool and on independent television there is Ian StJohn and Jimmy Greaves (&bquo;The Saint and Greavsie&equo;), who have taken the art of televised sport a step further by reproducing in the studio all the mixture of jokes and outlandish memories, bets, hunches, tactical shrewdness, and affectionate &bquo;piss-taking&equo; that make up a friendly hour in the pub. 
 Television, it should be remembered, can conserve and celebrate just as it can abbreviate and denature. 
 Despite the view that television has created a &bquo;global village&equo; in which similar electronic images flicker before countless millions creating a common mass culture, the presentation of sport on British television differs sharply from that of the United States or of France. 
 Each country develops its own ways of using television to promote its own tastes and values. 
 Styles of commentary, methods of editing, programming schedules, and the interspersing of sport with other subjects all contribute to establishing national styles within the framework of a common technology. 
 ln Britain, the pattern of televised sport has in many respects followed the natural preferences of the &bquo;amateur&equo; establishment. 
 With the exception of the Cup Final, the independent channels have concentrated on racing and on wrestling for Saturday afternoon entertainment and do not show golf or cricket. 
 Currently the ITV sports budget is around &pound;14 million. 
 &bquo;In newspaper terms, the BBC is much more Telegraph  and we are the Mirror  or even the Sun &equo;, remarked ITV's head of sport recently. 
 As an established &bquo;national&equo; institution the BBC head of sport claims &bquo;we don't approach life from a purely business point of view&equo;. 
 Historically the BBC has been in a privileged position to negotiate coverage with the &bquo;gentlemen amateurs&equo; of the MCC, the Committee of the All-England Club, and the four rugby unions. 
 &bquo;I have never attempted to conceal my belief that &bquo;Wimbledon&equo; treated us generously,&equo; wrote the Head of Outside Broadcasts in 1952. 
 &bquo;I assumed it was the deliberate policy of an amateur sport towards a &bquo;public service&equo;.&equo; 
 From early on the government underpinned this advantage by laying down that certain &bquo;national&equo; events could not be contractually monopolized by either side. 
 This had the effect of giving the BBC an effective monopoly as advertising revenue could best be maximized by providing an alternative to sport on independent television. 
 A cricket audience was too restricted to share profitably. 
 Despite a few celebrated deserters including former England captain Tony Greig, cricket has resisted being incorporated into a private television circus run from Australia by Kerry Packer. 
 Mike Brearley, the subsequent England captain and a Cambridge graduate with a distinctly academic turn of mind, was revealing in his reasons for turning down the offer, which would have overturned the historical structure of international cricket: &bquo;Money apart, Kerry Packer is not my style. 
 England is my home. 
 I prefer the chugging British coaster with a cargo of pig-iron to a monstrous supertanker hurriedly constructed. 
 We put up with the buckets to catch the drips in the dressing-room at Taunton in order to enjoy the wisteria round the door of the George at Bewley.&equo; 
 Cricket, in fact, has negotiated a successful compromise with the world of broadcasting, enjoying extensive coverage, which is now used to gain lucrative &bquo;low-key&equo; sponsorship and advertising. 
 Through their sponsorship of cricket, Cornhill, until recently a little-known City insurance company, turned themselves into a household name at the cost of a million pounds over five years. 
 In 1981 Cornhill's banners appeared 7,459 times on a television service resolutely opposed to advertising. 
 The benefit for Cornhill was its &bquo;awareness level&equo; (the number of people who mentioned it when asked to name an insurance company), which shot up from 2 per cent in 1977 to 17 per cent in 1981. 
 In addition, the firm recruited cricketers for its publicity functions and was given free tickets and entertainment facilities for the Test matches. 
 Naturally, television exposure was the overwhelming consideration for Cornhill and this was presumably also true for other sponsors, which included Schweppes, United Friendly Assurance, Commercial Union Assurance, the Prudential, Gordon's gin, Haig's whisky, Whitbread's beer, Younger's beer, Wrigley's spearmint among others. 
 Despite the &bquo;wisteria&equo;, cricket has come to be quietly alive to capitalism. 
 The same has turned out to be true of show-jumping, a little-known landed pursuit before it was taken up by the BBC as a sport which might appeal to women, especially when Pat Smythe rode Flanagan to four European Championship victories between 1957 and 1963. 
 As the standards of competition became even higher, costs shot up and sponsors came forward to support an activity with high social status and a good media profile. 
 The BBC again found itself the unwilling accomplice of the advertisers. 
 The unfortunate Dorian Williams, whose cultured, distinctly upper-class accent was synonymous with commentary on the sport, was required to tell the viewers that the next contestant was Harvey Smith riding &bquo;Hitachi Music Centre&equo;. 
 &bquo;Trade&equo; had infected even gentry pursuits, though the presence of royalty in the person of Princess Anne and her husband, both competitors of international standard, kept up the social tone. 
 The role of sponsorship and television together has brought vast amounts of new money into sport, providing high earnings for tournament winners or top team-players. 
 In return sportsmen and women have to make themselves available to the press and the sponsors for promotional purposes. 
 A sea-change is taking place. 
 Nineteenth-century amateurism has been stood on its head. 
 Consider the following articles, which by chance appeared side by side in the Guardian  in 1982. 
 One concerned the transfer of Kevin Keegan from Southampton to Newcastle United. 
 The deal involved a transfer fee plus a complicated sponsorship package, which required Keegan to advertise and do promotional work for Scottish and Newcastle Breweries. 
 Keegan duly appeared at the press conference to extol his new club and his sponsors, despite the fact he was known not to drink the product himself. 
 &bquo;You don't have to sell Newcastle United to anyone. 
 This is a great club, the only one that can beat Liverpool for the enthusiasm of its supporters&equo;, he enthused. 
 His instant sincerity was much appreciated by all concerned. 
 Keegan &bquo;did the business&equo; on the field and off. 
 On the same page appeared a sharp rebuke to Ken Brown, an idiosyncratic professional golfer, who had committed the unforgivable sin of refusing to give interviews to the press or television and making good his escape from a crowd of journalists by vaulting over a barrier. 
 &bquo;We view Brown's behaviour very seriously,&equo; said the presiding official, &bquo;he is doing a disservice to the PGA &lsqb;Professional Golfers' Association&rsqb; and to everyone concerned with the game.&equo; 
 The promoter of the tournament went further: &bquo;It's time the PGA brought in a disciplinary element for this sort of behaviour. 
 There is a lot of money to be won this week and people should earn it not only on the course but off it as well.&equo; 
 Brown was a &bquo;bad sport&equo; who was not &bquo;playing the game&equo;, but Keegan was a &bquo;model pro&equo;. 
 Such judgements were based upon a willingness to comply to the full with the turning of sports into a &bquo;media event&equo;. 
 The praise of Keegan and the criticism of Brown might have surprised and distressed earlier generations of gentlemen-amateurs but it was logical in its own terms; if players wished to become rich, they had to sell themselves as well as their skill. 
 The older code, which put the integrity of players and the game itself above money, had been abandoned. 
 Brown was supposed to be a kind of entertainer, albeit a reluctant and irritable one, and he had to sing for his supper. 
 Top sportsmen frequently mixed with celebrities from the 1920s onwards. 
 Footballers sometimes appeared on a music-hall bill in the late Victorian and Edwardian years but it was not until the inter-war years that top players became &bquo;stars&equo;. 
 Steve Bloomer of Derby or Billy Meredith at Manchester were famous locally rather than nationally. 
 Dixie Dean, however, had a wider following. 
 He was friendly not only with well-known boxers and bookies but with George Robey and with other public Merseyside figures like Bessie Braddock. 
 Alex James of Arsenal was worshipped in London and in Scotland. 
 In snooker Joe Davis even put on a show at the Palladium during the Second World War with Tommy Trinder, Sid Field, Arthur Askey, and Tessie O'Shea. 
 Trinder, who became a director of Fulham, pointed the way towards a larger-scale penetration of the boardroom by entertainers. 
 Eric Morecambe's directorship at Luton was another example. 
 The logical culmination of the process came when the pop singer and song-writer Elton John took over the chairmanship of Watford. 
 Pop singer Rod Stewart took inordinate pride in his brief time as a professional with Brentford and would make well-publicized appearances to support Scotland. 
 George Best, as we saw, was closely linked to &bquo;pop culture&equo; and international teams began to make special records as part of a &bquo;media package&equo; for the World Cup. 
 Top sportsmen liked to think of themselves as &bquo;personalities&equo;. 
 Mick Channon observed that &bquo;most famous people are &bquo;characters&equo; (presumably including himself in this select group). 
 When very successful footballers, cricketers, boxers, golfers, even amateur rugby players like Bill Beaumont and Gareth Edwards, retired from their sport they might hope to cash in somehow. 
 They could perhaps join the growing band of pundits. 
 There were talk shows, after-dinner speeches, and quiz programmes as well. 
 Some of these sporting &bquo;characters&equo; play golf and appear with comedians such as Jimmy Tarbuck and Bruce Forsyth or actor Sean Connery for a few holes and a bit of friendly banter. 
 Peter Allis has turned golf into a kind of harmless interview where public figures hit a few shots and chat about themselves. 
 Substantial sums of money are raised for charity by show-biz football teams. 
 The athletic disc jockey is a distinctively contemporary phenomenon. 
 Ian Botham's alleged flirtation with cannabis and the occasional female admirer has occupied the popular press far more than his performances as the great all-rounder of English cricket. 
 He inadvisedly tried to launch himself very briefly in Hollywood. 
 He also walked from John O'Groats to Land's End for charity with celebrities doing well-publicized stints by his side. 
 He has been endlessly harassed by the press who desperately need a story. 
 The &bquo;good guys&equo; are all very well but they don't make headlines. 
 Wimbledon has been dull without McEnroe from the gossip point of view. 
 Cricket can be boring when Botham behaves, and snooker needs Alex Higgins even if it does not like to say so. 
 The crazy circus rolls on and on. 
 More coverage of more sports is supplemented by endless interviews and chat-show appearances. 
 There seems to be no saturation point. 
 Amidst such massive coverage there has been little television interest in what ordinary people get out of sport. 
 Sports programmes do not see this as part of what they are supposed to be doing. 
 Sport is high-performance stuff varied with a bit of club golf played by famous people or a marathon which involves both top athletes and the general public. 
 The availability of less well-known sports very cheaply has attracted some interesting coverage, which brings the viewer closer to the ordinary competitor. 
 For example the sport of crown green bowling, which was very little known outside of the north of England, has been shown to a wider public; the greens are often oddly bereft of spectators, and the northern accents of the players are plainly audible as they urge on their woods or confer solemnly as a pair over the last bowl of an important &bquo;end&equo;. 
 Even these modest broadcasts show only the best of the bunch. 
 Why are there no programmes about ordinary clubs and ordinary people? 
 A rare exception to this unrelieved diet of excellence came recently in the shape of a programme made by unemployed men on Teesside about the place in their life of the municipal golf-course. 
 &bquo;For a couple of hours I feel like a man again,&equo; said one. 
 Another, making a joke out of his poverty, hit a good drive and sighed, &bquo;That's gone further than I went on my holidays.&equo; 
 There was much of this, a few small side-bets, and plenty of mixing between the generations. 
 The club had its blazer and badge, a captain and lady captain and an honours board. 
 It was imitative of the suburban golf club but independent and unashamed. 
 Television had brought golf to the working class and for just a moment television gave us an idea of what it meant to them. 
 HOOLIGANS 
 Hooliganism has been the exception to the rule that the media are only interested in victories, records, and the private life of the stars. 
 In recent years the collective aggression displayed by groups of younger fans has caused a kind of &bquo;moral panic&equo; in the press. 
 Football hooliganism has been defined as a major social problem. 
 It has attracted not only widespread condemnation but a fair amount of sociological analysis as well with the result that there is a lively debate taking place about its origins and nature. 
 Of particular interest to the historian is the question of continuity or discontinuity in this kind of behaviour. 
 Did the 1960s see a sharp break in the form and content of the collective behaviour of young working-class spectators? 
 Or is the current wave of hooliganism in British football merely a continuation of old traditions, which we now are less willing to tolerate and more anxious to report? 
 Serious discussion of the phenomenon began with a debate over the role of the press in reporting violent incidents at football matches. 
 It was argued that the sensationalizing of relatively minor forms of rowdyism invented hooliganism as a &bquo;social problem&equo;. 
 Young fans found a new &bquo;hooligan&equo; identity created for them by journalists with a vested interest in whipping up public indignation. 
 Headlines like &bquo;SAVAGES! 
 ANIMALS!&equo; or &bquo;BIRCH&equo; EM&equo; and &bquo;SMASH THESE THUGS&equo; encouraged the public to treat young football fans as criminals, and the fans themselves then acted out the role that had been supplied for them. 
 Garry Whannel traced four main themes in the analysis of football hooliganism in the popular press in the 1970s: fans were &bquo;mindless/senseless&equo;; they were &bquo;maniacs/lunatics&equo;; &bquo;foul/subhuman&equo; (which led some fans to chant back at the police and the respectable public &bquo;We hate humans&equo;); finally that they were &bquo;so-called supporters&equo; and in a small minority, i.e. they made up only a very small percentage of the crowd and they had little interest in the game itself. 
 Much of this analysis of the media treatment of hooliganism drew upon the work of Stanley Cohen. 
 The new &bquo;sociology of deviance&equo; suggested hooligans were not abnormal young people and that the whole phenomenon &mdash; like the Mods and Rockers panic before &mdash; had been &bquo;amplified&equo; by the popular press in order to boost their circulation and pander to the prejudices of their readers. 
 One of the most enduring and widespread of these prejudices, which achieved the status of a popular myth, was that &bquo;things weren't like that in my day&equo;. 
 Geoffrey Pearson's recent Hooligan: a History of Respectable Fears  gives a persuasive account of law-and-order myths, which shows that people continually locate &bquo;the good old days&equo; of decent behaviour at some time about twenty or thirty years in the past. 
 Those concerned about football hooliganism today idealize the stable post-war years when it was safe to be on the terraces and one could walk the streets at night. 
 Yet back in the 1950s there was the &bquo;Teddy Boy&equo; to alarm the public and to set against the allegedly poor but honest inter-war years when people could leave their doors unlocked. 
 Between the wars the kind of juvenile gang-violence portrayed, for example, in Graham Greene's Brighton Rock  again led to unfavourable comparisons being made with the past. 
 In the 1920s and 1930s London had its &bquo;Drury Lane Boys&equo;, &bquo;Fulham Boys&equo;, &bquo;Waterloo Road Gang&equo;, &bquo;Chelsea Boys&equo;, and many more. 
 Glasgow was notoriously violent. 
 Billy Fullerton's Protestant gang from Bridgeton wreaked havoc on Catholics, especially if they incautiously made themselves easy targets by wearing a Celtic scarf. 
 However, a closer look at the supposedly more stable Edwardian era found men like Baden-Powell and Charles Masterman deeply concerned over the problem of &bquo;boy life&equo;;, adolescence was invented as a unique psychological stage and youth cults like the &bquo;Ikey boys&equo; were defined as a &bquo;problem&equo; requiring &bquo;solutions&equo; such as special &bquo;youth clubs&equo; and movements. 
 And so the process went on; back into the Dickensian world of the Artful Dodger and then the violence of the eighteenth-century &bquo;mob&equo;. 
 Each generation created its own myth of stability and fastened upon disorderly juvenile elements in its own culture to prove the thesis. 
 Pearson sums up his argument as follows: 
 Across the centuries, we have seen the sane rituals of territorial dominance, trials of strength, gang fights, mockery against elders and authorities, and antagonism towards &bquo;outsiders&equo; as typical focuses for youthful energy and aggressive mischief. 
 Even under vastly different social conditions there are striking continuities between the violent interruptions to pre-industrial fairs and festivals, and the customary eruptions during modern Bank Holidays or the weekly carnival of misrule at contemporary football games &mdash; where the football rowdy, with his territorial edginess, mascots, emblems and choral arrangements in the &bquo;rough music&equo; tradition, must seem like the incarnation of the unruly apprentice, or the late Victorian &bquo;Hooligan&equo;. 
 The opening sections of this book have already provided evidence of juvenile &bquo;misrule&equo; in pre-industrial and in modern sports. 
 Violence of different kinds has certainly been endemic in sport and fighting between groups of players or spectators is nothing new. 
 Territoriality was the key to urban working-class sporting loyalties and this was sometimes expressed in acts of violence. 
 So to what extent is juvenile violence a &bquo;constant&equo; varying only in style and in detail over time? 
 The notion that the media have &bquo;amplified&equo; football violence may have been tenable ten or twenty years ago, but the current scale of hooliganism does not appear to be much exaggerated by the media. 
 Recently the press have, if anything, tended to understate the extent of the problem to deny hooligans &bquo;the oxygen of publicity&equo;. 
 The view that hooligans actually learn how to behave from the papers and reflect back to the public the image that has been created for them is not really borne out in personal interviews. 
 Moreover, the nature of crowd behaviour may be different from the past not just in style but in substance. 
 The &bquo;continuity&equo; thesis is obviously attractive to the social historian but important reservations and unanswered questions remain. 
 In essence the issues are these: first, given the old traditions of &bquo;misrule&equo; and &bquo;gang life&equo;, how far do contemporary forms of violence in sport resemble earlier ones; second, why did football matches &mdash; the stadia, the surroundings, the routes and transport to and from the game &mdash; become the chosen site of hooligan behaviour? 
 If continuity is the key to football hooliganism, then there should be some solid evidence of similar forms of violence at football matches since the formation of the Football League. 
 If discontinuity is the case, there is the alleged distinctiveness of recent crowd behaviour and explanations of it as part of a general transformation of the urban working class since 1945 to consider. 
 First we need a proper idea of what it is we are seeking to explain. 
 Who are the hooligans? 
 This is reasonably easy to answer. 
 Judging by surveys and by convictions they are largely white, urban, unskilled school-leavers ln their teens. 
 Married hooligans are relatively rare. 
 What is &bquo;hooligan&equo; behaviour? 
 Social psychologists have attempted to pin it down using video recordings, &bquo;participant/observer&equo; reports, and interviews with hooligans. 
 What emerges is that much of the actual group aggression &mdash; the chanting, threats, charges &mdash; is symbolic and ritualized. 
 Hooligans go through the motions of violence but relatively little damage is done either to property or to the person. 
 The danger of injury or death arises less from fights between rival groups of fans as from the panic that actual or threatened attacks provoke amongst the general public. 
 The tragedy at the Heysel stadium in Brussels, for example, came from the crush of spectators fleeing from the drunken charges of Liverpool fans. 
 None of the 38 who died was murdered personally by English hooligans. 
 The point here is not to exonerate the violent behaviour of certain Liverpool supporters but rather the reverse, i.e. to emphasize the potentially fatal risks which are being run each week in stadia where large and rowdy confrontations of young spectators take place. 
 The Ibrox casualties of 1902, the Bolton disaster of 1946, and others were a result of overcrowding and poor facilities, but the Heysel deaths were caused by hooligans. 
 The violence of the fans itself may be largely symbolic (though beatings and occasionally stabbings do take place), but its potential consequences in enclosed spaces present a genuine danger to public safety. 
 It is not reasonable to suggest that hooliganism is merely inflated by the press and best treated by &bquo;radical non-intervention&equo;. 
 The concentration of several thousand younger fans systematically chanting abuse and taunting one another, forcibly separated by the police and each threatening to attack the other is neither an imaginary problem nor simply a product of imitative behaviour picked up from incautious media coverage. 
 Fans dress carefully in order to identify themselves within their group. 
 The styles change with bewildering rapidity but the way of tying a scarf or the kind of boots and socks worn carry a message about the &bquo;hardness&equo; of the wearer. 
 &bquo;Hardness&equo; is what much of hooligan behaviour is about. 
 When hooligans themselves are asked to define the term they usually say &bquo;a right little hardnut&equo;; someone willing to get &bquo;stuck in&equo; when a fight breaks out. 
 Most &bquo;hooligans&equo; use the word in a flattering sense to describe the &bquo;hardest&equo; members of their own group. 
 Chanting is &bquo;macho&equo; in the sense that opposing players, supporters, and officials are often abused in sexual terms (&bquo;wankers&equo; and &bquo;cunts&equo;), and some of the scornful chanting has a deliberately &bquo;caveman&equo; style as in &bquo;Oxford Boys we are here/ shag your women, drink your beer/ &mdash; a widely favoured kind of verse freely adapted by other fans. 
 They do not use the &bquo;animal&equo; terms their critics use except in the case of black players where ape-like grunting and the throwing of bananas are common. 
 The most important feature of contemporary hooliganism is the taking and holding of &bquo;ends&equo;. 
 Away supporters, especially those from clubs with &bquo;hooligan&equo; reputations, try to drive home supporters from their traditional end. 
 &bquo;That's what it is,&equo; said a young Cardiff fan, &bquo;that's what it's all about. 
 You've to get in their end and take it &mdash; the away supporters have.&equo; 
 A young Arsenal fan made the same point after having listened rather contemptuously to a discussion by academics about working-class &bquo;resistance&equo; to increasing middle-class infiltration of football. 
 &bquo;They don't give a sod for the students and all the other wankers and pooftas that turn up&equo;, he declared. 
 &bquo;All the North Bank &lsqb;the Highbury hooligan end&rsqb; care about is their team and the other end and that's all there is to it.&equo; 
 Hooligans do not normally attack older or better-off supporters. 
 They save their wrath for other working-class youths like themselves, who happen to have been born or grown up somewhere else. 
 What evidence is there of this kind of behaviour at football matches before the First World War or in the inter-war period? 
 There are plenty of references to violent incidents of various kinds. 
 Football was never an entirely respectable sport and from the outset crowds swore and shouted, occasionally threw things or charged on to the pitch. 
 There are also records of fights between individual spectators and more rarely between groups of spectators. 
 One of the most infamous of all football riots took place in Glasgow in 1909 when a crowd of around 6,000 invaded the pitch at full time. 
 However, in this case, the crowd was angry that extra time was not going to be played and vented their fury on the pitch and the police rather than on one another. 
 Of course, gang fights between supporters of Celtic and Rangers were quite common, especially between the wars, as Bill Murray's study of The Old Finn  makes clear. 
 Something akin to the contemporary pattern of hooliganism has long existed in Glasgow as a result of Irish Catholic immigration and militant working-class Scottish Protestantism. 
 In Glasgow fighting between fans was not just a matter for juveniles. 
 Although youths were predominant, there was no shortage of older men willing to fight for sectarian reasons. 
 Both Rangers' and Celtic supporters were organized into &bquo;brake clubs&equo; in order to travel to away matches. 
 There were frequent rowdy incidents as these gangs of travelling supporters descended on a town for an away match, especially after the First World War when the struggle for Irish independence was at its height. 
 The Celtic brake clubs would sing &bquo;The Soldier's Song&equo;, &bquo;Keep the Green Flag Flying&equo;, and &bquo;God Save Ireland&equo; whilst chalking slogans like &bquo;Rebels 2, Black and Tans 0&equo; on the sides of their carriages and vans. 
 Rangers' supporters replied in kind, and so the blood feud went on and on &mdash; and continues to this day. 
 Glasgow, however, was not Britain. 
 Despite heavy Irish immigration into south Lancashire, the Midlands, and London, Orangeism was less ferocious south of the Border. 
 Certain teams did become very loosely identified with Catholic or Protestant support in Liverpool and Manchester, but this was never a prominent feature of English football or a significant source of violence. 
 Tony Mason, who has weighed up both the composition and the behaviour of Victorian and Edwardian football crowds as carefully as the sketchy evidence permits, suggests that skilled workers were disproportionately dominant within the crowd. 
 It seems probable that it was not until the doubling in the size of crowds between the wars that the &bquo;rough&equo; as opposed to the &bquo;respectable&equo; working class was fully represented as a proportion of the total population. 
 Dunning and Murphy have tried to argue that violent street-gangs, whose antics led to several alarmed inquiries around the turn of the century, were likely to have been present at football matches from the outset. 
 This is speculative but they are on firmer ground when they point out that violent incidents were underreported both by referees in their correspondence with the FA and by the press. 
 A detailed examination of the Leicester Mercury  from 1895 to 1914 has revealed 137 reports of violent incidents nationally as against 116 in the FA minute-books. 
 Moreover, fifty-five of the 137 reports in the Leicester Mercury  related to Leicester itself, which suggests that there was a good deal more trouble at local level than reached the national press or the FA. 
 In fact, only fifteen of the Leicester Mercury's  137 incidents appeared in the FA's total of 116. 
 Conversely the Leicester Mercury  only reported a fraction of the officially minuted FA incidents. 
 &bquo;Underrecording in both directions&equo; was an important factor, as Dunning and Murphy stress. 
 But do these totals prove that hooligan behaviour of a kind broadly comparable with the present day was widespread before the First World War? 
 Looking more closely at the kinds of misbehaviour reported in the Leicester Mercury , the descriptions of crowd offences committed within Leicestershire from 1894 to 1914 do not permit any clear reconstruction of crowd behaviour. 
 Verbal abuse and disorder was the most common category of offence followed by pitch invasions or encroachments. 
 There were sixteen instances of physical violence or assault reported between 1895 and 1914, but these included throwing missiles at players as well as fights between spectators. 
 Going on to the inter-war years the authors note that there was no great reduction in the number of incidents reported in the press, despite the reputation of the large crowds of those years fur generally good behaviour. 
 The bulk of reported incidents again concerned bad language and unsportsmanlike conduct. 
 The authors conclude that the improving image of the game drew a wider and more respectable public, including more women. 
 This runs counter to Mason's suggestion that more unskilled workers attended between the wars. 
 There is no obvious way of resolving the question of crowd composition. 
 Proper data was never collected at the time. 
 One thing, however, is pretty clear. 
 Nowhere in the vast press coverage and literature of match reports is there any reference to the growth of a violent, organized youth subculture within football. 
 Casual, individual violence was almost certainly more common than today but &bquo;hooliganism&equo; in the collective and contemporary sense did not take place at football matches. 
 It is unacceptable to deduce from the lack of prosecutions that hooligan behaviour was formerly tolerated to such a degree that the culprits were neither censured nor prosecuted. 
 The &bquo;argument from silence&equo; will not do, especially in the late Victorian era. 
 During the second half of the nineteenth century the police were increasingly active against all sorts of minor public offences such as drunken or disorderly behaviour or the playing of street games. 
 A moralistic middle-class press or the civic or football authorities themselves would never have ignored systematic gang-violence either in football grounds or around them. 
 The problem of &bquo;street arabs&equo; and juvenile gangs was very much in the mind of those who formed the Boys' Brigade, Church Lads, and the Scouts. 
 A recent oral history of schoolchildren shows how close an eye the police kept on &bquo;larking about&equo;. 
 Home Office reports on football-ground safety in 1924 did not even raise hooliganism as an item on the agenda. 
 The picture which emerges is one where there was a good deal of casual crudity and the occasional fight between individuals or small groups but little orchestrated rowdyism or violence. 
 Examining the reports of the Chief Constable of Birmingham between 1900 and 1940, Tony Mason notes that football does not merit inclusion as a policing problem. 
 Perhaps most eloquent of ali is the simple fact that the grounds themselves were not segregated. 
 Large numbers of &bquo;away&equo; fans were uncommon except for local derbies. 
 Even then opposing fans mixed on the same terraces without the &bquo;taking of ends&equo;. 
 Accounts of watching football composed by ordinary spectators emphasize how familiar many people were to one another, the wide age-range, and the lively banter. 
 A lifelong Manchester City fan recalled that in the 1940s &bquo;it was a very mixed crowd. 
 There were a lot of old blokes, and women, even some elderly women. 
 You ali stood there together. 
 You knew everybody. 
 You never saw'em between games. 
 But we always stood roughly in the same place and we knew the forty or fifty people around us 'cos they were always there. 
 The worst hazard of standing in that crowd was someone pissing down the back of your leg.&equo; 
 There were occasional fights when groups of visiting supporters descended on a local pub but very little trouble at the ground itself. 
 Moreover when there were fights, observed the chairman of the Birmingham City Supporters' Club, &bquo;it was punch-ups among men in those days&hellip; when I was a lad, if I stepped out of line I got a bloody good hiding from my Dad&equo;. 
 Denis Brailsford, an inter-war spectator and a distinguished sports historian, recalled that he first went to football in the 1930s as part of his father's extended family of miners and their wives, who made up the core of a group that regularly went to Mansfield Town's home games. 
 There were few visiting spectators and there was no singing or chanting. 
 However, &bquo;there would be swearing, there would be people coming in drunk&hellip; staggering from the local pubs into the ground, but they were a tiny, tiny minority and you would get the odd fight breaking out&equo;. 
 Brailsford quite categoricaliy rejects the idea that group aggression was part of the spectacle in the way it has come to be since the 1960s. 
 &bquo;I never remember a fight with more than two people involved with the rest of us encouraging them usually, holding their coats until the police stepped in to break it up, and these scuffles normally had nothing to do with loyalty to rival teams.&equo; 
 The structure of the crowd differed sharply from the present. 
 This is the nub of the matter. 
 Crowds were composed of groups of family, friends, or work-mates tending to go to the same part of the ground and recognizing those around them. 
 There were no &bquo;ends&equo; where the young congregated unsupervised. 
 Heavy drinking, spitting, and swearing rather than collective violence marked off the &bquo;rough&equo; from the rest &mdash; the self-controlled &bquo;respectable&equo; elements. 
 How then did occasional individual violence give way to the regular and organized group aggression of the &bquo;ends&equo; witnessed since the 1960s? 
 At one level the answer to this question is deceptively straightforward. 
 Until the 1950s away support at games (except &bquo;derbies&equo;) was limited by shortage of money, especially amongst young workers. 
 But between 1951 and 1962 juvenile weekly wages rose by 83 per cent. 
 Motor cycles and scooters, clothes, records, and football expenses accounted fur most of the new disposable income. 
 This in itself would hardly have been significant had it not been for a wider transformation of the adult male working class. 
 The halving in aggregate attendance at football matches, which has taken place between the early 1950s and the early 1980s (from almost 40 million to under 20 million), is a result of the disinclination of married men to spend most Saturday afternoons watching live football. 
 The car might need a running repair; the wife would want a &bquo;drive&equo; in the country or, at least, a lift to the shops. 
 Spectator sport could be followed from home on a winter's afternoon and older men increasingly chose to do this. 
 Thus the family, neighbourhood, or work-place groups of older and younger men and a sprinkling of women, which seem to have formed the basic unit of attendance between the wars and before, broke up. 
 Juvenile hooliganism was mainly the consequence of the coil apse of the controls which older family and time-served men had exerted. 
 The composition of the crowd altered and with it went the surveillance and supervision of the young. 
 As the age-structure changed older spectators tended to leave the terraces to take up the increasing amount of seated accommodation; the &bquo;ends&equo; were left to &bquo;the lads&equo;. 
 As gangs of home supporters confronted rival travelling groups, the internal segregation of the ground by age was intensified. 
 The older men, who still wanted to attend live games, learned to avoid either of the &bquo;ends&equo;, and with falling attendances there was no difficulty in finding a relatively safe place elsewhere in the ground. 
 So the process gained momentum. 
 Hooliganism and segregation were mutually reinforcing. 
 So much for the &bquo;how&equo; of hooliganism but what of the &bquo;why&equo;? 
 Even taking an ethologist's view that young men are fighting animals who need to work off aggression harmlessly in play &mdash; a sweeping and contentious assumption &mdash; we st ill have to account for the specific form of football hooliganism since the 1960s. 
 Why was group identity expressed in this rather than in some other way? 
 What social meanings, if any, can be detected in the synchronized clapping and threats aggression? 
 Hooligan behaviour is more elaborate than one might think. 
 Oxford United fans, for example, were found to have a repertoire of over 250 carefully orchestrated chants ranging from &bquo;We&equo; re gonna win the league, tra la la la&equo; to &bquo;You're gonna get your fuckin&equo; heads kicked in&equo; &mdash; the favoured greeting for visiting fans. 
 Interpretations which see hooliganism as a conscious protest against poor urban conditions and employment prospects, though often finding favour with politicians, are facile. 
 The contemporary hooligan phenomenon arose in the 1960s at a time of unprecedented prosperity and low unemployment and has continued through recession both in the depressed north and the relatively prosperous south. 
 Southern hooligans in employment sing &bquo;You'll never get a job&equo; to northerners, especially Liverpudlians. 
 Nor do fans see themselves as engaging in a kind of working-class resistance to the commercialization of football in any straightforward sense. 
 Central to the phenomenon is the idea of territory and community. 
 Hooligans often take care to evade police escorts and to slip into rival territories unobserved. 
 Young Arsenal supporters sometimes disembark from trains south of the river and enter Chelsea territory across Wandsworth Bridge. 
 In one sense this kind of thing has been taking place for centuries. 
 The continuity thesis is not without some merit if carefully defined. 
 Traditional football had been an expression of male prowess and village pride sanctioned by custom and loosely supervised by adults. 
 Under industrialization these games and the &bquo;bands of youth&equo; were either suppressed or marginalized. 
 What Edwardian sociologists liked to call &bquo;boy-life&equo; existed at the informal level of the street-gang or more respectably in the &bquo;youth club&equo; movement. 
 Central to the working class was the establishment of a stable urban culture segregated by sex where boys &bquo;learned&equo; how to be men. 
 This kind of socialization involved, for example, finding out how to drink without getting hopelessly or degradingly drunk; how to indulge in banter and when to risk a fight. 
 Men passed on these things to their sons and their apprentices. 
 Although there was plenty of loutish and rough behaviour in public by groups of juveniles, there was always a counterbalancing influence within male culture. 
 The gang rivalries of the street were kept within bounds and out of the world of adult entertainment. 
 Since the 1950s the old solidarities of working-class culture have disappeared. 
 So too have many of the communities themselves. 
 Networks of neighbours have been broken up by rehousing. 
 Sons are far less likely to follow their fathers or other male relatives into the same occupations or places of work. 
 Football since the 1950s has come to provide a kind of surrogate community for the young; the club defines their identity and the &bquo;end&equo; is their territory, even if they have moved out to high-rise blocks miles away. 
 Membership of a working-class community was something their fathers took for granted. 
 Working men of earlier generations had less need to assert who or what they were. 
 They inherited a firm class culture and lived within it. 
 They were not urged by their teachers to achieve educational success or by advertisers to join a consumer society where class differences were blurred by the possession of material goods. 
 Hooliganism is partly an assertion of &bquo;hardness&equo; and an attachment to local territory, which the boys see as the traditional characteristics of their class. 
 This is what seems to have been behind the &bquo;skinhead&equo; or &bquo;boot-boy&equo; phenomenon that has been a part of football hooliganism. 
 Shaving their heads unlike long-haired middle-class students or pop singers of the period and wearing heavy workmen's boots and braces, they seemed like a caricature of the world that their parents had left. 
 They perpetuated the old traditions in new ways. 
 Football became the single most important focus for this. 
 Extensive community work and interviews with young Arsenal supporters in a run-down housing estate by Robbins and Cohen confirmed this impression. 
 The boys talked nostalgically about the way fighting had been a part of their fathers' world; &bquo;about the time old man MacIlroy, half-pissed, had taken on ali the men folk of his very extended family, at his sister's wedding, and stili had time to call for more beer. 
 Young Neil told how old man Allen one day for a bet had drawn a line across a bar-room floor at the Black Horse and challenged all comers to cross it.&equo; 
 Would their children talk with similar nostalgia about the time their dads led &bquo;the North Bank on a charge against the Chelsea &bquo;Shed&equo;? ss Sport presents a problem for such youths. 
 On the one hand it offers a way of displaying hardness, on the other it is respectable, adopted as part of the official culture of &bquo;school&equo; or &bquo;youth club&equo;. 
 In the Roundhouse, a Catholic housing estate in Liverpool, a slightly older man remarked to members of a teenage gang &bquo;you lot are just like we was. 
 We'd always be fighting coz we knew the older fellas had. 
 Like yourselves, you see us lot playing for Heriots and see fellers going in hard, and say I can be just as hard.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Boys&equo;, as they were known, formed their own team rather than play in established youth sides but were dismissed from the local league for fighting and violent play. 
 In another participant/observer study of a delinquent group within a secondary school, Paul Willis noted how one boy had initially started out very well, with school reports praising his co-operative attitude and his achievements in cricket, football, and cross-country until &bquo;his whole manner and attitude changed&equo;. 
 When asked to explain this the boy remarked &bquo;my father called me an ear'ole &lsqb;a &bquo;crawler&equo; or conformist&rsqb; once, in the second year, for playing football and coming to school&equo;. 
 Playing sport as opposed to watching professional football was identified with acceptance of school authority. 
 When some boys at the school put excrement under the headmaster's chair, he contrasted the culprits unfavourably with true school sportsmen: &bquo;Last Friday I was feeling pretty low when I found out about this lot&hellip; but then I went to football on Saturday, there were several lads and teachers there, playing their hearts out or giving up their time just for the school, and then I thought, &bquo;Perhaps, it's not so bad after all.&equo; 
 Naturally this idea of sport is anathema to the hooligan. 
 Middle-class ideals of &bquo;playing the game&equo; have always been alien to rough working-class culture. 
 Deracinated urban youths have built upon this uncompromisingly physical attitude to games and turned it into a different, more aggressive, and organized subculture. 
 Some of West Ham's most violent supporters have come from the satellite estates of north London or new towns like Harlow or Thamesmead. 
 A young messenger-boy for the Post Office described what he thought brought youths to Highbury. 
 &bquo;Success isn't the most important thing, it's got most to do with where you live, which team you support, or where you used to live before you got moved out&hellip; you go back there, support your old team.&equo; 
 When a group have lost their old territory in which their traditions were established, football provides a symbolic substitute for the young in the heart of the old community. 
 Supporting West Ham was a way of staying an East-Ender, going to the Boleyn pub beside Upton Park and &bquo;steaming in&equo; against rival supporters or immigrants. 
 &bquo;Everyone from our side of the bar used to steam round an' kick fuck out of the Pakis&equo;, remarked one hooligan approvingly. 
 &bquo;You get them all standin&equo; in a mob, all talkin&equo; that chapati language an&equo; all that, an&equo; you never know whether they're talkin&equo; about you. 
 .. It was like the black hole of Calcutta down my factory.&equo; 
 Crude racial abuse is widespread on the terraces. 
 Black players have to endure endless taunts except when one scores a goal for the hooligan's team. 
 Pakistanis have the added stigma in the eyes of the white hooligan of tending to be better off, linguistically separate, less physical, and less interested in football. 
 Racism seems to have become one of the most dangerous and distinctive aspects of contemporary football violence in comparison to earlier forms of juvenile disorder and has begun to spread to cricket too. 
 The National Front and other crypto-fascist fringe-groups have consciously attempted to use football as a means of spreading their ideology amongst young white workers and have specifically targeted certain clubs such as West Ham and Millwall. 
 Some of the most vicious and persistent football offenders have connections with fascist organizations, although the bulk of young supporters do not. 
 Here it is important to make a distinction between different types of hooligan. 
 At the apex, as it were, of the hooligan hierarchy are those in their late teens or early twenties who have a record for violence. 
 They are a minority who are drawn to football as a means of fighting; they go seeking &bquo;aggro&equo; and are half-admired, half-feared by the bulk of young fans. 
 In recent years this older element seems to have become more prominent; they are often smartly dressed and travel to games by car or on scheduled train services away from police surveillance, organized in gangs with names like the Inter-City Firm, the Main Line Service Crew, or the Anti-Personnel Firm. 
 They plan their assaults meticulously and even have kept records to produce a league table of violence. 
 They are a small group increasingly watched by the police and sociologically marginal to the hooligan phenomenon. 
 It is the symbolic violence of the teenager on the terraces, which spills over into the odd affray with visiting gangs that is more typical than the premeditated violence of disturbed or habitually aggressive individuals, who see football as a kind of arena for serious assault with little risk of arrest. 
 More extensive use of video film and exemplary sentencing may discourage the ultra-violent minority, but the assembling of large mobs of chanting and charging youngsters at the &bquo;ends&equo; seems to have become an established part of youth culture. 
 Only age restrictions, which would be costly to clubs already financially hard-pressed as well as being difficult to enforce, could stop this. 
 Stoke and Coventry have attempted to bring back families into the game with a &bquo;Lads and Dads&equo; programme. 
 Watford, among other clubs, have tried a similar initiative, though re-creating &bquo;organic&equo; communities of spectators is beyond the scope of well-intentioned clubs. 
 Serious as it is, the problem of hooliganism has to be kept in proportion. 
 Only a minority of urban youth engages in such behaviour. 
 In several African and South American states there have been far more serious incidents in which large numbers of people have been killed. 
 In one case war was declared over a disputed game. 
 Even in a society without any apparent &bquo;hooligan&equo; problem such as France there was a powerful tradition of misrule before, during, and after games, especially amongst the Rugby players of the south-west. 
 Holland has had its violent confrontations between Amsterdam and Rotterdam teams and their fans; Borussia Dortmund's supporters' club had neo-Nazi links and the fascist Right in Italy have tried to infiltrate the &bquo;ragazzi di stadio&equo;, such as the self-styled &bquo;Fighters&equo; of Juventus. 
 American football is notoriously violent. 
 Players in the virtually invincible Yale side around the turn of the century would dip their shirts in blood from an abattoir before a match. 
 American football itself has been described as an exercise in &bquo;controlled violence&equo;. 
 Both baseball and American football abound in &bquo;hooligan&equo; incidents. 
 In 1976 at Foxboro &bquo;one fan stole another's wheelchair, thirty were hospitalized, another stabbed. 
 Two died of coronaries&hellip; and while a policeman was giving a coronary victim resuscitation, a fan relieved himself on both.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mother, may I slug the umpire, may I slug him right away&equo; was a parody of crowd behaviour at baseball games published by the Washington Critic  in 1886. 
 Hooliganism is more habitual and more fully developed in Britain than elsewhere, but it is not confined to Britain. 
 Nor is violence confined to football. 
 Rugby, whose spectators are a fairly respectable lot, turns a blind eye to fighting on the field. 
 Slinging the odd punch is part of the game and the recent imprisonment of a prominent Welsh player for a blatant and dangerous assault was criticized by most players and supporters. 
 In a recent &bquo;friendly&equo; fixture between Penygraig and Brencethin youth teams the referee himself was assaulted. 
 His nose was broken in two places by a player he had sent off for violent play. 
 Football hooliganism, therefore, can neither be explained in terms of simple continuities nor as an abrupt discontinuity; the location and the specific forms of juvenile riotousness were new but the phenomenon itself was as old as the hills. 
 This is why it is so perplexing. 
 One face of the hooligan is thoroughly traditional. 
 When young supporters chant &bquo;We'll be running round Pompey with our willies hanging out, singing I've got a bigger one than you&equo;, or some other scatological rhyme, slightly changed to fit the time and place, they are doing nothing new. 
 This kind of rudeness goes back to Rabelais and far beyond. 
 The same went for the man who complained in the following terms to a local government committee for &bquo;Better Football&equo;: &bquo;I visited the New Stand lavatories. 
 After two minutes I was showered with hot tea and a selection of cakes from the next door cubicle. 
 Then a couple of Jumping Jack fireworks came over the top, one of which fell into my underpants. 
 No sooner had I thrown it into the toilet than it exploded and I was spattered with the pan's contents. 
 At this point I heard a gale of raucous laughter.&equo; 
 This suspiciously hilarious incident sounds as if it had been polished in the telling, as many hooligan incidents are. 
 There are archetypal anecdotes which crop up again and again in one form or another. 
 There is the one where a madcap home supporter gingerly urinates from above on opposition fans who are innocently drinking tea in what they take to be a gentle drizzle. 
 A variant of this is the celebrated Celtic and Rangers story about a lone fan caught by the opposition and made to fetch the hot Bovril at half-time. 
 His captors keep one of his shoes to make sure he comes back, and return it to him filled with excrement. 
 On recounting the tale to a journalist, the victim is asked if he thinks there will ever be an end to this cycle of violence, to which he answers, &bquo;No, as long as they keep shitting in our shoes, we'll keep pissing in their Bovril.&equo; 
 Antics of this kind had been the stuff of carnival throughout western Europe for centuries. 
 In nineteenth-century Paris young revellers would melt down chocolate and smear horrified passers-by with what they took to be excrement. 
 Examples of loose continuities could be multiplied ad infinitum . 
 Fighting and joking, after all, were the main amusements of bachelors in pre-industrial Europe. 
 An anthropologist who by chance was travelling recently on a ferry during a battle between Manchester United and West Ham fans observed a distinct similarity with the ritual warfare of tribal societies. 
 &bquo;They seemed to be enjoying themselves immensely, making a lot of noise, rushing dramatically up and down the stairs, spraying the fire-hoses everywhere, and throwing the occasional bottle or glass at the other side.&equo; 
 As they did so &bquo;they experienced a transcendent moment of community with their mates&equo;. 
 So where does this leave us? 
 Pre-industrial survival or contemporary malaise? 
 The special circumstances of territorial displacement and the withdrawal of adult supervision, which appear to have been more pronounced in Britain than in other parts of western Europe where the family is stronger as a recreational unit, have made the problem worse here than elsewhere; this has led to the formation of the &bquo;ends&equo; which in turn has tended to attract a small fascist and psychotic fringe. 
 Hooliganism is not one but several overlapping phenomena &mdash; traditional misrule, new forms of territorial aggression, youth styles both invented or reflected in the media. 
 All this is combined with the resentment of ethnic minorities by those who see football as a way of reasserting their national pride. 
 Chauvinism, local and national, lies at the heart of hooliganism and England fans seem to find in foreigners a convenient target fur a vague resentment at Britain's diminished place in the world. 
 Football has become a substitute for patriotism amongst the disaffected, half-educated white working-class youth of a nation which only a generation ago was respected and feared throughout the world. 
 Street-fighting and village brawls at football matches were so much a part of &bquo;traditional&equo; society that we tend to forget how relatively civilized modern social life has become. 
 There are manifest continuities between the rites of violence in contemporary Britain and earlier periods. 
 But the specific forms  of hooliganism are  new; football crowds were not segregated by age before the 1960s; youth did not congregate around parts of football clubs as their territory &mdash; they had a larger territory and community which they shared with their older male relatives. 
 When there were fights at football matches there was no dramatic media coverage. 
 All of these features have combined to create the contemporary problem; hooliganism exemplifies to perfection the difficulty of disentangling what is new from what is old in social history. 
 Conclusion 
 IN 1965 a Sports Council was set up to advise the government on future policy on sport and physical education. 
 This was a novel step and came from the advice of the Wolfenden Committee which reported in 1960 on &bquo;Sport and the Community&equo;. 
 Wolfenden was commissioned not by the state but by the Central Council of Physical Recreation (CCPR), which had been set up in 1935 as a co-ordinating body for the many voluntary associations involved in the running of sport. 
 Alongside the CCPR there was the National Playing Fields Association formed in 1925 to increase urban playing space; there was also some limited provision of physical training facilities for the unemployed in the 1930s by the National Council for Social Service. 
 But ali of these organizational initiatives stopped well short of full-blooded state intervention. 
 Even the Physical Training and Recreation Act of 1937, which made funds available to promote fitness amidst rumours of war and the realities of domestic rearmament, was exceedingly modest in scope with a meagre two-million-pound budget in comparison with the vast sums spent on &bquo;Kraft durch Freude&equo; by the Third Reich and Mussolini's &bquo;Dopolavoro&equo; programme. 
 The small-state tradition of the Victorians was strong and resilient. 
 There was a very restricted physical education &bquo;establishment&equo; in the form of specialist colleges for teacher-training. 
 These institutions were concerned mainly with gymnastics and confined largely to women until after the Second World War. 
 Games were not even made compulsory in state schools until 1944 despite the importance of athleticism in private education. 
 The ideology of amateurism discouraged the notion that sport was an appropriate sphere of state activity. 
 The government even declined an invitation to take part in an UNESCO conference on &bquo;The Place of Sport in Education&equo; in 1954. 
 It was not that sport was unimportant. 
 On the contrary, sport was a characteristic, almost a birthright of Britons everywhere. 
 But its virtues would be sapped if it was &bquo;nationalized&equo;. 
 Sport was the true province of private persons in private clubs and tampering with this smacked of an authoritarianism foreign to all that Britons &mdash; Labour, Liberal, and Tory &mdash; held most dear. 
 The fill story of how this attitude has gradually changed cannot be told here. 
 My purpose has been to account for the rise and consolidation of amateurism rather than to catalogue its contemporary decline. 
 Pressure to increase state involvement came from various directions. 
 There was the huge extension of state activity in other areas of social life that came about as a result of the &bquo;warfare means welfare&equo; principle of the 1940s. 
 If sport was &bquo;a good thing&equo;, then the state should provide for it within the framework of the welfare state along with health and education. 
 The limits of what had formerly been considered the proper role of the state had changed. 
 Additionally the growing importance of the media, especially radio and television, highlighted the relatively poor performance of British sportsmen and women at an international level. 
 Britain only won one gold medal in the 1952 Olympics and that was in an equestrian event. 
 The Soviet Union had entered international sport with a vengeance, throwing the weight of a massive state machine against West European and American dominance of athletics. 
 Cold War influences filtered through gradually and merged with a growing concern about the effects of increased leisure and affluence on the young, especially the problem of delinquency. 
 &bquo;It is easy to ridicule the &bquo;that's not cricket old boy&equo; attitude,&equo; remarked Wolfenden, &bquo;but in its deeper (and usually inarticulate) significance it stili provides something like the foundations of an ethical standard which may not be highly intellectual but does have a considerable influence on the day-to-day behaviour of millions of people.&equo; 
 It took a Labour Government less inhibited than the Tories with their informal links to the amateur &eacute;lite to bring sport within the ambit of the welfare state by setting up the Sports Council. 
 The consequences of state intervention since 1964 have been use fully summarized in a recent report of the Sports Council on &bquo;The Impact of the Sport For All Policy, 1966&ndash;84&equo;. 
 The efforts of the state have mainly gone into providing better facilities for sport, especially in inner cities. 
 This rather belated official intervention has not met with much success. 
 &bquo;Sport For All&equo; has done little to overcome the inequalities present at the start of the campaign&equo;, conclude the report's authors. 
 Sports centres with excellent pitches and pools have been built but they have either been under used or more often patronized by groups who already had a high participation ratio, especially adult male car-owners. 
 The unskilled, women, the older members of community, and rough youths on the delinquent fringe have been conspicuous by their absence. 
 This is not the place to enter into a debate about contemporary sports policy. 
 The point is rather to stress the limits of state action. 
 The mere provision of facilities is not enough. 
 As this book has insisted over and over again, sport is to do with attitudes and values not just with exercise. 
 Peter McIntosh, the co-author of this report and a pioneer in the historical study of sport in modern Britain, concludes that the state via the Sports Council should &bquo;base both research and promotion on enjoyment rather than social function&equo;. 
 Commitment to sport has to be freely given; it has to be fun; it cannot be foisted on to the poor or the wayward from above because it is good for them. 
 This brings us back to a central theme of Sport and the British : the extraordinary degree to which it has been promoted privately without politicians, employers, or trade unionists taking a significant part except as enthusiastic individual sportsmen. 
 People have created their own kinds of pleasure through sport and there has been no powerful institutional &bquo;push&equo; of the kind that came, for example, from the French Church after 1905 or the German Social Democratic Party of the Wilhelmine era. 
 Britain even lagged behind the United States in the provision of industrial recreation facilities. 
 Muscular Christians and middle-class moralists in a private capacity certainly boosted the cause or games. 
 But their ideas had only limited influence on the way games were played and understood by the mass of manual workers. 
 This leads naturally to another key point: whatever social or political meanings are attached to sport by different groups, participation remains intensely sociable and largely organized around the institution of the individual &bquo;club&equo; &mdash; a neglected social creation of the Victorians. 
 Conviviality has been at the heart of sport. 
 The fierce rivalries of teams and top competitors has masked the warmth of participating together in a team or standing on the terraces cheering on your side. 
 Sport is more about making friends, building communities, and sharing experiences than keeping fit. 
 There may be hostility to rivals but there is also the deep sense of solidarity and identity that comes from fierce loyalties to a place or a people. 
 This sociability has been largely male. 
 Female participation in sport has been negligible until recently. 
 Men have kept women out of sport except as helpers for those aspects of club life like dances and teas which were not segregated. 
 When Frankenberg went to carry out anthropological research in a village on the Welsh borders in the early 1950s he found that the village football team provided &bquo;a symbol of village unity and cohesion against the outside world&equo; and had &bquo;a central place in village social activity&equo;. 
 The team had a supporters' club in which local women were represented. 
 Conflict arose when their wishes over the use of club funds towards a Coronation carnival were ignored by the men. 
 The women demanded their &bquo;gifts&equo; of time and interest to the club be reciprocated by the donation of time and money by the players for the collective life of the community. 
 Female social  participation may have been more widespread than has been realized. 
 Women have certainly been socially active in middle-class sports like tennis and golf, which also have a significant element of active female participation. 
 But in sport as a whole they have been mostly conspicuous by their absence. 
 In swimming &mdash; the single most popular physical recreation after walking &mdash; the importance of teaching children to swim has drawn in some women and competitive swimming is a very important sport for girls. 
 As the social secretary of a swimming-club remarked, &bquo;you start off by just coming down to watch&hellip; and gradually you start to get involved&equo;. 
 She had to admit that she found swimming &bquo;a bit boring really&equo; but there was the possibility of shared recreation. 
 &bquo;We were always very interested in the dances&equo; &mdash; the links between sport, dances, and courtship is a world of its own which would repay further her study. 
 Female involvement may have been at the fringes, though what took place in this &bquo;marginal, area may turn out to have been more important than long-forgotten events on the field of play. 
 However, the social integration element, though unduly neglected, should not be pressed too hard, especially amongst urban workers. 
 Observers of a mining community in the 1950s noted that &bquo;husband and wife live separate and in a sense secret lives&hellip; it is a point of honour among men to keep some time for drinking and attending sporting events with their mates&equo;. 
 After a year or two of marriage &bquo;men return once more to the company of their mates&equo;. 
 In modern Britain sport has been one of the ways that men have kept themselves apart, defined their own territory, and indulged their enthusiasms. 
 What the Edwardians called &bquo;boy-life&equo; had its own kind of &bquo;clubbable&equo; logic whether amongst the &bquo;Old Boys&equo; of the Long Room or on the terraces of Old Trafford. 
 The pattern of male involvement, however, has depended primarily on social class with important regional and national variations. 
 The way changing class structures and urban experience have moulded sport has been the central concern of the book. 
 Chapter 1 examined the nature and decline of traditional forms of sport. 
 Old-established festive customs, in which sports mixed with eating, dancing, and drinking according to the traditions of the Church and agricultural practice, were gradually eroded. 
 Different activities declined at different times and in different ways. 
 Animal sports were put down by crusading urban and evangelical pressure. 
 The creation of a private association to prosecute offenders and chivvy local and central government into action was a pioneering effort in Victorian middle-class moral interference in the lives of the poor. 
 Yet the prohibition of cock-fighting and animal-baiting was only politically possible because of the tacit consent of the landed &eacute;lite, who had already largely desert ed these activities for more exclusive and civilized ones. 
 Disgust at cruel sports came to be a distinguishing feature of British life. 
 Even a vocal minority of skilled manual workers supported the ban. 
 The same applied to traditional football except that in this case legislation merely banned the game from the public highway. 
 Football, however, had lost much of its rumbustiousness before it was outlawed from the streets. 
 Still, the continuities were as important as the changes. 
 Cricket and horse-racing prospered, drawing good crowds and plenty of money. 
 Prize-fighting remained popular, though technically illegal, until the 1880s. 
 Increasingly publicans took over the task of providing facilities for sports which had once been enjoyed on the streets or on common land. 
 Sporting grounds were opened alongside pubs, and by the mid-nineteenth century, there were plenty of independent commercial grounds where &bquo;pedestrian&equo; events were held. 
 Although the Highways Act of 1835 steadily drove pedestrianism off the roads, it did not drive it out of existence. 
 Athletics was a popular sport before the age of the Oxbridge blue and village cricket was thriving when county cricket was still unknown. 
 There was no leisure vacuum in early Victorian Britain. 
 Rather there had been a subtle unravelling of what had once been a more integrated pattern of recreation. 
 First, the withdrawal of the gentry and later their large tenants from rural life coincided with growing criticism and interference from an increasingly powerful middle class. 
 Second, the combined forces of civilized distaste gradually had an effect on the working-class &eacute;lite whilst the actual times and spaces for the old sports both in town and country were ever more restricted. 
 By no means all of the old sport s were abandoned, but they were more or less confined either to the margins of community life or to the remoter parts of the nation. 
 This was particularly evident as far as the young were concerned. 
 The special place that they had enjoyed in traditional sports was much reduced. 
 Either they joined in with their adult workmates or they played children's games in the streets. 
 Ancient games did survive amongst the young and continued to be enjoyed into the middle of this century, but their songs and rhymes, and the old chasing, throwing, and racing games were increasingly regarded as puerile. 
 Adults would have been thought foolish to take part in what were now only infantile amusements. 
 The enthusiasm of the common people for the old sports was weakened to such an extent that there was a genuine receptiveness on the part of the mass of the population to the revised forms of play that were being nurtured amongst the privileged in the mid-Victorian public schools. 
 There were two sides of middle-class sport. 
 The first was the code of amateurism as embodied in public school games; the second was the emergence of suburban recreation. 
 Amateurism provided a bridge between the old world of aristocratic values and the new one of bourgeois exertion and competitiveness. 
 Fair play embodied a new philosophy that was probably more pervasive and influential than the more widely known &bquo;work-ethic&equo; and &bquo;call to seriousness&equo; amongst the Victorians. 
 The dynamism and distinctiveness of the new private educational system with its unprecedented cult of games is perhaps the best-known aspect of the social history of sport. 
 &bquo;Athleticism&equo;, as it was sometimes called, was a kind of moral code or system of ideas. 
 Public school sport and the &bquo;old-boy&equo; network helped foster a sense of solidarity rather than social division between landed wealth, the new industrial &eacute;lites, and the liberal professions. 
 Yet sport did not bind the whole of the bourgeoisie and the aristocracy together. 
 The middle classes were split between the northern industrial element, which tolerated professionalism and took directorships of Football League and Rugby League clubs, and the bankers, brokers, doctors, lawyers, civil servants, and schoolmasters who formed the bulk of the amateur establishment in southern England. 
 That amateurism was both a code of ethics and a system of status was borne out by the fact that &bquo;amateur&equo; was often used in conjunction with &bquo;gentleman&equo;. 
 The two went hand in hand until the later nineteenth century. 
 One way of defining the middle classes is to try to understand how they kept themselves morally distinct from the lower orders. 
 An alternative perspective comes from looking at what they did rather than what they said. 
 In practice, the force of amateur values was slowly eroded. 
 Nationalism, the media, and market forces were partly responsible. 
 But changing middle-class manners and values were also important. 
 There was a shift towards a more casual, private, and hedonistic style of life. 
 The late Victorian and Edwardian period offered low taxes, cheap servant labour, and reasonable returns of capital whilst the retail price index fell by around 10 per cent between the wars. 
 By 1939 there were two million private cars and taxation was no more than 10 per cent for a man on &pound;500 a year. 
 &bquo;You need money in this England,&equo; as Priestley said, &bquo;but you do not need much money.&equo; 
 Suburban commuters, who increasingly formed the bulk of the middle-aged middle classes, were often rather hazy about &bquo;the games ethic&equo; and confined the ideal of amateurism to rugby, cricket, or athletics. 
 Amateurism waned as a set of values for living. 
 Golf had rules of &bquo;etiquette&equo; rather than an ethic of fair play and public service. 
 Being middle class was becoming more a matter of consumption than of belief. 
 Any family could join in provided they had the money and were not Jewish &mdash; racism thrived tolerably well in meritocratic suburbia where Jews sometimes had to form their own clubs. 
 What better forum for conspicuous consumption than the locker-room or the golf club car-park? 
 Whilst paying lip service to the sporting values of the public schools, suburban man was busy with less physically and morally taxing forms of exercise. 
 The mould of cheerful materialism was starting to take shape. 
 The amateur ideal prospered in its purest form in the Empire. 
 &bquo;Athleticism&equo; provided a crucial, distinctive element in the British &bquo;imperial idea&equo;. 
 A flair for games and a talent for government went hand in hand. 
 The British were a superior race, blessed with exceptional energy, toughness, and qualities of leadership, which they refined in their play and used throughout the world to promote the rule of law, the Christian religion, and the &bquo;rational&equo; use of economic resources. 
 This &bquo;civilizing mission&equo; was both a &bquo;burden&equo; and a &bquo;duty&equo; as well as being a source of pleasurable employment and riches. 
 Such was the self-image of Empire, which spread out from the public schools and into the public mind with the growth of the popular press and the introduction of compulsory primary education. 
 Banner headlines and patriotic textbooks told the British they were &bquo;an imperial race&equo; &mdash; a message pictorially reinforced on biscuit-tins, sauce-bottles, and cigarette-cards. 
 Youth movements were fiercely loyal to Crown and colonies, especially the &bquo;Boy Scouts&equo;, which their founder, Baden-Powell, at first had wished to name the &bquo;Imperial Scouts&equo;. 
 Then there was the elaborate and explicitly imperial ceremonial that surrounded the monarch in life and in death. 
 This helped pave the way for the full-blooded domestication of the idea of Empire at the popular imperial exhibitions held first at Wembley and later in Glasgow between the wars. 
 AU this helped provide a favourable climate for imperial sport &mdash; Test matches, rugby tours, and ultimately the institution of the Empire Games itself. 
 Whilst sport offered an acceptable outlet for Dominion nationalism it also proved a useful tool for incorporating indigenous rulers into the running of the Empire, especially in India. 
 Even with decolonization and the cutting of formal colonial ties, a sport like cricket in the West Indies has consolidated good relations. 
 Coexisting &mdash; sometimes uneasily &mdash; with imperialism there was domestic nationalism. 
 Sport has helped to give the English a coherent national culture no less than it has the Irish, the Welsh, or the Scots. 
 It also spread English values through the Empire which became hopelessly con fused with &bquo;Britishness&equo;. 
 For it was the English &eacute;lite, formed in those new institutions of national culture, the public schools, who ran the show. 
 Despite strong parochial and provincial loyalties, the pull of sport as part of a national culture in England grew stronger between the wars. 
 And this in turn fed the flames of a wider imperial culture of British sports. 
 Since the 1960s the problem of South Africa, which goes beyond the scope of the present survey, has placed far greater strains on Commonwealth sporting links than ever before. 
 Yet they continue, still surprisingly vigorous, though how long the Commonwealth Games can survive boycotts of the kind mounted at Edinburgh in 1986 is much less certain. 
 Historically sport has broadly been a cohesive force in imperial relations. 
 Only the nationalist Irish explicitly exempted themselves from the interplay of national identity and shared sentiments through games. 
 The Irish enforced a &bquo;Ban&equo; on British sports in the sense that those who wished to play Gaelic football or hurling under the aegis of the Gaelic Athletic Association could not also play football or cricket. 
 The Welsh and Scots adopted a different tactic which was more in keeping with their less explicitly political expression of nationality. 
 Rugby in South Wales and football in central Scotland reflected a new sense of working-class cultural nationalism which was distinct from the bardic celebrations in Wales and the romanticism of readers of Sir Walter Scott and nostalgic expatriates. 
 Nationalism was only one element in the working-class sporting tradition. 
 The range and richness of sport as a component of popular culture has been overlooked by those who take a &bquo;diffusionist&equo; view, concentrating on how middle-class games and values were passed on to industrial workers via muscular Christians and social reformers. 
 Two major points emerged in our analysis of popular participation. 
 First, there was no effective imposition of middle-class games on urban workers in the name of &bquo;social control&equo; or &bquo;rational recreation&equo;; second, a distinct and introverted tradition of sport grew up combining old-established popular traditions within a more systematic national framework. 
 While there was no shortage of articulate individuals with the intention  of improving the lower orders through their play, the impact of churches, youth movements, and employers was largely restricted to the provision of facilities and routine organization. 
 Ideologically they did not get very far. 
 Such ventures never formed more than a significant minority of the total number of clubs, most of which were based on street or neighbourhood groups set up and run by ordinary working people. 
 These clubs did not necessarily take their sport in the spirit of fair play. 
 Fierce local loyalties and rivalries were the life-blood of the amateur football leagues just as they had been in parish recreations a century before, and this carried over into commercial spectator sport, which offered a new kind of community life and identity. 
 As industrial communities became established on a grander scale with second, third, and fourth generation residents, there was a need to express territoriality in new ways. 
 This tension between change and continuity is the key to understanding the inner meaning as opposed to the outward form of working-class sport. 
 Hence the attachment to gambling. 
 Here the traditions of the gentry and the common people met in joint rejection of the middle-class sporting morality that outlawed betting in the name of decency and &bquo;character&equo;. 
 Horse-racing, a sport that had largely remained in the hands of the aristocracy and which was the object of criticism from bourgeois ideologues and socialists alike, grew rapidly in popularity. 
 Rationality, so dear to the reforming heart, ironically found its fullest expression in the picking of winners after careful perusal of &bquo;the sporting intelligence&equo;. 
 Calculating the draws on the coupon, the odds on a dog, the speed of a bird might draw upon reserves of numeracy and judgement, but this did not betoken the triumph of a &bquo;scientific world-view&equo;. 
 Record-breaking and the alleged mania for quantification cannot properly explain the appeal of sport. 
 A new precision was certainly present and this was important for the dedicated few. 
 But statistics were not at the heart of the thing except for the occasional schoolboy or zealot. 
 Nor, on the other hand, was violence. 
 &mdash; Edwardian working-class sport as a whole was less violent than it had been a half-century before. 
 Even ratting contests and prize-fights seemed to lose their appeal in the last quarter of the century. 
 The tradition of gambling that had been associated with brutal sports came to be centred on horse-racing and later football. 
 Boxing, or football for that matter, was stili pretty rough and the crowds could be crude and rowdy, but the overall impression was of a more orderly world. 
 Popular recreation was more &bquo;rational&equo; in a bureaucratic sense and it was more respectable than before, but its pleasures remained deeply traditional: drinking and betting, chaffing your mates and cheering on the standard-bearers of your real or adopted territory. 
 This, at least, was the way things were until the third quarter of this century. 
 Since the Second World War Britain's industrial and imperial heyday has passed and with it a peculiarly British way of playing. 
 Most dramatic has been the demise of the amateur. 
 The MCC abolished the distinction between gentlemen and players in the early 1960s. 
 Henceforth there would only be &bquo;cricketers&equo;. 
 Wimbledon followed suit a little later by opening up competition to professional tennis players. 
 Amateurism was scrapped at the same moment that the imperial structure it had helped to sustain was itself wound up. 
 Simultaneously the status of the professional improved as players began to assert themselves not as &bquo;club servants&equo; or &bquo;skilled workmen&equo; but as entertainers who should be paid in accordance with their market value. 
 Footballers success fully abolished the imposition of the maximum wage, though the retain-and-transfer system took longer to scrap. 
 British sport began for the first time to embrace commercialism, although the process was cautious and gradual. 
 The Football League, for example, has only accepted shirt advertising and fu 11 commercial sponsorship in the last few years. 
 The Amateur Athletic Association have clung to their name despite condoning the principle that athletes be paid &mdash; often very large sums &mdash; provided it is done through the setting up of &bquo;trust funds&equo;. 
 Behind these profound changes lies the impact of television combined with a shift in the values of the organizing &eacute;lite. 
 Media coverage now offers the possibility of enormously increased revenue from advertising either directly or indirectly through named sponsors. 
 The idea of &bquo;the game for the game's sake&equo; that underpinned athleticism as a moral code has come to seem strangely antiquated. 
 Gentlemanly distaste for &bquo;trade&equo; is as out of place in sport as it is in the Conservative Party of Mrs Thatcher. 
 Alongside the late entry of capitalism into sport, which is bringing Britain closer to the commercialism of the Tour de France or the Superbowl &mdash; both of which significantly have begun to attract British audiences in sizeable numbers in the later 1980s &mdash; there lie two pressing issues: the decline of live audiences for sport and the rise of a hooligan subculture. 
 The old crowd controls at football matches have gone as working men increasingly stay at home to watch sport, leaving the stadium &mdash; or the unseated &bquo;ends&equo; at least &mdash; as an arena for the young. 
 Football has become the focus for a new kind of identity for working-class male youth and it is quite possible that other forms of sport &mdash; cricket for instance &mdash; will be similarly used. 
 Fierce loyalties to a professional club &mdash; often located outside an adolescent's immediate territory as is the case with many Manchester United or Liverpool supporters attracted by playing success, glamour, and television coverage &mdash; create new juvenile communities, who briefly suspend hostilities at internationals in the cause of English chauvinism. 
 No wonder George Orwell had no respect for sport. 
 By chance the writing of this book began in 1984 amidst a flood of neo-Orweliian speculation about nuclear war, the ecology of the planet, information technology, the North-South dialogue, and the dangers of television. 
 Then, as abruptly as it had pitched camp, the caravan moved on. 
 Gratefully or guiltily, we plunged back into the present with its reassuring calendar of events from Wembley to Wimbledon, from Lord's to Twickenham, from Ascot to &bquo;The Open&equo;. 
 The apocalyptic stock-taking was put aside for some future anniversary or crisis. 
 Sport resumed its place at the centre of male culture providing familiar landmarks for private lives, giving a kind of chronology or structure to the year. 
 There is no escaping sport. 
 Each year the time devoted to it and the importance attached to it, especially on television, seems to increase. 
 The cult of sport sometimes seems to take on the quality of an Orwellian nightmare. 
 Will the next millennium see man obsessed by athletic entertainment to the exclusion of other kinds of culture? 
 Will the state promote sport as a safe, numbing kind of nationalistic cocoon for healthy, obedient citizens? 
 If the past is anything to go by &mdash; and what better measure do we have? &mdash; this will not happen. 
 Sport may be taken too seriously; high-performance spectator sport is arguably too central to our lives already. 
 But the friendliness and common sense of ordinary players, the humour, excitement, and the fin it affords offer reasonable grounds for hope. 
 These values will mediate the impact of mass culture. 
 The relationship between the two will determine the shape of British sport in the future. 
 Beautiful FLOWER ARRANGEMENTS 
 Sensational ideas for your home 
 Sue Lawley &bquo;Sometimes I'd rather be ironing&hellip;&equo; 
 COOK IN STYLE 
 Marvellous melon ideas 
 Barbecued spare ribs 
 Tangy Madeira cake 
 Lose pounds with the low-fat diet 
 A new high energy plan that works &mdash; for you and him! 
 It's healthy! 
 Mum's story &bquo;One hug could kill my daughter&equo; 
 Contents 
 Fashion 
 Divided dresses 
 The new trouser shape for women 
 Beauty 
 Beauty: hair conditioning 
 Beauty, form and fitness: our beauty update 
 Advice 
 Money: having a flutter on the horses 
 Consumer: unsolicited telephone calls 
 The lawyer advises: kidnapping 
 Health 
 Gynaecology: breast-fed babies 
 General Medicine: low blood pressure 
 Alternative health: mineral water 
 Homes and Gardens 
 Homeshop: the best of mail order shopping 
 Homestyle: wicker and cane furniture 
 DIY: fitting a bath/shower tap mixer 
 Plantworld: all white garden 
 Fiction 
 Perfect Alibi&hellip; 
 News and Views 
 Around and About: keeping you in the know 
 Job of the week: probation officer 
 This week's people: names in the news 
 Reviews: cinemas, music, video, books 
 Features 
 Talking point: trying to change a partner 
 Reader's story: Diabetes won't change my life 
 Travel: Leeds 
 Regulars 
 Readers' letters 
 A problem shared, You reply 
 Horoscopes 
 Animals: breeding butterflies 
 In the kitchen 
 Kitchen Notes: new ideas, menus, advice 
 To Knit, to sew, to make 
 Homecraft: Father's Day cards 
 Pattern: kimonos 
 Knitting: easy-knit cotton sweater 
 Games 
 Crossword, fig-jig 
 Prize word-finder, puzzle solutions 
 ON THIS WEEK'S COVER 
 REAL LIFE STORY 
 &bquo;One hug could kill my daughter&equo; 
 THE LOW-FAT DIET 
 Lose pounds with our diet plan! 
 BEAUTIFUL ARRANGEMENTS 
 Sensational flower displays at home 
 PROFILE: SUE LAWLEY 
 &bquo;Sometimes I'd rather be ironing&equo; 
 COOK IN STYLE 
 Marvellous melons &bull; Barbecued spare ribs &bull; Tangy Madeira cake 
 Best of the week 
 Lose weight the healthy way 
 In the supermarket recently, I crept up on the man in my life who was examining the label on a frozen gateau. 
 &bquo;We can't eat that, it's loaded with calories,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;But it only has 4 grams of fat,&equo; came the smart reply. 
 Restricting your consumption of fats is a sound way to lose weight and a healthy way of eating for all the family. 
 But how do you sort out the goodies from the baddies? 
 Our Low-Fat Diet Plan tells you how. 
 It's comprehensive and really easy to follow. 
 And, no, we didn't succumb to the gateau. 
  Caroline Richards Editor  
 Our Fascinating World 
 Toothpaste contains cement and seaweed 
 In the 16th century, Elizabethans rarely cleaned their teeth but instead gargled with sugar water to sweeten the breath. 
 Urine was recommended as a mouthwash because its acidity was thought to prevent tooth decay! 
 A hundred years ago people brushed with toothpaste made from burnt eggshells or crumbled porcelain. 
 Weird ingredients 
 Now toothpaste is more palatable. 
 We all know that fluoride is added to fight tooth decay but modern toothpaste also contains powdered chalk, aluminium oxide (found in cement) to remove plaque, and a derivative of seaweed which is used to thicken it. 
 Making the stripes 
 A reservoir of coloured gel is put near the nozzle. 
 When the tube is squeezed the gel is forced through tiny holes, into the paste. 
 Laughter Lines 
 &bquo;Did you find your horse well-behaved? 
 Yes, he let me go first at every fence&equo; 
 &bquo;Waiter, may I have some bread, please? 
 Sorry, madam, we only have toast&equo; 
 PAPER SMILES 
 Boa constrictor, 6 &frac12; foot, hand reared, very good eater, likes children. 
 &pound;350. 
 Satan and lace wedding dress. 
 Size 10, &pound;50. (seen in newsagent's window) 
 Victorian cottage style settee and rocket, a bargain at &pound;100. 
 Baby brand new &pound;27, save &pound;15. 
 Plus several other cheap bits. 
 Know any good jokes, seen any howlers in print? 
 We'll pay &pound;5 for every one used &mdash; but sorry, we can't return anything you send.  
 &bquo;Heaven to me is a great big baked potato and someone to share it with&equo; Oprah Winfrey 
 Fashion 
 Divided dresses 
 When it gets hot in the city, go for this season's favourite &mdash; the divided dress. 
 It's short, smart, comfortable &mdash; and cool 
 Soft collaring makes this mini version of the divided dress ideal for holiday wear &mdash; great for showing off tanned legs. 
 Create a sharper image with this updated coat-dress. 
 It has a shawl collar, wide belt and cuffed hemline. 
 Thin vertical stripes and a drawstring waist make this divided dress ideal for the fuller figure. 
 Dramatic African-inspired prints are toned down for softer, everyday wear. 
 A perennial favourite, the polka dot gets a new lease of life in bold emerald green and brilliant white. 
 Excellent value, this beautiful cornflower blue dress looks great on its own &mdash; but for even greater impact try adding equally bright accessories. 
 Around and About 
 Compiled by Rosalind Lowe 
 Clock watcher's ticking treasure 
 Chock-a-block? 
 It's more like clock-a-block for timepiece collector and repairer, Sandra Pember. 
 She can barely move in her Gloucestershire home for the 200 or so ticking treasures jostling for space on the walls, mantelpieces and floors &mdash; anywhere where there's a minute  space to be had. 
 Sandra began collecting several years ago after a large repair bill for a timepiece prompted her to learn the intricate ins and outs of their workings. 
 She's now a fully fledged clock &bquo;doc&equo; and can repair her treasures herself. 
 Her magnificent antique collection, which includes a 110-year-old Black Forest Clock, is very popular with other dedicated clockwatchers, and has even been put on display at Gloucester Museum. 
 Luckily for Sandra and her two children, Anne, 16 and John, 11, not all the clocks are in proper working order, Otherwise, she says, &bquo;the noise would be incredibly deafening if they all chimed at once!&equo;  
 Is this what it's like to have time on your hands? 
 Luckily Sandra has become expert enough to do her own repair work 
 A gift that really grows for you 
 If you are looking for an appealing gift that doesn't cost the earth, Belinda Thomas could provide a solution. 
 She runs Greener Gifts Ltd, from her home in Chipping Sodbury, near Bristol and will sell you 36 square feet of woodland for &pound;25. 
 Belinda's project &mdash; to plant more woodland &mdash; was motivated by concern for the environment, especially the loss of the natural habitat for wildlife. 
 But initially she couldn't think how to raise the money for it &mdash; until she hit on the idea of Greener Gifts. 
 With a bank loan, Belinda bought 5&frac12; acres of land bordering Avon and Gloucestershire and planted it with beech, lime, oak and ash trees. 
 Buyers receive a deed confirming ownership of a plot and can visit the whole forest whenever they want. 
 &bquo;It's a gift that grows,&equo; says Belinda. 
 Contact her on 0454 320522.  
 Daughter Pollyanna inspired Belinda's woodland project 
 The best of friends 
 Diana, a West African gorilla, hasn't forgotten the foster dad who hand-reared her from birth. 
 Now 18-stone, this 16-year-old &bquo;baby&equo; still expects to be spoon-fed and cuddled by Bristol Zookeeper, Mike Colbourne. 
 &bquo;It's very important that human contact is continued with gorillas who have lost their parents. 
 It gives them a much-needed sense of security,&equo; he says. 
 He even went into her cage just after she gave birth. 
 &bquo;Diana was wary of me. 
 She would go to the far side and we would watch each other. 
 Then one day she started pushing the baby toward me, as if to say, &bquo;Go on. 
 You can look at it&equo;.&equo;  
 Gorilla Diana still has a soft spot for zoo-keeper Mike 
 Newsflash 
 First moves 
 A Babycham survey revealed that 83% of men favour women making the first move in relationships. 
 But only 78% of women want to do the asking. 
 Whiff of success 
 American researcher Dr William Dember, claims that pleasant fragrances could be beneficial to people in jobs demanding sustained attention. 
 We're all fibbers 
 Lies are essential in life, says Professor Loyal Rue &mdash; not only do we lie to others, we tell ourselves fibs to make us feel better. 
 Pipe dream for German artist 
 Some of the water-pipes in the town of Wilhelmshaven, Germany seem to have taken on a life of their own. 
 This pipe-monster appears to have decided to deliver the water. 
 If meeting him could make you reach for something a lot stronger than H 2  O, you will be relieved to hear that he's anchored to the ground. 
 The statue is the work of artist Heinrich Krebs. 
 &bquo;Renewal of the waterworks means many specially designed pipes are discarded,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;I got permission for a symbolic statue, and this giant Pumpman is the result!&equo; 
 Matter of opinion 
 Should we feel obliged to tip? 
 Everyone has faced the embarrassing dilemma of deciding how much extra to give a waiter, hairdresser or taxi-driver. 
 But when you consider today's high prices, should we have to pay more &mdash; especially when the service hasn't been good? 
 So is it about time we got rid of this confusing tradition? 
 Tipping is a great way of showing your appreciation, says June, 23. 
 &bquo;Whether you've enjoyed quick service in a restaurant or had a great hair-do, giving a cash token lets people know their talents aren't taken for granted.&equo; 
 When people hover for a tip, it's excruciating, says Jon, 34 &bquo;I don't see why people working in certain industries should be singled out for special treatment. 
 Milkmen and plumbers don't expect a gratuity.&equo; 
 It would be far better if employers paid their workers a decent wage, says Tracey, 44. 
 &bquo;They shouldn't force them to rely on this old-fashioned and arbitrary way of making up their wages &mdash; it's just not fair. 
 However, I do usually bow to tradition and give waiters and hairdressers a little extra.&equo; 
 If people are made aware that the better the service, the more they earn, then it really is an incentive to work hard and perform well, says Tony, 28. 
 &bquo;Tipping &mdash; or rather not  tipping is a good way of showing your disapproval as well as your appreciation.&equo;  
 Job of the week 
 Probation Officer 
 For Frances Minhinnick a normal day's work means dealing with people &bquo;who have broken into schools, nicked cars, committed burglaries, robberies and rape.&equo; 
 As an officer with the Inner London Probation Service, she's responsible for some 30 offenders, all under the age of 21. 
 &bquo;My work involves challenging people about why they offend. 
 I talk to them about the choices they've made which led them to offend, and help them to find strategies to avoid it in the future,&equo; she explains. 
 Her first job as a voluntary residential social worker was looking after juveniles who had &bquo;come through the system of care&equo;. 
 After 14 months, she decide to train for the probation service. 
 Officers are supposed to work 150 hours a month, but Frances, 27, does more. 
 Her job can also mean giving up her Saturdays to attend court, or an evening to see a client who is out during the day. 
 She has even taken a group of clients on holiday. 
 Most of Frances' clients are men. 
 For women officers there's always the possibility that they'll have to deal with the perpetrators of sexual abuse and violence. 
 &bquo;Inevitably there are going to be offences where I feel disgusted by what the person has done and I would probably say that to them. 
 That's quite an effective way of starting to be honest with someone,&equo; admits Frances. 
 &bquo;Building up a feeling of trust is very important.&equo; 
 Safety is another consideration. 
 &bquo;I have never been physically assaulted by a client but there have been circumstances when I've thought I should be a bit careful. 
 If I were planning a home visit to see someone I didn't already know, I'd go with another colleague.&equo; 
 Although there are many male probation officers, Frances believes that women are well suited to probation work as they &bquo;tend to have a degree of sensitivity and an ability to listen and to understand what pain means. 
 You have to like people, and treat them with patience and firmness.&equo; 
 One of the pluses of the job is having really supportive colleagues. 
 And there are many rewards. 
 &bquo;For instance, if you've been working towards getting a client somewhere to live and they get it and they come back to you and say &bquo;Thanks&equo;, that is simply amazing,&equo; says Frances. 
 FACTFILE 
 Are you patient and enthusiastic? 
 To work as a probation officer, you need to be a qualified social worker and must have the appropriate CQSW qualification (Certificate of qualification in Social Work). 
 Studying and training usually takes two years. 
 Where can you get more information? 
 Write to the Home Office, Probation Division, 50 Queen Anne's Gate, London SW1H 9AT. 
 Telephone: 071-273 3000.  
 Variety is a big attraction of Frances Minhinnick's job. 
 &bquo;I'm not office-based &mdash; I'll go to court duty one day, a prison visit the next and perhaps a home visit the following day,&equo; she says. 
 Sherine's in fashion 
 When Sherine Pherozshaw couldn't find the party dress she wanted, she didn't make do with what was on offer in the shops. 
 She simply decided to design her own. 
 The result was a stunning, white lace dress &mdash; an impressive feat made all the more amazing by the fact that Sherine was only eight years old! 
 &bquo;A friend of my mother's runs up the clothes for me, but I want to learn how to use a sewing-machine,&equo; she says. 
 Now 13, Sherine, a petite size eight, gets inspiration from country walks around her home in King's Langley, Hertfordshire, as well as on family holidays in Devon. 
 Two of her favourite outfits are a daffodil dress and a mustard, silk two-piece. 
 &bquo;Natural colours are flattering,&equo; she says, &bquo;I'd never use fluorescent green!&equo; 
 The young designer plans to go to fashion college, and has been busy choreographing her own charity fashion shows in the meantime. 
 &bquo;My friends help by modelling the outfits. 
 We have a lot of fun.&equo;   
 Unable to find a dress she liked, Sherine discovered her own talent for fashion 
 The TROUSER SHAPE for Summer 
 The latest look for this season is lean, elegant and very flattering. 
 Take your pick from bright colours, bold patterns or classic neutrals 
 Dramatic colours look great with neutral, slimline pants. 
 Choose these soft linen pants for comfort and style. 
 Wear these striking cropped trousers with strappy kitten-heeled shoes to show off your legs to best effect. 
 Team eye-catching checks and a fitted blouse with a sweetheart neckline, for the ultimate in 50s glamour. 
 Fashionable lacing on the waistband of these trousers helps to accentuate a trim figure. 
 YOUR RIGHTS 
 ASK THE LAWYER 
 Are the worried by legal problems Let barrister Fenton Bresler tell you exactly where you stand 
 Can I see the will? 
 Before my mother died she told me of a letter to me, held in the bank, which I was to receive on her death. 
 Since she died I have tried without success to get this letter. 
 The bank manager says that I cannot have it until the will's executor, my stepfather, agrees. 
 I've talked to my stepfather, but he denies that the letter even exists. 
 I've asked to see the will but he has refused. 
 Is there anything I can do? 
 I'm afraid a beneficiary is not entitled to see a will or receive a copy. 
 All you can do is wait until your stepfather gets the will admitted to probate. 
 Then it becomes public property and you can, for a small fee, obtain a copy from Somerset House in London. 
 As for the letter, return to the manager and explain to him that, as it's addressed to you, it is your property. 
 The executor has nothing to do with it! 
 Must I pay off our joint overdraft? 
 I lived with a man for 10 years. 
 For most of that time he took drugs. 
 At one time a business proposition came up and, thinking it would help him kick his habit, I agreed to a joint overdraft. 
 He has now left me and I'm stuck with paying a hefty joint overdraft. 
 What should I do? 
 Technically you are both liable for the overdraft and if you could find this man you could sue him. 
 But given his lack of money it's hardly worth it. 
 Banks are not soulless institutions. 
 Contact your manager and see what he suggests. 
 MONEY AND YOU 
 Having a flutter on the horses 
 If you're going to have a bet on the Derby, do make sure you understand the system 
 Nearly 50% of all women allow themselves a once-a-year bet on the horses, according to a recent Gallup survey conducted for the UK's largest bookmaker, Ladbrokes. 
 And a large number of these one-off bets will be placed with Britain's 10,000 betting shops on June 5 when the world's most famous flat race, the Derby, takes place on Epsom Downs. 
 Make a choice 
 Some people pick their horses by choosing a name they fancy, others stick a pin into the list of runners! 
 If these approaches seem a bit arbitrary, then learn how to assess the horse's &bquo;form&equo;. 
 This details its past record, how its performance is expected to be affected by the jockey, whether the grass is soft or firm and the distance. 
 You'll find all this information, including the horse's form rating, in your newspaper. 
 Place your bet 
 Once you've chosen your horse, you can place a bet right up until the &bquo;off&equo; &mdash; when the race starts. 
 The two most popular types of bet are &bquo;Win&equo; and &bquo;Each Way&equo; (EW). 
 A Win bet means that the horse you select must come in first place and the amount that you win will depend on the odds. 
 For example, if you place &pound;2 on a horse with odds of 5/1, and it wins, you win &pound;10 (five times &pound;2). 
 You also get your &pound;2 stake back. 
 For a &pound;1 &bquo;Each Way&equo; bet, you stake &pound;2. &pound;1 of this goes on the same horse to win and the other &pound;1 goes on the same horse to finish in the first three or four places, depending on how many runners there are in the race. 
 This part of the bet will be settled at one fifth of the odds. 
 Betting tax is charged at 10p in the pound, so tax on a &pound;2 bet will be 20p. 
 It's simpler and cheaper to pay it when placing your bet, rather than on your winnings. 
 If you go to the racecourse you can bet at the course's own betting shop or go out into the &bquo;betting ring&equo; where bookmakers have odds chalked up on boards. 
 If you place a bet with your chosen bookie, you will get the price he quotes, no matter how odds change before the race starts, and there is no tax to pay. 
 Try the &bquo;Tote&equo; 
 Finally, you can use the &bquo;Tote&equo;, available at betting shops for some kinds of bets. 
 All money bet on a certain race is placed in a pool, of which the winning tickets get a portion. 
 The size of the &bquo;tote dividend&equo; winners get depends on how much money has been staked and the number of winners. 
 Above all, remember that there is no such thing as a safe bet. 
 Be prepared to lose your money. 
 Next week: financial help for the disabled. 
 Consumer 
 How to put an end to telephone touts 
 Unsolicited calls from salespeople are annoying, but there may soon be a way to stop them 
 Research shows that in 1990 about 60% of us received calls from telephone salesmen, yet three quarters of us object to them. 
 Until now, there was little we could do about this, but complaints have been taken seriously and discussions are now under way between OFTEL, the Office of Telecommunications, and the British Direct Marketing Association (BDMA, representing companies who use telesales). 
 The idea is to set up a Telephone Preference Service. 
 Consumers will be able to put their names on a register of people who don't want to receive sales calls. 
 The scheme should be in operation by the end of the year, and companies will be disciplined, even disconnected, if they persist in phoning any consumers whose names appear on the register. 
 At about the same time, British Telecom are also hoping to introduce a formal code of practice. 
 At present there are just informal guidelines (found at the back of your telephone directory) which say, among other things, that sales people should state their names and their company at the beginning of the call. 
 They should ask if the timing of the call is inconvenient and offer to ring back if not. 
 And finally, they should explain at the very beginning of their conversation why they are phoning you. 
 At present, if you want to stop receiving sales calls, it's up to you to tell each company which contacts you not to bother you in future. 
 Under telephone licence regulations they must keep a list of all such requests and respect them in future. 
 If the calls continue, you should complain to OFTEL  or to the Data Protection Complaints Office . 
 The BDMA  will also investigate any complaints which are made about its member companies. 
 Next week: making the most of your MP  
 Offenders will be disciplined 
 Firms must keep a list of those who ask not to be called 
 In Court Today 
 Student paralysed in car crash receives &pound;1M 
 A brilliant student's seven-year battle for compensation after being crippled for life, has finally come to an end with a record award of &pound;1.2 million. 
 The young man, who is now 23 years old, was only 16 when a car ploughed into him and a couple of friends as they walked home from a party. 
 Seven other youngsters were injured and another killed instantly. 
 The parents of the student were told that his chances of survival were slim. 
 A fight for life 
 But he pulled through, and after 14 months in hospital he was finally allowed home. 
 However, as a result of the accident, he has completely lost the use of his arms and legs and he is now able to communicate with other people only by using his parents to interpret his signs. 
 The young man's solicitor explained to the court how badly he was hurt in the accident. 
 &bquo;He is trapped in a body which is severely disabled and will spend the rest of his life in a wheelchair.&equo; 
 Going to university 
 The solicitor said of the award: &bquo;It's a reasonable figure which will give him satisfactory compensation for a very serious road accident.&equo; 
 The young man, who comes from Gloucestershire, is now studying for A levels and said, through his father, &bquo;I am very pleased indeed. 
 I want to go to university and this will help me achieve that goal.&equo; 
 His father commented: &bquo;Our son hopes to lead an independent life and this money will help him. 
 We will be able to provide the equipment he needs to lead a normal life, and we know he'll want for nothing in the future.&equo; 
 The 18-year-old who caused the accident admitted that he'd been driving recklessly. 
 He was sentenced to 18 months' youth custody and was banned from driving for six years. 
 The award was made as part of an out of court settlement by the driver's insurance firm. 
 It happened to us 
 &bquo;My ex-husband had kidnapped my daughter&equo; 
 Wendy Almon went to pick up two-year-old Eva, but found she'd been abducted 
 After a long and bitter divorce, 34-year-old Wendy Almon was looking forward to starting a new life. 
 &bquo;I'd finally won custody of my daughter Eva and we had just moved down from Scotland to Leeds with my boyfriend Glynn. 
 Things seemed to be looking up at last,&equo; she says. 
 But Wendy's happiness wasn't to last. 
 &bquo;The arrangement was for my ex-husband, Thom, who's American, to see Eva, now three years old, for one week in every four,&equo; explains Wendy. 
 &bquo;It seemed to work OK, although I was always a bit worried Thom might take Eva from me &mdash; he still had her US passport.&equo; 
 Then in November last year, soon after Wendy had given birth to Bryony, her second daughter, everything began to go wrong. 
 &bquo;Eva was with her father, and all was fine until the day before she was due to come home,&equo; recalls Wendy. 
 &bquo;Thom called to say he'd be a day late, and then he just hung up.&equo; 
 Wendy tried to call him back but got no reply. 
 &bquo;I immediately guessed something was wrong &mdash; he always put his answering machine on if he didn't want to talk. 
 By the next morning I was feeling sick with worry, and so we decided to drive to Scotland to collect Eva ourselves.&equo; 
 When they arrived, Wendy's worst fears were confirmed. 
 &bquo;The house was empty &mdash; no furniture, nothing,&equo; she recalls. 
 &bquo;I went into a panic. 
 Eva was only two then, and all I could think was that he'd stolen my little girl. 
 Thank goodness Glynn was there.&equo; 
 Glynn immediately contacted Wendy's lawyer. 
 &bquo;He first registered Eva as a missing person and then got a judge to issue an order to seek and find her,&equo; explains Glynn. 
 &bquo;The judge agreed to sign a warrant for Thom's arrest as soon as it was clear he'd left the country with Eva.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wanted to do something, too,&equo; recalls Wendy. 
 &bquo;So we went through Thom's mail and found an invoice for the furniture shipment to New Jersey. 
 I guessed that's where he had gone.&equo; 
 The police, however, still needed proof that Thom had left the country with Eva before issuing a warrant. 
 &bquo;We decided to contact an American lawyer. 
 He froze all Thom's US bank accounts, which is legal and common practice in the USA. 
 He also impounded Thom's furniture and had a New Jersey warrant for his arrest issued,&equo; says Wendy. 
 Thom was nearly caught in New Jersey, but he fled to another state. 
 &bquo;New Jersey warrants are useless in any other state,&equo; explains Wendy. 
 &bquo;We needed a federal warrant, which is valid all over America. 
 That meant the Scottish police asking the Americans to extradite Thom. 
 After three weeks of legal wrangling the Foreign Office finally asked the Americans for help. 
 But they only asked for Eva to be found, not brought home. 
 I thought I would never see her again.&equo; 
 In the end it was the action of freezing Thom's bank accounts that finally traced him. 
 &bquo;After a month in hiding he was running out of money,&equo; explains Wendy. 
 &bquo;His US lawyer contacted ours and said he wanted to swop our daughter for a guarantee that he wouldn't be arrested! 
 We knew that his lawyer was in Colorado. 
 So I put two and two together and told the state police.&equo; 
 Within days Eva was safe. 
 &bquo;She was taken into custody. 
 We flew out the next day. 
 She was in my arms on January 15.&equo; 
 Now safely home, Eva shows few signs of her experience. 
 &bquo;She's her normal chattering self,&equo; says Wendy. 
 &bquo;But now we're in the middle of another legal battle with Thom for compensation for the abduction. 
 It cost us &pound;50,000 to get Eva back, but I'd spend it again if I had to.&equo; 
 Next week: victims of hit and run drivers  
 Legal wrangling goes on, but Eva's with Wendy and Glynn 
 &bquo;He wanted to swop her for a guarantee that he would not be arrested&equo; 
 OUR EXPERT REPLIES 
 Up to 1,000 children are snatched from this country by their mother or father every year. 
 And, although child abduction is a criminal offence, finding the child often comes too late for prosecution to take place &mdash; the parent has already left Britain. 
 Wendy was luckier than most. 
 Her daughter was taken to America which is a European Convention country (there are 16 in all). 
 This meant that she could have used the Convention's rulings on child abduction to get Eva back. 
 She'd have been given help by the Lord Chancellor's Department, and her costs would have been minimal. 
 But it can take many months and, as Wendy realised, the longer she waited, the harder it would be to trace Eva. 
 So, like many other parents in her situation, she decided to fight her own case. 
 But for parents whose children are taken to non-Convention countries, there is no choice. 
 They have to make a huge effort, spend large amounts of money and often wait months, even years, to trace their son or daughter. 
 And there is the likelihood that they won't get permission to take their child home. 
 Mental strain on parents in either situation is enormous, and often likened to bereavement. 
 The most important thing for any parent who suspects that the father or mother of their child will try to take them, is to make sure they give them no opportunity. 
 Reunite, the National Council for Abducted Children, offers advice about prevention and recovery. 
 It has a national and international network of lawyers and tries to link parents to each other for mutual support.  
 &bquo;Tracing a child may take months, even years&equo; 
 STOP PRESS 
 Energy Efficient? 
 It's now easier to check if the house you are planning to buy is &bquo;green&equo;, thanks to a new rating scheme launched by the National Energy Foundation. 
 National Home Energy Rating (NHER) assesses the efficiency of heating, lighting and domestic appliances on a scale of one to 10. 
 Write to the Foundation for a list of NHER assessors in your area who will carry out a check for a fee starting at &pound;50. 
 Danger of hiring DIY equipment 
 A recent survey by the Consumers Association (CA) showed that a third of the tools hired from 32 randomly selected shops were found to be faulty when examined by experts. 
 And half the people who hired items were given no verbal advice on choosing and using them. 
 The CA advises that all tools should come with printed instructions &mdash; already the policy of the Hire Association of Europe. 
 If there aren't any, ask for them. 
 Make sure you hire from an HAE member and ask for a demonstration. 
 If you do end up hiring an unsafe tool, inform your local trading standards officer immediately.  
 GET YOUR HAIR INTO GREAT CONDITION 
 With a little extra help your hair can start the summer as it means to go on &mdash; looking terrific. 
 Follow our advice, and get your locks ready to face up to the rigours and trials of sun, sea water and chlorine 
 Summer sunshine and frequent dips in the sea or pool will lift your spirits and brighten the natural lights in your hair, but you should take care to remember that, as with most things, it is possible to have too much of a good thing. 
 Chlorine is well-known for its drying and oxidising qualities which have the effect of bleaching the hair and reacting against the chemicals used in perms and colorants. 
 Sun and salt water are equally drying and a combination of all three can prove harmful to your hair leaving it looking dull and frizzy and very much the worse-for-wear. 
 However, it is possible to limit the damage with extra conditioning and give your locks an extra boost by taking some Brewer's yeast, Vitamin B complex or kelp tablets each day. 
 ADAPT YOUR PRODUCTS WHEN THE SUN SHINES 
 If you plan to have a perm or some colouring book your appointment 2&ndash;3 weeks before going on holiday. 
 Shades for sunny days 
 Gerard Kierans, UK Artistic Director of the Graham Webb group of salons, says: &bquo;Coloured hair can change in the sun so we always ask clients to let us know when they're going away. 
 The colourist can then take this into account when choosing the shade.&equo; 
 Ian Denson of John Frieda suggests having highlights several weeks before leaving and protect your hair in the sun when sunbathing by combing through conditioner. 
 Products to pack 
 Gerard also stresses the importance of taking the right conditioning products on holiday with you. 
 &bquo;Many people take an all-in-one shampoo and conditioner, then moan when their hair looks dry and brittle. 
 Whether your hair has been chemically treated or not, you should take extra rich products to put back the moisture removed by the sun, sea and chlorine. 
 Always pack products with built-in UV filters.&equo; 
 STEPS TO HEALTHY HAIR 
 While, in the 80s, it was fine for your hair to look fashionably unkempt, the 90s is all about healthy, well-groomed hair with a natural shine. 
 Full of body and bounce, it should move as you do. 
 Follow our guide and make cutting, cleansing and conditioning work for you. 
 You'll soon be able to see &mdash; and feel &mdash; the improvement. 
 Regular trimming can make hair look thicker 
 The first step is a visit to your hairdresser to have your hair shaped and the split ends cut. 
 Even the tiniest trim gives more body. 
 A re-style can provide locks with a new lease of life. 
 Quick tricks 
 While you're there, ask for some styling tips from your hairdresser &mdash; most are happy to oblige and you can pick up some very useful tricks of the trade. 
 Gerard Kierans comments: &bquo;Even a simple tip can save time and effort. 
 For example, the easiest way to find your parting is to comb your hair back, then push it forwards until it parts naturally &mdash; this is very useful if you're caught without a mirror.&equo; 
 Adding height 
 If you've got long hair ask your stylist to show you how to put it up. 
 French plaits and pleats are fashionable at present. 
 Some hairdressers charge extra for this but it's well worth paying a few pounds for. 
 GENTLE CLEANSING 
 Getting hair into shape means taking extra care at every stage. 
 If you wash your hair frequently use an extra mild shampoo that won't dry it out. 
 Try Daniel Field Spring Water Frequent Wash Shampoo, &pound;2.40 for 250ml. 
 Choosing shampoo 
 Look for a formula to suit your hair type. 
 After washing, your hair should feel soft, yet full of body. 
 If it feels lank, switch to a lighter product and make sure you rinse well. 
 Try some massage 
 When you wash your hair massage your scalp to stimulate the flow of oxygen and nutrients to the hair follicles. 
 Apply shampoo to your hands then smooth it evenly over your hair. 
 Starting at your forehead and working down to your neck, firmly massage small areas at a time. 
 CONDITIONERS REPAIR THE DAMAGE 
 On healthy hair the cuticle scales lie flat, reflecting light and giving hair a healthy sheen. 
 When hair is damaged the roughened cuticles no longer overlap smoothly. 
 Conditioners help by smoothing the hair's surface and replenishing some of its natural moisture.  
 Don't think that just because a shampoo doesn't lather well it isn't doing its job. 
 Handfuls of froth simply mean that the manufacturer has added lots of foaming agents. 
 Find a cleanser to suit your hair type. 
 Hair Problems 
 If you're taking regular care of your hair and it still looks less than great, don't be downhearted. 
 Most hair care worries can be sorted out by changing your basic routine or using products to suit your hair type. 
 We answer three of your queries about getting hair into tip-top condition. 
 My hair always seems to look lank and lifeless, even though I make sure that I wash and condition it regularly. 
 What am I doing wrong? 
 Try switching to hair care products with a light consistency and make sure you rinse out any setting agents thoroughly. 
 The resins in these products can form a sticky coating on the hair, which makes it look dull, lank and lifeless. 
 Once a week, use a specially formulated shampoo to deep-cleanse your hair, like Marks &amp; Spencer Professional Formula Anti-Build-Up Shampoo, &pound;1.75 for 250ml. 
 If your hair is long, apply conditioner to the older, dryer ends only. 
 I've been using a leave-in conditioner on my hair and am very pleased with the results. 
 However, recently I've noticed white specks appearing in my hair. 
 Could the product itself have given me dandruff? 
 It sounds as though you've been using more conditioner than your hair needs. 
 The product that hasn't been absorbed is causing these unsightly specks. 
 Try using a smaller amount, massaging it between your fingers before applying hair to ensure that it's evenly distributed. 
 Or try a spray product like Lamaur Nu-plex Daily Leave-In Conditioning Mist, &pound;7.45 for 236ml. 
 My hair seems to have lost some of its colour as I've got older. 
 I don't want a complete shade change but would like to cheer it up for summer. 
 Have you any suggestions? 
 Temporary colorants are a good way to add warmth, richness and shine to your natural shade. 
 They coat the hair with colour and, because they don't contain peroxide, won't dry or damage it. 
 Our favourites are J F Lazartique highlighting creams for hair. 
 They come in nine shades and give a short-lived burst of colour which fades over three to four shampoos. 
 If you've a few grey hairs and want something more lasting try their colouring emulsion for grey hair which lasts two to three months. 
 They're quite pricey &mdash; &pound;13 and &pound;8, respectively &mdash; but, unless your hair is very long, there's enough for several applications  
 If you'd like to brighten the colour of your hair, but don't want to risk undermining its condition, try a temporary colorant. 
 These won't damage you hair at all: in fact because they contain lots of conditioning agents they can make it much more shiny and manageable. 
 An intensive conditioner will work much better if you cover hair with a polythene bag after applying to seal in body heat. 
 If your hair is long, the ends need extra attention. 
 Revitalise them with conditioning serum. 
 TALKING POINT 
 Is it wrong to try to change YOUR PARTNER? 
 Many of us try to improve our other halves from time to time &mdash; perhaps you wish he were tidier while he would prefer you a little slimmer. 
 But will this harm the relationship in the long term, or is a bit of criticism good for you? 
 Judith Leggett had told her partner Patrick Cartan, 32, yet again, that she didn't like his awful checked shirts. 
 But, as before, he didn't take any notice. 
 So she opted for desperate measures to get him to change his image. 
 &bquo;I just threw them all in the bin,&equo; remembers Judith, 27, from Cambridge. 
 Luckily, Patrick saw the funny side and went out and bought some shirts his partner approved of. 
 Throwing out all those shirts hasn't really altered Patrick in any major way, but Judith is happier. 
 But can it threaten your relationship if you try to change your loved one too much? 
 Are women more prone than men to finding fault? 
 And what's really wrong with knocking a few of the rough edges off your partner? 
 Andrew Lloyd-Webber's new wife, horsewoman Madeline Gurdon, has tried to smarten him up. 
 She's encouraged him to cut his hair and lose weight, and still Andrew somehow can't help looking a little scruffy. 
 Zelda West-Meads of the marriage guidance counselling service, Relate, believes it's perfectly acceptable to change your partner in the way Madeline and Judith have done, although she would recommend you using more tact than Judith did. 
 &bquo;If you're fed up with your partner wearing that shaggy old jumper, why not suggest that you go shopping together and help him to choose something better?&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;Do try and be kind.&equo; 
 But some people don't just try to change their other half's appearance: they want to alter their characters, too. 
 Rachel Browne, 25, who's a trainee solicitor from Devon, believes she's managed to influence her boyfriend Al Damon, 30, in more fundamental ways than his style of shirt. 
 &bquo;He's not particularly assertive, so I try to make him more so,&equo; she explains. 
 &bquo;He never used to notice when people took advantage of him, so I started pointing it out. 
 Now I think he's considerably less likely to be taken for a ride.&equo; 
 Rachel does know she shouldn't try to change Al, but she says, &bquo;It's inevitable. 
 People are very seldom exactly what you would like them to be.&equo; 
 Karen Gorbutt, 30, from South London, has been trying for years to get her partner, Matthew Allen, 30, to be considerate around the house. 
 &bquo;The way he turns on the television as soon as he walks into the room drives me nuts,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;But after rowing about it for ages, I came home from work the other day and it wasn't on. 
 He was reading a book. 
 For all my nagging, he'd got the message and turned it off.&equo; 
 While Judith, Rachel and Karen are sure their partners are happy to go along with the little alterations they try to make, Zelda says that interfering too much can prove to be very dangerous to a relationship. 
 &bquo;Imagine how you would feel if you were on the receiving end of your criticism,&equo; she suggests. 
 Social psychologist Robin Gilmour of the University of Lancaster warns that constant criticism &bquo;can lead to your partner feeling resentful&equo;. 
 Indeed, the cost of trying to change someone can be very high. 
 Victoria Lockhart, 20, finished her three-year relationship with Dennis Harper, 25, when she got fed up with his endless attempts to alter the way she looked. 
 She's very slim with curves in all the right places, but Dennis wanted her to be even thinner. 
 &bquo;He used to buy slimming magazines for me and put them in my bag,&equo; remembers Victoria, who lives in Manchester. 
 &bquo;When we were in restaurants, he'd say, &bquo;You don't want any pudding, do you?&equo; 
 And he'd always ask how much I'd eaten that day.&equo; 
 Sometimes his concern with changing the way she looked amused Victoria, but at other times she found it upsetting. 
 In the end, she explains, &bquo;I became more confident and  happy with the way I looked. 
 I didn't want to be dictated to.&equo; 
 So she left. 
 Beth Wilson, 24, of Hull, tried to transform her boyfriend, Mojo Hughes, 24, from the outgoing man who enjoyed partying every night into someone who was happy to spend a quiet evening in with her. 
 &bquo;At first he agreed that he'd much rather be at home with me. 
 We started spending most weekends at home together. 
 But it put too much pressure on the relationship, and when it finished I realised that he'd resented what I had done. 
 He found that he couldn't go out with the lads anymore, and he felt he'd lost his happy-go-lucky side. 
 After we split up he started going out with a woman who wanted to go out on the town every night &mdash; like him.&equo; 
 Beth's experience suggests that people don't change deep down, even if they really want to try to please their partner. 
 Zelda says, &bquo;You shouldn't go into a relationship saying, &bquo;I'll alter him&equo;, or &bquo;Once we're married&hellip;&equo;, because they may not change, and what will you do then?&equo; 
 So do women try to change men more than men want to change women? 
 Londoner Roz Jakes, 30, thinks it works both ways. 
 She's managed to persuade her partner, James Allen, 28, to try vegetarian food. 
 &bquo;When I first met him he thought I was mad because I didn't eat meat. 
 Now he'll look out for restaurants we can both go to,&equo; she explains. 
 She is bringing up their daughter, Katherine, 21 months, to be a vegetarian, too. 
 And while James still eats chops with his meal, Roz says, &bquo;When Katherine asks him if she can have some of his dinner, he says, &bquo;Mummy wouldn't like it&equo;.&equo; 
 She won James round to her way of eating, but in return he tries to alter her, too. 
 &bquo;He wants me to have really short hair, just as I did 10 years ago.&equo; 
 Roz and James have both tried to change each other. 
 But she's noticed among her friends that women carry on trying for much longer. 
 &bquo;Changing a man is a way women can show their power. 
 It's a way of saying to yourself, if he really loves me, he'll stop doing that because I want him to&equo;, Roz says. 
 Yet Zelda says, &bquo;I don't think it's only women who want to change their partner. 
 There are times when we all want to get inside the other person's head and switch a few knobs to re-programme them completely. 
 Of course, that's just not possible.&equo; 
 Beth Wilson disagrees, &bquo;I think women often have an ideal of the perfect man, and if he scores nine out of 10, then it's far too much a temptation not to want to try to change that last little bit.&equo; 
 She also thinks that men tend to choose women who make up for their own shortcomings. 
 &bquo;I always tried to make Mojo more organised,&equo; she says, &bquo;but all that ended up happening was that I kept his diary and sent letters off for him. 
 He didn't ever change himself, he just went out with organised women.&equo; 
 In the end, psychologist Robin Gilmour believes, if you feel there's something that needs changing in your relationship, you should think very carefully about continuing in it. 
 &bquo;The most successful relationships are the ones in which the issue of changing people doesn't arise,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;If you can't accept your partner as he is, you shouldn't be going out with him.&equo; 
 ROD'S LINE-UP OF LOOK-ALIKES 
 Singer Rod Stewart hasn't changed the women he's been out with; he's just exchanged the model &mdash; they all have long blonde hair and long legs. 
 Social psychologist Robin Gilmour says, &bquo;Some people have a strong blueprint of their ideal person, so they choose a similar one each time.&equo; 
 Zelda West-Meads of Relate adds, &bquo;Here someone is looking for their ideal, but she doesn't exist. 
 Rather than recognise points about themselves that need changing, what they are doing is changing their partner for a new one.  
 BRITT EKLAND Swedish Britt was the original blonde bombshell 
 ALANA STEWART Married for five years, Rod and Alana had two children 
 KELLY EMBERG After six years together she won &pound;7,000 a month palimony 
 RACHEL HUNTER &bquo;This time I really mean it &mdash; she's changed my life 
 People are very seldom exactly what you'd like them to be 
 Changing the Royal image 
 The suits are now double-breasted and more sleek, the ties more sophisticated, the hair more stylish and the fashionable loafers are a definite improvement on the old lace-ups. 
 Charles has been transformed since he married Diana. 
 But there are some thing she can't change, like the way he shoves his hand into his pocket, his preference for classical music to Dire Straits, and looking at buildings rather than eyeing up the latest cat-walk creations  
 The youngest old-fogey in town 
 Fashion conscious in his 40s 
 Your Letters 
 The novel idea of recycling stories 
 After coming across a hefty pile of best  magazines prior to moving house earlier this year, I thought of a novel idea. 
 I cut out all the short stories from nearly 100 magazines and pasted them into a collection of scrapbooks. 
 So far, I've given two to friends in hospital and one to an elderly neighbour, who's begged me to let her have another one so that she can pass the first one on. 
 It's something I can do on long, boring evenings and gives the recipients a lot of pleasure. 
 I wonder if other readers will give it a try?  
 &pound;25 LETTER OF THE WEEK 
 A truly green garden 
 We have a marvellous collection of birds in our garden, such as thrushes and blackbirds. 
 They clear the lawn of slugs and at the same time delight us with their presence. 
 We even have a tiny yellowhammer which visits us each morning. 
 We never  use pesticides or insecticides and this is the wonderful result. 
 Square-eyed generation 
 Seeing a video hire shop on a Saturday night crammed with people choosing what they are going to watch that evening is a sad sight. 
 Whatever happened to getting together with your friends or family and talking together? 
 These days, everyone just sits in front of the box for entertainment. 
 The only thing people seem to have to talk about is television. 
 &bquo;What did you watch last night?&equo; may be a good way to open a conversation but it's a lousy topic to continue with. 
 Think before you judge 
 I'm often surprised by people who voice their opinions and are adamant that they are right &mdash; from those who think people with a hereditary disease shouldn't have children, to people who feel strongly about disposable nappies. 
 How can they be so certain that their judgements are fair and just? 
 I wonder if they have really thought about other people's situations. 
 If we all tried to see things from more than our own view point, the world would be a better place. 
 Family reservations 
 My friend was fed up with preparing meals for her teenaged children who then often didn't turn up to eat. 
 So she decided to take &bquo;bookings&equo;. 
 Each day her youngsters have to reserve a seat at the table and no prior reservation means no meal. 
 Her restaurant is now permanently booked! 
 JUST FOR LAUGHS 
 &bull; After a big family celebration, we all grouped together to be photographed. 
 I noticed that my mother kept asking my boyfriend and my brother's girlfriend to move further and further over until they were almost standing on their own. 
 When I asked my mother what she was doing, she replied: &bquo;I thought if nothing were to come of your relationships, I could cut them out of the photographs!&equo; 
 &bull; When my mother arrived to stay with us, my young son Adam greeted her excitedly. 
 &bquo;Will Daddy be able to do his trick?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;What trick is that?&equo; she responded. 
 &bquo;Well&equo;, came the reply from Adam, &bquo;he said that if you stayed longer than a week he'd hit the roof!&equo;  
 Homeshop 
 Ideas by post 
 Our choice of the best mail order buys 
 Join the home guard 
 Keep surrounding surfaces clean and clear up fast after a messy job with this practical polyethylene sheet. 
 It provides an ample working area and has corner fasteners to lift the edges, and help to prevent spills. 
 What's more, when you've finished with it simply wipe it clean and then fold it flat for easy storage. 
 Waterproof and tearproof, the Tidy Sheet measures 81cm square ref 8159 &pound;2.49, p&amp;p &pound;1.94 on orders up to &pound;30. 
 Mail order from Lakeland Plastics,  
 Miraculous magnet 
 Strong enough to lift up to 200lbs, this six stacked rust resistant magnet has an overall gripping area of 8.25cm square and will collect dressmakers' pins or DIY nails just like magic. 
 Mighty Magnet, &pound;29.95 p&amp;p &pound;2.95. 
 Mail order from Science Museum Brainwaves,  
 THE THINGS PEOPLE BUY 
 Sounds in the round 
 Here's the world's first radio that doubles as a fun fashion accessory in its own right. 
 Enclosed in a transparent shell with an ingeniously designed neck strap-cum-aerial, it can go anywhere you can go. 
 Colourful flashing lights synchronize the sound. 
 Measuring 6cm across with AM/FM and headphone adaptor the Switch It radio costs &pound;24, p&amp;p &pound;2.50. 
 Mail order from Compare,  
 Another tall story 
 Used originally by Tallymen who sat behind a high desk to keep account of cargo being unloaded, and later adapted by film directors, you'll find this seat ideal if you have a breakfast bar. 
 You can also have it personalised with your name. 
 Tallyman chair, 76cm high &pound;36.50; letters 25p each, p&amp;p &pound;.45. 
 Mail order from Nauticalia Ltd,  
 Kind cleansers 
 This range of products, not tested on animals, includes 150ml each of Evening Primrose Oil Moisturiser, Periwinkle Skin Toner, Watercress Cleanser and a tablet of 100gm vegetable soap. 
 Natural Skincare Collection &pound;9.99 p&amp;p &pound;.45. 
 Mail order from WWF UK Ltd,  
 Dual role jug 
 Whether it's for fresh juice or making coffee in the microwave, the versatile Microbist jug is a must for the modern kitchen. 
 Made from microwave-friendly materials, it can be used to brew and re-heat coffee quickly and removing the plunger transforms it into a stylish juice jug. 
 The six-cup Microbist &pound;11.99 p&amp;p incl. 
 Mail order from Life Cycle Products,  
 A black and white number 
 Let your man make a bold statement with this sporty outfit. 
 Top, 100% cotton &pound;14.99, lined cotton polyester trousers with elasticated waist and ankles, &pound;16.99, cotton baseball cap with mirror perspex &bquo;NYC&equo;, &pound;8.99 p&amp;p incl. 
 Mail order from Caroline in Direct Sales, Freemans,  
 Ordering Goods 
 When buying by mail order, keep a copy of the details relating to both the company you are buying from and the item. 
 If you haven't heard from the firm within 28 days, write to find out why. 
 Never send any cash with your order. 
 All catalogues mentioned on this page are free to best  readers unless otherwise stated. 
 Every effort is made to ensure prices are accurate and goods available, but best  cannot take responsibility for either. 
 GOOD HEALTH 
 GENERAL MEDICINE 
 Can low blood pressure be a risk? 
 Most of us have been warned about the health risks of high blood pressure (hypertension) but few people are aware that in several European countries the opposite condition of low blood pressure (hypotension) is regarded as a medical problem. 
 In West Germany, up to one in 10 of the population is said to suffer. 
 Symptoms of hypotension include tiredness, light-headedness or dizziness and fainting, all of which could easily be attributed to other complaints. 
 Headaches are common, too, as are cold hands and feet. 
 What's confusing, though is that some of these symptoms are sometimes reported by people who suffer from high blood pressure. 
 Permanently low blood pressure, meanwhile, shouldn't be confused with temporary hypotension. 
 This normally occurs after any sudden and serious loss of blood or after excessive fluid loss following a severe bout of diarrhoea. 
 It can also occur after a heart attack or, if you are taking drugs to treat high blood pressure and you exceed the recommended dose. 
 Yet it's estimated that about one in five of us is affected. 
 Among young people, women seem to be more prone to it than men, while research shows that sufferers are generally of slim build and underweight. 
 But older men and women may be affected too, and evidence has shown that some races are more likely to have it than others. 
 Australian Aborigines, East Africans, Bengalis, Asians and Philippinos all have generally lower blood pressures than Europeans. 
 The good news is that people with lower blood pressures have lower mortality rates than those who suffer from hypertension. 
 And, despite claims, particularly among the Germans, French, Italians and Spanish, that it is a bad thing, many American insurance companies reckon that people with low blood pressure in middle age, far from suffering a disease, are expected to lead the longest and healthiest lives.  
 Patients who have hypotension can expect longer,  more healthier  lives 
 Next week: different ways to relieve pain 
 GYNAECOLOGY 
 Breast is still the best, say experts 
 Babies that are breastfed are less likely to fall victim to gastro-enteritis, respiratory infections and glue ear. 
 And it's also known that breastmilk has a special value for babies most vulnerable to infection, for example those born ill or premature. 
 Magic ingredients 
 Now new research has added to that list &mdash; this time it can help fight urine infections. 
 The good news is that this protective effect not only extends to babies, it applies to the nursing mothers too. 
 The magic ingredients in breastmilk which are thought to strike the germs responsible for causing urine infections, are a group of sugars, called oligosaccharides. 
 These sugars, which are found in the milk itself, and also in the urine of nursing mothers, protect in two ways. 
 Firstly they prevent the bacteria that cause urine infections from sticking to the skin cells in the bladder and urethra. 
 Secondly they act on E coli, bacteria responsible for the vast majority of urine infections. 
 The oligosaccharides have been found to be particularly concentrated in colostrum &mdash; the thick, creamy pre-milk that is produced by the breasts in late pregnancy and during the first few days after birth before the breastmilk proper comes in. 
 Not only is colostrum known to be extremely nutritious but it too has special protective properties against illness. 
 Protective effect 
 And the good news doesn't stop there. 
 Another group of researchers, this time in Sweden, has discovered that this protective effect doesn't only last for as long as the baby is breastfed. 
 The milk creates a more balanced bacterial environment in the gut, and children of six or seven who were breastfed as babies are less likely to succumb to urinary infections than their bottlefed brothers and sisters. 
 The lesson is to breastfeed your baby if you can. 
 Even if it's only for a few days both you and your baby will benefit.  
 Next week: can the pill help fertility? 
 ALTERNATIVE HEALTH 
 Get the most from mineral water 
 More people are now turning to the bottled version as an alternative to tapped 
 The latest decade has seen a huge increase in the popularity of mineral waters. 
 This is not surprising, when you consider the life history of much of our tap water. 
 If you live in London, yours could be the seventh pair of kidneys that your glass of water has passed through and chemicals used in farming today seep into the ground to pollute and contaminate the water. 
 This doesn't happen to mineral waters. 
 The bottles you buy today contain rain water which fell up to 80 years ago. 
 Filtered through hundreds of feet of layers of purifying sand, shale and rock, the rain water has been enriched with natural minerals &mdash; the most beneficial of which are calcium, for building bones, magnesium and sodium, an important constituent of salt. 
 Although minerals are only present in minute quantities it's worth remembering that when choosing your water. 
 Anyone with high blood pressure, or heart disease, for example, should avoid those with a high sodium content. 
 Here is a selection of the most common mineral water. 
 MALVERN WATER 
 The oldest established of the English brands. 
 It comes from springs in the hills above Malvern, and as these are granite, little of their composition dissolves into the water so it is very low in minerals. 
 Almost no taste at all, hence its wide use as a mixer with scotch! 
 STILL HIGHLAND SPRING WATER 
 One of the best-selling of the British waters. 
 Low in sodium and nitrates, this is suitable for those with heart and kidney problems. 
 EVIAN 
 The biggest seller of all still waters in its native France. 
 And because it is very low in minerals, it suits a wide range of people and is ideal for families with young children. 
 It's the only water that the French government recommends for mixing baby foods. 
 The spa at Evian has been famous since the 18th century as the place to go for the treatment of kidney stones and urinary infections. 
 Evian water takes 15 years to filter down from Alpine snows to the town spring. 
 BUXTON SPRING WATER 
 Very light with a delicate flavour. 
 There is a moderate level of minerals which has given this water its therapeutic reputation since Roman times. 
 It comes out of the ground at 82&deg;F, and was drunk by Medieval pilgrims and Mary Queen of Scots. 
 SAN PELLEGRINO 
 From the Italian Alps. 
 Quite rich in magnesium and calcium, but low in salt. 
 Used since the 13th century to aid digestion. 
 SPA WATER 
 A Belgian variety with a very low salt content and one of the best known mineral waters in the world. 
 With its slightly metallic flavour, Spa is perfect for those on a low salt diet. 
 RAMLOSA 
 A Swedish brand. 
 Alkaline and moderately rich in minerals, it takes up to 80 years to filter through 295 feet of sand, clay, shale, coal and siltstone. 
 This selection of carbonated and still waters cam be found on most supermarket shelves.  
 Next Week: relief for glue ear from osteopathy 
 Stop Press 
 Reducing risk of heart attack 
 MEN WITH high blood pressure who are treated with a beta blocker drug are less likely to suffer sudden death from a heart attack, a new 11-country study has shown. 
 In all 3,200 middle-aged men were given either beta blockers or diuretics for their blood pressure over a 10-year period. 
 At the end of the study there were 30% fewer sudden deaths in the beta blocker group. 
 This, researchers believe, is due to the drug's direct action on the heart. 
 &pound;2 million MS unit to open 
 A NEW unit is to be set up by the Multiple Sclerosis Society which will devote its time to research into MS, a disease of the nervous system. 
 More than &pound;1.25 million of the &pound;2 million needed has already been raised and the Society hopes to open the unit soon. 
 Pill use increase 
 MORE WOMEN than ever prefer the contraceptive pill as their means of birth control and many are reluctant to consider newer methods, according to a recent survey. 
 The National Opinion Poll (NOP) found that 32% of women were using the pill, compared with 25% in a similar poll taken in 1987. 
 It happened to me 
 &bquo;A simple cough was enough to break her ribs&equo; 
 It wasn't until Joanna Venet was seven months old that her mother, Rosemerry, realised she was suffering from brittle bones 
 Like any other mother, Rosemerry Venet was thrilled when her daughter, Joanna, was born. 
 The only trouble was that, unlike most babies, Joanna didn't seem to enjoy being bounced and cuddled. 
 &bquo;She would cry, constantly,&equo; recalls Rosemerry, 38, from Leeds, &bquo;yet there was never anything obviously wrong.&equo; 
 Rosemerry and her husband, Harry, 50, later found that their gentle playing had actually been breaking their daughter's bones. 
 For Joanna, now 15, had osteogenesis imperfecta, more commonly known as brittle bone disease. 
 The nightmare began when she was just five months old. 
 Rosemerry heard a resounding &bquo;crack&equo; as she changed her nappy one day. 
 Joanna had dislocated her hip and was admitted to hospital. 
 &bquo;She screamed out in pain as the doctors examined her,&equo; recalls Rosemerry, &bquo;it was terrible.&equo; 
 Numerous X-rays showed that Joanna had a broken left leg and had fractures to several ribs as well as her spine. 
 &bquo;Everybody at the hospital seemed to be accusing me of causing the injuries. 
 It was like a terrible dream,&equo; remembers Rosemerry. 
 &bquo;I knew I hadn't done anything to Joanna and at the same time I was totally confused as to how it could have happened.&equo; 
 Joanna was kept in hospital for 10 weeks, during which time she was tested for all kinds of illnesses. 
 &bquo;They were horrendous, long days. 
 I was frightened for her and frantically worried,&equo; remembers Rosemerry, who also had her elder daughter, Rosalind, now 17, to look after. 
 Joanna was diagnosed as having brittle bones. 
 &bquo;Of course, we were devastated, but we knew now what had been wrong all along &mdash; and at least they couldn't blame me any more.&equo; 
 The doctors told the Venets that when Joanna was four she would be able to undergo a series of operations to insert strengthening rods into her legs. 
 &bquo;But in the meantime, even coughing could break Joanna's ribs &mdash; which it did many times. 
 Her legs were by far the worst, though &mdash; just supporting her own body weight could break them. 
 She'd be in plaster for six weeks each time she broke them,&equo; says Rosemerry. 
 So at just four years old, little Joanna was confined to hospital for two years while the operations took place. 
 &bquo;It was heart-breaking &mdash; she looked so frail, I felt as if I'd almost lost her,&equo; says her mum. 
 Now, however, Rosemerry admits that the success was worth the sacrifice. 
 &bquo;From having literally dozens of fractures she progressed so much I can't remember the last time she had one.&equo; 
 And Joanna's bones have strengthened naturally as she has grown older. 
 She's now able to walk around the house although outside she has to use a wheelchair. 
 And she's determined not to be held back by her condition. 
 She's taking GCSEs this June and hopes to go on to &bquo;A &bquo;levels. 
 And each week she goes snorkelling with a disabled club. 
 She's even been abseiling. 
 &bquo;If I can break something, I break it. 
 I know it will hurt for a little while, but I'll get better, so why worry? 
 I don't see why I can't lead a normal life,&equo; says brave Joanna. 
 &bquo;In any case, I'm certainly going to try.&equo; 
 OUR EXPERT REPLIES 
 Dr Colin Paterson, Senior Lecturer in Biochemical Medicine at the University of Dundee 
 Brittle bone disease, or osteogenesis imperfecta, has been around for at least 4,000 years. 
 There's even a &bquo;mummy&equo; in the British Museum of an affected child. 
 It occurs in all races and can vary greatly in severity. 
 Children with an apparently mild form of the disease can be difficult to diagnose in the early stages. 
 Sadly, the Venets' experience of being accused of child abuse is not uncommon. 
 In one case a child was removed from her mother after a fracture at the age of 18 months. 
 She was nearly adopted before the correct diagnosis became obvious at the age of five. 
 Recent research has shed light on this disease. 
 All or most cases result from an inborn defect in the formation of collagen, the tough fibrous protein essential for the strength of bone. 
 Bone is normally strong because it consists of a lattice-work of collagen fibres with calcium, the chalk-like material, in the gaps. 
 In brittle bone disease, collagen is abnormal in strength or in the links between the fibres. 
 However, it is not a problem of calcium deficiency; eating extra milk or cheese doesn't help the condition. 
 As the Venets' experience shows, trying to avoid fractures in brittle bone children can be very difficult. 
 Sometimes they break a bone without any known injury; at other times fractures don't happen when you might expect them most. 
 In some cases surgery can help, as it has for Joanna. 
 Practical help and advice is available from the Brittle Bone Society, 112, City Road, Dundee DD2 2PW.  
 &bquo;Parents are sometimes accused of abuse&equo; 
 With help from Rosemerry (right), Joanna leads a normal life 
 The deformed bone (A) is broken and steel pins (B) inserted to strengthen it (C) 
 &bquo;The success of the operation was worth all the suffering&equo; 
 Next week: update on hay fever 
 PROFILE 
 SUE LAWLEY 
 &bquo;My idea of bliss is a pile of clean sheets and an iron&equo; 
 She spends her working life in the glamorous world of celebrities and top politicians. 
 But when she's at home, Sue Lawley loves nothing more than getting down to some old-fashioned housework 
 For 17 years Sue Lawley was the serious face of the BBC. 
 Unafraid to pose even the most awkward questions to MPs, she was a respected political interviewer and newsreader. 
 Then four short years ago, shortly after she turned 40, it all changed. 
 Suddenly, she was hosting Wogan , dripping diamant&eacute; jewellery, wearing shiny tights, high heels and rustling short taffeta skirts. 
 She was pointing at her guests with red-painted fingernails and flirting with the men. 
 It seemed as if one of the most respected women on television had succumbed to the lure of glitzy fame. 
 The truth was, Sue was just being adventurous. 
 &bquo;I don't think I am a born light entertainer and I don't think I'm a born serious political interviewer,&equo; Sue explains. 
 &bquo;I think I can do a little of both. 
 People all the time wish to pigeon-hole you&hellip; to say that I am totally a chat-show host or I am entirely a serious headmistress figure. 
 The truth is I am between the two and capable of doing both.&equo; 
 But last year her own late night BBC TV chat show, Saturday Matters , floundered. 
 Then in September, Sue announced that she was leaving the BBC after 20 years to join Granada Television which, she said, was fully prepared to give her the freedom necessary to put together the type of programme she truly wanted to make. 
 Her first interview for the new series, which started on Easter Monday, was a scoop half hour interview with Prime Minister John Major at No 10 Downing Street. 
 But reaction was typically divided. 
 Many viewers thought she'd used the famous Lawley charm to make him relax and talk about his childhood and family. 
 But others criticised her for interrupting too often and looking unprofessional as she slumped in her seat asking him about his O level exam achievements. 
 Sue insists that her new show will prove successful. 
 &bquo; Saturday Matters  wasn't a disaster, but it missed something. 
 I think I need to do more with people &mdash; in depth, rather than keeping the bubble in the air at frothy chat-show level,&equo; she explains. 
 Away from the cameras, Sue, 44, reveals yet another side to her character. 
 The only journalist to put Mrs Thatcher on the spot during the Falklands War is happy to admit that she loves housework. 
 When she was castaway on Radio 4's Desert Island Discs  &mdash; a year before taking over the show &mdash; Sue told the then presenter Michael Parkinson that the luxury she would want on the island would be an endless supply of clean sheets and an iron. 
 &bquo;It's my idea of bliss to stand in the kitchen with the window open on a beautiful summer's day, following some complicated recipe in the hope that it will come out all right,&equo; she says. 
 But while the dream now may be a domestic one, in the past Sue has allowed her work to come before her home life. 
 She married solicitor, David Ashby in 1974, and six years later they parted. 
 The couple had two children, Tom, now 14, and Harriet, 11. 
 &bquo;I think perhaps I did not work hard enough at my marriage,&equo; she admits now. 
 &bquo;That was unfortunate and has remained a huge sadness to me. 
 The reverberations and knock-on effects of a broken marriage are deeply disruptive and unsettling to everyone involved &mdash; you, your children, all members of both families. 
 However, our lives worked out, we are both happily  remarried and, since we only live a mile apart, it's very easy for the children to come and go to visit their father.&equo; 
 Seven years after the divorce, Sue married TV executive Hugh Williams, 44, the former head of BBC Manchester, in 1987. 
 She now tries to balance home life and career &mdash; but admits it is not easy. 
 &bquo;I want it all,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;I want my children, Harriet and Tom, to be happy and rounded and good, and the same for me and my husband Hugh, and my house and my supper table. 
 And I am not the only woman who wants a fulfilling working life and domesticity as well. 
 Yet it can sometimes make things bloody difficult.&equo; 
 Still, Sue has a lot of past experience to draw on. 
 Her mother ran a drapery shop in Dudley, West Midlands. 
 &bquo;She was a business woman six days a week and had two children &mdash; my sister and me &mdash; so she really had to organise her life,&equo; says Sue, whose father was a dairy farmer. 
 The family lived in a council flat above her mother's shop. 
 For those who find Sue's perfect BBC voice refined and soothing, it is a shock to learn that she ironed out her Black Country accent while studying modern languages at Bristol University. 
 She claims it was as a result of hearing herself say, &bquo;coom on, buzz,&equo; while waiting in a bus shelter. 
 She says that changing her accent while at university was not easy for her parents to accept. 
 &bquo;It was difficult for me when I went home&hellip; 
 I know they hated me. 
 Having moved the other side of the fence I was determined to stay there.&equo; 
 These days her voice and lifestyle belie her upbringing. 
 Sue now lives in Putney in a Victorian house, and the family also has a cottage in Oxfordshire. 
 &bquo;It was Hugh's home, you see,&equo; she explains. 
 &bquo;We don't get there often enough. 
 There's a stream where we spend hours sticklebacking. 
 &bquo;It sounds a bit idyllic and it is, but it can't really happen very often for boring, practical reasons. 
 We love walking, but I don't like walking through charted territory. 
 It's nice to strike off.&equo; 
 It's a comment that could sum up her working life at the moment. 
 She thought hard before deciding to leave the BBC to find new challenges with ITV. 
 It is ironic that her new show will be called simply Sue Lawley . 
 When she first stood in for Terry Wogan she insisted, &bquo;I love standing in for Wogan  but I'm honestly not looking for The Sue Lawley Show with my name in lights and me swooping down a staircase.&equo; 
 But Sue is adamant her new show will be different. 
 &bquo;What I plan to produce for ITV, and I know they'll give me the scope, are quality, probing interviews. 
 To do what I do well, be proud of it, and watch it knowing that it was bloody good and entirely born of me.&equo; 
 And maybe we'll see a new look, too. 
 &bquo;I'm conscious of my over-perfectly groomed image which some find off-putting,&equo; she says. 
 An elegant 5ft 8in and a trim 9st 4lbs, she can wear clothes by Catherine Walker, her favourite designer, with cool elegance. 
 That striving for perfection spills over into her home life too. 
 &bquo;My tidiness is in-built, unhappily for me. 
 It makes my life a misery. 
 I envy people who don't bother to wash up at night and leave stuff all over the place &mdash; I really enjoy going to their houses. 
 I wish I could stop myself from having to have everything just right,&equo; Sue admits. 
 &bquo;I spend half my life changing beds, stuffing the washing machine and emptying wastepaper baskets.&equo; 
 From junior reporter to celebrity 
 After graduating from Bristol University, where she had been President of the Students' Union, Sue joined the Thomson Organisation as a trainee reporter on the Western Mail  and South Wales Echo  in Cardiff. 
 On the advice of a friend, she applied for and got a freelance job with the BBC in Plymouth. 
 It was during the regional link-ups with Nationwide in London that she was spotted as a young broadcaster with great potential. 
 She joined Nationwide in 1972 and spent 12 years in the studio. 
 She moved to Tonight , The Nine O'Clock News  and The Six O'Clock News  before leaving current affairs to stand in for Wogan . 
 She won the coveted job of presenter of Desert Island Discs  almost four years ago. 
 &bquo;It is a matter for regret that she seems to have turned away from serious current affairs interviews,&equo; says a founding executive of Channel 4 News . 
 &bquo;She's shown that she can think on her feet, that she won't be bullied, even by a Prime Minister. 
 The trouble is the more she spreads herself into showbusiness, the more bland she will become. 
 And I think that's slightly sad.&equo; 
 Sue, no doubt, will soon be proving him wrong.  
 &bquo;I didn't work hard enough at marriage &mdash; it's remained a huge sadness to me&equo; 
 &bquo;My tidiness is in-built, unhappily for me. 
 It makes my life a misery&equo; 
 &bquo;I love standing in for Wogan, but I'm honestly not looking for The Sue Lawley Show with my name in lights&equo; 
 Sue married Hugh Williams in 1987 &mdash; each partner already had two children, Polly and Amy, Harriet and Tom, from previous marriages. 
 She doesn't find it easy to balance her home life with her career, and relies on her husband for his sound advice 
 Screen debut &mdash; Sue joined Nationwide in 1972, and stayed there for 12 years 
 The glamorous life &mdash; Sue has moved to chat shows and Desert Island Discs 
 PERSONALITY OF THE WEEK 
 Alfred Molina 
 His wife was acting before he was born but Alfred insists this is the perfect relationship 
 For years, the only person who believed that Alfred Molina would ever become a star was his wife, actress Jill Gascoine, and he credits her for his new-found success. 
 &bquo;She's cured me of all my hang-ups by giving me self-confidence,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;Her first professional job was before I was born, and she has taught me a lot.&equo; 
 After leaving drama school, Alfred found himself struggling. 
 Then, out of the blue, a call came from Hollywood. 
 Steven Spielberg needed a tough guy for the opening sequence of the film Raiders of the Lost Ark  &mdash; and Alfred got the part. 
 From then on his luck seemed to change. 
 In 1982 he landed a role in the musical Destry Rides Again , and met Jill Gascoine.He was an unknown; she was a TV star. 
 He was 29; she was 45. 
 Despite this age difference they fell in love, and five years ago got married. 
 &bquo;Meeting her was the turning point in my life,&equo; he admits. 
 And that includes his career. 
 In 1985 came his first major screen role as the Russian sailor Sergei in the 1985 British film, A Letter To Brezhnev . 
 After that the plum parts began to roll in. 
 He starred as playwright Joe Orton's homosexual lover in Prick Up Your Ears , and will play Tony Hancock in a BBC1 television film to be shown in the autumn. 
 Now, with the Hollywood movie Not Without My Daughter , in which he stars opposite Sally Field, due out later this year, it looks as if he's finally set for international fame. 
 But, says Alfred, it would take more than Hollywood stardom to lure him away from the Sussex cottage he shares with Jill and 12-year-old Rachel, his daughter from a previous relationship. 
 &bquo;When I'm away, I get so homesick for Jill. 
 Thank goodness I met her &mdash; I don't know how I'd have turned out without her.&equo;  
 Alfred's dark looks come from his Italian mother and Spanish father 
 Jill made a guest appearance in El C.I.D., the jokey ITV detective series in which Alfred played an ex-policeman 
 &bquo;Whenever I'm away I get so homesick for Jill. 
 Thank goodness I met her&equo; 
 BEAUTY FORM FITNESS 
 HEALTHY EATING 
 Make the most of FRUIT 
 Usually, diets don't put a limit on fresh fruit but you need to choose carefully &mdash; some varieties are more slimming than others 
 A lot of us eat far too little fresh produce, relying instead on convenience foods, fast foods and sweets. 
 But, although increasing your intake of fruit and vegetables has numerous advantages and benefits &mdash; both are generally low in calories and rich in Vitamin C which helps keep colds at bay &mdash; it is possible to eat too much. 
 Body cleansing and energy giving 
 There are dozens of good points about eating plenty of fruit. 
 It helps with the flushing out of toxins from the body, cleansing it and restoring vitality. 
 Fruit is also rich in potassium which stops you feeling tired. 
 Grapefruit can help reduce harmful blood cholesterol levels and cranberry juice relieves cystitis. 
 Which is best, fresh, dried or canned? 
 Calorie-wise, all fresh fruit is lower than both dried and tinned. 
 Nibbling on dried fruit may quickly eat up your calorie allowance &mdash; just 25g (1oz) of sultanas or raisins provides 70 calories, whereas 100g (4oz) grapes provides the same. 
 Always stick to tinned fruit in natural juice where possible. 
 Compare the calories in half a fresh grapefruit (20&ndash;25 calories) to the same weight of tinned segments in natural juice (40&ndash;45 calories) or in syrup (80 calories)! 
 Eat it raw whenever possible 
 &bull; Ideally, stick to three pieces of fruit a day. 
 &bull; It's fine to eat fruit for breakfast, between meals and before a main meal but not during it as it can upset the digestion rate of the other foods you're eating. 
 &bull; Raw fruit is better than cooked as a rule. 
 It's more digestible and no vitamins or minerals have been lost before you eat it. 
 &bull; Mix soda or mineral water with fruit juices for a more refreshing drink &mdash; and get twice the amount for your calories. 
 A small glass of unsweetened orange juice on its own costs almost 60 calories. 
 &bull; Fruit that's sharp can be sweetened up with artificial sweetener or sprinkle cinnamon on grapefruit instead of sugar. 
 &bull; Guard yourself against premature ageing of the skin by eating plenty of vitamin A rich fruits such as apricots, nectarines and canteloupe melon.   
 Undeniably, fresh fruit is an important part of our diet. 
 We need it for essential vitamins and roughage. 
 But moderation is the key to good health. 
 Mix fruit juice with water for a more refreshing longer drink and check our guide (below right) for your best calorie choice 
 NATURAL BEAUTY 
 Almond treats 
 Rich in protein, calcium and B vitamins, almond oil is renowned for its soothing, emollient properties while the crushed  kernals  can be used in skin scrubs. 
 SKIN POLISHER 
 Help dislodge blackheads by mixing a handful of finely ground almonds with enough honey and rosewater to make a paste. 
 Massage over your face for five minutes. 
 Rinse off thoroughly. 
 FOOT SOAK 
 For aching, tired feet, mix a few drops of peppermint oil with one tbsp of almond oil and add to a bowl of warm water. 
 Soak feet for 10 minutes. 
 HAIR SAVER 
 Dry, split ends? 
 Warm equal parts of almond and olive oil, then massage into ends to soften and nourish hair. 
 Wash out with diluted shampoo. 
 BEST BUYS: 
 Marks &amp; Spencer Extracts from Nature Apricot, Almond and Avocado Cleanser, 200ml, &pound;2.25.  
 TESTED FOR YOU 
 The best disposable razors 
 To de-fuzz quickly, disposable razors are the answer. 
 But can you really get a close, smooth shave without the risk of painful nicks or razor burn? 
 We put five brands to the test 
 PRODUCT 
 COMMENT &amp; RATING 
 Bic Lady Shaver, 45p for 4 
 &bquo;The sharp blade gave me a close shave in one go, but I also cut myself twice. 
 The razor will probably last several shaves &mdash; that's if I can put up with its luminous yellow colour!&equo; 
 Rating ** 
 Simply Smooth Hair Remover, &pound;1.99 for 2 
 &bquo;I found the wide head difficult to use as it didn't fit the contours of my skin. 
 I didn't need to apply much pressure and even though I cut myself once, my skin was smooth afterwards. 
 &bquo;Rating *** 
 Wilkinson Sword Sensitive Retractor, 37p for 5 
 The blade glided easily over my skin and left it very smooth. 
 There was no irritation even though I'm sensitive. 
 I only needed minimum pressure to get a close shave.&equo; 
 Rating ***** 
 Gillette Blue II, &pound;1.99 for 10 
 Swivel head means it follows contours of your skin well, and the double blade ensures a really close, clean, smooth shave. 
 Minimal hair regrowth after three days. 
 Blade still sharp.&equo; 
 Rating **** 
 Boots Bodycare Disposable Razors, 89p for 5 
 I didn't nick my skin even though I shaved quickly. 
 I had to rinse quite often to get rid of debris, but it did give a close shave. 
 The slide-on safety cover is a good idea.&equo; 
 Rating **** 
 OVER THE COUNTER 
 Summer lip shades 
 Strong lipstick shades are not only difficult to apply, but they can look overpowering, especially on sun-kissed skin. 
 A sheer, natural-looking lip tint is much better. 
 These ones come in four summery shades: Soft Red, Soft Pink, Damson and Coral. 
 Slick on just a touch of colour or use a complementary tint over your favourite lipstick to add extra gloss. 
 These lip tints also contain nourishing calendula, wheatgerm, Vitamin E and aloe vera and have UVB filters to give minimum sun protection for your lips. 
 Making scents 
 Aromatic oils have been used for centuries for their therapeutic and beauty benefits. 
 Each of the four fragranced oils used here are combined with purified tonic water and henna extract. 
 Inside the bottle you will find a handful of sparkling semi-precious gemstones which spiritual healers believe affect our health and well-being. 
 Add a few drops to your bath or massage the oil into your skin. 
 Buff your nails 
 If there's one nail-care necessity, it has to be a buffing pad. 
 Apart from giving your nails a natural-looking lustre, buffing regularly can help them grow long and strong by stimulating the blood supply to each nail. 
 This handy dual-purpose kit contains two buffers. 
 Use the slightly abrasive grey one to soften ridges and prepare nails for colour or use the pink one to bring out the natural shine instead of applying polish to your nails. 
 BULLETIN BULLETIN 
 Are simple formulas better for your skin? 
 Our cosmetics and toiletries have come a long way since the days when Elizabeth I used highly toxic lead powder to whiten and enhance her complexion! 
 But some dermatologists believe that today's skin products can do more harm than good. 
 Special screening for beauty products 
 Advances in the field of cosmetics mean that today superfluous ingredients and allergens can be identified, then substituted or removed, which is great news indeed for anyone with a sensitive skin. 
 &bquo;The trouble is, the more ingredients there are in a product, the more chance there is of becoming allergic to them,&equo; says dermatologist, Steven Wright. 
 Natural ingredients aren't always better 
 It's wrong to assume that just because a cream says it contains plant extracts it's better for your skin. 
 &bquo;Ten per cent of all plants are capable of leaving you with a red itchy rash or skin swelling,&equo; adds Steven Wright. 
 Tried and tested old skincare favourites 
 Often, products that contain only a few basic ingredients, like Simple, Nivea, Neutrogena and good old Vaseline, are the safest. 
 But even some of the oilier of these can prevent the skin from breathing.Test the irritancy level of your skin by applying the product to the inside of your elbow for several days and see if there's a reaction. 
 FREE 
 Creamy moisturiser 
 Dry skin tends to be on the sensitive side, so choosing a moisturiser can cause problems. 
 Bring back softness with Boots Skin Kindly Creamy Moisturising Lotion. 
 Containing glycerine, sunflower oil and a blend of mineral oils, it is a great moisturiser and, being fragrance-free and lanolin-free, it's ideal for sensitive skins. 
 We have 1,000 150ml bottles to give away &mdash; the offer is worth &pound;1.65. 
 10 MINUTE WORKOUT 
 Trim and firm your thighs 
 Follow these three exercises every day and come summer you'll be in great shape 
 Kneel on all fours, then rest forearms on floor, palms flat. 
 With your back straight, bottom muscles clenched and foot flexed, slowly lift your leg up behind you, ease it higher to the count of 16, then repeat on the other leg. 
 Kneel on all fours, back straight and look forward as you lift and then lower your right leg, knee bent, out to the side. 
 Do 16 lifts, then repeat on the other side. 
 This is excellent for toning and shaping inner thighs. 
 Lie on your right side with head resting on your outstretched arm. 
 Bend your lower leg slightly to support your spine and raise the other leg slowly to an angle of 45&deg;. 
 Hold for a count of eight. 
 Repeat eight times on each side, twice.  
 Help and Advice 
 A Problem Shared 
 Psychologist Elizabeth John is here to help, with expert advice and practical suggestions 
 &bquo;Our sons are always fighting and I can't stand the strain any more&equo; 
 My married life is being disrupted by my 10-year-old stepson. 
 I'm 32 and have two children from a first marriage &mdash; a daughter of 10 and a son of 13. 
 I also have a seven-year-old daughter from a previous long-term relationship. 
 The boys hate each other. 
 They fight viciously and tell lies to get each other into trouble. 
 My son usually has the upper hand because he's older. 
 My husband sometimes scolds my stepson but more often blames my son. 
 All this has caused a lot of tension in our marriage. 
 Once my husband left me and went back to his ex-wife. 
 She won't have anything to do with the boy and my husband has said she used to mistreat him. 
 I've tried to love my stepson but I really resent him. 
 If things don't get better soon, I'll have a nervous breakdown or divorce my husband. 
 I've been through both already so I know what I'm talking about. 
 Please help me. 
  Amanda  
 Our psychologist replies 
 When two families start living together for whatever reason, everyone has a new role to play and, until new house rules have been established, the children are bound to feel insecure, jealous and anxious. 
 They have been through an unsettling time and are finding it difficult to readjust. 
 The boys' behaviour is their way of protesting at these changes and competing for your affection and attention. 
 Your son resents his stepbrother for taking up your time, and is worried that you don't love him any more. 
 Your stepson has to get used to a whole new family, which is a big shock for him after being an only child. 
 Considering the sad relationship he had with his mother problems are bound to arise. 
 Don't let the boys know that they have the power to cause a rift between you and your husband. 
 You need to present a united front and avoid taking sides or playing one child off against the other. 
 Begging or threatening tactics won't help in the long run either. 
 Your own son needs to be encouraged to behave in a mature way, while your stepson has to be reassured that he belongs in the new family. 
 Both are desperate for love and affection so don't hold back. 
 Encourage all the children to talk openly about their feelings so that hidden resentments are not bottled up inside them. 
 Only when the children feel less threatened will they be able to relax, and it's up to you and your husband to give them that security. 
 The National Stepfamily Association helpline (see box) is manned by trained staff who can advise you how to tackle this situation. 
 &bquo;How can I help my friend overcome these panic attacks?&equo; 
 For the last five years, a good friend of mine has suffered from panic attacks. 
 Recently, things have got worse and she's become agoraphobic. 
 Although I take her on short trips to the shops, she can't cope with going too far from the house. 
 It's so sad because she used to be such a lively and outgoing person. 
 I've looked into the possibility of counselling but all the services are miles away. 
 I'd appreciate any advice as I do want to help her overcome her fears and enjoy life again. 
  Pauline  
 Our psychologist replies 
 You've been a good friend but unfortunately this is not going to be enough to help your friend. 
 When someone can't cope with panic attacks, agoraphobia is often the consequence and treating this condition requires specialist help. 
 Your friend should talk to her GP, who will refer her to a specialist. 
 Meanwhile, she can help herself to control her panic attacks by slowing down her breathing as soon as she feels an attack coming on. 
 A cold wet cloth placed on her cheeks will help alleviate the symptoms. 
 Encourage your friend to contact Phobic Action (see box) who organise self-help groups which you could attend. 
 To help you both understand why panic attacks happen, read Self Help for Your Nerves (see box). 
 &bquo;My husband moans that I'm not as slim as when we first met&equo; 
 I'm 40 years old and feel really down in the dumps. 
 Six months ago I started smoking and put on a lot of weight because I was constantly nibbling. 
 I now weigh 13 stone. 
 My husband, who's 41, hates the fact that I smoke and moans that I eat too much. 
 Like me, he's fond of his food and drinks a lot. 
 He weighs 20 stone, and I worry about him being so overweight. 
 He gets annoyed if I say anything about it, but that doesn't stop him going on about how slim I was at 17 when we first met. 
 Eating is my one little comfort. 
 How else can I stop myself from feeling miserable? 
  Margaret  
 Our psychologist replies 
 Comfort eating and disliking yourself are two classic symptoms of depression, so try to work out why you started in the first place. 
 It seems that one underlying problem is your relationship with your husband, who is gradually undermining your self confidence by comparing you as you are now with the way you looked as a teenager. 
 This is hardly a fair comparison. 
 He's also applying double standards &mdash; allowing himself to eat and drink to his heart's content but disapproving when you do the same. 
 Don't let him persuade you to accept that he's right. 
 Your aim should not be to lose weight, but to bring your eating habits under your control. 
 Join a group like Weight Watchers (see box) who can give you support and encouragement in achieving this goal. 
 Meeting people who are going through the same experience will help you out of your depression. 
 For the sake of your health make a determined effort to stop smoking. 
 Contact Quit (see box), a group who help smokers to break the habit. 
 It's also worth visiting your GP for advice on healthy eating and how to wean yourself off nicotine. 
 Remember, you are your own person and it's up to you to take care of your health and decide how you want to look. 
 &bquo;Since I became pregnant he hasn't been interested in me&equo; 
 My boyfriend and I are both 24 and have been seeing each other for three years. 
 For the last year we have lived together in my flat. 
 Since I became pregnant five months ago, he has neglected me. 
 He never wants to go out with me, not even to see his parents, who live nearby. 
 I can't help thinking things will only get worse when I have the baby. 
 I am working part-time, but my maternity leave begins next month. 
 My boyfriend has a full-time job but barely gives me enough money for the shopping. 
 If I ask for extra to buy baby clothes, he says he doesn't have the spare cash. 
 He's out every night, sometimes until the early hours. 
 I'm so depressed and often cry myself to sleep. 
 I would throw my boyfriend out, but I'd be scared of living alone. 
 Why won't he give me more support? 
 If he's stopped loving me, surely he would have left me by now? 
  Susannah  
 Our psychologist replies 
 Your boyfriend is finding it hard to come to terms with the prospect of fatherhood and is taking his resentment out on you. 
 Explain to him how you feel and chat to his parents, who may rally round and give you the support he refuses to give you. 
 You can't force him to act responsibly but you can make sure he doesn't treat you like a doormat. 
 He's your partner in theory, but he doesn't fulfil that role in practice. 
 You may well be better off without him instead of living in limbo, not knowing what he's thinking or why he's acting in this way. 
 Be firm, and tell him that he must either pull his weight or leave. 
 It will take courage to do this, but delivering an ultimatum may bring him to his senses.  
 Your Replies 
 Readers share their own experiences of problems featured on this page, and offer advice and support 
 She's being forced to pay money to see her grandchild 
 When Annie's daughter died at the age of five, she was heartbroken. 
 So when her son married and his wife had a baby girl she felt as if she'd regained the daughter she'd lost. 
 Now her son and his wife have split up and, because her son is unemployed, he is offering limited financial support to his family. 
 Annie has become the subject of her daughter-in-law's revenge by being forced to pay her money to see her grandchild. 
 She feels she has lost a daughter all over again. 
 My story is similar to Annie's in that I made the same mistake and thought of my granddaughter as a substitute child. 
 When my own daughter was born I was a single parent, and had to work to pay the bills, so I missed the best years of her childhood. 
 She's now grown up with her own baby. 
 I no longer need to work and she was delighted when I offered to care for the baby during the week. 
 She looked so like my daughter did at her age, and the pleasure she gave me compensated for the lack of time I had with her mother when she was a child. 
 But last year my son-in-law changed jobs and the family went to live in Holland. 
 I was heartbroken, but I'm slowly coming to accept the situation. 
 We must both understand that a child needs a mother more than a grandmother. 
  Maureen  
 There's nothing worse than being taken for granted. 
 My son married two years ago and my grandson was born four months later. 
 We visited each weekend, and I looked after the baby during the week. 
 My son and his wife often asked us to bring groceries and we bought clothes for Ben. 
 I don't begrudge the support we've given, but I was annoyed when I realised we were being taken for granted. 
 They never paid for the groceries. 
 After a while, I told them we didn't want to be treated this way. 
 I was shocked by their reaction. 
 For several weeks we were denied access to our grandson. 
 In time things improved. 
 Our relationship is still strained, but at least we are now accepted on our terms. 
 Try standing up to your daughter-in-law. 
 It worked for me, and I hope it works for you. 
  Maxine  
 He has a well-paid job but he expects her to pay for the family car 
 Megan's been married for 18 years and still loves her husband, but resents his meanness. 
 Although he has a large enough income to support them both, he puts most of it into a building society and also invests money in shares. 
 He expects Megan to work part-time to pay for groceries and clothes for herself and their three children. 
 She is forced to buy things from charity shops to make ends meet. 
 Now he's told her that she should pay for the new family car. 
 You've every right to feel hard done by, so don't start thinking that you're being selfish. 
 Your husband is being unreasonable. 
 What's the point in saving everything for a comfortable old age if you're suffering hardship now? 
 He seems to be obsessed with investing every penny, while at the same time turning a blind eye to the needs of his growing family. 
 He's obviously insecure about money. 
 It's possible that he's trying to test your love for him. 
 His logic seems to be that if he doesn't give you any money, he can be sure you're staying with him because you love him, and not because of his earning power. 
 You must make your feelings known and ask him if this really is the case. 
 Tell him that you do love him, but you will have very little time and energy to show that love while you are forced to worry about where the next meal is coming from. 
  Rachel  
 Are you sure your husband realises just how much of a struggle you find it to keep the household going? 
 Husbands can easily get out of touch with the cost of living unless they do the shopping regularly and see the bills. 
 Don't let your resentment build up any more &mdash; explain the financial situation to him clearly and calmly. 
 List all your outgoings and expenses over a few weeks. 
 Prove to your husband that you are not extravagant but point out that it is impossible to make ends meet on a pittance. 
 If necessary, take him shopping with you, or better still, send him to the supermarket alone so that he realises the cost of basic necessities. 
 It will probably be quite an eye-opener for him! 
 Ask him what he's saving for &mdash; is he worried about redundancy? 
 Or just making sure he has enough when he retires? 
 Remember, marriage is a shared contract, and you and your children have every right to claim money from your husband. 
  Joy  
 Should she give in to her love for another woman? 
 Sally is 22 and has been with her current boyfriend for three years. 
 She has recently started a new job and feels attracted to a senior female colleague who is rumoured to be gay. 
 Sally is not sure whether or not she should admit her feelings to this woman. 
 You should really think twice before approaching this woman or before telling your boyfriend. 
 You may just be bored with your current relationship, and your boredom is making the idea of an affair with a woman seem all the more exciting. 
 Pleas don't commit yourself unless you're absolutely sure of your true feelings. 
 I had a similar experience several years ago, when I left college and started my first job. 
 I, too, felt deeply attracted to a female colleague. 
 I discussed my feelings with the woman in question and I slept with her, but I deeply regretted it later on and was sorry that I hadn't weighed up the consequences more thoroughly beforehand. 
 Things became very awkward between us afterwards and, as a result, I had to quit my job. 
 It all caused me severe emotional stress and a career setback. 
 Take my advice, think things through. 
  Sarah  
 I sympathise with Sally. 
 I was 24 and had been married for four years before I discovered I was a lesbian. 
 I realised the truth when I became close to a friend of a friend and gradually fell in love with her. 
 I caused a lot of hurt to my husband and family when I left them to live with her, but my partner, Kate, felt as strongly about me as I did about her and I know it was the right thing to do. 
 However, before you speak to your colleague, consider the possibility that she might already be involved in a relationship. 
 Perhaps you should try and find out a little more about her before admitting your feelings. 
 Even if she is sympathetic, it doesn't mean that she will automatically want to start a serious relationship with you just because she is gay. 
 You must be prepared for rejection and disappointment. 
  Claire  
 IF YOU HAVE A PROBLEM OR ADVICE TO GIVE&hellip; 
 &hellip; write to Elizabeth John, A Problem Shared, best , 10th Floor, Portland House, Stag Place, London SW1E 5AU. 
 If you are replying to a letter, please mention the writer's name and the date of the magazine in which it appeared. 
 Unfortunately we are unable to answer letters individually.  
 THIS WEEK'S PEOPLE 
 WE MEET 
 MATTHEW BRODERICK 
 It took an injured knee to convince the 28-year-old star that he wanted to become an actor. 
 Years later, his career reached a peak when he kissed Marlon Brando 
 Have you always had an ambition to act? 
 I wanted to be an actor when I was very little, but then I changed my mind. 
 My father, who's also an actor, once wanted me to be in a play that he was in, and just being asked made me cry. 
 I always put it off and played a lot of sport at high school instead, until I hurt my knee really badly. 
 Then I had no excuse not to audition for plays, and when I did I found that I enjoyed it. 
 Did you enjoy acting alongside Marlon Brando in the recent film The Freshman? 
 It was a pleasure. 
 The pinnacle of my career. 
 Just to get to meet him and work with him was a thrill, but I got to kiss him, too! 
 I remember having some trouble not laughing during that scene. 
 You also appeared with Sean Connery recently. 
 What was he like? 
 He's a very intimidating fellow. 
 My girlfriend is very cool and she isn't easily impressed, but when she met Sean, he looked into her eyes and said; &bquo;nice to meet you&equo;, and she kind of fainted without falling over! 
 Are comedy roles your favourite ones to play? 
 I want to play as many different roles as I can possibly manage. 
 I guess I do have a slight leaning towards comedy, but I find if I do a bunch of comedies, I get anxious to do something dramatic, and the other way round. 
 Do you enjoy working in the theatre? 
 I find it a more natural environment. 
 Film-making involves acting for 10 minutes and then waiting around for two hours. 
 On the stage you get two hours of release, which is very pleasant. 
 Are you bothered that your theatre work is often forgotten? 
 Well, it is really strange, because I've done quite a lot of stage work, but it's funny because a lot of people &mdash; even other film actors &mdash; don't know about it. 
 Several times it's happened to me that someone has come up to me and asked if I've ever done a play. 
 I always say, &bquo;Me, I'm the great Matthew Broderick, stage actor.&equo;. 
 Do you have any plans to get married? 
 Not yet. 
  Anwar Brett  
 Nigel decides to broaden his horizons 
 He's fed up with being known as The Charmer . 
 &bquo;It's a name I seem to be stuck with, but it really would be nice to be called something else for a change, says actor Nigel Havers, best known for his role in the ITV series of the same name. 
 Now he's decided he's not just going to act, he's going to make programmes, too. 
 With his friend, Michael Whitehall, he's producing a new drama series for ITV called, The Good Guys , starring himself and Keith Barron. 
 &bquo;It's not because I have ambitions to say &bquo;I'm in charge&equo;,&equo; says the man who started work as a researcher on the Jimmy Young radio show. 
 &bquo;I hate confrontations of any sort,&equo; he adds.  
 He sometimes has to work to maintain his cool image. 
 For instance, he was furious at the press speculation which surrounded the break-up of his marriage. 
 But rather than hit back, he listened to his father, Lord Havers. 
 &bquo;His advice was to shut up and get on with it,&equo; says Nigel 
 Greta's still waiting for her knight in shining armour 
 It's reassuring to know that even beautiful actresses worry about what they're gong to wear to go out in the evening. 
 Greta Scacchi, 31, star of White Mischief  and Heat and Dust  says, &bquo;I hate the thought of standing out in the crowd. 
 I get all dolled up for a party and then I look at myself in the mirror and suddenly chicken out, put my jeans on, ruffle up my hair, and only then do I feel comfortable.&equo; 
 Greta's latest film, The Fires Within , opens this month, but the Italian-English actress is tired of rushing from one movie to the next. 
 &bquo;The film lifestyle is one of cutting yourself off from your base and your friends, your identity even. 
 You just keep floating off,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;I'm in my 30s now,&equo; she adds, &bquo;and a lot of my friends are looking round and saying, &bquo;Why don't you have a family, a husband and a baby?&equo; 
 It's this big disappointment. 
 We've been waiting for the knight in shining armour and then there isn't one. 
 Or if there is, he turns out to be impossible to live with,&equo; she says. 
 Why Michael had to give up smoking 
 With a new film, The Hard Way , now showing at the cinema, it's hard to believe that Michael J Fox resolved last year to give up being a film star and spend more time with his wife, Tracy Pollan, and their son, Sam, who's three this week. 
 Michael met Tracy when they starred together in the American television sitcom Family Ties . 
 The couple have a home in Hollywood and a farm in Vermont, but Michael, who is widely regarded in Hollywood as a workaholic, found it hard to put family first and is now keen to produce his own films as well as act in them. 
 Despite the pressures of his work, he has managed to give up smoking. 
 He used to get through 60 a day. 
 &bquo;As soon as Sam came along I made a vow never to smoke near him. 
 I didn't want him to breathe that stuff into his lungs,&equo; he says. 
 Stop Press 
 Murder mystery star Angela Lansbury is well on her way to becoming the highest paid female star on US television. 
 The 65-year-old actress wanted to quit Murder She Wrote , but she's now been offered &dollar;300,000 an episode. 
 It'll be hard to refuse. 
 Super-shy George Michael bought his Californian dream home for &pound;3 million two years ago, but he's spent less than a fortnight in the futuristic house. 
 Jeremy Irons and his wife Sinead Cusack want their son Sam to learn French, so they've sent him to study in France. 
 But they're missing him badly, they say. 
 Quote of the week is from Don Johnson: &bquo;They say it's lonely at the top, but it's lonely at the bottom and in the middle too.&equo; 
 Happy birthday this week to: Ron Wood, 45&hellip; 
 Jason Donovan, 23&hellip; 
 Suzi Quatro, 41&hellip; 
 Vince Clark, 30&hellip;.  
 VINTAGE STARS 
 AUDREY HEPBURN 
 She's made just a handful of films in the last 20 years, but the actress says she doesn't miss the silver screen &mdash; she prefers to dedicate herself to children's charity work instead 
 Once best known for her bewitching performances in films like Breakfast at Tiffany's  and Roman Holiday , today Audrey Hepburn is renowned for her work with children. 
 She's held the post of special ambassador to the children's charity UNICEF since 1988, visiting war-torn and poverty-stricken countries such as Vietnam and Bangladesh. 
 This Thursday she opens a London Symphony Orchestra concert at the Barbican centre based on Anne Frank's diaries. 
 Audrey, 62, will be reading selected pieces from the writings of the young Dutch girl who died in a concentration camp. 
 She chose the extracts herself, and suggested the idea for the concert, which is in aid of UNICEF. 
 Like Anne Frank, Audrey spent the Second World War in occupied Holland. 
 She was born in Belgium, but she and her mother were on holiday in Holland when hostilities broke out. 
 When the war was over, she won a scholarship to study ballet in London. 
 It was when she was in London that Audrey won a role in the 1951 film Monte Carlo Baby . 
 While she was filming in the south of France, she met the writer Colette who insisted Audrey play Gigi  on Broadway in America. 
 With that performance, her meteoric rise from ballet dancer to actress was complete. 
 She went on to win an Oscar for Roman Holiday  and charmed cinema-goers with films like Funny Face  and My Fair Lady . 
 However, in 1967 she decided she'd had enough of the movies, although she did appear recently in Always , along with Richard Dreyfuss and Holly Hunter. 
 She has made only a handful of films in the past 20 years. 
 Audrey has no regrets about her decision, preferring to throw her energies into looking after children. 
 She has two grown-up sons, Sean and Lucas. 
 &bquo;I'm potty about my two sons,&equo; she says, adding, &bquo;I've always loved children. 
 My work with UNICEF is now all part of it.&equo; 
 Ben's serious about being funny 
 Ben Elton, 32, star of the BBC series The Man from Auntie , is known for his angry humour. 
 But he says, &bquo;I prefer to think that I'm passionate. 
 I do have venom for bullies, or for anyone who shows contempt for others.&equo; 
 One of the subjects he's most passionate about is the environment. 
 His second novel, Gridlock  (published by MacDonald, price &pound;13.95) is out this month. 
 In it, he imagines what would happen to London if it became so choked with cars that no-one could move. 
 His first Green novel, Stark , sold more than half a million copies. 
 But he says, &bquo;I don't set out to evangelize or alert the world. 
 If I set out to teach, rather than entertain, I would achieve neither. 
 My aim is to be seriously funny.&equo; 
 The show always goes on for Shirley 
 She says she couldn't stop singing, even if she wanted to try. 
 &bquo;There's a demon inside me that says, &bquo;Go on, go on&equo;,&equo; reveals Shirley Bassey, who's playing the Albert Hall this week at the end of another British tour. 
 She's also got a new album out. 
 &bquo;I feel that if I don't sing, the world will pass me by,&equo; she says. 
 But the woman who was born the youngest of seven children in Tiger Bay in Cardiff has always lived life to the full. 
 She's been divorced twice, and travelled the world singing songs like Goldfinger  and Big Spender . 
 But in 1984, tragedy struck when her 24-year-old daughter, Samantha, plunged to her death from the Clifton Suspension Bridge near Bristol. 
 Shirley, 54, took a year off before returning to the stage. 
 &bquo;I take all the bad things &mdash; and the good &mdash; and turn them round and use them in my singing,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;I need to be wanted and loved by the audience. 
 When the music starts I walk out on stage and the spotlight hits me. 
 It's magic. 
 Suddenly I'm in another world.&equo; 
 YOUR WEEK IN THE STARS 
 Astrologer Carol Morris looks at what the heavens hold this week 
 Gemini 
 (May 21&ndash;June 20) 
 Mercury, your ruler, begins to move through your sign, making it a good time to plan for the future. 
 Venus improves your already sociable nature, so it's a great week for meeting new people. 
 Take extra care if you are travelling. 
 Cancer 
 (June 21&ndash;July 20) 
 You should surround yourself with close friends &mdash; it will put you in a good mood for dealing with a financial matter. 
 But even if you've got plenty of money in your pocket at the moment, you mustn't let others take advantage of your generous nature. 
 Leo 
 (July 21&ndash;Aug 21) 
 As Venus moves into your sign, the pride you have taken in your appearance is bound to turn a few heads. 
 But as you are determined to live it up and have a good time, you must watch your health and try not to burn the candle at both ends. 
 Virgo 
 (Aug 22&ndash;Sept 22) 
 You are a perfectionist at heart. 
 But this week, you should try to curb your impatience with those who are slack in their work. 
 Concentrate instead on your own reputation by continuing to live up to the high standards you always set yourself. 
 Libra 
 (Sept 22&ndash;Oct 23) 
 You are good at expressing yourself, which stands you in good stead if you want to ask someone to do you a favour. 
 Venus enhances your social life from Thursday, and you'll find the company of your female friends is what you need right now. 
 Scorpio 
 (Oct 23&ndash;Nov 22) 
 A difficult aspect between Mars and Saturn could jeopardise the enviable position you are in now. 
 If things begin to get difficult now, don't panic &mdash; you don't want to throw everything away by headstrong action. 
 Be extra vigilant regarding house security. 
 Sagittarius 
 (Nov 23&ndash;Dec 20) 
 This will probably be a week full of frustration. 
 You long to get away and enjoy some freedom, but circumstances beyond your control dictate otherwise. 
 Take comfort in close companions who are really supportive and ready to listen. 
 Capricorn 
 (Dec 21&ndash;Jan 19) 
 Money problems arise this week as Saturn and Mars confront each other. 
 You don't want to lose what you have worked so long to achieve, so beware of hard-sell techniques. 
 During the next two weeks you must look after your health. 
 Aquarius 
 (Jan 20&ndash;Feb 18) 
 Mars is in your opposite sign Leo, making it difficult to cope with a special relationship. 
 Stay calm and let nature take its course. 
 Little things will irritate you more than usual but try to keep cool, especially when dealing with personal issues. 
 Pisces 
 (Feb 19&ndash;Mar 20) 
 The week begins on a bright note with some pleasant news. 
 During the next couple of weeks, important family discussions should be underway. 
 There will be a tendency for you to be accident-prone, so whatever you do, slow down, and take your time. 
 Aries 
 (Mar 21&ndash;April 20) 
 The tempo of living quickens this week and it will be difficult to avoid getting caught up in the frantic pace of events. 
 Mars charges your love-life with physical energy and passion but don't spoil it by making too many demands on your partner. 
 Taurus 
 (April 21&ndash;May 20) 
 Later in the week, a less seemly side to your nature emerges. 
 But who can blame you? 
 You seem to be getting very little thanks for all your hard work. 
 From Thursday onwards, the influence of Venus will be bringing out the artistic side of you. 
 Phone for your tarot future on 0898 200101 
 and listen to our tarot hotline. 
 The computer will select the cards and your personal prediction will be read. 
 Calls are 45p per min, 34p per min cheap rate.  
 THE low-fat DIET 
 If you enjoy your food and don't want to eat less, but do  want to lose weight and reduce the risk of heart disease, this is for you. 
 It's full of hints and tips on low-fat eating and healthy living 
 How the diet works 
 This is a diet on which you'll find you can eat hearty, sensible-sized meals and still reduce your weight. 
 Unlike most other diets, it doesn't suggest that you should eat less, merely that you should eat less fat. 
 By cutting down the proportion of fat in your diet you can increase the other constituents (protein and carbohydrate), and because of this, you should have no hunger pangs. 
 If you do feel hungry, you can eat anything you like &mdash; as long as it has little or no fat in it. 
 Why eat less fat? 
 The energy content of fat is more than double that of protein and nearly three times as much as carbohydrate. 
 If the type of foods you eat means that all your meals are heavily loaded with fat then they will contain a lot of energy &mdash; and if you don't take a lot of exercise to burn this up, you will inevitably put on weight. 
 What are the right fats? 
 We need to cut back our intake of saturated  fats as all the evidence indicates that these affect cholesterol levels &mdash; the strongest predictors of heart disease. 
 You should also make an effort to avoid &bquo;hydrogenated vegetable oil&equo; &mdash; a process by which the oil becomes saturated. 
 There is also strong evidence that we should increase the proportion of mono-unsaturated  fats, as these have been shown to raise the level of HDL cholesterol (see Heart Disease &mdash; the risks) in the blood. 
 The richest source of MUFAs is olive oil &mdash; there is a low incidence of coronary heart disease in Mediterranean countries where it's widely used. 
 Poly-unsaturated fats  should constitute the next largest share of your fat intake, after mono-unsaturated fats. 
 How fibre helps 
 Complex carbohydrates will make up your food intake when you cut down on fats, and should provide over half your energy needs. 
 These foods contain soluble fibre  (especially oats, split peas, lentils, chickpeas, red kidney beans, soya beans, and haricot beans) and can prove valuable in helping to reduce cholesterol. 
 Getting your diet right 
 Reduce fat intake &mdash; to 15% of your diet or less. 
 Mono-unsaturates (MUFAs) should make up the largest proportion of fats consumed. 
 Polyunsaturates (PUFAs) come next after MUFAs. 
 Foods containing saturated fats should be avoided. 
 THE FATS FOUND IN YOUR FOOD 
 Saturated 
 Watch out! 
 These are the greatest danger so avoid them: palm kernel oil. 
 butter, coconut oil, lard, margarine, suet, vegetarian suet, standard soft ,  margarine 
 Mono-unsaturated 
 Evidence suggests these can help prevent heart disease: olive oil, peanut (groundnut) oil, rapeseed oil, grapeseed oil 
 Poly-unsaturated 
 Don't use these quite as much as mono-unsaturates: sunflower oil, safflower oil, corn oil, soya oil, walnut oil, all margarines and spreads labelled &bquo;high in polyunsaturates&equo;  
 Choose olive, sunflower or soy oil. 
 As a general rule vegetable oils are much better for you than fats that are derived from animals 
 Heart disease &mdash; the risks 
 A rich fatty diet not only tends to make you overweight, it can also raise the level of cholesterol in the bloodstream &mdash; a predictor of heart disease. 
 The most important types of cholesterol are: 
 Low density lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL) &mdash; which transports cholesterol from the liver to the rest of the body 
 High density lipoprotein cholesterol (HDL) &mdash; which transports cholesterol from the body back to the liver for excretion. 
 LDL helps to build up the deposits that cause heart disease, so it should be as low as possible. 
 HDL cholesterol should be as high as possible. 
 TIP: Regular exercise lowers LDL cholesterol levels, yet raises the HDL cholesterol levels &mdash; and reduces the risk of heart disease.  
 Seven days of low-fat eating 
 Our menu list will give you some idea of how tasty and interesting a low-fat diet can be. 
 Follow it through one week &mdash; or pick and choose the ideas that appeal to you. 
 MONDAY 
 Breakfast Oat cereal and skimmed milk, wholemeal toast, low-fat spread and jam. 
 Lunch Rice cakes, low-fat cheese, tomatoes and onion, apple. 
 Dinner Chilli con carne with brown rice, fresh green salad, fat-free yoghurt. 
 TUESDAY 
 Breakfast Bran flakes, chopped banana, skimmed milk. 
 Lunch Wholemeal pasta shell salad, red and green peppers, onions, chickpeas, kidney beans, tomatoes and lean diced ham, wholemeal roll with low-fat spread. 
 Dinner Chicken casserole, boiled potatoes in their skins, lemon sorbet. 
 WEDNESDAY 
 Breakfast Oat bran cereal, skimmed milk and stewed apple, wholemeal toast with a little low-fat spread. 
 Lunch Baked beans on wholemeal toast, virtually fat-free yoghurt, orange. 
 Dinner Grilled kipper, tomatoes, peas and boiled potatoes, banana to finish. 
 THURSDAY 
 Breakfast Porridge with skimmed milk and stewed apple. 
 Lunch Wholemeal sandwich with low-fat spread, fresh salad filling, eg lettuce, low-fat soft cheese, sliced tomatoes, fruit with virtually fat-free fromage frais. 
 Dinner Bolognese sauce made with lean mince, and wholemeal spaghetti. 
 Virtually fat-free yoghurt for dessert. 
 FRIDAY 
 Breakfast Oat bran cereal with skimmed milk, wholemeal toast, low-fat spread and jam. 
 Lunch Rice salad made with tuna, onions, red kidney beans, peppers, lettuce &mdash; mixed with plain virtually fat-free fromage frais. 
 Rye bread, crispbread, or high-fibre crackers and low-fat spread, virtually fat-free yoghurt. 
 Dinner Cauliflower in low-fat cheese sauce. 
 Boiled carrots and jacket-baked potato, date slice. 
 SATURDAY 
 Breakfast Porridge with skimmed milk and small banana. 
 Lunch Ratatouille with jacket-baked potato, brown rice or wholemeal pasta. 
 Apple. 
 Dinner Vegetable quiche (small portion), mixed salad (no dressing or a little olive oil dressing), wholemeal bread and low-fat spread, fruit. 
 SUNDAY 
 Breakfast Virtually fat-free plain yoghurt, fromage frais or cottage cheese, wholemeal toast with low-fat spread and jam or yeast extract. 
 Lunch Lean roast meat (visible fat removed), jacket-baked potato, lightly steamed green vegetables, oat-topped fruit crumble, fat-free yoghurt. 
 Supper Wholemeal sandwich with low-fat cream cheese and banana filling. 
 Apple or orange to finish. 
 Shopping List 
 Here's what you'll need to buy for the week's low-fat diet. 
 DAIRY PRODUCE 
 Skimmed milk 
 low-fat spread, natural and fruit virtually fat-free yoghurts 
 virtually fat-free fromage frais 
 very low-fat cottage cheese 
 low-fat hard and soft cheeses. 
 MEAT 
 Very lean minced beef 
 Meat for roasting (very lean, with visible fat removed). 
 FISH 
 Kipper &mdash; or other oily fish 
 eg smoked mackerel. 
 CEREAL 
 Wholemeal flour 
 oat bran 
 bran flakes 
 brown rice 
 wholemeal pasta 
 wholewheat/high fibre bread and rolls or baps 
 rye bread 
 high-fibre crispbreads 
 crackers 
 FRUIT AND VEG 
 Fresh vegetables 
 salad ingredients 
 dried/tinned chickpeas and red kidney beans 
 fresh fruits &mdash; including lemons and bananas. 
 EXTRA 
 Food can be low in calories but still delicious. 
 Choose fruits in season to make our mouthwatering sorbet, and make sure your vegetables are really fresh for the tastiest ratatouille 
 Strawberry Sorbet 
 Serves 6. 
 Fat content per serving &mdash; nil; energy content per serving &mdash; 174 calories. 
 Make syrup by heating 225g (8oz) caster sugar and 600ml (1 pint) water together over a low heat, stir until sugar dissolves. 
 Simmer 10 minutes, allow to cool. 
 Place 450g (1 lb) hulled strawberries in another saucepan with a little water and simmer until softened. 
 Rub through sieve, pour into sugar syrup and make up to 1.15 litres (2 pints) with extra water. 
 When cool, add 10ml (2tsp) lemon juice, pour into shallow flat container. 
 Freeze until nearly firm. 
 Whisk 4 egg whites until lightly stiff. 
 Scrape frozen mixture into cooled bowl. 
 Break up, fold in egg whites, freeze until firm. 
 This recipe can also be made with raspberries, blackcurrants or blackberries. 
 Ratatouille 
 Serves 6. 
 Fat content per serving &mdash; 2g; energy content per serving &mdash; 87 calories. 
 Place 2 large aubergines, cubed, and 2 medium courgettes, cubed, in colander, sprinkle with salt, place plate on top. 
 Leave 1&ndash;2 hours, rinse, drain well. 
 Heat 10ml (2tsp) olive oil in large saucepan. 
 Slice and fry 4 medium onions until soft. 
 Add aubergines, courgettes, 2 large red peppers, sliced garlic and 150ml (&frac14; pt) red wine, cover and cook 30 minutes. 
 Add 4 large sliced or 400g (14oz) can tomatoes, 5ml (1tsp) crushed coriander seeds, salt and pepper to taste, cook uncovered 30 minutes, until liquid has reduced. 
 Stir in 10ml (2tsp) basil or 15ml (1 tbsp) parsley. 
 Bolognese Sauce 
 Serves 4. 
 Fat content per serving &mdash; 5g; energy content per serving &mdash; 108 calories. 
 Heat 2.5ml (&frac12;tsp) olive oil in saucepan and fry 1 chopped onion until golden. 
 Add 1 finely sliced carrot and 1 stick finely chopped celery and cook 5 minutes. 
 Add 225g (8oz) very lean mince to pan, stirring until browned. 
 Sprinkle 15ml (1 tbsp) flour over sauce. 
 Stir in over moderate heat. 
 Add 15ml (1 tbsp) tomato pur&eacute;e, stock, salt and black pepper. 
 Cover and simmer 30 minutes.  
 All the family can enjoy eating the low-fat way and it will do everyone a world of good. 
 So pack up a picnic with fresh fruit, crunchy salads and wholemeal rolls with tuna or low-fat cottage cheese fillings 
 LEAD A healthy LIFE 
 After following our low-fat diet, keep the weight off by adapting the plan to your daily diet. 
 Our chart will help you to choose the foods you should eat 
 The Best Breakfast 
 The first meal of the day should be substantial, otherwise you're likely to feel hungry later. 
 Good low-fat ways to start the day include: 
 Muesli, with skimmed or semi-skimmed milk. 
 Porridge, served with skimmed milk. 
 Wholemeal/wholegrain bread, ideally with no spread, or a little very-low-fat spread, plus reduced-sugar jam or marmalade, meat or yeast extract, very-low-fat curd or cottage cheese, mashed banana. 
 Two rashers lean back bacon (visible fat removed) plus two tomatoes and 50g (2oz) mushrooms, grilled or dry-fried, wholemeal bread or toast. 
 Reduced-sugar baked beans 150g (6oz) with grilled tomato and a thin slice of lean ham. 
 Thinly sliced Edam or low-fat hard cheese on wholemeal toast with tomato. 
 Boiled, poached, scrambled or dry-fried egg (no fat). 
 No more than three eggs a week. 
 Grilled or baked kipper. 
 Dried fruits soaked overnight in apple juice, with fat-free fromage frais.  
 Always be sure to start the day with a good breakfast 
 AVOID 
 Smoking and excess alcohol 
 No matter how well you eat, your body (particularly heart and lungs) is bound to suffer if you smoke and drink alcohol. 
 Smoking 
 Smoking is linked both to lung cancer and coronary heart disease. 
 Having more than 20 cigarettes a day doubles  the risk compared with not smoking at all, and it takes about a year of non-smoking for that risk to return to normal. 
 It's far more of a risk than being overweight, so don't let the fear of putting weight on stop you from giving up cigarettes. 
 Alcohol 
 Too much can be a risk factor for heart disease. 
 Keep within the recommended guidelines, which are measured in units &mdash; equal to a glass of wine or half pint of beer. 
 &bull; The  guidelines  for men is 21 units a week. 
 &bull; The guideline for women is 14 units a week. 
 When you're eating out 
 When you eat out, be aware of the high and low levels of fat in foods and you'll become more discerning in your choice. 
 Choose simple starters such as chilled fruit juice, melon, clear soup, salads with a little olive oil dressing, or seafood dishes without sauces. 
 Main courses might include fish, poultry, lean meat and vegetarian dishes, but you should avoid sauces. 
 Always choose jacket or boiled potatoes and fresh vegetables. 
 For dessert, go for fresh fruit or water ice. 
 Avoid sundaes and cream. 
 Try lower fat cheeses, such as Edam, Camembert and Brie. 
 Eat water biscuits or oatmeal biscuits &mdash; without butter. 
 Avoid cream liqueurs and take tea and coffee black or with skimmed milk. 
 Take more exercise 
 Keeping fit doesn't just make you feel better &mdash; it has real health benefits, too. 
 If you exercise more, you use up more of the energy from your food, so reducing your chances of putting on any additional weight. 
 Exercise also makes your heart stronger. 
 As it has to pump more blood round the body to service the muscles you're using, it will get bigger and stronger in order to do so more efficiently. 
 This reduces any tendency to high blood pressure, as well.  
 To be effective, exercise must be regular and brisk. 
 A leisurely cycle or stroll in the park is not enough &mdash; aim to raise your pulse rate significantly by walking a mile or two &mdash; or cycling instead of going by car 
 Quick low-fat lunches 
 Try one of these low-fat packed lunch ideas as a change from sandwiches: 
 Wholemeal pitta bread with your favourite low-fat sandwich filling or salad in the pocket. 
 Pancakes rolled up around a sandwich filling or salad. 
 Cold, cooked jacket potato plus a tub of salad, sandwich filling, or dip. 
 Pot of salad or cold cooked vegetables &mdash; eg ratatouille. 
 Fresh, raw vegetables &mdash; eg carrot, celery or cucumber sticks, cauliflower florets, radishes, tomatoes, rings of young sweetcorn cob &mdash; plus a low-calorie dip. 
 Hot soup, stew or casserole in a thermos flask, plus a roll &mdash; but no butter or margarine. 
 Virtually fat-free yoghurt or fromage frais, or fresh fruit for dessert. 
 Great sandwich ideas 
 Here are lots of low-fat sandwich filling suggestions &mdash; many of which are moist enough to use without butter, margarine or low-fat spread. 
 Avoid white bread and choose from wholemeal, rye, granary or multigrain. 
 Meat fillings 
 Very low-fat curd cheese, tomato slices. 
 sliced raw mushroom dipped in lemon juice and a slice of lean ham; or a slice of lean ham, chopped and mixed with 2 tablespoons plain virtually fat-free fromage frais and 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard, on a bed of shredded red cabbage; or diced cooked chicken breast, diced red or green pepper, a chopped pineapple ring, 1 teaspoon tomato pur&eacute;e; all mixed with enough plain virtually fat-free yoghurt to moisten; or bread spread with tomato pur&eacute;e topped with shredded lettuce and lean, grilled back bacon &mdash; visible fat removed. 
 Fish fillings 
 Three sardines tinned in tomato sauce, mashed, plus tomato slices; or mashed tuna mixed with chopped green pepper and chopped cucumber, on a bed of shredded lettuce; or cooked, skinned and mashed mackerel, mixed with very low-fat soft cheese, lemon juice and black pepper. 
 Vegetarian fillings 
 A grated 2.5cm (1&ins;) cube of Edam or low-fat hard cheese mixed with Dijon mustard, 1 tablespoon plain, virtually fat-free yoghurt and black pepper; or grated raw white cabbage, carrot and celery, 1 chopped pineapple ring, 1 tablespoon peanuts and raisins mixed with 1 tablespoon plain virtually fat-free fromage  frias ; or very low-fat cottage cheese mixed with finely grated carrot, 1 tablespoon raisins, a dash of lemon juice and 2 teaspoons finely chopped onion; or bread spread thinly with peanut butter topped with chopped or grated apple and sprinkled with lemon juice.  
 Anchovies, red peppers and olives make a tasty sandwich 
 Learn to eat the low-fat way 
 EAT REGULARLY 
 EAT 2 OR 3 TIMES A WEEK 
 EAT ONCE A WEEK 
 CEREAL 
 Wholemeal bread, wholegrain cereals, porridge oats, crispbreads, brown rice, wholemeal pasta, cornmeal, untoasted sugar-free muesli 
 White bread, white flour, white rice and pasta, water biscuits, pastries, puddings, cakes made from wholemeal flour 
 Sugar-coated cereals, semi-sweet biscuits, ordinary shop-bought muesli, plain buns and scones 
 FRUIT AND VEG 
 All fresh, frozen and dried fruit. 
 Unsweetened tinned fruit. 
 All fresh, frozen, dried and tinned vegetables &mdash; especially peas, beans, lentils. 
 Baked potatoes 
 Oven chips labelled &bquo;cooked in sunflower oil&equo; and &bquo;40% less fat&equo; (grill if possible). 
 Olives 
 Fruit in syrup, crystallised fruit, avocado, chips and roast potatoes cooked in suitable oil 
 FISH 
 All fresh and frozen fish, eg cod, plaice, herring, mackerel. 
 Tinned fish in brine or tomato sauce, eg sardine, tuna 
 Fish fried in suitable oil (those oils consisting of mono-unsaturated or polyunsaturated fats are best) 
 Prawns, lobster, crab, oysters, winkles, tinned fish in oil (drained) eg tuna, salmon, sardines 
 MEAT 
 Chicken, turkey, veal, rabbit, game. 
 Soya-protein meat substitute. 
 Very lean red meat, small portion, no more than once daily 
 Lean beef and lamb, lean pork, ham, gammon, very lean minced meat 
 Liver, kidney, tripe, sweetbreads, grilled back bacon, duck and rabbit 
 EGGS AND DAIRY 
 Skimmed milk, soya milk, cottage cheese, low-fat curd cheese, virtually fat-free yoghurt, egg white, virtually fat-free fromage frais 
 Semi-skimmed milk. 
 No more than 3 whole eggs per week, including those in baked items, eg cakes, quiche, flans 
 Medium-fat cheeses, eg Edam, Gouda, Camembert, Brie. 
 Cheese spreads. 
 Half-fat cheeses labelled &bquo;low fat&equo;. 
 Condensed skimmed milk 
 PRESERVES, JAMS AND SPREADS 
 Marmite , Bovril . 
 Chutneys, pickles. 
 Sugar-free spreads, artificial sweeteners 
 Fish and meat pastes. 
 Peanut butter. 
 Low-sugar jams and marmalades 
 Boiled sweets, fruit pastilles and jellies. 
 Jam, marmalade and honey and spreads with high sugar content such as lemon curd 
 DRINKS 
 Freshly made tea, coffee (not too many, not too strong with skimmed milk and no sugar) 
 White wine, lager and spirits with low-calorie mixers eg soda water 
 Sweetened drinks, squashes, fruit juices. 
 Malted milk or hot chocolate drinks made with skimmed milk 
 BADDIES 
 There are some foods that you should try to exclude from your meals if you want to stay trim and slim. 
 Savoury 
 Deep-fat-fried chips, roast potatoes. 
 Sausages, luncheon meats, corned beef, meat p&acirc;t&eacute;s, salami, streaky bacon, pasties, Scotch eggs, visible fat on meat, crackling, chicken skin. 
 Crisps and snacks, cream crackers, cheese biscuits. 
 Fish roe, taramasalata, fried scampi. 
 Cream soups, mayonnaise. 
 Sweet 
 Pastries, puddings cakes and sauces made with whole milk. 
 Suet puddings, ice cream. 
 Chocolate and chocolate sauces, toffees, fudge, butterscotch, carob chocolate. 
 Coconut, sweet or cream-filled biscuits. 
 Dairy 
 Whole milk and cream, full-fat yoghurt. 
 Cheese, eg Cheddar, Stilton, cream cheese. 
 Evaporated or condensed milk, imitation cream. 
 Excess eggs (no more than three a week). 
 Butter and all high-fat spreads, shortenings not labelled &bquo;high in polyunsaturates&equo; or  &bquo;monosaturates&equo; . 
 Lard, suet, dripping. 
 Cooking tips 
 Trim fat from red meats. 
 Roast meats on a rack to drain fat. 
 Remove skin before cooking chicken or turkey &mdash; wrap in foil to prevent drying out. 
 Bake, roast, grill or fry meats slowly , without any added fat. 
 Dry-fry or boil mince, and pour off resulting fat. 
 Use less meat than the stated quantity and add canned beans to reduce fat content. 
 When you're out shopping choose fresh vegetables in season &mdash; and not just for you. 
 The entire family will also benefit from eating more wholesome foods 
 Personal Story 
 &bquo;Diabetes made me blind &mdash; but I won't let it ruin my life&equo; 
 Since losing her sight, Philippa Bastable has taken up competitive swimming and has a new career, too 
 During the big freeze in December last year, Philippa Bastable, like many others, was stranded for 11 hours on the snowbound M6. 
 But for Philippa, from Aylesbury, it was especially scary. 
 With no food and only a couple of bottles of Lucozade  in the car, she knew that if the delay lasted much longer, her blood glucose could fall to such a dangerously low level, that she risked slipping into a diabetic coma. 
 Philippa has suffered from diabetes ever since she was five years old, so she knows the symptoms of both comas and hypoglycaemic episodes, which are the stage before, only too well. 
 &bquo;I can recognise the warning signs straight away &mdash; I start to tremble and go into a cold sweat,&equo; explains Philippa. 
 &bquo;As long as I drink some Lucozade  straight away, then I'm OK. 
 But if I don't that's when I risk slipping into a coma.&equo; 
 Fortunately help came in time on that particular day. 
 But as a sufferer of a very severe form of diabetes, 34-year-old Philippa has had to struggle not to let her illness take over her life. 
 Seven years ago, as a consequence of her diabetes, Philippa was left totally blind. 
 &bquo;Of course I was terrified when it happened,&equo; she recalls, &bquo;but I'm not the sort to be beaten. 
 I was determined to carry on as normally as I could.&equo; 
 It was her bubbly, outgoing nature that helped Philippa grow up with her condition. 
 &bquo;I was so young when it was first diagnosed that I can't really remember a time without it. 
 By the time I was six I was giving myself injections, twice a day, before and after school. 
 I didn't really understand what it was all about except that there were always sugar lumps in my pocket for when I didn't feel very well. 
 That was in case I had a &bquo;hypo&equo;,&equo; she recalls. 
 A more serious complication of diabetes is damage to the retina, the light-sensitive area at the back of the eye. 
 &bquo;I knew that there was always the danger that I could lose my sight, but I really thought it only happened later in life,&equo; says Philippa. 
 &bquo;So when I went for my regular eye check-up I had no idea that anything was wrong. 
 The surgeon took one look at my eyes and said, bluntly: &bquo;Well, they're a right mess, aren't they?&equo;. 
 He wasn't the least bit sympathetic and I was terrified.&equo; 
 After that news followed several emotionally charged months as Philippa waited to find out whether her vision could be saved. 
 Her GP referred her to a hospital in Watford, North London, where she underwent laser treatment to try and prevent the damage from getting any worse &mdash; but it didn't help. 
 And gradually, over a period of about nine months, she began to lose the use of her eyes. 
 &bquo;It happened quite slowly, so I didn't stop doing the things I had always done &mdash; apart from driving. 
 That's why I still cope now with all the everyday things like the ironing and housework. 
 In a way I was preparing myself,&equo; she says. 
 Even so, there were times when Philippa crumpled under the strain. 
 &bquo;I was even taken to hospital at one point thinking I had a hypo coming on, but then we realised that I was actually having panic attacks &mdash; a delayed reaction to losing my sight. 
 I suppose I'd never really sat down and cried about it,&equo; she recalls. 
 That hospital visit marked a low point for Philippa. 
 &bquo;I only had light and dark vision at that stage. 
 I remember lying in bed and the only thing I could see was the dim glow of the light bulb on the ceiling. 
 Before I left hospital that had disappeared, too. 
 That's it, it's gone completely now, I thought. 
 That was very hard.&equo; 
 But Philippa wasn't to be allowed the time to get really depressed. 
 &bquo;A mobility officer from the social services got me into action straight away. 
 I think he was my saving grace. 
 Of course, there are times when it's frustrating &mdash; it can take me twice as long to find anything, for example. 
 But there's always a voice in me, saying, &bquo;I'm not going to let it beat me&equo;.&equo; 
 Gradually, with the constant support of her family and friends, Philippa learned to come to terms with her situation. 
 She signed up with her local college for a typing course, and later she taught herself Braille. 
 And when she found she was putting on some weight, she took up swimming regularly. 
 Three years after losing her sight she finally felt ready to start looking for a job. 
 &bquo;I'd previously been trained in management and I didn't want to be an audio typist. 
 After all, I've only lost my sight &mdash; not my brains. 
 I refused to settle for second best, unless I absolutely had to,&equo; she says. 
 And her persistence paid off. 
 A year later she was offered a job with Rothmans to join their customer liaison department. 
 There she's been provided with Braille equipment and a talking computer. 
 And her swimming is progressing rapidly, too. 
 Only three years since starting swimming competitively, she has won 45 medals. 
 She's also in the National Blind Swimming Squad and is a real hopeful for Britain's 1992 line-up at the Disabled Olympics in Barcelona. 
 &bquo;Obviously there are times when I think, why me?. 
 It's the smaller things that get you down &mdash; like when I went out the other day to buy a dress for my god daughter's birthday. 
 My fianc&eacute;, Derrick, had to make the final decision about the colour etc&hellip; 
 But I'm not a bitter person. 
 There's very little I don't do that I used to do. 
 You just have to accept things and get on with your life.&equo;  
 &bquo;By the time I was six, I was giving myself injections twice a day&equo; 
 &bquo;There are times when I think, &bquo;why me?&equo; 
 But I'm not a bitter person&equo; 
 Despite her disability, Philippa is very confident &mdash; she strides out with her guide dog Paula and is a medal-winning swimmer 
 Seven years after losing her sight Philippa now holds down a full-time job. 
 &bquo;I decided to make a go of it,&equo; she says 
 NATURAL CHOICE 
 Remarkably versatile and elegantly styled, wicker and cane furniture for indoors and outside has never looked better and you'll find a wide selection to choose from 
 SITTING PRETTY 
 No need to skimp on comfort with these suites &mdash; they're available with deep padded cushions 
 Solid style 
 Made from bamboo poles, which are exceptionally strong, the framework of this suite is bleached and then whitewashed for a unique finish. 
 Extra wide seats and easy backs provide a combination of comfort and detailed eye-catching design. 
 Diners' delight 
 A clean-cut, lightweight informal style makes this natural rattan furniture an excellent choice for your dining area. 
 Dual role 
 This handmade rattan furniture has been lacquered, making it suitable for indoors and out. 
 It coordinates easily with an existing colour scheme and cushions can be covered in fabric from the wide range available from Laura Ashley shops. 
 Lattice lover 
 A wonderfully decorative sofa that features superb canework. 
 It has cushion covers that are easily removable for dry cleaning and the sofa comes complete with two matching scatter cushions. 
 It is shown here in antique brown but it is also available in white.  
 Lounging around 
 This comfy willow chaise longue gives you the perfect excuse for relaxing and putting your feet up. 
 Woven wicker 
 Diamond patterned cane with cotton covered cushions makes for comfort on the patio. 
 SUMMER COLOURS 
 Look out for the wide range of painted wicker that's around. 
 Take your pick from pure classic white or go for bolder shades 
 Sea view 
 Inspired by the grand ocean liners of the 1930s, where similar pieces were a familiar sight in the saloons and lounges, these items are available in both country blue and antique almond. 
 The chair comes with a loose seat pad, the table has a 6mm glass top. 
 Matching tray available. 
 Old English style 
 A willow green wicker armchair takes on a whole new look when a collection of pretty floral covered cushions and a deep frill are added. 
 Economise on fabric by only making the frill to cover the front of the chair. 
 Designer desk 
 White walls provide the perfect backdrop for this rattan desk. 
 The colour detail has been achieved by immersing the cane in a colour bath before it's woven and plaited into stunning and practical furniture. 
 A whole range of pieces is available in this classic colour combination, but just one or two items in a room would look attractive. 
 ESSENTIAL ELEMENTS 
 Look out for unusual room accessories to add the finishing touch 
 Neat fit 
 A corner shelf unit is a smart way to display ornaments. 
 Two into one 
 This wicker screen is ideal for dividing your lounge or concealing unwanted clutter. 
 Topping table 
 This circular table suits every decor. 
 The bottom tier is great for storing your copies of best . 
 KEEPING YOUR WICKER AND CANE IN TIP TOP CONDITION 
 If you keep your wicker or cane furniture in a well heated room or conservatory, moisten it regularly with a plant spray. 
 Wash down with a damp cloth &mdash; avoid using soaps. 
 Don't leave unvarnished wicker or cane outside. 
 Although it is a natural fibre, it tends not to weather well. 
 Never use wicker chairs to stand on for odd jobs around the house. 
 Did you know that traditional Lloyd Loom furniture is made from paper twisted around fine steel, which is then woven into the finished product? 
 If you have any original Lloyd Loom which is slightly the worse for wear, contact Graham Mancha on 029 6615121. 
 He can mend pieces, or advise on what to do. 
 HOMECRAFT 
 Happy FATHER'S DAY 
 Make your dad's day extra special with these brilliant handmade cards &mdash; each one bearing a small but welcome gift 
 You will need 
 Card: white, yellow, blue, orange, green, mauve 
 Sticky backed orange paper 
 Pritt Stick paper glue and double-sided tape 
 Felt-tip pens and coloured paper for letters 
 Patterned giftwrap and 3 red buttons 
 Gifts to put in cards: pens, pencils, paper clips, packets of seeds, spotted handkerchief 
 Tips and hints 
 To make a really successful card design it to complement your father's hobbies. 
 Adapt the idea for other special occasions. 
 You could design your own Christmas cards in this way and fill them with small gifts. 
 You could adapt the dapper Dad's card to include a smart tie or even a pair of cufflinks. 
 How to make the writer's card 
 Prepare the basic card 
 Mark and cut out a piece of the yellow card 30 &times; 20cm. 
 Use a craft knife for really sharp edges. 
 Cut a strip of patterned giftwrap 30 &times; 7cm. 
 Stick this strip across the lower half of the card for the tablecloth. 
 Score on the wrong side and then fold the card in half. 
 Draw the lettering 
 Either use a suitable sized stencil or trace off letters, from the magazine to spell DAD. 
 Mark the letters in reverse on the wrong side of the sticky orange paper, cut them out ready to stick across the front of the mug. 
 Then cut out a fun motif to decorate the mug. 
 Make the mug 
 From the mauve card cut out a rectangle 14 &times; 10cm and a handle 7cm long. 
 Mark in 2cm from the mug sides along base and 1.5cm from each side along top. 
 Join up and fold along lines. 
 Apply double-sided tape to the sides and do the lower edge on the wrong side. 
 Assemble 
 Position the mug centrally on to the card and stick the base. 
 Now position and stick the handle under one side then stick the other side. 
 Make sure that the mug sides are vertical and the top bows out. 
 Fill with a selection of colour co-ordinating pens and pencils. 
 The gardener's card 
 Cut a piece of blue card 30 &times; 20cm. 
 Then cut a strip of green card 30 &times; 6cm and cut deep zigzags along one edge to represent the grass. 
 Stick along base edge of blue card. 
 Score card on the wrong side and then fold in half. 
 For the flower pot, cut a piece of orange card 14 &times; 10cm. 
 Mark in 3cm from each side of long base edge, and mark 1cm from each side of top edge. 
 Join up marks to graduate sides. 
 Score along these lines and bend inwards for tabs. 
 Stick the flower pot centrally to card, as with the mug. 
 Cut a strip of orange card 15 &times; 3cm for the rim. 
 Score across rim 6mm from each end; bend inwards to form tabs and stick over upper edge of pot. 
 Choose an appropriate motif and stick to the base of the pot. 
 Slip gift seed packets inside. 
 The dapper dad's card 
 Cut a piece of white card 20 &times; 30cm. 
 Carefully draw on thick blue stripes. 
 Score, and fold card as before. 
 Cut 2 collars from the white card, each 15 &times; 6cm. 
 Mark and score a 1.5cm strip across one long edge. 
 Join this point diagonally up to the outer edges of tab. 
 Cut along lines to form collars and stick in place. 
 Cut a piece of white card 12 &times; 10cm for the shirt pocket. 
 Mark on blue stripes to match shirt. 
 Trim down sides so base edge is 10cm wide. 
 Stick to card. 
 Stick buttons down the front and slip gift handkerchief into pocket.  
 Next week: renovating a chair 
 The beautiful art of flower arranging 
 New ways with FRESH FLOWERS 
 You don't have to be an expert to create lovely arrangements, just follow Jenny Plucknett's advice for simple but sensational floral displays, both for everyday and for special occasions 
 Planning a display doesn't mean sticking rigidly to a formal design. 
 However, for the best effect, you do need to work out the right size and shape for your arrangement, choose appropriate containers and know which colours of flowers go well together. 
 Bear in mind that the container should be in proportion to the size of the flowers &mdash; small blooms are lost in a large vase. 
 If you just want to brighten your home, avoid an &bquo;over-arranged&equo; look by using informal containers and groupings and choosing long-lasting flowers. 
 For special occasions, you can be more extravagant and go for dramatic, impressive displays. 
 In miniature 
 Small containers are best for small flowers, but are also a good way to display blooms with short or broken stems. 
 For greater impact, try grouping several displays together as a single one can look a little lost. 
 Teacups, tiny jars, egg cups or even thimbles can be used. 
 As long as you can fit in a piece of florist's foam, it can hold flowers! 
 With small arrangements, make sure you check the water level frequently and top up as necessary.  
 Something as simple as a mug can turn a handful of pansies into a vivid display. 
 Here it picks out the teaset design 
 Vases with a difference 
 Your kitchen cupboards can often yield unusual but excellent flower containers. 
 Glass pie plates and quiche dishes are perfect for low displays. 
 A circular cooling rack will hold the flower stems in place. 
 Pretty china jugs and teapots are ideal for taller displays. 
 Use crumpled chicken wire to hold the flower stems in place. 
 Earthenware and enamelled casseroles can co-ordinate perfectly with autumn golds.  
 Florist's foam will help to turn a shallow bowl into a lovely container. 
 Start your arrangement around rim and then build up towards the middle to hide the foam 
 Co-ordinating colour 
 When you don't have a vase to match your flowers, decorate one. 
 Paint on oil-based paint, then partially rub off for an antiqued look. 
 This urn containing tulips has been aged with pinkish tones, while its base colour echoes that of the grape hyacinths.  
 Group for effect 
 To make a stunning group arrangement use the same flowers but in different containers. 
 Line up a row of pretty jam jars on the kitchen windowsill and fill them with daffodils, for example. 
 On a tray, set out a matching teapot, milk jug and sugar bowl. 
 Fill them with the same flowers using the colours of the china. 
 Wine glasses will look effective arranged down a long dinner table, alternating single large blooms with groups of tiny flowers.  
 Arrange jugs of flowers in order of size, choosing harmonising blooms such as violets, ranunculus and stocks 
 Make it smell sweet 
 When you plan a display, include scented flowers, either shop-bought or home-grown, so that your arrangement smells as good as it looks. 
 Simple to grow scented climbers include many lilies, petunias, lily-of-the-valley, tobacco plants, pinks and carnations, honey-scented buddleia, narcissus, sweet peas, freesias and summer jasmine. 
 Add honeysuckle (not all the varieties smell so check before buying that it is fragrant) and climbing roses. 
 Many of the older rose varieties also have a strong scent. 
 Contact Roses du temps pass&eacute; and Harkness for catalogues.  
 To make the most of fragrant flowers such as these sweetly scented golden and white freesias and white lilies, display them by massing the flowers closely together in side-by-side containers. 
 Position the vases in front of an open window so that the breeze wafts the scent into the room 
 For longer-lasting flowers&hellip; 
 After buying or picking flowers recut stems and place in cool, deep water, up to neck level for at least two hours. 
 Submerge foliage completely (except grey) for several hours. 
 If the greenery is grimy add a drop of washing-up liquid. 
 Next hammer the ends of woody stemmed plants. 
 Remove leaves that will be below water level when flowers are arranged. 
 Poppies, euphorbias and other flower stems that contain a milky fluid, plus roses, last longer if you dip the stem in boiling water for 30 seconds. 
 Protect the flower head with paper or a cloth to prevent scalding it. 
 When some flowers start to wilt, trim the rest for a smaller arrangement. 
 The bright primary colours of the sunny yellow tiger lilies and gerbera, red-pink clusters of carnations and brightest blue cornflowers mix with the rusty orange nasturtiums and pink sweet peas and Sweet Williams. 
 All this colour is offset by the tiny yellow green flowers of lady's mantle. 
 In a natural arrangement use mainly medium size headed flowers with just a few large heads 
 The easy way to make an elegant impact 
 Create this stylish, colourful display in three simple steps 
 Setting the height 
 Put a block of florist's foam in a jug half-filled with water. 
 Insert one iris towards the back. 
 Trim the other to about two-thirds this height and position it in front of the first, to give a strong central line. 
 Then insert escallonia, leaning out, at sides of jug 
 Soften the edges 
 Insert the tiger lilies, in a triangular group overhanging the foam and jug lip. 
 Put two carnations, cut to the same length as the shorter iris, on either side. 
 Insert another carnation in a diagonal line with the tiger lilies. 
 Tuck in ivy to act as background 
 You will need 
 A 
 3 tiger lily blooms 
 B 
 2 blue irises 
 C 
 3 carnations 
 D 
 a few stems of escallonia 
 E 
 large ivy leaves 
 Displays for SPECIAL OCCASIONS 
 There are times when you want a more elaborate floral arrangement. 
 Whether it's for a formal dinner party or a family celebration, we show you how 
 At a formal dinner party, you have an excuse to be extravagant with the floral decorations. 
 This large display (right) in a cool, fresh, green and white colour scheme, provides a central focal point for the table, but it is not so large that it obscures the guests' view. 
 Tiny baskets of cherries are tucked away in the display, an idea popular in Victorian times. 
 They're surrounded by bear grass, asparagus fern and ivy, to create the background, and then filled out with bridal gladioli, freesias, Singapore orchids and a few fragrant roses.  
 This eye-catching display contains tiny baskets of fruit. 
 Omit the baskets on one side for a buffet table if it is set against the wall 
 Floral table edging 
 Swags create a wonderful effect on wedding or special buffet tables. 
 Make the base with Oasis to keep the flowers fresh for several days. 
 Cut a block into eight rectangular blocks, about 7&ndash;8cm in length. 
 Place the sections end to end, on fine grade polythene sheeting, then roll up to form a tube. 
 Tie each section of foam in position, with one piece of string, winding it around the plastic tube between the blocks. 
 Push the flowers and the foliage through the plastic.  
 Roses, alstroemeria and chrysanthemum heads make a luscious decoration for a long table. 
 Here the leaves were inserted into a swag base first to create the background. 
 Then the flowers were added in small groups and singly, along the garland or bunched to form a central group 
 Brighten up a dull corner 
 Paint a wicker basket white to create the perfect base for colourful flowers 
 Framing with foliage 
 A basket must first be lined with polythene to make it waterproof. 
 Add a block of pre-soaked Oasis and insert eucalyptus branches to make a dome shape, with some extending horizontally outwards. 
 Build up to form a frame for the russet chrysanthemums 
 Filling in colour 
 Trim flower stems to a similar length and bash the ends with a hammer to enable them to draw up water. 
 Insert the flower sprigs into the foam, within the general framework. 
 Start by inserting the blooms at the back then work your way along the sides and then finish at front 
 Use the right equipment 
 Florist's foam or Oasis. 
 When soaked, this allows stems and branches to be positioned securely and take up water. 
 If you're using delicate stems you may first have to make holes in the Oasis with a knitting needle. 
 Different foams are sold for a variety of plants and uses. 
 Wire netting Crumple up wire netting into a ball and push into a container. 
 The netting should fit quite snugly and reach to just below the rim of the container. 
 You can also use a circle of wire netting, shaped like a mound, to cover the top of the container. 
 Hold it in place with a rubber band.  
 Make your dinner table the centre of attraction 
 For an informal dinner party, don't hide your guests from one another with a giant display but rather use a series of small containers grouped to suit your table shape. 
 This type of display is foolproof and takes only minutes to arrange. 
 Wine glasses, tumblers and individual souffl&eacute; dishes are ideal containers and contents can be chosen from single giant blooms, a miniature flower and foliage display, candles and small fruits and nuts. 
 On a long table place containers in a row. 
 On a square or round table they can be arranged in a circle around a group of tall candles or a bowl of fruit. 
 Fix the candles in place to the base of the container with melted wax or adhesive putty. 
 Choose a scheme that will tone in with your tablecloth and china or pick out one small colour detail and highlight it with your floral display.  
 Different sized candles have been mixed with large and small blooms, including sprays of pale pink chrysanthemums, blue-dyed gypsophila and flowerheads of irises, lilies and daisy-like gerbera, all carefully arranged in pretty chunky blue glasses 
 How to wire flowers 
 Push one thick stub wire up stem, then two thinner wires through base of petals, forming a cross. 
 Twist down stem, cover with tape. 
 Tape flowers together as you work. 
 To wire an ivy leaf, push half a length of wire through the back of the central vein, one third down from the point of the leaf. 
 Fold down one wire half to lie against the stem, wind the other half around stem and wire. 
 Tape. 
 Wedding corsage 
 Use leaves from your most decorative house plants and add just a few perfect blooms to create a beautiful corsage for a special occasion. 
 Once you've mastered the basic technique (see how to wire flowers, left), then it's easy to create a corsage. 
 Choose flowers that complement your outfit, as well as blooms that clash for a startling effect. 
 Including scented flowers in the display adds a special touch. 
 Each flower and leaf will need to be separately wired before taping together (see left). 
 Once arranged, spray the corsage with water, protect in a box and place in the refrigerator to keep it fresh overnight.  
 This corsage uses the deep pink of nerines to mimic the colour of the dress 
 Design a flower tree 
 Trees can be made to any size. 
 Make a miniature for a table or have a larger pair on either side of the front door. 
 Choose a container to match your tree's size to keep it stable. 
 First, cover the ball of Oasis with leaves and moss. 
 Hold these in place with bent stub wires, shaped like hair pins, then add the flowers on short cut stems. 
 Spray to keep fresh. 
 For a more permanent display use dried flowers. 
 Use a broom handle cut to the size you require, a length of vine, or a rustic pole for the trunk.  
 Place a plastic bag in your pot and fill with ready mixed cement. 
 Push in the wooden pole. 
 When set, lift out and trim plastic 
 Using wire netting and lengths of wire attach a block of wet Oasis securely to the top of the &bquo;trunk&equo; 
 Push foliage, then flowers, into the Oasis, or use wires to pin moss in place. 
 Hide cement with more moss 
 DIY and home hints 
 Fitting a bath/shower mixer 
 Enjoy all the benefits of a shower simply by replacing your bath taps with a mixer unit 
 This is the simplest type of shower to fit. 
 The mixer tap takes the place of the existing bath taps, and can be used either to fill the bath or provide a shower. 
 Bath/shower mixer taps cost from as little as &pound;40. 
 However, we chose the Aqualisa Aquamixa (from &pound;334.65), a thermostatic bath and shower mixer. 
 Telephone 0959 63240 for stockist details. 
 The integral thermostat guarantees that shower water temperature stays constant even if taps are turned on elsewhere. 
 1. 
 Turn off water 
 You will need to turn off hot and cold water supplies. 
 The gate valve for cold water will be close to the cold water cistern; the hot water valve will be near the hot water tank. 
 Open the taps to drain water in the pipes. 
 If the cold taps are fed directly from the mains, or if you have an instant water heater, seek further advice. 
 2. 
 Remove old taps 
 Unscrew any bath panelling and use a bath/basin spanner on the nearest tap to unscrew the nut holding the pipe to the tap, then the nut holding the tap to the bath. 
 If necessary use a metal bar to increase the leverage, then repeat for the further tap. 
 Brace the tap with a piece of wood or a cloth-wrapped spanner. 
 3. 
 Check connections 
 After withdrawing the old taps, check that the length of the new tap &bquo;tails&equo; matches that of the old bath taps. 
 If it's shorter you may need a pair of (22mm/&frac34;&ins; BSP) tap adaptors; if longer, you may need to cut the pipe and then fit two new (22mm&frac34;&ins; BSP) tap connectors. 
 Choose the push-fit kind for ease of use. 
 4. 
 Clean the surface 
 Remove any old sealing compound which may be present on the bath close to the tap fixing. 
 Take care not to scratch the surface on plastic baths. 
 The new tap should be provided with a sealing washer or gasket. 
 If it doesn't have one, buy some non-setting plumber's mastic to seal between the tap and the bath. 
 5. 
 Replace the taps 
 To fit the new mixer tap follow step 2 in reverse. 
 Make sure that you put the plastic washers provided onto the tape &bquo;tails&equo; before screwing on the back nuts and that the small fibre washers in the tap connectors are present and are undamaged. 
 Turn the water on slowly and tighten the nuts if there are any leaks. 
 6. 
 Fit the shower head 
 Drill holes and fit the wall plugs before screwing on the shower slider rail or bracket (see How to drill through tiles  in best , issue 20/91). 
 Follow instructions for the correct height, and make sure the restraint is fitted to prevent the shower head dangling in the bath. 
 Test the shower before replacing the bath panel. 
 Top tips for a fun Father's Day 
 Pride and joy 
 Offer to clean his car both inside and out. 
 Tidy the boot and glove compartment as well, and, if you know how to, make sure that the car has enough oil and water. 
 Basket of goodies 
 If your father has a favourite hobby, gather together a few well-chosen gifts that you know he will like and wrap them in a presentation basket. 
 Alternatively, you could fill the basket with his favourite foods or toiletries. 
 Lazy day 
 Start the day as you intend it to continue and take him breakfast in bed on a tray. 
 Make sure he's awake first, though! 
 A quick card 
 If you've forgotten to buy a card and the shops are all closed, simply cut out some funny or pretty pictures from magazines, paste them onto a piece of card and then write your own personalised message inside. 
 He'll love it. 
 Take your pick 
 Choose a particular chore that you know he hates doing, such as mowing the lawn, weeding the garden or putting the dustbin out, and offer to do it yourself. 
 If it's something that needs doing every day, keep it up for a week. 
 Pooling resources 
 If you are short of cash, club together with brothers and sisters and combine your money so you can buy a present between you. 
 And finally 
 Don't forget granddad &mdash; remember he's a father too! 
 TIP OF THE WEEK 
 Mrs M Dunn of Oban, Scotland has a good idea for maximising space in a small bathroom. 
 She suggests suspending a hanging basket from the ceiling and using it to store spare soap, toothpaste, talcum powder and toilet rolls.  
 Plantworld 
 by Rosie Atkins 
 COLOUR CO-ORDINATION 
 An all-white garden 
 Bring a timeless tranquility to your garden with the luminous quality of green and white blooms and foliage 
 For a dramatic impact, mass all of your white flowers together. 
 However, if you lack the confidence to toss away your favourite purple lilac bush, create a similar effect on a smaller scale by concentrating on a single border, window boxes or even pots on the patio. 
 All-white gardens are at their most striking when enclosed by walls or dark yew hedges. 
 In the evening they can take on a luminous glow and fill the air with perfume. 
 In spring, Clematis montana  will soon cover trellises and walls with a shower of white blooms. 
 C montana  &bquo;Wilsonii&equo; is scented, too, and flowers a little later. 
 A white wisteria such as Wisteria floribunda  &bquo;Alba&equo; can be trained to make a fragrant bower, while Solanum jasminoides  &bquo;Album&equo; (Jasmine nightshade) likes a sheltered position and has star-shaped flowers which bloom even in late autumn. 
 Of the many white roses, &bquo;Iceberg&equo;, available as a climber, bush or standard, is the most popular. 
 Fragrant shrubs 
 The evergreen Viburnum tinus  &bquo;Gwenllian&equo; has white flowers with pinkish buds from late winter. 
 For scent, you can't beat Daphne odora  &bquo;Alba&equo; with its winter flowers that smell of roses. 
 Flowerbeds 
 Vinca minor  &bquo;Alba variegata&equo; trails its decorative leaves over pots or shady beds, while tall containers packed with white hostas look smart. 
 Fragrant lilies such as lilium longiflorum  and the hardier, later-flowering L. speciosum  &bquo;Album&equo; are perfect for containers. 
 The fragrant tobacco plant ( Nicotiana affinis ) should be planted in the back row of borders. 
 While Dicentra exima  &bquo;Alba&equo;, white anemones, hydrangeas, campanulas and daisies will bring interest to your flowerbeds until autumn. 
 Plant bulbs like white hyacinth, lily of the valley and white tulips to boost next year's display.  
 Iberis sempervirens looks stunning next to hosta foliage 
 Gardens to visit 
 Sissinghurst, Kent (former home of Vita Sackville-West, main picture above); Newby Hall, North Yorkshire; Hidcote Manor, Gloucestershire; Barrington Court, Ilminster, Somerset; Folley Farm, Reading, Berkshire; Grey Court, Henley-on-Thames, Oxfordshire; Chenies Manor, Little Chalfont, Herts. 
 TOPICAL TIPS 
 Buy a packet of nasturtium seeds and pop them into the sides of hanging baskets. 
 Put straw mats under strawberry plants to protect fruit from rotting. 
 Remove any debris from the garden pond and thin out plants showing signs of excessive growth. 
 Plant dahlia tubers in the garden now, covering them with 7.5cm of soil. 
 Avoid accidents with the strimmer by protecting young trees with plastic tubes or weed by hand. 
 HOW TO&hellip; plant chrysanthemums 
 Now is the time to plant chrysanthemums. 
 Choose a sheltered sunny position with well-drained and composted soil which is weed free. 
 To get plant out of the pot, turn it upside down with the stem between your fingers and give the pot a gentle knock. 
 Place a cane in the ground then make a small planting hole just deep enough to cover the roots. 
 Leave a depression around the stem to form a puddle when you water. 
 Secure plant to the cane then water well. 
 Water again after a few days and start feeding in June. 
 A BEAUTIFUL BLOOM 
 The Brazilian or florist's gloxinia 
 If you are looking for an attractive houseplant, choose this favourite 
 The stunning bell-shaped flowers of the Brazilian or the florist's gloxinia are often beautifully marked so they make a real splash of vibrant colour in your home. 
 This plant is a hybrid which has evolved over years of cross breeding with the Sinningia speciosa  from Brazil. 
 Treat florist gloxinias as annuals and grow them from seed in spring, or grow from tubers potted up in spring so they are just covered by the compost. 
 Flowers last longest if kept in a cool place and given a high phosphate feed once a month. 
 When plant dies down, reduce the watering and store the tuber in its pot in a dry, warm place. 
 Repot tuber in February, start watering and you will see a repeat performance that year. 
 Overwatering the plant causes root rot.  
 Popularly known as the florist's gloxinia, Sinningia speciosa can produce beautiful trumpet-shaped flowers, ranging from shades of red, purple and pink to white, five months after sowing if kept in a greenhouse with a night temperature of 18&ndash;21&deg;C 
 READERS' OFFER 
 Keep compost moist 
 Prevent plants in containers and hanging baskets from drooping during a long hot summer by adding water-retentive gel, such as Broadleaf P4, to the compost. 
 Normally costing &pound;4 for 125g, this pack is available to best  readers at the special price of &pound;3 p&amp;p inclusive. 
 This quantity is sufficient for 125 litres of compost, enough to plant up a considerable number of hanging baskets, pots and window boxes.   
 Mouthwatering MELONS 
 Although melons are available most of the year, they are at their best &mdash; and cheapest &mdash; now. 
 Cool and fragrant, these thirst quenching fruits can be eaten alone, or with cold meats or salads. 
 They make a really versatile choice for summer 
 Cucumbers and marrows belong to the same family; melons come in four basic types: 
 Winter melons include the slow-ripening honeydew, which is oval, smooth and yellow. 
 Its flesh is juicy, but has little fragrance. 
 Netted melons are in season from April to December and include Galia; they have a coarse crochet-like &bquo;net&equo; on golden yellow skins. 
 Flesh varies from green to orange and is juicy and refreshing. 
 Cantaloupe melons include Ogen and Charentais. 
 In season from July to early October. 
 Their skin is rough and sometimes striped, with a sweet and scented delicate flavour. 
 Watermelons are large and round with green or green and yellow striped skins and red flesh. 
 The sweet flesh is 90% water and is a great thirst-quencher. 
 ITALIAN HAM AND MELON STARTER 
 Serve Parma ham with melon &mdash; it's a classic combination 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 
 Preparation: 10 mins 
 1 Ogen or Galia melon 
 1 Honeydew melon 
 100g (4oz) Italian salami 
 100g (4oz) Parma ham 
 100g (4oz) mild Cheddar or Lancashire cheese 
 Freshly ground black pepper 
 Leave the melons to stand at room temperature for 30 minutes and then cut into quarters, lengthways. 
 Scoop away the seeds and discard. 
 Take a thin-bladed knife and run it closely between the flesh and the rind until they separate. 
 Place the flesh back on the rind, and cut the Ogen quarters into four slices and the honeydew quarters into six slices. 
 Place the sliced melons alternately on a large platter and fan out the wedges. 
 Arrange slices of salami and Parma ham between each of the melon wedges. 
 Slice the cheese as thinly as possible and place in the centre of the plate. 
 Season generously with the freshly ground pepper, then serve with plenty of crusty French or Italian bread. 
 Easy ways to prepare them 
 PEELING 
 Use a sharp knife to remove the skin by slicing downwards, following the shape of the melon. 
 Peel off a thick layer as the flesh immediately under the skin is hard and bitter. 
 Alternatively, quarter melon and run a sharp knife along the curve. 
 HOW TO DE-SEED 
 To prepare melons for chopping once you have removed the skin or to serve smaller melons like Galia or Charentais you need to remove the seeds. 
 Cut the melon in half and scoop out the seeds, which are slippery and stringy. 
 REMOVING WATERMELON SEEDS 
 Watermelon is speckled with black seeds. 
 If you remove these from the melon it makes eating it easier. 
 To do this: use a sharp knife and slice melon into wedges. 
 Then using the end of a teaspoon, ease out the seeds. 
 MAKING MELON BALLS 
 Halve the melon and scoop out the seeds. 
 Then using a specially designed melon baller (available from cookshops or larger supermarkets) or a small measuring spoon, insert it deep into the flesh, twist it and then make a full turn to form the ball. 
 Tap spoon to release melon ball.  
 A DELICIOUS STARTER 
 An appealing mix of three different coloured melons 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 
 Preparation: 25 mins 
 1 Charentais melon 
 1 Ogen melon 
 &frac12; small watermelon 
 300ml (&frac12; pt) cr&egrave;me fra&icirc;che or single cream 
 15ml (1 tbsp) honey 
 15ml (1 tbsp) Amaretto liqueur (optional) 
 50g (2oz) whole blanched almonds, cut into slivers 
 Halve the Charentais and the Ogen melons and scoop out the seeds. 
 Make melon balls using a melon baller or teaspoon. 
 Insert the baller or spoon deep into the flesh, twist to turn, then scoop out a ball. 
 Repeat using as much of the flesh as possible. 
 Cut the watermelon in half and scoop away as many black seeds as possible from the flesh. 
 Make balls as before and place in a serving dish with the others, tossing them to mix the colours. 
 Add the cr&egrave;me fra&icirc;che or cream to the honey and Amaretto, if using. 
 Spoon the mixture over the melon balls. 
 Place the blanched almonds on a piece of foil, and toast under a hot grill until they are lightly browned. 
 Cool, then sprinkle over the melon balls in the dish. 
 Serve immediately. 
 Adding alcohol 
 Amaretto liqueur is an Italian almond-flavoured liqueur, so if you like the taste of almonds and Italian amaretti biscuits you're sure to love it. 
 If you prefer, use any other liqueur or spirit such as brandy, Cointreau  or, for something that's refreshingly different, why not try adding Pimms  or sparkling white or ros&eacute; wine? 
 CRISP AND REFRESHING SALAD 
 Adding a succulent melon turns a simple salad into a low-calorie main course 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 
 Preparation: 15 mins 
 1 Iceberg lettuce 
 1 Ogen melon 
 1 large pickled dill cucumber 
 225g (80z) seedless grapes 
 For the dressing: 
 90ml (6 tbsp) freshly squeezed orange juice 
 120ml (8tbsp) sunflower oil 
 pinch each of salt, pepper and sugar 
 25g (10z) freshly chopped chives 
 Remove any damaged outer leaves from the lettuce, cut it in half, then place cut side down on a board and thinly shred each half, using a sharp knife. 
 Place the lettuce pieces in a salad bowl or large mixing bowl. 
 Cut the melon in half and scoop out the seeds. 
 Cut into quarters, then peel away the rind. 
 Chop the quarters into small cubes and add to the salad bowl, along with any juice. 
 Chop the dill cucumber thinly and add to the bowl. 
 Wash the grapes and halve them, then toss into the bowl. 
 To make the dressing: place the orange juice and oil in a screw-top jar with the salt, pepper and sugar. 
 Replace lid and shake well, then mix in the chives. 
 Pour over salad. 
 Toss together, then serve alone or with cold chicken or turkey. 
 Unusual combinations 
 Pickled cucumber provides a delicious, sharp contrasting taste to the sweet, succulent melon and grapes in this recipe but if you prefer you could use &frac13; of a medium fresh cucumber instead. 
 Include prawns for a special treat or add chicken or ham for a really substantial meal. 
 MAKE A RIPE CHOICE 
 A good melon should feel heavy for its size, so hold two or three and go for the heaviest. 
 A ripe melon will smell sweet, and yield slightly at the stalk end. 
 If the skin is very soft, the melon is over-ripe. 
 Watermelons should sound hollow when tapped and have a bright, firm flesh with no woodiness. 
 To ripen melons, keep them at room temperature for a few days, when ripe store in the fridge and eat as soon as possible. 
 Honeydew melons ripen slowly and will often keep up to a month, but smaller varieties will take less time to ripen. 
 Serving melons However you serve them, always take melon out of the fridge half an hour before serving, or it will be very bland and tasteless. 
 If you do not want to scent everything in your refrigerator, keep any ripe melons in a tightly closed plastic bag.  
 KITCHEN NOTES 
 News, views and recipe ideas for you each week 
 Ice cream with a touch of luxury 
 Did you know that ice cream can be one of the lower calorie desserts? 
 Slimmers, when tempted by the sweet section of a menu should go for the vanilla ice cream &mdash; at around 130 cals a scoop, it beats a wedge of cheesecake (260 cals). 
 But for a special treat indulge yourself with one of these luxury flavours: English toffee, pecan, Dutch chocolate, strawberry, vanilla and even clotted cream vanilla all from the Cricket St Thomas range of ice creams. 
 Try this delicious quick dessert: unroll a bought chocolate swiss roll. 
 Spread with a layer of softened chocolate ice cream and some drained, chopped, canned cherries. 
 Decorate with whipped cream. 
 Summer Herbs 
 The flavour of herbs comes from essential oils in the leaves, stem and flowers. 
 These are released when heated or crushed. 
 Herbs are at their best when freshly picked. 
 If you need to keep them longer, rinse and pat dry and store them in a sealable container in the fridge. 
 Freeze in a sealed polythene bag, or hang bunches in an airy room until dry, then store in an airtight jar for six months. 
 Delicate herbs keep their flavour better when frozen. 
 Tougher herbs are better dried. 
 CHIVES 
 Known as &bquo;the little onion&equo;, this herb is best used raw in salad dressings, or added to dips and sauces, or to flavour savoury butter and egg dishes. 
 The dried equivalent is quite acceptable. 
 BASIL 
 A strongly flavoured herb, used by the Italians, who add it to their tomato-based recipes. 
 It has a strong aroma and pungent, but slightly sweet taste and is suitable for freezing and drying. 
 It adds a delicious flavour when used fresh in salads, or with lamb or summer vegetables. 
 CHERVIL 
 Used a lot in French cooking, chervil has a delicate, sweet flavour and blends perfectly with fish, chicken, eggs, cheese and many fresh vegetable dishes. 
 DILL 
 This slender, feathery herb bears a strong resemblance to fennel. 
 The leaves have a distinctive aniseed flavour and are also known as &bquo;dill weed&equo;. 
 Both leaves and seeds may be used to give a mild, slightly sweet flavour to foods. 
 Dill is traditionally used in many fish dishes, or as a flavouring for vinegars, fresh vegetables, mayonnaise and dressings. 
 CORIANDER 
 This is mainly grown for its spicy seeds, an essential ingredient in Indian dishes. 
 The leaves are used in Middle Eastern and Greek cooking for their slightly spicy flavour and pungent scent. 
 Coriander is now widely used in similar ways to parsley &mdash; as a garnish, or sparingly in meat dishes. 
 ON OFFER 
 Low caffeine tea 
 Lovers of a good strong cuppa may be interested to know that there may be more caffeine in a cup of tea than in a cup of coffee. 
 But there is no need to feel discouraged, because there are low caffeine drinks available in the shops &mdash; like these PG tea bags that contain only one third of the normal caffeine content. 
 Here's your chance to sample them. 
 The first 750 readers to send name and address on a postcard to best  /PG Low Caffeine offer,  will each receive a free pack of 40 tea bags. 
 QUICK 4 SANDWICH IDEAS 
 Try these fun-packed ideas for a super Bank Holiday picnic 
 Ni&ccedil;oise baguette 
 Slice a French stick in half lengthways and brush the bread with olive oil. 
 Fill it with a mixture of lettuce, tomatoes, pickled cucumbers, spring onions, tuna fish, hard-boiled eggs and some pitted black olives. 
 Pastrami on rye 
 Butter sliced dark rye bread and spread thinly with mustard. 
 Fill with pastrami (a highly seasoned smoked beef) and watercress. 
 If pastrami is too strong a flavour for your taste, then use roast beef or ham instead. 
 Pitta pocket 
 Slice wholemeal or white pitta bread and fill with cooked chicken, flat-leaved parsley, sliced tomatoes, lettuce, sliced onions and hummus &mdash; a Greek chickpea dip available from most large supermarkets and delicatessens. 
 Italian salad roll 
 Fill a halved ciabatta roll (these are now available from many supermarkets) or a crusty roll with some salami, lettuce and sliced red or green peppers. 
 Drizzle a little vinaigrette dressing over the salad. 
 and even more&hellip; 
 Sliced avocado, mozzarella cheese and tomato, with fresh basil leaves or pesto sauce in lightly buttered soft grain bread. 
 A long hoagie roll or short French stick split lengthways and filled with lettuce, turkey or ham, mustard, cheese and coleslaw. 
 Chopped, cooked chicken, sliced mushrooms and mayonnaise in a soft bap. 
 Granary bread spread with cream cheese, then topped with well-drained pineapple chunks, sliced bananas or chopped dates, plus walnuts or sultanas. 
 Tip: Always dry lettuce carefully when using it as a filling to prevent sandwiches going soggy.  
 Midweek Meal 
 Cut out recipes and keep in plastic folders 
 Barbecue spare ribs 
 A really cheap main course that's finger-licking good 
 Serves 4 
 1 onion, finely chopped 
 1 clove garlic, crushed 
 60ml (4 tbsp) red wine vinegar 
 45ml (3 tbsp) clear honey 
 60ml (4 tbsp) tomato ketchup 
 30ml (2 tbsp) soy sauce 
 10ml (2tsp) Worcestershire sauce 
 197g (7oz) can chopped tomatoes 
 5ml (1 tsp) French mustard 
 8&ndash;12 pork spare ribs 
 salt and freshly ground black pepper 
 1 bunch spring onions, 
 lemon wedges, to serve 
 METHOD 
 Place onion and garlic in a large jug. 
 Add the red wine vinegar, clear honey, tomato ketchup, soy sauce, Worcestershire sauce, canned tomatoes and French mustard, then stir well to mix. 
 Trim spare ribs of any excess fat, then place in a large roasting tin. 
 Season generously with salt and freshly ground black pepper. 
 Pour the barbecue sauce over the spare ribs. 
 Toss ribs in sauce until completely coated. 
 Cook for 30 minutes, then turn ribs and coat in the sauce again. 
 Cook for a further 20&ndash;30 minutes, cover with foil and cook for 15 minutes. 
 Trim spring onions and slice diagonally. 
 Place ribs in serving dish, garnished with spring onions and wedges of lemons. 
 Watercress, celery and tomato salad 
 Quick and easy to prepare and nutritious, too! 
 Serves 4 
 For the salad: 
 1 head celery 
 1 bunch watercress 
 100g (4oz) button mushrooms 
 100g (4oz) cherry tomatoes 
 For the dressing: 
 60ml (4 tbsp) olive oil 
 30ml (2 tbsp) white wine vinegar 
 10ml (1 tsp) Dijon mustard 
 pinch of sugar 
 salt and freshly ground black pepper 
 METHOD 
 Trim celery (keeping leaves intact) and wash thoroughly. 
 Cut into 2.5cm (1&ins;) lengths. 
 Place in salad serving bowl. 
 Trim off watercress stalks, rinse and place in serving bowl. 
 Trim off the mushroom stalks and wipe mushrooms with kitchen paper. 
 Cut in half and add to bowl. 
 Remove tomato stalks, rinse and halve. 
 Add to bowl and toss salad ingredients together gently. 
 To make the dressing: place olive oil, vinegar, mustard, sugar, salt and freshly ground black pepper in a screwtop jar. 
 Shake vigorously to mix and pour over salad just before serving. 
 Toss salad gently to serve.  
 best  tip Never rinse mushrooms under cold running water to clean them &mdash; they will go soggy. 
 All you need to do is to wipe them with absorbent paper. 
 Potato skins and dip 
 These make a tasty change to chips or jacket potatoes 
 Serves 4 
 For the potato skins: 
 6 large baking potatoes 
 15ml (1 tbsp) olive oil 
 salt 
 oil for deep frying 
 For the dips: 
 300ml (&frac12;pt) soured cream 
 1 bunch freshly chopped chives or 30ml (2 tbsp) dried )  
 salt and freshly ground black pepper 
 10ml (2 tsp) tomato ketchup 
 2 tomatoes, chopped 
 1 small green pepper, de-seeded and chopped 
 flat-leaf parsley, to garnish (optional) 
 METHOD 
 Preheat oven to 200&deg;C (400&deg;F, gas 6). 
 Wash potatoes to remove any excess dirt. 
 Rub a little olive oil over each and sprinkle with a little salt. 
 Wrap each potato in foil and bake for 1hr 5mins until just tender 
 Place oil in deep fat fryer. 
 Meanwhile, make the dips: place half the soured cream in a small bowl, and stir in most of the chives, reserving a few for garnish. 
 Season. 
 In another bowl mix the remaining soured cream with ketchup and tomatoes. 
 Season generously. 
 Stir in most of the chopped pepper, reserving some for garnish. 
 Heat oil in deep fat fryer to 190&deg;C (375&deg;F). 
 Remove potatoes from oven, take out of foil and cut into quarters lengthways. 
 Scoop out most of the potato, leaving the skin and a layer of potato, to form a boat shape. 
 Fry 5&ndash;6 skins at a time, for 1&ndash;2 mins, and drain on absorbent kitchen paper before serving. 
 Place dips in serving dishes. 
 Garnish soured cream and chive dip with chives and sprinkle chopped peppers over tomato dip. 
 Garnish skins with parsley, if using. 
 Cherry ice cream sundae 
 Treat yourself to this cool and extravagant dessert 
 Serves 4 
 300ml (&frac12;pt) whipping cream 
 397g (14oz) can red cherry pie filling 
 8 scoops vanilla ice cream 
 60ml (4 tbsp) chocolate sauce 
 4 strawberries, sliced 
 METHOD 
 Gently whip cream until softly peaking. 
 Do not overwhip it or it will begin to separate. 
 Spoon 30ml (2 tbsp) cherry pie filling into the base of 4 tall, sundae-style glasses. 
 Add a scoop of vanilla ice cream to each glass, then spoon or pipe on 30ml (2 tbsp) of the whipped cream 
 Top with 45ml (3 tbsp) cherry pie filling, then add another scoop of ice-cream and a big dollop of cream. 
 Drizzle over the chocolate sauce and top with the sliced strawberries. 
 Serve immediately. 
 COOK'S CLASS 
 Step-by-step TANGY MADEIRA CAKE 
 Moist, delicious and simple to make, this orange Madeira cake is drenched in a warm honey syrup after baking. 
 Store the loaf in a cake tin and slice it when needed &mdash; it keeps well for up to one week 
 Preparation: 20 mins 
 Cooking: 1 hour 
 For the cake: 
 175g (6oz) butter 
 175 (6oz) caster sugar 
 3 eggs, lightly beaten 
 100g (4oz) plain flour 
 100g (4oz) self-raising flour 
 pinch of salt 
 2&ndash;3 tbsp freshly squeezed orange juice 
 15ml (1 tbsp) orange rind, grated 
 For the syrup: 
 freshly squeezed juice of 1 orange 
 15ml (1 tbsp) orange rind, finely grated 
 45ml (3 tbsp) clear honey or golden syrup 
 15ml (1 tbsp) Cointreau, Grand Marnier or any other orange liqueur (optional) 
 FREEZING: Wrap in foil or freeze slices in polythene bags for up to 3 months. 
 MICROWAVE: Not suitable. 
 STEP 1 
 Grease and base line a 900g (2lb) loaf tin with baking parchment. 
 Preheat the oven to 180&deg;C (350&deg; F, Gas 4). 
 Using a large electric balloon whisk or hand-held electric whisk cream the butter and sugar together until really light and fluffy. 
 Then whisk in the beaten egg gradually, adding a teaspoon of flour with each addition to stop curdling. 
 Tip: If it does curdle add a little more flour and whisk again. 
 STEP 2 
 Sift the plain and self-raising flours and salt together onto a plate, then sift again directly into the creamed butter and sugar mixture. 
 Gently fold the flour into the mixture with the orange juice and rind. 
 Tip: To fold flour in use a large metal spoon in a figure-of-eight motion, as gently as possible, to prevent knocking out any of the air. 
 (Double sifting of the flour traps more air and helps make the cake lighter). 
 STEP 3 
 Spoon the mixture into the prepared tin and spread it level on top using a flat-bladed knife. 
 Bake in the centre of the oven for approximately 1 hour until golden brown and risen. 
 Test the centre with a warmed metal skewer &mdash; it should come out cleanly, with no cake mixture or crumbs sticking to it. 
 The cake should also feel springy to the touch. 
 Tip: Do not overcook cake as it will dry out while cooling in tin. 
 STEP 4 
 Place freshly squeezed orange juice and rind, clear honey or syrup and alcohol in a large saucepan and heat gently until honey has dissolved. 
 Remove the mixture from heat. 
 Remove cooked cake from oven and leave the cake in the tin. 
 Pierce small holes on top with a fine skewer. 
 Pour the syrup over the warm cake and leave until completely cold and all the syrup has been absorbed. 
 Cook's note 
 If you fancy adding some cherries to your cake for a fruity change, make sure, when using glac&eacute; cherries, that you rinse and dry them thoroughly with kitchen paper before folding into the cake mixture. 
 You could also add drained, pitted canned cherries. 
 Toss these in a little flour before folding into the mixture. 
 This will ensure that they don't sink to the bottom during cooking. 
 Vary the flavour 
 Instead of oranges, try the following: 
 Lemon  Use lemons in the basic mixture and syrup. 
 Vanilla  Add 5ml (1 tsp) vanilla essence and 45ml (3 tbsp) milk to the basic mixture and omit the syrup. 
 Cherry &amp; Kirsch  Add 50g (2oz) washed and dried glac&eacute; cherries, and 45ml (3 tbsp) milk to basic mixture. 
 Sprinkle with 30ml (2 tbsp) Kirsch instead of syrup.  
 ANIMAL WORLD 
 by David Alderton 
 AT HOME IN THE WILD 
 Encouraging BUTTERFLIES into your garden 
 You can convert your garden into a butterfly haven by simply growing a small nettle patch and planting a few special flowers 
 Stinging nettles are the most natural breeding ground for some of our prettiest butterflies. 
 So if you have any growing in a corner of your garden, cut some of them down now and by July there will be fresh growth for butterflies to lay their eggs on. 
 The peacock, red admiral and small tortoiseshell all lay their eggs on nettles and the young caterpillars feed on the fresh new leaves. 
 Butterflies feed on nectar collected from flowers and among their favourites are buddleia and sedum. 
 Try to plan your garden so that there are flowers with energy-giving nectar available right into the autumn. 
 Michaelmas daisies, which flower as late as October, are a good source of nectar for peacocks and tortoiseshells that need to build themselves up before hibernating for the winter. 
 The red admiral and painted lady also need to gather their strength ready for the hazardous journey back to southern Europe and North Africa. 
 For the spring, the pink/purple aubretia flowers are popular among butterflies emerging from hibernation, as are yellow wallflowers. 
 Breeding 
 Why not breed caterpillars and release the butterflies into the garden? 
 Purchase eggs, larvae, pupae and breeding cages from entomological suppliers. 
 For a brochure, send sae to Butterfly Farm (Christchurch), 6 Westwoods, Box Road, Bathford, Bath.  
 You can rear caterpillars and release butterflies, like this peacock, into your garden, provided you offer adequate feeding sites such as a bed of nettles 
 OUR EXPERT REPLIES 
 My new pair of peach-faced lovebirds produced a clutch of 10 eggs, but none of them has hatched. 
 Why is this? 
 Almost certainly because you have two laying hens rather than a pair! 
 They are impossible to sex by sight, but their average clutch size is less than six eggs. 
 You can check if they are fertile by holding each egg in front of a bright light. 
 If the light passes through the egg, it is infertile. 
 Try to swap one of the hens for a proven cock. 
 Which mammal has the shortest life-span in the wild? 
 Evidence suggests that shrews probably have the shortest lives. 
 The European common shrew, found throughout Britain but not in Ireland, lives for less than a year. 
 They breed equally rapidly, producing litters of up to 10 and can have three or four litters during their brief lives, so they're among the most prolific, as well. 
 REVIEWS 
 CINEMA 
 The Hard Way 
 A comedy double-act between the lean, nervy, James Woods and the cheeky, chubby Michael J Fox. 
 Woods plays an explosive but repressed Manhattan cop, with Fox as a Hollywood matin&eacute;e idol who decides to shadow him by way of research for a tougher kind of cinematic role. 
 On the surface their pact is simple enough &mdash; Fox willingly teaches Woods about women, and Woods reluctantly teaches Fox about policing. 
 But their relationship frequently founders, amid much hilarity, on the rocks of the cop's cynicism of silver screen glitz and the actor's naivet&eacute; about the tough world of crime. 
 This is a noisy, rumbustious film that's prone to burying itself in hails of gunshots and sheets of flame. 
 But director John Badham keeps up the momentum successfully, carrying the action all the way to an improbably happy end. 
 Over Her Dead Body 
 Comedy thriller with Judge Reinhold and Elizabeth Perkins as murderous lovers who won't let a corpse stand in their way. 
 But although Enid's dead she just won't lie down, and has an uncanny knack of making her presence felt at the most inconvenient times. 
  Rozencrantz  and Guildenstern are Dead 
 Hamlet , one of Shakespeare's best known tragedies, is transformed into slapstick comedy in this film version of Tom Stoppard's popular play. 
 Turning the original classic topsy-turvy, Stoppard makes Hamlet himself take a back seat and elevates two minor characters to star status. 
 VIDEO 
 Cadillac Man 
 &bquo;If you don't laugh, you'll cry&equo; is Robin Williams' motto in this humorous and very human film about Joey, a car salesman who can't resist making a sale, even at a funeral. 
 Joey's used to dealing with difficult customers, but when he comes face to face with a gun-toting angry young man, it takes all his soothing charm to save the day. 
 Frightening, frenzied and funny by turn, this makes you less quick to dismiss salesmen as selfish and sly. 
 She Said No 
 Courtroom drama. 
 A rapist (Judd Hirsch) sues his victim (Veronica Hamel) for libel. 
 Plot similar to The Accused  but no less disturbing. 
 MUSIC 
 Intro 
 JJ 
 This musical duo hail from Manchester and take their name from vocalist Jan Johnston. 
 Their debut album provides a fine introduction to a pair who avoid grand production techniques, preferring clear vocals, a good tune and simple accompaniments. 
 Jan's pure voice rings out on quiet tracks such as Denim , Blue  and Going Nowhere , accompanied either by fellow songwriter Tony Kirkham on acoustic guitar or by herself on piano. 
 The more poppy numbers such as Come Back Baby  and Slide Away  have a fuller sound with the addition of violin and drums. 
 JJ's music is like a breath of fresh air. 
 It may not be very profound, but it is supremely satisfying. 
 BOOKS 
 Meridon by Philippa Gregory 
 Meridon is a gypsy child who dreams of clean clothes and big houses. 
 Little does she know she's really Sarah, last of the aristocratic Laceys, given to the gypsies at birth. 
 A runaway horse takes her to her ancestral home, and her past unfolds. 
 Torn between high society and the life of the workers on the estate, she makes many mistakes before seeing the truth. 
 Short-listed for this year's romantic fiction award. 
 (Penguin, &pound;4.99)  
 Joy by Marsha Hunt 
 (Arrow, &pound;4.99) . 
 Brilliant story of three sisters who are determined to be famous but are dogged by tragedy. 
 Maggie Jordan by Emma Blair 
 (Bantam, &pound;4.99) . 
 Love and politics clash when Maggie falls for a hard-hearted soldier.  
 James Woods finds it hard to hang on to his sanity in this comic role 
 Salesman Joey sweet-talks his trickiest customer 
 Jan and Tony keep it simple with some refreshing results 
 TRAVEL 
 LEEDS 
 A green and pleasant city 
 No longer industrial and grimy, this Northern metropolis is packed with culture and history. 
 By Ruth Ling 
 Since the early 70s, the local council of Yorkshire's largest industrial city has been cleaning up its act. 
 It has sandblasted 100 years of black soot off Leeds' fine civic buildings to reveal the pale sandstone underneath, turned much of the city centre into a traffic-free pedestrian zone and made their old manufacturing mills into museums. 
 The council has also built a new art gallery dedicated to local sculptor, Henry Moore, put in an Olympic-sized pool and demolished the squalid 30s housing estate which had been planned as the largest in Europe &mdash; in its place stands the brand new West Yorkshire Playhouse. 
 Add to all that the claim that Leeds has more parkland than any other city in Britain, plus a wealth of historical architecture which dates back to 1152, and it's hardly surprising that England's third largest city is now fast becoming a very popular UK holiday destination. 
 Wander around the centre, and you could be forgiven for thinking that the whole of Leeds was built in Victorian days. 
 Its ornate Town Hall was completed in 1858 and was ceremonially opened by Queen Victoria herself, while the oval, glass-domed Corn Exchange was erected three years later. 
 These, and the many other fine Victorian buildings in the city, were paid for by the fortunes made in the 19th century in the wool manufacturing and tailoring trades. 
 But, outside the city centre, the architecture changes, especially with Kirkstall Abbey, the earliest surviving building in the area. 
 Cistercian monks arrived there in 1152 and built their large abbey in some remote fields close to the banks of the River Aire. 
 Today, the remarkably well-preserved ruins of the church, Abbot's House and Infirmary are set in an attractive, wooded park &mdash; though surrounded by an incongruous mass of streets and factories. 
 Adjacent to the monastery, in what used to be the Great Gate-house, is the Abbey House Museum with three reconstructed Victorian streets. 
 Just south of Kirkstall Abbey is Armley Mills, once the world's largest woolen mill. 
 It's now an award-winning industrial museum, and features a recreation of the city's Jewish tailoring quarter. 
 There's also an exhibition and 20s-style Picture Palace at Armley Mills on the early history of the movies because it was at nearby Leeds Bridge, in 1888, that the first moving images were made. 
 The event is marked by a plaque on the Museum of Leeds Trail, which links 40 historic sites in the city. 
 There are more moving images at Middleton, in south-east Leeds, where the world's first commercial railway was opened to carry truckloads of coal from Middleton Colliery to the city's mills. 
 Today, it's a museum with several vintage locomotives, and you can ride in an old train pulled by a steam engine. 
 As well as the railways, it was the Leeds and Liverpool Canal, completed in 1816, which put the city on the map. 
 These days, the Canal Basin bustles not with goods but with pleasure boats. 
 The locks and warehouses behind the City Station have been restored as Granary Wharf. 
 Here, beneath the Victorian vaulted brick arches, is the Arches Craft Arcade of 22 shops complete with outdoor markets and entertainment at weekends. 
 Leeds has always had a great market tradition: the original Penny Bazaar, forerunner of Marks &amp; Spencer, was founded in the city in 1884 by Michael Marks. 
 But perhaps the grandest shopping to be had in the area is at the Victoria Quarter. 
 It's a wonderfully decorative place: everywhere you look, there are marble columns, mosaics, mechanical tableau clocks, decorative  terracotta, wrought iron gates and fountains. 
 Steel columns support the vaulted, domed glass ceilings. 
 When you're footsore from walking the city streets, make a visit to Roundhay Park, with its landscaped gardens and woods and the Waterloo Lake, where you can hire a boat or go fishing. 
 Leeds City Council has made great provisions for handicapped people in all its buildings and public places, and at Roundhay Park there are scented gardens for the blind. 
 The park also hosts the Leeds Show and major pop concerts and has tennis courts, bowling and putting greens, a sports arena and a golf course. 
 Further afield, there are stately homes to visit, such as Harewood House and Temple Newsam. 
 Leeds is well-equipped for sports, with 21 golf courses and 22 sports and leisure centres, but if all this action leaves you feeling in need of a rest, you can always take yourself off to the theatre. 
 Leeds has four to choose from. 
 Most famous is the Leeds City Varieties, one of the oldest music halls in the country and home of BBC TV's The Good Old Days . 
 There's also the Grand Theatre, which hosts touring companies and is the permanent home of Opera North. 
 One of Yorkshire's famous sayings is &bquo;Where there's muck, there's brass&equo;. 
 And, while there may not be a lot of muck any more, there is still plenty of brass. 
 For, when it comes down to it, there's nothing to beat a brass band. 
 There's always one to be heard somewhere during the summer &mdash; in the piazza in front of the art gallery and Town Hall or in a park. 
 Whether it's the Police Band or one from a nearby mill town, there are fewer nicer ways to end a summer day in Leeds than to sit in a deckchair at sunset, listening to the haunting sound of the trumpets and trombones. 
 For further information contact the Tourist Information Centre,  
 Where to stay 
 Leeds has a variety of accommodation, from the modern four-star Ladbroke Dragonara and Hilton Hotels, close to the station, to homely B&amp;B guesthouses in the Headingley area, two miles from the the city centre, and university and college residences during the vacations. 
 For 30s elegance and personal service, there's the imposing Queen's Hotel, overlooking City Square, while the modern Merrion Hotel is convenient for nightclubs. 
 The Tourist Information Centre has full accommodation details. 
 Getting there 
 By road  The A1, M1, M621 and M62 are all within a five minute drive of the centre. 
 By rail  Intercity from all over the country. 
 By Coach  National Express to Leeds. 
 By air  Leeds&ndash;Bradford Airport is at Yeadon, seven miles west of Leeds. 
 Traditional fayre 
 Yorkshire is famous for its roast beef and Yorkshire pudding, and many of the city's top hotels have carveries specialising in this dish, such as the Ridings Roast Room at the Queen's Hotel. 
 Fish and chips are a Northern favourite and always fresh here, but for a real treat go to Harry Ramsden's at nearby Guiseley, said to be the largest fish and chip shop in the world &mdash; and, with its plush decor and chandeliers, a very chic chippie! 
 Leeds has some splendid pubs, such as Whitelocks, a pretty Edwardian tavern in a hidden yard off Briggate, which has magnificent old cut glass, tiles and mirrors. 
 The TIC can tell you about the local brewers Tetleys' Heritage Inns, including the 1,000-year-old Bingley Arms at Bardsey. 
 Don't forget to take some Yorkshire parkin home with you &mdash; this delicious dark gingerbread is available from any good cake shop!  
 For fish and chips with an upmarket flavour, visit Harry Ramsden's in Guiseley 
 The first moving images were made at Leeds Bridge 
 You can hire a boat or go fishing at Waterloo Lake 
 The City Square (left), is perfect for a rest after an afternoon's shopping in the pedestrianised centre, just a few minutes walk away. 
 Or there's Thornton's Arcade (above), one of several glass-roofed malls built by Edwardian theatre designer Frank Matcham at the turn of the century 
 Harewood House, a few miles north of Leeds, contains the richest collection of Chippendale furniture in the world 
 Have a city break 
 You don't have to go into the country to have a relaxing holiday 
 Fourteen cities are taking part in a campaign to attract more tourists. 
 Sixty hotels in places like Birmingham, Manchester and Swansea are offering two nights B&amp;B on any weekend this year from &pound;26 per person. 
 Telephone 0792 650891 for details. 
 Culture city 
 Following Glasgow last year, Dublin is European City of Culture 1991. 
 Highlights are Bloomsday, from June 16, when James Joyce is commemorated with readings and walking tours; an Irish street party on August 18, and the Dublin Theatre Festival on October 7&ndash;19. 
 Trusthouse Forte has two-night breaks in its Dublin International Hotel or Shelbourne Hotel - telephone 0345 500400 for details. 
 Brighter Birmingham 
 With the opening of the International Convention Centre the city hopes to put itself on the tourist map. 
 The Hippodrome Theatre is now the home of the Royal Ballet and the Alexandria Theatre boasts the D'Oyly Carte Opera Company. 
 Cadbury World at Bournville tells the story of chocolate and there's a collection of historic cars at nearby Autoworld. 
 &bquo;Warm-Hearted Weekends&equo; are being offered at a selection of hotels for &pound;22 or &pound;26 B&amp;B per night (tel 021-780 4321 for further information).  
 Highland dancing will mark Dundee's 800th anniversary 
 Visit the Royal Doulton Pottery in Stoke-on-Trent 
 Go on a &bquo;Grand Tour&equo; with British Heritage Tours (0244 344222). 
 In Portsmouth, for instance, you stay at the Hilton Hotel and visit HMS Victory (above and right) 
 5 MINUTE FICTION 
 Perfect alibi&hellip; 
 The evening class had been Amanda's way of escaping her boring husband for a few hours. 
 Now it offered her the chance to get away from him for ever&hellip; 
 By Geoff Gomme 
 Elation filled Amanda. 
 It was perfect. 
 So simple, she wondered why the idea hadn't occurred to her before. 
 A slight adjustment to the mower and &mdash; poof! 
 Goodbye George. 
 At first, like her many other activities, the home maintenance course at the Adult Education Centre had been just a desperate device to take her away from the boredom of George. 
 But tonight's lesson, dealing with electrical fittings, had been a revelation. 
 Tonight she'd seen the way to get rid of him for good. 
 As she walked the short distance home, the lecturer's words ran through her mind. 
 &bquo;Hundreds of people get killed every year using faulty domestic electrical appliances,&equo; he'd warned. 
 &bquo;Bad connections, damaged leads, incorrectly wired equipment are lethal. 
 That's why it's so important&hellip;&equo; 
 But that was when Amanda's attention had wandered. 
 She'd seen the possibilities at once. 
 All she had to do was cross a couple of wires and George would become just another victim of a tragic domestic &bquo;accident&equo;. 
 She knew there'd be no chance indoors &mdash; George never attempted even the smallest job about the house. 
 But there was one job he took pride in. 
 Every Saturday morning &mdash; weather permitting &mdash; he mowed the lawn. 
 And the mower was electric&hellip; 
 Amanda flung off her coat in the hall and walked briskly into the lounge. 
 There was George &mdash; dull, dreary George &mdash; sprawled full-length on the settee, his nose deep in a book as usual. 
 Amanda snorted. 
 &bquo;Huh! 
 Is that all you've done the whole evening &mdash; read?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mmm,&equo; George muttered, without looking up. 
 Amanda glared down at him. 
 How his eternal reading infuriated her. 
 Why she'd married him she couldn't imagine. 
 It hadn't taken her long to discover that they had nothing whatsoever in common. 
 He never wanted to go anywhere or do anything, while she craved excitement &mdash; a bit of sparkle in her life. 
 Well, after Saturday, she wouldn't have far to go to find it&hellip; 
 Dave Wise had moved in next door a month ago. 
 He was lively, witty and darkly handsome &mdash; the exact opposite of George. 
 The moment their eyes met, Amanda knew she wanted him. 
 She didn't doubt for one minute that the feeling was mutual. 
 They were two of a kind &mdash; extroverted and fun-loving. 
 Unfortunately, he was also married. 
 Not that his mousey little wife was any match for her own looks and personality, Amanda thought contemptuously. 
 She was almost as boring as George. 
 Amanda stalked into the kitchen and plugged in the kettle. 
 &bquo;Coffee?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes please, dear.&equo; 
 Astonishing how acute his hearing could be where his stomach was concerned. 
 She carried the two steaming mugs into the lounge, setting one down near George's elbow. 
 Without lifting his eyes from the book he was reading he groped with his hand to find it. 
 Amanda watched. 
 How many times had she watched him do that? 
 And how many times had she thought how easy it would be to poison him? 
 But she'd always rejected the idea. 
 Poison was too easily detected. 
 No, she thought grimly, what she'd learned tonight was a much better way. 
 Amanda sipped her coffee, letting her mind dwell pleasurably on thoughts of the future. 
 Saturday was fine and sunny. 
 Amanda beamed &mdash; now George had no excuse for not mowing the lawn. 
 Still, it was best to make sure. 
 &bquo;The grass is a bit long, will you be mowing it this morning, George?&equo; 
 George looked up irritably from his bacon and eggs. 
 &bquo;Don't I always?&equo; he snapped. 
 &bquo;What makes you ask?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just wondered, dear,&hellip;&equo; 
 George seemed bad-tempered this morning &mdash; unusual for him, she thought. 
 In the hall she chose the prettiest coat she had. 
 It seemed to match her mood. 
 &bquo;I'm helping to set out the stalls for the hospital bazaar &mdash; should be back about midday,&equo; she called, as she let herself out of the house. 
 By 10 minutes to 12 everything was ready for the bazaar, so Amanda set out for home, tingling with a mixture of excitement and fear. 
 Had &bquo;it&equo; happened yet? 
 Suppose George wasn't dead, only injured? 
 Suppose someone had seen her yesterday, tinkering with the mower? 
 Suppose&hellip;? 
 But it was no use imagining; in a few minutes she would know everything. 
 As she turned the corner into Perry Street her heart began to pound. 
 Outside No 26 a crowd had gathered. 
 At the kerb-side stood an ambulance and a police car. 
 It had worked! 
 She had done it. 
 George was dead. 
 She was free. 
 Now everything was hers: the house, George's savings. 
 And Dave. 
 Two ambulance-men crossed the pavement, carrying a stretcher. 
 On it was a blanket-covered figure. 
 It had to be George. 
 As she drew closer, a burly, red-faced police sergeant detached himself from the crowd and moved towards her, notebook in hand. 
 &bquo;Mrs Atkins?&equo; 
 Amanda clapped her hand to her heart. 
 &bquo;My God! 
 George. 
 Is &mdash; is he&hellip;?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't worry, Mrs Atkins, your husband is alive and perfectly well.&equo; 
 &bquo;Alive?&equo; 
 Her dismay showed all too plainly on her face. 
 &bquo;But then, who&hellip;?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm afraid the man who died was your neighbour, Mr David Wise.&equo; 
 Dave? 
 Amanda stared open-mouthed at the sergeant, her knees suddenly weak. 
 &bquo;Your husband was very lucky. 
 Your neighbour's car wouldn't start, so he offered to take Mrs Wise in his if Mr Wise mowed his lawn&hellip;&equo; 
 Amanda began to shake uncontrollably. 
 Suddenly she felt sick. 
 She'd killed the wrong man! 
 Through her daze she slowly became aware of the sergeant's voice. 
 &bquo;&hellip; found that someone has tampered with the wiring of the mower. 
 It's too obvious to be accidental. 
 Perhaps you could shed some light on that, Mrs Atkins&hellip;?&equo; 
 The way he was looking at her, it was obvious he knew the truth. 
 &bquo;No, no, no!&equo; 
 Amanda tried to scream, but no sound came from her parched throat. 
 The sergeant's face was cold. 
 &bquo;Nevertheless, Mrs Atkins, I would appreciate it if you could answer a few questions down at the station&hellip;&equo; 
 George and Penny watched the scene through the window of No 28, their hands tightly entwined. 
 &bquo;Well, darling,&equo; George murmured. 
 &bquo;Everything's worked out well for us &mdash; thanks to you spotting Amanda fiddling with the mower.&equo; 
 Penny snuggled closer. 
 &bquo;You were the clever one &mdash; fixing our car so that it wouldn't start.&equo; 
 George chuckled. 
 &bquo;That was easy. 
 The tricky part was the mower. 
 The way Amanda had it rigged, it wouldn't have killed a sparrow&hellip;&equo;  
 If you'd like to submit to the fiction page, please send your manuscripts (1,400 words approx) to the Fiction Editor at the address on page 3 in April or October only. 
 Jack Pertwee was getting married in the morning and the Kingsmarkham and District Darts Club were in the Dragon to give him what George Carter called a send-off. 
 &bquo;I don't like the sound of that, George,&equo; said Jack. 
 &bquo;I'm getting married, not buried.&equo; 
 &bquo;It comes to the same thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thanks very much. 
 I'll buy you another drink for that.&equo; 
 He moved up to the bar but the darts club chairman intercepted him. 
 &bquo;My round, Jack. 
 Don't you take any notice of George. 
 Marilyn's a lovely girl and you're a lucky man. 
 I know I speak for us all when I say there's no one here who wouldn't like to be in your shoes tomorrow.&equo; 
 &bquo;His pyjamas more like,&equo; said George. 
 &bquo;You ought to see them. 
 Black nylon they are with a karate top. 
 Cor!&equo; 
 &bquo;Keep the party clean, George.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's it to be then, gentlemen?&equo; said the barman patiently. 
 &bquo;Same again, Bill, and have one yourself. 
 No, Jack, man is a monogamous animal and there's no partnership on earth to touch a happy marriage. 
 Especially when you're starting off on the right foot like you and Marilyn. 
 Bit of money in the Post Office, nice little flat and nothing to reproach yourselves with.&equo; 
 &bquo;You reckon?&equo; 
 Jack was in a hurry to gloss over that right foot and reproaching stuff. 
 The chairman's homily called to mind the short &mdash; but too long &mdash; talk he and Marilyn had suffered two days before in the vicar's study. 
 He downed his beer, looking around him uncomfortably. 
 &bquo;The first ten years are the worst,&equo; he heard someone say, and he turned, suddenly nettled. 
 &bquo;Well, damn it,&equo; he said, &bquo;you are a bloody cheerful mob. 
 I notice it's the bachelors who don't have a good word to say for marriage.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right,&equo; the chairman concurred. 
 &bquo;Pity there aren't a few more husbands to back me up, eh, Jack? 
 Charlie Hatton now. 
 There's an ux-ux-what's the word I want?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't ask me. 
 What the hell does it matter, anyway? 
 You and your words. 
 This is supposed to be a stag party, not an annual general meeting. 
 What we need is someone to liven things up.&equo; 
 &bquo;Like Charlie. 
 Where d'you reckon he's got to?&equo; 
 &bquo;He said he'd be late. 
 He's bringing the lorry down from Leeds.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe he's gone home first.&equo; 
 &bquo;He wouldn't do that. 
 The last thing he said to me on Wednesday,&equo; Jack&equo;&equo; he said, &bquo;I'll get along to your rave-up on Friday even if I have to knock the guts out of her. 
 I've told Lilian to expect me when she sees me.&equo; 
 No, he'll come here first all right.&equo; 
 &bquo;I hope nothing's happened to him, that's all.&equo; 
 &bquo;Like what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, he's had that lorry hi-jacked twice, hasn't he?&equo; 
 &bquo;Bloody old woman you are, George,&equo; said Jack, but he too had begun to feel uneasy. 
 It was nine-thirty, only an hour to go before the Dragon closed. 
 Charlie was going to be his best man. 
 Marvellous wedding he'd have if they found his best man at midnight somewhere in the Midlands with his head bashed in. 
 &bquo;Drink up,&equo; said the darts club wit, &bquo;and I'll tell you the one about the girl who married the sailor.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've heard it,&equo; Jack said dolefully. 
 &bquo;Not this one you haven't. 
 Same again, please, Bill. 
 There was this girl, you see, and the night before she got married her mother said, &bquo;Now whatever you do, don't let him&hellip;&equo;&equo; 
 &bquo;Hold your horses, mate. 
 Here's Charlie now.&equo; 
 They were all big men, topping six feet, but Charlie Hatton was a little fellow with a brown face and very brilliant sharp eyes. 
 They flashed quickly and calculatingly over the assembled company before Charlie smiled. 
 He showed a setof perfect white teeth which no one there but Jack knew were false. 
 Charlie was sensitive about having false teeth at thirty &mdash; why hadn't all that wartime milk and orange juice set him up for life as it had his contemporaries? &mdash; but he didn't mind Jack knowing. 
 He didn't mind what Jack knew about him, within reason, that is, although he had ceased to confide in him as absolutely as he had in the days when they passed through Kingsmarkham Primary School together. 
 They were friends. 
 In another age and another society it might have been said that they loved each other. 
 They were as David and Jonathan, but if anyone had hinted such Jack would have poked him on the nose, and as for Charlie&hellip; 
 The drinkers in the Dragon all privately and rather proudly believed that Charlie was capable of anything. 
 Marilyn Thompson was Charlie's wife's best friend; Charlie was to be Jack's best man and one day he thought he would be godfather to Jack's first child. 
 Many a time they had drunk thus together, as boys, as youths, as men, and come out under the same starlit sky to walk beside each other up the familiar High Street where every house was a landmark and every face part of a shared history. 
 There might have been no one else in the pub tonight but the two of them. 
 The others were but background and audience. 
 Jack was passing through a door tonight, dying a little, and as always Charlie would die with him too. 
 If these emotions stirred under the stubbly balding crown, Charlie showed none of them. 
 His grin wide, he slapped Jack on the back and peered six inches up into the bridegroom's handsome red face. 
 &bquo;I made it then, me old mate. 
 My brother Jonathan, very pleasant hast thou been unto me; thy love to me was wonderful, passing the love of women&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I reckoned you would,&equo; said Jack and his heart was filled with joy. 
 &bquo;I'd have had it in properly for you if you hadn't. 
 What're you going to have?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not that gnat's piss, for a start. 
 Eleven bloody hours I've driven today. 
 You're a mean devil if you can't run to scotch, Jack.&equo; 
 &bquo;Give me a chance, I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Put it away. 
 It's only my fun, you know me. 
 Seven doubles, Bill, and you needn't look like that. 
 No wonder they reckon the beer's on the turn in here. 
 I've taken the lorry back to the depot and I'm walking home if that's what's worrying you. 
 Happy days, Jack, and may all your troubles be little ones!&equo; 
 Charlie had opened his wallet with a flourish, taking care that its contents were visible to all the patrons of the bar. 
 His pay packet was there unopened and he didn't open it now but paid for his round from a wad of notes held together with an elastic band. 
 It was a thick wad and although most of the notes were green, some were blue. 
 &bquo;How the rich live,&equo; said George Carter. 
 &bquo;You want to make something of it, do you?&equo; 
 &bquo;No need to get touchy with me, mate. 
 I must want my head tested sorting mail all day when I could be picking up wads of it on the lorries.&equo; 
 &bquo;You ought to know. 
 It's your bloody head. 
 Take it along to a trick cyclist if it bothers you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Break it up,&equo; said the club wit. 
 &bquo;I was just telling you about this girl and what her mother said on the night before she got married to the sailor.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who got married?&equo; said Charlie. 
 &bquo;Her mother? 
 Bit late in the day for that, wasn't it? 
 OK, mate, it's only my fun, but Jack and me heard that one our last term at school. 
 And the sailor said,&equo; Have it your own way but if we don't we'll never have kids.&equo; 
 Right? 
 That the pay-off?&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you and good night.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be like that,&equo; said Jack. 
 Charlie had a knack for rubbing people up the wrong way. 
 Funny he never fell foul of him. 
 &bquo;My round, I think.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can't have that, Jack. 
 Seven more doubles, Bill. 
 Jack, I said put it away. 
 I can afford it. 
 There's plenty more where that came from. 
 I come in late, didn't I, so I've got lee-way to make up?&equo; 
 &bquo;No more for me,&equo; said the man whose joke Charlie had spoiled. 
 He patted Jack's shoulder and said good night while the others drank their whisky in an awkward silence. 
 &bquo;Last orders, gentlemen, please,&equo; said the barman. 
 George Carter dipped his hand into his pocket and brought out some small silver. 
 &bquo;One for the road then, Jack?&equo; 
 Charlie looked at the little coins. 
 &bquo;What's that? 
 Your missus's housekeeping?&equo; 
 George flushed. 
 He wasn't married; Charlie knew he wasn't married; knew moreover that his steady had chucked him two weeks before. 
 George had got the deposit ready for a house and made the first down payment on a dining suite. 
 &bquo;You bastard,&equo; he said. 
 Charlie bristled at him, a smart little fighting cock. 
 &bquo;Nobody calls me a bastard.&equo; 
 &bquo;Gentlemen, gentlemen,&equo; said the barman. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said the chairman, &bquo;pack it in. 
 Talk about folks being touchy, Charlie. 
 No wonder they're touchy when you pick on them the way you do.&equo; 
 He smiled breezily, struck an orator's attitude. 
 &bquo;Now the evening's drawing to a close, and I reckon we ought to take the opportunity of conveying to Jack here the heartiest good wishes of the Kingsmarkham and District Darts Club. 
 I for one&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll take it as said, then, shall we?&equo; said Charlie. 
 &bquo;A hearty vote of thanks for the chairman.&equo; 
 He put another fiver on the counter. 
 As rude as George had been, the chairman shrugged and gave Jack a nod which was meaningful and sympathetic but which Jack ignored. 
 Then he went, taking another man with him. 
 The barman wiped the counter in silence. 
 Charlie Hatton had always been cocky but in the past weeks he'd become insufferable and most of the meetings had broken up like this. 
 Of the stag party now only Jack, Charlie, George and one other remained. 
 He was a lorry driver like Charlie, his name was Maurice Cullam and until now he had scarcely opened his mouth except to pour alcohol down it. 
 Now, having witnessed the rout and ignominy of his friends, he took his last drink and said: 
 &bquo;Been seeing much of McCloy lately, Charlie?&equo; 
 Charlie made no reply and it was Jack who said, &bquo;Why, have you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not me, Jack. 
 I keep my hands clean. 
 Money's not everything. 
 I like to sleep quiet in my bed.&equo; 
 Instead of the expected explosion, Charlie said softly and mildly &bquo;Time you slept for a change.&equo; 
 Maurice had five children born in six years. 
 Charlie's crack could be taken as a compliment and as such, to the relief of George and Jack, Maurice took it. 
 He smiled sheepishly at this tribute to his virility. 
 Considering Maurice's wife was an exceptionally plain woman, there were a good many ripostes Charlie could have made, ripostes which might have been transparently insulting. 
 Instead he had chosen to flatter. 
 &bquo;Time, gentlemen,&equo; said the barman. 
 &bquo;Here's wishing you all you wish yourself, Mr Pertwee.&equo; 
 The barman usually called Jack by his Christian name and Jack knew &bquo;Mr Pertwee&equo; was a mark never to be repeated, of the respect due to a bridegroom. 
 &bquo;Thanks a lot,&equo; he said, &bquo;and for a grand evening. 
 Ill be seeing you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let's be toddling, Jack,&equo; said Charlie, and he tucked his fat wallet away. 
 The air was soft and mild and the sky scattered with many stars. 
 Orion rode above them, his belt crossed by a wrack of midsummer cloud. 
 &bquo;Lovely night,&equo; said Charlie. 
 &bquo;Going to be a fine day tomorrow, Jack.&equo; 
 &bquo;You think?&equo; 
 &bquo;Happy is the bride that the sun shines on.&equo; 
 Drink had made George sentimental and he turned his mouth down lugubriously as he remembered his steady and the down payment on the furniture. 
 &bquo;You have a good cry, mate,&equo; said Charlie. 
 &bquo;Nothing like a bit of a weep to make a girl feel better.&equo; 
 George led the Kingsmarkham group of Morris dancers and in the past Charlie had fripped him when he appeared in his motley suit, his cap and bells. 
 He bit his lip, clenching his fists. 
 Then he shrugged and turned away. 
 Get stuffed,&equo; he muttered. 
 The others watched him cross the road and make his unsteady way down York Street. 
 Jack raised one hand in a feeble salute. 
 &bquo;You shouldn't have said that, Charlie.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, he makes me sick. 
 Let's have a bit of a sing-song then, shall we?&equo; 
 He put one arm around Jack's waist and the other, after a barely discernible pause, around Maurice's. 
 &bquo;One of them old music-hall ballads of yours, Charlie.&equo; 
 They meandered along under the old overhanging house fronts and Jack had to duck his head to avoid cracking it on a lamp in an iron cage. 
 Charlie cleared his throat and sang: 
 'Mabel dear, listen here! 
 There's robbery in the park. 
 I sat alone in the YMCA, 
 Singing just like a lark &mdash; 
 There's no place like ho-ome, 
 But I couldn't go home in the dark!&equo; 
 &bquo;Yoo-hoo!&equo; yelled Jack in Wild Western imitation, but his voice tailed away as Inspector Burden of Kingsmarkham CID emerged from Queen Street and approached them across the forecourt of the Olive and Dove. 
 &bquo;Evening, Mr Burden.&equo; 
 &bquo;Evening.&equo; 
 The inspector viewed them with cool distaste. 
 &bquo;We wouldn't want to do anything likely to lead to a breach of the peace, would we?&equo; 
 He passed on and Charlie Hatton sniggered. 
 &bquo;Copper,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I reckon I've got more in this pocket than he gets in a month.&equo; 
 Maurice said stiffly, &bquo;I'll say good night then, Jack.&equo; 
 They had come to the Kingsbrook bridge and the beginning of the footpath to Sewingbury that followed the waters of the river. 
 Maurice lived in Sewingbury, Charlie in one of the new council flats on the far side of the Kingsbrook Road. 
 The footpath was a short cut home for both of them. 
 &bquo;Wait for Charlie. 
 He's going your way.&equo; 
 &bquo;I won't, thanks. 
 I promised the missus I'd be home by eleven.&equo; 
 Charlie had turned his back, making it plain he didn't want Maurice's company. 
 &bquo;Powerful stuff, that,&equo; Maurice said, his face pale in the lamplight. 
 &bquo;I don't reckon I should have mixed it.&equo; 
 He belched and Charlie sniggered. 
 &bquo;Cheers, Jack, see you in church.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cheers, mate.&equo; 
 Maurice vaulted the stile and, by a miracle, landed steadily on his feet. 
 He passed the wooden seats, ducked under the willows, and the last they saw of him was his undulating shadow. 
 Jack and Charlie were alone. 
 They had drunk a great deal and the night was warm, but on a sudden they were both stone-cold sober. 
 Both of them loved women and in that love as in every emotion they were inarticulate, yet in no impulse of the heart were they so tongue-tied as in this great and pure friendship of theirs. 
 As with the Greeks, they had found in each other an all-embracing spiritual compatibility. 
 Their women were their pride and treasure, for bed, for hearth and home, for showing off, for their manhood. 
 But without each other their lives would be incomplete, lacking, as it were, the essence and the fuse. 
 They had never heard of the Greeks, unless you counted the man who kept the Acropolis restaurant in Stowerton, and neither could now understand the emotion which held each of them, preserving him in silence and a kind of despair. 
 If Charlie had been a different man, a cultivated man or effeminate or living in a bygone age when tongues were more freely unloosed, he might now have embraced Jack and told him from a full heart how he entered wholly into his joy and would die for his happiness. 
 And if Jack had been such another he would have thanked Charlie for his unstinted friendship, his generous loans, his hospitality and for bringing him Marilyn Thompson. 
 But Charlie was a sharp little lorry driver and Jack was an electrician. 
 Love was between a man and a woman, love was for marriage, and each would have died before admitting to anything more than they &bquo;got on well&equo; together. 
 They hung over the bridge, dropping stone chippings into the water, and then Charlie said: 
 &bquo;I reckon you need your beauty sleep, so I'll be on my way.&equo; 
 &bquo;We got your present, Charlie. 
 I wasn't going to say nothing till the others had gone, but it's a real grand job that record-player. 
 It quite knocked me back when I saw it. 
 Must have set you back a bit.&equo; 
 &bquo;I got it cost, mate.&equo; 
 Another stone dropped and splashed in the darkness beneath. 
 Marilyn said she'd be writing to Lilian.&equo; 
 &bquo;She has, too. 
 A lovely letter come from her before I went up north. 
 A real educated girl you got there, Jack. 
 She knows how to put a letter together all right. 
 You don't grudge the outlay when you get a letter like that. 
 I brought you two together and don't you ever forget it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, you know how to pick them, Charlie. 
 Look at Lilian.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I'd better get looking at her, hadn't I?&equo; 
 Charlie turned to face his friend and his shadow was short and black against Jack's long one. 
 He raised his hard little hand and brought it down on Jack's resoundingly. 
 &bquo;I'll be off, then.&equo; 
 &bquo;I reckon you'd better, Charlie.&equo; 
 &bquo;And if I don't get the chance tomorrow &mdash; well, I'm no speechmaker like Brian, but all the very best, Jack.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll get the chance all right. 
 You'll have to make a speech.&equo; 
 &bquo;Save it up till then, eh?&equo; 
 Charlie wrinkled his nose and winked quickly. 
 The shadows parted, he negotiated the stile. 
 &bquo;Good night, me old love.&equo; 
 &bquo;Night, Charlie.&equo; 
 The willows enclosed him. 
 His shadow appeared again as the path rose and dipped. 
 Jack heard him whistling, &bquo;Mabel dear, listen here&equo; under the stars and then as the shadow was absorbed and lost in the many tree shadows, the whistle too faded and there was no sound but the gentle chatter of the stream, the Kingsbrook that flowed everlastingly over its bed of thin round stones. 
 Many waters cannot quench love, nor the floods drown it. 
 Detective Chief Inspector Wexford didn't care for dogs. 
 He had never had a dog and now that one of his daughters was married and the other a student at drama school, he saw no reason why he should ever give one house-room. 
 Many an anti-dog man joins the ranks of dog lovers because he is too weak to resist the demands of beloved children, but in Wexford's household the demands had never been more than half-hearted, so he had passed through this snare and come out unscathed. 
 When therefore he arrived home late on Friday night to find the grey thing with ears like knitted dishcloths in his favourite chair he was displeased. 
 &bquo;Isn't she a darling?&equo; said the drama student. 
 &bquo;Her name's Clytemnestra. 
 I knew you wouldn't mind having her for just a fortnight.&equo; 
 And she whisked out to answer the telephone. 
 &bquo;Where did Sheila get it from?&equo; 
 Wexford said gloomily. 
 Mrs. Wexford was a woman of few words. 
 &bquo;Sebastian.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who in God's name is Sebastian?&equo; 
 &bquo;Some boy,&equo; said Mrs Wexford. 
 &bquo;He's only just gone.&equo; 
 Her husband considered pushing the dog on to the floor, thought better of it, and went sulkily off to bed. 
 His daughter's beauty had never ceased to surprise the chief inspector. 
 Sylvia, the elder married one, was well-built and healthy, but that was the best that could be said for her; Mrs Wexford had a magnificent figure and a fine profile although she had never been of the stuff that wins beauty contests. 
 While he&hellip; 
 All he needed, he sometimes thought, was a trunk to make him look exactly like an elephant. 
 His body was huge and ponderous, his skin pachydermatous, wrinkled and grey, and his three-cornered ears stuck out absurdly under the sparse fringe of colourless hair. 
 When he went to the zoo he passed the elephant house quickly lest the irreverent onlooker should make comparisons. 
 Her mother and sister were fine-looking women, but the odd thing about Sheila was that her beauty was not an enlargement or an enhancement of their near-handsomeness. 
 She looked like her father. 
 The first time Wexford noticed this &mdash; she was then about six &mdash; he almost hooted aloud, so grotesque was the likeness between this exquisite piece of doll's flesh and her gross progenitor. 
 And yet that high broad forehead was his, the little tilted nose was his, his the pointed &mdash; although in her case, flat &mdash; ears, and in her huge eyes he saw his own little ones. 
 When he was young his hair had been that flaxen gold too, as soft and as fine. 
 Only hope she doesn't end up looking like her dad, he thought sometimes with a rich inner guffaw. 
 But on the following morning his feelings towards his younger daughter were neither tender nor amused. 
 The dog had awakened him at ten to seven with long-drawn howls and now, a quarter of an hour later, he stood on the threshold of Sheila's bedroom, glowering. 
 &bquo;This isn't a boarding kennels, you know,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Can't you hear her?&equo; 
 &bquo;The Acrylic Swoofle Hound, Pop? 
 Poor darling, she only wants to be taken out.&equo; 
 &bquo;What did you call her?&equo; 
 &bquo;The Acrylic Swoofle Hound. 
 She's a mongrel really, but that's what Sebastian calls her. 
 She looks as if she's made of man-made fibres you see. 
 Don't you think it's funny?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not particularly. 
 Why can't this Sebastian look after his own dog?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's gone to Switzerland,&equo; said Sheila. 
 &bquo;His plane must have gone by now.&equo; 
 She surfaced from under the sheets and her father saw that her hair was wound on huge electrically heated rollers. 
 &bquo;I felt awful letting him walk all that way to the station last night.&equo; 
 She added accusingly, &bquo;But you had the car.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's my car,&equo; Wexford almost shouted. 
 This argument he knew of old was hopeless and he listened to his own voice with a kind of horror as a note of pleading crept into it. 
 &bquo;If the dog wants to go out, hadn't you better get up and take her?&equo; 
 &bquo;I can't. 
 I've just set my hair.&equo; 
 Downstairs Clytemnestra let out a howl that ended in a series of urgent yelps. 
 Sheila threw back the bedclothes and sat up, a vision in pink baby doll pyjamas. 
 &bquo;God almighty!&equo; 
 Wexford exploded. 
 &bquo;You can't take your friend's dog out but you can get up at the crack of dawn to set your hair.&equo; 
 &bquo;Daddy&hellip;&equo; 
 The wheedling tone as well as the now seldom-used paternal appellation told Wexford that a monstrous request was to be made of him. 
 He glared, drawing his brows together in the manner that made Kingsmarkham's petty offenders tremble. 
 &bquo;Daddy, duck, it's a gorgeous morning and you know what Dr Crocker said about your weight and I have just set my hair&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I am going to take a shower,&equo; Wexford said coldly. 
 He took it. 
 When he emerged from the bathroom the dog was still howling and pop music was issuing from behind Sheila's door. 
 A degenerate male voice exhorted its hearers to give it love or let it die in peace. 
 &bquo;There seems to be an awful lot of noise going on, darling,&equo; said Mrs Wexford sleepily. 
 &bquo;You're joking.&equo; 
 He opened Sheila's door. 
 She was applying a face pack. 
 &bquo;Just this once, then,&equo; said the chief inspector. 
 &bquo;I'm only doing it because I want your mother to have a quiet lie-in, so you can turn that thing off for a start.&equo; 
 &bquo;You are an angel, Daddy,&equo; said Sheila, and she added dreamily, &bquo;I expect Clytemnestra has spent a penny by now.&equo; 
 Clytemnestra. 
 Of all the stupid pretentious names for a dog&hellip; 
 But what else could you expect of someone called Sebastian? 
 She had not, however, yet &bquo;spent a penny.&equo; 
 She flung herself on Wexford, yelping frenetically, and when he pushed her away, ran round him in circles, wildly gyrating her tail and flapping her knitted ears. 
 Wexford found the lead, obligingly left by Sheila in a prominent position on top of the refrigerator. 
 Undoubtedly it was going to be a beautiful day, a summer's day such as is unequalled anywhere in the world but in the South of England, a day that begins with mists, burgeons into tropical glory and dies in blue and gold and stars. 
 &bquo;Full many a glorious morning,&equo; quoted Wexford to Clytemnestra, &bquo;have I seen, flatter the mountain tops with sovereign eye.&equo; 
 Clytemnestra agreed vociferously, leaping on to a stool and screeching hysterically at sight of her lead. 
 &bquo;Bear your body more seemly,&equo; said Wexford coldly, switching from sonnet to comedy without varying his author. 
 He looked out of the window. 
 The sovereign eye was there all right, bright, molten and white-gold. 
 Instead of mountain tops it was flattering the Kingsbrook meadows and turning the little river into a ribbon of shimmering metal. 
 It wouldn't do him any harm to take this ungoverned creature for a short jaunt in the fields and the experience would give him a splendid ascendancy over Inspector Burden when he walked into the station at nine-thirty. 
 &bquo;Lovely morning, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was, Mike. 
 The best of it's over now, of course. 
 Now when I was down by the river at half seven&hellip;&equo; 
 He chuckled. 
 Clytemnestra whimpered. 
 Wexford went to the door and the dog screamed for joy. 
 He clipped on the lead and stepped forth into the sweet peace of a summer Saturday in Sussex. 
 It was one thing to boast afterwards of pre-breakfast hiking, quite another to be actually seen leading this freak of nature, this abortion, about the public streets. 
 Observed in uncompromising midsummer light, Clytemnestra looked like something that, having lain neglected at the bottom of an old woman's knitting basket, has finally been brought out to be mended. 
 Moreover, now that she had achieved the heart's desire for which she had turned on her shameless, neurotic display, she had become dejected, and walked along meekly, head and tail hanging. 
 Just like a woman, Wexford thought crossly. 
 Sheila would be just the same. 
 Hair out of curlers, face cleaned up, she was in all probability downstairs now calmly making her mother a cup of tea. 
 When you get what you want you don't want what you get&hellip; 
 On a fait le monde ainsi. 
 He would, however, eschew the public streets. 
 From this side of town, the footpath led across the fields to the bank of the stream where it divided, one branch going to the new council estate and Sewingbury, the other to the centre of Kingsmarkham High Street, at the Kingsbrook bridge. 
 Wexford certainly wasn't going to embark on a sabbath day's journey to Sewingbury, and now they had mucked up the Kingsbrook Road with those flats, there was no longer any point in going there. 
 Instead he would walk down to the river, take the path to the bridge and pick up his Police Review at Braddan's on his way home. 
 They always forgot to send it with the papers. 
 In agricultural districts pastureland is usually fenced. 
 These meadows were divided by hedges and barbed wire and in them great red cattle were grazing. 
 Mist lay in shallow patches over the hollows and where the fields were lying fallow the hay was nearly ready to be cut, but it was not yet cut. 
 Wexford, very much a countryman at heart, marvelled that the townsman calls grass green when in reality it is as many-coloured as Joseph's coat. 
 The grass heads hung heavy with seed, ochre, chestnut and powdery grey, and all the thick tapestry of pasture was embroidered and interlaced with the crimson thread of sorrel, the bright acid of buttercups and the creamy dairy-maid floss of meadowsweet. 
 Over it all the fanning whispering seed and the tenuous mist cast a sheen of silver. 
 The oak trees had not yet lost the vivid yellow-green of their late springtime, a colour so bright, so fresh and so unparalleled elsewhere in nature or in art that no one has ever been able to emulate it and it is never seen in paint or cloth or women's dresses. 
 In such things the colour would be crude, if it could be copied, but against this pale blue yet fixedly cloudless sky it was not crude. 
 It was exquisite. 
 Wexford drew in lungfuls of scented, pollen-laden air. 
 He never had hay fever and he felt good. 
 The dog, who had perhaps feared a pavement perambulation, sniffed the air too and became frisky. 
 She poked about in the brambles and wagged her tail. 
 Wexford undid the lead clip and let her run. 
 With a kind of stolid tranquillity he began to reflect on the day's work ahead. 
 That grievous bodily harm thing was coming up at a special court this morning, but that ought to be all wrapped up in half an hour. 
 Then there was the possibility of the silver on sale at the Saturday morning market being stolen goods. 
 Someone had better go down and have a word&hellip; 
 No doubt there'd been the usual spate of Friday night burglaries, too. 
 Mrs Fanshawe had regained consciousness in Stowerton Royal Infirmary after her six-week-long coma. 
 They would have to talk to her today. 
 But that was the uniformed branch's pigeon, not his. 
 Thank God, it wasn't he who had to break the news to the woman that her husband and her daughter had both been killed in the car crash that had fractured her skull. 
 Presumably they would now resume the adjourned inquest on that unfortunate pair. 
 Burden said Mrs. Fanshawe might just recall why her husband's Jaguar had skidded and overturned on the empty fast lane of the twin track road, but he doubted it. 
 A merciful amnesia usually came with these comas and who could deny it was a blessing? 
 It seemed downright immoral to torment the poor woman with questions now just for the sake of proving the Jaguar's brakes were faulty or Fanshawe driving over the seventy limit. 
 It wasn't as if any other vehicle had been involved. 
 No doubt there was some question of insurance. 
 Anyway, it wasn't his worry. 
 The sun shone on the rippling river and the long willow leaves just touched its bubbling golden surface. 
 A trout jumped for a sparkling irridescent fly. 
 Clytemnestra went down to the water and drank greedily. 
 In this world of clean fast-running water, of inimitable oaks and meadows which made the Bayeux tapestry look like a traycloth, there was no place for somersaulted cars and carnage and broken bodies lying on the wet and bloody tarmac. 
 The dog paddled, then swam. 
 In the sunshine even grey knitted Clytemnestra was beautiful. 
 Beneath her flat furry belly the big shallow stones had the marble veining of agate. 
 Upon the water the mist floated in a golden veil, spotted with the dancing of a myriad tiny flies. 
 And Wexford who was an agnostic, a profane man, thought, Lord, how manifold are thy works in all the earth. 
 There was a man on the other side of the river. 
 He was walking slowly some fifty yards from the opposite bank and parallel to it, walking from the Sewingbury direction to Kingsmarkham. 
 A child was with him, holding his hand, and he too had a dog, a big pugnacious-looking black dog. 
 Wexford had an idea, drawn partly from experience in looking out of his office window, that when two dogs meet they inevitably fight. 
 Clytemnestra would come out badly from a fight with that big black devil. 
 Wexford couldn't bring himself to call his charge by her name. 
 He whistled. 
 Clytemnestra took no notice. 
 She had gained the opposite bank and was poking about in a great drifting mass of torn grass and brushwood. 
 Further upstream a cache of rubbish had been washed against the bank. 
 Wexford, who had been lyrical, felt positively pained by this evidence of man's indifference to nature's glories. 
 He could see a bundle of checked cloth, an old blanket perhaps, an oil drum and, a little apart from the rest, a floating shoe. 
 Clytemnestra confirmed his low opinion of everything canine by advancing on this water-logged pocket of rubbish, her tail wagging and her ears pricked. 
 Filthy things, dogs. 
 Wexford thought, scavengers and dustbin delvers. 
 He whistled again. 
 The dog stopped and he was just about to congratulate himself on his authoritative and successful method of summoning her, when she made a plunging dart forward and seized the mass of cloth in her mouth. 
 It moved with a heavy surge and the dog released it, her hackles rising. 
 The slow and somehow primeval erecting of that mat of grey hairs brought a curious chill to Wexford's blood. 
 The sun seemed to go in. 
 He forgot the black dog, coming ever nearer, and his joy in the morning went. 
 Clytemnestra let out an unearthly keening howl, her lips snarling back and her tail a stiff prolongation of her backbone. 
 The bundle she had disturbed eddied a few inches into the deeper water and as Wexford watched, a thin pale hand, lifeless as the agate-veined stones, rose slowly from the sodden cloth, its fingers hanging yet pointing towards him. 
 He took off his shoes and socks and rolled his trousers to his knees. 
 The man and the child on the other side watched him with interest. 
 He didn't think they had yet seen the hand. 
 Holding his shoes, he stepped on to the stones and crossed the river carefully. 
 Clytemnestra came to him quickly and put her face against his bare leg. 
 Wexford pushed aside the willows that hung like a pelmet and came to the rubbish pocket, where he knelt down. 
 One shoe floated empty, the other was still on a foot. 
 The dead man lay face-downwards and someone had smashed in the back of his head with a heavy smooth object. 
 One of these very stones, Wexford guessed. 
 The brambles shivered behind him and a footstep crunched. 
 &bquo;Keep back,&equo; Wexford said. 
 &bquo;Keep the child back.&equo; 
 He turned, shielding what lay in the water with his own big body. 
 Downstream the child was playing with both dogs, throwing stones for them into the water. 
 &bquo;Christ!&equo; said the man softly. 
 &bquo;He's dead,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;I'm a police offer and&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I know you. 
 Chief Inspector Wexford.&equo; 
 The man approached and Wexford couldn't stop him. 
 He looked down and gasped. 
 &bquo;My God, I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, it isn't a pleasant sight.&equo; 
 The thought came to Wexford that something very out of the way had happened. 
 Not so much that here on a fine June morning a man lay murdered, but that he, Wexford, had found him. 
 Policemen don't find bodies unless they are sent to look for them or unless someone else has found them first. 
 &bquo;Will you do something for me?&equo; he asked. 
 The newcomer's face was green. 
 He looked as if he was about to be sick. 
 &bquo;Will you go down to the town, to the nearest phone box and get on to the station? 
 Just tell them what you've seen. 
 They'll do the rest. 
 Come on, man, pull yourself together.&equo; 
 &bquo;O.K., it's just that&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps you'd better let me have your name.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cullam, Maurice Cullam. 
 I'll go, I'll go right away. 
 It's just that &mdash; well, last night I was having a drink with him at the Dragon.&equo; 
 &bquo;You know who it is then? 
 You can't see his face.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't need to. 
 I'd know Charlie Hatton anywhere.&equo; 
 He looked a right Charlie in those tails and striped trousers. 
 That would be something funny to say to his best man when he came. 
 &bquo;You and me, we look a pair of right Charlies, Charlie Hatton.&equo; 
 Quite witty really. 
 Jack often thought he wasn't quick enough to match Charlie's easy repartee, but now he had thought of something that would make his friend smile. 
 Dear old Charlie, he thought sentimentally, the best friend a man ever had. 
 Generous to a fault, and if he wasn't always strictly above-board-well, a man had to live. 
 A Charlie knew how to live all right. 
 The best of everything he had. 
 Jack was ready to bet all the crisp honeymoon pound notes he had in his pocket that Charlie would be one of the few quests not wearing a hired morning coat. 
 He had his own and not off the peg, either. 
 Not that he looked half bad himself, he thought, admiring his reflection. 
 At this age boozing didn't have much visible effect and he always had a red face anyway. 
 He looked smashing, he decided, shyly proud, as good as the Duke of Edinburgh any day. 
 Probably the Duke used an electric shaver though. 
 Jack put another bit of cotton wool on the nick on his chin and he wondered if Marilyn was ready yet. 
 Thanks to Charlie boy, they'd been able to splash a bit on the wedding and Marilyn could have the white satin and the four bridesmaids she'd set her heart on. 
 It would have been a different story if they'd had to find the key money for the flat themselves. 
 Trust Charlie to come up with a long-term interest-free loan. 
 That way they'd be able to blue some of their own savings on having the flat done up nicely. 
 How well it had all worked out! 
 A fortnight away by the sea and when they came back, the flat all ready and waiting for them. 
 And it was all thanks to Charlie. 
 Moving away from the mirror, Jack looked into the future, twenty, thirty years hence. 
 Charlie would be a really rich man by then. 
 Jack would be very much surprised if his friend wouldn't be living in one of those houses in Ploughman's Lane like the one where he sometimes did electrical jobs with real old French furniture and real oil paintings and the kind of china you looked at but didn't eat off. 
 He and Charlie had had a good laugh over that particular house, but there had been something serious in Charlie's laughter and Jack had guessed he aimed high. 
 They'd still be mates of course, for there was no side to Charlie Hatton. 
 It wouldn't be beer and a hand of solo then, but dinner parties and bridge games with their wives in cocktail gowns and real jewellery. 
 Jack grew dizzy as he thought of it, seeing them sitting with tall glasses on a shady patio and, strangely, seeing them too as they were now, untouched by the hand of time. 
 Abruptly he came back to the present day, his wedding day. 
 Charlie was taking a hell of a time about coming. 
 Maybe there was some difficulty about Lilian's dress or he was waiting for her to get back from the hairdresser's. 
 Charlie was dead keen on Lilian doing him credit and she always did, always looked as if she'd just stepped out of a bandbox. 
 After Marilyn, she'd be the best dressed woman at the wedding, blonde, shapely, in the green dress Marilyn had got so superstitious about. 
 Jack dabbed at his chin again and went to the window to watch for Charlie. 
 It was ten-thirty and the wedding was fixed for an hour's time. 
 She was blonde, shapely, pretty in Sheila Wexford's style but without Sheila's transcending beauty. 
 Her face was rather blunt, the features unfinished putty dabs, and now it was swollen with crying. 
 After they had told her Wexford and Burden sat helplessly while she flung herself face-downwards on the sofa and sobbed into the cushions. 
 Presently Wexford moved over to her and touched her shoulder. 
 She reached for his hand, clutched it and dug in her long nails. 
 Then she struggled up, burying her face in his hand and her own. 
 The expensive velvet cushions were blotched with her tears. 
 Wexford glanced quickly around the smartly, even luxuriously, furnished room. 
 Over the back of one of the chairs hung a blue and green flowered dress, a green coat, long wrist-buttoning gloves. 
 In the middle of the long teak dining table lay Lilian Hatton's wedding hat, an elaborate confection of satin leaves and tulle as green and fresh as the real leaves he could see through the picture window in the Kingsbrook meadows. 
 &bquo;Mrs Hatton,&equo; he said gently and she raised her face obediently, 
 &bquo;Mrs Hatton, weren't you worried when your husband didn't come home last night?&equo; 
 She didn't speak. 
 He repeated the question, and then she said in a voice choked with sobs, &bquo;I didn't expect him home. 
 I only half-expected him.&equo; 
 She dropped Wexford's hand, recoiling as if in taking it she had done something indecent. 
 &bquo;When he didn't come,&equo; she said, &bquo;I thought He hasn't made it, he hasn't made Jack's party. 
 He's stopping off on the road, he'll be in in the morning, I&hellip;&equo; 
 The sobs were uncontrollable and she gave a long piteous cry. 
 &bquo;I won't trouble you any more now, Mrs Hatton. 
 You say your mother's coming? 
 If I could just have Mr. Pertwee's address&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Jack, yes,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Jack'll take this hard.&equo; 
 She drew a long breath, twisting her hands. 
 &bquo;They'd been pals since they were schoolkids.&equo; 
 Suddenly she stood up, staring wildly. 
 &bquo;God, Jack doesn't know! 
 It's his wedding day and Charlie was going to be his best man. 
 Oh, Jack, Jack, poor Jack!&equo; 
 &bquo;Leave it to us, Mrs Hatton,&equo; said Inspector Burden. 
 &bquo;We'll tell Mr Pertwee. 
 Bailey Street, is it? 
 We'll tell him. 
 There's your front door bell now. 
 I expect that'll be your mother.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mum,&equo; said Lilian Hatton. 
 &bquo;What am I going to do, Mum?&equo; 
 The older woman looked past her, then put her arms around the shaking shoulders. 
 &bquo;Marilyn said I shoudn't wear green to a wedding, she said it was unlucky.&equo; 
 Her voice was very low, a slurring mumble. 
 &bquo;I bought that green coat just the same. 
 I never got as far as the wedding, Mum, but it was unlucky, wasn't it?&equo; 
 Suddenly she broke into a terrible, loud and demented scream. 
 &bquo;Charlie, Charlie, what am I going to do, Charlie?&equo; 
 She held on to her mother, clawing at the lapels of her coat. 
 &bquo;Oh my God, Charlie!&equo; she screamed. 
 &bquo;I never get used to it, you know,&equo; said Burden quietly. 
 &bquo;Do you think I do?&equo; 
 Wexford had amiable, sometimes distinctly fond feelings for his subordinate, but occasionally Burden made him impatient, especially when he instituted himself keeper of the chief inspector's conscience. 
 He had a smug parsonical face, Wexford thought unkindly, and now his thin mouth turned piously down. 
 &bquo;The worst is over anyway,&equo; he said crossly. 
 The bridegroom won't go into transports of grief and you don't put off your wedding because your best man's been done in.&equo; 
 You callous devil, said Burden's look. 
 Then the neat, well-modelled head was once more averted and the inspector re-entered his silent, respectful reverie. 
 It took only ten minutes to get from the Hatton's flat to Bailey Street where, at number ten, Jack Pertwee lived with his widowed father. 
 The police car stopped outside a tiny terraced house with no garden to separate its front door from the pavement. 
 Mr Pertwee senior answered their knock, looking uneasy in a too large morning coat. 
 &bquo;Thought you were our missing best man come at last.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm afraid Mr. Hatton won't be coming, sir.&equo; 
 Wexford and Burden edged themselves courteously but firmly past him into the narrow hall. 
 &bquo;I'm very sorry to tell you we have bad news.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bad news?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sir, Mr. Hatton died last night. 
 He was found down by the river this morning and he'd been dead since midnight or before.&equo; 
 Pertwee went pale as chalk. 
 &bquo;By gum,&equo; he said, &bquo;Jack'll take this hard.&equo; 
 His mouth trembling, he looked at them both and then down at the knife-edge creases in his trousers. 
 &bquo;D'you want me to go up and tell him?&equo; 
 Wexford nodded. 
 &bquo;Well, if that's the way you want it. 
 He's getting married at eleven-thirty. 
 But if I've got to tell him, I suppose I've got to tell him.&equo; 
 They both knew Jack Pertwee by sight. 
 Most Kingsmarkham faces were familiar to Wexford and Burden remembered seeing him the night before arm-in-arm with the dead man, singing and disturbing decent citizens. 
 A happily married man himself, he had the deepest sympathy for the widow, but in his heart he thought Jack Pertwee a bit of a lout. 
 You didn't have to tread softly with such as he and he wondered scornfully why the fellow's face was lard-coloured. 
 Impatiently he watched him lumber blindly down the steep narrow staircase and when the bridegroom reached the bottom, Burden said curtly: 
 &bquo;Your father's told you? 
 Hatton was murdered last night. 
 We want to know the lot, where you'd been and what time you left him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Here, go easy,&equo; said the father. 
 &bquo;It's been a shock. 
 They were old mates, my boy and Charlie.&equo; 
 Jack pushed past him into the poky front parlour and the others followed. 
 The wedding flowers had come. 
 Jack had a white rose in his buttonhole and there were two more, their stems wrapped in silver foil, on the fumed oak sideboard. 
 One was for the bridegroom's father and the other would never be worn. 
 Jack plucked the flower out of his morning coat and closed his fist slowly over it, crushing it into a pulp. 
 &bquo;I'll get you a drop of whisky, son.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't want it,&equo; Jack said with his back to them. 
 &bquo;We was drinking whisky last night. 
 I never want to touch it again.&equo; 
 He pulled his black immaculate sleeve across his eyes. 
 &bquo;Who did it?&equo; he shouted. 
 &bquo;We hoped you'd be able to tell us that,&equo; said Burden. 
 &bquo;Me? 
 Are you out of your bloody mind? 
 Just show me the bastard who killed Charlie Hatton and I'll. 
 ..&equo; He sat down heavily, spread his arms on the table and dropped his head. 
 &bquo;Charlie,&equo; he said. 
 Wexford didn't pursue it. 
 He turned to the father. 
 &bquo;What was it last night, a stag party?&equo; 
 Pertwee nodded. 
 &bquo;D'you know who was there?&equo; 
 &bquo;Jack, of course, and poor old Charlie. 
 Then there was all the darts club lot, George Carter, fellow called Bayles, Maurice Cullam from Sewingbury and a couple of others. 
 That right, Jack?&equo; 
 Jack nodded dumbly. 
 Charlie got there late, Jack said. 
 They left at closing time split up outside, I reckon. 
 Charlie and Cullam'll have walked home across the fields. 
 That right, Jack?&equo; 
 This time Jack lifted his head. 
 Burden thought him a weak womanish fool, despising his red eyes and the muscle that twitched in his cheek. 
 But Wexford spoke gently. 
 &bquo;I realise this has been a blow to you, Mr Pertwee. 
 We won't bother you much longer. 
 Did Mr Cullam and Mr Hatton walk home together?&equo; 
 &bquo;Maurice went first,&equo; Jack muttered. 
 &bquo;About twenty to eleven it was. 
 Charlie. 
 .. Charlie stayed for a bit of a a natter with me.&equo; 
 A sob caught his throat and he coughed to mask it. 
 &bquo;He said he wished me luck in case he didn't get the chance today. 
 Christ, he didn't know he'd never get another chance.&equo; 
 &bquo;Come on, son, bear up. 
 Let me give you a little drop of scotch. 
 You owe it to Marilyn to keep going you know. 
 It's your wedding day, remember?&equo; 
 Jack shook off his father's hand and lurched to his feet. 
 &bquo;There isn't going to be no wedding,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You don't mean that, Jack, think of that girl of yours, think of all them folks coming. 
 They'll be getting to the church in a minute. 
 Charlie wouldn't have wished it.&equo; 
 Stubbornly Jack said, I'm not getting married today. 
 D'you think I don't know what's right, what's proper?&equo; 
 He wrenched off his tie and flung his morning coat over the back of a chair. 
 His father, with a working man's regard for hired finery, picked it up, smoothed it and stood draping it over his arm like an outfitter's assistant. 
 Bewildered by the holocaust of events, by death that had suddenly changed a world, he began apologising, first to the policemen: &bquo;I don't know what to say, his best man to die like that&hellip;&equo; and then to his son: &bquo;I'd give my right hand to have things different, Jack. 
 What can I do for you, son? 
 I'll do anything you say.&equo; 
 Jack dropped his handful of bruised petals. 
 A sudden dignity made him straighten his back and hold his head high. 
 &bquo;Then get down to that church,&equo; he said, &bquo;and tell them the wedding's off.&equo; 
 He faced Wexford. 
 &bquo;I'm not answering any more questions now. 
 I've got my grief. 
 You ought to respect me grief.&equo; 
 Still the old man hesitated, biting his lip. 
 &bquo;Go on, Dad,&equo; Jack said fiercely. 
 &bquo;Tell them it's all off and tell them why.&equo; 
 He gasped as if suddenly, at this moment, it had come home to him. 
 &bquo;Tell them Charlie Hatton's dead!&equo; 
 Oh, Jonathan, thou wast slain in thy high places. 
 .. How are the mighty fallen and the weapons of war perished! 
 &bquo;A best man, indeed,&equo; said Burden. 
 &bquo;Everyone's best man.&equo; 
 You callous devil, thought Wexford. 
 &bquo;Naturally Pertwee'd be upset. 
 What did you expect?&equo; 
 Burden made a moue of disgust. 
 &bquo;That sort of grief, that's the widow's province. 
 A man ought to have more self-control.&equo; 
 His pale ascetic face flushed unbecomingly. 
 &bquo;You don't suppose there was anything&hellip;? 
 &bquo;No, I don't,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;And why can't you call a spade a spade? 
 They were friends. 
 Don't you have friends, Mike? 
 A pretty pass we've come to if a man can't have a friend without being labelled queer.&equo; 
 He stared aggressively at Burden and declaimed loudly and meaningfully, &bquo;O brave new world, that has such people in it!&equo; 
 Burden gave a stiff repressive cough and maintained silence until they reached York Street. 
 Then he said coldly, &bquo;George Carter's place is down here, old Pertwee said.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's the Morris dancer, isn't he? 
 I've seen him cavorting about on summer nights outside the Olive and Dove.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lot of affected nonsense.&equo; 
 But George Carter wasn't wearing his cap and bells this morning. 
 From the brilliantined hair and the smart lounge suit, Wexford gathered that here was a wedding guest. 
 He hinted at the unlikelihood of Jack Pertwee's being married that day and was inwardly amused to observe that this piece of information &mdash; the fact that Carter would be deprived of his cold chicken and champagne &mdash; distressed him more than Hatton's death. 
 The wedding guest did not exactly beat his breast but he looked considerably crestfallen. 
 &bquo;All that money wasted,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I know, I was making plans for my own wedding, but then you won't want to know about that. 
 Pity Jack had to be told, really. 
 I don't seem to be able to take it in. 
 Charlie Hatton dead! 
 He was always so full of life, if you know what I mean.&equo; 
 &bquo;And very well liked, I gather.&equo; 
 George Carter's eyebrow went up. 
 &bquo;Charlie? 
 Oh well, mustn't speak ill of the dead.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'd better speak the truth, Mr. Carter,&equo; said Burden, &bquo;and never mind whether it's ill or not. 
 We want to know all about this party last night. 
 The lot, please. 
 You can take your time.&equo; 
 Like Jack Pertwee and yet utterly unlike him, Carter took off his jacket and loosened his tie. 
 &bquo;I don't know what you mean by the lot,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It was just a bunch of mates having a drink.&equo; 
 &bquo;What happened? 
 What did you talk about?&equo; 
 &bquo;O.K.&equo; He gave them an incredulous glance and said sarcastically, &bquo;stop me if I'm boring you. 
 Charlie come into the Dragon at about half nine, maybe a quarter to ten. 
 We was drinking beer so, of course, Charlie has to make us all feel small by paying for whiskies all round. 
 A crack hand at that was Charlie Hatton. 
 I made some comment and he bit my head off. 
 This the sort of thing you want to know?&equo; 
 &bquo;Exactly the sort of thing, Mr. Carter.&equo; 
 &bquo;Seems a bit mean, that's all, with the poor geezer dead. 
 Then someone else was telling a joke and he sort of &mdash; well, humiliated him, if you know what I mean. 
 He was like that, always had to be top dog. 
 He drank my drink because I said something about all the money he was always flashing around and then he made a dirty crack about&hellip; 
 Well, that doesn't matter. 
 It was personal. 
 He got at our chairman too and he left with a couple of the others. 
 Geoff had already gone. 
 There was me and Charlie and Maurice and Jack left and we went when they closed. 
 And that's the lot.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're sure?&equo; 
 &bquo;I told you there was nothing much. 
 I can't think of any more&hellip; 
 Oh, wait a minute. 
 But it was nothing.&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll have it just the same, Mr Carter.&equo; 
 George Carter shrugged impatiently. 
 &bquo;I don't even know what it was about. 
 Nothing, I reckon. 
 Maurice said &mdash; it was after the others had gone &mdash; Maurice said, &bquo;Seen much of McCloy lately, Charlie?&equo; 
 I think those were his words. 
 I know the name was McCloy but it didn't mean nothing to me. 
 Jack didn't like it and he was a bit shirty with Maurice. 
 I reckon Charlie looked a bit sick. 
 God, it was all so&hellip; well, it was nothing. 
 But Charlie'd always rise. 
 I expected him to rise. 
 I don't know why. 
 He didn't. 
 He just made a crack about Maurice needing to sleep quiet in his bed. 
 Said it was time he did, meaning Maurice had so many kids and&hellip; well, you can get the message.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not altogether,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;Had Cullam suggested that Hatton couldn't sleep quiet in his?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right. 
 I forget that bit. 
 I wish I could remember his words. 
 Something like &bquo;I don't have nothing to do with McCloy, I like to sleep quiet in my bed.&equo;&equo; 
 Very interesting Wexford thought. 
 Far from being popular, Hatton had evidently had a host of enemies. 
 He had spent less than an hour in the Dragon and during that time he had succeeded in needling at least four men. 
 &bquo;You mentioned all the money Hatton used to flash around,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;What money?&equo; 
 &bquo;He always had wads of it,&equo; said Carter. 
 &bquo;I've known him three years and he was always flush. 
 But he'd had more lately. 
 He bought four rounds of double scotches last night and it didn't even make a hole in what he'd got.&equo; 
 &bquo;How much had he got, Mr. Carter?&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't count it, you know,&equo; Carter said with asperity. 
 He blew his nose on his clean white wedding handkerchief. 
 &bquo;He'd got his pay packet, but he didn't touch that. 
 Then he had this roll of notes. 
 I told you I didn't count them. 
 How could I?&equo; 
 &bquo;Twenty pounds, thirty, more?&equo; 
 Carter wrinkled his forehead in an effort of concentration. 
 &bquo;He paid for the first round out of a fiver and the third with another fiver. 
 He'd got two fivers left, then. 
 As well as that there was a wad of oncers&equo;. 
 He indicated with two parted fingers a quarter of an inch. 
 &bquo;I reckon he was carrying a hundred quid besides his pay.&equo; 
 By lunchtime Wexford and Burden had interviewed all those members of the darts club that had been present at Jack Pertwee's stag party with the exception of Maurice Cullam, but none of them had been able to do more than confirm that Hatton had been aggressive, vain and malicious and that he had been carrying a great deal of money. 
 They returned to the police station, passing the parish church on whose steps a June bride and her attendants were being photographed. 
 The bridegroom moved out of the throng and Wexford felt a strange sentimental pang because it was not Jack Pertwee. 
 Then he pulled himself together and said, as they mounted the station steps under the concrete canopy: &bquo;Now if we were cops inside the covers of a detective story, Mike, we'd know for sure that Hatton was killed to stop Pertwee getting married today.&equo; 
 Burden gave a sour smile. 
 &bquo;Easier to kill Pertwee. 
 I'd have thought.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, but that's your author's subtlety. 
 Still, we aren't and he wasn't. 
 The chances are he was killed for the money he was carrying. 
 There was nothing in his wallet when I found him.&equo; 
 The foyer of the police station enclosed them. 
 Behind the long black sweep of counter Sergeant Camb sat fanning himself with a newspaper, the sweat dripping down his forehead. 
 Wexford made for the stairs. 
 &bquo;Why not use the lift, sir?&equo; said Burden. 
 The police station was not yet half a dozen years old, but ever since its completion the powers that be, like fussy housewives, had been unable to let well alone, adding innovation after innovation, perpetually trying to improve their handiwork. 
 First there had been the stone tubs on the forecourt, a constant temptation to vandals who got a more than commonly satisfying kick from ravishing these particular flowers. 
 Then came the consignment of houseplants for the offices, tradescantia and sanseveria and ficus elasica that were doomed from the start to dehydration and ultimately to have their pots serve as repositories for cigarette ash. 
 Last year it had been glass sculpture, a strange green tree, a very Ygdrasil, for Burden's sanctum, and for Wexford an inky-blue, amorphous pillar that in some lights grossly resembled the human figure. 
 These, too, had been fated, Wexford's broken by a pretty young woman who was helping him with his enquiries and Burden's one day inadvertently put out with the rubbish. 
 That should have been the end of it. 
 And then, just as the foyer was beginning to take on a shabby, comfortable look, the lift arrived, an elegant black and gilt box with a sliding door. 
 &bquo;It isn't working yet,&equo; Wexford said, a shade nervously. 
 &bquo;That's where you're wrong. 
 Been operating since this morning. 
 Shall we try it?&equo; 
 &bquo;I should just like to know what's wrong with the stairs,&equo; Wexford exploded. 
 &bquo;It's a downright disgrace wasting the ratepayers' money like this.&equo; 
 He stuck out his lower lip. 
 &bquo;Besides, Crocker says walking upstairs is the best exercise in the world for me with my high blood pressure.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just as you like,&equo; said Burden, turning his face away so that Wexford should not see him smile. 
 By the time they reached the third floor they were both out of breath. 
 The flimsy yellow chair behind Wexford's rosewood desk creaked as he lowered his heavy body into it. 
 &bquo;For God's sake open a window, Mike.&equo; 
 Burden grumbled that opening windows upset the air conditioning but he complied, raising the yellow venetian blind and letting in a powerful shaft of noonday sunshine. 
 &bquo;Well, sir,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Shall we re-cap on what we know about Charlie Hatton?&equo; 
 &bquo;Thirty years old, born and bred in Kingsmarkham. 
 Two years ago he got married to a Miss Lilian Bardsley, sister of the man he's in business with. 
 Bardsley's got his own firm, transporting small electrical goods.&equo; 
 &bquo;Was Hatton a full partner?&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll have to find out. 
 Even if he was, I can't see he could get that flush driving loads of irons and heaters up to Leeds and Scotland a couple of times a week. 
 Carter says he had a hundred quid on him, Mike. 
 Where did he get the money from?&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe this McCloy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do we know any McCloys?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not that I can recall, sir. 
 We shall have to ask Maurice Cullam.&equo; 
 Wexford wiped his brow with his handkerchief and, following Camb's example, began to fan himself with the morning paper. 
 &bquo;The philoprogenitive Cullam,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;He had one of his quiverful with him when I found Hatton this morning. 
 He's a lorry driver too, Mike. 
 I wonder&hellip; 
 Hatton had his lorry hi-jacked twice this year.&equo; 
 Burden opened his pale-blue eyes wide. 
 &bquo;Is that so?&equo; 
 &bquo;I remembered,&equo; said Wexford, &bquo;as soon as Cullam told me whose the body was. 
 Both times were on the Great North Road and no one was ever done for it. 
 Hatton got knocked on the head the first time but the second time he wasn't hurt, only tied up.&equo; 
 &bquo;Once,&equo; said Burden thoughtfully, &bquo;is fair enough. 
 Occupational hazard. 
 Twice looks fishy. 
 I want to hear what the doctor has to say. 
 And if I'm not mistaken that's him outside now.&equo; 
 Dr. Crocker and Wexford had been at school together. 
 Like Jack Pertwee and Charlie Hatton, they were lifelong friends, but their friendship was a casual business and their manner to each other dry, irreverent, often caustic. 
 Crocker, some six years the chief inspector's junior, was the only man Burden knew who could get the better of Wexford and match his acid tongue. 
 A tall lean figure with deep lines carved vertically down his brown cheeks, he came into the office looking as cool as he did on a winter's day. 
 &bquo;I used your lift,&equo; said the doctor. 
 &bquo;Very smart. 
 Whatever will they think of next?&equo; 
 &bquo;Pictures are threatened,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;The inspector here is to have a suitable flower piece and I a Constable landscape.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know much about art,&equo; said Crocker, sitting down and crossing one elegant lean leg over the other, &bquo;but there's one painting I would like to have. 
 Rembrandt, The Anatomy Lesson. 
 Lovely thing it is. 
 There's this poor devil, this corpse, you see, lying on the table with his guts laid open and all these students&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you mind,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;I'm just going to have my lunch. 
 You doctors bring your revolting trade into everything. 
 We can hear your ideas on interior decoration another time. 
 Now I want to know about Charlie Hatton.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perfectly healthy bloke,&equo; said the doctor, bar the fact that he's dead.&equo; 
 He ignored Burden's glance of reproof. 
 &bquo;Someone bashed him on the back of the head with a heavy smooth object. 
 I'd say he was dead by eleven but it's impossible to be accurate about these things. 
 What did you say he did for a living?&equo; 
 &bquo;He was a lorry driver,&equo; said Burden. 
 &bquo;I thought that's what you said. 
 He'd got a marvellous set of teeth.&equo; 
 &bquo;So what?&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;He ought to have had good teeth.&equo; 
 Rather ruefully he ran his tongue over the two stumps that held in place his upper plate. 
 &bquo;He was only thirty.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure,&equo; said Crocker, &bquo;he ought to have had his own being a war baby and a cog in the welfare state. 
 The point is he didn't. 
 What I meant was he'd got just about the finest set of false teeth I've ever seen. 
 Lovely ivory castles. 
 Very nifty grinders Charlie Hatton had, all cunningly contrived to look more real than the real thing. 
 I'd be surprised if they cost less than two hundred quid.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rich man,&equo; said Wexford ruminatively. 
 &bquo;A hundred pounds in his wallet and two hundred in his mouth. 
 I wish I could believe he'd come by it honestly, driving his lorry up and down the Great North Road.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's your problem,&equo; said the doctor. 
 &bquo;Well, I'm away to my lunch. 
 Tried the lift yet?&equo; 
 &bquo;In your capacity as my medical adviser, you advised me to walk upstairs. 
 Physician, heal thyself. 
 About all the exercise you get is pressing the button on your automatic gear change. 
 You want to watch your blood pressure, too.&equo; 
 &bquo;I should worry,&equo; said Crocker. 
 He went to the door where the sunshine showed off his elegant figure and absence of paunch to best advantage. 
 &bquo;All a matter of metabolism,&equo; he said airily. 
 &bquo;Some have it rapid.&equo; 
 He looked back at Wexford. 
 &bquo;Others slow. 
 The luck of the draw.&equo; 
 Wexford gave a snort. 
 When the doctor had gone, he opened the top drawer of his desk and took from it the contents of Charlie Hatton's pockets. 
 The wallet was there, but it was empty of money. 
 It was still soaking wet and now Wexford carefully removed from its leather partitions a photograph of Lilian Hatton, a driving licence and a darts club membership card and spread them in the sun to dry. 
 In the pocket also there had been a clean handkerchief with a small card caught between its folds. 
 You couldn't see the card until you unfolded the handkerchief and now Wexford looked at it for the first time. 
 It too was wet and the ink writing on it indecipherable, but it was still recognisable as the pasteboard square dentists use to remind patients of their appointments. 
 On the top was printed: Jolyon Vigo, B.D.S., L.D.S., R.C.S., Eng., Dent. 
 Surg., 19 Ploughman's Lane, Kingsmarkham, Sussex. 
 Tel: Kingsmarkham 384. 
 Wexford held it up in the bright shaft of sunlight. 
 &bquo;The source of the delectable dentures, d'you reckon?&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe Vigo can tell us where the money came from if Cullam can't,&equo; said Burden. 
 &bquo;My wife goes to Vigo. 
 He's a good dentist.&equo; 
 &bquo;A fly one too, if you ask me, getting a sharp little customer like Charlie Hatton to part with two hundred for thirty-two teeth. 
 No wonder he can afford to live in Ploughman's Lane. 
 We're in the wrong job here, Mike, and no mistake. 
 I'm going for my lunch now. 
 Join me? 
 And then we'll go and root Cullam out of his domestic bliss.&equo; 
 &bquo;May as well use the lift,&equo; said Burden with a trace of self-consciousness. 
 It was more than Wexford's life was worth to admit his craven fear of the lift. 
 Although a notice inside clearly stated its capacity to carry three persons, he was secretly afraid that it would be inadequate to bear his vast bulk. 
 But he hesitated for no more than a moment before stepping inside and when the door was closed he took refuge in clowning. 
 &bquo;Soft furnishings, table linen, cutlery,&equo; he said facetiously, pressing the button. 
 The lift sighed and began to sink. 
 &bquo;First floor for ladies' underwear, stockings&hellip; 
 Why's it stopping, Mike?&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe you pressed the wrong button.&equo; 
 Or it won't stand my weight, Wexford thought, alarmed. 
 The lift came to rest at the first floor and the door slid open. 
 Sergeant Camb hesitated apologetically on the threshold. 
 &bquo;Sorry, sir. 
 I didn't know it was you. 
 I can walk down.&equo; 
 &bquo;Three persons are permitted, Sergeant,&equo; Wexford said, hoping his now very real trepidation didn't show. 
 &bquo;Come along.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not bad, is it? 
 The tribute of a grateful government.&equo; 
 Come on, come on, he thought, and pictured the three of them plummeting down the last thirty feet into the basement. 
 &bquo;You off to see Mrs. Fanshawe, I suppose?&equo; he said superfluously. 
 The lift floated lightly, steadied and the door opened. 
 Must be stoutly built, thought Wexford, like me. 
 &bquo;I heard she'd regained consciousness.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm hoping the doctors'll have broken the news about her husband and her daughter, sir,&equo; said Camb as they crossed the black and white checkerboard foyer of the station. 
 &bquo;It's not a job I fancy. 
 They were all the family she'd got. 
 She's hasn't a soul in the world barring her sister who came down and identified the bodies.&equo; 
 &bquo;How old is she?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mrs Fanshawe, sir? 
 Fifty odd. 
 The sister's a good bit older. 
 Horrible business for her having to identify Miss Fanshawe. 
 She was a nasty mess, I can tell you. 
 Face all&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm just off for my lunch,&equo; said Wexford firmly. 
 He marched through the swing doors in front of the others and Camb got into the car. 
 The stone flowerpots on the forecourt sported bright bouquets of pelargoniums, their magenta-splashed faces turned gratefully to the noonday sun. 
 &bquo;What was that all about?&equo; asked Burden. 
 &bquo;Mrs Fanshawe? 
 It's not our cup of tea. 
 She and her husband were driving home from Eastbourne in Fanshawe's Jaguar. 
 It overturned in the fast lane on the twin-track road on the other side of Stowerton. 
 Their home was in London and Fanshawe must have been in a hurry. 
 God knows how it happened, there wasn't another thing on the road, but the Jag overturned and caught fire. 
 Mrs Fanshawe was flung clear, the other two killed outright. 
 Badly burned too.&equo; 
 &bquo;And this Mrs Fanshawe doesn't know?&equo; 
 &bquo;She's been in a coma since it happened six weeks ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;I remember now,&equo; said Burden, lifting the plastic strip curtain the Carousel Cafe hung up in hot weather to keep out wasps. 
 &bquo;The inquest was adjourned.&equo; 
 &bquo;Till Mrs. F. regained consciousness. 
 Presumably Camb's going to try and get her to tell him just why a seasoned driver like Fanshawe overturned his car on an empty road. 
 Some hopes! 
 What d'you fancy for lunch, Mike? 
 I'm going for the salad myself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Two ham salads,&equo; said Burden to the waitress. 
 He poured himself some water from a chilled carafe. 
 &bquo;Getting quite transatlantic the old Carousel,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;And about time too. 
 Not so long ago the water used to steam away like a perishing engine on these tables in hot weather. 
 What's the betting this McCoy's running a big racket, paying Charlie Hatton to leave his lorry unattended and paying him to keep other lorry drivers occupied whenever the chance presents itself? 
 Lorries are always getting hi-jacked. 
 They leave them in these lay-bys while they have a little kip or a cup of tea. 
 Hatton could have done a nice little distracting job there. 
 Fifty or a hundred quid a lorry depending on the load.&equo; 
 &bquo;In that case, why does McCloy kill the goose that lays the golden eggs?&equo; 
 &bquo;Because Hatton gets scared or fed-up and threatens to rat on him. 
 He may even have tried blackmail.&equo; 
 &bquo;I shouldn't be a bit surprised,&equo; said Burden, spreading butter on his roll. 
 The butter was almost liquid. 
 Like the rest of humanity, he reflected, the Carousel staff were disappointingly inconsistent. 
 &bquo;But my daughter wasn't in the car.&equo; 
 Seldom had Sergeant Camb felt so sorry for anyone as he did for this woman who lay against the piled pillows. 
 His heart ached for her. 
 And yet she was in one of the nicest private rooms in the hospital; she had a telephone and a television; her nightgown was a silly frou-frou of frills and spilling lace and on her thin fingers the rings &mdash; diamonds and sapphires in platinum &mdash; rattled as she clasped and unclasped the sheet. 
 It's true what they say, money can't buy happiness, thought the simple sergeant. 
 He had noticed there were no flowers in the room and only one &bquo;get well&equo; card on the table by the chair where the policeman sat. 
 From her sister, he supposed. 
 She hadn't anyone else now, not a soul in the world. 
 Her husband was dead and her daughter&hellip; 
 &bquo;I'm very very sorry, Mrs. Fanshawe,&equo; he said, &bquo;but your daughter was in the car. 
 She was travelling back to London with you and your husband.&equo; 
 &bquo;They didn't suffer,&equo; put in the young policewoman quickly. 
 &bquo;They can't have felt a thing.&equo; 
 Mrs. Fanshawe touched her forehead where the dyed hair showed half an inch of white at the roots. 
 &bquo;My head,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;My head aches. 
 I can't remember things, not details. 
 Everything's so vague.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't you worry,&equo; said Camb heartily. 
 You'll find you'll get your memory back in time. 
 You're going to get quite well, you know.&equo; 
 For what? 
 For widowhood, for childlessness? 
 &bquo;Your sister's been able to supply us with most of the details we need.&equo; 
 They had been close, Mrs. Fanshawe and Mrs. Browne, and there wasn't much about the Fanshawes Mrs. Browne hadn't known. 
 From her they had learned that Jerome Fanshawe had a bungalow at Eastover between Eastbourne and Seaford and that he and his wife and daughter had driven down there for a week's holiday on May 17th. 
 The daughter Nora had left her post as an English teacher in a German school before Easter. 
 She was between jobs, at a loose end, Camb had gathered, otherwise nothing would have induced her to accompany her parents. 
 But she had accompanied them. 
 Mrs. Browne had been at their Mayfair flat and seen them all off together. 
 They had left Eastover days earlier than had been expected. 
 Mrs. Browne couldn't account for that, unless it had been because of the wet weather. 
 Perhaps no one would ever know the reason, for Jerome Fanshawe's Jaguar had skidded, crashed and caught fire five miles from the hospital where the sole survivor now lay. 
 &bquo;I won't bother you for long,&equo; Camb said gently. 
 &bquo;Perhaps you can't remember much about the crash. 
 Do you think you could try and tell me what you do remember?&equo; 
 Dorothy Fanshawe had forgotten who these kind though tiresome people were, just as she had again forgotten where she was. 
 Her sister had been to see her and made her very tired and various strangers had moved her and pummelled her in a familiar manner that made her angry. 
 Then someone had told her that Jerome was dead and had waited for her to cry. 
 Mrs. Fanshawe had twisted her rings &mdash; they were a great comfort to her, those rings &mdash; and said: 
 &bquo;Then it's all mine now, mine and Nora's.&equo; 
 They thought she was wandering and they went away. 
 She was glad to see the back of them with their interfering ways and their lack of respect. 
 There was only one person she wanted to see and that was why she stared so searchingly into the young pretty face of the policewoman. 
 But she had been in a coma, she wasn't mad. 
 She knew very well this wasn't the right face. 
 &bquo;Am I in London?&equo; she asked clearly and briskly. 
 &bquo;No, Mrs. Fanshawe,&equo; said the sergeant, thinking how quavering and weak her voice was. 
 &bquo;You're in Stowerton Royal Infirmary, Stowerton in Sussex.&equo; 
 &bquo;You seem very well-informed,&equo; said Mrs. Fanshawe, pleased because she had succeeded so well in pulling herself together. 
 &bquo;Perhaps you can tell me why my daughter doesn't come to see me? 
 Haven't they told her I'm here? 
 Nora would want to know. 
 She'd come home.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Mrs. Fanshawe. 
 ..&equo; The policewoman sounded very wretched, almost distraught, and catching her eye, Sergeant Camb gave her a sharp reproving glance. 
 Better leave it, the look said. 
 Maybe it's more merciful this way. 
 Let her learn about it by degrees. 
 The mind had its own way of softening blows, he thought sententiously. 
 &bquo;Now back to the-er, accident,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Just try and see if you can tell me what happened when you left Eastover. 
 It was getting dark and there wasn't much traffic on the road, it being a Monday. 
 It had been raining and the read was wet. 
 Now, Mrs. Fanshawe?&equo; 
 &bquo;My husband was driving,&equo; she began and she wondered why the man's face wore such a sloppy expression. 
 Perhaps he had noticed her rings. 
 She slid them up and down her fingers, suddenly remembering that the five of them were worth nearly twenty thousand pounds. 
 &bquo;Jerome was driving&hellip;&equo; 
 What a silly name it was. 
 Like Three Men in a Boat. 
 That made her giggle, although the sound came out like a harsh crackle. 
 &bquo;I sat beside him, of course, and I was knitting. 
 I must have been knitting. 
 I always do when Jerome drives. 
 He drives so fast,&equo; she said querulously. 
 &bquo;Much too fast and he never takes any notice when I tell him to go slower, so I do my knitting. 
 To keep my mind off it, you know.&equo; 
 Mean and selfish Jerome was. 
 A man of fifty-five hadn't any business to drive like a crazy teenager. 
 She had told him that, but he had ignored her like he ignored everything else she ever said. 
 Still, she was used to being ignored. 
 Nora never took any notice of what she said either. 
 When she came to think of it, the only thing she and Jerome had ever agreed about was what a difficult, trying and utterly maddening creature Nora was. 
 It was exactly like her to go away and not get in touch with her parents. 
 Jerome would have something to say about that. 
 .. Then there swam pleasantly into her muddled mind the recollection that Jerome would never have anything to say about anything again, never drive at eighty-five or pick on Nora or do those other terrible and humiliating things. 
 Tonight, when she felt better, she would write to Nora and tell her her father was dead. 
 With Jerome out of the way and all that money for themselves, she felt they would have a much happier relationship&hellip; 
 &bquo;I was knitting a jumper for Nora,&equo; she said. 
 What a marvellous constitution she must have to remember that after all she'd been through! 
 &bquo;Not that she deserved it, the naughty girl.&equo; 
 Now, why had she said that? 
 Nora had been naughty, much naughtier than ever before, but for the life of her Dorothy Fanshawe couldn't remember of what that naughtiness had consisted. 
 She wished the policeman or whoever he was would wipe that mawish sheeplike expression off his face. 
 There was no need for anyone to feel sorry for her, Dorothy Fanshawe, of Astbury Mews, Upper Grosvenor Street, W.I. She was a merry widow now, rich in her own right, soon to be well again, the mother of a good-looking talented only daughter. 
 &bquo;I don't remember what we talked about,&equo; she said, &bquo;my late husband and I. Nothing, probably. 
 The road was wet and I kept telling him to go slower.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your daughter was in the back seat, Mrs. Fanshawe?&equo; 
 Oh! really, how absurd the man was! 
 &bquo;Nora was not in the car. 
 I keep telling you. 
 I keep telling you. 
 Nora went back to Germany. 
 No doubt she is in Germany now.&equo; 
 To the sergeant the jerky bumbling words sounded like the raving of a madwoman. 
 In spite of what the doctors said, it seemed to him probable that the accident had irremediably damaged her brain. 
 He didn't dare take it upon himself to enlighten her further. 
 God knew what harm he might do! 
 Sooner or later, if she ever got her reason back, she would realise that her daughter had resigned from this German job six weeks before the accident, that she hadn't breathed a word to her aunt or her friends about the possibility of her returning to Europe. 
 The girl's body had been identified by her aunt, Mrs. Browne. 
 She was dead and buried. 
 &bquo;I expect she is,&equo; he said soothingly. 
 &bquo;No doubt she is. 
 What made your husband swerve, Mrs. Fanshawe?&equo; 
 &bquo;I was knitting.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you hit something, did a tyre burst?&equo; 
 &bquo;I told you, I didn't look. 
 I was knitting.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did your husband cry out, say anything?&equo; 
 &bquo;I think he said &bquo;My God&equo;,&equo; said Mrs. Fanshawe. 
 She couldn't really remember anything, only that she had been knitting and then she had woken up in this bed with her nosy, bossy sister sitting beside her. 
 But Jerome was always saying &bquo;My God&equo; or even &bquo;My Christ&equo;. 
 He had a limited vocabulary and she had stopped telling him not to be blasphemous twenty years ago. 
 &bquo;I don't remember anything else,&equo; she said. 
 That was all they were going to get out of her. 
 She wasn't going to waste her strength. 
 She needed it for the letter she was going to write in a minute to Nora. 
 Camb looked compassionately at the quivering febrile mouth and the long unfiled nails that played with those rings. 
 Mrs. Fanshawe had told him nothing. 
 Perhaps he ought to have realised it was too soon, or his superiors ought to have realised. 
 They would have to go now anyway. 
 The young lady doctor had said ten minutes, but they must have been here twenty. 
 Here was the nurse coming now. 
 Funny uniforms they wear these days, he thought, eyeing the girl's navy-blue nylon overall and hat like a white forage cap. 
 Poor Mrs. Fanshawe was staring at her desperately. 
 No wonder, exhausted and broken-hearted as she was. 
 No, it wasn't Nora. 
 Just for a split second Mrs. Fanshawe had thought it was. 
 But Nora never wore an overall, she despised housework &mdash; and this girl was wearing an overall, not the rather smart dress for which Mrs. Fanshawe had first taken it. 
 She had a cap on her head too. 
 Was it possible that her sister had taken on a new maid for the Fanshawes' flat and not said anything about it? 
 More than possible, considering how interfering her sister was. 
 Interfering but irresponsible. 
 A responsible person would have sent for Nora by now. 
 &bquo;What's you name?&equo; 
 Mrs. Fanshawe said sharply. 
 &bquo;Rose, Mrs. Fanshawe. 
 Nurse Rose. 
 I've come to make you more comfy and bring you your tea. 
 You could drink a nice cup of tea, couldn't you? 
 I'm afraid you'll have torun along now Sergeant. 
 I can't allow my patient any setbacks, you know.&equo; 
 Very talkative, thought Mrs. Fanshawe. 
 Takes a lot upon herself. 
 She tried to sit up. 
 &bquo;Rose,&equo; she said, &bquo;I want to write a letter to my daughter, my daughter in Germany. 
 Will you fetch me writing paper and a pen, please?&equo; 
 She doesn't know, Camb thought, she's new. 
 Nobody's told her. 
 Just as well. 
 He intercepted the policewoman's glance and crushed it with a frown. 
 &bquo;We are getting better, aren't we?&equo; said the nurse skittishly. 
 &bquo;Writing letters! 
 Well, I don't know, I'm sure. 
 I'm certain you haven't got any paper of your own. 
 I'll tell you what I'll do, I'll just pop down the corridor and borrow some from Mrs. Goodwin in number four. 
 Then I'll post your letter when I go off duty, shall I?&equo; 
 &bquo;That will be very kind of you,&equo; said Mrs. Fanshawe austerely. 
 &bquo;Then you can bring the tea.&equo; 
 A pert girl and probably untrainable, she thought. 
 Time would show. 
 At any rate, Jerome wouldn't be there to upset this one, catch her in corners and smack her bottom like he had the Danish au pair. 
 Jerome was dead. 
 She'd always said he'd kill himself driving like that and now he had. 
 Why hadn't he killed her too? 
 What good fortune had decreed that she be saved and be sitting here in her own bed in her own flat? 
 But it wasn't her own flat. 
 Very carefully Mrs. Fanshawe marshalled her thoughts and her memories. 
 Jerome was dead, Nora was in Germany and she was in Some-thing-or-other Royal Infirmary. 
 A hospital. 
 Very thoughtful of someone to have engaged a maid for her in hospital. 
 Unless this Rose was a nurse. 
 On course, she must be a nurse. 
 What a fool I am, thought Mrs. Fanshawe. 
 I feel exactly as if I were having a very prolonged dream but every time I come out of it I'm so tired I fall back into it again. 
 The inaccurate information given by all these busybodies didn't help at all. 
 People were so inefficient these days. 
 First her sister had forgotten to inform Nora, then this policeman said Nora had been with her and Jerome in the Jaguar. 
 They must all think she was out of her mind. 
 As if a mother didn't know where her own daughter was! 
 Why, she even remembered Nora's address. 
 Goethestrasse 14, Koln, West Germany. 
 Mrs. Fanshawe was very proud of the way she wrote Koln like that instead of Cologne. 
 What reserves of strength and intellect she must have to remember details like that! 
 And after all she'd been through. 
 Presently the nurse came back with the paper. 
 &bquo;Thank you, Nurse,&equo; said Mrs. Fanshawe to show what a fine grasp of things she had. 
 She tried to hold the pen, but it zig-zagged all over the paper like that Planchette thing her father had used long ago. 
 &bquo;Why not let me write it for you?&equo; said Nurse Rose. 
 &bquo;Perhaps it would be better. 
 I'll dictate. 
 Shall I begin?&equo; 
 Nurse Rose had to exercise all her powers of concentration to sort out from the mumblings and digressions exactly what Mrs. Fanshawe wanted to say. 
 But she was a kind-hearted girl and, besides, it always paid to be attentive to patients in the private wing. 
 Last year when one of them had left after only a fortnight she had given Nurse Rose a travelling clock and a nearly full bottle of Rochas' Femme. 
 &bquo;&equo; Dearest Nora,&equo;&equo; she read aloud, &bquo;&equo; I am almost well again and think you should come and see me. 
 Poor Daddy would have wished it. 
 I expect auntie has told you everything and you have been too busy to come, but please come now. 
 We will let bygones be bygones. 
 Love from Mummy.&equo; 
 That all right, Mrs. Fanshawe? 
 I've got some stamps, enough to make up to ninepence. 
 I think I'll pop it in the post now when I go for my tea.&equo; 
 Coming back from the pillar box at the end of Charteris Road, Nurse Rose met the Private Wing sister. 
 &bquo;I've just been posting a letter for poor Mrs. Fanshawe, Sister,&equo; she said virtuously. 
 &bquo;I like to do what I can, you know. 
 Anything to cheer them up. 
 She was so keen to get a letter to her daughter off tonight.&equo; 
 &bquo;Her daughter's dead.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Sister, you don't mean it! 
 Oh God, how dreadful! 
 I never dreamt, I never guessed&hellip; 
 Ooh, Sister!&equo; 
 &bquo;You'd better get back on duty, Nurse, and do try not to be so impulsive. 
 The child who opened the door to him was the one that had been out in the fields with his father. 
 He was a boy of about seven, big for his age, aggressive looking and with food adhering to his face in greasy red and brown streaks. 
 &bquo;Who is it, Dominic?&equo; came a voice from the sleazy depths of this small and totally inadequate council house. 
 &bquo;A man,&equo; said Dominic simply. 
 &bquo;What does he want?&equo; 
 To put an end to all this pointless colloquy, Wexford stepped into the hall, then the living room. 
 Three more children were watching athletics on television. 
 The remains of lunch were still on the stained crumb-scattered tablecloth and a woman sat at the table feeding a baby from a bottle. 
 She might have been any age between thirty and sixty and Wexford set the lower limit so low only because of her young children. 
 Her hair was thin and fair and long, caught back with an elastic band, and her face was thin and long too, wizened and pinched. 
 A weariness that was as much chronic boredom as physical tiredness seemed the most dominant thing about her. 
 It was the sordid exhaustion of poverty, of overwork, of perpetual near-incarceration, of eternal nagging demands, and to be left alone just to sit for perhaps only five minutes in unthinking apathy was her sole remaining desire. 
 To this end she never wasted a word or gesture and when she saw Wexford she neither greeted him nor even lifted her head, but said to one of her little girls: 
 &bquo;Go and fetch your dad, Samantha.&equo; 
 Samantha jerked a thick black cat off her lap and trailed listlessly via the kitchen to the back garden. 
 A middle-class woman, a woman with more money and fewer children, might have apologised for the squalor and the smell of a hundred stale meals. 
 Mrs Cullam didn't even look at him and when he asked her at what time her husband had come home on Friday night she said laconically, &bquo;Quarter past eleven.&equo; 
 &bquo;How can you be so sure of the time?&equo; 
 &bquo;It was a quarter past eleven.&equo; 
 Mrs Cullam put the baby on the table among the crumbs, removing its napkin which she dropped on the floor, and said in the same low economical tone, &bquo;Get me another nappie, Georgina.&equo; 
 A strong smell of ammonia fought with the cabbage. 
 The baby, which was female, began to cry. 
 Mrs Cullam lit a cigarette and stood against the table, her hands hanging by her sides, the cigarette dangling from her mouth. 
 Georgina came back with a grey rag, sat down and watched her brother poke his fingers in the cat's ears. 
 &bquo;Leave the cat alone, Barnabas,&equo; said Mrs Cullam. 
 Her husband came, drying his hands on a tea cloth, the black dog cowering at his heels. 
 He nodded to Wexford and then he turned off the television. 
 &bquo;Get up, Samantha, and let the gentleman sit down.&equo; 
 The child took no notice and made no sound when her father slapped one arm and yanked her up by the other. 
 He viewed the room helplessly, paying particular attention to the discarded napkin, but there was no disgust on his face, only a vaguely resentful acceptance. 
 Wexford didn't take the vacant seat and something in his expression must have told Cullam he wanted privacy, for he said to his wife, &bquo;Can't you get them kids out of here?&equo; 
 Mrs. Cullam shrugged and the ash from her cigarette fell into a plate of congealing gravy. 
 She hoisted the baby on to her hip and dragging a chair close up to the television set, sat down and stared at the blank screen. 
 &bquo;Leave the cat alone, I said,&equo; she remarked without heat. 
 &bquo;What were you wanting?&equo; 
 Cullam asked. 
 &bquo;We'll go into your kitchen, if you don't mind, Mr Cullam.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's in a right old mess.&equo; 
 &bquo;Never mind.&equo; 
 Mrs Cullam made no comment. 
 She switched on the television without looking up. 
 Two of the children began to fight in the depths of their armchair. 
 Wexford followed their father into the kitchen. 
 There was nowhere to sit so, pushing aside the handles of four encrusted saucepans, he leant against the gas cooker. 
 &bquo;I only want to know who McCloy is,&equo; he said mildly. 
 Cullam gave him a look of not altogether comfortable cunning. 
 &bquo;How d'you know about McCloy, anyway?&equo; 
 &bquo;Come on now, you know I can't tell you that.&equo; 
 The children were screaming now above the sound of the racy athletics commentary. 
 Wexford closed the door and he heard Mrs Cullam say, &bquo;Leave the bleeding cat alone, Barnabas.&equo; 
 She had wasted a word. 
 &bquo;You know who he is,&equo; Wexford said. 
 &bquo;Now you can tell me.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 Honest I don't.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't know who he is, but last night in the pub you asked Mr Hatton if he'd been seeing much of McCloy lately. 
 You wouldn't touch McCloy because you like to sleep quiet in your bed.&equo; 
 &bquo;I tell you, I don't know who he is and I never saw him.&equo; 
 Wexford removed his elbow from its dangerous proximity to a half-full plate of cold chips. 
 &bquo;You didn't like Mr Hatton very much, did you? 
 You wouldn't walk home with him, though he was going your way. 
 So you went on ahead and maybe you hung about a bit under the trees.&equo; 
 Pursuing the line, he watched Cullam's big beefy face begin to lose colour. 
 &bquo;I reckon you must have done, Cullam. 
 A strong young fellow like you doesn't take thirty-five minutes to get here from the Kingsbrook bridge.&equo; 
 In a low, resentful voice, Cullam said, &bquo;I was sick. 
 I was nearly home and I come over queer. 
 I'm not used to scotch and I went into the gents down by the station to be sick.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let me congratulate you on your powers of recovery. 
 You were fit enough to be out on a country walk at seven-thirty this morning. 
 Or were you just popping back to see you'd left Hatton neat and tidy? 
 I want to see the clothes you wore last night.&equo; 
 &bquo;They're out on the line.&equo; 
 Wexford looked at him, his eyebrows almost vanishing into the vestiges of his hair, and the implications in that look were unmistakable. 
 Cullam fidgeted, he moved to the crock-filled sink, leaning on it compressing his lips. 
 &bquo;I washed them,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Pullover and trousers and a shirt. 
 They was &mdash; well, they were in a bit of a state.&equo; 
 He shifted his feet.&equo; 
 &bquo;Charming,&equo; Wexford said unkindly. 
 &bquo;You washed them? 
 What d'you have a wife for?&equo; 
 For the first time he noticed the washing machine, a big gleaming automatic affair, and the only object in that kitchen that was not stained or chipped or coated with clotted food drips. 
 He opened the back door and eyed the sagging clothesline from which the three garments Cullam had named hung between a row of napkins. 
 &bquo;The blessings of modern mechanisation,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Very nice too. 
 I often remark these days how the roles of the sexes have been reversed.&equo; 
 His voice became deceptively friendly and Cullam licked his thick lips. 
 &bquo;A man can be dead tired after a week's work but he can still give his wife a helping hand. 
 One touch of a button and the family wash comes out whiter than white. 
 In fact, a gadget like that turns chores into pleasure, you might say. 
 Men are all little boys at heart, when all's said and done, and it's not only women that like to have these little playthings about to make a break in the daily round. 
 Besides, they cost so much, you might as well get some fun out of them. 
 Don't tell me that little toy cost you less than a hundred and twenty, Cullam.&equo; 
 &bquo;A hundred and twenty-five,&equo; said Cullam with modest pride. 
 He was quite disarmed and, advancing upon the machine, he opened the gleaming porthole. 
 &bquo;You set your programme&hellip;&equo; 
 A last uneasy look at the chief inspector told him his visitor was genuinely interested, paying no more than a routine call. 
 &bquo;Put in your powder,&equo; he said, &bquo;and Bob's your uncle.&equo; 
 &bquo;I knew a fellow,&equo; Wexford lied ruminatively, &bquo;a lorry driver like yourself. 
 Big family too and we all know what inroads a big family makes. 
 He got in bad company, I'm sorry to say. 
 His wife kept on at him, you see, wanting more gear about the house. 
 He'd already turned a blind eye when a couple of his lorries got hi-jacked. 
 Well, you can't call it a crime, can you, looking the other way in a cafe when somebody's nicking your vehicle from a lay-by?&equo; 
 Cullam closed the porthole, keeping his head turned. 
 &bquo;They paid well, this bad company. 
 Mind you, this fellow jibbed a bit when they offered him two hundred to knock off a bloke who wouldn't play along with them, but not for long. 
 He reckoned he'd a right to nice things the same as this bad company he'd got in with. 
 And why not? 
 We're all equal these days. 
 Share and share alike, this fellow said. 
 So he hung about in a lonely spot one night, just where the other fellow was due to pass by &mdash; and well, Bob's your uncle, as you so succinctly put it. 
 He's doing twelve years, as a matter of fact.&equo; 
 Cullam looked at him, trucently disillusioned. 
 &bquo;I saved up my overtime for that washer,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Sure it wasn't McCloy's little dropsy for services rendered? 
 Isn't a man's life worth a hundred and twenty nicker, Cullam? 
 There's a sump on that machine of yours, you know. 
 I can't help asking myself if there's blood and hair and brains in that sump, you know. 
 Oh, you needn't look like that. 
 We could find it. 
 We can take that machine apart this afternoon, and your drains. 
 They're a funny council, Sewingbury. 
 I knew a family &mdash; six children in that case there were &mdash; they got evicted neck and crop just because they cracked a drainpipe. 
 Vandalism, the council called it. 
 We'll get your drains up, Cullam, but we're busy right now. 
 I don't reckon we could find the labour to get them put back again.&equo; 
 &bquo;You bastard,&equo; said Cullam. 
 &bquo;I didn't hear that. 
 My hearing's not what it was, but I haven't got one foot in the grave. 
 I'd like to sit down, though. 
 You can take that rubbish off that chair and wipe it, will you?&equo; 
 Cullam sat on his washing machine, his long legs dangling. 
 Behind the closed door the programme had changed from athletics to wrestling and once more the baby had begun to cry. 
 &bquo;I told you,&equo; said its father. 
 &bquo;I don't know who McCloy is and I don't. 
 I just said that to Charlie to needle him. 
 Always bragging and boasting, he got on my wick.&equo; 
 Wexford didn't have to absorb any more of the squalor to see what Cullam meant. 
 This house was the very embodiment of sleazy discomfort. 
 It was a discomfort which would have brief pause only while its inhabitants slept and it extended from the top to the lowest level. 
 The man and his wife were weighed down by almost every burden known to the philoprogenitive, ill-paid artisan; their home overcrowded, even their animals wretchedly tormented. 
 The parents had neither the character nor the love to make coping and organisation tenable. 
 He remembered Charlie Hatton's brand-new flat, the pretty young wife with her smart clothes. 
 These two men did the same sort of job. 
 Or did they? 
 &bquo;If I tell you how it was,&equo; Cullam said, &bquo;you won't believe me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe not, try me.&equo; 
 Cullam put his elbows on his knees and leant forward. 
 &bquo;It was in a cafe,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;One of them places where they have rooms for drivers to kip down for the night. 
 Up on the A1 between Stamford and Grantham. 
 I was coming up to my eleven hours &mdash; we're not supposed to drive for more than eleven hours &mdash; and I went in and there was Charlie Hatton. 
 I'd seen his lorry in the lay-by. 
 We had a bite to eat and got talking.&equo; 
 &bquo;What load do you carry?&equo; 
 &bquo;Tyres, rubber tyres. 
 While we was having our meal I looked out of the window and there was a fellow there &mdash; in the lay-by &mdash; sitting in a black car. 
 I don't know why, but I didn't much like the look of him. 
 I said so to Charlie, but all he said was I was like an old woman. 
 He was always saying that to folks. 
 Then he got me and two more drivers to go into his room for a hand of pontoon. 
 He said it was quieter in there, but I couldn't see the lay-by from his room and after a bit I went outside. 
 The fellow in the car was still there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you take the number? 
 Could you describe him?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know.&equo; 
 Cullam gave him a shifty look. 
 &bquo;I never took the number. 
 I sat in the cab for half an hour and then this fellow went off. 
 Charlie'd said he wanted to phone Lilian and when I come back over the road he was in a phone box. 
 I wanted a light for my fag &mdash; I'd run out of matches &mdash; so I opened the door of the box and just asked Charlie for a light. 
 Well, I don't reckon he'd heard me coming. 
 &bquo;Tell Mr. McCloy it's no dice,&equo; I heard him say and it was then I said had he got a match? 
 He jumped out of his skin like he'd been stung. 
 &bquo;What the hell are you up to,&equo; he shouts at me, &bquo;interfering with my private phone calls&equo; He was a white as a sheet.&equo; 
 &bquo;You connected this call with the man in the car?&equo; 
 &bquo;I reckon I did,&equo; Cullam said, &bquo;I did afterwards when I thought about it. 
 My mind went back a couple of months to when Charlie'd asked me if I'd like to make a bit on the side. 
 I wasn't interested and that was all there was. 
 But I never forgot the name McCloy and when Charlie got so cocky in the pub I thought I'd needle him a bit. 
 That's all.&equo; 
 &bquo;When was the cafe incident, Cullam?&equo; 
 &bquo;Come again?&equo; 
 &bquo;When did you overhear Hatton's phone conversation?&equo; 
 &bquo;Way back in the winter. 
 January, I reckon. 
 Not long after Charlie had his lorry pinched and got hit on the head.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right. 
 That'll do for now, but I may want to talk to you again.&equo; 
 Wexford went back through the Cullam's living room. 
 The children had disappeared. 
 Mrs Cullam still sat in front of the television, the baby asleep now in her lap, the dog lying across her slippered feet. 
 She moved her head as he crossed the room and for a moment he thought she was going to speak to him. 
 Then he saw that the movement was a mere craning of the neck because for an instant he had obstructed her view of the screen. 
 Dominic, Barnabas, Samantha and Georgina were sitting on the kerb poking sticks through the drain cover. 
 Wexford wasn't inclined to be sentimental over the Cullams but he couldn't help being faintly touched that they who were poor in everything had been affluent, extravagant and imaginative in one respect. 
 If they never gave their children another thing, they had at least endowed them with names usually reserved to the upper classes. 
 Dominic, whose face was still coated with food, looked up trucently as he passed and Wexford said, because he couldn't resist it: 
 What's the baby called?&equo; 
 &bquo;Jane,&equo; said Dominic simply and without surprise. 
 When Wexford got home for his tea Clytemnestra wagged her darning-wool tail at him but she didn't get out of his chair. 
 Wexford scowled at her. 
 &bquo;Where's Sheila?&equo; he asked his wife. 
 &bquo;Dentist's.&equo; 
 &bquo;She never said anything about toothache.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't go to the dentist's because you've got toothache any more. 
 You go for a check-up. 
 She's having that molar of hers crowned.&equo; 
 &bquo;So I suppose she won't feel up to taking that creature out in the morning. 
 Well, she needn't put it on to me. 
 I've got enough on my plate.&equo; 
 But Sheila danced in gaily at six o'clock and smiled at her father to show off the triumph of orthodontics. 
 &bquo;There, isn't that great?&equo; 
 To satisfy her Wexford peered into the perfect mouth. 
 &bquo;That filling was getting a bit of a drag,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Very shy-making for close-ups. 
 An actress has to think about these things.&equo; 
 &bquo;I bet Bernhardt never bothered about her teeth,&equo; said Wexford to annoy her. 
 Sheila opened her eyes wide and fixed her father with a precisely constructed look of wistful adoration. 
 &bquo;Did you often see Bernhardt when you were a young man, Pop?&equo; she asked. 
 Wexford's reply was an ill-tempered snort. 
 He pushed a cup of tea to his daughter who rejected it in favour of cold milk. 
 This she sipped slowly, very conscious of the picture she made in her cream linen dress, her pale hair slightly but attractively disordered, Roman sandal thongs binding her long legs to the knee. 
 Wexford wondered what life held for her. 
 Would she succeed and the future be a succession of triumphs, starring parts, world tours, fame, the increasing terror of growing old? 
 Or would she marry some young idiot like this Sebastian and forget all her aspirations in the possession of two children and a semi? 
 Because he was a father and no longer young he confessed to himself that he would prefer the latter. 
 He wanted her to be safe. 
 Nothing on earth would have made him tell her so. 
 No such thoughts troubled her, he fancied. 
 Living in the moment, she drank her milk and began to prattle on about her visit to the dentist. 
 &bquo;If I ever settle down&hellip; 
 &equo; Sheila said this in much the tone of incredulity as she might have said, &bquo;If I ever die.&equo; 
 &bquo;If I ever settle down, I wouldn't mind a house like his. 
 Not in Kingsmarkham of course. 
 Stratford might be nice or the Cotswolds near Stratford.&equo; 
 &bquo;Within commuting distance,&equo; Wexford put in slyly. 
 His daughter ignored him. 
 &bquo;One of those black and white houses it is. 
 Terribly ancient and full of atmosphere. 
 Of course, the surgery part's all modern. 
 New copies of Nova and Elle. 
 I thought that progressive.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thoughtful too,&equo; said Wexford, &bquo;what with everyone in Kingsmarkham being bi-lingual.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your generation just wasn't educated, Pop, but I can tell you I hardly know anyone who doesn't read French. 
 Anyway, the old fuddy-duddies can look at the antiques.&equo; 
 Sheila put her glass down and tossed her head. 
 &bquo;Gorgeous painting on the walls, and some marvellous glass sculpture.&equo; 
 Sounds like the police station, Wexford thought. 
 &bquo;And where is this shrine of culture?&equo; he said aloud. 
 &bquo;Ploughman's Lane.&equo; 
 &bquo;He wouldn't be called Vigo would he?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mm-hm, he would.&equo; 
 Sheila sat on the sofa and began painting shiny black lines on her eyelids. 
 &bquo;It's about time you and Mummy stopped going to that dreary old Richardson in the High Street and switched to Mr Vigo.&equo; 
 The most difficult feat of her artistry completed, she started to stroke her lashes with a mascara wand. 
 &bquo;Mr Vigo is an absolute dream. 
 One of those fair-haired characters with a craggy face. 
 Madly sexy.&equo; 
 Wexford winced and hoped she hadn't seen. 
 His daughters were still little girls to him. 
 Who the hell did this craggy fair fellow think he was, projecting his dreamy sexiness at his little girl? 
 &bquo;Of course he's not young,&equo; said Sheila serenely. 
 &bquo;All of thirty-five, I daresay. 
 One foot in the grave and the other on a bar of soap.&equo; 
 &bquo;About thirty-five,&equo; said Sheila seriously. 
 She held her eyelashes up with two fingers to curl them. 
 &bquo;He's got a baby of six months and &mdash; something rather tragic. 
 His older child's a mongol. 
 Ghastly, isn't it? 
 It's eight now and Mr Vigo hasn't seen it for years. 
 He and his wife tried and tried to have another one and they did, but it took them all those years. 
 Of course he worships the baby.&equo; 
 &bquo;How do you know all this?&equo; 
 Wexford asked. 
 She was a detective's daughter all right. 
 &bquo;I thought you went to get your tooth done, not do a survey.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, we had a long talk,&equo; Sheila said airily. 
 &bquo;I don't suppose you can understand, but I'm interested in human nature. 
 If I'm going to be a real actress I'll have to know what makes people tick. 
 I'm getting quite good at summing people up.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bully for you,&equo; said her father sourly. 
 &bquo;I've been trying for forty years and the margin of error's still about eighty per cent.&equo; 
 Sheila looked at herself in her handbag mirror. 
 &bquo;Mr Vigo's got a very smooth sophisticated manner. 
 Cool, if you know what I mean. 
 I sometimes think dentists have a very interesting relationship with their patients. 
 They've got to be nice, have the right psychological approach, otherwise you'd never go back to them again, would you? 
 It's such an intimate thing. 
 I mean, can you think of any other situation, Pop, when a man gets so close to a woman except when he's actually making love to her?&equo; 
 &bquo;I sincerely hope nothing like that happened.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Pop&hellip; 
 I was just saying what it was like. 
 I was making a sort of comparison.&equo; 
 Sheila giggled and twisted a strand of hair around one finger. 
 &bquo;Although, when I was going he did give me a sort of squeeze and said I'd got the loveliest mouth he'd ever seen.&equo; 
 &bquo;My God!&equo; said Wexford, getting up. 
 &bquo;If you don't mind what you say to your father, you might remember he's also a detective chief inspector.&equo; 
 He paused and then said, not realising the effect his words would have, &bquo;I may go along and see this Vigo.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Pop!&equo; 
 Sheila wailed. 
 &bquo;Not because of your lovely mouth, my dear. 
 In pursuance of an enquiry of my own.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, don't you dare&hellip;&equo; 
 All this time Mrs. Wexford had placidly eating ginger biscuits, but now she looked up and said calmly: 
 &bquo;What a silly girl you are. 
 I often think it's a blessing intelligence isn't in the interpretive arts. 
 If you've finished with your face you'd better take that dog out.&equo; 
 At the word dog, Clytemnestra uncurled herself. 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; said Sheila meekly. 
 They stood under the willow trees, looking at the river. 
 Anyone who didn't know them might have taken them for a couple of businessmen out for a Sunday afternoon stroll. 
 But almost everyone in Kingsmarkham knew them and knew also by now that this was the spot where Charlie Hatton had been murdered. 
 &bquo;I said we'd have to talk to everyone in the darts club,&equo; said Burden, stopping down at the water's edge, &bquo;and I reckon we have. 
 Funny, isn't it? 
 Pertwee's the only one who could put up with Hatton for a moment, but no one's willing to come out with it. 
 It's always the others who were daggers drawn with him. 
 The one you're talking to is all tolerance and forbearance. 
 The farthest he'll go is to admit a sort of resentment. 
 Does a man do murder because a mate of his riles him in a pub or because he's got more money than he has?&equo; 
 &bquo;He might if he was going to get some of the money,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;A hundred pounds is a lot to a man like Cullam. 
 We're going to have to watch Cullam, see if he does some big spending in the next few days. 
 I'm not at all happy about the way he washed the clothes he was wearing on Friday night.&equo; 
 Burden was advancing gingerly across the river, trying not to get his feet wet. 
 He trod on the projecting stones which the water lapped without covering. 
 Then he bent down and said, &bquo;There's your weapon.&equo; 
 From the bank Wexford followed the direction of his pointing finger. 
 All but one of the stones were furred at their perimeters and partly on their surfaces with green weed. 
 Burden was pointing to the only one that looked bare, as if until very recently it had lain with its exposed area embedded in the river's gravelly floor. 
 He squatted precariously and lifted the stone in both hands. 
 Then he eased himself to his feet and scrambled back to Wexford. 
 It was a big stone, not round, but elongated and shaped rather like a mandolin. 
 The side which had lain on the river bed was green and moss-grown and there was nothing about it except for its shape and its anomalous position in the water to show that it might have been used as a lethal weapon. 
 Wexford grasped it in both his hands, raised it high and brought it down hard to meet the empty air. 
 Hatton had been walking along in the dark and someone had waited for him among the willows and the brambles, the stone ready for use. 
 Full of whisky, his thoughts fuddled and far away, Hatton had given warning of his approach. 
 He had been whistling and probably not bothering to tread softly. 
 The stone had been raised high just as Wexford was raising it now but brought down that time on the back of Hatton's skull. 
 Once, twice, more than that? 
 As many times as it took to kill. 
 Then Hatton had rolled into the water. 
 His killer had rifled his wallet before casting the stone into the stream. 
 Wexford thought all these things and he knew Burden was following his thoughts, matching them, so he didn't bother to say anything. 
 He dropped the stone and it rolled a little before falling into the water with a soft plop. 
 Across the meadows he could see the flats of the council estate, the sun striking their plate-glass windows and making them blaze as if the whole place was on fire. 
 &bquo;Since we've come so far,&equo; he said, &bquo;we may as well have another chat with Mrs Hatton.&equo; 
 Her mother was with her and three other people. 
 Jack Pertwee sat on the smart checked tweed sofa holding the hand of a girl with a monumental pile of black hair and eyelashes like shoe brushes. 
 Mrs Hatton and her mother were both in black, smart unseasonable black relieved with a great deal of showy costume jewellery. 
 The widow's suit looked brand-new and Wexford couldn't help wondering if she had actually been out the previous afternoon to buy it. 
 She wore a white blouse with an ostentatious frilly jabot and a big paste spray on one lapel. 
 Her stockings were dark and her shoes, though also apparently new, the outdated stiletto-heeled pointed kind of gleaming black patent. 
 She looked as if she were about to set off for a provincial cocktail party, an office party of female executives. 
 At first Wexford felt a curious distaste and then he thought about the dead man and what he knew of him. 
 This was the way Charlie Hatton would have like his widow to look, brave, defiant, bedizened. 
 The last thing a cocky little man like Hatton would want was a kind of spiritual suttee. 
 He surveyed the rest of the company. 
 Plainly they had interrupted a mourning tea party. 
 The girl on the sofa must be the bride whose nuptials Hatton's death had deferred. 
 And the other man? 
 &bquo;My brother, Mr Bardsley,&equo; said Mrs Hatton. 
 She spoke in a low dutiful voice. 
 Her eyes were swollen under the thick green and black make-up. 
 &bquo;They were all very fond of Charlie. 
 Would you like a cup of tea? 
 You can if you want. 
 You're welcome.&equo; 
 &bquo;We won't, thanks, Mrs Hatton.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, sit down then, there's plenty of room.&equo; 
 She said it proudly, indicating the several empty chairs. 
 They were good chairs, upholstered and cared for, not the uncomfortable dining seats with hard backs a less affluent hostess would be obliged to offer latecomers. 
 Looking at the branched hanging lamp of teak and smoky glass, the velvet curtains and the big colour television set, Wexford decided that Hatton had done his wife proud. 
 Cullam and he were both lorry drivers, both lived in council accommodation, but that was all they had in common. 
 He glanced at Bardsley, a fair rabbity man, like his sister but less well-favoured, and he observed his suit. 
 It was very likely his best suit &mdash; today of all days he would surely wear his best suit &mdash; but it was a cheap off-the-peg affair. 
 &bquo;Please forgive me, Mrs Hatton, if I ask a few routine questions,&equo; he said. 
 She gave him a pleased earnest nod. 
 &bquo;You and Mr Hatton were in business together, I understand, Mr Bardsley?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right.&equo; 
 &bquo;Was it a full partnership?&equo; 
 Bardsley put his teacup down and said in a melancholy voice, &bquo;I was thinking of taking him into partnership, but business hasn't been that good lately. 
 As it was, he just worked for me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Would you mind telling me what wages you paid him?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I don't know&hellip; 
 I don't rightly like to.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course he don't,&equo; Jack Pertwee suddenly interrupted belligerently. 
 &bquo;What's it got to do with what happened on Friday?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right, Jack.&equo; 
 murmured the girl and she squeezed his hand. 
 &bquo;You can see Charlie did all right for himself. 
 You've only got to look around you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't make trouble, Jack,&equo; Mrs Hatton said with that peculiar intense control of hers. 
 &bquo;The officers are only doing what they have to.&equo; 
 She fingered her brooch uneasily. 
 &bquo;Charlie usually brought home a bit over twenty pounds a week. 
 That's right, isn't it, Jim?&equo; 
 JimBardsley looked unhappy about it and his voice became aggressive. 
 &bquo;I've been lucky to make that much myself lately,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Charlie was one of the sort that make a little go a long way. 
 I reckon he was careful.&equo; 
 Marilyn Thompson tossed her head and a lock of hair drifted from the elaborate structure. 
 &bquo;He wasn't mean, anyway,&equo; she flared, &bquo;if that's what you mean by careful. 
 There's not many men who aren't even relations that'd give someone a record player for a wedding present.&equo; 
 &bquo;I never said he was mean, Marilyn.&equo; 
 &bquo;It makes me sick. 
 What you want to do is find who killed him.&equo; 
 The girl's hands trembled and she clenched them. 
 &bquo;Give us a cig, Jack.&equo; 
 Her hands enclosed Pertwee's wrist as he held the lighter and they were no more steady than his. 
 &bquo;You lot,&equo; she muttered, &bquo;you lot don't reckon nothing to a working man. 
 If he hasn't got a nice home you call him a layabout.&equo; 
 She glared at Wexford, pushing back her hair. 
 &bquo;And if he's got things like your class take for granted you jump right on him, say he must have nicked them. 
 Class, class, class,&equo; she said, tears trembling on the brush-bristle lashes. 
 &bquo;That's all you think about.&equo; 
 &bquo;Wait till the revolution comes,&equo; said Bardsley nastily. 
 &bquo;Oh, shut up, the pair of you,&equo; Mrs Hatton said shrilly. 
 She turned to Wexford, her controlled dignity returning. 
 &bquo;My husband did overtime,&equo; she said, &bquo;and he had his side lines.&equo; 
 Side lines, Wexford thought. 
 He got a little overtime and he made it go a long way. 
 The man had colour television, false teeth worth two hundred pounds; he gave his friend a record player for a wedding present. 
 Wexford had seen that glass and teak lamp in a Kingsmarkham shop and noted it had been priced at twenty-five pounds, one and a quarter times Hatton's weekly wage. 
 When he was killed he had had a hundred pounds on him. 
 &bquo;If he's got things like your class take for granted,&equo; the girl had said, &bquo;you say he must have nicked them.&equo; 
 Curious, really, Wexford reflected, watching her huddled now in the crook of Pertwee's arm. 
 Of course she was very young, probably got a Communist shop steward for a father, and doubtless went about sneering at people better-educated and better-spoken than herself. 
 It was an aggressive type that had even reached Kingsmarkham, a type that talked pacifism and the rights of man and brotherly love without the energy or courage to do anything that might bring these desirable conditions nearer. 
 And yet he said nothing to provoke her outburst. 
 Neither for that matter had Bardsley beyond hinting that Hatton had been prudent. 
 Had she risen to this intangible slight bait because she knew Hatton's wealth had been dishonestly come by? 
 If she knew it, green and uncouth as she was, Pertwee would know it also. 
 Everyone in this room but Burden and himself might know it. 
 Not for the first time he reflected on the power of grief. 
 It is the perfect unassailable defence. 
 Pertwee had already employed it the previous morning effectively to terminate interrogation. 
 Mrs Hatton, even more expertly, kept it under a piteous control that only a brute would have the brashness to disregard. 
 She was moving about the room now, balancing painfully but stoically on her high heels, taking empty cups and plates from each of her guests with a gentle murmur for every one of them. 
 Wexford took in the looks that passed to her from each of her visitors, her mother's merely solicitous, Pertwee's indicative of deep affection, Bardsley's shifty, while the thwarted bride leaned forward, stuck out her chin and nodded her utter committed partisanship. 
 &bquo;Did your husband have a bank account, Mrs Hatton?&equo; 
 Burden asked as she passed his chair. 
 The sun was full on her face, showing every stroke and grain of make-up, but at the same time driving expression from it. 
 She nodded, &bquo;At the Midland,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'd like to see his paying-in book.&equo; 
 &bquo;What for?&equo; 
 The truculent harsh voice was Pertwee's. 
 Wexford ignored him and followed the widow to the sideboard from a drawer of which she took a long cream-coloured book. 
 He handed it to Burden and said, apparently inconsequentially: 
 &bquo;When did your husband get his false teeth, Mrs Hatton?&equo; 
 Pertwee's muttered &bquo;Bloody nosy-parker&equo; made her flinch a little and throw a desperate glance over her shoulder. 
 &bquo;He'd always had them. 
 Had them since he was twenty&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;This present set?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, no. 
 They were new. 
 He went to Mr Vigo for them about a month back.&equo; 
 Nodding, Wexford eyed the paying-in book over Burden's shoulder and what he saw astonished him far more than any of Hatton's prodigality. 
 Some three-quarters of all the slips in the book had been torn out and with the exception of three, all the stubs had been torn out too. 
 On the most recent remaining stub the date was April and on that occasion Hatton had paid into his bank account the modest sum of five and fourpence. 
 &bquo;Fourth dividend on the pools that was,&equo; Mrs Hatton said with a miserable gulp. 
 The other two stubs were filled in each with amounts of two pounds. 
 &bquo;Mrs Hatton,&equo; he said, beckoning her into a corner. 
 &bquo;The purpose of these stubs in a paying-in book is for the holder to have a record of the amount of money he had deposited in his bank. 
 Can you suggest to me why Mr Hatton tore them out? 
 They must have been filled in at the bank either by Mr Hatton himself or else by the cashier who was attending to him.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a mystery to me. 
 Charlie never talked about money to me. 
 He always said&hellip; 'She gulped again and a tear trickled through the make-up. 
 &bquo;He always said, &bquo;Don't worry your head about that. 
 When we got married I promised I'd give you everything you want and so I will. 
 You name it, you can have it.&equo;&equo; 
 She bent her head and began to sob. 
 &bquo;He was one in a million was Charlie. 
 He'd have got me the moon out of the sky if I'd wanted it.&equo; 
 The girl Marilyn got up and put her arms around her friend. 
 &bquo;Oh, Charlie, Charlie&hellip;!&equo; 
 The drawer was open, Hatton's cheque book exposed. 
 Wexford leafed through it and saw that Hatton had paid twenty-five pounds for the lamp on May 22nd. 
 Thirty pounds had been paid to Lucrece Ltd, High Street, Kingsmarkham (his wife's wedding outfit?) and another thirty in the same week, the last week of May, to Excelsior Electrics, Stowerton (Pertwee's record player?). 
 Then came three blank stubs, lastly one filled in for fifty pounds cash. 
 There was no stub for Vigo, the dentist. 
 Hatton must have paid for his teeth in cash. 
 He put the books back in the drawer and stood waiting for Mrs Hatton to recover. 
 Her mother and brother had departed to the kitchen from where Wexford could hear their muted whisperings and the funereally careful clink of cups. 
 The widow's eye make-up had transferred itself to Marilyn Thompson's handkerchief. 
 &bquo;I keep breaking down,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I can't seem to stop myself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, but just reckon what you've been through, love.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know what I'd do without you two.&equo; 
 Pertwee said nothing but his baleful pugnacious look was absurd in its intensity and Wexford was almost embarrassed. 
 He said lightly, &bquo;Does the name McCloy mean anything to you, Mr Pertwee?&equo; 
 That it meant nothing, less than nothing, to Mrs Hatton he was sure at once. 
 Of Pertwee and the girl he was less certain. 
 The latter's lower lip stuck out and her eyes flickered. 
 For an instant she was a primitive creature looking for a hole to hide in. 
 Pertwee had reddened, possibly only with anger at Wexford's persistence. 
 &bquo;Sounds Irish,&equo; was all he said. 
 &bquo;Doesn't it also sound familiar?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not to me, I don't know any McCloy. 
 Never heard of him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Strange then that you should have discussed this Mr McCloy with your friends in the Dragon on Friday. 
 Is he a local man?&equo; 
 &bquo;I told you I'd never heard of him.&equo; 
 Pertwee bit his lip and looked down at his knees. 
 Wexford watched him feel for the girl's hand, but she was occupied with Mrs Hatton, dabbing at her face and smoothing her hair. 
 Forsaken, deserted, the hand came up to Pertwee's brow and pushed into the greasy black waves. 
 &bquo;Can't you leave us alone now?&equo; he pleaded and Wexford felt impotently that once again the man was enclosing himself within the unimpregnable defence of grief. 
 &bquo;I never knew what went on on the lorries,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I wasn't Charlie's only friend. 
 He had hundreds of friends. 
 Ask Jim Bardsley, ask Cullam.&equo; 
 Pertwee's eyes were glazed and dull. 
 &bquo;Let someone else do dirt on his memory.&equo; 
 Jim Bardsley had an apron tied round his waist. 
 He moved gingerly about the kitchen, putting away crockery, as if he were afraid his touch might damage or contaminate the pristine glory of its equipment. 
 The Hatton flat and the Cullam house had one thing in common, an automatic washing machine. 
 Mrs Hatton had plenty besides mixers, electric tin-openers, a steam iron as well as the huge scarlet refrigerator and the cooker with eye-level grill. 
 &bquo;You transport this kind of stuff, don't you, Mr Bardsley?&equo; 
 Burden asked. 
 &bquo;I suppose Mr Hatton got it wholesale.&equo; 
 &bquo;I daresay,&equo; Bardsley said cagily. 
 &bquo;Irons, electric fires and so on, was that the load you lost when Mr Hatton's lorries were hi-jacked?&equo; 
 Bardsley nodded unhappily. 
 &bquo;Doubtless you were insured?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not the second time, not in March when they knocked it off at Stamford. 
 I had to stand the loss myself.&equo; 
 Bardsley untied his apron and hung up the tea cloth that, appropriately enough in this flat, was a large linen facsimile of a pound note. 
 &bquo;Set me back, I can tell you. 
 I reckon poor old Charlie was glad I hadn't taken him into partnership. 
 Mind you, they found the lorry both times. 
 It wasn't damaged, just the stuff gone, that's all. 
 That second time Charlie'd pulled into a lay-by and gone to sleep at the wheel. 
 The villains didn't harm him, thank God. 
 Just tied him up and put a gag in his mouth.&equo; 
 &bquo;But he was injured on the previous occasion?&equo; 
 &bquo;Had a bit of concussion,&equo; Bardsley said. 
 &bquo;There wasn't any mark to show, bar a bit of a bruise.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ever heard of the name McCloy, Mr Bardsley?&equo; 
 &bquo;It doesn't ring a bell,&equo; said Bardsley and Burden believed him. 
 &bquo;Mind you,&equo; he added, &bquo;I've seen my own stuff flogged off in the market here. 
 Known it was mine but couldn't prove it. 
 You know what them stallholders are, up to all the tricks.&equo; 
 He scratched his head. 
 &bquo;I was a bit too nosy that time and I haven't seen the stall here since.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you do, Mr Bardsley, come straight to us. 
 Don't argue about it, come straight to us.&equo; 
 &bquo;OK,&equo; said Bardsley, but without hope. 
 Burden left him contemplating the printed tea cloth as if, were it possible to transmute it to paper, reduce its size and multiply it manifold, he would be a happy man. 
 &bquo;First of all,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;I'd like to know exactly how much there is in the account.&equo; 
 The bank manager became pedantic and precise. 
 &bquo;Exactly six hundred and nine pounds, four and sevenpence.&equo; 
 &bquo;I take it that's a current account? 
 He didn't have anything on deposit, did he?&equo; 
 &bquo;Unfortunately, no. 
 When Mr Hatton began paying large sums in I did attempt to persuade him to open one, the rate of interest being so desirable, you understand. 
 Five per cent, as you doubtless know. 
 But Mr Hatton wouldn't. 
 &bquo;I'm one for the ready, Mr Five Per Cent,&equo; he said to me in his amusing way.&equo; 
 The manager sighed. 
 &bquo;A very likable, amusing man, poor Mr Hatton. 
 One of the best.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's a matter of opinion, Wexford thought. 
 &bquo;What were these large sums?&equo; 
 &bquo;Really, it seems most unorthodox, but if you insist.&equo; 
 A large ledger was opened and horn-rimmed glasses set on the manager's nose. 
 &bquo;Mr Hatton opened this account in November of last year,&equo; he began, &bquo;with the sum of one hundred pounds.&equo; 
 Payment for the first lorry hi-jacking, Wexford thought, a nice little bit of compensation for his concussion. 
 &bquo;Nothing was added to it until January when two separate payments of fifty pounds were made.&equo; 
 Two more hi-jackings, set up by Hatton, who had kept the drivers occupied at pontoon in a carmen's cafe? 
 Wexford felt rather pleased. 
 All the pieces in his puzzle were falling neatly into place. 
 &bquo;Then in March, March 15th, a further hundred was paid in, but no more after that until May 22nd.&equo; 
 The manager paused and Wexford made a mental note to find out whether any lorries had been hi-jacked on Hatton's A1 route during the penultimate week of May. 
 Evidently Hatton got a hundred when he was personally involved, fifty when it was someone else to be knocked on the head and left in a ditch. 
 Such a likable, amusing man! 
 &bquo;How much?&equo; he said coldly. 
 The manager readjusted his glasses. 
 &bquo;Er&hellip; let me see&hellip; 
 Good heavens. 
 No, it isn't an error. 
 Really, I wasn't aware&hellip; 
 As a matter of fact, Mr Hatton paid five hundred pounds into his current account on May 22nd. 
 And what in God's name, Wexford thought flabbergasted, did Hatton have in his power to do that was worth five hundred pounds? 
 What could a lorry be carrying that its load was so valuable to a thief as to make Hatton's a feasible reward? 
 There would have to be several men involved in the racket, McCloy himself, two or three men to commandeer the lorry and incapacitate the driver as well as Hatton. 
 McCloy would want the lion's share of whatever the load realised and if Hatton, a mere decoy, got five hundred, the three henchmen would be worth at least five hundred apiece. 
 Four times five and what for McCloy? 
 A thousand, two thousand? 
 That meant a cargo to the value of four or five thousand pounds. 
 At least. 
 For McCloy wouldn't get anything like the cargo's true value in his underworld market. 
 Well, it should be easy enough to find out. 
 A hi-jacking of that magnitude wouldn't be likely to be quickly forgotten by the police in whose district it had occurred. 
 He couldn't understand why he didn't recall it himself. 
 It must have made front-page news. 
 The last week but one in May, he repeated to himself. 
 Presumably they'd never done anyone for the job. 
 They certainly hadn't done Hatton. 
 &bquo;And after that&equo; he said calmly. 
 &bquo;Regular payments of fifty pounds a week over the past six weeks.&equo; 
 Wexford checked an explosion of astonishment. 
 &bquo;But no more large sums?&equo; 
 It was obvious what had happened. 
 Hatton had done his jobs for McCloy and the last one had been something spectacular. 
 So spectacular &mdash; perhaps involving great injury or death. 
 Why the hell couldn't he remember it? 
 That Hatton, finding some weak spot in McCloy's armour, had commenced to blackmail him. 
 A lump sum down on May 22nd and then fifty pounds a week. 
 It must have been nice while it lasted, Wexford reflected amorally. 
 What was more exhilarating to a poor man than a sudden influx of unearned cash, springing from a seemingly limitless fertile source? 
 How could such a one as Hatton restrain himself from making a splash? 
 It came into Wexford's mind that money metaphors often have to do with water, gushing, springing, and that business men talk of liquidity and cash flow. 
 He came to the Kingsbrook bridge and paused for a moment on the parapet, listening to the soft suck and chatter of the stream. 
 Everlastingly the Kingsbrook rattled over its stones, hindered here and there by tree roots or a growth of weed, but ultimately unimpeded, always moving, glittering in the sun as if gold pieces gleamed beneath its ripples. 
 By the water's edge Hatton had met his death. 
 Because a source less abundant and less generous than this river had dried up? 
 &bquo;There are only three McCloys in this district,&equo; Burden said on the following morning. 
 &bquo;I've seen them all and they struck me as perfectly ordinary honest citizens. 
 A couple in Pomfret are brothers. 
 One's a teacher at the comprehensive school and the other's lab assistant. 
 James McCloy, who lives here in town, runs a very small unsuccessful sort of decorating business.&equo; 
 &bquo;Small fry?&equo; said Wexford, still thinking of his fish and water metaphors. 
 &bquo;Very small. 
 No sign of any more money than is needed to keep the wolf from the door. 
 Still, I've been through the trade directory and come up with something a bit more hopeful. 
 There's a firm in London, in Deptford, calling themselves McCloy &amp; Son Ltd., and what d'you think their line of business is?&equo; 
 &bquo;Etonne-moi,&equo; said Wexford after the manner of Diaghilev to Cocteau. 
 Burden looked at him suspiciously, so he said with amused impatience, &bquo;I don't know, Mike, and I'm not in the mood for this suspense stuff.&equo; 
 &bquo;They spray the laminated surfaces on to small electrical equipment.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do they, indeed?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've put through a call to London and I'm waiting for them to ring me up. 
 If there's anything at all promising I'm off to Deptford.&equo; 
 &bquo;While you're waiting,&equo; said Wexford, &bquo;you might get on to Stamford police, Stamford in Lincolnshire. 
 I'd like to know just what did happen when Hatton's lorry was hi-jacked on the 15th of Marchand if they've got any McCloys in their district.&equo; 
 &bquo;Stamford, sir? 
 Isn't there a bridge there where poor old Harold won a victory before coming a cropper at Hastings?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wrong one,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;This is a charming little ancient town of grey stone which the A1 now fortunately by-passes. 
 Shakespeare mentions it. 
 &bquo;How a good yoke of bullocks at Stamford fair?&equo; 
 You might also ask them if they had a big hi-jacking at the end of May. 
 It might not have been near them, of course, but it was so big they'll likely have heard of it.&equo; 
 The pretty toy of a lift had born his weight serenely on four occasions by this time and he no longer felt much trepidation on entering it. 
 As it sank obediently to the ground floor, he thought again about McCloy's mysterious feat of modern highwaymanship. 
 He had checked the file of that period and found nothing. 
 Now he too was waiting for a phone call, promised for the afternoon. 
 Scotland Yard would enlighten him when they had consulted their records. 
 But how could it have escaped his knowledge and the newspapers? 
 Sergeants Camb and Martin were gossiping in the foyer when he emerged from the lift. 
 He gave a low cough. 
 &bquo;Just discussing this Fanshawe inquest, sir,&equo; said Camb respectfully. 
 &bquo;I thought it had been adjourned.&equo; 
 &bquo;The coroner wants to resume now, but I've told him we've nothing to go on. 
 I'm all for waiting till Mrs Fanshawe perks up a bit.&equo; 
 &bquo;In a bad way, is she?&equo; said Martin. 
 Like an old woman in a supermarket queue, Wexford thought derisively. 
 &bquo;That accident's turned her brain, I reckon. 
 She's no more fit to appear in court than she was six weeks ago. 
 God knows, I can sympathise. 
 Her husband's dead and her only child. 
 It's not funny, I can tell you, trying to tell a sick woman her daughter's dead when she keeps insisting she's alive and in Germany.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe she is alive,&equo; said Wexford, more from a mischievous desire to throw a spanner in the works than from conviction. 
 He was sick and tired of the name Fanshawe. 
 He didn't burden the uniformed branch with his problems and he didn't see why he should have to listen to Camb's maunderings. 
 &bquo;Maybe it was someone else in the car.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, no, sir; the aunt identified the girl.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, it's your problem, Sergeant. 
 You're the coroner's officer.&equo; 
 Wexford added annoyingly. 
 &bquo;We all have our troubles and we must deal with them as best we can.&equo; 
 He swung open the door and said over his shoulder, &bquo;I don't know what you think you're doing, Martin, distracting the coroner's officer in the execution of his duty. 
 If you want a job just run upstairs and say McCloy to Mr Burden. 
 I'm away to the dentist myself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not in much pain, sir, I hope?&equo; 
 &bquo;You're behind the times,&equo; said Wexford, chuckling. 
 &bquo;You don't go to the dentist these days because you've got toothache, you go for a check-up.&equo; 
 It was too fine a day for the car. 
 Wexford crossed the road to Grover's newspaper shop and turned into York Street. 
 In the display window of Joy Jewels the sun set the rhinestone ropes and little gilt collarets ablaze, and the plane tree leaves shadowed the pavements in damask tablecloth patterns. 
 After the petrol station and the little houses, in one of which George Carter lived, were left behind, the street petered out into a country lane. 
 Such was the incline of the hills at this point and the arrangement of the trees that, looking straight ahead, nothing that was not absolutely pastoral could be could be seen. 
 A stranger to the district, coming over a brow of the hill, would have stopped astonished and perhaps a little peeved to see Ploughman's Lane lying beneath him. 
 Not that there was anything to dismay the aesthetic purist. 
 Through the centuries about twenty-five houses had been built in Ploughman's Lane, first of all for the minor gentry, the widows and kinsmen, for instance, of the lord of the manor; in more recent times, equally large and widely spaced dwellings had been put up for the professional class. 
 From where he stood Wexford could see roofs, a yellow patch of new thatch on the far left, red tiles some fifty yards from it, then the pinnacled and turreted grey slates so dear to the heart of the Victorian bourgeoisie; next, half lost among the spread arms of a black cedar, the pinned-down tarred fabric that roofed a split-level ranch bungalow. 
 He descended briskly, glad of the shade the thickening trees afforded. 
 A Bentley swam out from behind the ranch house's tamarisk hedge, accelerated arrogantly and, passing him, drove him back flat against the hedge. 
 &bquo;And if I should chance to run over a cad.&equo; 
 Wexford quoted, 
 &bquo;I can pay for the damage if ever so bad. 
 So pleasant it is to have money, heigh ho/&hellip;&equo; 
 God Almighty, he was getting as bad as Maurice Cullam! 
 He had noted the number of the Bentley. 
 Very nice cars they all had around here. 
 There was another Bentley outside the grey slate Gothic place with a smart yellow Cortina snuggling up against it. 
 Married bliss, thought Wexford, grinning to himself. 
 Even the wives' cars were sizable. 
 No minis and no second- or third-hand jalopies. 
 But women would never be equal, he reflected, pleased to have discovered a new profundity, until the day came when men stopped thinking it natural that their wives should always have the smaller car. 
 And they always did, no matter how rich they were; no matter, come to that, if the wives were richer or bigger than the husbands. 
 He tried to think of a wife who had a larger car than her husband's and he couldn't think of one. 
 Not that he particularly wanted women to be equal. 
 As far as that went, he was quite satisfied with the status quo. 
 But to have lighted upon a new yet universal truth amused him and he went on thinking about it until he came to Jolyon Vigo's house. 
 The tall dark girl got off the London train and as she passed through the barrier at Stowerton station she asked the woman collecting tickets where she could get a taxi. 
 &bquo;There's only one. 
 But he won't be busy at this time of day. 
 You might be lucky. 
 There you are! 
 I can just see him, waiting on the rank.&equo; 
 She watched the girl march briskly down the steps. 
 Very few women as smart and cocksure as that one arrived at Stowerton station, even from London, even in the height of summer. 
 The ticket collector, who had just had a new perm, thought the girl's geometrically cut and excessively short hair awful. 
 It made her look like a boy, or how boys used to look in the days when men had some self-respect and went to the barber's. 
 Flat-chested and skinny too, like a stick all the way down. 
 You had to admit, though, that that kind made a good clothes prop. 
 The suit she was wearing was the colour and texture of sacking, a foreign-looking suit somehow with those buttoned pockets, but the ticket collector was willing to bet it hadn't cost a penny less than forty guineas. 
 It hardly seemed fair that a kid of &mdash; what would she be? 
 Twenty-three? 
 Twenty-four? &mdash; had forty quid to throw away on a bit of sacking. 
 Money talks all right, she thought. 
 It was money that gave that snooty lift of the chin, too, that masterful stance and walk and that stuck-up voice. 
 The girl approached the taxi and said to the driver: 
 &bquo;Will you take me to Stowerton Royal Infirmary, please?&equo; 
 When they got to the hospital she opened her brown leather bag to pay him and he noticed that, as well as the English money, she had some funny-looking foreign notes in her wallet. 
 He half hoped she would give him one of them by mistake so that he could make a scene, but she didn't. 
 He summed her up as a sharp little piece with a head on her shoulders. 
 She was a stranger to the place but she knew where she was going. 
 As he reversed, he saw her march confidently into the porter's office. 
 &bquo;Can you direct me to the private wing?&equo; 
 &bquo;Straight down the drive, madam, and you'll see a notice with an arrow.&equo; 
 The porter called her madam because she had asked the way to the private wing. 
 If she had asked for Ward Five he would have told her morning visiting in the public wards was forbidden and he might, because he was feeling benevolent, have called her love. 
 On the other hand, he couldn't imagine anyone like this ever wanting a public ward. 
 She was madam, all right, a proper little madam. 
 Nurse Rose was late with her bed-making on Tuesday morning. 
 She had seen to Mrs Goodwin by nine o'clock and stopped for a chat and a bit of buttering-up. 
 You were half-way to being a lady's maid with these private patients and if they wanted you to paint their fingernails while they told you their life histories you couldn't choose but obey. 
 Just the same, she would have been well ahead but for those policemen turning up again and wanting to ask poor Mrs Fanshawe more questions. 
 Of course she couldn't make poor Mrs Fanshawe's bed while they were poking about and it was nearly twelve before she managed to get the poor deluded creature into a chair and the sheets whipped off. 
 &bquo;It might take a letter a week to get to Germany, mightn't it?&equo; said Mrs Fanshawe, taking her rings off and amusing herself by making them flash in the sunlight right into Nurse Rose's eyes. 
 &bquo;Weeks and weeks,&equo; said Nurse Rose, blinking. 
 &bquo;You don't want to worry about that.&equo; 
 &bquo;I should have sent a telegram. 
 I think I'll get you to send one for me.&equo; 
 Once bitten, twice shy, thought Nurse Rose. 
 She wasn't even going to humour Mrs Fanshawe any more. 
 Stick her neck out and her life would be a succession of errands for Mrs Fanshawe, running about the town sending crazy messages to a girl who didn't exist. 
 &bquo;Would you like me to brush your hair?&equo; she asked, pummelling the pillows. 
 &bquo;Thank you very much, my dear. 
 You're a good girl.&equo; 
 &bquo;Back into bed then. 
 Ooh! 
 You're as light as a feather. 
 Don't leave those lovely rings on the table, now.&equo; 
 Nurse Rose had really been very helpful, Mrs Fanshawe thought. 
 She didn't seem or look very intelligent, but she must be. 
 She was the only one who didn't keep up this nonsense about Nora being dead&hellip; 
 When Nora came she would get her to run up to the flat and root out that paste thing she'd once bought on a whim at Selfridges. 
 It wasn't worth more than thirty shillings, but Nurse Rose wouldn't know that and she decided she would definitely give it to Nurse Rose. 
 She lay back comfortably while her hair was brushed. 
 &bquo;While you're getting my lunch,&equo; she said, &bquo;I'll think how I'm going to word my telegram. 
 Oh, and you might take my sister's card away. 
 It's getting on my nerves.&equo; 
 Nurse Rose was glad to escape. 
 She came out of the room, pulling her bag of soiled linen, and because she wasn't looking where she was going, almost cannoned into a tall dark girl. 
 &bquo;Can you tell me where I can find Mrs Dorothy Fanshawe?&equo; 
 &bquo;She's in there,&equo; said Nurse Rose. 
 She had never seen anything like the shoes the girl was wearing. 
 They were of brown calf with a copper beech leaf on the instep and their shape was so strange and outlandish that Nurse Rose decided they must be the extreme of fashion. 
 Nothing like them had ever been seen in Stowerton, nor, for that matter, Nurse Rose believed, in London. 
 &bquo;Mrs Fanshawe's just going to have her lunch,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I don't suppose it matters if that's held up for ten minutes.&equo; 
 Not to you, Nurse Rose thought indignantly, whoever you may be. 
 But she couldn't let those desirable shoes vanish without any comment and she said impulsively, &bquo;I hope you don't mind my asking, but I do think your shoes are super. 
 Where did you get them?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nobody minds a compliment,&equo; said the girl coldly. 
 &bquo;They were made in Florence but I bought them in Bonn.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bonn? 
 Bonn's in Germany, isn't it? 
 Ooh, you can't be! 
 You can't be Nora. 
 You're dead!&equo; 
 Earlier that morning Wexford had quoted Justice Shallow and now, as he contemplated Jolyon Vigo's house, he thought that this was just the sort of place Shallow might have lived in. 
 It would have been a mature house already in Shakespeare's time, a &bquo;black and white&equo; house, timbered, solid, so perfect a place to live in that it seemed in advance to confer upon its owner grace and taste and superiority. 
 A climbing rose with yellow satiny flowers spread across the black striped gables and nestled against the tudor roses, carved long ago by some craftsman on every square inch of oak. 
 On either side of the front path a knot garden had been planted with low hedges and tufts of tiny blossom. 
 It was so neat, so unnatural in a way, that Wexford had the notion the flowers had been embroidered on the earth. 
 A coach-house of slightly later vintage served as a double garage. 
 It had a small belvedere and a vertical sundial under its pediment. 
 The garage doors were open &mdash; a single untidy touch &mdash; and within Wexford saw two cars. 
 Again it amused him to note the general application of what he was beginning to think of as Wexford's Law. 
 A woman was in the act of opening the door of a pale blue Minor. 
 She slammed it and, carrying a child in her arms, squeezed between the small vehicle and the huge, finned Plymouth, dragonfly blue, that stood a foot from it. 
 The phrase &bquo;a woman with a child&equo; somehow suggested a peasant and a shawled baby. 
 Eyeing her, Wexford thought that to say a lady with an infant would be better. 
 &bquo;What d'you want?&equo; she said in the sharp high-pitched voice of the local gentry. 
 Before she could add, as she was evidently about to, that she never bought anything at the door, he announced himself hurriedly and asked for her husband. 
 &bquo;He's in the surgery. 
 You go round by the pleached walk.&equo; 
 Marvelling that anyone could say this without a trace of selfconsciousness or humour, Wexford looked her up and down. 
 She was a plain young woman, thick and dark with a worn face. 
 She put the child into a pram and wheeled it down the path. 
 The boy was big and handsome, blue-eyed and fair-headed. 
 He looked as though by being born he had sapped his mother's strength and left her a used-up husk. 
 Wexford was reminded of a butterfly, fresh and lusty, that has escaped from a dried chrysalis. 
 He was not precisely sure what a pleached walk was, but when he came upon it there was no mistaking it and, smiling to himself, he descended a flagged step and passed into a green tunnel. 
 The trees whose branches met and interwove above his head were apples and pears and already the young green fruit hung abundantly. 
 The walk led to some greenhouses and what had once been a stable, now converted into a surgery. 
 Amid all this sylvan glory the notice giving the dentist's working hours struck a discordant note. 
 Wexford opened a latched horse-box door and entered the waiting room. 
 A pretty girl in a white coat came out to him and he reminded her of his appointment. 
 Then, having no inclination for Elle or Nova, he sat down and viewed the room. 
 It Was a funny place for Charlie Hatton to have found himself in and Wexford wondered why he hadn't attended the dentist in the town. 
 On these walls were none of the usual posters bidding young mothers to drink milk in pregnancy and bring their toddlers for a twice-yearly check-up. 
 Nor was there any notice explaining how to get dental treatment on the National Health Service. 
 You couldn't imagine anyone sitting here with a handkerchief pressed to a swollen jaw. 
 The walls were papered in a Regency stripe and the one or two pieces of upholstered furniture looked like genuine antiques. 
 The curtains were of dark chintz patterned with medallions. 
 A small chandelier caught the sun and made rainbow spot patterns on the ceiling. 
 Wexford thought the place was just like the sitting room of a person of taste. 
 There were dozens like it in Kingsmarkham. 
 But this was just a dentist's waiting room and it made him wonder what the rest of the house would be like. 
 He was in for a surprise. 
 He was admiring a stylish flower arrangement, observing how cunningly a spray of jasmine had been made to tremble half in, half out of the vase and trail against the console table, when the girl came back and told him Mr Vigo would see him now. 
 Wexford followed her into the surgery. 
 There was nothing out of the ordinary here, just the usual chairs and trays of instruments and contraptions of tubes and clamps and wires. 
 Ice-blue blinds were lowered to keep out the noonday sun. 
 Vigo was standing beside one of the windows, fingering some instruments in a tray, and when Wexford came in he didn't look up. 
 Wexford smiled dryly to himself. 
 This air of being always overworked, preoccupied by esoteric matters was, he knew, characteristic of some doctors and dentists. 
 It was part of the mystique. 
 In a moment Vigo would glance round, show surprise and make some swift apology for being engaged on matters beyond a policeman's comprehension. 
 The dentist had a fine leonine head, the hair fair and abundant. 
 His jaw was strong and prominent, the mouth thin. 
 One day when he was old this would be a nutcracker face but that was a long way off. 
 He seemed to be counting and when he had finished he turned and reacted as Wexford had expected he would. 
 &bquo;Do forgive me, Chief Inspector. 
 A little matter that couldn't be left. 
 I understand you want to talk to me about the late Mr Hatton. 
 I've no more patients until after lunch, so shall we go into the house?&equo; 
 He took off his white coat. 
 Under it he was wearing a slate-blue suit in tussore, the cut, material and colour not quite masculine enough for his height and heavily muscled chest. 
 He had the figure of a rugby international and he made Wexford, who was just on six feet, feel short. 
 Wexford followed him through the pleached walk and they entered the house by a glazed garden door. 
 It was like stepping into a museum. 
 Wexford hesitated, dazzled. 
 He had heard of Chinese rooms, heard of Chinese Chippendale, but he had never seen a room furnished in the style. 
 The brilliance of its colours turned the remembered garden outside into monochrome. 
 His feet sank into a carpet whose blues and creams evoked a summer sky and, at Vigo's behest, he lowered himself uneasily into a chair with a yellow satin seat and legs of rearing dragons. 
 The dentist moved with apparent carelessness between tables and cabinets loaded with china and jade and stood, a faint smile on his thin lips, under a long picture of red fish painted on silk. 
 &bquo;I don't know what you can have to ask me about Mr Hatton's teeth,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;He didn't have his own teeth.&equo; 
 Wexford had come to talk business and yet for a moment he could not. 
 Talk of false teeth in this setting? 
 His eye fell on a set of chessmen ranged on a table in a far corner. 
 They were two armies, one of ivory, one of red jade, and the pawns were on horseback, the white armed with spears, the red with arrows. 
 One of the red knights on a panoplied charger had a contemporary Western face, a raw sharp face which called to mind absurdly that of Charlie Hatton. 
 It grinned at Wexford, seeming to prompt him. 
 &bquo;We know that, Mr Vigo,&equo; he said, wrenching his eyes away and fixing them on an eggshell thin service, made to contain jasmine tea. 
 &bquo;What surprises us is that a man of his means should have such superb false ones.&equo; 
 Vigo had an attractive, rather boyish laugh. 
 He checked it with a shake of his head. 
 &bquo;A tragedy, wasn't it? 
 Have you any idea who could have&hellip;? 
 No, I mustn't ask that.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've no objection to your asking, but no, we've no idea yet. 
 I've come to you because I want you to tell me everything you can about Mr Hatton with particular reference to anything you may know about the source of his income.&equo; 
 &bquo;I only know that he drove a lorry.&equo; 
 Vigo was still savouring with pride and joy his caller's astonishment. 
 &bquo;But yes, I see what you mean. 
 It surprised me too. 
 I don't know much but I'll tell you what I can.&equo; 
 He moved to a cabinet whose door handles were the long curved tails of dragons. 
 &bquo;Will you join me in a pre-luncheon sherry?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't think so, thank you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Pity.&equo; 
 Vigo didn't press him but poured a glass of Manzanilla for himself and sat down by the window. 
 It gave on to a shadowed court whose centrepiece was an orrery on a stone plinth. 
 &bquo;Mr Hatton made an appointment with me at the end of May. 
 He had never been a patient of mine before.&equo; 
 The end of May. 
 On the 22nd of May Hatton had paid five hundred pounds into his bank account, his share, no doubt, of the mysterious and elusive hi-jacking haul. 
 &bquo;I can tell you the precise date, if you like. 
 I looked it up before you came. 
 Tuesday, 21st May. 
 He telephoned me at lunchtime on that day and by a fluke I had a cancellation, so I was able to see him almost immediately. 
 He'd had dentures since he was twenty, very bad ill-fitting ones, by the way. 
 They made him selfconscious and he wanted a new set. 
 I asked him why he'd lost his own teeth and he said the cause had been pyorrhea. 
 Knowing a little of his circumstances by this time &mdash; at any rate, I knew what his job was &mdash; I asked him if he realised this would involve him in considerable expense. 
 He said that money was no object &mdash; those were his actual words &mdash; and he wanted the most expensive teeth I could provide. 
 We finally arrived at a figure of two hundred and fifty pounds and he was perfectly agreeable.&equo; 
 &bquo;You must have been surprised.&equo; 
 Vigo sipped his sherry reflectively. 
 He touched one of the chessmen, a crenallated castle, caressing it with pride. 
 &bquo;I was astonished. 
 And I don't mind telling you I was a little uneasy.&equo; 
 He didn't elaborate on this unease but Wexford thought he must have been worried lest the two hundred and fifty wasn't forthcoming. 
 &bquo;However, the teeth were made and fitted at the beginning of June. 
 About a month ago it would have been.&equo; 
 &bquo;How did Mr Hatton pay you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, in cash, he paid me on the same day, insisted on doing so. 
 The money was in five-pound notes which I'm afraid I paid straight into my bank. 
 Chief Inspector, I understand what you're getting at, but I couldn't ask the man where he got his money from, could I? 
 Just because he came here in his working clothes and I knew he drove a lorry&hellip; 
 I couldn't.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you ever see him again?&equo; 
 &bquo;He came back once for a check. 
 Oh, and a second time to tell me how pleased he was.&equo; 
 Again Wexford was becoming bemused by the colours, by the seductive spectrum that caught and held his eye wherever he looked. 
 He bent his head and concentrated on his own big ugly hands. 
 &bquo;On any of his visits,&equo; he said stolidly, &bquo;did he ever mention someone called McCloy?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't think so. 
 He spoke about his wife and his brother-in-law that he was in business with.&equo; 
 Vigo paused and searched his memory. 
 &bquo;Oh, and he mentioned a friend of his that was getting married. 
 I was supposed to be interested because the chap had sometimes been here doing electrical repairs. 
 Hatton said something about buying him a record player for a wedding present. 
 The poor fellow's dead and I don't know whether I ought to say this&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Say on, Mr Vigo.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, he did rather harp on what a lot of money he spent. 
 I don't want to sound a snob but I thought it vulgar. 
 He only mentioned his wife to tell me he'd just bought her something new to wear and he tried to give me the impression his brother-in-law was something of a poor fish because he couldn't make ends meet.&equo; 
 &bquo;But the brother-in-law was in the same line of business.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know. 
 That struck me. 
 Mr Hatton did say he had a good many irons in the fire and that sometimes he brought off a big deal. 
 But frankly, if I thought about that at all, I imagined he had some side line, painting people's houses perhaps or cleaning windows.&equo; 
 &bquo;Window cleaners don't speak of bringing off big deals, Mr Vigo.&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose no. 
 The fact is I don't have many dealings with people of Mr Hatton's&hellip;&equo; 
 Vigo paused. 
 Wexford was sure he had been about to say &bquo;class&equo;. 
 &bquo;Er, background,&equo; said the dentist. 
 &bquo;Of course you're suggesting the side lines weren't legitimate and this may be hindsight, but now I look back Mr Hatton did perhaps occasionally have a shady air about him when he talked of them. 
 But really it was only the merest nuance.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I won't trouble you any further.&equo; 
 Wexford got up. 
 It must be his over-sensitive suspicious mind that made him see a relieved relaxing of those muscled shoulders. 
 Vigo opened the carved oak door for him. 
 &bquo;Let me see you out, Chief Inspector.&equo; 
 The hall was a largish square room, its flagged floor dotted with thin soft rugs, and every inch of burnished ancient wood caught the sunlight. 
 There were Blake prints on the walls, the Inferno scenes, Nebuchadnezzar with his eagle's talons, the naked Newton with his golden curls. 
 Stripped of his blue tussore, Vigo himself might look rather like that, Wexford thought. 
 &bquo;I had the pleasure of a visit from your daughter the other day,&equo; he heard the dentist say. 
 &bquo;What a very lovely girl she is.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm told she's much admired,&equo; Wexford said dryly. 
 The compliment slightly displeased him. 
 He interpreted it as spurious and ingratiating. 
 Also there had been a note of incredulity in Vigo's voice as if he marvelled at such an old goose begetting a swan. 
 The front door swung open and Mrs Vigo came in, holding the child. 
 For the first time since his arrival, Wexford remembered that there was another child, a mongol, confined somewhere in an institution. 
 The baby which Vigo now took in his arms was perhaps six or seven months old. 
 No one could have doubted its paternity. 
 Already it had its father's athletic limbs. 
 Vigo lifted the boy high, laughing as he chuckled, and there came into his face an intense besotted adoration. 
 &bquo;Meet my son, Mr Wexford. 
 Isn't he splendid?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's very like you.&equo; 
 &bquo;So they tell me. 
 Looks more than seven months, doesn't he?&equo; 
 &bquo;Going to be a big chap,&equo; said the chief inspector. 
 &bquo;Now that we've each complimented the other on his handsome offspring, I'll take my leave, Mr Vigo.&equo; 
 &bquo;A mutual admiration society, eh?&equo; 
 Vigo laughed heartily but his wife's face remained grave. 
 She took the boy from him roughly as if so much exaggerated worship offended her. 
 Again Wexford thought of the mongol whose fate no amount of money could change. 
 Grief fills the room up of my absent child, lies in his bed, walks up and down with me&hellip; 
 Wexford went out into the sunshine and the knot garden. 
 The call from Scotland Yard came through half an hour after Wexford got back to the station. 
 In the whole country only two lorries had been hijacked during the latter part of May and neither was on Hatton's regular route. 
 One had been in Cornwall, the other in Monmouthshire, and they had been loaded with margarine and tinned peaches respectively. 
 Wexford looked at the memo Burden had left him before departing for Deptford: 
 &bquo;Stamford say no records of any thefts from lorries in their area during April or May.&equo; 
 It was unlikely that Hatton could have had a hand in the Cornwall or Monmouthshire jobs. 
 Margarine and tinned fruit! 
 Even if there had been tons of it, a fourth or fifth share couldn't have amounted to five hundred pounds. 
 Besides, wasn't he underestimating Hatton's haul? 
 He had banked five hundred on May 22nd, drawn out twenty-five pounds for the lamp. 
 Another sixty had gone on clothes and the record player. 
 And all this while, Wexford guessed, Hatton had been living like a king. 
 True, the first and perhaps the second blackmail payments had come in before he was obliged to pay for his teeth at the beginning of June, but he had blithely paid two hundred and fifty for them in cash when the demand came. 
 Surely that meant that although Hatton had banked only five hundred on May 22nd, he had in fact received more, perhaps even twice that sum. 
 He carried notes about with him in his wallet, on one occasion, at any rate about a hundred pounds. 
 Suppose there had been no mammoth hi-jacking at the end of May? 
 That would mean that all Hatton's wealth had been acquired through blackmail, and blackmail entered into not as the consequence of a hi-jacking but of something else. 
 There was a lot more to this, Wexford thought with frustration, than met the eye. 
 &bquo;There seems to be a lot more to this than meets the eye,&equo; said Sergeant Camb indignantly. 
 &bquo;Mrs Fanshawe's own sister identified the dead young lady as Miss Nora Fanshawe.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nevertheless,&equo; the girl said, &bquo;I am Nora Fanshawe.&equo; 
 She sat down on one of the red spoon-shaped chairs in the station foyer and placed her feet neatly together on the black and white tiles, staring down at the shoes Nurse Rose had so gushingly admired. 
 &bquo;My aunt was probably very strung up and you say the girl was badly burned. 
 Very disfigured, I suppose?&equo; 
 &bquo;Very,&equo; said Camb unhappily. 
 His immediate superior and his superintendent had departed ten minutes before for a conference at Lewes and he was more than somewhat at a loss. 
 What the coroner was going to say to all this he dreaded to think. 
 &bquo;Mrs Fanshawe's sister seemed quite certain.&equo; 
 But had she? 
 He remembered the scene quite vividly, taking the woman into the mortuary and uncovering the faces, Jerome Fanshawe's first and then the girl's. 
 Fanshawe had been lying on his face and the fire had scarcely touched him. 
 Besides, the woman had recognised the silver pencil in his left breast pocket, his wristwatch and the tiny knife scar, relic of some schoolboy ritual, on that wrist. 
 Identifying the girl had been so extremely distasteful. 
 All her hair had been burnt away but for the black roots and her features hideously charred. 
 It made him shudder to think of it now, hardened as he was. 
 &bquo;Yes, that's my niece,&equo; Mrs Browne had said, recoiling and covering her own face. 
 Of course he had asked her if she was quite certain and she said she was, quite certain, but now he wondered if it was mere association that had made her agree, association and horror. 
 She had said it was her niece because the girl was young and had black hair and because who else but Nora Fanshawe could have been in that car with her parents? 
 Yet someone else had been&hellip; 
 And what the hell was the coroner going to say? 
 His eyes still seeing the charred appalling face, he turned to the young hard untouched face in front of him and said: 
 &bquo;Can you prove you're Nora Fanshawe, miss?&equo; 
 She opened the large hide handbag she was carrying and produced a passport, handing it to Camb without a word. 
 The photograph wasn't very much like the girl who sat on the other side of the desk, but passport photographs seldom are much like their originals. 
 Glancing up at her uneasily and then back to the document in front of him he read that Nora Elizabeth Fanshawe, by profession a teacher, had been born in London in 1945, had black hair, brown eyes and was five feet nine inches tall with no distinguishing marks. 
 The girl in the mortuary hadn't been anything like five feet nine, but you couldn't expect an aunt to tell the height of a prone corpse. 
 &bquo;Why didn't you come back before?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;Why should I? 
 I didn't know my father was dead and my mother in hospital.&equo; 
 &bquo;Didn't you write? 
 Didn't you expect them to write to you?&equo; 
 &bquo;We were on very bad terms,&equo; the girl said calmly. 
 &bquo;Besides, my mother did write. 
 I got her letter yesterday and I took the first plane. 
 Look here, my mother knows me and that ought to be enough for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your mother&hellip;&equo; 
 Camb corrected himself. 
 &bquo;Mrs Fanshawe's a very sick woman&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;She's not mad if that's what you mean. 
 The best thing will be for me to phone my aunt and then perhaps you'll let me go and have something to eat. 
 You may not know it, but I haven't had a thing to eat since eight o'clock and it's half-past two now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I'll phone Mrs Browne,&equo; Camb said hastily. 
 &bquo;It wouldn't do for her to hear your voice just like that. 
 Oh dear, no.&equo; 
 He was half convinced. 
 &bquo;Why me?&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;Why do I have to see her? 
 It's nothing to do with me.&equo; 
 &bquo;You see, sir, the super and Inspector Letts have gone to Lewes&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Did the aunt recognise her voice?&equo; 
 &bquo;Seemed to. 
 She was in a bit of a way, I can tell you. 
 Frankly, I don't have much faith in the aunt.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, bring her up.&equo; 
 Wexford said impatiently. 
 &bquo;Anything to make a change from lorries. 
 And, Camb &mdash; use the lift.&equo; 
 He had never seen her mother or her aunt so he couldn't look for family resemblances. 
 But she was a rich man's daughter. 
 He looked at the bag, the shoes, the platinum watch and, more than anything, he sensed about her an air, almost repellent, of arrogance. 
 She wore no scent. 
 He took from her in silence the passport, the international driver's licence and Mrs Fanshawe's letter. 
 It occurred to him as he turned them over that Nora Fanshawe &mdash; if she was Nora Fanshawe &mdash; probably stood to inherit a vast sum of money. 
 Jerome Fanshawe had been an affluent stockbroker. 
 It might be that this girl was a con woman and he and Camb the first victims of a colossal deception. 
 &bquo;I think we had better have an explanation,&equo; he said slowly. 
 &bquo;Very well. 
 I don't quite know what you want.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just a moment.&equo; 
 Wexford took Camb aside. 
 &bquo;Was there nothing but this Mrs Browne's word to identify the dead girl?&equo; he asked rather grimly. 
 Camb looked downcast. 
 &bquo;There was a suitcase in the car with clothes in it,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We went through the contents of two handbags we found in the road. 
 One was Mrs Fanshawe's. 
 The other had nothing in it but some make-up, a purse containing two pounds and some silver and a packet of cigarettes.&equo; 
 He added defensively. 
 &bquo;It was a good expensive handbag from Mappin and Webb.&equo; 
 &bquo;My God,&equo; said Wexford in disgust, &bquo;I just hope you haven't landed us with a female Tichborne claimant.&equo; 
 He went back to the girl, sat down on the opposite side of the desk and gave a brisk nod. 
 &bquo;You went on holiday with Mr and Mrs Fanshawe to Eastover?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;On what date was that?&equo; 
 &bquo;May the 17th,&equo; the girl said promptly. 
 &bquo;I am a teacher of English at a school in Cologne and I gave up my job at the end of March and returned to England.&equo; 
 &bquo;Since when you have been living with Mr and Mrs Fanshawe?&equo; 
 If the girl noticed that he didn't refer to them as her parents she gave no sign. 
 She sat stiff and tense with her finely sculpted head held high. 
 &bquo;Not at first,&equo; she said and he sensed a faint diffidence creep into her voice. 
 &bquo;My parents and I hadn't been on good terms for some time. 
 I went back to live with them &mdash; or rather, to stay with them &mdash; in the middle of May. 
 My mother wanted me to go down to the bungalow with them and because I wanted &mdash; I wanted our relations to improve &mdash; well, I said I would.&equo; 
 Wexford nodded noncomittally and she went on. 
 &bquo;We all drove down to Eastover on Friday, May 17th&hellip;&equo; 
 Her shoulders stiffened and she looked down at her folded hands. 
 &bquo;That night I had a disagreement with my parents. 
 Is there any need for me to go into details?&equo; 
 Without waiting for Wexford's consent to her reticence, she swept the quarrel aside and said, &bquo;I felt it was useless to try and patch things up. 
 We were worlds apart, we&hellip; 
 The result was that on the Saturday morning, I told my mother there was nothing for me in England and I was going back to Germany to try and get my old job back. 
 I took one of the suitcases of clothes I had brought with me and went to Newhaven to get the boat for Dieppe.&equo; 
 &bquo;And did you get your old job back?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fortunately I did. 
 There's a shortage of teachers in Germany as well as here and they were only too glad to see me. 
 I even got my old room back in the Goethestrasse.&equo; 
 &bquo;I see. 
 Now I should like the name and address of the authority who employ you, the name of your landlady and that of the school in which you've been teaching.&equo; 
 While the girl wrote this information down for him, Wexford said: 
 &bquo;Weren't you surprised to hear nothing from Mr or Mrs Fanshawe during the past six weeks?&equo; 
 She looked up and raised her straight, rather heavy, black eyebrows. 
 &bquo;I told you we'd quarrelled. 
 My father would have expected an abject apology from me, I assure you, before he condescended to write.&equo; 
 It was the first show of emotion she had made and it did more to make Wexford believe her story than all the documentary evidence she had furnished him with. 
 &bquo;These silences were commonplace with us,&equo; she said, &bquo;especially after a set-to like the one we had that night. 
 Six months could have gone by. 
 Why should I imagine any harm had come to them? 
 I'm not clairvoyant.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you came as soon as Mrs Fanshawe wrote.&equo; 
 &bquo;She is my mother, after all. 
 Now do you suppose I might go and get myself some lunch?&equo; 
 &bquo;In a moment,&equo; Wexford said. 
 &bquo;Where are you planning to stay?&equo; 
 &bquo;I was going to ask you to recommend somewhere,&equo; the girl said a shade sardonically. 
 &bquo;The Olive and Dove is the best hotel. 
 I suggest you get in touch immediately with your late father's solicitors.&equo; 
 The girl got up and not a crease marked the skirt of her suit. 
 Her self-confidence was almost stupefying. 
 Camb opened the door for her and with a crisp &bquo;Good afternoon&equo; she took her leave of them. 
 As her footsteps died away, the sergeant burst out miserably: 
 &bquo;If she's Nora Fanshawe, sir, who, for God's sake, was the girl in the road?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's your problem, Sergeant,&equo; Wexford said unkindly. 
 &bquo;It could well be yours, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what I'm afraid of. 
 Haven't I got enough with a murder on my hands?&equo; 
 Lilian Hatton was an easier nut to crack than the girl who called herself Nora Fanshawe. 
 She broke down and wept bitterly when Wexford told her that that her husband's supplementary income had come from a criminal source. 
 He was almost sure that it was all a revelation to her and he watched her in sad silence as she covered her face and shook with sobs. 
 &bquo;I have been given your husband's log book by your brother, Mrs Hatton,&equo; he said gently as she recovered herself. 
 &bquo;Now I also want to know if you keep any sort of diary or engagement book yourself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just a pad by the phone,&equo; she gulped, &bquo;where I kind of jot things down.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm going to ask you if you'll kindly let me borrow that.&equo; 
 &bquo;You think,&equo; she began, dabbing at her eyes as she came back with the pad, &bquo;you think someone &mdash; someone killed my Charlie because he wouldn't go on &mdash; go on doing these jobs for them?&equo; 
 &bquo;Something like that,&equo; Now was not the time to suggest to this woman that her husband had been a blackmailer as well as a thief. 
 Who knew Mr Hatton would pass along the Kingsbrook path that night?&equo; 
 She twisted the damp handkerchief in hands whose nails were still pitifully and bravely painted the way Charlie Hatton had liked them, red and shiny and glittering. 
 &bquo;All the darts club,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;And me &mdash; I knew. 
 My mum knew and my brother, Jim. 
 Charlie always came that way back from the pub.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mrs Hatton, did your husband ever receive any callers in this flat that you didn't know? 
 Strangers, I mean, that he wanted to talk to alone?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, he never did.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps when you were out? 
 Can you ever remember your husband asking you to go out and leave him alone with anyone?&equo; 
 The handkerchief was torn now, sopping wet and useless as an absorbent. 
 But she put it to her eyes and brought it away streaked black and green. 
 &bquo;When he was home,&equo; she said, &bquo;I never went out. 
 We always went out together. 
 We was like &mdash; like inseparable. 
 Mr Wexford&hellip;&equo; 
 She gripped the arms of her chair and two red flame-like spots burned in her cheeks. 
 &bquo;Mr Wexford, I've heard all you've said and I've got to believe it. 
 But whatever my Charlie did, he did it for me. 
 He was a husband in a million, a good kind man, a wonderful man to his friends. 
 You ask anyone, ask Jack&hellip; 
 He was one in a million!&equo; 
 Oh! withered is the garland of war! 
 The soldier's poll is fallen&hellip; 
 Strange, Wexford thought, that when you considered Charlie Hatton you thought of war and soldiers and battles. 
 Was it because life itself is a battle and Hatton had waged it with unscrupulous weapons, winning rich spoils and falling as he marched home with a song on his lips? 
 How sentimental he was getting! 
 The man was a blackmailer and a thief. 
 If life was a battle and Charlie Hatton a soldier of fortune he, Wexford, stood in the position of United Nations patrol whose job it was to prevent incursions on the territory of the defenceless. 
 &bquo;I don't want to ask you anything more now, Mrs Hatton,&equo; he said to the widow as he left her weeping among the dead man's ill-gotten glories. 
 In the High Street he encountered Dr Crocker emerging from Grover's with a copy of the British Medical Journal. 
 &bquo;Been making any good arrests lately?&equo; asked the doctor cheerfully. 
 &bquo;Now, mind, mind your hypertension. 
 Want me to take your blood pressure? 
 I've got my sphyg in the car.&equo; 
 &bquo;You know what you can do with your sphyg,&equo; said Wexford, proceeding to tell him in lurid detail. 
 &bquo;I reckon just about the whole population of Kingsmarkham knew Charlie Hatton would be taking the field path home that night.&equo; 
 &bquo;No reason why it should be a local man, is there?&equo; 
 &bquo;I may not be a wizard with sphygmomanometer,&equo; said Wexford derisively, &bquo;but I'm not daft. 
 Whoever killed Charlie Hatton knew the lie of the land all right.&equo; 
 &bquo;How come? 
 He'd only got to be told by Charlie that he'd be leaving the High Street by the bridge and walking along the local river.&equo; 
 &bquo;You think? 
 You reckon Hatton would also have told him the river bed was full of stones one of which would make a suitable weapon for knocking off his informant?&equo; 
 &bquo;I see what you mean. 
 There could be one or more brains behind the killing but whoever struck the blow, albeit a henchman, was Kingsmarkham born and bred.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right, Watson. 
 You're catching on. 
 My old mate,&equo; Wexford remarked to no one in particular, &bquo;albeit a sawbones, is coming on.&equo; 
 Suddenly his voice dropped and tapping the doctor's arm, his face hardening, he said, &bquo;D'you see what I see? 
 Over there by the Electricity Board?&equo; 
 Crocker followed his gaze. 
 From Tabard Road a woman wheeling a pram had emerged in Kingsmarkham High Street And stopped outside a plate-glass display window of the Southern Electricity Board. 
 Presently two more children joined her, then a man holding a third child by the hand and another in his arms. 
 They remained in a huddle on the pavement, staring at the dazzling array of kitchen equipment as if hypnotised. 
 &bquo;Mr and Mrs Cullam and their quiverful,&equo; said Wexford. 
 The family were too far away for their conversation, an apparently heated and even acrimonious discussion, to be audible. 
 But it was evident that an argument was taking place between the adults, possibly as to whether their need of a refrigerator was greater than their desire for a mammoth room heater. 
 The children were taking sides vociferously. 
 Cullam shook one of his daughters, cuffed his elder son on the head, and then they all plunged into the showroom. 
 &bquo;Will you do something for me?&equo; 
 Wexford asked the doctor. 
 &bquo;Go in there and buy a light bulb or something. 
 I want to know what that lot are up to.&equo; 
 &bquo;What, spy on them and report back, d'you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;Charming way you put it. 
 That's what I spend my life doing. 
 I'll sit in your car. 
 Can I have the keys?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's not locked,&equo; Crocker said awkwardly. 
 &bquo;Is that so? 
 Well, don't come screaming to me next time one of the local hippies pinches a load of your acid off you. 
 Go on. 
 A forty watt bulb and we'll reimburse you out of petty cash.&equo; 
 The doctor went unwillingly. 
 Wexford chuckled to himself in the car. 
 Crocker's cautious approach to the electricity showroom, his quick sidelong glances, called to mind days long gone by when Wexford, then a sixth-form boy, had witnessed this same man as a child of ten, scuttling up to front doors playing &bquo;Knocking Down Ginger&equo;. 
 In those days the infant Crocker had run up paths lightly and gleefully to bang on a knocker or ring a bell and, elated with an enormous naughtiness, hidden behind a hedge to see the angry householder erupt and curse. 
 There was no hedge here and Crocker was fifty. 
 But as he entered the showroom, had he too experienced a flash of memory, a stab of nostalgia? 
 Jesu, Jesu, thought Wexford, once more evoking Justice Shallow, the mad days that I have spent! 
 And to see how many of my old acquaintance are dead&hellip; 
 Enough of that. 
 On the lighter side it reminded him of Stamford and he wondered how Burden had got on. 
 Somehow a little business in Deptford didn't quite match up with his own ideas of McCloy's origins. 
 Samantha Cullam scuttled out on to the pavement. 
 Her mother came next, lugging the pram. 
 When the whole brood were assembled their father regimented them with a series of fortunately ill-aimed blows and they all trailed off the way they had come. 
 Then Crocker appeared, duplicity incarnate. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't snap at me like that, you saucy devil,&equo; said the doctor, immensely pleased with himself. 
 &bquo;I set traps, as the Psalmist says, I catch men.&equo; 
 &bquo;What did Cullam buy?&equo; 
 &bquo;He didn't exactly buy anything, but he's after a refrigerator.&equo; 
 &bquo;Getting it on the HP is he?&equo; 
 &bquo;Money wasn't mentioned. 
 They had a bit of a ding-dong, Mr and Mrs, and one of the kids knocked a Pyrex dish off a cooker. 
 That brute Cullam fetched him a fourpenny one, poor little devil. 
 They're all dead keen on getting this fridge, I can tell you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, what about these traps you laid?&equo; 
 &bquo;That was just a figure of speech,&equo; said the doctor. 
 &bquo;Didn't I do all right? 
 I bought the bulb like you said. 
 One and nine if you don't mind. 
 I'm not in this for my health.&equo; 
 &bquo;They call themselves McCloy Ltd.,&equo; Burden said wearily, &bquo;but the last member of the firm of that name died twenty years ago. 
 It's an old established set-up, but I reckon it's on its last legs now. 
 In this so-called affluent society of ours folks buy new stuff, they don't want this reconditioned rubbish.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can say that again,&equo; said Wexford, thinking of Cullam. 
 &bquo;The Yard put me on to six other McCloys all more or less in the hardware business or on its fringes. 
 Not a smell of anything fishy about one of them. 
 Stamford have given me a list of local McCloys and there again not a sniff as far as they know. 
 But I'll be off to Stamford in the morning to have a scent round. 
 The local force have promised me all the help I need.&equo; 
 Wexford lounged back in his swivel chair and the dying sun played on his face. 
 &bquo;Mike,&equo; he said, &bquo;I wonder if we haven't been starting from the wrong end. 
 We've been looking for McCloy to lead us to his hired assassin. 
 We might do better to find the hired assassin and let him lead us to McCloy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cullam?&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe. 
 I want Martin to be Cullam's shadow and if he goes and pays cash for that refrigerator we're really getting somewhere. 
 Meanwhile I'm going to make Hatton's log book and Mrs. Hatton's engagement book my homework for tonight. 
 But first, how about a quick one at the Olive and Dove?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not for me thanks, sir. 
 I haven't had an evening in for a week now. 
 Divorce is against my wife's principles but she might get ideas as to a legal separation.&equo; 
 Wexford laughed and they went down in the lift together. 
 The evening was warm and clear, the light and the long soft shadows more flattering to this market town High Street than the noonday sun. 
 The old houses were at their best in it, their shabbiness, the cracks in their fabric veiled, as an ageing face is veiled and smoothed by candlelight. 
 By day the alleys that ran into a scruffy hinterland were rat-hole rubbish traps but now they seemed romantic lanes where lovers might meet under the bracket lamps and as the sun departed, watch the moon ride over a Grimms' fairy tale huddle of pinnacled rooftops. 
 As yet it was only eight o'clock and the sun reluctant to leave without treating its worshippers to a pyrotechnic display of rose and gold flames that burnt up the whole western sky. 
 Wexford stood on the south side of the bridge and listened to the river chuckling. 
 Such an innocent river, for all that it knew a secret, for all that one of its stones had put a man out of sight of the sunset! 
 All the street windows of the Olive and Dove were open, the curtains fanning out gently over window boxes and over fuchsias that dripped red flowers. 
 On the forecourt a band of Morris dancers had assembled. 
 They wore the motley coat of jesters and one of them was hopping around on a hobby horse. 
 To his amusement Wexford picked out George Carter among the company. 
 &bquo;Lovely night, Mr Carter,&equo; he said jovially. 
 Rather shamefacely Carter waved at him a stick with ribbons and bells on. 
 Wexford went into the saloon bar. 
 At a table in the alcove on the dining-room wall sat the girl Camb had brought to him earlier in the day, an elderly woman and a man. 
 Wexford brought his beer and as he passed them the man got up as if to take his leave. 
 &bquo;Good evening,; &bquo;Wexford said. 
 &bquo;Have you decided to stay at the Olive?&equo; 
 The girl was sparing with her smiles. 
 She nodded sharply to him and said, naming his rank precisely, &bquo;I'd like you to meet my father's solicitor, Mr Updike. 
 Uncle John, this is Detective Chief Inspector Wexford.&equo; 
 &bquo;How do you do?&equo; 
 &bquo;And I don't think you've met my aunt, Mrs Browne?&equo; 
 Wexford looked from one to the other. 
 Marvellous the way he always had to do Camb's work for him! 
 The aunt was looking pale but excited, the solicitor gratified. 
 I'm quite prepared to accept that you're Miss Fanshawe now, Miss Fanshawe,&equo; Wexford said. 
 &bquo;I've known Nora since she was so high,&equo; said Updike. 
 &bquo;You need have no doubt that this is Nora.&equo; 
 And he gave Wexford a card naming a London firm, Updike, Updike and Sanger of Ava Maria Lane. 
 The chief inspector looked at it, then again at Mrs Browne who was Nora Fanshawe grown old. 
 &bquo;I'm satisfied.&equo; 
 He passed on to an empty table. 
 The solicitor went to catch his train and presently Wexford heard the aunt say: 
 &bquo;I've had a long day, Nora. 
 I think I'll just give the hospital a ring and then I'll go up to bed.&equo; 
 Wexford sat by the window, watching the Morris dancers. 
 The music was amateurish and the performers self-conscious, but the evening was so beautiful that if you shut your eyes to the cars and the new shop blocks you might imagine yourself briefly in Shakespeare's England. 
 Someone carried out to the nine men a tray of bottled beer and the spell broke. 
 &bquo;Come into the lounge,&equo; said a voice behind him. 
 Nora Fanshawe had removed the jacket of her suit and in the thin coffee-coloured blouse she looked more feminine. 
 But she was still a creature of strong straight lines and planes and angles and she was still not smiling. 
 &bquo;May I get you a drink, Miss Fanshawe?&equo; 
 Wexford said, rising. 
 &bquo;Better not.&equo; 
 Her voice was abrupt and she didn't thank him for the offer. 
 &bquo;I've had too much already.&equo; 
 And she added with a dead laugh, &bquo;We've been what my aunt calls celebrating. 
 The resurrection of the dead, you see.&equo; 
 They went into the lounge, sat down in deep cretonne-covered armchairs and Nora Fanshawe said: 
 &bquo;Mr Updike wouldn't tell me the details of the accident. 
 He wanted to spare me.&equo; 
 She beckoned to the waiter and said without asking Wexford first, &bquo;Bring me two coffees.&equo; 
 Then she lit a king-size cigarette and slipped it into an amber holder. 
 &bquo;You tell me about it,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You don't want to be spared?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course not. 
 I'm not a child and I didn't like my father.&equo; 
 Wexford gave a slight cough. 
 &bquo;At about ten o'clock on May 20th,&equo; he began, &bquo;a man driving a petrol tanker on the north to south highway of Stowerton by-pass saw a car overturned and in flames on the fast lane of the south to north track. 
 He reported it at once and when the police and ambulance got there they found the bodies of a man and a girl lying on the road and partially burned. 
 A woman &mdash; your mother &mdash; had been flung clear on to the soft shoulder. 
 She had multiple injuries and a fractured skull.&equo; 
 &bquo;Go on.&equo; 
 &bquo;What remained of the car was examined but, as far as could be told, there was nothing wrong with the brakes or the steering and the tyres were nearly new.&equo; 
 Nora Fanshawe nodded. 
 &bquo;The inquest was adjourned until your mother regained consciousness. 
 The road was wet and your mother has suggested that your father may have been driving exceptionally fast.&equo; 
 &bquo;He always drove too fast.&equo; 
 She took the coffee that the waiter had brought and handed a cup to Wexford. 
 He sensed that she would take it black and sugarless and he was right. 
 &bquo;Since the dead girl wasn't I,&equo; she said with repellently faultless grammar, &bquo;who was she?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm hoping you'll be able to tell us that.&equo; 
 She shrugged, &bquo;How should I know?&equo; 
 Wexford glanced at the curled lip, the hard direct eyes. 
 &bquo;Miss Fanshawe,&equo; he said sharply, &bquo;I've answered your questions, but you haven't even met me half-way. 
 This afternoon you came to my office as if you were doing me a favour. 
 Don't you think it's time you unbent a little?&equo; 
 She flushed at that and muttered. 
 &bquo;I don't unbend much.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I can see that. 
 You're twenty-three, aren't you? 
 Don't you think all this upstage reserve is rather ridiculous?&equo; 
 Her hand was small, but, ringless and with short nails as it was, it was like a man's. 
 He watched it move towards the cup and saucer and for a moment he thought she was going to take her coffee, get up and leave him. 
 She frowned a little and her mouth hardened. 
 &bquo;I'll tell you about my father,&equo; she said at last. 
 &bquo;It might just help. 
 I first knew about his infidelities when I was twelve,&equo; she began. 
 &bquo;Or, let me say, I knew he was behaving as other people's fathers didn't behave. 
 He brought a girl home and told my mother she was going to stay with us. 
 They had a row in my presence and when it was over my father gave my mother five hundred pounds.&equo; 
 She took the cigarette stub from her holder and replaced it with a fresh one. 
 This sudden chain smoking was the only sign she gave of emotion. 
 &bquo;He bribed her, you understand. 
 It was quite direct and open. 
 &bquo;Let her stay and you can have this money&equo;. 
 That was how it was. 
 The girl stayed six months. 
 Two years later he bought my mother a new car and at just the same time I caught him in his office with his secretary.&equo; 
 She inhaled deeply. 
 &bquo;On the floor,&equo; she said coldly. 
 &bquo;After that it was an understood thing that when my father wanted a new mistress he paid my mother accordingly. 
 By that I mean what he thought the girl was worth to him. 
 He wanted my mother to stay because she was a good hostess and kept house well. 
 When I was eighteen I went up to Oxford. 
 &bquo;After I got my degree I told my mother I could keep her now and she should leave my father. 
 Her response was to deny everything and to tell my father to stop my allowance. 
 He refused to stop it &mdash; mainly because my mother had asked him to, I suppose. 
 I haven't drawn it for two years now, but&hellip; 'She glanced swiftly at her bag, her watch. 
 &bquo;You can't always refuse to take presents,&equo; she said tightly, &bquo;not when it's your own mother, not when you're an only child.&equo; 
 &bquo;So you took a job in Germany?&equo; 
 Wexford asked. 
 &bquo;I thought it would be as well to get away.&equo; 
 The flush returned, an unbecoming mottled red. 
 &bquo;In January,&equo; she said hesitantly, &bquo;I met a man, a salesman who made business trips to Cologne from this country.&equo; 
 Wexford waited for her to talk of love and instead heard her say with a strange sense of shock, &bquo;I gave up my job, as I told you, and came back to London to live with him. 
 When I told him that if we were to be married I wouldn't ask my father for a penny he&hellip; well, he threw me out.&equo; 
 &bquo;You returned to your parents?&equo; 
 Nora Fanshawe raised her head and for the first time he saw her smile, an ugly harsh smile of self-mockery. 
 &bquo;You're a cold fish, aren't you?&equo; she said surprisingly. 
 &bquo;I was under the impression you despised sympathy, Miss Fanshawe.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps I do. 
 Want some more coffee? 
 No, nor do I. Yes, I went back to my parents. 
 I was still sorry for my mother, you see. 
 I thought my father was older now and I was older. 
 I knew I could never live with them again, but I thought&hellip; 
 Family quarrels are uncivilised, don't you think? 
 My mother was rather pathetic. 
 She said she'd always wanted a grown-up daughter to be real friends with.&equo; 
 Nora Fanshawe wrinkled her nose in distaste. 
 &bquo;Even upstage reserved characters like myself have their weak spots, Chief Inspector. 
 I went to Eastover with them.&equo; 
 &bquo;And the quarrel, Miss Fanshawe?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm coming to that. 
 We'd been on surprisingly good terms up till then. 
 My father called my mother darling once or twice and there was a kind of Darby and Joan air about them. 
 They wanted to know what I was doing about getting another job and all was serene. 
 So serene, in fact, that after we'd had a meal at the bungalow and a few drinks my mother did something she'd never done before. 
 My father had gone off up to bed and she suddenly began to tell me what her life with him had been, the bribery and the humiliation and so on. 
 She really talked as if I were a woman friend of her own age, her confidante. 
 Well, we had about an hour of this and then she asked me if I had any romantic plans of my own. 
 Those were her words. 
 Like a fool I told her about the man I'd been living with. 
 I say like a fool. 
 Perhaps if I hadn't been a fool I would have been the dead girl in the road.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your mother reacted unsympathetically?&equo; 
 &bquo;She goggled at me,&equo; said Nora Fanshawe, emphasising the verb pedantically. 
 &bquo;Then, before I could stop her she got my father out of bed and told him the whole thing. 
 They both raved at me. 
 My mother was hysterical and my father called me a lot of unpleasant names. 
 I stood it for a bit and then I'm afraid I said to him that what was sauce for the goose and at least I wasn't married.&equo; 
 She sighed, moving her angular shoulders. 
 &bquo;What do you think he said?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's different for men,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;How did you guess? 
 At any rate, for once my parents presented a united front. 
 After my mother had obligingly betrayed all my confidences to him in my hearing, he said he would find the man &mdash; Michael, that is &mdash; and compel him to marry me. 
 I couldn't stand any more, so I locked myself in my bedroom and in the morning I went to Newhaven and got on the boat. 
 I parted from my mother just about on speaking terms. 
 My father had gone out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you for unbending, Miss Fanshawe. 
 Have you been suggesting that the dead girl might have been your father's mistress?&equo; 
 &bquo;You think it impossible that my father would drive his wife and mistress together to London? 
 I assure you it's not unlikely. 
 For him it would simply have been a matter of bringing the girl along, telling my mother she was coming with them and paying her handsomely for the hardship occasioned.&equo; 
 Wexford kept his eyes from Nora Fanshawe's face. 
 She was as unlike his Sheila as could be. 
 They had in common only their youth and health and the fact, like all women, of each being someone's daughter. 
 The girl's father was dead. 
 In a flash of unusual sentimentality, Wexford thought he would rather be dead than be the man about whom a daughter could say such things. 
 In a level voice he said, &bquo;You gave me to understand that as far as you know there was no woman at the time but your mother. 
 You have no idea who this girl could be?&equo; 
 &bquo;That was the impression I had. 
 I was evidently wrong.&equo; 
 &bquo;Miss Fanshawe, this girl clearly could not have been a friend or neighbour at Eastover whom your parents were simply driving to London. 
 In that case her relatives would have enquired for her, raised a hue and cry at the time of the accident.&equo; 
 &bquo;Surely that would apply whoever she was?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not necessarily. 
 She could be a girl with no fixed address or someone whose landlady or friends expected her to move away about that particular weekend. 
 She may be listed somewhere among missing persons and no search have begun for her because the manner of her life showed that occasional apparent disappearances were not unusual. 
 In other words, she could be a girl who led a somewhat itinerant life in the habit of taking jobs in various parts of the country or moving about to live with different men. 
 Suppose, for instance, she had spent the weekend in some South Coast resort and tried to hitch a lift back to London from your father?&equo; 
 &bquo;My father wouldn't have given a lift to anyone. 
 Both he and my mother disapproved of hitch-hiking. 
 Chief Inspector, you're talking as if everyone in that car is now dead. 
 Aren't you forgetting that my mother is very much alive? 
 She's well on the way to recovery and her brain isn't affected. 
 She insists there was no one in the car but my father and herself.&equo; 
 Nora Fanshawe lifted her eyes and her voice lost some of its confidence. 
 &bquo;I suppose it's possible she could be having some sort of psychological block. 
 She wants to believe my father was a changed man, that no girl was with them, so she's convinced herself they were alone. 
 That could be it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sure it must be.&equo; 
 Wexford got up. 
 &bquo;Good night, Miss Fanshawe. 
 Thank you for the coffee. 
 I take it you'll be staying her a few days?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll keep in touch. 
 Good night, Chief Inspector.&equo; 
 The next step, he thought as he walked home, would be to investigate the missing persons list in the holiday towns and London too, if those proved fruitless. 
 That was routine stuff and not for him. 
 Why, anyway, was he following this road accident that wasn't even properly his province to distract his mind from the urgency of the Hatton affair? 
 Because it had features so distracting and so inexplicable that no-one could simply explain them away? 
 Of course it would turn out that the dead girl was merely someone Jerome Fanshawe had come across that weekend and who had taken his fancy. 
 Nothing so dramatic as Nora Fanshawe had suggested need have happened. 
 Why shouldn't Fanshawe just have said to his wife, &bquo;This young lady has missed her last train and since she lives in London I said we'd give her a lift&equo;? 
 But in that case Mrs Fanshawe would hardly deny the girl's presence. 
 There was more to it than that. 
 There was the handbag. 
 Camb had searched that handbag and found in it nothing but make-up and a little money. 
 That wasn't natural, Wexford reflected. 
 Where were her keys? 
 Come to that, where were all the other things women usually stuff into bags, handkerchiefs, dress shop bills, receipts, tickets, pen, letters? 
 The things which were there were the objects by which someone might be identified. 
 Wexford let himself into his own house and the dog Clytemnestra galloped to meet him. 
 &bquo;What would you do,&equo; Wexford said to his wife, &bquo;if I brought a young girl home and offered you a thousand pounds to let her stay?&equo; 
 &bquo;You haven't got a thousand pounds,&equo; said Mrs Wexford. 
 &bquo;True. 
 There's always a fly in the ointment.&equo; 
 &bquo;On the subject of young girls and money, Mr Vigo has sent a whacking bill for your daughter's tooth.&equo; 
 Wexford looked at it and groaned. 
 &bquo;Pleached walks!&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Chinese Chippendale! 
 I just hope one of my customers pinches his orrery, that's all. 
 Is there any beer in the house?&equo; 
 Suppressing a smile, his wife stepped over the now recumbent form of the knitted dog and went into the kitchen to open a can. 
 A pewter tankard at his elbow, Wexford spent the next couple of hours studying Hatton's log book and Mrs Hatton's engagement diary. 
 It was the week immediately preceding May 21st which interested him. 
 On the 22nd Hatton had paid five hundred pounds into his bank and two days prior to that had either been in possession of a large sum of money or confident of acquiring it, for on the 21st, a Tuesday, he had ordered his new set of teeth. 
 Mrs Hatton's engagement diary was a calendar in the shape of a rectangular book. 
 The left-hand pages bore a coloured photograph of some English beauty spot with an appropriate verse, both for the picture and the time of year, while the right-hand pages were each divided into seven sections. 
 The days of the week were listed on the left side and a space of perhaps one inch by five was allowed for brief jottings. 
 Wexford opened it at Sunday, May 12th. 
 The photograph was of Kentish fruit orchards and the lines beneath it from As You Like It: &bquo;Men are April when they woo, December when they wed. 
 Maids are May while they are maids, but the sky changes when they are wives.&equo;; 
 Not true of the Hattons, he thought. 
 Now to see how Mrs Hatton had occupied herself during that particular week. 
 Nothing for Sunday. 
 Monday May 13th: C left for Leeds. 
 Mother to tea. 
 Tuesday May 14th: RangGas Board. 
 C home 3 pm. 
 Pictures. 
 And here in Hatton's log book was the Leeds trip confirmed. 
 He had stopped twice on the way up, at Norman Cross for lunch at the Merrie England cafe, and at Dave's Diner near Retford for a cup of tea. 
 His room in Leeds was with a Mrs Hubble at 21 Ladysmith Road, and on the return journey he had stopped only once and again at the Merrie England. 
 There was nothing in the log book at this stage to make even Wexford even pause. 
 Hatton had done the journey in the shortest possible time, leaving no possible spare moment for undercover activities. 
 He turned back to the diary. 
 Wednesday, May 15th: C off work. 
 Rang doctor. 
 Mem, NHS, not private. 
 Interesting. 
 Hatton had been ill and at that time apparently not in funds. 
 Thursday May 16th: C summer flu. 
 Ring Jack and Marilyn put off dinner. 
 There was no entry for Friday May 17th. 
 Saturday, May 18th: C better. 
 Doctor called again. 
 Jim and mother came. 
 That completed the week. 
 Wexford turned the page to Sunday, 
 May 18th: C left for Leeds. 
 Mem, will ring me 8 pm. 
 J and M came for drinks and solo game. 
 Opposite was a photograph of a large country house and the lines: &bquo;It is a truth universally acknowledged that a single man in possession of a good fortune must be in want of a wife.&equo; 
 Wexford smiled grimly to himself. 
 Monday, May 20th: C bad again. 
 Left Leeds late. 
 Home 10 pm. 
 Quickly Wexford checked with the log book. 
 Yes, here was Hatton's entry that he had been too ill to start the return journey until noon. 
 He had driven home slowly and stopped twice on the way at the Hollybush at Newark and at the Merrie England. 
 But had he really been ill or had he been shamming, crafty sick to give himself extra time in Leeds? 
 For however he acquired that money he must have acquired it, Wexford was certain, during the 19th or the 20th of May. 
 Tuesday, May 21st. 
 C fit again. 
 Day off. 
 Saw Jack and Marilyn. 
 Appointment 2 pm with dentist. 
 A precise little woman, Lillian Hatton, if not exactly verbose. 
 Impossible to tell if she knew anything. 
 The last place to which she would have confided her secrets was this calendar diary. 
 It didn't look as if Hatton had been up to much on that Monday morning in Leeds, but you never knew. 
 There was always the night between Sunday and Monday to be considered. 
 For all Wexford knew or could remember there might have been a bank robbery in that city at that time. 
 It would have to be checked. 
 He wondered why the Fanshawe business kept intruding and upsetting his concentration, and then suddenly he knew. 
 Fanshawe had crashed his car on Monday, May 20th; an unidentified girl had died on May 20th and also on May 20th something big had happened to Charlie Hatton. 
 But there couldn't be a connection. 
 Fanshawe was a wealthy stockbroker with a flat in Mayfair and, apart from a bit of moral nastiness, not a stain on his character. 
 Charlie Hatton was a cocky little lorry driver who had probably never set foot in Mayfair all his life. 
 It was just a curious coincidence that Hatton had been killed on the day following that of Mrs Fanshawe's regaining consciousness. 
 Wexford closed the books and emptied his tankard for the third time. 
 He was tired and fanciful and he had drunk too much beer. 
 Yawning ponderously, he put Clytemnestra outside the back door and while he waited for her, stood staring emptily at the cloudless, star-filled sky. 
 &bquo;Good morning, Miss Thompson,&equo; Wexford said with a heartiness he didn't feel. 
 &bquo;Mrs Pertwee, if you don't mind.&equo; 
 She picked up one of the wire baskets that were stacked outside the supermarket and gave him a selfconscious, defiant stare. 
 &bquo;Jack and me got married very quietly yesterday afternoon.&equo; 
 &bquo;May I be among the first to offer my congratulations?&equo; 
 &bquo;Thanks very much, I'm sure. 
 We didn't tell no one about it, just went off to church quietly by ourselves. 
 Jack's been so cut up about poor Charlie. 
 When are you going to catch his killer, that's what I want to know? 
 Not putting yourselves out, I reckon, on account of him being a working fella. 
 Been different if he was one of your upper crust. 
 This capitalist society we live in makes me spit, just spit it does.&equo; 
 Wexford backed a little, fearing she might suit the action to the word. 
 The bride snapped her bootbrush eyelashes at him. 
 &bquo;You want to pull your socks up,&equo; she said relentlessly. 
 &bquo;Whoever killed Charlie, hanging'd be too good for him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dear, oh dear,&equo; said Wexford mildly, &bquo;and I thought you progressives were dead against capital punishment.&equo; 
 She banged into the supermarket and Wexford went on his way, smiling wryly. 
 Camb eyed him warily as he entered the police station. 
 &bquo;Getting interested in this Fanshawe business, I gather, sir. 
 I met Miss Fanshawe on my way in.&equo; 
 &bquo;So interested,&equo; Wexford said, &bquo;that I'm sending Detective Constable Loring down to find out who's missing in the holiday towns and it might be worth our while to check with London too.&equo; 
 Burden had left for Stamford. 
 Stepping into the lift, Wexford decided to do the London checking himself. 
 Young women were beginning to get on his nerves. 
 There were so many of them about, and it seemed to him they caused as much trouble to a policeman as burglars. 
 Now to see how many of them were missing in London. 
 This task was for him somewhat infra dig, but until Burden and Sergeant Martin brought him some information he had little else to do, and this way he could, at any rate, be certain it was well done. 
 By lunchtime he had narrowed his search down to three out of the dozens of girls missing in the London area. 
 The first was a Carol Pearson, of Muswell Hill, interesting to him because she had worked as a hairdresser's improver at a shop in Eastcheap. 
 Jerome Fanshawe's office was in Eastcheap and the hairdresser's had a barber's shop attached to it. 
 Hers was also a significant name because she had black hair and her disappearance was reported on May 17th. 
 The second girl, Doreen Dacres, was like Carol Pearson, black-haired and aged twenty, and his interest was aroused because she had left her room in Finchley on May 15th to take a job in Eastbourne. 
 Nothing further had been heard of her either in Finchley or at the Eastbourne club address. 
 Bridget Culross was the last name with which he felt he need concern himself. 
 She was twenty-two years old and had been a nurse at the Princess Louise Clinic in new Cavendish Street. 
 On Saturday May 18th she had gone to spend the weekend with an unnamed boy friend in Brighton, but had not returned to the clinic. 
 It was assumed that she had eloped with her boy friend. 
 Her hair was also dark, her life erratic and her only relative an aunt in County Leix. 
 Young women! 
 Wexford thought irritably, and he thought also of his own daughter who was making him scrape the bottom of his pocket so that at some future possible never-never time she might be able to smile without restraint before the cameras. 
 The long day passed slowly and it grew very hot. 
 Clouds massed heavily, dense and fungoid in shape, over the huddled roofs of the town. 
 But they did nothing to diminish the heat, seeming instead to enclose it and its still, threatening air under a thick muffling lid. 
 The sun had gone, blanked out by sultry vapour. 
 To an observer Wexford might be thought only to be sitting, like many other inhabitants of Kingsmarkham, waiting for the storm to break. 
 He did nothing. 
 He lay back by the open window with his eyes closed and the warm breathless air came to him just as in another cooler season heat fanned from the grid lower down the wall. 
 No one disturbed him and he was glad. 
 He was thinking. 
 In Stamford, where it was raining, Inspector Burden went to a country house supposedly occupied by a man named McCloy and found it deserted, its doors locked and its garden overgrown. 
 There were no neighbours and no one to tell him where McCloy had gone. 
 Detective Constable Loring drove along the promenades of the south coast towns, calling at police stations and paying particular attention to those clubs and cafes and amusement halls where girls come and go and pass each other. 
 He had found a club where Doreen Dacres had been engaged but where no Doreen Dacres had arrived and this comforted him. 
 He even telephoned Wexford to tell him about it, his elation subsiding somewhat when he heard the chief inspector had also found this out three hours before. 
 The storm broke at five o'clock. 
 For some time before this heavy clouds had increased and in the west the sky had become a dense purplish-black, a range of mountainous cumulus against which the outlines of buildings took on a curious clarity and the trees stood out livid and sickly bright. 
 In spite of the clammy heat, shoppers began to hurry, but the rain which fell so readily when rainy days preceded it, now, after a fortnight's drought, held off as if it could only be squeezed out as a result of some acute and agonising pressure. 
 It was as though the clouds were not themselves mere vapour but impermeable sagging sacks, purposely constructed and hung to contain water. 
 The first whispering breeze came like a hot breath and Wexford closed his windows. 
 Almost imperceptibly at first the trees in the High Street pavement began to sway. 
 Most of the merchandise outside greengrocers' and florists' had already been taken in and now it was the turn of the sunblinds to be furled and waterproof awnings to take their place. 
 The air seemed to press against Wexford's windows. 
 He stood against them, watching the dark western sky and the ash-blue cumulus now edged with brilliant white. 
 The lightning was the forked kind and it branched suddenly like a firework and yet like the limb of a blazing tree. 
 As its fiery twigs flashed out and cut into the inky cloud, the thunder rolled out of the west. 
 Wexford dearly loved a storm. 
 He liked the forked lightning better than the zig-zag kind and now he was gratified by a second many-branched display that seemed to spring and grow from the river itself, blossoming in the sky above the Kingsbrook meadows. 
 This time the thunder burst with a pistol-shot snap and with an equal suddenness, as if at last those swollen vessels had been punctured, the rain began to fall. 
 The first heavy drops splashed in coin shapes on the pavement below and in their tubs the pink flowers on the forecourt dipped and swayed. 
 For a brief moment it seemed that the rain still hesitated, that it would only patter dispiritedly on the dust-filled gutters where its drops rolled like quick-silver. 
 But then, urged on as it were by a series of multiple lightning flashes, it hesitated no more and, instead of increasing gradually from the first tentative shower, the water gushed forth in a vast fountain. 
 It dashed against the windows, washing off dust in a great cleansing stream, and Wexford moved away from the glass. 
 The sudden flood was more like a wave than rain and it blinded the window as surely as darkness. 
 He heard the car splash in and the doors slam. 
 Burden, perhaps. 
 The internal phone rang and Wexford lifted the receiver. 
 &bquo;I've got Cullam here, sir.&equo; 
 It was Martin's voice. 
 &bquo;Shall I bring him up? 
 I thought you might like to talk to him.&equo; 
 Maurice Cullam was afraid of the storm. 
 That didn't displease Wexford. 
 With some scorn he eyed the man's pale face and the bony, none-too-steady hands. 
 &bquo;Scared, Cullam? 
 Not to worry, we'll all die together.&equo; 
 &bquo;Big laugh,&equo; said Cullam, and he winced as the thunder broke above their heads. 
 &bquo;I don't reckon it's safe being so high up. 
 When I was a kid I was in a house that got stuck.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you got out unscathed, eh? 
 Well they say the devil looks after his own. 
 Why have you brought him here, Sergeant?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's bought that refrigerator,&equo; said Sergeant Martin. 
 &bquo;And a room heater and a load of other electrical bits and pieces. 
 Paid cash for them, a couple of quid short of a hundred and twenty pounds.&equo; 
 Wexford put the lights on and behind the streaming glass the sky looked black as on a winter's night. 
 &bquo;All right, Cullam, where did you get it?&equo; 
 &bquo;I saved it up.&equo; 
 &bquo;I see. 
 When did you buy that washing machine of yours, the one you washed your gear in after Hatton died?&equo; 
 &bquo;April.&equo; 
 As the storm receded and the thunder became a distant grumbling, Cullam's shoulders dropped and he lifted sullen eyes. 
 &bquo;April, it was.&equo; 
 &bquo;So, you've saved another hundred and twenty pounds in just two months. 
 What do you get a week? 
 Twenty? 
 Twenty-two? 
 You with five kids and council house rent to pay? 
 You've saved it in two months? 
 Come off it, Cullam. 
 I couldn't save it in six and my kids are grown up.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't prove I didn't save it.&equo; 
 Cullam gave a slight shiver as the overhead light flickered off, then on again. 
 A rolling like the banging of many drums, distant at first, then breaking into a staccato crackling, announced the return of the storm to Kingsmarkham. 
 He shifted in his chair, biting his lip. 
 Wexford smiled as a zig-zag flash changed the gentle illumination of the office into a sudden white blaze. 
 &bquo;A hundred pounds,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That's pathetic payment for a man's life. 
 What's yours worth, Sergeant?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm insured for five thousand, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's not quite what I meant, but we'll let it pass. 
 You see, an assassin is paid according to his own self-valuation. 
 Never mind what the victim's life's worth. 
 If a road sweeper kills the king he can't expect to get the same gratuity as a general. 
 He wouldn't expect it. 
 His standards are low. 
 So if you're going to employ an assassin and you're a mean skinflint you pick on the lowest of the low to do your dirty work. 
 Mind you, it won't be so well done.&equo; 
 Wexford's last words were drowned in thunder. 
 &bquo;What d'you mean, lowest of the low?&equo; 
 Cullam lifted abject yet truculent eyes. 
 &bquo;The cap fits, does it? 
 They don't come much lower than you, Cullam. 
 What, drink with a man &mdash; drink the whisky he paid for &mdash; and then lie in wait to kill him?&equo; 
 &bquo;I never killed Charlie Hatton!&equo; 
 Cullam leapt trembling to his feet. 
 The lightning flared into his face and, covering his eyes with one hand, he said desperately, &bquo;For God's sake can't we go downstairs?&equo; 
 &bquo;I reckon Hatton was right when he called you an old woman, Cullam.&equo; 
 Wexford said in disgust. 
 &bquo;We'll go downstairs when I'm good and ready. 
 You talk and when you've told me where McCloy is and what he paid you, then you can go downstairs and hide your head.&equo; 
 Still on his feet, Cullam leant on the desk, his head hanging. 
 &bquo;It's a lie,&equo; he whispered. 
 &bquo;I don't know McCloy and I never touched Hatton.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where did the money come from then? 
 Oh, sit down, Cullam. 
 What sort of man are you, anyway, scared of a bit of thunder? 
 It's laughable, afraid of a storm but brave enough to wait in the dark down by the river and bash your friend over the head. 
 Come on now, you may as well tell us. 
 You'll have to sooner or later and I reckon this storm's set in for hours. 
 Hatton had fallen foul of McCloy, hadn't he? 
 So McCloy greased your palm a bit to walk home with Hatton and catch him unawares. 
 The weapon and the method were left to you. 
 Curious, you were so mean, you even grudged him a proper cosh.&equo; 
 Cullam said again, &bquo;It's all a lie.&equo; 
 He twisted down into the chair, holding his head and keeping it averted from the window. 
 &bquo;Me bash Charlie on the head with one of them stones? 
 I wouldn't have thought of it&hellip; 
 I wouldn't&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Then how did you know it was a river stone that killed him?&equo; 
 Wexford pounced triumphantly. 
 Slowly Cullam raised his head and the sweat glistened on his skin. 
 &bquo;I didn't tell you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nor me, sir,&equo; said the sergeant. 
 &bquo;Jesus,&equo; Cullam said, his voice uneven and low. 
 The black clouds had parted to show between them shreds of summer sky turned sickly green. 
 Against the glass the unremitting rain pounded. 
 Stamford police knew nothing of Alexander James McCloy. 
 His name was on the voters' list as occupying Moat Hall, the small mansion Burden had found deserted, but plainly he had left it months before. 
 Burden plodded through the rain from estate agent to estate agent and he at last found Moat Hall, listed in the books of a small firm on the outskirts of the town. 
 It had been sold in December by McCloy to an American widow who, having changed her mind without ever living in the place, had returned it to the agent's hands and departed to spend the summer in Sweden. 
 Mr McCloy had left them no address. 
 Why should he? 
 His business with them had been satisfactorily completed; he had taken his money from the American lady and disappeared. 
 No, there had never really been anything in Mr McCloy's behaviour to make them believe he wasn't a man of integrity. 
 &bquo;What do you mean, &bquo;really&equo;?&equo; 
 Burden asked. 
 &bquo;Only that the place was never kept decently as far as I could see, not the way a gentleman's house should be. 
 It was a crying shame to see those grounds neglected. 
 Still, he was a bachelor and he'd no staff as far as I know.&equo; 
 Moat Hall lay in a fold of the hills perhaps a mile from the A1. 
 &bquo;Was he always alone when you saw him at the house?&equo; 
 Burden asked. 
 &bquo;Once he had a couple of chaps with him. 
 Not quite up to his class I thought.&equo; 
 &bquo;Tell me, were you taken all over the house and grounds to make your survey or whatever you do?&equo; 
 &bquo;Certainly. 
 It was all quite above board &mdash; none too clean, but that's by the way. 
 Mr McCloy gave me a free hand to go where I chose, bar the two big outhouses. 
 They were used for stores he said, so there was no point in me looking. 
 The doors were padlocked anyway and I got what I wanted for my purpose from looking at the outside.&equo; 
 &bquo;No stray lorries knocking about, I daresay?&equo; 
 &bquo;None that I saw.&equo; 
 &bquo;But there might have been in the outhouses?&equo; 
 &bquo;There might at that,&equo; said the agent doubtfully. 
 &bquo;One of them's near as big as a hangar.&equo; 
 &bquo;So I noticed.&equo; 
 And Burden thanked him grimly. 
 He was almost certain that he had found him, that he could say, &bquo;Our McCloy was here,&equo; and yet what had he achieved but dredge up a tiny segment of McCloy's life? 
 The man had been here and had gone. 
 All they could do now was to turn Moat Hall upside down in the forlorn hope something remained in the near-derelict place to hint at its erstwhile owner's present refuge. 
 &bquo;Are you going to charge me with murdering him?&equo; 
 Cullam said hollowly. 
 &bquo;You and McCloy and maybe a couple of others when you've told us who they are. 
 Conspiracy to murder, the charge'll be. 
 Not that it makes much difference.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I've got five kids!&equo; 
 &bquo;Paternity never kept anyone out of jail yet, Cullam. 
 Come now, you wouldn't want to go inside alone, would you? 
 You wouldn't want to think of McCloy laughing, going scotfree, while you're doing fifteen years? 
 It'll be the same sentence for him, you know. 
 He doesn't get off any lighter just because he only told you to kill Hatton.&equo; 
 &bquo;He never did,&equo; Cullam said wildly. 
 &bquo;How many times do I have to tell you I don't know this McCloy?&equo; 
 &bquo;A good many times before I'd believe you. 
 Why would you kill Hatton on your own? 
 You don't have to kill a man because he's got more money and a nicer home than you have.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't kill him!&equo; 
 Cullam's voice came dangerously near a sob. 
 Wexford switched off the light and for a moment the room seemed very dark. 
 Then, as his eyes grew accustomed, he saw that it was no darker than on any summer evening after heavy rain. 
 The light had a cold bluish tinge and the air was cooler too. 
 He opened the window and a light fresh breeze clutched at the curtains. 
 Down below on the forecourt the tub flowers had been flattened into a sodden pink mush. 
 &bquo;Listen, Cullam,&equo; he said, &bquo;you were there. 
 You left the bridge ten minutes before Hatton started. 
 It was twenty to eleven when you said goodbye to Hatton and Pertwee and even walking none too fast you should have been indoors at home by eleven. 
 But you didn't get in till a quarter past. 
 The following morning you washed the shirt you'd been wearing, the pullover and the trousers. 
 You knew a river stone had been used to kill Hatton and today you, who get twenty pounds a week and never have a penny to bless yourself with, spent a hundred and twenty quid on luxury equipment. 
 Explain it away, Cullam, explain it away. 
 The storm's blowing over and you've nothing to worry about except fifteen years inside.&equo; 
 Cullam opened his big ill-made hands, clenched them and leant forward. 
 The sweat had dried on his face. 
 He seemed to be having difficulty in controlling the muscles which worked in his forehead and at the corners of his mouth. 
 Wexford waited patiently, for he guessed that for a moment the man was totally unable to speak. 
 Terror had dried and paralysed his vocal chords. 
 He waited patiently, but without a vestige of sympathy. 
 &bquo;The hundred quid and his pay packet,&equo; Cullam said at last. 
 His tone was hoarse and terrified. 
 &bquo;I&hellip; 
 I took it off his body.&equo; 
 &bquo;What did he want it for, Charlie-bloody-Hatton? 
 I've been in his place, I've seen what he'd got. 
 You ever seen his wife, have you? 
 Got up like a tart with her new frocks and her jewellery and all that muck on her face, and not a bleeding thing to do all day long but watch that colour telly and ring up her pals. 
 They hadn't got no kids, yelling and nagging at you the minute you get in, crawling all over you in the night because they're cutting their bloody teeth. 
 You want to know when my missus last had a new frock? 
 You want to know when we last had a night out? 
 The answer's never, not since the first baby come. 
 My missus has to buy the kids' clothes down the jumble sale and if she wants a pair of nylons they come off the Green Shield stamps. 
 Bloody marvellous, isn't it? 
 Lilian Hatton's got more coats than a perishing film star but she has to go and spend thirty quid on a new outfit for Pertwee's wedding. 
 A hundred pounds? 
 She wouldn't even miss it. 
 She could use it for spills to light her fags.&equo; 
 The flood-gates had opened and now Cullam, the reticent, the truculent, was speaking without restraint and from a full heart. 
 Wexford was listening with concentration, but he did not appear to be listening at all. 
 If Cullam had been in a fit state to observe behaviour he might have thought the chief inspector bored or preoccupied. 
 But Cullam only wanted to talk. 
 He was indifferent to listeners. 
 All he required was the luxury of silence and a nearly empty room. 
 &bquo;I could have stuck it all,&equo; he said, &bquo;but for the bragging. 
 &equo; Put it away, Maurice,&equo; he'd say. 
 &bquo;Your need's greater than mine,&equo; and then he'd tell me about the new necklace he'd bought for his missus. 
 &bquo;Plenty more where that came from,&equo; he'd say. 
 Christ, and I can't find the money to buy my kids new shoes! 
 Two kids I'd got when I'd been married as long as Hatton. 
 Is it fair? 
 Is it right? 
 You tell me.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've listened to the party political broadcast,&equo; said Wexford. 
 &bquo;I don't give a damn for your envy. 
 Envy like yours is a hell of a good motive for murder.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah? 
 What would I get for killing him? 
 I wasn't in his will, I've told you what I did. 
 I took the money off his body. 
 Five kids I've got and the milkman don't come till eleven in the morning. 
 You ever tried keeping milk for five kids without a fridge in a heatwave?&equo; 
 He paused and with a shifty, fidgety look, said, &bquo;D'you know what Hatton'd have done that Saturday if he hadn't been killed? 
 Wedding first, Pertwee's wedding, and Hatton all got up in a topper with his tarty wife. 
 Round the shops afterwards, not to buy anything, just to fritter. 
 Charlie told me it wasn't nothing for them to get through twenty nicker poking about in the shops. 
 Bottle of wine here, some muck for her face there. 
 Then they'd have some more booze at the Olive, have dinner. 
 Off to the pictures in the evening and in the best seats. 
 Bit of a contrast from me, isn't it? 
 If I want to relax I go out in the garden, anywhere to get away from the kids' bawling.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you a Catholic, Cullam?&equo; 
 That surprised him. 
 He had perhaps been expecting a tougher comment and he hunched his shoulders, muttering suspiciously, &bquo;I haven't got no religion.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't give me that stuff about children then. 
 Nobody makes you have children. 
 Ever heard of the pill? 
 My God, they knew how to plan families twenty years, thirty years before you were born.&equo; 
 Wexford's voice grew hard as he warmed to a favourite theme. 
 &bquo;Having kids is a privilege, a joy, or it should be, and, by God, I'll get the County down on you if I see you strike that boy of yours on the head again! 
 You're a bloody animal, Cullam, without an animal's&hellip; 
 Oh! what's the use? 
 What the hell are you doing anyway, cluttering up my office, wasting my time? 
 Cut the sob stuff and tell me what happened that night. 
 What happened when you left Hatton and Pertwee at the bridge?&equo; 
 Stamford had promised to give Burden all the help they could and they were as good as their word. 
 A sergeant and a constable went back with him to Moat Hall and the locks on the two outhouses were forced. 
 Inside they found oil on the concrete floor and, imprinted by that oil, a tracery of tyre marks. 
 Apart from that there was nothing to show a suspect occupancy but two crushed cardboard cases in one corner. 
 Both had contained canned peaches. 
 &bquo;No joy here,&equo; said Burden to the sergeant. 
 He threw the flattened cardboard down in disgust. 
 &bquo;I've got things like this in my own garage at home. 
 The supermarket gives them to me to bring my wife's shopping home in on Fridays.&equo; 
 He came to the doorway and started across the deserted yard. 
 As surely as if he could see them actually arriving, see them now, he pictured the stolen lorries driven in. 
 The big doors would open for them and close on them and McCloy and the men who were &bquo;not quite up to his class' would unload them and store the cargoes here. 
 Back-slapping, laughing immoderately, Charlie Hatton would go into the house for a drink and a &bquo;bite to eat&equo; before driving the lorry away and abandoning it. 
 &bquo;I'd like to go over the house,&equo; he said, &bquo;only breaking and entering's not in my line. 
 We'll have to wait for permission from the expatriate lady in Sweden.&equo; 
 Cullam got up and wandered to the window. 
 He looked as if he expected Wexford to hinder him, but Wexford said nothing. 
 &bquo;He was flashing all this money about in the Dragon. 
 On and on about it he was when we walked up to the bridge.&equo; 
 Cullam stood by the window, staring fixedly now at the road he had trodden with Hatton and Pertwee. 
 The wet pavements cast back mirror reflections. 
 Wexford guessed the Kingsbrook must have swollen now, its stones submerged under a mill-race. 
 &bquo;Pertwee told me to wait for Charlie Hatton,&equo; Cullam said. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't do that. 
 God, I was sick of him and his money.&equo; 
 Slowly he pushed a hand through his thin tow-coloured hair. 
 &bquo;Anyway, I told you, I wasn't feeling too good. 
 I just walked along the path in the dark.&equo; 
 Thinking of what you were going home to, Wexford thought, and what Hatton was. 
 There would have been no sound down there but the sibilant trickle of water. 
 Above Cullam, above the web of black branches, a tranquil galaxy, a net of stars. 
 Greed and envy took from a man's heart everything but &mdash; well, greed and envy. 
 If Cullam had noticed anything as he walked it would have been the rubbish, the flotsam that the river sucked in and gathered on Its journey through the meadows. 
 &bquo;Did you wait for him?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wait, nothing!&equo; 
 Cullam said hotly. 
 &bquo;Why would I? 
 I hated his guts.&equo; 
 Wexford wondered how long since anyone had made so many damaging admissions in this office in so short a space of time. 
 Cullam burst out violently. 
 &bquo;I was sick then. 
 I threw up under the trees. 
 And I felt bloody, I can tell you.&equo; 
 He shuddered a little, but whether at the memory of this vomiting by the water's edge or of something even uglier Wexford could not tell. 
 He watched the man narrowly, not caring for the wariness of his eyes and the way his hands had begun to twitch. 
 &bquo;I'm not used to whisky. 
 A half of bitter's more my line.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're not the only one,&equo; Wexford said sharply. 
 &bquo;What happened then? 
 Did you hear Hatton approach?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd heard him for a bit by then. 
 I could hear him whistling a long way behind. 
 He was whistling that stupid little old song of his about the man who was scared to go home in the dark.&equo; 
 Wexford looked up and met the shifty eyes. 
 They slid away furtively, the pink lids blinking. 
 Was Cullam a complete clod or did he realise how macabre his words had been? 
 A man would have to be totally deficient in imagination to fail to be struck with a kind of horror and awe. 
 &bquo;Mabel, dear, 
 Listen here, 
 There's robbery in the park&hellip;&equo; 
 Burden, who had heard them, had memorised the words and repeated them to his chief. 
 &bquo;Robbery in the park&hellip; 
 ' How did it go on? 
 Something about there being no place like home but he couldn't go home in the dark. 
 It was Wexford's turn to shiver now. 
 In spite of his age, his experience, he felt a cold thrill run through him. 
 &bquo;Then it happened,&equo; Cullam said suddenly. 
 His voice trembled. 
 &bquo;You're not going to believe this, are you?&equo; 
 Wexford only shrugged. 
 &bquo;It's the truth. 
 I swear it's the truth.&equo; 
 &bquo;Save your swearing for the dock, Cullam.&equo; 
 &bquo;Christ&hellip;&equo; 
 The man made a sudden effort and the words tumbled out fast. 
 &bquo;The whistling stopped. 
 I heard a sort of sound&hellip;&equo; 
 He had no descriptive power, few adjectives but hackneyed obscenities. 
 &bquo;A kind of choking, a sort of &mdash; well, God, it was horrible! 
 I felt so bloody bad, anyway. 
 After a bit I got up and &mdash; I went back. 
 I was scared stiff. 
 It was sort of creepy down there. 
 I couldn't see nothing and I &mdash; I stumbled over him. 
 He was lying on the path. 
 Could I have a drink of water?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be a damned fool,&equo; Wexford snapped. 
 &bquo;You needn't be so rough with me,&equo; Cullam whined, &bquo;I'm telling you, aren't I? 
 I don't have to tell you.&equo; 
 &bquo;You have to, Cullam.&equo; 
 &bquo;I struck a match,&equo; the man mumbled. 
 &bquo;Charlie's head was all bashed in. 
 I turned him over and I got blood on me.&equo; 
 The words slurred and he gabbled. 
 &bquo;I don't know what come over me. 
 I put my hand inside his coat and took hold of that wallet. 
 There was a hundred quid in it, just on a hundred. 
 He was all warm&hellip;&equo; 
 Wexford stared at him aghast. 
 &bquo;He was dead, though?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know&hellip; 
 I don't&hellip; 
 Christ, yes, he was dead! 
 He must have been dead. 
 What are you trying to do to me?&equo; 
 The man put his head in his hands and his shoulders shook. 
 Wexford took hold of his jacket roughly, pushing him so that his head jerked up. 
 The tears on Cullam's cheeks awoke in him a nausea and a rage so fierce that it was all he could do to prevent himself from striking him. 
 &bquo;That's all, everything.&equo; 
 Cullam whispered, shuddering. 
 &bquo;The body rolled down the slope into the water. 
 I ran home then, I ran like hell.&equo; 
 He put his fists into his eyes like a child. 
 &bquo;It's all true.&equo; 
 he said. 
 &bquo;The stone, Cullam, what about the stone?&equo; 
 &bquo;It was laying by him. 
 By his legs. 
 I don't know why but I chucked it back in the water. 
 There was blood on it and hair, bits of hair and &mdash; and other bits&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;A bit late in the day to get squeamish, wasn't it?&equo; 
 Wexford's tone was savage, its effect electric. 
 Cullam sprang to his feet and let out a great cry, drumming his fists on the desk. 
 &bquo;I never killed him, I never, never&hellip;! 
 You've got to believe me.&equo; 
 Burden had just come in, damp and disgruntled, when Wexford erupted bull-like from the lift. 
 &bquo;Where's Martin?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't ask me. 
 I've just driven close on two hundred miles and I&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Never mind all that. 
 I've got Cullam upstairs and he's come out with a fine tale.&equo; 
 Controlling his voice with an effort, he gave Burden a swift precis. 
 &bquo;Says he took the money off Hatton's corpse. 
 Maybe that's all he did. 
 I just don't know.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you'll hold him? 
 Keep him here on a charge of stealing the hundred quid and the pay packet?&equo; 
 &bquo;Something like that. 
 Martin can deal with it. 
 I want you and Loring and anyone else going spare over in Sewingbury to turn Cullam's house upside down.&equo; 
 &bquo;In case he's got McCloy's blood money hidden away?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mike, I'm just beginning to wonder,&equo; Wexford said wearily, &bquo;if McCloy isn't a myth, a fiction. 
 Cullam's a damned liar and all we know of McCloy rests on his word alone. 
 Why shouldn't he have fabricated McCloy as a neat little red herring?&equo; 
 He sighed. 
 &bquo;Only he hasn't got any imagination,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;McCloy exists all right,&equo; Burden said emphatically. 
 &bquo;He's an elusive sort of bird but he exists.&equo; 
 It was eleven when Wexford got home. 
 They had searched Cullam's house, grubbing through soiled unmade beds, cupboards full of clothes that smelt of food spills, drawers containing a jumble of broken rubbish. 
 They had searched but the only money they had found was two and eightpence in Mrs Cullam's handbag, a white plastic handbag with black grease in its creases. 
 And their only sinister discovery was bruises and contusions on the legs of one of the children&hellip; 
 &bquo;Give me an ounce of civet, good apothecary,&equo; said Wexford to Clytemnestra, &bquo;to sweeten my imagination.&equo; 
 In the belief that he had told her she was a good dog, Clytemnestra wagged her plumed grey tail. 
 The door opened and Sheila came in. 
 &bquo;What are you doing home on a Wednesday?&equo; said her father ungraciously. 
 &bquo;That thing came off my tooth. 
 I was eating a Milky Way and it collapsed. 
 So I had to come down and see Mr Vigo.&equo; 
 She gave him a disarming smile and kissed his cheek. 
 Her hair was dressed in a pyramid of fat ringlets and she looked like a Restoration wench, maid to Millamant, scene stealer, fit to be kissed in corners. 
 &bquo;Well, did he fix it up?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mm-hm. 
 On the spot. 
 He said he wouldn't charge me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Charge you? 
 Me, you mean. 
 And I should hope not.&equo; 
 Wexford grinned, sloughing off the memory of Cullam's filth like a soiled skin. 
 &bquo;Now you've got false teeth,&equo; he said, &bquo;you mustn't expect to eat toffee.&equo; 
 &bquo;I haven't got false teeth. 
 I've just got a crown. 
 D'you want some of my coff-choc? 
 It's Nes and drinking chocolate mixed up. 
 Quite groovy.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't think so, lovey, thanks all the same.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mr Vigo and I got quite matey,&equo; said Sheila. 
 She dropped on the floor and, lying on her stomach with her elbows on the carpet, looking up into his face. 
 &bquo;He gave me tea in that Chinese room of his. 
 I was scared to move, he's obviously so crazy about all that stuff. 
 His wife came in and banged the door and he was furious because it made the china rattle; he said she just didn't understand.&equo; 
 &bquo;How quaint. 
 What you might call a new one.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Pop, it wasn't like that. 
 When I went the receptionist was just leaving and she walked down into the town with me. 
 She said Mr Vigo had really married for money. 
 She was an heiress and she had a hundred thousand pounds and Mr Vigo wanted money to collect that Chinese stuff. 
 He only stays with his wife now because of the baby. 
 And he goes away most weekends. 
 Sometimes he doesn't come back till quite late on a Monday night. 
 The receptionist thinks he's got a girl friend in London. 
 She seemed a bit jealous. 
 D'you know, I get the idea he sleeps with her too.&equo; 
 Wexford kept his face unmoved, but for the faintest flicker of what he hoped looked like sophisticated amusement. 
 He wasn't shocked by what he had been told; he was astonished that it should have been said to him by his own daughter. 
 In a way he was proud and grateful. 
 Nearly forty years had passed since he was Sheila's age. 
 Could he have spoken such words to his father? 
 He would rather have died. 
 Sheila stretched, got up easily. 
 &bquo;Since I'm home,&equo; she said, &bquo;I may as well do my duty. 
 Fancy ten minutes down by the river, dog?&equo; 
 Wexford Said quickly, &bquo;No, not there, sweetheart.&equo; 
 What, allow his child to walk alone by those dark waters? 
 &bquo;I'll take the dog.&equo; 
 &bquo;Really?&equo; 
 &bquo;Go on. 
 Get off to bed. 
 That hair looks as though it'll take a lot of coping with.&equo; 
 Sheila giggled. 
 &bquo;You'd be surprised.&equo; 
 He stared, somewhat appalled, as she lifted the wig like a hat and dropped it over a cut-glass vase. 
 &bquo;My God, it's a wise father that knows his own child!&equo; 
 He eyed her eyelashes suspiciously, her long fingernails. 
 How many more bits were take-off-able? 
 Wexford, who was hardly ever shaken from his equilibrium by the devious excesses of criminals, was perpetually astonished by his own daughter. 
 Smiling wryly, he fetched the lead and yanked Clytemnestra from the best armchair. 
 The night air was fresh, washed by the storm into a cool clarity. 
 Hardly a star showed, for the sky was veiled by a lacy wrack, bleached snow-white by the moon that rose in a clear unclouded patch. 
 The meadow grass he had compared to a tapestry had since that earlier walk been cut and the land had become a pale stubbly desert. 
 It was cold for the time of year. 
 When he came to the river he saw that it was much swollen. 
 In places the stones were totally submerged under the racing water. 
 Wexford whistled up the dog and stepped on briskly. 
 He could see the bridge now, its stones gleaming silver and the hart's tongue ferns between them like shivering slivers of metal. 
 Someone was standing on the parapet, leaning over and looking down. 
 It was some time before Wexford could decide whether it was a man or a woman and when he realised it was a woman he called out a brisk, cheerful good night so that she should not be afraid. 
 &bquo;Good night, Chief Inspector.&equo; 
 The voice was low, ironic, immediately identifiable. 
 Wexford approached Nora Fanshawe and she turned to face him. 
 &bquo;A fine evening after the storm,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;How's your mother?&equo; 
 &bquo;She'll live,&equo; the girl said coolly. 
 A reserve that was part distaste blanked her features. 
 Wexford knew that look. 
 He had seen it hundreds of times on the faces of people who fancied that they had said too much to him, opened their hearts too wide. 
 Presumably they imagined their confidences led him to regard them with disgust or pity or contempt. 
 If only they knew that to him their revelations were but bricks in the house he was trying to build, rungs on the ladder of discovery, twisted curve-edged pieces in the current puzzle! 
 &bquo;Nothing fresh come back to her?&equo; 
 &bquo;If you mean about the girl in the car, she says there was no girl. 
 I know when she's telling the truth.&equo; 
 &bquo;People never remember what happened immediately before they got hit on the head,&equo; Wexford said cheerfully, &bquo;especially when their skulls are fractured. 
 It's a medical fact.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that so? 
 I mustn't keep you, Chief Inspector. 
 Did you know your dog's out in the road?&equo; 
 Wexford retrieved Clytemnestra from the path of a solitary oncoming car. 
 The driver wound down his window and cursed him, adding that for two pins he'd tell the police. 
 &bquo;Blooming thorn in my flesh, you are,&equo; Wexford said to the dog as he clipped the lead. 
 on. 
 &bquo;A source of humiliation.&equo; 
 He watched the girl retreat into the Olive and Dove, the moonlight casting her shadow black, straight and attenuated. 
 Ibrahim's got a video and sometimes he lets me watch it. 
 I can't always follow the story in films and that, but sometimes I like watching the telly &mdash; specially nature programmes and that. 
 He never opens his curtains, so it's always like night in his room, even if it's daytime. 
 He's got this red light, so it looks all cosy, and sometimes he uses a candle. 
 It's pretty cosy, but to tell the truth it ain't all that comfy. 
 All he's got is a mattress on the floor and this video machine. 
 There ain't no chairs or carpet or nothing, so if I go and see him I have to sit on the floor. 
 I don't mind it really. 
 I don't think people in the house like Ibrahim all that much. 
 I can tell by the way people look at him. 
 He don't talk too much cos his English ain't so good, so people don't really bother to talk back. 
 But sometimes they come to his room to watch the video. 
 He don't mind that at all &mdash; I think he likes the company. 
 When he shows a film or summat his room's like a little cinema &mdash; you know, people sitting round watching the telly in the dark, and smoking and laughing at the funny bits and that. 
 When it's just me and Ibrahim he talks a lot about his home. 
 I can't remember where he comes from, but it's in the desert I think. 
 I reckon he's pretty homesick to tell the truth. 
 When it's just me and him he plays his favourite where he lived. 
 It looks pretty nice from the pictures. 
 All hot and that. 
 It must be blummin cold in England if you come from the desert. 
 He's got a wife in his home, but he ain't seen her for ages. 
 I reckon that must be pretty lonely like, not ever seeing your family. 
 He says he wants to go back to his country, but he can't. 
 I dunno why, but he says he can't. 
 Sometimes he talks in a foreign language &mdash; you know, just to himself like. 
 I don't understand it or nothing, but I like listening anyhow. 
 It's like sort of music. 
 He's got a friend &mdash; this black man who comes to the house sometimes. 
 I don't think he lives here, cos I never see him except in Ibrahim's room. 
 He usually brings food and stuff, but he don't stay for long. 
 He just brings stuff for Ibrahim and then goes. 
 Ibrahim never goes out, not even to the shops or nothing. 
 I spect it's cos it's too cold. 
 I reckon it must be real cold after the desert. 
 When his friend comes, they talk together in this foreign language. 
 I suppose he's from Ibrahim's country, but I never asked. 
 Nobody likes Ibrahim much. 
 Nobody goes to see him unless he's showing a video. 
 But I think Ibrahim's OK. 
 To tell the truth, I think he's pretty lonely on account of his wife and that. 
 He's always pleased to see me and sometimes he gives me food and stuff. 
 Once he told me he likes me cos I don't ask questions. 
 I think Ibrahim must be ill or summat, cos Marie says he's a junky &mdash; you know, he's got to take drugs and stuff like that. 
 It's a shame really that people got to take medicine. 
 But they have, you know, or else they'll get iller. 
 But I think Ibrahim's OK. 
 He's a little funny sometimes, but he's real kind and that. 
 If the weather's all right and it's not raining or nothing, I usually go to the garden to help Mr Frost. 
 He's got a key, and if he's in the garden he lets me in. 
 It's not his job or nothing, but he likes doing stuff in the garden, and most days he's there. 
 He's pretty old and don't hear too well, and I have to shout so he can hear me. 
 There was a boy at school who was deaf, but he could read lips so we didn't have to shout. 
 But I do with Mr Frost. 
 He's always saying &bquo;What say, boy?&equo; and I have to go right up to him and shout. 
 I think he should get a hearing aid &mdash; it's easier than shouting all the time. 
 We don t do much in the garden &mdash; a bit of weeding or raking leaves and that, but I like it anyhow. 
 Nothing much grows in winter, but it's nice to be in the garden. 
 Mr Frost says it looks real nice in the summer when all the flowers come out. 
 I can't wait for the summer. 
 I bet it looks real good. 
 Marie helps me with my money, and every week she gives me some so I can buy plants and stuff for my room. 
 I got loads of plants now. 
 I dunno their names and stuff, but they're real nice. 
 There's this flower shop not far from the house, and I go there and buy summat every week. 
 I go on my own like, not with no one else. 
 I reckon that's pretty grown up. 
 The woman in the shop's pretty friendly and she tells me what to do with the plants &mdash; you know, water them once a week, or keep them out of draughts and that. 
 The other week she tried to get me to buy some different plants, but I didn't do it. 
 I get the same plants every week &mdash; these real nice ones with the soft petals. 
 I got loads of them now &mdash; mostly different colours. 
 I really like them ones. 
 They're my favourite. 
 Fullblast calls me Billy Weed on account of all my plants. 
 I told him they ain't weeds, but proper plants like, but he still keeps on calling me Billy Weed. 
 I promised Marie I wouldn't go out with Fullblast again. 
 nicks things, and if I did that, the police would come and take me away. 
 So I promised I wouldn't go out with him again. 
 I wouldn't nick things anyhow, cos it's wrong. 
 I reckon of all my favourite bits, I like when me and Marie are on our own best. 
 Like when we go to the laundrette, or she takes me to the swimming baths to have a hot shower. 
 it's just her and me. 
 Marie works in this place most nights, so she don't usually come home till I'm asleep. 
 I dunno what her job is cos she never told me. 
 I think it's working in this club or summat. 
 She don't really like it, but she does it anyway. 
 I spect she can't get another job or summat. 
 If I'm with Ibrahim, I go to bed when he tells me, otherwise I just go to bed when I'm tired. 
 It's pretty noisy at night-time, specially if there's a band practising in the house. 
 I don't mind it, but it's pretty hard going to sleep with this banging going on. 
 I like having lots of people round the house &mdash; it's like school. 
 It's just at night it gets a bit noisy. 
 One night I'm in bed &mdash; just sort of lying there, thinking about stuff and that when Marie walks in and goes straight over to her door. 
 It's dark, but I know it's Marie cos she's got her jangly boots on and I can hear them. 
 &bquo;Marie?&equo; 
 I say. 
 I'm pleased to have her back so early. 
 Like I say, she don't usually come back till the morning. 
 She don't hear me, so I say it again, but she just unlocks the door and goes into her room. 
 I dunno why, but I get the feeling's summat's up &mdash; you know, a sort of scared feeling in my tummy. 
 So I get out of bed and stick some clothes on. 
 I can see the light under Marie's door, but there's no noise or nothing. 
 She usually plays music when she's home. 
 I knock on her door, but she don't say nothing, so I just push it open. 
 &bquo;Go away, Billy.&equo; 
 She's lying on her mattress with her face in the pillow. 
 she s still got her boots on, and they're a bit muddy. 
 I dunno what to do, so I just sort of stand there. 
 Satan's miaowing for food but I don't pay it no attention. 
 Summat's up with Marie &mdash; I can tell. 
 I sort of kneel down and give her a touch on the shoulder. 
 She jumps a bit, but she don't look up. 
 Her face is still stuck in the pillow. 
 &bquo;Leave me, Billy.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's wrong?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just go away.&equo; 
 She starts crying now. 
 She don't make no noise, but I know she's crying. 
 She's sort of shaking like you do when you laugh. 
 I dunno what to do. 
 I hate it when people cry, cos it makes me want to do the same thing. 
 I sort of get this lump in my throat and then my eyes start to sting. 
 I'm sort of kneeling there, so I put my hand on Marie's back to make her feel better, but she rolls away from me. 
 &bquo;Don't touch me.&equo; 
 Then I see her face. 
 I can't believe it. 
 One eye's all red and swelled up and her lip's been split. 
 It's all puffy and bloody. 
 I stare at her, then I start crying. 
 She's so beautiful, and why did this happen? 
 I can't get any words out. 
 We just look at each other &mdash; me crying and Marie just staring. 
 She looks like someone else. 
 She don't look like Marie at all. 
 I try and stop my crying, but every time I look at her it starts again. 
 I can't understand why she looks like this. 
 She's so pretty normally, but now she's all bloody and hurt. 
 &bquo;Get me a cigarette, Billy,&equo; she says. 
 Her words come out funny &mdash; sort of muffled like, cos of her lips. 
 I get up and have a look round the room, but things are blurry on account of my tears and I can't find her fags. 
 I sort of rub my face with my hands and have a proper look, but I can't find none. 
 I'm real confused. 
 &bquo;I've got one,&equo; she says. 
 Marie's sitting up on the bed with a packet of fags. 
 She looks pretty calm now. 
 She ain't crying or nothing, but her face is horrible to look at. 
 I find her some matches and try and light one, but it won't light. 
 She takes them off me. 
 &bquo;Sit over there, will you hen?&equo; she says, pointing to the chair by the fire. 
 I go and sit down. 
 I stopped crying now, but I feel a bit shaky so I look down at my feet and try to figure things out. 
 That's what I do when I get worried &mdash; I try to figure it out. 
 But I can't do it &mdash; all I can think about is Marie's face. 
 &bquo;What happened, Marie?&equo; 
 My voice goes all funny, but I keep from crying. 
 She don't say nothing &mdash; she just shakes her head. 
 Satan comes over and rubs against her hand like he does when he's hungry, but she just stares at him. 
 &bquo;Boil me some water, will you Billy?&equo; 
 I find the kettle and plug it in. 
 Marie looks calm now, but she's all tight in her body, like she's real angry and she's trying not to show it. 
 &bquo;They said they'd kill me,&equo; she whispered. 
 She shuts her eyes and sort of lets out a moan like a dog whining or summat. 
 She s still got the fag and matches in her hands, so I take them away from her. 
 Then I sort of hold her hands tight while she rocks back and forward on the bed. 
 Her moan gets louder and she opens her mouth till she's bawling like a baby. 
 It scares me a bit, but I still hold onto her hands. 
 She's rocking real hard now &mdash; her eyes shut and her mouth open, her face all bashed up. 
 I get an idea to hug her, so that's what I do, and we rock back and forward together. 
 She hangs onto me real hard like she's scared I'll let go, making this funny noise. 
 To tell the truth, it's pretty scary. 
 We hang onto each other for ages, not saying nothing. 
 My legs get all tingly after a bit on account of how I'm sitting, but I don't move. 
 I just stay there holding onto Marie. 
 I sort of give her hair a stroke and say &bquo;there, there&equo; like I seen people do with babies. 
 She stops her moaning after a bit. 
 The kettle's boiling like mad so I get up careful like and unplug it. 
 Marie's still rocking &mdash; hugging herself like some of the poorly kids at school used to. 
 She looks a bit cold, so I go and fetch the blanket off my bed and wrap it round her shoulders. 
 She don't seem to notice &mdash; she don't say thank you or nothing. 
 She just stares at the floor and rocks. 
 Her face is pretty bloody and that, so what I do is wet some paper tissues under the tap, and real careful like, I rub the blood off of her mouth and chin. 
 She sort of flinches but I dab real soft and she lets me finish. 
 Her bottom lip is fat and purple and there's a split down the middle. 
 Her eye ain't bleeding, but it's almost closed up. 
 I don't touch it cos it looks too painful. 
 Marie's face is real white and she's still sort of staring like she don't know what's going on. 
 Then she pushes the blanket off and stands up. 
 She pours the hot water into the sink. 
 &bquo;Leave me for a bit, Billy,&equo; she says with her back to me, so I go out and sit on my bed. 
 I'm pretty worried to tell the truth. 
 I ain't never seen Marie like this. 
 It ain't just her face being all bashed up and that &mdash; it's the way she didn't say nothing, but just stared at the floor. 
 Normally she's real happy. 
 Summat bad's happened to her. 
 I wait till her room's quiet, then I tap on the door and go in. 
 She's in bed now, lying on her back and staring at the ceiling. 
 I go and sit on the floor by the mattress and watch her. 
 We don't say nothing for a long time. 
 &bquo;It was horrible,&equo; she says at last. 
 She puts her hand out without looking at me, and I take hold of it. 
 &bquo;They were so&hellip; vicious.&equo; 
 She looks at me like she's asked a question and she wants me to answer. 
 Her hand's gone all limp, then she suddenly takes it away. 
 &bquo;Why, Billy? 
 Why do you hate us so much?&equo; 
 I dunno what to say. 
 I dunno what she's going on about, so I don't say nothing. 
 She's real upset about summat &mdash; I know that, but I  don't hate her. 
 I bite my lip. 
 I wish she wouldn't look at me like that &mdash; she's gone all hard and like she don't like me no more. 
 I feel her touch my hand again, but I can't look at her. 
 I feel all upset now. 
 Marie's my friend. 
 I don't hate her. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Billy. 
 Don't cry &mdash; it wasn't your fault.&equo; 
 It's like a dream. 
 Everything was OK. 
 I was lying in bed, happy, and then Marie comes home and she's all bashed up, then she says I hate her. 
 I can't look at her, so I go and fetch a tissue and wipe my nose. 
 I dunno why I'm crying. 
 It's silly to cry, specially when it ain't me who's hurt, but I can t stop. 
 I'm really unhappy. 
 I can't remember being so unhappy &mdash; not ever. 
 I go back and sit down again, and she takes a hold of my hand and squeezes it like she's saying sorry or summat. 
 I still don't understand. 
 &bquo;Why did they hit you, Marie?&equo; 
 &bquo;They're animals &mdash; that's why.&equo; 
 &bquo;But why?&equo; 
 I look at her, but she just shakes her head. 
 She lies there for a long time, not saying nothing. 
 Then she asks me to get a small bottle of pills from her drawer. 
 I find them easy enough, and give her the bottle. 
 It's a little brown bottle like the ones they used to have at school. 
 She swallows a couple of the pills and lies back down again. 
 Her hair's all over the pillow, and I want to brush it. 
 Looking at her hair, I can pretend her face ain't all hurt and that, and that everything's OK and that. 
 But she starts crying again. 
 I sort of sit by her bed till she falls asleep. 
 It's weird, but when she's asleep she looks real young, even though her face is all puffy. 
 I'm not tired no more so I just sit and watch her. 
 I still don't understand why she was all bashed up. 
 She's my friend. 
 I been to hospital once to visit someone. 
 I can't remember who, but they were pretty poorly like and all round the bed was flowers and fruit and that. 
 I remember cos it looked so nice. 
 Sitting there, I think about that for a while, then I decide to bring all my plants in and stick them round the bed. 
 I don't have no fruit, but I reckon just plants are OK without the fruit. 
 So that's what I do &mdash; I bring all my plants and the flowers Mr Frost gave me a couple of days ago. 
 It was nice of Mr Frost to do that. 
 He gave me a whole bunch of flowers for nothing. 
 I stuck them in a milk bottle cos I ain't got a proper flower vase, but they look OK like that I reckon. 
 When I finish putting them all round the bed, it looks real nice. 
 I reckon Marie'll be pretty surprised when she wakes up. 
 I hope it makes her feel better. 
 It's pretty late, but I don't go to bed. 
 What I do is sit in the chair by the fire. 
 I reckon if Marie was awake, she'd like the company &mdash; you know, so she wouldn't be afraid or nothing. 
 So I stay there just in case she wakes up. 
 Marie's pretty under the weather for the next couple of days. 
 It's not just her face and that, though it looks pretty painful still. 
 It's like she's real sad and quiet like. 
 I been spending a lot of time with her these days. 
 It's nice for me, even though she's sad. 
 She don't want to be on her own, even at night, so what I done was drag my mattress and sleeping bag into her room, and that's where I'm sleeping now &mdash; on her floor. 
 She don't sleep too well, and she gets bad dreams even though she takes pills and that to help her sleep. 
 The day after her accident we went to the swimming baths so she could have a shower. 
 We go once or twice a day now. 
 All Marie wants to do is wash. 
 I don't mind going with her. 
 I just hang round the entrance and wait for her. 
 Marie told me she'd teach me to swim one day. 
 I'd like that. 
 She don't go to work no more, and sometimes she cries for no reason. 
 I do my best to make her feel better, but still she cries and that. 
 She likes the flowers and plants in her room, so I left them there. 
 I feel real sorry for Marie. 
 It ain't nice what happened to her. 
 Sonja helps me look after Marie, but mostly it's me, cos Sonja's pretty busy in the kitchen. 
 I reckon Marie likes me being round her, and doing things for her. 
 I usually make her coffee, and if she runs out of fags or needs summat from the shops, I go for her. 
 I don't mind doing that. 
 I reckon Marie's the best friend I ever had. 
 I introduced Marie to Mr Frost, and sometimes if she wants to go out and get some fresh air, we go to the gardens. 
 I think she likes the gardens. 
 She don't help out or nothing &mdash; she just sits on the bench, or wanders round looking at things, but I think she likes it. 
 To tell the truth, there ain't much to do in the garden, but we go quite a lot anyhow. 
 Mr Frost's nearly always there, and if he is, he unlocks the gates and lets us in. 
 The weather's pretty nice these days. 
 It's still real cold, but the sky's clear and sunny. 
 I like days like that &mdash; they smell real good. 
 I just wish Marie wasn't so sad. 
 I like Marie &mdash; I really do. 
 I had a girlfriend at school &mdash; Sara, her name was. 
 She wasn't a proper girlfriend or nothing &mdash; we was just mates like. 
 But I called her my girlfriend, and it made me feel pretty good. 
 She had summat growing in her brain and she died. 
 That really upset me, that did. 
 I visited her a couple of times in the hospital, and then Mr Browne told me she died. 
 Just like that. 
 That made me real sad, cos she was my best girlfriend. 
 Sometimes I think about her, and that makes me feel all sad when I remember her, cos she's dead now. 
 I reckon Marie's my best friend now. 
 She ain't exactly my girlfriend, but we spend loads of time together, going out and that. 
 I ain't asked her if she's my girlfriend, but I think she is in a way. 
 I know she likes me cos she told me. 
 The things I like best about Marie are how she laughs and her hair. 
 She lets me brush her hair sometimes. 
 I love doing that. 
 It's long and shiny and it takes me ages to do it. 
 It's a blummin beautiful colour &mdash; all sort of black with bits of brown in it, and sometimes, in the sun, it looks sort of blue. 
 It's OK living with Marie. 
 At first I got a bit embarrassed &mdash; you know, about taking off my clothes and that, but now it's OK. 
 I go and change in the toilet and wear my mac like a dressing gown, and then hop into my sleeping bag and take it off. 
 Marie gets changed behind the wardrobe door, and anyway, I always shut my eyes when I know Marie's getting undressed. 
 Like I say, Marie don't work no more, so we have the whole day together if we want. 
 Sometimes she wants to do things on her own, but most times we do things together &mdash; you know, like going to the swimming baths or going shopping and stuff like that. 
 I really like doing things together. 
 It makes me feel all grown up, like Marie's my girlfriend and that. 
 I reckon Marie is really pretty &mdash; prettier than Sara. 
 Sara had summat wrong with her eyes, and to tell the truth, she wasn't pretty at all. 
 But she had nice hair &mdash; not so long as Marie's, but just as shiny. 
 It was sort of orangery, not black like Marie's, but it was real nice too. 
 I never brushed it or nothing like I do to Marie's. 
 They didn't like us touching the girls at school, so I wasn't allowed. 
 When I brush Marie's hair in the morning, I sometimes think about Sara. 
 I reckon if Sara's in heaven, she wouldn't mind me brushing someone else's hair. 
 There's nothing wrong with being friends &mdash; it's only when you do summat selfish it's wrong. 
 To tell the truth, I get a bit jealous of the other people who come and see Marie. 
 She ain't got a boyfriend or nothing &mdash; not a proper one, but still a lot of boys come and see her. 
 I don't think she's all that keen on them, and sometimes she kicks them all out, if it's getting late and she wants to go to bed. 
 She likes Peter, I know that. 
 I like Peter too. 
 He's pretty old, but he's real nice. 
 He was real kind to Marie after her accident. 
 He spent a long time with her, talking, and making her feel better when she was crying and that.. 
 Peter's pretty nice, but to tell the truth I like to be with Marie on my own best. 
 When she's with other people I don't always understand what they're going on about and that makes me feel stupid. 
 Still, I don't think Marie likes any of the boys much &mdash; except for Peter. 
 I can tell by the way she looks at them. 
 I know Marie likes me cos she told me. 
 I ain't sure if I'm her boyfriend or not. 
 She's better now, you know, after her accident and that. 
 Her face is all healed up, and she don't cry so much. 
 She still gets a bit funny sometimes, and won't go out at night, even if there's a party or summat. 
 That suits me, cos I like to stay in with her. 
 It's great when it's just me and her in the evening. 
 What we do is, pull the curtains shut and switch on the fire. 
 Then Marie'll put a record on, or sometimes the radio, and we just sit about chatting. 
 Marie likes to ask me about my family and that, but I don't really like talking about that much &mdash; except Annie, that is. 
 Sometimes Marie writes some stuff &mdash; poems and that, or else she reads a book. 
 She likes reading. 
 If she does that, I get on with the jigsaw. 
 Marie bought me this blummin huge jigsaw with millions of bits. 
 It's a picture of a load of boats in the water. 
 It's real difficult on account of all the sea and sky and that, but it's real fun. 
 I'm good at jigsaws &mdash; I'm twice as quick as Marie. 
 Marie read me one of her poems the other day. 
 It was called &bquo;Billy Bayswater&equo; and she said it was about me. 
 I didn't understand it all, but I thought it was real beautiful. 
 There was summat about my head in the stars and walking on clouds in it. 
 I liked that bit, I did. 
 Walking on clouds. 
 I don't see much of Fullblast now. 
 To tell the truth, I'm a bit sad about Fullblast. 
 When he heard about Marie's accident he just made a joke. 
 That upset me, that did. 
 I don't think it was right to make a joke about that. 
 I like to have a laugh and that, but there's some things you shouldn't laugh at. 
 Like when someone gets hurt. 
 Ibrahim's gone now. 
 He got in trouble last week and he's in prison. 
 It's a shame really, cos Ibrahim was OK. 
 He sold his video, and so nobody went to see him no more, except for me. 
 And then he got arrested for summat, and now he's in prison. 
 Carl from upstairs got arrested too, and he said that Ibrahim was screaming all night in the room next to him in the prison, and when they opened the door in the morning, he'd scratched all the skin off of his face. 
 I dunno why he did that, but when I heard Marie tell that, I felt really horrible. 
 I dunno why anybody would do that. 
 Now I don't suppose he'll never get to his home and see his wile again. 
 Marie's teaching me to swim. 
 I bought a pass for the swimming baths so I can get in for free. 
 I had to take my picture in one of them photo booths. 
 That was fun, that was. 
 I took two of me and two of me and Marie. 
 In the ones with both of us, we was laughing like mad. 
 They're real nice pictures &mdash; I keep them in my pocket and take them out sometimes to look at them. 
 We look real happy in them. 
 It ain't like I'm scared, but to tell the truth, swimming, s a lot harder than I thought. 
 I don't mind getting wet and that &mdash; I don't even mind my head going under water. 
 That's UK, except when I get water up my nose. 
 It's the floating bit that's difficult. 
 I can do it OK if I hang onto the side, but when I let go I just sink. 
 Marie's real patient though, and she tries again and again. 
 It's pretty good fun, but it'd be better if I could float. 
 Marie says I got to relax more. 
 I said I'll try. 
 Marie's a brilliant swimmer. 
 I like watching her going up and down the baths. 
 I usually stand at the shallow end after she's finished teaching me the floating bit, and watch her have her swim. 
 She ain't so quick as some of the others, but she's real good at swimming. 
 She don't hardly splash at all. 
 She's like one of them underwater swimmers I seen on telly &mdash; you know, all slow and graceful like. 
 The first time we went, Marie wore her bra and knickers, but she was told off for that, so she bought this real nice swimming costume. 
 It's all shiny and blue, and it's real tight. 
 I try not to look, but you can see her boobies and that. 
 She looks blummin beautiful in that swimming costume. 
 We go to the baths a lot still. 
 Not every day like we used to just after her accident, but quite a lot all the same. 
 To tell the truth, my favourite bit is having a hot shower afterwards. 
 But Marie likes swimming, so I don't mind going with her. 
 She says it's ages since she's done any exercise, and it's good for her. 
 She says we'll get some old bikes so we can bike to the baths instead of walking. 
 That's a good idea, I reckon. 
 I used to have a bike before I went to school. 
 That was ages ago &mdash; I hope I ain't forgot how to ride one. 
 I'm still sleeping on Marie's floor. 
 I hope she don't tell me to go back to my old room, cos I really like sleeping with Marie. 
 The best bit's when the light's out, and I can listen to her breathing, and if I want to say summat &mdash; you know, summat that happened in the day &mdash; I can just speak soft and she'll hear me. 
 I don't even mind if she's asleep and she don't answer, it's just as good listening to her breathing. 
 She's sleeping much better now, and she don't have to take pills no more. 
 I'm glad about that, cos to tell the truth, she used to get a bit strange sometimes after she took them. 
 You know, sort of clumsy and sleepy like she was drunk or summat. 
 Anyway, she's stopped taking them, so she's back to normal. 
 The other best bit about sleeping with Marie is waking up and seeing if she's awake. 
 Sometimes she is, and sometimes she ain't. 
 Like I say, she's sleeping well now, and she's often up before I even wake up. 
 But even if she's up, she ain't dressed properly &mdash; she just wears her dressing gown. 
 She don't get dressed till after she's had her cup of tea, and that's my job to make it. 
 As soon as I'm awake, I stick the kettle on and make us two cups of tea. 
 &bquo;Thank you, William,&equo; Marie says to me when I give her the tea, and I say &bquo;Is there anything else, your Highness?&equo; like we're king and queen or summat. 
 Then she gets back into bed, dressing gown and all, and I hop back into my sleeping bag and we drink our tea. 
 We never open the curtains till after breakfast and we're dressed. 
 Marie keeps cornflakes and stuff in the room, and if there's any milk we have that, or else we have some toast and jam. 
 After breakfast, I go out to the toilet and get dressed and Marie gets dressed in the room. 
 Then she'll open the curtains and look out to see what the weather's like, and then she'll say summat like &bquo;How about a walk, Billy?&equo; or &bquo;Jigsaw weather today, hen.&equo; 
 Like I said, I reckon Marie's the best friend I ever had. 
 &bquo;Billy, it's about time we did something about the way you look.&equo; 
 Marie's standing behind me and we're both looking in the mirror on the inside of the wardrobe. 
 She reaches over and brushes the hair off of my eyes. 
 &bquo;You could use a haircut.&equo; 
 She brushes my hair behind my ears and holds the top bit to one side. 
 It's ages since I had a haircut. 
 We used to have them real often at school. 
 &bquo;How about we cut the sides and front short, and leave the back long?&equo; 
 &bquo;OK,&equo; I say. 
 I don't really mind. 
 I love Marie touching me like she's doing now. 
 Her hands are real soft and warm and when she touches me, I feel all sleepy and happy. 
 To tell the truth, I couldn't care less about my hair. 
 All I want is her to carry on brushing my hair with her hands. 
 She puts her hands on my shoulders and steers me to the chair. 
 &bquo;You sit down and wrap this towel round your neck.&equo; 
 She chucks a bath towel to me. 
 &bquo;And I'll borrow Sonja's scissors.&equo; 
 I do like she says, and sit there with the damp towel round my neck and wait for her to come back. 
 It's real quiet in the morning &mdash; there ain't hardly anyone moving about the house. 
 I like it when it's quiet and it's just me and Marie. 
 It's like we're sort of living here together &mdash; you know, sort of like we're married or summat and living in a proper house of our own and all that. 
 It's good and sunny today and everything in the room s all lit up and interesting looking. 
 My plants look real healthy in the sun and the photos Marie's stuck on the wall are all shiny. 
 She's always sticking piccys on the wall &mdash; you know, things she cuts out of mags and that. 
 Marie comes back in and gives me a smile. 
 She's real happy nowadays. 
 I'm really really glad about that. 
 I hate to see someone sad. 
 &bquo;Now, sir,&equo; she says, walking round the chair and looking at me like she's a real barber. 
 &bquo;A short back and sides was it? 
 Or a mohican?&equo; 
 I laugh, but I dunno what to say so I just shrug. 
 Marie starts combing my hair. 
 There's a few knots in it and it hurts a bit when she tugs the comb, but I don't say nothing. 
 It's just great to have Marie touching me like this. 
 When she s finished combing, she puts the mirror on the table in front of me so I can see myself. 
 &bquo;Completely off the ear I think don't you?&equo; she asks, holding my hair back. 
 I turn my head sideways to see how I look with my ears showing, but I can't see proper. 
 &bquo;It makes you look quite distinguished.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean?&equo; 
 I turn the other way, but it's difficult to see in the mirror cos the corner's been broke off. 
 &bquo;Older,&equo; she says. 
 We had real fun with Marie cutting my hair. 
 She took her time, and done it real careful. 
 I couldn't really see what she was doing, but I didn't mind. 
 I trust Marie &mdash; I think she's really great. 
 When she's done, she hands me the mirror and I have a look. 
 I must admit I'm a bit shocked at first. 
 She's cut it real short, so it feels all bristly when I rub my hands over it. 
 But I reckon it looks OK. 
 It's always a shock when summat's different, but you get used to it in the end. 
 She takes the towel off me and then squats down and begins brushing bits of hair off of my face with her fingers. 
 It's real lovely to have Marie there so close to me with her brushing her fingers over my face. 
 She ain't really looking at my face, but straight into my eyes. 
 &bquo;You're a handsome devil &mdash; you know that, Billy?&equo; 
 She lifts her eyebrows at me and then stands up and goes over to the sink. 
 I give a laugh. 
 &bquo;You don't believe me?&equo; she says, turning the tap on. 
 I carry on laughing. 
 I'm laughing cos I'm so happy. 
 Marie s filling the kettle with water and Satan's sleeping on the windowsill and the house is quiet and Marie says I'm handsome. 
 I don't think I ever been so happy. 
 Marie smokes a fag while I brush up the hair and stick it in the bin. 
 I wish Marie was still cutting my hair. 
 I really liked it, the way she moved my head and brushed her fingers through my hair. 
 She's lying on the bed, blowing smoke at the ceiling. 
 The smoke sort of hangs in blue layers above the bed and I watch it for a bit. 
 Someone upstairs is playing a record &mdash; I can just make out the thumping of the drum. 
 &bquo;Let's go out, Billy,&equo; Marie says all of a sudden. 
 &bquo;Get you some clothes on.&equo; 
 She rolls off the bed and stubs the fag out. 
 Marie gets all excited when she gets a good idea &mdash; suddenly she's all full of energy and she can't sit still. 
 She's like that now &mdash; her eyes are all bright and shiny in the sun. 
 &bquo;We'll go to the charity shop and see what they've got.&equo; 
 There's a charity shop on the main road where sometimes me and Marie go. 
 She bought herself a pair of shoes there once. 
 They weren't new or nothing, but they looked OK. 
 I've forgot what they're like, but they were pretty good, I remember that. 
 It's cold outside, even with my hat pulled over my ears. 
 I tell Marie I'd like some gloves cos I lost mine, and she says we'll have a look and see if there's any good cheap ones. 
 I like going shopping with Marie, even if we don't buy nothing. 
 I just like looking in shop windows. 
 The charity shop's not really a proper shop &mdash; it ain't smart or none of that, and there's just a couple of old women sitting by an electric fire and helping out customers when they want to try on clothes and that. 
 It's pretty scruffy and it's got this funny smell &mdash; sort of dusty like. 
 But it's interesting enough. 
 There's loads of stuff &mdash; you know, bits and pieces like old clothes and teapots and books and that. 
 The first thing Marie does when she goes in is go over to the hats. 
 I knew she'd do that, cos she really likes hats. 
 She's got loads in her room. 
 &bquo;Come over here, Billy. 
 Try this on.&equo; 
 She's holding up this straw hat &mdash; a bit like the one in the picture on my wall &mdash; you know, the one with the man in the boat. 
 I take off my woolly hat and try it on. 
 It feels funny after my other hat. 
 It's all hard and cold, but Marie laughs and turns me round so she can see it from all sides. 
 &bquo;It's perfect! 
 Have a look in the mirror.&equo; 
 I go over to the long mirror and have a look. 
 I reckon it looks really great. 
 It's a bit bust on one side but I really like it. 
 It makes me look all grown up &mdash; you know, like someone in a film or summat. 
 , We'll need a jacket to go with that,&equo; Marie says. 
 She's looking through this rack of suits so I go and give her a hand. 
 There's this white blazer with these thick purple stripes, and I take it off the hanger. 
 We both look at it for a bit. 
 I ain't sure if I like it. 
 It's sort of more like a pyjama top than a blazer. 
 &bquo;I dare you, Billy.&equo; 
 I think about it for a bit. 
 &bquo;OK.&equo; 
 Marie helps me off with my coat and holds it while I slip the jacket on. 
 It's pretty big, even with my jumper underneath, but it's got this lovely silky lining and it feels really comfy. 
 Marie steps back and sort of squints at me. 
 &bquo;Hmm&hellip;&equo; 
 We both go over to the mirror and look at it. 
 &bquo;Hmm&hellip;&equo; 
 I say this time. 
 It sort of looks OK, but not quite. 
 Marie steps in front of me and rolls the sleeves up to my elbows and then turns the collar up. 
 She squints at me again and then looks round the shop for summat. 
 &bquo;Ah!&equo; she says, and then goes over to the other side of the shop. 
 I have another look at myself in the mirror. 
 It ain't too bad. 
 I push the hat back and then stick my hands in my pockets. 
 I try and keep a straight face, but I can't help grinning at myself. 
 Marie said I was a handsome devil! 
 &bquo;How about this?&equo; 
 She drapes this green scarf round my neck. 
 It's real cold against my skin and I jump a bit, but I reckon it looks really good. 
 It's nice material &mdash; all heavy and silky like. 
 It looks great with the jacket and hat. 
 &bquo;Turn round, Billy. 
 Let's have a look.&equo; 
 I do a little turn like I seen them fashion models do. 
 Marie watches me a bit then she nods her head. 
 &bquo;You look great, hen.&equo; 
 I grin at myself in the mirror. 
 I look like someone else &mdash; you know, some famous person like. 
 &bquo;Are you going to get summat, Marie?&equo; 
 I say. 
 She's looking through the dress rail. 
 &bquo;I can't really afford to, but what the hell!&equo; 
 She picks up this blue skirt and holds it against her legs and then puts it back on the rail. 
 &bquo;You're only young once, Billy boy. 
 You might as well enjoy it.&equo; 
 She takes out this dark red dress with these big white dots and goes over to the mirror. 
 She smoothes the dress out against her front and looks at it in the mirror. 
 Standing there with her back to me, she looks more beautiful than I ever seen her. 
 I get this real strong urge to stand behind her and put my arms round her and give her a hug, but I don't move. 
 I just stand there watching her with her hair falling out of her hat, holding this dress against herself. 
 &bquo;What do you think, Billy?&equo; 
 She turns round to face me. 
 It's a pretty dress I suppose, but anything would look pretty on Marie. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; she asks. 
 I can't think of nothing to say, so I just nod. 
 She looks blummin beautiful, that s all I know. 
 Marie asks one of the old women if she can use the changing room, and she shows her where it is. 
 I have a look round the shop while Marie gets changed. 
 There's a nice china dog on the side by some books, but I don't go over and have a look. 
 Normally I would, but I just don't want to move. 
 I can feel this happy feeling bubbling in my tummy. 
 When I get like that, I get my urge to shout. 
 That's all I want to do &mdash; I just want to shout and jump. 
 I make myself breathe slow. 
 I get too excited sometimes and spoil things. 
 I don't want to be sick or nothing. 
 That would make Marie disappointed. 
 I look over at the changing room. 
 There's a curtain across the door, but it ain't long enough so I can see Marie's feet and her black trousers all in a ball on the ground. 
 I can t wait for Marie to be finished here so we can walk down the street in our new clothes. 
 Sometimes she holds onto my arm in the street &mdash; you know, just natural, like I'm a girl and she's just a friend or summat. 
 I get real proud when she does that. 
 Marie's so pretty and lovely, I want everyone to see us, so they'll say how grown up and lucky I am to have such a lovely girlfriend. 
 Marie pulls the curtains back and steps out. 
 She's got the dress on and she's taken her hat off so her hair's all over her shoulders. 
 I can see her little gold necklace twinkling like a star round her neck. 
 The old woman from the shop asks her if it fits and Marie does a couple of turns in front of the mirror. 
 &bquo;Pretty well.&equo; 
 She stops turning so she's facing me. 
 &bquo;D'you like it?&equo; 
 I look at the dress. 
 It's got these tight sleeves that look too short and the bottom bit is all bunched up so when she turns it all billows out. 
 The waist is real narrow &mdash; there's a little belt there that Marie tied up. 
 Her neck and shoulders are bare and cold looking. 
 It's a beautiful dress. 
 She looks so pretty. 
 &bquo;I think it's great.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not too loud?, 
 She sees I don't understand. 
 &bquo;Bright,&equo; she says. 
 I shake my head. 
 &bquo;I'll take it,&equo; she says to the old woman. 
 &bquo;And what Billy's wearing too.&equo; 
 I want to keep my new clothes on, so the old woman gives me a big paper carrier bag to put my mac and woolly hat in. 
 Marie sticks her jeans in too &mdash; she's going to wear the dress under her coat. 
 Marie pays the woman and we go out. 
 Marie's in a real good mood &mdash; she likes buying things. 
 She grabs a hold of my arm and skips along beside me. 
 She keeps poking me in the side with every step. 
 &bquo;Come on &mdash; skip!&equo; 
 I try doing it, but I get sort of tangled up. 
 &bquo;You're hopping. 
 Skip. 
 Like this.&equo; 
 She skips on ahead of me, and then turns round. 
 &bquo;See?&equo; 
 I try it. 
 It's blummin difficult. 
 I nearly get it right, but I end up hopping again. 
 We both laugh and Marie takes hold of my arm again. 
 &bquo;Let's forget that,&equo; she says. 
 We take our time on the way back, stopping to look in shop windows and that. 
 I really like my new jacket and hat and scarf, and when we stop and chat with a couple of people from the house, they say how smart I look. 
 I try and catch my reflection in the shop windows we go past, just to see what me and Marie look like together. 
 I reckon we look pretty good. 
 We're walking past this telly shop when Marie suddenly stops and goes back a couple of steps. 
 &bquo;We're on TV,&equo; she says, pointing into the window. 
 There's loads of TV sets in the window and I dunno which one to look at. 
 &bquo;This one &mdash; here.&equo; 
 She waves with one hand and points with another. 
 There's a small black and white set, and I can see two people on it, with one of them waving a hand. 
 &bquo;Is it us?&equo; 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; she says, pointing at a camera in the window. 
 &bquo;We're being filmed. 
 Wave your hand and watch the screen.&equo; 
 I do like she says. 
 It's really weird seeing yourself on telly. 
 It ain't like looking in a mirror cos I ain't looking straight at myself, but sort of down from above. 
 &bquo;I always fancied being on TV,&equo; Marie says, giving a bow. 
 &bquo;Marie, Queen of Scots &mdash; prima ballerina.&equo; 
 She starts humming and doing these dance steps. 
 I move to one side so it's just Marie on the telly, and watch her. 
 It's like watching a proper programme. 
 It ain't really like ballet, but it looks sort of real &mdash; you know, like Candid Camera or summat. 
 She finishes her dance and I clap. 
 Then she grabs my hat and sticks it on her head. 
 &bquo;I say, I say, I say,&equo; she says in this funny voice. 
 She's going to tell a joke, and I start laughing already. 
 &bquo;Did you hear about the Irishman who took his car in for a service? 
 He couldnae fit it through the church doors!&equo; 
 She takes the hat off and does a couple of dance steps. 
 I'm laughing like crazy now. 
 &bquo;What's yellow and dangerous?&equo; she asks. 
 &bquo;I dunno!&equo; 
 I yell, looking at the telly screen. 
 &bquo;Shark infested custard! 
 How do you fit four elephants into a Mini?&equo; 
 &bquo;I dunno!&equo; 
 &bquo;Two in the front and two in the back!&equo; 
 She does a little dance, making a noise like a trombone, then she bows and the hat falls off. 
 I give her a clap and turn round. 
 She's grinning at me, her eyes all sparkly. 
 &bquo;Your turn, Billy.&equo; 
 She hands me the hat and moves me into the middle of the pavement. 
 &bquo;Ladies and gentlemen, boys and girls,&equo; I start. 
 Marie's got her back to me, watching the telly. 
 &bquo;Mr Billy Bayswater will now sing you a song. 
 The name of it is &mdash; &bquo;Old MacDonald had a farm&equo;.&equo; 
 Marie gives a little cheer, and I clear my throat. 
 &bquo;Old MacDonald had a farm &mdash; ee-aye-ee-aye-oh. 
 And on that farm he had a &mdash;&equo; 
 I can't think what animal to do. 
 &bquo;Duck,&equo; Marie says. 
 &bquo;With a&mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Quack, quack here,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;And a quack, quack there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Here a quack.&equo; 
 &bquo;There a quack.&equo; 
 &bquo;Everywhere a quack, quack.&equo; 
 We're falling about laughing. 
 I'm trying to flap my arms like a duck and quack at the same time. 
 These couple of kids are watching us like we're mad, but we just carry on. 
 &bquo;Old MacDonald had a farm &mdash; ee-aye-ee-aye-oh.&equo; 
 We go through the whole song with both of us making the noises and me doing the actions. 
 The funniest one was the horse. 
 We was laughing so much we couldn't get no sound out. 
 And when I pretended to be a horse I got so excited I bumped into this litter bin and fell over. 
 When we finish we're hanging onto each other. 
 We've been laughing so much we're weak. 
 Marie's eyes are all wet and she can't stop giggling. 
 She tries to keep a straight face, but she keeps cracking up. 
 &bquo;Home we go, hen. 
 I can't take any more of this.&equo; 
 We take each other's hand and start walking. 
 We don't say nothing on the way back, but sometimes we just burst out laughing for no reason at all. 
 Sometimes Marie gets letters. 
 You know, from friends and that. 
 When she gets one she usually reads it out to me. 
 Marie used to live in Scotland and sometimes her friends write to her. 
 I like it when Marie gets a letter, cos I never get one &mdash; except my giro cheque. 
 I wish I had a friend who'd write to me. 
 It must be nice to get letters and that. 
 One morning, Marie gets this letter and she sort of reads it quick. 
 Just to herself &mdash; you know, not out loud like she normally does. 
 I ask her if it's from Betty, her best friend in Scotland, but she says it ain't. 
 She looks pretty shook up from the letter. 
 &bquo;Who's it from then, Marie?&equo; 
 I ask her. 
 She hesitates a bit, like she don't want to say. 
 Then she stuffs the letter back in the envelope and chucks it on the side. 
 &bquo;From my husband,&equo; she says. 
 For a minute I'm pretty confused. 
 I never knew Marie had a husband. 
 I thought she was single, like. 
 &bquo;We bust up a while back,&equo; she says. 
 It's pretty sunny and there's a patch of white light on the floor by my foot. 
 I sort of dabble my foot in it like it's a puddle. 
 I never knew Marie was married. 
 Maybe she told me and I forgot. 
 The puddle suddenly disappears and I look over at Marie. 
 She's frowning like she's thinking real hard. 
 &bquo;I never knew you was married,&equo; I say. 
 She sighs and picks up the envelope again. 
 &bquo;It wasn't much of a marriage. 
 We fought like hell for most of the time. 
 That's why I left &mdash; he kept beating me up.&equo; 
 I remember Marie's face when it was all bashed up. 
 Maybe her husband did that. 
 &bquo;Does he live in Scotland?&equo; 
 She nods and pulls the letter out again. 
 I watch her face when she reads through it. 
 It's hard to believe Marie's got a husband. 
 I suppose she's old enough and that, but it's still hard to believe. 
 I always thought she was single. 
 Even though she tries to hide it, I can see she's pretty upset by the letter. 
 When she's finished reading it again I ask her what's the matter. 
 &bquo;Nothing,&equo; she says a bit sharp like. 
 &bquo;He's finally getting out, so now I can move back.&equo; 
 She looks at me for a bit, then she goes over to the drawer and takes out another envelope. 
 This one's got some photos in it. 
 She looks at them for a bit and then hands them over to me. 
 They're pictures of a little girl. 
 She's dressed in this furry pink thing, and she's got these little white shoes on. 
 She looks real pretty with her yellow hair. 
 In one of the pictures she's sitting on a lady's knee. 
 At first, cos I'm looking at the baby, I don't see who the lady is. 
 Then I have a closer look and see that it's Marie. 
 She looks a bit different to now. 
 Her hair's shorter in the picture and she's a bit fatter. 
 Marie comes behind me and looks over my shoulder. 
 &bquo;That's Josephine. 
 She'll be two in February.&equo; 
 I don't really hear Marie cos I'm thinking. 
 It's funny, but I sort of recognise the baby. 
 She reminds me of someone I seen &mdash; someone I knew really well. 
 I think about it real hard, but I can't remember who it is. 
 It's a bit annoying like, cos I can't remember, so I give Marie back the pictures. 
 &bquo;She's in care,&equo; she says, looking at the photos again. 
 &bquo;If I can move back to my place, they'll let me have her back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who is she?&equo; 
 I ask. 
 Maybe I've met her with Marie before and that's why I recognise her. 
 &bquo;She's my daughter, Billy.&equo; 
 I stare at Marie. 
 I don't understand. 
 She slides the photos into the envelope and then shoves them back in the drawer. 
 &bquo;I should've told you before.&equo; 
 I shut my eyes real tight to try and stop the room going round. 
 Marie's got a baby. 
 She's got a husband and a baby and I never knew. 
 I open my eyes and look down at Marie's tummy. 
 She would've been all fat there once, and a baby growing inside of her. 
 Inside of Marie. 
 I dunno if I'm happy or sad. 
 Marie's got a baby. 
 I have to sit down cos I feel all dizzy. 
 Marie pulls her boots on and says she's going out to get some fags. 
 She looks a bit worried. 
 She don't ask me if I want to go with her, but even if she did I wouldn't go. 
 I got to think about this on my own. 
 She sort of ruffles my hair and goes out. 
 After a minute I get up and go into my old room. 
 There's still a couple of beat up chairs there and I sit down in one of them. 
 I got to think about this. 
 I think real hard, but it's difficult to concentrate. 
 Marie's got a husband and a baby. 
 A husband and a baby. 
 I look over at the posters on the wall. 
 I ain't took them down cos Marie's got plenty of pictures on her walls. 
 I look at each of them. 
 They look pretty stupid now. 
 There's that one of the man and the woman in the boat smiling at each other. 
 I suppose they're married &mdash; I never thought about it before. 
 I get up and look at the picture real close to see if there's a baby in the boat, but I can't see one. 
 Suddenly I start ripping the poster off the wall, ripping it into bits. 
 I chuck them on the floor and kick at them. 
 Bloody, bloody, bloody. 
 I thought she was my girlfriend. 
 I thought she liked me. 
 When I done that I feel a bit sorry. 
 That was my favourite picture and now it's all ripped up. 
 I'm crying a bit as I try and stick the pieces together, but I can't do it so I just leave them on the floor and sit back in the chair. 
 I'm sorry I done that &mdash; it was a nice picture. 
 Life's confusing sometimes, you know. 
 Like when you think you just got things figured out, they change all of a sudden. 
 I thought Marie was my girlfriend. 
 I didn't really want to marry her or nothing, but I thought, you know, that we was friends like. 
 You know, like boyfriend and girlfriend. 
 But now she's all married and stuff. 
 I stop my crying and just sit there a bit. 
 I know people think I'm stupid, and I know they laugh at me and that. 
 Most times I don't mind, but sometimes things get pretty confusing. 
 Like this morning. 
 You know, one minute I'm thinking Marie's my girlfriend, and then all of a sudden she says she's got a husband and that. 
 Things'd be much easier if people didn't make it so complicated. 
 It's people really, that make things difficult. 
 I wish people would tell the truth. 
 Marie comes back in after a bit. 
 I rub my face quick so she don't see I've been crying. 
 She looks at the bits of paper on the floor, but she don't say nothing. 
 I wish I'd hidden the bits &mdash; I feel silly ripping it up for nothing. 
 She squats down in front of me and puts her elbows on my knees. 
 I turn away so I can't look at her, but she leans over and looks me straight in the face. 
 &bquo;What's up, Billy?&equo; 
 Her nose is all cold and wet and I want to wipe it for her, but I don't. 
 I would've yesterday, but things are different today. 
 &bquo;Come on, Billy. 
 Tell me.&equo; 
 She gives me a little smile and I feel a bit better. 
 &bquo;Are you still my friend?&equo; 
 I say, quiet like. 
 Her smile gets bigger, but she looks sort of sad. 
 &bquo;Of course I am.&equo; 
 I'm still not sure if she means it or not. 
 &bquo;But you got a husband.&equo; 
 &bquo;I had  a husband. 
 Not any more.&equo; 
 She rubs the tops of my legs like I'm cold and she's trying to warm me up. 
 Won t you forgive me for keeping it a secret?&equo; 
 A door slams along the corridor and I can hear music coming from upstairs. 
 Suddenly everything's OK. 
 I'm at home and Marie's with me, and she's still my friend. 
 &bquo;I really like you, Marie,&equo; I say. 
 Suddenly I get all laughy, cos Marie's my friend and I'm happy. 
 &bquo;And I really like you too, hen.&equo; 
 She pats my knee and stands up. 
 &bquo;Are you coming to the house meeting? 
 Remember? 
 You said you would.&equo; 
 I look up at her. 
 She's standing with her back to the window and I can see a sort of thin blue light round her body. 
 She looks real pretty standing there with her old coat on. 
 I jump to my feet and give her a hug, and she pats my back. 
 &bquo;Easy does it, Billy. 
 Don't get too excited.&equo; 
 The meeting's in the big room upstairs. 
 It's where the bands practise. 
 I can't remember what band Petra's in, but I seen them practise once. 
 They were OK, but I didn't think they was brilliant. 
 There's old mattresses up against all the walls and someone's stuck hundreds of egg boxes on the ceiling. 
 Marie says it's to keep the noise in, but I don't reckon it works too well, cos you can hear them all over the house when they practise. 
 It was pretty interesting watching Petra's band practise. 
 They don't know any songs all the way through, and they kept stopping. 
 Petra sings with them. 
 She tries real hard, but she don't really sing &mdash; she sort of shouts. 
 I here s about ten people when we come in, sitting on the floor. 
 I don't know all the people in the house yet &mdash; there's too many, and new people are always coming. 
 I sit down on the floor next to Marie and look round. 
 One of the window's been smashed and someone's stuck newspaper over the hole. 
 Dirty Dave's decorated most of the walls and mattresses. 
 He's pretty young &mdash; only about my age, and he paints a lot of the walls in the house &mdash; you know, with felt pens and spray cans and that. 
 I don't really like his drawings &mdash; it's mostly words and rude pictures. 
 To tell the truth, I find it pretty embarrassing, but nobody seems to mind. 
 He wanted to do Marie's room, but she wouldn't let him. 
 We sit around for a bit, chatting. 
 Daggy comes over and talks with me and Marie a bit. 
 She's OK, is Daggy &mdash; she's a friend of Sonja's. 
 She's an artist, but I ain't seen none of her paintings. 
 I spect she's better than Dirty Dave. 
 Suddenly someone bangs on the drum in the corner, and we all look up. 
 It's Peter. 
 &bquo;OK everybody. 
 Listen up.&equo; 
 He does a little drum roll and hits a cymbal. 
 I give a little laugh and Peter looks over at me and hits it again, harder this time. 
 I like Peter &mdash; he's a good laugh. 
 &bquo;I hereby call this meeting to order.&equo; 
 Everyone claps a little and Peter sits down on the drum stool. 
 He twirls the stick in his hand and crosses his legs. 
 &bquo;And the agenda, members of the board is&hellip; shit.&equo; 
 Someone gives a little cheer, and Peter holds up his hand. 
 &bquo;Not just any shit, but the turds laid by &mdash;&equo; He twirls the stick again and then points at someone I never seen before. 
 &bquo;Coprophile Colin.&equo; 
 There's another lot of clapping. 
 I join in, even though I ain't sure what's going on. 
 &bquo;As anyone who graces the top floor knows, Colin is turning his room into a cess pit. 
 The bog, dear members of the board, may  be a bourgeois invention, and perhaps Colin's biodegradable crap is a true anarchist statement, but some of you are finding the stink of revolution too much.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hold on, Peter,&equo; Colin says all of a sudden. 
 He's got a brown beard and he looks pretty ill. 
 Sort of dirty. 
 &bquo;Macrobiotic shit doesn't smell!&equo; 
 &bquo;But why don't you use the goddam bog?&equo; someone says. 
 They all look at Colin, waiting for him to answer. 
 He's confused for a bit. 
 &bquo;But what's wrong with crapping on newspaper and emptying it out every now and then? 
 It doesn't stink.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bullshit man!&equo; 
 A black boy shouts. 
 &bquo;I have to live next to you and it stinks like fuck!&equo; 
 He shouts this pretty loud. 
 I don't like it when people shout. 
 It scares me a bit to tell the truth. 
 It gets pretty confusing after this. 
 Everyone starts talking at once &mdash; some of them shouting and others just laughing. 
 Colin's getting pretty flustered and red in the face. 
 Marie don't say nothing and nor does Peter. 
 I look over at him while everyone's arguing and he smiles and winks at me like he's really enjoying himself. 
 I don't really know what's going on, but everyone's arguing about summat. 
 They carry on arguing for a bit, then Peter hits the cymbal again. 
 Everyone shuts up. 
 &bquo;Let's find out what Billy thinks about this,&equo; Peter says. 
 Someone laughs, but I can see from Peter's face that he ain't making a joke. 
 I dunno what to say and I look down at my feet. 
 To tell the truth, I wasn't really listening to what everyone was saying. 
 &bquo;Should Colin use the bog like everyone else?&equo; 
 Peter says. 
 I think about it for a bit. 
 Satan don't use the toilet neither. 
 He goes on a newspaper in Marie's room. 
 It stinks a bit, but I reckon it's OK for a cat to do that, cos a cat's an animal. 
 But I dunno why Colin don't use the toilet. 
 It's all pretty confusing cos Colin ain't a cat or nothing, so why don't he use the toilet? 
 I don't really know what to say, so I just look at Marie. 
 Everyone's quiet, waiting for me to say summat. 
 Marie nods at me and smiles. 
 I wish Peter wouldn't ask me difficult questions. 
 I don't like talking about toilets and stuff &mdash; it's dirty. 
 &bquo;Why are you so interested in &mdash;&equo; I stop and go red a bit. 
 &bquo;In what, Billy?&equo; 
 &bquo;In&hellip; dirty.&equo; 
 Everyone laughs and I think I said the wrong thing, but Peter smiles at me and stands up. 
 &bquo;Meeting over,&equo; he calls out. 
 &bquo;The zen patriarch has spoken.&equo; 
 After the meeting, me and Marie go to Peter's room. 
 I been there before. 
 I really like it &mdash; it's got these carpets over the walls and lots of interesting stuff like a museum or summat. 
 It's real cosy, specially if he's got the fire on. 
 He's got loads of interesting things like wooden masks and a big metal pipe for smoking and a little brass bell. 
 He lets me look at them when I come to see him. 
 He's nice like that, is Peter &mdash; you know, he don't wait for me to ask &mdash; he just says &bquo;Make yourself at home, Billy&equo; or &bquo;Have a look at this,&equo; or &bquo;Guess where I got this?&equo; 
 My favourite is his glass ball. 
 It's like a big marble &mdash; real heavy, like &mdash; and when you look through it everything goes upside down. 
 I like looking through it. 
 It's a bit like at the swimming baths when you open your eyes under water. 
 If you hold it in your hands it gets warm. 
 I like that bit of it. 
 I get on and look through Peter's stuff while Marie talks to him. 
 I don't pay them too much attention cos I'm busy, but I think Marie shows him the letter she got this morning. 
 Peter's got this long arrow in his room. 
 It's wood with a teeny metal bit at the end and red feathers. 
 He told me the story about where he got it &mdash; it was real interesting, and a true story &mdash; not a made-up one. 
 I've forgot the story, but it was real interesting. 
 I ask him if he'll tell me the story again, but he just looks over at me and shakes his head. 
 They're looking pretty serious, Marie and Peter. 
 I spect it's summat to do with the letter. 
 I try and remember what the letter was about, but I've forgot. 
 Summat about her husband. 
 And a baby. 
 I don t like it when grown-ups get all serious and that. 
 Often bad things happen after &mdash; you know, like you're taken away to school, or they tell you someone died or summat like that. 
 I sort of get that feeling now &mdash; you know, like summat bad's going to happen. 
 &bquo;Come and sit down here, Billy,&equo; Peter says, patting the sofa he's sitting on. 
 I got the glass ball in one hand and the arrow in the other. 
 I can't remember where they go, but Peter tells me to bring them too, so I go and sit on the sofa next to him. 
 When I get older I'm going to have gold teeth like Peter &mdash; I reckon they look real good. 
 I roll the glass ball round in my hand a bit, waiting for them to say summat. 
 It looks like they're going to say summat bad on account of how serious they're looking. 
 Sometimes I wish bad things wouldn't happen. 
 &bquo;Where's your family, Billy? 
 Your mum and dad?&equo; 
 Peter asks all of a sudden. 
 I carry on rolling the ball. 
 I can see colours inside of it. 
 He asks the question again, but I don't say nothing. 
 The glass ball's pretty warm now and I press it to my cheek and sort of roll it against my skin. 
 &bquo;Have you got any family, Billy? 
 Can you remember them?&equo; 
 I start hitting the arrow on the side of my leg, making this whacking sound like Mrs Seaton beating the rugs on the washing line. 
 Whack, whack, whack, she used to go and clouds of dust would fly all about. 
 It used to make me and Annie sneeze if we got too close. 
 &bquo;Come on,&equo; Marie says like she's playing a game. 
 &bquo;Won't you tell us?&equo; 
 I go on whacking the side of my leg. 
 Mrs Seaton's husband died so she didn't have no money &mdash; that's why she worked for us. 
 I like Mrs Seaton. 
 She's fat and she used to cuddle me and Annie. 
 She smells nice too &mdash; like flowers and soap. 
 And when she whacked the rugs me and Annie used to sneeze on account of the dust. 
 Peter takes the arrow away from me. 
 &bquo;You'll hurt yourself,&equo; he says, slipping it under the sofa. 
 Marie and Peter are watching me with a sort of worried look on their face. 
 I wonder if I'm going to have a fit, and that's why they're watching me. 
 I hope I won't have a fit. 
 I don't understand why they're talking about Mrs Seaton. 
 &bquo;I miss her, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mrs Seaton.&equo; 
 It's getting pretty dark. 
 I can hardly see the things on the table in the corner. 
 &bquo;Who's Mrs Seaton?&equo; 
 Peter asks. 
 That surprises me when he says that, cos I thought he knew who Mrs Seaton was. 
 &bquo;She looks after me and Annie,&equo; I tell him. 
 I want to get summat else to play with and I try and get up, but Peter holds me by the arm. 
 &bquo;Just a sec, Billy. 
 Who's Annie?&equo; 
 &bquo;I seen a photo of her,&equo; I say. 
 &bquo;She's wearing this pink thing, and she's got these white shoes.&equo; 
 I hear Marie go &bquo;Ah&equo;, and Peter looks at her quick. 
 &bquo;Annie's your sister, isn't she. 
 You told me about her once didn't you, Billy,&equo; Marie says. 
 I nod. 
 &bquo;About how you used to play together.&equo; 
 I shut my eyes and sort of squeeze my legs to my chest. 
 I really like Annie. 
 She's my best best friend. 
 &bquo;How old is she, Billy?&equo; 
 I open my eyes and think about it for a bit. 
 &bquo;This high,&equo; I say, holding my hand out. 
 &bquo;But she grows real quick.&equo; 
 &bquo;So, when did you last see her?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ages ago.&equo; 
 I really miss Annie, now I think about her. 
 We used to play together real well &mdash; that's what Mrs Seaton said. 
 I used to help her with things &mdash; you know, things that little kids can't do too well, like cutting up their food and opening doors and stuff like that. 
 And she used to make up these stories and tell them to me. 
 Real good stories too, just like they was from a book. 
 Annie was real clever &mdash; even though she was only a little kid, like. 
 I wish I could see Annie again, but they took me away, and they wouldn't let me see her again. 
 &bquo;Where do Annie and Mrs Seaton live, Billy? 
 Can you remember?&equo; 
 I wish they'd stop asking all these questions &mdash; I'm getting a bit confused. 
 And I wish they wouldn't ask about Mum and Dad and Annie and Mrs Seaton. 
 It makes me all upset when I think about them. 
 I don't want them to ask me any more questions, so what I do is I lie back in the sofa and shut my eyes like I'm asleep. 
 I feel real tired all of a sudden. 
 I can hear Marie and Peter talking soft, but I don't listen to them. 
 I don't want to talk no more. 
 When I open my eyes again it's nearly dark. 
 I can see two orange spots of light where Marie and Peter are smoking fags. 
 They ain't talking no more. 
 Marie turns to look at me, and I can just see the light shining off her eyes. 
 &bquo;What about some crumpets for tea?&equo; she says. 
 It's getting nearly Christmas now. 
 I dunno how long we got to wait, but it's pretty soon. 
 The shop round the corner's selling these Christmas trees. 
 They ain't got no lights on or nothing like that, but they're real nice all the same. 
 If you stick your hand in them it's all prickly cos they got these tiny little leaf things and they prick. 
 The best thing about them is their smell. 
 They smell real good, I reckon. 
 I want to buy a Christmas tree and decorate it like we used to at school but Marie says we ain't got enough money. 
 That's a shame, that is, cos I really like Christmas trees. 
 They're all Christmassy and that. 
 I bought some Christmas cards all on my own. 
 I went into this shop and got a little box of them. 
 I wasn't with Marie or nothing &mdash; I was all on my own, like. 
 I was pretty pleased with myself. 
 They're real nice cards &mdash; there's some that got pictures of a blue sky with a big white star and some men on a camel and that. 
 And there's some of baby Jesus in his bed with all these cows and sheep and stuff looking at him all gentle like. 
 Baby Jesus was real poor, so he had to grow up on a farm and that, and when he got bigger he went round with some friends telling everyone about God, and then he died. 
 Mr Browne said Jesus died cos we're all bad, but I dunno about that. 
 I reckon he died cos he wanted to go back to his home in Heaven and be with God. 
 You see, it wasn't his real home here &mdash; his real home was up in Heaven with God and the angels. 
 He was only visiting earth like, so he could tell people about God and that. 
 I don't blame Jesus for wanting to go home. 
 Jesus was good though. 
 I like him a lot. 
 He went round with some seeds, planting them in the ground and that, but some of them grew and some of them didn't. 
 It's always that way &mdash; I dunno why, but it is. 
 You can try real hard, but it don't make no difference &mdash; sometimes a plant won't grow no matter what you do. 
 Anyway, they're real nice cards. 
 I wish I had someone to send them to. 
 The electric shop down the road's got these fairy lights in the window. 
 You know, for Christmas, like. 
 They leave them on all night, even when the shop's shut. 
 It's real great to watch them cos they blink on and off all the time. 
 They're all round the window. 
 They don't half look pretty. 
 When I go out to the shops &mdash; you know, to get stuff like milk or fags for Marie or summat &mdash; I always stop a bit and watch them. 
 I wish it was Christmas all the time. 
 It's nice when people put fairy lights in shop windows and stuff. 
 They should do it all the time I reckon. 
 Marie says there's a street in town that's all lit up with Christmas lights &mdash; you know, all across the street and that. 
 She says she might take me to see them. 
 I'd really like that, I would &mdash; I really like Christmassy things. 
 I dunno, but there's summat up with Marie. 
 She's been a bit funny these last couple of days, like summat's bothering her or summat. 
 I dunno what's up, but I reckon summat is. 
 And then I find out. 
 We're walking back from the shops &mdash; me and Marie &mdash; and we stop for a bit to look at the lights in the electric shop. 
 She's pretty patient, Marie is. 
 I know she ain't really interested in shop windows and that, but she don't mind waiting while I have a look. 
 It's getting dark, so the lights look extra pretty, flashing on and off. 
 It's pretty good cos when the lights go off I can see me and Marie in the window like it's a mirror &mdash; and then when the lights come on, we disappear. 
 There's summat about these lights that remind me of Annie &mdash; I dunno what it is. 
 Maybe we had some lights like it once. 
 I reckon that's it, cos they look sort of familiar. 
 I'm watching the lights and that, and then suddenly Marie says summat. 
 &bquo;I've got to go away, Billy,&equo; she says. 
 I don't want to turn round cos the lights are on at the moment. 
 &bquo;Where to?&equo; 
 I say, still looking at the window. 
 &bquo;Scotland. 
 I'm moving back in with my baby.&equo; 
 I keep forgetting Marie's got a baby. 
 It's still pretty odd when I remember &mdash; you know, that Marie's a mum and that. 
 The lights are off for a bit, so I turn round to look at her. 
 &bquo;Is Scotland a long way?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 A long, long way.&equo; 
 I've had enough of the lights, so we turn round and head back to the house. 
 Raven passes by on the other side of the street, but he don't notice us. 
 &bquo;When are you coming back, Marie?&equo; 
 &bquo;I won't be coming back.&equo; 
 We carry on walking a bit. 
 It's blummin freezing and the pavements are a bit slippy so we have to walk careful like. 
 &bquo;Will I go with you?&equo; 
 I ask. 
 She stops and looks at me. 
 She looks pretty sad, like she's got some bad news. 
 I reckon I know what's coming. 
 &bquo;I can't look after you any more, Billy.&equo; 
 I scrunch up my face to stop myself from crying. 
 I get this sort of aching feeling in my nose, and I give it a rub. 
 I knew summat bad was coming. 
 I knew Marie was going to say summat. 
 &bquo;Who'll look after me?&equo; 
 I ask after a bit. 
 &bquo;I'm going to get in touch with your social worker. 
 What's his name?&equo; 
 A cat nips across the pavement in front of us and slides through a gap in the fence. 
 I try and see where it went, but it's too dark. 
 &bquo;Mr Jackson,&equo; I say. 
 I can't look at Marie. 
 I'd cry if I did, so I look down at my feet. 
 I don't want to be looked after by Mr Jackson. 
 I don't want Marie to go away. 
 The street lamps are on, making the pavements all fuzzy and silvery like fish. 
 You got to be careful when the pavements are frosty cos you can slip and hurt yourself. 
 Why isn't Marie going to stay here? &mdash; it's OK here. 
 She's got Satan and a nice room and her record player and all that. 
 Why's she got to go away? 
 It ain't far back to the house, but it takes ages cos we got to walk slow. 
 I got this sort of tight feeling in my throat all the way back &mdash; you know, like I'm going to cry. 
 I don't want to cry, and I sort of hold myself in when we walk back, but I don't half feel sad. 
 We don't say nothing &mdash; we just walk. 
 When we get back to the house, Marie gives me the key to the door and I unlock it and let her go in first. 
 There's someone's motorbike in the hall, and we got to squeeze past it. 
 I been trying to think all the way back, but I can't figure it out. 
 It's all so sudden like, Marie going away and that. 
 She switches the light on in her room, and I go in and sit straight down on the chair. 
 I don't take off my coat or nothing &mdash; I just sit down. 
 I feel really miserable to tell the truth. 
 I was OK till Marie told me she was going away, and now I feel all sad. 
 Marie looks at me like she's waiting for me to say something. 
 &bquo;I don't want Mr Jackson to look after me. 
 I want you to.&equo; 
 Marie squints like she's hurt herself and squats down by the chair. 
 She's still got her hat on, and her hair is all tucked up inside. 
 &bquo;Can't you understand, Billy? 
 I've got my own life to lead.&equo; 
 I start crying now. 
 I try not to, but I just can't stop. 
 &bquo;I don't want you to go.&equo; 
 Marie leans forward and sort of hugs me. 
 I'm crying like mad now &mdash; I just can't stop. 
 Marie strokes the back of my head, but it just makes it worse. 
 I don't understand why she's got to go. 
 Everything's great here. 
 She's my friend. 
 She can't go and leave me. 
 Why do people always leave you? 
 As soon as you get to really like someone, they go off and leave you. 
 Like Sara at school who died. 
 Sometimes I think God is pretty cruel. 
 All I want is some friends, but as soon as I get some real good friends they go off and leave me. 
 It ain't fair I reckon. 
 It just ain't fair. 
 On Marie's last night, we had a sort of party in her room. 
 Marie's got loads of friends, and they all came to say goodbye. 
 We had a pretty good time I suppose, but to tell the truth I didn't feel like a party much. 
 I'm going to miss Marie. 
 She's my best friend. 
 Marie left this morning. 
 I gave her a hand packing up her clothes and stuff. 
 She's only got two suitcases, so she had to leave a lot of stuff behind &mdash; like her tailor's dummy and all the furniture. 
 She sold her record player to Eric from the top floor. 
 She said I could keep any of the stuff she left behind, or sell it if I wanted, but I dunno about that. 
 She couldn't take Satan with her, so she asked me to look after him. 
 She told me how much food to give him every day, and to be sure to leave the window open a bit so he could get into the garden and do his business. 
 I don't mind looking after Satan &mdash; it's a bit of company. 
 Marie took a taxi to the station on account of her bags being so heavy. 
 I wanted to go with her to the train, but she told me to stay at home otherwise I'd get lost on the way back. 
 It was real sad saying goodbye to Marie. 
 I think she was sad too, cos her eyes watered like she was going to cry. 
 I really didn't want her to go, but she had to. 
 I helped her put her bags into the taxi and then we sort of kissed goodbye. 
 I was brave and didn't cry or nothing, but I was real sorry to see her go. 
 She was the best friend I ever had. 
 Marie said I could stay in her room, and she left a lot of stuff so it'd be comfy, but to tell the truth I feel real sad in there on my own. 
 It looks all lonely like with Marie's bits and pieces gone. 
 She took the material off of the wall, and all her shoes and make up and just about everything cept the big stuff. 
 She said I could stay in her room, but I ain't going to. 
 Marie's gone and left me. 
 I dunno why, but she did &mdash; just like Annie and Sara. 
 And now it's just me. 
 All on my own. 
 I wish Marie was still here. 
 I want to sleep in my old room, so what I do is take the mattress and stick it back in my old room. 
 Marie's left me her sleeping bag and all the blankets so I'm OK for sleeping and that. 
 She also left her electric fire, so I take that in too. 
 I stick the fire on in my room and warm myself by it for a bit. 
 It's flipping cold today, so I'm real glad I got an electric fire. 
 I got to be careful about remembering to switch it off. 
 It's dangerous if you leave it on all night &mdash; you can start a fire and that if you ain't careful. 
 It ain't too bad &mdash; you know, with the sleeping bag and the electric fire and that, but I still feel miserable. 
 If Marie was here then I'd be OK, but she ain't. 
 She's gone to Scotland to look after her baby. 
 She's got a little girl, Marie has. 
 I know cos she showed me a picture once. 
 I wish she didn't have to go. 
 I dunno what to do. 
 Normally, Marie and me'd get a cup of coffee and then sit by the fire and chat. 
 She'd have a fag with her coffee, and I'd sit and watch the smoke making patterns in the air, and it'd be quiet and it'd be just her and me. 
 I go back into her room and have a look around. 
 It's funny in here with everything all different. 
 Marie's gone to Scotland to look after her baby, so everything's going to be all different and Mr Jackson's going to look after me. 
 I think about making some coffee, but I don't bother in the end &mdash; it ain't worth it just for me. 
 Marie's left most of her pictures on the wall, and I have a look at them. 
 She was always cutting pictures out of magazines and sticking them on her wall. 
 There's a photo of a cat sitting on a chair, licking its paws. 
 I stuck that one on the wall. 
 I liked that picture so Marie let me cut it out and stick it on the wall. 
 I try to take it off so I can keep it, but the paper tears. 
 I stick the bits in my pocket anyway. 
 It's a nice picture &mdash; it'd be a shame to just chuck it away. 
 Marie's left a load of mags behind, so I pick one up and have a flick through it. 
 When I open it, a load of bits of paper fall out and flutter to the ground. 
 I don't bother to pick them up. 
 No one lives here no more, so it don't matter. 
 I try and stop myself, but I just start crying. 
 I know it ain't grown up and that but I can't stop myself. 
 I feel so sad with Marie gone. 
 I wish she hadn't gone away. 
 I go back to my room and lie on the bed. 
 I end up staying there for ages, thinking about Marie and that. 
 She said she'll send me a letter, but I reckon it's too early to go and have a look. 
 I'll ask Sonja tomorrow to see if there's a letter for me. 
 It's nice that she's going to send me a letter. 
 That makes me feel a bit better, but I still dunno when I'm going to see her again. 
 She's a long way away. 
 I didn't get up all day till it got dark and Mr Jackson came. 
 He wasn't very pleased with me, and told me off for not saying where I'd moved to. 
 He said I can't go on living here, not on my own like. 
 He's going to try and get me into Combe Court. 
 I don't want to go to Combe Court. 
 It smells. 
 Mr Jackson stayed quite a bit. 
 He wanted to know how I'd been getting on, and who'd been helping me out. 
 I told him all about Marie and showed him the pictures we took in that photo booth. 
 He wasn't very interested in Marie. 
 He just sort of glanced at the photos and then carried on talking. 
 Mr Jackson's always busy. 
 He told me he'd come back tomorrow, and then he went off. 
 He asked me if I'd had anything to eat today. 
 I said yes, cos I thought I had, but to tell the truth, I ain't sure now. 
 I don't want to see Mr Jackson tomorrow, but I didn't tell him that. 
 I try to like Mr Jackson, but to tell the truth, he ain't all that friendly. 
 He pretends to be, but he ain't really I reckon. 
 When Mr Jackson went I just carried on lying there. 
 It got dark pretty soon after, but I didn't bother to move. 
 I just stayed there listening to people moving around upstairs. 
 I spend a long time thinking about Marie and some of the things we done together. 
 Like swimming and shopping and that. 
 I wish Marie was here so we could talk about it. 
 When I wake up, I know summat's up when I open my eyes and see it's all bright, but it takes me a minute to remember where I am. 
 Marie's room's sort of dark in the morning on account of the curtains, but my room ain't got no curtains so it's real bright. 
 When I see I'm in my old room, I remember Marie's gone. 
 I was OK when I woke up, but when I remember Marie's gone I start feeling sad. 
 It's extra cold today and I don't want to get up. 
 Normally I'd get up and make me and Marie a cup of coffee, but there ain't no point now, so I stay in bed. 
 I got a bit of a headache on account of how cold it is and I snuggle back into my sleeping bag. 
 I listen for noises, but it's real quiet. 
 I think everyone's asleep except for me &mdash; I can't hear nothing apart from the traffic. 
 I don't want to get up. 
 Normally I would, to make the coffee and that, but there don't seem no point now. 
 Marie's gone so I ain't got no one to make coffee for. 
 I wish she was here and everything was OK again. 
 I dunno what to do. 
 I try to go to sleep again, but I ain't sleepy, and I get all fidgety. 
 I might as well get up &mdash; I could do with summat to eat, to tell the truth. 
 It's really flipping cold today, so I get dressed as quick as I can. 
 I switch on the fire and warm my hands for a bit. 
 I got to remember to be careful with the fire. 
 Marie told me to be sure to switch it off when I ain't in the room, or else at night when I'm sleeping. 
 I really don't want to go to Combe Court. 
 I want to stay here with Marie and Satan and Peter and the rest of them. 
 It ain't fair. 
 Once I'm a bit warmer, I go into Marie's room and have a look for the cornflakes. 
 Marie left some food for me &mdash; some coffee and cereal and a bit of bread. 
 Normally we'd buy our meals from the downstairs kitchen, but for breakfast we had our own food so we didn't have to get up till late. 
 Anyhow, Sonja and Petra never did breakfast. 
 I always enjoyed that, having breakfast in bed. 
 Satan's miaowing, so I feed him first. 
 I think I forgot to feed him yesterday, I can't remember. 
 I got to be more grown up if I'm going to look after a pet. 
 Marie bought loads of cat food before she left, so there's plenty for him. 
 I fill up his new dish to the top and stick it on the floor. 
 He's real excited when I'm shoving the food into his dish &mdash; rubbing against my legs and miaowing like crazy. 
 I suppose he must be real hungry if I didn't feed him yesterday. 
 He gulps down the food real quick, spilling bits onto the floor. 
 I wonder if Satan misses Marie. 
 I don't suppose so &mdash; all Satan's interested in is food. 
 I get the milk carton from the window and pour it over my cornflakes. 
 At first when I tip it up nothing comes out, then it all sort of glugs into the bowl. 
 I shake it a bit and hear a rattling, so I look inside. 
 There's a lump of ice floating in the carton. 
 I try and get it out with my fingers, but I can't reach it so I pour it into another bowl and put it on the floor for Satan to drink. 
 It must be pretty cold for the milk to freeze, I reckon. 
 It wasn't even in a fridge or nothing &mdash; it was just pressed up against the window to keep it cold. 
 I sit down in the armchair and eat my cereal. 
 The milk's so cold it makes my teeth ache. 
 Normally I like breakfast, but the milk's too cold and it's making my face ache. 
 I want to leave it, but I carry on till I'm finished. 
 You got to eat all your food up cos there's children in the world who's starving. 
 Satan won't touch the milk &mdash; it must be too cold for him too. 
 When he's finished eating, he starts washing himself. 
 I really like that about cats &mdash; the way they keep themselves clean. 
 He finishes after a bit and then jumps up on the window ledge. 
 The window's shut and he turns round and looks at me. 
 &bquo;You want to go out, Satan boy?&equo; 
 I say. 
 He don't understand me of course, but he miaows like he's saying yes. 
 I'm glad I got Satan &mdash; it's someone to talk to. 
 We weren't allowed to keep pets at school. 
 Mr Browne had a gerbil in a cage in the classroom, but we weren't allowed to take it to the dorms &mdash; it had to stay in the classroom. 
 That's one reason I don't want Mr Jackson to send me to Combe Court &mdash; they wouldn't let me keep Satan. 
 I get up and open the window, then I see Satan's done a job on the floor by the chair. 
 Marie would be mad if she saw that, so I rip a page from one of her mags and scrape it up. 
 &bquo;Naughty Satan,&equo; I say, looking cross at him. 
 &bquo;You shouldn't've done that.&equo; 
 It's my fault really, cos the window should've been open. 
 I got to remember things like that. 
 I let Satan out and chuck the paper in a drawer. 
 If Mr Jackson sees me all grown up, then maybe he'll let me stay here. 
 I rinse the bowl in the sink. 
 The water's real cold, but I wash my face anyhow. 
 I got to look after myself. 
 I got a toothbrush somewhere but I can't find it now everything's changed. 
 It used to be in the blue mug, but Marie took that. 
 I don't spect she's took my toothbrush &mdash; she probably put it somewhere. 
 I look round the room, but I can't find it. 
 So, what I do is, I just sort of rub my teeth with my fingers. 
 I use toothpaste and that, so I suppose it works OK. 
 Then I remember it's the next day and there'll be a letter from Marie. 
 For a second I get so excited, I have to calm myself down. 
 I'd forgot! 
 I rush out into the hall, down to the front door. 
 The postman's been &mdash; there's some letters on the side. 
 I pick them up and look at the envelopes. 
 I look for one starting with a &bquo;B&equo; cos I know what that looks like. 
 It takes me quite a while to go through them cos I check every one careful like. 
 A couple of them's got &bquo;B's in them and I try and work out which one's for me, but it's too hard. 
 Some of them are typed and some are written &mdash; you know, by hand like. 
 I dunno if Marie's got a typewriter &mdash; she never told me. 
 I feel each letter to see if I can guess which one's mine. 
 There's a fat one. 
 I hope it's that one. 
 I hope it's a good long letter. 
 And maybe photos too &mdash; that'd be great. 
 I get a bit flustered with all the letters, so what I do is, I take them all and go to Sonja's room. 
 I bang on the door, but no one answers, so I push it open and go in. 
 Sonja's still in bed asleep. 
 I tiptoe over to her bed and give her a nudge. 
 I have to shake her quite hard before she wakes up. 
 Sonja looks real different without all her make up. 
 She looks sort of young looking. 
 She grumbles a bit about me waking her up, but I don't think she minds all that much. 
 She's pretty kind. 
 I give her the letters and ask her which one's for me, and she looks through them quick. 
 &bquo;There is no letter for you, Billy,&equo; she says, handing them back and shutting her eyes. 
 I think she's pulling my leg, so I ask her again. 
 &bquo;There's nothing,&equo; she says. 
 I want her to check through them again. 
 She must've made a mistake &mdash; Marie said she'd write to me. 
 Sonja sighs and looks through them again. 
 &bquo;She only went yesterday, Billy. 
 It's too early for a letter.&equo; 
 She shuts her eyes again and rolls over. 
 I look at the back of her head for a minute. 
 Marie said she'd write to me. 
 She said so. 
 I want to ask Sonja if she thinks the postman lost it, but I stop myself. 
 I'll ask her later. 
 I go back downstairs and put the letters back. 
 I'm real disappointed about that. 
 I don't understand. 
 Marie said she'd write to me. 
 Summat must've happened. 
 I go back into Marie's room. 
 I feel better with some of her stuff around me. 
 I'm real disappointed about the letter. 
 Marie's left her hairbrush. 
 I don't think she meant to &mdash; I spect she forgot, cos it's a good brush and she used to use it all the time. 
 I pick it up and brush it over my hand. 
 I'm glad she forgot her hairbrush &mdash; it really reminds me of her. 
 It's like she's still here &mdash; you know, having her hairbrush and that. 
 There's some of her hairs in it, all long and black. 
 I take a couple out and wind them round my finger. 
 I really liked Marie's hair &mdash; it was real beautiful. 
 I pretend Marie's in front of me and I'm brushing her hair like I used to. 
 &bquo;Well, Marie,&equo; I say, pretending that she's sat there listening to me. 
 &bquo;What are we going to do today?&equo; 
 I carry on brushing and act like she's talking back to me. 
 We'll go to the park to see Mr Frost, she says. 
 I nod and smile and just carry on brushing. 
 She's sitting down with her back to me, just like she always used to, and I'm brushing slow and gentle, making her hair nice and neat. 
 Then I do summat I ain't never done before. 
 I put the brush on the side and carry on smoothing her hair with just my hands. 
 I stop a bit and hold her head in my hands. 
 Then I imagine she turns round and I lean over and kiss her on the mouth. 
 I shut my eyes and hold my lace to hers for a long time. 
 I can smell Marie &mdash; the way her hair used to smell. 
 We kiss for a long time, then I straighten up. 
 &bquo;Marie,&equo; I say, looking down at her. 
 &bquo;Will you marry me?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course, Billy darling,&equo; she says. 
 Then we're walking round the room and she's holding my arm like we're married and that. 
 I've got this smart suit on and Marie's wearing this white wedding dress with all these frilly bits. 
 All these people are watching us and clapping like mad cos they're so happy and proud of us. 
 I walk round the room sort of smiling and sometimes waving or stopping to talk to someone. 
 I meet Mr Browne and introduce Marie. 
 &bquo;This is my wife, Mr Browne,&equo; I say, all proud like. 
 Mr Browne says &bquo;Pleased to meet you&equo; and shakes Marie's hand. 
 I can see Mr Browne is impressed cos I'm all married and my wife's so beautiful and I'm so grown up and that. 
 There's a loud bang on the front door and I jump. 
 Mr Jackson said he'd come today. 
 I listen for a bit to hear if anyone's going to answer the door. 
 I hope it ain't Mr Jackson. 
 I look round the room quick to make sure it's neat looking. 
 I should've tidied up a bit &mdash; that would've made Mr Jackson think I'm grown up enough to look after myself, but it's too late now. 
 I go back to my room. 
 My sleeping bag's on the floor, and I shove it on the bed quick. 
 Then I see the electric fire's still on. 
 I run over and switch it off. 
 Marie told me I shouldn't leave it on when I ain't in the room, and here I am &mdash; the first day she's gone and I've gone and left it on. 
 I'm so stupid. 
 Why do I always forget things? 
 I'll never be grown up if I keep forgetting things. 
 Maybe Mr Jackson's right &mdash; I can't stay here on my own. 
 I start crying. 
 I try real hard to be sensible and do things right, but they never work out. 
 I dunno why, but they never do. 
 It's not that I don't try &mdash; I do. 
 It's just sometimes I can't manage. 
 You know, I forget things and stuff like that. 
 I'll never be married and grown up and all that stuff. 
 I miss Marie. 
 I miss her more than I ever missed anyone. 
 If she was here everything would be OK and Mr Jackson wouldn't want to take me away. 
 &bquo;What's the problem, Billy?&equo; 
 I look up. 
 Mr jackson s standing in the doorway. 
 I wipe my face on my sleeve. 
 I wish Mr Jackson hadn't seen me crying &mdash; he'll think I'm a real baby. 
 &bquo;Nothing, sir.&equo; 
 He comes over and sort of squeezes my shoulder. 
 &bquo;Don't you worry,&equo; he says, &bquo;I've got you a place in Combe Court. 
 We'll just get your things together, then we'll be off.&equo; 
 He looks at me, worried like. 
 I've started crying again. 
 I try to stop, but I just can't. 
 I don't want to go to Combe Court. 
 &bquo;We'll drive there,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;You'd like that now, wouldn't you. 
 I nod my head and a tear falls onto my hand. 
 Mr Jackson drives me in his car sometimes for a special treat. 
 But now I don't want to go nowhere. 
 I want to stay here. 
 Mr Jackson helps me get all my stuff together. 
 I ain't really got much &mdash; just my clothes and that, so it don't take long. 
 We stick all my stuff in the suitcase and sort of squash it down so it all fits in. 
 I dunno what to do with the posters on the wall, and in the end I just leave them there. 
 Maybe someone else would like to use them. 
 I ask Mr Jackson if I can take all my plants, and he looks at them doubtful like. 
 &bquo;I don't know, Billy. 
 There's an awful lot of them.&equo; 
 He hums and haws for a bit then he says he'll put them in his car and ask if I can keep them at Combe Court. 
 I hope so &mdash; I really like my plants. 
 Mr Jackson tells me to shove my dirty clothes in a placky bag, so I do that. 
 The jigsaw won't fit in the suitcase. 
 It's back in its box now, but it's still pretty big &mdash; so I have to stick it in with the dirty washing. 
 I hope all the bits don't fall out of the box. 
 &bquo;Is this yours?&equo; he says, holding up my new hat that Marie bought me. 
 &bquo;Yes, sir.&equo; 
 He sticks it on his head and gives a big grin, like he's trying to cheer me up. 
 I hold out my hand for the hat and he gives it to me. 
 I dunno what to do with it, so I stick it on my head. 
 &bquo;Let's check the other room now, shall we?&equo; 
 I follow him into Marie's room. 
 I don't really like Mr Jackson being in here &mdash; I dunno why, but it's sort of private &mdash; you know, just me and Marie's like. 
 Satan's back in and I suddenly remember I got to look after him. 
 I tell Mr Jackson that, but he says I can't take him with me cos they don't let us keep pets at Combe Court. 
 I dunno what to do about that. 
 Marie asked me to look after Satan, and I suppose that makes him mine now. 
 Mr Jackson says that maybe someone in the house can look after him. 
 I think about that for a bit. 
 I don't want no one else to look after him &mdash; I  want to. 
 It ain't fair, them not letting you keep pets in 
 Combe Court. 
 I'm grown up enough to look after Satan. 
 I know what to do and that &mdash; you know, how to feed him and how to leave the window open. 
 It ain't fair I reckon. 
 I decide to go up and see Peter and ask if he'll look after Satan. 
 I grab him and go upstairs. 
 Peter ain't in, but his door's open, so I stick Satan on his bed and then shut the door quick so he won't try and run out. 
 I reckon Peter'll look after him OK. 
 When I come back Mr Jackson is trying to shut my suitcase. 
 It's pretty full and it won't shut proper. 
 One of the clips is bust. 
 &bquo;Have you got any string we can tie this up with, Billy?&equo; 
 Mr Jackson asks. 
 I dunno, so I have a look round, but I can't find none. 
 The shop on the corner sells string &mdash; I know cos I seen it &mdash; so I ask if I should go and buy some. 
 &bquo;Good idea,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;You go off and do that and I'll start loading your plants.&equo; 
 I stick on my coat and jam the hat on so it won't come off in the wind. 
 I ask Mr Jackson if he wants anything from the shop &mdash; you know, like fags or a newspaper or summat, but he says he don't. 
 He checks I got enough money to buy the string, and then I go off. 
 When I'm walking to the shop I think a bit about moving and that. 
 I hate moving to tell the truth. 
 It's sort of sad leaving things behind. 
 I don't understand why I always got to move. 
 As soon as I get settled in some place, it's time to move on. 
 And then you get put in a new place and you got to start all over again, finding where things are and making friends and that. 
 I was real happy living here with Marie. 
 I was getting real grown up and that &mdash; you know, looking after Satan and doing the shopping and that. 
 Now I got to move and start all over. 
 I was right about the shop selling string, and I buy a nice ball of it &mdash; all clean and white. 
 It looks pretty strong stuff &mdash; useful like. 
 I dunno. 
 I just don't want to go back to Combe Court. 
 I don't want to see Mr Jackson again neither. 
 I really don't. 
 I hang around the pavement by the shop for a bit, fiddling with the ball of string in my pocket. 
 It's flipping cold. 
 I wish I had my woolly hat on, not my straw one. 
 It's nearly Christmas I reckon. 
 I reckon it's going to snow soon. 
 It always snows at Christmas. 
 I dunno, but I just don't want to budge. 
 I feel like staying outside the shop all day just watching the people go past and fiddling with this string in my pocket. 
 It ain't fair, Mr Jackson making me go to Combe Court when I don't want to. 
 I want to stay here. 
 Then I start walking. 
 I know I'm going the wrong way, but I don't care. 
 I ain't going back. 
 I ain't never going to see Mr Jackson again. 
 I know my way round here and I know I'm going the wrong way, but I just carry on. 
 I'll go back tonight and then I'll do summat. 
 I'll run away or summat, or hide from Mr Jackson. 
 I could go to Scotland to see Marie. 
 She's still my friend &mdash; she'd like to see me, I bet. 
 I walk as quick as I can so Mr Jackson won't find me. 
 I'll walk all day and then come back tonight. 
 Peter'll help me &mdash; he's good at ideas. 
 Maybe I can live at the house and hide if Mr Jackson comes round. 
 Anyway, I can't live at Combe Court. 
 Marie said she'll write to me and she don't know where Combe Court is. 
 And if she comes back to the house, she won't be able to find me, so I got to stay there. 
 And then I get a pretty good idea. 
 Marie can come back to the house and bring her baby and we can carry on like before with me sleeping on the floor and that. 
 I wouldn't mind that, even with the baby. 
 Marie could look after the baby and I could help out by going to the shops for fags and milk and stuff like that. 
 And then maybe Marie and me could even get married and I could sleep in her bed, and we could be all married and that. 
 I should've said that to Marie &mdash; I reckon that would've been OK. 
 Maybe when I go back tonight Sonja can write to Marie telling her that. 
 I reckon it ain't a bad idea. 
 I get to this big main road with a park on the other side, so I cross over careful and go in. 
 I think I been here with Marie. 
 I think it's where we watched the ducks once. 
 I wish Marie was here now &mdash; she'd know what to do about Mr Jackson and Combe Court and that. 
 I wander round the park a bit looking at the trees and stuff. 
 There ain't many people about &mdash; I suppose cos it's too cold. 
 There's still some old leaves that ain't been brushed up yet, so I kick at them as I go along. 
 It's great, this park. 
 It's nearly like being in the country. 
 It'd be just like the country if there wasn't all the noise from the traffic. 
 I been to the country once with Annie. 
 I try not to think about Mr Jackson and that. 
 I feel a bit naughty to tell the truth, going off like that and leaving Mr Jackson waiting for me. 
 But I really didn't want to go to Combe Court. 
 I think I'd rather live in the park than go to the smelly old place. 
 I was there before &mdash; at Combe Court. 
 It was after I left school. 
 I didn't like it. 
 It wasn't just young people like at school, it was all sorts. 
 Grown ups and all sorts. 
 There was this really old bloke &mdash; everyone called him &bquo;Captain&equo;. 
 I suppose he was a captain of a ship or summat when he was younger. 
 I didn't really like him. 
 He was real old. 
 And dirty too. 
 He used to like me I think, but to tell the truth, I didn't like him much. 
 He never shaved, and he used to smell real bad. 
 He used to come and sit at my table when we had meals. 
 I hated that, cos he used to eat all slobbery like &mdash; you know, dribbling and that. 
 He was real old so I suppose he had trouble with his false teeth or summat, but anyway, it was pretty disgusting watching him eat. 
 He tried to touch me once &mdash; you know, down there. 
 That gave me a big shock that did, and after that I used to move away if he came too close to me. 
 I don't like people doing things like that. 
 Captain'd been at Combe Court for ages and ages I think, cos he knew everyone, even the very poorly ones like Glenda. 
 He knew all the nurses and doctors too. 
 But even so I don't reckon he had any friends. 
 Not real friends like. 
 No one used to come and visit him. 
 I reckon it was cos he was so dirty and ate so slobbery. 
 I dunno, but I reckon that's real sad. 
 I can hear a woman calling &bquo;Benjy, Benjy&equo; and I turn round to see what's up. 
 She's calling to a little dog which is running after summat with his tail wagging like mad. 
 It's great to have a dog I reckon &mdash; they're more fun than cats. 
 You can take dogs out for walks and teach them tricks and stuff. 
 Me and Annie had a dog once I think. 
 I ain't sure &mdash; I think it was us and not someone else. 
 It was ages ago, so I've forgot. 
 I think we had a dog, though. 
 It had yellow hair and it used to swim in the sea when we chucked sticks for it. 
 I think maybe it was called Simon &mdash; I ain't sure. 
 I carry on walking. 
 It ain't like I'm going nowhere special &mdash; it's just so cold I got to move to keep from freezing. 
 I think about the milk this morning, how it froze and it wasn't in a fridge or nothing. 
 There's blood in your body, and I get to thinking about what would happen if your blood froze. 
 You know, froze solid like a lump of ice. 
 I reckon you'd be like one of them statues &mdash; all hard and cold, sort of stuck in one shape. 
 I try it for a bit &mdash; you know, pretending that I'm all frozen, but someone on a bike comes down the path and I got to move to get out the way. 
 There's a wooden bench by the side of the path, so I sit down and stretch my legs out. 
 My trainers are a bit wet from kicking the leaves but my socks are dry I think. 
 I need a new pair of shoes, Marie said. 
 My trainers are getting pretty worn out now. 
 She said we'd get some in the sales, but I suppose it's too late now. 
 She's in Scotland. 
 I wish she wasn't. 
 I wish she was here, sitting next to me on the bench, holding my hand like she used to. 
 It's pretty quiet apart from the traffic, and there's hardly anyone around. 
 Sometimes people jog past, dressed up in tracksuits and that, but mostly I'm on my own. 
 I sit on that bench for quite a while &mdash; till it starts getting dark. 
 Then suddenly I get all cold, and I have to jump around a bit to get warm. 
 I wish I'd got my woolly hat. 
 This straw one's real nice and that, but it ain't all that warm. 
 I could do with a hot drink or summat &mdash; I'm froze. 
 I reckon I've waited long enough, and I can go back home now. 
 I don't suppose Mr Jackson's waited all this time. 
 I spect he's gone back to his office. 
 I hope he ain't too angry at me. 
 I didn't want to be naughty, but I really didn't want to go to Combe Court. 
 But I spect he's gone now anyhow. 
 What I can do is, I can go back and see if his car's still there. 
 I know what his car's like &mdash; it's yellow, and he's got this sticker on the back window. 
 I know cos he took me out in it sometimes. 
 If it's gone, then I'll go back in and see Peter. 
 Peter's clever &mdash; he'll have a good idea, I'm sure. 
 I start going back the way I came. 
 I walk pretty quick to warm myself up. 
 Just then, the street lights come on. 
 It's funny, but when the lights come on, it suddenly seems more dark in the park. 
 They look nice though, the lights &mdash; all warm and orangey. 
 I'm looking forward to getting back home and sitting by the fire. 
 I'll make a cup of coffee and toast some crumpets by the fire. 
 Then I'll go and see Peter and see if he's got a good idea what I can do. 
 I his park s blummin huge &mdash; I never knew it was so big. 
 I carry on walking till it's really dark and all the cars have got their lights on. 
 I got to cross the road &mdash; I remember that, so when I get to a gate I go out and have a look round. 
 The road's real busy now &mdash; there's hundreds and hundreds of cars and buses all queuing up. 
 It looks real nice with their headlights on and their little red lights at the back. 
 Sort of Christmassy. 
 It's pretty difficult to cross the road on account of all the traffic, so I just carry on walking on the pavement. 
 I don't feel too bad now &mdash; I'm pretty hungry, but I'm warm enough. 
 Sometimes it's a bit like a dream, walking on my own down the pavement with all these car lights flashing in my lace. 
 It's OK like, but just a bit dizzy-making. 
 I carry on walking for quite a bit. 
 There's more and more lights over the road &mdash; you know, from shops and that, and there's more people walking about. 
 I ain't in any real hurry and I stop every now and then for a look round. 
 I can't remember if I been here before or not &mdash; streets look all different at night from how they are in the day. 
 I got to cross the road, but I can't see no green man thing where I can cross safely. 
 I got to be careful &mdash; cars just suddenly come out from nowhere and it's easy to have an accident. 
 It's best if I don't go unless there's a proper green light thing. 
 It's easy to have an accident, crossing the road. 
 There's an underground thing &mdash; you know, steps going down to a station, so I go down there and wander around for a bit. 
 Some of the lights in the tunnel are busted, and it smells of piss. 
 There's loads of rubbish around &mdash; cardboard boxes and paper and stuff, and there's this man under one of the lights, blowing into a mouth organ thing. 
 He ain't playing a tune or nothing, he's just breathing in and out and making these weird noises, like rusty springs creaking or summat. 
 There's a few people now and then going past, but no one stops. 
 I hang round by him, watching him for a bit. 
 I dunno what he's doing. 
 I think maybe he's blind, cos he's got his eyes shut. 
 His cap's on the floor in front of him and I think about picking it up for him, cos maybe if he's blind he don't know he's dropped it. 
 I leave it in the end &mdash; there's summat a bit scary about him. 
 I run past him and up the steps to the street. 
 I'm pretty confused when I come out the other end. 
 It's all different here &mdash; there's loads of shops and a cinema and that. 
 I try and figure out if I crossed the road or not, but it's too confusing. 
 I can't see the park no more, so it's hard to tell where I am. 
 There's this big roundabout with all these cars packed together and people on bikes slipping through the gaps in the traffic. 
 It looks pretty nice with all the lights and buildings and that. 
 There's this great big building thing like a bridge or a gate or summat with these spotlights on it. 
 It looks real old and special, like summat in a museum or summat. 
 To tell the truth, I dunno where I am. 
 I sort of recognise it, but I ain't sure &mdash; a lot of places look sort of the same. 
 I have a think for a bit, then I start walking up the street I'm on. 
 It looks pretty busy and there's loads of shops and that, so it might be the right way. 
 I don't mind this, walking along streets at night. 
 I don't even mind being on my own. 
 If I was with someone else I'd have to talk to them or hurry to keep up with them, but this way I can go at my own speed. 
 I like looking in shop windows so I can take my time if I'm on my own. 
 My favourite shops are ones with loads of lights in them, specially those coloured lights. 
 There's quite a few restaurants with people in them having their tea. 
 I hey look real nice restaurants &mdash; sort of posh. 
 I'm pretty hungry by now but I don't go in. 
 I never been to a restaurant &mdash; not on my own like. 
 It's OK in a caff &mdash; you can just ask for egg and chips or if they have pictures you can just point, but I think I might have trouble in a restaurant cos you got to read from a menu thing, and I have a bit of trouble with my reading. 
 I'd go in if Marie was with me, but I'm on my own and I might have a bit of difficulty with the menu. 
 So instead, what I do is just stand outside and look through the window. 
 There's this one with candles on the table in these little glass bowls, and it all looks cosy and nice. 
 There ain't many people in there &mdash; I suppose cos it's too early for people to have their tea. 
 There's a man and a woman sitting at a table by the window, and I watch them for a bit. 
 They ain't eating yet, they're just drinking and talking. 
 They don't see me, so they just carry on, real friendly and private like. 
 It looks real nice, them sitting there, just the two of them. 
 I wish Marie was here &mdash; we could go in and have a meal together. 
 I carry on up the street, looking in the windows. 
 There's a TV shop with all these tellies on in the window, and I stop a bit and watch. 
 I don't like telly all that much, but I stop anyhow. 
 There's this person sitting on the pavement watching them. 
 At first I think it's an old man, but then I see it's a lady. 
 She's all wrapped up warm with this big old coat on. 
 She's got a trolley basket and a couple of placky bags full of stuff and she's made a sort of seat out of them so she's real comfy like. 
 I dunno which telly she's watching cos there's three sets on, all with different programmes. 
 She sort of glances at me and then she goes back to watching her programme. 
 She looks real comfy there, like she's sitting in an armchair at home. 
 You can't hear nothing cos the glass is too thick, so you got to guess what the people are saying. 
 I stay there a bit watching a telly programme with this man doing stuff. 
 I think he's doing tricks and that, cos he's got hankies and playing cards and that. 
 I don't really understand what he's doing, but it's OK to watch him for a bit. 
 The lady's watching a wildlife programme I reckon, cos all of a sudden she says'I was bitten by a tiger once.&equo; 
 I look over at her, but she don't say nothing else. 
 She just carries on watching the telly. 
 I dunno why she's talking about tigers cos there's horses on the telly. 
 Maybe there was a picture of a tiger and I missed it. 
 She looks real comfy there and I think about sitting down for a bit and watching telly, but I ain't got nothing to sit on so I just carry on standing up. 
 It's a pretty good idea I reckon &mdash; you know, if you ain't got a telly, to sit outside a telly shop. 
 You can't hear the sound or nothing, but you can make that up. 
 After a bit I get bored and carry on walking up the street. 
 I was going to say goodnight to the lady, but I stopped myself cos she looked so interested in the programme she was watching. 
 I suppose she comes here every night with her bags and things cos she ain't got a telly at home. 
 I reckon I should nearly be home by now &mdash; I been walking for ages. 
 I still dunno where I am, but I reckon I should be home pretty soon. 
 I go down this side street where there ain't so many big shops. 
 There's shops and that, it's just they ain't so big and some of them ain't got lights on. 
 I'm getting cold again, and my feet are aching with all this walking. 
 I reckon I been walking for hours now. 
 I think about Mr Jackson and I get a sort of uncomfortable feeling when I remember he was waiting for me at the house and I didn't come back. 
 I spect he was pretty angry about t tell him I was living at the house with Marie. 
 I feel in my pocket and find the ball of string I bought. 
 I pull it out and have a look at it. 
 It's pretty good stuff. 
 It's real strong stuff. 
 I'm glad I ain't at Combe Court now &mdash; that's where he was taking me to. 
 There's a sign for a railway station all lit up. 
 There's caffs and that usually in railway stations. 
 I could really do with a bit of a sit down and summat to drink, so I go down the driveway into the station. 
 It's blummin enormous inside &mdash; I didn't expect nothing like this. 
 It's got this great high roof and loads of trains. 
 It's real smoky and that. 
 I like railway stations &mdash; you know, how big and noisy and busy they are. 
 I was right &mdash; there's a caff there, so I go in. 
 It's like the dining room at school &mdash; all big and echoey. 
 It's pretty nice though. 
 It's got pictures on the walls and real flowers on the table. 
 Usually flowers in caffs are plastic, but these ain't &mdash; they're really real. 
 There's a young bloke cleaning the tables. 
 He's wearing a paper hat &mdash; you know, like they do in caffs. 
 A woman's washing the floor with a mop and a bucket. 
 She looks like a nurse in her blue uniform and her scarf over her head. 
 It's pretty quiet in the caff. 
 There ain't no music playing or nothing like there usually is, just the sound of people talking and the clunking of the fruit machine. 
 I go up to the counter and have a look to see what they got to eat. 
 It's pretty good here &mdash; they got photos of food all lit up over the counter so you can just point. 
 I get real hungry looking at the photos &mdash; I ain't ate for ages. 
 I feel in my pocket for my money and pull it out. 
 My hands are real cold cos I lost my gloves and my fingers won't work proper &mdash; they're all sort of numb. 
 I spread the coins out in my hand and have a look. 
 It don't look like I got much &mdash; I ain't got no paper money. 
 There's an old woman with thick glasses and a name tag who's serving the hot drinks so I go over to her and ask how much money I got. 
 She counts the money quick. 
 &bquo;97p&equo;, she says. 
 &bquo;What can I get for that?&equo; 
 I ask her. 
 I know it ain't much, but I dunno if it's enough to get a proper meal like. 
 She asks me what I want, and I think for a bit. 
 &bquo;Coffee,&equo; I say. 
 &bquo;And that.&equo; 
 I point at the photo of a pie and chips. 
 That looks pretty good &mdash; I dunno if it's steak and kidney or chicken, but either way would suit me fine. 
 &bquo;You haven't got enough for that, love,&equo; she says, friendly like. 
 &bquo;If you really want coffee then all we've got are those buns or sweets.&equo; 
 I think about it for a bit, then I ask her if I can afford some sandwiches. 
 &bquo;Not if you want a drink, love.&equo; 
 I dunno what to do. 
 I want a drink and  summat to eat. 
 In the end I decide to get a big cup of coffee and a jam doughnut. 
 I pay at the counter and get my change. 
 I hen I take my stuff over to the table by the window. 
 My fingers are froze, so I warm my hands on the cup for a bit before I try drinking. 
 My hands are shaking so much I have to sip my coffee without picking it up &mdash; you know, by just sort of ducking my head and slurping it up. 
 I know it ain't really polite, but my hands are shaking so much I'd spill it if I picked it up. 
 After a bit I feel better so I start eating my doughnut. 
 I chose the biggest one they had, and it's all glittery with sugar. 
 The first bite I take makes all the jam squirt out the side over my chin. 
 I ain't got a hankie or nothing so I try and lick it off with my tongue, but I can't get all of it. 
 I can picture Marie &mdash; how she'd tell me off if she could see me. 
 &bquo;Oh, hen, you're a messy one,&equo; she'd say with her laugh. 
 She didn't really mind me making mistakes. 
 She'd just laugh and say summat like that. 
 ln the end I got to scrape the jam off with my finger. 
 I try and eat the rest of the doughnut as neat as I can but I end up all sugary and sticky. 
 I try wiping my fingers on my coat, but it don't help much &mdash; I still feel all sticky. 
 I still got a bit of coffee left after I finish eating the doughnut, so I sip it slow to make it last, and look round the caff. 
 There's three young kids &mdash; younger than me &mdash; playing at the fruit machine by the door. 
 I dunno if they're friends or brothers. 
 I reckon they're friends cos they don't really look like each other and there ain't no grown up with them, like they're a family out with their mum and dad. 
 I watch them for a bit, but they don't win nothing. 
 One of them's smoking a fag. 
 I think he's trying to look all grown up and that, but he don't really &mdash; he just looks like a young kid trying to be grown up. 
 The bloke with the paper hat comes round with this trolley thing to clear the tables. 
 He don't clear mine even though I'm finished, but when he goes past I ask if I can have a lend of his dishcloth to wipe my fingers. 
 He don't mind me asking, and lets me use it. 
 He goes off again when I give him his cloth back. 
 He looks pretty bored. 
 There's a telephone on the wall just by my table and I think for a bit about who I'd like to phone. 
 I got this real urge to speak to someone on the phone &mdash; I dunno who &mdash; just someone. 
 I can't think of anyone I'd really like to speak to, except Marie of course, but I dunno if she's got a phone in Scotland. 
 Even if she has, I ain't got her number. 
 I wonder what it'd be like if the phone suddenly rung and it was for me. 
 That'd be nice, that'd be &mdash; but I don't expect anybody would phone. 
 That's a shame really, cos I'd like to talk to someone. 
 I sit there for a bit longer, till I finish my coffee, then I decide to go out and have a look round the station. 
 I like railway stations with all their trains and whistles and that. 
 I dunno how tall it is, but the Christmas tree outside the caff is blummin huge. 
 It nearly reaches the roof. 
 I stand in front of it and look up at the lights. 
 They ain't fairy lights, but normal light bulbs painted all different colours. 
 It's got all these decorations too &mdash; red and purple and blue glass balls like bunches of grapes. 
 It looks real pretty. 
 There's rows of benches in front of it and I sit down for a bit to look at the tree. 
 There's a woman sitting on the bench in front of me and she's eating chips from a bag. 
 I can smell them from where I'm sitting. 
 I wish I'd bought some chips &mdash; I'm still pretty hungry. 
 There's a bloke behind me with a big suitcase, reading a newspaper. 
 I spect he's waiting for a train. 
 I wish I had my suitcase with me and I was going somewhere nice. 
 It'd be nice to be waiting here for a train and then getting on it and going somewhere nice. 
 Like Scotland or somewhere. 
 There's loads of people coming and going. 
 I spect they're coming home from work, cos they look like they're in a real hurry. 
 There's some shops too and some people are going in to buy things &mdash; papers and books and that. 
 I think about it for a bit, then I get up and go over to the shops. 
 I like looking in shops &mdash; you know, not buying things, but just looking. 
 I'm just coming up to this shop when this girl stops me. 
 I'm pretty surprised cos I don't know her. 
 I hope she ain't going to ask me a question &mdash; you know, like where summat is, like the ladies or summat, cos to tell the truth I don't really know my way round here. 
 But she don't ask me where nothing is, she just asks me if I can spare lOp. 
 She needs some money for a ticket. 
 I dunno if I got lOp, but I pull out my change anyhow. 
 I hold it out to her so she can take lOp, and she takes the lot. 
 I dunno how much it is &mdash; it's probably about lOp. 
 She says thanks and then goes off. 
 She don't look too well. 
 She's young and that, but there's summat wrong with her eyes &mdash; they're all red and watery. 
 I don't mind giving her money. 
 I think it's a good idea to help people out if they ain't got money and that. 
 I don't go in the shop just yet. 
 I stand outside and watch the girl going round asking other people for money. 
 She's got a friend with her &mdash; a girl with long shiny hair like Marie's. 
 Some people don't stop when she asks them for money, but most people think for a bit and then dig in their pockets and give her summat. 
 I reckon they must've nearly got enough for a ticket cos they ask quite a few people. 
 I get bored with watching them after a bit, so I go in the shop and have a look at their books. 
 The shop ain't got no proper doors &mdash; it's just like part of the station so you can walk in and out without using a door. 
 Normally I like looking through books &mdash; you know, if they got nice pictures and that in them, but I dunno &mdash; I just ain't very interested at the moment. 
 It's hard to concentrate on a book with all these people around. 
 The shop's pretty crowded &mdash; I spect people are buying stuff for Christmas, so I just stand around watching them. 
 Everyone seems in a real hurry, even when they're looking through books. 
 Then some music starts up. 
 It's coming from outside, so I go out and have a look. 
 There's this big brass band set up in the middle of the station with these people sitting in chairs with their instruments all silvery and shiny. 
 It sounds really nice, the music they're making &mdash; it's all loud and echoey. 
 They're playing Christmas songs &mdash; I know cos I heard this one at school before. 
 We Wish you a Merry Christmas, this one's called. 
 I go right up so I can see proper. 
 They're all wearing the same sort of clothes &mdash; black, with these black hats &mdash; even the girls. 
 I like the man who's playing this great big shiny thing like a fog horn. 
 I listen real close to him, but he don't really play the tune &mdash; he just sort of goes blah-blah-blah every now and then. 
 It don't really sound like the tune, but it fits in real well with the rest of them. 
 When they stop I give them a clap, but no one else does. 
 Some people smile when they go past and there's this woman with a couple of kids over the other side from me, but most people just walk past like they ain't interested. 
 A girl in a smart black uniform is collecting money in this box and quite a few people stop and drop money in it. 
 I wish I had some money to give her, but I ain't got none left. 
 The next song they play is a slow one &mdash; Silent Night. 
 It's one of my favourites. 
 We used to sing this one at school. 
 It, s all about baby Jesus being born and that. 
 I wish I could remember the words, but I've forgot them so I just hum along with the tune. 
 It's nice that Jesus has got a birthday and that, just like a normal person. 
 I like presents and all that, but &mdash; I dunno &mdash; if it's Jesus's birthday then why don't we give him prezzies? 
 I know he's dead and that, but we could do things like, I dunno, like when you put flowers on someone's grave when they died. 
 We could give little presents to Jesus, like flowers or summat. 
 The band plays for quite a bit. 
 I know most of the songs, but there's one or two I don't. 
 They're nice songs &mdash; even the ones I don't know. 
 I specially like the man with the big silvery fog horn thing. 
 I'd like to play one of them. 
 When they finish, the band pack up and fold their chairs up. 
 There's lots of talking and laughing when they do that &mdash; they look like they've had a real good time. 
 I just sort of hang round watching them. 
 A big van pulls up and they stick their stuff inside and get in, but just before they go, the man with the fog horn thing turns round and says all friendly like, &bquo;Happy Christmas&equo;. 
 I say &bquo;Happy Christmas&equo; back and then he gets into the van and they drive off. 
 It's real quiet after they've gone, and there ain't many people around. 
 I really liked the band playing all them songs. 
 It's a shame they had to go. 
 The shop's shut now. 
 I think for a bit what I should do. 
 To tell the truth, I could do with a pee, but I dunno where the toilet is. 
 I spect there's one on the station somewhere, but I dunno where it is. 
 I stop this man in a black uniform and ask him where it is, and he shows me. 
 It's up the side of the platform &mdash; I can just see the light over the door from where I'm standing. 
 I thank the man and go over to it. 
 The toilet's really big. 
 It smells a bit, but it ain't too bad. 
 I have a pee, then I wash my hands at the sink. 
 You always got to wash your hands after you go to the toilet, cos there's germs and stuff. 
 It's great, cos the water's warm, and I fill up the sink and keep my hands in it for a long time. 
 My fingers feel all tingly, but it don't half feel good to stick them in the water. 
 I look up at myself in the mirror while I'm soaking my hands. 
 I keep forgetting I got my straw hat on. 
 It's really neat I reckon &mdash; like that picture of the man in that rowing boat. 
 Marie bought it for me, and she said it looked really great. 
 She said I was a handsome devil, too. 
 I smile at myself in the mirror. 
 I let the water out of the sink and dry my hands on this roller thing. 
 It's busted, so there's a whole long sheet of towel on the floor, like a bog roll that's been dropped. 
 It don't look too clean, but I dry my hands on it anyhow. 
 Back on the platform, I dunno which way to go. 
 Sometimes I get like that, you know &mdash; I just forget where I am. 
 Even in places I been to hundreds of times. 
 Sometimes I forget people too, but not so often as places. 
 I know I'm at the station, cos that's obvious, it's just I can't exactly remember how I got here. 
 It's like I never been here before. 
 There's all these trolley things outside the toilet. 
 They're sort of like cages and a car thing pulls them along, and stuff is stuck in them, like newspapers and all that. 
 I know cos I seen them already. 
 I walk right up to the end of the platform. 
 There's a train in, but there ain't nobody on it, and all the lights are off. 
 I been on a train with the school once &mdash; we went to the seaside and I cut my toe. 
 There's a sort of side bit with all these trolleys in, so I go in there. 
 I dunno what the time is, but I reckon it's getting pretty late. 
 I think it's about time I went back home. 
 I can see this light shining from the side, so I squeeze through a couple of trolleys to see if I can get out that way. 
 It ain't a door or nothing &mdash; it's just a big gap in the wall. 
 I spect they use it for driving their vans through. 
 But when I get there I can't find no way out. 
 There's this sort of metal gate over it &mdash; you know, made of wire. 
 It don't look like there's no way out this way. 
 I was hoping there was, cos it's about time I got back home &mdash; it's getting pretty late. 
 I try and see where I can get out, but it's pretty dark where I am &mdash; I can't hardly see anything except these trolley things. 
 I know the station's on one side, cos there's light coming from there, so I go back that way. 
 When I get out, I'm going straight back home. 
 But when I get to the other side I can't get onto the platform cos of this other gate. 
 Suddenly I get all lost. 
 I can't remember how I got in. 
 I sort of start running now to find a way out quick, but this wire fence goes all the way down to the wall at the other end and I can't find no door in it. 
 I wish it wasn't so dark. 
 It's all confusing. 
 It's all crowded with all these trolleys and I keep bumping into them. 
 I give my leg a nasty bash, but I don't stop and see if it's bleeding &mdash; I just want to get out. 
 I just got to get out to where it's light. 
 I try the other side again, but it's locked. 
 It's a horrible place. 
 It's all dark and all I can see are these metal cages all round. 
 I really want to get out of there. 
 I look all the way round but all I can see are the shapes of the trolleys and the wire fence on both sides. 
 If there was a light on I could find my way out easy, but it's too dark and confusing. 
 All I want to do is get out. 
 I go back over to the other side. 
 I'm so scared I start crying a bit. 
 I keep banging into these horrible trolleys, and everything's all dark and dirty. 
 There's a horrible smell like a garage, and I'm scared. 
 Then I see the way out. 
 There's a gap in the wall, and it goes right onto the platform &mdash; there ain't no fence or nothing stopping me getting out. 
 I'm real relieved when I see that, and head straight for the gap. 
 I feel much better when I'm back on the platform, and I sit down for a breather. 
 That was horrible in there, getting lost and that. 
 I'm real glad to be out of that place. 
 It takes me a little time to get calm again. 
 It was easy, really, getting out of there &mdash; it was just I was confused by it being dark and that. 
 There wasn't nothing to be afraid of &mdash; it was only a side bit with some trolleys and stuff in it. 
 But to tell the truth, I was pretty frightened. 
 I stand up and brush my coat down just in case it got dirty with me sitting on the ground. 
 I think it's a good idea if I get back home now &mdash; I'm feeling pretty tired and I want a lie down. 
 I go back down the platform, back to where the shops are. 
 One or two of them are still open, and it's still pretty bright with all their lights and that. 
 There's a hamburger bar open, and it smells real good. 
 I'd really like a hamburger, but I'm broke. 
 I hope it don't take me too long to get home &mdash; I could do with summat to eat. 
 To tell the truth, I ain't really sure where I am. 
 I know it's a train station and that, but I dunno how to get home from here. 
 I just hope it ain't too far. 
 I can see a policeman by the place they sell tickets. 
 He's got his big winter coat on with silver buttons and his tall hat. 
 They told us at school to ask a policeman if we got lost, and show him our yellow card with our name and address on it. 
 I think for a bit about going to ask him how I get home but I don't want to ask him in case he tells Mr Jackson. 
 If he told Mr Jackson then he'd come and take me to Combe Court, and I don't want that. 
 And anyway, I ain't got my yellow card on me. 
 I hang around for a bit, pretending to look at some writing on the board. 
 I could just ask him casual like &mdash; you know, like I'm going to meet a friend there or summat, but I can't remember the address. 
 I'd know where I lived if I saw it, but just at the moment I can't remember the name of the street it's in, and the policeman wouldn't know if I don't have the address. 
 In the end I just walk past him without looking at him. 
 I don't want him asking me questions like where I'm going and stuff like that, just in case he tells Mr Jackson. 
 I don't think the policeman saw me. 
 Even if he did, he ain't following me. 
 I dunno what to do now so I go up to the big electric sign board and have a look at it. 
 It's got lots of words written up, one after the other &mdash; I suppose the names of where the trains are going. 
 Sometimes there's a clicking noise and all the words change. 
 It's pretty interesting watching that &mdash; the way the words change so quick. 
 There ain't many people about &mdash; I suppose cos there ain't no more trains. 
 The platform's pretty empty. 
 There's this man on this big white car thing going round cleaning the floor. 
 There's sort of brushes under the car so when it goes round it sweeps and washes the floor at the same time. 
 It looks pretty good fun, driving that thing. 
 If I could get a job doing summat like that I reckon I wouldn't have to stay at Combe Court. 
 When I got the job on the building site, Mr Jackson said I was grown up enough to live on my own. 
 I reckon I could do a job like that. 
 It'd take me a while to learn how to drive it, but after I learned that I reckon I could do it. 
 It don't look too hard, driving round and round. 
 You just have to be careful not to hit anything. 
 I watch the man till he's finished and he drives off. 
 The floor's all shiny and new looking now. 
 It's empty except for this man and woman. 
 They're looking up at the sign board, and holding each other's hand. 
 I watch them for a bit. 
 I spect the man's going away, cos they keep hugging and kissing like they do in films. 
 I reckon that bloke's pretty lucky. 
 I wish I had a girlfriend who'd hug and kiss me when I was going to catch a train. 
 It must be real nice. 
 He's much taller than the woman, and she sort of hangs from his neck when they kiss, stretching up on tiptoe to reach him. 
 She can't stop kissing him. 
 He's probably going away for a long time, that's why. 
 It's sad, going away, but it must be nice all the same to have someone kiss you at the railway station. 
 I'm standing there watching them, and then suddenly they just walk off. 
 They don't even go to the train place &mdash; they go the other way, and up the driveway and out of the station. 
 I thought they was going to catch a train, and that's why they was hugging and kissing and that, but I dunno &mdash; maybe they was just planning to go away or summat. 
 Anyhow, they just went. 
 Just then this voice comes over the loud speaker. 
 I can't understand what the woman's saying &mdash; it's too loud and echoey to understand. 
 It sounds sort of sing-song &mdash; not like someone talking at all, more like a tune. 
 I dunno what she was saying. 
 Probably stuff about trains and that. 
 Someone blows a whistle, and this train starts rumbling, like it's getting ready to drive off. 
 It's pretty smoky &mdash; the trains give off this browny smoke and it don't blow away &mdash; it just sort of drifts up to the roof. 
 It looks pretty, but it smells flipping horrible. 
 I dunno what to do, so I go back to the caff and have a look in the window. 
 It's nearly empty now. 
 I think about it for a bit, then I go in. 
 I ain't got no money, but I don't reckon they'll mind me sitting there and just looking out the window. 
 It's pretty cold on the platform &mdash; I could do with getting warm. 
 I sit in the same seat as before, just by the window. 
 No one comes up to me to ask what I want, so I reckon it's OK for me to be there. 
 Someone's left a cup and saucer on the table, and when someone comes round, I pretend I'm drinking just in case they ask what I'm doing. 
 I dunno how long I sit there, but I reckon it's quite a while. 
 I don't do much except look round and think about things &mdash; mostly Marie and that. 
 It seems like ages since she's been gone. 
 I reckon there'll be a letter from her now, cos she said she'd write to me. 
 I got to get home though. 
 I wish someone would come and take me home. 
 I'm feeling pretty tired to tell the truth. 
 The same bloke who was there before comes up to me and tells me they're closing. 
 He takes the cup off of the table and sticks it on his trolley. 
 I don't want to go out &mdash; it's blummin freezing outside, but I ain't got no choice. 
 They're closing, so I got to get out. 
 I put my hat on and get up. 
 I dunno how I'm going to get home. 
 If I knew the way back, then I could walk, but I don't think I know the way from here. 
 I go and sit on the bench in front of the Christmas tree and stare at it. 
 We had a big Christmas tree once &mdash; ages ago, it was. 
 We stuck this white stuff like candyfloss on it &mdash; angel's hair it was called. 
 Annie helped me put it on. 
 She was only little then and I had to hold her up so she could reach. 
 I pretended it was Annie's hair we was putting on the tree, and I called her a little angel, but she got upset about that, so I stopped. 
 She was pretty touchy sometimes, Annie was. 
 But she was a good kid really. 
 She looked pretty as anything with her yellow hair and her cute little face. 
 She was real clever too. 
 She couldn't read or nothing cos she was too little, but she used to tell me stories &mdash; you know, made up ones like. 
 When we finished decorating the tree, we stuck all the prezzies underneath and Annie told me what she reckoned they was. 
 She was only guessing like, cos they were all wrapped up in paper, but she said she knew. 
 She had a real good imagination, Annie did. 
 I remember Mrs Seaton gave us some mince pies and we ate them hot, sitting on the floor in front of the tree &mdash; just the two of us. 
 Annie told me I'd get a bike for Christmas &mdash; a red one with a basket. 
 None of the prezzies was big enough for that, but she said it was a magic bike that got big when you wanted to ride on it. 
 Cos I'm thinking so much about Christmas and that, I don't see this old bloke till he calls out to me. 
 He's sort of half-lying on the floor, holding onto one of the benches. 
 I ain't sure if he's talking to me, so I don't say nothing. 
 &bquo;Give us a hand, son,&equo; he calls out. 
 &bquo;My leg's come off.&equo; 
 I get up and go over to him. 
 He's pretty scruffy and I think he's spilt summat on his mac, cos there's a big stain down the front. 
 His leg looks like it's broke &mdash; it's sticking out at a funny angle. 
 &bquo;Can I help you, sir?&equo; 
 I ask. 
 I spect he's fallen over and can't get up. 
 &bquo;My leg's come off,&equo; he says again. 
 He leans forward and picks up one of his legs and pulls it right out from his trousers. 
 I get a bit of a shock when I see that, cos it comes away from the rest of his body. 
 Then I realise it's a false leg. 
 I ain't never seen a false leg before. 
 I know some people got them, but I ain't never seen one before. 
 &bquo;Help me get this back on,&equo; he says, handing me the leg. 
 Though he's old and that, he looks a bit embarrassed. 
 His face don't go red or nothing, but he's got a sort of embarrassed look in his eyes. 
 I spect it ain't very nice to have to ask people to help you with things like that. 
 Sometimes I get embarrassed if I can't do summat on my own. 
 Sometimes you feel a bit stupid asking someone for a hand. 
 I look at the false leg for a bit while he pulls up his trouser leg. 
 It's sort of creepy looking. 
 It don't really look like a leg. 
 It's the right shape and that, but it looks sort of artificial like a doll's leg, except big. 
 It's made of plastic and it's all pink and shiny. 
 It's supposed to look like skin, but it don't at all. 
 It just looks like pink shiny plastic. 
 It's blummin horrible I reckon. 
 The foot is real enough, cos it's got this shoe and sock on it, but the leg bit is real creepy. 
 He tells me what to do, and shows me his stump. 
 It's sort of bandaged up so you can't see the skin. 
 I'm glad you can't see the skin, cos it's probably all shiny like Flora's hand when she got all her fingers burnt off. 
 His leg comes to a sort of point, like the end of a pencil or summat and he tells me to shove it in the end of the false leg. 
 I don't mind helping him and that, but I must admit I'm feeling a bit uncomfortable with this leg. 
 &bquo;Push it on hard, son.&equo; 
 I push as hard as I can. 
 His leg sort of jams into the plastic like a pencil into a pencil sharpener. 
 I help him get up and he stamps his leg so it goes on proper. 
 &bquo;God bless you, son,&equo; he says, holding onto me. 
 I think he's been drinking in the pub cos I can smell it on his breath. 
 &bquo;Tell me, are you a Jock?&equo; 
 I dunno what he's going on about, so I just look at him. 
 &bquo;Are you from Scotland, like?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, sir,&equo; I say. 
 He speaks a bit like Marie, so I suppose he lives in Scotland as well. 
 He's swaying a bit and I have to grab him cos I think he's going to fall over. 
 Well, maybe you've got Scottish ancestors then.&equo; 
 He straightens up his mac and gives me a real serious look. 
 Then he takes a bottle out of his pocket. 
 &bquo;Will you share a drop with me?&equo; he says, waving the bottle so I can see it. 
 I think it's whisky or summat, so I say no thank you. 
 I don't like whisky. 
 &bquo;All right then,&equo; he says, putting it back in his pocket. 
 &bquo;God bless you, and a Happy New Year to you.&equo; 
 He takes my hand and squeezes it hard. 
 &bquo;Are you sure you're not a Jock?&equo; 
 He shakes his head like he can't understand summat, then he lets go of my hand. 
 I'm glad he's let go, cos it was starting to hurt, he was squeezing so tight. 
 &bquo;Well, good night to you,&equo; he says. 
 He walks off and I watch him till he disappears round the corner. 
 He walks funny &mdash; sort of dragging one leg, a bit like Fullblast. 
 I spect it's cos he's got a false leg. 
 When he's gone, I think for a bit about Scotland. 
 I suppose that's where he's from. 
 I should've asked him if he knows Marie, cos that's where she lives now &mdash; in Scotland. 
 I think about going after him and asking him, but I change my mind. 
 He was friendly enough and that, but I dunno, I felt sort of uncomfortable with him. 
 I couldn't really understand what he was going on about, and I didn't like the way he shook my hand so blummin hard. 
 I go back and sit on the bench by the Christmas tree. 
 I wish I wasn't here. 
 I wish I was back at home with Marie, and it was warm and we had summat nice to eat like fish and chips or summat nice like that. 
 I have a look in my pockets to see if I got any sweets or anything, but I ain't. 
 All I got is a ball of string and some bits of paper. 
 I have a look at the paper to see what it is. 
 It's that picture of a cat that used to be on Marie's wall. 
 That was a nice picture &mdash; Marie liked it I think, cos she didn't mind me sticking it on the wall. 
 It's a shame it's got ripped. 
 It's gone right across its middle, but it don't matter too much, cos if you hold the bits together you can still see it OK. 
 Looking at that picture reminds me of the photos of me and Marie &mdash; you know, them we took in that photo booth. 
 I always carry them in my pocket &mdash; in the inside one, so they're safe and I won't lose them. 
 I pull the pictures out and have a look at them. 
 I always feel happy when I see them. 
 It's hard not to when you see how happy we are in the picture &mdash; we're laughing our heads off. 
 I dunno what was so funny, but we was killing ourselves. 
 I love these pictures &mdash; they're my best things. 
 I really wish Marie wasn't in Scotland. 
 I get up after a bit and stick the stuff back in my pockets and start walking the way I came in. 
 I have to stop and let a long line of trolleys go by. 
 They rattle and bash into each other, a whole long string of them. 
 I spect they're being taken someplace for stuff to be put in them. 
 Most of the platforms are empty, but there's a couple of trains still in. 
 Their engines are still on, rumbling like great big animals, but I don't think they're going nowhere cos there's no one about. 
 I get to the big entrance to the station and have a look outside. 
 I can see the lights from a couple of shops at the end of the driveway, but they ain't open I think &mdash; they just got their lights on. 
 I dunno what's best &mdash; you know, if I should go out or stay here. 
 It's all dark and misty outside, and it's real cold. 
 I ain't really scared of the dark, not normally, but looking out there, it's a bit scary. 
 It looks all big and open. 
 There's all these buildings and streets out there, but it's like they're all empty &mdash; you know, like there's no one out there, just things. 
 I know there's loads of people really, it's just they're all at home asleep. 
 But still I get the feeling there ain't no one out there. 
 It's all so big and confusing &mdash; all them streets and cars and places. 
 I turn round and go back into the station. 
 I dunno what I want to do, but I don't want to go out there. 
 At least I know where things are in the station. 
 I'd rather go home, but I dunno how to get there, and I don't want to get lost. 
 They've switched the Christmas tree lights off, but apart from that, the station's pretty light. 
 The lights in the caff are still on &mdash; it looks like it's open, but it ain't, cos I tried the doors and they're locked. 
 I sit back down on the bench and sort of snuggle into my coat to try and keep warm. 
 I wish I still had my gloves &mdash; my hands are freezing. 
 I shut my eyes and try to go to sleep, but there's too much going on to sleep. 
 These vans keep coming and going and the man on the cleaning machine is having another go at cleaning the floor. 
 It's too cold to sleep anyhow. 
 I watch this man with a red face and a little black hat sweeping all the rubbish up. 
 There's loads of stuff round the benches and he makes quite a pile after a while. 
 He sweeps under the bench I'm sitting on, and I lift up my feet so he can sweep under them. 
 He don't say nothing to me &mdash; he just carries on sweeping like I ain't there. 
 That looks a pretty good job, sweeping the floor, though I'd rather have a go on the sweeping machine. 
 I suppose if you work at night you got to sleep during the day. 
 Marie used to do that when I met her &mdash; you know, sleep all day and then go out at night. 
 I suppose you get used to it after a while, sleeping in the day. 
 When the man finishes, he sticks all the rubbish in this big black placky bag like they have at the laundrette, and he takes it away. 
 People leave a lot of litter around. 
 They just chuck it on the floor. 
 We was told at school not to do that. 
 We had to find a proper bin to chuck it in. 
 I think that's best, using a bin. 
 If you just chuck it on the floor, then someone s got to come round alter you and pick it up. 
 This man with long greasy hair and a sleeping bag sort of rolled into a ball comes over and starts looking in the bins. 
 I dunno what he's looking for &mdash; maybe he lost summat. 
 Sometimes you chuck summat away by accident and then you have to go looking in bins to find it. 
 I don't think he finds what he's looking for, cos after he looks in all the bins he goes off without taking nothing out. 
 I think it's best if I get some sleep. 
 I'm pretty tired now. 
 I lie down on the bench and try and make myself comfy. 
 I got to take my hat off, cos it keeps falling off and I don't want it to get dirty. 
 Marie gave me that hat &mdash; I don't want it spoiled. 
 I leave my shoes on, cos it's too cold otherwise. 
 It ain't too uncomfortable, but it's really blummin cold. 
 I wish I had my green sleeping bag with me, like that bloke before. 
 I reckon I could sleep if I was warm enough. 
 I get a bit dizzy lying down on the bench, like I'm falling backwards and I got to sit up for a bit. 
 I dunno if I, m feeling quite right. 
 Things are looking a bit funny &mdash; you know, a bit dizzy-making. 
 The roof's real high and all the noises are echoey. 
 It's like there's nobody except for me &mdash; all alone in this big place, all open and cold. 
 Things are pretty busy now. 
 They opened the gates by the steps and quite a few people are coming and going through them now. 
 It was just a few at first, but after a while it got more and more till it's quite crowded now. 
 The caff's open too. 
 I thought about going in there, but I ain't got no money. 
 I wish I'd got some cos I could really do with a hot drink. 
 I ain't feeling all that well to tell the truth. 
 I suppose I got a bit of sleep last night. 
 It's hard to tell, cos I always seemed to be awake, but then I remember waking up with a jump when this voice comes over the loud speaker. 
 That was a bit of a shock, cos I was dreaming about summat about a train and Marie going away, and then suddenly I came to and found myself in the station. 
 For a second I thought Marie was with me, but it was only a dream. 
 I'm real stiff from lying on the bench, so I get up and stretch. 
 I stamp my feet to warm them up. 
 My toes are froze &mdash; they're all sort of numb. 
 I don't feel too tired, but I could do with summat to eat. 
 I'm blummin starved. 
 I hang round the station a bit, watching the people all hurrying to catch their trains. 
 Sometimes people are in so much of a hurry they run. 
 I dunno why they're all hurrying. 
 I don't understand that. 
 It's still dark outside. 
 I expected it to be light, cos I thought it was morning on account of all the people all hurrying about. 
 It's still misty as well. 
 It ain't scary like it was before. 
 It ain't scary when there's all these people around. 
 Some of the shops are open now. 
 There's a caff down the road from the station with steamy windows and a couple of blokes in there having their breakfast. 
 It looks real nice in there. 
 I'd really like some breakfast. 
 I got a nasty taste in my mouth &mdash; sort of stale like. 
 I watch the two blokes through the window then I carry on walking. 
 If I get home soon I can have summat to eat. 
 I spect Marie's left some food in the cupboard. 
 The pavements and cars are all covered in this white frost sort of stuff. 
 It looks pretty &mdash; all sort of sparkly like silver glitter or summat. 
 I got to walk careful cos the pavements are so slippy. 
 It's sort of like snow, but not quite. 
 If you scrape your foot on the pavement you can make shiny black marks, like slugs make. 
 The mist's real thick now. 
 It makes everything look sort of fuzzy, and when cars drive past, their lights sort of fill up the street. 
 It looks real beautiful. 
 It's like the mist's made everything all quiet. 
 The traffic's real slow &mdash; the cars just sort of hissing past slow and quiet, their headlights all fuzzy and ghostlike. 
 It's like walking in a dream, all the shops and cars and everything all sort of fairy tale, like they ain't really there. 
 It's been dark for ages. 
 Nights in winter are long &mdash; I dunno why, but they are. 
 It makes me feel a bit funny being in the dark for so long. 
 I dunno, but it ain't like normal, walking down the street with the lights all fuzzy. 
 It's like it's still night and I never been to sleep at all. 
 Sometimes I get like I can't remember how I got some place. 
 You know, it's like I'm suddenly there, just sort of plonked down in a place and I got to really struggle to remember how I got there. 
 It's a bit like that walking down this street. 
 I know I stayed the night at the station but it don't feel real. 
 It's like it was someone else. 
 It's a funny feeling. 
 It's still like nighttime, but I know it ain't cos there's too many people about. 
 I spect they're all going to work or summat. 
 They've been to bed and got up in the morning, and now they're going off and doing things, like going to work and that. 
 It's always dark in morning in winter &mdash; it used to be dark when I got up to go to the building site. 
 It's morning and all that &mdash; it just looks like night. 
 Everything looks all quiet and special in the mist. 
 It looks really nice &mdash; sort of misty. 
 I walk down the main road, past all these shops. 
 I think I been here before, cos there's the telly shop from last night. 
 The old woman's gone &mdash; I spect she's at home now. 
 I stop a bit and watch a programme through the window. 
 There's this woman talking to this bloke. 
 I dunno what she's talking about cos I can't hear through the glass, but she keeps laughing at things he says. 
 She looks all warm and comfy in her clean clothes and that. 
 I wish I was in the warm. 
 I'm aching all over. 
 back home, so I carry on down the road. 
 It's real busy now. 
 There's all these hundreds of cars sliding past with their lights all red and white. 
 Some cars have got yellow lights. 
 One after the other, they're all pressed into one great snake. 
 They're hardly moving at all &mdash; I can nearly keep up with them just by walking quick. 
 It's getting sort of light now. 
 The street lights are still on, but the sky ain't black no more. 
 It ain't sunny, it's just sort of grey. 
 I ain't half glad that night's over, and it's going to be light soon. 
 It ain't so misty now, but the pavements are still sparkly. 
 With the light, it feels colder and I run down the road a bit to warm myself up. 
 There ain't no shops or nothing round here. 
 It's just a street and some old buildings &mdash; you know, for people to live in and that. 
 It looks pretty nice now it ain't so dark. 
 I'm real glad it's getting light. 
 There ain't a proper pavement here &mdash; it ain't concrete like, but just earth. 
 There's sort of grass, but it's pretty wore out and it's mostly just mud, except hard. 
 It feels like concrete on account of how cold it is, but it ain't &mdash; it's earth. 
 There's trees too, all down the street. 
 I like trees. 
 They're better than lamp posts and that, cos trees grow out of the ground, so they're extra special like. 
 The street's real wide, and there's loads of cars jamming it up. 
 There's loads and loads of cars here, all different. 
 When I get to the end I stop and have a look round. 
 I might have trouble crossing the road here. 
 I got to be careful crossing the road, specially when I ain't feeling too good. 
 But I'm lucky, cos there's this bloke who comes along, so when the lights turn green I just follow along behind him till I get to the other side. 
 I can see this park. 
 I can't see too much of it, cos it's still dark, but it looks pretty big. 
 It's got a pond, and there's all these trees. 
 I think I'll go and have a look around. 
 I like parks, specially when they got ponds, cos there's usually ducks and that. 
 That'd be good fun, to go and watch the ducks. 
 I wish I had some bread &mdash; I like feeding the ducks. 
 I find some steps, so I go down into the park and have a wander round. 
 The grass is all white and crunchy from the frost. 
 Frost ain't good for plants, it turns them black and kills them off if you ain't careful, but I reckon grass must be OK. 
 There's lots of trees and bushes. 
 They're real nice &mdash; they ain't sort of usual trees, you know, like you'd find in a wood or summat. 
 They look special &mdash; you know, all clipped and that. 
 Not like wild trees at all. 
 I go down to the side of the pond to have a look round. 
 I thought it might be frozen all over, like a picture I seen once with all these people skating on the ice, but it ain't. 
 The sides are a bit icy and there's sort of puddles with sheets of ice over them. 
 I step on a few and watch them crack in the middle like a sheet of glass. 
 It's pretty good fun &mdash; I like the noise it makes when it breaks. 
 There's some ducks and that sheltering under some bushes. 
 At first I couldn't see them, but when I heard a little quack I had a close look and saw them all there huddled together and trying to keep warm. 
 It must be blummin cold for a duck in this weather. 
 I dunno if they got nests or nothing to go to at night, but sat there under that bush all huddled up, they look froze to death. 
 There's a sort of metal fence I can sit on, so I rest there for a bit and watch the ducks and that. 
 They're all wrapped up in their feathers like old men in blankets trying to keep warm. 
 It's a pretty nice park. 
 It's got loads of flowerbeds and that, and a little bridge over the middle of the pond. 
 It looks sort of like a picture &mdash; you know, a proper painting, with all the bushes and the frosty grass and that. 
 If I was a real good painter or summat, I'd paint a picture of this all sort of dark green and grey and black. 
 I stay there for quite a bit, looking round and that, till it gets light. 
 The sky sort of turns grey and then whitey-blue and then in the end it's daytime and it's all sunny. 
 There ain't no clouds in the sky &mdash; just one or two wispy ones right above my head, but it's still blummin cold. 
 It looks warm and that, cos it's so sunny, but it ain't warm at all. 
 Maybe it's a bit warmer, but it ain't much. 
 I don't really mind, cos it looks so nice in the sun, but I'd rather it wasn't so blummin cold. 
 The ducks don't seem to mind it, cos there's quite a few swimming about now. 
 There's all sorts of ducks here &mdash; all different colours. 
 My favourites are these ones with black heads and a little red hat. 
 It ain't a hat really, it just looks like one. 
 They look real funny: they look sort of bad tempered and cross. 
 A bit like Mrs Riley, to tell the truth. 
 I wish I had some bread to give them; I spect they're hungry. 
 I like watching them get out of the water &mdash; they look real funny. 
 They sort of clamber out all clumsy like and then they waggle their tails like a dog and then start cleaning their feathers all quick. 
 They look funny and cuddly &mdash; except for the geese. 
 I don't really like the geese. 
 They scare me a bit. 
 I wish I had a nice coat of feathers &mdash; my mac ain't all that warm, and my straw hat hardly keeps my head warm at all. 
 They look sort of cosy in all their feathers. 
 I suppose feathers must be pretty warm things. 
 I dunno, I'd quite like to stay watching the ducks, cos they're pretty interesting, but I'm too blummin cold for that and I got to get back home. 
 I get up and start walking over to the bridge. 
 There's a few people about now. 
 There's this bloke with a white coat on and this bag of bread, feeding the birds. 
 There's a load of pigeons round his feet, all fighting over the bits of bread he chucks them. 
 I wish he would give me some of that, I'm flipping starved. 
 The birds just sort of bob their heads like they're wind up toys. 
 Then suddenly there's this loud bang from somewhere and they all fly off, like a mirror that's been smashed &mdash; pieces flying everywhere. 
 I sit down on the bench and look up at the sky. 
 It really looks beautiful today &mdash; all blue and new and fresh. 
 These white seagulls Hash past, like flashing bits of light, and the traffic in the background rumbling away. 
 It's like being at the sea, early in the morning with the seagulls and the sea pounding away and the fresh air. 
 The old bloke's still chucking bread down. 
 It's nice that he does that &mdash; you know, comes and feeds the birds like that. 
 There's this baby starling with these funny stubby wings trying to get to bits of the bread but the other birds are too quick for it. 
 I wish the old man would give some to it. 
 I wish he would give me some too, but I suppose he brought the bread just for the birds. 
 It's too cold to sit around for long, so I get up and walk onto the bridge. 
 It's a nice bridge, this. 
 Half-way across there's this old pigeon just sitting on the side. 
 It's all scruffy and wet and looks all beat up. 
 It's just sitting there, not moving or nothing. 
 We stare at each other for quite a bit &mdash; me and this pigeon. 
 Its eyes are like glass beads &mdash; you know, like a toy's. 
 It's hard to believe it can see anything with them eyes. 
 They just look like bits of black glass. 
 It looks so sad there, all cold and lonely, that I hold my hand out to sort of stroke it, but it flies off. 
 I wasn't going to hurt it or nothing &mdash; I was just going to stroke it, but it flew off anyway. 
 I feel OK now. 
 If I walk quick I don't feel too cold. 
 I walk like I seen them soldiers do &mdash; the ones with the red suits and big hats I seen. 
 They looked pretty good &mdash; all colourful and that, but I didn't stop too long to watch them. 
 I dunno, but I didn't like the way the man was shouting at them. 
 I dunno what he was shouting, but I didn't like it. 
 He sounded angry. 
 It was pretty good seeing them all marching together, though. 
 There's this blummin huge bridge so I stop a bit and look over the edge. 
 The water's real black and cold-looking. 
 I bet if you fell in there you'd get froze in a second. 
 It's a long way down to the water but I can see a fag packet bobbing along. 
 I spect someone chucked it off the bridge. 
 It's like a little boat, bobbing there, up and down. 
 There's a couple of boats, but they ain't moving &mdash; they're just rocking side to side. 
 I been on a boat once with the school. 
 It was pretty good fun, but I felt a little sick from all the rocking. 
 I don't suppose it would matter much if I fell in anyhow, cos I can nearly swim. 
 I can float and that, so if I fell in, that's what I'd do. 
 I'd just lie on my back like Marie showed me and float like a fag packet. 
 It'd be cold and that, but I wouldn't drown. 
 One day I'll learn to swim real good, so I can go up to Scotland and show Marie and she'd be real surprised. 
 She was a good swimmer in her blue swimsuit. 
 I don't spect I could be as good as her, but I'd be nearly as good. 
 This long boat comes past and I run over so it goes underneath me. 
 It's real wide and flat. 
 It's got stuff in it, but I can't see what it is. 
 I don't think it's a boat for people like the one we went on at school. 
 I think it's for taking stuff to the factory and that. 
 When it goes past I want to run over to the other side of the bridge, but there's too much traffic to cross the road, so I just watch the trail of water it leaves behind. 
 It's a sort of triangle, spreading further and further out till it reaches the sides of the river. 
 That sets the little boats rocking like crazy, like there's a sudden storm or summat. 
 I try and find the fag packet, but I can't see it no more. 
 Maybe it's sunk now &mdash; it was tiny compared to that boat. 
 It's lucky I wasn't in the water then floating, cos that would've been dangerous with that boat going past. 
 I have a look round for the fag packet, but it's gone. 
 I spect it's sunk. 
 There's some seagulls floating on the water. 
 At first I thought they was bits of paper or summat that someone chucked in, but when the big boat went past, they all flew off. 
 It must be great to be a bird &mdash; you know, just flying over people and buildings and that. 
 If I was a bird, I'd fly real high &mdash; as high as I could &mdash; close to the sun where I'd be warm. 
 Then I'd just go round and round looking down on things &mdash; you know, like from a plane. 
 Sometimes I'd come down to see people and do things, but only when I wanted to. 
 If I was a bird, I'd fly to Scotland to see Marie. 
 It'd be real easy &mdash; I'd just say to myself &bquo;Well, I think I'll just pop over and see Marie today&equo;, and five minutes later I'd be there and we could have tea together, then if I didn't want to stay the night I'd just fly into the sky again and stay there. 
 It never gets dark in the sky, so I'd never be afraid. 
 I stop outside this laundrette and warm myself up. 
 There's all this steam coming out, sort of billowing out onto the street, and if I stand in it, it feels real warm. 
 I'd like to go in for a bit, but there's loads of people in there and I ain't got no washing to do. 
 But it's nice to stand out there in the warm steam, getting warm. 
 I stay there for quite a while, until I get real good and warm. 
 If I nearly close my eyes and carry on walking I can pretend I'm blind. 
 I seen a blind man once &mdash; he'd got a stick so he could tap the pavement so he didn't fall down no holes. 
 I try walking for a bit with my eyes closed proper, but I keep having to open them cos I'm scared I'm going to bump into summat. 
 If I was blind it'd be real difficult to go for walks and that. 
 I suppose it'd be like nighttime all the time &mdash; you know, real dark and that, except you couldn't switch the light on. 
 I'm as hungry as anything. 
 If I could have summat to eat, I'd have a big bowl of oxtail soup &mdash; all hot and steamy. 
 Like that time I was ill in bed. 
 Oxtail soup and buttery toast and jelly for afters. 
 Red jelly. 
 There's a sort of market here, like the one I used to go to with Marie and Sonja, cept not so big. 
 It's mostly fruit and veg, but there's one or two stalls selling clothes and stuff. 
 Socks and that. 
 I'd like to buy a woolly hat &mdash; my ears are stinging, it's so cold, but I ain't got no money. 
 I like my straw hat Marie bought me, but to tell the truth it ain't so warm as a woolly one. 
 I have a look in the gutter to see if any fruit or stuff has been chucked away. 
 That's what I used to do with Marie &mdash; look for food they chucked away cos it was bashed up and that. 
 Sometimes I got real nice things. 
 I found a pineapple once. 
 There wasn't nothing wrong with it &mdash; it was just a little bashed up on one end, that's all. 
 I can't find nothing here, except a couple of old spuds, and they ain't no good cos you got to cook them first. 
 I thought they was pears at first and I got excited, cos I like pears, but they wasn't. 
 They're spuds. 
 It's only a little market, but the pavement's pretty crowded with all these people, and I keep getting bumped. 
 There's this little bent old man with a shopping trolley thing and he bashes it into the back of my legs. 
 He don't say sorry or nothing, even though he did it quite hard. 
 He just goes on past me, puffing away and shoving this trolley thing in front of him. 
 There's a stall selling chickens, all white and plucked with their heads cut off. 
 Their skin's all bumpy, like they're cold, but they ain't of course cos they're dead. 
 This woman with a red headscarf is looking at them and chatting to the man behind the stall. 
 She's got a fag in her mouth, and she's squinting her eyes against the smoke. 
 There's a long bit of ash on the end of her fag, and when she talks it falls off onto the chickens. 
 Then she does summat that really shocks me. 
 She grabs a hold of this duck's neck and starts twisting it &mdash; you know, like she's trying to kill it. 
 She ain't looking at it &mdash; she's carrying on talking to the man, but she keeps twisting the neck of this white duck. 
 I want to shout out and stop her, but I can't get no sound out. 
 I can't believe it &mdash; you know, the way both of them are just being so normal like, and she's twisting the neck of this duck and killing it. 
 Then I see what it really is, and I nearly laugh. 
 It's a white placky bag she's twisting, not a duck's neck. 
 It just looks like it. 
 I really thought it was a duck. 
 I got to sit down after that, and I find a wooden crate. 
 I'm sweating a bit, and my skin feels all prickly. 
 I really thought it was a duck. 
 I thought she was just standing there twisting the neck of this duck. 
 It made me feel really funny seeing that. 
 It's real smoky and noisy with this traffic. 
 I can feel the lorries every time they go past &mdash; the ground sort of shakes like a whatnot &mdash; an earthquake. 
 There ain't so many people about, and them that are look like they're real busy &mdash; you know, just hurrying along as though they're in a rush to get home. 
 I don't really like it round here &mdash; it's dirty and there ain't hardly any shops. 
 I'm feeling real heavy and tired and my feet's aching so I have a sit down on a wall and swing my legs for a bit. 
 I dunno what to do &mdash; I really don't. 
 I wish Marie was here &mdash; she'd know the best thing to do. 
 She always knew what to do. 
 I take out the photos of me and Marie and look at them. 
 They've got bent from being in my pocket &mdash; there's a crease right across Marie's forehead. 
 I sort of iron it out flat on my knee and look close. 
 I remember when me and Marie took those pictures. 
 We was in this railway station and Marie had just been to the dentist. 
 I remember, I waited for her in the waiting room. 
 After the dentist we went to the station to get the tube back to the house, and Marie said &bquo;Let's get some photos for your swimming pass&equo;. 
 I remember I had to get some photos so I could get into the swimming pool for nothing. 
 So I sat on this stool thing and Marie pulled the curtain and the light flashed twice and then Marie leaps in and sits on my lap, and it flashes again. 
 I couldn't wait for the pictures to come out, I was so excited to see them. 
 And when we seen them, we just bust ourselves laughing, cos they looked so funny with Marie's hair all over the place and me with this real surprised look on my face. 
 I wish I could find my way back home. 
 It can't be far, I know that, but I dunno the way. 
 If I had the address on a yellow card I could show it to someone and they'd tell me. 
 They'd say &bquo;Oh yes, I know. 
 Down this road, turn this way and then turn that way and you'll be there. 
 It ain't far.&equo; 
 I'd thank them and I'd be home in five minutes and I could sit in Peter's room looking at his stuff and chatting with him. 
 It'd only take a minute to get back and then all this would be over. 
 But I got to carry on walking, cos I don't have no card. 
 Maybe if I walk long enough I'll get to Scotland and I can see Marie. 
 She'd be real surprised to see me, I bet. 
 Then I get a real good idea. 
 Bayswater! 
 Billy Bayswater! 
 That's where I live! 
 I'm so pleased with myself I shout it out. 
 Bayswater! 
 It ain't a street or nothing, but if I get there I might recognise summat and then know where I am. 
 Then I could find the house and unlock the front door and go in and everything. 
 I'm real chuffed with myself for thinking of that. 
 That was a real grown-up thing to do. 
 There's a woman just up the road so I hop off the wall and run after her. 
 My legs are a bit wobbly and I nearly fall over. 
 I steady myself against the wall. 
 I mustn't get too excited, but I can't help it &mdash; I'm going to be back home soon and everything's going to be OK. 
 The woman's dark like runny chocolate, her skin all smooth and beautiful. 
 She's heard of Bayswater and she points up the road. 
 You'll have to go back into town, she says. 
 I'm so pleased with her for knowing the way I want to hug her. 
 I don't, cos it ain't polite with strangers, but I give her a real nice smile instead. 
 She smiles back at me, all sort of friendly. 
 She ain't young or nothing &mdash; I spect she's got kids and that, but her skin is so lovely and soft-looking and warm like runny chocolate I just want to touch it. 
 I don't &mdash; I just say thank you and goodbye, then I go off up the road. 
 God, I'm so happy I could dance! 
 Now I know the way I don't feel tired no more. 
 Sometimes I get a little dizzy and that and I sort of feel real tall &mdash; you know, like a giant. 
 When I look down at my feet they look miles away. 
 I feel OK and that, but just a little funny. 
 I don't mind though &mdash; I'm going to be home soon. 
 I got to remember the name so I don't forget. 
 Bayswater. 
 Billy Bayswater. 
 I walk as quick as I can, till I'm nearly running. 
 It's great to be out somewhere and then decide to go home, and there it is, waiting for you, and all you got to do is walk a bit and then you'll be home and everything'll be OK. 
 I'm looking forward to having summat to eat, and then having a lie down. 
 I'd quite like a rest now, and I would if there was somewhere to lie down, but I don't want to get dirty. 
 I'm feeling a bit dizzy to tell the truth. 
 I'm feeling OK and that, but just a bit dizzy. 
 There's a house with a broken window &mdash; a big black hole in the window, and I laugh at it. 
 I'm going home. 
 I don't have to stay here. 
 I got my own home and it ain't got a broken window. 
 It's got an electric fire and food in the cupboards, and I got a cat and a sleeping bag and all sorts. 
 I'm better than any old broken window. 
 If I had a broken window I wouldn't put my fingers through it &mdash; no way. 
 That'd be stupid. 
 What I'd do is stay on the other side of the room so I wouldn't get sucked through it. 
 They're dangerous, broken windows. 
 I hurry on past &mdash; I don't want to put my fingers through the glass. 
 It's getting dark. 
 I didn't know, but then suddenly the street lights come on. 
 I stop under a lamppost and look up at the light, all orange and flickery. 
 Then I get this hot feeling at the back of my head and everything goes funny and I find myself on the floor. 
 I've fell over. 
 I felt so dizzy looking up that I fell over. 
 I sort of get up onto stop to have a sit down or nothing. 
 I keep on walking, cos Marie'll be waiting up for me. 
 I spect she's worried about me, being gone so long. 
 But I bet she'll be real surprised to see me. 
 And proud too, cos blimey, I been walking for ages and when I get back home she'll think I been real clever to find my own way back, and I ain't got a yellow card or nothing. 
 The pavement feels a bit springy. 
 I dunno if it's cos it's new, but it feels spongy. 
 It's weird walking on it &mdash; I can feel my feet sink into it like I'm walking on rubber. 
 If I get too tired I might just have a lie down and have a little kip. 
 I'm pretty warm so I don't need a blanket or nothing and I can just bunch up the pavement into a pillow if I need one. 
 I reckon that'd be just as comfy as a proper bed. 
 It feels real soft and warm. 
 And if anyone came up and told me off for sleeping on the pavement I'd say I was the King of England and I can sleep anywhere I like. 
 But I don't lie down &mdash; I just carry on walking. 
 I got to be careful of the traffic, cos a car nearly hit me. 
 This man stopped real quick and blew his horn and shouted summat at me. 
 I didn't hear what he shouted, but I was pretty lucky I wasn't run over, cos to tell the truth I wasn't really looking where I was going. 
 I was looking in all the shop windows, at the reflections. 
 I got to be more careful and watch where I'm walking. 
 I don't want to have an accident. 
 Once I seen someone dive into the road like diving into water. 
 They just went in head first and was swallowed up in the road. 
 It wasn't as splashy as water &mdash; it was sort of like cake mix. 
 Sort of poury like but not too wet. 
 They didn't come up again &mdash; I dunno where they went. 
 I dunno why I thought of that &mdash; I just did. 
 Why didn't they come and visit me, Mum and Dad? 
 Everyone else had visitors &mdash; cept for Captain. 
 I really wanted them to visit me, but they never did. 
 Sometimes I think about things we do &mdash; you know, everyday things like walking or washing our face or eating or summat. 
 Sometimes when I think about them, they seem real complicated. 
 Like if you thought about how you walk &mdash; you know, moving your legs and all that &mdash; it's real hard. 
 I try it for a bit, thinking real hard about walking. 
 I walk real slow, feeling my body all heavy, like I got big boots on. 
 I suppose when babies learn to walk it's like this &mdash; you know, one foot in front of the other real slow and wobbly. 
 I try walking like that for a bit. 
 I dunno why, I just do. 
 I suppose it's interesting. 
 People don't know how hard walking is when you really think about it. 
 I'm surprised how clever people are, walking without even thinking about it. 
 It's pretty amazing the way we can do all these things. 
 Sometimes we just don't think about how clever we really are. 
 I get this big feeling again. 
 It's like everything's a long way away, and everything's real big and unreal looking. 
 It ain't scary or nothing &mdash; it feels quite good, sort of like a dream. 
 Maybe I am  dreaming. 
 It's real busy here. 
 There's loads of shops with their lights on and traffic and people hurrying along the pavement. 
 I'm still walking real slow. 
 I ain't trying to, it's just I can't walk quick. 
 It's like I'm real light &mdash; you know, like one of them silver balloons &mdash; and every step I have to be careful not to float off. 
 I think about my legs, but I don't really have no feeling in them. 
 I can still make them work and that, it's just like they ain't mine. 
 You know, it's like that plastic leg I saw once &mdash; you know, the false one. 
 I don't really mind this walking. 
 It's easy enough and it's pretty interesting. 
 What I don't like is the noise. 
 Everything's so loud. 
 I go past this bloke selling papers and he shouts summat out and I got to stick my fingers in my ears, it's so loud. 
 His shouting sounds like a trumpet or summat. 
 It should be a nice sound, but it's too loud and it sort of upsets me. 
 The cars are all blowing their horns too. 
 I really don't like that. 
 It ain't that it's too noisy &mdash; it's just, you know, like a dentist's drill or summat &mdash; it, s a noise that makes you want to run away from it. 
 I try walking with my hands over my ears, and it's a bit better. 
 I can still hear stuff, but it sounds swishy like when you listen to one of them curly sea shells. 
 It's like I'm just floating down the street, just a head bobbing along in the water. 
 Sometimes I think I'm invisible and I can pour myself into places like I'm made of water. 
 Invisible water just running over things, round people, down the street. 
 Warm water running away, and nobody can't see me and nobody can't catch me. 
 I'm happy now. 
 I'm warm and free and there's lights and people, and nobody's asking me questions. 
 Nobody can't catch me cos I'm invisible. 
 They can't see me. 
 I, m just water swirling round them and they're too busy to feel me. 
 They can't feel me cos they don't know I'm there, and if I want to I can fly over their heads and leave them behind and live in the sky. 
 So I dance. 
 I dance like I'm splashing water, swirling round them, down the street. 
 Everything's so bright and beautiful and nobody can't see it. 
 They're all statues and I'm dancing into the gaps between them, rolling into the spaces like I'm a ball of water &mdash; a red watery marble rolling along the street and nobody can't see me and nobody can't catch me. 
 I could walk like this for ever. 
 Just roll down the street, going on and on and on. 
 The lights are like smashed glass &mdash; all shattered into a million bits. 
 I stop and watch the traffic lights change. 
 Red, orange, green &mdash; they sort of fill me up with colours. 
 Red, orange, green &mdash; I could stay here forever. 
 It's her! 
 It's Annie! 
 She's walking along the pavement ahead of me, holding onto this woman's hand. 
 I dunno who the woman is, but it's Annie. 
 She's had her hair cut, but it's Annie all right. 
 I run after her, bumping against people in my rush. 
 God, she'll be surprised to see me! 
 I get stuck in a crowd of people coming out the tube and I have to stand on tiptoe so I can keep my eye on her. 
 I shout &bquo;Annie!&equo; but she don't hear me. 
 I'm laughing like crazy &mdash; I can't believe it. 
 Annie, come to see me! 
 There's a gap in the crowd and I dart through and run after them. 
 I call out her name again, but she still don't hear me &mdash; she's too busy talking to the woman. 
 She's got this cute little duffle coat on and a bobble hat with her hair sticking out the bottom. 
 I overtake them and turn round. 
 &bquo;Annie,&equo; I say, squatting down like I used to. 
 She'd always run into my arms when I did that so I could lift her up, but she don't do it this time. 
 They stop, Annie and the woman, and just stare at me. 
 Then I see it ain't Annie &mdash; it ain't her at all. 
 It's some other little girl. 
 I feel real weird all of a sudden, seeing it ain't Annie. 
 I just stay there, squatting down and the woman gives me a funny look and tugs the little girl's hand and they walk round me and go off down the road. 
 I turn and watch them go. 
 I thought it was Annie &mdash; I really did. 
 She had the same colour hair, all yellow and curly, and she walked in just the same way, sort of little bouncing steps. 
 I just stay there, squatting on the pavement, blubbering like a baby. 
 I thought it was Annie, and we'd go home together and see Marie and they'd both be proud of me and we could sit in front of the Christmas tree together and guess what the wrapped up presents were, and eat mince pies and all that. 
 I was sure it was Annie, but it wasn't. 
 I made a mistake, and I'm so stupid. 
 Nobody won't come and see me cos I'm so stupid and I always make mistakes. 
 And Mum's always telling me off for doing things wrong. 
 That's why they sent me to school &mdash; cos I'm handicapped. 
 Now nobody's going to come and see me, and Marie's gone away and Annie don't know where I am and they won't have Christmas with me and we won't open prezzies together. 
 It's just colours I can see through my tears &mdash; just smashed bits of colour. 
 I don't want to go on. 
 I'm too tired. 
 I just want to stay here and sleep. 
 I'm warm and tired and the ground's soft, so I just lie down where I am and shut my eyes. 
 The noises swirl round me, but it don't bother me. 
 I'm falling. 
 Falling head over heels in black. 
 I won't move. 
 I won't move for ever. 
 They left me at school, Mum and Dad and Annie. 
 They took me there in the car. 
 Simon was in the back on his tartan rug and he kept licking my suitcase. 
 I didn't know where I was going and I was scared. 
 Annie had drawed me a going-away card &mdash; a real good picture of a man and a house. 
 I couldn't really tell what it was till she told me, but when she did I could see it. 
 It was a real good card. 
 I had that in my hand and I was crying. 
 Mum and Dad were all tight and not saying much and Annie just chatted away to me in the back and Simon kept licking at the suitcase like it was a bone or summat. 
 And then we got to school and it was all big and confusing and there was all these boys I'd never seen before, all with their parents and some of the kids were weird-looking with funny eyes. 
 One kid was in a wheelchair and this other one couldn't walk proper. 
 I didn't want to stay there &mdash; I wanted to go home, but Mum told this old woman my name who smiled at me and showed me my bed and that. 
 Mum helped me put my clothes in the drawer. 
 She said I'd have a real good time here &mdash; playing sports and sleeping in the dorm with all the other boys. 
 I tried to believe her, but I was too scared. 
 I really didn't want to stay there, even if we did play sports and everything. 
 There was this funny smell and all these strange kids. 
 They all knew each other and was laughing and kidding around and I was scared cos it smelt so bad and was so big and bright and I didn't know where I was. 
 Then Mum and Dad and Annie all said goodbye and I was crying and so was Annie. 
 Dad patted me on the head and Mum gives me this little kiss on the cheek and then they went off and left me with this old woman. 
 Mum kept calling her &bquo;sister&equo;, but she wasn't my sister &mdash; Annie was and I didn't want to stay there, but they went off and left me. 
 I open my eyes and push myself up. 
 I dunno what I'm doing lying on the floor, getting all dirty. 
 I stand up and brush my coat down. 
 My hat's fell off so I stick it back on and look round. 
 I feel OK now &mdash; it's just my legs are aching. 
 I ain't had a fit or nothing &mdash; I was just lying down cos I was tired. 
 I stand there a bit, organising myself. 
 I got to get back home, that's the thing. 
 I got to be grown up and ask people the way. 
 I stop this man and ask him where Bayswater is, but he don't understand me and just shrugs. 
 Then I see a policeman and I go over to him. 
 The policeman knows OK and tells me, but he looks at me funny all the time. 
 He asks if I'm all right and I say yes. 
 I don't feel too bad &mdash; my legs ache and I got a sort of tight feeling in my tummy, but apart from that I'm OK. 
 It's a little complicated what he says, and I don't follow it all, but I know he said carry straight on down this street, so I thank him and go off. 
 That's what they told us to do at school &mdash; ask a policeman if we're lost. 
 The street goes on for ages, but it's pretty interesting. 
 There's loads of shops I can look in and there's all these Christmas lights. 
 It's real pretty. 
 I'm glad it's Christmas and there's lights in the shop windows and all that. 
 When I get home I'll make Marie and Annie a Christmas card. 
 I'll do a real nice one and get Peter to write inside it so it's all neat. 
 I'll do that tomorrow when I'm home. 
 At the end of the street, there's this big square with loads of people in it. 
 It's like this film I seen about these penguins &mdash; you know, how they all lived together on this island, and they was loads of them, all jammed together. 
 In the middle of the square there's this huge Christmas tree. 
 I never seen a Christmas tree so big &mdash; it's as high as a house. 
 It's got all these white lights all over it and it's real tall. 
 It looks great there, standing in the middle of the square, looking down at all the people and cars and that. 
 It's even bigger than the buses that go past. 
 There's a man cooking chestnuts on the corner and I stop and warm my hands over the fire and look at the Christmas tree. 
 The chestnuts smell real good &mdash; all hot and nutty. 
 I'd really like some, but I ain't got no money, so I just make do with warming my hands. 
 Everything looks real pretty 
 I44 round here &mdash; the lights and the tree and the stalls selling postcards with their lights on. 
 It feels real Christmassy &mdash; you know, all sparkly and glittery and that. 
 There's a lot of traffic here and it takes me quite a bit to cross all the roads to get to where I want. 
 I dunno, but I get the feeling everyone's all looking forward to Christmas &mdash; you know, opening all the prezzies and stuff like that. 
 A couple of girls go past and they got this red sparkly stuff wrapped round their necks &mdash; you know, a sort of silvery string they hang on Christmas trees. 
 I spect they've been to a party. 
 They look all happy and warm together, wrapped up in their winter coats with this sparkly stuff round their necks like a scarf. 
 I call out &bquo;Happy Christmas&equo; after them, but they don't hear. 
 My ears are burning in the cold, but there's nothing I can do about it. 
 My fingers are froze too. 
 They don't work so well on account of how swollen they are &mdash; they're all sort of purply and itchy. 
 I try rubbing them, but I'm too tired to do that for long, so I just stick them back in my pockets. 
 I get a bit dizzy again and have to take it easy, so what I do is I walk with one arm against the shop windows and that, so I don't fall over. 
 I can't walk too quick like that, but at least I don't fall over. 
 There's this shop, all lit up with these bright lights, and loads of stuff in the window &mdash; toys and that. 
 I stop in front of the shop and look inside with my forehead sort of pressed against the glass. 
 There's these springy sort of things bouncing up and down on a string like they're alive. 
 They look like some sort of animal, bouncing up and down like that. 
 I watch them for quite a while. 
 They just go up and down, up and down and never stop. 
 My eyes go funny after a bit, so I look at summat else. 
 There's this red Father Christmas &mdash; a sort of plastic doll thing. 
 It looks pretty weird. 
 I think it's a blow-up thing &mdash; you know, like a rubber ring you go swimming with. 
 It don't look like a 
 Father Christmas much, but I know it is, cos it's got a red suit and a white beard. 
 I don't like its eyes. 
 They're just sort of painted on &mdash; you know, like black dots. 
 I wouldn't really fancy that &mdash; it'd be no good to cuddle or nothing. 
 It's too shiny and that. 
 There's this siren going behind me, getting louder and louder, and I turn round to have a look. 
 It's a big white ambulance with a blue light on top, flashing on and off. 
 It's making a hell of a racket, but it stops the noise after a bit, cos it gets stuck in the traffic. 
 I don't like noise that loud. 
 It upsets me. 
 I turn back and carry on looking in the window, but it's hard to concentrate with this blue light flashing on and off in the glass. 
 On and off. 
 Blue and then nothing, real quick. 
 It's like it's flashing in my head. 
 I shut my eyes, but it's too late. 
 I can see all these sparks and flashes &mdash; red and blue fireworks going off. 
 Then I feel myself falling. 
 My teeth are soft like chewing gum. 
 I bite them together and feel them squash. 
 My head hurts real bad &mdash; right inside my eyes. 
 I sit up and rest against the wall. 
 It hurts too much to keep my eyes open, so I just sit there trying to concentrate. 
 I had a fit &mdash; I know that. 
 My legs are warm and I give them a feel. 
 I think I wet myself. 
 I open my eyes and try and look at my trousers to see if it's true, but my eyes are all blurry and I can't see proper. 
 I hope I ain't wet myself. 
 It takes me a bit to remember where I am. 
 It's pretty confusing at first, cos all I remember is this blue light, and it ain't here no more. 
 At first I thought I was out shopping with Marie, cos of all the people and cars and that, but then I remember I'm lost. 
 I'd like to stay lying down for a bit to make my headache go away, but I made a puddle on the pavement and I got to move. 
 I get up and lean against the window and sort of pat down my coat. 
 I'm all embarrassed cos my mac's all wet with the pee. 
 There's a big warm patch on the back. 
 My trousers and socks are wet too. 
 It's real embarrassing to wet yourself. 
 hate wetting myself like a baby. 
 I got to carry on. 
 I got to find Marie and get my trousers changed. 
 I hope she ain't far cos I really want to change my trousers and take off my mac. 
 It's stupid to wet yourself like a baby. 
 I want to go home. 
 I really do. 
 I stop these couple of young kids and ask them where my home is, but they just laugh at me. 
 They don't go off or nothing &mdash; they just stand there laughing like summat's real funny. 
 I dunno what they're laughing at, but I smile like I understand. 
 My head still hurts real bad, and I'm still a bit confused, but I pretend I understand. 
 I say thank you, and carry on. 
 I dunno if they told me the way &mdash; I can t remember, but I think it's this way. 
 Walking's real difficult now, and I have to stop every now and then to steady myself against a wall or a lamppost. 
 My legs feel real heavy. 
 The people walking past look like puppets, moving all quick and jerky. 
 All the traffic looks shiny like it's just rained, or they all been polished. 
 It looks kind of nice, but I don't stop and watch it. 
 I dunno, but there's summat scary about the cars and that. 
 It's like they're sharks or summat, or fish with these big white eyes looking for things to eat. 
 And they're real dangerous too &mdash; they might jump onto the pavement and swallow me up with their big eyes. 
 I don't want to go near them, so I walk right up against the shops, sort of leaning right against the windows so they won't get me. 
 It's so bright and noisy. 
 I dunno where I am. 
 It's like a fairground. 
 Maybe that's it. 
 All these kids and lights and noise, and it's sort of scary and exciting at the same time. 
 I dunno what all these people are doing. 
 Maybe summat special is happening and they're rushing to get there, cos they look real excited and busy and hurrying to get some place. 
 But their eyes scare me, how shiny they are. 
 And they don't look &mdash; you know, like they ain't really seeing. 
 Like a doll's eyes, or a pigeon's eyes. 
 They just rush on by. 
 I want to shut out the noise. 
 It's too much. 
 I want to put my hands over my ears, but I'm too tired. 
 I'm really, really tired. 
 Even if there was a fair I wouldn't go. 
 I just want to go to bed and get to sleep. 
 I got to be careful at the doorways, cos there's people coming in and out and a couple of times I nearly get knocked over by people bumping into me. 
 There's this doorway with no light on and I trip over summat and have to grab a hold of the side. 
 My head's spinning, so I just sort of lean there a bit and have a rest. 
 Summat's moving on the floor and I sort of watch it out the corner of my eye. 
 It's a dog I think, chewing on a bone or summat. 
 I'd give it a pat if I had the strength, cos I really like dogs, but I just turn my head and look at it instead. 
 Then I see it ain't a dog &mdash; it's a person. 
 They're all wrapped up in bits of cloth and lying on all this cardboard. 
 It's a woman I think &mdash; a young black woman with a woolly hat on. 
 She don't say nothing to me, she just looks at me with these big eyes. 
 Her look's kind of scary &mdash; I seen people at Combe Court like that. 
 They're the ones that's always shouting and chucking things and causing trouble. 
 I dunno why she's lying there. 
 Maybe she's ill or summat. 
 But I don't understand why she don't go home instead of lying on that cardboard. 
 It must be pretty uncomfortable sleeping like that, and I bet it's cold without no proper blankets and stuff like that. 
 I don't say nothing to her &mdash; I just stare at her a bit. 
 I know it ain't polite to stare, but she's doing it to me, and to tell the truth I'm so tired I can't move. 
 She looks like an animal lying down there. 
 Not a dog or nothing, you know, not an animal you keep in the house, but one in the wild, like a fox or summat. 
 It's like a little cave in there in the dark with her rags and her bits of cardboard &mdash; like a cave and she's an animal who lives there and is all scared and angry when someone comes in by accident. 
 I say I'm sorry for treading on her, but she just looks at me like she don't understand. 
 Maybe she's deaf or summat. 
 I turn round and go back onto the street and then have one last look at her. 
 She ain't moved. 
 She's still staring at me like an animal. 
 I dunno where all these people are going to. 
 Maybe they know summat cos they all look like they know where they're going. 
 All these faces sliding past me, all lit up in the light &mdash; it's like a dream. 
 All these faces. 
 Annie and Marie. 
 Mrs Seaton. 
 And Mum. 
 Why didn't she come and visit me? 
 Why not? 
 I wanted her to come and she never did. 
 She never did. 
 I must've spilt summat or maybe I trod in a puddle cos my trousers are all wet and cold. 
 I dunno where I am. 
 I think I'm going some place but I can't remember where. 
 Maybe I'm going to meet Marie &mdash; I can't remember. 
 The pavement's too crowded to walk on without bumping into people, so I step off and walk in the gutter. 
 There's all these people. 
 Hundreds and hundreds of them, and none of them know me. 
 All these hundreds of people with shiny eyes and they're all going home. 
 I've fell over again &mdash; I just can't stay on my feet. 
 It didn't hurt when I fell over cos the road's real soft and spongy. 
 Everything looks so high from here, and I'm all squashed and thin like I'm paper and people can walk over me and it wouldn't hurt and they wouldn't know I was there. 
 There's a fag end on the ground by my eye and I watch it for a bit. 
 Someone's chucked it down there and they've gone off and forgot it and they don't even know who I am. 
 They've just gone off somewhere and left it behind. 
 I'd like to stay here on the floor but there's cars beeping at me and I think I'm lying in the road, so I push myself up and sort of crawl to the pavement. 
 There's some people standing round watching me, but they don't give me a hand. 
 They just stand there looking at me. 
 When I get onto the pavement I just sit there with my feet in the road. 
 I don't feel too good. 
 I feel sort of sick. 
 Suddenly I start puking into the road, but nothing comes up except this slimy stuff. 
 It tastes horrible and I spit it out. 
 I puke again, but it's just like my tummy s being squeezed and all I do is make this coughing noise and nothing comes out. 
 My eyes feel all hot and my head's prickly like someone's pulled my hair. 
 I sit there for quite a bit, hunched up on the pavement. 
 I'm blummin freezing now &mdash; I can't stop shivering. 
 My teeth are chattering like mad. 
 I wish someone would come along and take me home. 
 My hat ain't on my head, and I look round for it. 
 I can't see it nowhere &mdash; it must have fell off someplace. 
 I'm real disappointed about that. 
 It was a nice hat, and Marie gave it to me, so it's extra special. 
 I feel on my head again, but it ain't there. 
 She bought that for me, Marie did, and now I've gone and lost it. 
 I dunno how long I sit there, I just sit there and sort of watch the cars go by. 
 I'm still shivering, but I don't puke up again. 
 I'm a bit dizzy when I stand up and have to hang onto this litter bin, but I'm OK after a bit. 
 I carry on walking down the street, careful not to bump into people so I don't fall over again. 
 Sometimes I got to stop and breathe deep cos I feel sick, but I don't puke up again. 
 I don't understand. 
 There's this bloke on top of this bus &mdash; you know, one of them big ones with no roof, and he's just shouting. 
 I can't understand what he's saying, but he's just shouting at the lights and everything, like he's real angry about summat. 
 The bus turns the corner and it gets stuck in some traffic for a bit and he just carries on shouting again and again. 
 I dunno why, but he is. 
 Again and again. 
 He's sort of waving one arm and hanging on with the other. 
 I dunno. 
 I just dunno. 
 It's like a bath, stepping into a hot bath of all these colours. 
 There's lights all across the road, from one side to the other. 
 Big stars and a Father Christmas and reindeer and it's all so bright just hanging over my head and stretching all down the road like a tunnel of hot colour all hanging in the sky so beautiful and magic. 
 I can't believe it. 
 I ain't never seen anything like it &mdash; all them colours and Father Christmas, huge, as big as a giant &mdash; all red and gold and glittery. 
 It's the most beautiful thing I ever seen. 
 And stretching all down the road, hundreds, millions of lights and colours. 
 I can't stop myself from laughing and clapping my hands. 
 This is where I been going to. 
 It's like church with the sun shining through them coloured windows and pictures of Jesus with light all round and angels floating in the sky and the sun shining and all that. 
 It just falls all over, all round me like a firework going off and floating down the sky. 
 I wish Marie and Annie was here so they could see it. 
 I look round for someone to show it to. 
 There's this man and woman walking by with lots of shopping bags and a little boy hanging on to his Dad's belt. 
 &bquo;Look!&equo; 
 I shout, pointing into the sky. 
 They all glance up quick and then back at me. 
 I say it again and the man looks at me a bit angry like. 
 I squat down next to the little kid and point again. 
 &bquo;Look at the lights!&equo; 
 He looks scared of me, and hangs even tighter on to his Dad's belt. 
 His Mum sort of turns him away and says summat foreign and they all walk off quick. 
 I try someone else, but they don't stop. 
 This old woman don't hear the first time, and when I say it again, she just says yes and walks away. 
 She just walks away. 
 I mean, she don't even look up at the lights. 
 Why don't they look? 
 Why don't people see how beautiful it is? 
 I don't understand. 
 The people slide past like fish and I'm sucked down the street, heading for the next and then the next set of lights. 
 When I'm under them, it's like standing in the sun. 
 It's all hot and bright and lovely. 
 And then the next lot of lights sucks me to it and I just slide down the street. 
 I'm just slipping down the hill being bumped by people but I don't hardly notice. 
 All there is, is this colour and more of it and more of it. 
 Then the lights just stop. 
 At the bottom of the hill, they just stop and it's a normal street. 
 I turn round and look back. 
 When I do that, it's like summat inside of me is pulled out and streaks back up the street, under all the lights, right round the corner to where I can't see. 
 I got to shut my eyes and turn round. 
 It's too beautiful to look at. 
 I carry on walking. 
 I don't look back or nothing. 
 It's so beautiful it's sort of scary &mdash; you know, feeling so excited at the lights. 
 But I wish Marie and Annie had seen them lights. 
 They would've understood. 
 They would've looked at the lights, I know. 
 But it's too late now. 
 They won't never see it. 
 They won't never know how beautiful it was. 
 It's just a normal shop window &mdash; you know, with lights on and these statues and that, but it's been done like it's someone's dining room. 
 There's a little pretend fire with red light flickering and a real Christmas tree with little fairy lights and stuff hanging from it. 
 There's prezzies all wrapped up under the tree, just like we used to have when I lived with Annie and Mum and Dad. 
 There's this big table with these people sat round it like they're having dinner &mdash; Mum, Dad and a little girl. 
 She ain't really the same as Annie. 
 Annie's much more pretty, but it's sort of like her &mdash; you know, about the same size and that. 
 They're all sitting round this table, like they're going to start eating any moment. 
 There's a wicker basket in the middle of the table and plates and glasses and stuff on the table. 
 I can see a bottle poking out the basket and there's a chicken too, all brown and cooked. 
 They're only statues &mdash; I know that &mdash; but they look really real, just like a real family sitting round a table just about to eat their Christmas lunch. 
 I stand looking in that window for ages. 
 I'd really like to be in there. 
 They all look so happy and warm like a real family, just like Annie and Mum and Dad. 
 I have a look round to see if Simon's there, but I can't see him. 
 Mum never lets Simon in the room when we're eating, so that's why. 
 He's probably locked in the kitchen, scratching at the door trying to get out. 
 I wish Marie was here to see them. 
 She'd be real surprised to see them all sat round the table looking so happy. 
 I got my nose pressed against the glass and it keeps steaming up with my huff, so I wipe it with my fingers. 
 I wish I was in there. 
 I wish I could sit at the table and help cut up Annie's food like I used to, and we'd have crackers and we'd wear those paper hats and have them little prezzies from inside the crackers. 
 And if I got summat Annie wanted &mdash; you know, like a little necklace or a whistle or summat, I'd just give it to her, and Mum would say what a polite boy I was, and Dad would smile at me, and we'd all be happy. 
 I spect Mrs Seaton's still in the kitchen. 
 She's probably heating up the mince pies so we can have them hot when we're sitting on the floor in front of the Christmas tree trying to guess what the wrapped up prezzies are. 
 The window keeps getting misty and I have to rub it so I can see through. 
 I wish they'd let me in. 
 I wish they would. 
 Annie's going to be in bed soon, and I ain't said goodnight to her. 
 Dad's going to carry her upstairs and tuck her into bed with her bunny hot water bottle, and leave her light on so she don't get scared in the dark. 
 I wish this window wouldn't keep getting steamy. 
 I rub it real hard. 
 It's making me annoyed. 
 They shouldn't have left me at school. 
 I didn't want to stay there and I didn't want to go to Combe Court, cos I hate it and it smells and the Captain slobbers in his food and Christmas is horrible with no good prezzies and Annie not there. 
 Why didn't you visit me? 
 Why not? 
 Why did Marie go away? 
 Why did she leave me like that? 
 Now I got no one. 
 I want to go home. 
 I don't want to stay out here. 
 I know I'm shouting, but I don't care if I'm being naughty. 
 I want to go home. 
 I bang on the glass with my fist. 
 Soft and then harder and harder. 
 I want to break the glass, but it's too thick. 
 I can't get in. 
 I start screaming and chucking myself against the window, but it won't break. 
 They won't let me in. 
 I run fast as I can at the window, but it still won't break. 
 It won't break. 
 There's a red smear on the window. 
 I can taste blood running down the back of my throat, then my arms are grabbed and everything just spins all colours and then black. 
 My fingers don't work too well. 
 They all wrapped up in white bandage stuff. 
 I think they're my fingers, but it's hard to tell. 
 I'm in bed with this blue blanket and my feet sticking up. 
 A girl's sitting next to me. 
 It's big here, like school. 
 My fingers are all white. 
 I'm warm and sleepy and there's this girl. 
 I dunno who she is. 
 &bquo;One more mouthful, then we're finished.&equo; 
 I dunno who this girl is. 
 She's wearing a white dress. 
 I think she might be a nurse, but I dunno where I am. 
 &bquo;Come on, Billy.&equo; 
 She's holding a spoon. 
 I look at her face. 
 She's got pretty eyes. 
 Like a cat's with the sun shining in them. 
 I like her eyes. 
 They're real pretty. 
 &bquo;Open your mouth, Billy.&equo; 
 My fingers are all bandaged up. 
 I must have hurt them, I reckon. 
 The girl pops a spoon in my mouth, and then scrapes at my chin. 
 &bquo;There's a good boy.&equo; 
 There's a girl sitting next to me. 
 I dunno what she's doing, but she's smiling real nice at me. 
 She's got pretty eyes. 
 &bquo;Now, what about a nice mince pie, Billy?&equo; 
 YOUR BODY CLOCK IN HEALTH 
 Our subject is the body clock; how it influences our physiology and behaviour and how it interacts with the rhythms in our environment. 
 In this part of the book we will attempt to answer the following questions: 
 &bull; What experimental evidence leads us to believe that we possess an internal body clock? &bull; What do we know about the rhythms that the clock controls. 
 &bull; Is the clock the same in all of us and at all stages of our lives? &bull; What do we know about the clock itself &mdash; where is it, what influences it, and how does it work? &bull; What is the usefulness of such a clock? 
 BODY RHYTHMS: INTERNAL AND EXTERNAL CAUSES 
 A rhythmic world 
 We live in a rhythmic world. 
 from early childhood we are all aware of the annual cycle of the season and its effect on nature, from the general sense of dormancy in the winter to the burst of light, warmth, colour, and activity in summer. 
 Every year we observe the changes in heat and length of daylight, the migrations of birds, the falling of leaves in Autumn, and the rebirth of plant and animal life in Spring. 
 These seasonal changes arise because our planet's axis is not vertical but tilted slightly. 
 As a result, as the Earth goes around the sun once every year, its two hemispheres alternate between receiving the sun's rays more directly (in summer) or obliquely (in winter). 
 In addition to these annual changes, there are daily ones and it is these and the responses of living organisms to them that are the subject of this book. 
 The distinction between night and day is one of the most pervasive rhythms that we experience. 
 The Earth spins on its axis, exposing us to, and hiding us from, the light of the Sun. 
 The time taken to complete one revolution of the Earth is decreasing over aeons of time but at the moment it is, give or take the odd second, 24 hours; this defines the solar day. 
 Many aspects of our environment show a rhythm with a period of 24 hours as a result of this solar day. 
 Thus the periods of lighting, heating, mixing of the water in inland lakes, and the existence of on-shore or off-shore winds all have a value of 24 hours and are caused by the daily spinning of the Earth and the apparent movement of the Sun that this produces. 
 But it is not only the Sun which appears to orbit the Earth. 
 The Moon does also, and it can exert a more powerful effect where tides are concerned. 
 The Moon and everything that is on our planet's surface mutually attract each other. 
 Thus, two huge &bquo;bulges&equo; of water appear in the oceans, one facing towards the Moon and another facing away from it. 
 These bulges are the cause of our high tides. 
 Because the Moon revolves around the Earth, the lunar day &mdash; the time it takes for the Moon to appear at equal heights above the horizon on successive occasions &mdash; is longer than 24 hours. 
 It is about 24 hours 50 mins. 
 Thus with respect to solar time, the tides get later each day. 
 Only occupants of the deep oceans or the darkest recesses of caves will escape such rhythmic influences and live instead in a world where the passage of daily time has no obvious consequence and where tides have no effect. 
 Even here, some annual changes might be seen such as the amount of detritus that showers down from the ocean surface or the species of animal sheltering in the cave. 
 Rhythmic responses in living organisms 
 It is not only the environment but also the animals and plants that inhabit it that display rhythms. 
 This can be seen most clearly when considering their behaviour. 
 Many animals are diurnal &mdash; that is they are active in the daytime and inactive at night &mdash; whereas nocturnal creatures show the opposite orientation. 
 In addition, particularly in hotter regions, there are animals that are active about the times of dawn and dusk when it is not too hot or cold. 
 We are all aware to some degree of the daily rhythms of nature around us. 
 Few people have not woken to the sounds of the dawn chorus nor seen moths drawn to artificial lights as daylight fades. 
 Birds become quieter in the afternoon, while butterflies and other insects are more active, feeding on the opened flowers. 
 At twilight, mosquitos and midges appear and then, as darkness falls, nocturnal creatures such as hedgehogs, owls, and bats take over. 
 Flowering plants also respond to their environment as shown by the charming example of Linneaus, flower clock (Table 1.1). 
 Their responses affect the habits of nectar-seeking insects and the type of pollen that is being spread at a particular time of day. 
 If the day is sunny, as drying proceeds, clouds of wind-borne seeds will be released or pods will open, often scattering their contents explosively. 
 Table 1.1 Linnaeus's Flower Clock 
 0600 spotted Cat's Ear opens 0700 African Marigold opens 0800 Mouse Ear Hawkweed opens 0900 Prickly Sowthistle closes 1000 Common Nipple Wort closes 1100 Star of Bethlehem opens 1200 Passion Flower opens 1300 Childing Pink closes 1400 Scarlet Pimpernel closes 1500 Hawkbit closes 1600 Small Bindweed closes 1700 White Water Lily closes 1800 Evening Primrose opens 
 Carolus Linnaeus (1707&ndash;1780) 
 Humans are normally diurnal, but we are not as immutable as plants or other animals. 
 Some of us have to work at night and sleep during the day. 
 The developments of artificial light and packaged food have enabled us to develop a certain independence from the natural environment. 
 Even so, reasons of convenience generally result in our synchronizing our times of sleep, leisure, and meals, and night workers often adopt a &bquo;normal&equo; timing for their life-style during their rest days. 
 Accepting that we respond to our environment, whether it is natural or artificial, we can see that these responses appear to produce further changes in us. 
 We are just under one inch taller on getting up in the morning than we are on going to bed at night. 
 This is because, during sleep, our spine no longer needs to support the weight of our body. 
 Therefore, fluid passes into the discs between our vertebrae, causing them to swell slightly and this makes us taller. 
 When we get up, the weight of our bodies compresses these discs and squeezes out the extra fluid. 
 Normally half of this &bquo;extra&equo; height is lost in the first hour after waking but, if exercise is taken on waking, then the loss of height is more rapid. 
 These results suggest that our rhythm of sleeping and being awake &mdash; in turn a response to our rhythmic environment &mdash; causes the changes in our height. 
 Support for this idea comes from the following observations. 
 &bull; If sleep is taken during the daytime, then height is gained in the same way as during a normal night. 
 &bull; If you stay awake at night and do not lie down, the increase in height does not occur. 
 Other animals and plants also show physiological and bio-chemical changes that appear to result from the organisms&equo; responses to their environment. 
 Is this the whole story? 
 Is a living creature rhythmic wholly because it is driven by a rhythmic environment and life-style? 
 Rhythms do not result only from our habit and environment 
 To answer this kind of question, detailed measurements of physiological or biochemical processes are required. 
 Two examples are shown in Fig. 1.1. 
 Body temperature is higher in the daytime than at night, and urine flow is lower overnight. 
 Could these rhythms also reflect our environment and life-style? 
 To some extent, this is indeed the case. 
 Higher body temperatures in the daytime could be the result of our greater activity when it is light, with muscle effort producing the increased heat. 
 In addition, environmental daytime temperatures would be higher, and heat loss from our body would be more difficult, whilst heat gain from the sun would be greater. 
 All these factors are reversed at night when we are asleep and inactive in a cooler and less interesting environment, and body temperature would fall as a result. 
 A similar argument can be applied to urine production except that the emphasis, would be on fluid intake. 
 Thus, at night, urine flow would be low because we cannot drink when we are asleep, and in the daytime our kidneys would respond to an increased fluid intake. 
 Experience, however, indicates that, unlike the case of height, these rhythms do not result wholly from our life-style and the environment. 
 Consider the following examples. 
 &bull; With regard to thermal comfort (whether we think our environment is too hot or too cold), a particular room temperature might make us feel cold and even shiver in the morning but in the evening the same room temperature will sometimes feel hot and stuffy. 
 &bull; When the activity of our kidneys is considered, a bed-time drink does not waken us by filling our bladders during the night, whereas a similar drink in the daytime causes urine flow to increase quite rapidly. 
 &bull; After a flight to a new time zone our life-style can become muddled. 
 We cannot sleep at the new night time, we feel tired during the daytime (at a time corresponding to night in the time zone we have just left), and our appetite is upset. 
 &bull; If we work at night, and have to try to sleep during the daytime, we have difficulty in adjusting our habits in spite of having an &bquo;active&equo; environment at night and a quiet, sleep-conducive environment (a quiet, darkened bedroom) during the daytime. 
 All these examples suggest that there is something else, over and above a response of the body to our life-style and environment. 
 A clue as to what this might be comes from our personal experience if we attempt to miss a night's sleep and stay up all night (fig 1.2). 
 In this circumstance we feel more tired as the evening and the night wear on. 
 This is intuitively what we would expect and we would say that it was due to a lack of sleep. 
 In practice, however, from about 5 o'clock in the morning onwards changes occur that cannot be explained in this way. 
 During the latter part of the night, in spite of having had no sleep, feelings of fatigue begin to diminish. 
 Indeed, by about the middle of the morning we feel surprisingly alert &mdash; we might even not bother with sleep after all &mdash; and we appear to have overcome the effects of a lost night &bquo;s sleep. 
 By contrast, later the next evening, we will find that our fatigue increases very markedly and we will feel much more tired than on the previous evening. 
 That is, in addition to the tendency to feel tired because we have been awake a long time, there is some rhythmic change that decreases our fatigue at some times and increases it at others. 
 Observations such as these suggest that there are rhythmic changes in our bodies that are produced by some internal factor in addition to those produced by our environment and life-style. 
 In practice we distinguish between the external cause of a rhythm, which is caused by our life-style or environment, and another internal cause, which we might say is due to a clock within our body. 
 The rhythms we shall consider in this book all consist of a mixture of internal and external causes. 
 (In the example of body height given above, the internal cause of the rhythm is unusually small.) 
 We shall consider their importance to us and how they are produced by combinations of our body clock, life-style and the environment. 
 Separating the internal and external causes of body rhythms 
 Having established that body rhythms are a mixture of internal and external causes, we need to have some experimental means by which we can measure the contribution of each to the total rhythm. 
 This can be achieved by use of a constant routine, experiment. 
 The aim of this experiment is to study individuals under circumstances in which the external causes of rhythms are removed. 
 First, we must make the environment constant and study individuals in constant lighting, humidity, and temperature. 
 Second, we must keep the life-style constant. 
 To achieve this, individuals remain awake and seated for a full 24 hours (the time for the rhythm to show a full cycle) and the way they spend their time is as constant as possible. 
 Time is passed by reading, writing, listening to music, playing cards, doing jigsaws, etc. 
 Meals also have to be modified so that they do not produce a rhythmic input to the body. 
 One way is to arrange that an identical snack is taken every 5 hours throughout the day and night. 
 In our experiments, subjects had to be more heroic since they had an identical &bquo;snack&equo; of milk, salt solution, a plain biscuit, and orange squash every hour &mdash; a way of ensuring an adequate but non-rhythmic intake of fluid and salts during the experiment. 
 Such &bquo;constant routines&equo; remove all external rhythms since both the environment and the life-style of the individuals have been constant throughout the 24 hours. 
 What happens to the daily rhythms under such circumstances? 
 Two examples are shown in fig. 1.3. 
 This figure shows that daily rhythms are less marked but show a similar pattern (that is, general shape and timing) when measured in the absence of external rhythms. 
 The rhythm that persists in such constant routines must be caused internally and it is produced by the body clock. 
 In addition, the differences we see between the rhythm measured normally and under constant routine conditions must be due to external causes (rhythms in our life-style and environment). 
 Not only does this result confirm that the rhythm we measure under normal circumstances (in fig. 1.1, for example) has an external as well as an internal cause but also it enables us to compare their size. 
 Thus the two causes appear to be of a similar size in the case of body temperature (Fig. 1.3, top) but the internal cause in the case of urinary flow (Fig. 1.3, bottom) is rather smaller, with daytime and night-time values on the constant routine being more similar. 
 The &bquo;constant routine&equo; experiment also tells us one other important fact about the two causes of our rhythms; that normally they are similarly timed. 
 For example, during the daytime the internal clock as well as our life-style and environment raise body temperature and the urinary removal of water. 
 At night our internal clock, sleep, and our inactive environment act together to decrease temperature and urinary loss. 
 Unfortunately for us, internal and external causes do not always co-operate. 
 Examples would be night-workers or in travellers who have arrived recently from other continents. 
 This mismatching of the two causes of a rhythm can produce difficulties and these will be considered in detail in Chapters 10 and 12. 
 &bquo;Larks&equo; and &bquo;Owls&equo; &mdash; the interaction between internal and external causes 
 Although people are equal in that they possess in common many rhythms, composed of external and internal causes, there are also differences between them. 
 Some of the best known are the differences between &bquo;larks&equo; and &bquo;owls&equo;. 
 &bquo;Larks&equo; are morning people who tend to wake up and get up early in the day. 
 They welcome the new day and tend to feel at their best at about noon or earlier. 
 Evenings are their weakest time since they soon begin to feel fatigued and want to go to sleep relatively early. 
 The evening people, or &bquo;owls&equo;, tend to be the opposite in all of these matters. 
 They stay up late, are slow to get going in the morning, and seem to gain in strength as the day wears on. 
 By the evening they are still full of energy when the early risers wilt. 
 It would be misleading, however, to think of everybody as a &bquo;lark&equo; or &bquo;owl&equo;. 
 There is a wide range between the two extremes, and most people can be defined as &bquo;intermediate&equo;. 
 A brief test at the end of this chapter has been designed to give some idea of how much of a &bquo;lark&equo; or &bquo;owl&equo; you are. 
 Why are some of us &bquo;larks&equo; and others &bquo;owls'? 
 Is it a function of our body clock or our life-style, or due to some interaction between the two? 
 Just as we differ in mental and physical characteristics, so too do we differ when the detailed properties of our body clock are considered. 
 There is evidence that the body clock of &bquo;larks&equo; runs faster than average, so that there is a tendency for the clock to wake them up earlier &mdash; and make them feel tired earlier. 
 The &bquo;owls&equo; have clocks that run slower than average so that later bedtimes and a tendency to &bquo;lie-in&equo; are more likely. 
 In addition, &bquo;lark&equo; and &bquo;owl&equo; characteristics can be created by circumstances. 
 Thus, those whose work necessitates an early start (for example, farmers, bakers, some factory workers, and long-distance commuters) will routinely time their life-style (retiring, rising, and meal times) earlier than average and their environment &mdash; when it is dark or light, noisy or quiet &mdash; will be adjusted to match. 
 By contrast, some sections of the community (for example, students, disc jockeys, and casino croupiers) plan their life-styles and environment to be much later than average. 
 Often such a life-style &mdash; and, with it, the timing of daily rhythms &mdash; continues into retirement due to habit rather than need. 
 Whether we are a &bquo;lark&equo; or an &bquo;owl&equo; can depend upon the properties of our individual body clock as well as the timing of our life-style. 
 Sometimes the two reinforce each other. 
 Thus an &bquo;owl&equo; will often pursue his hobbies or interests late into the night so that his preferred life-style will accentuate the natural tendency of his clock. 
 By contrast, &bquo;larks&equo; might tend to avoid late-night parties in favour of early morning exercise: a matching of their chosen life-style and the properties of their body clock. 
 It might be imagined that an individual with a &bquo;lark'-like clock but an &bquo;owl'-like life-style or vice versa would have difficulties. 
 This is indeed the case and will be covered when shift-work is considered in Chapter 12. 
 Now try this: 1. 
 Are you a &bquo;lark&equo; or an &bquo;owl'? 
 For each of the following questions choose the most appropriate answer. 
 Do not cross-check your answers . 
 (The questions are based on a fuller questionnaire by Horne J. A. and Ostberg O. (1976). 
 Int.  
 J. Chronobiol.  4, 97&ndash;110). 
 1. 
 What time would you choose to get up if you were free to plan your day? 
 A 0500&ndash;0600 B 0600&ndash;0730 C 0730&ndash;1000 D 1000&ndash;1100 E 1100&ndash;1200 
 2. 
 You have some important business to attend to, for which you want to feel at the peak of your mental powers. 
 When would you prefer this meeting to take place? 
 A 0800&ndash;1000 B 1100&ndash;1300 C 1500&ndash;1700 D 1900&ndash;2100 
 3. 
 What time would you choose to go to bed if you were entirely free to plan your evening? 
 A 2000&ndash;2100 B 2100&ndash;2215 C 2215&ndash;0030 D 0030&ndash;0145 E 0145&ndash;0300 
 4. 
 A friend wishes to go jogging with you. 
 She/he suggests starting at 0700&ndash;0800. 
 How would you feel at this time? 
 A On good form B On reasonable form C You would find it difficult D You would find it very difficult 
 5. 
 You now have some physical work to do. 
 At what time would you feel able to do it best? 
 A 0800&ndash;1000 B 1100&ndash;1300 C 1500&ndash;1700 D 1900&ndash;2100 
 6. 
 You have to go to bed at 2300. 
 How would you feel? 
 A Not at all tired, unable to get to sleep quickly B A little tired, unlikely to get to sleep quickly C Fairly tired, likely to get to sleep quickly D Very tired, very likely to get to sleep quickly 
 7. 
 When you have been up for half an hour on a normal working day, how do you feel? 
 A Very tired B Fairly tired C Fairly refreshed D Very refreshed 
 8. 
 At what time of the day do you feel best? 
 A 0800&ndash;1000 B 1100&ndash;1300 C 1500&ndash;1700 D 1900&ndash;2100 
 9. 
 Another friend suggests jogging at 2200&ndash;2300. 
 How would you now feel? 
 A On good form B On reasonable form C You would find it difficult D You would find it very difficult 
 Now, score your answers. 
 Add up the points for the 9 questions: 
 Q.1 A=1 Q.2 A=1 Q.3 A=1 B=2 B=2 B=2 C=3 C=3 C=3 D=4 D=4 D=4 E=5 E=5 
 Q.4 A=1 Q.5 A=1 Q.6 A=4 B=2 B=2 B=3 C=3 C=3 C=2 D=4 D=4 D=1 
 Q.7 A=4 Q.8 A=1 Q.9 A=4 B=3 B=2 B=3 C=2 C=3 C=2 D=1 D=4 D=1 
 Interpreting your score 
 Your score can range from 9 to 38. 
 This is only a guide, of course, but your score can be interpreted as follows: 9&ndash;15 Definitely a lark 16&ndash;20 Moderately a lark 21&ndash;26 Neither a lark nor an owl; intermediate type 27&ndash;31 Moderately an owl 32&ndash;38 Definitely an owl 
 Most of you will score between 21&ndash;26. 
 SOME PROPERTIES OF THE BODY CLOCK 
 Even though the role of the body clock as the internal cause of a rhythm can be investigated after removing external causes by performing a constant routine for 24 hours, this only enables us to assess the effects of the clock over a single cycle of the rhythm. 
 in order to get a better estimate of how accurately the clock works we need to be able to study it for much longer periods of time. 
 This suggests that we need to perform an experiment in which volunteers remain on a constant routine for as many days as possible. 
 Not surprisingly, such experiments are rare! 
 A Swedish study went some way towards achieving this aim by using soldier &bquo;volunteers&equo; and keeping them awake for about 72 hours in a constant environment. 
 They performed a series of tests and took an identical snack every 3 hours throughout the study. 
 The results showed that rhythms with a period of about 24 hours continued and this confirmed the activity of the body clock during the experiment (fig 2.1). 
 As the experiment wore on, however, there was clear evidence that loss of sleep was beginning to dominate the results, there being a progressive increase in fatigue and decrease in the speed of shooting at a target. 
 We cannot be sure of how to interpret the results. 
 Do they result from the body clock, from sleep loss &mdash; or from some mixture of these factors? 
 In addition, investigating only three cycles of the body clock is still inadequate if we are to determine its properties in any detail &mdash; and a longer experiment is not feasible. 
 A different type of experiment is required. 
 Studying the body clock for extended periods of time 
 Consider the following experimental design for a volunteer studied on his own. 
 He is instructed to go to bed when he feels tired, to get up when he feels rested, and to eat meals when he estimates that it is breakfast, lunch, and dinner time. 
 Snacks (elevenses, tea, supper) and any (indoor) exercise can also be taken when desired. 
 The choice of food and the way to spend the waking hours are entirely at the discretion of the volunteer. 
 The &bquo;catch&equo; is that, even though the time when something is done is decided by the volunteer, he has no cues from clocks , television, or other humans as to what the time really is. 
 The experimenters keep a record of what the volunteer does and, by means of a hidden clock, when he does it. 
 Because there are no constraints placed upon the timing of the volunteer's activities in such a time-free environment, these are called free-running experiments and the rhythms measured during them are known as free-running rhythms. 
 What happens? 
 Do individuals lose all sense of time and become erratic, or do they maintain a rhythmicity in their lifestyle and bodily functions? 
 Individuals do not become random in their habits. 
 Their rhythms of body temperature and the elimination of materials in the urine, and whether they are asleep or awake and active, (the sleep/wake cycle), all continue. 
 This is shown in fig. 2.2 in the case of a free-running experiment lasting nearly four weeks. 
 Notice that the times of waking become a little later each day and this indicates that the cycle length is greater than 24 hours, about 25 hours in the case shown. 
 In spite of such an unexpected result, it is important to see that the general pattern is very regular and to remember that, as far as the volunteer is concerned, he gets up at the &bquo;normal&equo; time each &bquo;morning&equo; to be ready for a full day ahead of him. 
 (for the moment, the important point to be gained from these results is that the maintenance of rhythms, in the absence of external information about time, confirms the presence of an internal body clock. 
 The significance of the clock running slow with a cycle length of 25 rather than 24 hours will be considered later). 
 Before continuing with our main theme there are a few points that may need clarifying. 
 The first is how is a time-free environment found in order to perform these experiments? 
 Time-free environments 
 One possibility is to perform experiments in the relatively constant conditions that exist near the poles. 
 In summer the sun does not set and so there is no alternation of day or night to give cues as to the passage of time. 
 There are also likely to be few time-cues from animals or other humans &mdash; such as tourists. 
 The continuous darkness of the winter time could be made use of, but this has been less attractive both to volunteers and experimenters. 
 Such an environment is free of time-cues but is inhospitable because of its climate. 
 There are also potential problems if emergencies arise, or if there is failure of the monitoring apparatus &mdash; in sub-zero temperatures this is a real possibility. 
 One advantage of such a site, however, is that samples of blood and urine that are required for analysis of rhythms are readily refrigerated so that deterioration is less of a problem than in other environments. 
 A second time-free environment is provided by underground caves. 
 In these there is no penetration of natural daylight and the only sounds are those of running and dripping water. 
 Volunteers have stayed alone in such environments for more than nine months. 
 Clearly they are easier &bquo;laboratories&equo; to reach, and far less dangerous than the poles with regard to climate and the hazards of survival. 
 Even so, they are uncomfortable and unpleasantly damp and dark, and the need for artificial lighting and heating can produce fumes that make the situation inconvenient. 
 The third, and preferred, method is to build an isolation unit, specially constructed for such experiments. 
 (We stress that &bquo;isolation&equo; in this context implies isolation from time-cues in the environment rather than sensory deprivation.) 
 The first one was built in Germany and later, in 1968, the one we use was built in Manchester. 
 Subsequently several others have appeared in different countries which differ in the sophistication of their construction and the experimental measurements that can be made. 
 Ours is now described in a little more detail (see fig. 2.3). 
 The inner chamber is designed so that up to four volunteers can be accommodated in modest comfort (though, as already mentioned, free-running experiments are performed on one volunteer only). 
 There are areas for sleep (bunk beds), leisure (easy chairs), and eating (table and dining chairs) as well as for food preparation and washing up. 
 Separated from the main living area are a toilet, shower, and wash basin. 
 We have found that volunteers have no difficulty in living in such a unit, either alone or in groups of up to four. 
 By now, over 250 volunteers (mostly university students) have taken part in our experiments, the duration of which varies from 12 to 22 days. 
 Leisure time can be spent as an individual wishes. 
 Often music is played, though writing letters, playing cards or chess, and even (occasionally!) revision for examinations are all activities that can be carried out. 
 Radio and television cannot be allowed; newspapers can be delivered &mdash; but always slightly out-of-date and at random intervals so that no cues as to the passage of outside time are given. 
 The whole isolation chamber is housed inside an outer building and is mounted on rubber blocks so that vibration from traffic etc. does not reach the volunteers. 
 The outer building contains a plant room which supplies and keeps constant the air supply, its humidity and temperature. 
 The electricity supply is also regulated so that &bquo;surges&equo; in the National Grid &mdash; which may accompany the beginning or end of certain television programmes and so affect domestic lighting and identify the passage of time &mdash; are smoothed over. 
 The outer building is also an area where recording apparatus can be housed and where the experimenters can monitor the progress of the experiment by closed-circuit television. 
 Provided that volunteers are not allowed a watch and that they do not use television or radio then they are in an environment which combines some of the comforts of home with the more exacting requirements of free-running experiments. 
 There is also the possibility of making many more measurements in such a laboratory than in experiments at the poles or in caves. 
 It is reassuring to know that experiments performed in these three rather different time-free environments have all given results like those shown in Fig. 2.2. 
 Alternatives to the concept of a body clock 
 Another major problem that we must consider is the possibility that the continuing rhythmicity is not due to the body clock. 
 Two alternative explanations, and our comments on them, follow. 
 1. 
 The rhythm is responding to an external influence that has not been controlled in the experimental protocol. 
 The problem is to decide what such an influence might be. 
 The influences upon humans of the planets, moon, and factors such as magnetic fields, atmospheric pressure, and cosmic rays have been imagined by some, including lovers, astrologers and those who, in the past, have diagnosed types of &bquo;lunacy&equo;. 
 Unfortunately, when such influences are considered as explanations of the results of free-running experiments, the following problems have never been satisfactorily dealt with. 
 &bull; Why do individuals have free-running rhythms that differ in length? 
 Even though the average value is 25 hours (see p. 25), individuals show values generally within the range 24&ndash;26 hours. 
 (As suggested in Chapter 1, &bquo;larks&equo; tend to be at the lower end of the range and &bquo;owls&equo; towards the top of it.) &bull; Where are the sense organs that pick up such external factors? 
 There is evidence for a magnetic sense in some animals, including humans. 
 However, its role in influencing these rhythms &mdash; let alone actually being responsible for them &mdash; is not at all established. 
 Sense organs for lunar and planetary influences, for atmospheric pressure and cosmic rays are as yet purely hypothetical. 
 2. 
 The results are due to a regular structuring of an individual's life-style; they are a reflection of the regularity of our habits rather than of some body clock. 
 There is much to be said for such a theory. 
 There is no doubt that individuals tend to structure their day around routines of meals, personal hygiene, leisure, work, etc. 
 There are, however, some problems with this theory. 
 &bull; It is not clear how the duration of sleep could be controlled as regularly as is observed to be the case. 
 Even though it might be argued that a regular life-style implies a regular degree of fatigue and so will require a regular amount of sleep, in practice, such a degree of regularity is not achieved. 
 Individuals go to bed later or earlier than average on certain occasions, as can be seen by close inspection of Fig. 2.2. 
 For example, an individual might go to bed later than usual on one occasion because a piece of work or some leisure time activity took longer than normal. 
 It is likely that this will make him more tired than usual and so we might guess that he will sleep longer. 
 This would result in his rhythms running more slowly when he was interested and more quickly when he was bored (because he would go to bed earlier due to the lack of something interesting to do and so require less sleep). 
 This idea &mdash; that longer activity spans would be followed by longer sleeps and vice versa &mdash; does not find experimental support. 
 The reverse is seen: long &bquo;daytimes&equo; tend to be followed by shorter sleeps and vice versa. 
 (Consider days 7 and 11 in Fig. 2.2, for example). 
 This is a result that is much easier to account for if we suggest that a body clock is responsible for the alternation between sleep and activity. 
 Such a clock will wake an individual when a certain stage of the sleep/wake cycle is reached; if he goes to bed late then that stage will be reached after a shorter period of sleep than usual. 
 Such is the experience of most of us when we go to bed late: we might sleep slightly later than usual but rarely long enough to compensate completely for the late night. 
 Our body clock has woken us for the next day after only a minimal opportunity for extra sleep. 
 &bull; When all results from the free-running experiments are considered, the sleep/wake cycle is about 25 hours. 
 If it were due to some &bquo;memory&equo; of our life-style then we would predict that about half the population would show a value less than 24 hours and the free-running periods of individuals would be distributed fairly symmetrically about an average value of 24 hours. 
 We have stressed the regularity that is observed in free-running experiments and interpreted it as evidence for the body clock. 
 However, we should add that, particularly when experiments lasting several months are performed, certain irregularities do creep into the results. 
 Occasionally sleep is missed, or is twice as long as usual. 
 Sometimes volunteers alternate between normal and long sleeps (lasting 16 rather than 8 hours, for example) or even appear to adopt a sleep/wake cycle that lasts about 50 rather than 25 hours. 
 In such circumstances, rhythms of food intake also can become irregular with missed or extra meals during the course of a single &bquo;day&equo;. 
 However, the rhythm of body temperature generally retains its regular 25 hour period. 
 These results do not require us to dispense with the idea of an internal body clock, if only because they appear very rarely in experiments lasting only a week or so. 
 (By contrast, the 25-hour rhythms are regularly seen). 
 Instead the results suggest that the system requires an occasional rhythmic input from the outside world to run smoothly. 
 The alternatives to an internal body clock (planetary influences, cosmic rays, etc.) do not offer a ready explanation of these irregularities. 
 Adjusting the body clock 
 Even if it is accepted that there is now overwhelming evidence that we possess a body clock, it will appear to have little use. 
 It tends to run with a period different from that of a solar day! 
 Indeed it is this inaccuracy that leads to its often being called a circadian clock (from the latin, circa  &mdash; about; diem  &mdash; a day) If it is correctly timed one day, it will be approximately 1 hour late the next, about 2 hours late the day after that, and so on until it will be &bquo;useful&equo; again after about 3 weeks. 
 This idea can be readily appreciated when the rising times of the volunteer in Fig 2.2. are considered. 
 With reference to real, external time, by day 9 of the experiment he was acting like a night-worker, even though he always go up at what he called 0800 and then ate breakfast. 
 By day 22 he was getting up at the &bquo;correct&equo; time (that is, his morning and real morning coincided), but had lost a whole day. 
 Clearly this is unhelpful. 
 Equally clearly, this is not what really happens since, if it were, rhythms would be observed to be timed irregularly when different individuals were compared. 
 This is not so and we stress that the results in Fig. 1.1 are routinely found. 
 The daily body rhythms are timed similarly in different individuals, and in the same individual on different days, with regular differences of only a few hours between the timing of, say, the body temperature rhythm in &bquo;larks&equo; and &bquo;owls&equo;, for example. 
 How is this adjustment achieved? 
 Consider how any watch or clock is adjusted. 
 We set it by comparing it with some reference time. 
 This might be a radio or television programme or some natural phenomenon, for example when the sun or another star reaches its highest point in the sky. 
 In fact the early mechanical clocks were adjusted by comparing them with sundials. 
 (Nowadays, the use of celestial bodies for setting clocks is not widespread &mdash; a measure of how &bquo;unnatural&equo; our life-style has become.) 
 The same principle is made use of by plants and animals, including man, when they adjust their body clock. 
 The external reference that is used is the timing of one or more rhythms in the environment. 
 The rhythm that is made use of depends upon the type of environment, the organism, and the period that the body clock will be adjusted to. 
 Since the environmental rhythm is giving a time-cue to the organism it is called a zeitgeber  (from the German, Zeit &mdash; time; geber &mdash; to give). 
 Some time-cues affecting animals and plants are given in Table 2.1. 
 Mention must be made of those creatures that inhabit the inter-tidal zone, that is the region of the shore between high- and low-tides. 
 Their life-style is dominated by the tides rather than the sun and they are adjusted to the tidal, not the solar, day. 
 The important role of the environment in modifying behaviour, the external cause, has already been described. 
 Clearly, there will be a wide overlap between the role of the environment in contributing to this external cause of a rhythm, its effect upon an organism's behaviour, and its ability to adjust the body clock. 
 Time-cues in humans 
 Humans are bound to be special cases, since they are more independent of the natural environment than are plants and other animals and this is an area which is not yet fully understood. 
 Humans are synchronized to a 24-hour cycle, however, and so time-cues must exist, albeit often artificial ones. 
 In practice, the sleep/wake cycle seems to exert an important effect upon many of our daily rhythms and the timing of many of them is determined by the time of mid-sleep or the middle of our waking hours. 
 That is not to say that sleep or being awake are the only time-cues of importance to humans. 
 What is likely to apply for most of us is the following scenario. 
 There is a whole social structure associated with our life-style. 
 There are times when it is convenient for us to go to sleep (the shops are not open, etc.) and when it is expected that we will not be noisy. 
 While sleeping at night we fast and are exposed to a quiet, dark environment. 
 Waking in the morning is again normally imposed upon us by social factors &mdash; the need to get to work, to do shopping, to fulfil appointments, etc. 
 Thus, structuring our times of sleep necessarily affects our times of food intake and activity and when we are exposed to light and an active environment. 
 Under normal circumstances, the time-cues come as a package and is not particularly useful to separate out any one from the group; all play a role and act in harmony to adjust our daiLy rhythms. 
 Describing our time-cues in this way acknowledges that independence from the natural environment has been achieved. 
 Unlike plants and animals we do not have to go to bed with the sun or to get up at each high tide; our man-made environment is based on a 24-hour solar day of course, but it need not be timed to coincide with sunrise or sunset. 
 Indeed, the exact timing we choose will depend upon social and work factors and the comments made earlier about &bquo;larks&equo; and &bquo;owls&equo; will be pertinent here. 
 For students, there is a tendency to socialize in the evenings; therefore bedtimes and rising times are fairly late. 
 for those who must start work early in the morning (for example, bakers or farmers who have to deal with livestock), their life-style requires them to be active earlier. 
 for those working in, or frequenting, nightclubs and casinos, their personal time-cues are particularly late. 
 Extreme examples exist when night-workers are considered, but these produce special problems that will be dealt with later. 
 Individuals will also vary in the importance they attach to a particular time-cue. 
 For example, blind people will be unable to use light/dark changes and so will have to make more use of a regular sleep/wake rhythm or of social commitments. 
 Some people who have fewer external commitments (single, unemployed, or self-employed individuals, for example) might make less use of normal time-cues and their rhythms might even come closer to a 25-hour free-running period. 
 When extra commitments &mdash; particular meetings, examinations, or tutorials, for example &mdash; come round then such a life-style has to be modified. 
 To some extent the majority of us behave in this way. 
 At the weekends, we are no longer constrained by the timetable of our weekdays and we may have a fuller social life in the evening. 
 Bearing in mind also that our body clock tends to run slow at the weekend, we will tend to have later nights and lie-ins, all of which cause a slight delay of our body clock. 
 The problem begins on Sunday night when we have to go to bed early (by body time) and so we will have some difficulty in getting to sleep. 
 The next morning we will be woken &bquo;early&equo; by the alarm and may experience &bquo;Monday morning blues&equo;. 
 This fairly common phenomenon stresses the interaction that normally takes place between our body clock, our social commitments, and time-cues. 
 Whilst we stress the artificial nature of most time-cues, it would be misleading to suggest that natural light is without effect. 
 We and our daily rhythms can respond to bright light and an appropriate use of this may become part of our armoury for speeding up adjustment of the body clock after a time-zone transition. 
 for those living near the poles, where such a daily cycle is missing, other artificial time-cues must be adhered to instead. 
 Unfortunately, such people have not had their daily rhythms studied in detail and so we do not know the time-cues that are important to them. 
 Now try this &mdash; 2. 
 How strong are your time-cues? 
 The need for time-cues to produce a body clock with a stable 24-hour period has already been described. 
 The diary below is one way to establish how regular are the rhythms in your life-style and environment. 
 Fill in a log (like the example given below) every hour over the course of a &bquo;typical week&equo;. 
 Mark whenever an option applies. 
 Fill in separately the three categories of activity, lighting and food. 
 Scoring the log 
 One easy way is to calculate the percentage of possible occasions when a particular activity or environmental condition applies. 
 Do this for each hour of the day and do it separately for activity, lighting, meals, and drinks. 
 Examples of this kind of analysis as applied to the types of activity are shown below (Fig. 2.4) for: 
 &bull; a person on a normal routine working in the daytime; &bull; a night-worker; &bull; somebody with a very irregular life-style; &bull; a new-born baby; &bull; a watchkeeper on a merchant ship. 
 We will refer back to these examples later in the book. 
 Adjusting your body clock 
 Sometimes we want to change the timing of our life-style. 
 For example, after a series of late nights and lie-ins (holidays for example), it might be time to get back to our normal hours of work; alternatively, on retirement, a lifetime of early morning rising can be altered. 
 Our body clock as well as our habits will need modification. 
 We know that our clock is normally adjusted by various external factors &mdash; and now we can use them to help us adjust to a change in life-style. 
 In later sections we will consider how to adjust our body clocks to much larger shifts &mdash; as after a time-zone transition or during nightwork, for example. 
 Becoming less of an &bquo;owl&equo; or more of a &bquo;lark' 
 This is a likely problem after holidays or long weekends; you do not feel tired at the new bedtime but do feel tired when it is time to get up. 
 A solution is to make the following adjustments and stick to them for a few days while the body clock follows the lead given by your altered life-style. 
 The method is designed to accentuate ways that advance your body clock and play down ways that cause it to delay. 
 &bull; If you can't get to sleep, don't get up or have a meal or snack; relax and read quietly instead. 
 Remember too that sleepiness is promoted by a warm, quiet environment. 
 &bull; When it is time to get up, do so. 
 Do not take naps in the daytime if you feel tired. 
 If you do either of these then you won't feel tired the next evening&hellip; and the difficulties will continue. 
 If you resist any temptation to nap in the daytime you will be more able to get to sleep at your next bedtime. 
 &bull; If possible, take a brisk walk or light exercise first thing in the morning, particularly if it is light then. 
 &bull; Try to arrange for your activities to be concentrated in the first part of the day and for relaxation to come later. 
 &bull; Advance your meal times by the same amount as you change your times of getting up and going to bed. 
 Becoming more of an &bquo;owl&equo; or less of a &bquo;lark' 
 This can occur when, for example, you no longer need to get up early for work. 
 You wish to get up and go to bed later but you tend to wake up early and become tired too early in the evening. 
 The advice now promotes the delaying of your body clock and guards against those factors that might advance it. 
 &bull; If you wake up early, don't get out of bed but relax instead and &bquo;snooze&equo;. 
 This will be easier, of course, if your bedroom is dark and quiet. 
 &bull; Try to arrange for your day to start as leisurely as possible; take time over your breakfast. 
 Similarly try to arrange for your most active work to be done later in the day. 
 &bull; When you feel tired in the evening, do not go to bed yet &mdash; find something interesting to do: an evening stroll, for example or a visit to friends. 
 It is not a good idea to sit in front of a warm fire and relax while having a quiet read as this may cause drowsiness. 
 A nap after lunch, on the other hand, will help you to feel less tired on the evening. 
 &bull; Change your meal times to fit in with your delayed times of getting up and going to bed. 
 Making your body clock more regular 
 Particularly as we become older there is a tendency for rhythms to become less regular (see Chapter 7). 
 This need not matter but the following advice is aimed at those for whom it is an inconvenience. 
 &bull; Strengthen your daily time-cues and make them as reproducible from day to day as possible. 
 In practice this means a regularity in mealtimes, times of physical and social activity, and times of going to bed and rising. 
 If you can make use of natural or artificial time-cues (such as daylight or traffic noise) then so much the better. 
 &bull; If you wake during the night (sometimes because you need to empty your bladder) then return to bed and relax as soon as possible, Do not get up for a cup of tea or snack as this will give misleading information to your body clock. 
 &bull; As you get older, you tend to need less sleep. 
 Therefore make sure that you are not going to bed too early, particularly if you have taken a nap after lunch. 
 people often complain of &bquo;insomnia&equo; in such circumstances! 
 YOUR BODY CLOCK, FATIGUE AND SLEEP 
 Fatigue and body temperature 
 We have already outlined the evidence (Chapter 1 and 2) that the rhythms of fatigue and body temperature have both external and internal causes. 
 for alertness (or fatigue) the evidence must be based upon subjective measurements, but, for body temperature, objective measurements are possible. 
 It will have been noted that the rhythms of body temperature and alertness are timed very similarly with higher values in the daytime and lower values at night (compare figs 1.2 and 1.3). 
 This means that a higher body temperature is associated with a higher degree of alertness or a smaller amount of fatigue. 
 The detailed explanation of what makes us feel alert is not known, but it is certain to be some function of brain activity, and brain activity increases with body temperature. 
 This is because enzymes (proteins that are responsible for carrying out the chemical processes within the body) act more quickly as the temperature is raised. 
 This relationship between body temperature and the speed of biological processes applies throughout the animal kingdom. 
 It is why butterflies warm up before flight, either by exposing their wings to the sun's heat or by generating heat internally by vibrating them; it is why lizards bask in the morning sun; and it is the explanation for the saying: &bquo;fast runs the ant as the mercury rises&equo;. 
 If a raised body temperature promotes alertness and staves off feelings of fatigue, high body temperatures are obviously disadvantageous when we wish to get to sleep. 
 We all have experienced inability to sleep when we cannot settle down and problems occupy our minds. 
 Many factors can cause this but one of them would be a body temperature that is not falling fast enough in the evening. 
 It is a common finding when we are jet-lagged or trying to sleep in the day after night-work. 
 In both of these cases our body clock is wrongly timed for our life-style and so it does not cool us down and make us feel more fatigued in the hours just before bedtime. 
 Fatigue, body temperature, and sleep 
 If a link exists between body temperature and the sensation of fatigue, then it is reasonable to enquire if the abilities to fall asleep and remain asleep are also related to body temperature. 
 Experiments have been performed to investigate, at different times of the day and night, how easy it is to fall asleep, how likely it is to wake up spontaneously, and how long volunteers can stay asleep. 
 The results show that when body temperature is low or falling then not only is fatigue higher but also sleep is easier to initiate. 
 By contrast, waking is more likely to occur if the body temperature rising or has reached a high level. 
 So, in the evening when the body temperature is beginning to fall, there is a natural tendency to fall asleep and in the morning, when body temperature begins to rise rapidly, we are most likely to wake up. 
 Related to these results is the question of how long we can stay asleep (in a laboratory that is always equally quiet, dark, and warm) at different times of the day. 
 Figure 3.1 shows that if we go to bed at the &bquo;normal&equo; time we sleep about eight hours, a result that most of us would accept as part of our daily experience. 
 However, the figure also shows that if we fall asleep when the body temperature is about to begin to fall (about 6 o'clock in the evening), there is the possibility of sleeping for about 12 hours. 
 By contrast, even if we manage to get to sleep at about 10 o'clock in the morning the sleep is likely to be shorter and broken. 
 In effect we have considered this already (Chapter 2) when we described how delayed retiring times did not tend to be associated with longer sleeps; it was a rising body temperature that curtailed sleep and over-rode any need for more sleep that might have existed. 
 There is one exception to this general parallelism between temperature, fatigue, and the ability to sleep. 
 After lunch (at about two o'clock) many of us feel tired and may take a short nap, even though body temperature does not nominally fall much at this time. 
 The phenomenon is called the &bquo;post-lunch dip&equo; &mdash; a reference to the dip in mental performance that occurs then. 
 Its cause is uncertain &mdash; it is also found even if we do not eat then &mdash; but it means that it is often possible to catch up on lost sleep by taking a nap at this time. 
 Sleep and hormones 
 It would be a mistake to assume that sleep is a period when the body is marking time and just ticking over idly. 
 The exact role of sleep is uncertain, but, in humans as in other animals, it is a very active process as far as electrical activity in the brain is concerned. 
 It has been suggested that sleep is a time when brain activity changes from one of acquiring, interpreting, and acting upon information obtained from the environment to one of consolidating daytime memories and experience. 
 Sleep is also a time when some animals purposely conserve energy because it would be wasteful not to do so. 
 Thus a creature that hunts by daylight would waste its energy if it rushed around in the night when its prey was hiding in a burrow and, anyway, it would be poorly equipped for hunting then. 
 A third role of sleep is that it provides an opportunity for the growth and repair of tissues. 
 This is controlled by several hormones, particularly growth hormone (in both sexes) and testosterone (mainly in men). 
 The release of growth hormone (fig 3.2) is dominated by external factors rather than the body clock and is linked to the electrical changes in the brain associated with &bquo;deep&equo; sleep. 
 This is normally found in the first part of sleep (see below). 
 It is interesting to note that severe physical exercise in the daytime is sometimes associated with increased deep sleep the following night; perhaps there is a link here between deep sleep, an increase in growth hormone release, and the growth of muscular tissue that is produced by exercise. 
 Other hormones rise at night also (fig 3.2). 
 These include cortisol (which rises later in the night as the body prepares for waking and is strongly influenced by the body clock); antidiuretic hormone (which is one of the ways in which fluid formation by the kidney is reduced at night, see Chapter 6); and the male sex hormone, testosterone, as well as some of the hormones that control the reproductive cycle in women. 
 The effect of such &bquo;nocturnal surges&equo; in sex hormones, as the increased release of these hormones is called, might be to increase the sexual drive at night. 
 It is fairly easy however, to caste doubt on such a suggestion scientifically; the effect of the nearness of a potential mate is an obvious alternative explanation. 
 The authors know of no experiments in which the strengths of sexual drive and sexual receptiveness have been systematically studied throughout the whole 24 hours. 
 Sleep and sleep stages 
 Sleep is not a single process, as we know from our own experiences. 
 Sometimes we feel we have been deeply asleep and at others we recall that we have been dreaming. 
 Watching the sleep of other people and of animals confirms that sleep can be quiet, with deep, slower breathing, or apparently eventful with body movements and even sounds being made. 
 It has been known for some years now that records of the electricity activity of the brain during sleep &mdash; by electrodes attached to the scalp, face and neck &mdash; confirm that different types of sleep exist. 
 These have been classified into two main types. 
 The first &mdash; rapid eye movement sleep (REM), dream sleep, paradoxical sleep &mdash; appears to be associated with dreaming. 
 Our eyes, legs, and even our voice act as though we are living out the dream. 
 The other main type of sleep &mdash; slow wave sleep &mdash; is also called &bquo;deep sleep&equo; because it is more difficult to raise us from. 
 During a normal night's sleep we cycle between these two main states, generally getting through about four cycles as the night passes. 
 Figure 3.3 also shows that the first cycles are richest in deep sleep and that REM sleep is concentrated towards the end of the night. 
 If we have recently lost sleep (after a week of trying to sleep in the daytime, for example) or have been awake for an unusually long time, then the amount of deep sleep is increased but it is still concentrated in the earlier part of sleep. 
 Deep sleep appears to be a response to our life-style and reflects the amount of prior wakefulness much more than the time of day when sleep is taken. 
 That is, it has a very weak internal cause and a very marked external one. 
 By contrast, REM sleep shows a strong internal cause and is often used as a marker of the body clock. 
 Experiments in which sleep was taken at different times have shown that REM sleep is very little affected by external factors, with most REM activity in the hours between 8 o'clock and noon, and least in the hours just before midnight. 
 It is for this reason that the amount of REM activity increases during the course of a normal night's sleep (fig. 3.3). 
 If sleep is taken at an unusual time, the changes associated with it (the release of some hormones, the type of sleep) will be affected to different extents depending on whether they are dominated by external factors or the body clock. 
 phenomena that are influenced mainly by the body clock will be affected more (you are sleeping at the &bquo;wrong time&equo; as determined by this clock) than those determined mainly by external factors. 
 Some of these points are illustrated in Table 3.1 which compares the effects of sleep at night and during the day upon growth hormone release and deep sleep (dominated by an external cause, the act of going to sleep) and cortisol release and REM sleep (dominated by the body clock). 
 Whether such abnormalities lead to sleep being less &bquo;refreshing&equo;, or to other problems, is not known. 
 At the present time, as we have described, the problem with daytime sleep is believed to be only that it is too short. 
 &bull; REM sleep can &bquo;squeeze&equo; deep sleep out of the first part of sleep towards the middle of it. 
 YOUR BODY CLOCK, WAKING AND PHYSICAL ACTIVITY 
 We have already considered how the body clock, by lowering body temperature and increasing the sensation of fatigue, helps to promote and maintain sleep. 
 The opposite effect &mdash; that a rising body temperature promotes waking and alertness &mdash; is equally important, of course; but being awake and active involves other factors. 
 Cortisol and adrenalin 
 At times of stress, the body responds in a complex way; two hormones are central to this response, cortisol and adrenalin. 
 The exact role of cortisol is unknown, but its importance can be deduced from the observation that animals that cannot produce cortisol, due to injury for instance, are very vulnerable in emergencies. 
 Normally (see Fig. 3.2) cortisol is secreted mainly around the time of waking and this seems to be part of dealing with the &bquo;stress&equo; of waking up and preparing for the new day. 
 Excessive stress can damage the heart and it might not be a coincidence that cardiac disorders are most frequent at the time of waking or the hours just after. 
 Some results from the study upon army volunteers who stayed awake for 72 hours in constant conditions and ate regular meals were considered earlier (Chapter 2, fig. 2.1). 
 In addition to doing &bquo;target practice&equo; and recording how tired they felt, the volunteers collected urine samples which could be used to estimate the concentration of adrenalin in blood. 
 fatigue ratings, the speed of shooting at a target, and the rate of urinary excretion of adrenalin are shown in fig. 4.1. 
 Note that the rhythm of adrenalin is timed opposite to that of fatigue and the same as that of shooting speed. 
 Adrenalin is another &bquo;stress&equo; hormone. 
 It is released when we are angry or anxious and its release is a major part of the &bquo;fight and flight&equo; reaction in animals. 
 It exerts many effects upon the body. 
 It makes the heart pump blood faster (we have all felt the pounding and racing of our hearts when we are roused); dilates the airways of our lungs (so we can breathe faster); and causes a great increase in the release of energy &mdash; by breaking down glycogen (the form in which glucose is stored) for muscles, and fat (from fat storage depots) for the rest of the body. 
 In sum, it enables the body to be most able to deal with danger and to be most efficient physically. 
 The obvious fact that stressful circumstances, such as anger or danger, are not conducive to going to sleep is due to adrenalin to a large extent. 
 Under normal circumstances when there is no undue stress &mdash; as in the examples of the soldiers or people living normal lives &mdash; adrenalin is released in far smaller amounts. 
 Even so, it is still an important hormone and &bquo;tones up&equo; the body so that it can perform more efficiently during the daytime. 
 Equally important is its decrease in concentration in the evening, which relaxes the body so that sleep is more easy to achieve. 
 The adrenalin rhythm is like that of body temperature, therefore, in its general timing and its general integration with the sleep/wake cycle. 
 Exercise and its physical demands 
 Can the body perform physical work equally well at all times of the 24 hours? 
 Consider the biochemical and physiological changes that are required to exercise efficiently. 
 &bull; The basic biochemical process is one by which glycogen in the muscle (a store of glucose) is broken down to release energy which can then be used to drive the muscles. 
 &bull; An increased blood supply brings the extra oxygen needed for glucose breakdown and removes the waste materials (mainly carbon dioxide and lactic acid). 
 &bull; An increased pumping of the heart ensures that the exercising muscles receive all the extra blood and yet enough still goes to the brain and other vital organs. 
 &bull; An increased rate and depth of breathing ensures that more oxygen is taken into the blood (for delivery to the muscles) and that the extra carbon dioxide is removed from the body. 
 &bull; An effective means of increasing heat loss from the body is required. 
 This will prevent a build-up of the huge amount of heat that is produced in exercise. 
 It is achieved by increased blood flow to the skin and an increased sweating rate. 
 Do daily rhythms exert any effect upon these processes? 
 Their role during the daytime, when the body is primed, will be to increase the ease and efficiency with which such mechanisms come into play. 
 Laboratory tests have shown that the rates of oxygen uptake and amounts of muscle effort that volunteers could develop tend to be greater in the daytime than at the night. 
 But the position is more complex than that. 
 Individuals were also asked to assess the severity of a task at different times during the 24 hours. 
 Even though the task &mdash; one that involved pedalling on a stationary bicycle &mdash; was equally demanding at all times, it was felt by the volunteers to be most difficult to achieve in the middle of the night. 
 In summary, exercise is most efficient in the late afternoon. 
 At that time we can respond by the greatest amount and at the greatest speed and we perceive it as being least difficult. 
 These differences in athletic performance might not be very large, a matter of only a few per cent, but for world-class athletes, the difference between a world record and a mediocre performance can be only fractional. 
 It is not surprising, therefore, that world records are generally broken in the afternoon, not during the night. 
 It will also raise a few problems for sportsmen and sportswomen who are training or competing in a new time zone to which they have not yet adjusted. 
 Thus a normal training time in the new time zone might coincide with night on home time and so lead to a physically poorer and psychologically dispiriting performance. 
 For the rest of us, who rarely perform at our physical maximum, these problems would seem far removed. 
 Yet, for some, physical work at night seems more demanding than during the daytime and this is clearly another disadvantage for the night-worker. 
 Now try this 
 Making use of our rhythms 
 So far we have not considered how to use a knowledge of body rhythms to our advantage. 
 As later chapters will show, advice can be given to travellers and shift-workers who have recently changed their routines. 
 However, people living normal routines also can benefit from a knowledge of what their body clocks are telling them. 
 Here are some ideas. 
 A comfortable room temperature 
 How comfortable we feel is determined not only by the temperature of the body (in effect, the temperature of the blood going through the brain) but also by that of the skin. 
 In order to feel comfortable we must get the balance right. 
 For example, if we have raised our body temperature by exercise or effort then cooling ourselves by taking a cold shower, a swim, or a cold drink makes us more comfortable. 
 Also, if we are cold, warming our hands in front of the fire is very comforting. 
 A similar line of reasoning &mdash; warm the skin if the body is cold &mdash; explains the idea of &bquo;one for the road&equo; or the &bquo;stirrup cup&equo;. 
 The nip of alcohol causes the blood vessels to dilate and so warm the skin and make us comfortable in spite of being out in the cold. 
 It can, however, be dangerous insofar as it promotes heat loss: your body is tending to become cold in a cold environment. 
 As a final example consider the passage of air across the skin of our face &mdash; a very sensitive area. 
 If our body is becoming too warm &mdash; through sunbathing, for example &mdash; then the air is a &bquo;pleasant breeze'; if it is tending to be rather cool &mdash; seated in wintertime &mdash; then the air is a &bquo;draught&equo;. 
 Bearing this in mind, we can now look at daily changes in body temperature. 
 In the evening, body temperature is being reduced and so tends to be slightly higher than required. 
 You can help this fall in body temperature by being inactive all evening (sitting in front of the television?), but if you are quite active physically then you can maintain a sense of comfort if you turn down your room thermostat a few degrees in the evening or if you roll up your sleeves and aid heat loss this way. 
 If you are active in the evening and yet do neither of these things, then you may find the room stuffy. 
 In the morning, body temperature is being raised and so it tends to be slightly lower than required. 
 This requires a warmer environment for us to feel comfortable. 
 Cheaper alternatives to turning up the central heating are to do a brief bout of gentle exercise, which increases body heat from the inside, or to wrap up well, which reduces loss to the outside. 
 Exercise and physical exertion 
 The usefulness of gentle exercise in the morning to help warm us up has just been mentioned. 
 It will also help to alert us and loosen up the joints in the spine by squeezing out fluid from the discs between the vertebrae (see Chapter 1). 
 But remember that the increased size of the discs in the morning might increase the risk of a &bquo;slipped disc&equo;; be careful and, particularly when lifting heavy loads, make sure that you are doing so correctly &mdash; or even delay the task till afternoon. 
 For severe exercise, the best part of the day is late afternoon, because the body is most efficient then and you will be able to push yourself harder. 
 Waking up and getting to sleep 
 A short bout of exercise has a further role, namely of waking you up in the morning as it turns on the alerting mechanisms of the body. 
 Other means of waking you up include hot or cold showers &mdash; tactics that &bquo;shock&equo; the body &mdash; or cups of coffee, containing the stimulant caffeine. 
 In all cases, the effect of the body clock is being accentuated by our life-style, generally by means of the hormone adrenalin. 
 In the evening the aim is to relax the body. 
 Therefore hot and cold showers, arguments, and exercise are not good preludes to helping you get to sleep. 
 Also, a large meal, particularly with coffee or tea, might keep you awake whilst it is being digested (though some people find that it is easy to fall asleep after a meal). 
 Many people practice relaxation techniques, take a long soak in a bath of warm (not hot or cold) water, or have a quiet read in bed before turning out the light. 
 All these methods are calming us down and decreasing adrenalin release, and so accentuate the likelihood of falling asleep that is being promoted by our body clock. 
 YOUR BODY CLOCK AND MENTAL ACTIVITY 
 We have already established that physical work seems harder at night than during the daytime; does the same apply to mental performance? 
 We are concerned if we perform badly or dangerously at some times and the effects of poor performance will also be of interest to managers and the general public. 
 Managers will wish to know if the body clock means that there are times when the output of their work-force is below standard and the general public will be concerned about the possibility that safety in industrial processes, public services, transportation, etc. will be adversely affected at some times. 
 Some problems of measuring performance at work 
 Unfortunately, as soon as an attempt is made to measure &bquo;performance&equo;, a whole series of problems arises. 
 It can be very difficult to decide how to measure performance at many jobs. 
 For example, how would you measure if a plumber, a lorry driver, a teacher, or a magistrate had just performed a task well? 
 In the cases of the plumber and magistrate, is it the number of jobs or cases completely successfully? &mdash; but some are more difficult than others. 
 For the teacher, is it how well the class has understood? &mdash; but the topic might be difficult or the pupils not very bright. 
 How do you judge the lorry driver? 
 By whether or not he is late? 
 By how few times he has lost his way? 
 Surely this depends upon the traffic conditions and the difficulty of the route. 
 Sometimes the position is considered from a slightly different viewpoint and only poor performance &mdash; as assessed by accidents or errors  &mdash; is considered. 
 Even that can be complicated. 
 How would you establish at all reliably if a magistrate, politician, inspector, or teacher had made an error? 
 And even if errors could be assessed satisfactorily, there need not be any clear link between full-blown errors or accidents and a performance that is generally sub-standard &mdash; as any self-critical driver knows. 
 In addition it is difficult to attribute more errors or a poorer performance wholly to the effects of a body clock. 
 Consider the problems of traffic accidents more closely. 
 If it were found that more accidents occurred in the winter months between 6 and 8 o'clock in the evening compared with noon and 2 o'clock, is this because, during the early evening, lighting is worse, there is more traffic, drivers have been working longer and are more tired, or weather conditions are worse? 
 It might be considered that performance at many factory jobs would be easier to assess since a product is involved. 
 However, if one shift performs better (and &bquo;better&equo; might refer to the quality or quantity &mdash; or both &mdash; of product that is made) is it because it consists of more conscientious workers; their conditions of working are better, or they have less distraction; they are supervised more closely and the conveyor belt moves faster; or their body clock enables them to work better at some times of the day than others? 
 Clearly, if we want to know the role that the body clock plays in our mental performance, all these other influences must be controlled or eliminated. 
 Some improvements &mdash; but further problems 
 Let us consider how some of these difficulties could be removed or controlled. 
 In principle, we require the following conditions to be observed. 
 1. 
 The same workers are investigated at different times of the day. 
 2. 
 The workers have been on duty for the same amount of time whenever measurements are made. 
 (It is known that performance deteriorates after several hours of work.) 3. 
 External factors (lighting, heating, noise, traffic conditions, weather factors) are kept constant. 
 4. 
 The work being investigated is always of the same type and difficulty. 
 5. 
 The individual, not a supervisor or the speed of a conveyor belt, decides the rate at which the task is carried out; this is termed a &bquo;self-paced task&equo; 
 Condition (1) can be fulfilled by requiring the same work-force to work all shifts in a rotating shift system. 
 With sufficient manipulation of the rota, it would be possible to arrange for the work-force to have been working for the same number of hours at different times of the day &mdash; condition (2). 
 The conditions described in (3) are sometimes fairly easy to control (for example, the amount of noise and environmental temperature), but there are other conditions (traffic density or natural lighting, for example) where this can be more difficult or impossible. 
 In many jobs, condition (4) can be fulfilled as it is possible for similar types of work to be tackled throughout the 24 hours. 
 In other cases this is not so. 
 Teaching at night is unlikely to prove popular (with teacher or pupil!) and the night shift in a hospital ward cannot be made equivalent to the day shift (except for intensive care units which are continuously busy). 
 finally, condition (5) cannot be fulfilled in all occupations. 
 For ambulance men and air-traffic controllers, those in &bquo;supply-and-demand&equo; situations, the demand is due to external factors and the workers have to respond; their work load is not self-paced. 
 Errors measured in the workplace 
 It must be apparent by now that satisfactory studies are likely to be rare. 
 Some studies, however, do exist and a selection is shown in Fig. 5.1. 
 We need not discuss the results in detail except to note the following points. 
 &bull; Errors tend to be more frequent at night than during the day. 
 &bull; A post-lunch increase in error exists. 
 Not only are the results of such &bquo;on site&equo; studies of immense value for what we assume they tell us about the role of our body clock in affecting mental performance, but they also serve two further roles. 
 First, they act as a standard against which the results of other tests (below) can be measured. 
 Second, they confirm the difficulties of interpretation that can arise, as can be seen by considering the result which shows the frequency of errors made by locomotive drivers. 
 &bquo;Error&equo; here refers to the failure to respond to a warning light that comes on when a signal at red is passed. 
 If the brake is not applied by the driver then it is applied automatically; it is the frequency of these automatic braking incidents that is recorded as an error. 
 From what we already know about the body clock and the &bquo;post-lunch dip&equo;, the high frequencies of errors during the night and after lunch are not unexpected; but why are errors so infrequent in the evening? 
 It is because at this time the warning light is more easily visible in the twilight than in the daylight. 
 So this external factor offsets the fact that performance in the evening due to the body clock might be deteriorating. 
 It will be noted that the improved visibility of this warning light does not completely offset the increased tendency to make an error during the night. 
 Mental performance tests 
 By now it might be wondered whether there is any satisfactory way to measure mental performance. 
 The many complications seem to preclude this even though the importance of success is as great as ever. 
 Psychologists have broken down &bquo;real&equo; jobs into a series of &bquo;simple&equo; components and have then devised tests for assessing these simpler components. 
 It can be argued that these tests are a reliable indicator of performance when tested under controlled conditions. 
 The simple components are as follows. 
 The sensory component 
 Information has to be taken in to the brain &mdash; often through the eyes but this is only because humans rely so much upon this sense. 
 Touch, hearing, taste, and smell can all be in addition (consider how a chef, carpenter, piano-tuner, tea-taster, or perfumier work, for instance). 
 The central component 
 This is the processing of information by the brain itself. 
 It will include reasoning or thinking and might make considerable use of long-term memory or experience. 
 The motor component 
 This is a type of action. 
 It might be as straightforward as writing down or calling out an answer, pressing a button, etc. or it may be a task that requires manipulative skills such as wiring an electrical component or threading a needle. 
 It might include a complex co-ordination between arms and legs as in driving a car. 
 Short-term memory and vigilance 
 There are two other components that tasks can possess, short-term memory and vigilance. 
 These also involve processing within the brain but are slightly different from what is normally meant by thinking or drawing on memory and experience. 
 Short-term memory is the phenomenon by which we can remember a telephone number long enough after looking it up to be able to dial it. 
 It enables us to remember the cards that have been played in a hand of bridge, the objects on a tray in the game of pelmanism, or reading a meter and recording the result (see Fig. 5.1). 
 Short-term memory is a temporary store of information and often it is irrelevant to convert the information into a long-term memory, the type of memory that enables us to recall events years later. 
 Thus, although it might be useful to remember a particular telephone number (and so convert a short-term into a long-term memory), this is often not the case and we are unlikely to want to remember every hand of cards. 
 That is, short-term memories are often required to be forgotten. 
 A few people do seem to be able to remember everything (they have &bquo;photographic memories&equo;) but this can often lead to remembering a mass of unwanted material and so things have to be actively &bquo;unremembered&equo;. 
 The other component of tasks is vigilance. 
 Through vigilance we detect changes in our environment such as in traffic conditions, a new &bquo;blip&equo; on the radar screen, or a faulty product on a conveyor belt. 
 It is a characteristic of a task requiring vigilance that it can span a long time, minutes or hours or even a whole work-shift. 
 A selection of simple tests 
 To illustrate the ways in which different components of performance can be assessed, we will consider examples from a small selection of the tests that have been devised. 
 At the end of the chapter (Now Try This &mdash; 4), we will suggest that you adapt the tests so that you can measure your own performance. 
 Group 1: Tests which require large amounts of sensory input These tasks require a simple response and not much thought, coupled with the need to sift through large amounts of data in order to find a &bquo;target&equo; amongst unwanted information (fig. 5.2). 
 AGBHJTYOWLNMPASDDQGTUITLMDJEX RYHSKMXHWYUSGHWWMLQWMSPLEUJDM UJKSEHMSKQXGKLLQTHOMPDHJJEKLO YWTFGHIKMCCOWLXPMTXWKIRLMHJDB POEKJDNMFKURHHNRJKSSLPLQXYJDD QWBDHJKPLMCBSXAZIDZKLEGHLCVVE PDMSMBBOJWSQMNXLUDTTKWKLFMRQL BNKLFMNSGBEOPAGVSBHKFMNXBVSJH ILDKJMSVSKIRGQNBXTYUOLLKHWTPS WJKMVLHMLKJOLKSQMXRTKJDMPGNPP UKDGHHXBNLQJMDELOPSGRTLNAQIFF UJKDMFEOIPSKLFHLDDWNDSLOUFCSL LPEJKDNFKLRUHFLLSMJCGBQKTDLRI LKDHGRYUIEPKDSIWLGORRMFILEKMD Fig. 5.2 Sample for Groups 1A or 1B (for more details, see p. 57). 
 A. Cross out the E's in the following passage.  
 B. Cross out duplicate letters that are adjacent to each other.  
 The letters can be chosen so that unwanted ones differ from the target by larger or smaller amounts. 
 Thus Es are difficult to distinguish from Fs in contrast with Os and Xs, for example. 
 How long it takes to complete the whole block of letters is measured. 
 Group 2: Tests which stress the motor output 
 Clearly some sensory input is necessary, but this and the amount of thought required are rather small in comparison with the motor response required. 
 Often this is some form of manipulative skill. 
 A. Put a dot into the centre of each circle (Fig. 5.3) . 
 A test would consist of about 20 &bquo;lines&equo;, each of about 20 linked circles. 
 B. Threading beads onto a string . 
 How many beads could be threaded in 2 minutes would be measured. 
 In the first case the task is easier if the targets are larger, are closer to each other and more regularly arranged. 
 In the second case the sizes of the beads and the holes through them can vary. 
 Group 3: Tests stressing a co-ordination between sensory and motor components 
 We give two examples of these. 
 A. Copy each symbol accurately (Fig. 5.4) . 
 It will be noted that a great variety of difficulty could be introduced here &mdash; both in the shape of the symbol and the standard of accuracy that is required in the answer. 
 Typically a test might consist of measuring how many symbols could be copied in 2 minutes. 
 B. Substitute one symbol for another . 
 Letters A-F could be paired with the symbols in Fig. 5.4 and then a string of random letters, say BCEFADDB etc, would be required to be coded by use of the relevant symbol. 
 As with test (A), the difficulty can vary greatly in both the accuracy required in the copied symbol and the similarities between the different symbols. 
 Again, the number of substitutions accomplished in 2 minutes would be measured. 
 Group 4: Tests stressing short-term memory 
 The general format of the test is the same as that for tests (A) and (B) in Group 1. 
 The difference is that each line has to be searched to establish the presence or absence of a target set of letters (the order of the target set is not important &mdash; only whether or not the whole set is present). 
 Obviously, whilst scanning the letters this set has to be remembered and it is changed for each test. 
 Its length is conventionally 2, 4, or 6 letters requiring low, moderate, and high amounts of short-term memory, respectively. 
 Thus the target letters for comparing with each line of Fig. 5.2 might be HW (low level), OWPS (medium level), or QTXLDG (high level of short-term memory required). 
 The time taken to complete the task would be measured. 
 Group 5: Tests stressing reasoning or some other form of central processing 
 A. Logical reasoning &mdash; 1  The sequence &bquo;AB&equo; or &bquo;BA&equo; is given randomly. 
 A statement about the sequence is given (that is, &bquo;B does not follow A&equo; or &bquo;A precedes B&equo;); the subject is required to answer if the statement is true or false. 
 A test would consist of measuring how many examples could be done in 2 minutes. 
 B. Logical reasoning &mdash; 2  A set of premises is given about the relationship between A, B, C, D, E (e.g. A &gt; B; B = C; C &gt; D; D = E). 
 It is required to know what the relationship is between A and E, choosing from: greater than; less than; equal to; cannot say. 
 Again how many examples could be done in 2 minutes would be measured. 
 C. Syllogisms  Accepting the truth of two premises, one has to choose the most appropriate conclusion from a set of possibilities. 
 for example: &bull; premise one: no foods are poisons &bull; premise two: some drugs are poisons 
 Therefore, choose the most appropriate possibility from: 
 1. 
 No foods are drugs 2. 
 Some drugs are not foods 3. 
 Some poisons are not drugs 4. 
 No drugs are foods The number of syllogisms done in 2 minutes would constitute the test. 
 D. Mental arithmetic  Take the example 47 &bull; 93 &mdash; 28 =? 
 This is as obvious as it is tedious! 
 Clearly a great variety of difficulty could be introduced into the tests. 
 Again, how many could be one in a set period of time would be measured. 
 The final two groups of tests cannot be illustrated. 
 Group 6: Measuring speeds of response (reaction time) 
 A. Simple reaction time  When a light is switched on (or a note is sounded) a button must be pressed as quickly as possible; the delay in doing this is measured. 
 The time taken to do this, say, 10 times is measured. 
 B. Choice reaction time  A modification of A is for a choice of buttons to exist; the correct button must be pressed to extinguish the light or stop the sound. 
 The time taken to extinguish a sequence of, say, 10 lights or sounds is taken. 
 Group 7: Vigilance tests 
 Due to the very nature of vigilance, the tests to measure it must take much longer than is required for the other tests above. 
 A test session lasting 30 minutes or more is not unusual. 
 The tests require the subject to indicate when a signal is abnormal or missed. 
 Thus a stream of pulses lasting 1 second each and given at 10 second intervals could be the &bquo;background&equo; (they could be sound pulses or pulses on a screen, for example); the &bquo;signal&equo; being sought could be the absence of a pulse, one that was shorter or longer than the standard value or one that appeared too soon or too late. 
 In addition, the size and frequency of the &bquo;errors&equo; could be varied. 
 The percentage of &bquo;signals&equo; that is detected correctly is generally measured. 
 How useful are these tests? 
 A great advantage of these tests &mdash; one that was not found in &bquo;real&equo; tasks &mdash; is that sets of them can be made of equal difficulty. 
 Therefore, differences in performance of these tests do not reflect variation in the tests themselves. 
 If the external conditions are standardized (temperature, lighting, comfort of the volunteer) the results reflect the mental performance of the individual. 
 But the tests are susceptible to many factors that can distort the results. 
 Each session normally consists of several types of test, together with a vigilance session of, say, 30 minutes. 
 The total session might take up to one hour. 
 This not only makes it unlikely that employers will allow many such sessions per day (and that is a disadvantage scientifically) but it also means that the tests, particularly by virtue of necessarily being repetitive, are boring for the subject. 
 There is also the problem that performance testing is highly susceptible to personal distractions and even though the tests and conditions of testing can be standardized, the motivation of those taking them cannot. for example, in some of our own experiments we found that subjects like to accompany each testing session with music. 
 Unfortunately, slow music and fast music altered how they performed the tests so music is now forbidden during testing sessions. 
 Another problem is that the tests show practice effects; that is, for the first day or so of testing, subjects' performances improve greatly (and so mask any daily rhythms) as they are getting used to the tests and are developing their personal ways of tackling them. 
 To counteract this problem, subjects are given sufficient practice tests before the experiment to ensure that this effect has worn off. 
 All these difficulties must be taken into account when we interpret the results of tests of mental performance. 
 What do these tests tell us about mental performance? 
 In spite of all these difficulties, results have shown that the different types of performance measured by these tests display characteristic rhythms. 
 some typical examples are shown in fig. 5.5. 
 For obvious reasons, most tests have been performed only during the daytime. 
 With the exception of tests in Group 4, performance rises after waking and falls during the evening. 
 Between these times it shows either a slight rise or a general plateau (tests of Groups 1, 2 and 6) or a slight decline after a peak at about noon (Groups 3, 5 and 7). 
 In most subjects there is also a temporary decline in the early hours of the afternoon &mdash; the &bquo;post-lunch dip&equo;. 
 When subjects are tested at night their performance is generally rather poor. 
 In short, the results of most tests are very similar to those measured &bquo;on site&equo;, but with much more difficulty, see fig. 5.1. 
 It will be noted that, in general, the performance rhythms are similar to those of temperature and adrenalin (see Chapters 1 and 4). 
 One exception to this parallelism is those tasks which have a large short-term memory component (see Group 4 tests, above). 
 These tasks appear to be done better at night with a general decline throughout the daytime to lowest values in the early evening. 
 A second exception to the parallelism between performance and temperature is a more general one. 
 In stressful circumstances the effects of daily rhythms are &bquo;swamped&equo; by the response of the body to the emergency. 
 For example, if you smell burning in the middle of the night you will respond immediately and fully, and not bother to &bquo;consult&equo; any body clock to see if you should calm down and be asleep! 
 This applies to both your physical and mental performance. 
 It is important, however, to remember that normally we are not stressed and so, particularly in repetitive and boring situations, the effect of our body clock upon mental performance becomes greater. 
 How well many tasks are performed is affected by another factor &mdash; &bquo;fatigue&equo;. 
 This is a mixture of tiredness and a kind of boredom and it produces a deterioration in mental performance. 
 fatigue increases and mental performance worsens as the amount of time spent on the task increases, particularly if we have lost sleep or the task is repetitive and boring. 
 Vigilance (Group 7) is particularly susceptible to fatigue. 
 To counteract this, an individual generally benefits from continual changes in the type of task being performed as well as continual updating on how well or badly the task is being done. 
 There is also benefit to be gained from a break or &mdash; better &mdash; a short sleep. 
 Fatigue contributes to the fall-off in performance that occurs as the time spent awake (or on duty) increases. 
 This effect will be in addition to the daily changes in performance that are due to the body clock and which, therefore, would be predicted to peak between 4 and 6 o'clock in the afternoon. 
 So, in tasks where the effects of fatigue are substantial (Groups 3, 5, and 7) peak performance will occur about noon rather than late in the afternoon (see fig. 5.5). 
 Making the tests relevant to real tasks 
 Even though the rhythms in performance measured by the tests and &bquo;real&equo; tasks are similar (compare figs. 5.1 and 5.5), it is reasonable to ask how relevant are these tests to the &bquo;on site&equo; situation? 
 It seems possible to argue that the tests described so far &mdash; for example, crossing out duplicate letters from blocks of random letters, answering questions of logic relating to the sequence of two letters, and copying symbols &mdash; are tests produced by psychologists for use by psychologists and that their relevance to &bquo;real&equo; tasks remains to be proved. 
 In attempts to deal with this type of criticism, the basic tests have been &bquo;upgraded&equo; in several ways. 
 Examples are: 
 &bull; several types of test (and therefore several components of mental performance) have been combined. 
 for example, in one test subjects are required to insert ball-bearings into holes in a cylinder; the holes are of slightly different sizes; the ball-bearings are of slightly different sizes; and the cylinder is revolving. 
 Such a test combines elements of Groups 1&ndash;3. 
 As another example, subjects have to draw an irregular shape &mdash; the shape being seen as a reflection in a mirror. 
 This combines elements of Groups 1&ndash;3 and 5 with a fair degree of exasperation! 
 &bull; Several tasks are required to be performed simultaneously and the subject is required to distribute his time between them as efficiently as possible. 
 This is supposed to mimic the stress of the decision-making process. 
 At times, it seems to those taking part to resemble a bad dream as they are required to be vigilant in spite of distractions elsewhere caused by other unfinished tasks! 
 &bull; Complex computer-based games have been developed so that scores for manipulative skill, decision-taking, vigilance, etc. can all be calculated as the game proceeds. 
 Clearly, games can be devised that are tests of far more subtle strategies and complex manoeuvres. 
 Taken to an extreme, driving and flight simulators aim to duplicate the real thing exactly and if used repetitively they could assess changes due to daily rhythms. 
 Measuring mental performance by proxy 
 The use of sophisticated computer games and simulators certainly begins to mimic &bquo;real&equo; tasks &mdash; but we have reached another problem. 
 The cost of buying equipment and the requirement of skilled personnel to maintain and run it can make its use in the repeated assessments which are required for measuring rhythms prohibitively expensive. 
 We have almost come full circle. 
 We have tried to measure &bquo;on-site&equo; performance of real tasks, but it was too complex and easily distorted. 
 So we developed simple tests to overcome some of the difficulties, but they were often not very &bquo;relevant&equo;. 
 So we made these tests more complex in order to increase their relevance, but in so doing we produced tests which were so sophisticated as not to be widely available due to cost and personnel requirements, and which began to show some of the problems found when we measured performance &bquo;on-site&equo;. 
 Is there an alternative to this at times unhappy compromise between &bquo;relevance&equo; and &bquo;simplicity'? 
 Some have suggested that there are daily rhythms which mirror those of mental performance but which are not as difficult to measure or as prone to interference, and they come up with old standbys, body temperature and adrenalin. 
 The parallelism between these two rhythms and performance has been commented upon and illustrated before. 
 That is, when performance in the field is difficult to measure satisfactorily, body temperature or adrenalin rhythms might be used as a substitute. 
 But it must always be remembered that it is an assumption that body temperature and performance are parallel (or oppositely phased in the case of short-term memory), an assumption that has not been tested under all conditions, and so, at times, might be wrong. 
 Nevertheless, it is a fact that during shiftwork and after time-zone transitions, body temperature and adrenalin rhythms have been used in addition to, or even in place of, measures of performance at &bquo;real tasks&equo; or at the simpler tests devised by psychologists. 
 Now try this &mdash; 4 
 Measure your own performance 
 You might like to try and measure your own performance. 
 This requires care and patience in the preparation, performance, and marking of the tests but it can be most rewarding. 
 The comments are intended as guidelines only. 
 Choice of tests 
 With sufficient ingenuity all the tests except those in groups 2B, 3A, 5C could be devised by a computer. 
 For many tests, they are best printed on paper, but for some, Groups 5&ndash;7, the test can be run on the computer screen. 
 How many tests required? 
 At least 20 sessions, spread over several days, are required to remove the major effects of practice. 
 The investigation itself requires the test sessions to be repeated as often as possible, say on 5 occasions at each test time, to reduce the effects of variability. 
 So, if you plan to measure performance at 8 times of day, then 40 complete test sessions, in addition to the practice sessions, will be required. 
 Performing the tests 
 Remember that performance is susceptible to the effects of external conditions, the mood of the subject and sleep loss, as well as to rhythmic changes. 
 So it is most important to standardize your own frame of mind and the conditions for doing the tests. 
 Marking the tests 
 This has been described in the chapter. 
 Generally, the rate of performance (that is, sums done in the time allotted or the time taken to complete the task) is scored rather than its accuracy. 
 Note that a good performance is more sums done but less time taken. 
 Individuals can differ widely in their scores and this makes direct comparisons between them difficult. 
 One way to deal with this is to express each result from an individual as a percentage of the mean value for that person; in this way, all vary about the same mean value of 100 per cent. 
 However, if you are looking for rhythmic changes in a single volunteer then it is the changes  in performance, not the absolute level of performance, that are most important. 
 Beware also of another problem. 
 If you are scoring the tests yourself, rather than getting the computer to do it for you, then always do so at the same time of day &mdash; otherwise there would be variability due to time-of-day effects upon your scoring ability. 
 Good luck! 
 YOUR BODY CLOCK AND DEALING WITH FOOD 
 Another group of linked rhythms is that which includes rhythms in the intake and digestion of food, the chemical changes that are performed upon this food and the removal of waste material from the body. 
 Is it time to eat yet? 
 We do not eat throughout the 24 hours but show a rhythm that is dominated by social factors and the structure of our day. 
 For example, coffee breaks, tea breaks, and a lunch hour are all incorporated into our work hours. 
 Meal times can serve as a focus for certain social activities; consider, for example, the &bquo;Sunday roast&equo;, the wining-and-dining of lovers, and even the &bquo;working breakfast&equo;. 
 Fluid intake too, in the form of wine, beer, spirits, and a cup of tea, serves a social role as much as a biological one. 
 Unlike babies, we do not eat or drink just because we are hungry or thirsty. 
 Many people, particularly night-workers, feel that they lose their appetite in the middle of the night. 
 Yet it is not uncommon for people who cannot get to sleep, or who have woken up, to get up in the middle of the night and to make themselves a snack because they are hungry. 
 On other occasions when people feel tired, and again this applies particularly to night-workers, they know they should eat (a rumbling stomach and hunger pangs tell them this) and yet have no appetite. 
 jaded palates need some titillation and yet another &bquo;fry-up&equo; might not be the answer. 
 Clearly there is a complex mixture of physiology and psychology in this situation. 
 In many experiments upon individuals isolated from the time-cues in the environment (free-running experiments), food intake &mdash; breakfast, &bquo;elevenses&equo;, lunch, etc. &mdash; continues to be distributed normally during the course of the waking span. 
 Even though biological factors such as the state of hydration of the body will indicate that some food or fluid intake is required, the size and type of meal are likely to be determined also by habit and life-style. 
 Having decided upon getting up, an individual will then eat several meals and snacks as part of a &bquo;normal&equo; pattern of eating. 
 As in a normal environment, an individual in a time-free experiment will show a very similar pattern of eating day by day. 
 Even so, considerable differences between individuals and cultures exist. 
 Some people miss breakfast, while others have their main meal at midday rather than the early evening. 
 Interestingly, in those subjects living for fairly long periods in isolation, in whom the pattern of sleep and activity becomes irregular (see Chapter 2), meals too become erratic in their numbers and composition. 
 perhaps the loss of social interaction that is normally associated with mealtimes contributes to this. 
 Accepting that meals are a very important part of a person's life-style means that their timing might have an important role in adjusting the body clock. 
 The effect can be direct, through the influence of food intake on gut activity (see below), or indirect, through the social factors that are associated with meals. 
 Indigestion and constipation 
 After eating the meal, the food must now be digested. 
 This requires the co-ordinated release into our gut of a series of digestive enzymes and fluids which are then mixed with the food. 
 The digested material is slowly passed through the gut by muscle action, and foodstuffs, water and salts are absorbed into our blood stream. 
 What remains is converted into solid material for elimination as faeces. 
 There is no good evidence to indicate that these processes cannot be achieved by the body equally well at any time of the day or night. 
 Our personal experiences &mdash; for example of the unpleasant effects upon our digestive system of an unusually large meal late at night &mdash; are difficult to interpret. 
 In this case, was it the timing of the meal (the point in question), its size or richness, the wine, or the act of staying up late that was the cause? 
 There is some evidence that the concentration of acid in the stomach is highest in the night and this might explain why the pain associated with excess gastric acid is most marked at night and can wake you then. 
 As food is taken into the gut, so there is a controlled sequence by which the gut contents are passed towards the anus. 
 Once the residue left after absorption of foodstuff reaches the last part of the gut, the desire to defecate results. 
 In herbivores particularly, but also in most animals and babies, defecation takes place more than once per day. 
 In health, constipation is rare, being a reflection in many human cases of a lack of roughage in the diet. 
 In adults, the decision whether or not to defecate is under voluntary control. 
 Most of us defecate once a day and at a convenient time. 
 When this routine becomes disorganised &mdash; as after time-zone transitions and during night-work &mdash; this can be inconvenient, particularly if we have a busy and highly-ordered life-style, and even socially embarrassing. 
 When there are no social restraints, as in time-free isolation experiments, for instance, defecation appears to be more &bquo;spontaneous&equo; &mdash; that is, less regular and sometimes more frequent. 
 The relative importance of habit and biological factors in such circumstances is hard to decide. 
 Making use of our food 
 The biological aim of the meal has been to enable foodstuffs to be taken into the body for its growth and repair. 
 Fats are passed to fat storage depots and sugars to the liver and muscles. 
 Several hormones, particularly insulin, the hormone that is deficient in sugar diabetes, control these processes. 
 Insulin prevents the rise in blood sugar which would adversely affect brain function and cause sugar to be wasted by spilling over into the urine. 
 The amount of insulin released into the bloodstream by the pancreas in response to eating a standard amount of glucose is less in the afternoon and evening than in the morning, and this suggests that there is a rhythm in the sensitivity of the pancreas to raised blood glucose. 
 In addition the insulin appears to be slightly more effective in the morning at promoting glucose uptake and use by the cells of the body. 
 Thus, the body appears to be able to respond more to raised blood glucose early in the daytime and this is in spite of the fact that we normally take in larger amounts of glucose later in the daytime. 
 Another difference between the effects of a morning and evening meal of equal size and calorie content has been found. 
 Subjects tended to lose weight when they had breakfast only, but not when dinner was their only meal. 
 Before a successful method for dieting is assumed to have been found it must be realized that the effects were small and that the difference might reflect the greater energy expended by those who ate in the morning. 
 They had been &bquo;set up&equo; for the day by their large breakfast and so might have been more active than those who were hungry during the daytime. 
 In other words, to be hungry throughout most of the day might cause lethargy and sluggish behaviour. 
 Recent work suggests that there might be a daily rhythm in the composition of a mother's milk. 
 Particularly in countries where the diet is poor it might be of very considerable significance if the mother can make better milk at some times of the day. 
 There is still, however, disagreement between researchers as to when the mother produces the most nutritious milk. 
 This might reflect cultural differences as well as effects due to the type and quantity of food consumed by the mother. 
 Further work remains to be done. 
 Our rhythmic kidneys 
 Linked to the intake and use of food and drink is the elimination in the urine of excess fluid and salts and of waste materials. 
 Nearly all substances that appear in the urine show daily rhythms and these are due to our habits as well as our body clock. 
 The internal cause of the rhythm can be established in the normal manner &mdash; by making the intake of food and water, the posture, and environment of the volunteers constant through the 24 hours (see Fig. 1.3) The rhythm that persists in these circumstances indicates that the effect of the body clock and the difference from the normal rhythm is due to external causes. 
 This type of experiment indicates that the relative importances of the external and internal causes depends upon the substance being considered. 
 for example, the internal cause of the rhythm in potassium excretion is quite large, whereas for calcium and water excretion the external cause is dominant (see Fig. 1.3). 
 Unfortunately, even if we know that a urinary rhythm is due partly to the body clock, we cannot yet be confident about details of the way in which this clock produces the rhythms in renal elimination. 
 The external cause of the rhythms of urine formation comes from two sources: our diet and changes in posture. 
 The effects of meals are easy to understand. 
 We drink and eat in the daytime but not at night and so there is an excess of fluid and salts in the body in the daytime, and a deficit during the night. 
 Even so, the effects of posture (lying down when asleep and being more upright during the daytime) pose a problem. 
 Lying down increases the return of blood back to the heart and brain. 
 (It is for this reason that lying down when you feel faint is a good idea). 
 Such an increased return of blood is monitored by receptors that signal the amount of filling of the heart. 
 These receptors wrongly interpret the increased return of blood when lying down as a sign that excess blood volume has caused the blood vessels to become &bquo;overfull&equo; and so the kidney is instructed to remove the excess water and salts. 
 (Such a reflex effect occurs also in outer space in a zero-gravity environment because blood no longer pools in the limbs then. 
 The reflex increase in urine flow that is produced in this circumstance severely tested the resources of the space-suits worn by the early astronauts!) 
 The problem is this: why is the reflex increase in urine flow so much smaller at night when we lie down to go to sleep? 
 The answer is that renal function, like bodily functions in general, is highest during the daytime and partially &bquo;closed down&equo; at night. 
 In the case of kidneys, this is brought about by several factors &mdash; by changed rates of secretion of some hormones (see Fig. 3.2), by altered activity in the nerves going to the kidney, and by a reduction in blood supply to the kidneys. 
 It is a very good example of the internal cause of renal rhythms &mdash; the body clock &mdash; overriding the external cause, a change in posture. 
 The result is important since it decreases the rate of bladder filling during the night and allows us to sleep longer. 
 In daytime sleep, such an effect is not present and night-workers can vouch for the broken sleep produced by the more rapid filling of the bladder after lying down during the daytime. 
 The effect is not observed in some renal and heart disorders; then the rate of urine flow on lying down at night is greater than during the daytime and this will be diagnostically useful to the physician. 
 In babies and some old people also, renal rhythms are abnormal and the reduced urine flow at night is not seen. 
 particularly for old people this, coupled with a tendency to have a &bquo;weak bladder&equo;, can have distressing consequences. 
 A knowledge of the rhythms in urine formation can be important when treatment with drugs is concerned since they are removed from the body in the urine. 
 The degree of acidity of the urine shows a daily variation, nocturnal urine being most acidic. 
 Many drugs are acidic or alkaline and this affects their removal in the urine; acidic drugs are excreted more easily in the daytime and alkaline ones at night. 
 Since drugs are costly, it might be desirable to give the drug when it is less readily removed by the kidneys. 
 This will reduce the amount of drug required and so the cost of treatment. 
 Giving less drug might have another advantage, since drugs are toxic materials and there is always the risk that the kid will suffer damage. 
 Since the kidneys produce the largest volume of urine in the middle of the day, any drug that is being removed will be least concentrated in the urine, and so be least likely to cause damage, at this time. 
 It can be seen that the physician or doctor will have to bear both factors in mind when deciding if the time when a drug is to be taken is important (see also Chapter 14). 
 YOUR BODY CLOCK AT DIFFERENT STAGES OF YOUR LIFE 
 We have considered so far daily rhythms in healthy adults. 
 Here we will consider the differences from adults that are found in the rhythms of healthy babies, adolescents, and aged people. 
 These are important times of our lives &mdash; too often biology books neglect them and assume we are forever in our youth and prime. 
 Not only does the body clock contribute to the changes that are found, but also we can gain clues about the nature of it by a study of the changes. 
 The development of rhythms in young children 
 The newborn child does not show 24-hour rhythms, as any parent will affirm (fig. 7.1). 
 The baby's feeding habits, which directly concern a nursing mother, and its waking and crying habits, which directly concern both parents, tend to be distributed evenly throughout the 24 hours (see the sleep profile of a newborn child in Fig. 2.4). 
 As the baby grows up, 24-hour rhythms begin to appear from about the second month of life onwards. 
 fully established daily rhythms &mdash; that is, ones like those in adults &mdash; do not develop until about five years of age. 
 Interestingly, not all rhythms develop at the same rate. 
 As a general rule, those with the highest internal cause (body temperature, for example) develop later in life than those with marked external causes (urine flow, for instance). 
 The rhythm of sleep and activity is one of the first to develop. 
 Why this should be so will be discussed in a moment but it does enable the other observations to be accounted for by a single theory. 
 This theory is that, as in the adult, the changes associated with being asleep and awake will have a direct effect upon all rhythms, and so become the external cause of them. 
 As a result of this, rhythms with the greater external cause will appear to develop earlier in childhood than those with a smaller external cause. 
 This theory also implies that the internal body clock takes up to five years to develop fully. 
 What causes the sleep/wake rhythm to arise first, and how does the body clock develop later? 
 External and internal causes for developing rhythms 
 The simplest answer to the question about what causes the sleep/wake rhythm to arise is that it is a reflection of the rhythmic world in which the newborn child has been placed and to which it begins to respond. 
 Even if the baby wakes at random times &mdash; in order to feed, for example &mdash; there are some times of the 24 hours when its environment is less stimulating and responsive than others. 
 This might be by parental design or due to natural events. 
 Thus parents might decide to get the baby into a routine and this would mean imposing some sort of 24-hour cycle upon the child. 
 This might include the amount of light, noise and general stimulation the child received during the daytime and the lack of these at night. 
 It might also involve feeding times; during the daytime, meals would be given more readily in response to the child's cries than during the night. 
 Even if the child were &bquo;demand fed&equo;, its environment and parents' sleep would tend to decrease the likelihood of its waking and being fed at night in comparison with the daytime. 
 Accepting that the rhythms of children in a structured environment appear to develop more quickly, is this advantageous to the child? 
 In one study, body weight as well as general development progressed more in a group of premature babies living in a hospital nursery which imposed light/dark and noise/quiet rhythms than in a group who had been in a ward with less emphasis on the differences between night and day. 
 perhaps, therefore, a &bquo;natural&equo; rhythmic environment is beneficial. 
 It would be wrong to believe that the body clock develops only in response to a rhythmic environment and the effect upon the sleep/wake and feeding rhythms that this produces. 
 There are several pieces of evidence that suggest that daily rhythms develop spontaneously even in the absence of environmental cues. 
 &bull; In some children studied in a normal, rhythmic environment the sleep/wake rhythm shows an intermediate stage between a lack of rhythmicity and the presence of normal rhythms (Fig. 7.1). 
 This intermediate stage consists of what appears to be a free-running rhythm with a period that differs from 24 hours. 
 The observation that the period of the sleep/wake rhythm differs from 24 hours is important because it indicates that environmental cues cannot have been responsible. 
 &bull; In rare instances, new-born babies have been studied for several months in a constant environment in a hospital ward. 
 They develop a weak sleep/wake rhythm in the absence of external time cues, the implication of which has just been discussed. 
 &bull; In rodents, rhythms continue to develop in animals that have been reared for several generations in constant conditions. 
 This indicates that a rhythmic environment is not needed, but a possible effect from the rhythmic social and suckling influences of the mother has not been excluded. 
 &bull; In fruit-flies &mdash; an insect much used by geneticists &mdash; and in rodents there are various mutants that show abnormal rhythmic behaviour. 
 Some show no daily rhythms, others have a clock that runs faster than normal, with a &bquo;daily&equo; rhythm of 20 hours, and others show periods that are closer to 30 hours. 
 These mutations can be transmitted from one generation to the next in breeding studies. 
 Since these results are obtained in animals that have been living in a normal environment, they mean that the clock originates, at least in these animals, from an abnormal &bquo;internal&equo; structure, the chromosome. 
 But we would be equally wrong if we believed that the development of rhythms depended wholly upon internal factors. 
 It is probable that an individual &bquo;s daily rhythms would not develop fully in the absence of a rhythmic environment. 
 As with many other aspects of development, it is likely to be some mixture of &bquo;nature and nurture&equo;. 
 The potential to develop normal rhythms is present in us all and is part of our genetic make-up. 
 In normal environments this potential is fully realized. 
 In environments in which there is little daily rhythmicity, the development of daily rhythms occurs (see above) but it is not quite normal insofar as the amplitudes (sizes) of the rhythms are likely to be less. 
 In summary, with their development in infancy as well as their manifestation in adults, rhythms are associated with both external and internal causes. 
 Ultradian rhythms &mdash; the origin of daily rhythms? 
 It must not be assumed that the absence of a 24-hour rhythm in newborn babies means that they have no rhythms at all. 
 Indeed, they do show rhythms in activity, waking, feeding requirements, bladder-emptying and body temperature &mdash; rhythms that all have a period between one and four hours and so are called ultradian. 
 These ultradian rhythms are present in adults also, even though their amplitude is less than that of the 24-hour rhythm. 
 The clearest example of this is the alternation of two types of sleep &mdash; dream sleep and deep sleep, as described in Chapter 3 &mdash; but ultradian rhythms in urine production and the performance of mental tasks have been described also. 
 We have already seen that it is common to feel tired about lunchtime (the &bquo;post-lunch dip&equo;); this is about 12 hours after retiring and so is another example of an ultradian rhythm with a period less than 24 hours. 
 It has been considered that the simultaneous presence of ultradian and daily rhythms suggests that they are related in some way and possibly all come from the same body clock. 
 Further information about possible links can be obtained if we consider the way in which 24-hour rhythms &bquo;grow&equo; out of ultradian ones during infancy. 
 Ultradian cycles do not lengthen to become equal to 24 hours. 
 Instead, the times when one would expect the ultradian rhythm to produce a burst of activity or feeding drop out. 
 Take as an example the feeding behaviour of a growing baby that is demand-fed. 
 Initially he might be fed about every 4 hours. 
 In due course the parents are relieved when he begins to &bquo;miss&equo; his two o'clock and then his six o'clock feeds. 
 Presumably the 24-hour environment is interacting with his ultradian rhythms. 
 At night, even though the baby has woken, the quiet, dark, unstimulating environment makes him more likely to go back to sleep. 
 The important point is that if one ultradian peak is missed then the baby waits until the next peak. 
 As infancy progresses, the ultradian peaks at night are missed as the effect of the daily  (24-hour) rhythm becomes dominant. 
 In premature infants the development of the 24-hour sleep/ wake rhythm is delayed in comparison with that of full-term babies. 
 This result might indicate that the body clock is slow to mature in premature babies. 
 An alternative explanation, however, is that rhythms with a 24-hour period are received from the external world &mdash; but that these are picked up and transmitted to the body clock less effectively in premature babies. 
 What is certain (see Chapter 14) is that the fetus can respond to inputs from its mother which show a 24-hour period, whereas the newborn baby &mdash; particularly when premature &mdash; is much less able to respond to 24-hour rhythms in this new environment. 
 The time immediately after birth is one when the baby begins to respond to these new time-cues. 
 The end result is that components with a 24-hour period are dominant, both in the environment and in the body clock, by the time the child has reached his fifth birthday. 
 In some children, the development of daily rhythms is poor. 
 If the under-development applies to renal rhythms then the production of urine at night might be considerably higher than in normal children and this can lead to the problem of bed-wetting. 
 What all this work suggests is that the human's body clock and rhythms show several periods and that the combination of life-style and environment tends to accentuate one of these. 
 Interestingly, a 12-hour day is regularly being practised in those countries where an afternoon siesta is taken, and also by those watch-keepers on merchant ships where the shift pattern of the officers is often 4 hours work followed by 8 hours leisure and sleep, the combination being undertaken twice each 24 hours. 
 A sleep profile for someone on such a shift system is shown in Fig. 2.4. 
 Puberty and sexual maturation 
 The body clock plays a role in the complex changes that occur at puberty. 
 Growth hormone is released into the blood during the first part of sleep, but this is affected by the 24-hour body clock to a small extent only, so that changes in the timing of sleep are followed almost immediately by changes in growth hormone release. 
 However, growth hormone, like other hormones, is released in a series of short bursts and it is the frequency of these that is increased just after sleep onset (see fig. 3.2). 
 The total amount of growth hormone that is secreted per day increases to a maximum at about the time of puberty and is partially responsible for the growth spurt that is seen at about this time. 
 During puberty, in addition to the frequent bursts of hormone release at night, there are smaller, less frequent bursts during the daytime. 
 After puberty, the release of growth hormone tends to decline, first during the daytime and then during sleep; by old age (60 years and over) it has, in effect, fallen to zero, even at night. 
 These processes &mdash; a series of ultradian pulses, the frequency of which shows a 24-hour rhythm and the distribution of which alters with age &mdash; occur also with the sex hormones (see Fig 3.2). 
 In the male, testosterone is secreted throughout the 24 hours with higher values at night. 
 The total amount of testosterone secreted daily as well as the amplitude of the daily rhythm decline with age after a peak during youth; it resembles growth hormone, therefore, in these respects. 
 For females, from puberty to menopause there is a monthly cycle of oestrogens and progesterone and, in these also, daily and ultradian rhythms of release are found. 
 Such rhythms are normally observed throughout reproductive life, but the position is complicated because the amplitude of the 24-hour rhythm depends upon the stage of the monthly cycle that the female has reached. 
 After menopause theses daily rhythms decline in amplitude towards zero. 
 Rhythms in old age 
 With increasing age, our daily rhythms begin to change. 
 In general there are two types of change; a decrease in amplitude and an increase in the day-to-day differences in timing of the rhythm. 
 Why should these changes occur? 
 One change that is associated with ageing and that will alter the rhythms of hormone release is the declining ability of the body to respond to instructions from the brain. 
 This is very noticeable when the decreased amplitude of the daily rhythms of sex hormones is considered (see p. 81). 
 Thus, at least initially, the decline of sexual function is because the ovaries or testes become less responsive to normal signals from the brain. 
 In addition, ageing is associated with a general decrease in the ability of the body to respond or adjust to changes imposed upon it. 
 Not only will this worsen the symptoms of &bquo;jet-lag&equo; and any problems associated with shift-work but also it impairs the effectiveness of many systems which are responsible for controlling the body. 
 for example, the maintenance of blood pressure when changing from a lying to a standing position is achieved less rapidly as we age; as a result the blood supply to the brain is decreased for a longer time and there is a greater tendency to feel dizzy. 
 Another example, with an all too frequent tragic outcome, is shown by temperature regulation. 
 Older people are more susceptible to cold, in part because information from the brain in response to a lower blood temperature and a cool skin is acted upon less readily by the systems in the body that normally carry out those instructions. 
 There is the additional possibility that the body clock itself might, like other parts of the brain and body, deteriorate with age. 
 The body clock has been studied very little in older volunteers and so we do not know the answer to this. 
 Those few studies that have been carried out in free-running experiments suggest that the body clock might run slightly faster. 
 As a result we will go to bed and get up earlier, and we become more like &bquo;larks&equo;. 
 It is possible that the strength of the daily clock also decreases in the aged; this would mean that the amplitude of the rhythms it influences would decrease. 
 If this idea is applied to the sleep/wake rhythm, it means that the &bquo;polarity&equo; between waking activities during the daytime and nocturnal sleep would decrease. 
 Naps during the daytime and waking up during the night would both increase; these changes are often observed. 
 There is, however, a possible external cause to them as well as, or instead of, the internal cause. 
 Decreasing mobility and retirement are likely to reduce daytime activities and there will be a greater opportunity for daytime naps, particularly after lunch. 
 Less sleep is needed by the elderly, but the habits of a lifetime might not be changed automatically, with the result that individuals retire earlier than necessary and too much time is spent in bed. 
 Consequently, sleep might become disturbed, particularly when, in addition, kidney function does not decrease at night as much as it once did. 
 All these factors &mdash; due to external and internal causes &mdash; will conspire to produce an individual who is less polarized in his life-style between day and night. 
 An increased freedom in life-style might be supposed to account for the increased variability in timing of daily rhythms that is found in the elderly. 
 In a recent study performed by the authors, however, old people who lived at home were asked to record their habits each day (times of waking, eating, visiting friends, sleeping, etc) for a &bquo;typical week&equo;. 
 In this way we could get some idea of the day-by-day variability in the subjects' habits. 
 We found that older individuals showed less variability; in other words, they became more &bquo;set in their ways&equo; and this would tend to stabilize daily rhythms. 
 Therefore, the day-by-day changes in the timing of rhythms seen in the aged do not appear to be due to day-by-day irregularities of habits, and this suggests an internal cause due to the body clock. 
 further, it is intuitively likely that a clock that is becoming less strong is also becoming less accurate. 
 YOUR BODY CLOCK &mdash; MORE DETAILS 
 We have discussed the evidence for a body clock and the kinds of rhythmic change that it normally produces. 
 What we have not yet considered is where the body clock is and how it is adjusted by external time-cues. 
 We then need to comment on the usefulness of such a clock. 
 Where is the body clock? 
 We do not know the exact site of the body clock in humans for the obvious reason that experiments to determine this are unethical. 
 We do, however, have some fairly clear ideas as to its whereabouts in several mammals including monkeys, near-neighbours to us in an evolutionary sense. 
 Interest has centred on the role of two small groups of cells, one on either side of the brain, that are called the suprachiasmatic nuclei (SCN). 
 Their position in the brain is important because: 
 &bull; They are part of a region of the brain called the hypothalamus which also controls body temperature, food and water intake, sexual drive, and hormone secretion. 
 &bull; They are close to those regions of the brain which are involved in controlling sleep and alertness and exchange large amounts of information with these areas. 
 &bull; They are (as their name indicates) immediately above the optic chiasm, an area where the two nerves which carry visual information from the eyes cross over each other on their way to that part of the brain that analyses vision. 
 Evidence that the SCN are the body clock can be summarized as follow: (1) Rhythmic electrical activity can be recorded from the nerve cells that make up the SCN and this rhythm has a period of about 24 hours. 
 Clearly this is a promising start for a clock, but it might indicate instead that these cells receive a rhythmic input from another region of the brain which is the clock. 
 In the same way, nerve cells in the spinal cord show activity whenever a particular movement is made by the arm. 
 These cells are not, however, the origin  of arm movement but are merely driven by other regions of the brain. 
 (2) Removing the SCN abolishes the rhythms of feeding, drinking, and activity. 
 Although this result would be required if the SCN were the clock, two problems still remain. 
 First, there would be the same result if the SCN were part of the transmission pathway by which the body clock communicates with the rest of the body (see above). 
 Second, and this will be commented upon, some rhythms begin to show ultradian periods (that is, ones with a cycle length of 1&ndash;4 hours) rather than a complete absence of rhythmicity after removal of the SCN. (3) Neural connections between the SCN and most other regions of the brain have been cut and yet the SCN has continued to be rhythmic. 
 This appears to remove the objection raised in (1) above, except that: 
 &bull; Severing all  the inputs to the SCN is not possible technically. 
 &bull; Chemical links between the SCN and the rest of the brain are not removed by this technique. 
 (4) Slices of the brain have been removed and incubated in special tissue-culture chambers. 
 When these chambers have been maintained in constant conditions, the electrical activity from slices of the SCN, but not from other regions of the brain, has shown a daily rhythm. 
 (5) Very recently it has been shown that transplants of the SCN can be used to pass rhythmicity from one animal to another. 
 The results in (4) and (5) appear to remove the reservations expressed above. 
 Do these findings, taken together, indicate that the SCN are the site of the body clock? 
 Some would say they do, but others believe another interpretation is better. 
 This alternative is based on the observations in (2) above that ultradian rhythms arise after removal of the SCN. 
 They suggest that the SCN coordinates ultradian inputs (from other regions of the brain) to produce the 24-hour rhythm. 
 Without the SCN the ultradian rhythms would continue &mdash; only the 24-hour component would be missing. 
 Further work is required to test this idea. 
 Certainly, if it were true, it would readily enable explanations for the simultaneous presence of daily and ultradian rhythms in the adult and the switch from ultradian to daily rhythms during the months after birth (see Chapter 7). 
 The requirement for a clock to show more than one period is not a problem. 
 Consider, for example, a mechanical clock: its several cogwheels will all turn at different rates and it is almost an arbitrary decision to link some of these to &bquo;hands&equo; that tell us the passage of the seconds, minutes, hours, or lunar month. 
 So too with the body clock: it might be that several outputs with different periods are possible and that we tend to concentrate upon the daily or circadian clock because this is the period that is most useful to the organism and which has naturally been accentuated by the environment with its 24-hour period. 
 As far as humans are concerned, we know that SCN are present in that region of the brain which controls body temperature and the release of various hormones. 
 It will be recalled that temperature and cortisol show a daily rhythm that is much influenced by the body clock and this suggests, but does not prove, that humans and other primates are very similar with regard to the site of the body clock. 
 How do time-cues exert their effects upon the body clock? 
 One advantage of siting the body clock in the SCN becomes apparent once we try to understand how time-cues might affect it. 
 Considering the importance of the light/dark cycle as a time-cue, we must expect that there will be some sort of link between the body clock and the eyes. 
 It has been shown in some animal species that there are nerves running from the eyes to the SCN. 
 Whilst their presence does not prove that this is how the light/dark cycle normally adjusts the clock, it does seem to make it a very reasonable working hypothesis. 
 To test this hypothesis further would require selectively cutting these nerves, which, as yet, has not been possible technically. 
 What about other time-cues? 
 In humans, as we have shown, there are also possible time-cues from the timing of meals, the sleep/wake rhythm and social activities (see Chapter 2). 
 Again, we do not know how the time-cues work but there are schemes that can very reasonably be suggested. 
 Thus, sleeping and being awake are controlled by a region of the brain that is not only close to the SCN but also exchanges large amounts of information with them. 
 In addition, activities &mdash; whether due to muscle exercise, mental effort, or the excitement associated with social interactions &mdash; will alter the amount of nervous activity passing through this region of the brain. 
 Rhythmic changes in this neural activity could be the means by which an individual's lifestyle could act as a time-cue for his body clock. 
 It is equally likely that the activities associated with meals (chewing, digesting and absorbing food) could all send information to the SCN via nerves from the gut. 
 In addition, the absorption of food from the gut alters the relative concentrations of different amino acids (building blocks for protein) in the blood. 
 This changes their uptake into the brain and incorporation into substances that enable brain cells to communicate with each other and the rest of the body. 
 Clearly, a rhythm in food intake might be able to adjust the body clock via several mechanisms. 
 We stress that these are only proposals. 
 They still require experimental evidence before they can be accepted as fact. 
 Even so, we are taking the first steps in a long journey towards an understanding of the body clock and the way it adjusts to our environment. 
 The usefulness of the body clock 
 What advantage do we gain by possessing a body clock? 
 Could we not argue that the plant or animal responds to the rhythms in its environment anyway? 
 (That, after all, is what is meant by the external cause of a daily rhythm.) for example, could we not argue that the plant could move its leaves in response to the sun; the shore-dwelling creature leave its burrow in the mud when the tide recedes; or the diurnal or nocturnal animal respond to sunrise and sunset? 
 Notice that by this argument, such changes are initiated from outside the organisms and so inevitably occur after  the initiating event. 
 Particularly with plants, these responses might be rather slow. 
 For example, the process of moving leaves into the right position to catch most sunlight takes time, so that, because the sun appears to move continuously, the position of the leaves will always be behind the ideal one. 
 for the animal in its mud burrow, valuable time will be lost if it cannot prepare itself for foraging until after  the tide has left the shore. 
 The advantage of a body clock is that it can prepare an animal or plant and enable it to predict a future environmental condition and so be ready for the event when it takes place . 
 Thus the plant can, during the latter part of the night, move its leaves to a position appropriate for sunrise; predatory animals can prepare themselves for the activity of hunting and hunted animals can escape to safety before it is too late. 
 For humans, as we have discussed in Chapter 1, the body has been &bquo;waking us up&equo; since about 5 o'clock in the morning so that, by the time we normally wake, we are prepared for the rigours of a new day; in the evening our body begins to &bquo;tone us down&equo; to prepare us for getting to sleep. 
 Responses to the environment are still required, of course, because the body clock is not a perfect timekeeper and, anyway, environments cannot be predicted precisely &mdash; the tide can be higher, food abnormally scarce, or the day more cloudy so darkness comes earlier. 
 Both mechanisms &mdash; that due to the clock and that due to the environment &mdash; are required by a living organism, and our previous discussion of the roles of the environment, as an external cause of a rhythm as well as a Zeitgeber  giving time-cues to adjust the body clock, shows how intimate their combination is under normal circumstances. 
 This integration between the environment and the organism is a fine example of the evolutionary response of a living organism to ecological factors. 
 Ecology is the study of the organism and its relationship to the environment. 
 Time and rhythms are an integral part of this relationship. 
 Humans are bounded by such principles as much as are other living organisms. 
 Technological advances might mean that we live in an artificial environment with respect to time-cues, but it is a rhythmic  environment nevertheless, and our possession of a body clock means that all the advantages that come from the integration of biological and environmental rhythms apply equally to ourselves. 
 Now try this &mdash; 5 
 A scientific problem &mdash; number 1 
 To get some ideas of the difficulties involved in studying the body clock &mdash; a structure hidden inside the brain whose activity can only be inferred indirectly by measuring the rhythms it is believed to produce &mdash; consider the following analogy. 
 A family of four is believed to be involved in organizing a spy-ring from their home. 
 You have to prove this. 
 You have free access to the family outside their house, but when they are inside you can investigate them only by looking through the windows of their house. 
 You have no helpers and can only devote a total of 4 hours observation time to the task on any day. 
 What is the best way to approach the task? 
 The answer will depend upon your definition of &bquo;best&equo;, of course, but some of the decisions you will have to make are listed below. 
 (Comments in brackets refer to comparable difficulties when studying the body clock.) (1) When should you study the family? 
 (You are rarely able to sample rhythms as often as you would like.) (a) Are your 4 hours of observations made in a single session or a number of sessions? (b) If it is a single session, is this at the same time or at different times each day? (c) If it is at different times, then how do you arrange them? (d) If it is a number of sessions, then how many? 
 Having decided upon this you then have the problems in (c). 
 (2) How should you study the family when it is at home? 
 (Do you concentrate on a large or small area of the brain; if the latter, which one, if the site of the clock has not been established beyond all doubt?) (a) Do you follow one person only throughout your observation time(s) or choose, instead, a single place to see which of the family, if any, are there? (b) If you choose to observe a single place, then do you study a place that is large or small, say, the front garden, a single- room, or the exit at the end of the drive? (c) If it is a single room, which one? 
 Do you change the room? 
 If so, how often? 
 To which other place? 
 You might argue that such an investigation, though time-consuming, would enable you to build up the picture you want. 
 But consider how the following additional constraints would make your task so much more difficult (and relate these constraints to the problems of being unable to study the SCN directly, of being unsure of exactly how it then sends its information to produce the rhythms in, say, temperature or urine flow &mdash; things that we can  measure &mdash; and even of not being certain that the SCN is the only area in the brain that is part of the body clock). 
 1. 
 You are not quite sure exactly how the spies would communicate with each other &mdash; that is, are you to investigate letters, phone calls, radio transmissions, or informal notes? 
 2. 
 The house is surrounded by a high wall. 
 You know that there are many paths leading to the house and from the house, but: (a) You do not know how many there are, where they come from, or where they go to. 
 (b) You cannot study some of these paths closely &mdash; they are guarded and can be viewed only from a distance. 
 (c) In addition, there are so many visitors that you have no time to question them all. 
 Which would you choose? (3) There is now a rumour that the family has another house, which may be used for organizing the syndicate, in addition to/ instead of the house you are observing, but you don't know the location of the other house. 
 It is not quite so simple now, is it? 
 Even though you might continue to build up a picture of the whole operation, it must be based upon an increasing number of assumptions &mdash; and assumptions might be wrong, with potentially catastrophic effects upon the correctness of your account of the family and its activities. 
 YOUR BODY CLOCK IN DISORDER 
 We have considered so far the daily rhythms of humans in health. 
 In Part II we describe the effects of abnormalities of daily rhythms. 
 These abnormalities arise either because there is an abnormality in some aspect of the timing system itself or because modern society has made demands upon us that have outstripped our biological evolution. 
 But to end our book on jet-lag and shift-work would be too negative, and so we will end by describing an area in which the knowledge of daily rhythms has enabled a small but important contribution to medicine to be made &mdash; the diagnosis and treatment of illness and disease. 
 ABNORMALITIES AND DAILY RHYTHMS 
 In the simplest terms, the daily timing system consists of a body clock that is synchronized by external time-cues and that sends information to a variety of systems in the body and so produces daily rhythms in them. 
 Intuitively, one would guess that abnormalities could arise at many points in such a system and we will now consider severe clinical disorders which bear this out. 
 Patients with severe illness and general irregularities in daily rhythm 
 Daily rhythms are abnormal in subjects who have recently undergone major surgery or who are in intensive care because of serious illness. 
 There are many reasons why this might be so. 
 Some possibilities are: &bull; The patient, particularly in an intensive care unit which has artificial rather than natural lighting, is in an environment that is poor with respect to natural time-cues. 
 &bull; The patient's treatment &mdash; including artificial feeding, ventilation, etc. &mdash; is likely to be continuous rather than rhythmic. 
 Many drugs will be given if and when needed, probably with no obvious rhythm. 
 &bull; The patient's perception of his environment and his response to it is likely to be grossly reduced, since he might be unconscious or paralysed, for example. 
 Accepting these abnormalities in the patient then the abnormality of the timing system that might be observed could take one of several forms. 
 There could be: 
 &bull; A complete loss of rhythmicity (because the body clock or its expression has been suppressed); 
 &bull; A free-running rhythm with a period greater than 24 hours (because the time-cues were too weak or the subject was unable to receive or respond to them adequately); 
 &bull; A rhythm of reduced amplitude (because the external cause of a rhythm was reduced and/or because the internal cause was weak); 
 &bull; An abnormal clock period due to recurrent episodes of an illness or its treatment. 
 Bearing all these factors in mind, the demonstration that patients in intensive care show abnormal daily rhythms, and that these abnormalities take on many forms, is not surprising. 
 Unfortunately, since there are so many possible explanations, the correct one is most difficult to ascertain. 
 Yet, if a lack of time-cues or a difficulty in perceiving them were important in some cases, then a possibility that has not yet been tested is one of attempting to promote the presence of 24-hour rhythms in a patient by increasing external time-cues or by administering sedation and intravenous feeding on a daily schedule. 
 The basis for such a treatment would have some parallel with the imposition of a daily routine and 24-hour environmental cues upon premature babies (see Chapter 7). 
 A loss of adjustment to the 24-hour day 
 Some individuals, even when living in normal society, do not remain in synchrony with the 24-hour day and instead free-run with a period of about 25 hours. 
 For some, the reason is one of choice; they do not have a job or social links that tie them to a 24 hour day. 
 A single, introverted individual who was self-catering and whose job did not require contact with others would be able to live like this. 
 There is not necessarily any &bquo;problem&equo; here. 
 Such an individual could choose to ignore conventional time-cues and so cocoon himself in an artificial world in which meals and artificial lighting are adjusted to accord with the dictates of his body clock &mdash; like the subject in a cave (in chapter 2) and the opposite of what happens normally, when our life-style adjusts our body clock. 
 His sleep pattern might look something like that shown in fig. 2.2. 
 There are, however, some examples where the individual appears unable to adjust to a 24-hour routine in spite of attempts to do so. 
 One example was of a graduate who enjoyed a good job with normal daytime hours. 
 His body clock free-ran so that on occasions he was the victim of a clash between an internal cause &mdash; which thought it was night and wanted him to sleep &mdash; and an external cause, society &mdash; which required him to work in the (real) daytime. 
 The unfortunate subject would feel tired at work and yet have difficulty in sleeping at night. 
 At other times, the demands of his body clock and society coincided but then much of his time would be spent catching up on lost sleep. 
 In fact this individual found the stress of such an existence too much and was forced to leave his job. 
 Less extreme cases than this are more common (see fig. 2.4). 
 Thus individuals might retire and rise progressively later each day until they would miss a whole sleep because it was going to clash with daytime commitments. 
 At this point they would go to bed slightly earlier than the rest of us (because they were tired), and start the delaying process all over again. 
 The problem seems to be that social factors are not a strong enough time-cue. 
 This might reflect the individual's lack of interest in normal social factors, some error in the pathway linking time-cues to the body clock or some abnormality in the clock itself &mdash; an insensitivity to normal time-cues, for example. 
 There is another group, the blind or partially sighted, who cannot make satisfactory use of the light/dark cycle as a time-cue. 
 Even though their life-style is often timed normally, daily rhythms of body temperature and the concentrations of the hormones melatonin (see below) and cortisol in the blood are irregular, often with what appears to be a free-running period. 
 Even though the obvious explanation of the abnormal rhythmicity is that these people suffer from the loss of the light/dark cycle as a time-cue, the result also indicates that the other time-cues (social factors, activity, and meal times) are inadequate. 
 Promoting adjustment to a 24-hour day 
 For those examples that have been described so far, the best advice that can be given to individuals is to help them to strengthen their time-cues and to take more notice of them. 
 (Readers might be reminded of Now Try This &mdash; 2, Chapter 2). 
 for example, an Individual with difficulty in adjusting to a 24-hour day should make every attempt to strengthen the rhythmic influence of social factors and meal times by adhering as rigidly as possible to a regular routine. 
 In addition, he might consider taking a shower or some exercise on waking, procedures which are aimed at stressing a regular start to the day. 
 Another method that has been tested upon some blind people is the regular use of the hormone melatonin, a product of the pineal gland. 
 The pineal gland is a small structure buried deep on the brain. 
 Its function in man is not certain. 
 (It was believed by Descartes to be the seat of the soul.) 
 In some animals its biological role is more clearly defined. 
 In them it is concerned with picking up information about the timing and length of daylight. 
 This information is then used to control the seasonal breeding cycle. 
 Since the pineal produces its hormone melatonin only during the dark, melatonin might also be used to match the sleep/wake rhythm of the animal to the light/dark rhythm. 
 In such cases melatonin might be some sort of &bquo;darkness indicator&equo; and some have even called it an &bquo;internal time-cue&equo;. 
 The important point is that melatonin might be a link between the environment and body clock in ourselves also and its release might promote inactivity or tiredness. 
 There is some support for this in that melatonin capsules can be taken in the evening to produce a consistent overnight rise in the blood concentration of this hormone and that this treatment appears to stabilize the sleep/wake rhythm of blind subjects. 
 Clocks adjusted to the wrong time &mdash; &bquo;Monday morning blues&equo; and some forms of insomnia 
 Most of us experience &bquo;Monday morning blues&equo; &mdash; the feeling of tiredness and low spirits on the first day back at work after the weekend of rest. 
 Our body clock has adjusted readily enough to the delay in our life-style at the weekend (remember that the free-running period is more than 24 hours), but is less easily advanced, as is required, on Sunday night and Monday morning (see Chapter 2). 
 Most of us are back to normal by Tuesday, however, because we can advance our body clock, even if with some difficulty. 
 Insomnia is a common complaint in which the sufferer has poor sleep that is often broken many times during the course of the night. 
 There is no evidence in the great majority of cases that an altered body clock is in any way responsible, but there is one group of people who suffer from a fairly rare form of insomnia called Delayed Sleep phase Syndrome. 
 They cannot get to sleep until about 2 o'clock in the morning or later, even when they go to bed much earlier. 
 As a result, they are normally very tired during weekdays when they are compelled to wake at a normal time for work. 
 On holiday and at weekends, however, they recover their loss of sleep since they can get their full quota, say 8 hours, between 2 and 10 o'clock in the morning. 
 They are not free-running &mdash; they are stabilized to a 24-hour day. 
 It is just that they show a very late timing of their sleep/wake rhythm with respect to normal time-cues. 
 It appears that they can delay their body clock with ease but they cannot advance it, so that if they ever go to bed late then they are stuck with a body clock (and bed-time) that tends to become ever more delayed. 
 The treatment is simple. 
 &bull; Patients are asked to go to bed 3 hours later each &bquo;night&equo; and get up 3 hours later each &bquo;morning&equo; &mdash; this they will find easy, of course. 
 &bull; After several days on this schedule they will be going to bed and getting up at their chosen time, one that gives them enough sleep during the weekdays. 
 &bull; They must now stick strictly to a 24-hour life-style &mdash; no late nights &mdash; or they will have to begin treatment all over again. 
 This is not a cure, since the underlying problem has not been tackled. 
 Indeed, the exact cause of the problem is not clear, though possible explanations include: 
 &bull; A body clock that runs slower than average; 
 &bull; Poorly developed means by which time-cues are passed to the clock; 
 &bull; A body clock that is insensitive to normal time-cues. 
 Whatever the explanation, the above treatment is cheap, does not involve drugs and gives the patient a greater control over his treatment. 
 An even less common form of insomnia is Advanced Sleep Phase Syndrome. 
 When one considers the symptoms (going to sleep and waking up very early), the treatment (advancing the patient's life-style by 3 hour per &bquo;day&equo; until it is correctly timed), or the possible causes (a clock that runs faster than average), it is seen as the opposite of Delayed Sleep Phase Syndrome. 
 Perhaps it will have occurred to the reader that there might be links between the disorders and treatments described so far. 
 Thus a free-running rhythm indicates that the time-cues are not strong enough to entrain the body clock to a 24-hour period. 
 This might be because the time-cues are too weak, the transmission of them to the body clock is poor, the clock itself is insensitive to time cues, or it possesses an abnormally long or short free-running period. 
 The treatment has been to strengthen the time-cues by increasing the regularity of an individual's life-style (and all the time-cues this entails), or by mimicking this by taking melatonin regularly. 
 Further, as is often the case, the clinical conditions might be regarded as rather extreme cases of variability in the ease with which we adjust our body clock, a process that is found normally within the human population. 
 As discussed in Chapter 7, ageing increases the tendency for us to become &bquo;larks&equo; &mdash; and some of us are &bquo;larks&equo; anyway &mdash; because the body clock has then a free-running period that is below the average for the population as a whole. 
 In an extreme case, this might result in Advanced Sleep Phase Syndrome and even require clinical treatment. 
 Likewise there might be a progressive increase in the free-running period of the body clock as we pass through the sequence: &bquo;slightly an owl&equo;, &bquo;definitely an owl&equo;, Delayed Sleep Phase Syndrome, free-running rhythm in normal society. 
 Some forms of depression &mdash; inadequate timing systems? 
 There are many forms of depression and a connection between abnormal body clocks and three types of depression have been suspected: rapidly cycling manic-depression, some forms of endogenous depression and seasonal affective disorder. 
 At the outset we must state that the picture is still very unclear and that those forms of depressions which can be linked to an abnormal body clock are likely to form only a small proportion of all cases. 
 Manic depression 
 Patients with this disorder switch between mania and depression; a few do so regularly. 
 One very clear example is shown in Fig. 9.1. 
 Also included is a plot of the time of peak of body temperature on successive days. 
 The time of peak becomes progressively earlier. 
 When the temperature peak was at about the normal time, the patient showed a temporary remission of symptoms; when the temperature was timed too early she tended to feel depressed; and when it was timed too late she tended to experience mania. 
 One explanation of the progressive advance of the temperature rhythm is that it is being driven by a body clock that is running too fast. 
 In this case it shows a period of about 21 hours which is too rapid to be adjusted to a normal value of 24 hours. 
 Interestingly, some, but not all, patients (&bquo;lithium responders&equo;) show a remission of symptoms when they take tablets containing lithium salts. 
 Lithium exerts many effects in the body. 
 It has been shown that, in some animals, one of these is that lithium slows the free-running period of the body clock. 
 The argument might be put forward, therefore, that the treatment slows the body clock enough for it now to be adjusted to a 24-hour day by normal time-cues. 
 The &bquo;explanation&equo; raises many problems, not the least being why the symptoms should depend upon whether the temperature rhythm is delayed or advanced with respect to the sleep/wake rhythm. 
 Endogenous depression and seasonal affective disorder 
 In some cases of endogenous depression there was one symptom which suggested that an abnormality of the internal clock might exist. 
 It was where depression was most marked in the morning and decreased during the course of the day. 
 It was also noted that patients reported an improvement in their mood if they were woken early or deprived of sleep and so, presumably, exposed to daylight much earlier in the day. 
 The idea arose that in healthy subjects there is a &bquo;critical period&equo; early in the morning (but after we have woken up) when light is &bquo;required&equo; by the body. 
 In patients with this type of depression, their critical period is advanced so that it falls during sleep. 
 As a result, the body would not normally receive light during the critical period, but it would do so if the patient stayed awake all night or got up early. 
 In apparent agreement with this idea, some subjects appeared to benefit from continual advances of their sleep/wake rhythm (as though they were continually flying eastward) or by being woken temporarily at about four o'clock in the morning to receive a burst of bright light for about an hour. 
 Both treatments would enable patients to be awake and so to receive light at their earlier &bquo;critical period&equo;. 
 The advance of this critical period, however, cannot easily be linked to the idea of a body clock which tends to run fast and so produce daily rhythms which are timed too early because, when daily rhythms have been investigated in these patients, it appears that daily rhythms are irregular , rather than altered in a particular direction. 
 There is, however, one type of depression in which shifts of daily rhythms are found more regularly &mdash; Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD). 
 Strictly, this is outside the remit of this book since it is a seasonal or annual rhythm, but we include it since it is believed to involve a disorder of daily rhythms. 
 Seasonal affective disorder is associated with depression that is marked during the Winter and early Spring and regresses in the Summer. 
 It has been suggested that it occurs when susceptible individuals do not get enough natural light during the winter months. 
 In support of this view is the finding that the incidence of SAD amongst different populations increases as one passes from the equator towards higher latitudes &mdash; as do the length of the winter nights and the likelihood of waking in the dark on winter mornings. 
 Early successes in the treatment of this disorder consisted of exposing patients to bright light in the morning, so mimicking the longer hours of daylight associated with summer. 
 More recently, however, it has been found that bright light at other times of the day &mdash; in the evening, which also mimics the light in summer-time, and at noon, which does not lengthen daylight hours &mdash; has an effect also. 
 As we have already discussed, bright light acts as a time-cue in humans and so might be helping patients not only because it fell in a critical period (though how this might work is still not known), but in addition, or instead, because it adjusted the body clock and so removed a conflict of timing between the patient's body clock and his sleep/wake rhythm. 
 Thus, if the body clock is delayed then one tries to advance it by giving bright light in the morning, and if it is advanced then the light is given in the evening to delay it. 
 (In effect, such treatment is using bright light as a time-cue to adjust the body clock appropriately.) 
 Some researchers have obtained very impressive results with such a treatment. 
 patients recover from their depression at about the same time that their body clock, as measured by the melatonin rhythm, adjusts its phase to match the sleep/wake rhythm. 
 Whilst this is an effective treatment, there are certain comments that must be considered from a scientific viewpoint: 
 &bull; Some patients should have bright light when it would be predicted to worsen their symptoms by adjusting the body clock in the wrong direction. 
 Of course there are ethical problems here but, in the absence of these control experiments, it might be that light is exerting its effect by some other means, say, by encouraging the patient to become more active. 
 &bull; How well do changes in the melatonin rhythm measure changes in the body clock? 
 (Remember the hypothesis is that the treatment is successful because it adjusts the clock.) 
 Adjustment of other markers of the body clock (such as body temperature) should also be measured. 
 &bull; With all treatments that are designed to improve the mood or feelings of a patient, the placebo effect must also be considered. 
 The placebo effect means that any  treatment will improve a patient merely because he wants to recover and is responding to the clinician's attempts to help rather than to a specific treatment. 
 In summary, it is not yet clear that a modification of the daily rhythms is a necessary requirement of treatment or that an abnormality of the body clock is the cause of the disorder. 
 It should also be pointed out that other circumstances where there is an abnormality of timing of the body clock (for example, after a time-zone transition, during shift-work, in blind subjects and in patients with Delayed Sleep phase Syndrome) all tend to produce and feeling of malaise rather than a fully-blown clinical depression. 
 further work needs to be performed in this important area. 
 For example, it is possible that clinical cases are only an extreme form of a normal reaction to the short winter days. 
 It must be realized that many people are less excited about going to work in the dark rather than the light &mdash; a dull start to the day. 
 Also it might be that those who suffer from SAD differ from most people only because they are more susceptible than the rest of the population to feeling &bquo;under the weather&equo; when they do not see daylight, particularly in the morning. 
 If this is correct then there are important implications for people who are &bquo;near the borderline&equo;, if it is decided not to change the clocks between the summer and winter, but rather to retain Daylight Saving Time throughout the year. 
 The extra hour of daylight in the winter evenings that this would mean would also be accompanied by an extra hour of darkness in the winter mornings. 
 Now try this &mdash; 8 
 A scientific problem &mdash; Number 2 
 Consider the following comments about SAD. 
 Can you devise ways of testing them? 
 These are questions designed to test an understanding of the scientific method, not means diagnosis or recipes for treatment. 
 (If you think that you are a SAD sufferer then contact your doctor.) (1) Most SAD cases are referred to clinics in the months December to April. 
 (a) How could you test if the factor which causes SAD was lack of light or the cold weather? (b) Would you get more information by considering patients who had suffered for several years rather than only once? (2) Bright light is often found to bring relief. 
 How would you eliminate a placebo effect &mdash; that is, the treatment works because the patient thinks (or hopes) that it will? (3) Carbohydrate (sugar) intake is found to increase in patients with SAD. 
 How could you show that this was not because chocolate bars, sweets, etc., are more likely to be eaten since your depression means that you cannot be bothered to cook a proper meal? 
 Some comments follow on the next page. 
 1. 
 (a) Ask patients when the symptoms first appeared. 
 (This assumes they can recall this accurately). 
 Does this tend to correspond to spells of cold weather, to times of dull weather, or the length of daylight? 
 Does the onset of SAD symptoms depend upon whether the subject lives an &bquo;outdoor&equo; or &bquo;indoor&equo; life? (b) The patients could keep a diary of their moods throughout the year, a form of self-diagnosis. 
 Moreover, they are likely to consult their doctor after a shorter delay if their SAD is a recurrent problem; this is a suggestion that could be tested statistically. 
 2. 
 Give some other &bquo;treatment&equo; that does not involve bright light. 
 Exercise? 
 Sitting in front of a set of dim lights? 
 Giving noise or music? 
 Unfortunately, patients are likely to have learned from media coverage that light is somehow involved, so they will have a prejudice against other treatments. 
 Even so, giving bright light at a time which should not affect the body clock or even adjust it in the wrong direction could be tested &mdash; as has already been described. 
 3. 
 Make all types of food (protein, fat, and roughage as well as carbohydrate) equally easy to obtain. 
 In practice this might require constant supervision of the patients over the course of several weeks. 
 An alternative would be for patients to keep a daily record of their food. 
 Not all could, or would, do this but, even if they did, the problem that patients might choose the type of food because of habit rather than careful deliberation still exists. 
 (In fact, there is carbohydrate craving , so it is not just a matter of apathy about cooking.) 
 We hope another point is made by these questions and comments, namely that the problem is very complex, requires large amounts of meticulous study, and the results are most difficult to interpret unambiguously. 
 TIME-ZONE TRANSITIONS &mdash; THE PROBLEM 
 What is jet-lag? 
 The tour operator for a trip to New York, Delhi, or any distant land will stress the comfort and the excitement of it all, the new places, people and life-style, and the sense of romance and adventure. 
 The possible fatigue, indigestion, headaches, irregular bowel habits, difficulty with sleeping and concentrating &mdash; in fact, generally feeling &bquo;below par&equo; &mdash; will not be mentioned. 
 These are the symptoms of &bquo;jet-lag&equo;, and they are being experienced by more and more people as flights &mdash; many no longer a short journey across to France but spanning the globe &mdash; become more common. 
 How does jet-lag affect us? 
 Why do we get it? 
 And, most importantly, what can we do about it? 
 The symptoms of jet-lag have already been mentioned. 
 They constitute an assortment of ill-defined symptoms that affect people in different ways and to different extents. 
 Typically, a person suffering from jet-lag will feel tired at some point in the daytime and yet be unable to sleep well at night through difficulty getting to sleep or waking early. 
 This will increase a sense of general fatigue and might result in headaches and difficulties with concentration. 
 Appetite might be poor and food that is eaten will be difficult to digest; bowel movements will occur at inconvenient times in the night or at unaccustomed times during the day, or the traveller might suffer constipation for a few days. 
 Older people, those who are less regular in their life-style and solitary people, all tend to be affected more than the young, the methodical and the social extrovert. 
 The symptoms are generally worse the further you fly and they are more marked after eastward flights than those to the west. 
 Flights in a north-south direction (or vice versa) give less trouble than either eastward or westward journeys. 
 What causes jet-lag? 
 Why is the body so disorientated? 
 There is a combination of two factors: the change in time zone and the sluggishness of our body rhythms to adjust to change. 
 We must consider each in turn. 
 Time zones 
 The Earth revolves on its axis once every 24 hours. 
 As a result, each country (except those close to the Poles) will experience sunrise, the passage of the sun across the sky, sunset and night once each revolution. 
 Because of the direction in which the Earth revolves, the sun always rises in the east and sets in the west. 
 As we travel to the east, therefore, these events occur earlier and, on a westward journey, they take place progressively later. 
 The time at which the sun is highest in the sky is also affected in the same way. 
 This moment is defined as noon on local time. 
 This has the obvious advantage that all countries match their local time to the hours of daylight, but it also means that different countries have different local times. 
 In order to standardize all these local times, the worlds has been divided into 24 time zones &mdash; each spanning 15 &deg; longitude. 
 Matters are made easier for us in the United Kingdom since the time zone that all others are related to is that which passes through England &mdash; Greenwich Mean Time (GMT). 
 Countries to the east of us are in time zones with local time that is ahead of GMT, whereas local time and the time zones to the west are delayed with respect to ours. 
 for example, when it is 4 o'clock in the afternoon (1600) &mdash; in England, it is 11 o'clock in the morning (1100) in New York (5 time zones to the west), 8 o'clock in the morning (0800) in Los Angeles (8 time zones to the west), 8 o'clock in the evening (2000) in Abu Dhabi (4 time zones to the east), and midnight (at the end of the day) in Singapore (8 time zones to the east). 
 The position is complicated in 2 ways. 
 first, countries modify local time by 1 or 2 hours, according to whether it is winter or summer, in order to make more use of the daylight hours. 
 Second, if a traveller goes eastwards halfway round the Earth he will have passed through 12 time zones and gained 12 hours with respect to GMT; he will meet another traveller who has travelled westward and so is 12 time zones (12 hours) behind GMT. 
 At this point on the Earth (180 &deg; longitude) the International Dateline is reached. 
 Suppose it is 12 noon on a Monday by GMT; at this moment, to the traveller who has travelled eastwards it will be midnight at the end of Monday, but to the westward traveller it will be midnight at the beginning of Monday. 
 That is, crossing the International Date Line means that we either gain a day (eastwards crossing) or lose one (westwards crossing). 
 A further consequence of having time zones is that, when we travel we have to adjust to local time in the new time zone. 
 It is this adjustment which causes difficulties for our body rhythms. 
 The body clock and time-zone transitions 
 The advantage of our body clock is that it improves the way in which we fit into a rhythmic environment (this was considered in more detail in Chapter 8). 
 Thus our falling plasma adrenalin and body temperature in the evening prepare us for sleep by toning us down, just as rising values from 5 o'clock in the morning onwards prepare us for the rigours of a new day. 
 An important property of such a clock is its stability; that is, its timing does not alter much from day to day. 
 It can be seen that this very advantage now becomes disadvantageous after a time-zone transition when an adjustment of our body to new local time is required. 
 for some days after the flight, the body clock &mdash; and with it our daily rhythms &mdash; will tend to lag behind. 
 Not only do we feel disorientated with respect to our habits but also there are more objective measurements to indicate that the flight has disorganized us. 
 If we measure our rhythms in mental performance (our ability to do mental arithmetic or to reason logically) we find that the normal daytime peak, with a morning rise and evening fall, is absent. 
 Instead, we might find that performance is improving just before bedtime, and deteriorating after sleep. 
 Superimposed upon this will be a general decline in performance due to loss of sleep and fatigue. 
 Moreover, body temperature and adrenalin rhythms will show a similar disorientation. 
 Jet-lag is the consequence of there being a mis-match between our body clock and the external timing, because our body clock is slow to adjust to the change in local time.  
 Knowledge of this fact, together with understanding some properties of our body clock, will enable us to promote adjustment of our clock to the new time zone and so reduce the difficulties of jet-lag . 
 Other explanations of jet-lag 
 There is no reason whatsoever why our explanation of jet-lag as a consequence of a mismatching between the body clock and the new external environment should go unquestioned. 
 Accordingly, we offer some comments on some alternative &bquo;explanations&equo; that have been given. 
 As is often the case, they contain some truth and can be used constructively when attempting to deal with jet-lag. 
 It is &bquo;in the mind' 
 This is partially true. 
 Many of the symptoms of jet-lag relate to how we feel, but such an explanation does not explain why we should feel below par, and seems less acceptable when one would expect the mind to be concentrated on enjoying oneself on holiday or performing at one's peak on business or at athletics, for instance. 
 Moreover, the abnormal timing of bowel habits, of hunger and, particularly, of temperature, performance, and hormone rhythms is difficult to explain in these psychosomatic terms. 
 Certainly, expecting that you will suffer from jet-lag hardly helps and this becomes an argument for adopting a positive attitude to the difficulties and knowing that they can be minimized by following the advice we give later. 
 It is due to the inconvenience of intercontinental flight 
 Disruption of our normal routine, loss of sleep, waiting for the flight to be called, and the apprehension associated with flying will all take their toll. 
 The severity of jet-lag, however, is dependent upon the number of time zones crossed rather than the length of flight. 
 This is why jet-lag is not so marked after a flight in the north-south direction. 
 To be sure, the general inconvenience of such a flight disrupts you and makes you tired, but only temporarily, so that there are no symptoms of jet-lag by the second day at your destination. 
 The effect of time-zone changes, free of problems from the flight itself, can be removed by experiments in isolation chambers. 
 In these, the subjects live a normal routine by the clock and then, suddenly, the clock can be changed. 
 for example, if might be 12 noon and the experimenter might change the clock to 8 o'clock in the evening, so mimicking a time-zone transition to Singapore. 
 The subjects must continue to live their normal routines, but now in accord with the new local time. 
 The inconvenience of flight has been removed; has jet-lag? 
 In such simulated time-zone transition experiments, changes to the body's rhythms are observed to be very similar to those after real time-zone transitions. 
 In addition, many components of jet-lag &mdash; altered sleep, fatigue, loss of appetite, changed bowel movements &mdash; are found, and the rate of adjustment of the body rhythms to a simulated time-zone transition is similar to that observed after real transitions. 
 Thus, many of the problems of time-zone transitions can be modelled in the laboratory where travel difficulties are no longer relevant. 
 Even so, becoming angry when travel arrangements go wrong can hardly help. 
 In brief, keep calm . 
 The laboratory experiments also exclude the time spent on the actual flight itself. 
 As we shall see, this can be an important part of the battle against jet-lag. 
 It is due to a change of life-style 
 The &bquo;change of life-style&equo; argument is unsound because the change is not necessarily greater the further you fly or the more time zones you cross. 
 Consider, for example, the cultural differences for a European in journeying to parts of Africa (large, but few time zones crossed) or New Zealand (smaller cultural changes but more time zones crossed). 
 The traveller to New Zealand from England has more jet-lag to contend with than the traveller to Africa. 
 In addition, jet-lag is experienced on returning home after a stay in another country, when the traveller is returning to his own culture. 
 Alterations in diet and even hygiene might well produce indigestion and &bquo;traveller's tummy&equo;, but this does not exclude the possibility that the time-zone transition produces similar or additional changes. 
 Simulated time-zone transitions in the laboratory, where the diet remains unchanged, confirm that the change in local time produces a change in appetite and bowel movements. 
 It is a matter of experience 
 It could be argued that, with practice, the body becomes more able to adjust to a time-zone transition, a kind of &bquo;learning&equo; effect. 
 Some travellers maintain that they get used to jet-lag but others find that the problem becomes worse. 
 Travellers might get used to jet-lag in the sense that they learn to live with it, or they might find it progressively more irksome as their initial excitement with travel begins to wear thin. 
 The idea that the body clock might adjust more readily with practice is an attractive one, but there is no evidence to support it. 
 What might arise with practice is a better routine for coping with jet-lag, and this is the aim of the next chapter. 
 Adjusting the body clock 
 Accepting that the body clock is slow to adjust to a time-zone transition, our aim must be to speed up this adjustment. 
 Adjustment will be speeded up if we can strengthen the time-cues in the new time zone. 
 To recapitulate what we described in Chapter 2, the main examples are our rhythms of: 
 &bull; Sleep and naps; &bull; Physical activity (including exercise, walking, gardening); &bull; Business activity (including appointments, shopping, office hours); &bull; Social influences and leisure time (including the pub, disco, theatre, parties); &bull; Mealtimes; &bull; Exposure to natural daylight and darkness. 
 Under normal circumstances these different rhythms give the same information about external time; that is, they reinforce one another. 
 This can be seen when the differences between night (when it is dark, quiet and we sleep) and day (when we arrange our meals, our business, social and physical activities and it is a noisier, more &bquo;active&equo; environment) are considered. 
 In practice, during our waking hours we are subject to social conventions and personal routines which jointly determine when we eat, relax, work, have parties, etc. 
 Those who, day by day, show regular habits and who are subjected to these external influences in a regular way possess body clocks that are more accurately adjusted to 24 hours than do those whose life-style is less regular (see fig. 2.4 and pp. 97&ndash;99, for example). 
 Such knowledge will be the basis of the advice we give in the next  chapter for promoting adjustment after a time-zone transition. 
 TIME-ZONE TRANSITIONS &mdash; ADVICE 
 Advice on time-zone transitions depends very much upon the kind of journey being made, so we consider the following possibilities: &bull; A flight crossing only a few (one or two) time zones; &bull; A flight crossing several time zones, (to the west or east) and when the stop-over, before returning home, is short; &bull; A flight crossing several time zones to the west where there is sufficient time and need for adjustment to the new time zone; &bull; A flight as in the last example, but to the east. 
 How far is your journey? 
 Table 11.1 gives a general guide to the number of time zones between the United Kingdom and other countries. 
 Corrections might have to be made if Single or Double Summertime (Daylight Saving Time) is in operation. 
 If the journey does not start or end in the United Kingdom then the list can be used by combining entries. 
 Thus, for a journey from Saudi Arabia to the east coast of America: 
 &bull; The east coast of America is five time zones to the west of the United Kingdom. 
 &bull; Saudi Arabia is three time zones to the east of the United Kingdom. 
 &bull; Therefore the journey is eight time zones in a westward direction. 
 If the country you are visiting is not listed in Table 11.1, you can find out how many time zones distant it is by the following means: 
 &bull; The telephone directory. 
 The information can be found under the section on international dialling codes. 
 &bull; A world atlas. 
 Some give the time zones directly. 
 If not, they can be estimated by knowing that one time zone equals 15 &deg; longitude. 
 Thus Christmas Island (105 &deg; E) is seven time zones to the east and Jamaica (75 &deg; W) is five time zones to the west. 
 But be warned, not all countries abide exactly by these rules, and so slight regional modifications are quite common. 
 Since all journeys start with a flight, we will first advise briefly on suitable behaviour during the flight, 
 What to do during the flight 
 The anxieties associated with a journey and the change of routine can cause a general sense of fatigue which will often be increased by loss of sleep as a result of the timing of the journey. 
 Another problem arises because the air on board the aircraft has an oxygen pressure and water vapour content that are low in comparison with &bquo;fresh air&equo; and such an environment tends to cause dehydration and headaches. further, the lack of movement that is possible during the flight can lead to stiffness, even cramp. 
 Drinks 
 Coffee, tea, and alcohol are likely to be offered, but try to limit how much of these you drink. 
 This is not a &bquo;killjoy&equo; attitude but an attempt to guard against the dehydration produced by the dry air in the cabin. 
 All these drinks possess diuretic properties, that is, they increase the loss of body fluids in the urine. 
 fruit juices, squashes and spa waters are recommended alternatives. 
 Still drinks are better than fizzy ones (because of the reduced air pressure that exists in an aircraft cabin during a flight.) 
 Food 
 Foods necessarily tend to be of the &bquo;convenience&equo; type and low in fibre (&bquo;roughage&equo;), and so might cause constipation later on. 
 Try instead to eat foods that are higher on roughage; fresh fruit, wholemeal bread or rolls, celery, or carrots are all important sources of roughage. 
 You might even take some fresh fruit with you for the journey. 
 Exercise 
 Try to get some exercise during the flight to decrease stiffness and the possibilities of cramp and swollen ankles. 
 For some, a stroll down the aisles is sufficient, but isometric exercises (alternate tensing and relaxation of muscles) or those involving only limited movement (of the neck, back, arms and legs, for instance) can be performed conveniently within the confines of your seat. 
 One enterprising airway promotes this idea by showing an in-flight video that leads passengers through such a work-out. 
 Sleep or naps and waking time 
 Boredom and fatigue will lead to the tendency to take naps but whether this should be encouraged or resisted depends upon details of the journey. 
 This is discussed below. 
 With some airlines, there is the facility (for example the &bquo;sleeperette&equo;, to take a good sleep rather than just a nap). 
 A flight crossing only a few time zones 
 If you are flying to the east and crossing only one or two time zones or flying to the west and crossing three or less time zones, you are unlikely to suffer from the effects of jet-lag. 
 Even so, you are advised to leave at least one clear day between the flight and an important business meeting. 
 During this spare time you can catch up on lost sleep (as long as your naps do not prevent a full night's sleep), relax after the stresses of the journey, adjust drinking and eating habits, and generally adapt to your new surroundings. 
 During the flight you are advised to sleep or nap if it is night time. 
 If it is daytime try reading a book, talking, playing cards, etc. but do not nap . 
 A flight crossing several time zones but only a short visit 
 If your stay in the new time zone is brief (1 or 2 days), then a substantial adjustment to it is unlikely. 
 Therefore you are advised to arrange important meetings at times coincident with daytime on your home time and to avoid times coincident with night on home time. 
 After a flight to the east, meetings should take place in the latter half of the daytime rather than in the morning by new local time. 
 After a flight to the west, meetings should take place in the morning by new local time rather than in the latter part of the day. 
 If you feel tired, a short sleep before an important meeting can be beneficial as long as it ends at least one hour before your meeting to make sure that you have woken up fulLy. 
 Sleeping pills are not advised unless they are short-acting benzodiazepines whose effects wear off in time (see p. 124). 
 A flight crossing several time zones and staying at your destination for several days 
 If your stay is longer, then you can attempt to promote adjustment of your body to the new time zone. 
 This entails matching your life-style to that of the new time zone as fully and rapidly as convenient. 
 This will have the effect of strengthening the time-cues which cause adjustment of the body clock. 
 We stress that this advice will not remove jet-lag but should minimize its duration. 
 In many cases, following the advice, particularly with regard to sleep, will initially be against the &bquo;natural&equo; dictates of the body clock, but, as we have explained, obeying the body clock in this case will only prolong the difficulties in living with the new time zone. 
 Example one &mdash; a flight to the west 
 This requires you to delay your body clock, which tends to be comparatively easy since it naturally tends to run rather slowly. 
 Before the Flight 
 Can you begin to adjust your life-style to the new time zone in the days immediately before departure? 
 One possibility is to go to bed one to two hours later than normal each night and get up one to two hours later each morning. 
 Of course this might not always be possible. 
 It is rarely useful to try and adjust fully to the time-zone transition before the journey, since this will interrupt your life-style too much. 
 During the flight 
 Set your watch immediately to agree with local time at your destination. 
 During the flight try to sleep if it is night time at your destination and, when it is daytime there, try to stay awake &mdash; find somebody to talk to, a book to read or watch the in- flight movie. 
 If required, the facility to take a good sleep can be a great advantage over having to try to nap in your seat. 
 Be warned, however, that there are two practical problems that might arise if you attempt to adjust your habits in the ways suggested. 
 First, the in-flight schedule is sometimes arranged in accord with time in your departure zone. 
 Second, if you have to break your journey or change flights, make sure you use the appropriate local time for making the connection. 
 After the flight 
 ADOPT THE NEW LOCAL TIME FOR ALL ASPECTS OF YOUR LIFE-STYLE Sleep  Since the new local time will be behind your body clock's time, you will tend to wake too early and feel ready for sleep in the afternoon or early evening. 
 Recommendations are: 
 &bull; Try to sleep in surroundings that are as quiet, dark, and comfortable as possible. 
 &bull; If you wake early (often because you need to pass urine), stay quietly in bed until the correct rising time after having emptied your bladder. 
 &bull; If you feel tired during the day, resist the temptation to take a nap. 
 For the first day or so after the flight you might find it helps to retire to bed one or two hours earlier than your normal time &mdash; but no earlier than that! 
 Physical activity and natural light  Light exercise and brisk walks taken at your accustomed time by the new local time will help to adjust you to the new time zone and to make you feel ready for sleep at bedtime. 
 A particularly good time to be out-of-doors in natural lighting in the first two to three days after the flight is that corresponding to the evening and first part of the night on &bquo;old time&equo;, 9 o'clock to 3 o'clock; this should help to delay your body clock. 
 By the same token try to avoid bright natural light for the first two to three days after the flight at times corresponding to 5 to 11 o'clock in the morning on old time as this will tend to advance your body clock. 
 Table 11.2 gives examples of this advice in practice. 
 Social activities  Provided that they do not stop you going to bed at the proper time, social activities are a very good way of adjusting to the new time zone, particularly if they enable you to spend time out-of-doors in natural daylight at the times recommended in Table 11.2. 
 Table 11.2 Good and bad times for exposure to natural light in the first two to three days after a time-zone transition Meals and drinks  &bull; Try to make meals of the &bquo;correct&equo; type (breakfast, lunch, etc.) at your adjusted times. 
 Do not take a large supper which may make sleep difficult immediately afterwards. 
 &bull; There is some evidence that high-protein foods (fish, meat, etc.) and caffeine-containing drinks (coffee, tea) are best taken in the morning and that a light snack rich in carbohydrates (fruit juice and dessert) is best for supper; caffeine-containing drinks should be avoided just before sleep. 
 &bull; Alcohol is a bad  &bquo;nightcap&equo; &mdash; it sends you to sleep, but will act as a diuretic and cause you to awaken to pass urine. 
 Example two &mdash; a flight to the east 
 After a flight to the east, your body is behind the new local time and to adjust to it you will have to advance your body clock. 
 Because the body clock tends to &bquo;run slow&equo;, advancing it is more difficult and this explains why it takes longer to adapt (see Table 11.3). 
 Even so, the advice is similar in principle to that given for a westward flight. 
 Before the flight 
 If possible, try to adjust at least partially to the local time of your destination by going to bed one or two hours earlier each night and getting up one or two hours earlier each day. 
 Again this might not always be possible, but going to bed and getting up earlier are not likely to intrude too much upon your normal working life. 
 During the flight 
 The advice is the same as that given for westward flights &mdash; though, of course, whether people living in the new time zone are awake or sleeping will differ. 
 Again, in-flight arrangements are sometimes timed with respect to the departure zone. 
 After the flight 
 ADOPT THE NEW LOCAL TIME FOR ALL ASPECTS OF YOUR LIFE-STYLE Sleep  Since the new local time will be ahead of your body clock's time, you will tend to have difficulty in waking up and feeling alert during the morning. 
 You will also tend not to feel tired by the time the local inhabitants are going to bed. 
 The advice is the same except that now the &bquo;dangers&equo; are: 
 &bull; If you cannot get to sleep at night, stay in bed and rest. 
 If this continues to be unsuccessful then some travellers purposely &bquo;miss&equo; the first sleep in their new time zone to make sure that they are tired on the second night. 
 &bull; If you feel tired when it is time to get up &mdash; indeed, you might just be getting off to sleep! &mdash; do not stay in bed, but get up. 
 A &bquo;lie-in&equo; of one to two hours but no more  is permissible for the first day or so. 
 Physical and social activities, meals, and drinks  All the advice given for westward flights applies equally after flights to the east. 
 Table 11.2 shows times when natural light is recommended or advised against. 
 Now you wish to advance your clock so natural lighting at what was 5 to 11 o'clock in the morning on old time is good, but bright light at what was 9 o'clock in the evening to 3 o'clock in the morning is undesirable. 
 How long might jet-lag last? 
 Table 11.3 gives a guide to the duration of jet-lag that might be expected after a single journey. 
 Older people tend to be nearer the upper limit of any range than do younger people, but some combination of the factors mentioned can help individuals approach the lower limits. 
 Drugs and jet-lag 
 For those on regular medication 
 Clearly, if you are required to take medications, the instructions &bquo;first thing in the morning&equo; or &bquo;with meals&equo; will involve some irregularity after a time-zone transition and change of routine have taken place. 
 Unfortunately, it might not be just a matter of rescheduling &bquo;waking time&equo; and &bquo;mealtimes&equo; along the lines we have suggested above, since the body does not adjust immediately to the new routine. 
 Consult your doctor if at all in doubt. 
 Drugs and other aids for overcoming the difficulties of jet-lag 
 Several possibilities come into this category and some have been mentioned earlier. 
 Here we will summarize the position briefly. 
 First there are the hypnotics which help you sleep and the stimulants which wake you up. 
 We would always advise caution in the use of these because they might have side-effects and we suggest any unnecessary use of drugs is undesirable. 
 Nevertheless, if a good sleep is imperative, say before an important meeting, then a short-acting hypnotic might be helpful (it needs to be short-acting or its effects might last into the next waking period). 
 An alternative is to take a short nap before the meeting, making sure there is at least one hour between the nap and meeting so that you can waken fully. 
 Alcohol is a poor way of getting a long sleep as its diuretic effect wakes you because of a full bladder. 
 Stimulants in the form of pills are unnecessary; coffee, fresh air, and light exercise are effective substitutes. 
 There is no pill of which we are aware that can be relied upon to promote adjustment of the internal clock. 
 Pills can now be bought which, it is claimed, can help this process but their worth has not been fully established scientifically. 
 Moreover, some appear to consist of little more than the &bquo;active constituents&equo; of the dietary regimen we have already described &mdash; a regime whose effectiveness is not accepted by all research workers. 
 Recent work has shown promising results for tablets containing melatonin. 
 They can be taken a few hours before sleep is required in the new time zone. 
 The results of scientific tests validate these tablets as a means of reducing the fatigue associated with jet-lag. 
 It is not yet known if other symptoms of jet-lag are reduced and there is little clear evidence that they adjust the body clock that controls body temperature and performance rhythms. 
 That is, they might act as does aspirin in the case of a headache in curing a symptom but without affecting the cause. 
 Unfortunately melatonin is not yet commercially available. 
 Recently, an electronic device has been marketed which gives advice on when you should expose yourself to daylight at your destination. 
 In this respect it is very similar to Table 11.2, therefore, the major difference being its cost. 
 In short, therefore, the best advice for combating jet-lag is to adopt a new routine in accord with your new time zone, to strengthen all possible time-cues, and so to reset the body clock as quickly as possible . 
 Enjoy your flight and trip! 
 BRITAIN 
 Exercise Roaring Lion: 5 Airborne Brigade Captain R J Metcalfe 
 5 Airborne Brigade is the Army's &bquo;Instant Readiness&equo; Force, and is able to deploy anywhere in the world in a matter of days. 
 Here we see it practising for just this role. 
 On the island of Safra (Salisbury Plain training area) the situation has become desperate. 
 The ruling royal family have been embezzling oil revenues and have been ousted from power by the Safran Peoples' Liberation Party. 
 This presents the powerful neighbouring country of Guambia with the opportunity to invade the island, under the pretext of a request for assistance from the royal family. 
 Guambia's historical claim on the island has become more significant since oil was discovered, and the main reason for the invasion is economic.  
 Safra has a defence agreement with the UK, and Her Majesty's Government is obliged to deploy military force to assist in restoring the island's independence. 
 5 Airborne Brigade has been tasked to carry out the mission, as the Army's only dedicated force earmarked for operations outside the NATO area. 
 Guambian forces on the ground are currently occupying defensive positions to the west of the vital oil installations, Which are situated in the northeast of the island. 
 They are reinforcing all the time by both air and sea. 
 They have an airborne capability (1 PARA) Which was used to secure their early objectives by parachute assault. 
 Their intention is assessed as being to seize the oil installations at the earliest opportunity. 
 It is therefore vital that UK forces deploy to Safra as soon as possible. 
 At RAF Lyneham 500 men are sweating over the vast amounts of equipment the individual soldier attaches to his body prior to jumping into a theatre of war. 
 Many men will leave the aircraft with weights not far short of their own body weight; almost all of this kit will be essential to carry out the soldiers' tasks. 
 It will include the personal weapon, three days' rations and ammunition, along with as much water as can be carried, and also nuclear, biological and chemical warfare equipment, since the enemy is known to have a chemical weapons capability. 
 It may include parts of larger support weapons such as mortars, radio equipment and spare batteries. 
 It will almost certainly include little or no personal equipment, as there simply is not enough space. 
 The comforts of home will be in short supply. 
 In an hour's time the men will board a crowded, and today extremely hot, C-130 Hercules aircraft. 
 They will fly at low level for two hours, with many men suffering the effects of air sickness and dehydration. 
 In spite of the inevitable tension, it will be a relief to jump out of the aircraft. 
 The men have been exhaustively briefed on drop zones and emergency procedures, as well as the ground plan, to the extent that any man or unit should be able to carry out another's task. 
 However, they have not been briefed that in this case the drop zone will be changed at the last minute. 
 A few men will not get the message during the flight, and will land believing themselves to be on a different drop zone. 
 Confusion is inevitable. 
 The aim of this is to test the flexibility of every man in the group by imposing a situation which requires a major change in the plan, at no notice. 
 The men in the group will have to cope with this sudden change of plan as if they had known about it all along. 
 This group is the leading parachute battalion group, or LPBG. 
 It is self-sustaining for three days, and includes all the men, equipment and stores required to fight in a limited conflict. 
 In this case it is based on the Parachute Regiment's 2nd Battalion (2 PARA), supported by light armoured vehicles of the Life Guards, gunners from 7 Parachute Regiment Royal Horse Artillery (7 PARA RHA), engineers from? 
 Parachute Squadron (9 PARA SQN RE), medics from 23 Parachute Field Ambulance (23 PARA), and the many other essential elements Which have grouped with the LPBG for this particular exercise. 
 Such grouping is always tailored to suit the requirements of the specific operation or exercise. 
 Later in the day it will take less than five minutes simultaneously to drop the Whole group, with their stores, into Safra from fifteen C-130 Hercules aircraft. 
 The technique used for jumping in these numbers is known as static line  parachuting. 
 This means that the parachute release is attached to the aircraft by a line Which automatically opens the parachute on exiting the aircraft. 
 The man is also equipped with a reserve parachute and a container for his personal equipment. 
 This container is fitted to one of the man's legs shortly before the drop, and is lowered from the body on a rope once the parachutist has left the aircraft. 
 This allows it to land nearby but not interfere with the descent. 
 Using this method a full C-130 Hercules aircraft load of ninety heavily-laden troops can be dispatched from two parallel side doors in no more than forty-five seconds. 
 The drop is from 800 feet, giving an individual time of descent of about forty seconds, depending on individual weights. 
 A total of 1,280 soldiers will be deployed this way during the course of the exercise. 
 This will be immediately preceded by the dispatch from the tail-gate of the aircraft of a &bquo;wedge&equo;, a platform containing up to a ton of stores. 
 In addition to this, stores may be dropped as &bquo;door bundles&equo; from the side doors. 
 Vehicles are loaded on to special platforms and dropped out of aircraft specifically designated to carry out this task on to adjacent or parallel drop zones. 
 At the same time, elements of the 1st Battalion the Royal Regiment of  Fusiliers (1 RFF), one of two non-parachute-trained battalions in the brigade, are also preparing for an airborne operation. 
 In this instance one hundred men, With two Scorpion armoured vehicles and two stripped-down Land-Rovers, will be landed on and seize an airfield held by a small enemy force. 
 The aircraft will land, disgorge the troops and take off again immediately, being on the ground for less than three minutes. 
 This operation will coincide with the parachute landings &bquo;up country&equo;. 
 Securing this airfield is vital to the success of the operation, because much of the remainder of the brigade will land by air craft later. 
 The remaining infantry unit in the brigade is the 1st Battalion King Edward VII s Own Gurkhas (1/2 GR). 
 It is also preparing to take off for Safra, to be moved straight into a defensive position by Chinook and Puma support helicopters. 
 Under these circumstances the Chinook can carry up to equipped men, and the Puma carries sixteen. 
 The battalion group will complete in Safra by early evening. 
 Almost all of these elements depend in some way for their initial success on the brigade's own advanced forces, the Pathfinder Platoon. 
 This small unit,  consisting of highly-skilled soldiers recruited from within the brigade, jumped into Safra in the early hours of this morning. 
 The method they employed for the drop is known as HALO (high altitude low opening). 
 The Pathfinder Platoon is the only brigade sub-unit to use this free-fall technique, Which enhances the chances of avoiding detection and involves leaving the aircraft at heights of up to 25,000 feet, followed by a long free-fall descent and then landing using steerable parachutes. 
 Their tasks on landing are to check the drop zones and landing sites for enemy activity, and mark them for the incoming aircraft, as well as performing detailed reconnaissance tasks of key targets and objectives. 
 They will meet up with the commanding officers of some of the major units on the ground to brief them on the results of their reconnaissance. 
 Later in the day they will be rebriefed to move well forward of the remainder of the brigade, to carry out further intelligence-gathering activities. 
 At the end of Day One there are well over 2,000 soldiers in Safra, all of whom have arrived by air transport. 
 Many more are awaiting follow-on air-land sorties, along with the large numbers of vehicles and stores that were not delivered with the initial assaults. 
 However, not all of the necessary supporting organisations, personnel, equipment and stores can be transported by air, and must therefore sail to Safra. 
 This &bquo;sea tail&equo; left Marchwood today aboard the logistic landing ship (LSL) Sir Galahad. 
 In due course they will arrive in Safra to be offloaded over a beach and thence travel by road into the theatre of operations. 
 Until then, resupply to the front line units will be by airdrop (parachute) resupply. 
 In all, over 300 tons of stores will be delivered into Safra this way, with individual aircraft capable of dispatching up to twenty-four one-ton containers per sortie. 
 The situation in Safra itself has continued to deteriorate, with enemy forces now in a position to press home attacks against the vital areas. 
 Defensive positions must be prepared as fast as possible. 
 In particular the positions around the vital bridges across the river lying between the oilfields and the enemy must be secured. 
 This is quickly achieved by 2 PARA and 1 RRF, although the enemy have already destroyed one of the bridges. 
 The Life Guards and the Pathfinder Platoon push out a reconnaissance screen to the front of the bridges and give early warning of the inevitable enemy attacks Which occur during the night. 
 The Gurkhas occupy a depth position around the oilfields. 
 They too will be attacked by an enemy force (1 PARA), parachuted into friendly forces' positions with a view to causing maximum confusion. 
 This attack will coincide with helibore assaults to attack friendly forces' positions from an unexpected direction. 
 At the end of the first day 5 Airborne Brigade has achieved its objectives. 
 If all goes according to plan the enemy will fall back into a defensive position to the west of the area, around an airfield. 
 The brigade will force them to withdraw most of their forces and will defeat the remainder in a classic set-piece brigade attack, on a well-sited defensive position. 
 Prior to this, parachute and helibore raiding tasks will take place on pockets of enemy around Safra and on adjacent islands (other training areas). 
 Logistic units will be established well forward, with resupply aircraft landing on &bquo;dirt strips&equo;, Which in reality are no more than fiat fields. 
 Finally, British forces will be withdrawn once the  territorial integrity of the island has been restored. 
 This will be by helicopter and Hercules aircraft, taking less than half a day for the majority of the fighting troops. 
 Day One of the exercise is over. 
 Clearly it has not been a typical day, even for 5 Airborne Brigade; yet such operations have taken place seventy-three times since the Second World War. 
 The benefits of training days such as today will be filly realised When a similar situation arises in the future, as it inevitably will.  
 a private from 1 Para, 5 airborne Brigade, with his face camouflaged ready for Exercise Roaring Lion 
 The C-130 Hercules disappearing into the gloom has just deposited these parachutists of the Parachute Brigade on the ground. 
 They exited from the aircraft at a height of approximately 800ft. 
 The bundles hanging underneath ac parachutist contain their equipment 
 parachutists from 5 Airborne Brigade land on Salisbury Plain 
 The drop into SAFRA begins 
 The Army Physical Training Corps Captain J V Larkham APTC 
 The Army Physical Training Corps is responsible for keeping the Army fit. 
 At its HQ in Aldershot it runs various PT courses and trains instructors who are then sent world-wide to maintain standards of fitness in every unit of the British Army. 
 The best way to illustrate a typical day in the life of the Corps is to see What one man, in this case Warrant Officer Class 2(WO2) C Wilkinson, did on 30 June 1989. 
 He arrived for work at the Army School of Physical Training at 0730 hours. 
 At 0810 he gathered his staff around him for the daily conference to discuss the day ahead, before taking the morning parade of those attending various courses at the school, to ensure that everyone had turned up for work. 
 He was then required to go down to the ranges to practise shooting with the 9 mm pistol. 
 PTIs may spend most of their life in gymnasia, but they are first and foremost soldiers, and are expected to keep up their military skills. 
 After an extremely quick change from combat kit to PT order, he was taking  an anatomy class by 1100 hours. 
 After another quick change he spent the lunch-hour bicycling around Aldershot at high speed, training for a triathlon event later in the summer. 
 The afternoon was spent in the Aldershot Military Athletics Stadium officiating as a starter. 
 At 1600 hours WO2 Wilkinson gave some treatment to a fellow PTI Who had injured his back in the gymnasium trying to show off! 
 Being a qualified physiotherapist and a PTI can be a useful combination. 
 Finally he spent an hour from 1630 to 1730 in his office finishing off his paperwork and checking on the next day's programme. 
 But, as is so often the case in the Army, that was not the end of the day: from 1930 to 2130 that evening he had agreed to referee a boxing competition between two local regiments. 
 Friday 30 june was not untypical of a normal day at the PT School. 
 The motto of the AFTC is &bquo;A Healthy Mind in a Healthy Body&equo;, but there is no doubt that a sense of humour also helps!  
 Physical training can fun! 
 Boxing is a popular sport in the Army. 
 Here WO2 Wilkinson referees a match i the gymnasium in Aldershot 
 Pairs Obs and Recce: 7 Regiment, Army Air Corps Captain Darrel Locke AAC 
 The Army Air Corps flies all the Army's helicopters. 
 Here Captain Darrell Locke describes what he did on 30 June 1989. 
 0930 on a Friday morning and I'm about to start work. 
 Normally this might earn me an interview without coffee with my Flight Commander, but I do have an excuse for arriving at work an hour later than usual &mdash; Gazelle Flight were night-flying last night. 
 Flying at any time of the day is demanding; at night the demands can be greater, but they are far outweighed by the privilege of seeing the earth from such a spectacular vantage point. 
 Whether it is flying through the valleys of Norway in a landscape lit only by the dim glow of the snow-covered mountains, or across the almost solid darkness of Salisbury Plain, you can't beat flying with the owls and the bats. 
 Anyone with the slightest interest in aviation will know of the array of technical devices which enable a pilot to navigate himself and his aircraft with pinpoint accuracy around the globe. 
 In the Army, however, we draw lines on our maps and off we go. 
 There is no sense in training to use fancy navigation aids when we would be unable to use them in wartime, and besides &mdash; that's cheating. 
 This all sounds well and good until you find yourself airborne at night, armed only with a line on a map, and you find that none of the features on your map can be seen because &mdash; surprise, surprise &mdash; it's dark! 
 That's not strictly true, of course; roads and buildings stand out because of the lights Which people kindly leave on for us. 
 So we navigate at night by relating built-up areas to the map and using time and distance &mdash; flying on a known heading for a known time. 
 Sometimes, like last night, if we are landing in a field location we will be able to home-in on radio transmissions from a ground station and fly until we are overhead. 
 Then it is a relatively simple matter to descend and land in the field, though it can be fun when the only thing visible in the black outside the cockpit is the light of the marshaller's torch (just try judging how far away a solitary light is when you are next out on a moonless night). 
 At least night flying has earned us an extra hour in bed. 
 No such luxury for the four members of Scout Flight, Who have been out flying since before 0400. 
 The Paras have been jumping into one of the dropping zones on Salisbury Plain since first light, so the Scouts have been on standby on the DZ in case there should be any casualties. 
 Luckily they are more likely to be used to collect the used parachutes scattered across the DZ.  
 As well as the Gazelle and Scout helicopters of G58 Squadron, 7 Regiment Army Air Corps comprises 656 Squadron with a flight of Gazelles and one of Lynx anti-tank helicopters, and 2 Flight with their six Gazelles. 
 The Aerospatiale Gazelle forms a large part of the Regiment and thus is the real workhorse. 
 In peacetime the Gazelle earns its living on such tasks as ferrying VIPs around the country. 
 When not involved in tasking, we train for our wartime roles such as observation and reconnaissance, or Air Observation Post work. 
 On top of all this the pilots need to reach certain training levels, for example night or instrument flying, thus enabling us to fly twenty-four hours a day and in poor weather. 
 Most Army helicopters now operate with a crew of two, and the Gazelles of 658 Squadron are no exception. 
 The pilot in the left-hand seat will command the aircraft and make all the tactical decisions, leaving the other pilot to concentrate on flying safely. 
 Command of the aircraft rests with the more experienced pilot, rather than the one of higher rank, so that the situation can arise Where a recently promoted sergeant is making the tactical decisions for a relatively senior captain. 
 This morning we are going to carry out What we call a &bquo;pairs obs and recce&equo;  task. 
 Two Gazelles will go out together and find vantage points from which to observe notional enemy positions. 
 Each aircraft will be acting as an extra set of eyes for the other in an attempt to see before being seen. 
 For our training purposes we will be presented with a tactical scenario together with a target to try to observe. 
 This target may be a building or a crossroads, or even an airfield, depending on how devious the compiler of the exercise has been. 
 While the two aircraft commanders get their heads together to sort out the best approach to the problem we have been set, the two pilots sort out the flying side of life. 
 What is the weather like? 
 Which aircraft have we got and can it take two crew and a full load of fuel? 
 Are there any Royal flights on today, or any other airspace restrictions? 
 Well, it looks as though the Queen Mother is off to Scotland for the day, but that won't affect us, so it seems that we can go ahead. 
 Returning to the operations and planning room, our aircraft commanders are briefed on factors likely to affect the sortie, and then it's into the tactical briefing. 
 &bquo;Enemy forward elements are believed to have reached this road. 
 Our mission is to find out how far they have advanced and in Which direction they are  heading. 
 Guns are available.&equo; 
 This last comment doesn't mean that we can strap on our sixshooters and holsters, but rather the guns of the artillery are on call if we should have a chance to use them. 
 The Gazelle has no armament of its own, so uses the firepower of the artillery and of fighter ground attack aircraft, if available. 
 We direct aircraft or gunfire on to their targets for maximum accuracy. 
 Of course today there are no real guns &mdash; only a radio ground station playing the role to give us practice in procedures. 
 Briefing completed, pilots head for the aircraft While aircraft commanders complete the last-minute documentation. 
 Now just kick the tyres, light the fires and leap off unarmed into battle. 
 Well, it's not quite like that in real life, more a case of methodical checks to minimise any possible risks; firstly, the exterior of the aircraft, then all the internal switches, knobs, buttons and dials. 
 When all is checked we start engine and rotors. 
 We are cleared by Air Traffic Control to taxi and take off. 
 Once clear of Salisbury Plain the real flying begins. 
 Our aircraft leads the way whilst the second weaves to left and right to cover our tail. 
 Not only do we have the problem of the exercise tactical scenario, but also there are real dangers. 
 As we descend we slow down and begin to call out  hazards as soon as they are seen: &bquo;wires left to right 500 metres&equo;, &bquo;birds two o'clock&equo;. 
 As if this were not enough we have to avoid livestock, standing crops and a myriad of other obstacles. 
 All this with a notional enemy gunning for us. 
 But the speed is slowing now, even though the pressure is still on. 
 We edge up a small re-entrant to the top of a ridge, while the second aircraft creeps along a woodline 200 metres to the left. 
 Our position is too exposed, so we have to back off and try again half a mile to our right. 
 Success! 
 Between the two aircraft we can now see all of our target area. 
 As we are studying the area, a Land-Rover appears with an orange cross on the side; this is our enemy tank for the day. 
 We note the direction of travel and radio the information back to base. 
 Given the order to use the guns we go ahead and, using well-practised procedures, call down the full weight of fire from a notional battery of Abbott self-propelled guns. 
 Mission accomplished, we head for home, though it's not just a case of turntail and run as fast as we can. 
 We slide back from our observation positions and pick our way back to the rear area. 
 After all, there is still the threat of enemy anti-aircraft missiles. 
 To cause minimum inconvenience to the locals, the flight commander calls an end to the tactical phase of the exercise and we begin a climb from What is colloquially known as the &bquo;weedosphere&equo; up to the dizzy height of 1,000 feet. 
 As we start to climb we accidentally cut across the bottom of the garden of a large, secluded house. 
 The owner has seen us and is even more surprised than we are; after all, she was sunbathing nude by the side of the pool! 
 Back in the office and it's time for constructive criticism. 
 Every aspect of the trip is analysed to see Where we went wrong and how we can prevent it happening next time. 
 If we flew a perfect mission every trip then there would be no need to train, but then in a perfect world we would not need an Army and I would be out of a job. 
 At the end of the debriefing we are all still on speaking terms, and no one disagrees violently with the criticism of his performance, which is What you would expect from anyone Who aspires to take their profession seriously. 
 The sortie has taken something over four hours to complete, for a little over an hour and a half in the air. 
 A late lunch consists of a NAAFI pie and a cup of tea While everyone attempts to sort out their &bquo;personal admin', the Army's great catch-all phase for anything from writing letters to darning socks. 
 While we have been away the two Scouts have returned from providing DZ cover and are parked outside the hangar. 
 A third has just returned from an overnight trip to Otterbur in the north-east of England Where it has been helping to move personnel and mat&eacute;riel around the ranges. 
 This leaves just two aircraft out working: the Gazelle Which went out this morning, and a Scout which is out practising abseiling drills on the far side of the airfield. 
 Half an hour later the Gazelle returns from task, followed shortly afterwards by the Scout. 
 The ground crew can now work to refuel, clean the squashed bugs off the bubble and put the aircraft to bed. 
 The ground crews within the Army Air Corps are generally the unsung heroes behind everything we do. 
 Everyone sees the helicopters and wants to ask about them. 
 However, without the unseen help of ground crew, from the soldier Who refuels the aircraft to all the  technicians Who keep those aircraft serviceable, there would be no flying at all. 
 The 30th of June ends with making last-minute arrangements for the annual Squadron Open Day. 
 By 1800 hours we are able to call it a day. 
 The aircraft are safely hangared and the technicians have assured themselves that those cowboy pilots haven't damaged any of their babies.   
 Infantrymen are ferried forward to their positions during an exercise in BErlin. 
 This is an unusual task for a Gazelle helicopter which is normally used in reconnaissance duties 
 Lynx helicopter of the Army air Corp take off 
 An air trooper of 2 flight Army Air Corps provides close protection for the Gazelle helicopters at a forward airfield 
 Lynx helicopter in action 
 Passing-Out Parade at the WRAC Centre 
 The Army could not function without the Women's Royal Army corps. 
 Indeed its strength is about to be doubled from about 5,000 to 10,000. 
 Here we are taken through a day at WRAC Headquarters in Guildford. 
 It's 0530 hours, and the sound of birdsong rings around Queen Elizabeth Park, Guildford, the home of the Women's Royal Army Corps. 
 At the gatehouse the milk float arrives with the daily delivery and Tim Tyier, the milkman who has served the Centre for many years, starts his rounds. 
 The regimental police and duty staff also commence their morning rounds; opening up buildings, checking security and turning off the security lights. 
 The cooks on the &bquo;early shift&equo; enter the Elizabethan Restaurant and start preparing breakfast for some 500 hungry servicewomen. 
 Meanwhile, in two of the Training Company accommodation blocks there is an air of excitement, for today there is a passing-out parade. 
 It is the finale of two of the recruit courses: the Regular recruits have spent eight weeks at the WRAC Centre completing an intensive course which provides a young woman with all the basic military skills Which she will require to be able to take her place alongside her male counterpart in the modern British Army. 
 They have been an action-packed eight weeks, with map reading, first aid, nuclear, biological and chemical warfare instruction, weapon training, fieldcraft, physical training and a myriad of other subjects to prepare the recruit for her chosen career. 
 The Territorial Army recruits have spent only fourteen days in Guildford, having travelled from their units scattered throughout the United Kingdom. 
 They have left behind their civilian employment and all their other commitments to undertake their basic military training. 
 Amongst their ranks are housewives and mothers with teenage children, civil servants, factory workers, teachers, secretaries, a roofer and a self-employed graphic design artist. 
 They too have mastered the fundamentals of the Common Military Syilabus and will continue to build on the foundations laid at the WRAC Centre When they return to their units. 
 By 0700 hours the 120 recruits of the junior intake, Who are in their fourth week of training, have finished cleaning their rooms and join the centipede of recruits marching in small groups towards the Elizabethan Restaurant. 
 At home most were never up at this hour, and breakfast was either a meal only to be enjoyed at the weekend or eaten hastily prior to catching the bus to work. 
 Now it is an essential part of the day and young recruits quickly learn that a good breakfast is vital if they are to survive another demanding day.  
 Outside the birdsong has been replaced by the sound of a military band marching up the road. 
 Following close behind is the parade, 140 recruits and eighteen staff Who are taking part in a rehearsal for today's parade with the band, which is the Pegasus Band of the Parachute Regiment. 
 They are standing ln for the WRAC Staff Band Who are away on an important engagement in Eastbourne and Who have only recently returned from a tour in BAOR. 
 After two circuits of the massive parade ground, said to be one of the largest in Great Britain, everyone is satisfied and the recruits return to their accommodation While the band retires for some well-earned refreshments. 
 During all the activity on the square, 5 Platoon have been working away in the gym doing circuit training under the watchful eyes of the Physical Training Instructors. 
 During their course each recruit will complete forty-four periods of PT and a further twenty periods of games and sports. 
 In addition to the muscle-stretching circuits, the recruits tackle endurance runs of up to six and a half miles, aerobics, assault courses and the Military Swimming Test. 
 They will certainly leave the Centre much fitter than When they arrived, but not without a few bumps and bruises sustained along the way. 
 &bquo;Left, left, left, right, left&equo; &mdash; the familiar sound drifts across Queen Elizabeth Park as 6 Platoon march to the armoury to return the sub-machine-guns after two periods of weapon training. 
 WRAC recruits have been doing weapon training only since July 1988, but they quickly master the skills of stripping and assembling, cleaning and preparing, before they progress to live firing on the ranges. 
 The WRAC recruits have proved to be excellent shots and many of the scores achieved would be the envy of their male counterparts. 
 One of the WRAC Weapons Instructors looks on as the weapons are handed in at the armoury. 
 A peaceful calm settles across the Centre for a short time before the parade. 
 However, it does not extend to the Regimental Headquarters, where the Adjutant appears to be becoming somewhat heated on the telephone as a local unit announce that a helicopter will be arriving at 1130 hours to collect maps from the adjoining map depot. 
 Eventually she convinces the caller that the timing is somewhat inconvenient as the square will be fully occupied by the parade; a revised time is agreed and another crisis is averted. 
 Just time for a cup of coffee, she thinks, but she will have to make it herself as the office is short staffed, with the Corporal Clerk away representing the Corps at the celebrations to mark the tenth anniversary of the Queen Mother being appointed Lord Warden of the Cinque Ports. 
 The Adjutant abandons the idea of a coffee and hurries towards the Officers' Mess Where the Inspecting Officer is due to arrive shortly. 
 Her progress is delayed by the 400 parents and friends who have all decided to move to the edge of the parade ground to ensure they get good seats for the parade. 
 The aroma of lunch wafts from the Elizabethan. 
 Today they serve over 700, as most of the visitors will join the recruits for the meal. 
 At 1100 hours all is set and the parade ground is filled by the long ranks of the 180 members of Training Company and the Pegasus Band all awaiting the arrival of the Inspecting Officer, Brigadier Mike Scott DSO CBE, who commanded the 1st Battalion of the Scots Guards in the Falklands War. 
 The junior recruits sit on the edge of the parade ground to witness the parade and to learn  what they must achieve after a further four weeks' training. 
 They are joined by forty members of the WRAC Association London Branches. 
 It is a good few years since most of them were serving, and the memories will soon be flooding back. 
 There are also nine members of the Kent Army Cadet Force, so one side of the parade ground represents three generations of servicewomen. 
 The Parade Commander brings the parade to attention as the staff car draws up &mdash; the video cameras whir as fathers and brothers jockey for the positions with the best view. 
 Everyone stands for the general salute &mdash; they may be civilian guests, but they have studied the programme avidly and have learnt what to do. 
 The Inspecting Officer, accompanied by the Commandant and the Parade Commander, head for 1 Platoon Who are the first to be inspected. 
 There follows a slow procession as the Inspecting Officer progresses along the ranks of extremely proud recruits and Training Staff. 
 While the band plays incidental  music the recruits struggle not to sway to the tones of the well-known tunes. 
 Where do you come from? 
 What trade are you going to follow? 
 Have you enjoyed the course? 
 Why did you join the Army? 
 What have you learnt about yourself during training? 
 These are amongst the questions the Inspecting Officer asks the recruits. 
 To one side of the square the stretcher party from Headquarters and Holding Company hover ready to remove any casualties to the medical centre. 
 They won't be needed today, as the Inspecting Officer is just finishing his inspection of the band, and the parade will shortly be on the move. 
 The bass drum beats and the parade sets off as one to march twice past the Inspecting Officer. 
 The platoon commanders shout their commands and the recruits manoeuvre into the required formations. 
 Past the saluting dais in perfectly straight lines, shoes glinting in the sun and heads held high. 
 The TA bring up the rear, dressed in their lightweight trousers, boots and shirts; many a member of staff and Regular recruit wishes that they were dressed the same, as the sun is high in the sky and their No 2 dress is somewhat warm. 
 Minutes later the band strikes up again and leads the parade off the square. 
 No longer recruits, but trained servicewomen; amongst the smiles there is the occasional tear, as it is almost the end of recruit training. 
 As the platoons march towards the assembly hall for a short church service and the Inspecting Officer's address and presentation of awards, a minibus pulls away from the selection centre. 
 Inside are five potential recruits who have just spent twenty-four hours being briefed, tested, interviewed and assessed. 
 Having spent a night in accommodation which is the same as the recruits' and having had the opportunity to talk to some of the recruits in the Sandes Coffee Shop last night, they have an excellent idea about their future career. 
 AIl five have been offered the vacancies they wanted: one to be a military policewoman, another a driver, the third to train as an administrative assistant, While the other two are destined to be a staff clerk and a telecommunications operator. 
 They have been guaranteed vacancies and will all return to the Centre next month to start their recruit training. 
 In the meantime there is much to be achieved before they too will march off the parade ground as trained servicewomen. 
 At last the formal part of the proceedings is over and the recruits are united with their friends and relations. 
 As the recruits recount all sorts of &bquo;anglers&equo; tales' about the last eight weeks of training, the Inspecting Officer and Commandant mingle with the visitors, Who have travelled from all corers of the United Kingdom and a few from further afield. 
 After half an hour the gathering breaks up and the recruits escort their visitors off to lunch, or on a tour of camp for yet more photographs. 
 Brigadier Scott is taken to the Sergeants' Mess to meet the Mess members, all of Whom have played vital parts either as instructors or in the administrative support of the recruits' training, prior to lunching in the Officers' Mess. 
 Before going for their lunch the Physical Training Instructors must complete the last of their duties as ushers. 
 In addition to controlling the visitors during the parade, they have been collecting for the WRAC Association and the collection boxes must be returned to Corps Headquarters. 
 As the corporals head for lunch they pass a recruit from the TA platoon shepherding her  visitors toward the museum, Where she is convinced that she has found a photograph of her mother, Who served in the Auxiliary Territorial Service in 1945. 
 While the recruits and their visitors enjoy the day, the staff and students of the Warrant Officers' and Non-Commissioned Officers' Wing continue their work. 
 Twenty-four potential corporals are approaching the climax of their Corporals' course, and this afternoon they will be tackling the practical command tasks Which are designed to test their leadership skills and their ability to solve practical problems. 
 The students on the nine-and-a-half-day course represent twelve different WRAC trades: range assistants, analysts, military accountants, cooks, kennelmaid, medical assistant, switchboard operator, stewardess, supply specialist, movement controller, telecommunications technician and postal and courier operator. 
 Tomorrow they will go back to their units, Which are scattered from Hong Kong to Berlin, Northern Ireland and all over Great Britain. 
 The junior recruits have all gone to Aldershot to take their Military Swimming Test and to have chest X-rays. 
 The senior recruits have gone out with their visitors, before they return to pack ready for their departure to their trade training in the morning. 
 The students on the Corporals' course have solved most of the command tasks and have returned to their syndicate rooms to be debriefed. 
 The Adjutant is back at her desk as a helicopter lands on the square. 
 It is not the one to collect maps, but a VIP helicopter bearing the Minister to the Armed Forces. 
 The Adjutant hastens out to see him to his car, which is waiting on the edge of the square. 
 The WRAC Centre helicopter landing site is often used by visiting dignitaries, and as he leaves the Minister tells the Adjutant that he wishes to visit the unit in the autumn. 
 A group of potential servicewomen watch the activity as they complete their one-mile run as part of the selection procedure. 
 In the Elizabethan Restaurant the shift has changed and tea is being prepared; the duty staff will be in for an early meal shortly. 
 The civilian staff put out the empty milk bottles and leave the camp, another day's work done, and the regimental police staff in the guardroom check to see that all the recruits have booked in and that all the visitors have been booked out. 
 The junior recruits set about their evening tasks While the seniors pack and then head for the NAAFI for their end-of-course party. 
 Elsewhere, in the Warrant Officers' and Non-Commissioned Officers' Wing accommodation, there is another end-of-course party in full swing. 
 The Orderly Officer inspects the duty staff on staff parade and then goes on her rounds to check the perimeter fence. 
 The regimental police secure the buildings, and as dusk falls the Orderly Officer is on her rounds again to check the NAFFI. 
 By 2300 hours all is quiet as the majority of the unit prepares for bed. 
 Just as birdsong awoke the unit, an owl is heard calling as it flies its nightly patrol over 
 Queen Elizabeth Park. 
 Another day at the WRAC Centre draws to a close.  
 The platoon commander reports her platoon ready for inspection to the inspecting officer at a passing-out-parade at WRAC Depot in Guildford 
 The inspecting officer reviewing the passing-out platoon 
 the Maritime Arm: 17 Port Regiment, Royal corps of Transport 
 The Royal corps of Transport is responsible, for the most part, for the provision of land transport to support the Army's logistics needs. 
 Here we see a less well known side of the Corps' life &mdash; its maritime arm. 
 At first, all he could see was the glint of water and the dark outline of the Isle of Wight, across the Solent. 
 Gradually, almost imperceptibly, the light strengthened and soon he could make out the shape of boats, the mexeflote causeway and the patchwork of woods and fields on the island. 
 Standing silently in his trench, dug into the shingle on Browndown Beach, Driver Oliver looked along the sights of his light machine gun. 
 If the enemy was going to attack, this was always the most likely and dangerous time. 
 52 Composite Port Squadron, one of the two regular operational squadrons in 17 Port Regiment RCT, was on exercise. 
 Nearby, the remainder of the squadron was stirring after a brief respite in a busy twenty-four period. 
 Some would have had no sleep. 
 Ramped Craft Logistic and mexeflote rafts had been arriving regularly throughout the night, continuing the build-up of vehicles and ammunition Which had been going on for the past two days. 
 It looked as though it was going to be another fine day. 
 If the weather held and there was no attack, the build-up should soon be complete. 
 As a Class 2 Port Operator, Driver Oliver had already played a full part in the discharge of many of the vessels, but everyone took their turn at sentry duty in the trenches protecting the squadron location. 
 And now, as dawn broke, Driver Oliver kept a watchful eye on the slowly lightening coastline. 
 The horizon cleared, and the dark outline of an anchored vessel developed into the clear grey shape of one of 51 Port Squadron's Ramped Craft Logistic (RCL), which had been attached to 52 Port Squadron for the duration of the exercise. 
 In the Wheelhouse of RCTV Audemer,  Corporal Fisher rubbed his tired eyes and looked along the thirty-three-metre length of the RCL and its now empty cargo deck, capable of carrying up to ninety-six tonnes of vehicles or freight. 
 The crew had been busy running cargo and vehicles on a waterborne Main Supply Route until just after midnight. 
 As a Class 2 Navigator, Corporal Fisher was mate of the RCL, and was often called upon to command and navigate the vessel through coastal waters as far afield as Norway and Portugal. 
 The RCL's crew of six men, all RCT seamen and marine engineers, allowed a two-watch system to operate. 
 The &bquo;skipper&equo;, or coxswain, ran one and the mate the other. 
 In the command post further back from the beach, Corporal Williams, the duty radio operator, was decoding a message which had just been received. 
 &bquo;RFA Sir Percivale  now due your location 0900 hrs. 
 Two hundred passengers  and one hundred vehicles plus containers and freight for discharge.&equo; 
 He passed the message to the duty watchkeeper. 
 Lieutenant Male read it and smiled to himself. 
 He was looking forward to this. 
 It would be very different unloading the skip across the beach to the routine operation in Marchwood Military Port. 
 Everything would have to be unloaded at anchorage on to mexeflote rafts and then brought ashore. 
 Vehicles would then drive off, up the roller trackway Which had been laid like a silver ribbon across the soft shingle of the beach, and formed up in marshalling areas before moving on to their destination. 
 Containers and freight, craned down on to the raft from the deck of the LSL, would be lifted off by the giant Fiat Allis fork-lift trucks. 
 He looked at his watch &mdash; 0445 hours, just over an hour to go before breakfast. 
 Back at the Military Port in Marchwood, the working day for the remainder of the regiment would not start for another hour and a half. 
 Apart that is from those on duty. 
 Security is a high priority in all military establishments, and sentries are constantly on patrol, twenty-four hours a day. 
 At 0630 hours the first of the early risers entered the cookhouse for breakfast. 
 Army food might once have been something of a joke, but certainly not any more. 
 The standards are as good as any first class hotel. 
 Fresh grapefruit, bacon and eggs and piping hot coffee and rolls. 
 A good solid start to the day. 
 In the Sergeants' Mess, Sergeant Allen finished his breakfast and walked across to the armoury. 
 A group of soldiers were already there, collecting their rifles ready to go to the rifle range. 
 He called the roll. 
 Two men still missing, but plenty of time yet. 
 Sergeant Allen always liked to be ready early, to have everything buttoned up before the Troop Commander arrived: it got things off to a good start. 
 He ran through his check list: ammunition, radios, first aid, packed meals.. 
 . Everything in order and the last two men just arriving now. 
 Perfect. 
 &bquo;Good morning, sir, last man just collecting his weapon &mdash; ammunition and stores all loaded in the truck &mdash; ready to go in two minutes.&equo; 
 It would be a good day. 
 Just twenty-five men on the range. 
 Today they would have their annual personal weapon test. 
 Those waiting to fire would receive first aid instruction, and then afterwards everyone would spend some time in the gas chamber wearing NBC kit. 
 Constant training and familiarisation give everyone more confidence in their equipment and their ability to survive a chemical attack in war. 
 By now the camp was coming to life properly. 
 Those not on exercise, shooting on the range or included in particular duties, were gathering outside the gymnasium. 
 The PTI appeared carrying two footballs and everyone relaxed slightly. 
 He was a good PTI, he made PT fun and didn't just stick to PT and running &mdash; but there was no messing about either and he doubled them across the barracks to the football pitch, Where in the next half hour they worked as hard playing football as they would have done in the gymnasium. 
 Meanwhile, as the Quay Foreman (the Warrant Officer in charge of Port Operations), WO2 Barker, walked down the Port South road, five vehicles loaded with ammunition rumbled past him. 
 The duty plant operator, Lance-Corporal Adcock, was just finishing the first parade service on his equipment &mdash; a Henley Hermes fork-lift truck with a twenty-five-ton lifting capacity. 
 He had hoped there would be time for a quick cup of tea but it wasn't to be. 
 The first  container wagon was already waiting outside with two containers for Kenya. 
 Just as he finished dealing with that, another two containers arrived&hellip;. 
 Up until eleven o'clock everything went pretty well, When just as you start thinking to yourself that's the last one for a while, lo and behold another wagon turns up. 
 It was quite pleasant to get a radio call at 1115 hours to say &bquo;stop doing the container wagons, we're starting the Arakan.' 
 This job consisted of picking up thirty-six containers from the jetty Where they were being unloaded from HMAV Arakan  (one of the two Army Landing Craft Logistic) and moving them to the container park. 
 Quite a job to keep up with the crane. 
 You tend to get one behind, then suddenly, before you know it, the number on the jetty seems to have multiplied. 
 Well, it was just into lunchtime and word came to stop &mdash; but almost immediately that was changed, and we were working through to get the ship finished. 
 Working part of lunchtime had a slight advantage for me because it meant I now had a bit more time to load the container rail set. 
 Twenty containers later, the movements NCO came out with the rest of my day's details &mdash; five trailers to cross-load ready for the Bicester lads to pick up later in the afternoon. 
 As it was getting late, it was time to recruit the assistance of a second machine to get the job done on time&hellip;. 
 Browndown Beach 0900 hours almost to the minute, and RFA Sir Percivale  is dropping anchor 400 yards offshore. 
 An RIB (Rigid Inflatable Boat with a ninety-horsepower outboard engine, capable of nearly forty knots) races out to meet her with the operations captain and a customs officer on board. 
 Customs clearance is a necessary peacetime requirement, but it doesn't interfere too seriously with the exercise. 
 On the beach, the &bquo;Beachmaster&equo; (the staff sergeant in charge of beach operations), Staff Sergeant McRobb, is getting impatient. 
 The wind is beginning to get up and he is keen to be started. 
 The stern ramp is down almost as quickly as the anchor and the first mexeflote raft is soon manoeuvring into position&hellip;. 
 It's nearly 1000 hours before the first mexeflote raft brings ashore an assortment of Land-Rovers, trailers and four-tonners. 
 Again, inexperienced drivers &mdash; if I have to say &bquo;low ratio, low gear&equo; once more I think I'll thump someone! 
 The discharge goes smoothly. 
 By 1330 hrs it is complete and I've managed to throw some lunch down and grab another brew. 
 The next job is to reconfigure the mexeflote rafts so that they can be used for other tasks. 
 This is hazardous at the best of times, using a crane and the natural motion of the sea to lock and unlock the mexeflote cells. 
 It's not easy When the wind is force two or three &mdash; but by now it is blowing force six with a sea state to match and it is becoming dangerous. 
 As the wind continues to rise it is decided to postpone the operation until it moderates &mdash; too many men's fingers and hands at stake! 
 The flotes are secured to the beach by their bow lines, using one of the &bquo;Fiats&equo; with a bucket like a bulldozer, to bury the lines and hold them fast. 
   1800 hrs &mdash; more food, another brew and this time enough for seconds. 
 I can be more leisurely now &mdash; my next real deadline is 2000 hours When the OC's &bquo;O Group&equo; is held. 
 I contemplate a quick thirty minutes in my sleeping bag, but by the time I've checked on the sentries again it's too late. 
 After the &bquo;O Group&equo; I'm in the picture for the tasking over the next twenty-four hours. 
 My priority is to get the mexeflote reconfiguration completed. 
 The wind has moderated by 2100 hrs so we start Where we left off, completing the job by 0200 hrs the next morning. 
 Check the sentries one more time then I'm in my sleeping bag by 0230 hrs &mdash; luxury &mdash; a lie-in now until 0530 hrs!&hellip; 
 Back in Marchwood the &bquo;routine&equo; operation of the port had continued. 
 With half the regiment away on exercise and some on the range, the remainder had been busy. 
 WO2 Barker, the Quay Foreman, hadn't stopped: 
 Started to load the first mexeflote raft with ammunition for MV Puma  (a chartered merchant ship carrying ammunition to the continent for troops in Germany), at 0950 hours. 
 By 1130 hours the load was complete and slipped, bound for Netley Buoys Where the Puma  is anchored. 
 I can now split the &bquo;shore side&equo; gang and start to load the RCL with the remaining ammunition and the two twenty-foot containers. 
 It is 1230 hours. 
 I book the late meals at 1430 hours for everyone, and organise the loading of fifty pallets for the exercise &mdash; working through lunch to get the vessel away as quickly as possible. 
 Break for lunch &mdash; half an hour and then back again. 
 By now phone calls into and out of my office average one every thirty seconds. 
 I dream of somewhere quiet Where no one can find me. 
 By 1600 hours the load on PTA Sir Geraint,  Which has been going on all afternoon, is complete to the Chief Officer's satisfaction. 
 The RCL is back. 
 Everyone is clearing up. 
 1650 hours &mdash; I take a final walk round. 
 Everything away. 
 I close down the port operations office. 
 Suddenly the port looks deserted. 
 I walk back up to the top gate. 
 Another day over&hellip;. 
 Staff Sergeant McRobb supervising the loading of vehicles on to a Royal Corps of Transport craft at the military Port of Marchwood near Southampton 
 The Army Catering Corps Major M W Herriot ACC 
 Napoleon is supposed to have said &bquo;An army marches on its stomach.&equo; 
 her we see a typical day in the life of the Army Catering Corps. 
 No 4 Region Army Catering Service (UK) has its headquarters in York. 
 Responsible to the General Officer Commanding the Military District, their task is to ensure the required catering services are provided daily for some 12,000 Regular and 11,000 Territorial Army soldiers throughout the north-east of England. 
 Each unit has a team of ACC chefs allocated to it, led by a Master Chef. 
 Every infantry battalion has some twenty chefs led by a Warrant Officer, Whilst a smaller training unit might have only eleven chefs, led by a Staff Sergeant. 
 In civilian parlance Major Mike Herriott, Who runs No 4 Region, could be described as the &bquo;District Catering Operations Manager&equo;, and as such he arranges for each of the twenty Master Chefs to receive regular visits from one of the team of three Area Catering Officers (ACOs) or six Area Catering Warrant Officers (ACWOs). 
 Progress is monitored and difficulties reported. 
 Lieutenant-Colonel Gordon Wilkinson has responsibility for two military districts and looks after &bquo;England north of the Wash&equo;. 
 His office and that of Major Herriott are side by side in York. 
 On 30 June Colonel Wilkinson was at his desk catching up on policy matters after having been away for several days visiting units in the Liverpool area and attending an Army Catering Corps Promotion Selection Board held at Exeter. 
 He actually wears out suitcases in this job. 
 That day was, for the Colonel, devoted to a succession of telephone calls and a stack of files, most with &bquo;urgent&equo; tags pinned on them. 
 It was Major Herriott's turn to get out of the office, having held the fort whilst his leader had been away. 
 Accompanied by Warrant Officer Bill Morgan, ACWO for the York area, he spent the day visiting 16 Air Defence Regiment, Royal Artillery, near Scunthorpe in Lincolnshire. 
 Meanwhile, further north at Catterick Garrison near Darlington, Captain Brian Hymers, one of the two ACOs in that garrison, was involved in managing the provision of lunch for His Majesty King Olav of Norway. 
 The King, in his capacity as Colonel-in-Chief of 1st Battalion The Green Howards (Alexandra, Princess of Wales's Own Yorkshire Regiment), was paying a visit to present new Colours upon the occasion of the regiment's tercentenary celebrations. 
 Captain Hymers had selected Sergeant Christopher Evans, serving with 8 Signal Regiment, also at Catterick, to prepare lunch for the King.  
 Chris Evans is something of a star and was a finalist in the &bquo;Army Chef of the Year&equo; competition in 1989. 
 He made it all seem easy, producing an excellent meal, and the lunch party at the Commanding Officer's residence went off without a hitch. 
 Captain Hymers didn't stay to see the coffee served because he then went on to visit another of his garrison units, namely the Duchess of Kent's Military Hospital. 
 Joined by the Master Chef, Warrant Officer Bill McSeveny, he toured the hospital wards to talk to the patients and staff to ensure that his customers were content and that all their respective dietary requirements were being met. 
 It is not always easy to keep Warrant Officer McSeveny's mind on catering, because he is a rugby referee of note and When not on parade with his whistle he is usually talking or playing rugby. 
 However, in June, rugby is still some time away and his formidable catering expertise was well in evidence in the hospital. 
 Elsewhere in Catterick that day, another member of the team, Warrant   Officer Dunston was busy ensuring that the enormous catering support required by the 1st Battalion The Green Howards for their tercentenary celebrations was running smoothly. 
 In view of the size of the commitment, an outside catering contractor had to be called in to help provide lunch for 1,400 people in a large marquee on the garrison sports ground. 
 Quite correctly, the ACS insists that such contractors produce the same standards of catering that are expected of the ACC. 
 It fell to Warrant Officer Dunston to ensure the service was up to an impeccable standard, not an easy task in the boiling heat of the summer of 1989. 
 In this business, as soon as one meal is complete there is a need to start on the next, and the ACC chefs of the battalion, lunch behind them, had now to prepare for the functions to be held that evening in the Officers', and Warrant Officers' and Sergeants' Messes for 180 and 350 people respectively. 
 No fuss, no bother, but hard physical work nevertheless, with high job satisfaction When it's all over. 
 All in all, a not untypical day in Catterick, Which houses one of the largest garrisons in the Army, composed of a diverse range of units and all catered for by No 4 Region. 
 Happily there were no reports of scurvy, beri beri or other ailments caused by malnutrition! 
 The Territorial Army now constitutes a vital element of the British Army and has to be supported in the same way as the Regular Army. 
 One of No 4 Region's officers, Captain James Knowles, supported by Warrant Officer Ronald Fowles, spends much of his time advising, instructing and inspecting the catering operations of TA units the length and breadth of northern England. 
 On 30 June 1989, Captain Knowles and Warrant Officer Fowles were visiting the Army's transit training camp at Scarborough to ensure that 35 Signal Regiment (V) from London on their annual summer training camp were enjoying a satisfactory standard of catering. 
 This is particularly important When one considers that the TA soldier is fed by a TA chef, and although that TA chef wears an ACC cap badge, he can be recruited from any walk of life ranging from bus driver to company director, to sewerage worker. 
 They are a wonderful bunch of men Who seem to find the hard physical work involved therapeutic. 
 They really are a special breed. 
 The ACC are busy&hellip; always. 
 Caterers live in the real world, not for them exercise followed by exercise, because they do for real in peace what they would do in war and they wouldn't want to change that. 
 Feeding soldiers is not a glamorous business; for the most part it is an administrative function that goes unnoticed. 
 However, feeding is critical and soldiers who are unfed can't fight, indeed after about forty-eight hours they fall over! 
 That didn't happen on 30 June 1989 and it won't happen at any time in the future if the Army Catering Corps has anything to do with it!  
 Sergeant Chris Evans at work in a typical Army kitchen 
 Captain Brian Hymers and WO2 Bill McSweeny chat to Mr Sam Samgate, a patient of theirs, in the Duchess of Kent Military Hospital 
 Serving to Lead at RMA Sandhurst 
 The Royal Military Academy Sandhurst is famous throughout the world. 
 In this chapter we are able to witness a typical day in its life. 
 The thirtieth of June 1989 begins early for some of the officer cadets of the Royal Military Academy Sandhurst. 
 It is just past midnight and many of the cadets from Old College are guarding well-concealed patrol bases in remote valleys and woods up in the Welsh hills near Sennybridge. 
 They have been on exercise for a week, learning and practising the techniques of counterrevolutionary warfare in a rural setting. 
 This particular setting is very authentic and the cadets have had only the company of sheep during their enthusiastic quest for insurgents. 
 The weather is not kind, having rained steadily for most of the week, fully endorsing everyone's suspicions that the Sennybridge hills conjure up their own unique climate. 
 Most of these seemingly alert young men, acting as sentries for their sleeping comrades, are soaked to the skin and looking forward to a little sleep themselves before the final push against the enemy. 
 The sentries begin waking up the patrol base. 
 &bquo;Half an hour to be ready in all respects for the move&equo;, the orders said. 
 Two hours for the approach march to the enemy's encampment and everyone to be in position before the first hints of dawn. 
 Sleep-drugged figures stumble quietly around their bivouacs, feeling for the last few items of rain-sodden kit to stow in their bergens. 
 The Directing Staff are out and about, unobtrusively encouraging, cajoling and even hissing the occasional order until the column moves off. 
 The enemy's base, a disused farmhouse, has been examined in great detail by an earlier reconnaissance patrol and everyone knows, in theory at least, how to reach it and What to do on arrival. 
 The drills begin to take over&hellip; movement by night, how to react to any unexpected encounters en route. 
 .. and a myriad of other details, talked about in the classroom, practised back in the Academy grounds and now for &bquo;real&equo;. 
 The march is reasonably uneventful, insofar as this is possible moving ninety fully-equipped men through a dense, damp forest in the dark, but the Company arrives at its final rendezvous intact and on time. 
 The next trick is to divide the Company into &bquo;cut-off&equo; groups and an assault group, for the delicate business of closing with and capturing or destroying the enemy. 
 The leaders of the groups take command and move silently towards their predesignated positions on the approaches to the farm. 
 The area around the farm had been described in detail the evening before, during the orders for the attack. 
 Now the importance of certain landmarks and reference points becomes clear; each group knows What to do for the attack.  
 The most frustrating aspect of this preparatory phase is the waiting period before the attack is triggered. 
 Every man has moved into position and must remain silent and unobserved until the critical moment. 
 The rain continues, as does the struggle to stay warm and awake. 
 The brain drifts back to full consciousness now that there is a vague hint of light spreading across the eastern sky. 
 At last, at about 0345 hours, the farm buildings become defined against the woods and fields beyond. 
 Soon the enemy &mdash; Gurkhas from Sandhurst's own demonstration company &mdash; can be observed moving about their base. 
 A long burst of fire from a machine-gun shatters the dawn and, before the echoes die away down the valleys, the attack is under way. 
 There is theatrical panic in the enemy base as they react to the noise and weight of firepower. 
 few well-laid plans survive after the initial exchange of fire, and our famous Gurkha insurgents are not going to give up without one of their renowned fights. 
 They swiftly organise a counter-attack and fight their way out of the farm buildings, heading off in a most unexpected direction, not at all within the design of battle envisaged by the officer cadet commanding the operation. 
 He gives fresh orders to his nearest cut-off group to redeploy rapidly. 
 The resulting action is a combined display of enthusiastic pursuit by the cadets and good-natured acceptance of inevitable defeat by the insurgents. 
 The farm and its outbuildings are captured, together with several prisoners. 
 Those that have tried to escape have been either &bquo;killed&equo; or rounded up. 
 All in all, a good conclusion to a well planned and executed attack, and a good note upon which to end the exercise. 
 A thoroughly satisfying breakfast follows the post-mortem of the exercise, and it is still only 0530 hours! 
 The coach trip back to the Academy is remembered by few, as the dirty and damp officer cadets catch up on much lost sleep. 
 As the coaches slip quietly through the tolls on the Severn Bridge, the Royal Military Academy itself is beginning to come to life. 
 One company starts the  day with a military history lecture on the Second World War, another is being taught the skills of interviewing, both by the Academy's own academic staff. 
 For the senior intakes and the Women's Standard Course, breakfast is followed by Military Technology. 
 The lecture team comes from the Royal Military College of Science, Where Army undergraduates read science degrees. 
 They will give presentations on those aspects of engineering and science that are having an impact on the development of military equipment and systems. 
 After the lecture the cadets are divided into groups of about twenty-five to discuss the implications of all that they have heard. 
 The pattern will repeat itself throughout much of the day, with discussion following each presentation. 
 In Academy Headquarters another type of presentation is under way: &bquo;All male and female officers are now trained at Sandhurst, the majority following either a forty-four-week course for male non-graduates, or a twenty-eight-week course for graduates and women officer cadets.&equo; 
 This time it is the home team briefing a visiting General about the Sandhurst courses. 
 The length and content of the course has changed many times since the last war, and several high-ranking officers are updated each year. 
 &bquo;The training year follows much the same pattern as the conventional academic year, with the main intakes arriving at the beginning of the spring, summer and autumn terms and passing out after the respective twenty-eight- or forty-four-week courses. 
 There is a great emphasis on sport and outdoor pursuits, and during the holidays the cadets are obliged to take part in adventurous training activities both in the UK and abroad.&equo; 
 The briefing continues, giving the General a complete picture of Sandhurst in 1989. 
 Much has changed since he was at the Academy in 1959 and he will soon see just how much When he makes a personal tour of the Academy. 
 He begins, Where present-day Sandhurst began, in Old Building. 
 Courses have been run continually since 1812 in this part of the Academy, and with its impressive frontage, parade square and greensward leading down to the lake, it dominates the grounds. 
 Behind the fa&ccedil;ade there are hundreds of rooms; most famous perhaps is the Indian Anny Memorial Room directly behind the Grand Entrance, Which doubles as a museum and an ornate function room. 
 The rest of the rooms are in day-to-day use as ante-rooms, offices, accommodation, or halls or study. 
 It is in one such hall of study that he encounters the TA Commissioning course, which is examining the art of patrolling. 
 They are currently locked in animated detailed discussion with their platoon commander, an experienced infantry captain. 
 Having established the finer points, the course moves out to the Barossa training area of gorse, bracken and small pine woods adjacent to the Academy. 
 They act out roles and techniques under the watchful eye of their instructors. 
 A position of all-round defence is adopted, prior to moving on towards an imaginary objective. 
 It is hard to take it all seriously When practising during daylight, but as our friends in Wales found, controlling a mobile body of men at night, without getting lost and remaining undetected, is not easy. 
 The visiting General smiles to himself as he watches the patrol reacting to an imaginary enemy ambush. 
 This aspect of training has not changed at all. 
 Cadets are in disarray, Directing Staff shouting advice and encouragement, and the imaginary enemy winning!  
 Three miles outside the Academy gates, the sleepers from Sennybridge are woken up, propped up and generally made to look like smart, alert soldiers entering a military environment. 
 The homecoming procedure, even after a long and exhausting exercise, is well known. 
 All weapons are cleaned and examined before being locked back into the armoury, then personal kit can be dealt with. 
 Washing machines and dryers are kept busy for the rest of the day and much of the night. 
 The TA course's patrolling is coming on well and the visitor has moved on to see What the junior intake is doing. 
 These officer cadets have been at the Academy since early May and are now well into their fourteen-week first term. 
 Like the other intakes they are a mixture of schoolboy entrants, overseas cadets and ex-soldiers with varying degrees of experience and proficiency in the ranks. 
 So far today they have been studying how orders for an operation are given and the particular way in which the Army goes about explaining a complex undertaking. 
 When giving orders, much of the impact of What is said is derived from the stage management of the Whole procedure. 
 The General looks on as a cadet is singled out to deliver his orders to others from his platoon. 
 He and his fellow cadets will have plenty of opportunity in the next two terms to practise this particular communication skill, and it is used extensively as a means of assessing cadets. 
 Sandhurst's motto is &bquo;Serve to Lead&equo;, and putting a cadet under pressure is just one way of developing leadership qualities. 
 With the details of ohms, amps, radiation dosages, and the speed of a new high-velocity missile fresh in their minds, the military technologists have exhausted their discussions and now find themselves on parade. 
 After hearing about the latest methods of transporting troops about the battlefield, it is reassuring to know that the leg, foot and boot still work! 
 The General is impressed. 
 He is taken back again to 1959, to the Sandhurst he remembers. 
 Drill, he had been told thirty years ago, is a curious aspect of training. 
 It epitomises many of the characteristics of good soldiering: attention to detail, speed of response to orders, and a sense of pride, and it forges a link with the traditions of the past. 
 The pageantry of the Sovereign's Parade, When the senior cadets are formally commissioned and the Adjutant tides up the steps of Old Building on his White charger, goes back many years. 
 So too does the humour in the Company Sergeant Major's patter as he demands and gets higher and higher standards &mdash; &bquo;Mr Smith, sir, at drill you are as much use as a window cleaner in Beirut.&equo; 
 By late afternoon the clean-up following the Sennybridge exercise is nearly complete. 
 For the Gurkhas Who provided the enemy, however, there is still no rest. 
 They are now in their full fighting order of dress, giving a very detailed and practical demonstration of patrolling to the TA course. 
 This will clear up any mysteries from this morning's lesson and set the scene for tonight's exercise. 
 Overlapping with the men's TA course is a course fur women TA officers. 
 They have spent the morning in classrooms working through a command post exercise; they practise passing information and responding to the numerous and varied problems that would be posed in a real headquarters. 
 Then, in contrast to their sedentary morning, they have an orienteering competition in the afternoon, followed by a rehearsal fur their Passing-Out Parade. 
 The visiting General departs from the Academy after tea. 
 His short visit has  given him much information about the courses but, more importantly, he now has an intimate feeling of how these young men and women, drawn from all walks of life, are trained. 
 For him the high spot of the day was listening to the very earnest young man delivering an extremely good set of orders. 
 The stage management was good, the model of the terrain excellent, but he attacked the wrong objective! 
 He clearly remembers a similar young man under similar circumstances back in 1959! 
 By the time the General's car has nosed its way into London and home, most of the cadets are changing fur dinner. 
 Some, like the women's TA course, are dressing fur their end-of-course party, while others are preparing to do battle during their night patrol exercise. 
 The cadets on Academy guard duty are patrolling the grounds; those with enough money and energy are heading fur the bright lights. 
 All will have to be back fur an &bquo;at home&equo; sports weekend against the Combined Naval Colleges of Manadon and Dartmouth. 
 These I keenly fought competitions make use of all the excellent sports facilities throughout the Academy: cricket, tennis and clay pigeon shooting in the grounds, golf, swimming in Sandhurst's own indoor pool, and even rowing on the lakes. 
 By midnight the end-of-course party is in full swing, but most cadets, like the General, are sound asleep. 
 The guard continues its relentless search for for suspicious people and packages. 
 The patrol moves quietly from its position of all-round defence. 
 It has successfully completed its task and is returning home. 
 Another day in the life of Sandhurst.  
 You learn to sleep anywhere in the Army! 
 Field Marshal Sir Nigel Bagnall inspecting officer cadets at the RMA Sandhurst during a Passing-Out Parade. 
 Notice how the platoon he is inspecting has been &bquo;sized&equo; with the tallest men on the smallest in the smallest in the middle. 
 The cadets are carrying the SA-80 rifle 
 Preston Barracks, Brighton: The Territorial Army 
 The Territorial Army is an integral part of the Army. 
 This chapter gives a fascinating insight into the &bquo;other life&equo; led by thousands of men and women throughout Britain. 
 For the TA, 30 June has been stretched into the ensuing weekend, 1 and 2 July. 
 Preston Barracks was built before the Second World War for a cavalry regiment. 
 It lies on the easter outskirts of Brighton in East Sussex, and today is the home of three Territorial Army units, each representing a different part of the Army. 
 The oldest is 583 (EOD) Squadron of the Royal Engineers, EOD standing for Explosive Ordnance Disposal. 
 It was formed in 1981 and is now part of the new 101 (London) Engineer Regiment, the bomb disposal experts of the TA. 
 Formed a year later is a detachment of 253 Provost Company, Royal Military Police (V), whose headquarters is at Tulse Hill in South London, with another detachment at Southampton. 
 The newest unit, raised in 1986 as part of the TA's expansion programme, is B (Somme) Company of 6th/7th Battalion, The Queen's Regiment, an infantry unit. 
 In time of war, the men and women of the Territorial Army make up about one-third of the Army, providing more than half the infantry needed in BAOR and over sixty per cent of the Army's medical services. 
 Without them this country could not meet its NATO and home defence commitments. 
 The TA's members are all civilians during the day, busy at their own careers, and the training and experience volunteers get during their time in uniform provide a different perspective on life. 
 Management and leadership training and experience for NCOs and officers, new skills training for everyone, and a very much higher level of fitness than that of the average civilian are benefits of their voluntary service. 
 In the fifty years since the TA was last called up for war there have been many changes. 
 In 1939 the TA was poorly equipped. 
 Today it is identically equipped to the Regular Army and is highly trained in at least one speciality. 
 This weekend is typical of many throughout the year. 
 It started early for some with a trip to just north of the Scottish border to practise demolition techniques. 
 Dalbeattie in Dumfries and Galloway is the site of a Second World War factory, the ugly remains of this building needing to be removed by the Scottish Development Agency. 
 Two members of the permanent staff and four TA sappers under the command of the Permanent Staff Administration Officer, Captain Brian Batty, left by road early on Thursday morning. 
 They had much to do, including drawing explosives and equipment from local depots, and liaison with the police and local authorities.  
 Friday evening back at Preston Barracks saw an increase in activity. 
 At 1930 hours another forty volunteer sappers assembled in the TA Centre, and after drawing kit, boarded an Army coach for their long trip north. 
 The senior TA officer is Lieutenant John Forbes. 
 At about the same time an advance party from the RMP detachment of ten volunteer &bquo;redcaps&equo; leave for a short journey to Thorey Island, where their company has planned a military skills training weekend. 
 A number of activities have to be organised by the following morning so that the TA NCOs from all three detachments can be trained and tested in a variety of skills, from working on a range and map reading to first aid and driving. 
 Saturday morning at Brighton starts off with a flurry of activity. 
 At 0600 some eighty volunteers from the Infantry Company are assembled under the charge of the company OC, Major Ron Dalby, a TA officer. 
 They draw weapons and kit, check it, then into the transport for the journey to Hankley Common, an Army training area near Aldershot. 
 At 0915 they arrive to spend the rest of the day practising such infantry techniques as ambushing, section and platoon attacks  and patrolling. 
 All this is very necessary preparation for the major exercises planned for later in the year when they will join with other battalions, Regular and TA, to practise their wartime role. 
 While all this is going on, far away to the north the volunteers of the Royal Engineers have arrived and are getting straight down to work. 
 They work solidly until 1700 hours, drilling some 480 boreholes, each fourteen or fifteen inches deep, in the walls of the old torpedo factory which is scheduled for demolition on Sunday morning. 
 This completed, the holes are charged with explosive, then all are joined with a detonator cord ring main. 
 For Corporal Gary Elmer, whose day job is as a builder, this is a big change: during the week he puts them up, and at weekends he knocks them down! 
 Meanwhile at Thorey Island, one of the groups is under the charge of Corporal Alison Miller, Whose civilian job is as a secretary, but at weekends she becomes a Women's Royal Army Corps Provost NCO. 
 Nicknamed &bquo;Alpha&equo;, she has the distinction of being the first woman, Regular or TA, to gain the coveted Provost Marshal's Gold Whistle award for being top on her recruits' course. 
 Today, everyone had motorcycle and driver training. 
 Handling a long-wheelbase Land-Rover with its trailer over rough ground is an art that needs plenty of practice. 
 In Scotland, by 0830 on the Sunday the sappers had cleared up the site, breakfasted, packed up their tents and kit, loaded the vehicles and parked them safely away from the danger area. 
 The liaison officer and local police were on the nearby road, ready to stop the traffic. 
 The officer in charge went forward to check that all was well and with a Permanent Staff Instructor laid out the electrical initiation cable and applied the detonators to the ring main they had fitted up the previous afternoon. 
 Everyone had to be behind the firing point, and after a final check that no one was in the danger area, the authority to fire was given. 
 At 0900 promptly the youngest and newest recruit had the privilege of pressing the button. 
 This time, Sapper Andrew Wright, a nineteen-year-old trainee accountant from Brighton, had that privilege. 
 A loud bang echoed through the valley. 
 When the smoke and dust died down, the factory had ceased to exist. 
 The sappers who had been involved in the preparation work could then go forward to see the devastation caused by the explosives. 
 By 0930 they were all in their coaches for the long journey back to Brighton, for that evening they all became civilians again and had to be ready for their ordinary jobs on Monday. 
 Two years before, two TA soldiers met at an Army open day. 
 Today they are Mr and Mrs Barnard, but for this weekend they are both in the uniforms of lance-corporals, both members of the sapper squadron, but in different sections. 
 Brian, a twenty-year-old draughtsman, had seen it all before, but it was the first time for Jane, his nineteen-year-old wife, whose daytime job is as a telephonist. 
 Another young woman, who helped sort out the yards of explosive cord on the Saturday, is a young mother, and at the weekends is Private Margaret Smith. 
 A full-time mother, a part-time Sainsbury's stacker, and a part-time member of the TA. 
 How does she fit it all in? 
 That is a question many Regulars ask about each of the 75,000 or so volunteers who make up today's TA. 
   For the RMP at Thorey Island, Sunday morning brings watermanship tests, swimming and PT and a return to barracks after lunch. 
 Perhaps the least welcome part of the TA's weekend is having to wash the Land-Rovers and motor cycles, and clean and store the kit, for all this equipment must always be ready for instant use. 
 Almost at the same time as the redcaps get back, so do the infantry from the Queens. 
 They pile out of the transport, some still with traces of camouflage cream on their faces and various grasses and leaves still woven into their uniforms to break up their silhouettes. 
 Despite thirty-six hours in the field they look a cheerful bunch, all prepared to swap &bquo;war stories&equo; in the mess after a clean-up before going home.  
 The Territorial Army holds regular exchanges with overseas forces; pictured here, a TA infantry soldier on exercise with a United States National Guardsman 
 Private Joanne Hilton and Private Andrew Smith of 583 EOD Squadron RE prove that men and women work together in today's TA 
 Territorial Army sappers pictured during a night drill session 
 Pass-Off Day at the Light Division Depot 
 All soldiers have to be trained. 
 This look at day in the life of the Light Division Depot shows us how it's done. 
 It is early morning and dawn has crept over the land with the suddenness characteristic of summer. 
 The sky is already a clear, broad blue but it is not yet warm enough to tempt the thin mist from the fields and hedges. 
 Nothing stirs save a falcon high above the heath, silent in its daily vigil. 
 For four members of the guard, returning from a patrol of the barrack perimeter, morning has come earlier than for most. 
 For the past two hours they have provided part of the vital screen against the possibility of terrorist activity. 
 Although barely two months into their training, these young men are armed and equipped as for operations. 
 They move with a purpose and an assurance which belies their relative inexperience, using the cover available, constantly alert and alive to anything unfamiliar on their patrol route. 
 Soldiers have a way of adapting to change. 
 Most of the recruits at the depot view guard duties as an onerous but vital part of their daily lives. 
 Many look upon them as an opportunity to put training into practice, or as a means of getting their first introduction to the tasks that will face them should they be posted to Northern Ireland. 
 None fails to realise the importance of security measures and the part that each has to play in their implementation. 
 As the patrol, now unloaded and debriefed, relax over a mug of tea and a cigarette, the depot slowly comes back to life around them. 
 The new day centres customarily on the cookhouse. 
 Already lines of recruits are filing past the hotplates to collect the Catering Corps' famous blend of humour and culinary excellence. 
 For the majority, today is just another training day, but for one group of men breakfast has never tasted so good. 
 For the thirty or so recruits of Calais Platoon, part of the Adult Training Company, today is the day towards which they have worked for the past five months. 
 Pass-Off Day: the end of training and the gateway to battalion life. 
 After a breakfast taken at a marginally more leisured pace than normal, those recruits due to parade that day return to the platoon lines to add finishing touches to the uniforms and equipment to be worn later in the morning. 
 Spit and polish and the mindless regime of kit preparation have never been guiding principles in the Light Division; nonetheless, each recruit takes a pride in his appearance and is at pains to ensure that his turnout is of the highest standard. 
 Whether it be for family, friends or just for the occasion, appearance on the parade is viewed as a token for all the other skills learnt during the nineteen weeks of basic training.  
 A glance around the accommodation reveals much to indicate the changes that have evolved in the training of recruits for the Division and the Army as a whole. 
 The soldiers are now housed in five-man rooms; duvets, music systems and the occasional television are in evidence. 
 Gone is the harshness of the typical barrack block. 
 Chores are kept to sensible levels of cleanliness and tidiness &mdash; no more the mindless round of polishing and &bquo;dagging&equo; for their own sake. 
 Similar changes in attitude have been in evidence throughout the training of these recruits, so much so that the unenlightened diehard points indignantly to an apparent decline in discipline and general standard. 
 Not so: the recruit of  today is generally better educated and more enquiring than his counterpart of previous decades. 
 He therefore requires and merits more enlightened treatment than the correction preferred previously. 
 He is normally an individual who prefers to be convinced rather than compelled, to be motivated rather than threatened. 
 He is an individual Who through constructive and progressive training can be encouraged to think increasingly for himself in order to carry out his role as an infantryman. 
 By the time uniforms are donned and inspections completed, the time for the parade itself is drawing near. 
 Almost five hundred friends and relatives  have made the trip to Winchester, to encourage and support the recruits due to graduate to the status of trained Light Division soldiers. 
 The contribution made by these visitors to the atmosphere and overall success of the day is considerable &mdash; for many of them, it is their first taste of the life now fully adopted by their sons, brothers and boyfriends who are now on parade. 
 They are impressed at the speed and efficiency with which the spectacle unfolds. 
 The marching at 140 paces per minute (noticeably swifter than the more conventional pace), the bugle calls in lieu of words of command and the famous final &bquo;double-past&equo; are all hallmarks of the distinctive style of the Division. 
 The parade complete, all repair to the NAAFI for the traditional celebratory drink. 
 It is now that the marked effect of training can most clearly be felt. 
 The recruits themselves have taken on a new air of self-confidence. 
 Although many look forward with uncertainty and some apprehension to joining a battalion, all display a supreme contentment and relief that the rigours of basic training have been mastered. 
 It is in the admiring, almost disbelieving, words of parents and friends, however, that the real achievement of training can be noted. 
 Strikingly, even as the newly-qualified trained infantrymen relax outside the NAAFI with their visitors, the process of coaching other recruits to that goal goes on relentlessly around them. 
 A junior platoon, still weeks from their own Pass-Off Parade, marches slowly past, the fatigue of a day's fieldcraft training mixing with a look of envy on their faces as they notice the celebration of those for whom training is now a memory. 
 In the distance a squad limbers up for physical training; they wear training shoes rather than boots, indicating that for them training is in its earliest stages. 
 All in all a total of seventeen strands of training can progress at any one time, ranging from Adult platoons to Junior Leaders and Territorial Army recruits. 
 As evening draws in, an apparent peace descends once more on the depot. 
 Training has been completed for the week, and the platoon which paraded for its Pass-Off today has now left the barracks for ten days' leave prior to posting to various battalions in England, Ulster and around Europe. 
 The falcon still wheels in silence high in the cooling air above the statue of Sir John Moore, the spotlights flick on around the camp perimeter and once again a security patrol prepares to leave the gate.  
 Damn! 
 I should have tried harder at the long jump at school 
 I need to lose some weight 
 The Irish Guards 
 For many, the Guardsman in his red tunic epitomises the British Army. 
 This chapter shows us what the Brigade of Guards is really like. 
 They're changing the guard at Buckingham Palace &mdash; 
 Christopher Robin went down with Alice. 
 Alice is marrying one of the guard. 
 &bquo;a soldier's life is terrible hard.&equo; 
 Says Alice. 
 A A Milne, When We Were Very Young   
 If Alice were marrying one of the Irish Guards on duty at Buckingham Palace today, she would probably comment, not that his life is &bquo;terrible hard&equo; (though of course training is tough), but that it is terribly varied. 
 Variety and fun are the real hallmarks of serving in the &bquo;Micks&equo; these days. 
 30 June 1989 found most of the battalion not on guard in bearskins and tunics, but enjoying the last day of a fortnight's shooting on the ranges at Salisbury Plain, on ISAAC. 
 The Army is full of initials: ISAAC stands for Infantry Skill At Arms Camp. 
 During the two weeks of glorious sunshine, we all did our annual weapons, first aid and fitness tests. 
 All infantrymen have to achieve high scores on their own personal weapon (usually the SA 80 rife) and another (the Light Support Weapon &mdash; a machine-gun variant of the SA 80) alternative. 
 We also have to run three miles in full kit (forty-four pounds including rifle and helmet) in thirty-three minutes; and demonstrate that we can give first aid, among other tests. 
 Our ISAAC ended on 30 June with a shooting competition. 
 All 650 men in the battalion were divided into teams of five, which had to run 100 metres and then shoot down twelve metal plate targets, four teams against each other at a time. 
 Like most soldiers' days, 30 June started early. 
 The cooks were up at 0500 hours, preparing the usual early breakfast for men condemned to hard work. 
 Reveille for the remainder was at 0600, as the transit camp we had been living in for the fortnight had to be handed over to the next inhabitants spick and span. 
 After washing, cleaning, packing and breakfast, the companies departed for the ranges in four-tonne trucks: like most of the infantry, we fight on our feet, but generally travel in vehicles. 
 We had a visitor for our last day on the ranges: the Army Commander, Lieutenant-General Sir David Ramsbotham, who had commanded us in 3rd Armoured Division during our last tour in Germany, in 1985. 
 Before going to the shooting competition, he visited one of the rifle companies doing selection tests for promotion to Lance Corporal. 
 Forty Guardsmen in the battalion attend the promotion course; 4 Company was selecting their best men to go on the course later in the year. 
 Every man took his turn in commanding his section of six or seven in a task designed to test his planning, leadership and coolheadedness under pressure. 
 A temperature in the eighties and the Army Commander looking on added to the stress: testing circumstances for the Guardsmen to earn their places on the promotion course. 
 Naturally the glorious weather was a talking point with the General: he might be forgiven for thinking the Micks were a bit blas&eacute; about the temperature and the change of scene from London ceremonial duties. 
 &bquo;Pretty hot, eh?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, it's all right, sir, it's nothing after Belize, sir.&equo; 
 (The battalion got back from a six-month tour there in April &mdash; our second Caribbean posting in nine years.) 
 &bquo;And it's not as hot as the Troop-either, sir.&equo; 
 (Our ISAAC started straight after &bquo;the Troop&equo; &mdash; the Queen's Birthday Parade, in which many of the battalion, including this company, had taken part. 
 It gets mighty hot in &pound;2,000 of scarlet, gold and bearskin, parading all morning in the sunshine.) 
 &bquo;And it'll be hotter in Cyprus.&equo; 
 (120 men of the 650 in the battalion went off to Cyprus in September for a month.) 
   The General moved on to Support Company. 
 Each infantry battalion has five companies. 
 Headquarter Company contains the administrative staff of the battalion: clerks, cooks, drivers, mechanics, tailors, storemen and so on. 
 Then there are three rifle companies of three platoons, each armed with the new rife and its light machine-gun variant, anti-tank rockets and grenades. 
 Finally there is a support weapons company, which contains the mortar platoon (their eight 8lmm mortars are the battalion's own artillery); the Milan platoon, with Milan anti-tank missiles; the signals platoon, which provides all our communications; and the reconnaissance platoon, which moves ahead of the rest of the battalion on operations, scouting out the lie of the land and the enemy. 
 All these specialist platoons are manned by selected men who have already proved themselves in rifle platoons. 
 Groups of new men drafted from the rifle companies were being introduced to their new weapons as the Army Commander went round. 
 Some were getting their first experience of Wombat, the anti-tank gun which is issued along with Milan missiles to anti-tank platoons in Berlin battalions: the battalion moves to Berlin in 1990 for two-and-a-half years. 
 &bquo;Lovely weather &mdash; bit hot, eh?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not as hot as it was on HMS Boxer.' 
 (There is a constant flow of Micks visiting our affiliated Royal Navy ship, the destroyer HMS Boxer;  some of Support Company had just joined her for a Channel cruise.)  
 &bquo;Oh, it's hot, sir, but it was worse at the athletics last week.&equo; 
 (The previous week the battalion athletics team had won the zonal championships, beating all the other teams from the London, South-Eastern and Eastern military districts: athletics, soccer and boxing are the main Irish Guards sports, but we also have three Army cricketers, one of the top three cycling teams, the Army racquets champions, good cross-country, squash and tennis teams; and our rugby team once beat the Welsh Guards.) 
 &bquo;Oh sir, it was hotter yesterday on the March and Shoot.&equo; 
 (Over the past two days, the platoons had all competed in a punishing forced march against the clock, followed by a shooting match.) 
 By 0930, when the General arrived, the shooting competition was in full swing. 
 The teams waited in company ranks, to do what the British infantry has always excelled at: firing aimed shots faster and more accurately than the enemy, in any conditions. 
 Though the weapons and equipment are constantly modernised (the Micks got the new design of helmets two years ago, the new rifles last year, and we are due the new webbing next year), Napoleon's generals would still have recognised the discipline and aggression, as would the Kaiser's, and Hitler's. 
 As the General's visit ended, the competition drew to a close. 
 The Commanding Officer presented the prizes to the victorious 2 Company team, and we had finished with ISAAC 1989. 
 The battalion boarded the vehicles to return to Chelsea Barracks, ceremonial duties &mdash; and Alice, of course.  
 CONNER'S DAY or &bquo;Its a dogs Life in the Irish Guards&equo; 
 I woke as usual at half past six, and went straight out for a run in the park, like I do every morning, with LCpl Smith who has the bunk next to mine. 
 We got back to the Barracks at a quarter past seven, and then I realised something strange was going on: I got some breakfast. 
 Now normally I am not allowed to eat breakfast, because of public (ceremonial) duties. 
 The rest of the battalion is ordered to eat before parades &mdash; for if a man faints and he has missed breakfast, he can be charged with rendering himself unfit for duty. 
 However, it is different for an Irish Wolfhound; they are all terribly worried that I'll have to answer nature's call along with the call of duty, and embarrass us all in some grand place like Wellington Barracks Square, or the Mall, or even the forecourt of Buckingham Palace. 
 So on the days when I lead the Micks on Mounting Guards, I don't get breakfast, I just make up for it at lunch. 
 On this particular Friday I remembered that of course all the men were away shooting ISAAC or some other unlucky fellow. 
 (Humans do lead a terribly hard life sometimes.) 
 What was more, not only did I have breakfast with I the family (I live in the Smiths' Quarter in Chelsea Barracks) &mdash; toast, bacon and sausages, washed down with milk &mdash; but we had no muster parade that morning, and no Adjutant's Orders to attend. 
 We usually go in daily, so that I can check that he's doing his job right. 
 Apart from LCpl Smith, and my driver (I have my own Land-Rover), the Adjutant is really the one I work most closely with; we always seem to take part in the same parades, but we usually get back to barracks first, leaving the officers and men on guard. 
 With no Changing the Guard today, we had a lovely relaxed morning &mdash; a drive down to the Guards Depot to see a couple of my friends in the Guards Dog Unit &mdash; German Shepherd Guard Dogs. 
 A run round the woods, and then pies and sandwiches for lunch. 
 My coat, like a bearskin, is well groomed but very thick and warm so I had my usual &bquo;Irish siesta&equo; in the afternoon. 
 In fact l usually take things easy until I have dinner at seven with the Smiths. 
 I have tripe and biscuits, except on Sundays when it's meat and two veg (and millions of spuds, of course). 
 After dinner the people watch the television but I prefer to watch the tropical fish in the Smiths' tank: give me piranha fish any day over cricket or soap operas. 
 At half past eight I have a final walk in Buron's Court, opposite the Royal Hospital Chelsea, and then I go to bed about eleven &mdash; hoping it's a breakfast day tomorrow. 
 Conner is the Irish Wolfhound (Mascot) of the 1st Battalion Irish guards.  
 Trooping the colour on Horse Guards Parade each year in front of Her Majesty the Queen is one of the major events in the Brigade of Guards' calender 
 General Ramsbotham with members of 2 Company, the Irish Guards 
 Company Sergeant Major Kirkland administers &bquo;first aid&equo; to Lance-Corporal Parkin's! 
 Sergeant Twomey giving his platoon some gentle encouragement 
 Myself and Lance-Corporal Smith 
 GERMANY 
 An Armoured Infantry Battalion: The Royal Scots 
 Mechanised infantry in battle. 
 This chapter illustrates what it would be like, through the eyes of the Royal Scots. 
 Werl is a small, quiet West German pilgrimage town on the line of the historic Bundestrasse One. 
 Napoleon marched through it on his way to Moscow, but today the road is used by those who wish to avoid the pressures of autobahn driving and see something of the pleasant, rolling countryside of Westphalia. 
 Werl serves the prosperous Westphalian Plain as a market town. 
 It lies on the eastern edge of the Ruhr coalfield and is some fifteen miles from the M&ouml;hne Dam, one of the targets of the famous &bquo;Dambusters&equo; raid. 
 On the hills above the town, amongst cool, dark pines, is Albuhera Barracks, the present station for the 1st Battalion the Royal Scots. 
 The Royal Scots, the First of Foot, is the oldest regiment of the line in the British Army. 
 Its ancestors served abroad from the 1630s onwards, and the tradition of foreign service continues today. 
 The 1st Battalion is part of the 3rd Armoured Division, Which is the 1 st British Corps' reserve division. 
 The division has the important task of defeating any enemy breakthrough into the British Corps area and is equipped with the Army's latest equipment, including the Warrior Armoured Infantry Fighting Vehicle. 
 Warrior is the replacement tracked vehicle for the now outdated FV 432. 
 It weighs twenty-eight tonnes, carries ten men, and mounts a turret with a 30mm Rarden cannon and a 7.62mm chain gun. 
 The crew comprises a commander and gunner, who sit in the turret, and a driver. 
 All three remain with the vehicle. 
 Seven infantrymen are carried in the back, forming the dismounting element. 
 It is they who carry out the traditional infantry role of closing with and destroying the enemy. 
 Powered by a 550bhp Perkins engine and fitted with an advanced suspension system, Warrior can move cross-country faster than any other armoured vehicle currently in service with the British Army. 
 On roads it can reach speeds in excess of 45mph with ease. 
 The vehicle provides increased armoured protection from artillery fire and certain anti-tank weapons for the soldiers it carries, and its special air filtration system enables the crew to survive closed-down inside the vehicle when nuclear, chemical and biological weapons have been used. 
 Infantry battalions equipped with Warrior are known as armoured infantry. 
 The Royal Scots were the third infantry battalion in the Army to convert from the older FV 432 to Warrior. 
 Tactical training with Warrior, following conversion, started in March 1989 with a series of map exercises and discussions. 
 This was developed further during a deployment in the field to practise  battle procedures and enable the battalion to see just how mobile Warrior is. 
 At 0300 hours on 30 June 1989, 1st Battalion the Royal Scots found itself deployed into hides, along with the attached tanks, artillery and engineers that make up the Royal Scots battle group. 
 The previous day had been one of frantic activity. 
 An earlier breakthrough by an enemy motor rifle division supported by tanks and artillery had been halted by 6th Armoured Brigade, of which the Royal Scots form a part. 
 At 1800 hours on 28 June the brigade had been ordered to take three positions which formed a bridgehead from which the enemy could further develop his attack. 
 It had been a difficult task. 
 By last light the three armoured infantry companies of the Royal Scots were in defensive positions that were strongly held, although hastily prepared. 
 Supported by Milan missile firing posts from the battlegroup's anti-tank platoon, and fire from the mortar platoon and the artillery, the companies held out against probing attacks by enemy reconnaissance patrols of armoured vehicles and tanks. 
 In these short, sharp engagements, the night viewing sight that Warrior mounts came into its own. 
 After reassessing the situation, however, the Brigade Commander decided to pull back the battlegroup and move it into temporary hides. 
 The soldiers had found it a long and tiring period. 
 Once in the hides, sentries had been posted to protect the company positions, and many of the men took  the opportunity to get some rest, if only for a few minutes. 
 In the quiet of the dawn, the young platoon commanders and their sergeants walked around the four vehicLes that made up their command, to check their soldiers and their equipment. 
 In the move between the last position and this, a number of the Jocks had taken the opportunity to make a hot drink, and as the chill of early morning crept into them, the sweet tea lifted their morale. 
 Whilst the enemy had probed the positions the Jocks held, it had managed also to break through once more to the north. 
 The brigade that it faced had been forced to give ground. 
 The pulling-back of 6th Armoured Brigade had given the Divisional Commander the force he needed to destroy the enemy. 
 It appeared that the enemy force, consisting of two motor rife regiments (the equivalent of a British brigade), plus a flank guard of a tank company, had halted seventeen kilometres to the north-west of the brigade's current position, and that they were facing south-west. 
 The brigade's mission was to destroy the enemy, and the attack would begin at 0430 hours. 
 The armoured regiment of 6 Armoured Brigade had the task of piercing the enemy formation. 
 This required the destruction of the tanks that formed the tank guard. 
 Their attack would be supported by the full firepower of all available artillery batteries and mortars, and would be preceded by an attack by RAF Tornado and Harrier aircraft. 
 Once through, the tanks would press on into the enemy's main body, preparing the way for the armoured infantry to clear any remaining opposition. 
 It would be a bold attack, requiring determination and aggressive spirit to see it through. 
 The speed of reaction of the Whole brigade, and the use of maximum firepower to keep the enemy's heads down would be vital factors. 
 Two important enemy locations had been identified as objectives for the Royals. 
 One appeared to be an enemy headquarters, the other an area of high ground. 
 As this information came into the command Warrior, the Company Commander called an orders group. 
 The Company Sergeant Major moved around the position, calling platoon commanders and those in charge of the elements attached to the Company Group. 
 They assembled quickly to hear the brief set of orders that explained their respective tasks in the battle to come. 
 The company was to be the right assault company in the battlegroup attack. 
 It had the job of destroying the enemy headquarters. 
 The fireplan would be under the control of the company once it moved from its final assault position on to the enemy position. 
 As the Company Commander confirmed the final details of the movement plan, he stressed the need for speed of reaction and movement. 
 There would be no room for indecision: the task had been detailed, everyone knew what his job was and how he fitted in. 
 The platoon commanders went back to their soldiers and covered the facts and details that affected their men. 
 Equipment was checked once more and the Jocks paired off to arrange each other's camouflage. 
 Once complete, the sections mounted their vehicles. 
 Space is at a premium in the back of a Warrior. 
 Seven men plus their personal equipment, rifles, LAW 80 anti-tank missiles, ammunition, rations, jerricans of water, sleeping bags, kit bags, and the vehicle tool kit soon fill the available space. 
 However, without all this the infantry's most vital asset, the soldier, does not function effectively.  
 Soon the company moved off. 
 The route had been marked by the reconnaissance platoon; even so, as they moved at speed past each key point vehicle commanders glanced at their maps to check their progress. 
 It was important that the brigade did not move too far forward too soon. 
 To do so would run the risk of compromising the most vulnerable part of the operation. 
 Until the armoured regiment had crossed its start line, the armoured infantry would pause momentarily in forward holding areas. 
 As the Warriors moved on, the section commanders continued to tell their men over the vehicle briefing system what they were to do and what they should expect. 
 The thirteen kilometres to the forward holding area were covered in as many minutes. 
 The Second-in-Command organised the company into the final order of march whilst the other commanders carried out final checks. 
 Already the tanks ahead were in action and it seemed as though they had made contact with, and destroyed the majority of the enemy flank guard. 
 The effects of the artillery bombardment and the air strikes had been devastating. 
 The enemy were caught off balance by the shock of the attack. 
 The progress the tanks had made enabled the Commanding Officer to advance the timings for the move of his companies. 
 As radio silence was lifted on the company radio net, the Warriors started up and moved out as one. 
 It was a further four kilometres to the final assault position, and, since the company group was complete, it was the Company Commander's intention to move straight through into the attack. 
 As the group moved at best speed towards the start line, evidence of the recent tank battle littered the area. 
 There were no problems on the move, and the Forward Observation Officer reported that the fireplan was ready. 
 The Company Commander started his countdown. 
 As the company moved out, the fireplan started. 
 Reports from the lead platoons indicated that the artillery fire was being most effective in keeping the enemy pinned down. 
 The move across open ground involved covering about 1,500 metres, but, with the fireplan to cover the company, and with the  speed and protection the Warriors afforded, the company was certain it would across the featureless landscape that surrounded the enemy's position. 
 From the moment the lead vehicles broke cover, they could see the enemy headquarters, halted at the edge of a wood. 
 In under a minute the company had hit its objective. 
 As the two forward platoons prepared to dismount, the chain guns clattered into action, covering the near edge of the enemy position with machine-gun fire. 
 The platoon commanders barked their orders to dismount and the vehicles came to an abrupt standstill amongst the enemy. 
 Following well-rehearsed dismounting drills, the riflemen poured out of the Warriors and in next to no time were providing their own fire support as the Warriors reversed away at high speed to give covering fire from positions where they would be less vulnerable to short-range anti-tank weapons. 
 By the time the Warriors had reached the objective, the riflemen in the back had been sufficiently aware of what was going on around them to know that their own survival would depend on the spirit of fight they could produce. 
 When the power rear doors opened, the men moved out to the left and right of their vehicles, into their battle positions, and began to shoot at the enemy. 
 Once the Warriors had reversed out of their way, the sections began to move forward to clear the enemy positions at bayonet point. 
 It was a long business. 
 The Company Sergeant Major had difficulty in keeping the platoons resupplied with ammunition. 
 As the two lead platoons secured their objectives, it looked as though the position was taken, but suddenly an enemy depth position sprang into life. 
 Almost immediately, the Company Commander committed his third platoon, which had been kept in reserve for just such an eventuality. 
 Using the fire provided by the now empty Warriors to support their move forward, the third platoon dashed forward and hit the enemy at full speed. 
 In the face of all this, the enemy resistance collapsed. 
 Throughout the Royal Scots' positions, those enemy who had survived were breaking. 
 After considering the situation, the Commanding Officer concluded that his training objectives had been achieved. 
 Picking up the radio handset, he called the exercise to a halt. 
 The battlegroup had been in the field for two weeks and had practised a number of operations of war. 
 It was now time for him to call in his battlegroup to tell his men of their achievements. 
 Gathering the soldiers around him, the Commanding Officer explained what he had set out to achieve two weeks ago. 
 The two weeks of training on the Soltau-Luneberg Training Area had given the Royal Scots the opportunity to test to the full those operating procedures and ideas that had been developed since the conversion to Warrior had started in the new year. 
 Just as important, it had allowed the soldiers to practise their infantry skills in the field. 
 30 June 1 989 was the culmination of the Royal Scots' battlegroup training. 
 The battalion could now look forward to returning to Werl and the preparations for firing camp, when the Warriors' guns could be fired on the range. 
 The vehicles started to move off to the washdown point and thence to the trains that would take them home.  
 Members of a Rifle Section stand ready for action in front of their Warrior Mechanised Combat Vehicles 
 A Challenger Tank and a Warrior move forward together. 
 Unlike its predecessors, Warrior is capable of keeping up with a Main Battle Tank across country 
 The Corps of Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers: a Day in the Life of an Armoured Workshop 
 The modern army depends on its increasingly complex equipment working properly. 
 It is the job of the Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers to ensure that this happens. 
 &bquo;Hello 71, this is 13J, Taskrep, over&equo;, the radio crackles. 
 &bquo;71. 
 Send, over.&equo; 
 &bquo;13J, Serial 18 &mdash; ZAP 205, Serial 36 &mdash; Grid 822903&hellip; over.&equo; 
 Corporal Broadhead rapidly decodes the message and briefs his boss: &bquo;The battlegroup have an armoured personnel carrier on the prairie north of Antelope Road with a blown engine &mdash; shall I call Corporal Bromby, it's his crew's turn for a task?&equo; 
 At the British Army Training Unit Suffield (BATUS), not far from Calgary in western Canada, a detachment of twenty-five men from 6 Armoured Workshop's Forward Repair Group (FRG) is being kept busy looking after the 17/ 2lst Lancers battlegroup engaged in Exercise Gazala, the climax of their live firing exercises. 
 &bquo;The B81 power pack is in the back of the stores truck, Corporal Bromby,&equo; AQMS Williams explains, &bquo;I've put the casualty's location and registration number on the Taskrep card; get away as soon as you can. 
 Take Rattlesnake Road to the junction with Antelope Road. 
 Then you'll need clearance before you enter the range template &mdash; it's being controlled on channel 4.&equo; 
 Prior to going to BATUS, the battlegroups carried out two weeks' preparatory training in the Soltau Training Area in northern Germany. 
 Although half of the FRG is in Canada for six weeks, most of the rest are supporting the Blues and Royals battlegroup on exercise in Soltau. 
 It is 0300 hours in Munster, and the Workshop Duty Officer's phone rings at 6 Armoured Workshop Royal Electrical and Mechanical Engineers' base in West Germany. 
 &bquo;Morning, sir, it's Sergeant Richards, ringing from Soltau. 
 Sorry to wake you at this hour but we've had a host of tasks during the night. 
 We've already lifted two Challenger CV12 power packs and once we've fitted new ones, I'll have no fit stock left. 
 The battlegroup have already warned me of a third tank needing a new pack and the Commanding Officer wants everything fit for his final exercise tomorrow. 
 I know you've got none fit in Munster at the moment, but hopefully the Lads in the Power Pack Section can make something of the ones we've just lifted. 
 They should be with you in about an hour&hellip;.&equo; 
  &bquo;Another glorious Canadian sunset,&equo; Lieutenant Robinson, the FRG commander in BATUS, observes as he enters the FRG command post. 
 &bquo;Brief me on the latest situation, please, &bquo;Q&equo;.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's been a fairly quiet day. 
 Corporal Baber and his two crew are on their way here having fitted an L60 in one of C Squadron's Chieftains. 
 Corporal Fincham and his men are resting &mdash; they haven't had a task since they changed the final drive in one of Recce Troop's Scorpions this morning. 
 Corporal Bromby's team are on task north of the Antelope Road changing a B81 &mdash; they should be finished in about three hours.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good, live firing's just stopped and if the last few nights are anything to go  by, we'll be hearing from the battlegroup soon, once their own fitters have had a chance to check out the day's casualties., 
 Only an hour later, in Munster, Buller Barracks is coming to life as the soldiers and civilians employed in the workshop start work. 
 Although most of the FRG are in Canada or Soltau, this is only one small part of 6 Armoured Workshop. 
 Commanded by a major, it has about 250 officers and soldiers, organised into six platoons, and employs over seventy German civilians. 
 By 0800 hours, most of the repair shops are humming as the tradesmen set about their various repair tasks. 
 In &bquo;B&equo; Shop, the overhead crane is sweeping down with a new Bedford axle. 
 ln &bquo;A&equo; Shop, Corporal Tait and his crew of two vehicle mechanics have been hard at work for three hours; having inspected and confirmed that a new engine is needed, they are well on their way to having the first CV12 pack stripped apart. 
 Unfortunately life is never simple &mdash; the Stores Platoon confirms that they have no Challenger engines in stock and that the next one is not expected for three or four days; improvisation will obviously be needed if the Blues and Royals are to have all their tanks working. 
 At 0900 hours the weekly production conference is being brought to order by Major Rod Paul, who runs the civilian labour force and doubles as the workshop's Production Officer. 
 He's assisted by the Artificer Sergeant Major &mdash; the ASM. 
 &bquo;First, ASM, can you give us a summary of last week's activities?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, in total the workshop repaired ten power packs, thirty-two vehicles and ninety-four assorted electronic and optical items. 
 In particular, we fixed the last four of those fuel tankers that have been awaiting gearbox spares. 
 ln terms of productive hours, we've achieved 2,320 hours, excluding all the work done in Canada and Soltau.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about new work received in the last week?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, 14/ 20th Hussars came back off exercise with a lot of dead equipment and 2nd Field Regiment has just finished a major inspection in preparation for firing camp starting in three weeks. 
 The result is that we've received over 3,000 hours of new work, and most of this is on priority jobs. 
 And, finally, we received two more dead CV12 power packs from the FRG at Soltau a few hours ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll discuss tackling that lot later, once the platoon commanders have given me their expected manpower availability for the next week&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, it's a bit warmer here in Canada than it was in Soltau in March.&equo; 
 Craftsman Dale appears, streaked in oil, from the depths of the engine compartment Where he has been tightening up a mounting bolt. 
 &bquo;Another half hour should see this job finished; we should be back at the FRG asleep by first light. 
 Let's have a sup of that coffee, Taff.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hello 7lD, this is 71, send SlTREP, over.&equo; 
  &bquo;7lD, about thirty minutes to completion if there are no problems, over,&equo; replies Corporal Bromby, clambering on to his vehicle. 
 Two minutes later, he jumps down again. 
 &bquo;No sleep for us tonight. 
 That was the boss; all the other crews are already on task and D Squadron needs a new gearbox in one of its Chieftains &mdash; it's about six miles from here so they're sending out a truck with the spares and we're to meet it there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Never mind, only six days to R &amp; R &lsqb;Rest and Recuperation&rsqb;,&equo; muses Craftsman Dale. 
 &bquo;I'm off canoeing in the Rockies for a fortnight with Mr Robinson. 
 You're going back after the normal four days, aren't you, Taff?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; replies Craftsman Browne, &bquo;but I'm going to make the most of it &mdash; Geordie and I are going to hire a car and drive into the States to visit Yellowstone Park, getting back in time to spend a night in the Cadillacs Club in Medicine Hat&hellip;.&equo; 
  It is just after lunch when the phone rings in Captain Rob Tuck-Brown's office. 
 &bquo;Sir, can you come across to the Gun Shop? 1 think we've found a serious defect which could affect the Warrior fleet.&equo; 
 Five minutes later the Platoon Commander and the Weapons Artificer are studying the bits of broken and twisted metal. 
 &bquo;We took this out of a Warrior in Oxford Barracks this morning &mdash; they had been practising firing at multiple targets, using the power traverse, When suddenly the turret went out of control &mdash; It's a good job they weren't live firing on the range or someone could have been killed. 
 What appears to have happened is&hellip;. 
 Between them they must decide whether this is a one-off fault or whether other vehicles are likely to be affected, and if the defect is likely to endanger life. 
 Fifteen minutes later: &bquo;I'll leave you to dig out the part numbers and the vehicle details, Staff. 
 I'm going to brief Major Lower that we should recommend the whole fleet be grounded at least until we've had time to get this examined in detail and to inspect a few more.&equo; 
 The Officer Commanding, Major Mike Lower, is putting down the phone as Captain Tuck-Brown knocks and enters. 
 &bquo;That was the FRG from Soltau &mdash; they've cleared most of the tasks from last night, less a Chieftain power pack change that's in hand and one badly bogged tank &mdash; they're having to find a route in for a second armoured recovery vehicle, and, of course, the last Challenger pack change &mdash; how are the lads doing on those packs that came in this morning?&equo; 
 &bquo;We've been slowed down by the lack of a new engine but we've found a good engine in the second pack they sent us &mdash; it needs a couple of hours of work on minor jobs, but if everything goes well we should have something ready for out-inspection later this afternoon. 
 But that's not why I came across &mdash; Staff Sergeant MacDonald has found a potential major problem&hellip;.&equo; 
 Back in the power pack repair bay, Corporal Tait and his crew are still working as first the civilians and then the soldiers finish their day's tasks and return home. 
 &bquo;We'll take a quick break for some tea and then we should be ready to run it up in another hour,&equo; he briefs Captain Tuck-Brown, who has come across to check on progress before going home for the day. 
 &bquo;The Duty Officer will organise a truck as soon as you've finished and you know my home number if there are any problems.&equo; 
 It is 1900 hours when the peace of the evening is broken by the cough of the Challenger engine being fired into life by its starter motors, soon followed by the roar of the twenty-six-litre engine and the scream of the twin turbos. 
 Corporal Tait busies around the pack checking for oil leaks and tightening the odd bolt; ten minutes later the crew are smiling as they clear up, looking forward to a well-deserved shower. 
 The Duty Officer, having dispatched the still warm power pack to Soltau, is settling down to a quiet evening when the phone rings: &bquo;Corporal Johnson, Military Police, sir. 
 We've got a job for your duty recovery crew &mdash; there's been an accident on the autobahn ten miles north of Munster. 
 There's an eight-tonne on its side &mdash; can you get someone up there as soon as possible?&equo; 
  It is approaching midnight in Munster when the recovery crew return to conclude another busy day for the workshop. 
 Meanwhile in Canada: &bquo;Hello 71, this is 13J, Taskrep, over.&equo; 
 The radio crackles in the FRG command post. 
 &bquo;I suppose it was too much to expect a quiet afternoon,, Corporal Broadhead comments as he answers the call. 
 Minutes later, Corporal Bromby and his crew are loading up in the Alberta sunshine. 
 &bquo;It's a Chieftain auxiliary generator about eight miles down Bayonet Trail,&equo; he briefs his crew. 
 &bquo;Let's hope we get back before first light this time.&equo;    
 Trying to establish why a component snapped 
 A line-up of Warrior Mechanised Combat Vehicles in Germany 
 A Platoon Commander plans the next move from the turret of his Warrior 
 A Scimitar tracked armoured reconnaissance vehicle which mounts a 30mm Rarden cannon. 
 The four short barrels on each forward edge of the turret are smoke dischargers arranged in such a pattern as to form an instant smokescreen in front of the vehicle in an emergency 
 A CV12 Challenger Tank Power pack being fine tuned by REME fitters. 
 A power pack can be changed in the field, although it is a complex and time-consuming operation 
 Battle casualty simulation can be quite realistic on exercise! (see previous chapter) 
 a Chieftain Power Pack change in progress 
 A badly bogged Challenger tank about to be extricated 
 Building Bridges with 28 Amphibious Engineer Regiment Captain D J G Wood RE 
 The Royal Engineers are responsible, amongst other things, for getting across rivers. 
 The Amphibious Engineer Regiment forms a vital part of BOAR. 
 The peace in the harbour area was undisturbed, except for the insistent and mildly annoying buzz of flies. 
 The Troop Commander thought that they were probably flying round the same small area in a patch of strong sunlight to keep warm; the Troop Staff Sergeant opined that there was probably something nasty buried beneath the carpet of dead leaves. 
 The Clansman radio in the Sultan Command Vehicle squeaked into life with a request for a Critical Asset Return and a Warning Order for a task, sent in BATCO radio code. 
 The critical assets being referred to were the twelve M2D Amphibious Bridging and Ferrying Vehicles operated by the troop, which lay dispersed and camouflaged under the high oak and pine trees of this wooded harbour area, about thirty kilometres south-east of Hamburg. 
 The M2, or Alligator as it is known in West German service, is a vehicle the size of an average forty-five-seater passenger coach, and is essentially a self-propelled bridging pontoon. 
 It consists of a boat-like main hull and two outrigger pontoons, or sideswimmers, which are lifted hydraulically to rest on top for road travel and which are extended and lowered to the sides for stability on the water. 
 These vehicles, or &bquo;rigs&equo; as they are normally called, were just some of those in use with 28 Amphibious Engineer Regiment on that stifling June afternoon, and the troop was nearing the end of a three-week Commanding Officer's Exercise. 
 Whilst the signaller busied himself with decoding the latest message from on high, the Troop Commander's mind raced back over a fairly hectic three weeks, Which had taken the troop from Hameln (of Pied Piper fame), the regiment's home base on the River Weser, eastwards to the River Leine and north the River Aller, before swinging north-west to the mouth of the Weser in the Bremerhaven area. 
 They had then moved once more east, in the early hours of yesterday morning, to their present location not far short of the Inner German Border. 
 ln that time, the sixty men had adjusted to the soldiers' normal routine of work at night and lie-up during the day. 
 They had carried out a large number of ferrying and bridging operations, in addition to the more usual Engineer jobs of demolitions and dry bridging using the Medium Girder Bridge. 
 For part if the time they had been in support of another Engineer regiment for joint  river crossing operations, and on one occasion had carried infantrymen over a one-kilometre-wide stretch of the Weser, using their rigs as landing craft. 
 &bquo;It's a Warning Order for a bridge across the River Elbe, sir,&equo; said the Signaller. 
 &bquo;Can't be right,&equo; said Staff; &bquo;the Elbe is miles wide.&equo; 
 &bquo;A bit less than that,&equo; mused the Troop Commander, &bquo;but by the map it's about two hundred and fifty to three hundred metres and a damn sight wider than we're used to. 
 Ask them to confirm that they do mean we've got to bridge as opposed to ferrying.&equo; 
 The confirmation came within seconds, along with details of the Orders Group, at Which the Commanding Officer would give his instructions for this, the longest M2 bridge built by the regiment in recent years. 
 The bridge was to be built across the river at Lauenburg, and at that point it was some two hundred and thirty metres wide, which would require a minimum of thirty-two rigs to complete. 
 It was to be built and ready for traffic by 0030 hours the following morning. 
 While the Troop Commander attended the &bquo;O&equo; Group in Regimental Headquarters, which was ensconced in yet another fly's paradise of a farmyard some twenty-five kilometres away, the remainder of the troop were roused from their fitful dozing in the late afternoon sunshine to prepare their main compo meal of the day, check equipment and attend to the usual rituals of washing, shaving and boot and weapon cleaning. 
 Each rig crew comprises a driver, Who drives the vehicle on land, a pilot, Who operates it when it becomes a &bquo;boat&equo; on the water, and the youngest member, a crewman, who operates the hydraulic ramp controls and does all the deck jobs. 
 The commander, who is typically a twenty-three-year-old Lance-Corporal, makes up the four-man crew. 
 Usually the most experienced crew member, and an Amphibious Engineer Class One, he can do all of the others' jobs, and if the crew is reduced to three, due to manpower shortages or a temporary absence, he normally also drives. 
 Amphibious Engineer is an additional trade to Combat Engineer, and many of the men also have an artisan trade, such as plumber, draughtsman or sheet metal worker, as a third string. 
 In harbour the rig is usually opened out to its full water width of six metres, and the four independently suspended wheels can be retracted into the main hull, so that it appears to squat on the ground. 
 This means that its shape is changed considerably as an aid to camouflage, and the crew can gain access to the main hull and engines for essential servicing and checks. 
 It also has the added advantage that, by spreading a canopy over the on-board crane, a shelter can be made in which to sleep and cook when in harbour. 
 As the afternoon turned into a slightly cooler early evening, each crew methodically checked over their rig. 
 Each of the two big Magirus Deutz diesel engines was inspected, along with all the operating controls, the propulsion system, including the big main propeller, and the myriad parts of the hydraulic system. 
 The crane, for moving the ramps which connected the rigs together and the inshore rig to the beach, was tested for free operation. 
 The main hull and its two sideswimmers, with their secondary propellers, were carefully scrutinised. 
 Oil levels were topped up and minor repairs carried out. 
 The worst damage to hulls etc. had been reported on arrival in the area after last  night's operation, and the troop's attached REME Forward Repair Team had worked on for hours after most others had taken to their sleeping bags. 
 One by one the Corporals who commanded each rig section reported their charges ready for the water. 
 On full fuel tanks of five hundred litres, each rig has a road range of one thousand kilometres, or can operate in river current speeds of two metres a second (about four knots) for about six and a half hours without refuelling. 
 Three joined together can form a ferry capable of carrying the Challenger tank, or they can be coupled to form a bridge capable of carrying even the heaviest Army loads. 
 All that remained to be done by seven that evening was to attend the Troop Commander's Orders or &bquo;O&equo; Group, and at last light dismantle the camouflage net, close up and move to the river. 
 At the &bquo;O&equo; Group held on the Troop Commander's return, each Rig Commander was briefed on his part in the forthcoming operation, his place in bridge and on the contingency plans in case of breakdown, accident or enemy interference. 
 All five troops of the regiment would be involved, with twenty  eight rigs in bridge and at least a further six in reserve. 
 Safety cover was to be provided by combat support boats from the Support Squadron. 
 At prearranged intervals that night, the troop columns left their widely dispersed harbour and hide areas and, following the regimental route, after a twenty-kilometre drive arrived at the bridge site in the carefully thought-out launching order. 
 Under a slightly overcast sky, but with a fair amount of ambient light and a touch of red to the west to show Where the sun had expired, the safety boats, their navigation lights brightly lit for the occasion, skittered about like playful sheepdogs before settling down to hold station in midstream. 
 They were to stay on the alert for any soldier unlucky enough to go overboard. 
 As each group of rigs arrived they moved quietly on to the sloping cobbled ramp, which in times past had been used by a civilian ferry, and with a hiss of hydraulics opened out. 
 The crew, moving rapidly yet almost soundlessly, carried out the few jobs required to convert the land vehicle to a boat, and within seconds the rigs slid rapidly into the dark water and powered away to swing out  their ramps and couple together in twos and threes. 
 Simultaneously the men of the bank support section tugged and pulled their steel wire ropes and tirfor winches into place, to provide anchorages from which to hold the ends of the bridge in the correct depth of water for loading. 
 Within a few minutes all the rigs had arrived and splashed in, and the earlier arrivals which had formed two- and three-rig rafts were crabbing across the river and pushing upstream to the bridge centreline. 
 The crane ratchets of the later arrivals could still be heard clearly as their crews outramped, and rising bow waves could be spotted as an occasional laggard powered upstream to its proper place in the echelon. 
 Both the two-rig landing bays had moved into the banks on the centreline, and their combined crews, assisted by the ubiquitous bank support section, had connected the anchor ropes and the short ramp sections, Which were added to the main ramps to allow traffic easy access to the bridge. 
 The Troop Staff Sergeant detailed to supervise the construction was insistently calling the rafts into the head of the bridge, where they coupled on with remarkable rapidity. 
 The end of the bridge was clearly visible as it grew out of the far bank, and needed only a couple of rafts to make it complete. 
 At that moment the men detailed as River Watchers radioed that a fast-moving vessel was coming downstream, and the Safety Officer, not at all sure of the newcomer's identity or intentions, fired an illuminating parachute flare over the nearly complete bridge to warn of the obstruction across its bows. 
 The Wasserschutz Polizei,  or River Police launch, Whose arrival had been expected much earlier, turned on its blue flashing light and jauntily turned to take station upstream, in order to intercept any barge or ship choosing to ignore the river closure order which had been imposed by the river authorities for the night. 
 Finally, the closure raft inched carefully into the remaining gap, and after the briefest hesitation the ramps dropped into their receiving lugs and were pinned. 
 The bridge was complete, the air blowers on each rig whined as the remaining air bags were inflated for additional buoyancy, and footwalk posts and ropes were installed. 
 A few last checks by the Bridge Commander, and it was declared ready for traffic, seven minutes ahead of time. 
 The first vehicles loomed out of the darkness on the south bank, driving only on convoy lights with each one following the barely seen, under-chassis-mounted, single White light of the one in front. 
 Rig Commanders stationed on the inshore ramp guided the drivers on with brief flashes of their green lights, and the convoy drove steadily across. 
 The bridge was held against the current by the engine power of twenty-eight port engines, finely adjusted by the pilots on their stands above the rig cabs. 
 From the start to finish, the bridge had taken under three hours to build. 
 It remained in place only a few minutes more, When the Commanding Officer ordered not only a change of the command team which had built it, but a change of design as well. 
 The bridge was to be broken, more rigs were to be added to reduce the water gaps between them, and the whole thing reassembled within one hour. 
 Following only a little chaos, much speedy uncoupling and in-ramping, and a very occasional one-sided angry conversation between &bquo;Staff&equo; and a couple of  luckless young sappers, the aim was achieved, and shortly after the break of a glorious dawn, each rig ran the Union Flag up its mast in honour of a very rare occasion. 
 Bridge lengths vary from three to four rigs on the Leine to an average ten rigs on the Weser and really, given the practised excellence of the crews, this last thirty-one-rig bridge of Exercise Neptune's Gallop 1989 should not have aroused much emotion, but it did made the thirtieth of June a little bit different.  
 A chance to show the flag! 
 The completed bridge made up of Royal Engineer M2 floating rigs. such a bridge would normally be dismantled before dawn in wartime since it would be a prime target for enemy aircraft during daylight hours. 
 An M2 bridge is capable of taking the Challenger Battle Tank 
 The Royal Military Police in Berlin 
 The situation in Berlin has undergone massive changes recently. 
 But the Four Powers are likely to remain responsible for the city for the foreseeable future. 
 The Royal Military Police role in the city is particularly important. 
 Captain Richard Moore is Adjutant and British Sector Operations Officer wit 2nd Regiment Military Police. 
 he has served in Berlin for three years. 
 &bquo;Hello, Romeo 24 Bravo, this is Zero. 
 Go now to directly north of the Reichstag. 
 West Berlin Police report an escape.&equo; 
 It is 0100 hours on 30 June 1989. 
 An RMP patrol is tasked to the scene of an escape from the Soviet Sector of Berlin. 
 On arrival the patrol members find that two men have apparently just crashed a lorry through a fence and swum across the River Spree. 
 They are now both gratefully sipping piping hot coffee, provided by RMP, still dripping wet, with looks of wonderment and happiness written across their faces. 
 Berlin. 
 A city divided by ideologies. 
 The &bquo;last outpost of freedom&equo;, over one hundred miles from West Germany and only forty miles from the Polish border. 
 The British Army with a garrison of 3,000 troops maintains Britain's &bquo;protective presence&equo; here, behind the Iron Curtain. 
 An island surrounded by 165 kilometres of wire and wall complete with barren expanses, blinding searchlights, war dogs, and sinister guard towers. 
 A city containing such famous (and infamous) landmarks as Hitler's Bunker, the Reichstag, the &bquo;Wall&equo; and the Soviet War Memorial. 
 A place Where the legacy of the Second World War still rests upon the shoulders of the British, French and American Allies forty-five years later and where the effects of post-war decisions impact on the daily routine of the RMP soldiers. 
 The role of the 2nd Regiment of the Royal Military Police is unique. 
 It is only in Berlin that dealings with Russian soldiers from the 
 Soviet Sector are commonplace; simply day-to-day duties. 
 Captain Richard Moore's day begins as the ring of the telephone wakes him with a start from a deep sleep. 
 It is Sergeant Eddie Grant at the RMP Control Room, warning him of a possible major problem in the Soviet Sector. 
 The time must be around 0130 hours. 
 A group of soldiers have gone across to East Berlin for an evening's entertainment. 
 AIl servicemen must return to the West before 0030 hours, but tonight only five out of the group of six are back on time at Checkpoint Charlie; one has got lost along the way. 
 A patrol is already searching, and other mobiles are on stand-by. 
 There are only a few places where he can be, but it isn't until 0500 hours that he is found walking along Unter den Linden, the most famous and beautiful  of Berlin's pre-war streets, having apparently lost contact with his friends. 
 Panic over. 
 Having got back to bed for a few hours, at 0800 Captain Moore arrives at his office in the RMP Headquarters, which is housed in the 1936 Olympic Stadium Barracks, and by mid-morning is feeling a bit smug about the noticeable dent in the paperwork on his desk. 
 Still outstanding is the project of redrafting the regulations for Autobahn Corridor travel, but that will have to wait. 
 More pressing is the statistical report on British military travellers to the Soviet Sector last month: 7,874 travellers in June, an increase of over 2,000 on the same month last year. 
 The trend is ever upwards, as East Berlin draws more and more visitors. 
 It is now 0915 hours. 
 Down in the control room a shift change took place an hour ago, and a different platoon is now thinly dispersed throughout the British Sector of Berlin. 
 Woman Corporal Debbie Burns and Corporal John Harvey make up today's Wall patrol. 
 They are based at a duty room outside the Soviet War Memorial in the Tiergarten, tasked with policing the 3.7 kilometres of Wall which separates the British and Soviet sectors. 
 The Soviet War Memorial is one of only two places Where the Russian military have representation in the West, and in order to maintain it they employ soldiers who cross the Wall from their barracks in East Berlin. 
 The Soviet soldiers guarding the Memorial are driven in every day, but because of the  sometimes unpredictable reactions of West Berliners to the sight of Russian soldiers, 2 RMP are charged with escorting the guard when in transit. 
 Although not a difficult duty, it is intriguing, and develops an unusual working relationship with the Soviets. 
 By 1030 hours the Wall patrol has completed its escort task and is free to assist an Engineer Corporal who has just had a collision in his car with an East German in the Soviet Sector. 
 To reach East Berlin they must cross through Checkpoint Charlie, not far from their outpost. 
 After dropping their weapons off &mdash; the RMP do not go armed into the Soviet Sector &mdash; with the Checkpoint Duty NCO, they arrive at the accident shortly after a Volkspolizei  (People's Police) patrol has turned up. 
 Under the Quadripartite Agreement for Berlin the East German Police have no jurisdiction over any of the three Western Powers, though they often try to assert their authority by demanding that soldiers produce identity documents. 
 In this case the Corporal has refused, and an argument is in progress. 
 W/Cpl Burns informs the Volkspoliqei  that their request is outside the terms of the Agreement, and that if they want any details they must call for a Soviet officer, to whom the information will be given. 
 Avoiding further confrontation, the East Germans release the British soldier without further incident, other than contacting his insurance company the next day. 
 On the way back to their Wall patrol route, Debbie and John come across Mr John Runnings, a seventy-two-year-old American who travels to Berlin every summer to protest about the Wall. 
 In 1986 he smashed a concrete top section of the Wall with a sledgehammer, and was arrested by East German Border Guards for his pains. 
 He has returned to Potsdamer Platz &mdash; the Piccadilly Circus of old Berlin &mdash; meticulously to paint the part of the Wall which replaced the part he previously damaged. 
 The NCOs take no action &mdash; Wall graffiti is an acceptable activity in Berlin &mdash; other than to warn him that he runs the risk of being arrested by the East Germans again. 
 For the purpose of upkeep the Wall was built approximately three metres east of the true border, creating a strip of land called the Untebaugebiet. 
 It is here, in what is technically the Soviet Sector, that civilians run the risk of being arrested by East German soldiers who can easily cross the Wall (when on duty) through one of several camouflaged doors. 
 As far as they are concerned, the strip of land is not Soviet Sector but DDR territory, part of their &bquo;Haupstadt&equo; (capital city). 
 The three Western Allies don't agree with the East Germans on this point, which has been the cause of many disagreements in the past. 
 Today's town patrols have not been very busy, but as it is hot and it's summer, they aren't too concerned. 
 Patrolling the Ku-damm in the heart of West Berlin isn't exactly a hardship. 
 Two patrols are out, one on motorcycles and the other in a standard duty van. 
 The weather convinces these men to take the opportunity for a walk around the area of the war-damaged Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church, which is preserved as a constant reminder of the past. 
 This area is always full of interest: mime artists, solo guitarists and full-blown jazz bands entertain the passing public. 
 Contributions from the RMP are gladly received.  
 After lunch a town patrol is called to meet up with today's &bquo;Wire&equo; patrol at Gatow Ranges. 
 Patrols of the forty kilometres of wire separating the British Sector from East Germany are performed by soldiers from the three resident infantry battalions and the Berlin Armoured Squadron, although until 1982 RMP carried out this task. 
 Gatow Ranges are adjacent to the Wire, not far from Berlin's Royal Air Force Station. 
 Periodically, groups of East German soldiers cross over the Wire, laden with cameras to watch and photograph British soldiers shooting on the ranges. 
 As is required by operating procedures, the Wire Patrol Commander from the 1st Battalion the King's Regiment has contacted the RMP regarding today's large presence of East Germans. 
 The five soldiers prove, as always, to be quite a spectacle for passing motorists. 
 No action is needed today as they are not encroaching into the British Sector. 
 They do, however, offer a marvellous photographic opportunity for all the British soldiers present. 
  On training today are the men and women of 2 Platoon. 
 Corporal Steve Giles has somehow talked his Platoon Commander into letting him go on a familiarisation helicopter flight around the Sector perimeter. 
 Helicopter trips around the city are fascinating and great fun; they are an integral part of daily patrolling of the British Sector. 
 Two other members of the platoon have drawn the short straw, and are now dressed in their best uniforms to perform the once-monthly guard duties at the Allied Kommandatura building. 
 The remainder of the platoon has been &bquo;volunteered&equo; to help the 1st Battalion the Black Watch with specialised training for fighting in built-up areas. 
 The NCOs &mdash; all Military Policemen hold the rank of at least Lance-Corporal &mdash; join soldiers from other units in the garrison to play &bquo;locals&equo; in the Army training area of Ruhieben. 
 This unusual experience turns out to be informative and fun. 
 The time spent getting to know other Berlin servicemen away from the more common disciplined environment is good for both sides, and helps to generate a good relationship between the police and the military community. 
 At 2200 hours Captain Moore has to be at Checkpoint Bravo to receive a military convoy that has transitted East Germany along the road corridor from Helinstedt in the West. 
 Already waiting are Sergeant Tosh Collins, RMP Sector Operations Sergeant, and Colour Sergeant Taff Skuse, a Royal Regiment of Wales soldier and one of seven Russian interpreters belonging to 2 RMP. 
 Colour Sergeant Skuse has already driven down to the Soviet Checkpoint, one kilometre away in East Germany, to warn the Russians that a British military convoy is expected to enter the city. 
 The convoy has already been through a Soviet Checkpoint at Marienborn on the West/East German border, Where the numbers of men and vehicles have been thoroughly checked. 
 The RMP's job, along with the Soviet Checkpoint Commander, at the end of the journey is to confirm the numbers have not increased due to any unauthorised hitchhikers. 
 A miscount necessitates a recount, and it is imperative that the numbers are accurate. 
 The rapport between the British RMP and the Russians is excellent, and during the check conversation flows freely. 
 There will no doubt be an excuse for them to drink vodka together again soon. 
 Upon completing their goodbyes, the convoy is led out of the Soviet Checkpoint, past numerous East German barriers, gates and armed border guards, whose task it is to keep their own people from entering West Berlin. 
 It passes under a bridge, on the reverse of which is written the ominous words &bquo;YOU ARE LEAVING THE AMERICAN SECTOR&equo;. 
 The RMP can now go home. 
 It has been a long day, but there are still a couple of hours to run, and this is Berlin, where anything can happen. 
 &bquo;Hello, Romeo 11 Alpha, this is Zero. 
 We have an unconfirmed report of shots fired in the area of Brandenburg Gate. 
 West Berlin Police are at the scene and have requested your assistance&hellip;.&equo;  
 An East German border guard making a video from on top of the Berlin Wall. 
 he chose an ironic slogan to sit above! 
 Tank transporters from 16 Tank transporter Squadron RCT on the final part of their journey into Berlin bringing 15th/19th hussars' tanks to relieve the resident Cavalry Squadron 
 The Allied Checkpoint Charlie building. 
 Once the only route that Allied personnel could use to travel into the Soviet Sector, with the dismantling of the wall it is now redundant 
 NORTHERN IRELAND 
 In Northern Ireland with the Royal Hampshires 
 The British Army has an appallingly difficult job to do in Northern Ireland, none more so than the infantry. 
 This chapter describes a day in the life of the Royal Hampshire Regiment, in this strife-torn corner of the United Kingdom. 
 The 1st Battalion the Royal Hampshire Regiment took over operational control of the city of Londonderry on 5 March 1989. 
 The last time the &bquo;Tigers&equo; patrolled these streets was exactly ten years earlier. 
 Then our Commanding Officer commanded Y Company, the Regimental Sergeant Major was a platoon Sergeant, and the majority of today's soldiers were just starting their secondary schools in Hampshire. 
 The regiment is on a two-and-a-half year tour, so we have moved here with our families. 
 The wives (but not the men) shop in the city, as they would anywhere in England. 
 The children attend the local schools, where they are completely integrated and speak very highly of the educational standards. 
 The thirtieth of June was a fairly typical day. 
 B Company were in the city for their second tour, A Company were training, and Y Company were committed to guards and duties. 
 Z Company were just returning from a fortnight's well-earned leave while, as always, HQ Company were administering, paying, feeding, clothing and transporting the rest of the battalion. 
 But it is in the city, on the west bank of the River F ore, that we shall concentrate, with the officers and men of B Company. 
 Theirs was the first company to deploy into the city in March and now, halfway through their second tour, their knowledge of the ground and the way of life of Derry is unsurpassed. 
 The following passages have been written by two of the platoon commanders. 
 lieutenant S is twenty-five. 
 A graduate in Geography from the University of Edinburgh, he was commissioned in the Argyll and Sutherland Highlanders three years ago. 
 He has been attached to the Royal Hampshires since December last year. 
 He commands 4 Platoon and has completed one city tour at RUC Rosemount, a detached platoon base close to the Creggan and Bogside areas of the city. 
 This tour he is based in Fort George, alongside Company Headquarters. 
 Midnight passing marks the start of another day, and for many people the start of a good night's sleep. 
 However, it also marks another six hours of duty for the sangar sentries and two teams on military escorts. 
 The Platoon Commander  visits the sangars during the night, and is not surprised by the sentries' alertness and cheerfulness. 
 On his way round, via the Operations Room, he hears about the armed escort vehicles in hot pursuit of a police Hotspur Land-Rover, which in turn is giving chase to an orange Lada for minor motoring offences. 
 Other minor infringements, vehicle checkpoints (VCPs) and house calls keep the military escorts busy all night, but routine in the sangars seems endless. 
 At 0600 hours, duties change. 
 Two fresh teams start as the Quick Reaction Force, or QRF, which are changed regularly during the day. 
 The QRF are pleased to hear that lunch is at Strand Road, where the food is better, and the two teams deploy with letters to write and books to read. 
 Anything to break the monotony of waiting, yet being at a split second's notice to move, to any incident, anywhere in the city. 
 Nothing happens. 
 A patrol at 1100 hours, involving three bleary-eyed teams, deploys into the city. 
 Coffee and a careful briefing make the difference, and the boys spark as always. 
 Vehicles are checked, dustbins avoided, sighting reports sent, car trawls and information reports filled out. 
 As usual, nothing dramatic to report, but a quick and thorough debrief means no information is wasted. 
 Four teams deploy in pairs for a VCP task. 
 VCPs are set apparently at random, and vehicles stopped in the same way, but there is a method in the madness. 
 &bquo;Oh no, not again,&equo; remarks an attractive blonde whose car is stopped for the second ti me in a day. 
 However, she leaves more cheerfully after a few choice words from one of the boys suggesting that her photograph should be changed because it doesn't do her justice. 
 After the evening meal four teams again deploy, accompanied by an RUC liaison officer, who is as helpful and cheerful as ever. 
 Patrol tasks include keeping a particular lookout for flat-bed lorries, which are used by the IRA as baseplates for their inaccurate and random, but nonetheless effective, homemade mortars. 
 2045 hours, and the last patrol of the day has just left. 
 Information in the briefing includes who is going Where tonight, and various vehicles to be searched if the opportunity arises. 
 The QRF is changed for the final time, and the boys get to bed. 
 2200 hours, and military escorts change. 
 Midnight approaches, and those not on duty are fast asleep. 
 A blast is heard outside the camp. 
 Tension mounts. 
 &bquo;Contact wait out!&equo; 
 The confusion is exacerbated by differing reports on Police and Army radios. 
 A Police vehicle has been hit. 
 Tyre blown off. 
 No one injured. 
 The military escort team, commanded by a young corporal known to his friends as &bquo;Flat Top&equo;, swings into action. 
 The QRF are deployed. 
 Seconds of confusion quickly change to clear-cut orders and a follow-up. 
 Flat Top, Mac and Taff tear down an alley. 
 Sadly, nothing is found. 
 The area is cordoned. 
 Midnight passes and another sleepless night begins. 
 Lieutenant F, also twenty-five, hails from Wales. 
 Having served three years with the TA, he transferred to the Regular Army three years ago, and although from the Royal Regiment of Wales now sports the Royal Hampshire cap badge for his six-month attachment. 
 He commands 5 Platoon at RUC Rosemount. 
  The sky was turning several shades of blue as night gave way to day. 
 The first rays of the sun appeared over the stark metal mortar sheeting covering the cookhouse The three teams stood shivering in the courtyard, shaking the chill of the morning from their bodies. 
 We deployed on to the cold, deserted streets, two teams from the back gate and one from the front. 
 In the gardens the grass glistened with dew, which left imprints where the soldiers' feet had passed. 
 Each team was well aware of the danger that lurked on the seemingly innocent roads. 
 At 0430 there are no civilians about, and if a bomb had been planted this would be an ideal time to detonate it. 
 Forty minutes later, having checked out several vehicles Which were unknown to us, the teams re-entered the base. 
 Another patrol complete. 
 It is, as the Lance-Corporal says, &bquo;a good way to start the day&equo;. 
 Prior to the patrol I had been given a verbal briefing on the night's events. 
 Now I return and read the log, paying particular attention to any changes in tasks or &bquo;fast balls&equo; for the forthcoming day. 
 While we have been patrolling the chef has been woken, and breakfast awaits our return. 
 After breakfast I take a stroll around the base checking that  all the daily administrative tasks have been completed. 
 The ablutions, cookhouse and accommodation are checked for cleanliness, these jobs being a major headache in a platoon location. 
 Once I am happy, the men are allowed to stand down until the next patrol. 
 I use the words &bquo;stand down&equo; loosely. 
 All teams are at ten minutes' notice to move. 
 As the day progresses the next task is a neighbourhood patrol with the RUC. 
 I have found the attitude of the people in Londonderry surprising. 
 Since our first tour, people will now talk to us first, and some will even stop for a chat. 
 It is a shame, however, that they want nothing to do with the RUC. 
 The briefing for the patrol will take place at Fort George, so all the teams jump on the vehicles and drive down. 
 On arrival I have a chat with the Duty Sergeant, who hands me a map with a route or &bquo;beat&equo; on it. 
 Once my men are fully briefed we move out on task. 
 Communication is the most important part of any patrol. 
 It enables the Commander to maintain a mental picture of the location of any team, and to think how he would react if an incident occurred to any one of them. 
 Once the task is complete we return to Fort George and drop off the RUC. 
 My vehicles are then sent to fuel up and also to collect our rations. 
 Meanwhile  I've walked into the Ops Room to find the Ops Officer with his feet on his desk eating Smarties, thinking about an Op order he is due to write. 
 Having collected the mail and picked up the following day's patrol tasks, the vehicles arrive and we return to Rosemount for lunch. 
 An afternoon patrol is on the task sheet &mdash; providing a reassuring presence on the ground, and an opportunity for gathering intelligence and seeing who is about. 
 It is not easy for any of us to stop and chat to people that we do not know, but in ti me confidence grows. 
 As we move on from chatting to some cheerful and cheeky young kids with an impressive vocabulary (even to a soldier), they throw a few stones at us and run away laughing. 
 They are only doing what their brothers and sisters have done before them, and in some cases probably their parents. 
 Returning to camp the debrief reveals an interesting sighting of a suspected IRA member, but this information on its own is of little significance, as there is no evidence to link him to a crime. 
 Administration takes up much of the day, especially if there are a lot of patrols. 
 But the days flash by in a blur. 
 We are able to stand down for a while in the evening to get some sleep, write letters, play darts or watch TV. 
 I spend some time extracting the following day's tasking for my platoon and allocate teams to each task. 
 Any problems within the platoon are dealt with; my door is always open for a chat, and there is always someone with a problem. 
 Another patrol completes the evening. 
 On return a bath, and a final word with the Guard Commander, Whom I ask not to wake me up unless something goes &bquo;bang&equo;. 
 Then it's time to slide into bed for a few hours' sleep, to be woken once again for a patrol that will signal the start of a new day. 
 Twenty-four hours have indeed passed, but the end of a day does not necessarily mean sleep. 
 In each of the bases a guard goes on duty. 
 The Company Operations Room is manned by a signaller, and a watchkeeper keeping abreast of all patrolling activity by Police and Army. 
 Vehicle checks continue to be sent and are processed. 
 Endless mugs of tea and coffee are consumed. 
 Letters are written home, and before the night seems settled, dawn is breaking and another day begins. 
 The first of July will no doubt be much like the thirtieth of June &mdash; such is the tragedy of Northern Ireland.  
 On patrol in Northern Ireland. 
 Whilst one man moves the other covers him 
 Members of 4 Platoon, B Company, of the Royal Hampshires carrying out a vehicle check in the city centre 
 The Bomb-Disposal Men: A Day in the Life of an EOD Detachment 
 No branch of the British Army is more justly admired than the bomb-disposal men. 
 Here we see what really goes on during on day in their lives. 
 It is 2215 hours, and the team room in a Detachment of 321 Explosive Ordnance Disposal Company is quiet except for the steady drone of the television in the corner and the occasional outburst from the Province Incident Radio Net (PIN). 
 The team members are slumped in armchairs, watching a video of Top Gun. 
 It's about the third or fourth ti me that they have seen it &mdash; the same is probably true for most of the videos on the camp. 
 It is something to watch, however, and it makes the time go quickly When the team is not working. 
 A cloud of cigarette smoke hangs over the group, slowly wafting over the television set and out through the open window. 
 The non-smokers dislike the perpetual and pungent cloud, but have grown to accept it without serious complaint &mdash; it's the least of their worries. 
 The detachment is part of 321 Explosive Ordnance Disposal Company whose task, in Northern Ireland, of neutralising terrorist bombs (IEDs) or Improvised Explosive Devices, as they are officially known) has earned them worldwide respect. 
 From humble beginnings, during the Malaya and Borneo campaigns, terrorist bomb disposal has become a sophisticated and deadly game played between these men and the terrorists. 
 Some of their equipment is highly complex, some of it very simple. 
 The training that they receive is comprehensive and the testing thorough. 
 A high failure rate ensures that only those with the right aptitude for the job eventually make it to the Company. 
 Their record is awe-inspiring. 
 Since 1969 they have attended some 38,000 incidents and neutralised approximately 4,460 IEDs. 
 In the course of this work eighteen operators have been killed. 
 They are the most highly decorated unit in the British Army. 
 The Detachment Commander, a Captain and Ammunition Technical Officer (ATO) in the Royal Ordnance Corps, is busy writing up reports for the couple of incidents the team has attended during the preceding few days. 
 He only glances up at the television occasionally, as he is intent on finishing these as quickly as possible in order to give himself ti me to write a letter home to his wife. 
 In his late twenties, he finds himself having to conduct family business via telephone and letter. 
 The two-month period between finishing his Special-to-Theatre EOD course at the School of Ammunition and arriving in the Province suddenly became two days' notice, due to a shortfall in EOD Operators. 
 Consequently his wife has been left to fend for herself over a variety of matters. 
 The  same is true for many of the other Operators in the Company. 
 Tonight on the phone she was sounding down; the washing machine had broken down and the cat was thought to have broken its hip. 
 A trip to the vet had proved otherwise, but it was yet another worry on top of all the others. 
 Wives with husbands in Northern Ireland worry, but in this job the worries are perhaps slightly greater. 
 Terms like &bquo;I'm fine&equo; and &bquo;there's no need to worry&equo; don't cut much ice after two months away. 
 Stresses are easily transmitted over the phone and fuel concern. 
 Letters avoid this, which is why writing them becomes such an important part of the daily ritual. 
 Corporal M, or &bquo;Bobo&equo; to his colleagues, the team number two, is also only 
 Account for the previous week, he is busy filling in the end-of-month returns required by Company Headquarters. 
 Training returns, ammo expenditure, equipment serial number, vehicle mileage &mdash; all have to be documented. 
 Having only recently arrived in the Province, this is the first ti me he has had to do them, and they are taking him some ti me. 
 Still, doing these rather than the outstanding equipment performance reports means that he doesn't have to use of  the typewriter. 
 The Captain seems to have got accustomed to single-finger typing but he, as yet, has not. 
 Still, he's got five more months in which to practise. 
 Corporal L, the Royal Signals Operator, is half asleep in his chair. 
 He thinks that he probably overdid it in the gym tonight. 
 With only very limited recreational facilities available on the camp, the gym is popular. 
 He promises himself an easier workout tomorrow. 
 The team escort, a soldier on loan from the Glosters, is making coffee. 
 The job with the EOD team has been a real eye-opener for him. 
 On previous tasks he has usually been on the cordon ringing the incident that the EOD team has been involved with, and cursing them for taking so long. 
 Now he has had a chance to work with them and perhaps better understands the intricacies of their job. 
 The Captain stops writing and listens more intently to the speaker on the wall &mdash; the PIN net has got a lot busier all of a sudden. 
 Then the message screams out &mdash; &bquo;ATO request, possible mortar attack on RUC Cookstown, ICP Grid 483768.&equo; 
 The room suddenly becomes a hive of activity as the team spring into action. 
 The escort races to the arms cabinet to withdraw the team's weapons, whilst the others run out to the garage to load the last of the equipment. 
 Meanwhile the Captain is answering the phone. 
 The local battalion have rung to give a few more details of the incident. 
 Flak jackets and helmets are hastily pulled on as the team race out to their vehicles. 
 A last-minute check by the Captain, and then the command &bquo;Let's go!&equo; is given and the vehicles move out. 
 A flick of a switch and the flashing blue lights and two-tone horns shatter the relative peace of the night. 
 The barrier at the main gate is already open and the two vehicles shoot through and off into the darkness. 
 The team drive at speed in the centre of the road, other vehicles permitting. 
 Speed and distance from the road edge  probably wouldn't make a lot of difference if a landmine was detonated as they went by, but doing it makes everyone feel better. 
 Most of the vehicles they meet on the road move over to let them pass, but there are always the odd one or two who will be damned if they will. 
 Tonight it is a Ford Escort with two male occupants. 
 As the vans move right over to pass them one of the men gives the team the finger. 
 It is ignored; however, he looks familiar and the vehicle registration number is mentally noted by the Captain, to be passed on when they have finished the task. 
 They quickly reach the incident scene. 
 Troops have already cordoned off the surrounding area with white mine tape, which flutters in the slight breeze. 
 Civilians, accompanied by RUC officers, can be seen moving away from the area, having just been evacuated from their houses. 
 Two fire appliances, lights flashing, wait to one side, their hoses snaking away into the darkness where an explosion has broken all the street lighting. 
 A figure is being carried into an ambulance. 
 The two vans come to a halt in their standard configuration. 
 Corporal M and the escort start to off-load the equipment whilst the Captain speaks to the Incident Commander, an RUC Inspector, and the Cordon Commander, an Infantry Major. 
 Apparently a lorry carrying a rubbish skip was hi-jacked in nearby Pomeroy several hours ago and the driver held at gunpoint. 
 The terrorists then loaded a mortar launcher into the skip and drove the lorry into the council yard, just one hundred metres from the Police Station. 
 The mortars were then fired, just as the evening shift was arriving. 
 However, it would seem that only one launched successfully before an explosion occurred on the lorry itself. 
 Several other mortar bombs have been thrown out into the darkness. 
 None reached its intended target and the only casualties that the terrorists have caused are two passing civilians hit by flying glass and debris &mdash; one is seriously ill. 
 By the ti me the Captain returns, Corporal M has removed the &bquo;Wheelbarrow&equo; from the van, and is busy loading its weapons. 
 This marvellous track-driven robot is an essential part of the EOD team's equipment. 
 Born out of a need to have some form of remote means to neutralise a device, it has been developed throughout the present campaign to its current form, the Mark 8. 
 With its cameras, extending arms and weapons, it is a versatile machine, capable of disrupting a bomb without the Operator having to make a manual approach. 
 On this job, however, it is only used to give a view of the smouldering remains of the skip and lorry. 
 A solid beam of light suddenly illuminates the scene as Nitesun, the heliborne lighting system, hovers overhead. 
 With its aid, two unexploded mortar bombs are located. 
 Both are embedded in the roof of a nearby school and so the Captain has to make a manual approach, without the benefit of wearing the EOD protective suit. 
 He climbs up a ladder and on to the roof. 
 In the flickering light he appears like a cat moving around cautiously. 
 He is reminded of the Company emblem, Felix the cat, the helmeted feline with nine lives, and once again thinks how highly appropriate it is. 
 After some ti me the job is completed and the two mortar bombs have been neutralised. 
 The long metal tubes, detonators, detonating cord and homemade explosives are laid out on the ground, whilst the Police and the host of  other interested parties take photographs. 
 The items are then bagged by the Scenes of Crime Officer, and a date is agreed with the Police for a statement to be taken. 
 After debriefing the other agencies and packing their equipment, the EOD team leave and make their way back to base. 
 The day is not yet over, however. 
 All of the equipment has to be cleaned and prepared, ready to go again. 
 The incident also has to be logged and the details passed over the phone for the Colonel's briefing at his daily conference later that morning. 
 Corporal T, the REME technician, is dragged out of bed to repair a minor fault on the Wheelbarrow. 
 His work usually starts when the team return from a task. 
 It is 0320 before the team finally get to bed, with the Captain promising them a lie-in until 1000 hours. 
 The telephone rings at exactly 0930. 
 It is the local Battalion Ops Room. 
 A patrol in the city centre was crossing a road when a small explosion occurred near a fence-post. 
 There have been no casualties but ATO is once again required to clear the scene. 
 This ti me it is only a five-minute journey through the narrow streets. 
 However, the route takes them over a culvert near the hospital. 
 An IED was once placed there before, and the team never like driving over it. 
 A lit tie extra speed and crossed fingers is normal &mdash; this time is no exception. 
 Soon the Wheelbarrow is trundling down the road towards the explosion site, and it is established that an IED positioned in a hole by the fence-post and fired through a wire appears to have only parti ally exploded. 
 The main charge  is still in the hole. 
 Wheelbarrow attempts to pull the bag from the hole, but it is too heavy. 
 Once again the Captain will have to make a manual approach. 
 He stands, arms outstretched like an ancient knight, whilst the remainder of the team dress him in the EOD suit. 
 Weighing some 60 lbs, the suit is designed to give limited protection against flying fragments. 
 If a large IED exploded near him, however, it would do little except keep him reasonably in one piece. 
 On cold days it does have the advantage of keeping him warm, but on hot days it can be unbearably uncomfortable. 
 On a recent job, neutralising an 800-lb landmine, he lost nearly half a stone whilst wearing the suit. 
 Nevertheless, it is a psychological comfort. 
 With his portable equipment &mdash; weapon, tool bag and hook and line &mdash; the weight, as he shuffles out of the ICP, is up to about 70 lb. 
 It is a long lonely walk down to where the Wheelbarrow now sits, forlornly peering at the fencepost. 
 The Captain looks constantly from side to side, ready to react to anything suspicious. 
 By the time he reaches the post he is sweating profusely. 
 The   distinctive smell of diesel and marzipan, the smell of terrorist home-made explosive, is obvious even from ten metres away. 
 The bag is difficult to get a hold on, but eventually he manages to secure a line to it and troops back up the road to the waiting vehicles. 
 As soon as he is back his team are around him, removing the protective plates and helmet in order to ease the discomfort for a while. 
 A pull on the line, and the bag is out of the hole, its contents spilled out into the road. 
 The task is soon completed after this, and the team are pleased to hear that a local IRA member has been arrested in connection with the incident. 
 Neutralising IEDs is one thing, but actually getting a terrorist into court and hopefully prison is the main aim. 
 It's a cheering bonus when this happens. 
 Upon return to their base the Captain disappears to the Ops Room to brief them about the incident, whilst his team once again prepare the equipment. 
 Once that is completed the Captain is joined by Corporal L for a planning conference on a forthcoming job of clearing some derelict houses of a suspect IED. 
 It was not scheduled until later that night, but since the ATO team are there they decide to get it out of the way. 
 The team don't complain as it means an extra journey and a possible late night being avoided. 
 By 1800 hours the team are back home, watching the television. 
 In their self-contained kitchen the microwave is busy heating up their evening meal. 
 They could eat in the main cookhouse, but tonight they prefer their own culinary efforts. 
 The Captain is in his office, once again completing the daily incident log and contemplating more reports that have to be written. 
 He's in the middle of a correspondence promotion course and the books line his desk. 
 He thought he would have plenty of time to study. 
 Things, however, have turned out slightly differently and the books have remained largely unopened. 
 Suddenly the phone rings: a suspect car bomb in the city centre. 
 Once again the room becomes a hive of activity, and the evening meal is forgotten. 
 They wait, kitted up and vehicles running, for ten minutes before the phone rings again and they are told to stand down; it was a false alarm. 
 A sigh of relief. 
 The vehicles are put away again, and the now cold and slightly unappetising evening meal is pushed back into the microwave. 
 It is 2130 and the EOD team are grouped around the television set again, cigarette smoke spiralling up to the ceiling. 
 The Captain is reading the paper, Corporal L is making the coffee and Corporal M is half asleep. 
 Everyone is contemplating an early night &mdash; it has been a long day, one of the busiest for a while. 
 All is quiet. 
 The radio suddenly chatters into life; the phone rings&hellip;.  
 An Ammunition Technical Officer (ATO) donning his equipment on the site of a suspected Improvised explosive Device (IED) &mdash; Army terminology for a terrorist bomb &mdash; so that he can make a close inspection of the device if necessary 
 Wheelbarrow dealing with a suspect car bomb. 
 the Wheelbarrow allows bomb disposal officers to deal with suspect bombs remotely. 
 It has saved many lives 
 Wheelbarrow needs regular maintenance. 
 here it is being checked over back in base after an operation 
 The EOD team preparing Wheelbarrow on the site of an Improvised Explosive Device (IED). 
 Note the operator's colleague providing cover against outside interference 
 Part of 5 UDR cordon around a bomb on the railway link between Northern Ireland and Eire. 
 The IRA regularly attempt to disrupt this line as part of their campaign of economic warfare against the state 
 Soldiers from 6 UDR prepare to fly out form their base in a Lynx helicopter. 
 helicopters are used to mount operations such as snap roadblocks or to deposit surveillance teams in rural areas 
 The Ulster Defence Regiment 
 The Ulster Defence Regiment live with the Northern Ireland problem every day of their lives. 
 This chapter tells us what it's like. 
 As dawn broke on 30 June the lines of white tape became more obvious to the two soldiers lying in the ditch, a little way up the road. 
 A flashing amber light reflected off the red and White signboards, which simply read &bquo;Road Closed&equo;. 
 The scene was alI too familiar to the soldiers, both from C Company of the 5th (County Londonderry) Battalion of the Ulster Defence Regiment, but on this occasion the circumstances were rather unusual. 
 At 0700 hours the previous morning a bomb had exploded under the engine of a passenger train, just before an unmanned level crossing on the main Belfast to Londonderry railway line, in the north-west of Northern Ireland. 
 5 UDR in Whose district the incident took place, immediately became responsible for cordoning the area in order to create a safe space within Which the specialists from the Royal Army Ordnance Corps, Royal Engineers and Royal Ulster Constabulary could work, examining and collecting forensic evidence, as well as ensuring that the remainder of the line was clear of any further devices. 
 The cordon, supported by joint mobile patrols from the RUC and other elements of the battalion, remained in place until the whole area was declared clear at 1600 hours on 30 June, and responsibility for operations in the area was handed back to the police. 
 C Company withdrew to barracks in order to rest before embarking on the next operation early the following morning. 
 As the vehicle convoy turned through the barrack gates, so too did the first of the battalion's part-timers, arriving to begin their duty. 
 Many of the part-timers report for duty for twelve nights every month. 
 They leave their civilian jobs, and instead of heading for home and a quiet night in front of the television, report in to their company bases, change into military uniform and are briefed for the night's patrol tasks, which will take them through until the early hours of the morning, When they again become civilians. 
 The part-time element of a battalion is made up from all sections of the community: farmers, solicitors, factory workers, office managers, garage mechanics and the unemployed, to name but a few, alI united by the common desire to see their country rid of terrorism. 
 A large number of the part-timers have been reporting for duty for the entire twenty years of the Ulster Defence Regiment's existence. 
 Fifty miles south-west of the railway line bomb, 13 Platoon of 6 UDR reported in for duty at 0600; they had been hoping for a quiet day, in order to catch up on some training. 
 However, three days earlier an RUC reserve constable had been murdered by the IRA using an under-vehicle booby trap. 
 13 Platoon had  subsequently been tasked with providing the security for the funeral, which was to be held in a small village near Strabane. 
 The operation had been planned the previous day after close liaison with the local RUC Headquarters, and was to include a detailed search of the area using dogs and helicopters. 
 1 on the ground, having been flown from their barracks in Omagh some twenty miles away. 
 Once in position, the platoon began to search the funeral route, as well as the churchyard and cemetery. 
 It was here that the dogs came into their own, casting about for any tell-tale scent that would betray the presence of a hidden bomb. 
 The soldiers meanwhile were looking into back gardens, dustbins and under hedgerows. 
 The search lasted until 1130 hours, after Which the platoon took up positions along the route and established vehicle checkpoints on roads throughout the area. 
 These were moved frequently so that terrorists could never be sure where the next checkpoint would be. 
 As the time for the funeral approached, so the RUC began to arrive to take over on point duty from the UDR, who then merged into the background but nevertheless maintained a discreet but ever-watchful presence. 
 The funeral passed off without incident, and by 1630 hours the majority of the platoon was able to return to Omagh, leaving a section under the command of the platoon commander to cover the post-funeral gathering in the church hall. 
 The cordon was eventually lifted at 1900 hours and the section flown home, only to prepare for a very full day's patrolling on the following day. 
 The day's missed training would have to be fitted in some other time. 
 In Belfast, the day started on a humorous note When, at 0130 hours, the top cover sentry of a mobile patrol from one of the companies of 7th/ 10th (City of Belfast) Battalion noticed that the front door of a bank was wide open. 
 The patrol dismounted from their vehicles and, having informed the battalion operations room of their find, deployed around the bank to await the arrival of the RUC. 
 As the patrol commander approached the door of the bank, he spotted a black briefcase leaning against a wall. 
 He immediately withdrew the patrol to a safe distance and together they began to clear the area for any other suspicious signs. 
 The street was soon cleared and an incident control point was set up. 
 The RUC arrived, a sergeant in command. 
 The patrol commander had just finished briefing the police on the situation when one of the patrol shouted, &bquo;There's someone in the bank.&equo; 
 The patrol gave cover as the police approached the building. 
 Just at that moment a man staggered out of the door of the bank; when he saw the tableau of police and soldiers in front of him, he threw his arms up in the air. 
 The RUC sergeant went forward and arrested the man, who turned out to be the bank security guard who was rather the worse for drink, and had forgotten to lock the door! 
 The whole incident was over within an hour and the patrol was able to return to their base. 
 South-east of Belfast lies rural County Down, the tactical area of responsibility of 3 UDR. 
 D Company had spent the previous day digging a line of trenches to cover a series of vehicle checkpoints on all the main roads, and were just settling down for their first day's occupation of the trenches. 
 For a change the weather was fine, and when shortly after midnight the company second in command went round to visit the soldiers in the trenches, he found morale  high. 
 One of the new breed of Sandhurst-trained officers in the regiment, he has also attended the Platoon Commanders' Battle Course at the School of Infantry, and is well versed in the principles of living in a defensive position. 
 When he had finished visiting all the positions he returned to his base at Ballykinler in time to get a couple of hours' sleep before briefing the helicopter pilots who were to fly in support of the checkpoint operation. 
 The helicopters lifted off at 1030 hours. 
 Having criss-crossed the ground, the aerial spotter sighted a van being driven suspiciously, near one of the dugin positions. 
 The pilot dipped the nose of the aircraft and dropped down behind the van, close enough to be able to read its registration number: only a delivery van from the nearby town. 
 The static checkpoint operation continued for most of the day, relieved only  When elements of the company were flown from their entrenched positions to set up snap checkpoints on roads that could not be covered permanently. 
 By early evening the company second in command had exchanged his helicopter for a Land-Rover, and was out visiting the platoons in their trenches again, before returning to barracks to brief the part-time soldiers who were taking over the mobile patrolling tasks for the night. 
 The briefing over, he returned to the countryside to join his company commander in his trench to see out the remainder of the night. 
 Not every battalion had such a busy day. 
 In East Tyrone, s UDR started the day on a happy note when the Commanding Officer called the Administrative Officer to his office and told him that he was to be promoted to Captain. 
 This was followed by the Company Commander of B Company being asked to organise a barbecue around the swimming pool (the legacy of a former Commanding Officer who had discovered an under-used JCB in the grounds of the base). 
 In the Operations Room, some of the female part-time watchkeepers were just coming on duty and were being briefed on the operations that were planned for the day and those that were already taking place. 
 The UDR has some 700 women in its ranks; they are fully integrated into the regiment and, although they do not carry weapons, perform the same duties as their male counterparts. 
 The air operations officer was in the middle of co-ordinating the helicopter tasking for the day, when a Wessex landed beside the swimming pool, causing part of the screen fencing to blow into the pool and OC B Company to have a minor sense of humour failure. 
 In Battalion Headquarters, the Welfare Officer was busy co-ordinating holidays for the children of soldiers Who have been killed by terrorists, when a call was received to say that the grave of a terrorist victim had been vandalised. 
 Forgetting the holidays temporarily, she headed out in her car to assess the damage for herself. 
 Thankfully, the damage was minimal and she was able to return to barracks knowing that the Battalion Welfare Fund would be able to pay for the cost of the necessary repairs. 
 Later in the day she was busy again when the Intelligence Officer informed her that it had become necessary for a UDR soldier and his family to move from their present house. 
 The well-tested welfare organisation swung into gear, as the Welfare Officer once again climbed into her car to go and speak to the wife and assure her that temporary accommodation had been arranged for her and the family, and that the move from one house to another would be made as smooth as possible. 
 As the Welfare Officer drove back through the camp gates she was greeted by the smell of a well-smouldering barbecue and the news that the Greenfinch rounders team had lost heavily in a tournament at RAF AIdergrove. 
 It hadn't been an unusual day. 
 Although 1/9 UDR in Antrim and 11 UDR in Portadown passed relatively uneventful days in their respective areas, another day it might have been their turn to face the sort of challenges met by 3, 5, 6, 7/10 and 8 UDR on 30 June 1989. 
 These brave men and women face the threat of terrorism every day of the year. 
  My name is Private A and I am a part-time soldier in the 4th (County Fermanagh) Battalion of the Ulster Defence Regiment. 
 Each week I try to do at least three duties, and Friday 30 June was my third that week. 
 It had been a long hot day on the farm where I help my father with his large dairy herd. 
 As it is the hay and silage season, we had been going non-stop since dawn. 
 My mother had a big spread waiting for us that evening When we got cleared up, and then it was time to report to the UDR base for patrol duty. 
 I got my personal weapon and kit together, checked under the car, and headed for Angelo. 
 The lads were already at the armoury drawing their rifles, then there was the briefing. 
 We were due to go out at 2000 hours. 
 Great, a change from mobiles: it was a boat patrol and rummage search of an island close to the border, where there is a constant high threat of attack from a cross-border shoot. 
 A great night for it, and those Rigid Raiders are the fastest boats on the Lough. 
 We left Angelo by Land-Rover with the boats in tow, and put them in the water  at a nearby jetty. 
 No time wasted, away within seconds at top speed. 
 It gave the cabin cruiser set a thrill to see us in action. 
 You wouldn't think there was a war on, the way the tourists can't stay away, but who can blame them in weather like this? 
 Wouldn't have minded sipping pink gins aboard a cruiser myself, but the job's got to be done and we have got plenty worth fighting for. 
 A speedy journey in the boats took us to one of the 365 islands in Lough Erne. 
 We carry out rummage searches of the islands to deter such activities as smuggling, and terrorists from using them as locations for weapon hides. 
 Within minutes of disembarking from the boats and starting the search we all found to our disappointment that the good weather still hadn't dried out the long grass of the islands, and we were all soon soaking. 
 The search was completed at dusk. 
 The boats picked us up at a pre-arranged rendezvous and we sped off again to do a foot patrol on the lough shore road. 
 As it was Friday night, nearing the end of our tour of duty, there was plenty of traffic on the road as people came home from pubs and dances. 
 As our pick-up ti me approached we mustered under our patrol commander and soon moved back to base, tired but satisfied that we'd done a good job. 
 After the patrol debrief, I changed, collected my personal weapon and returned home. 
 With any luck my father wouldn't call me for the milking too early; he generally doesn't when I've been out on patrol the night before. 
 Getting in after half past three to get up again at six o'clock is no fun. 
 At least on the farm I can work &bquo;flexi-time&equo;, not like some of the boys who have to be at their civy job at half eight in the morning. 
 As I approached the house, I noticed that my parents' bedroom light was still on. 
 It always is on the nights I'm out with the UDR. 
 They pretend for my sake they don't worry. 
 I turned the key in the door and crept in. 
 As I climbed the stairs my Dad's voice called out with relief as he always does, &bquo;Is that yourself, son?&equo;  
 top cover sentries on a 7/10 UDR mobile patrol 
 A UDR boat patrol passes Enniskillen Castle. 
 In Ulster there are several large inland lakes and sea loughs. this is the most efficient way of covering these areas 
 EUROPE 
 Swords into Ploughshares: the UN Battalion in Cyprus Captain P Watkins 
 The British Army has provided troops for the UN all over the world. 
 Here Captain Phillip Watkins, holding the appointment of Humanitarian Officer with the Royal Horse Artillery, describes a day in his life in Cyprus whilst wearing the blue beret of the UN. 
 &bquo;And then sixty sit-ups, stand by, go.&equo; 
 It's 0700 on the 30 June and my body has already been up for an hour and run four miles. 
 The rest of me is just catching up. 
 The PT instructor barks out his orders with an enthusiasm that is unnatural for this time of the morning. 
 Members of Headquarters Battery follow them with varying degrees of success. 
 In the case of the postal orderly, his sixty situps must be on a cumulative basis. 
 We have been here five months and he has one month left to complete his sixty. 
 By contrast the Sergeant Major has already finished, and is jogging on the spot with an air of contempt for the rest of us mere mortals. 
 My mind has at last caught up, and indeed overtaken my body. 
 It's ahead in the shower, imagining the delight of hot water. 
 In the event, the water is far from hot &mdash; the EOKA gunmen who were once interned in this camp probably relied on the same boiler for water, and I am sure it was with a wry sense of humour that the Greek Cypriot government allocated St David's Camp to the British contingent of the UN Forces in Cyprus. 
 After a quick breakfast it's across to HQ to read the sitreps (situation reports). 
 Each of the two sub-units of the British contingent manning the BZ (Buffer Zone) has sent in a sitrep detailing the previous twenty-four hours' activity in the BZ. 
 A quick scan to see if anything has happened in my department. 
 As the Sector Humanitarian Officer, one of my concerns is farming activity within the Buffer Zone. 
 I see from the sitreps that a farmer has been escorted out of the BZ by the UN soldiers from the western sub-unit, for farming in an unauthorised area. 
 Today it's a Greek Cypriot farmer who is cultivating land too close to the Turkish military positions for the UN to guarantee his safety. 
 It is just as likely to have been a Turkish Cypriot farmer moving too far south. 
 Allowing farming in the BZ is the best means available to the UN to achieve its stated aim of contributing to the restoration of normal conditions. 
 It is also the point at Which the divided communities meet, and if the expansion is to continue without incident it must be closely regulated. 
 Passes are issued and soldiers act as escorts to any farmer Who may feel insecure.  
 Many of the tasks of soldiers of the UN battalion are of this humanitarian nature, rather than purely operational. 
 Later today, soldiers from the eastern sub-unit, which is located on the outskirts of Nicosia, will provide an escort for an Armenian funeral. 
 The cemetery is situated inside the BZ only 200 metres from the Turkish military positions: the presence of UN blue berets will reassure both sides. 
 By 0815 we are half-way through the Commanding Officer's morning conference. 
 Each department head is responsible for briefing the Colonel. 
 The Operations Officer has briefed us on a shot fired from one of the Turkish observation towers. 
 The situation is that the UN Commander of the area requested information on the shot from the Turkish forces. 
 They reported it as a negligent discharge during a change of the guard. 
 The matter is now closed; the explanation is plausible, it happens with alarming frequency on both sides. 
 I have reported on the illegal farming to the CO, and now it's the turn of the Operations Information Officer. 
 I think it's fair to say that the only significant report from the Operations Information Officer during this tour has been the  dates of the first flights bringing Swedish holidaymakers to Larnaca. 
 Today's information on the movement of a Greek Cypriot National Guard convoy pales into insignificance. 
 The Colonel runs through his diary for the day. 
 He has a meeting with Colonel Charalambedes, the Officer in Command of National Guard forces in our area. 
 Following this the Colonel is to visit Dhekelia, where the two other subunits which form the other half of the battalion are providing security for the British Garvison. 
 Regular visits by the Colonel and the Adjutant ensure that the HQ element, which remains in the Buffer Zone for six months, does not lose touch with the two sub-units, which rotate to these duties after three months with the UN. 
 The Colonel will first visit the sub-unit guarding the Signals Regiment based at Ayios Nikolaos, and then go on to the sub-unit at Dhekelia. 
 Both sub-units are involved in internal security duties which demand long hours of vigilance, which must be managed carefully to avoid routine and monotony. 
 To help provide variety for the UN battalion, as well as refresher training, troops of twenty-six soldiers will embark on two weeks of Adventurous and Military Training. 
 Today the Adjutant is visiting troops Who are mounting a heliborne assault on the village of Pararnali, as a culmination of their week of military training. 
 (The Operations Information Officer tells me the Adjutant is really going to Dhekelia to water-ski-but then Operations Information is seldom accurate!)  
 After a run through the Adjutant's forecast of events, revealing yet two more VIPs visiting the battalion later in the month, the morning prayers change tack. 
 The Regimental Sergeant Major, responsible for co-ordinating sporting activity in addition to his normal duty, reports that a number of soldiers from the regiment are going on a sailing course. 
 Opportunities for water sports are good on the island, and the RSM is able to get most of the soldiers on one short course, such as canoeing or diving, during the tour. 
 The daily conference over, it's on to the main activity of the day for me, which is a Long Northwind Patrol. 
 Outside the UNBZ, the Humanitarian Officer has responsibilities for visiting the enclaved people of this divided island; that is Greek Cypriots still living in the North, and Turkish Cypriots still living in the South. 
 Each of these communities receives visits from the UN, and today we are going to the North. 
 In the British contingent's area of responsibility there is the town of Kyrenia, and the Maronite villages of Asomatos, Karpasha and Kormakiti, which nestle in the western foothills of the Kyrenia mountain range. 
 The Maronites are Greek-speaking Catholics living in Turkish-held territory, and as if that were not enough of a mixture, in order to maintain links with their Lebanese roots they hold their church services in Arabic. 
 Today I will lead a convoy of UN lorries with food and gas to these villages. 
 The aim of the patrols is couched in high ideals of maintaining peace, aiding the world food programme and supporting the International Red Cross. 
 At a practical level, we see fair play, and deliver the groceries. 
 The rest of the Humanitarian team, Staff Sergeant Punter, Sergeant McMenemy and Sergeant Ryiance left camp early this morning (missing the sixty sit-ups!) to supervise the loading of the lorries. 
 They will rendezvous with me at the Turkish Checkpoint in Nicosia. 
 My first visit is to the Red Cross, to pick up medicines requested on the previous patrol and then on to visit the Franciscan nuns, who run a school in Nicosia. 
 We visit the Sisters for two reasons. 
 The first is that three nuns from the same order work in the largest of the villages, Kormakiti, and so we provide a useful link. 
 The second reason is that they always give us a packed lunch! 
 At the Turkish Checkpoint, paperwork complete, we meet up with Sergeant Nafi, a legend of the Levant. 
 Sergeant Nafi is a Turkish Cypriot policeman Who has accompanied these patrols for the last fourteen years. 
 He knows all the villagers personally, and is as indispensable to me as he was to the previous twenty-seven Humanitarian Officers. 
 Before midday we arrive at the first village and are met by the Mukhtar, Hadji Hanna. 
 The Mukhtar is the elected head of the village, and all requests or problems are passed through him to me. 
 The average age of the villagers is over seventy, and in this village, Asomatos, there are only twenty-seven Maronites left. 
 These are dying communities whose youth has moved to the prosperous South; requests are therefore those associated with old age. 
 As the lorries are unloaded I am aware of a disturbance. 
 Sergeant Nafi gives me a knowing look and I realise we are about to see a repeat performance of the Greek tragedy play. 
 It's a play I have seen acted regularly in each village, and on every occasion it's exactly the same. 
 The goods delivered consist of  everyday groceries, and they are busily collected by the villagers and thrust into bags. 
 It's not the first delivery of food after a famine, but the scene suggests it could be. 
 Suddenly, but predictably, the main actor enters the stage and speaks in a piercing voice, intelligible to me only because it is unmistakably one of alarm. 
 With true Mediterranean emotion the hands move to the face to emphasise tragedy. 
 The finger is then pointed. 
 The second actor, the accused, immediately begins a soliloquy of defence. 
 Soon they are joined by the supporting cast taking sides. 
 The language difference is unimportant, the plot is clear. 
 Something is missing, and somebody is clearly guilty &mdash; &bquo;whodunnit?&equo; 
 Sergeant Nafi looks at me, sighs and closes his eyes. 
 I know it's time for audience participation. 
 He rises slowly, but then delivers a fierce tirade of Which any Sergeant Major would be proud. 
 The villagers are stunned into silence and turn to face me, centre stage now, but I do not have a speaking part. 
 Instead I put on my best British Empire District Commissioner look of authority while Sergeant Nafi begins to search. 
 He proves the accused innocent, and then, surprise, surprise, we find the missing item, Halloumi cheese, in the bottom of one of the delivery boxes. 
 The tragedy turns into comedy. 
 We all share the joke and then the lemon squash! 
 After an uneventful visit to the thirty-seven villagers of Karpasha, we arrive in the village of Kormakiti, which has 215 residents. 
 Not all today's requests are routine. 
 Sister Agnesey enquires if any progress has been made in acquiring commodes. 
 The request was first submitted a number of months ago, but all attempts through the usual channels have failed. 
 The sisters are concerned and making an impassioned plea. 
 They invite me to visit one of the needy. 
 We step off the main road, down two steps and into one of two rooms which constitute home. 
 There is no electric light, and the floor is compacted earth. 
 A picture of the Virgin Mary and a cross are the only wall decorations, and the furniture consists of a single chair and a table. 
 In the corner of the room is a large bed hung with a dark musty surrounding curtain. 
 The smell is human, raw, and overpowering. 
 I am greeted by a timid and frail old man who, clutching his hands nervously, thanks me for coming: a greeting he continues to offer throughout my stay. 
 Sister Agnesey leads me to the bed on which lies Maria Frantzia, the old man's wife; she smiles and we exchange a few words. 
 Maria has lived paralysed in this bed for thirty years. 
 The experience is sobering, a renewed effort has to be made to obtain commodes. 
 Writing the patrol report back in St David's Camp, I am able to state that the four ladies in Kyrenia are all well. 
 With the paperwork finished, it's across to the Mess for a cup of tea and to catch up on the rest of the news. 
 The last task of the day for the humanitarian branch is to visit the village of Mammari and speak to the local farmers. 
 The meetings are usually relaxed and informal, and tonight is no exception. 
 Turkish coffees are brought to the table, together with vegetables soaked in lemon juice. 
 The farmers from this village own land in the Buffer Zone that has been lying fallow for fourteen years, but which is now being opened up. 
 When we began the project we were inundated with farmers waving korchanis  (land title deeds) to the relevant fields. 
 Five months into the project, we are now at a manageable level and tonight we arrange to open a further six fields over the next week.   
 Captain Watkins discusses the finer points of farming with a local 
 A beach landing in Cyprus adds realism to military training 
 A British-manned UN checkpoint in Cyprus 
 Decorating the walls of this particular coffee shop are pictures of EOKA gunmen, reminders of past struggles. 
 Today, thankfully, the acrimony is forgotten and only the coffee is bitter. 
 The meeting is over within an hour and we return to the camp. 
 Walking from the Regimental Headquarters to the Mess there is time to reflect on the day and think about the future. 
 My day is over, but the soldiers on the line will continue to man observation posts and patrol throughout the night. 
 In four weeks' time the regiment moves from peacekeeping with the United Nations to peacekeeping by deterrent in West Germany. 
 My thoughts are then interrupted by a tired and strained voice: &bquo;&hellip; forty-eight, forty-nine, fifty&hellip;.&equo; 
 It's 2030 hours and the postal orderly struggles on. 
 Ed. note : Two weeks later the first commode was delivered to Maria Frantzia.  
 Captain Watkins discusses the finer points of farming with a local 
 A beach landing in Cyprus adds realism to military training 
 A British-manned UN checkpoint in Cyprus 
 ACE Mobile Force Supply Company: Royal Army Ordnance Corps 
 The Allied Command Europe Mobile force is a NATO organisation. 
 One of Britain's contributions is the provision of the bulk of the manpower for the supply company. 
 It is five o'clock in the morning, but already the sun has crept over the horizon and the temperature is rising. 
 Ten days ago the AMF(L) Supply Company RAOC arrived in northern Turkey to support the multinational Allied Command Europe Mobile Force (Land), (AMF(L)), as part of the Logistic Support Battalion. 
 The climate, terrain and culture of the region could not be more different from that which they had experienced in northern Norway only three months earlier. 
 The temperature in Bardufoss regularly reached minus 30&amp;degree; C; here on the outskirts of Corlu it is frequently plus 35&dollar;degree; C at midday. 
 Physical fitness is most important for coping with these extremes of climate, because lengthy periods of acclimatisation are not possible &mdash; work must start immediately on arrival in a new theatre of operations. 
 The company base moved from its deterrent operations location two days ago. 
 Gone now are all the flags and signs of welcome to the world's press and senior military guests. 
 The Force welcomes visitors, because its primary role is deterrent, and the Force can best fulfil its mission by showing how effectively a multinational, integrated force can operate in isolated locations on the flanks of Europe. 
 The company's location is a wide area of open, rolling countryside, parched grassland dissected by open dry fissures. 
 Finely woven desert camouflage nets cover all our tents and equipment, blending well with the terrain. 
 Despite the total lack of natural foliage, or local buildings, the company is well hidden from ground and aerial observation. 
 Fortunately the AMF(L) Supply Company has its own mobile shower unit co-located with it, and this is a very popular port of call first thing in the morning and throughout the evening. 
 The Company Command Post is already a hive of activity as the daily reports are being collated on a computer, ready for transmission to Battalion Headquarters. 
 A member of the Stores Platoon is engrossed with the fax machine in another corner of the tent, passing demands for urgently required spare parts, not available in theatre, to the Logistic Operations Centre at SHAPE (Supreme Headquarters Allied Powers in Europe) at Mons in Belgium. 
 A member of the German Wire Company is conducting a line test on one of the telephones, and the Turkish interpreter, a young, olive-skinned Lance-Corporal with only two of his eighteen months' national service remaining, and known to all by his first name of Ercan because his surname is unpronounceable in English, is standing near the entrance drinking coffee and smoking a foul-smelling cigarette.  
 Captain Piervittorio Stefanoni, the Italian Force Veterinary Officer, arrives at the entrance to the Command Post. 
 He is a small, bearded, rather rotund man in his late thirties, always jovial and yet a true professional who takes his responsibilities very seriously. 
 Accompanied by Major Clive Elderton, the Company Commander, and the interpreter, they set off for the local slaughterhouse some ten kilometres away. 
 They pass a pair of very solemn Turkish sentries from the Host Nation Support Unit, receiving a rather lethargic response to their cheery wave. 
 A brief halt at the Military Police Post to book out with the Belgian Military Policeman on duty, and they are off along the main road into Corlu. 
 Despite the early hour &mdash; it is not yet 0600 hours &mdash; the road is busy with overcrowded buses, ancient taxis and slow-moving, overloaded cargo vehicles. 
 This is the main highway from Istanbul, which lies about 100 miles to the east, to the Greek border, some 100 miles to the west, and although in most parts it has a good tarmac surface it is in the main single carriageway. 
 The locals go to suicidal lengths to overtake vehicles travelling only marginally slower than themselves. 
 Entering Corlu it is apparent that the street traders have already reserved their pitches, and a queue has formed outside the baker's shop. 
 Ragged children wearing a semblance of black and white uniform skip along the pavements on their way to school; by midday their schooling will be over for the day and they will start work alongside their parents, or engage in various enterprises from shoe shining to the selling of postcards. 
 Other children, destined for the afternoon session in the schoolhouse, are already at work. 
 Outside the local military headquarters the Turkish Military Police stand guard. 
 They have Kalashnikov rifles slung ready across their chests and wear distinctive red and white armbands and helmets. 
 These are the Asiz,  and are a common sight throughout the Turkish military. 
 The slaughterhouse is on the outskirts of the town, and can be smelled before it comes into view. 
 The NATO party arrive to find the local butcher has already assembled a dozen healthy-looking beasts behind the main building ready for inspection. 
 Captain Stefanoni sets to work immediately, examining flanks, ears and tongues, and soon selects the five beasts required to feed five thousand multinational customers. 
 The Turkish slaughtermen offer the ubiquitous Turkish tea, a strong bitter brew known as chi , which invariably precedes all conversations, and the RAOC Master Butcher and his three British and two Belgian butchers, who have been busy all night cutting and jointing, now prepare themselves to assist in the slaughter of the cattle and sheep. 
 The Muslim religion dictates that this is a particularly bloody affair, but the special skills of these tradesmen have, in a very short period, led to mutual respect and friendship, despite a total language barrier. 
 The next port of call is back in the town, where other members of the Ration Platoon will be busy collecting the day's fresh fruit and vegetable order. 
 The driver pulls up outside a small, somewhat dilapidated shop in the back streets. 
 A Turkish two-and-a-half-ton truck from the Host Nation Support Unit is parked outside, and several members of the Company, assisted by an Italian and a German soldier, are busy loading the truck with all manner of fresh produce. 
 In the door of the shop stands the owner, with the Company's Ration  Warrant Officer conducting individual qualitative and quantitative checks on what is being loaded on to the vehicle. 
 A break is taken, instantly chi  appears and the visitors are presented with an enormous banana, a great delicacy in this region. 
 Pleasantries are exchanged; seemingly all is well; however, the quality of oranges is rather poor today, and nectarines will have to be issued in lieu! 
 Elsewhere in the town other RAOC victuallers from the Ration Platoon are collecting the order for dry goods and dairy products. 
 The next port of call, however, is the Petroleum Platoon, who are operating a Bulk Fuel Installation adjacent to the main road leading to Istanbul. 
 The platoon have constructed the fuel farm and are currently receiving a bulk inload from Petrofisi, the main Turkish fuel supplier. 
 The large rubber pillow tanks lie on rubber sheeting within earth walls, dug to the Platoon Commander's specification by a local contractor. 
 A wide assortment of fuel tankers is parked in the area: German and British-Unit Bulk Refuellers, enormous American tankers, an Italian kerosene tanker and two distinctive red and white Petrofisi tankers. 
 Soldiers from all eight NATO nations participating in the exercise are hard at work operating pumping equipment, dispensing fuel to unit refuellers, receiving fuel from the PetroFisi tankers into the pillow tanks, and refuelling an assortment of military vehicles from a kerbside facility. 
 Nearby a specially-trained RAOC Petroleum Operator is testing the specification of the fuel being delivered. 
 His portable laboratory is set up in a small tent which is unbearably hot, and could well do without the added heat from his bunsen burner. 
 Meanwhile other members of the platoon work under the watchful eye of the Royal Engineer Petroleum Fitter Corporal, Who is struggling to keep the fuel pumps running despite the dust and searing heat. 
 A message arrives at the Platoon Command Post requesting fire-fighting assistance; it transpires that a Turkish vehicle carrying British ammunition has overturn and that fuel is leaking from the ruptured fuel tank. 
 The Platoon Sergeant loads the necessary extinguishers and fire-fighting equipment into the back of a vehicle and they speed off The accident has occurred a few hundred metres from the Turkish depot in which ammunition is stored for the Force. 
 The Sergeant Ammunition Technician RAOC working in the depot was first on the scene, and managed to evacuate the driver and passenger of the vehicle by German Fluey helicopter to the AMF(L) Italian Field Hospital. 
 It transpired later that neither was seriously injured. 
 The Asiz  were already at the scene of the accident, and the arrival of the company's interpreter did much to help communication between the Asiz,  the local fire brigade and the British Sergeant. 
 He managed to move most of the ammunition away from the fuel but some would only be accessible When the vehicle was righted by the recovery section from the AMF(L) Workshop. 
 With the situation well under control it is time to return to the Company HQ. 
 Over a lunch of cold meat salad, bread from the RAOC mobile field bakery and fresh fruit, in the communal dining tent the Company Commander hears how a member of the Stores Platoon spent most of the morning trying to purchase Bedford truck spares. 
 The Turks are particularly skilled at copying all manner of goods, and the young RAOC Supply Specialist Corporal visited six  Bedford suppliers in the local town, and drank at least a gallon of cif , before he was satisfied that he was buying genuine Bedford parts! 
 Meal times provide a marvellous forum for stories, some wildly exaggerated, others somewhat embarrassing. 
 It seems that another Lance-Corporal from the Stores Platoon, responsible for running the Force laundry contract, somehow managed to get all his personal laundry starched and pressed. 
 The perk backfired, however, for when he collected his bundle it was so heavily starched he could not break into either his trouser legs or jacket sleeves! 
 Language, it would seem, is no barrier to soldiers' stories, for when this little gem emerged the Italians, Belgians and Germans in the dining tent erupted in fits of laughter along with their British workmates.  
 A post-lunch cup of coffee in the Command Post is interrupted by an air-raid warning and an increase in the threat of chemical attack. 
 After one hour in NBC (nuclear, bacteriological and chemical) protective clothing and respirator, life gets extremely uncomfortable. 
 The NBC suit is definitely not designed for wear in hot climates; the outcome of this episode is an attack by Belgian F-16s, Which results in several simulated casualties. 
 These events hamper the breakdown and issue of fresh and combat rations to the Force, and the Bath Unit is prepared in case it is necessary to deal with decontamination. 
 Clearance patrols are mounted to ensure that our area is clear of the enemy. 
 After dinner it is time to visit the bakers, hard at work in the mobile field bakery. 
 The heat inside the oven and preparation containers is almost unbearable, and yet the bakers survive shifts of twelve hours at a time. 
 In Norway in winter the smell of freshly baked bread, and the warmth from the containers, are great attractions, and visitors seem to congregate around the bakery like bees around a honey pot. 
 Not so in Turkey, where bakers can lose several pounds in weight during each shift. 
 As night comes the temperature drops slightly, bringing a little respite. 
 Another day over, typical of many others for the AMF(L) Supply Company RAOC on exercise in support of the multinational Force. 
 Time to reflect that the next deployment is to Denmark in the autumn, then Norway in winter, before the delights of northern Italy in spring. 
 However, there are a further two weeks in Turkey yet, time to visit the Blue Mosque in Istanbul, haggle for genuine Turkish carpets in the Grand Bazaar and take part in what promises to be an emotional but fascinating tour of the Gallipoli Battlefields.  
 Napoleon is meant to have said that an army marches on its stomach. 
 Bread forms the basis of the daily diet and the AMF makes its own 
 The Royal Army Medical Corps: a Day in the Life of 3 Armoured field Ambulance BAOR 
 Men as well as equipment have to be &bquo;repaired&equo; in battle. 
 This is the task of the men of the Royal Army Medical Corps. 
 Here we see them training for that role. 
 There was a hollow empty echo as the Quartermaster slammed the door of the 3rd Armoured Field Ambulance regimental headquarters. 
 Almost everybody was away. 
 He went out of the gate, wondering what the rest of the unit had been doing. 
 It was just another day in the life of 3rd Armoured Field Ambulance. 
 A Squadron were on a training exercise in Vogelsang, B Squadron were providing the medical support to the Nijmegen Marches in Holland, and Private Johnson was on an individual medical attachment to BATUS (the British Army Training Unit Suffield) in Canada. 
 The Vogelsang Training Centre is an impressive facility. 
 Formerly it was a prestige camp designed for the cream of the Hitler Youth. 
 In those days Vogelsang was a type of Butlins for Brownshirts. 
 Nowadays it is maintained as a NATO Training Centre. 
 Literally translated, Vogelsang  means &bquo;bird song&equo;, but it was some time before the dawn chorus when the Squadron Sergeant Major bawled out the orders for reveille. 
 As a young private reluctantly eased himself out of his sleeping bag, he was heard to say, &bquo;I thought there was only one 5.30 in the day, and that is after tea.&equo; 
 At 0600 hours, A Squadron was on parade in PT kit. 
 Some individuals looked far from the Army image of the lean, mean fighting machine. 
 Even so, an exciting timed race around the challenging assault course on the hill produced some impressive performances. 
 This invigorating start to the day ended with a cold shower, and by 0730 a substantial breakfast had been polished off. 
 The appetite of the British soldier is enormous, neither a rasher of bacon nor a crumb of bread was left to feed the birds. 
 A Squadron had been divided into sections for the first period of their military training. 
 Privates scampered around trying to locate missing items of personal kit, NCOs were supervising the application of camouflage cream on the faces of section personnel, and squadron officers were discussing the final plans for the training. 
 Basic infantry tactics were taught by guest instructors invited to join the Squadron from the Royal Scots (The Royal Regiment), the Royal Regiment of Fusiliers, and the Queen's Lancashire Regiment. 
 By the end of the first lesson some medics seemed so confused that they could not explain the difference between an arrowhead formation and a reef knot.  
 Everyone seems to enjoy loud bangs, so during a lesson on trip flares attention was riveted on the NCO teaching the correct precautions against triggering a trip wire. 
 Attention changed to hilarity when the unfortunate NCO instructor accidentally set off one of his own trip flares. 
 Later, a container of tea punctuated the morning training. 
 No one has ever discovered the secret recipe for army tea. 
 The second half of the morning was devoted to first-aid training. 
 Cries of anguish were heard from the medical instructor, who was beginning to despair after seeing his practice resuscitation doll murdered by an overenthusiastic driver attempting to learn the principles of expired air resuscitation. 
 After lunch, chemical survival skills were taught, each section spending time in turn in the tiny brick hut known as the &bquo;gas chamber&equo;. 
 On the firing ranges, a more complicated event was taking place. 
 Having completed the very demanding annual Personal Weapons Test, each section member was required to run up a plank of wood to a window-frame, shoot at a target on the other side of the window, and then throw himself six feet down into a simulated building interior. 
 After a theatrical demonstration by the instructor, everyone managed to perform this procedure satisfactorily, except for a young Second lieutenant medical student, who landed badly and broke his ankle. 
 The young officer was told to stop complaining, pick up his weapon and complete the course. 
 Eventually his complaints were taken seriously, and the first-aid training module was put into practice three days ahead of schedule. 
 His leg was splinted, and thereupon he experienced life in a military hospital from the casualty's viewpoint. 
 As the sun went down over the trees, everyone in the squadron had enjoyed a hard day's military training and, after a good dinner and some well-deserved beers, they were very happy and were looking forward to the challenges of the next day. 
 Compared with Vogelsang, reveille in Nijmegen was altogether more civilised. 
 ft was already 0900 hours on the first day of the Nijmegen Marches when B Squadron crawled out of their sacks and drifted towards the ablutions. 
  They had been set up in the Heumensoord Camp for several days, but today an air of excitement pervaded the squadron. 
 Had all the training and preparation been enough, they wondered? 
 Today would be the big test. 
 The Nijmegen Marches are an annual high-profile event in which 33,000 people, from all over the world, march twenty-six miles per day for four consecutive days. 
 3rd Armoured Field Ambulance were tasked to provide medical support to the British military contingent, Which consisted of 1,500 servicemen and servicewomen from the Army and the Royal Air Force. 
 The main British medical facility, manned by B Squadron, consisted of a very large plastic tent supplied by the Dutch authorities. 
 This was adapted by adding on a number of field ambulance tents, to provide a reception and documentation area and a huge waiting bay with 200 spaces available for crippled marchers. 
 A long red carpet ran the entire length of the complex, adding a touch of regal splendour to the facility. 
 The marchers had hit the road before 0500 hours, and by midday they were limping back to Heumensoord, having achieved success on day one. 
 Success at Nijmegen is measured by the ability to complete the four days as a team. 
 Speed is irrelevant, and all teams are advised to take it slowly. 
 There are three rest areas along the route, and B Squadron detached a section of medics to each of these areas. 
 The sections had been hard at work since 0600 hours, and they had been very successful at keeping all the teams on the road. 
 Back at Heumensoord the first casualties arrived. 
 &bquo;It's only a small blister,&equo; said one stoic sergeant from the RAF Regiment. 
 However, examination of his foot showed that he had lost one-third of the skin from his heel. 
 The sergeant hobbled along the red carpet in his flip-flops and paused alongside a line of footpaths containing a bright purple solution and cubes of ice. 
 &bquo;Take a seat and put your feet into that,&equo; said a sympathetic medic. 
 The sergeant sat down, placed his feet into the ice-cold potassium permanganate solution and heaved a euphoric sigh of relief. 
 After a few minutes, he was led into the &bquo;blister bunker&equo; for some restorative treatment. 
 The tinc benz and zinc oxide plaster treatment is the cornerstone of blister therapy; however, the sergeant's feet were so damaged that a layer of &bquo;moleskin' had to be applied. 
 Now a new man, the sergeant marched out gratefully, ready for another day. 
 By 1500 hours the atmosphere in the British Medical Facility was frenetic. 
 The waiting area was overflowing, with more than 200 marchers anxiously expecting treatment. 
 Two NCO drivers from the Field Ambulance were passing through the assembled ranks selling chocolates, buns and cold drinks. 
 All the young medics worked tirelessly in the blister bunker. 
 &bquo;This may sting a bit, but it's good stuff,&equo; said a new young private reassuringly, as he aimed a can of tinc benz spray at the foot of a young blonde WRAC girl. 
 It was his first visit to Nijmegen and, although he had got his CMT 3 qualification, he had spent most of his two months at 3rd Armoured Field Ambulance checking equipment, putting up tents and doing guard duties. 
 Now he was doing the job he was trained for, treating real patients. 
 At about 1600 hours an ambulance arrived outside the facility, its blue light flashing. 
 The reception staff hurried out to meet it. 
 It had been a very hot day and this was the first heat-stroke casualty. 
 The unfortunate victim was wheeled  directly into the major treatment area, where he was examined by the duty medical officer. 
 He was swabbed with spirit and covered with a cold wet sheet. 
 He was very confused, his body temperature was high and he was dehydrated. 
 An intravenous infusion was started. 
 On the other side of the major treatment bay was the field dental chair. 
 A Canadian soldier with toothache was receiving expert treatment from the Field Ambulance dentist. 
 Being the only military dentist in Nijmegen, he had willingly offered his service to all the assembled nationalities in Heumensoord camp. 
 In another area of the medical facility, the physiotherapy officer was hard at work; a deluge of strained joints, aching muscles and swollen feet were receiving very professional treatment with ice and ultrasound. 
 Some of the marchers were apprehensive about this very hi-tech physiotherapy department. 
 &bquo;Does acupuncture hurt?&equo; asked one marcher, who had his eyes firmly set on a placard on the other wall which read: 
 &bquo;PAIN IS OUR PLEASURE AGONY IS OUR AIM&equo; 
 It's OK, doc, I'll just take an aspirin,&equo; said another. 
 The evening shift of medics took over from their exhausted colleagues at 1800 hours. 
 The work went on until the last marcher had been patched up. 
 It was almost 2215, and 300 cases had been treated on the first day. 
 Would they survive another three days of marching? 
 That didn't bear thinking about. 
 It was time to join the Zommerfest in town. 
 Every year, the Nijmegen Marches are accompanied by a carnival in the town. 
 A band plays at every street corner, crowds drift from bar to beer stand to disco and back to bar. 
 The atmosphere is relaxed and friendly as the marchers and their supporters wind down after a hard day. 
 The field ambulance minibus ran the boys down into town, and brought them back to camp in hourly shuttles until 0300 hours. 
 &bquo;That was a great day,&equo; said a happy but exhausted lance-corporal, &bquo;and look what i've got.&equo; 
 With great pride he brandished a collection of Russian military insignia and cap badges, which he had swapped with an English-speaking cadet in the Soviet Army marching team. 
 Next year it would be different; A Squadron would be supporting the marches and B Squadron would be training at Vogelsang.  
 Urban combat creates particularly difficult conditions for the removal of a casualty. 
 Here 20 Field Ambulance practise their technique at Voselsang 
 A medical orderly and a nurse patch up a competitor's foot during a break in the Nijmegen Marches 
 ACE Mobile Force Infantry Battalion: Royal Regiment of Fusiliers 
 Here we see the Royal Regiment of Fusiliers operating on the other flank of NATO with the ACE Mobile Force 
 A single day is not long enough to illustrate fully the roles played, or the variety of jobs undertaken by the UK Infantry Battalion of the Allied Command Europe Mobile Force (Land) &mdash; AMF(L). 
 However, 30 June 1989 saw the Battalion deployed on its biennial AMF(L) exercise to Denmark, hard at work alongside the other armies that make up the AMF(L). 
 The AMF(L) was formed in 1960 when it was decided by NATO that a show of unity amongst its members was necessary in times of international tension. 
 It was felt that units from different countries should be brought together to form a force of brigade size (about 5,000 men), operating together under the NATO banner. 
 The reason was that there were certain areas of Europe which were protected by the forces of only one NATO nation, and consequently these were particularly vulnerable to aggression. 
 In the north, this meant Norway and Denmark, and in the south Italy, Greece and Turkey. 
 It was believed that sending a NATO force to any of these areas would deter any potential aggressor from taking action. 
 Eight NATO countries contribute to the AMF(L): Belgium, Canada, West Germany, Italy, Luxemburg, the Netherlands, the United Kingdom, and the United States of America. 
 There are Land (AMF(L)) and Air (AMF(A)) Forces. 
 Luxemburg does not contribute to the Air component, but all the others contribute in some way to both. 
 The British Army contingent includes infantry, artillery, armour, signals, and logistic units. 
 The 2nd Battalion, Royal Regiment of Fusiliers, was then the infantry battalion in the ACE Mobile Force, and had been in that role since May 1987. 
 Its main commitment is to the north, and thus every winter the battalion trains in Norway in Arctic Warfare. 
 Denmark is their other northern commitment, and it is there that 2 RRP found itself on 30 June 1989. 
 The first part of any AMF(L) exercise is What is called &bquo;deterrent operations&equo;. 
 It is considered a vital part of the mission of the AMF(L) to make an outward display of friendliness towards the population and above all to display unity within the Force itself. 
 This involves vehicle and foot patrols, public displays, and meeting local dignitaries as well as visiting places of work and schools. 
 Each nation provides a company of men for this task, known as Key Company. 
 C Company were the UK Key Company for Exercise Avenue Express, and were based in the coastal town of Hofoaek, fifty kilometres west of Copenhagen. 
 30 June started early for those men of C Company who were out on patrol. 
 The first vehicle patrols were out at 0600 hours, so reveille was at 0430  hours. 
 Before setting off they have to be briefed by the Intelligence Section on their tasks for the day, and the patrol leader has to report to the Operations Room for a study of his route. 
 At 0600 the first patrol of eight men, led by Lieutenant Roger Thompson, rolled out of Hofoaek Barracks in their two Land-Rovers on the start of their 270 kilometre round trip. 
 They had been briefed to report in on their mobile telephone at certain checkpoints en route, and to inform the Ops Room of any suspicious incidents, but their main task was to stop and talk to locals, in order to make their presence known in as friendly a way as possible. 
 It should be added that for the sake of building up a realistic scenario for the exercise, incidents involving &bquo;enemy&equo; forces are interjected. 
 The patrols are expected to react to these, and an umpire accompanies them to see that there is fair play. 
 The vehicles were fired upon by two men in civilian clothes as they pulled up to a T-junction. 
 Shots were returned, but the gunmen escaped to a nearby copse. 
 The 2 RRP patrol gave chase, but a white car pulled away before they could reach them. 
 The vehicle details were taken down and reported back to Holbaek immediately. 
 The umpire was pleased with the reaction, but  &bquo;awarded&equo; the driver of the first Land-Rover a gunshot wound to the leg and put his vehicle out of action. 
 This delayed the Whole patrol for two hours whilst the unfortunate driver was flown to the Field Hospital in a Gazelle helicopter which was called out to the scene, and a REME team drove out to repair the Land-Rover. 
 By now the remaining three patrols from C Company were all reporting similar incidents. 
 A &bquo;landmine&equo; destroyed one vehicle, a patrol was ambushed as they spoke to some locals, and a foreign parachute and map were discovered on a beach after a tip-off. 
 All did not go against the Key Company, however; prisoners were taken at some of the incidents, some carrying vital information. 
 The Ops Room telephone rang continuously, and the staff were kept busy handling reports as well as keeping HQ AMF(L) informed as to what was going on. 
 The same day an early start was made by those men of A Company and Fire Support Company Who were involved in the Parade and Equipment Display at Vaerlose Airfield near Copenhagen. 
 At 0430 they left their tented bases in the south of Zealand, to travel north. 
 The early start enabled A Company to carry  out some drill and take part in the parade rehearsal with the other AMF(L) units. 
 Similarly, Fire Support Company had to set up their display of mortars, anti-tank missiles and Scimitar tracked recce vehicles. 
 An integral part of deterrent operations, the parade and display were part of an open day for the public, designed to show the Danes who and what had flown into their country to exercise for two weeks. 
 The Regimental Band led the parade, supported by their Italian counterparts. 
 On a blazing hot day, in front of 15,000 people, Major-General Carstens, the German Commander of AMF(L), made a speech stressing the importance of AMF(L) operations. 
 Another event of 30 June which typifies life in the AMF(L) was the NATO Challenge Cup. 
 This is a competition held during every exercise, for which all the nations enter teams. 
 It involves an arduous ten kilometre run preceded by a long assault course, against the clock, finishing with a shoot on the firing range. 
 The teams of twenty-six men run individually, and points are awarded for time and accuracy of shooting. 
 With temperatures reaching 80&dollar;degree; F, several teams dropped men through heat exhaustion, but the Germans (263 Parachute Battalion) managed a very quick time and dropped only three shots on the range. 
 The A Company team, led by Second Lieutenant Philip Alexander, came in a minute slower but scored maximum points with their shooting and just clinched the title. 
 After both B and C Company put in similar performances the Cup was firmly in British hands for the first time. 
 But the rivalry was friendly enough for all teams to congratulate each other on their performances.  
 In order to improve the efficiency of the Force, most units take part in &bquo;cross training&equo; during deterrent operations. 
 There are shooting days When soldiers fire the rifles and machine-guns of their counterparts, and a live-firing mortar and artillery exercise is held. 
 In reality, deterrent operations might last for weeks or even months, but the AMF(L) must exercise as a fighting force if it is to prove its worth. 
 On 30 June those men not involved in the parade, display or Challenge Cup were training with the Canadians, Germans and Danes. 
 A platoon from B Company were having their own shooting competition with the Canadians and Germans. 
 The Germans this time proved to be the better shots, but were very impressed with the new British SA-80 rife and its optic sight. 
 At the same time a platoon from A Company were finishing their week attached to the 1st Battalion the Danish Life Regiment, during which time they were thundering over training areas in the Danish Ml 13 Armoured Personnel Carrier. 
 30 June was a busy day for the battalion, but typical for an AMF (L) exercise. 
 In a Europe that is drawing ever closer together, 2 RRF were doing their bit.   
 Men of the B Company 2 RRF Challenge Cup team approach the end of the March and Shoot competition 
 Fusilier John Fergus, B Company, having completed the NATO Challenge Cup 
 A Challenger Tank on exercise with the AMF. 
 Notice the 120mm gun remains stabilised in the horizontal position whatever the angle of the chassis of the tank 
 (Left to right) Fusilier Wilkes, Thompson and Morris, Lance-Corporals Evans and Parker preparing to spend the day training with German troops 
 Building Defects and their Treatment 
 Decay and Repair of Timber 
 It is mainly rot or insect attack which affects the serviceability of timber structures. 
 When an attack is found, it is advisable to obtain the view of a specialist who will be able to identify the type of decay and advise on the treatment of the timber, including designating any parts that should be removed. 
 There fungal decay is found, this expert should specify the cause and suggest measures for its elimination. 
 Clearly, the existence of timber decay is likely to be related to other shortcomings in the condition of the building and these faults may require rectification in addition to treatment of the timber. 
 Problems may have been built into the original design through the inadequate protection of timber from ground moisture, lack of ventilation or roof-slopes which were insufficiently steep to drain away all rainwater. 
 Equally, defects may be owed to some earlier modification of the original arrangement or construction and these changes need to be identified and corrected. 
 This circumstance could include the bridging of an original dpc by &bquo;remedial&equo; rendering applied over insufficiently weather-tight brickwork. 
 More probably, decay and deterioration of materials and installations is the result of lack of maintenance, the results of which may include blocked or broken rainwater drains, displaced roof tiles or peeling paint finishes, all of which can lead to timber decay. 
 Rot in Timber 
 Timber decay which is not owed to insect action is normally the result of fungal attack. 
 It aids understanding of these phenomena to recognise that the function of all timber pests is to break down and convert dead trees into soil, allowing new trees unimpeded growth. 
 The fact that the dead wood has been shaped for use as a building material is of no consequence to a fungus or a beetle. 
 The fungi are parasitical and can only live by feeding on organic matter, including wood and leaves. 
 In contrast to most plants, they breathe in oxygen and give out carbon dioxide. 
 All fungi require about 20 per cent moisture content in the host wood to germinate and although in new buildings the moisture content of the timber may be as high as 18 per cent, this is soon reduced to about 12&ndash;14 per cent by heating and ventilation of the enclosed spaces. 
 Therefore, in a sound, dry building there is no need to fear fungal attack. 
 The most serious and devastating wood fundus and the species most frequently found in old building is dry rot or Serpula lachrymans . 
 Having established itself in damp timber, this infection can spread to dry wood and brickwork. 
 Its life-cycle starts with a spore, of which there are countless millions in the atmosphere. 
 These spores are highly resistant tot extremes of heat and humidity and are very long-lived. 
 A spore which lands on wood with a moisture content of 20&ndash;25 per cent in a still and stuffy atmosphere where the temperature is between 7&deg; and 27&dollar;C (44&dollar; and 80&dollar;F) can germinate and then throw out hollow strands known as hyphae. 
 These initially hair-like fibres seek out and feed off the cellulose in the wood which is digested by the fungus to leave a dry, desiccated and fragile shell of wood-fibre or lignin which, in the absence of the cementitious cellulose, cannot continue to perform any structural role required of the timber. 
 Having drawn the cellulose from one section of the wood, the hyphae reach on to adjacent sections of timber to continue the process, while the strands of the initial attack unite into an equally fast-spreading cotton-wool-like growth known as mycelium. 
 In the later stages of an attack, strands called rhizomorphs develop from the mycelium to convey moisture from the decomposing wood to sound timber many feet away, weeping &bquo;tears&equo; on to it until it, too, is subjugated and ripe for attack. 
 When this action is well established, the fungus will produce a sporophore, or fruiting body, which produces millions of spores. 
 The sporophore is at first a whitish-grey, unpleasant-looking fleshy growth and gradually becomes more leathery and dewy. 
 It bursts at internals to release into the atmosphere an enormous number of rusty-red spores which are carried on the breeze to germinate in distant damp timber, starting the process afresh. 
 Dry rot exhibits an almost uncanny knowledge of the presence of timber and is able to thrust through brickwork mortar joints and to travel across brickwork behind plaster over great distances in its search for fresh food. 
 In this respect, it is quite capable of spreading from one building to another through a thick party wall. 
 Evidence of the existence of dry rot may be found in a musty smell pervading a suspect space; the presence of a whitish cotton-wool-like fungal growth on timber; cracking and bulging of joinery mouldings such as skirtings and door linings owed to the shrinkage of hidden fixing timber which has been attacked by the fungus; and readily apparent ravaged timber showing deep cracks across the grain, giving a &bquo;cubed&equo; appearance. 
 Once dry rot has been discovered, the only remedy is extermination of the fungus together with the rectification of the unhealthy conditions which invited the attack. 
 The fungus has no heart nor &bquo;Achilles&equo; heal and unless it is completely destroyed to its limits, it will develop fresh strength and start again to devour the timberwork. 
 There are two possible strategies for the treatment of an attack of dry rot. 
 The building owner may either employ a builder to carry out the work or opening up and eradication, or he may call in one of the numerous specialist firms to deal with the attack. 
 If a builder is entrusted with the work, it must be ensured through a full briefing and careful supervision that only conscientious, knowledgeable and skilled tradesmen are employed who are able to give rational advice on the proper nature and extent of the remedial treatment if the initial assessment of the degree of damage proves to be inaccurate. 
 The advantage of employing a specialist firm is that its tradesmen are more likely to be well trained and experienced in this field of building preservation, with a thorough and successful job being a more certain result. 
 However, it should be clear that any firm which issues a guarantee must inevitably err on the side of over-zealousness, which will add to expense. 
 The first step in eradicating dry rot is to find the heart of the outbreak and to trace its extent with great care and thoroughness. 
 Each branch of the fungus must be traced from its source to the growing tip, and finishes should be opened up to reveal timber 1/2m (1&ndash;1/2ft) beyond the affected material. 
 Floorboards, plaster, timber trim, including architraves and skirting boards, and other finishes (including apparently impenetrable tiling) must be removed from timber and masonry if the slightest suspicion exists that the fungus has reached beneath or behind them. 
 When the full extent of the attack is known, treatment can begin. 
 If fruiting bodies are present, these should be treated with fungicide to prevent the spread of air-borne spores. 
 Then all infected timber is cut out so that all affected wood, including apparently sound wood up to 1/2m (1&ndash;1/2ft) away from the visible extremities of the attack, is removed. 
 Where important structural timbers are infected but have not been weakened by the fungus, it may be practical to treat them with fungicide to retain them. 
 All fungus-infected timber which has been removed should be burned immediately together with any shavings or sawdust from the infected area. 
 Brickwork into which the mycelium has spread and any masonry which adjoins an outbreak must be similarly poisoned. 
 If a structural wall is too thick to absorb the fungicide to its core, it must be drilled with a series of holes into which the liquid is injected in order to permeate the entire thickness. 
 Wherever possible, walls should be treated from both sides. 
 Leading gutters and roofs, defective rainwater downpipes, mounding of adjacent soil which bridges the dpc and all other sources of dampness must be removed. 
 Poorly ventilated and stagnant spaces must be opened up to a constant current of air by the introduction of new ventilation openings as even a vigorous attack of dry rot can be arrested (but not reduced) by exposure to fresh air. 
 New timbers inserted as replacements should be thoroughly treated from every face against infection. 
 Common chemical treatments include pressure impregnation with copper, chrome or arsenic salts. 
 These are industrial processes carried out only to order unless the use of &bquo;treated&equo; timber in the rebuilding is specified from the outset. 
 The chemicals are water-borne and the timber takes a long time to dry out. 
 Even though these treatments drive the chemicals into the timber to a much greater depth than surface application by spray or brush, the wood may not be completely impregnated, particularly in the heartwood, so that notches and ends cut on site after treatment must be dipped in preservative or touched up with a brush. 
 If this is not done, the protection is bypassed. 
 Other forms of fungal decay of timber in buildings are relatively unimportant because they are not able to spread to sound wood. 
 However, they do indicate the existence of unhealthy conditions in which more serious trouble could develop. 
 As this observation suggests, combined or separate attacks from dry rot and other less voracious fungi are common in neglected and decaying buildings. 
 These minor fungi are generally termed wet rot. 
 Coniophora cerebella , or the cellar fungus, is the most common. 
 It cannot live on timber with a moisture content of less than 25 per cent and thus is usually found in situations too damp for dry rot. 
 The fungus can be identified by its fine dark brown or black strands and its green and leathery fruiting body. 
 A paper-thin shell of sound wood is left on the surface of the infected timber which shows deep cracks along the grain but rarely across it as may result from dry rot. 
 Eradication of the less serious fungi is usually a simple matter of cutting out and burning the infected timber. 
 However, it is wise to treat the area with fungicide as a precaution against any subsequent outbreak of dry rot which could be encouraged as the construction dries out. 
 Insect Action on Timber 
 The destructive action of beetles on timber is rarely as serious as fungal attack because an infected section is only weakened by the combined cross-sectional area of the tunnels it contains &mdash; the strength of the surrounding wood remains unimpaired. 
 Beetle attack which has ceased requires little attention except for any necessary repairs to the damaged timbers. 
 In contrast, an active attack should not be left unattended and can be identified by the clean appearance of the &bquo;flight holes&equo; and the little patches and piles of fresh bore dust which fall from them. 
 The main insect enemies of timber in buildings are the death-watch beetle and the common furniture beetle and the two are often found together. 
 It is at the larva stage of their development when boring and feeding of the grubs takes place that the damage is caused because the adult beetles do not eat and they live only for a short time. 
 The different species can be identified by the different sizes of their flight holes and sometimes by the type of wood attacked. 
 In early summer, the beetles themselves may also be found. 
 The death-watch beetle has a life cycle of three to ten years depending upon the nature of the timber it inhabits. 
 It lays its eggs in any cracks or crevices in suitable timber &mdash; hardwood is preferred, particularly the outer and softer layers of sapwood. 
 Timber which has already been affected by fungus or decay offers a special attraction. 
 The attack is usually concentrated in damp and more easily edible wood such as built-in bonding timbers, the eaves ends of rafters and the vearing ends of beams and trusses. 
 After the grubs have eaten extensive &bquo;galleries&equo; in the wood over a period of years, with the resultant dust being emitted in bun-shaped pellets, the larva enters a pupal stage lasting three to six weeks and emerges as a fully grown beetle. 
 It remains in its pupal chamber until the following spring and emerges in April, May or June to seek a mate. 
 It is at this time that the characteristic tapping sound which gives the beetle its name can be heard. 
 The flight holes are about 3mm (1/8in) in diameter. 
 An attack may die out if the timber becomes hard and unpalatable to the beetle with age and correct maintenance. 
 The common furniture beetle can be found in both hardwood and softwood, chiefly in the sapwood from close to the bark. 
 Therefore, it is a more serious pest in the lighter construction adopted in post-medieval buildings where the proportion of sapwood is high. 
 Although, as is apparent in &bquo;woodworm&equo; damage to furniture, flight holes frequently appear in polished surfaces, the eggs are laid in cracks, joints and unvarnished recesses. 
 They hatch out in 3&ndash;4 weeks and the larvae bore into the wood. 
 After a period of 12&ndash;36 months, the last 2&ndash;3 weeks of which are spent in a pupal stage near the surface, the grub becomes a fully grown beetle. 
 It immediately finds its way to the surface and emerges to mate in the months of June, July or August. 
 The flight holes of the furniture beetle are smaller than those of the death-watch beetle and are about 1.5mm (1/16in) in diameter. 
 Wet or damaged timber is the appetising food for the insect but apparently sound wood may be equally badly afflicted. 
 The house longhorn beetle is another insect pest which seems to be confined to parts of Hampshire and south-west Surrey. 
 It is found mainly in timbers less than fifty years old and is a much larger insect than the furniture beetle. 
 Its larvae bore voraciously to and fro along the grain of the wood, generally under a thin, intact surface. 
 The beetle emerges in June or August via a few and scattered flight holes about 6&ndash;12mm (1/4&ndash;1/2in) long which inadequately represent the true extent of the unseen damage. 
 Only fresh, sound wood is affected. 
 As applies in the treatment of fungal attack, in the eradication of insect pests it is necessary to identify the unhealthy conditions which have invited the attack, and to cure them at source. 
 Dampness and lack of ventilation are as welcoming to insects as they are to wood fungi and once these conditions are rectified the beetles will feel less inclined to stay. 
 All local dust, dirt and rubbish should be cleared away, partly to remove conditions congenial to the beetles but also to facilitate treatment with insecticide. 
 The full extent of the attack must be discovered in order to assess its severity. 
 It is important to differentiate between timbers which have been so badly eaten that their strength has been reduced, necessitating replacement, and those which, though damaged, still contain enough sound wood to continue their original jobs. 
 Timber which is so severely honeycombed that it is virtually useless &mdash; termed &bquo;frass&equo; &mdash; is likely to coincide with the sapwood content of structural timber. 
 Thus some affected beams which are riddled with holes and appear to be useless, may be found, on investigation, to contain solid heartwood quite adequate to perform their structural roles. 
 The most extensive and expensive part of the work in some cases is the initial removal of wholly infested wood and beetle-riddled frass. 
 The latter can be removed by scraping or wire-brushing. 
 All infested wood must be cleared away and burnt and related constructional cavities must be cleaned out carefully. 
 When the sound timber is clean and readily accessible it can be treated with insecticide. 
 The methods of application are brushing, spraying and injection. 
 The technique in brush application should be to spread the liquid generously over the surface and onto cracks. 
 Spraying is carried out with a coarse spray at low pressure. 
 Where the bearings of timbers are inaccessible, it may be necessary to drill deep holes for saturation of the buried beams' ends by injection. 
 Because flight holes connect with sub-surface galleries bored by the insects, injection into these cavities is also a good means of impregnating hidden material with insecticide. 
 Generally, sound timbers, such as wallplates and lintels which are built into masonry and which show only one or two surfaces to the building interior, may be treated by coating their exposed faces with a thick &bquo;mayonnaise&equo; preservative paste. 
 The success of the treatment depends very much on the skill and intelligence of the operatives and careful supervision to ensure that attention is given to the full extent of affected areas. 
 Plainly, this process is facilitated if the working areas are readily accessible, well lit and well ventilated. 
 Any new timber which is introduced into the treated areas in repair or replacement work should also be treated with preservative containing an insecticide. 
 In practice, the proprietary liquids which are used in the pressure-vacuum impregnation of timber against fungal attack also contain insecticides and effectively identical products are available through builders' merchants and DIY outlets for brush and spray application on site. 
 In-situ Repair of Timber 
 In addition to rot and insect attack which may be regarded as defects intrinsic to timber, problems also arise from the way timber elements of traditional buildings were assembled. 
 Frequent use was made of the bressummer arrangement described in the preceding chapter for the introduction of large openings, such as shopfronts, into pre-existing buildings. 
 Many such heavy timber beams supporting joists of the first floor were inserted into existing buildings in such a way that their ends may have had an inadequate bearing on to slender timber &bquo;storey posts&equo; installed adjacent to the party walls. 
 Intermediate storey posts were sometimes added to support these bressummers and the wall above. 
 Problems often develop where bressummers and storey posts were installed in an existing building because of progressive sagging of the timber as well as the crushing effect of the superincumbent masonry and the onset of rot. 
 In later Victorian buildings, iron beams and columns replaces timber in this arrangement. 
 Where these members were built into the original construction, such problems would be less likely, but the causes of defects and deterioration associated with bressummers should be identified, particularly if it is the intention to increase loads upon these elements. 
 Conspicuous distortion of a broad opening spanned by a bressummer may call for the insertion of diagonal steel bracing, brick piers to stiffen flank walls and new intermediate supports. 
 A more common problem in timber upper floors and suspended ground floors is the rotting of joist-ends above built-in wallplates. 
 When &bquo;untreated&equo; timber (ie, wood which has not been impregnated with preservative) is built into solid walls, it has no protection from dampness in the wall and it is common for joist-ends to be shielded by a skin of brickwork only a half-a-brick thick (Fig 31). 
 Such joist-ends will decay if their moisture content remains over 20 per cent for long periods. 
 Unfortunately, there are usually no signs of an impending problem before structural failure occurs. 
 Moss growth on an external solid wall may suggest that the wall and its built-in joist-ends have been subjected to damp. 
 This condition can be corrected by temporarily propping the floor, cutting out the rotten joist-ends, treating the sound timber to be retained with preservative and restoring support to the joists through a bracket or joist-hangers (Fig 32). 
 The wall-plate, which is likely to be decayed, should also be removed. 
 Where decay has advanced along the joist into the building interior, it may be necessary to splice on a new timber end to the member, carried on a joist-hanger. 
 The length of this splice and the size of the bolt for making the connection depends upon floor span, loading, spacing of joists and distance of the splice from the support, but for a 4m (13ft) span in domestic-type work, with joists at 400mm (16in) centres, the splice would be 610mm (24in) long with two 12mm (1/2in) diameter bolts installed 400mm (16in) apart over 75mm (3in) square toothed-plate connectors. 
 To ensure that the wall retains adequate lateral restraint after the joists have been rehung, stainless steel straps at about 1,200mm (48in) centres should be installed. 
 In some circumstances, it may prove more economical to replace complete joists. 
 Overloaded or lightly structured timber floors are also likely to deflect or sag, producing a dished or sloping floor surface. 
 This condition is worsened by the cutting of notches in the joists to house sub-floor services like heating pipes. 
 Consequently, excessive deflection, or, in extreme cases, collapse, can occur. 
 It is often possible to fill these notches with hardwood wedges. 
 This measure does not correct the existing deflection but it stiffens the floor to imposed load. 
 Where it is not possible to strengthen a sagging floor by the addition of secondary timbers relieving the overloaded joists, it may be feasible to strengthen any integral timber beams by inserting steel flitch plates into slots formed in these members (Fig 33). 
 Alternatively, where access is available, steel strengthening plates can be added to a beam's top and bottom surfaces to form flanges. 
 These two techniques, and the addition of steel side or cross-rods respectively to strengthen individual beams or entire joisted floors at mid-span, all involve the substitution of metal for overstressed wood in the part of the member that is subject to tensile stress. 
 Roof trusses, as well as timber floors, can fail in a variety of ways, and failure by crushing at the joint of the principal rafter with the tie is assisted by any decay which affects this area. 
 As this joint is usually close to the bearing of the truss, it may be possible to repair a truss comprising small timber members with plywood gusset plates (Fig 34). 
 There also exists a range of specialised repair methods which use epoxy resins. 
 These substances are able to permeate and saturate partly decayed timber. 
 On hardening, the resin/timber combination acquires high strength and rigidity more akin to the cured resin than to timber. 
 This material will also bond well to stainless steel rods so that badly decayed timber can be drilled, stitched and glued to achieve higher strengths than the original construction. 
 However, this is a very expensive process which is usually reserved for repairs to failed joints in ancient timber-framed structures where the removal and replacement of individual members is impracticable. 
 Defects in Roof Coverings 
 Where a sloping roof was originally erected to the correct pitch (ie, the roof was not constructed at too shallow a slope, which would cause rain to penetrate its covering of slates or tiles) defects are invariably owed to the deterioration of the roof covering or the breakdown of joints between materials, which in roofs usually means outworn metal valley-gutters, dislodged hip and ridge cappings and deformed or poorly repaired flashings. 
 Slates eventually decay because of their reaction with weak acids formed from sulphur and other atmospheric pollutants dissolved in rainwater. 
 The slates &bquo;exfoliate&equo; and begin to absorb, rather than resist, moisture. 
 Slated urban roofs are likely to have reached this state after about eighty years. 
 The &bquo;grip&equo; of the slate on its fixing nails is not assisted by this reduction in rigidity and dislodged slates seen on old roof-slopes may have slipped because decay has affected the parts of each slate closest to the fixing nails. 
 A more usual reason for slipped slates is corrosion of the original iron fixing mails. 
 The weight of a slate will eventually sever the rusted shanks of iron nails and high winds encourage such dislodged slates to slip further out of place. 
 Where the general condition of a slated roof-slope is good, slipped slates may be resited by extracting the remains of the corroded fixings from beneath the overlapping course with a slater's ripper. 
 The head of a narrow strip of lead, zinc or copper, which will form a clip or &bquo;tingle&equo;, is then fixed to the sliver of batten accessible through the joint exposed by the extracted slate and the slate is slid back into place over this strip and secured by folding the free end of the metal over the lower edge of the slate (Fig 35). 
 This clip fixing of slipped slates is merely an expedient which cannot forever put off the day when the permanent refixing or renewal of the entire roof covering is necessary. 
 There are two forms of sub-slate roof-deck construction favoured by the traditional builders which may store up serious problems for restorers of old buildings once a breach has occurred in the roof covering. 
 The first potentially troublesome arrangement involved the nailing of the slates to timber battens in the conventional way, but these battens were first fixed to boarding or &bquo;sarking&equo; nailed to the top surfaces of the rafters. 
 Even where a bituminous felt layer was laid on top of the boarding, this form of construction is likely to compound problems of rainwater penetration once a gap appears in the roof covering because the water which enters, instead of draining out of the construction at the eaves, settles on the upper edges of the local slate-fixing battens, inducing rot both in them and the boarding. 
 Equally bad from the point of view of damp exclusion in the circumstance of a breach appearing in the roof surface, and even worse in terms of the restrictions it places on the opportunities for salvaging slates in any wholesale reconditioning of the roof covering, is the arrangement in which the slates are nailed directly to boarding, no fixing battens having been incorporated. 
 If this form of construction cannot be identified from an inspection of voids in the roof surface made from the exterior, it may be possible to deduce whether or not it applies by noting the pattern of nails which have penetrated into the roof-space through the boarding. 
 Such an inspection should also help to identify any dampness or rot which has affected the boarding. 
 Where such decay is well advanced, complete replacement of the roof cladding with a boarded, counterbattened and battened construction, including underslating felt and a new slated surface, may be required. 
 Defective tiled roofs can produce problems identical to those posed by ageing slate roofs, but because clay plain tiles are necessarily hung on battens (not every tile is nailed except on very steeply pitched roofs) and it is not possible simply to apply tiles direct to a boarded surface as in the case of a slate covering, the problem of rotting roofing battens and sarking does not arise in connection with tiling. 
 Much more common in tile roofing &mdash; as it was in the cheapest form of slated roof &mdash; was &bquo;open batten&equo; construction in which the tiles are hung on battens fixed directly to the top surfaces of the rafters without any intermediate boarding. 
 It is in snowy weather that owners of buildings roofed in this way most regret this form of construction because wind-blown powdery snow easily enters narrow chinks in the roof surface, and where there is no underslating felt (as applies in most old constructions), the snow settles between the ceiling joists, later melting and saturating ceilings and other internal finishes. 
 Tiles are less durable than slates, but good quality clay plain tiles can easily last for sixty years. 
 Because the majority of tiles are simply hooked on to the battens, it is easier to replace a slipped or broken tile with a new unit than it is to replace a nail-fixed tile. 
 Owing in part to their lower cost, it has become popular in recent years to replace both clay plain tiles and slates with interlocking concrete tiles. 
 This policy can produce further problems. 
 Where roof-spaces are not well ventilated (as occurs when a roof is reclad with a more windproof and watertight construction), the close-textured nature of the concrete tiles which contrasts with the relative porosity of clay tiles may encourage the formation of condensation on their undersides, encouraging dampness and rot in stagnant roof-spaces. 
 More seriously, because the tiles are much heavier than either slates or clay tiles, the simple replacement of one of these traditional coverings with concrete units, where no steps have been taken to strengthen a lightly structured roof, is likely, at best, to result in deflection of the roof surface (sagging of concrete tile replacement roof surfaces is a common sight in older houses). 
 At worst, collapse of the roof structure may result. 
 Such a circumstance is far less likely to arise if defective slating is replaced either with a new natural slate roof or a surface of one of the several types of lightweight synthetic slate that are now obtainable. 
 A common weakness of the joint between materials in roofing results from the replacement of outworn lead flashings with a splayed mortar fillet at the junction of the roof surface with projecting chimney-stack or party-wall-parapet brickwork. 
 Eventual breakdown of the bond between the mortar and the brickwork introduces an open joint which draws in moisture down the back of the small lead or zinc soakers which are incorporated to drain from the roof edge any moisture that penetrated the mortar (Fig 36). 
 The only enduring solution to this problem is the replacement of the mortar fillet and soakers with a carefully installed sheet-lead stepped flashing. 
 Asphalt was often used as a flat-roof surface in older buildings in locations where it was appreciated that a sheet-metal covering would prove unsuitable because of the very large area of roof or where regular foot traffic was anticipated. 
 It was also used as the finish for small or irregularly shaped subsidiary roofs over bays and porches, etc. 
 Where it was used to coat a sloping surface, it is likely that defects will emerge, inviting water penetration, because the material tends to &bquo;creep&equo; under its self-weight. 
 This property is intensified by the action of sunlight on the asphalt. 
 As the material becomes hotter, it regains the capacity to flow which characterised it molten state at the time of its installation. 
 Consequently, splits appear in the surface which will admit water. 
 On flat surfaces this action is minimised by laying a carpet of light-reflective white limestone chippings on the asphalt, but this treatment cannot be extended to sloping sections or to roofs carrying regular foot-traffic. 
 A special solar-reflective white paint may be applied to these panels which will increase the life-span of the surface. 
 One great advantage of asphalt over other forms of sheet roof covering is its tolerance to being &bquo;patched&equo; in situ. 
 Small repairs may be made to a damaged surface by flooding the affected area with molten asphalt after the defective section has been cut out. 
 Eventual physical breakdown of the material is delayed by careful preparation of the substratum and it has always been safer to lay asphalt on concrete roof slabs than on timber boarding. 
 Where a defective asphalt roof on boarding is to be renewed, the level boarded surface must be covered with bituminous felt before the asphalt is applied. 
 The felt acts as a membrane which isolates movement in the boards from the asphalt, the natural elasticity of which may not be sufficient to absorb such movement. 
 Re-use of Metal Structures 
 The successful re-use of an existing iron structure depends on the quality of the original construction and whether it has been subjected to significant alterations. 
 The opportunities for successfully re-using a structure to which it is necessary to make major modifications in order to suit it to its new task are small, even with ironwork of exceptionally good quality. 
 This is because original structures tend to be fairly well matched to the original requirements for load-bearing. 
 Because iron structural members were used in circumstances where great strength was required, it is very unlikely that serious defects, such as could affect timber or masonry before they become unsafe, can arise without causing collapse. 
 However, less significant defects are often readily identified. 
 These include delamination of wrought iron which arises with corrosion, owed to the presence of slag in the material between layers of almost pure iron. 
 Also, it should be noted that there were no satisfactory ways of forming structural connections in cast iron by any processes such as welding, brazing or soldering. 
 If such techniques appear to have been used, the structure should be regarded as suspect, because all reputable Victorian engineers were aware of the risks of making connections by these methods. 
 Where these is no need for a retained iron structure to accept enlarged loads and it is apparent that the metal members are in food condition, not having been subjected to detrimental modifications, the chief consideration in re-using the installation is to achieve an acceptable standard of fire resistance. 
 The building owner must establish whether the structure will provide an acceptable period of fire resistance in its unmodified state or if it can be simply modified to meet mandatory requirements. 
 The performance of cast iron in fire is better than might be expected by those who have some knowledge of the dramatic reaction of steel structures to fire. 
 It is possible for hot iron to crack under a stream of cold water (ie, from fire brigade emergency action), but cases where this circumstance has led to premature structural collapse are rare. 
 Cast-iron members generally heat up more slowly than equivalent steel sections. 
 The strength of cast iron also decreases less rapidly with temperature. 
 Because of the original engineers' appreciation of its intrinsic brittleness, cast-iron members tend to be stressed to lower levels than steelwork and the way they were incorporated into buildings usually allows them to expand in a fire without generating increased stresses. 
 Where cast-iron columns support timber beams, the exposed surfaces of the beams may char, but they do not expand and generate lateral movements on columns as might steel beams or iron beams. 
 Thus there is every reason for building control officers, when assessing conversion proposals which rely on the re-use of aged iron structures, to consider the fire performance of each case on its own merits. 
 Consequently, it is not unusual for a local authority to confer a fire resistance capacity of half an hour on an unprotected cast-iron structure. 
 According to circumstances, the building inspector may be prepared to rate an unprotected cast-iron structure as one hour fire-resisting and where iron beams are partly embedded in brickwork or concrete (eg, in jack-arch and filler-joist floors) a greatly enhanced fire-resisting performance results from this partial protection. 
 Where the fire-resistance of a cast-iron member must be increased, it is no longer necessary to apply protective materials which conceal the shape and &bquo;character&equo; of the components. 
 Various intumescent materials are available which can be sprayed on to the iron, after suitable cleaning and priming, to five a fire-insulating coating. 
 There are &bquo;thin film&equo; and &bquo;thick film&equo; materials, the former being generally described as intumescent paint and the latter as intumescent mastics. 
 Both types work on the principle of swelling up at high temperatures to produce a &bquo;charred&equo; foam coating which so insulates and protects the member from heat that the temperature of the metal remains well below that of the fire. 
 The maintenance of structures with intumescent coatings should be carefully considered, particularly if there is a risk that the covering may be removed at some future time in the life of the building. 
 Suitable products and the exact extent of their application should be agreed with the local authority's building control officer before the rebuilding work is commenced. 
 Where the surfaces of cast-iron columns and other compression members display cracks, these defects need not necessarily reduce the opportunities for re-use of these elements. 
 Techniques exist for the &bquo;stitching&equo; of such fractures and they include a method in which groups of holes spaced at pre-defined centres are drilled across, and at right angles to each crack. 
 The residual iron between these holes is then broken out and a &bquo;multi-dumb-bell&equo; shape metal &bquo;key&equo;, precast in a special alloy, is inserted tightly into each serrated aperture by gentle hammering. 
 Many such keys are required to stitch together securely a significant crack. 
 When sufficient keys have been installed, their projecting parts are ground down, the new metal and the iron local to the crack is sanded, and the surface may be repainted, producing a virtually invisible repair which restores most, if not all, of the strength of the original component. 
 Farm Buildings 
 The detailed design of farm buildings changed only gradually in the past, but the rate and type of change is now very much quicker as a result of the significant alterations in farming methods which have occurred since World Wall II &mdash; primarily greatly increased mechanisation. 
 Consequently, the traditional buildings are generally becoming redundant. 
 They may be modified, but often this is not feasible, causing new structures of a very different kind to be erected. 
 The old buildings are then demolished or left to decay. 
 All farm buildings provide valuable evidence for agricultural history. 
 The traditional buildings tend to reflect the considerable regional differences in types of farming and in the methods of housing and threshing the crops or housing and feeding the livestock. 
 The old buildings that survive and can be preserved thus have a cultural significance as well as the functional potential for conversion to other uses. 
 Hence there follows a full description of the origin and staple features of the constituent parts of the traditional farmstead because it is important that the untutored town dweller who is contemplating the purchase and conversion of an old farm building should recognise the different building types, understand the operational influences which shaped the form of each structure, and frame his or her ideas for the conversion so that any permanent evidence of agricultural history which the building provides is not erased. 
 As farming methods changed, so the designs of farm buildings may have been changed to adapt to the new ideas. 
 The pace of change varied according to the region so that a building layout considered out of date in one area might still be fashionable in another. 
 The design of farm buildings was also affected by the local building tradition. 
 During the nineteenth century, with improvements in communications, these traditions were modified by the consequently increased sensitivity to changing preferences in architectural styles. 
 The speed at which an awareness of national fashions in architecture grew varied from one area to another. 
 Sometimes, quite independent of this influence, certain rural estates continued to practise their own distinctive styles of building. 
 A group of farm buildings, together with the farmhouse, forms the farmstead. 
 Farmsteads are found in nucleated or closely grouped settlements (ie, villages and hamlets), in small groups of two or three farms, or they are isolated. 
 The location of traditional farmsteads is the result of centuries of development and change. 
 Those that remain in villages are the survivors of a larger number of such groupings which were much reduced by the policy of enclosing open fields which was pursued during the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries. 
 Thus a settlement of two or three farmsteads, or even an isolated one, could be the shrunken remains of a village or hamlet. 
 The isolated farmstead may represent either the occupation of previously unfarmed land by a single farm or the movement of a farmstead out of a village following enclosure of the open fields. 
 Sometimes farm buildings were built away from the central farmstead. 
 Generally, they did not form a fresh farmstead as they lacked some necessary buildings. 
 The foremost non-farmstead building group and the type of most relevance to readers of this book who are seeking an old agricultural building to convert, is the field barn . 
 It consisted of a threshing barn, often with an attached shed and foldyard for sheltering loose cattle. 
 Field barns were built to serve land lying some distance from the farmstead, or which could only be reached from it by way of steep hills. 
 They first appeared in the seventeenth century and ceased to be built after the middle of the nineteenth century, when the advent of portable threshing machines meant that ricks could be built and threshed in the fields and field barns were no longer needed. 
 For this reason, many of these structures have disappeared. 
 The number and size of the buildings of the farmstead was affected not only by the size of the farm but also by the type of farming practised. 
 On an arable farm with only a few cattle kept to make manure, little provision would be made for these animals, but there would be one or more barns, stables and shelters for carts. 
 On a mixed farm, there would be a larger number of buildings for cattle, while on a pastoral farm the reduced need for waggon horses caused the stables to be small and there would be little accommodation for crops. 
 It is interesting to note that sheep had almost no effect on the form of the farmstead as buildings were very rarely provided for them. 
 Where land was readily acquired so that the farmstead could be enlarged in a logical way, rather than the haphazard development which resulted from the erection of buildings on whatever sites became available, individual buildings within the grouping were sited so as to maximise efficiency. 
 Threshed straw had to be taken from the barns to the cattle or the horses for use as feed or litter. 
 Because the cattle were the principal users of straw, it was important to have them near the barn. 
 Then the stable could be either beyond the cow-house or adjoin the barn on the other side. 
 For economy in building costs, these three types of farm buildings were sometimes combined into a single building. 
 The form most frequently found is the barn with lean-tos built against it to provide cow-houses, stables or cart-shed. 
 The cost of one wall was saved and because the buildings housing animals were close to the barn, they could be supplied more easily with straw. 
 Another common composite building placed the cow-house, stable or cart-shed under part of the barn. 
 The part of the barn sited on top of these areas thus became a loft raised above the threshing floor. 
 In some cases, this arrangement was adopted to take advantage of sloping ground. 
 However, the bank barn  was a different response to a sloping site. 
 The barn was built parallel to the ridge of the bank, being entered at high level on the uphill side. 
 On the downhill side the barn was thus at first-floor level with the cow-house, stable or cart-shed lying underneath. 
 This type of building is almost unique to the Lake District of England. 
 Within the farmstead, the farmhouse might be attached to some, or all of the other farm buildings. 
 Where the barn adjoined the dwelling it is called a laithe house , and often the stable and cow-house were built beyond the barn as part of the same range. 
 Such buildings can be found in the Pennine region of Yorkshire and the Lake District, although these combination buildings are not restricted to the north of England, similar types being found in the West-country. 
 Close contact with animals and manure was not always desired, so an extreme solution was to move the farm buildings well away from the farmhouse &mdash; sometimes even out of sight of it. 
 Where the farmstead is sited away from the house, a labourer's cottage might form part of the group, for security reasons. 
 Although former stables and cow-houses may offer opportunities for conversion into dwellings, it is often the case that they were too cheaply and impermanently built and are too small to provide a structure which is easily adapted into a house. 
 This applies even where (as was usual) the stable incorporated a loft for the storage of hay so that this fodder could be pitched readily into the racks in the stalls below, because the loft exploited the roof space and was rarely built as a full-height upper storey. 
 In contrast, stables attached to large town mansions in Central London convert very satisfactorily into &bquo;mews houses&equo; because living accommodation for the grooms and coachmen was originally provided in purpose-designed upper storeys. 
 Barns as Dwellings 
 More promising as a building type for conversion into living accommodation, as many people have recognised is the barn. 
 This is because the barn is often the largest of the non-domestic buildings of the farmstead and the large volume which it encloses offers many options for the creation of a comfortable and characterful dwelling. 
 In most traditional farmsteads it was also the central point to which the other buildings related. 
 A comprehensive account of the function and characteristic features of traditional barns follows, because it is apparent from even a brief tour of any rural district that the treatment meted out to many old barns in the course of their conversion into houses has been insensitive, or even atrocious, and even these enormities have occurred despite their owners' clearly expressed intentions to preserve, rather than erase, the &bquo;barn-like&equo; qualities of the buildings. 
 The encouragement of a more enlightened attitude in would-be converters of barns is crucial to the welfare of the architectural heritage of the countryside because the number of old barns converted to date may represent only the tip of the iceberg. 
 It is estimated that seventy thousand old barns survive, many in poor condition. 
 Most are ill-adapted to the demands of modern, mechanised agriculture and, unless converted to new uses, may well disappear. 
 These buildings are now almost equally at risk from insensitive conversion as they are from demolition because a softening in the attitude of local planning authorities towards proposals for change of use of agricultural buildings has recently been encouraged by central government in an attempt to ameliorate the worsening financial circumstances of farmers. 
 Most farmers view old buildings as a liability and the relaxation of a planning authority's traditional strictness in assessing proposed changes of use of such structures enhances their development potential, makes them more marketable and encourages the owner to sell them and to put up cheaply built, impermanent and often ugly sheds for storage of crops and farm machinery. 
 Traditionally, the barn was a building for housing and threshing the corn and pulse crops grown on the farm, the former category comprising wheat, oats, barley and rye, and the latter including peas and beans. 
 It could also house hay (cut grass) and threshed straw. 
 Almost invariably, barns had one threshing floor, with bays for housing the crops opening off it (Fig 37 and Plate 1). 
 The threshing floor, which was paved, probably in contrast to the floor surfaces of the bays to either side, always ran across the barn. 
 The size of barns varied greatly, but there were nearly always only one or two threshing floors. 
 The size of the farm was not the only factor affecting the size of its barn. 
 The most important factor was whether all the crops were housed in the barn or whether some or all were kept in ricks in the fields, being moved to the barn for threshing. 
 The practice in medieval times was to house all of the grain crops in the barn, using ricks as a last resort only when the barns were full. 
 This procedure naturally produced very large barns. 
 By the early eighteenth century in Scotland and Northumberland, the bulk of crops were housed in ricks, the barns consequently being small with space for housing only one rick at a time and a threshing floor. 
 In contrast, the practice of storing all the crops in barns and so of erecting large buildings, continued well into the nineteenth century in the south of England and East Anglia. 
 Contemporary reasons for continuing to build large barns included the view that grain was better housed in barns than in ricks and was always a hand to be threshed, while the cost of thatching ricks was avoided and savings were made by avoiding the double-handling generated by moving ricks to the barn for threshing. 
 The barn was filled with harvested crops, leaving only the threshing floor clear. 
 The crops were stacked right up to the roof ridge, or close to it, so using almost all the roof space. 
 Until the eighteenth century it was common to house two, three or more corps together in the barn, but a later development was the use of half the barn for threshed straw, filling only one side of the threshing floor with unthreshed corn, and the emergence of this practice may have accompanied the increased use of ricks for housing crops or faster threshing by machinery. 
 Apart from the general qualities of broad, plain, unperforated surfaces, simplicity of shape and an impression of massiveness (particularly in stone-built barns), several other features are characteristic of traditional barns. 
 Perhaps the most conspicuous is the large waggon door . 
 The most common type is the high, wide central doorway, closed by hinged double doors. 
 This doorway was made high in order to permit laden waggons or carts to enter the barn and to unload from the threshing floor into the bays. 
 Its height also admitted light to illuminate the threshing operation and air for winnowing the husks from the threshed grain. 
 It was normal for pairs of waggon doors to face each other on opposite side walls of the barn (Plate 2), but in some barns the threshing floor could be approached only from one side, there being a blank wall opposite. 
 This prevented the through draught which was valued for winnowing and meant that carts had to back out, so it was a less popular arrangement. 
 High porches shielding the waggon doors are found in many surviving medieval barns and in some later examples, particularly in the South. 
 They were useful for increasing the size of the threshing floor and in protecting crops on this surface during inclement weather. 
 Laden wagons could shelter in such porches if the threshing floors were already occupied by other vehicles unloading. 
 The porch could also be used as a cartshed. 
 Barn doors commonly stopped 305&ndash;610mm (1&ndash;2ft) above the ground with a separate panel of boards below. 
 This was held in place by a groove in the bottom of the door jamb which projected slightly for the purpose. 
 This &bquo;lift&equo;, as it is called, enabled the foot of the doors to clear the manure in the yard and kept pigs off the threshing floor when the doors were open. 
 It would also catch grain bounding off the floor with the force of flail threshing. 
 The second most characteristic external feature of many barns is the pitching hole , a window-like opening, covered by a wooden shutter, several of which might be provided in the side and end walls in order to pitch corn or hay into the barn from a cart standing outside. 
 They also admitted light and air if the barn was not full. 
 In shape, such apertures were roughly square, although circular openings began to appear in the early nineteenth century and are often a conspicuous feature of the brick-built Victorian estate barns of Cheshire. 
 Lastly, air vents  were provided in the walls of barns to prevent the crops inside from becoming mouldy. 
 Air vents in stone-built barns were normally slits or single holes, often widely spaced and sometimes arranged in rows. 
 No special provision was needed in weatherboarded timber-framed barns because the boards did not fit closely together. 
 The greatest range of types was found in brick-built barns owing to the ease with which patterns could be formed by omitting half-bricks or narrower units without affecting the structural stability of the walls. 
 As in stone-built barns, slits were widely used in brick structures and they were generally arranged in rows. 
 Half brick-wide holes were easily arranged in rows and granted good overall ventilation. 
 Geometric arrays of holes appeared in the mid-nineteenth century &mdash; probably in parallel with the Victorian enthusiasm for patterned &bquo;polychromatic&equo; brickwork &mdash; and seem to be the most widespread type. 
 Not to be confused with air vents is the owl-hole , a nearly square or circular opening 150&ndash;230mm (6&ndash;9in) across, set high up in the gable of the barn. 
 This feature was first introduced in the eighteenth century to let owls into the barn to catch vermin. 
 Barn interiors were generally open from end to end &mdash; there was no physical separation of the threshing floor from the bays. 
 The commonest and oldest barn plan places the threshing floor in the middle. 
 A barn with a central threshing floor would be at least three structural bays in length, each bay being perhaps 4.25&ndash;5.5m (about 14&ndash;18ft) long, although the distance between roof trusses could be smaller (say, 3m (10ft)), the bays might be of different lengths and the simple triangular roof trusses might not span more than 5.5&ndash;6m (18-19-1/2ft) (Plate 3). 
 Barns were sometimes built with integral aisles, along the lines of a church. 
 Clearly, such an arrangement necessitates the use of more elaborate and comprehensive timber framing than would be employed in a narrow barn where masonry walls provide all the support for the roof. 
 The use of aisles permitted the erection of a much wider building than would otherwise have been possible. 
 Aisled barns are of the order of 9&ndash;15m (29&ndash;49ft) wide; a simple triangular truss could be made to span a building 10m (33ft) wide, but most &bquo;single-cell&equo; barns were of the width defined above and would certainly not exceed 7.5m (24&ndash;1/2ft) in width. 
 Aisled barns are found in two main areas of England. 
 Timber-framed examples have survived in an area extending from Wiltshire and Hampshire across to Suffolk and Kent. 
 The other area is South Yorkshire and the Pennine district of Lancashire. 
 In some of the barns in these latter areas, the aisles were not used for storage but were shit off for some other purpose, such as housing the cattle. 
 The quite complex structure of timber-framed aisled barns may present problems of maintenance and preservation, as well as constraints on flexibility of internal planning, for the would-be converter of such a building to domestic use. 
 However, it is clear that an imaginative treatment of this form of interior could show off the texture and complexity of the original timber structure to dramatic effect. 
 Threshing machines were initially more used in the north than in the south of England, commencing in the early nineteenth century. 
 At first, the machinery was fixed, standing within the barn. 
 Naturally enough, the introduction of machinery led to a new plan in some contemporary barns. 
 The threshing floor disappeared. 
 One end of the barn was completely lofted, with the corn being fed into the building at first-floor level through pitching holes. 
 The other part was a straw barn. 
 Reliable portable threshing machines were a later development and were used much more in the south than in the north. 
 The machine could either stand on the threshing floor of an orthodox flail-threshing barn, which provided shelter from the weather, or it could be taken to the ricks in the fields. 
 The first practice probably encouraged the retention of many old and large flail-threshing barns which might otherwise have fallen into disuse, inviting demolition. 
 Indeed, apparently traditional flail-threshing barns continued to be built throughout the nineteenth century because of their ability to house the threshing machine as well as the crops. 
 In contrast, adoption of the second policy guaranteed the disappearance of many old barns because they became redundant unless they were retained as covered rick-houses or stores for straw. 
 However, the protection of hay, straw or even unthreshed corn was more simply achieved by the erection of a more modest and inexpensive building than the traditional flail-threshing barn. 
 This is the hay barn  or Dutch barn  which is completely open on one or more sides. 
 Very old examples consist of brick or stone pillars supporting a pitched roof, but they were rarely built before the late nineteenth century as they were considered an extravagance. 
 Their use increased considerably from the 1880s when the familiar skeletal iron-framed hay barn with a curved corrugated-iron roof began to appear in all parts of the country. 
 It will be appreciated that these insubstantial structures cannot form as satisfactory a basis for conversion into dwellings as can the traditional masonry-built flail-threshing barn. 
 Rectory Farm Barn, Upper Heyford, Oxfordshire 
 As photographs of the original building show clearly (Plates 1&ndash;3), before conversion, this stone-built barn displayed many of the conventional features described in the foregoing account. 
 It included large waggon door openings in the middle of each side elevation, with storage bays to either side of the central threshing floor to which these doors gave access. 
 Ventilation was provided by slits sited high in its stone-built walls and the gables contained owl-holes close to the apex of the roof (Plate 1). 
 Unfortunately, the roof surfaces had been reclad with corrugated iron when the original locally quarried stone slates became unserviceable. 
 The barn was built in 1839 and was the largest structure in a range of buildings. 
 When the present owner purchased it, the barn was part of a redundant farmyard in the centre of the small stone-built village of Upper Heyford. 
 The required accommodation was a residence for a family of five and the new owner requested that the living accommodation should be on the first floor to take advantage of the splendid views to the west over the Cherwell Valley. 
 An attached shed to the south of the barn was demolished, and the architect, Timothy Bruce-Dick, decided to infill the gap between the barn and a range of cow-houses which existed to the north with a two-storey structure which would act as a covered link to this northern wing and provide a playroom over garages (Fig 38 and Plate 4). 
 As well as creating enlarged internal accommodation, this treatment also helped to form a sheltered eastern entrance courtyard, the other two sides being a grass bank on the east and a new stone wall to the south. 
 The existing stone walling was retained and the original massiveness of the east elevation was preserved and even emphasised by retaining the high level ventilation slits and minimising the number of new windows on this sunless side. 
 Bathrooms, a kitchen and a utility room, needing only small windows, were located behind this elevation (Fig 38). 
 The association with a traditional barn incorporating porches has been skilfully exploited in order to broaden the width of the building at its centre so that an enclosed entrance porch and a generous &bquo;dog-leg&equo; staircase, giving access to the first floor, could be included on one side, while the equivalent projection on the west side houses an oriel window serving the dining-room which gives a commanding view over the Cherwell Valley. 
 Where these projections of the formerly open central bay of the building are not glazed, they are finished in dark-stained timber, a treatment that has been applied to all new external and internal timberwork and is a conventional finish for the external woodwork of many local farm buildings. 
 The double-height entrance lobby leads to a ground-floor gallery which runs to the north end of the barn where it connects with the garages. 
 Off this gallery all the principal bedrooms face west over an extensive private garden (Plate 5). 
 From the gallery the main staircase leads up to a first-floor open-plan living/dining-room/kitchen area, the hefty roof timbers of the old barn being exposed overhead. 
 A further dog-leg stair leads up from this level to second-floor guest accommodation located entirely in the roof space framed by the original trusses, and a narrow bridge leads across from the head of the stair to a complementary study balcony (Fig 38). 
 A glasshouse was erected against the south gable to exploit the potential for solar heat gain to assist space heating of the dwelling. 
 On sunny winter days, panels in the original south gable can be opened to allow air trapped in this conservatory and warmed by the sun to circulate in the body of the house. 
 Also planned was a covered swimming-pool, linked to the main house through the former cow-houses, which would be converted into changing accommodation and general storage. 
 The reconstruction was undertaken by direct labour (ie, the building owner organised and executed much of the work), starting in the spring of 1979, the house and playroom link being occupied in October 1979. 
 Because the bulk of the work was supervised by the owner, the overall cost is difficult to assess, but a figure of &pound;50,000 at 1979 prices probably represents the right order of expense. 
 Place Barn, Wilmington, Polegate, East Sussex Place Barn, Wilmington, is flint-walled barn which was formerly attached to Priory Farm at the head of the hill that leads out of the village to the South Downs. 
 It has a long, narrow plan, the northern end of which may have been used for stabling horses or housing the cattle. 
 This combination of uses is suggested by the existence of a dormer-roofed pitching hole close to the roof eaves at the north end and the two high-level square ventilation openings which are closely associated with it (Plate 6). 
 The waggon door was close to the south end of the barn, serving crop storage areas to either side. 
 The only differences between its layout and that of the &bquo;classic&equo; threshing barn were the inclusion of a hay loft, carried on brick pillars, to give an upper level at the south end and an attached cart-shed adjoining the west elevation, also at the south end. 
 When the new owners who proposed to convert the barn first saw it in 1978, the whole structure had been used for stabling horses, and accordingly, brick partitions had been erected to form stalls inside. 
 This modified use meant that the original waggon door opening had been reduced in width (Plate 7). 
 It was the new owners' intention to restore a more barn-like appearance. 
 They had lived in Holland for twenty years and had been much impressed by Dutch conversions of barns into dwellings which tend to be more simple, &bquo;scrubbed&equo; and &bquo;puritanical&equo; than the often over-elaborate treatment that is applied to British projects. 
 Planning permission for its conversion into a dwelling existed when the barn was purchased, but the scheme was particularly disliked by one of the new owners who believed, partly for the reason cited above and partly because of her training as a sculptress, that a simpler treatment, more strongly evocative of the barn's original function, might be adopted and still give comfortable and convenient living accommodation. 
 Hence, in conjunction with a local architect who provided technical advice and who prepared drawings for statutory approvals, a new scheme was developed. 
 The strategy for the exterior was to reintroduce a &bquo;barn-like&equo; appearance. 
 This was more possible on the east and south elevations which adjoin the head of the village street and a public car park access road respectively than it was on the west and south sides. 
 This is because the former faces lack either a sunny aspect or a pleasant prospect and the preservation of privacy is an important consideration on elevations so close to the highway. 
 Thus, changes to the east elevation included the necessary insertion of a small and unpretentious front entrance door in a pre-existing opening and the modification of the partly infilled former waggon-door opening to simulate the appearance of the original double doors. 
 This was achieved without restoring the opening to its former width by applying a pair of new timber-boarded and dark-stained doors to the east elevation. 
 The southern leaf of the double doors was fixed open against the wall and the opposite leaf was fixed closed over a new infilling cavity-wall construction of concrete blockwork (Fig 39) and Plate 8). 
 Thus the appearance of a double door is created, although the actual opening is only of single-door width and is filled with one large panel of clear double-glazing. 
 Ensuring that the glazing of such new openings is kept well back from the external face of the walls (at least 225mm (9in)) has meant that reflection has been minimised and the &bquo;black hole&equo; unglazed-opening appearance of apertures in traditional barns has been recreated. 
 This treatment was also applied to the smaller door, reached via a short flight of external stone steps that previously served the upper-level hay-loft, so that the new infilling panel of clear double-glazing, set well back from the external face of the wall, helps to light a sitting room while a &bquo;door&equo;, which can be swung like a shutter to seal this opening, is fixed back against the face of the adjoining flintwork. 
 It might be argued that this device, although an ingenious reference to the converted barn's former purpose, is not a practical feature in a dwelling because even double-glazing will not prevent the excessive heat loss and cold radiation caused by such large windows. 
 There is some substance to this criticism, but developments in glass technology since the date of the completion of the Place Barn project have much improved the thermal performance of double glazing. 
 It is now possible to obtain purpose-made double-glazed units incorporating &bquo;low E&equo;, or low emissivity, glass which includes a thin and imperceptible metallic coating on the inside surface of the outer leaf of each unit to reflect interior heat back into the room while allowing solar heat to enter the building. 
 Hence, much larger areas of double-glazing than could formerly have been contemplated, consistent with maintaining comfort, may now be built into external walls. 
 To give additional light to the new upper-level sitting room, it was decided to insert a group of three fixed windows in the south elevation above an existing opening (Plate 9) and in the north elevation two similar openings were added. 
 The west elevation was subject to most change. 
 Four additional openings were made in this external wall and three existing openings were modified in order to admit adequate light to the altered interior. 
 The three new windows &mdash; which were flanked by brickwork jambs matching the existing brick dressings to the flintwork &mdash; were spanned by brick segmental arches, a treatment also applied to the reprofiled opening opposite the former waggon door which accommodates a new sliding aluminium &bquo;patio&equo; door within a hardwood frame. 
 The brick-built garage which adjoined this west elevation was demolished and rebuilt with its new external walls showing a flint facing matching the remainder of the structure. 
 This change also allowed a more harmonious treatment to be adopted for the roof of this outshot. 
 By using salvaged slates, it was possible to revise the roof of the garage to a &bquo;cat-slide&equo; form projecting out and down from the eaves of the main rear roof-slope at a slightly shallower pitch than this surface (Plate 10). 
 The addition of three roof windows close to the eaves of this upper roof-slope at a slightly shallower pitch than this surface (Plate 10). 
 The addition of three roof windows close to the eaves of this upper roof-slope could then augment the daylighting of the upper-level studio that enters through the newly-glazed original eaves-level pitching hole of the east elevation. 
 It was not necessary to re-roof the attached cart-shed on the west side, the pitched and hipped shape of which was retained, but the original timber-framed and boarded north elevation of this &bquo;wing&equo; was removed and replaced with a cavity wall, finished externally with salvaged facing bricks. 
 This projection, with the addition of a sliding door at the rear of an existing door opening, could then accommodate a bedroom. 
 Internally, two further bedrooms were provided, both at ground-floor level. 
 Between this pair of northern bedrooms adjoining the entrance door, a cloakroom with a WC and hand basin and a bathroom were installed (Fig 39). 
 This is also the point at which access to the upper-floor studio and store is obtained via an iron spiral staircase. 
 In order to create sufficient headroom within the studio, it was necessary to remove an existing tie-beam which spanned between two timber posts that helped to support the roof structure and to adapt and re-site this member at a higher level, just below the soffit of the ceiling (Plate 11). 
 Naturally, the greater part of the volume of this room is within the roof space and a consequence of this is that a small pre-existing ventilation opening, which was sited high up below the eaves of the barn and is now glazed to form a window, has its sill at floor level. 
 This room-in-the-roof terminates to the rear of a massive brick-built chimney which dominates the main central living space of the barn. 
 Plainly, there was no such feature in the building prior to its conversion, but its insertion has been undertaken so carefully and with such sensitivity towards the simple, almost primitive shapes and textures of the original interior that it looks like a perfectly natural element. 
 A huge &bquo;inverted funnel&equo; of painted, coarsely plastered brickwork lies on top of an oak beam which acts as a fascia spanning a very broad fireplace, also lined with white-painted brickwork (Plate 12). 
 To give a suitably &bquo;thick&equo; appearance to the painted plaster surface applied over the new brickwork of the chimney, &bquo;Sirapite&equo; plaster was mixed with wallpaper paste and smeared over the overprecise profiles of the new work. 
 On other new internal surfaces some good &bquo;rough plastering&equo; was undertaken by very skilled tradesmen. 
 The introduction of the equally direct and simple brick-built chimney above the rear roof-slope hardly detracts from the reposeful form of the old barn's roof. 
 The central living-room extends right up into the apex of the roof, the original heavy roof timbers &mdash; rafters, purlins and tie beams &mdash; being exposed to the interior (Plate 13). 
 To emphasise fully the drama of this grand space, rather than remove the raised hay-loft occupying the south end of the building, it was decided to retain this area as a dining gallery overlooking the living room, with a private sitting room at the same level lying behind a new partition. 
 By excavating the existing ground-floor surface at this south end, it was possible to obtain a minimal, although legally acceptable, 2m (6&ndash;1/2ft) headroom for non-habitable accommodation below the gallery. 
 This comprises a shower room and WC, a dry-goods store, a larder, the passage leading to the third bedroom and the kitchen. 
 The kitchen is thus three steps down from the living-room floor level and is paved with the same material &mdash; York stone slabs approximately 60mm (2&ndash;1/2in) thick, below which a low-pressure piped hot water central-heating system is installed. 
 The upper-level dining gallery and sitting-room are reached from the living-room via short flight of open-riser timber stairs. 
 The owners who undertook the conversion of Place Barn were Mr and Mrs J. de Geus &mdash; Mrs Ann de Geus being responsible for the concept and much of the detailed design of the conversion. 
 They received invaluable technical advice from architect Colin Humphrey. 
 The builder was H. Wilson Ltd. 
 The conversion of Place Barn received the accolade of a Civic Trust Award in 1982. 
 Conversion Potential of Other Crop-Storage Buildings 
 Apart from the fairly standardised buildings housing the animals and the customary crops, some areas of the country also boast more specialised buildings for housing other crops, and these structures may be susceptible to conversion to valued and highly characterful accommodation. 
 Prominent among these buildings is the hop-kiln, which was used for drying hops (the main use for which is in beer, although they are also incorporated in other delicacies) before they could be despatched to market. 
 These structures are found in the hop-growing areas of Kent and East Sussex, where they are called oast-houses, and the westernmost part of Surrey, Herefordshire and West Worcestershire. 
 The most obvious kilns that survive are the square or circular-plan nineteenth-century type which are high rooms with tall conical roofs terminating in cowls. 
 They were invariably attached to a two-storey building of more conventional shape. 
 Circular kilns first appeared in Kent around 1805 and soon became the normal pattern there. 
 They are called &bquo;roundels&equo;. 
 Roundels with tiled conical roofs require special tiles. 
 These are known as &bquo;Kent peg tapered tiles&equo; as they narrow in length, holes being incorporated at the narrow ends to accept wooden pegs which locate them on the roofing battens. 
 Until recently, these tiles, were made by hand, but now finding suitable second-hand replacement units is becoming difficult. 
 Square-plan kilns were not used in the South until shortly before World War I. The kilns had brick walls; inside, at ground level, there was an open brick box to contain the fire, the draught being controlled by the entrance door. 
 The drying floor was sited about 3m (10ft) above the furnace and was of slatted wooden construction, being made of laths or battens set fairly close together. 
 The hot air from the fire passed up between the laths. 
 The hops were spread on a horsehair cloth laid on the battens, access to this upper level being gained through a high-level door in the side of the kiln. 
 Above was a steep-sided cone, usually timber-framed like a roof, with a plastered internal finish and clad with tiles or slates externally. 
 In a few instances, the cone itself was of brick and this form of construction existed at Tibb's Oast, a mid-nineteenth century oast-house, the conversion of which is described later. 
 Capping this cone was the cowl. 
 Repair of the cowl, the most distinctive part of the oast, requires a craftsman's knowledge and skill. 
 Its purpose is to ventilate the kiln, enabling the moisture-laden air to be drawn from the hops. 
 This air is known as the &bquo;reek&equo;. 
 The vane is the oast's rudder and ensures that the boarded surface always faces the wind, thus preserving the opportunity for moist air to escape (Plate 14). 
 Considerable dexterity is required to lower and raise a cowl. 
 It is quite normal for a cowl to weigh 200kg (31st) and extend to 4.5m (15ft) in height with a diameter of 1.8m (6ft) at its base, and four men are required to manoeuvre it. 
 Where vaned cowls are to be replaced, it is not advisable for them to be fixed in place, not only for the sake of authenticity, but also to simplify maintenance. 
 Damp must not be allowed to enter as rot can quickly result. 
 Until recently, cowl bases (or &bquo;curbs&equo;) were made from elm, but Dutch elm disease has made this material difficult to obtain. 
 Today, it is more usual to replace the base with marine ply. 
 Tradition demands that the cowls should be painted white and it is common practice to spray their surfaces with glass-fibre to improve durability. 
 Normally, cowls require considerable maintenance and possible replacement every ten years &mdash; a costly consequence of owning an oast. 
 The vane is sometimes called the &bquo;finger&equo; or &bquo;flyboard&equo; and it gave farmers an opportunity to display their individuality. 
 In kent, many vanes were completed with the Kentish horse motif and hunting scenes were popular. 
 Other animals were also depicted. 
 Additionally, most &bquo;fingers&equo; bear the personal mark of the executant craftsman. 
 Adjoining the kilns was a two-storey building, the upper floor of this structure being about 1m (3ft) below the drying floors of the kilns which were reached via short flights of timber stairs (Fig 40). 
 This area was used for receiving the hops and for spreading them out to cool after they were removed from the kilns. 
 Once the redistribution of moisture had taken place, the hops were swept into &bquo;pockets&equo;. 
 These were long sacks which were suspended through a circular hole in the floor, called the trading hole (until presses were introduced, the hops were compressed by a man treading them in). 
 A later development introduced a press to compress the hops in each pocket which was held in a pocket sling. 
 After pressing, the pockets were tied and then stored in the ground-floor storage area, which was only required as a space in which the pockets were hung and for stoking the fires in the kilns. 
 Otherwise, it had no connection with hops and might be used for cidermaking, housing livestock, or as a cartshed. 
 The pockets of hops were stored here until they were shipped off to market or to a brewery. 
 It was common for the storage building to be accompanied by a pair of kilns and a complete range of such structures might be erected adjacent to a very long storage building on a site where the cultivation of hops was undertaken intensively (eg, at the hop farm of a brewery.) 
 Tibb's Oast, Udimore, Rye, East Sussex 
 This oast-house conversion is rather unusual in that four kilns or &bquo;roundels&equo; are attached to the central storage shed, a pair being placed on both sides of this building, giving a symmetrical composition. 
 The shed itself was largely of wooden construction, and as the photograph of its pre-conversion condition indicates (Plate 15), it was in a very ramshackle state. 
 Hence the first job for the new owners in the autumn of 1983 was the demolition of the decaying boarded &bquo;front&equo; elevation of this structure which filled the gap between the eastern pair of roundels. 
 This action enabled the new infilling east elevation clad in painted timber boards to be installed to the rear of the original wall-plane, better exposing to view the cylindrical forms of the kilns (Plate 16). 
 The upper floors of the storage shed were also at inconvenient levels and the discovery of wholesale decay in this joisted construction supported a policy of removing these elements and replacing them with a new upper-floor set at a level which could be extended into the roundels to give adequate headroom in the new ground-storey rooms, while ensuring that the four upper-storey bedrooms located in these projections had a sufficiently deep vertical wall surface to accommodate conventional windows. 
 With the drying floors removed, the brickwork of the roundels proved not to be very strong and it was necessary to span the circular spaces with timber beams before the new upper floor was installed. 
 It was also necessary to fabricate and fit a new rotating cowl to replace the louvred terminal which was missing from the apex of the south-east roundel. 
 Where the louvred cowls has survived, glazing had to be added internally in order to present wind-blown rain from entering the vents, and efforts were made to waterproof the sloping brick surfaces of the roundels' conical roofs by coating them with bitumen. 
 Because the junction of a pair of roundels produces a triangular interstitial space internally as well as externally, one of two such internal areas was used to accommodate a WC, which is reached from an intermediate landing of the staircase (Fig 41 and Plate 17). 
 Apart from the four first-floor bedrooms, all of which are housed in the roundels and which are 5.1m (17ft) in diameter, the upper storey was used to house a large games room, an airing cupboard and a bathroom. 
 The north-east roundel bedroom was provided with an en suite bathroom. 
 The lower storey includes a very generous stair and entrance hall, extending to two storeys in height at its centre within a peripheral first-floor gallery, a double garage, utility room and a large kitchen being accommodated in the western half of the former storage shed. 
 The dining room occupies the south-east roundel, the lounge the north-west roundel, a study the north-east roundel and the south-east roundel accommodates a fifth bedroom. 
 After several months' work, during which time they lived in a caravan parked on the site, the owners, Mr and Mrs Bates were able to move into the future garage area of the building in August 1984 and to continue work on the upper-floor accommodation under the shelter of the reslated roof. 
 The quickly erected boarded external finish of the former storage shed and the predominantly &bquo;dry&equo; construction of the internal wall linings made this a practical policy once reconstruction, during the spring and summer months, of the decayed lower-storey brickwork was complete and had produced a habitable shell. 
 The complete interior of the house could not be occupied until the final months of 1985 and the owners stayed for only one further year before the challenge of converting a local barn tempted them away! 
 Churches and Chapels 
 Before considering the various methods which various owners and developers have adopted to achieve the satisfactory conversion of church buildings to domestic use, it is important to be aware of the procedure through which the majority of churches become available for conversion. 
 In the case of the Anglican Church, whose buildings make up the largest group of ecclesiastical structures, there exists a quite involved and considered procedure which is defined by the Pastoral Measure of 1983. 
 Although there is no generally agreed forecast of the number of Anglican churches likely to be declared &bquo;redundant&equo;, the Bridges Commission of 1960 suggested that 790 buildings could be involved. 
 It is noteworthy that by 1976, eight years after the original Pastoral Measure came into effect, almost 500 churches had been declared redundant by the Church Commissioners. 
 Of these, 37 per cent were destined for demolition. 
 The remainder were to be preserved or put to other uses, but delays in reaching decisions often meant that the buildings had been severely vandalised by the time they were available for conversion. 
 The procedure is first for the Pastoral Committee of the Diocese to consult the Council for Places of Worship, receiving from it a report which sets out the architectural qualities and historic interest of the building. 
 Reference is also made to other Anglican churches in the area as a choice may have to be made between one building and another. 
 Having decided upon a recommendation that a particular church should be declared redundant, the Pastoral Committee sends the papers relating to the proposal to the bishop of that diocese. 
 He has the opportunity to comment on these documents before forwarding them to the Church Commissioners. 
 The Pastoral Measure defines the interested parties, including the local planning authority, who must be consulted before this stage is reached. 
 If the Church Commissioners subsequently agree to seal a Declaration of Redundancy, advice is sought on the future of the building from the Advisory Board for Redundant Churches, a national body which was set up under the Pastoral Measure. 
 If the building is of architectural or historical importance, or contains fine built-in furnishings, the Advisory Board may recommend vesting the church in the Redundant Churches Fund. 
 This fund is another creation of the Pastoral Measure. 
 It is provided with an income from central government and church sources and acts as a &bquo;holding body&equo; for churches which are of sufficient importance to be preserved, unmodified, &bquo;in the interests of the Nation and the Church of England&equo;. 
 For those churches not vested in the Redundant Churches Fund or retained by the Board of Finance of the diocese, two categories can be perceived: a) those that will be demolished (although the Advisory Board may initially withhold a demolition certificate) and b) those that can be adapted to a range of alternative uses. 
 Plainly, it is this latter category that is of most interest to readers of this book. 
 Because the resources of the Redundant Churches Fund are fairly slight related to the large number of churches which are falling into disuse, it should be equally clear that conversion is often the only way in which a creditable building can be saved from complete destruction through neglect and vandalism. 
 Of course, conversion can only be considered as an exercise in the conservation of a noteworthy building if the alterations are as sympathetic as possible to the fabric and general appearance of the original building. 
 The Church Commissioners have the right to declare a particular use as being unsuitable, and the Advisory Board is required to approve or withhold approval of the proposed adaptation. 
 Every diocese that is actively pursuing the problem has appointed a Redundant Churches Uses Committee whose task it is to seek out suitable alternative uses. 
 Enquiries related to redundant churches, and especially their adaptation, should be addressed in the first place either to the secretary of the Redundant Churches Uses Committee of the Diocese (see diocesan handbook) or to the Secretary of the Advisory Board for Redundant Churches of the Church Commissioners. 
 In relation to churches serving other denominations, it has been the case until recently that Roman Catholic churches have rarely fallen out of use, although the general decline in religious observance is beginning to affect some of these buildings too. 
 In the circumstance of their redundance, the usual prescription has been the demolition of the buildings and sale of their sites, but it is likely that where redundancy affects noteworthy buildings &mdash; and an increasing number of Roman Catholic churches, lacking the exemption from &bquo;listing&equo; currently enjoyed by the Anglican churches, are being listed as buildings of architectural or historic interest &mdash; the church hierarchy may have to consider offering them for conversion to alternative uses. 
 Information regarding the ownership of churches belonging to the various non-conformist sects can be obtained either from the General Secretary of the Free Church Federal Council or from the appropriate denominational headquarters. 
 In general, the property of the non-conformist churches is administered either directly by the denominational headquarters as managing trustees, or else legally held by this body as custodian trustee and managed by honourary officials from the local church membership. 
 Baptists and Congregationalists encourage the incorporation of property in the regional or County Union and the Wesleyan Methodist Church (now combined with the Congregationalists in the United Reformed Church) usually prefers the system of local personal trustees. 
 Among the free churches there is no set system of redundancy procedure as there is for the Anglican Church, so that it may be for officials from the local congregation to decide if and how to dispose of vacant church property. 
 Planning 
 A problem with the conversion to domestic use of a church planned in the conventional way arises from the cross-sectional shape of the building. 
 Staple features of the church plan since early Christian times have been the cruciform shape and the division of the interior into a high central nave, flanked on either side by lower aisles. 
 Although satisfactory for accommodating a large congregation in a uniformly lit space, such an arrangement does not offer the possibility of simple subdivision into a series of identical spaces suitable for use as dwellings. 
 One feature of this cross-sectional arrangement which is immediately apparent is the large area of roof surface which it generates, the roof surface of the central nave normally being sloped at a very steep pitch. 
 Thus a large, lofty volume is enclosed by the roof and is useless except for the purpose of admitting daylight to the &bquo;spinal&equo; space of the building via high-level clerestory windows. 
 The architects of the Gothic period exploited this device to the full, for they recognised that greater religious impact could be made by stressing the luminosity and verticality which result form its adoption. 
 Many converters of churches which incorporate this arrangement have naturally regarded this space as a zone in which living-rooms might be accommodated, and the beneficial use of such roof space has largely been made possible by the widespread employment of standard reversible ventilating and double-glazed roof windows. 
 However, the adoption of this policy alone does not solve the problem of making optimal use of the volume, because filling up the highest part of the nave with habitable accommodation arranged on one or several storeys deprives the lower-level spinal space of the church of natural light. 
 The solution adopted in converting several two-aisled church interiors into dwellings has been to regard this low-level central strip as a spinal access corridor serving all, or most of the flats &mdash; a sort of internal &bquo;street&equo;. 
 This policy is shown in the scheme for the conversion of All Saints and St Barnabas, Stockwell, London, which is described and illustrated in this chapter. 
 In the few cases where the church plan diverges from the conventional arrangement by including only a single side aisle rather than the normal two, this volume, rather than the nave space, can be used to accommodate the dwellings access corridor, although it is noteworthy that in the conversion of St James's Church, Farnham, Surrey, which is also described in this chapter, the optimum cross-sectional treatment of such an asymmetrical plan placed the longitudinal access corridor in the former nave space, the aisle projection being used to accommodate living-rooms. 
 A complementary difficulty is the achievement of a physically and visually satisfactory interface between the large western window characteristic of neo-Gothic cruciform-plan churches and the floors which must be inserted in the formerly unitary volume of the high church interior in or der to provide functional habitable rooms. 
 These new levels invariably clash with such a feature and variations on one means of convincingly disguising what might be an unattractive junction of new and retained construction are illustrated in the following sections, which include accounts of the conversion of two conventional nineteenth-century Anglican churches. 
 Chapel of Nunc Dimittis and Saint Mark, Bilton, Rugby, Warwickshire 
 This building was erected by Richard Orme Assheton, Rector of Bilton and a local landowner, in 1983 in memory of his wife. 
 Its chief importance to architectural history lies in the fact that it is a very early example of the work of J. Ninian (later Sir Ninian) Comper (1864&ndash;1960), a notable church architect of the early twentieth century. 
 The commission to design the memorial chapel was first given to G.F. Bodley (1827&ndash;1907), an eminent church architect of the late-Victorian period, but Bodley passed it on to Comper who had been his most highly talented pupil. 
 Although the building was largely complete by 1893, the bell turret at the north-east corner was added in 1904 and is of a more conspicuously &bquo;Arts and Crafts Movement&equo; style than the body of the church (Plate 18). 
 The Rev. Assheton was an avid collector of stained glass and the original grouped &bquo;lancet&equo; windows of the side walls contain stained glass from several periods (including the Middle Ages). 
 The liturgical &bquo;east&equo; window &mdash; which is actually in the south wall &mdash; contains glowing Victorian stained glass designed by G. F. Bodley. 
 Richard Assheton may have employed the best church architects of his day because he was himself an amateur architect (he designed a church at Flecknoe, near Daventry, south of Rugby) and hence may have appreciated the difficulties of architectural design and the ability of talented practitioners to resolve them happily. 
 After many years of use by the local community, with regular services continuing into the early 1970s, the chapel was declared redundant in 1975. 
 A chance inquiry into an old debt revealed that the building had never been fully consecrated and thus would revert to Assheton family ownership after a year and a day's disuse. 
 Hence, around 1980, William Assheton, an architectural student whose forebears included the Rev. Richard Assheton, found he was the new owner of the building. 
 As his course of study at the School of Architecture, University of Manchester, demanded a period of practical training in an architect's office, William Assheton decided to spend this time working in Coventry so that in his spare time he could design and supervise the conversion of the chapel into a dwelling for his own use. 
 The work was carried out during the period 1980&ndash;1 and the existing building construction was found to be generally in good condition. 
 The well-built and massively thick brickwork walls continued effectively to exclude wind and rain although an attack of dry rot had affected the suspended timber ground floor. 
 This problem did not extend to the roof timbers as this construction was very well ventilated. 
 However, it was necessary to renew the roof covering of clay plain tiles with identical material. 
 The policy adopted for the conversion involved exploiting to the full the high, undivided volume of the interior to create two storeys of living accommodation. 
 This scheme was suggested by the need to remove the partially rotten wooden floor, thus deepening the space available for subdivision. 
 A small amount of excavation down to a new lower-level concrete floor slab then provided sufficient height for two habitable storeys in the central zone of the building (Fig 42). 
 This volume was confined to the central area because excavation was restricted to the &bquo;core&equo; of the plan in order to avoid undermining the existing external wall foundations (Fig 43). 
 As most of the original windows were located quite high in the side elevations of the chapel, they could become low-level windows lighting the new upper storey, and space enough remained in the formerly imperforate lower-level panels of the side walls to introduce new &bquo;tripartite&equo; windows sited vertically below the original openings in order to light the rooms of the lower storey. 
 This area &mdash; which throughout, is somewhat lower than the original ground-floor level (necessarily retained in the entrance hall) &mdash; accommodates three bedrooms. 
 Because the achievement of a habitable room height in this lower storey necessitated deeper excavation of the central zone, the bedrooms too incorporate a change in floor level. 
 A short flight of stairs adjoins each entrance door and leads down to the central sleeping area. 
 This arrangement also produces a shallow perimeter &bquo;ledge&equo;, parallel to at least one external wall, which can be used as a window seat. 
 This disposition of rooms made it possible to treat the residual high-level space as a single living/dining/cooking area, with the kitchen located at its northern end, divided from the generous living-dining-room only by a head-height folding screen. 
 This arrangement allowed the elaborate wooden structure of the steeply pitched roof &mdash; now much closer at hand following the insertion of the upper floor &mdash; to remain unmodified, an impressive preserved construction &bquo;oversailing&equo; the new living accommodation. 
 The original windows of the &bquo;east&equo; gable and the side walls having become low-level lights closely related to the new upper floor, the fine stained glass they contain can now also be admired at close range. 
 William Assheton's attitude to the design of the conversion was based on the view that although the building might function as a house, it ought still to be recognisable as a church. 
 This preference has produced at least two problems. 
 First, the adoption of lightweight construction for new partition walls and the structure of the upper floor, although kind to the integrity of the original building fabric, has led to excessive sound transmission between rooms, a condition which is exacerbated by the inversion of the normal domestic arrangement &mdash; ie, the siting of the living-rooms over the bedrooms. 
 The architect owner admits that it might have been better to regard the converted building primarily as a house and to order priorities for the location and constructional &bquo;envelopes&equo; of rooms accordingly. 
 This would have meant adopting dense and heavy new construction for partitions and the upper floor (ie, solid-brickwork dividing walls supporting a slab or concrete planks). 
 Secondly, the new proximity of the original side windows to the floor of the living-room quickly revealed the propensity of the stained-glass panels to admit draughts and clearly it would be wise to install secondary glazing within these openings to seal leaks, even at the expense of losing an uninhibited view of the coloured glass. 
 Also, following the removal of the suspended timber ground floor and the excavation of sub-floor earth so that adequate headroom could be obtained in the lower-storey bedrooms, it was necessary to install a continuous waterproof membrane below the new concrete floor slab in order to prevent penetration of the construction by rising damp. 
 The product adopted for this task was a laminated bitumen and polyethylene sheet material which demands very careful attention to the formation of joints between sheets if groundwater penetration is to be entirely excluded. 
 On reflection, the owner felt that it would have been better adopt the traditional method of &bquo;tanking&equo; the semi-basement lower floor with in situ asphalt. 
 An aesthetically satisfactory answer to the need to insert additional windows to light the new lower-level accommodation was found by not only siting the new openings in the same vertical alignment as the original triparite lights, but also by aiming to reproduce the general appearance of the existing windows. 
 Absolute fidelity to the prototypes would have demanded the use of stone mullions, sills and lintels framing wrought-iron casements as well as the reproduction of the segmental-arched profile which caps each opening. 
 However, insufficient height was available to install windows copying the attenuated shape of the original &bquo;lancets&equo; and the unquestioning reproduction of the arch form in the new windows would have produced a weaker visual result than the treatment which was adopted &mdash; the insertion of new tripartite lights capped by a simple square-headed profile (Plates 18 and 19). 
 In this way the original window apertures &bquo;read&equo; satisfactorily as the high level &bquo;extension&equo; of lower, squatter openings, rather in the manner that, in the internal view of a cathedral nave, the triforium openings of the nave arcade are vertically extended and handsomely terminated by the high-level clerestory windows. 
 Also, expense was spared by the adoption of a simple square-headed shape in contrast to the original arched profile, and it was the cost consideration which similarly led to the new window sills, mullions and lintels being manufactured in reconstructed stone to match the existing dressings, rather than the natural material. 
 Reproduction of the slender frames of the original wrought-iron casements was effected by having the new fixed and opening lights fabricated from standard steel sections, colour-coated to match the finish of the original metalwork. 
 St James Court, Farnham, Surrey 
 The conversion of St James's Church, East Street, Farnham, Surrey, which was completed in 1980, was probably the pioneering development of the current spate of residential conversions of churches for multiple occupation. 
 The church was built in 1876 to the designs of Henry Woodyer (1816&ndash;96), an accomplished church architect who designed many ecclesiastical buildings, a large number of which are located in Surrey. 
 The building's external walls are faced in ironstone setts with Bath stone dressings to corners and door and window openings. 
 By virtue of its considerable size and its elevated site, the church makes a significant contribution to the townscape of Farnham's &bquo;east end&equo;. 
 It is the sole building of good quality in this predominantly commercial and rather nondescript part of the town. 
 As Farnham's second Anglican church, it was never very successful in attracting large congregations and was declared redundant in 1974. 
 The Church Commissioners proposed its demolition because they were unable to identify any alternative use for the building. 
 As often applies in such cases, it became evident that the church was held in some affection by the local residents and, in response to public concern, the local planning authority, Waverly District Council, initiated a search for alternative uses. 
 The council's Conservation Officer interested his colleagues in the Architect's Department in investigating possible residential use of the building. 
 An architectural analysis of the structure showed that conversion of the church into council-owned dwellings, rented to young people, was practicable. 
 It was also the only alternative use for which finance was available. 
 Thus the church and its site were purchased for &pound;20,000 in 1979 by Waverly District Council, while the adjacent church hall was sold off separately by the local diocese for conversion into two small private dwellings. 
 The fact that the church was not of the highest architectural quality eased some of the problems that could have been associated with its conversion into flats. 
 The creation of several dwellings within a building previously devoted to one use necessitates the division of the original large single volume of the church interior and the loss of the special qualities of light, spaciousness and acoustics which that large volume possesses. 
 Compartmentation of the interior means that the building is experienced in a new way &mdash; details which were once distant (and which may have been executed in the knowledge that they would not be viewed at close hand) are seen in &bquo;close-up&equo; for the first time and in relation to much smaller and more intimate spaces (Plate 20). 
 Despite the architect's awareness of the radical transformation that would be effected by conversion of the church into dwellings, it remained his objective to retain the essential character and best qualities of the original building and to keep the existing stonework as untouched as possible. 
 This aim could have been frustrated by the need to keep costs to the minimum in order to maintain the economic viability of the project, but both requirements were satisfied by confining all new openings to the roofs of the aisle and the nave. 
 Alterations to these surfaces were less expensive than any modification of the walls and had less impact on the overall appearance of the church. 
 Cost considerations also controlled the amount of restoration work which was undertaken. 
 Such work had to be minimal if the project was to remain viable. 
 Fortunately, the church was in very sound structural order &mdash; only one small area of dry rot was found in the course of the conversion &mdash; and restoration work was confined to the replacement of several crumbling gable coping stones and related &bquo;kneelers&equo;, together with wire-brushing of some small areas of stonework where this was necessary. 
 No attempt was made to return either the interior or exterior stonework to its original condition. 
 The accommodation provided by the conversion consists of 16 flats of which 6 are two-person units. 
 The remaining 10 dwellings comprise 9 bed-sitters and one apartment with a separate bedroom. 
 As it was difficult to convert the square-ended chancel into living accommodation and it was felt important to retain part of the church in its original state, this area was left almost untouched in order to operate as a multi-purpose &bquo;community room&equo;. 
 An intermediate floor was inserted in the adjoining transept to form a small communal lounge linked to the first-floor corridor by a balcony crossing the chancel and by a small staircase to the ground floor (Fig 44). 
 This space had previously accommodated the organ loft. 
 Preservation of the chancel as a single space allowed the high stained glass of the east window to be retained in its original form without interruption from new intermediate floors. 
 Other communal accommodation includes a kitchen, laundry, two bathrooms (a shower is provided in each flat) and two store rooms). 
 The conversion of St James's did not result in the classic consequence church conversion &mdash; namely, the creation of a central lightless dwellings access corridor between two lateral banks of living accommodation. 
 This is because the church has an asymmetrical plan with a single southern aisle rather than the more usual arrangement of south and north aisles flanking a central nave. 
 Thus the interior contained only a single row of nave arcade columns (Plate 21) and the comparative narrowness of the plan meant that there was space for only a range of shallow ancillary rooms &mdash; stores, bathrooms and laundry (Fig 44) &mdash; on the north side of the ground-floor flats access corridor once dwellings of suitable size, restricted to the spans of the nave arcade bays, had been accommodated. 
 This arrangement has helped to reduce the potential oppressiveness of the resulting internal corridor because the northern &bquo;strip&equo; of service rooms also accommodates the two staircases that serve the two publicly accessible upper floors of the building and natural light spills into the ends of the corridor through the glazed enclosures of these features, reducing the room's apparent length. 
 Only the second-floor dwellings are on two levels. 
 Single-storey units occupy the ground and first floors (Fig 44 and Plate 22). 
 Constructional Details 
 With the exception of the stained-glass east window, all the original windows of diamond-shaped leaded lights set in wrought-iron frames were removed and replaced with purpose-made steel frames containing simple rectangular side-hung casements. 
 The residual top section of glass within the arched section at the head of each window was replaced by a panel of glass directly bedded in the stonework. 
 The tiled roof over the single south aisle was stripped off and partly replaced with bronze-coloured aluminium glazing bars framing bronze-tinted &bquo;anti-sun&equo; glass, the upper panels of which are laid to the same slope as the original roof, the lower panels producing a range of shallow vertical windows, the combination of which gives &bquo;conservatory&equo; lighting to the first floor flats (Plate 23). 
 The remaining small areas of flat roof, extending from the vertical glazing almost to the eaves of the aisle roof, accommodate roof-lights admitting natural light to the ground-floor flats which would otherwise be only poorly lit by the original lancet windows of the aisle wall. 
 The end wall of the aisle, adjoining the main entrance, os the only place where alteration of the existing stonework was undertaken. 
 The original tiled roof oversailed this wall with a conventional tiled verge. 
 In order to &bquo;contain&equo; the higher profile of the new, glazed aisle roof, the wall was raised slightly with new ironstone masonry, producing a parapet wall under a new sloping stone coping. 
 The architect, Roy Toms, of the Waverly District Council, was worried about what could have been an unsympathetic alteration to a venerable building, but a visit to St Martin's, Dorking, another Woodyer church, confirmed that its architect had adopted raking parapets to terminate the aisle roofs there, and the discovery of this period precedent vindicated the use of this treatment at St James Court. 
 The original suspended wooden ground floor was entirely removed after penetration of this structure for the installation of the new cross-walls and their foundations showed that some residual sections were badly affected by woodworm. 
 The new ground floor is of in situ concrete and contains horizontal drainage ducts. 
 Few additional loads were placed on the original structure. 
 The two main additional floors are largely carried on new masonry crosswalls which are, in turn, carried on their own new strip-footing foundations. 
 The structure of these intermediate floors comprises closely spaced pre-cast concrete beams, the intermediate voids being infilled with &bquo;hollow pot&equo; units. 
 On top, a sand/cement screed gives a solid, level floor finish. 
 This heavy construction, which has good sound-insulating properties, provided an economic solution to the problem posed by the need to insert new floors in spite of the fact that all the beams had to be manhandled into position because there was no access for mechanical handling. 
 The new third floor, which is the upper floor of the two-storey dwellings, is of conventional joisted timber construction. 
 As applies almost invariably in the conversion of columnated church interiors, compartmentation of the interior of St James's adheres strictly to the original division of the nave into bays which, in this case, placed the columns at approximately 3.5m (11&ndash;1/2ft) centres. 
 Contract Details 
 When detailed drawings of the scheme had been prepared, they were put out to competitive tender and the resulting offers were assessed by the Department of the Environment against a &bquo;cost yardstick&equo; related to similar newly built accommodation. 
 Consequently, the ministry concluded that the conversion represented &bquo;good value for money&equo; and the contract was awarded to builders John Worman Ltd on a fixed price basis. 
 The eventual cost of the conversion was &pound;238,000 and the reconstruction period extended to fifteen months, the work being completed in the last quarter of 1980. 
 In late November of that year, the first tenants moved into the building and the development almost immediately became the only award-winning refurbishment scheme in the Department of the Environment Housing Awards for 19891, despite tough competition from more than four hundred entries. 
 It is important to recognize that an identical project promoted at the present time would not offer good value for money in comparison with a new-build scheme. 
 This is because St James's Church was not listed as a building of architectural or historic interest after it was declared redundant and thus the cost of the building work would attract Value Added Tax at the standard rate. 
 A new-build scheme providing equivalent accommodation would be exempt from this tax. 
 Only if a building is listed can this significant premium on construction costs be avoided, although the majority of disused churches which are offered for conversion are of &bquo;listed&equo; status. 
 The only note of criticism which can be sounded in relation to the admirable job of careful conversion which created much needed and characterful dwellings within the shell of a disused church at St James Court emerges from the preservation-conscious atmosphere of the present day. 
 This mood might question the suitability of making the radical alterations to the aisle roof and the almost equally severe remodelling of the south slope of the nave roof which were implemented here (Plates 24 and 25). 
 Although it is clear that these changes were made in order to admit light to the new, deep-plan living accommodation, it is conceivable that the judicious use of ranges of standard reversible and ventilating roof windows might have provided an answer to this requirement which would have been less erosive of the original external appearance. 
 Church of All Saints and St Barnabas, Stockwell, London SW8 
 This church was erected in the mid-nineteenth century in an area of South London which was being developed, to an overall plan, as a residential estate. 
 In a pattern of development which took the form of a circus containing a garden at the centre, with roads radiating towards the cardinal points, the land was divided into small plots which were developed by various builders between 1843 and 1850. 
 While the estate was being developed, a site was conveyed to the Church Building Commissioners for the erection of the church of St Barnabas. 
 The foundation stone was laid on 27 July 1848 by the Duke of Cambridge. 
 The building was erected by builder George Myers at a cost of &pound;4,800 to a design by architects Isaac Clarke and James Humphrys. 
 Accommodation was provided for a congregation of about 1,500 people and the church was consecrated on 24 June 1850 by the Bishop of Winchester. 
 It is noteworthy that Ralph Vaughan Williams was at one time the organist here. 
 The axis of the nave of the church is also the centre-line of the road which leads east from the central circus of Lansdowne Gardens. 
 Before conversion, the building had a simple plan with a nave and aisles of six bays terminated by a shallow semi-octagonal apse at the east end. 
 In conformity with the principles of the Ecclesiological Society, whose views on church design were increasingly influential in the 1840s and '50s, no internal gallery was provided. 
 Also in deference to their preferences, the building was carried out in the Early English Gothic style, its structural brickwork being faced externally with Kentish ragstone dressed with Bath stone at corners and door and window openings. 
 The central nave of the church was clerestoried and a slender bell-turret of octagonal plan was subsequently installed against the south-west corner of the nave, projecting slightly beyond the south aisle. 
 The interior was plain with two-light windows lighting the apse. 
 The nave arcading was borne on alternate octagonal and circular stone columns with foliated capitals and supported a timber roof carried on &bquo;hammer beam&equo; trusses. 
 Originally, the east window contained rich stained glass portraying St Barnabas and St Paul. 
 The church was restored in 1948 and was refurnished with the organ from All Saints Church nearby. 
 All Saints Church had been erected in 1876&ndash;8, but after being damaged during World War II, it was demolished and most of its parish was combined with that of St Barnabas so that the latter church was renamed All Saints and St Barnabas. 
 In the post-war years and partly in consequence of much local redevelopment, congregations declined and the church was eventually declared redundant in the early 1980s. 
 The building and its site were purchased from the Church Commissioners by the Society for Co-operative Dwellings, a secondary housing co-operative, in mid-1983. 
 The society-s proposal to convert the church into dwellings followed on from the same sponsor's conversion of a similar local and redundant Anglican church, St James's, Knatchbull Road, Stockwell Park. 
 SCD acted on behalf of a primary housing co-operative, Ekarro Housing Co-operative, who were active in the area, housing single people referred to them by various caring agencies. 
 They had already purchased and converted the adjacent vicarage into twelve dwellings and seized the chance to convert the church to provide more units to house the majority of the co-operative on one site. 
 In the early 1980s, such churches were not yet recognised as vehicles for providing housing and this ignorance of the potential of All Saints and St Barnabas generated a low purchase price which was a vital element in making the financing of this publicly funded scheme work within accepted limits. 
 The support of the client co-operative,, the local planning authority and the earlier experience at St James's, Knatchbull Road, helped to persuade the Housing Corporation to fund the scheme. 
 Quite independent of the social merits of re-using a redundant building to provide comfortable dwellings for local people at modest rents, a main factor encouraging the retention of All Saints Church was the value accorded by the local authority planners to the building for its contribution to the townscape. 
 In this respect the Planning Department preferred the &bquo;permanent&equo; use offered by conversion to rented housing to a transitory use, such as might result from re-use of the building as, say, a carpet sales warehouse. 
 In fact, the alternative course open to the Church Commissioners of demolition of the building and sale of the site might not have been easily pursued, had they chosen to adopt that route. 
 Although All Saints is not a listed building, it lies within a conservation area so that any proposal to demolish it would have been subject to same scrutiny as plans for the demolition of a listed building. 
 It is far from clear that the necessary Listed Building Consent for demolition would have been forthcoming from the local authority. 
 By the same token, in contrast to the conversion of St James's, Knatchbull Road, where 50 per cent of the cost of external repairs to this listed building was met by English Heritage, only 25 per cent of the cost of this work at All Saints was covered by a central government grant. 
 Funds were also provided by Lambeth Council as the local Inner City Partnership Authority, for the execution of landscaping and external works. 
 Fortunately, the church did not have the problems or liabilities which result from the existence of an associated graveyard. 
 Although an adjoining area of ground had been purchased for this purpose, it was never developed as a burial ground and its virgin state allowed the Ekarro Housing Co-operative to complement the conversion of All Saints and St Barnabas with a new building, in the style of the surrounding villas, accommodating further flats for co-operative members (Plate 26). 
 The total contract cost of the church conversion and the adjacent new building was of the order of &pound;1.25 million and the work extended over twenty-one months. 
 The accommodation provided through the conversion of All Saints and St Barnabas comprises 25 flats, consisting of 4 bed-sitters, 2 single-bedroom units, 8 double-bedroom units, 5 two-study-bedroom units, 2 three-study-bedroom units, 2 two-double-bedroom units, 1 three-bedroom unit and 1 single-bedroom unit, the last two dwellings being sited at ground-floor level for the use of disabled people. 
 The planning principles adopted included keeping the common circulation areas and services central &mdash; all-internal kitchens and bathrooms back on to the spinal corridor which occupies the central strip of the former nave space (Fig 45). 
 To obtain additional internal volume and a satisfactory relationship between new floor levels and existing or modified window openings, the original ground floor, which consisted of two panels of suspended timber construction under the areas formerly accommodating pews, separated and flanked by strips of tiled floor on a solid base where the gangways ran, was removed to give a further 400mm (16in) of height. 
 The resulting cavity below the central ground floor corridor has been used to house horizontal drain-runs and other services. 
 Naturally, the new dwellings had to be so arranged as to satisfy the requirements of building regulations and a significant stipulation of the old Constructional By-laws for Inner London under which this design was produced, related to the amount of daylight which must be admitted to habitable rooms. 
 The requirement of the old London Building Acts was that an area of window equal to at least 10 per cent of its floor area should be provided to light a habitable room. 
 This requirement is continued by the current Building Regulations (1985). 
 Thus it can be seen that there is a clear relationship between the depth of each habitable room which is confined to the width of a church's nave arcade bay and the usable area of the related existing window in the side wall. 
 It is common for these perforations in the broad surfaces of church external walls to be small. 
 At All Saints and St Barnabas the difficulty of a comparatively small total area of existing windows failing to light adequately a much increased area of floor-space has been overcome in two ways. 
 First, the reduction of the ground-floor level so that five storeys could be accommodated satisfactorily in the building height meant that the new first floor would cut across the aisle windows if they were left unmodified. 
 As the existing windows were more than large enough to light the second-storey accommodation to building regulations standards, it was decided to shorten these openings. 
 The enlarged opaque panel thus formed below each of these &bquo;paired lancet&equo; windows was then perforated with a new opening containing a steel-framed French window to admit light to each living-room of the outer ranges of ground floor rooms (Plate 27). 
 Secondly, the third-floor accommodation, lit only by the small clerestory windows of the nave (composed of shallower paired lancets), managed to obtain the necessary amount of daylight from the glazing being placed at the rear of the original traceried stonework where the splayed internal window-revels generate an area exposed to daylight which is larger than the window area seen from outside (Fig 46). 
 Services and Construction 
 Individual gas supplies were not provided in the services included in the rebuilding, partly because of the difficulties in projecting the resultant chimneys and flues through the external surfaces &mdash; the appearance of which was closely watched by officials of English Heritage. 
 The dwellings are heated by communal gas boilers, the fuel used being heat-metered into each flat &mdash; occupants have the option of reducing or suspending the flow of the low-pressure hot water central hearing &mdash; while a &bquo;landlord's meter&equo; records the amount of heat used in common areas. 
 The structure of the &bquo;infilling&equo; construction relies on support provided by new load-bearing masonry cross-walls which were installed in this lateral alignment on the centre-lines of the nave piers. 
 &bquo;Separating&equo; floors &mdash; ie, those which separate one &bquo;layer&equo; of dwellings from the flats located above or below &mdash; are of concrete construction and most of the new concrete floors were executed by laying down pre-cast concrete planks which then received a steel-reinforced concrete screed as a structural topping. 
 As the existing and new foundations are founded on a common &bquo;ballast&equo; subsoil, it was not found necessary to install movement joints between the new and the old constructions, although this policy was adopted in the reconstruction of St James's, Knatchbull Road. 
 Where individual dwellings have intermediate floors, these were carried out in traditional timber joisted construction, the joists being hung from the new masonry cross-walls on joist-hangers. 
 In addition to the residential accommodation, the converted church includes an entrance and main stair lobby which extends to the full height of the north aisle, incorporates two arches of the original nave arcade and gives an impressive indication of the powerful verticality of the original church interior. 
 An adjoining one-and-a-half-storey-high common-room and a laundry associated with the rear entrance are also provided for the use of residents. 
 Constructional problems which were encountered during the contract included the discovery of the serious decay of a considerable area of the Kentish ragstone facing. 
 Where this problem was found at high level on the aisle gable walls, it was owed to a poor constructional detail. 
 The original stones of the sloping gable coping had simply been bedded on the slate-roof covering of the aisles at their verges so that rain entering the joints between the coping stones had saturated the top courses of the stone facing and caused premature decay. 
 This condition has been corrected by replacing the defective detail with a conventional sloping stone coping oversailing a &bquo;secret gutter&equo; of in situ lead which terminates the new roof slating, the new coping being bedded on an impervious damp-proof course (Plates 28 and 29). 
 Replacement of the eroded ragstone facing could have provided a problem were it not for the fact that the builder who was employed to undertake the conversion was dismantling an identically constructed church at Canterbury at the same time and thus it was possible to import salvaged ragstone from the demolition for re-use at All Saints and St Barnabas. 
 As this description of the reason for the decay of the stonework suggests, the original roof surfaces also presented increasing problems and complete replacement of the roof slating was necessary. 
 In contrast to the policy adopted at St James's, Knatchbull Road, it was decided to re-roof All Saints and St Barnabas with natural slates rather than the cheaper synthetic slates that had been used on the earlier project. 
 In this way, slates salvaged in the process of stripping the roof could be re-used, and, in fact, one complete nave roof-slope was reslated with salvaged material. 
 Because the salvaged slates were of a size which is not readily obtainable today, the other roof-slope was reclad with new Welsh slates of conventional &bquo;Countess&equo; dimensions; 500x250mm (20 x 10in). 
 The different sizes of slate used on each main roof-slope is of little consequence because the two surfaces cannot be seen together. 
 Because All Saints and St Barnabas has a broadly symmetrical plan and it is therefore logical to dispose dwellings to either side of a spinal corridor, the church has been converted in accordance with this principle at the lowest levels where the cross-section is widest (Fig 47). 
 In conformity with the conventional treatment, where the cross-section narrows from a church with a central nave and side aisles at the lower levels to a narrow, lofty nave only at upper levels, optimum use is made of this space by filling it with a single range of dwellings. 
 Because it is a high volume, it is usually necessary to install two-storey units in this space (compare St James Court, Farnham). 
 In the case of the very high void at All Saints and St Barnabas, three-storey units take up most of the volume. 
 This arrangement denies natural light to the body of the spinal corridors which serve the ground-, first- and second-floor dwellings, giving them an institutional quality that is only slightly reduced by the relief from the cellular treatment of space offered by the lofty entrance lobby and main staircase space at the west end. 
 Nevertheless, the insertion of twenty-five comfortable and characterful dwellings into the complicated interior of this church is a tour-de-force of three-dimensional geometry. 
 The &bquo;collegiate&equo; quality of the three-level dwellings which are sited in the topmost section of the nave and which are reached via integral winding staircases is particularly delightful. 
 The project architect was Angela Clemo of Southbank Architects who continued the work following the reconstitution of the Society for Co-operative Dwellings into a secondary housing co-operative which does not offer in-house architectural services. 
 The builder was R. Durtnell Ltd. 
 Schools 
 Specialised buildings for the education of children have a relatively short history in Britain. 
 Throughout the greater part of the nineteenth century, most people were averse to official intervention in social and family affairs and the Victorian age can be seen as an era in which individualism was the leading social ethic. 
 The two main political parties &mdash; Tories and Liberals &mdash; agreed on a minimal role for the state in the nation's affairs. 
 It was widely believed that if the individual was allowed to follow his own interests, within the law of the land, then general good would result. 
 Yet many people in Victorian Britain were not indifferent to the widening divisions between rich and poor that seemed to be a consequence of this ideology. 
 Most saw it as an evil, although the ways suggested to combat the condition varied greatly. 
 Eventually, it was recognised that some of the results of the laissez-faire mentality could pose a threat to social stability and the health of rich and poor alike. 
 Hence there was an extension of the powers of local government and the state intervened after 1870 to provide universal elementary education. 
 The establishment of a system of elementary education available to all the country's children was one of the great achievements of late Victorian Britain.. 
 Before W. E. Forster's Elementary Education Act of 1870, educational provision was haphazard. 
 Secondary education was available for the more fortunate and higher education was reserved for the privileged few. 
 In early Victorian times illiteracy was widespread. 
 The churches played a significant part in dealing with this condition and the parish schools were the most important providers of elementary education. 
 They were were usually built with donations from private individuals, many prompted by charitable feelings, others by the belief that education was an antidote to revolution. 
 Government grants became available later in the period to assist all denominations to establish schools. 
 The parish school was usually small and relied on one teacher, whose small house was often part of the school buildings. 
 The school master might be assisted by an unqualified &bquo;pupil-teacher&equo;. 
 There was a shortage of trained teachers and the planning of schools reflected this circumstance; most of the instruction was done in a large school-room, off which there might be one or two classrooms which were used for teaching smaller groups. 
 A larger school might have separate school-rooms for boys and girls. 
 An entrance porch, cloakrooms and lavatories made up the rest of the accommodation. 
 The simplest arrangement is apparent in the original building of the village school at Shawell, Leicestershire, the conversion of which is described and illustrated later in this chapter. 
 The original fabric of Shawell school also displays another quality that is characteristic of mid-Victorian church schools &mdash; the neo-Gothic style of architecture. 
 An urban example of this type of school, St Peter's at Vauxhall, South London, is also described in this chapter. 
 Probably the adoption of the Gothic style for church schools is not so surprising when it is considered that the design of schools was a subject in which the influential Ecclesiological Society &mdash; the significant impact of whose views on church design has already been referred to &mdash; was prepared to interest itself. 
 In an article of 1847 in its journal, The Ecclesiologist , the society advocated a separate roof for the school-room and the headmaster's house with the classroom set at right-angles to it and a lean-to cloakroom. 
 Separation of the sexes was also considered desirable where this could be achieved. 
 The school should be &bquo;the prettiest building in the village next to the church&equo;. 
 Of course in conformity with ecclesiological principles, schools were expected to be in the Gothic style. 
 High Anglican architects such as William Butterfield (1814&ndash;1900) and George Edmund Street (1824&ndash;81) took up these ideas and produced a series of parish schools which combine simple planning and construction with details they had developed for church architecture. 
 The elevations, as well as the planning, are frequently extremely plain. 
 In St Peter's school at Vauxhall which is described later, we see the work of another very talented church architect, John Loughborough Pearson (1817&ndash;97). 
 The design of Victorian village schools often manifests a concern for the use of local building materials and the desire to create a picturesque silhouette. 
 In the vast majority of these buildings, the entire accommodation was single storey, the central schoolroom being lit by very high, arched windows located in the gables. 
 The problem of designing parish schools in towns was greater. 
 Often they are not unlike village schools, but where space was limited on a cramped city-centre site, multi-storeyed buildings were erected. 
 In an extreme case, it might be necessary to put the playground on the roof. 
 J. L. Pearson avoided this arrangement at St Peter's by confining the two-storey teaching accommodation to the perimeter of the wedge-shaped site at the rear of his church, the central &bquo;spine&equo; of the plan linking the blocks on the east and west site boundaries to create two largely internal courtyards which operated as children's playgrounds (Fig 53). 
 Like Shawell school, St Peter's was built in the 1860s and so preceded the Elementary Education Act of 1870 that called for large numbers of schools, mainly in crowded urban areas, to be built with public rather than private money. 
 London, for example, had over four hundred such Board schools by 1895. 
 Many of them were designed by E. R. Robson (1835&ndash;1917) who was the first architect to the London School Board. 
 Robson's work was influential, partly because in 1874 he published School Architecture , a book in which he illustrated a number of London Board schools. 
 As they often occupy cramped sites, London Board schools are usually multi-storey buildings. 
 In their planning they retain the large central school-room, but the provision of classrooms is greater than the norm established by the church schools. 
 The members of the School Boards were more secular in their thinking than the builders of the earlier parish schools, and although some designers used the Gothic style, it was argued that &bquo;&hellip; a continuation of the semi-ecclesiastical style&hellip; would appear to be inappropriate and lacking in anything to mark the great change which is coming over the education of the country&equo;. 
 The new &bquo;Queen Anne&equo; manner of the time seemed to be a style that would permit greater freedom of planning and lacked the associations with religion evoked by neo-Gothic forms. 
 The London Board schools were usually built of yellow London stock brick with red brick dressings, although the later buildings, and the majority of contemporary schools erected in provincial cities, were carried out entirely in red brick. 
 Tall, white-painted window frames, subdivided by many glazing bars, were placed under segmental arches of red brickwork and the most prominent features were the high gables which gave the buildings a varied and lively skyline. 
 This craggy silhouette invariably was further enhanced with tall chimney stacks and, often, a crowning bellcote, cupola or turreted staircase towers. 
 Most of the early London Board schools have been replaced or altered and most of those which survive remain in use as schools. 
 However, the inner city depopulation of recent years has led to falling rolls in city schools and the consequent rationalisation of local education has caused certain Board schools to become redundant, releasing them for alternative uses. 
 In Bethnal Green, in East London, two such schools at Olga Street and Bow Brook, have been converted into dwellings. 
 The planning principle of converting the barrack-like main blocks of these buildings into flats has been the exploitation of the 4.2m (14ft) standard height of each classroom by siting a mezzanine &bquo;sleeping gallery&equo; on the internally located kitchenette/bathroom areas, overlooking a &bquo;double-height&equo; living-room which is lit by the large and lofty classroom windows. 
 An identical approach has been adopted in the conversion into flats of the former Ducie High School, Greenheys, Manchester. 
 The conversion to a house of the former village school at Airton, in the Yorkshire Dales, which is one of the following case studies, shows how a similarly &bquo;standard&equo; type of local authority school &mdash; in this case in a rural location &mdash; can be transformed into a convenient and characterful dwelling without adversely affecting its external appearance. 
 The Old School, Shawell, Leicestershire 
 Shawell is a small village close to the boundary of Leicestershire with both Warwickshire and Northamptonshire. 
 As an old-established settlement, it had boasted its own school since 1604 and the schoolmaster's house of this date, although much altered, survives on an adjoining site. 
 The school was founded as the result of a bequest made by a local landowner, John Elkington Esq, and a copy of his will, dated 2 April 1604, is in the possession of the present owners of the school, Mr and Mrs Goddard. 
 Although the surviving school building as of much later date, it has a fairly complicated history. 
 A school-room of brick construction was erected on the site of the ancient building in 1862. 
 A simple, single school-room with an entrance porch on the east side, it catered for the children of Shawell and the surrounding villages until after World War I. It is significant that even such a simple building as this was not immune from the stylistic preferences of contemporary architects and the steeply pitched roof-slopes of the schoolroom are &bquo;stratified&equo; with bands of alternating plain and fish-scale pattern tiles in true &bquo;High Victorian&equo; fashion. 
 This treatment is shown clearly in the photograph of the east elevation, taken in Edwardian times, with the schoolchildren crowding the entrance steps (Plate 31). 
 Similarly, the three-light windows below pointed arches and the brickwork of the otherwise plain gables is relieved by a diaper pattern formed in &bquo;header&equo; bricks of contrasting colour. 
 By 1922 the single school-room was no longer adequate to meet the needs of the local school population, so the full width of the building was extended eastwards under a pair of pitched roofs to create a second classroom, head-teacher's room and internal side entrance lobby replacing the demolished attached porch (Plate 32). 
 The final alteration came in 1959 when, at long last, internal WCs serving the staff and pupils were added in a single-storey flat-roofed extension to the south. 
 It will be appreciated that even after these enlargement, Shawell school was not a large building. 
 When a new junior school was built in a nearby village in the late 1970s, the building became redundant. 
 The present owners knew the village through visits to a local pub and became aware that the old school was standing empty. 
 Their offer to buy the building was accepted by the Leicestershire County Council and they moved onto the building in 1981. 
 Since then they have been effecting a gradual programme of repair, restoration and alteration. 
 It was plain that the existing accommodation &mdash; two classrooms separated by a half-glazed folding partition, a head teacher's office and WC block &mdash; did not provide an arrangement that could be easily adapted to give convenient living space. 
 An essential first step was to create a bedroom and this was formed from the larger part of the former WC block. 
 By retaining the other elements of the plan of this block, the main entrance that had been created in 1959 could be maintained as the &bquo;front door&equo; with the bathroom/WC being reached from the adjacent entrance hall (Fig 48). 
 It was similarly easy to convert the head-teacher's office into a kitchen adjoining the side-entrance lobby. 
 This left a suitable strategy for conversion of the former classrooms to be decided. 
 Because twin gables flanking a central valley gutter had been adopted to cap the elevation of the 1922 extension, it was not possible to form an upper storey in this section. 
 Fortunately, the classroom located below this block was the smaller of the two, and because it adjoined the kitchen, it made a logical dining-room. 
 To the rear of the glazed, folding partition lay the larger, higher volume of the original school-room. 
 It was believed that this area offered more opportunities for conversion into convenient living space. 
 However, the most significant obstacles to this plan were the deep trusses of heavy timbers which spanned the roof space at two locations to brace purlins supporting the rafters of each roof-slope (Fig 49). 
 Instead of giving a clear internal height of 6.9 (22&ndash;1/2ft) (extending up into the apex of the roof space), headroom beneath these two trusses was reduced to 4.4m (14ft) at the junction of their curved braces with the tie-beams, thus denying the opportunity to install two storeys of habitable accommodation at these points. 
 To make optimum use of the volume, an ingenious device was employed. 
 It seemed sensible to reserve each end bay of the roof space for a bedroom, lit by a new window installed either in an adjacent roof-slope or in the flanking gable. 
 Each bedroom would be reached via a staircase sited in the central bay, but headroom for a lower-storey living-room could not be achieved below this stair and still give an adequate height for a door opening beneath the truss tie-beams, allowing unobstructed access from the main landing into the bedrooms. 
 Thus the stair was installed with a mezzanine-level landing, giving a headroom below of only 2.05m (6&ndash;1/2ft) &mdash; ie, the height of a conventional internal door &mdash; and allowing an equivalent headroom below the tie-beams of the roof trusses above. 
 A short flight of three steps beyond the line of each truss and to the rear of each bedroom door then ascends to the floor level of each end-bay bedroom (Fig 50). 
 In this way, the new upper floor is prevented from crossing the original three-light arched windows which serve the end bays of the lower storey, and the stair is prevented from conflicting with the central window of this range by the introduction of a further quarter-landing at an intermediate level that turns its lowest flight parallel to the side elevation at a level just below the window-sill (Fig 49). 
 The area below the stair then becomes part of the lounge, extending back from the glazed folding doors that separate it from the dining-room (Fig 48). 
 To introduce daylight into each of the new upper-storey bedrooms, instead of puncturing the patterned brickwork of the gables, it was decided to construct large dormer windows matching the style of the existing windows of the lower storey. 
 these have been installed under new steeply pitched roofs which harmonise with the form of the main roof (Plate 33). 
 The cost of installing these features and retiling the remainder of the roof was assisted by a Repairs Grant provided by the local authority. 
 The need for remedial work on the roof covering became apparent when the worn-out lead valley gutters began to leak, although discomfort from this source had to be endured for almost two years until the Repairs Grant was awarded. 
 Perhaps the regrettable feature of the conversion of Shawell school &mdash; which is being carried out with great care and sensitivity &mdash; is the retention of the 1950s flat-roofed WCs extension which, almost gratuitously, fails to relate in any way to the form of the original building. 
 It is unfortunate that the space enclosed by the 1862 building, together with its 1922 extension, was too small or too lacking in services provision to offer a convenient corner for installation of the new bathroom and WC. 
 The logical re-use of existing services has led to the retention of the overly utilitarian postwar outshot when it would have been better to demolish it and to restore the four-square appearance of the pre-war building. 
 Village School, Airton, North Yorkshire 
 This village junior school, built to a standard county council plan in the inter-war period, like Shawell school, was converted into a dwelling by the efforts of the occupants. 
 The building was purchased by a local clothing manufacturer to provide a family dwelling and a small office for the administration of his company. 
 Like Shawell school, it is a high-roofed structure, but it is slightly more complicated in having a T-shaped plan (Fig 51). 
 Separate entrances for boys and girls were located in the small north wing which forms the leg of the &bquo;T&equo; (Plate 34). 
 In 1980, the owner approached a local architect, John Wharton, to provide him with a design that could be easily executed by direct labour and it was immediately apparent that exploitation of the high volume of the main east-west wing of the building would be the best way of obtaining the maximum accommodation. 
 Although the apex of the pitched roof of this wing was 6.5m (21ft) above floor level, unlike the arrangement that applies at Shawell school, the internal space did not extend up to the roof ridge-board. 
 A broad central strip of flat ceiling existing above the classrooms to give a maximum headroom of only 4.3m (14ft) which could not be divided horizontally to give two storeys of habitable room-height. 
 Hence it was decided to remove this ceiling and its supporting joists and to resite it at a higher level. 
 This was achieved by installing new ceiling joists, at 400mm (16in) centres, bearing on the top surfaces of the large purlins that support the rafters at the centre of their span. 
 Following the installation of a suspended ceiling of plasterboard and plaster skim coat below these joists, a headroom of 2.6m (8&ndash;1/2ft) could be achieved in the new upper storey, the floor of which was formed from boards nailed to 50 x 150mm (2 x 6in) joists at 400mm (16in) centres. 
 Below this floor, a headroom of more than 2.4m (8ft) resulted in the residual lower-storey space. 
 The main east-west wing of the school originally accommodated two classrooms &mdash; as at Shawell, divided by a glazed, sliding-folding partition. 
 Above this central partition lay a heavy timber roof-truss, supporting the purlins and extending down to suspended ceiling level. 
 As it was impractical to remove this essential structural element, the new first-floor construction had to terminate on this line, so the added floor was restricted to the east side of the central truss. 
 The western half of this wing could then be dedicated to a &bquo;double-height&equo; living-room with French windows opening out, through a deepened former window opening, on to the garden. 
 Hence, over this section, it was not necessary to remove the existing ceiling, but a desire to emphasise the still lofty volume of this room caused the client to request the insertion of a &bquo;minstrel's gallery&equo; upper level over part of this area. 
 By the introduction of a 75 x 75mm (3 x 3in) square-section hollow steel post sited close to the centre of the room for the support of heavy timber trimmers, it was possible to construct a gallery which extends between the flank walls on modestly-sized 38 x 150mm (1&ndash;1/2 x 6in) joists, carrying boards which give a platform 2m (6&ndash;1/2ft) wide overlooking the larger part of the living-room. 
 Headroom equivalent to door head-height could just be achieved both below and above this gallery and under the retained ceiling. 
 Access to the gallery is obtained via a removable ladder. 
 The remainder of the upper-storey accommodation, which was created at a slightly higher level in the eastern half of the main east-west wing, is reached from the ground floor via a spiral stair. 
 It comprises two single bedrooms and a double bedroom. 
 At ground-floor level, the stair devolves into a central hall, from which access is gained to the single lower-storey bedroom, a waiting lobby associated with the office, and the bathroom/WC as well as the living-room which is reached by passing below the gallery. 
 Also reached through a door located below the gallery is the kitchen, which re-uses the former &bquo;Boys' Entrance&equo; to the school as the new main entrance to the dwelling. 
 Apart from housing the bathroom/WC and the kitchen, there is sufficient space in the small norther wing of the school for a small utility room to be provided en suite with the kitchen. 
 Apart from the deepening and modification of the existing central window openings of each main gable to create garden access doors, the only other alterations to the external appearance were modifications to the existing very high classroom windows of the east and south elevations to reconcile them with the newly inserted upper floor and gallery. 
 Because these two constructions are at different levels, the existing fixed and &bquo;hopper-vent&equo; windows of eight lights were removed and replaced with sash-pattern frames incorporating top-hung, open-out casements, boarded panels infilling the gap between the head of the lower-storey vent and the sill of the upper-storey window (Plate 35). 
 As there is a trio of high and narrow lights in each main gable, the problem of reconciling this glazing with the added upper floor was less critical than in a case where large windows, surmounted by pointed arches, occupy the gables &mdash; this is almost a standard feature of Victorian village schools. 
 As applies with the treatment of such windows in the western gables of churches, it is probably kinder to the existing architecture to avoid a &bquo;collision&equo; between the new floor and the broad and high-arched opening. 
 In most cases of the conversion of schools that incorporate this feature, the owners have wisely left space between the edge of the added floor and the window to give a mezzanine platform overlooking a &bquo;double-height&equo; living-room, as in the arrangement adopted at the west end of the main wing of Airton school. 
 Because the stone-built, partly render-clad building proved to be extremely sound, little alteration to the exterior or renewal of materials was necessary. 
 Indeed, it was even found possible to reuse the characteristic roof-top ventilator of the school-room as the vented enclosure in which to terminate internally located pipes that provide fresh air to the new bedrooms. 
 St Peter's School, Vauxhall, London SE11 
 The church of St Peter, Vauxhall, was built between 1863 and 1865 on part of the area formerly occupied by the Vauxhall Pleasure Gardens; its altar is on the site of the Neptune Fountain, and the late-eighteenth-century house which adjoins the church and is now the vicarage was originally the home of the manager of the gardens. 
 Its architect was J. L. Pearson, a highly accomplished church designer, most of whose work was for the &bquo;High Church&equo; wing of Anglicanism. 
 Because the established church played a major role in the provision of education before the passing of the Elementary Education Act of 1870, it is not surprising that the lofty, brick-built church of St Peter shares its site with a school. 
 The site is shaped like a truncated wedge and Pearson placed the majority of the school buildings along its east and north sides. 
 However, this does not provide sufficient accommodation, so a high two-storey wing was erected on the west boundary and was linked across to the eastern range by a short &bquo;spinal&equo; block, creating two courtyards following completion of the church, for the erection of the school preceded construction of the church by two years. 
 The northern courtyard, with a fairly open aspect to the west, was the boys' playground, while the south court provided a play area for the girls. 
 The building not only accommodated schools for boys and girls, but also an art school and a soup kitchen (later converted into a school-room). 
 Alterations to Pearson's design were made by the architect J. T. Knowles in 1873. 
 Over the years, the buildings were subject to many more changes and extensions as facilities were added or improved. 
 The aspect of the north playground to the west was largely lost with the construction of an independent WC block, and part of the eastern range fronting St Oswald's Place, which originally accommodated the art school, was rebuilt as a flat-roofed block after bomb damage during World War II (Plate 36). 
 In terms of consistency of architectural style, this was a regrettable change, because Pearson's carefully crafted High Victorian Gothic treatment of tall sash-windows spanned by pointed arches of &bquo;polychromatic&equo; brickwork was replaced by a much more utilitarian brick &bquo;box&equo;, fenestrated with standard steel-framed casements arranged horizontally and contrasting strongly with the pre-existing forms. 
 The development of more modern schools in the locality, combined with falling numbers of pupils from this depopulating &bquo;inner city&equo; area, caused the closure of the school in 1977. 
 The north wing of the otherwise redundant building was leased to a gymnasium/health club. 
 In 1982, the school was put on the market by the agents to the Church Commissioners and the Inner London Education Authority. 
 At that time, Russell Mills, an artist who was looking for a dwelling that would be large enough also to provide studio space, realised that the building might subdivide suitably to meet, at low cost, the similar needs of fellow artists and designers. 
 With the help of an architect, Tony Fretton, he deduced that even if the north wing continued as a gymnasium, the remainder of the accommodation would divide satisfactorily into six residential/studio units. 
 Despite the fact that only three weeks were available between his first viewing of the premises and the date for submission of offers, Russell Mills managed to find five collaborators, and their tender succeeded in competition against bids from office developers, engineering firms and an art college. 
 The would-be occupants and their architect had successfully, demonstrated to the vendors that the character of the Grade II listed building would remain undisturbed by its conversion into dwellings. 
 The six participants also took a risk in buying the building without planning permission, but some months later they obtained consent for change of use from school premises to residential/studio units and the architect was able to instruct a builder to commence Stage 1 &mdash; the conversion of the building into six basic, serviced &bquo;shells&equo;. 
 This stage of the work took nine months. 
 The north wing of the school would have made three extra units, but as it was rented out to the health club, the new owners decided to maintain this arrangement. 
 Because it is not possible for more than four people to share a freehold, the owners of each of the six units formed themselves into a management company in order to buy the building; each became a director of the company and was given a 999-year lease of his or her dwelling. 
 The purchase price of each unit was chiefly related to its area, although other factors entered in, such as the amenity offered by the single private garden. 
 It was also clear that some of the new occupants needed studios with specific qualities. 
 For instance, two potters who share a unit required ground-floor premises to accommodate their heavy kiln and to allow easy access from the street for the delivery of materials. 
 Similarly, a photographer who also occupies a ground-floor unit needed a huge room that could operate as a photographic studio. 
 A designer chose the only flat with a garden and a fashion consultant, Juliet Mann, who is similarly keen on horticulture, chose the only unit with a flat roof so that she could establish a roof-top conservatory above her flat. 
 From the start, the participants decided that firm agreements should be made in advance in writing. 
 Thus, their solicitor drew up a document detailing joint responsibility for communal maintenance of roofs, courtyards and external paintwork. 
 Money from the rent of the gymnasium is put back into the company to pay for repairs, contract window-cleaning and other matters of mutual concern. 
 If any of the present owners wish to sell their share of the converted building, the remaining directors must approve the new purchaser, but otherwise the dwellings can be sold in the normal way. 
 It is clear that a main attraction of the project for its participants was the opportunity offered to obtain a large amount of space in a Central London location for a modest outlay. 
 In fact, the average size of unit 110sq m (1,200sq ft) and since the school was purchased in 1982 for &pound;162,000, an average-size unit cost &pound;27,000. 
 However, all the new occupants were faced with considerable expense in converting their areas of the building into habitable accommodation because each newly formed unit lacked even basic services provision, and by 1986 most people had spent an additional &pound;55&ndash;60,000 on their conversion. 
 Tony Fretton, the architect who had devised the original division of areas to form six units and who had advised on the allocation of flats, was retained by both Russell Mills and Juliet Mann to design the interiors of their dwellings. 
 Russell and Ann Mills' flat is particularly impressive as it is located on the upper floor of the school's west wing (Plate 37 and Fig 53) and so extends up into the apex of the steeply-pitched roof. 
 The vast room of 21.3 x 5.4m (70 x 18ft) had been divided into three classrooms separated by half-glazed partitions. 
 One of these was removed to form the large general living area, at the end of which is the dining table, with the kitchen hidden behind panelling formed from painted tongue-and-groove boarding. 
 The partitioned end of the room is north-facing and makes an ideal studio, lit, as it is, by the original tall neo-Gothic windows. 
 The architect has cleverly preserved the integrity of the lofty space by restricting an inserted upper level to the central section of the room. 
 This zone accommodates a double bedroom with en suite bathroom and, being mainly in the roof space, is lit by a large new roof-light. 
 The necessary insulation of the thin roof construction against heat loss was achieved by draping a glass-fibre quilt, laminated with aluminium foil, beneath the rafters. 
 The silvery underside of this material is exposed to the interiors of the studio and living/dining areas, but these are such lofty spaces that this inexpensive treatment does not detract from their grandeur. 
 The colour scheme is monochromatic throughout in accordance with Russell Mills' preference to keep the space &bquo;&hellip; clear and simple, everything visually quiet&equo;. 
 Selective demolition of some post-Victorian accretions (like the independent WC block on the western boundary) helped to make the building more suitable for its new use, but otherwise external alterations were very modest. 
 This follows the ethic pursued in the conversion of similarly old city-centre premises in New York of leaving exteriors more or less alone so as not to attract attention. 
 Other than some waterwashing of the exuberant polychromatic brick arch that surmounts the entrance to the former south playground (now the communal car park), no cleaning of external brickwork has been undertaken. 
 In the same way, only modest repairs were needed to the steeply pitched slated roofs &mdash; wholesale reroofing was not necessary. 
 The northern playground is in the process of being transformed into a communal garden as earth and foliage replace characterless tarmac. 
 The scheme is an impressive realisation of the idea of combining uses within units contained in a single building &mdash; in this case, living space and craft/design studios. 
 However, it must be emphasised that the flexibility shown by the local authority in approving this combination of residential and occupational functions within individual units is very unusual and was probably encouraged by the planners' recognition that this approach could act to conserve a listed building with the least possible alteration of its character. 
 The combination of different uses in separate parts of one building, rather than within individual units, is dealt with in the final chapter. 
 Mills, Factories and Warehouses 
 Probably the most common type of conversion project at the present time is the adaptation of a mill or warehouse into a block of dwellings. 
 The riverside warehouses of the London docklands have become favourite subjects for this treatment during the last decade and an outstanding conversion of one such building &mdash; Thames Tunnel Mills &mdash; is described in this chapter, while the final chapter of the book contains an analysis of a similar building that has been converted to house a range of new uses, including sixty apartments. 
 However, conversion of more modest manufacturing and storage buildings into individual dwellings has occurred over many years &mdash; possibly even centuries. 
 It will be appreciated that before widespread industrialisation, the erection of highly specialised buildings was something of a rarity. 
 It used to be the normal practice to adapt buildings for different purposes over their lives. 
 Evidence of the logical development of this practice can also be found in one ow two early industrial buildings. 
 At least one small nineteenth-century factory in Dentorn, Greater Manchester, as an area noted for the manufacture of hats, was built with certain architectural features included so that it might easily be converted into a terrace of houses. 
 should there be a downturn in trade. 
 Only since the general adoption of the policy of specialisation engendered by the Industrial Revolution has it become common to demolish and rebuild rather than to adapt and extend. 
 So natural had this practice become that only in the past fifteen or twenty years has there grown up in Britain the idea of conserving redundant industrial and commercial buildings and putting them to new uses. 
 Early candidates for this treatment among industrial buildings, and prior to the enthusiasms of the last twenty years. 
 were traditional watermills and windmills which had become redundant with the introduction of steam, and later electrical power. 
 Before describing the opportunities and shortcomings of such structures for conversion to domestic use, it is necessary to say something about the process of grinding grain to produce flour, because the anatomy of these buildings was dictated by this process. 
 Corn-milling is one of the oldest and most necessary human occupations. 
 The main good grains on which we depend for an essential part of our daily diet come from plants belonging to the family of grasses and cannot be readily digested until the tough outer shells are broken up and, sometimes, removed. 
 A grain of wheat, for example, consists essentially of three parts: the bran, made up of several outer coverings, the germ (the embryo of the new plant) and the endosperm, the starchy centre which is made into flour. 
 Various methods have been developed to break open such cereal grains and to extract flour. 
 During the Iron Age, the first rotary mill appeared in Britain. 
 It consisted of a stationary lower bed stone and an upper stone that was turned above it while grain was fed through a central hole or &bquo;eye&equo; in the top stone. 
 The grain was ground between the faces of the stones which came to be grooved to give a better cutting action, and the ground meal was distributed to the outside edge of the stones for collection. 
 This method of grinding grain had to await the human skill to fabricate tools from two materials because three wooden parts were essential to the rotary mill: the rynd  which bridged the eye of the runner stone and enabled it to be hung on top of the wooden spindle , and the handle , used for turning the running stone. 
 The spindle, projecting upwards from the centre of the bed stone, was at first fixed to carry the runner stone a little above the bed stone, but later the elevation of the spindle could be altered to allow regulation of the gap between the stones and so control the fineness of the meal. 
 The rynd and the spindle soon came to be made from iron to be more durable, and the handle was developed to become a lever for turning the runner stone by animal power. 
 Eventually, the handle was superseded by a power drive applied to the spindle, and its successor is the central shaft of all windmills and watermills. 
 Water power was first used to turn millstones about two thousand years ago, the earliest waterwheels being horizontal, fixed to the projecting lower end of the spindle. 
 From the first century AD, the principles of gearing were understood and used by the Romans, so that a horizontal millstone could be turned by a vertical waterwheel. 
 The Romans probably introduced the geared watermill and are first recorded in England during the last quarter of the twelfth century. 
 By the end of the thirteenth century, they were common landmarks in the English countryside. 
 During the eighteenth century, corn-milling had to keep pace with the growth of population and industry. 
 The form of mills had developed only slowly since the Middle Ages, but by the middle of the eighteenth century the technology of wind and water power was being investigated scientifically and there was competition for mill sites because of enlarging industrial needs. 
 Established corn mills often had first claim to the use of watercourses, but their machinery needed modernising to improve efficiency. 
 Steam power was first used to drive corn mills in the 1780s following its adoption in textile mills and the building of Albion Mill, beside the Thames at Blackfriars, London, in 1784, greatly influenced the development of milling. 
 It was the first purpose-built flour factory and had twenty sets of millstones driven by two steam-engines. 
 The success of Albion Mill marked the beginning of the move from the trade's dependence on small country watermills and windmills, often with only two or three sets of stones, to larger merchant mills built close to centres of corn trading and importing. 
 In the late nineteenth century, when vast quantities of grain were shipped into British ports from overseas, the milling industry became concentrated at ports and in towns with good canal, rail or road links. 
 The method of milling grain between two stones probably reached its peak in Britain in the watermills and windmills of the early nineteenth century. 
 The rival method of using metal rollers for milling corn had been tried as early as the sixteenth century but was generally only adopted for malt-milling until, in 1834, a Swiss engineer substituted rollers for the original stones in the reconstruction of an existing mill. 
 In consequence of his success, mills using both stones and rollers were built in Britain from the 1860s. 
 The first successful flour-manufacturing plant using only rollers was the Manchester mill established by Henry Simon in 1878. 
 By 1881 he had built the first fully automatic milling plant at Chester and from that time, mechanically powered roller-milling rapidly supplanted stone-milling in the mass production of flour. 
 In medieval times, bringing corn to the mill was the responsibility of the customer. 
 It was brought by the customers when required for use rather than all at once so that large-scale storage was not needed at the mills. 
 Horse-drawn and water-borne transport became important with the expansion of trade during the eighteenth century. 
 To simplify the handling of sacks of corn, facilities such as loading ramps, waggon bays and internal or external hoists that could lift sacks to the top of the mill for storage were installed. 
 Both windmills and watermills were built taller or larger to accommodate additional machinery and grain storage space, and an extra floor was often provided above the rest of the accommodation so that grain could be emptied into bulk storage bins and led through spouts to millstones as required. 
 In modern mills, grain is stored in silos which are often separate from the mill and near to a bulk intake point. 
 The business of manhandling sacks has been replaced by automation, the grain being conveyed mechanically or pneumatically direct to the mill. 
 Types of Mills 
 Windmills 
 Various types of windmill emerged, and it is possible to distinguish the characteristics of these among the survivors. 
 Post Mills were first built in the twelfth century and there is little difference in design between the early examples and those constructed in the nineteenth century. 
 Built mainly of wood, the rectangular boarded body of this type of mill turns on a central post to face the wind. 
 At the foot of the post are horizontal beams and diagonal beams to carry the weight of the uprights. 
 It is plain that such essentially lightweight structures, the form of which is determined almost entirely by operational considerations, may offer few opportunities for conversion into comfortable living accommodation. 
 Smock or frock mills are so called because their shape is said to resemble a man dressed in a smock. 
 Constructed from wood on a circular base, this type of mill was usually eight-sided, although six-, ten- and twelve-sided mills were also built. 
 In this type, only the cap of the mill and sails rotate to work the grinding stones, so the wooden walls are either sloped or battered to allow free movement of these elements. 
 These mills, which sometimes have a tarred brickwork plinth with the wooden structure painted white, are more frequently converted into houses than the less enduring post mills. 
 Tower mills are similar to smock mills in shape and working machinery, but brick or stone is used for the structure instead of wood. 
 Porous brickwork tower mills were often tarred against the weather and in Sussex they were frequently tile-hung. 
 Tower mills can be seen all over Britain, but south-east England houses more wooden smock mills. 
 In East Anglia, the Midlands and the North, stone and brick-built mills become more common. 
 Many mills in low-lying country were built to power drainage pumps. 
 Although many windmills have been converted to domestic use, it is plain that there are distinct limitations on the opportunities for winning convenient living accommodation from these structures. 
 A major constraint upon the straightforward re-use of a windmill as a dwelling is imposed by its circular or polygonal plan which tends to conflict with conventional cubical furniture and may only be reconciled satisfactorily with purpose-made, built-in fitting (Plate 40). 
 The cylindrical rooms which are logically formed within the tower at several levels are usually of quite small diameter &mdash; indeed, decreasing diameter the nearer they are to the top of the tower. 
 Windmills share these limitations with other cylindrical structures such as lighthouses and martello towers and these qualities have tended to cause most owners of these types of buildings to regard the tower form as only one element of a new house created from the salvaged structure, the remainder of the accommodation being a newly built extension which more suitably houses a spacious entrance hall, additional bedrooms and, possibly, an attached garage. 
 An example of such a conversion, in which the former windmill is only partly recognisable, has recently been completed at Ramsey, Cambridgeshire (Fig 54). 
 However, it is only fair to add that, in this case, the surviving windmill structure was little more than a ruinous stone stump before conversion work began (Plate 41). 
 Most owners of &bquo;recycled&equo; windmills are also naturally disinclined to reinstate the wooden sail structures of their mills because of the considerable maintenance liability which is imposed by restoration of these complex and highly exposed features. 
 Watermills 
 Following the Romans' introduction of the geared watermill into England, many such mills were established &mdash; the Domesday Book lists 5,624 mills, although a good proportion of these would have been worked by horses or oxen rather than water. 
 In the Middle Ages these mills were the property of the lord of the manor who possessed &bquo;soke rights&equo;, which meant that anyone growing corn on his manor was obliged to have it ground at the lord's mill because hand mills were outlawed. 
 The miller would then deduct a proportion of the grain in payment for his services. 
 As a result of the soke system, the medieval miller was often the subject of suspicion and distrust. 
 The amount of toll-in-kind payable for the service of milling the grain varied according to region and period, but the average charge was one-sixteenth part of the grain by volume. 
 No miller was allowed to buy or sell grain or flour except surplus toll corn until after the reign of Elizabeth I and although the influence of the soke began to wane during the seventeenth century, toll-in-kind was not replaced by a monetary charge until an act of 1796. 
 Even then, old habits died hard, and at Wakefield, Yorkshire, one of the most important grain markets outside London, the milling soke was not finally abolished until 1853. 
 Arguments and local strife were often caused by the building of a new watermill because the necessary raising of weirs and cutting of races would affect the flow of water to other mills on the same stream. 
 The number of mills that could work effectively on the same stream was limited, which led to smaller streams being used by means of building dams to create mill-ponds. 
 In these smaller waters, the miller could work by day and his mill-pond would be replenished at night. 
 Seasonal and tidal changes posed problems for mills situated on larger rivers. 
 Waterwheels could not function at low water, so adjustable wheels were made. 
 Installation of these devices proved costly and very few were used. 
 The floating mill, moored to a bridge or pier in the cities, solved this problem, but in the country the miller had to moor in open stream and grain had to be conveyed to him by boat. 
 Use was also made of the power of the sea by constructing tidal mills along the coast. 
 As these buildings were constantly threatened by storms and high tides, it was important to choose a sheltered position protected from gales. 
 Several such mills have survived along the south coast of England on shores where the Isle of Wight gives protection from the prevailing south-westerly winds. 
 Mills were often built on an estuary where the water could be trapped upstream at high tide by sluice gates. 
 In other parts, a sea wall would be built at a suitable inlet to enclose a mill-pond. 
 The miller's day was dictated by the movements of the tides because his source of power would only be available for short periods of two or three hours at a time. 
 Early waterwheels were made of wood, but as cast iron developed the miller made use of this new material for his machinery. 
 Wooden wheels decay quickly with the cycle of immersion in and emergence from the water. 
 Thus it is rare to find a wholly wooden wheel intact today. 
 Cast-iron wheels were too expensive for the miller to install, so a hybrid construction emerged. 
 The hub, bearings and rims of otherwise wooden wheels might be made of iron. 
 Wheels made completely of iron began to be used during the eighteenth century. 
 Each wheel was made in sections and assembled at the mill, paddles made of wood being retained. 
 Iron fittings could replace wooden components gradually, allowing major alterations to take place over a long period. 
 This atmosphere of making changes only slowly and of preferring a tried and tested &bquo;free&equo; source of power to more efficient engine-driven plant can be savoured at Lockyer's Mill, Clapton, near Crewkerne, Somerset, a mill of 1864 in which grain is still milled commercially by water power provided by the River Axe (Plate 42). 
 As well as milling corn, water-powered mills have been used for weaving and spinning. 
 In Sheffield, until the 1930s, power from a waterwheel was even used to grind cutlery. 
 Textile Mills 
 When the mills of the North of England are referred to, we think immediately of the nineteenth-century factories which were built for the purpose of manufacturing yarn and textiles, rather than buildings containing corn-grinding machinery. 
 The earliest textile mills were similar to the traditional water-powered flour mills because they consisted of load-bearing masonry external walls and wooden floors held up by timber posts or cast-iron columns and often occupied equally remote rural locations in order to exploit fully the power provided by the rushing streams of narrow Pennine valleys. 
 With the introduction of steam power from the later eighteenth century, the necessity for a streamside location disappeared and, particularly in regard to cotton spinning, a climate of high humidity became a more important requirement. 
 Hence the enormous success of Oldham, a hilly settlement in East Lancashire with considerable reserves of coal, situated only 11km (7 miles) from Manchester, the greatest yarn market in the world in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. 
 By 1871, Oldham had more cotton-spinning spindles than any country in the world outside the USA and it maintained that position of superiority until 1937. 
 At the peak of production, around three hundred cotton mills were concentrated on Oldham. 
 A writer in an edition of the Manchester City News  of 1908 recorded that such a vast hive of industry could overpower even a worldly-wise observer: 
 &bquo;the smoke of the innumerable tall chimneys lies over all like a poultice&hellip; houses and shops go on for ever, and at the back of them, blotting out all the rest of the world, rise great precipitous mills like frowning cliffs, at whose base are the small houses where the folks live like coneys at a mountain foot. 
 The cotton mill was essentially a container for machinery, simple in design and unfussy in appearance. 
 Many multi-storey mills impressed &mdash; and continue to impress &mdash; by their sheer size. 
 The basic dimension of a mill was its width which determined both the length and the height, and which was itself determined by the length of the cotton-spinning &bquo;mule&equo;. 
 The increase in maximum width of these buildings from 30m (99ft) in 1868 to 48m (158ft) in 1905 was necessary in order to accommodate the longer mules which were enlarged to their technical optimum, consistent with rigidity, of 1,392 (116 dozen) spindles. 
 These wider mills were thus squarer than their predecessors which had tended to be long and narrow. 
 Consequently, it was necessary to introduce more daylight into the broader interiors and this became possible in the 1890s with the use of reinforced-concrete floors and steel girders. 
 The arched window was allied to the brick jack-arch system often employed to achieve an incombustible floor construction and tended to produce an opening which was disproportionately high related to its width. 
 In contrast, the square-headed window spanned by the steel beam of the new technology could have a width disproportionate to its height. 
 Taken together with the replacement of the solid, load-bearing external walls by rows of brick piers flanking narrower infill panels, this development allowed the area of window relative to wall to increase to a maximum in the 1900s when the fa&ccedil;ades of mills became more glass than brick. 
 Elevations were ultimately reduced to a matrix of concrete-encased steel beams and columns, the voids between which were filled with large, gridded, steel-framed windows surmounting low infill panels of brickwork. 
 Mills of the Oldham type were usually five storeys high with a warehouse and conditioning room in the cellar. 
 The most impressive interior space of the mill was the engine room, from which power was transmitted to each floor by means of a rope-race that used cotton ropes of local manufacture. 
 This arrangement was adopted from the 1870s. 
 Because raw cotton is an inflammable material, mills had to be made fireproof either in whole or in part. 
 The adoption of iron instead of wood for floor beams helped to achieve this aim. 
 The sprinkler, invented in the USA in 1881, was a further safeguard against the dire effects of fire and its introduction into cotton mills produced the water towers which crown the main external staircases of many of the later mills. 
 Internally, a hardwood floor surface helped to maintain an equable temperature, permitted work to be done in bare feet and simplified the recovery of waste cotton. 
 In Oldham, and other towns of East Lancashire (but not in West Yorkshire where stone was plentiful), the chief constructional material was brick because it was cheaper than stone. 
 At first bricks were made on site from abundant local clay. 
 Later they were supplied by specialist brickmakers whose numbers increased greatly during the last quarter of the nineteenth century. 
 Each mill was likely to require around 4 million bricks, 2 acres of glass and 2,200 tons of iron and steel. 
 Mill-designing architects and mill builders avoided any superfluous decoration, dispensing with the external rendering and cornices between the storeys that would have been demanded by classical precedent. 
 Often the sole ornament applied to mills was projecting angle piers and a small cornice near the top of the facade, surmounted by a &bquo;blocking course&equo; of bricks, although some very large mills built during the Edwardian period, when labour and materials were cheapest, display elaborate decorative brickwork. 
 It is apparent that the conversion to domestic use of a textile mill up to 48m (158ft) wide is like to pose problems. 
 Partly for this reason and partly because of slight local demand for living accommodation so markedly individualistic as apartments created in former textile factories (which may not be entirely free from unpleasant associations), only one or two of the smaller, older and picturesquely situated textile mills have, to date, been converted into dwellings. 
 Warehouses and Factories 
 The large urban or dockside warehouse is a building type strongly related to the grander grain and textile mills, not only because it often stored the raw materials or products processed by these latter buildings, but also in its constructional composition. 
 The storage of grain or many bolts of cloth imposed loads upon the structures of these buildings almost as heavy as the machinery contained in the textile mills and therefore their construction had to be equally robust and similarly fireproof. 
 Many cotton warehouses displaying gridded elevations reminiscent of those of the mills themselves were erected in central Manchester, &bquo;Cottonopolis&equo; in the period leading up to the start of World War I, and the later the building, the more elaborate and showy was the architecture. 
 For the largest and most prominent buildings, located in that city's Whitworth Street area, colourful cladding of their steel skeletons with elaborately moulded glazed terracotta blocks was de rigueur. 
 The conversion of one building of this confident era, Granby House of 1908, is the final project described in this chapter. 
 Following a series of projects in which it has been shown that mills and large warehouses may satisfactorily be converted into dwellings, some interest has been shown in the possibility of treating redundant factories similarly. 
 A four-storey former clothing factory at Ipswich, Suffolk, has been converted into 103 flats, 24 of which are roof-top penthouses which were sold to leaseholders, the remaining 79 dwellings being &bquo;fair rent&equo; flats for council and housing association nominees. 
 The cost of this project, which was completed in 1983, was almost &pound;2 million. 
 In Glagow, the former Wylie and Lochhead Cabinet Works on Kent Road has been converted into a block of 196 flats for sale and its sumptuous Grade A listed stone-clad main elevation has been carefully restored. 
 In the other main cities of Scotland, where most city-centre residents are flat-dwellers, tenements being the predominant residential building type, several other large commercial or industrial buildings have recently been converted into dwelling complexes. 
 In Dundee, a former jute mill has been converted into 72 flats, while in Edinburgh a scheme at High Street/Bell Street is creating 172 flats in former bonded warehouses. 
 A Glasgow &bquo;suburb&equo; is to witness a very large scheme involving the restoration of the five warehouses at Spiers Wharf, the terminus of the Glasgow branch of the Forth and Clyde Canal at Port Dundas, to create almost two hundred dwellings for sale. 
 However, apart from the pioneering Ipswich project and Glasgow's Kent Road Cabinet Works scheme, elsewhere in Britain little has yet been done to promote, or to try to demonstrate, the advantages of re-using redundant factories as dwellings. 
 This may be because the &bquo;classic&equo; factories of the twentieth century tend to be low-rise, usually single-storey structures, built to very broad plans from cheap and impermanent materials. 
 Consequently, they require radical alteration and major upgrading of their constructional envelopes, local environment and services to make them suitable for subdivision into saleable dwellings. 
 To date, it appears that no developer has been prepared to challenge the accepted policy by retaining and adapting a low-rise factory structure for housing rather than choosing demolition and redevelopment. 
 Watermill, East Sussex 
 This building was erected in the nineteenth century and was the first mill on the site. 
 A stream, which is a tributary of the River Ouse, was dammed to create a large millpond which feeds the waterwheel. 
 The structure of the wheel remains alongside the north-west elevation of the mill, although the wooden paddles have entirely rotted away and it cannot be made to turn (Plate 43). 
 A broad wheel of small diameter, it is of the overshot, pitch-back type and sits below a &bquo;launder&equo;, or large iron tank, which accepts water from the &bquo;flume&equo;, connected with the mill-pond, so that water is ducted on to the top of the wheel, causing it to rotate backwards. 
 The benefit of this arrangement is that the wheel does not lose efficiency in the manner of the traditional overshot wheel which is continuously fighting backflow turbulence at its junction with the tailstream. 
 As in many early industrial buildings, the original layout of this mill was very simple. 
 A large block of rectangular plan, containing all the mill machinery &mdash; axles, gearing, etc &mdash; adjoined the waterwheel. 
 The construction of this block comprised a ground-storey brickwork plinth, perforated with a handful of windows where these were necessary to light the interior, surmounted by a timber-framed and boarded upper-storey structure, a third &bquo;attic&equo; storey being accommodated largely in the void formed by the steep-sided pitched roof. 
 From the gable of the south-west elevation projects a boarded &bquo;lucarne&equo;, or sack hoist enclosure, a feature which is characteristic of many older flour mills. 
 because this main block is quite wide at more than 8m (26ft), and the considerable weight of stored grain and flour sacks had to be supported safely, the span of the floors between the flank walls was halved by introducing a central row of cylindrical cast-iron columns sited at approximately 2m (6&ndash;1/2ft) from front to rear. 
 These columns support stout timber beams, on to which bear the joists, running parallel to the flank walls, that carry the boarded floors. 
 This is the classic structural/constructional arrangement of the small watermill of lowland England. 
 However, this mill differs from the simple prototype in having a brickbuilt outshot against its south-east elevation which was constructed to house an auxiliary steam-engine that would be brought into use during periods of drought. 
 A prominent detached brick-built chimney served the engine and adjoins the north-east corner of the extension (Plate 44). 
 The present owners purchased the mill in 1976 after part of it had been used to house chickens and the mill-pond had been used for fish-farming. 
 It had ceased to operate as a flour mill as early as 1938 and in the immediate post-war period it was used as a seed store. 
 Thus it will be appreciated that the building was in a rather unkempt and neglected state when the present owners began to restore the structure in 1983. 
 Prior to their purchase of the building, the owner of the adjoining mill house had made two attempts to obtain permission from the local authority to change the use of the mill from industrial premises into a dwelling, but it was only with the current owners' application of 1977 that planning permission for this change was granted. 
 The mill-pond was drained for a three-year period in order to allow some necessary excavation. 
 Derelict pig-pens were demolished and a vast amount of chicken droppings had to be dug out and carted away. 
 A goose paddock was transformed into the garden. 
 Following the demolition of a wooden fuel-store lean-to that had adjoined the south-east elevation of the engine house, most of the restoration work consisted of the replacement of decayed material. 
 The pitched roof of the main block was re-tiled and large areas of the painted external weatherboarding (including the whole of the rear gable) were taken down and replaced with new material backed with a lining of bituminous felt to better exclude the wind. 
 The plan for converting the large volumes of the mill interior into living accommodation involved retaining the entrance into the lean-to engine house and using it as the main entrance to the building. 
 The brick shell of this element could then accommodate an entrance lobby, study, cloakroom, sewing-room and stair hall, giving access to the main first-floor living room, also entirely located in the engine-house outshot (Fig 55). 
 To light this room it was necessary to introduce a range of large windows into the flank wall of the engine house, just below eaves level. 
 More importantly, the existing upper floor of this outshot proved to be too close to the lean-to roof to give a habitable room-height, so rather than raise up the roof level of the entire extension, it was decided to reduce the level of the upper floor to create adequate headroom. 
 Access to the dining room in the north-east corner of the main block was then made via a short flight of stairs. 
 Beyond the dining-room, in the north-west corner of the main block, a breakfast/dining-room was located, separated from the bathroom and dressing room associated with the main bedroom, by a dogleg staircase located at the centre of the north-west elevation (Fig 55). 
 The lowest level of the main stair with its related rear hall, a large L-plan bedroom with en suite bathroom and a utility room, while the top storey has been reserved for two more bedrooms and a further bathroom. 
 Conversion of this space has yet to take place and the unlined timber skeleton of the boarded external-wall construction of the upper storeys remains on view to the interior, awaiting its insulation and internal finishes. 
 In consequence of its importance as a relic of local industrial archaeology, the mill has been listed as a building of architectural or historic interest (Grade II), a status which has not been jeopardised by the very careful treatment of the building by its present owners in their continuing programme of conversion and conservation. 
 Castle Mill, Dorking, Surrey 
 The existence of a mill on the site of Castle Mill, Dorking, is noted in the Domesday Book. 
 It takes its name from Betchworth Castle, a medieval mansion that was altered in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries but is now a ruin. 
 The original building (which can still be discerned today) was a simple block of rectangular plan adjoining a &bquo;breast-shot&equo; waterwheel, powered by a mill-stream fed from the River Mole. 
 With the construction of the South Eastern Railway Company's nearby Reading-Tonbridge line in the mid-nineteenth century, an increase in trade for the mill was anticipated, and an extension, equal in height to the main block, was built on its south side. 
 Naturally enough, the new, faster, mode of transport acted to reduce trade rather than to increase it and the mill suffered declining fortunes until it ceased to operate as a flour mill shortly after World War II. 
 It became derelict rapidly, a picturesque feature of the local landscape, until the late 1960s (Plate 45). 
 During this period it was recognised by the local planning authority as a building of considerable local importance, and, accordingly, was listed Grade II. 
 The family who had owned and operated the mill continued to live in the imposing nearby mill house, but were unable to fund a restoration of the redundant mill, so that when a Repairs Notice was served on them by the local authority, they were obliged to sell the building. 
 It was purchased by an architect, Michael Manser, in 1969, for what would now be regarded as a nominal sum. 
 At that time, Michael Manser lived and practised in South Kensington. 
 He was anxious to obtain a weekend retreat close to London and the derelict mill promised conveniently located, characterful accommodation. 
 His decision to purchase the mill heralded the start of a thorough and extensive process of restoration. 
 The construction of Castle Mill consists of a brickwork plinth, surmounted by timber-framed and weather-boarded upper storeys, and an attractive mansard roof capped its blocky form. 
 It is easy to see that this was a practical means of enclosing a large volume which then could be used for the storage of grain, and the profile is reminiscent of the gambrel-roofed hay barns in the USA. 
 This treatment contributes to the quality of verticality and stateliness which characterises the building, soaring above the tail-race of the mill-stream (Plate 46). 
 The essential structure of the mill &mdash; both masonry and timberwork &mdash; was found to be very sound. 
 Even the boarded cladding was in need of only piecemeal repair rather than wholesale renewal. 
 The slate roof was treated similarly, although the need to install central heating meant that the roof ridge at the junction of the main block with the nineteenth-century extension had to be punctuated by a new chimney. 
 Internally, the existing building incorporated floors on seven levels because the floor levels of the Victorian extension did not ally with those of the original block. 
 As the majority of the mill machinery remained &mdash; waterwheel, axle, pit wheel, &bquo;wallower&equo;, power shaft and millstones &mdash; and these components were chiefly situated in the lowest storey, Michael Manser decided to retain most of these items in a &bquo;set piece&equo; display, reminding visitors of the mill's former function, and visible from the generous entrance hall of the house through a glass door (Fig 56). 
 An existing external door was re-used as the main entrance and the new straight-flight stair, giving access to the first-floor living-rooms, was located on the site off the former upper storeys' access ladder. 
 The rest of the ground floor, occupying the Victorian extension of the main block, converted satisfactorily into a garage, boiler room and tankroom for oil storage once the existing timber floor of this section had been replaced by a concrete slab. 
 Below this new slab it was practical to install a sewage collection chamber of 1,818 litres (400 gal) capacity, associated with a macerator and pump, allowing waste to be reduced and then pumped through a small-diameter pipe to a private sewer manhole 150m (492ft) away. 
 All new soil stacks installed in the building discharged into this sealed sub-floor collection chamber. 
 At first-floor level, the volume of the main block allowed the inclusion of a large stair hall, kitchen/breakfast-room and dining-room en suite with a &bquo;gazebo&equo; formed from the original outshot that projected over the waterwheel. 
 An attempt was made to preserve a sense of the large, formerly unitary space of the mill's second storey which had had to be subdivided to create the dining- and food preparation rooms, by &bquo;unifying&equo; the stair hall and dining-room through very large sliding doors which formed the end panels of the dining-room rear wall. 
 In normal circumstances, these full-height panels would be slid back to ensure a &bquo;flow&equo; of space up the straight-flight stair from the entrance hall, through the first-floor stair hall and into the dining-room. 
 To satisfy the demands of the local authority's building inspector, who was not happy with this lack of fire compartmentation in a single-staircase building incorporating many levels, these sliding doors were tensioned against counterweights so that in the event of a fire, fusible links in the cables restraining the counterweights would melt, causing the weights to drop and drawing the doors closed. 
 This area of the first floor had housed four millstones as well as the upper section of the power shaft. 
 The architect-owner decided to retain one of these stones as well as the timber shaft and these features make a prominent contribution to the character of the dining-room. 
 From the first-floor accommodation of the main block, and to the front of a brick-built hearth serving the new chimney flue, the slightly raised floor of the Victorian extension, reached via a pair of steps and through double doors, provided the site for the drawing-room. 
 The loading door formerly incorporated in the east elevation of the extension was replaced by a large fixed window of plate glass. 
 The second floor could then become the bedrooms level. 
 A further single-flight stair, in this instance incorporating winding treads at its base, discharges on to the large second-floor landing, off which radiate all four bedrooms (Fig 56). 
 Because, at this level, the floor of the extension is considerably higher than the floor of the main block, the master bedroom is reached from this landing via a flight of five stairs. 
 Extension of this elevated level into the south-west corner of the main block allowed an en suite bathroom to be attached to the master bedroom. 
 The subdivision of the remaining, very large volume of the third storey of the main block into three further bedrooms and a bathroom was accomplished by installing new timber-framed partitions, cranked on plan, which thus provided built-in wardrobes for all the secondary bedrooms. 
 From the second-floor landing, a ladder-like stair, more steeply raked than those serving the lower floors, leads up to a large loft, wholly accommodated in the roof space of the main block, which was not exploited as living accommodation in the original conversion scheme. 
 Michael Manser sold Castle Mill soon after its conversion was complete and since that time it has had two further owners, the first of whom installed a lift linking the ground-floor entrance hall with the first-floor dining-room, the generous volume of which has been somewhat reduced by the intrusion of the lift shaft into its south-west corner. 
 The flow of space between dining-room and first-floor stair hall so valued by the Mansers was shunned by the succeeding owner who replaced the large sliding doors and fixed centre panel with a conventional solid partition incorporating a hinged access door. 
 Some further windows were added, puncturing the weatherboarded exterior and tending to reduce the opacity of the walls which is so characteristic of simple and strong early industrial buildings. 
 The third set of owners since the mill's &bquo;reincarnation&equo; extended the living accommodation into the former storage loft contained by the roof. 
 They were also watermill enthusiasts and continued the work of restoration that was begun by Michael Manser by restoring the waterwheel to working condition. 
 The elm paddles of the iron wheel were renewed and the mechanism was modified to operate on the &bquo;undershot&equo; principle because a lowering of water levels brought about by a local flood alleviation scheme made impracticable the restoration of the original &bquo;breast-shot&equo; arrangement. 
 The great care taken by Michael Manser to conserve the majority of the existing building in his scheme for its conservation was recognised in European Architectural Heritage Year 1975 when he received a Civic Trust Heritage Year Award for the restoration and adaptation of Castle Mill. 
 Thames Tunnel Mills, Rotherhithe, London SE16 
 The story of the conversion of Thames Tunnel Mills at Rotherhithe on the south bank of the River Thames in central London provided a clear contrast to the foregoing accounts of the renovation of traditional water-powered, corn-grinding mills in Surrey and Sussex. 
 Thames Tunnel Mills is, in fact, two buildings, which together formed a warehouse and flour mill. 
 The western half of the block was a six-storey flour mill of around 1850. 
 Internally, a grid of cast-iron cruciform-plan columns supported massive timber beams bearing joisted and boarded floors. 
 The eastern half was a warehouse, a storey higher than the mill and built later, around 1890. 
 Steel beams and columns supported its intermediate floors. 
 The building was in use for its original purpose until the early 1960s, but by the time it was acquired for conversion into dwellings in 1977, it had lain empty for more than ten years and was decaying rapidly because the upper floors and roof covering of the mill had been destroyed in a fire. 
 At that time, the building could have been said to typify the dereliction of the whole London docks area. 
 In the post-war period, these districts had undergone precipitous decline from their pre-war position as thriving communities servicing the world's largest port. 
 Consequently, much demolition of &bquo;life-expired&equo; riverside wharves and warehouses was occurring. 
 Many acres of land were cleared to await future development and there were few places either north or south of the river where a group of traditional waterside commercial buildings remained. 
 Fortunately, Thames Tunnel Mills adjoins the handsome early-eighteenth century church of St Mary, Rotherhithe, so that when the Department of the Environment designated the church and the surrounding buildings as an outstanding conservation area, the building became eligible for grant aid from the Historic Buildings Council and their help was crucial to the funding of the development. 
 The scheme of conversion was designed to provide fair rent accommodation for 118 mainly young, single, local people, either in bedsitters or flats which two or four people would share. 
 Seventy-one flats were created. 
 Such provision was thought to be important in a borough where the majority of housing is in local authority estates with little provision for single people. 
 The scheme was innovatory in providing housing at controlled rents in a converted building on a spectacular riverside site, something which previously had been regarded as the preserve of affluent owner occupiers. 
 Although the flats are very compact, generally following the standards laid down for this type of housing in DoE Design Bulletin 29, they share the facilities of a jetty on to the river, and a roof-top conservatory and roof garden, all of which were made possible by a &pound;200,000 grant from the Historic Buildings Council. 
 These are feature additional to the normal provision in this type of housing. 
 The brief for the architects, Hunt Thompson Associates, from their housing association client, was to explore the suitability of the building for conversion into flats, subject to the standards and cost limits laid down by the Housing Corporation and the Department of the Environment. 
 It was immediately apparent that the main challenge to the ingenuity of the designers was the considerable width of the building, which, at 20m (66ft), was more than double the dimension usually found in residential buildings. 
 It followed that it would be sensible to locate elements not needing daylight &mdash; stairs, lifts and corridors &mdash; in the interior of the building. 
 Kitchens, bathrooms and entrance lobbies to flats could also be placed internally. 
 As every flat needs to have these service spaces, and such spaces occupy a fixed minimum area in a flat of any size, it made sense to maximise this internal accommodation in order to utilise fully the broad interior, and this was achieved by making the majority of flats one-bedroom or bedsitter units. 
 The advantages of adopting this planning policy informed the decision that the development should be primarily for single people. 
 Although it was beneficial both to optimal planning and the creation of much-needed accommodation to maximise the number of rooms that could be sited internally, the aggregation of these spaces was still inadequate to &bquo;fill up&equo; the middle of the broad interior, and in the flour-mill section of the building the residual central space was devoted to a full-height internal courtyard or &bquo;atrium&equo; which rises through seven storeys to terminate in a glass-roofed conservatory. 
 In the centre of the plan of the eastern half of the building, the original grain-storage silo structure of the warehouse was retained for use as a lift, staircase and refuse chute (Fig 58). 
 Corridors giving access to the flats in this half wrap around three sides of the silo and are extended as galleries, supported by timber beams and cast-iron columns, salvaged from the original internal structure, to enclose the atrium, which allows daylight to penetrate down to every floor of the building. 
 Grouped around the bottom of the atrium are a common room giving access to a riverside terrace, a laundry and the caretaker's office and flat (Fig 57). 
 At the top of the atrium, the pitched-roof-profile roof-light was made larger than was strictly necessary in order to provide a conservatory complete with tropical plants (Plate 48) which leads out on to a landscaped roof garden capping the western half of the building. 
 It is clear that some provision of communal rooms is important in the conversion of old buildings to multiple occupation, and consistent with other comparable projects analysed in this book, the common room of Thames Tunnel Mills is logically located at ground-floor level. 
 However, the architects' view is that this communal aspect of the building is most clearly expressed architecturally by the central atrium, a space overlooked by the lift lobbies and the galleries of each upper floor that gives access to the flats. 
 The difficulties encountered in negotiating all the necessary approvals, particularly the funding, for a scheme which departed from the norm of fair rent housing explain the exceptionally long period of four years that preceded commencement of the building contract. 
 A major problem that arose at an early stage was the reconciliation of the local authority's requirements for one car-parking space per flat with the DoE's refusal to fund a scheme in which the entire ground floor would be used for parking. 
 A compromise was eventually negotiated in which the space to the west of the building, originally planned as a garden, was devoted instead to a car park and to compensate for this loss of amenity, the Historic Buildings Council then agreed to pay for the provision of the jetty and roof garden. 
 When the Housing Corporation refused to contribute to the cost of these features, the HBC relaxed its general policy of contributing only 50 per cent of the cost of eligible items and met the full cost. 
 The condition of the original internal structures and existing buildings was so bad that cost studies showed that, as well as offering higher standards of fire and sound insulation, the provision of an entirely new structure within the retained shell of the building would be cheaper than a process of repairing and upgrading the surviving framing. 
 This policy of renewal was effected by installing a replacement internal structure of load-bearing brick walls and in situ concrete floors. 
 A consequence of this decision could have been the creation of evidence that the project was merely an exercise in &bquo;fa&ccedil;adism&equo; &mdash; the policy of retaining only the external skin of a building as a &bquo;screen wall&equo; to new accommodation, which often creates a disagreeable distinction between the &bquo;stage set&equo; of the preserved shell and the entirely rebuilt interior. 
 In order to avoid this &bquo;skin deep&equo; quality, in the central atrium the brickwork of the original party wall between the buildings has been preserved at the eastern end of this space to the full height and width of the block. 
 Similarly, by re-using salvaged beams and columns to &bquo;frame&equo; the atrium, a character has been given to this space which is evocative of the interior of the original building, yet does not mock its new use. 
 All circulation spaces within the building &mdash; corridors, galleries, staircases and lift lobbies &mdash; have been designed so as to exploit the brick-built elements of the original structure. 
 Elsewhere, new brickwork flanking circulation spaces and certain living-rooms has been painted and in every flat at least one wall-panel of the original brickwork is left exposed. 
 Efforts to retain the character of the original building externally extended to a decision not to clean the brickwork. 
 Repair and repointing work was kept to a minimum and new pointing was carefully matched to the colour of the original joints. 
 Features such as cranes, loading bays and the 25m (83ft) high free-standing chimney were retained and the original windows were replaced with steel casements of similar pattern (Plate 49). 
 The importance of maintaining the relationship between the building and the river was expressed not only in the provision of the boat jetty, which is linked to the common room, but also in the balconies, connected to the main circulation galleries of every floor, which overlook the water. 
 Clearly, all flats located in the northern part of the building enjoy views both up and down the river, because the building is located in a concave curve of the Thames. 
 Several flats have living rooms in which the loading-bay doors of the original warehouse have been converted into fully glazed French windows sited behind simple steel railings. 
 The contract for construction of a residential development wholly or partly funded by the Housing Corporation may be awarded to a builder only if he submits the most favourable tender in competition. 
 Thus, when Hunt Thompson Associates had completed the technical information, six contractors were invited to submit tenders for the reconstruction of Thames Tunnel Mills on a fluctuating price basis. 
 When these offers were received, it was apparent that the lowest tender considerably exceeded the cost acceptable to the Housing Corporation, who insisted that savings of &pound;170,000 should be made before this lowest price could be accepted. 
 The architects duly made economies, although they were dismayed that these had to include the reduction to a dwarf wall of the high wall intended for the street side of the car park because they felt that the omission of a high wall at this point would detract from the character of Rotherhithe Street. 
 However, the Housing Corporation refused to fund this item. 
 The Historic Buildings Council was unable to increase its grant to pay for this work and it was only because of the intervention of the chairman of the planning committee that an exceptional grant to cover the extra cost was obtained from Southwark Council. 
 At an earlier stage the council had accepted the architects' proposal to replace the chainlink fencing around the adjacent churchyard with cast-iron railings of period appearance. 
 These were installed under a separate contract and Hunt Thompson Associates' supervision, and they have considerably improved the appearance of the conservation area. 
 The tender submitted by J. L. Eve Construction Ltd, was reduced to &pound;2,024,681 after making economies, and this figure was accepted in November 1980. 
 Work commenced on site in January 1981 with an anticipated contract period of 104 weeks. 
 Practical completion of the project was ultimately achieved in March 1984. 
 The resultant cost per square metre of gross floor space was &pound;401.62. 
 The common areas of the building are maintained to an immaculate standard by the resident caretaker and a small team of cleaners &mdash; there is no evidence of abuse of staircases, lifts or corridors as is apparent in many local authority or other housing association schemes. 
 Reflecting the great care taken by the architects to conserve and enhance the qualities of this former industrial building as a significant element in the metropolitan riverside scene, the project has received several awards, including a Doe Housing Design Award and a Civic Trust Award, both of which were presented in 1985. 
 &bquo;The Old Wharf&equo;, Arun Navigation Terminus Warehouse, Billingshurst, West Sussex 
 The River Arun, from Littlehampton on the English Channel to Pulborough in West Sussex, has been navigable since the seventeenth century. 
 The upper reaches of the river remained unnavigable until, in the late eighteenth century, it was decided to construct a parallel canal, drawing water from the river, from Newbridge near Billingshurst to Pallingham Quay, above Pulborough, where the canal would join the river. 
 This project was promoted by Lord Egremont who wished to improve the condition of local agriculture by upgrading transport facilities. 
 A terminus wharf was established at Newbridge. 
 In 1816, the logical extension of this waterway to join the waters of the Wey Navigation, about 26km (16miles) to the north, and hence to establish an inland navigation between London and the English Channel, was completed with the opening of the Wey and Arun Junction Canal, whose main sponsor was again the second Lord Egremont. 
 Traffic carried by the new truck waterway thus increased beyond the volume of goods which had been conveyed along the old cul-de-sac Arun Navigation and it was necessary to extend the waterside storage buildings that had been established at Newbridge. 
 Hence, in 1839, the Arun Navigation Company erected a substantial brick-built warehouse on the Newbridge site and this wharf quickly became a busy centre for the collection and conveyance of agricultural produce from the Billingshurst area until competition from the newly constructed railway robbed the canal of most of its traffic in the late 1860s. 
 Thereafter the canal went rapidly into decline. 
 The Wey and Arun Junction Canal was formally closed in 1871, leaving Newbridge Wharf as the terminus it had been before construction of this waterway, until the closure of the Arun Navigation in 1888. 
 Following the demise of the canal, the old wharf buildings found a new use as hay barns for the adjoining farm. 
 The buildings continued to be used for this purpose until the mid-1980s when an enterprising manager of a local farm realised that something could be done to salvage the structures for a more profitable use. 
 Not until recently did the West Sussex County Council wish to encourage the development of tourist-related activities in parts of the county other than the Channel coast, but a change in policy, provoked by the recognition of the potential of the rural hinterland for attracting tourists, allowed the new owner of the wharf warehouse to contemplate its conversion into a guest house and family dwelling because the project became eligible for grant aid from the English Tourist Board. 
 The warehouse had suffered considerably from the neglect associated with its low-grade use as a hay barn and was little more than a masonry shell devoid of weather-tight windows and doors when the work of conversion commenced. 
 Large trees had rooted in the canal bank below its east wall, obscuring its impressive waterside location (Plate 50). 
 Internally, some evidence of the building's commercial use remained &mdash; notably the shaft and pulleys of a large wooden rope-hauled hoist, sited close to the apex of the roof space, which the present owner has carefully restored and integrated into the building as a relic of its former use. 
 This was possible because the topmost floor of the two-and-a-half storey building is entirely in the roof space, obtains all its daylight from a new roof-light and therefore cannot be used easily for habitable accommodation. 
 It is reserved for use as a children's play area. 
 The first floor accommodates the bedrooms for the guests &mdash; each bedroom being paired with an en suite bathroom &mdash; together with sleeping accommodation for the proprietor and his family, while the ground floor includes a large guests' lounge, TV room and breakfast room to the east of the main entrance/staircase hall. 
 To the west of this space lies the guests' dining-room, a large kitchen incorporating a dining area for the family, a pantry, living-room, utility room and small office adjoining the secondary entrance (Fig 59). 
 Also included in this &bquo;private&equo; section of the building is a straight-flight staircase which leads up from the small hall containing the secondary entrance to serve the family's first-floor sleeping accommodation. 
 The architects, Derek Irvine Associates, were obliged to locate the main &bquo;public&equo; staircase at the centre of the plan with light flooding in through the roof-light which straddles the roof ridge above, because the considerable width of the building &mdash; 11.4m (37ft) &mdash; necessitated some means of introducing light into the middle if gloomy internal corridors were to be avoided. 
 Considerable care has been taken to retain a &bquo;period&equo; appearance to the building. 
 The existing roof covering was completely stripped and the rafters were brush-cleaned. 
 Glass-fibre quilt insulation was laid between them and, following the application of roofing felt, new timber roofing battens were fixed to accept the sound slates which had been salvaged from the original construction. 
 Only small quantities of imported second-hand slates were needed to supplement the re-used material. 
 A brick-built chimney had to be integrated into the reconstituted roof and new lead flashings were provided to reconcile this feature, as well as the added roof window, soil vent pipes and roof-light, with roof surfaces. 
 Repairs to the existing masonry were carried out in matching brickwork and the purpose-made joinery of new windows and external doors has been retained in its natural colour under a clear sealant, rather than being painted, which might have detracted from the mellow textures of the renovated building (Plate 51). 
 To furnish the interior authentically, the owner sought out period items &mdash; panelled doors, chimney pieces, etc &mdash; from local buildings that were to be demolished and installed them in appropriate positions. 
 Various panels of brickwork have been left exposed rather than plastered over, and the original heavy timber floor beams generally continue to project down below ceilings. 
 Outside, equal care has been taken to ensure a picturesque setting for the restored building by removing most of the jungly vegetation which formerly swathed the canal banks, dredging the canal and regrading the banks so that guests are greeted with a pleasant prospect from the ground floor lounge and the &bquo;wharfside&equo; location of the building is appreciated (Plate 52). 
 The owner wished to reconstruct the wharf structure which had disappeared since the active days of the waterway, but no drawings or photographs of this feature could be found. 
 The restoration of the warehouse and the adjoining 457m (500yd) length of canal is viewed with enthusiasm by the Wey and Arun Canal Trust, a society which has worked since the early 1970s for the complete restoration of the Arun Navigation and the Wey and Arun Junction Canal between Pallingham and the River Wey, and which has restored the opportunity for navigation to several stretches of these waterways. 
 Granby House, Granby Row, Manchester 
 Granby House is a seven-storey building of 1908 which was built as a cotton warehouse. 
 Its outside walls are largely of pressed red brick, although there is a plinth and decorative band courses at various levels, carried out in Portland stone (Plate 53). 
 It is in the heart of Manchester, but for many years industry and commerce have been moving away from the city centre, increasing the risk that only a lifeless core will be left. 
 The city council recognises the need to re-inject life into the potentially deserted central area, particularly after business hours, and it is considered that there is no surer means of achieving this aim than by encouraging young people to live in the city centre again. 
 Before the conversion of Granby House, it was not clear how this could be done without incurring enormous expense. 
 A local housing association believed that the conversion of an existing building into an attractive block of flats would assist the process of regenerating the city centre, provided a sound building could be obtained cheaply. 
 After several previous attempts, the Northern Counties Housing Association found and converted Granby House into flats with the help of an Urban Development Grant. 
 Northern Counties is a large housing association, with its headquarters in Manchester, which has specialised in fair rent and shared ownership housing schemes. 
 In recent years, when there have been reductions in public funding for housing associations, it has been developing an increasing proportion of properties for sale in order to maintain and expand its activities. 
 The association wished to be involved in a major city-centre conversion but needed to be sure that the selected project would succeed. 
 The essence of the association's idea was to develop flats for sale and this would make it possible to bring in private institutional finance &mdash; eg from a building society which might then become involved in providing mortgages for the individual purchasers. 
 It is noteworthy that this type of conversion scheme was becoming fashionable in London, but the great difference was that flat prices in the capital were, and remain, very much higher that those applying in Manchester. 
 However, in the latter city, building costs were almost as high as those of London, so some form of subsidy was necessary. 
 It was believed that an Urban Development Grant might meet this need and Manchester City Council agreed to support the association's application for this form of government assistance. 
 On the private sector side, the Nationwide Building Society were interested in participating. 
 This left one further matter to be resolved. 
 The development of housing for sale with the use of private funding cannot be carried out by a registered housing association &mdash; Northern Counties Provident Housing Association &mdash; had to be set up. 
 While these arrangements were being formulated, the developer was looking for a suitable building. 
 Granby House is listed Grade II and stands within the Whitworth Street Conservation Area. 
 Following its use as a cotton warehouse, the building had been the headquarters of a mail-order company and ended its commercial career accommodating the offices of a number of small businesses. 
 It was the fourth building in the area that the association considered for conversion and had studied in detail. 
 Selecting the optimum building and obtaining it on satisfactory terms are matters of great importance where institutional finance is involved. 
 In each case, the association had commissioned structural surveys, followed by feasibility and market studies. 
 Indications of the purchase price of each building were obtained and full funding proposals were prepared. 
 Although conversion of each of the first three buildings considered was potentially viable, all three failed one or more tests of the practicality/viability analysis. 
 When Granby House came on to the market early in 1983, it looked more promising. 
 It was in good condition, its shape and window arrangement made the formation of a central light-well unnecessary, and the city council were keen to prevent it from falling into long-term disuse. 
 However, the Regional Development Officer of the housing association insisted on carrying out the same thorough appraisal of its potential that had been applied to the previous buildings. 
 Consequently, an architect and builder were invited to prepare and cost a conversion scheme. 
 The association's own quantity surveyor and marketing department made detailed investigations. 
 On the basis of a building purchase price of &pound;200,000, the total cost of the project would be &pound;1 million, or about &pound;16,000 per flat. 
 The average selling price for a one-bedroom flat in Manchester was reckoned to be around &pound;11,000 at that time (in contrast to at least &pound;25,000 in London). 
 The prices being asked for vacant buildings in Manchester were quite high, being based on &bquo;hope value&equo; rather than use value. 
 After much negotiation, the association was obliged to pay a purchase price of &pound;210,000 for Granby House at the end of 1983. 
 The Nationwide Building Society agreed to put up &pound;703,000 at 2 per cent above their normal rates because of the experimental nature of the scheme. 
 Manchester City Council supported an application for an Urban Development Grant of &pound;300,000. 
 At this point, the builder on whose estimate the scheme was based went into liquidation, so a new contractor had to be found. 
 It was decided to enter into a fixed price &bquo;design and build&equo; contract with a major firm and to appoint an external project manager to oversee the building work. 
 It was felt that these arrangements would lessen the risk of the association being drawn into difficulties if anything else went wrong. 
 Following a tender competition, the offer from Fairclough Building Ltd. was chosen, but the cost had now risen to almost &pound;1.3 million, partly because of the imposition of VAT on building operations in the 1984 budget. 
 Because Granby House was a listed building, the contractor eventually became exempt from this tax, but as he could not reclaim any VAT he had already paid to suppliers, he had to pass most of it on to the developer. 
 The increase in cost also necessitated a fresh application for Urban Development Grant. 
 The Nationwide Building Society felt that they could not increase their investment because it was linked to unchanged valuations and therefore the new ratio of public to private funds had to be higher than before, even though the housing association was prepared to invest some of its own resources. 
 &pound;601,000 was applied for, including a contingency sum of &pound;50,000. 
 In the event, only &pound;575,000 of this grant was taken up. 
 It took several months to obtain approval and construction work started only in August 1984. 
 The fact that the building is listed limited the opportunities for external alterations, and internal layouts had to respect existing window locations (Fig 60). 
 It was possible to leave untouched the greater part of the existing structure. 
 The general construction is of brick external walls with a central masonry spine wall running from front to back. 
 The building is covered by a reinforced concrete roof of mansard profile, which houses the seventh storey. 
 The structure of the open warehouse floors consisted of cast-iron columns supporting steel, iron or heavy timber beams. 
 On these members 75mm (3in) thick pine floorboards are fixed, performing a structural function as well as providing a floor surface sufficiently substantial to resist the heavy loads imposed by stored textiles. 
 The structural alterations consisted of the removal of the existing goods lifts, the addition of two passenger lifts and the formation of various internal doorways in existing internal masonry. 
 The architects, John Cottam Partnership, found space for 61 flats, comprising 50 one-bedroom and 11 two-bedroom dwellings. 
 The enclosure of individual flats within the large open floor spaces was achieved with the use of metal-stud and plasterboard partitions. 
 Metal-framed suspended ceilings were installed throughout, two layers of &bquo;fireline&equo; board being incorporated at ceiling level in order to provide a one-hour period of fire resistance between storeys. 
 The partitions contain sound insulation and thermal insulation to the level required for inclusion of projects in the Electricity Board's Civic Shield Award Scheme. 
 All dwellings and the hot water system are heated using off-peak electricity. 
 The flats were sold on 125-year leases and priority was given to first-time buyers. 
 Owing to the delays that had occurred since the marketing studies were made in 1983 and because of the attractiveness of the finished scheme, it was found that considerably higher prices could be obtained for the flats than had been originally foreseen. 
 Most of the apartments were sold quite quickly, raising a total of &pound;1.1 million. 
 Even so, this did not cover the full cost of the project, confirming that some form of subsidy was essential. 
 ERIKA RAN, mile after effortless mile around the park until dusk brought the bone-chilling mist; then, in a loping run, under the great beech tree, home. 
 Supper was ready &mdash; soup and Bulgarian tinned fruit &mdash; eaten, dishes washed, Erika and Paul ready to go out, Herr and Frau Nordern too. 
 &bquo;The Beyers rang,&equo; Frau Nordern said, mentioning some friendly acquaintances who lived a couple of streets away. 
 &bquo;We're going to have a drink and play cards. 
 It will be a nice change.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Erika agreed that it would be a nice change for her mother but she looked at Omi, sitting quietly in her chair. 
 &bquo;I don't think that I'll go to the Youth Club after all,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'll stay in, rest &mdash; and do some homework.&equo; 
 But that ploy didn't work. 
 Omi smiled her patient, wise smile. 
 &bquo;Go, child,&equo; she said, &bquo;go.&equo; 
 Erika and Paul went, Paul politely, solicitously, opening the door for Erika and waving her through first, although it was a tight squeeze in the tiny vestibule, and at the bus-stop, in a bizarre parody of good manners, insisting that Erika stand in front of him. 
 Erika looked at him shrewdly. 
 &bquo;Are you being funny, Paul? 
 Because if you are&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Funny!&equo; 
 Paul looked hurt. 
 &bquo;I'm being polite.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, that's what's funny,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;And what have you been looking so pleased about this week? 
 Just because I got you off seeing Herr Lettner doesn't mean it won't happen again. 
 And next time don't expect me to help you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know that,&equo; Paul was odiously grateful. 
 &bquo;And thanks a lot for that, Erika. 
 But you've seen me doing my homework, haven't you? 
 I've been doing that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, for a week.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, a week's good. 
 You've got to get used to these things. 
 But listen, Erika,&equo; Paul stamped his feet against the cold. 
 &bquo;Listen, when you go to the sports school you'll leave home, won't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;If I go I might.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I'll tell you what.&equo; 
 Paul looked down the road to where distant lights told of the approach of the bus. 
 &bquo;I've been thinking. 
 When you go, Omi won't need that big room all to herself, will she? 
 So I was thinking, when you go she could move into my room and I could have yours.&equo; 
 &bquo;Paul!&equo; 
 Erika's cheeks flamed, with temper. 
 &bquo;You really are the end. 
 Don't you ever  think of anyone but yourself?&equo; 
 She swung on to the bus. 
 &bquo;No, go away,&equo; she said, as Paul sat next to her. 
 &bquo;Listen,&equo; Paul said. 
 &bquo;I am  thinking of someone else. 
 I'm thinking of Omi!&equo; he urged, in one of the most improbable remarks he had ever made. 
 &bquo;Your room is on the street. 
 Mine would be quieter &mdash;&equo; 
 But the rest of his appeal was lost as Erika pushed past him and stood at the end of the bus, well aware that Paul would rather postpone his appeal than stand the two slow lurching miles to the club. 
 The Youth Club of the Paris Commune as it was officially known, or the &bquo;Paree&equo; as its more irreverent members called it, was a gimcrack affair, cracked concrete and cheap plastic panels, tucked beside the inevitable block of flats, and a health centre, but it was well equipped: table tennis, television, a library, a concert room, a rather more substantial annexe for weight lifting, a hall which doubled up for meetings of the Free German Youth and dancing, and a comfortable lounge where one could buy coffee and soft drinks. 
 A girl was playing Chopin in the concert room as Erika went into the lounge. 
 Rosa was there drinking fruit juice with Fritz Kott and a few other pupils from the Egon Schultz School who greeted her with the same, unanimous question: &bquo;What happened?&equo; 
 Struggling not to blush, although failing, Erika told them, stressing emphatically the provisional nature of the interview. 
 But that qualification was brushed aside. 
 &bquo;No ifs or buts,&equo; Fritz said. 
 &bquo;You're in. 
 In .&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;But it's a big maybe. 
 I've got to keep jumping well.&equo; 
 &bquo;And why shouldn't you?&equo; 
 Fritz said. 
 &bquo;If you can do a thing once you can do it again. 
 Right, Rosa?&equo; 
 &bquo;Absolutely,&equo; Rosa said. 
 &bquo;And do it better. 
 And the way you're jumping now Erika&hellip; wow!&equo; she pointed to the ceiling. 
 &bquo;Oh, you never know,&equo; Erika protested. 
 &bquo;You can reach your peak and that's it.&equo; 
 She laughed despite herself. 
 &bquo;That has to be true, doesn't it? 
 Otherwise people would be jumping over the Television Tower.&equo; 
 &bquo;Some truth in that,&equo; Rosa agreed. 
 &bquo;I know I've reached my limit. 
 No, really. 
 I know it. 
 And to be tops you can lose a lot&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;And gain a lot, too,&equo; Fritz said, with a warmth glowing beyond loyalty. 
 &bquo;Well, we'll see,&equo; Erika said, &bquo;and talking of seeing, look who's here.&equo; 
 The who  was a Herr Hocher who, with a dedicated voluntary worker, Fr&auml;ulein Renn, ran the Youth Club. 
 He was a tall, rather gloomy man in his forties, dressed, as he always and incongruously was, in the blue and white of the F.G.Y. and accompanied by Herman Guttenbruk, he of the trip to, and interminable lecture on, the Soviet Union. 
 Herr Hocher's long face split into a welcoming smile &mdash; or what might, charitably, have passed for one. 
 &bquo;Ha! ha! ha! familiar faces&hellip; yes&hellip; but not too familiar, I'm sorry to say. 
 Ha! ha! 
 Klaus, isn't it? and Klara &mdash; Oh, of course &mdash;&equo; corrected &mdash; &bquo;Erika, Fritz, Rosa&hellip; we really ought to see you more often, ought we not? 
 Don't you have a duty to support&hellip;.&equo; 
 But the group had its answer to that: pressures of training, all working hard at normal school subjects, and  attending F.G.Y. meetings at school. 
 &bquo;But, ha! ha! able to make time for a dance,&equo; Herr Hocher said. 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; Rosa said, with an air of sweet reasonableness. 
 &bquo;We have to have some relaxation. 
 The school doctor says that we should work hard, but not overwork,&equo; adding a muffled &bquo;ha! ha!&equo; as, baffled, Herr Hocher retreated to the T.V. room where there was a noisy scuffle. 
 &bquo;The Louts,&equo; Fritz said. 
 &bquo;I hope that they aren't staying for the dance.&equo; 
 There was a general sigh of agreement. 
 The Louts were a bunch of youths from another district who came to the club now and again and mildly disturbed the dances. 
 There was never any real trouble, as the consequences for hooliganism in the G.D.R. 
 could be extremely severe, but some horseplay, and the occasional illicit disc was put on the record-player, much to Herr Hocher's annoyance. 
 Just once there had been a fight but as the then leader of the Louts had, unwittingly, taken on a junior boxing champion, he had ceased appearing. 
 But still, the Louts were tedious, at least in the eyes of Erika and her friends, the more so to Erika who had an uneasy, and not unjustified feeling that Paul was always likely to be drawn into their orbit. 
 More people were drifting into the club, all of whom asked Erika how her interview had gone. 
 &bquo;I don't understand how they know,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;I didn't tell anyone.&equo; 
 Fritz grinned. 
 &bquo;Don't you know? 
 In this country everything is a secret &mdash; and nothing is secret.&equo; 
 The group laughed as the first strains of a Hungarian pop group wailed from the hall. 
 &bquo;Shall we go in?&equo; 
 Fritz asked. 
 Erika resolutely shook her head. 
 &bquo;Not until there are more people in there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Now, now,&equo; Fritz said. 
 &bquo;You mustn't be shy. 
 Just think what it will be like doing the high jump with 50,000 people watching you!&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't!&equo; 
 Erika felt goose-pimples on her arms and the thought crossed her mind that, despite all that had been said to her about courage, perhaps she wasn't really cut out for stardom, after all. 
 But she firmly stamped on that thought. 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Let's go in. 
 But I'm not dancing, remember.&equo; 
 They strolled into the hall where a few couples were vaguely swaying under the glare of yellow neon, and the basilisk stare of Fr&auml;ulein Renn. 
 Rosa nudged Erika. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; she said out of the side of her mouth. 
 Erika looked. 
 A girl was sauntering into the hall. 
 She was something of a celebrity at the Egon Schultz School. 
 Her father was a high official and had taken her with him on a trip to London and she had returned with her hair in orange stripes. 
 She had actually appeared at school like that &mdash; once. 
 When she came back the next day the stripes had been dyed her natural brunette, but badly, so that her hair still seemed striped, hence her nickname, Bunte. 
 She was also something of a femme fatale , with the looks of a young Marlene Dietrich, and a blas&eacute; manner to match. 
 Bunte casually wiggled over to Erika and her friends. 
 &bquo;Helloo&equo; she drawled. 
 &bquo;How is Rosa? 
 How is Erika? 
 How is Fritz? 
 All well, yes. 
 Athletic, yes. 
 Democratic, yes. 
 Socialist, yes. 
 Healthy minds in healthy bodies, yes. 
 Who will dance with me? 
 In the discos in the West they darken the lights, in the East they brighten them. 
 But come, Fritz.&equo; 
 To Erika's intense annoyance, Fritz promptly accepted the invitation &mdash; obeyed the command, rather &mdash; and as Rosa moved on to the floor with another boy, she was left feeling abandoned &mdash; and foolish. 
 She felt a rare prickle of envious hostility and in that mood, defiantly and with a lunatic rashness, accepted an invitation to dance with one of the Louts, whose approach was loutish enough: a jerk of the head and a mumbled, &bquo;Wanna dance, chick?&equo; 
 Erika moved on to the floor, keeping the Lout at a safe distance, but he was not as loutish as his manner suggested. 
 &bquo;You're a good dancer,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;A really good mover.&equo; 
 &bquo;Better than her?&equo; 
 Erika indicated Bunte. 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 Although she's not bad,&equo; the Lout said. 
 &bquo;But what's the matter with her hair? 
 It's all stripy.&equo; 
 Erika told him the reason, expecting a sneering laugh, but the Lout was impressed. 
 &bquo;That's something,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That takes some nerve you know, to do that to your hair and go to school.&equo; 
 &bquo;It seems silly, to me,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;They do that in the West,&equo; the Lout said. 
 &bquo;Stripe their hair. 
 Cut it, too, in patterns.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; Erika said loftily. 
 &bquo;It's barbaric.&equo; 
 Hoping to squash the Lout with that word. 
 But the Lout was unsquashed. 
 &bquo;It's individualism. 
 Shows your personality. 
 Makes you someone. 
 Someone different. 
 Yourself.&equo; 
 Erika was mildly scandalised by this heresy. 
 &bquo;True individualism lies in the proper relationship of each person to society,&equo; she said, primly. 
 &bquo;Eh? 
 Oh, that junk,&equo; the Lout said. 
 &bquo;Hey, listen, do you want to come to Wannsee?&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 Erika stopped dancing. 
 &bquo;Now? 
 With you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure, why not? 
 There's going to be a big party in the woods, real rock and roll. 
 I've got a scooter.&equo; 
 He added that information with an air of modest pride. 
 Erika laughed incredulously. 
 &bquo;Go to Wannsee on the back of a scooter in this weather? 
 You must be crazy.&equo; 
 &bquo;O.K. Suit yourself.&equo; 
 The Lout shrugged as the music ended. 
 &bquo;See you around,&equo; he said, making a bee-line for Bunte. 
 Rosa came across the dance-floor, her face serious. 
 &bquo;Erika,&equo; she said, &bquo;what on earth are you doing?&equo; 
 &bquo;Dancing,&equo; Erika said. 
 Rosa was impatient. 
 &bquo;You know what I mean. 
 If you hurt your foot&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm being careful,&equo; Erika said, in a voice which meant that Rosa could mind her own business. 
 &bquo;But &mdash;&equo; Rosa began. 
 &bquo;I don't want to hear any &bquo;buts&equo;,&equo; Erika snapped, her eyes on Fritz who, despite competition from the Louts, was talking to Bunte. 
 Another disc started, Herr Hocher placing it on the record-player with his own hands, the result being a foxtrot played by a Russian orchestra, and he himself took the floor with Fr&auml;ulein Renn, the pair of them going through what seemed to the young people weirdly funny gyrations together. 
 Finally, elbowed out of Bunte's presence by the Louts, Fritz ambled over to the girls. 
 &bquo;That's put the stopper on it,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Has it? 
 On what, might I ask?&equo; 
 Erika was freezingly polite. 
 &bquo;This music,&equo; Fritz said. 
 &bquo;I think that it's very nice music,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Honestly?&equo; 
 Fritz was surprised. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Erika smiled across the floor at the odious Herman Guttenbruk. 
 &bquo;And I think that someone would like to dance it with me ,&equo; she said, as Herman, lured by the smile, came across and with a ludicrous bow, asked Erika if she would do him the honour of the dance, Erika graciously accepting, to her delight leaving Fritz looking disconsolate and unhappy. 
 &bquo;I much prefer this music,&equo; Herman said, doing an awkward shuffle. 
 &bquo;Pop music is degenerate. 
 Don't you agree?&equo; 
 &bquo;Hmm?&equo; 
 Erika was too occupied in looking over Herman's shoulder at Fritz to pay him any attention. 
 &bquo;I said pop and rock are degenerate,&equo; Herman repeated. 
 &bquo;In fact I was surprised to see you dancing to pop music, and with one of them .&equo; 
 Erika had no intention of being lectured to by Herman. 
 &bquo;What's wrong with dancing with one of them?&equo; she demanded. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Herman bumped into Herr Hocher and apologised profusely. 
 &bquo;They aren't good types.&equo; 
 &bquo;They don't breathe all over you though.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorry. 
 Very sorry.&equo; 
 Herman, whom Erika had already been keeping at a safe distance from her feet, backed away. 
 &bquo;But you know what I mean, Erika.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do I?&equo; 
 Erika was aloof but seeing Fritz watching her pulled Herman closer. 
 &bquo;How can we dance if you're miles away?&equo; 
 Herman, startled but pleased, moved in, only to be disconcerted as Erika pushed him away. 
 &bquo;Not that close,&equo; she said, although pleased by the expression on Fritz's face. 
 The record ended and Erika walked off the floor with Herman in attendance. 
 Herr Hocher put on another record, an amateurish jazz band. 
 &bquo;Shall we?&equo; 
 Herman said. 
 &bquo;I thought that you said this was decadent music,&equo; Erika replied. 
 &bquo;Oh, not this. 
 This is quite acceptable. 
 They play it in the Soviet Union. 
 I heard it while I was there. 
 I went to a Young Pioneer dance in Moscow&hellip;.&equo; 
 But his reminiscences, twice, thrice told, were lost on the dance-hall air as Erika walked away round the hall, affecting not to see Fritz who was standing moodily by the door, and giving a start of surprise when he asked her to dance. 
 &bquo;I'm going for a juice,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Anyway, I thought that you had a partner.&equo; 
 &bquo;What? 
 Oh, Bunte. 
 I danced with her.&equo; 
 &bquo;Really? 
 I thought you were teaching her calculus.&equo; 
 Erika! 
 Fritz followed her into the lounge. 
 You did say you weren't going to dance, and she did ask me. 
 I just didn't want to seem rude. 
 And then you went and danced with that Lout &mdash; and  with Herman. 
 Didn't you see me looking at you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I might have done,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;I wanted you to stop dancing &mdash; no! &mdash;&equo; as Erika turned on him &mdash; &bquo;because of what you said, about hurting your foot. 
 That's all.&equo; 
 &bquo;So you didn't mind me dancing with other people?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Fritz went red, which, Erika thought, made rather a nice change from her own blushing, and looked at his shoes. 
 Erika thawed, melted, forgave Fritz, for which he was pathetically grateful, and sent him for fruit juice while she looked for Paul who was happily playing table tennis. 
 She went back into the lounge and sat with Fritz, finding out how remarkably much they had in common, until they were joined by Rosa and other friends and spent two magical hours until, at 10.00, she stood up. 
 &bquo;Home time,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; cutting off Fritz's protests. 
 &bquo;I'm in training and I should be in bed now. 
 Where's Paul?&equo; 
 Fritz scurried off and returned with a reluctant Paul and they went to the door. 
 The Louts had also had enough, enough of Herr Hocher, that is, and were on their scooters, revving them with an ear-splitting racket. 
 &bquo;So,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Good-night, Fritz.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good-night, Erika.&equo; 
 Fritz stared at her. 
 &bquo;I&hellip; 
 I&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 Fritz gulped, &bquo;I wonder&hellip; how about tomorrow?&equo; 
 Erika shook her head. 
 &bquo;I can't. 
 Really. 
 Training.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Of course.&equo; 
 Fritz took a step nearer Erika. 
 &bquo;Perhaps &mdash;, then his face changed. 
 &bquo;Look at Paul,&equo; he said. 
 Cursing Paul under her breath Erika turned. 
 Paul was deep in conversation with a very loutish Lout indeed. 
 &bquo;Paul!&equo; 
 Erika cried over the din of the scooters. 
 &bquo;Paul!&equo; 
 Paul did not, or affected not to, hear her and Erika walked across the yard and took him by the elbow. 
 &bquo;Time for you to come home,&equo; she said, quite as firmly as her mother. 
 The Lout eased the throttle on his scooter and leered through the exhaust smoke. 
 &bquo;What's this about going home? 
 Come with us, have a good time.&equo; 
 Erika ignored him. 
 &bquo;Come on,&equo; she said to Paul. 
 Paul actually hesitated and the Lout stuck his oar in again. 
 &bquo;Are you coming or not, kid? 
 Never mind what she says.&equo; 
 &bquo;Keep out of this,&equo; Erika flared up. 
 &bquo;Clear off.&equo; 
 &bquo;Now just a minute.&equo; 
 The Lout began to swing off his scooter. 
 &bquo;Who are you to give orders? 
 If the kid wants to come he can, see?&equo; 
 &bquo;No he can't.&equo; 
 Fritz's voice came over Erika's shoulder, and it sounded astonishingly determined. 
 &bquo; Another Nosey Parker! &equo; 
 The Lout simulated astonishment. 
 &bquo;The massed ranks of the F.G.Y.! 
 Well keep your nose out of this, Comrade , unless you want trouble.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't want it,&equo; Fritz said. 
 &bquo;But if you insist.&equo; 
 The Lout hesitated for a moment but then, as the other scooters roared out of the yard, he shrugged and revved his own scooter up. 
 &bquo;I'll see you again,&equo; he shouted. 
 &bquo;Any time,&equo; Fritz bellowed back as the Lout drove off, tooting his horn derisively. 
 &bquo;Thanks Fritz,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;But there was no need to bother.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right,&equo; Fritz said. 
 &bquo;I know that character. 
 His father is a big shot and he thinks he is, too. 
 He needed taking down a peg.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wasn't frightened of him,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;I'm sure you weren't.&equo; 
 &bquo;So.&equo; 
 Erika shivered a little. 
 &bquo;So.&equo; 
 Fritz was solicitous. 
 &bquo;Better not stand about.&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll miss your bus.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Slowly, hesitantly, Fritz's hand moved forward and slowly, hesitantly Erika's hand stole forward too and touched it. 
 &bquo;See you Monday then.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 The touch of the hands became the slightest of caresses and then the hands recoiled. 
 &bquo;Good-night,&equo; Erika said, and left with a sullen Paul at her heels. 
 The bus came and they boarded it, but to Erika it seemed less like the familiar old lumbering, lurching, yellow Berlin bus, and more a vehicle of romance, gliding through a night made mysterious by more than fog. 
 But even these strange raptures were forgotten when they got off and, outside the flats, Erika turned on Paul. 
 I won't tell about tonight,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Nothing to tell,&equo; Paul muttered. 
 &bquo;Nothing!&equo; 
 Erika shook her head. 
 &bquo;What do you think Father and Mother would say if they knew you were even thinking  of going off with those kids &mdash; and at this time of night! 
 You're crazy Paul. 
 Really crazy.&equo; 
 And so am I, she thought, as she ran up the stairs. 
 Only Omi was in, and she was ready for bed. 
 Erika helped her prepare and, when she was safely in bed, sat by her. 
 &bquo;Will you do something for me tomorrow, Liebchen ?&equo; 
 Omi asked. 
 Anything, Omi. 
 Anything at all. 
 &bquo;You are sure?&equo; 
 &bquo;Absolutely.&equo; 
 Omi sighed. 
 &bquo;I would like to go to church. 
 Will you take me?&equo; 
 &bquo;Certainly.&equo; 
 Erika tucked in a corner of Omi's duvet. 
 &bquo;Would you like to go to the Cathedral? 
 We could do some window shopping, too.&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 I would like to go into the country. 
 I know a church in Tappersdorf. 
 We can go on the S-Bahn .&equo; 
 &bquo;That would be very nice,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;We'll go. 
 Sleep now. 
 Good-night.&equo; 
 Herr and Frau Nordern came home contented after a pleasant evening. 
 A last drink of coffee was had, and the flat settled down to slumber. 
 As the owl hooted and the night train called, Erika was already slipping into the state where the real world fades and the dreamworld begins, thinking of Fritz and that last, subtle touch of two hands. 
 chapter 13 
 THE NEXT morning Erika helped Omi dress in black, the only colour she considered suitable for Divine Service. 
 Erika dressed soberly, too, although, in an uncharacteristic act of defiance, she pinned her F.G.Y. badge on to her lapel. 
 Although not approving of church-going, Herr Nordern offered to drive Omi and Erika to the church but, the day being bright and sunny, the offer was declined. 
 &bquo;Thank you,&equo; Omi said, &bquo;but, really, the fresh air will do me good.&equo; 
 She smiled. 
 &bquo;And a trip on the S-Bahn , it is a long time since I had one.&equo; 
 Across the table Erika looked up thoughtfully from her smoked ham. 
 With a twinge of conscience it occurred to her that it was not often Omi got out; a rare trip to the theatre or a concert, Wannsee in summer, or Potsdam, but in the winter she was trapped in the flat, passing long, lonely hours looking on to a street where little happened. 
 &bquo;I'll take her out more,&equo; Erika thought, and then realised that she might not be around to do so. 
 Herr Nordern insisted that he should drive Erika and Omi at least to the S-Bahn  station and stood with them until the train came, then, shaking his head, he handed Omi into a carriage. 
 Tappersdorf was a few stops along the line &mdash; countrified and still keeping a rural quietness: poplars masked a factory, behind pre-war houses with steeply pitched roofs fields of sprouts stretched away, the sprouts looking oddly sentient as they stood in their patient, frosty queues, waiting to be picked. 
 Under the inevitable power lines the church looked rural, too: a simple wooden structure with a sharp, narrow steeple prodding at the sky as if to remind God that it was there, its bell clanking as an additional reminder and as a summons to the faithful. 
 There were a good number of these, the men and women solemn in their Sunday best, although the young people, and there were plenty of those, too, were surprisingly casual, wearing jeans and bright sweaters under their black leather jackets; casual and cheerful, too, in their attitude as they entered the church, calling greetings, and making good-natured jokes, much to Omi's disapproval. 
 The interior of the church was quite different: bare, bleak and uncompromising, painted white with a black cross standing on a simple table. 
 If a soul was to meet God there it was without the mediation of stained glass, pictures, images or incense. 
 It was a building for the speaking, and the hearing, of the word of God &mdash; and no distractions allowed. 
 But bleak though the building might be, the welcome was warm, Elders shaking hands with the congregation, delighted to see two new faces, ushering Omi and Erika to their seats. 
 Omi not being of the school which sits as far at the back of a church as possible, Erika found herself under the nose of the Minister, who beamed upon her, and surrounded by family groups: parents, grandparents and children who made an agreeable din until a small group of musicians struck up the opening bars of the first hymn. 
 Erika had been to church before: with Omi, once on her own out of curiosity, and once with the F.G.Y. as a prelude to a discussion on Modern Superstitions. 
 So the service was not unfamiliar; the readings from the Bible in the magnificent prose of Martin Luther, the prayers, the general confession, the great hymns, sung with unaffected fervour and in which Erika joined (although she was critical of the flautist) both because she liked singing and because it would have hurt Omi had she remained silent. 
 But in the prayers, although she knelt and bowed her head, her attention was on the people in the church. 
 How strange, she thought, that such normal, pleasant people could bring themselves to believe in the existence of God. 
 How extraordinary that people her own age should believe such grotesque, non-scientific ideas as that a man could be resurrected from the dead after, and a horrible thought it was, after being crucified; and how fantastic that they should believe that all  the dead would rise from their graves &mdash; all of them, those countless millions, millions upon millions, rising from the clay into which they had, long since, dissolved&hellip;. 
 She peered sideways at Omi. 
 Omi's old head was bowed and her gnarled fingers were pressed together in prayer. 
 Was she praying for resurrection, asking the mysterious, invisible Maker of All Things to hasten the day when she and her dearly loved man would be united again as they had been in those golden days long past? 
 But if Omi was, then surely she was wrong. 
 Erika remembered the Watchword Omi had been reading on the day when Karl had come. 
 The Watchword had read, &bquo;Let the dead bury their dead: but go thou and preach the kingdom of God.&equo; 
 Erika was still not completely sure what the text meant but one thing about it was  clear, people had better things to do than to dwell on the past and surely &mdash; it came upon Erika in a flash of intuition &mdash; surely the State was doing just that: not, of course, leaving the dead unmourned, and certainly not forgetting the evils of Fascism, but moving forward &mdash; preaching a socialist gospel &mdash; and not merely preaching it, doing it: making a fairer, better, juster Germany. 
 Yes! 
 With a mixture of admiration at her own acumen, pride in her country, and affectionate pity for Omi, Erika politely sat upright as the Minister began his sermon. 
 It was not short. 
 When the congregation of the Lutheran Church gathered to hear the Word of God expounded, they expected to hear it expounded fully, and the Pastor of Tappersdorf was ready to oblige, not merely comparing the German text for the day &mdash; a reference to the doings of an obscure Old Testament prophet &mdash; with the original Hebrew, and giving a learned half-hour to an explanation of the circumstances in which the prophet lived, suffered, and prophesied, a time in which it seemed a small group of people struggled for the truth and searched for God under the shadow of huge decadent empires to the East &mdash; and the West, but he, the Pastor, was perfectly willing to apply the prophet's message to the present day &mdash; and to present-day socialist Germany, at that. 
 With a little of the guilty excitement of enjoying a forbidden pleasure, Erika began to listen attentively. 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; the Pastor said, &bquo;of course, the State may properly demand our obedience in many matters: obeying its laws &mdash; if the laws are just; making us pay taxes &mdash; if the taxes are properly spent; supporting its policies &mdash; if the policies are wise. 
 So far the Church is at one with the State. 
 But where do we differ, as Micah differed from the priesthood and rulers of his day? 
 &bquo;It is in this. 
 In the end a totalitarian state says that everything which exists belongs to it. 
 The Church says that in the end everything which exists belongs to God. 
 &bquo;But what is the difference there? 
 What is the difference between an almighty state and almighty God? 
 It lies in one simple point. 
 God has given us complete autonomy, that is self-government, the government of ourselves. 
 We call that freedom, the freedom to do good &mdash; or evil &mdash; and we, the Church, say that the choice between good and evil is an individual one. 
 Of course, if an individual chooses evil then it follows that he must be punished, but he must be punished because he, or she, has deliberately chosen to do evil. 
 &bquo;That is a terrible gift but it is a precious one. 
 It belongs to us as individuals regardless of the power of the State or the claims of the State. 
 And if the State denies us that right of individual choice then, although it might shower us with gifts, it is robbing us of our deepest, profoundest freedom, that upon which all other freedoms depend, and so the State, any State, which denies God's ultimate gift must be opposed.&equo; 
 The Pastor paused for a moment and looked thoughtfully at his flock and, Erika was convinced, piercingly at her. 
 &bquo;There is one more point I should like to make. 
 We are in the season of Advent which, as we know, means the Coming &mdash; &mdash; the Coming of our Lord Jesus Christ &mdash; and He, as we know also, was crucified by rulers who set the claims of the State above Him. 
 But what is the image Advent calls to our minds? 
 Surely it is of the family of Christ, Father, Mother, and Child.&equo; 
 The Pastor smiled a little wryly, &bquo;It is called a unitary family, now, and unitary families are under attack in certain quarters, but the family is at the heart of our religion and our civilisation. 
 Why? 
 Because there we find trust and confidence and love. 
 Every totalitarian state has attacked the family because in that small, loving group they see a threat to the power of the State. 
 And so, if the State sets its claims against those of the family it must be resisted.&equo; 
 The Pastor gazed at the bare, raftered ceiling. 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; he said, &bquo;of course, we are happy to live in a state where no such claims are made. 
 Amen.&equo; 
 The final prayers were said, a final hymn sung, and the blessing given. 
 The congregation stood up and amiably shuffled out, shaking hands as they did so. 
 At the door the Minister was waiting. 
 Surrounded by his flock he nonetheless had an eye on Omi and Erika and, although he made no apparent attempt to meet them, Erika and Omi found themselves facing him. 
 &bquo;Gn&auml;dige Frau,&equo; &mdash; &bquo;Gracious lady.&equo; 
 Omi held out a gloved hand in a stately, aristocratic manner. 
 &bquo;Von Ritter,&equo; she announced herself. 
 &bquo;My granddaughter, Erika Nordern.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, a pleasure.&equo; 
 The Minister shook hands firmly with Erika, his eye resting for a moment on the F.G.Y. badge in her lapel. 
 We haven't seen you before, Frau von Ritter, Erika. 
 &bquo;We live in Biesdorf,&equo; Omi said. 
 &bquo;I see. 
 That will be St Mark's. 
 Pastor Dietrich.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 But I confess I don't go as often as I might,&equo; Omi said. 
 &bquo;My age, and winter.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, winter,&equo; the Minister's voice had the rueful edge common to Germans when speaking of that season. 
 &bquo;And Erika?&equo; 
 He turned to her. 
 &bquo;Do you go to St Mark's?&equo; 
 The question was put lightly but, in view of Erika s F.G.Y. badge, there was a certain teasing quality to it. 
 Somewhat self &mdash; consciously, Erika denied going to St Mark's, or any other church. 
 &bquo;I'm an atheist,&equo; she said defiantly, although feeling rather foolish for saying so; foolish and a little ashamed with Omi standing next to her. 
 But the Pastor was undisturbed. 
 &bquo;An atheist. 
 Quite. 
 But you came to our church.&equo; 
 &bquo;I brought my grandmother,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 The Minister smiled. 
 &bquo;Well, that is a Christian act. 
 Did you enjoy the service?&equo; 
 Actually, Erika had enjoyed it; the resonance of the language, the communal singing and the friendly presence of the congregation had a warmth which, she had to admit, the meetings of the F.G.Y. lacked. 
 As if reading her thoughts the Minister leaned forward a little. 
 &bquo;We have a youth group. 
 Why not come along? 
 You could give a talk &mdash; perhaps &mdash; on atheism.&equo; 
 The treacherous red invaded Erika's cheeks. 
 &bquo;I don't think so. 
 I'm very busy. 
 But excuse me, my grandmother, I mustn't keep her in the cold.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, of course not.&equo; 
 The Minister was solicitous. 
 &bquo;One of us will drive you to the station.&equo; 
 But that offer was declined too, courteous goodbyes were exchanged, and Omi took Erika's arm as they walked back to the S-Bahn . 
 On the way there was a caf&eacute;, a reasonable sort of place with discreet lace curtains. 
 Omi squeezed Erika's elbow. 
 &bquo;Shall we have coffee? 
 We've done our duty so we can have a little treat.&equo; 
 Erika was ready for a treat and a moment later, surrounded by a forest of plants which gave the caf&eacute; an Amazonian aspect, they were seated and ordering coffee and cakes. 
 Omi sighed contentedly as she looked around the room which had a fair smattering of elderly ladies, like herself having a Sunday morning treat. 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; she said, &bquo;I feel better, so much better. 
 It is too long since I went to church &mdash;&equo; she broke off as the coffee and cream cakes arrived. 
 &bquo;Dear me, when I was a child we went to church twice  every Sunday. 
 We girls wore starched white aprons and very uncomfortable they were too. 
 Not that I approve of the way some of the young people were dressed today. 
 The Creator deserves our respect.&equo; 
 She nodded firmly at Erika. 
 &bquo;But you were dressed properly. 
 A true von Ritter.&equo; 
 Erika demurred mildly. 
 &bquo;I'm a Nordern, Omi.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, a Nordern too. 
 I don't deny it.&equo; 
 Omi looked searchingly at Erika. 
 &bquo;But you take after our line. 
 You have fine bones and eyes. 
 The face of an aristocrat.&equo; 
 &bquo;Omi!&equo; 
 Erika dissented quite vehemently from this heresy while, despite herself, her eyes were searching for a mirror. 
 &bquo;You shouldn't say such things. 
 Besides, those old Junker  &mdash;&equo; she was about to say all  those Junker  but in deference to Omi did not &mdash; &bquo;they didn't all look nice. 
 Some of them were awful. 
 Take Hindenburg,&equo; she said, mentioning the last President of the Reich before Hitler took power. 
 &bquo;Hindenburg.&equo; 
 Omi waved a dismissive hand. 
 &bquo;He was middle-class. 
 All Germany may have worshipped him &mdash; but not the von Brombergs. 
 Do you know, in the first World War, when he was Commander-in-Chief, they put up wooden statues of him in all the towns and you could pay and hammer a nail in it! 
 It was for war charities but can you imagine anything more barbarous?&equo; 
 She shook her head then reached across the cakes and patted Erika's hand. 
 &bquo;But you should not forget your ancestry. 
 I know that this is Socialist Germany and all are equal, but blood counts &mdash;&equo; she held up her hand as Erika opened her mouth in a scandalised protest. 
 &bquo;Yes, blood and breeding.&equo; 
 &bquo;But Omi!&equo; 
 Erika was truly shocked. 
 &bquo;That is just what the Nazis said!&equo; 
 &bquo;Ach! 
 That scum.&equo; 
 True contempt showed in Omi's eyes. 
 &bquo;They talked about the glory of the family and then taught children to inform on their parents. 
 Wickedness. 
 Wickedness! 
 No wonder the Almighty brought his lightning on our heads. 
 But it is true, Liebchen , ancestry counts, a family line going back 600 years&hellip; and I see it in you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you see it in Paul?&equo; 
 Erika asked, with a toughness which surprised herself. 
 &bquo;Paul&hellip;.&equo; 
 Omi sliced her cake. 
 &bquo;He takes after his father, doesn't he? 
 He has inherited&hellip; what do they call them?&equo; 
 &bquo;Genes,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 He has inherited the Nordern genes. 
 There is something&hellip; crude about him. 
 It's true, isn't it?&equo; 
 Omi took a tremulous sip of her coffee. 
 Erika watched her across the table feeling baffled. 
 There was genetic inheritance, of course, and Paul was&hellip; well&hellip; crude, like all boys, but it didn't work the way Omi was suggesting, nothing like it. 
 The trouble was that she wasn't quite sure how it did work. 
 She made a mental note to listen more attentively to her lessons in biology and in Marxism, and then, to divert Omi from the views she was expressing, Erika said: &bquo;Uncle Karl will be back soon, Omi. 
 Then we can have the party.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, Karl!&equo; 
 Omi's face lighted up in a vivid smile. 
 &bquo;My Karl. 
 It is something to find a brother, Liebchen .&equo; 
 She stared into her coffee as though it were a pool reflecting the past. 
 &bquo;He wasn't cruel, really,&equo; she said, as if defying an invisible accuser. 
 &bquo;Cruel?&equo; 
 Erika was astonished. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 Omi blinked. 
 &bquo;Did I say cruel? 
 Oh. 
 Well boys are. 
 I don't know why. 
 Pulling wings off flies, killing nestlings&hellip; 
 Karl was misunderstood.&equo; 
 &bquo;I see,&equo; Erika said, although she didn't see at all. 
 She felt disturbed; thinking of the gleaming Karl with his polished manners and mannered poise, and of how once he had been a boy. 
 &bquo;Wild&equo;, Omi had called him the night he arrived, a wild boy, and now another dimension had been added to that figure from long ago: cruelty &mdash; a cruel boy&hellip;. 
 &bquo;But that was long ago,&equo; Omi said. 
 &bquo;Long, long ago. 
 And soon we shall all meet again for the last time. 
 All of us who are left&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Omi!&equo; 
 Erika smiled. 
 &bquo;You will all meet again, many times.&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Omi was certain. 
 &bquo;It will be the last time. 
 We are all growing old and we shall die and be buried.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's not true,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;It is true.&equo; 
 Omi pushed away her coffee cup. 
 &bquo;In any case, Karl will go, and then you will go away, too.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, Omi.&equo; 
 Erika leaned forward. 
 &bquo;I shan't be going far &mdash; even if I go at all.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you won't be at home, will you?&equo; 
 Omi said. 
 &bquo;You won't be coming home in the evening. 
 But there, I'm just a selfish old woman, and a foolish one. 
 You must forgive me, my Dear. 
 And it is true what your father says&hellip; when I think of what it was like after the War, and when I look around now &mdash;&equo; suiting her actions to her words she looked around the caf&eacute;, at the ladies, old and frail, like herself, respectable in black and grey &mdash; &bquo;these went through it too,&equo; she said, &bquo;and look at them, at us, coffee and cake on a Sunday morning. 
 Perhaps it is a miracle&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;You should write it down,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Write your memoirs, all your experiences.&equo; 
 Omi looked steadily at Erika for a long moment, and looking back into Omi's fine, hooded eyes, Erika sensed for the first time ever, not merely that Omi was an old woman who walked rather slowly, was glad of help in undressing, and who, on days when her arthritis was very bad, needed her meat cutting for her. 
 She was a woman from an age quite different from Erika's own; separated by a gulf, a measureless chasm of experience distancing them each from the other as surely as though they were beings from two different planets. 
 Omi crooked a finger for the waitress who offered the bill with subtle deference, and Omi paid it with subtle superiority. 
 And then Omi tapped the table, once. 
 &bquo;Write my memoirs?&equo; she said, and smiled, but such a smile as Erika had never seen on her grandmother's face before: wry, mocking, and, shockingly, cynical. 
 Then the smile went and the eyes were veiled and Omi rose and said, &bquo;I don't think anyone would want to hear my memoirs. 
 Let us go home.&equo; 
 THE NEXT day or two were ones of mild confusion. 
 the phone rang constantly as various relatives called from across the G.D.R. 
 demanding to know the date of the party &mdash; which was unanswerable, since no one knew when Karl would be back from Dresden &mdash; and either confirming that, anyway, if it was to be on a week-end they would be resent &mdash; or not Frau Nordern was annoyed b the refusals but Herr Nordern had a drier view &bquo;Most of them have hardly heard of Karl,&equo; he said &bquo;and anyway it isn't everyone who wants to be seen meeting&hellip;. 
 The rest of the remark he left unsaid, but it did not need spelling out. 
 There were those in the G.D.R. 
 not unhappy at staying away from a western business man, even though he might be a temporary guest of the State; after all, they were permanent  guests and who knew but&hellip;. 
 Although indignant at this slur on her relatives, Frau Nordern forgot it as she, Omi, and Erika became absorbed in planning a menu for the party. 
 Herr Nordern joined in, and even Paul was co-opted although his contribution was less than successful as his views on suitable food seemed to consist only of frankfurter sausages, Cola, and, drawn from a mysterious memory of the dinner in the Palast, champagne. 
 In addition there was the tension of waiting for news from the Ministry of Sport and despite all Herr Nordern's warnings, based on his own profound experience of bureaucracy, he, as well as the rest of the family, found himself waiting with more than usual interest for the postman's knock. 
 And Herr Nordern had tensions of his own to cope with. 
 Despite the assurances of the Director of his Department that he was favourably looked upon, and despite the fact that there was no doubt that at his office he was being treated with a subtle air of respect, nothing formal or official about his promotion had been announced; and as he knew very well, a change of Directorship, a shift in Government economic policy, even a chill wind in international relations, could mean the end of his hopes. 
 And always, at the back of his mind, there was the business with the Police; a mere shadow, as he repeatedly reminded himself, without substance, but there just the same and often, as he went through Ostkreuz on the S-Bahn , he was tempted to get off and see Lieutenant Werner, merely to get the matter sorted out once and for all but, mindful of Bodo's advice, he never did. 
 Erika had her own preoccupations, too. 
 There was, of course, first and absolutely foremost, the need to keep on jumping, and to do so at the very highest level; a need which Fr&auml;ulein Silber emphasised repeatedly. 
 &bquo;Remember, Erika,&equo; she said, &bquo;you are on the ladder, but only just. 
 You have to keep showing improvement, and not just in height but in technique. 
 Your leg is still trailing when you go over the bar. 
 You must concentrate, wipe out everything from your mind but the leap; everything . 
 And I hear that a girl in Pankow is breaking 1.80 every time she jumps.&equo; 
 Erika was not too sure about the girl in Pankow, half suspecting that Fr&auml;ulein Silber was using her as a means of putting pressure on herself. 
 That she was lacking a little in concentration was true, but then she had plenty to disturb her concentration: Uncle Karl, Omi s strange remarks about breeding, the coming party, and, of course, and most disturbing of all, Fritz Kott. 
 And yet what was Fritz to her? 
 Until a few weeks ago she had been scarcely aware of him except as a friendly and familiar face in class; but now, now she was very much aware of him &mdash; and he was very definitely aware of her; much to Erika's embarrassment sitting with her and Rosa at lunch, at the next desk in class, asking her out to the cinema and even, to Erika's amazement and, she suspected, his own, offering to help Paul with his homework &mdash; in the Nordern home, that is &mdash; an offer declined both by Erika and Paul, although Paul did corner Fritz in school and suggest to him that if he actually did  the homework then he, Paul, would further his, Fritz's, courtship of Erika; Paul being shrewd enough to guess the motive behind Fritz's philanthropic gesture even though the square on the hypotenuse might remain a mystery to him. 
 Rosa gently teased Erika about the vestigial romance but was serious about the advice she gave, that Erika was not, repeat not , to get involved with a boy-friend, especially with the Indoor Championships drawing nearer, and with the Ministry of Sport keeping an eye on her. 
 It was advice Erika took seriously, distancing herself from Fritz as much as possible and adroitly using Rosa as a shield so that Fritz was forever baulked in his obscure desires. 
 But still, on the bus going to and from school, on her steady, daily runs in the park, swimming, weight-lifting, doing her exercises, and on those other rare occasions when she was alone and free from the demands of school, State, and family, Erika found herself thinking of Fritz, although what she thought she scarcely knew herself, except that she knew that she blushed when she did so&hellip;. 
 However, on the Wednesday, Erika's mind was freed from Fritz because her mother took her out. 
 &bquo;Meet me at the Centre after school,&equo; she said, imperiously. 
 &bquo;I shan't be free until 7.00,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;I'll be in the gym.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's all right,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;But what about supper &mdash; for Omi and Paul and Father?&equo; 
 &bquo;They can look after themselves for once,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Just meet me at 7.00.&equo; 
 During the day, Erika wondered what her mother wanted her for, but after two hours in the gym she had given up wondering, and, indeed, had forgotten about it. 
 In fact she was walking to the wrong bus-stop before she did recall it. 
 Getting to the Health Centre was a tedious business involving a bus and a clanking ride for a few stops on the underground and Erika was glad to find her way to it, jammed among the usual blocks of flats, although at that time of night they had rather a festive air with every window lighted. 
 Frau Nordern was free when Erika finally penetrated to her room, sitting at her desk behind a mound of reports. 
 She shook her head at Erika. 
 &bquo;Some of these women,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Forty years of socialism, education, propaganda rewards and punishments, and still&hellip; 
 It makes you despair at times. 
 Let's go.&equo; 
 Without explaining to where they were going she walked regally from the room swinging her brief-case which, unlike a great many brief-cases on the streets of Berlin, was filled with notes and papers and not stolen goods. 
 &bquo;One bus,&equo; she said, as they stood on Lenin Allee. 
 &bquo;It should be here in a moment.&equo; 
 As if obeying her the bus did appear and ten minutes later she and Erika were at Frankfurter Allee, a roaring road choked with an army convoy: dozens of lorries, their contents masked by huge tarPaulins. 
 Frau Nordern did not give the lorries a second glance but dived down a side-street into a rather agreeable square. 
 &bquo;Here we are,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Here&equo; was the Buda, the restaurant where the great party was to be held, a long, low building, part of it pre-war, and with its outside liberally plastered with posters of a vastly hairy Karl Marx. 
 &bquo;I want to make sure that everything is in order,&equo; Frau Nordern said, grimly, as they crossed the square. 
 &bquo;I remember Omi s birthday party. 
 Erika remembered that, too. 
 The restaurant had been double booked and when the two parties had met there had been a scene akin to the opening of World War Three until Frau Nordern, at her most imperious, and with the additional, strategic advantage that her husband was a state official and the opposition merely clerks from the Centrum store, cowed the manager and routed the clerks. 
 It seemed that the manager remembered it plainly, too, because as they entered the restaurant, he came from behind his desk like a bolted rabbit and, before Frau Nordern had time to speak, assured her that everything would be in order if only, his hands out wide, beseechingly, if only the gn&auml;dige Frau would give him a date . 
 The manager was a small Hungarian with the cosmopolitan air restaurateurs have the world over and full of a nervous, twitching charm. 
 &bquo;Just a little notice, gn&auml;dige Frau,&equo; he begged. 
 &bquo;I shall have to get extra waiters, order the food, prepare the wine, get musicians &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;We have our own musicians,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Oh!&equo; 
 The manager's face fell as he saw that part of his commission disappear. 
 &bquo;But still, for the rest&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll have plenty of notice,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Now I want to see the room.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, the room.&equo; 
 A subtle expression crossed the manager's face, almost a mocking smile. 
 &bquo;But you have seen the room.&equo; 
 &bquo;Four years ago,&equo; Frau Nordern said dryly, &bquo;and it needed cleaning and painting then. 
 The room!&equo; 
 &bquo;The room.&equo; 
 The manager shrugged, as if defeated. 
 He led them down a small corridor, paused by a door, took out a huge bunch of keys, slowly, and deliberately, unlocked the door, and then, with a dramatic, indeed melodramatic, flourish, flung it open. 
 &bquo; Voil&agrave; !&equo; he said. 
 There was a moment's stunned silence then, &bquo;My word,&equo; said Frau Nordern. 
 &bquo;My word! 
 &bquo; Voil&agrave; !&equo; indeed.&equo; 
 And &bquo; voil&agrave; &equo; was the word, Erika thought. 
 Her memory of the room had been of a dingy, barrack-like hall with fine plaster swags, marred by the fact that chunks of them had been missing, and they, and the room, not improved by having been painted in a weird mixture of colour: purple, pink, green, ochre, rather like the bike belonging to the old man on the S-Bahn . 
 The manager leaned against the wall, arms folded, ankles crossed, in a typical hotelier's pose, and enjoyed his sensation. 
 The plaster work had been restored and gilded so that it glittered against a dazzling white ceiling and against walls hung with crimson wallpaper. 
 Echoing the ceiling, the woodwork was an immaculate white, picked out with crimson, and the floor had been sanded, showing a beautiful, if chipped, parquet. 
 &bquo;You like it?&equo; the manager asked, as if the room had been especially redone for Frau Nordern's sake. 
 &bquo;I certainly do,&equo; Frau Nordern answered, as if the room had  been done for her. 
 &bquo;Come.&equo; 
 The manager crooked a finger and beckoned Frau Nordern and Erika across the room. 
 He jiggled with a formidable lock on a cupboard and opened it. 
 &bquo;See!&equo; 
 The cupboard was stocked with linen, and of the finest quality. 
 &bquo;For the tables,&equo; the manager said, somewhat unnecessarily, and, dropping his voice reverentially he murmured, &bquo;Irish, the finest in the world.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern fingered the linen with covetous hands. 
 &bquo;But how&hellip;?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; the manager smiled wholeheartedly. 
 &bquo;The combine did well last year &mdash; and it was my turn.&equo; 
 &bquo;So that was it,&equo; Erika thought. 
 Like many businesses in the G.D.R. 
 the Buda was part of a combine, leased from the State by the manager and also part of a co-operative. 
 And, as was the rest of the country, reflecting a growing prosperity. 
 &bquo;But the linen,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Ah!&equo; 
 The manager raised a finger and said, with pride in his voice, &bquo;The Deputy Mayor gave a party here six months ago. 
 A private party,&equo; he gave a swift and completely Eastern European look around the room and, almost imperceptibly, lowered his voice; &bquo;with some Friends.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aha!&equo; 
 Erika thought. 
 That was it. 
 A prominent man, Friends &mdash; Russians in other words &mdash; and so skilled men, wallpaper, paint, gold leaf &mdash; and fine linen instantly available; she smiled as she wondered whether Bodo had had a hand in it. 
 Quite likely he had. 
 &bquo;So,&equo; the manager locked, and double locked the cupboard, led the way from the room, locked and double locked that door too, and took the Norderns into the restaurant bar. 
 He pulled out two chairs from a table, brushed a table-cloth of distinctly inferior quality, insisted that Frau Nordern and Erika sit down, and, overriding their feeble protests, treated them to drinks, a large Bulgarian wine for Frau Nordern and a Club Cola for Erika. 
 &bquo;Sit,&equo; the manager said, &bquo;enjoy your drinks, think about your menu, but remember, gn&auml;dige Frau, notice , please.&equo; 
 Rather more docile than when she had entered, Frau Nordern agreed that she would give notice, ample notice, more than enough notice to make sure that they had the room and raised her glass in salute as the manager beamed on Erika and then withdrew to welcome the first of his evening guests, stout, prosperous looking men in heavy dark suits: officials, with their wives. 
 &bquo;Well, well,&equo; Frau Nordern sipped her wine. 
 &bquo;What a surprise. 
 Nice, isn't it?&equo; 
 It was, Erika agreed, much nicer than the Palast, as a matter of fact. 
 She liked the Hungarian manager with his charm and evident desire to please, his pride in his dining-room and linen and his unabashed pleasure at their pleasure; so unlike the haughty anonymity of the Palast. 
 &bquo;So, the Deputy Mayor had a party in that very room!&equo; 
 Frau Nordern glanced at a menu, &bquo;And the prices have hardly gone up at all.&equo; 
 She fished in her brief-case and, to Erika's amazement took out a packet of cigarettes. 
 &bquo;Oh yes,&equo; she said, &bquo;I do sometimes, especially after a day like I've had. 
 No need to mention it to Father, though.&equo; 
 Erika shook her head, hypnotised by the sight of her mother smoking. 
 &bquo;We really must find out when Karl is coming back,&equo; Frau Nordern went on. 
 &bquo;I don't want to miss getting that room. 
 We'll put flowers in it, bouquets&hellip; 
 Omi will be so proud and happy.&equo; 
 She half-smiled. 
 &bquo;She still hankers after the Adlon.&equo; 
 She tapped the ash off her cigarette and looked around the restaurant. 
 More people had come in, well-dressed men and women, shedding vast overcoats, ordering wine, food, lighting cigars&hellip; a violinist, young, blonde, blue eyed, dressed improbably as a gipsy woman was playing a tzigane, accompanied by a pianist dressed even more improbably as a gipsy man. 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; Frau Nordern sighed, &bquo;it will be nice when Hans gets his promotion. 
 We'll be able to get out more, come to places like this. 
 And get another flat, bigger, although you'll be away &mdash; no, Erika,&equo; brushing aside any protest, &bquo;Hans is sure you'll go, but another room will be so good. 
 A room of my own, to have some privacy&hellip;.&equo; 
 Privacy; Erika longed for it herself, often, but it occurred to her, for the first time, that her mother might long for it, too, might want it and, indeed, need  it, and it dawned on her, also for the first time, that her mother had never  had any privacy since the end of the War; that all her life since then she had lived in small apartments, actually in one small room for long periods, and sharing even that room with others&hellip;. 
 Her mother was leaning back, her head tilted, a faint flush from the wine tinting her cheeks, the tilt of her head drawing the flesh from her chin and jaw, making her look young, younger than her years, and handsome, and, Erika suddenly realised, her eyes were of an exquisite forget-me-not blue. 
 Erika looked away, puzzled. 
 Across the room a young man, eating on his own, was looking at her mother, and not innocently, either. 
 &bquo;Mother!&equo; 
 Erika whispered. 
 &bquo;That man, that man over there. 
 He's staring at you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hmm?&equo; 
 It took a moment for Erika's words to sink in. 
 Frau Nordern blew out a voluptuous stream of smoke and looked at the man who suddenly became extremely interested in his herring Bismarck. 
 &bquo;He's quite good-looking,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 The blue eyes turned on Erika like searchlights. 
 &bquo;Just an observation. 
 An objective judgement.&equo; 
 She took a drink of her wine, and then, disconcertingly, asked, &bquo;What's all this about a boyfriend?&equo; 
 The blood rushed to Erika's face. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 And then, with a flash of temper, &bquo;Has Paul been telling stupid tales?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern raised a shoulder. 
 &bquo;He didn't need to. 
 You've been mooning about for a few weeks,&equo; she chuckled, ruefully. 
 &bquo;I'm not blind, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's nothing,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Anyway, I haven't got a boyfriend.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Just don't go getting involved with some spotty adolescent. 
 Not now at any rate, you've got too much at stake.&equo; 
 She gazed into her glass. 
 &bquo;I'm going to have another drink. 
 It's so nice in here, not worrying about other people, or getting supper, or anything. 
 And sitting with you. 
 It's a long time since we did that.&equo; 
 It had been more than a long time, Erika reflected. 
 In fact she had never sat in a restaurant alone with her mother. 
 They had taken an occasional coffee together after shopping, but this was a new experience. 
 Totally new. 
 And it was new seeing her mother leaning back with a drink and a cigarette, looking years younger than her age; and she herself felt different, older, suddenly, if older was the word she wanted. 
 But how strange it was, the changes which the past two or three weeks had brought: not merely the changes of circumstances; her father and his hoped for promotion, herself going to the Stadium, Omi talking about herself, Fritz&hellip; but the whole relationship inside the family had altered, and she herself had changed, and it had begun with the arrival of Uncle Karl, as if he were a sorcerer, a wave of whose manicured hands could transform life, as alchemists thought they could transform base metal into gold or, with a certain sinister frisson , perhaps the other way around. 
 But that was not a pleasant thought and Erika firmly pushed it away, thinking of movement from a lower to a higher stage of development, as Marx taught, and such as was taking place now, she and her mother sitting together, no longer like mother and daughter, teacher and child, but more like sisters. 
 Frau Nordern's drink came. 
 She lighted another cigarette. 
 &bquo;Have a glass of wine,&equo; she said. 
 She waved away Erika's protest that she was in strict training. 
 &bquo;A glass of light wine won't kill you,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Anyway, you'll have enough strict training where you're going.&equo; 
 Sisterlike or not, Frau Nordern's word was enough and Erika found herself with a glass of light Hungarian wine and enjoying it, too. 
 Frau Nordern tapped ash from another cigarette into her ashtray. 
 &bquo;You're sure you want to go?&equo; 
 &bquo;Go?&equo; 
 Erika blinked. 
 &bquo;We've just &mdash;&equo; she gestured at the drinks. 
 &bquo;Go to the special sports school,&equo; her mother said, a little testily. 
 &bquo;We are all excited about it, but you don't have to go if you don't want to. 
 Remember that. 
 I don't want you going just because you think that it will please us &mdash; Hans and me. 
 It will mean giving up a lot, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought that you wanted me to go,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;I do,&equo; Frau Nordern toyed with her glass. 
 &bquo;But sometimes I wonder why. 
 You know, most parents want their children to do things, do this, do that, make money, become famous, have a better house&hellip; car&hellip; although, actually, there are plenty who want the opposite &mdash; yes, that's true, some are jealous, full of hate &mdash; I see it at work &mdash; but you&hellip; 
 I want you to go because you want to go. 
 It will mean giving up a lot and &mdash;&equo; she gave the ghost of a smile &mdash; &bquo;I know what that means. 
 I missed a lot when I was your age.&equo; 
 Yes, Erika knew that. 
 Her mother had missed a lot; a refugee on that terrible trek with Omi, the bleak years in a ruined city in a ruined country, the children coming late, work again&hellip;. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Mother,&equo; she said. 
 Frau Nordern waved smoke from her eyes, waved away the past. 
 &bquo;I'm not complaining,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I was lucky. 
 Your father was always good to me, and his uncle. 
 Better than we deserved. 
 What were we to them?&equo; 
 She veiled her eyes in a startling evocation of Omi. 
 &bquo;It wasn't what you might think. 
 Women outnumbered men in those days, you know. 
 The men were buried between here and&hellip;&equo; she drew an invisible line with her fingers, as if sketching the road from Berlin to Stalingrad, Bonn to El Alamein, Stuttgart to Normandy. 
 &bquo;Yes, always good, to me and Omi, even in the rubble times. 
 That's why I stayed &mdash; here I mean.&equo; 
 Emboldened by her glass of wine, and by this new found intimacy, Erika asked, &bquo;Mother, are you glad you stayed?&equo; 
 &bquo;Glad?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern pushed her glass a little. 
 &bquo;What does that mean? 
 If we had gone to the West, then what? 
 I might have had a different man, a bigger apartment, a bigger car, travel that way instead of this. 
 But things would have been much the same. 
 They are really. 
 People live their lives&hellip; somehow&hellip;.&equo; 
 She looked up, the blue searchlights glowing. 
 &bquo;I would have had different children. 
 You and Paul might never have existed. 
 that's a strange thought, isn't it? 
 But here you are, and here I am, and I wouldn't have that different, Liebchen . 
 But Omi&hellip; 
 I don't know. 
 I think that she might have gone. 
 Does she ever speak about it to you?&equo; 
 Erika shook her head. 
 &bquo;Never a word.&equo; 
 &bquo;She wouldn't. 
 She has honour. 
 Give the old Junker  that.&equo; 
 Erika was shocked. 
 &bquo;Mother,&equo; she said, &bquo;the Junker  put Hitler in power.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, they did,&equo; Frau Nordern agreed. 
 &bquo;Some of them. 
 Some of them tried to blow him up, too. 
 And they paid for it.&equo; 
 That was true, Erika admitted: the July Plot in 1944 when a group of officers, aristocrats to a man, had tried to assassinate Hitler and been caught and hanged with piano wire &mdash; and filmed being hanged &mdash; and the film shown at Hitler's headquarters as after dinner entertainment&hellip;. 
 &bquo;One of them was a relative of yours,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;You didn't know that, did you? 
 A second cousin. 
 And there were Junker  and Junker . 
 The Brombergs and the Ritters, they were always Christians, very devout, God-fearing&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Were you one, a Christian?&equo; 
 In the warm intimacy of the caf&eacute; Erika felt emboldened to ask such a question. 
 &bquo;I was brought up as one,&equo; Frau Nordern said, &bquo;but after 1945&hellip; a God who would allow that to happen&hellip; that's what I mean about Omi's honour. 
 She gave her word to God when she was confirmed and she kept it. 
 Just as she gave her word to Hans.&equo; 
 &bquo;Gave her word?&equo; 
 Erika was intensely interested. 
 &bquo;Oh, not formally.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern toyed with her wine. 
 &bquo;No oath-taking on a Bible or anything like that, but there was an understanding.&equo; 
 &bquo;An understanding?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 You know your father. 
 Working class, a socialist through thick and thin, and us. 
 Two worlds, really. 
 It could have been difficult. 
 So the past was forgotten. 
 Wiped out. 
 Our past I mean. 
 Even Father.&equo; 
 For a moment Erika was at a loss as to whom her mother was talking about, then it dawned on her. 
 &bquo;You mean your father.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who else? 
 Of course I hardly knew him. 
 I've forgotten him, actually.&equo; 
 Yes, but Omi hadn't, Erika thought, she had not forgotten that handsome officer who had courted her all those inconceivable years ago. 
 &bquo;I'm a bit worried about Omi,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Worried?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, she seems, I don't know, a little withdrawn just now. 
 Have you noticed?&equo; 
 Erika put her chin on her hand. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; she admitted. 
 Omi had been rather silent, in the flat at any rate, although&hellip;. 
 &bquo;She talked when we went to church,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Oh, what about?&equo; 
 Erika shrugged. 
 &bquo;Family, breeding.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern glanced at her watch but seemed in no hurry to move. 
 &bquo;I suppose that's because of Karl coming back. 
 It must have stirred up some memories for her, days of wine and roses, eh? 
 No matter how deep it's buried, the past, back it comes, like ghosts, really. 
 This is a city of ghosts.&equo; 
 Erika looked up, startled. 
 What a strange remark that was, coming from her mother who always seemed so practical and matter-of-fact. 
 Frau Nordern did not miss Erika's surprise. 
 She took another sip of wine and smiled crookedly. 
 &bquo;It is. 
 Everyone here is haunted one way or another. 
 The things that were done, the dead&hellip; strange isn't it, all those Germans killed by the Russians, Germans killed by Germans. 
 Ach, it's best forgotten. 
 It only leads to rows &mdash; like the other night.&equo; 
 &bquo;But we can't forget everything, Mother.&equo; 
 Erika dutifully echoed the lessons of school. 
 &bquo;We have to learn from the past.&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose so.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern rose. 
 &bquo;Anyway,&equo; she returned abruptly to the affairs of the practical world. 
 &bquo;We must find out when Karl is coming back so we can book the room. 
 I don't want to miss that. 
 Have you enjoyed it? 
 Being out?&equo; 
 Yes, Erika had enjoyed it, very much so; the proud little manager, looking at the other guests, the intimacy of the talk with her mother, and, knowing her mother's pride in her children, she had been touched by her concern about the special sports school. 
 That thought in particular kept her warm as they left the restaurant for the bitter streets of the city. 
 Herr Nordern was a little grumpy when they got home. 
 Steinmark was still absent and he, Nordern, was doing two men's work which annoyed him, particularly as he wanted to give the best possible impression of himself during the next few weeks. 
 He welcomed his wife and Erika briefly, said that as he had prepared the meal he was not going to wash up, and retreated into his bedroom. 
 Frau Nordern and Erika ate, fussed over by Omi. 
 Paul was dragged from his retreat to wash up, a little work was done, and then, as the family prepared for bed, the phone rang. 
 Frau Nordern threw her hands in the air. 
 &bquo;Always the same. 
 You either sit down for a meal or get ready for bed and the phone goes.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll get it.&equo; 
 Erika picked up the phone and through a barrage of crackles heard a smooth voice. 
 &bquo;Uncle Karl,&equo; she said, handing the receiver to her mother. 
 Frau Nordern snatched at it. 
 &bquo;Karl? 
 Speak up, I can't hear you. 
 The usual G.D.R. 
 telephone conversation took place, as if two deaf people were talking to each other on a rowdy main road, but fragments of conversation filtered through as Frau Nordern repeated what Karl, presumably, was saying. 
 &bquo;Ah!&hellip; 
 Good&hellip; yes, well&hellip; coming back!&hellip; 
 What?&hellip; 
 When? 
 Yes&hellip; 
 YES&hellip;.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern beckoned Omi. 
 &bquo;He'll want to talk to you.&equo; 
 Omi picked up the phone, said &bquo;Karl&equo; a couple of times, then frowned at Frau Nordern. 
 &bquo;I can't hear anything.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern took the phone again, bellowed &bquo;Karl!&equo; several decibels louder than Omi, shook the phone as if it were a recalcitrant child, listened again, then put it down. 
 &bquo;Cut off,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Never mind. 
 It's all right. 
 He's finished in Dresden and he's coming back tomorrow.&equo; 
 Omi's eyes glowed but Frau Nordern raised a warning finger. 
 &bquo;He may not be able to get round immediately, but he'll let us know as soon as he can. 
 So, now we can really get on with the party. 
 Actually, I'll be glad to get it over with. 
 It's so unsettling.&equo; 
 The Norderns went to their beds. 
 As ever, Erika peered through her window for a moment or two. 
 The sky was clear and glittering with icy stars. 
 A police car went past, the Dresden train, punctual to the minute, its klaxon, muted by distance, sounding a friendly, human signal. 
 The owl hooted in the beech tree and, to Erika's deep delight, it was answered by another owl. 
 Erika smiled, glad to know that her owl had company. 
 She gently turned Omi's pillow to stop her mild snoring and then drifted off into her own dreamless sleep. 
 THE NEXT morning was bustle with herr Nordern still a little grumpy. 
 &bquo;Didn't sleep well,&equo; he said, mildly apologetic, snatching a bite of bread and cheese, gulping a cup of coffee standing before nodding curtly and dashing out into a freezing morning. 
 Herr Nordern's temper wasn't improved when, having caught the S-Bahn , he realised that he had left his book of tickets in his other Jacket. 
 He was strongly tempted to stay on the train and take his chance but remembering the man he had seen the Railway Police arrest he got off at Lichtenberg and bought a ticket at the machine. 
 He was cutting his journey fine and it was only by actually jogging from Friedrichstrasse, and feeling a fool for doing so, apart from almost breaking his neck by slipping on the icy pavement, that he arrived at his office before the ominous red line was drawn. 
 Consequently he was in a ferocious temper when he got into his room and saw a mound of mail on his desk, half of which was addressed to Steinmark. 
 &bquo;Steinmark!&equo; he exploded. 
 &bquo;Herr Nordern to attend to this &mdash; and this &mdash; and this &mdash;!&equo; 
 He scattered the letters across his desk. 
 &bquo;What the devil is he up to in Dresden? 
 A few archives to look into. 
 He's been there for weeks and I could have done the whole thing in a couple of days. 
 I know what he's doing &mdash;&equo; answering himself &mdash; &bquo;skiving off! 
 And what's the matter with you?&equo; 
 He looked sternly at Herr M&uuml;ller who had an odd expression. 
 &bquo;You've not heard then?&equo; 
 M&uuml;ller asked. 
 &bquo;About him?&equo; 
 &bquo;About who?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was testy. 
 &bquo;Steinmark,&equo; M&uuml;ller said. 
 &bquo;He's dead.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dead?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was astounded. 
 &bquo;Dead? 
 That's impossible. 
 He's as healthy as you or me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Was,&equo; M&uuml;ller said. 
 &bquo;But he's dead all the same.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern sat down heavily. 
 &bquo;It's&hellip; 
 I mean&hellip; that's incredible. 
 What happened?&equo; 
 M&uuml;ller shook his head. 
 &bquo;They say it was an accident. 
 Someone said he was hit by a train.&equo; 
 &bquo;A train!&equo; 
 Nordern stared at the mail, dumbfounded. 
 &bquo;How in God's name could that happen?&equo; 
 M&uuml;ller shrugged. 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 That's all I've heard.&equo; 
 &bquo;But it's&hellip;.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern groped for words as he stared at the envelopes with Steinmark written across them. 
 &bquo;It's fantastic. 
 I mean, how?&equo; 
 &bquo;Your guess is as good as mine,&equo; M&uuml;ller said. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Nordern fished out a cigar. 
 &bquo;I'll be honest, I never liked the man but &mdash;&equo; he lit his cigar. 
 &bquo;I suppose that we'll get the details in time.&equo; 
 &bquo;I hope we get a replacement,&equo; M&uuml;ller said heartlessly as they settled down to work. 
 At 10.30 Herr Nordern's phone rang. 
 Herr Nagel, the Section Head, wished to see him. 
 &bquo;Come in, come in,&equo; Nagel said as Nordern rapped on his door. 
 &bquo;Take a seat. 
 You have heard of this business about Steinmark?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Terrible. 
 M&uuml;ller says he was hit by a train!&equo; 
 Nagel was exasperated. 
 &bquo;I don't know how these things get around, but that's quite correct.&equo; 
 He flicked a finger against the palm of his hand. 
 &bquo;He was badly&hellip; well&hellip; mangled.&equo; 
 &bquo;But how on earth can you get hit by a train?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;A child, yes, but a grown man! 
 If it was a car&hellip; but a train!&equo; 
 Nagel flicked his palm more vigorously then placed his hands on his desk. 
 &bquo;It seems&hellip;.&equo; 
 He hesitated for a moment and lowered his voice&hellip;. 
 &bquo;It seems that there are some, well, some low drinking dens on the other side of the tracks. 
 It also seems that our Herr Steinmark had some&hellip; some degraded habits. 
 He had been going there, to that area and&hellip; 
 I don't need to spell it out for you but the assumption is that he was going back drunk and got hit. 
 That information is for you only. 
 Understood?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Nagel nodded. 
 &bquo;I must say it makes you wonder what the Security Police are up to not knowing that &mdash; and Steinmark working with secret archives.&equo; 
 He stared bleakly over Herr Nordern's head. 
 &bquo;I dare say that there will be some questions asked.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll bet there will be,&equo; Herr Nordern thought. 
 There would be some uneasy heads lying on their pillows that night. 
 &bquo;Did you know anything about him?&equo; 
 Nagel asked. 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was emphatic. 
 &bquo;I never saw him outside work &mdash; apart from Union meetings.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; Nagel agreed. 
 &bquo;These middle-aged bachelors&hellip; anyway, don't be surprised if Security want a word with you. 
 But still, we have to think about our own work. 
 I was hoping that Steinmark would be back on Monday but I'm afraid that you will have to carry on the best you can. 
 I'll find a replacement as soon as possible. 
 If there is anyone you would like to recommend let me know. 
 And keep an eye on young M&uuml;ller.&equo; 
 &bquo;M&uuml;ller is all right,&equo; Nordern said, a little surprised at his own warmth. 
 &bquo;I'm sure he is, but these young men&hellip;. 
 Anyway, carry on and let me know if there are any real difficulties. 
 Sorry you are going to be burdened, but there it is. 
 Now, about these figures for the meeting next week&hellip;.&equo; 
 The talk drifted off into technicalities for a while, and then, those disposed of, Nagel told Herr Nordern that he could go. 
 &bquo;But keep this business about Steinmark under your hat,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Oh, and perhaps as senior man you might like to arrange something for his funeral, a wreath, represent the Section, that sort of thing. 
 If you would?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern would, yes, although he would no more have refused than he would have tried to jump over the Wall. 
 He went back to his office, made some sharp remarks to a surprised, and hurt, M&uuml;ller about sloppy work, worked himself, then went to the canteen for his lunch. 
 The canteen, a gloomy area in the basement, was buzzing with talk about Steinmark. 
 Herr Nordern was quizzed by the entire staff but stoically maintained that he knew no more than anyone else. 
 But as he attacked his potato salad Herr Nordern felt exultation. 
 Not, of course, at Steinmark's death, but at how Nagel had confided in him and how, quite explicitly, responsibility for the sub-section had been handed to himself. 
 Both were signs that he was, indeed, marked for promotion. 
 It was hard luck on Steinmark, that went without saying, but if the man had been lurking in disreputable quarters and lurching home drunk, it was his own fault. 
 All that now remained was to get the next couple of weeks over &mdash; have the party, get Karl away, see Erika settled, get the business of the accident cleared up and then, although he did not normally think in melodramatic terms &mdash; then the future! 
 He finished his lunch, went back to his office, gave a bemused M&uuml;ller a stern warning about the standards expected from state officials, buckled into a solid afternoon's work and, when the working day was over, carried a bulging briefcase home. 
 He opened the familiar door, giving the aluminium plate a rub with his sleeve, but in the tiny vestibule he paused. 
 A smell, rich, savoury, and unfamiliar was drifting from the flat. 
 He raised his eyebrows and pushed into the sitting-room. 
 There, with the rest of the family, drinking whisky, smooth, dapper, silver hair gleaming, face glowing, teeth shining, was Uncle Karl. 
 &bquo;My dear fellow!&equo; 
 As glossy as a fashion-plate, Karl jumped up, grasped Herr Nordern's hand, and beamed into his face. 
 &bquo;What a pleasure to see you again. 
 I know that it has only been a couple of weeks but my word, it does seem longer, and so much has happened to you, hasn't it? 
 I know because I called around early and took my sister out for tea. 
 You don't mind, do you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course not.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was a trifle brusque, not only because he did mind Karl being in his flat at dinner-time, but also because he found his florid manners irritating. 
 &bquo;And,&equo; Karl flourished a whisky bottle. 
 &bquo;May I tempt you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course you may,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Have a drink Hans &mdash; and can you smell that? 
 Karl brought a saddle of venison.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern nodded to Karl, took the whisky, and then felt bound to be agreeable. 
 &bquo;How was Dresden? 
 A successful trip?&equo; 
 Karl smiled. 
 &bquo;Oh yes. 
 Yes. 
 I think that I can say it was.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm glad to hear it.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern slumped on a chair. 
 &bquo;Oddly enough, I had some news from Dresden today.&equo; 
 He looked across at Frau Nordern. 
 &bquo;Steinmark is dead.&equo; 
 He told the details to an incredulous audience, although tactfully leaving out the part about Steinmark's base habits, merely suggesting that he had probably been taking a short cut across the line. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Frau Nordern shook her head. 
 &bquo;People will do that. 
 You see the children at the S-Bahn  here. 
 They just will not go over the bridge.&equo; 
 She frowned at Paul who affected an air of exaggerated innocence. 
 &bquo;But Steinmark! 
 You never know, do you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Still, it helps my promotion along,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Are you all right?&equo; 
 He turned to Karl who had spluttered into his drink. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Yes. 
 Quite all right.&equo; 
 Karl dabbed his mouth with one of his beautiful handkerchiefs. 
 &bquo;Drink went down the wrong way.&equo; 
 He poured himself more whisky, pressing Herr Nordern to have another, too, and saying that he was leading the Norderns into bad ways but that they must forgive him as it wasn't very often they saw him, ha! ha! and Herr Nordern, while not prepared to accept that he was led by anyone except the leaders of his country, took the whisky, thinking, what the devil, he had worked like a dog all day, and it was true, Karl would not be with them much longer and they would probably never see him again and, he had to confess, he wouldn't mind if he never saw him again as long as either of them lived. 
 And it was excellent whisky. 
 &bquo;We've been working out the date for the party,&equo; Frau Nordern said, producing an enormous desk diary. 
 &bquo;It will have to be a week on Saturday.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why so late?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern asked. 
 &bquo;I would have thought Karl wants to get away before then.&equo; 
 &bquo;Erika.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern said firmly. 
 &bquo;She can't be going off to a big party before the Championship. 
 She has to go into very  strict training for the week before, and a week on Saturday means we can have the party on the evening after the Championship.&equo; 
 &bquo;That suit you Karl?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Karl smiled, &bquo;I would have preferred to go sooner but yes I can stay. 
 A little more business, and maybe some sightseeing. 
 It occurred to me that perhaps I could invite Erika and Paul out for lunch.&equo; 
 &bquo;That is nice,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;And Erika might show you some sights.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, sights.&equo; 
 Karl nodded. 
 &bquo;I have seen a few, you know, ha! ha! but yes, that would be excellent. 
 A little sightseeing with a pretty girl &mdash; but you are sure it would not be inconvenient, Erika? 
 It wouldn't interrupt your training?&equo; 
 No, lunch and a little sightseeing would not interrupt Erika's training or, Paul eagerly assured everyone, his homework. 
 &bquo;It will be a great event, the party,&equo; Karl said. 
 &bquo;A rare meeting, and you, dear sister,&equo; he turned to Omi, &bquo;will be at the head of the table with me!&equo; 
 &bquo;Speaking of which,&equo; Herr Nordern, while quite happy to lounge back with a good cigar and a glass of whisky, was also ready for his meal. 
 Reading his thought Frau Nordern stood up. 
 &bquo;All right, Hans. 
 It should be ready now.&equo; 
 The table was laid, the saddle of venison made its appearance, from his cornucopia Karl produced excellent wine, the venison was carved, toasts exchanged, and then there was a vigorous knock on the door. 
 &bquo;Now who can that be,&equo; Frau Nordern said, exasperated. 
 &bquo;Go and see, Paul, and tell them that we're busy.&equo; 
 Paul went, but the caller was not to be turned away. 
 On the contrary he strode in, rubbing his hands and making it clear that he, too, would like a piece of venison, and he being Bodo it was not really possible to refuse him. 
 &bquo;Let me introduce you,&equo; Herr Nordern said, resigned to his fate. 
 &bquo;My brother Bodo &mdash; Uncle Karl.&equo; 
 Erika watched the meeting of the men with interest. 
 Bodo, big in his brown overalls, holding out a large, square, calloused hand with broken finger-nails and taking Karl's white hand firmly but, Erika noticed, not squeezing hard. 
 A surprisingly delicate gesture for such an apparently rough man. 
 &bquo;Well, I'm glad to meet you,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;Of course, I've heard all about you.&equo; 
 &bquo;And I have heard about you.&equo; 
 Karl flashed his charming smile. 
 &bquo;My dear sister was talking about you only today at tea. 
 A builder! 
 A splendid profession; to make homes for people, build new cities, really, a modern hero!&equo; 
 He chattered on in his easy way to a somewhat sceptical family who were not accustomed to thinking of Bodo in this new and totally unexpected light. 
 Bodo himself said little, tucking into the venison but, Erika noticed, he kept a sharp and shrewd eye on Karl. 
 Inevitably, over supper, the conversation turned on Karl. 
 Bodo asked about the building trade in West Germany, Herr Nordern about economic planning, Frau Nordern was curious about the social welfare services, and Paul asked about rock and roll, about which Karl modestly denied all knowledge. 
 &bquo; The Merry Widow  is more my taste, and my sister's, too. 
 Is that not so?&equo; 
 Turning to Omi, skilfully bringing her into the conversation, and complimenting her on the way the venison had been cooked. 
 &bquo;But of course we know something about it, don't we?&equo; 
 He addressed himself to Bodo. 
 &bquo;Forgive me for saying so but in East Prussia &mdash; Poland, I should say! &mdash; we had our pick of game. 
 Deer, wild boar, so we can claim to be connoisseurs. 
 Although I must say it is difficult to find a butcher now who understands how to hang meat, dear me, yes&hellip;.&equo; 
 The talk drifted away to food, shortages of in the G.D.R. 
 stoutly denied by Herr Nordern, strange gluts of &mdash; equally stoutly defended by him, memorable meals of the past, the coming party, and, although Omi barely spoke a word, sitting silently, merely picking at her meal, Karl kept up a lively alert manner which belied his years. 
 Supper over, Paul, with astonishing docility, took the plates away and Karl produced brandy, the very best French cognac, and a little was sipped over coffee. 
 &bquo;I do hope that you don't mind, Bodo,&equo; Karl said. 
 &bquo;This is not in any way meant to be a slight on the excellent brandy one gets here.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's about ten times better,&equo; Bodo said bluntly and cheerfully, swigging his glassful and accepting another. 
 &bquo;Aha! 
 I see that you are not afraid to speak your mind,&equo; Karl said. 
 &bquo;I do like that in a man &mdash; openness and frankness. 
 I've always found it paid, in the Army and in business. 
 Tell the truth and shame the Devil, as they say, ha! ha!&equo; 
 And that, Erika thought, was a curious remark for Karl to make, bearing in mind that he had lived a lie for many years but, glancing at her parents, and they not batting an eyelash, she kept quiet. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Bodo answered Karl, rolling a cigar in his blunt fingers and sounding profoundly sincere. 
 &bquo;That's what they say, right enough. 
 By the way, Hans, did you hear any more from Ostkreuz?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ostkreuz?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern blinked. 
 &bquo;Yes, the cops.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Police?&equo; 
 Karl interrupted, his eyes bright and penetrating. 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; Herr Nordern was dismissive. 
 &bquo;Nothing, nothing at all. 
 A case of mistaken identity.&equo; 
 He explained briefly what had happened and added, untruthfully, that the Police had been friendly, helpful, and understanding. 
 &bquo;It is odd though,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Two accidents in just a few days.&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose so.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern told Bodo about Steinmark. 
 &bquo;And I was in Dresden only last night,&equo; Karl said. 
 &bquo;A most unpleasant coincidence. 
 I'm only &mdash; I won't say glad , no, that would be quite the wrong word, but, shall I say relieved , that it happened last night.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why is that?&equo; 
 Bodo asked, casually. 
 &bquo;My dear chap!&equo; 
 Karl leaned forward and tapped Bodo on his knee. 
 &bquo;I might have been on the train that hit him! 
 What a ghastly thought! 
 Thank goodness that I came back this morning.&equo; 
 &bquo;Right.&equo; 
 Bodo said. 
 &bquo;But I hope that there weren't any well-dressed men wandering around the railway line in Dresden last night.&equo; 
 A little of Karl's immaculate poise slipped. 
 He stared into his brandy and then, rather sourly for such a charming man, said, &bquo;I'm afraid that I don't quite follow you, Bodo.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was thinking of Hans and the car accident,&equo; Bodo said, quite unruffled. 
 &bquo;Some idiot might have seen a well-dressed elderly gent near the railway line and then you could have been questioned.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, now I see!&equo; 
 The cloud lifted from Karl's face. 
 &bquo;Of course, I understand. 
 Foul play suspected, mistaken identity, a wrongful arrest! 
 My word, Bodo, I really think that you are in the wrong profession. 
 You ought to be writing detective stories!&equo; 
 He laughed in his merry way. 
 &bquo;But I was tucked up in bed early &mdash; not difficult in Dresden you know, they don't have West German television down there &mdash; oh! 
 Perhaps I should not have said that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why not,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;Idiots' alley, we call it. 
 Just because of that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you indeed?&equo; 
 Karl was slightly disapproving. 
 &bquo;Forgive me, but as a guest of your Government I&hellip; well, I'm sure that you understand.&equo; 
 He glanced at his watch. 
 &bquo;But really, I ought to be tucked up in bed now. 
 At my age&hellip; and I have ordered a taxi&hellip;.&equo; 
 Karl was muffled up in his luxurious overcoat. 
 He kissed Frau Nordern, Erika, and Omi, holding her firmly but gently, and staring into her old eyes, and saying, Do remember our little chat this afternoon, dear sister,&equo; and she, her eyes moist, like a well refilling after a drought, promised that she would. 
 A peek through the window showed that the taxi had arrived, brief farewells were made to the men, and Karl left, promising to ring them the next day and making mock threats to Erika and Paul should they forget to meet him the following Sunday. 
 &bquo;As if you would,&equo; Frau Nordern said to Paul as the door closed on Karl. 
 &bquo;But you would forget your homework. 
 Do it now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Homework,&equo; Herr Nordern said with more sympathy than he would normally have allowed himself. 
 &bquo;I've plenty to do myself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Understood.&equo; 
 Bodo was sympathetic. 
 &bquo;I'll be off in a minute.&equo; 
 He helped himself to another brandy and waved the bottle before Herr Nordern's eyes. 
 &bquo;Oh, very well,&equo; Herr Nordern had a nip and, as Erika volunteered to wash up, Frau Nordern, not to be outdone, had one also, and, coaxed by the family, Omi had a thimbleful too. 
 &bquo;So,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;What do you think of Karl, Bodo. 
 Isn't he a gentleman?&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose so,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;I don't know the type so I can't tell. 
 Don't mix with nobs much. 
 Well-dressed though, and I wouldn't mind having his watch.&equo; 
 Omi tutted censoriously but Frau Nordern was more open in her disapproval. 
 &bquo;Really Bodo, don't you think of anything but&hellip; but things  and money.&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Bodo, gap-toothed, grinned. 
 &bquo;But I was thinking about Steinmark. 
 Just shows, doesn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Shows what?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern demanded. 
 &bquo;Oh, just that you can never tell. 
 Put the right clothes on someone and everyone judges them by their appearance. 
 Dark-blue suit, black hat, respectable official &mdash; like Hans &mdash; or Steinmark. 
 Smart grey suit, business man; brown overalls &mdash; a thick head. 
 All right! 
 I'm joking. 
 And I'm off.&equo; 
 He stood up, shrugging his broad shoulders into a thick sheepskin jacket. 
 &bquo;So, good-night all. 
 See you at the party if not before. 
 Omi, you know how to cook venison. 
 He edged around the sofa and banged on Paul's door. 
 &bquo;Keep up the homework,&equo; he shouted. 
 &bquo;Get good marks and I'll give you a terrific record. 
 Erika &mdash;&equo; calling through the plastic ivy. 
 &bquo;Don't forget, I'm taking you to the Stadt Berlin. 
 See me out Hans.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern followed Bodo into the vestibule and on to the landing. 
 &bquo;Close the door,&equo; Bodo muttered. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;The door.&equo; 
 Bodo put out a large hand and pulled the door to. 
 &bquo;Come down to the bar with me,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The bar?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern could not believe his ears. 
 &bquo;At this time of night?&equo; 
 &bquo;There's one by the S-Bahn ,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;Come on. 
 I mean it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bodo!&equo; 
 Herr Nordern sighed hugely. 
 &bquo;I want to talk to you,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;What about?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was incredulous. 
 &bquo;I can't tell you here,&equo; Bodo muttered, with more than a touch of impatience. 
 &bquo;It's important. 
 But if you don't want to hear it&hellip;&equo; he made as if to go but Herr Nordern took him by the elbow. 
 &bquo;Is it really important?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's why I came round,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;But&hellip; 
 &equo; Herr Nordern stared for a moment into Bodo's steady brown eyes. 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Just a minute.&equo; 
 He went back into the flat, grabbed his coat, told an astonished Frau Nordern that he was going out for a moment and, without waiting for any protests, dashed out and joined Bodo at the foot of the stairs. 
 The bar was crowded with men coming off shift from the electronics factory all arguing heatedly about a disputed penalty in a soccer match being shown on a T.V. set above the counter, the fact that the match had taken place two months before in no way diminishing the fervour of the argument. 
 Bodo and Herr Nordern found a table in a back room. 
 Ignoring his brother's plea that he didn't want any, Bodo ordered beer. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern demanded. 
 Bodo held up a warning finger. 
 &bquo;Wait for the beer,&equo; he said, and while they waited exchanged jovial insults with the men at the counter. 
 &bquo;You know the men in here, too, do you?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern asked. 
 &bquo;Some of them.&equo; 
 Bodo pointed to a seedy-looking character. 
 &bquo;He got you those spark plugs.&equo; 
 He chortled as Herr Nordern shuddered, and laughed again as the waitress, a stout fifty year old, brought the beer and refused his offer to take her for a sensuous holiday in Siberia. 
 &bquo;I thought that you said this was an important matter,&equo; Herr Nordern snapped. 
 &bquo;I didn't come here for a boozy evening.&equo; 
 Bodo took a long mouthful of beer. 
 &bquo;It is,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It is important. 
 Believe me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; 
 Bodo lowered his glass. 
 &bquo;Have you heard any more from the cops, about that accident?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern felt a flicker of alarm. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Not at all. 
 Why, have you heard anything?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well&hellip;.&equo; 
 Bodo waved his hand and ordered more beer. 
 &bquo;Speak normally,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Don't shout, but don't whisper, either.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was aghast. 
 &bquo;You mean someone might be listening!&equo; 
 &bquo;You never know.&equo; 
 Bodo asked the waitress if she would take the romantic lead in a film he claimed to be making and when she had gone, said, &bquo;I don't think so, but you never know, do you? 
 It's one of the advantages of a bar, they can't bug them all. 
 Still&hellip;.&equo; he paused and lit a cigarette. 
 He waved out the match, gazed at it thoughtfully for a moment, dropped it into the ashtray and then looked at Herr Nordern. 
 It was a hard, uncompromising look, like a prize-fighter weighing up an opponent. 
 &bquo;Listen, Hans,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You've not done anything wrong, have you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wrong? 
 Me?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern's voice quivered with indignation. 
 &bquo;What wrong could I have done?&equo; 
 &bquo;Dunno,&equo; Bodo said. 
 He suddenly stood up. 
 &bquo;Back in a minute.&equo; 
 He strode to the counter and began talking earnestly with a burly man dressed in white house-painter's overalls. 
 Herr Nordern gulped his beer and drummed his fingers on the table. 
 He was sweating, and not just because of the stuffiness of the room. 
 He fished out a cigar and lighted it with fingers which were trembling. 
 Despite everything he had drunk already that night he badly wanted a brandy &mdash; and a large one at that. 
 And as Bodo made his way back to him he ordered two from the stout waitress who didn't stop and joke with him . 
 &bquo;Sorry,&equo; Bodo said, lowering his bulk next to his brother. 
 &bquo;I had to see that man. 
 What's this?&equo; he asked as the waitress brought the brandies. 
 &bquo;You don't want to hit that stuff too hard,&equo; knocking his back without a qualm. 
 &bquo;Never mind that,&equo; Herr Nordern gulped his brandy. 
 &bquo;What's this about something being wrong?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Bodo looked cheerful and unconcerned, but his voice was serious. 
 &bquo;I've been asking around, about Werner &mdash; &mdash; you know, the cop at Ostkreuz.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Get to the point can't you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm getting there,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;But listen, Hans, come on now, we are brothers.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course we're brothers.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern clenched his fist. 
 &bquo;For Christ's sake, I brought you up!&equo; 
 All right, all right, Bodo said. 
 I know that. 
 But Hans, tell me, have you been mixed up in any rackets?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern almost dropped his glass. 
 &bquo;Me! 
 In a racket?&equo; 
 &bquo;Keep your voice down ,&equo; Bodo said. 
 Herr Nordern made a huge effort and controlled himself. 
 &bquo;Of course I haven't been in any rackets. 
 You're the one for that,&equo; he added bitterly. 
 Bodo did not deny the charge. 
 &bquo;But I'm serious. 
 You've not got mixed up in any fiddles?&equo; 
 &bquo;What fiddles could I be in?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;I don't know.&equo; 
 Bodo shrugged. 
 &bquo;Some racket in your Department. 
 Currency, maybe. 
 Something to do with Karl.&equo; 
 &bquo;Karl!&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was astounded. 
 &bquo;You mean Uncle Karl?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 Why not? 
 He's a crook,&equo; Bodo said flatly. 
 Herr Nordern could not believe his ears. 
 &bquo;How can you say such a thing? 
 How can you? 
 You only met him tonight.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's a con man,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;I can spot them a mile off.&equo; 
 &bquo;I think that is a wicked thing to say,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Truly wicked.&equo; 
 Bodo was genuinely surprised. 
 &bquo;What's wicked about it? 
 I don't mind. 
 Good luck to him if he can get away with it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't mean that,&equo; Herr Nordern said, &bquo;and you know it. 
 I mean it's wicked even to say it. 
 Karl is a guest of the Government!&equo; 
 Serious or not, whatever the business Bodo had to talk about with his brother, to Herr Nordern's dismay he burst out laughing. 
 He patted Herr Nordern on the shoulder and shook his head. 
 &bquo;All right, Hans,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;All right.&equo; 
 He was still laughing as two policemen came into the bar, but, despite himself, and despite his certain knowledge of his complete innocence, Herr Nordern's heart sank as they made their way towards his table. 
 &bquo;Oh the devil,&equo; he whispered, but Bodo was quite unperturbed. 
 &bquo;Hello Heini, Joachim.&equo; 
 He jabbed a thumb at Hans. 
 &bquo;My brother.&equo; 
 Hands were shaken, drinks offered, regretfully refused by the policemen. 
 Heini leaned forward and murmured into Bodo's ear. 
 &bquo;No problem,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;A hen-house. 
 You've got the timber?&equo; 
 The policeman whispered something and Bodo grinned. 
 &bquo;Should be good stuff then. 
 O.K. Some time next week? 
 Fine.&equo; 
 Heini nodded thanks and left the room, followed by his colleague, both giving piercing, policemen's glances around the bar as they left. 
 &bquo;Sorry,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;Got to keep in with them, though.&equo; 
 He looked sideways at Herr Nordern. 
 &bquo;What was that you were saying about guests of the Government?&equo; he added dryly. 
 Herr Nordern shook his head. 
 &bquo;Do you know everyone in Berlin? 
 But I can't stay here much longer &mdash;&equo; he groaned as the waitress came with two beers and two gins. 
 &bquo;From the cops,&equo; the waitress said. 
 &bquo;Got to keep drinking,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;Look normal.&equo; 
 He filched one of Herr Nordern's cigars. 
 &bquo;But all right. 
 Business.&equo; 
 &bquo;At last.&equo; 
 &bquo;Right.&equo; 
 Bodo took a deep breath. 
 &bquo;I've been asking around about Werner, who interviewed you about the accident. 
 Well listen, Hans, there isn't a Werner at Ostkreuz cop-shop.&equo; 
 Against his better judgement Herr Nordern gulped some beer and then mopped his face with his handkerchief. 
 &bquo;What are you saying?&equo; 
 Bodo shrugged. 
 &bquo;I don't know, but there was a Werner at Schwerin in '81.&equo; 
 &bquo;So?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern's voice rose. 
 &bquo;He was in the Border Police then,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;The Border Police? 
 But what's he doing dealing with a traffic accident?&equo; 
 The room seemed to spin a little and Herr Nordern grabbed the table. 
 &bquo;It doesn't mean a thing,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Werner &mdash; it's not an uncommon name &mdash; no?&equo; he asked, as Bodo shook his head. 
 &bquo;I think it's the same man,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;I don't understand.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't either,&equo; Bodo said. 
 Both men were silent for a moment then, clutching at a straw, Herr Nordern said, &bquo;It must be something to do with you. 
 You're the one up to your neck in rackets. 
 My God, do you realise what could happen if there was any scandal? 
 I'm up for promotion, and there's Erika&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've thought about that,&equo; Bodo was serious. 
 &bquo;But I don't think so. 
 In fact I'm sure of it. 
 They wouldn't bring in the heavy mob for me, I'm not important enough. 
 Besides, I've done too much for the big pots. 
 They wouldn't want any scandal, either. 
 But this business of the car crash, it sounds phony to me.&equo; 
 &bquo;But why in hell should the police make up a story about an accident?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern demanded. 
 &bquo;Why? 
 Where's the sense in it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Search me. 
 But if you've done nothing wrong then you've got nothing to worry about &mdash;&equo; although Bodo rather spoiled this optimistic remark by adding, &bquo;I hope.&equo; 
 &bquo;So what should I do?&equo; 
 Bodo shook his head. 
 &bquo;I still wouldn't do anything.&equo; 
 &bquo;But &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;No buts,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;If you don't do anything then you've got no worries, see? 
 Start doing something and it looks as if you have  got worries.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I am worried,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 I know, I know. 
 But appear not to be. 
 Just carry on as normal, right? 
 I'll do the poking around. 
 So. 
 Let's go.&equo; 
 They left the bar, Bodo exchanging farewells as if he had not a care in the world. 
 Herr Nordern staggered as the night air hit him and Bodo held his elbow as they lurched back to the flats. 
 &bquo;O.K.,&equo; Bodo climbed into his pick-up. 
 &bquo;I'll be in touch. 
 Just &mdash;&equo; he hesitated for a moment and Herr Nordern leaned forward eagerly. 
 &bquo;Just what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just keep a low profile,&equo; Bodo said, as he started the engine and roared away. 
 Herr Nordern went up the stairs, into a dark flat and a discontented bedroom. 
 &bquo;Where have you been?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern hissed. 
 &bquo;Only with Bodo,&equo; Herr Nordern swore as he pulled his shirt off and it became entangled with his vest. 
 &bquo;Only with Bodo!&equo; 
 Disapproval seeped from Frau Nordern. 
 &bquo;What were the two of you up to?&equo; 
 &bquo;Having a drink.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern sat down heavily, making the bed lurch. 
 &bquo;Go to sleep.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was asleep,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Where are you going now?&equo; 
 &bquo;Bathroom.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern wove unsteadily across the living-room into the bathroom and plunged his face into cold water. 
 &bquo;Stupid,&equo; he thought, looking at his flushed, dripping face in the mirror. 
 &bquo;Utterly stupid. 
 Drunk and stupid.&equo; 
 He began to clean his teeth, jabbing at his mouth, then dropped the toothbrush on to the floor. 
 He picked it up, banging his head on the bowl. 
 He drank some water and felt worse, then groped his way back to the bedroom. 
 He climbed into bed and lay on his side, not moving and scarcely breathing. 
 There was silence for a moment or two and then, like the voice of doom, Frau Nordern spoke again. 
 What did Bodo want? 
 Nordern groaned. 
 &bquo;I'll tell you tomorrow,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Tomorrow.&equo; 
 Another silence. 
 Herr Nordern breathed a little easier, then: &bquo;Now.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern pressed his hot face against his pillow. 
 &bquo;You know Bodo.&equo; 
 He had a flash of inspiration. 
 &bquo;He wanted to borrow some money. 
 To build a hen-house. 
 It sounded utterly preposterous but it led to a longer silence. 
 Frau Nordern's breathing became deeper and more regular. 
 Herr Nordern relaxed a trifle. 
 &bquo;Did you? 
 Lend him the money?&equo; 
 &bquo;No! 
 No. 
 No. 
 Now go to sleep. 
 I've got work to do tomorrow.&equo; 
 &bquo;You won't do it drinking with Bodo till all hours,&equo; Frau Nordern said, but it was a Parthian shot as she did, then, go to sleep. 
 Herr Nordern lay awake, listening to his wife blowing little bubbling breaths. 
 He did not feel well. 
 In fact he was not far from being sick. 
 What was the matter with him? he thought. 
 He was drinking like a fish, and had been for weeks. 
 And now he was lurching about his flat with innocent children asleep in their beds, and he had lied to Helga. 
 He had never done that before in all their life together. 
 Just the thought of it made him feel unclean. 
 For a moment he was tempted to wake her up and confess but thought better of it. 
 &bquo;But I will tell her tomorrow,&equo; he promised. 
 &bquo;Some of it, anyway.&equo; 
 Then he, too, slipped off into an uneasy sleep, and strange, vivid dreams, in which Lieutenant Werner chased him down endless, war-torn and shattered streets, for ever. 
 HERR NORDERN did not feel better the next morning, in fact he felt considerably worse. 
 As he shaved his reflection seemed to be the face of a low criminal &mdash; or like one of Bodo's associates &mdash; and when he went into the sitting-room his wife bore more than a passing resemblance to an exceptionally severe judge about to condemn that criminal to hard labour for life. 
 Herr Nordern gave her a ghastly, feeble grin, as if asking for remission, but Frau Nordern turned a cold face away, showing only an upright back and stiff neck which in their rigidity seemed to symbolise the rectitude of all the generations of the Houses of von Bromberg and von Ritter. 
 Gulping coffee, Herr Nordern stared at that unyielding back and felt his heart sink. 
 As he went into the bedroom for his brief-case he shook his head. 
 &bquo;I can't do it,&equo; he thought. 
 &bquo;I really can't go through the day feeling like this.&equo; 
 He looked through the window. 
 It had snowed during the night but not heavily. 
 He took a deep breath and opened the door. 
 &bquo;Er&hellip; 
 Helga&hellip;.&equo; he said. 
 Frau Nordern did not hear him or at least seemed not to. 
 Herr Nordern cleared his throat. 
 &bquo;Helga?&equo; 
 This time Frau Nordern deigned him a glance, but only that. 
 &bquo;Your brief-case is on the dressing-table,&equo; she said before turning back to her coffee. 
 &bquo;Ahem, ahem.&equo; 
 Needlessly Herr Nordern cleared his throat again, frowning at Paul who was goggling at him while stuffing himself with cheese and cold ham. 
 &bquo;It's not that. 
 Could you spare me a moment?&equo; 
 He shook his head and beckoned at the same time, feeling an unutterable fool for doing so. 
 Frau Nordern gazed at him for an icy moment then stalked into the bedroom. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; she demanded. 
 Herr Nordern closed the door. 
 As he did so his wife raised her eyebrows as if at some freakish aberration. 
 &bquo;What on earth are you doing that for?&equo; she asked. 
 Herr Nordern held out his hand. 
 &bquo;Helga,&equo; he said, &bquo;listen, I want to talk to you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Talk to me?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern was, or sounded as if she was, utterly amazed. 
 &bquo;Now?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, not now. 
 Not just this minute.&equo; 
 Despite himself Herr Nordern was irascible. 
 &bquo;Look, I'll get the car out and drive you to work and tell you as we go.&equo; 
 &bquo;Get the car out? 
 Tell me as we go? 
 Tell me what?&equo; 
 Beneath his new submissiveness Herr Nordern felt another flicker of exasperation, the more so because he was  being submissive. 
 &bquo;I'll tell you in the car,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If you want to come.&equo; 
 He looked at his watch. 
 &bquo;But we'll have to go now.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern gave him a calculating look then nodded. 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo; If  the car works.&equo; 
 For an anguished three minutes Herr Nordern thought that the Lada would not work but, in company with a neighbour s antiquated Volkswagen, after a bout of racking, early morning, heavy smoker's coughing, it came to a sort of half-life as, quite unnecessarily, because the Lada's engine could be heard half-way across Berlin, Herr Nordern tooted its feeble horn. 
 In the flat Frau Nordern drained the last of her coffee, snatched her brief-case, kissed Omi, and swept to the door. 
 Still munching cheese, Paul made a dive for his coat only to be halted by his mother's withering glare. 
 &bquo;Aren't we coming?&equo; 
 Paul demanded indignantly. 
 &bquo;Coming where?&equo; 
 &bquo;In the car.&equo; 
 &bquo;The car?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern gave Paul a cold, blue stare. 
 &bquo;Just you make sure that you don't miss your bus &mdash; and bring your homework back.&equo; 
 The door slammed behind her as Paul looked dolefully at Erika. 
 &bquo;What's the matter with them?&equo; he demanded. 
 &bquo;Nothing.&equo; 
 Erika was firm. 
 &bquo;And &mdash;&equo; to an approving nod from Omi she added, &bquo;don't say them  about Mother and Father. 
 It isn't polite.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's them who aren't being polite,&equo; Paul muttered, sotto voce . 
 And in fact Frau Nordern was not being polite as Herr Nordern drove the Lada in a wobbly course down Klara-Lettkin-Strasse. 
 &bquo;I hope that you have something worth saying,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Herr Nordern struggled with the gears as a gigantic lorry with a huge sign saying &bquo;Workers of All Countries Unite&equo; painted on it cut across him, its horn blaring. 
 &bquo;Helga &mdash;&equo; he cursed as another lorry swung across his bonnet. 
 Clutching her brief-case, Frau Nordern jerked her chin. 
 &bquo;If all you can do is swear &mdash;, &bquo;For Christ's sake!&equo; 
 A motor-cyclist slithered towards the car. 
 &bquo;Just a minute.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern heaved on the steering-wheel and swung the Lada into the relative safety of a narrow street shadowed by the bulk of a church where he pulled up, although wisely keeping the engine running. 
 Frau Nordern raised her head as if appealing to the Deity presiding over the church. 
 &bquo;What are we doing here ?&equo; she asked, as if, by some miracle, they had arrived in Lapland. 
 &bquo;Just a moment. 
 One moment.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern pulled out a cigar. 
 &bquo;Can't talk in that traffic. 
 I'm sorry.&equo; 
 He lighted his cigar, puffed furiously, sank back in his seat, as far as it would allow him to, and stared fixedly through the windscreen, already lightly furred with snow. 
 &bquo;Look, Helga, it's about last night. 
 When I got back.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern turned a marmoreal face, and when she spoke her voice was as cold as her face. 
 &bquo;You were drunk.&equo; 
 &bquo;Er&hellip;.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern fidgeted with his cigar. 
 &bquo;Not actually drunk, Helga.&equo; 
 &bquo;You were!&equo; 
 Frau Nordern was contemptuous. 
 &bquo;Lurching about the flat. 
 I heard you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, all right. 
 I was &mdash; a bit. 
 But that's not it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not what?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern turned her face away. 
 &bquo;Don't do that, Helga,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Look at me, please. 
 Thank you. 
 I was worried &mdash; let me finish &mdash; &mdash; Bodo &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Bodo!&equo; 
 Frau Nordern was withering. 
 &bquo;I thought that he'd have something to do with it.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, it's not what you think &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't know what I think.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern struggled with her window. 
 Smoke billowed out and a few snowflakes fluttered into the car. 
 &bquo;You did lend him the money, didn't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Lend him money?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern said blankly. 
 &bquo;Forgotten already.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern jerked her chin. 
 &bquo;I said that you were drunk.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right!&equo; 
 Herr Nordern threw his cigar out of the window. 
 &bquo;I was. 
 I was drunk. 
 Drunk! 
 Don't keep going on about it. 
 I'm trying to talk to you.&equo; 
 There was an ominous minute's silence and then, even more ominously, Frau Nordern spoke. 
 &bquo;He's in trouble, isn't he? 
 Serious trouble.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern tapped the steering-wheel. 
 &bquo;No. 
 No, he isn't in trouble. 
 But he told me something. 
 It&hellip; it was about Werner.&equo; 
 &bquo;Werner?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 The policeman. 
 The one who interviewed me about the accident.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about him?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern tugged at his collar. 
 &bquo;Bodo said &mdash;&equo; he repeated what Bodo had told him. 
 Frau Nordern listened intently. 
 When Herr Nordern had finished some of her iciness had melted. 
 &bquo;What does it mean?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;I don't know.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern shook his head. 
 &bquo;But that's why I was worried and drank too much.&equo; 
 &bquo;So it wasn't about lending money to Bodo at all?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern stared at his hands. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Helga, lying to you.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's all right.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern forced her window up. 
 &bquo;I didn't believe you anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;You didn't?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was rather offended. 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern half-smiled. 
 &bquo;You're not a good liar, Hans. 
 Not enough practice.&equo; 
 She paused. 
 &bquo;And Bodo said don't do anything?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;I see.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern looked at her watch. 
 &bquo;We'd better get going, I'm late already.&equo; 
 Twenty minutes later, after a silent, worried drive, Herr Nordern dropped off his wife at the Welfare Centre. 
 &bquo;I'll pick you up tonight if you like,&equo; he said. 
 Frau Nordern hesitated then shook her head. 
 &bquo;I may have to go to a meeting. 
 I'll see you back home.&equo; 
 She nodded curtly at a respectful errant mother then stooped to the car window. 
 &bquo;Don't worry your head about Werner. 
 It can't be anything.&equo; 
 She raised her hand as a dubious Herr Nordern forced the car into almost the right gear and drove off with a curious jerking motion, then turned and went into the Centre with a look on her face which boded ill for anyone who crossed her path that day. 
 The brief Berlin day faded away. 
 Errant mothers wished that they weren't or, given that they were, had a different case officer from Frau Nordern. 
 In his office an anxious Herr Nordern gouged out a few marks from unenthusiastic colleagues for a wreath for Steinmark's funeral. 
 It stopped snowing but grew colder as the East breathed an icy wind across the city, and in the Egon Schultz school the music of Johann Sebastian Bach echoed through the corridors. 
 The music came from members of the school orchestra who, with Erika on the flute, were rehearsing the &bquo;Musical Offering&equo; by Bach, an unusual piece as it was Bach's only work written for five instruments. 
 Erika was surprised to find that she was beginning to like Bach. 
 As short a time as a few weeks previously she had been, when not bored, repelled by his music. 
 It had seemed, the great choral works excepted, mere mathematics, endless, tedious variations on simple themes, clever, of course, but no more than that. 
 But now she was being drawn, as it were unwillingly, into his world which although intellectual &mdash; abstract, even &mdash; was, she was discovering, informed by deep, profound passion. 
 It was an excellent rehearsal and the music teacher, Frau Fegel, was delighted. 
 &bquo;Very good,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Really good. 
 The balance was correct, and the technical quality. 
 But we must concentrate on drawing out the feeling .&equo; 
 She looked at the clock. 
 &bquo;We could run through it once more.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Frau Fegel,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;I have to go to the gym. 
 &bquo;Ah, athletics.&equo; 
 Frau Fegel was less than enthusiastic. 
 &bquo;If you must.&equo; 
 Must was the word and Erika left the music room, Frau Fegel taking her place; the sound of the music followed Erika as she went down the corridor to the gym. 
 And there, after her warming-up exercises, she leaped like a gazelle, undisturbed by the fact that she was being filmed on video by two pupils and barely noticing that during the session a small group of people tiptoed on to the gallery, and she did her last jump to applause. 
 Showered and changed, she went back into the gym and found Fr&auml;ulein Silber standing modestly in the background while, very much in the foreground were Herr Wolf, from the National Stadium, and Fr&auml;ulein Carow. 
 Herr Wolf shook Erika's hand. 
 &bquo;Excellent jumping,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You remember Fr&auml;ulein Carow, of course. 
 You see we haven't forgotten you, Erika. 
 Not that we came just to see you. 
 Even promising young athletes don't bring us out on a winter's day; we do have little tours of inspection, occasionally.&equo; 
 He smiled his pleasant, open smile. 
 &bquo;We have been to other schools. 
 I must say that the standard of high jumping is very good this year. 
 So, congratulations, Erika. 
 I notice that you have got your left leg sorted out. 
 Well done Fr&auml;ulein Silber. 
 We'll see you at the next coaches' meeting.&equo; 
 To cordial goodbyes they left, leaving Erika and Fr&auml;ulein Silber alone in the huge gym. 
 &bquo;Good,&equo; Fr&auml;ulein Silber said. 
 &bquo;Really good, Erika.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's thanks to you, Fr&auml;ulein,&equo; Erika said. 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber waved the thanks aside but Erika persisted. 
 &bquo;I mean it. 
 If it hadn't been for you, after my fall&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;You did that yourself, recovering,&equo; Fr&auml;ulein Silber said. 
 &bquo;All the coaches in the world wouldn't have been of any use if you hadn't had courage. 
 And now &mdash;&equo; she made a typical high-jumpers' gesture, that which marks them out from all other athletes, raising her arms and stretching her torso, as if taking off to challenge that dappled crossbar. 
 &bquo;You noticed what Herr Wolf said?&equo; she continued. 
 &bquo;They'd been to other schools and the standard is high? 
 Yes, and there is one girl in particular, in Pankow, Karen Bloxen. 
 She's only just moved to Berlin so I don't know much about her &mdash; these provincials&hellip; 
 &equo; Fr&auml;ulein Silber gave a wintry smile, &bquo;and her coach is keeping her heights dark, but I know that she is keeping the bar up. 
 However, we'll see about that &mdash; it's one thing jumping well in your own gym, but it's another one altogether doing it in a stadium &mdash; in a championship &mdash; with thousands of people looking at you. 
 That's when people crack. 
 That's when courage counts &mdash; and nerve.&equo; 
 &bquo;You won a championship,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber smiled a little crookedly. 
 &bquo;The Pomeranian Zonal Championship.&equo; 
 She subsided gracefully on to a mat and motioned Erika to join her. 
 &bquo;Area Junior Champion, but that was my limit. 
 I went to a special sports school &mdash; not Leipzig,&equo; she added hastily, to a nod from Erika who knew very well what Leipzig meant in the athletic world of the G.D.R., the absolute, superlative top &mdash; &bquo;but I was a second rater there. 
 Oh yes,&equo; she raised a finger as Erika tried to protest. 
 &bquo;I was. 
 But I had a fine training, the best in the world. 
 Better even than the Americans. 
 And now I have a good job, one I like. 
 And I was with them, with the Greats. 
 Do you know that I once beat Ulrike Meyfarth!&equo; 
 She laughed. 
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; two years later she won the Gold Medal in the Olympics. 
 But I saw them, I saw them face to face. 
 And one day I will say that I saw Erika Nordern, say that I coached her. 
 That will be something.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fr&auml;ulein!&equo; 
 Her face crimson, Erika protested. 
 &bquo;It's true.&equo; 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber turned her green eyes on Erika. 
 &bquo;I mean it, you have the real stuff. 
 So.&equo; 
 She stood up. 
 &bquo;One week to go. 
 A week of real  concentration, and then&hellip;.&equo; 
 Erika stood up, too, and gave a rueful shrug. 
 &bquo;Concentration.&equo; 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber was suddenly sharp. 
 &bquo;What about it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; Erika sighed. 
 &bquo;It's just that we are having a party &mdash; after the competition,&equo; she added hastily. 
 &bquo;It's for my great-uncle. 
 People are coming from all over the place, and the flat&hellip;.&equo; she held out her arms. 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber clicked her teeth in exasperation. 
 &bquo;That won't do. 
 It won't do at all.&equo; 
 &bquo;But &mdash;&equo; Erika began, only to be cut off. 
 &bquo;No buts about it.&equo; 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber's voice had the snap of authority. 
 Erika shook her head, for once letting authority go unheeded. 
 &bquo;We can't put the party off, Fr&auml;ulein. 
 All the arrangements have been made.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; Fr&auml;ulein Silber said. 
 &bquo;I'm not suggesting that. 
 But I've been thinking about next week. 
 You are crowded at home?&equo; 
 Erika hardly bothered to say &bquo;yes&equo;. 
 For a family in the position of hers it would have been like saying one needed air to breathe. 
 But Fr&auml;ulein Silber was in a different position. 
 &bquo;My flat is small,&equo; she said, &bquo;but there's room for two, and it's quiet. 
 It would be a good idea if you came and stayed with me. 
 Not if you don't want to, of course. 
 Would you mind?&equo; 
 Erika blinked. 
 &bquo;No, I don't think so.&equo; 
 &bquo;And your parents?&equo; 
 Erika thought for a moment &mdash; a brief moment. 
 &bquo;I'm sure that they wouldn't,&equo; she said, although wondering what her mother would say. 
 &bquo;Ask them anyway. 
 But the main thing is yourself.&equo; 
 The green eyes peered at Erika. 
 &bquo;It's an important week and if you would be happier at home&hellip;.&equo; 
 Erika did not need that last qualification. 
 To have a week away, and with Fr&auml;ulein Silber&hellip; even the thought of Omi faded as she thought of it; after all, it would only be for one  week, pushing away the traitorous thought that one week for herself was quite different from a week in Omi's life, and, treachery giving way to treason, she did have her own life to lead; and so she said, firmly, &bquo;It will be all right, Fr&auml;ulein. 
 And thank you. 
 Good-night.&equo; 
 She walked away across the polished floor, then halted and turned. 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber was standing by the high jump, one hand resting on the bar. 
 &bquo;Thank you so much, Fr&auml;ulein,&equo; Erika called. 
 &bquo;For everything.&equo; 
 And then, overcome by her own emotion, she ran from the gym, and the school. 
 Outside the door she paused, breathing the chill and chilling air. 
 From the school came more music, the school choir rehearsing for Christmas. 
 She could see the choir through the windows of the Hall: a hundred pupils, rapt, or, at any rate looking  rapt, under the vast banner of the G.D.R. 
 They were singing a folk-song, simple but moving, and Erika came close to tears. 
 Perhaps she was  destined for glory. 
 Perhaps, one day, the pupils singing would say &mdash; boast! &mdash; &mdash; that they had known Erika Nordern. 
 She remembered what her father had said that day in the Stadium; the German Democratic Republic was a good country, a great country, a miracle. 
 The choir sang: 
 &bquo;Ah! 
 Wald und Berg&hellip;. 
 Ah, forest and mountain, 
 River and lake 
 My love for you will never fade&hellip;.&equo; 
 And then a tentative voice called from the darkness. 
 &bquo;Erika?&equo; 
 Erika broke away from her reverie and peered into the gloom. 
 &bquo;Who's there?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Who's that?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's me.&equo; 
 Preceded by a cloud of vaporised breath, a figure shuffled into the light spilling from the Hall. 
 &bquo;Fritz!&equo; 
 Erika raised her hand. 
 &bquo;What are you doing here?&equo; 
 Fritz Kott gave a hangdog grin. 
 &bquo;I was just passing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just passing?&equo; 
 Erika was amazed. 
 &bquo;You live miles away.&equo; 
 She had a sudden insight, at once alarming and ludicrous. 
 &bquo;You haven't been waiting here since school ended, have you? 
 I mean waiting for me?&equo; 
 Fritz gave an even more ghastly grin. 
 &bquo;Er&hellip; no. 
 No. 
 I was just passing.&equo; 
 &bquo;You have been waiting!&equo; 
 Erika stamped her foot in vexation. 
 &bquo;Tell the truth. 
 Are you crazy? 
 Standing around in this weather for ages.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's not cold.&equo; 
 Fritz shuddered as he spoke. 
 &bquo;Of course it's cold. 
 It's freezing!&equo; 
 A devastating thought struck Erika. 
 &bquo;I hope that no one has seen you hanging about round here.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no one. 
 Honest.&equo; 
 Fritz spoke with fawning eagerness. 
 Erika flushed. 
 &bquo;So you have  been waiting. 
 What are you thinking of? 
 You'll have the whole school talking.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, really.&equo; 
 Fritz took a step nearer. 
 &bquo;Honestly, Erika, no one has seen me. 
 I just wanted to see you, that's all.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you see me every day,&equo; Erika snapped. 
 &bquo;You saw me today.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Fritz stared at his shoes. 
 &bquo;But it's&hellip; you know&hellip; it's not the same.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not the same as what?&equo; 
 Erika demanded. 
 &bquo;Not the same as&hellip; as&hellip; you know&hellip;.&equo; 
 Fritz's voice tailed dismally away. 
 He rolled his eyes and tugged at his collar and blew on his finger-nails; and then Erika felt a sensation she had never known before; one that in all her life of order, regimentation, structures, and of love and caring, too, it had never occurred to her that she might have. 
 She felt a sense of power: power utter and complete over another human being, and in the black and bitter night, she used it. 
 &bquo;Know what?&equo; she asked, knowing that Fritz was there to be toyed with. 
 Fritz gave her an earnest look which was, if anything, even more ghastly and idiotic than his grin. 
 &bquo;The&hellip; the disco,&equo; he said, huskily, as if lowering his voice would give that humble word a significance beyond all words. 
 &bquo;The disco?&equo; 
 Erika frowned and tilted her head as if trying to remember and then, cruelly, said, &bquo;Oh yes, where I danced with that interesting lad, and with Herman Guttenbruk.&equo; 
 &bquo;Erika!&equo; 
 Fritz was outraged. 
 &bquo;You know what I mean.&equo; 
 &bquo;I haven't the faintest idea what you mean.&equo; 
 Erika had her mother's iciness. 
 &bquo;And please don't tell me what I know or don't know.&equo; 
 &bquo;No! 
 No, of course not. 
 Sorry.&equo; 
 Fritz made a strange gargling noise. 
 &bquo;I just meant, I mean, er&hellip; would you like to come for a coffee. 
 The Kiev isn't far.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Kiev!&equo; 
 Erika, who rather liked the Kiev, was disdainful. 
 &bquo;I certainly wouldn't go there.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right.&equo; 
 Fritz took another step forward and almost fell over his feet. 
 &bquo;Listen, we could go to the Baltic &mdash;&equo; naming a horribly expensive caf&eacute; and one far beyond his means &mdash; &bquo;it's only a few stops on the bus &mdash;&equo; 
 But the little game was over for Erika. 
 Her fingers and toes were chilling and slowly and almost imperceptibly the mist settling on her fur collar was turning a frosty white. 
 &bquo;I think that you're crazy,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You really are. 
 Anyway, I should be home by now. 
 Don't hang around school waiting for me ever again. 
 Good-night.&equo; 
 But the good-night was not as definite as it sounded and Fritz, cowed though he was, knew it and walked with Erika to her bus-stop and waited with her in the cold until the bus did trundle along, and even then he made an attempt to get on it with her, a ploy which, with a deft use of her elbow, Erika foiled, leaving him standing at the bus-stop; a lonely rejected youth, bowed as with the sorrows of all the world &mdash; and yet irresistibly comic. 
 &bquo;He's in love with me!&equo; 
 Erika thought, and burst out laughing. 
 But comical though he was, and although Erika laughed, yet her heart was touched, and as the bus juddered through the deserted streets, all the way home she looked into the window, seeing not the flats, factories, and dark parks, but, wonderingly, her own reflection. 
 As ever, Omi was in, sitting patiently at the table, writing one of the many letters with which she kept the tattered network of Brombergs and Ritters precariously bound together. 
 She smiled as Erika entered the room although her smile had that new wistfulness about it. 
 Erika kissed Omi's old cheek, and then made hot chocolate. 
 &bquo;Have you had a good day, Omi?&equo; she asked, sitting with her grandmother. 
 &bquo;Ach! 
 Such a day.&equo; 
 Omi shook her head. 
 &bquo;The telephone. 
 On, on, on! 
 I've written down the messages.&equo; 
 She made to rise but Erika forestalled her and got the telephone pad. 
 &bquo;I couldn't hear what they were saying most of the time,&equo; Omi said, as Erika ran her eye down the list of calls written in Omi's shaky, old-fashioned script. 
 &bquo;The line was so bad, clickings and buzzings, and I'm not quick&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right.&equo; 
 Erika was cheerful. 
 &bquo;They'll call again, anyway. 
 Bet your boots on it. 
 Omi chuckled. 
 &bquo;Ah, Liebchen , you do my heart good. 
 She peered over her spectacles. 
 &bquo;And how pretty you look. 
 Such a complexion. 
 Like the English girls. 
 I had a cousin, Heinrich von Str&ouml;bel. 
 He fell in love with an English girl just because of her cheeks&hellip;.&equo; 
 Erika felt the blood flow into her  cheeks. 
 She lowered her cup. 
 &bquo;Omi,&equo; she was about to tiptoe into that mysterious realm summed up by the word love when, maddeningly, the phone rang. 
 &bquo;Another!&equo; 
 Omi said as Erika, mildly &mdash; internally &mdash; cursing, reached and took the receiver. 
 &bquo;Erika?&equo; 
 Through a barrage of clicks and crackles, Frau Nordern's voice reached Klara-Lettkin-Strasse sounding oddly ghostly. 
 Erika? 
 It s your mother. 
 Your mother ! 
 &bquo;Yes, I can hear you,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; Erika shouted across the bedlam on the line. 
 &bquo;Know what? 
 Is that you Erika?&equo; 
 The interference mysteriously stopped and through a clear line Frau Nordern's voice boomed with all its usual authority, as if the ghost had miraculously become embodied with all the solidity of human flesh. 
 Erika held the phone away from her ear for a moment then spoke into it quietly. 
 &bquo;Yes, it's me, and I can hear you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good. 
 Who is there?&equo; 
 &bquo;Omi and I.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where's Paul?&equo; 
 &bquo;At the F.G.Y.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hm.&equo; 
 There was a brief pause, then, &bquo;Are you sure?&equo; 
 Erika sighed. 
 &bquo;Yes, it's Friday right.&equo; 
 There was a suspicious assent. 
 &bquo;And Father isn't there?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well listen, Erika &mdash; are you listening?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course I am.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good. 
 I may be a little late so don't wait supper for me. 
 Do you understand that?&equo; 
 For a moment Erika was strongly tempted to say that she didn't but instead she meekly said, &bquo;Yes, Mother.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right.&equo; 
 Suddenly the cacophony broke out again on the line. 
 Erika heard something vague and peremptory from her mother and then, as the line went dead, the front door rattled, Herr Nordern came in, and Erika shrugged and dropped the phone back on to its holder. 
 At the other end of the line Frau Nordern did much the same, then stood up and stuffed her brief-case with various documents. 
 She locked her desk and her office, and moved majestically out of the Centre. 
 She caught her usual bus, but instead of getting off at Frankfurter Allee and catching the S-Bahn  to Biesdorf, she stayed on it, all the way to Ostkreuz where, like Herr Nordern once before her, she made her way to Ostkreuz Police Station. 
 HERR NORDERN would have recognised the scene inside the Station as if it were a replay of a film, or a remake, rather: the shady characters and the drunks, and the badinage  reflecting a curious bonhomie  between the Duty Officer and the offenders, although the cast was different and, it being later, the Station was busier; the offenders looking more offensive and the policemen more policeman-like, bigger, harder, and, in all senses of the word, more arresting &mdash; although, big and hard though they were, two of them, bundling out an unfortunate to a police van, gave way respectfully to Frau Nordern as she stalked towards the desk. 
 The Duty Officer, elderly and paunchy, raised a lumpy face from a crime sheet, or a sports paper, both of which were on his desk, looked again, and stood up. 
 &bquo;Frau?&equo; 
 &bquo;Lieutenant Werner,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 The Duty Officer leaned forward. 
 &bquo;Who?&equo; 
 &bquo;Werner,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Lieutenant Werner. 
 And I haven't got all night.&equo; 
 The lumpy face creased into a puzzled frown. 
 &bquo;Werner?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern heaved up her brief-case and let it fall on to the desk with a satisfying, rather official thud. 
 &bquo;That's four times we've said the name.&equo; 
 &bquo;Werner.&equo; 
 The Duty Officer made it a fifth time, glanced, not without anxiety at the brief-case, momentarily at Frau Nordern, then with relief, over her shoulder, and jerked his lumps and bumps. 
 &bquo;Frau.&equo; 
 A striped sleeve rested on the desk. 
 &bquo;Can I help you?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern turned. 
 A sergeant with a face which looked as if its owner was more used to giving lumps than receiving them was standing next to her. 
 With an air of hugely controlled patience she said, &bquo;I want to see Lieutenant Werner.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why is that, Frau?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern gave an ominous drum-roll on the desk with her fingers. 
 &bquo;That is for me to tell the Lieutenant.&equo; 
 The Sergeant waited for the drum-roll to die away, and for a drunk, shouting incoherently, to be dragged through a grim looking door. 
 &bquo;We're busy tonight,&equo; he said reasonably, &bquo;Frau&hellip;?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nordern!&equo; 
 Frau Nordern snapped. 
 &bquo;And I'm busy all the time. 
 Now get me the Lieutenant.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm afraid that he's not here, Frau,&equo; the Sergeant said in a blank, bureaucratic voice. 
 &bquo;Then get me whoever is  in charge,&equo; Frau Nordern said, in an equally bureaucratic voice. 
 The Sergeant hesitated for a moment. 
 &bquo;And I'm to say?&equo; 
 &bquo;Say I'm from the Ministry of Justice.&equo; 
 The boozy gabble of the offenders was suddenly silenced, although whether it was the tone of Frau Nordern's voice or the word &bquo;ministry&equo; which stilled it, it would be hard to say. 
 In the uncanny silence the Sergeant looked again at Frau Nordern, and at the brief-case. 
 &bquo;Very well,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Er, would the Frau like a seat?&equo; 
 He gestured at the row of chairs where the offenders lolled. 
 Frau Nordern gave them a contemptuous glance and the Sergeant coughed. 
 &bquo;No, perhaps not. 
 If the Frau would wait just one moment then.&equo; 
 &bquo;One moment,&equo; Frau Nordern said, placing a well aimed dart between the Sergeant's broad, grey-clad shoulders as he went into an inner office. 
 The moment stretched into one, two, three, a minute, another. 
 The hands on the big wall clock jerked around with the enthusiasm of a convict doing forced labour, the offenders stared at their battered and scuffed shoes in awed silence with the exception of a drunk who had missed the dreaded word MINISTRY and who openly admired Frau Nordern's figure but who, with the solidarity of the criminal underworld, was instantly hushed into silence by the other offenders. 
 His sports paper having mysteriously disappeared, the Duty Officer scratched furiously at a vast form, a flush, as ominous as a gathering storm began to show on Frau Nordern's neck, and then the door of the office opened, the Sergeant came out, and behind him a stocky man in plain clothes, smoking a cigar, and blinking through bloodshot eyes, waved Frau Nordern forward. 
 As Frau Nordern went into the office a babble of voices rose behind her, still audible, although muted, as the door was closed by the man with the cigar. 
 He waved Frau Nordern to a seat and took one himself. 
 &bquo;Marx,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Otto Marx. 
 No relation. 
 And you are Frau Nordern?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Frau Nordern sat bolt upright and gave Marx her commanding glare which, however, did not have quite the same effect on him as it had done on the Duty Officer. 
 &bquo;So you want to see Lieutenant Werner?&equo; 
 Marx said. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern waved at the cigar smoke but, unperturbed, Marx puffed vigorously away. 
 &bquo;He's not here,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Well, when will he be here?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern demanded. 
 Marx blinked his bloodshot eyes. 
 &bquo;Couldn't say.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern frowned as Marx stubbed out his cigar and promptly took out another one. 
 &bquo;What rank are you?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Sergeant.&equo; 
 Marx struck a match. 
 &bquo;Detective Sergeant.&equo; 
 &bquo;And are you in charge of this station?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Marx lighted his cigar. 
 &bquo;Then who is in charge?&equo; 
 &bquo;Inspector Gr&uuml;n, but he's not here either, so in a manner of speaking I suppose I am  in charge just now.&equo; 
 From behind the frosted-glass door there were bangs and scuffles and a wild drunken bellow. 
 Marx blinked at what could be seen of the office ceiling through the hanging cloud of his cigar smoke. 
 &bquo;Business improving,&equo; he observed. 
 &bquo;Friday night. 
 Is this a Ministry affair, Frau?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern hesitated. 
 &bquo;No, not exactly.&equo; 
 Marx peered at Frau Nordern. 
 &bquo;You said you were from the Ministry.&equo; 
 &bquo;I work there,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Not quite the same thing,&equo; Marx said, mildly and without rancour, as if half-truths and no-truths were part of his life, which they were. 
 &bquo;Still, if there's anything you want to talk about you'll have to talk to me or no one.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern bit her lip in vexation. 
 &bquo;When can I see Lieutenant Werner?&equo; 
 &bquo;Couldn't say.&equo; 
 Marx shrugged. 
 &bquo;Inspector Gr&uuml;n then?&equo; 
 Marx shook his head. 
 &bquo;Difficult. 
 Very difficult.&equo; 
 He picked a shred of tobacco off his lip. 
 &bquo;Especially if you won't say what you want to see him about.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern gave an exasperated &bquo;tut&equo;. 
 &bquo;Does Lieutenant Werner work here?&equo; she demanded. 
 Marx's manner altered abruptly. 
 He gave Frau Nordern a hard stare. 
 &bquo;You ought to know better than to ask that. 
 Who works here is a State Secret.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; of course. 
 Sorry.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern, uncharacteristically meek, was forced on to the defensive. 
 Even asking about State Secrets was a serious crime, and both she and Marx knew it. 
 &bquo;You're quite right.&equo; 
 Marx nodded grimly. 
 &bquo;All right, Frau, we'll forget it. 
 Now what do you want?&equo; 
 He leaned forward confidingly. 
 &bquo;One policeman is the same as another.&equo; 
 Very well. 
 Frau Nordern coughed in what for her was a diffident manner. 
 &bquo;It's about my husband. 
 He was called in here a few days ago, about an accident.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean, yes?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern allowed herself a note of exasperation. 
 Marx blinked his bloodshot eyes. 
 &bquo;I mean yes. 
 What accident was it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern nodded. 
 &bquo;It was a motor-cyclist, he was knocked down and the driver didn't stop.&equo; 
 &bquo;So?&equo; 
 Cigar ash spilled down Marx's jacket. 
 &bquo;So we want to know what's happening.&equo; 
 Marx pawed at his jacket, rubbing the ash in rather than dusting it off. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern had a flash of temper. 
 &bquo;Why do you think? 
 My husband's worried about it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh?&equo; 
 Marx sounded mildly surprised. 
 &bquo;Just a minute.&equo; 
 He stood up and went to a battered grey filing cabinet, rummaged through it, and grunted. 
 When he turned around he was leafing through a file. 
 &bquo;Yes, Nordern&hellip; accident&hellip; number&hellip; statement taken&hellip;.&equo; 
 He leaned against the cabinet forcing Frau Nordern to turn awkwardly in order to see him. 
 &bquo;What's he worried about, your husband? 
 He says he had nothing to do with it.&equo; 
 &bquo;He certainly hadn't,&equo; Frau Nordern snapped. 
 &bquo;So?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern flushed. 
 &bquo;So I want to know how the investigation is getting on. 
 We have a right  to know. 
 Do you realise what it's like having something like this hanging over your head?&equo; 
 Marx re-lit his cigar. 
 &bquo;No, I don't,&equo; he said blandly. 
 &bquo;Well you ought to,&equo; Frau Nordern flashed, then, realising the oddity of the remark, retracted. 
 &bquo;Of course I don't mean that you should&hellip;.&equo; 
 She paused, at a loss for words, but Marx wasn't. 
 &bquo;I hope that you don't,&equo; he said in a tough, menacing voice. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern was taken aback by the toughness and the menace. 
 &bquo;But I just want to know what's happening, that's all.&equo; 
 Marx yawned, showing blackened teeth. 
 &bquo;Enquiries proceeding.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern made another foray. 
 &bquo;Who is the case officer?&equo; 
 Marx dropped the file back in the cabinet and slammed the drawer shut. 
 State Secret, too. 
 He went to the door and opened it. 
 There was a babble of voices, astonishingly cheerful under the circumstances. 
 Marx rolled his cigar from one side of his mouth to the other. 
 &bquo;They're not worrying,&equo; he said. 
 &mdash; &bquo;And they are  guilty. 
 Goodnight, Frau.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern snapped a good-night back and stormed out of the Station, and such was the mood showing on her face there on the S-Bahn  a railway policeman checking tickets did not ask for hers but wisely changed carriages at Lichtenberg station and looked for other prey. 
 The family had finished their supper when she got home, but her temper was soothed by her reception: Herr Nordern coming from the bedroom to greet her, Omi fussing, Erika getting her meal, even Paul helping her off with her coat, although he rather spoiled his effect by then chucking it over the back of a chair instead of hanging it up. 
 She finished her supper of pork and sauerkraut then, as she had a coffee, Herr Nordern joined her and the family and had coffee himself. 
 Feeling rather guilty, Frau Nordern listened as he described the arrangements for Steinmark's funeral. 
 &bquo;It seems to be taking a long time,&equo; Omi observed. 
 &bquo;It's the inquest,&equo; Herr Nordern said, &bquo;and they're having the devil of a job finding a relative to make any arrangements.&equo; 
 &bquo;Has he no family?&equo; 
 Omi asked. 
 Herr Nordern shook his head. 
 &bquo;Seems not. 
 All wiped out in the War and he was brought up in an orphanage. 
 He was a lonely, miserable wretch. 
 The Police opened his flat, hardly any furniture, just a pile of dirty magazines.&equo; 
 There was a moment's silence and, as Omi murmured a prayer for Steinmark, Frau Nordern looked around at her family and felt her throat tighten. 
 &bquo;My God,&equo; she thought. 
 A lonely, miserable wretch, living a furtive life in a shabby room somewhere, uncared for, unmourned, and it could have happened to her husband, to herself, Omi&hellip; the War could have done that, its implacable hand wiping out all human ties. 
 As she looked again at the faces of her family she was ready to burst into tears and almost did so but Erika, moving lightly into the kitchen, said: &bquo;Fr&auml;ulein Silber thinks that I should stay with her next week.&equo; 
 Lobbed through the plastic ivy it was a minor bombshell. 
 Steinmark was forgotten, and even Werner and the accident slipped from Frau Nordern's mind as the family clucked over this news. 
 &bquo;A week away from home? 
 Before the Championships?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern shook her head. 
 &bquo;You should be here, sleeping in your own bed and eating good food.&equo; 
 Omi, too, shook her head, in sadness rather than disagreement, but, as usual, Herr Nordern was bluntly commonsensical. 
 &bquo;What's the fuss? 
 Erika has been away plenty of times, and if Fr&auml;ulein Silber thinks that it is the right thing to do then it is  the right thing. 
 She's the expert, but it's up to you, Liebchen .&equo; 
 As Erika had already made up her mind, that effectively ended the debate. 
 The television was switched on, Omi started a new piece of crochet-work, Herr Nordern abandoned his statistics, Frau Nordern her reports, and Paul, boldly and half-truthfully announcing that he had finished his homework, joined Erika on the sofa to watch a good thriller on West German television. 
 It began to snow again and the dark streets of Berlin had a new, immaculate blanket, hiding the grime and grease of the day. 
 The film ended most satisfactorily, vice punished and virtue rewarded, the villain caught and the heroine finding true love with the detective. 
 As Herr Nordern said, it might easily have been made in the G.D.R., yawning as he spoke, that being a signal the whole family understood. 
 A few minutes later, Erika sat by Omi. 
 &bquo;It was a good film, wasn't it?&equo; she said, smoothing Omi's pillows. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Omi took her Watchword. 
 &bquo;So you will leave.&equo; 
 She raised her hand, stilling Erika's voice. 
 &bquo;Of course that is right. 
 You must have peace and quiet before such an event. 
 Here &mdash;&equo; she smiled &mdash; &bquo;it will be like a railway station, people coming and going &mdash; staying, too. 
 No, you must go, rest, relax, and then win your vaulting.&equo; 
 &bquo;Jumping,&equo; Erika said. 
 The familiar gurgle came from the bathroom. 
 &bquo;My turn.&equo; 
 Erika took her dressing-gown and slipped out, deftly avoiding her mother who was going to her room. 
 &bquo;Good-night, Mother,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Good-night.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern paused for a moment then waved her hand. 
 &bquo;Ah, go to Fr&auml;ulein Silber. 
 It's the sensible thing to do.&equo; 
 Erika disappeared into the bathroom, Frau Nordern into the bedroom where Herr Nordern was sitting at his desk, looking absently at the wall. 
 &bquo;You're not thinking of starting work, are you?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern asked in a tone of voice which strongly suggested that if he was then he could go and do it somewhere else. 
 &bquo;Eh?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern blinked. 
 &bquo;No, no. 
 I was just thinking.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, about Steinmark, and us. 
 How lucky we are, a family together, and how lucky I am.&equo; 
 &bquo;How lucky I am.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;And my mother.&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern shook his head. 
 &bquo;You would have been all right in the end. 
 But men&hellip; they go downhill so quickly.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Hans.&equo; 
 It was rare for Frau Nordern to kiss her husband affectionately but she did so now, kissing him on the cheek and ruffling his hair. 
 Herr Nordern smiled. 
 &bquo;Thank you, my Dear.&equo; 
 He gazed at Frau Nordern as she squeezed past the desk and sat on the bed. 
 &bquo;I'm so glad I told you the truth this morning. 
 I would have felt bad all day otherwise.&equo; 
 He stood up, stretched his arms, took two paces to the window, and peered, with some difficulty, through a hedge of cacti. 
 &bquo;Still snowing,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Ah, honesty is the best policy. 
 It really is.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern looked at her husband's broad back. 
 &bquo;Honest Hans,&equo; she thought. 
 &bquo;Solid, thorough, plodding, even,&equo; (that had been said of him by a Bromberg once to Frau Nordern &mdash; &mdash; but once only) &bquo;but kind in his shy way and decent to the very core.&equo; 
 She thought again of Steinmark and his lonely miserable life, and of the single women, and there were many in Berlin, living their lonely lives in bare rooms across the city&hellip;. 
 She bit her lip, took a deep breath, and spoke. 
 &bquo;Hans, I went there today.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hmm?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern half-turned. 
 &bquo;Where?&equo; 
 For a moment Frau Nordern was tempted to lie, to say that she had been to a meeting, or a mother. 
 &bquo;After all,&equo; she thought, &bquo;why say something which might upset Hans?&equo; 
 Some things were best left unsaid, after all, some bones best left unrattled, some secrets left buried. 
 But it wasn't the time for secrets, or the place. 
 &bquo;I went to Ostkreuz,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;To the Police Station.&equo; 
 It took a moment for the truth to sink in, but when it did Herr Nordern jumped. 
 &bquo;What!&equo; 
 He turned, caught his hand on a cactus spike, swore, and gaped. 
 &bquo;Ostkreuz?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern moved uneasily on the bed. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;But&hellip;.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern shook his head. 
 &bquo;But why? 
 I mean&hellip; did they send for you?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; frau Nordern shook her  head. 
 &bquo;I just went.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern sat down heavily at his desk. 
 &bquo;Just went? 
 I don't understand.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wanted to see this Werner man.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern raised her chin pugnaciously. 
 &bquo;I wanted to know what is going on. 
 &bquo;But Bodo &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't Bodo me,&equo; Frau Nordern snapped, but immediately raised her hand in apology. 
 &bquo;Sorry Hans. 
 I didn't mean to speak sharply. 
 I know what Bodo said about letting the matter lie, but I don't agree with him. 
 We have a right to know what is going on, so I went to find out.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern sucked his thumb for a moment, biting at the cactus spike. 
 &bquo;And what did you find out?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Frau Nordern tugged at the collar of her dressing-gown. 
 &bquo;Not much.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern bit impatiently at his thumb. 
 &bquo;Did you see Werner?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I saw a sergeant called Marx.&equo; 
 &bquo;Marx?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Despite herself Frau Nordern laughed. 
 &bquo;A stubby man, chain-smoking cigars.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern grunted. 
 &bquo;I think he was there when I saw Werner. 
 Bloodshot eyes?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;And what did he say?&equo; 
 &bquo;He said enquiries were proceeding.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's all?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;So it's still hanging over us.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern frowned. 
 &bquo;Did you find out anything about Werner?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern shook her head. 
 &bquo;They said any information like that is a State Secret.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course it is.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was sharp. 
 &bquo;You ought to know that.&equo; 
 He rapped the desk. 
 &bquo;I wish you hadn't gone. 
 I really do. 
 Bodo was quite right.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern agreed that he probably had been. 
 &bquo;And what did you find out? 
 Nothing, nothing at all.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern was meek. 
 &bquo;All you've done is make us look suspicious.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern demurred. 
 &bquo;I don't see that. 
 There's nothing wrong in asking about an accident.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;But there is in asking about Werner.&equo; 
 There was a glum silence for a moment or two then Frau Nordern climbed into bed. 
 &bquo;Put the light out will you?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern switched off the light but went back to his desk. 
 There was the sputter of a match as he lighted a cigar. 
 &bquo;Aren't you coming to bed?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern asked. 
 &bquo;In a minute.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern joggled her side of the bolster. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;It's all right,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;You meant well. 
 Go to sleep. 
 I'll be in bed soon.&equo; 
 But ten minutes later, as Frau Nordern was drifting off into an uneasy slumber, Herr Nordern was still at his desk, staring into the darkness, the end of his cigar glowing like a red warning signal as the snow drifted down on to Berlin, and his family, and the city, slept. 
 FRAU NORDERN woke to a clear cold light and, to her amazement, Herr Nordern looming over her with a coffee. 
 I didn't sleep very well, he said, almost apologetically. 
 &bquo;I thought that you would like a coffee in bed for a change. 
 You're not going to work are you?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern took the coffee and blinked sleepily. 
 &bquo;No. 
 Saturday isn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;All day.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern turned to the door. 
 &bquo;Sorry if I was sharp last night, about you going to the Police. 
 It just took me aback.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern sipped her coffee. 
 &bquo;It was stupid of me.&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 Why shouldn't we ask. 
 Anyway, I'm going to the office. 
 The office ,&equo; he repeated. 
 &bquo;No more secrets, eh?&equo; 
 He smiled shyly. 
 &bquo;Be back by 1.00 &mdash; I hope. 
 'Bye.&equo; 
 Leaving behind an amused wife he went into the livingi-room where Erika, dressed in a track suit, was having her breakfast. 
 &bquo; Liebchen ,&equo; Herr Nordern heaved on his overcoat. 
 &bquo;Going running?&equo; 
 Erika wagged a finger. 
 &bquo;Been,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Five kilometres.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern waved a goodbye and walked along the familiar road to the S-Bahn  station. 
 &bquo;My God.&equo; 
 He shook his head. 
 &bquo;Five kilometres and it's barely light. 
 &bquo;I couldn't run five metres.&equo; 
 As the train rattled into the station he felt a glow of pride. 
 &bquo;What a girl &mdash; and my daughter. 
 I just hope that there is nothing to this Werner business. 
 My God, I hope not.&equo; 
 Behind him, in the flat on Klara-Lettkin-Strasse, there was a cheerful atmosphere. 
 Touched by her husband's bringing her coffee Frau Nordern was in a good humour, dismissing her own worries about the accident as mere alarmism stoked by Bodo, and tempering her authoritarian ways by letting Paul stay in bed for an extra fifteen minutes instead of, as usual, rousing him in the manner of a sergeant in charge of a penal battalion. 
 The arrival of the mail helped, too: a mound of letters from the relatives who were, or, if they were to be given free accommodation, thought that they were, coming to Uncle Karl's party. 
 &bquo;I think that Fr&auml;ulein Silber was right,&equo; she said, reading a letter from an obscure, elderly maiden cousin who lived in an even more obscure district of the country. 
 &bquo;Hetta's coming. 
 My God, Mecken, what a place to live!&equo; 
 Erika laughed and Omi smiled, breaking her wan mood. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;That awful bog-land. 
 When we were children we were told that we would be sent there if we were naughty. 
 Poor Hetta. 
 Still, it will be good to see her.&equo; 
 Erika, who had never set eyes on Hetta in her life, stoutly agreed, and even Paul, making a dishevelled appearance, said with his new courtliness that he would like to meet her, causing Frau Nordern to raise a sceptical eyebrow and warn him not to be sarcastic at that time of the morning. 
 &bquo;So.&equo; 
 Erika stood up. 
 &bquo;I'm going to the gym. 
 I can tell Fr&auml;ulein Silber that I'll be staying with her next week then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Frau Nordern looked at her mail and added, ruefully, &bquo;I wouldn't mind staying with her myself.&equo; 
 The sun had broken through as Erika went to the bus-stop and by the time she had reached school it was quite warm, this pleasing Erika who feared that really severe weather would cause Uncle Karl to cancel the tour of Berlin the next day. 
 In the gym, though, in front of the school video team, Fr&auml;ulein Silber was at her most severe, even criticising Erika's warm-up exercises and clapping her hands with exasperation at Erika's run-up, that curved and crucial approach to the bar. 
 But after an hour of steady jumping, Fr&auml;ulein Silber's mood changed abruptly. 
 With an approving clap of her hands she ended the session, smiled, and said, &bquo;Excellent. 
 Very good.&equo; 
 She dismissed the video crew with the threat of terrible penalties if the video tape was not perfect, waved Erika down on the mat, and joined her. 
 She leaned forward, her face serious. 
 &bquo;Erika, you jumped really well there at the end. 
 First-class technique &mdash; you'll see for yourself on the video tape. 
 But &mdash;&equo; 
 Erika's face fell, &bquo;But.&equo; 
 Life seemed full of them. 
 Her father would take her sailing on the Wannsee next summer &mdash; but ! 
 They might move into a bigger flat &mdash; but ! 
 She was jumping A.I &mdash; but ! 
 &bquo;Cheer up.&equo; 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber's somewhat chilly face splintered into a smile. 
 &bquo;What I'm saying is this. 
 Until a few weeks ago you were jumping with passion. 
 Yes, with real feeling. 
 With &mdash;&equo; she searched for the right word. 
 &bquo;With dynamism . 
 That's it. 
 You were dynamic. 
 Watching you jump was&hellip; well, it was like seeing a firework going off, a sky-rocket. 
 You just shot up, whizzing all over the place, erratic but really zooming, and that partly compensated for any lack of technique. 
 Now your technique is good, not perfect by any means, but good. 
 But the fire has gone. 
 Wait.&equo; 
 She raised her hand, stilling Erika's instinctive protest. 
 &bquo;Don't worry. 
 It always happens. 
 People start spontaneously in sport. 
 It's a natural activity; running, jumping, kicking footballs. 
 Having fun, really. 
 But then to be good at a sport, really good I mean, you have to learn how to do what you are doing naturally in the best way possible. 
 And that means technique. 
 But, and it does happen, learning the technique dampens the fire &mdash; and then we have to stoke it up again.&equo; 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber paused and looked steadily at Erika. 
 &bquo;In fact you have to forget the technique. 
 It's there now. 
 It's built into you. 
 What was unnatural has become natural, you don't have to think about it, your body will do the right thing in the right way, like breathing. 
 Strange, isn't it? 
 You spend years learning something only to forget what you've learned. 
 Like riding a bicycle.&equo; 
 &bquo;Or playing Bach,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Bach?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; Erika stretched her legs. 
 &bquo;Frau Fegel was saying the other day when we were playing Bach that our technique was good but that we had to learn to put feeling into our playing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just so!&equo; 
 Fr&auml;ulein Silber smacked her muscular thigh. 
 &bquo;Exactly, and remember, art and sport have this in common, they are both means of self-expression. 
 But they are more than just that. 
 A child screaming is expressing itself, or like those artists who daub things in the West &mdash; they say they are expressing themselves.&equo; 
 It was clear from Fr&auml;ulein Silber's face that she did not think highly of modern art. 
 &bquo;But with discipline, art and sport are ways of developing  one's personality. 
 And it can be done at any level. 
 Even a paraplegic can be a sportsman. 
 That is why we encourage mass sport in the G.D.R. 
 And &mdash;&equo; adding a little hastily &mdash; &bquo;mass participation in all forms of human activity, art, crafts, and &mdash;&equo; somewhat improbably &mdash; &bquo;philosophy, Marxism-Leninism. 
 But &mdash;&equo; 
 She rose with the fluent movement of the athlete. 
 &bquo;Enough of that. 
 So, you will be staying with me next week?&equo; 
 Yes, Erika would. 
 &bquo;Good. 
 I'll call for you in my car tomorrow. 
 Next week we put the fire back into you. 
 Goodbye &mdash; and don't forget your exercises this afternoon.&equo; 
 They parted and Erika caught her bus, wondering about the relationship between technique and feeling. 
 It was an interesting thought, to learn something in order to forget it; as Fr&auml;ulein Silber had said, like learning how to ride a bike, but like many other things, too, learning to play a musical instrument for instance. 
 And this business of self-expression &mdash; she thought of Bunte with her striped hair. 
 &bquo;I really must think about the whole question,&equo; she thought, as she went up the stairs to the flat. 
 Her mother and Omi and Paul were in, going through the arrangements for the party and wondering where the various guests could be put up &mdash; for free. 
 Erika joined them, scanning the mail, and Bodo bustled in, ruddy from the cold, rubbing his calloused hands together, taking a glass of plum brandy, and filling the flat with an air of cheerful, rough, vigorous outdoor life. 
 &bquo;Just called to see you about the musicians for the party,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;How many? 
 Six? 
 Eight? 
 Ten?&equo; 
 &bquo;Three,&equo; Frau Nordern said promptly. 
 &bquo;Piano, drums, and a what-do-you-call-them? 
 An accordian.&equo; 
 Bodo shook his head. 
 &bquo;They'll only play with four. 
 That includes a violinist.&equo; 
 &bquo;How much?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern asked &mdash; and blenched when she heard the figure. 
 &bquo;I'm certainly not paying that,&equo; she said indignantly. 
 &bquo;Half would be too much.&equo; 
 &bquo;Come on Helga.&equo; 
 Bodo swigged his brandy. 
 &bquo;It's a good price and &mdash;&equo; he winked slyly at Erika &mdash; &bquo;and for another twenty marks they'll wear gipsy dress.&equo; 
 &bquo;Gipsy &mdash;&equo; Frau Nordern began, but stopped as Erika burst out laughing. 
 &bquo;Oh, a joke. 
 Very funny. 
 But I'm not paying that much if they dress up as&hellip; as&hellip;.&equo; 
 She searched for words, and was still searching for them as the front door opened and Herr Nordern came in. 
 At once Frau Nordern went on to the attack. 
 &bquo;Hans, the money Bodo wants for his musicians!&equo; 
 &bquo;Not my  musicians,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;I won't make anything out of them.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern gave him a disbelieving stare. 
 &bquo;Anyway,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You tell him Hans &mdash; and we only want three.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern hesitated, then nodded. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Er, come into the bedroom, Bodo.&equo; 
 Bodo blinked. 
 &bquo;A secret session.&equo; 
 He guffawed. 
 &bquo;It's about a musician not a disarmament conference.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, yes. 
 But come anyway.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern brusquely waved Bodo into the bedroom and closed the door behind them. 
 &bquo;What the &mdash;&equo; Bodo began, then saw the expression on his brother's face. 
 &bquo;Oh. 
 Serious.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe, perhaps, I don't know.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern rummaged in his desk, brought out a half-bottle of schnapps, two glasses, and poured drinks. 
 &bquo;Sit down,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It's this Werner business, Bodo. 
 Helga went to Ostkreuz last night.&equo; 
 Bodo whistled. 
 &bquo;Not wise, Hans. 
 Not wise.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know that.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern gulped his drink. 
 &bquo;But she didn't tell me she was going.&equo; 
 Bodo downed his drink and held his glass out for more. 
 &bquo;So what happened?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern told him, barking savagely at an innocent Paul who poked his head around the door to ask what time they wanted lunch. 
 &bquo;Asking about Werner&hellip;.&equo; 
 Bodo shook his head. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 But what's the harm in it &mdash; I mean what?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern said, then held out his hand. 
 &bquo;I know. 
 I know. 
 Anyway, she saw this man Marx. 
 What do you know about him?&equo; 
 But Bodo did not get round to answering that question because, to another curse from Herr Nordern, the door opened again &mdash; only this time the frame was blocked by Frau Nordern, her pale face paler than usual, her hand at her throat, and her eyes wide and staring. 
 &bquo;It's for you,&equo; she said to her husband. 
 &bquo;It's that man from Ostkreuz. 
 It's Sergeant Marx.&equo; 
 There was a stunned silence, broken finally by Herr Nordern. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Marx? 
 Here?&equo; 
 &bquo;At the door,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;He's waiting.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can't believe&hellip;.&equo; 
 Some of the blood drained from Herr Nordern's face. 
 &bquo;What does he want?&equo; 
 &bquo;He wants you,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 The rest of the blood seeped away from Herr Nordern's face, leaving it as white as his wife's. 
 He licked his lips and looked at Bodo who, grim-faced, shrugged. 
 &bquo;Have to see him,&equo; Bodo said. 
 &bquo;He isn't going to go away.&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern stood up rather stiffly and squared his shoulders. 
 &bquo;He won't.&equo; 
 Automatically he smoothed his hair and adjusted his tie. 
 &bquo;Well, it can't be anything &mdash;&equo; and again, passionately, &bquo;it can't be! 
 You'll come, Bodo?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure.&equo; 
 Bodo stood up, as solid as a brick wall. 
 &bquo;All the way.&equo; 
 &bquo;Right, then.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern went through the sitting-room to the front door. 
 Marx was there, leaning on the door-frame, a hat rammed on the back of his head, a cigar jammed in the corner of his mouth, blinking his bloodshot eyes. 
 &bquo;You want to see me?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern said. 
 Marx nodded and gave a chesty cough. 
 &bquo;What about?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern tried to sound firm and innocent although, as he was desperately aware, sounding feeble &mdash; and guilty. 
 Marx coughed again. 
 &bquo;Perhaps we ought to go inside.&equo; 
 &bquo;Inside? 
 Oh, of course. 
 Yes.&equo; 
 As if they were doing a bizarre dance, followed by Marx, Herr Nordern backed through the tiny vestibule, into the sitting-room, and a silent, apprehensive circle of Norderns. 
 &bquo;You've met my wife, I think,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;This is my mother-in-law, my children, and my brother.&equo; 
 Omi and the children got perfunctory nods from Marx but he peered intently at Bodo who, massive arms folded, was leaning against the wall. 
 &bquo;I know you,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;And I know you,&equo; Bodo answered in a tough, unyielding voice. 
 &bquo;And you've got your hat on.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern's heart jumped, but Marx merely raised his eyebrows. 
 &bquo;So I have,&equo; he said, and removed it. 
 &bquo;'Scuse me.&equo; 
 He addressed Frau Nordern. 
 &bquo;Where I spend my time people don't bother.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern gave a placatory smile and was about to say, completely untruthfully, that he &mdash; they &mdash; understood, when, to his horror, Bodo butted in again. 
 &bquo;Well we do here,&equo; he said in his toughest voice. 
 Herr Nordern held his breath but Marx nodded. 
 &bquo;I suppose you do.&equo; 
 There was a long moment's silence. 
 The Norderns looked at Marx who stood before them as if he was quite happy to stand there in silence all day. 
 Finally Herr Nordern spoke. 
 He tried to sound jocular but realised that he sounded almost pleading. 
 &bquo;And what can I do for you, Sergeant? 
 It is Sergeant, isn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Detective Sergeant.&equo; 
 Marx looked around for an ashtray, found one, and deliberately ground out his cigar-end. 
 &bquo;It's about the accident. 
 You remember that, I suppose?&equo; 
 Again Herr Nordern was going to speak, knowing as he did so that he would sound feeble, when again Bodo stepped in and said, in a distinctly non-feeble voice, which sounded like a cement-mixer, &bquo;Of course he remembers. 
 Get on with it.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern's pounding heart stopped momentarily. 
 &bquo;Oh my God,&equo; he thought. 
 &bquo;Oh Bodo, please keep your mouth shut. 
 Don't provoke the Police. 
 Don't make matters worse.&equo; 
 But Marx, in an equally tough voice, merely said, &bquo;O.K. Let's do just that,&equo; put his hand in his breast pocket, slowly pulled out a horribly official-looking envelope, and slowly and carefully took from that an even more horribly official-looking form, folded once, in what to Herr Nordern seemed an indescribably sinister manner from top to bottom instead of side to side. 
 Marx unfolded the form and spoke to Herr Nordern. 
 &bquo;Perhaps you'd like to sit down.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Yes, if you say so. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern sank on to the sofa and, astonishingly, found himself holding his wife's hand, and feeling hers firmly gripping his. 
 Frau Nordern turned her head. 
 &bquo;Erika, Paul, go to your room. 
 Omi?&equo; 
 But as Erika and Paul obediently, docilely, left the room &mdash; not without a backward glance from Paul &mdash; Omi shook her head. 
 &bquo;I will stay here if I may,&equo; she said, looking at Marx as if he were an unpleasant insect. 
 Not that the look bothered Marx. 
 He blinked at Herr Nordern, then peered at the document and began to read aloud, in a hoarse voice: &bquo;By Order of the Minister of Justice, I, the Chief of Police of the City of Berlin&hellip;&equo; 
 In Omi's room, the door opened a crack: herself frightened, Erika peeked into the sitting-room and hushed an even more frightened Paul into silence as he whispered, &bquo;What is it? 
 What's going on?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing,&equo; Erika whispered back. 
 &bquo;It's all right,&equo; although, as she looked through the crack it did not seem all right at all; in fact it seemed all wrong. 
 Her father and mother were sitting tensely on the sofa, Omi at the table, upright, disdain on her fine features, Bodo, huge against the wall, and all of them staring at the stubby, shabby, ash-stained figure of Marx, blinking through his red eyes at the document and reading aloud in an artificially solemn voice, practised in legal jargon and with which he, no doubt, had read out a hundred, a thousand, such documents. 
 &bquo;&hellip; of the City of Berlin&hellip; you, Herr Nordern, official, of 13 Klara-Lettkin-Strasse, Biesdorf, in the jurisdiction of the City of Berlin, are hereby given official notification that &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; Erika placed her hand over her mouth. 
 &bquo;Please,&equo; she thought, &bquo;please please.&equo; 
 And then summoning up all her courage, listened to Marx continue. 
 &bquo;That the accident at the corner of&hellip; resolved&hellip; culprit apprehended&hellip; said Herr Nordern cleared of all suspicion&hellip; and etc., and etc., and etc., And that's that,&equo; Marx said unemotionally as he folded the form and slid it back into the envelope. 
 Herr Nordern felt his hand tremble. 
 With an effort of will he tried to stop it but it carried on trembling. 
 &bquo;Cleared?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Cleared? 
 You mean&hellip; you mean I'm cleared?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right.&equo; 
 Marx stuck the envelope into his pocket. 
 &bquo;Actually, I shouldn't be telling you yet, but as your wife came to the station saying how worried you were I thought I'd call in and tell you. 
 You don't mind, I hope?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mind!&equo; 
 Herr Nordern jumped from the sofa, exultant. 
 &bquo;My God, thank you. 
 Thank you, Sergeant. 
 Cleared! 
 Do you hear that, Helga? 
 Bodo? 
 Ah! 
 A drink. 
 We must have a drink on it. 
 Erika, Paul, come in, come in. 
 Get some glasses, Erika. 
 Ha! ha! 
 Sergeant, you'll have a drink with us? 
 Of course you will.&equo; 
 He opened a bottle of brandy, his hands trembling and his face no longer white but red. 
 &bquo;Here Sergeant.&equo; 
 He handed a brimming glass to the imperturbable Marx. 
 &bquo;And thank you. 
 Thank you very much. 
 Very much .&equo; 
 Marx downed his glass in one gulp and absent-mindedly held it out for more. 
 &bquo;That's all right,&equo; he said as Herr Nordern eagerly refilled it. 
 &bquo;You would have heard officially on Monday but I thought why not tell you now and save you a week-end's worry. 
 I was passing anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;Passing!&equo; 
 Herr Nordern laughed. 
 &bquo;I'm glad that you were, Sergeant. 
 Hey, Helga? 
 Bodo?&equo; 
 He filled glasses and took one himself. 
 &bquo;But the other man, the culprit?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; Marx was dismissive. 
 &bquo;We got him. 
 It's like I said, the witness got the licence number garbled.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern gave a huge sigh of relief. 
 &bquo;You did say that, Sergeant. 
 Yes, you said that when I saw you at the station, ha! ha!&equo; 
 &bquo;And the victim?&equo; 
 Omi whispered from her seat behind the table. 
 &bquo;Oh, him. 
 He seems to be pulling round,&equo; Marx said. 
 &bquo;Thank God,&equo; Omi said, a sentiment shared cordially by all the family. 
 &bquo;And thank you again, Sergeant,&equo; Herr Nordern said, as Marx stood up, spilling cigar ash over himself and the carpet. 
 Herr Nordern shook hands with him, escorted him to the door, and saw him down the stairs as an excited buzz broke out among the family. 
 &bquo;I can't say how glad I am,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Over! 
 That nightmare.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's the word.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern came back, rubbing his hands. 
 &bquo;Nightmare. 
 I can't believe that it is  over. 
 You were right, Bodo, saying to leave the matter alone &mdash; although you gave me a turn when you were so&hellip; so abrupt with the Sergeant.&equo; 
 Bodo sat down, making the chair creak. 
 &bquo;You don't want to let the cops walk all over you,&equo; he growled. 
 &bquo;Anyway, I knew it was nothing when he came in.&equo; 
 &bquo;You did?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 They come in twos when they're out for trouble. 
 Anyway, you were innocent all along.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ach!&equo; 
 Frau Nordern waved her arms. 
 &bquo;What does it matter. 
 It's over, that's the thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;And it's past lunch-time,&equo; Herr Nordern said, adding hastily, &bquo;not that I'm bothered, but the children, and Omi&hellip;.&equo; 
 Lunch was ready, Bodo, pressed to stay, was persuaded, two bottles of wine were opened, a good, warming goulash brought in, and then, as Herr Nordern rather ceremoniously raised his glass to offer a toast, the telephone rang. 
 The whole family groaned, then burst out laughing. 
 &bquo;Leave it,&equo; Herr Nordern said as Erika moved to take the call, but, as usual, the phone was hard to resist and, pulling a face, Herr Nordern took the call himself. 
 The line was surprisingly good, free from the usual squawks and clicks, and coming through, smooth, bland, was the voice of Uncle Karl. 
 &bquo;Hans? 
 My dear fellow. 
 Karl here. 
 How are you, and the family?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well. 
 We're all well,&equo; Herr Nordern bellowed from force of habit. 
 &bquo;In fact we're very well indeed.&equo; 
 &bquo;Really?&equo; 
 Karl sounded intrigued. 
 &bquo;Hans, you sound&hellip; exhilarated. 
 Have you heard some good news?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, yes!&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was triumphant as he told Karl of Marx's visit. 
 &bquo;Ahh,&equo; Karl purred with satisfaction. 
 &bquo;Splendid. 
 Simply splendid. 
 Of course I never doubted that your excellent police force would catch the real culprit, but it must have cleared your mind. 
 Most unpleasant having something like that hanging over your head. 
 No &mdash;&equo; in answer to Herr Nordern's promptings &mdash; &bquo;I'm truly sorry but I can't join you today. 
 Actually I was calling to confirm my little trip with Erika tomorrow.&equo; 
 The phone was handed over to Erika, who confirmed the trip and then gave the phone to her mother, who exchanged a few banalities and then handed it to Omi, who cooed and clucked and finally returned it to Herr Nordern who said, briefly, that they all looked forward very much to seeing Karl again and firmly replaced the receiver before anyone else could claim it. 
 &bquo;Eat,&equo; he said, in a voice which meant, undeniably, now . 
 Eat it was, the goulash excellent, good black bread, and the wine very passable. 
 Herr Nordern looked around the table, exuberant, dizzy with happiness, and then, remembering the toast he had been about to make, raised his glass. 
 &bquo;To us,&equo; he said proudly. 
 &bquo;To all of us, but especially to you, Erika. 
 The week of your life ahead of you!&equo; 
 Frau Nordern and Omi beamed on Erika, Bodo banged the table with his fist, making the plates bounce alarmingly, Erika blushed, and, for reasons known only to himself, Paul went a fiery red, too. 
 &bquo;And what did Karl want with you?&equo; 
 Frau Nordern asked when the hubbub had died down. 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;It was about tomorrow. 
 Tomorrow ,&equo; she repeated after getting a blank stare from her mother. 
 &bquo;I'm meeting him, to go on a trip round the city. 
 That's if the weather is good.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course, I'd quite forgotten,&equo; Frau Nordern said. 
 She spooned goulash down her handsome throat. 
 &bquo;Where will you take him?&equo; 
 &bquo;The zoo,&equo; Paul butted in, only to be butted out by his mother. 
 &bquo;The zoo!&equo; 
 She was blistering. 
 &bquo;You might as well say take him on the swings in the park. 
 What would you say, Omi?&equo; 
 Omi half-smiled. 
 &bquo;It isn't the weather for sightseeing, but he might care to look at the old Adlon hotel.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern, pouring out more wine, shook his head. 
 &bquo;Do you think so, Omi, really? 
 Not much to see there and it's a bit near the Bun &mdash;&equo; he chopped his sentence short. 
 &bquo;Sorry.&equo; 
 He coughed. 
 &bquo;Shouldn't have mentioned it, but you know what I mean.&equo; 
 They did &mdash; even Paul. 
 Herr Nordern had been about to say &bquo;the bunker,&equo; the stretch of waste land behind Friedrichstrasse where, in his concrete tomb, as the Russians had battered their way into the city in 1945, Hitler had lived his final appalling fantasy; commanding armies which did not exist, so condemning thousands, hundreds of thousands of civilians to death in those final lunatic days. 
 Under docks and willowherb, the Bunker was still there, sealed but poisoned and poisonous, in a haunted city the spectres of an evil past still emanating from it, not least the ghosts of the six children of the Goebbels, killed by their own parents as a final insane act of homage to Der F&uuml;hrer. 
 For a moment the ghosts hovered around Klara-Lettkin-Strasse until Bodo exorcised them. 
 &bquo;Take him on a tourist bus,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They're still running. 
 Whizz round the sights and then if you've got any sense get back inside the Palast.&equo; 
 Although the idea of the Palast appealed to Frau Nordern she was not too sure of the propriety of Karl's being whizzed around anywhere, especially on a tourist bus. 
 Bodo grinned. 
 &bquo;Well&hellip; what about you Paul? 
 Any more ideas?&equo; 
 Paul had plenty but as, owing to a fixed and completely unbreakable appointment with the F.G.Y., he was not going on the tour, his ideas were of no consequence. 
 &bquo;But you're coming to lunch,&equo; Erika said, consoling him. 
 Paul perked up at that and, in any case, Herr Nordern shifted the topic. 
 &bquo;Wait until tomorrow before you decide,&equo; he said to Erika. 
 &bquo;The weather might be too bad, anyway.&equo; 
 That prospect looked increasingly likely as the day wore out its brief existence. 
 The clouds were lifting and breaking and at dusk, as Erika padded home from her run in the park, the temperature was falling. 
 It grew colder still as the night fell, a crackling frost under a sickle moon, but the coldness did not reach into the Norderns' flat and it would not have done so even had the central heating broken down, the joy and relief of the family generating enough warmth to melt the polar ice-cap if necessary. 
 &bquo;I can't say how I feel,&equo; Herr Nordern said for the twentieth time. 
 &bquo;I really can't. 
 It's all over. 
 Done with. 
 Finished. 
 Now all we have to do is our duty to the State and it's full steam ahead for the Norderns.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern agreed, although not without adding a rider of her own: &bquo;I always did think that Bodo was being alarmist.&equo; 
 But she said that almost as if it were expected of her rather than with conviction &mdash; and the family knew it. 
 Paul, in fact, moved to Bodo's defence. 
 &bquo;Uncle Bodo is all right,&equo; he said, only to be crushed by his mother. 
 &bquo;And who said he wasn't?&equo; she demanded, and, pulverising as well as crushing, added, &bquo;Go and tidy your room or you won't watch television tonight.&equo; 
 Paul, whose remark had been the opening move in a carefully planned campaign to enhance Bodo's image so that his plan to leave school and work with him would not meet resistance, meekly accepted the rebuke and the order, especially as the television he  wanted to watch was a rock concert. 
 Frau Nordern sternly watched Paul's retreating back then, dotingly, smiled at Erika. 
 &bquo;You ought to get ready,&equo; she said. 
 Erika, rubbing her hair after&equo; her shower said, &bquo;Get ready for what?&equo; 
 &bquo;For tomorrow,&equo; her mother said. 
 &bquo;You're going to Fr&auml;ulein Silber's.&equo; 
 Erika laughed. 
 &bquo;There's ages of time.&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern was sharp. 
 &bquo;You'll be busy tomorrow and besides, I like things done with plenty of time to spare.&equo; 
 Erika following her, she bustled into Omi's room and began rummaging in the dressing-table pulling out garments to a running commentary of, &bquo;Are these clean? 
 Is this? 
 This one isn't. 
 I'll lend you my suitcase, yours isn't fit to be seen&hellip;.&equo; 
 Erika sat on her bed smiling and when, after a few vigorous minutes, her mother announced that all was ready, she burst out laughing. 
 &bquo;And just what is so funny?&equo; her mother demanded. 
 &bquo;Nothing really,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;It's just that I might as well have stayed in the sitting-room, that's all.&equo; 
 She laughed again and, after a suspicious moment, Frau Nordern laughed too, a rich, throaty chuckle. 
 &bquo;I suppose so,&equo; she said. 
 She shook her head. 
 &bquo;I can't get used to the idea that you're growing up and can look after yourself. 
 And I shouldn't go through your things. 
 I know I hated it when Omi did it to me when I was your age.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right, Mother.&equo; 
 Erika smiled, an enchanting open smile which illuminated her entire being and the entire room. 
 &bquo;Look away. 
 All open for inspection. 
 No secrets.&equo; 
 Frau Nordern looked at Erika for a long, long moment. 
 &bquo;No secrets,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Bless you, child.&equo; 
 In the next room, Herr Nordern, reading the evening paper, heard the laughter, and the warm voices, and felt again profound happiness and contentment in his heart. 
 He lowered his paper, lighted a cigar, and looked across at Omi. 
 &bquo;We live in a good country,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Mmm?&equo; 
 Omi raised her head from her crochet-work. 
 &bquo;If you say so.&equo; 
 &bquo;I do say so.&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was vigorously affirmative, combative even, but he was taken aback by Omi's response. 
 &bquo;You didn't think that the other day,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I beg your pardon?&equo; 
 Herr Nordern was indignant. 
 Omi hooked a thread around her crochet-hook. 
 &bquo;When you were complaining about the Police,&equo; she said. 
 Herr Nordern raised his hand in protest but let it fall again. 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; he thought, &bquo;why argue? 
 She's just an old woman living in the past, and if I never have another one this evening is going to be a good one.&equo; 
 And good it was: good wine, good food, and a good film on the television, even Paul's request for the rock concert being allowed &mdash; for ten minutes. 
 Omi sat quietly crocheting, Erika conscientiously worked on her sightseeing list for the next morning, writing out appropriate comments from the official guide to the city, Herr Nordern, guilt-free, smoked and drank brandy and Frau Nordern sat by him, having a drink, too, wondering whether she might have a cigarette &mdash; but deciding not to, preferring to keep that secret to herself. 
 And then, good-night, and goodnight, and the Nordern family went to bed. 
 As ever, Erika sat with Omi for a while, holding her hand. 
 &bquo;You are packed already?&equo; 
 Omi said. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Erika looked at the splendid silver plastic suitcase on her bed. 
 &bquo;Mother did it.&equo; 
 She laughed again, but Omi did not join in. 
 Erika looked at her thoughtfully. 
 &bquo;Omi,&equo; she said, &bquo;you're not sad, are you? 
 I'm only going to be away for a few days.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know.&equo; 
 Omi patted Erika's hand. 
 &bquo;Only a week, and you must have a good week. 
 And you must have a good morning tomorrow with Karl.&equo; 
 Erika had a sudden thought. 
 &bquo;Why not come with me?&equo; she asked. 
 A half-smile played on Omi's lips. 
 &bquo;I think not,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Not in this weather, but thank you for the thought, my dear one. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 The flat fell quiet. 
 Erika slipped into the bathroom and met her father coming out. 
 &bquo;Good-night, Liebchen ,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Oh, just one thing. 
 &bquo;Tomorrow&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 Erika said. 
 &bquo;Show Karl Bebel-Platz,&equo; Herr Nordern said. 
 &bquo;Make sure he doesn't miss it.&equo; 
 And on that enigmatic note he kissed her cheek and went to bed. 
 When Erika tiptoed back into the bedroom Omi was asleep. 
 Erika took the Watchwords from her hands, flicked out the bedside lamp, and stood by the window: a silent street. 
 No one moving, not a man nor a woman, not a car or a motor bike, not even a dog barking under the sickle moon which shone in an opalescent sky surrounded by a diadem of stars. 
 In the beech tree, over the boulder, the owl called, for all the bitter frost warm in his golden feathers, and soon Erika was in her fleece of down, sleeping the sleep of the young and the innocent and the pure of heart. 
 NO SNOW fell during the night and at 10.00, after Erika had run her five kilometres under a dazzling blue sky, Karl ran and said that he thought he rather did that a brief tour of Berlin would be possible and that he would be waiting in the lounge of the Palast at 11.00; adding that Paul should meet them at the television Tower at 1.00 
 Waiting he was in the gold and brown of the Palast, himself immaculate, pink, flashing his smile as he complimented Erika on her appearance and, in her leather coat and with her fur hat at a rakish angle, and her face glowing with health, Erika deserved the compliment. 
 &bquo;The streets aren't icy?&equo; he asked, and, reassured that they were not &mdash; not in the city centre, anyway &mdash; he suggested that they might take a short stroll, just a short one, if that suited Erika. 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; Erika said. 
 She took out her list. 
 &bquo;I thought that we would go up the Television Tower and see the view, then go to the museums, especially the Pergamon, then the Palace of the Republic, then&hellip;.&equo; 
 Her voice died away as Karl benignly shook his head. 
 &bquo;A most interesting programme, my Dear, but perhaps a little too much. 
 I have seen a great many sights, you know. 
 My hosts have taken me around, and I thought that we would have lunch in the Television Tower &mdash; in fact I have reserved a table. 
 No, I thought that perhaps a stroll down Unter den Linden &mdash; such memories for me there &mdash; and then I have another idea. 
 A surprise, ha! ha!&equo; 
 A little crestfallen, Erika put her list away and dutifully said that of course she would be happy to do whatever Uncle Karl wished to do. 
 &bquo;So.&equo; 
 Karl waved a hand, a brown-uniformed attendant gave them a respectful salute, and they sauntered out. 
 Karl tucked Erika's arm under his as they crossed the bridge over the green, splintered ice of the Spree which formed a chill moat around the great museums, by the great dome of the Protestant Cathedral, and on to the broad stretch of Unter den Linden. 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; Karl shook his head as he looked down the avenue. 
 &bquo;It has changed, the bombing, the battle, but&hellip; some has survived, shops, libraries, the Embassies&hellip;.&equo; 
 Erika took out her notes. 
 &bquo;A great deal of damage was done during the anti-fascist struggle but the German Democratic Republic is restoring these monuments to art and culture.&equo; 
 &bquo;Admirable.&equo; 
 Karl took a pace or two forwards. 
 &bquo;My hosts have driven me down the avenue and given me the figures. 
 Most admirable. 
 And to see that &mdash;&equo; 
 With surprising agility Karl darted across the road to where, on a bronze plinth, brazen himself, a mighty figure rode a horse. 
 Erika followed Karl with a few lithe strides. 
 &bquo;Frederick the Great,&equo; she said, unreeling her lesson learned by rote. 
 &bquo;King of Prussia.&equo; 
 She pointed to the frieze under the formidable warrior-king: &bquo;General Yorck, General Bl&uuml;cher, General Scharnhorst, principal generals of the War of Liberation in which the German people freed themselves from French occupation in 1813. 
 Although representatives of the Prussian ruling class they played a necessary role in the development of the national aspirations of the people which was to lead to our new Germany&hellip;.&equo; 
 But Karl was not listening. 
 He placed his hand on the plinth as one might lay a hand upon a sacred object so that its virtue might flow from it to oneself. 
 But when he turned, his face was as bland as ever. 
 &bquo;Yes indeed,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Frederick and the generals, Prussian generals, ha! ha!&equo; he laughed meaninglessly. 
 &bquo;Shall we saunter on?&equo; 
 With less alacrity he allowed himself to be guided across the other lane of the avenue, on to the safety of the pavement, and to an oddly impressive square, framed by the Catholic Cathedral, the Opera House, and the old Royal Library. 
 &bquo;The State restored the Cathedral,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;It was badly damaged by shelling in 1945.&equo; 
 &bquo;Most meritorious,&equo; Karl murmured. 
 &bquo;I do know the square &mdash; rather well.&equo; 
 &bquo;It is called August-Bebel-Platz now,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;And Father thought that you ought to see this. 
 It is new since your time.&equo; 
 She walked across the cobbles and pointed to a plaque set in the wall of the Library. 
 &bquo;Another interesting sight.&equo; 
 Karl gave a vulpine smile as, in her clear voice, Erika read aloud: 
 &bquo;On this spot, on the tenth of May, 1933, under the evil spirit of Fascism, the gangsters of the Nazi party burned the noblest works of German and World Literature. 
 &bquo;Let the burning of these books remind us to be everlastingly on our guard against Imperialism and War.&equo; 
 The plaque, and the Platz , always moved Erika. 
 And the scene of the burning of the books, seen on film by her many times, was as vivid as an actual memory: Hitler's jack-booted thugs in their brown shirts, swastikas on their arms, heaving the books from the Library and heaping the heritage of the world on to a pyre, dancing and gloating as the flames consumed book after book, volume after volume: Heine, Schiller, Brecht, Thomas Mann, Einstein, Freud, Marx: history, poetry, novels, science, the works of philosophers, psychologists &mdash; men and women who had dedicated their lives for the betterment of the brutes who burned their books; brutes living in utter ignorance, leading lives as dull and limited as the beasts of the fields, inspired only by resentment, vile prejudice, and blind hatred of what they could not understand, and, it was true, victims themselves of poverty and ignorance seeking victims in their turn &mdash; and finding them. 
 And not only in their books. 
 Erika knew the words of a Protestant pastor, himself tortured and executed by the Gestapo: &bquo;First they came for the Jews &mdash; and we said nothing. 
 Then they came for the Communists &mdash; and we said nothing. 
 Then they came for the Socialists &mdash; and we said nothing. 
 Then they came for the Trades Unionists &mdash; and we said nothing. 
 And then they came for us, and there was no one left to defend us.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Standing in the Platz  in her elegant coat and furs Erika was on the verge of tears: first the books were thrown on to the flames and then, in a terrible and inevitable sequence, human beings were put into the incinerators. 
 And it was an inevitable  sequence. 
 The books were the products of minds, and the minds were the products of brains and bodies, so what more natural than to burn the bodies which produced the minds which produced the books? 
 And all the rest of humanity which offended you, too: Jews, gipsies, the mentally handicapped, Poles, Russians &mdash; the Untermensch  &mdash; &mdash; the subhuman, subhuman because they did not have blue eyes and blond hair, white skin or, that vaguest, and because most vague, most potent of myths, the right blood . 
 As if humanity distinguished between the blood of a Jew, or a Pole, or an African, or an Indian &mdash; or a German. 
 Erika, born after the smoke of the death camps had stopped drifting across Europe, wanted deeply to try and say this to dapper Uncle Karl, born before the smoke fouled the skies. 
 She turned to speak to him, but he was not there. 
 &bquo;Uncle?&equo; 
 She ran past the Library to the corner of Unter den Linden and saw Karl, notable in his elegant overcoat, sauntering down the street. 
 &bquo;Oh dear,&equo; Erika snapped her fingers and caught up with Karl. 
 &bquo;Uncle, I thought that you would like to see the very spot where they burned the books,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Yes, yes.&equo; 
 Karl nodded. 
 &bquo;Terrible. 
 Awful. 
 But I was getting a trifle chilled &mdash; just a trifle, you know, and on this beautiful day &mdash;&equo; he waved a gloved hand at the brilliant sky and the buildings, dazzling in a chiaroscuro of stone and snow, the snow making the grey stone look black, the stone making the snow blindingly pure. 
 &bquo;Yes, such a day, and to stroll along as I did so many times in the old days. 
 How gay it was in spring, under the linden trees: people sauntering, the caf&eacute;s full, everyone enjoying themselves, and to walk it now with &mdash;&equo; he smiled again, an elderly uncle's smile, recalling long lost days, when the linden trees bloomed along the avenue &mdash; &bquo;with a pretty girl. 
 Ah&hellip; what memories among these buildings&hellip;. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Erika's assent was less than whole-hearted, for, although she was proud of the care the State was lavishing on the old buildings, and although, in fact, she preferred this part of the city, she felt it a duty to defend the crude and blatant concrete of the post-war Berlin. 
 &bquo;Nowadays most people go to Alexanderplatz,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;To the new city.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course, of course.&equo; 
 Karl clutched Erika as they negotiated a rather icy patch of pavement. 
 &bquo;But this is  new.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; Erika paused with Karl. 
 &bquo;The Embassy.&equo; 
 &bquo; The Embassy .&equo; 
 Karl, as it were, added the italics as he cast a speculative eye over a huge grey building which loomed over the avenue like a battleship over a flotilla of cargo boats and from which, in the still, clear air, hung a vast flag, red, with a golden hammer and sickle emblazoned on it. 
 Karl looked across the street to where, among the cargo boats, the French and British Embassies hung out their  flags, then looked again at the battleship. 
 &bquo;It is large, isn't it.&equo; 
 Erika had to agree. 
 There was no denying that the Soviet Embassy was large, enormous, one might say, making lilliputian a convoy of Russian lorries parked outside from which, mysteriously, soldiers in olive green and red were taking canteens of food. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Erika said, feeling oddly defensive. 
 &bquo;But of course, the Soviet Union is our best friend.&equo; 
 &bquo;So I understand.&equo; 
 Holding Erika, Karl sauntered past a G.D.R. 
 policeman and looked sideways at the Russian troops. 
 &bquo;Do you know,&equo; he said, &bquo;in all my stay here I have hardly ever seen a Russian soldier.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;The Friends are usually in the countryside. 
 They go to dances and, of course, they join in exercises with our People's Army.&equo; 
 &bquo;How comradely,&equo; Karl said. 
 &bquo;How pleasant, too, dancing with the country girls. 
 So&hellip; unaffected . 
 No wonder you call them Friends. 
 The official title is it not? 
 Yes, I rather like that. 
 And this.&equo; 
 He halted at the corner of Unter den Linden and Grotewohlstrasse. 
 Across the street, beyond a wide stretch of frost-laced gravel, there was a huge triumphal arch on which were four horses driven by a goddess of peace, over whom, in turn, hung two flags, both enormous as if vying with each other and both striped red, orange and black, the far one with those stripes alone, but the near one bearing the wreath, hammer and dividers of the German Democratic Republic, and under it all, cutting the avenue in half, halting it with the abruptness of Finis at the end of a book, and behind a fragile metal fence, snow on its top giving it an odd, festive look, there was a drab grey wall made of concrete blocks. 
 Karl gazed across the street, looking at the arch, and the horses and goddess, and the flags of the two Germanys. 
 &bquo;The Brandenburger Tor,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We call it the Gate of Peace now,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;The Gate of Peace. 
 Karl pressed his hand to his mouth and coughed. 
 &bquo;What a charming name. 
 But the&hellip; the concrete?&equo; 
 &bquo;The Anti-Fascist barrier,&equo; Erika said dutifully. 
 &bquo;It was built to prevent Fascist agents from the West entering the G.D.R. 
 and committing acts of terrorism.&equo; 
 &bquo;A most wise precaution,&equo; Karl said. 
 &bquo;The Anti-Fascist Barrier. 
 And to think that in the West they merely call it the Wall. 
 But I see that we can go a little nearer.&equo; 
 Looking carefully both ways, he led Erika across the road, on to the gravel plaza, and peered through the metal fence. 
 &bquo;The Anti-Fascist Barrier. 
 How insignificant it looks, but what a bold conception. 
 Really, quite a stroke of genius. 
 But, Erika,&equo; he lowered his voice a little. 
 &bquo;These people &mdash;&equo; he gestured to a group of men and women, posing in three lines, the front row kneeling, the tallest at the back, all beaming as a photographer stepped back in order to get their picture with The Wall in a clear focus. 
 &bquo;Who are they?&equo; 
 Not for the first time that morning Erika felt slightly uncomfortable. 
 &bquo;They are tourists,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Tourists?&equo; 
 Karl raised his eyebrows. 
 &bquo;Friends,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;Russians.&equo; 
 &bquo;And so they are! 
 So they are!&equo; 
 Unnervingly Karl burst into a high-pitched hyena-like laugh. 
 His shoulders shook underneath his beautiful overcoat. 
 &bquo;Ha! ha! ha! hee! hee! hee! 
 Oh dear! 
 Oh dear me!&equo; 
 He dabbed his eyes with his immaculate handkerchief. 
 &bquo;Forgive me.&equo; 
 He exploded with laughter again. 
 &bquo;Hee! hee! hee! 
 How Adolf would have relished this.&equo; 
 &bquo;Adolf?&equo; 
 Erika turned and stared at Karl's face, crimson with laughter, horror dawning in her violet eyes. 
 Karl stopped laughing as suddenly as he had begun, his face grave and concerned and kindly. 
 &bquo;Excuse me, my Dear, laughing so. 
 Most undignified in an old man.&equo; 
 He poked his head forward, like a tortoise coming out from its shell. 
 &bquo;You look quite shocked, Erika.&equo; 
 Instinctively Erika recoiled. 
 &bquo;Adolf,&equo; she whispered. 
 &bquo;Ah!&equo; 
 Understanding dawned on Karl's face. 
 &bquo;I think I understand. 
 But I was thinking, looking at them &mdash;&equo; he gestured towards the tourists &mdash; &bquo;seeing them in a group, it reminded me of a time in cadet school. 
 We had a group photograph with a long time-exposure and a friend of mine, a dear friend, ran from one end of the back line to the other and had his picture twice on the same photograph. 
 He was called Adolf. 
 Adolf von Seydlitz.&equo; 
 Relief flooded through Erika, and showed in her face. 
 &bquo;But of course!&equo; 
 Karl slapped his side. 
 &bquo;Of course, of course! 
 Adolf means only one person to you. 
 But remember, before that terrible man Adolf was an honoured name in Germany.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, Uncle Karl.&equo; 
 Erika was contrite. 
 &bquo;There, there.&equo; 
 Karl patted her arm, making Erika feel that she was deeply in the wrong but was being forgiven. 
 &bquo;A little mistake on your part, but we will forget it. 
 These misunderstandings do take place, the generation gap, as they say over there.&equo; 
 He gestured to where the flag of the other Germany hung over the old Tiergarten . 
 Erika smiled, pleased that the little cloud had passed over. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry.&equo; 
 And, receiving another encouraging nod from Karl pulled out her list. 
 &bquo;So, where would you like to go now? 
 Omi thought that you might like to see the old Adlon. 
 It isn't far &mdash;&equo; 
 Karl shook his head. 
 &bquo;Just between ourselves, I have been there!&equo; 
 His eyes twinkled. 
 &bquo;Just for old times' sake I went, not that there is much to see! 
 But I rather thought, you know, if you wouldn't mind, we might go to Treptower Park.&equo; 
 &bquo;Treptow?&equo; 
 Erika was startled. 
 &bquo;You mean the Pleasure Park?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Karl shook his head, amused. 
 &bquo;I'm a little too old for pleasure parks. 
 I thought we might go to the War Memorial.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Soviet War Memorial?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Karl said. 
 &bquo;I've heard about it but it is one of the sights my hosts haven't shown me. 
 Shall we go?&equo; 
 &bquo;If you want.&equo; 
 Erika agreed but was somewhat dubious. 
 &bquo;It's rather a long way, though. 
 We would have to go to Alexanderplatz and get the S-Bahn &hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;That won't be necessary,&equo; Karl said. 
 &bquo;I have a car!&equo; 
 He glanced at the watch Bodo admired so much. 
 &bquo;And if the man is punctual he should be here &mdash; now! 
 And so he is.&equo; 
 He pointed across the street to where a long, black, polished car had pulled up. 
 &bquo;Good German efficiency,&equo; Karl said, as they crossed the street and climbed into the back of the car. 
 Karl leaned forward and spoke to the driver. 
 &bquo;You have the map?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; The driver flourished a street plan, with a route marked in red. 
 &bquo;Good.&equo; 
 Karl settled back. 
 &bquo;Go.&equo; 
 With what to Erika, used to the erratic behaviour of the old Lada, was miraculous smoothness, the driver let in the gears and drove down Grotewohlstrasse but instead of turning left at Leipziger Strasse, carried on into a warren of tiny streets. 
 Determined to be her Uncle's guide Erika said, &bquo;I think that we are going the wrong way, Uncle. 
 There are only factories down here.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know, my Dear,&equo; lolling back in the car Karl nodded lazily. 
 &bquo;But you must remember that I am  an industrialist and, really, factories are as interesting to me as museums, ha! ha!&equo; 
 The car zigzagged through the streets. 
 Karl, his head turned steadily to his right, peered intently at the run-down flats and battered buildings and factories lining small side-streets, each and every one of which ended in that apparently insignificant, almost unobtrusive wall of grey concrete blocks. 
 As they crossed the broad reach of the Spree at Elsenstrasse, where tugs were crunching through the ice, Erika pointed out what sights there were to see but Karl merely gave a perfunctory nod and returned to his absorbed stare through his window. 
 They drove past the big Siemens factory, plastered with huge portraits of Marx and Lenin, on to the broad, tree-lined avenue of Am Treptower Park, swung into a car-park, and stopped. 
 &bquo;Treptow,&equo; the driver grunted. 
 Erika and Karl got out of the warmth of the car into a crystalline coldness, walked up an avenue lined with bare trees and came to an enclosed garden. 
 In its middle was a statue of a weeping woman holding her slain son. 
 The Motherland mourning her dead, Erika murmured. 
 &bquo;The Motherland?&equo; 
 Karl queried. 
 For a moment Erika was puzzled by the query, then she understood. 
 Karl would still think of Germany as the Fatherland. 
 &bquo;It means the Soviet  Motherland. 
 Of course there is a memorial to the German victims of Fascism and militarism. 
 It is on Unter den Linden and &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;I've seen it.&equo; 
 Karl almost jerked the words out. 
 He turned his head and walked towards a flight of shallow steps above which jutted two triangles of red granite. 
 &bquo;Red flags dipped in mourning,&equo; Erika said. 
 Karl nodded and began to walk slowly up the steps, Erika by his side, moving at a funereal pace. 
 Step by step they climbed, and as they ascended, black against the dazzling blue sky and glazed under a shroud of ice, a vast figure began to loom: a helmeted head, a flowing cape, a sword in one hand and a child in the other, and beneath its booted feet, visible as Erika and Karl reached the top of the stairs, a broken swastika, and bearing the whole gigantic figure, a grassy mound. 
 Between Erika and Karl, standing at the top of the steps, and the statue there was a sunken garden, its sides punctuated by slabs of concrete. 
 It was quiet, hushed almost. 
 No one else was in the garden and dense rows of leafless poplars damped the grinding roar of the lorries on Am Treptower Park. 
 &bquo;And this is it?&equo; 
 Karl said. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Erika pointed to the looming statue. 
 &bquo;That is a Soviet infantryman of the Red Army.&equo; 
 Karl peered bleakly forward. 
 The corners of his mouth were dragged down and his plump cheeks looked shrunken, like withered apples. 
 He looked very old. 
 &bquo;I know the shape,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; Erika thought. 
 Having spent years fighting them, Karl would recognise a Russian soldier. 
 &bquo;How tactless of me,&equo; she said to herself, and to cover up the awkwardness she felt she pointed at the statue. 
 &bquo;The soldier is carrying a German child rescued from Fascism,&equo; she said, &bquo;and the swastika&hellip;.&equo; 
 But that hardly needed explaining. 
 &bquo;Would you like to go down and look at the inscriptions on the slabs?&equo; 
 For a long, long moment Karl hesitated then, with a curious shrug of his shoulders, he said, &bquo;Yes. 
 By all means let us see the inscriptions.&equo; 
 They went down the steps and walked slowly around the garden. 
 The inscriptions in German and Russian were cut into the concrete blocks, each of which carried a bold, crude, but appropriate carving. 
 &bquo;These represent the glorious struggle of the Soviet Union in the fight against Fascism,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;So I observe.&equo; 
 Karl paused at the first block and then started back, looking truly astonished. 
 &bquo;These words are by Stalin! 
 Josef Stalin!&equo; 
 He cackled mirthlessly. 
 &bquo;My God in His Heaven! 
 Josef Stalin!&equo; 
 He shook his head in wonderment. 
 &bquo;This must be the last place on earth where his words are public &mdash; except Albania.&equo; 
 For a reason not quite clear to her, Erika felt embarrassed, as if there were an irony in Karl's words, especially the reference to Albania, which she felt she was not clever enough to understand. 
 &bquo;I can't really say about that,&equo; she said, &bquo;but &mdash;&equo; launching into a text learned by heart &mdash; &bquo;although guilty of many deviations from Marxism-Leninism and Socialist legality, Stalin did lead the heroic resistance of the Soviet peoples in the anti-Fascist war.&equo; 
 They sauntered on, Erika conscientiously describing each slab as they reached it: &bquo;Tribute to the glorious soldiers of the Red Army&hellip;. 
 Tribute to the glorious airmen of the Red Air Force&hellip;. 
 Tribute to the glorious peasants of the Soviet Union&hellip;.&equo; her voice clear in the silent garden as the enormous statue loomed over them. 
 At the foot of the mound they halted and peered up at the statue, eerie under its glaze of ice, which stared sightlessly far above their heads. 
 A flight of steps led up the mound to the base of the figure. 
 &bquo;We could go up,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;There is a room inside.&equo; 
 &bquo;And what is inside the room?&equo; 
 Karl asked. 
 &bquo;Well&hellip; nothing really,&equo; Erika confessed. 
 &bquo;It is a dome. 
 With mosaics.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mosaics. 
 How very Eastern,&equo; Karl said. 
 &bquo;This mound is a mausoleum,&equo; Erika said. 
 &bquo;5,000 soldiers of the Red Army are buried under it. 
 Killed in the Battle for Berlin.&equo; 
 &bquo;5,000?&equo; 
 Karl pursed his lips. 
 &bquo;They lost more than that, 100,000, more like. 
 Berlin did not fall so easily.&equo; 
 There was an edge to his voice, of defiance, almost. 
 &bquo;I suppose so,&equo; Erika said, a little lamely. 
 &bquo;There are other cemeteries.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Karl turned and walked back along the other side of the garden, although this time Erika did not draw his attention to the words of Josef Stalin paying tribute to glorious workers, doctors, nurses, and so on. 
 They re-climbed the steps to the granite flags and there Karl turned and looked again at the statue, his face still sunken and sour. 
 Rather timidly, and feeling that somehow she had let her uncle down, Erika touched Karl's arm. 
 &bquo;Don't you like it?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Like it?&equo; 
 Something which might &mdash; or might not &mdash; have been a smile, touched Karl's lips. 
 &bquo;Let me put it this way, child. 
 It is&hellip; inspiring.&equo; 
 &bquo;Really?&equo; 
 Erika glowed with pleasure. 
 &bquo;Yes, really. 
 That is exactly the right word. 
 This &mdash;&equo; he waved his hand &mdash; &bquo;this has given me true inspiration. 
 Now, come.&equo; 
 They took a pace or two and then, suddenly, Karl turned back and spat a couple of words. 
 &bquo;I beg your pardon?&equo; 
 Erika, a pace ahead, turned, too. 
 &bquo;Nothing. 
 Nothing at all.&equo; 
 Karl said sharply and then, with something of a return to his jolly, Uncle Karl manner, he said, thoughtfully, &bquo;Have you noticed, there are no birds here. 
 None at all.&equo; 
 REDEMPTION BY PARRICIDE 1925&ndash;1929 
 In 1793, the Fellows of Magdalen College, Oxford, erected a large building of simple classical design on the edge of their deer park. 
 To distinguish it from the medieval part of the college which hugs the splendid fifteenth-century cloisters, they called it New Buildings. 
 By 1925, New Buildings had begun to look old and stately. 
 Built from soft Headington stone, and blackened by the soot from college chimneys, it had something of the crumbly, grand appearance of a country house in Ireland. 
 In front of the building was a neatly made formal garden. 
 Behind and all around it was a richly planted park, in which deer grazed. 
 Beyond it, to the east, was a meadow, thick with fritillaries in spring and surrounded by a wooded path, known (after the essayist and moralist who was a fellow of the College in the early eighteenth century) as Addison's Walk. 
 There can be few more beautiful places in Europe. 
 C. S. Lewis was given rooms in New Buildings and moved in shortly after the end of the summer term, 1925. 
 He had expected to be given the rooms furnished by the College. 
 He had no money in his bank account, and when he gazed about at the huge drawing-room, smaller inner drawing-room and large bedroom, he had no idea how he was to find the money to buy the barest essentials &mdash; a few chairs, a table, a bed. 
 All that met his eye was the linoleum on the floor which the College bursar, in a spirit of generosity, said that he could keep. 
 The bed was necessary, because Lewis intended to sleep in the College, at least during the week in term-time. 
 Why not? 
 He was a bachelor, and this was certainly expected of him by his colleagues. 
 The modern habit of Oxford dons' merely coming into their colleges to teach, and perhaps lunch, before cycling or driving home to their wives and children had not caught on. 
 Most fellows would have dined in college on most nights, whether they were married or not; and the huge majority were still bachelors for whom the celibate life was the norm. 
 Lewis was now twenty-seven years old. 
 Mrs Moore was fifty-three. 
 Maureen Moore was nineteen, and when she had finished her qualifications she would become a music teacher. 
 There was no question of Lewis abandoning the Moores, but the body does not always believe the evidence of its senses; and from this time onwards Minto (as Lewis had begun to call Janie, after a variety of sweet to which she was devoted) began to develop a series of psychosomatic conditions which strengthened the ties binding him to her side. 
 A holiday on Exmoor in the course of that summer was dogged by her rheumatism. 
 If it kept her awake all night, then it was only right that she should wake up Jack for fresh hot-water bottles to be applied to the afflicted areas. 
 They consulted a doctor who told them that there was very little that could be done for a rheumatic attack. 
 Yet those are mistaken who imagine (as, for example, Warnie did) that Mrs Moore was nothing but a distraction from the serious business of work. 
 For one thing, although she was  a distraction, she did try not to be. 
 She honestly believed that she was making life easier for Jack, by providing him with a background of home, where not only were meals provided and clothes mended, but his time was also jealously guarded. 
 She made a point of ensuring that others did not disturb him when he was at his books, even though it was not always a rule that she was able to keep herself. 
 I don't think I ever saw J&lsqb;ack&rsqb; work more than half an hour without the cry of &bquo;Barboys!&equo; &mdash; &bquo;Coming, dear!&equo;, down would go the pen, and he would be away perhaps five minutes, perhaps half an hour; possibly to do nothing more important than stand by the kitchen range as scullery maid. 
 Then another spell of work, then the same all over again. 
 And these were the conditions under which Screwtape  and indeed all his books were produced. 
 How, it may be asked, could any serious work be done in those circumstances? 
 The answer is that in the years when Minto was in her fall vigour, Lewis's flow of words was limited. 
 A glance at the shelf containing his long list of books shows us immediately that the bulk of his work was completed when Minto was in her dotage or after she died. 
 He was a fluent and rapid prose writer. 
 But his first major prose work &mdash; The Allegory of Love &mdash;  took about eight years to complete. 
 This was the price he paid far having thrown in his lot with a person who with all her virtues &mdash; generosity, warmth of character, genuine and passionate admiration, as well as love, for Lewis himself &mdash; did not have the concept of a working day. 
 She belonged to that great majority of intelligent human beings who think of a book as something with which to beguile the hours of solitude of an evening. 
 After years of living with Lewis she still knew but did not know that &bquo;a man&equo; could regard reading as the main business of the day and everything else as an interruption. 
 On the other hand, if Lewis had been allowed to live in this way, though we might have had a few more mighty works of literary history from his pen, it is doubtful whether he would have written the works for which he is more popular. 
 He is the great chronicler of the minor domestic irritation, of the annoying little trait bulking to (literally) hellish proportions. 
 Domestic life with his father had been the training-school for this distinctively Lewisian vision. 
 Minto not only provided him with plenty of Screwtape-  style domestic situations. 
 She also had a rich enjoyment of the comedy of human character, which was one of the things she shared with Lewis. 
 For example, at the next table at the Exmoor Forest Hotel, he had overheard two people talking to each other, a &bquo;very well bred looking old man with a dry peevish voice whom I took to be mentally deranged and a woman who was either his daughter or his nurse&equo;. 
 Lewis took the trouble to transcribe what he remembered of their conversation: 
 HE: Look at this ham. 
 It's all cut in chunks. 
 SHE: Oh, do be quiet. 
 HE: Anyone would think they were cutting it for coal-heavers (pause) or stonebreakers. 
 It's&hellip; it's&hellip; wasteful you know, so wasteful. 
 SHE: Well, you needn't worry about that, need you. 
 HE(savagely): Look at that. 
 It's abominable. 
 SHE: Oh do be quiet. 
 Get on with your lunch. 
 I want to go out. 
 HE: What's it like out? 
 SHE: It's lovely. 
 HE: Oh yes, I know it s lovely. 
 What I want to know is, is it cold or hot? 
 SHE: It was cold when I first went out, but &mdash; HE(interrupting): There you are, cold. 
 I knew it was cold. 
 SHE: I was going to say, if you'd let me, that it was very hot before I got back. 
 HE (after a pause): Look at that. 
 It's really disgraceful to cut ham like that. 
 It was a nice ham too. 
 Well smoked, well cured and good fibre. 
 And they go and spoil it all by cutting it in chunks. 
 Chunks. 
 Just look at that (stabbing a piece and holding it up in mid-air). 
 SHE: Oh, do get on. 
 HE: (Something inaudible) SHE: Well they've as much right here as we have. 
 Why can't you get on and eat your lunch? 
 HE: I'm not going to be hustled over my lunch. 
 Hustled. 
 I won't let you hustle me in this way. 
 (A pause.) 
 Why don't you ask Mrs Ellworthy to let you make some of that nice porridge of yours. 
 SHE: How could I in a hotel? 
 (They had a long argument over this.) 
 Then HE (almost pathetically): Why don't you eat some of this salad? 
 It's beautifully flavoured (here his voice broke and he added almost in a whisper) &mdash; with CUCUMBER. 
 If it wasn't far the ham&hellip; 
 And so they went on. 
 The impulse which made Lewis transcribe the dialogue at such length was something which could have been directed into comic fiction. 
 It was the side of Lewis which reflected his father's love of &bquo;wheezes&equo;. 
 Albert's love of recording the essential transitoriness of irritation, mere human annoyingness, gives an almost stream-of-consciousness effect in the Lewis Papers . 
 &bquo;Sunday, August 10, 1913: I wish this awful man would not come into our house&equo; is a fairly typical entry, transcribed from Albert's pocket diary. 
 Obviously in the presence of some prize bore, Albert had scribbled this down and shoved the book across the table to Warnie or Jack. 
 Everyone in the world has had such thoughts. 
 The distinctive Lewisian thing was to have written them down. 
 In Albert's &bquo;wheezes&equo;, human beings are often behaving foolishly, but they are observed with some warmth. 
 In Jack's transcriptions of such experiences, the vision of humanity is bleaker. 
 Already, before he has found a theological universe in which to create them, they have the feeling of lost souls, fodder for hell. 
 I suspect that Mrs Moore's sense of humour contributed much to the genuine streak of misanthropy in Lewis's nature. 
 In spite of this, his animus against his father was already diminishing. 
 At the end of the vacation &mdash; in the last two weeks of September &mdash; he returned to Ulster, and Albert gratefully recorded, jacks returned. 
 A fortnight and a few days with me. 
 Very pleasant. 
 Not a cloud. 
 Went to the Boat with him. 
 The first time I did not pay his passage money. 
 I offered, but he did not want it.&equo; 
 Jack Lewis was about to embark on his professional career as a college tutor at Magdalen; and since not everyone is familiar with the way Oxford functions, it might be worth explaining exactly what his work was going to entail. 
 He did not need Albert to pay his fare on the Irish packet for, at last, he was an independent man, earning his own living. 
 As a Fellow of Magdalen he earned &pound;500 a year, considerably more than his father's allowance of &pound;210. 
 Lewis was about to embark on a three-stranded career. 
 He would be a university lecturer, responsible far lecturing perhaps once a week; a Fellow of Magdalen, involved in the administration of the College; and, perhaps most importantly, a college tutor. 
 He was responsible for all those men at Magdalen who were reading English. 
 He had to prepare them for the study of Old English (Anglo-Saxon), Middle English (that is, the language and literature of England from about 1200 until 1450, including Chaucer) and all the remaining periods of English literature up to the Victorian period. 
 He was also responsible for instructing his pupils in the History of the English Language and in philology (the growth, history and structure of words). 
 Some of this teaching could be done in classes &mdash; the routine language work, for example. 
 But the bulk of it was done by way of the tutorial, a weekly session in which the pupil read aloud an essay of some three thousand words to his tutor and they then discussed it. 
 This is the distinctive method of instruction at Oxford, and it is extremely prodigal of time. 
 If, say, on Wordswoth, he would, instead of having one hour in which they all discussed Wordswoth together, have seven hours in which they all discussed Wordswoth separately. 
 This method of teaching, though daunting at first far the pupil, is a formative experience, the aspect of the course to which most Oxford graduates look back with most gratitude. 
 It is not an hour in which a pupil sits learning what the tutor has to teach. 
 It is, or should be, an hour in which the pupil gradually comes to learn to defend himself or herself in argument, to have confidence in his or her own prose style, to grow up intellectually. 
 But it has a strange effect on the tutor. 
 For the pupils (to keep to the same example), it is one gloriously stimulating hour in which they have the chance to pour out all that they have felt and discovered about The Prelude . 
 Very few people, at nineteen or twenty, have the humility or cynicism to realize that their thoughts on any particular book will coincide with eerie exactitude to everyone else's. 
 For the tutor it is the seventh conversation about The Prelude  he or she has had that week. 
 After only a very few years of teaching it becomes the twenty-first or the forty-ninth. 
 It is small wonder that many dons (as teachers at Oxford are called; a shortening of Latin dominus)  develop a kind of crust, a persona, a &bquo;character&equo; to help them through these increasingly one-sided experiences. 
 &bquo;O brave new world that has such people in it,&equo; says Miranda; to which donnish Prospero replies, &bquo;is new to thee.&equo; 
 The good Oxford tutor never forgets that &bquo;tis new to thee.&equo; 
 But in order not to forget it, an element of artifice, of manner, is essential from the start. 
 The younger the tutor, the more this manner will be felt necessary as a defence. 
 This is not to say that a don must affect mannerisms or artificial eccentricities as a way of keeping his distance from the pupil &mdash; though many have done this. 
 It is more an inevitable consequence of two people (particularity people of a similar age) finding themselves sitting together week after week in a setting which, socially speaking, is hard to define. 
 In Lewis's day, some formality was added to the proceedings by the undergraduate's wearing a gown. 
 Nevertheless, as they both sat in upholstered armchairs or a sofa in front of a fire, mere was something domestic about it. 
 &bquo;I'm not your schoolmaster, &bquo;Lewis once crossly remarked to a pupil. 
 Nor quite, though, is the pupil considered the tutor's equal. 
 Again, in Lewis's day the relationship would have begun with the pupil calling his tutor &bquo;Sir&equo; and the tutor calling his pupil by his surname. 
 Later, when they came to know each other better, the pupil might graduate to calling him &bquo;Lewis&equo;, but this would be in the case of intimates. 
 There is  something curiously intimate about the tutorial &mdash; about meeting regularly &agrave; deux  to have conversations of a depth and intellectual intensity which will probably never be repeated in the pupil's life. 
 Yet where the two do not like one another or the chemistry is wrong, the relationship will remain distant for the entire three years. 
 From the beginning, Lewis was a conscientious tutor who tried to keep the balance right between amiability or conviviality (not always possible between incompatible types) and his duty to the pupils to give them sufficient preparation for their examinations. 
 Since he was also responsible for teaching a weekly class of seven young women at Lady Margaret Hall (a women's college in North Oxford) and for teaching philosophy to the undergraduates of Magdalen, his first few years at the College were strenuous. 
 English, as a subject, had evolved cautiously, and at Oxford, far many years, it was on the defensive. 
 First, it was on the defensive against the Germans. 
 It was they, shamingly, who had led the great discovery of old Germanic literature, which included the Old English texts Beowulf The Wanderer, The Seafarer  and the great rhythmical prose-sermons of Aelfric and Wulfstan. 
 English scholars, all classicists or ex-classicists, hurried to catch up and prove themselves the equals of the Germans in philological and textual skill. 
 Then again, English at Oxford was on the defensive against the other faculties. 
 Was English a &bquo;proper subject&equo; such as Law or Greek? 
 Since any well-educated person had read The Rape of the Lock  or Paradise Lost , how could English justify itself as an academic discipline? 
 The answer was that it would make the study of literature highly historical and linguistic. 
 In order to do well at English at Oxford, you would have to show more than a purely aesthetic aptitude. 
 You would need to have a sound grasp of English history before you began; and you would need, at every point, to relate your study of the literature of any given period to the state and development of the language. 
 In the earliest stages, this required a fall working knowledge of the processes of Germanic philology and the history of sound-change, a branch of study which is extremely difficult to master. 
 It calls on the speculative ability of a scientist (for the so-called laws of sound-change such as Grimm's Law and Verner's Law are, like scientific laws, working hypotheses about the development of sound); it also requires a workable memory and a simple ability to reason, to see logical consequences, an ability not always found among students of literature. 
 Lewis worked extremely hard at preparing this part of the course for his pupils. 
 Needless to say, it was the part which most of them hated; they were longing to get it finished so that they could write their essays on Hamlet  or Keats. 
 Without a knowledge of what was happening to Germanic diphthongs and vowels in the Dark Ages, however, even a clever pupil at Oxford in those days would have done badly. 
 Lewis organized &bquo;Beer and Beowulf&equo; evenings for his pupils, during which he taught them to chant mnemonics to master the processes of sound-change: 
 Thus &AElig; to &Ecaron; they soon were fetchin' Cf. such forms as &THORN;&AElig;C and &THORN;ECCEAN. 
 There is a kind of innocence about this which makes the modern reader, coming upon it all sixty years after the event, squirm with embarrassment. 
 The bluffness of Lewis, which before he became a don was only part of his nature ('Heavy Lewis'), was fast hardening into a persona. 
 The more arty and airy-fairy his pupils, the bluffer and beerier and louder he became. 
 Magdalen, which had been Oscar Wilde's college, always attracted a fair number of rarefied and aesthetic young men, and it was on to the path of this tradition that one of Lewis's first pupils, John Betjeman, happily placed his bedroom-slippered toe. 
 Betjeman appeared in a pair of eccentric bedroom slippers and said he hoped I didn't mind them as he had a blister. 
 He seemed so pleased with himself that I couldn't help saying that I should mind them very much myself but that I had no objection to his  wearing them &mdash; a view which I believed surprised him. 
 Betjeman liked teasing Lewis. 
 He opted to be taught medieval Welsh as a special subject. 
 He was perfectly entitled to do this by the statutes of the English Faculty; but there being, at that date, no one in Oxford who could teach it, Lewis had to organize a tutor from Aberystwyth to be brought to Oxford once a week by train. 
 Sometimes Betjeman surprised Lewis by producing &bquo;a very creditable essay&equo;. 
 But for the most part he was, in Lewis's eyes, an &bquo;idle prig&equo; who wasted his time cultivating well-born families and pretty boys and visiting exotic churches. 
 On one occasion when he had failed to produce an essay for the third week running, Betjeman wandered sheepishly into Lewis's room and threw himself on his knees by the hearth. 
 &bquo;What is the matter, Betjeman?&equo; asked Lewis. 
 &bquo;I'm hopeless. 
 I've failed to produce an essay yet again. 
 I shall be a failure, I shall have to take Holy Orders, but you see, I'm in such an agony of doubt, I can't decide.&equo; 
 &bquo;What can't you decide, Betjeman?&equo; 
 &bquo;Whether to be a very High Church clergyman with a short lacy surplice, or a very Low Church clergyman with long grey moustaches.&equo; 
 Lewis treasured this conversation in after years, but at the time he found it disconcerting and annoying. 
 He bullied Betjeman. 
 &bquo;You've got no style, Betjeman,&equo; he used to taunt the younger man. 
 &bquo;Why can't you go away and get some style?&equo; 
 Betjeman asked Lewis to a number of his parties, and Lewis found their High Church pansyism fairly difficult to stomach. 
 He saw Betjeman's qualities. 
 It may even have been &mdash; for he was quick to spot poetic talent &mdash; that he could see where Betjeman's true genius lay. 
 If so, it would only have increased his feeling of vulnerability and awkwardness for, until he had come to recognize that he was not going to be the greatest poet of the age after Yeats, Lewis was always hostile to poets. 
 Betjeman introduced Louis MacNeice to him with the words &bquo;He doesn't say much, but he's a great poet.&equo; 
 It prompted in Lewis the immediate feeling that MacNeice was &bquo;absolutely silent and astonishingly ugly&equo;. 
 He had a rooted antipathy to T. S. Eliot which, even after they had both become famous as defenders of the faith and brothers in Christ, was still hard to shake off. 
 When Betjeman failed his Divinity exams at the end of his first year, it would have been open to his tutor to plead for him with the College so that he could resit these comparatively unimportant exams and stay on at the University. 
 Lewis let Betjeman sink. 
 Betjeman recalled the moment in his autobiographical poem, Summoned by Bells : 
 I sought my tutor in his arid rooms, Who told me, &bquo;You'd have only got a third.&equo; 
 Betjeman always loathed Lewis thereafter, though as they got older they both tried to make a bit of a joke about it. 
 In the spring of 1926, Lewis's own secret career as a poet took a great stride forward as he completed his long narrative poem Dymer . 
 He had been working on it ever since the end of the war, and showing it in whole or in part to his friends. 
 Harwood, when he had read Canto II, had &bquo;danced for joy&equo;, and Barfield had a very high opinion of the work. 
 Reading Dymer  today, it is hard to see why. 
 It reads like Masefield on a very bad day; and one uses the word &bquo;reads&equo; with caution, since few people in recent times, except Lewis enthusiasts anxious to have read their way through the entire canon, can ever have bothered to press on with Dymer . 
 He had been meditating on the parricidal theme which runs through Dymer  since he was a pupil of Kirkpatrick's. 
 Versions of it in prose and rhyme had been written up while he was still at Gastons. 
 After meeting Mrs Moore, the theme of a powerful female entered the story &mdash; 
 Always the same&hellip; that frightful woman shape Besets the dream-way and the soul's escape. 
 The tale concerns a young man &mdash; Dymer &mdash; who escapes from a city &mdash; the Perfect City &mdash; which is a cross between Plato's Republic and an English public school, and becomes entangled with a hag-like older woman. 
 She seems gay at first but she is quickly transformed, after a short lovemaking, into a Spenserian crone. 
 From the ecstatic moment when 
 He opened wide His arms &mdash; the breathy body of a girl Slid into them he is penitent. 
 He thinks that if he is only slavish enough in his service of the old hag, the beautiful girl to whom he once made love will come back to him: 
 I would be content To drudge in earth, easing my heart's disgrace&hellip; 
 If at the year's end I saw her face somewhere. 
 But he never finds her again, and is imprisoned in his strange mixture of tormented lust and repentance. 
 The fruit of this mysterious union, into which Dymer has drifted, is a monster. 
 In the latter part of the story, the monster and Dymer are involved in an Oedipal struggle, and the father is killed. 
 By then the &bquo;monster&equo; has gone through many transformations, unable to decide who he is or which of his many disguises represents the true &bquo;him&equo;; but he can only find liberty by killing the father who sired him. 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; Lewis insisted, &bquo;I'm not Dymer.&equo; 
 Of course not. 
 What troubles the admirer of Lewis the critic &mdash; the man who had such an eye for excellence in the poets of past ages &mdash; is that he could be capable of stanza after stanza in which the verse is deadened by flat language, repeated clumsy enjambments and sheer technical incompetence. 
 Much of it just fails to scan correctly &mdash; very odd for someone who was lecturing and giving tutorials on English poetry. 
 In February 1926, Lewis plucked up courage and showed the poem to his colleague in the English Faculty, Nevill Coghill. 
 He begged Coghill to keep the matter to himself. 
 &bquo;I don't want it known here &lsqb;i.e. at Magdalen&rsqb; that I am writing &bquo;pomes&equo; &lsqb;sic&rsqb;.&equo; 
 Coghill felt that he had discovered a &bquo;considerable poem&equo; by &bquo;a powerful new poet&equo; (though &bquo;in the Masefield tradition&equo;), and he wrote back to Lewis in adulatory terms. 
 Lewis felt &bquo;as if you had given me a bottle of champagne&hellip; 
 Your remarks on the Masefieldian lines go to the root of the matter &mdash; I should say the bad  Masefieldian lines for in some points one would not in the least be ashamed to have learned from him&hellip; 
 &equo; Lewis was especially grateful that Coghill was so appreciative of Dymer's &bquo;spiritual experiences&equo;; and in particular that he approved of the theme of &bquo;redemption by parricide&equo; which Lewis feared &bquo;would seem simply preposterous and shocking&equo;. 
 Coghill did more than heap praises on Dymer . 
 He found a publisher for it. 
 When 
 Guy Pocock of Dent read the poem, he felt &bquo;there can be no possible question of its greatness&hellip; 
 I have not read any new poetry to touch it since the publication of The Everlasting Mercy  &lsqb;by John masefield&rsqb;.&equo; 
 When the book did appear, in beautiful, almost square duodecimo format, it was adorned with a naked figure, the hero, embossed on the end board. 
 We stretches up beyond the sun. 
 He is there again in the frontispiece, like a figure in the Tarot cards, breaking his chains and dancing towards the spheres. 
 Behind him, a winged, helmeted figure leans on a cruciform, phallic-looking sword. 
 It takes a little while for an author to realize that his book has been a complete failure. 
 He waits and waits. 
 Lewis anxiously opened The Times Literary Supplement  every Friday for a year, hoping far a good notice for the poem. 
 A favourable review did appear, but not until a year later. 
 By then, the poem had sunk from public consciousness. 
 It did not sell, and it made almost no impact whatsoever. 
 It is striking that Lewis did not want it known in College that he wrote &bquo;pomes&equo;, but only natural that he should have looked outside Magdalen for soulmates within his own Faculty. 
 It is the least satisfactory feature of collegiate universities that for all social and administrative purposes &mdash; meals and meetings and life in Common Room &mdash; the academics minx not with those who share their intellectual preoccupations but with people of completely different disciplines. 
 In an ideal world this would mean that a lot of clever people, all anxious to communicate enthusiasm for their subject, would talk helpfully about it to their colleagues. 
 In a rosy paragraph of Surprised by Joy  Lewis paid tribute to 
 Five great Magdalen men who enlarged my very idea of what a learned life should be &mdash; P. V. M. Benecke, C. C. J. Webb, J. A. Smith, F. E. Brightman and C. T. Onions&hellip; 
 In my earliest years at Magdalen I inhabited a world where hardly anything I wanted to know needed to be found out by my own unaided efforts. 
 One or other of these could always give you a clue. 
 ('You'll find something about it in Alanus.&equo; 
 &bquo;Macrobius would be the man to try &bquo;etc) This is certainly how dons talk in the novels of Dorothy L. Sayers. 
 Whether they did so at Magdalen in the years 1925&ndash;1929 there are few alive old enough to remember. 
 The key phrase in Lewis's paragraph here is &bquo;my earliest years&equo;. 
 He writes from the perspective of later years when the dons of Magdalen were anything but congenial society to him. 
 Even in those early years, when honest old men were tossing out such useful snippets of information as &bquo;Macrobius would be the man&equo;, the college did not provide soulmates of the kind Lewis always craved. 
 Coghill, who had been a friend since they read English together as undergraduates in 1923, was now the English tutor at Exeter College. 
 He probably remained Lewis's best friend in the English Faculty during the early years at Magdalen. 
 The Faculty in those days was comparatively small, and still dominated by old men who were primarily literary historians. 
 Criticism of the kind which became popular with the pupils of I. A. Richards at Cambridge later in the century was absolutely unknown at Oxford. 
 Reading English was really a literary way of reading History. 
 The sort of scholarship which predominated was textual scholarship, as exemplified by Percy Simpson's monumental edition of Ben Jonson. 
 But there was a new broom coming into the English Faculty at this period and, although younger than Simpson, Wilson, Garrod and the rest, he appeared to be more radically reactionary. 
 This was the Rawlinson and Bosworth Professor of Anglo-Saxon, who had been appointed to his chair at the age of thirty-two, in the same year that Lewis got his fellowship at Magdalen. 
 His name was J. R. R. Tolkien. 
 It was another medievalist, under Tolkien's influence, who gave utterance to the view that &bquo;Literature stops in 1100; after that there's only books,&equo; but they were sentiments which in a crude way echoed Tolkien's own position. 
 A graduate of Exeter College, Oxford, Tolkien had read Classical Mods and then done a version of the English course which was rigidly philological, and did not concern itself with post-medieval literature. 
 Much more important than this was Tolkien's vast imaginative life, one day to make him famous as author of The Lord of the Rings , but at this date completely hidden from all but his family and close friends. 
 True, Tolkien's favourite books were the old books &mdash; in English, the Anglo-Saxon poets; in Icelandic, those of the Elder Edda; in Celtic, the old Welsh Triads and the Irish was by far the most distinguished scholar in his field of Old and Middle English, his interest in it all was very far from being &bquo;purely academic&equo;. 
 It was as though an extraordinary story &mdash; a great mythology, with half-forgotten legends, languages and lore &mdash; had been unfolding in his head from the time he began to think; and his appreciation of the Old Literature was at the deepest level imaginative and creative. 
 An example of this can be seen in his youthful discovery of the biblical poems of the Anglo-Saxon poet Cynewulf. 
 In the poem Crist , Tolkien came upon the lines: 
 Eala Earendel engla berhtast ofer middangeard monnum sended. 
 (Hail Earendel, brightest of the angels, sent to men upon Middle Earth.) 
 The dry-as-dust scholar, the Percy Simpson sort of scholar, would merely note here that Earendel meant &bquo;shining ray&equo;. 
 Tolkien himself thought that this bright ray was the Old English word far Venus, here applied to John the Baptist, herald of the Christ. 
 But it was not the mere surface meaning of the words which arrested him. 
 &bquo;I felt a curious thrill, as if something had stirred within me, half awakening from sleep. 
 There was something very remote and strange and beautiful behind those words, if I could grasp it, far beyond ancient English.&equo; 
 Tolkien brought a response on this level of emotional intensity to those texts which, for the majority of the English Faculty, were the &bquo;boring part of the course&equo;. 
 Indeed, when Tolkien arrived, he found that the Old English being dished up to the likes of Betjeman was in a grossly truncated form, and the poetry was mainly seen as a quarry for &bquo;gobbets&equo; &mdash; that is, short passages of a very few lines, used for the purposes of testing the candidates' knowledge of sound-changes. 
 Tolkien's suggestion was that the Faculty should reform its syllabus, giving space far a proper study of the Old English poets. 
 Since this would necessarily involve cutting out some other part of the course, he suggested stopping the syllabus at 1830, and removing the study of Victorian literature. 
 Lewis was strongly opposed to this move. 
 But on his first proper encounter with Tolkien &mdash; at a meeting with English Faculty colleagues at Merton College in May 1926 &mdash; he could not help being charmed by this &bquo;smooth, pale, fluent little chap&equo;. 
 At that date, as Lewis himself tells us, he had two very marked prejudices. 
 &bquo;At my first coming into the world I had been (implicitly) warned never to trust a Papist, and at my first coming into the English Faculty (explicitly) never to trust a philologist. 
 Tolkien was both.&equo; 
 One of the first things Tolkien did after his return to Oxford in 1925 was to set up an Icelandic reading group such as he had enjoyed during his last job, as Professor of English at Leeds. 
 The idea was that the few men in the University who could read the original language of the Edda and the Sagas should group together with those who wished to learn, and read their way through the principal texts. 
 They called the group the Kolbitar (coal-biters), an Icelandic kenning which means those who sit around a fire. 
 The group was quite large. 
 It included Nevill Coghill from the beginning, and also John Bryson and George Gordon, who had supported Lewis as a candidate for the fellowship at Magdalen and became President of the college in 1928. 
 C. T. Onions, the philologist, another fellow of Magdalen, was a founder member of the Kolbitar, and not long after it was founded two other fellows of Magdalen were asked to join: Jack Lewis and Bruce McFarlane, the historian. 
 It was very much Kirkpatrick's method of learning a language. 
 Never having read a word of Norse (Old Icelandic) before, Lewis plunged in and attempted a few lines of Laxdaela Saga. 
 For someone with a good reading knowledge of German and Anglo-Saxon, the coguate tongue of Norse offered few difficulties. 
 Lewis, who had known the sagas in translation since Gastons days, was very happy with this further enrichment of the pleasures of reading. 
 But he was soon to find that Tolkien had more to offer him than the chance to learn Old Norse. 
 Lewis himself represents the summer of 1929 as the turning point of his whole life. 
 The fluency with which he himself wrote about this period was born out of a particular requirement. 
 A publisher had asked him to explain, some quarter of a century after the event, how he passed from scepticism to religious belief. 
 Minds more subtle than 
 Lewis's would probably have shrunk from the attempt. 
 And those who have made similar attempts at spiritual self-chronicling have hedged their story about with provisos. 
 &bquo;It was not logic that carried might one say that the quicksilver in the barometer changes the weather. 
 It is the concrete being that reasons; pass a number of years and I find my mind in a new place: how? the whole man moves; paper logic is but the record of it.&equo; 
 There can be no doubt that the &bquo;whole man&equo; Lewis moved from a position of atheism in his undergraduate years to an acceptance in the early 1930s of &bquo;mere Christianity&equo;. 
 In his autobiography, he tries to see how this happened to &bquo;the whole man&equo; &mdash; to the man who had been haunted since youth by a sense of joy&equo;, to the man whose love of Autumn, of Northernness, even of his own mother, was always, as he came to feel, a longing for one without whom our hearts will find no rest. 
 But for a handful of obvious reasons, Lewis does not draw a picture of &bquo;the whole man&equo; in Surprised by Joy  It is partly that a natural reticence made him draw a veil over the two greatest facts of his emotional history: his relationships with his father and Mrs Moore. 
 Probably, by the time he came to write Surprised by Joy  his way of looking at himself had become so idiosyncratic that he was not able  to see the significance of these two relationships in his religious, as well as in his whole emotional, development. 
 His old friend Barfield ruefully suggested that &bquo;at a certain stage in his life he deliberately ceased to take any interest in himself except as a kind of spiritual animus taking stock of his moral faults&hellip; 
 Self knowledge for him had come to mean recognition of his own weaknesses and shortcomings and nothing more.&equo; 
 This, no doubt, was what enabled Lewis, in telling the story of his life, to separate the departments of his life, telling us only the &bquo;spiritual&equo; story and leaving that part of himself which Newman would have called &bquo;the concrete man&equo; hidden in shadows. 
 So of his falling in love with Mrs Moore we are merely informed that &bquo;even if I were free to tell the story, I doubt if it has much to do with the subject of this book,&equo; and of his father's death in the late summer of 1929 that this &bquo;does not really come into the story I am telling&equo;. 
 If either of these sentences were true, the story would not have been worth telling, since the conversion would have been a purely fanciful affair which bore no relevance to Lewis at the deepest levels of his being. 
 His reluctance to tell the fall story is all of a piece with his extreme slowness, after his religious conversion, to accept Christianity, a religion which tries the heart, which searches us out and knows us. 
 His embarrassment about self-disclosure gives the impression, belied by his other books, that he knew nothing of the mystery that grace works by means of human weakness, not by side-stepping it. 
 Since Lewis buried the secrets, first from himself and then from others, there is not much hope that those coming after will be able to follow the story of his conversion. 
 He gives us a few outlines of &bquo;paper logic&equo; followed by a paragraph or two describing some of the religious experiences themselves. 
 The logical crisis went back to the time when he first started to read philosophy as an undergraduate and related to his reading of the English Idealist philosophers, as well as to his return (for the purposes of passing his exams, and later as a tutor) to the English empiricists of the eighteenth century. 
 He had slowly, and unwillingly, come to feel the necessity of believing in an Absolute. 
 He was driven into something &bquo;like Berkleyanism&equo;; and he took to feeling that there was no harm in positing the existence of some form of Absolute Spirit, so long as this was firmly distinguished from the God &bquo;of popular religion&equo;. 
 Something which focused his intellectual uncertainties at this time was reading Alexander's Space, Time and Deity , which introduces &bquo;enjoyment&equo; and &bquo;contemplation&equo; as technical terms. 
 &bquo;We do not think a thought&equo; in the same sense in which we &bquo;think Herodotus is unreliable&equo;. 
 When we think a thought, &bquo;thought&equo; is a cognate accusative (like &bquo;blow&equo; in &bquo;strike a blow&equo;). 
 We enjoy the thought that Herodotus is unreliable and in so doing, contemplate the unreliability of Herodotus. 
 I accepted this distinction at once and have ever since regarded it as an indispensable tool of thought.&equo; 
 It was a linchpin of Lewis's theism that thought itself was a metaphysical act; his exploration of this theme in his book Miracles  and the subsequent heated debate between himself and a fellow-Christian philosopher, Elizabeth Anscombe, provided one of the great academic sideshows in the Oxford of the late 1940s. 
 But of course, had Alexander's argument and Lewis's interpretation of it been irrefutable, had it been the kind of thing which compelled religious certainty, then all the philosophers in Oxford would have fallen to their knees when they had finished reading it. 
 They did not do so. 
 The fact that Lewis did is not a sign that he was illogical, merely that he was caught up in a spiritual drama which involved more than &bquo;paper logic&equo;. 
 There were, primarily, the tugs of sympathy. 
 His closest friend from childhood, Arthur Greeves, was religious. 
 His closest undergraduate friend, Owen Barfield, was also a believer. 
 When he visited Lewis at Magdalen (Barfield was now working as a solicitor in London), the two friends often reverted to their &bquo;Great War&equo; and there was no doubt, any longer, who was going to be the victor. 
 Someone who occasionally joined in these discussions was a pupil of Lewis's, Alan Griffiths, who had also become a friend. 
 He, like Lewis, had not yet reached a position of religious faith, but he was dissatisfied with purely materialistic explanations for life's mysteries, and he found the conversation of Barfield intoxicating. 
 Once, when the three of them were sitting in Lewis's rooms, Lewis happened to refer to philosophy as &bquo;a subject&equo;. 
 &bquo;It wasn't a subject  to Plato,&equo; said Barfield, &bquo;it was a way. 
 &bquo;The quiet but fervent agreement of Griffiths and the quick glance of understanding between those two revealed to me my own frivolity. 
 Enough had been thought, and said and felt and imagined. 
 It was about time that something should be done.&equo; 
 Among the circle of people he found most sympathetic, Lewis was in fact beginning to feel an odd man out. 
 Coghill and Tolkien were both Christians. 
 Chesterton, always a favourite author, was a Christian; it was at this period that Lewis read The Everlasting Man , and it made a profound impression on him. 
 But there was something, or, as Lewis came to feel, someone, else. 
 No doubt there were many contributory external or psychological factors in what was happening to the way he perceived his own personality. 
 It could be said that some sort of crisis was going to force itself up in the life of a strongly emotional young man who was so strictly engaged in compartmentalizing his life: a father who was never meant to know about Janie Moore; Minto herself cut off from college; almost all his friends kept in darkness about his emotional history, and most of them at this period unaware of his religious interests; pupils who were discussing with him the things he cared about most &mdash; books &mdash; but in a fashion which prevented his strength of feeling breaking through. 
 Griffiths far instance, only came across Lewis's power of imaginative invention and insight of which I had no conception before. 
 It must be remembered that Lewis always affected (I think it was deliberate) to be a plain, honest man with no nonsense about him, usually wearing, when out on a walk, an old tweed hat and coat and accompanied with a pipe and a dog.&equo; 
 Beneath this exterior something was going to have to &bquo;give&equo; if Lewis was to survive. 
 Shortly before he admitted what was happening to him, he re-read the Hippolytus  of Euripides. 
 He did so for no particular reason; it was just an impulse. 
 The theme of the play (as Lewis somehow expects all readers of his memoirs to remember) is the rejection and suppression of erotic love. 
 Phaedra, the all-powerful matriarch, conceives a wild passion for her stepson Hippolytus, who rejects her love with speeches hostile not just to her but to the whole erotic faculty. 
 In her grief, she kills herself. 
 When the father of Hippolytus, Theseus, returns from his travels, he is unable to believe that no sexual congress has taken place between his wife and his son. 
 He banishes Hippolytus and prays for his death, which is granted when Poseidon sends a sea monster to upturn the young man's chariot. 
 Too late, Theseus learns that his son loved and was loyal to him after all. 
 This is a play in which the priggish young hide their emotions while their elders give themselves up to extremes of passion. 
 It is also a play in which mortals are seen as figures of infinite pathos in a universe controlled by the whims of a cruel fate and a capricious deity. 
 Reading the play almost shattered Lewis. 
 His decision, since the madness of Doc Askins, to live without the emotions, was one that he realized was impossible. 
 &bquo;There was a transitional moment of delicious uneasiness and then &mdash; instantaneously &mdash; the long inhibition was over, the dry desert lay behind, I was off once more into the land of longing, my heart at once broken and exalted as it had never been since the old days at Bookham.&equo; 
 He began to feel himself approached by God, and in the summer of 1929 went through a mystical experience. 
 As befitted a man who had sung the pleasures of the ordinary, it occurred on a bus going up Headington Hill, on his way back to Mrs Moore's house. 
 There were no words in the experience, but he became aware of the fact that he was keeping something at bay; or another way of looking at it would be that he was wearing some rigid outer clothing, like corsets or a suit of armour. 
 In his moment of illumination on the bus, Lewis felt that he could either remain encased in this shell, or he could take it off. 
 After this strange sensation he felt as if he were a snowman &bquo;at last beginning to melt&equo;. 
 Some time in that summer of 1929, in his college rooms at Magdalen, he &bquo;gave in, and admitted that God was God, and knelt and prayed; perhaps, that night, the most dejected and reluctant convert in all England&equo;. 
 The &bquo;conversion&equo; was a recognition that God was God. 
 It was not a conversion to Christianity. 
 He writes about it in unforgettably dramatic terms and with the sublime egoism (to use the word purely, with no pejorative sense) of a man alone with God. 
 He really was, at that moment, one for whom there were &bquo;two and two only supreme and luminously self-evident beings, myself and my Creator&equo;, as Newman described his own experience. 
 Since Lewis was to go on to become a faithful and devoted Christian, he writes rather as if the &bquo;conversion&equo; were a fait accompli , after which nothing could be the same. 
 But men have had such experiences and done nothing further about them, either because they have decided that there was less to the experience than they at first supposed, or because they could not endure the ethical and spiritual demands which were implied in the unspoken, ineffable moment of divine knowledge. 
 That summer, however, events were to place a seal on what happened to Lewis in his Magdalen rooms. 
 It is probably fanciful to cast Mrs Moore as Phaedra, or the P'daytabird as Theseus, but now Lewis was crossing the sea to see his father for the last time. 
 A great emotional business was reaching its climax. 
 Lewis continued, throughout life, to be obsessed not only by his father, but also by the possibility that his life could be interpreted in a purely Freudian way. 
 &bquo;In those days, the new psychology was just beginning to make itself felt in the circles I most frequented in Oxford,&equo; he told readers of the 1950 reprint of Dymer . 
 Much earlier, at the time of &bquo;the Doc's insanity&equo; in 1923, Lewis had written to Greeves, &bquo;Arthur, whatever you do never allow yourself to get a neurosis.&equo; 
 This piece of advice might suggest that his grasp of the &bquo;new psychology&equo; was still at the rudimentary stage, since he speaks of a neurosis as if it were something avoidable. 
 The letter is interesting, though, for the light it casts on his rooted dread of mental imbalance, and on his horrified feeling that the unsatisfactory relations which had existed between himself and his father since eariy adolescence might somehow mar him for the rest of his life: You and I are both qualified for it &lsqb;neurosis&rsqb; because we were both afraid of our fathers as children. 
 The Doctor who came to see the poor Doc (a psychoanalyst and neurological specialist) said that every neurotic case went back to the childish fear of the father. 
 But it can be avoided. 
 Keep clear of introspection, of brooding, of spiritualism, of everything eccentric. 
 Keep to work and sanity and open air &mdash; to the cheerful and the matter of fact side of things. 
 This was advice which he had been unable to fallow himself. 
 With the reading of Hippolytus  and the cracking of the outer shell of his cheerful, hard-working, no-nonsense self, introspection was running riot and &bquo;spiritualism&equo; &mdash; by which he clearly meant dabbling in affairs of the spirit rather than solely a preoccupation with the dead &mdash; had, by the summer of 1929, taken a firm grip on him. 
 No wonder, then, that when he came to write up the experience in Surprised by Joy  he should have been so insistent that his father's last illness and death &bquo;does not really come into the story I am telling&equo;. 
 He was frightened that hostile readers of his theological work would be able to say that his religion could be &bquo;explained&equo; in terms of the Oedipus complex (or perhaps the Hippolytus complex); and that he was only able to find peace for his heart by coming to terms with a Heavenly Father of his own projection when he had seen the last of his earthly father in Belfast. 
 So much did he dread that his own was a case of &bquo;redemption by parricide&equo; that he emphasized the unwillingness with which he accepted the divine call with language which is exaggerated and almost coarse. 
 He was a &bquo;prodigal who is brought kicking, struggling, resentful and darting his eyes in every direction for a chance of escape&equo;. 
 He crossed the Irish channel on 12 August and reached Little Lea on the morning of the thirteenth. 
 His father had been &bquo;under the weather, since July, and Lewis was half-aware that he might be coming home for the last time. 
 Once he set eyes on Albert, he knew that the old man was very sick indeed. 
 His father rejoiced to see him, and noted that Jacks was &bquo;looking remarkably well and in great form&equo;. 
 Jack fell quickly into the routine of looking out for the absurdities in his father's speech to put into a P'dayta-Pie for Warnie; but he had no heart for it. 
 He began to write about one such P'daytaism, and then crossed it out. 
 The truth was, as he wrote to Warnie, that &bquo;P. is rather seriously ill.&equo; 
 It was cancer of the bowel, though the doctors were slow or unwilling to diagnose it at first. 
 Not long after Jack came home, Albert began to run high fevers. 
 His heart was not strong either, and by the end of the month he was confined to his bed. 
 Jack stayed up to nurse him. 
 Delighted to have his boy at home, Albert was in particularly cheerful form, in spite of his pain. 
 When the doctors broke it to him that he would need an operation, his son noted that &bquo;he is taking it like a hero.&equo; 
 All of a sudden, Jack saw that his father was  a sort of hero &mdash; a maddening, eccentric hero but a man whose decency, courage and good humour were as unshakable as his sincere piety. 
 The two men were enjoying a condition of harmony which had been unknown in all the previous years. 
 The house was fall of memories; but even to call them memories was to imply that Jack had put them behind him; and he had not. 
 &bquo;Every room is soaked with the bogeys of childhood&hellip; 
 The awful rows, the awful returnings to school.&equo; 
 He sat in the dining-room, able to enjoy a few biscuits and fruit rather than the &bquo;gargantuan midday meal which was hitherto compulsory&equo;. 
 Every day he saw Arthur Greeves, who was still living next door, having studied art at the Slade School in London and returned to Belfast with no prospects. 
 Arthur, who had followed so much of Jack's inner journey, was the perfect companion during those strange days. 
 Much of the time, however, Jack was alone. 
 When his father was tucked up for the night, the son would wander out into the garden and enjoy the cool air as a contrast to the fug of the sick-room. 
 &bquo;My father and I are physical counterparts: and during these days more than ever I notice his resemblance to me&hellip;&equo; he mused. 
 At the beginning of September, the doctors recommended an operation, and Albert was moved into a nursing home. 
 The operation revealed the extent of the cancer, but nevertheless Jack was told mat his father might live for &bquo;a few more years&equo;. 
 Since he had teaching to prepare at Oxford for the following term, he said an unwilling farewell to his father and took the boat home. 
 Four days later, on 25 September, Albert Lewis died. 
 In the Lewis Papers , Warren remarked, &bquo;With his passing we lose him who may perhaps be described as the hero of our saga&hellip; 
 His age was 66 years and 33 days.&equo; 
 MYTHOPOEIA 1929&ndash;1931 
 &bquo;I treated my own father abominably and no sin in my whole life now seems to be so serious,&equo; Lewis blurted out to a correspondent twenty-five years after A. J. Lewis's demise. 
 His remorse was perpetual and far-reaching, and it coloured the whole of his memory. 
 Sadness far the way he had felt about the old man blended with a sense that his childhood was irrecoverably lost, and the knowledge that the very past when it was in flight Lived, like the present, in continual death. 
 Moreover the death of Albert only served to emphasize the emotional burden which he was now craving: the increasing loneliness of the ageing Janie Moore, and the total isolation of his brother. 
 Stationed as a soldier in Shanghai, and unable to get home until the following April, Warnie was in an agony of sorrow for the old days. 
 &bquo;The P'daytabird is dead,&equo; his diary solemnly records. 
 All day I have been seeing pictures of him at his best; jumbled up in no chronological sequence &mdash; Saturday evening tram rides and visits to the Hippodrome with late supper afterwards in Malvern days, earlier days of &bquo;where do you want to go to&equo; in the study&hellip; the &bquo;Well, boys this is grand&equo; at the beginning of the holiday&hellip; his little drop of whiskey: his fund of wheezes. 
 How far Warnie emulated at this stage of life his father's fondness for a little drop of whiskey, and at what point he began his calamintous descent into alcoholism is not easy to determine. 
 He was not actually dismissed from the service, though it was because of alcohol that he was asked to volunteer his own early resignation. 
 One thing was certain. 
 The death of his father made him homeless. 
 &bquo;Worst of all, being pulled up by the roots &mdash; worse for me than for j&lsqb;ack&rsqb;; for Leeborough has always been my base whereas his real home has been Hillsboro &lsqb;Mrs Moore's rented house in Headington, Oxford&rsqb; far some years now. 
 The thought that there will never be any going home is hard to bear.&equo; 
 That the other person in Jack's life, Mrs Moore, was also profoundly lonely is made clear by a generous, and at me same time comically self-revealing, letter which she wrote to Warnie on 29 October. 
 She urged Warnie to treat Hillsboro as a home, and confessed: 
 I should have been very glad of your society this last year, Maureen has been at the Royal College of Music, and I have been much alone, only for the animal's company I don't know what I should have done and poor Mr. Papworth &lsqb;a dog&rsqb; has been so ill we had to telephone a vet up at 2 a.m. one morning it was a funny night, Jack and I in our dressing gowns in the kitchen trying to comfort Mr. Papworth. 
 Jack and the vet (who turned out to be an Irishman too) drinking whiskey which they thought was brandy because I'd put it into a brandy bottle&hellip; 
 All this was kindly meant, and the suggestion that Warnie was welcome with Jack and Minto was some comfort. 
 But the exiled soldier wanted more than a place to stay: he wanted, to a Peter Pan-ish degree, everything as it had been in his childhood home. 
 In one of his lengthy letters to Jack from Shanghai, he suggested that they &bquo;yield to sentiment and construct the Little End Room in your sitting room at Magdalen&equo;. 
 In another letter he suggested constructing the &bquo;Little End Room&equo; in a spare bedroom at Headington, &bquo;a place where we can always meet on the common ground of the past and ipso facto a museum of the Leeborough which we want to preserve&equo;. 
 Furthermore, this 36-year-old officer was in desperation about the fate of their boyhood toys, locked up in a trunk in the attic at Leeborough. 
 He found it &bquo;intolerable&equo; to think of the toys falling into the hands of other children &mdash; &bquo;The idea of a crowd of embryo right wee fellas&equo; ' getting hold of them and Bolshevising and applying to their own base purposes that well-ordered world in which we spent so many happy hours&equo;. 
 Jack felt the need to treat these outbursts by Warnie with firmness as well as with gentleness, not least because his brother was giving voice to feelings which he shared quite passionately himself. 
 He rejected the idea of a Little End Room museum, not least because &bquo;a museum is preciously like a mausoleum&equo;. 
 He said it would be a mistake, &bquo;a mistake in sentiment; for it could only mean that we were embalming the corpse of something that isn't really dead and needn't die at all &mdash; an aesthetic mistake &mdash; because we don't really want to have the taste of our schooldays established as a boundary for our whole lives&equo;. 
 To anyone who knew Lewis in the second half of his life, and remarked his preference for boys' books such as R. M. Ballantyne or Captain Marryat over the so-called &bquo;moderns&equo;, there can be no doubt that he was here addressing a warning not just to his brother but to himself. 
 Within a very few weeks of his father's death, Lewis found himself obliged once more to take up the routines of an Oxford term: weekly tutorials, college meetings and lectures. 
 Any thought of what was to happen to his family home in Belfast had to be shelved until a joint decision could be reached with his brother when he next came home on leave. 
 The most marked feature of Lewis's own emotional and intellectual life as the autumn days grew shorter and the year 1929 drew to its close was the development of his friendship with J. R. R. Tolkien. 
 It is only now, decades after they were first written down, that the reading public can begin to have any sense of the extent and range of Tolkien's mythological writings. 
 From his early years, he had been engaged in the creation of a whole world, comparable in scale with the world of Greek mythology, with a pantheon of gods, a hierarchy of elvish immortals, and a vast cycle of stories, some of them &bquo;forgotten&equo;, or not yet formulated, in his imagination; some surviving in fragmentary form; some planned as long prose narratives; some conceived as great poems, longer than Beowulf  The sheer volume of all this, much of it composed before his fortieth birthday, bears testimony to a rare artistic self-confidence. 
 One receives the strong impression that Tolkien would have continued to write his gnominsh grammars, his elvish etymologies, his histories of mythological lost ages, his wanted to read them or not. 
 And indeed, the very extent to which they would lie readable was called in question by their range and bulk. 
 For how could a reader who knew nothing of the original matter &mdash; the origin of the Silmarils, the rise and fall of Numenor, the triumphs and ultimate ruin of Gondolin, etc. &mdash; find a way in ? 
 There exists no easy guide to me Tolkien mythology, and the existing materials, when published, have required the extensive annotation of Tolkien's son. 
 Nevertheless, no writer, however self-sufficient, writes without a thought of an audience, and Tolkien was happy to discover anyone who could appreciate what he was up to. 
 It was evident, from conversations with him at the Kolbitar, that Lewis was such a man, and in version of his Lay of Leithian , the story of how the mortal Beren, returning from the wars, through the forests of Neldoreth, encounters the elfish maiden Luthien and falls in love with her. 
 Thingol, Luthien's father, is so enraged that a mortal should dare to woo his daughter that he says he will only give her hand to Beren if he will wrest one of the Silmarils, or enchanted jewels, from the iron crown of the dark lord Margoth. 
 This impossible quest, which indirectly leads to the undoing of Thingol's own elvish kingdom, is only possible because Luthien accompanies Beren on his journey. 
 He manages to penetrate the fastness of the dark lord disguised in a wolfskin, while she is hidden in the garment of a bat; but it is her own enchantments, her beauty and her songs, which ultimately defeat the evil one. 
 Tolkien never finished the Kay of Leithian , though he worked at it on and off far seven years, composing at least two versions of the poem in more than four thousand lines of octosyllabic couplets. 
 Though at times the verse is technically imperfect, it is full of passages of quite stunning beauty; and the overall conception must make it, though unfinished, one of the most remarkable poems written in English in the twentieth century. 
 It is worth describing it at such length so that readers who have not  read Tolkien's &bquo;minor&equo; works might develop some idea of Lewis's importance as Tolkien's &bquo;onlie begetter&equo; or &bquo;miglior fabbro&equo;, for there can be very little doubt that it was Lewis's friendship and encouragement which led Tolkien to write the works which made his name with the public; just as it was Tolkien's friendship which released in Lewis wells of creativity which had remained (though he was so naturally fluent) mysteriously dry. 
 It was therefore an important moment when Tolkien gave Lewis the Lay of Leithian  to read in manuscript. 
 It has been said that Lewis's expressed distaste for the poetry of his contemporaries, such as MacNeice and Eliot, was based on jealousy. 
 Tolkien, when he read this suggestion after Lewis's death &mdash; and after his own relationship with Lewis had become less than happy &mdash; rejected it as entirely unworthy. 
 He knew that Lewis was a greater man than that. 
 From personal experience, he knew that Lewis could be a generous, though by no means an uncritical, reader of contemporary poetry. 
 Lewis wrote to Tolkien: 
 I sat up late last night and read the Geste  as far as to where Beren and his gnomish allies defeat the patrol of orcs above the sources of the Narog and disguise themselves in the reaf  &lsqb;Old English: &bquo;garments, weapons taken from the slain&equo;&rsqb;. 
 I can quite honestly say that it is ages since I have had an evening of such delight; and the personal interest of reading a friend's work had very little to do with it. 
 I should have enjoyed it just as well if I'd picked it up in a bookshop, by an unknown author. 
 The two things that come out clearly are the sense of reality in the background and the mythical value. 
 Lewis had seen, almost more clearly, one suspects, than the author himself saw, what was the essence of Tolkien. 
 In order to draw this out of him, he wrote a vastly elaborate commentary on the Lay , softening the blow of his harsher criticisms by inventing the personae of a whole group of scholarly editors who are debating the text in the way that scholars have disputed over Homer or Beowulf  It would seem that Tolkien took a great deal of notice of Lewis's invented editors, for he rewrote his Kay  and incorporated a high proportion of their emendations. 
 The device was a clever one on Lewis's part, for since he was seven years younger than Tolkien and a relatively junior member of a faculty in which &bquo;Tollers&equo; was a professor, there was the need to tread carefully. 
 It was not simply a question of age and hierarchy. 
 Tolkien was by temperament a very different man from Lewis. 
 He could be touchy and irritable; Lewis could be brash and tactless. 
 There was a touch of elfish melancholy, as well as of delicacy, in Tolkien which would never respond to the broader outlines of Lewis's essentially sunny disposition. 
 Lewis would not have guessed that Tolkien's Kay  would remain unfinished. 
 It must have seemed clear to him at once that Tolkien was a man of literary genius, and this fact only brought home to him his own sense of failure as a writer. 
 &bquo;From the age of sixteen onwards, I had one single ambition, from which I never wavered, in the prosecution of which I spent every ounce I could, on which I really and deliberately staked my whole contentment; and I recognise myself as having unmistakeably failed in it.&equo; 
 He knew that as yet the appropriate style  eluded him. 
 He knew neither what to write nor how to write it. 
 In Tolkien, by huge contrast, he met a man whose style had been with him from the beginning. 
 Lewis responded so warmly to Tolkien's imagined world because, as he wrote to Arthur Greeves, &bquo;he is, in one part of him, what we were.&equo; 
 That is to say, Tolkien's stories could be said to be an embodiment of that Northernness with which Lewis and Greeves had been in love since early adolescence. 
 Lewis was subtle enough to see that this was at best a half-truth, and perhaps he was beginning to sense that what Tolkien's friendship had to offer him was something rather more important than a regress to me nursery. 
 For Tolkien, whose literary pilgrimage was to be so lonely, and whose return to Oxford had not been marked by great domestic happiness, there was something very cheering in the company of this clever, widely read, humorous and spontaneously affectionate Irishman. 
 When he reflected with sadness on the unhappiness of his marriage towards the end of 1929, he noted, &bquo;Friendship with Lewis compensates for much.&equo; 
 The death of Albert Lewis inevitably involved his two sons in practical decisions. 
 What was to be the future of their house in Belfast? 
 Where would Warnie live? 
 How much money would be available to them when the probate of the estate had been completed? 
 The decision to sell Little Lea more or less made itself. 
 Jack could not possibly run the house from Oxford, and Warnie was still a serving officer in the Army. 
 When he came home on leave in April 1930, they both returned to their childhood home and made all the necessary arrangements for its sale. 
 It was &bquo;perfectly beastly&equo; as Warnie said in his diary, to see &bquo;P's grave with its fresh turned earth and a handful of withered daffodils at its head alongside Mamy's. 
 It was also a shock to discover that their father's investments only yielded an income of some &pound;190 per annum net, considerably less than Warnie (desperate to leave the Army and live on his pension) had been hoping. 
 The house, thought to be worth about &pound;3,000 by the lawyers, in fact went for less. 
 Not the least of their tasks was the disposal of the toys. 
 They decided in the end to bury the trunk of &bquo;characters&equo; from Animal-land unopened. 
 A huge hole was dug in the vegetable patch for the purpose. 
 After several days of dividing their possessions into things they wished to keep and things which could be given away or sold, they were ready to leave the house for the last time. 
 It was a tremendous wrench, one from which Warnie never truly recovered. 
 One of his last acts was to heave the contents of the wine cellar (some bottles of whiskey) into the back of a relative's car. 
 Clearly the whereabouts of those bottles, and the number of them, had been one of the P'daytabird's little secrets, for Warnie writes, &bquo;Nothing brought home to me the finality of the old life as did the carrying out of those bottles and putting them into &lsqb;the&rsqb; car &mdash; to see the mysteries of that jealously guarded secret room emerge as plain matter of fact bottles, and the cellar stand revealed as an ordinary empty cupboard was an unpleasant feeling.&equo; 
 Jack wrote a poem to Warnie, urging him not to look back out of the car window as it hurtled away, leaving their childhood behind them. 
 Yet look not out. 
 Think rather, &bquo;When from France And those old German wars we came back here Already it was the mind's swift haunting glance Towards the further past, that made time dear.&equo; 
 Then to that further past, still up the stream Ascend and think of some divine first day In holidays from school. 
 Even there the gleam Of earlier memory like enchantment lay. 
 Already, the germ is present which was to flower most fully in The Last Battle : the idea of school holidays being a mere Platonic shadow of our permanent refreshment in Paradise, of our earthly homes being but a reflection of heaven. 
 which preoccupied them. 
 Jack had very decided misgivings about Minto's impulsive suggestion that Warnie should live with them. 
 To Warnie, he had written a letter fall of the gravest admonitions, designed to make him think carefully about what he was committing himself to. 
 Can you stand as a permanency our cuisine &mdash; Maureen's practising &mdash; Maureen's sulks &mdash; Minto's burnettodesmondism &mdash; Minto's mare's nests &mdash; the perpetual interruptions of family life &mdash; the partial loss of liberty? 
 This sounds as if I were either sick of it myself or else trying to make you sick of it; but neither is the case. 
 I have definitely chosen and I don't regret me choice. 
 What I hope &mdash; very much hope &mdash; is that you, after consideration, may make the same choice. 
 But me thought of sharing his Minto-life with Warnie was not without its complications for Jack himself. 
 In a letter to Arthur Greeves, he said that Warnie and Mrs Moore liked each other, &bquo;and, I hope, as W. gets broken into domestic life, they may come to do so still more: but in the interval mere is a ticklish time ahead and in any case it is a big sacrifice of our&hellip; 
 &equo; At this point the manuscript breaks off. 
 Greeves, in pencil, has written &bquo;very private&equo; and &bquo;to be burnt&equo; at the top of the letter and the following pages of it are missing. 
 The letter concludes, &bquo;You are my only real Father Confessor.&equo; 
 Warnie, no sophisticate in emotional matters, found Jack's relationship with Janie Moore incomprehensible. 
 Jack &bquo;commonly referred to Mrs Moore as &bquo;my mother&equo;. 
 On the only occasion when Warnie tried to probe Jack on the origin or true nature of his relationship with Minto he was shut up with great vehemence. 
 There is enough recorded in Warnie's diaries over the next twenty years of friction and domestic misery to make us see why Jack had misgivings about the advisability of their all attempting to live together. 
 The factor which clinched their decision was the discovery of a house which they could only afford to buy if all three pooled their resources. 
 After long years of living in unsatisfactory rented accommodation, it now looked as if Jack and Minto could afford a place of their own. 
 They first set eyes on the house which was to be &bquo;home&equo; for the rest of Jack's life on 7 July 1930. 
 Minto was &bquo;more excited&equo; than Warnie had ever seen her when he returned from Aldershot far week-end leave, happy to leave behind him his fellow-officers, whom he nicknamed the Aldershits. 
 When Jack took him to see the house, Warnie was just as enthusiastic. 
 &bquo;I instantly caught the infection.&equo; 
 The house itself was unimpressive, little more than a low-lying cottage of modern design which would not easily accommodate four grown-up people. 
 In order to make it suitable, Minto believed that it would be necessary to build on at least two extra rooms. 
 What made it so enchanting was the setting. 
 The gardens and grounds covered eight acres, nestling at the northern foot of Shotover Hill. 
 The house took its name &mdash; The Kilns &mdash; from the two old brick kilns which stood by its side. 
 Further in, towards the base of the hill, was a wood, within which were one large pool and several smaller ones, formed by the hollowing-out of the old stone quarries in a previous century. 
 It was said that the poet Shelley had been here to sail paper boats. 
 &bquo;Many a &pound;10,000 house is worse situated and has a much poorer garden, &bquo;Warnie observed. 
 The asking price was &pound;3,500. 
 This was a considerable sum of money. 
 The sort of modest suburban house which Mrs Moore was renting at the time could be purchased in those days for &pound;850 or &pound;1,000. 
 The Lewises&equo; substantial house in Belfast was finally sold for &pound;2,300, seven months after their purchase of The Kilns. 
 Minto airily spoke of being worth &pound;1,000 and able to raise a further &pound;2,000 as a mortgage, but this was not the case. 
 Upon investigation, it was discovered that her Askins inheritance, held in trust, enabled her to have a mortgage of just &pound;1,500. 
 Dons, in those days, did not reckon on buying houses, still less on having mortgages. 
 The huge majority of them lived in rented houses in North Oxford. 
 The Kilns venture was highly unusual, and the Lewis brothers knew that they could only afford it by taking the great risk of throwing in their lot together; in the event the purchase price was lowered to &pound;3,300. 
 Warnie paid the cash deposit of &pound;300, and raised a mortgage of &pound;500, Minto's trustees put up a mortgage of &pound;1,500 and Jack raised a mortgage of &pound;1,000. 
 On this precarious basis, life at The Kilns began &mdash; and the distinctive Lewisian habitat had been established. 
 Surprised by Joy  limited by the necessarily artificial conventions of autobiography, gives an impression that the development of Lewis's religious opinions was much more cut and dried than was really the case. 
 He gives us a picture of a firm conversion to theism in the summer of 1929, followed by a period in which he believed in God, but not in the doctrines of Christianity. 
 Then, in the late summer of 1931, he writes that he passed definitely from this position of &bquo;rational meism, into a fall acceptance of the Christian dispensation. 
 While not exactly false, this simple version of his spiritual growth gives no picture of the tremendous vacillations in his faith which he confided to Arthur Greeves during this period. 
 For example, in his attempt to lead a new life, he attributes any success he may have had in conquering lust, anger or pride to God's grace , a very specifically Christian idea; and this is a full fifteen months before his conversion to Christianity. 
 Anything which smacks of an incarnational theology, he eschews. 
 That is to say he is not in the least drawn to the idea that Christ came in the flesh, and he finds the simplicity and literalism of what might be termed &bquo;mere Christianity&equo; frankly unacceptable. 
 To Greeves, the orthodox believer, he wrote in January 1930, &bquo;In spite of all my recent changes of view I am still inclined to think that you can only get what you  call Christ out of the Gospels by picking and choosing and slurring over a good deal.&equo; 
 The authors he found most helpful in this &bquo;interim&equo; period were all mystics, or figures who emphasized spirit over matter &mdash; MacDonald, William Ralph Inge, Jacob Boehme, whose quasi-theosophical, semi-astrological De Signatura Rerum (The Signatures of Things)  gave him &bquo;about the biggest shaking up I've got from a book, since I first read Phantastes &equo;. 
 But such moments of uplift as were provided by the mystics could not prevent Lewis's common-sense humility from seeing &bquo;how much of one's philosophy and religion are mere talk&equo;. 
 When in college, he had begun to attend chapel (i.e. the prayer-book office of morning prayer) each day. 
 It could not prevent him from having doubts. 
 &bquo;I have no rational ground for going back on the arguments that convinced me of God's existence: but the irrational deadweight of my old sceptical habits, and the spirit of the age, and the cares of the day, steal away all my lively feeling of the truth, and often when I pray I wonder if I am not posting letters to a non-existent address.&equo; 
 For those who are familiar with Lewis's literary persona, as for the much smaller number of people who knew him in life, his acceptance of an orthodox Christian position seems in an almost literal sense fitting. 
 There are certain clothes we feel comfortable in and which we would wear in preference to all others. 
 On this level of mere temperamental affinity (not considering its truth or falsehood) we feel Lewis to be a man who would be most happy in Christian garb. 
 There is no doubt that until he discovered this clothing (be it artificial carapace or &bquo;the whole armour of God&equo;), Lewis was only half-formed as a writer, as a literary imagination, perhaps as a person. 
 Many readers of his apologetics must have been disconcerted by me fact that his chapter about conversion in Beyond Personality  is entitled &bquo;Let's Pretend&equo;. 
 He suggests that the moment you &bquo;make a shot at saying your prayers&equo; and say &bquo;Our Father&equo; you are &bquo;dressing up as Christ&hellip; 
 That is why children's games are so important. 
 They are always pretending to be grown-ups playing soldiers, playing shop. 
 But all the time they are hardening their muscles and sharpening their wits, so that the pretence of being grown-up helps them to grow up in earnest.&equo; 
 This process of &bquo;let's pretend&equo; took an irreversible step forward one September night in 1931, when Lewis was entertaining J. R. R. Tolkien to dinner at Magdalen. 
 He had also asked Henry Victor Dyson, a lecturer at Reading University who had been an exact contemporary of Tolkien's as an undergraduate at Exeter College. 
 Like Tolkien, Dyson (known to all his friends as Hugo) was a Christian &mdash; though he was a High Anglican while Tolkien was Roman Catholic. 
 Lewis had got to know him because he was a frequent visitor to Oxford, anxious to get a job in the Oxford English Faculty, and a friend not only of Tolkien but also of Nevill Coghill. 
 Dyson was a beguilingly witty man, handsome and bright-eyed, whose talk was a flow of fantasy, keen literary appreciation and occasional learning. 
 Like many Oxford men, he belonged to the strong Socratic tradition in which dialogue was esteemed as highly as the written word. 
 As the years went by, and some of his friends became prolific writers, Dyson came to be jealous of their reputations and to scorn what they wrote. 
 He himself published almost nothing. 
 In 1931, however, they were all still comparatively innocent as far as publication was concerned. 
 Lewis had his two slender volumes of verse, and Tolkien his learned edition of Sir Gawain and the Green knight  and his article on Ancrene Wisse and Hali Meith-had  (which combines deep linguistic learning with a justly famous account of the world of this West Midland prose writer which we can recognize as a foretaste of the Hobbit's native Shire). 
 These were hardly a threat to Dyson's rhetorical skills. 
 Dyson, besides, though unpublished and &bquo;a don at Reading&equo; (as he always half-ironically described himself) rather than at Oxford, was more a man of the world than either Tolkien or Lewis. 
 He had been a friend of Lawrence of Arabia; he knew Ottoline Morrell, at whose house Garsington Manor he had met Virginia Woolf, Bertrand Russell and D. H. Lawrence, among others. 
 The combination of Tolkien and Dyson was therefore a formidable one. 
 After dinner the talk fell to the great question which was uppermost in Lewis's mind: that question being, in the words of his pupil Betjeman, &bquo;and is it true, and is it true, this most amazing tale of all?&equo; 
 Owen Barfield, both in conversation and in writing, had already gone a long way in revealing to Lewis the fallacy of making sharp distinctions between &bquo;myth&equo; and &bquo;fact&equo;. 
 In his book Poetic Diction  he had pointed out that in earlier times, those who first used language did not necessarily distinguish between &bquo;metaphorical&equo; and &bquo;literal&equo; uses of words. 
 The Latin spiritus , for example, means breath . 
 Modern rationalists might wish to distinguish between the &bquo;meaning&equo; of &bquo;spirit in some elevated sense&equo; and that of &bquo;merely breath&equo;. 
 But early users of the language would not have made such a distinction. 
 When the wind blew it was not &bquo;like&equo; someone breathing. 
 It was the breath of a divinity. 
 This powerfully confirmed the way in which Tolkien had been accustoming himself to think about the world ever since he grew to manhood. 
 One of the great distinctions in his mythology is made between the Elves, who are &bquo;animist&equo; and &bquo;pagan&equo;, and the Men, who are destined to move beyond this. 
 The Elves, who will never leave the material universe and do not know what happens to Men when they die, are embodiments of language-users for whom the breath-wind-spirit distinction would be meaningless. 
 By contrast, God willed that &bquo;the hearts of Men should seek beyond the world and should find no rest therein&equo;. 
 In his dialogue with Lewis that September night, Tolkien was really arguing for a less human and more &bquo;even&equo; approach to the Gospel story. 
 Lewis complained that he could not see any personal relevance for himself in the story of Christ. 
 &bquo;What I couldn't see was how the life and death of Someone Else (whoever he was) 2000 years ago could help us here and now &mdash; except in so far as his example  helped us.&equo; 
 Tolkien pointed out that this was, as much as anything, an imaginative failure on Lewis's part. 
 When Lewis came across myths  of dying and reviving gods, he was moved. 
 When he read stories about Balder, Adonis and Bacchus, he was prepared to &bquo;feel the myth as profound and suggestive of meanings beyond my grasp even tho&equo; I could not say in cold prose &bquo;what it meant&equo;. 
 He stopped short of understanding Christianity because when he thought about that, he laid aside the receptive imagination with which he allowed himself to appreciate myth and became rigidly narrow and empiricist. 
 He should understand that &bquo;the story of Christ is simply a true myth: a myth working on us in the same way as the others, but with this tremendous difference that it really happened : and one must be content to accept it in the same way.&equo; 
 To this extent, Tolkien argued, &bquo;doctrines&equo; which are extracted from the &bquo;myth&equo; are less true than the &bquo;myth&equo; itself. 
 The ideas are too large and too all-embracing for the finite mind to absorb them. 
 That is why the divine providence revealed himself in story. 
 Lewis claimed that this was tantamount to &bquo;breathing a lie through silver&equo;, a riposte which Tolkien felt sufficiently challenging to require a written reply. 
 The result was the verse known as &bquo;Mythopoeia&equo;, some of which he quoted in his essay. 
 Its &bquo;argument&equo; repeated the discussion which he and Lewis shared with Dyson on that memorable September night. 
 Myth was the exact opposite of a &bquo;lie breathed through silver&equo;. 
 Man's capacity to mythologize was a remnant of his pre-lapsarian capacity to see into the life of things: 
 Disgraced he may be, yet is not dethroned, And keeps the rags of Lordship once he owned. 
 It was a completely still, warm evening, and the three friends walked round and round the mile-long circuit of Addison's Walk beneath the avenues of beeches. 
 Quite suddenly, at a crucial point in the conversation, there was a rush of wind, causing the first fall of leaves in the season. 
 They stood in the dark and listened. 
 At first the pattering leaves sounded like rain. 
 It was at this point that Tolkien reiterated the argument already made familiar to Lewis by Barfield. 
 We speak of &bquo;stars&equo; and &bquo;trees&equo; as though they were entities which we had mastered in our post-Newtonian, materialist fashion. 
 But for those who formed the words star  and tree  they were very different. 
 For them, stars were a living silver, bursting into flame in answer to an eternal music in the mind of God. 
 All creation was &bquo;myth-woven and elf-patterned&equo;. 
 It was late; the clock in Magdalen Tower had struck three in the morning before Lewis let Tolkien out by the little postern on Magdalen Bridge. 
 Dyson lingered, and he and Lewis found still more to say to one another, strolling up and down the cloister of New Buildings. 
 They did not part until four a.m. 
 Nine days later, on 28 September, there was an outing from The Kilns to Whipsnade Zoo. 
 Minto and Maureen, accompanied by an Irish friend called Vera Henry and the dog Mr Papwoth, who had recovered his strength before going hence and being no more seen, were to travel by car. 
 Jack and Warnie were to go by motorcycle &mdash; Daudel as Warnie called it &mdash; with Warnie in the saddle and Jack in a low-slung sidecar. 
 It was a thick, misty day, but when the two brothers got beyond the small market town of Thame, the fog gave way to bright sunshine. 
 They stopped far beer and then waited anxiously at an agreed spot for Minto and the others. 
 They had still not turned up by two o'clock, and since their sandwich lunch was in the car, Jack and Warnie were feeling &bquo;uncommonly peckish&equo;. 
 At two-twenty Minto's party appeared, saying that the reason for their delay was that Liddiat, the handyman employed by Minto at The Kilns, had pumped up the tyres of the car so hard that it was impossible to drive at more than fifteen miles per hour. 
 In spite of the frayed tempers caused by this, it was an enjoyable expedition. 
 Everyone, but especially the two Lewises, loved the zoo, and Jack made friends with a bear whom he nicknamed Bultitude. 
 He said how much he would like to adopt the bear &mdash; which, in a sense, he was to do, for Bultitude appears as one of the characters in the final volume of his space trilogy That Hideous Strength . 
 To all appearances, it had been a completely normal day. 
 Only, as Lewis tells us in Surprised by Joy , &bquo;when we set out I did not believe that Jesus Christ is the Son of God, and when we reached the zoo I did.&equo; 
 When confiding the news to Greeves, he said, &bquo;My long night talk with Dyson and Tolkien had a good deal to do with it.&equo; 
 We are told that Janie Moore bitterly resented the final stages of 
 Holy Communion for attending &bquo;blood feasts&equo;. 
 There is something puzzling here, since Mrs Moore, though an unbeliever, had been happy to have her own daughter confirmed, and there is a steady succession of references in Jack's letters and diaries, during the years 1919&ndash;1931, of attendance at church with Minto. 
 We must assume either that Warnie's memory exaggerated the virulence of her hostility to Jack's conversion, or that there was some particular thing about it which affected her more than anyone else. 
 We cannot know &mdash; and she was by this time fifty-eight years old to Jack's thirty-three &mdash; whether she felt personally slighted by the change. 
 We do know what Jack's views were of the Christian and sexual morality: &bquo;There is no getting away from it: the Christian rule is &bquo;Either marriage, with complete faithfulness to your partner, or else total abstinence.&equo; 
 In later years, offered the objection that celibacy is not always possible, Lewis the radio evangelist was to be quite unambiguous: &bquo;faced with an optional question in an examination paper, one considers whether one can do it or not; faced with a compulsory question, one must do the best one can&hellip; 
 It is wonderful what you can do when you have to.&equo; 
 The letters to Greeves suggest that he did not find this part of a Christian's duty very easy ('Daily Castration Prevents Master Bation'). 
 But he was not a man to say one thing and do another. 
 He meant his Christian commitment to be total. 
 This commitment grew out of profound emotional changes over which he had no control, and of which he himself perhaps had only an imperfect knowledge. 
 The first change, the move to theism, happened in 1929 and coincided more or less directly with the death of his father. 
 It would be far too glib to suggest that he consciously made the second change, to adopt Christianity, merely to give himself an excuse to abandon sexual relations with Mrs Moore, whatever the nature of those relations had been. 
 There are some men who pay prostitutes not for overtly sexual favours, but far humiliation of the most humdrum kind. 
 Such people, caught in a strange web of masochism, find their emotional fulfilment not in acts of love but in being made to scrub kitchen floors or scour out pans. 
 &bquo;He was as good as an extra maid,&equo; said Minto. 
 Certainly, as his mind prepared itself for the acceptance of the 
 Christian orthodoxies, he was making dogged attempts to come to terms with his sado-masochistic tendencies. 
 In February of 1931, he and Warnie had attended a production of James Elroy Flecker's Hassan  at the Oxford Playhouse. 
 It was not very well done, but well enough for me: indeed to see it really well acted would be too much for me. 
 In reading it the cruelty is just about balanced by the extreme beauty of the lyrics and much of the dialogue, so that the total effect, tho&equo; sinister, like a too bright dream which is sure to turn into nightmare before the end, yet is bearable. 
 On the stage, where one has less time to dwell on the cadence or suggestion of the individual words, me cruelty is unendurable. 
 Warnie went out half way through. 
 I felt quite sick but thought it almost a duty far one afflicted in my way to remain, saying to myself, &bquo;Oh, you like cruelty, do you? 
 Well now stew in it&equo; &mdash; the same principle on which one trains a puppy to be clean &mdash; &bquo;rub their noses in it&equo;. 
 It has haunted me ever since. 
 The disturbing thing about this letter to Arthur Greeves is the extent to which he does not see that the remedy proposed sounds all too like the disorder he wishes to eliminate. 
 For the shaming pleasure of voyeuristic torture, he has substituted the pleasure of having his nose rubbed in it. 
 Like many sexually na&iuml;ve people, Lewis supposed that if he eliminated the consciously erotic elements of his sexuality from the surface of life, he would be able to dispel the habits and characteristics of which these particular tastes were a mere symptom. 
 Perhaps if he had worried less about them, and taken a less self-reproachful line, the outlines of his personality would have softened with the years. 
 Perhaps, too, if they had known about his &bquo;tastes&equo;, his friends would have been less puzzled by two of his most mysterious personality traits: his delight in verbal bullying, of students or intellectual opponents, and his apparently cheerful domestic enslavement to Mrs Moore. 
 The college grind of meetings and tutorials went on. 
 Lewis had by now settled into the role of tutor, but he did not relax in it. 
 His pupils neatly all felt (particularly the first pupil of the morning, at ten a.m., who watched him lay down his steel-nibbed pen with an air of resignation) that tutorials were an interruption to what he considered his real work. 
 And he had a notorious asperity for which he was afterwards sometimes penitent. 
 Treating his pupils to the compliment of rational disagreement sometimes spilled over into a verbal contest so fierce that the young person concerned was abashed or even frightened. 
 The feelings may be imagined of the pupil who rashly let fall a slighting reference to Sohrab and Rustum , to be answered by Lewis's brandishing an old regimental sword of his brother's which stood in the corner of his room and shouting, &bquo;The sword must settle this!&equo; 
 The experience of the others was probably less dramatic, but they all knew the sharp edge of Lewis's tongue. 
 &bquo;As to yesterday morning, I was a bit &bquo;short&equo;. 
 If you take into account the fact that I have been up till after midnight every night since Monday, that I have a cold, and that that morning I had been talking on a sore throat from 9.30 to 1 o'clock, perhaps you will understand.&equo; 
 Quite as remarkable as the original display of ill temper was the graciousness which prompted him to apologize for it. 
 &bquo;The truth is,&equo; he admitted to Alan Griffiths, &bquo;I have a constant temptation to over asperity&hellip; even when there is no subjective anger to prompt me: it comes, I think, from the pleasure of using the English language forcibly &mdash; i.e. it is not a species of Ira  but of Superbia.  
 &bquo;  Some pupils came in time to like it; not simply because the outbursts were part of Lewis &bquo;act&equo;, but because he was conscientious teacher, who was concerned, as the Great Knock had been, to wage war on sloppy language and sloppy thinking. 
 John Lawlor, a pupil from 1936 onwards, said of himself that he &bquo;passed from dislike and hostility to stubborn affection, and then to gratitude for the weekly bout in which no quarter was asked or given&equo;. 
 In this he almost certainly spoke for the majority of Lewis's pupils. 
 As a pupil of slightly later vintage, Derek Brewer, remarked, &bquo;Many of his pupils became teachers of one sort or another and all, or most of them, became his friends.&equo; 
 That is pretty high praise; and though there are some obvious exceptions, they were fewer as the years went by. 
 A tutor who could command the unhesitating affection and intellectual respect of so miscellaneous a collection of men as Derek Brewer (later Master of Emmanuel College, Cambridge), the drama critic Kenneth Tynan, the publisher Charles Monteith and the poet John Wain was clearly doing his job. 
 One aspect of the Lewis regime about which the majority of his pupils had some misgivings, however, was the termly dinner he gave for them. 
 He called it the &bquo;English binge&equo;. 
 It was a dinner held at his own expense in a private room at Magdalen, and it was a symptom of his great generosity. 
 But it was also a throwback to a form of behaviour which, however natural it might have seemed to officer cadets in the First World War, was excruciatingly embarrassing to succeeding generations of Magdalen men. 
 The idea of the evening was primarily to get drunk, and this was a matter about which Lewis was exuberantly insistent. 
 The conversation had to be what he called &bquo;bawdry. 
 &bquo;Nothing above the belly or below the knee tonight!&equo; he exclaimed on one of these evenings, savouring the rowdy songs and bawdy rhymes which resulted. 
 One of his pupils, Roger Lancelyn Green, has commented on a letter which Lewis wrote to Warnie describing the &bquo;English binge&equo; at Christmas 1931. 
 &bquo;Bawdy ought to be outrageous and extravagant,&equo; Lewis had written; and Green tells us, &bquo;he proceeds to give a very mild example.&equo; 
 It is a remnant which &bquo;dates&equo; Green and reveals our later generation as less innocent and more acquiescent. 
 Green does not quote  the example, which is a song about an angry father who suspects that his daughter has been ravished by the protagonist of the ballad. 
 What Lewis calls &bquo;the good part&equo; goes as follows: 
 Hark! 
 I hear a step on the stair! 
 Sounds to me like an angry father, With a pistol in either hand, Looking for the man that screwed his daughter (Rum ti-iddle-ey etc). 
 I have seized him by the hair of his head And shoved it into a bucket of water And I screwed his pistols up his arse A dam sight harder than I screwed his daughter (Rum ti-iddle-ey etc). 
 Lewis spent Christmas Day 1931 transcribing this ditty for Warnie, who had returned for his last spell of service in Shanghai. 
 With the role of the heavy father properly cast &mdash; stumping up the stairs with a desperate expression and his two pistols, he wrote, &bquo;this anticlimax, this adding of injury to insult, seems to me irresistible&equo;. 
 He regretted that bawdry of this kind was the &bquo;only living folk-art left to us. 
 If our English binge had been held in a medieval university we should have had, mixed with the bawdy songs, tragical and even devotional pieces, equally authorless and handed on from mouth to mouth in the same way, with the same individual variations.&equo; 
 One somehow thinks that only Lewis could have stepped, with a few vigorous steps, from a defence of drunken all-male &bquo;stag&equo; evenings to a vivid illustration of the life and literature of the Middle Ages. 
 REGRESS 1931&ndash;1936 
 Lewis was by now thirty-three years old. 
 By the age of thirty-three Keats and Shelley were dead; Byron had finished two-thirds of his major work. 
 Even a figure more comparable with Lewis, G. K. Chesterton, had at this age published five of his most distinguished books, and discovered his own voice. 
 With Lewis this was not so, and it is probably vain to look for reasons. 
 We can account for what he was doing with his time, but this is not the same thing as explaining how or why the tone of voice &mdash; that vigour, that distinctively Lewisian freshness and vitality &mdash; was so long in coming. 
 What we do know is that his full conversion to Christianity released in him a literary flow which only ceased with death. 
 From then on, works of scholarship, fantasy, literary appreciation, and apologetics poured from his ever-fertile brain. 
 The poetry got much better too. 
 The angel's song at the end of The Pilgrim's Regress  is in a different league from the unhappier patches of Spirits in Bondage  or Dymer . 
 Terse, poignant, and well made, it says what could only be said in poetry. 
 The thought, perhaps, is borrowed from Tolkien, whose immortals cannot see why men dread death. 
 ('We who bear the ever-mounting burden of the years do not clearly understand this. 
 &bquo;) But the perspective is very distinctly that of Lewis, who was to spend nearly all his literary energies imagining what the world would look like if seen from heaven. 
 Lewis began to write The Pilgrim's Regress , appropriately enough, on a return visit to Northern Ireland to stay with Arthur Greeves in the spring of 1932. 
 &bquo;We have come to Puritania,&equo; he said, &bquo;and that was my father's house. 
 I see that my father and mother are gone already beyond the brook. 
 I had much I would have said to them. 
 But it is no matter.&equo; 
 The book owes its title and framework to Bunyan, but it is much more satirical in tone and purpose than The Pilgrim's Progress . 
 Read today, its contemporary references seem crude and dead as mutton. 
 Anyone can work out who the &bquo;subspecies&equo; Marxomanni, Mussolimini and Swastici are meant to represent, but they do not really play an important part in the story, since we can feel that John, the Pilgrim, is not really tempted or overwhelmed by them, any more than Lewis ever felt the slightest inclination to become a Maminst or a Fascist. 
 Similarly, the pre-First World War diction now creates moments of unintentional comedy, as when the figure of Christ says to John, &bquo;You must play fair,&equo; or when John's plunge into the pool of faith is described as &bquo;he took a header&equo;. 
 (Lewis, incidentally, had been &mdash; taught to dive only very lately, by Owen Barfield, an event which he considered full of religious significance.) 
 Any fair-minded critic of The Pilgrim's Regress  must also admit that some of its conceits are unfortunate. 
 The identification of lust with &bquo;brown girls&equo; probably had no racial connotations in that innocently discriminatory age; but the scenes towards the end where the Witch tries to capture John with her wiles do leave the disconcerting impression that Lewis thought of Christianity as little more than a good &bquo;cure&equo; for lust. 
 All that must be conceded, and yet the book's virtues greatly outweigh its faults. 
 Some of the contemporary satire -John Betjeman as &bquo;Victoriana&equo;, Edith Sitwell as &bquo;Glugly&equo; &mdash; is still quite funny. 
 ('She was very tall and lean as a post&hellip; 
 She waddled to and fro with her toes pointing in&hellip; 
 Finally she made some grunts and said: &bquo;Globol obol ookle ogle globol gloogle gloo.&equo;) 
 The assaults on the neo-Thominst revival of the period are also well made. 
 There are sentences in &bquo;Neo-Angular's&equo; speeches which are echoed almost word for word in the essays of T. S. Eliot and the letters of Evelyn Waugh. 
 So you have met Mother Kirk? 
 No wonder that you are confused. 
 You had no business to talk to her except through a qualified Steward&hellip; 
 Reason is divine. 
 But how should you understand her? 
 You are a beginner. 
 For you, the only safe commerce with reason is to learn from your superiors the dogmata in which her deliverances have been codified for general use. 
 The book has the unmistakable stamp of Lewis upon it. 
 There is the tremendous narrative verve; there are the flights of true sublimity side by side with the knockabout of comedy and debate; there is, above all, the sense which informs nearly all his religious writing, that a human being's relationship with God is the great Romance of life. 
 The subtitle is An Allegorical Apology for Christianity, Reason and Romanticism , and it is important to remember that for Lewis the three things went together. 
 Tolkien had taught him that the inability to believe in Christianity was primarily a failure of the imagination . 
 This insight had enabled Lewis to recover all the things in art and in life which he had been enjoying since imaginative awareness dawned. 
 In Puritania, religion had been the stuff of cant, of laws, of promised punishments for behaviour which the Pilgrim's inner conscience could not condemn. 
 But there had also been this other vision &mdash; of the &bquo;green wood full of primroses&equo; &mdash; which he had glimpsed through a hole in the wall, and which promised all the things which Lewis and Greeves had come to label &bquo;It&equo; or &bquo;Joy&equo;. 
 These were the pleasures he got from the beauties of nature, from the music of Wagner, from the watercolours of Beatrix Potter, from the books of William Morris, George MacDonald and Wordsworth. 
 What he discovered in his &bquo;regress&equo; was that all these things were echoes of the heavenly places. 
 In the allegory, it is not easy to work out the extent to which the regress is a return to Puritanian values. 
 The double values of the stewards, and the ethics based on fear of punishment are rejected. 
 But Mother Kirk &mdash; a sort of Anglican version of Langland's Mother Church &mdash; is certainly John's guide in the final stages of his journey. 
 J. R. R. Tolkien, to whom Lewis read aloud The Pilgrim's Regress , liked the book. 
 Thirty years later, however, Tolkien saw that there was more in the word &bquo;regress&equo; than had immediately met his ear. 
 He saw that Lewis would not re-enter Christianity by a new door but by the old one: at least in the sense that in taking it up again he would also take up again or reawaken the prejudices so sedulously planted in childhood and boyhood. 
 He would become again a Northern Ireland Protestant &mdash; though with a difference, certainly: he was no longer a resident; he was learned; he had the wonderful gifts both of imagination and a clear and analytical mind; and above all his faith came of Grace to which he responded heroically, in patience and self-sacrifice &mdash; when he was aware of himself. 
 Tolkien's contention was that something he called &bquo;the ulsterior motive&equo; &mdash; the bogey of Lewis's Ulster background &mdash; lurked beneath the surface of his imagination, and rose when he was off his guard to make him brutal in manners, crude or illogical in thought. 
 Anyone who has studied Lewis's work must know what Tolkien meant, though the &bquo;ulsterior motive&equo; is much more apparent in Lewis's reported speech (particularly in speech lubricated by the wine of High Table or the beer of Oxfordshire pubs) than on the printed page. 
 But Tolkien's censure, written from the standpoint of one who had himself hardened in a sentimental devotion to the religion of his boyhood, must not be accepted without qualifications. 
 With his conscious self, Lewis had a very distinct loathing of Ulster Protestantism. 
 When he attended St Mark's, Dundela, for the first time after his conversion, he was repelled by the sense that &bquo;these good Produsdands&equo; went there to express party solidarity rather than religious feeling; and he found his Irish relations almost universally repulsive. 
 He and Warnie, for example, had decided that they would erect a memorial window to their parents in St Mark's, but it was a decision they quickly came to regret when the Lewis, Hamilton and Ewart cousins all weighed in with suggestions of what should go into the window. 
 The incumbent of St Mark's, the Rev. Claude Lionel Chavasse, suggested that the window might contain a view of St Mark's itself in the background. 
 Lewis immediately guessed that this suggestion came not from Chavasse but from his Aunt Lily, and in the irrational way that such family meddling irritates, this prompted an extraordinary flow of anger. 
 He described the case to Warnie: 
 It just occurs to me as I write that Chavasse in this matter is probably the unwilling mouthpiece of the Select Vestry: I daresay even that monstrous regiment of women, incarnated in Lily Ewart, is really at the bottom of it. 
 Zounds! &mdash; I'd like a few minutes at the bottom of her! 
 No &bquo;thought inform&equo; would there &bquo;stain my cheek&equo;: a firm hand rather would stain Goth hers. 
 He disliked the ethos of Irish Protestantism and he did not believe in its doctrines. 
 If the mark of a reborn evangelical is a devotion to the Epistles of St Paul and in particular to the doctrine of Justification by Faith, then there can have been few Christian converts less evangelical than Lewis. 
 When he has been a Christian for three years, we find him, in the pages of his brother's diary, reading The Epistle to the Romans, the greatest exposition in Scripture of the themes of Original Sin, Grace and Justification by Faith. 
 jack&equo;, we discover, &bquo;has been reading this epistle with a commentary but could get no help from it.&equo; 
 In later years, when Lewis showed Mere Christianity  to four clergymen, of four different denominations, for their criticisms, he received hostile comments from two of the four. 
 One of these two, inevitably, was his old pupil and sparring partner Alan Griffiths (by then a Roman Catholic monk, Dom Bede Griffiths), who claimed that Lewis undervalued the doctrine of the Atonement. 
 Perhaps more fundamental than this was the criticism he received from a Methodist minister that the book does not really mention, let alone do justice to, the central Christian doctrine of Justification by Faith. 
 Lewis came to the faith by means of what one could loosely term Neo-Platonism. 
 It was the sense of another world which drew him; the sense he got from MacDonald (a convert to Broad Church Anglicanism from Congregationalism) of Heaven being penetrable through dreams and the subconscious and the exercise of the imagination. 
 It was the conviction of Tolkien (a Roman Catholic) that truth is best discerned through myth which finally tipped the balance. 
 In all this period he was influenced by Barfield (a disciple of Rudolph Steiner) and by rereading Plato himself, as well as by Neo-Platonist writers such as Dean Inge (Broad Church). 
 It is therefore a mistake to make too much of &bquo;the ulsterior motive,. 
 In actual devotional practice, Lewis was greatly guided by reading the Imitutio Christi  of Thomas &agrave; Kempis. 
 The hallmarks of Thomas &agrave; Kempis's approach to the religious life are a rigorous inner self-discipline and a conformity, for reasons of humility, to the existing forms of Christianity as met from day to day wherever you happen to be. 
 As to the outward forms of religion, Lewis decided from the moment that he became a Christian that he should attend his college chapel on weekday mornings and his parish church on Sundays. 
 As it happened, the ritual of Magdalen chapel was &bquo;Low Church&equo; and that of the Headington Quarry church was &bquo;High&equo;. 
 With his background in Ulster, where he had seen the blasphemous absurdity of Christians hating one another on the grounds of historical or ritual difference, he was always rigorously &bquo;non-party&equo; in his Anglicanism. 
 His non-ritualism was still, in the early 1930s, perfectly normal and there were many Anglicans who would have shared it, though perhaps not all would have been quite so dogged about it as he. 
 On Palm Sunday, 1934, for example, Lewis and his brother attended the liturgy at the parish church in Headington Quarry. 
 The vicar &bquo;came down to the steps at the top of the nave, accompanied by a server with a basket of palms and we all went up and got one except J&lsqb;ack&rsqb;.&equo; 
 This might be thought to be the ulsterior motive surfacing; but if so, it has to be balanced by Lewis's unconquerable distaste for hymns (not a markedly Protestant trait). 
 At the Quarry church, if he attended a choral service, it was his invariable custom to leave during the singing of the last hymn. 
 He had, in fact, an almost Tridentine attitude to the liturgy. 
 In spite of his distaste for &bquo;frills&equo;, he saw church-going as something one did out of obedience; something which shaped the life of prayer and reminded each individual that he or she was a &bquo;member incorporate in the blessed company of all faithful people&equo;; but not something which needed to be added to, still less enjoyed as a hobby. 
 Warnie, incidentally, was less brave than Jack, and dutifully went up to fetch his palm, in an agony of embarrassment. 
 &bquo;I think that there is a real risk that an imaginative child may get the impression that a bit of palm is in some way a magical charm,&equo; he considered. 
 To be on the safe side, he burnt his when he got home, presumably unaware that this was, liturgically, the &bquo;correct&equo; and Catholic thing to do, though some forty-six weeks too early. 
 By now, the household of The Kilns had taken on the shape which it was to maintain until well after the Second World War. 
 Warnie had retired from me Army at the earliest possible opportunity, in December 1932, and moved in with Jack and Minto as a permanent fixture. 
 He was thirty-seven years old. 
 The question of what he was to do with himself for the rest of his life was never properly resolved in his mind or anyone else's, which perhaps accounts for his periodic assaults on the whiskey bottle &mdash; what Minto called &bquo;Warnie's benders&equo;. 
 Being Irish herself, and the sister of a man who had gone mad with syphilis, she was rather more tolerant of Warnie's foibles than he was of hers. 
 Among the innumerable items which they brought away from Little Lea &mdash; a lumpish wardrobe to which Jack had a sentimental attachment, for instance &mdash; there were countless letters, diaries and family papers stretching back to the lifetime of their Lewis and Hamilton grandparents. 
 Warnie was a natural historian, and he set himself the task of putting all these documents into chronological order. 
 The real interest of the past, he wrote, &bquo;lies in the answer to the question, How did the ordinary undistinguished man live?&hellip; and it is with a view to providing posterity with an addition to such all too scanty materials that the papers&hellip; have been embodied in permanent form.&equo; 
 Undergraduate pupils of Jack's throughout the middle years of the 1930s got used to passing through the outer drawing-room of his rooms at Magdalen where sat the mysterious figure of Captain Lewis, typing with two fingers on an ancient black portable. 
 The finished result, eleven bound volumes of single-spaced pages, is a testimony to Warnie's extraordinary patience, as well as to his seemingly inexhaustible appetite for contemplating his own immediate past. 
 Every note, every school report, every passing wheeze of the P'daytabird is here; and since, by a strange series of chances, the Lewis Papers  now reside in an air-conditioned cavern in the suburbs of Chicago, we may suppose that they will survive for ever, perhaps long after Oxford and Ulster have been lost to sight. 
 Jack never seems to have regarded the proximity of his brother, even while doing his teaching, as a burden; if anything, it was the reverse. 
 But the possibilities of domestic tension were increased by Warnie's presence a hundredfold. 
 Both Warnie and Minto were jealous of anyone who claimed Jack's love; this meant that they were bound to be jealous of one another, since for both of them Jack was the most important person in the universe. 
 Shortly after moving into The Kilns, Minto had engaged a gardener to help her with the eight acres of ground. 
 His name was Fred Paxford, and he lived in a small wooden bungalow on the other side of the brick kilns. 
 Paxford was a &bquo;character&equo;, given to looking on the black side of every passing scene, and to lugubrious murmurings of &bquo;Abide with Me&equo; and other hymns while he toiled. 
 His pessimistic character was fairly faithfully reproduced in Pudlleglum, the Marshwiggle in The Silver Chair . 
 In spite of Paxford's strong left-wing views, Minto idolized him and allowed him to occupy the same sort of position in her household as John Brown had occupied at the court of Queen Victoria. 
 He was consulted as an oracle on all occasions, however inappropriate, and this was something which Warnie found insufferably annoying. 
 His diaries chronicle each phase of irritation with novelistic detail. 
 I quite suddenly got very bored with M's conversation tonight. 
 She has lately developed a tiresome habit of becoming a mere compendium of Paxford's views; every conceivable topic is met with a reply beginning &bquo;Paxford says&equo;. 
 I am resigned to being addressed by the new name of Pax-Wanxie, but if she is to become a mere conduit of the Paxford philosophy it will be a very great bore. 
 Further, it makes me angry with myself to find that the perfectly natural and utterly unfair result is that I begin to dislike Paxford, no exercise of the will convincing me that it is not the unfortunate P. who is boring me with his views on everything under the sun. 
 A magnificent example of the &bquo;Paxford says&equo; routine is provided when Maureen and Minto have been into Oxford to get two wireless sets on approval. 
 The scene is the kitchen at The Kilns and both sets are plugged in. 
 MAUREEN: Well the A set certainly has the better tone. 
 MINTO: Oh no, dear, Paxford says the B set has a lovely tone; he says the A set is tinny. 
 MAUREEN: Well, it blurs the sound: you can't hear the &bquo;Underneath&equo; of any music. 
 MINTO: Paxford and I were saying it was so clear. 
 MAUREEN: Then it's easier to find stations on the A set. 
 MINTO: Paxford says the B set is easier; Paxford says he got forty stations on it: he made it work beautifully. 
 MAUREEN (trying the B set which emits a series of siren-like whoops and then a muffled jazz band): It doesn't seem particularly easy to get ANY station on the B. 
 MINTO: Ask Paxford, dear: he'll show you how to work it in the morning. 
 MYSELF (Internally): Bugger Paxford. 
 (Aloud): Well, goodnight, I'm off to bed. 
 MINTO: Goodnight Pax-Warnie. 
 Paxford says &mdash; (I close the door and go to bed). 
 Jack avoided being a witness to these scenes much of the time by residing in college. 
 For half the year, he would sleep at The Kilns. 
 But during the three eight-week terms his routine was to sleep in college, at least for the days in the middle of the week. 
 If Maureen was at home, she would drive into Oxford to fetch him home for lunch. 
 Sometimes Paxford fulfilled this office. 
 And if neither of them was at home Lewis would return to The Kilns by bus; so Minto was visited each day. 
 There was, indeed, never a day, except when he was away on short holidays, during which he did not spend some time in her company, from the time of their first association in 1919 until her death in 1951. 
 This has been represented as some kind of martyrdom on Lewis's part; and doubtless, like any long-term relationship, it called for reserves of patience and good humour on both sides. 
 But it is absurd to suppose that Lewis had nothing to gain from Minto's company, or that all thEir time was spent discussing domestic trivia (much as she and Lewis both enjoyed  such discussions). 
 A recent pen has asserted that Mrs Moore was never seen with a book in her hands. 
 It is true that she was not academic; this was part of her charm for Lewis. 
 But even the most rudimentary reading of his many surviving letters will reveal passages which speak of the pleasures of reading with or to Mrs Moore. 
 In 1936, for example, we find them reading Virginia Woolf's Orlando  together; and in 1943, Lewis wrote to a friend that Minto was reading Jane Eyre . 
 She, for her part, accepted the fact that he was gregarious and, like the great majority of men in those days, tended to congregate with members of his own sex. 
 Our social mores have changed so much that it is easy to single out as personal characteristics those which were actually held in common by neatly everyone. 
 Lewis, for instance, is frequently spoken of as a man who enjoyed male coteries, as though, in the 1930s, the regiments, the London clubs, the Oxford and 
 Cambridge colleges and the City companies were all overflowing with &bquo;mixed&equo; company. 
 This simply was not so, and the fact that Lewis spent evenings in the company of male friends was not what distinguished him. 
 Even to speak of those by-now famous evenings as a coterie is to imply that they were both more formal and more enclosed than was the case. 
 For example, one day in 1934 or 1935, Lewis had influenza. 
 In those days, if you were ill in England, the doctor visited you, rather than expecting you to stagger to the surgery. 
 Minto summoned the man who had recently taken over the Headington practice from the household's former practitioner, Dr Wood. 
 The doctor who appeared was R. E. Havard, and after five minutes of talk about influenza (Lewis had rather a fondness for discussing symptoms man to man), they fell to some ethical or philosophical talk. 
 Lewis, it struck Havard, a recent convert to Roman Catholicism and a devotee of Thomas Aquinas, took a remarkably idealistic, Berkeleyan view of things. 
 On the strength of this exchange, Lewis realized that Havard would be a man who would enjoy meeting some of the people who had taken to dropping into his rooms at Magdalen on Thursday evenings. 
 Not long afterwards, therefore, Havard was invited to call at Magdalen. 
 Warnie was there to welcome him and to dispense drinks. 
 Others present included Lord David Cecil, who had lately come back to Oxford to teach English Literature at New College, and Adam Fox, the college chaplain. 
 Dyson and Tolkien were also there. 
 Lewis was the presiding genius; the meeting took place in his rooms and it was he who chose the moment to ask if anyone present had any work in progress which they wanted to read aloud. 
 It was in this way that Havard first came to hear many of Tolkien's tales, David Cecil's Two Quiet Lives , and reflections on Dante by Colin Hardie (who taught Classics at Magdalen and was also a regular member of the circle), as well as many of Lewis's own works. 
 This was no ordinary gathering of men. 
 The level of wit and comment, sometimes abusive, sometimes adulatory, about what was read was consistently high. 
 How many &bquo;literary&equo; men, happily ensconced in a coterie, would ask along their doctors? 
 Can we imagine a GP being made to feel welcome in the Bloomsbury set? 
 But one also sees in the adoption of Havard the vivid contrast which existed between the clubbable Lewis liked by his friends and the figure he presented on the domestic scene. 
 It is easy to get the impression that he was the only one to suffer in this area, constantly put upon by Mrs Moore or bored by her daughter. 
 Seen from the women's angle, things could sometimes appear differently. 
 No sooner had Havard become a friend than Lewis casually asked one day why Minto and Maureen did not entertain the doctor's family; have his wife to tea and allow his children to swim in the quarry pond. 
 Minto was always happy to entertain young people, and the invitation was issued. 
 The Havards arrived at The Kilns, Maureen played tennis with them, swam with them and provided them with the sandwiches and cakes which she and her mother had been preparing all day. 
 They liked the Havards, and were pleased to have met them. 
 Not so Jack, who appeared to have forgotten that it was his idea to invite them in the first place. 
 &bquo;Really, Maureen,&equo; he bellowed at her, &bquo;the friends you insist on inviting round become uglier and uglier. 
 I never saw such an ugly  family as the Havards.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, the doctor continued to be a friend whom he enjoyed meeting in the evenings. 
 The roughness and sheer wild irrationality of Lewis's domestic persona were matched by the genuinely warm-hearted impulse which had led him to befriend Havard in the first place. 
 Havard, who came to be nicknamed &bquo;Humphrey&equo; (because this was what one member of the group thought was his name) and sometimes the UQ or Useless Quack, came to be a much loved friend of them all. 
 His presence among them was highly symptomatic. 
 There was nothing of &bquo;the ivory tower&equo;, nothing &bquo;donnish&equo;, about Lewis's intelligence. 
 In all his talk, and in his writings, he addressed the sympathetic, lively minded &bquo;general reader&equo; or &bquo;average man&equo;. 
 Even his learned writings have the readability and freshness of appeal of &bquo;popular&equo; work; indeed, the distinction between &bquo;learned&equo; and &bquo;popular&equo; is one which seems in reading Lewis to be quite false. 
 And one feels this even when he is at his most learned. 
 In all available time not devoted to teaching, to domestic life or to friendship, Lewis had been hard at work, ever since the late 1920s, on the book which was to become The Allegory of Love . 
 Letters to his father in 1928 revealed how he had grown to love the oldest part of the Bodleian &mdash; Duke Humfrey's Library. 
 &bquo;If only one could smoke and if only there were upholstered chairs, this would be one of the most delightful places in the world.&equo; 
 Others who have appreciated the painted ceilings, mullioned windows and carved bays of that supremely beautiful room must have felt that one of its great charms resided in the absence of modern furniture and tobacco smoke. 
 Be that as it may, it was here mat Lewis began to build up his encyclopaedic knowledge of late medieval literature. 
 As far back as 1925, he had dreamed of a complete history of the love allegory from Ovid to Spenser, and by 1928 two chapters of a more modest scheme, starting with the Proven&ccedil;al troubadours, were finished. 
 But Lewis's conception of the book changed as he himself changed, and nothing much more got written until 193 1. 
 The substance of his book &mdash; the history of allegorical love literature from the early Middle Ages to the late sixteenth century &mdash; was worked out in lectures to undergraduates. 
 Lewis had a distinctive manner of lecturing, which was not greatly altered over the years. 
 He began speaking as soon as he entered the lecture-room, which he generally did five minutes after me hour. 
 He finished five minutes before the hour. 
 He spoke slowly, sometimes at dictation speed, if quoting an author whom he thought his audience should not miss. 
 The lectures were delivered in a full, deep, slightly Irish version of the Oxford voice ('Lat'n&equo; for Latin, and rolled Rs), enlivened with amusing analogies and examples from modern life and literature. 
 He had his father's gift for sensing what sort of an audience he was addressing, and adapting his matter accordingly. 
 He told jokes well. 
 His lectures were above all popular because he packed them with information. 
 Clever undergraduates liked them because of their enormous range. 
 Lazy undergraduates liked them because Lewis did half their work far them &mdash; providing summaries of books they would never get around to reading themselves, and lightening his commentaries with entertaining asides. 
 But it was not until the early 1930s that The Allegory of Love  began to take shape as a book, and it was not finished until 1935. 
 It is a phenomenal compendium of lightly worn, deeply read learning, and in every page we see why Lewis was such an inspired teacher. 
 He unselfconsciously expects the reader to be as interested as he is in Jean de Meung or Alanus. 
 In consequence we are, or wish that we were. 
 What is more, it is a big-hearted, generous book. 
 Lewis does not set out to make himself cleverer than the reader, stili less cleverer than the authors whom he is discussing. 
 Like an enthusiastic guide in a foreign country, he is anxious to share with us the unexpected treasures he has found and which we might, without his help, have missed. 
 Indeed, if he has a fault as a critic it is in his boyishly enthusiastic generosity towards authors &mdash; Thomas Usk, Lydgate &mdash; who are not really as interesting as he makes them sound. 
 It is not that he lies  about them, rather that only a patient and omnivorous prospector would have found the particular treasures which he quotes. 
 The treasures are real enough. 
 But who would guess, for example, having read some of the Lydgate he quotes &mdash; 
 And as I stoode myself alloone upon the Nuwe Yeare night, I prayed unto the frosty moone, with her pale light &mdash; what a dull time we should have if we tried to read our way through The Fall of Princes ? 
 Supremely, however, this generous desire to show us the best in an author is manifested in his long chapter about Spenser, and there he marks himself out not as a kindly eccentric, but as a pioneer of modern taste. 
 Thanks very largely to Lewis, Spenser is now once more regarded as one of the greatest English poets, having sunk into almost total obscurity before The Allegory of Love  was written. 
 Moreover, in showing us what he loves about Tbe Faerie Queene , he shows us in embryo what he hardly knows at this point himself: the sort of books which he himself will excel at. 
 In his descriptions of Spenser's Christian purpose, his blending of allegory with adventure, his use of homely familiar figures, like St George, side by side with figures from a much older mythology and figures from his own imagination, Lewis is actually writing a recipe for how to construct the Narnia chronicles. 
 There is never a moment's dullness in The Allegory of Love . 
 Its readability partly consists in the enthusiasm which has already been mentioned, and in the liveliness and unexpectedness of the examples: the comparison of Boiardo's fantasies with Mickey Mouse; the likening of Spenser's Radigund to Simla memsahibs in Kipling. 
 But the essential and unifying feature of the book is the voice of the author. 
 One could say very certainly, therefore, that the book could not be complete until Lewis as a &bquo;character&equo; was complete. 
 He is not afraid to come before us in this book as a full-blown figure, someone who is quite recognizable (from earliest school letters and the accounts of Kirkpatrick) as &bquo;the real Lewis&equo; but who is also, for the first time, &bquo;found&equo; as an artistic voice. 
 Johnson once described the ideal happiness which he would choose, if he were regardless of futurity. 
 My own choice, with the same reservation, would be to read the Italian epic &mdash; to be always convalescent from some small illness and always seated in a window that overlooked the sea, there to read these poems eight hours of each happy day. 
 Part of the pleasure of reading Lewis, when it is a pleasure, is meeting with this figure. 
 Few academics would think it proper to bring themselves before the reader in this way, particularly in a work of learning. 
 But the important point is not that they would hesitate to do it, but that we would not be interested if they did. 
 Part of Lewis's discovery of himself as a writer was the discovery of a means of presenting himself to the reader. 
 It is the rhetoric of Romanticism &mdash; &bquo;the egotistical sublime&equo; &mdash; and not everyone liked or likes it. 
 Barfield, to whom he dedicated The Allegory of Love , describes a moment when he read Lewis's &bquo;Open Letter to Dr Tillyard&equo;. 
 Tillyard, one of the foremost Milton scholars of his day, had suggested that we can only fully understand Paradise Lost  when we understand the man who wrote it. 
 For Lewis, this was &bquo;the personal heresy&equo;, a vivid example of which would be the present biography, which seeks to shed light on a man's work by researching into the recesses of his mind and the outward events of his life. 
 It is typical of Lewis's later self that he should have seen no virtue at all in Tillyard's approach, and that furthermore he should have labelled it &bquo;heresy&equo;. 
 What struck Barfield, however, was the manner in which this slightly absurd debate was conducted. 
 &bquo;We have both learnt our dialectic in the academic arena where knocks that would frighten the London literary coteries are given and taken in good part; and even where you think me sometimes too pert you will not suspect me of malice. 
 If you honour me with a reply it will be in kind; and then, God defend the right!&equo; 
 Barfield describes how he read this sentence, slapped down the book and shouted: &bquo;I don't believe it! 
 It's pastiche!&equo; 
 While such thoughts were inevitable for those who knew Lewis before the great change came upon his life, it was not quite right to speak of &bquo;pastiche&equo;. 
 It was all a bit odder than that. 
 After he became a Christian, Lewis did completely change his view not only of his own personality but of human personality in general. 
 &bquo;My own empirical self is becoming more important,&equo; he wrote to Barfield, &bquo;and this is exactly the opposite of self-love.&equo; 
 It is said that when he heard his own voice on the radio, some seven years after writing this letter, Lewis was surprised and in some measure disconcerted. 
 In a similar way he might have been surprised by the figure he cut in prose or come to that in life. 
 But he was in no sense putting on an act. 
 The strange locutions, the shabby clothes, the combination of kindliness and brusqueness, the strong &bquo;personality&equo; but increasing impersonality  of his conversation and interests, were all part of the same process. 
 It is comparable with the oddness which might visit all our outward appearances if we stopped looking in mirror. 
 The only contrived thing about it was the initial impulse, which interpreted the New Testament injunction to deny self as to &bquo;live without an image of the self&equo;. 
 The &bquo;image&equo; of C. S. Lewis, which many were to find rebarbative, was not, as they imagined, stage-managed or rehearsed, but it was none the less odd for that. 
 The Allegory of Love  was sent in manuscript to the offices of the Oxford University Press in London. 
 As with much else in Lewis's life, it seems as though there was a Providence in its journey, for it landed on the desk of a man celled Charles Williams. 
 THE INKLINGS 1936&ndash;1939 
 W. H. Auden, the rising star of the English poetic firmament, met Charles Williams about a year after Lewis did. 
 Auden had been asked by the Oxford University Press to prepare The Oxford Book of Light Verse , and he went along to discuss this with Williams at his office in Amen House. 
 At this period in his life, Auden was still a subscriber to the bundle of ideologies &mdash; leftist in politics, atheist in religion, Freudian in psychology &mdash; which went with being a 1930s intellectual. 
 Yet, in the presence of Williams, he felt &bquo;for the first time in my life&hellip; in the presence of personal sanctity&hellip; 
 I had met many good people before who made me feel ashamed of my own shortcomings, but in the presence of this man &mdash; we never discussed anything but literary business &mdash; I did not feel ashamed. 
 I felt transformed into a person who was incapable of doing anything base or unloving.&equo; 
 T. S. Eliot, who published many of Williams's books, felt the same. 
 Eliot had first met Williams &mdash; of all unlikely settings &mdash; at a tea-party given in London by Lady Ottoline Morrell, and felt &bquo;a kind of benediction&equo; emanating from this curious bespectacled creature who &bquo;appeared to combine frail physique with exceptional vitality&equo;. 
 Williams was a man who was able to hold many apparently contradictory ideas in harmony. 
 For example, he was able to reconcile membership of the Church of England (rather High) with belonging to such occult groups as the Order of the Golden Dawn. 
 Thomas Cranmer and Aleister Crowley were held in uneasy balance in his sympathies. 
 A rather unsatisfactory marriage was glorified in his imagination by high-sounding comparisons between himself and Dante, while his largely innocent office romances &mdash; which do not appear to have gone much beyond crushes on secretaries &mdash; were seen in terms of Launcelot's devotion to Guinevere and the threatened breaking of the Round Table. 
 Entirely self-educated and cockney in speech, Williams (rather like Blake in an earlier generation of London mystics) had an almost matter-of-fact awareness of the other world. 
 Angels &mdash; or &bquo;angelicals&equo; as he would have preferred to call them in his strange idiolect &mdash; were as real to him as omnibuses or mortgage repayments &mdash; and far more likely to obtrude into his consciousness. 
 In his theological writings, it is not always easy to see at what point he steps over the borderline between magic and religion. 
 In his fiction, there is an analogous blurring of distinctions, shocking or thrilling depending on the reader's taste. 
 Once Oxford University Press had accepted The Allegory of Love  for publication, it was sent to Charles Williams, who worked on their editorial desk in London. 
 It so happened, entirely by coincidence, that Coghill lent Lewis a copy of Williams's novel The Place of the Lion  at precisely this moment. 
 The merits contained in any Williams novel &mdash; and this one has many &mdash; are not purely literary. 
 Indeed, none of his novels is well shaped or well written. 
 The characters have improbable names and say improbable things. 
 The excitement of The Place of the Lion  is in its power to shake the reader up &mdash; to make us feel that the world is not the place we thought it was. 
 Here, for example, we meet a very ordinary young woman with the very extraordinary name of Damaris Tighe. 
 She is the sort of girl we might meet in the pages of a Barbara Pym &mdash;, a bit of a scholar, leading a spinsterly existence in a middle-class house in an English country village. 
 But she is in fact in grave theological and spiritual error. 
 Her &bquo;subject&equo; is the relationship between the angels of medieval philosophers and the Ideas and Forms in Plato. 
 Her paper The Eidoli and the Angeli  is not a suitable one to read to the little study group which meets in a neighbour's house: the group, it transpires, is actually in touch with the world of spirits. 
 These people are not, like Damaris, dry-as-dust, unbelieving intellectuals. 
 They are magicians and hierophants. 
 The Eidoli and the Angeli have power to invade even dull suburban English houses. 
 Damaris discovers that she has been guilty of intellectual sin in failing to believe, to realize imaginatively, the nature of the material she is studying. 
 This is rather like the moment in Lewis's life when he described philosophy as a subject and Barfield replied that to Plato, philosophy was not a subject but a way. 
 In The Place of the Lion , the Platonic archetypes of which objects and creatures in the world are but reflections or repetitions actually appear. 
 A lion which at the beginning of the book seems as though it might just be an escaped animal from a nearby zoo turns out to be the great Lion of Strength. 
 Perhaps the most extraordinary moment in the story is when the Butterfly appears and ali the butterflies in the world, in a great swarm, are absorbed back into his essence. 
 Lewis was overwhelmed by reading this book. 
 In the course of time, we begin to read Williams's influence in Lewis's own work &mdash; the Lion of Strength will reappear as Aslan, Judah's Lion, crushing the Serpent's Head in the Chronicles of Narnia, for example. 
 The immediate impact in February 1936 was inner and self-disciplinary. 
 &bquo;The reading of it has been a good preparation for Lent as far as I am concerned: for it shows me (through the heroine) the special sin of abuse of intellect to which all my profession are liable, more clearly than I ever saw before. 
 I have learned more than I ever knew about humility. 
 In fact, it has been a big experience.&equo; 
 If Lewis had been learning more than he knew before about humility, Williams had been learning more than he knew before about medieval literature. 
 At the very moment Lewis was finishing The Place of the Lion , Williams was reading The Allegory of Love  with great admiration. 
 &bquo;I regard your book as practically the only one that I have ever come across, since Dante, that shows the slightest understanding of what this very peculiar identity of love and religion means,&equo; Williams wrote, signing himself &bquo;Very gratefully yours&equo;. 
 The bulk of Lewis's book is pure literary history, though its earlier chapters refer to the strange pseudo-religion of Love which appears to have originated in twelfth-century Provence. 
 But it is entirely characteristic of Williams, whose head was always buzzing with Dante, and with the dangerous borderlines between sacred and profane love, that he should have read The Allegory  in that way. 
 Not long after this, Lewis and Williams met in London, as they continued to do at irregular intervals for the next three years. 
 They really were very different types. 
 Williams was emotionally exuberant, Lewis was profoundly buttoned up. 
 Lewis was plump, and rather coarse in appearance; Williams, who has been unkindly likened to a monkey, was actually rather ethereal in manner, with his long fingers and piercing eyes. 
 The ugly voice was not merely ugly; it was, by many accounts, half-hypnotic. 
 But different as they were in appearance, temperament and background, they discovered in common a strong belief in the absolute reality of the supernatural world. 
 It had been latent in Lewis ever since his encounter with God in Magdalen in the summer of 1929. 
 But to meet Williams was to make the belief yet more inescapable. 
 Many readers of The Place of the Lion  would be unable to convict the heroine of &bquo;sin&equo; at all. 
 She is a modern woman, with a modern consciousness. 
 How can we expect her to adopt the thought patterns of an earlier age? 
 This problem of historical relativism is one of the most besetting for anyone who wishes to read an old book without either getting it hopelessly wrong or, worse, assuming that the fact that we are modern and the author of the book &bquo;medieval&equo; or &bquo;old&equo; implies the superiority of one or the other. 
 Quite apart from the problem of the factual reliability of old books (is it so, for example, that there really are  such eidoli  and angeli  as Williams, Abelard, Pseudo-Dionysus and Plato believed?), we meet, much earlier, the simple difficulty of adjusting to old meanings. 
 Learning an old language &mdash; Middle English, Old French, Latin &mdash; is more than an exercise in matching modern word for old word. 
 It often involves the modern mind's entering into old concepts for which there is no modern equivalent. 
 What writers from past centuries believed about the world, the sky, themselves is often untranslatable, and we will never quite master it without the help of a guide. 
 This was the task Lewis set himself. 
 The Oxford lectures which he gave at this time were eventually to be published as The Discarded Image , perhaps the most completely satisfying and impressive book he ever published. 
 One could wish it eight times as long, a great compendium like Burton's Anatomy of Melancholy . 
 The subtitle of the book is An Introduction to Medieval and Renaissance Literature . 
 But this is not a work of criticism, nor an attempt to make you like The Faerie Queene  or the Confessio Amantis . 
 It is a wide-ranging analysis of the world picture which almost all the old writers would have taken for granted but which we, our minds fed with different mythologies and sciences, would very easily mistake. 
 How, for instance, did a medieval man look at the sky? 
 Having early disposed of the false idea that in the Middle Ages people believed in a flat earth, Lewis tells us to look at the sky itself. 
 You must go out on a starry night and walk about for half an hour trying to see the sky in terms of the old (Ptolemaic) cosmology. 
 Remember that you now have an absolute Up and Down. 
 The Earth is really the centre, really the lowest place; movement to it from whatever direction is downward movement. 
 As a modern, you located the stars at a great distance. 
 For distance you must now substitute that very special, and far less abstract, sort of distance which we call height: height which speaks immediately to our muscles and nerves. 
 The Medieval Model is vertiginous. 
 And the fact that the height of the stars in medieval astronomy is very small compared with their distance in modern, will turn out not to have the kind of importance you anticipated&hellip; 
 To look out on the night sky with modern eyes is like looking about one in a trackless forest &mdash; trees forever and no horizon. 
 To look up at the towering medieval universe is much more like looking at a great building. 
 The &bquo;space&equo; of modern astronomy may arouse terror, or bewilderment or vague reverie; the spheres of the old writers present us with an object in which the mind can rest, overwhelming in its greatness but satisfying in its harmony. 
 That is the sense in which our universe is romantic and theirs was classical. 
 By the time we have finished his chapter called &bquo;The Heavens&equo;, we have not only been informed about what the shape of the Ptolemaic universe was like, and how the belief in astrology worked, and how much knowledge was in our sense &bquo;scientific&equo; and how much &bquo;poetic&equo; or &bquo;mythological&equo;. 
 We have actually had our picture of the universe changed for ever. 
 By this, I do not mean mat Lewis has represented the medieval picture as &bquo;better&equo; than the modern; but he has shown us that both are merely pictures. 
 And in understanding the old picture so vividly, he has prepared us to appreciate, and to understand, many things which we either could not previously have hoped to understand, or which we had been looking at with half-open eyes. 
 He enhances our sense not only of the poets' universe &mdash; me cosmology of Dante and Milton, for example &mdash; but also of the symbolism used by painters and architects. 
 The past is still a foreign country, but we have been shown round it by the most genial and expert of guides. 
 Such basic matters as what people believed about their own bodies &mdash; made up of humours &mdash; or their pasts are juxtaposed with fascinating excursions into such areas of belief as the fairies and mythical beasts. 
 The range of reading and reference is prodigious. 
 Almost the most enjoyable thing of all is Lewis's ability to find traces of the &bquo;old world&equo; &mdash; beliefs which go back to Isadore of Seville or Macrobius or even as far as Plato &mdash; surviving in the pages of Fielding, Johnson or Wordsworth. 
 In The Discarded Image  his omnivorous reading taste is best synthesized. 
 If 1936 was a sort of annus mirabilis  far Jack, it was one of mixed happiness for Warnie. 
 The more Jack was in demand, as a lecturer, teacher, and man of letters, the more danger there was that Warnie would be thrown back on his own society or, worse, on that of Mrs Moore. 
 They really were not compatible, in spite of the affections they held in common. 
 There were other loves besides the love of Jack which bound them together. 
 At the end of January, for example, Warnie took Minto and Maureen to the Electra cinema to see the funeral of George V, and it was obvious that they were all much affected by it. 
 A fortnight later came the emotionally more disturbing death of Minto's dog, Mr Papwoth. 
 He was fourteen years old, blind and hardly able to walk, but they had grown much attached to him and could hardly endure the thought of his death. 
 In the last four days of his life, he could take nothing but whisky, administered to him by Warnie. 
 Jack too felt a painful void &mdash; &bquo;one remembers his old happy days, especially his puppyhood, with an ache&equo;, and for Minto it was grief &bquo;as if for a human being&equo;. 
 (They were eventually to get another dog &mdash; a very lively golden retriever, but before that Warnie had bought himself a boat.) 
 For J. R. R. Tolkien, the 1930s were a decade of continuous literary activity. 
 Unlike Lewis, who tended to write out his &bquo;stories or essays once, and only lightly revise them, Tolkien was a cautious and hesitant &bquo;maker&equo;. 
 He was in a continual process of rewriting his material and revising his mythology. 
 It would seem as though The Hobbit , for instance, the story which was to make him famous when it was published in 1937, had existed in embryonic form as early as about 1930. 
 Lewis was shown a version in 1932 and admired it enormously. 
 It was probably in 1937 that he and Tolkien had a conversation about their distaste for much of what was being published at that time. 
 &bquo;Tollers,&equo; said Lewis, &bquo;there is too little of what we really like in stories. 
 I am afraid we shall have to try and write some ourselves.&equo; 
 It was agreed that Tolkien should write a story about time-travel, and Lewis one about space-travel. 
 Tolkien's story, The Lost Road , seems to be the only example of his attempting to depict the twentieth,, in legends and lost tales of the old world, Alboin and Audoin by name. 
 In only a very few pages, we have left the twentieth century far behind and discovered that these two descend from the Lombardic heroes mentioned in the Old English poem Widsith  (Aelfwin and Eadwin); and since Aelfvin means &bquo;Elf-friend&equo;, we are not surprised to find ourselves drifting further back to the times when elves still walked the earth, before Numenor (the Atlantis of the Tolkien mythology) had sunk beneath the waves. 
 Sadly, The Lost Road  only survives as a fragment, and its story line is at a rudimentary stage of evolution. 
 There could be no greater indication of the contrast between me two friends' approach to their craft than a comparison between The Lost Road , tentatively built up stage by stage, with an infinite number of backward glances at the whole mythology that has gone before, and Lewis's self-confident brush strokes as he dashed off Out of the Silent Planet . 
 The latter is a book in which the author is firing on all cylinders. 
 It brings together Lewis the scholar, Lewis the voracious reader of anything from medieval schoolmen or Italian epic to modern science fiction, Lewis the Christian apologist, Lewis the Irish satirist in the savage tradition of Swift, Lewis the failed Romantic poet. 
 &bquo;Thus skidding violently from one side to the other, his youth approached the moment at which he would begin to be a person.&equo; 
 It is the story of a philologist (said to be loosely based on Tolkien, but in fact fairly unlike him: Tolkien recognized some of his own opinions and ideas Lewisified in the character) who, by a series of mishaps on a walking tour, comes to a house where two sinister scientists, Weston and Devine, are planning a visit to outer space. 
 They have everything ready except a human being to accompany them on their voyage. 
 They are going to a planet celled Malecandra (which turns out to be Mars) and, having made a previous recce there, they are under the impression that the inhabitants are fierce and eat men. 
 Hence their need for a human companion to placate the natives on their arrival. 
 Out of the Silent Planet  is a book which is quite un-put-downable. 
 The freshness of the writing reflects the boyish excitement with which Lewis wrote it and read it aloud, chapter by chapter, to his circle of friends. 
 Into the excitement is woven a tragic sense of the Fall, both as something Romantically conceived (the ruin of the earth, of Man's relationship with the beasts, of the erotic life) and as straight Christian theology. 
 The theology does not wage war on the story. 
 The eldils , the angelic beings who are at first invisible to Ransom, and their hierarchic sense of obedience are introduced gently. 
 And the sheer incidentals, the imagined languages of the Martian creatures, the poetic hrossi , the intellectual sorns  and the practical and commercially minded pfifftriggs  have a playful quality which, while being purely enjoyable, is not without satiric edge. 
 Many of the linguistic elements are borrowed from Tolkien and &mdash; which must have been more exasperating for their originator &mdash; changed and got &bquo;wrong&equo;. 
 Lewis's eldils , for instance, are little more than the angels of Judaeo-Christian tradition; but by confusing them linguistically with Tolkien's eldalie  (in The Silmarillion) , he implies that the elves of mat mythology are angelic, which they are not &mdash; they are simply elves. 
 Any irritation Tolkien felt at this appropriation of his own imaginative world did not prevent him from doing his best for the book. 
 Since it had been a great success when read aloud to &bquo;our local club&equo;, Tolkien had absolute confidence in submitting it to the publisher of The Hobbit , Stanley Unwin. 
 Tolkien's letter reveals that in the original draft of the story the hero is called not Ransom but Unwin ('The latter detail could I am sure be altered'). 
 Ransom, the name finally arrived at, develops its own significance in the sequels to Out of the Silent Planet . 
 Stanley Unwin turned the book down. 
 It had already been shown by Lewis to Dent, publisher of Dymer , who rejected it. 
 Unwin did, however, pass the typescript to a small publishing company called The Bodley Head. 
 They accepted it and it was swiftly published, appearing before the end of 1938. 
 It received high praise, often from surprising quarters. 
 &bquo;Here is a very good book,&equo; declared that sentimental realist Hugh Walpole. 
 &bquo;It is of thrilling interest as a story, but it is more than that; it is a kind of poem, and it has the great virtue of improving as it goes on. 
 It is a unique thing, fall of stars, cold and heat, flowers of the planets and a sharp sardonic humour.&equo; 
 Walpole himself, after a spell of agnosticism, had returned to Christian belief in middle age. 
 The Lewisian thing about the first of his space stories is precisely its blend of literary originality and religious truth; it is not &bquo;theology&equo; dressed up as &bquo;literature&equo;; rather it makes its best literary effects when it is at its most religious because the religious matter is what most engages the author's imagination. 
 In this, Lewis resembles two of his favourite authors, Edmund Spenser and George MacDonald. 
 The Muses have been traditionally at war with Christ, ever since the period of late classical antiquity, when Jerome and Augustine both viewed literary excellence with the gravest suspicion. 
 Lewis is one of those very rare writers whose Muse appears to be an anima naturaliter Christiana . 
 There have been plenty of good writers who were also Christians. 
 Plenty of Christians have tried their hand at putting their beliefs into prose or poetry, usually with calamitous aesthetic results. 
 There have been very few with the gift of Dante or John Milton, who have written at their best when being most Christian. 
 It was to this great tradition, though as a self-confessedly very junior follower, that Lewis quite easily and naturally belonged. 
 This did not mean that he was above sacrificing aesthetic principle &mdash; if there is such a thing, and if he had it &mdash; to the purely partisan pleasures of Morte aux pa&iuml;ens . 
 Dante could turn aside from his most sublime passages of religious contemplation to hone a gratuitous insult for the benefit of Florentine families whom he happened to dislike. 
 Milton, who sang of God and his angels, was equally happy slinging mud at bishops. 
 Tolkien and Lewis, in some of the same spirit, decided to make a party issue out of the election to the Oxford Chair of Poetry in 1938. 
 Unlike other professors at Oxford, the Professor of Poetry is elected by the MAs of the University: that is to say, not only by the dons, but also by all the old members of the University who have paid the appropriate fees and undergone, either in person or in absentia , a short ceremony in the Sheldonian Theatre. 
 Although there have been some famous poets who occupied this chair (for example Matthew Arnold and W. H. Auden), it has much more commonly been occupied by dons; and the point at issue when choosing candidates for the Chair of Poetry has very seldom been their views about the subject on which they are supposed to lecture, still less their competence to do so. 
 One day over breakfast, the chaplain of Magdalen, Adam Fox, opened his newspaper and saw that Sir Edmund Chambers was being put up as a candidate for the Chair of Poetry. 
 He described him as &bquo;a retired civil servant who has made Shakespeare his hobby&equo;. 
 In this Fox was simply showing his ignorance. 
 Though indeed he had been a civil servant, Chambers was one of the foremost literary scholars in England. 
 His books The Medieval Stage  and The Elizabethan Stage  remain classics of literary history, and in their range and period there are few better anthologies of verse than his Early English Lyrics  and Oxford Book of Sixteenth Century Verse . 
 He had lately come to live in a village called Eynsham, near Oxford, he was a D.Litt. of his old university, and all this Lewis must have known. 
 Nevertheless, when Fox made the preposterous statement that &bquo;This is simply shocking, they might as well make me professor of Poetry,&equo; Lewis responded, &bquo;Well, we will.&equo; 
 It is hard, at this distance of time, to see what his motives were, apart from the mere love of a fight for its own sake, and the desire to promote one of his friends. 
 If E. K. Chambers could be suspected of being dull and pedantic, what were Fox's qualities? 
 He had published one &bquo;long and childlike&equo; (his own words) poem called Old King Cole  and he had won the sacred poem prize (in another competition open to all MAs of the University). 
 He was no orator. 
 He had nothing much to say about poetry. 
 He was a grotesquely inappropriate choice. 
 Nevertheless, Lewis put up Fox to stand against Chambers, and his gang of friends rallied to Fox's support. 
 This had its (presumably) desired effect of annoying a lot of other dons. 
 They, guided by the strong impression in &bquo;literary&equo; circles that Chambers was an old bore and Fox was a non-starter, put up their own candidate, Lord David Cecil, a friend of Lewis's, as it happened, and the English tutor at New College. 
 But no quarrel in England is ever about what it seems to be about. 
 Although David Cecil was and always had been a devout Christian, he became the favourite candidate of those who resented the &bquo;clerical candidate&equo;, the man who had been put up by Lewis, just because he was a Christian. 
 So the literary set, many of them agnostic or hostile to religion, ranged behind Lord David, while those who had already committed themselves, together with those who esteemed him as a scholar, voted for E. K. Chambers. 
 This was a situation which the Ulsterman in Lewis relished. 
 For the time being, he ceased to be a cloistered academic and became once more the son of the police-court solicitor in Belfast, the city where the most popular political slogan at election times was &bquo;Vote early, vote often&equo;. 
 Lewis knew well that most of the dons would vote for David Cecil or E. K. Chambers. 
 They would thereby split the opposition. 
 All he needed to do was to collect the votes of the majority of MAs who had left the University. 
 By putting up a clergyman as a candidate, he could rely on the vote of hundreds of MAs who, sitting in their country rectories, could easily be persuaded by a judiciously worded letter that their old University was falling into the hands of infidels. 
 A vote for Fox became, absurdly, a vote for the Church, a vote for Orthodoxy, a vote far all the things which Lewis now &bquo;stood for&equo;. 
 In staunch Irish fashion, he laid on transport for Fox's supporters to be &bquo;bused&equo; into Oxford on. 
 the appropriate days and rewarded them for their votes with meals and refreshments at Magdalen. 
 Fox was a nice man, much liked among a wide circle of his fellow-clergy. 
 He romped home. 
 The election did much to harm Lewis's reputation in Oxford. 
 The dons felt that he could not be trusted: that he was populist, bullying, showy, and hostile to them. 
 By his campaign for Fox, Lewis probably destroyed his own chances of promotion in the University, even though he was very obviously the most distinguished member of the English Faculty. 
 It is certainly easy for those who did not belong to Lewis's group of friends, and who merely come upon the record of it in after days, to see its faults. 
 Chief among them, and born of the group's increasing feeling that they stood far something, embattled against a hostile world, was their tendency not only to see merit where none existed (in the poetry of Fox, for example), but actually to think that belonging to the group &mdash; which began at around this period to be known as the Inklings &mdash; was in itself a sort of merit. 
 One gets the feeling from Warnie's diary, for example, that it was better to be a good Inkling than a good poet, or even a good man. 
 The most exaggerated example of this (it was the dangerous tendency which Jack himself labelled the &bquo;Inner Ring&equo;) was when they attended a production of Hamlet  at the New Theatre in Oxford, produced &mdash; as were so many great Oxford University Dramatic Society productions in the middle years of this century &mdash; by Nevill Coghill. 
 &bquo;What dramatic merit the play had&equo;, Warnie noted afterwards, &bquo;seemed to have been supplied by Coghill and not by Shakespeare.&equo; 
 Shakespeare, one realizes, had the supreme misfortune not to be an Inkling. 
 One gets the strong feeling that he would not (in the unlikely event of his standing as a candidate) have stood much chance of becoming Professor of Poetry at Oxford if Lewis and Tolkien had had anything to do with it. 
 Though Fox was never to give a distinguished lecture, his friends were triumphant. 
 He had defeated, as Tolkien boasted to his publisher, &bquo;a Knight and a noble Lord. 
 He was nominated by Lewis and myself, and miraculously elected: our first public victory over established privilege. 
 For Fox is a member of our literary club of practising poets  before whom The Hobbitt , and other works (such as the Silent Planet)  have been read.&equo; 
 That was certainly one way of looking at things. 
 The original Inklings club had been started by an undergraduate at University College, and broke up in 1933. 
 This was a literary dining club, to which Tolkien and Lewis had both, on different occasions, been invited as guests. 
 Little by little, Lewis, with his passion for nicknames, adopted this one to describe his own circle of friends. 
 It was never a formal club with minutes, or apologies for absence, or any &bquo;business&equo; or recognizable membership. 
 Yet, as Tolkien remarked, &bquo;it was a pleasantly ingenious pun in its way, suggesting people with vague or half-formed intimations and ideas plus those who dabble in ink.&equo; 
 In this way, another Oxford legend was born. 
 It would be a mistake, however, even when the intimacy between Lewis and Tolkien was at its strongest, to believe that this was the only thing in both their lives. 
 Tolkien always had close family ties in which Lewis had no wish to be involved. 
 Knowing Tolkien to have his difficulties, maritally speaking, the two Lewis brothers stayed away; and Lewis, who disliked sharing spoken intimacies with friends, never allowed the conversation to develop if Tolkien tried to speak of his troubles. 
 On one occasion when Tolkien tore a ligament playing squash, and was told that he would be confined to his bed for ten weeks, Lewis went to see him &mdash; but, as Warnie recorded, he &bquo;found Madame &lsqb;i.e. Tolkien's wife&rsqb; there, so could not have much conversation with him&equo;. 
 The Tolkien children were invited to swim and punt on Lewis's lake at The Kilns, but there was nothing in the way of a &bquo;family friendship&equo; between the two. 
 Indeed, Lewis was always impatient with &bquo;Tollers&equo; if he pleaded family commitments as a reason for not attending an Inklings evening. 
 Lewis, for his part, had his  own private world which he did not share with the Inklings. 
 There was the whole, and very important, world of his friendship with animals. 
 A large part of his pleasure derived from walking holidays, when he could put Oxford, college politics and the routines of work behind him. 
 There were many such tours in the pre-war years, often taken with Barfield, sometimes with Warnie, sometimes both. 
 Between 2 January and 6 January 1939, for example, the brothers walked forty-two miles in the Welsh Marches (i.e. borders &mdash; from me Old English mearc ), and rounded them off with a stay in Great Malvern. 
 The trip awakened many boyhood memories, and Warnie remarked that they might do worse than spend their declining years there. 
 Jack readily agreed. 
 It was a peculiar exchange to take place between men in full vigour, aged forty and forty-four respectively. 
 It is as though they could not wait to sink into a dotage spent in permanent contemplation of their childhood. 
 The in-between bits &mdash; what some call life &mdash; seemed by such standards to be so much waste of time, which they could not be done with fast enough. 
 To beguile some of the time in Malvern, they went to the cinema. 
 The Lewis brothers were not great cinema-goers, and there were few films in the 1930s which they viewed with enjoyment. 
 No&euml;l Coward's Cavalcade , for example, though Jack could see its merit, struck him as fundamentally cheap, &bquo;a mere brutal assault on one's emotions, using material which one can't help feeling intensely. 
 It appeals entirely to that part of you which lives in the throat and chest, leaving the spirit untouched.&equo; 
 A film which apparently did touch the spirit was King Kong , though we do not know whether Jack found it quite as exciting as Warnie did: &bquo;There were astounding representations of the various prehistoric monsters,&equo; Warnie confided breathlessly to his diary. 
 &bquo;How they were done I cannot imagine&hellip; &bquo; 
 For their third cinematic adventure of the decade (unless one counts the showing of George V's funeral), they booked tickets at the cinema in Great Malvern to see Walt Disney's Snow White and the Seven Dwarves  It turned out to be &bquo;first rate&hellip; 
 It was well worth going to if only for the scene of the spring cleaning of the dwarfs&equo; house. 
 We came out into a lovely night: the effect of the quiet town, in the moonlight, with the snowclad hills behind is one that I shan't soon forget,&equo; wrote Warnie. 
 It was an evening of blissful happiness for Jack's brother, a return to boyhood, those beloved &bquo;Malvern days when it was just the two of us against the P'daytabird&equo;. 
 This was the last walking holiday the two brothers were ever to take together. 
 Warnie, though he was by all accounts a most delightful and courteous companion, was a clear case of arrested development. 
 Emotionally, he was imprisoned in his boyhood, the only difference being that the whiskey bottle was substituted for cream buns and lemon pop as the greatest imaginable treat. 
 With Jack, however, things were less simple; we come once more to Barfield's worry that there was something affected about the younger brother's attitudes and poses. 
 Certainly, there is no inherent virtue in having read ali the latest books, nor in following intellectual fads and trends. 
 But if, as William Empson (no ally) believed, Lewis was &bquo;the best read man of his generation, one who read everything and remembered everything he read&equo;, there is something a little disappointing in such a man rejoicing in the limitations of his sympathy. 
 On one level, it is quite a good joke in the decade of Brecht's Der Gute Mensch von Sezuan  to be relishing the washing-up scene in Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs  in the decade of Sartre's La Naus&eacute;e  and (as far as English publication was concerned) Joyce's Ulysses , to be whooping with delight at the reprint of Adventures of Tom Pippin  by Roland Zuiz. 
 Where this is born of genuine enthusiasm, well and good. 
 But Lewis's friends sensed, from this period onwards, something which had begun half as a tease hardening into an attitude. 
 David Cecil, an omnivorous and generous-hearted reader, was almost always unable to persuade Lewis to like books written by &bquo;moderns&equo;. 
 Although Lewis had read Kafka and Virginia Woolf, the virtues of Proust or D. H. Lawrence or T. S. Eliot were virtues he delighted in being unable to see. 
 One picks up a suggestion of this position calcifying into something more like the outlook of a crusty old gentleman in a club in a letter he wrote in June 1938 to Barfield. 
 In one paragraph, he makes some perfectly reasonable objections to his pupils' and colleagues' remoteness from life. 
 In the next he moves to crustiness: 
 They keep sheep in Magdalen grove now, and I hear the fleecy care bleating all day long: I am shocked to find that none of my pupils, though they are all acquainted with pastoral poetry, regards them as anything but a nuisance: and one of my colleagues has been heard to ask why sheep have their wool cut off. 
 This is all splendid and we are on Lewis's side. 
 But then he goes on: 
 It frightens me, almost. 
 And so it did the other night, when I heard two undergrads, giving a list of pleasures which were (a) Nazi, (b) leading to homosexuality. 
 They were: feeling the wind in your hair, walking with bare feet on the grass, and baring in the rain. 
 Think it over: it gets worse the longer you look at it. 
 It is twenty-two years since I read that letter, first published in Warnie's selection of his brother's correspondence, and on and off I have been thinking it over. 
 At no time have I been able to see anything cither Nazi or necessarily homosexual in the listed pleasures, which are precisely of the kind which might occur in a George MacDonald fantasy. 
 But the pleasures are, of course, those of youth, and Lewis at the age of forty seems to have forgotten what it was like to be young. 
 He sees exuberant, and perhaps sensual, pleasure in the natural world, of the kind which he once described so lyrically in letters to Arthur Greeves (there is in fact a letter about bathing in the rain at Parson's Pleasure); now such stuff seems to him &bquo;Nazi&equo;. 
 If this misgiving about Lewis is at all fair (the sense of a carapace hardening upon him), then one must also view with ambivalence his excursion into the realm of religious apologetics. 
 Ashley Sampson was the owner of a small London publishing house, which ran a series called &bquo;Christian Challenge&equo;. 
 Knowing of Lewis's philosophical training and Christian sympathy, and admiring his two published prose works, he asked if Lewis would be prepared to undertake a 40,000-word contribution to the series. 
 The subject proposed was The Problem of Pain . 
 As Lewis tells us in the preface to the published version of this book, his initial reaction was to wish for anonymity, &bquo;since if I were to say what I really thought about pain, I should be forced to make statements of such apparent fortitude that they would become ridiculous if anyone knew who made them,. 
 Sampson, however, insisted that Lewis should put his name to anything which was written, and in the course of 1939 he set to work. 
 The book was finished and completed the following year. 
 It is a book which vigorously displays, from its opening paragraphs, all Lewis's strengths and weaknesses as a religious apologist. 
 Most disconcerting, to those who love The Discarded Image , is the apparent cheerfulness with which he abandons the depth and range of his historical imagination in favour of a style of rhetoric which seems more reminiscent of the Belfast police courts. 
 What is so troubling is that the Discarded Image  Lewis is there beside the bullying rhetorician, and we do not know which of them is going to speak next. 
 &bquo;Lay down this book and reflect for five minutes on the fact that all the great religions were first preached, and long practised, in a world without Chloroform.&equo; 
 That is The Discarded Image  self, usefully prodding our imaginations into seeing things from a proper perspective. 
 And this self, in the introductory chapter, is surely right to suggest that moral sense and a sense of the numinous do not come naturally &mdash; as some anthropological dismissals of religion might suggest &mdash; from some crude pre-scientific attempt to explain the universe. 
 The universe, viewed in those pre-chloroform days, was dark and painful and horrible, and wherever else the human race derived its image of a loving, moral creator, it was not from a simple contemplation of nature. 
 But then comes a statement about Christ which seems to emanate not from a rational clever man trying to help us to understand things more clearly, but from a rhetorical trickster who is not thinking at all. 
 There was a man born among these Jews who claimed to be, or to be the son of, or to be one with the something which is at once the awful haunter of Nature and the giver of the moral law. 
 The claim is so shocking &mdash; a paradox and even a horror, which we may easily be lulled into taking too lightly &mdash; that only two views of this man are possible. 
 Either he was a raving lunatic of an unusually abominable type or else He was, and is, precisely what He said. 
 There is no middle way. 
 If the records make the first hypothesis unacceptable, then you must submit to the second. 
 Since a version of this argument was repeated in his broadcast talks and made a linchpin of Lewis's defence of Christianity, it may be profitable to lay down our books for five minutes as he urged us to do when thinking of a world without chloroform and meditate on what he has laid before us. 
 Let us keep our meditation simple by discounting various facts fact, for example, that most of Christ's Jewish contemporaries did not believe in His divinity or join the newly founded Christian Church or sect. 
 Did Lewis therefore suppose that they were all very stupid, or damnably wicked? 
 Neither alternative is particularly probable or palatable. 
 Let us concentrate rather on the last sentence of the paragraph quoted and work our way back through the foregoing non sequiturs . 
 &bquo;If the records make the first hypothesis unacceptable&hellip; 
 &bquo; The Discarded Image  is a book which was written by a man with an unusual sensitivity to the differences between past and present. 
 The men and women of the past saw the same physical universe that we did, but their way of seeing it was quite different; their way of describing it in written form more different still. 
 This does not mean that the old books can provide us with no concrete evidence from the past, but it does mean that old books must be read with delicacy; with a sense that if we go blundering into them, assuming that they mean what we mean by words like sky, earth, history  or nature  we shall get everything wrong. 
 If we read the book in their  way &mdash; whether we are reading Dante, or Chaucer, or Isadore of Seville &mdash; we will get something from it. 
 The more we soak up their way of looking at things, their method of understanding, the more we shall get. 
 Read it in our way and we shall merely be, as Lewis says in the preface to The Discarded Image , like &bquo;travellers who carry their resolute Englishry with them all over the Continent, mix only with other English tourists, enjoy all they see for its &bquo;quaintness&equo; and have no wish to realise what those ways of life, those churches, those vineyards mean to the natives&equo;. 
 As an apologist, he seems totally blind to the fact that the New Testament is just such a collection of old books, which require, if we are to understand them aright, patience and a willingness to listen to scholars who have meditated for a long time on the nature of the (often quite puzzling and contradictory) material which they contain. 
 Lewis's claim that &bquo;the records&equo; give us a stark choice about Christ &mdash; either he was a &bquo;raving lunatic&equo; or else &bquo;He was, and is, precisely what He said&equo; &mdash; is startling, to say the least. 
 To what &bquo;records&equo; is he referring? 
 Different books of the New Testament have different ways of describing the indescribable, that is, the nature of Christ, and the first three centuries of Christendom are a history of ceaseless dispute among the most learned doctors of the Church as to what this nature was, and how it was made manifest during the period of the Incarnation. 
 This is not to deny the truth of orthodox Christian belief. 
 It is to point out that there is nowhere in existence a set of &bquo;records&equo; which could prove that Christ was either a lunatic or &bquo;precisely what He said&equo; He was. 
 The Epistles of St Paul and the Apocalyptic Book of Revelation contain many high and mystical expressions of belief about Christ but they cannot be described as &bquo;records&equo; of the kind which would compel rational belief. 
 If they were, the world would simply be divided into a majority of believing Christians and a small handful of people who were either too stupid or too wicked to accept something which was obvious and clear-cut. 
 But the nature and being of Christ are not made obvious and clear-cut even in the pages of the New Testament. 
 Even if we accept only the four gospels as &bquo;the records&equo; for the purposes of Lewis's argument, we have to see that they present a differing picture. 
 The Fourth Gospel, for example, does not lie  when it puts into the mouth of Christ words, and whole patterns of speech, which we do not find on His lips in the first three gospels. 
 But it does, by this convention, proclaim itself to be a book of a special kind, one designed to proclaim what the faithful believe about Christ, not necessarily a book which is straight narrative history in the modern mode. 
 The first three gospels contain no reference to Christ's having made any such great discourses as fill chapters 13&ndash;16 of St John, and since it seems unlikely that the author of the Gospel took notes during the utterance of this sublime discourse, we have to assume them to be a literary creation. 
 Not a lie, but a creation of what the author believed to be more true than verbatim records. 
 It follows that behind every statement we make about the historical Jesus there has to be a tacit qualification: &bquo;We are told this by such-and-such an evangelist, writing in a particular literary mode, far a particular audience, in a particular place at a particular period of history.&equo; 
 You cannot, in isolation from church doctrine, and in isolation from the plain facts of literary history, say that Jesus said this ming or that thing. 
 If you do, you find yourself faced with unedifying alternatives such as those which Lewis proposes. 
 All we have is what the Gospels say that He said. 
 Precisely what these differing accounts mean  by such phrases as &bquo;Son of Man&equo;, or even &bquo;Son of God&equo;, cannot be translated into our own modern thought processes without some Discarded Image-  style readjustments of sympathy. 
 And besides that, we discover in the various Gospels quite differing accounts of the earthly Christ's reticence about Himself. 
 The famous &bquo;secrecy&equo; of the Messiah in St Mark's Gospel, for instance ('See thou say nothing to any man'), does not really fit into either of Lewis's categories of raving lunatic or self-proclaimed Divinity. 
 The curious thing is that Lewis, though so very widely read in other areas, had read almost no works of biblical scholarship. 
 The revolution in New Testament scholarship which had come about during the hundred years before he wrote The Problem of Pain  appears to have passed him by. 
 Perhaps in one sense it does not matter that he ignored the sometimes vandalistic assaults on the gospel texts by Form-critics and Redaction-critics; just as it could be seen not to matter that the school of philosophy in which he was reared had been rendered more or less obsolete by the man who &mdash; in the year that Lewis was writing The Problem of Pain &mdash;  had become a professor of philosophy at Cambridge: Ludwig Wittgenstein. 
 What is so odd, though, is that Lewis was tempted to argue  the faith, to analyse and defend it in a manner at once so roughshod and so cerebral when it had come to him by quite other means. 
 The philosophy of Wittgenstein did not destroy the faith &mdash; it destroyed certain methods of nineteenth-century Idealist argument. 
 The new biblical critics did not destroy the faith: they merely forced on intelligent people the distinction between history and church doctrine. 
 Neither philosophy nor textual criticism, however, had led Lewis to the form. 
 He had been led to it by his experience of the numinous, and by the exercise of his imagination. 
 Above all, he had been led to it by the discovery that story, myth, could not only carry truth, but also be  truth. 
 Surely the corollary of his great &bquo;mythopoeia&equo; discussion with Dyson and Tolkien was that the story of Christ was much more important than any doctrine which a fallible or fallen human mind could extract from it? 
 Trying to define, or speaking as if it were possible to define, &bquo;precisely what He meant&equo; by saying who He was, was a sort of profanity. 
 Yet of course it was not meant profanely. 
 The Problem of Pain  was written with the best of intentions. 
 Lewis felt that he must put all his talents to the service of God. 
 This led him to suppose that his capacity to argue a case was a talent which, quite as much as his imagination and his literary taste, must be consecrated. 
 And in the context of the time, there was a sort of heroism in this. 
 Lewis was fully aware of the fact that there was a purely irrational intellectual snobbery abroad in England at that time, more powerful than any genuine intellectual stumbling-block to faith. 
 When one sees that it was this snobbery which he set out to attack, it is possible to understand why he set about the delicate problem of pain in so breezy a fashion. 
 Similarly, when one reads the dedication of The Problem of Pain &mdash;  'to the Inklings' &mdash; one understands some of its short-cuts, as well as some of its more peculiar turns of phrase (e.g. of the Incarnation &mdash; &bquo;It has the master touch &mdash; the rough, male taste of reality. 
 &bquo;). This was a book which began life as chapters to be read aloud to like-minded male friends. 
 It was brief, pithy and, like everything Lewis wrote in prose, hugely readable. 
 None of that small band of men who sat round smoking and drinking their beer or whisky could have had any idea, as they heard Jack vigorously defending the doctrine of hell in nine pages, that the publication of these religious speculations, pieced together at a busy time between giving lectures and examining, was to change his destiny forever. 
 They would certainly have been completely astonished to learn, as would the author, that The Problem of Pain  would become a great commercial success. 
 By the time it came out, in any case, all their lives had been irrevocably altered by the progress of world events. 
 There is one encounter worth mentioning before we bring to an end this account of Lewis in 1939. 
 Some time during the course of that summer, Dr Harvard introduced Lewis to the Roman Catholic Chaplain to the University, Monsignor Ronald Knox. 
 One would have assumed that as two classicists, Punch  contributors and men of letters of an old-fashioned Christian temper, Lewis and Knox would have known each other for years. 
 But Knox, who was the most brilliant orator of his generation at Oxford &mdash; star of the Union, wit, punster in tongues ancient and modern &mdash; had left Oxford before the end of the First World War to become a Roman Catholic, and after his return there as chaplain to the Catholics, it was perhaps understandable that he should have kept a low profile. 
 Lewis greeted him warmly with the assertion that he was possibly the wittiest man in Europe. 
 Knox modestly demurred, but the meeting was said to be happy and humorous. 
 Perhaps they might have developed into friends. 
 Though Lewis was not friendly to Catholicism, the two men had much more of a playful kind in common. 
 Both enjoyed &bquo;bad&equo; literature &mdash; in Knox's case, the poetry of Ella Wheeler Wilcox, in Lewis's the novels of Amanda McKittrick Ros. 
 Both were brilliant parodists. 
 Both liked spontaneous rhyming. 
 Their friendship, however, was not to be. 
 Within a few weeks of their meeting, England was at war. 
 Knox had gone into the country to translate the Vulgate into English and Lewis was being prepared by an unseen providence for war work no less surprising. 
 SCREWTAPE 1939&ndash;1942 
 &bquo;This is a fallen world,&equo; J. R. R. Tolkien wrote to one of his sons early in the Second World War. 
 &bquo;The world has been &bquo;going to the bad&equo; all down me ages.&equo; 
 Wars tend to prompt religious reawakening in a populace. 
 Although, as Lewis remarked in a wartime sermon, all individuals face the ultimate realities all the time, war quickens and sharpens our awareness. 
 When everyone in the country lives with the prospect of having their house destroyed by a bomb during the night, the Christian talk of Armageddon seems less fanciful than in the &bquo;weak piping times of peace&equo;. 
 Those who in peacetime seemed brave or merely quaint for believing in all those old doctrines found themselves in wartime much in demand, some as evangelists, some as prophets, some as teachers. 
 The immediate consequence of the outbreak of war was that Lewis found his circle of friends broken up and changing. 
 The Useless Quack joined the Navy and grew a gingery beard, which enabled Lewis (always anxious to invent fresh sobriquets  for his friends) to label him the Red Admiral. 
 Warnie, though forty-one, was recalled to active service, given the rank of major, and sent to France, where he remained until the evacuation from Dunkirk. 
 Most of the friends were too old or too physically enfeebled to be capable of offering themselves for military glory. 
 Dyson had a club foot; Lewis still had shrapnel in his lung. 
 They, Tolkien and Coghill stayed in Oxford and when need arose worked as ARP wardens. 
 The life of the University both did and did not go on. 
 Young men still came up to the colleges, but they reminded Lewis of his own position in 1917, when his glimpse of Oxford life was just a prelude to the horrors of battle. 
 The war had its compensations. 
 Not the least of these was that the 
 Oxford University Press moved out of London, and took most of its remaining employees to Oxford. 
 Among them was Charles Williams, who rather surprisingly left his wife and child behind to brave the Blitz in their Hampstead flat while he and his beloved secretary Celia came to take up their (separate) residences in Oxford. 
 He claimed that Lewis was the only person in Oxford whom he really saw, but this was the reverse of the truth. 
 It may have been largely thanks to Lewis that Williams became something of a cult figure, idolized by pious lady dons, aspirant mystics and others. 
 He had real charm, which made canny figures such as Tolkien distrust him. 
 Lewis was bowled over by him, and was anxious that as many people as possible should have the benefit of his wisdom. 
 It was the strange circumstance of wartime which enabled Lewis to put Williams forward as a lecturer in the English Faculty. 
 They needed teachers, and Williams was an experienced public speaker at WEA lectures and evening classes. 
 His lectures on Milton were first given in the beautiful fifteenth-century Divinity Schools, underneath the Bodleian Library. 
 The audience packed this room to capacity. 
 It was certainly not what undergraduates at Oxford had come to expect from a lecturer. 
 Many were surprised by Williams's appearance, which was simian and scarlet-faced, slightly boozy. 
 The cockney voice was declamatory, hierophantic. 
 It was more like being present at a seance than at a lecture. 
 He held a copy of Milton's works in his hands, but whenever he quoted from the poet he held the book aloft, like the Gospel at High Mass, sometimes going so far as to wave it to and fro behind his head as he chanted out the words. 
 The first lecture was on Comus  (subsequent talks on Milton had to move to the large lecture-room at the Taylorian Institute, the Divinity Schools being too small). 
 Comus  is a masque in which a young lady's chastity is tried and not vanquished. 
 Some of those who attended the lecture have implied to me that not everyone took it particularly seriously. 
 There were even giggles as this (as he seemed to some of them) funny little man with a funny voice urged the audience to abstain from fleshly lusts. 
 But we see what we want to see, and for Lewis this performance by Williams was a revelation. 
 There we elders heard what we had despaired of hearing &mdash; a lecture on Comus  which placed its importance where the poet placed it &mdash; and watched &bquo;the yonge fresshe folkes he or she&equo; who filled the benches listening first with incredulity, then with toleration, and finally with delight, to something so strange and new in their experience as the praise of chastity. 
 The lecture, and Williams's conversation, turned Lewis's own thoughts to Milton. 
 In the second year of the war, he was asked to deliver some lectures at Bangor &mdash; the University College, North Wales &mdash; and he chose as his theme Milton's Paradise Lost . 
 The lectures, which were subsequently published as A Preface to &bquo;Paradise Lost&equo; , represent Lewis at his very best. 
 If someone had never read Lewis before, and wished to get a taste of him, there would be no better book with which to start. 
 In its asides &mdash; quite apart from what he tells us about Milton &mdash; we see what it was about Lewis which struck W. T. Kirkpatrick as so remarkable, and which made him such a valued teacher and friend to so many people in the course of his life. 
 Here is evidence of a mind abundantly stocked with reading which the author has enjoyed &mdash; effortlessly, intelligently, and selflessly enjoyed &mdash; and he wishes to communicate this enjoyment to us. 
 The range is so impressive &mdash; everything from Lucretius to Tristram Shandy , from Virgil to Kinglake, from Beowulf to T. S. Eliot has been absorbed, not for the sake of being bookish but always &mdash; one feels &mdash; in an outward-looking manner. 
 There is a great moral self-confidence and a common sense in the writing &mdash; as when he offers one possible explanation far why so many people, reading Paradise Lost , have supposed Satan to be the &bquo;hero&equo;. 
 To make a character worse than oneself it is only necessary to release imaginatively from control some of the bad passions which, in real life, are always straining at the leash; the Satan, the Iago, the Becky Sharp, within each of us, is always there and only too ready, the moment the leash is slipped, to come out and have in our books that holiday we try to deny them in life. 
 There is, too, a constantly intelligent conversational quality about the writing which makes one see how very good his talk must have been. 
 One thinks of him saying, of the Odyssey , &bquo;The poem is an adventure story. 
 As far as greatness of subject goes, it is much closer to Tom  Jones  or Ivanhoe  than to the Aeneid  or the Gierusalemme Liberata . 
 Or, apropos of the necessity of having a good historical imagination when reading, &bquo;I had much rather know what I should feel like if I adopted the beliefs of Lucretius than how Lucretius would have felt if he had never entertained them.&equo; 
 On a purely aesthetic level, one is frequently haunted by his (at first sight paradoxical) defence of Milton's preference far Hebrew over Greek lyrics. 
 &bquo;But if any man will read aloud on alternate mornings for a single month a page of Pindar and a page of the Psalms in any translation he chooses, I think I can guess which he will first grow tired of.&equo; 
 So much for the asides &mdash; but how good is Lewis on the subject he sets himself &mdash; on Milton? 
 I think I have read most of what was written by or about him in English between the seventeenth century and, say, 1975. 
 There are not many better books than Lewis's. 
 The passages on Milton and St Augustine, Milton and angels, Milton's theology, are all first-rate. 
 He has done more theological &bquo;homework&equo; here than he did for some of his own religious books, and it shows, even though learning was never more lightly worn. 
 Moreover the basic picture of Milton himself, though only sketched in very lightly, is completely authentic: 
 He is a neat, dainty man, &bquo;the lady of Christ's&equo;; a fastidious man, pacing in trim  gardens. 
 He is a grammarian, a swordsman, a musician with a predilection for the fugue. 
 Everything that he greatly cares about demands order, proportion, measure and control In poetry he considers decorum the grand masterpiece. 
 In politics he is that which of all things least resembles a democrat &mdash; an aristocratic republican who thinks &bquo;nothing more agreeable to the order of nature or more for the interest of mankind than that the less should yield to the greater, not in numbers but in wisdom and virtue&equo;. 
 An extraordinarily high proportion of Milton scholars have chosen to disregard these truths about their subject, and have decided that because Milton was on the side of the regicides this made him a revolutionary and, because a revolutionary, therefore a man of the Left, perhaps even an agonized Maminst, or at least a sympathizer with the Diggers and Levellers of his own day. 
 The less biographical or historical evidence there is for this view of Milton, the more the scholars believe it, producing readings of Paradise Lost  which ignore Lewis's golden rule, &bquo;You must, so far as in you lies, become an Achaean chief while reading Homer, a medieval knight while reading Malory, and an Eighteenth Century Londoner while reading Johnson. 
 Only thus will you be able to judge the work &bquo;in the same spirit that its author writ&equo;.&equo; 
 Lewis does present in his Preface to &bquo;Paradise Lost&equo;  a very convincing impression of having read the poem which John Milton set out to write and meant us to read. 
 If that seems like faint praise, you should read the dozen most recent books on Paradise Lost . 
 Very little criticism  as such survives the generation in which it is written. 
 The same is true, incidentally, of most philosophy and theology. 
 Those who practise these branches of study often mistake them for spheres of knowledge when they are more accurately seen as examples of dialectic or rhetoric &mdash; ideas which may be better aired in talk. 
 All critics, however dispassionate, bring to their subject thick encrustations of personal prejudice and, which they are probably even less well equipped to notice, assumptions which are attributable to the spirit of the age. 
 Lewis's debate in the Preface  with other Milton critics &mdash; with Saurat, Eliot, I. A. Richards or Leavis &mdash; all seems pretty dead to us now, since not many people would read any of the aforementioned critics nowadays as critics  unless they were interested in the history of criticism for its own sake. 
 What makes Lewis's criticism rather different is a combination of two very rare qualities. 
 One is contained in the sentence which is most often mocked in the Preface to &bquo;Paradise Lost&equo; : 'A schoolboy who reads a page of Milton by chance, for the first time, and then looks up and says &bquo;By Gum&equo;, not in the least knowing how the thing has worked, but only that new strength and width and brightness and zest have transformed his world, is nearer to the truth &lsqb;than the critics&rsqb;.&equo; 
 Lewis never lost his schoolboyish sense of wonder and enjoyment. 
 It is what makes him such a refreshing literary historian. 
 He was not ashamed of the &bquo;By Gum&equo; school of reading. 
 What we also notice in the chapters dealing with the Fall, and in particular with Adam and Eve, is that this is not just a book by a scholar in a library. 
 It is also a reading of Milton by a creative intelligence. 
 In stories of great temptation, of interplanetary flights, wrestlings with the powers of good and evil, Lewis found something which had already engaged his own pen, and would continue to do so. 
 Not least among the new friendships which Lewis formed during the war was his friendship with an Anglican nun called Sister Penelope (Lawson) of the Community of St Mary the Virgin at Wantage. 
 She was eight years Lewis's senior, and a woman of high intellectual abilities. 
 Richard Hunt, former Keeper of Western Manuscripts at the Bodleian Library and a considerable Medieval Latinist himself, once told me that he thought Sister Penelope the best translator from Latin in her generation. 
 It was not, however, of learned matters that she first wrote to Lewis but of science fiction. 
 She had enjoyed Out of the Silent Planet.  
 &bquo;At  ordinary times we do not read novels at all, as you may imagine, but the right novel at the right moment can have a real spiritual value.&equo; 
 In return for a book of her own &mdash; God Persists  &mdash; Lewis sent Sister Penelope The Pilgrim's Regress , and she noted his acerbic satire on High Anglicans. 
 He admitted to her, &bquo;I'm not&hellip; what you call high. 
 To me the real distinction is not high and low, but between religion with a real supernaturalism and salvationism on the one hand and all watered-down modernist versions on the other.&equo; 
 This sounds like a true distinction, but in real life things are a little different. 
 An Anglican may not wish to be seduced into all the absurdities of church politics, still less into the hobby of church ceremonial. 
 But the distinctions between &bquo;high&equo; and &bquo;low&equo; in so far as they are doctrinal do of necessity affect devotional practice. 
 An instance had arisen on a walking tour Jack and Warnie took in Derbyshire in 1936. 
 Coming to the parish church at Taddington, they found a notice to say that the Blessed Sacrament was reserved there and should be treated with &bquo;special reverence&equo;. 
 The two brothers later had an argument about it over their lunch. 
 Warnie said that there was room only for a clear cut division of opinion &mdash; if one is a Catholic, the aumbry contains Our Lord and of course even prostration is hardly reverence enough: but if one is Church of England, it contains but a wafer and a little wine, and why in front of that should one show any greater reverence than in any other part of the church?&hellip; 
 Jack was not satisfied and seemed to think that there was a middle view between the two.&equo; 
 Seven or eight years later, by the time he preached his remarkable sermon &bquo;The Weight of Glory&equo; C. S. Lewis clearly had a full belief in the Eucharistic Presence, or there would be no force in the rhetoric of his &bquo;Next to the Blessed Sacrament itself, your neighbour is the holiest object presented to your senses.&equo; 
 It might be imagined by those who are not themselves Anglican that the habit of &bquo;going to confession&equo; is limited only to markedly &bquo;High&equo; churches, but this is not necessarily the case. 
 The practice does take place in the Church of Ireland, though as it happened, it did not seem to have come Lewis's way at St Mark's, Dundela. 
 In Oxford, after his conversion, things were different. 
 Among his Anglican friends, Coghill probably went to confession. 
 Dyson certainly did. 
 It was very much the custom of most churches in central Oxford, even though it has never been obligatory in the Anglican Communion. 
 &bquo;All may; some should; none must&equo; is the Church of England rule. 
 Lewis undoubtedly felt that he should, but was nervous about taking the plunge. 
 His friendship with Sister Penelope somehow made it easier. 
 &bquo;The decision to do so was one of the hardest I have ever made: but now that I am committed (by dint of posting the letter before I had time to change my mind) I began to be afraid of opposite extremes &mdash; afraid that I am merely indulging in an orgy of egoism.&equo; 
 He had written to Father Walter Adams, who had a strong reputation as a confessor and spiritual director. 
 He was a member of the Society of St John the Evangelist, an Anglican religious order popularly called the Cowley Fathers and based in Oxford. 
 The drama of the moment was recaptured in Perelandra , the second in the science-fiction trilogy, where Ransom remembers the strength which was given to him in a moment requiring supreme moral courage. 
 It happened once while he was trying to make up his mind to do a very dangerous job in the last war. 
 It had happened again while he was screwing his resolution to go and see a certain man in London and make to him an excessively embarrassing confession which justice demanded. 
 In both cases, the thing had seemed a sheer impossibility; he had not thought but known that, being what he was, he was psychologically incapable of doing it; and then, without any apparent movement of the will, as objective and unemotional as the reading on a dial, there had arisen before him, with perfect certitude, the knowledge &bquo;about this time tomorrow, you will have done the impossible&equo;. 
 Having been to confession and passed through &bquo;the wall of fire&equo;, Lewis wrote to Sister Penelope, &bquo;the suggestion about an orgy of egoism turns out, like all the Enemy propaganda, to have just a grain of truth in it, but I have no doubt that the proper method of dealing with that is as I intend to do, to continue the practice. 
 &bquo;* The practice of confession brought before Lewis the drama of redemption as a perpetual game of cat and mouse with the Devil &mdash; the Enemy. 
 The very particularity of the sacrament forces upon the penitent the sense that it is on the here and now &mdash; that row we had with the neighbours, the bad temper with which we did the washing-up, this specific uncharitable thought or unchaste deed &mdash; that salvation and damnation depend. 
 It is in the small area of our own conscience and our own personal behaviour that the good angels and the bad angels are wrestling over our souls, an idea which is both stupendous and slightly comic. 
 Betjeman's poem &bquo;Original Sin on me Sussex Coast&equo; makes a point unwillingly learnt from his old tutor when it depicts the sheer wickedness of children bullying one another, unseen by the sentimental eyes of the mother whose mind has been washed by modern advertising techniques and the vacuous optimism of the age: 
 Does Mum the Persil-user still believe That There's no Devil and that youth is bliss? 
 As certain as the sun behind the Downs And quite as plain to see, the Devil walks. 
 * It is categorically not the case that Lewis had &bquo;always wanted to attack the practice&equo; of sacramental confession &bquo;whenever he found it, This strange assertion (among many other inaccuracies) occurs in Clive Staples Lewis: A Dramatic life , by William Griffin. 
 Griffin quotes Lewis as saying, in a letter written to his father in March 1928, &bquo;If you try to suppress it, you only make martyrs.&equo; 
 Griffin's readers are not told that Lewis was not, here, speaking about confession. 
 The &bquo;it&equo; which he speaks of suppressing is the Oxford Group Movement formed by Frank Buchman and later known as Moral Rearmament. 
 The letter (written four years before Lewis became a Christian) expresses distaste for the Groupers' reported custom of extracting public confessions from their devotees. 
 war. 
 It was some time after making his first confession that he bumped into a pupil in Addison's Walk. 
 The pupil had been at Magdalen for a year, and then left to join the Army. 
 He was in uniform, very much in the situation in which Lewis had found himself as an undergraduate at Univ. 
 Having given his news, he asked Lewis what he was writing. 
 &bquo;I've had this idea&equo;, said Lewis, &bquo;of letters from a senior devil to a junior devil&equo; The Screwtape Letters  brought into literary use qualities which Lewis had had to a highly developed degree ever since adolescence. 
 His ability to see through human failings, his capacity to analyse other people's annoyingness, his rich sense of comedy and satire, had as yet only found their outlet in letters to Greeves, and to a lesser extent in such collections as P'dayta-Pie. 
 In The Screwtape Letters  his inspired malice is given creative rein. 
 &bquo;She's the sort of woman who lives for others &mdash; you can always tell the others by their hunted expression.&equo; 
 Or take the old woman who is really a slave to the Gluttony of Delicacy but thinks she is the very model of abstinence: She is a positive terror to hostesses and servants. 
 She is always turning from what has been offered her to say with a demure little sigh and smile, &bquo;Oh, please, please&hellip; all  I want is a cup of tea, weak but not too weak, and the teeniest weeniest bit of really crisp toast.&equo; 
 You see? 
 Because what she wants is smaller and less costly than what has been set before her, she never recognises as gluttony her determination to get what she wants, however troublesome it may be to others&hellip; 
 In a crowded restaurant she gives a little scream at the plate which some overworked waitress has set before her and says, &bquo;Oh, that's far, far too much! 
 Take it away and bring me about a quarter of it.&equo; 
 To the comedy of such pen-portraits (and Screwtape , it has to be admitted, is a cruel book), is added moral wisdom and a developing religious vision. 
 Lewis is extremely good at describing the actual territory in which the moral life, for most of us, is thrashed out, and the extent to which we enable ourselves to be deluded about ourselves and other people: 
 When two humans have lived together for many years it usually happens that each has tones of voice and expressions of face which are almost unendurably irritating to the other. 
 Work on that. 
 Bring fully into the consciousness of your patient that particular lift of his mother's eyebrows which he learnt to dislike in the nursery and let him think how he dislikes it. 
 Let him assume that she knows how annoying it is and does it to annoy &mdash; if you know your job he will not notice the immense improbability of the assumption. 
 It is the last bit of that sentence which contains the punch. 
 Though Lewis is said to have found the task of writing these letters morally exhausting &mdash; entailing as it did the ceaseless identification of himself with the malign and diabolical point of view &mdash; their great strength is that, rather like a dramatic monologue by Browning, they reveal the speaker without  succumbing to his terrible outlook. 
 Although they are the letters of instruction from an older devil to a younger, Screwtape's sense of what the Enemy (i.e. God) is preparing for his servants cannot fail to break through. 
 One must face the fact that all the talk about His love for man, and His service being perfect freedom is not (as one would gladly believe) mere propaganda, but an appalling truth. 
 He really does  want to fill the universe with a lot of loathsome little replicas of Himself &mdash; creatures whose life, on its miniature scale, will be qualitatively like His own, not because He has absorbed them but because their wills freely conform to His. 
 We want cattle who can finally become food; He wants servants who can finally become sons. 
 We want to suck in, He wants to give out. 
 Or again: 
 He's a hedonist at heart. 
 All those fasts and vigils and stakes and crosses are only a fa&ccedil;ade. 
 Or only like foam on the sea shore. 
 For at sea, out in His sea, there is pleasure, and more pleasure. 
 He makes no secret of it; at His right hand are &bquo;pleasures for evermore&equo;. 
 Ugh! 
 Once he started, Lewis appears to have written The Screwtape Letters  very quickly. 
 He offered them to the editor of the one periodical which, by this stage, he was in the habit of reading: a High Church weekly, since defunct, called The Guardian.  
 The Guardian  published the letters in weekly instalments from May to November 1941. 
 Lewis was paid &pound;2 per article, and the money was paid directly into a fund for &bquo;Clergy Widows&equo;. 
 Ashley Sampson, who had commissioned The Problem of Pain , persuaded his parent publisher to make an offer for the publication of Screwtape  in book form. 
 When it was published, in February 1942, the first printing of 2,000 copies was sold immediately. 
 There were two reprintings in March, and the book has been in print ever since, selling over a million copies. 
 What had begun as a jeu d'esprit  of a mere 30,000 words or so made Lewis a household name. 
 The other factor which contributed to this effect was his decision to become a broadcaster. 
 This came about in an equally haphazard fashion. 
 Feeling sheepish about his ineligibility for active servIce, Lewis had accepted an invitation from the RAF chaplains to tramp around the country and give talks to the men in various RAF stations. 
 Tolkien, who found the contents of these talks, when published, not especially to his taste, nevertheless admired the simple religious feeling which inspired them. 
 Teaching was his original object. 
 He took it up in a Pauline spirit, as a reparation; now the least of Christians (by special grace) but once an infidel, and even if he had not persecuted the faithful, one who scorned the Faith, he would do what he could to convert men or stop them from straying away. 
 The acceptance of the R.A.F. mission, with its hardship of travel to distant and nasty places and audiences of anything but the kind he was humanly fitted to deal with, lonely, cheerless, embarrassed journeys leaving little behind but doubt whether any seed had fallen on good soil; ali this was in its way an imitation of St. Paul. 
 The talks which Lewis gave to the RAF were on such basic issues as &bquo;Why we think there is a Right and Wrong&equo;, and from such simple beginnings he framed, in language which was meant to be arresting to ordinary men in the ranks, an exposition first of the theist position, then of the Christian religion. 
 In February 1941, he was approached by the Director of Religious Broadcasting at the BBC and asked if he would be prepared to give a series of broadcast talks on &bquo;The Christian 
 Faith as I see it &mdash; by a Layman&equo;; and although there was first a certain amount of debate about what the nature and title of the broadcasts should be, Lewis began to do this in the late summer of 1941, taking the train from Oxford to London every Wednesday evening, and broadcasting from 7.45 to 8.00 p.m. 
 Sound-broadcasting is a particular skill, not necessarily related to literary ability though impossible without it. 
 That is, one needs the literate ability to express oneself clearly; but one also needs the right voice and the ability to be concise. 
 Lewis's broadcasts during the war were in three series, and they were written up (published more or less as spoken over the air) as Broadcast Talks  (1942), Christian Behaviour  (1943) and Beyond Personality  (1944). 
 The key to them lies in the title of the second series &mdash; Christian Behaviour . 
 Lewis is better than any modern writer both at explaining what Christian behaviour should be and at analysing its difficulties. 
 People often think of Christian morality as a kind of bargain in which God says, &bquo;if you keep a lot of rules I'll reward you, and if you don't I'll do the other thing.&equo; 
 I do not think mat is the best way of looking at it. 
 I would much rather say that every time you make a choice you are turning the central part of you, the part of you that chooses, into something a little different from what it was before. 
 And taking your life as a whole, with all your innumerable choices, all your life you are slowly turning this central thing into either a heavenly creature or into a hellish creature. 
 It is unfortunate that shorthand here makes Lewis imply that the life of submission to Grace is a course of self-improvement. 
 Indeed overall, he says surprisingly little about Grace and next to nothing about the sacramental life; for these reasons one might regret the title which he gave to the three books gathered into one &mdash; Mere Christianity  &mdash; for it implies that he has written a sort of mini-Summa or encyclopaedia of theology. 
 That was not his intention. 
 His intention in the lively fifteen-minute talks was to answer such questions as &bquo;Can an intelligent person be a Christian?&equo; 
 &bquo;What should a Christian's attitude be towards war, sex or money?&equo; 
 &bquo;Is there a heaven and a hell?&equo; 
 He answers these questions with a breeziness and a self-confidence which on an academic podium would have been totally unacceptable. 
 And the language and idiom of the broadcasts has dated: &bquo;There has been a great deal of soft soap talked about God for the last hundred years. 
 That is not what I am offering. 
 You can cut all that out&hellip;&equo; or &bquo;The Christian replies &lsqb;to some Aunt Sally which Lewis has conveniently erected&rsqb; &bquo;Don't talk damned nonsense&hellip;&equo; or &bquo;I personally think that next to Christianity Dualism is the manliest and most sensible creed on the market.&equo; 
 It is hard to read these sentences without a smile. 
 Nor are all his attempts at analogy helpful. 
 Certainly to explain the Incarnation in a quarter of an hour over the air is a tall order, but Lewis could surely have done better than to say, &bquo;If you want to get the hang of it, think how you would like to become a slug or a crab.&equo; 
 Apart from being offensive, this is bad theology. 
 God made human beings in His own image and likeness. 
 Human beings did not make slugs or crabs. 
 Man could not &bquo;redeem&equo; the slugs even if slugs were in need of redemption. 
 Such lapses were seized upon eagerly by Lewis's jealous academic colleagues. 
 There is nothing like worldly success on the part of one academic to make all the others hate him or her. 
 Lewis's immediate success with the general public, and the huge popularity of his theological books, guaranteed him a rough ride with the Fellows of Magdalen, as well as with those in the Oxford Faculties of Theology and English Literature. 
 Of course, it was not just the atheists who disliked him. 
 It was a Christian colleague in the English Faculty who said, &bquo;The problem of pain is quite bad enough without Lewis making it worse.&equo; 
 Even those one would expect to have rejoiced at the religious revival which Lewis's popularity heralded and to a certain degree inspired could only bring themselves to sneer. 
 R. H. Lightfoot, for example, the chaplain of New College, and author of a learned commentary on St John's Gospel, remarked to a young colleague of Lewis's: &bquo;His defection to the area of theology is a sad loss to the English Faculty. 
 I wish it could be said to be a gain to the Faculty of Theology.&equo; 
 Lewis knew that they were all saying things like this, and it stung. 
 It hurt even more that friends like Tolkien, to whom he had dedicated The Screwtape Letters , could not respond to Lewis's effusions as &bquo;Everyman's Theologian&equo;. 
 However little his colleagues liked Lewis's activities as a lay evangelist, there can be no doubt about his tremendous impact on the church of his day. 
 Father Andrew, the saintly co-founder of the Society of the Divine Compassion, wrote to one of his many correspondents: &bquo;To me it is one of me most hopeful things of this epoch that it has produced C. S. Lewis.&equo; 
 As far as the Church of England was concerned, there were giants in those days. 
 Perhaps they were the last days before the final eclipse. 
 T. S. Eliot was completing the Four Quartets . 
 All too briefly, until his untimely death in 1944, there was an Archbishop of Canterbury who was not only a learned philosopher and theologian but was also able, in such writings as his Readings in St John's Gospel  to speak to people at a simple devotional level. 
 Dorothy L. Sayers was writing her series of radio plays about the life of Christ called Man Born to Be King . 
 Lewis's popularity was part of this, and it was with more than a scent of victory in the air, victory over the agnostics and freethinkers, that he consented to be involved with the foundation of the Socratic Club in Oxford in 1941. 
 This was an undergraduate debating society, founded with an aggressively Christian purpose by a student at Somerville College called Stella Aldwinkle. 
 Since all undergraduate societies are meant to have one senior member, she asked Lewis to become the President of the Society, a position he held until his departure for Cambridge in 1954. 
 &bquo;Those who founded it do not for one moment pretend to be neutral,&equo; Lewis confessed. 
 &bquo;It was the Christians who constructed the arena and issued the challenge&hellip; 
 &equo; Socratic evenings took the form of two speakers facing one another over some such topic as &bquo;Is theology poetry?&equo; or &bquo;If we have Christ's ethics does the rest of Christianity matter?&equo; 
 The ideal Socratic evening came about when one of the speakers was an out-and-out atheist, but sometimes the society could only find speakers of opposing viewpoints within the Christian fold. 
 When Lewis himself was speaking, it was not always easy to find a tame atheist who was prepared to come along and be mauled in public debate; for on these occasions he reverted to type and became again the P'daytabird prosecuting an unlikely prisoner in the Belfast police courts. 
 No one who witnessed these debates has ever suggested that Lewis played fair. 
 He argued with tremendous vigour, and when he demolished his victims it was with evident relish. 
 There were those who admired Lewis's moral courage in being thus prepared to testify for the Christian faith, but not everyone found the spectacle altogether edifying. 
 On top of all his other commitments, Lewis was writing the second volume of his space trilogy. 
 &bquo;I've got Ransom to Venus and through his first conversation with the &bquo;Eve&equo; of that world: a difficult chapter&hellip; 
 I may have embarked on the impossible,&equo; Lewis wrote to Sister Penelope on 9 November 1941. 
 The effort shows in the writing. 
 Perelandra  is the most ambitious of the outer-space stories, and the one with the most single-minded theological aim: nothing less than an imagined temptation-scene between Satan and Eve in which she does not  succumb. 
 For the purpose of saving her, Ransom (veteran of the journey to Malecandra in Out of the Silent Planet)  is actually made a Ransom for her, a sort of Christ figure sent to wrestle with the wicked scientist Weston who tries to bring about the Fall on the newly inhabited planet Venus. 
 Not even John Milton's imagination had attempted such a theme. 
 It is no wonder that Perelandra  is an artistic failure. 
 How could it have succeeded? 
 This is not to say that it does not contain many magnificent passages, some comic, some sublime. 
 And, almost more than any of his other fiction, it reveals what Lewis as a writer was chiefly concerned to achieve. 
 He wanted nothing less than a revival of the Romantic movement in literature, only a revival under firm Christian management. 
 The key passage, from this point of view, is the temptation offered by Weston/Satan (the Un-Man) to which the Woman all but yields: the image of herself as a great soul. 
 &bquo;Greatness, tragedy, high sentiment &mdash; these were obviously what occupied her thoughts.&equo; 
 The new Eve momentarily wants to be a tragedy queen; for a few flickering instants, she wants to be like almost ali the characters in literature whom we find most beguiling &mdash; Cleopatra, Anna Karenin, Madame Bovary, Eve herself in Paradise Lost  &mdash; a figure who has risked everything for the sake of une grande passion . 
 To set against this the prosaic virtues of humility and obedience, and to make them seem not merely right but also interesting, is &mdash; when the writer is a fallen creature writing for other fallen creatures &mdash; an impossible task. 
 Lewis tried, and inevitably blundered this way and that, sometimes falling into appalling sentimentality, sometimes writing ridiculous masculine-minded nonsense about &bquo;a woman's place&equo;. 
 The story does, however, abound in felicities; the physical descriptions of the planet, for example, are superb. 
 And there are scenes of great moral effectiveness, as when Ransom, plucking up his courage far the struggle with Weston, recalls that &bquo;at that moment, far away on earth&hellip; men were at war, and white-faced subalterns and freckled corporals who had but lately begun to shave, stood in horrible gaps or crawled forward in deadly darkness, awakening like him to the preposterous truth that all really depended on their actions.&equo; 
 The effectiveness of that is not just to make Ransom's struggle real, but also to demonstrate the metaphysical excitement of all moral choices, on the silent planet as well as beyond the music of the spheres. 
 Outwardly, the plot of Perelandra  is borrowed from Milton's Comus , and its chief ideological failing stems from this. 
 Milton never makes clear exactly how the Lady's virtue is saved. 
 In the end, it would seem that she is not strong enough to resist Comus's wiles without the intervention of Sabrina. 
 Likewise in the case of Lewis's Eve: if she is ransomed by Ransom's struggle with the Un-Man in the underworld, a sort of Harrowing of Hell sequence, how can she be said to have resisted the temptation on her own; and if she has not really  resisted through her own strength &mdash; if she is to be rewarded with immortality and felicity for something she has not done herself &mdash; where is the justice in the punishment, on another planet, of Eve and her descendants, for something which again was not wholly her responsibility? 
 Are we to suppose that human beings only exercise free will when they sin &mdash; or, worse, only sin when they exercise free will? 
 These questions were to make John Milton abandon any discernable belief in the doctrine of Grace and become a sort of Stoic. 
 Lewis never seems to have faced the problem, either in his imaginative writings or in his works of theology. 
 If the woman resisted Weston's voice simply out of obedience to Maleldil, then what was the function of Ransom? 
 This was the question, in notional form, which he had asked Tolkien and Dyson during the September night of 1931 when they talked Lewis into becoming a Christian. 
 &bquo;My puzzle was the whole doctrine of Redemption: in what sense the life and death of Christ &bquo;saved&equo; or &bquo;opened salvation&equo; to the world&hellip; 
 What I couldn't see was how the life and death of Someone Else &bquo;whoever he was&equo; 2000 years ago could help us here and now.&equo; 
 Perelandra  shows that even on the mythopoeic level this most difficult of doctrines had not been absorbed by Lewis. 
 Another decade was to pass before it really sank in, and he could write, &bquo;What an ass I have been both for not knowing and for thinking I knew. 
 I now feel that one must never say one believes or understands anything&hellip; &bquo; 
 This was an admission made to Sister Penelope in 1951. 
 In 1941 he was still very content with an unrealized, cerebral exposition of the Christian gospel which was to lead him into many distortions. 
 Nevertheless, the sisters of the Community of St Mary the Virgin were very happy to receive the dedication to Perelandra: 'To  some ladies in Wantage&equo;. 
 TALES OF THE TUB 
 Bathrooms with Aplomb 
 IRISH GARDENS 
 Join our Grand Tour 
 THE HEDGEHOG 
 Not just a prickly face 
 THE GREAT BRITISH PUDDING REVIVAL 
 TAIT &amp; STYLE 
 Fashion from Orkney 
 Send for our supermac: under 30&pound; 
 Follow the antiques trail 
 Goggle at gargoyles 
 JANE GOODALL 
 MICHAEL VINEY 
 HANNAH HAUXWELL 
 COUNTRY LIVING 
 ISSUE NUMBER 63 MARCH 1991 ON SALE 7 FEBRUARY 
 FEATURES 
 AMBASSADOR FOR THE CHIMPS 
 Jane Goodall, defender of the ape Anne Boston 
 FOX WARFARE 
 One farmer's fight to save his lambs Charlie Pye-Smith 
 THE GARDENER'S ACCOMPLICE 
 The discreet charm of the hedgehog Christopher Probert 
 FOOL'S GOLD 
 West Mayo in prospective peril Mary Dowey 
 HOLY SINISTER 
 Gargoyles sacred and profane Richard Rosenfeld 
 KING JAMES'S FRUITFUL ERROR 
 Round and round the mulberry tree James Driver 
 WRIST WATCH 
 Preventing and treating RSI Dr Charles Shepherd 
 ELEMENTAL EXPOSURE 
 Testing weatherproof cameras Steve Ashton 
 HOUSES &amp; GARDENS 
 HOMEFRONT 
 Taking cover with rugs and throws Gabi Tubbs 
 EMPORIUM 
 Compiled by Fiona Douglas Robertson 
 DRAKE'S PROGRESS 
 Collecting aquilegias Barty Phillips 
 THE GARDEN PATH 
 Miranda Innes 
 THE MEETING HOUSE 
 Comfortable chic in Lancashire Judi Goodwin 
 TUSCANY IN SOMERSET 
 A corner of England that is for ever Italy Hester Page 
 FAUCET SAGA 
 Bathrooms with aplomb Gabi Tubbs 
 BACK IN THE PINK 
 Restoration of a Suffolk farmhouse Gillian Darley 
 CRAFTS 
 TAIT &amp; STYLE 
 Felting in Orkney Katy Brown 
 FOOD &amp; DRINK 
 ROLYPOLY, PUDDINGS AND PIE 
 Great British Puddings Philippa Davenport 
 SEAL OF APPROVAL 
 The history of the cork Kathryn McWhirter 
 FASHION &amp; BEAUTY 
 BEST FRIENDS 
 Clothes to play in Robert Burgess 
 BEAUTY FROM WITHIN 
 Paula McWaters 
 REGULARS 
 MAGPIE 
 Compiled by Vicky Carlisle 
 BRIAN REDHEAD 
 NETWORK 
 News pages Edited by Jules MacMahon 
 SCENES FROM A PROVINCIAL LIFE 
 Michael Viney 
 FOLLOW THE ANTIQUES TRAIL 
 Bath and beyond Deirdre McSharry 
 ESCAPES 
 Wiltshire with and without children Compiled by Jules MacMahon 
 BOOKS 
 Save our neglected historic houses Marcus Binney 
 MOTORING 
 Danger; male drivers Frank Page 
 YOUR LETTERS 
 Compiled by Teph Willis 
 MY COUNTRY CHILDHOOD 
 Hannah Hauxwell 
 OFFERS 
 PURE WOOL THROW 
 AQUILEGIAS 
 WILLOW BASKET 
 SCARVES AND SHAWLS BY TAIT AND STYLE 
 BLACK MULBERRY TREE 
 ALL-WEATHER RIDING COAT 
 COMPETITIONS &amp; TREATS 
 THE RULING PASSION OF JOHN GOULD 
 10 books to be won 
 WIN A BOOK OF SECRETS 
 IRISH GARDENS: A GRAND TOUR 
 Visit eight of the best Miranda Innes 
 STAY IN A MEDIEVAL MANOR IN GLOUCESTERSHIRE 
 Three nights for the price of two 
 FREE ADMISSION TO ANTIQUES FAIR, BATH 
 WIN AN OLYMPUS AF-I TWIN CAMERA 
 CLASSIFIED ADVERTISING 
 ADVERTISERS' INDEX  
 Faucet saga 
 Drake's progress 
 Homefront 
 Buy an all-weather riding coat 
 Rolypoly, puddings and pie 
 FIRST WORDS 
 Happy Birthday to us! 
 Thanks to you, loyal readers, Country Living  is now celebrating its fifth year as a monthly publication, with a circulation of 175,000. 
 Many people express surprise that the magazine is so young, and Radio 4's News Stand  programme recently described us as &bquo;good old Country Living &equo;. 
 I took that as a compliment &mdash; a sign that we have become accepted as part of everyday (country) life. 
 In our five years we have supported many country issues and charities. 
 We have campaigned for better rural transport, and for unleaded petrol and catalytic converters to be made more widely available. 
 We have publicised the plight of arctic terns, seals, badgers and intensively reared animals. 
 We have tried to present both sides of the hunting and shooting debate, and will be publishing the results of last month's field sports questionnaire as soon as they are analysed. 
 We have supported farmers and rural enterprise through features and our Small Rural Business Award and independent food shops competition. 
 We are successful, but success brings brickbats. 
 We have been accused by some of having too many features about the south of England, by others of having too many about Scotland and Wales; of having too much mud on our boots, of romanticising the countryside, of being too green, too blue, too red, too expensive and aspirational in our tastes, too harshly realistic in our coverage of controversial issues. 
 Each month we take note of your letters and try to redress the balance, hoping that over the year we get it just about right. 
 Fortunately, as well as complaints, we have received plenty of praise and awards for our distinctive photography and excellent writing over the past five years. 
 Some of our best writers are on the staff of the magazine, and one of them is Associate Editor Anne Boston. 
 This month she has contributed a terrific interview with Jane Goodall, the intrepid watcher and champion of chimpanzees (see pages 34&ndash;36). 
 As well as receiving your letters, we like to meet you at the Royal Show, reader workshops and garden visits. 
 I hope gardeners among you will take up our offer of a grand tour of Irish gardens in June. 
 I went to the Wicklow Gardens Festival last year and enjoyed it thoroughly; and the welcome I received at Hunter's Hotel makes a return visit hard to resist. 
 Reports on Tinakilly House Hotel are just as complimentary. 
 Details on pages 88&ndash;92. 
 I was also thrilled to be invited to the wedding of Jack Woolley and Peggy Archer, a small family and village affair at which Peggy looked demure in a cream silk chiffon frock; Jack and best man Nelson Gabriel were devastatingly handsome in their grey morning coats. 
 We toasted the couple with champagne, sampled Jean-Paul's cake (not bad, considering how little time he had to make it) and were allowed to throw confetti over the happy couple in their BBC function room &mdash; or was it really Grey Gables? 
  Francine Lawrence   
 Francine Lawrence with Peggy and Jack (June Spencer and Arnold Peters) 
 NEXT ISSUE ON SALE MARCH 14 
 MAGPIE 
 A TREASURE TROVE OF TEDDY BEARS, TAPESTRIES, TILES AND TROPICAL FISH, PLUS A SCENTED BOOK OF SECRETS. 
 COMPILED BY VICKY CARLISLE 
 BOX CLEVER 
 Catriona Stewart sells her patch boxes to some of the most exclusive shops in the country, yet she still works at the kitchen table &bquo;with meals, toys and people all around&equo;. 
 Rectangular, oval, hexagonal and so on, her range of 17 paper boxes are decorated with watercolour designs of flowers and rural scenes, and inscribed on the lid and inside with quotations or simple messages. 
 At &pound;8.65, each box is hand-made with recycled paper, and finished with a matt varnish for protection. 
 Contact Catriona in Petersfield, Hampshire, on 0730&ndash;69112. 
 FRUITS FROM THE VINE 
 This vine-leaf bowl with its cargo of glossy lemons comes from a pottery founded in the 1920s by a member of the Bloomsbury Group, Phyllis Keyes. 
 After the Second World War the pottery moved to Tingewick, the Keyes family house, where it continues under the aegis of Phyllis's great-niece, Sara Johnson. 
 The pottery retains the atmosphere of a family business: the exclusive designs are hand-glazed with meticulous care, in colours that are themselves hand-mixed. 
 There is a small stock in the pottery but most of the work is commissioned. 
 This bowl costs &pound;70, the fruit from &pound;7. 
 Tingewick Pottery is at Upper Street, Tingewick, Bucks MK18 4QJ. 
 PRICKLY PROBLEMS 
 Hedgehogs injured on the roads and other countryside casualties find their way to 21-year-old Jonathan Hodges at The Falconry, Otter and Wildlife Sanctuary near Cheadle. 
 Some birds and animals come via the RSPCA and he receives funding for these; but he himself pays for the care of injured wildlife brought in by the public. 
 Jonathan would value help with feeding, caring and building quarters for convalescing badgers. 
 To volunteer, visit or make a donation, call 0538&ndash;75784. 
 For more on hedgehogs, see page 58. 
 SILKEN SEAS 
 Yearning for turquoise seas and sunshine skies, or just suffering from mid-winter blues? 
 Liz Jones's hand-dyed silk scarves, swimming with shoals of brightly coloured tropical fish, will enliven any grey March day. 
 Inspired by the coral coasts of Papua New Guinea (where Liz lived and worked for nine years), this aquarium on silk is made by using a rubber-based glue called gutta in the same way that wax is used in the batik process. 
 Choose from an assortment of shapes, sizes and colours and order from Liz (who works from a cottage near Evesham) on 0386&ndash;871159. 
 Prices from &pound;20. 
 ROOFTOP RENOVATIONS 
 Traditional peg tiles have been in great demand since the storms of the past few years, so for Tenterden tile makers Spicer, the clouds had a silver lining. 
 Spicer's tiles and fittings are made by hand from clay, according to methods first used by craftsmen during Richard III's reign. 
 The unique roughened texture induces rapid weathering so that new tiles quickly blend with old ones &mdash; particularly useful for those living in ancient or listed buildings. 
 The tiles are available in two textures &mdash; sanded or weathered &mdash; and a variety of colours. 
 Secondhand peg tiles and ornamental tiles are also stocked. 
 For details contact Andrew and Jane Spicer on 0797&ndash;270784. 
 THE WOMAN'S DOMAIN 
 &bquo;How happy were I if the Gods above/Would equalize my fortune wth. my Love,&equo; 
 Alice Sherard wrote in her Notebook of Instructions (1675) &mdash; soon realising her aim by marrying Sir John Brownlow, heir to Belton House and its Lincolnshire estates. 
 Once widowed, she kept the estates within the family by marrying one of her five daughters to her nephew, Belton's male heir. 
 In The Woman's Domain: Women and the English Country House  (Viking/National Trust, &pound;16.99), authors Trevor Lummis and Jan Marsh intertwine the stories of seven women with the country houses they occupied. 
 Formidable Elizabeth of Shrewsbury (Bess of Hardwick Hall): Rosalie Chichester (an early animal rights campaigner, shown here with her Sunday School girls); ravishing Emma Hamilton (later Nelson's mistress) and others come to life through their letters and household accounts, their courtships and inheritances. 
 FOOLED BY GOULD? 
 You could be forgiven for remembering John Gould as a brilliant painter of birds &mdash; that's exactly what he would have wanted. 
 But in fact his skills were deployed as a manipulator and producer. 
 He gathered around him a circle of artists &mdash; his wife, Elizabeth Coxen, and Edward Lear among them &mdash; who learnt to interpret his clumsy sketches into lithographs, which Gould then corrected, albeit with precision and confidence. 
 In The Ruling Passion of John Gould  (Barrie &amp; Jenkins, &pound;16.99) Isabella Tree has documented the life of this unscrupulous genius and assembled some of &bquo;his&equo; magnificent illustrations (these are culmenated toucans). 
 To win one of 10 copies, tell us on a postcard what the toucan feeds on. 
 Answers marked Country Living  /Birds to the address on page 2 by 31 March. 
 MARBLING BY THE BOOK 
 The original method of making marbled endpapers used oil paints to produce a pattern on the surface of a tank of &bquo;size&equo; (a watery, gelatinous mixture). 
 The resulting patterns were transferred to paper by carefully floating it on top. 
 Frederica Freer has cut out the messy business by photographing the endpapers of 18th- and 19th-century books from the collection in her Gloucestershire house and turning the prints into postcards. 
 There are 16 designs, each giving the details of the book it was taken from; a pack of eight assorted cards and envelopes costs &pound;3.20; order on 060874&ndash;219. 
 CUSHION THE EFFECTS 
 If you fancy trying your needle at tapestry but feel daunted by mammoth prices and Bayeux complexity, Myriad tapestry kits may be the solution. 
 Polyanthus, poppy, magnolia and morning glory are four of six designs in the Myriad range, all inspired by English garden flowers. 
 Kits contain a full-colour printed canvas to make an eight-inch panel, wools, needle and instructions, and cost just &pound;13.95. 
 For a catalogue, send an sae to Myriad Designer Tapestry Kits, 16 High Street, Hadleigh, Suffolk IP7 5AP. 
 ODDS-ON FAVOURITE 
 Refna Hamey is currently one of the hottest tips among artists of the racecourse; her commissioned paintings include Corbiere, Grittar and Celtic Shot. 
 She paints mainly in acrylics, in a pointillist style with a sponge; and also produces cont&eacute; drawings on paper coloured to suit the coat of the horse. 
 She tries to capture a horse's character, whether it is wild or thoroughbred. 
 &bquo;I like to get pictures as if the horse is about to blink or breathe, the nostrils about to expand or contract, the legs about to break into a trot or canter.&equo; 
 For those not fortunate enough to own a racehorse, Refna will also paint humble family pets &mdash; dogs, cats and recently even a pet ram. 
 Refna's work is exhibited at the Equus Gallery in Newmarket (0638&ndash;560445) and she can be contacted in Gloucestershire on 0285&ndash;659918. 
 BEAR-FACED CHIC 
 Alfonzo (inset) reaches new heights of ursine designer chic: he wears a Cossack tunic and trousers to emphasise his Russian heredity, and his bright-red mohair fur is distressed to look as if generations of Grand Dukes have hugged him. 
 Teddy Bears of Witney have the original Steiff Alfonzo, made in 1908 for Princess Xenia Georgievna, and a limited edition of replicas. 
 The Cotswold-stone shop sells bears vintage (&pound;2,500) and everyday (&pound;10), and owner Ian Pout has trawled the world for the top teddies. 
 At &pound;110 Alfonzo is beyond most piggy-banks, so look on him more as an investment than a bedfellow. 
 The shop is at 99, High Street, Witney, Oxon (0993&ndash;702616). 
 New (not vintage) bears are sold by mail order. 
 LOVE STORY 
 &bquo;I feel sad when I don't see you. 
 Be married, why won't you?&hellip; 
 I will not make you bring in wood and water, or feed the pig, or milk the cow.&equo; 
 Who could decline this touchingly simple proposal from a 19th-century American suitor? 
 It appears in a new range of books (Birthday Book, Address Book, Book of Days, Book of Secrets) published by Pavilion in time for Valentine's Day to complement Love , Penhaligon's latest Scented Treasury of Verse and Prose . 
 Celebrated and little-known meditations on love by Donne, Rossetti, Shakespeare, and many others are coupled with beautiful paintings that prove the power of love to inspire artists, too. 
 The fragrance of Elizabethan rose, flower of love, permeates each book. 
 To win one of 25 copies of the Book of Secrets, tell us on a postcard who wrote The Great Lover  and send it to Country Living  /Love at the address on page 2 by 31 March. 
 BRIAN REDHEAD 
 &bquo;A worm may turn, but it will never turn nasty&equo; 
 Please, said a friend of this journal, egged on I suspect by a green-fingered two-year-old son, will you put in a word for the worm? 
 Charles Darwin beat me to it, I replied. 
 He considered the earthworm to be the most important animal in the history of the world. 
 But she has a point. 
 The worm is not only overlooked but undervalued. 
 The very word, whether used as noun or as a verb, is dismissive. 
 Even a worm will turn, we sneer. 
 He wormed himself in, we hiss. 
 All of which is very unfair. 
 A worm may turn, but it will never turn nasty. 
 And the garden would be lost without them. 
 It is estimated that the worm population in the average herbaceous garden is about a quarter of a million per hectare, which is roughly a hundred thousand per acre. 
 And as Gilbert White, the 18th-century naturalist, said, 
 without worms the earth would soon become cold, hardbound, void of fermentation and consequently sterile. 
 What worms do is tunnel through the earth. 
 Although they have no bones or skeleton, they are very strong. 
 All segments and bristles, they can anchor one end while pushing themselves forward with the other. 
 The maze of tunnels they create constantly aerates and drains the soil. 
 But they do not simply push their way through: they eat their way through, digesting any organic material as they go. 
 In effect, they both turn over the soil and fertilise the soil. 
 Worms are hermaphrodite &mdash; each one is both male and female, so any adult pair can reproduce, duly and dually, as it were. 
 They need to because they have many enemies both above and below ground. 
 Every early bird is after them, and a mole can eat twice its weight in worms every day. 
 The common earthworm can be anything from four inches to a foot long, and many people claim to have seen worms 20 inches long, but that may be stretching a point. 
 Three years ago there were reports that an earthworm six feet long had been found in Stratton St Margaret, near Swindon in Wiltshire, on an allotment. 
 But when they sent the specimen to the Natural History Museum it was found to be the intestine of a hedgehog, if you will pardon the expression. 
 A few months later a man living in Herne Bay in Kent found a live earthworm in his garden after a rainstorm. 
 He said it was six feet six inches long, and he took it to Bramble Wildlife Park near Canterbury for examination. 
 Unfortunately, before it could be positively  indentified  it fragmented and somebody threw the bits away. 
 Not that we need worms to be giants to be seduced by them. 
 The first World Worm Charming Championships, I recall, were held at Willaston, near Nantwich in Cheshire, in July 1980. 
 A local farmer's son, Tom Shufflebotham, who was then 20, charmed 511 worms out of the ground in half an hour. 
 He did it by gently vibrating the soil, coaxing the worms to the surface. 
 A great feat. 
 Perhaps you would like to take up worm charming, or at least worm watching. 
 March is the month when they begin to venture forth, having spent much of the winter lining their tunnels with fallen leaves. 
 They emerge at dawn and in the evening, for they are not wholly subterranean in their habits. 
 No more are they carefree. 
 They keep one end firmly in the ground while the other end explores the surface looking for anything organic. 
 They drag what they find into the tunnel, eat some of it and deposit the rest, which then rots and helps to feed the plants. 
 But all the time they forage they are alert, ready to withdraw instantly at the first hint of danger. 
 If you want to observe them as the light fades you must walk very carefully because they are very sensitive to vibrations and will shoot back into their tunnels at the slightest tremor. 
 They are also very sensitive to light, so it is no good shining a torch on them unless the beam is shielded by red plastic. 
 I confess I cannot really see worm watching catching on as a mass pursuit with worm watcher clubs and organised field visits, but I did hear of an infants' school where the worm has joined the tadpole as a creature for study. 
 And a friend in Scotland swears that he once heard a sermon preached on the wonders of creation in which the minister made much of the sanctity of the earthworm and even speculated on whether every earthworm is an individual. 
 That in turn apparently provoked a great argument afterwards among the students who had been in the congregation, with much quotation of Darwin and some rumblings among the creationists present. 
 Eventually an old gentleman who had been listening with much amusement to their discussion said that what mattered was not whether the earthworm has an immortal soul but whether it has a purpose. 
 And they all agreed that it has. 
 But that is true of all creatures great and small, not least the worm. 
 NETWORK 
 SCHEMES TO HELP THE DISABLED ENJOY THE COUNTRY, A REPRIEVE FOR SOWS, AND THE STORY OF VILLAGERS WHO BOUGHT THEIR OWN SHOP. 
 EDITED BY JULES MACMAHON 
 HARE VIRUS SCARE 
 Recent reports of a virus hitting hares in Britain need to be clarified, says Dr Stephen Tapper of The Game Conservancy Trust. 
 European Brown Hare Syndrome (EBHS), which yellows the arteries and causes liver damage, was first identified in 1986 by wildlife pathologists in Germany, after abnormally high mortality rates in hare populations. 
 It has only recently been recognised by MAFF experts, and media coverage has been misleading. 
 &bquo;It seems the continental disease may have been in this country for some time,&equo; Dr Tapper says, &bquo;but we don't believe hare populations are in serious danger.&equo; 
 The warm, dry summer of 1989 was a particularly good breeding year for hares, and was followed by a high autumnal &bquo;die-off&equo;. 
 In many cases, ordinary infections could be pinpointed, though some deaths were left unexplained and may have been due to EBHS. 
 But cold weather and a scarcity of food on arable land usually brings numbers down with the onset of winter. 
 The high mortality rates could simply be seen as nature playing its part in curbing hare numbers. 
  Henrietta Holder  
 DISABLED ACCESS 
 Imaginative provision has been made for wheelchair-bound bird watchers at the Rutland Water Nature Reserve. 
 A hide designed with their needs in mind can be found not far from the car park, and a concrete ramp allows easy access. 
 Inside, an apron has been fixed in front of the window-slots so wheelchairs can be pushed close, giving people the chance to sit comfortably and watch many of the 250-plus bird species. 
 Information from Tim Appleton on 1572&ndash;724101. 
 Blind &bquo;sightseers&equo; are also being given extra confidence to explore the countryside. 
 Nottingham University's Blind Mobility Unit has devised a system that produces &bquo;touch maps&equo;, raised plans formed from braillon plastic sheeting. 
 New symbols are used to indicate access points, pathways and other features of interest. 
 Many existing maps concentrate on urban areas, but the National Register of Maps for the Visually Handicapped in London (071&ndash;873 2599) is building up a library of rural maps too. 
 Organisations that have produced maps for their own areas can send copies to Dr A Tatham so others can benefit. 
 Details from the Royal National Institute for the Blind (0733&ndash;370777), The Fieldfare Trust (0742&ndash;701668) and the Countryside Commission (0242&ndash;521381). 
  Christine Harris  
 REPORT FROM THE REGIONS 
 Wootton Courtenay, a Somerset village of 90 households, three businesses (a post office, a garage and a shop) and a bus that comes twice a week, has recently won a battle to keep the heart of its community &mdash; the village shop &mdash; mostly thanks to the driving force of Stephen Parnell. 
 When the owners could no longer cope with the interest payments and pressure of their business, having tried to find a buyer for two years, they decided simply to close up. 
 With a post officer close to retirement and a garage owner struggling with ill health, Parnell was desperate not to let the quality of village life plummet. 
 At a public meeting last September he suggested that saying &bquo; they  ought to do something about it&equo; was pointless, and boldly proposed that the only way to save the shop was for everyone in the village to club together and buy it. 
 Raising &pound;130,000, setting up the share-holding/debenture scheme, running the shop and his own art gallery in Porlock, has meant that Parnell's life is not quite what it was pre-September. 
 &bquo;However, it's all been worth it,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;All sorts of people have helped: The Rural Development Commission has lent us &pound;10,000 to top up what we raised; all the retired, trainee and working accountants, lawyers, journalists and businessmen in the village have put in hours of voluntary work, and our grocery wholesaler Pharaoh Quirke has given us a new fascia board.&equo; 
 Opened officially on 11 January by their local MP Tom King, The Wootton Courtenay Villagers' Store and Company Limited is once again on secure foundations and trading well. 
 Further information on how to save your village shop using community initiative can be obtained from your local branch of the Rural Development Commission. 
  Katy Brown  
 SOW STALLS BANNED 
 The good news for pigs is that the Agriculture Minister John Gummer has announced his intention to introduce regulations banning the narrow breeding stall and neck and girth tethers for sows. 
 Strangely enough, his announcement came just the day before Sir Richard Body's press conference on his Pig Husbandry Bill, due for its second reading on 25 January. 
 Mr Gummer declared that a consultation paper is being drawn up in order to put regulations under an already existing Act before Parliament by the summer. 
 New installations of the sow stall would be banned from this year, and current systems phased out by the end of 1998. 
 Under the dry sow stall system pregnant sows are kept in metal pens with concrete floors, too small for them to turn or groom themselves. 
 Enforced inactivity causes chronic foot diseases and other ailments. 
 Sir Richard Body, a farmer who has kept pigs himself for many years, explained that he intends to press on with his Private Member's Bill since it would phase out the sow stalls within five years instead of the Minister's eight years. 
 &bquo;It is a coincidence that they announced it on the eve of my press conference,&equo; he admitted. 
 Farm animal welfare campaigners put it differently. 
 &bquo;The action of a private member has triggered the Government into action,&equo; commented Joyce D'Silva of Compassion in World Farming. 
 &bquo;We are really pretty delighted. 
 Pigs don't have a high public image and the dry sow stall is one of the worst kinds of factory farming. 
 Even if Sir Richard's Bill fails, Mr Gummer has been forced to bring in regulations himself. 
 But for the sake of the pigs we would obviously prefer Sir Richard's shorter phasing-out period.&equo; 
 The British initiative should also add a major impetus to bringing in EC-wide rules, now that more humane systems exist. 
 Look out for our forthcoming profile of Sir Richard Body, and articles on farm animal welfare. 
  Ann Boston  
 CHILDREN HATCH OUT RARE TURKEYS 
 For nearly 20 years, Simon Young, Education Officer at the Cheshire College of Agriculture near Nantwich, has championed the wildlife cause. 
 And he has done it largely with and for local schoolchildren: &bquo;The children are my ears and my eyes and my workforce.&equo; 
 The thousands of children who visit the college each year provided much of the research for the country's first Wildlife and Landscape Management Plan, now regularly consulted by major estates including the Royal Parks. 
 Children are now hatching rare breed turkey eggs in their classrooms (pupils from the Weaver School, Nantwich, are shown left) as part of another project &mdash; the rare breeds are vital to the turkey world as the white supermarket birds are incapable of breeding naturally. 
 Simon's first book, Green Wellies For All  (Lion Publishing, &pound;3.99), is published on 28 March under the pseudonym Peter Hamilton. 
  Jane Fickling  
 CONIFER CAMPAIGN 
 A local group in Dyfed is attempting to buy back 100 acres of land currently planted with Sitka spruce in order to uproot the conifers and return the acres to the original wild landscape of upland sheep farm. 
 Nicholas Luard of the John Muir Trust (husband of our cookery writer Elisabeth Luard) has joined forces with local people to form the Bara Ceirch Conservation Group, named after the farm on which the conifer plantation is sited. 
 The group is only too aware that the dangers of conifer plantations are not limited to creating great black tracts of sterile land (nothing grows beneath their dense needles). 
 More worryingly insidious is their ability to act as magnets to acid rain, taking it from the atmosphere and releasing it into the soil, where it leaches down and enters the water system. 
 Nicholas Luard and the other members of the group were particularly concerned about the planting of conifers at Bara Ceirch farm as it stands at the headwaters of the Rivers Cothi and Towy, two of the finest salmon rivers in Wales. 
 The plantation itself is close to a feeder stream that runs straight into the Cothi, as would acid taken in by the conifers. 
 The effects could be disastrous for the entire fish population, which in turn is bad news for the local industries based on fishing. 
 The National Rivers Authority in Wales has called for a ban on conifer plantations in sensitive areas, but Nicholas Luard and the Bara Ceirch group feel they need to act more quickly to save the river. 
 If you'd like to know more or offer help, contact group member Lynn Hughes, 3 Hill Close, Llangathen, Carmarthen, Dyfed SA32 8QE. 
 HOMEFRONT 
 taking cover 
 USE THROWS TO GIVE NEW LIFE TO AN OLD SOFA, AN INSTANT CHANGE IN DECOR &mdash; OR SIMPLY TO KEEP YOU WARM. 
 BY GABI TUBBS 
 Main picture, over whole settee  Multicoloured linen throw (215x236cm), &pound;425, by Cefyn Burgess at Contemporary Textile Gallery. 
 On seat, left to right  Italian open-weave wool throw with contrasting binding (260x270cm), &pound;145, from Collier Campbell. 
 Plain gold merino wool cloak, &pound;60, from Elliot Fine Fabrics. 
 Large broken-stripe yellow and off-white lap rug in wool and cashmere (150x200cm), &pound;170.75, from Colefax &amp; Fowler. 
 Heathery lambswool and mohair blanket (152x203cm), &pound;58.50, from Elliot Fine Fabrics. 
 Lime broken-stripe lap rug from Colefax &amp; Fowler, as before. 
 Red-pepper, saffron and turquoise pure silk throw (91x182cm), &pound;230, by Rosemary Atkinson 
 Over back, left to right  Burgundy/saffron/green lambswool tartan blanket (154x180cm), &pound;99.50, from The Scotch House. 
 Pastel wool blanket with patchwork effect in open weave (110x220cm), &pound;395, by Richard Womersley at Designers Guild. 
 Midnight blue/turquoise/yellow tartan rug in cashmere and wool (145x180cm), &pound;215, from The Scotch House. 
 Baby Lily is wearing cowl-neck cashmere jumper, &pound;190, by Pringle of Scotland. 
 Above  Soft cotton checked throw in cream and salmon pink (127x177cm), &pound;39; cream textured sampler cover in pure cotton (127x170cm), &pound;31; both from The American Country Collection 
 Above, top to bottom  Pure silk check throw in paprika and slate (91x182cm), &pound;230, by Rosemary Atkinson. 
 Black velvet-edged wool shawl with rose print (53x53cm), &pound;95, from Collier Campbell. 
 Fine wool tartan shawl in yellow/burgundy/green (142x140cm), &pound;39.50, from The Scotch House. 
 Richly coloured wool shawl in abstract print (53x53cm), &pound;75, from Collier Campbell. 
 Fine lambswool checked blanket in brick and cream (127x127cm), &pound;52.81, from Welstead Mills. 
 Thick pure wool blanket in sage and red-earth tartan (147x147cm), &pound;59.50; fine wool tartan shawl (140x140cm), &pound;39.50; both from The Scotch House 
 Left, top to bottom  Fine wool throw in window-pane check (127x127cm), &pound;35, from Welstead Mills. 
 Broken-stripe fringed lap rug (150x200cm), &pound;170.75, from Colefax &amp; Fowler. 
 Cotton throw with Williamsburg leaf pattern (127x180cm), &pound;39, from The American Country Collection. 
 Navy and white pure wool rug by Melin Tregwynt Mill, &pound;27.75, Country Living  offer (see page 29) 
 EMPORIUM 
 CLASSICAL CORBELS AND PENNSYLVANIA PAINTS; FIONA DOUGLAS ROBERTSON REVEALS HOW TO RECREATE THE EFFECTS IN THIS MONTH'S HOMES FEATURES  
 1 Settling down with a book  can be a chilly experience if there's no blanket to snuggle beneath. 
 Our traditionally woven throw from Melin Tregwynt Mill is made of 100 per cent pure new wool and guarantees a good, warm read. 
 Measuring 60&ins; by 48&ins;, it comes in indigo, rose or Wedgwood checks on cream. 
 Our special offer price is &pound;25.75. 
 Order using the coupon on page 154. 
 2 A classical corbel  makes a comely supportive device as a shelf bracket (see page 67), or a bookend. 
 This model (19 x 19.5cm), in high-density polyurethane, is only &pound;28.75 from Orac Decor. 
 It comes primed, ready for the paint finish of your choice (we applied a rich marbled effect). 
 For stockists nationwide ring 0483&ndash;271211. 
 3 Rug-scattered floors  (see page 63) are an attractive alternative to wall-to-wall carpets; for bright colours at reasonable prices, take a look at Tapetes . 
 Hand-woven and dyed in Mexico to North American Navajo designs, these colourfast and washable wool rugs can be made in any colour and size. 
 Prices start at &pound;80 for an 80 x 150cm rug. 
 A catalogue costs &pound;1, refundable with a purchase; ring 0747&ndash;870155 for further details (answerphone). 
 4 Exoticism  is never amiss in the bathroom, where the right tiles can create the effect of an Eastern bathhouse. 
 The UK Tech Team has obtained permission to import hand-painted Persian-style tiles in a design that dates back over 2,000 years. 
 This panel of 32 costs &pound;138 and is available from Ceramic Tile Design. 
 Ring 071&ndash;381 1455 for further details. 
 5 If you wonder  how someone like Sam Fifield-Hall (page 87) keeps her flagstones looking polished, here's a tip: detergent and heavy steam-cleaning wash away the glow with the dirt, so Sam suggests a quick once-over with a broom, then a soft-shoe shuffle in sheepskin slippers. 
 6 1 and 4 Salvaged bathroom fittings  command high prices but add authenticity. 
 If you want a cool Art Deco atmosphere, an original shower mixer like this costs &pound;295 from Stiffkey Lamp Shop's bathroom section in Norfolk. 
 Fine reproductions are also sold: this chrome loo-roll holder costs &pound;40. 
 For further details ring 0328&ndash;830460. 
 If zealous cleaning has taken its toll on your traditional enamel bath, the Antique Bath and Tap studio in Cheshire has a countrywide re-enamelling service . 
 They use the stoving technique, where the bath is put through the ovens at a controlled temperature, lower than that required for vitreous enamelling and so less damaging to old baths. 
 The fee is about &pound;300 plus VAT excluding transport costs &mdash; or they can re-enamel the bath in situ. 
 Ring 0270&ndash;626554. 
 2 Based on the old  thunderbox loo, this model from the Smallbone Sycamore bathroom range uses traditional lines to create a contemporary form. 
 Smallbone designs to individual requirements, so ring 071&ndash;581 9989 for a catalogue. 
 Price available on request. 
 3 If our shower wall  on page 128 appeals to you, a marbling kit (in Carrara) by Jocasta Innes from House Style will help create a similar effect. 
 It's &bquo;marbling-by-numbers&equo; with the use of veining maps. 
 At &pound;29.99, a kit covers four to six square metres. 
 Waterproof using a clear varnish. 
 Ring 071&ndash;377 9262 ext. 237 for details of stockists. 
 5 Painted American country  furniture grows more popular here; copy the look with a coat of paint on old faithful pieces. 
 Heart of the Country in Staffordshire is importing Old Village paints from Pennsylvania, made to 18th-century recipes. 
 Available in a range of earth pigments, including Cupboard Blue (like the Stothert's dresser, page 66), British Red and Antique Yellow; a pint pot costs &pound;7.50 (plus &pound;2.50 p&amp;p). 
 Ring 0543&ndash;481612 for free colour charts. 
 AMBASSADOR for the  CHIMPS 
 JANE GOODALL HAS SWAPPED RESEARCH FOR INTERNATIONAL CAMPAIGNING &mdash; IN AID OF HER FAVOURITE APES. 
 BY ANNE BOSTON 
 At the RSPCA's Centenary Conference in Oxford, a tall slim woman with greying hair drawn back in a pony tail, unobtrusively dressed in a shirt and slacks, came to the podium. 
 &bquo;Someone in the audience has asked me to greet them the way the chimpanzees greet each other in the wild at Gombe,&equo; Jane Goodall began. 
 &bquo;Hoo &mdash; hoo &mdash; hoo  &mdash; hoo  &mdash; HOO &mdash; HOO &mdash; WAAAAAH&hellip;&equo; 
 Who else in that distinguished gathering of philosophers, psychologists, veterinary professors and ethologists would desert their dignity so far as to imitate an animal ? 
 But then Jane Goodall is an anomaly, unique in animal behaviour research. 
 Her 30-year study of the Gombe National Park chimpanzees is the longest continuous field project ever recorded; it has made her &mdash; and the chimpanzees &mdash; a living legend, earning her honorary degrees, doctorates and wildlife-conservation awards all over the world. 
 It was her research that showed how close we are in evolutionary terms to the apes: how they communicate with each other, use tools (hitherto thought to be a strictly human activity) and develop lifelong bonds of family and friendship. 
 Equally, her study was the first to find that chimpanzees wage war on each other, hunt and eat other animals, and even turn murderously on their own kind. 
 Yet Jane Goodall started out with no formal scientific training. 
 You have only to read her bestselling books, In the Shadow of Man  and Through a Window , to recognise that by temperament she is a romantic and a child of nature. 
 And instead of distancing herself from her subject with the language of &bquo;scientific&equo; detachment, her message is one of passionate commitment to the primates she has studied for almost the whole of her adult life. 
 Jane Goodall's findings have helped to transform conventional scientific thinking about animals &mdash; which, of course, is used to rationalise how they are treated. 
 When she started publishing her work, animal behaviour research was dominated by theorists who contended more or less literally that to find out how a creature worked, you took it to bits. 
 I have good reason to remember a booklength early monograph of hers, published in the British journal of Animal Behaviour : it was almost the first text I ever read as an apprentice sub-editor. 
 Unlike the usual descriptions of repellent and apparently pointless tests on laboratory animals, hers was a wonderfully vivid account of her observations of wild chimps in their natural habitat. 
 She scandalised the academic conventions by naming all the chimps (Mr Leakey, after her mentor Louis Leakey; Mr McGregor, after the Beatrix Potter character) and referring to them as &bquo;he&equo; or &bquo;she&equo;, instead of &bquo;it&equo;. 
 &bquo;I didn't realise that animals were not supposed to have personalities, or to think or to feel emotions or pain,&equo; she recalls &mdash; which is just as well, since she went ahead and recorded what she observed, instead of what she was supposed to observe. 
 The chimps' individuality has always delighted and fascinated her, and Jomeo and Gigi, two full-blown eccentrics, are given a chapter each in Through a Window . 
 Jomeo is endearingly accident-prone and forever unsuccessful with females; Gigi, by contrast, is wildly popular with the opposite sex and has made up for her childlessness by becoming a universal aunt to other females' babies. 
 In science, the cardinal sin is anthropomorphism. 
 &bquo;But is it so terrible?&equo; 
 Jane Goodall asks. 
 &bquo;Chimpanzees are so like us intellectually and physiologically, it's absurd to think that we can't have some kind of rapport.&equo; 
 So long as the animals' behaviour is meticulously noted, she argues, empathy and intuition can be invaluable in interpreting it. 
 As a child she always dreamt of working with animals. 
 But where did the dream come from? 
 She shrugs and gestures heavenwards. 
 &bquo;Dr Dolittle and Tarzan. 
 Animals always came first &mdash; every book I read was about them.&equo; 
 The first animal she ever made friends with was a pig: &bquo;When I was small I always wanted to join a circus with a troupe of six Tamworth pigs. 
 Tamworths are the big ginger ones, you know? 
 That was my first ambition.&equo; 
 If that aim failed to materialise, it was no more extraordinary than the life that followed. 
 Her parents divorced when Jane was 12, and she and her sister hardly knew their father. 
 His absence was more than compensated for by her mother Vanne, whom she obviously adores. 
 Vanne took the first boat trip across Lake Tanganyika to Gombe Stream Chimpanzee Reserve with Jane in 1960, when the authorities refused to give a 20-year-old girl permission to set up camp on her own. 
 And it was Vanne who laid crucial foundations of goodwill with the local people, treating their ailments at her camp &bquo;clinic&equo; and making lifelong friends. 
 Susceptible to malaria, and having recently had open-heart surgery, Vanne can no longer go out to Africa; but when Jane visits the UK she stays with her mother in Bournemouth. 
 When they first shared a tent in the rainforest, how could they have foreseen that the camp would be Jane's home for almost her entire adult life? 
 Gombe is still inaccessible by road &mdash; but despite its isolation, it hasn't lacked human interest. 
 When her mentor, Louis Leakey, sent out the young photographer Hugo Van Lawick to photograph the chimpanzees at Gombe, he wrote to Vanne that he'd found just the husband for Jane. 
 He had &mdash; and the years of their marriage and their son Grub's early childhood were spent mainly at Gombe. 
 After their divorce Jane worked on, helped by students at the growing research station. 
 In the early 1970s she met Derek Bryceson, director of Tanzania's national parks. 
 Two years later they married, with Jane still based at Gombe while he kept his home and work in Dar es Salaam. 
 Bryceson had been a wartime pilot; shot down in the Middle East, he taught himself to walk again only through exceptional determination. 
 The disability didn't prevent him from farming in Tanzania and going on to hold several posts in the Tanzanian Cabinet. 
 Jane's chimp-watching patrols were impossible for him, but he visited often until his death from cancer, which left her devastated. 
 Meanwhile there were tragedies in the chimp colony. 
 Polio, apparently passed on from a human epidemic in the region, had already reduced their numbers. 
 Then a four-year &bquo;war&equo; between different groups caused the death of a whole community. 
 Worst of all was the four-year reign of terror when a female chimp, Passion, turned killer; during this gruesome time only one infant survived Passion and her daughter's cannibalistic attacks, until they both became pregnant and the deaths stopped. 
 And in the middle of this came the kidnapping of four students, who had to be ransomed from Zairean rebels across the lake. 
 The kidnappings were a traumatic event and for some time the Gombe Stream Research Centre was closed to students. 
 &bquo;It's a shock when it happens to you. 
 But I knew humans are capable of evil and it didn't change my view of humanity.&equo; 
 Whereas the chimpanzees' warfare and cannibalism changed for ever her rose-coloured idea of them as somehow &bquo;better&equo; than us. 
 It took Jane Goodall years to accept the new picture. 
 But the scenes of violent aggression have since been mitigated by equally extraordinary examples of altruism, in which older chimps have &bquo;adopted&equo; orphans too young to care for themselves. 
 New problems are constantly arising. 
 The camp is currently terrorised by the chimp community's first and only rogue male, Frodo. 
 Adult chimpanzees are much smaller than human beings, but up to three times as strong. 
 &bquo;I'm really frightened of Frodo. 
 Everybody is. 
 He's mean.&equo; 
 While this ambitious adolescent completes his long path of challenge and conquest, he terrorises everyone in his way &mdash; including researchers, who have to observe the chimps in pairs. 
 &bquo;But I always watch chimps alone and it's spoilt Gombe for me.&equo; 
 At 50 Jane Goodall looks fragile and sounds softhearted, but she has learnt to be tough. 
 The Gombe rainforest is not the sort of Eden we might fondly imagine. 
 She had to scramble daily through dense thorny undergrowth, up and down ravines slippery with mud, sit for hours in pouring rain, cope with illness and poisonous insects and marauding baboons. 
 Her capacity for solitude and disregard for physical comforts helped her to survive. 
 Now she has swapped all that for a nonstop international round of meetings, negotiations, lectures, media appearances. 
 In September, a month after the RSPCA conference, she was in England for the publication of her new book. 
 At our interview at the Royal Overseas League she was about to leave for a pit-stop author's tour, with an immensely heavy bag containing a laptop computer on which she fires off requests and thank-you letters: to American Secretary of State James Baker for his introduction to President Mobutu, to the King of Spain for agreeing to host a fundraising dinner for a chimp sanctuary in Spain. 
 She's an unofficial ambassador, I suggest. 
 &bquo;That's what I've been called,&equo; she agrees: &bquo;ambassador for the chimps.&equo; 
 At the turn of the century there were chimpanzees in 25 African states. 
 They are already extinct in five of these, and nearly so in four more, because of habitat destruction and because chimps are susceptible to human diseases. 
 And they are trapped and killed for food, or sold by poachers. 
 Baby chimps are captured by killing the mother, which is brutally wasteful: the infant often dies, along with other chimps trying to defend the mother. 
 Some small captives become pets but within five years they are potentially dangerous and have to be put behind bars. 
 Others are smuggled abroad for circuses or tourist entertainments or sold for medical research: there are 1,500 chimps in American labs. 
 The Jane Goodall Institute is fundraising and campaigning for more humane treatment of these pathetic captives, as well as for those in the wild. 
 The work in setting up sanctuaries for threatened chimps began when she was asked by the American ambassador in Burundi to design a conservation plan. 
 But the funding fell through, and she was told to give up the project. 
 &bquo;I said, &bquo;I can't. 
 I still care about the chimps; I've met the flipping things&equo;.&equo; 
 A researcher sent to report back to the Jane Goodall Institute kept hearing of captive chimps under sentence of death unless a place was found for them. 
 It was the same story in the Congo and again in Zaire. 
 &bquo;I wish  I hadn't been to Zaire. 
 I've told them I will help with advice, but I can't commit one dollar, they've got to do it themselves.&equo; 
 How many sanctuaries does she hope to set up? 
 &bquo;Basically, in every country where chimps need one. 
 In good business, what you do is raise the money and then start the project. 
 I've started the project and now I'm trying to raise the money. 
 My scientific colleagues say how can you possibly get involved when chimps in captivity live for 50 years? 
 I say, just put yourself in the position of one of those chimps living in concentration-camp conditions.&equo; 
 Every chimp's suffering haunts her. 
 In Brazzaville, she came across Gregoire, ancient and emaciated, kept chained up since 1943. 
 All his hair had dropped out and his behaviour was deeply disturbed. 
 Jane persuaded volunteers to give him food and attention. 
 &bquo;Gregoire now has some hair and he's put on weight! 
 Isn't it wonderful?&equo; 
 She strongly objects to the chimps' tea party in Brooke Bond tea ads: &bquo;I still want to know how the chimps are made to move their mouths like that. 
 I know of no natural movement you could reinforce.&equo; 
 Scrupulous honesty, and a strong sense of the ridiculous &mdash; she can be very funny &mdash; save her from sentimentality. 
 She speaks with an almost childlike directness that wins over the most sceptical audience. 
 And, unlike some animal lovers, she likes people. 
 On top of all her other commitments, she is involved in a major aid project to supply African health services with surplus American medical equipment. 
 She considers this &bquo;probably the most exciting thing I've been involved with. 
 It does tie in with conservation. 
 We're asking very poor countries to set aside land they could be cultivating food on &mdash; we have to give them something in return.&equo; 
 She must find it galling to be confused, as she often is, with Dian Fossey, the American disciple of Louis Leakey who studied gorillas in Rwanda; her life and murder &mdash; probably by poachers &mdash; became the subject of a Hollywood film. 
 Fossey made many enemies among both her colleagues and the local Africans. 
 In sharp contrast, Goodall learnt about diplomacy early on, back in England after her first spell at Gombe. 
 The press had already scented a story, and friends at Regent's Park Zoo urged her to speak out about the zoo animals' wretched living conditions, now she had seen them in their natural habitat. 
 &bquo;By pure chance I had dinner that night with Sir Malcolm MacDonald, a very experienced diplomat and former High Commissioner of Kenya. 
 He said, &bquo;Jane, is your goal to help the chimps, or is it to appear  to be helping the chimps?&equo; 
 I said, &bquo;My goal is to help them.&equo; 
 And he said, &bquo;The President of the London Zoo is very powerful. 
 You don't want to put him in a corner and have him as an enemy. 
 Tell me what you'd like to happen.&equo; 
 So I told him. 
 Two weeks later, the changes I wanted for the animals &mdash; shade, water, things like that &mdash; were done. 
 It was the best lesson I've ever had, and it came at just the right time.&equo; 
 After chimps, she is very fond of pigs; she says she's planning an anthology about them. 
 Apart from nostalgia for her troupe of Tamworths, this is partly out of gratitude for the plasticised pig valve in her mother's heart &mdash; &bquo;so pigs came to the fore again&equo; &mdash; and partly her horrified response on reading about European factory farms in Peter Singer's seminal book Animal Liberation . 
 She turned vegetarian as a result. 
 &bquo;After I stopped eating factory-farmed meat I now cannot stand the feeling of eating flesh. 
 Even the big fish like tuna or swordfish &mdash; they take so much longer to die, the tearing in the mouth of the hook. 
 I don't think I'll be eating fish much longer. 
 But I want to stay healthy so I can be useful.&equo; 
 Zoologists today have widely accepted that Jane Goodall's field research, apart from its own merits, has supplanted much observation of captive animals, showing that their behaviour is often disturbed and even psychotic. 
 But perhaps her greatest achievement with the chimps at Gombe has been to show how astonishingly close they are to humanity &mdash; and so to narrow the gap between us and the rest of the animal world. 
 She has no difficulty in reconciling Darwin's theory of evolution with her own Christianity. 
 &bquo;I can never understand why there should be a conflict between science and religion,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;I believe in human destiny. 
 I believe that we are evolving &mdash; we've done our physical evolution, I suppose, though we may eventually lose our appendix or the little toe. 
 But there's also a moral  evolution that's been going on. 
 A century ago there were children working down the mines in Britain. 
 Today they have gone. 
 There is a very strong moral attitude now towards human suffering. 
 And that's one stage closer to seeing animals in the same way.&equo; 
 The Jane Goodall Institute (UK) is a non-profit-making charity. 
 For details of membership, write to the Institute at 15 Clarendon Park, Lymington, Hants SO41 8AX.  
 In the Shadow of Man  (paperback, &pound;8.95) and Through a Window  (hardback, &pound;15) are both published by Weidenfeld &amp; Nicolson.  
 &bquo;THERE IS A VERY STRONG MORAL ATTITUDE NOW TOWARDS HUMAN SUFFERING. 
 AND THAT'S ONE STAGE CLOSER TO SEEING ANIMALS IN THE SAME WAY&equo; 
 DRAKE'S PROGRESS 
 CUSTODIAN OF THE COLUMBINE, ALIAS AQUILEGIA, JOHN DRAKE HAS SPENT YEARS RESEARCHING AND EXCHANGING SEEDS. 
 BY BARTY PHILLIPS 
 PHOTOGRAPHS/JOHN GLOVER 
 Every spare moment of John Drake's time is devoted to the two-acre garden he has carved out in an open and exposed part of the Fens near Cambridge. 
 He is an architect who works in London during the week; he also runs a landscape consultancy business called Drake and Lynch; is a member of the Hardy Plant Society; and is the holder of the National Collection of Aquilegias, under the auspices of the National Council for the Conservation of Plants and Gardens. 
 The clue to his gardening success in such unpromising terrain can be found at Hidcote in Gloucestershire, for it was a visit there during the 1960s that inspired him to hedge in his land, making a series of compartments to protect plants from the weather. 
 &bquo;Otherwise,&equo; he points out, &bquo;there's nothing to stop the wind between here and the Urals.&equo; 
 The land was originally a corn field and runs in a long narrow strip, still bordered by fields. 
 About a third of the way along stands the comfortable red-brick house that John's father built in 1938. 
 The now well-established hedges of beech, hornbeam, sea buckthorn ( Hippophae rhamnoides ) and an espaliered lime create a friendly environment where many different plants can flourish together. 
 &bquo;I try to plant in straight lines &mdash; I don't like amoebic-shaped beds. 
 My father thinks they should be in curved lines. 
 That's the only disagreement we have.&equo; 
 Seven years ago the garden was opened to the public, together with two others in the village, as a local fundraising event. 
 This is now a yearly fixture, as is a visit by members of the Hardy Plant Society, and a one-day opening to the public under the National Gardens Scheme. 
 People can also view the garden by appointment. 
 &bquo;It's amazing how much you need to know, and you can't know it all. 
 I'm very much cap-in-hand when people come &mdash; they may know more than I do. 
 I would like to open in winter. 
 That's the time when you can work out how people deal with their roses and the pruning and there are lots of other things flowering then, too.&equo; 
 Built up over the past 10 years, his aquilegia collection consists of about 130 species and hybrids, with the emphasis on species &bquo;to save as many as possible from extinction and allow present and future generations to know and enjoy their great beauty&equo;. 
 His interest began when he first opened the garden and found that many visitors wanted seeds from his 10 aquilegias. 
 &bquo;There were only about 15 varieties available then, but I did some research and came across an American monograph written before the Second World War that listed 250. 
 I decided to see how many I could collect, and to make them available to anyone who wanted them.&equo; 
 The collection is kept in pots so the plants can be moved about &mdash; to the Chelsea Flower show or to other nurseries for crossing. 
 Through seed exchanges he received seeds from this country and abroad. 
 Aquilegias grow wild throughout the northern hemisphere, so there are plants from Transylvania, Czechoslovakia, The Sofia Botanic Garden in Bulgaria, Japan, China and North America. 
 There are aquilegias everywhere in the garden. 
 &bquo;They seed all over the place and have the morals of tom cats, so are found in every flower bed, skulking behind hedges, peering round gate posts, naturalising in any open space. 
 This is Aquilegia  &bquo;Adelaide Addison&equo;, a white and blue granny's bonnet. 
 The original Adelaide's family still lives in Cambridgeshire. 
 And this is A. vulgaris  &bquo;Nora Barlow&equo;, named after a descendant of Charles Darwin. 
 The Barlow family, too, still lives in Cambridge. 
 This one is A. canadensis , orange and red.&equo; 
 The next part of garden you encounter is herby and low growing, with paths and pavings. 
 Here the grey-green foliage of Dicentra formosa  &bquo;Stuart Boothman&equo; complements an Alchemilla alpina , with each leaf outlined in silver. 
 There's a shrubby plantain, Plantago cynops , that makes a hairy mound with recognisable plantain heads poking out, and huge red trumpets of an Incarvillea delavayi  to add a sudden burst of colour. 
 To the west is the tall beech enclosure in front of the house where roses and other herbaceous plants flower under the trees in June and July. 
 Rosa arvensis , which has tiny white flowers, is a British native scrambler and sprawler. 
 There is an unusual small catmint ( Nepeta phylloclamys ) next to some tiny lilies that grow only six inches tall, and a viola on a tall stem that E A Bowles wrote about. 
 There are several clumps of the non-climbing spring sweet pea Lathyrus vernus  &bquo;that hardly anybody grows&equo;: it has small purple and blue flowers and helps to fill out the border. 
 Next to a spectacular variegated honesty that has to be sown from seed are a rare Acanthus dioscoridis  and a Helleborus abchasicus . 
 But John Drake doesn't really want to talk about rare plants. 
 &bquo;I believe in putting common stuff next to rarer things. 
 That makes the rare ones more difficult to find, but they aren't the main thing anyway. 
 What's wrong with growing some of our own native plants? 
 I've got some that were grown in Tradescant's time. 
 I'm keen on the scabious family and I'm trying to grow old wallflowers, but they are very difficult and susceptible to virus. 
 That's why nobody has succeeded in creating a National Collection.&equo; 
 He has a great many euphorbias: E. characias  with its giant yellow bottle-brush heads and brown bracts is allowed to lounge about in large clumps in corners; E. palustris , a smaller yellow one, came originally from the Chelsea Physic Garden. 
 Gales make it difficult to grow things actually against the house, but lavender and hellebores seem to cope. 
 Round the side of the house is the blue garden with the indefatigable blue centaurea rearing unkempt heads among bluebells, violets, a borage with blood-red buds, deep-purple auriculas and tall forget-me-nots. 
 The old tennis court was transformed, John confesses, with &bquo;an idea that came straight from Vita Sackville-West: four white prunuses in a white garden. 
 Most of our garden is open to the sky, and of course East Anglian skies are wonderful, but here you can walk in the shade.&equo; 
 There are small box bushes clipped into Christmas-pudding shapes, and tall silver birches, flexing in the wind. 
 The lime hedge is the only part of the garden that is sprayed, to prevent the leaves being eaten by aphids. 
 The row of deutzia grown as a snowy hedge in rough grass is much more effective than a single bush. 
 &bquo;I've tried growing interesting plants in grass but it's very hard. 
 We can do snowdrops, masses of all-white narcissi, crocuses, primulas, violets, cowslips and fritillaries.&equo; 
 He recently planted some old apple trees (including a &bquo;Peasgood's Nonsuch&equo;), walnuts, alders and two whitebeams, with a row of Norway maple ( Acer platanoides ) to mark the end of the land. 
 The garden has been planned to make the last amount of work for those who maintain it: John himself; his father, who is now 80 and can work for only short periods; Mr Broughton, who clips the hedges, and Patricia who weeds. 
 John fills in a gardening diary every day and often refers back to it to find out when they mulched or did other jobs. 
 &bquo;It's a very useful reference. 
 You have to do a lot of forward thinking. 
 It's silly to presume a garden is going to stand still: it won't. 
 We made the mistake of not putting in the trees before the hedges and it's taken them seven or eight years to get going because it's so exposed. 
 We don't stake anything now. 
 We don't dig. 
 We cut grass with a ride-on mower and dead head if not growing for seed. 
 The thing is to do a little bit often.&equo; 
 AQUILEGIAS OFFER 
 John Drake runs an aquilegia mail-order service and is offering Country Living  readers a 10 per cent discount on plant orders. 
 For a catalogue send 50p and a sae to John Drake, Hardwicke House, Fen Ditton, Cambridge CB5 8TF; quote Country Living  as your reference when you order.  
 Main picture Aquilegia  &bquo;McKana Hybrid&equo; x Olympica strain has spurs of the palest pink 
 Above John Drake kneels beside Rosa  &bquo;Camaieux&equo; (left) and Philadelphus  &bquo;Beauclerk&equo; (right) 
 The yellow bells and red spurs of  Aquilegia  &bquo;McKana Hybrid&equo; 
 The colour purple: an Aquilegia vulgaris  seedling 
 The pink-and-white delicacy of Aquilegia  &bquo;Munstead White&equo; 
 Aquilegia  &bquo;McKana Hybrid&equo; with golden Origanum vulgare  &bquo;Aureum&equo; 
 Euphorbia characias  with a foreground of E. robbiae , hostas and Stachys lanata  
 Euphorbia griffithii  &bquo;Fireglow&equo; has brilliant flame-orange bracts 
 the  GARDEN path  
 BY MIRANDA INNES 
 FEATS OF CLAY 
 Weathered clay barley-sugar edgings finish off a path or flowerbed with a crisply period touch, but aside from shoving a few in your handbag next time you visit Mount Stewart, they tend to be hard to find. 
 To solve this problem, as well as the crying need for oast, antiqued peg, mathematical, scallop, fishtail, bullnose, ridge, hip, corner and Victorian garden tiles, Aldershaw Handmade Bricks and Tiles was born. 
 Also stocked are rose or lily stepping stones and decorative wall bricks, chimney pots and paving slabs, all with marvellous subtle colours, uneven hand-made character (difficult to achieve), and an unsurpassable ancient look. 
 Aldershaw, Kent Street, Sedlescombe, Battle, East Sussex TN33 0SD (0424&ndash;754192). 
 COURSE TALK 
 If you yearn to learn, try to join one of Clare Whately's garden courses. 
 Sue Phillips will be in Twickenham on 12 March telling you how to make a cottage garden, and Hazel le Rougetel will tackle roses on 14 March at Holmbush, in West Sussex. 
 James Arbuthnott will reveal the secrets of unusual wall shrubs and climbers at Catton Hall, Derbyshire, on 5 March. 
 If you are very speedy, you might just catch Norrie Pope of Hadspen Nursery demonstrating horticultural propagation at Kiftsgate (seen below) on 27 February, or James Compton (ex-Chelsea Physic Garden) growing recondite plants there on 28 February. 
 The price of &pound;43 plus VAT includes lunch, wine and course notes. 
 For details, ring 040372&ndash;2883. 
 Later this year there will be special garden tours. 
 BASKET CASE 
 Don your poke bonnet and gather ye rosebuds in our basket. 
 Or cheiranthus or cherries or cheese for that matter; anything will look delicious laid tenderly across its rustic expanse of whippet-brown and bark-green willow. 
 The baskets measure an ample 15 inches by 13 inches, and 10 inches to the top of the handle, and are hand-made in Somerset by P H Coate and Son who have been at it for a century and a half. 
 Well, their ancestors have. 
 Should you want to do some withy and teasel research for yourself, you might visit their willow and wetland centre in Stoke St Gregory where they grow 50 acres of willow and harvest it every winter, when the plants are dormant and the rods measure 8 feet. 
 The basket costs just &pound;17.95, inclusive of postage and packing. 
 The coupon for ordering is on page 154. 
 A BOOK AT BEDDING TIME 
 Frances Lincoln publishes some very desirable garden books. 
 Coming out this month, The Gardener's Year  (&pound;14.95) by Burkhard M&uuml;cke and John Ferguson is beautifully photographed and packed with information. 
 This is what they say about tackling your pelargoniums now. 
 &bquo;Overwintered dormant pelargoniums (geraniums) will be ready to break into new growth and need attention now if they are to develop into sturdy, compact plants for summer display on the balcony or patio. 
 If you pruned them back by one-third of their height before moving them into their winter quarters, then they may be cut back once more by an equal amount. 
 Otherwise they should now be pruned back hard. 
 Always cut back to an outward facing bud so that new shoots will not grow inwards toward the centre and cross each other. 
 &bquo;If the pelargoniums were overwintered in their old containers then it is best to remove them, shake off much of the old potting compost from the roots and repot in fresh compost &mdash; moderately heavy, with good drainage but not more than one-quarter peat or other organic matter. 
 Pelargoniums seem to flower better when rather pot-bound, so keep their roots restricted. 
 When repotting, ram the compost down very firmly. 
 You may replant in the old containers or pot up in individual pots for replanting later. 
 &bquo;As soon as the stems start to plump up, new shoots will break. 
 From now on your pelargoniums need 15&ndash;20&deg;C (59&ndash;68&deg;F) warmth, moderate watering and plenty of light.&equo; 
 Having neatened up your pelargoniums, you could use the prunings to increase your stock. 
 Your average five-year-old could achieve respectable cuttings thus: prune early in the morning and put the trimmings in a plastic bag to keep moist. 
 Fill pots with firmed, damp potting compost. 
 Trim your cutting to just under a leaf node with a sharp knife or razor blade &mdash; they should end up around three inches long &mdash; and remove the leaves from the bottom half. 
 Dip a quarter-of-an-inch of the rooting end into hormone rooting powder and tap off the excess. 
 Make a hole in the potting compost with a dibber or pencil and poke your cutting into the hole, making sure the rooting end touches the compost at the bottom; you should get six cuttings in a four-inch pot. 
 Water them with a fine rose and let them drain. 
 Then make a little airtight hood with a clear plastic bag and a rubber band and put the pots somewhere warm and light, where direct sunlight will not scorch the plants. 
 Ignore them, but make sure they do not dry out completely. 
 Move them to the cold outside world when they have made strong roots. 
 FOX WARFARE 
 IN THE MENDIPS, A SHEEP FARMER IS STRUGGLING TO PROTECT HIS LAMBS FROM THE FOXES THAT WATCH AND PREY. 
 CHARLIE PYE-SMITH INVESTIGATES 
 Three years ago John Small, a sheep farmer in the Mendip Hills, read an editorial in his local newspaper which claimed that foxes never killed lambs. 
 He drove down to the paper's office and presented a lamb, killed the night before, to the editor. 
 &bquo;He suggested it could have died another way,&equo; Small recalls, &bquo;so I took out a knife, skinned it on his desk, and showed him where the fox's teeth had punctured the flesh.&equo; 
 Next week the paper ran a piece misquoting and ridiculing Small's allegations against foxes. 
 Few animals inspire such extremes of love and hate as the fox, and this may go some way towards explaining why so much nonsense is written and talked about them. 
 To some people the fox is the worst type of vermin; to others it is a gentle creature that has been much maligned. 
 Both sides have a point: some foxes kill lambs, poultry and game, and some foxes are guilty of no crime greater than the dispatching of mice and earthworms. 
 John Small farms 1,000 acres of windswept plateau 15 miles south of Bristol. 
 He is an affable, humorous, softly spoken man whose 1,400 breeding ewes &mdash; mostly Kerry sheep &mdash; produce about 1,750 lambs each spring. 
 Every year he expects to lose around 10 per cent of his lambs. 
 Some 60 or 70 are killed by foxes; most of the rest die of hypothermia. 
 Small's battle against the foxes is never-ending. 
 &bquo;If we didn't shoot them,&equo; he says, &bquo;then within two or three years they would be so out of hand that we'd have to give up sheep farming.&equo; 
 Most years he and his brothers kill 40 foxes, sometimes more. 
 Last year foxes were unusually abundant and 27 were shot during the first week of lambing. 
 When I arrived, Small showed me the bodies of two lambs killed by foxes the previous night. 
 &bquo;Often they'll kill a couple of lambs, take one at the time and leave one to be picked up later,&equo; he explained. 
 Small took out a knife and skinned the lambs: bone and sinew were mangled behind their necks, and there was much blood, showing that the lambs had been killed by foxes, rather than taken as carrion by crows. 
 Small reckons that foxes account for &pound;2,000 worth of lambs a year (assuming &pound;35 for a store lamb) on his farm. 
 The manager of the neighbouring pig farm couldn't put a figure to his losses, but thought them considerable, especially in May and June, when fox cubs start hunting their own food. 
 &bquo;If they take seven piglets in a night,&equo; he said, &bquo;that's &pound;70 lost straight away.&equo; 
 At times the foxes work in pairs, one distracting the sow, or ewe, while the other grabs the offspring. 
 It is sometimes argued that the loss of lambs is partly the shepherd's fault: that greater care for the flock would cut down losses to predators. 
 Perhaps this is true of some farmers, but it certainly couldn't be said of Small's enterprise. 
 The two shepherdesses are up until two o'clock each morning looking after ailing animals, and Small tours the farm continually during daylight hours, checking on the progress of lambing and giving help wherever it's needed. 
 I went round with him twice: once just before dusk, then again at six o'clock the next morning after a filthy, freezing night. 
 Small shot one sheep half-paralysed by septicaemia, and brought in seven ewes that had lost lambs or fallen ill. 
 During the night a score of lambs had been born; several had died (most of hypothermia) and at least one had been taken by a fox. 
 &bquo;They say foxes just take the weaker lambs,&equo; Small said, &bquo;but I don't think that's true. 
 In any case the weak will often survive if they're looked after.&equo; 
 Small believes there are a number of reasons why his flock suffers such heavy fox predation. 
 For one thing, there is a tremendous amount of scrubland nearby &mdash; especially on the flanks of the Cheddar Gorge &mdash; and this acts as a reservoir for foxes. 
 For another, his is one of the largest sheep farms in the area and one of the few where the ewes are lambed outdoors. 
 This is ideal fox country, as there is a good supply of wild and domestic food all the year round. 
 &bquo;By the time my sheep are lambing,&equo; Small says, &bquo;the foxes are probably glad of a change of diet: it's 11 months' pork from the pig unit next door, then one month's lamb.&equo; 
 In the Mendips the fox is considered vermin and treated as such. 
 However, it would be wrong to think that foxes are a nuisance everywhere. 
 Surveys of sheep farmers in England and Wales have found that relatively few suffer significant losses of lambs to foxes. 
 David Macdonald, one of Britain's leading fox experts, questioned 400 lowland sheep farmers in England: almost half said they had never lost a lamb to a fox. 
 In a similar survey, Welsh hill farmers said they lost, on average, one lamb to a fox every two years. 
 Macdonald suggests that foxes account for just one in every 15 or 20 lambs that die on Scottish hills. 
 All this goes to show that generalisations about foxes are meaningless. 
 Apart from printing the sort of story that incensed John Small, newspapers have also helped to foster and perpetuate other myths about foxes. 
 One of these is that urban foxes are being dumped in the countryside. 
 This is grist to the horror-story mill, raising the spectre of gangs of streetwise foxes savaging the na&iuml;ve livestock of the countryside. 
 &bquo;About two years ago,&equo; explains Emyr Hughes, the NFU's deputy regional director for North Wales, &bquo;there were rumours that foxes were being dumped in the Berwyn Mountains. 
 It was alleged that a van &bquo;full of foxes&equo; had been seen. 
 But we never had any conclusive proof.&equo; 
 Brian Toon, the public affairs officer for the Masters of Foxhounds Association, is also sceptical about such stories. 
 &bquo;I've seen numerous newspaper reports,&equo; he says, &bquo;but there's no hard evidence of this happening. 
 Nobody has come forward with any car numbers; and nobody has reported any sudden explosion of the fox population in the countryside.&equo; 
 Even if urban foxes were dumped in rural areas, they would probably do little harm. 
 &bquo;If there's any cruelty involved,&equo; Hughes says, &bquo;it would be to the foxes, not to the sheep. 
 Urban foxes are used to scavenging; they'd probably starve in the countryside.&equo; 
 In the London suburb where I live we see plenty of foxes, and I feel far greater affection for them than for the local cats or dogs. 
 The foxes cause little nuisance, whereas domestic pets befoul the streets, parks and gardens. 
 Before I visited Small's farm, I held the view that shooting foxes was always both odious and wrong. 
 Now I have changed my mind: Small convinced me that in his case there was no alternative. 
 At 11 o'clock on the night of my visit we went on a fox shoot. 
 Small took the wheel of a dilapidated pick-up, while two men knelt behind the cab with shotguns. 
 Small's nephew stood behind the firing squad and trained a searchlight back and forth as we hared across the fields. 
 We were looking for the reflective eyes of a fox. 
 It was sleeting so hard we could barely see for 30 yards. 
 We returned after half an hour, the three men behind frozen and miserable. 
 Had we seen a fox, the pick-up would have sped after it, at 40 mph or more, and the men would have shot it. 
 Occasionally they injure a fox and it gets away, presumably to die sometime later. 
 &bquo;But on the whole it's humane and quick,&equo; Small says. 
 &bquo;We don't think of this as a sport; it's just something that has to be done.&equo; 
 In this country foxes are killed in a variety of ways: by hounds, by trapping, by snaring, by gassing and by shooting. 
 If foxes have to be killed, then shooting strikes me as being as decent a method as any, and probably far better than most.  
 Main picture John Small with his flock in the Mendip hills 
 Above right The red fox, Vulpes vulpes  
 Above left The body of a lamb killed by a fox. 
 Teeth marks are just visible on the neck, behind the ears 
 &bquo;IF WE DIDN'T SHOOT FOXES, WITHIN TWO OR THREE YEARS, WE'D HAVE TO GIVE UP SHEEP FARMING.&equo; 
 SCENES from  A PROVINCIAL LIFE 
 &bquo;THERE IS SOMETHING ABOUT THE ENFOLDING DARKNESS, THE INVISIBLE WINDRUSH AND RUMBLE OF SURF, THAT POWERFULLY CONCENTRATES THE MIND.&equo; 
 LIKE THE EARLY MONKS ON THE SCEILIG ROCK, MICHAEL VINEY FINDS HIS CREATIVE SPUR ON THE IRISH EDGE OF THE ATLANTIC 
 A while ago, a captain of industry exhorted Ireland to get up earlier in the morning. 
 In our nearest village, eight miles away, the shopkeepers turned in their beds and slept on: the first wisp of turf smoke might curl up at nine, the first tractor rattle in at half-past. 
 But we were a little ahead of the captain: winter and summer, we're up at five. 
 I think of him sometimes, as the birds are singing in the hedges and the rising sun glints in the windows of houses across the bay. 
 We are each sitting there, the captain and I (and my wife Ethna too, come to that), sipping our tea on opposite sides of this sleeping island and thinking our early, wide-awake thoughts. 
 His are the kind, I must suppose, that make men rich and nations prosperous. 
 Nothing much hangs on my own, so easily distracted by the swoop of a crow or the amazing bright green of raspberry leaves as the sun floods our hillside acre. 
 What we share, the captain and us, is mastery of time &mdash; the freedom to order our day in ways that make better use of it. 
 &bquo;To choose time is to save time,&equo; Francis Bacon said, a go-getter if ever there was one. 
 Our own choice was made soon after our move from the city and the switch from the desk to a spade and scythe. 
 Finding ourselves too tired to be creative at the end of the day, we switched our lives around and put the &bquo;thinking&equo; hours first. 
 Against all expectations, getting up at five is actually easier in winter. 
 If the purpose is to write, each at our separate window, there is something about the enfolding darkness, the invisible windrush and rumble of surf, that powerfully concentrates the mind. 
 Like the early Irish monks on the Sceilig rock (like a prior, then, and abbess), we work in the certainty that nothing will intervene. 
 The screens of our word-machines glow as serenely as illuminated manuscripts. 
 An occasional distraction, an even more seductive glow, is the full moon hanging over the sea, right in the middle of my window. 
 As a child I had a Japanese black-lacquered box, inlaid with a moon in mother-of-pearl, shimmering above dark islands. 
 That is the scene before me now, except that the moon, riding low in its arc and viewed through the Earth's dusty atmosphere, is spuriously tinged with gold. 
 In spring or autumn, the moon has sometimes tempted me out to walk the shore, confident of magical encounters. 
 But along that bare and silvery rim of sand, any self-respecting wild thing could not fail to see me first. 
 And my moon-walks are mocked in the morning by the tracks of otter and fox stitched along the tideline. 
 If we'd been looking for an easy acquaintance with nature, we would have chosen a different landscape: something lusher and more intricate, not this bleak and famished hillside on the Atlantic's edge. 
 But we were drawn by the Romantic taste in scenery, what Bertrand Russell called &bquo;wild torrents, fearful precipices, pathless forests, thunderstorms and generally what is useless, destructive and violent&equo;. 
 Thus, we fell for a prospect of grandeur and space: rugged mountains, rocky islands, vast ocean horizons &mdash; whatever negated the confinement of a city. 
 Here, on an acre formerly abounding in thistles and docks, we have woven our own covert of windbreaks and fuchsia bushes and make great play of raising cabbages where cabbages &mdash; or at least, where sweetcorn, courgettes and petits pois &mdash; were hardly intended to grow. 
 A changed view of time is one of the really momentous recognitions of the self-directed, &bquo;alternative&equo; life. 
 Not only does it set you free  to live in the present but you had better start enjoying it, because &mdash; at the age of 40 or 50 or whatever &mdash; this is it , the future has arrived! 
 I was chronically frustrated by the city's killing of time: all those coffees and slow pints, all that hanging about for other people. 
 (&bquo;As if you could kill time without injuring eternity,&equo; Thoreau said.) 
 I remember the awe with which I realised &mdash; suddenly, while pushing the bike up the bog road &mdash; that I now had no excuses for putting off being happy; there was no one left to blame. 
 &bquo;And what do you do all day?&equo; asks a city visitor. 
 More wounding than the question is the inability to give a coherent answer. 
 You do so many things, it seems pointless to mention any one of them. 
 The flux, the flow, the drifting balance of our days needs a particular kind of patience. 
 Some occupations are a better preparation for it than others, and journalism, fortunately, is a job that gets you used to taking what comes. 
 Those callings that live to the spirit of critical-path analysis might introduce more order and efficiency to homesteading, but they could also lead one to break rather than bend. 
 It is commonplace for me to step outside the door in the morning intending to do one particular task, and then to come back in for a lunchtime bowl of soup having done three or four entirely different jobs of maintenance or repair. 
 It can be frustrating when I'm pursuing some grand design such as building a shed or planting a hedge; but I suppose it teaches that life is a process of becoming. 
 The easy course, in fact, in a life of &bquo;self-sufficiency&equo; is to drift from day to day, working hard but always responding to circumstances; on a subsistence holding like ours, there is always somewhere to be weeded; something to be mended or maintained. 
 Hard experience has taught me to be selective in my procrastination. 
 A midwinter day&hellip; the wind to the north, the sky in rags, hail whipping in from the islands in dark squalls. 
 Fragments of slate appeared as if by magic on the lawn. 
 Slipping for years, pointed out tactfully by our friends and neighbours, pushed back into place with the bamboo boathook, they had chosen that day to fall. 
 A small distinct hole is disclosed, the size of a man's hand. 
 It must be dealt with. 
 Now. 
 One piece of incompetence uncovers another &mdash; overlaps another, like the treacherous slates on the roof. 
 The ladder is broken; it has rusted through because I left it out in the rain. 
 The nearest one is in the next townland and my bicycle has a puncture. 
 I walk there and back between squalls, the long ladder on my shoulder getting heavier with every step. 
 Then down the lane to borrow a slating ladder, the one that hooks over the roof ridge. 
 My neighbour is delighted. 
 &bquo;You're one of us now! 
 When the day is fine the roof doesn't need mending; when it's raining it's not the right weather do to it!&equo; 
 Beaming, he waves me off into another wintry shower. 
 Fifteen feet up, the wind seems stronger and colder, the footholds more suited to the Eiger; there is no place to put anything down. 
 I slide the new slate on a &bquo;hanger&equo; into place, and bed it in with black, bituminous, goo. 
 Clinging to the roof, knees trembling, squinting through wind-tears, trowelling mastic into the crusted slope of slates, I felt, indeed, one of a great, procrastinating brotherhood. 
 Since then we've had a new roof, but its glossy perfection, like a blank page, says nothing about man and his lifelong bargaining with time.  
 &bquo;I REMEMBER THE AWE WITH WHICH I REALISED &mdash; SUDDENLY, WHILE PUSHING THE BIKE UP THE BOG ROAD &mdash; THAT I NOW HAD NO EXCUSES FOR PUTTING OFF BEING HAPPY; THERE WAS NO ONE LEFT TO BLAME&equo; 
 THE GARDENER'S ACCOMPLICE 
 APART FROM A DIET OF WORMS, HEDGEHOGS EAT SLUGS, BEETLES AND BUGS. 
 CHRISTOPHER PROBERT STUDIES THESE PRICKLY PEST CONTROLLERS 
 Should you hear curious snortings and snufflings from your garden after dark this spring, don't put up the barricades. 
 If you summon up the courage to investigate, you might find not alien creatures but a friendly hedgehog or two, emerging from hibernation and foraging for food among the shrubs in your borders. 
 Erinaceus europaeus  &mdash; the common hedgehog to you and me &mdash; is, as its name suggests, both common and hog-like in its habits; although in some areas its numbers have been drastically reduced by road accidents and agricultural practices. 
 This endearing creature has a special place in our countryside lore; in the past, it was believed to suckle from sleeping cows, to be immune to snake bites, and to pick up fallen apples by rolling on them. 
 However, in the midst of a changing countryside, it is rural and suburban gardens rather than fields and hedgerows that now provide some of the best havens for these mammals, as they do for much of our native wildlife. 
 Fully developed hedgehogs can grow to a length of around 225mm and weigh between a half and one kilo. 
 For their size, they can be quite quick, as anyone who has followed a lively one across a garden or road will testify. 
 They can also climb, hence their success at moving round and between gardens in their quest for food. 
 Chain-link fences and creeper-clad walls present no obstacle to a determined hedgehog, and unless your garden is completely surrounded by impenetrable walls a wandering hedgehog has probably passed through. 
 Hedgehogs reach breeding condition during late March and early April, shortly after rising temperatures and hormonal changes provide the cues for wakening from their winter hibernation. 
 By May and June, courtship rituals are at their peak, with three to five offspring born five weeks later. 
 Baby hedgehogs do not have the spines that so readily identify their parents, but these soon start to grow. 
 By the time they are mature, hedgehogs can have several thousand of the modified hairs that give them their prickly appearance and an ideal form of defence against attackers. 
 The young hedgehogs are reared by their mothers, and at about four weeks of age they may be seen foraging with her in the darkness. 
 At six weeks the litters disperse, leaving enough time for some females to have a second litter in late summer. 
 A plentiful supply of food is particularly important for hedgehogs after hibernation and prior to breeding. 
 That's why hedgehogs find gardens so attractive &mdash; they are excellent sources of food. 
 Hedgehogs enjoy a varied diet based mainly on beetles, caterpillars and earthworms, of which there are plenty in a well-stocked, productive garden. 
 They will also eat birds' eggs, hen and duck eggs, slugs, millipedes, earwigs, small mammals and birds, and have even been known to attack adult hens and pheasants. 
 In the role of garden pest controllers hedgehogs are terrific, often devouring large quantities of garden pests nightly. 
 But they also take scraps thrown out for birds, together with the bread and milk put out for them by well-meaning animal lovers. 
 The pros and cons of feeding hedgehogs have been the subject of much debate, but scientific evidence suggests that, even if supplementary food is put out for hedgehogs, they will still hunt on their own account. 
 As bread and milk are not especially nutritious, if you must feed them try putting out dog food, raw mince, raw liver and scrambled egg. 
 Late summer and early autumn are important times for hedgehogs to build up their body weight prior to hibernation. 
 As winter approaches, food supplies dwindle to almost nil; if the hedgehogs did not hibernate, they would probably starve. 
 Hibernation lasts for between four and five months, from October until March or a little later in the north of Britain. 
 During this time, heart rate slows to about one tenth of the normal rate, breathing almost ceases, body temperature falls dramatically and the hedgehogs lose over 30 per cent of their body weight. 
 To protect themselves during their winter slumbers, they build nests. 
 These are often concealed under fallen logs, tucked away beneath piles of leaves in hedges, underneath garden sheds or even deep inside warm compost heaps. 
 Once built, the nests are lined with tightly packed leaves which act as insulation and the hedgehogs are then ready to sleep the winter away, occasionally waking and wandering about on the off chance of finding a meal. 
 Gardeners are often inadvertently responsible for hedgehog losses during the autumn by being over-zealous in tidying up their gardens. 
 Clearing away all the leaves under a hedge is bad news for hedgehogs, as is smartening up the accumulated debris behind a toolshed or summerhouse. 
 Some occupied nests are destroyed by bonfires later in the year, so it is wise to check heaps of leaves and twigs before lighting them. 
 Another potential hazard is water. 
 Ponds or garden pools with steep sides are lethal traps. 
 Small animals fall in and, despite being able to swim, cannot climb out again. 
 A gently sloping edge or ramp leading into the water is vital if you do not want to endanger the hedgehogs that visit your garden. 
 What else can you do to help &mdash; apart from driving more sensibly? 
 How about building a hedgehog house? 
 Then, even if there are no other suitable spots for hibernation, the hedgehogs will have a chance of survival. 
 If yours is the kind of garden that is attractive to hedgehogs &mdash; lots of cover, plenty of natural food and close to other good habitats &mdash; then you could well find your offer of a house taken up this winter. 
 But remember &mdash; no peeping! 
 You will be able to tell whether you have had a tenant when you open up the box next spring, and you may be able to hear the occupant enjoying the garden if you listen out after dark. 
 For more information about hedgehogs, and membership details, send a large sae to The British Hedgehog Preservation Society, Knowbury House, Knowbury, Ludlow, Shropshire SY8 3LQ (0583&ndash;890287). 
 They have a free catalogue of over 300 hedgehog-related items, including &bquo;Don't Squash Me&equo; stickers. 
 MAKING A HEDGEHOG HOUSE 
 Hedgehog houses are cheap and easy to build. 
 First, you will need some untreated 25mm-thick timber. 
 Using this, make a box 375mm square and 375mm high, with a lid that can be taken off in the spring so that the box can be cleaned. 
 Cut an entrance hole, 125mm high and 150mm across, in one side of the box at floor level. 
 The third stage is to construct an entrance tunnel, also made of untreated 25mm-timber. 
 It needs to be 450mm long, 125mm high and 150mm across, with a floor. 
 When complete, it should fit snugly into the entrance hole in the side of the box. 
 You should now have something resembling a small square igloo. 
 Next, take a length of piping &mdash; PVC is ideal &mdash; with a bore of about 15mm. 
 Drill a hole in one of the sides of the box, at the top, and insert the pipe. 
 This will act as a ventilation tube for the hedgehog. 
 Lastly, put some dry leaves and grasses into the box, filling it about a quarter full. 
 At this stage, the house is ready to be moved on site. 
 Find a quiet, well-sheltered and drained part of the garden &mdash; a sloping bank is good &mdash; or dig the box into the ground underneath some shrubs. 
 Cover the top with a PVC sheet and surround the house with at least 225mm of soil, leaving the tunnel entrance clear. 
 Make sure that the ventilation pipe is unobstructed, and that water cannot run down the pipe into the house. 
 Your hedgehog house is now ready for occupation.  
 Main picture Young hedgehogs in the next; born bald, within hours they start to develop their protective spines 
 Right A family of common hedgehogs &mdash; Erinaceus europaeus ; there are about 17 hedgehog species native to Europe, Asia and Africa 
 THE MEETING HOUSE 
 TIM AND PATSY STOTHERT'S QUAKER MEETING HOUSE IS APTLY NAMED, FOR IN IT DIVERSE STYLES CONVERGE AND VICTORIANA COMES FACE TO FACE WITH ART DECO. 
 BY JUDI GOODWIN 
 PHOTOGRAPHS/PAUL BARKER 
 Tim and Patsy Stothert are perfectionists in the art of comfortable chic. 
 Their home, an 1855 Quaker Meeting House at Garstang, near Preston, is furnished in what they describe as an eclectic &bquo;mish-mash&equo; of styles, from 16th century to late 19th and everything in between. 
 They bought the house five years ago and have almost finished the ground floor. 
 &bquo;But we hit the three-year barrier,&equo; Patsy says. 
 &bquo;Everybody is enthusiastic about a house for the first three years. 
 After that they think, sod it, that will do. 
 And we've done nothing for two years.&equo; 
 Despite the authentic antiques, the house doesn't look off-puttingly formal. 
 &bquo;We wanted it to look comfortable,&equo; Patsy says. 
 Every room looks welcoming and lived in. 
 Painted dressers are distinguished with age and use, Oriental rugs have pleasing glimpses of threadbare patches. 
 Even cracked pots have found a second life as lamp bases. 
 The children (Max, five, and Oliver, seven) play freely throughout the house &mdash; the Stothert philosophy is that the odd mark on the furniture all adds to the patina. 
 Tim has the kind of gut feeling for old furniture that comes from being the second generation in the trade. 
 His father was a dealer and he learnt his first lesson at eight years old. 
 &bquo;He taught me never to look first at the things you want to buy. 
 Look at three things in a shop and make sure that the last thing you ask the price of is the thing you want.&equo; 
 He made his first professional purchase at the age of 16, while still at art college, when he bought a plate for two shillings at Preston market. 
 &bquo;I threw it away because it was totally unsaleable,&equo; he says, putting into practice another lesson from his father: never look at your mistakes, get rid of them because they'll annoy you. 
 Nowadays his mistakes are fewer, though Patsy reveals he is prone to hiding a few under the bed. 
 His clients are mostly dealers and decorators so he specialises in the unusual. 
 &bquo;Outsize versions of things or miniatures. 
 Or anything extraordinary.&equo; 
 He recently removed a stone lion from the top of a building in Preston with hired crane &mdash; a traffic-stopping exercise. 
 &bquo;When I see something that's right, it hits me. 
 I've bought it in my mind before I know the price.&equo; 
 But buying for his own home requires a totally different approach. 
 &bquo;Things have to be very cheap,&equo; he says. 
 Far from regarding a tight budget as a restriction on their decorating, Tim and Patsy see it as a positive advantage. 
 &bquo;Not having any money is a very good formula for decorating,&equo; Tim says, &bquo;because you can't afford to make mistakes.&equo; 
 The Stotherts work on the theory that modest things can look good in the right surroundings, and there are plenty of examples around the house. 
 Six botanical prints in the drawing room were &bquo;kicked around and very inexpensive&equo;. 
 But put in matching frames and hung alongside a pair of brackets that cost a tenner the arrangement is pleasing. 
 They've also been lucky: a box of curtains bought for &pound;20, for resale, yielded the magnificent tapestries now hanging in the study. 
 The big advantage of old, slightly faded curtains is that they are a good starting point round which to build a comfortable, well-used look; one that is hard to achieve with brand-new designer materials. 
 &bquo;The trouble with modern textiles is that they use synthetic dyes and the colours don't look right in an old setting,&equo; Patsy says. 
 It was this vague dissatisfaction with new materials that planted the seed for a second business, reproducing antique textile prints, in collaboration with London colleagues Richard and Sarah Miles. 
 Tim had acquired an exceptional pair of early-19th-century patchwork quilts and casually commented that perhaps they should reprint some of the designs. 
 The two couples spent hours laboriously unpicking the stitching until they had released the fabric squares, from which they chose five to reproduce. 
 Printing on pure white cotton was disastrous. 
 So Patsy tried dipping it in cold tea first. 
 The experiment worked; now all fabric is given an initial staining before the main production run, in a colour most accurately described as &bquo;tea dust&equo;. 
 If professional textile designers had translated the patterns, they would probably have perfected the colour register &mdash; the correct alignment of the plates in four-colour printing. 
 But the Stotherts prefer the more haphazard look of the old wood-block printing, where colours out of line, gaps and smudges, all add to the authenticity. 
 Tim believes they are breaking new ground as antique dealers producing a fabric range, though in America he says the best decorators are also antique dealers, a trend which he predicts could grow here. 
 &bquo;The furniture and fabrics should go together, because what you're selling is a complete look.&equo; 
 When Tim helps clients to decorate they have to accept they will not end up with a &bquo;decorated&equo; house in the London sense of the word. 
 For him, authenticity is a higher priority than fitted carpets and designer wallpapers &mdash; and the money saved can be invested in good antiques. 
 The Stotherts have invested a great deal of time in their house. 
 The walls are simply painted but they mix their own paint meticulously, experimenting until they get the colour just right. 
 The study walls are a rich red to pick up the burgundy of the tapestry curtains. 
 The drawing room is soft mushroom: &bquo;Getting the right shade was difficult because anything too clean could make the crewel work look dirty.&equo; 
 The floors are inexpensively tiled, though they have gone to great lengths to achieve the right effect. 
 Coir matting in the drawing room gives a plain background for Turkish rugs and has the bonus that the rugs don't &bquo;walk&equo;. 
 Quarry tiles in the kitchen, dining room and hall are laid on the diagonal, on top of a timber floor. 
 The tiler said it couldn't be done. 
 &bquo;But in the end he stood back and agreed how good it looked.&equo; 
 The other area of controversy was in the kitchen, where cupboards were to be installed by John Saunders, a friend in the business. 
 He wanted to do his best for them with floor to ceiling units in the latest paint effects. 
 But Patsy and Tim wanted a few simple cupboards painted white, made to look as if they'd always been there. 
 &bquo;I don't know why people need all that storage space,&equo; Patsy says. 
 &bquo;They must be expecting a nuclear attack.&equo; 
 She manages perfectly well with the original larder for storing food, and a huge Victorian cupboard to store pots. 
 A dresser holds a collection of old tins that once contained pills for headaches, stomach and liver ailments, concocted by Tim's great-grandfather, a manufacturing chemist who set up in business in the 1880s. 
 Though their value is minimal compared with some of the treasures that pass through Tim's hands, he has a particular affection for the old tins. 
 &bquo;All the best antiques are inherited,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;They haven't been restored or retouched. 
 They have a very special significance.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Country House Tour&equo; collection of fabrics and a selection of kelim-covered furniture is available from Tim Stothert, Interior Decoration, Calder Mount, Bruna Hill, Garstang, Lancs PR3 1QB (0995&ndash;605384). 
 Fabrics also available from Stothert &amp; Miles Fabrics, 8 Holbein Place, London SW1W 8NL. 
 For your nearest local stockist, ring 071&ndash;730 1957.  
 Main picture The study, with its comfortably worn Turkey carpet. 
 The 1820 Gillow table supports a fretted gothick reading stand; two alabaster vases on the mantelpiece are copies of Roman originals and typical &bquo;grand tour&equo; souvenirs from the 1860s. 
 The curtains are 1880s machine-woven copies of a design for a Turkish carpet. 
 Above The exterior of the 19th-century house; the conservatory was added much later 
 Main picture The dado in the hall was completely rebuilt using medium density fibreboard. 
 Top left Four Piranesi prints grouped above a concealed radiator that sports two ostrich eggs. 
 An ormolu hall lantern hangs in the top corner 
 Top right A painted cane chair and Victorian bust among the scented geraniums in the conservatory. 
 Above Tim and Patsy Stothert check the colour match between their new fabric, Pillar and Bird, and the original. 
 In the background are more fabrics from the Stotherts' range &mdash; Rambling Rose, Parrots and Palm, and Hanging Baskets 
 Main picture The drawing-room table is an 18th-century Chinese opium table, now used to display a 17th-century Delft vase. 
 Above a kelim-covered sofa, Corinthian brackets support a pair of 18th-century Chinese plates. 
 Top left In the kitchen the 17th-century Italian table draws the eye down to the oak dresser and a splendid Regency portrait. 
 The crude figure on the dresser is a tobacconist's advertising ware 
 Top right The painted dresser with tins advertising Tim's great-grandfather's remedies 
 Above The bathroom is &bquo;a cross between Art Deco and early Holiday Inn&equo; 
 FOOL'S GOLD 
 WEST MAYO FACES DEVASTATION AT THE HANDS OF GOLD PROSPECTORS, BUT LOCAL PEOPLE ARE DETERMINED TO UNDERMINE THEIR PLANS. 
 BY MARY DOWEY 
 PHOTOGRAPHS/TOM KELLY 
 The west of Ireland has a reputation for swift seduction. 
 When Peter Mantle first arrived in the Doolough Valley five years ago and saw the three lakes linked by the Bundorragha River glinting in the sun, he was completely smitten. 
 He was a fanatical fisherman, and here on the borders of Galway and Mayo he found himself in some of the best fishing waters in Europe. 
 Mantle enquired about cottages for sale. 
 Then, on a sudden whim, he bought Delphi, a crumbling but beautiful fishing lodge, together with 1,000 acres of boggy land and as many again of river and lake. 
 Work began at once to restock the fishery and restore the lodge and collapsed cottages on the estate. 
 By 1988, a fishing timeshare scheme had been successfully launched, the cottages were rented out and the lodge was open for guests. 
 But, less than three years on, a barrage of unforeseen problems has compelled Peter Mantle to take on the responsibilities of a new role: that of vigorous country crusader. 
 To begin with, the sea-trout on which Delphi fishery's international reputation is founded have been mysteriously dying in large numbers for two seasons, and the volume of fishing business has dwindled to a trickle. 
 In the longer term, the rush for EC sheepfarming and forestry subsidies &mdash; understandable in an area of poor agricultural land &mdash; is giving Mantle serious cause for concern. 
 Over-grazed hillsides stripped of their heather are eroding into the valley, bringing down silt that will in time upset the natural balance of the water chemistry, with possible adverse effects on fish stocks. 
 The recent upsurge in forestry planting may be harmful too, Mantle fears, with increasingly large numbers of conifers transmitting acid rain down through their roots into waters that already have an acidic tendency. 
 But the threat he regards as greatest of all is the one he least expected: the discovery of gold in the mountains at his back door. 
 He remembers driving up the road a few years ago and accosting a stranger who was dabbling in a stream with what looked like a frying-pan. 
 &bquo;When he told me he was panning for gold, I simply didn't believe it. 
 Then there was a great deal of talk, and we hoped it was just share-hyping. 
 Soon it became clear the prospecting company was trying to suppress its excitement. 
 It seems definite now that the gold deposits here have commercial potential.&equo; 
 Glencar Explorations, the company that holds the prospecting licence jointly with a British company, Andaman Resources, is one of 20 mining concerns currently investigating gold deposits in Northern Ireland and the Republic. 
 As its diamond-tipped drill moves from place to place along a rock band that stretches through the Mweelrea Mountains and the Sheeffry Hills, local concern is growing. 
 There is scant support for a project that, if it goes ahead, cannot fail to leave its mark on a remarkable stretch of untamed countryside. 
 Peter takes little comfort from the fact that the exploration is now centred in an area north of the Doolough Valley, so that any future mining is likely to leave his own watershed unaffected. 
 He is anxious not purely for Delphi, set in one of the last unspoilt valleys in Ireland, but for the whole wild sweep of west Mayo beyond it, up to the bustling tourist town of Westport. 
 Goldmining is, by nature, a messy business. 
 With the precious metal that has been undetected for so long in the folds of these hills, disseminated through the rock in an average ratio of half an ounce to a ton of stone, the sheer volume of likely debris is worrying. 
 When the gold has been extracted from the crushed and ground rock, only about half of that can fit back into its original space. 
 There is also concern that, no matter how carefully any mining operation is conducted here, the landscape cannot remain unscathed: promises that everything will be &bquo;put back as it was&equo; when the mine is no longer profitable are considered na&iuml;ve. 
 As a former chairman of An Taisce, Ireland's equivalent of the National Trust, says: &bquo;How on earth do you rehabilitate a 6,000-year-old peat bog?&equo; 
 The process of extracting the gold is a still more emotive issue, since the preferred method involves sprinkling a solution of cyanide (which bonds with metals) on to the ground-up ore. 
 An American anthropologist, Lesli O'Dowd who has settled in Mayo and is the author of an Earthwatch special report, Gold Mining and the Irish Environment , feels that its risks have been exaggerated, but that other metals and chemicals released during cyaniding may pose a more serious toxic threat. 
 These would find their way, with other wastes, into a tailings pond &mdash; in every sense a depression in the landscape. 
 The silver-tongued apologists of goldmining maintain that fears about all these things are grossly inflated and take no account of the strict environmental controls that would be enforced. 
 They have a point, undoubtedly. 
 But Mayo dwellers are still left dreading the thought of noise, dust and vibration; of new roads built to bear heavy trucks across the hills; of perimeter fencing and security lights where once there were only grazing sheep. 
 Above all, they dread an accident. 
 The feeling is that no amount of legislative safeguards can entirely eliminate the risk of a chemical spill, wreaking havoc in this watery landscape where a network of mountain streams fed by high rainfall could quickly wash the damage into the drinking water, or down to the mussel farm and salmon fishery at the mouth of Killary harbour. 
 &bquo;Our livelihoods, our environment, our heritage are all being put under threat,&equo; says Peter Shanley of the militant Mayo Environmental Group (MEG), &bquo;and for what? 
 For the short-term gain of a few mining companies.&equo; 
 Many in the area share his view that far more jobs in tourism, aquaculture and farming are at risk, however slightly, than the number goldmining would create. 
 While industry sources suggest up to 200 could be employed, Lesli O'Dowd estimates the likely figure at less than a quarter of that, with perhaps as few as 10&ndash;15 jobs for local people. 
 Nor does it seem likely that the Irish state would benefit significantly from this goldmine in the west, or indeed any other. 
 Despite having some of the largest base-metal mines in Europe, Ireland has collected only &pound;5 million in mining royalties, which have typically run at between five and nine per cent of profits since 1970. 
 If Glencar does apply for a licence and planning permission to mine in west Mayo it will meet opposition on two levels. 
 Those who anticipate that both will be granted will campaign for legislation to enforce a new schedule of environmental safeguards. 
 They hope it will prove so complex and costly to implement that the company may finally decide that mining in Mayo simply isn't worth the trouble. 
 The strategy of MEG will be more straightforward &mdash; a blunt refusal to countenance goldmining in this part of the country. 
 They feel their vehement opposition to gold prospecting on Croagh Patrick, the mountain of pilgrimage south of Westport, has already proved their capabilities: last May the Minister for Energy, Mr Bobby Molloy, yielded to pressure by refusing to renew Burmin's prospecting licence there. 
 At the same time, he ruled that the national parks in Kerry and Connemara would be no-go areas for mining. 
 The irony is that this victory may contain the seeds of eventual defeat. 
 The writer Michael Viney left Dublin 13 years ago to live a life of peace and self-sufficiency in a remote house, from whose windows he can now glimpse the drilling rig (see Scenes from a Provincial Life, page 53). 
 He believes it would be extremely difficult for the Irish Government, having made these special exemptions, to announce that other parts of Mayo are now to be added to the list. 
 But perhaps public agitation will, in the end, be the catalyst required to neutralise the threat. 
 Peter Mantle thinks so, and MEG is heartened by the fact that the handful of farmers in the area who are sitting on the fence and hoping to make a fast punt out of an imminent El Dorado are outnumbered by a mass of people for whom gold holds no allure. 
 Some are dyed-in-the-wool environmentalists, many are businesspeople with tourist interests, but many more are ordinary people. 
 &bquo;The sort who would think nothing of putting their rubbish out on the side of the road,&equo; as one observer noted, &bquo;but who still feel very strongly indeed that there should be no goldmining here. 
 It has to do with land as well as landscape, and the right to farm in a time-honoured way.&equo;  
 Gold prospecting has been banned on the holy mountain of Croagh Patrick, but a road built by the exploration company before planning permission was applied for remains as an ugly scar 
 Above Peter and Jane Mantle with one-year-old Camilla, and springer spaniels Jigsaw and Wino. 
 Their home, Delphi Lodge, overlooks Finlough. 
 Below The Bundorragha River flows south of the gold-prospecting area, but should mining begin locals feel it would still be too close for comfort 
 Above The vulnerable beauty of Killary harbour: &bquo;It only takes one fool to drop a barrel of chemicals,&equo; Peter Mantle says, &bquo;and we're all wiped out.&equo; 
 Below Extracting the rich gold deposits in the Sheeffry Hills would disrupt time-honoured patterns of sheep-grazing 
 HOLY SINISTER 
 HORRIFYING HARBINGERS OF HELL, MONSTROUS CARBUNCLES OR MEDIEVAL FORERUNNERS OF &bquo;SPITTING IMAGE&equo;? 
 RICHARD ROSENFELD INVESTIGATES THE DEMONOLOGY AND MYTHOLOGY OF GARGOYLES 
 Sloshing up the tracks in the dank woods that separate Chedworth's Roman villa from its village, high on the eastern edge of the Cotswolds, three sights await you. 
 Deer nosing through the far undergrowth, always standing in clearings you can never hope to reach for the ensnaring, chest-high coils of bramble. 
 The startling view, on leaving the woods, 40 miles clear to the Wiltshire Downs. 
 And, as you descend steeply into the next valley, and round the Norman church, a line of eight gargoyles &mdash; one a benign lion, one a madman in mid-vomit, one a splendid, arrogant griffon. 
 This is nothing compared with the spectacular catalogue of gargoyles and grotesques found elsewhere: South American lemurs; crocodile-toothed, bulging-eyed monsters; tormented faces emitting vegetation as if it were ectoplasm; demons gulping down children, baboons, and even snarling severed heads. 
 What, though, are they doing on churches? 
 Originally they were a crude if effective attempt to get the plumbing right. 
 They channelled rainwater away from the guttering through open-mouthed figures, which occasionally contained a short section of pipe. 
 This guaranteed that the water fell to the ground just clear of the walls, so protecting them against damp, discoloration and decay. 
 But the utilitarian function of keeping church walls dry hardly accounts for the occasionally bizarre juxtaposition of the sacred and profane: Christ and the saints among the foully contorted and pagan fertility symbols, the Virgin Mary elbowed by giants (usually depicted with both hands pulling back fierce lips). 
 Even the medieval church's spiritual leader, St Bernard of Clairvaux, wanted an explanation. 
 In 1125 he bawled famously: &bquo;What's the point of these ridiculous monsters to the brothers studying in the cloisters?&hellip; 
 There are such fantastic, varied shapes on view that it's more tempting to study these carvings than our books or the laws of God. 
 Heavens above, if we're not ashamed of these unclean things, at least let's regret the expense.&equo; 
 Had he seen a letter from Pope Gregory in AD 601 he'd have had a better idea of what was happening. 
 Gregory's psychologically astute strategy for converting the English to Christianity did not involve a takeover and clear-out, replacing demons with Christ, but coexistence. 
 If the new religion forced too difficult and direct a choice, it could have had a sticky launch. 
 That's why the early church assimilated existing magical beliefs and imagery (often rooted in Celtic mythology), becoming a reservoir of the popular subconscious. 
 The more you hunt around Saxon or medieval churches, scrutinising the roof and tower with binoculars, the more evidence you will find of a wide range of pre-Christian beliefs. 
 Even Canterbury Cathedral, the citadel of English Christianity, contains a marvellous range of mermaids, demons, snarling beasts and old gods. 
 Furthermore, many early churches were built on pagan sites, purified with holy water, where trees and stones had once been worshipped. 
 (One church, at Knowlton, Dorset, stands within a neolithic monument and ceremonial circle.) 
 Pagan festivals were incorporated into the church calendar, fertility rites becoming Christian processions. 
 The yule log became a Christmas &bquo;ingredient&equo;; many magic springs became holy wells, still capable of healing the sick. 
 In other words, the church controlled popular magic by offering its own brand. 
 It began to cater for all tastes. 
 The end result was that stonemasons had three sets of images to play with and blend, invariably at their own discretion: images rooted in earlier pagan beliefs, contemporary medieval life and the Bible. 
 Many pagan images accepted into the church gradually became a part of its symbolic language, even though their new meanings are not always clear. 
 The Green Man is a good example. 
 Originally he would have symbolised vegetative fertility, and possibly even the sacrificial May King. 
 From the 13th century on, however, he increasingly consists of a Dantean, damned, defeated face sprouting or framed by vegetation. 
 At his most repellent, thick tendrils and leaves coil out of the forced-open mouth, eyes, or nose, lush and relentless, engulfing the victim's head. 
 This motif is placed throughout churches, on roof bosses, capitals, fonts, bench ends, and even tombs. 
 But what does it signify? 
 The dark root of evil? 
 The Tree of Life that sprouted from the seed of Adam's mouth (according to one version)? 
 The natural fallen world? 
 Or the image of the Fallen, those who have committed the sin of idolatry? 
 Bamberg Cathedral in south Germany contains one of the most sinister of all Green Men. 
 The carver has reversed the traditional image, creating, instead of a passive victim with blankly staring eyes, an ancient, menacing face that is made of leaves, not being terrorised by them. 
 It is the kind of face you only see outlined high in a woodland canopy late at night. 
 The kind that defies logic, and horrifies. 
 The severed human or animal head was another powerful pre-Christian image later adopted by the church. 
 To primitive tribes a head, stuck on a pole at the village boundary, averted evil and brought luck. 
 In some churches carved heads are similarly found perched on the top of pillars, often biting into them. 
 Many were given three faces, the number three having long been sacred. 
 Until the practice was banned, the church used this image to signify the Holy Trinity. 
 Pagan demons also lend themselves to biblical interpretations. 
 The most popular suggest the evil that vigilant Christians must fight against, evil prowling beyond the sanctity of the church. 
 Are their open jaws the jaws of Hell, or they are the equivalent of a near-Satanic Dirty Dozen, under the command of the angels &mdash; the church's way of fighting like with like? 
 No one can be entirely certain. 
 The best gargoyles and grotesques are real attention grabbers because of their sheer vitality. 
 Masons invariably gave their subjects good individual gestures and/or expressions. 
 If they are not doing something (like having a comic scratch), their faces supply the action. 
 Even the demons have a life beyond their symbolic significance. 
 The eyes of the riled flare, literally popping out of the sockets. 
 A demon seizing a victim may not merely grab, but shoot its claw into the toothless mouth, throttling by the tongue. 
 A monster eating a child does not just gnaw its head, but holds its wrists to stop it wriggling. 
 With the really grotesque grotesques, the authorities may not have been quite so lenient. 
 Why else should so many be high out of sight of the congregation, only sharply visible to us when using a telephoto lens? 
 Since the stonemasons were usually allowed to create their own designs, they were also given the freedom to crack good jokes. 
 Some are unquestionably crude. 
 At St Mary Redcliffe, Bristol, there is an image of a man sitting on a privy, fingers pinching his nose against the pong. 
 At Magdalen College, Oxford, there is a splendid example of a couple having oral sex. 
 To the church's credit it has never seriously attempted to rewrite this side of its history. 
 Many gargoyles have certainly been destroyed, but thousands remain. 
 Even during the Reformation it was biblical scenes likely to promote superstition and idolatry that came down. 
 And where the old gargoyles are now crumbling away, attempts are being made to replace them, expensive though this is. 
 Michael Groser, one of the leading stonemasons in Oxford, has made several in the past. 
 &bquo;A small item can cost &pound;200 minimum, with an average size head at &pound;500,&equo; he says. 
 He used the same tools (hammer and chisel) as his medieval predecessors, and just like them he was left to devise his own designs. 
 &bquo;When I started,&equo; he recalls, &bquo;I did try to follow old patterns, but it wasn't easy, so I followed my imagination. 
 I found my own apprehension of form and my sense of humour very much the same as masons of around four hundred years before. 
 If I had an area that was wider than the height, I sometimes made a double head, with three noses. 
 The French did precisely the same thing.&equo; 
 Five of Michael Groser's gargoyles for Oxford's St Edmund Hall are based on college fellows. 
 Some, in the medieval tradition, are caricatures &mdash; gently affectionate and amusing. 
 The Dean and his pet labrador are both depicted wearing dog collars; the bursar, with ears big enough to flap over to Christ Church, is seen tightly clenching two money bags. 
 But how long will they last? 
 &bquo;Other things being equal, longer than the originals. 
 But it depends on the air. 
 A lot of gargoyles have deteriorated more in the last 70&ndash;80 years than in the preceding 200 years because of the pollution. 
 One prays they will indeed last this long. 
 Old churches without this rich mix of gargoyles would appear muted and reinvented, like a present minus its past, a belief without its moments of uproar and despair, or a locality stripped clean of its ghosts.  
 Main picture St Thomas &agrave; Becket just before his murder &mdash; one of many chilling gargoyles that line the walls of Toddington Manor, Gloucestershire. 
 Above A panting, pig-eared demon found at Winchelsea church, East Sussex 
 Above left A tortured soul writhes in contorted agony at Kilpeck church, Hereford and Worcester. 
 Above right A Green Man with double foliage stares down from an arch-boss in the chapter house of Southwell Minster, Nottinghamshire 
 Top Murder most foul? 
 Another of the haunted heads of Toddington Manor. 
 Above left A stone tribute to the craftsmen builders of Brasenose College, Oxford. 
 Above right Damned sinners trapped in the Jaws of Hell on a nave-roof boss in Norwich Cathedral 
 Top Beaked horse-heads champ an arch in St Ebbe's church, Oxford 
 Above A monstrous mouthful tops a pillar in Kilpeck church, Hereford and Worcester 
 TAIT &amp; STYLE 
 COLOURS SING AND CIRCLES SPIN ON INGRID TAIT'S ORCADIAN FELTED SHAWLS. 
 BY KATY BROWN 
 PHOTOGRAPHS/NUTAN 
 A telephone box converted into a greenhouse stands in the garden next to Brae Studio, the old school where Ingrid Tait has her felting workshop. 
 There's no space in it to prick out seedlings, but it certainly won't blow over in the robust Orkney winds, and the tomatoes seem to grow perfectly well. 
 That telephone box represents the spirit of the Orcadians. 
 Alongside the splendidly untrammelled landscape, there are disadvantages to living on Orkney. 
 It's a smallish island, over two hours from Glasgow by air; to travel or transport freight is intimidatingly expensive; it is dark in winter and rains more than average. 
 But none of this prevents things from happening. 
 If you want to grow tomatoes but can't keep a greenhouse standing, you find something equally useful. 
 And if you want to run a business that involves shipping an unwieldy machine across Pentland Firth and Scapa Flow, servicing orders from London, New York and Japan, and travelling to Glasgow and London to seek commissions from the smartest fashion houses, then Back Road in Stromness is probably as good a place as any to do it from. 
 Ingrid spent many years at art schools in Glasgow and London during the mid-1980s before establishing Tait &amp; Style in Stromness. 
 Born in 1962 in Canada while her Orcadian parents were living there, she returned to Orkney as a small child and has lived there most of her life. 
 As the people she designs for are &bquo;from south, or abroad&equo; (Orcadians call everywhere south of Pentland Firth simply &bquo;south&equo;), the balance wasn't exactly weighted in favour of settling in Orkney. 
 But the machine decided for her. 
 The machine is the crux of Ingrid's business: her innovations in the craft of felting are contributory and her designs are responsible for the sort of client who commissions her, but without the machine it couldn't have happened. 
 Ingrid's machine is a smaller and much-adapted version of the industrial, multi-needled monsters used in the Yorkshire weaving and woollen mills to make insulating material and upholstery fabric. 
 She'd been using these for years, ever since a practical demonstration by an art-school technician fired her to experiment with felting techniques. 
 While studying spinning in Huddersfield (as part of her degree course in textile design at Middlesex Polytechnic) there had been no time for her to try out the machine, so the then sceptical technician told her to come back later. 
 &bquo;I wandered down to Huddersfield market and found some woollen scarves for &pound;1 each. 
 They made me wonder if I could use pure woven wool as a base for my own technique with the machine. 
 I embroidered a design and laid some flax on a scarf, and put it through the needles. 
 The technician was more excited by the resulting effect than I was: I just thought it was a bit of fun. 
 But he believed I was really on to something.&equo; 
 She was still at art school in London, so these massive machines were hardly accessible. 
 But throughout her course, and while at the Royal College of Art doing her MA, she continued to develop her felting whenever she found time to go north. 
 In essence, Tait &amp; Style designs are made by laying strands of wool and teased-out flax on to woven cloth. 
 This is embroidered by hand, then passed through the machine two or three times. 
 The barbed needles pick up tiny threads and pump them through the fabric, bringing back more threads from the base fabric and welding them to the appliqu&eacute;. 
 The result is a strongly bonded design showing clearly on the front and in a ghostly form on the back. 
 The realisation that the Huddersfield technician might be right came only when Ingrid was selected to show on the student stand at the Fabrex exhibition in October 1989. 
 With her friends, Jacqui McLennan and Freddie Robins, Ingrid had put together a collection of felted designs. 
 Fashion buyers clamoured. 
 &bquo;It was like a jumble sale in a village hall,&equo; she laughs. 
 &bquo;They wanted everything we had on the stand &mdash; and they were only meant to be samples. 
 We took masses of orders, from Paul Smith, Liberty and Whistles, and only when the show was over did we understand what we'd let ourselves in for.&equo; 
 She had no workshop, nobody to help her and no business acumen. 
 And, worst of all, no machine of her own. 
 Undaunted, Ingrid took on the jobs, and through long, exhausting, financially unrewarding slog, completed them. 
 She did a business course at weekends, stayed in Huddersfield during the week, paid for friends and helpers to stay there too, and hired the big factory machines. 
 Then her original mentor found her a machine to buy. 
 &bquo;It was a heap of greasy, rusting metal,&equo; she remembers. 
 But increasing despondency about the impracticality of using hired machines to carry out orders made her persevere, and the advice of friends and a local engineering firm convinced her it was worth bidding for. 
 These machines are so rare that one like Ingrid's, new, could cost &pound;80,000, and she might have had to wait four years for delivery. 
 Once the nightmare of buying it was over (&bquo;It was a battle of sweat and nerves. 
 The agent never treated me as a serious buyer because I didn't fit his image of a businessman&equo;), the adaptation process began. 
 The machine was shipped to Orkney, still not in working order, while Ingrid carried on going to Yorkshire to process a big order from Paul Smith for a bold circles design on chalkstripe suiting. 
 Ingrid's designs have a complex web of influences. 
 To an outsider the light and landscape of Orkney seem crucial: the circles, dots, hazy shadows and strong lines must have some root in the stone circles, wind, and wide skies. 
 But Ingrid almost denies this: &bquo;I'd been the typical first-year art-school person, entrenched in one style that was really landscapey &mdash; all earthy colours and shapes. 
 Now I try to surround myself with as many influences as I can and avoid all that. 
 Maybe I'll go back to it one day.&equo; 
 Ingrid feels more influenced by painters like Sonya Delaunay and Picasso, and by the fragments of colours and textures that she collects for reference. 
 The walls of her drawing/negotiating/telephoning corner in the workshop are hung with postcards and clippings; the surfaces are covered with pebbles, Celtic and Viking details and copies of Orcadian stone carvings. 
 Bags of coloured wools are pegged on to scaffolding near the machine and sample lengths of fabric and felted scarves are swagged about the place. 
 In the workshop, overlooking the sea, there is a long ex-grocery bench that came from Ingrid's grandfather's shop. 
 Here Deirdre MacKenna, her right-hand helper, provides an anchor for the business in Stromness when Ingrid is away. 
 She supervises the pre-felting embroidery, keeps an eye on stock, trains people to work the machine. 
 &bquo;I sit here sewing and watch the sand and seaweed in the water down there. 
 What a place to earn a living,&equo; she says. 
 Deirdre is Scottish herself, so it's not as if she's new to wide skies and stirring views, but Orkney surpasses all she's known before. 
 &bquo;The light here is extraordinary. 
 It must have something to do with why so many painters and designers are doing really good work here. 
 Not stuff dictated by tourists, but real, pure art and craft.&equo; 
 The pursuit of excellence is evident throughout Tait &amp; Style. 
 The people who work with Ingrid are carefully chosen, not for their formal training (apart from Deirdre, none of them has any) but for their eye. 
 They need to be spontaneous enough to translate Ingrid's abstract designs into wool and embroidery, and have a keen sense of colour and shape. 
 She regularly employs her grandmother, &bquo;who's the best seamstress I'll ever find &mdash; she teaches all the others to sew beautifully&equo;, and, after school, a 14-year-old girl who is already showing great design ability. 
 Ingrid believes it was fate that enabled her to work in Orkney, near her family, with her friends, and on an island she loves. 
 But it is simpler than that, and less romantic. 
 She is canny and determined, and her talent is so special that she could be running her workshop from an oil rig in the North Sea &mdash; people would buy her work just the same. 
 As long as the machine could be there too. 
 We flew to Kirkwall with British Airways, which flies to Orkney and Shetland regularly, from Glasgow and Edinburgh via Inverness. 
 TAIT &amp; STYLE OFFER 
 Ingrid Tait is offering Country Living  readers a 10 per cent discount on her Landscape pattern scarves and shawls (see above). 
 They come in small, medium and large sizes and usually cost from &pound;25 to &pound;75. 
 To order call Tait &amp; Style on 0856&ndash;851186.  
 Main picture Local girl Amy Colap wearing two of Ingrid's shawl designs, Dots and Stripes. 
 This page Dyed fleece. 
 Inset Ingrid Tait 
 Main picture Ingrid's abstract patterns, especially Ikat (far left) contrast well with Jacqui McLennan's graphic face and Freddie Robins's hearts. 
 Left Hanking yarn before it is dyed. 
 Below left Ingrid's felt shawls keep out the icy winds that whip across Rackwick Beach, Hoy. 
 Below right The finished effect looks random, but getting the different tensions and densities of colour right needs precision 
 Main picture Squaring the circle Below left Ingrid's Granny Gorie &mdash; &bquo;the best seamstress I've ever had&equo; &mdash; has been an invaluable source of advice Right and below right Orkney's stark shorelines, wide skies and drifting clouds are echoed in Ingrid's landscape pattern 
 TUSCANY in  SOMERSET 
 SAM AND GRAEME FIFIELD-HALL HAVE CREATED A CORNER OF ENGLAND THAT IS FOREVER ITALY. 
 BY HESTER PAGE 
 PHOTOGRAPHS/MELVIN GREY 
 Sam and Graeme Fifield-Hall were quite happy living in the city and running a business. 
 But Sam harboured other desires. 
 She dreamt of a life in a Tuscan farmhouse, with an ancient barn built around a central courtyard, bathed in the apricot hues of an Italian sun. 
 At the end of a trip to Devon, a friend offered Graeme a lift to the station. 
 On the way, they stopped at a farmhouse that was about to be put up for sale. 
 Graeme's friend, an estate agent in Chard, needed to view the house before the details could be written. 
 &bquo;I didn't even get out of the car,&equo; Graeme recalls, but he was amazed by what he saw. 
 &bquo;Near the house was a barn like a castle, with a courtyard in the centre. 
 It was everything Sam had ever wanted &mdash; except that it was in Somerset and not in Tuscany.&equo; 
 The next day he took Sam down to see it. 
 &bquo;It didn't officially go on the market. 
 We just decided we had to have it,&equo; he says. 
 The farmhouse was rather nondescript. 
 It was built in 1803 but had been badly modernised over the years. 
 The outside stone walls had been rendered and the windows replaced and double-glazed. 
 &bquo;We had to apply a lot of age very quickly.&equo; 
 Sam invited her best friend down for Christmas. 
 &bquo;It was the greatest incentive I could think of. 
 She would need at least one room that wasn't like a builder's yard,&equo; Sam says. 
 They started with the kitchen. 
 &bquo;There was no natural character to the room: it was a white box with modern doors, modern units and a Rayburn that stuck out of the wall like a sore thumb.&equo; 
 It had pink quarry tiles and the Rayburn was yellow; these were the features of the room she decided to work around. 
 They decided to use Taunton bricks, which are pink and yellow, to build the units, and heard of a chimney in Taunton that was being demolished. 
 &bquo;The bricks arrived filthy black and Graeme had to scrub and wash every single one.&equo; 
 He built the brick units and their arches himself. 
 He also built the fireplace to house the Rayburn. 
 &bquo;We got up three times during the night to see if the arch was still holding up.&equo; 
 Sam took it upon herself to plaster the walls. 
 &bquo;I wanted very rough plaster, as a farm labourer or a member of the family would have done it. 
 It looked awful at first &mdash; so bad it was wonderful &mdash; but as it dried it revealed an incredible gradient of colour.&equo; 
 The natural plaster was exactly the same colour as the pink in the brick, while the yellow in the brick was the same colour as the Rayburn, so it all started to pull together. 
 The last thing to jar the senses was a modern cupboard door. 
 &bquo;I decided to crackle glaze it to merge with the French antique furniture,&equo; Sam explains. 
 Paint, varnish, more varnish and a blow-drier hastened the effect and old brown shoe polish filled in the cracks. 
 &bquo;My reward came later when a neighbour dropped in to see how things were going. 
 &bquo;Ooh, lovely,&equo; she said, &bquo;but it'd be nice if you stripped that door.&equo; 
 I was very pleased that it was so convincing.&equo; 
 The original window shutters for the front of the house were found in the barn and Graeme rehung them. 
 &bquo;By the time my friend arrived I was exhausted and in a foul mood and so was Graeme. 
 We had almost completely forgotten about Christmas &mdash; but at least the kitchen was finished.&equo; 
 Back in the city, Sam and Graeme had owned a prop hire business, lending out country antiques, backgrounds and surfaces to photographers and stylists, mostly for cookery pictures. 
 &bquo;A few photographers used their own things but there was a gap in the hire business. 
 No one seemed to be paying much attention to the backgrounds. 
 I though more texture was needed, and more choice  of texture.&equo; 
 Sam had worked with art directors and photographers in New York. 
 &bquo;They would come to my flat and borrow my things for their photographs,&equo; she explained. 
 &bquo;We would have had a monumental amount of stuff anyway, even if we hadn't had the business.&equo; 
 They travelled all over the countryside asking farmers if they could buy the rustic doors that were lying in the mud at the back of the barn. 
 Flemish and Spanish doors, slabs of different coloured marble, stone surfaces, panelling, good mahogany, were all snapped up for background effect. 
 &bquo;And we learnt all the paint effects to produce any sort of wooden finish or marbling.&equo; 
 They've continued the business, using the house as a country location, though home-making activities have often got in the way. 
 But their decorating knowledge was invaluable when it came to restoring the farmhouse. 
 In the first year they decided to dig a boating pond. 
 &bquo;We dug the pond because there wasn't anything to look at and it seemed a very obvious thing to do. 
 You'd take a lovely walk down the field and then suddenly you'd be up to your knees in a bog. 
 There were seven springs in that corner.&equo; 
 They kept the best of the natural wetland below the pond. 
 &bquo;The pond is actually too close to the house. 
 The wildfowl land here, but when we open the back door they tend to fly off. 
 But slowly the birds have decided to stay. 
 We now have our own ducks and they have nested and hatched their eggs, and a male moorhen and his family have been in residence for a couple of years. 
 &bquo;Every day, the first thing I do when I wake in the morning is go to the window to look at the pond. 
 In the summer at the end of an exhausting day, we take a drink and get into the boat and float. 
 No one can reach us, it's bliss.&equo; 
 Turn to page 29 for decorating ideas to copy.  
 Main picture The larder was formerly the dairy room. 
 Hanging on the wall (behind the lemons) is a lethal-looking old American corn-drying rack Top The farmhouse seen from across the fields Above Graeme and Sam Fifield-Hall 
 Main picture The dining-room dresser is a &bquo;marriage&equo;: an elm dresser top sitting on an elm coffer. 
 17th-century pan lids hang from the shelves. 
 Top Sam dried the sweetcorn and artichokes that sprout from the Italian wall-mounted jardini&egrave;re. 
 Above At the far end of the garden room a bathtub has been planted with herbs for the winter 
 Main picture Flagstones in the hall have been worn smooth by years of hobnail boots. 
 A wooden Tudor bowl and a cider flagon cover the top of a pine haberdasher's chest; the framed crewelwork behind must have been &bquo;horrendously bright&equo; at one time, but has now faded to more acceptably gentle colours. 
 Above right Chinese woven grass has been laid on the guest bedroom floor. 
 It's thick and durable but the carpet-layers swore never to work with it again. 
 Above left An oil-on-leather screen shields a corner of the living room. 
 The Pennsylvania Dutch tole watering can might be repro but looks extremely convincing. 
 Inset right Graeme's cousin painted the bull. 
 Inset left Sam on her tractor-mower: &bquo;Three sheep don't eat enough grass to keep six and a half acres looking tidy&equo; 
 IRISH GARDENS 
 A GRAND TOUR 
 And grand it is to be sure. 
 The gardens of Ireland have a special dreamlike quality, like gardens known as a child &mdash; where everything was bigger and greener, and chattering rabbits abounded. 
 Where sounds of humanity are muffled by the absorbent tranquillity, where vegetative abundance struggles in mysterious thickets and leaf-thatched tunnels, and moss-veiled statues stand transfixed listening for the echoing revelry of a party that ended centuries ago. 
 Irish gardens have the peaceful innocence of prelapsarian Eden; you are quite likely to have the place to yourself, and most have not yet plumbed the commercial depths of the pot pourri franchise. 
 Irish gardens are islands of perfection in a landscape of empty fields as rough and tussocky as a moulting dog. 
 Behind their perimeter walls lie freshly laundered flowers, verdant grass still sparkling from the last shower, yew hedges in an ecstasy of precision clipping. 
 The rain, and the warmth, and the general tolerance of the character of plants make for an almost threatening exuberance. 
 And the gardens stimulate, inspire and amaze. 
  Miranda Innes   
 Top left  The conservatory at Killruddery, simple but beautiful. 
 Lounging putti watch fountains plash in the parterre, and there is a huge leafy pillbox through whose massive walls you fight to come upon a hushed round pond with lilies and a boat. 
 There are whispering groves, wide spreading lawns where coy stone ladies nestle in the green, and miroirs d'eau &agrave; la Courances  which might reflect a sky of tender blue. 
 The most benignly haunted garden I have ever visited 
 Middle left  Mount Usher &mdash; 20 &bquo;Robinsonian&equo; acres, once a potato patch and now thickly planted with trees, especially eucryphia and eucalyptus. 
 Embothrium even, flaming against a dark background of yew. 
 Very romantic, with shrubby entanglements of magnolia, maple and cornus on either side of the shining River Vartry, and an apple orchard bearded with mistletoe. 
 There is a strange grafted conjunction between a laburnum and a pink cytisus (best avoided), and a fernery in a secret gully reached by walking a gangplank over a rushing rivulet. 
 Horrors! there is an azalea walk. 
 But this is no vulgar skirmish of brittle nylon colours &mdash; its startling brightness is as carefully coordinated as a Zandra Rhodes gown 
 Left  Rosemary Brown engulfed in fuchsia, geranium and festoons of Passiflora antioquiensis  in her conservatory at Graigueconna. 
 Her garden is not huge &mdash; three acres &mdash; but there are some spectacular trees grown for their multi-coloured bark, and 80 different old-fashioned roses. 
 The borders are a soft fusion of pink and blue with grey and purple foliage, and in a climate that explores most permutations of grey, she adds light with splashes of primrose 
 Main picture  Helen Dillon's Dublin garden has a richly tapestried Edwardian air with fragrant bowers and half-hidden statuary, contrasted with a perfectionist expanse of richly bordered lawn. 
 Here, a small clump of scarlet tulips brings a disproportionate flash of brilliance to a spring dalliance of Daphne mezereum , muscari, erythronium and Magnolia stellata  
 Above  The stables at Bushey Park, a stone's throw from Powerscourt. 
 Wreathed with white wistaria, they are half-hidden behind a ghostly phalanx of variegated osteospermum, Salvia argentea , white allium and a banksiae rose which has managed to escape predatory Wicklow deer. 
 The Victorian porch was transported from England on a car roof, bringing unexpected excitement to prosaic motorway travel 
 Left  Iris, oriental poppies, symphytum and Geranium himalayense  in the richly planted borders of the walled garden at Beech Park. 
 The Shackletons grow all sorts of rarities &mdash; black poppies from the Himalayas, celmisia from New Zealand, the waxy red Blandfordia punicea  from Tasmania and a collection of alpines 
 Main picture  Butterstream, Jim Reynold's garden in County Meath, is as lovely as anything real could be. 
 He has a flawless sense of colour and form, and realises an ideal balance between formal clipped structure and drifting floral ephemera, springing delicious surprises upon the enchanted visitor. 
 There are winding green paths through dense corridors of perennials, all plum and violet, rose-pink and silver; there are corkscrews and pyramids of box, green exclamation marks defining the Tuscan temple; there is a full and frothing white garden crisply held in check by clipped evergreens, a laburnum walk and a wooden Doric temple wreathed in clematis. 
 It's just too much, so it is 
 Powerscourt is a garden of extraordinary impact, whose grand location shaped like a vast scallop shell is echoed by its picturesque reflection in the Wicklow Mountains. 
 It is a spectacular site, over which the blinded hulk of a ruined mansion casts a dark spell. 
 This is the garden as theatre, where reclining tritons, Greek warriors and winged horses are transfixed in mid-whinny, where a tower (out of Thomas Gray by Caspar David Friedrich) rises inexplicably from a wooded declivity, where there is a sudden outbreak of brilliant Japanesery and an 18th-century grotto made from petrified sphagnum moss. 
 The designer of all this magnificence, one Daniel Robertson, was crippled by gout, and directed operations from a wheelbarrow, toping the while from a flagon of sack. 
 More recently, sans sack and barrow, J J Costin has designed a minutely documented herbaceous border. 
 EXCLUSIVE FOUR-DAY GARDEN TOUR FROM &pound;349 
 Country Living  has joined forces with Time Off, the short-break specialists, to bring you an exclusive tour of the eight Irish gardens shown here, from Tuesday 18 to Friday 21 June. 
 Come with us to enjoy Mount Usher whose lilies, poppies and peonies gladdened the heart of William Robinson. 
 The next day prepare for Killruddery, where we will tour the house and garden and enjoy lunch in the splendid conservatory. 
 Then explore Graigueconna, make a brief tour of Bushey Park House and gardens and hasten on to watch the sun beyond the grandiose setting of Powerscourt. 
 The following day we make for Beech Park with its luxuriant walled garden, and Butterstream, an enchanted blend of romance and formality. 
 A comparatively lazy day with plenty of time to ooh and aah. 
 On the fourth and last day we land in paradise: 45 Sandford Road, Dublin, the home of Helen Dillon, a gardener whose plants are encouraged and castigated like a wayward infants' class. 
 Choose from two hotels, an hour's drive south of Dublin, in Co. 
 Wicklow: Hunter's Hotel, an informal family-run coaching in; or Tinakilly House, an elegant Irish country house hotel. 
 Both have an excellent reputation for good food and are members of the Irish Country House and Restaurant Association. 
 The price is &pound;349 per person at Hunter's Hotel; &pound;369 per person at Tinakilly House. 
 It includes return British Midland flights from Heathrow to Dublin; four days car hire (including insurance and unlimited mileage and based on two people sharing); three nights accommodation (including breakfast), sharing a twin room with bathroom; admission to all eight gardens; lunch on Wednesday and Thursday; afternoon tea on arrival on Tuesday. 
 There are 30 places available on a first come, first served basis; the closing date is Friday 15 March.  
 ROLYPOLY, PUDDINGS AND PIE 
 PHLIPPA DAVENPORT'S RIB-STICKING RECIPES WILL TAKE YOU STRAIGHT BACK TO YOUR NURSERY DAYS 
 PHOTOGRAPHS/JAN BALDWIN 
 Puddings, like cooked breakfast, are jewels in the crown of British cookery. 
 By puddings I do not mean the pretty little fripperies that are offered at the end of an elegant dinner as token appeasement of our sweet-toothed leanings. 
 I mean serious winter puddings, steamed, boiled and baked, sticky, rich and sweet, that sit fair and square on the plate and fill you with a glorious glow of warmth and well-being. 
 Substantial puddings like these were once a vital fuel and restorative for those who laboured in the fields. 
 They were the crumbs of comfort the leisured classes craved to assuage the draughty chill of English baronial halls. 
 You could argue &mdash; and some do &mdash; that such puddings ought to go the way of the dodo now that we all lead more sedentary and centrally heated lives. 
 I disagree. 
 To tuck into a daily dose of pudding would be a gross indulgence, of course, but surely we still need puddings occasionally. 
 There is nothing quite like them for resuscitating spirits depressed by wintry gloom. 
 Lord spare us from puritans. 
 Why not allow yourself to be seduced by the voluptuous charms of a luscious pudding every now and again? 
 Enjoy it to the full, I say, and don't feel guilty. 
 More time in life is wasted by feeling guilty than almost anything else. 
 Great British Puddings are just cause for jubilation. 
 They ought to be celebrated in season. 
 We owe it to gastronomy to keep them alive. 
 Even the French acknowledge our supremacy in this field. 
 &bquo;Blessed be he that invented pudding, for it is a manna&hellip;&equo; as the often quoted late-17th-century French visitor, Monsieur Misson, rhapsodised in a letter home. 
 It would be a pretty poor state of affairs if we abandoned our traditional puddings, leaving only the tourists to appreciate them. 
 You don't need guests, you don't need freezing weather or any other excuse to put pudding on the menu &mdash; although it is true that a good pudding shared with like-minded Billy Bunters makes for a convivial party, and if the day dawns cold and frosty it may give an agreeable edge to appetites. 
 Sunday lunch has a suitable sense of occasion about it and for many people it is the only time of the week when they can relax and enjoy a leisurely get-together with family or friends. 
 Sunday supper is another favourite occasion for pudding eating. 
 At supper there is more likely to be a simple salad than a roast on the menu, which has the advantage of leaving you with more room to do proper justice to the pudding. 
 Most days in most households are sensibly puddingless. 
 This is no hardship when there are fine fruits on offer instead: compotes of dried fruits as well as fresh apples, pears, bananas, citrus fruits and the first invigorating taste of early forced rhubarb. 
 And it means that when we cook and eat puddings we can do so wholeheartedly. 
 The Victorians tried to spoil the pleasures of puddings with foolish economies and in so doing brought Britain's once fine reputation to its culinary knees. 
 Beware being heavy-handed with flour. 
 Do not skimp and debase using margarine in place of butter, skimmed milk instead of cream. 
 Remember Eden Phillpotts' remark that: &bquo;No mean woman can cook well. 
 It calls for a generous spirit, a light hand and a large heart.&equo; 
 It sums up perfectly the attitude needed to make good puddings. 
 Winter puddings are meant to be lavish. 
 They should be bursting with calorific deliciousness: butter, cream, eggs, dried fruits, nuts, sugar, jam, chocolate, treacle and other good things. 
 That way they will not only taste wonderful, they will also make you feel as cosy as wearing a cashmere sweater, or sitting with your toes in the Aga and a purring cat on your lap. 
 The virtuous and those plagued by dogs (not mutually exclusive groups) can always walk off some of the effects of a pudding afterwards. 
 Others may think it digestively more prudent to follow the example of Badger in The Wind in the Willows , sitting down quietly in a commodious armchair for a session with &mdash; or maybe under &mdash; the newspapers. 
 Do not look on these pages for lightweight and health-conscious confections. 
 These recipes are intended to be unadulterated bliss. 
 Many are old classics. 
 Some may take you back to the nursery. 
 I have dusted down others and given them sacrilegious new twists, incorporating nuts into rolypoly, for example, and using kumquats instead of lemons for old-fashioned Sussex Pond Pudding. 
 Complement proper puddings with proper sauces. 
 Lavish them with real custard, cream or a jam sauce that is generously jammy &mdash; and don't forget that Christmas Plum Pud isn't the only pudding that makes a grand entrance wreathed in alcoholic flames. 
 TOFFEE APPLE CHARLOTTE 
 It is the use of dessert fruit and the hint of lemon that make this apple pudding so good. 
 Quick and easy to prepare, not too heavy or sweet, it makes a fine choice to follow a roast &mdash; just leave it to cook while you eat the main course. 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 
 2&ndash;2&frac12; lb Cox or other sharp but sweet dessert apples 1&frac12; tbsp lemon juice and the zest of 1&frac12; lemons 1 dozen or more thin slices of bread cut from a crusty French loaf or bloomer butter, golden syrup and demerara sugar 
 Butter an ovenproof dish &mdash; a very shallow dish to ensure the apples cook evenly and to allow for a good ratio of topping to filling. 
 Peel and core the fruit, cut it into crescent-moon slices and put it into the dish. 
 Add the lemon juice and zest and mix gently. 
 Spread slices of bread on one side only with butter and syrup. 
 Lay the slices, crumb side down, over the fruit, overlapping them slightly like roof tiles. 
 Scatter with a spoonful or two of sugar and slide the dish on to a baking tray. 
 Cook at 375&deg;F (190&deg;C) gas mark 5 for 25&ndash;30 min until the apples are hot and tender and the topping is deliciously toasty. 
 Serve hot or warm, alone or with yoghurt or cream. 
 MARMALADE PIE 
 Here is a pudding that offers the cook a fine opportunity to show off home-made marmalade. 
 I recommend it particularly for Sunday lunch with visitors from abroad whose eagerness to try a proper British pudding might grow a little faint if faced with a hefty suet pudding or steamed sponge. 
 Serves 8 
 shortcrust pastry made with 6 oz flour &amp;3/4; lb marmalade 2&ndash;3 eggs and 2 oz caster sugar 
 Use the pastry to line a 10-inch shallow fluted tart tin. 
 Blind bake it completely. 
 This can be done a day ahead. 
 If the marmalade is a low-sugar, rather runny one, you will need 3 egg yolks. 
 Otherwise 2 will be enough. 
 Beat the yolks into the marmalade until creamily mixed. 
 Put the filling into the pre-baked pastry case and bake at 350&deg;F (180&deg;C) gas mark 4 for 20 min or so until it is hot and just set. 
 Whisk 2 egg whites to stiff snowy peaks, gradually incorporating the sugar. 
 Swirl the mixture gently over the filling and bake for 15 min more until the meringue is softly set and streaked with gold. 
 Let the pie rest for 5&ndash;10 min before serving, or wait until it is cold, but be sure to serve it the day of making or the meringue may begin to weep. 
 Cream, flavoured with a tot of brandy, goes well with this. 
 PASSIONATE QUEEN OF PUDDINGS 
 Queen of Puddings is aptly named: perhaps the most delicate and lovely of all puddings. 
 Traditionally jam is spread between the custard and the meringue. 
 Grapefruit or lemon jelly marmalade makes a more sophisticated choice. 
 Fresh passion fruit is heretical but wonderfully aromatic. 
 Serves 4&ndash;5 
 1 pt creamy milk and 3&ndash;4 passion fruit the finely grated zest of 2 lemons 2 oz butter and 4 oz white breadcrumbs 5 oz caster sugar and 4 large eggs 
 Scald the milk with the citrus zest in a medium-sized saucepan. 
 Away from the heat add the butter, cut into dice, and 1 oz sugar. 
 When melted stir in the crumbs and leave to soften and swell for 10 min. 
 Beat in the yolks of the eggs, one at a time. 
 Turn the creamy custard mixture into a well-buttered pie dish of 3 pt capacity and bake at 350&deg;F (180&deg;C) gas mark 4 for about 25 min until set round the edges but still a little wobbly in the centre. 
 Spoon the ripe passion fruit pulp evenly over the custard. 
 Whisk the egg whites to stiff snowy peaks, gradually beating in 4 oz sugar, then pile the meringue mixture over the pudding. 
 Return the dish to the oven and bake for 15 min until the billowing clouds of marshmallowy-soft meringue are softly set and streaked with gold. 
 Let the pudding rest for 5&ndash;10 min before serving. 
 STICKY GINGERBREAD SPONGE 
 I dreamt up this one during ten stormy and electricityless days last January. 
 A spicy lifesaver, it is especially delicious if made a day ahead and reheated next day. 
 Serve with cinnamon custard or a sauce made by warming together some treacle and golden syrup with just a squeeze of lemon and a dash of syrup from the jar of stem ginger. 
 Serves 6 
 black treacle and golden syrup 4 oz stem ginger, chopped into small pieces 4&frac12; oz butter, at room temperature 6 oz self-raising flour, sifted with 2 
 3 tsp ground ginger, 1 tsp cinnamon and &frac12; tsp allspice 3 large eggs, lightly beaten 1&frac12; tbsp ginger wine or milk 
 Stand the tins of treacle and syrup in a pan of hot water for 10 min to make the contents runny and easy to measure. 
 Butter a 2&frac12;&ndash;3 pt pudding basin and a circle of greaseproof paper to cover it. 
 Put some treacle and syrup into the prepared basin, say 5 or 6 tbsp of each &mdash; don't stint &mdash; and stir gently to mix. 
 Bring to the boil a pan half-filled with water. 
 Beat the butter in a mixing bowl until creamy and light. 
 Add just 3 tbsp of syrup and just 4 tbsp of treacle and blend well. 
 Beat in the eggs, one at a time, then the flour and spices. 
 Add the ginger wine and, finally, the stem ginger, mixing it in very thoroughly. 
 Spoon the pudding into the basin. 
 Cover with the greaseproof paper, then with foil and tie with string. 
 Steam for about 2&frac12; hr. 
 Loosen the pudding and turn it out to serve straight away. 
 Or let it mature, still wrapped, in a cold larder overnight, and reheat by steaming for 1 hr or so next day. 
 KUMQUAT POND PUDDING 
 Arguably the most satisfying of all winter puddings for anyone with a trencherman appetite is Sussex Pond Pudding. 
 Classic versions contain one or sometimes two lemons. 
 This variation on the theme is bursting with extravagant quantities of kumquats and comes to table sitting in a pond of its own sauce. 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 
 &frac12; lb self-raising flour and &amp;1/4; lb suet scant 1 tsp baking powder and 1&frac12; tsp cinnamon 2 fl oz each milk and water, mixed &amp;3/4; lb kumquats, washed and pricked about 5 times each 6 oz chilled and diced butter 5 oz granulated sugar 
 Butter a 2 pt pudding basin and a circle of greaseproof paper to cover it. 
 Bring to the boil a large pan half-filled with water. 
 Stir the flour, suet, cinnamon and baking powder together then mix in the liquid to bind. 
 Use three-quarters of the pastry to line the basin. 
 Pile the fruits into it, scattering the butter and sugar between layers. 
 Roll out a pastry lid, place it over the filling and damp the outer rim. 
 Fold the excess lining pastry over the lid and press to seal the two layers of pastry together. 
 Cover with the greaseproof paper, then some foil and tie with string. 
 Steam for 2 hr. 
 Unmould for serving on to a heated plate large enough to accommodate the pudding and the sauce that will seep from it. 
 MIDWINTER BAKEWELL 
 In summer I stuff my Bakewell puddings with fresh berries. 
 In winter I fill them with a rich and succulent mincemeat mixture. 
 Derbyshire folk may query the authenticity of this but I defy them not to enjoy the results. 
 Serves 8 
 For the pastry: 
 2 oz each lard and butter 4 oz each plain and wholemeal flour 2&frac12; tbsp orange juice to bind 
 For the filling: 
 3 oz each sultanas and raisins 2oz each currants and flaked almonds &amp;1/4; pt hot tea plus 2 tbsp brandy or rum a good pinch each of cinnamon and allspice the finely grated zest of 1 orange 
 For the topping: 
 &amp;1/4; lb each butter and caster sugar &amp;1/4; lb freshly ground almonds and 2 eggs 
 Mix the spices and zest with the brandy. 
 Pour on the hot tea and stir in the fruits. 
 Cover and set aside for several hours or overnight, stirring occasionally if passing. 
 Make the pastry and use it to line a 10-inch shallow fluted flan tin. 
 Blind-bake at 400&deg;F (200&deg;C) gas mark 6 for 15 mins, then for a further 10 min without greaseproof paper and baking beans. 
 To make the topping, first barely melt the butter. 
 Away from the heat, add the sugar to the pan, then stir in the ground almonds and the lightly beaten eggs, in that order. 
 Tip the fruits into a sieve (save the juices that drain from them to whip with thick cream to serve with the Bakewell) and mix them with the flaked almonds. 
 turn the mixture into the pre-cooked pastry case and pour the topping over it. 
 Bake at 400&deg;F (200&deg;C) gas mark 6 for 40&ndash;45 min until the topping has set to a golden crust. 
 Cool till tepid or, better still, serve cold. 
 BEST BREAD &amp; BUTTER PUDDING 
 Rich and soothing, this decidedly grown-up version of an old nursery favourite owes more to Anton Mosimann than to Mrs Beeton. 
 I love it just as it is but it can be sauced with burnt brandy. 
 Crush a sugar lump and add it to the brandy in which the raisins were soaked; warm the mixture, set it alight and drizzle it over the pudding just before bringing to table. 
 Serves 4&ndash;5 
 6&ndash;8 nanny-thin, slightly stale slices of bloomer loaf 2&ndash;3 oz raisins, plumped up overnight in a few spoonfuls of brandy butter and whole nutmeg (or ground allspice) 4 large eggs and 1 pt half cream 2&ndash;3 tbsp demerara sugar or crushed coffee sugar crystals (optional) 
 Butter a shallow ovenproof dish or 4&ndash;5 individual souffl&eacute; dishes. 
 Butter the bread and sprinkle on a grating of nutmeg or pinches of allspice. 
 Cut the slices in half and stand them semi-upright round the edges of the dish(es) and across the centre. 
 Drain the raisins and scatter them between the slices. 
 Beat the eggs with the cream and pour it on. 
 Set aside for 20&ndash;30 min. 
 Put the dish(es) into a roasting pan containing enough freshly boiled water to come halfway up the sides. 
 Bake at 325&deg;F (160&deg;C) gas mark 3 until the custard is just set but still trembling in the centre and the tops of the bread projecting from it are deliciously toasty and crusted. 
 This will probably take 30&ndash;45 min depending on the size, shape and depth of the dish(es). 
 Sprinkle with sugar for extra crunch or drizzle with burnt brandy as described in the introduction to this recipe, and serve. 
 DARK CHOCOLATE PUDDING 
 The classiest, most chocolatey chocolate puddings are made with best quality, slightly bitter dessert chocolate that is high in cocoa solids. 
 This pudding also includes a little cocoa powder for good measure. 
 Light in texture, it is sublime served with cascades of cream poured over. 
 Serves 6&ndash; or just 4 chocaholics. 
 &amp;1/4; lb each butter and vanilla sugar &amp;1/4; lb best dark chocolate, grated 1 oz cocoa powder, sifted and mixed with 3 oz freshly ground almonds 6 large eggs, separated 
 Butter a 3 pt pudding basin and a circle of greaseproof paper to cover it. 
 Half-fill a large pan with water and bring to the boil. 
 Beat the butter in a warmed mixing bowl until creamy. 
 Add the sugar and beat again until fluffy and light. 
 Beat in the grated chocolate. 
 Add the cocoa mixture and the egg yolks, in alternate spoonfuls, and continue beating until smooth and creamy. 
 Whisk the egg whites. 
 Slacken the chocolate mixture with one-third of them then fold in the rest. 
 Turn the pudding into the basin. 
 Cover with the greaseproof paper, then with foil and tie with string. 
 Steam for 70 min, by the end of which time the pudding will be perfectly puffed up and set with a just-molten streak in the centre. 
 Unmould on to a hot plate and serve straight away. 
 BUTTERSCOTCH WALNUT SPONGE 
 Miller Howe in the Lake District is the home of John Tovey's famous Sticky Toffee Pudding. 
 This sibling confection is steamed, not baked, nutty and almost as rich. 
 A friend has described it as worth putting on weight for. 
 Serves 5&ndash;6 
 For the butterscotch topping: 
 4 oz pale muscovado sugar 2&frac12; oz butter and 4 tbsp cream 
 For the sponge: 
 4 oz each butter and pale muscovado sugar 3&ndash;4 oz chopped walnut pieces 1 tsp cinnamon and 2 tbsp Camp coffee essence 2 large eggs and 4 oz self-raising flour &amp;1/4; tsp bicarbonate of soda dissolved in &frac12; tsp warm water 
 Butter a 2 pt pudding basin and a circle of greaseproof paper to cover it. 
 Half-fill a large pan with water and bring to the boil. 
 Put the butterscotch topping ingredients into a small pan. 
 Place over gentle heat and stir until the sugar and butter have melted, then simmer for 3 min and pour into the prepared pudding basin. 
 For the sponge, first cream the butter and sugar with the cinnamon until soft and fluffy. 
 Add the sifted flour and lightly beaten eggs in alternate spoonfuls, mixing well. 
 Beat in the coffee and when the mixture is creamy and light, add the bicarbonate of soda and the chopped walnuts. 
 Spoon the mixture carefully and evenly over the topping. 
 Cover with the greaseproof paper, then some foil and tie with string. 
 Steam for 1&frac12; hr before unmoulding and serving on a hot platter large enough to take the pudding and its moat of butterscotch sauce. 
 LEMON TREACLE TART 
 Treacle tarts filled with syrup-soaked breadcrumbs can be a little cloying. 
 This Suffolk version is more subtle: a creamy lemon custard with syrupy undertones. 
 Serves 6 
 1 x 8-inch shallow fluted shortcrust pastry case, blind baked and cooled 2 eggs lightly beaten with 4 tbsp soured cream the zest of 1 lemon and 1&frac12; tbsp lemon juice 6 tbsp golden syrup 3 tbsp freshly ground almonds 
 Stand the tin of syrup in hot water just long enough to make the syrup thin, runny and warm &mdash; not hot. 
 Measure 6 level tbsp of the syrup into a small bowl that has been rinsed out with hot water. 
 Beat in the lemon juice and zest, then the egg and cream mixture, using a fork to blend the ingredients smoothly. 
 Scatter the freshly ground almonds over the base of the pastry case and carefully pour the syrup mixture on top. 
 Bake the tart on a preheated baking sheet at 350&deg;F (180&deg;C) gas mark 4 for 40&ndash;45 min until the filling is creamily set. 
 Serve warm, not piping hot. 
 If preferred the lemon treacle tart can be completely cooked a day ahead and reheated gently just before serving. 
 APRICOT &amp; ALMOND ROLYPOLY 
 Steamed rolypoly was once served in all the best nurseries. 
 The baked version, with its crunchily golden crust, is still a rib-sticking favourite in diehard gentlemen's clubs. 
 The better the jam the better the rolypoly, and I like to gild the lily by lacing the dough with almonds and orange zest, too. 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 
 6 oz self-raising flour and 1 tsp cinnamon 3 oz each grated suet and flaked almonds the zest of 1 orange and 6 tbsp orange juice at least &frac12; lb dried apricot and orange jam (or other good jam, preferably home-made) 
 Stir together the flour, ground cinnamon, grated suet, flaked almonds and orange zest. 
 Mix in the orange juice to bind. 
 Roll out the pastry to an oblong measuring 8 x 12 inch. 
 Leaving a clear border of at least &frac12; inch all round, spread the jam thickly over the centre. 
 Damp the pastry edges with cold water. 
 Roll up the dough from one short end to the other and pinch the ends together to seal. 
 Slide the rolypoly on to a greased baking tray, seam side down. 
 Bake for 40 min at 220&deg;C (425&deg;F) gas mark 7, reducing the heat a little if the pudding begins to brown too much. 
 Serve with custard, rather than cream, in accordance with tradition.  
 Toffee Apple Charlotte 
 Passionate Queen of Puddings 
 King James's  FRUITFUL ERROR 
 BY WISELY REINTERPRETING HIS ROYAL COMMAND, JAMES THE FIRST'S SUBJECTS BEQUEATHED US A LEGACY OF SWEET MULBERRY TREES. 
 BY JAMES DRIVER 
 King James I was a vain, foolish man, full of grandiose, impractical plans to impress the rest of 17th-century Europe. 
 Most of his many failures are, mercifully, long forgotten; but one doomed scheme &mdash; to bring England her own silk industry &mdash; has left 20th-century cooks and gardeners a rich, if somewhat neglected, legacy. 
 A silkworm &mdash; actually the caterpillar of the silk moth &mdash; will spin the cocoon that can yield an astonishing 800 metres of pure silk only if it is fed leaves from the white mulberry tree. 
 This tree, Morus alba , produces poor, almost inedible, fruit. 
 King James offered financial rewards to persuade people to plant mulberries to feed his imported silkworms. 
 Those who took his rewards, however, proved far cannier than their monarch. 
 Their long folk memories recalled other attempts to produce native silk over the previous hundred years &mdash; and how all of them had failed. 
 The unpredictable English weather meant that delivering the leaves at the right time and at exactly the right stage of development for silkworms to thrive on them was impossible. 
 The farmers knew this. 
 Far better, then, not to plant the worthless white mulberry, but rather to take the king's money and plant instead the almost identical black mulberry, Morus nigra , which since Roman times had borne delicious crops of long, purple fruit. 
 The mulberry can grow to a very great age, and some of those planted over 380 years ago can still be found. 
 These survivors, and their many descendants, provide us with one of the most versatile of tree fruits. 
 A mulberry is very similar in shape to a loganberry, but its taste is unique. 
 Even after all these years it still carries an authentic medieval flavour. 
 On reaching full maturity, and becoming almost black, the berries dissolve in the mouth, releasing a flood of juice that is sweet, but shot through with a sharp, vibrant tang alien to the bland, manufactured taste of the increasing number of modern hybrid berries. 
 Blackbirds and thrushes enjoy feeding on them, too. 
 If birds do look like working their way through a crop, the berries can be picked when still only a deep red colour. 
 At this stage they are probably too acidic for most palates to be eaten raw, but they are ideal for using in pies, tarts, jams and jellies. 
 A perfect way to serve them is in a tart of shortcrust pastry, mixed with three or four free-range eggs and plenty of sugar, and baked for half an hour or so in a medium-hot oven. 
 In choosing the best moment to collect the berries it is worth remembering that in the past growers expected their fruit to fulfil more than one function. 
 Along with elderberries, bilberries and blackberries, mulberries had another use as the source of a deep blue dye &mdash; spend a few minutes plucking really ripe ones, and you'll quickly learn why. 
 Perhaps it is because of this that an alternative method of picking was developed. 
 Sheets would be spread out under the tree and the trunk would be shaken vigorously. 
 As this must have resulted in plenty of bruised fruit it was probably invented by winemakers rather than cooks, and mulberries have an interesting place in wine history. 
 Until comparatively recently English vineyards had never had any sort of reputation for producing fine wines. 
 In Saxon times some produced no wine at all, their grapes being used for vinegar. 
 To make drinkable what wine was produced, the native vintners sweetened it with mulberries. 
 This not only took the edge off the bitter taste, but also gave the drink a warm, attractive colour that looked (even if nothing else about it was similar) something like the superior imported French wines. 
 Mulberries remain, of course, a marvellous ingredient for home-made wine. 
 The trees are traditionally planted in the middle of a lawn. 
 Here they can develop slowly without having to compete with other hungrier, more demanding plants. 
 As they grow into their compact form, their beautifully regular, heart-shaped leaves hang down from a tangle of branches to give glorious dappled shade from the hottest summer sun. 
 According to an old adage, the mulberry is a sure indicator of the coming of warmer weather: 
 When the mulberry tree grows green, 
 The last of winter's frosts you've seen. 
 It is certainly not a tree for the impatient or faint-hearted gardener. 
 Long after even the latest apple tree has finally broken into leaf, the mulberry's branches remain stubbornly bare. 
 Its buds never seem to burst until the summer is truly about to arrive. 
 Because mulberry trees are usually found in the centre of a lawn, not hidden away in the kitchen garden or grown in an orchard, they often provide a focus for children's play. 
 The song &bquo;Here we go round the mulberry bush&equo; reflects this (though an alternative theory holds that a mulberry tree was often planted in prison exercise yards, and inmates recited the rhyme as they walked round it). 
 The fruit is ideal for children, too. 
 Its zesty taste deters even the greediest from eating too much. 
 One tree in a school near Worcester has remained in its original position, while the buildings around it have been demolished and rebuilt over the centuries. 
 It bears so much fruit that it can still supply the appetites of 50 children and a large population of garden birds. 
 However unattractive King James was as a man and a monarch, he did leave a few noble monuments to grace his reign. 
 He commissioned the most famous translation of the Bible; was a patron of Shakespeare in his later years; wrote a treatise on the harmful effects of smoking; and, completely by accident, caused the revival of one of our most noble garden trees. 
 Deciding which achievement was the most remarkable is all a matter of taste. 
 MULBERRY TREE OFFER 
 Through our special offer you can plant your own mulberry tree for just &pound;18.95. 
 A black mulberry ( Morus nigra ), it will be about three feet high when delivered, ready to be planted out (with instructions enclosed). 
 It will grow to approx. 20 feet. 
 To order, fill in the coupon on page 154.  
 A stylised mulberry tree from the pages of a 16th-century herbal and bestiary 
 SEAL of approval  
 WHY DO WE FASTEN BOTTLES OF WINE WITH CORK? 
 KATHRYN McWHIRTER POPS THE QUESTION 
 Corks have kept wine safe in bottles for thousands of years. 
 Historically, there was nothing to match them, for cork expands snugly into the quirkiest of hand-blown bottle necks. 
 Nowadays, wine can be sealed just as, or sometimes more, effectively with a &bquo;crown cork&equo; &mdash; the crimped-edged metal cap used for beer. 
 Champagne ages perfectly in the producers' cellars with a cheap crown cork, and only sprouts its traditional mushroom just before it goes on sale. 
 The efficient, hygienic Swiss are really sold on crown corks; many of their finest wines are metal-capped. 
 But cork is special. 
 It's smart, effective, ecologically sound and it does pop  in such a thirst-rousing way. 
 Corks first popped in ancient Greece and Rome, but then gave way to more primitive stoppers. 
 Medieval paintings show twists of cloth jammed into bottlenecks, or cloth or leather tied over the top, sometimes smeared with sealing wax. 
 It wasn't until the mid-16th century that corks began to appear again. 
 Shakespeare must have thought them common enough: in As You Like It  a frustrated Rosalind says, &bquo;I prithee, take thy cork out of thy mouth that I may drink thy tidings.&equo; 
 Cork stoppers were certainly common by the second half of the 17th century, though up to the early 18th century the really smart alternative was the glass stopper, which had to be ground to fit each individual hand-blown bottle. 
 Cork is made up of a myriad of tiny cells, each imprisoning a tiny pocket of air. 
 Shove it in a bottle neck, and it springs back, shaping itself to the glass. 
 And it stays put, not only because it's in a tight squeeze, but because the microscopic sliced-through cells all around the cork's perimeter act as an army of suction pads. 
 It is also inert and flavourless, water- and wine-resistant, and unaffected by heat or cold. 
 No other packaging material can be greener than cork. 
 It grows on trees and once cut grows back again and again. 
 Cork is the bark of the evergreen cork oak, which grows, wild or cultivated, in a narrow belt around the western Mediterranean and nearby Atlantic coasts, mostly in Portugal, quite a lot in Spain, and also in western Italy, Sicily, Sardinia, Corsica and North Africa. 
 It takes about 30 years from planting for a tree to grow enough bark to be harvested. 
 The pinkish, dusty core of the tree that remains turns to reddish-brown, then in the following year becomes grey and crusty, and gradually begins to regenerate its corky bark. 
 Nine or ten years later, it is stripped again, and so on for more than 150 years. 
 The business of turning bark into stoppers is very much a cottage industry, apart from a few modern factories. 
 The curved planks or tubes of cork are stacked out in the sun for three months or more to dry, then boiled for an hour or so with fungicides and antiseptics to kill off any bugs and moulds, and to soften the bark by extracting tannins and minerals. 
 It then spends about a month in cellars or dark warehouses to &bquo;ripen&equo; to its maximum softness and elasticity, before being cut into strips just wider than the diameter of a cork. 
 I always fear for the fingers of the Portuguese works who feed these strips through the punching machines that make the corks, deftly guiding faults in the strip away from the cutter. 
 The punched corks are graded by quality, either by machine or by chattering teams of headscarved women. 
 A cork doesn't have to be long to be good. 
 A short cork is perfectly adequate for a wine destined to be drunk within a few years. 
 The best cork is the smoothest and densest, with the fewest veins. 
 These dark veins are not just potential channels for wine or air to seep through. 
 They can be the source of a uniquely evil smell. 
 &bquo;Corked&equo; wine has a powerful pong, rather like musty, mouldy walnuts, and current estimates hold that two out of every 100 bottles are affected. 
 A common cause, according to recent research, is the chlorine solution sometimes used to bleach and sterilise corks. 
 It is thought that this reacts with the woody tissue of the veins to produce trichlorophenol or TCP and that residual moulds feed on this, producing a &bquo;corked&equo; -smelling compound. 
 Australia and New Zealand have a special problem with &bquo;corked&equo; corks, even though they buy the best quality, because the moulds flourish in the warm, damp conditions of the sea voyage from Europe. 
 We've been seeing more &bquo;corked&equo; wines in Europe, too. 
 The trouble is, cork has been in short supply. 
 Recent harvests have been short and not enough trees have been planted for the future. 
 Cork prices have risen, and all but the best wine-makers in Italy, Germany, Spain and Portugal in particular have plumped for cheaper, veinier corks. 
 The EC plans a rescue attempt, with subsidies and incentives to plant more cork oaks. 
 May they preserve us from the hermetic seal. 
 BEST FRIENDS 
 CLOTHES TO FEEL AT HOME IN, WHEREVER YOU ARE AND WHOEVER YOU ARE WITH. 
 GOOD COMPANIONS NEVER GO OUT OF FASHION. 
 BY ROBERT BURGESS 
 PHOTOGRAPHS/TIM EVAN-COOK 
 HAIR AND MAKE-UP FOR CHARLES OF THE RITZ/JO GILLINGWATER STOCKISTS/PAGE 112 
 Photographed in and around Charingworth Manor, nearing Chipping Campden in Gloucestershire; Country Living  would like to thank the hotel for their help in compiling this feature. 
 See page 112 for details of a special offer to readers. 
 BEAUTY from within  
 THIS MONTH, ADVICE ON DIET AND SKINCARE TO KEEP YOU BEAUTIFUL FOR LIFE. 
 BY PAULA McWATERS 
 TWENTIES 
 Many a teenage dream has been threatened by the appearance of an untimely spot, and, somewhat unjustly, the adolescent agonies of excess oiliness and blemishes can often plague sufferers well into their early twenties. 
 Improved diet is the best mode of attack but rigorous skincare is also essential. 
 Soap and water is too harsh; try a soap-free wash cream such as Clarins Gentle Foaming Cleanser (&pound;9 for 125ml) or Yves Rocher's Soin Clarifiant Gel Cleansing Mousse (&pound;3.95 for 75ml; call 081&ndash;845 1222 for mail order). 
 The latter contains grapefruit extract which maintains an acid pH on the skin's surface and has a mildly astringent effect on open pores. 
 Follow with a toner for oily skin, then a light, non-greasy moisturiser like Yves Rocher's Soin Clarifiant Normalising Gel (&pound;4.95 for 30ml). 
 Twice a week, use a gentle skin scrub to remove dead cells. 
 Make your own by mixing oatmeal and water into a paste; massage over the face, leave for a few minutes, then rinse with warm water. 
 By the age of 25 or so the oiliness should be settling down but you may find yourself with a new problem: laughter and frown lines must finally be acknowledged as the first signs of an ageing skin. 
 THIRTIES 
 There's still no miracle cure for facial lines, despite manufacturers' claims, but there are  things you can do to delay them. 
 For instance, dietary care should be stepped up: drink a litre of water a day to clear your system; snack on sunflower and pumpkin seeds, a rich source of essential fatty acids; and increase your intake of raw vegetables and fruit. 
 Collagen, the rough semi-elastic web that keeps the lower layer of skin supple, needs vitamins B6 and C and zinc to keep it healthy. 
 Another help is selenium, a vital trace element: one brazil nut will provide your daily needs. 
 The neck and the eyes are two giveaway areas. 
 It's easy to forget the neck in a cleansing routine but it will soon show signs of wrinkling if neglected. 
 Our tester tried Nectar Elderflower Neck Gel (&pound;2.35 for 30g; call 09603&ndash;51580 for mail order), which contains apricot and elderflower extract. 
 The texture and fragrance are light and pleasing. 
 We have 75 tubs of Neck Gel to be won; just tell us which has more vertebrae in its neck, a giraffe or a horse. 
 Answers on a postcard to Country Living/Neck Gel  at the address on page 2 by 28 March. 
 For eyes, try Beauty Without Cruelty Eye Cream (&pound;1.75 for 15ml), a light, easily absorbed moisturiser. 
 Rich creams are best avoided around the eyes as the skin absorbs too readily here and may become puffy. 
 FORTIES 
 As you enter your forties your skin is likely to be even drier and may now show a tendency towards flakiness, broken veins and dry patches. 
 Continue with the dietary recommendations above, and exercise regularly. 
 A cycle ride, walk or swim at least three times a week will boost your circulation and help maintain a healthy bloom. 
 Make the most of sleeptime by using a nourishing cream such as Boots No7 Pure Care Special Treatment Cream (&pound;3.95 for 100ml) or B.Pure Night Cream (&pound;6.99 for 45g; call 071&ndash;602 4026 for mail order details). 
 The first 500 Country Living  readers to order B.Pure Night Cream will receive a free 30g tub of Face Scrub, worth &pound;4.99. 
 Massage night cream into your face and neck before your night-time bath; the warmth will help the skin to absorb the cream. 
 Any surface oil not absorbed after 10&ndash;15 minutes should be blotted off with a tissue. 
 Cell regeneration slows down now, so blemishes may take longer to heal. 
 Speed healing by applying a vitamin E cream, like that by Nature Knows Best (&pound;2.35 for 50g from health food shops or call 759&ndash;302595 for mail order details). 
 Our tester found it very effective. 
 If you have thread veins avoid facial steaming and don't use any toner containing alcohol. 
 After moisturising, disguise thread veins, blemishes and dark circles under the eyes with a good concealer. 
 Two of our testers recommend Rimmel's Hide the Blemish (&pound;1.09), having used it for years. 
 It comes in three shades (light, medium and dark) and is easy to blend. 
 FIFTIES 
 The dangers of excess sunlight are well known but there is increasing evidence that even everyday UVA exposure can have an ageing effect on skin. 
 As you reach your fifties, if not before, switch to a moisturiser containing UVA filters to help prevent further damage, such as Empathy Moisturising Lotion (&pound;3.29 for 125ml) or Cream (&pound;3.29 for 50ml). 
 Both of these contain vitamins A and E to nourish the skin. 
 Sebaceous glands slow down now and your skin may feel very dry and taut so avoid harsh toners. 
 A splash of mineral water &mdash; fizzy or still &mdash; gives a good pep-up after cleansing, but don't use it straight from the fridge. 
 Extremes of temperature exacerbate broken veins and blotchiness. 
 A regular brisk walk will improve muscle tone, but in winter protect your cheeks with a generous application of moisturiser and a soft woollen scarf pulled up round your face. 
 And lastly, beware the bottle and the bean: alcohol and coffee both dehydrate the skin. 
 For a copy of The Wright Diet for Looking Good  by Celia Wright, an excellent sheet of dietary advice for healthy skin and hair, send your name and address and a first class stamp to Green Farm (  CL ), Burwash Common, East Sussex TN19 7LX. 
 WRIST watch  
 REPETITIVE STRAIN INJURY IS NOT CONFINED TO THE OFFICE. 
 ANYONE, FROM GARDENERS TO MUSICIANS, MAY BE AT RISK, REPORTS DR CHARLES SHEPHERD 
 For a &bquo;disease caused by typing&equo; &pound;45,000 may seem an awful lot of compensation, but this is the figure awarded last year to a typist suffering from RSI (repetitive strain injury). 
 The term RSI covers a wide variety of painful hand and arm conditions which have two key factors in common: first, prolonged repetitive movements that result in inflammation, pain and weakness. 
 Second, if the condition goes unrecognised, or is incorrectly treated, irreversible damage may occur. 
 Doctors in the UK have recently been warned that RSI may soon reach epidemic proportions as public recognition increases and compensation becomes a reality. 
 Like many &bquo;new diseases&equo;, RSI started life in America, as simple office trauma. 
 Then it spread to Australia, where it became known as kangaroo paw! 
 If the Australian experience is anything to go by, the cost here to government, employers and insurance companies could soon run into millions of pounds. 
 RSI is a genuine condition, to which anyone with employment or a hobby involving repetitive hand movements is at risk. 
 The dramatic increase in the problem has resulted from the introduction of the new technology of keyboards and VDUs into the workplace. 
 Users now sit immobile for hours on end, except for rapid and intense finger movements. 
 The new athletic demands on untrained muscles and tendons produce the inflammation, pain and weakness that can result in severe and permanent disability. 
 However, RSI doesn't just involve hi-tech professionals using keyboards. 
 It can affect anyone whose work involves specific repetitive movements: gardeners, hairdressers, cleaners, chicken gutters, writers and musicians, as well as the sportsmen and women whose activities can lead to aptly named conditions such as tennis elbow. 
 The commonest RSI is a condition known as tenosynovitis, or &bquo;teno&equo; to its many victims. 
 This is inflammation of the tube-like sheaths that surround and protect the tendons. 
 Fingers are moved backwards and forwards by these delicate sinews &mdash; flexor tendons in the palms, which bend the fingers, and extensor tendons on the back of the hand, which straighten them again. 
 Prolonged repetitive activity can set up inflammation in almost any tendon or sheath. 
 Sarah is 33 and a gifted seamstress. 
 Last year she decided to turn her hobby into full-time employment by opening a shop in a rural crafts centre. 
 As the workload gradually increased she started to notice discomfort and tingling sensations around her wrist joint, but particularly at the base of her thumb. 
 The pain was becoming so intense that by the end of the day she could hardly grip her scissors. 
 Fortunately, her GP was well aware of RSI and quickly diagnosed what is called de Quervain's tenosynovitis. 
 Despite a prolonged period of rest, the inflammation took many weeks to settle down &mdash; even with a steroid injection. 
 Sarah is now working again, part-time, but with a more varied pattern of work. 
 However, her RSI could become a recurring problem unless she takes careful precautions. 
 For many victims, obtaining a diagnosis of RSI, especially when symptoms are still vague and intermittent, is not easy. 
 Some GPs remain ignorant of the existence of RSI as a bona-fide illness, or even hostile to the very idea. 
 Because a clinical examination may not reveal anything abnormal, they may conclude the the symptoms are &bquo;all in the mind&equo;. 
 X-rays don't reveal much, either, since the inflammation lies in the soft tissues and not in the joints. 
 This only adds to the suffering, because early diagnosis and appropriate treatment are necessary to prevent long-term complications. 
 The ideal management of any case of RSI involves a doctor well acquainted with the subject, and a good physiotherapist. 
 In the very early stages proper rest (using a splint) is the best way to reduce the inflammation. 
 Local heat, ultrasound and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) can also help. 
 Some doctors recommend immediate intervention with steroid injections, but although these can have a dramatic effect in reducing inflammation and relieving pain, they can also create a false sense of security. 
 Surgery and manipulation have little or no place in the treatment of most RSIs. 
 Once the acute episode of RSI has been identified and treated, the next essential step is to prevent a recurrence. 
 Anyone who simply returns to the same repetitive activity is heading for further trouble &mdash; especially if their technique is at fault. 
 Claims for compensation are forcing many employers to take RSI seriously, at last, and to tackle the root causes in the workplace. 
 Good employers, working with occupational health advisors, should now be doing all they can to help, by ensuring that anyone involved in a high-risk activity has the most comfortable working environment possible. 
 For keyboard operators this means seating at the correct height and having a work station where the wrists are straight and the elbows bent at 90&deg;. 
 Restructuring work routine may also involve job rotation, variation of tasks, and regular breaks from high-risk activities. 
 As more and more employees hear about RSI, claims for compensation are bound to rise &mdash; last year more than 2,000 people were awarded state injury benefits. 
 Consequently, RSI is also becoming the subject of heated debate within the medical profession. 
 Some orthopaedic surgeons are now adopting a much more sceptical view, as every work-related ache seems to be given the RSI label. 
 In Australia, where compensation claims have rocketed, RSI has even been nicknamed myalgic compensationitis. 
 There's no doubt that exaggeration of symptoms can become a powerful factor in pursuing compensation claims, and if bogus claims do create an RSI bandwagon, genuine cases will fail as a result. 
 For anyone who has been significantly disabled by RSI there are two routes that can be followed. 
 First, the Department of Social Security pays Industrial Injury Disablement Benefit for certain types of RSI, provided you: &bull; are in a job regarded as &bquo;at risk&equo; of causing RSI (the self-employed are usually excluded). 
 &bull; have a firm diagnosis of either tenosynovitis or writer's cramp. 
 Most other types of RSI are excluded. 
 Sporting injuries do not qualify. 
 &bull; can satisfy a medical examination board that you are more than 14 per cent disabled by RSI. 
 (The percentage of disability determines the amount of benefit.) 
 Leaflet N12, If You Have an Industrial Disease , from the DSS, describes the state benefits available and how to apply. 
 The alternative is to take out a civil action in the courts. 
 Here the outcome is still very unpredictable, with few precedents to follow. 
 In the new-technology jobs of banking and computers, where employers are anxious to avoid publicity, most claims are being settled out of court, but as the number of cases increases, litigation could become more popular. 
 Obviously, legal advice should be obtained from a professional body, trade union, or solicitor well versed in such claims.  
 FAUCET SAGA 
 BATHING BELLES INSPIRED BY SCANDINAVIAN PAINTED INTERIORS, AMERICAN RETRO AND EDWARDIAN GENTLEMEN'S DRESSING ROOMS. 
 BY HESTER PAGE AND GABI TUBBS 
 BATHING Beauty  
 Indulge your most precious moments in the perfect setting. 
 A beautiful bathroom by C P Hart, coupled with a top-to-toe skincare programme from Clarins, will transform your daily cleansing routine from a necessity into a luxury 
 CALLIGRAPHY/JANE THOMSON 
 PHOTOGRAPHS/NADIA MACKENZIE 
 Bathe your world in splendour. 
 The Duker Roll Top cast iron bath combines elegance and nostalgia with durability and convenience. 
 Freestanding on ball and claw feet, its excellent heat and sound insulation ensures long hot baths while the household sleeps on undisturbed by noise. 
 Choose from semi-matt white &bquo;edelweiss&equo;, as shown, or gloss white, both supplied primed to enable you to decorate its exterior to your own taste. 
 Roll Top bath, &pound;736, set of four feet, &pound;99.35. 
 Clarins Body Shaping Gel Concentrate, like all Clarins skincare preparations, is based on natural and plant ingredients. 
 Light and invigorating, it is specifically designed to combat skin &bquo;sponginess&equo;, the unsightly dimpling that can occur especially on buttocks and thighs. 
 Applied daily after a bath or shower, the key active ingredients, guarana, L-carnitine, silanols and caffeine, get to work on unwanted fatty deposits, firming, toning and contouring the body, while forming an invisible supporting film on the skin. 
 Body Shaping Gel Concentrate, 150ml, &pound;19. 
 The handsome hexagonal design of C P Hart's Serie 1930 bathroom products is an inspired reinterpretation of a traditional shape. 
 Made in Germany to the most exacting of modern standards, each item in the suite is available in &bquo;edelweiss&equo;, as shown, gloss white, manhattan grey or flannel &mdash; a semi-matt grey. 
 From an extensive range, we have shown the one-hole basin and pedestal, &pound;531.30, lavatory (wc pan, cistern, seat and cover), &pound;607.20, one-hole bidet, &pound;270 and bevelled mirror above the basin, 800 x 550mm, &pound;161. 
 Clarins Eau Dynamisante is the first skincare product which provides both beauty and fragrance benefits. 
 A light blend of twelve plant extracts, Eau Dynamisante combines a delightful natural fragrance with an all-over skincare treatment. 
 The fragrance &mdash; a fresh bouquet of citrus, chypre and woody notes &mdash; has aromatherapeutic properties to stimulate the senses, while both fragrant and non-fragrant extracts, including aloe, ispaghul, harpagophytum, ginger, coriander, horsetail and eleutherocoque, moisturise, firm and tone the body. 
 Clarins Eau Dynamisante, 200ml, &pound;19.50, 100ml, &pound;13. 
 C P Hart's superb variety of bathroom accessories will add the crucial touch to your choice of bathroom suite. 
 All styles are available in chrome (as shown) or &bquo;new brass&equo;. 
 We have selected taps from the Liberty range: wall-mounted bath shower mixer, &pound;324.30, monobloc basin mixer, &pound;156.40 and monobloc bidet mixer, &pound;150.65. 
 Other accessories are from Leonardo:&hellip;. 
 And for the final soft touches to your skincare programme, Clarins Fragranced Gentle Shower Mousse and Fragranced Gentle Deodorant both bear the unique Eau Dynamisante scent. 
 The creamy-textured shower mousse, which contains, syndets, aloe, ispaghul and ginseng, has a dermatological cleanser to combat dryness as it cleanses, while the deodorant anti-perspirant, in an ozone-friendly spray, blends farnesol, aluminium salts and extracts of sage and liquorice to ensure that you will carry the great feeling from those first precious moments in the bathroom with you throughout the longest of days. 
 FOLLOW the  ANTIQUES TRAIL 
 BATH 
 &hellip; 
 AND BEYOND, WHERE DEIRDRE McSHARRY FINDS FURNITURE AND TEXTILES TO DECORATE A HOUSE AS JANE AUSTEN MIGHT 
 Breathes there a woman with soul so dead that she can take a trip round Bath's exhilarating architecture without wanting to take home &bquo;a touch of the Georgians&equo; &mdash; even if it's only a silver spoon? 
 In a recent survey, one in four visitors to Bath gave a trip round the antique shops as a major reason for visiting the city. 
 (Not surprisingly, the survey was commissioned by the Bath and Bradford on Avon Antique Dealers' Association.) 
 In my 20 or so years visiting the city I don't believe I ever went home empty-handed. 
 The upshot of this is that I've now become a resident, which makes a weekly tour of junk and antique shops even more vital. 
 My list of favourite haunts is purely personal and certainly not all-embracing. 
 I hope you will want to take time and make your own discoveries. 
 As I was helped in getting my eye in by visiting two important houses in Bath, you may wish to do the same. 
 One Royal Crescent, well restored and furnished in the style of 1770 by The Bath Preservation Trust, is the only house of the period open to the public. 
 In the second, The Holburne of Menstrie Museum (in Great Pulteney Street), hangs a fine collection of Gainsboroughs in rooms furnished with period pieces, silver and porcelain. 
 Similar museum-quality furniture is available in the fine shops in the streets between the Pump Room, The Circus and The Assembly Rooms. 
 Anthony Emm of York Street is reckoned to be the doyen. 
 Kit Alderson of Brock Street has taste I admire. 
 The aforementioned Bath and Bradford on Avon Antique Dealers' Association provides a helpful leaflet and map of its 40 or so members. 
 When you consider that there are 120 dealers in the are you can appreciate why Bath is second only to London for the serious hunter. 
 It explains the number of dealers greeting the dawn on the M4, to be in the queue outside The Bath Antiques Market each Wednesday, followed by a hard day's trawl of the shops. 
 Window displays on Wednesday have a special glitter. 
 Few complain about &bquo;Just looking thanks&equo; in a town where stock is displayed in authentic settings; where you can walk the patch in a day; where dealers make time to talk and where Bath's famous light lends allure to even the diciest piece. 
 And the good news is that at a time of recession there are bargains to be had: even grand dealers might discuss a discreet price reduction. 
 Tom Hickman, painter and former dealer, claims: &bquo;You can still furnish a house for a song if you know where and how to look.&equo; 
 Making the most of a buyer's market, I asked dealers for their advice. 
 Tom Hickman says: &bquo;Never buy the obvious; buy what no one else wants. 
 Make snap decisions. 
 Don't hang around. 
 Look at the person, not the goods. 
 If you like their taste, take them out to tea and make an offer. 
 They don't make &pound;100 on everything they sell.&equo; 
 Kitchenalia, early Heal's furniture, late-Victorian light oak, fireplace equipment, textiles are good value, Hickman says. 
 He recommends markets, salerooms, charity shops and reclamation yards in and around Frome, as good hunting grounds. 
 Simon Creese-Parsons, who sells fine decorative pieces at Jadis, reckons: &bquo;There's never been a better time to buy.&equo; 
 He believes that classic English furniture is the best buy in hard times. 
 &bquo;A good dealer gives a service &mdash; everything I sell is in perfect condition and I buy back my stuff if need be.&equo; 
 A French armoire with carving in high relief and a painted berg&egrave;re chair are among his regular stock: he and his partner Neil Mackay now manufacture painted pieces as part of their decoration service. 
 Jadis is in London Road, a good place to begin. 
 Now in the heart of the decoration area of Bath, stretching from the London Road to the end of Walcot Street, we come on Penny Philip whose small shop is a shrine to period textiles: toile de Jouy, Scandinavian bedlinens and shawls are displayed on decorative iron furniture. 
 (Shawls start at around &pound;100.) 
 She helps clients furnish their houses: &bquo;Matching is a bore: I mix florals with stripes with checks. 
 There's nothing like the soft texture and colour of old fabrics: learn to use and take care of them.&equo; 
 A yard or so along and under the sign of Josephine, owner Clare Newbold arranges a m&eacute;lange of decorative items with the surreal air of a Cocteau movie. 
 Garden chairs, mirrors and painted pine blend together. 
 Wise dealers swoop on Monday when Clare has changed the windows. 
 Bookshelves with an antique finish are &pound;165 to order. 
 Keep on the decorative trail to Haliden at 98 Walcot Street, where Brian Dennis sells rugs on three floors. 
 Variations on the tribal and village rug theme range from saddle bags to carpets large enough to replace boring old Wilton. 
 &bquo;And cheaper for the space,&equo; Dennis says. 
 &bquo;People are buying Balouchs, Turkomans and Shiraz. 
 Most are woven of natural dyes in geometric &lsqb;Turkish&rsqb; or flower &lsqb;Persian&rsqb; patterns. 
 A Shiraz with a good pile is priced at &pound;760. 
 &bquo;If perfect it would cost &pound;1,500,&equo; Dennis adds. 
 Now go uptown to the heights of Lansdown where there's another clutch of shops devoted to decorative antiques. 
 At 27B Belvedere, Gene and Sally Foster show good Victorian stock. 
 &bquo;Away with prettiness &mdash; I like the solid masculine appeal of the library,&equo; Gene says, citing a console table with faux marbre  top, an Arts and Crafts hallstand (&pound;195) and a pair of heavy curtains, 10 feet long, in a stunning neoclassical print, for &pound;95. 
 Next door, Paul Farnham's display is in contrast. 
 Stark metal pieces, a giant gazebo, French garden chairs, an urn (all in a white-painted room-setting) give a stagey Chekhovian look that decorators like. 
 A fine tapestry stool is &pound;550. 
 Below at 38 Belvedere, Ann King has a shop like a walk-in linen cupboard stacked with embroidered bedlinen, underwear, quilts and racks of period clothes, mostly 1940s and 1950s. 
 Northumberland quilts to toss over chairs start at &pound;70. 
 Square, lace-edged pillowslips are &pound;25. 
 There's an even bigger selection of period linens and lace at Collectible Costume. 
 Lace curtains from &pound;25 are a speciality. 
 But for la cr&egrave;me de la cr&egrave;me of &bquo;softs&equo;, as the trade calls linens and textiles, drive out to Freshford, where in a former hunting lodge Elizabeth Baer keeps her magpie collection, displayed in a linen room with that authentic &bquo;air of pleasing decay&equo; so admired by John Fowler (of Colefax &amp;). 
 A woman of taste and energy, Mrs Baer goes right to the source &mdash; provincial villages in France &mdash; for her fine curtains, natural linens and variations on the theme of blue (or beige or grey) and white stripes so sought after by decorators. 
 Kitchenalia and garden implements, including dramatic flour and bulb sieves, are a speciality and belong on the most chic garden-room walls. 
 Old linen glass cloths are &pound;6 and pairs of curtains start at &pound;200. 
 By appointment only, to serious collectors and decorators. 
 Now on to Bradford on Avon, the ancient wool town, and up the steep hills lined with stone houses, most of which seem to be antique shops. 
 The interiors are worth the detour. 
 &bquo;You can park here and see a good deal of stock in an hour or two,&equo; claims Barbara Humble, who moved out from Bath two years ago. 
 Mac and Barbara Humble live above the shop in a house they waited 16 years to buy. 
 The former chairman of the Antique Dealers' Association, Mac is witty about the ways of his trade, but serious about antiques. 
 &bquo;When times are hard people should buy useful things and buy the best they can afford,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;Quality furniture holds its price. 
 If it has colour and patination and is not over-restored, it's worth the money. 
 Take out a loan if you have to! 
 Invest in a good piece now: later, it will be worth much more,&equo; he says, gesturing towards tip worktables, fire irons, needlework samplers and silk pictures. 
 Four framed Victorian prints of owls are good value at &pound;395. 
 At 5 Woolley Street live Richard and Pamela Nadin who deal in unusual and rather strong pieces, often with a touch of the Gothicks. 
 &bquo;I like nice faded things from country houses,&equo; Richard says. 
 A chair freak &mdash; odd because he never sits down &mdash; he likes to offer a selection of good chairs upholstered in period prints, often by MacKenzie Hodsoll. 
 His speciality is the upholstery of Howard and Sons of Berners Street, London. 
 The downfilled upholstery is a bench-mark, he says: &bquo;You sink into it and it moulds to the body.&equo; 
 One sofa measuring eight by four foot must be the largest country house sofa in captivity. 
 Another treasure house worth the drive is Matthew Eden's, to the east of the city, at Pickwick End, Corsham. 
 His taste is evident in the nicely worn country house furniture and accessories. 
 In the bosky garden is a selection of wire garden pieces designed by his father Robin in the 1950s. 
 Made locally by two craftsmen, they start at &pound;230 for a chair. 
 In the opposite direction is Tilly Manor in West Harptree, which looks altogether too French to be in north Somerset. 
 Note the coat of arms over the door and the fine plasterwork &mdash; with the date 1659 &mdash; over the fireplace. 
 Good country house furniture in mahogany and pine, plus silver, brass and pictures, are on sale. 
 Owner Jeremy Scott has his own restoration workshop. 
 His policy is that everything should be properly displayed, marked and priced. 
 He advises: &bquo;Buy what is functional and decorative. 
 If you have a choice, buy the better piece.&equo; 
 Good value today, he feels, are quality 1920s copies of Georgian originals. 
 Typical of the stock are six chairs in Regency style but dating from the 1950s, for &pound;850; and a pair of delicate late-Victorian rosewood chairs at &pound;85 each. 
 Spending money with dealers whose taste I like is my method of shopping, but it is always fun, and often profitable, to have a flutter at the auction rooms. 
 And you should make one early raid on the Wednesday or Saturday markets, which offer dozens of stalls and hundreds of bargains if you have the patience to sift through the dross. 
 Serious rely on the frequent antiques fairs because of the big selection. 
 You only have to snip out the listings in the local paper on Saturday, a column filled with auctions, sales, markets and fairs in an area that stretches from Bath to Frome, Shepton Mallet, Devizes and Wells. 
 The legendary Bath Antiques Market at Guinea Place every Wednesday is good value for jewellery (especially Victorian pieces), silver, rugs and &bquo;softs&equo;, with a special mention for Joanna Proops's souk-like stall cascading with quilts, shawls, linens, rugs and period clothes. 
 If you're lucky you'll find period curtains costing much less than new. 
 On a platform is displayed the interesting collection of tribal and village rugs &mdash; no machine makes &mdash; offered by Craig Bale of Silk Road. 
 Shiraz and Afghan rugs sell at prices under &pound;500. 
 Cushions start at &pound;20 and old ikats and other textiles are good value at around &pound;100. 
 Craig recommends a fine Balouchi rug in a geometric weave five by three feet for &pound;100: &bquo;These natural dyes look good in period houses.&equo; 
 That's the secret of Bath's success. 
 It makes all the shoppers feel as if they could live in the style of Jane Austen. 
 The second Decorative Antiques Fair will be held in the Pavilion Rooms, North Parade Road, Bath, from 16&ndash;18 May. 
 We have arranged a special offer: Country Living  readers will be admitted free on presentation of the first page of this article (or take along the March issue if you do not wish to cut your magazine). 
 Further information on 0225&ndash;442215.  
 Below left Deirdre McSharry (left) with Penny Philip, who implores her customers to &bquo;pick up the fabric and feel it&equo;. 
 More of her textiles are displayed top centre. 
 Top left Painted ware from Josephine, including two salt boxes and an egg rack. 
 Top right A pair of decorative 19th-century French vases and a putti centrepiece for an archway at Jadis 
 BACK IN THE PINK 
 TIMOTHY AND CHRISTINE EASTON HAVE NO TIME FOR BUILDERS WHO SANDBLAST THE PAST INTO OBLIVION. 
 IN THEIR SUFFOLK FARMHOUSE, CAREFUL DETECTIVE WORK HAS REVEALED THE ORIGINAL PAINTED DECORATIONS, NOW LOVINGLY RESTORED. 
 BY GILLIAN DARLEY 
 The image of a perfect Suffolk farmhouse must surely be a pink house, with a gable or two and a tall, intricate, brick chimney, the whole wrapped around by a moat and some venerable trees. 
 Just such a house has been brought back to life by Timothy and Christine Easton. 
 In addition to being a family house it is Timothy's working base for his painting and sculpture. 
 Timothy, a self-confessed amateur of vernacular architecture, has followed a traditional line in reinstating and enhancing the features and materials of the house. 
 In addition, he has pursued his own passion for the painted interior decoration of this particular kind and scale of East Anglian yeoman farmhouse &mdash; a type of house that, only a few years ago, was hardly considered worthy of notice, so complete was the obsession of historians with work by named architects. 
 Luckily, the picture has altered as it has become clear that in agriculturally wealthy areas, where farmers were often owner-occupiers, they lavished great attention on their houses. 
 Certainly the Eastons' house points to a proud history. 
 They had previously lived in, and worked on, a medieval timber-framed house at nearby Debenham, and had learned much from their successes and failures there. 
 Seven years ago, needing more space for their family (two daughters, currently both art students) and their work, they decided to move, and to take on a rather dilapidated but unrestored farmhouse. 
 It benefits from a lovely site, opposite the parish church and close to farm buildings, away from the village centre. 
 The Eastons did not rush into the task. 
 A year passed while they grew used to the house, learned how the light fell and how the various rooms worked. 
 They had fallen upon all sorts of riches, some immediately apparent but others that took some seeking out. 
 &bquo;I looked for a single builder, because I wanted to work closely with someone while I was doing the &bquo;unpicking&equo; myself,&equo; Timothy says. 
 He didn't employ an architect or surveyor, hoping that by being on the job and so closely involved, he &bquo;could control things not being removed&equo;. 
 Sore experience on the Debenham house made him very aware of how easily original details can be lost in inexpert hands. 
 The first choice of a single builder did not work out, but Timothy Easton has high praise for his replacement, Barry Rose, from Debenham: &bquo;He was excellent and could do virtually anything.&equo; 
 For window repairs, and those to panelling and cupboards, a local joiner, Malcolm Neeve from Saxtead, was another &bquo;find&equo;. 
 Where window-glazing repairs were concerned, Timothy turned to Kent Blaxill, a Colchester firm with great expertise. 
 He decided not to go for repair grants. 
 &bquo;If you are going to gut the house all in one go, this commits you to thousands of pounds worth of work. 
 As this house was structurally sound the remedy was to do the work one room at a time.&equo; 
 On damp proofing, the local firm used actually advised doing it partially, in order not to upset the balance in the timber. 
 &bquo;They did it without a guarantee, but that didn't particularly worry me. 
 Damp isn't a major problem; we are high on the site and there is the moat to take away any surface water.&equo; 
 Timothy's interest in decorative schemes drew him to look carefully for evidence of the old painted ornament, and he found plenty. 
 Walls were painted to echo the close studding of the timber-framed structure, although in the form of columns with different-patterned capitals in silhouette. 
 The ceiling in the old kitchen was painted dark grey and etched with circles, some enclosing helixes and geometric foliate forms, while the fireplaces were surrounded by brickwork, itself painted over and ornamented in all kinds of ways. 
 There seems to have been a hierarchy of colours, ranging from grey, to red for the principal rooms. 
 It all took a lot of investigation, finding paint traces on plaster plugs in the timbers, for example, although some rooms had kept quite clear evidence of both colour and pattern. 
 Christine, herself a painter, and Timothy did this themselves. 
 The core of the house is a 15th-century hall, which retains the plan of the screens passage that divided the open hall from the service areas of buttery and pantry. 
 In the 16th century, an east wing was added to replace the earlier parlour, while in the 17th century a kitchen wing was built to balance it to the west. 
 The effect was completed by the addition of elaborate and pretty Gothick windows around the end of the 18th century. 
 A Victorian porch has replaced the original double-height one, which had a tiny room above it. 
 The &bquo;best&equo; rooms have chimney-pieces picked out in a canny false-stone effect (in fact no more than mortar) or else ornamented by rubbed and painted bricks. 
 The Eastons restored the ornamental paintwork, most of it imitation brickwork painted over the actual brick, and in the case of the wall paintings, have reinstated the full scheme. 
 As well as the painted decoration, the Eastons are fortunate in also having two good plaster ceilings. 
 The one in the parlour is divided into sections by bands of naturalistic vegetation in a typical 17th-century manner; above, in the main bedroom, is a simple affair, with applied plaster oak leaves. 
 It needed a lot of repair as two largish areas had fallen off. 
 &bquo;We gathered up most of the decorative bits, and put them back into lime plaster.&equo; 
 The old hair plaster proved remarkably resilient, and Timothy found a Blue Circle product, &bquo;Snowplast&equo;, that was ideal for making good. 
 Other attractive features, which help to show the age and history of the house, are two winding back stairs with oak treads, a small amount of panelling, cupboards with a delicate dentil cornice, the pamments (great clay tiles) on several of the floors (now relaid over insulation), and a number of the original latticed tripartite windows (an oriel flanked by two small windows). 
 On the blank east wall the Eastons have opened up windows, following the outlines of earlier mullions. 
 Suffolk County Council has long been over-stretched on the conservation side, and comparable houses have suffered from lack of expert advice. 
 Internal sandblasting and restoration, which can obliterate all the social and architectural clues, is all too common. 
 It is hard to imagine the average builder, unskilled in the repair of old buildings, recognising the significance of the two cat skeletons and the pile of old clothes that the Eastons found tucked behind the chimney in the old kitchen. 
 Offered by past inhabitants to help guarantee their good fortune, they often turn up in old houses in this part of the world &mdash; probably unrecognised and tossed in the dustbin. 
 The Suffolk farmhouse was nothing if not practical. 
 The storage and preparation of food took place on the north side, where the Eastons have made a studio out of the old pentice, called the tempting shed, which ran along that side. 
 On the north-east corner is the cellar, complete with winter bee boles and a drainage channel out to the moat. 
 The original dairy, with copper and other traditional fittings, is now their kitchen, releasing the farm kitchen as a delightful breakfast room complete with roaring fire and well-worn pamments on the floor. 
 As if the house were not large enough, there are generous attics stretching right across it, offering another five rooms for expansion. 
 Once, these would have been an important farmhouse store for produce that needed safe keeping in a dry place. 
 The Eastons' sense of the history and archaeology of their house is evident in every detail, yet they are not imprisoned by that. 
 The farmhouse is a welcoming, fascinating building in which past and present happily coexist. 
 An exhibition of recent paintings by Timothy Easton is on view throughout March at The Chris Beetles Gallery, 10 Ryder Street, St James's. 
 London SW1Y 6QB (071&ndash;839 7551).  
 Main picture Timothy and Christine Easton's Suffolk farmhouse reflected in the moat that surrounds it Inset, previous page Timothy Easton, painter and sculptor Far left The shape of the internal porch in the parlour shows that the room was once panelled. 
 On the floor, the pamments, or great clay tiles, have been relaid over insulation Left The fireplace decoration in the kitchen chamber, now Timothy's studio, differs from that in the other rooms. 
 The black imitation columns were originally painted in the 17th century, and have been carefully restored 
 Below The parlour chamber has its early-17th-century wall studs picked out in red to denote its higher status than the other, grey-painted, rooms. 
 The small circles on the &bquo;ochred and pencilled&equo; fireplace were thought to give spiritual protection to the occupants 
 ELEMENTAL EXPOSURE 
 THOUGH THE RAIN IT RAINETH EVERY DAY, YOU NEEDN'T MISS A PHOTO OPPORTUNITY. 
 STEVE ASHTON PUTS SIX WEATHERPROOF CAMERAS TO THE TEST 
 The most telling personal images are captured by simple cameras in the hands of people who know nothing about photography. 
 We're not talking art here, we're talking memories. 
 For &bquo;simple&equo; read &bquo;automatic&equo;; uncluttered exteriors conceal complex innards. 
 Light-sensitive cells govern lens-aperture and shutter-speed settings; infra-red beams measure distances to activate lens focusing; motors wind films and operate zoom lenses. 
 Some moments are too fleeting for clumsy fiddling. 
 If you venture out in all weathers, you need a compact camera that can brave the elements, too. 
 Armed with a dozen rolls of film, I put six cameras to the test in the rain-lashed hills of Snowdonia. 
 KODAK WEEKEND 35 
 A plastic case waterproofs this disposable camera to a depth of eight feet. 
 It survived a dunking in a mountain stream, and brought back a picture of a retrieving hand to prove it. 
 The Weekend comes preloaded with a 24-exposure (ISO 400) colour-print film, so all you have to do is shoot and wind on, then hand over the whole camera to the developers at the end. 
 Easy. 
 But the designer writing on the camera body needlessly confuses the first-time user searching for the shutter-release pad, which even adults find hard to operate. 
 Kodak explains that it must be stiff to resist water pressure at depth. 
 Picture quality from the plastic lens and relatively coarse-grained film is perfectly adequate for album snapshots. 
 Verdict: 
 Recommended for one-off use in conditions where you dare not risk an expensive camera. 
 YASHICA T3-AF 
 The T3's elegant, understated styling will appeal to those who prefer to be discreet about their photography &mdash; a noisy film-winding motor notwithstanding. 
 It fits snugly into the hands and is ideal for grabbing action shots with a minimum of fuss. 
 Discerning photographers will appreciate the quality of results possible from the f2.8 Zeiss lens. 
 I would have liked some manual override on exposure settings, though the fill-in flash is some compensation. 
 I'd happily take this camera on my adventurous travels. 
 Verdict: 
 A likeable camera capable of securing good results without effort. 
 OLYMPUS AF-1 SUPER 
 Plain looks hide advanced gadgetry. 
 Beginners will enjoy their success with this deceptively simple camera. 
 A chunky grip on the lens cover and a positive shutter-release button make cold-weather shooting easy. 
 Picture quality, to my eye, is in the same league as the similarly priced Yashica, yet the Olympus is lighter, smaller and includes useful extra features such as a fast-recycling flash and a quick-fire mode for those going&hellip; going&hellip; gone action sequences. 
 As with the Yashica and Minolta AF-SP, the 35mm lens means you have to get close to the action if your photos are to have real impact. 
 Verdict: 
 A good choice as a go-anywhere camera, provided you won't feel limited by the single lens. 
 OLYMPUS AF-1 TWIN 
 Similar in most respects to the AF-1 Super, the Twin adds a second lens of 70mm focal length, activated at the touch of a button. 
 I expected to pay for twin-lens versatility with loss of picture quality, but this wasn't the case at all. 
 This invaluable extra feature adds little to the overall weight and bulk of the AF-1, though you do lose the AF-1's fast-recycling flash and close-up facility. 
 I have an aversion to noisy cameras, and this one rings several decibels before it's done with selecting and focusing the lens, and winding on the film. 
 Nevertheless, if I had to choose just one of these six cameras to serve all my picture-taking needs, this would be it. 
 Verdict: 
 Versatile weatherproof camera capable of good-quality results. 
 Highly recommended. 
 MINOLTA AF-SP 
 Least expensive of all the autofocus cameras on trial, the AF-SP's design style belongs to the age of cast-iron kitchen fittings. 
 Looks aren't everything, of course, and that homely exterior houses some hi-tech instrumentation. 
 I also liked the positive hand grip and the relative quiet of the motors. 
 Limited specifications in automatic exposure and focusing will disappoint photography buffs, though few would detect tangible differences in the average snapshot. 
 Verdict: 
 An adequate performer if you don't want to spend more than &pound;100. 
 MINOLTA WEATHERMATIC 35DL 
 Waterproof to a depth of 16 feet, the Weathermatic makes a sturdy companion for the unstoppable outdoor enthusiast. 
 In a few hurried situations I forgot to switch on, and missed the picture opportunity while trying to figure out why the camera wasn't working. 
 What a pity the &bquo;off&equo; switch doesn't blank out the viewfinder &mdash; a fail-safe reminder adopted by most camera designers. 
 The Weathermatic happily bobbed about in mountain pools, the automatic flash adding sparkle to underwater shots. 
 Water pressure deactivates the autofocusing mechanism, and a close-up mode will give sharp results from a subject only two feet away. 
 Otherwise, I thought the specifications somewhat limited for a camera of this price. 
 True, it has a second lens but this one is of a mere 50mm focal length &mdash; too similar to the standard 35mm lens to make much of a difference. 
 If you are attracted by the Weathermatic's underwater ability, remember that you are paying for elaborate waterproofing seals, not for exceptional lens quality or advanced specifications (even the self-timer and tripod bush have been sacrificed). 
 Under normal circumstances you will be carrying an unnecessarily heavy and bulky camera. 
 Verdict: 
 The only compact camera for the underwater enthusiast. 
 Serious divers will have to pay over &pound;500 for a Nikon Nikonos underwater camera. 
 For these trials the six cameras, and a 35mm SLR &bquo;control&equo; camera, were subjected to 50 separate operations in a variety of conditions. 
 Results were recorded on film supplied by Kodak. 
 Overleaf is a table summarising the results, along with the main specifications of the individual cameras. 
 WIN OUR RECOMMENDED CAMERA 
 You could win an Olympus AF-1 Twin, worth &pound;150, the camera recommended by Steve Ashton for its versatility and all-round performance. 
 Select the correct answer to the following question: Some cameras are fitted with a backlight button. 
 Does this: A Create silhouette effects; B Allow additional light through the lens; C Activate the fill-in flash mode; or D Lock the exposure settings while recomposing the picture? 
 Then briefly describe an occasion on which you wish you'd had a waterproof camera. 
 Send your answer, together with your name and address, on a postcard to the address on page 2. 
 Please mark your postcard Country Living  /Camera. 
 Answers should arrive by 30 April.  
 Main picture The sturdy, eye-catching Minolta Weathermatic 35DL. 
 Inset top Braving the elements in Snowdonia, the line-up of cameras tested: (clockwise from top)  
 ESCAPES 
 COUNTRY LIVING  EXPLORES WILTSHIRE, WITH AND WITHOUT CHILDREN 
 BISHOPSTROW HOUSE, WARMINSTER 
 To spend a night at Bishopstrow House is to be pampered: it is elegant gracious, the warm, mosaicked swimming pool is often empty; and playing on the indoor tennis court makes you feel worthy of eating quantities. 
 And the bathrooms &mdash; of course every room has one &mdash; are so deep in soft, white towels that you could happily sleep there. 
 That's if you're an adult, and after all, this sort of English hotel is a very grown-up place. 
 We went with a two-year-old, which made things rather different. 
 He loved the swimming pool, revelled in the spacious gardens, and enjoyed the fact that other little ones were staying there. 
 In a place full of precious antiques, this shows great generosity by the management. 
 However, welcoming children and coping with them are quite separate qualities. 
 Two-year-olds generally cots and, though we had asked for one in advance, we were provided with a single bed which we had to surround with cushions to make it safe. 
 Children also tend to want honey or Marmite sandwiches for tea and, when they want tea, they really want it. 
 Sadly, there was no Marmite and no honey, we were told, and we'd have to wait at least 20 minutes. 
 However, once he was in bed, we felt pampered again. 
 There's a listening service via the telephone to let parents eat with peace of mind, and nothing could surpass the service in the dining room. 
 The waiters, and particularly the wine waiters, are so beautifully trained that you notice only their discretion and skill &mdash; you hardly even see them filling your glass or taking your plate. 
 They certainly never creep round to ask if everything is all right. 
 They must just be confident that it is. 
 Tender pigeon breast salad; smoked chicken spring roll; dry champagne sorbet; monkfish with basil and crispy ratatouille: all were prepared perfectly. 
 Bishopstrow House, near Warminster, Wiltshire, is the place for a treat, especially if you're leaving the children behind. 
 An off season break costs &pound;114 per person per night (minimum two nights) for dinner, bed and breakfast: call 0985&ndash;212312 for more details. 
  Katy Brown  
 THE SIGN OF THE ANGEL, LACOCK 
 Lacock is National Trust village whose idea of a modern house is one built in 1758. 
 Some date back to the 13th century, and The Sign of the Angel hotel was built in 1480 for a wool merchant. 
 The sanitation has improved since the merchant's time, but it's somewhere to treasure as much for what hasn't happened to it as for what has. 
 Though some of its flourishes are a little twee, the decor is mainly solid and unflamboyant, with chintz kept to a happy minimum. 
 It even has antique furniture that is used rather than just polished. 
 Tall claustrophobics won't like the hotel's narrow passageways, uneven floors, low ceilings and even lower beams, but everyone should love them. 
 All the bedrooms have private bathrooms. 
 The pleasantest is probably Room Three, which has a High-Spanish mahogany bed in it. 
 It once belonged to Isambard Kingdom Brunel and is extraordinarily large for a man so small. 
 Did he wear his hat in it? 
 The restaurant consists of a &bquo;little&equo; dining room bigger than the &bquo;big&equo; dining room, and a &bquo;sitting&equo; room that is a dining room, too. 
 The food is good &mdash; vegetables fresh from the hotel garden &mdash; but the choice is narrow: just one meat and one fish or vegetarian main course. 
 Silver cutlery, candlelight, linen napkins and unobtrusive service all encourage you to linger over your meal &mdash; and return soon for another. 
 Lacock and its presiding Angel are restful places to be in and it's easy to feel happy there doing very little. 
 The Hunting Lodge is good for teas and the Fox Talbot Museum has a collection of pictures by photographic pioneer William Henry Fox Talbot. 
 The oriel window shown in his earliest existing negative can be seen at the nearby Lacock Abbey. 
 If you do have the energy for some serious antiques-hunting, Bath is 12 miles away and Bradford on Avon around eight (see Antiques Trail, p134). 
 Double rooms with full breakfast are &pound;40 per person per night; dinner is from &pound;20 per person. 
 Contact The Sign of the Angel, Lacock, nr Chippenham, Wilts SN15 2LB (024973&ndash;230). 
  David Shannon  
 BOOKS 
 SAVE THESE HOUSES 
 A SERIES OF BOOKS HAS RESCUED HUNDREDS OF BUILDINGS FROM DERELICTION. 
 BY MARCUS BINNEY, FOUNDER OF SAVE BRITAIN'S HERITAGE 
 For all the gloom in the property market, there remains an insatiable demand for old buildings to restore and convert. 
 Every time SAVE Britain's Heritage publishes a new catalogue of historic buildings in need of new owners and new uses we are swamped with orders and enquiries. 
 Our latest hot seller is Nobody's Home , an illustrated catalogue of decaying buildings from cottages to castles, the sequel to last year's Empty Quarters . 
 An encouraging number of the properties in Empty Quarters  have already been snapped up. 
 Grove House in Bawtry, three 17th-century cottages combined as one house in the 18th century, has been bought and restored as a private house. 
 Lifford Manor, King's Norton, Warwickshire, has been acquired and refurbished as headquarters of accountants Pridie Langard. 
 Enquiries come from people who are retiring, are moving to the country, or simply want to restore buildings as a hobby. 
 And there are always builders looking for cheap properties to renovate. 
 An increasing number of calls come from people looking for start-up premises for small businesses. 
 Some have special requirements, like a playgroup looking for a church hall, or the woman who wanted a redundant church in Wales for a design company. 
 There is a big demand for craft workshops. 
 Our first catalogues on properties at risk concentrated on particular types of buildings such as country houses and churches. 
 Many had been decaying steadily for years: their owners had no use for them and could not imagine that anyone else would. 
 Two things have changed this situation. 
 First, planning authorities have gradually begun to use their powers to serve legally enforceable notices requiring owners to carry out repairs to seriously neglected listed buildings. 
 Where listed buildings stand empty and completely abandoned they are able to carry out emergency work themselves and send the bills to the owners. 
 Initially they hesitated to do this because owners are entitled to respond with a purchase notice requiring the council to buy the building, potentially landing ratepayers with a large bill for restoration. 
 In fact, there is almost always someone keen to take over a neglected historic building, so when a council serves a repairs notice, or the planning committee sends a warning letter, the owners tend to realise there may be some value in the property and either sell it or repair it themselves. 
 Secondly, the sheer number of enquiries generated by people who have bought our reports often persuade owners to sell. 
 And there are now enough successful examples of sympathetically restored buildings to convince owners that restoration is feasible. 
 When we published our reports on country houses at risk ( Tomorrow's Ruins, Silent Mansions  and Endangered Domains ) we found that within two years up to two-thirds of the houses had found new owners or new uses. 
 Happily, these include some of the most desperate cases, like Borringdon, a once-magnificent Elizabethan house outside Plymouth which was no more than a gutted shell clinging to a precipice, but today is a comfortable country house hotel. 
 Llangoed Castle, in Wales, which the owner had been determined to demolish, has just been transformed into a hotel by Sir Bernard Ashley, husband of Laura. 
 Palladian Belford, in Northumberland, has been restored as flats by one of the Sainsbury family trusts. 
 Regency Grovelands, in Middlesex, another neglected wreck, is now a private nursing home. 
 The most recent of these reports on major historic properties is Scotland's Endangered Houses . 
 While there will be strong demand for almost any large house in England if it is in an attractive setting, however remote, in Scotland there are dozens of truly spectacular castles and mansions in varying states of decay. 
 In Scotland, unlike England, rates were charged on empty buildings and many owners simply took the roof off to avoid the levy. 
 Because many of these houses were little known, or stood unseen at the end of long drives, there was no pressure to repair them. 
 One of SAVE's most important groups of publications aims to give architects a developers a clear set of principles to adopt in dealing with particular types of buildings. 
 The first was The Country House: To Be or Not To Be , produced with Kit Martin. 
 He has successfully rescued a whole series of major houses, without a penny of historic buildings grants, by adapting them as self-contained houses and cottages. 
 His winning formula has been to restore the houses in stages, a wing at a time: they are so attractive and such good value that they almost invariably sell before they are completed. 
 His principle is to maintain the gardens and grounds as they are for all the residents, so that from outside it is not apparent that the building has been divided up. 
 Inside, he has always found that the people who buy the bigger houses like one or two very large rooms, while the stables and service wings at the back make smaller cottages for people working locally. 
 Churches: A Question of Conversion  was produced with Derek Latham, an architect who specialises in historic buildings and runs his practice from a skilfully adapted church in Derby. 
 One of the most ingenious examples illustrated is St Luke's, in Harrogate, a handsome Victorian church on a prominent street corner, which has been transformed almost imperceptibly into 29 flats by a housing association. 
 A Future for Farm Buildings  by Gillian Darley shows that, for all the controversy over their conversions, barns can be sympathetically transformed for a range of uses. 
 The latest of SAVE's publications is Bright Future: The Re-Use of Industrial Buildings , written with the architect Francis Machin, who is best known for his futuristic conservatories, but whose conversions include the transformation of my own barn into a library and office. 
 Here we illustrated numerous dramatic conversions of warehouses and textile mills whose open-plan layouts made them adaptable for virtually any purpose. 
 For those with a taste for the unusual and exotic, Pavilions in Peril  remains not only an engaging armchair read, but an explorer's guide to a forgotten world of follies and garden temples. 
 The key to the success of SAVE's publications, and indeed our message as a whole, is conveyed in one word: photographs. 
 The reason we receive massive newspaper publicity for reports like Empty Quarters  and Nobody's Home  is that every property is illustrated. 
 When SAVE was launched in 1975, good photographs of endangered buildings were very scarce, but with today's improved methods of printing we can use any reasonable snapshot we are sent. 
 And thanks to the sophistication of modern cameras and film, automatic light metres and focusing, even the most inexperienced photographer can take a usable and very helpful picture. 
 So next time you see a decaying barn or cottage, stop the car, take a snap or two, and send them to SAVE with the name and address of the property. 
 For remarkably little effort, you may have saved an endangered building.  
 Above Little Potash, Potash Lane, Bracon Ash, near Norwich. 
 A privately owned half-timbered cottage (mostly 16th-century) with pantiled roof and porches, it has been standing empty for years 
 Right Hever Lodge, Reginald Road, Maidstone, Kent, was built in 1851. 
 Though sadly neglected, it has retained its asymmetrical grandeur and architectural riches: crow-stepped gables, fish-scale slate roof, arched windows with hoodmoulds, two-storey loggia and stair turret 
 DANGER MALE DRIVERS 
 YOU'VE HEARD THE JOKES: NOW READ THE FACTS. 
 FRANK PAGE EXAMINES THE MYTHS ABOUT DIFFERENCES BETWEEN MEN AND WOMEN BEHIND THE WHEEL 
 A friend of mine was driving on the M1 when he came up behind everybody's un-favourite motorist, the one who sits resolutely in the middle land and refuses to move left, no matter how empty the inside lane. 
 &bquo;I gave him a quick flash of my headlights and he immediately slammed on his brakes,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;So I thought if he were that kind of driver I would not get involved. 
 I pulled over and just cruised past him. 
 But he was incensed; he came alongside me and started making all sorts of threatening gestures. 
 &bquo;Eventually I got a bit fed up. 
 The kids had been in the car and there was a water pistol on the shelf under the dash. 
 I picked it up and aimed it at him. 
 He went as white as a sheet and backed off immediately. 
 Now I'm waiting for the police to call, following up a report that there's some madman loose on the M1, threatening to shoot other drivers.&equo; 
 This story took my mind back to a survey on driving that was published a while ago on the differences between men and women behind the wheel. 
 One of more than 1,000 women drivers taking part said, &bquo;Men have to be good at everything, especially driving&hellip; it's a big ego thing.&equo; 
 There certainly seems to be a significant polarisation between the sexes in their approach to driving. 
 The popular folklore emphasises it. 
 Jokes about men driving are mostly on the macho theme: &bquo;Men love a fast and powerful car, especially painted red &mdash; it's a virility symbol.&equo; 
 But jokes about women drivers (always told by men) are about hanging a handbag on the pulled-out choke or never being able to use the rear-view mirror because it's always positioned for make-up repairs. 
 Yet women drivers have the last laugh. 
 They get cheaper insurance rates because their accident records are better; they have fewer problems with their cars because they don't thrash them; and they probably expend far less nervous energy when they are driving, because they treat it like any other domestic activity. 
 &bquo;Basically, we are just much more tolerant than men,&equo; says Judith Jackson, one of the tiny minority of female motoring correspondents &mdash; she writes for The Guardian  and Homes &amp; Gardens . 
 &bquo;Women are less likely to react violently in a stressful situation. 
 We're more patient, too. 
 Women will wait much longer at an intersection rather than take a risk. 
 It drives men mad, but it's the sensible thing to do. 
 We generally look upon cars as tools of our trade, so we treat them sensibly and carefully. 
 I would sum it up by saying cars are for work, not for worship.&equo; 
 Many women drivers seem to agree with Judith. 
 The survey, sponsored by General Accident Insurance, found that more than 60 per cent of female respondents complained of male aggressiveness on the road. 
 Male drivers' arrogance is almost as bad as their aggression, it seems. 
 One in nine of the women surveyed reckoned that male drivers &bquo;think they own the road&equo; and nearly three-quarters of them said men were too impatient. 
 Recent Government statistics seem to bear this out. 
 The number of male drivers killed in road accidents rose by 25 per cent in the first quarter of 1990, a fact blamed by the Automobile Association on increasingly aggressive driving by men. 
 There was little change in the number of female deaths. 
 The problem is that arrogance and aggression are often expressed at the expense of other road users. 
 Female respondents also complained that men drive too fast and are often very discourteous to others. 
 Sue Baker, Observer  motoring correspondent, has a theory: &bquo;So often, when driving on a motorway, you see strings of cars in the outside lane, driving too fast and too close, the drivers trying to intimidate one another. 
 But you seldom see a woman driver mixed up in it. 
 &bquo;I did a television report about how the traffic police in Germany take pictures of cars being driven dangerously, in order to prosecute the drivers later. 
 This policeman was saying, &bquo;He does this,&equo; and &bquo;He overtakes dangerously.&equo; 
 I said: &bquo;Hand on a minute &mdash; you keep talking about men. 
 How often do you prosecute women?&equo; 
 He replied, &bquo;Almost never &mdash; they just don't do it.&equo;&equo; 
 Does this battle of the sexes on the motorways affect country roads, too? 
 Talking to some of my friends, it seems to be a universal problem. 
 Beth Llewellin lives near Ellesmere in Shropshire, and goes there for family shopping. 
 &bquo;We park on the road, which is convenient, and usually people are very good about taking their turn to get into an empty space. 
 But sometimes I get cut up by another vehicle as I go for a space &mdash; and it's always a man.&equo; 
 Avril Boyd, who lives in Clare, Cambridgeshire, has trouble with male drivers, too. 
 &bquo;There are a lot of pretty well-off farmers round our way, driving things like Range Rovers,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;They are all a bit &bquo;Out of my way &mdash; I'm king of the road&equo;. 
 Then we get the young yobs, driving souped-up Minis and Capris. 
 They drive like maniacs and totally without discipline. 
 It seems to be particularly bad in the country, because we are inadequately policed. 
 These guys seem to think all speed limits are there to be broken and they just don't believe they will ever be caught.&equo; 
 But that's all about male and female attitudes. 
 Are there physical or temperamental differences that make men better drivers, or vice versa? 
 The General Accident survey makes a telling point. 
 Asking both men and women how many times they took the driving test before getting through, the researchers found that men had a significantly higher success rate, with 57 per cent passing at the first attempt. 
 For the women the figure was 47 per cent &mdash; though another 33 per cent got through second time. 
 Whether this indicates that men are more adept at driving, or simply more confident about the test, is open to debate. 
 Perhaps the most significant figures in the survey are those indicating the characteristics that men and women see in drivers of the opposite sex. 
 The women showed their distrust of men at the wheel by citing all sorts of objections. 
 &bquo;Impatient&equo; was the key word &mdash; noted by 74 per cent of respondents, followed by &bquo;too fast&equo;, &bquo;aggressive&equo;, &bquo;arrogant&equo; and &bquo;discourteous&equo;. 
 The men responded with contrary characteristics for women. 
 &bquo;Over-careful&equo; was almost the top-scoring quality &mdash; with 48 per cent of men choosing it, and nearly as many following up with &bquo;indecisive&equo; and &bquo;too slow&equo;. 
 But &mdash; and this is the nub of the matter &mdash; the highest score in the list of women's driving qualities, as rated by men, was for &bquo;safe&equo; &mdash; 54 per cent. 
 And, really, isn't that what driving is all about? 
 LETTERS 
 Do write with views and news of your own country living 
 COMMUNITY SPIRIT? 
 How I disagree with P R Owen's views on the community charge (December, 1990, Letters). 
 Every family needs, and has a right to, a place to live in: no one needs  a second home, except perhaps MPs. 
 For anyone else this is a self-indulgent luxury. 
 Those with a second home should pay at least double the community charge for the area, then they would be making some recompense for taking up properties that could be used for people who need them. 
  P M Smith, Denbigh, Clwyd  
 My reaction to P R Owen's having to sell his weekend cottage is good riddance. 
 We have recently moved to an area of Norfolk that is infested with holiday homes: our village is rendered lifeless for half the year, and local people find it impossible to afford homes because prices have been forced up by the greater buying power of outsiders. 
 We ourselves are to some extent part of this problem, but we do at least live and work in the village full time. 
 The only local people who live in the village live in cottages tied to the estate, and many cottages lie empty for most of the year while the number of rural homeless grows. 
 The one good effect of the poll tax may be that it forces the sale of these empty properties to people who will breathe new life into half-dead communities. 
  John Woodcock, Kelling, Norfolk  
 DIVINING WORKS WONDERS 
 I was most interested in your article on water divining (November 1990) because I was asked to practise this art in Africa many years ago. 
 I used a forked stick &mdash; usually willow &mdash; and was very successful in finding water 20&ndash;40 feet below ground level. 
 The fork would twist in my hands and cause blisters, as Donovan Wilkins described. 
 All sorts of theories to explain the phenomenon have been advanced, but as far as I am concerned, it works. 
  G A W Partridge, Preston, Lancashire  
 STYLE ON A SHOESTRING 
 &bquo;Discontent and feelings of inadequacy&equo;? 
 (Ann Jacob's letter, November 1990). 
 Come now, a little imagination and subtle poaching of the ideas of Country Living  's more affluent readers is all that is required. 
 Inspired by pictures of grand herb gardens, I grew some herbs from seeds and cuttings, to set up my own herb garden in front of our semi-detached house. 
 An old, renovated Victorian cast-iron pump provides a centrepiece. 
 It has now become a challenge to find new varieties of herb &mdash; at the last count there were just over 130. 
 My tiny kitchen has been given a rustic look by hanging up a hop bine from a farm, and a string of onions (99p) adds the finishing touch. 
 Let those spend fortunes on their homes who can afford it: the same look can often be achieved more economically. 
  June Lewis, Bolton, Lancashire  
 HOOKED ON COUNTRY LIVING 
 I confess! 
 I am a country living junkie and my appetite for magazines devoted to country life is insatiable. 
 There is no praise high enough for December's Country Living , surely the best Christmas magazine produced last year. 
 It is difficult to decide which article was best, for every one was superbly written, with wit and an ever-vigilant eye to detail. 
 This is what makes the magazine rare. 
 Your writers allow their subjects full throttle, letting them shine through the pages as the great characters they have become (witness Marwood Yeatman, Sheila Kitzinger et al). 
 Brian Redhead's page will be read to my five-year-old daughter and my husband on Christmas Day. 
 Mr Redhead could bring God to the godless: his article brought tears to my eyes. 
 Rosemary Verey's way of writing about gardening fills me (new to gardening and not very good at it) with inspiration and pleasure. 
 I spent much of my childhood in the New Forest and have watched with sadness as it has deteriorated over the decades. 
 My sympathies are with Marwood Yeatman, who has the right perspective on life and whose lifestyle I am now gaining myself. 
  Chlo&euml; Powell, Wrexham, Clwyd  
 THE PRINCE &amp; THE POTTER 
 Having been aware of only detrimental media coverage of Prince Charles, I was heartened to read your profile in the January issue, which concentrated on his varied contribution to British life, especially his involvement with the conservation of the countryside. 
 Two years ago a young potter friend, Vivienne Newton, benefited from the Prince's Trust. 
 She was able to make herself a pottery workshop by joining two old telephone engineers' caravans together, and now works from her father's market garden near Livingston. 
 She would have had great difficulty establishing herself, but as it is she has sold her pottery successfully through shows and through galleries. 
 I would like to commend you for the support you give to rural artists and craftspeople, through your excellent articles &mdash; especially at a time when, due to cuts in grants, such people need all the help they can get. 
  Jenny Proctor, Longriddry, East Lothian  
 YOUR PROBLEM SOLVED 
 FRAME WORK 
 I have several old silver photograph frames, whose &bquo;innards&equo; have worn out so the frames no longer stand properly. 
 Is there a company that would make new frames using my silver surrounds? 
  William Fullick, London E12  
 There is a firm in Birmingham that should be able to help. 
 Hampton Utilities is a member of the British Jewellers Association, and its skilled craftsmen can carry out all sorts of repairs to silverware, antique and modern, including cutlery, candlesticks, mirrors and regimental medals. 
 Send the photograph frames by registered post to Hampton Utilities (Birmingham) Ltd, 15 Pitsford Street, Hockley, Birmingham B18 6LJ (021&ndash;554 1766), explaining what needs to be done: the company will then give you a quotation for the work. 
 Those who live nearby can take in items for repair, but the company will also accept commissions from overseas &mdash; even as far away as Australia. 
 For advice on any aspect of country living, write to Letters at the address on page 2. 
 We can answer only problems printed on this page. 
 MY COUNTRY CHILDHOOD 
 Hannah Hauxwell 
 I was three years old when we moved across the dale to Low Birk Hatt Farm. 
 There isn't any other place I would describe as home. 
 To me there is nowhere like it and never will be. 
 It was my life and my world. 
 I did not appreciate how beautiful the countryside was until I was much older. 
 As a child, I just enjoyed it. 
 The house was at the bottom of a valley near the reservoir, surrounded by rolling hills. 
 There were green fields as far as the eye could see. 
 But inside the house it was a different story; there wasn't much space at all. 
 Grandma and Granddad slept in one bedroom; Mother, Father and I in the other; and my two great-uncles slept downstairs. 
 My father had bought the farm at an auction, at what turned out to be an inflated price. 
 As he was the only able-bodied man on the farm, it was a constant struggle for him to make the mortgage payments. 
 My mother had her hands full with housework and caring for four elderly people. 
 I did little bits to help, like picking up sticks for firewood and fetching water from the well, as we didn't have any electricity or running water. 
 I also helped with the milking but was very slow. 
 I started using one hand and it was ages before I learnt to use two. 
 As I was the only child, the animals were my playmates. 
 We had sheep, cows, horses, dogs and pigs. 
 The pigs were my favourites. 
 Most people think that pigs are dirty and ignorant, but I had many happy times with them. 
 I used to love cleaning them out. 
 I had my own shovel with a broken handle. 
 I was even allowed to look after two piglets on my own; they were very intelligent and affectionate. 
 But I didn't get to the point of giving them names, which was just as well, because in the end they both had to go to market. 
 When I wasn't with the animals I spent hours playing with my favourite toy, a large piece of wood which I pretended was our horse, Dicks. 
 I also had two dollies, one made for me by our great family friend, Mrs Fawcett, the other stitched by my mother from an old piece of quilted petticoat. 
 Sometimes I would make a house out of the large old boxes stacked in the yard, and take in my dollies and set up home. 
 I was perfectly happy until I was sent to school at the age of five. 
 I was very shy and not the sharpest of children. 
 I didn't make friends easily, but the funny thing is that some of those I went to school with, and wasn't so close to, have become good friends in later life. 
 There were 30 pupils of different ages in one room, with one blackboard and one teacher. 
 She didn't take to me; I don't know why. 
 She certainly had her favourites, which is only natural, but she shouldn't have shown it. 
 To be fair, she was a good-hearted woman who tried to do her best. 
 But to this day I have nightmares in which I have to go back to school, and I'm so relieved to wake up and find that it was only a dream. 
 The best time was in the winter when the snow was so bad I couldn't walk the mile across the fields to school. 
 Sometimes on a winter afternoon it would start coming in and get so black you couldn't see. 
 When that happened we were all sent home early. 
 When I was seven my father died. 
 He was only 36. 
 He was such a nice man, very quiet and reserved. 
 That was a terrible time. 
 It meant that my mother's workload greatly increased, but with my uncles' help we struggled on. 
 At least we had each other. 
 But it also meant that when I left school at 14 it was not possible to think about finding a job or life away from the farm. 
 I was needed there. 
 Some of my happiest memories date from the time when Father was alive. 
 One summer, just the three of us, Mother, Father and I, set off together to start the haymaking two miles away, at a parcel of land we owned down the road. 
 We left the older ones to look after the farm and we took the horses. 
 There were lots of wild roses and foxgloves growing in the lane and you could smell the hawthorn. 
 We spent several nights there in a derelict house without a roof. 
 Those summer nights will stay with me for ever, with the moon illuminating the darkness and the birds calling to each other in the trees at sunset. 
 Everything came to life in the summer with the warm weather and long days. 
 Most of all, I remember the summer flowers. 
 Granddad was a gardener and grew some very nice flowers in the garden as well as all our fruit and vegetables. 
 We had marguerites, daisies, pansies and wallflowers. 
 But the best were his rose bushes, a type you don't often see now. 
 They were white with a lovely pink blush when in bud, and had the most powerful scent. 
 I have never come across anything like them again, although I haven't seen very many gardens. 
 My mother, Grandma and I sometimes took some of my grandfather's produce to market in Barnard Castle. 
 This meant taking the market bus, which was a great adventure for me. 
 Sometimes we did well, sometimes we didn't; the prices were not up to much. 
 But I remember being happy just staring at all the people passing by. 
 My childhood memories were a great source of strength to me after the members of my family died, one by one, and I was left to work the farm alone. 
 My mother was a great inspiration; she was such a lovely jolly little lady, with precious little to be jolly about. 
 Now, I try not to think too much about those days. 
 I had to leave Low Birk Hatt two years ago and move into the village, five miles away. 
 I have a new life now and new friends. 
 But my 60 years at the farm were the best part of my life, and in spirit I am still there. 
  Interview by Alison Nadel  
 Daughter of the Dales  by Hannah Hauxwell and Barry Cockcroft is published by Century (&pound;14.99)  
 Hannah Hauxwell (right) with her mother 
 RECIPES 
 Eastwell Manor's Mark Clayton 
 BALBIRNIE HOUSE 
 Fife hospitality 
 DEEP FAT FRYERS 
 Latest developments 
 CATERER &amp; Hotelkeeper 
 NEWS 
 OPINION 
 GREEN LIGHT FOR BHRCA REVAMP 
 JUDGE QUASHES FOOD HYGIENE FINES 
 DIET ADVICE IGNORED 
 REPORT SLAMS &bquo;HAZARDOUS&equo; POOLS 
 STAKIS STRONGMAN Stakis chairman Sir Lewis Robertson tells of his plans for the group 
 INTERNATIONAL Salomon Brothers report predicts recovery for European hotels, but not until the end of 1991 
 LETTERS 
 JOE HYAM On customer service 
 VIEWPOINT Michael Raffael appreciates a good bed &amp; breakfast 
 PEOPLE Whitbread chairman announces intention to retire in 1992 
 BUSINESS 
 VENTURE CAPITAL TURNS TO LEISURE 
 PROPERTY Equity dries up for hotels 
 FOOD PRICES 
 CAREERS &amp; TRAINING London's Springboard career centre is a success, but continuing support is needed 
 TECHNOLOGY Generating and controlling your own power 
 AWARDS Sutcliffe announces Indian day regional winner 
 COVER STORY 
 RECIPES FROM EASTWELL MANOR Mark Clayton produces intricate dishes with a large number of ingredients 
 FEATURES 
 MENUS Frances Bissell comments on a menu in honour of Bernard Gaume, and another for Prince Charles' Youth Business Trust 
 MARKETING MAGIC Balbirnie House, Fife, established more than 50% occupancy during its first 18 months, due to carefully targeted marketing 
 JAIL BREAK A profile of the catering system at HM Prison Pentonville, North London 
 LIGHT AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL Third of our four-part report on Tricon Foodservice Consultants' advice to the ailing Valley Hotel, Ironbridge, Shropshire 
 WHAT'S NEW 
 LIQUID ASSETS Brian Jordan takes a close look at the increasingly professional wines of England 
 FRIED AND TESTED Research into frying technology means deep-fat fryers are becoming more cost-effective 
 COUNCIL PUBLISHES FOOD SAFETY CODES 
 FOOD 
 EQUIPMENT 
 CLASSIFIED 
 YOUR NEXT MOVE: ALL THE BEST JOBS AND PROPERTY 
 NEXT WEEK 
 WEALTH FROM HEALTH The surge of interest in healthy lifestyles means big business for health farms 
 FISH &amp; SIPS &mdash; MATCHING FISH WITH WINE (below)   
 Balbirnie House in Fife. 
 See page 38 
 OPINION 
 Speaking in harmony 
 In recent months there has been a lively debate &mdash; much of it behind the scenes &mdash; into how the hospitality industry can speak more effectively to Government. 
 A new committee, the Joint Hospitality Industry Congress, is being formed for this purpose by the British Hotels, Restaurants and Caterers Association (BHRCA), see page 8. 
 However, much misunderstanding surrounds the nature of the so-called &bquo;one voice&equo; campaign which Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper  has been instrumental in promoting. 
 Now, on the eve of the formation of the congress, is a good time to clear up any misapprehensions. 
 People have been talking about finding &bquo;one voice&equo; for the industry for many years. 
 There was good reason for this: when Government ministers want to test opinion in a particular sector, they normally turn to a single trade body, such as the National Farmers Union, the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, or the Retail Consortium. 
 But while the BHRCA speaks for many companies and individuals, it does not represent everyone, or even every sector, and is sometimes at odds with the views of other bodies. 
 But even if ministers have the time to canvass views from a multitude of different organisations, there is a risk that the hospitality sector's views will be ignored by Government when too many diverse and conflicting responses are made. 
 While the industry desperately needs to present a more united front to Government and the public, a single voice does not mean the loudest voice, which can drown contrary views. 
 It should be a powerful voice, united where possible, but if there are disagreements there should be no attempt to pretend otherwise. 
 The BHRCA is to be applauded for taking the initiative on this issue, but if the joint congress is to receive the whole-hearted support of other leading organisations, it is important that no single &bquo;lead organisation&equo; should take ownership. 
 Its success will depend on the active participation of many other bodies, large and small. 
 Only in this way can the industry's &bquo;one voice&equo; be in harmony rather than unison. 
  CATERER &amp; Hotelkeeper   
 NEWS 
 SCHOOL MEALS 
 School meals need to be marketed to school children in the same way that brewers market themselves, Theo Goldberg, managing director of marketing firm IMCOT, recently told the Local Authority Caterers Association annual conference. 
 Mr Goldberg said that after adopting a consumer-style approach to marketing, both Norfolk and Surrey County Councils had seen increased use of the school meal service. 
 Norfolk had recorded a 6% increase or &pound;100,000 in sales. 
 Both councils used the services of BBC Food and Drink  presenter Michael Barry for publicity campaigns. 
 He also devised new menus. 
 DORCHESTER STARS 
 The Dorchester in London has celebrated its 60th anniversary by regaining its AA, five-red-star rating. 
 The association has inspected the refurbished hotel three times since its reopening and, according to the AA's Albert Hampson, it is &bquo;even better than before&equo;. 
 The Dorchester is one of only seven hotels to have five red stars. 
 GUIDE'S AWARD 
 Egon Ronay's Cellnet Guide to Hotels and Restaurants  will next year feature a Chef of the Year Award for the first time. 
 Andrew Eliel, editor of the guide, said the award had been launched because it was felt the best chef did not necessarily work in the best restaurant. 
 DEMAND DOWN 
 Demand for accommodation in central London's five-star hotels fell by 5.1% in 1990 compared with 1989, according to a study from consultancy Hospitality Valuation Services. 
 The report predicts 1991 will see further declines in occupancy and achieved room rates. 
 BHA 
 Under a new name, the BHRCA is set to give the industry the single voice it demands. 
 Richard Gordon reports 
 In possibly its shortest annual general meeting on record &mdash; a mere 26 minutes &mdash; the British Hotels, Restaurants &amp; Caterers Association (BHRCA) last week voted to change its name to the British Hospitality Association (BHA). 
 The name change, which will officially happen in January 1992, had been expected since the association took delivery of a weighty industry assessment from Saatchi &amp; Saatchi last summer. 
 The agency's report suggested a new name would help to improve the image of the BHRCA, and would take advantage of public goodwill towards the hospitality industry in the UK. 
 Forte chief executive Rocco Forte, who was elected unopposed as first president of the BHRCA, told the AGM at London's Inn on the Park that the new name &bquo;is more appropriate for the challenges we will face in the future&equo;. 
 &bquo;It signals change to the outside world and will help create a new image for the association which better reflects the more aggressive stance which we intend to take,&equo; Mr Forte said. 
 The change was welcomed by BHRCA members and, although there was no debate at the AGM before the vote, many spoke afterwards of earlier vigorous debates in the committees which make up the BHRCA. 
 Alistair Borthwick, vice-chairman of the East Anglia Divisional committee, who is also a farmer and member of the National Farmers Union (NFU), said the name change would help to improve membership. 
 &bquo;The NFU is well known for representing farmers, and it's necessary for the BHA to be easily understood as representing the hospitality industry in all its forms,&equo; he said. 
 The AGM also decided to radically alter the structure of the BHRCA. 
 Out will go the National Council, Board of Management and Council of Chairmen. 
 In will be a single body called the National Executive with representatives from the regional divisions and industry sector panels. 
 For the first time this will give contract caterers direct access to the BHRCA management. 
 It will also create a link between the finance committee and what was the Board of Management. 
 SINGLE VOICE 
 A recent survey of BHRCA members found they had joined principally because they wanted an effective voice to put the industry's case to Government. 
 Mr Forte said the present trading difficulties had at least one benefit &mdash; in drawing the Government's attention to the industry. 
 &bquo;Even with a Government committed to free enterprise, we have faced problems in the past 12 months. 
 Business rates up 30%, VAT increases and a statutory minimum wage increase of 10%, when most of us are on a pay freeze. 
 &bquo;If our contribution &lsqb;to the economy&rsqb; is not fully understood, we will face even bigger threats, regardless of which party is in power,&equo; he warned. 
 In its new form, the BHRCA is determined to lead the hospitality industry in its attempts to head off these &bquo;threats&equo; and further challenges from Brussels. 
 Mr Forte admitted that while the BHRCA was the largest industry association, there were other groups which had a &bquo;legitimate claim to speak for certain sectors of the industry&equo;. 
 He issued a call for other industry bodies to join the BHRCA on a committee, called the Joint Hospitality Industry Congress. 
 &bquo;The aim is to draw together the various industry bodies so we can discuss issues of common interest. 
 It is very rare that we disagree as an industry, but it is equally rare that we speak in a co-ordinated way,&equo; he said. 
 While Mr Forte had reservations about the lengthy name of the congress, he hoped it would lead to a structure which should enable the industry to speak with a single voice on many issues.  
 Chefs peak at summit 
 Long hours and tough working conditions are often par for the course in catering. 
 But Alan Brazier, head chef of Westminster's QEII Centre catering operation, took even normal levels to new extremes during last week's G7 economic summit. 
 Over the summit's four days the centre was home to 4,000 journalists and media staff, who were served more than 42,000 meals. 
 Mr Brazier and his senior staff, including deputy head chef Kevin Glasby (above) and senior sous chef Nick Bryan, worked virtually around the clock, pausing only for three hours sleep before starting again at 5am. 
 But Mr Brazier gave an unhesitating &bquo;yes&equo; when asked if he would go through the experience again. 
 Media folk munched their way through &pound;100,000-worth of food, including 940lb of smoked salmon, 5,000lb of cheese, 1,300lb of beef rib, 17,280 eggs and 16 gallons of baby squid and octopus. 
 &bull;At Lancaster House, where the heads of state held their historic talks, the catering was carried out by Essex-based Crown Catering Group. 
 PPL cracks down on illegal music 
 Music played in many hotels and restaurants is being played illegally, according to Phonographic Performance Limited (PPL), the company which issues one of the two licences necessary to play pre-recorded music. 
 The PPL licence is required by anyone using commercial sound recordings on their premises, in addition to the licence issued by the Performing Rights Society (PRS). 
 A spokesman for PPL said that many hoteliers and restaurateurs believe that they only need a licence from the PRS to be fully covered. 
 The PRS licence protects the copyright of the songwriter/composer, while the PPL licence protects the copyright of the recording. 
 Not all music requires both licences. 
 A recording of Mozart, for example, requires only a PPL licence. 
 It does not need a PRS licence as copyright exists for only 50 years. 
 Out of 700 cases that the PPL took to court last year, it is thought that as many as 100 could have been brought against hotels or restaurants. 
 PPL issues two kinds of licence, one for background music and one where music is a featured attraction, such as a discotheque or dance. 
 The PPL licence for background music costs &pound;65.80 a year, but will rise in September to &pound;69.92 (including VAT). 
 FINES 
 David Newham, head of general licensing at PPL, warned the industry that buying a licence was cheaper in the long term, as fines could be between &pound;800 and &pound;1,000. 
 In June the British Hotels, Restaurants &amp; Caterers Association (BHRCA) finally reached an agreement over revised tariffs with the PRS (see Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper , 27 June&ndash;3 July). 
 Mr Newham explained that the BHRCA, Brewers Society and the National Licensed Victuallers Association entered into discussions with PPL over revising their tariffs, but the BHRCA withdrew, requesting separate negotiations. 
 One of the problems for the BHRCA was that more than one PPL licence may be needed; for example, if the same music is played in the bar and reception, and both are self-contained. 
 Mr Newham said the PPL would have &bquo;no qualms&equo; about seeking redress from those who consistently ignored them, but added: &bquo;If you were to apply for a licence today we could be lenient about past fees.&equo; 
 The PPL recently commissioned Gallup to carry out a survey of the benefits of recorded music. 
 It found that four out of five publicans and restaurateurs in the survey agreed it was good for business, and four out of five managers said recorded music made customers stay longer. 
 &bull;The Performing Right Society (PRS) has won a High Court action to prevent the owner of the Miramar Hotel, Blackpool, Lancashire, from operating a television in the hotel lounge. 
 An officer from the PRS had visited the hotel and heard a copyright-protected piece of music being played on the TV for which the hotel had no PRS licence. 
 The case was brought by the PRS after the hotelier, John Hill, refused requests by the society to take out a &pound;58 public performance licence. 
 The hotelier was ordered by the court to cease using the TV in the lounge and to pay the cost of the case, expected to run into thousands of pounds.  
 Kevin Glasby in action at the QEII Centre 
 LONDON WARNING 
 Vice-President of the London Tourist Board (LTB), Lord Pitt of Hampstead, has called for a London-wide authority to plan and co-ordinate development in the capital. 
 At the LTB's annual meeting last week, Lord Pitt said London was being undermined as a tourist attraction by a &bquo;lack of some kind of co-ordinating body, able to promote the capital and fight for its best interests&equo;. 
 London's position was threatened by foreign competition and the rising international profile of cities such as Birmingham and Glasgow, warned Lord Pitt. 
 &bquo;Unless there is a serious change of attitude, being the capital will not be a strong enough magnet to draw people to London.&equo; 
 RUSSIAN VISIT 
 A delegation from Europe's largest hotel, the Izmailovo in Moscow, recently visited the Moat House International Hotel, Glasgow, to see for themselves the operating standards of a western hotel. 
 The Izmailovo, which has 5,000 bedrooms is about to undergo a three-year, &pound;20m refurbishment to enable it to compete in the international business and tourism travel market. 
 The delegation looked at a range of hotel operations including food preparation, customer care programmes, sales and marketing and budgeting. 
 The Izmailovo will be visited next year by a team from the Scottish Hotel School. 
 MOSCOW HOLD 
 A downturn in trade has forced London restaurateur Amin Ali, owner of Jamdani and the Red Fort, to put on hold his plans to open a restaurant in Moscow. 
 But he quashed rumours that the Red Fort had been quietly put up for sale due to his financial difficulties. 
 Multi-tenant scheme for Heal's 
 Catering &amp; Allied Services has broken the mould of contract catering in the UK with the introduction of a scheme which allows different companies in one building to share full-service staff restaurant facilities. 
 The company, which has 80 staff restaurant contracts, now operates the Heal's building in London's Tottenham Court Road as its first UK multi-tenanted scheme, which it pioneered in the Netherlands. 
 It already ran the staff restaurant at Heal's when retail conglomerate Storehouse occupied the entire building, but the opportunity to introduce the multi-tenant system presented itself following the departure of Conran Design. 
 The system means that all companies within a building have access to a staff restaurant facility without the cost of installing their own kitchen and restaurant. 
 John Houston, managing director of Catering &amp; Allied, said the benefits of the scheme were particularly relevant in a recession where companies were trying to hold down costs. 
 Peter Mountfield of TCR Properties, the company which manages the Heal's building, said the availability of staff restaurant facilities had also been a useful marketing tool to potential tenants. 
 The price of space in the building includes use of the facility. 
 City caterer High Table &mdash; a subsidiary of the French Group Elitair, which has multi-tenant schemes in France &mdash; is also looking at this type of operation.  
 Three hundred years of catering for the City of London were celebrated by Ring &amp; Brymer at the Museum of London last week. 
 Boar's head and jugged hare were among the contemporary dishes served in front of the company's original 18th-century shop front in Cornhill, which now stands in the museum. 
 At the time, the company was called Birch &amp; Birch. 
 It was 1837 that it became Ring &amp; Brymer, an entity retained by Lord Forte when he took over the company in 1962. 
 The company holds the distinction of having catered for every Coronation Banquet since George III came to the throne in 1760. 
 JUDGE QUASHES FOOD HYGIENE FINES 
 by Dom Walsh 
 A Cambridge caf&eacute; owner has won an appeal against a &pound;13,500 fine imposed last month under Food Hygiene Regulations, after the judge accepted that she did not have the money to pay it. 
 Julia Pledger, owner/director of Fitzbillies, took her case to Cambridge Crown Court after she was fined &pound;900 on each of 15 counts ( Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper , 30 May&ndash;5 June). 
 The court accepted the seriousness of the offences, but felt that a fine of &pound;5,000 would have been more appropriate. 
 However, even that figure was waived after the court heard that Ms Pledger had no realistic chance of being able to pay. 
 She was obliged only to pay court costs of &pound;400. 
 Since the offences were first reported, Ms Pledger's business has gone into receivership and Fitzbillies is now in the process of being refurbished under new management. 
 But Cambridge City Council's environmental health department warned that the success of the appeal did not set a precedent, and that the court had been careful to reiterate its concern at the &bquo;grave breaches of the Food Hygiene Regulations&equo;. 
 The judge was moved to comment that if any customer had seen the photographs used in evidence against Ms Pledger, they would have immediately stopped patronising Fitzbillies. 
 Geoff Keerie, assistant city environmental health officer, said the council was disappointed with the result of the appeal, but that it was content that the threat of a serious risk to public health had been removed. 
 &bquo;We are satisfied that &lsqb;Ms Pledger&rsqb; is no longer in the food trade and putting customers at risk, which after all, is our priority reason for doing this work,&equo; he said. 
 Original fines had included one of &pound;900 for a cracked wooden spoon. 
 Other offences included not having a bar of soap on a wash basin and no &bquo;Now Wash Your Hands&equo; sign on the wall and having a cracked marble worktop. 
 &bull;Many caterers are finding the Food Safety Act an administrative nightmare according to Les Routiers, the small hotels and restaurants consortium. 
 Managing director Duncan Bradbury said that although most caterers were prepared in food hygiene training and temperature control, they found much of the legislation confusing. 
 BA in-flight catering costs must become more competitive 
 British Airways (BA) in-flight catering must cut costs or face contracting out, according to Chief Executive Sir Colin Marshall. 
 In recent talks with trade unions, Sir Colin said that catering costs were not fully competitive with those of outside contractors, and that the gap would have to be closed if the business were to be kept in-house. 
 Catering is just one of the areas BA is examining for potential cost-cutting. 
 And at BA's annual meeting last week, chairman Lord King said: &bquo;Our business is to get people into planes and fly them. 
 I don't want to make bread rolls; I want to eat them.&equo; 
 However, Maurice Decarteret, operations manager at BA's Catering Centre South, Heathrow, reacted angrily to suggestions that catering might be contracted out. 
 He said: &bquo;We would be looking to make ourselves viable in-house before going down that road, and we are well able to do it.&equo; 
 Mr Decarteret also pointed out that if catering services were contracted out, &bquo;very delicate industrial relations issues&equo; would be high-lighted. 
 BA in-flight catering serves all long-haul and a small number of short-haul services from the UK, producing about 25,000 meals a day from Catering Centre South, where 1,200 people are employed. 
 Most of the short-haul catering is already contracted to Forte Airport Services, which caters for BA out of eight UK airports as well as from four overseas airports. 
 A Forte spokeswoman said: &bquo;We continue to develop a close partnership with BA. 
 We welcome opportunities to extend the scope of this partnership as and when they arise.&equo; 
 Another company that will be watching developments with interest is Sutcliffe Catering, which earlier this year won the staff contract for BA's 45 sites &mdash; a total of 40,000 people. 
 OPEN FOR BUSINESS 
 The Belvedere, Holland Park, London, has reopened under the ownership of Town &amp; County. 
 Jeremy Strode, the chef from the 90-seat Belvedere restaurant, has devised a Californian-style menu. 
 Boddington's first Henry's Table in the South of England has opened in Beddington Park, Surrey. 
 The 92-seat restaurant, called the Grange, cost about &pound;1m to build. 
 Cafe R&eacute;n&eacute; has opened in Hughenden Yard, Marlborough, Wiltshire. 
 The 72-seat restaurant/bar, selling authentic French food, is the third in the South-west for owner Kambiz Shayegan. 
 A boomerang-shaped bar is one of the features of Antipodean-style restaurant Sydney Street in Sydney Street, London. 
 Owners James Morgan, Andrew Christodoulou and Theo Demetriou are importing fish, meat and wine from Australia and New Zealand. 
 Scottish-based restaurant group Littlejohn's is to open a 100-seat restaurant in the Highland resort of Aviemore. 
 The company also operates Littlejohn's in Stirling, Perth, St Andrews and Durham, serving fast food and traditional British dishes. 
 Wimpy International has opened a further four restaurants at the Metro Centre, Gateshead; Carbis Bay, Cornwall; Shirley, Hampshire; and Sudbury, Suffolk. 
 Allied Breweries has opened its 11th Mississippi Exchange Bar Diner, in Guildford, Surrey. 
 Genuine American bric-a-brac has been specially imported from the Deep South for the &pound;820,000 restaurant.  
 Survey calls time on fears 
 Government concerns that the 1988 Licensing Act would encourage greater consumption of alcohol have been proved unfounded. 
 The reforms extended the licensing laws to allow hotel bars and pubs to stay open on weekday afternoons and until 3pm on Sundays. 
 Results of a survey conducted by the Department of Health &mdash; the first to be published since the change in the law &mdash; showed that the average adult weekly alcohol consumption had not changed between 1987 and 1989. 
 Average consumption remained stable at 8.8 standard units per week, or the equivalent of four pints of beer. 
 Before the law received Royal Assent there was resistance to its implementation. 
 Home Office ministers and anti-drink campaigners were concerned that extended hours could encourage people to consume alcohol. 
 However, the survey of 3,600 people found that afternoon drinking was still the exception with only 6% of recent drinkers (those who have had an alcoholic drink in the previous week) having had a drink in licensed premises between 4pm and 5pm during the previous week. 
 &bquo;It is clear that the extensions to permitted opening hours have not led to a marked increase in overall consumption,&equo; the report concluded. 
 Veal protest 
 The Royal Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals has called on consumers to ask restaurateurs the country of origin of their veal. 
 The campaign aims to prevent the import of veal from France and Holland, where calves are reared under conditions which have been banned in Britain. 
 DIET ADVICE IGNORED 
 The British are still largely complacent about their eating habits, despite a barrage of advice in recent years about the importance of a healthy diet, according to a report by market researcher Mintel. 
 More than eight out of 10 consumers, out of a sample of about 1,500, said their consumption of meat and fish was unaffected by health considerations and 60% did not care about calories, while more than half claimed not to worry about calories, while more than half claimed not to worry about salt, sugar or caffeine. 
 Mintel's Healthy Eating  report follows hot on the heels if the latest Government Committee on Medical Aspects of Food Policy (COMA) report, which advised consumers to cut down on intake of nutrients such as sugar, fats and salt. 
 Mintel's research found that most adult consumers belonged to one of the following three groups: 
 &bull; Diet ignorers &mdash; representing 42% of the sample. 
 These were meat eaters who admitted to not caring about their intake of salt, sugar, caffeine or calories. 
 They were most likely to be men, aged 20 to 24, many of whom lived in Scotland. 
 &bull; Diet aware &mdash; representing 23% of the sample. 
 These were meat eaters who did pay attention to their intake of salt, sugar and caffeine and were also concerned about calories. 
 They were most likely to come from the 35&ndash;44 or 55&ndash;64 age group. 
 &bull; Diet conscious &mdash; a minority of just 8% who avoided meat or were vegetarians and were careful about their intake of salt, sugar, caffeine and calories. 
 This group was drawn from the 15 to 19-year-olds and the ABC1 socio-economic group. 
 For those who did choose healthy alternatives, the most popular product was low-fat margarine used by nearly half the sample, followed by skimmed milk used by 40%. 
 One in five chose decaffeinated tea and coffee while 14% used artificial sweeteners. 
 The report also highlighted the difference in attitudes between men and women. 
 Women were more likely to be consumers of healthy alternatives. 
 Only three in 10 were diet ignorers compared with more than half the men. 
 Who's for an ostrich leg? 
 The Cottage in the Wood Hotel, Malvern Wells, Hereford &amp; Worcester, cannot be accused of burying its head in the sand with its decision to introduce South African ostrich to its &agrave; la carte lunch and dinner menu. 
 The meat, which looks like dark veal, is imported by the hotel from France. 
 The hotel is serving it cooked in butter with mushroom and cream flamed with brandy. 
 Cost is &pound;13.95. 
 A Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries &amp; Food spokesperson said there was nothing to stop hotels and restaurants serving unusual meats, provided they complied with food hygiene regulations. 
 Salmonella in decline 
 Recent outbreaks of salmonella have declined to sharply, according to latest Government statistics, but experts have warned that it is too soon to conclude that salmonella is under control. 
 Figures from the Public Health Laboratory Service (PHLS) revealed 7,848 confirmed cases of salmonella during the first six months of this year, a 17% decrease over the same period last year. 
 But the PHLS warned that the first six months of the year were always lower risk times because of the colder weather, and said figures for the third-quarter could be higher. 
 &bquo;Two quarters do not make a trend,&equo; said a PHLS spokesperson. 
 &bquo;It could be years before overall trends are established.&equo; 
 And the figures do not account for the numbers of unreported cases. 
 A spokesperson for the Institution of Environmental Health Officers said the institution hoped the decrease was because of Government activity focusing attention on food safety.  
 NEWS FOCUS 
 Report slams hazardous pools 
 Hoteliers are backing calls for tougher legislation to make hotel swimming pools safer following an IEHO report slamming hotel pools' safety standards. 
 Dom Walsh reports 
 Hoteliers are supporting calls for stronger safety legislation for swimming pools after a survey revealed hotel pools to be the most hazardous in the private sector. 
 The report, compiled by the Institution of Environmental Health Officers (IEHO), slammed poor safety procedures and the lack of supervision and rescue equipment, and called for tougher legislation to tackle the problem. 
 The survey, conducted between September and December last year, looked at 687 of the UK's 2,000 privately run pools of which 363 &mdash; just over half the sample &mdash; were in hotels, guesthouses and conference centres. 
 Of those 363 hotel pools, 31% were found to have inadequate or no rescue equipment and 21% lacked or had insufficient pool surround fitments. 
 Only 44% provided lifeguard supervision. 
 Of the sample as a whole, which included leisure centres, holiday camps and caravan parks, even those pools providing lifeguards exhibited worrying deficiencies, the survey said. 
 Over 34% of pools with supervision kept no training records for lifeguards, while 43% did not allow them to concentrate solely on supervision. 
 Another 23% did not make duty periods overlap to ensure continuous monitoring. 
 Unclear marking of the pool edge, unprotected access at the deep end, narrow surrounds and safety notices obscured by plants were all identified as common problems likely to increase the risk of accidents. 
 But one of the main problems highlighted by the report was ignorance of existing health and safety guidelines, produced in 1988 by the Health and Safety Commission (HSC) and the Sports Council in a document called Safety in Swimming Pools . 
 Pool operators were often unaware of their responsibilities to report accidents and dangerous occurrences to their local authority. 
 Of the hotels in the survey, four had been served improvement notices by environmental health officers, while three had received prohibition notices. 
 According to Tim Mayled, founder of the fledgling Hotel Leisure Managers Association and country club manager of the Lygon Arms, Broadway, Hereford &amp; Worcester, firm legislation rather than guidelines were needed. 
 &bquo;Albeit that they're very good guidelines, at the end of the day it's still up to individual to decide whether they adhere to them or not,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;This is where the problems arise.&equo; 
 Current legislation is embodied in the Health and Safety at Work Act which places a general duty on an employer to &bquo;conduct his undertaking in such a way as to ensure, as far as is practicable, that persons not in his employment who may be affected thereby, are not exposed to risks to their health and safety.&equo; 
 Hotel swimming pools also fall within the framework of the Control of Substances Hazardous to Health Regulations (COSHH) which require that exposure to substances hazardous to health, such as water disinfectants, is either prevented or adequately controlled. 
 The IEHO is calling for the strengthening and extension of existing legislation, a move supported by Mr Mayled, who felt that making the HSC guidelines law was the only way to improve standards across the board. 
 He suggested that one of the main factors which led to unsafe conditions was cost. 
 Equipment and supervisory staff were expensive, he said, and leisure facilities were often the fist victims of cost-saving cutbacks. 
 But Mr Mayled also pointed out the commercial logic of implementing proper procedures. 
 &bquo;It can be a positive marketing tool,&equo; he said. 
 The Health &amp; Safety Executive, however, maintained that the HSC's comprehensive guidelines were adequate and that the laying down of rigid prescriptive standards was impossible given the diversity of sizes and types of pool. 
 But Philip Brook, general manager of Queens Moat's Telford Hotel, Golf &amp; Country Club in Shropshire, which has the biggest hotel swimming pool in the Midlands, argued that legislation was both necessary and possible. 
 &bquo;With the food hygiene regulations, local authorities must assess each food outlet on its risk factor. 
 I see no reason why this could not apply to different sizes of swimming pool.&equo; 
 This type of system would recognise that there are some cases where constant poolside supervision was not reasonably practical, after weighting of risk against cost, as the IEHO report conceded. 
 Report author Janine Avery said: &bquo;Among EHOs hotels would generally be categorized as low-risk areas. 
 But we want swimming pools to be looked at specifically, rather than as just part of the hotel as a whole.&equo; 
 In its recommendations, the IEHO said that any pool should be fully supervised by trained staff unless it fills three criteria; the pool is used infrequently; a relevant member of staff is always aware when the pool is in use; and that use be restricted to adults of known swimming ability. 
 The report recommended that clear and enforceable standards be introduced for the following: &bull; supervision requirements; &bull; maximum duty times and minimum training requirements for lifeguards; &bull; provision of safety equipment; &bull; provision of extra services within swimming pools, such as supplying of food and drink, use of diving boards, slides and flumes. 
 It also suggested that legislation should be brought in that required planners, designers and architects to consider future health and safety needs at the initial design stage.  
 STAKIS STRONGMAN 
 Sir Lewis Robertson has had to make tough decisions to revive Stakis' fortunes. 
 He tells Dom Walsh of the many he has yet to make 
 Since the appointment of Sir Lewis Robertson as chairman of Stakis in February, the company has experienced wholesale changes. 
 More than 100 jobs have been axed, a For Sale sign has gone up over a large slice of its assets and chief executive Andros Stakis has been ousted. 
 Sir Lewis' avuncular features mask a hard-nosed businessman unafraid of putting financial exigency before personal sentiment. 
 It's not for nothing that he has earned his reputation as Scotland's most effective &bquo;company doctor&equo;. 
 However, Sir Lewis has made great efforts to dispel an admitted &bquo;deep scepticism&equo; at his appointment among the group's staff of more than 7,000, and there is growing confidence among them in what he is doing. 
 He gained a lot of brownie points, for example, when the company announced its record interim losses of &pound;45.1m and then revealed plans to sell off the majority of is leisure division. 
 Just before the official announcement, Sir Lewis had 140 copies of a video distributed around the group, letting staff know of the position and of future plans. 
 Probably the harshest decision was the need for a new chief executive (yet to be named) to replace Andros Stakis &mdash; a move he made unhesitatingly, but &bquo;with much regret and much personal vexation&equo;. 
 Another change has been the centralisation of the various head office functions into new Glasgow offices, which Sir Lewis hopes will boost staff morale. 
 However, one of the most important decisions he has yet to make will determine the fate of the group's involvement in Aviemore, frequently referred to as &bquo;Stakisville&equo; thanks to its ownership of three hotels and the Aviemore Centre itself. 
 While Sir Lewis declared himself to be reasonably happy with the way the group's three hotels were being used, he admitted that the 100-acre-plus ski resort was suffering from a glaring lack of investment, and poor road communications. 
 He said a study showed that the 30-year-old Aviemore Centre required &bquo;more or less total renovation&equo;, and that a road spur needed to be built off the A9 bypass. 
 Finance, of course, is the main problem, especially as Stakis is winding down its land and estates division and is putting no more money into property development. 
 Yet it needs to make good the outdated complex, which is not even geared to withstanding bad weather. 
 &bquo;We can do it either by going joint with somebody, or indeed by selling it, or in a variety of ways involving outside capital,&equo; Sir Lewis explained. 
 However, money has been set aside for a refurbishment programme across the group's 30 hotels. 
 An initial sum of &pound;2m will be put into the more urgent cases, he said, with more to follow. 
 Meanwhile, Sir Lewis does not intend to rush his decision on the future of the Country Court concept, currently on ice with only six of a planned 20 hotels off the starting blocks. 
 But he was clear that change was inevitable. 
 &bquo;When the Country Court programme was started, building hotels was still quite a sensible thing to do. 
 Today it may not be the right way forward because it's probably much cheaper to buy a hotel,&equo; he said. 
 But the immediate priority, he emphasised, was to get back to the basics which Sir Reo Stakis tried to inculcate in his managers: using staff effectively to provide a service on the spot and giving the customer what he or she needs and expects.  
 The face of Stakis' future 
 INTERNATIONAL 
 ISRAEL RECOVERS 
 Israel's tourist industry is gradually recovering to pre-Gulf War levels, according to latest Israeli Government statistics. 
 Between January and February 1991, 38,200 tourists visited the country &mdash; just 20% of the figure for the same period in 1991. 
 In May, however, 91,000 visitors were recorded &mdash; two thirds of the total for May 1990. 
 The Israeli Government Tourist Office anticipates that tourist numbers will return to pre-crisis level by August 1991 and will continue to rise rapidly. 
 However, the recovery is not expected to be strong enough to enable total visitor numbers for 1991 to surpass 1990's record of 1.4 million. 
 GHANA HOTEL 
 Lonrho is to open a four-star standard hotel in Ghana, West Africa, in August. 
 The &pound;7.5m 100-bedroom project, designed by Kent-based architects Ratcliffe Stott Associates, will be one of Ghana's premier hotels located in a prime seafront position in the capital, Accra. 
 LUXURY BUILD 
 Omni Hotels Asia-Pacific and Barito Pacific Group are to jointly develop a luxury full-service hotel in Jakarta, Indonesia. 
 The 340-bedroom hotel, the Omni Jakarta Hotel, will be managed by Omni Hotels Asia-Pacific. 
 The hotel is expected to open in 1994. 
 SYDNEY NIKKO 
 A nineteenth-century fruit and grain warehouse in Darling Harbour, Sydney, is the site of a Nikko hotel opening in September. 
 The five-star-standard, 649-bedroom hotel will have a pre-war ocean liner theme which will include curved timber panelling, etched glass and polished chrome interior. 
 UPTURN AHEAD FOR EUROPEAN HOTELS 
 Europe's hotel industry is on the bumpy road to re-establishing its pre-Gulf War position but full recovery is not expected until at least the end of 1991, according to a report from analyst Salomon Brothers. 
 The European leisure market's short-term potential has faded in the wake of the Gulf War and slowing economic growth but prospects for 1992 and beyond are brighter, the report states. 
 Report author Jill Krutick said that in the meantime the race was on among the large hotel chains to achieve a pan-European presence with branded hotel products. 
 &bquo;As travel becomes more international, chains are moving across country lines to try to win a loyal customer base,&equo; she said. 
 The report points out that over the past two years there have been international hotel mergers and acquisitions worth &dollar;8.8b (&pound;5.5b). 
 At least one European company has been involved in &pound;5b-worth of these. 
 Ms Krutick predicted that as the single European market drew closer the travel industry would see an increase in business. 
 Despite temporary set-backs Europe remains the axis to world travel. 
 In 1990 Europe received 64% of worldwide tourists (271 million visitors) and 51% of the receipts for world travel (see chart). 
 European Community countries were the targets for 40% of the world's travel activity. 
 The lion's share of travel in Europe is dominated by Europeans. 
 In 1990, Europe's main city hotels attracted a mix of 37% non-domestic Europeans, 24% domestic and 19% US travellers. 
 Discounting, too, increased as an acceptable practice as European hoteliers imitated their US counterparts. 
 Average discounts from published room rates in Europe's main cities increased to 31% in 1990 from 27% in 1989. 
 Amsterdam, Athens and Dublin discounted the most heavily in 1990 at about 40%, while Munich and top Paris hotels discounted 20%. 
 In US dollar terms room rates remained the highest in Paris, London, Rome and Geneva and lowest in Budapest, Prague and Athens. 
 London luxury hotels fared badly because of their dependence on US tourists. 
 Five-star property occupancy rates fell by 4.2 percentage points to 70.4% in 1990. 
 Germany escaped relatively unscathed from the Gulf War. 
 Berlin room rates soared by 26% in 1990 and occupancy rates jumped by 9.5 percentage points over the previous year to 80.95%. 
 And in Paris, where there were fewer hotel room additions before the Gulf War, occupancy rates fell by 1.4 percentage points to 74.8% in 1990 but roomrates advanced by 9.1% in local currency. 
 Bidding is on for Interhotel 
 UK hotel companies are anxiously awaiting the outcome of round one in the bidding for the former East German hotel group Interhotel. 
 The portfolio of 30 hotels includes the Grand Hotel in Berlin. 
 Others in the group range from the new Dresdener Hof in Dresden &mdash; a purpose-built tourist hotel with 13 bars and restaurants &mdash; to resort hotels with 800 single bedrooms designed for factory workers on holiday. 
 Because of this wide range of hotel types, potential UK buyers are waiting to see whether the German government agency handling the sale &mdash; Treuhandstalt &mdash; will allow the break-up of the group. 
 UK bidders could include Forte, Inter-Continental and Queens Moat Houses.  
 LETTERS 
 COMPOUNDING THE PROBLEM AT ASHLEY COURT 
 &bquo;Life Savers&equo; ( Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper , 13&ndash;19 June) was, to me, incredible!. 
 What is more, the remedy advised is likely to compound the problem. 
 The Povahs' predicament appears to have become a common one, and of course there is sympathy, but one does wonder at the borrowings and the strategy upon which they were based. 
 I, for one, would like to know the source of such indulgent lending. 
 The role of the accountant also appears to be a mystery. 
 However, though I must challenge the advice given, I agree that careful consideration must immediately be given to every detail relevant to the business operation. 
 Staffing levels and costs are, without question, too high and must be reduced. 
 The spare land and any other spare assets should be disposed of to raise cash to meet the demands of creditors, but that is the limit. 
 The food service and bar should not be contracted out, the staff should be considered and only those who are indeed surplus to the requirements and standards of the business should become redundant. 
 Nor would the letting of the house at &pound;400 a month be advisable, because the accommodation in the hotel that the Povah family would need is worth considerably more in terms of income. 
 Mr Povah should stay put and control the business, and deal with sales contracts by phone and mail. 
 Mrs Povah should become actively involved and they should jointly draw the &pound;1,000 a month quoted. 
 This should be included in a salaries and wages budget of 20% of turnover. 
 Heat, light and power should be revised and contained at 3%, and administrative costs reduced to 10%. 
 Assuming that the lenders will agree to defer capital repayments, and the fixed charge of &pound;207,192 quoted in Table III becomes applicable, a projected profit and loss account for 1992 can be prepared. 
 This would show, on 1991 figures, but at a more realistic 70% than the 78.6%, a low of &pound;15,143 net profit. 
 Much better than the quoted loss projected of &pound;12,728. 
  BRYAN LATTER BTL Consultancy, 92 Maygrove Road, West Hampstead, London NW6  
 ADVANTAGE IN COLLABORATION? 
 Having read with interest the saga of the Ashley Court Hotel, and now the first instalment on the Valley Hotel ( Caterer , 11&ndash;17 July), it strikes me that the Povahs and the Cassons should combine their marketing, accounting and food systems skills. 
 There's many a true word spoken in jest, but there must be lessons here to help them all awaken from the financial nightmare that the lending institutions have exacerbated. 
  CHRIS BONE Farm Cottage, Birds Drove, Sutton St James, Lincolnshire.  
 DEMAND IN &bquo;DISDAINFUL&equo; 
 I have just received a request (not quite a demand) from Expotel for &pound;350 (+10% commission on bookings) to join its hotel database, otherwise I risk falling off its screens. 
 In the old days, travel agents looked after their customers by finding them the best-value hotels at the required destination. 
 By looking after customers' interests, they built up their business. 
 I wonder how many of Expotel's customers are aware that Expotel's recommendations are based not on hotel quality but on the self-interested payment up-front of this &bquo;sweetener&equo;, plus exclusive corporate rates? 
 Such a cavalier approach to customers surely leaves Expotel vulnerable to competitors and to bright, investigative trade journalists. 
  JOHN JENKINSON Evesham Hotel, Cooper's Lane, Evesham, Hereford &amp; Worcs.  
 CATERERS NEED HELP ON HYGIENE 
 I was interested to read &bquo;Cambridge caf&eacute; fined &pound;13,500&equo; ( Caterer , 30 May&ndash;5 June). 
 Food businesses fail to meet basic food safety standards through ignorance. 
 This ignorance is compounded by a lack of knowledge of where to turn to for advice, and a fear of direct contact with enforcing authorities. 
 When enforcement procedures are taken against a business, the cost of obtaining expert opinion and the legal costs of providing a defence can prove prohibitive and even result in commercial disaster. 
 I applaud and support the efforts by Bill Bates, food safety consultant at Control UK, in his attempts to get an arbitration board set up, but have reservations about the priority likely to be given to this by food minister, David Maclean. 
 In the meantime, businesses must understand the requirements of the legislation, implement suitable management controls to maintain the required standards, and review their insurance and their use of external support services &mdash; which can be cost-effective investments in the event of crisis. 
 D.W. CODD Director of Safety Services, Managing Director IRPC-Hinton, Stockwell House, Hinkley, Leicestershire. 
 &bquo;HALF MEASURES&equo; FOR CROWNS 
 I am greatly disappointed in the London Tourist Board's initiative for small-to-medium sized hotels which do not operate restaurants, but wish to achieve a three-crown rating. 
 We now have to form an arrangement with a local restaurant to offer an evening meal on our behalf, and we offer transport to the restaurant ourselves. 
 For goodness sake, why should small city-centre hotels have to operate restaurants or be forced into stupid little half-measures such as the aforementioned to get a rating? 
 Small city-centre hotels can very rarely operate restaurants profitably (especially not in London). 
  M.S. THEODORE Bryanston Court Hotel, Great Cumberland Place, Marble Arch, London W1.  
 WALKER TOOK WRONG ROUTE 
 It was extremely disappointing to read your news story entitled &bquo;Unfriendly Wales&equo; ( Caterer , 4&ndash;10 July), and I am led to wonder where Tom Harrison chose to walk in the principality. 
 I would like to show him a folder overflowing with letters from visitors to Llangoed Hall, praising the warmth and professionalism of the staff. 
 I should further point out that Llangoed Hall is running a series of walking weekends in conjunction with a national magazine and Wayfarers, an organisation for walkers in Great Britain. 
 Perhaps Mr Harrison would have second thoughts if he walked in our neck of the woods. 
  TOM WARD General Manager, Llangoed Hall, Llyswen, Brecon, Powys.  
 THANKS FOR THE KIND WORDS 
 On behalf of all local authority caterers, I thank Joe Hyam for his kind words and support for the local authority caterers. 
 He says: &bquo;Small budgets, apologetic councils strapped for cash, and a complex social and sometimes ethnic mix of young customers and their parents don't make for an easy life.&equo; 
 I would agree with him, but then when did caterers ever ask for an easy life? 
 The positive side of local authority catering is the reward of seeing children happily and healthily fed, of winning the political battle for a small budget to market healthy eating and providing good steady work for thousands of caterers. 
 Joe should also remember that many of us get a buzz out of controlling budgets of up to &pound;30m a year, employing 3,000 staff, and providing food in up to 600 units. 
 Some of us even enjoy the political battles, provided we win a few. 
  MAGGIE TILTMAN Local Authority Caterers Association, Jacobs Well, Guildford, Surrey.  
 LANGUAGES ARE WINNING WORDS 
 I was delighted that your Opinion column ( Caterer , 4&ndash;10 July) highlighted the need for better language skills. 
 Our report Lost for words , published last year, showed considerable complacency in Britain, because so many visitors have an impressive command of English. 
 Yet English is not the native language for almost half of our overseas visitors. 
 Meeting their expectations means communicating with them in their own tongue. 
 That is why the British Tourist Association launched its &bquo;Winning Words&equo; initiative, to encourage the tourism industry to improve the service it offers to non-English speaking guests. 
 Our industry can create new markets and opportunities with a modest investment in language initiatives. 
 Even the most basic multi-language signs or the occasional &bquo;Guten tag&equo; will create goodwill and develop future business. 
 The winning words in the 1990s will be those spoken in the languages of our customers. 
  WILLIAM DAVIS Chairman, British Tourist Authority, Hammersmith, London W6.  
 FINANCIAL HANDS COULD BE TIED 
 Regarding Garry Hawkes' letter &bquo;Hygiene first at contractor&equo; ( Caterer , 11&ndash;17 July), during my employment with Forte, the properties for which I was responsible were often visited by internal inspectors from John Forte's department. 
 They were excellent in every aspect and always more than willing to give positive practical advice to allow hotel managers to conduct their business with the backing of a truly professional team. 
 However, Mr Hawkes should note the need for public relations guidance, as perhaps the local government officials mentioned have their financial hands tied by central Government which in turn accepts contributions to the Conservative Party, from Forte. 
  GEOFFREY TALLIS Proprietor, Newton House Hotel, Glencarse, Perth.  
 ALPHA STUDENTS MEET IN LONDON 
 Alpha is a group is University of Ulster graduates who feel it would benefit all Northern Ireland graduates in the catering and tourism fields to keep in touch, both socially and on a professional level. 
 May I draw attention to our recently established London branch, which meets regularly to discuss current issues and share ideas and experiences. 
 Our next meeting will take place at 7pm on 29 July at the Hotel, Catering and Institutional Management Association headquarters, 191 Trinity Road, London. 
 All current and new members will be made most welcome. 
 For details please contact:  SEAN MURRAY Assistant Food &amp; Beverage Manager, Ritz Hotel, Piccadilly, London W1.  
 YOUR VIEWS&hellip; 
 We welcome your views on any subject relevant to the catering industry, but please keep letters short and to the point. 
 We reserve the right to edit where necessary. 
 Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper  will not publish letters sent anonymously or under pseudonyms. 
 However, names and addresses can be withheld at the discretion of the editor, but must be supplied. 
 Letters offering services will not be printed. 
 Letters should be addressed to: Letters Editor, Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper , Room 1504, Quadrant House, The Quadrant, Sutton, Surrey SM2 5AS. 
 Don't forget to print your full name, address and, if possible, give a telephone number where you can be contacted. 
 Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper, 25 July 1991 
 JOE HYAM 
 HOW NOT TO DO IT 
 It is sometimes beneficial to compare our industry with other service industries. 
 When you look at the way our railways are run, we can only be grateful that British Rail no longer owns hotels, particularly when you recall what a wonderful training ground the old British Transport Hotels used to be. 
 Imagine a hotel where the service changed without warning and the staff had no idea what was happening. 
 It is 8am. 
 You are looking for coffee, orange juice, toast. 
 And what do you get? 
 An announcement. 
 We apologise to customers for the cancellation of breakfast owing to: repair work in the kitchen, staff shortages, a fatality in the cold room, the non-arrival of deliveries. 
 You approach the reception desk: &bquo;Where can I go for breakfast?&equo; you ask. 
 &bquo;'s closed.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean by 's closed?&equo; 
 &bquo;I mean there's no breakfast. 
 Try the place round the corner.&equo; 
 You go to the place round the corner. 
 There is a &bquo;closed&equo; sign on the door. 
 There is no sign of a shop or caf&eacute; open anywhere. 
 You return to the hotel. 
 &bquo;The place round the corner is closed,&equo; you say. 
 &bquo;You can get breakfast in the restaurant now. 
 The chef's come in.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why didn't you tell me a minute ago?&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't know. 
 Did I?&equo; 
 Far fetched? 
 Not a bit of it. 
 No hotel service could be quite so crass. 
 But that's a fair equivalent of what happened at Gatwick Airport railway station recently. 
 First the indicator board wasn't working. 
 Then it became apparent that the advertised service to London every 15 minutes had been reduced to a 30-minute service. 
 We were advised by the ticket collector to catch an ordinary train, but the train didn't turn up. 
 So back we went to the barrier. 
 &bquo;It should have done,&equo; he said, when we told him. 
 &bquo;You'll be quicker on the express.&equo; 
 Having been criticised for giving no information, BR now gives it all the time with endless repetition, except when you really want it. 
 And it calls you &bquo;customers&equo;. 
 There is a difference between being called a customer and being regarded as one, which seems entirely to have escaped BR. 
 A customer makes a choice. 
 BR customers often don't have the choice. 
 CUSTOM AND PRACTICE 
 The truth about customers is that most people who serve them see them, at some time or other, as enemies. 
 Neville Blech who, with his wife Sonia, runs the Mijanou restaurant in London, tells a story which sums up this hidden facet of service. 
 Customer: &bquo;I'd like the stewed apples please, but without the custard.&equo; 
 Waitress: &bquo;I'll ask the chef.&equo; 
 The waitress returns. 
 &bquo;Chef says the dish is stewed apples and custard. 
 You can't have one without the other.&equo; 
 Customer: &bquo;I don't believe it. 
 What else did he say?&equo; 
 Waitress: &bquo;He said if you start giving them apples without custard, where will it ever end?&equo; 
  Joe Hyam Director, Academy of Culinary Arts   
 VIEWPOINT 
 Watch out for the rise of the B&amp;B 
 I would rather stay at a good bed &amp; breakfast than in several five-star hotels I could name. 
 My reasons have something to do with the costs and value. 
 B&amp;Bs come in all shapes and sizes. 
 It's not hard to find bad ones with cubby-hole rooms, nylon sheets and towels like emery boards, but at the other extreme there are elegant houses with antique furniture. 
 Rooms and their facilities compare to those on the country house circuit. 
 The welcome is personal and genuine and the breakfast may be fresher and taste better than in almost any hotel. 
 The price per night in one of the best can be as much as &pound;35; but it could be less than &pound;25. 
 By any measuring stick, that's a very good deal. 
 This creates a curious situation. 
 Many hoteliers, both independents and chain operators, feel they have to charge &pound;50 or &pound;100 to make a profit. 
 According to their calculations, they are asking a fair rate. 
 On the other hand, the public, providing that it shops around, can probably buy the same product elsewhere for a fraction of those prices. 
 A two-tiered position has arisen almost by accident and certainly without any fuss. 
 There was a time when five-star hotels were assumed to be better than four-star and so on down the line. 
 For the past decade, at least, it has been recognised that quality exists above and beyond any guide's objective star rating. 
 What has escaped notice, however, is the knock-on effect of this principle. 
 Guest houses, inns, farmhouses and B&amp;Bs have all been improving in the same way as the rest of the industry, so that the best of them compare in their own category with say, AA red star hotels. 
 They won't attract much attention individually. 
 They are too small for that; some have only one or two letting rooms; they can't market themselves, though an English Tourist Board grading or a high &bquo;Q&equo; rating from the AA can help. 
 For the moment they may not, singly or collectively, present a serious commercial challenge. 
 A chain hotel located in a city centre or at the exit roundabout of a motorway guarantees many identical rooms. 
 The average business traveller, who doesn't pay his own bills or make his own booking, will plump for that option in preference to a detour down a country lane or through suburbs in search of some unknown quantity which might turn out to be a gem. 
 The existence of a cheap national network of accommodation, however diffuse, unstructured and unregulated, is one reason why Forte and other groups have not opened super-budget hotels like their French counterpart Accor, where rooms sell at approximately &pound;15 a night. 
 No traditional formula could compete on value-for-money with a well-run guesthouse where, as the public has begun to realise, it can expect cheaper prices coupled with modern levels of comfort. 
 B&amp;Bs are a unique British invention, like the sandwich. 
 Just as the snack has changed from being a national joke into a respected billion pound industry almost overnight, so the most humble sector of the hospitality industry is on course to become the high-flier of the 1990s. 
  Michael Raffael Cookery writer    
 PEOPLE 
 SAM WHITBREAD TO RETIRE NEXT YEAR 
 Sam Whitbread, chairman of Whitbread since 1984, is to retire in July 1992 and will be replaced by Sir Michael Angus, chairman of Unilever. 
 In anticipation of the move, Mr Whitbread has already handed effective control of the company to his chief executive Peter Jarvis and has been made non-executive chairman. 
 He will continue as a non-executive member of the board. 
 Sir Michael, who is already on the Whitbread board, is also chairman of the Board Remuneration and Audit Committees and is a non-executive director of Thorn EMI and British Airways. 
 HOWARD HEADS BATH SPA KITCHEN 
 Alex Howard has been appointed head chef of Forte's Spa Hotel in Bath, Avon. 
 He replaces Berndt Meister, who will be redeployed. 
 The Bath Spa said Mr Meister's appointment was never seen as long-term and that he had been appointed to groom Mr Howard for the position. 
 TRAINING ADVICE 
 Four food and hygiene education and training consultants have linked up to form the Food, Health &amp; Advisory Service in London. 
 They are Ben Fenton, Amin Dinno, George Couling and Peter Wild. 
 The team aims to provide an educational training package based on the syllabus used for the Institution of Environmental Health Officers' course. 
 FURUYA TO HEAD SALES 
 The New Otani group of hotels has appointed Takashi Furuya as director of sales, Europe. 
 Mr Furuya joined New Otani in 1974 working in international sales in Tokyo. 
 He moved to London in 1988 as assistant director of sales. 
 New Otani has also appointed Elizabeth Rees as sales executive. 
 AMANN GOES TO COPTHORNE 
 Eric Amann has been appointed to the new post of deputy manager at the Copthorne Slough-Windsor. 
 Mr Amann joins the Copthorne group from Forte's international division where he was director of food and beverage operations at the Royal Mansour Hotel, Casablanca, Morocco. 
 CAPITOL GAINS GAWEL 
 Lesley Gawel has joined Capital Catering Management Services, Reading, Berkshire, as operations manager. 
 Miss Gawel was previously with the Civil Service Catering Organisation (CISCO) where she was responsible for 27 outlets. 
 Miss Gawel replaces Janet Lawrenson who becomes business development manager, responsible for the company's expansion in the home counties, North-west of London. 
 MACRAE IN ACTING ROLE 
 David MacRae is acting manager at the Gatwick Penta Hotel, following the departure of Norbert Hummel. 
 Mr Hummel is to run Penta's new hotel in Moscow. 
 Mr MacRae has been at the hotel for five years. 
 He started as financial controller and then moved on to become executive assistant manager. 
 HOUSSIN IS GM OF OAK HOTEL 
 Bernard Houssin has been appointed general manager of the Oak Hotel Group from the Arcade Hotel in Portsmouth, Hampshire. 
 Guy Madec becomes general manager of the group's first hotel, the Oak Hotel Wigan, Greater Manchester. 
 He was previously deputy manager at the Arcade Hotel, Portsmouth. 
 SPECIALIST CONSULTANCY 
 Rachel Shackleton, formerly training director for Windjammer Landing in St Lucia, and Bea Van Gessel, assistant general manager of European Country Hotels, have joined forces to form their own consultancy. 
 Paradigm Management, based in Twickenham, Middlesex, will specialise in staff and management training, design of systems and control, and marketing. 
 IN OTHER MOVES 
 Didier Boidin to manager of the Hotel Inter-Continental, London, from resident manager Le Grand Hotel in Paris. 
 Jon and Helen Monk, previously at the Calais Campanile, are to manage the Cardiff branch of the French hotel and restaurant chain Campanile UK. 
 Joe Koizumi has been appointed Japanese concierge at the Gloucester Hotel, Kensington, London. 
 Dawn Henderson to travel trade sales executive with the Hotel Conrad, Chelsea Harbour, London. 
 Andrew Tilley to director of sales and marketing, the Balmoral Hotel, Edinburgh, from the Hilton Group in Hong Kong. 
 Bill Farrelly moves from Cornwall College to Richmond College, Surrey, as a lecturer on catering. 
 David Clarke, general manager of the Caledonian Hotel, Edinburgh, has been appointed chairman of the Edinburgh Principal Hoteliers Association. 
 David Mealing to Mount Charlotte Thistle's St George Hotel, Teesside Airport, from the Abernant Lake Hotel, Llanwrtyd Wells, Wales.  
 Andrew Magson, previously head chef at Burt's in London's Soho, has taken charge of the kitchen at Caf&eacute; Fish, London W1, replacing Ian McKenzie. 
 Before Burt's Mr Magson worked at Inigo Jones for five years. 
 Caf&eacute; Fish is now in its fifth year of offering a fish-only menu which ranges from moules marini&egrave;re to bouillabaisse. 
 Produce for the restaurant is sourced daily from British ports, Billingsgate and Normandy. 
 BUSINESS 
 MANAGEMENT MISS 
 Management training centres are receiving an increasing share of the lucrative training course market at the expense of hotels, according to Gill Smillie, head of Conference Venues CountryWide. 
 Ms Smillie said organisers of training courses often complained that hotels were inflexible towards meal times, unaware of the needs of training and rarely offered the standards of presentation and technology required. 
 &bquo;What is worrying for hotels is that the training course market is tasting a new set of standards, and may never return to hotels,&equo; she said. 
 CASH DIRECTORY 
 The Commercial Initiative has published the Directory of Commercial Finance Lenders , a comprehensive guide on sources of finance. 
 The guide features contact names and addresses of lenders; information lenders required from potential borrowers; lending criteria; details of special schemes and an index showing which lenders are active in 70 business sectors. 
 The guide is available for &pound;55 from Commercial Initiative, 124 Lambton Road, London SW20. 
 LOOK TO EUROPE 
 Hoteliers will increasingly look to Europe in the next 10 years to satisfy their investment needs, according to Jonathan Bodlender, chairman of Horwath Consulting. 
 Horwath Consulting is sponsoring a two-day conference arranged by international conference organiser IIR at The Dorchester, London, on 22 and 23 October. 
 Twenty-two speakers from leading international companies will speak about investment opportunities and expansion in Europe in the 1990s. 
 Venture capital turns to leisure 
 by Richard Gordon 
 In the past year 3i, the venture capital company, has invested &pound;30m in the leisure industry and it expects to spend more in the future despite the recession. 
 The investment by 3i represented a 73% increase over the previous year, which ended at 31 March 1990. 
 Robert Lowe, 3i's industrial adviser in the leisure sector, said the recession had resulted in acquisition prices returning to more sensible levels. 
 &bquo;We are in a good position to help strong management teams take advantage of this,&equo; he said. 
 The company, which recently sold its stake in the Sheraton Edinburgh (see page 26), has not restricted its funds for leisure investment, according to Martin Woods, an accounting adviser working with Mr Lowe. 
 &bquo;The funds are there for the right project. 
 &bquo;We took the view in the press that hotel and leisure property prices were too high and therefore were cautious about investment.&equo; 
 He said 3i had always taken a long-term view and had not been as badly hit by the recession as the banks had because it had been cautious. 
 &bquo;Now that we are getting back to realistic prices and trading performance can justify capital costs, it makes more sense to invest,&equo; he said. 
 He said the gradual drop in interest rates was also contributing to the improvement in investment conditions. 
 &bquo;Interest on borrowed money has been greater than profitability which required further funding by the banks. 
 Lower interest rates mean trading returns are more able to cover interest payments,&equo; Mr Lowe added. 
 The company believed more opportunities in the pub sector could materialise following the implementation of the Monopolies and Mergers Commission report. 
 &bull;The latest drop in interest rates was also welcomed by Christie &amp; Co, the property agent. 
 Managing director Kevin Eakin said that while the half percentage point cut would not have a dramatic effect, it was part of a series of cuts all in the right direction. 
 &bquo;There is evidence that the market in pubs, hotels and restaurants has been picking up &mdash; we believe it bottomed out six months ago &mdash; and that is another welcome move in bringing purchasers out again,&equo; he said. 
 Christie Group has reported a pre-tax loss of &pound;2.6m for the year to March. 
 The loss compares with a profit of &pound;1.2m the previous year. 
 Industry cautious over BCCI collapse 
 Asian hoteliers and restaurateurs have been reluctant to disclose the extent to which they have been affected by the collapse of the Bank of Credit and Commerce International (BCCI). 
 A spokesman for Control Securities &mdash; the largest Asian-owned UK company to be affected by the BCCI collapse &mdash; refused to comment on the issues. 
 But according to analysts, Control Securities, which owes BCCI about &pound;2m of a &pound;5m loan, will be hit by the loss of rent from two office blocks which it leased to the bank. 
 When new occupiers lease these properties, Control Securities will have to absorb a &pound;7m loss in the value of these assets. 
 The true extent of the financial damage will only be known when the company announces its year-end results at the end of July. 
 An angry spokeswoman for Edwardian Hotels said the group was not prepared to make any comment on BCCI. 
 A spokesman for Sarova Hotels said: &bquo;In the past we have had a satisfactory working relationship with BCCI and the current situation has not presented problems.&equo; 
 Ryan Hotels blames losses on tourism 
 Ryan Hotels, the Dublin-based hotel and tour operator, has been badly hit by the downturn in tourism. 
 In the six months to 25 April, the company recorded a loss of I&pound;509,000 (&pound;461,000), a turnaround from a pre-tax profit of I&pound;362,000 (&pound;336,000) in the previous year. 
 Turnover was down from I&pound;8.25m to I&pound;7.02m. 
 Ryan chairman Conor McCarthy said the Gulf War had seriously disrupted travel to Ireland and the US tourist market had yet to recover, although bookings from the Irish, UK and Continental markets were strong.  
 PROPERTY 
 JARVIS SELLS 
 The 70-bedroom Salutation Hotel, Perth, Scotland, one of the Embassy hotels bought by John Jarvis in 1990, has been sold for an undisclosed sum to Strathmore Hotels. 
 The purchase is the first for Strathmore, which was recently founded by Ronnie Rickard, former managing director of Norscot Hotels. 
 The company plans to develop a chain of 15 to 20 two- and three-star hotels in Scotland and Northern England over the next five years. 
 The sale was handled by Druce Hotels &amp; Leisure International. 
 FOREIGN BUYER 
 The Grosvenor House Hotel in Stratford-upon-Avon, Warwickshire, has been sold to an overseas investment company. 
 Knight Frank &amp; Rutley, which handled the sale on behalf of the vendor Frames Welcome Hotels, said the purchaser was an overseas trust which intended to extend the hotel. 
 M4 SERVICES 
 Rank Motorway Services has opened a &pound;7.9m service area on junction 47 of the M4 at Penllergaer, Swansea. 
 More than 100 staff will be employed at the facility, which has self-service and fast food restaurants, a 50-bedroom Rank Motor Lodge and a restaurant for lorry drivers. 
 ADVANCE PLANNING 
 Planning consent for a Center Parc at Longleat, Wiltshire, has yet to be gained, contrary to a report in Caterer  (11&ndash;17 July). 
 REFURBISHMENT 
 Floating restaurant the Tattershall Castle has been towed to Chatham, Kent, for a &pound;1m refurbishment. 
 It will return in mid-August and reopen at the beginning of September. 
 &bull; Turn to Classified to see what is on the property market. 
 Equity dries up for hotels 
 by Richard Gordon 
 The hotel industry faces a search for investors as property values slump worldwide and loans exceed asset values. 
 According to Kay Dymock, partner of estate agent Jones Lang Wootton's international hotels division, the challenge for the hotel industry in the '90s will be the search for equity. 
 The estate agency has identified institutions as the most likely equity source in Europe. 
 &bquo;While some institutions have made public share investments in hotel companies, the property departments remain shy of hotels,&equo; she said. 
 Hotels most likely to interest international investors would be those with strong revenue rather than those with development potential. 
 The UK institutions would be the most difficult to persuade to enter the hotel market because of the short-term pressures on fund managers. 
 &bquo;We are looking at Continental institutions such as pension funds which take a more long-term view or are more entrepreneurial.&equo; 
 Bill Cross, chairman of TransAct, a newcomer to the European hotel broker scene, said there was enormous demand for new international-style hotels. 
 Huge sums were involved, he said, but nobody was sure where the money would come from. 
 &bquo;Institutions have a jaundiced view of hotel property. 
 Unlike offices, the level of income fluctuates although sometimes over a longer period it fluctuates at a higher level than commercial. 
 &bquo;So for institutions equity investment in hotels is perhaps a little too speculative.&equo; 
 However, investors worried about the instability of the hotel market could be reassured with leases rather than management contracts, he said. 
 &bquo;With leases they miss the opportunity for super profits but they are guaranteed a return of 7% initially and then up to 10%. 
 They would have to wait until the property is sold before the super profits come in.&equo; 
 Arthur de Haast of Jones Lang Wootton said institutions needed evidence of hotel performance as a real estate investment. 
 New owner for Sheraton Edinburgh 
 The original developer of the Sheraton Edinburgh has sold the 263-bedroom hotel to a new company, Hotel Corporation of Edinburgh Holdings. 
 Sheraton will continue to manage the hotel. 
 Capital Hotel Partnership, the hotel's developer, was a joint venture between ITT Sheraton, Prudential Venture Managers and finance company 3i. 
 The Hotel Corporation of Edinburgh is chaired by Robert Gibbons, senior partner of Fox &amp; Gibbons, solicitors. 
 Mr Gibbons is also chairman of bottle water company Highland Spring. 
 Fox &amp; Gibbons is a law firm in the Middle East and has specialised in Middle East fund management for more than 25 years. 
 Arthur de Haast, a partner of Jones Lang Wootton, which advised the vendor, said the new owner was taking a medium to long-term view on the investment. 
 Conran plans wharf complex 
 Sir Terence Conran, former chairman of retail conglomerate Storehouse Group and developer of the Bibendum restaurant, is spearheading the development of a restaurant and retail complex at Butler's Wharf near Tower Bridge in London. 
 Le Pont de la Tour, as the complex will be known, will cost about &pound;1.25m and will occupy 10,000sq ft in a converted riverside warehouse. 
 It will include a 105-cover restaurant, bar and grill seating 60 people, a wine merchant, speciality food store and bakery. 
 Partners in the project, which is due to open in September, include Joel Kissin, formerly general manager of Bibendum and Hilaire, and David Burke, a former sous chef at Bibendum.  
 FOOD PRICES 
 Fresh and flavourful 
 Make the most of British pork because prices are low for the time of year. 
 Lean minced beef is on offer this week in most areas and there are some good buys to be had with topside, silverside and rump. 
 New season's lamb is superb and there are plenty of lamb cuts on offer. 
 Make the most of home-grown strawberries as the season is now at its peak. 
 Prices will vary from area to area and if we get heavy rain supplies will fall, forcing prices to rise. 
 Very much the same applies to raspberries. 
 Imported will still be arriving though to keep supplies at a reasonable level. 
 Other new season good fruit buys are gooseberries, redcurrants and blackcurrants. 
 Currants are usually expensive because they are labour-intensive to pick. 
 Look for new season's cauliflowers. 
 The quality this year is first class. 
 Spring greens are at their best and quality primo cabbage is the best green buy this week.   
 CAREERS &amp; TRAINING 
 Pub chain trains for Europe 
 Taylor Walker is benefiting from a customer care programme that it believes will enable it to compete with its European counterparts. 
 Taylor Walker managing director David Longbottom said: &bquo;Unlike our European counterparts, in the UK we do not perceive bar work as having professional status. 
 Bar work is thought to be transitory, undemanding and unskilled. 
 We are trying to correct this with training programmes and staff recognition schemes.&equo; 
 The customer care programme includes four simple charters which cover all aspects of hospitality from hygiene standards to a cheery welcome to each and every customer. 
 The brewery employs people to visit its pubs anonymously to quantify the effects of these charters. 
 These inspectors nominate those staff they feel deserve extra recognition. 
 Taylor Walker training manager Nick Leach said barstaff were tested by the area manager to see if they knew the names of at least 100 customers, plus their regular drink. 
 Youngsters learn how 
 Contract caterer Gardner Merchant is to provide catering instruction for children's charity Barnardo's latest training restaurant. 
 Dr B's Kitchen in Belfast, Northern Ireland, will train up to 16 young people with learning difficulties for employment in the catering industry. 
 The restaurant opened earlier this month. 
 Gardner Merchant is already providing instruction at Barnardo's other two units, Dr B's Kitchen in Harrogate, North Yorkshire, and Dr B's Caribbean Restaurant in Leeds. 
 Recruitment takes off thanks to Springboard 
 by Bally Sall 
 Springboard &mdash; London's one-stop career centre &mdash; was a resounding success in its first five months due to financial contributions and the support of hotel and catering businesses. 
 But, according to the director of the London Tourism Manpower Project Peter Evans, more needs to be done. 
 By the end of March, after five months of operation, Springboard had placed 3,000 people in work, and, despite the recession, had handled over 200 vacancies a week. 
 It also recorded over 2,000 inquiries from employers on the centre's computers. 
 Nearly 60 companies &mdash; including Travellers Fare, McDonald's, Kentucky Fried Chicken and Mount Charlotte Thistle Hotels &mdash; have used Springboard as a recruitment base. 
 McDonald's recruitment officer Christina Pellini, who is hiring trainee managers for the 50 units the company plans to open this year, uses Springboard once or twice a month because &bquo;it provides good quality people&equo;, she said. 
 &bquo;It is very well organised and books interviews for me. 
 All I have to do is turn up and see the applicants,&equo; she said. 
 SUCCESS 
 Springboard's job centre manager, Colin Foster, said the success was due to its high penetration of the market. 
 &bquo;We are getting a high percentage of the available jobs. 
 We fill 60% of all vacancies, which is quite a good conversion rate,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Evans said he had been pleased with Springboard's activities in its first year. 
 But he added: &bquo;An awful lot still needs to be done about the image of the industry. 
 In some cases, we have met with open hostility, particularly from some parents, and we need to do more to dispel this. 
 &bquo;They have walked away from the catering and hospitality industry stand, dragging their child with them, and said &bquo;You don't want to join that!&equo;&equo; 
 But if this good work is to continue, Springboard needs increased financial support from its patrons and sponsors because the Government's contribution so far this year is nil. 
 &bquo;The London City Action Team contributed &pound;75,000 last year. 
 This year there will be nothing so we shall have to tighten our belt and concentrate our efforts on giving value for money,&equo; he said. 
 He believes much more can be done with more resources and that the industry needs Springboards in other conurbations such as Birmingham, Manchester, Glasgow and Bristol, Avon, if people are to attach a lot more importance to it. 
 Springboard's other activities have included industry representation at careers fairs and conventions, visits to teachers and schools and invitations for schools to visit its offices.  
 TECHNOLOGY 
 Power to the people 
 Efficient plant is only part of the answer to rising energy costs. 
 Other considerations are price of energy and the way its use is controlled. 
 Geoff Tyler reports 
 There are two ways to cut the price of energy. 
 One is to shop around the electricity companies and the other is to generate it yourself. 
 Eventually every electricity user will be able to buy from whichever supplier offers the best deal. 
 In practice this will be one of the 14 regional companies (the old boards). 
 At present a hotel has to have a peak demand of over one megawatt, a tall order, but in March 1994 &mdash; if not earlier &mdash; users with a 100kW demand will be given shopping freedom. 
 The annual bill for 100kW users is somewhere above &pound;20,000, depending on tariffs used. 
 Later, in April 1998, the demand limits will be removed altogether and everybody will e able to shop around. 
 A hotel in Manchester will be able to buy its electricity from, say, Eastern Electricity in Clacton, Essex, and negotiate the prices and tariffs in the same way goods are bought from a private vendor. 
 This is good news for the hotelier who is prepared. 
 Many do not take full advantage of the various daytime, night and off-peak tariffs on offer from their electricity company. 
 To get a 5% or 10% saving the hotel will need to know its exact electricity consumption pattern and what the overall result of each tariff profile on offer will be. 
 A more intriguing possibility is to generate power in the hotel. 
 Until recently, CHP systems &mdash; combined heat and power, also called co-generation &mdash; have been only for large hotels and have meant high capital outlays. 
 Mow small systems are technically feasible and schemes exist which involve the hotelier in no capital cost at all. 
 The few dozen hotels already operating CHP, I forecast, will soon be joined by hundreds more. 
 Combined heat and power systems are, basically, oil, gas and sometimes solid fuel engines driving generators for electricity and capturing heat from the cooling system and exhaust gases for the hot water and central heating system. 
 The unit goes in the basement, plant room or wherever, and the hotel comes off the grid supply of electricity &mdash; although it is sensible to retain a connection for emergencies. 
 EFFICIENCY 
 At first glance CHP seems inefficient &mdash; but it is not. 
 Conventional electricity generation loses to the atmosphere enough heat for the needs of every home, office and factory in the country. 
 Estimates put grid-generated power at 25% to 35% efficiency after heat and transmission losses. 
 A hotel's conventional boiler for heat production alone usually achieves 70% and standby electricity generators, 50%. 
 According to Harwell Laboratory's energy technology support unit, in CHP systems 80% to 90% of fuel used is converted to electrical power and heat. 
 The proportion varies between systems but a typical profile is about 50% heat and 30% to 40% electricity. 
 What do these figures do for the bottom line? 
 One example in Torquay, Devon, has proven itself over a few years. 
 Torquay Leisure Hotels manages the adjacent Derwent and Victoria hotels, which have a total of 270 bedrooms and a swimming pool. 
 Its trial with CHP started in November 1986 with a Countryman WaterMota gas-fuelled CHP system with an electrical output of 48kW in the Derwent. 
 Success led to a second CHP system in 1989 for the Victoria. 
 The Derwent's energy cost savings were &pound;3,000 in the first year and now run at more that &pound;4,000 a year. 
 The Victoria's savings are over &pound;5,000 a year. 
 Payback on the investment is on target at four-and-a-half years for the Derwent and an even shorter period for the Victoria. 
 Managing director of Torquay Leisure Hotels, Laurence Murrell, points out that for the system to be financially successful, the units must run for the maximum possible number of hours. 
 BALANCE 
 &bquo;The most critical factor in achieving this has been to establish the correct balance between the CHP units and the (supplementing) boiler plants and to maintain that balance,&equo; he said. 
 That advice is echoed across the CHP industry. 
 It is possible to install an over-large CHP unit and sell the excess electricity it generates back to the grid. 
 In practice the price obtained will be less than the generating cost, so as a business proposition it is a non-starter. 
 Most specialists advise sizing the CHP unit to cope with regular peak demand, make it work like crazy as Murrell suggests, and use current from the grid when demand outstrips the generator's capacity. 
 Forte's Penthouse Hotel in Manchester, is another example. 
 It has a 38kW gas-fuelled unit from Combined Power Systems which is achieving net savings of &pound;2,700 on energy bills with an annual gross electricity cost reduction of 61%. 
 Forte has gone over to CHP with enthusiasm. 
 The group has Combined Power Systems in 14 hotels with another 28 on order. 
 Most involve no capital outlay, being supplied under the discounted electricity purchase scheme. 
 Combined Power Systems, in conjunction with Norweb, installs the units and maintains them. 
 The hotelier buys the fuel. 
 The heat if free of charge and electricity generated is sold to the hotel at a discounted rate  set to show an overall saving against the fuel cost. 
 Offering similar schemes is Cogen Systems, part of Midlands Electricity. 
 Its zero outlay option is just that. 
 Its shared outlay option involves the hotelier paying the installation cost and buying fuel but having he system run and maintained by Cogen, with a consequently much lower electricity charge. 
 CHP sizes are cost-effective &mdash; now down to about 17kW electrical output &mdash; and suitable for the average 25-bedroom hotel. 
 However, in the absence of a restaurant or any other areas of demand for power and heat, such as a swimming pool or sauna, it pays to be cautious. 
 Checking the electricity bill will show if consumption is greater than, say, 20,000kW/hr a month. 
 If it is, investigate CHP. 
 First call could be to the CHP Association, an independent body which will send lists of member companies and general information. 
 Second call could be to those CHP companies prepared to offer a free initial energy analysis. 
 A questionnaire which asks about the systems now in use and for figures from electricity bills is all that is involved. 
 Among those who will do this are Combined Power Systems, SPP Energy and British Gas. 
 But generating or buying-in low-cost electricity and heat is pointless if the hotel wastes it. 
 There is obvious merit in good insulation, using only the most efficient kitchen appliances, heating systems and such. 
 But topping out with computerised control can save energy by matching usage accurately with need. 
 CONTROL 
 Building Energy Management (BEM) systems can now operate the CHP generation plant automatically, ramping its output up and down as reflected by the power load called for by the BEM's control of the building. 
 That control will include switching off heat and lights in unoccupied rooms, regulating heating systems to precise comfort control levels and running air conditioning only when the air sensors show it to be necessary. 
 This systems then bring all this together graphically on to a computer screen &mdash; which can be the hotel's back-office system to avoid duplication. 
 Honeywell's new Deltanet Graphic Central, for example, displays the status of comfort controls, energy management, fire and security systems fully integrated. 
 The operators can, of they have a mind to question the systems' automatic decisions, run through the status of the entire building or a single valve. 
 More importantly, the display highlights any system or area experiencing abnormal conditions, whether plant malfunction or unacceptable ambience levels. 
 How such systems are set is a matter for the hotelier. 
 Landis &amp; Gyr's new system in the new Forte Hotel in Exeter, Devon, for example, is usually set for guest and function rooms to be controlled at 20&deg;C between 6am and 10am and from 4pm to midnight. 
 At other times temperature is reduced to 18&deg;C unless, using local controls, guests set temperature to their own liking. 
 Water temperature to all areas is regulated in a similar manner, as is kitchen ventilation. 
 The new Holiday Inn at King's Cross, London, will also have a Landis &amp; Gyr system, controlling energy, fire and security systems and elevators when it opens next year. 
 One big cost in BEM system, wiring plant and rooms to the computer, can now be avoided by using the mains cabling itself as the data communication network. 
 Drayton Controls offers such a system which claims to have overcome the line noise problems experienced by earlier mains-data-line techniques. 
 Not all BEM efficiency relies on sophisticated computer control. 
 Allen-Martin includes in its range advanced energy management systems using techniques such as sonic sensors to determine when a room is occupied, but the company also has a more down-to-earth suggestion. 
 This a bedroom key for receptacle which turns on energy systems only when the fob is inserted &mdash; and turns them off again when the guest takes the key out to leave the room. 
 SAVINGS 
 At the Lakeside International Hotel in Camberley, Surrey, this idea alone was credited with saving &pound;3,500 a year &mdash; and the system only cost the hotel &pound;3,900. 
 Other examples of hotels saving large sums of money with BEMs include the Exeter Arms Hotel near Exeter, which saved &pound;1,700 a year in one of the earliest hotel examples of computerised BEM, a Drayton system, back in 1982. 
 These days BEM systems cost little or no more than conventional controllers so the Exeter Arms' payback period of two-and-a-half years would be much shorter today. 
 As a start in calculating one's own energy costs and spotting where the savings could be made, the department of Energy's Energy Efficiency Office has published two free booklets, both entitled Energy Efficiency in Buildings , in editions for hotels and catering establishments. 
 &bull; For details, contact the Energy Efficiency Office, 1 Palace Street, London SW1E 5HE. 
 CHP Association, 35&ndash;37 Grosvenor Gardens, London SW1W 0BS.  
 Drayton's MCS mains-borne system simplifies and reduces the cost of installation by utilising existing mains wiring 
 AWARDS 
 FEMALE TEAM WINS THROUGH TO FINAL 
 An all-female catering unit from Hainault, Essex, has won the first stage of a nationwide competition being held by Sutcliffe Catering to find the best Indian theme day at one of its units. 
 The eight women head Sutcliffe's catering unit at P&amp;O Containers at Hainault, and competed against 60 units from its City &amp; Central London/Essex region. 
 They received a &pound;500 Argos voucher from Caterplan and Booker Fitch Food Services and go forward to a grand final with Sutcliffe's five other regional winners. 
 Entries were judged on food presentation, staff dress, restaurant decor, innovation and increased covers, as well as the presentation of the entry. 
 ROYAL HONOUR FOR SLEATH 
 Shaun Sleath, operations director of Forte Penthouse Hotels in the Midlands, has been awarded the Prince Philip Medal 1991. 
 The medal, presented by the Duke of Edinburgh at Buckingham Palace, is awarded each year to a holder of a City &amp; Guilds qualification who has gone on to a senior management position in their chosen field. 
 This is the first time that the award has gone to somebody from the hotel and catering industry, or indeed from the service sector as a whole. 
 Mr Sleath gained his City &amp; Guilds certificates in catering and cookery at Huddersfield Polytechnic in 1968. 
 MONDAVI WINE SCHOLARSHIP 
 Andrew Salter of the Spa Hotel, Tunbridge Wells, Kent, has been awarded the Wine Guild of the UK 1991 Robert Mondavi Scholarship. 
 The judges were impressed with Mr Salter's initiative and ability in the selection, care and understanding of wine. 
 Mr Salter wins one week as the personal guest of Robert Mondavi at one of California's wineries. 
 The scholarship is open to those aged 21&ndash;30 with Wine and Spirit Higher Certificate or equivalent and who have been in full-time employment in the catering industry for at least two years or have experience of direct sales in on-licensed premises. 
 CHEMISTRY OF SUCCESS 
 More than 1,000 wines and spirits from 30 countries are undergoing detailed chemical analysis in the first stage of the 1991 International Wine and Spirit Competition. 
 A panel of six judges will choose winners after a series of stringent tests. 
 Twelve international and nine national trophies are to be awarded in different classes. 
 A trophy and bursary will be awarded to the Winemaker of the Year at a presentation on 14 October in London. 
 This year has seen a 30% increase in entries from South Africa, bringing its total to 160. 
 The USSR and Argentina have each made a submission for the fist time in the competition's history. 
 DOMINO'S EURO CHAMP 
 Bernard Hammon, manager of Domino's Pizza at Shepherd's Bush, London, has been voted the company's European Manager of the Year. 
 Twenty-four-year-old Mr Hammon received the award from Domino's Pizza founder and chairman Thomas Monaghan at the Domino's European Award banquet in Manchester. 
 The Manager of the year awards are open to Domino's staff who have been managers for more than nine months. 
 STAKIS MARKS STAFF SERVICE 
 Stakis Hotels recently presented Stakis Highland Lodges' Peter McIntosh with a &pound;1,000 travel voucher and a gold and diamond pin in recognition of his 25 years' service. 
 Two staff &mdash; Colin McKenzie, also of Stakis Highland Lodges, and Vincent di Nozzi of the Dunblane Hydro &mdash; received 20-year service awards of a gold watch plus a gold, emerald and diamond pin. 
 The Dunblane Hydro's general manager, Mike McCartan, and assistant bar manager Nick Darby, received 10-year awards of crystal decanters and glasses, plus gilt pins. 
 Stakis president Sir Reo Stakis presented the awards at Glasgow's Grosvenor Hotel. 
 In all, 24 staff were rewarded. 
 RITZ CHEF SETS RECORD 
 Guy Krenzer, senior sous chef at the Ritz, has become the youngest chef to be awarded the title of Meilleur Ouvrier de France (MOF). 
 Twenty-six-year-old Mr Krenzer receives his medal from President Mitterrand at the Elys&eacute;e Palace, Paris. 
 He joins Michel Roux as one of only two MOFs working in the UK. 
 HEART BEAT DOUBLE 
 A Hampshire leisure park's caterers have won two healthy eating awards, 
 The 170-seat Wagoners restaurant and the 60-seat Station Tearooms and Paultons Park, Romsey, Hampshire, have won Heartbeat Awards in the national Look After Your Heart campaign. 
 The Wagoners self-service restaurant offers hot and cold menus, and the Station Tearoom provides a variety of snacks on its menu. 
 &bquo;We have always demanded he highest standards from our catering staff,&equo; said Paulton's catering manager Gary Weldon-Jones. 
 &bquo;I believe that the new legislation and initiatives such as the Heartbeat Campaign should be welcomed because they can only serve to benefit the industry.&equo;  
 Through to the final: P&amp;O Containers, Hainault, Essex team in Sutcliffe Catering's Indian day competition (Left to right, rear): Dorothy Waldock, unit manager; Lorraine Webb, second chef; Clara Roberts and Maureen Talbot, catering assistants; Kerrie Thaddeus, head chef; (front) Catherine Hermon and Beryl Taylor, catering assistants. 
 The eighth member of the unit catering assistant, Stella Panayi, was on holiday at the time of the photograph. 
 See first story. 
 Krenzer: youngest MOF 
 MENUS 
 Dinners with a difference 
 written and selected by Francis Bissell 
 For once Bernard Gaume sat down and enjoyed dinner in the Chelsea Room. 
 I do not know if it was the first time since his appointment as executive chef at the Carlton Tower in 1968, but I do know it was a rare occurrence to see him even emerge from his kitchen, let alone dine. 
 On this occasion, however, he was driven out by a handful of his prot&eacute;g&eacute;s, now all executive chefs elsewhere in London. 
 They and many of Gaume's friends and colleagues came together one evening in May to celebrate his 40 years in the kitchens of the world with a sumptuous dinner, matched by a fine selection of wines. 
 David Chambers of Le Meridien was responsible for the foie gras starter, Vaughan Archer of the London Hilton for the broth of scallops, Martin Davies of Brown's Hotel for the wild salmon stuffed with tomato and cream courgettes. 
 The stuffed saddle of lamb was the work of John King of Les Ambassadeurs, and Martin Docket, chef p&acirc;tissier of The Connaught, prepared the apple pastry dessert. 
 The wines were all from excellent recent vintages, including the fine 1988 white burgundy and an Alsace wine, which perfectly complements foie gras with is light, grapey fragrance on the nose and multiple layers to flavour on the palate. 
 Clarets of 1981 are much in evidence now, following the introduction of the 10-year rule. 
 Indeed, many clarets, even the classified growths, are drinking before their 10th birthday while others, of course, will take much longer to come around. 
 Now is about right for many of the 1981s, which are, however, not great wines, but very engaging and drinkable and at relatively affordable prices, even those with the well-known names. 
 I was also sent details of a most interesting menu served at a banquet for Prince Charles and the Prince's Youth Business Trust held in Warwick Castle. 
 A vegetarian Indian banquet was prepared and managed by staff of the Bombay Brasserie, supported by the chef from the parent company, the Taj Group of Hotels in India. 
 According to Arun Harnal, one of the main challenges was the transport of the large charcoal-fired tandoor to the basement of the castle in order to make fresh naan bread for the dinner. 
 The descriptions of the dishes are tantalising indeed, starting with spinach fritter in &bquo;tangy sauces&equo; and yoghurt soup with white radish and pepper. 
 Next came a dish cooked to a recipe from the Royal House of Sailana, vegetables simmered in an almond and pistachio sauce, followed by aubergines stuffed with mint and coconut chutney and baked in a banana leaf. 
 A dish of crisp okra and one of basmati rice cooked in tomato juice and Indian herbs followed. 
 Fresh Alphonso mangoes and Indian petits fours completed the meal. 
 I imagine the royal visitor, and indeed most of the other guests, found the even a welcome change from the same old banquet menus! 
 THE CHELSEA ROOM 
 Hyatt Carlton Tower, London 
 OCCASION: Bernard Gaume's 40 years in the kitchens of the world, 15 May COVERS: 90 CHEFS: David Chambers, Vaughan Archer, Martin Davies, John King, Martin Dockett 
 FOOD AND BEVERAGE MANAGER: David Loewi 
 WARWICK CASTLE 
 Warwickshire 
 WINE: Mo&euml;t &amp; Chandon Champagne 
 OCCASION; Prince's Youth Business Trust Banquet, 21 May 
 COVERS: 95 
 CHEFS: Udit Sarkhel and Satish Arora 
 MANAGER: Arun Harnal of the Bombay Brasserie   
 Mark Clayton 
 Mark Clayton's cooking has grown in stature with his job responsibility. 
 Janet Harmer reports 
 Mark Clayton's cooking has progressed in the year he has been head chef at Eastwell Manor, near Ashford, Kent. 
 Now working in a larger kitchen and with more staff than in his previous position as head chef at Turner's restaurant in London, he is able to produce more intricate dishes with a greater number of components to them. 
 The development of Clayton's first course &mdash; a guinea fowl terrine with apple, celery and shallot dressing &mdash; is typical of many that now come out of kitchen. 
 &bquo;It was a team effort, starting life as a coarsely shopped terrine and developing into the layered terrine it now is, showing off the colours and textures of the ingredients,&equo; he says. 
 The roast fillet of lamb with herb crust to follow is a classic dish, presented by Clayton with great finesse. 
 The wild mushroom and leek timbale provides added interest and the sauce, made piquant by a combination of white wine and white wine vinegar, provides the perfect cutting foil to the fatty lamb. 
 &bquo;It's a well-balanced dish on which we've worked hard on both taste and presentation,&equo; Clayton says. 
 He describes the passion fruit mousse as the perfect dessert to finish a fairly rich and substantial meal. 
 &bquo;Although I love traditional British desserts such as jam sponge, I can never manage to eat them at the end of a three-course meal,&equo; Clayton says. 
 &bquo;This mousse gives a superb robust flavour, yet is light and very fresh tasting.&equo; 
 Wines to accompany Clayton's dishes have been chosen by Eastwell Manor's restaurant manager, Philip Ashworth. 
 To partner the terrine, Ashworth suggests a refreshing 1987 Cabernet Sauvignon ros&eacute; Simi. 
 &bquo;This won't upstage the strength of the terrine and will also make an ideal ap&eacute;ritif for a summer's day.&equo; 
 The delicate flavour of the English new season lamb needs something light and fruity, says Ashworth, recommending a red burgundy 1986 Aloxe-Corton. 
 The 1989 orange muscat flora from Brown Brothers is the choice to partner the dessert. 
 PASSION FRUIT MOUSSE WITH CREAM FILLED BRANDY SNAP 
 (Serves 4) 
 MOUSSE 4 passion fruit (garnish) &frac12;lb passion fruit pulp, using about 25 passion fruit 5oz double cream 4oz castor sugar 5 eggs 
 BRANDY SNAPS 2oz butter 2oz castor sugar 2oz flour 2oz glucose 
 CREAM FILLING &frac14;pt whipped cream dash white wine juice of &frac14; lemon icing sugar to taste 
 Mousse: whisk all ingredients together. 
 Strain and place in moulds. 
 Cook in a water bath at 350&deg;F for about 30 minutes. 
 Allow to cool. 
 Brandy snaps: mix all ingredients in a bowl. 
 Place thumbnail-size pieces on a baking tray and cook in a hot oven until golden brown. 
 Remove from oven, leave for about 1 minute then roll each in the shape of a cigarette. 
 Serve: turn the passion fruit mousse out on to the centre of the plate. 
 Fill the brandy snaps with the cream mix. 
 Scoop the pips out of the passion fruit, reserve for garnish. 
 Spread some on top of the mousse. 
 Place half a passion fruit on the plate with some pips falling out. 
 Arrange two brandy snaps on each plate and serve. 
 COARSE GUINEA FOWL TERRINE WITH APPLE, CELERY AND SHALLOT DRESSING 
 (Serves 12&ndash;15) 
 TERRINE 2 guinea fowls 6oz pork fat 8 shallots, chopped 1lb duck livers &frac18;pt port &frac18;pt madeira &frac18;pt veal stock &frac14;pt olive oil 1&frac12;lb bacon rashers freshly chopped herbs (chervil, tarragon, parsley, coriander and chives) salt, pepper brioche 
 SHALLOT DRESSING 15 shallots, finely chopped 1 dstsp finely diced celery 1 dstsp finely diced apple &frac14;pt white wine vinegar 4 cherry tomatoes 1 sprig fresh thyme 1 bay leaf 1lb mixed salad leaves (lollo rosso, curly endive and radicchio) olive oil, to taste 1 dstsp hazelnut oil salt, pepper 
 Terrine: remove the breasts and legs from guinea fowl. 
 Bone the legs and mince the leg meat, pork fat and 4oz of the duck livers through the coarse plate of the mincer. 
 Seal the breasts and remaining livers in hot olive oil, season and allow to cool. 
 Reduce the veal stock and alcohol by one third, allow to cool. 
 Add the chopped shallots, stock and herbs to the minced forcemeat and season. 
 Line a terrine with bacon rashers leaving an overlap for the top. 
 Fill the terrine with layers of forcemeat and guinea fowl breast. 
 Fold over the bacon to cover the top. 
 Cook in a water bath in an oven at 280&deg;F for about 45 minutes. 
 Sauce: place the chopped shallots in a pan and add the vinegar, thyme and bay leaf. 
 Bring to the boil and allow to cool. 
 Whisk in olive oil to taste and season with salt. 
 Serve: slice the terrine, place on centre of plate. 
 Toss the salad leaves lightly in hazelnut oil and season. 
 Quarter the cherry tomatoes. 
 Arrange the salad leaves and cherry tomatoes around the terrine. 
 Add some celery and apple to the shallot dressing and spoon around the guinea fowl terrine. 
 Serve with toasted brioche.  
 CAREER TO DATE 
 Mark Clayton joined Eastwell Manor as head chef just over a year ago. 
 He was previously head chef at Turner's restaurant, London. 
 His first position, after training at Thanet Technical College, Broadstairs, Kent, was at Boodle's, the London club. 
 This was followed by experience at the Capital Hotel, London, and the Toastmaster Inn, Burham, Kent, as chef de partie, before returning to the Capital Hotel as sous chef. 
 His next move, also as sous chef, was to Chez Nico to work for Nico Ladenis when he was at Shinfield, Berkshire. 
 He then took his first head chef position for the opening of Brian Turner's restaurant in 1986. 
 ENGLISH LAMB FILLET, ROASTED AND TOPPED WITH A HERB CRUST AND SERVED WITH A MUSHROOM AND LEEK TIMBALE IN A PIQUANT SAUCE 
 (Serves 4) 
 LAMB 1 pair of long best ends of lamb freshly chopped marjoram, mint, tarragon and parsley white breadcrumbs from &frac12; loaf of bread 1 tsp Dijon mustard 5 shallots, chopped &frac18;pt clarified butter &frac12;lb shiitake mushrooms &frac12;lb yellow pleurote mushroom 1lb leeks duck fat 
 PIQUANT SAUCE 2pt veal stock &frac18;pt white wine vinegar &frac18;pt white wine 2 shallots, sliced 4oz butter peppercorns bay leaf fresh thyme 
 THYME BUTTER fresh thyme 1 shallot &frac18;pt white wine &frac18;pt chicken stock dash white wine vinegar dash double cream 12oz butter 
 Sauce: reduce the white wine vinegar, white wine, shallots, peppercorns, bay leaf and thyme. 
 When almost dry add the veal stock and roasted lamb bones. 
 Simmer gently until reduced. 
 Pass through a muslin cloth and finish with the butter. 
 Lamb: remove fillets of lamb from the best ends. 
 Chop the bones and refine for the sauce. 
 Cut the lamb into four portions. 
 Wash and chop the leeks. 
 Blanch in boiling water quickly and refresh in cold water, drain. 
 Slice the mushrooms, reserve four small yellow pleurotes for garnish. 
 Saut&eacute; the mushrooms in duck fat and drain. 
 Mix the mushrooms and leeks and season. 
 Press the mix into a buttered timbale mould. 
 Wash and chop the fresh herbs. 
 Drain the excess water in a cloth but do not re-wash. 
 Prepare the breadcrumbs in a food processor, add the herbs, seasoning and chopped shallots (which have been cooked in a little white wine until dry). 
 Mix, adding some clarified butter to form a firm paste. 
 Thyme butter: reduce all the ingredients, except cream and butter. 
 When reduced, add cream, bring to boil. 
 Whisk in butter to taste. 
 Do not reboil. 
 Pass and keep warm. 
 Method: roast the lamb, keep pink. 
 Brush lamb lightly with Dijon mustard. 
 Apply the breadcrumbs, mix evenly and gratinate under a salamander until golden brown. 
 Warm the leek timbales in a steamer (or microwave if in a plastic mould). 
 Finish the sauce to correct consistency. 
 Saut&eacute; the four yellow pleurotes in duck fat, keep warm. 
 Serve: arrange the timbale in the centre of the plate. 
 Slice each portion of lamb into three pieces. 
 Top the timbale with a pleurote. 
 Spoon the piquant sauce around the lamb and spoon a little thyme butter over the timbale. 
 Serve immediately.  
 HOTELS 
 MARKETING MAGIC 
 A carefully targeted marketing plan ensured Balbirnie House an occupancy rate of over 50% during it first 18 months of business. 
 Lorna Pettipher reports 
 Balbirnie House, near Glenrothes in Fife, set itself a double challenge when it opened in November 1989: not only did it launch into a depressed economy, but during a traditionally poor month for Scottish hotels. 
 Yet the team of four businessmen which owns and operated Balbirnie House has achieved an average occupancy rate of 50%&ndash;60% ever since opening. 
 Resident at Balbirnie House from day one has been managing director Eric Brown, who initiated the project. 
 Since 1977 Brown had been looking to buy a business in Scotland, where his family, roots and contacts are. 
 He describes himself as a &bquo;career manager&equo; and has extensive experience of hotels. 
 Between 1973 and 1981 he was general manager at the Golf View Hotel in Nairn, during which time its turnover increased by 800%. 
 In the wake of this success, Brown planned to buy a going concern and turn round a business that was trading badly. 
 He spent almost 10 years looking for a Scottish hotel near a large population centre, but found nowhere suitable. 
 He also considered buying a castle in the Borders and converting it, but all the available properties were too distant from any population centres or local infrastructure of any significance. 
 Prices were too high in the Aberdeen area and, once again, people too thin on the ground on the West Coast. 
 As possible locations for a hotel became increasingly focused, Brown realised that he needed partners. 
 A banker introduced him to Balbirnie's future financial director Michael Thomson, a chartered accountant and managing director of Peter Thomson Wine Agencies in Perth. 
 They worked together for six months in project planning and Brown took a teaching job at the Strathclyde Business School which also allowed him to keep looking for hotel sites. 
 He was there for 18 months. 
 Alan Russell was the next partner to join the Balbirnie team. 
 He had sold Chapeltoun House in Ayrshire, which he had built up over 10 years, and was looking to invest in another business. 
 Brown had worked with Russell earlier in his career and both felt that their respective skills complemented one another. 
 &bquo;My commercial strengths are marketing, identifying opportunities and building up businesses,&equo; explained Brown. 
 &bquo;Alan Russell is a brilliant chef-proprietor. 
 We add to each other's abilities.&equo; 
 The final member to join the Balbirnie partnership was Nash Broaddus. 
 Broaddus &mdash; owner of Prodesco, a textile company in Pennsylvania, and an American with extensive business interests outside catering &mdash; was a friend and former hotel client of Brown, and had always wanted to be involved in the hospitality industry. 
 His partnership strengthened the Balbirnie team in shareholding terms, broadening its equity base. 
 Balbirnie House was purchased from the Glenrothes Development Corporation (GDC). 
 The 200-year-old mansion was once the home of the Balfours of Balbirnie and them the headquarters of the GDC. 
 The freehold was purchased at a reasonable price in a complicated deal that allowed for a sensitive refurbishment of the grade 1-listed building and a limit of 30 hotel bedrooms. 
 Two million pounds was spent on the ensuing refurbishment, which took approximately 10 months. 
 &bquo;We didn't know until September 1989 whether we would be open or not before Christmas,&equo; recalls Brown. 
 &bquo;But November 1989 it was, so we had to hold back and then &bquo;go for it&equo; very late in the day to launch the hotel. 
 We have had to spend a disproportionate amount of money on marketing and selling.&equo; 
 The disproportionate amount in question has been nearer 10% of the annual budget, in comparison to the 5% that Brown would normally expect to spend in marketing a new hotel. 
 There were about 25 cocktail parties to launch Balbirnie, and employees from other hotels in the region were among the guests. 
 &bquo;We did everything that we could  think of to get the name Balbirnie flying up there,&equo; Brown says. 
 &bquo;Advertising in the local and national Scottish press raised awareness of our existence. 
 Inviting other hotels' employees to see Balbirnie made our name and product familiar to them. 
 We could then be recommended to people by them when their hotels were full. 
 We offered prizes in competitions and made donations to charities.&equo; 
 Brown describes his product as a country mansion in a 400-acre park. 
 He identifies potential markets and then targets them individually, although sometimes interests clash. 
 &bquo;Even at a local event, marketing can be complicated. 
 If you go for the business community in Glenrothes you risk losing the rest of the local market, who may perceive the hotel as too upmarket for them. 
 Our bar lunches, for example, are as reasonable as any hotel's in the area. 
 Yet customers walk through an entrance with 24ft stone pillars to reach our bar and they expect prices to be high in such an environment.&equo; 
 Bar meals act as an important shop window for the hotel &mdash; a means of attracting potential customers to the restaurant or to stay &mdash; and staff at Balbirnie always give personal tours to anyone wishing to view the hotel. 
 So, despite high overheads, bar meal prices at Balbirnie are deliberately kept at a competitive level. 
 Room rates are pitched at &pound;69 for a single and up to &pound;140 for a de luxe double. 
 Dinner in the main restaurant is &pound;22 a head without wine. 
 A programme of national and international guest-chef visits to Balbirnie, to cook with head chef George Mackay, has also helped to raise its profile. 
 Brown's working day starts at 6.30am and doesn't really end. 
 He expects to stay at the hotel for some years to come to oversee operations. 
 &bquo;I have never had to run so fast in a job in my life, and the incredible speed of things at the moment is all thanks to the recession,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;My job now is to focus on areas that yield business and pare down initiatives that have not been fruitful. 
 Incentive markets, conference markets, Scottish Tourist Board and British Tourist Authority contacts are all working well for us. 
 The trick is to keep bringing in people to view Balbirnie &mdash; business clubs, individuals &mdash; anyone.&equo;  
 Balbirnie House 
 Eric Brown, the initiator and managing director of Balbirnie House 
 PRISON CATERING 
 JAIL BREAK 
 Inmates work successfully alongside prison officers to produce 2,400 meals a day at Pentonville prison. 
 Natalie Valios reports 
 The kitchen looks like any other to be found in an establishment catering for large numbers. 
 But there is one big difference &mdash; excluding supervisors, it is manned by people who don't want to be there. 
 For these are the kitchens at HM Prison Pentonville in North London. 
 Built in 1872, the Victorian prison has had its fair share of history. 
 It was originally used for prisoners waiting to be deported to Australia, and it also housed the infamous Crippen and Christie who were both hanged and buried there. 
 Pentonville is still an all-male prison where inmates continue to slop out, although a new sanitary system with toilets is being installed. 
 The prison caters for short-term stays, with one-third of prisoners being unconvicted and awaiting trial. 
 About 28 inmates and nine officers, including woman officer Alison Ashton, work shifts to produce 2,400 meals a day for the 800 inmates. 
 Everything, including peeling vegetables, baking bread and butchering meat, is done on-site. 
 The kitchen at Pentonville was built in 1977, but a new one is planned for installation in a couple of years. 
 Surrounded by potential weapons, an inmate has to be given the all-clear by the prison's hard labour board to ensure potentially dangerous prisoners do not work in the kitchen. 
 As an extra precaution, the kitchen has a &bquo;shadow cabinet&equo; containing all the knives and butchering implements. 
 The locked cabinet was so named because there is a painted black shadow behind each knife to enable officers to keep a tally of those in use. 
 Two seemingly harmless items which inmates are forbidden to touch are essences and yeast. 
 These items are kept locked away as essences can make a lethal cocktail and yeast can be used to make hooch, an illicit drink. 
 Catering responsibilities for the prison lie with Mike Lamb, a prison governor whose title is G5 Caterer. 
 After training as a chef, he completed three years' National Service in the Army, and worked as a sales representative and marketing manager. 
 He later bought a restaurant in Scotland, before taking out a lease on a hotel in Scarborough, North Yorkshire. 
 Lamb, 53, joined Pentonville 11 years ago. 
 After spending six months as a landing officer, he moved to the kitchens. 
 &bquo;Instead of looking after paying guests, I'm now looking after unpaying ones!&equo; he says. 
 For Lamb, catering is a very satisfying part of being a prison officer, but he does have dissatisfactions: &bquo;I don't think the rations are enough and there isn't enough variety. 
 What we produce is monotonous.&equo; 
 The kitchen staff have to cater for all diets from vegan to diabetic, and from Muslim to Jewish. 
 Religious festivals are always observed. 
 In the bakery, which operates from 6am to 3pm, 400 loaves are baked daily, along with rolls, cakes, pizzas and quiches. 
 It is cheaper to bake on the premises than buy-in food. 
 When the ovens broke down it cost more than &pound;1,200 a week to buy in the necessary items. 
 A weekly allowance of &pound;13.14 is provided for each prisoner, plus an additional weekly supplement of 29p for meat-eating prisoners and 39p per week for vegetarians and vegans. 
 &bquo;With this I can buy anything I like as long as it's food from suppliers approved by the Home Office,&equo; Lamb says. 
 Inmates are allowed two pieces of fresh fruit a week bought from another allowance of 20p. 
 Vegetables, milk and bacon come from a 400-acre prison farm, Hollesly Bay Colony in East Anglia. 
 There are eight prison farms in the UK run by the Home Office Farm and Gardens Department. 
 Lamb stresses the importance of keeping to a strict timetable for meals. 
 &bquo;We are not providing food in a normal environment,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;It wouldn't matter if you were at home and lunch was half an hour late. 
 Here the routine timing of food, letters and visits is of prime importance.&equo; 
 Breakfast is at 8am, lunch 11.15 am and tea (main meal) at 4.15pm. 
 The last meal is scheduled early because of the shift rota operated by officers. 
 All food is cleared away by 5pm. 
 The prison is locked up, the inmates are counted and the main staff go off duty. 
 A supper is served later in the evening. 
 A typical daily menu would be: breakfast &mdash; tea, porridge, bread with margarine and jam or marmalade, boiled egg; lunch &mdash; tea, soup and roll, beef curry or savoury mince, rice, peas and cabbage; tea &mdash; bread and margarine, chicken cutlet or meat and potato pie, mashed potatoes, marrow fat peas, tomato gravy, bread pudding and custard, tea; supper &mdash; trifle, tea. 
 A vegetarian and vegan option is always offered. 
 &bquo;We operate a menu to get the best out of the rations,&equo; Lamb says. 
 &bquo;We have to balance it so they last seven days. 
 It wouldn't do to run out of flour on day five. 
 Bread and pastries  in particular play an important role in the prison diet because of the roughage and carbohydrate content. 
 Food prepared in the kitchen is eaten only by the inmates. 
 The officer's mess is a simple operation outside the prison gates where an appointed officer prepares meals for his colleagues. 
 Only two outsiders are permitted to eat from the kitchen &mdash; the governor, who has to sample one meal every day to be able to answer any complaints the following day, and the doctor, who tastes the food two or three times a week to ensure that it is balanced and nutritious. 
 A 50g sample of each food item must be kept for 72 hours in case there is an outbreak of food poisoning. 
 There hasn't been one yet. 
 Prisons are exempt from having regular visits from environmental health officers, but in April 1992 this Crown Immunity will be lifted. 
 Senior officer Ken Sweeney said that the prison was already operating within the provisions of the new Food Safety Act: &bquo;Although we don't have to, we already invite in EHOs because we have nothing to hide and are open to advice.&equo; 
 Sweeney has worked at Pentonville for almost nine years and is in charge of the general kitchen floor. 
 He works under Lamb. 
 &bquo;Inmates want to work in the kitchen because it means they can be out of their cells for most of the day and can have a bit of extra food,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;But they tend to be heavy handed with the equipment, which generally lasts only half its normal life here.&equo; 
 Sweeney points to the stressful nature of the job: &bquo;Prison officers used to join from the Forces,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;I was a ship's cook in the Merchant Navy and used to handling men. 
 But now prison officers are taken from all walks of life.&equo; 
 In case of trouble when handling prisoners, alarms are positioned at strategic points around the prison. 
 Within one minute of being triggered, the alarm summons about 50 staff to the problem spot. 
 Its function is to stop injury to staff and prisoners alike. 
 As Lamb says: &bquo;It's a lifeline.&equo; 
 &bull; A version of this article first appeared in Caterer &amp; Hotelkeeper  's sister publication Baking Update .  
 TRICON II 
 LIGHT at the end of the TUNNEL 
 The Cassons are now coming round to Tricon's point of view, but still need a bit of convincing. 
 Janet Harmer reports on the action they still need to take to meet their projected targets 
 THE STORY SO FAR 
 Philip and Lesley Casson bought the Valley Hotel in Ironbridge, Shropshire, for &pound;415,000. 
 In the past three years they have spent &pound;1m transforming the former run-down pub on the banks of the River Severn into an attractive 34-bedroom hotel with restaurant and conference facilities. 
 However, the combined effects of the recession and greater competition caused by the opening of new hotels in nearby Telford, together with a narrow marketing plan, have resulted in bedroom occupancy falling short of the Cassons' achieved target of 50%. 
 Tricon Foodservice Consultants has been brought in to give advice, but the Cassons have had some difficulty in accepting the drastic measures needed to ensure survival. 
 After lengthy consideration Philip and Lesley Casson now believe they can achieve the sales and labour cost targets contained in Tricon's projections, outlined last week. 
 But, unfortunately, they are having great difficulty in accepting the need to cut overhead costs, which are still far in excess of the target of 18% of turnover and are preventing the Valley Hotel from making a projected net profit by the end of the year. 
 The greatest area of concern involving overhead costs are: leasing and rental charges; heat, light and power; advertising; and sundry costs. 
 Leasing costs are high because some equipment purchased as part of the redevelopment was funded on leasing agreements. 
 In order to achieve a profit in the projected turnover, these costs must be halved. 
 The Cassons need to review each item on lease and consider whether to return it and cancel the lease, re-finance the lease on a longer term or seek a moratorium on payments. 
 One item on lease is a new in-house laundry which was acquired when high bedroom occupancy was anticipate and its was though that the hire cost of linen would be more expensive. 
 As well as reviewing the leasing of equipment, they must also consider the power and labour associated with the laundry. 
 The high cost of heat, light and power means that the Cassons need to seek advice form the utility companies over tariffs, rates and off-peak usage. 
 In the meantime, specific cost-cutting exercises need to be considered to bring the cost for the next six months down to about &pound;9,000. 
 The Cassons' current advertising costs are high, so maybe now is the time to concentrate on direct selling. 
 A new budget of &pound;1,500 for the next six months should be enough for local advertising. 
 Since last week's article, May's operating results for the Valley Hotel have been produced, showing a welcome increase in sales which indicate that the medium level sales shown in Tricon's profit and loss projection are achievable. 
 MARKETING PLAN 
 The Valley Hotel is competing directly with three- and four-star hotels &mdash; all of which have greater marketing resources &mdash; in the Telford area. 
 These hotels are offering competitive corporate business rates, as well as superior accommodation and leisure facilities which the Valley Hotel does not have. 
 But the hotel does have the advantage of being able to offer a scenic and historic location and the more personalised level of service that a small independent hotel can offer. 
 Tricon strongly advises the Cassons to realign the hotel's position in the marketplace to take advantage of currently untapped business. 
 The need to cut operating costs will restrict the time, energy and financial resources available to promote the hotel. 
 BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES 
 Overnight tourist visitors 
 The Valley Hotel is ideally situated to appeal to the overnight tourist, mid-week and weekend break markets. 
 But in the past the Cassons have not benefited from this market due to a reluctance  to offer competitive rates, service and special promotions. 
 The Valley is the only three-star hotel in the Ironbridge Gorge. 
 Also, there are 37 rooms in other hotels and inns, over 100 rooms in guest houses and B&amp;Bs and accommodation for 80 people in self-catering &mdash; all representing a sizeable market for evening restaurant and bar business. 
 The Cassons can develop this market by: &bull; Cultivating links with the Ironbridge Gorge Trust accommodation office and offering discounted rates and packages for chance bookings. 
 &bull; Offering midweek packages at competitive rates &bull; Creating an autumn-winter weekend break package and Christmas programme, and promoting them by sending a mailshot to all past guests. 
 &bull; Exploring the benefits of joining a hotel consortium. 
 &bull; Distributing sample menus and information to local B&amp;Bs not offering evening meals; inviting owners for a free meal and making a special offer for guests. 
 &bull; Offering retail sales within the hotel, eg local guides, souvenirs, chocolates. 
 Day tourist visitors 
 The Valley Hotel has three prime attractions to day tourist visitors &mdash; a large car park, excellent facilities for children and a large garden area leading directly to parkland and the River Severn. 
 Facilities for morning coffee and afternoon teas are very limited in the Gorge and opportunities exist for the Valley Hotel to service individual tourists  and coach tours. 
 This can be achieved by: &bull; Leaflet drops and advertising at local tourist sites. 
 &bull; Changing hotel signage to offer a more welcome image to non-residents. 
 &bull; Encouraging use of the restaurant and bars for families through children's menus, Sunday lunch menus, barbecues and special events. 
 &bull; Targeting coach companies and tour operators covering the Gorge. 
 &bull; providing coffee and afternoon tea facilities &mdash; perhaps in the grounds and in the mews conservatory area. 
 Local social use 
 The completion of the new function suite offers the Cassons tremendous scope to promote the hotel as a social venue for local residents, associations and businesses. 
 It is an ideal location for wedding receptions, having large attractive grounds. 
 They could achieve this by: &bull; Developing a Christmas programme. 
 &bull; Developing a children's menu, Sunday family lunches and barbecues. 
 &bull; Drawing up a programme of special events in the bar and restaurants and encouraging local newspaper coverage. 
 &bull; Leaflet drops through newspaper deliveries, free newspapers, door-to-door, and at major local events. 
 &bull; Using events held in the hotel, such as craft fairs, to promote other hotel facilities. 
 &bull; Developing links with local societies and associations, such as the Lions, Rotary, Chamber of Commerce and Women's Institute. 
 Corporate business 
 A comprehensive programme of action to increase corporate business could include: &bull; Inviting conference organisers and representatives from local companies to the hotel for open days and lunches. 
 &bull; Forming a secretaries' club to offer discounts on meals, special interest events, wine-tastings, cookery demonstrations, sports days, hen nights etc. &bull; Developing a Christmas programme aimed at office parties. 
 &bull; Special offers for midweek residents such as wine of the month and bar promotions. 
 &bull; Discount rates for back-to-back bookings to encourage use by contract engineers currently using the Travelodge and guest houses. 
 &bull; Offering free accommodation for spouses. 
 PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT 
 Despite the hotel's attractive riverside location, there are both internal and external elements which need further attention to maximise the hotel's potential. 
 First, the hotel entrance, located on a main road, is fairly anonymous to passers-by. 
 Ideally, the hotel name should feature prominently on a large sign, either over the gateway opening or mounted above the wall each side of the entrance and angled to face incoming traffic. 
 At the same time as new signs are being made, the hotel name could be changed. 
 &bquo;Valley&equo; alone is a rather anonymous name and does not capitalise on the hotel's location. 
 Tricon suggested that the &bquo;Ironbridge Valley Hotel&equo; is an improvement and probably more easily remembered. 
 Although the hotel's car park is a good size and is easily accessible, the large expanse of tarmac in front of the hotel tends to project an institutional image which could be softened by planting some trees and shrubs in large tubs. 
 The Cassons could capitalise on the hotel's pleasant gardens by introducing outdoor furniture and parasols. 
 This would help attract passing visitors to stop for a drink or meal and would visually soften the rather bleak appearance of the exterior brickwork. 
 Access to the bars and restaurant is currently achieved only through the hotel reception. 
 An external door to the main bar does exist and should be clearly indicated with external signs and menu boards. 
 The most attractive feature of the hotel interior is the layout and design of the new bedroom extension as a series of mews cottages reached by a conservatory courtyard. 
 This has the potential to be developed as a revenue-producing area. 
 With the addition of caf&eacute;-style furniture, planning and decorative lighting, it could be a pleasant caf&eacute; operation serving teas, coffees and snacks, as well as acting as a focus of activity. 
 There are two serveries in the bar, with seating accommodation divided by a double doorway. 
 One of the bar serveries could be removed, releasing extra space and removing the need for double manning. 
 The resulting room could be used for private parties and conference meals. 
 Tricon believes the restaurant suffers from its name, Chez Maw. 
 Tricon managing director Tony Horton says; &bquo;It sounds inelegant, its meaning is esoteric and I suspect it acts as a deterrent to potential external customers.&equo; 
 The restaurant offers an extensive &agrave; la carte menu, with average spend for a three-course meal with coffee at &pound;20 a head. 
 There is also a three-course menu of the day for under &pound;13, but almost total emphasis is put on the promotion of the &agrave; la carte menu. 
 &bquo;Careful consideration should be given to re-marketing the restaurant by introducing a style of menu that is more appropriate in style, content and price for the identified target markets,&equo; Horton says. 
 These basic proposals for the development of the hotel need not cost a great deal: Outside signage &pound;2,000 medium term External planting &pound;500 long term External furniture &pound;1,500 short term Reception lighting &pound;300 short term af&eacute; facility &pound;2,500 long term Restaurant development &pound;1,000 medium term 
 Tricon defines short term as being implemented this summer, medium term as within six months and long term as within one year. 
 &bull; Next week in the final part of this series, Tricon assesses the long-term future for the Valley Hotel.  
 Philip and Lesley Casson were strongly advised to realign the hotel's position in the marketplace 
 LIQUID ASSETS 
 Simply English 
 Brian Jordan looks at a selection of English wines, and some of the opportunities they provide 
 More English wines are beginning to appear on wine lists as growers become increasingly professional about their production and marketing. 
 While the quality of English wines can now compare with estate-grown and bottled wines from Germany or Alsace &mdash; in that they are fairly uniform &mdash; they bear the crisply full-flowered taste we often look for in a good table wine or aperitif. 
 Well over 50% of restaurants in the UK now include English wines on their lists. 
 Many report that customers are beginning to show growing interest as awareness of traditional English food increases. 
 But they admit the interest is still largely experimental and that demand comes mainly from foreign tourists willing to try English fare. 
 The UK wine industry's new-found potential is largely a result of the planting of grape varieties more suited to our climate. 
 There are now more than 500 English vineyards, with the northernmost near Leeds where the temperature reached 94&deg;F last August. 
 A vineyard was recently planted at Spennymore, County Durham. 
 The largest 25 producers account for more than 50% of the area planted and it is their names which are most often seen on merchant's lists. 
 Originally, most English vineyards contained the dull M&uuml;ller-Thurgau grape, produced years ago by cropping the classic but late-ripening Riesling with the workhorse Sylvaner to produce a grape that appealed to few drinkers. 
 Although much has been learned in England about producing better wine from the M&uuml;ller-Thurgau, it is in Germany where profits have financed research into better grapes for northern climates. 
 There, with names like Reichensteiner, Huxelrube, Faber and Bacchus, we find grapes better suited to our growing conditions. 
 Efforts with red grapes can, however, be described only as experimental, with the wines produced tending towards a deep ros&eacute; rather than a true red colour. 
 Don't be surprised by label names like Rosa Muscat, Auxerrois, Kerner/Kerning, Huxelvaner and others. 
 SPARKLING 
 Sparkling wine is still at the fledgling stage, but developments are taking place. 
 Those merchants offering Brut sparkling wine produced by the M&eacute;thode Champenoise include Carr Taylor (0424 752501) in Sussex, Lamberhurst (0892 890286) in Kent and Moorlynch (0458 210393) in Somerset. 
 Tenterden on the Kent/Sussex border (058 06 3033) is just releasing its first pink bubbly using mainly Pinot Noir grapes. 
 If organic is what you seek &mdash; and this is fast becoming big business &mdash; then try Dr Hugh Tripp's fully organic Seyval wine from Avalon in Somerset (0749 86393). 
 Another is Bewl Valley wines, produced by the Chapman family at the Bewl Valley Vineyard (0580 241741) near Tunbridge Wells, East Sussex, from Bacchus and Faber varieties. 
 Bewl Valley is beginning to reap the benefits after its first crop in 1987. 
 Bottles from this region sell wholesale at about &pound;72 a case. 
 Most English wines have a fine fruit structure and a racily crisp freshness, so they are well matched to lightly flavoured fish &mdash; especially fish such as trout &mdash; and to light poultry dishes. 
 Chicken risotto and typically English dishes like rabbit pie, ham and chicken pie, and roast pork or veal accept the fruity dry palate of M&uuml;ller-Thurgau or Seyval. 
 These wines also make a good accompaniment for vegetarian dishes, especially leek-based dishes. 
 If you serve English wines, remember not to over-chill them. 
 A cellar temperature of 10&deg;C (50&deg;F) is ideal. 
 Expect to pay about &pound;50 to &pound;60 a case for English wines, which will never be cheap because crop levels are seldom high and most vineyards are small. 
 Those wine merchants that do sell cases below the &pound;50 barrier are Berkmann (071&ndash;609 4711) for Chiltern Valley; Deinhard Adgestone (071&ndash;261 1111); Eldridge Pope selling Wraxhall (0305 251251); Quellyn Robert, selling Lamberhurst (0244 310455) and Grants of St James with Saxon Valley, Tenterden and Staple St James. 
 Remember that more English wine is sold direct from vineyards than is offered through wine merchants, and in this way you can often negotiate a better price.  
 Lamberhurst, Kent &mdash; one of the vineyards which offers sparkling wine produced by M&eacute;thode Champenoise 
 FRYERS 
 Fried and tested 
 Manufacturers have been oiling the wheels of technology to make fryers slicker with the help of computerisation. 
 Many recent developments have resulted from the demands of large users wanting more from their fryers. 
 David Mascord reports 
 The humble fryer has come a long way since the days when it was little more than a heating element and a thermostat. 
 Although advances such as secondary high-limit thermostats, which cut off the power if the fryer overheats, are now fitted as standard on almost all machines, there have been plenty of other developments. 
 These include an increasing trend towards automation and computerisation and a greater awareness of methods for making effective, economic use of oil. 
 Large chains, such as McDonald's and Beefeater, spend thousands of pounds on research into frying technology and on the best ways of cooking their staple menu item, French fries. 
 To these large organisations frying is virtually a science. 
 Often co-operating with reputable frying equipment manufacturers and suppliers, they test everything from the critical point at which a food product fries best, to the recovery times for oil temperatures. 
 Consequently, many of the recent developments in deep-fat fryers have resulted from the demands of these large customers and from the manufacturers' experiences in supplying machinery designed to survive the hectic pace of the fast food industry. 
 In the long term, hotel and restaurant caterers at all levels will benefit from this co-operation because any innovations will eventually be offered as an option or even a standard fitting on the models if frying equipment they purchase. 
 But it is worth investing in brand new, state-of-the-art equipment for what is argued by some to be an unhealthy form of cooking? 
 And isn't there a danger that the demand for food cooked in deep-fat fryers will dwindle as a result of increasing publicity about healthy eating? 
 David Miles is national sales manager for Frankie Catering Equipment, supplier of electric Fri Fri machines, whose prices range from &pound;220 for a &bquo;D&equo; series counter-top model to about &pound;6,500 for the latest computerised suite. 
 Miles does not think that this is the case and believes frying is healthy, profitable and popular. 
 &bquo;Alongside the coffee machine, a fryer is the most profitable piece of machinery in a restaurant &mdash; providing you use the right equipment for your purposes. 
 As far as Fri Fri is concerned, running costs are equal to half a penny for every pound of fried product,&equo; he says. 
 Like many others in the industry, Miles points to the number of fast food outlets opening every day as an indication of the continuing popularity of deep-fried foods and adds that unhealthy frying is caused principally by poor frying practices. 
 &bquo;Frying is basically healthy because, if the temperature of the oil is correct, you seal the food instantly. 
 It becomes unhealthy if you overload the amount of product; use the wrong fryer for the job; or if you don't allow for the recovery period of the oil temperature.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you put a frozen product into oil heated to 180&deg;C the temperature will immediately drop to maybe 145&deg;C, so it is important to allow for the  recovery rate to let the oil return to 180&deg;C to brown the chip. 
 &bquo;Allowing for the recovery period is also important as far as the next cooking cycle is concerned. 
 Otherwise, if the oil is not at the right temperature, you end up boiling the food rather than deep-frying it.&equo; 
 Miles recently visited the Electricity Association's testing laboratories to observe experiments on frying temperatures. 
 The tests showed that if a product which should be cooked at 180&deg;C is deep-fried at the correct temperature to seal it and is cooked as recommended, it will absorb only 6% of its weight in oil. 
 However, when a product is fried at 10&deg;C below the recommended temperature it absorbs 32% of its weight in oil. 
 &bquo;Quite simply,&equo; Miles concludes, &bquo;frying itself is not a bad process to use but the deep-fat fryer has to be used correctly.&equo; 
 The need to educate people, both to use deep-fat fryers properly and to clean and filter oil regularly, is a factor also referred to by sales and marketing director for Garland Catering Equipment, Keith Davies. 
 Garland supplies a range of gas and electric models, including what it claims to be the world's largest selling fryer, the Master Jet MJ35. 
 &bquo;The biggest mistake caterers make is to put too many chips in a basket at a time. 
 The trick is to do it little and often &mdash; notice what they do in the fast food chains,&equo; Davies says. 
 &bquo;Also caterers don't clean and filter often enough. 
 People will spend more on cooking oil during the lifetime of the machine that they did on the initial capital cost of the machine. 
 They will spend more than &pound;40 a week on oil &mdash; that's &pound;2,000 a year &mdash; but you could spend &pound;3,000 on a modern filter system and that will be paid back in 18 months.&equo; 
 Garland recently introduced its Footprint filter system, designed to fit under the Master Jet range of fryers. 
 It is an entirely &bquo;hands off&equo; method of filtration capable of filtering up to six fryers without moving from fryer to fryer. 
 An increasing number of suppliers of deep-fat fryers and accessories are trying to make the potentially messy process of filtration easier for caterers and many of their latest products reflect this awareness. 
 Just three examples are: a mobile filtration unit (price &pound;1,341) from G.F.E. Bartlett, which heats filtered oil to prevent it becoming viscous; the mobile Fastfilter from Fast International, featuring a roller pump to ensure any solidified fat is pumped out and so, the company says, eliminating the need for heater coils; and Stott Benham's Fry-Saver, which costs &pound;1,600 until 1 August, and is claimed to increase efficiency by providing 15 times more filtering area than standard filter paper. 
 Fish and chip shop chain Harry Ramsden's has recently installed &pound;100,000-worth of Florigo frying equipment in its Guiseley, West Yorkshire, Blackpool and Glasgow outlets as part of a massive kitchen refurbishment programme. 
 The Guiseley installation is custom-built and consists of one eight-pan and one nine-pan range. 
 It has to cope with anything from 100 to 400 customers at a time. 
 &bquo;The main advantage of the new fryers is the technology. 
 They are gas with electronic ignition and thermostatic control. 
 The controls are set to cook chips at 185&deg;C and the temperature is displayed on the front of the suite which means the fryer doesn't have to keep his eye on each pan,&equo; says general manager Andrew Harding. 
 The Florigo fryers have a combination of round and square pans. 
 The square pans are for fish and the round &bquo;rapid recovery pans&equo; are for chips. 
 The shapes prevent them from bunching together. 
 &bquo;With the previous pans we used you had 22lbs of chips ready at one time and about half way through you tended to lose the quality because some of the chips would get sweaty. 
 The new pans mean we have fewer chips ready more often.&equo; 
 The other main benefit Harding sees is the internal filtration system in the Florigo fryer: &bquo;You can filter from one pan to another, drain the pan into a filtration tank and you can pump that into any other frying basin. 
 You can also filter four or five times a day.&equo; 
 His recommendation to other caterers is to consider a unit with an internal filter  system simply because it means oil can be re-used, maybe three times a day. 
 Also, in his view, it saves on fuel and oil costs. 
 Some of the latest equipment is designed to use automation to cope with the combined problems of filtration and misuse of equipment by staff. 
 Garland developed the first on-site programmable deep-fat fryers as a result, Davies says, of difficulties caused by rapid staff turnover and the use of unskilled labour. 
 &bquo;Caterers need to offer a consistent food product to their customers. 
 Consistency comes from either using the same staff all the time &mdash; which is unusual &mdash; or from automation. 
 &bquo;Also you now have the phenomenon of the demographic time bomb. 
 In the next few years there will be fewer young people and these tend to make up the majority of staff in many outlets, so caterers &mdash; and particularly the large chains &mdash; will come to rely more on automation in the near future.&equo; 
 One main advantage of computer control is that it can differentiate between real time and elastic time. 
 This means that if, for example, the cooking cycle is programmed for two-and-a-half minutes at a required temperature the machine will adjust to compensate for the fall in temperature which occurs when a frozen or chilled food will have been cooked for two-and-a-half minutes at the correct temperature. 
 Other automated items such as baskets and shake alarms (signalling the moment during cooking when it is necessary to shake the basket so as to ensure even cooking throughout) are already available as an option on many machines, while some units will even tell you when to change the oil! 
 US-made Broaster pressure fryers from Fast Food Systems offer the latter function. 
 Again these machines are computer monitored (a feature which is common on units from the USA and now more in evidence on European-made machines) with the computer simply emitting a beep and flashing up a &bquo;filter now&equo; sign when filtration should take place. 
 Pressure fryers are machines with a tight-sealing lid (rather like an oversized pressure cooker) designed to allow faster cooking at lower temperatures. 
 The cover over the top allows the moisture which comes off the food to stay beneath the oil and seal it. 
 Similar units are also available from Servequip and Barbeque King and are usually offered in both gas and electric versions. 
 Pressure fryers are used principally for dishes such as chicken, fish and mushrooms &mdash; but not chips &mdash; where the requirement is to keep the food moist. 
 Price may prohibit caterers who don't aim to specialise in this sort of food product. 
 The cheapest electric Broaster costs about &pound;3,750, with prices rising to &pound;6,150. 
 All have in-built filters. 
 Fast Food Systems supplies pressure fryers to Southern Fried Chicken outlets. 
 Bryan Soppitt, sales director for Fast Food Systems, which also supplies standard Dean fryers, agrees with his colleagues in the frying industry that the trend is toward de-skilling the frying operation so as to rely less on staff in order to achieve quality and consistency in the end product. 
 Soppitt foresees an increasing move to hands off filtration and stresses that oil must be treated gently. 
 &bquo;Looking after your oil is paramount &mdash; the oil companies are always trying to educate their customers. 
 People who mix old and new oil or just keep topping it up are sacrificing the good oil for the bad. 
 &bquo;Also certain operators are seduced by the price of cheap oil. 
 In pressure fryers especially, you need a quality oil because cheap oil will break down quickly under pressure. 
 &bquo;Even though we try to tell this to our customers, some of them will pay &pound;3,300 for a Broaster and then buy cheap oil. 
 If they want a good quality product, and they want a good life for their oil, they will have to buy good oil. 
 &bquo;We recommend vegetable or groundnut oil &mdash; this also means that the food product is healthier because the frying medium is better.&equo; 
 Most companies are willing to give customers the best service they can, and virtually all suppliers interviewed stressed their eagerness to talk to caterers about their individual needs to as to match the right product to the right task. 
 It is well worthwhile getting plenty of advice and shopping around. 
 BUYING TIPS 
 &bull; Choose the right fryer for your application; don't buy solely on price. 
 &bull; Consider your power and volume needs. 
 For electric machines one supplier offers this rough guide: look at the ratio of kilowatts (kW) power to litres of oil &mdash; you need roughly 1.5kW per litre of heated oil (heated oil is above the element). 
 In the case of gas models. 
 experts now believe you must think in terms of how much you need to produce. 
 Zanussi's 701 range and G. F. E. Bartlett machines, for example, are judged by the size of the batch cooked in each cycle. 
 &bull; Is the fryer available in free-standing form or is it available as a modular unit to build into a suite? 
 &bull; Does the fryer have a fast and efficient recovery time? 
 &bull; How easy is it to clean? 
 Under the new hygiene regulations fryers are likely to come under close scrutiny because traditionally the job of cleaning them is one of the worst in the kitchen. 
 Does the fryer break down into easily manageable parts? 
 If electric, do the elements lift up to allow for thorough cleaning? 
 Does it have castors for all-round access? 
 &bull; What safety features are available? 
 Is there a good quality second thermostat? 
 If it is a gas fryer, does it have a flame failure device? 
 &bull; Does the machine have an effective cool zone into which loose particles of food can fall so as not to expose the oil to carbonisation, which will reduce the life of the oil? 
 &bull; How much automation do you need on your fryer? 
 &bull; Does it have an insulated pan for extra economy?   
 Fri Fri computer-monitored frying station from Franke Catering Equipment 
 The Florigo fryers at Harry Ramsden's Guiseley fish and chip emporium 
 Electroway 600 fryer from Moorwood Vulcan 
 WHAT'S NEW 
 Linpac sets store by green policy 
 Food packaging manufacturer Linpac has marked its announcement of a corporate environmental policy with the introduction of a 50% recycled polystyrene food container. 
 The policy, under the banner &bquo;Taking care of the world we share&equo;, commits the company to carrying out regular environmental audits, training employees to improve environmental performance and using suppliers with a similar attitude towards the environment. 
 It also outlines the company's intention to participate in committees which influence legislative developments affecting packaging in the environment. 
 &bquo;Polystyrene can, in theory, be recycled indefinitely,&equo; said Linpac director Terry O'Connell. 
 &bquo;The problem with recycling is that we cannot determine the colour of waste material in advance. 
 The end product can come out in a variety of shades. 
 &bquo;This is why food packaging products can only be 50% recycled. 
 The box has to be coated in a thin covering of virgin material to ensure that there is a consistent colour for labelling. 
 It is also important that the food comes into contact only with clean packaging.&equo; 
 The process used to coat the recycled material was developed in the USA. 
 China showcase 
 Royal Doulton and Wedgwood are to produce the tableware for the restaurant and banqueting facilities at the new Queens Moat House (QMH) hotel in Stoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire. 
 The hotel incorporates the former home of Josiah Wedgwood and QMH wants the hotel to be a showcase for the work of the potteries. 
 Twelve other Stoke potters will also be supplying china to the hotel, which opens in September. 
 Council's code spells out Act 
 by Christina Simons 
 Westminster City Council has taken the initiative and published its own code of practice for caterers on the implications of the Food Safety Act 1990. 
 The code deals with the hygiene, design and construction of food premises, temperature control and cross contamination. 
 In two additional sections it deals with advice on food labelling and stock control. 
 Westminster chief environmental health officer (EHO) Robert Crozier, who masterminded the scheme, announced details of the code at a food safety conference organised by Cater Electric and Olympic Catering Equipment at Danbury Conference Centre, Essex. 
 He told delegates: &bquo;I have found it difficult to understand some of the regulations myself. 
 If I, as an EHO, find them difficult, how can caterers be expected to interpret them accurately?&equo; 
 Under the legislation, managers of catering establishments could be held personally responsible for each breach of the regulation and each penalty could mean fines of between &pound;2,000 and &pound;20,000. 
 The code received a warm reception from conference delegates but several caterers in the audience criticised their local EHOs for failing to present a united front on the interpretation of regulations. 
 However, Mr Crozier made it clear that even if the code were adopted by every borough, EHOs could continue to interpret the law according to individual situations. 
 &bquo;In my borough we have a lot of odd-shaped kitchens. 
 This makes it difficult for caterers to use the most suitable materials possible on walls and floor surfaces for maximum hygiene,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;To accommodate this problem we have written into the code of practice that caterers can use experimental surfaces under certain conditions. 
 This situation would not necessarily hold true for another council.&equo; 
 PROSECUTION 
 Although Mr Crozier admitted his department was still gearing up to implement the legislation, he confirmed that once all the stall were fully trained they would begin prosecuting offenders. 
 &bquo;And under the law, it is simply not enough to design a kitchen with good equipment in it &mdash; you must now have the means to monitor and control operations,&equo; he said. 
 He hoped that the code would be passed on via the Institution of Environmental Health Officers network and adopted by EHOs throughout the country. 
 The code has been welcomed by other London boroughs. 
 which have adopted 95% of its contents. 
 Mr Crozier advised caterers unsure about equipment or hygiene practices used in their kitchens to ring their local EHO and find out exact local requirements before making alterations. 
 A copy of Westminster's code of practice and other supplementary information can be obtained by telephoning Theresa Riley in 071&ndash;798 1093. 
 Associations cool to EC proposal 
 A draft European Community regulation proposing that producers label their food-stuffs with a Protected Graphical Indication (PGI) or Designation of Origin (PDO) has been given the thumbs-down at the consultation stage with trade bodies describing it as &bquo;protectionist and unnecessary&equo;. 
 The proposal sought to apply the appellation contr&ocirc;l&eacute;e principle to food with regional characteristics. 
 However, of the 34 trade and consumer bodies and enforcement authorities which responded to the House of Commons Select Committee, the majority said the differences between PGI and PDO categories were &bquo;too ill-defined to be readily discernible and, moreover, failed to offer other benefits.&equo; 
 Consumer groups claimed full and clear labelling of food products would be preferred, which would enable customers to choose between similar products and &bquo;to decide for themselves as to what constituted the best quality at a given price.&equo; 
 Agricultural producers, however, welcomed the idea and said quality foods could be encouraged and preserved by recognition and protection under the proposed rule. 
 David Curry, Parliamentary Secretary at the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries &amp; Food, concluded that the balance of opinion was against the regulation and significant amendments would have to be made to the proposal to make it acceptable. 
 Salmon safe 
 Recent press reports that salmon from Scottish fish farms were contaminated with the unlicensed chemical Invermectin have been condemned by Professor Randolph Richards, Deputy director of the Institute of Agriculture at University of Stirling, as unsubstantiated.  
 FOOD 
 Cheesecake 
 Luvable Lemon Lush Cheese Cake is a frozen dessert with a digestive biscuit base topped with layers of baked and unbaked lemon cheese and fresh cream. 
 The cake is finished with piped cream, white chocolate flakes and a lacing of lemon curd. 
 Portions can be cut while frozen, and the cake takes between 15 and 30 minutes to defrost. 
 Flour mixes 
 A selection of flour-based mixes has been added to the Happy Chef own-label range, including De-Luxe Sponge Mix, Batter Mix, Scone Mix and Shortcrust Pastry Mix. 
 All come in 3kg sizes and prices start at &pound;2.79. 
 P&acirc;t&eacute;s 
 Brussels, Ardennes, Garlic and Provencale are the latest flavours in the range of Farmhouse Spreading P&acirc;t&eacute;es from Plumrose. 
 Each comes in a 75g rectangular tub and has a clear, resealable lid. 
 Choc pud 
 White Lightning is a 14-portion dessert made of chocolate fudge and meringue, with three layers of chocolate sponge topped with white chocolate mousse. 
 Chicken burger 
 Yankee Chickenburger in a Bun is a pre-cooked, microwavable, breaded burger with dill mayonnaise in a sesame-seeded bran bun. 
 It joins the Yankee Hot Dog as the latest in the Yankee range of microwavable snacks. 
 Both products are packed in sealed wrappers, 12 to a case. 
 Bulgarian jams 
 Bulgarian premium jams are being brought into the UK under the Naturall label. 
 The strawberry, plum, peach, black cherry and apricot jams are said to have a high fruit content and contain no artificial colours or preservatives. 
 Margarines 
 Country Range margarines now come in 12.5kg-bulk, 2kg soft and 2kg-sunflower sizes, as well as 48 &times; 250g packets. 
 Fudge cake 
 Florida Orange Fudge Cake has chocolate fudge sandwiched between orange sponge. 
 The dessert is covered in chocolate and topped with orange hearts. 
 Cold meats 
 Five slicing cold meats have been launched by Princes in 4lb sizes. 
 Pork &amp; Pepper &mdash; spicy chopped pork with red and green peppers; Pizza Roll &mdash; spicy chopped pork with hunks of garlic salami, black olives, red popper and gherkins; Turkey Roll; Chicken Roll; and Chicken &amp; Ham Roll. 
 Bouillons 
 Menu Bouillon is a range of Italian bouillons in 1kg tubs, six to a carton. 
 Beef, Chicken, Vegetable and Low-Fat Granular Beef flavours are said to be high in meat, chicken or vegetable extracts.  
 FOODSERVICE 
 State-of-the-art hot meal vendor 
 CAFE Quick is a state-of-the-art vending machine which dispenses freshly cooked meals from frozen in less than a minute. 
 It holds 216 packets of food in a freezer unit fitted with a first-in-first-out stock rotation system and an alarm, which will shut down operations if the temperature gets too high. 
 Once the machine is activated, either by coins or cards, a hydraulic lift places a plate with the selected food into a microwave for defrosting. 
 The food is then pushed out of its protective package and left in its serving dish to be cooked in a hot-air oven. 
 After cooking, the protective cardboard outer is removed and the cooked food dispensed. 
 The machine is fitted with a computerised management system to control stock flow. 
 Caf&eacute; Quick costs &pound;9,500 and has a three-product menu choice of chips, chicken and pizza. 
 The manufacturer estimates that break-even point could be achieved with 14 meals per day. 
 Fridge store 
 The Stainton is a refrigerated storage unit with rubber-tyred castors for easy movement. 
 The unit has a stainless steel chilled storage cabinet with an integral blown-air refrigeration system which, the manufacturer claims, can be maintained at 3&deg;C to 5&deg;C. 
 Bar bits 
 An Appetiser Stand, Cherry &amp; Lemon Dispenser and Ice Cutting Tongs are all part of a range of bar accessories from Mitchell &amp; Cooper. 
 Moulded, splinter-proof cutting blocks, called Barboards, are also available. 
 These are made of heavy-gauge metal with a polished stainless steel surround. 
 Time stickers 
 Time and temperature indicators are small stickers which can be placed in the outside of food containers and will change colour from white to red of food temperature rises above 12&deg;C for more than two hours. 
 Food package 
 Hot'n'Tender is a hot food package from Servequip, which the company claims will enable independent caterers to project a corporate image. 
 Henny Penny pressure fryers and display/holding cabinets form the centre of the package, with uniforms, menu screens and point-of-sale material also available emblazoned with the Hot'n'Tender logo. 
 Heavy weight 
 The Linkline Trolley is designed to ease the transportation of heavy loads such as beer kegs, crates of bottles and dishwasher racks. 
 The trolley has rollerbearing wheels with rubber tyres, can turn on its axis, and can be manoeuvred easily with one hand. 
 It is available with retaining chains or webbing straps. 
 Power box 
 Koolatron is a 12-V portable insulated box which can keep its contents either warm or cool by using a portable power pack. 
 To cool, the motor forces air out of the box, so lowering the temperature. 
 To warm, air is taken from outside the box and combined with heat generated by the motor. 
 The largest capacity box of 1.2cu ft holds the equivalent of 48 &times; 12oz cans and the smallest capacity model holds nine 12oz cans. 
 In addition the 0.9cu ft model has a built-in cutting board. 
 Cool pads 
 Chill Pads, which maintain chilled products at temperature, are claimed to be longer-lasting than ice and more effective than eutectic plates. 
 The Chill Pads are made from disposable, non-toxic material divided into 40g sachets. 
 Each sachet contains dry crystals which expand on contact with water to form a solid, ice cube-shaped gel. 
 The sachets can be frozen individually or in sheets for use in cooling boxes. 
 Chill Pads can be cut to length and are packaged in 120m rolls, costing &pound;240.  
 Caf&eacute; Quick meals take less than a minute to heat up 
 Chill pads can be frozen individually or in sheets 
 KITCHEN 
 Complete cooking 
 The SC20, a 20-grid steam convection oven, can be used in sous vide or cook-chill operations. 
 The SC20 is a convection oven, a steamer, and a combined steam/convected air oven in one. 
 It can cook food at temperatures of between 40&deg;C and 100&deg;C, and comes with a roll-in oven rack and loading trolley. 
 The list price is &pound;11,109 and includes a meat probe and six gastronorm-sized grid shelves. 
 As a basic air convection oven, the SC20 costs &pound;7,995. 
 Combi oven 
 The Jetwave Series 2 combination oven has a 700-watt microwave, a 2,400-watt infra-red grill, and can be used as either a forced air or natural convection oven. 
 Each cooking function can be used singularly or simultaneously and the controls are said to be simple to operate. 
 It also features a pyrolytic self-cleaning cycle which, when the oven reaches temperatures of 480&deg;C, burns off all dirt and grease leaving a wipe-away ash deposit. 
 The oven door becomes self-locking at 300&deg;C. 
 Hot cupboards 
 Guardsman Hotcupboards (below) now come in mobile versions. 
 The 70cm GM2 with a 240-plate capacity costs &pound;497, and the 360-capacity, 100cm GM3 costs &pound;590. 
 The hot cupboards are also available with bain marie service tops in a choice of seven combinations of half- or quarter-gastronorm containers. 
 Dough mixer 
 A pizza dough mixer, which rotates in the opposite direction to the mixing tools, is said to eliminate cleaning problems and prevent the dough riding up the side of the bowl. 
 The bowl is removable for ease of cleaning, and the unit is finished in stainless steel and comes in 12kg, 20kg, 30kg, 40kg, and 60kg sizes. 
 Boiling table 
 A solid-top boiling table has been added to the Yeoman series of gas-fired cooking equipment. 
 The boiling table measures 90cm wide and 73cm deep and is made with a cast-iron top with a single burner under a bull's-eye in the middle. 
 Heat input for the table is 7.38kW, and it comes with adjustable feet on stainless steel legs. 
 Moulds 
 Specialist moulds for p&acirc;tisserie work are being imported from French company Matinox. 
 Letter presses, pyramids, flowers and leaves are just some of the shapes and patterns available. 
 Eight burners 
 The Masterchef range of medium-duty cooking equipment now includes an eight-burner range with a double and single oven. 
 The unit is made in stainless steel and has cast-iron pan supports with removable drip trays underneath. 
 Other items in the range include: a 60cm or 90cm grill; a six-burner Masterchef range with double oven; a four-burner Masterchef; the Masterfry fryer; and a six-burner range with convection oven underneath. 
 Modular range 
 Snack 650 is a modular range of medium-duty cooking equipment from the Italian-made Giga Series. 
 The range includes a selection of hobs, griddles, fryers, bain-maries, chip scuttles and sink units, as well as a convection oven and pasta cooker. 
 Base cupboards, worktops, stands and refrigerated base units are also available. 
 All are supplied in either gas or electric models. 
 Oven-to-table 
 Maitre d'hotel is a range of oven-to-tableware in solid stainless steel with gold-plated handles. 
 Various sized cloches, terrines, gratin dishes and l&eacute;gumiers are available. 
 Refrigeration 
 The Broadside range of refrigeration units from Stott Benham consists of a 1,400-litre, a 700-litre and a 500-litre model, all of which have removable interior fittings for easy cleaning. 
 All three models have foam insulation and a thermostatically controlled, forced-air cooling system. 
 Leak detector 
 Energy leakage in commercial and domestic microwaves can be checked and monitored with the hand-held TEK-500 Microwave Leakage Detector. 
 The monitor has four lamps which indicate levels of energy leakage, and an alarm sounds if hazardous levels are found. 
 It costs &pound;129.  
 The SC20 steam convection oven 
 WORLD VISION OF BRITAIN 
 From the Overseas Director's Office 
 Dear YHA member, 
 ETHIOPIA THE MILLION TREE APPEAL 
 Last October, YHA members raised over &pound;47,000 to plant over 800 acres &mdash; a staggering 470,000 trees &mdash; in Shone Valley, Southern Shewa, Ethiopia. 
 The reforestation programme, targeting to plant 7.5 million trees over a seven year period, is on its way. 
 Soon barren land will begin to show signs of fertility. 
 Then it will be possible for crops to grow on soil where, earlier, no plant life could have been supported. 
 And all because of trees. 
 The Shone Valley Reforestation programme is one of several such projects being organised by World Vision throughout Ethiopia. 
 You may have seen the article about the reforestation of Ansokia Valley in the October issue of YHA magazine. 
 It really is one of Ethiopia's few success stories over the last decade. 
 Now, with your help, World Vision is looking to repeat the success at Shone. 
 The early signs are encouraging &mdash; but there's a long way to go. 
 A NEW CHALLENGE 
 World Vision has set YHA members a new challenge. 
 TO RAISE THE FUNDS FOR THE NEXT MILLION TREES TO BE PLANTED AT SHONE. 
 It's a big challenge but I am sure that together we can do it. 
 It means about 1,700 YHA members raising an average of &pound;60 to plant an acre of trees. 
 And, because of sponsorship, you don't have to fork out the whole &pound;60 yourself. 
 Attached to this letter is your sponsorship form. 
 The target for each member is to raise &pound;60 in sponsorship from friends and relatives. 
 Every 10p plants a tree. 
 Please don't leave it to others. 
 Even if you can't raise the full &pound;60 please do the very best you can. 
  JEFF THINDWA Overseas Director  
 P.S. A YHA participant will be selected to visit the Shone Reforestation project later this year. 
 That person could be you! 
 ETHIOPIA. 
 AND FAMINE. 
 AND TREES 
 It is perhaps not widely appreciated the effect deforestation can have on a country like Ethiopia. 
 One of the main causes of recurrent famine throughout Ethiopia is the problem of massive deforestation, although in the regions of Wollo, Tigray and Eritrea it has been made worse by war. 
 40 years ago, 40% of Ethiopia was covered with forests. 
 By 1985 this figure had reduced to under 4%. 
 Without the vegetation, the topsoil is washed away. 
 Without the topsoil, water retention is negligible. 
 Without water retention the land becomes baked. 
 And, since crops will not grow on baked land, famine is the result. 
 All because of lack of trees. 
 Deforestation also affects the environment in other more complex ways. 
 It causes a reduction in evapotranspiration (a complicated word which means that fewer clouds are formed) and an increase in temperatures. 
 ALL ABOUT SHONE 
 The Shone Soil and Water Conservation and Afforestation Project (to give it the full name) is situated in Sike Awraka, Southern Shewa. 
 It is 200kms (124 miles) south of Ethiopia's capital, Addis Ababa, far from the areas affected by the civil war. 
 Over a 7 year period, World Vision plans to plant 9 million trees in the Shone Valley. 
 Each species will have been selected for certain properties: 
 GREVILIA ROBUSTA 
 (Australian silky oak) because it is drought resistant 
 ACACIA SALIGNA 
 because of its rapid growth and water retention 
 CASUARINA LUSTINACA 
 because it takes nitrogen from the air and puts it back into the soil 
 LEUCAENEA LUCOCEPHALIA 
 because as a nitrogen fixing species it protects and improves the soil 
 The cost for each acre of reforestation is about &pound;60 and about 600 trees are planted to each acre of land. 
 The effects are both rapid and dramatic. 
 Within two or three years, springs come back to life, wildlife returns and crops flourish. 
 CARE Britain 
 Dear Friend, 
 With this letter I have enclosed a small sachet of salt and sugar granules. 
 Please hold the sachet in your hand as I tell you how a small handful of granules like these have the power to stop the world's biggest child killer. 
 You see, on the day you read this letter another 14,000 infant lives will be lost. 
 That is one for every minute of every day. 
 In 12 months a staggering total of 5 million under fives will have perished, victims of just one cause: diarrhoeal diseases spread by dirty water. 
 It is a terrible thought isn't it? 
 So many young lives wasted. 
 But there is something else you should know too. 
 It makes the tragedy even more complete, yet at the same time contains the seeds of hope. 
 Every one of these deaths is preventable. 
 The effects of diarrhoeal disease can be conquered with one of the simplest and cheapest natural remedies known to science. 
 One full course of treatment costs as little as 5 pence, and can save a life. 
 That is why the sachet I have sent you is so important. 
 A spoonful of sugar and a pinch of salt dissolved in a litre of water is all it takes. 
 And the effect is remarkable. 
 The sugar &mdash; salt &mdash; water treatment, known as Oral Rehydration Therapy (ORT) takes only 24 hours to work &mdash; replacing vital body fluids and salts that are lost when diarrhoea strikes. 
 I have enclosed a simple card which explains in more detail how ORT works. 
 But treatment with ORT has to begin immediately a child feels ill. 
 As every parent knows, any illness in a very young child is serious. 
 Its condition deteriorates fast. 
 In the hot dry conditions of Africa and India, dehydration is more than serious. 
 It is a killer. 
 Once diarrhoeal disease has set in a baby will go under in just two or three days. 
 That is why every minute counts. 
 And why it is so important that you respond to this appeal today. 
 You will be making a personal and lasting contribution to the ORT work I have told you about. 
 And to the many other ways in which CARE is helping the world's poorest people to find a way out of poverty and ill-health. 
 Please help, by sending a donation today. 
 A gift of just &pound;12 could provide enough sachets of ORT to save 240 children. 
 &pound;15 could save 300. 
 Do support this appeal. 
 With your help we can put life-saving Oral Rehydration Therapy within reach of more mothers and more children. 
 And save more precious lives. 
 Many thanks for helping. 
 Yours sincerely,  Francis Carroll Director of Appeals  
 P.S. Please keep the sachet, as a reminder of how little it takes to save a child's life. 
 You may like to know that the cost of these sachets have been met by a generous donor. 
 Thank you again for helping.  
 ORT is one example of the health care programmes which CARE is helping to introduce in countries as far apart as India and Peru. 
 CARE was formed in 1946 and helps the poorest of the poor in 38 countries in Africa, Asia and South America. 
 SAVE THE CHILDREN 
 &bquo;The child must be protected beyond and above all considerations of race, nationality or creed&equo; Eglantyne Jebb &mdash; founder, Save the Children. 
 1923 
 Dear Friend, 
 When I've written to you in the past, it's usually been to tell you about the developments of some of our long term programmes. 
 This time I have a very different kind of success story to tell you. 
 It's a story of how five years of patience and understanding saw extraordinary achievements &mdash; both for us, and for the children of Vietnam. 
 Determined to see change 
 For many years, no outside organisation had been given permission by the Vietnamese government to establish themselves in their country. 
 That, of course, included us. 
 But we knew what life was like for the children of Vietnam &mdash; and we were determined to see change. 
 Try to imagine working in waist-high muddy water for 10 hours every day to earn a living. 
 that's exactly what life consists of for over 70% of Vietnam's labour force &mdash; and thousands of them are children. 
 To many &mdash; as young as 12 &mdash; farming Vietnam's sodden rice fields is their only means of survival. 
 And, with barely even the most basic of medicines available, each day these children are prone to the countless diseases and infections that flourish within the grimy water around them. 
 Ironically, for a country almost covered in water, another major concern for children's health in Vietnam is the sheer lack of clean drinking water. 
 Just one reason why the mortality rate for under-fours is eight times higher than our own. 
 As I'm sure you'll understand, when I first came to see this awful situation I was consumed with a feeling of frustration &mdash; knowing, as I did then, that it could be some time before we'd be in a position to intervene. 
 Naturally, before we could get involved, we first had to show the Vietnamese government that we had truly grasped the often complex problems of its country. 
 A time to discover what the children needed most. 
 We knew that our first step had to be spending time learning how we could best help Vietnam's children. 
 Only by doing this could we ever hope to work effectively with the government in the future. 
 We appointed a project co-ordinator in Bangkok. 
 From there, she was able to make regular visits to Vietnam &mdash; and so give us essential reports on where our help was needed most. 
 Her days were spent visiting countless villages, communities, clinics and hospitals. 
 Medical equipment was, and still is, a priority. 
 She soon found that hospitals and clinics were short of the most basic equipment &mdash; like sterilisers, vaccines and training books. 
 On reaching villages, she immediately drafted proposals for pilot projects, to help mothers provide a nutritious diet for their children. 
 As her reports started to come together, our excitement grew about what we could now achieve for the children of Vietnam. 
 A proud day for everyone 
 Then, at last, the news that we'd all worked so hard for. 
 The Vietnamese government agreed to let us work in their country. 
 It was an encouraging day for everyone. 
 No longer were our proposals for long term projects just reports on pieces of paper; they were real &mdash; and not just for us, but for the children of Vietnam. 
 The future 
 And that, to date, is my story. 
 But the story has only just begun. 
 The really hard work is ahead of us. 
 And this, my friend, is where you come in. 
 I want to be able to write to you again &mdash; soon &mdash; and tell you how our projects are developing &mdash; not just in Vietnam, but across the world. 
 With your support now, I'll be able to do just that. 
 Save the Children is totally committed to being wherever children need us. 
 Your donations mean we'll always be there, no matter what the circumstances, or how long it takes. 
 Please don't let this wonderful success story end here. 
 Yours sincerely,  Nicholas Hinton Director General.  
 P.S. As I've shown, SCF makes sure that your donation works as hard as possible for the children that need it most. 
 But if you use your Deed of Covenant form every &pound;1 you give becomes &pound;1.33 &mdash; so your gift can work even harder. 
 To donate, please use your Freepost envelope. 
 CAFOD 
 On the side of people in need 
 The Catholic Fund for Overseas Development 
 March 1990 
 Dear Friend, 
 CAFOD Family Fast Day &mdash; Friday 9th March 1990 
 As the Lent Family Fast Day approaches I would like to thank you all again for the magnificent response to the Bishops' Appeal for Ethiopia. 
 But at the same time I want to stress how crucially important to CAFOD are the offerings from the coming Family Fast Day. 
 They will enable us to keep our promises to provide funds to over 500 development projects with poor communities throughout Africa, Asia and Latin America. 
 We realise that you may well make your Family Fast Day offering through your parish. 
 We are grateful to you and hope that this year our theme will capture the imagination of all our supporters. 
 Its title is &mdash; 
 Share the Work of Renewing the Earth 
 The intention is to highlight how today we in this country may join through our offerings with those of little or no material wealth in the Third World in the urgent task of making human development possible for even the poorest. 
 The goal is to renew the earth and to cherish it so that its fruits, its resources and its wealth may be shared by everyone &mdash; and without leaving a legacy of pollution and destruction for the next generation. 
 In Ethiopia, in the midst of war and facing famine, CAFOD is working with thousands of people in a dozen communities who are seeking to protect the topsoil in their fields, building irrigation channels, planting trees and learning new farming techniques so that millions of acres of farmland in their country may remain fertile. 
 Civil war hampers their efforts but rather than cease their work of &bquo;renewing the earth&equo; they often labour at night to avoid the constant threat of bombings from the air. 
 In many parts of Cambodia rice is growing and fishponds are being restocked as village communities use the funds and technical assistance that CAFOD has provided to revive their devastated country. 
 Adults and children spend time learning to read and write so that they may recover and renew what is best even though it is all sadly threatened again by those who destroyed it a generation ago. 
 In Brazil the forests are being indiscriminately destroyed and many indigenous peoples, like the Yanomami Indians, are being slowly wiped out as gold prospectors and others invade their lands, poison their rivers, and bring disease and death in their wake. 
 CAFOD is working with the Bishop of Roraima and the local Church to try to protect the Yanomami people, their lands and their future. 
 To participate in Family Fast Day is to participate in these programmes, and many others like them, whose goal is to &bquo;share the work of renewing the earth&equo;. 
 I am also enclosing a copy of the latest CAFOD Journal for your interest. 
 With very best wishes. 
 Yours sincerely,  Julian Filochowski Director  
 UNICEF UK 
 Dear Friend 
 If 30 jumbo jets full of children crashed every day, there would be news headlines in every country. 
 The whole world would mourn. 
 There would be a public outcry to stop it happening. 
 Yet the plain fact is that this number of children are dying every day &mdash; dying from diseases we know how to cure. 
 And their suffering goes unreported and, for the most part, ignored. 
 Will you help us to reach out to these forgotten victims? 
 Because what you choose to do in the next few minutes could decide whether a child will live or die. 
 Naima, the girl in the picture on the envelope, is one of the children who needs our help. 
 In Bangladesh, where she lives, diseases like tuberculosis, diphtheria, whooping cough, tetanus, polio and measles are rife. 
 To us in Britain, the names of these diseases mean very little. 
 Advances in health care have meant that most of them are seldom heard of here. 
 And today very few British parents would be seriously alarmed to be told their children had measles. 
 But in the developing countries of Asia, Africa and Latin America, parents live in mortal fear of these diseases &mdash; and for very good reason. 
 Around the world, they cause the deaths of three and a half million children every year. 
 And they leave many more crippled, blind or mentally handicapped. 
 Imagine, for a moment, what it must be like to be the parent of young children in a poor community in Bangladesh or Mozambique. 
 To dread the slightest sneeze or cough that might herald the onset of polio or tuberculosis. 
 To know that, if the disease does strike their children, they can do very little but wait, hope and pray. 
 In this country we can count our blessings that our children are not constantly at the mercy of these diseases. 
 But it still makes me angry to know that in other countries so many children die, so many families are bereaved, simply because they lack basic health care. 
 Whether or not you have children of your own, I know you will feel the same way. 
 Yet the answer is in our own hands, because it is now perfectly possible to immunise all  the world's children against the six killer diseases I have mentioned. 
 That's why I am writing to ask you to take part in a great campaign: for universal child immunisation. 
 But the end of 1990 we want to reach a situation where at least eight out of ten of the world's children are immunised. 
 This is a high enough level of protection to control the diseases and prevent epidemics devastating whole communities. 
 It is a goal we can reach, provided we can raise the funds we need. 
 Governments are helping, but is isn't enough. 
 That's why we need the support of every friend of UNICEF throughout the world. 
 And already we are making heartening progress. 
 In war-torn Lebanon, for instance, UNICEF helped negotiate &bquo;Days of Tranquillity&equo; so that 350,000 children could be immunised during these breaks in the fighting. 
 In Turkey, a massive public education campaign has succeeded in immunising over 4 million children. 
 Village leaders and schoolteachers worked with us to spread the word about the benefits of immunisation. 
 And religious leaders played their part too, with Imams preaching the call to immunisation from every one of Turkey's 54,000 mosques. 
 And Senegal, one of the 30 poorest nations in the world has set the best example of all. 
 In 1985 fewer than one in ten of the country's children were immunised. 
 Today, with UNICEF's help, around seven out of ten are protected. 
 Thanks largely to our supporters around the world, we in UNICEF have put everything we can into our worldwide immunisation programme over the past few years. 
 Already over 60 per cent of the world's children are immunised. 
 Millions of young lives have already been saved.  
 We are within striking distance of our goal. 
 But there is still so much to be done. 
 In South East Asia, for example, still only a third of children are immunised against diphtheria, whooping cough and tetanus in the vital first year of life. 
 The future &mdash; the very lives &mdash; of these children depend on our ability to reach them with vaccines and health education. 
 That's why it is so important that we don't give up for an instant. 
 The six killer diseases not only CAN be brought under control by the end of 1990. 
 For the sake of these children they MUST. 
 If it seems an ambitious goal, let me ask you a simple question. 
 What value would you place on the life of a child? 
 In one way it seems absurd &mdash; outrageous, even &mdash; to measure human life in pounds and pence. 
 But in another way it is perfectly possible &mdash; because the cost of immunising a child against the six killer diseases, and quite possibly saving his or her life, is just around &pound;6. 
 How many times have you heard people say that the greatest gift in the world is good health? 
 But for millions of people in the world's poorest countries, who live in fear of diseases like measles and whooping cough it is quite literally true. 
 My hope is that you will become a supporter of UNICEF and that, together, we can give them what they so desperately need: a passport to health for their children. 
 And if enough of us are prepared to give a donation &mdash; just a proportion of what we spend on our own families and friends at Christmas &mdash; we can reach that precious goal of Universal Child Immunisation by the end of 1990. 
 Our UNICEF field workers and medical teams have worked so tirelessly in recent years to bring immunisation to the children of the world. 
 Please help them go the last mile, by sending as much as you can. 
 Remember, every &pound;6 you send will immunise a child and maybe save a life. 
 Please send your gift in the envelope provided. 
 Or, to join our campaign now and get your gift to us even faster, please phone 01&ndash;200 0200 and speak to one of our helpers, quoting your Access or Visa card number. 
 Better still, if you can, please arrange to give regularly to UNICEF's work so we can carry our campaign for better child health care into the future. 
 It's simple to do this now by filling in the direct debit and covenant on the back of the donation form. 
 And please accept my heartfelt thanks now for your concern and your generosity. 
 I know it will give as much joy and satisfaction to you as it will to me, to know that we have played our part in this great crusade for children's health. 
 With every good wish for the festive season and the New Year ahead. 
 Yours sincerely,  Robert Smith Director UNICEF UK  
 P.S. As a token of UNICEF's gratitude for your generous support, I have enclosed your 1990 UNICEF pocket diary. 
 I hope that as you use it through the year, it will serve to remind you of the life-saving work you are helping to make possible for children throughout the world.  
 In Lebanon, soldiers bring children to be vaccinated and hand out leaflets about immunisation. 
 Mothers queue to immunise their children at this busy health centre in Thailand 
 Crowds gather outside a church in the Philippines for BCG vaccinations against measles and tuberculosis. 
 A Turkish health team restock their portable insulated vaccine carrier 
 At a health post in West Java, a record is made of this child's weight and immunisation details 
 UNICEF AT WORK AGAINST THE KILLER DISEASES 
 Help us give every child a passport to health&hellip; and make 1990 the year we break the grip of the six killer diseases. 
 Dear friend, 
 For most of us in Britain, Christmas and New Year are a time of good cheer in the company of family and friends. 
 And, thankfully, many can afford to splash out a little on treats and luxuries. 
 Indeed at this time of year, hundreds of millions of pounds are spent on children's toys alone. 
 But for vast numbers of children in the developing world, such gifts are beyond their wildest dreams. 
 For them, life itself is the best gift they could receive. 
 In some countries as many as one child in three dies before reaching the age of five. 
 There is something you and I can do now to change this. 
 We can support UNICEF's Passport to Health campaign, to immunise the world's children against the six major killer diseases &mdash; polio, tuberculosis, whooping cough, tetanus and measles &mdash; by the end of 1990. 
 It doesn't take much. 
 The cost of fully immunising each child is around &pound;6. 
 So by sharing a little of what we have, we can remover the threat of these terrible diseases which, currently, kill three and a half million children a year. 
 I hope you will join me in supporting this campaign. 
 Please give what you can. 
 Let's all do our best to give UNICEF the funds they need. 
 I know they'll put that money to the best possible use &mdash; saving precious young lives. 
 Thank you. 
  Sir Richard Attenborough, CBE, UNICEF Goodwill Ambassador  
 &hellip; and your help can save even more lives. 
 No matter how you choose to help UNICEF's life-saving work for the world's children, your support is vitally important and very greatly appreciated. 
 But of course our work will not end when we have broken the grip of the six major killer diseases. 
 In fact, it will only just have begun &mdash; because we will need to go on working hard to sustain that achievement. 
 That's why the most valuable support you can give us is long-term support &mdash; the kind that increases our regular income and helps us plan for the future. 
 It would mean so much to us if you would give a regular amount under Covenant, by filling in the Direct Debit form and Deed of Covenant above. 
 By doing this, you will enable us to claim back the tax you've already paid on your gift. 
 That will add 33% to its value without costing you a penny extra. 
 So a gift of, say &pound;20, will become &pound;26.67 at no added cost to you. 
 When you consider how much that extra amount can achieve, you will appreciate how valuable your Covenant can be. 
 For example, for every three children you help us immunise with your gift, your Covenant will make it possible to immunise one more &mdash; and quite possibly save another life. 
 We welcome Covenants of &pound;10 or over. 
 The only conditions the Taxman lays down is that you give the same amount regularly for at least four years and that you are a UK taxpayer. 
 To make a Covenant, just complete the two forms above and return them to us in the envelope provided. 
 Please note the Direct Debit may only be used with the Covenant. 
 You can also pay your Covenant by Access or Visa by filling in your credit card number overleaf. 
 Remember &mdash; making a Covenant to UNICEF costs you nothing extra, but it means a lot &mdash; perhaps even the difference between life and death &mdash; to the children of the world. 
 THE CHILD KILLERS 
 The six childhood diseases you can help us prevent 
 MEASLES 
 In the developing world measles is the most devastating of all the six major childhood diseases &mdash; killing more than two million children a year. 
 Not only is measles a killer, but it also causes blindness, deafness and mental handicap in thousands of children every year. 
 SYMPTOMS 
 Initial symptoms resemble those of a cold, with red, watery eyes, running nose, cough, and high fever. 
 Greyish-white spots, leading to a red spotted rash follow. 
 PREVENTION 
 Just one dose of BCG vaccine a 9 months of age can prevent measles. 
 POLIO 
 Every year, over a quarter of a million children under the age of 3 contract polio. 
 Around 25,000 die. 
 But many more are crippled by the disease. 
 The virus is spread through contact with contaminated food and water. 
 SYMPTOMS 
 Polio symptoms include: cold-like symptoms, fever, sore throat, nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, headache, stiffness of the neck, muscle pains in the limbs and the back and, ultimately, paralysis. 
 PREVENTION 
 Three doses of the polio vaccine at 6, 10 and 14 weeks of age are needed to protect children against polio. 
 The vaccine can be given at the same time as immunisations against diphtheria, whooping cough and tetanus. 
 WHOOPING COUGH 
 Whooping cough claims around 600,000 young lives each year &mdash; half of those deaths are of children less than 1 year old. 
 SYMPTOMS 
 The disease, which is caused by bacteria, is characterised by spasmodic coughing, accompanied by sneezing and fever. 
 Its common name is derived from the &bquo;whoop&equo; children make as they desperately struggle to inhale after a coughing spasm. 
 PREVENTION 
 Three doses of the DPT vaccine are needed, at 6,10 and 14 weeks of age, to immunise children against whooping cough. 
 DIPHTHERIA 
 Diphtheria kills 100,000 children each year. 
 The disease usually occurs as an acute infection of the throat, but it can affect the heart and brain of infants and young children. 
 It is also common in developing countries as an infection of the skin. 
 SYMPTOMS 
 Although infections of the skin and nasal passages are often mild, infections of the throat can become serious. 
 Initial symptoms include fever and mild sore throat. 
 Membranes may develop in the throat, causing death by asphyxiation. 
 Other complications can include paralysis of the palate, eye muscles, throat, muscles of the respiratory tract or arm and leg muscles. 
 PREVENTION 
 Children must be immunised with DPT vaccine in the first 6 months of life. 
 TUBERCULOSIS 
 Tuberculosis strikes around two million children under 5 every year and kills 30,000. 
 All forms of the disease begin as tuberculosis of the lung although it can affect other organs including the membranes encasing the brain and spinal cord, the bones, joints and kidneys. 
 Tuberculosis spreads easily and it is often passed on from older members of the family to the children. 
 Without proper treatment, sufferers from tuberculosis of the lung can be contagious all their life. 
 SYMPTOMS 
 Symptoms include low fever, cough, blood in the sputum, chest pain, sweating at night and weight loss. 
 PREVENTION 
 One dose of BCG vaccine provides protection against TB during childhood. 
 This needs to be given at birth, or as soon as possible afterwards. 
 TETANUS 
 Neo-Natal tetanus, the worst child-killer after measles, claims the lives of nearly one million children every year in the developing world. 
 Almost all newborn babies who contract tetanus die. 
 The disease is caused by unsterile methods of cutting the umbilical cord at birth or by &bquo;dressing&equo; it with ash, mud or animal dung. 
 SYMPTOMS 
 The first sign of tetanus in a newborn baby is the inability to suck or swallow and muscular spasms of the lips and mouth. 
 Muscular stiffness and spasms then develop throughout the body, which can be accompanied by convulsions. 
 PREVENTION 
 Pregnant mothers who are given the tetanus vaccine provide their baby with natural immunity for the first 12 weeks of its life. 
 Lasting immunity can be provided by then vaccinating the infant at 6, 10 and 14 weeks of age with DPT vaccine. 
 How every &pound;6 you give can save a child's life. 
 Throughout the world, in over 120 developing countries, UNICEF is working to immunise all the world's children against the six major child-killing diseases. 
 It is not an easy task &mdash; and it is not just a matter of buying the vaccines. 
 Those vaccines have to transported to some of the most remote parts of the world and need to be kept constantly refrigerated, even in tropical heat. 
 Educating the people is vitally important too &mdash; because unless families understand why immunisation is so important, they will not bring their children forward to be vaccinated. 
 That is why UNICEF field workers and medical teams are working with local community and religious leaders in countless towns and villages to spread the word about how the six major diseases can be defeated. 
 The successful work that was done to eradicate smallpox some years ago shows what can be achieved. 
 It is ten years now since the last case of smallpox was reported. 
 Now, after years of hard work, we are in sight of immunising all the world's children against polio, tuberculosis, diphtheria, whooping cough, tetanus and measles. 
 With your help we can achieve that goal in 1990 &mdash; and in doing so, we can save the lives of three and a half million children every year. 
 It costs around &pound;6 to immunise one child. 
 That includes the cost of vaccines needles, syringes and cold storage. 
 Every &pound;6 you can send will help save a child's life. 
 Please support our Passport to Health campaign and give as generously as you can. 
 Save the Children 
 Now Christmas is over, who will help the children? 
 Won't you be our friend? 
 Christmas is now behind us. 
 But before we lose the spirit of Christmas, will you make one more gift of kindness? 
 Wherever children are in need &mdash; month in, month out, year after year &mdash; Save the Children Fund helps with your help. 
 Save the Children is Britain's leading international children's charity. 
 Our aim: to bring help and comfort to poor, hungry, sick and needy children throughout the world. 
 We cannot achieve this aim without the support of friends. 
 Friends like the Post Office workers who have kindly agreed to deliver this leaflet for nothing&hellip;. 
 And friends like yourself who are willing to give a child somewhere the gift of life and hope. 
 As this new year begins, there's so much work to be done&hellip; 
 Now, as a new year begins, will you help Save the Children to continue providing care and support all over the world? 
 Please read a little about our work, then give whatever you can. 
 You can be sure that your donation, however small, will make an important difference to the lives of needy children in Britain and overseas. 
 Working with children all over Britain 
 Here in Britain, Save the Children works with thousands of children every day. 
 And with your support, we can help give even more of these youngsters a better start in life. 
 Giving care and affection. 
 Organising community playgroups to look after the under-fives. 
 Offering after-school play and leisure opportunities for children with nowhere to go. 
 Devising ways to keep younger children out of care and older children out of trouble. 
 And giving young parents a source of friendly, practical advice. 
 Helping families to help themselves 
 For so many British children, growing up in an inner city area could mean missing out on so many things they need to grow up healthy and secure. 
 Sometimes, it's simply a question of somewhere safe to go after school while parents are working. 
 But there are greater problems, too. 
 Save the Children works all over the country to help children and their families overcome the effects of high unemployment, inadequate housing lack of community services, language difficulties and the family tensions that can follow. 
 Our drop-in Family Centres are a particularly important feature of our work in inner-city Britain. 
 They provide stimulating surroundings for the underfives and support for their parents. 
 Like all Save the Children's community projects, these Centres are developed in partnership with their users and parents are encouraged to play a major role in both running the Centre and raising funds. 
 Bringing new hope to children and parents 
 Overseas, too, Save the Children concentrates on long-term benefits for whole communities. 
 But even a small donation can make a big difference to one child's life. 
 In Africa, for example, it costs just 20p &mdash; the price of a cup of tea &mdash; to immunise a child against six killer diseases. 
 Yet every minute, six children die and six are crippled by TB, measles, polio, whooping cough, tetanus or diphtheria. 
 With your help we can end this needless tragedy. 
 And if you are a parent yourself, please spare a thought for the mothers of these children so far away. 
 Will you help us provide the basic hygiene and nutritional teaching they so desperately need? 
 By training one local villager we can bring change to a whole community. 
 What's more, we'll give families the economic and technical support they need to irrigate land, grow crops, raise livestock and so provide a better future for their children. 
 There's still so much to be done 
 In Britain today, and all over the world, there are countless children and their families whose future depends on Save the Children. 
 Will you help us to be there when they need us? 
 Please send whatever you can. 
 Just complete and detach the form overleaf and enclose it with your donation or credit card number in the envelope provided. 
 Thank you. 
 Read this vital message to you from The Princess Royal 
 &bquo;Sadly, thousands of children in the world today suffer needlessly. 
 Not just overseas where Save the Children has built up a well deserved reputation for its long term and disaster work &mdash; but here in Britain, too. 
 Here, the Fund runs many family projects that are less well-known but doing work that is every bit as important. 
 This appeal is going out to you after  Christmas. 
 At Christmas people give generously. 
 Not only to their own families, but also to charities, often in thanks for their own good fortune. 
 Afterwards, it's easy to forget that the important work for the children still goes on. 
 And still needs your support. 
 That is why I am asking you now to become a Friend of Save the Children. 
 This leaflet has been delivered free by your local postman or postwoman as a result of generous support by the Union of Communication Workers. 
 The Fund is very grateful to them for their help. 
 And to you, for yours.&equo; 
  Anne Her Royal Highness The Princess Royal GCVO President of The Save The Children Fund  
 Give us a helping hand 
 For every &pound;1.00 you give, the children get &pound;1.33's worth or help. 
 It's easy. 
 It's called a covenant. 
 Which, very simply, means you agree to make a regular donation to Save the Children for four years or more. 
 We can then reclaim the income tax you &mdash; or your spouse &mdash; have paid already. 
 If you pay the basic rate, every &pound;1.00 you give is suddenly worth &pound;1.33. 
 That's enough to provide 100 antibiotic tablets to fight infections and  sufficient vaccine to protect four children from polio for life. 
 When you sign the Deed of Covenant, it means you're helping us to give more help to more children. 
 You give 
 We receive 
 And we can buy 
 &pound;12 
 &pound;16.00 
 Laying hens to help 16 families in the Himalayas feed their children. 
 &pound;24 
 &pound;32.00 
 A doctor's stethoscope. 
 &pound;60 
 &pound;80.00 
 Enough food to give 330 children in India a nourishing meal. 
 &pound;120 
 &pound;160.00 
 Workshop tools to help UK teenagers in a high unemployment area to learn new skills. 
 &pound;150 
 &pound;200.00 
 A nurse working with sick children in Honduras for six weeks. 
 &pound;250 
 &pound;333.33 
 A solar-powered refrigerator to store vaccines which protect children from fatal diseases. 
 &pound;500 
 &pound;666.67 
 A generator providing vital power and light for a medical team working in remote rural areas. 
 When you consider that our work costs &pound;100,000 a day, you'll understand why every penny counts. 
 Make your donation even more valuable 
 The most valuable way to give 
 Quite apart from the fact that every &pound;1.00 you give us by covenant is worth &pound;1.33 your contributions mean we can rely on a regular income. 
 So we have the financial security to meet our greatest challenge &mdash; developing long-term projects. 
 Why is this our greatest challenge? 
 Because Save the Children want to lay the foundations for a better future. 
 To help the children of today &mdash; and tomorrow. 
 That's why we spend your money on helping to build village vegetable gardens in Honduras. 
 Something more than emergency rations are required in a country where 80% of children under the age of five suffer from malnutrition. 
 And a village water supply will protect everyone from a common yet life-threatening disease like diarrhoea. 
 Your covenant means we help children in 53 countries around the globe. 
 By setting up mother and child health services. 
 Organising immunisation campaigns against killer and crippling diseases. 
 Training volunteer auxiliary nurses. 
 And supporting schools. 
 In the United Kingdom alone we run 100 projects and help 15,000 children every day, in many different ways. 
 You make it possible. 
 Please help us to make your money work even harder. 
 Complete the Deed of Covenant today. 
 And return it to The Save the Children Fund, Freepost, London SE5 8BR. 
 Later we shall send you another form to sign, so we can claim the tax. 
 Thank you&hellip; on behalf of the children.  
 With a covenant &mdash; every &pound;1 is worth &pound;1.33. 
 Enough to buy 133 antibiotic tablets. 
 A simple education &mdash; no country in the world has a future without it. 
 Relief schemes lead onto long-term projects, helping people to help themselves. 
 Your questions answered 
 Q. What is the minimum amount I can covenant? 
 A. We ask for &pound;12 a year &mdash; to give a smaller amount please use the Bankers Order. 
 Q. How often do I make my donations? 
 A. It's up to you whether you prefer to pay monthly, quarterly or annually. 
 If you're able to lend us the entire amount of your covenanted donation at the outset (e.g. &pound;100 if you decide to covenant &pound;25 a year) we can invest your contribution as a lump sum and earn extra interest over the years and still reclaim the tax. 
 Just ask for more details. 
 Q. What if I don't have a Bank Account? 
 A. You can still make out a Deed of Covenant, and send the money directly to Save the Children by Postal Order. 
 Q. Do I have to pay income tax in order to help Save the Children by covenant? 
 A. No. 
 Provided your married partner is a taxpayer, we can still claim an extra 33p for every &pound;1.00 you give. 
 However, under new tax rules, from April a husband and wife will be treated as two separate tax payers. 
 Therefore, your taxpaying partner will have to complete the deed of covenant in order for us to claim the tax. 
 Q. What if I'm in the higher tax bracket? 
 A. Then there's all the more reason to make out a covenant. 
 let's say you pay tax at 40%. 
 If you agree to give us &pound;1,200 a year, the ACTUAL cost to your is only &pound;960. 
 But Save the Children receives the startling amount of &pound;1600&hellip; making your donation almost 67% more valuable. 
 Remember &mdash; you can help in other ways, too. 
 Sponsor a child 
 For millions of children, no money means no education. 
 Sponsorship will transform their lives. 
 When you become a sponsor, you help an individual child and receive regular reports about his or her progress. 
 Become a volunteer. 
 Your time can be as valuable as your donation. 
 Did you realise we've a network of over 850 branches in the UK? 
 Our volunteers raise millions of pounds every year. 
 Many have only a few hours to spare, but they enjoy helping in this way. 
 Leave a legacy. 
 We'd like to send you our free booklet &bquo;A Will to Leave.&equo; 
 You'll find advice about making out a Will. 
 And we explain how a legacy helps Save the Children. 
 Ask for our catalogue. 
 Choose your gifts from our carefully chosen selection. 
 All profits go to the children. 
 Or, buy from one of our shops which are all run by volunteers.  
 Someone cares enough to sponsor his education. 
 He's lucky. 
 Help Save the Children 
 national schizophrenia fellowship 
 What is Schizophrenia? 
 Schizophrenia and related disorders are among the most disabling of mental illnesses. 
 Yet it is often a hidden disability, which isolates both the people who suffer from it and their families. 
 There are up to 250,000 sufferers in Britain today &mdash; about 20,000 of them in hospital at any one time. 
 (This means that it takes up more hospital space than any other single illness.) 
 Schizophrenia can take a number of forms. 
 It is difficult to diagnose, as there is no simple test. 
 But some experiences are common among people who suffer from it. 
 For example, hallucinations: hearing strange and often frightening voices. 
 Delusions: believing things about yourself and others which make ordinary life very difficult if not impossible, such as believing that people and even objects are working against you. 
 It is NOT a matter of having a &bquo;split personality&equo;. 
 As a result of the illness, people with schizophrenia often have great difficulty in finding or keeping employment, housing, and relationships. 
 Without proper treatment and support, many end up homeless, unemployed for long periods, and cut off from their families. 
 Many sufferers do recover but frequently there are relapses. 
 Stress and other problems can make the illness worse. 
 There is no known cure but the illness can be treated &mdash; by medication backed by practical and caring support. 
 Founded in 1972, the National Schizophrenia Fellowship is a voluntary organisation set up by relatives of people with schizophrenia and allied disorders. 
 Self-help groups at local level provide information, advice and support to families and many are involved in developing housing and day activity projects. 
 Our advisory services answer thousands of queries from people all over the country. 
 We have helped with many television and radio programmes. 
 We organise conferences and meetings. 
 We have made reasoned submissions to National and Local Government and other authorities.  
 We need your support 
 Please send me more information about schizophrenia and the Fellowship, including a publications list, covenant form, and details of how to join. 
 I would like to make a donation to support the work of the Fellowship, and enclose a cheque/postal order 
 Friends of the Earth 
 July 1990 
 Within the next ten years much of the Amazon Rainforest could be wiped out. 
 Will you help stop this destruction? 
 Dear Friend, 
 Imagine you are driving at midday. 
 Your headlights are full on. 
 People are wearing face masks. 
 Others are choking on the acrid fumes. 
 Airports have been closed. 
 Smoke hangs in a yellow pall over half the country. 
 This is what it has been like during the dry season in Brazil for the past two years. 
 Thousands of fires raged out of control across Amazonia. 
 Millions of acres of rainforest were reduced to a desolate wasteland of charred tree-stumps. 
 In 1989 alone, an area nearly twice the size of Belgium was devastated. 
 Friends of the Earth desperately needs your help now to prevent the greatest man-made ecological catastrophe yet known: the systematic burning of the Amazon Rainforest. 
 TOMORROW WILL BE TOO LATE. 
 The tropical rainforests are the richest source of life on earth, the result of millions of years of evolution. 
 A four square mile area of rainforest can contain up to 1,500 species of flowering plants, as many as in the whole of Britain. 
 Rainforests contain tens of thousands of unique types of trees, birds, butterflies and mammals. 
 Many are now threatened with extinction. 
 The forest-dwelling people are being murdered, terrorised, infected with diseases and driven from their territories as the forests are being destroyed. 
 Entire tribes have disappeared as a result of forest destruction. 
 If the devastation continues at current rates, much of the Amazon Rainforest will have been obliterated by the end of the century, now just ten years away. 
 WHY ARE THE RAINFORESTS SO IMPORTANT TO US? 
 With all the problems facing us at home, what have the rainforests got to do with us? 
 In fact they are the key to our survival &mdash; and our planet's future. 
 This is because the deliberate burning of the rainforests pumps hundreds of millions of tonnes of carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. 
 Carbon dioxide is the main cause of global warming &mdash; the Greenhouse Effect. 
 We now know this threatens to dramatically alter the world's weather patterns, raising sea levels and bringing floods, droughts and famines to us and the Third World. 
 Rainforests give us life in other ways too. 
 One in every four purchases from your local chemist contains compounds derived from rainforest species. 
 Many more life-saving drugs are waiting to be made from rainforest species. 
 And yet these species are vanishing at the rate of one every half hour, before we can even identify and research them. 
 For instance, 2,000 plants that promise to be valuable in treating cancer come from the rainforests. 
 A rainforest plant, the Madagascar Periwinkle, has been discovered to perform miracles in treating childhood leukaemia. 
 Already research has begun into chemicals from the Morton Bay Chestnut, an Australian Rainforest tree, as an inhibitive drug against the Aids virus. 
 Growing in the wild, plants related to our cultivated food crops provide new genetic strains. 
 With cross-breeding, they improve crop yields and increase resistance to pests and disease. 
 When we destroy this &bquo;genetic bank&equo; we may also kill our hope for feeding our planet in the future. 
 WHO IS LIGHTING THE FIRES IN THE RAINFORESTS? 
 Ludicrous as it may seem, government policies in some rainforest countries actually encourage the fires. 
 In Brazil, until very recently, wealthy farmers actually received tax subsidies as an incentive to burn the forest for cattle ranches. 
 Despite a cut back on subsidies, existing land ownership laws still encourage clearance for ranches. 
 But the ranches are also shortlived. 
 Rainforest soils are usually very poor and when exposed to the harsh sun and heavy tropical rains, their fertility is soon washed away. 
 When this happens, the land is abandoned and yet more rainforest is burned. 
 Transnational companies, particularly oil and mining concerns, are also to blame, driving new roads into remote areas to reach their concessions. 
 These roads open up the rainforest to waves of settlers who move into the forests and clear even more land by fire. 
 The crisis taking place in Brazil is happening throughout the world's rainforests. 
 The situation is now so serious that an area of tropical rainforest the size of 6 football pitches is destroyed every minute of the day. 
 WHAT IS FRIENDS OF THE EARTH DOING TO HALT THIS MADNESS? 
 Many people in rainforest countries are fighting to stop this terrible destruction, including Friends of the Earth organisations in Brazil, Indonesia and Malaysia. 
 They need our help now more than ever before to exert massive international pressure on the governments, institutions and companies involved. 
 So far: 
 we have joined with other organisations and persuaded the World Bank to pull out of a number of projects that threaten to destroy forests. 
 Friends of the Earth has persuaded Lloyds, Midland and Nat West Banks to re-direct their funds from a &dollar;600 million loan for destructive development projects in Amazonia; 
 we have written and published a new &bquo;Good Wood Guide&equo; to help stop the sale of rainforest hardwoods; 
 we are helping the Amazonian Indians and tribal people in Malaysia in their fight for survival by generating worldwide publicity for their cause, and campaigning to protect their rainforest lands; 
 we have persuaded the international paper-making giant Scott to pull out of a forest-destroying project in Indonesia; 
 we are persuading international companies such as BP, Shell and Conoco to make sure that their activities are not destroying rainforests; 
 we are researching overseas aid projects to show how the Amazon can be developed without harming the rainforest; 
 we are lobbying the EC to make sure its aid programmes and industrial activities are not destroying the rainforest. 
 These actions work. 
 We have proved that we can get things done. 
 By concentrating on the governments, banks and companies involved, and by assisting the tribal people, we can help to save the rainforests. 
 Your support for our work will enable us to be even more effective. 
 WE URGENTLY NEED YOUR SUPPORT 
 Remember, at the current rate of devastation, much of the remaining rainforest could be destroyed within the next 10 years. 
 We must act now to stop this happening. 
 Friends of the Earth relies on gifts from concerned people, and if you have taken the trouble to read this letter, I sincerely believe you may be one of those who will help. 
 Please support us today by joining Friends of the Earth. 
 Or if you prefer, by simply sending a donation of &pound;100, &pound;35, &pound;20, &pound;10 or whatever you can afford. 
 Every penny counts in the battle to save the forests. 
 Please reply today if you can. 
 The rainforests and the tribal peoples who live there have never needed your help so urgently. 
 Yours sincerely  David Gee Director  
 PS. 
 If you are able to send a total of &pound;35 or more we will show our thanks by sending you a free copy of &bquo;How to be Green&equo;. 
 DON'T LET THE TROPICAL RAINFORESTS GO UP IN SMOKE. 
 IT'S UP TO YOU. 
 Friends of the Earth 
 TIME IS RUNNING OUT 
 Imagine a rainforest the size of England, Scotland and Wales. 
 Now imagine that same rainforest being totally destroyed by fire in just three months. 
 A terrifying thought isn't it? 
 It happened in Brazil last year. 
 Half the world's rainforests have already been destroyed, mainly in the last forty years. 
 And lost with the rainforests are endangered animals, rare plants and the homelands of innocent forest-dwelling people. 
 We must act now. 
 Unless we do, in the short space of one human lifetime, we will have undone millions of years of evolution. 
 Our whole future may depend on the rainforests. 
 We are the last generation who can avert this catastrophe. 
 THE CATALOGUE OF DESTRUCTION 
 The rainforests are being destroyed at a frightening rate, by burning, logging, flooding, mining and pollution. 
 In the Amazonian rainforests, deliberate burning is the greatest problem. 
 On one single day last year, a satellite spotted 8,000 fires. 
 The smoke this produced was so dense that it closed airports and smothered half the country. 
 The results of this wilful burning reach far beyond the rainforests. 
 Hundreds of millions of tonnes of carbon dioxide are pumped into the atmosphere each year from tropical forest burning, contributing to the &bquo;Greenhouse Effect&equo; &mdash; or global warming &mdash; which could severely disrupt the world's climate. 
 Rainforests are the source of a multitude of raw materials with immense potential value to medical science. 
 Many of these will be lost forever, before they have even been named. 
 The Amazon rainforests alone are home to many unique animals and to one fifth of the world's bird species. 
 These are all under threat from the advancing destruction. 
 Rainforest-dwelling people have learnt to live in harmony with their environment. 
 Their unparalleled knowledge of the uses and properties of forest plants and wildlife will disappear with the forests. 
 ANNUAL LOSSES OF RAINFOREST 
 SAVING THE RAINFOREST 
 Update 
 HOW ARE THE RAINFORESTS BEING DESTROYED? 
 In West Africa and South-East Asia, commercial loggers cut down hardwoods to supply rich consumer countries &mdash; but they rarely replant. 
 The governments of developing countries construct huge projects through foreign aid and investment. 
 Rainforests have been flooded for hydro-electric dams. 
 Roads and mining also cause widespread devastation. 
 But the benefits are usually very shortlived. 
 Transnational oil and mining companies pollute rivers and finance grossly disruptive mines. 
 To reach their concessions, they build roads into previously remote areas. 
 These roads create access for settlers and ranchers who advance yet further into the rainforest. 
 WHY IS THE RAINFOREST BEING BURNT? 
 In many countries the answer is cattle. 
 Existing laws actively encourage clearance of forests for cattle ranching. 
 and the quickest way to get the land is to burn the rainforests. 
 But the cattle ranches are shortlived. 
 When the land is exposed to the harsh tropical sun and torrential rain, it quickly becomes infertile. 
 When this happens the land is abandoned and yet more rainforest burned. 
 WHO LOSES? 
 The answer is brutally simple &mdash; everyone and everything. 
 The indigenous people who live in the forests all around the world have been murdered, terrorised and driven from their land by greedy developers. 
 Over 2,000 plants which are being investigated for their anti-cancer properties come from the rainforests &mdash; as more rainforests disappear, so too might a possible cure for diseases such as Aids. 
 Forest-dwelling animals and birds including the Jaguar, Woolly Spider Monkey and Scarlet Macaw are in imminent danger of extinction. 
 Many of our foods originate from tropical forest species such as rice, cocoa, fruit, maize and coffee. 
 Species not yet discovered could hold the answer to world hunger. 
 THE GREENHOUSE EFFECT 
 Burning tropical rainforest produces millions of tonnes of carbon dioxide each year, which contributes to global warming &mdash; the Greenhouse Effect. 
 Greenhouse gases trap heat and prevent its escape from the atmosphere into space. 
 As the world becomes hotter, there could be disastrous changes in weather patterns and widespread flooding as sea levels rise. 
 Living tropical forests also absorb carbon dioxide. 
 Without the forests, global warming will be even more devastating. 
 The Greenhouse Effect is now the e world's most pressing environmental problem. 
 One of the solutions is to protect the rainforests.  
 Visible light from the sun passes through the atmosphere to the earth's surface. 
 Heat radiation leaves earth. 
 Some escapes, but gases in the atmosphere trap the rest, keeping the earth warm. 
 A build-up of gases, including carbon dioxide and CFC's, prevents additional heat radiation from escaping, thus heating up the earth excessively. 
 What is Friends of the Earth doing and how can you help? 
 Friends of the Earth is mobilising public opinion around the world. 
 Already we have helped to pressure the World Bank into reviewing its road-building programmes and, most recently, to cancel a loan for a huge new dam in the Amazon. 
 We have helped to bring about the formation of the International Tropical Timber Organisation &mdash; to regulate the industry and to set up sustainable management. 
 We have encouraged the governments of Britain and the USA to reconsider their support for Indonesia's notorious Transmigration Programme. 
 We are working with a wide range of people throughout the world to find a balance between genuinely sustainable forestry and the outright protection of the last remaining virgin rainforest. 
 You can play your part. 
 All UK consumers have some impact on the rainforests. 
 Before you buy furniture, make sure it isn't made from tropical hardwoods, unless from a sustainable source. 
 If you travel to a tropical country, write to that country's tourist office to tell them that you are concerned about the preservation of their forests. 
 Don't buy curios or trophies made from wild species. 
 Exercise your democratic rights. 
 Write to your MP and to the European Parliament to insist that they act to stop the destruction of the rainforests. 
 Your letters really will make a difference. 
 And please help our vital campaigns by sending a donation to Friends of the Earth. 
 We rely entirely on the concern of private individuals like yourself.  
 Half of the world's rainforest has already been destroyed. 
 Burning 
 Road building 
 Flooding 
 Cattle Ranching 
 Mineral and Oil Extraction 
 Logging 
 ENDANGERED NOW 
 Scarlet Macaw, Amazonia, one of nature's most colourful birds. 
 Other imminent losses in Amazonia include the Giant Otter and the Woolly Spider Monkey. 
 Tiger, South East Asia. 
 Other creatures at risk in South East Asia are the Tapir and the Giant Atlas Moth. 
 In Sumatra, Rafflesia Arnoldii, the world's largest and stinkiest flower, is disappearing. 
 Gorilla, Congo Basin, Central Africa. 
 The mountain Gorilla, a uniquely social animal, is threatened by habitat destruction and poaching. 
 Jaguar, Central America. 
 One of the world's most beautiful cats is fast disappearing. 
 In 30 years, Central America has lost two thirds of its rainforests. 
 Friends of the Earth is one of the leading environmental pressure groups in the UK. 
 Established in 1971, FoE now has more than 270 active local groups in England and Wales, 180,000 supporters and a separate organisation in Scotland. 
 FoE's role is to persuade politicians and decision makers at every level that only by protecting the Earth can we protect ourselves &mdash; against pollution and the destruction of our urban and rural environment. 
 FoE campaigns on 12 major issues, including Global Warming, Tropical Rainforests, Water and Air Pollution, Energy, The Ozone Layer and Recycling.  
 PRINTED ON RECYCLED PAPER 
 HOPE FOR THE FUTURE IN A CHANGING WORLD 
 CND 
 I'd like to take a few moments of your time&hellip; 
 We all have hopes for the future and that is why supporting CND is so important. 
 But our hopes aren't shared by everyone, especially those who threaten our future with nuclear weapons. 
 That is why I am writing to ask for your support. 
 Our government is making plans. 
 Plans for our future, without our consent. 
 Despite the changes taking place in Europe, it plans to station even more nuclear weapons here in Britain. 
 It's an illogical and dangerous policy. 
 But the time for Cold War policies is over. 
 The world is changing fast and it is the ideas of CND and the peace movement that are at the forefront of change. 
 We are the peacemakers. 
 CND is launching a new campaign as part of our overall goal of a nuclear-free world. 
 The time has come for Britain to cut its military spending and begin to use its limited resources for our real needs. 
 A &bquo;Peace Dividend&equo; for homes, hospitals and environment. 
 &bull; We have commissioned a report that shows that spending money in the civil sector creates more jobs than spending money on defence industries. 
 &bull; We will be briefing MPs, making sure they have accurate information, and ensuring that the &bquo;Peace Dividend&equo; is a major issue at all the political party conferences. 
 &bull; We will be providing information for CND supporters around the country to show how a &bquo;Peace Dividend&equo; could benefit their local areas. 
 These are just some of our plans and they are ambitious. 
 We need to raise at least &pound;50,000 to put our plans into effect. 
 One way you can support us is by sending a donation. 
 Now more than ever it is important to be a force for change. 
 Nuclear weapons are Britain's Berlin Wall. 
 Through the pressure of our numbers and the power of our campaigning, we too can bring them down. 
 We know we can succeed. 
 WE can get rid of Trident missiles just as we got rid of cruise missiles. 
 We can keep up the pressure for more treaties just as public pressure led to the signing of the INF treaty in 1987. 
 And we know from opinion polls that most people now want Britain to play its part too in making the world a safer place. 
 So play your part. 
 Please send us a donation and keep CND's peace message at the forefront of a changing world. 
 Thank you. 
  Bruce Kent.  
 P.S. We can plan our campaigns more effectively if we have a regular income. 
 A Banker's Order would help us enormously and if you are able to fill in the form enclosed and send us &pound;5 a month we will send you a FREE copy of our monthly magazine &bquo;Sanity&equo;.  
 BY THE PRESSURE OF OUR NUMBERS&hellip; 
 AND THE POWER OF OUR CAMPAIGNING&hellip; 
 WE ARE SEEING CHANGE. 
 The Exile Appeal for Refugees in Britain 
 Refugees are people whose lives have been shattered by intolerance, persecution, torture and fear of death. 
 They seek a chance to rebuild their lives in safety, hoping that one day they may be able to return home. 
 The British Refugee Council has been working with and providing services to refugees in Britain since 1981. 
 There is an ever increasing need for our work. 
 That is why we appeal for your help. 
 Settling in 
 Most refugees have little time to prepare for life in a new country. 
 They arrive with few belongings, haunted by events left behind. 
 Often there is little respite when they get here. 
 How can they support themselves? 
 Will they be sent back? 
 Last year more than 3,000 refugees from 60 countries were helped by BRC workers. 
 New arrivals were also put in touch with groups of refugees from their own countries. 
 These community groups themselves provide a range of welfare and cultural services and can help reduce the isolation which so many refugees experience.  
 &bquo;We don't come here for economic reasons &mdash; we come here to seek life.&equo; 
 Ugandan refugee in Britain. 
 Refugee children 
 Recently a 17-year old refugee arrived in England with her three-year-old sister and applied for asylum. 
 Their father had been arrested; their mother was isolated in an area cut off by fighting. 
 Faced with this situation, the elder girl sold some family property and bought two tickets to London. 
 On their arrival immigration officers contacted BRC workers at the Langtry Walk hostel. 
 It is not unusual for unaccompanied children to travel as refugees. 
 Desperate parents often ask adults flying to a safe country to take their children for them. 
 The children are often left on arrival. 
 However, children do not always find it easy to get asylum. 
 Five children between the ages of nine and 14 who were on their way to Germany were left in London by accompanying adults. 
 Over a period of three weeks they were shunted back and forth between Germany, London and Cairo until the Home Office granted them temporary admission. 
 BRC was contacted and we found them somewhere to live and someone from their own country to look after them. 
 The children have lost contact with their families. 
 Their future is uncertain. 
 A refugee's story 
 &bquo;I was arrested, imprisoned and tortured. 
 I did not expect to survive but miraculously I escaped and got out of the country. 
 Then my wife was taken. 
 She was imprisoned and tortured. 
 I arrived in England and applied for asylum. 
 I was put in touch with the British Refugee Council and given a room in one of their hostels. 
 They arranged English classes for me. 
 All this time I was desperately worried about my family. 
 I learned that my wife had been released but had very little money to live on. 
 I was fortunate to be granted full refugee status in under a year, this entitled me to bring my family here. 
 Again BRC was able to help. 
 It took a lot of organising. 
 I had not seen them for over two years. 
 Imprisonment and becoming refugees had affected us badly and we needed the support we were given. 
 Now I am studying to get a British qualification to continue the work I did at home. 
 We have been allocated a flat and I hope we can live a normal life in spite of the past. 
 BRC cares 
 Somewhere to live 
 Finding a place to stay is one of the biggest obstacles facing refugees on arrival. 
 Last year BRC hostels and satellite houses received over 500 refugees, giving priority to the disabled, torture victims, single parent families and women. 
 In addition to providing accommodation ourselves, BRC's team of housing workers find other accommodation for those in need. 
 Often we can secure the release of refugees from detention if we can find them somewhere to live. 
 The chance of a job 
 The difficulty of getting a worthwhile job is one of the greatest barriers to the successful settlement of refugees in Britain. 
 BRC trains hundreds of refugees each year for employment. 
 A home when you're old 
 BRC runs residential homes where elderly refugees can find the help and comfort they need. 
 Many still bear the scars of Nazi oppression. 
 Campaigning for change worldwide 
 On the international front, BRC spearheads the concerns of most British agencies involved with refugees worldwide. 
 We are in the unique position of having privileged access to information from their workers in almost every region where refugees are concerned. 
 At home, for example, we are seeking from the government a code of practice so that all refugees arriving here receive consistent, fair and humane treatment. 
 Who is a refugee? 
 A refugee is &bquo;a person who, owing to a well-founded fear of persecution for reasons of race, religion, membership of a particular social group or political opinion, is outside the country of his nationality and is unable or, owing to such fear, unwilling to avail himself of the protection of that country&equo; , according to the United Nations 1951 Convention and 1967 Protocol Relating to the Status of Refugees. 
 By signing the Convention and Protocol, Britain chose to receive refugees favourably and not return them to countries where they may have reason to fear persecution. 
 Refugees bring with them not just a bundle of belongings but an accumulation of skills and knowledge and a real determination to make a positive contribution to their new country.  
 It doesn't take much to become a refugee. 
 Your race or beliefs can be enough. 
 Torture &mdash; the continuing pain 
 According to Amnesty International, torture is practised in more than 90 countries. 
 Many refugees have suffered from this and other forms of inhuman treatment. 
 Of course, most countries deny that they torture people. 
 Even this can affect refugees adversely &mdash; their stories of torture may not be believed when they apply for asylum. 
 Torture and other forms of trauma often result in devastating long-term psychological effects. 
 Victims need treatment, care and understanding. 
 They rarely forget the horror that they experienced. 
 Even those who receive treatment frequently break down in old age. 
 Previous generations of refugees still need our help and support. 
 Detained 
 Numbers of refugees seeking asylum in the United Kingdom are held in detention for long periods following their arrival. 
 Detainees are often subject to prison conditions despite the fact that they have not committed any crime. 
 Some asylum seekers have been detained for over a year. 
 Detention causes acute psychological stress; the trauma of fleeing persecution is heightened by imprisonment, isolation and the threat of deportation. 
 The myth of floods 
 It has been suggested that Britain is being &bquo;flooded&equo; with refugees. 
 The facts do not support such alarmist statements. 
 In 1988 there were 5,105 applications for asylum in the UK. 
 This is slightly up on the previous year but for the past five years there has been no substantial rise in the number of asylum-seekers. 
 Over the same period, over 400,000 immigrants have come to Britain and over a million people have emigrated to other countries. 
 Asylum-seekers are not a major factor in immigration terms. 
 Britain's generosity as a receiving country is, however, open to question. 
 In the same period from 1984 to 1987 we received far fewer applications for asylum from refugees than our European neighbours. 
 Sweden, Denmark, Belgium, Switzerland, West Germany, Austria, France and the Netherlands all received more applications for asylum from refugees than the UK both in absolute terms and in proportion to population. 
 From Simon Rattle CBE 
 Dear Friend 
 &bquo;SUICIDE AGGRAVATED BY OFFICIAL INDIFFERENCE AND LACK OF CARE&equo; was the verdict on a Ugandan refugee who hanged himself while in detention in Pentonville Prison. 
 Ahmed Katangole was due to be deported, the Home Office had refused him refugee status. 
 Those chilling words &mdash; official indifference and lack of care &mdash; may well sum up the experience of refugees in many countries, not just our own. 
 But I find them particularly disturbing when related to the death of a refugee seeking asylum in Britain. 
 It is for refugees in Britain that I am writing to ask for your help. 
 The massive violation of human rights around the world &mdash; some 90 countries are believed to  practice  torture &mdash; means that escape and exile is the only hope for many survivors of that oppression. 
 The British Refugee Council urgently needs your support for its vital work with and for exiles who seek a new life here. 
 Please be generous. 
 With grateful thanks,  Simon Rattle  
 P.S The target for this Exile Appeal is &pound;125,000. 
 It is a lot for a young charity still to establish itself. 
 But it can be done &mdash; with your help.  
 &bquo;It is because of you that I am living here in peace. 
 Otherwise I would have been sent back to my country and I do not know what would have happened to us.&equo; 
 THE VEGETARIAN SOCIETY 
 LIVE STOCK FARMING ISN'T JUST KILLING ANIMALS 
 Meat is not cheap. 
 Apart from costing the lives of countless millions of animals each year, its production is also causing starvation for millions all over the world. 
 How can the production of food result in people going hungry? 
 Because over half the world's cereal harvest is fed to livestock being reared for slaughter, and not to men, women and children. 
 And it takes a full 3lbs of that grain to produce just 1lb of poultry. 
 Or 10lbs of grain to yield a mere 1lb of intensively reared beef. 
 It's a shameful waste of resources. 
 One that you can help to correct by rejecting meat from your diet. 
 Because the more people who go vegetarian, the more the agricultural industry &mdash; and it is an industry these days, as mechanical as any other &mdash; will be forced to re-assess its methods of operation and adjust its swollen meat production policy down as demand dwindles. 
 STARVING 
 A third of the world's population is starving. 
 15 MILLION children die every year because of malnutrition, die slowly and horribly. 
 And yet, this planet could supply ample food for everyone. 
 The problem is mis-management &mdash; a huge wastage of resources &mdash; take a look at these figures: 
 10 acres of land (that's about 5 football pitches) will support 
 61 people on a diet of soya beans 
 24 people on a diet of wheat 
 10 people on a diet of maize 
 2 people on a diet of cattle meat 
 At least ten times as many people can be supported on a cereal diet  than  on a meat based diet &mdash; and that figure rockets up to 30 TIMES AS MANY people being supported by a diet based on soya protein. 
 This country alone could support 250 MILLION people on a plant based diet, that's almost five times the current population. 
 Countries like Ethiopia and India grow their own grain. 
 Countries like Britain take that food from where it is needed most to feed to livestock over here. 
 Did you know that we imported cereal from Ethiopia during the famine just so that we could have our meat? 
 So, next time you hear yourself say those words &mdash; I'm starving &mdash; think about what you are saying. 
 Are you really that hungry? 
 Are you really so hungry that you just have to nip into that fastfood burger joint? 
 THINK ABOUT THE CONSEQUENCES, THINK OF THE PEOPLE WHO REALLY ARE STARVING BECAUSE WE TAKE THEIR FOOD FROM THEM TO SATISFY OUR APPETITE. 
 SUFFOCATING 
 As if all this weren't reason enough, there's always the environment. 
 Tropical rainforest produces most of the oxygen YOU breathe, and right now large multi-national companies are clearing vast areas of that forest for cattle ranching. 
 Cattle that go to produce the basic ingredient of that beefburger. 
 Forests are destroyed, cattle reared and slaughtered and the land left infertile. 
 When that forest goes, it goes for good, and it's going fast. 
 100 acres of rainforest is devastated and disappears every minute of every day, cutting off our lifeblood, YOUR AIRSUPPLY. 
 MEAT ISN'T JUST MURDER, IT'S SUICIDE 
 YOU can do something about the situation, YOU can take personal responsibility for conserving the  worlds  finite resources, by not consuming meat and animal products. 
 Cut down your meat consumption, better still cut out meat and slaughterhouse products altogether. 
 JOIN THE MOVEMENT TO STOP THIS WASTE &amp; DESTRUCTION 
 JOIN THE VEGETARIAN SOCIETY 
 WE MUST STOP THIS MADNESS! 
 SEE INSIDE HOW YOUR DONATION WILL HELP US WITH THE FIGHT FOR THE FOREST&hellip; 
 The tropical rainforest tree pictured on the front of the leaflet was at least 400 years old when a chainsaw cut it down. 
 For centuries it was part of the richest life support system in the world. 
 But it was not the only rainforest tree to fall on that day. 
 Every day that passes 74,000 acres of rainforest in the world are burned, logged or bulldozed to the ground. 
 In the last 80 years half of the world's rainforests have been destroyed. 
 Wholesale destruction for hardwood doors, windows, coffins and plywood 
 Only two or three in every hundred forest trees are suitable for logging. 
 Yet in the course of logging over half the surrounding forest is severely damaged. 
 It's an immense price to pay for hardwood doors, windows, coffins and plywood. 
 Cattle Ranching 
 Hungry subsistence farmers follow in the wake of loggers. 
 They clear the remaining forest by fire, opening it up for their own agriculture, or to hand over to cattle ranchers. 
 Millions of acres of tropical forest have been cleared in the pursuit of cheaper beef for hamburgers. 
 Over 50% of the land cleared to produce hamburgers in Brazil has now been exhausted and abandoned. 
 Treasure chest thrown away 
 The tropical rainforests are a treasure chest of undiscovered medicines, natural drugs and chemicals, new disease resistant strains of fruits and crops. 
 Throwing them away is sheer folly. 
 Wildlife lost for ever 
 Many rainforest species cannot live anywhere else. 
 They have evolved over millions of years to occupy their own niche, under the forest's protection. 
 While larger mammals can often adapt, many lovely birds, butterflies, moths and other insects cannot. 
 It's estimated that each day another three species are lost for ever. 
 The people of the forest 
 Anti-leukaemia and other drugs were only discovered when scientists talked to forest tribes. 
 That knowledge, handed down by word of mouth over generations is invaluable. 
 Yet since 1900, 90 entire forest tribes have been wiped out. 
 WWF is working to collect and save this knowledge. 
 The aftermath death, flood, famine 
 Cleared tropical forest soon turns to desert. 
 The hopes of financial reward turn to fear of disaster. 
 The thin soil that covers the forest floor is easily washed away. 
 Without plants and soil to act as a &bquo;sponge&equo;, soaking up the rain and releasing it gradually, flooding is commonplace. 
 The forest also recycles nutrients and once it has gone all fertility goes with it. 
 In some countries famine has been the final &bquo;harvest&equo; of deforestation. 
 Ethiopia was heavily wooded not so long ago. 
 Its people now pay a heavy price for the loss of their forests. 
 Cutting down the forest is sheer madness. 
 There is no long term gain of any kind. 
 Only permanent, incalculable loss. 
 And burning it sends huge quantities of carbon dioxide into the air, adding to the &bquo;Greenhouse Effect&equo; that is already influencing world climates with such disastrous results. 
 It's got to stop, and stop now before it's too late.  
 OVERLEAF: How you can help us to stop the forest massacre 
 A living medicine chest One in four of the medicines we use, owe their origin to plants and animals in tropical forests. 
 Thanks to two drugs developed from natural alkaloids in a Madagascan plant, the Rosy Periwinkle, the chances of recovering from childhood leukaemia and several other cancers are now greatly increased. 
 Stop the destruction of the rainforest with a gift to WWF. 
 WWF is respected worldwide for its knowledge of wildlife and nature conservation. 
 And WWF has the &bquo;clout&equo; with foreign governments and large companies to bring a halt to the destruction of the rainforests. 
 Here's how: 
 Use the forests as a resource: 
 The rainforests are an immense resource capable of feeding and sustaining the growing populations of developing countries. 
 We are helping to set up protected National Parks and helping communities to &bquo;harvest&equo; the forests, so they see how much more valuable the forests are intact than cut down. 
 Hardwood planting: 
 We are persuading logging companies and governments to manage the logging of rainforests better and to grow their own hardwoods on separate plantations outside the rainforest. 
 But to continue this work we need your donation today. 
 Here's how your donation will help us to stop the forest massacre. 
 &pound;18 
 will provide a WWF trained forest guard with a uniform. 
 &pound;25 
 will provide enough fuel to keep a WWF forestry team Landrover going for a week. 
 &pound;50 
 will buy enough tools and seeds to set up a tree nursery. 
 &pound;100 
 4 gifts of &pound;100 will pay for a WWF expert to go to Geneva to influence an international meeting discussing the fate of the rainforest. 
 &pound;500 
 will be a major contribution to the costs of a forest resources survey in Brazil. 
 Recycled paper 
 World Wide Fund For Nature 
 The hardwood forest trees in this picture were at least 100 feet tall and took 400 years to grow. 
 Yet their death by chainsaw took only a few moments. 
 I am writing to tell you what those few minutes of destruction will now mean and to ask for your urgent help to stop this needless forest massacre before it is too late. 
 Dear Friend, 
 Very few trees in a tropical rainforest are good enough for logging &mdash; perhaps two or three in every hundred. 
 Here's what happens when loggers move in: &mdash; bulldozers clear roadways through the forest so the lorries and other equipment can get in. 
 Sunlight pours in on a world which has evolved to live in darkness. 
 Plants that can't survive in bright light die. 
 Birds and animals with &bquo;night eyes&equo; flee. 
 &mdash; as ancient hardwood trees are felled, they are dragged out by bulldozers or hauled through the front on overhead cables. 
 Over half the surrounding forest is severely damaged in this precess. 
 Yet more species of plant and animal life die out as their very specialised habitat is disturbed. 
 &mdash; when loggers move on, hungry subsistence farmers take advantage of the roadways. 
 Just a short time ago the forest was impenetrable&hellip; and safe. 
 Now it is open and defenceless against the machetes which slash down the undergrowth for tinder. &mdash; when the tinder is dry the fires can be lit to burn off the remaining forest to make way for agriculture or ranching (in many areas this &bquo;slash and burn&equo; forest clearance happens without first even removing the usable hardwood). 
 On the day you read this letter 74,000 acres of natural tropical rainforest, untouched for thousands of years, will be cleared in this way. 
 And in just some two years from now, perhaps three at the most, that same cleared forest ground will be abandoned. 
 Forest soils are so poor they can't support more than two or three seasons' crops. 
 Even grass grows so thinly that cattle can't feed properly. 
 Once the ground has lost its protective cover of vegetation it quickly turns to desert. 
 Where tropical forest grew only a few years ago, a vast desert is now rapidly engulfing inland Brazil spreading at a rate of several miles a year. 
 Clearing a rainforest in this way is sheer madness. 
 There simply are no long term gains to be had. 
 Only destruction and poverty. 
 And it's not just tropical countries that are affected. 
 Forest burning currently accounts for 20% of the world's annual production of carbon dioxide. 
 This is a major contribution to the &bquo;Greenhouse Effect&equo; with its catastrophic influence on the earth's climate. 
 Rainforests absorb carbon dioxide and produce the oxygen essential for all life, including our own. 
 That's why the forest massacre has got to stop. 
 And why it's vital that you help us to stop it. 
 And it has to stop now. 
 * Of the tropical rainforest that covered the equatorial belts of Asia, Africa and South America just 80 years ago, over half has now gone. 
 * At the present rate of destruction many countries whose only real asset is the forest may have none at all by the year 2,000. 
 It's hard to imagine a vast country like Brazil totally stripped of forest but it could happen unless we re-double our efforts now. 
 It's already very late in the day, but not too late. 
 If you will help us today, we have a plan of action which we know can work. 
 Here's what WWF is doing: 
 The forests are an immense resource capable of feeding and sustaining the people that live in forested areas. 
 Its produce of fruit, fish, nuts, raisins, dyes, medicines and natural chemicals are worth far more than the value of cut timber. 
 WWF is working to help the communities to learn how to manage their forests on a sustainable basis, so that they can benefit year in, year out. 
 Already we've secured two very important areas of tropical rainforest in Cameroon and Nigeria as protected National Parks. 
 We are helping to introduce better farming, livestock and soil conservation methods in the areas around the National Parks so the people don't feel a need to clear the forest for more land. 
 And we've helped people to start their own tree nurseries and grow their own trees for firewood. 
 Where not long ago the forest was thought of as an &bquo;enemy&equo;, it is now a source of life and livelihood. 
 And we're working to get governments and logging companies to grow more of their own wood on special plantations so they don't need to invade the forest. 
 At the moment for every 100 trees felled only one is planted. 
 Both of these measures will be effective, but we urgently need to increase the scale of this work. 
 WWF is internationally respected for its conservation work. 
 People will, and do listen. 
 What we've got to get over now is the need for action straight away, not next year or the year after. 
 WWF have over 70 tropical forestry projects and these need your support now. 
 And if you will help us with a donation today, I know we can get the action we need. 
 Here's how your donation will help us to stop the forest massacre. 
 &pound;15 will provide a WWF trained forest guard with a uniform. 
 &pound;25 will provide enough fuel to keep a WWF forestry team Landrover going for a week. 
 &pound;50 will buy enough tools and seeds to set up a tree nursery. 
 &pound;100 4 gifts of &pound;100 will pay for a WWF expert to go to Geneva to influence an international meeting discussing the fate of the rainforest. 
 &pound;500 will be a major contribution to the costs of a forest resources survey in Brazil. 
 Amounts like these, and more are urgently needed. 
 WWF only exists because of the money we receive from our supporters. 
 So your donation will play a direct and important part in our work. 
 Please support this appeal by sending a donation today. 
 Your gift is urgently needed and will be put to immediate use. 
 If you can afford a donation of &pound;18 or more, we will be delighted to send you our special WWF pen. 
 With many thanks for your help. 
 Yours sincerely,  George Medley OBE, Director, WWF.  
 P.S. A rainforest tree can be felled with a chainsaw in less time than it has taken you to read this letter. 
 And many thousands will fall today. 
 Please send your gift straight away. 
 In the fight to stop the rainforest massacre, every day counts. 
 FREE With your donation 
 is this charming WWF Pen. 
 Accept this WWF pen with our thanks for your donation of &pound;18 or more. 
 In the battle to save the rainforests every &pound;1 counts. 
 That's why WWF will be delighted to send you our special WWF Pen as a gesture of thanks for your gift of &pound;18 or more. 
 The pen comes in  it's  own attractive slip case. 
 And because it bears our Panda insignia it will help to spread the message about our work when friends and colleagues see you using it.  
 Whales and Dolphins 
 Their future is now in your hands 
 Whale and Dolphin Conservation Society 19A James Street West, Bath, Avon, BA1 2BT. 
 Registered Charity 298656 
 So much in common 
 Welcome to the awe-inspiring world of whales and dolphins. 
 A diverse family of warm-blooded mammals whose grace and beauty are well-known and appreciated across all five continents. 
 In contrast, we still know so little of the ways of life and intelligence of these magnificent creatures. 
 As the largest-brained animals on earth, whales are regarded by many as our ocean-going equivalents. 
 Certainly, they hold a very special place in human history and whether subjects of worship, art, friendship, fear, love or commercial exploitation, whales have always inspired the deepest feelings. 
 Over the centuries, trade in whale products helped many nations prosper; no country now generates wealth and food by taking this awful toll. 
 It's our turn now to give life back to whales and dolphins. 
 So different in nature 
 Despite a major international campaign in the 1970's, the world's whales are STILL in desperate trouble. 
 Recent surveys show previous estimates of whale numbers to be wildly optimistic. 
 Incredibly, certain countries continue their whaling activities against the best scientific and conservationist advice. 
 Thankfully, most large whales are now fully protected. 
 However, many of the smaller whales, such as dolphins, are not. 
 Hundreds of thousands of these animals are dying at man's hand every year. 
 Poisoned by pollution, hunted for meat, drowned in fishing nets or simply bored to death in captivity, the toll is growing by the day. 
 Largely unprotected and little understood, these populations of small whales need immediate investigation and protection if we aren't to repeat the dreadful and potentially catastrophic mistakes we've already made with large whales. 
 So how can you help? 
 &bquo;Of course, all this takes a great deal of time and money. 
 But, most of all, it takes the will of people like you who care about whales and dolphins to make it happen. 
 So should we let them sink into oblivion and folklore? 
 Or should we give them back their dignity, their freedom and their rightful place in the natural order of the world's rivers and oceans? 
 Please show that you really care, either by joining the society or by supporting our work with a donation. 
 We are a registered charity that devotes ALL its time and resources toward the conservation and protection of every known species of whale and dolphin. 
 On the back of this leaflet, you'll find a few of the projects we're involved with. 
 Overleaf, a way to make many more a reality. 
 Time is running out &mdash; it's in YOUR hands. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 Membership benefits 
 Twice a year you will receive our highly acclaimed colour magazine &mdash; &bquo;SONAR&equo;. 
 Full of beautiful photographs of whales and dolphins, as well as reports from around the world. 
 Updates in our regular newsletter on national and international developments and activities. 
 Opportunities to join whalewatching expeditions. 
 The pleasure and satisfaction of belonging to one of the world's leading whale and dolphin conservation groups. 
 WHALE AND DOLPHIN CONSERVATION SOCIETY 
 WORKING THROUGHOUT THE WORLD 
 WDCS exposed the cruel trade in live orcas (killer whales) captured off Iceland in nets. 
 WDCS co-sponsored a study of the rare Hector's dolphin off New Zealand. 
 WDCS paid for vital repairs to a whale rescue boat in Massachusetts, USA. 
 WDCS is co-sponsoring a study of dolphins that are being harpooned off Peru. 
 WDCS is co-sponsoring a preliminary survey of the threats facing several dolphin species off Chile's coast. 
 WDCS published a special report on &bquo;Small Cetaceans &mdash; the forgotten Whales&equo; and an educational guide &bquo;Whales and Dolphins of the World&equo;. 
 WDCS co-produced a report on the maintenance of cetaceans (dolphins and whales) in British dolphinaria 
 WDCS is leading the UK campaign against dolphin killing by the tuna industry. 
 AND WITH YOUR HELP WE PROMISE TO DO MUCH MORE  
 Common dolphins (Photo courtesy of Marine Mammal Fund) 
 Friendly encounter with a wild bottlenosed dolphin (Photo courtesy of Brian Holmes) 
 Pilot whale being killed &mdash; Faroe Islands (Denmark) 
 Harpooned minke whale &mdash; Norway 
 Sean R. Whyte &mdash; Director WDCS 
 Humpback whale breaching (photo courtesy of James D Watt) 
 100% recycled paper 
 LIFE IS CHEAP. 
 WILL YOU BE A SPONSOR? 
 WHILE THE WESTERN WORLD BUYS LIFE'S LITTLE LUXURIES, IN THE POORER WORLD, LIFE ITSELF IS THE LUXURY. 
 Last year, over &pound;900 million was spent on toys in the U.K. 
 Each year over a million African children die from diarrhoea spread by dirty water. 
 Britain ate its way through &pound;3.3 billion of sweets in 1988. 
 Just &pound;10 a month could give a child and family a chance to overcome desperate poverty. 
 You can help give them a more self-reliant future. 
 CAN YOU SAY NO TO A CHILD WHO NEEDS YOUR HELP? 
 Sponsoring a child means 
 You help one child, his or her family and community. 
 You commit yourself to long-term help as the only way to promote real change. 
 ALL the children in the target community benefit from the pooled fund of sponsorship money. 
 A maximum of 5% of your contribution is used to send you reports on the practical help your money provides and letters from your sponsored child. 
 You learn as you give, gaining new insight into the lives and needs of poor communities. 
 ActionAid. 
 Fighting poverty through child sponsorship. 
 Childhood should be a happy time and for many children in Britain it is. 
 Children in poorer countries are not so lucky. 
 While toy sales here have hit a record high they face a desperate shortage of clean water. 
 Diseases which cause our young only minor discomfort kill one in four children from Sierra Leone before their fifth birthday. 
 As Britain's largest Third World child sponsorship charity, ActionAid believes that long-term help &mdash; with agriculture, education, healthcare and training programmes as well as savings and credit schemes &mdash; is the only way the world's poor and their children will ever break free from crushing poverty and work towards a brighter future. 
 And we believe sponsorship is a key to this brighter future. 
 What sponsorship could mean to Kadiatu. 
 Seven year old Kadiatu lives in Numia in Sierra Leone. 
 Her people are farmers growing just enough food for themselves and a little rice and groundnuts as cash crops. 
 As a result of high demands made on the soil and the lack of good fertilizer, yields are low. 
 Kadiatu and her family live on a meagre rice diet and so suffer from protein and calorie malnutrition. 
 But you can help. 
 For through sponsorship, ActionAid is working to improve farming methods and educational facilities, and to set up a community development programme so the villagers themselves learn how to identify problems and deal with them more effectively. 
 Kadiatu's sponsorship money will also help pay for basic healthcare and hygiene training for her mother and other women in the village. 
 Sponsorship means giving direct help to assist people in their fight against poverty. 
 Please become a sponsor today. 
 What sponsorship means to the Hinch family. 
 Barry and Morna Hinch sponsor ten year old Baindu from Sierra Leone. 
 Helping a Third World child had been in the back of their minds for some time, but it was an ActionAid advertisement in their Sunday paper that spurred them into action. 
 The Hinches see sponsorship through ActionAid as the best way of helping a child and his or her community. 
 &bquo;We chose sponsorship through ActionAid because of the personal link with a child and the fact that the money goes directly to help the child's family and village. 
 With ActionAid you know exactly where your money goes and the good it is doing.&equo; 
 What impressed them most was that ActionAid works with the people themselves to decide how the money should be used to help the whole community. 
 When Barry and Morna sent off their first &pound;10 ActionAid sent back a personal file on Baindu, and her community, plus a photograph. 
 They are sent regular reports on the community's progress and a quarterly paper reporting on ActionAid's work worldwide. 
 The Hinches see &pound;10 as a realistic sum to pay out each month, especially with the convenience of a direct debit. 
 &bquo;It's good to see that a small amount can achieve so much.&equo; 
 SPONSOR A CHILD. 
 Please. 
 Baindu has been lucky. 
 But there are thousands of children like Kadiatu waiting for the help sponsorship can bring. 
 And one of them is waiting for you. 
 All you have to do is pick up a pen, or phone and send your first ten pounds. 
 Thank you.   
 &pound;21.75 
 33p a day 
 Sierra Leone photos by Jerry Flynn. 
 LONDON ASSOCIATION FOR THE BLIND 
 Dear Friend, 
 I wonder what you will say in answer to this letter; I shall await your reply with some anxiety, for if our letters go into the waste paper basket we shall be unable to continue our many services for the benefit of those who are blind. 
 Although our Head Office is in London, we help registered blind and partially sighted people nationwide, particularly through our Grants-in-Aid scheme which makes over 6,000 payments a year to blind people in need. 
 Were it not for the support of sympathetic friends, the residents in our Homes and those who work in our factory could not be given the necessary help and encouragement to overcome their handicap, for we are dependent on voluntary help. 
 I expect you receive many similar requests; you cannot respond to all, I know. 
 But if you have the gift of sight, please close your eyes&hellip; and I feel confident you will extend a helping hand to those on whose behalf I am writing to you. 
 Yours sincerely  Eileen Howard E Howard (Mrs) Appeals Secretary  
 P.S. Please act NOW &mdash; a cheque in the post is worth two in your cheque book! 
 Your donation will help in practical ways 
 Help in time of need 
 Many blind people struggle to pay their bills and provide themselves with the necessities of life. 
 We have an alarming number of distressing cases in our files of youngsters, families and old folk who need us. 
 And we can help in a variety of ways with immediate cash help&hellip; paying towards the cost of a heating bill&hellip; a rates demand&hellip; or a telephone bill, sometimes an elderly person's only link with the outside world. 
 Small sums of money, but the hope they can restore is priceless. 
 Somewhere to live 
 We can provide a proper home for those who find themselves with nowhere to live. 
 Many of the people we care for suffer from other crippling disabilities as well as their blindness. 
 We have sheltered accommodation, with understanding professional staff, for blind men and women who are unable to look after themselves. 
 And we run purpose built flats (the world's first) for those able to lead independent lives. 
 We can also offer short holidays for blind people in our two hotels, carefully adapted for their special needs. 
 Somewhere to work 
 We can also provide suitable employment for blind people in our modern factory in London. 
 It is difficult to find work these days, but for blind people it is virtually impossible. 
 We are able to give them the independence they so badly need, and with it self respect and dignity. 
 London Association for the Blind, 14&ndash;16 Verney Road, London, SE16 3DZ Telephone: 071&ndash;732 8771  
 Helping Blind &amp; Partially Sighted people since 1857 
 Founded in 1857 helping blind and partially-sighted people nationwide. 
 Registered charity 295913 A Limited Company registered in England 26688. 
 All year round we help blind and partially sighted people living near you! 
 Blindness can strike anyone at any time, regardless of who they are or where they live. 
 That is why London Association for the Blind extends its help to people throughout the country and is at work in your area. 
 An important part of this work is the provision of cash grants to visually impaired people in need. 
 Now we are appealing for money and we are asking the people of Oxfordshire for their help; money so that we can continue to help people in your county like John Granger&hellip; 
 Strongly independent all his life, John Granger didn't let blindness change his lifestyle, and although now in his nineties has only just moved into a sheltered flat in Oxford. 
 John likes to visit his old friends and also travels to see his brother who has had a stroke. 
 The high travel costs added onto everyday expenses were causing John distress and so LAB were pleased to award John an annual grant to help him keep in touch with his brother and retain his independence. 
 Registered as blind, Gail Thompson from South Oxfordshire also has a degenerative illness which has left her wheelchair bound. 
 Gail now lives with her widowed mother who looks after all her needs. 
 They are both on low incomes and find it very hard to cope with all the additional expenses of Gail's illness. 
 LAB were able to make an annual grant to Gail to help ease her financial difficulty. 
 Doris Howell recently suffered the shock of losing her sight practically overnight and finds everyday things difficult to cope with. 
 She lives in a top floor flat in Oxford and has had several accidents on the stairs leaving her very unsure about going out on her own. 
 Existing on a small pension, Doris can't afford a fridge and has to buy fresh food nearly every day. 
 LAB were happy to make a special grant for a fridge for Doris so she doesn't have to shop so often. 
 From household bills to fridges, we are there for those who need us. 
 Will you be there for us? 
 (Cases mentioned are factual. 
 Names have been changed to protect the privacy of those involved) 
 YOUR DONATION WILL HELP IN PROVIDING &mdash; 
 Cash Grants to those in need 
 Holiday Hotels 
 Residential Accommodation 
 Flats and Flatlets 
 Care Homes 
 Training and Employment 
 ALTERNATIVES TO A DIRECT DONATION 
 Banker's Order 
 Deed of Covenant 
 Deposited Deed 
 Legacy 
 Please tick box on coupon below for further information on the above.   
 Not so long ago, John Hargreaves had cancer. 
 If he can run for us, so can you. 
 Thanks to cancer research, John is now fit and well. 
 Since his recovery, he's been running for the Cancer Research Campaign. 
 The CRC depends entirely on voluntary contributions. 
 Why don't you help by running for us? 
 Write to us and we'll send you official sponsor forms, a CRC running vest, a fixtures calendar and a discount card worth 15% on selected mail order sportswear. 
 With the London marathon coming up, there's no better time to start. 
 Even if you don't win, you'll be helping us beat cancer.   
 Fighting cancer on all fronts. 
 JOIN THE RACE TO BEAT CANCER 
 We all know someone who has cancer or who has died of this dreadful disease. 
 Discovering new treatments and techniques in the fight against cancer is the aim of the Tenovus research teams. 
 Will you help raise funds to maintain this important research by getting yourself sponsored each time you enter an event? 
 Please help yourself and others to combat this killer disease.  
 TENOVUS FIGHTS CANCER 
 Barnardos 
 Keep fit and run for the charity which values your contribution 
 Make your effort go farthest. 
 Run for the children and young people who are disabled or disadvantaged. 
 Call John Girling on 081&ndash;550 8822 for your free running vest, car sticker, sweatband and sponsor form. 
 I WANT TO HELP! 
 r=it1 in every 700 people in the U.K. may have Multiple Sclerosis 
 ARMS has for 15 years battled against Multiple Sclerosis on behalf of sufferers, their carers and families. 
 ARMS range of activities includes: &frac12; million pound Research Programme; Education and Information; Telephone Counselling; Face to Face Counselling; Physiotherapy; Nutritional Advice; Speech Therapy; Continence Advice; Oxygen Therapy; Social Interaction. 
 A choice of 64 Centres and Support Groups nationwide.  
 I wish to help ARMS in their fight against Multiple Sclerosis. 
 Please send me a sponsorship package and free t-shirt as soon as possible.  
 NSPCC 
 BY LISTENING HELP US PROTECT CHILDREN 
 As part of the Society's work to protect children from abuse and neglect a national NSPCC Child Protection Help Line is being launched in the Spring of 1991. 
 A single national number, free to all callers, will be available to anyone wishing to seek advice or take action on behalf of abused or neglected children. 
 WILL YOU HELP US RAISE &pound;6 MILLION TO FUND OUR NEW SERVICE? 
 Please send me a free Running Vest and Sponsor Pack.  
 GREENPEACE 
 LONDON MARATHON 
 Against all odds, Greenpeace has brought the plight of the natural world to the attention of caring people. 
 You can help us even up the odds. 
 Get sponsored for Greenpeace when you run. 
 For sponsor forms and information please write to:  
 OR RING OUR HOTLINE ON: 071&ndash;704&ndash;8101 
 Quote the code DS002 to receive a FREE running vest (state M, L or XL).  
 AGAINST ALL ODDS 
 The Malcolm Sargent Cancer Fund for Children 
 Patron H.R.H. 
 THE PRINCESS OF WALES 
 The Fund was launched on March 26, 1968 as a lasting and practical memorial to the much-loved British musician whose name it bears. 
 Over 1000 new cases are accepted by the Fund each year. 
 Grants are made for warm clothing, heating bills, beds and bedding, nourishing foods, convalescent holidays, etc. 
 One of our Social Workers has written: &bquo;Mrs. Young was deeply grateful and delighted by the morale grant for Mark. 
 When she told him he spent hours studying catalogues and brochures deciding how to spend it. 
 As Mark has a fascination for all things electrical, he decided on an electronic watch that &bquo;spoke&equo; the time. 
 Despite his overall fatigue and discomfort, Mark wore it proudly and explained and demonstrated how it worked to everyone involved in his care. 
 I certainly feel it was a great delight to him during the last days of his life.&equo;  
 All funds raised by runners in sponsored marathons or &bquo;fun runs&equo; are gratefully acknowledged and help to provide convalescent holidays, travel expenses and little luxuries for our children. 
 A red cotton T-shirt or running vest is available at a nominal charge of &pound;1.00 together with sponsorship forms.  
 Run for Shelter 
 HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF PEOPLE ARE HOMELESS IN BRITAIN and many more live in unhealthy or dangerous conditions. 
 YOU CAN HELP THEM. 
 When you run get sponsored for Shelter! 
 The money you raise will give practical help &mdash; and hope &mdash; to homeless people.  
 RUN YOUR MARATHON ON BEHALF OF INTERMEDIATE TECHNOLOGY 
 Intermediate Technology enables poor people in the Third World to develop and use technologies and methods which give them more control over their lives and which contribute to the long-term development of their communities. 
 Contact Debbie Smith at Intermediate Technology,  for your sponsor form and T-shirt. 
 CHATSWORTH HOUSE OBSTACLE RACE 
 SUNDAY MAY 19th 1991 
 START 19 NOON 
 6 miles with obstacles. 
 Teams of four. 
 Entry fee &pound;4.00 per team member. 
 Souvenir to all finishers. 
 Prizes to winning teams. 
 Family day out with fundraising stalls and the delights of Chatsworth House. 
 All proceeds to the British Deaf Sports Council. 
 Assisted by INPRINTS SCREENPRINTERS and LIONS INTERNATIONAL 
 NATIONAL ASTHMA CAMPAIGN 
 ON APRIL 21ST, RUN FOR SOMEONE WHO CAN'T. 
 Taking part in the marathon could be out of the question for many people with asthma. 
 They have to live with the fear of sudden attacks that leave them struggling to breathe. 
 And every year asthma kills more than 2,000 people. 
 That's why we need your help to raise money for urgent medical research. 
 Send off the coupon for your free T. Shirt and sponsorship form. 
 And get out there and run for those who can't.  
 Birthright 
 Research for healthier babies and healthier women 
 &bquo;Babies &mdash; I'd run a mile&equo; 
 How often have you heard that said by men and women in their teens and early twenties? 
 Yet when you have your own baby, it's all so different. 
 Only then do you understand the heartache of women whose pregnancies end in disaster or those who can't have the baby they want. 
 Birthright's medical research tries to overcome these problems and many more. 
 So say thank you for the health of your baby by supporting Birthright when you run.  
 TORTOISES WANTED 
 CAN YOU HELP? 
 In fact, it's not just tortoises we want, we'd also love a few hares, a few gorillas and lots of colourful clowns. 
 In the last London Marathon an equally strange collection of runners gave the One Small Step appeal a great boost. 
 In 1991, with your support, the appeal could pass its finishing post. 
 BIG REWARDS! 
 One Small Step is building a laboratory that will help keep many children from lives spent in a wheelchair&hellip; please help to make this possible for our kids and run for them in the next London Marathon.  
 LONDON MARATHON '91 
 Run for us, so we can run for them&hellip; 
 By running for Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital Fund you could help support the research desperately needed to save children's lives.  
 Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital Fund 
 RUNNING TO HELP REBUILD LIVES 
 &bquo;A very special, personal kind of care&equo;. 
 That is what we provide in our residential homes for elderly people. 
 And in our psychiatric rehabilitation centres for men and women of all ages recovering from mental illness. 
 Both groups need very special care &mdash; yet so often they are the forgotten people in our community. 
 Loneliness, fragile health and homelessness are just a few of the problems they face without our help. 
 All our residents receive a very special, personal kind of care. 
 But we need your help to continue our work. 
 There is no better way to help people in need than through supporting Care. 
 Will you please consider running to help us rebuild more lives and show that you, too care? 
 For further information, sponsorship pack and free T-shirt, please contact: Liz O'Sullivan   
 2Care* 
 *Care for the Elderly and Hope for the Hurt Mind 
 Support Disabled Sports 
 Help people with disabilities to enjoy participation in their sport by running and raising funds in 1991 for The British Sports Association for The Disabled. 
 The charity that provides the opportunities and facilities for disabled people to take part in sport. 
 We need YOUR  support to enable us to continue with our work. 
 Please pledge your support below and we will send you a Running Vest or &bquo;T&equo; Shirt and sponsor pack.  
 HOMES FOR HOMELESS PEOPLE TRUST 
 We are the only charity that actually houses single homeless people on a national basis. 
 We have 26 member groups throughout the U.K. working on the frontline of homelessness. 
 So, every penny that we receive goes towards cost-effective direct provision for the single homeless.  
 NSE NATIONAL SOCIETY FOR EPILEPSY 
 1 in 200 has Epilepsy 
 We provide short term medical assessment and rehabilitation of those newly diagnosed, and long term care if necessary. 
 We are foremost in research and have an acclaimed information service. 
 We must raise &pound;1,200 per day to continue our vital work. 
 Please help us to help them help themselves. 
 I'D LIKE TO HELP. 
 I'VE BEEN ACCEPTED FOR London Marathon&hellip; (other events) 
 Please complete form overleaf and we will send you a free vest and sponsorship package.  
 RUNNING FOR STARLIGHT 
 The Starlight Foundation grants wishes for critically/chronically and terminally ill children. 
 We shall soon see our 500th wish come true and are now organising a wish-a-day. 
 But we need YOUR help to ensure we never say no to any of our &bquo;special children&equo;. 
 Please help us. 
 For free T-shirt and sponsorship form please reply to:  
 New York could be only 26 miles away 
 If you run for St. John Ambulance in the 1991 ADT London Marathon 
 As a runner you'll be familiar with the work of St. John Ambulance volunteers. 
 YES VOLUNTEERS! 
 It seems we do such a professional job many people don't realise we are funded by voluntary contributions and not by the Government. 
 Our ambulances, First Aid Units, uniforms and even our Vaseline is paid for by donations. 
 So if you have a place in this  years  ADT London Marathon or indeed any other running event please raise money for St. John Ambulance. 
 And remember&hellip; we can only be there &bquo;Providing You  Care!&equo; 
 Win a Trip to the New York Marathon 
 The runner who raises the most money for St. John Ambulance in the 1991 ADT London Marathon will win a trip to the New York Marathon (including guaranteed entry, return airline ticket, accommodation and transport to and from the Marathon). 
 Win a Trip in St. John's Hot Air Balloon 
 Anyone who raises money for St. John Ambulance in the 1991 ADT London Marathon will be entered into a prize draw to win a fantastic trip in our very own hot air balloon. 
 After all we might as well put all that hot air you produce to some good. 
 To run for St. John Ambulance simply complete the form below and send it in to our Marathon team. 
 We'll send you a special St. John running vest and a leaflet giving you hints on fund raising.   
 Could this be stopped with a Phonecard? 
 During the last four decades, the natural habitats of Britain's wildlife have been ravaged by modern farming methods, urban sprawl and pollution. 
 140,000 miles of hedgerow, 95% of traditional hay meadows, 40% of natural woodlands and 60% of wild heathland have all been destroyed. 
 As a result, the otter, barn owl and red squirrel are now virtually extinct in many parts of the country. 
 To protect those that remain, The Royal Society for Nature Conservation is running the British Wildlife appeal, chaired by Sir David Attenborough. 
 The aim is to raise &pound;10 million, and to help with this, British Telecom have donated &pound;100,000 to the appeal. 
 As well as this donation, British Telecom have produced three special Phonecards depicting the otter, barn own and red squirrel in order to help raise awareness of both the appeal and the plight of British wildlife. 
 Each Phonecard comes in a special wrapper giving you the information you'll need to add to British Telecom's donation, with the money that's raised going towards protecting the natural habitats of all endangered species in Britain. 
 These animals cannot speak for themselves. 
 But, by buying one of these new British Telecom Phonecards, each one of us will have the chance to speak on their behalf.  
 British TELECOM It's you we answer to  
 CONCERNED FOR OUR COUNTRYSIDE? 
 Help the Woodland Trust protect Britain's heritage. 
 The Woodland Trust is dedicated to protecting one of the most important features of Britain's heritage &mdash; our native broadleaved woodland. 
 We already care for over 400 woodland areas, and in addition to saving, on average, a wood every week we're planting thousands of trees each year to create new woods. 
 By joining one of Britain's fastest growing conservation charities you can help conserve and improve Britain's landscape for present and future generations to enjoy. 
 Membership starts at &pound;8 and you'll receive regular newsletters, a car emblem and a guide to Woodland Trust woods which are free for you to enjoy. 
 EXCLUSIVE OFFER 
 Join now and we'll send you a quality reproduction print of a beautiful woodland scene, FREE.  
 We ask everything of him. 
 We ask just &pound;6 of you. 
 Every time a lifeboatman puts to sea, he risks his life. 
 Becoming one of our members helps reduce those risks. 
 Because your &pound;6 helps buy him protective clothing and helps us provide him with the best equipped boats. 
 All of which will make his task safer to undertake. 
 And as the lifeboats are run entirely on voluntary contributions and membership fees, the &pound;6 you give to us is vital. 
 For men who never question whether they should go, is &pound;6 too much to ask?  
 Royal National Lifeboat Institution 
 40 PAGES OF GIFTS, CLOTHES AND TOYS FROM AROUND THE WORLD 
 From beautiful alpaca wool jumpers to a handcrafted rocking chair &mdash; from puzzles that'll confound to a traditional tribal face mask&hellip; 
 There's no other catalogue quite like the OXFAM Christmas catalogue. 
 Because no other catalogue offers such exciting gifts from all over the world &mdash; at such value for money prices. 
 And there's a very special offer for you if we receive your request as a result of this notice. 
 You'll be entitled to a free pack of thirty Christmas cards worth &pound;4.95. 
 We'll send all the details with the catalogue. 
 So reserve your OXFAM Christmas catalogue now.  
 SAVING HISTORIC HOUSES IS NOBLE. 
 LIVING IN ONE IS SUBLIME. 
 Dating back to medieval times, Britain's historic houses are one of our greatest treasures. 
 However, but for the work of Country Houses Association many would have been lost to the nation. 
 We are a charity dedicated to their preservation. 
 One of the ways we achieve this is by creating apartments within the houses, based on a monthly charge from &pound;600 per person together with a returnable loan. 
 Included in the monthly charge are all meals, central heating, hot water, maintenance and cleaning. 
 For more information simply return the coupon.  
 COUNTRY HOUSES ASSOCIATION 
 What's it worth to join the RSPB? 
 The future of our wild birds and environment is under threat. 
 Heathlands, hedgerows and woodlands are vanishing. 
 Moorlands are being destroyed marshes drained, streams cleared and river banks cut back. 
 Every year, countless agonising deaths occur through the pollution of rivers from factories or oil spillages at sea. 
 On land, the use of pesticides is endangering both our birds and their food. 
 What is the RSPB doing about it? 
 Backed by thorough research, we press for new laws and policies to create a healthier, richer future. 
 We have established over 100 nature reserves. 
 We have saved many birds (like the Avocet) from extinction in Britain. 
 But action costs money. 
 To continue this vital work, we urgently need your help. 
 Please help us in the Action for Birds today.   
 IF YOU CARE, THE RSPB WILL ACT. 
 CAPTIVITY DRIVES TURTLES UP THE WALL. 
 This pet turtle will continue walking into the glass until its snout is bloody. 
 He exists, stressed and traumatised, in complete conflict with his biological program, literally dying to be free. 
 The Reptile Protection Trust wants to ban the trade in pet turtles. 
 Money raised would fund our campaign to lobby relevant authorities internationally and engage in public education. 
 If you would like to help the Trust or find out more, send &pound;2,30 for our fact sheet and booklet, &bquo;Reptiles: Misunderstood, Mistreated and Mass-Marketed&equo;. 
 If you want to keep turtles happy, don't keep them at all.  
 THE REPTILE PROTECTION TRUST 
 THE WEDDING OF THE CENTURY 
 No marriage has had the exposure of this one. 
 It was the wedding of the century, the fairy tale that excited, fired and fascinated people all over the world. 
 Millions poured on to the streets of London on 29 July 1981 to be able to say they were there on the day, to tell their children and grandchildren what it was like. 
 Hundreds of millions more watched it on television and can remember the dress she wore, the horse-drawn carriage she arrived in, the kiss on the balcony of Buckingham Palace, the cheering, the music, the colour and the happiness. 
 For Lady Diana Spencer, just twenty years old, it was the most thrilling day of her life. 
 She walked down the long red-carpeted aisle of St Paul's Cathedral a commoner. 
 She returned a Princess. 
 It was all her dreams come true. 
 She had married her Prince, the man she loved. 
 They would have beautiful children and live happily ever after. 
 But it was not quite so simple. 
 As she took her wedding vows, Diana was saying goodbye to the life that she had taken for granted for twenty years. 
 Saying goodbye to the freedom to walk down a street on her own, to browse through the sales, to decide on the spur of the moment to visit friends, or meet for a drink in the pub. 
 She had married not just the man, she had married his job, and all that it involved. 
 She had married a man for whom duty always came first. 
 She had married a large, closely knit family. 
 Worse still, she had married into a life so public that at times she felt there was no place on earth where she could escape from the prying eyes. 
 The Prince had high hopes on that July day too. 
 He had spoken earnestly, some years before, about finding the right girl to marry, about not letting his head be ruled by his heart; but come the day, he had married because he had fallen in love. 
 At the age of thirty-three, he had found someone to share his life and passions with; someone to help shoulder the burden. 
 Someone pretty, witty and sexy, who made him laugh and feel young and carefree. 
 But it was not to be quite as he had hoped either. 
 Their ten years of marriage have been fraught with difficulties that neither could have foreseen. 
 They have had to learn to live with one another, to adjust, to get used to each other's habits, hobbies,  friends and relations &mdash; the most crucial and critical period for every newly married couple &mdash; but they have had to do it all under the full glare of the media. 
 Every step, every look, every word has been quoted, scrutinized and analysed. 
 They have been spied on by the paparazzi, betrayed by trusted servants, embarrassed by indiscreet friends, and have had to endure a constant torrent of innuendo, gossip, lies and half-truths in newspapers, magazines and books &mdash; none of which are they able to repudiate. 
 29 July 1981. 
 Newly married, Charles and Diana on the steps of St Paul's Cathedral 
 At times it has looked as though the difficulties might have proved insurmountable, the strain too much. 
 The media seemed to be willing the marriage to fall to pieces. 
 The adulation that had greeted Diana in the early days began to turn sour. 
 &bquo;Revelations&equo; from a bitter ex-valet branded her a tyrant with a heated temper who had swept into the Prince's life and, like a spoilt child, banished trusted staff and old friends and even stopped the Prince from hunting and shooting. 
 Charles, said journalists &bquo;in the know&equo;, was being &bquo;pussy whipped&equo; by a petulant and jealous wife. 
 Any attempt to redress the situation backfired. 
 The couple invited newspaper editors to a series of private lunches at Kensington Palace, to appeal to their better nature, but to no avail. 
 The editors revelled in the honour, ate their lunches and went back to their offices to continue publishing every last tit-bit they could find. 
 The Prince and Princess allowed the television cameras into their home, so the public could see for themselves that they were a close and happy family. 
 After a hour of simpering sycophancy from the presenter, the Prince took the viewer into his garden, where he said he loved to sit and think and talk to his plants. 
 That was it. 
 The loony Prince. 
 Every time he tried to make any kind of serious statement or speech for years thereafter, people came back to the plants. 
 They were worrying times. 
 Diana took the criticism to heart, avidly read what was being said about her and became depressed and despondent. 
 Charles worried about the effect it was having on her; and grew angry and frustrated on his own behalf, that no one seemed interested in the ills of the world. 
 All they wanted to do was poke fun at him, look at the cut of his suit, or his hairstyle, or measure his bald patch. 
 Ten years on, however, Charles and Diana have come through it. 
 They have found a new enthusiasm for life, a new determination to be the people they are and behave as they will. 
 They have settled down, sorted out their personal problems, adjusted their lives to accommodate each other, found a way to cope with the pressure and emerged with a very strong successful partnership. 
 Furthermore, the strength they have built into their marriage has brought confidence to them both. 
 Diana has made the transition from girl to woman and has become secure and fulfilled; Charles has confronted the spectre of middle age and doubt, and emerged certain. 
 He has not just found a role for himself, which was something he had agonized over for years, but has used his position to lead an assault on the ills of modern society; to try to alter people's basic thinking, not just in an effort to improve their lives, but to persuade them of the need to preserve the planet for future generations. 
 After years of being thought a crank, he is at last being taken  seriously. 
 Where once he felt like giving up, he now has the zeal and determination to push further and harder and keep on going until there is real change in the way mankind behaves. 
 1990 in Hungary. 
 Ten years on their problems are behind them 
 The Prince's contribution is unique. 
 It is unlike that of any politician, environmentalist or businessman, however committed and well intentioned they may be. 
 He has taken up the challenge to lead. 
 He no longer simply makes meaningful speeches that stir things up. 
 He believes we are at a deeply significant turning point in human history and if we are to come through it we have to change not just the way people behave, but also the way in which they think. 
 He is convinced we have to adopt entirely new value systems, change our philosophical orientation and spiritual thinking; stop behaving as though the earth is here for mankind's personal convenience and learn to regard ourselves as one small part of a much larger whole. 
 He knows precisely where he is going now and is fit and eager for the challenge. 
 He no longer fears ridicule or criticism; instead, his fear is that people will not act swiftly enough, that human nature has locked itself into a process of acquisitiveness and materialism, and that three hundred years of our industrial society have alienated people from the aesthetic values mankind once possessed. 
 These are his own thoughts; the Prince is nobody's puppet. 
 The press scoffed at his walks in the Kalahari Desert, at his fascination with lost and ancient tribes; but experiences like that, plus a lifetime of travelling all over the world, seeing underdeveloped and overdeveloped countries and every kind of political regime, has brought him to this viewpoint. 
 Time and again he is savaged for speaking on subjects about which his critics claim he knows nothing. 
 In fact, his education is encyclopaedic and eclectic. 
 He reads and digests material on a vast range of topics and picks the brains of most of the leading authorities. 
 He trawls for advice and information from dozens of people, who find themselves invited to Kensington Palace quite out of the blue. 
 The Princess has her own area of interest. 
 Her concerns are much closer to home, much more for people and individuals than cosmic matters, which provides a perfect foil for her husband. 
 She has spent much of the last ten years establishing herself and securing her home base, and it is only now that she is beginning to realize her potential. 
 She has grown into an elegant and gracious woman, but lost none of the spark that made her such an endearing young bride. 
 She wins hearts everywhere she goes, and, with a quick aside, puts everyone instantly and skilfully at their ease. 
 She also goes anywhere she wants. 
 She has emerged as independent, resourceful and resilient. 
 With no qualifications and precious little experience, she has taken on the job of Princess of Wales and is turning it into a significant career &mdash; and at the same time has brought up two small boys. 
 Five years ago people might have thought her greatest contribution had been to the British fashion industry. 
 No longer. 
 She has turned into a champion of the underdog, gone out on a limb to support unglamorous causes like AIDS victims, drug abusers and the mentally handicapped. 
 She has worked tirelessly and helped raise millions of  pounds for the charities she has taken on. 
 She is now growing into a confident speaker, prepared to say what she thinks. 
 Whereas once her every outfit hit the headlines, it is now her every word &mdash; and they are very much her words. 
 In this respect, she has learnt a great deal from her husband. 
 Like the Prince, she requests and gathers together information and reading material on all of the subjects she has taken on. 
 People who meet her in the course of a briefing or a visit are constantly surprised by her knowledge, the intelligence of her questions, and her retention of what she has read &mdash; often on quite scientific subjects. 
 Added to that is her instinctive feeling for people &mdash; what to do and say that will please them most. 
 She is in the good news business and a master of the art. 
 Diana wins hearts everywhere she goes 
 Between them, the Waleses have established a way of operating over the last ten years that is unmistakably their own; and quite unlike any other branch of the Royal Family. 
 Their homes, both in London and in the country, epitomize their attitude. 
 They are comfortable, friendly, lived-in places; elegant, not grand. 
 The furnishings are pretty, a mixture of modern and antique, and the rooms are full of light and colour, with large vases of flowers and pot plants liberally scattered about. 
 Children and dogs run around and climb on the furniture. 
 Their sons are noisy and mischievous and don't always do what they are told, and in every respect are normal, healthy, confident little boys. 
 There is formality when there has to be, but everyone who visits either house is immediately put at ease. 
 They have achieved the same in the way they work. 
 Traditionally, members of the Royal Family play a passive role. 
 Wherever they go they are escorted by a vast armada of local dignitaries, including the Lord Lieutenant, the Mayor or Mayoress, complete with the chains of office, the Chief Constable of Police and every last member of the town council. 
 This mass of people, all dressed in their Sunday best, bedecked with badges and brass, hovers like a human shield, while the Royal in question inspects whatever is on show, shakes a few select hands and exchanges benign pleasantries, before being whisked away in a grand black limousine. 
 The Prince and Princess have each, in their own way, reversed the order of play. 
 They deal with the dignitaries in the politest possible way, but it is clear to everyone that it is not the dignitaries they have  come to see and talk to, but the ordinary people. 
 They very swiftly get down to basics, ask pertinent questions, build up a rapport, and do so away from the rest of the party, away from the reporters and press cameras. 
 This is where they do such good, where they really make a visit worth while and where they learn what ordinary people think, need and feel. 
 Washington D.C. 1986, with Vice-President and Mrs Bush. 
 Charles has taught Diana how to handle state occasions 
 They are very much a two-career couple and, although the work overlaps from time to time, they have two very distinct careers, which take them in different directions. 
 Diana has learnt a phenomenal amount in the last ten years &mdash; much of it from her husband. 
 He has taught her how to handle state occasions, how to deal with foreign potentates, when to speak and when not to, how to manage tiring tours and how to cope with the strains of travel. 
 He has helped her with her public speaking, suggested ideas, discussed her concerns and boosted her confidence when it was low. 
 Diana has helped Charles by bringing him into the modern era, teasing him and leavening his spirits, and keeping him young and abreast of young people's thinking. 
 She too has given him confidence and relieved some of the loneliness of his position. 
 It is a successful and formidable double-act. 
 They may not have found quite the soulmate in each other that they had been looking for, but their relationship has made up for it in other ways. 
 It is now a caring and loving one, in which they both feel free to be themselves, and the trust between them is absolute. 
 They are still irritated and frustrated when their privacy is invaded and still upset by hurtful articles in the press, or inaccurate stories. 
 They argue from time to time, they get tired and cross and let stress get the better of them, like any other couple, but the union is essentially a happy one. 
 Against all the odds it has worked, and this is a measure of just how strong they both were as individuals when they came to the marriage ten years ago. 
 Their union has not only survived the rigours of a decade, but has come out at the other end stronger than ever. 
 It is that strength, both individually and collectively, that will ensure that if the monarchy survives into the twenty-first century, it will not just be as &bquo;a privileged irrelevance&equo;, but as a very potent force for good. 
 A LOVE MATCH 
 It was a love match. 
 Despite all the scheming and matchmaking that went on behind the scenes, when Charles and Diana took their wedding vows on 29 July 1981, they were undoubtedly in love. 
 Diana had been in love with Prince Charles for several years, since their first meeting when she was a sixteen-year-old home from school for half-term and he was her elder sister's boyfriend. 
 He had come to Althorp, their family home, for a pheasant shoot. 
 He later said his first impression of her then had been, &bquo;What a very jolly and amusing and attractive sixteen-year-old. 
 I mean great fun &mdash; bouncy and full of life and everything.&equo; 
 In truth, he was very much smitten by Sarah at the time and he would scarcely have noticed the rather nondescript little sister who fell passionately in love that day. 
 That was November 1977. 
 It was the year of the Queen's Silver Jubilee and the Prince, just twenty-nine, was drawing to the end of his first year as a full-time working member of the &bquo;family firm&equo;. 
 He had been through school and university, he had travelled the world, he had completed five years in the armed forces, he had flown fighter planes and helicopters &mdash; and for nine months had had command of a mine hunter in the North Sea. 
 On the romantic front he had had a string of engaging and pretty girlfriends, not least of all the vivacious flame-haired Lady Sarah Spencer. 
 He had been in and out of love, but never found quite the right girl at quite the right time to make him a wife. 
 Diana was nothing more than a schoolgirl, unworldly in the extreme. 
 She was popular with the other girls at West Heath and enjoyed her years there, but she was never very promising academically, and her reading was almost entirely limited to Barbara Cartland romantic novels. 
 Outside the classroom she fared better. 
 She consistently won swimming cups and also the school dancing competition one year. 
 She took up the piano and, according to her headmistress Ruth Rudge, &bquo;made phenomenal progress for someone who started late&equo;; and although she never made it into any of the school teams, she loved tennis. 
 During her last year she joined the Voluntary Service Unit and visited an old lady in Sevenoaks once a week. 
 None of it was remarkable, but it all added up. 
 In her last term she won the Miss Clark Lawrence Award for service to the school: a special award, not necessarily given, &bquo;for  anyone who has done things that otherwise might have gone unsung&equo;. 
 Diana, pulling faces, was still the girl he remembered, great fun, bouncy and full of life 
 After meeting Prince Charles, Diana went back to school that November day to have a second shot at her O levels, which eluded her yet again, and the following month, at the age of sixteen and a half, she left for good. 
 Next stop was finishing school in Switzerland, where speaking English was a punishable offence. 
 In theory, she studied domestic science &mdash; dressmaking and cooking &mdash; and took a pitman's correspondence and typing course. 
 In practice, she learnt to ski; but it was the first time she had been away from her friends and family, the first time she had been on a plane, the first time she had been abroad, and she was desperately unhappy. 
 After just six weeks she returned home and refused to go back. 
 By the time she and the Prince were engaged two years later, she was still no better educated. 
 She had been a mother's help to a family in Hampshire, she had babysat through an agency in London, and had taken on cleaning jobs. 
 She had done a three-month cookery course and, as a last-ditch attempt to acquire some proper qualifications, she had enrolled as a student teacher with Betty Vacani, in Knightsbridge, who ran dancing classes for tiny tots. 
 This had not worked either. 
 finally, in the autumn of 1979, Diana found the perfect job, working part-time as an assistant in a small kindergarten in Pimlico, for a friend of her other sister, Jane. 
 It left plenty of time for shopping and meeting friends, two of her passions. 
 Unlike the Prince, she had had no love affairs when their friendship began at the beginning of that year. 
 She had a wide circle of friends, all from the same social set, ex-public school, most of them with parents living in the country. 
 She had her own flat, at Coleherne Court off the Old Brompton Road &mdash; bought with money that had been put into trust until her eighteenth birthday &mdash; which she shared with girlfriends. 
 It was prettily furnished by Diana and, although the hallway was a jumble of bicycles and tennis racquets, the rest of the flat was remarkably clean and neat. 
 Diana could never go to bed and leave a mess behind, however late; she would always tidy up and wash any dirty dishes. 
 Diana and her friends were a clean-living set &mdash; none of them smoked or drank much &mdash; and when they went out, it tended to be in a group. 
 They would go to one another's flats, have supper in a bistro, go to a film, or sit at home with bowls of spaghetti, chatting and watching television. 
 At weekends they would go off to the country. 
 Within her own social set, Diana was confident and happy. 
 She was quite unsophisticated, but always good company at a dinner party, guaranteed to get everyone talking and laughing. 
 She was fun, and people liked to have her around because she was easy and undemanding and always had a quick reply. 
 But she was no intellectual and, apart from a passion for the ballet, which she used to attend with her grandmother, Ruth, Lady Fermoy, she was like any ordinary teenager. 
 She spent her time shopping, reading women's magazines, listening to pop music and watching television. 
 On the face of it, she and Prince Charles had very little in common when they re-met in 1979. 
 Quite apart from the intellectual and educational differences, they  did not even share the same hobbies. 
 Charles was a compulsive horseman; Diana didn't ride. 
 The Prince loved opera; her love was ballet. 
 He hated pop music; she enjoyed it. 
 Her sport was tennis; he had never played. 
 For this reason, some of the Prince's closest friends were against the marriage; they feared that with so little in common it could never work. 
 But there was more to Diana Spencer than met the eye. 
 Beneath the giggling, bubbly little-girl exterior was strength and depth; an uncanny maturity and a sensitivity that belied her years. 
 For all her privilege and wealth, life had not been easy and the experiences of childhood had left an indelible mark. 
 Diana's parents had had an unhappy marriage. 
 Her father, Earl Spencer, at that time Viscount Althorp, was the perfect gentleman to all who knew him, but not so gentlemanly behind closed doors. 
 Her mother, Frances, stayed with him until she had produced the son he so desperately wanted, but when Diana was just six years old her mother left home. 
 She had met and fallen in love with Peter Shand Kydd, a wallpaper millionaire, seen a chance of happiness, and taken it. 
 What she had not known was that in leaving home she would have to forfeit her four children. 
 There was a messy divorce and, in the subsequent custody proceedings, custody of Sarah, 
 Jane, Diana and Charles was granted to their father. 
 Johnnie Spencer had called upon some of the highest names in the land as character witnesses, including his ex-wife's own mother, Ruth, Lady Fermoy. 
 Of all the children, Diana was the most affected by the sudden loss of her mother. 
 The two older girls had already begun boarding school, so were away for most of the time, and Charles was only three and easily amused by the nanny. 
 It was Diana, aged six &mdash; old enough to understand she had been left, but not yet old enough to understand why &mdash; who felt so bereft. 
 The security she had known was suddenly gone, her small world shattered. 
 During that period everyone rallied round, particularly her two grandmothers, Ruth, Lady Fermoy and Cynthia, Countess Spencer. 
 She became close to both women and, although she still saw her mother from time to time and still has a very strong relationship  with her that has not been diminished by the divorce, a special bond was forged with the two older women. 
 When Countess Spencer died in 1972, it was another loss for Diana to cope with. 
 Diana with her mother, Frances Shand Kydd. 
 The marriage to Earl Spencer had not been a happy one. 
 Prince Charles had had similar experiences. 
 His grandmother had been like a mother to him for most of his childhood. 
 Obviously there was no broken family in his case, but his mother was always either busy or away, even before she became Queen, and her parents stepped into the breach. 
 It was his grandparents he spent his first Christmas with. 
 He was with them again for his second Christmas and his third birthday. 
 He was even with them the night the King died in 1952. 
 It was his grandmother he spent his fifth birthday with and that same year his parents went off on a tour of the Commonwealth, which took them away from him for six long months. 
 To the small child standing on the dockside waving goodbye it was a minor bereavement every time. 
 As a result, Charles is closer to his grandmother in many ways than his own mother. 
 Diana, likewise. 
 The Prince and Princess's grandmothers have been the best of friends for most of their lives. 
 Ruth, Lady Fermoy and her husband Maurice knew the Queen Mother and King George VI when they were still Duke and Duchess of York, before the abdication. 
 They remained friends and, when Maurice Fermoy died in 1952, Ruth became the Queen Mother's lady-in-waiting. 
 There is no doubt that the two old ladies did a little plotting to marry their favourite grandchildren off to on another; but without the events of 1979 their dearest hopes might never have come to be.  
 If the Queen Mother provided a mother figure for Charles, it was his great-uncle, Lord Mountbatten, who became a father substitute. 
 His own father, Prince Philip, was in the Navy for much of his childhood and the relationship between father and son was in any event a difficult one. 
 Prince Philip was frankly disappointed in his first born and took no pains to hide his feelings. 
 Charles was too sensitive for his liking, too intellectual, too philosophical, and although Charles adored his father and has spent a lifetime trying to please him and be as he would like, he has never really succeeded. 
 As a result, he grew up with very little self-confidence. 
 There is no doubt that Charles has done a great deal that his father has been proud of and has excelled at sports like polo that the Duke of Edinburgh played when he was younger, but the Prince never felt he was good enough. 
 In his wisdom, Lord Mountbatten saw what was happening and, after his retirement in 1965, concentrated his attention on the young Prince and became a vital figure in his life. 
 Charles adored him and had done since he was a small child. 
 Uncle Dickie, as he was known to the whole family, was a dynamic, tyrannical figure, full of energy, drive and ambition, who aroused strong passions in everyone who came into contact with him. 
 He was a national hero, he had been Supreme Commander in South East Asia during the Second World War, the last Viceroy and first Governor General of India, first Sea Lord, and finally Chief of the Defence Staff. 
 Born in 1900, the same year as the Queen Mother, he had spent twenty-three years at the top, he had travelled all over the world, he had stories and memories of escapades and people and was a colourful raconteur. 
 To Charles he was an indispensable source of wisdom and experience and he relished the time spent in his company. 
 Mountbatten saw Charles for what he was and liked what he saw, and for the first time the growing Prince was given some real sense of his own worth. 
 His great-uncle took Charles under his wing and prepared him for the job ahead. 
 No one could have been better suited for the role, nor taken to it with more enthusiasm. 
 He became friend, teacher, mentor and confidant. 
 Charles spent many a weekend with Mountbatten at Broadlands, his home in Hampshire,  where he felt totally at ease. 
 The Prince took his problems to Broadlands and also his girlfriends. 
 It provided the perfect sanctuary and Mountbatten was always there with time and interest to talk and advise. 
 Charles with Lord Mountbatten in 1976 &mdash; a vital figure in his life 
 By 1971, however, Charles was in the Navy and much of his time was spent at sea. 
 &bquo;As you know only too well,&equo; he wrote after leaving Broadlands on one occasion to embark on a six-month cruise, &bquo;to me it has become a second home in so many ways, and no one could ever have had such a splendid honorary grandpapa in the history of avuncular relationships.&equo; 
 The affection was entirely reciprocated. 
 Mountbatten missed Charles enormously when he went off on long trips and felt lonely and deprived without his increasingly regular visits. 
 &bquo;I've been thinking of you &mdash; &mdash; far more&equo;, he wrote, &bquo;than I had ever expected to think of a young man &mdash; but then I've got to know you so well, I really miss you very much.&equo; 
 And in his diary he wrote, &bquo;It's lovely having him here, we've had so many cosy talks. 
 What a really charming young man he is.&equo; 
 The advice that came out of those cosy talks, however, was not necessarily heeded. 
 On one occasion, for example, Charles flew down to Broadlands to consult Mountbatten about a speech he had written for the Gandhi centenary tribute. 
 The older man read the text overnight and came up with some suggested changes, all of which the Prince ignored. 
 &bquo;He very politely pointed out in each case,&equo; recalled Mountbatten, &bquo;that it was not the way he would have phrased it, and so it remained virtually unchanged. 
 I thought it was really splendid.&equo; 
 But on the subject of women, the Prince did take his honorary grandfather's advice. 
 &bquo;I believe, in a case like yours,&equo; wrote Mountbatten, coincidentally on St Valentine's Day in 1974, &bquo;the man should sow his wild oats and have as many affairs as he can before settling down, but for a wife he should choose a suitable, attractive and sweet-charactered girl before she met anyone else she might fall for. 
 I think it is disturbing for women to have experiences if they have to remain on a pedestal after marriage.&equo; 
 As fast as the Prince could comply, however, the press were trying to marry him off. 
 &bquo;I've only got to look twice at someone,&equo; he said in desperation, &bquo;and the next morning I'm engaged to her.&equo; 
 It was not only intensely irritating, but it also frightened many women off, and made the normal process of two people getting to know one another quite impossible. 
 Thus having Broadlands to use for this purpose made life very much easier. 
 While happy to welcome any number of beautiful women to his home, Lord Mountbatten secretly cherished hopes that Charles would marry his granddaughter, 
 Amanda Knatchbull, and by 1979 was busy plotting ways of bringing them together. 
 A visit to India being planned for the Prince the following year seemed the perfect opportunity. 
 Mountbatten proposed that he and Amanda should accompany Charles, so he could show &bquo;the two young people I love so much&hellip; the country which means so much to me&equo;, but the Duke of Edinburgh thought this a bad idea. 
 He thought it a mistake for the Prince to make his first visit in the shadow of such a  legendary figure. 
 David Checketts, who was Prince Charles's private secretary at the time, was also dubious. 
 &bquo;You think I'll take over the whole show, don't you?&equo; accused Mountbatten. 
 However, terrorists determined the issue. 
 On 27 August 1979 Lord Mountbatten, on holiday in County Sligo in the Republic of Ireland, was brutally murdered. 
 A fifty-pound bomb, planted in his fishing boat, exploded as he set off out of the little harbour of Mullaghmore to inspect lobster pots. 
 He had with him his daughter and her husband, Lord and Lady Brabourne, their fourteen-year-old twin sons, Nicholas and Timothy Knatchbull, Lord Brabourne's elderly mother, and Paul Maxwell, a local lad who enjoyed helping with the boat. 
 Miraculously, Lord and Lady Brabourne and one son, Timothy, survived. 
 Lady Brabourne senior was pulled out of the water alive, but died in hospital the next day. 
 The rest of the fishing party were killed. 
 Mountbatten's &bquo;execution&equo;, claimed the IRA faction responsible, &bquo;was a way of bringing emotionally home to the English ruling-class and its working-class slaves&hellip; that their government's war on us is going to cost them as well&hellip; 
 We will tear out their sentimental imperialist heart.&equo; 
 Many hearts were torn out that day, among them the Prince's. 
 He was in Iceland, fishing with friends, when he heard the news and flew straight to Windsor Castle, to a father who was still unable to help. 
 Charles was overcome with grief; he felt shocked, frightened and alone. 
 He had lost the greatest friend he would ever have. 
 He had lost the one person who believed in him, the one person whom he could trust with his innermost thoughts. 
 Life, as he told his friends, would never be the same again. 
 Any prospect of romance with Amanda Knatchbull was killed that day too. 
 But in the weeks that followed they became very close and clung to one another in their loss. 
 After the funeral Charles retreated to Balmoral, where he watched the BBC obituary of Mountbatten over and over again, and walked the lonely moors. 
 He was joined there by Amanda's brother, Norton (now Lord Romsey), and his fianc&eacute;e, Penelope Eastwood; and although the cousins had never been especially friendly before, a strong bond grew between them as they talked day after day, trying to make sense of it all. 
 A year before his death, Charles had written to Lord Mountbatten, once again thanking him for his help. 
 &bquo;I was deeply grateful for our conversation yesterday morning and being able to pick your brains on the subjects was an immense help. 
 As I said to you yesterday, I have no idea what we shall do without you when you finally decide to depart. 
 It doesn't bear thinking about, but I only hope I shall have learnt something  from you in order to carry it on in some way or another.&equo; 
 &bquo;FOR GOD'S SAKE, RING ME UP &mdash; I'M GOING TO NEED YOU&equo; 
 Had Lord Mountbatten lived, there is a good chance that Diana Spencer would not have become Princess of Wales. 
 He might have foreseen the problems that would ensue after their marriage, seen that there was a gulf between Charles and Diana that would be difficult to bridge and advised against it. 
 But Mountbatten was gone and no one would ever quite fill the void he left. 
 His death quite literally shattered the Prince and for a time he lost all sense of purpose. 
 While Mountbatten was still alive, Charles had begun working on many projects and had become enthused by what he could do to help the young and the disadvantaged; he was fired by what needed to be done in the inner cities and keen to find ways of defusing racial tension. 
 Some of his staff disapproved of the direction he was taking, and four months before Mountbatten died, his private secretary, Sir David Checketts, resigned. 
 He was replaced by an even greater traditionalist, Edward Adeane, who also had reservations about what the Prince was doing. 
 But Mountbatten had backed up Charles. 
 He more than anyone appreciated that if the monarchy was to survive, it needed to be updated. 
 It could not afford to be seen as a drain on the taxpayer and it should be relevant to the times. 
 After Mountbatten's death, Charles no longer knew where he was going. 
 He grew withdrawn and introspective. 
 Help came from a number of sources, including his own deep faith, but there were individuals too. 
 The Queen Mother was one. 
 She understood his grief and his sense of loss and loneliness &mdash; she had been there herself, after the King's death &mdash; and she knew about the feelings of despair and the long, long time the scars would take to heal, but she also knew about the importance of carrying on. 
 Another source of support was Sir Laurens van der Post, who had also known Mountbatten, and who had been a Japanese prisoner of war in Java. 
 This extraordinary  man, explorer, farmer, writer and mystic, taught Charles to seek the depth and strength within himself, to use the experience of Mountbatten's death, to use the suffering and learn from it: to grow in the spiritual sense; and above all, to ensure that his great-uncle had not died in vain. 
 Had Mountbatten lived, Diana may never have become Princess of Wales 
 Rumours of a royal romance were rife in November 1980 
 Charles rallied. 
 The year before Mountbatten died he had taken over the reins of the United World Colleges (UWC) from his great-uncle. 
 This movement, co-founded with Kurt Hahn, founder of Gordonstoun, was a passion of Mountbatten. 
 Its aim was to promote peace and international understanding through education. 
 Lord Mountbatten had spent ten years tirelessly promoting the dream, talking about it all over the world, often in the highest places, inspiring everyone around him and shamelessly raising money to build more colleges. 
 At the end of his ten years there were three: in Canada, Singapore, and the original one, 
 Atlantic College in Wales. 
 Charles had taken over the role of president determined to make a positive contribution. 
 Van der post reminded Charles that to slow down, even for a while, would be to give the terrorists what they had wanted. 
 The Prince knew his friend was right. 
 He had had 2,500 letters from members of the public expressing their grief, sympathy and admiration for a man who they felt had in some way belonged to ordinary people and understood them. 
 Charles knew he had to fight for them. 
 Mountbatten had wanted him to be a leader of men. 
 Now was the time to do it. 
 The Prince had come to know Van der Post in Kenya two years before, when he had been his guide on safari. 
 He is a remarkable old man in any setting, but in the bushveld of southern Africa, where he was born and has lived for much of his life, he was in his element. 
 Every evening the small party would sit under the stars and listen to his stories of life in the African interior, his extensive travels and explorations, his war years and his friendship with the Swiss psychologist Carl Jung. 
 The Prince felt he was in the company of someone very special, took great delight in time spent talking to him, and was inspired by all that he heard. 
 Guided by his new-found friend, Charles studied Jung and also the work of economist and philosopher E. F. Schumacher, who wrote a book entitled Small Is Beautiful ; over the years the Prince has found many of the answers he was searching for. 
 Charles put on a brave face to the world, but secretly he was in turmoil for many, many months; and one other person who helped see him through this period was Diana. 
 They had re-met, after that first encounter at Althorp, at Sandringham in January 1979, when the Queen had invited Diana and her sister Sarah (whose relationship with the Prince was well and truly over) for a weekend's shooting. 
 It was not a surprising invitation. 
 Their other sister, Jane, had married Robert Fellowes, a member of the Queen's permanent staff, the year before; and, given the rest of the Spencer family's connections with the Royal family, the surprise was that she had never been invited before. 
 Both of her grandmothers had been ladies-in-waiting to the Queen Mother. 
 Her father had been an equerry to the Queen and to King George VI before  that; and before her grandfather died in 1975 and her father became the Eighth Earl Spencer and moved to Althorp, the family had lived in a house on the Sandringham Estate. 
 It was where Diana was born and had spent the first fourteen years of her life. 
 Diana arrived at Sandringham that weekend having just been through a most traumatic period. 
 Her father, whom she adored, had collapsed the previous September with a cerebral haemorrhage and had lain in a coma in the National Hospital in Queen Square, London, for nearly four months. 
 No one expected him to live. 
 To make matters worse, he had a new wife, Raine, formerly Lady Dartmouth, a formidable woman who became fiercely protective. 
 She set up a bedside vigil, had special drugs imported from Germany, played him his favourite music and discouraged everyone else from visiting, including his own children. 
 Her steely determination, however, had worked, and that very weekend Earl Spencer had been released from hospital and moved into a suite at the Dorchester Hotel, until he was strong enough to be moved home to Northamptonshire. 
 It had been a difficult time for everyone, but especially Diana, who was perhaps closest to her father of all the children. 
 Charles took to Diana that weekend and began seeing her on a regular basis when they returned to London. 
 She was only eighteen and still quite unsophisticated but, after all the glossy and sophisticated women he had gone out with, that was part of her appeal. 
 She was fun and easy to be with, natural and down to earth, yet she was sensitive and courageous in the way she had coped with her father's illness. 
 She had no expectations and made no demands. 
 The Prince could relax, be himself and simply enjoy her friendship. 
 He would ring her up every couple of months or so and invite her to the opera, or to dinner and no one paid any attention to this. 
 After Mountbatten's death, Diana's qualities were especially appealing. 
 She was there with the warmth, sympathy and understanding that few others could offer. 
 She instinctively knew what he was going through, drawing from the experience of her own troubled past; and he found himself growing increasingly fond of her. 
 The media, in the meantime, were clamouring for him to marry. 
 It had been a preoccupation for several years, but now it was becoming intense. 
 Even his father  had started badgering him. 
 He had a duty, he was reminded, to secure the line of succession, to produce an heir to safeguard the monarchy. 
 He was over thirty: it was no longer an intrusion into his privacy; it was rightly a matter of public concern. 
 He must stop dallying with film stars and floozies and get on and find a wife. 
 Diana with her father. 
 No one had expected him to survive a massive cerebral haemorrhage 
 Charles looked around for a suitable candidate and nudged, no doubt, by a couple of doting grandmothers, found Lady Diana Spencer. 
 She was eminently suitable, well liked by everyone and was ready and waiting. 
 What had begun as a schoolgirl crush had grown into a profound and romantic desire to be Charles's bride. 
 She had no ambitions for a career. 
 What she craved was the security of marriage and was only too pleased when Charles began to take her seriously during the summer of 1980. 
 They saw a great deal of each other, but, because Diana was so much younger and usually just one of a party, no one who saw them together ever suspected she was a girlfriend. 
 It was not until September when she was spotted with Charles on the banks of the River Dee at Balmoral by the royal reporter, James Whittaker, that anyone was any the wiser. 
 At that point life changed more than anyone could have foreseen. 
 The press laid siege to Diana's flat in London and followed her every move until the engagement was announced five months later. 
 They were testing months. 
 Diana had no form of protection, and no help in dealing with the press. 
 She had never been exposed to anything like it before, and initially she found being the centre of attention quite amusing. 
 The sight of dozens of photographers leaping to their lenses every time she opened her front door made her giggle. 
 She enjoyed giving them the slip, as she sometimes succeeded in doing. 
 On one occasion she packed up her car as if about to go away for the weekend, then sauntered up the street, leading the press to believe she had gone to buy a packet of  Polos. 
 By the time she reappeared, she had been up to Scotland and back, to spend the weekend with Charles at the Queen Mother's home, Birkhall. 
 With Prince Andrew and Charles at a polo match. 
 What Diana craved was the security of marriage 
 She coped with the press with astonishing skill for someone who was just nineteen years old, and was always painstakingly polite. 
 But as time went on, it became less of a joke. 
 Journalists rang her day and night, even in the early hours of the morning. 
 They kept up a twenty-four-hour vigil outside Coleherne Court, and plagued her at the kindergarten. 
 They followed her wherever she went. 
 Stories appeared that were untrue, newspapers quoted things she had not said and she began to feel panicky. 
 Charles was worried she might be scared off. 
 Her mother was so worried she wrote to The Times  asking, &bquo;Is it fair for any human being, regardless of circumstances, to be treated in this way?&equo; 
 In the House of Commons sixty MPs tabled a motion &bquo;deploring the manner in which Lady Diana Spencer is treated by the media&equo;, and &bquo;calling on those responsible to have more concern for individual privacy&equo;. 
 And the Press Council called senior editors to the first extraordinary meeting convened in its twenty-seven-year history to discuss the matter. 
 Despite all this, nothing changed. 
 The public's fascination with &bquo;Shy Di&equo;, as she was dubbed, was simply insatiable. 
 In February the engagement was announced and Diana was rescued. 
 She now came under the giant umbrella of the Royal Family and at last the palace was able to give her full protection. 
 A personal bodyguard was assigned to her and has been with her day and night ever since. 
 Gone were the last vestiges of normality. 
 As she left Coleherne Court she left a poignant note for her flatmates, giving them her new telephone number: &bquo;For God's sake ring me up &mdash; I'm going to need you.&equo;  
 March 1981, Diana's first official engagement. 
 The press still followed her every step 
 AFTER THE HONEYMOON 
 Diana meant every word of her note. 
 Friends have been of paramount importance to her in the last ten years and she has not deserted them. 
 She may have become an international superstar, wined and dined with kings and presidents, prima ballerinas, film idols, pop legends and sporting heroes; she may be ferried around in motorcades and private yachts and planes; and she may be given priceless jewels to wear. 
 Yet the people who truly matter in her life are the friends she had when she was an ordinary teenager. 
 These are the people who have seen her through the difficult times, who have helped her adjust to the life before her and who have kept her in touch with the real world. 
 &bquo;Here is the stuff of which fairy tales are made,&equo; proclaimed the Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Robert Runcie, to a packed cathedral, on that famous wedding day. 
  Before him sat Queen Elizabeth II, the Queen Mother and every member of the British Royal family; and most of the crowned heads of Europe, innumerable monarchs from Africa, the Middle East and Asia, including the 25-stone King of Tonga, for whom an extra-large chair had been specially made. 
 There were 160 foreign presidents and prime ministers, dozens of high-ranking diplomats, civil servants, local government officials, members of the armed forces, politicians and industrialists. 
 &equo; Here is the stuff of which fairy tales are made.&equo; 
 The wedding millions flocked to see 
 Back at Balmoral, Charles and Diana were classic newly-weds 
 Yet seated side by side near the front &mdash; ahead of Nancy Reagan, America's First Lady, and many other dignitaries &mdash; were those three girls from Coleherne Court: 
 Ann Bolton, Virginia Pitman and Carolyn Pride. 
 There were other friends too and people she had grown up with. 
 Not far behind them sat David Thomas and his wife, a jeweller who had looked after the Spencer family for years and sold Diana several pieces: but he was still &bquo;just a humble jeweller&equo;, and was expecting to be tucked away behind a pillar at the back. 
 This has to be a mistake, he had thought, as they were directed ever closer to the front. 
 It was no mistake. 
 Humble jeweller or not, as far as Diana was concerned he was a friend. 
 To their surprise, all the workers from Althorp were there too. 
 They had been told by Earl Spencer that there were sadly insufficient tickets for him to invite them, but  Diana used her own allocation to ensure they were there. 
 State occasion or not, it was her day and she wanted to be surrounded by her friends. 
 Relaxed and happy aboard the Royal Yacht Britannia at Gibraltar, at the start of their honeymoon in the sun 
 She may have been just twenty years old, and secretly terrified, but she would only have one wedding in her life, and she was determined to make it her own. 
 And for all the pomp and ceremony, for all the formality and precision, the security and the months of planning, for all the cameras and lights, it was still a touching and surprisingly intimate affair. 
 The couple were determined their honeymoon should be too, despite equal determination on behalf of the world's press to keep them company. 
 After a few days at Broadlands, they flew to Gibraltar to join the Royal Yacht Britannia  for a two-week cruise in and around the Mediterranean. 
 For two weeks the press flew from one Greek island to another, like migrating birds, at the slightest rumour. 
 They set to sea in boats and cruisers; one newspaper even hired a Lear jet, which flew over the area day after day. 
 But thanks to the ingenuity of Edward Adeane, who planned it all, no one found them. 
 It was the first and last time they have had such privacy and they returned to Balmoral to join the Royal Family for their traditional September break, tanned, relaxed and obviously very much in love. 
 Within days of arriving they held a press  conference, on the understanding that the press would thereafter leave them alone, and it was the most informal such occasion anyone can remember. 
 They were classic newly-weds, unable to take their eyes or their hands off each other, laughing and joking and clearly very happy. 
 For two weeks they managed to evade the press. 
 It was the first and last time they have ever had such privacy 
 Their honeymoon had been &bquo;fabulous&equo;, said Diana, bubbling over with enthusiasm and dying to tell the world. 
 She could &bquo;highly recommend marriage&equo;, she said. 
 &bquo;It's a marvellous life, and Balmoral is one of the best places in the world.&equo; 
 The last year had been like a dream, a fairy tale; but suddenly, as the cameras retreated and the curtains drew on another quiet Balmoral evening, with the Queen insisting on formal dress for dinner, as she does every night, the dream began to dissolve. 
 The honeymoon was over and the reality of what she had taken on began to dawn. 
 Diana had known she was marrying into a close family, but she was unprepared for how claustrophobic it would be, or how dull she would find long spells in their company, with their passion for dogs and horses. 
 She had also known that Charles would have to see his mother just as regularly after they were married as before: there were matters of state they had to discuss, and discuss in private. 
 It was part of the job: his mother was sovereign, he was her heir and they would share secrets that no one else could ever know. 
 Rationally, Diana understood, but emotionally, the Queen was still her mother-in-law and the relationship was as difficult as for any new wife. 
 Their weeks in Scotland were an anticlimax. 
 Her husband, who had been so attentive in the sunshine, was back on home territory, in the place he loved best on earth, surrounded by the people and the activities he loved most. 
 He was also back to the daily pile of paperwork and would be closeted with secretaries for much of the day. 
 When that was done, he would be off fishing, thigh deep in the River Dee for hours on end, or shooting. 
 Diana did not especially care for either of those activities and she did not ride, which kept the rest of the family amused. 
 Not surprisingly, she grew bored and lonely. 
 She longed for something to do other than trudge the glorious, heather-clad grouse moors. 
 The weather did not help. 
 It rained almost every day, and she began to feel imprisoned. 
 She railed against the formality and the dreariness  of it all, balked at the routine; her mood swinging back and forth, from tears and misery to elation. 
 She wanted to go home, but it was out of the question. 
 There was no alternative but to grin and bear it. 
 With the Queen at the Braemar Games. 
 The honeymoon was over 
 Returning to London was not the cure. 
 Diana had been blaming the Highlands for what was a far more fundamental malady. 
 Charles had been a bachelor for thirty-two years. 
 He had a house in Gloucestershire and another at Kensington Palace, and staff who had been with him for years, accustomed to his simple and masculine lifestyle and accustomed to ruling it. 
 He had a well-established routine in his life. 
 He would rise early to work at his desk and return to it after a day's engagements, often until well past midnight. 
 His sports and hobbies frequently took him away for the best part of the weekend; work also ate into parts of Saturday and Sunday. 
 For the remainder of his free time, he had an established circle of good friends, whom he saw regularly. 
 Most important of all, when duty called, Charles was there. 
 Whether it was the Trooping of the Colour, a state visit, or Remembrance Sunday, whatever the time or day of the week, the dates were in his diary and he was on parade without fail and without question. 
 It never occurred to Charles that Diana would find any of this odd or difficult to accept; but her upbringing had been entirely different. 
 She had never had any real discipline in her life in the way Charles had. 
 She had done as she pleased. 
 If she wanted to give up on something she did. 
 She had never been pushed academically, although there is no doubt she had the intelligence to have done far better than she ever did. 
 She had walked away from finishing school and she had walked away from Miss Vacani's; and her parents had never sought to interfere with her freedom, or impose restrictions on her. 
 Charles, by contrast, had known nothing but restriction and discipline. 
 His life had been ruled by others from day one. 
 He can never remember a time when he didn't have a detective to guard him, or private cars, planes or trains to transport him. 
 He had never been able to lose himself in a crowd, or dash off somewhere suddenly on a whim. 
 He had lived in castles and palaces, and been attended by courtiers, soldiers and valets.  
 Diana had never had any real discipline in her life. 
 Charles had known nothing else 
 Much as his parents might have wanted Charles to have a normal upbringing, it was impossible. 
 They sent him to proper schools &mdash; the first royal child not to have been educated by private tutors &mdash; but he was never just another pupil; he was never allowed to forget the accident of birth that set him apart. 
 He grew up in the public spotlight, never free from prying eyes and press comment, never sure when a trusted friend would betray him, or when a casual remark to a stranger might blow up in his face. 
 Sent away to prep school at eight, he was lonely and homesick and no sooner had he settled in than he moved to public school, to Gordonstoun, a bleak and desolate place on the windswept north-east coast of Scotland, with a regime to match. 
 For the first three years he endured abject misery. 
 At the point when he began to enjoy himself, he was sent off to go through it all again in Australia, in order that the Commonwealth could be seen to have played some part in his education. 
 For six months he lived in even more spartan conditions at Timbertop, in the Australian bush. 
 Again he had to prove himself, this time to 135 tough young teenagers aged fourteen and fifteen who were not impressed by his title. 
 It was a crash course in survival, and in learning how to get on with people; but when he made friends there, he knew, probably for the first time in his life, that he was liked for who he was and not what he was. 
 His three years at Cambridge were some of the happiest of his life and also the most normal. 
 Apart from having a detective, who lodged in the room next door at Trinity, he lived like everyone else &mdash; except that yet again his course was interrupted. 
 In the midst of his second year he was sent off to the University College of Wales at Aberystwyth, for a crash course in everything Welsh prior to his investiture as Prince of Wales in the summer of 1969. 
 It was not an easy transition. 
 Prince Charles had a rough reception and a difficult, at times terrifying three months at the hands of extreme Welsh nationalists. 
 Groups like the Welsh Language Society and the Free Wales Army were said to be training freedom fighters in the mountains and he was barracked everywhere he went. 
 A. J. P. Taylor called the decision to send Charles to Aberystwyth a &bquo;sordid plot to exploit&equo; him. 
 &bquo;Mr Wilson&equo;, he said, &bquo;is imposing on Prince Charles a sacrifice which he would not dream of imposing on his own son., It was indeed a sacrifice and one from which many a twenty-year-old would have turned and run. 
 So intense was the hatred in the town that, shortly before Charles was due to arrive, the principal of University College, Dr Tom Parry, had advised the visit be called off. 
 Never before had the Prince encountered such anger and hostility, nor been exposed to such real and persistent danger. 
 His mentor during the stay was the Secretary of State for Wales, George Thomas (later created Lord Tonypandy), who became a lifelong friend as a result. 
 He knew that it was no use shielding Charles. 
 He had to face the enemy. 
 Charles needed no pushing. 
 One particular day, having struggled through an ugly crowd of protesters to the safety of the Welsh Office, the Prince announced he was going back out to talk to them.  
 &bquo;I would advise against it, sir,&equo; said George Thomas. 
 &bquo;I know you would,&equo; said Prince Charles, &bquo;but I'm going.&equo; 
 &bquo;In that case, sir,&equo; said the Secretary of State, &bquo;I'm coming with you.&equo; 
 Sometimes it worked, sometimes they simply shouted abuse, but his greatest success was when he addressed the Welsh League of Youth Eisteddfod at Aberystwyth in Welsh, having studied the language for just six weeks. 
 It was a hostile audience. 
 The League had already declared that it would boycott the investiture and, when he stood up to speak, a hundred or so extremists began shouting and jeering, and dozens had to be dragged off by the police before he could be heard. 
 Undaunted, he spoke for seven minutes to an audience of 5,000 people and won considerable respect from some hard-bitten nationalists, including Gwynfor Evans MP, president of Plaid Cymru. 
 &bquo;His performance was amazing,&equo; he confessed, &bquo;I have never heard anyone who has taken to Welsh so recently master the language so well.&equo; 
 The investiture went ahead on 1 July and was a splendid and dramatic piece of pageantry; it was also strangely moving. 
 As he knelt at his mother's feet, the sovereign invested her son with the symbols of office, &bquo;by girding him with a Sword&hellip; by putting a Coronet on his head&hellip; and a Gold Ring on his finger&hellip; and also by delivering a Gold Rod into his hand, that he may preside there and may direct and defend those parts to hold to him and his heirs&hellip; for ever&equo;. 
 &bquo;I, Charles, Prince of Wales,&equo; responded the Prince, &bquo;do become your liege man of life and limb and of earthly worship, and faith and truth I will bear unto you to live and die against all manner of folks.&equo; 
 With that, he took the letters-patent from his mother, rose to his feet, gave her the kiss of fealty, and took his place on the throne to her right. 
 A trade-union organizer from mid-Wales spoke for many an onlooker that day. 
 &bquo;I am not a royalist,&equo; he said, &bquo;I am a socialist and I wouldn't cross the street for the Prince myself. 
 But I'll tell you this, that young man has done more for Wales already than we could dream of.&equo; 
 At the age of twenty-two, the Prince's life was still being ruled by others. 
 After university it was announced that he was going into the armed forces. 
 &bquo;It is pointless and ill informed to say that I am entering a profession trained in killing,&equo; he said in his defence. 
 &bquo;The Services in the first place are there for fast, efficient and well-trained action in defence. 
 Surely the Services must attract a large number of duty-conscious people? 
 Otherwise, who else would subject themselves to being square-bashed, shouted at by petty officers, and made to do ghastly things in force ten gales? 
 I am entering the RAF and then the Navy because I believe I can contribute something to this country by so doing. 
 To me it is a worthwhile occupation and one which I am convinced will stand me in good stead for the rest of my life.&equo; 
 These sort of sentiments had never crossed Diana's mind. 
 In no way had she ever been prepared for the life she was now expected to lead and Charles had some difficulty in understanding her feelings. 
 For all his altruism, he is intrinsically self-centred. 
 Having been waited on hand and foot for most of his life and had people  jump whenever he called, he has never really had the opportunity to be anything else. 
 He had thought Diana would quietly fit into his routine. 
 Diana, for her part, thought she would become a wife and mother; but, with all the servants and secretaries who surrounded the Prince, including a valet who selected and prepared his clothes for the day, packed for him and even did his personal shopping, she felt superfluous, and just a little jealous. 
 Some of them were loyal and trusted men who had been with the Prince for years and, as well as relying heavily upon them, he liked them. 
 They enjoyed their position of confidence and some were a little resentful at having the boat rocked by the arrival of the Princess. 
 Some of the Prince's friends were also somewhat put out at having their cosy relationship altered by the distraction of a young wife. 
 They had enjoyed his single status and the attention he devoted to them, and frankly did not want the intrusion of a newcomer. 
 She, in turn, found some of his friends hard-going. 
 She disliked the intimacy he showed towards some of them, was resentful of the memories they shared of which she was not a part, and felt excluded. 
 She also found it intolerable to have her husband's old girlfriends around. 
 Apart from a handful of friends that were his own age, like Nicholas Soames and Lord Romsey &mdash; who were still fourteen or fifteen years Diana's senior &mdash; most of the people Charles enjoyed seeing were older, with the result that Diana frequently found she was socializing with her father's, or even grandfather's, generation. 
 They were often men of learning, like Sir Laurens Van der Post or the historian Sir Harold Acton. 
 She was quite out of her depth and, frankly, bored. 
 Her own friends were poles apart from his. 
 They were young, rich and ambitious, typical Hooray Henries, with Sloane Ranger girlfriends; Charles found them just as unsympathetic as they found him. 
 It was no different from the situation that most couples face in the early days of their marriage, when they discover they don't like each other's friends. 
 The way they dealt with it was no different from any other couple either, except that every move was being monitored by the media. 
 Diana was accused of banishing the Prince's friends. 
 LEARNING THE JOB 
 Diana's first public engagement as Princess of Wales was, appropriately, a tour of the principality, and it was obvious from the very first day that she had an extraordinary talent. 
 Whatever personal problems she and Charles had were put to one side and they gave the people of Wales a visit to remember. 
 She plunged into the crowds, who had turned out in their thousands to greet her, as though she had been doing it all her life. 
 She instinctively knew what to say to people and whose hand to clasp hold of. 
 &bquo;My dad says give us a kiss,&equo; shouted a little boy at the first stop in Rhyl. 
 &bquo;Well then, you had better have one,&equo; said Diana, and bent down to kiss him on the cheek. 
 She noticed one woman in the crowd was blind, and sought out her hand and squeezed it. 
 &bquo;What nice shiny medals,&equo; she said, spotting a hunchbacked old soldier at the Deeside Leisure Centre. 
 Then to his beaming wife, &bquo;Did you polish them for him?&equo; 
 And when the rain poured down in Carmarthen and the streets were like rivers, still the crowds stood out and waited. 
 They were soaked right through to the skin and shivering in the cold. 
 Diana looked half-frozen herself and battled with a useless umbrella; the feather on her hat began to flop, yet she stayed and chatted for longer than ever, as if to reward the people for their patience. 
 &bquo;Now I've seen her, she's everything I thought she would be,&equo; said one woman. 
 &bquo;She's the flower in the royal forest.&equo; 
 The Prince was bursting with pride, and amused to find himself redundant. 
 At each stop they would take one side of the street each and he could not help notice the disappointment on people's faces if they got him rather than her. 
 He was left apologizing for not having enough wives to go round. 
 &bquo;Do you want me to give those to her?&equo; he would ask when people desperately pointed bunches of flowers in her direction. 
 &bquo;I seem to do nothing but collect flowers these days. 
 I know my role.&equo; 
 In three days they covered 400 miles. 
 It was exhausting but exhilarating, not least of all because, in the middle of it, Diana learned that she was pregnant. 
 It could not have been more exciting news and everyone was thrilled, but her small and newly  gathered staff took a deep breath. 
 They had only just recovered from dealing with all the correspondence and presents from the wedding; six days later, when the pregnancy became official, lorry loads of letters, bibs and baby boots rained down upon them. 
 Diana had gathered together a small staff who were learning the ropes as fast as she was. 
 The principal members were a private secretary, Oliver Everett, who worked for the diplomatic service and was recalled from Madrid to set up her office; and Anne Beckwith-Smith, a specialist in eighteenth-century English painting, who worked at Sotheby's and was brought in as full-time lady-in-waiting. 
 The task was to set up the office, get a system going to deal with the fan mail, gifts and general correspondence, liaise with dress designers and process the requests for patronages as they came in. 
 Within her first year Diana had been approached by 150 charities. 
 She had chosen just five to start with, most of them to do with children, which seemed appropriate, and the Welsh National Opera, which was also fitting. 
 Fond as she is of children, however, they are by no means her only interest. 
 The Princess found herself pigeon  holed for a long time as a result of those early associations, but they were nevertheless a useful apprenticeship. 
 In Wales, the crowds turned out in their thousands to greet their new Princess, and they were not disappointed 
 Charles had his own household to deal with his affairs which he had brought together when he came out of the forces. 
 David Checketts was his first private secretary, a former squadron leader in the RAF who had been equerry to the Duke of Edinburgh, and was the perfect person to help the Prince make the transition from the armed services into a full-time working member of the &bquo;family firm&equo;. 
 He had left in 1979, when he felt he was no longer the right man for the job, and the Honourable Edward Adeane had replaced him. 
 The man who ran the office was Michael Colborne, a chief petty officer whom Charles had become friendly with aboard HMS Norfolk , during his early days at sea. 
 He was a trusted friend and one of the few people ever to have been in the Prince's employ who spoke frankly to him, and when asked would give an honest, if sometimes unwelcome, opinion. 
 Quite often Colborne would get an equally honest and unwelcome reply. 
 The Prince has a fierce temper, which Colborne often caught the brunt of. 
 On one occasion Lord Mountbatten had found him licking his wounds and asked if the Prince had been upsetting him. 
 &bquo;Bear with him, Michael, please,&equo; said Mountbatten. 
 &bquo;He doesn't mean to get at you personally. 
 It's just that he wants to let off steam, and you're the only person he can lose his temper with. 
 It's a back-handed compliment really, you know. 
 He needs you.&equo; 
 It was Colborne as much as anyone who took Diana under his wing in the early days. 
 They shared an office from the engagement to the wedding and he was a fatherly shoulder to cry on when the going was tough. 
 Edward Adeane was not the man for the job. 
 He was a brilliant lawyer, with a first-class brain, but very little tolerance of lesser intellects. 
 He detested the commercial world and, although he was much the same age as the Prince, had no time for the young. 
 He could no more understand what went on in a twenty-year-old's head than fly to the moon. 
 When Diana once asked him what the capital of Australia was, he was rendered totally speechless. 
 Charles took on the job of improving Diana's geography and also of teaching her the tricks of the trade &mdash; how to handle the different sorts of engagements, how to remember names and avoid missing or offending anyone, how to pace herself, how to address people, what sort of questions to ask and how to steer clear of banana skins. 
 Dealing with people came naturally and was in many ways the most important part of the job, but there was more that could come only with experience, and Charles was there to pass on some of the things he had learned over thirty-three years, some of them the hard way. 
 There was no job specification for the Prince of Wales and no guidelines for a Princess of Wales either. 
 Their roles have just evolved. 
 Charles had been moved early on by the plight of disadvantaged young people and much of his energy had gone into that. 
 He had formed what later became the Prince's Trust while he was in the Navy,  and the grants that went out in the early years were paid for, anonymously, out of his naval allowance. 
 Candidates had to write down what they felt would most help them improve their lives and these suggestions were forwarded to the Prince in the diplomatic bag to wherever he happened to be in the world; he then chose whom the money should go to. 
 The scheme bore the unmistakable stamp of Kurt Hahn and his trust system that Charles had seen in operation at Gordonstoun. 
 Applicants were given cash grants, usually no more than &pound;75, and trusted to use it for the purpose they had proposed - such as buying a bicycle to do a newspaper round, obtaining equipment for a camping trip, or acquiring the wherewithal to learn a new skill or a sport. 
 There was no bureaucracy, no strings: it was a straightforward gift. 
 It would challenge young people's sense of responsibility, he hoped, and show these troubled teenagers that someone trusted and believed in them. 
 It paid dividends and, as the scheme grew, many of the beneficiaries came back in order to help others. 
 As he went about the country talking to young people involved with the Trust, 
 Charles could see at first-hand the tension that was building up in the vast depressing wastelands of the inner cities, where young people had no work, no ambition, no feeling of belonging, no pride in their surroundings &mdash; nothing, in fact, to get out of bed for in the mornings. 
 In addition, there was racial tension. 
 During the Queen's Silver Jubilee Year in 1977 Charles had encountered a typical scene. 
 He had been visiting a youth club in Lewisham, where twenty-four members, all black, had recently been arrested on mugging charges. 
 As he arrived he was met by a rabble of noisy, angry youths. 
 The one at the front, shouting loudest, was wearing a badge saying &bquo;Stuff the Jubilee&equo;. 
 Charles walked straight up to him and asked what was wrong. 
 When the boy told him how the police had made the arrests, the Prince called the division commander, whose men had arrested the twenty-four, to listen to what the boy had to say. 
 Charles suggested they get together at a later date to sort it out. 
 This is precisely what happened. 
 The twenty-four were tried by a court of law in the proper way, but the black community and the police began a dialogue that led to far better relations between the two than there had ever been before. 
 The Prince paid the price. 
 He had been seriously out of line, he was told; meddling in dangerous and delicate situations where he had no business; going way beyond his brief. 
 The criticism hurt, but it was from encounters like this that Charles discovered what his position as Prince of Wales was all about. 
 It gave him, he realized, a unique ability. 
 He could bring people together who would not under normal circumstances converse; and once they were talking, of course, there was hope. 
 The fearsome riots that swept the inner cities in 1981, in Brixton first, then Toxteth and Hansworth, Moss Side and Bristol, came as no surprise, and convinced Charles that this was the area where he could be of some use. 
 Ignoring his advisers, he concentrated his efforts in finding ways of improving life for the young people living in those areas.  
 Edward Adeane disapproved. 
 Charles was taking the job a long way from the safe arena of charitable patronage and ribbon-cutting and into politically dangerous areas, where constitutionally, he ought not to be. 
 Adeane was also unhappy about his association with Operation Raleigh, an ambitious round-the-world sailing venture, the second he had been involved with, run by the explorer John Blashford-Snell. 
 The idea was to take young people from all sorts of backgrounds and countries, including the inner cities, and give them &bquo;the challenges of war in peacetime&equo;: a combination of adventure and community service. 
 The Prince was becoming enthused, and as he grew more confident about the area he had targeted and took on more projects, he began to make increasingly serious and significant speeches. 
 At this point another problem reared its head. 
 Diana had captivated the country and the obsession with her was showing no signs of abating. 
 The media simply could not get enough. 
 Whenever she accompanied him, whether to a glossy film premi&eacute;re or a major speech, they reported on the clothes she was wearing, the hairstyle, the hat, the jewellery, whether she looked well, or strained or too thin. 
 What Charles said in major speeches which he put a great deal of time and thought into, seldom went farther than the four walls he spoke within. 
 The nation, it seemed, was far more concerned about the cut of Diana's coat than the crisis in society.  
 Diana had captivated the country; Charles was proud, but Diana was beginning to upstage him 
 She started a craze for pearl chokers, which had not been seen in years. 
 Culottes and ethnic jumpers, which she wore on her honeymoon, flooded the shops. 
 And there was scarcely a shirt to be found that did not have the high necks and ruffles that she favoured in the early days. 
 Women even cut their hair in the same style. 
 The Prince had had an inkling of what was to come in Wales, when the crowds had been so eager to see Diana that they could scarcely hide their disappointment if Charles and Diana took one side of the street each and they were on the side of the street he took. 
 Then, he had been quite amused and content to joke about being nothing more than a flower bearer, but he was not so happy when it became a regular occurrence. 
 With the exception of his mother, he had never played second-fiddle to anyone. 
 Every member of the Royal Family enjoys star status; they are used to being the centre of attention and there is strong unstated rivalry between them. 
 In the normal course of events they will only be seen en masse after the Trooping of the Colour and on Christmas morning at Windsor; and the wisdom passed from experienced staff to newcomers is never to put them on stage together. 
 The situation became quite delicate. 
 Proud though he was of his wife, Charles could not help noticing she was stealing the limelight. 
 Even when he went to engagements on his own, people would ask why he had left her behind, where was she? 
 For some reason, the public expected Diana to be with him wherever he went. 
 Yet they never expected the Duke of Edinburgh to accompany the Queen everywhere, or Mark Phillips to be seen with Princess Anne. 
 The confidence he had gained from having a loving wife was being undermined by a feeling of rejection from the public. 
 Subconsciously he was beginning to resent her; and there were flashes of anger when he accused his staff of paying her too much attention. 
 The solution was to operate independently, to abide by the unwritten rules of royal management and not let the Prince and Princess get into a position where they were competing for the limelight except when the occasion was pure entertainment. 
 But on 21 June 1982 the problem temporarily dissolved when at three minutes past nine in the evening, Diana gave birth to Prince William. 
 PARENTHOOD 
 Having children so early in their marriage was a mixed blessing. 
 Diana had felt unwell for much of the early part of her pregnancy, and was not quite herself, which made the process of settling down to married life all the more difficult. 
 But William was a much loved and much longed-for baby, and the Prince and Princess could not have been happier. 
 Charles had taken an active interest from the start. 
 He had wanted children for years: not having them had been the one drawback to marrying late. 
 He had had to make do with friends' children, many of whom were his godchildren. 
 He found them enormously relaxing to be with. 
 Like animals, they are great levellers &mdash; not remotely impressed by a string of titles &mdash; and he always found he could build up a good rapport with them. 
 Having his own was his greatest wish and transformed his life. 
 He went along to Diana's breathing classes to prepare for the birth and was there by her side in the private Lindo Wing at St Mary's Hospital in Paddington when William emerged after sixteen hours of labour. 
 It was the most exciting, extraordinary experience he had ever had, and for a long time afterwards he would bend any ear he could find on the subject. 
 Even at formal dinners where weighty matters were being bandied about, he would seek out other young fathers to swap stories with them about the thrill and magic of childbirth. 
 Both Charles and Diana were determined that their children were going to have normal, happy childhoods. 
 They were convinced there should be no long periods of separation. 
 Nannies were inevitable and, within their social set, also very much the norm; but the choice of Barbara Barnes to look after William was an indication that it was going to be a relaxed regime: she had no formal training, never wore a uniform and liked children to call her by her Christian name. 
 Most important of all, she had a healthy sense of humour. 
 There was no way that any nanny in the Wales household was going to become a substitute for either parent. 
 Charles became as adept at changing nappies and bathing William as Diana, and, even when he was small, both spent as much time as they could with him. 
 Thus when they flew up to Balmoral for the first time after his birth, the entire family travelled together, despite the merchants of doom who insisted they should  never fly together in the same plane lest it crash and kill both heir and second-in-line to the throne. 
 On landing, it was Charles who carried the baby-basket off the plane and the nanny carried the bags. 
 When they set off the following year on a tour of Australia and New Zealand, William, as well as two nannies and acres of baggage, went too. 
 Charles and Diana are both very fond of the Antipodes &mdash; Charles feels particularly at home there after his months at Timbertop &mdash; but it was a long and exhausting tour. 
 They were away from home for six weeks and in that time covered thousands of miles, made over forty flights, attended a multitude of receptions, galas and banquets and shook more hands in walkabouts than could ever be counted. 
 Once again, everyone wanted a glimpse of Diana, everyone wanted to touch her. 
 Being able to return to William in the evenings brought back a sense of reality and made a difference to the whole trip. 
 Parenthood affected Charles dramatically. 
 It focused his mind on the future and about the world that his small and fragile son would one day inherit. 
 It made him re-evaluate his philosophy, his life, and gave him a whole new perspective. 
 He entered, as he explained to me later, what Carl Jung would probably have described as &bquo;the middle period&equo;. 
 The press interpreted it as encroaching lunacy. 
 It began with a speech to the British Medical Association. 
 It was a glittering occasion, their 150th anniversary, and Charles was president. 
 Agonizing over what to say, he was suddenly struck by inspiration. 
 &bquo;The most extraordinary thing happened,&equo; he explained, &bquo;I was sitting here (at his desk in Kensington palace), and I happened to look at the bookshelf, and my eyes settled on a book about Paracelsus. 
 So I took the book down and there was my speech; and the response to it was extraordinary. 
 I've never had so many letters. 
 I've been a great believer in intuition ever since.&equo; 
 His speech dealt the BMA a devastating blow: 
 I have often thought that one of the less attractive traits of various professional bodies and institutions is the deeply ingrained suspicion and outright hostility which can exist towards anything unorthodox or unconventional. 
 Perhaps we just have to accept it is God's will that the unorthodox individual is  doomed to years of frustration, ridicule and failure in order to act out his role in the scheme of things, until his day arrives and mankind is ready to receive his message. 
 A protective Prince angrily telling photographers to leave his wife alone at a polo match 
 Leaving hospital with Prince William. 
 Charles was thrilled to be with Diana at the birth 
 I would suggest that the whole imposing edifice of modern medicine, for all its breathtaking successes is, like the celebrated Tower of Pisa, slightly off-balance. 
 It is frightening how dependent upon drugs we are all becoming and how easy it is for doctors to prescribe them as the universal panacea for our ills. 
 Wonderful as many of them are, it should still be more widely stressed by doctors that the health of human beings is so often determined by their behaviour, their food and the nature of their environment. 
 The speech sent shock waves through the medical profession, but the Prince had hit a nerve and, for all the criticism that was heaped on his head in the aftermath, the letters from the public told him he had been right. 
 Furthermore, it was spoken from the heart. 
 Charles believes in the Platonic ideal of a healthy mind in a healthy body, plenty of exercise, self-help and positive thinking. 
 He strongly believes that if there is a chance someone's suffering can be helped by an alternative method, then why not let them try it. 
 A year later another professional body, also celebrating its 150th anniversary, had its feet kicked from under it. 
 Charles had long been interested in architecture &mdash; he had grown up with beautiful buildings and visited hundreds more all over the world; he had read extensively on the subject and, by the very nature of the job, had seen a multitude of buildings, especially in the inner cities, that not only looked ghastly, but that people clearly found ghastly to live in.  
 Becoming pregnant so early in their marriage was a mixed blessing. 
 The Trooping of the Colour in June 1982 
 So, as the architects comfortably settled back into their chairs cradling their after-dinner brandies in preparation for some regal platitudes, the Prince launched into a stinging attack that left them reeling. 
 It was time they stopped designing buildings without a thought for the people who had to live in them, he said. 
 The proposed extension to the National Gallery looked like &bquo;a kind of vast municipal fire station &mdash; complete with the sort of tower that contains the siren. 
 I would better understand this type of &bquo;high-tech&equo; approach if you demolished the whole of Trafalgar Square and started again with a single architect responsible for the entire layout. 
 But what is proposed is like a monstrous carbuncle on the face of a much-loved and elegant friend. 
 &bquo;What have we done to our capital city? 
 What have we done to it since the bombing of the last war?&equo; 
 And of the proposed Mansion House Square project, he went on, &bquo;It would be a tragedy if the character and skyline of our capital city were to be further ruined and St Paul's dwarfed by yet another giant glass stump better suited to downtown Chicago than to the City of London.&equo; 
 Charles had savaged the soft underbelly of yet another hallowed institution and has not been forgiven to this day. 
 Once again, however, he discovered he had struck a chord with ordinary people, people who had felt they were unfit to pass judgement on modern buildings because they lacked the qualifications. 
 And although many architects still find it hard to say Charles's name without curling their lips, most of them do admit that by bringing the whole subject into the public domain, architecture has had a much-needed shot in the arm. 
 In 1984, however, they were admitting nothing. 
 They were furious, as Charles had known they would be. 
 He had not made the speech lightly, a considerable amount of thought and soul-searching had gone into it, and it was against the advice of most of his staff that he went ahead with it. 
 Community architecture had come about as a reaction to the tower blocks of the 1960s which were clearly not working: they had led to vandalism and mugging and terrifying isolation for the people who lived in them. 
 Charles had recently met a number of community  cities, made such perfect sense and was so inspirational that he felt compelled to bring it to a wider audience. 
 Arriving with Prince William in Alice Springs, Australia, at the beginning of a long tour in 1983 
 There was one more group dealt a glancing blow by the Prince around the same time: and this was Britain's farmers. 
 Lawrence Woodward, director of Elm Farm Research Centre, a small newly formed charity set up to research and develop organic agriculture, wrote to Prince Charles asking if he would speak at the first organic food conference to be held in Cirencester in January 1983. 
 Charles could not, but sent a message instead; not the tame few words that Woodward had drafted for him, but something much more forthright: 
 For some years now modern farming has made tremendous demands on the finite sources of energy which exist on earth. 
 Maximum production has been the slogan to which we have all adhered. 
 In the last few years there has been an increasing realization that many modern production methods are not only very wasteful but probably also unnecessary&hellip; 
 I am convinced that any steps that can be taken to explore methods of production which make better and more effective use of renewable resources are extremely important. 
 Even if it may be some time before they are commercially  acceptable, pioneer work is essential if our planet is to feed the teeming millions of people who will live on it by the twenty-first century. 
 A touch of tenderness at Newcastle Stadium, New South Wales 
 I shall be watching the practical results with interest to see what might be applicable to our work in the Duchy of Cornwall, for I am sure that there will be lessons that we can learn. 
 The conference had nothing like the coverage of either the British Medical Association or Royal Institute of British Architects festivities, so its impact on the public at the time was negligible; but it marked a significant turn in the Prince's own farming methods, brought environmental concerns slowly into consumer consciousness and in the long term dealt a devastating blow to the agrochemical industry. 
 The Duchy of Cornwall, where Charles had promised to apply the lessons of organic agriculture, is one of the largest estates in Britain, about 130,000 acres in all, of which the greater part is on Dartmoor. 
 The remainder is farmland, mostly in the West Country, plus forty-five acres in south London, including the Oval cricket ground. 
 The Prince inherited it upon becoming Prince of Wales and will lose it if and when he becomes King. 
 In the meantime, it is his only source of income and he has to pay for everything out of it, both his personal and official expenses, including the upkeep of his and Diana's homes, their household, their wardrobes, the children's schooling, the official cars, and the cost of entertaining. 
 He also pays 25 percent of that income to the Treasury in lieu of tax. 
 Neither he nor Diana receives a penny from the Civil List. 
 The only expense that is paid for is air transport, when they use aircraft of the Queen's flight, the Royal Train, and the Royal Yacht Britannia . 
 The title Duke of Cornwall and the estate to go with it dates back to 1337, when Edward III created it to give his eldest son, the Black Prince, an income and somewhere to live; it was he who decreed that it should always go to the eldest son. 
 So if there is no son, as during George VI's reign, it is held by the monarch. 
 When Charles came of age in 1969, the Duchy had been in abeyance for thirty-three years and was seriously rundown; much of it was yielding nothing. 
 Although administered by a council, which met three times a year to review policy, it had undergone none of the post-war modernization and investment that had rescued the rest of the farming industry from the crippling effects of war. 
 No one seemed to have realized that Charles would need an income when he came of age. 
 Land stewards had become autonomous, farm buildings had fallen into disuse, land had been poorly managed, properties had been allowed to run down and rents had gone unreviewed. 
 If the Prince was going to be able to live off it when he finished his naval career and support the wife that everyone seemed so desperate for him to acquire, something radical had to be done. 
 So in 1972 a new secretary was appointed for the task, Anthony Gray, who worked away for some years and helped set it on its feet again. 
 Once he came out of the Navy, Charles became a little more involved, but it was not really until the end of the decade, after Mountbatten's death, when he was looking for a real job to do, that Charles took up the reins himself. 
 In so doing he found  another character, John Higgs, who became central to his development. 
 Charles and John Higgs clicked, and it was largely thanks to the relationship struck up with him, and the sheer personality of the man, that Charles became wholly and genuinely enthused by every aspect of the Duchy. 
 Charles had said he wanted a practical farmer on the council who knew something about estate management, and John Higgs was the man found for the job. 
 He had been the estate bursar at Oxford, and there was little about farming, estate management, rural development and conservation that John Higgs did not know. 
 He was a grey-haired dynamo of a man, bursting with ideas and good humour, who was not afraid to speak his mind to the Prince of Wales. 
 When Tony Gray retired in 1981, 
 Higgs became secretary. 
 Charles had known next to nothing about farming. 
 The Queen has a large farm at Windsor, which the Duke of Edinburgh manages, and another at Sandringham; and she herself is very knowledgeable about livestock and pedigrees, as is the Queen Mother. 
 But Charles knew very little and nothing at all about management, business and finance. 
 His education had not prepared him for this in any way. 
 John Higgs gave him a crash course. 
 He inspired the Prince, worked alongside him, coached him in the ways of business, schooled him in the art of responsible land management, encouraged him to try out new ideas, and helped turn the Duchy from a non-profit making concern into one that five years later had made net profits of &pound;1.46 million.  
 With a wife and child to support Charles needed to make the Duchy profitable. 
 The family in Auckland, New Zealand, in 1983 
 HIGHGROVE 
 Having set the Duchy on the road to providing an income for the Prince of Wales, the next task had been to find him a house and, of all those short-listed in the summer of 1980, Charles chose Highgrove. 
 He had specifically wanted somewhere with a farm and Highgrove had 410 acres; also, to be within easy range of his friends and relatives, and again it fitted the bill. 
 It was a few miles outside the pretty market town of Tetbury in Gloucestershire; two hours from London down the M4 motorway, with easy access to Wales and the West Country; close to Princess Anne's house, Gatcombe Park; his friends, the ParkerBowles; and not far from Windsor. 
 It was also not far from Cirencester Park, Cowdray Park and Smith's Lawn for polo. 
 What is more, it was in the midst of Beaufort Hunt country and the Prince was hunting two or three times a week during the season. 
 What it was not, however, was either very large or very grand. 
 It had been previously owned by Maurice Macmillan MP, son of the late Conservative Prime Minister Lord Stockton, and the Duchy paid over three-quarters of a million pounds for the property. 
 From the security point of view it was uncomfortably close to the road, and had a public footpath (which has since been re-routed) running across the garden, no more than two or three hundred yards from the house, but the Prince liked it. 
 He especially liked the old and rare trees that had been planted in the garden by a previous owner, Colonel Mitchell, who bought the house in 1893. 
 He was a great expert, founder of the arboretum at Westonbirt nearby, and he filled every vista with a dazzling display of ornamental and specimen trees, which the Prince has since added to. 
 Owning a home of his own was a huge pleasure, but greater still was the pleasure of having a garden of his own. 
 All the royal residences have magnificent gardens and he had grown up appreciating them, but they are tended by gardeners: neither the Queen nor the Duke of Edinburgh is interested. 
 The gardener of the family is the Queen Mother, whose gardens at her Scottish hideaways, the Castle of Mey and Birkhall, are stunning, and it is she who over the years has made them so. 
 So Charles had the will but not the way and called on his friend Lady Salisbury to help. 
 Mollie Salisbury had designed several gardens for friends, as well as her own at  Hatfield House in Hertfordshire, and she was only too delighted to help plan a garden from scratch. 
 When Charles moved in to Highgrove there was practically no garden at all, just acres of lawn and some box hedges. 
 There was also a walled kitchen garden, which had been let go to grass, and a large hole had been knocked into one of the walls to let the tractor in to mow it. 
 With Mollie Salisbury's help, Charles designed his entire garden, and furthermore, with the assistance of just one gardener, he dug it, manured it and planted it too. 
 He discovered in the weeks and months that passed a real passion; a task that was not only deeply therapeutic, but one that he also found he could do rather well. 
 Lady Salisbury describes him as &bquo;a natural plantsman&equo;. 
 What Charles also wanted now he had a garden of his own was wild flowers. 
 The greatest wild-flower expert in this country is Dr Miriam Rothschild, who had known Charles since he was a child, and was also a friend of Mollie Salisbury. 
 She ran the Royal Society for Nature Conservation, founded by her father in 1912, of which the Prince is patron. 
 In conjunction with her passion for insects and butterflies, on which she is a leading authority, she had a scheme underway to reintroduce wild flowers to the countryside. 
 She still travels the world, tirelessly delivering papers at scientific gatherings and converting anyone she comes across on the way. 
 Charles was one such, and he invited her to Highgrove to work her magic. 
 She is no romantic. 
 Although she enjoys the aesthetic value of wild flowers, her reason for encouraging their widespread growth is principally scientific. 
 A vast range of plants are used in medical preparations and as research continues new species are found to have beneficial properties. 
 If a species is allowed to become extinct, however insignificant it may have appeared to be, that is one potential medication lost to mankind for ever. 
 At that time it was the idea of looking out over fields of swaying poppies and cornflowers that appealed to the Prince. 
 On a strip of land between the house and the kitchen garden over ninety species of wild flower now grow. 
 More grow alongside the drive and are a lasting pleasure to him. 
 The garden was and still is his paradise and his pride and joy, and whenever Charles has the time he will put on a pair of old trousers, find a spade and get down to some real manual labour. 
 He now has two gardeners working full time: Dennis, a grand old boy who has scarcely been out of Gloucestershire in his life &mdash; and has been looking after foxhounds for the Duke of Beaufort for most of it; and Trevor Jacobs, a younger and professionally qualified horticulturist. 
 Dennis presides over the walled garden, which supplies the kitchens at Highgrove and Kensington Palace and grows all the weird and wonderful varieties that the Prince acquires and delights in surprising his guests with. 
 He had ten varieties of carrot in the ground when I visited, including a purple carrot that has not been grown since the eighteenth century. 
 The entire garden is organic; and any new idea that the Prince picks up in his travels, he immediately tries out at home. 
 The walled garden is divided by stone-chip paths with neat low box hedges, and there are flowers and  herbs growing alongside the vegetables. 
 In the middle there is a little pond with a fountain, and the golden carp that swim in it are so tame that they come at the sound of Dennis's voice. 
 Dennis also looks after the fruit cage and the greenhouse, where he grows scented plants for the house, like stephanotis and jasmine. 
 He works from dawn to dusk and then, for recreation, goes home to his little cottage in the grounds and tends his own little garden, growing prize specimens for the local show. 
 William and Harry have a tree house to play in in the woods at Highgrove 
 Trevor takes care of the rest of the garden, plants up the giant tubs that sit outside the house, helps the Prince plan new features and site new trees and additional flower beds. 
 He also weeds the existing beds, prunes the roses and, as well as all the other seasonal jobs, cuts the lawns and hedges. 
 There are dozens of hedges, which the Prince is growing in order to create topiary; there is also an avenue of trimmed and rounded golden yew trees leading the eye, in classic style, to a folly at the foot of the park. 
 It is an exciting garden, the hedges and paths divide it so that you come upon different parts almost by surprise, such as the scented garden, the woodland garden, built around some of the trees that Colonel Mitchell left behind him, with a sturdy wooden tree-house for the children, and the patio garden where the Prince sits and does paperwork during the summer months to the soothing sound of water, which springs from a sculpture he commissioned of stone whales. 
 The folly was a gift from the Sultan of Oman, just one of the many presents that now adorn the property. 
 The giant wrought-iron entrance gates, for example, came  from the people of Tetbury, the fruit trees espaliered against the walls of the vegetable garden were presented by the Worshipful Company of Fruiterers and the herbs came from a women's institute in Sussex. 
 The small heated swimming pool hidden from view near the rose walk was a wedding gift from the Army. 
 In the gardens of Kensington Palace; but Charles was happiest in the gardens of Highgrove 
 The whole estate is a reflection of the Prince's philosophy about the countryside. 
 He has built a new cowshed in the last year, and it is of brick and Cotswold stone &mdash; in keeping with the existing buildings. 
 The dry-stone walls have been repaired in the traditional way; fences in the fields to keep the animals back are wooden post-and-rail, there is no barbed-wire to be seen; and where the Prince has planted new trees in the parkland, they are all protected from the livestock by solid wooden guards, not the plastic sort most farmers use. 
 Sheep graze within view of the house and also a herd of Aberdeen Angus, and a number of horses, some with foals. 
 To complete the idyllic farmyard scene, chickens, a mixture of varieties, strut and scratch about the driveway and the fields. 
 Charles was keen to use his estate at Highgrove as an example for the rest of the Duchy. 
 In bringing it up to date and making it profitable, he had to tread warily, for although it was made up of land and property, it was essentially about people. 
 Rents needed to be brought up to a realistic level, housing stock modernized, particularly in some of the rundown areas of Kennington, and surplus sold off, without souring relations with his tenants. 
 So he began to involve them in some of the decisionmaking about how their environment might be improved, their needs met. 
 He called meetings to solicit their views and thus began his own experiments with what was effectively community architecture. 
 On the rural side he had 180 tenant farmers, each with between 50 and 130 acres apiece; and just as the Prince wanted the goodwill of his urban tenants, so too in the country. 
 So he and John Higgs made frequent forays into the countryside giving farmers no more than twelve hours' notice of the intended visit. 
 Higgs insisted on this so their wives would not be caught in curlers; but the idea was that Charles should see the farms and the farmers as they really were, not spruced up and on parade. 
 Charles wanted the farmers to talk frankly to him so he could learn about their lives and problems, and put what he learnt to good effect. 
 A frank talk was a help, but it was no substitute for knowing what it was like to have to milk cows at the crack of dawn every morning or mend fences, or battle with the elements, and so he began a series of annual stays on Duchy farms. 
 He spent a week working alongside the farmer, mucking out cattle yards, feeding pigs, dipping sheep; and living as a guest in his house. 
 Charles thoroughly enjoyed the experience and it was a rare opportunity to see how ordinary people lived. 
 The media, once again, saw it as further indication of encroaching madness. 
 The Prince feels he has a responsibility as a landowner to set an example to others, always to take the humane or the conservationist route above the straight commercial. 
 Early on, working in tandem with John Higgs, he had brought in the Farming and Wildlife Advisory Group and the Nature Conservancy Council to look at all the  farms on the estate to make sure they were farming with conservation in mind. 
 His preoccupation with conservation has grown over the years, but even then it was nothing new. 
 It was a subject Charles had been actively concerned about for most of his adult life. 
 It had even been the topic of his first public speech in 1968. 
 He had grown up with a love of the countryside. 
 The Royal family are country people, their interests and off-duty activities are all to do with the countryside, and the Prince always had a good knowledge of its workings; but it was not until after he became chairman of the steering committee for Wales that he discovered the danger it was in. 
 He said: 
 We are faced at the moment with the horrifying effects of pollution in all its cancerous forms. 
 There is the growing menace of oil pollution at sea, which almost destroys beaches and certainly destroys tens of thousands of seabirds. 
 There is chemical pollution discharged into rivers from factories and chemical plants, which clogs up the rivers with toxic substances and adds to the filth in the seas. 
 There is air pollution from smoke and fumes discharged by factories and from gases pumped out by endless cars and aeroplanes. 
 Waste is yet another problem. 
 When you think that each person produces roughly 21 lbs of rubbish per day and there are 55 million of us on this island using non-returnable bottles and indestructible plastic containers, it is not difficult to imagine the mountains of refuse that we shall have to deal with somehow. 
 The speech might have been delivered last week. 
 In fact, it was twenty-one years ago, in February 1970. 
 Even more prophetic words were to follow: 
 The list is longer, but what I am getting at is that it is going to be extremely expensive to cut down this pollution. 
 In the end it will be the general public, as consumers, who will have to pay. 
 Are we all prepared to accept these price increases for the sometimes dubious advantage of seeing our environment improved? 
 Are we prepared to discipline ourselves to restrictions and regulations that we feel we ought to impose for our own good? 
 If we are not, then this meeting and the whole of Conservation Year will have been a gigantic, costly and splendid waste of time. 
 Twenty-one years ago there were very few people who shared the Prince's point of view. 
 Those who did were mostly long-haired, bearded and dressed in open-toed sandals. 
 Even in the early 1980s, the press saw his adherence to the theme as one more idea to mock. 
 Charles, however, was determined to use the farm at Highgrove as a model to put his ideas into practice. 
 After delivering his message of support to the organic movement at Cirencester, he held a seminar at Kensington Palace to air the issues, and he and John Higgs subsequently went down to Elm Farm to investigate the possibilities of employing organic methods on the home farm. 
 The basic philosophy involves farming as far as possible within a closed system: in a nutshell, growing crops to feed  the animals and using the manure those animals produce to fertilize the soil in order to grow more crops. 
 The use of soluble chemical fertilizers is banned, as are hormone stimulants. 
 The animals must be reared in humane conditions, which means that intensive operations &mdash; like battery henhouses or veal units &mdash; are forbidden. 
 Modern farmers now endeavour to dominate nature by using chemicals that ensure growth. 
 The organic farmer works with nature, recognizing the intricate and holistic properties of agriculture, so that growth is encouraged and problems averted not by introducing an outside agent, but by structuring and adapting the system. 
 This philosophy appealed to Prince Charles and he was keen to give it a go, but, like everything else in the Duchy, the home farm had to pay its way. 
 John Higgs had reservations. 
 He felt a lot of hot air was talked by some of the purists. 
 Nevertheless, he agreed to visit West Germany on the Prince's behalf, where the movement was far more advanced, and report back. 
 He returned after a very jolly trip, with a ten-pound carrot and a giant pumpkin, which he sent to Prince Charles. 
 &bquo;We found as much wind in Germany,&equo; said the memo attached, &bquo;as there is in this pumpkin.&equo; 
 Wind notwithstanding, Charles decided to go ahead and experiment, initially on an eighty-acre block of land at Highgrove; this has proved so successful that, by the end of 1991, all the arable land on the farm will be up to organic farming standards. 
 John Higgs, alas, did not live to see it. 
 He died after a very short and sudden illness in June 1986. 
 Charles was shocked. 
 He had lost another close companion, another friend, one who had helped and guided him and given him such pleasure. 
 Before his death the Prince knighted John Higgs, and went specially to St Thomas's Hospital to perform the investiture at his bedside. 
 THE CHARITABLE PRINCESS 
 A myth abounds that women just need to be told they are going to meet the Princess of Wales and they go into labour. 
 It no doubt helps if they are already pregnant; but the notion is not as fanciful as it sounds. 
 In July 1984 the Princess had agreed to become patron of a small medical research charity called Birthright, which had been set up initially to try and minimize the dangers of pregnancy and childbirth. 
 Diana's first visit in her new role was to open a new research centre at King's College Hospital, which dealt with the problems of high-risk babies; this had been funded by Birthright. 
 It was the first centre of its kind, and was offering treatment to women who had suffered problems with previous pregnancies &mdash; women who had had handicapped babies, for example, or stillbirths. 
 The Princess had said she particularly wanted to meet mothers who had had a treatment known as chorionic villus biopsy, which was a very exciting breakthrough. 
 It is a means of discovering at just eight weeks of pregnancy whether the foetus is normal. 
 Birthright had funded its development in Britain, and this was its introduction at King's College Hospital. 
 The charity's national organizer, Vivienne Parry, set about finding some mothers-to-be to meet the Princess; but as fast as she found them, they went into labour. 
 This happened with no less than eight. 
 On the morning of the visit, her final hope, a woman whose baby was due the following day, rang Vivienne to say she was getting pains. 
 &bquo;Well, cross your legs,&equo; said Vivienne, now desperate, &bquo;and get down here right away.&equo; 
 The woman did as she was told, met the Princess, and went into labour in the car on the way home. 
 This mother was a perfect example for the Princess to meet. 
 Her first baby had been born with a genetic disease and had died, but the disease had not been diagnosed until she was pregnant with her second child. 
 Fortunately, it was born healthy. 
 When she became pregnant for the third time she was given an amniocentesis, the only form of testing available at that time. 
 It meant she didn't know whether the foetus carried the disease until she was twenty-one weeks pregnant, by which time abortion is very difficult both physically and emotionally. 
 The new treatment had meant that this woman was able to establish that her fourth baby was healthy when she was only ten weeks and two days into her pregnancy.  
 September 1985. 
 Childbirth was no less magical the second time around with Prince Harry 
 It was a triumph of modern science, and the new patron could not have been more impressed &mdash; although being seven months pregnant herself she was a little bit squeamish at the sight of the giant ten-inch needles used in the procedure. 
 Whether Diana's interest in Birthright was planted by her obstetrician George Pinker, who was then its president, or by several of her friends who have had problems and become involved, her decision to add Birthright to her list of patronages marked a turning point in its history. 
 In 1984 Birthright had an income of &pound;600,000, and very few people had heard of it. 
 The research it funded all took place in laboratories inside hospitals and there was nothing tangible to show for it. 
 Diana opened the first research centre that treated patients. 
 She went on to open more and more all over the country. 
 She met &bquo;miracle&equo; babies and, at the less glamorous end of the scale, opened a cervical-cancer unit. 
 In fact, it was the extra revenue she brought in at the baby end that enabled the charity to open up units for cervical cancer, and fund other research into unappealing but equally vital conditions. 
 Through her involvement, Birthright has leapt from being a fringe charity into a major one. 
 Its income is now &pound;1,500,000 a year and rising fast. 
 Nothing could give the Princess more satisfaction. 
 Her preference is for small charities where she feels she can do some good, and where she has some natural interest. 
 The British Deaf Association (BDA) was another such charity. 
 This had  been one of the 150 organizations that had written asking for patronage when Diana became engaged, and had been turned down. 
 Then, quite out of the blue at the end of 1983, they had a letter from the Palace saying that the Princess had decided she would like to be their patron. 
 It was no coincidence, perhaps, that its president was the Marquess of Salisbury, married to Mollie Salisbury who had spent so much time helping with the garden at Highgrove. 
 The Princess has a curious effect on pregnant women. 
 Diana visiting the Birthright unit at St Mary's Hospital, London 
 So Diana was among friends, but she was still enormously nervous on her first visit to the BDA headquarters in Carlisle. 
 This was the beginning of her determination to learn sign language, which has been more of a boost to the deaf community over the years than any other gesture. 
 Liz Scott-Gibson, who is now director of sign language services for the BDA, subsequently went to Kensington Palace to teach the Princess; and on a later visit, to a school in Durham, Diana surprised everyone by being able to communicate to the deaf people she met without an interpreter. 
 Ever since, she has been delighting deaf people she encounters by communicating in their own language. 
 Dr Barnardo's was another charity she took on at about the same time; this charity has left its old orphanage image behind, and the Princess feels her connections with it have been fruitful. 
 As with all her involvements, though, it was a gradual process. 
 Diana was still the new girl in those days, very much learning as she went along, shy and unsure of herself, and leaning heavily on others for support and guidance. 
 But Diana's impact on fund-raising was evident from the start. 
 She only had to shake a hand to increase the revenue and bring more publicity to the organization than any amount of money could buy. 
 Her presence was enough to make front-page news. 
 This was also true, of course, of the Prince. 
 He may not have attracted the cameras in quite the way the Princess did, but he certainly brought recognition and respectability to every company or organization whose threshold he crossed. 
 The prestige  they reaped from a visit was incalculable. 
 This was one aspect of his life that Charles found hard to come to terms with, especially during this period when he was evaluating and reassessing his role in life. 
 For someone with his intellect, his was an intensely frustrating position. 
 He was famous, people flocked to catch a glimpse of him, they stood for hours in the freezing cold in the hope that he would choose their hand to shake &mdash; for no better reason than an accident of birth. 
 Charles constantly felt he had done nothing to earn it; there was no feeling of satisfaction in a job well done. 
 He had not won an election, sung an aria, or even built up a business empire. 
 Diana immediately wanted to learn sign language after her first visit to a school for the deaf 
 He was famous simply because he happened to be the Prince of Wales; and in his darker moments he felt that charities and organizations only wanted him because of his name. 
 The most useful contribution he could make was to turn up on the right day in the right uniform, cut ribbons, and make cosy speeches. 
 When he did try to make some real contribution to society, it seemed that all he got for his trouble was The Prince was too sensitive, too intelligent, to play the part mapped out for him, the part that his courtiers were there to help maintain. 
 He longed to do some real work that would give him some satisfaction at the end of a day, yet there seemed to be nothing for him to do. 
 He began to question the ethics of his whole position. 
 His was one of the richest families in the world. 
 He knew nothing but privilege. 
 He lived in beautiful houses, travelled the world in the greatest of comfort, and wanted for nothing. 
 This is how monarchs and their families have lived for generations, without ever questioning that it should be so. 
 Charles was undergoing serious doubt. 
 His Prince's Trust brought him into contact with the real world. 
 He repeatedly met people whose lives were desperate. 
 Their living conditions were grim, their education was minimal, and their prospects for the future were bleak. 
 It was not just the inner cities. 
 There were no jobs for young people in rural areas; rising property prices meant that they were unable to find housing in the villages in which they had grown up. 
 The problems did not stop there. 
 During 1981 the Prince had been patron of the International Year of Disabled People, and met yet another vast group of people who suffered enormous hardship and prejudice, and whom society did not seem to care about. 
 While grain mountains grew in the West, millions of people in the Sudan were dying of starvation. 
 Practically nothing had been done for the environment since 1970; people had simply built more cars, more roads, more factories, and thrown ever-increasing tons of chemicals on to the land. 
 It had turned out to be exactly as Charles had forecast, &bquo;a gigantic, costly and splendid waste of time&equo;. 
 There was so much to do; there were people out there whom the system was failing; there was a world that was being poisoned. 
 But what could he do about it? 
 He felt impotent, uncertain about what he should be doing, what was expected of him. 
 With the exception of Michael Colborne, everyone within the palace was telling Charles that he should not be getting involved. 
 Adeane had strongly advised against the controversial speeches of the past year, especially the one to the architectural profession. 
 He disapproved of the Prince's involvement in Operation Raleigh; he  even felt that Charles's youth and inner-city work was politically border-line and unwise. 
 Adeane counselled against it all, and was backed by the Duke of Edinburgh. 
 Colborne was pulling the other way: he said there was a social revolution going on outside the palace gates; he believed young people needed leadership as they never had needed it before, and the Prince was the one who could lead them. 
 Uncertain which route to take, and lacking the confidence to follow his instincts, the Prince turned in on himself. 
 He retreated to Highgrove and took out some of his frustration on the soil and the polo field. 
 At other times he revelled in the distraction of his children. 
 &bquo;Have a good weekend, sir,&equo; said Harold Haywood, secretary of the Prince's Trust, one Friday night. 
 &bquo;Well, I was hoping to do some digging,&equo; said the Prince, &bquo;but it's so hard that I can't get the spade in. 
 So I expect I'll be nappy changing instead.&equo; 
 Nappy changing it was, his detective confirmed, while the nanny had the weekend off. 
 There was a new baby in the house by this time. 
 On 15 September 1984 Charles was once again by Diana's side at St Mary's Hospital when Prince Harry came into the world. 
 The magic was every bit as exciting the second time around as it had been with William. 
 Charles was fiercely proud of his wife and son, and felt that if there was any point to life at all, this was it. 
 This was another bone of contention with Adeane. 
 As a bachelor, Adeane had no concept of the intense pleasure fatherhood had brought the Prince, and no understanding of why he should want to spend so much time at home. 
 It seemed that when the Prince was not at home, he was playing polo. 
 Adeane's function as private secretary appeared to be little more than the job of arranging the Prince's schedule around polo and the children's bath times. 
 The press had noticed too. 
 They had calculated that in one particular three-month period Charles had had fifteen engagements, Princess Anne had carried out fifty-six, Prince Philip, forty-five, and the Queen, twenty-eight. 
 The tabloids were calling Charles work-shy and lazy, and the Duke of Edinburgh told him to pull his socks up. 
 Colborne conceded that he was fighting a losing battle; a battle against the entire social structure within the palace and the snobbery and jealousy of the Old Guard that surrounded the Prince. 
 Colborne's departure was a shock to Charles. 
 He was the one person within his household who had told him the truth; he had been his eyes and ears in the community, voiced the opinions of the man in the street. 
 At times he had been his conscience too &mdash; when the Prince had lost his temper or been rude to someone, Colborne would write him a note and tell him so. 
 He was devoted to the Prince, but he had served him for ten years and his wife had scarcely seen him. 
 He was now fifty, and he felt she deserved more from her marriage. 
 He left just a few days before Christmas in 1984. 
 Less of a surprise was Edward Adeane's departure the very next day. 
 Charles summoned Adeane, they had yet another blazing row, and Adeane returned to the more predictable workings of the Bar. 
 He had been an excellent courtier of the very  best tradition. 
 His misfortune was that Charles was not a traditional Prince of Wales. 
 It was not only his staff who found Charles difficult during this period. 
 He is a man whose emotions are close to the surface, and who plunges into profound troughs. 
 Although the arrival of Harry was a break in the gloom, the Prince was a prickly man to live with. 
 He was tortured and temperamental and hugely demanding of everyone around him. 
 Diana was sympathetic, but did not fully understand his unrest, nor his frantic soul-searching. 
 She was twenty-three and simply too young to comprehend the feelings of middle age &mdash; let alone those of a middle-aged Prince . 
 Besides, she was very wrapped up in a world of her own. 
 She had two delicious babies, she was a Princess, a star, and the world was her oyster. 
 She was having a ball. 
 Admittedly, there were times for her when it all became too much, when the intrusion and the invasion were a strain. 
 But there was a flip side to the coin. 
 When she was dressed and made up and prepared for it, she enjoyed the attention, she enjoyed being photographed, and she found the sight of her face on the covers of magazines and newspapers enormously exciting. 
 She loved wearing beautiful clothes and priceless jewels, and was thrilled to meet her favourite pop stars and actors, go to rock concerts, ballets, operas and glittering film premi&eacute;res. 
 It was exciting to travel by private plane and helicopter with courtiers standing to attention, to be driven in a limousine the size of a small house, and to stay in palaces and castles in the lap of luxury. 
 It was a far cry from life at Coleherne Court, where there was no one but herself to do the washing, ironing and vacuuming. 
 Sometimes she had to pinch herself to make sure it was not all a dream. 
 Diana had been very young when she married Charles, and not just in years. 
 She had seen none of this glamorous life; she had seldom even been to smart restaurants, let alone banquets and star-studded receptions. 
 Despite her wealth and connections, her life had been quietly sheltered. 
 She knew nothing of the drugs or drop-out culture of her generation. 
 She dressed in clothes that her mother bought her, such as tartan skirts and matching jumpers, and seldom wore  make-up. 
 Hardly a head would turn if she walked into a room. 
 She watched television, listened to music, and dreamed about favourite pop stars &mdash; just like any normal teenager. 
 Diana loves dressing up, wearing priceless jewels, and going to film premi&eacute;res 
 In the first four years of her marriage that life had been turned on its head, transformed out of all recognition. 
 She was famous the world over, in a way that no member of the Royal Family, not even any Hollywood legend, had ever been. 
 People flocked in their thousands to see her, they hung on her every word, watched her every move on television. 
 In the same space of time she had married, embarked on a new and totally alien job, had a baby, celebrated her twenty-first birthday, and then had a second child &mdash; all momentous events in anyone's life, without the other pressures she was having to cope with. 
 They had been very heady years. 
 Much as she might have wanted to help, Diana was in no position to give Charles the attention he needed. 
 In many respects she found him an enigma. 
 She understood his need for sport, because she too enjoyed exercise; what she did not understand was his need to punish himself with such dangerous activities. 
 In the summer months it was polo, which he played unremittingly three or four times a week. 
 In winter he put his polo ponies out to grass at Highgrove, and got his hunters into peak condition. 
 Again, three or four times a week he would push himself to the limit, galloping across the countryside with the hounds, risking life and limb in another of the most physically exacting sports known to man. 
 At other times he craved solitude and took himself off to Balmoral to fish, paint and stalk deer. 
 Diana found his obsessions puzzling, and not a little hurtful. 
 She could not understand why he should want to spend so much time away from home and his family.  
 Charles played polo unremittingly three or four times a week. 
 Diana found his obsession hard to understand 
 DIFFERING INTERESTS 
 The Prince's behaviour was no reflection on Diana or their children. 
 In those difficult months and years Charles was unaware of anyone but himself. 
 He had reached a crossroads in his life. 
 He had lost many of the people who mattered to him, and he was unsure of himself and his abilities. 
 He knew he had a duty, but a duty to do what? 
 To open buildings and preserve the royal status quo? 
 Or to try and improve the lives of the people who would one day be his subjects? 
 Diana had married no ordinary man. 
 Charles had never been carefree, never been allowed to be childish or make mistakes like his peers, never had friends to call on and pour his heart out to. 
 His had been an isolated and lonely existence, despite the people perpetually at his side. 
 He would never be able to settle down to married life like a suburban husband. 
 He was a man apart, a man desperate to be of some use, driven to understand the purpose of life and his role within it. 
 Charles enjoyed the time he spent with his wife and children, but the events of the last four years had been no less momentous for him, and his way of coping with the stress and tensions in his life had always been by testing himself physically. 
 He is not a natural extrovert; leadership was thrust on him from a very early age. 
 The trials of his childhood and teenage years turned him into the perfect Prince, but they did not alter his fundamental nature. 
 public speaking is something he enjoys today, but it was a gruelling experience in the early days, as were walkabouts. 
 City life, even in the environs of Kensington Palace, is a trial to the Prince; he feels suffocated by London and longs to escape to the country and be at one with nature. 
 Polo is the Prince's game because it was his father's game and also Mountbatten's; and it is the ultimate test. 
 &bquo;I am one of those people&equo;, he has said in the past,&equo; who must take exercise not only to be able to give of my best, but just to survive &mdash; I mean, I can't function without it. 
 If I can have a game of polo I feel five hundred times better in my mental outlook. 
 But without some form of exercise I'm afraid to say I get terribly jaded and &mdash; well, not depressed, but below par.&equo; 
 Polo requires tremendous fitness, and 100 per cent concentration. 
 It is a dangerous game, as he discovered yet again in the summer of 1990. 
 But the Prince has always enjoyed flirting with danger, like his cousin, Prince William of Gloucester, who was killed in a plane crash in 1972. 
 Charles had pushed himself to the limit in the armed  forces and had insisted upon doing the full training that his fellow officers did &mdash; despite protests from his superiors. 
 He had done the Royal Marines commando training, he had insisted on parachute jumping and escaping from a tank in 100 feet of water in a simulated exercise &mdash; an exercise that killed two men over the next two years. 
 Sometimes his superiors did put their foot down. 
 There were a few exercises they forbade, and would never let the Prince pilot supersonic Buccaneers or the Sea King anti-submarine helicopters; but he did qualify for membership of the exclusive Ten Ton Club, by flying at more than 1,000 m.p.h. in a phantom scrambled from Leuchars in Fife, which he had taken over Balmoral before going supersonic off the coast of Scotland. 
 Unknown to most people, he had also driven a Formula Two racing car belonging to world-champion racing driver Graham Hill around the track at Thruxton &mdash; and come perilously close to disaster. 
 He had lost control on the wet surface and spun right off the track. 
 For the Prince it was the beginning of a love affair. 
 In a gondola in Venice, April 1985 
 But these were the things that made life worth living. 
 Charles hated the feeling that he was being wrapped in cotton wool; he felt cheated when he was not allowed to do what other men did. 
 If he could confront physical danger and win he could go to bed feeling that he had achieved something with his day. 
 Horse riding was his route to this feeling. 
 It was &bquo;the sport of kings&equo; after all, and however dangerous, Charles was determined that no one was going to take that pleasure away from him. 
 His other necessity in life was solitude. 
 He had needed it ever since he was a child. 
 Even as a schoolboy he had taken himself away from the crowd for long lonely  walks, and sat in the silence of the small chapel in the grounds at Gordonstoun. 
 Of all the community services on offer, he had chosen the coastguards, which involved nights spent quietly in a hut on the cliff tops watching for shipping; and the hardest part of all the trials he endured in the Navy was being marooned on a ship for months on end with no opportunity to be alone. 
 Charles would never be able to settle down to married life like a suburban husband. 
 On the Royal Yacht Britannia in 1985 
 The Prince is no hermit. 
 He enjoys the company of others, likes nothing better than a good dinner surrounded by friends, and large noisy get-togethers with his family. 
 His interest in people in the street is very genuine too. 
 He wants to know how they live, how they think. 
 Many are the times he has held up busy working schedules because he has become fascinated by someone he has encountered in a crowd. 
 Polo is a team game, hunting is a gregarious activity, and he uses it as such. 
 He chats to people in the field, remembers faces, and will pick up on topics discussed in a previous conversation. 
 He actively seeks out company at times, but on other occasions he needs to be completely alone. 
 To take stock, to recharge his batteries, and there is no place on earth he would rather do it than in the Highlands of Scotland. 
 He is surrounded there by everything he loves; he can walk for mile upon mile and meet nothing more taxing than the occasional sheep; he can fish one of the best salmon rivers in Britain; he can stalk deer, a sport he finds fascinating as well as challenging; and he can paint. 
 Charles took up watercolour painting nearly twenty years ago, and it has become one of his greatest pleasures. 
 &bquo;The great thing about painting&equo;, he says, &bquo;is that it is your own individual interpretation of whatever view you have chosen. 
 Because it obliges you to sit down and make a careful observation of the chosen subject, you discover so much more than by just pointing a camera. 
 As a result, you become increasingly more aware of the quality of light and shade, of tone and texture and of the shape of buildings. 
 In short, it has revolutionized my life and, through the requirement of intense concentration, it is one of the most relaxing and therapeutic exercises I know.&equo; 
 The Prince is genuinely modest about his artistic talent, perpetually apologizes for his amateurishness and longs to be more skilled; and, as with most things, he finds he  becomes much better with daily practice. 
 Balmoral is one place where he can do that. 
 &equo; If I have a game of polo I feel five hundred times better in my mental outlook.&equo; 
 Diana with Charles at a polo match in Melbourne in 1985 
 The Prince's other favourite place to paint, and indeed to be, is Italy, which, for all his travels, he had never visited until the spring of 1985. 
 It was a visit filled with promise and excitement, and one that he and the Princess obviously enjoyed. 
 They were going to the home of opera, to listen to some Verdi, Puccini and Donizetti; and to see at first hand the fine art and architecture that he had studied and only previously heard about or seen in books. 
 They were to look at the sculpture of Michelangelo, and the frescoes on the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel. 
 Charles had longed to visit the Basilica in Rome, to see Venice in all its glory; to walk across the Ponte Vecchio in Florence, virtually unchanged since the sixteenth century, and to visit the villages in the Tuscan hills, intact after hundreds of years. 
 He had heard so much about it from the Queen Mother &mdash; who as a child had been there every year &mdash; and from so many other people that he had felt it was a part of his education that was sorely lacking. 
 The high spot of the tour, however, was to be an audience with the Pope. 
 Charles had planned to take part in a private Mass with the Pope, but was forbidden at the last moment after strong protest to the government from the Church of England hierarchy. 
 It was an official state visit, so he and the Princess were ruled by the Foreign Office and, in this case, overruled. 
 Charles was intensely angry and upset. 
 He has a deep religious conviction, which tends towards the ecumenical, and this would have been a perfect expression of his beliefs and also a personal and rewarding spiritual experience. 
 It was not to be. 
 Instead, they had a forty-five-minute audience, which Diana was extremely nervous about &mdash; more so than at any meeting  with any leader before or since. 
 However, it turned out to be a very relaxed meeting, so much so that when the private session was over and the press were invited in to take photographs, the Prince said to the Pope, &bquo;Let me introduce you to my press corps.&equo; 
 From Rome they flew down to join Britannia  in Sicily for the remainder of the tour, where the Prince's artist friend John Ward was waiting. 
 &bquo;If my grandmother can take Sir Hugh Casson to Venice,&equo; he had said some months before, &bquo;can I take you?&equo; 
 Charles and Diana had a very relaxed audience with the Pope on their Italian visit 
 Charles had met Ward several years before, and, as well as seeking his advice as a teacher, had commissioned several paintings from him. 
 Shortly before the wedding Edward Adeane, Charles's private secretary, had been in a dining club with the artist; he pushed a packet of cigarettes across the table towards him. 
 Written on the back were the words, &bquo;My boss wants you to draw his wedding&equo;. 
 Not long afterwards came another request, this time in a slightly more orthodox fashion, for John Ward to paint the Princess. 
 He has since painted Prince William's christening and Prince Charles himself, and the portraits all hang in pride of place in the privacy of Kensington Palace and Highgrove. 
 From Sicily they sailed up the coastline to Venice together. 
 Every day the Prince and Princess went off on official business, to look at churches, visit hospitals and meet people, and the minute they were back on board the royal yacht, Charles would  quickly change into some comfortable clothes and sit on deck with his sketchbook and teacher, until the very last minute before the bell for dinner. 
 The deaf children of the Molfetta Deaf School in Trani were proud to have been singled out for a visit by the Princess 
 The trip was a revelation. 
 Diana was not so enthused by the architecture, which Charles delighted in, but there was no doubting the warmth of the welcome &mdash; they were greeted everywhere as &bquo; Carlo e De &equo; &mdash; and the sheer beauty of the place and the warm weather lifted everyone's spirits after an English winter. 
 Diana also enjoyed the attentiveness of Italian men, whose appreciation of good-looking women and elegant dressing is second to none. 
 She visited hospitals and schools, even a school for the deaf, where she boasted that she was President of the British Deaf Association. 
 The children didn't understand at first, but when it was later explained to them, they were enormously proud that she should have singled them out for a visit. 
 It was one of the most enjoyable tours they had had. 
 With the prospect of William and Harry joining them for a holiday afterwards, Diana was in good heart. 
 For the Prince, it was the beginning of a love affair, one that has taken him back to Italy on many occasions. 
 He has found friends there. 
 He stays with the historian Sir Harold Acton, in Florence, and the fabulously rich Frescobaldi family; and spends his time painting and soaking up the culture of the land that bred so many great artists. 
 Last year he was invited to hold an exhibition of his work at Urbino, in central Italy, at the house once owned by the Renaissance painter Raphael, which he had visited a few years before. 
 It was the first time that such an offer had ever been made; initially, he was loath to put his sketches on public display &mdash; but he was also flattered. 
 Finally, after some &bquo;agonizing&equo;, he agreed &bquo;on the grounds&equo;, as he wrote in the introduction to the catalogue, &bquo;that I have a passion for Italy, her people, her countryside and the way in which art quite naturally seems to invade every aspect of life, thereby producing an atmosphere that is totally irresistible&equo;. 
 He sent the paintings but none were for sale. 
 As he explained in Urbino, &bquo;These sketches are very much a part of myself and I am sure those who paint themselves will understand how hard it is to part with something into which, when inspired, you have poured your heart and soul.&equo; 
 He is also concerned about being unable to control their value on the open market, with individuals making money out of what had originally been a means of raising money for charity. 
 Sir Hugh Casson had helped Charles and encouraged him with his painting for many years, and is impressed by his skill. 
 He said of the Urbino exhibition: 
 The works on show are as relaxed as the setting &mdash; they speak quietly &mdash; no drama, no rhetoric &mdash; and their message is clear that The Prince of Wales, like every serious artist, paints not just what he sees but what he is&hellip; a man obviously happiest in the open air, preoccupied (like all Englishmen) with our landscape and our weather (itself as misty, mid-toned and lacking in extremes as the English themselves). 
 He draws inspiration from ordinary scenes and simple places that he knows and loves. 
 He obviously has heeded Ruskin's advice not just to look at things but to &bquo;watch&equo; them. 
 Diana does not paint, and could not have shared her husband's absorption. 
 Her interests are almost all active ones; and to be with someone whose idea of a holiday is to sit stock still for three hours at a time, with a small box of watercolours and a sketch pad and &bquo;watch&equo; things, was beyond her. 
 Fishing held no appeal for her either. 
 Nothing could be more boring, to her mind, than standing on the banks of a river for hour after hour, sometimes the entire day, hoping for a fish to take. 
 She had neither the patience nor the inclination. 
 Diana needs people; unlike the Prince, she is not much good at being on her own. 
 As a child at Althorp, a big and lonely place where she often had no other children for company, she would go into the kitchen to chatter to the cook and the cleaners, and even the delivery men who dropped in. 
 She loves talking to people, and keeping in touch with what is going on in their lives. 
 As such, she is a compulsive user of the telephone, and rings everyone, especially friends and family. 
 She is also a great letter-writer, a hangover no doubt from years at boarding school, where she had to write to both parents every week. 
 She writes as she speaks, a flow of news and thoughts in large, generous handwriting, with affectionate endings, such as &bquo;Lots of Love&equo; or &bquo;All my love&equo; &mdash; even to members of her staff. 
 People are her lifeline; they would have been whoever she had married. 
 She loves the country and Highgrove is home, especially with the children, but she needs to know the city is not too far away, with shops and cinemas and friends to meet up with. 
 The idea of being marooned at Balmoral for months on end is her vision of purgatory. 
 So after a brief visit to Balmoral in the summer, Diana soon established a pattern of leaving Charles to it and returning to London and her friends. 
 This was quite the most sensible arrangement; it was more fun for the children too. 
 Their friends were either in London or around Gloucestershire, and they had very active social lives, particularly after William started kindergarten in September 1985. 
 Charles, in the meantime, would invite people who he knew shared his enthusiasms to keep him company. 
 He went off to Italy one year with his cousin and fellow-artist, Lady Sarah Armstrong-Jones. 
 He went fishing with his friends of old, 
 Lord and Lady Tryon. 
 Kanga, as she is better known, was an ex-girlfriend and has remained a trusted friend. 
 Lord and Lady Tryon had a house in Iceland where Charles had frequently been a guest before he was married. 
 In fact, he was fishing on a fiord nearby at the precise moment when his detective brought him the news that Lord Mountbatten had been killed. 
 The Tryons, in return, have frequently joined him for some fishing at Balmoral. 
 The Prince is also very keen on deer stalking, another pull to keep him in the Highlands for as long as he can manage. 
 He is not especially fond of killing animals but, as a countryman, he sees culling deer as a necessity. 
 If they were allowed to breed at random and each live life to its natural end, in the absence of any real predators, they would overrun the land, destroy the habitat in an ever-desperate search for food, and upset the eco-system. 
 A good stalker only singles out weak animals from a herd, or those that are past their best. 
 Finding the right animal may involve tracking the herd for miles across steep and inhospitable terrain, and waiting  patiently for the right opportunity. 
 It is a skilled sport, best done by people who understand and admire their quarry and are fit enough to pursue and outwit it. 
 This is not one of his solitary pursuits, however. 
 He is usually accompanied by a stalker and gillie, local men who are familiar with the herds and their habits, and who know the country like the back of their hands and can help lead those doing the shooting to the right place. 
 They take ponies to carry the stags down the hill &mdash; nevertheless, it can be a long and exhausting day out. 
 Prince Charles has been deer stalking since he was a child and takes great pride in a clean kill. 
 He finds it far more challenging than shooting either grouse or pheasant, which he has also done plenty of. 
 There have repeatedly been stories that Diana's disapproval had stopped Charles shooting, but these rumours are quite untrue. 
 Diana was brought up with it, just as Charles was, and is a fair shot herself, although she does not shoot any more. 
 She is nevertheless perfectly happy to go out with the guns and take the boys. 
 The fact was that Charles gave up shooting for a few years because he had simply grown bored with it: it was too easy to blast away overfed birds frightened into the air by a band of beaters. 
 He still joins in the traditional New Year shooting at Sandringham, but, apart from that family outing, he seldom bothers with shooting birds nowadays. 
 If given an invitation to stalk, however, he jumps at it. 
 He is frequently a guest of Colonel Sir Donald Cameron of Lochiel at Achnacarry, his 80,000-acre deer forest near Fort William. 
 Trudging back one evening, having been out all day and having had no luck, Charles spotted a large heap of rocks on the hillside above them, and asked what it was. 
 Told that it was a fox's cairn, he insisted on climbing up by himself to have a look at it, and was gone for about twenty minutes. 
 Meanwhile, darkness began to fall. 
 When he finally rejoined the others he was carrying several samples of rock, and there was very little light left. 
 The party still had to cross Loch Arkaig by boat to meet up with his security men who were waiting with a Range Rover, and were clearly becoming worried. 
 They  switched on the car's headlights as a beacon; but, all of a sudden, as the Prince and his companions were half-way across the water, the lights swung round and moved away as the vehicle set off down the glen. 
 Charles feels the strong pull of the Highlands, but Diana seldom stays for long 
 When they landed there was no choice but to start the ten-mile journey to Achnacarry Castle on foot, so they set off, even though they had been walking all day. 
 just then they saw the lights come hurtling back up the rough track towards them. 
 In the confusion of explanations and apologies that followed, one of the security men rounded on the stalker for keeping the Prince out so late. 
 Charles defended the man stoutly, and asked instead, what the hell the driver thought he had been doing careering up and down the lochside like that. 
 &bquo;All you're doing is wasting petrol,&equo; he said. 
 Another stalking host is Lord King, British Airways supremo, who has a hunting lodge in the Borders. 
 Lord King is a friend from the fox-hunting field, another sport that Charles would defend on the grounds of control and conservation. 
 farmers encouraging foxes to live on their land encourage a whole range of other wildlife that enjoys the same habitat, as has been done at Highgrove. 
 If the farmers did not want the foxes, they would plough up those areas, and some of those other species might entirely disappear. 
 To which the Prince would add that it is a traditional and historical part of the English way of life, and one that is not, contrary to public opinion, exclusively for the rich. 
 Most hunts are made up of a complete cross-section of society, the only qualification being an ability to ride. 
 Once again, Charles does not hunt because he enjoys killing foxes. 
 He hunts because he finds it exciting to ride a horse at speed and over such unpredictable obstacles. 
 He seldom hunts in Gloucestershire because he finds the large expanses of flat and open farmland boring. 
 So although he has gone to some trouble to leave tracks across his own land at Highgrove specially for the local hunt, the Beaufort, he hardly ever joins them. 
 He much prefers riding with the Quorn in Leicestershire, where there are more hedges and gates to jump. 
 He particularly delights in riding near the front of the field so that he can watch the hounds at work &mdash; something that fascinates him. 
 The Prince's defence of blood sports, which so many of his friends find indefensible, is a curious inconsistency, and one on which he is not keen to be challenged or criticized. 
 Spike Milligan, the ex-Goon, who has been a friend for years, is a veteran anti-blood sports campaigner. 
 He once said that the Royal Family had inherited the problem of hunting and shooting; it was in the blood. 
 The label &bquo;Hunting junkies&equo; was not well received by his friend, the &bquo;Trainee King&equo;.  
 SEARCHING FOR A ROLE 
 The greatest cause of the Prince's despondency had been the feeling that he served no useful purpose. 
 Friends considered him so depressed during this period that they were even beginning to think the unthinkable &mdash; that he might give up and turn his back on society and all its ills, and do what he would have really chosen to do with his life: be a country squire. 
 But in September 1985 he joined forces with a man who was to play a large part in changing all that. 
 Stephen O'Brien is a remarkable man, liked and respected by everyone he comes into contact with. 
 His main mission in life for the last ten years, as chief executive of an organization called Business in the Community (BitC), has been to cut unemployment and regenerate the inner cities. 
 BitC is a charity, set up in 1981, to breathe life back into Britain's dying towns and cities. 
 It is a partnership between business, central and local government and trade unions, based on the American experience. 
 The idea is simple: communities with high unemployment and economic depression can be turned around if the companies that operate in those communities can be persuaded to become involved in them, invest in them, and train and recruit people from within them. 
 The motivation is self-interest. 
 If the community itself becomes prosperous, the people living in it will have more money to spend on the goods and services being provided by the companies. 
 Everyone benefits. 
 O'Brien had approached the Prince at the end of 1984 because he wanted support for a particular project, called Fullemploy. 
 It was a training programme for young unemployed blacks in the inner cities, and O'Brien, knowing that Charles already had an interest in this area through the Prince's Trust, thought it was worth seeing if Charles would help. 
 The Prince was more than keen to help; as a result of that approach he convened a meeting, known as the Windsor Conference, which is still widely regarded as one of the most significant advances ever made in race relations. 
 Between them they brought together in a hotel in Windsor the chairmen of sixty major companies in Britain and a crowd of bright, articulate members of the black community. 
 The black community did the rest. 
 They designed the agenda, ran the conference, and for twenty-four hours the white chairmen were their guests. 
 They mixed, talked and ate together and discussed the problems of unemployment among black youths.  
 Many people still felt that Diana spent an inordinate amount on clothes 
 Prince Charles addressed the conference, saying that racism was a problem of the white society and not the black. 
 It was a failure to recognize the potential of the black community and a failure to use it. 
 The Prince and Stephen O'Brien hit it off well from their first meeting. 
 They shared a common vision, and a very genuine concern for people, their needs, and the quality of their life. 
 O'Brien is much the same age as Charles, and a man of huge industry and enthusiasm whom Charles is able to spark ideas off. 
 He is not impressed by the Prince because of who he is, but because of the man he is: because of his gift for talking to people, his tenacity and his courage in confronting problems that other men would shy away from. 
 The risk that he took in bringing the whole Windsor Conference together was enormous. 
 Nothing of its kind had ever been done before, and it could have blown up in his face. 
 So when the invitation to become president of BitC arrived shortly afterwards, Charles accepted with alacrity. 
 The invitation could not have come at a better time. 
 He had been hit by a new wave of depression. 
 He and Diana had just returned from an exhausting tour of America, plugging Britain and British industry at every turn. 
 They had endured an embarrassing fund-raising dinner, for which rich Americans had paid 5,000 dollars a ticket, only to discover on their return that the Confederation of British Industry had done nothing to follow it up with any kind of sales drive. 
 &bquo;What's the point?&equo; said Charles. 
 &bquo;I'm no good at anything. 
 It's all a waste of time. 
 But BitC was an outfit with drive, enthusiasm, and a determination to make the sort of changes in society that Charles had been trying to make for years. 
 Here were people who shared his ideals and had the financial support of government and industry, while his endeavours had to rely on the begging bowl. 
 And here were people who wanted him not just for the name on the letter-head, but because they thought he could make a positive contribution. 
 Here, as it has turned out, was an organization where he has found he is seriously good at something, and where all the disparate strands of his life have come together with extraordinary clarity. 
 &bquo;The day you think I am not useful,&equo; he said to one of BitC's directors, &bquo;tell me. 
 I want to be involved in the growth of something. 
 I don't just want to open things and be seen trundling around. 
 I can go to all the dinners and banquets on earth, but it's not going to make any difference to the world. 
 What I want to do is be part of something that does.&equo; 
 Despite his pessimism, the Prince has, of course, made a considerable difference, if not to the world, then certainly to a number of individuals living in it. 
 One such group was the disabled community for whom he had set up the Prince of Wales Advisory Group on Disability. 
 Under the chairmanship of Bill Buchanan &mdash; who, like the group's then director, Nancy Robertson, is wheelchair-bound &mdash; the committee highlighted five major areas of neglect for disabled people: access, housing, employment, independent living and prevention. 
 They are steadily working through them. 
 The first was tackled in a way that was to set the pattern &mdash; a devastating technique  that the Prince has used time and again: bringing people together who would not normally meet. 
 In some cases they may be diametrically opposed. 
 In this instance he invited the top private housebuilders, designers and architects in Britain to a lunch at Kensington palace, and put them together with members of his advisory group, two of whom were in wheelchairs. 
 They called for four changes in modern house design: sloping paths in the landscaping rather than steps, lower concrete thresholds, wider doors to let wheelchairs through, and a downstairs lavatory. 
 The result was certainly an improvement. 
 Sir Laurie Barratt of Barratt's Homes set his architects to work at once and, after a few initial hiccups, the message has filtered through. 
 The Prince of Wales is an irrepressible font of ideas, a classic entrepreneur. 
 In another area, he had long cherished a dream to provide some sort of community service for young people in this country. 
 Most people, he felt, have an altruistic streak in them &mdash; irrespective of social background, culture or experience &mdash; and they should have the opportunity, at least once in their lives, to work together with others for the benefit of the community. 
 He had watched the effect that team spirit had had on the young people who had been on Operation Drake. 
 Many more youngsters had been dispatched around the world in Operation Raleigh, and he felt there must be a way for every young person to experience these kind of benefits. 
 This was the way. 
 So he wrote to George Thurstan, an ex-marine who was running the Drake Fellowship; this was a scheme set up by the Prince in the wake of the inner-city riots, to give young people from those areas adventure training. 
 Why, asked the Prince, was Britain the only country in Europe that did not have some kind of community service. 
 The answer was that community service was a political minefield, and had been rejected as unworkable every time it had reared its head. 
 If you put young people to work digging ditches, the argument ran, you were keeping other people out of employment; and what young people needed was not bogus work but real jobs. 
 It was a red rag to a bull. 
 &bquo;Stop telling me reasons why it can't be done,&equo; the Prince thundered, &bquo;and get on and find a way.&equo; 
 Bureaucracy and red tape make him angrier than almost anything else. 
 &bquo;Set up a pilot scheme,&equo; he demanded. 
 So, doing as they were bid, discussions were duly held with everyone concerned; just six months after the Prince's letter landed on George Thurstan's desk, a pilot scheme opened for business in Sunderland. 
 Twenty-one days later the Prince arrived to see what was going on. 
 What was going on was such a success that the idea was launched nationwide five years later, in April 1990, as Volunteers. 
 &bquo;It's an opportunity,&equo; says the brochure, &bquo;to spend some time doing voluntary work. 
 It's not for no-hopers. 
 It's not another source of free or cheap labour. 
 It's not for do-gooders. 
 It's not for ethnic minorities, or ethnic majorities. 
 It's not for the unemployed. 
 The handicapped. 
 Or Young Offenders. 
 It's not for anyone in particular. 
 It's for everyone. 
 In general. 
 And that includes you.&equo;  
 The schemes are locally run on a franchise basis, by voluntary organizations, schools or employers, and the hope is that in the first phase, up to 1993, 10,000 people aged between sixteen and twenty-four &mdash; immediately dubbed &bquo;Charlie's Army&equo; by the press &mdash; will join full- or part-time programmes of about twelve weeks. 
 The brochure continues: &bquo;A lot of things will happen to you during your time with the Volunteers. 
 You'll become part of a team. 
 You'll learn new skills. 
 You will probably do things that you have never done before in your life. 
 And may never get the opportunity to do again.&equo; 
 The activities include befriending the elderly or taking them on day trips, re-creating trails and footpaths in National parks, organizing and running barge  holidays for mentally handicapped children, and &bquo;greening&equo; inner cities by developing disused allotments. 
 The greatest cause of Charles's despondency was the feeling that he served no useful purpose 
 Seeing his ideas &mdash; which were greeted with such a chill at first &mdash; take off, was a tremendous boost to the Prince of Wales. 
 But that was not until 1990. 
 The gloom and despondency of the 1980s was destined to last a little longer yet. 
 More trouble appeared in the shape of an ill-judged television film, which Charles and Diana agreed to make for Independent Television News in 1985: seemingly innocuous, with a bland, not to say sycophantic, interviewer in the shape of Sir Alastair Burnet. 
 They allowed the cameras into Kensington palace and Highgrove but in the space of two evenings' viewing they came perilously close to destroying that magic ingredient that is so essential to the monarchy: its mystique. 
 In times when there are ever-louder grumblings about the money that is spent maintaining the Royal Family, it is imperative that the public has its belief confirmed that they are special, and in some way different from the rest of us. 
 Allowing the public into their homes for a peep at family life, which left us feeling they were not particularly special, was a dangerous gamble that backfired. 
 Showing the Princess in conference with one of her dress designers did nothing to allay the view that she spent an inordinate amount of money on clothes; and broadcasting the Prince's remark that he talked to the flowers in his garden was a bad mistake. 
 What was said tongue-in-cheek was received as confirmation of everything that had gone before: the Prince of Wales was seriously out of his tree. 
 He can laugh about it now, and has referred to it in many speeches since to very good effect; but at the time it hurt. 
 Not only that, it was brought up time and again by the media and used to undermine the serious work that he was trying so hard to do. 
 Charles bitterly regretted having allowed the cameras in. 
 But at the time he had no one with the expertise to guide him, and was very easily influenced by the persuasive arguments of the last person he spoke to on any given subject. 
 He lacked the confidence that has come in the last three or four years to make decisions and stick to them. 
 He was also crying out for an efficient office. 
 After Edward Adeane's departure, David Roycroft, who was a career diplomat from the Foreign Office, had held the fort until a successor could be found, but the whole set-up had always been curiously amateurish. 
 The right hand never knew what the left was doing. 
 People got through to the Prince who should not have, and those who should have didn't. 
 Letters were lost, and time and again Charles would discover that his staff had failed to show him a document or letter, or turned down an invitation on his behalf without ever showing it to him. 
 When Adeane left, Charles had definite ideas about the sort of man he wanted to replace him, but it was six months before the right man could be found. 
 He wanted someone of high calibre, with business and administrative skills, who was outside the traditional courtier mould yet compatible with the Old Guard already in situ . 
 Most important of all, he wanted someone who was sympathetic to his views and who would not be over-protective. 
 The difficulty was that a man of this calibre  would almost certainly have to be prepared to take a substantial drop in salary. 
 No one gets rich working for the Royal Family. 
 It was a headhunter who found Sir John Riddell, a successful investment banker in his early fifties. 
 The Prince needed sound advice, particularly as he moved into more and more controversial areas. 
 He could not afford to make mistakes; all his life he had been at pains to learn and understand how ordinary people live and had delved into the seamier side of human nature, but he was still very unworldly. 
 He was surprised to find, for example, that men who make their living out of reporting news and gossip should go away from a private lunch with him and the Princess and talk about it. 
 He was even more baffled when he tried to convert some of his Duchy property in Kennington into small units for single teenagers &mdash; a group that finds it notoriously difficult to find accommodation &mdash; and met with vociferous local anger. 
 It took the left-wing blunt Liverpudlian Cathy Ashton, at BitC, to explain it to him. 
 &bquo;The trouble is,&equo; she said, &bquo;that you are inevitably in the position of people being able to say, &bquo;It's all right for you, you don't have to live next door to those punks and weirdos.&equo; 
 Charles had simply thought he was being philanthropic. 
 Again, on the flight home from Melbourne at the end of their Australian tour in 1985, Charles hand-wrote a long and frank letter about his thoughts on a wide range of issues, including the Greater London Council &mdash; a politically explosive subject &mdash; &mdash; and had entrusted it to the common mail, without apparently thinking it unwise. 
 And he once passed on to BitC an invitation he had received requesting him and the Princess to open the conference of a Brent Women's Association, with a note saying, &bquo;Do you think I should do it? 
 C.&equo; The answer was a categorical no: one of the items on the agenda was &bquo;Police Brutality in Brent&equo;. 
 A ROCKY PATCH 
 Charles and Diana may not have had many interests in common when they first met, but one that they did have, and have enjoyed together throughout their marriage, is skiing. 
 But yet again, this was another area of their lives that was mismanaged. 
 Given the media's obsession with Diana, it was hardly likely that they would allow the couple the luxury of a week alone in the snow. 
 Somebody should have seen the inevitable scramble coming, but no one did. 
 The result was chaos: their first skiing holiday ruined by the press, who turned the icy mountain roads of Liechtenstein, where they were staying, into a re-run of the Monte Carlo rally. 
 To escape the posse of photographers and television crews that were always lying in wait, they would set off at high speed along treacherous tracks, with Europe's press in hot pursuit. 
 The lesson was learned, and in subsequent years a photocall has been organized for the first day, when the Prince and Princess pose sweetly for the cameras on the understanding that thereafter the media will go home so the two can holiday in peace. 
 They were posing for just such a photocall at Klosters in February 1986, when the photographers suddenly noticed another figure standing in the background, dressed in a Davy Crockett-style fur headband. 
 &bquo;It's Fergie,&equo; someone said, and within seconds Charles and Diana were left staring at an empty patch of snow where a moment before dozens of photographers had been elbowing one another for the best position. 
 They had lit upon Sarah Ferguson instead, who was hotly tipped to be announcing her engagement to Prince Andrew any day, and her appearance in Klosters was their dream come true. 
 So was it Diana's. 
 If her own marriage had been the result of some matchmaking, so too was Andrew's marriage to Sarah later that year. 
 She herself was principal matchmaker. 
 Diana had met Fergie through polo. 
 Sarah's father, Major Ronald Ferguson, is Charles's polo manager, so she was frequently at Smith's Lawn, the Guards' Club in Windsor Great Park, where Charles was based, and inevitably she and Diana often sat chatting while the Prince played polo. 
 Fergie was not, strictly speaking, Diana's type; she was certainly not like her old friends, nor indeed many of the friends she has  made in the last few years. 
 She was larger than life, she had seen the world, she was game for anything, she was jolly and vibrant, spoke her mind; all in all, she was fun to be with. 
 Having known the Royal Family all her life, she was easy to talk to, and was one of the few people who knew what Diana was talking about when she spoke about her day-to-day life. 
 In short, they became friends, and as time passed Diana thought her a good match for her errant brother-in-law. 
 It worked, and at first it seemed a perfect arrangement. 
 Everyone seemed to like Fergie; she was so natural, so unspoilt, and she brought a breath of fresh air wafting through the corridors of Court. 
 For Diana, it was like having an ally in the camp, and Balmoral was much more enjoyable that year with Fergie about. 
 She was not alone any more in feeling oppressed by the strict formality, the strict time-keeping; after-dinner games were more lively &mdash; and she was no longer the only one who wanted to giggle at the sound of the bagpipes that played them out of the dining-room after dinner every night. 
 To begin with, Sarah Ferguson deflected the attentions of the media too. 
 But as time passed, she became a dangerous influence. 
 Emboldened by what she saw her friend get away with, Diana felt able to loosen the shackles a little. 
 She had been in the royal straitjacket for five years and, like most women who marry and have children when they are very young, she began to realize what she had been missing out on. 
 Without Fergie's influence, for example, she would never have gone along to the Berkeley Square night club, Annabel's, as she did on the night of Prince Andrew's stag party, with Fergie and comedienne Pamela Stephenson, both of them dressed up as policewomen. 
 It was unusual company for her to keep in any event: delightful though Pamela Stephenson may be, her public image is not altogether regal, and Charles has always recognized the need to choose his friends, particularly those in showbusiness, with care. 
 Before Fergie appeared, Diana would never have poked an umbrella into the rump of a gentleman friend at Ascot. 
 She might have done it in private &mdash; she is fun and without question, a little flirtatious &mdash; &mdash; but Diana had understood from the start that her public image had to be beyond reproach, and it always had been. 
 Now she appeared to be unconcerned what  people thought. 
 She was spotted driving about London late at night on her own, having apparently slipped out without her detective. 
 It was the paparazzi who trailed her, but it could so easily have been terrorists. 
 One thing they have enjoyed together throughout their marriage is skiing. 
 In Liechtenstein in 1985 
 Diana met Sarah Ferguson through polo, and they became firm friends 
 The tide of affection in which the public had held Diana since she first came to their notice had begun to turn. 
 They began to criticize and mutter doubts about the stability of the fairy-tale marriage. 
 By 1987 she and Charles seemed to have reached an all-time low, if not in their marriage, then certainly in the public's perception of it. 
 It began in Klosters again, with the famous photocall, this time a foursome of the Waleses and the Yorks, ending with Diana and Fergie wrestling to push the other off balance. 
 With Diana in the snow, Charles looked distinctly unamused and drew the session to a close. 
 There were reports of Diana playing tricks on Charles too &mdash; changing jackets with a friend, so he would attempt to take home the wrong woman; and there were reports that he spent his evenings at home in the chalet while Diana danced the night away with friends in a disco. 
 The Princess left Klosters on her own. 
 Back in London, her name began appearing in the gossip columns. 
 She had been, it seemed, to endless dinners, parties and weddings on her own, she had been spotted at local cinemas with friends, sitting in the stalls alongside ordinary members of the public, and she had been seen on the town, at pop concerts, and in restaurants, with handsome young men. 
 Two names in particular appeared with enough regularity for people to talk. 
 That of Philip Dunn, a City banker; and cavalry officer David Waterhouse, a major in the Lifeguards. 
 The fact that in every instance she was chaperoned, at least by a detective and usually by a group of other friends too, never seemed relevant. 
 The tabloids seemed hell-bent on knocking Diana off the pedestal they had put her on, determined to prove, or invent if necessary, that she had a roving eye. 
 In April the Prince went off to the Kalahari Desert for a few days with Sir Laurens Van der Post, to see for himself the society that his friend had written and talked about so much. 
 No sooner had he come back than he left Diana and the children at home yet again, and went to Italy on a week's painting holiday. 
 Rumours that the marriage was in trouble were gaining substance, particularly when by the end of the summer the press had calculated that Charles and Diana had spent only one day in six weeks together. 
 He had been in Scotland with Kanga, so they said. 
 Diana had been in London with the children, leading a hectic social life. 
 On the one occasion when they had met in those six weeks, it had been to visit flood victims in Wales, in the town of Carmarthen, which had been hit by the freak October hurricane. 
 Charles flew down from Aberdeen, Diana arrived from Highgrove; but instead of going home together, at least for the night, they went their separate ways. 
 By the end of the year even the serious newspapers were discussing the constitutional implications of divorce. 
 Once again there seemed to be no one around the Prince and Princess with the foresight to see that the situation was becoming seriously out of control. 
 A simple statement to explain why Charles was staying away so long would have been better  than nothing. 
 Left with nothing, the press could only draw the conclusion that the marriage was indeed close to disintegration. 
 All they needed was the proof, and when a photographer hired by a down-market Sunday newspaper caught the Princess of Wales emerging from her friend Kate Menzies's mews house during the early hours of the morning with David Waterhouse, and fooling around in the quiet road, they thought they had it. 
 Diana was distraught. 
 She and her detective rushed over to the photographer and she pleaded with him to hand over his film, and tell nothing of what he had seen. 
 He surrendered the film, but, not surprisingly, he went straight back to the newspaper and the story was headline news. 
 That was the turning point. 
 The Princess was given a serious fright. 
 She had been having a little innocent fun. 
 It was a way of releasing some of the strain and tension of her life. 
 She enjoyed being with her friends; their conversation was lively and interesting, they belonged to the real world &mdash; the world she had left behind. 
 She could relax with them and pretend for a while that she was still one of them. 
 She was flattered by their attention and affection, but it was wholly innocuous. 
 She knew that, and Charles knew that, but the public were evidently beginning to think otherwise. 
 The public, of course, had only the word of the press to guide them, and although there was more than a germ of truth in what the tabloids reported, this was by no means the first autumn in which the Prince had spent weeks without his wife and children. 
 Ever since William had started school, Diana had had to be based in the south. 
 Charles had chosen to stay in Scotland because it was the perfect time of year for all the activities he enjoyed there. 
 It was not pure holiday. 
 Paperwork and a fleet of secretaries and staff go with him wherever he goes, and Balmoral is no exception. 
 So his remaining north of the border for the autumn of 1987 was no indication, in itself, of the state of their marriage. 
 The Prince was infuriated by the reports. 
 He had long since given up reading the tabloids. 
 As he explained when I met him, he became so angry when he read what they had to say about the Princess that he wanted to ring the editors and complain, but realized that, rather than spending every day on the telephone, a simpler solution was to stop reading them. 
 For some years, therefore, he has only read The Times . 
 But even The Times  was giving space to the possible consequences of a royal divorce. 
 It made him even more depressed. 
 What right did anybody have to hold forth about his marriage? 
 What business was it of theirs anyway? 
 This was the final straw. 
 He felt that he had given enough. 
 For thirty-nine years he had devoted himself to the British public. 
 He had been through hell in the course of duty; he had made sacrifices that would be asked of no other human being. 
 He had been made an object of fun and a target for abuse. 
 He was wrong whatever he did. 
 If he spoke out, he was accused of poking his nose into matters he knew nothing about; if he stayed out of it, he was accused of slacking and taking too many holidays. 
 He was ridiculed for his speeches, and mocked for his concern about the inner cities. 
 Most hurtful and unfair of all, though, he had been the butt of jokes about his appearance for as long as he could remember &mdash; everything from his ears to his hairline.  
 He had had to fight for everything he had done, fight the people who wanted to wrap him up safely and wheel him out for a bit of ribbon-cutting and ceremonial. 
 It would have been a lot easier to have done nothing. 
 His job as Prince of Wales, after all, was simply a job of waiting and preparing to become sovereign. 
 He could have followed in the footsteps of some of his more notorious predecessors, by gambling, drinking and scandalizing society. 
 Or he could have opted out altogether. 
 What he had done, he had done because he wanted to make some contribution, pay back to society the great debt he felt by being born to such privilege. 
 He had given everything he had. 
 Was it too much to ask that he be allowed some privacy in his life? 
 If his marriage was in trouble it was because he and Diana had not been given a chance. 
 His wife had been plagued by the press from the beginning, and coping with the stress of it all was simply too much. 
 Nevertheless, the fact that the matter had come to such a head did have a sobering effect on them both. 
 The press had no right to pry and push and sneak about in their private lives, but it was undeniable that if their marriage were to fail, it would open up an entire can of constitutional worms that the monarchy could well do without. 
 Their marriage was not like anyone else's. 
 They could not afford to let it fall apart. 
 Braving the cameras and the columnists, and the experts who'd been brought in to analyse every glance and nuance of their body language, they faced the world, and slowly worked at healing the rift between them.  
 For Diana, coping with the life she had taken on, and with motherhood, was simply too much 
 SAVING THE ENVIRONMENT 
 When an organization invites the Prince or Princess of Wales to make a speech on their behalf, it is customary for them to write a draft, incorporating any appropriate facts and figures or particular message that they want conveyed in the speech. 
 The Department of the Environment provided just such a draft when they invited the Prince, as the United Kingdom's patron of the European Year of the Environment, to open the Second International Conference on the protection of the North Sea in November 1987. 
 It was a prestigious event, attended by ministers and top delegates from all over Europe, and the speech delivered to the Prince's office was straightforward and bland, essentially a pat on the back for Britain in all she was doing to keep the North Sea clean. 
 The Department had underestimated their speaker, and in so doing had made an embarrassing mistake. 
 Charles took one look at the proffered platitudes, which he knew to be absurd, and set about writing an alternative. 
 As with his architectural assaults, he trawled for information from a wide range of experts in the environmental field, including the pressure group Friends of the Earth, whose director at that time was Jonathon Porritt. 
 Armed with some facts and figures, he confidentially approached a number of very senior civil servants within the Department of the Environment. 
 All the advice he had been getting, he told them, was that Britain was in fact very culpable in North Sea pollution issues. 
 The speech he had been given was way off the mark, and he would like the truth. 
 The truth he got, but, when he rose to his feet at the splendid Queen Elizabeth II Conference Centre to declare the summit open, no more than a few people present had any inkling of what he was about to say. 
 The Secretary of State, Nicholas Ridley, was certainly not one of them. 
 The Prince spoke as follows: 
 The North Sea was once one of Europe's great highways. 
 This &bquo;silver sea, was also, and still is, one of the world's richest fishing zones &mdash; as well as a playground for sailors and a source of inspiration for poets and painters. 
 But over the past century we have made it into a rubbish dump. 
 The effluents we  pour heedlessly into its waters are a threat to its delicate ecological balance. 
 Some argue that we do not have enough proof of danger to justify stricter controls on dumping or to warrant the extra expenditure involved. 
 They say we must wait for science to provide that proof. 
 If science has taught us anything, however, it is that the environment is full of uncertainty. 
 It makes no sense to test it to destruction. 
 While we wait for the doctor's diagnosis the patient may easily die. 
 We do not have a lot of time left in which to act&hellip; 
 We know enough to know that these things are not good for our life support system or for our quality of life, and that our activities have damaging effects on our wildlife. 
 Therefore, how we decide to use our oceans and waterways in future is probably one of the most important choices for this particular generation. 
 The Prince could not have hoped for a better platform. 
 The effect was explosive, and deeply embarrassing to the government's position, which for years had been obstructive &mdash; to such an extent that Britain had long been known as &bquo;The Dirty Man of Europe&equo;. 
 Demands for action to clean up sulphur dioxide emissions from power stations, widely believed to be responsible for the &bquo;acid rain&equo; that was killing forests, lakes and rivers &mdash; not just in Scotland, but as far afield as Germany and Scandinavia &mdash; were brushed aside on the grounds of inconclusive evidence; a similar attitude was taken towards the radioactive discharges from the nuclear reprocessing plant at Sellafield. 
 The government had never been prepared to take any action without incontrovertible proof of a direct relationship between an industrial process and a particular pattern of death, disease or environmental damage. 
 If the Prince of Wales had not stood up and spoken as he did that day, the government might have remained entrenched on the subject for considerably longer than it was. 
 It was something of a turning point for the Prince too. 
 He had trod a very narrow path, fraught with danger; had he been wrong on any detail, it would have spelt disaster. 
 Speaking his mind about the medical profession, even waging war on the architectural establishment, was a very different matter from denouncing the government's attitude to pollution. 
 He had come close to the mark in his various schemes for the inner cities, but he had always taken great care not to overstep the boundary. 
 It was imperative, as he knew, not to get embroiled in politics, and he had been utterly furious when it appeared that architect Rod Hackney had done it for him. 
 In October 1985 the Manchester Evening News  ran a story, immediately picked up elsewhere, that Charles had confided in Hackney about his fears for the future, of a country divided into the &bquo;haves&equo; and the &bquo;have-nots&equo;, of &bquo;no-go&equo; inner-city areas, and racial minorities alienated from the rest of society. 
 Charles was in Australia when this particular bomb dropped, but he still felt the full effect of the fall-out. 
 There were angry calls from Buckingham Palace and Downing Street and, in the House of Commons, Labour's Shadow Home Secretary was treating it as a gift from heaven.  
 Charles nearly always re-writes the speeches that are prepared for him 
 The North Sea summit was a first. 
 The Prince had never publicly been so outspoken on such a politically sensitive subject, but it was something he felt he could not ignore. 
 He believed it was his duty to speak out. 
 He has devoted time and energy to people because it is the people who will one day be his subjects, and he feels a sense of responsibility towards them; but he will also be King of the British Isles, and has a responsibility to safeguard those Isles for future generations. 
 Everything he had seen, read and heard told him that Britain was in grave danger from the excesses of industrialization, and nothing very significant was being done to halt the process. 
 The problem had not appeared overnight; he was not leaping feet first into a situation that he had not thought about. 
 Prince Charles had been talking and gently agitating about the subject for many years. 
 It was now seventeen years since the Countryside in 1970 Conference, when he had talked about &bquo;the horrifying effects of pollution in all its cancerous forms&equo;. 
 It was all those problems, and a few more, that were now fouling up the North Sea and other parts of Britain. 
 His North Sea assault gave the environmentalists a powerful and unique spokesman; it made the government sit up and take notice; and it speeded up the long and painful process of making the public aware that there was a very real problem to solve, which was going to involve personal sacrifices. 
 Another instance of Charles's outspokenness was his attack on the proposed Paternoster Square development. 
 This turned him into a hero of the silent majority. 
 He discovered that night, in what has been called his &bquo;Luftwaffe&equo; speech, that his was not a voice in the wilderness; instead, he was speaking for the man on the Clapham omnibus. 
 The occasion was the annual dinner of the Corporation of London's planning and Communication Committee at the Mansion House, when Charles seized the opportunity to say a few words about the plans for the redevelopment of Paternoster Square. 
 This is the area to the north of St Paul's Cathedral, where there is a 1950s development, which he described as &bquo;the prototype for all the windswept urban squares dreamt up in the fifties and sixties&equo; that amounted to &bquo;the rape of  Britain&equo;. 
 The whole lot was to come down and make way for a million square feet of office space, and the company developing the site had held a competition to find a master-planner. 
 Seven architectural practices were invited to enter, and it was awarded to Arup Associates. 
 Charles had been given a view of the plans some months before and had been appalled. 
 &bquo;I must confess I was deeply depressed,&equo; he said later. 
 &bquo;It didn't seem to rise to the occasion. 
 This site is next to our great national cathedral &mdash; the very heart of the capital city. 
 What place in Britain could be more important? 
 This was something that I felt I had to speak up about.&equo; 
 Speak up he did, to dramatic effect. 
 As he began his speech, his hosts at the Mansion House dinner looked on in disbelief: 
 It is not just me  who is complaining. 
 Countless people are appalled by what has happened to their capital city, but feel totally powerless to do anything about it. 
 The Queen is a proud mother, but sometimes she feels Charles is too outspoken 
 What have we done to St Paul's since the bombing? 
 In the space of a mere fifteen years, in the sixties and seventies, and in spite of all sorts of elaborate rules supposedly designed to protect that great view, your predecessors, as the planners,  architects and developers of the City, wrecked the London skyline and desecrated the dome of St Paul's. 
 Not only did they wreck the London skyline in general. 
 Charles's attacks on modern architecture made him a hero of the silent majority. 
 After attacking earlier plans, he laid the foundation stone of the National Gallery extension 
 They also did their best to lose the great dome in a jostling scrum of office buildings, so mediocre that the only way you ever remember them is by the frustration they induce. 
 Can you imagine the Italians walling in St Mark's in Venice or St Peter's in Rome? 
 You have, Ladies and Gentlemen, to give this much to the Luftwaffe: when it knocked down our buildings, it didn't replace them with anything more offensive than rubble. 
 We did that. 
 Large numbers of us in this country are getting fed up of being talked down to and dictated to by the existing planning, architectural and development establishment. 
 And at street level, just look at Paternoster Square. 
 Did modern planners and architects in London ever use their eyes? 
 Surely here, if anywhere, was the time and place to sacrifice some profit. 
 If need be, for generosity of vision, for elegance, for dignity; for buildings which would raise our spirits and our faith in commercial enterprise, and prove that capitalism can have a human face. 
 The Prince had become older and wiser since his previous attacks. 
 He had considered what he would say long and hard, he had had discussions with a wide variety of architects, planners and journalists, eighteen of whom had attended a meeting at Highgrove in September. 
 He had trawled for views and ideas, as has become his method. 
 At least twenty-five professionals made an input to the speech. 
 It caused a furore nevertheless. 
 Most of the architectural establishment were outraged, and lost no time in condemning the Prince. 
 They did not mince their words. 
 One developer said his speech was &bquo;as welcome as a bad smell in a space capsule&equo;. 
 The architect Richard MacCormac said, &bquo;I believe there is a danger that classicism is being used as a cure-all architectural pill, when architecture has got a lot more to it than just putting in columns and capitals. 
 If Prince Charles wants to go on in this exhorting role, he has to understand architecture.&equo; 
 Richard Rogers described the Prince's actions as &bquo;very vicious &mdash; and very questionable democratically&equo;. 
 The best way to deal with him was &bquo;to starve him of the oxygen of publicity&equo;. 
 &bquo;As I anticipated,&equo; the Prince said, &bquo;there was rather an interesting row after I said all that. 
 But it instantly became clear that I wasn't speaking just for myself.&equo; 
 What Charles craved was a return to classical architecture, to buildings that were sympathetic to their surroundings, that were well proportioned and sensitive to human feelings, and not purely functional. 
 Of the Paternoster Square development, what he wanted to see, he said, was &bquo;a roofscape that gives the impression that St Paul's is floating above it like a great ship in the sea&equo;. 
 Waiting in the wings, as he knew, was just such a scheme, which had been produced by a young architect called John Simpson. 
 A plan of it had appeared in the  Architects' Journal  the previous Friday, and it also appeared in The Times  the morning after the Prince's speech. 
 At that time classical architecture was largely confined to the world of country-house building, and the majority of architects exhibiting were older men. 
 By 1987, however, the classical style of architecture had started being used on large-scale developments also, and the average age of the architects doing this kind of work had dropped. 
 Over half the exhibitors were in their thirties and forties, an age that was becoming of increasing significance to the Prince. 
 He was greatly cheered to find so many young architects designing the new classical buildings of which he so much approved. 
 John Simpson had also been appalled by the competition entries for Paternoster Square and, at a very late stage, had managed to get hold of a copy of the brief &mdash; &mdash; to provide office space and car parking &mdash; and had sat down with a number of colleagues to draw up a scheme of their own. 
 The Arup scheme had been a modernist design, which essentially built a wall around St Paul's and squeezed in as much office space as possible behind it. 
 John Simpson and his associates wanted to try and reunite the cathedral with the rest of the City. 
 Any new buildings, they felt, must relate to the cathedral and be a part of the City. 
 Initially, they simply put together a series of guidelines, concerned with scale, height and the street network between the buildings, which amounted to two sheets of paper that they sent to the developer. 
 Nothing came of it; the developers were not interested in the Simpson ideas. 
 Undeterred, Simpson went on to produce an &bquo;alternative&equo; scheme, which, thanks to the Prince's involvement in bringing the whole issue into the open, went on public display alongside models of all the official proposals in the crypt of St Paul's Cathedral. 
 The Arup scheme held centre stage, but the public, whose views were for once solicited, showed a very definite preference for the Simpson plan. 
 It became a matter for public debate, newspaper articles were written, television programmes made, and the London Evening Standard  sponsored Simpson's planning application to the City. 
 Neither Arup nor the developers stood a chance. 
 The site has changed hands several times since then. 
 It is now owned by the Paternoster Association, which is made up of British, American and Japanese interests. 
 It now seems certain that St Paul's Cathedral will not be surrounded by a modernist wall, but by a sympathetic series of buildings in the best classical tradition. 
 RELATING 
 It would perhaps be too trite to pretend that the Prince and Princess's marriage was saved by Diana's involvement with Relate (formerly called the Marriage Guidance Council). 
 It certainly might have helped Diana to listen and learn from counselling sessions, where other couples' problems are aired and discussed; but there is no doubt that by taking on the role of patron at a time when the world was prophesying doom for her own marriage was an exceptionally brave thing for her to do. 
 As 1988 progressed it became obvious that Diana had matured immeasurably. 
 She had relaxed, and found new confidence. 
 She seemed to have come down to earth, leaving behind the soap-opera image that she had once appeared to be caught up in. 
 Any whiff of scandal had evaporated, and she now threw herself into a hectic work schedule. 
 So too did the Prince. 
 The various strands of his life were beginning to come together. 
 He had plunged into the den of architects once more, and been suitably bloodied. 
 He had also set the cat among the pigeons on the environmental issue. 
 The relationship with BitC was working well and, as he began his fortieth year, the future was looking positive. 
 It was the start of a new improved relationship between the royal couple. 
 Whatever had gone on in those weeks apart, whatever course of action their friends had counselled, a minor transformation had occurred. 
 The warm familiarity was back, and they appeared to find pleasure and amusement in each other's company. 
 A trip to Australia for the country's bicentennial celebrations was a good start to the year. 
 Diana not only ostentatiously wore outfits that she had been seen in before &mdash; to knock a few criticisms on the head about the money she spent on her wardrobe &mdash; but she also seized the opportunity to kill off a few more misconceptions. 
 Visiting a music school in Melbourne, the royal couple looked in on a cello class that was in full swing, supervised by a delightful seventy-eight-year-old professor, Henri Touzeau. 
 Knowing the Prince played the cello, the professor asked whether he would like to have a go. 
 Charles had once been able to play quite proficiently, but was very out of practice. 
 He had taken up the cello at Gordonstoun, when his housemaster, Bob Whitby, could stand the noise of the bagpipes &mdash; his chosen instrument &mdash; no longer.  
 For Diana to become Patron of Relate was an exceptionally brave thing to do when the world was prophesying doom for her own marriage 
 &bquo;No, not at all, thank you,&equo; said the Prince, and, even when pressed by the professor, he would not be moved. 
 So the professor turned his attention to Diana, and invited her to play the piano. 
 Scarcely pausing for thought, she sat herself down at the keyboard and, without so much as a sheet of music to look at, launched into Rachmaninov's Second Piano Concerto, blushing deeply to the round of spontaneous applause. 
 The professor was filled with praise. 
 The Princess, he declared, was &bquo;very accomplished, a very sensitive player and shows great musical ability. 
 She played with such warmth.&equo; 
 Her grandmother would have been proud. 
 Before she was married, Ruth, Lady Fermoy, trained as a concert pianist under Albert Cortot at the Paris Conservatoire. 
 It certainly knocked the &bquo;Disco Di&equo; image firmly on the head. 
 Not only does Diana play the piano at home, she invariably has a background of classical music playing in her sitting-room and in her private study. 
 At a gala concert of the Philharmonia Orchestra to inaugurate an International Conference on Cancer Nursing, she was sitting in the dark of the Royal Festival Hall playing the movements on an imaginary piano on her knees. 
 Her taste has changed as she has grown older. 
 She still likes pop music, especially the singers and groups she grew up with, like Neil Diamond, Dire Straits and Duran Duran, and thoroughly enjoys the rock concerts she attends, but she now finds classical music more soothing to read and work to. 
 Also, she is busy educating herself about opera. 
 When Diana became patron of the Welsh National Opera, one of the original five patronages she took on when she became Princess of Wales, she confessed that she did not know very much about opera &mdash; and that her principal love was ballet. 
 &bquo;But  my husband is going to teach me,&equo; she said &bquo;and I am going to teach him about ballet.&equo; 
 With this in mind, she had taken Charles with her when she went to see them perform for the first time. 
 It was a production of Carmen, at the Dominion Theatre in London in December 1983. 
 Although based in Cardiff, the Welsh National Opera tours extensively, and for the last twelve years has had a regular season in London too. 
 This was an ambitious, complex production, and, thanks to a particularly officious fire officer, it teetered on the brink of disaster. 
 It gave Brian McMaster, the company's managing director, the worst night he has ever had. 
 Listening to counsellors help others no doubt helped their marriage. 
 Visiting a Relate centre in Worcester 
 The fire officer inspected the set at about 6 o'clock on the evening of the performance, as fire officers normally do, to put a flame to the scenery to ensure it is properly fire-proofed. 
 The same production had been playing in six or seven theatres in Britain already, and no fire officer in any of those places had found any problem. 
 This fire officer, however, refused to allow the use of a sizeable proportion of the props, around which the entire show was structured; and, although the Prince and Princess of Wales were arriving in one and a half hours' time along with five Cabinet ministers, and the cast would have no time to rehearse without the props they relied upon, he was not to be budged. 
 &bquo;Everyone's concentration on stage completely went,&equo; recalls Brian McMaster with a nervous chuckle. 
 &bquo;It was the worst performance we have ever given. 
 That night must have set the arts in Britain back years. 
 The Princess was very kind though. 
 She said she enjoyed it.&equo; 
 She also went up on to the stage afterwards to meet the singers, and endeared herself to them all when one of the chorus asked, &bquo;Why don't you come and audition for the company?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, my husband says I've got rather a good voice,&equo; she responded. 
 That has yet to be tested in public, but the evening certainly did not put her off &mdash; &mdash; she has been an ardent fan of the Welsh National Opera ever since. 
 She has also made a concerted effort to improve her knowledge. 
 Her old flatmate Carolyn Pride, who has since married and become Carolyn Bartholomew, has been instrumental in this. 
 She is extremely musical. 
 She was studying at the Royal College of Music when she  moved into Coleherne Court with Diana, and then went on to become an opera singer, pausing only recently to have a couple of children. 
 She has taken Diana to Covent Garden on innumerable occasions in the last few years. 
 They go quite privately; they buy tickets for the Grand Tier and, although a detective goes too, no one knows the Princess of Wales is in the house until they find themselves sitting behind her. 
 Diana's principal love has always been ballet. 
 At a Bolshoi ballet performance in London 
 Diana much prefers sitting in the body of the auditorium where she can see what is going on on stage. 
 In most theatres, including Covent Garden, the view from the Royal Box is one of the worst in the house. 
 She prefers the auditorium, even when she is there in an official capacity, as John Young, chairman of the National Hospital, discovered to his dismay. 
 The Princess had become patron of the hospital, where her father made his miraculous recovery after his cerebral haemorrhage in 1978, and in May 1988 she had agreed to attend a gala performance of The Magic Flute  at the London Coliseum. 
 John Young, a larger-than-life figure, had automatically assumed the Princess would sit in the Royal Box, and had sold tickets in the belief that everyone in the theatre would have a view of the Princess. 
 No, he was firmly told, the Princess would sit in the Dress Circle. 
 He protested. 
 people were coming from all over the country to see her, and anyone sitting at the back of the stalls or the upper circle would not catch a glimpse. 
 &bquo;I got a bloody nose over that,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;I was told to mind my own business.&equo; 
 It was a demonstration of Diana's new-found confidence. 
 At one time she might have wanted to sit among the crowd, to escape from the prying eyes, but she would never have had the confidence to say so. 
 Her assurance has obviously come with age and experience, but there is no doubt that her first major public speech marked a turning point. 
 It was the day she received the Freedom of the City of London, at the Guildhall in July 1987 &mdash; a terrifying ordeal by anyone's standards. 
 She had to stand up in the midst of a certain amount of pomp and ceremony and address a large audience, which included her own family, her husband, the Prime Minister, the Lord Mayor and a host of City dignitaries, many of them accomplished public speakers themselves. 
 In the early days Diana had had some guidance from Sir Richard Attenborough. 
 He had been able to teach her some of the ploys that actors use to control their breathing when they are nervous, and project their voices so they can be heard. 
 For the past six years, however, she had done little more than declare things open, or say a few words of thanks in public. 
 It was clear that she had picked up a lot from the Prince's own style, especially the self-deprecating wit. 
 Diana began her speech: 
 I am rather unsure of my qualifications for such an honour, but I feel deeply grateful and flattered to be joining the many famous people who have received the Freedom of this great City, including my more illustrious and worthy ancestor,  the third Earl Spencer. 
 I know my Spencer ancestors built their wealth in the sixteenth century on the rearing of sheep, and I believe one of the benefits of receiving the Freedom of the City is that Freemen, or Women, are able to drive sheep across London Bridge and through the City of London. 
 I promise I will give you good warning before I avail myself of this privilege. 
 My connections with the City are, as I have said, rather tenuous, but it is nearly six years ago to the day since our wedding, when yet again the traffic in the City was brought to a standstill. 
 Since that July day I have visited the City on numerous occasions&hellip; connected directly or indirectly to asking the City for help with fund-raising. 
 Perhaps now is an opportunity of thanking everyone for their generosity and to say how greatly I know it is appreciated by the charities and organizations concerned. 
 &bquo;Be always ready, according to your power to relieve the poor and help the distressed&hellip;&equo; is a quote from The Rules for the Conduct of Life , a copy of which is given to all new Freemen &mdash; or perhaps it should now be Freepersons. 
 Sitting in the audience was Diana's father, Earl Spencer, who had always been very proud of his daughter, and only too happy to tell the world so. 
 &bquo;She's very genuine, she's very beautiful and she's still very much in love with Prince Charles,&equo; he told Woman's Own , in a bid to rebut rumours that the marriage was in trouble. 
 &bquo;Charles and Diana have their rows&equo;, he said, &bquo;what couple doesn't? 
 But they are nothing out of the ordinary.&equo; 
 Of the rumours, he said, &bquo;Diana finds them very hurtful because they are not true.&equo; 
 And on the other burning question that was asked time and time again &mdash; whether she will have more children &mdash; he said, digging an even deeper hole for himself: 
 &bquo;She'd love a large family because she knows the joys of it. 
 She likes the atmosphere of a large family. 
 I'm quite sure she'd like to have several more children yet &mdash; five seems a good number. 
 &bquo;There are times when I wish she could have a couple of years off to bring up her children, be at home with them, and not worry about anything else apart from them and her husband. 
 Instead, it's a bit like a non-stop circus.&equo; 
 Royal reporters have been speculating on a new pregnancy for years, and members of the public have been no less nosy. 
 Visiting Aberdeen one day a woman in the crowd said, &bquo;When are you going to have another baby?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll have to ask my husband about that,&equo; replied the Princess. 
 There have been several false alarms in the tabloids, but at the end of 1986 reporters thought they had a scoop. 
 It was during Diana's trip to the Gulf with the Prince, when they suddenly spotted her obstetrician, George Pinker, in Bahrain, among the guests at an official dinner. 
 But Diana was equally surprised. 
 &bquo;George, what are you doing here?&equo; she asked. 
 The answer was that he had flown out quite coincidentally to attend a wedding. 
 The Princess would like more children. 
 She would dearly love some daughters to be able to pass her jewellery on to and, coming from a large family, she enjoys the atmosphere that plenty of children create. 
 The Prince would no doubt also like to have more children, but he is very torn over the question of population control. 
 Having witnessed the horrifying poverty and hunger in countries where there is just not enough food to feed the teeming masses, he feels depressed and worried about the future. 
 In most areas of life, he tries to practise what he preaches. 
 The Prince and Princess had both been on particularly good form throughout that Gulf tour, and were reduced to giggles on several occasions, none more so than during a desert picnic. 
 Wherever they went a box of Kleenex tissues lay in wait for Diana, and for Charles, a mysterious red briefcase. 
 And there in the middle of the desert, in a tent hung with persian carpets, were the ubiquitous tissues and the briefcase. 
 Opening it up Charles found a telephone inside, but was still none the wiser.  
 They were both on particularly good form throughout the Gulf tour of November 1986 
 Diana has always been in danger of getting the giggles at the least appropriate moment, and age has done very little to cure her. 
 The smallest thing can set her off, and the customs in the Middle and Far East did not help. 
 In the Gulf, in addition to the Kleenex, everywhere they went, no matter what time of day, they were given little cups of very strong coffee to drink. 
 In Japan, the custom of taking their shoes off everywhere, sitting on the floor to eat, and having an elaborate tea ceremony at every port of call, finally cracked her up. 
 In Thailand, in 1988, she and Prince Charles once again had to go barefoot. 
 Charles has had years of practice and had already encountered all the customs and forms of national dress that amuse Diana so much. 
 But his sense of the absurd is no less than hers. 
 for most of his life he has been stuck with a reputation for finding the Goons funny, but nothing since that era. 
 Far from it. 
 He and Diana attended the gala opening of Barry Humphries' show, Back With A Vengeance , in aid of the Royal Marsden Hospital, and both were in hysterics. 
 In it, Humphries plays his outrageous Australian creation, Dame Edna Everage, and Prince Charles kept slapping his knees with merriment and rocking with laughter. 
 Also, at the Gala Night of a Hundred Stars evening at the Mayflower Theatre in Southampton, a mime artist came on stage and found himself struggling with a sticky audience. 
 His humour was just not working. 
 Suddenly, great guffaws of laughter that went on and on broke the silence, so much so that people began to stretch forward to see who they were coming from. 
 It was none other than the heir to the throne, blissfully unaware, and convulsed with mirth.  
 Diana has always been in danger of getting the giggles at the least appropriate moment 
 THE WISHING WELL APPEAL 
 The Princess of Wales is never kept waiting. 
 It is simply not etiquette. 
 Elaborate arrangements are made everywhere she goes, with split-second timing, to ensure that there are no embarrassing hold-ups. 
 Father Christmas, however, operates in much the same way, and when both celebrities were planning to meet up, in December 1987, to deliver Christmas presents to sick children at Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital, there was no competition. 
 The Princess stood out in the cold and waited. 
 The year before, she and the Prince of Wales had been sent an unusual gift. 
 It was a book, specially written, printed and bound, the only one of its kind, about the historical links between Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital and the Royal family. 
 The old Victorian hospital, which has performed miracles on thousands of sick children from all over the world in the intervening years, had reached the end of its life. 
 Some &pound;30 million was needed to rebuild it, and the hospital was planning a massive appeal. 
 An archivist digging through the files had discovered a collection of fascinating links between the hospital and the Royal family since Queen Victoria became its patron in 1852. 
 At that time, 21,000 children under the age of ten died in London every year, almost half the total deaths in the capital. 
 The gift was by way of an invitation for the Prince and Princess both to become patrons of the appeal; it was the idea of professional fund-raiser Marion Allford, who had been brought in as the appeal director. 
 No male member of the Royal family had ever been directly involved with the hospital before, but she feels strongly that when children are in hospital it is the parents' problem, not just the mother's, and so the request was specifically for them both to be patrons. 
 They agreed, although they made it clear that they were not prepared to involve William or Harry in the exercise. 
 So in October 1987 the Wishing Well Appeal was officially launched by the Prince, via satellite link from Highgrove. 
 He was particularly pleased to be patron of Great Ormond Street, he said, because he had been there himself as a child. 
 On one occasion doctors had come to Buckingham Palace to take his tonsils out, but on the other occasion he had been what he called, &bquo;a blue light special&equo;; he was rushed to the hospital with acute appendicitis, where the nurses, he said, had spoilt him rotten. 
 Named after the fountain that originally stood in the  hospital garden, where children threw coins to wish for good health, the Wishing Well Appeal became one of the most successful fund-raising campaigns ever conducted. 
 In well under the two years they had allowed themselves, the appeal had a total of &pound;54 million with a further &pound;30 million promised by the government. 
 In a fifteen-month period either Charles and Diana, or both, had attended eleven special events for the appeal, and held several private receptions in addition. 
 Diana greets Father Christmas outside Great Ormond Street Children's Hospital before delivering the presents 
 They had hosted a cocktail party at Kensington palace, for example, for the heads of all the major national clubs and associations with large memberships; these habitually adopt a charity to support each year. 
 The Prince made a short speech about the needs of the hospital, and then both he and Diana went round the room and spoke to everyone individually, with the result that the Wishing Well Appeal spread like wildfire. 
 The emotive logo &mdash; the crudely drawn child's face with a big blue teardrop rolling from its eye &mdash; became familiar to every family in Britain. 
 Donations were pouring into the appeals office in the basement of Great Ormond Street at the rate of &pound;2 million a month. 
 So fast, in fact, that they had to call a halt to it. 
 But December was a day for the children. 
 Diana waited outside the main entrance of Great Ormond Street holding a clutch of excited little hands for a good five minutes before the Wishing Well song, which pop star Boy George had specially recorded for the appeal, struck up; and then Father Christmas, in the shape of a heavily disguised Jimmy Tarbuck, juddered round the corner on his sleigh, pulled by two little white ponies. 
 The sleigh was piled high with presents donated by the Variety Club, which he and the Princess then took into the hospital and distributed to the children inside.  
 Diana always makes an effort to talk to children at their level 
 It was the Princess at her best; completely natural and giving each child her undivided attention. 
 When she is doing anything with children, she always squats down to their level, touches them and listens to them, and the response she gets in just a few moments with each is quite extraordinary. 
 Having delivered the presents, however, her next stop was the basement, which had been hastily and frugally fitted out to house the appeals office, with its six telephone lines and fifty cramped volunteers drafted in to handle the money as it flooded in. 
 It was very basic indeed, and only by dint of preparation for the royal visitor did it have any carpeting on the stairs. 
 Yet the volunteers had been beavering away down there for two months, working well into the night on many occasions, and were to be there for many more months to come. 
 They were the unsung heroes of the whole appeal. 
 Diana had said she would look in to say hello to give them a morale boost, but when one of her staff saw the route she had to take to get there they said she could not possibly go. 
 It was positively hazardous. 
 The only access to the basement was down a flight of steep steps, and involved ducking under a low ceiling. 
 &bquo;Nonsense,&equo; said the Princess, and set off down the stairs at a spanking pace. 
 Diana has grown increasingly fit over the years. 
 Like the Prince, she takes a great deal of exercise, and frequently leaves the people who escort her on visits around the country struggling to keep up. 
 She is also hugely inquisitive, and unless they have planned their route carefully, and can keep safely abreast of her, Diana is quite likely to open interesting-looking doors to see what is behind them. 
 Something else the organizers have to consider is the Princess will never skip a bed in a hospital ward, or a group of people in a room. 
 The Royal Marsden Hospital, the country's leading cancer hospital, discovered this very early on. 
 If Diana has to walk through a ward with twenty beds in it, she will stop and talk to the occupant of each and every one, and the time keepers just have to get ulcers. 
 It is far better, they have realized, to limit the tour. 
 The Prince is rather easier to keep tabs on, but there is always the unforeseen to disrupt even the best-laid plans. 
 Just last summer he was visiting Fort Perbrook, in Portsmouth, built in Napoleonic times, where an excellent youth-training  scheme was being run and he was to address a seminar. 
 The Fort was a warren of underground tunnels and batteries and in every way a security nightmare, and the Prince's staff and members of BitC (also involved in the outing), who had done the recce, realized they had to get the Prince away from the youth schemes and down into the safety of the seminar very quickly. 
 Diana laying the foundation stone for the new Royal Marsden Cancer hospital in Fulham, London 
 As the helicopter came down to land, to their dismay they saw that the organizers had not only laid on about fifteen different activities for the Prince to inspect, including mountain-bike scrambling; but children from no fewer than five primary schools were gathered together in great banks to greet him. 
 In thirty-eight minutes flat he was supposed to be addressing a very high-powered seminar on enterprise. 
 The Prince became fascinated and vanished from sight into the mountain bikes, and it was twenty-four minutes before anyone could extract him and move him on. 
 Visiting a school in Doncaster in December 1989, Charles was on another very tight schedule, again with BitC. 
 He had exactly eight minutes to hear a report back from business leaders who had been looking at inner-city schools. 
 As the royal party came through the school gates, however, an entire youth brass orchestra, who again had obviously been at the ready for several hours on a cold wintry day, burst into life in the playground. 
 The Prince, of course, had to go and say hello, and disappeared once again, emerging ten minutes later having had a long discussion with the chief brass player. 
 Many of Charles's ideas sprang from a memorable visit to Boston in September 1986, when he had been invited to speak at the Harvard 350th Commemoration Ceremony. 
 It was an opportunity to talk about education and America, an irresistible combination as far as he was concerned, for which he happily interrupted his holiday at Balmoral. 
 There was no pool of academics or professionals contributing to this talk; it was a speech very much from the heart, and the thoughts expressed &mdash; mocked by the tabloids, needless to say, as philosophical ramblings &mdash; are still very relevant today. 
 &bquo;I have heard a great deal about Harvard &mdash; who hasn't? 
 After all, it has produced a cornucopia of leaders for the United States in many fields, not to mention the fact that six Harvard men have become president of the United States. 
 I have also heard of Yale&hellip; 
 &bquo;I confess that I have not addressed such a large gathering since I spoke to 40,000 Gujerati buffalo farmers in India in 1980, and that was a rare experience.&equo; 
 He moved on to the &bquo;enduring significance and value of the Anglo-American relationship&equo;. 
 &bquo;We must beware lest unscrupulous people exploit these areas of misunderstanding and divert our attention from the really important task, which is our common defence of the kind of freedoms we hold so dear: the freedoms for which this noble university so proudly stands and for which so many of its sons gave their lives in foreign fields.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps, too, as parents you may be wondering, like I do frequently, whether the  educational system you are confronted with is the right one to produce the kind of balanced, tolerant, civilized citizens we all hope our children can become? 
 The next day the Prince was leading a small group of businessmen he had brought over from Britain, including Stephen O'Brien, to look at a scheme called the Boston Compact, evidence that the United States had woken up sooner than anyone else to the dilemma of falling educational standards. 
 It was a simple enough idea. 
 Businesses in a central location are, more often than not, short of labour. 
 Very often there are schools, just across the road, full of children who will very probably become unemployed when they leave because they will not be equipped to fill any of the jobs that are available. 
 So, the businessman goes across the road to the people running the schools, and says, &bquo;These are the jobs we want filled, if you can teach the children these skills we will give them priority if they come to us for a job when they leave.&equo; 
 The Prince wanted BitC to try the same idea in Britain. 
 So, in due course, a pilot Compact, or Education partnership, was launched in the East End of London, linking four schools with eighteen local businesses. 
 There are now over forty Compacts in operation, which are succeeding &mdash; as much as anything by involving parents in the deal. 
 It has been working miracles. 
 Parents who previously took no interest in their children's education have suddenly become motivated. 
 In London, the Compact has been so successful that children who would previously have left as soon as they reached the school-leaving age of sixteen, are deciding to stay on at school to take further exams. 
 The companies who thought they were buying themselves employees to stack their shelves or deliver mail are getting nothing of the sort. 
 They are all rather proud of the outcome; and the Prince is delighted. 
 The Prince now has a strong team behind him, which is more in tune with his activities than ever before, and better qualified. 
 Sir John Riddell went back to the City, and was replaced by Major General Sir Christopher Airy, recently retired from commanding the Household Division, admirable qualifications for the job. 
 The Prince also has three assistant private secretaries &mdash; Peter Westmacott, who is on secondment from the Foreign Office, and advises on diplomatic niceties; Commander Richard Aylard, retired from the Navy, who is Comptroller of the Household, and the Prince's resident environmental expert; and Guy Salter, with business expertise. 
 It is a stronger team than the Prince has had before, but still understaffed, given that, as well as finding material for his speeches and meetings, they also have to research and organize his day trips and foreign tours, liaise with the press office and the Princess's assistant private secretary, Patrick Jephson, over their diaries, as well as handle the colossal amount of mail that arrives by every post. 
 It is a punishing job, and Charles is no easy man to work for. 
 He is a perfectionist, and he is impatient. 
 Yet, at the same time, he inspires extraordinary loyalty. 
 Eileen was dead. 
 Her body lay at the rest in the chapel downstairs, the light filtering in through lancet windows on her oak coffin and the dark-stained, hand-carved pews. 
 They had taken him down in the lift and he had stood there looking at her face, peaceful and still. 
 He had stooped to kiss her cold cheek and smelt in the hollow of her neck the waxen odour of death. 
 Her features, serene, composed, invested mortality with mystery and beauty. 
 Later, he stood there again and watched his mother's tears. 
 His father, gaunt and grey, supported her with strong, clay-hardened hands, his face set in bleak endurance. 
 Their grief sharpened his guilt. 
 It was he who should be lying there and not Eileen. 
 He had known for some time that it was inevitable. 
 Sister Cooney had been the first to hint it to him. 
 After his last visit, he had gone to her and begged to be told the truth. 
 &bquo;I'll ask Doctor Staples for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;The truth is what I want &mdash; nothing else.&equo; 
 &bquo;The truth is sometimes hard to accept,&equo; Sister Cooney had said, her sharp face kindly and concerned. 
 Later, when she had consulted Doctor Staples, she returned,  looking grave. 
 &bquo;All I can tell you at the moment is that she is on the danger list. 
 You were on it yourself once.&equo; 
 She looked at him hesitantly. 
 &bquo;You know there are different forms of this disease?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; he said apprehensively. 
 &bquo;What form has Eileen?&equo; 
 &bquo;The name wouldn't mean anything to you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd like to know it, all the same,&equo; he said, as if the knowledge could somehow enable him to come to grips with it and defeat it. 
 &bquo;Acute miliary tuberculosis.&equo; 
 It had been a simple matter after that to slip down to Mike Quinn, who was an acknowledged authority on all aspects of the disease by virtue of his ownership of one book, and borrow his Encyclopaedia of Human Ailments . 
 Back in bed he found the relevant passage: 
 Acute Miliary Tuberculosis is the most virulent form of this diseases. 
 spreading by the blood, the bacilli become established in every part of the body and thus overcome the patient, not so much by local damage as by the great general toxaemia, which produces symptoms not unlike those of typhoid fever&ndash; irregular fever, rapid pulse, dry skin and all the evidence of raging pyrexia, leading to delirium and coma, followed almost inevitably by a fatal termination. 
 He saw her alive just once more. 
 About eight o'clock in the evening he was summoned to her bedside. 
 &bquo;She's been calling for you,&equo; Sister Duggan told him. 
 He found her lying with a cold compress on her forehead, the pupils of her eyes strangely dilated. 
 They seemed to look through and beyond him and to focus &mdash; if they focused at all &mdash; on something infinitely remote. 
 The fingers of her left hand, which lay outside the clothes, picked compulsively at the blankets. 
  When he took her hand in his, it was flabby, soft and tremulous. 
 Sometimes her lips moved and she muttered something in a low tone. 
 He spoke her name and bent over to listen. 
 Her head turned slightly towards him and she fixed him with that blind, unthinking stare. 
 &bquo;Eileen,&equo; he called. 
 Her lips moved, but she made no sound that he could hear. 
 &bquo;Eileen,&equo; he said again. 
 &bquo;Do you hear me?&equo; 
 &bquo;Richard&hellip; 
 &bquo;The words came faintly. 
 &bquo;Where's Richard?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm here, Eileen,&equo; he said. 
 Her head turned away and she began to mutter incoherently. 
 &bquo;She's been like that most of the afternoon,&equo; Sister Duggan, who was standing by at the foot of the bed, told him. 
 &bquo;Father Furlong came a while ago and anointed her. 
 She's been a little easier since. 
 But she keeps asking for you.&equo; 
 He sat looking at her, with the numbed conviction that she was dying. 
 It seemed to him that the essential Eileen had already receded from her eyes. 
 There was no recognition in them, no awareness. 
 She began to mutter again and he leaned forward to listen. 
 Amongst the jumble of words, he distinguished his own name and the word &bquo;home&equo;. 
 &bquo;Eileen,&equo; he said, &bquo;I'm here.&equo; 
 She turned languidly towards the sound and spoke very distinctly. 
 &bquo;It's late, Richard. 
 We'll have to be going home.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; he said and pressed her hand, &bquo;we'll go soon.&equo; 
 It was an exchange they had had a hundred times during childhood at the end of some day's adventure in remote fields. 
 Twilight and mystery were woven into the words &mdash; along with fear and a reluctance to accept the inevitable. 
 They were the last words they spoke to each other. 
 Almost  immediately she lapsed into inertia and lay there, as if asleep, but with her eyes open and staring. 
 &bquo;She seems easier now,&equo; Sister Duggan said, as she gestured to him to withdraw. 
 In the morning, Matron, a large, comforting presence in navy blue, came with Sister Cooney to speak to him. 
 &bquo;You must prepare yourself for bad news,&equo; she told him. 
 &bquo;Is she dead? he asked bluntly. 
 &bquo;She's in a deep coma,&equo; Matron said. 
 &bquo;We don't think she can 
 &bquo;She's tranquil,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;She's in no pain.&equo; 
 &bquo;How long&hellip;?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's impossible to say &mdash; not very long.&equo; 
 Eileen lingered on through the morning and the brown September afternoon, her life twirling like a hectic-stricken leaf on a thin stem. 
 It was evening and the corridor was loud with the homely rattle of teacups when Sister Cooney came to tell him she was dead. 
 Now they were gathered in the chapel for her final journey home. 
 The coffin had been fastened down and lay on trestles, honey-coloured in the slanting light, awaiting its removal. 
 The undertaker, a fat man with a bunch of keys hanging from the index finger of his right hand, stood whispering to his father and Michael. 
 His mother, a crushed figure in black, sat beside him in a pew. 
 On the other side of him sat Liam, bewildered and broken. 
 &bquo;She was so young,&equo; his mother had whispered over and over again, until he wanted to shout at her to stop, &bquo;so young, and all her life before her.&equo; 
 They had stood about his bed, caught for a moment in a frieze of grief, all of them welded by tragedy into an awareness of their common flesh, their common loss.  
 &bquo;A few months ago she was in her full health and it was you we were worried about,&equo; Michael cried. 
 The undertaker was looking at his watch. 
 Death was his business and it had to be organised efficiently. 
 Grief was the climate in which he worked and he had inured himself to it. 
 On the whole it was a profitable venture. 
 Nobody wanted to be mean at such a time. 
 An undertaker's bill was paid and not questioned. 
 &bquo;She was always so&hellip; alive!&equo; his father said. 
 They had sifted minutely through the circumstances of her death. 
 Always at the end, they took refuge in some single statement that they repeated again and again. 
 It was a statement that summoned up some private vision they had of her, the simple words swelling to become a vehicle for all their feelings about her. 
 Some friends and neighbours had come to accompany her home. 
 They stood about deferentially at the back of the little chapel, not wishing to intrude on the privacy of the family's mourning. 
 At a nod from his father, the undertaker beckoned towards a group of men who came forward with subdued eyes, eager to express their sympathy in the one manly way that was open to them. 
 The undertaker selected four of them and they bent willingly to the coffin, easier in their minds about the embarrassments of grief, because now they had something they could do. 
 They lifted her gently onto their shoulders and moved down the chapel. 
 &bquo;She was talking about the cherries,&equo; he told Michael. 
 &bquo;It was the last thing she talked about.&equo; 
 &bquo;You only have them a few years, after all,&equo; his mother cried. 
 At the door, she embraced him in wordless grief. 
 His father put his ann roughly about them both. 
 &bquo;I don't like leaving you here, son,&equo; he said.  
 &bquo;Poor Richard!&equo; his mother said. 
 &bquo;We're all forgetting about you.&equo; 
 The fat undertaker had closed down the tailgate of the hearse and stood about on the gravel, twirling his keys. 
 It was over an hour's journey home at the pace funerals travelled, and the coffin was due in the parish church at six. 
 He looked at his watch again and wondered if it was time to intervene. 
 Matron and some of the nurses were standing by. 
 They came forward again to shake hands and sympathise. 
 Sister Duggan had Eileen, s few belongings in a case and handed them to Liam. 
 &bquo;I was looking after her chickens for her until she came home,&equo; Liam had cried in the chapel. 
 Michael took the case from him and led him away to the hired car. 
 &bquo;What are we going to do at all!&equo; his mother cried, as his father led her after them. 
 &bquo;God is good,&equo; his father said ritually. 
 &bquo;In spite of everything, God is good!&equo; 
 As he looked at them walk away, something hard in him revolted and he cried inside himself. 
 There is no God. 
 There is no good. 
 There's nothing but disease and decay and death. 
 He watched their departure through a spreading mist, and when the last car had gone and the avenue was silent except for the long sigh of grass, he allowed himself to be taken back to his room. 
 Sounds from the corridor intruded on his grief. 
 People still walked about and talked and laughed. 
 They were eating, sleeping, defecating, or otherwise engaged in some momentous enterprise. 
 Eileen was dead and it meant nothing to them at all. 
 hike a herd of antelope, grazing indifferently while one of their number was being savaged by lions, they would go on, singing and clapping their hands and making a great  noise against the darkness. 
 Eileen was dead and it made no difference at all.  
 It was quiet when Vincent slipped out of bed. 
 There was no sound except breathing and soft, nocturnal sighing from the darkness beyond the verandah. 
 He had watched until the night nurse had left the office and now he was as sure as he could be that she had gone below for a meal. 
 Bulbs in pale globes lit the corridor at intervals, the light reflecting off shiny walls. 
 When he passed the entry that led to the bathrooms and toilets, he became more circumspect. 
 It would be hard to give a satisfactory explanation if he were found in that part of the house so late at night. 
 He stood at the ornate head of the stairs and listened. 
 There was no sound at all. 
 He tiptoed swiftly down the stairs, keeping close to the wall. 
 When he came to the bottom, he stood again and listened. 
 Then he put his head out slowly and looked up the corridor. 
 There was no one in the office. 
 He was about to step across to the darkness of the recess and Lily's room when he heard footsteps and the sound of voices below him in the tiled entrance hall. 
 He recognised the loud bray of Doctor O'Connor-Crowley. 
 She was grumbling about being called out at such a late hour. 
 Whoever was with her was explaining that it was an emergency. 
 He stood listening as they crossed the hall and waited for the sound of the  lift gates closing. 
 But instead, he heard them begin the ascent of the stairs. 
 He daren't go back or they would see him. 
 He heard his name whispered from the recess and stepped lightly across into the gloom. 
 A hand caught his and drew him quietly into the room. 
 They stood in the darkness behind the open door and listened to the foots steps. 
 Vincent felt his heartbeat quicken, and tightened his grip on Lily's hand. 
 They stood there, breathless, as the steps came nearer, stopped for a moment outside then turned up the corridor. 
 &bquo;That was a near thing,&equo; Vincent whispered. 
 They listened as the sound receded &mdash; not moving, thrilled by the danger of discovery and by their nearness. 
 They laughed a little hysterically, and whispered to each other to be quiet and then laughed again, drunk with the joy of touching hands and the scent of their bodies in the dark. 
 &bquo;I told you we'd meet in spite of them,&equo; Vincent said. 
 It was the eve of Lily's departure to Seapark. 
 Vincent had put in a request to visit her and had been refused. 
 It was strictly forbidden for male patients to visit anyone except close relatives on the female floor. 
 &bquo;You'll have to wait now until she's gone,&equo; Lily said. 
 &bquo;Close the door, then.&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 These doors are always kept open.&equo; 
 They moved together in the friendly darkness, opening their arms to each other. 
 It was something they had dreamed of many times. 
 In their minds it had been prefaced with romantic dialogue and protestations of love. 
 But now it seemed as natural as the confluence of two rivers and needed no words at all. 
 Their bodies, meeting at many points, spoke of hunger and human need and deprivation. 
 &bquo;We'll meet again, Vincent, won't we? 
 &bquo;Yes, of course, we will!&equo;  
 &bquo;Sometimes I think we'll never see each other again.&equo; 
 He pressed his face into her hair. 
 It smelled fresh and newly washed, and curiously stamped with her youth, her beauty, her frail mortality. 
 A moist breath of autumn and ripeness came to them through the open window. 
 There was a brittleness in the sound of wind through the trees that spoke of fall and ruin. 
 Their ears, attuned to the corridor, caught the whisper of distant movement. 
 &bquo;It must be Elsie,&equo; Lily said. 
 &bquo;Did you know she's back?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Vincent said. 
 &bquo;When? 
 How is she?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yesterday. 
 She had a haemorrhage just before she came in. 
 I'm afraid she may be having another. 
 She complained of spotting in the afternoon. 
 That's probably why the doctor's here. 
 She's a different Elsie &mdash; very down in herself.&equo; 
 &bquo;God,&equo; Vincent groaned, &bquo;what hope is there for any of us!&equo; 
 They clung together in silence, the dread of their disease and its mortal power oppressing them. 
 &bquo;Maybe the ones that die quickly are the lucky ones,&equo; Vincent said with a surge of pessimism. 
 Outside they heard footsteps and voices on the corridor. 
 Suddenly the light in the recess came on. 
 &bquo;My God!&equo; 
 Lily hissed. 
 &bquo;They're coming in here.&equo; 
 She sprang guiltily away from Vincent, pushing him off balance. 
 He stumbled backwards and struck a bed screen that crashed to the floor, bringing him with it. 
 Lily screamed in flight. 
 There was a rush of feet from outside. 
 The room light came on and Nurse Bodkin and Doctor O'Connor-Crowley stood in the doorway. 
 Vincent picked himself up slowly and rubbed his ribs. 
 &bquo;What's the meaning of this? 
 Doctor O'Connor-Crowley rasped.  
 Vincent looked at Lily who was standing beside her bed, twisting the tassel of her dressing gown between her fingers and crying. 
 His first feelings had been of shock and then fear. 
 He was aware of the need to conciliate, to plead, to attempt to explain. 
 But the sight of Lily's tears and the arrogant tone of the doctor's voice pushed him into truculence. 
 &bquo;It's not what you think&hellip; &bquo;he began. 
 &bquo;Don't be insolent,&equo; the doctor snapped. 
 &bquo;Get back to your floor and report to me in the office at twelve tomorrow.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, no, Doctor, please,&equo; Lily cried, as the threat to Vincent's future, inherent in the command, became clear to her. 
 The innocence of the encounter, and the sharp pitch of emotional stress to which it had brought him, were significant factors in Vincent's response. 
 His voice, when he spoke, instead of being conciliatory, was angry. 
 &bquo;She's going away and we may never meet again. 
 I came to say goodbye.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's all&hellip; we were doing,&equo; Lily cried, &bquo;saying goodbye.&equo; 
 &bquo;At this hour of the night!&equo; the doctor sneered. 
 &bquo;We asked for permission during the day and couldn't get it,&equo; Vincent protested. 
 &bquo;You know the rules as well as I do.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rules!&equo; 
 Vincent shouted, casting off all restraint, &bquo;I'm sick of your rules! 
 We may never see one another again, but nobody cares, because there's no provision for it in the rules. 
 We may die and no one here will worry too much &mdash; as long as we do it according to the rules!&equo; 
 Lily covered her face with her hands and began to sob. 
 Nurse Bodkin bustled over to her and put her arm around her shoulder, making soothing noises and easing her into a sitting position on the bed. 
 &bquo;That's quite enough,&equo; Doctor O'Connor-Crowley shouted. 
  &bquo;Get back to your floor at once. 
 I shall deal with you in the morning.&equo; 
 Vincent looked towards Lily, who raised her eyes and looked back at him sadly. 
 Her mind was full of fears about his future. 
 What decisions, made arbitrarily and in anger, would be handed down to him in the morning? 
 What would happen to him if he were sent packing? 
 With his head lowered, Vincent walked out and padded heavily up the stairs. 
 He stood on the verandah in his own ward and stared out into the darkness. 
 Underneath, someone was awake and coughing. 
 The lights of a car came probing around the comer of the building, cutting a wide swathe through the Hackness and disappearing like a will-o'-the-wisp through the trees. 
 In bed, his mind kept turning in an endless loop, living and reliving what had happened. 
 When the night nurse came and flashed her light curiously over him, he pretended to be asleep. 
 He was surprised eventually by the cold greyness of morning, and sat up, despairing of rest. 
 As soon as it was bright enough, he took out notepaper and wrote two letters &mdash; one to Arty and one to Lily. 
 Then he retrieved his clothes and suitcase from the locker-room, dressed himself and packed his case. 
 Arty was still asleep, one arm hanging loosely over the side. 
 Vincent resisted the temptation to wake him and tell him everything. 
 He simply put the letters on Arty's locker and turned away. 
 It was seven and the night nurse had already begun her round at the other side of the house when he slipped downstairs. 
 Lily's door was still open. 
 It was not easy to pass without looking in. 
 But it was best to leave her undisturbed. 
 Arty would see that she got his letter before she left for Seapark. 
 Breakfast was being prepared in the kitchens. 
 He smelled  frying bacon and heard the chatter of women as he walked across the tiled hall and let himself out through a side door. 
 The morning air was sharp and bracing as he turned down the avenue. 
 He walked a little uncertainly, unused to the solid earth under his feet. 
 The smells from the grass and the hedges were strange and fresh and exciting. 
 When he turned to look, it seemed to him that the hospital was moving away from him like a phantom ship, butting through the September mists.  
 Since the interview in Matron's office, Sister Cooney and Doctor O'Connor-Crowley had barely been on speaking terms. 
 Doctor Staples, in his brisk way, had dealt with the matter summarily and to the full satisfaction of neither. 
 &bquo;In so far as the patient was being phased off this treatment,&equo; he had begun, pointing with the back of his pen to certain entries on Commander Barnwell's chart, &bquo;it would be technically correct to say that there has been a minor error.&equo; 
 Minor! 
 Sister Cooney seethed silently under her blotched skin. 
 How minor would it have been if the poor man had died? 
 Error! 
 Doctor O'Connor-Crowley rolled the offensive word down the corrosive reaches of her mind. 
 She did not make errors. 
 &bquo;What error?&equo; she asked truculently. 
 &bquo;The patient received the same amount of air as he was given the previous week. 
 Phasing out required a gradual reduction &mdash; at least 100 ccs less,&equo; Doctor Staples said. 
 &bquo;That was my point entirely,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 She could not &mdash; and did not try to &mdash; hide the triumph in her voice at being thus vindicated. 
 &bquo;On the other hand,&equo; Doctor Staples said, &bquo;it would be  unscientific to assume that this had anything to do with his lung collapse. 
 &bquo;Post hoc &mdash; propter hoc&equo; is bad logic.&equo; 
 &bquo;Precisely!&equo; 
 Doctor O'Connor-Crowley said. 
 &bquo;He already had had similar amounts &mdash; and more, much more &mdash; and nothing had happened.&equo; 
 Doctors! 
 Sister Cooney sneered to herself. 
 Covering up for each other as usual &mdash; &bquo;dog does not eat dog&equo;, their sole code of ethics. 
 &bquo;There was an error,&equo; she insisted. 
 &bquo;There were several errors,&equo; Doctor Staples said, &bquo;and one of them was this unseemly wrangle in front of the patient.&equo; 
 &bquo;He was barely conscious,&equo; Doctor O'Connor-Crowley said. 
 &bquo;All the more reason why he should have been having the full attention of you both,&equo; Doctor Staples said sharply. 
 &bquo;I dislike incompetence,&equo; Sister Cooney told the room in general, &bquo;wherever &mdash; and in whoever &mdash; I find it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ladies!&equo; 
 Doctor Staples had an edge of impatience in his voice. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid I find you both culpable in this. 
 As the patient is now out of danger, I don't propose to take the matter any further. 
 You may consider the incident closed.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course the old rip was negligent,&equo; he conceded to Sister Cooney later. 
 &bquo;I know all about her and her refills &mdash; 100 ccs more or less mean nothing to her. 
 She might as well be pumping a bicycle!&equo; 
 &bquo;Sister Cooney is inclined to exceed her authority,&equo; he allowed carefully to Doctor O'Connor-Crowley when they were alone. 
 &bquo;She's a stickler for accuracy. 
 We all have to keep on our toes when she's around.&equo; 
 &bquo;Impossible woman!&equo; 
 Doctor O'Connor-Crowley complained. 
 &bquo;I suspect her trouble is menopausal,&equo; Doctor Staples confided, smiling inwardly at his own two-faced diplomacy. 
 A melancholy came over Arty when Vincent left. 
 He began to  grow morose. 
 He sat for hours staring into a hand mirror, tilting it this way and that and bending his head. 
 He took to long fits of massaging, until his scalp glowed a wealed pink and his arms dropped from exhaustion. 
 His concern began to spread from his hair to his skin. 
 He examined it for blotches and blemishes, and subjected any irregularities to the most rigorous scrutiny. 
 Mid you know,&equo; he asked Phil, who had been trying to solicit his help all morning in the writing of a very important letter, &bquo;That cancer can start as a little discoloration &mdash; even a tiny wart or mole? 
 &bquo;Is that a fact? 
 Phil showed a diplomatic interest in the hope of gaining Arty's favour. 
 &bquo;It's like a time bomb you carry round with you,&equo; Arty said, &bquo;and the alarm mightn't go off for twenty-five years.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that a fact, now? 
 Phil said again. 
 &bquo;And it might go off tomorrow!&equo; 
 Arty examined a freckle on his nose with deep suspicion. 
 &bquo;Isn't it a wonder, now,&equo; said Phil, seizing the chance to turn the conversation his way, &bquo;That shaggin' chancer of a Dagg from Belfast didn't claim his dirty water could cure cancer too!&equo; 
 &bquo;Did it do you no good at all? 
 &bquo;No more nor if it was duck's piss!&equo; 
 &bquo;Piss is supposed to be good for warts,&equo; Arty said. 
 &bquo;Did you ever hear that?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Phil said. 
 &bquo;Listen, Arty, I'm writing to this Dagg fellow. 
 Would you &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Some warts are cancerous,&equo; Arty said, laying the mirror aside and getting out of bed. 
 &bquo;Would you tell me what to say to him? 
 &bquo;You're only wasting a stamp, Phil. 
 You'll never get your money back.&equo; 
 &bquo;God, Arty, you promised to help us!&equo;  
 Tell him it made your mickey fall off and you'll sue him for loss of your wife's affection,&equo; Arty shrugged indifferently, as he drew on his dressing gown and headed for the bathroom, where there was a larger mirror. 
 &bquo;Christ, Arty, watch your language!&equo; 
 &bquo;Wrap up a sausage and send it to him for proof,&equo; Arty called as the door swung to behind him. 
 &bquo;You're a terrible man altogether!&equo; 
 Phil complained, mourning the ending of a conversation that had begun to interest him. 
 The ambulance that took Lily away brought Frank back. 
 It was a shrunken Frank, whose body seemed to have contracted out of sympathy with his shrivelled spirit. 
 He lay, propped up by pillows, his face a slaty waste of sagging flesh, with lines of tension around the mouth and dull eyes. 
 A long bandage was fixed to the bottom of the bed and he was encouraged and bullied to pull on this several times a day, and hoist himself forward and perform exercises to rebuild the muscles of his butchered back. 
 After a few feeble and dispirited attempts to rotate his shoulders in a circular movement, or raise and lower his arms, he subsided with a groan and lay slumped until the nurse helped him up again and the torture continued. 
 &bquo;You must keep trying, Mr O'Shea,&equo; Nurse Bodkin urged. 
 &bquo;What difference does it make?&equo; frank looked at her out of his sunken eyes. 
 &bquo;That's what you say now,&equo; Nurse Bodkin said briskly, guiding his fumbling, unmotivated fingers towards the bandage. 
 &bquo;But what will you be saying if you see yourself in a month's time with a list on you like the Leaning Tower of Pisa? 
 What will Mrs O'Shea say?&equo; 
 What would Kitty say? 
 He knew well what Kitty would say. 
 Though it wouldn't make the least bit of difference to her what  way he looked, she would not let the occasion pass without punishing him sharply for still being alive. 
 She would survey him coldly with eyes that spat venom &mdash; Look at you with the gimp of an old scarecrow on you, they would say. 
 A fine thing you're going to be to warm a woman's bed at night. 
 Her voice might be saying something different but that, in essence, would be the message. 
 Kitty had that facility for slipping the knife in, even when on the surface she might only be talking about the weather. 
 He wondered what she was doing at that very moment. 
 It was something he seemed to have spent a great deal of his life wondering. 
 Into his twilight existence her face floated like a mirage. 
 He saw her coarsening features through the bottom and sides of a raised glass. 
 He saw her eager body arched to welcome some casual stranger, her passion loosed in that spendthrift laugh that would never ring for him again. 
 &bquo;Why the hell didn't I die and be done with it!&equo; frank said bitterly. 
 &bquo;Mr O'Shea feels very sorry for himself. 
 It's not like him at all,&equo; Nurse Bodkin reported. 
 &bquo;It's a touch of postoperative melancholy,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;We'll have to snap him out of it and keep him to the exercises or he'll ruin himself.&equo; 
 She closed the manilla folder she was working on, and with a firm set to her finely whelked face, she strode to his bed. 
 &bquo;Mr O'Shea,&equo; she said sternly, &bquo;you haven't been doing your exercises properly.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's the use, Sister,&equo; frank said listlessly. 
 &bquo;It's not yourself I'm worried about.&equo; 
 Her voice was harsh. 
 &bquo;It's the others. 
 Think of the bad example you are to anyone on the list for surgery. 
 What hope can they have, if they see you slumping about like a filleted herring, wallowing in self-pity? 
 I'm ashamed of you. 
 A man in your position should be giving a lead.&equo;  
 &bquo;The poor schoolmaster must live his life in a glass cage and do nothing that would scandalise the parish!&equo; frank grumbled. 
 &bquo;That's more like it,&equo; Sister Cooney eased her face into the makings of a smile. 
 &bquo;I'm glad to see there's some spirit left in you still.&equo; 
 &bquo;Damn little, then!&equo; 
 Frank said. 
 &bquo;Come on, now,&equo; Sister Cooney urged. 
 &bquo;Try stretching down to touch your toes. 
 That's a good one to build up the muscles.&equo; 
 She stood at the bottom of the bed and reached out her hands to catch his and pull them forward. 
 &bquo;God!&equo; frank groaned, as she relaxed her grip and eased him back. 
 &bquo;It's like being on the rack.&equo; 
 &bquo;It gets easier as you go on,&equo; she encouraged. 
 &bquo;Try again.&equo; 
 &bquo;I couldn't.&equo; 
 &bquo;You must,&equo; she insisted, taking his hands. 
 &bquo;Don't pull me,&equo; frank pleaded. 
 &bquo;I'll do it myself &mdash; if you'll give me time.&equo; 
 He lifted his hands feebly and, leaning forward, dropped them languidly on the blanket in front of him. 
 His body followed his hands a little, pushing them forward, until his head slumped down and he lay there, breathing laboriously. 
 From the bottom of the bed Sister Cooney eyed the limp hair on his thinning crown. 
 &bquo;God!&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Now, try again &mdash; only put more effort into it this time.&equo; 
 Frank fumbled for the bandage, caught it and eased himself cautiously back into a sitting position. 
 She stood beside him, pressing his back down as he leaned forward again. 
 &bquo;Good!&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You didn't die yet.&equo; 
 &bquo;No such luck!&equo; 
 Frank groaned. 
 &bquo;It gets easier with practice,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;Now, hold your two hands forward in front of you like this, as if you were going to dive. 
 Then put as much of a stretch on them  as you can and move them apart and backwards, as if you were swimming.&equo; 
 She stood and watched his weak attempts to comply. 
 &bquo;Back,&equo; she directed, &bquo;further back &mdash; much further back &mdash; back until you can't go any further, until you feel your chest is going to split in two.&equo; 
 frank dropped his hands and would have fallen, had she not steadied him and guided his fingers back to the bandage. 
 &bquo;A little rest,&equo; she said briskly, &bquo;and then we'll try again.&equo; 
 &bquo;If this old body has anything to try with,&equo; Frank gasped. 
 &bquo;Do you know what I feel like? 
 I feel like a maggot in a carcass. 
 I know I'm alive. 
 But everything around me is dead.&equo; 
 &bquo;The body is tougher than you think,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;It needs driving, that's all. 
 It's a sophisticated kind of machine and, like a machine, you can't afford to let it get rusty or it'll seize up.&equo; 
 &bquo;God!&equo; 
 Frank protested. 
 &bquo;If this thing of mine is a machine, it certainly needs oiling.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what I'm trying to tell you.&equo; 
 Sister Cooney smiled. 
 &bquo;Come on, now. 
 We'll try a few more.&equo; 
 &bquo;The tinnitus you can expect, I'm afraid,&equo; Doctor Staples said, &bquo;and the vertigo too &mdash; a little deafness even. 
 Have you felt any deafness?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't think so,&equo; Richard said. 
 &bquo;Well, you may have a little. 
 All these are side effects of the streptomycin. 
 So don't be too worried. 
 Is the ringing in the ears bad?&equo; 
 &bquo;Disconcerting more than anything else,&equo; Richard said, hearing, even as he spoke, the tiny tintinnabulation, faint as fairy bells. 
 &bquo;And the PAS, of course, brings on nausea and discourages eating?&equo;  
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; especially in the morning.&equo; 
 Every morning since the new treatment had started he had been wakened to the thermometer and a medicine glass, half-full of a yellow, foul-tasting mixture that curdled in his stomach and sat there all day in a poisonous knot, waiting for the smell and taste of food to release its venom again. 
 &bquo;You're not having a very happy time, are you?&equo; 
 Doctor Staples said. 
 &bquo;I'm not complaining,&equo; Richard hurried to assure him. 
 &bquo;I just thought that&hellip; as it's new&hellip; you'd like to know&hellip;, 
 &bquo;Everything! 
 Absolutely everything!&equo; 
 Doctor Staples said. 
 &bquo;No detail is too small. 
 As a matter of fact, I'm preparing a paper on the side effects for the medical association at this very moment. 
 The treatment is prolonged. 
 You understand that?&equo; 
 &bquo;I wasn't expecting any instant miracles,&equo; Richard smiled. 
 &bquo;The prognosis is quite good, though &mdash; very encouraging, in fact,&equo; Doctor Staples said. 
 Anything, Richard thought, would be better than sawing half a man's chest away. 
 He had seen Frank's mutilated back when they had both been down for screening, and had been deeply shocked. 
 There was dignity, at least, in the way Eileen had died. 
 Thank God she had been spared the ordeal of surgery. 
 It was the first time since her death that he had been able to think of it with anything like acceptance. 
 There had been long weeks when he lay sunk in gloom and introspection. 
 During the rest hours and at night, he had turned his face to the wall and cried over their shared youth and all the bonds of sun and blowing grass and long evenings full of the sound of tumbling rooks that tied their lives together. 
 Occasionally he had gone in to sit by Commander Barnwell's bed and seek comfort in his sea-scoured face and calm eyes. 
 &bquo;Dreadfully sorry, old chap!&equo; the Commander had said  when he first heard, Lis voice wheezing and whistling in his throat. 
 Richard had nodded his head and looked at the floor and said nothing. 
 &bquo;It was so untimely,&equo; the Commander said passionately after a long silence, &bquo;so very untimely.&equo; 
 Richard nodded again, and again there was silence. 
 &bquo;Must come for all of us one day.&equo; 
 The Commander stirred fretfully in bed and rearranged the blankets. 
 His breath, after the exertion, came in startled gasps. 
 &bquo;What's life,&equo; he said with a pessimism that fed Richard's gloom, &bquo;only waiting for the end.&equo;  
 Arty's melancholy had deepened. 
 He sat with his hand mirror all day and every day. 
 He bent and twisted himself before it, jerking suddenly this way and that, as if he were lying in wait for disease, determined to pounce on it before it could strike. 
 He pestered anyone who came along to look at his back and examine it for spots. 
 The other patients began to avoid him, to look at him oddly, to wonder about him. 
 One morning after breakfast and a prolonged peering into the mirror, Arty broke and screamed at Phil, who had come across to borrow a newspaper. 
 &bquo;Keep away from me, Phil! 
 Keep away! 
 It's contagious.&equo; 
 &bquo;God bless us and save us!&equo; 
 Phil exclaimed in alarm, &bquo;What's wrong, Arty, boy? 
 &bquo;Smallpox!&equo; 
 Arty cried. 
 Phil looked at him queerly and began to back off. 
 &bquo;Keep your old paper,&equo; he said defensively. 
 He turned away, and when he had got a safe distance, he began to whistle &mdash; a moist whistle that said he wasn't really disturbed at all about Arty's strange behaviour. 
 &bquo;Here's the bleedin' paper!&equo; 
 Arty flung it across to him. 
 &bquo;Only keep away!&equo;  
 &bquo;I think I'll go across and have a chat with that young fallow who came in the other day,&equo; Phil said in a conversational tone to no one in particular and rushed out to Sister Cooney's office. 
 &bquo;God, Sister,&equo; he poked his head around the jamb of the door, &bquo;That Arty fellow is acting terrible strange. 
 He says he has some disease.&equo; 
 &bquo;Isn't he in the right place for it? 
 Sister Cooney smiled and looked up at the board in front of her as the bell rang. 
 &bquo;There's somebody ringing in your ward now. 
 Maybe it's him.&equo; 
 &bquo;That fellow do have forty different diseases a day lately,&equo; Phil said. 
 &bquo;You never know with him whether he's coddin' or in earnest. 
 I don't think he knows himself sometimes.&equo; 
 Sister Cooney pressed a button on the panel and stood up. 
 &bquo;We'll soon find out,&equo; she said briskly. 
 &bquo;He do be usin' cruel bad language lately too,&equo; Phil complained piously. 
 She shooed him back to bed in front of her and he went meekly enough, entering with studied indifference, tapping his fingertips together as he went. 
 He threw his dressing gown casually on the chair and &mdash; with never a glance at Arty &mdash; jumped between the sheets, picked up the newspaper from the floor beside the bed, opened it out and peered over the top, his ears tuned to the conversation. 
 &bquo;Well, Arty. 
 Something wrong?&equo; 
 Sister Cooney asked. 
 &bquo;Smallpox, look!&equo; 
 Arty pointed his finger to hi s open mouth. 
 &bquo;Listen, Arty Byrne,&equo; Sister Cooney said crossly, &bquo;I've no time for joking. 
 What's wrong with your mouth? 
 &bquo;Looh ah ih!&equo; 
 Arty's voice thickened and blurred into animal grunts as he tried to speak and extend his tongue at the same time. 
 Sister Cooney examined his tongue critically. 
 &bquo;There's nothing the matter with your tongue. 
 It's perfectly normal.&equo;  
 &bquo;Spos &mdash; uk!&equo; 
 Arty said. 
 &bquo;Draw in your tongue and speak normally.&equo; 
 &bquo;I said look at the spots.&equo; 
 &bquo;There are no spots.&equo; 
 &bquo;There are &mdash; hundreds of them. 
 I've been watching them multiply all morning. 
 My tongue is covered with them &mdash; uk.&equo; 
 &bquo;Put in your tongue,&equo; Sister Cooney ordered. 
 &bquo;It's smallpox. 
 You'll have to isolate me,&equo; Arty told her. 
 &bquo;Smallpox!&equo; 
 Sister Cooney's voice was scathing. 
 &bquo;Do you know what smallpox is? 
 If you had smallpox, you'd have a rash. 
 Let's see your chest and abdomen.&equo; 
 Briskly she unbuttoned his pyjama top and examined him. 
 &bquo;Not a trace. 
 Not a thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what I'm trying to tell you,&equo; Arty said, with a touch of desperation in his voice. 
 &bquo;The rash is on my tongue.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't have a rash on your tongue.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I have &mdash; uk!&equo; 
 Arty said again. 
 &bquo;Keep in your tongue, please.&equo; 
 Arty closed his mouth and began to brush the heel of his open hand against his left temple in a repeated gesture of frustration. 
 Sister Cooney was surprised to see tears in his eyes. 
 &bquo;I knew you wouldn't believe me,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If it makes you feel any better, I'll get the doctor to have a look at you when he comes.&equo; 
 As soon as she had gone Phil was out of bed again and, with a half-fearful look at Arty, put on his dressing gown and sauntered out to spread the news. 
 &bquo;That Byrne fellow is gone loony,&equo; he told whoever would listen to him. 
 &bquo;And it wasn't today or yesterday he began either, if you ask me. 
 Hid I ever tell you about the letters he used write to ones he didn't know from Adam &mdash; mad letters about him being an airplane pilot? 
 God, you meet all kinds in a place like this!&equo;  
 When Doctor Staples came, he examined Arty and listened patiently to his self-diagnosis.The doctor neither confirmed nor denied that he was suffering from smallpox &mdash; which pleased Arty immensely. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; he agreed, &bquo;I think we should shift you. 
 We'll move you to a room of your own &mdash; put you under observation. 
 Would you like that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Arty said. 
 &bquo;I think it would be safer.&equo; 
 Tell me this,&equo; Doctor Staples asked, &bquo;you've been depressed lately, am I right? 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Arty said, feeling that at last he had someone who understood hi m and was taking his case seriously. 
 &bquo;Well, we can do something about that straightaway and at the same time keep you under observation. 
 How would that suit you? 
 &bquo;Fine!&equo; 
 Any was relieved. 
 When a week passed and Arty's condition had not improved, Doctor Staples returned with a worried frown. 
 &bquo;We may have to send you out to&hellip; another hospital&hellip; for some treatment. 
 You wouldn't mind that, would you? 
 You'd go out in the morning and be back again in the afternoon.&equo; 
 &bquo;What hospital? 
 Arty asked. 
 &bquo;We'll have to arrange about that,&equo; Doctor Staples said vaguely. 
 &bquo;Get in touch with Hearne,&equo; he told Sister Cooney, when they were back in the office. 
 I think a course of electroconvulsive therapy is what young Byrne needs.&equo; 
 &bquo;The mental hospital?&equo; 
 Sister Cooney looked concerned. 
 &bquo;Yes, but don't tell him that &mdash; not for the moment, anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;Poor fellow!&equo; 
 Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;He's normally in such high spirits.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's a characteristic of manic-depressive psychosis, isn't it? 
 Doctor Staples said. 
 &bquo;Periods of elation followed by bouts of depression. 
 Delusions of physical disease are common in the  depressive part of the cycle. 
 We'll just have to see what a course of ECT will do for him.&equo; 
 The following morning, Arty was taken by ambulance to the huge Victorian red-brick pile on the edge of town &mdash; a massive structure set well back in the fields and surrounded by a high wall to protect the sensibilities of the sane from too close a confrontation with one of society's more disagreeable problems. 
 He was brought back a few hours later, dazed and dreamy, with a dull headache and no very clear notion of what had been done to him or why. 
 All he remembered was being strapped to a couch, the sudden fear, the cold touch of electrodes to Lis head, and the convulsive shock before the blackout. 
 Elsie Hogan, her young face wasted and gaunt, was lying in bed reading a letter. 
 She was in a ward with strangers now. 
 Lily was gone. 
 Mrs Doran was gone too, slipping off one wet October day with her husband, her eyes &mdash; even as she said goodbye &mdash; filled with the anticipation of familiar fields and deep pastoral quiet. 
 Elsie had wept for kind Mrs Doran and for her husband, that strange, silent, sympathetic man, lifting his feet cautiously as he sidled across the polished floor. 
 There was something strong and elemental in them that would outlast a world in flux. 
 The letter was from Lily, in neat, sloped handwriting, like careful embroidery. 
 It's all different here. 
 Everyone's on the ground floor in chalets&ndash; wooden chalets in fields of grass. 
 The atmosphere is different too. 
 There's more hope here. 
 In Ardeevan we just lay and rotted and nothing ever happened between Doctor Staples's weekly rounds&ndash; except that someone died. 
 A lot of people are on streptomycin now and there are new operations. 
 Did I tell you I may have to have surgery? 
 Elsie let the letter drop and sighed. 
 It was the atmosphere that  was killing. 
 No one ever knew what was to happen next, as Lily said. 
 The place was full of rumours and gloomy talk, most of it ignorant and ill-informed. 
 She felt herself drowning in disease, like the fly she once found floundering in the filth of her sputum mug. 
 Vincent came to see me and stayed all day. 
 He looked very well and was full of talk of making his way in the world and starting a business some day. 
 He's in England now&ndash; a place called Warwick. 
 He's got a job in a factory. 
 He's saving three pounds a week and putting it in the post office at hoe. 
 He writes every week without fail. 
 Do you remember how you were on to me to write to him? 
 No need for that anymore&hellip; 
 Elsie put away the letter and cried. 
 She did not know why she was crying. 
 It wasn't like her at all. 
 A flurry again in Commander Barnwell's room. 
 A running and ringing in the darkening afternoon, urgent voices on the phone and the grind and clang of the lift as it came and went. 
 Next door, Richard heard and wondered. 
 Something heavy and metallic was wheeled in. 
 Oxygen? 
 Collapse again? 
 Outside on the corridor, the rumours were beginning to spread. 
 His heart &mdash; his other lung &mdash; both lungs &mdash; the poor man was having a haemorrhage. 
 His door was closed. 
 That was a bad sign. 
 When the doctor had come and gone and the place was quiet again, Richard put on his dressing gown and tiptoed across. 
 There was no response to his quiet knock. 
 He opened the door and looked in. 
 The screens were around the bed and the draught from the door set them billowing like sails. 
 In the hall light, he had the odd notion that the Commander was afloat on a full and soundless tide. 
 He stood uncertainly, listening, wondering if he should go any further or retreat before someone came along. 
 There was a strange silence about the room that puzzled him. 
 He  coughed mildly to test its depth and the sound was spirited away and absorbed into the stillness. 
 &bquo;Commander,&equo; he whispered and stepped forward towards the bed. 
 The door snapped shut behind him. 
 There was no sound, no movement from the bed. 
 Outside, the wind whistled thinly along the fluted tiles and stirred the open window sash. 
 He pulled the cloth of the screens aside and peered into the dimness. 
 The Commander was lying on his back. 
 His head rested on the pillow at an unusual angle, the chin tilted abnormally high, so that, from the foot of the bed, Richard was looking into the dark pits of his nostrils. 
 There was nobody with him &mdash; and that was odd. 
 He was just drawing the screens apart to step inside, when the door opened. 
 Sister Cooney came in and snapped on the light. 
 Even as he turned in alarm, he carried with him, trapped on his retina, the picture of the Commander's face, hollow and empty. 
 &bquo;Richard! 
 What are you doing here?&equo; 
 He stared wordlessly at her, seeing only that pale, withdrawn face. 
 &bquo;You shouldn't be in here,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 There was compassion and no reprimand in her voice. 
 &bquo;The Commander!&equo; he said in a shocked tone, whose grief took him unawares. 
 &bquo;He, s dead, isn't he?&equo; 
 &bquo;Back to your ward now, like a good fellow.&equo; 
 Sister Cooney took him by the arm and he went with her, unresisting. 
 &bquo;I was talking to him this morning,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Look.&equo; 
 He pointed to his locker. 
 &bquo;He gave me that book.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'd better get into bed.&equo; 
 Sister Cooney, noting the way he trembled, helped him off with his dressing gown and tucked him in. 
 &bquo;He is dead, isn't he?&equo;  
 She nodded without speaking. 
 &bquo;He gave me that book only this morning &mdash; Jane's Fighting Ships . 
 It lists every ship in the British Grand Fleet in the First World War.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll get you a warm drink and a hot-water bottle,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;The poor man had a seizure,&equo; she continued, busying herself at the blankets. 
 &bquo;It was to be expected, you know. 
 He never really recovered from that setback he had.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was talking to him this morning,&equo; Richard said again, wondering why he could not control his shivering. 
 &bquo;He was all right then.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a shock, I know,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;We were talking about the Battle of Jutland. 
 He was showing me the ships that were lost in the battle. 
 He was always talking about Jutland. 
 He was there, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was the way he would have liked it,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;Quick in the end.&equo; 
 &bquo;He was to go and live in Falmouth,&equo; Richard said. 
 &bquo;He told me it was all fixed up. 
 Mrs Barnwell&hellip; 
 &bquo;He stopped and looked at Sister Cooney. 
 &bquo;Does she know?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not yet. 
 We haven't contacted her yet.&equo; 
 &bquo;She was coming this evening. 
 He said she was coming.&equo; 
 &bquo;Poor woman!&equo; 
 Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;She knew, of course. 
 She was expecting this.&equo; 
 He saw the Commander's pale face, the nose pinched and sharp, the eyes expressionless, like the windows of a deserted house. 
 Was that what she was expecting? 
 When he had taken the tea and lay warmly wrapped and no longer shivering, Sister Cooney left him. 
 He lay with his eyes closed, conscious of his own body, conscious of the body in the other room, and the difference now between them. 
 He expected to die, but the expectation was always of something remote,  deferred. 
 He wondered if the Commander had known, if Eileen had known. 
 He found himself praying for Eileen and the Commander and all the dead, wherever they were. 
 Death, whatever it was, was a reality, a more important reality than life, if one were to judge by its duration. 
 Its mystery somehow diminished life, or did it enlarge it by making life and its purpose more mysterious still. 
 It certainly did not diminish God or lessen His reality. 
 In the face of such mystery, God was much more than just a protective wing to creep under. 
 Later, when Mrs Barnwell came, Sister Cooney took her in to see Richard. 
 She extended her thin, cold hand and accepted his commiseration. 
 &bquo;He was always a free spirit,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Clover Lodge didn't suit him at all. 
 He felt landlocked in the middle of all those fields.&equo; 
 &bquo;He talked of moving to Falmouth,&equo; Richard said. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Mrs Barnwell turned momentarily away. 
 &bquo;It was all arranged.&equo; 
 She shook his hand again before leaving and he lifted the book from the locker. 
 &bquo;I'd like to return this,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It was his.&equo; 
 &bquo;You keep it,&equo; Mrs Barnwell said. 
 &bquo;Sister tells me you were his friend.&equo; 
 'He was a good friend to me,&equo; Richard said. 
 &bquo;Misfortune,&equo; Mrs Barnwell said, &bquo;makes friends of us all.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't see any great change in you,&equo; Kitty O'Shea told her husband. 
 &bquo;You look much the same as you always looked.&equo; 
 &bquo;How would you know?&equo; 
 Frank asked. 
 &bquo;You haven't really seen me for years.&equo; 
 &bquo;You haven't been that long away.&equo; 
 Kitty smiled, wilfully misunderstanding him. 
 It was her smile that always did for him. 
 It hinted at intimacies  once shared and now denied. 
 It stirred the man in him even as it gored him. 
 It was a trap from which he could never escape. 
 &bquo;Or is it that it doesn't seem long? he continued bitterly, knowing the futility of carping, but being unable to stop it. 
 &bquo;Wy did you come at all?&equo; 
 &bquo;To see my lord and master, what else!&equo; she laughed. 
 &bquo;It's a long time since I was that &mdash; if I ever was.&equo; 
 Frank's mind went back to that torrid summer when they had melted into intimacy. 
 He had climbed through her window in the sweet nights, nights that would torment his memory for ever with the perfume of darkness and intrigue. 
 Even then she had taken the initiative. 
 &bquo;You like me, don't you? she had asked, her long hair loosened for sleep. 
 &bquo;You know I do.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, then, what are you worried about? 
 After that he had worried about nothing at all. 
 He had been a cheerful fellow in those days and life was as inconsequential as a laugh on the wind or the carelessly squandered words of a song. 
 Her red hair was a beacon in the night &mdash; a flame in which he had long since been charred. 
 &bquo;Well, whose fault was that?&equo; 
 Kitty took up the challenge again. 
 &bquo; Mea culpa !&equo; 
 Frank said. 
 &bquo; Mea maxima culpa !&equo; 
 &bquo;Christ!&equo; 
 Kitty exclaimed in exasperation, &bquo;Wy do schoolmasters always have to talk like that? 
 I often wonder if they're men at all.&equo; 
 She looked at him in disgust. 
 He would take that too, as he took all the rest. 
 Why couldn't he rise up and assert himself, shout at her, curse her, take off a great belt with a brazen buckle on it, like some muscular labouring man and beat hell out of her? 
 You could have respect for a man who lusted after you and fought for  you and took you. 
 But none for this milksop, who backed away and threw little delicately-barbed darts and had such reliance on the supremacy of reason and words. 
 &bquo;Why do you come at all?&equo; 
 Frank added. 
 &bquo;You haven't come all this way just to tell me you despise me, have you?&equo; 
 &bquo;As a matter of fact,&equo; Kitty said in a carefully careless tone, &bquo;There is something you ought to know before that busybody Condon gets on to you about it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Father Condon? 
 About what? 
 &bquo;You haven't had a visit &mdash; or a letter from him, then? 
 &bquo;No. 
 What's wrong? 
 Are you in some kind of trouble? 
 Don't tell me you're&hellip;, 
 &bquo;What kind of a fool do you think I am!&equo; 
 Kitty said impatiently. 
 &bquo;It's nothing like that.&equo; 
 &bquo;What, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;I can just see him looking down that long nose of his and saying in that sanctimonious voice: &bquo;there's something you ought to know, Mr O'Shea&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;What should I know? 
 Frank asked, his mind braced against shock. 
 &bquo;A lot of gossip! 
 That's all it is,&equo; Kitty said carelessly. 
 &bquo;People can never mind their own business.&equo; 
 &bquo;What should I know?&equo; 
 Frank insisted. 
 Kitty took out her cigarettes and lit one nonchalantly. 
 She drew in deeply and exhaled through her nose, then snapped the cigarette briskly from her mouth and pointed it at him with a flourish. 
 &bquo;You remember I had to get in a barman to help with drunks and keep a bit of law and order about the place? 
 &bquo;I remember,&equo; Frank said bleakly, with the familiar sensation of being sucked into a morass. 
 &bquo;Is it O'Gorman you're talking about? 
 &bquo;Tom, yes.&equo;  
 Her use of the Christian name angered him. 
 She had never used his own for years &mdash; he was always &bquo;you&equo; or &bquo;your man there&equo;. 
 &bquo;Tom, Dick or Harry,&equo; he said, &bquo;what does it matter! 
 So yourself and O'Gorman have been up to something? 
 You don't expect me to be surprised, do you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I knew you'd jump to conclusions,&equo; Kitty said. 
 &bquo;Do you want me to tell you or not? 
 &bquo;Better you than Father Condon, I suppose,&equo; Frank said, staring at the blankets. 
 &bquo;It's not what you think, mind!&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing is ever what I think.&equo; 
 &bquo;I &mdash; we &mdash; thought it a good idea at the time, with the late closing and it so hard to get people off the premises &mdash; and all the cleaning up to be done afterwards&hellip; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Thought what a good idea? 
 &bquo;That he should live in.&equo; 
 &bquo;A very good idea!&equo; 
 Frank said bitterly. 
 &bquo;So &mdash; convenient and everything.&equo; 
 &bquo;Will you listen to me!&equo; she hissed. 
 &bquo;Will you listen to me!&equo; 
 Frank raised his eyes angrily. 
 &bquo;There's been one thing understood between us for years and that was that you were to be discreet. 
 You owe me that much &mdash; if nothing else. 
 Never on the premises. 
 That was our agreement.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're getting it all wrong,&equo; Kitty said. 
 &bquo;He's not that kind of fellow.&equo; 
 &bquo;I hope he keeps his door locked at night, then, if he isn't,&equo; Frank said venomously. 
 &bquo;As a matter of fact, he does.&equo; 
 &bquo;I won't ask how you found out,&equo; he taunted. 
 The locked door &mdash; if it was really true &mdash; made him feel more despondent than ever. 
 It would intrigue and challenge her.  
 &bquo;You, re just like old Condon,&equo; she said, &bquo;coming poking about in his sly way.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's no business of mine, of course!&equo; 
 Frank said sarcastically. 
 &bquo;I soon put the run on that fellow,&equo; Kitty continued without comment. 
 &bquo;It's not right for a married woman to have a man in the house and he not her husband,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;It's a cause of scandal.&equo; 
 'that makes two of us, Father,&equo; says I, thinking of that whey-faced housekeeper of his. 
 &bquo;Haven't you a woman in the house that's not your wife!&equo;&equo; 
 She laughed in her careless way before drawing on her cigarette. 
 &bquo;For your own sake you should get rid of him &mdash; or make him live out,&equo; Frank said quietly after a period of silence. 
 &bquo;Why the hell should I? 
 &bquo;If you don't know yourself, there's no use in me telling you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bloody hypocrites, the lot!&equo; 
 Kitty said. 
 She crushed her cigarette in the ashtray and stood up to go. 
 &bquo;So, now you know,&equo; she said. 
 She looked so competent and self-assured, so hard, so distant from his own thought and feeling that she might just as well have been a stranger, passing by without a glance in the street. 
 The only thing that linked them was the embarrassing albatross of a marriage in whose death both of them had been guilty.  
 A Christmas tree had been set up in the corridor with fairy lights that winked on and off. 
 There were balloons in all the wards and coloured paper that hung in drooping loops. 
 The light came strangely rich through gaudy lanterns and shone on a brave display of Christmas cards. 
 On Christmas Eve a candle-lit procession, led by Matron, came to sing carols. 
 The wind from the verandah set their long cloaks billowing and the candle flames aflutter. 
 The sound, blown faint from distant wards, was melancholy with memories of other, happier Christmases. 
 On the day itself there was a special menu and paper hats were distributed. 
 In the afternoon there was dancing on the wards. 
 Beer, stout and a furtive drop of spirits were in circulation. 
 Sister Cooney watched the festivities develop with a benign eye. 
 A sprig of holly with three berries was taped with sticking plaster to the wall over her desk. 
 From time to time she glanced a little apprehensively at the numbered board with its blank bulbs. 
 An emergency at a time like this could spoil everything. 
 Looking in at the observation ward, with its partly screened beds, she hoped that Mike Quinn &mdash; poor man &mdash; wouldn't take it  into his head to go in a hurry. 
 Downstairs, too, there was young Elsie. 
 From Arty's room came the sound of an accordion. 
 He was sitting on the side of the bed, his head slightly tilted, his eyes closed. 
 His foot tapped the floor in time to the music. 
 Ted Nugent leaned his shoulder against the doorjamb, looking in at him. 
 &bquo;Can't you play something a bit more lively? 
 Ted called. 
 Arty opened his eyes slowly and inclined his head towards a notice on the door &mdash; a notice he had put there himself. 
 &bquo;Can't you read?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;KEEP OUT &mdash; SMALLPOX,&equo; Ted read and laughed. 
 &bquo;You don't really believe that, do you? 
 Arty closed his eyes again and concentrated on the music. 
 &bquo;Hey, it's Christmas!&equo; 
 Ted called, as he turned to leave. 
 &bquo;Can't you play something cheerful?&equo; 
 &bquo;I can only play the way I feel,&equo; Arty said. 
 Jack Carbery had put on his blue serge suit for the occasion and sat in the middle of a few friends, his collar stud gleaming, and the apple in his throat bobbing about like a cork on water as he drank. 
 Jack was in a cheerful mood. 
 He had a good roof over his head, clean sheets, enough to eat and a bottle of stout in his hand. 
 &bquo;Do you know what it is?&equo; he enquired, wiping his mouth reflectively with the back of his hand. 
 &bquo;There's a power of good men gone since this time last year.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; said Joe Connors, a dark little man who reached forward with spatulate fingers for the corkscrew, &bquo;There's only a few of us left.&equo; 
 They began to make a head count, lingering over the names with relish, proud of being survivors. 
 Carbery took a pack of cards out of his pocket and dealt them for Twenty-five. 
 He tilted his head as he dealt, to keep the smoke that curled up from his  cigarette out of his eyes. 
 &bquo;I suppose Mike out there will be the next to go,&equo; he said in a pleasant conversational tone. 
 &bquo;Let him hould his hoult till the day is over, anyway,&equo; Joe said. 
 &bquo;He have no business dyin' today and muckin' up everything.&equo; 
 Phil sat on the side of Frank's bed and talked. 
 &bquo;That Arty have it cruel bad, whatever he have,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I was down there to see Rim and he hardly spoke to me. 
 He have a notice on his door. 
 Do you know what it says?&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; Frank said wearily. 
 &bquo;I heard all about it.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you haven't heard the worst. 
 He says now it's typhoid he have and it's all my fault.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your fault?&equo; 
 Frank began to show some interest. 
 &bquo;He says typhoid comes from pellucid water &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Polluted,&equo; Frank suggested. 
 &bquo;Well, some kind of water, anyway. 
 He's trying to make out that I gave it to him when I gave him a spoonful of that&hellip; stuff&hellip; 
 I got from that shagger in Belfast. 
 He says it was just dirty water and I poisoned Rim. 
 Did you ever hear the like of that? 
 No wonder they're sending him over to the mad house for th&equo; electric.&equo; 
 Frank looked at Rim sardonic ally. 
 He didn't like what he saw. 
 There wasn't much subtlety or human sympathy about Phil. 
 He was an overgrown child who never saw beyond his own narrow world. 
 &bquo;Any fellow that'd pay a pound a bottle for dirty water &mdash; water that could very well carry typhoid,&equo; Frank said severely, &bquo;should have his head examined too. 
 A touch of th&equo; electric would do Rim no harm at all.&equo; 
 Phil got up from the bed abruptly and turned away with an awkward gesture &mdash; his usual response when he felt insulted. 
 &bquo;You'd want to mind who you'd be talkin' to in this place,&equo; he protested.  
 &bquo;You'd want to mind who you'd be taRing the cure from, too,&equo; Frank said. 
 Richard, wearing the new dressing gown and slippers that had been his mother's practical present, stood at the window, looking out over the bare countryside. 
 The river, swollen and bloated, lay heavy on the sunken fields. 
 Everything was stark and colourless &mdash; a predominance of mud and slate washes &mdash; just like his life. 
 &bquo;They're dancing up front. 
 Why don't you come and join them? 
 He turned to see Nurse Lambert smiling at the door. 
 Her butterfly cap sat at a saucy angle on her black hair. 
 &bquo;Who am I to dance with?&equo; 
 He smiled back at her. 
 &bquo;Me!&equo; 
 She held out her hand in invitation. 
 &bquo;Aren't you on duty?&equo; 
 &bquo;Who cares! 
 It's Christmas.&equo; 
 &bquo;So it is,&equo; he said, his smile fading. 
 &bquo;Well, come on, then!&equo; 
 He took her outstretched hand &mdash; very soft, very feminine &mdash; and allowed her to lead Rim away. 
 Out on the corridor, Nurse Bodkin was hovering hopefully near a suspended piece of mistletoe. 
 &bquo;Happy Christmas!&equo; she called invitingly to Ted Nugent as he passed. 
 &bquo;God, Nurse,&equo; Ted exclaimed virtuously, &bquo;There's nothing for a hot-blooded sinner like me to do when he sees you coming, except close his eyes and pray for continence.&equo; 
 &bquo;Go on out of that!&equo; 
 Nurse Bodkin crowed with delight. 
 &bquo;You men are all the same. 
 A girl wouldn't be safe with one of you.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's not our fault,&equo; Ted said complacently. 
 &bquo;If your nature is fire, all you can do is burn.&equo;  
 Nurse Bodkin pointed overhead and simpered. 
 &bquo;Aren't you going to honour the mistletoe?&equo; 
 Ted made a loose grab at her before continuing on his way. 
 When he was at a safe distance, he turned and cal led. 
 &bquo;You're a terrible woman altogether to be leading a fellow on like that! 
 I'd better go before you tempt the two of us into dismantling and abusing the sacred structure of the Sixth Commandment.&equo; 
 In the back ward a fiddle had struck up. 
 Two or three couples began to dance. 
 The rest sat and watched. 
 &bquo;More women is what we need,&equo; the men cheered as Nurse Lambert and Richard walked in. 
 &bquo;It isn't safe to come in here.&equo; 
 Nurse bodkin winked in delight as she waltzed past. 
 &bquo;Dance, Nurse, dance,&equo; the men roared, surrounding Nurse Lambert, who was young and attractive and popular. 
 &bquo;Later,&equo; she smiled and held out her arms to Richard. 
 He was disturbingly aware of her as they moved off. 
 Her arms, which were bare to the elbows, were freckled and lightly downed in the artificial light. 
 He began to wonder about her life outside the hospital. 
 &bquo;Do you like dancing, Nurse?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;Yes, I do,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;And don't call me Nurse. 
 My name is Keelan.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's an unusual name.&equo; 
 &bquo;It shouldn't be, then. 
 It's Irish. 
 Caol  and fionn  &mdash; slender and fair.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; he said, eyeing her dark hair, &bquo;it half suits you anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nobody's perfect,&equo; she laughed. 
 As soon as the dance ended she was swept away by somebody else. 
 Richard sat on a bed and watched her for several dances before claiming her again.  
 &bquo;I thought you were never going to rescue me,&equo; she teased. 
 Just as the dance was finishing she drew him towards the door. 
 &bquo;Let's get out of here before the mob swamps us again.&equo; 
 Richard opened the door and they slipped away. 
 Their going was noticed and raucous cheers followed them. 
 Out on the corridor, Keelan took her stand under the mistletoe. 
 &bquo;Well, aren't you going to kiss me?&equo; 
 Richard put his arms awkwardly about her and brushed her lips with his. 
 &bquo;Happy Christmas!&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Maybe it will be &mdash; yet!&equo; she laughed and, taking his hand, led him into a storeroom and closed the door. 
 Sometime in the early evening a bel 1 rang and there was a flurry about Mike Quinn's bed. 
 Screens were pulled, lurching and swaying on screaming castors, the curtains swelling like sheets in a squall. 
 Sister Cooney came, a calming influence, with a syringe in a kidney dish. 
 Later she was seen phoning from the office. 
 A nurse remained by the bed monitoring Mike's pulse. 
 An hour passed before there was another flurry, this time from the corridor. 
 The voice of Doctor O'Connor-Crowley, like a racing-engine snarling through the gears, bore down on Sister Cooney, who sat writing in the office. 
 &bquo;Inconsiderate!&equo; she roared. 
 The office door shuddered behind her, and a baying, as of hounds savaging each other, filled the suddenly silent wards. 
 Presently they erupted like twin explosions to examine Mike Quinn. 
 &bquo;This man is dying,&equo; Doctor O'Connor-Crowley shouted. 
 &bquo;There's absolutely nothing that anyone can do.&equo; 
 She snapped the screens together as she emerged. 
 The sound was as final as the closing of a coffin lid. 
 She looked down through the wards where the festive celebrations had momentarily stopped. 
 On a sudden impulse she was  off, shouting as she went, &bquo;What's going on here? 
 Why aren't you people in bed? 
 This is a hospital &mdash; not a hotel. 
 Sister! 
 Sister! 
 Who gave these patients permission to have alcohol? 
 Who authorised this? 
 Back to your wards. 
 Back to your beds. 
 What, in God's name, has anyone here to celebrate?&equo; 
 When everybody was suitably chastened and miserable, she left, cannonading down the corridor in great rolls of receding thunder. 
 Near the stairhead she met Phil, who was emerging from a game of cards in one of the single rooms and had missed all the theatricals. 
 &bquo;A Happy Christmas, Ma'am,&equo; Phil oozed &mdash; the day that was in it and a little whiskey fortifying his courage. 
 &bquo;What's happy about it, you stupid little man!&equo; she cried. 
 &bquo;Don't you realise that it's the last Christmas most of you in here are ever likely to see?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wasn't that a terrible thing to say to anyone?&equo; 
 Phil poured complaint into the receptive ear of Sister Cooney, as he sought comfort at her door. 
 &bquo;Don't mind that one,&equo; she soothed. 
 &bquo;Here's a bit of news that'll cheer you up. 
 Her tour of duty is almost done. 
 She'll be leaving for good before the New Year. 
 What do you think of that, now?&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll celebrate for a week,&equo; Phil exulted. 
 &bquo;We might even take longer!&equo; 
 Sister Cooney smiled. 
 &bquo;Happy Christmas, Phil!&equo; 
 At tea-time the momentum of the day &mdash; or what was left of it after Doctor O'Connor-Crowley's intrusion &mdash; petered out and things began to sag. 
 People sat about, replete and vacant. 
 Ghosts of other Christmases began to walk and nudge. 
 Downstairs, Elsie Hogan, the bloom of youth scoured from her skeleton, lay waiting for the haemorrhage that would end it all. 
 Her hair clung in damp strands to her forehead, emphasising  the whiteness of her face with the starkness of a black border on a mourning card. 
 Behind his screens, Mike Quinn gagged on ropes of his own phlegm but was considerate enough to hang on a little longer. 
 Everyone was asleep before the night nurse came on Rim, hunched and still, a smile on his wasted features in the soft halo of torchlight.  
 Frank looked up in surprise when Matron walked in. 
 The morning was her usual time for coming, a flurry of nurses preceding her, squaring comers of blankets, clearing lockers, thumping pillows, crisp and antiseptic as they swept through. 
 Then in their wake, a stately schooner under full sail &mdash; Sister Cooney bobbing like a fretful tug in attendance &mdash; she hove in sight, a strongly-timbered woman, solid and soundly ballasted. 
 &bquo;Someone to see you, Mr O'Shea,&equo; Matron said, a concerned look on her face. 
 Frank sat up, a faint alarm bell ringing in his head. 
 It would have to be some unusual visitor to be thus announced by Matron. 
 &bquo;Is anything wrong?&equo; he enquired. 
 &bquo;Inspector O'Connell wishes to speak to you,&equo; Matron said gently. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid you must prepare yourself for a shock. 
 He has some very distressing news.&equo; 
 &bquo;Kitty!&equo; 
 Frank exclaimed. 
 &bquo;What's happened?&equo; 
 &bquo;Your wife has had&hellip; a very serious&hellip; accident,&equo; Matron said hesitantly. 
 She beckoned to someone outside and a garda inspector walked in. 
 &bquo;Where? 
 How? 
 How is she?&equo; 
 Frank raised himself laboriously in the bed, before subsiding weakly into the pillows.  
 &bquo;Perhaps,&equo; the inspector said, when the introductions had been made, &bquo;you would leave us, Matron. 
 I think it might be easier on Mr O'Shea if I spoke to him alone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; Matron said. 
 &bquo;Ring for Sister or myself if you need us.&equo; 
 The inspector accompanied her to the door and closed it carefully after her. 
 He laid his cap, containing his gloves, upside-down on the locker. 
 &bquo;What happened? 
 Why are you here?&equo; 
 Frank asked. 
 &bquo;Your wife&hellip; &bquo;the inspector began. 
 &bquo;Is she dead?&equo; 
 The inspector looked at Rim keenly as he spoke, measuring his words, gauging the reaction. 
 &bquo;There was a fire&hellip; &bquo;he began. 
 &bquo;Oh my God!&equo; 
 Frank covered his face with his hands. 
 The inspector's evasive reply was sufficient answer to his question. 
 &bquo;We did all we could,&equo; the inspector said. 
 Frank began to shake his head violently. 
 &bquo;Not dead!&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;She can't be dead!&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sorry to have to bring you this terrible news,&equo; the inspector said. 
 He turned away to face the window, a tall man with grizzled, close-cropped hair. 
 There was silence in the room for some time as he waited for Frank to regain his composure, to ask the inevitable questions. 
 The gutter beneath the window, he noticed, was half-choked with a black silt, the residue of dead leaves. 
 &bquo;How did it happen?&equo; 
 Frank asked at last. 
 &bquo;We're not sure. 
 We think an oil heater may have overturned &mdash; or perhaps it was left too close to some curtains. 
 It started in the bedroom. 
 The fire brigade from town was on the scene within twenty minutes of the alarm and got it under control very quickly. 
 But when we broke in, they were dead.&equo; 
  &bquo;they? 
 &bquo;O'Gorman, the bartender, and your wife. 
 Smothered &mdash; the two of them.&equo; 
 &bquo;The two of them&hellip; 
 &bquo;Frank echoed the words, then lay with his head sunk on his chest, a man in a stupor. 
 Silence again in the room, a long, agonising silence. 
 &bquo;Would you like me to call someone? the inspector enquired, looking at him anxiously. 
 &bquo;Smothered, you say? 
 &bquo;Mercifully, yes. 
 The fire hadn't touched them at all.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who raised the alarm? 
 &bquo;One of our men on patrol. 
 He noticed the flames and the smoke.&equo; 
 The inspector coughed apologetically and placed his hands together, uncertain how best to say what had to be said next. 
 &bquo;There's&hellip; something&hellip; else,&equo; he began slowly. 
 Frank lifted his head and looked at him, waiting for him to continue. 
 &bquo;&hellip; something you should know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes? 
 &bquo;The&hellip; ah&hellip; manner in which they were found would seem to indicate that both had been drinking heavily. 
 There were a number of bottles and glasses in the room. 
 The doctor found a very high alcohol content in their blood.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, God!&equo; 
 Frank moaned. 
 The inspector looked at his sunken head with compassion. 
 It was a distressing part of his duty to have to tell people things they were better off without hearing. 
 &bquo;They died in their sleep,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There's something you're leaving out,&equo; Frank said suddenly in a harsh tone. 
 &bquo;Isn't there?&equo; 
 The inspector sighed with relief. 
 He had been wondering if the  man suspected, wondering how he could prepare Rim for the final crushing rev elation. 
 &bquo;What do you mean? he asked carefully. 
 &bquo;They were together? 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;In my wife's room?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;In bed together?&equo; 
 &bquo;It seems so. 
 Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;Christ Jesus, damn the whoring pair of them!&equo; 
 Frank cried and tumed away, covering his face with the blankets. 
 Richard read of the fire in the newspaper on his way back from the county hospital. 
 It was the kind of tragedy that so often called for sympathy &mdash; a momentary sympathy and thrill of horror, mixed with shamefaced satisfaction that it had happened to someone else -before one passed on to less disturbing news. 
 But it was different when someone you knew was involved. 
 It couldn't be dismissed so easily. 
 He had become friendly with Frank since he had moved into Commander Barnwell's room. 
 He had helped Rim with his exercise. 
 They had talked. 
 &bquo;Dreadful, isn't it? said Keelan Lambert, who was accompanying him. 
 He tried to imagine what it would be like to get such news. 
 Husbands and wives were bound by deep ties-like two branches grafted together. 
 He remembered little things &mdash; childhood images trapped in memory: his father's hand laid momentarily on his mother's as they sat at table; laughter from their bedroom at night; his mother straightening his father's tie and drawing her finger in a delicate gesture along his cheek. 
 &bquo;The poor man was just beginning to pull round after his operation,&equo; Keelan said.  
 Richard touched his finger reflexively to a light dressing on the left side of his neck where it met the collarbone. 
 The wound was beginning to smart a little. 
 &bquo;Giving you trouble, is it?&equo; 
 Keelan asked. 
 &bquo;Stings slightly. 
 That's all.&equo; 
 To supplement the work of the new drugs, Doctor Staples had decided that the phrenic nerve in his neck should be temporarily crushed. 
 This would relax the diaphragm and push up his lung. 
 The introduction of air into the peritoneal cavity would push the lung up even further and give the diseased part a chance to rest. 
 &bquo;The operation didn't take long, anyway,&equo; Keelan comforted. 
 &bquo;You could hardly call it an operation &mdash; ten minutes on the table and a local anaesthetic,&equo; Richard replied. 
 He laid aside his paper and allowed himself to be lulled into a rhythmical vacuity by the swaying of the ambulance. 
 Through the glass in front, he watched the greying head of Marty with the topped end of a cigarette behind his left ear. 
 Keelan was a soothing presence beside him. 
 Their bodies touched gently and came apart as they rounded a bend. 
 Their steadying hands met along the seat. 
 She let her fingers linger on his and smiled. 
 &bquo;Don't look now,&equo; she squeezed his hand, &bquo;but old spoilsport is watching in the mirror.&equo; 
 They laughed in shared amusement. 
 He felt suddenly happy at being alive. 
 It was something he had not felt for a very long time. 
 Frank's door was closed when he got back and there was a notice on it saying that he was not to be disturbed. 
 He was under sedation, Sister Cooney informed Rim, and was best left alone until he had absorbed the shock. 
 The following morning Richard was taken down to the treatment room and given his first induction of air. 
 The experience  was enough to keep him preoccupied for some time. 
 He spent most of that day wrestling with discomfort and nausea. 
 Whenever he sat up, the preserve on his chest was intense. 
 His stomach seemed to be floating on a rising tide that compressed it against his sternum. 
 At the back of his mind was the fear that he had been given too much air, that his lungs could not sustain the pressure, that they would collapse as Commander Barnwell's had collapsed. 
 The notice was off Frank's door by the time he was able to move about again and the door itself was open. 
 It was late afternoon, with the darkness already lurking in the comers, when he went in. 
 Frank was lying back on the pillows with his eyes closed. 
 Richard was about to slip out again, when he stirred and opened them 
 &bquo;I hope&hellip; 
 I haven't disturbed you,&equo; Richard said awkwardly. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Frank said in a tired voice, &bquo;not at all.&equo; 
 &bquo;I&hellip; read about it in the papers,&equo; Richard said, not knowing how to begin. 
 &bquo;I'm very sorry.&equo; 
 Frank grasped his proffered hand and said nothing. 
 &bquo;It must&hellip; have been&hellip; a dreadful shock.&equo; 
 &bquo;God help us all!&equo; 
 Frank said and turned his head away. 
 He roused himself with an effort, sniffed and shook his head vigorously. 
 &bquo;Sit for a little, like a good fellow.&equo; 
 Richard sat on the side of the bed and looked at the floor. 
 &bquo;It's a strange world, isn't it? he said. 
 &bquo;Youth is the best time,&equo; Frank said quietly after a while. 
 &bquo;There's still hope then.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 The room was full of darkness now, except for a bright triangle near the door where the light from the corridor fell. 
 &bquo;I was twenty-three that summer,&equo; Frank whispered. 
 &bquo;There'll never again be a summer like it. 
 Never!&equo;  
 Richard sat helplessly and listened to him cry. 
 There was nothing he could say, nothing he could do. 
 Like the sun peering from behind a cloud, Arty began to brighten and beam again. 
 The notice came down from his door. 
 One day it was there and the next it was gone. 
 Neither Sister Cooney nor the doctors made any comment, but its disappearance was noted. 
 Ted Nugent, as might be expected, showed no such delicacy. 
 &bquo;How's the typhoid or whatever-it-was, then? he asked. 
 &bquo;I could have been a little hasty in my diagnosis,&equo; Arty allowed with an embarrassed smile. 
 &bquo;I'm no doctor, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can say that again!&equo; 
 Ted laughed. 
 &bquo;Hey!&equo; 
 Arty said, anxious to change the conversation. 
 &bquo;Do you remember Vincent Finn? 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 What about him? 
 &bquo;I had a letter from Rim. 
 He's in a sanatorium in England.&equo; 
 &bquo;What could he expect &mdash; running off like that!&equo; 
 Ted was indifferent to Vincent's fate. 
 &bquo;The fellow was out of his&hellip; 
 &bquo;He stopped carefully, remembering Arty's condition. 
 &bquo;He had no sense.&equo; 
 &bquo;He may be coming back, you know,&equo; Any said, ignoring or not noticing Ted's remark. 
 There was something about the prospective return of Vincent that cheered Rim. 
 &bquo;He says the doctor over there is trying to arrange it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Coming back here? 
 He must be off his&hellip; he must be joking!&equo; 
 Ted said. 
 The letter from Lily came on the morning of the funeral. 
 It lay around the office for a day or two, until someone had time to open it and send it back with a brief note, giving the time and circumstances of Elsie's death.  
 The letter itself had been short, its tone bleak. 
 Lily was on the point of having what might yet prove to be only the first stage of a thoracoplasty. 
 There were complications that she didn't understand &mdash; something to do with the fluid they kept draining off, something arising out of the chronic empyema. 
 The doctors were so evasive that it was impossible to get anything definite from them. 
 She now suspected that they had known long before and were breaking it to her gradually. 
 She was very depressed and pessimistic about the future. 
 Vincent was getting treatment again. 
 She spent most of her time in tears. 
 She was sick with worry about everything. 
 It's like being caught in huge sticky web&ndash; the more you struggle, the more entangled you get. 
 Did you ever feel that it would be nice to give up struggling and close your eyes and sleep and never wake any more? 
 She lay propped up in pain and wondered when it was she had begun to loathe her body &mdash; she who had always been so proud of her figure and liked to pirouette in front of the glass after stepping from her clothes, admiring the slim smoothness of her thighs, the trim concavity of her belly, the neatness of her breasts, her skin with the sculptured texture of marble, her neck slender as the stem of a wineglass, and the bound-up hair in which fire lurked and leaped. 
 Pain was a living organism grafted into her. 
 It gnawed at her like a ravenous animal. 
 It burned and raged through her like a fever, until she began to imagine that she was no longer herself, no longer human at all, but the heart of fire, the savage tooth, the embodiment of the very essence of pain. 
 What was she now but a maimed thing, repugnant and ugly, which no love could ever be large enough to embrace? 
 There could never now be that bridal night she had dreamed of, that uninhibited leap into love and happiness. 
 Vincent had sworn that he would love her to the grave and beyond. 
 What would he say, what would he think, what would he feel, if he saw her now? 
 It was as if the operation had excised her will to live. 
 She lay, apathetic, dull as the lustreless droop of her hair on the  pillows. 
 She had been taken back to Ardeevan and put in one of the observation wards. 
 But for her there was no sense of homecoming. 
 Mrs Doran was gone, Elsie was dead. 
 If Elsie could be taken so easily, what hope was there for anyone? 
 What was the use in struggling? 
 Better to surrender quietly to that hell of pain, to slide into it, to crumble and fold like burning straw, to merge and coalesce and become one with it, until, phoenix-like, she floated away on the other side, whole and free. 
 When her mother came and sat beside her, twisting her fingers nervously and pulling on and off her gloves, lifting and laying down her basket in agitation, Lily rallied a little. 
 Her father, a neat, spare man, sat on the bed and stroked her hand and said very little beyond the commonplace, putting all his affection and concern into that quiet gesture. 
 He scrutinised her face anxiously as she listened to her mother, and when her eyes turned languidly towards him, he smiled and stroked her hand more earnestly. 
 But when she turned back to her mother again, his face resumed its worried, searching frown of concentration, his ear attuned below the level of conversation to the pain and weariness in her voice. 
 Once, moved beyond composure by something he heard or saw, he rose abruptly and stood with his back to them, facing out over the sodden countryside. 
 Behind him his wife's voice went on, chiding gently about the fruit that had remained untouched on her locker, the meals returned uneaten. 
 &bquo;You'll have to try and eat, dear, to make yourself strong again. 
 If I peel an orange now, will you eat a little &mdash; just to please your father? 
 He took the day off from work specially to come with me. 
 He's worried about your not eating.&equo; 
 When they had gone, Lily cried for them in their helplessness, feeling, for all her weakness, stronger than them, realising that  it was easier to contemplate one's own death than the death of someone loved. 
 Something in their need of her pulled her back from the seductive slide into oblivion. 
 She would have to exert her will and fight against the pain-consuming darkness, if not for her own sake, then for theirs. 
 Old Barnwell is dead. 
 Mike Quinn is dead. 
 Elsie Hogan is dead. 
 Every week, somebody dead. 
 It's enough to drive any body off his rocker. 
 Talking of which, you'll laugh when you hear I went a bit bonkers myself for a while. 
 I don't know what came over me. 
 The Strange and Singular Lunacy of A. Byrne, you could call it! 
 Anyway, I'm OK again. 
 I got this notion that I'd some terrible disease&ndash; as if the Con wasn't terrible enough&ndash; and everybody would catch it off me. 
 The worst thing about it was that nobody would believe me until it was too late. 
 The old fellow even came to see me, so you know how bad I was. 
 seeing him, of course, didn't make me any better. 
 He just sat there, scratching his head with those black fingernails and telling my mother there was never anything like that on his side of the family. 
 It was all her fault, if you could believe him. 
 Maybe it was, too, because anyone would want to be a little round the bend to marry him&hellip; 
 It was easy now to write to Vincent about his father's visit in a flippant, amusing way, but it hadn't been like that at all. 
 &bquo;You'll disgrace us all,&equo; Arty's father had said. 
 &bquo;What will people say? 
 It's bad enough to have a son of mine in this place. 
 But getting treatment in the mad house!&equo; 
 &bquo;Wasn't I born and reared in a mad house? 
 Arty had retorted harshly. 
 &bquo;What do you mean, boy? 
 What do you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;He means nothing at all,&equo; his mother had intervened, &bquo;except that you've upset him. 
 Will you leave the poor fellow alone? 
 The doctor said he wasn't to be excited.&equo; 
 Then his father was off on another tack. 
 &bquo;It&equo; s them doctors is all  to blame. 
 I want a word with them fellows. 
 I want to know what they meant by sending a son of mine to &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm no son of yours,&equo; Arty interrupted. 
 &bquo;Are you out of your&hellip;? his father stopped and looked in a startled manner at his mother, who had given him a sharp dig, then began to cough. 
 &bquo;I think you're looking much better today, Arty.&equo; 
 His mother had stepped in to fill the embarrassed silence. 
 &bquo;Have you put on some weight?&equo; 
 Did I tell you Madeleine came to see me again shortly after you left? 
 She's better to talk to than write to, if you know what I mean. 
 I hardly ever write letters any more. 
 I got fed up of all that daft nonsense. 
 You were right about pretending. 
 She loves music and says she'd like to sing in a band. 
 If I was outside, she said she could telephone me every day for nothing, if I gave her the number of a phone box and arranged to be there for a certain time&hellip; 
 Madeleine's second visit had been before his long slide into melancholy. 
 During the succeeding weeks he had not written &mdash; except to send her an enigmatic note warning her to keep away. 
 Her response had been a spate of anxious letters which he had let accumulate in his locker. 
 When the cloud lifted, he had taken them out and read them. 
 Moved by her obvious concern, he had written to explain that he had been through a bad time, but was better now. 
 Madeleine replied with the news that she had been promoted and was moving to a town not twenty miles away. 
 &bquo;I'd be able to come and see you oftener &mdash; if you'd like me to, Arty.&equo; 
 He pondered the implications of this for a few days, uncertain whether to welcome it or feel alarmed. 
 It would mean telling her everything &mdash; and telling the full truth about himself had never been easy. 
 It would also mean giving the signal for the relationship to develop. 
 Did he really want it to continue? 
 Something in  the loneliness and fear he had experienced during his ordeal told him that he did. 
 She knows all about me being bonkers and everything and doesn't seem to mind. 
 she's coming to see me again soon. 
 Meanwhile his health was improving. 
 As soon as the visits to the mental hospital had ended, he had been put on streptomycin and PAS, like several of the younger patients. 
 The reputation of the new drugs had preceded them and a ripple of optimism ran through the sanatorium, though Doctor Staples had been careful to stress that they were still in the experimental stage. 
 But it would have taken a lot more than the doctor's understandable caution to dispel the general euphoria. 
 Richard was having a lean time. 
 He was in a state of perpetual nausea. 
 The ringing in his ears persisted. 
 He was sore from constant injections. 
 He could neither lie nor sit comfortably, and when he walked about, the pressure under his collarbone was intense. 
 Still, there was reason for optimism. 
 He had put on weight. 
 The sputum had decreased and for two successive tests had been negative. 
 Three negative reports in a row would be a strong indication that the disease had been arrested. 
 All that remained after that was to continue the treatment until the lesions calcified. 
 So for him the next test &mdash; whose result he was awaiting &mdash; would be crucial. 
 Meanwhile there was Keelan Lambert with whom he was developing some hind of tentative relationship. 
 She was stationed now on the male floor and visited him frequently &mdash; sometimes in the line of duty, sometimes for a few minutes when her work was finished, often &mdash; as now, when she should have been elsewhere &mdash; for an illicit cigarette.  
 &bquo;Congratulations!&equo; she said, as she blew smoke carefully through the open window. 
 &bquo;I saw it on your chart.&equo; 
 &bquo;Saw what?&equo; 
 Richard had laid aside his book to watch her, standing there with that bright, scrubbed freshness young nurses always seem to have. 
 &bquo;Your third test. 
 It's negative.&equo; 
 He smiled back at her, shaking his head, pleased but wary, in case it might be premature. 
 &bquo;Are you sure? 
 &bquo;Of course I'm sure. 
 I told you I saw it on your chart. 
 You don't seem very excited.&equo; 
 &bquo;I am excited,&equo; he laughed, &bquo;way down somewhere.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's the funny thing about you,&equo; Keelan said. 
 &bquo;There's such a lot of you way down somewhere. 
 You take life very seriously.&equo; 
 &bquo;Wouldn't you, if you were in my position?&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose so. 
 Anyway, it's good news, isn't it? 
 &bquo;Great!&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll be out before you know where you are.&equo; 
 &bquo;Will I?&equo; 
 &bquo;There you go again,&equo; she chided, &bquo;looking for trouble around every comer.&equo; 
 &bquo;There you go again,&equo; he laughed. 
 &bquo;It's always summer and you're walking through fields of daisies.&equo; 
 Since Christmas his feelings about Keelan were ambivalent. 
 He was flattered by her interest. 
 In the desert in which he found himself, her youth and beauty shone like some exotic bloom. 
 At times he felt tender and protective towards her, but sometimes he surprised himself by the hatred he felt for her, because she was healthy and free and had no need of him. 
 For her the world was full of young men whose bodies were untainted by disease and these &mdash; he persuaded himself &mdash; were the ones she really craved, having no care for him at all, except some morbid interest  in a diseased thing, which, presently, she would thrust aside with a disdainful shudder. 
 Sometimes, when he thought he might die, as Eileen had died, some deep and insatiable curiosity about life and living in him, some craving to take with him a deeper knowledge of women and their essence made him long to lie in love with her, to taste the sweetness of her mystery, to see the world just once from a vantage point where the lost and lonely flesh that is man and woman comes together in a healing synthesis. 
 An inquest had been held and a verdict of accidental death returned. 
 It was reported in all the newspapers. 
 But nowhere was there a mention of the exact circumstances in which they had been found. 
 Frank was grateful for that, at least. 
 Votes of sympathy were passed and the matter forgotten. 
 For a long time he was obsessed by the image of them in bed together. 
 It floated mockingly through his sleep and came like a mirage between his eyes and the daylight. 
 He saw them laughing carelessly together, ruttish and brutal in their casual coupling. 
 He saw their tangled limbs relax and slide into sleep, arms trailing. 
 He saw the spilled spirits and the creeping flames. 
 What had been her last thoughts? 
 Triumph after conquest? 
 Warm animal feeling of satiety? 
 Relief at the momentary quieting of a tyrannical appetite? 
 Disgust and self-loathing? 
 She would never find now whatever it was she had been looking for from life. 
 Neither would he, because all he had ever wanted was her love. 
 He prayed that she would be forgiven for being herself and following her nature. 
 He had tried to forgive her; there was nothing else he could do. 
 He prayed he might be forgiven whatever deficiency in him  had contributed to her waywardness. 
 All his life he had sought her pardon for the failure which she either could not or would not spell out for him. 
 He raked through their life together, looking for clues. 
 But nothing presented itself. 
 Was it some insensitivity in his nature that had failed to respond to the nuances of the relationship, some obtuseness of perception that had prevented him from seeing, as it still prevented him from understanding? 
 In an effort to distract him, Sister Cooney had encouraged Doctor Staples to draw up a new and exacting regimen of exercises for him which she would supervise herself. 
 She had him out of bed, touching his toes, bending and swaying with outstretched arms, leaning this way and that, rotating his hips, raising and lowering his shoulders, until his mind was numbed and he obeyed her commands like a robot. 
 Much of the exercise was done in front of a mirror so that he could see for himself and correct the sag on the right side where his ribs had been removed. 
 There was always the danger of curvature of the spine. 
 To correct the curve it was necessary to stretch the concavity and contract the convexity &mdash; in furtherance of which he spent a good deal of his time moving across the floor in a peculiar creeping posture, which Doctor Staples referred to as &bquo;Klapp's crawl&equo;. 
 He threw himself into the exercises with a hind of despairing frenzy. 
 If he kept himself occupied, there was less time to think. 
 Sister Cooney urged him to it. 
 She was in each morning like a circus trainer to put him through his routine. 
 She cracked her whip and he responded. 
 There was something brutal and, at the same time, patient and caring about her single-mindedness. 
 There was method in her toughness which he recognised and appreciated. 
 She was pushing his body to the limits of its endurance to divert and ease the strain on his spirit. 
 When the  exercises finished for the day, he relaxed into numbness, his mind free and floating on a gently rocking tide. 
 More and more, as the days passed, he returned to that early summer, sealing his mind agaInst what followed. 
 There was a hind of peace in forgetfulness. 
 But all the time, he was aware of the shutter in his memory; behind it, monsters prowled.  
 They were in the office, reviewing charts and assessing progress. 
 &bquo;Richard Cogley seems to be coming along nicely.&equo; 
 Doctor Staples lifted his eyes from the chart. 
 &bquo;We'll send him for another x-ray when he's completed his course of strep.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's made a remarkable recovery,&equo; Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Maybe we'll be able to count him as one of our successes yet.&equo; 
  &bquo;  She opened another chart and handed it to him. 
 &bquo;What do you think of Frank O'Shea?&equo; 
 Doctor Staples held the x-ray up to the light. 
 &bquo;He's quite a lot of muscle to build up there yet.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's very determined &mdash; makes a great effort with the exercises.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good!&equo; 
 &bquo;Tragic &mdash; about his wife &mdash; wasn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Worse even than it appeared,&equo; Doctor Staples said knowingly. 
 &bquo;She was a lively piece, from what I hear &mdash; flying her kite all over the place. 
 I believe she and the barman&hellip; 
 &bquo;He raised his eye brows and stopped. 
 &bquo;I was wondering about that,&equo; Sister Cooney said thoughtfully. 
 &bquo;But how can anyone be sure?  
 &bquo;I have it from the coroner himself. 
 They were found in&hellip; ah&hellip; compromising circumstances.&equo; 
 &bquo;Poor man!&equo; 
 Sister Cooney said. 
 &bquo;Does he know? 
 &bquo;Unfortunately &mdash; yes. 
 He had to be told.&equo; 
 He lifted his hands in a helpless gesture, then, letting them drop, he picked up the next chart. 
 &bquo;Did we -by the way-get some communication about that chap, Finn? 
 &bquo;There is a letter somewhere,&equo; Sister Cooney searched until she found it and handed it to him. 
 &bquo;They want to know when we'd have a bed. 
 It seems he's fit to travel.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm in two minds whether we should have him at all. 
 Fellows like him unsettle other patients. 
 How do we know he won't discharge himself again after a week? 
 &bquo;It wasn't the usual hind of thing.&equo; 
 Sister Cooney had sympathy for Vincent, who, until his departure, had been a model patient. 
 &bquo;You remember the incident of the girl and Doctor O'Connor-Crowley?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, yes, that&hellip; 
 &bquo;Doctor Staples said vaguely. 
 &bquo;There's a bed vacant in Ward 4.&equo; 
 &bquo;I have somebody for that &mdash; chap of seventeen. 
 Finn will have to wait his tum. 
 Interesting case this one. 
 Working in a flour mill. 
 Lung coated with the stuff. 
 It's essential to get him in straightaway. 
 Boy called James Reville. 
 I want him in this evening. 
 You'll have to shuffle people around and give him a room to himself &mdash; isolate him. 
 It's not TB, you see, but just as deadly for all that.&equo; 
 February was wet, with gales that howled up the valley and rattled the glass doors leading to the verandah. 
 The floor-covering near the doors was dulled with damp, like the bloom on a plum. 
 Because the rain blew in gusts, the doors were usually closed and the glass clouded and wept, and the  world closed in and nothing existed at all except a diseased crew, buffeted and windswept, butting their way through the void. 
 Yet there was a sealed-in-cosiness when darkness fell early and the lights came on. 
 The wind fretted and slapped, like the brush of an animal body against the glass. 
 It beat at the stonework and screamed about projections. 
 It hammered glass and roof with vicious bursts of hail. 
 The glass itself was converted into smudged mirrors which enlarged their ambience and distanced them from the storm. 
 It was the kind of weather Jack Carbery loved, when he could lie for hours, securely wrapped, and sleep &mdash; to wake again with the comfortable feeling that a warm meal was near and, after it, a pipe or cigarette and casual conversation with his friends. 
 There was nothing he had to do to earn it, or nothing to threaten his security, except a too-rapid recovery, which he daily prayed against and which a good God would surely not allow &mdash; at least until summer came in and clothed a scarred earth with kindliness. 
 His chronic disease, which erupted periodically like a benign volcano, was his insurance policy. 
 He saw the new drugs as a threat to his well-being, and lived in dread of the day when they might be prescribed for him. 
 It was pleasant to lie and think of other Februaries and see himself abroad at dusk in the fields under a chilling rain, standing in a cart hunched up against the storm, bending and rising and bending again to toss turnips to the streaming cattle, listening to their soft thud in the mud and the straining of the horse as his hooves sucked and sank, the cattle lowing plaintively and the sharp crunch of their scooping teeth. 
 Then back to the farmyard to untackle and fodder the horse, to strip off his own thatch of soaked sacking, and milk cows by the light of a lantern that swung from a hook in the roof and smelled sharply  in contrast with the milky smell of steaming cows and the less agreeable smell of fresh dung. 
 Supper at the kitchen table &mdash; bread coarsely cut and buttered, with none of the little refinements that were considered necessary for the family, who ate in another room. 
 His clothes steaming as he bent to light a cigarette from a blazing splinter on the open hearth. 
 Then out to his bed in a loft over the cowshed, leaving the family to draw in together in a cosy, alien-excluding unit around the flaming and hissing timber, to lie and smoke by the light of a candle and think o better days in the orphanage and wonder in unembittered fashion &mdash; for he had been happy there &mdash; about the mother who had abandoned him and the even shadowier lover who must have abandoned her. 
 No one was likely to recommend that a hopeless old chronic like him should be put on the new drugs at this stage, because they were still in short supply and there were many more interesting patients on whom to experiment. 
 But Jack didn't know that and, even if he had known, it would only have given him a false feeling of security, because the threat from streptomycin, when it came, was not of a hind that he could have imagined or foreseen. 
 The first week of February had barely passed when Doctor Staples fired a warning shot across his bows. 
 &bquo;Beds! 
 Beds! 
 Beds!&equo; 
 He bustled in one day, rubbing his hands, a fashion of his when he had something unpleasant on his mind. 
 &bquo;What am I going to do for beds? 
 Do you know how many people I have waiting for that bed or yours, Jack? 
 Carbery looked at him warily, his eyes pleading not to be involved in such dangerous speculation, and shook his head slowly without speaking. 
 &bquo;Half a dozen, at least. 
 Isn't that right, Sister?  
 Sister Cooney looked sympathetically at Jack, but was constrained to nod in agreement. 
 &bquo;I could empty out this whole ward and fill it before evening with four new patients &mdash; four I could help, Jack; four that need help and need it now.&equo; 
 Jack looked at the blankets and said nothing. 
 &bquo;It's the new Health Act &mdash; with free hospitalisation for infectious diseases,&equo; the doctor explained to Sister Cooney. 
 &bquo;It's the new treatment as well. 
 GPs have cottoned on to it and are clamouring for beds. 
 They're building new sanatoriums &mdash; Ardkeen, Sarsfleld's Court, Merlin Park -but until they're open, the pressure is on.&equo; 
 He flicked through Jack's chart and snapped it shut abruptly. 
 &bquo;Put him down for x-ray, Sister, and we'll see.&equo; 
 When they were back in the office again, Sister Cooney drew the matter down. 
 &bquo;That poor man has nowhere to go,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;He's no family. 
 The people he's staying with don't want him.&equo; 
 &bquo;We're running a sanatorium, not a retirement home,&equo; Doctor Staples said harshly. 
 &bquo;Malingering is a luxury we can no longer afford to subsidise.&equo; 
 &bquo;We can't throw him out in this kind of weather.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I suppose not,&equo; Doctor Staples sighed. 
 &bquo;Maybe we could fix him up in the county home,&equo; he said thoughtfully after some reflection. 
 &bquo;Get on to them, Sister, will you? 
 Sometimes after the exercises, Sister Cooney stood and talked, while Frank lay back in bed, his breathing like the wind through dry leaves, and a rusty flush on his cheekbones. 
 Frank was an easy man to talk to. 
 He listened &mdash; at first with a curious air of detachment, as if he was an observer from another civilisation, or someone whose own experience had come to an end, someone  who was waiting to embark on a journey and looked at the world with vacant eyes, his mind already in transit. 
 Hers was a friendly and comfortable presence and he was grateful to her for it. 
 he was surprised at himself, at first, for feeling grateful, for being able to feel anything at all. 
 He was surprised at himself for looking forward to her arrival and the hard, punishing exercises; for feeling anxious, if her coming was delayed; for hoping she would linger a minute afterwards and talk about the weather or some unusual flurry on the corridor. 
 The first time she brought him flowers &mdash; a posy of crocuses in a glass jar &mdash; he suddenly and unaccountably wept. 
 She excused herself hurriedly and left, returning with a great bustle to announce her coming, when she had given him time to compose himself. 
 He was sitting up, holding the jar in his cupped hands, admiring the delicate curve of the petals. 
 &bquo;It's a long time since anyone brought me flowers,&equo; he smiled apologetically. 
 &bquo;They're nice, aren't they?&equo; 
 Sister Cooney said. 
 Then, without a pause, but with a sharp change of tone and inflexion, she was the starched, crisp, efficient Sister. 
 &bquo;Now, if you'll hop out of bed and slip on your dressing gown, we'll start.&equo; 
 Vincent had written to tel 1 her that he was coming back. 
 He wondered how she was and why she wasn't writing. 
 He was worried about her silence. 
 It wasn't like her. 
 He would be coming over by boat and a male nurse would come with him as far as D&uacute;n Laoghaire. 
 He could travel well enough on his own, if only they'd let him. 
 But that was the way they did things over there &mdash; well-meaning but fussy. 
 She would have to drag herself out of her lethargy and write. 
 Some patients got others to write for them when they were low, but there was nothing Lily wanted to say to Vincent that she  could ask anyone to write. 
 She seemed to lack all will or decision. 
 In the early days after the operation, when she was tightly bound in a many-tailed bandage to which weights were sometimes attached, and with drainage tubes still trailing from her, she had managed to scribble notes to him almost every other day. 
 Now, more lightly bound and sitting more comfortably in what the doctors called &bquo;Fowler's position&equo;, she found many reasons for indecision and delay. 
 The irreversibility of her mutilation lay like a fallen tree across her spirit. 
 She no longer combed and preened herself. 
 When the nurses &mdash; who, to encourage morale, insisted that every patient, however ill, should wash &mdash; came to help her, she submitted with an indifference that alarmed them. 
 She suffered meekly the humiliations of the bedpan. 
 Something in her that had, at first, revolted in anger and frustration at her own helplessness, now shrivelled and atrophied. 
 She would lie for hours &mdash; days even, for she had lost all interest in time &mdash; in an abstraction of pain, her bruised mind slipping and struggling and relapsing into a slough. 
 The future, which once had seemed to her a long, grassy vista into distant sunlight, was now a black impenetrable vapour, blowing towards her menacingly, like some poisonous gas, and threatening to envelop her. 
 She would have to write to Vincent. 
 His name broke into syllables, fragmented further into letters, and whirled, like flecks of butter in a chum, round and round in her mind. 
 Round and round, intermittently, through the days it spun, crystallising now and again &mdash; before breaking apart once more &mdash; into the essence of him, an image, like sudden flashes on a screen, of his diffident smile when they first met, the touch of his hand on her elbow as he guided her to a seat down that summer lane. 
 What could she say to him except that she felt her life &mdash; their life together &mdash; slipping away; that whether she survived or slid  wearily from her broken body, there was no longer any prospect of happiness for them; that he should forget her and make his own world without her? 
 The letter, when she came to write it-painfully, word by word over many days &mdash; was quite different to what she had intended. 
 I love you and that's all I know&ndash; all that's worth knowing. 
 If only we realised in time, we wouldn't waste our lives on trash. why is the best thing in the world tied to the least lasting? 
 If only I could see you&ndash; just once? all our drams, Vincent, where are they? 
 Our end is like our beginning&ndash; we know nothing 
 She read it over many times, letting her tears fall unchecked on the page. 
 She hoped Vincent would understand, would draw consolation from the knowledge that her life had not been empty, because her love would live on, wanning with its humanity a cold and, possibly, hostile universe.  
 Arty was sitting up in bed, his hair shining from a liberal application of something that looked and smelled like perfumed vaseline and came from a jar labelled Easi-Gro. 
 Over his pyjamas he had put on a new Fair Isle pullover which had been his mother's Christmas present. 
 He was busily pruning his nails with a pair of scissors and trying to make up his mind about the proper degree of flippancy to adopt for his conversation with Madeleine, when the romance of his afternoon was suddenly eclipsed by the strident voice of his father, grating like a rusty wheel on a dry axle. 
 &bquo;I was looking for you all over. 
 Since when did they move you down here?&equo; 
 &bquo;What are you doing here? 
 Is it the end of the world or what?&equo; 
 Arty looked at him without welcome. 
 &bquo;I was expecting a visitor.&equo; 
 &bquo;A lady, God help us, by the dolled-up look of you. 
 Isn't your father visitor enough for you?&equo; 
 He wiped his drooping moustache with the back of his hand. 
 Arty had a whiff of his alcoholic breath as he leaned forward to sit. 
 &bquo;Are you on a booze-up or what? he asked belligerently.  &bquo;that's what I get for coming to see you and your mother in bed with the flu,&equo; his father protested indignantly. 
 &bquo;Is she all right? 
 There was concern in Arty's voice &mdash; a concern that seemed to annoy his father. 
 &bquo;I was ten times worse myself and got over it on my feet,&equo; he said in casual dismissal, opening his raincoat and reaching inside for a cigarette. 
 &bquo;You don't smoke, I suppose.&equo; 
 He waved the box vaguely in Arty's direction, extracted a cigarette, lit it and immediately started to cough. 
 &bquo;You'll kill yourself with those things,&equo; Arty said in a tone in which hope was mingled with disgust. 
 &bquo;Devil a much you &mdash; or anybody else &mdash; would care!&equo; 
 Arty acknowledged by his silence the truth of the remark. 
 &bquo;Why did they shift you down here?&equo; 
 His father leaned back and blew smoke towards the ceiling. 
 Arty looked round at Jack Carbery and the five others who had been moved to the ground floor with him. 
 &bquo;Shortage of beds,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;This used to be a recreation room. 
 People are dying to get in here now. 
 Did you know that? 
 &bquo;God, you're a gas tum!&equo; 
 His father's laugh changed quickly into a prolonged cough. 
 &bquo;Dying to get out of here too,&equo; Arty said. 
 &bquo;Don't push your luck,&equo; his father advised, rubbing his eyes with his finger. 
 &bquo;Tel 1 us,&equo; he continued, &bquo;a butty of mine came in here last week, Sandy Cooper &mdash; you know Sandy from Chapel Lane? 
 Where would I find him? 
 &bquo;Upstairs,&equo; Arty said, feeling suddenly cheered. 
 &bquo;Maybe you'd better go up and see him &mdash; now.&equo; 
 &bquo;No hurry,&equo; his father said. 
 &bquo;He won&equo; the going any place, will he?&equo; 
 &bquo;Listen,&equo; Arty pleaded in desperation, &bquo;will you do me a favour and feck off up to see him I told you I was expecting someone. 
 Sandy'll be delighted to see you.&equo;  
 &bquo;That'll be a change from my son, won't it?&equo; his father chided. 
 &bquo;Sure, I'll go up to Sandy, but first I want to see this great one you're expecting.&equo; 
 He raised one end of his moustache in a sardonic grin. 
 &bquo;It's nobody you'd know,&equo; Arty sniffed shortly. 
 &bquo;Nobody I'd know!&equo; his father mimicked. 
 &bquo;Is she a black woman or what &mdash; you're so ashamed of her? 
 They both looked up together as the door opened and Madeleine came hesitantly forward. 
 &bquo;This is her!&equo; 
 Arty hissed. 
 &bquo;Now, will you go?&equo; 
 &bquo;God, you're doing all right for yourself,&equo; his father's rasping voice filled the ward. 
 Madeleine stood to look around, then, seeing Arty, smiled and walked towards them. 
 &bquo;Where'd you pick her up? his father whispered as he stood and raised his hat in a gesture that was too elaborate. 
 &bquo;Sshhh!&equo; 
 Arty said, a cloud on one side of his face, while the other turned with a smile to greet Madeleine. 
 &bquo;Hello!&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Hello, Miss!&equo; 
 His father nodded agreeably and settled his hat back on his head. 
 &bquo;Goodbye!&equo; the dark side of Arty hissed. 
 &bquo;You'll find your man upstairs.&equo; 
 His father brushed the chair he had been sitting on and, with a flourish, invited Madeleine to sit down. 
 He showed no inclination to leave. 
 &bquo;How are you, Arty?&equo; 
 Madeleine smiled, then looked in an enquiring way towards his father. 
 &bquo;This is&hellip; my father. 
 He's just going,&equo; Arty said ungraciously. 
 He was twisting his fingers and not at all at ease. 
 &bquo;Pleased to meet you, Miss.&equo; 
 His father extended his oil-blackened hand for her to shake.  
 &bquo;Pleased to meet you, Mr Byrne. 
 My name's Madeleine.&equo; 
 She shook his hand firmly and sat down. 
 There was a pause as they looked at one another and adjusted their minds to the needs of conversation. 
 Arty's father was the first to speak. 
 &bquo;What line of business would you be in? 
 I'm in bicycles myself.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's a first cousin to Sir Walter Raleigh,&equo; Arty ventured and laughed nervously. 
 &bquo;He's a real comedian, this fellow,&equo; his father appealed to Madeleine, &bquo;isn't he?&equo; 
 Madeleine laughed and looked in amusement at Arty. 
 &bquo;Would you be in the bank or that? his father probed. 
 &bquo;I'm a telephonist,&equo; Madeleine said. 
 &bquo;Give us a ring sometime!&equo; 
 Arty was getting more and more desperate. 
 &bquo;On the wireless he should be,&equo; his father said. 
 &bquo; Much Binding in the Marsh  or something like that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't forget your man upstairs,&equo; Arty pleaded. 
 &bquo;Terrible weather, isn't it?&equo; 
 Madeleine said conversationally. 
 &bquo;Did you come far?&equo; 
 Arty's father asked. 
 &bquo;Your man is in Ward 4,&equo; Arty prompted. 
 &bquo;He was enquiring about you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Tryin, to get rid of me.&equo; 
 His father looked at Madeleine archly. 
 &bquo;You'd better mind yourself with this fellow. 
 Doesn't want his old man around doing gooseberry.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know which of you is the greatest joker,&equo; Madeleine laughed. 
 Arty's father stood up and patted his hat lower on his forehead. 
 Two's company,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;A man knows when he's not wanted.&equo; 
 &bquo;Any sensible man would,&equo; Arty said sourly.  
 His father opened the lid of Arty's sputum mug and dropped the butt of his cigarette inside. 
 &bquo;I'll see you on the way back.&equo; 
 &bquo;No need to hurry,&equo; Arty told him. 
 He leaned over to catch his father's sleeve and hissed, &bquo;No feckin' need to come back at all!&equo; 
 His father ignored him and smiled graciously at Madeleine. 
 &bquo;On the telephone, eh? 
 I could never get the hang of them things at all.&equo; 
 &bquo;You get used to it,&equo; Madeleine said. 
 &bquo;We'll be seein' you, then.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not if we can see you first!&equo; 
 Arty spat. 
 At the door his father turned to wink familiarly at Madeleine. 
 &bquo;Mind what I said, now, girlie,&equo; he grated in a raucous roar that turned all heads. 
 &bquo;Your man there is a quare hawk, I'm tellin' you. 
 Look at him &mdash; throwin' his eye up your skirt &mdash; and it no time at all since he gave up wettin' the bed!&equo; 
 Most of the hour Richard spent pacing up and down the corridor, stopping at windows to look out between the buildings at bare trees and transparent hedges. 
 By the end of February he was on a second hours' exercise, and Sister Cooney, who had watched his restless pacing and had seen that he was bored, found him some light work to do. 
 &bquo;That library is in a right mess since Jim Kielthy took it over,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You're a fellow who's fond of books. 
 How would you like to arrange and classify and catalogue the lot?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd love to,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Good! 
 I'll fix it for you with Matron.&equo; 
 The following day she was back with a hard-covered, exercise book and a pot of glue. 
 &bquo;Everything's arranged. 
 Your first hour &mdash; or as much of it as you care to spend there. 
 The book is for the catalogue. 
 The glue is for pasting the various classifications on to the shelves. 
 Kielthy won't trouble you, by the way. 
  We've&hellip; ah&hellip;,&equo; she smiled, &bquo;retired him on pension. 
 Jack Carbery will take on the distribution of books. 
 Jack's a good careful fallow. 
 You can explain to him about your system and he'll put the books back where he found them.&equo; 
 &bquo;Right!&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;When do I start?&equo; 
 &bquo;Now if you like.&equo; 
 Her smile broadened. 
 &bquo;I'll have Nurse Lambert take you down in the lift. 
 Matron says she may give you a hand today &mdash; or, indeed, at any time when things are slack on the wards.&equo; 
 Richard blushed like a schoolboy. 
 &bquo;I'll send her down to you,&equo; Sister Cooney laughed. 
 At the door she could not resist a parting shot. 
 &bquo;I suppose you could classify her under &bquo;Romance&equo;.&equo; 
 There was a skittishness about Sister Cooney lately, he noted. 
 She was more than usually cheerful. 
 He wondered if it was the promise of spring. 
 &bquo;hike all nurses, you're a martinet at heart,&equo; Frank gasped. 
 He stopped swinging his arms and stood with hands on hips, looking at her, his head and shoulders heaving. 
 He sat down on the bed and let his arms sag. 
 &bquo;Thanks, Sister &mdash; for the push and all. 
 I needed it.&equo; 
 He felt grateful to her for dragging him out of the pit and back into the daylight. 
 It was a drab light and there was no great cheer in it, but it was, at least, better than the dark. 
 He joined his hands and sat looking down at them, watching his thumbs circle each other like wary combatants. 
 &bquo;There's something I'd like to tell you,&equo; he began slowly, &bquo;That is, if you wouldn't think it an intrusion.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't have to tell me anything.&equo; 
 Sister Cooney sensed that he was about to confide something that he might later regret. 
 Patients &mdash; under the stress of emotion &mdash; sometimes did that.  
 &bquo;It wasn't much of a marriage, you know,&equo; he said after a while. 
 &bquo;Are you sure you want to talk about it?&equo; 
 &bquo;That made it worse, you see. 
 There was nothing to hold on to. 
 You have more to reproach yourself with. 
 You feel more guilt. 
 You think of all the things you might have done and didn't. 
 You feel like a climber who unties the rope when he finds it irksome and, because of your carelessness, someone behind slips and falls to his death.&equo; 
 &bquo;Frank,&equo; Sister Cooney said quietly, &bquo;I know all about your wife's death.&equo; 
 He raised his hand to his mouth in a gesture of dismay and held it suspended there a few inches from his face. 
 &bquo;All?&equo; he whispered. 
 &bquo;All.&equo; 
 &bquo;About herself and&hellip; 
 O'Gorman&hellip; too?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 So you know and I know that you, of all people, have nothing to feel guilty about.&equo; 
 Frank covered his face with his hands and sat rocking himself backwards and forwards, like a child seeking comfort in a healing rhythm. 
 &bquo;Who else knows? he asked. 
 &bquo;Doctor Staples &mdash; no one else.&equo; 
 He lowered his hands and looked at her. 
 &bquo;I'm glad you know. 
 I wanted to tell you.&equo; 
 He gestured helplessly &mdash; an awkward, futile action without grace in it. 
 &bquo;You mustn't think badly of her, though,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;No &mdash; and you mustn't ever again think badly of yourself.&equo; 
 &bquo;You see, I knew her.&equo; 
 Frank allowed his tears to flow unchecked. 
 &bquo;Nobody else did. 
 Nobody else at all.&equo; 
 There were fears that the chronic empyema, which the thoracoplasty had been expected to cure, would recur on the other side. 
 Lily had experienced pain there and her temperature fluctuated  wildly. 
 Doctor Staples had examined her carefully, then called for cannula and trocar and performer the aspiration that she had been assured would never again be necessary. 
 He drew off some fluid and relieved the pressure, then went back to the office, where he shook his head gloomily as he pored over the report that had come back with her from Seapark. 
 If the thing persisted, her only remaining lung would collapse under a bag of pus and she would die, because she could no longer breathe. 
 Lily lay in mild shock afterwards, while nurses fussed about her with hot-water bottles and held a cup of strongly sweetened tea for her to sip. 
 Her mind was capable of thinking of nothing at all. 
 She felt battered into numbness by the sustained assault on her diminishing reserves. 
 She felt her spirit shrivel in her, withdrawing in alarm from the coldness of her extremities. 
 Her eyes were closed against the glare of lights overhead, but still their dazzle came through. 
 It occurred to her hazily that her own condition was like that of a bulb she had once seen when the power had been suddenly cut down and the light had dimmed to the faintest red glow in the filament.  
 The library was a comfortable brown room with tall windows to floor level and doors opening on to the terrace with its crumbling balustrade and ornamental urns. 
 The books were housed in mahogany bookcases which covered the walls from floor to ceiling. 
 In the centre of one wall there was a Palladian mantelpiece in grey marble and above it a shield, bearing the coat of arms of the Challoner family. 
 The room had one long table with half a dozen chairs ranged around it. 
 The carpet was a faded red. 
 The floor at the edge was stained a dark oak. 
 A few cane chairs with bright cushions stood near the windows, whose heavy drapes matched the carpeting. 
 To open the door and step inside was to leave the atmosphere of a hospital. 
 This, and the musty smell of books, was its chief attraction for Richard. 
 On the shelves, the books themselves were in a chaotic jumble, stacked in piles, or stuffed in, spine first. 
 The disorder pleased hIm. 
 There would be hours of satisfying work in sorting and rearranging. 
 &bquo;Did you ever see such a mess!&equo; 
 Keelan laughed. 
 &bquo;Where on earth are we going to start?&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll clear one shelf onto the table here, and then we'll see.&equo; 
 &bquo;We may as well start at the top, then.&equo; 
 She dragged over a  stepladder, climbed it, and began to hand him books. 
 When the shelf was cleared, she stepped down and asked, &bquo;Now, what? 
 &bquo;We'll make a rough division into fiction and nonfiction for a start,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We can subdivide later.&equo; 
 They sorted through the books and divided them into two lots. 
 Then they replaced the nonfiction temporarily, as the volumes came to hand, and started on the second half. 
 The sight of her body, poised above him as she stretched and leaned, distracted him, and he stood to watch her, until she turned with a questioning half-smile to hand down another bundle. 
 &bquo;Perhaps you've had enough for today?&equo; 
 Keelan was suddenly gone and Nurse Lambert was in her place. 
 &bquo;You sit there. 
 I'll put the nonfiction back with the rest. 
 We can leave the fiction on the table until tomorrow.&equo; 
 On the way up in the lift she was herself again and kissed him hurriedly between floors. 
 But it was Nurse Lambert who stepped briskly out of the lift and escorted him to his door. 
 He was not sure which he wanted her to be and was still puzzling about it next day when she called to take him down. 
 She was a pleasant girl, but he didn't really know her. 
 He felt now that it was impossible to know other people until one saw how they reacted in extremity or under pressure. 
 He had known very little about himself until he was face to face with death. 
 Eileen's death had made the lot of them aware of depths in themselves and in each other that they had not known of before. 
 &bquo;Are you going back to university?&equo; 
 Keelan asked as they worked. 
 &bquo;You're talking about a world that seems light years from here. 
 I can't even begin to think about it.&equo; 
 He walked over to the window and tapped on the glass. 
 &bquo;I'm a goldfish in a bowl,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That may or may not be reality out there. 
 I don't know any  more. 
 The whole thing may be an illusion. 
 Do you realise I haven't walked on grass for almost a year? 
 &bquo;It's still the same grass.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I'm not the same person. 
 I don't mean just physically &mdash; that, too, of course. 
 I'll never be the same again,&equo; 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 &bquo;Because so many things that seemed important aren't important any more.&equo; 
 What was important now? 
 People, friends, someone to love &mdash; and beyond that nothing at all. 
 Frank folded the brief letter from his solicitor and put it back into its envelope, before tossing it negligently aside. 
 &bquo;That's that!&equo; he said with an expansive feeling of well-being. 
 &bquo;As of Friday last, I am without house or home &mdash; and I never felt better.&equo; 
 Sister Cooney looked at him with a polite, questioning smile and waited for him to continue or change the subject, as he thought fit. 
 &bquo;I've sold out, lock, stock, and barrel &mdash; particularly barrel &mdash; because I hated that pub,&equo; he explained. 
 &bquo;It's something I always wanted to do.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've sold the lot?&equo; 
 &bquo;The pub, the land, everything!&equo; 
 &bquo;But where will you live? 
 &bquo;Hotel, guesthouse, somewhere&hellip; &bquo;he said vaguely. 
 &bquo;Anywhere &mdash; as long as it's not Moyalla. 
 I'm tired of country villages where everybody lives in everybody else's pocket.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about your job?&equo; 
 &bquo;Time enough to worry about that. 
 I could always retire on disablement pension, find some quiet town, a town on a river, where there'd be some fishing. 
 I might buy a little business,  maybe a newsagency &mdash; pipes, tobacco, a few books, stationery, fishing tackle. 
 There'd be time to read, have a chat with people, walk in the sun, make a new life.&equo; 
 &hellip; 
 I could have belted him with a bicycle chain. 
 What's the use in having ould fellows, when you don't need them any more? 
 If they had any understanding or decency in them, they'd die and leave you in peace. 
 Mothers are all right, I suppose, you'd miss them fussing about the place, but ould fellows are like that hind tits of a cow&ndash; no good for use or ornament. 
 all they ever do id booze and belch and kick up a stink and take the best seat at the fire. 
 There ought to be a law against them. 
 Madeleine said she didn't mind, but you could see his lordship was going down like a dose of castor oil. 
 Still, she didn't puke outright and that's something. 
 But the afternoon was done for. 
 She's a grand girl, though. 
 She's coming again soon. 
 About Lily, all I know is that she's not well. 
 She hasn't been for a long time. 
 But don't worry. 
 The news that you're coming soon will lift her out of it. 
 Mrs Moore sat with Lily's pale hand in hers and talked with desperate gaiety about the coming of spring. 
 What she did not say &mdash; what she could not say &mdash; was that the cold high days with their lengthening light terrified her. 
 Their brittle and unsettling promise had already crept into the dark comers of her house and laid bare its emptiness. 
 Winter had been a huddle of darkness and hoPe, but now spring laid its probing finger on the hidden dust and called for recognition and ruthless change. 
 Already it was whispering at the roots of grass, inciting it to rise, breathing on sheltered primroses, preaching its false gospel of resurrection and renewal, while underneath, the rot continued, the trampled snail returned to clay and beauty drew sustenance from a grave. 
 She looked at Lily's shrunk and sanded face, abstracted on  some pinnacle of pain, and saw it lanced by the fierce thrust of grass and sucked dry by the brutal assault of flowers. 
 She clasped her daughter's hand in despair, as if she would pull her back from the falsely-beckoning light. 
 The faint pulse of Lily's wrist under her fingers was a knife-twist in her heart. 
 &bquo;Don't give in, love!&equo; she whispered fiercely. 
 &bquo;Don't give in!&equo; 
 Lily's hand fluttered negatively in her own and a harrowed smile, fleeting as a wind's breath, stirred her lips and then they stretched back again into a tense, bloodless rictus. 
 Mrs Moore hadn't understood much of what Sister Duggan had told her about the recurrence of fluid and the aspiration that was again necessary. 
 But she understood well enough that her daughter's life was slipping away. 
 She sat on the bed, as on the sand of some ebb sea, surrounded by a vast loneliness. 
 Early March with crows tumbling and swooping about the verandah after flung crusts, scraping the air in hoarse conflict. 
 Jack Carbery, fully dressed, sat on a chair beside his bed, looking up at them. 
 The world, he thought, was a competitive place and the weakest went without. 
 His cardboard suitcase lay ready, and he looked stiff and awkward in his shiny suit of blue serge and clumsily knotted tie. 
 He watched as a homemaker, winging high, dropped its bundle of thin twigs and pushed itself into a steep dive to join the scramble. 
 At half-ten the ambulance would arrive to bring him to the county home. 
 He took out of his waistcoat pocket a large watch which he had bought years before from a cheap-Jack at a fair. 
 It was a quarter past. 
 The watch was reliable. 
 It kept good time. 
 He had paid ten shillings for it. 
 It was the kind of thing a man might pass on to his son some day &mdash; if he had a son. 
 He noticed a ragged old crow fall away from the raucous  throng and glide to the ground. 
 It stood about patiently until a crust dropped, then approached it with a sideways hopping motion and began to tear it. 
 The old and the weak had to counter strength with cunning. 
 Jack stroked the watch affectionately with his finger and returned it to his pocket. 
 Its strong beat had been a friend beside his ear at night as he lay thinking, or when he woke to have a quiet smoke in the darkness. 
 With his few belongings it was home to him wherever he went. 
 Its stopping would be like a death in the family. 
 Doctor Staples had got him a place in the county home. 
 There was a little work to do, fetching and carrying about the kitchens, for which he would get ten shillings a week. 
 It would be enough to keep his pipe pleasantly burning. 
 More crusts fell from the vicious scramble overhead. 
 The old crow selected the largest one and dragged it to safety, out of the way of a pair of young birds chasing them down. 
 He would get to know the cook and ingratiate himself by being agreeable and doing her favours. 
 It was the best way to make a snug billet for himself. 
 There was nothing to be got from being disagreeable or testy. 
 It would be important to be on the right side of the nuns too. 
 A punctilious attention to prayers and strict religious observance would win their indulgence. 
 There was a good living to be had for a shrewd man in an institution. 
 He was best to be free of the humiliations and the uncertainties of the farm. 
 Patients were flocking in for the new treatment. 
 He no longer resented the loss of his bed. 
 The future was more secure than he had ever dreamed possible. 
 He would be back from time to time, but never again as a mendicant. 
 His illness would stand to him in the other place too. 
 With his history, no great physical demands could be made on him.  
 When the ambulance arrived, Sister Cooney came down to see him off. 
 &bquo;Well, Jack, how do you feel about your new home? 
 &bquo;Fine, Sister, fine! 
 God is good. 
 He never closes one door but he opens another.&equo; 
 He lifted his suitcase, which was light enough, and held out his hand. 
 Sister Cooney took it and shook it warmly. 
 &bquo;They'll look after you well there,&equo; she smiled. 
 &bquo;If they don't, let us know and we'll get on their track.&equo; 
 She accompanied him out to the ambulance and closed the door behind him. 
 As it slid down the avenue the old crow, which had risen and was circling warily, dropped down again to its crust. 
 Sister Cooney stood and watched it in mild amusement, before turning and walking thoughtfully inside.  
 &bquo;Well, well, well!&equo; 
 Frank laughed. 
 &bquo;I never knew this Kielthy character was an atheist.&equo; 
 &bquo;What makes you think he is?&equo; 
 Richard laid an armful of books on the table and strolled over to where Frank was sorting through a shelf. 
 Frank drew out a heavy copy of the Douay Bible and held it up. 
 &bquo;Who else would put this under fiction?&equo; 
 He brought the Bible over to the table and sat down. 
 It was pleasant to be among books again. 
 He liked their feel and smell. 
 It had been Sister Cooney's idea to take him down to help in the library. 
 He was on an hour now and making good progress. 
 Cogley was a nice quiet chap and they got on very well together. 
 &bquo;Have you seen his censored list?&equo; 
 Richard asked. 
 &bquo;I found them wrapped in a brown-paper parcel with &bquo;Dirty Books&equo; scrawled on the outside with a purple pencil.&equo; 
 &bquo;What kind of books did the learned Jim censor?&equo; 
 Frank smiled. 
 &bquo;Would you believe, The Way of All Flesh ? 
 &bquo;The title bothered him, I suppose,&equo; Frank laughed. 
 Light splayed from his glasses as he looked up, glasses that  brought into the room high-scudding clouds and an airy scrawl of branches. 
 &bquo;What was the thora like? 
 Richard asked suddenly, impelled by the curiosity that drives people to stare at and question the survivors of some calamity. 
 Frank rubbed his cheek thoughtfully with the heel of his fist before replying. 
 &bquo;Actually,&equo; he said, &bquo;it's like so many things in life &mdash; something you go through with once, because you have to. 
 But you'd die rather than face it again.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who's talking of dying on a fine day like this?&equo; 
 They looked up to find Sister Cooney standing there. 
 There was something youthful and springlike about her crisp, starched stance. 
 She glanced at the book-laden table and at the general disarray. 
 &bquo;I'll have to send for Jim Kielthy to clear up this mess,&equo; she laughed. 
 &bquo;I might have guessed that too many cooks&hellip; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Actually, what you're looking at is creative disorder,&equo; Frank protested lazily. 
 &bquo;We've been making great progress.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can see that!&equo; 
 There was some nuance of intimacy in her tone that made Richard look up in surprise and then look at Frank. 
 What he saw surprised him even more. 
 It seemed to him that he had intercepted some secret communication between them. 
 Sister Cooney picked up a pile of books and began to replace them on the shelves. 
 &bquo;Enough for today,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Any more progress like this and we'll be back where we started.&equo; 
 She tumed to Richard, &bquo;Oh, that reminds me,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I've some good news for you. 
 Doctor Staples says you may take a turn on the walks from now on. 
 Half an hour will be enough to start with. 
 You may take a stroll before you go up, if you wish. 
 Frank and myself will put the rest of these back.&equo; 
 Richard looked out at the sun and the trees with a quickening heart. 
 For so long he had wondered if he would ever walk abroad  again. 
 Sister Cooney opened the French windows and he felt the air sweet on his face. 
 &bquo;Half an hour and no more,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;And when you come in, take the lift back up. 
 You're in no condition yet to tackle the stairs.&equo; 
 It was strange walking out after so long. 
 It was like entering a new element. 
 The free play of air around him defined and set the limits of his body in a way that he had completely forgotten. 
 The exposure was a little frightening at first and instinctively he kept close to walls. 
 Stepping off the concrete path onto gravel was a new sensation and he felt himself slide and stumble. 
 The gravel came up, hard and irregular, through the soles of his slippers. 
 Walking on it safely was a skill he would have to relearn. 
 He stepped back onto the concrete and came round to the front of the building where the flowering cherries were just coming into bud on the lawn. 
 He stood and looked at them sway, feeling a unity with them as his body swayed to the same light breeze. 
 A desire to touch them, to feel the smooth hardness of living wood again, brought him across the tarmacadam to the grass, which felt spongy and cool under him. 
 There was a sensuousness about it that filled him with a desire to run shouting across it, to roll in it, to bury his face in it and sniff life out of its roots, to draw up his childhood from the green stems, to lie supine and shade his eyes from the sun and dream himself back into nature. 
 He had forgotten how things smelled. 
 He pulled a fistful of grass and crushed it to his face. 
 He sniffed at the warm bark of the cherries. 
 He punctured the skin with his nail and tasted the sap. 
 He chewed ribs of grass and swallowed green saliva. 
 Out on the path again, he plucked and crushed a bay leaf and retired into the fragrance of his cupped hands. 
 Wherever he walked, spring came at him with a rush, overwhelming him with sensation. 
 He  felt like an infant staggering uncertainly out of doors for the first time into the infinitude of the universe. 
 At the decaying gate-lodge the ambulance stopped and Vincent got out. 
 It was the last of several stops on the way down from D&uacute;n Laoghaire. 
 His stomach still felt queasy and he was grateful for the fresh air. 
 He leaned against the door of the ambulance and drew in the mossed and woody scent of trees. 
 The call of rooks was loud in the pillared light, a call that was answered antiphonally, like receding echoes, from many quarters. 
 The sun had brilliance but no heat. 
 Somewhere near was the gurgle and trickle of water. 
 &bquo;All sight if I walk up a bit? he called to Marty, who was leaning forward with his elbow on the wheel and his open palm supporting his chin. 
 &bquo;As far as the last bend,&equo; Marty said. 
 &bquo;You're not supposed to be out. 
 You wouldn't want to get me into trouble, would you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just to the bend &mdash; to clear my head. 
 It's the last I'll see of the outside for a long time.&equo; 
 He turned and walked slowly up the avenue. 
 His legs were weak. 
 There was no elasticity in them and nothing at all of the swelling sap, rising around him. 
 &bquo;How bad it would be,&equo; Marty told himself callously as he watched him go, &bquo;to have your bed and your bellyful and no worries at all!&equo; 
 He had been up since five to meet the boat from which he was being exploited. 
 Vincent stood and wiped cold sweat from his forehead. 
 Twigs fell among the trees as the rooks rowed and ranted. 
 He pulled a sticky brown bud from a drooping chestnut and peeled it naked. 
 He held it to his nose and smelled its furry warmth, then spun it away from him with a twinge of regret at having torn it so  wantonly. 
 He was barely aware of the feeling. 
 It was no more than a shadow on his deepening melancholy. 
 Out of the same melancholy he grabbed irrationally at a whole branch, wrenched it off and tossed it among the trees. 
 In some frustrated way he felt in himself a deep affront at the prodigality and profuseness of life around him. 
 The rooks in their frenzy of building were an affront too. 
 There was nothing for him but a painful irony in their raucous clamour. 
 They were slaves of their own chemistry, following a blind biological urge. 
 What was in store for them and their young but the fox's maw, the poisoned grain and the angry scatter-shot of the farmer's gun? 
 Above him he heard the purr of engines, the slow, measured movement of cars in procession. 
 Another funeral. 
 He stood aside and leaned his back against the wire paling as the hearse came round the comer. 
 Whose turn was it this time? 
 He wondered if it was anyone he knew. 
 Look, he wanted to shout at the tumbling rooks, here is the only certain reality. 
 How efficient the place was &mdash; a model clearing house for death, turning out its yearly quota of corpses. 
 He blessed himself and dropped his eyes as the hearse passed. 
 There was a wreath of laurel, intertwined with daffodils, on the coffin. 
 People were walking after it &mdash; a young man about his own age with blank, staring face, a sobbing woman supported by her husband, and a girl, whose expression, as she passed, startled him. 
 It was some young person in the coffin &mdash; son or daughter snatched prematurely. 
 The girl's expression, her appearance, the set of her head? 
 He stepped out to have a better look. 
 The sudden movement brought him into the path of a mourner, whose elbow struck him a glancing blow and sent him reeling. 
 The man caught his arm and steadied him. 
 &bquo;Are you all right?&equo;  
 &bquo;I thought I recognised somebody there,&equo; Vincent said. 
 &bquo;Whose funeral is it? 
 &bquo;A neighbour of mine,&equo; the man said. 
 &bquo;Nice little girl she 
 Vincent felt his stomach heave with apprehension. 
 &bquo;What was her name?&equo; 
 &bquo;Gold bless us and save us!&equo; the man said. 
 &bquo;There's a power of young people after coming dead out of that place above.&equo; 
 &bquo;Her name? 
 Vincent pleaded. 
 The man looked at him with a kindly face. 
 He was short and middle aged and carried his cloth cap in his hand. 
 &bquo;A daughter of Paddy Moore of the Com Market. 
 That's who she was.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lily!&equo; 
 Vincent cried. 
 &bquo;Yes, Lily,&equo; the man said. 
 Vincent turned away and staggered to the wire and hung limp across it, his body trembling. 
 He heard with awful clarity, above the shuffle of feet and the soft roaring of cars, the croak and caw of rooks and their tattered scuffling overhead. 
 Lily! 
 The two of them holding hands in a summer lane. 
 The scent of her hair in the darkness. 
 Lily dead! 
 All our dreams, Vincent, where are they? 
 &bquo;She must not be dead,&equo; he shouted mutely. 
 &bquo;If Lily is dead, there's nothing left at all.&equo; 
 He pulled himself up and turned and ran down the avenue after her corps, past slow-moving cars, whose occupants stared at him curiously. 
 He brushed aside new-bursting buds that slapped at his face, until he stood by the rust-eaten iron gates, watching the hearse accelerate down the road. 
 The cars passed out, one by one, and sped after it. 
 &bquo;Hey!&equo; 
 Marty called from the ambulance. 
 &bquo;Get in.&equo; 
 Vincent walked out into the middle of the road and stood  there, his eyes fixed on the distant comer around which the hearse had disappeared. 
 A car stopped beside him and a friendly voice called, &bquo;Going to the funeral? 
 Vincent stared at the man blankly. 
 &bquo;Are you coming or not? 
 The man was getting impatient. 
 Behind him, cars were beginning to stop. 
 Vincent looked at him, as if seeing him for the first time. 
 &bquo;The funeral,&equo; the man said again. 
 &bquo;Do you want a lift? 
 He opened the door and waited. 
 As if in a trance, Vincent got in and sat down beside him. 
 The man let out the clutch and the car moved off.  
 The pale fire of spring daffodils warmed the room where Frank sat and read. 
 Now and again he looked up from his book, stared at them intently and smiled. 
 Even when he bent his head to the page, they came between him and the words. 
 Their light, like the tail of a comet, spread spectacularly across his mind. 
 After a while, he laid his book aside and sat there, his head tilted back, his thoughts adrift. 
 Soon he would be going out to start a new life. 
 It was an unexpected bonus for a man of fifty-one. 
 It would be foolish to expect too much after his experience, but there was an excitement in it, all the same. 
 He had cut himself loose from the past and had good hopes of making a comfortable landfall. 
 What was comfort only a roof over your head, a full belly, a fire, books to read and nothing on your mind? 
 Health too, of course. 
 &bquo;You remember our last conversation here? 
 Doctor Staples smiled. 
 &bquo;That was several lifetimes ago,&equo; Frank said, &bquo;But I remember.&equo; 
 He was seated again in Doctor Staples's office, watching the doctor examined his x-ray on an illuminated screen. 
 &bquo;I told you then your chances were good. 
 I can now tell you that you have exceeded our expectations,&equo; the doctor said.  
 &bquo;You consider it a success, then? 
 &bquo;Certainly I do. 
 You've done particularly w ell at the exercises.&equo; 
 &bquo;It was one hell of a job, then,&equo; Frank said, remembering the agony of the early days. 
 &bquo;Was, is and will be,&equo; Doctor Staples reminded him. 
 &bquo;It's something you'll have to continue for the rest of your life. 
 To ease off at any stage would undo all the good work.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't mind it now. 
 I've got used to it. 
 I rather like the whole penitential routine.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's the spirit! 
 Now, the next thing to talk about is when we can let you go.&equo; 
 He had been there so long, had been so doubtful &mdash; and, until recently, so indifferent &mdash; about seeing the outside again that the mention of discharge took him by surprise. 
 &bquo;You mean I may go soon?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, in a week or two. 
 We'll have another x-ray, do some final tests and let you off. 
 You'll have to report to the clinic regularly, of course &mdash; every week for a while and then once a month. 
 If all goes well, you may be able to go back to school when the new year starts in the autumn. 
 How do you feel about that? 
 &bquo;I'll have to think about it,&equo; Frank said vaguely. 
 He had practically made up his mind that he would never go back &mdash; certainly not to Moyalla and probably not to teaching. 
 But there was no point in bothering Doctor Staples with the complexities of his private life. 
 &bquo;What I mean is you should have a reasonably clean bill of health by then,&equo; Doctor Staples said. 
 He was tired of teaching, had already given too much of his life to it. 
 He was tired of respectability, tired of the constant tug-of-war to pull the lively minds of children out of the fields and hedges, where wisdom and philosophy began, into the abstractions of formal learning. 
 Too often he  had seen education serve no better purpose than to impose limits of caution and doubt on vision and imagination. 
 Far too often the village teacher was expected to be the creature of his employer, the school manager. 
 His public utterances were examined for heresy, his private life combed for scandal. 
 The good teacher was a safe man who spoke in mealy-mouthed platitudes, steeped himself in orthodoxy, made obeisance to all the right quarters, allowed his intellect and judgement to fossilise in the interests of&hellip; what? 
 His own security &mdash; a quiet, mindless life. 
 &bquo;Where will you go?&equo; 
 Sister Cooney asked. 
 &bquo;Into town for a bit. 
 I'll get a room somewhere: hotel, guesthouse. 
 What do you think? 
 &bquo;Guesthouse, maybe -less noise and you'd get more attention. 
 What you need is rest and good food.&equo; 
 &bquo;Guesthouse, then,&equo; Frank assented cheerfully. 
 &bquo;Would you like me to make enquiries?&equo; 
 &bquo;If it wouldn't be too much trouble.&equo; 
 It was no trouble at all. 
 Within a few days, she was back with news of a suitable place. 
 She had found a retired garda sergeant and his wife, whose family had grown and scattered, leaving them with a large house and room to spare. 
 They could offer him full board with a bedroom and sitting room on the ground floor for three pounds a week. 
 &bquo;It would be like having a flat of your own without the bother of preparing meals.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just what the doctor ordered,&equo; Frank said. 
 &bquo;Mrs Keane is a comfortable, homely person. 
 I think you'll like her. 
 The sergeant is easy-going. 
 He likes fishing. 
 Books too &mdash; they've a great lot of books.&equo; 
 &bquo;Anyone who likes fishing and books is all right with me.&equo; 
 It sounded a pleasant, civilised household to settle in until he  had time to look around him and decide about the future. 
 So, everything had been arranged. 
 &bquo;Will you come and visit me?&equo; 
 Frank asked tentatively. 
 &bquo;Are you just being polite, now, or do you mean that?&equo; 
 Sister Cooney looked at him closely. 
 &bquo;Of course I mean it. 
 Otherwise I wouldn't ask.&equo; 
 &bquo;Patients sometimes feel under an obligation,&equo; she explained, &bquo;and then, when the time comes, they regret it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not like that at all. 
 You should know that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; she said, &bquo;I think I do.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll come, then? 
 &bquo;I'd be delighted to.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll tell you what we'll do.&equo; 
 Frank took off his glasses and began to polish them in the sheet with enthusiasm. 
 &bquo;On your first evening off, we'll go out and have a meal -just a little celebration. 
 How about that? 
 &bquo;A little celebration would do you good,&equo; Sister Cooney said, hiding her pleasure. 
 &bquo;Lazarus rising from the dead and all that?&equo; 
 Frank laughed. 
 Arty sat in sombre mood, thinking of death. 
 Vincent had not tumed up and he wondered what he could possibly say to him when &mdash; or if &mdash; he did. 
 Death made little sense at the best of times. 
 Death of the young made no sense at all. 
 He sometimes wondered about his own death, but beyond thinking of himself on some long-distance collision course with annihilation, he could not imagine it. 
 He had seen so many people die. 
 At first it had been harrowing, but he had grown used to it. 
 It was possible to view the death of others in a detached way, even &mdash; if one were honest &mdash; to take pleasure in it. 
 There was the satisfaction of being a survivor, the morbid distinction of being first about with the news. 
 it made eating and doing a little more exciting to know  that someone else had just ceased doing these basic human things for ever. 
 He looked up as Phil strolled in, and the sight of him, standing there so ludicrously, so needlessly alive, made his mind veer like a weather vane in a high wind to a more frivolous way of thinking. 
 Phil, with his soft, sprawling face, looked like an excrescence &mdash; an unhealthy toadstool, swelling with yeasty exuberance out of decayed wood. 
 &bquo;Hey, Phil,&equo; he called, &bquo;did you ever think of dying at all? 
 Phil looked at him with bulging horror and searched around the metallic ward for some wood to touch, drumming his fingers at last in relief on the top of the locker. 
 &bquo;It's not right to be joking about things like that,&equo; he said. 
 He wondered if the effects of &bquo;the electric&equo; were wearing off and Byrne was going out of his mind again. 
 &bquo;It'll come one day and you'd be as well to be prepared.&equo; 
 &bquo;I trusts in God,&equo; Phil said. 
 &bquo;What more can I do?&equo; 
 &bquo;Make your will. 
 I'm going to make mine. 
 Will you witness it for me? 
 &bquo;It's not lucky to make a will. 
 Don't you know that?&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll make two,&equo; Arty said, reaching for some writing paper. 
 &bquo;Tell you what, Phil, I'll leave all I have to you, if you leave me your entire estate.&equo; 
 &bquo;What estate? 
 &bquo;Your tenements and hereditaments, as the lawyers say, your pleasure gardens, your fishing rights and the family jewels.&equo; 
 &bquo;Quit acting the cod, will you!&equo; 
 Phil said crossly. 
 &bquo;If that's the way you take it,&equo; Arty said, &bquo;I'll just have to leave it all to the ould fellow.&equo; 
 &bquo;What have you to leave to anybody? 
 Phil sneered. 
 Arty whistled cheerfully as he pretended to write. 
 &bquo;Last will and testament of Arthur Byrne, deceased&hellip; &bquo;  
 &bquo;It's not right, I tell you,&equo; Phil said. 
 &bquo;To my revered father, whose massive intellect has been a formative influence from my tenderest years, I leave, will and bequeath&hellip; &bquo; 
 &bquo;It's not natural for a son to be makin' fun of his father,&equo; Phil protested. 
 &bquo;That's where you're wrong, Phil ould son!&equo; 
 Arty laid down his pen and geared himself up for argument. 
 &bquo;It's the most natural thing in the world. 
 I read an article in Readers Digest  about this very clever fallow called Freud. 
 Do you know what he said about fathers and sons?&equo; 
 &bquo;Some daft fellow, I suppose,&equo; Phil scoffed. 
 Mow would I know what he said? 
 &bquo;He said it was natural for every son to want to kill his father and marry his mother.&equo; 
 Phil blessed himself quickly before speaking again. 
 &bquo;The dirty Communist!&equo; he cried, his voice trembling with shock. 
 &bquo;That class o&equo; talk is against the Catholic Church &mdash; against all the laws o' God and man. 
 That book should be banned. 
 People who say things like that should be locked up.&equo; 
 &bquo;Freud was a genius,&equo; Arty said, &bquo;The cleverest man of his day.&equo; 
 &bquo;He was a blackguard and no Catholic, whatever else he was!&equo; 
 Phil said. 
 He stood up to indicate thai the conversation was at an end and that he had no wish to be involved as a partner in such blasphemous and heretical talk. 
 When he had gone, Arty, smiling to himself at what he considered a victory, got out of bed and set off for the bathroom to wash his hair. 
 He took with him a towel and a bag, tied at the neck with a drawstring, a bag that bulged with jars and bottles, containing shampoos and pomades and lotions. 
 He whistled a tune as he strolled down the corridor. 
 Baldness, he told himself &mdash; and smiled at his own joke &mdash; was a receding problem. 
  Madeleine seemed to like him as he was, so why should he worry about something that wasn't important any more? 
 It was spring outside. 
 Sunlight lay on the grass. 
 He stood at a window and looked down over the trees, where rooks were crossing sticks in a light sway of air. 
 Like them, he was a survivor. 
 It was possible to think of a future away from this place.  
 EPILOGUE 
 Green thickened the hedges again. 
 Brown husks littered the paths under trees. 
 High above, the wind played a delicate tune through crumpled foliage. 
 Spring roared like fire through the grass. 
 It was a year since he had come up this steep, winding avenue. 
 He might have died &mdash; there was so little of his old self left. 
 He would be going out soon, but an umbilical cord would still tie him to this house of death. 
 Once a fortnight, he would come up the avenue and round that last bend and &mdash; with a tightening in his bowels &mdash; see it there, becalmed in the grass. 
 The spirits of Eileen and the Commander and of all who had died there, would crowd about him more densely than the blown petals of the flowering cherries. 
 Then voices would cry in the falling sigh of wind around its gables. 
 An old Ford, with straight back and matchbox rear window, laboured up the avenue. 
 He stood aside to let it pass. 
 In the back seat a thin face stared ahead. 
 It might have been himself a year ago. 
 When he came within sight of the front door, the car was parked outside and two men helping a third up the steps. 
 The young man leaned heavily on them, his head sagging loosely. 
 At the door Nurse Lambert stood waiting with a  wheelchair &mdash; crisp, starched, bright as the April sunlight. 
 She waved to him, before turning and wheeling her patient indoors. 
 The young man had seemed vaguely familiar. 
 He wondered what hIs condition was and whether he would survive. 
 Would he pull through and, like himself, fall in love &mdash; or imagine he was falling in love &mdash; with his nurse? 
 He wondered if falling in love with the nurse wasn't a necessary stage of convalescence. 
 Out here in the open, with the world large around him and light beckoning from beyond the horizon, it was not easy to fit Keelan into whatever lay ahead for him. 
 Inside it had been different. 
 With the universe narrowed to the four walls and death abroad in the corridor, she was womankind &mdash; the other half of reality. 
 Not to know her, not to love her (at the very least, not to want to love her) was to deny oneself the totality of experience. 
 Could he still love her when she had ceased to be a symbol and walked in the lesser light of her own individuality? 
 It was something that he would have to find out. 
 When he went upstairs, she was waiting for him. 
 &bquo;You look different in your clothes,&equo; she said, &bquo;almost like a stranger.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'd look different out of uniform. 
 You'd be almost a stranger too.&equo; 
 &bquo;We'd both be strangers, then, if we met outside? 
 &bquo;Maybe we would. 
 I don't know.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll be away home in a short while.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll be back for refills.&equo; 
 &bquo;They're always different when they come back,&equo; Keelan said. 
 &bquo;Things look different from the outside.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've been wondering about that,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It's the way of the world,&equo; she said with a wry smile. 
 There was something sad about the exchange &mdash; and a finality that he, by no means, approved of or desired. 
 There was still the possibility that when they did meet outside, it would be a  beginning, and not the end that neither wished for, but both half-expected. 
 &bquo;Time will tell,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Whatever happens when you go out,&equo; she said after a silence, &bquo;you must mind your health. 
 Don't be like poor Vincent. 
 You saw him coming in, didn't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;So, that's who it was!&equo; he exclaimed. 
 &bquo;I thought he looked familiar.&equo; 
 &bquo;Poor fellow!&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;He's in a bad way.&equo; 
 When she left him, he stood at the window for a long time, looking out over the newly-awakened countryside. 
 Below him in the valley, the river slid by greening banks, the infinity of space mirrored on its smooth surface. 
 He looked upwards. 
 Clouds uncoiled from the south-west with unhurried grace. 
 Above and beyond, the depths receded endlessly, mystery layered beyond mystery for ever.  
 PARISH OF ST THOMAS MORE &amp; ST HUGH OF LINCOLN with St Philip's Priory Begbroke 
 THIRD SUNDAY OF LENT Mass text p. 77 18th MARCH 1990 
 Fr Chris Bester 142 Oxford Road Kid 77093 
 Christ, the Spring of Life. 
 We share His life through the water of baptism which washes us clean and brings new growth into our lives. 
 BIDDING PRAYERS: 
 Lord hear our prayer And give us your saving grace 
 Let us pray for the sick members of our parish family. 
 Almighty Father, we commend to Your loving care all who suffer; grant them patience. 
 Cheer and uphold them with the knowledge of your love and restore them to full health. 
 We pray for Fr Donal Cahill, Alexander Johnson, John Lavery, Joyce Clarke, Joan Wright, Ann McGuckin, Joe Baron, Katy Murphy, Davina Hughes, Lin Webb, Doris Irwin, Elizabeth Woodward and Fr John Bradley. 
 Grant them healing and strength. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 Let us pray for the deceased members of our parish family. 
 Receive in tranquillity and peace, Lord, the souls of all your departed servants who have died recently, especially Barbara Martin. 
 We pray for all those killed each day in wars, disasters and accidents throughout the world; for prisoners of conscience; for Farzad Bazoft and all who die of torture, starvation and maltreatment; and for Margaret Tyrrell, John Rahilly, Ernest Cowley, George Smith, Eileen O'Connor, Peter Crawley and Helen Timms whose anniversaries fall at this time of the year. 
 Grant them forever the joy of your presence. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 LENTEN DEVOTIONS 
 Early morning Lenten Mass on Tuesday at 7.00 am. 
 Stations of the Cross and Benediction at Kidlington on Tuesday at 7.00 pm; at Woodstock on Wednesday evening at 7.00 pm. 
 The Bladon and Woodstock Lenten study group meets again on Monday evening in the new Methodist Hall at 7.30 pm to study chapter 3 of &bquo;God of Surprises&equo; by Fr Gerry Hughes, SJ. 
 Everyone is most welcome to join this happy company. 
 TODAY; 
 an appeal on behalf of &bquo;The Converts' Aid Society&equo; by Mr Keith Jarrett. 
 He will make us aware of the great hardships some people have to endure when they realise that to become a Catholic means making a tremendous sacrifice in their present lives. 
 Keith used to be the organist at St Mary's in Woodstock. 
 &bquo;LENT EXTRA&equo; 
 The very good little magazine is available again this week from the tables in the porch. 
 Please take one copy per family. 
 MARRIAGE PREPARATION COURSE 
 Monday and Tuesday evening 6.00 pm. 
 NEXT SUNDAY 
 there will be a celebration Mass for the children preparing for First Communion. 
 Last week I mistakenly told you that it would take place today, sorry. 
 COLLECTION 
 last week: Kidlington 285.77 Woodstock 123.46 Begbroke 72.85. 
 CAFOD 
 Any money saved from your family fasting on Fridays may be put into envelopes and placed on the plate at the offertory. 
 Offerings during Lent to this &bquo;third world&equo; charity will always be gratefully received. 
 Thanks to those of you who have already contributed. 
 You may also place offerings in the &bquo;CHARITY&equo; box in the back wall of St Thomas More church if you wish. 
 &bquo;CATHOLIC EDUCATION&equo; 
 is a marvellous new publication which is specifically for parents of pre-school children, to make them aware of the Catholic network of schools provided for them. 
 Too often some of our Catholic families are not aware of the existence of our excellent senior schools which provide for a solid Catholic education and a growth in faith for our children. 
 This publication sets out to remedy that fault and also offers important information about relevant educational changes taking place in all schools, which affects your child. 
 If you have a child of pre-school age please take a copy home today. 
 MOTHER AND TODDLER GROUP 
 meets at Blenheim Road Scout hut on Mondays from 1.30&ndash;2.15. 
 Lots of toys and activities and various refreshments available. 
 All for 50p per week. 
 Please contact Karen Dickens for more information; Kid 6104. 
 &bquo;FRIENDS OF THE SERVITES&equo; 
 will meet after the 7.00 pm evening Mass at the Priory on Wednesday. 
 Fr Paul Addison will celebrate his Silver Jubilee as a priest this year and a celebratory Mass of thanksgiving is arranged at St Mary's, Fulham Road on Saturday April 21st (Easter Sunday). 
 Any parishioner who would like to be present should phone Valerie Belton as soon as possible to see if a coach (or two) should be booked. 
 Val's phone no; 991 50405. 
 BARBARA MARTIN, 
 who was the mother of our previous parish priest, died last Sunday. 
 I phoned Fr Nick to express our sympathy and condolences and I said that we would offer 11.00 Mass to day for her. 
 May she rest in peace. 
 LENTEN READING 
 A selection of books may be found in the old baptistry at St Thomas More. 
 Please help yourself. 
 &bquo;TAIZE&equo; 
 There will be an evening of Taize-style worship and praise at the Priory on Thursday evening at 8.00 pm; refreshments to follow. 
 Please tell all your &bquo;ecumenical&equo; friends. 
 This is always a well-received evening. 
 CONGRATULATIONS 
 to some of our young parishioners who have hit the headlines recently. 
 Lisa Jackman, Tammy Arnold and Vicky Hann are champion gymnasts and Paul O'Keeffe is the junior County champion at 400 metres free-style. 
 Well done, everyone. 
 PARISH OF ST THOMAS MORE &amp; ST HUGH OF LINCOLN with St Philip's Priory Begbroke 
 SEVENTH SUNDAY OF EASTER Mass text p. 138 27th MAY 1990 
 Fr Chris Bester 142 Oxford Road Kid 77093 
 Jesus has returned to His Father. 
 We now await His Spirit to fill us with His love. 
 BIDDING PRAYERS: 
 Be with us Lord As we call on Your Name. 
 Let us pray for the sick members of our parish family. 
 Almighty Father, we commend to Your loving care all who suffer; grant them patience. 
 Cheer and uphold them with the knowledge of your love and restore them to full health. 
 We pray for Fr Donal Cahill, Alexander Johnson, John Lavery, Marie Grant, Joyce Clarke, Joan Wright, Ann McGuckin, Joe Baron, Katy Murphy, Davina Hughes, Lin Webb, Doris Irwin, Andy Lukes, Eileen Cassidy and Fr John Bradley. 
 Grant them healing and strength. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 Let us pray for the deceased members of our parish family. 
 Receive in tranquillity and peace, Lord, the souls of all your departed servants who have died recently, especially William Carroll and Cardinal Thomas O'Fiach. 
 We pray for all those killed each day in wars, disasters and accidents throughout the world; for prisoners of conscience and all who suffer from torture, starvation or maltreatment; and for George Swadling, Dermot Horgan, John Murphy, Robert Dunseath and Mary Bester whose anniversaries fall at this time of the year. 
 Grant them forever the joy of your presence. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 Benediction and Vespers at the Priory every Sunday at 6.00 pm. 
 PLEASE NOTE 
 time of Mass on Wednesday. 
 It will be the Mass which begins our day of prayer and adoration before the Blessed Sacrament. 
 A day of prayer for the spread of the Gospel and for an increase in vocations to the Priesthood. 
 The day of prayer at Woodstock will end with Benediction at 8.00 pm. 
 LAST SUNDAY 
 in the parish school we held our parish annual general meeting. 
 It was good to see those there voicing their opinions strongly about various aspects of parish life. 
 On Wednesday last I had an interview with the Archbishop and he asked me to leave Kidlington and go to a vacant parish in Birmingham (Rednal) where a friend of mine had died recently. 
 A new parish priest will be arriving here for next Sunday, whose name is Fr John Molyneux. 
 This is all very sudden, I know. 
 Its very upsetting in more ways than one and an awkward time for a change of priests so Fr John will want just a little time to settle in and feel at home. 
 I have been speaking to him on the phone and we have decided that it would be in everyone's interest to postpone First Holy Communion until the last Sunday of term, July 15th. 
 This will give Fr John time to meet and talk with the children, their parents and teacher. 
 We also thought that on the feast of St Thomas More, June 24th it would be a good idea to celebrate the feast in the evening in the school hall when we can all gather to meet for the first or last time and say &bquo;Hello&equo; and &bquo;Good-bye&equo; as appropriate. 
 This therefore will be my last Sunday with you and so I take this opportunity to thank you again for all your kindnesses to me and for the way you made me welcome when I arrived 5 years ago (doesn't time fly!). 
 Fr John is a lucky man to be coming to this parish. 
 I am sure that you will give him the same affirmation and support you gave to me when I arrived. 
 At college he was held in great affection and esteem by his fellow students. 
 He has a great sense of humour and will keep you all well-amused. 
 He was our college barber; and at a time when most of us were penniless he cut hair for a shilling (= 5p, to those who do not know what a shilling was). 
 And so we all had a close shave once a term. 
 We all called him &bquo;Mol&equo; abbreviating his name as students always do; and throughout the diocese he is known by all his brother priests as simply &bquo;Mol&equo;; and now I gather that his parishioners call him Fr Mol. 
 I asked him how he would prefer to be addressed and he said you can call him what you please, as long as it is polite. 
 APF 
 All promoters are invited to Courtfield, Ross on Wye on Sunday June 10th for the annual reunion. 
 Arrive anytime after 2.00 pm Bishop Mullins will celebrate Mass at 3.00 and tea will follow at about 4.00 pm. 
 Courtfield is the HQ of the APF and a lovely old building in a most beautiful spot. 
 Well worth the journey. 
 If interested, please contact Margaret 78356, Eileen 4129 or Mona 812134. 
 CLAY PIGEON SHOOT 
 A charity clay-pigeon shoot for the Romanian orphans will be held at &bquo;The Grapes&equo;, Yarnton on Sunday June 17th. 
 Please tell your friends. 
 CAFOD 
 Meeting on Thursday 31st May at 8.00 pm; 45, The Garth, Yarnton. 
 PILGRIMAGE TO WALSINGHAM 
 June 23rd. 
 Cost approx &pound;7. 
 Please ring Cliff (2715) or Marianne (6888) as soon as possible please. 
 CARERS 
 Summer picnic for Senior Parishioners. 
 At Walter and Molly Cowley's house, 23, Yarnton Road. 
 June 12th, 2.30&ndash;4.00 pm. 
 Pray for fine weather! 
 COULD YOU GIVE A CHILD A HOLIDAY? 
 WRVS arrange holidays for underprivileged children each year, aged from 6&ndash;12. 
 Could YOU help out? 
 Please contact WRVS OX. 
 53835 if you would like more information. 
 OUR WARMEST CONGRATULATIONS 
 to Jim Loughran and Bessie Embleton who were married at the Priory yesterday. 
 May the Lord bring them His comfort and peace. 
 PARISH OF ST THOMAS MORE &amp; ST HUGH OF LINCOLN with St Philip's Priory Begbroke 
 15th Sunday of the Year 15 July 1990 Page 34 
 Fr John Molyneux 142 Oxford Road Kid 77093 
 Jesus says &bquo;Happy are your eyes because they see, your ears because they hear!&equo; 
 BIDDING PRAYERS: 
 Lord, hear us: And bless us with a living faith. 
 Let us pray for the sick members of our parish family. 
 Almighty Father, we commend to Your loving care all who suffer; grant them patience. 
 Cheer and uphold them with the knowledge of your love and restore them to full health. 
 We pray for Fr Donal Cahill, Alexander Johnson, John Lavery, Marie Grant, Joyce Clarke, Joan Wright, Ann McGuckin, Joe Baron, Katy Murphy, James Ackroyd, Peter Ackroyd, Davina Hughes, Lynn Webb, Doris Irwin, Andy Lukes, Eileen Cassidy and David Kardus. 
 Grant them healing and strength. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 Let us pray for the deceased members of our parish family. 
 Receive in tranquillity and peace, Lord, the souls of all your departed servants who have died recently. 
 We pray for all those killed each day in wars, disasters and accidents throughout the world; for prisoners of conscience; and all who suffer torture, starvation or maltreatment; and for Martin John Hughes and Etheldreda Castle, whose anniversaries fall at this time of the year. 
 Grant them forever the joy of your presence. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 FIRST HOLY COMMUNION 
 The children of the parish are celebrating their First Holy Communion this week. 
 The First Holy Communion Mass begins at 10.30 am and NOT 11.00 am as usual. 
 KIDLINGTON FLOWER FESTIVAL 
 Proceeds for Christian Aid. 
 The Festival continues at St Mary's today. 
 SONGS OF PRAISE 
 To conclude the Flower Festival Songs of Praise will be held at 8.00 pm this evening at St Mary's. 
 Do come and join in. 
 A.P.F. 
 MISSIONS 
 (little red boxes!) 
 A cheque for &pound;290 has been sent for the June quarter. 
 Thank you all for your continued support and generosity. 
 CARDINAL NEWMAN CENTENARY MASS 
 The Centenary Mass for the Beatification of John Henry Cardinal Newman is being held at the Oratory, Birmingham, (NOT Rednal as it usually is) on Saturday 11th August, at 11.00 am. 
 Admission by ticket only. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 SONDRA BEUKEMA 
 is giving a concert in Kidlington Baptist Church on Thursday, 26th July, at 8.00 pm. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 CAFOD 
 Thanks to all those who came to the lovely Garden Party held in aid of CAFOD last Thursday evening. 
 &pound;80 was raised towards the Parish Project, bringing the current total raised to nearly &pound;200. 
 Thank you all. 
 FOS 
 There will be a short meeting of the Friends of Servites after the evening Mass on Wednesday 18 July. 
 Provisional total raised on the Fun Day is around &pound;1,800. 
 DEAR PARISHIONERS: 
 Congratulations and God's blessing on the children of the parish who make their First Holy Communion this week. 
 Please remember them in your prayers and ask God to guide them in the years to come, that they may continue to grow in love of him and of their neighbour. 
 Many thanks to those who worked so hard and so well to prepare the children. 
 Yours in Christ  JOHN F MOLYNEUX   
 &bquo;I got as far as unpacking my summer wear&hellip;!!&equo; 
 PARISH OF ST THOMAS MORE &amp; ST HUGH OF LINCOLN with St Philip's Priory Begbroke 
 20th Sunday of the Year 19th August 1990 Page 46 
 Fr John Molyneux 142 Oxford Road Kid 77093 
 With the Lord there is mercy and fullness of redemption. 
 BIDDING PRAYERS: 
 Lord, in your mercy; Hear our prayer. 
 Let us pray for the sick members of our parish family. 
 Almighty Father, we commend to Your loving care all who suffer; grant them patience. 
 Cheer and uphold them with the knowledge of your love and restore them to full health. 
 We pray for Fr Donal Cahill, Alexander Johnson, John Lavery, Marie Grant, Joyce Clarke, Joan Wright, Ann McGuckin, Joe Baron, James Ackroyd, Peter Ackroyd, Davina Hughes, Lynn Webb, Doris Irwin, Andy Lukes, David Kardus and John Tweddle. 
 Grant them healing and strength. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 Let us pray for the deceased members of our parish family. 
 Receive in tranquillity and peace, Lord, the souls of all your departed servants who have died recently. 
 We pray for all those killed each day in wars, disasters and accidents throughout the world; for prisoners of conscience; and all who suffer torture, starvation or maltreatment; and for Charles and Catherine Ellul, Bernard Murphy, Thomas Connolly, Kathleen Donohue, Betty Butler, Michael Sweeny, James Flood, Helen Anonuevo, and all whose anniversaries fall at this time of the year. 
 Grant them forever the joy of your presence. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 While I am away please note that there will only be weekday Masses on Monday and Friday. 
 Please note also that for this week ONLY the evening Mass at St. Philip's Priory, Begbroke has been transferred from Wednesday to Thursday evening, for the Feast of St. Philip Benizi, at 7.00 pm. 
 Friends of the Servites are invited to a reception afterwards. 
 There will be a sharing table and all are welcome to come. 
 LITURGY SHEETS FOR YOUNGER PARISHIONERS 
 with things to colour or do are available at the back of the church and in the cry room. 
 Parents please help yourselves, and use them to help your children &mdash; take a copy home with you if you wish. 
 A new sheet is available each week. 
 Any helpful suggestions or comments would also be welcome. 
 THE ANNUAL DIOCESAN PILGRIMAGE TO THE SHRINE OF THE ENGLISH MARTYRS AT HARVINGTON HALL 
 takes place this year on Sunday, 19th August. 
 The chief celebrant and preacher will be the Right Reverend Philip Pargeter, Auxiliary Bishop of Birmingham. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 PRAYERS FOR PEACE IN THE GULF 
 this Monday evening from 8.00&ndash;11.00 pm at St. Giles, Oxford. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 WOODSTOCK: 
 There will be a meeting of the &bquo;Friends of St. Hugh&equo; on Thursday, 30th August, at 7.30 pm in the Parish Hall. 
 CONFIRMATION PHOTOGRAPHS 
 are now available for those who ordered them, from Marianne Balazs (6888) &pound;6.50 each. 
 REPOSITORY 
 is open each weekday and Sunday, after Mass, in the Old Baptistry. 
 Items available include rosaries, medals, Mass cards, holy pictures and Advent calendars and Christmas cards (shop early for Christmas!). 
 The range will be extended in due course, meanwhile larger items (statues, missals, etc) can be ordered on request. 
 BULLETIN 
 Reminder that any notes you would like to appear in this bulletin should be given to Mrs Valerie Belton (0869 50405) or, FOR THE NEXT COUPLE OF WEEKS, placed in an envelope marked &bquo;Bulletin&equo; and posted through the letter box of the Parish House. 
 Please don't leave them to the last minute. 
 DEAR PARISHIONERS: 
 As announced last week, I am away on holiday for the next two weeks (you will notice that the weather has started to deteriorate&hellip;!). 
 While I am away the Fathers of the Priory are very kindly looking after things for me, so please refer any crises to them (telephone: 2149). 
 Some friends of mine are staying in the parish house for a holiday in my absence and in real need a key to the church may be obtained from them &mdash; but, please, only in real need! 
 Yours in Christ  JOHN F. MOLYNEUX   
 &bquo;Bye bye&hellip; be good!&equo; 
 PARISH OF ST THOMAS MORE &amp; ST HUGH OF LINCOLN with St Philip's Priory Begbroke 
 19th Sunday of the Year 12th August 1990 Page 44 
 Fr John Molyneux 142 Oxford Road Kid 77093 
 I will hear what the Lord God has to say, a voice that speaks of peace. 
 BIDDING PRAYERS: 
 Father, hear us; As we call on your name. 
 Let us pray for the sick members of our parish family. 
 Almighty Father, we commend to Your loving care all who suffer; grant them patience. 
 Cheer and uphold them with the knowledge of your love and restore them to full health. 
 We pray for Fr Donal Cahill, Alexander Johnson, John Lavery, Marie Grant, Joyce Clarke, Joan Wright, Ann McGuckin, Joe Baron, Katy Murphy, James Ackroyd, Peter Ackroyd, Davina Hughes, Lynn Webb, Doris Irwin, Andy Lukes, David Kardus, and John Tweddle. 
 Grant them healing and strength. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 Let us pray for the deceased members of our parish family. 
 Receive in tranquillity and peace, Lord, the souls of all your departed servants who have died recently. 
 We pray for all those killed each day in wars, disasters and accidents throughout the world; for prisoners of conscience; and all who suffer torture, starvation or maltreatment; and for Mary Wyse and Alfred Osborne, and all whose anniversaries fall at this time of the year. 
 Grant them forever the joy of your presence. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 FEAST OF THE ASSUMPTION 
 on Wednesday next is a Holyday of Obligation. 
 Please note the Mass times above. 
 The evening Mass at Woodstock on Tuesday fulfils the obligation. 
 EUCHARISTIC MINISTERS, READERS AND COUNTERS 
 should now have received their list for the next two months. 
 If not, please see Father John. 
 LITURGY SHEETS FOR YOUNGER PARISHIONERS 
 with things to colour or do are available at the back of the church and in the cry room. 
 Parents please help yourselves, and use them to help your children &mdash; take a copy home with you if you wish. 
 A new sheet is available each week. 
 Any helpful suggestions or comments would also be welcome. 
 THE ANNUAL DIOCESAN PILGRIMAGE TO THE SHRINE OF THE ENGLISH MARTYRS AT HARVINGTON HALL 
 takes place this year on Sunday, 19th August. 
 The chief celebrant and preacher will be the Right Reverend Philip Pargeter, Auxiliary Bishop of Birmingham. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 SOLI HOUSE, 
 the Diocesan Youth Centre in Stratford-on-Avon, as a new venture, is offering bed and breakfast at very cheap rates during the holiday season &mdash; ideal for students and families. 
 Anyone interested please see Father John for details. 
 CONFIRMATION PHOTOGRAPHS 
 are now available for those who ordered them, from Marianne Balazs (6888) &pound;6.50 each. 
 WOODSTOCK 
 &mdash; coffee after Mass in the hall this Sunday. 
 REPOSITORY 
 will be open each weekday and Sunday, after Masses, in the Old Baptistry as from Monday 13 August 1990. 
 Items available include rosaries, medals, Mass cards, holy pictures and Advent calendars and Christmas cards (shop early for Christmas!). 
 The range will be extended in due course, meanwhile larger items (statues, missals, etc) can be ordered on request. 
 BULLETIN 
 Reminder that any notes you would like to appear in this next bulletin should be given to Mrs Valerie Belton (0869 50405) or, FOR THE NEXT COUPLE OF WEEKS, placed in an envelope marked &bquo;Bulletin&equo; and posted through the letter box of the Parish House. 
 Please don't leave them to the last minute. 
 DEAR PARISHIONERS: 
 After next Sunday (19 August) I will be away from the parish on holiday for two weeks. 
 Any matters you wish to see me about between now and the end of August, please bring to my attention this week. 
 Yours in Christ  JOHN F. MOLYNEUX   
 &bquo;Psst!! 
 Cheap indulgences&hellip;!!' 
 PARISH OF ST THOMAS MORE &amp; ST HUGH OF LINCOLN with St Philip's Priory Begbroke 
 18th Sunday of the Year 5th August 1990 Page 42 
 Fr John Molyneux 142 Oxford Road Kid 77093 
 Nothing can come between us and the love of God made visible in Christ Jesus our Lord. 
 BIDDING PRAYERS: 
 Father hear us through your Son; Who is our food and our life. 
 Let us pray for the sick members of our parish family. 
 Almighty Father, we commend to Your loving care all who suffer; grant them patience. 
 Cheer and uphold them with the knowledge of your love and restore them to full health. 
 We pray for Fr Donal Cahill, Alexander Johnson, John Lavery, Marie Grant, Joyce Clarke, Joan Wright, Ann McGuckin, Joe Baron, Katy Murphy, James Ackroyd, Peter Ackroyd, Davina Hughes, Lynn Webb, Doris Irwin, Andy Lukes, David Kardus, and John Tweddle. 
 Grant them healing and strength. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 Let us pray for the deceased members of our parish family. 
 Receive in tranquillity and peace, Lord, the souls of all your departed servants who have died recently. 
 We pray for all those killed each day in wars, disasters and accidents throughout the world; for prisoners of conscience; and all who suffer torture, starvation or maltreatment; and for Harold Pollard, Jack Shaw, Rose O'Neill, Ellen Steen, Rosaleen Cook, and all whose anniversaries fall at this time of the year. 
 Grant them forever the joy of your presence. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 CARDINAL NEWMAN CENTENARY MASS 
 The Centenary mass for the Beatification of John Henry Cardinal Newman is being held at the Oratory, Birmingham, (NOT Rednal as it usually is) on Saturday, 11th August, at 11.00 am. 
 Admission by ticket only. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 EUCHARISTIC MINISTERS 
 please note that a new (pink) list for the next two months is now available at the back of church. 
 Please help yourself to one. 
 New lists for READERS (green) and COUNTERS (white) are also available. 
 Those involved are asked to make sure they have a copy. 
 A NEW IDEA! 
 for our younger parishioners. 
 Sheila Cooper has prepared a sheet of things to colour or do related to the theme of the Sunday Mass. 
 These are available at the back of church and in the Cry Room. 
 Parents please help yourselves, and use them to help your children &mdash; take a copy home with you if you wish. 
 A new sheet is available each week. 
 Any helpful suggestions or comments would also be welcome. 
 ECUMENICAL ACTIVITIES IN WOODSTOCK: 
 Meeting on Monday next, 6 August, in the Methodist Hall at 7.45 pm. 
 There will be an informal discussion and shared fellowship. 
 All are invited and welcome to join in. 
 PARISH CARERS 
 There will be a Cream Tea at Molly and Walter Cowley's home, 23, Yarnton Road on Tuesday, 7 August, from 2.30 to 4.00 pm. 
 All senior parishioners are welcome. 
 Please remember to let the Carers know if you know of somebody who is lonely. 
 THE ANNUAL DIOCESAN PILGRIMAGE TO THE SHRINE OF THE ENGLISH MARTYRS AT HARVINGTON HALL 
 takes place this year on Sunday, 19th August. 
 The chief celebrant and preacher will be the Right Reverend Philip Pargeter, Auxiliary Bishop of Birmingham. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 SOLI HOUSE, 
 the Diocesan Youth Centre in Stratford-on-Avon, as a new venture, is offering bed and breakfast at very cheap rates during the holiday season &mdash; ideal for students and families. 
 Anyone interested please see Father John for details. 
 A reminder that any notes you would like to appear in this next bulletin should be given to Mrs Valerie Belton (0869 50405) or to Father John. 
 Please don't leave them to the last minute. 
 DEAR PARISHIONERS: 
 During the past week there have been several occasions where people have been meddling with candles and other things in the church, including the money boxes yet again, and so it is with some sadness that I have decided to keep the church locked during the holiday period. 
 I apologise for any inconvenience this may cause, but I am sure you will understand the need to protect the place from fire or desecration. 
 Yours in Christ  JOHN F. MOLYNEUX   
 &bquo;I think I'm reaching melting point!&equo; 
 PARISH OF ST THOMAS MORE &amp; ST HUGH OF LINCOLN with St Philip's Priory Begbroke 
 16th Sunday of the Year 22nd July 1990 Page 37 
 Fr John Molyneux 142 Oxford Road Kid 77093 77093 
 May the Father of our Lord Jesus Christ enlighten the eyes of our mind, so that we can see what hope his call holds for us. 
 BIDDING PRAYERS: 
 Father have mercy on us; Through the power of your Holy Spirit 
 Let us pray for the sick members of our parish family. 
 Almighty Father, we commend to Your loving care all who suffer; grant them patience. 
 Cheer and uphold them with the knowledge of your love and restore them to full health. 
 We pray for Fr Donal Cahill, Alexander Johnson, John Lavery, Marie Grant, Joyce Clarke, Joan Wright, Ann McGuckin, Joe Baron, Katy Murphy, James Ackroyd, Peter Ackroyd, Davina Hughes, Lynn Webb, Doris Irwin, Andy Lukes, Eileen Cassidy, and David Kardus. 
 Grant them healing and strength. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 Let us pray for the deceased members of our parish family. 
 Receive in tranquillity and peace, Lord, the souls of all your departed servants who have died recently. 
 We pray for all those killed each day in wars, disasters and accidents throughout the world; for prisoners of conscience; and all who suffer torture, starvation or maltreatment; and for all whose anniversaries fall at this time of the year. 
 Grant them forever the joy of your presence. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 CARDINAL NEWMAN CENTENARY MASS 
 The Centenary Mass for the Beatification of John Henry Cardinal Newman is being held at the Oratory, Birmingham, (NOT Rednal as it usually is) on Saturday, 11th August, at 11.00 am. 
 Admission by ticket only. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 SONDRA BEUKEMA 
 is giving a concert in Kidlington Baptist Church on Thursday, 26th July, at 8.00 pm. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 EUCHARISTIC MINISTERS 
 please note that a new list for the next two months is now available at the back of church. 
 Please help yourself to one. 
 New lists for readers and counters are also available shortly. 
 The Family of the late Michael Conroy (Mick) would like to thank Father John and all Mick's friends for their floral tributes, Mass cards and messages of sympathy. 
 Holy Mass will be offered for your intentions. 
 A reminder that any notes you would like to appear in this bulletin should be given to Mrs Valerie Belton (0869 50405) or to Father John. 
 Please don't leave them to the last minute. 
 DEAR PARISHIONERS: 
 The holiday season begins to get into full swing as our schools close. 
 Whether you go away or not, I hope you all find time for a little rest and recuperation. 
 My own plans are somewhat uncertain because of the move, but I do plan to get away for a short break some time towards the end of the month, and I will keep you informed. 
 Yours in Christ  JOHN F. MOLYNEUX   
 &bquo;I'm still getting lost&hellip;!&equo; 
 (For some reason I found myself in Charlbury last week &mdash; about 15 miles from where I thought I was, and ought to have been!) 
 PARISH OF ST THOMAS MORE &amp; ST HUGH OF LINCOLN with St Philip's Priory Begbroke 
 17th Sunday of the Year 29 July 1990 Page 39 
 Fr John Molyneux 142 Oxford Road Kid 77093 
 I call you friends, says the Lord, because I have made known to you everything I have learnt from my Father. 
 BIDDING PRAYERS: 
 In your wisdom, Lord; Deepen our faith. 
 Let us pray for the sick members of our parish family. 
 Almighty Father, we commend to Your loving care all who suffer; grant them patience. 
 Cheer and uphold them with the knowledge of your love and restore them to full health. 
 We pray for Fr Donal Cahill, Alexander Johnson, John Lavery, Marie Grant, Joyce Clarke, Joan Wright, Ann McGuckin, Joe Baron, Katy Murphy, James Ackroyd, Peter Ackroyd, Davina Hughes, Lynn Webb, Doris Irwin, Andy Lukes, David Kardus, and John Tweddle. 
 Grant them healing and strength. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 Let us pray for the deceased members of our parish family. 
 Receive in tranquillity and peace, Lord, the souls of all your departed servants who have died recently. 
 We pray for all those killed each day in wars, disasters and accidents throughout the world; for prisoners of conscience; and all who suffer torture, starvation or maltreatment; and for Sally Steepe, Mary Eames, Amelia Reeves, Mary Tulley, Ellen Beddard, William Thomas Russell, Fergus O'Connor, Hannah Hartnett, and all whose anniversaries fall at this time of the year. 
 Grant them forever the joy of your presence. 
 Lord, in Your mercy Hear our prayer. 
 CARDINAL NEWMAN CENTENARY MASS 
 The Centenary Mass for the Beatification of John Henry Cardinal Newman is being held at the Oratory, Birmingham, (NOT Rednal as it usually is) on Saturday, 11th August, at 11.00 am. 
 Admission by ticket only. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 EUCHARISTIC MINISTERS 
 please note that a new (pink) list for the next two months is now available at the back of church. 
 Please help yourself to one. 
 New lists for READERS (green) and COUNTERS (white) are also available. 
 Those involved are asked to make sure they have a copy. 
 A NEW IDEA! 
 for our younger parishioners. 
 Sheila Cooper has prepared a sheet of things to colour or do related to the theme of the Sunday Mass. 
 These are available at the back of church and in the Cry Room. 
 Parents please help yourselves, and use them to help your children &mdash; take a copy home with you if you wish. 
 A new sheet is available each week. 
 Any helpful suggestions or comments would also be welcome. 
 PARISH CARERS 
 There will be a Cream Tea at Molly and Walter Cowley's home, 23, Yarnton Road on Tuesday, 7 August, from 2.30 to 4.00 pm. 
 All senior parishioners are welcome. 
 Please remember to let the Carers know if you know of somebody who is lonely. 
 KIDLINGTON FLOWER FESTIVAL 1990: 
 The organisers thank all those who helped to make the weekend so happy and successful. 
 Some 84 organisations took part (our thanks to Stephanie O'Keefe for doing our display) and about &pound;900 was raised for Christian Aid, as compared to &pound;661 last year. 
 THE ANNUAL DIOCESAN PILGRIMAGE TO THE SHRINE OF THE ENGLISH MARTYRS AT HARVINGTON HALL 
 takes place this year on Sunday, 19th August. 
 The chief celebrant and preacher will be the Right Reverend Philip Pargeter, Auxiliary Bishop of Birmingham. 
 For details, see the poster in the church porch. 
 SOLI HOUSE, 
 the Diocesan Youth Centre in Stratford-on-Avon, as a new venture, is offering bed and breakfast at very cheap rates during the holiday season &mdash; ideal for students and families. 
 Anyone interested please see Father John for details. 
 A reminder that any notes you would like to appear in this bulletin should be given to Mrs Valerie Belton (0869 50405) or to Father John. 
 Please don't leave them to the last minute. 
 DEAR PARISHIONERS: 
 Having had the opportunity to settle in a bit and have a look around, I am beginning to get my bearings. 
 One thing I have noticed is that the exterior of the church is in need of repair and redecoration. 
 Knowing (from expensive experience elsewhere!) how important it is to keep the fabric in good order, I propose to get this attended to as soon as possible. 
 We can just about afford it from immediate funds, and I trust I have your support in this work. 
 Yours in Christ  JOHN F. MOLYNEUX   
 &bquo;Sermon?&hellip; 
 Sorry &mdash; I haven't finished my colouring in yet!' 
 Frontier Youth Trust 
 Advancing the frontiers 
 News Spring 1990 
 &bquo;THEY WHO WOULD VALIANT BE&hellip;&equo; 
 Those who are active in frontier youth ministry know they are in a battle. 
 It's a fight for the well-being of young people who have the odds stacked against them; a fight for their total transformation. 
 It's a struggle with young people, alongside them as they experience the pleasures and pains, the excitements and disappointments of growing up in a hostile world. 
 It's a fight against all that dehumanises, blocks and blights those who are made in God's image and don't know their God-given potential in the present and in a future which goes beyond the grave. 
 The first Christians would identify with this contemporary struggle: the New Testament is peppered with allusions to battle. 
 They knew that &bquo;If (anyone) is in Christ he (or she) becomes a new person altogether &mdash; the past is finished and gone, everything has become fresh and new. 
 All this is God's doing, for he has reconciled us to himself through Jesus Christ; and he has made us agents of the reconciliation.&equo; 
 But, in entering the arena, these early Christians found that, &bquo;Our struggle is not against flesh and blood but against the rulers, the authorities, against the power of this dark world and against the spiritual forces of evil in the heavenly realms.' 
 Ephesians 6:12 
 Our Western culture, so heavily influenced by Enlightenment thinking, values and attitudes, has banished any vocabulary which enables us seriously to reckon with the &bquo;dark powers&equo;. 
 Others in different cultures and elsewhere in the world have retained the capacity to acknowledge these dimensions of human experience which are beyond the natural and everyday. 
 The powers and authorities were understood to have particular forms in the first century. 
 They were known and named &mdash; Nero the persecuting tyrant, oppressive tax systems, organised religion which institutionalised sexual promiscuity, systems of justice loaded against the defenceless and weak, customs which outlawed lepers &mdash; as well as individuals who misused power for their own ends. 
 But behind these was known to be God's Enemy variously named as &bquo;Satan, the devil, (a false accuser, slanderer, calumniator,) the evil one, the ruler of this world, the prince of the power of the air, Belial, Beelzebub, the god of this world, the destroyer, a murderer from the beginning and the enemy.&equo; 
 Frontier youth workers came up against the destructive, deceptive nature of evil in many of its present forms. 
 They deal with its expression in individual lives. 
 Many realise that the young and their families are caught up in and often complicit with a web of interacting forces which hold communities in their grip. 
 The situations in which they minister are &bquo;diabolical&equo; and they feel powerless to do anything about it. 
 Those whose calling it is to be God's agents of reconciliation are vulnerable to the ordinary wear and tear of any who seek to serve among the wayward and weak, the blocked and blighted among beautiful people unable to realise their potential. 
 They are also vulnerable to the stresses and strains of a larger cosmic struggle and can become casualties in the process. 
 This is as true for those who, like those in FYT's full-time staff team, serve God's servants, as it is for those who are at the sharpest end. 
 In the last three months, which should have seen the culmination of Jubilee Year, a number of things happened which combined to slow and stop the momentum of Jubilee Year. 
 These have included family breakdown, life-threatening illness, failure of nerve and serious accidents concerning ten of the small full-time team or those closest to them. 
 Some others holding key roles in a voluntary capacity have experienced unusual pressure. 
 Perhaps FYT's ministry has more significance than we realise to merit such concerted antagonism! 
 The first Christians also knew that divine resources were more than a match for the dark powers. 
 The exercise of prayer and worship takes on a deeper reality when the going is tough. 
 Passages of the bible have fresh relevance: faith and prayer are effective on others behalf. 
 God's love and support is known and experienced in the practical care of his people. 
 Jesus knew that those first disciples, a weak tiny bunch of nobodies, would be powerless and pathetic in a hostile world until they received the power of God in the Holy Spirit. 
 Easter reminds us that there is no rising without dying, no salvation without suffering. 
 &bquo;&hellip; having disarmed the powers and authorities (Christ) made a public spectacle of them, triumphing over them by the cross.&equo; 
 Colossians 2:15 
 Pentecost followed forty days later and there began an onslaught on all that denies, destroys and deceives in human experience which will continue until it is seen that &bquo;The kingship of the world now belongs to our Lord and to his Christ and he shall be king forever.&equo; 
 Revelation 11:15 
 Effective ministry in frontier situations not only requires dedicated skills and energies but it requires us to learn how best to wrestle with the principalities and powers. 
 The application of good practice is not enough. 
 We neglect God-given resources at our peril. 
 &bquo;So put on God's armour now! 
 Then when the evil day comes, you will be able to resist the enemy's attacks; and after fighting to the end you will still hold your ground.&equo; 
 Ephesians 6:13 
 Not only are frontier youth workers part of an enterprise which is global in extent. 
 We are also key players in a cosmic struggle. 
 From time to time diate experience into this wider context. 
  MICHAEL EASTMAN   
 Notes: p. 23 of Unmasking the Powers &mdash; the invisible forces that determine human existence  &mdash; Walter Wink, Fortress Press, Philadelphia. 
 Frontier Youth Trust is a national evangelical movement working to share a common vision of God's concern to meet the total needs of young people. 
 It acts as a service agency for Christians working with youth, and is concerned to provide opportunities for education, and training, for consultation and referral, and to make known or available information, research and resources for frontier work. 
 In many parts of the UK members meet in local groups for association, support and corporate action. 
 Membership of FYT is open to all youth workers, professional or voluntary, and working independently or under the auspices of local congregations, Board, Education Authority or national organisations. 
 FYT is trans-denominational and has extensive international links through the Scripture Union Movement, with which it has been associated since 1966. 
 EVENTS 
 CITY WISE 
 Applications to participate in City Wise, the one-off consultation on urban mission training, have to be in by 30 April &mdash; so write or ring for a form now if you are interested in coming. 
 City Wise is being held from 3rd&ndash;7th September, 1990 at St John's College, Nottingham. 
 International consultants include Dr Raymond Bakke, Manuel Ortiz and Dr Harvie Conn and there will be participants from around the world. 
 If you are involved in training others for urban mission, contact Rosy Fairhurst at FYT Headquarters. 
 Full fees are &pound;125 but there are bursaries available. 
 SCUPE 
 Michael Eastman, Terry Dunnell, Arkle Bell, Malcolm Goodspeed and John Oliver all hope to be at this International Congress on Urban Ministry. 
 FYT is acting as one of the Congress Partners. 
 DIARY 
 April 2nd&ndash;6th, 1990 
 Congress on Urban Ministry 1990  International congress organised by SCUPE. 
 Chicago 
 April 21st, 1990 
 FYT Skills Day for youth workers  Glasgow 
 Sep 3rd&ndash;7th, 1990 
 City Wise  An intensive consultation in training for urban mission. 
 Nottingham 
 October 20th, 1990 
 FYT Skills Day for youth workers  Glasgow 
 October 20th, 1990 
 FYT Midlands Autumn Conference  Nottingham 
 November 17th or 24th 1990 
 FYT Midlands Autumn Conference  Birmingham 
 TOWARDS 2000 
 Because of the bulk of work FYT General Committee had to get through in its meeting on 9&ndash;11th March in Nantwich, the Towards 2000 Conference was postponed. 
 Towards 2000 will see members of FYT Regional groups and committees meet together to work on the needs of marginalised young people in the last decade of this century.  
 Please send in copy for the summer issue of FYT News as soon as possible. 
 Pip Wilson's balletic impression of a serpent was just one of the highlights of Marketplace, a training day for youth workers held at Romford YMCA 
 PHILIP TOMPSON &mdash; an appreciation 
 Philip Tompson gave so much of his life to fostering Christian work with young people that it seems invidious to make special mention of one aspect of it. 
 His contributions included his work with Scripture Union, his long association with Cambridge University Mission, and his leading role with Andy Pierssene in setting up the Oxford Boys' Club Trust. 
 But perhaps the most exciting years were the early years of the development of the Christian Club Conference into the Frontier Youth Trust for Christian Club Work. 
 Philip was at the forefront of this development. 
 As the Club Conference Committee was struggling to express this wider vision in an initial Statement of Aims, it was Philip in 1964 who produced the winning title that we all now take for granted &mdash; Frontier Youth Trust. 
 The Rev E P Tompson was the first Chairman of its Executive Committee and in that capacity led the work forward to the point at which it was accepted as the youth club arm of Scripture Union, and a member of the SU Council assumed the chair. 
 His work as a leading founder member was invaluable. 
 It is the more important to record this because he did not seek the public eye. 
 His key role in creating FYT should not be forgotten. 
  Maurice Smith  
 A man of friendship, gentleness, integrity, stability, thoughtfulness, strength of character and wise counsel&hellip; 
 GENUINE. 
 Not only my words to express what Philip meant to CUM, Bermondsey and to our family. 
 Ringing round some of the ex club members they gave their pictures of Philip: &bquo;A quiet but firm man, who always had time to listen, and give advice when asked.&equo; 
 &bquo;I have fond memories of people being able to talk to Philip. 
 He seemed to just FIT IN.&equo; 
 &bquo;Philip was one who brought stability and understanding to CUM in camps, houseparties and meetings. 
 With his quiet and loving manner, he would always listen and wish to know what local people thought before he made any decisions. 
 He was a rock, and a sounding post for me, and many others, and is greatly missed.&equo; 
 Philip had the remarkable ability to cross cultures, being at home with the CUMers who often called him &bquo;Uncle Philip.&equo; 
 This was a move forward for one young man, who on the first meeting called Philip &bquo;The grey haired old GIT.&equo; 
 That was when he was chosen for a &bquo;crocker&equo; side. 
 Philip smiled. 
 It was pointed out to the young man that Philip was the chairman of CUM. 
 This instantly gained the desired effect. 
 &bquo;Alright &mdash; That grey haired old BLOKE.&equo; 
 Philip had a special interest, understanding and affection for the delightful, difficult rogues of CUM who he would always ask about. 
 He so often searched for the positive, supporting and standing up for CUM and Bermondsey. 
  Snowy Davoll  
 Philip Tompson pioneered Careforce in the late 1970's. 
 A group of evangelical youth organisations wanted to find a way to send 18&ndash;23 year olds they had been involved in discipling to put their faith to work. 
 They were to give a year of their energy, time and skills at cost to themselves. 
 The emphasis was to be mainly on placements in inner city areas. 
 Philip was 58 when he took the scheme on. 
 Working alongside him, I was impressed by his energy and capacity for hard work. 
 He travelled the country on his motorbike, convincing ministers that they wanted volunteers, and young people that they wanted to volunteer on a completely unproven enterprise. 
 His efficiency was remarkable: keeping record cards of every single visit and replying to letters by return of post. 
 Philip had a great interest and gift with the young. 
 He came to stay with my family for Christmas one year. 
 When my teenage son heard that the visitor was 60 and a bachelor, there was silence. 
 Philip turned up on his 1000cc BMW in a leather jacket. 
 He spent hours that Christmas in the garage with my son and the BMW and at the end of his stay, he gave him his leather jacket. 
  Clive Boddington  
 Many people lost a good friend when Philip Tompson died suddenly and unexpectedly last year. 
 The memorial service at St Helen's Bishopsgate, when 200 or more gathered, was witness to the wide circle of his interest and special gift of making and keeping friendships alive and fresh. 
 When FYT was formed in 1964, the high-energy group which gave rise to it needed a chairman who could mediate between differing views and draw differing visions into workable policies. 
 After the link in 1966 with Scripture Union, he took on the role of secretary instead for several years. 
 His unfailing support, wide advice, strong advocacy and practical help sustained and encouraged me from my start in September 1967 as FYT's first paid staff person. 
 He was in the office offering wise counsel, encouraging a forward look a weekend or two before he died. 
 When he married later in life, Ann shared Philip's interests and friends and became our friend too. 
 They took pleasure in hosting the reunion lunch on the day of the FYT celebration last October, for many present were known personally to him. 
 The first 25 years of FYT's life owes more than can be told to Philip Tompson. 
 He was a good friend indeed. 
  Michael Eastman  
 YOUNG PEOPLE AT RISK 
 DEVELOPING STRATEGIES 
 Dr Hoggarth works for Wolverhampton Council as an Assistant Director in the Leisure Services Department,  lwth  the Youth Affairs and Community Services Division. 
 She has previously been a youth worker and trainer in both the statutory and voluntary sectors. 
 All young people are at risk. 
 Some are more at risk. 
 All young people are at risk where they are not wanted, despised or feared. 
 There's a bitterness in the way in which young people are despised. 
 There is something about adult society which hates young people because of the economic dimension. 
 It is the feeling that young people are a burden on a society which does not need their labour or even specific skills. 
 The situation is changing now as young people with skills are becoming more in demand in the labour market with the falling youth population. 
 Suddenly school leavers are valued. 
 There are education compact deals. 
 But those who don't succeed or are not skilled or schooled enough to succeed aren't wanted. 
 They are seen as a drain on the profit because they don't function in the labour market to produce profit. 
 And so the resentment is worse than ever. 
 Klaus Offet, in his book Crisis of Capitalism , says that the Welfare State depends on profit. 
 The cost of maintaining the Welfare State is rising and coming into conflict with the profit. 
 There is tension between the two ends of the system. 
 &bquo;Yobs, hooligans, scum.&equo; 
 &bquo;We don't want them around us.&equo; 
 &bquo;They should be put down.&equo; 
 These are comments about young people which were spoken with a tenor of near hatred at a meeting of a council committee when young people weren't even on the agenda. 
 &bquo;Scroungers.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why pay for people on the dole.&equo; 
 These comments are felt acutely about young people. 
 There is an expectation that they can earn their way into the labour market but the labour market does not want them. 
 There is a rump who are dependent on the Welfare State and their place is resented. 
 There are the &bquo;golden few&equo; who win prizes in Youth Training Schemes. 
 What is risk? &mdash; what makes young people &bquo;at risk&equo; 
 1) 
 There is a risk of physical or mental ill health or damage, eg AIDS, prostitution, housing. 
 2) 
 Risk of criminalisation. 
 There is the danger that young people become permanently criminalised. 
 There is a &bquo;conveyor belt&equo; effect and it is almost impossible in the system for young people to get rid of the effect of a criminal record. 
 3) 
 There is the risk of alienation. 
 There is a distance from the State and a lack of control or consent about laws and State government. 
 The measure of community consent there was no longer affects Government. 
 4) 
 There is the risk of permanent damage and neglect to the individual's spiritual life. 
 Urban alienation is seen as a risk to the State and some projects succeed because they are sold on this fear that no response could endanger the State's stability. 
 What makes young people more or less at risk? 
 Dr Hoggarth gave two case studies from children she knew. 
 These very different characters were both &bquo;at risk&equo; in different ways because of the society they and we live in and their vulnerability in different areas: However, both are less &bquo;at risk&equo; than many because they are growing up loved and taught, ie given information rather than left ignorant and because there is some explanation of faith &mdash; relationship with God. 
 In both cases there is a basic assumption of health &mdash; that they can do it. 
 There is an assumption among many of sickness in young people. 
 For example, when troubles blew up at the Heath Town Estate in the Midlands they were immediately compared with Broadwater Farm and the place labelled a ghetto in the way the media treated the incident. 
 Nothing was said about the good, about the thriving community work and the community centre. 
 There was only an assumption of ill health. 
 The people there not only had to cope with the incidents themselves but living down the bad reputation. 
 There is a dynamic about poverty that makes it a risk increaser when it interlocks with other factors. 
 There is a spiral in the legislation about housing and benefits. 
 It is difficult to move out from home, to pay for furniture and heat, so young people are almost fated not to get enough money. 
 They start other things to deal with the debts such as prostitution and drugs. 
 It's a difficult job to look at the legislation and see a way through it for organisations dealing with homelessness &mdash; there is no way through it. 
 Some young people look upon drugs as a national industry: &bquo;what is so awful about doing it if there is no other way of getting a job.&equo; 
 It is easy to see how they argue it &mdash; how else would they get a home and a car and some spending money? 
 It is an industry in the inner city. 
 In Wolverhampton there is a long-standing prostitution trade. 
 Nonetheless, it is shocking to see nine year olds involved. 
 Research links it back to poverty and housing. 
 Parents allow children to be involved in prostitution because they bring in money. 
 It's a big step for them to get out of that because they need independent housing and distance from the men controlling it. 
 How do we break the cycle? 
 Young people with no job lose confidence and it is easy for them to slide into living in reversal of night and day. 
 It becomes a colossal step to re-enter working life, even if they are wanted back in the labour market. 
 It's not beyond some people in churches to lift a phone and get young people up. 
 Church people all have a role to play. 
 Drop the competition 
 Competition is endemic in the Christian world as elsewhere. 
 It doesn't matter whether people are &bquo;on the front-line&equo; or not. 
 Those that deal with paper are also involved in a job that needs to be done. 
 There should be no need for people in different roles to compete. 
 Then there is sectarian competition &mdash; over what is evangelical, too evangelical, not evangelical enough. 
 We don't need to compete like that. 
 The styles and roles can be complementary. 
 There are different functions, and the New Testament shows the way that the early church divided them up. 
 &bquo;In those days when the number of disciples was increasing, the Grecian Jews among them complained against the Hebraic Jews because their widows were being overlooked in the daily distribution of food. 
 So in the daily distribution of food. 
 So the Twelve gathered all the disciples together and said, &bquo;It would not be right for us to neglect the ministry of the word of God in order to wait on tables. 
 Brothers, choose seven men from among you who are known to be full of the Spirit and wisdom. 
 We will turn this responsibility over to them and will give our attention to prayer and the ministry of the word.&equo; 
 Acts 6v1&ndash;4 
 We should respect each other for what we do. 
 We damage and inhibit what we do because resources aren't shared. 
 Why bother with that? 
 Why not share our many resources for constructive mission. 
 We need the discipline of opening ourselves up to compassion. 
 Jesus was busy, but he still looked at the crowd and saw them. 
 Often we don't see them. 
 Daily life means that we have to stop seeing, for example on the tube. 
 Jesus allowed himself to see and to be bothered. 
 It's not a difficult exercise to open up oneself to see. 
 If you stand on Waterloo Station and look at the faces you will see what Jesus saw &mdash; a crowd that was  harrassed . 
 This isn't just emotional wish-wash: there is an immediate connection between compassion and discipleship. 
 In the passage in Mark 10, the incident where Jesus has compassion is followed with the hardest message about discipleship. 
 There is an automatic connection if one opens oneself up to see. 
 The trouble is that we don't see. 
 We can help people by giving them eye-opening devices &mdash; ways of seeing. 
 Assumptions. 
 We must operate on the assumption of health rather than accept that people are unhealthy. 
 What are our assumptions? 
 What is distinct to us or to church work from the assumptions of central Government where funding might direct us to exclude what we want to do and to be a youth service which would deliver a prescribed curriculum. 
 The Christian community needs to resolve that it won't buy the phrase &bquo;at risk&equo; wholesale. 
 Jesus's view of people is that they are basically healable. 
 The coming of God's Kingdom involves the restoration of people to  whoesness  and health. 
 We need to continually spotcheck that we are living and working in the light of that assumption. 
 State definitions of needs don't include the opportunity to know about God. 
 In an increasingly profit-driven state even the most conservative parts of the church have had to distance themselves from some policies. 
 The gospels show that discipleship sometimes means being at odds with the State. 
 Management 
 Industry and local authorities think in terms of &bquo;mission statements&equo; or customer care. 
 The purpose of the organisation needs to be translated into management actions. 
 These can be broken down into organisation of money, time and preparation. 
 Money. 
 We need money. 
 Some things can be done without it but we do need money. 
 It is sometimes hard to get but it is there. 
 We have to find management devices which are Christian in ethics to get the money. 
 A lot is tied up in properties which aren't used but are owned by the church. 
 We should review the resources we have but don't use and use them for mission. 
 We should approach the white public school middle class networks in the business world and let them deliver some money. 
 We don't all need to be in working class inner city areas. 
 There is a challenge to churches to get independent of State funding. 
 There is increasing conflict between the church and state funding and we need to free ourselves from wingeing about the cuts. 
 The church has a mission; let it provide money for the mission. 
 We must not simply take the victims role. 
 If we do take a victim's view of ourselves &mdash; that we are helpless and it's all impossible &mdash; then we won't shift. 
 And here is my advice about what is best for you in this matter. 
 Last year you were the first not only to give but also to have the desire to do so. 
 Now finish the work, so that your eager willingness to do it may be matched by your completion of it, according to your means. 
 For if the willingness is there, the gift is acceptable according to what one has, not according to what he does not have. 
 Our desire is not that others might be relieved while you are hard pressed, but that there might be equality. 
 At the present time your plenty will supply what they need; so that in turn their plenty will supply what you need. 
 Then there will be equality, as it is written: &bquo;He who gathered much did not have too much, and he who gathered little did not have too little.&equo; 
  2 Corinthians 8 v8&ndash;14  
 The passage from 2 Corinthians reminds us that if the readiness (or willingness) is there, it can be done. 
 We're asking He who has for what He has. 
 God asks us for what we have, not what we don't have. 
 The giving dynamic is not one of patronage but &bquo;as a matter of equality.&equo; 
 What equality is there in the giving between suburban and inner-city churches? 
 This will not be a matter of one-way giving, even though the suburban church has most of the material resources. 
 Look at what we can learn from the black churches. 
 It's the giving back of what we have got. 
 The simple possible is being asked. 
 Management of People 
 Two Christian solicitors are needed to represent young people in Wolverhampton and six voluntary organisations are in danger of going under because they need an accountant. 
 These roles need not be a burden if they were divided up between more people. 
 &bquo;The phenomenon of the wonderful people&equo; has hit the church. 
 We need to share out the wonderfulness and all do a bit &mdash; a &bquo;jobshare of the burnout&equo; &mdash; rather than having wonderful people dying on their feet. 
 Management of things 
 Transport, buildings and resources: We could share and network these better than we do. 
 We need to check whether our decisions are made on the basis of making our resources available to others and sharing theirs wherever possible before we strike out independently. 
 We should question whether the readiness is there, and if not, why not? 
 Is it a matter of equality: What does the management of mission mean? 
 Is the church going to be self-preserving or self-sacrificing? 
 DEVELOPING STRATEGIES: THE PEOPLE, THE PROCESS, THE OUTCOMES 
 The People: 
 Among the participants in the consultation, the following churches and organisations were represented: the Baptist Church, the Boys' Brigade, Campaigners, the Catholic Youth Service, Christian Endeavour, Church Youth Fellowships Association (CYFA), Iona Community, Kent County Council, Legge House, Oasis Hostels Project, Wolverhampton Leisure Service, the YMCA. 
 The Process: 
 Keith Wright of Legge House and on the FYT Management Group and Arkle Bell, FYT Field Officer and for the South West, began the process with the introduction and initial briefing. 
 Participants had an opportunity to introduce themselves and their interest in and perspective on the consultation. 
 It was clear from this point that the agencies represented worked in a huge variety of situations. 
 Several noted that policy makers were far away from the frontier in their organisations and that this led to obvious difficulties in making effective policies for work with young people at risk. 
 Small group work and a plenary on examining who are &bquo;young people at risk&equo; led into Liz Hoggarth's keynote speech. 
 This proved to be the catalyst for much of the discussion and also shaped the questions which the self-selected interest groups chose to pursue. 
 These questions included: &bquo;I want&hellip; to know how to increase provision for young people at risk in my organisation&hellip; to raise consciousness about young people on the agenda of my church&hellip; to change the attitude of Christians to that of the discipline of compassion.&equo; 
 Much time was spent in these groups, adopting problem-solving approaches to specific cases from the participants. 
 This was gathered together in the final session. 
 The Outcomes: 
 Participants agreed on highlighting the need for: 
 independent finance so that Christian agencies can set their own agenda 
 clear thinking and vision making the underlying theology more explicit for everyone 
 co-operation with other agencies 
 money 
 the release of talents and abilities in the family of the church 
 resourcing which is flexible and allows individuality to be central releasing the property and other resources which are not being used to their full potential. 
 Dr Liz Hoggarth and Keith Wright at the FYT Consultation, &bquo;Developing Strategies for Work with Young People at Risk.&equo; 
 The Consultation took place at All Saints Pastoral Centre, London Colney, Herts, 7&ndash;8 November 1989. 
 Liz was the keynote speaker. 
 Below is an abstract from her speech. 
 There is a dynamic about poverty that makes it a risk increaser when it interlocks with other factors. 
 It's not beyond some people in churches to lift a phone and get young people up. 
 Church people all have a role to play. 
 We need the discipline of opening ourselves up to compassion. 
 If you stand on Waterloo Station and look at the faces you will see what Jesus saw &mdash; a crowd that was  harrassed . 
 This isn't just emotional wish-wash: there is an immediate connection between compassion and discipleship. 
 &bquo;The phenomenon of the wonderful people&equo; has hit the church. 
 We need to share out the wonderfulness and all do a bit &mdash; a &bquo;jobshare of the burnout &mdash; rather than having wonderful people dying on their feet. 
 FROM THE FRONTLINE 
 Wimbledon wanderings 
 The Wimbledon Churches Youth Project are still looking for premises for a young people's advice centre. 
 After researching the project for a year, Paul Vincent decided to look for premises with a shop front that would make the centre easily accessible. 
 However, amid rapid development and shooting commercial rentals in Wimbledon, this has not been an easy search. 
 Paul and Malcolm Bream first spent time exploring possible sources of voluntary funding, and then saw what might be done with the local authority, but have now turned back to their original search for their own place. 
 The Government's Thompson Report makes specific reference to the need for advice and information work with young people and recommended local authority funding for such projects. 
 In fact, this theme dates right back to the Albermarle Report of 1960. 
 Despite extensive lobbying among councillors, their only offer was to share premises with a Citizen's Advice Bureau. 
 Feeling that they needed their own independence, they have now returned to look for funding from the voluntary sector. 
 They have now found premises which they are interested in, commercial property in a building owned by Grand Metropolitan, who are asking for &pound;15,000 a year for a property in bad condition. 
 The project is in negotiation with the owners at the moment, but hope that the prospect of an actual building will encourage sponsors. 
 Meanwhile, Paul and Malcolm are looking for potential workers, paid and unpaid. 
 Open home 
 Phil Mitchell, ex-FYT field officer for the North West, and his wife Lyn, decided a few months ago to open up their home to young people. 
 He writes, &bquo;We have seen some remarkable changes in some of the young people who come to our house, the main thing is that we are available, have time and share what we have, which is probably not very much. 
 A book by Mother Teresa has said much to us about how we are to be for Jesus in this situation.&equo; 
 Phil and Lyn are both Church Army Captains working in Bolton. 
 Theos 
 This summer in Australia, Theos are running seven missions. 
 Warrnambool is a new mission this year. 
 Gavin Sharp has started work as the Theos Co-ordinator, having previously worked as an outreach youth worker at Open House in Ivanhoe. 
 Romsey Mill 
 Response to the Jordan project appeal to set up a non-alcoholic bar in Cambridge has been excellent. 
 However, funds for the day-to-day running of the Mill are at a low ebb. 
 1990 sees the Mill's Tenth Anniversary, however, and various celebrations are taking place including a buffet meal and time of thanksgiving, celebration and praise. 
 Coke Hole Trust 
 1989 was a year of great staff change, at the Coke Hole Trust. 
 Martin Hardwidge, the General Secretary, left in April and Stuart Waddington has taken on that role. 
 Lorna Payne acted as Director while Barbara Henry was nursing a bad injury. 
 The Trust is facing a &pound;30,000 debt following higher expenditure keeping Coke Hole up to the standards of the new Residential Homes Act. 
 Fellowship Afloat and On Line 
 Fellowship Afloat have good news and bad news. 
 The good news is that they have managed to install all services &mdash; water, sewage, electricity and oil &mdash; on their major project developing Light Vessel. 
 They are also on target to complete installation of toilets and showers by Easter. 
 However, the rest of the work will not be completed in time for the season, which will make life running a heavily-booked programme of events difficult. 
 A serious fire on board the barge Memory means that it will be out of action for the rest of the season. 
 Fellowship Afloat have the use of Dawn, a fully-rigged barge, until the end of April but need another vessel to see them through until September. 
 Dawn is not ideal even now as it has very limited sleeping accommodation. 
 Finally, Fellowship Afloat are looking for a new chief sailing instructor. 
 This is an urgent need. 
 If you are interested, or know of anyone suitably qualified who might be, apply to the office on 0621 868113 for details. 
 OK at the OK Club 
 Just over a year since their financial crisis following cut-backs at Brent Council, the Oxford Kilburn club's target of increased financial aid of &pound;18,000 has been &bquo;handsomely exceeded&equo; during the year. 
 As a result of this the club has been able to run at a constant level of activity. 
 This figure included a grant from the Church of England Church Urban Fund of &pound;9,000 so a high level of giving is still needed.  
 Paul Vincent and Malcolm Bream 
 AROUND AND ABOUT 
 NORTHERN IRELAND 
 Joe Campbell led a &bquo;Doing Theology&equo; residential weekend from 23rd&ndash;25th March around the themes of justice and incarnation for more experienced frontier workers. 
 Recently Joe and his wife Janet have been involved in support for couples in frontier work. 
 Two new pieces of frontier work are being pioneered. 
 One is a Methodist initiative in Belfast, and the other is from the Congregational churches in County Down. 
 Much youth work in the region is led by young people and a lot of training is taking place for the leaders of different groups. 
 Two monthly Saturday sessions on different themes are ongoing. 
 SCOTLAND 
 Two practical skills day events for youth workers are planned in Glasgow, for 21st April and 20th October respectively. 
 In keeping with Glasgow's title &bquo;European City of Culture 1990&equo;, FYT is organising a day consultation on 29th September for church leaders to explore church cultures. 
 Four or five camps are being planned for the summer and different ways of leading camps are being explored. 
 Also, Youth Worker lunches &mdash; monthly gatherings at the FYT office &mdash; have just been launched. 
 A series of events is being planned for Glasgow, Falkirk, Aberdeen and Edinburgh. 
 Called Frontier Focus, these times will look at issues of counselling, leadership, training etc. 
 NORTH EAST 
 Jennie Appleby is still concentrating her time on the Cleveland area. 
 A training day is planned for May, further details from Jennie. 
 The Development Group is continuing to work on raising team support. 
 YORKSHIRE &amp; HUMBERSIDE 
 The Yorkshire &amp; Humberside committee is looking forward to the appointment of a new Field Officer. 
 MIDLANDS 
 Two day regional conferences are planned in Nottingham (27th Oct) and Birmingham 17th or 24th Nov). 
 They will be looking at frontier theology and practice. 
 Terry is hoping to take a Sabbatical at some stage this year. 
 He hopes to spend time exploring the challenges of &bquo;spirituality and non-literate young people&equo; with an emphasis on communicating and sharing the good news, working with the bible and the issue of ongoing nurture. 
 EAST 
 The East region committee and supporters were thrilled in early January when the extent of team support for a field Officer reached the target for the first year. 
 Sadly, Brian Rowe's personal circumstances have now changed and he is not able to take up the post. 
 The committee express their thanks for the work he has done in a voluntary capacity over the past months. 
 Two highly successful Scripture Union events in February at Colchester and Newport Pagnell, where committee members contributed, highlighted the demand for a worker. 
 Watch this space (and People ) for news of the appointment of a new Field Officer. 
 Meanwhile, networking continues between the widely-spaced workers in the region. 
 LONDON 
 At November's &bquo;Caring for the Carers&equo; day, Joe Campbell put youth workers in pairs to talk and pray together about their need. 
 Peter is still in correspondence with one or two people from this session. 
 He hopes to see work on the issue of support, particularly pairing up with another person. 
 Work is still going on to raise team support for Peter, and he hopes to be making more visits to churches. 
 Peter is planning a workshop on training for work with young people in October. 
 Finally, he is looking out for support material for Christian detached youth workers. 
 If you know of any in existence, please contact him at the London office. 
 SOUTH AND WEST 
 Arkle Bell is engaged in a lot of work training individual youth workers. 
 In his travels, Arkle will be staffing the Scripture Union stand for the first three weeks of Spring Harvest at Minehead, where he hopes to spend some time with Frank Shayi, SU South Africa's Fieldwork Director. 
 He will also be involved in a youth event in North Devon. 
 NORTH WEST 
 John Hutchinson is writing up an initial impressions report of the work in the region. 
 He is exploring closer links with Diocesan and other denominational youth bodies which overlap in their aims. 
 As it is difficult for people to get together, he is hoping to establish a telephone conference system. 
 The idea is to invite youth workers to ring up onto a party line on a certain night, giving them the theme for discussion beforehand, linking them up with other people to talk about their work. 
 PEOPLE 
 After two years of hectic creative activity, Jill Garner left the FYT team where, as Support and Resources Officer, she headed up the Jubilee Year programme and Development Appeal. 
 On the 1st March she took on wider responsibilities as Head of Scripture Union's Development and Communication Department. 
 We will miss you Jill! 
 Without your cheerful, creative and energetic contribution Jubilee Year would have remained plans on paper. 
 We are delighted that in her new capacity Jill will have a continuing relationship with FYT's public relations and funding needs. 
 To follow Jill but not to be her successor (who could be!) it is hoped to appoint an FYT Administrative and Resources Officer &mdash; see Sits Vac for details. 
 There is also a vacancy for a Field Officer in Yorkshire and Humberside &mdash; see Sits Vac again. 
 Brian Rowe has relinquished his role as Eastern Counties Field Officer so that he can concentrate on developing the Salt Cellar as a joint churches enterprise in Sudbury. 
 He remains on the Eastern Counties Committee and General Committee. 
 This has created a vacancy for a full-time post in the Eastern Counties, for one year initially. 
 Contact Michael Eastman for details of this post. 
 A part of the Jubilee Appeal funding has enabled Jennie Appleby to take up the half-time paid post of North East Field Officer, for a year in the first instance. 
 Margaret Hunter's appointment in Scotland is ongoing. 
 Monica Dunnell, Terry's wife, is gradually recovering from an acute infection. 
 Elizabeth Stacey, secretary in the FYT City Road office, has broken her leg again. 
 Sheila Eastman is making good progress with her chest condition. 
 Please pray about illness in the FYT family. 
 Mark Ruston died recently. 
 Long-time Vicar of the Round Church in Cambridge, he was a strong supporter of Frontier Youth Trust in its early days. 
 MONEY MATTERS 
 So far the Development Appeal is doing well. 
 A total of &pound;76,000 has been promised over four years of which &pound;57,000 is in hand now. 
 Some of this has been given by grant making trusts to specific projects. 
 The Appeal is running over into 1990 and a further Appeal leaflet is being produced. 
 Of the &pound;43,600 unallocated, &pound;30,100 has been received so far. 
 It is hoped that some of this will go towards special development project for the north east so that Jennie Appleby can come onto the staff on a more permanent basis. 
 THE BACK PAGE 
 SITUATIONS VACANT 
 We will be pleased to advertise job vacancies relating to frontier youth work. 
 Please send them in with as much notice as possible. 
 Frontier Youth Trust National Administrative &amp; Resources Officer 
 This national post in FYT's staff team is for the management and development of FYT's central services and field work support. 
 The Officer will be responsible for fundraising and financial management, logistical support, public relations and publications, servicing FYT's Central Committees and Working Groups and project development. 
 S/he will be expected to research and keep abreast of issues faced in urban and frontier mission amongst young people and to represent the Trust where necessary. 
 Experience in Community youth work and administration sought. 
 The post is for one year subject to a major review of FYT's organisation and management. 
 Closing date 17th April 1990  
 Yorkshire &amp; Humberside Field Officer 
 This is a post for someone qualified in Community &amp; Youth work with wide experience. 
 The task is to support, advise, train and encourage those involved in Christian Youth Work amongst young people outside the churches. 
 The officer will be responsible for finding, training and supporting volunteers to assist in this task. 
 Applicants for both posts should be practising Christians in agreement with the Trust's aims and purposes. 
 Applications are particularly welcome from women and those from minority ethnic communities. 
 Closing date 4th May, 1990. 
 Application forms for both posts from Michael Eastman at the FYT Office, 130 City Road, London EC1V 2NJ. 
 Youth Co-ordinator Parish of Gerrards Cross with Fulmer 
 Well-qualified full-time Youth Co-ordinator required who can offer theological resources and educational/training/youth leadership experience. 
 House and car provided as well as salary, expenses and appropriate pension arrangements. 
 Full details from the Revd Norman Russell, The Rectory, Oxford Road, Gerrards Cross, SL9 7DJ 
 Youth Worker Purley Youth Project 
 Christian Youth Worker required for Detached work in Purley, Surrey as part of an established church-led project grant-aided by the local authority. 
 Apply with cv to Mr M Miller, 8 Haling Park Gardens, South Croydon, Surrey CR2 6NP 
 FYT NEWS Rosy Fairhurst, Jill Garner 
 St Clement's CHURCH NEWS 
 JULY 1990 
 Salt and light 
 St. Clement's Rectory 58 Rectory Road Oxford 
 Tel: 248735 
 The Rector's Letter 
 Dear Friends, 
 We are most grateful to those of you who prayed for us on our recent visit to Zimbabwe. 
 Both the Bishop and the parish (St Mary's, Avondale) in Harare were obviously keen to have us and our visit helped confirm to us that this seems to be the Lord's next step for us. 
 Accordingly, subject to work permits being forthcoming, I have accepted a post as Rector, and Elizabeth as a Diocesan Counsellor with special responsibility for helping with the problems of AIDS. 
 We do not expect to arrive there before January. 
 General Synod 
 In consequence of this move, this month will be my last attendance at the General Synod. 
 It has been an experience which I have enjoyed. 
 Please pray that godly and suitable people will be chosen to help steer the affairs of the Church of England. 
 The new Synod to be elected at some date in the autumn will have the ticklish task of negotiating the issues about ordaining women to the priesthood. 
 The House of Laity is elected by your Deanery Synod members. 
 One of the topics being raised at the coming General Synod in a Private Member's motion is the whole question of our treatment of animals, and I include an article about this. 
 Michael Mitton 
 Michael will be visiting us to preach on July 22nd. 
 He is the new Director of Anglican Renewal Ministries and successor to Lawrence Hoyle who has preached for us more than once. 
 Although the Spirit of the Lord has permeated the church through what is called &bquo;charismatic renewal&equo;, and although it is like leaven in a lump which has begun to spread its influence, there are still many parts of the church unreached and unaffected. 
 Michael believes that ARM still has an important role in continuing the impetus of renewal and I am sure we will find his ministry an encouragement. 
 He is the author of two booklets and has a keen interest in meditation. 
 As ARM will I hope be  leavening  the church, so the church is meant to be like  salt  and light in the world. 
 The salt must be rubbed or soaked into the meat to preserve it. 
 We need to be &bquo;in the world&equo; but not &bquo;of it&equo;. 
 We need to be shining lights in the darkness. 
 Yours sincere friend  David Bishop  
 Animal Rights 
 I must confess to being a &bquo;convert about this matter. 
 Not that I have ever believed we should meekly accept unnecessary cruelty to animals, but having an agricultural background I have wanted to avoid taking a sentimental stance. 
 The behaviour of some animal rights supporters, who have sometimes appeared to care more for animals than they do for men and women, has also not commended their cause. 
 However, I recently received some literature about the appalling treatment of dogs and cats in South Korea where they are apparently regarded as a gourmet food. 
 The article included a suggestive phrase &mdash; &bquo;If people are kind to animals, they will probably be kind to each other too.&equo; 
 The author may or may not be aware of it, but he is stating a biblical principle. 
 In Dt. 25:4 it is decreed that an ox which is working should not be muzzled but allowed to eat. 
 Paul uses that very declaration in 1 Cor. 9 v 9&ndash;10 to demonstrate that God's concern for animals is paralleled by His concern for men and women. 
 Indeed it could be interpreted that His concern for humanity is a reflection of His concern for animals. 
 Similarly in 1 Tim. 
 5 v. 18 Paul uses a prescription about animals as grounds upon which to pay a church worker a decent wage. 
 There is a great deal of man's inhumanity to man as evinced in the use of torture on political prisoners or the application of apartheid to other races. 
 There is also much unnecessary hardship and fear and pain caused by man to animals in the way we breed them, market them, or eventually kill them in an abattoir. 
 I believe we should support responsible organisations campaigning on behalf of animals for two reasons: 
 1. 
 It is intrinsically a just cause; 
 2. 
 It may have rippling effects and result in more general kindness throughout society. 
  D.H.R.B.  
 Touchpoint Prayer Meeting 
 6.30 am&ndash; 8.30 am, Friday, 29th June. 
 Jon and Jackie's &mdash; 43a St. Clements 
 Everyone is welcome, breakfast is provided. 
 BE THERE!! 
 Pathfinder &amp; Explorer Ventures 
 It is very pleasing that 14 children and 7 adults, plus two former members of St. Clements are going on a Pathfinder of Explorer Venture this year. 
 A &bquo;venture&equo; is more than a holiday with a Christian emphasis. 
 In John 10 v. 10 Jesus says that He came so that &bquo;you may have life, life in all its fullness&equo;. 
 Well, life on a Venture will be &bquo;life in its fullness&equo; for most if not all of those attending. 
 For me and for many, a personal relationship with Jesus started on a Venture (they were called &bquo;camps&equo; in my day!) and attending and serving on a venture were valuable stepping stones towards greater Christian maturity. 
 When you pray for us please pray that not only will we all have a safe, energetic yet relaxing holiday but that during the course of the venture our faith in and walk with Jesus will be deepened. 
 We will let you know in the September magazine just how good the Ventures were and what went on. 
 At Wimborne, Dorset from 30th July to 6th August. 
 Leaders: Simon &amp; Judith Weedon, Gabrielle Willson, Nick and Chris Grew with Rebecca Prittie, Joel Prittie, Isobel Burnie, James Cook, Naomi Cook, David Chapman, Elspeth Grew and Ben Broad. 
 At Porthpean, Cornwall, from 30th July to 7th August: Sam Jones and Jonathan Grew. 
 At Chichester, Sussex from 11 August to 18 August: 
 Leaders: Ian and Caroline Johnson, Oliver Elphick, Steve Radley with James Chapman, Tom Elphick, Rachel Shaw, Pippy Shaw (plus Hannah Elphick, Joanna Johnson and Mark Johnson). 
  Ian Johnson  
 Then come along and help at Secret Agents, our 5&ndash;11 year old Holiday Club this summer! 
 WE NEED YOUR HELP! 
 How? 
 1. 
 By praying that many children from the local area will be drawn to the Holiday Club and the Church, with their families, and ultimately to faith in Jesus. 
 2. 
 By providing the necessary &bquo;junk&equo; (boxes, washing-up liquid bottles etc.) to make our craft activities less costly. 
 For details of what is actually needed, please see the list at the back of the church or an identical one in the Family Centre. 
 3. 
 By providing practical assistance on one or more mornings to lead or help lead craft, drama or games activities. 
 4. 
 By helping to run a creche for the under 5's of parents who are helping. 
 5. 
 (If you live in the parish) by displaying a poster encouraging children to come. 
 6. 
 By coming to a Family day on the Saturday, to meet and welcome new families to the church. 
 7. 
 By coming to the special Family Service on Sunday, also welcoming families new to St. Clements church. 
 8. 
 By volunteering to help in follow up activities planned for the autumn &mdash; perhaps a weeknight club for children, nurture groups for children and/or adults; we shan't know exactly until after the club has finished. 
 Secret Agents? 
 Secret Agents is the name given to a Christ centred, bible based holiday club resource material from Scripture Union. 
 Some of its ideas will form the basis of our club. 
 The programme aims to stimulate the children to find out the truth about Jesus through the eyes of His enemies, the Pharisees and the &bquo;secret agents&equo; that were often sent out to investigate and police His teaching and activities. 
  Ian Johnson  
 Kitalya Prison Farm 
 Ten years ago, Kitalya prison farm was the premier facility of its kind in Uganda. 
 Its 600 prisoners cultivated enough food to supply all the region's prisons. 
 Surplus yields were sold in Kampala's markets and reinvested in prison infrastructure and facilities. 
 Today, following years of civil war, it remains a shadow of its former self, with its buildings devastated and only 10% of the farm's 1000 acres under cultivation. 
 Last year the Ministry of Prisons, in Kampala, approached Food for the Hungry (an international Christian relief organisation) with a request for help. 
 They responded with blankets, clothes and seeds which have made a considerable difference to the prisoners' quality of life. 
 However, a great deal of work remains to be done to restore the prison's vitality. 
 Food for the Hungry UK are sending a team of volunteers to help with the rebuilding. 
 The aim is two fold, not only to rebuild Kitalya, but also to build relationships with staff and prisoners to share Christ's love. 
 As you may have heard, I shall be joining the workparty from July 27th&ndash; August 15th. 
 As a nurse, I shall also be acting as medical officer for the group. 
 Personally, I am hoping the trip will also provide me with an insight into relief and development work as I pray about my future. 
 I would very much appreciate the prayer support of the church, particularly for the following: 
 a) 
 that the Holy Spirit would use us to communicate the love of Jesus: 
 b) 
 for safety &mdash; we're 40 miles from a hospital: 
 c) 
 for strength &mdash; I fear I shall find it difficult in the heat: 
 d) 
 for finance &mdash; air fares to Africa don't come cheap! 
  Clare White  
 Russian Visitors 
 As you may have heard me mention already, I am involved in organising a one month summer school for 40 soviet teachers of English this July. 
 Half the programme will concentrate on modern teaching methods, but the other half aims to give participants opportunities to observe a range of aspects of British life. 
 Many of last year's group were interested in going to a church service, so this year I have arranged to bring them to the morning service at St. Clements on Sunday, 15th July. 
 It would be wonderful if after the service people would be willing to invite 2 or 3 Soviets into their homes for lunch. 
 They all speak excellent English and going on last year, are so pleased to be in Britain and so appreciative of everything arranged for them that they make an easy and rewarding group to entertain. 
 Please contact me if you are able to help. 
  Alison Coutts  
 Beyond the Parish 
 Did you know about the local CMS Vicar (featured in &bquo;The Door&equo;) who visits the caravans of motorway workers? 
 We prayed for him in June. 
 Come to our prayer group in July and find out which old and new friends we'll be praying for then &mdash; and bring your own suggestions and concerns. 
 Monday 2nd July 8.00 pm at the Family Centre. 
 It has been suggested that we might put our prayer list on the Overseas Board in church instead of the monthly missionary society's display, or as well. 
 What do you think? 
 This isn't a poll &mdash; we're only asking. 
 But do come and tell us your views. 
  Katy Hall  
 An Invitation 
 Peter Moger is getting married at Merton College Chapel on 21st July, and would be delighted if any members of the congregation would like to attend. 
 The invitation is for the service only (which is at 12 noon), since the numbers at the reception are limited by both space and budget. 
 A night with the Pathfinders 
 At 8 o'clock on Friday, June 15th, over 30 teenagers met in the church Family Centre for a strange ritual known only to a few as MIDNIGHTICESKATING. 
 This strange and very tiring event, designed by the church youth worker, began with a series of strange and tiring games. 
 After a short time, some of the braver members of the group drew up their courage to watch West Germany v The United Arab Emirates on the portable black and white that had mysteriously disappeared from the bedroom of 43a St. Clements and reappeared in the canteen room of the Family Centre. 
 Others, mainly the girls, spent the next hour or so exercising the jaw muscles &mdash; until the great white chief shouted, &bquo;OK; time to get together&equo;. 
 The troops were given their briefing in the hall. 
 The girls would sleep in the nice rooms, while the boys would have the canteen. 
 It was now 10.00 pm, so in 3+ hours they would all be woken and taken by fathers (mainly volunteered by their wives) to the of the action &mdash; the place known as Oxford Ice Rink. 
 There they would meet some others, who would join them for the next stage. 
 All those who wished, could then skate from 2&ndash;4 am. 
 Then upon completion of the mission, all would be returned to the Centre, to sleep. 
 Breakfast would be at 8.00 am and parents would return to collect their offspring at 9.30 am. 
 For the rest of the day all teenagers would be very grumpy and drive their parents up the wall. 
 The troops reluctantly went to their beds, among them a number who had never been to Pathfinders before, and others who were returning after a time away. 
 With the help of Captain Audrey Couper and Commander Ian Johnson, Private Wensley got them to stay quiet. 
 The leaders then sat back to watch &bquo;Godzilla&equo; on a late night B movie slot. 
 The time had come. 
 The girls were awakened and taken across in the first convoy, the boys in the next. 
 Skates were tied on the wrong feet; some boys were trying to remember when they had last changed their socks; the smell was incredible. 
 The first steps on the ice were amazing. 
 Now 45 people had joined together for 2 hours of fun. 
 The only failure came when Jon Wensley refused to skate (coward!!). 
 Watching Richard Arthurs was a lesson to us all, but what could be said about Ian Harrison?! 
 The return to the Centre was completed without mishap, and very little sleep was had from then on. 
 Most people were kept awake by Jon Wensley telling them to go to sleep. 
 Breakfast was eaten in relative silence. 
 Everyone was away by 10.00 am. 
 I'm sure all were grumpy all day. 
 How the boys could play football from 8&ndash;9 am I don't know &mdash; it was totally unforgettable! 
  An Eyewitness  
 The following are awarded the J.W. Medal for Courage: 
 Audrey Couper Ian Harrison Gwyn Guillebaud Ian Johnson Richard Arthurs Caroline Johnson (with bar, for cleaning the kitchen!) 
 Peter Shaw 
 Your reward will be in heaven, but also a King-size Mars bar each from me. 
 No &bquo;thank you&equo; will ever be enough. 
  Jon Wensley  
 THE OXFORD CHRISTIAN INSTITUTE FOR COUNSELLING 
 11 Norham Gardens, Oxford OX2 6PS Telephone: 0865 58154 
 Introductory Course in PASTORAL CARING 1990&ndash;1991 
 The Institute will be again offering an introductory course in Pastoral Caring, to help those with some experience of pastoral caring or counselling in their churches or fellowships to develop their gifts further. 
 The course aims to help participants: 
 towards a Christian appreciation of various approaches to pastoral care and counselling 
 to recognise some of the more common personal and congregational problems 
 to develop some basic skills in dealing with them 
 to serve in their local churches more effectively 
 The course does not train course members to become accredited counsellors. 
 WHEN? 
 The evening sessions of the course will run fortnightly from 4 October 1990 to late March 1991, with a break over Christmas: all evening sessions will run from 7.30 to 10.00 pm. 
 The evening sessions before Christmas will be on Thursday evenings, and after Christmas on Wednesday evenings. 
 In addition to the evening sessions there will be four &bquo;away-days&equo; on Saturdays (from 10.00 am to 4.30 am), which give the opportunity for some extended skill-training and group-work (an additional &bquo;away-day&equo; has been included this year). 
 We expect the away-days to be 13 October and 8 December 1990, and 19 January and 16 March 1991. 
 (Application forms from Theresa Gray) 
 Ruanda Mission CMS 
 157 Waterloo Road, London, SE1 8UU. 
 Telephone 01 161 1370. 
 New Code 071. 
 Now known as: MID-AFRICA MINISTRY (CMS) 
 To Vicars of supporting parishes 
 1st June 1990 
 Dear Friend, 
 As I am sure you have heard, Ruanda Mission has changed its name to Mid-Africa Ministry (CMS) and is entering a new phase of development. 
 As part of the extension, M.A.M. 
 is planning to appoint two new Travelling Secretaries, one for the North and one for the South of the U.K. (excluding Northern Ireland). 
 We would like to recruit secretaries who are relatively young and who might possibly, but not necessarily, be ordained. 
 The candidates need to have a commitment to world mission, good presentational/speaking skills and the mental and physical stamina for frequent travel. 
 If there is anyone in your parish whom you think might be interested and suitable, perhaps you would draw their attention to these posts and encourage them to write to me for application forms and job description. 
 With many thanks, 
 Yours sincerely,  Margaret Court General Secretary   
 become a SECRET AGENT! 
 Come to our holiday club! learn to be a secret agent: join in games, crafts, bible stories, fun! 
 WHEN: Tues. 28th Aug&ndash; Sun. 2nd Sept. 
 WHERE: St. Clement's Family Centre. 
 AGE: 5&ndash; 11. 
 For more information contact Ian Johnson 245385. 
 Balkan Proverb: Mirth and motion prolong life 
 THE PARISH OF SOUTH &amp; NEW HINKSEY, OXFORD 
 SERVICES: ST JOHN THE EVANGELIST, New Hinksey: Sundays: Holy Communion 8 and 9.30 am (sung) Evensong 6.30 pm. 
 Weekdays: Holy Communion: Wednesday 9.30 am. 
 On Great Feasts 9.30 am and 7.30 pm. 
 ST. 
 LAURENCE, South Hinksey: Sundays: Holy Communion 11.00 am. 
 CLERGY: The Revd. 
 E.J.C. Davis (Vicar), New Hinksey Vicarage (Tel. 245879) The Revd. 
 B. Singh, 9 Jersey Road, Rose Hill, Oxford (Tel. 717277) The Revd. 
 Dr. W.J.M. Oddie, 6 Sunningwell Road, Oxford (Tel. 242993) READER: Mrs. R.F.H. Colchester, 19 Dale Close, Oxford (Tel. 244192) 
 PARISH NEWSLETTER 
 SUMMER 1990 
 The Canterbury Stakes 
 The bookmakers are having a field day, so it seems, on the &bquo;Canterbury Stakes&equo;. 
 If the Church and secular press is anything to go by, a period of intense lobbying has begun with the various groups and interests within the Church of England backing their preferred candidates, or perhaps as significant, blacking others. 
 To the outsider, it must all seem very undignified. 
 Such lobbying has always gone on, but now with closer media scrutiny, things are more in the open. 
 How is an Archbishop or Bishop appointed? 
 Nowadays, with Synodical government, the Church has a greater say in the appointment of its leaders &mdash; well, in theory at any rate. 
 A body known as the Crown Appointments Commission, which has strong representation from the General Synod and from the diocese where there is a vacancy recommends two candidates to the Prime Minister, who in turn recommends them to the Queen who makes the appointment. 
 There is, of course, wide consultation at each stage, and in theory the Prime Minister or the Sovereign can reject the Crown Appointment Commission's recommendations. 
 Lord Callaghan, when he was Prime Minister, made the point that he was not necessarily going to be merely the post box in the system. 
 This arrangement has existed since the mid 1970s. 
 Before that, appointments were made by the Sovereign on the advice of the Prime Minister of the day. 
 Again there was wide consultation both within the Church and outside it, for Archbishops and Bishops are not just figures of local importance but have a national importance as well as leaders of the Church of the English People. 
 However, it is a moot point as to how representative of the Church of England the General Synod is, or indeed any other of the layers &mdash; Diocesan or Deanery. 
 And, as a result, how far does the Crown Appointments Commission reflect the views of the Church in making its recommendations? 
 One detects a certain apathy towards the whole business of synodical government, and parishes find it difficult to fill the vacancies allotted to them on the Deanery Synods. 
 One of the results is that synods have become the happy hunting ground of activists of one kind or another, and thus have become removed from the concerns of the ordinary man or woman in the pews. 
 Perhaps, if one was able to give advice to the Prime Minister on the appointment of the next Archbishop of Canterbury, it might be: Take your own soundings and make your own recommendation to the Queen. 
 Of course there will be howls of protest from the synodical activists and the liberal establishment, but the man or woman in the pews who are the real Church of England will thank you for it. 
 PS. 
 If anyone admits to taking the Tatler, they will find that one of the Clergy of the Parish, Dr William Oddie has contributed a major article in the June number on the appointment of a new Archbishop. 
 Heating St John's 
 The Diocesan Advisory Committee and the local Planning Authority have given the go-ahead for a Faculty from the Chancellor of the Diocese to install a new heating system in St. John's, and hopefully, it will be in and working by the time next winter comes. 
 As part of the fund raising towards the cost of this heating system, we are holding a Bring and Buy on Tuesday, 10 July in the Church Hall from 11 am. 
 Ploughman's lunches will be available. 
 Closure of the Vicarage Drive 
 The Vicarage drive and Church forecourt will be closed to the public as a through way between Wytham Street and Vicarage Road on Monday, 27 August, 1990 (Bank Holiday Monday). 
 This is required by law a) to maintain the private status of the ground, b) to preserve the Vicar's freehold rights of ownership (and those of his successors) and c) to prevent the creation of a Right of Way through the grounds. 
 Access to the Church and Vicarage will be through the Wytham Street entrance. 
 Crosslink Youth Club 
 Garden Party: This very pleasant annual event will take place on Thursday, 12th July at the home of Miss Nellie Millards, 21 Vicarage Lane at 6.30 pm. 
 July 8th: Punting at Cherwell Boat House &mdash; meet there at 7 pm. 
 Cost &pound;1.00 per person, Crosslink will make up the difference. 
 Bring towels and spare clothes, if you intend to the same as last year! 
 14th Oxford St John's Cub Scouts 
 Are holding a Summer Fare on Sat 14th July at the Church Hall. 
 Lots of events including Tombola and water pistol shooting. 
 Cake and white elephant stalls plus a grand prize draw. 
 New Hinksey School 
 At this year's May time celebrations all of the children performed country dances and a special feature was dancing around a Maypole by the children in Miss King's class. 
 The work in the school this term is centred around the theme of the &bquo;Natural World&equo; and &bquo;Living Things&equo;. 
 You may see groups of children around the community studying water life or bird watching. 
 On Sunday 24th June the school will have a stall at Fun in the Parks and on 13th July they hold their summer sports races and summer fair in Hinksey Park from 1.30&ndash;3 pm. 
 Do come to some or all of these events. 
 Parish Holiday 
 One Double Room is still available for either a single person or a couple. 
 Price &pound;37.00 per person. 
 Must have own transport. 
 If you are interested please ring Valerie Claridge (723507). 
 MISSIONS, MISSIONARIES &amp; Young Churches, Autumn 1989 
 Prayer 
 Lord, make me an apostle of your faith. 
 Where there is the darkness of unbelief, let me spread light; where there is the hate of social strife, love; where there is the error of heresy, truth; where there is the frustration of sin, forgiveness; where there are Muslims, devotion to Mary. 
 Grant that by my prayers and alms, I may give to each continent what it requires: to Africa, a native clergy of black hands lifting your body; to Asia, a rich harvest from the red blood, seed of her martyrs; to Oceania, a necklace of islands made into a Rosary for the faith; to Europe, already so tired, a renewal of youth at the altar of God; to America, an exchange of the pearl of great price for material riches. 
 Let me send my offerings where I cannot go; my pains to comfort sufferers whom I will never see; and my sacrifices to help plant the Cross in lands that know not yet of the Crucified. 
 I ask this through Christ our Lord. 
 Amen  
 Cover Picture: Korean seminarian wearing a T-shirt decorated with the Eucharistic logo. 
 Editor: Fr John Corcoran 
 This issue's cover features a Korean seminarian wearing a T-shirt bearing the emblem of the Eucharistic Congress which will be held in Seoul from 5th to 8th October. 
 A brief history of the Korean church is printed in &bquo;Here and There&equo; on page 20. 
 It is a church of martyrs and a fitting host for the 44th Eucharistic Congress. 
 That the Congress is held in Korea following Kenya in 1985 illustrates the growing significance of the young churches. 
 The picture of the seminarian reminds us too of the quite amazing increase of vocations in most of the young churches. 
 The Church in South Korea has 1,212 local priests, only 222 missionaries but an amazing 1,341 major seminarians. 
 More seminaries are needed here and in many other countries. 
 The young churches do not have the money to build them and so they quite rightly look to us Catholics of the rich countries of the world. 
 Here the bridge between us is the Society of St Peter Apostle, whose hundredth birthday we celebrate this year. 
 Full details of what promise to be uplifting and enjoyable celebrations are carried on page 4 and the back cover. 
 In Africa visitors are looked upon as a blessing and people go out of their way to meet them and make them feel truly welcome and at home. 
 Please help us to do the same for our visitors: Cardinal Arinze at Westminster Cathedral at 1.30 pm on 22nd October, and Father Michael Toror, Brother Karl Gaspar and Sister Bernadine at the various churches listed on the back cover. 
 The prayer opposite was composed last year by deacons on retreat before they were ordained priests and missionaries. 
 They are Nigerians, members of the all-African Missionary Society of St Paul. 
 A similar society, the Apostles of Jesus, is flourishing on the other side of the African continent, in Kenya. 
 As we pray this prayer we join with those generous young men as they set out on their missionary journeys. 
 The Missionary Society of St Paul was started by the Nigerian Bishops in 1977. 
 Already the Society has 29 priests and over a hundred seminarians. 
 &bquo;Fifty Years Ago&equo; on page 19 reports the joy that was felt when the first three African bishops of modern times were appointed. 
 How the wheel has turned. 
 Nearly all African bishops are now sons of Africa and they are sending out their own missionaries. 
 Supporting missionaries and young churches by prayer is asked of all APF members. 
 Father Michael Hurley begins a series of articles on prayer on page 14. 
 Please remember too all our deceased members and especially those whose names are listed on pages 22&ndash;23. 
 On page 23 too there is a picture of Carol McMahon who is generously giving hours of her time patiently illuminating a new Book of Remembrance for Eccleston Square. 
 When finished it will lie before the Lord in our chapel. 
  J. Corcoran  
 Centenary 
 This year the Church celebrates the centenary of the society of St Peter Apostle, the SPA. 
 In 1988 the Bishop of Nagasaki had to turn away young Japanese men from the seminary because he simply could not afford to keep them. 
 In desperation he wrote for help to Europe. 
 Mother and daughter, Stephanie and Jeanne Bigard responded. 
 They urged friends to join them and so the Society of St Peter Apostle was born a hundred years ago in France. 
 The Society supports the young churches in their task of training their own priests and religious. 
 In addition to building seminaries and other houses of study it helps to support over 63,000 seminarians. 
 Contrary to Europe, the young churches are experiencing a vocations boom. 
 These young men and women are sorely needed in rapidly growing churches which are supported less and less by Missionaries from Europe and North America. 
 The SPA is, if you like, a bridge. 
 A bridge between us who have the money and the young churches who have the vocations. 
 Our celebrations will open with a Mass in Westminster Cathedral at 1.30 pm in the afternoon of 22nd October, Mission Sunday. 
 Cardinal Hume will be the principal concelebrant; the Apostolic Pro-Nuncio, Archbishop Barbarito, will concelebrate with bishops from England and Wales. 
 Representatives of Missionary orders will also be present. 
 Cardinal Arinze will preach the homily. 
 Cardinal Arinze is a Nigerian and is the head of the Pontifical Council for Inter Religious Dialogue in Rome. 
 All friends and supporters of the Missions and the young churches are most welcome. 
 Do come with a friend. 
 Better still, bring along a coach from your parish. 
 Let's pack Westminster Cathedral and celebrate the Catholicity of the Church. 
 Further events in November are listed on the back of the magazine.  
 22nd October &mdash; Mission Sunday Mission Sunday is APF Day. 
 Celebrate it in your parish. 
 Come to Westminster Cathedral! 
 Solemn Mass at 1.30 pm. 
 Principal Celebrant: Cardinal Hume Homily: Cardinal Arinze 
 MALM SOW 
 Father Eugene is a Burmese priest. 
 He belongs to a minority tribe, the Karen, and in a Buddhist land he follows a minority religion. 
 To the Burmese he is &bquo;Malm Sow&equo;, the man in the white cassock who serves the &bquo;bearded God&equo;, Jesus Christ. 
 His days are spent travelling by boat ministering to the Catholics in his scattered parish. 
 The pupils provide their own food by keeping a cow, a couple of fish ponds, a large vegetable garden and some hens. 
 But Fr Eugene is also a missionary, and spends many hours with Buddhist monks talking of Jesus Christ and Buddha. 
 &bquo;We do not want to destroy Buddha but to christen him.'  
 Fr Eugene with his mother 
 Off to say Mass 
 The Church of tomorrow 
 Parish visiting by boat 
 The pictures used here are available in poster form (45 by 30 cm) in black and white. 
 They are intended to help promoters and secretaries mount displays in church or school, and may be obtained from Eccleston Square. 
 Posters shown in the Spring and Summer issues are also available. 
 You can sponsor the training of a young priest like Fr Eugene by paying &pound;200 a year (&pound;16.50 a month), covenanted if possible. 
 Please ask for our leaflet. 
 Photographs: Opus Sancti Petri Melters/present  
 &bquo;You have no famine, we have no famine&equo; 
 Anne Marie Coppock 
 As a member of a Faith and Justice group in Burnley I knew Father Corcoran before he returned to Kenya in 1986. 
 He invited me to go and see the Church in Africa and fortunately I accepted his invitation before he was recalled to become the APF director. 
 His mission was called Aluor. 
 It lies exactly on the Equator near Lake Victoria among the Luo people and in the Diocese of Kisumu. 
 The first thing you learn up in Kisumu is that none of the churches are large enough to hold the large congregations attending Mass. 
 And the second thing is just how enthusiastic everyone is, when celebrating Mass. 
 The music is lively with drums and dried bean shakers. 
 To my mind the Luo are on a par with the Welsh because everyone sings. 
 And the offertory processions are gay and colourful with young girls dancing and many gifts, including chickens, sugar cane, bananas and eggs, brought to the altar. 
 Even in those large congregations all the bidding prayers are spontaneous, beautifully prayed and with everyone obviously listening to what was being said. 
 It was strange not being able to communicate but someone who could speak English was always on hand to translate and often all I needed were those wonderful smiles and greetings from people. 
 Aluor was a busy mission with development projects, many women's development groups, new chapels being built, a small hospital and a marvellous school for blind children run by African sisters. 
 But it was the Church which really fascinated me. 
 Much of Fr John's time was also taken up visiting his outstations and taking Mass and the sacraments to the people who were visited every three months. 
 So I just tagged along in his pickup truck happy to share for a little while in the spiritual life of his huge parish. 
 I was always greeted with warmth and affection. 
 Always at the Bidding Prayers mention was made of me and my Christian community at home and prayers were offered for them. 
 And after Mass, accompanied by great hand shaking I was asked to pass on thanks to the Christians in Salford for their support but mostly great thanks for sharing our priest with them. 
 Many of their young men are going forward to train as priests, and at some time in the near future the people will be ministered to by their own men. 
 Until that day comes it is essential that other Christian communities support them. 
 The work of the priest in Kisumu is extended and shared by the catechist and leaders in the parishes and outstations. 
 Without the work of these dedicated men and women the Church could not progress as rapidly as it does. 
 Maurice Ododo is the catechist at Aluor mission and every day was busy going near and far training and teaching the Christians, preparing them for the Sacraments and instructing catechumens. 
 Par of his work also was to prepare couples for marriage. 
 One thing that struck me was the great need to bear children. 
 I myself have five children and in England this raises an eyebrow, but in Kenya I was often asked would I be having another soon. 
 And frequently women would express to me their need to be pregnant again. 
 Passing on life to another generation is seen as a great privilege and joy. 
 And it is important that the west does not crush this African life-style with our selfish talk of over population. 
 England and Wales are many times more populated than Kenya. 
 What is needed is generous help to ensure their children survive and aid systems which really are of benefit to the people. 
 So much of our aid is given with strings. 
 (Take our aid, but you must promise to buy our goods and especially weapons.) 
 And also we must be prepared to pay a realistic price for their goods &mdash; coffee, tea and sugar etc. 
 There was so much going on all over the mission, more often than not organized by the people themselves. 
 I remember mostly the great joy and vitality of the churches and communities I visited. 
 The liturgies were wonderful, and in small crowded mud huts great praise and thanksgiving was offered to Almighty God. 
 Their greatest joy was to have a priest with them to administer the sacraments and say Mass. 
 Things we take so much for granted. 
 And most striking was their simplicity and lack of greed. 
 One day while out visiting with Father John a man asked me how things were in my country. 
 Had we any famine? 
 Through an interpreter I replied that things were well and we had no famine. 
 To our western eyes as he stood in his raggy, holed clothes in front of his mud hut he would appear very poor. 
 But he raised his arms to Heaven and said, &bquo;Praise God, you have no famine and we have no famine. 
 God is good.&equo; 
 For me this is the message of Kenya &mdash; Praise God. 
 I was for a short time privileged to share in the joy and vitality and the oneness with Almighty God in his Luo people (Anne Marie will gladly give a talk and show slides to any interested groups in the North West. 
 Ring (0282) 31889.) 
 The Good That Lives After 
 Form of bequest to the APF 
 I bequeath to the Association for the Propagation of the Faith, English Branch, the sum of &pound; and I declare that the receipt of the Treasurer or National Director (for the time being) shall be a good discharge. 
 Form of bequest to Mill Hill 
 I bequeath to St Joseph's Society for Foreign Missions the sum of &pound; and I declare that the receipt of the Superior General or of the Rector (for the time being) of St Joseph's College, Mill Hill, London shall be a good discharge. 
 &bquo;Courtfield Weekends&equo; 
 Father Frank Thompson MHM 
 Courtfield was the happy family home of our founder, Cardinal Herbert Vaughan, whose mother, Eliza, spent an hour a day praying for religious vocations for her thirteen children. 
 Though she never lived to see the day, six of her sons became priests and four of her daughters nuns. 
 In its idyllic surroundings of the Herefordshire Wye Valley Courtfield has become a natural haven of peace. 
 Ten years ago it was thought that something positive should be done to encourage and thank our faithful and hardworking Secretaries and Promoters. 
 Weekend retreats were decided on and Courtfield was the obvious venue for the South West. 
 Over the past eight years hundreds of Promoters, in groups of thirty-seven, have spent relaxed, enjoyable and richly rewarding weekends with Father Michael Hurley our &bquo;retreat master&equo; and myself. 
 Each weekend begins on Friday evening with supper, followed by an introductory talk, film or video, night prayers and then the freedom to sit and chat or go to bed. 
 Following morning prayer there are &bquo;talks&equo; and lively discussion with Fr Michael and after lunch a &bquo;working session&equo; on the APF with myself. 
 Holy Mass is in the evening and I can only say that the warmth of the presence of God is felt. 
 The evening is given over to mission experience through film or slides, then night prayer followed by a social evening. 
 There is even a bar! 
 Sunday is usually a day of urgency &mdash; talks, Mass, lunch, conclusion, benediction and sad farewells follow in quick succession, and yet people feel uplifted and refreshed. 
 In Eliza Vaughan's day it was said of Courtfield: &bquo;You nearly break your neck going, but more nearly break your heart leaving there.&equo; 
 Today the roads have much improved but, as many letters from participants testify, the leaving hasn't changed at all! 
 Fr Frank Thompson MHM 
 Organizer in the South West 
 &bquo;Well, Frank, what is your mission appointment going to be&equo;? asked the Superior General just two weeks before my ordination. 
 If anybody knew he did! 
 &bquo;Borneo&equo;, I replied with confidence &mdash; and to Kenya I was sent! 
 I found myself second curate in a large mission called Kibuye on the outskirts of Kisumu town. 
 Dholuo was the language and I knew I was an encumbrance until I could make myself understood. 
 My parish priest had always dreamed of building outstation churches and, with the luxury of two curates, here was his chance to convert one into a builders' labourer! 
 I quickly learned the words &bquo;nyundo kod musmandy&equo;  (hammer and nails), though Sunday sermons proved a problem! 
 Two and a half years and four churches later my Dholuo had improved but my back had suffered from a fall through a ceiling and too much carrying of cement! 
 The Bishop thought a change would do me good and my next appointment was to Port Victoria where the language was Oluluyha and I could begin again trying to make myself understood! 
 My speciality shifted from building to wading through the Bunyala swamps with wellies and a rucksack on my back. 
 I discovered that wellies were good for keeping feet wet when the water came above your waist &mdash; and I found alternative footwear! 
 For another two and a half years I survived the mosquitoes and grew to love the people and was just looking forward to my first home leave when a letter from the Superior General appointed me to Vocations Director in the South of England! 
 I came home with a heavy heart and wondered how on earth I could foster vocations. 
 In four years I fostered one! and I am proud to say that Fr Liam Durrant, our present Vocations Director, came through my hands &mdash; should he be successful, would that make me a grandfather?! 
 I enjoyed another two years in Kenya but now my work is mission appeals in South West Britain and I have discovered at last the source of our treasure! 
 You are the people who make our work possible and I try to forge more tangible links between us. 
 Through yearly local reunions and retreat weekends in &bquo;Courtfield&equo; I have come to know, love and admire so many of you. 
 And when I appeal in parishes Sunday by Sunday I am aware that I meet the very people who made me a missionary. 
 &bquo;Lord, teach us to pray&equo; 
 Fr Michael Hurley MHM 
 The great Catholic writer and defender of the Faith, G.K. Chesterton, once wrote: &bquo;If a thing is worth doing, it is worth doing badly.&equo; 
 He meant, of course, that anything beautiful, anything worthwhile, should not just be left to experts &mdash; we should all be in there enjoying it, taking part in it. 
 If exercise is beneficial to health, it must not be left just to Seb Coe or Daley Thompson. 
 We should all be exercising, even when we do it badly, even when we cut a ridiculous figure as we job along, puffing and panting. 
 It's the same with other things &mdash; learning skills or hobbies. 
 And it is just the same with PRAYER. 
 There are few people who are experts in prayer, who do it well. 
 But, all of us know that we have to make the effort at prayer. 
 We may do it badly, but the beauty is that we do it at all. 
 In this First Article I want to make two points. 
 The first is that no one and no book can teach us to pray. 
 The only real teacher of Prayer is God Himself. 
 He can teach us because He knows us through and through &mdash; our strengths, our weaknesses, inclinations and dispositions &mdash; and He loves us with an all-penetrating love. 
 He wants us to be with Him, so that He can show us His Love. 
 He will teach us how to pray. 
 All we have to do is: Give Him time, and listen to Him. 
 The second point is: Most of us down the years have tried to pray, and have found a pattern that suits us. 
 One may say: &bquo;I pray best when the Rosary Beads are slipping through my fingers.&equo; 
 Grand! 
 Stay with it. 
 Another says: &bquo;I pray best when I sit before the Blessed Sacrament, or look at the Crucifix without saying anything &mdash; just being with the Lord.&equo; 
 That is a beautiful way of prayer. 
 Keep at it. 
 A third says: &bquo;I love to read a few words of the Gospel, so that I can see Christ and listen to what He is saying to me.&equo; 
 Isn't that a marvellous way of praying? 
 Stay there, for God is there with you. 
 Don't change your pattern of prayer merely because someone mentions the latest method just arrived on view. 
 Stay with your way of praying, provided it helps and brings you into the presence of God. 
 There are, indeed, many ways of praying and I will deal with some of them later. 
 For now, let me just stress: 
 1) 
 God is the only true Teacher of Prayer, so ask: &bquo;Lord, teach me to pray.&equo; 
 2) 
 Stay with the method of prayer that helps most and brings you into the Presence of God. 
 Perhaps I could ask you to read Psalm 5; and St Luke's Gospel, Chapter 11, verses 1 to 4. 
 Let us pray for each other. 
 God bless you all. 
  Michael Hurley  
 Trusting the Laity 
 Bernard Coleman MHM 
 In Kenya the Church started as in-service training scheme for teachers of Religious Education called CISRET. 
 It has proved to be a great grace for the Church. 
 In 1981 Vitalis Okoth from St Paul's Parish, Mbaga, was invited to go on the course. 
 Being a dedicated Catholic and chairman of the parish council he was an obvious choice. 
 Shortly after Vitalis finished his course, a teacher in one of the schools told me that he wanted to get married in Church. 
 He had had no instruction in the Faith and his wife was not a Catholic. 
 I saw that they would both need instructions for baptism and marriage. 
 The difficulty was finding a time to instruct them. 
 Their school was nine miles from Mbaga and there was no time after school finished in the evening for the teacher and his wife to come and return home before dark. 
 Saturday was not a suitable day as it is the only day that teachers can go shopping and can see to other family matters. 
 We were left with Sunday afternoon. 
 That was not really convenient for me as I often did not know at what time I would return from saying Mass in the outstations. 
 I was telling Vitalis about the problem when he volunteered to do the job himself. 
 To tell the truth, I was not over-enthusiastic. 
 I wondered if he would teach the right things and even if he knew enough himself! 
 He got down to work at once and even found another couple, both teachers, who wanted to &bquo;settle up&equo; in Church. 
 The following Sunday, when I returned from safari, there was Vitalis sitting under a tree with his little group. 
 After my lunch, I thought it better to go down and see them and to show my interest. 
 To my disbelief, Vitalis had started his course by teaching about the Sign of the Cross and the Our Father. 
 I think he saw my reservations. 
 He told me that it was necessary for them to start praying at home every day. 
 It was of no use if they received the sacrament of Matrimony and did not live as Christians. 
 Daily prayer in the home, he said, was essential. 
 Since they did not understand what the Sign of the Cross meant or the meaning of Our Father, he had started with a simple explanation of these and had told them how important it was to start praying together. 
 I remember saying to myself, &bquo;Clever Clogs! 
 You would have been talking a lot of deep stuff about Baptism and Matrimony.&equo; 
 From that moment, I never doubted that God had put the right man, Vitalis, in the right place at the appropriate time. 
 FATHER PETER'S CORNER 
 Over the years you get called all kinds of things, but a few weeks ago I reached new heights. 
 A Cameroonian schoolboy saluted me as his &bquo;heavenly brother&equo;. 
 I had not long returned to England after a visit to my old mission of Cameroon on the West coast of Africa. 
 There I had been present at the celebrations marking the Golden Jubilee of St Joseph's College, Sasse, (pronounced Sassay), where I used to teach. 
 Sasse, as it is generally known, is the oldest secondary school in the Cameroon Republic by a good ten years. 
 In its fifty years' existence it has poured out a stream of bishops, priests, doctors, engineers, businessmen, civil servants and politicians. 
 The Mill Hill priests who started Sasse in 1939 have made a great contribution to the national life of this young African country. 
 My &bquo;heavenly brother&equo; was not a Sasse boy, but from the primary school in nearby Mutengene mission where I had been staying for a few days. 
 (Mutengene is a harder word than Sasse so I had better give you the pronunciation: Moo-teng-genay.) 
 Gilbert had served my Mass every morning and was now writing to tell me about the approaching Easter examinations and was hoping to do well. 
 It struck me that in calling me his heavenly brother he had gone straight to the heart of all our missionary endeavours. 
 The Church, and that means all of us, including you, not just priests and bishops, has to spread the Good News to all the world. 
 It has to bring everybody to know God, and to give everybody the chance of the everlasting happiness with God that we call heaven. 
 We don't all work in the same way to spread the good News. 
 But we should all be doing something, and the best place to begin is with a prayer every day for God's blessing on the great work of telling people that God loves them. 
 God bless you all, my heavenly brothers and sisters. 
  FATHER PETER. 
 St Joseph's College, Mill Hill, London, NW7 4JX 
 MILL HILL NEWSROUND&hellip; 
 MILL HILL NEWSROUND&hellip; 
 SUDAN 
 Fr Piet Leliveld, newly arrived in war-torn Sudan, writes to say that he is now in Omdurman, near the site of the famous battle of 1898, waiting for a government permit to move to El Obeid. 
 Thanks to the Red Cross the town had been supplied with food for some months ahead. 
 &bquo;There are many refugees, and if you see the ones who survived you understand why the others did not.&equo; 
 Another Mill Hill Priest is working in Omdurman, living very simply in the shanty-town and trying to organize his flock into small Christian communities. 
 INDIA: HYDERABAD 
 Prema Seva Sadan is a project run by Fr Theo Raijmakers for the rehabilitation of street-children. 
 He is forced to interpret this description very literally. 
 &bquo;Once you start taking people from poor families you might well be tempted to concentrate just on them, and in the end you won't be taking anyone from the streets at all.&equo; 
 Bad as it is to be poor in Indian it's worse to be as destitute as the street-children. 
 The first thing to do is to give them food and shelter, medicine, and chance to take a bath, some clothing. 
 Time enough to think of rehabilitation later on. 
 &bquo;If someone has been living on the streets for a number of years he can't switch over to an organized life in a couple of days&hellip; it is too sudden. 
 We often find it takes three or four years before a youth is used to a regular life once more. 
 We keep open house here and they can come and go as they please before settling down, as many do, after a few attempts. 
 The results are encouraging. 
 We have our own little school here and a good number go to various schools in town. 
 Many are training as carpenters or tailors.&equo; 
 ISRAEL 
 Brother Huub de Bij has returned from a short stay in Israel where he was responsible for directing and producing a colour-video highlighting the plight of Christian Arabs, &bquo;a minority within a minority&equo;. 
 The film was made at the request of a Belgian organization and will be dubbed from English into French and Flemish. 
 PAKISTAN: PESHAWAR 
 Christians in Pakistan are 1% of the population, the rest being 97% Muslim and 2% Hindu. 
 Despite this tiny majority status the Catholics in Peshawar, the seat of Islamic fundamentalism, are in good heart. 
 Fr Fred Franklin, from Lincoln, describes the attendance at the Good Friday liturgy this year as being something he could never have imagined, with churches crowded to the doors and congregations flooding out to fill the church courtyards. 
 The long efforts of the years are beginning to show results and Catholics have a new self-confidence. 
 Another Mill Hill priest, Fr Greg Rice from the States, is local director of the relief-agency Caritas and is battling with the refugee problem. 
 There are three million refugees from Afghanistan in Pakistan. 
 Up to now they have been well looked after by the Pakistan government and established in villages of 50,000 to 60,000 people. 
 The new flood of refugees consequent upon the Russian withdrawal from Afghanistan is straining the relief services. 
 Another result of the altered circumstances in Afghanistan is the staggering increase in the drug traffic in Peshawar. 
 Fr Rice has taken over the running of a detoxification centre started some years ago by a Mill Hill priest who died recently. 
 For sheer lack of space and resources he is having to turn away drug-addicts who are begging for admission. 
 Letters to the Editor 
 Ref: your new Magazine title &bquo;Young Churches&equo;, I have always understood that there was only ONE TRUE HOLY &amp; APOSTOLIC CATHOLIC CHURCH. 
  E.J. Roche-Kelly, Esher  
 This terminology dates back to St Paul who spoke of the church in Corinth, in Thessalonika, etc. 
 Vatican II endorsed this terminology as does our present Holy Father. 
 When addressing the Cardinals in 1984. 
 Pope John Paul II said, &bquo;The Church is a communion of churches, and indirectly a communion of nations, languages and cultures. 
 Each of these brings a gift to the whole.&equo; 
 The young churches are those which until recently we called &bquo;the Missions&equo;. 
 Maybe &bquo;sister churches&equo; is a better title? 
 Ed. 
 &bquo;Fifty years ago&equo; leaves me almost speechless. 
 What is the average APF old dear like me to make of it? 
 I'm used to similar excerpts in The Telegraph  and in the local press, but don't expect them to be so  boring. 
 Good old bishop Shanahan, but the same splendid attitude has been shown since then! 
  Laura Payne, Southsea  
 Point taken. 
 Now &bquo;Fifty Years Ago&equo; has been relegated to the bottom of this page! 
 Ed. 
 I thought the centre double photo page of the celebration of Mass in the simple Third World Church was very beautiful. 
 I thought the great central arch of two tree trunks looked like our Blessed Lord's arms holding up the whole Church. 
  D. Latham, Stoke-on-Trent  
 In the Spring issue of the magazine, a correspondent reminisced about the days when she collected for &bquo;black babies&equo;. 
 I realize that this was done without any intention of hurting anyone, but maybe it would be good to point out that this term can and does offend. 
 I know that the &bquo;black baby&equo; campaign was merely an attempt at fund-raising, but when one realizes that this implies that black children were &bquo;for sale&equo; one can see that this term would be deeply offensive to black Catholics and others. 
 Indeed, I recently heard of a case where some Catholic white children taunted a Catholic black child with the words, &bquo;Are you one of those who were bought?&equo; 
 Without seeking to judge the past in any way, and trying to live out our belief that all races of equal dignity, maybe it would be good if such phrases were now quietly forgotten. 
  T.L. Burke MHM, APF Organizer, Liverpool  
 It was the famous Father William Doyle SJ who invented the &bquo;black babies&equo; slogan. 
 He had cards printed each with a picture of a rescued baby and an invitation to &bquo;buy&equo; a black baby orphan for half-a-crown. 
 Those who donated this amount &mdash; a princely sum before the First World War &mdash; had the right to select a baptismal name. 
 The money raised was given to the Holy Childhood and the scheme was adopted by Australia and Scotland. 
 Father Doyle became the famous Fr Willie Doyle of the trenches, where he was killed in 1917. 
 Time has indeed changed. 
 The Holy Childhood &mdash; one of the Pontifical Mission Societies &mdash; is now renamed Missionary Children with the slogan &bquo;Children Helping Children&equo;. 
 It is active in most of the young churches. 
 Ed. 
 Up to last year we used to collect used postage stamps and then when our dear friend Father Burbage left for Zambia we had to abandon it because we had no idea where they were sent to. 
  Denis Kileen, Hyde  
 The SPA collects used postage stamps at Eccleston Square, and last year received &pound;129 for them. 
 But please post stamps only in large envelopes. 
 Sending small packages costs the donor more in postage than the stamps are worth! 
 Ed. 
 FIFTY YEARS AGO&hellip; 
 Extracts from Missions and Missionaries , Autumn 1939 Fifty years ago the APF was 100 years old. 
 Africa's hour has struck! 
 The announcement that no less than three mission-territories are to be entrusted to native African bishops has rejoiced mission-minded Catholics all over the world. 
 But it is to the peoples of Africa that the news gave the greatest happiness. 
 The appointment of Mgr. 
 Kiwanuka as first Vicar-Apostolic of Musaka in Uganda, of Mgr. 
 Ramarosandratana as Vicar-Apostolic of Miaranarivo, Madagascar, and of Mgr. 
 Faye as Prefect-Apostolic of Ziguinchor, Senegal, brings Africa into line with India, China and Japan, who have each been able to boast their own bishops for some years. 
 At the time of going to press the arrangements for the consecration of these first black bishops of modern times are not yet complete, but it is rumoured that the Holy Father has expressed the wish to elevate all three distinguished sons of Africa to the  plentitude  of the priesthood with his own hands. 
 Here and There 
 KOREA 
 In 1777 a group of Korean scholars sat down to study some Catholic books which had arrived in Korea from Japan. 
 One of them, Yi Sung-hun, went to China in 1783. 
 In Peking he contacted missionaries and asked for baptism. 
 Taking the name Peter he returned home, took the Gospel to his friends and baptized them. 
 Without a priest they met every Sunday in a house on whose site Seoul Cathedral now stands. 
 So, Korea is the only country where the Catholic Church was founded not by missionaries, but by the people themselves. 
 Within seven years persecution broke out. 
 This lasted on and off, for a hundred years and gave the Korean church over 10,000 martyrs. 
 103 of these were canonized by Pope John Paul when he visited Korea in 1984 for its 200th Anniversary celebrations. 
 Now there are over two million Catholics in South Korea. 
 Last year 60 priests were ordained. 
 Now the Koreans boast 1,212 local priests and only 222 missionaries. 
 We have no statistics for the North. 
 Last year in Seoul diocese alone, more than one hundred thousand converts were received into the Church. 
 But the Church is facing major problems. 
 Despite its impressive growth it represents only 5 per cent of the total population and is not growing as fast as evangelical sects. 
 Parishes are too big. 
 Seoul Cathedral parish has over 30,000 Catholics. 
 Only parishes over 60,000 may have a curate. 
 Laity participate mainly through traditional organizations and the call now is for a new strategy based on small Christian communities. 
 This year the 44th Eucharistic Congress will be held in Korea from 5th to 8th October. 
 South Korea is known for its ship building. 
 But last year it sold seven million bibles translated into 119 languages to 90 countries and so became the world's largest exporter of bibles. 
 INDIA 
 Spanish Jesuit missionaries went to Gujarat in 1921. 
 Since then the Catholic population has risen from 4,000 to 120,000. 
 More spectacularly the province now numbers 290 Jesuits, 231 of who are Indians. 
 In recognition of the Salesians' work in education the Prime Minister, Rajiv Ghandi, has authorized a commemorative postage stamp picturing the Salesians' founder, St John Bosco, with an Indian boy. 
 India now has 55,000 religious sisters (nuns). 
 Only 2,000 are missionaries. 
 ZAMBIA 
 In 1984 the youth of the Diocese of Chipata met to discuss the story of Jesus on the road to Emmaus (Luke 24: 13&ndash;35) and ask the question, &bquo;What do we talk about as we walk the path of life?&equo; 
 At the end of three days their resolutions included a request that the diocese establish a centre where young people can study the Bible, dramatize the gospel passages and find ways of evangelizing the youth of Zambia. 
 With the help of the APF this centre has now been opened and operates under the motto, &bquo;Christ is our light. 
 Together let us shine.&equo; 
 EAST AFRICA 
 Due to an upsurge in vocations the Holy Ghost Fathers have now established a new province for Kenya, Tanzania and Uganda. 
 45 East Africans have been ordained and they have 102 major seminarians. 
 EAST TIMOR 
 In only five years the Catholic population of the diocese of Dili has increased from 280,000 to 540,000. 
 It is the rituals of the Church which particularly attract the local people. 
 MONASTERIES 
 Benedictine, Trappist and Cistercian monasteries are flourishing in the Young Churches. 
 There are 84 in Africa, 111 in Latin America, 80 in Asia, 10 in the Far East. 
 An average of 3 new monasteries are opened in the Third World every year. 
 SENEGAL 
 The first two missionary sisters from Senegal have received their missionary crosses from Cardinal Thiandoum, the Archbishop of Dakar. 
 As he presented the crosses he advised: &bquo;Live your religious life to the full. 
 Make Our Lady known and loved. 
 The Church in Senegal sends you to the Church in Benin.&equo; 
 JAMAICA 
 The Franciscan Missionary Sisters of Our Lady of Perpetual Help of Jamaica, commonly called the &bquo;Blue Sisters&equo; were founded in Jamaica in 1925. 
 Three Blue Sisters have now been sent as Missionaries to work in North West Atlanta, USA. 
 ITALY 
 In March parents and relatives of Italy's 17,000 missionaries made a pilgrimage to Rome. 
 In his address to them the Holy Father stressed that the era of Missionaries has not ended. 
 He appealed to Christian families to foster vocations to meet the growing challenge of those who do not know Christ. 
 MISSIONARIES 
 Although they suffer from a shortage of personnel themselves it is the young churches who are now providing the Church with missionaries. 
 Japan has 273 missionaries (30 priests, 239 sisters and 4 lay people). 
 Mauritius has 78 missionaries in 26 countries. 
 Chile has sent 96 missionaries (15 priests, 74 sisters, 3 brothers and 2 lay volunteers). 
 GROWING CHALLENGE 
 In 1986 (the latest year for which statistics are available) the world population grew by over 81 million (81,557,000) and the number of Catholics by over 12 million (12,426,000) to 864 million (864,379,000). 
 But the percentage of Catholics world-wide dropped from 17.68% to 17.64%. 
 Remember this advert? 
 Ordination Day! 
 The joy of Fr Toror and his mother 
 Father Toror was lucky. 
 In 1983 about 500 candidates for the priesthood had to be turned away in Asia and Africa as there was no room for them in the seminaries and no money left. 
 Will you help the Pope's SOCIETY OF ST PETER APOSTLE to ensure that these vocations are not lost simply through lack of funds? 
 &pound;12 can keep a student for a month 
 &pound;150 for a year 
 &pound;1,200 can see him through his course 
 Ask about our Student Adoption Scheme 
 Please remember the Society in your Will 
 THE SOCIETY OF ST PETER APOSTLE NEEDS YOUR HELP URGENTLY. 
 PLEASE DO SOMETHING NOW. 
 Father Toror is coming to England in November along with Brother Karl Gaspar CSSR from the Philippines and Sister Bernadine RNDM from India. 
 Meet them on: 
 Tuesday 14th at St Joseph's, GATESHEAD, 7.30 p.m. 
 Wednesday 15th at English Martyrs, PRESTON, 7.30 pm. 
 Thursday 16th at St Augustine's, MANCHESTER, 7.30 p.m. 
 Friday 17th at St Philip's, SMETHWICK, Birmingham, 7.30 p.m. 
 Sunday 19th at English Martyrs, HORLEY, Surrey, 4.00 p.m. 
 (Sunday evening Mass at 5.30 p.m.) 
 Monday 20th at St Matthew's, NORWOOD, London, 7.30 p.m. 
 Tuesday, 21st at St. Peter's, CARDIFF, 7.30 p.m. 
 Wednesday, 22nd at Clifton Cathedral, BRISTOL, 7.30 p.m. 
 Celebrate with them the Catholicity of the Church.  
 &bquo;Mission is never a destruction but rather a taking up and building afresh.&equo; 
 John Paul II, Redemptor Hominis  
 If you are interested in becoming a missionary, write to:  Mill Hill Missionaries Vocations Director: Father Mark Connolly MHM St Peter's House, College Avenue, Freshfield, Merseyside, L37 1LF 
 &bquo;Whoever lives and believes in me will never die&equo; John 11:26)  
 Please pray for all our deceased members. 
 Carol McMahon: illuminating the Eccleston Square Remembrance Book 
 Missions Missionaries and Young Churches  is the magazine of the Association for the Propagation of the Faith (APF) and the Mill Hill Missionary Society. 
 23 Eccleston Square, London, SW1V 1NU 
 The APF 
 (Association for the Propagation of the Faith) National Headquarters in England and Wales: 23 Eccleston Square, London, SW1V 1NU 
 Started by Pauline Jaricot at the age of 17 Now involves the whole Church in helping the world 
 &bull; The A.P.F. 
 was founded by a French girl, Pauline Jaricot, over 150 years ago, and, in 1922, was made by Pope Pius XI the official mission aid society of the whole Church. 
 The English Branch, in 1936, was linked at parish level, for practical purposes, to St. Joseph's Society for Foreign Missions, the Mill Hill Fathers. 
 &bull; The unique characteristic of the A.P.F. 
 is that it helps all the 910 missionary dioceses of the world through a central fund, to which all countries, including the missionary countries themselves, contribute. 
 The funds are distributed fairly to all missions twice a year. 
 None is neglected and none unduly favoured. 
 The National Directors of each country attend the meetings at which the distributions are made, and discuss them in some detail. 
 &bull; The subsidies given to the missions are of two kinds: 
 Ordinary subsidies: every missionary bishop gets, without fail each year, an ordinary subsidy of up to twenty thousand pounds for the ordinary day-to-day running of the diocese. 
 He can rely on this and plan accordingly. 
 Extraordinary subsidies: these are grants towards particular projects for which the bishop asks for help. 
 These projects range over the entire field of the life of the Church: the establishment of new dioceses; the training of catechists, lay leaders, nuns, priests; the building of churches, parochial centres, school centres; preaching the Gospel by press, television and radio; hospitals, clinics, leprosaria, disaster relief, medicines, transport and other miscellaneous works. 
 An average of nearly 2&half; thousand such projects a year are helped by the central fund. 
 Each year, the whole of the money coming in from the world A.P.F. 
 goes out to the missions. 
 &bull; This is a most unselfish and therefore most Christ-like way of giving. 
 If we give to personally known recipients, we experience gratification while they experience obligation. 
 By giving through a central fund to which all give according to their means and from which those in need receive, we fulfil our Lord's precept: Do not let your right hand know what your left is doing. 
 At the same time, we can be certain, because a full account is published, that our gifts go to the missions where they are most needed, are received with gratitude and reciprocated with prayers. 
 &bull; Prayer: The A.P.F. 
 is not simply a money-centred enterprise. 
 Every member is asked to PRAY DAILY for the world mission of the Church. 
 This concentration of the mind and the heart in prayer adds enormously to the value of the material gift and is a source of spiritual enrichment to the giver. 
 &bull; Understanding: Every member is encouraged to UNDERSTAND the meaning of the mission today through reading the magazine, Missions and Missionaries , given free to all members, so that there will be a growing realisation that the Church is Catholic because it is missionary, and that without the missions the Church would not be itself. 
 Through the A.P.F., with its central fund, its National Directors in every country, and its international co-operation, the universal character of the Catholic Faith is brought home to us, and great hope for the future of the Church in the world is given to us, as we see the vigour and variety of its progress in the mission lands. 
 Play your part in this great enterprise. 
 Join with the Pope in the A.P.F. 
 and help to bring the world to Christ. 
 To: Monsignor Mark Swaby National Director A.P.F. 
 23 Eccleston Square London SW1V 1NU 
 &bull; I would like to become a member of the A.P.F./Mill Hill organisation. 
 Please send me the membership form. 
 &bull; I enclose &pound;&hellip; to help the A.P.F. 
 spread the Faith. 
 Name Address  
 &bull; Cross out if it does not apply 
 Little Sisters of the Poor, and their home for old people near Trincomalee, Sri Lanka. 
 INTRODUCTION: BRIEF MOMENTS 
 The national character is often blamed for the mediocrity of British movies. 
 Either it's argued that British life doesn't show up well in front of a film camera, or that British filmmakers aren't capable of using that camera to probe behind the surface of things. 
 In either case, the problem with British movies is seen as British inhibition. 
 The nation's filmmakers, like its people, can't express emotion; they lack drive and passion, they're tame and repressed. 
 As a result, the British can write novels and plays, even produce an occasional world-class painter but, when it comes to cinema, they might as well forget it. 
 Much British cinema does lack emotional punch, and many screen Englishmen conceal their feelings so effectively beneath a stiff upper lip that it's fair to ask whether they're really human at all. 
 nevertheless, there are many films that undermine this argument, suggesting that British character won't do as an explanation of poor filmmaking. 
 Cinema may come more naturally to driven Americans, bustling Italians or even philosophically-minded Frenchmen but, when British filmmakers actually confront their national inhibitions, amazing things do happen. 
 Films as varied as The 39 Steps, The Wicked Lady, Brief Encounter, The Red Shoes, The fallen Idol, The Spanish Gardener, Accident, The Draughtsman's Contract, Another Time, Another Place  and A fish Called Wanda  are exciting precisely because they work to expose the social and cultural constraints to the expression of emotion, showing up the tension between the bland exterior and the seething interior. 
 Inhibition has been seen as the insoluble problem of British movies: it could be represented as the source of their great potential. 
 The great British films all tap into a problem, the gap between what is felt and what can be expressed, that is universal but gains a particular inflection from being seen in the British context. 
 While these pictures articulate the vision of directors like Alfred Hitchcock, Carol Reed, Michael Powell and David Lean, or writers like No&euml;l Coward, Graham Greene, Emeric Pressburger and Harold Pinter, the films were made possible by production contexts that encouraged these talented individuals to engage with questions that others simply skated over. 
 British films are too rarely good, not because of national character, but because of a production system that is inadequate to the task of generating a regular output of full-blooded films. 
 Filmmaking is such an enormously complex process that it's almost impossible for the outsider to apportion blame for the success or failure of a particular project. 
 Unless you were there, you can't know whether a film's failings should be attributed to the writer's incompetence or the director simply misunderstanding the script. 
 Perhaps the producer hurried the film prematurely into production, or the director didn't carry out the necessary preparation. 
 The lighting cameraman may have been going through a bad patch, or simply been driven crazy by the sort of director who can't make up their mind about anything. 
 It may have been that the editor didn't know how to cut a scene, or that the financiers called in a hack to re-edit the picture. 
 Critics are free to express opinions on such matters, but most of what you hear is pure speculation. 
 What one knows is that, when a film works, it's because writer, director and producer were working in harmony and could inspire everybody else on the project with their joint vision. 
 So when one producer or studio is responsible for a string of hits, it's only necessary to find out what distinguishes its operation from that of other, less successful, operations, or what has changed when the same producer or studio hit a bum run, to discover what makes for successful film production. 
 People have always needed to believe that individuals make films. 
 Otherwise, how would producers know what to buy, PR people what to sell, or critics whom to idolize. 
 If one believes that the director did it, then giving credit, or distributing blame, is a reasonably simple matter. 
 Just pluck the name from a film's credits, and forget the rest of the list. 
 The result is that there isn't really a model which describes filmmaking in its full complexity. 
 Most accounts assume it's a director's medium, in which the writer merely provides raw material and the producer a certain amount of logistical backup, enabling directors to put their vision on the screen. 
 Alternatively, filmmaking is seen as a sort of relay race in which each member of the creative team has control of certain moments &mdash; the producer handing over to the writer, who hands over to the director, who hands over to the lighting cameraman and so on until everything comes back to the producer again. 
 The assumption here is that the more quality names you have in the race, the more likely the product is to be of high calibre. 
 In reality, no concatenation of highly talented individuals ever made a great film. 
 More important than the qualifications of the artists and technicians working on the film is the creative environment in which they operate, and the way it organizes their collaborations. 
 Filmmaking is really a group activity. 
 It works when those involved play well off each other, helping individuals to realize their strengths. 
 Bad films emerge from creative anarchy which brings out the weaknesses of those involved. 
 Precisely because relationships are so fragile, it's in the planning stages, when a bundle of ideas and concepts are hammered out into a script, that the battle for a film is won or lost. 
 Long before the director first calls &bquo;Action&equo;, or anybody has to worry about time, money, the weather or an irritable starlet, the producer, director and writer can sort out the lineaments of the project by focusing on what the film is trying to do, and how it can be made to work. 
 From a good script will emerge a film in which every scene carries an emotional charge, involving the audience in the experience of the characters on the screen while also moving the film forward. 
 A badly-planned script, by contrast, necessarily leads to a badly-organized film, and the only reason anyone thinks otherwise is because so much seems to be going on during the shooting stage &mdash; money is spent, crowds of extras run in front of the cameras, tempers become heated and everybody becomes very tired &mdash; that the person trying to control this chaos appears to the casual observer as the only significant creative force. 
 The original auteur  theory sought to explain how a director could make a distinctive body of work within a filmmaking system, the Hollywood studios, whose factory-like production processes seemed designed to crush out individuality. 
 But the same evidence could have led to a theory celebrating the system which, by laying down norms, establishing disciplines and, most important of all, providing scripts that, while not always particularly imaginative, were at least a sound basis to work from, enabled  these directors to realize their individual vision. 
 When the studio system collapsed, many of the directors who had flourished within it found themselves unable to impose themselves on a process that too easily slipped out of their control. 
 There were British studios, like Rank's Independent Producers or Ealing in the 1940s, that, for a time at least, produced a similarly productive working environment, providing constraints for directors and writers to work against, and dedicated script departments which produced competent material for them to work from. 
 In each case the studios were able to produce a steady supply of good, sometimes amazing, films. 
 Too often, however, producers have not even got to first base, because the requirements for evolving strong scripts have been so poorly understood. 
 Writing, it's true, isn't thought of as one of the problems of British cinema. 
 It's the one thing the nation that produced Shakespeare (albeit 400 years ago!) thinks it can do rather well. 
 But writing screenplays  is something the British do very badly indeed. 
 Outside the script departments of a few studios, too  many producers have taken lazy routes to their scripts. 
 They have relied upon the ideas of novelists and playwrights with no deep interest in cinema, or the work of second-raters who might have produced something good if they had worked within a more stimulating environment, but never had the chance. 
 Or worse, they have simply transposed plays and novels to the screen, producing work at so many removes from the original stimulus to creation that the prospect of the finished film having any appeal to a contemporary audience was almost non-existent. 
 One could argue that British inhibition has played a part in the poverty of British scripts. 
 Perhaps the gentlemanly tradition that prevail d at some British studios was less stimulating than the rebarbative climate created by Hollywood moguls. 
 Or producers have not been sufficiently provocative and challenging in their discussions with screenwriters, failing to generate the levels of energy required to maximize a script's possibilities. 
 Perhaps the undramatic cosiness so often depicted on the screen is only a symptom of an unproductive cosiness in British film production. 
 But the poor organization of British production is a direct consequence of the way British filmmakers have felt their inferiority to both the American film industry and American cinema. 
 This inferiority problem is shared with most film cultures, but the British felt it particularly hard because the two nations' cultural and economic histories were so closely entwined. 
 From early on, Hollywood used British stories and lured British actors, later also directors and technicians, across the Atlantic, while making a mint out of British cinemagoers and developing strategies to drive the local product off the nation's screens. 
 Since the early 1920s, therefore, it has been impossible to talk about any aspect of British cinema without drawing unfavourable comparisons with Hollywood. 
 The thrusting, dynamic and optimistic Americans made the nostalgic and pessimistic British feel rather sorry for themselves. 
 Instead of seeing Hollywood as a powerful rival to be confronted and challenged, British producers have too often looked upon the US film industry as a much-wooed lady who will one day fall into their arms. 
 After all, because of a shared language, no barrier need prevent British films from having the same universal appeal as Hollywood products. 
 Don't we have a kinship with the Americans, the &bquo;Transatlantic branch&equo; of our race? 
 Wouldn't American distributors welcome the opportunity to diversify their product range with some little English films? 
 Such thinking has generally been wrong on every count. 
 At least two-thirds of Americans have never had any reason to think of the British as their Anglo-Saxon cousins; the East European &eacute;migr&eacute;s who ran the studios were no more likely than their successors to look upon British producers as partners, and nobody would queue to see a film just because it was British. 
 So strong was the filmmakers' infatuation with Hollywood that they were unable to work from an understanding of the situation that faced them, and develop British cinema according to its own economic and cultural realities. 
 For the most part, Hollywood has set the agenda. 
 not so much in the earliest days, when US producers had not yet sufficiently geared themselves up to satisfy the demands of their market, so that British exports to the States were largely unproblematic. 
 But, as soon as American distributors no longer needed British films, and the local producers had started to make longer films, the quality of British filmmaking nosedived. 
 UK filmmakers abandoned their innovations with film narrative, producing instead dull, static recordings of theatrical productions in order to secure pictures of the required length. 
 The new generation of producers that subsequently emerged came to believe it was possible for the British film industry to &bquo;take on&equo; the Americans, although this grand ambition had more to do with a desire to efface their inferiority complex than any serious resolve to face reality. 
 Meanwhile, the aspiration further skewed the industry. 
 Open field sites in the vicinity of London were taken over for the construction of studios in the belief that it was heaps of brick and iron rather than organizational flair that explained the success of Louis B. Mayer or Samuel Goldwyn. 
 And the production of numerous low-budget pictures stimulated by the Cinematograph Act of 1927 &mdash; passed to get the film industry moving again &mdash; was treated, for the most part, not as an opportunity to experiment with new styles and cultivate new talent, but as an occasion for allowing mediocrities to make low-budget versions of Hollywood pictures. 
 British cinema increasingly became a bargain-basement imitation of Hollywood. 
 Instead of five large companies dominating production, distribution and exhibition, as in the US, it had two, Rank and ABPC. 
 Producers were so busy fighting their own corner, and so mesmerized by the success of Hollywood, that they didn't have the strength to argue that keeping the industry fragmented and flexible, learning from Hollywood's example without simply imitating its outward forms, might be a better way of catering for a market the size of Britain than heading up the road of monopoly. 
 Even today, when the tottering of a Goldcrest or TESE is taken as a sign that the film industry is going under, it's assumed that big companies are the key to surviving in the film business, because that's the way they do things in LA. 
 The American connection has also disfigured the debate about what sort of films British producers should be making. 
 When, in the late 1920s, a critical backlash developed against films that made themselves vacuous in an attempt to match Hollywood styles, the only way people could think of doing it was to define British cinema as the opposite  of Hollywood &mdash; abandoning melodrama and flamboyance for realism, restraint and understatement. 
 British filmmakers have been struggling ever since with the conflicts created by this critical manoeuvre. 
 Should they be making low-budget films pitched largely at the local market and emphasizing their Britishness, as the critics demand, or big films on the Hollywood model for the world? 
 Does being true to oneself, and not selling out to Hollywood, really mean abandoning melodrama for realism, showmanship for seriousness, spectacle for solemn emotion, tight scripts for improvised styles? 
 Too often the choice for the British filmmaker has seemed to lie between critical approval combined with minimal box office or going all-out to emphasize the most garish, flamboyant and parochial aspects of popular cinema. 
 The best British films have always been those that transcended these artificial oppositions. 
 Made without unnecessary extravagance but containing action, spectacle and visual magic, they are films that spring out of the native culture but articulate a broad vision that can ring chords wherever they are shown. 
 They contain the sort of resonant imagery and psychological complexity one associates with the most determined European cinema, but within strong narratives that recall the best Hollywood films. 
 Producing films at that level requires a stronger nerve than British producers have generally shown. 
 The important British companies, from Korda's London Films to Goldcrest, have attracted capital at a point where they seemed to understand the economic need to balance Hollywood extravagance with a strong dose of parsimony, but all have ended up committing suicide by spending huge sums of money on attempts to emulate Hollywood. 
 No longer able to live with the difficulties inherent in producing films from a British base, they lost touch with reality and discarded common-sense. 
 Still able to see the problem, they no longer knew where to find its solution, and seemed happy in consequence to embrace their own annihilation. 
 Having started off making a big success with a little film, they ended up spending increasingly larger sums of money on bigger films until they had expended so much of their capital they could only go under. 
 The first success disproved the thesis they ended up trying to vindicate, and they progressively discarded financial sanity in a crazy attempt to blot out the problems from their minds. 
 British filmmakers have always needed to face two ways, inwards towards the hopes and fears of the native audience to which they must address their pictures, and out to a broader, international public. 
 Unable to develop an idea of filmmaking that was both British and  international, they concentrated their energies on defining their position on either side of that spectrum, and lost any sense of what cinema really is for. 
 &bquo;I was fed up with English filmmakers who seemed to think that they were automatically entitled to have a film industry&equo; Michael Powell has remarked of the situation in the late 1930s. 
 He went on to demonstrate, as Hitchcock had done earlier, just what a British international film industry would look like. 
 Too few filmmakers have recognized that the argument for a British cinema could only begin when they showed a readiness to listen to people's dreams and nightmares, and play them back to audiences in exciting narratives that would enable those watching to know themselves a little better, and to feel a widening sense of possibility in the way they shaped their lives. 
 Beginning Behind 
 The pattern of industrial organization prevailing in Britain at the end of the nineteenth century made it inevitable that Britain's pioneer filmmakers would quickly find themselves crowded off the world's screens. 
 This was not, however, immediately apparent to those photographers, instrument makers and lanternists who had been fired up to experiment with moving pictures after hearing reports of Edison's Kinetoscope, the original what-the-butler-saw machine, or witnessing the first projection of films made by the Lumi&egrave;re Brothers in 1896. 
 It didn't require much capital to manufacture the equipment or produce the short films, and for some time it was possible for small craftsmen on the British model to keep up with the big boys in France or the US. 
 Early pioneers like Robert William Paul or James Williamson entered on their new enterprise with confidence, even though they were only individual craftsmen working out of small workshops and studios. 
 Their past experience enabled them to produce and maintain their own equipment, and operate it with competence, but the fact that none had themselves initiated any of the significant developments in filmmaking or projects was an early indication of their unpreparedness for serious competition. 
 Paul had the technical know-how to copy Edison's Kinetoscope when he realized the American inventor hadn't covered all the necessary patents, to make his own camera when Edison cut off the supply of films and produce a film projector, the Theatrograph, within two months of hearing about Lumi&egrave;re's invention. 
 But, despite this ability to pick up on new innovations, and add refinements of their own, neither Paul nor any of the other pioneers found the backup necessary to generate significant leaps forward in the manufacture of equipment or the films themselves. 
 Scattered around the London suburbs, or in provincial towns like Sheffield, Brighton and Bradford, these pioneers had only limited access to capital resources, and their companies never grew to any real size. 
 They became directors, screenwriters, producers, even actors, because that was the way to sell their equipment. 
 Gradually film production became their main preoccupation, but only Cecil Hepworth became sufficiently involved to continue after the industry had hit its first crisis. 
 As industrial enterprises, all were minnows by comparison with the Edison Corporation in the US, which had financial backing from Wall Street to finance a fine workshop, a large staff. 
 In France too, the Lumi&egrave;re Brothers operated on a much larger scale than their British counterparts and, by 1902, Path&eacute;-Fr&egrave;res had expanded to the point where it carried out all the functions relating to film production &mdash; from the manufacture of film stock to exhibition. 
 none of Britain's filmmaking companies had this level of entrepreneurial energy. 
 They reacted to events, never initiating them, and this trait became an increasing liability as time passed. 
 Nevertheless, Britain's early filmmakers set about the business of film production with some brio and not a little flair. 
 Paul was soon making 50 short items a year; predominantly filmed vaudeville turns and trick films exploiting the new medium's capacity for visual magic. 
 Equally productive, though somewhat more sophisticated, was James Williamson, a former portrait photographer and lanternist who was one of a group of filmmakers gathered in Brighton. 
 Cinema developed alongside the wireless and the telephone as communications media that would change the way people perceived the world around them. 
 It is doubtful, however, whether these filmmaking pioneers had any sense at all of the new invention's potential significance. 
 They may have felt a degree of excitement as they turned their cameras on a train arriving at a station, waves crashing on the beach, or a group of workers emerging from their daily grind in the factory, but these early pieces of reportage were seen as nothing more than &bquo;animated photographs&equo;, a further step in the development of photography. 
 A little later, as filmmakers began to expend the medium's storytelling capacities, they drew from the techniques developed for the magic lantern or diorama and audiences saw a woman interrupting her husband in the act of kissing the maid, or a miller grappling with chimney sweeps in front of a windmill. 
 It was natural to see these moving pictures as nothing more than a novelty, perhaps merely a passing gimmick; they were, after all, only shown as an additional turn on the music-hall programme. 
 A little later, shows were put on at village fairs and halls by travelling showmen. 
 Places dedicated to film presentation, the penny gaffes, did start to spring up at the beginning of the new century, but it was only with the emergence of long films around 1910 that cinema acquired any sort of institutional presence in British towns. 
 There is an extraordinary variety to the films produced in the early days of British cinema, showing the diversity of sources from which filmmakers drew their ideas. 
 A film like Mary Jane's Mishap  (1903), in which an uncouth maid who has been a little careless with the paraffin evaporates through the chimney, but returns in ghostly form to visit her grave, derives its fantasy elements from magic lantern shows, whereas The Big Swallow  (1901), which shows camera and cameraman being swallowed up in a restless jaw, is more evidently a response to the medium's possibilities. 
 One also feels he potential of moving images being explored in some simple documentary footage, as in the almost abstract shots of boys throwing snowballs, wind-surfing, skating and tobogganing in Winter Sports  (1902). 
 Some films show their makers grappling with contemporary issues, without always the level of visual inventiveness applied elsewhere. 
 Two films made by James Williamson, for example, deal with the hardships endured by the families of those who fought in the Boer War. 
 In The Soldier's Return  (1902), a returning warrior rescues his mother from the workhouse, while the demobbed soldier of A Reservist before the War and after the War  (1902) steals a loaf of bread in order to supply the needs of his destitute wife and children. 
 Both these films are somewhat stagey, but contemporary comment could be combined with visual fantasy, as is revealed by Cecil Hepworth's The Perils of Modern Motoring  (1905), in which a policeman is left in a dismembered state after being mowed down by a car. 
 After his pieces have been reassembled, both the driver and the passengers from the offending vehicle disappear in a puff of smoke. 
 It was the fact that the same individual could experiment with such a wide range of themes, subjects and styles that kept the spirit of invention alive, and encouraged some startling developments in film narrative, none of which had anything to do with theatrical forms of presentation. 
 Williamson's Fire  (1901) competently builds tension by running together the story of a man in a burning room and the fire brigade scurrying to his rescue. 
 An even keener sense of anticipation is developed four years later in Hepworth's Rescued by Rover  (1905), about a dog's role in rescuing a kidnapped child. 
 Will the dog find the baby? 
 Will the dog persuade the master that he knows something important? 
 The way in which the film provokes these questions makes it possible, even today, to understand why this film was such a hit, selling 385 prints at &pound;10 apiece. 
 Many other films released at this time showed how widespread were the skills developed by Hepworth. 
 The travelling showman William Haggar's The Life of Charles Peace  (1905) may be less achieved but the sympathy it elicits for the ingenious villain who had been hanged in 1879 marks it out as a piece of genuine popular entertainment. 
 Rather more in line with British cinema's future disdain for anyone outside the middle classes is Williamson's Two Little Waifs  (1905), in which two adult gypsies are left to the flames while their daughter is carried off to her convalescence in a suburban garden. 
 Not all the content is quite so melodramatic, and the same filmmaker's Our Little Errand Boy  (1905) is a fabulous slapstick comedy about a plucky prankster who terrorizes his neighbourhood and, when pursued by the vicar, the shopkeeper, the matron and various others, locks them all behind the wire mesh of a chicken run. 
 It is around this time that the demand for films began to increase substantially and producers built larger studios to produce pictures that, while longer than before, were still some way short of what would become established feature length. 
 The search for subjects that would appeal to audiences narrowed the range of films made, and resulted in a sometimes excessive reliance on stories involving naughty boys, magic drinks, plucky dogs pursuing criminals and clothes left lying around for tramps to pick up. 
 But a film like When the Devil Drives  (1907), in which a train is taken over by the devil and taken at great speed under the sea and into the sky, shows that length did not necessarily constrict imagination, while The Airship Destroyer  (1909), with its combination of romance and action in the story of an inventor who develops a missile that will destroy an airship, shows a filmmaker drawing material from contemporary anxieties about aerial combat. 
 A final taste of freedom for the hero of The Life of Charles Peace  (1905) 
 Both the latter films were made by Walter Booth for Charles Urban, an American who had been sent to Britain in order to look after Edison's interests, then set up on his own as a distributor and exporter of French and American films. 
 He sponsored documentary films of the Boer War and also travel and scientific films, and distributed the films of Williamson and others. 
 Later he became involved with the Brighton-based G. A. Smith in developing the Kinemacolor process. 
 With his entrepreneurial skills, and his international connections, he seemed for a time the man most likely to lead the British film industry away from its artisanal base, but he turned out to be no more responsive than anyone else to developments that were going to make things very difficult for the pioneers. 
 Initially there had been a substantial market for British films in the US, where demand remained for some time ahead of the production levels achieved by American filmmakers. 
 But in 1908 Edison set up the Motion Picture Patents Company (MPPC), which included among its aims an increase in the share of the US market taken by domestic productions. 
 To achieve this aim involved driving out the small importers. 
 This was appalling news for the British companies, none of which had anything like the clout necessary to claim membership of the MPPC. 
 Of the two European companies that did become members, M&eacute;li&egrave;s had built its fortunes around the genius of one innovative filmmaker, whereas Path&eacute; had deliberately set out on an internationalist path, making films not only in France but also in Britain, the US, Italy, Germany, Russia and Japan. 
 Such small British companies as Cricks and Martin, Clarendon, British and Colonial and Urban came nowhere near that level of enterprise. 
 Hepworth, it seems, even resented foreign filmmakers operating in England and trying &bquo;to poach upon the natural preserves of other lands.&equo; 
 Imbued with such smugness, British filmmakers inevitably fell behind. 
 While the french film industry expanded from its well-organized base, the Edison cartel encouraged the more effective organization that came from combining production and distribution in one company, and Edison's competitors like Shmuel Gelbfisz (Goldwyn), a former glove salesman from Lodz, or Lewis Zeleznik (Selznick), a jewellery dealer from Kiev, began to exploit the potential of the new medium in the US, many of the British pioneers decided to pack it in. 
 G. A. Smith was among the first to give up, going to work with Urban on developing his new colour process; Haggar retired in 1909 to run his own cinema; Williamson curtailed the production of dramatic comic films after his standing contract with the UA was cancelled and directed his energies into educational filmmaking to escape &bquo;the horrible nightmare of having my business directed by outsiders.&equo; 
 And Paul decided, after the failure of his expensive trick film, The Butterfly  (1910), that production was &bquo;too speculative to be run as a sideline to instrument making.&equo; 
 Even Hepworth shifted for a while into distribution after losing a regular order from the US for up to 40 copies of every film he made. 
 Too late did he realize, as he later acknowledged, that he had been &bquo;lured by the apparent security of our trade with America and other countries into feeling that change and progress need not be too seriously contemplated.&equo; 
 The withdrawal of these pioneers from the scene need not have been bad news for the industry; few American production outfits made the transition to new times and M&eacute;li&egrave;s failed to keep up in France. 
 The problem was that, in the UK, no enterprising producer stepped forward to fill the gap their departure created. 
 Britain began to slip badly as a competitive producer of films, and the national market was increasingly ceded to imports from France and America. 
 On a visit to England in 1914, Charles Path&eacute; initiated what was to become a French sport, mocking the backwardness of British production. 
 This he blamed on a lack of enterprise: &bquo;There is no continuity of effort among your producers,&equo; he said, &bquo;They work too hastily and in too small a way.&equo; 
 A crisis of confidence among Britain's producers was the result of this sort of taunting, and from around this time one begins to detect in the press a sense that the nation's honour was threatened by its film industry's parlous condition. 
 &bquo;Hurrah! 
 English Drama Again Takes Premier Position&equo; ran the hopeful headline over a piece that described Hepworth's Rachel's Sin  (1911) as &bquo;a great triumph in film production&equo; which was &bquo;all ENGLISH&equo;. 
 But, despite Hepworth's brazen nationalism, confidence in British filmmakers declined. 
 As early as 1909, British and Colonial had brought over American directors and stars for its films. 
 And when the London Film Company was formed in 1913 by Dr Ralph Tennyson Jupp, as an offshoot of his Provincial Cinematograph Theatres exhibition company, he relied heavily upon American producers and directors. 
 With some reason did another Frenchman remark at this time that Britain had become no more than a colony of the American film industry. 
 The need to make films longer, in order to compete with American and French imports, also bred a more insidious form of dependence. 
 For 15 years British filmmakers had experimented with the medium, developing film editing and camera effects to build suspense, and explore a world of magic and fantasy. 
 Seen now, these early British films still have a feeling of freshness and spontaneity that derives from the natural performances of non-actors, and a loose approach to framing which allows interesting material to get in at the edge of the picture. 
 But when William George Barker decided to bring to the screen a stage production of Henry VIII  (1911), he cut British film production off from the innovations that had gone before. 
 Barker was a natural showman, promoting Henry VIII  with the declaration that he would burn all the prints of the film within six weeks, and his own sense of the significance of what he had done is echoed in Rachael Low's description of this as &bquo;the first really important feature film.&equo; 
 But the only thing that was important about the film was its length and the ill omens it offered for the future. 
 The development was welcomed by exhibitors, who felt that stage adaptations would enable them to attract a better class of customer, but they weren't to know what they were letting themselves in for. 
 It was also paralleled abroad, where a French production of Queen Elizabeth  was imported to the US by Adolph Zukor. 
 But whereas film industries as vital as the French or American could absorb this new development, the British industry was put into a straitjacket by it. 
 Since the prints of Henry VIII  were consigned to the flames at Ealing Studios, it's not possible to assess what merits Barker's production may have had, but some idea of the uncinematic monstrosity that was produced is suggested by a contemporary production of Richard III , which consists of 17 scenes played out from the stage to a static camera, interrupted by lengthy titles containing brief pieces of dialogue. 
 The chase films swept away by this development may have been repetitive but they offered an excitement that no one can have secured from the sight of London stage actors running through potted silent versions of Shakespeare. 
 Slightly more promising as a source of cinematic entertainment were the melodramatic novels to which Barker and others turned for narrative material. 
 But, as producers bowdlerized the romantic stories of Marie Corelli and Hall Caine, as well as literary classics by Dickens, Thackeray and George Eliot, the resulting films were all the evidence one needed that British filmmakers had lost confidence in their own ability to find and develop stories, and exploit the medium's potential. 
 They stripped these books down to their narrative skeletons, then scattered a string of incidents on to the screen without caring whether they moved or excited the audience. 
 With such a large literary storehouse to draw on, it all seemed so easy, even if the results were often dispiriting. 
 In 1914, one commentator rashly predicted that the fad for adaptations wouldn't last much longer. 
 After a brief flurry of original stories at the beginning of the First World War, it was back to business as usual and, by the early 1920s, some 95 per cent of film stories were adapted from the stage or novels. 
 The filmed play does not have to be stagey, nor the filmed look uncinematic, if the adaptation is imaginatively done. 
 But there was little understanding at the time of how much work was required to develop high-quality screenplays. 
 Writers were poorly paid, rarely given a screen credit and never encouraged to take a fresh approach. 
 Hepworth gives an account of the process of developing a script that reveals how undynamic was his approach to screenwriting, as well as how low a regard he had for writers: 
 When I read a book or saw a play or studied a synopsis, there came into my mental vision a fairly detailed and consecutive pattern of what the film would be like. 
 That pattern stuck in my head and gradually crystallized it out into a definite form, while the scenario was being prepared for me. 
 There is no sense here of any engagement with the writer on what the script should be like, nor does Hepworth anticipate substantial work being done on the text after his initial moments of introspection. 
 It's unsurprising that such an attitude failed to produce competent screenwriters, let alone exciting ones. 
 Hepworth justified poaching from literature because of &bquo;the advantage of a well-made plot, which was not at all easy to come by in original film scenarios&equo;, but what this ignores is the responsibility of producers like him to foster the writing skills which would end British cinema's reliance on the novel or play, and novelistic or theatrical styles of storytelling. 
 Without writers there could be no new ideas about what cinema could do, and without new ideas there could be no sense of British cinema having a purpose. 
 Instead of confronting their problems, producers fell back into a sorry-for-themselves analysis. 
 A series of screenings were arranged in 1912 to &bquo;demonstrate the high qualities of the British film&equo;, and they proved rather the opposite. 
 Producers responded to the critical backlash with a self-deceiving debate about whether British films did poorly because they were bad, or simply because they were suspected of being so. 
 Instead of looking for new approaches that could galvanize the industry to deal with its problems, the call went up for a leader who would, in the words of one Bioscope  editorial, be able &bquo;to make order out of disorder, to organize agreement and concord with a strong hand, tactfully and helpfully, yet with a stern repression of pettiness and ignoble motives.&equo;. 
 And filmmakers also began to argue for government legislation to protect the industry against marauding Americans. 
 When the director Maurice Elvey heard of a proposal to tax all films imported into Britain, he declared, &bquo;Why should the industry be protected. 
 If it is not strong enough to grow on its own, let it die as soon as possible.&equo; 
 Such a comment was not one, of course, to which any patriotically-minded Englishman could give heed. 
 Transition 
 There was much optimism about the prospects for British film production in the aftermath of the First World War. 
 &bquo;The industry&equo;, Hepworth later remarked, &bquo;had enormously increased its prestige with the public, Parliament and the press. 
 It had played no small part in tranquillizing things at home and inspiring &bquo;national will to victory&equo;, and that was earnestly acknowledged by the Prime Minister.&equo; 
 Unfortunately, most of this hopefulness was mere wishful thinking. 
 Cinema admissions had indeed increased as people sought escape at the movies from the horrors of war, and the flow of French and Italian imports had been disrupted, but the screen-time made available had been almost totally absorbed by American pictures: by 1918 some 80 per cent or films shown in Britain were from the US. 
 And, whereas filmmaking technique had been advancing in America, things had almost stood still in Britain. 
 In reality, the basis for the prevailing sense of optimism was nothing more than a sense that, with hostilities now ended, everyone could get back to business as usual. 
 But &bquo;business as usual&equo; would not be enough to enable British producers to compete for audiences against American films. 
 They hadn't grasped how popular American cinema had become with audiences worldwide. 
 They saw Hollywood films, just as everyone else did, and many made valiant efforts to learn from American filmmaking styles. 
 In 1920, for example, the notoriously rotund producer G. B. Samuelson made a trip to Universal Studios, where he produced six pictures to learn what he could about the American way of doing things. 
 He could have stayed at home since, in the year of his journey, Famous Players&mdash;Lasky set up its own studio in Islington, to make films the American way. 
 Yet British producers didn't appreciate the scale of what they were up against. 
 Hepworth was to speak wistfully of &bquo;a pressure in the air which we did not understand&equo;, saying that &bquo;we worked on as best we could in spite of it.&equo; 
 Money was not initially the problem. 
 The optimistic talk about the future of British films softened up sources of capital. 
 Hepworth raised &pound;100,000 to fund an expansion programme. 
 Alliance, one of a number of new companies formed after the war, spent &pound;90,000 on a grandiose production programme before seeing how a single one of its films performed in the cinemas. 
 And two of the larger distribution companies moved into production: Ideal with funding of around &pound;115,000, Stoll with some &pound;400,000 in the bank. 
 Such sums may have been trivial in comparison with the financial resources at the disposal of the larger American combines, but they provided a base that could have been built on. 
 Commercial success would have lured forth more cash. 
 Instead, within seven years, Hepworth had declared himself bankrupt and Stoll had withdrawn from the production business, having lost some &pound;200,000 from its various production ventures. 
 The production policy followed by Sir Oswald Stoll, a leading figure in the vaudeville world, was an imitation of Hollywood pursued with the aim of maximizing productivity and ensuring a steady supply of films for his distribution setup. 
 Productivity he achieved &mdash; by 1925 a third of the films made in Britain came from Stoll's studios at Cricklewood &mdash; but he was never anywhere near achieving his intention to &bquo;leave American buyers convinced of England's ability to deliver the goods.&equo; 
 The problem was twofold. 
 The market for British films was not sufficiently large to justify mass production of films at budgets high enough to ensure they reached real quality, and executives at Stoll didn't understand the difference between good stories and good cinema. 
 A lot of money was spent on the acquisition in 1920 of the rights to a series of novels by H. G. Wells, Edgar Wallace, Marie Corelli and Conan Doyle, but little care was expended on ensuring that these books were transmuted into workable scripts. 
 Things were much the same at Ideal, where Victorian novels and stage plays were preferred to books by contemporary worthies of literature. 
 Films like Lady Audley's Secret  (1920), the story of a bigamous marriage and a woman's cold-blooded murder of her devoted husband, were sensational without being plotted or shoot with an eye to involving an audience. 
 Alliance compounded its problems by allowing its production policies to be influenced by a consultative literary committee, on which theatrical big-wigs such as Arthur Wing Pinero played a leading role. 
 Factors such as the parasitic reliance on the stage and the book, the lack of attention given to screenwriting, the lack of flexibility in studio-based production and, at Stoll, a studio floor so constructed that it accommodated the noise and bustle of five films at the same time, had a deadening effect on anyone who came into the industry with new ideas or fresh visions. 
 When the young Alfred Hitchcock was looking for a studio in which to learn the craft of filmmaking, it never occurred to him to knock at the doors of Samuelson's Worton Hall or Stoll at Cricklewood. 
 Instead he went to work for Famous Players&mdash;Lasky, first as a subtitle writer and then as a screenwriter. 
 Even here, however, the shortage of filmmaking competence was felt, causing the American company to terminate the project in 1924 with a complaint that &bquo;the productions failed to reach a quality comparable to those made in the States.&equo; 
 In four years, Famous Players&mdash;Lasky had given the go-ahead to only one screenplay from a British writer. 
 The poor quality of the films coming out of Stoll and Ideal did nothing to improve the reputation of British pictures, nor strengthen the hands of their producer-distributors in negotiating good terms for their cinema screening. 
 And exhibitors were under increasing pressure from American practices designed to ensure it was US pictures which British audiences saw. 
 Hollywood produced duds too, but could package them up with surefire-winners like the Chaplin shorts and insist that the cinema booker buy everything in the package. 
 In this way exhibitors were forced to fill up their screens for months ahead with pictures they had never seen. 
 Often the only opening they could offer British producers would arise because a blind-booked film hadn't turned up. 
 As a result, British films were sometimes forced to wait up to 18 months to secure a release. 
 For small British companies with limited capital resources, that delay could be terminal. 
 Just how tough it could be for the independent producer is evident from the history of Minerva Films. 
 Set up in 1920 by actor Leslie Howard and director Adrian Brunel among others, with the hope that they could do something about &bquo;raising the standards of British films&equo;, the company had only enough capital to produce six short comedies. 
 Unable to get these onto the screen for 18 months, and lacking the clout necessary to raise the additional money for the six extra films they would need to secure foreign distribution, Minerva went under. 
 Brunel was a serious casualty of the sluggishness of British production at this period. 
 In 1922, he made The Man Without Desire , an imaginative account of a man who wakes from a sleep of several hundred years only to find he suffers from a lack of emotion. 
 The film was a success but, for the next five years, Brunel could secure no further directing opportunities and passed his time writing stories, editing imported films and producing home movies. 
 The sense of disappointment that hangs over the rest of his career reflects the loss of nerve that came from finding that, at the moment when his career seemed to be taking off, there were no opportunities to build on what he had achieved. 
 &bquo;Whenever I have had some sort of public success,&equo; he reported in his autobiography, &bquo;it has inevitably been followed by a period of personal financial distress and prolonged unemployment.&equo; 
 Occasionally, British producers were able to secure foreign revenue to supplement the returns available to their films from the home market, but no one managed to secure a regular outlet for their productions in the US. 
 Hepworth and Stoll failed in their attempt to set up a permanent sales operation in America; Samuelson secured a short-lived distribution arrangement with First National Exhibitors' Circuit, and various other films secured some sort of release. 
 But the problem was that British exhibitors didn't produce a sufficiently reliable supply of quality product to ensure that any of these efforts were long-lasting. 
 In 1922, the year in which audiences ere offered such striking films as Rex Ingram's The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse  and Fritz Lang's Die Niebelungen  cycle, not to mention Douglas Fairbanks' spirited version of an English story, The Adventures of Robin Hood , of the 422 British films offered to American exhibitors only six found buyers.  
 filming Ivor Novello in The Man Without Desire  (1922) 
 There were quality films made in Britain during this period, but their producers pursued a non-commercial approach. 
 Hepworth's obsessive desire to make &bquo;English pictures, with all the English countryside for background and with English atmosphere and English idiom throughout&equo; didn't keep him up-to-date with audience tastes. 
 Comin Thro&equo; the Rye  (1922), for example, exploits the beauties of the English countryside and constructs an allegorical subtext out of the changing seasons, but the narrative approach dilutes the dramatic potential inherent in its tale of a simple girl robbed of her true love by a heartless flirt, the sort of woman who is &bquo;very useful for amusing men on rainy days.&equo; 
 The passivity of the wronged girl is a trait she shares with the hero of Guy Newell's Fox Farm  (1922), a sensitive farmer abandoned by his go-getting wife after he has been blinded in an explosion. 
 Even before his accident, he's much given to lighting his pipe, slumping in a chair and arguing that it's no use pushing against fate. 
 Afterwards, he becomes loquacious about the Stoics, &bquo;men who took what came, because they knew that grumbling made no difference.&equo; 
 Worthy as such sentiments may be, they are not the stuff of powerful drama. 
 The low intensity of these rural idylls shows up the problems created by the failure of the commercially-minded companies to generate anything other than fusty, studio-bound melodramas, as unsuccessful in their way as the airy, de-sensationalized productions of their more creative competitors. 
 Newell and Hepworth might define their own styles against those of Stoll and Ideal but, since neither was particularly successful, there was no pressure operating on the one to be more &bquo;commercial, or the other to be more &bquo;artistic&equo;. 
 Both followed the route that came most naturally to them, with relatively unsatisfactory results all round. 
 The career of George Pearson provides an interesting example of the commercial and creative impulses fighting against each other in one person. 
 Pearson came to films from school-teaching when he was already 37. 
 Welsh&mdash; Pearson, the company he set up in 1915, remained small, making only three or four films a year, thus resisting the pressures for mass production that prevailed at the larger studios. 
 But, much more than a filmmaker like Hepworth, he had learnt to find stories that would have genuine popular appeal. 
 In 1914, Gaumont's London office commissioned him to make Ultus, the Man from the Dead , an attempt to match the success of the French company's Fant&ocirc;mas  series. 
 The film and its three sequels are well-constructed crime stories, told with speed and punch.  
 Alma Taylor against the English landscape in comin&equo; thro&equo; the Rye  (1922) 
 Criminal action in George Pearson's Ultus  (1915) 
 Pearson challenged the rest of British cinema's reliance on middle-class theatre by commissioning original stories that could appeal o  a more popular audience. 
 His sensitivity to audience tastes also led to his developing Britain's first homegrown film star in Betty Balfour, whom he put into a series of films featuring the character of Squibs, an impish Piccadilly flower girl. 
 The films are simple, unpretentious and amusing. 
 In Squibs Wins the Calcutta Sweep  (1922), for example, the energetic heroine suddenly comes into money, with which she spreads happiness to her neighbours and enjoys the high life, thereby offering audiences an opportunity for vicarious wish-fulfilment. 
 The film is not particularly well constructed, and the subplot featuring Squibs' sister's desperate life in Paris with a murderer on the run is poorly connected to the scenes of rejoicing back home, but the central character's vitality carries the story. 
 However, Pearson's lack of interest in the methods of play construction led him towards even more unfocused ways of organizing his films, aiming for a sort of primitive naturalism &mdash; &bquo;nothing more than the capture of things seen, life in the living, and by selection and arrangement, the flow of the human tale.&equo; 
 He described his 1924 film Reveille , an episodic account of how a group of humble people had been affected by the war, as &bquo;a scrapbook of pictures of life caught in the living, no hero, no villain, no plot, no tying up of loose threads.&equo; 
 His 1926 film, The Little People , was publicized as &bquo;just a bit of life caught by the camera&equo;. 
 Unfortunately audiences did not warm to such tales and their commercial failure led to Pearson losing control of his own company. 
 As a result, the creative phase of his career came to an end. 
 Pearson's enforced demotion within his own company, and the distaste shown by his partners for experiments that veered too sharply away from the comedies that had established Welsh&mdash;Pearson's reputation, is generally taken as evidence of the conservatism inherent in the film industry. 
 Pearson is seen as the first British director to be sacrificed on the altar of his art. 
 Nevertheless it does show considerable misjudgement to make films that had little to do with popular taste at a time when it was so difficult for British filmmakers to find an audience. 
 Pearson hoped that the sense of authenticity in his films would &bquo;carry feeling and understanding to an audience,&equo; but it was odd to imagine he could achieve genuine popularity by avoiding suspense and dramatic conflict. 
 Pearson's strategy led him to ignore, rather than deal with, the increasing crisis within British film production. 
 Those small producers who were so intimidated by the problems of securing significant distribution that they simply carried on producing small, cheap pictures which, according to Hepworth, &bquo;helped to build up and succour the very evil which was bringing about their downfall&equo;, inevitably went under first. 
 But even more ambitious filmmakers like Samuelson and Hepworth were pushed out by the difficulties involved in making film production profitable. 
 Production declined sharply. 
 In 1923, some 25 per cent of the films shown to the trade were British; the following year it was only five per cent. 
 In 1926, only 26 films went before the cameras. 
 To some extent this decline in quantity was coupled with an improvement in quality. 
 Nevertheless, the general contraction of the industry did further damage to its already shrivelled morale. 
 Conscious that British audiences were almost wholly uninterested in British films, some members of the industry increased their efforts to secure through persuasion and publicity what the films so patently could not. 
 In 1918, an attempt had been made to form a British Screen Club to influence the press in favour of British films. 
 Similar thinking lay behind the setting up of the British National Film League in 1921 to &bquo;encourage the production and exhibition of British-made films&equo;. 
 Its activities led to the British Film Weeks of 1924, which involved screening a programme of British pictures, accompanied by the sort of ballyhoo which left the public, according to critic Paul Rotha, &bquo;hypnotized into readiness to applaud the worst picture in the world because it was British.&equo; 
 Unfortunately, the films, which included Hepworth's Comin&equo; Thro&equo; the Rye , did nothing to support the claims made for them. 
 It must have begun to seem that there was nothing the British film producer could do to challenge the place of American films on the nation's screens. 
 Certainly, the Americans assumed that the victory was won; &bquo;Not even on the horizon,&equo; remarked Marcus Loew in 1926, &bquo;can I see the nucleus of a British film-producing industry.&equo; 
 But although these were indeed dog days for British film production, film producers were emerging who understood the need for modern styles of production, bigger budgets and more ambitious showmanship. 
 If neither Herbert Wilcox, Michael Balcon nor Victor Saville started off with much in the way of imaginative flair, they did at least know what was required to build successful enterprises. 
 All three came from the Midlands and had been at the sharp end of the business as salesmen for distribution companies. 
 When they launched themselves into production in 1922, Balcon and Saville with Woman to Woman , the story of a shell-shocked officer who comes out of amnesia to discover the truth about his sordid past, and Wilcox with two films of which the second, a florid melodrama called The Flames of Passion , was a hit, they used the same director, Graham Cutts, and judged it worthwhile incurring the expense of bringing over American stars, Betty Compson for Woman , Mae Marsh for Flames , in order to increase their films' marquee value at home and abroad. 
 The strategy worked in both cases, and the producers were able to turn their initial successes into the resilience required to survive the setbacks that followed. 
 Wilcox remained always the showman, often directing his movies even though, like Saville in the same role, he was always more competent than gifted. 
 He was committed to middle-of-the-road filmmaking, which he defined as &bquo;escape entertainment of pleasant people in pleasant surroundings doing pleasant things&equo;, had an eye for a subject that could be exploited, and was fascinated by stardom. 
 He loved to watch the crowds that gathered at Waterloo Station to greet the actresses he brought over from the US for his productions. 
 Dorothy Gish, for example, featured in his Nell Gwynn  (1926) and Madame Pompadour  (1927). 
 Balcon was unique among these &eacute;migr&eacute;s  from the Midlands in that he remained only a producer. 
 Having started his working life in business (with the Dunlop Rubber Company), he saw himself as an impresario rather than a producer&mdash;director, and he consistently sought to develop an environment which stimulated the creativity of others. 
 Through the successive phases of his career &mdash; at Gainsborough, Gaumont-British and then at his own Ealing Studios &mdash; he was to show that his talent lay in finding the most talented people available, giving them the best context to work in, inspiring and stimulating their efforts and intervening where necessary to ensure that the best possible film came out of the production process. 
 Balcon was the sort of producer the British film industry had needed for a long time. 
 He had the eye for detail and concern for quality lacking in Stoll or Samuelson, as well as the sort of business acumen that neither Hepworth nor Pearson had ever displayed. 
 Not, of course, that all the policies of the mature Balcon emerged at this period. 
 He was himself later to acknowledge the inadequacy of a production policy that drew so heavily on stage plays, particularly at a period before the arrival of sound when it was impossible, for example, to do more than allude to the savagery of No&euml;l Coward's attack on his social set in The Vortex  (1927). 
 Even so, some impressive films did emerge, notably The Rat  (1925), whose pulp subject matter and lowlife setting invites comparison with the popular work of Pearson, while the script, although untidy, is much more engaging. 
 Also, the performance of Ivor Novello as the impoverished hero whose charming vulnerability wins the hearts of all the girls, as well as that of a bored woman surrounded by too much luxury, and Cutts's mobile camerawork, put it in another class. 
 The film deserved its popularity and its sequel. 
 Novello, who had initially developed The Rat  for Brunel, was to join with Cutts' assistant, Alfred Hitchcock, in demonstrating that adapted stageplays didn't need to constrict cinematic invention as long as script and direction were entrusted to someone who could convey ideas in visual terms. 
 The Lodger  (1926) opens dramatically with the shot of a screaming girl, then shows the news being spread abroad, causing fear and panic throughout the city. 
 This might be the prelude to any adapted stage play, a stimulating montage before the proscenium arch is fitted over the screen. 
 But, although most of the rest of the film, until its chase finale, is played out within one house, where the lodger's strange behaviour arouses suspicions of his guilt, Hitchcock's interest in using the details of daily life to build anticipation and stir emotion ensures that the action never seems confined. 
 With good cause did Kine Weekly  subsequently hail the film for giving &bquo;promise of a genuine reaction against the deeply-rooted Wardour Street superstition that America will only buy pictures similar to her own.&equo; 
 The Lodger  represented a substantial step forward for British filmmaking. 
 Its release had, however, been held up for some time on instructions from C. M. Woolf, a shrewd film salesman who had played a key role in financing the first projects of both Balcon and Wilcox. 
 The re-editing he demanded has generally been taken as evidence of just that Wardour Street backwardness to which Kine Weekly  alluded. 
 But while it's true that Woolf's disapproval of the film's distinctive angles and extreme lighting contrasts does betray a degree of conservatism and, in his later campaign against The Man who Knew Too Much  (1934), he was clearly the enemy of anything even moderately original, Woolf was not a simple philistine. 
 Brunel, no less committed than Hitchcock to an &bquo;artistic&equo; direction for British films, was later unstinting in his praise of a man who &bquo;by his faith and support set the pace at a time when we most needed it&equo; and credited him with contributing &bquo;very considerably to the renaissance of the British film production industry.&equo; 
 Given that the re-editing of the film reduced the number of title cards from 300 to 80, it is reasonable to assume that Woolf's intervention considerably improved the film, and that Woolf's commercial experience provided a valuable lesson both for Hitchcock and Balcon. 
 What was being fought out over The Lodger  was a debate about how far it was possible to combine a concern for art with the values of popular cinema. 
 Hitchcock was triumphantly able to achieve this sort of synthesis, but it is not surprising that Woolf was suspicious of the highbrow values that were being propagated around this time, and decided to challenge their deployment on this film. 
 The formation of the Film Society in 1925, which aimed to make British filmmakers aware of the creative possibilities of the medium by screening the most artistically adventurous films being made in Russia, Germany and elsewhere, had caused some confusion in the commercial film industry, which rightly saw the Film Society's platform as a blast against the prevailing aesthetic orthodoxies. 
 Brunel, in fact, was advised by Gainsborough executives that continued attendance at the society's screenings would damage the reputation of the films, such as The Vortex  and Blighty , that he made for them. 
 But the company was inconsistent enough to employ Ivor Montagu, a Film Society stalwart, to re-edit The Lodger . 
 It is easy enough now to mock the film industry's seeming paranoia about the Film Society screenings. 
 After all, what sort of threat was a group of film people who got together with interested artists, writers and sculptors on Sunday evenings to screen foreign films? 
 Shouldn't producers have welcomed the society's aspiration to fertilize British film ideas and draw new talent into the cinema? 
 Or were they really unnerved by its stated intention to improve &bquo;standards of taste and executive ability.'? 
 But what their reaction shows is just how little awareness there was among Britain's film executives of cinema's artistic potential, and how little discussion had gone on about what sort of cinema British producers should develop. 
 &bquo;We were in the business of giving the public what it seemed to want in entertainment,&equo; Balcon later recalled. 
 &bquo;We did not talk about art or social significance.&equo; 
 One might have expected the intense difficulties confronting British film producers to stimulate discussion; instead it seems to have narrowed their perspective. 
 Nevertheless, Balcon did take practical measures of his own to develop more technically sophisticated films, by setting up productions in German studios, and working with European technicians whose superiority to their British counterparts was recognized. 
 Although Balcon was not the first to make films in Germany, he was the first to do so on a regular basis. 
 And while there were crudely economic motives in, for example, sending Hitchcock to reconstruct English and Oriental settings in Italy and Germany for his first film, The Pleasure Garden  (1925), it did at least show that he was as aware as the Film Society's membership of the backwardness of British films. 
 Balcon could reasonably feel defensive about the sort of criticism of British cinema that began to appear from the Film Society milieu, particularly in the pages of Close Up , a journal founded in 1927. 
 These writers criticized the industry for being a second-rate imitation of Hollywood, but that was because they despised American cinema and the &bquo;box-office bogey&equo;, not because they appreciated the economic gap between the two industries. 
 They depicted British cinema as indifferent to art, lacking drive and sense of direction and, in their distaste for the commercial orientation of the system, failed to suggest any ways to reform it. 
 Pulling apart the British film industry was the only solution offered. 
 They proposed getting rid of the philistines found along Wardour Street, London's Film Row, wiping out the middle-class personnel who had been creeping into the director's chair, or introducing a bunch of amateurs into the business. 
 &bquo;Oh, it's a mess,&equo; remarked one desperate commentator. 
 &bquo;And yet one sincerely wishes them well, but there just doesn't seem anything to say. 
 But while the gap between the filmmakers and the critical culture could seem an unbridgeable chasm, there were people with feet in both camps who were discussing how to wrest British cinema away from its dual dependence on the stage and American models. 
 In a letter to the London Evening News  of the late 1920s, Hitchcock expresses his own sense of how Hollywood models could be redeployed in a British context: 
 The Americans have left us with very few stories to tell. 
 But there is no reason why we should not tell stories of English  boys who leave the village and make good in the city &mdash; why rural drama should not be found and filmed among the mountains of Wales and moors of Yorkshire. 
 Our history &mdash; national and imperial &mdash; provides a wonderful storehouse of film drama. 
 And Hitchcock's films do demonstrate that a British filmmaker could learn from Hollywood, but yet create distinctive national films, and without breaking with the commercial filmmaking culture as Close Up's  writers proposed. 
 A similar position was put by Anthony Asquith in his first feature film, Shooting Stars  (1928). 
 The son of the former British Prime Minister, Asquith combined an intellectual grasp of film with commercial aspirations (although he lacked Hitch's grasp of the popular idiom). 
 He had studied the latest Russian, German and French film theories, spent six months mixing with movie people in Hollywood, then gone on to train at British Instructional Pictures, a maker of successful non-fiction films which moved into drama production in the late 1920s. 
 Asquith's d&eacute;but feature is fascinating both because its setting in a bustling film studio gives some impression of what it was like to shoot a picture in Britain at the end of the silent era, and because of what it argues as the future for British films. 
 There are two films being shot side-by-side in the studio. 
 Both are Hollywood-style productions, one a soppy Western, the other a slapstick item featuring a Chaplin lookalike. 
 The actress playing in the Western abandons her cowboy lover for the comic after he promises to take her to Hollywood and put her name up in lights, but the scandal that follows wrecks her career. 
 The cowboy, by contrast, stays faithful to his British films, however limited their ambition, becomes a director and goes on to make serious pictures. 
 The message is twofold. 
 British cinema must grow up, but it can only do so by building on everything it has already created, even when that includes silly Hollywood ripoffs. 
 Filmmakers and critics were not the only ones worrying about the state of British filmmaking, nor was the film industry the only British enterprise losing out to American competition. 
 The popularity of Hollywood films made them the most obvious indicator of the general shift in world trade. 
 In holding British films responsible for their own failure, industrialists were encouraged by the willingness of US producers to assert that the aim of the American film industry was &bquo;to Americanize the world.&equo; 
 General concern about the parlous state of British film production was expressed throughout the 1920s. 
 A letter to The Times  of 1923, for example, drew attention to &bquo;the dangers arising from the Americanization of the British Empire from the excessive number of American motion pictures shown&equo;, but things came to a head in 1924. 
 Production had sunk so low that in November, Black November, not a single film went into production in any of the country's studios. 
 Public attention was galvanized by a publicity gambit from the American distributors of The Phantom of the Opera , who persuaded a brigade of British soldiers to escort the print from Southampton to London. 
 These indicators of the native film industry's weakness encouraged The Federation of British Industries to intensify its campaign to bring attention to the way in which the disappearance of British films from the world's screens impacted on &bquo;the prestige of the country as a whole, and thereby the prestige of British industry also&equo;. 
 Even the Prime Minister, Stanley Baldwin, got in on the act, speculating upon &bquo;the enormous power which the film is developing for propaganda purposes, and the danger to which we in this country and our Empire subject ourselves if we allow that method of propaganda to be entirely in the hands of foreign countries.&equo;  
 Cowboys in Cricklewood &mdash; the studio setting of Shooting Stars  (1928) 
 It shows how little the FBI really understood about film production that their proposals to improve the situation focused on increasing the quantity of production, rather than stimulating a few high-quality pictures that might promote British prestige abroad. 
 A National Film Studio, combining the small companies into one strong conglomerate, had been proposed, but this idea made no more headway than a proposal to negotiate a reciprocity deal with the Americans, whereby they would take a certain number of British films into national distribution in return for free access to British screens. 
 The notion that won through involved stopping the American companies' strong-arm booking tactics and reserving a space in the domestic market for British films by requiring that exhibitors and distributors handle a proportion of domestic product. 
 The measure would compel American distributors to back British film production, ensuring a rise in the number of British films. 
 What it wouldn't do was ensure good pictures, and Herbert Wilcox saw at once that such legislation would create an &bquo;awkward squad&equo; of British films which would immediately become the laughing stock of the world.&equo; 
 He argued, along with Balcon, Pearson and Woolf, that it would do nothing to achieve the FBI's objectives. 
 But a proposed clause in the new act to disallow for quota any film of low standard of production and entertainment value was dropped because of the difficulties involved in determining which films should be excluded. 
 The drafters of the legislation overlooked the imbalance between the British and American markets. 
 The US had 20,000 cinemas, the UK only 4,000; 80 million people a week went to the cinema in the US, against only 20 million in the UK. 
 The average budget for a British film was &pound;7&ndash;10,000, against &pound;100&ndash;120,000 in the US. 
 The 1927 Cinematograph Act imposed a distributors quota of 7.5 per cent, and an exhibitors quota of five per cent, both rising to 20 per cent, but it did nothing in itself to shift the economic balance in favour of British producers. 
 However, thanks partly to the arrival of the sound film, this small measure was to change the nature of the British film industry in ways that could hardly have been foreseen by the legislators, and enable it to &bquo;project England&equo; more effectively than it had ever done before. 
 Reaching England 
 The Cinematograph Act of 1927 put producers in a strong position for negotiations with financiers. 
 There was now a captive market for British films, and that market would expand steadily through the ten years the act was set to remain on the statute book. 
 The first beneficiaries of this new climate were two would-be moguls who seized the opportunity to considerably expand their existing film holdings. 
 &bquo;The City is certainly more inclined to look kindly on the film trade than before, and thus a considerable weight that has handicapped us in the past is removed&equo;, remarked John Maxwell, as he launched British International Pictures (BIP) as a public company with interests in production, exhibition and distribution. 
 Maxwell, a former solicitor from Glasgow, had moved into exhibition in 1912, then distribution in 1923. 
 In 1926 he built studios at Elstree and made his first tentative move into production with The Woman Tempted . 
 Encouraged by the new legislation, he sought to become a big player on the local production scene. 
 His main competitors were two merchant bankers, Isidore and Maurice Ostrer, who had acquired a stake in Gaumont-British in the 1920s. 
 The new legislation encouraged them into a buying spree that led to their picking up such distribution companies as Ideal and C. M. Woolf's W&amp;F Film Services, and sufficient cinema circuits to build a chain of 316 theatres. 
 As well as continuing production at Gaumont-British, the company took a stake in Balcon's Gainsborough company. 
 These two combines were strong enough to focus filmmakers' creative and entrepreneurial energies, but not so dominant that they crushed out other centres of initiative. 
 The fresh availability of finance also drew into the industry people with a less developed understanding of cinema or business matters than Maxwell or the Ostrers. 
 New companies were set up by public subscription, and there was a substantial increase in the number of films produced. 
 Studios were built and additional stages added on to old complexes. 
 But this was not, at first, a boom with roots, and many of these new operations were to be swept away when the arrival of sound led to an increase in the cost of production. 
 As its critics feared, the legislation quickly established an area of production where cheapness was the only important criterion, with film being treated as so many yards of celluloid filled with moving figures. 
 There were not many talented British filmmakers, and American distributors were not simply being awkward when they decided to do no more than fulfil the letter of the law by distributing films from far-off parts of the British Commonwealth that nobody wanted to see. 
 And Maxwell reinforced their argument by importing European directors and stars to make BIP's more ambitious films. 
 Piccadilly  (1929), for example, had foreigners in all the key positions: the German E. A. Dupont as director, Alfred J&uuml;nge as art director, Werner Brandes as lighting cameraman, as well as Olga Tschechova and Jean Bradin as the film's stars. 
 Soon, however, distributors were able to secure cheaply-made films from small studios set up to supply their needs, and some American companies began to make their own &bquo;quota quickies&equo;. 
 A production environment that sought to minimize expense was not especially stimulating to creativity, and some idea of the cynicism involved is evident from the instruction given to Adrian Brunel by the bosses at MGM that he couldn't make any improvements in the film he had made for them lest his cuts shorten the film below the act's definition of a full-length picture. 
 &bquo;All vaulting ideas of film as an art had to be abandoned,&equo; remarked George Pearson. 
 &bquo;Only as a capable and speedy craftsman could one survive in that feverish and restless environment.&equo; 
 Pearson made no fewer than eight quota films in one year at Julius Hagen's Twickenham Studios, where one small stage was occupied around the clock, and pictures that had been scripted in a fortnight were filmed in another two weeks. 
 From this industrious factory, and from others across London, came a never-ending flow of costume melodramas, musicals, detective stories and films in every other sort of genre. 
 The quota legislation is generally depicted as a disastrous blow to the British film industry, dragging down its reputation and perpetuating the sort of mediocrity that previously characterized the output of Stoll and Ideal Studios. 
 But whereas in the early 1920s, cheapie production had constituted almost the entirety of British filmmaking, in the 1930s there existed a more ambitious production sector running in parallel. 
 In this context, the low-budget production area, by providing continuous employment, usefully offered directors and technicians opportunities to develop craft skills and promote their potential. 
 The quantity of talented filmmakers coming through the quota mill was not substantial. 
 Nevertheless, it did provide a stepping stone for some significant figures. 
 The Hungarian &eacute;migr&eacute;  Alexander Korda gained a foothold in British production by making Service for Ladies  (1932, Reserved for Ladies  in US) and five other pictures for Paramount. 
 David Macdonald made a series of quota quickies before going on to a larger budget with the striking comedy-thriller This Man is News  (1938), and Michael Powell built a reputation as a director of energetic quota films before making his mainstream d&eacute;but with Edge of the World  (1937), about the depopulation of a remote island in the Shetlands. 
 Sadly, neither Pearson nor Brunel, the two most distinguished industry veterans working the quota seam, was able to use this production area as the springboard to a comeback. 
 The quota film also offered directors the chance to work outside box office constraints and experiment with the medium's possibilities, as Hitchcock did with Number 17  (1932), his offbeat haunted-house Gothic. 
 And, although many quota films were, inevitably, bland transpositions of stage plays, there was an area of quickie production which, by taking stories of murder, robbery and blackmail from the newspapers, prepared British cinema to deal with tougher issues than its obsession with middle-class theatre allowed. 
 Quota filmmaking also made the argument for narrative simplicity that sometimes escaped the more prolix mainstream filmmakers. 
 As a result, Brunel could argue that killing off the quickie at the end of the decade was a mistake since it was possible to make &bquo;really fine, unspectacular pictures&equo;, and &bquo;we were evolving a technique that showed what could be done when facing fearful odds.&equo; 
 The quota, in short, forced some  British filmmakers to be realistic about the economic constraints operating in British filmmaking, and to look to what could be achieved within them rather than simply hoping that film budgets could rise on some magic carpet to figures close to those of Hollywood pictures. 
 As significant as quota in changing the nature of British film production was the arrival of the sound film. 
 In some ways, by seeming to justify the adaptation of stageplays and musical comedies to the screen, sound perpetuated the worst aspects of British film production. 
 One can easily understand the ferocity with which the more creative British filmmakers positioned themselves against the new development. 
 It was for them that Paul Rotha spoke when he declared: &bquo;The dialogue film, at its best, can only be a poor substitute for the stage.&equo; 
 And filmmakers like Brunel, Asquith and Powell worried about the loss of camera mobility and editing flexibility inevitable with the early sound technology. 
 But if sound set back filmmaking style by several years, it offered a great boom for the British film industry. 
 Drawing on the verbal and musical skills of comedians and other performers who were established in theatre and the music hall, filmmakers were able to make up for their failure to develop indigenous styles of visual comedy, and to produce relatively cheap pictures that enjoyed genuine popularity. 
 Their success in this area so changed the way British films were perceived that, in 1932, a year when a large number of exhibitors substantially over-filled their quota, the American showbiz journal Variety  reported on &bquo;the complete stranglehold the home-made pictures had established at the local box office.&equo; 
 Herbert Wilcox was among the first to realize the opportunities sound created for British filmmakers. 
 He had been quick to fit out his Imperial Studios with the necessary equipment, and produced Splinters  (1929) as his first sound film. 
 The script, about a soldier taken out of the trenches not, as he fears, to be shot, but to organize an army concert party, is just a rudimentary framework within which to present a number of variety turns. 
 If it is difficult now to concur with the Bioscope  reviewer's judgement that the film &bquo;surpasses in technical achievement anything of its kind ever made in Britain, and at times soars to heights of directorial brilliance&equo;, it's still possible to understand how an audience that had been accustomed only to silent films might warm to the various acts on display. 
 More easily comprehensible is the enormous success Wilcox enjoyed in the following year with Rookery Nook  (1930), the first of the Ben Travers farces he brought to the screen. 
 However token the attempts to open the play out from its Tudor house setting with shots of sea waves, a train coming into a station and a village street, the result is still entertaining. 
 The most popular films of the 1930s were those built around Britain's first superstars. 
 Among the many comic performers Balcon developed for Gaumont-British, such performers as the histrionic Cicely Courtneidge and the dapper, completely unexportable, Jack Hulbert, none matched the success of musical performer Jessie Matthews. 
 She danced with zest, sang sweetly and had a fine sense of comic timing. 
 And her posh accent was sufficiently artificial to be laughed at, where a more natural intonation would have alienated audiences. 
 She first made an impression in an adaptation of J. B. Priestley's rambling tale about a group of travelling performers, The Good Companions  (1933), and followed that with Friday the Thirteenth  (1933), which recounts the activities of a group of characters immediately before the crash of the bus in which they are riding. 
 Her major musical films included Evergreen  (1934), an untidy but profitable adaptation of a West End stage success; First a Girl  (1935), in which Matthews amusingly impersonates a female impersonator in a British version of the German Viktor und Viktoria , and the fascinating It's Love Again  (1936), in which Matthews is a struggling dancer who takes on the character of a fictional celebrity dreamed up by two desperate newspaper men. 
 The films are always set against glamorous backgrounds, with Matthews offering herself for audience identification as the outsider trying to enter a world that seeks to exclude her. 
 By contrast, the films made to exploit the vitality, comic talent and phenomenal singing voice of Grace Fields are at their best when set not against a showbusiness background, but in the midst of depressed working-class communities where Fields stands as a beacon of cheerfulness and hope. 
 If Looking on the Bright Side  (1932) is sometimes spoilt by the fact that the director, Basil Dean, seems to be under the impression he is making a sophisticated Hollywood musical, the scenes in the tenement block where Fields and her songwriter lover first meet are genuinely stirring. 
 And there is passion as well as poetry in Sing as We Go  (1934), one of the few films of the 1930s to make any reference to unemployment. 
 Framed by the story of the closure of Greybeck Mills, and its reopening, the centre of the film is a tour of popular culture articulating the message, &bquo;If we can't spin, we can still sing.&equo; 
 In her spirited struggle to survive in Blackpool, Fields becomes a waitress, a song plugger, a potential beauty contestant and a human spider in a sideshow. 
 The naturalness and energy in Fields' performances made these films popular with both middle-class and working-class audiences.  
 Jessie Matthews signs pictures for her fans 
 Gracie Fields was the mainstay of the production programme at Basil Dean's Associated Talking Pictures (ATP), where, towards the end of the decade, Dean developed another star in George Formby. 
 He's the smiling innocent who so trusts the sharks he meets in his various roles &mdash; newspaper reporter, army recruit, spy, racing bike rider or whatever &mdash; that he continually lands himself in trouble, forcing him back on reserves of charm, and his skill with a ukulele, to secure his escape. 
 Formby's films, with their straightforward plots and repressed naughtiness, were first-class family entertainment, making him the top box-office attraction of the late 1930s. 
 The regular production of films featuring these performers gave their production companies some sort of economic foundation to build on, as well as allowing producers like Balcon and Dean a glimpse of what a popular British cinema might achieve. 
 Dean was too much of a cultural snob to get the message, but Balcon sought to emulate the success of these pictures in his more serious, dramatic movies. 
 However, while it was comparatively easy to cobble together a story around a popular star, the British industry was not yet well organized when it came to finding a steady output of ideas for dramatic features and developing them into workable scripts. 
 The lack of competent screenwriters, and of directors with strong creative drives clearly limited executives' freedom of movement. 
 &bquo;Financiers and impresarios you can buy two a penny,&equo; the documentarist John Grierson lamented in 1931. 
 &bquo;Directors who have something to say and the power to say it, you can only close your fingers and wish for.&equo; 
 As head of production for Gainsborough Pictures and, from 1932, also for Gaumont-British, Michael Balcon had to make over 20 pictures a year. 
 In order to wean the company away from a reliance on theatre plays, he set up a major script department which drew on the talents of writers like Frank Launder, Sidney Gilliatt, Val Guest and Michael Pertwee, as well as occasionally giving jobs to young writers like Christopher Isherwood. 
 The result of this openness to new ideas began to pay off when films like the Gilliatt-scripted Rome Express  (1933), a streamlined comedy thriller, became hits at the box office. 
 The working principle of Balcon's life was that a &bquo;film producer is only as good as the sum total of the colleagues with whom he works&equo;, and he understood better than anyone else at the time how to turn the studio into a source of creative energy. 
 In order to ensure that every department at the studio was of the best, he set up training schemes for new entrants to the industry. 
 He also imported cameramen, make-up staff and editors from Europe and America, so that those working at the studio could learn the more advanced techniques. 
 Most important of all, he inspired the people who worked for him with a vision of what they were doing. 
 Just as the Hollywood moguls built an, albeit mythic, vision of the American dream, so Balcon, from a Jewish immigrant family, felt that films should &bquo;express England&equo;. 
 This conviction brought forth the rebuke from Michael Powell that Balcon was &bquo;suburban&equo;, but it was the sense of purpose Balcon gave to his employees that distinguished Gaumont-British from other local studios. 
 This interest in national subjects could have led to cosiness as it tended to during Balcon's time at Ealing Studios, but at this period he was under pressure from the Ostrer Brothers to maintain a diversity in his output and aim for the international market. 
 Powell unfairly argued that Balcon had &bquo;lost his soul&equo; in thus producing a programme of films, but the range of his output was a strength. 
 His only major mistake lay in the way he responded to the demand for international films. 
 Basil Dean called ATP the Studio with the Team Spirit, and its qualities as a place to work are suggested by the fact that such distinguished directors as Carol Reed, Thorold Dickinson and Basil Dearden emerged from Dean's tutelage. 
 Dean's weakness was his belief in the stage as the ideal source of film material, as a result of which the only films from ATP that secured broad popular appeal were those featuring Gracie Fields and George Formby. 
 Dean saw the theatre as the inherently superior form, setting up his company initially &bquo;to combine the current influence of the film studios with the wealth of past achievement of the theatre&equo;. 
 One of his early projects was a film version of John Galsworthy's Escape  (1930), which he proposed to the writer as a way to enable theatre to &bquo;regain influence&equo; over the screen. 
 The film was a flop but Dean continued to produce, as Dickinson put it, what were essentially &bquo;canned plays&equo;. 
 Something of the difference between working for Dean or Balcon and for John Maxwell can be gleaned from the fact that denizens of the latter referred to BIP's script department as the Borstal. 
 The company's head of production, Walter Mycroft, had been a founding member of the Film Society, but he doesn't seem to have had very much interest in nurturing talent. 
 There were competent individuals in the script department, just as there were good cameramen working on the studio floor, but the environment didn't encourage any of these individuals to stretch their creative powers. 
 &bquo;The story department of BIP fulfilled my worst fears,&equo; remarked Michael Powell. 
 &bquo;It was a Saragossa Sea of hopeful scriptwriters, an Isle of Lost Scripts.&equo; 
 While Balcon was encouraging his writers to come up with original stories, and steadily reducing the company's reliance on the theatre, BIP remained largely stagebound. 
 The company not only had no interest in encouraging innovation, but its fear of creative daring amounted sometimes to paranoia. 
 One Borstal inmate, Rodney Ackland, was expelled from the company when it was discovered that he had written a highbrow play while employed as a BIP screenwriter. 
 And the experiments with sound that Hitchcock carried out in films such as Blackmail  (1929) and Murder  (1931), as well as the narrative innovations of Rich and Strange  (1932, East of Shanghai  in US), seem to have irritated Maxwell even more than similar developments did C. M. Woolf. 
 Ackland records Hitchcock's account of how BIP treated its directors: 
 At the slightest sign of originality in approach or technique a director might well be regarded as a menace and any departure from the hoary formula adhered to by the executives could be considered highly presumptuous. 
 Test for sound &mdash; Andy Ondra with Hitchcock on the set of Blackmail  (1929) 
 The lack of ambition in the output of slapstick comedies, innocuous romances and bland dramas from BIP demonstrated Maxwell's willingness to accept the economic constraints of British film production, while doing little to encourage new approaches to low-budget filmmaking. 
 He had a good chain of cinemas, as well as a strong network of contacts in Central Europe. 
 Knowing how rauch he could expect to earn on a regular basis from each market, he tailored his budgets accordingly. 
 With quality technicians creamed off from other studios, he could make cheap films so that they looked good and brought in a respectable profit. 
 Since he had no arabition to sell his films in the US, there was no reason why he should be more adventurous. 
 A Board of Trade Memo in 1940 was to remark on Maxwell's notoriety for &bquo;pursuing a policy with which the rest of the industry is at variance, but bitter personal experience lay behind his low-level ambition. 
 In 1928 he had found, when attempting to sell BIP films to the US, that the doors were &bquo;barred in the faces of UK producers&equo;, and the excitement that Blackmail  caused at home was not matched in the US. 
 In other companies, however, as the production industry expanded and the films improved, it was natural that filmmakers would begin to think seriously about aiming for a share of the US market. 
 After all, it was one of the aims of the quota legislation to foster an industry that could promote Britain just as American films promoted America and, with only ten British films a year grossing &pound;100,000 at the local box office, the financiers backing British film companies began to push for expansion. 
 Encouraging them were the new links between British and American film companies that grew out of the quota legislation. 
 While Warner Brothers and Twentieth Century-Fox had set up their own production companies to produce British pictures, other US distributors relied on local suppliers. 
 Paramount, for example, as well as providing Korda with the money he needed for his first English films, made a deal with Wilcox's British and Dominions company to supply them with 12 pictures annually on budgets of &pound;30,000 apiece. 
 And Dean set up ATP with backing from RKO, although he was to be rapidly disappointed in his expectation that the company would provide him both with technical expertise and favourable distribution in the US. 
 Not only was the company interested exclusively in cheap pictures for the local market, but also Dean had to go through the ignominious process of securing cast approval on his pictures from Solly Newman, the head of the company's UK subsidiary, whom he regarded as both &bquo;illiterate&equo; and &bquo;over-shrewd where money was concerned.&equo; 
 The relationship between American distributors and British producers was an unequal one, but when British studios started to make films that went down well in America, executives became optimistic that they could turn the new relationships formed with US companies in their favour, and brushed aside Maxwell's repeated warnings that &bquo;as their films were produced in a manner most acceptable to their own people, there was no reason why they should go outside for pictures.&equo; 
 The first internationally successful British sound film was Rome Express  from Gaumont-British, but its box-office performance was soon eclipsed by that of The Private Life of Henry VIII  (1933), Alexander Korda's calculated attempt on the international market. 
 With a story sufficiently English to appease nationalist sentiment and Britain's only international star, Charles Laughton, in the central role, the picture deployed every lesson Korda had learned from his sojourns in Europe and Hollywood about pleasing an audience. 
 The film was fast, funny, naughty and irreverent. 
 It was a masterpiece of international cinema which brought Korda all the financial backing he could need and a dream deal with United Artists that led eventually to a partnership in the American company. 
 The problem for British producers seeking to emulate Korda's achievement was to define what an international British film might be. 
 Wilcox, always one to strike while the iron was hot, signed a deal of his own with United Artists, then remade his silent film, Nell Gwynn , presumably thinking its mix of history and sexiness made it sufficiently like Korda's hit to clean up. 
 But it was a flop, and Wilcox moved on from US to make successive deals with Universal and RKO. 
 Eventually he concluded that history without salaciousness was the answer, making Victoria the Great  (1937) and its followup, Sixty Glorious Years  (1938, US title Queen of Destiny ) as stately pageants, more solemn than exciting. 
 Graham Greene sarcastically remarked of the latter that &bquo;Both the director and the star seem to labour under the impression that they are producing something important&equo;, and the film's success was enough to assure Wilcox that Hungarian naughtiness should give way to solemn patriotism. 
 Despite his own patriotic convictions, Balcon initially avoided national subjects in pursuit of his new-found belief that &bquo;films had to be less and less parochial and more and more international in appeal.&equo; 
 Made on exceptional budgets of around &pound;100,000 after Gaumont-British had arranged distribution through Fox, neither Jew S&uuml;ss  (1934, Power  in US) nor The Tunnel  (1936, Transatlantic Tunnel  in US) had much to do with Britain. 
 Jew S&uuml;ss  featured Conrad Veidt as an ambitious aristocrat at a German court, whose intrigues lead to his being put on trial under an old law forbidding sexual relations between Jews and Gentiles, and the film was made because of its relevance to the contemporary situation in Germany. 
 The Tunnel  was the British version of a film that had already been made in France and Germany, about a crazed engineer who sacrifices his family in order to complete the construction of a link between Britain and America. 
 Both are spectacular, well-scripted pictures, but neither has the sort of commercial edge that would justify the high financial expectations their investors had of them. 
 These were films that had been grafted onto the Gaumont-British production programme, rather than emerging out of the script department as projects with potential that called for higher expenditure. 
 Films made in such a way were unlikely to be breakout hits.  
 the big movie &mdash; the execution scene of Jew S&uuml;ss  (1934), filmed at the Gaumont-British studio 
 The clash between Balcon's nationalism and the Ostrers' requirement that he pursue international popularity led to the signs of strain that are evident in much of the Gaumont-British output, and it is easy to understand why Balcon became so disillusioned with the idea of international production. 
 Cicely Courtneidge was put into a soldier's costume and sent off to war in pursuit of her simple-minded husband in the clumsy Me and Marlborough  (1935). 
 Raoul Walsh was brought over from the US to direct O.H.M.S . 
 (1937, You're in the Army Now  in US), the improbable tale of an American hoodlum who takes on the identity of a murdered gambling companion and finds himself in the British Army, where he slowly comes to understand the habits of self-effacing Englishmen. 
 It was perhaps the heightened awareness, evident in this film, of what distinguished the Americans from the British that produced such a weird send-up of the archetypal Englishman in the company's popular adaptation of Rider Haggard's King Solomon's Mines  (1937). 
 &bquo;So unlike the home life of our dear Queen,&equo; the character played by Roland Young comments in the presence of some wild African dancers. 
 His sang-froid  comes so naturally that, when death seems imminent, he remarks: &bquo;It seems too bad that just when we get to where there's a fortune in diamonds, the mountain should decide to sit down on it.&equo; 
 But the quest for patriotism with adventure could also lead to an adaptation of C. S. Forester's true-Brit Forever England  (1935), in which a lone sailor keeps a German ship occupied until it can be sunk by a British destroyer, and dies a hero's death in the process. 
 The quest for American success sometimes made Balcon's production programme an uneasy mix of the oppressively patriotic, the blandly spectacular and the uncomfortable hybrid. 
 But it also contained films by Hitchcock dealing with British stories that avoided the sort of grandiosity which afflicted so many of the pictures pitched at the US market, and had as much wit as The Private Life of Henry VIII . 
 Recognizing that audiences could never identify with nobs, Hitchcock's films showed ordinary people going through extraordinary experiences: &bquo;The upper classes,&equo; he remarked, &bquo;are too &bquo;bottled up&equo; to be of any use as colourful screen material, too stiffened with breeding to relax into the natural easiness and normality required by the screen.&equo; 
 But the characters played by Leslie Banks in The Man Who Knew Too Much  (1934), or Robert Donat in The 39 Steps  (1935), are archetypically English in their capacity to muddle through, triumphing over the dark forces ranged against them by their flexibility of mind. 
 With his powers of observation, his smooth, fast-moving narratives and his ability to make characters live on the screen, Hitchcock set himself apart from the rest of British cinema.  
 Madelene Carroll and Robert Donat escape in handcuffs under Hitchcock's gaze &mdash; a scene from The 39 Steps  (1935) 
 Comic splendour. 
 Cicely Courtneidge on parade in Me and Marlborough  (1935) 
 Despite Hitchcock's example, Korda argued that &bquo;stories that dig too deep into national roots start with a handicap.&equo; 
 He was essentially a European filmmaker, and he was drawn to pictures that featured lavish costumes and spectacular sets. 
 His market was the world, and he wasn't particularly concerned to toady either to the British or the Americans. 
 He may have made his name with a story from British history, but that was simply calculated opportunism as he showed by following with similar, though less amusing and successful, treatments of the lives of Catherine the Great  (1934) and Rembrandt  (1936). 
 He made films like Sanders of the River  (1935) and The Four Feathers  (1939), featuring courageous British aristocrats going off to fight for the British empire, not out of a sentimental admiration for those times, but because the Empire provided good stories, as Hollywood also found at the time. 
 And while the plot of The Ghost Goes West  (1935), about an American millionaire who buys a ghost-inhabited castle from an impoverished Scottish laird, might suggest an uncomfortable balancing act between the demands of the two national audiences, the appointment of a Frenchman, Ren&eacute; Clair, to direct, suggests that Korda was simply impressed by the story. 
 While Korda's freedom from nationalist hangups may be refreshing, too many of the films that came out of his Denham Studios lacked either the narrative drive of The Four Feathers  or the wit of The Ghost Goes West . 
 No amount of pouting by Marlene Dietrich or posturing by Robert Donat could reveal why anyone thought the audience would want to watch the dull account of the Russian Revolution offered in Knight Without Armour  (1937). 
 And, despite Korda's avowed belief in &bquo;lightness&equo;, little effort seems to have been made to mute the pompous misanthropy evident in the company's two H. G. Wells adaptations. 
 The Man Who Could Work Miracles  (1936) amusingly shows a simple bank clerk trying to grasp the potential of the miracle-working powers he has been given, but frames this story within a portentous divine commentary on &bquo;that little planet under the sun&equo;, occupied by &bquo;such silly little creatures, swarming and crawling.&equo; 
 And although Things to Come  (1936) offers a spectacular account of the horrors of mechanized warfare, no one was thinking of the native audience when putting into the mouth of Raymond Massey a description of Britain as &bquo;that last dismal vestige of ancient predatory soldiery, the last would-be conquerors.&equo; 
 Much more commercial calculation was required to justify the cost of these pictures: The Man Who Worked Miracles  came in at &pound;133,000; Things to Come  at &pound;241,000. 
 Since the American slump that created a space for Henry VIII  and some of Korda's succeeding films quickly passed, subsequent pictures had to be not just good, but exceptional, if they were to break through the resistance or American audiences to foreign films. 
 But neither Korda nor his regular scriptwriter, Lajos Biro, had the will to hone scripts for international consumption. 
 Graham Greene fairly remarked of the amorphous string of sequences that made up Rembrandt  that &bquo;no amount of money spent on expensive sets, on careful photography, will atone for the lack of a storyline, the continuity and drive of a well-constructed plot.&equo; 
 And Robert Donat cannot have been the only one who complained to Korda about a &bquo;silly and unproductive attitude towards scripts&equo;, which he credited as being at &bquo;the root of the failure of so many British films.&equo; 
 Korda's shirty reply suggested he wasn't willing to listen to such a criticism from an expensive star. 
 Certainly that was Donat's experience, writing from the set of Perfect Strangers  (1945): &bquo;No script to go on &mdash; just a mass of blarney from A. K. Our first complete script arrived five days ago &mdash; we have been filming for sixteen weeks! 
 Isn't it wicked.&equo;  
 Korda's extravagance &mdash; Things to come  (1936) filmed on the backlot at Denham 
 Korda enjoyed the attentions that his relatively exotic origins attracted from the British press. 
 Now that he owned his own studio by the banks of the River Colne he could play the mogul to the technicians, artists and directors he had gathered there. 
 But never a great organizer, he was bad at deputizing authority to others. 
 &bquo;His weakness,&equo; the critic C. A. Lejeune perceptively remarked, &bquo;is that he plays a lone hand. 
 His final authority is unshared and undeputed.&equo; 
 The result was unproductive chaos. 
 Rights were acquired in literary properties that would never be filmed. 
 Pictures were started, had money thrown at them, and then put to one side. 
 There was no process for acclimatizing the many foreigners who came to the studios to a different language and culture. 
 Writers and technicians were put on contract, then given nothing to do. 
 And nothing much was done to develop the careers of talented contract artists like Laurence Olivier, Vivien Leigh and Valerie Hobson at Denham. 
 The press adored Korda, because he represented &bquo;quality and the big time&equo;, but the extravagance was a matter of concern to his backers, the Prudential Assurance Company. 
 In 1938 they moved in to take control of Denham Studios. 
 It was not simply that London Films had registered a loss of &pound;330,000 for the fiscal year 1936. 
 The Prudential, like all other financial institutions involved in films, had been put in a panic by revelations about the activities of Max Schach, one of several central Europeans renting space from Korda. 
 During the boom sparked by the success of Henry VIII , banks, insurance companies and everyone else with money to lend had been pouring money into films. 
 Almost 100 new companies had been formed, and Schach had been able to secure over a million pounds in bank guarantees to finance not only such expensive disasters as Dreaming Lips, Love from a Stranger  and The Marriage of Gorbal , but even films that were never made. 
 Schach's reckless overspending, lousy scripts, and ineffective financial management made Korda appear a model of good filmmaking. 
 That didn't, however, help him when dealing with the Pru. 
 Everywhere the signs were that the British film industry was overheating. 
 Production rose from 153 films in 1932 to 212 in 1936, and the returns were insufficient to justify such expansion. 
 The bid to crack the American market hadn't worked, as Isidore Ostrer explained, due to &bquo;the fact that we are not accorded playing time in the most important situations, these being almost exclusively controlled by American producing interests.&equo; 
 British filmmakers were in trouble, and even Maxwell was only able to sustain profitability by cutting back production. 
 As early as 1935 Herbert Wilcox had been forced to resign from his British and Dominions company following the failure of his bid for US success. 
 Subsequently, both Dean and Balcon had trouble with their respective boards. 
 ATP could always come up with a few money-spinners in its annual output, but the lavish location and studio work on Whom the Gods Love , Dean's film on the life of Mozart, irritated board chairman Sir Stephen Courtauld, who began to argue that Dean was doing too much stage work, and had alienated George Formby. 
 After the company had declared a loss of &pound;96,678 for the year ending June 1937, Dean was, in his own words, &bquo;asked to walk the plank&equo;. 
 He was to retire altogether from films, declaring himself &bquo;tired of knocking my head against a brick wall.&equo; 
 Although Gaumont-British also declared a loss in 1937, of &pound;98,000, Balcon's departure from the company was precipitated by the prospect of Maxwell, a man whose production philosophy he abhorred, taking a stake in the company, and a general sense that he wasn't going to be able to continue the same broad-based production policy as before. 
 Maxwell never did join G-B, but Balcon's departure was followed by the closure of the company's larger Shepherd's Bush Studio. 
 Production was henceforth to be concentrated on a steady output of &bquo;marketable product&equo;, which meant basically low-budget comedies from the likes of Will Hay and the Crazy Gang. 
 Balcon moved, with several of the scriptwriters and directors he had brought up through Gaumont-British, to the American company, MGM. 
 He anticipated new openings for Anglo-American coproduction, in which British talent could be deployed with American actors on films financed by the Americans and given proper distribution in the US. 
 MGM had been responsible for some of the worst quota quickie outrages, and its new willingness to finance British-based production was the result of legislative changes which brought American companies deeper into British film production. 
 When the 1927 Cinematograph Act came up for review, there was agreement that the quota had stimulated domestic production and should be renewed, but that the quickie had to go. 
 Only Maxwell fought a rearguard action to defeat a measure imposing a minimum (though not very onerous, &pound;7,500) cost for quota-registered films, and allowing more expensive films to be registered for double or triple quota. 
 The latter measure made it worthwhile for the Americans to try and do what the British had failed at, making British films which would go down well in America. 
 Warner Brothers responded by announcing it would bring Hollywood stars to Teddington Studios. 
 Fox set up New World Pictures to make British films, and Columbia Pictures engaged Irving Asher, who had been making quickies for Warners, to initiate a production programme that led to such interesting pictures as The Spy in Black  (1938, U-Boat 29  in US) and Q Planes  (1939, Clouds Over Europe  in US), both of which tapped into contemporary anxieties about the prospect of war. 
 It was MGM that seemed to take the whole business most seriously. 
 Nevertheless, Balcon seriously overestimated the confidence of the company's boss, Louis B. Mayer, in British talent and his new head of production. 
 While Mayer was willing to finance films from Gainsborough if they brought him Hitchcock's The Lady Vanishes  (1938), and would pay &pound;150,000 for six films from Robert Donat, that didn't amount to a love affair with the British film industry. 
 Balcon could expostulate all he liked about the depth of British talent but, for Mayer, the film industry remained in Hollywood. 
 Thus the script that Sidney Gilliatt, among others, had worked on, for A Yank at Oxford  (1937) was taken back to Hollywood and then passed around to the resident heavyweights, including Ben Hecht, who wouldn't touch it, Herman Mankiewicz and Scott Fitzgerald. 
 In other areas too, Balcon was finding that Mayer's promise of autonomy was worthless. 
 &bquo;I had to be in charge,&equo; he later said, &bquo;when it came to the actual making of the films. 
 It was, for me, the only way to work.&equo; 
 Unsurprisingly, he left after completing only the one film, and his position was taken over by his erstwhile colleague, Victor Saville. 
 Ironically, A Yank at Oxford  is the least British of the three films produced by MGM in Britain. 
 The other two were The Citadel  (1938), from A. J. Cronin's novel about a once-idealistic doctor who becomes a cynical practitioner to the upper classes until the death of his friend on the operating table leads to a revival of his old principles, and Goodbye Mr Chips  (1939), a hymn to the glories of the English public school. 
 Both films starred Donat; neither had a British director. 
 Some of the same thinking that led Balcon to MGM persuaded Hitchcock, in 1939, to sign a deal with David O. Selznick and emigrate to Hollywood. 
 He wanted the best stars, effective US distribution and adequate finance, and no longer felt the British industry could deliver his requirements. 
 He did not immediately contemplate any drastic change in his filmmaking aesthetic, since his first Hollywood picture, Rebecca  (1940), was based on a British book and used British actors, and it was some time before he made a completely American picture. 
 Balcon took Hitchcock's departure hard, as well as that of another prot&eacute;g&eacute;, Robert Stevenson, feeling it reduced the chances of realizing his conviction that &bquo;London could and should be the capital of the film world.&equo; 
 The failure of British cinema's first big drive on the international market-place provoked some serious reflection about why British films had only limited offshore appeal. 
 More sensitive than their counterparts at the beginning of the decade had been to the technical qualities of Hollywood films, the critics of the time constantly drew attention to the gap between the aspirations and the achievements of British films. 
 They were not always fair in their criticism: few today would agree with the New Statesman  reviewer who wrote of The Lady Vanishes  that &bquo;the English should leave amorous wisecracking to the nation which invented and alone understands that art.&equo; 
 But Dilys Powell could reasonably complain of Jamaica Inn  (1939) that there was &bquo;hardly any suspense, hardly any of the building up to a climax which makes the dullest American film tolerable&equo;, and enthuse about Carol Reed's A Girl Must Live  (1939), saying it showed how the British could make &bquo;a comedy which has the speed and glitter and impudence of the best American comedies.&equo; 
 Much the same point was made by the Kine Weekly  reviewer, who commented that the film's dialogue coupled &bquo;wit and wholesome vulgarity with a sureness of touch that, until now, has been the irresistible prerogative of the Americans.&equo; 
 This sensitivity to American qualities was coupled with a new willingness to accept that commerce and art had to go hand in hand. 
 &bquo;And it is wrong,&equo; remarked Graham Greene on Goodbye Mr Chips , &bquo;to despise popularity in the cinema &mdash; popularity there is a value , as it isn't in a book: films have got to appeal to a large undiscriminating public: a film with a severely limited appeal must be, to that extent, a bad film.&equo; 
 Critics also drew attention to the failure of British films to exploit the potential of British life. 
 Greene remarked on how seldom the nation's directors used the camera &bquo;to establish a scene, a way of life, with which he and his audience are familiar.&equo; 
 And John Grierson persistently praised Hitchcock for putting ordinary people on to the screen, while attacking Asquith for making films that reflected &bquo;a leisure-class England which has lost contact with fundamentals, with the toiling earth and the men who go with it.&equo; 
 As the cinema of froth, of romantic never-never-lands where poor girls fell in love with handsome officers, was now seen to have failed, filmmakers were increasingly willing to listen to Grierson's expostulation: &bquo;The damned thing has no roots, and what is the use of saying otherwise.&equo; 
 Throughout the decade, Grierson had been sponsoring young filmmakers to go out and record the lives of ordinary working people. 
 The result in films like Shipyard  (1934/5), an impressionistic study of the life of a shipbuilding town, or Night Mail  (1936), a poetic record of the journey of the Postal Special from London to Glasgow, were films that revealed how much was being missed by the filmmakers who created fabulous fictions behind the walls of the studio &mdash; what Grierson described as &bquo;the cinema's capacity for getting around, for observing and selecting from life itself.&equo; 
 At a time when the feature industry was undergoing a re-examination and the documentary movement was split between filmmakers who felt that they should reach out to a cinema audience, and those like Grierson himself who preferred to exhibit films outside the theatre (e.g. town halls, schools, etc.), the possibility was open for some sort of rapprochement between the documentary and the fiction film. 
 Where previous discussions about the Britishness of British films had been coloured by official concerns about national status, and cinema's role in boosting American economic might, filmmakers increasingly focused on the possibility that good stories might be British stories. 
 &bquo;I am sure,&equo; said Balcon, &bquo;we can get into the American market, but it will be with films of genuine British character. 
 We shall become international by being national.&equo; 
 This position was not only the culmination of ideas that had been knocking around in Balcon's mind for the past six years or so, it was also a declaration of a new confidence in the possibility of British cinema, and a final casting off of the inferiority complex that had impaired British filmmakers since 1918. 
 The fact that British films of the early 1930s don't reflect pressing economic and social realities is sometimes blamed on the censorship system. 
 Jeffrey Richards, for example, claims the result of the strictures imposed by the British Board of Film Censors (BBFC) was &bquo;that the British screen in the 1930s was dominated by innocuous musicals, comedies and detective stories.&equo; 
 The argument is an easy one to assemble. 
 The BBFC aimed to ensure that British films were as bloodless as possible, contained no criticism of any foreign power and no attack on any established British institution such as the clergy or the judiciary, avoided all political, religious and social controversy, and did nothing that would risk causing offence or inflaming public opinion. 
 Also, the process of pre-censorship by what Thorold Dickinson called &bquo;ex-colonels and maiden aunts in long flowered frocks&equo; made filmmakers complicit with the censors in keeping everything a touch daring, challenging or controversial from the screen. 
 Lord Tyrrell, the former diplomat, who became BBFC President in 1935, notoriously declared that &bquo;we may take pride in observing that there is not a single film showing in London today which deals with any of the burning questions of the day.&equo; 
 But the argument is too neat, and dependent on the assumption of a desire on the part of filmmakers to express themselves about contemporary realities that was being repressed by the censorship system. 
 There is little evidence of the existence of that urge in the early part of the decade. 
 Balcon, for one, was not aware of any frustration on the part of his filmmakers, unless he was dishonest when remarking in his autobiography, &bquo;It is puzzling to me in retrospect that none of my films&hellip; in any way reflected the despair of the times in which we were living.&equo; 
 Given that there is little sign in early 1930s films of political comment disguised as fantasy or allegory, it is reasonable to assign limitations of these pictures more to filmmakers' sensibilities than censors' rules. 
 It is only around 1935, shortly after Lord Tyrrell's appointment, that filmmakers became actively conscious of censorship as a real restriction on their freedom of expression. 
 Victor Saville joined together with the story editor of Gaumont-British and worked out that filmmakers who took all the BBFC's rules seriously wouldn't be able to make Cinderella . 
 In 1936, outrage was expressed when two submissions to the BBFC to film Walter Greenwood's bestseller, Love on the Dole , were turned down. 
 The following year Graham Greene, having struggled to write a script from Galsworthy's Twenty-One Days  &mdash; about a murderer who killed himself and an innocent man who was hanged for the suicide's crime &mdash; within BBFC rules that forbade the representation of either suicide or a failure of British justice, joined with J. B. Priestley, Bernard Shaw and H. G. Wells in speaking out against the censorship system. 
 It was perhaps the argument that this imposition of middle-class morality was holding back the British cinema which led to the matter becoming an issue of public concern. 
 Following a series of attacks on the BBFC in the House of Commons during 1938, Lord Tyrrell was persuaded to relax his stance. 
 Thanks to the changing critical climate, the new ideas circulating among filmmakers and the relaxation of the censorship rules, the British films made at the end of the 1930s were much tougher and more emotionally charged, than anything that had gone before. 
 &bquo;How the financial crisis has improved English films!&equo; remarked Graham Greene in 1939, but the process had started earlier. 
 Brief Ecstasy  (1937), for example, is a powerful drama centring on a woman who has married her professor and abandoned work for a life &bquo;sitting all day knitting jumpers for my husband&equo;, who is then thrown into a whirlpool of desire when her one-time lover arrives at the marital home. 
 The following year Arthur Woods directed They Drive by Night  (1938), which makes evocative use of such ordinary English surroundings as a dance palace and the roadside caf&eacute;s along the Great North Road for the story of an ex-convict hunted for a murder he didn't commit, who comes back to London to hunt down the real killer, a weirdo with books like Sex in Relation to Society  and The Thrill of Evil  in his briefcase. 
 In On the Night of the Fire  (1939, The Fugitive  in US), Ralph Richardson plays a small-town barber whose desire to be shot of a miserable life, &bquo;earning a few quid a week and no hope of making anything more&equo; leads him first to an act of casual theft, then murder. 
 After accidentally bringing about the death of his wife and child, he sets up his own suicide. 
 It was of films like these that the exhibitor Sidney Bernstein may have been speaking when he said: 
 The public has always wanted good British films, not the million-pound &bquo;epics, which so often bore them, but the good, honest, unpretentious stories in which we have shown such promise &mdash; the records of everyday life. 
 Low-life thriller &mdash; actor Emlyn Williams with director Arthur Woods during filming of They Drive by Night  (1938) 
 &bquo;Real people &mdash; Real problems &mdash; a human document&equo; declared the poster for There Ain't No Justice  (1939), about a boxer who walks out on the crooked world of the professional fighter. 
 The same director, Pen Tennyson, also made The Proud Valley  (1939) which, with Carol Reed's The Stars Look Down  (1939), exploited the BBFC's new leniency towards stories with an industrial setting. 
 Both show life in a mining town with some degree of realism and Reed's picture, about a community in which the miners are browbeaten into working a coal seam which the proprietor knows to be dangerous, links itself to the documentarist sensibility with an opening voiceover referring to those &bquo;simple working people who take heroism for granted as part of their daily lives&equo;, and a concluding epilogue that calls for the world to be &bquo;purged of its old greeds.&equo; 
 Despite its distracting romantic plot, this was campaigning cinema which put a case for the nationalization of the mines as strong as the argument presented in The Citadel  for a National Health Service. 
 Filmmakers were attempting to link in to contemporary realities. 
 WAR CLOUDS OVER EUROPE read the banner headlines at the opening of Reed's earlier film, Bank Holiday  (1938), a picture whose setting suggests escapism but whose narrative argues for the need to face up to the dark side of life in order to find meaningful happiness. 
 Margaret Lockwood plays a nurse who, on the eve of a bank holiday, has to console a man whose wife has just died in childbirth. 
 Preoccupied with the thoughts of his suffering, the trivial concerns of her lover become increasingly aggravating as they hang around with the crowds at Brighton. 
 He seems over-concerned about what people think of them, to lust after her but not deeply love her. 
 Fearful that the widower will take his life, she rushes back to London, to a man grieving for a woman who once said to him: &bquo;don't be silly, there's no hurry, we've all our lives.&equo; 
 The mood of Bank Holiday  reflects that of a nation knowing that war must come, but other films dealt more directly with the storm clouds building up on the other side of the Channel. 
 Just how seriously intended was the concocted story of The Lady Vanishes  is clear from an early script which opens with a cut from a shot of Nazis strutting to geese on similar manoeuvres. 
 The message is even more explicit in The Four Just Men  (1939), a tale of derring-do in which some chaps set out to warn the nation of a demonic plan to destroy the British Empire, leaving world domination in one man's hands. 
 Like so many of the films that were to be made during the Second World War, The Four Just Men  doesn't only draw attention to the nature of the enemy; it also presents an evocative picture of just what it is that is under threat &mdash; &bquo;all the roads and rivers, fields add woods and hills that make up this funny old island.&equo; 
 The maturing of British cinema between 1939 and 1945 is often seen as a particular response to the conditions of wartime, when filmmakers were called upon to communicate to audiences an idea of &bquo;what we are fighting for.&equo; 
 But filmmakers were only able to rise so impressively to the challenge because of what had happened in the preceding decade. 
 While some filmmakers were making expensive films positioned in a European never-never-land, believing that placeless films were preferable to British films, the documentarists and, to some extent, the makers of quota pictures, were dealing with a more everyday level of life. 
 When the technical skills of the big-budge filmmakers were combined with the ideas of those working at a lower level, the result was the possibility of a thriving national cinema.  
 rushing to the seaside &mdash; Hugh Williams at the railway station for the start of Bank Holiday  (1938) 
 Dark Conflicts 
 The 1940s were a highpoint of British filmmaking. 
 The Second World War gave filmmakers a role, as reporters and commentators on the contemporary situation and providers of entertainments that enabled audiences to deal with their anxieties. 
 Official encouragement, genuine popularity and a sense of purpose helped further heal the self-doubt and hesitation that had previously constrained British filmmakers. 
 The rise in cinema admissions and consolidation of the industry's structure meant that, when the restrictions on subject matter were lifted at the end of the war, filmmakers could fully stretch their imaginations on stories that seemed relevant to the post-war mood. 
 The result was that, for a few years, directors like Carol Reed, David Lean, Michael Powell, Robert Hamer and Alexander Mackendrick created masterpieces. 
 But the new financing structure collapsed under them and, as the cultural energy build up during the 1939&ndash;45 period became depleted, these filmmakers were only occasionally to work again at the same level of intensity. 
 And British filmmaking was never quite the same again. 
 The production industry was much less active during the war than it had been before, producing an average of only 69 films annually, and as few as 46 in 1942. 
 If there was any substance in the argument that high quantity was necessary to bring about a certain level of quality, this retrenchment would have been disastrous. 
 Instead, the concentration of energies, combined with the prosperity that came with rising cinema admissions, from 19 million weekly in 1939 to over 30 million in 1945, enabled some filmmakers to create pictures of high quality. 
 Although the panic order for cinemas to close and production to cease was rapidly rescinded, many film studios were to be requisitioned by the military throughout the war. 
 ABPC (the company into which BIP had been absorbed), for example, lost its Elstree base. 
 By the spring of 1940 only six of the 19 pre-war studios were still operating. 
 But this was in many ways a blessing. 
 Too  many studios had been built in Britain during the production boom and, at a time when filmmakers were anyway keener than they had been hitherto to get out among ordinary people, they found they were no longer constrained by anxious accountants determined to maximize the use of studio space. 
 Among those who found wartime location shooting refreshing was the actor Michael Redgrave who credited much of the quality in The Way to the Stars  (1945), Asquith's atmospheric picture about life on an airforce base, to &bquo;the atmosphere of those three weeks at Catterick, which could never have been created in the studio.&equo; 
 Filmmakers were constricted as to subject matter by the requirement that their films contribute in some way to the war effort. 
 That was the deal to keep British filmmakers in business which Alexander Korda had proposed to government, and supported with his propaganda film, The Lion Has Wings  (1939), combining documentary footage with patriotic clips from earlier feature films and a contemporary narrative full of pontifications on Britain's purpose in going to war. 
 Balcon echoed Korda with his pledge that Ealing Studios would &bquo;grasp with both hands the opportunity of putting every phase of the war on to the screen.&equo; 
 Scripts had to be submitted to Ministry of Information (MOI) officials for vetting. 
 If the film presented an image of typically English virtues &mdash; independence of spirit, toughness, sympathy with the underdog &mdash; or put the case for the ideals of freedom and parliamentary democracy, then the filmmakers could have the stock they needed, and the necessary artists would be released from the ranks. 
 The MOI could also be helpful in liaising between film companies and government departments, and even put finance into the occasional film such as 49th Parallel  (1941, The Invaders  in US), Powell&mdash;Pressburger's skilful piece of star-studded propaganda. 
 If the MOI didn't approve, things were more difficult. 
 That filmmakers didn't feel hamstrung by the need to defer to the MOI reflects their own desire to &bquo;do their bit&equo;. 
 But the ministry was anyway not run by the maiden aunts of the BBFC but by members of the intelligentsia who took a reasonably broad view of wartime cinema, and recognized that effective propaganda was subtle propaganda. 
 As well as vetting projects, the MOI ran an Ideas Committee to notify filmmakers of issues that needed developing into film narratives. 
 It was then up to the industry's writers to find amusing and diverting ways to explore these important questions, sustain morale and present an image of British strength to the outside world. 
 Being asked to write stories that would distinguish an idiosyncratic, individualistic and, in some ways, rather odd group of people from the militaristic, regimented and brutal r&eacute;gime they were fighting against, was a challenge to which many found they could rise. 
 In some ways filmmakers enjoyed more freedom than before. 
 Under the censorship rules in force throughout the 1930s, they would not have been able to cast aspersions on a foreign power, tackle the relations between capital and labour, or take an irreverent view of the army. 
 But a nation now so proud of its right to freedom of speech could not exempt British institutions from criticism. 
 Love on the Dole  (1941), with its depiction of the grimness of life for the unemployed in the Salford slums, was finally given the go-ahead. 
 And many films attacked the sort of conservative attitudes which held back the British war effort. 
 The message of The First of the Few  (1942, Spitfire  in the US), a biopic of the life of R. J. Mitchell, is that the Spitfire was made possible by one man taking on short-sighted business executives and parsimonious government authorities. 
 Similarly, the hero of The Foreman Went To France  (1941, Somewhere in France  in US) has to overcome managerial indifference and bureaucratic obstruction to cross the Channel and recover machines that might otherwise fall into the hands of the Germans. 
 &bquo;Nothing in the King's regulations against using commonsense,&equo; remarks the Cockney in the group that's been persuaded to dump their official load and carry the machines through war-battered France. 
 This critical strain culminates in The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp  (1943), which argues that the gentlemanly values appropriate to the Boer War and the First World War are no longer suitable for fighting the Nazis. 
 &bquo;War starts at midnight&equo; screams the bald-headed general when his steam bath is interrupted by a plucky Home Guard soldier who has launched a premature start to a military exercise. 
 The films was advertised as the BANNED film because of Churchill's doubts about its message, but no serious attempt was made to stop it being made or shown. 
 The enemy was the more usual butt of filmmakers' criticism, particularly in comedies which showed warm-hearted, slightly muddled Englishmen winning through against the demon aggressors. 
 In Sailors Three  (1940, Three Cockeyed Sailors  in US), Tommy Trinder and his companions get drunk and end up on a German ship which, more by mishap than demon cunning, they occupy and deliver to their commander. 
 The amateurishness of Will Hay doesn't stop him winning over some Nazis, giving the others a good lesson in the English way of doing things, and bringing home their secret weapon in The Goose Steps Out  (1942). 
 But the apogee of imaginative anti-Nazism comes in Let George Do It  (1940, To Hell with Hitler  in US), when George Formby, who otherwise divides his time between playing his ukulele and trying to crack the code a bandleader is using to broadcast messages to the Germans, dreams a sequence in which he flies over Berlin in a Zeppelin, lands at a Nuremberg rally and challenges the F&uuml;hrer himself, &bquo;You, Adolf, put a sock in it.&equo; 
 Similar themes were treated more romantically in Carol Reed's Night Train to Munich  (1940, Gestapo: Night Train  in US) and Leslie Howard's Pimpernel Smith  (1941, Mister V; The Fighting Pimpernel  in US). 
 The latter features a seemingly placid English schoolmaster who is, in fact, smuggling refugees out of Europe. 
 Like the comedy films, these tales of the British winning through by skill and intelligence carry their propaganda messages lightly. 
 A point many be slightly rammed home as when, in The Foreman Went To France , the brutality of the Germans in shooting refugees and bombing cities to kill innocent civilians is several times reiterated, but there is never any point in these pictures where one feels the dramatic structure is being distorted for purely message-directed ends. 
 One cannot say the same for those films which make specific connections between earlier events in British history and now. 
 Lady Hamilton  (1941, That Hamilton Woman  in US), which Korda made in America with Vivien Leigh and Laurence Olivier, works most of the time as a love story, but the messages that constantly obtrude about men whose &bquo;insane ambition&equo; makes them want to destroy what others had built are not organic to the main narrative. 
 &bquo;You cannot make peace with dictators, you have to destroy them,&equo; Nelson asserts at one point for the benefit of inattentive members of the audience. 
 Nor are viewers left to make for themselves the link between the &bquo;nation of arch fanatics led by an arch fanatic&equo; that confronted The Young Mr Pitt  (1942) and Britain's contemporary enemies. 
 Presenting a very sanitized view of Pitt's career, the film ends up a hagiography of Churchill. 
 These films showed that using the past as a mirror through which to view the present was an approach of limited value during wartime. 
 Similar signs of strain were present in films that offered images of heroism. 
 Ships with Wings  (1941), for example, tells the improbable story of a flyer who loses his commission after an attempt to impress the admiral's daughter leads to the death of her brother. 
 He takes up a job as a pilot shuttling planes between a Greek island and the mainland, but is eventually able to vindicate himself when his old ship reaches the Aegean. 
 Recruited for a tricky mission, he pinions a German plane under his own, crashes into a dam, floods a German base and goes out in a blaze of glory, having saved the British fleet from likely destruction. 
 A peculiarly bad film which is made all the more dreadful by scattered shots of Greek swains sitting beside ancient pillars and playing their pipes, Ships with Wings  represented a turning point for Balcon, who had supervised the film's production at his Ealing Studios. 
 He concluded that the approach was &bquo;too heavily fictionalized&equo; to go down with an audience that was having to deal with the everyday realities of war. 
 &bquo;From then on,&equo; he recalled, &bquo;we learned to snatch our stories from the headlines and they had the ring of truth.&equo; 
 This coming-together of documentary and fiction filmmaking was the most significant aesthetic development of the period. 
 &bquo;It took a war to compel the British to look at themselves and find themselves interesting,&equo; Dilys Powell was later to remark. 
 Although the MOI Film Division, under Sir Joseph Ball, had been hostile to the documentary movement, his successors Kenneth Clark and Jack Beddington arranged for their GPO Film Unit to be absorbed within the Ministry. 
 The documentarists were natural allies of the government, well practised in tailoring their own ideas to the demands of their sponsors, and exploring ideas about British character that it had become important to validate in order to distinguish the natives from their foes. 
 Whereas Grierson had concluded in the late 1930s that &bquo;in the commercial cinema there is no future worth saving,&equo; Harry Watt hoped to &bquo;crash the commercial cinemas&equo; with story documentaries. 
 Having shown the potential of this genre in North Sea  (1938), his film about fishermen caught in a storm, he demonstrated with Target for Tonight  (1941), which follows an air-crew on a raid across the Channel, that films about the truth of war could secure a large audience. 
 The logistical problems involved in constructing a narrative out of fast-moving events restricted the potential of this genre, but other impressive story-documentaries were produced. 
 Churchill's favourite was Desert Victory  (1943), a loosely-structured account of the Desert Campaigns, but the most remarkable documentary of this period was Humphrey Jennings' Fires were Started  (1943). 
 Set on the home front, it follows a crew of firefighters working through the night to control the blaze at an East End warehouse. 
 Situating the men in their community, the film astonishes with its unstrained truthfulness and poetic intensity. 
 Balcon saw the potential for bringing into mainstream cinema the observational powers of the documentarists, and their capacity for evoking a quieter form of heroism than that displayed in Ships with Wings . 
 Both Albert Cavalcanti, the onetime head of the GPO Film Unit whose Brazilian origins had made him unacceptable as a civil servant, and Watt joined the tight group of filmmakers Balcon had gathered round him at Ealing. 
 Described by the studio's publicist-turned-producer Monja Danischewsky as &bquo;the Nanny who brought us up,&equo; Cavalcanti helped Ealing's filmmakers to develop the semi-documentary style of films such as San Demetrio London  (1943), which recounts the true story of a group of sailors bringing a wrecked oil tanker back to port. 
 But when these documentary imports came to direct films of their own, they revealed distinct personal leanings. 
 Watt's Nine Men  (1943) depicts a group of soldiers making their last stand in a desert hut, which has a dramatic intensity that pushes it to the edge of documentary fiction. 
 And Cavalcanti's Went the Day Well?  (1943, Forty-eight Hours  in US), draws upon a broader range of influences. 
 While setting up the calm surface of village life in a realistic manner, the film does so only as a contrast to the savagery that ensues: a priest is shot while making a stand against &bquo;the enemies and oppressors of mankind&equo;, the Post Office lady kills a German with an axe and is promptly bayonetted herself, and the vicar's daughter disposes of the Quisling squire, to whom she had been amorously linked. 
 In the way it lays bare dark emotional rumblings normally concealed beneath the constraints of village life, Went the Day Well?  suggests Cavalcanti had learned as much from the Surrealists he worked with in Paris as from Britain's documentarists. 
 To Michael Powell documentary was nothing more than a refuge for &bquo;disappointed feature filmmakers or out-of-work poets&equo;, but the wartime films he made within an immensely fruitful collaboration (the Archers) with the Hungarian Emeric Pressburger, with the two of them sharing credits for production, direction and screenwriting, take on documentary concerns in ways which indicate that the absorption of the documentary filmmakers into commercial filmmaking was only an incidental part of a process with roots deep in wartime culture. 
 A Canterbury Tale  (1944) centres, like Went the Day Well? , around a sinister village squire. 
 But while Cavalcanti uses his traitor to question the existing social order, Powell&mdash;Pressburger's Thomas Colpepper remains the guardian of the best English traditions. 
 He has taken to disrupting romantic trysts in the village by pouring glue into the hair of those girls who step out with soldiers; his motive being to encourage the largest possible number of servicemen to attend his lectures, where he speaks of the mysteries of the countryside. 
 There is a significant divide between Cavalcanti's surrealism and Powell's romantic mysticism but, within their bizarre plot, the Powell&mdash;Pressburger team also show us how land girls were being absorbed into the rural workforce, and the sort of connections that were being formed between British and American soldiers. 
 The film both fulfils the Powell&mdash;Pressburger partnership's aim to produce &bquo;original stories, written for the screen, keeping pace with events and trying to put into action what people were thinking and saying at the time,&equo; which is what the more obviously documentarist filmmakers were also trying to do, and articulates its own vision of the mystical forces in nature, culminating in the healing miracle that arrives for each of the three Canterbury pilgrims on their way to the cathedral. 
 The documentary impulse was inherent in the contract filmmakers made with the MOI at the beginning of the war, but it could absorb the poetic romanticism or Powell&mdash;Pressburger, the sophisticated visual and verbal montages produced by Humphrey Jennings, another documentarist with surrealist roots, in such 1941 pictures as Words for Battle  and Listen to Britain , as well as films in the realist tradition. 
 And it's significant that a strand of films showing how a group of individuals from different social backgrounds could be brought together by war and learn to forget their divisions, generally regarded as the supreme achievement of wartime &bquo;realism&equo;, was anticipated in Powell&mdash;Pressburger's One of our Aircraft is Missing  (1941), in which a bomber crew bales out over Holland and works its way home with help from the Dutch resistance. 
 A similar focus on the war's effect in shattering class barriers is present in In Which We Serve  (1942), where the trigger to unity is a torpedoed destroyer rather than a crashed plane, The Gentle Sex  (1943), which follows a group of women as they are trained to become competent fighters, and Millions Like Us  (1943), which brings together a mixed group of girls in an aircraft engineering factory. 
 &bquo;Realist&equo; films like these drew ecstatic praise from the local critics whose enthusiasm for the national cinema was a new phenomenon. 
 Writing shortly after the end of the war, Roger Manvell spoke of a &bquo;cinematic poetry peculiar to British films&equo; while Dilys Powell suggested that the films made during the war had &bquo;set the English film on the path in which masterpieces may be created.&equo; 
 Such enthusiasm may have had as much to do with the excited nationalism of wartime, as any substantial appreciation of these films' merits, and it should not be supposed that British filmmakers had universally gone from being dull and unimaginative to become masters of the cinematic art. 
 Just as stagebound as anything produced before 1939 is When We Are Married  (1943), in which three middle-aged couples are thrown into a frenzy upon discovering that the parson who married them all those years ago wasn't qualified to do so. 
 The script of They Met in the Dark  (1946), in which James Mason is a discharged sea captain hunting down those who delivered fake orders to his ship, is a textureless and muddled affair. 
 Nor did the documentary impulse make much impact on the films of Herbert Wilcox, whose &bquo;patriotic&equo; pictures always had a preachy tone. 
 In her primping performance as Amy Johnson in They Flew Alone  (1942), Anna Neagle is allowed to express none of the deeper motivations for her character's decision to defy convention and take up flying, and the film never tries to make anything of its contrast between Johnson's individualism and its concluding images of girls marching, clearly anything but individuals. 
 What these filmmakers miss is the level of emotional intensity that both the realist filmmakers, whom the critics approved of, and those of a more melodramatic or fantastic disposition, whom they didn't, seem able to conjure, for almost the first time, in the films they produced during the war. 
 The deprivations and adjustment entailed by war taught British filmmakers how to orchestrate strong emotions. 
 Whereas Hitchcock's last British film, the pre-war Jamaica Inn  (1939), could be said to be dealing with a similar area of subject matter to, say, Hatter's Castle  (1941), the emotional level struck by the latter is a world away from the former. 
 Hitchcock sets an innocent woman against Charles Laughton's squire, a criminal buffoon, and a gang of smugglers, but there is never any real conflict, and the ending is almost comic. 
 Hatter's Castle , by contrast, is remorseless, depicting the destruction of a family by the pressures created by its patriarch's social aspirations. 
 But it was at Gainsborough Studios, where production head Maurice Ostrer believed in making films that offered the audience &bquo;good themes and good laughs&equo; that filmmakers produced the most distinctive melodramas of this period, entertainments created at the opposite extreme to the realist dramas. 
 Tightly budgeted, aiming to thrill and drawing upon the talents of performers such as Margaret Lockwood, Phyllis Calvert, James Mason and Stewart 
 Granger, these full-blooded pictures were among the most popular films released in the latter stages of the war. 
 In The Man in Grey  (1943), Lockwood plays a ruthless woman who enters the house of an old schoolfriend as a governess and takes up with the man of the house. 
 After killing her former friend, she is ready for her final triumph but instead is killed by his riding whip. 
 It's a grim vision of the past, heavy with conflict, loss and unhappiness. 
 There's a somewhat lighter tone to The Wicked Lady  (1945), another big hit, in which Lockwood is the aristocratic wife whose passion for living and sense that if &bquo;I can't live while I'm alive, I'll go mad&equo; leads her into a double life as a highwaywoman. 
 What Dilys Powell missed when she described The Wicked Lady  as a concatenation of &bquo;the hoary, the tedious, the disagreeable,&equo; as did other critics who saw Gainsborough's films as a reassertion of an old escapist tendency in British cinema, was how much of an advance such films offered on everything of a similar sort that had gone before, and how they touched the sentiments of audiences who could no longer respond to stories of gallant endeavour quite as they could when it seemed that defeat was an imminent possibility. 
 While the films made at the beginning of the war appealed for people to forget selfish desires and apply themselves to the common good, to put aside class divisions in order to confront an enemy that threatened everyone equally, the Gainsborough films addressed themselves to the frustrations and the pain that came after continuous self-sacrifice. 
 What happens in many of the significant films that emerge after the war is that the claims of the community and the individual are set against each other, bringing together Ealing realism and Gainsborough melodrama in a tremendously fruitful, if brief and explosive, relationship. 
 Ealing Studios made films as untypical of itself as Dead of Night  (1945), a collection of mostly unsettling tales of the fantastic and of hidden desires that erupt from below, Pink String and Sealing Wax  (1945), in which the son of a strict father becomes the unwitting accomplice in a woman's murder of her husband, and even a costume melodrama, Saraband for Dead Lovers  (1948, Saraband  in US). 
 Powell and Pressburger brought an energy to films exploring this conflict between wartime values and those of the post-war world that reflects their increasing disaffection with the new England. 
 In I Know Where I'm Going  (1945), Wendy Hiller plays a go-ahead girl who, when forced to choose between the sort of rural mysticism the filmmakers previously invoked in A Canterbury Tale  and a &bquo;good&equo; marriage, is only reluctantly brought round to accept the former. 
 Black Narcissus  (1946) chronicles the breakdown of a community of nuns set up in the Himalayas, riven by inner conflicts and pulled apart by the intrusion of romantic figures from outside. 
 The conflict is played out for the last time in The Red Shoes  (1948), where the ballerina played by Moira Shearer initially lives unproblematically for her dancing, until she falls in love with a composer. 
 Forced to acknowledge the impossibility of achieving perfection in both love and work, she is driven to self-destruction. 
 The old wartime community that could absorb individual needs, the filmmakers are saying, is no more. 
 However, it's impossible for anyone who lived through those times to settle down to cosy domesticity, the world without adventure that Marius Goring offers Shearer. 
 The Red Shoes  is a declaration by Powell-Pressburger that they don't find post-war, welfare-state England a particularly brave or challenging place in which to live.  
 Michael Powell sizes up Marius Goring and Moira Shearer for The Red Shoes  (1948) 
 The films of David Lean show a similar drift towards a darker vision of the choices facing individuals in post-war society. 
 The domestic world which draws the suburban housewife away from the temptations of an illicit romance in Brief Encounter  (1945) is quite as cosy as that depicted in an earlier collaboration between Lean and No&euml;l Coward, This Happy Breed  (1944). 
 The fact that the film was hailed by critics as a triumphant piece of realism, even though the woman's choice between a passionate affair and married contentment is as melodramatic as that offered by any Gainsborough melodrama, reflects the kudos Lean had acquired as director of In Which We Serve , the critic's touchstone for quality. 
 Lean's realist reputation was enlarged by his first Dickens adaptation, Great Expectations  (1946) but, by the time he came to film the extraordinary expressionist opening to Oliver Twist  (1948), questions were being asked. 
 Critics were even more profoundly unnerved when Lean took a new approach to the Brief Encounter  story with The Passionate Friends  (1948), where the husband is a much more potent, interesting and violent character than the would-be lover, again played by Trevor Howard. 
 Finally, with Madeleine  (1950), Lean ventured into costume melodrama, telling the story of a nineteenth-century woman who may, or may not, have murdered her French lover. 
 The critics were appalled. 
 But, however rapidly the filmmakers who built their reputations during the war may have disillusioned the critics, with their narrow concept of what the nation's filmmakers should be doing, British filmmakers had reason to be confident in 1945. 
 They had built a strong relationship with audiences both at home and abroad. 
 In the US, thanks to an agreement that major distributors would give eight films annually a full circuit release, pictures such as The 49th Parallel, Target for Tonight  and In Which We Serve  had done remarkable business. 
 And there was now a British company as large as any American maker, under a leader, J. Arthur Rank, who wanted to breathe life into the dream that British films could conquer the American market. 
 Rank was a businessman who pursued a grander vision than Isidore Ostrer or John Maxwell had ever done. 
 The third son of a successful Yorkshire miller, he had the contacts necessary to raise all the backing he needed. 
 Having started in films by putting a few thousand pounds into a short religious picture in 1933, he went on to form British National, a production company, in association with Lady Yule, the wealthy widow of a Calcutta jute merchant. 
 He built a large studio at Pinewood and went into distribution with General Film Distributors (GFD). 
 Then, as the industry reeled from the production slump of the late 1930s, Rank extended his stake in the business. 
 He took over Denham from Korda in 1938 and by 1941 had acquired a controlling interest in Oscar Deutsch's Odeon cinema chain and the Gaumont-British set-up &mdash; both its cinemas and its filmmaking companies. 
 Between 1941 and 1947, Rank's companies were to be responsible for financing half the films made in Britain. 
 Rank controlled most available studio space, two cinema circuits (over 600 theatres) and the largest British distribution company. 
 With cinema admissions expanding rapidly, Rank was not only in a buoyant financial condition, but also in a strong position to negotiate a deal, which would secure his films a fair return from the US market, with major American companies increasingly concerned to protect their UK earnings. 
 As well as negotiating from strength, Rank had a realistic perception of just how tough he would have to be. 
 There was no question of simply negotiating a deal with one American company, as producers had done in the 1930s, and then just hoping for the best. 
 When his attempt to buy Korda's stake in United Artists didn't work out, Rank poached two of the company's employees and put them in charge of an international distribution operation, Eagle Lion Films. 
 Then, realizing the cost and risk of setting up an American operation only for his own films, he backtracked and arranged for US to handle his company's big-budget pictures. 
 He then opened discussions with Universal, a company in which he had taken a 25 per cent stake back in 1935, whereby Rank's smaller films would be packaged with the pictures of an independent US production company, and sold in a block to exhibitors. 
 But this sophisticated attempt to deal with exhibitor resistance to British films was ruled illegal by the US Justice Department in 1946 and had to be replaced by a less ambitious system, in which Rank's films were sold on their merits. 
 While continuing negotiation with the Americans, Rank also bought cinema circuits in Canada, New Zealand, Australia, Egypt and South Africa. 
 Many set the odds on Rank achieving his ambitions very low indeed, seemingly believing that, as Eric Ambler was later to remark, &bquo;a policy of selling British cars to America with their steering wheels on the right would have had the same chance of success.&equo; 
 And Michael Balcon, now convinced that making big-budget films to please the Americans was a sure way for the British film industry to commit suicide, began a campaign through the Cinematograph Films Council to draw attention to the amount of control Rank, with his dangerous policies, now had over the film industry. 
 The resulting Palache Report, named after its chairman and published by the CFC in 1944, articulated Balcon's concern that the British cinema was becoming a &bquo;channel for disseminating the ideas and aspirations, no matter how worthy in themselves, of one or two dominating personalities in this country,&equo; and backed his view that the British industry should concentrate on a regular output of low-budget, authentically British films. 
 But Rank was a disarming opponent. 
 He offered Balcon's Ealing Studios favourable distribution through his company's domestic and foreign network, with &bquo;independence as far as production was concerned&equo; together with a licence to go on producing low-budget British films. 
 Balcon was sensible enough to forget his scruples and accept. 
 Similarly, although Rank turned down Sydney Box's first independent feature, 29 Acacia Avenue  (1945), on the grounds that the innocuous story about an aborted premarital romp was &bquo;immoral&equo;, and offered him &pound;40,000 to put the film on the shelf, he was later to give Box the job of running Gainsborough's production programme. 
 In any case, by strengthening his position abroad, Rank had made himself unassailable at home. 
 The ministers and officials at the Department of Trade to whom the Palache Report was submitted were less concerned about the inner workings of the film industry than with how to respond to Treasury demands that they work to secure foreign currency. 
 Rank's argument that he needed the studios, the cinemas and the distribution network if he was to ensure that his films performed in foreign markets was, therefore, one that relevant officials were predisposed to accept. 
 And, given the rather jaundiced view that civil servants had by then formed of the movie business, it is not surprising that they preferred to commend Rank for observing &bquo;the normal standards of commercial efficiency and honesty, which have not so far been conspicuous within the film industry&equo; than listen to the arguments presented by Palache that budget control on Rank's film productions was inadequate. 
 In short, the DOT accepted that the existence of a conglomerate like Rank offered the best &bquo;prospects of making first-class films, of acquiring an export market.&equo; 
 Balcon was forced off the CFC, where places were found both for Alexander Korda, who shared the new mogul's enthusiasm for &bquo;bigger and bigger films,&equo; and for Rank himself. 
 For a time Rank produced films that really could compete against American pictures. 
 Powell and Pressburger brought their Archers outfit under the umbrella of Rank's Independent Producers company where they made all their films from The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp to The Red Shoes . 
 After the phenomenal success of In Which We Serve , the Italian producer Filippo del Giudice, whose belief in high-budget artistic filmmaking was in line with Rank's, attached his Two Cities company to Independent Producers, and made through it such films as the Lean&mdash;Coward This Happy Breed ; Laurence Olivier's rampantly patriotic version of Shakespeare's Henry V  (1945); Thorold Dickinson's unbalanced Men of Two Worlds  (1946, Witch Doctor  in US) and Carol Reed's Odd Man Out  (1945, Gang War  in US), the story of a dying gunman's desperate search for charity on the streets of Belfast. 
 To make Brief Encounter , Lean's Cineguild team joined Independent Producers as a separate company, as did Wessex, a company formed by former Crown Film Unit filmmakers Ian Dalrymple and Jack Lee. 
 The success of Independent Producers owed nothing to Rank's skills as an impresario; he had none. 
 He benefited from the way the highly productive film industry of the 1930s had given filmmakers such as Powell, on quota films, and David Lean, as a film editor, an opportunity to develop their creative skills and judgement. 
 And it was the filmmakers' good fortune that their first creative maturity coincided with Rank's willingness to give full scope to their talents. 
 Independent Producers may not have been a particularly well-managed production outfit but the filmmakers had developed sufficient self-discipline to ensure that, while the films might become increasingly expensive, they were always tightly constructed and realized the potential in their subject matter. 
 And a competitive working environment drew out from directors and writers the best they could achieve. 
 The creative excitement generated leads sometimes, in the work of Lean and Powell&mdash;Pressburger, to moments of creative delirium. 
 A more controlled production context had been established by Balcon at Ealing, where his belief that filmmaking was essentially a team activity had been strengthened by the importation of documentary filmmakers who were accustomed to working in tight-knit groups. 
 Even after projects had been assigned to particular producers, directors and writers, they remained studio properties, discussed at round-table discussions involving all the key people who worked there. 
 &bquo;The various projects were not regarded as competitive,&equo; Danischewsky recalled, &bquo;so we read each other's scripts and kicked in with our suggestions and contributions to all the films.&equo; 
 To strengthen the sense of group identity, set designers, editions, publicists and others graduated through the studio's hierarchy and became directors, writers or producers. 
 With this coherent team, in many ways bonded to the studio, Balcon set out to make films that mirrored what was happening to British society and fulfilled his aim of building up &bquo;a native industry with its roots firmly planted in the soil of this country.&equo; 
 For a time Ealing was as closely in touch with the hopes and frustrations of post-war audiences as were the directors and writers working for Rank's Independent Producers. 
 Both explored the breakup of wartime solidarity, the liberation of former restraints on individual selfishness and the irruption of dark, subversive and irrational forces to tear down the cosy myths so assiduously cultivated during wartime. 
 Behind the fa&ccedil;ade of normal family existence in an East End street, in It Always Rains on Sunday  (1947), lurk strong, violent desires. 
 The RAF officer who was so noble in conflict becomes the devious villain in Cage of Gold  (1950). 
 The willingness of England to welcome foreigners into its communities, celebrated during wartime in the pleasantries of Tawny Pipit  (1944), is thrown into question by the searing melodrama of Frieda  (1947), where the &bquo;kindly, good-natured people&equo; of Denfield become vicious xenophobes when the stranger amongst them is a blonde German girl. 
 And the willingness of the British aristocracy to yield place without a show of force is thrown into serious doubt by the calculated viciousness of Kind Hearts and Coronets  (1949), as the disowned son of a noble line works murderously through the family tree in order to claim his birthright. 
 British filmmakers would not for much longer feel free to look behind the placid surface of English life. 
 The history of Gainsborough Pictures shows just how strong were the forces dragging them away from conflict and passion, towards gentility. 
 Here Rank's insistence that he was in films to make money, that he wouldn't interfere because he knew nothing about production, was challenged by his lack of vision and, eventually, his weak stomach for full-blooded costume melodrama. 
 Gradually he undermined the potential of one of his most profitable production centres. 
 Key personnel, including Frank Launder and Sidney Gilliatt, left in anger to join Independent Producers after Rank had failed to support deputy production chief Ted Black in his determination to maintain a broad range of productions against Maurice Ostrer's desire to focus on costume melodrama. 
 Without the depth of talent to draw on, and with a Rank veto placed on a sequel to the phenomenally successful The Wicked Lady , Maurice Ostrer, who took over Black's responsibilities, was unable again to match the verve of the early period pictures. 
 He was in turn replaced by Sydney Box who, while reinstating Black's policy of maintaining a broad range of films and enlarging the script department, run by his wife Muriel, to develop original stories and train new writers, gave a twist to the company's film production that looks more like deference to Rank's demand for moral uplift than a full-hearted pursuit of the popular audience.  
 Robert Hamer prepares Joan Greenwood for the trial scene in Kind hearts and Coronets  (1949) 
 Extra-marital passion &mdash; Googie Withers and John McCallum steam it up for director Robert Hamer in It Always Rains on Sunday  (1947) 
 The early Gainsborough melodramas, while they never allowed the villainess to prevail, offered insight into the sensations of an evil life dedicated to, sometimes perverse, pleasure. 
 That openness to liberated desire is cut off in the films which the Boxes produce. 
 The heroine of The Good Time Girl  (1948) never seems to be enjoying herself. 
 She has a miserable time, leaving home for a job in a club, escaping from reform school to hang out with drunken hoodlums and joining up with some soldiers for a bout of petty thieving that culminates in murder, and the film never allows one into the girl's experience. 
 It's always angled towards the case for more funds to be allocated to reform schools set up for &bquo;the salvaging of these youngsters whose natural growth has been marred by bad upbringing, bad companions, bad luck.&equo; 
 Muriel Box claimed for the film that the issues it covered were &bquo;treated seriously and with sincerity.&equo; 
 Something of the same librarian's desire for accuracy seems to have afflicted Gainsborough's later nods in the direction of costume melodrama. 
 Of the promisingly-titled Bad Lord Byron  (1949), for example, Box remarked that &bquo;nothing was artificially concocted,&equo; but the film is also deathly dull to watch as various figures from Byron's life come into a court room to debate whether he was a great poet or a great cad. 
 The Gainsborough films that best characterize the desire of filmmakers to close their eyes to the darker currents in society, to make believe that the world really is as cosy as some wartime films made it out to be, are Holiday Camp  (1947) and the three sequels set amongst the jolly Huggett family. 
 Vote for Huggett  (1948), for example, shows the family patriarch played by Jack Warner making a stand against a corrupt local councillor, then with the he of the local youth club and three eccentric old ladies, exposing the property transactions that stand in the way of a lido and public garden being built to serve the local community. 
 The sanitized, simplified, view of the world offered in films like this anticipates later television styles, and mark the beginning of the closedown of any willingness on the part of British filmmakers to confront the difficulties of contemporary life. 
 The drift to comedy started by Hue and Cry  (1947), in which a group of kids foil some crooks, took Balcon's studio in a similar direction, but there is a spirit of anarchy in the early Ealing comedies and a recognition that, since there can be no final victories, the little people must sustain their rebellion. 
 Typical are the films written by T. E. B. Clarke, such as Passport to Pimlico  (1949), about a community whose discovery that it is an independent Burgundian principality enables the inhabitants to forget for a while the realities of post-war austerity, and The Lavender Hill Mob  (1951), about a bank clerk who robs a bank. 
 Even so, a process of gradual denial creeps into Ealing's output, most clearly represented in Train of Events  (1949), a film that brings together many of the characters who people post-war movies, only to kill them off or put a stop on their moral infractions. 
 A blitz baby hungry for love tries to get her hunted German lover away to safety in Canada; an actor, taunted by his wife for being still soft and weak, replies he's been &bquo;toughened&equo; by military service and proves it by strangling her, and a conductor plans to elope with his pianist mistress. 
 These troubled souls are mostly killed in the train crash. 
 Only the conductor and his lady survive, but the incident ends their romance. 
 The train is driven by Jack Warner, Mr Huggett himself, who the following year takes the part of a reliable policeman out to put a stop to juvenile delinquency in The Blue Lamp  (1950). 
 That film is generally taken as marking a shift in Ealing's focus from the sources of energy to the forces of repression. 
 The impression that post-war production was almost totally dominated by Rank and his subsidiary companies is largely accurate. 
 During the war, ABPC had been confined to a small studio at Welwyn, producing low-budget crime melodramas. 
 Production continued in this vein afterwards, with films like the Georges Simenon adaptation Temptation Harbour  (1946) and John Boulting's prosaic account of Graham Greene's Brighton Rock  (1947, Young Scarface  in US). 
 And when Alexander Korda returned from America, where he had been supporting Britain's propaganda effort, with the intention of competing with Rank, he had to use bravado and charm where Rank had cash. 
 Also, he didn't easily gauge the mood of a country emerging from war. 
 Perfect Strangers  (1945), which he directed for MGM, seemed glib in its presentation of the changes war had brought to a married couple, changing him from timid clerk to authoritarian naval officer, and her from drab housewife to confident member of the WRNS, but the film was popular nevertheless.  
 Pinkie on the phone &mdash; in the studio for Brighton Rock  (1947) 
 On the streets &mdash; onlookers gather for an exterior scene from Brighton Rock  (1947) 
 After a period as head of MGM UK, Korda reconstituted London films, bought and modernized studios at Shepperton, took over a controlling interest in the British Lion distribution company and purchased the Rialto Cinema in Leicester Square as his showcase. 
 But the larger films he made showed how out-of-touch he was with audience tastes. 
 An Ideal Husband  (1947), a film version of Oscar Wilde's play, is a lavish but stagey production set in 1895, when &bquo;Britain ruled the world and held the purse&equo;, showing the dilemma facing a government minister whose murky past catches up with him. 
 There followed such extravagant follies as Bonnie Prince Charlie  (1948) and an Anna Karenina  (1947) in which Vivien Leigh vainly tried to bring some of the same magic to the role as Greta Garbo had 12 years earlier. 
 Some compensation for these flops was provided by Carol Reed's The Fallen Idol  (1947), an adaptation of Graham Green's short story about a young boy's loss of innocence, and Anthony Asquith's The Winslow Boy  (1948), an adapted stage-play about the struggles of a naval cadet's father to prove his son's innocence of theft. 
 Korda lacked the resources to lure away a significant number of Rank's key directors. 
 But if Rank controlled the source of the more creative ideas, his company didn't have the management necessary to ensure the continuance of his production policy. 
 Rank was so convinced that making expensive films was the way to break through into the American market that he made no attempt to rein back costs. 
 While the magnificence of the result could justify the fact that The Red Shoes  cost twice as much as The Life and Death of Colonel Blimp , there were many cases where the extravagance worked against the final result, and Michael Powell has recalled that he became &bquo;impatient at the complacency of my associates about the mounting costs of our films.&equo; 
 Just how weak were Rank's budgetary controls can be seen from their dealings with Gabriel Pascal, the Hungarian producer whose brief career was built on his having persuaded George Bernard Shaw to trust him with the film rights to his plays. 
 But while Pygmalion  (1938) had been directed by the reliable Asquith, Pascal himself took over the reins on Major Barbara  (1941). 
 His pernickety attitude and lack of experience led to the film going almost 100 per cent over-budget. 
 Rank, having carried the can on that occasion, then allowed spending on Caesar and Cleopatra  (1945) to reach the mind-numbing figure of &pound;1,280,000, twice as much as The Red Shoes . 
 The film is so dull and wordy that it bears out in every frame Powell's assertion that Pascal &bquo;knew as much about directing as a cow does about playing the piano.&equo; 
 Rank was a company without the creative leadership to support its chairman's ambitions for the world market. 
 While Gainsborough was becoming enfeebled, nothing was being done outside Ealing and Independent Producers to bring on talent or set up new centres of production strength. 
 Rank's ambitions in the US were dependent on the company's films all being of a certain quality, but there was an insufficient understanding of what made a production unit like Ealing work, and the model was not copied elsewhere. 
 As a result, many of the films emerging from Rank were of poor quality. 
 Although the sums remitted back from the US were much lower than expected, and continuing high taxation rates caused a drain on domestic box office receipts, no attempt was made to rein in film budgets. 
 The company also started making silly mistakes. 
 Gainsborough's executives were pushed very much against their will into an expensive production of Christopher Columbus  (1949), simply because a lot of money had been spent on a script. 
 Muriel Box's complaint, of course, was that the script was &bquo;inaccurate,&equo; critic Richard Winnington's that the film &bquo;contrives with something like genius neither to inform, excite, entertain, titillate or engage the eye.&equo; 
 And Rank interpreted his own difficulty in understanding The Red Shoes  as evidence that he had a disaster on his hands. 
 He rushed it into UK cinemas to ensure that the shareholders didn't notice. 
 Sensibly he allowed UA to enjoy the benefits of a mega-hit in the US. 
 The Gater Committee on Film Production Costs, which reported in October 1949, was in no doubt that the film industry had brought its latest crisis down upon its own head, through creating &bquo;a general atmosphere of extravagance and unreality, leading to a disregard of expense which would not be tolerated in other forms of business.&equo; 
 Rank, however, argued with equal conviction that it was all the government's fault. 
 His case was not without foundation. 
 In July 1947, while Rank was in America negotiating with the five major companies, the British government responded to its own problem, a serious dollar shortage, by trying to slow down one of the major outflows and imposing a 75 per cent levy on remittable income from foreign films. 
 It was a stupid decision, indicating only the severity of the government's dollar crisis, and it is incredible that it should have been implemented without any discussion with the country's major exhibitor. 
 Rank, however, seems to have been taken unawares by a move that provided a disastrous demonstration of how ineffective he was in protecting the interests of the American companies. 
 &bquo;All my work was thrown away. 
 My two months in America went for nowt,&equo; he was to complain. 
 Rank had funded his forays into production on the back of profits accruing from the exhibition of US pictures but, instead of standing firm with the American companies when they announced a boycott of British screens, he decided to boost his own company's production. 
 If Rank seriously thought that his directors could work to order and effectively fill the gap in the release schedules, notwithstanding the audience's proven affection for US pictures, then he really did know very little about film production. 
 After the tax had been abolished and the boycott lifted, Rank compounded his incompetence by deciding to keep the best playdates for his mix of low-budget featurettes and big-budget pictures. 
 The Americans must have felt as if he was taking revenge on them for what had happened, but they had the final laugh since most of Rank's films weren't very good. 
 Rank could blame the government all he liked, but it was his own policies which had antagonized the Americans, alienated audiences and significantly increased the company's overdraft. 
 Rank's wilful demolition of his own dream suggests he had simply had enough of trying to create a niche for British films in the American market. 
 Certainly he was never again to be as actively interested in the company as he was in the late 1940s. 
 In 1959 Rank claimed that &bquo;Britain would now have a healthy industry and a very successful market&equo; if it had not been for the insensitivity of the Department of Trade. 
 It may be that it was their actions that tipped the balance for Rank, and decided him against pushing on with his ambitions. 
 After all, if the British government knifed him in the back when he was pursuing their patriotic interest, what was the point of going on? 
 If so, it is difficult to know how he would have stood up to the long haul that still awaited him. 
 British filmmakers could come up with films that would overcome the resistance of American exhibitors to non-Hollywood products, as the &dollar;5 million grossed by The Red Shoes  suggests, but they wouldn't do so in sufficient quantities until Rank had developed more sophisticated ideas about how to cajole the right sort of product from his writers, directors and producers. 
 The upward spiral on which film budgets were set suggests that Rank might have had to go on losing money for a long time before hitting on a way to achieve a steady supply of sellable films. 
 Also, it is difficult to know how well Rank's negotiating position would have held up after cinema admissions had started their precipitate decline in the mid-1950s. 
 But now, with hopes of a breakthrough into the American market dashed, there were signs of retrenchment everywhere in British filmmaking. 
 Rank closed down its smaller studios at Shepherd's Bush and Islington (the old Gaumont-British studios) as well as Denham and Highbury. 
 The budgetary cutbacks gradually drove the directors gathered in Independent Producers to London Films, but Korda was having problems raising cash to fund production, and his British Lion company was on the verge of bankruptcy. 
 The 45 per cent quota imposed in October 1948, in a futile attempt to support the films encouraged into production during the American boycott, had to be lowered to 40 per cent when 1,600 cinemas claimed exemption on the grounds that there simply weren't enough films to show, and it was reduced again to 30 per cent in 1950 (the level at which it remained until its abolition 23 years later). 
 In early 1949, 17 studios were idle, over a third of the film technicians' union's members were unemployed and British filmmaking, as a writer in the New Statesman  put it, was &bquo;facing disaster&equo;. 
 Indian Summer 
 British filmmaking ticked over during the 1950s, for the most part without any great ambition, or yen for artistic adventure. 
 Filmmakers settled down to live with the Americans, having decided against launching any further substantial challenges on their home turf. 
 The UK government, following the example of the French and Italians, instituted measures to strengthen the ability of local producers to secure a reasonable return from the domestic box office, and filmmakers developed undemanding forms of cinema, mainly comedies and war films, that would reliably appeal to native audiences. 
 Meanwhile, cinema admissions declined steadily, from 1,365 million in 1951 to 501 million in 1961, reinforcing the impression of limpness that hung around the whole of the British film industry. 
 The powerhouses of film production in the previous decade nearly all wilted in this atmosphere. 
 Only Alexander Mackendrick at Ealing and David Lean seemed able, to some extent, to sustain their earlier initiatives, the one by focusing an acerbic eye on the state of England, the other by applying his extraordinary craftsmanship to such international films as The Bridge on the River Kwai  (1957) and Lawrence of Arabia  (1962). 
 Powell and Pressburger made their last disillusioned statement on the post-war mood in The Small Back Room  (1949), the story of an explosives expert's struggles against drink and pain that was their first film after the defection to Korda. 
 They turned to florid over-statement with Gone to Earth  (1950) and, by the time the duo came to make Ill Met by Moonlight  (1956), it is difficult to dissent from Powell's own judgement that &bquo;we'd run out a bit of ideas&equo;. 
 The tough treatment of childhood Carol Reed had offered in The Fallen Idol  gave way to feyness in A Kid for Two Farthings  (1955) while Robert Hamer, expelled from Ealing, shifted from the controlled savagery in Kind Hearts and Coronets  via the eccentric Father Brown  (1954, The Detective  in US) to such routine comedy assignments as To Paris with Love  (1954) and School for Scoundrels  (1959). 
 And at Ealing itself, Balcon's post-war ambition for a cinema that would project &bquo;the true Briton to the rest of the world&equo; as a &bquo;leader in social reform, champion of civil liberties&equo; had shrivelled by the end of the 1950s to a commitment to make films about &bquo;day-dreamers, mild anarchists, little men who long to kick the boss in the teeth.&equo; 
 There were complex reasons behind the shift in each individual's creative potential. 
 Powell and Pressburger couldn't find the stories that expressed what they wanted to say to a contemporary audience, Reed suffered a loss of nerve after making two exceptional films with Graham Greene ( Fallen Idol  and The Third Man ). 
 Lean drew strength from being such a cerebral filmmaker, while Mackendrick had the advantage of being a (Scottish) outsider in the very English setting of Ealing studios. 
 Hamer, by contrast, was not only unable to flourish inside Ealing, where his projects were now considered too risqu&eacute;, but unable to thrive outside. 
 But the general inability of the film industry to support and encourage creative adventure was the responsibility of the two major companies, which were now in the hands of former accountants who had not cast off their old ways of thinking, John Davis at Rank and Robert Clark at ABPC. 
 Michael Powell noticed the development of a &bquo;civil service&equo; mentality within Rank at the time of making The Red Shoes , but his argument that &bquo;there is something after all to be said for lavishness, improvisation and a certain amount of waste&equo; was not likely to make much headway with John Davis, managing director of Rank from 1948, who disliked creative people, considering them extravagant and unreliable. 
 He remarked in 1953 that &bquo;film producers have grown fat, lazy and unimaginative.&equo; 
 Davis was the worst sort of person to have at the head of a monopolistic company. 
 Whereas Arthur Rank could argue in the 1940s that the diversity of production activity within the company eliminated the dangers of monopoly, Davis did away with alternative centres of initiative. 
 He didn't appreciate that a production company would only flourish if there were several channels, run by people with diverse sensibilities, through which to filter projects. 
 Production was now centralized at Pinewood Studios, with Davis's former personal assistant Earl St John, a one-time exhibitor, put in charge of making &bquo;inexpensive films without artistic pretensions, films that had no other object than to provide good family entertainment and show a profit.&equo; 
 Strong-willed producers previously housed under the Rank umbrella, like Filippo del Giudice, George Archibald, Joseph Somlo and Sydney Box all left, along with the prestige directorial talent, and their companies were consolidated into J. Arthur Rank Productions. 
 The majority of screenwriters were dismissed and half the production staff sacked. 
 This was asset-stripping on a grand scale, only the assets were stripped by the company's managing director and then thrown away. 
 With neither Rank nor ABPC willing to undertake adventurous production, the initiative passed to independent companies like John and James Woolf's Romulus Productions, the Boultings' Charter Productions and numerous others. 
 None of these operations, however, was strong enough to take on the role of nurturing talent or providing a supportive home for creative filmmakers. 
 Finance was on a film-by-film basis for the most part, with assistance coming from the new National Film Finance Corporation. 
 Successive government reports since the late 1930s had recommended setting up a national film bank, but it was only in the wake of the 1948 production crisis that the government seriously contemplated making funds available to the industry. 
 Some stop-gap funding was provided immediately for British Lion and this was followed, in April 1949, by the setting up of the National Film Finance Corporation which the Board of Trade provided with a revolving fund of &pound;5 million (expanded to &pound;6 million in 1950). 
 This money was initially paid out to distributors as a stimulus to set up a network of satellite producers but, after the corporation had trouble recovering the &pound;3 million invested in Korda's British Lion, money was directed into individual projects which they thought had commercial potential, as the percentage of the budget (usually 30 per cent) that couldn't be raised from a distributor. 
 Between 1950 and 1961, the NFFC helped into production almost half the 730 British first feature films produced. 
 The second government measure increased producers' bargaining power with financiers by reserving for British films a portion of the money taken at the domestic box office. 
 Although the returns accruing to a particular film from the Eady Levy, as it was called, were limited both by the size of the box office in any particular year, and that film's success in the market-place (the levy was paid out in proportion to a film's success), the promise it offered did make it easier for independents to raise cash. 
 Like previous government action to boost the native film industry, Eady strengthened the ties between British and American production. 
 The legislation's loose definition of a &bquo;British&equo; film, as one made by a British company in a British studio using a certain percentage of British crew, could be applied to a picture made by a British subsidiary of a US major, using an American director, writer and key cast. 
 Together with the agreement that led to the lifting of the Ad Valorem duties, which required US companies to invest a certain proportion of their earnings in Britain, Eady led to a considerable increase in British-based American production. 
 MGM, Fox, Warner and RKO made a substantial number of films out of London, many of them spectaculars rather than authentically British productions, and a number of producers like Albert (&bquo;Cubby&equo;) Broccoli and Sam Spiegel moved from America to the UK. 
 The fragmented production environment provided fewer opportunities for untried directors. 
 Recognizing this, the NFFC set up an independent unit, Group 3, to finance low-budget films. 
 This was a good idea, but the organization lacked effective leadership. 
 Its chairman was John Grierson who had never been particularly interested in responding to the requirements of the commercial market-place, and production control was in the hands of John Baxter, a onetime director whose films had been of the prosaic but worthy variety. 
 With budgets of around &pound;50,000, the preference was for gentle tales with a non-urban setting such as The Brave Don't Cry  (1952), about a Scottish mining disaster; Conflict of Wings  (1953, Fuss Over Feathers  in US), in which East Anglian villagers fight for the cause of bird sanctuaries against the needs of the RAF; Judgement Deferred  (1951) and Brandy for the Parson  (1951), both of which are smuggling stories. 
 But what aroused resentment from people in the film industry had nothing to do with the merits of these films, which critic Raymond Durgnat reasonably characterized as &bquo;sub-Ealing comedies so timid as to be positively ingratiating,&equo; nor the production programme's lack of profitability. 
 It was felt by John Davis and others that the government was backing unfair competition with the commercial companies. 
 For Davis, therefore, this feeble attempt at sponsoring new talent was unacceptable &bquo;socialism&equo;. 
 Group 3 was closed down in 1955. 
 Absorbing many of the energies that had been concentrated in Independent Producers, Korda's London Films was able for a time to resist the drift towards cosiness. 
 Somewhat chastened by his recent flops, burdened by the NFFC loan and prevented by his reputation for extravagance from raising substantial finance elsewhere, Korda kept away during this period from glamour, lavish sets and spectacle. 
 Although production controls were never tight at London Films, he reduced costs and increased production. 
 And for the more ambitious film projects he developed a coproduction arrangement with David O. Selznick, the producer who had lured Hitchcock to Hollywood. 
 It was with Selznick that London Films made one of the most remarkable films of the late 1940s, The Third Man  (1949). 
 Although Korda was now more of a financier than an active producer, it was his suggestion that led Graham Greene to visit Austria to see if he could find the background in the four-power occupation of Vienna which would inspire him to extend his one-line story: &bquo;I had paid my last farewell to Harry less than a week ago, when his coffin was lowered in the frozen February ground, so that it was with incredulity that I saw him pass by, without a sign of recognition, among the host of strangers in the Strand.&equo; 
 The film Greene developed with Carol Reed is a strong thriller that maximizes the potential of its locations. 
 It also contains in the character of Colonel Calloway, the world-weary Englishman responsible for alerting the innocent American writer of pulp novels to his former friend's evil doings, a perfect symbol of Britain's position after the Second World War, standing in the middle between battered Europe and gung-ho America. 
 &bquo;Great Britain has lost an empire and not yet found a role&equo; taunted Dean Acheson, the American Secretary of State, around this time. 
 The dilemma of which he spoke was felt by filmmakers as they sought to make films that dealt with the pressing contemporary issues, at a time when the initiative in world affairs had passed decisively to the Americans. 
 For a while they could believe, like the politicians, that an independent nuclear deterrent, the skills of their scientists and a special relationship with America would give the UK a portion of its old status. 
 The scientist who threatens to blow up London in the film John Boulting directed for Korda, Seven Days to Noon  (1950), does so in order that the whole world will be made aware of how a scientific dream had been corrupted. 
 In Lean's film The Sound Barrier  (1952), the central character, an engineer, is portrayed as a more deeply ambivalent figure, driven by his ambition to build a plane that goes faster than the speed of sound, seemingly prepared to accept the loss of his son and a pilot in pursuit of his dream, but actually torn by a deep sense of what he has lost. 
 One year later, Rank made The Net  (1953), also concerned with aviation, but here there is no attempt to confront the possibility that there is danger within the scientific project itself. 
 The hero is credited with wholly worthy motives, to &bquo;make this all one place&equo; so that &bquo;we may learn to trust one another and live in peace&equo;, and the only opposition to his dream comes from bureaucrats as obstructive as those who tried to restrain the foreman who wanted to go to France, and an interloper who plots to take the plane across the Iron Curtain. 
 Where the nuclear scientist in Seven Days to Noon  is shot, and the engineer in The Sound Barrier  ends the film a shattered man, the scientist in The Net  is rescued from danger and goes off home to resolve his marital problems. 
 Tame films of this sort show directors and writings giving up the struggle to deal with contemporary anxieties. 
 Lean and the Boultings drifted towards less intense forms of filmmaking, and the concerns evident in their early 1950s pictures were pushed out to less prestigious areas of film production. 
 These became, in fact, the almost exclusive preserve of Hammer Films, a company that had been making skilfully-marketed pictures with an eye on the US B-movie market since the late 1940s. 
 In 1955 the company picked up the film rights to a popular sci-fi TV series. 
 The resulting film, The Quatermass Xperiment  (1955), tells of a spaceship returning to earth with only one being on board &mdash; a monster gestating inside the skin of a crew member. 
 The film was immensely popular and had so clearly struck a chord that Hammer carried out a rethink of its production policy. 
 This led, through X The Unknown  (1957), which parodies the complacency of the authorities towards the radiation threat and Quatermass 2  (1957), in which the visiting monsters come much closer to taking over the world, to the cycle of horror films that started with The Curse of Frankenstein  (1956), moving away from immediate contemporary concerns towards mythological narratives that touched some of the same fears and terrors.  
 BBC cameras record the final appearance of a monster in The Quatermass Xperiment  (1955) 
 But if film executives were to be believed, the majority of the audience was less interested in salving their fears about wars and conflicts ahead than in looking back to the time when Britain had a role to play in the world. 
 Like the crooks pursued by the hero in Calling Bulldog Drummond  (1951), for whom &bquo;life in peacetime seemed unbearably flat&equo;, or the ex-officers who take over their old ship for smuggling runs across the Channel in the Ship that Died of Shame  (1955), or The League of Gentlemen  (1960), for whom robbing a bank promises their &bquo;finest hour&equo;, many filmmakers seemed to feel that there was nothing to do, now the war was over and the hopes of peace had faded, than go back to the site of old glories. 
 &bquo;The H-bomb looms ahead,&equo; remarked the critic William Whitebait, &bquo;and we daren't look at it, we creep back to the lacerating comfort of &bquo;last time&equo;&equo;. 
 From the demonstrations of British pluck and enterprise in The Wooden Horse  (1950), the first of a series of escape pictures, and the celebration of one woman's heroism in the Anna Neagle-starring Odette  (1950), through action films such as The Dam Busters  (1955), The Battle of the River Plate  (1956, Pursuit of the Graf Spee  in US) and Sink the Bismark  (1960), there is a sense of well-known events being played out for an audience that already knew about them. 
 The celebrations of selflessness and sacrifice are much as they were in the wartime films, but this time there seems little point in asserting them, nothing to be argued for. 
 These pictures function as rituals of reassurance, demonstrating that when there was a job to be done, the British got down to it. 
 They have nothing new to say about the war. 
 And when a new note does enter in, it sounds with despair. 
 The British commander who has to bring his team through the desert in Ice Cold in Alex  (1958) seems hysterical and incompetent by comparison with the Dutch South African who accompanies them but is working for the Germans; and the message of Ealing's Dunkirk  (1958) is summarized in one character's closing statement, &bquo;Somebody's made a muck of it but I don't think it's the army.&equo; 
 One understands from these films why critic Gavin Lambert remarked of his departure from England in 1956 that the country &bquo;really seemed in the doldrums, like it had lost the war almost.&equo; 
 Why did Ealing chose to make Dunkirk , about the evacuation of the British Expeditionary Force from the French beaches? 
 Perhaps they saw it as a last call for help to come to a failing Britain. 
 In other war films, however, the purpose is revealed by insistent preachiness, as in Reach for the Sky  (1956), where the story of Douglas Bader, the determined pilot who, despite losing both his legs in an accident, went on to command the air force during the Battle of Britain, is told as a story that &bquo;was not only an example to those in war but is now a source of inspiration to many in peace.&equo; 
 In other areas of filmmaking too, stories seemed to be chosen for the potential they offered for homily. 
 Films about juvenile delinquency, for example, from Cosh Boy  (1952) to Violent Playground  (1958), never explore the inner worlds of their characters, only demonstrate what a terrible threat to organized society such behaviour represents. 
 And the interminable squabbles of the couple in Escapade  (1955) are staged to make the point that expounding the pacifist cause, the main activity of the male member of the pair, isn't enough, and that the only hope for the world rests with their children, untouched by the complex, screwed-up emotions of the older generation. 
 Their eldest son aims to prove this by stealing an aeroplane to gain publicity for his pompous declaration that &bquo;We boys do not wish to kill the children of any other school.&equo; 
 Escapade's  director Philip Leacock specialized in the unsullied emotions of childhood. 
 In The Kidnappers  (1953, The Little Kidnappers  in US), two orphan boys demonstrate their deep needs to a stern grandfather by kidnapping a baby. 
 But more complex emotions creep in at the fringes of the tale, where the grandfather's ostracism of the man his daughter loves leads to several fraught emotional scenes. 
 And much the same process of intensification at the edges goes on in The Spanish Gardener  (1956), where another little boy is prevented by his possessive and emotionally repressed father from developing his relationship with a gardener. 
 The culmination of the drama, an explosion of emotions during a thunderstorm, has parallels in other Rank-financed movies of the time, when the lid comes off and all the emotions that have been barely repressed throughout the film come pouring out as if from some Pandora's box. 
 Such a lightning-spattered ending is found, for example, in Passionate Summer  (1958), where for most of the film the schoolteacher on a Caribbean Island has been keeping at bay the emotions directed towards him by a troubled pupil, the headmaster's wife and an air hostess. 
 Back to wargames &mdash; Jack Lee coaxes the actors in the Wooden Horse  (1950) 
 In these films the sort of sticky emotional conflicts which the production system seemed determined to cleanse from its films fight their way back into the movies. 
 Elsewhere, filmmakers attempted to substitute frenetic drama for intense conflict. 
 Set in places where many things happen, these films followed multiple story lines in a way that clearly anticipates a later staple of TV drama programming. 
 Hospitals were to become a setting later in the decade for &bquo;Doctor&equo; films, &bquo;Carry Ons&equo; and such tepid dramas as Behind the Mask  (1958), but the genre can be traced back to White Corridors  (1951) where, amidst the routine romantic squabbles, and an occasional lecture on the working of the NHS, two strong stories evolve: a researcher develops a drug that will kill infections resistant to penicillin and his lover secures herself a registrar's post against nepotistic competition, by skilfully operating on a patient her rival has misdiagnosed. 
 Front Page Story  (1953) is set in a newspaper office, where a harassed editor played by Jack Hawkins deals with homeless children, a scientist wanting to spill atomic secrets, a journalist's crisis of conscience and a wife who plans to walk out on him. 
 Hawkins' qualities in this sort of role were deployed again ln a film that brought together the American director John Ford and former Ealing writer T. E. B. Clarke, Gideon's Day  (1959, Gideon of Scotland Yard  in US), where he plays a slightly muddled police officer who, in true English fashion, only reveals his mettle under pressure. 
 Ealing's films of the 1950s also deal with communities, not torn apart by inner rivalries but bonded in solidarity against an external aggressor. 
 Increasingly what they came to oppose was the process of change &mdash; social, cultural and economic. 
 By the time the studio came to make The Titfield Thunderbolt  (1953), about a village's attempt to preserve their branch line against nasty entrepreneurs who have set up a bus service, gentle anarchy has given way to nostalgia for Olde England. 
 Balcon's strengthened determination to impose his own world-view on the studio's pictures accounts for the declining ambition of Ealing's production at this time. 
 Arthur Rank was no longer applying pressure on him to make bigger, more ambitious pictures, and Balcon was very much his own man. 
 The films give an increasingly wide berth to messy problems like sexuality and violence and, whereas Ealing's films during and immediately after the war had interrogated what was happening to England, many or those made in the 1950s just don't seem interested. 
 Balcon's desire to avoid &bquo;socially objectionable&equo; subjects and &bquo;to make pictures worthy of that name&equo; (whatever that was supposed to mean) provided a cover for turning the studio's face away from the world. 
 The solidarity and sense of community that had once been Ealing's strength now began to work against it. 
 Filmmakers were rarely imported from outside (Thorold Dickinson, who was allowed in to make Secret People  in 1952, could be regarded as an &bquo;old boy&equo; since he had worked at the studio during Basil Dean's time) and, with five directors responsible for two-thirds of the films made at the studio between 1942 and 1955, there was little competition inside the studio, and no exposure to fresh ideas from outside. 
 With a secure nest under Rank, and a distribution deal through Universal in the US, there was little contact with the marketplace, which could have driven the studio to search out new styles and new areas of subject matter. 
 There had developed, according to art director-turned producer Michael Relph, &bquo;a public school ethos&equo; which &bquo;stopped us growing up&equo;. 
 Attempts from within to knock the dust off Ealing cosiness were crushed by Balcon. 
 Robert Hamer planned to follow Kind Hearts and Coronets  with a sexually-charged film set in the West Indies, with Vivien Leigh in the key role, but this was cancelled two weeks before shooting began and he quit the studio in a huff. 
 Charles Crichton's desire to make a film of Kingsley Amis's Lucky Jim  was vetoed, even though the book is hardly risqu&eacute; or coarse. 
 In fact, the only film director who flourished within the Ealing set-up, by focusing upon the studio's evasions and working sufficiently within the grain for his deviations from it not to be too embarrassingly apparent, was Alexander Mackendrick. 
 There are sometimes signs of strain, as in the clumsy development of a conflict between husband and wife in Mandy  (1952, The Crash of Silence  in US) over whether or not their deaf-and-dumb daughter should be sent to a special school. 
 Nevertheless, the film deploys sounds and images with intense effect as it explores the inner experience of a little girl closed off from the world, for whom her family is a cage tightened around her and preventing her from communicating with the world. 
 Where Whisky Galore  (1948, Tight Little Island  in US) depicts a Scottish community determined to outwit officialdom and salvage the whisky from a shipwrecked boat, The Man in the White Suit  (1951) treads into that tricky area for British filmmakers, industrial relations, to suggest that when workers and management come together, it may have more to do with their own selfish interests than those of the broader community. 
 After the timid The Maggie  (1953, High and Dry  in US), Mackendrick's Ealing oeuvre culminates in The Ladykillers  (1955) where a gang of bank robbers, masquerading as an unlikely string quartet, engages in a battle of wills with an unutterably sweet and totally irritating landlady, symbol of Ealing's (and England's) determination not to think about the modern world, smothering the horrors and the nightmares in gentility.  
 Alexander Mackendrick talks with the ground engineers about Mandy  (1952) 
 The constraints Ealing placed upon Mackendrick were constructive, because they forced him to find original narratives that used Ealing's increasingly stale formulae against itself. 
 William Rose, the American writer of The Ladykillers , went on to write scripts outside Ealing that again deal with England's infatuation with old things, and resistance to change, but distil these through cosy middle-class couples. 
 Although relatively fresh and interesting, neither has anything like the same energy as his screenplay for Mackendrick. 
 Genevieve  (1953), one of Rank's biggest successes of the decade, was directed by another old Ealing hand, Henry Cornelius, who left the studio after making Passport to Pimlico . 
 The vintage car of the title is driven by a married duo who bicker, moan and make love all the way to Brighton, then challenge a less permanent couple to a race back to London. 
 Genevieve wins by driving herself across Westminster Bridge. 
 The fleapit at the centre of another Rose script, The Smallest Show on Earth  (1957, Big Time Operators  in US), directed by Ealing's Basil Dearden, is eventually burnt to the ground by its old commissionaire: &bquo;It were the only way weren't it&equo;, he says to the cooing couple who inherited the place in a town stinking of glue from the local factory, together with staff so lost in the past that they still enjoy looking at Hepworth's Comin&equo; Thro&equo; The Rye . 
 Although they make a go of the cinema for a while, by showing desert pictures and pushing up the heat so that they can sell cool refreshments, their only aim is to get back to middle-class life, but with enough money to avoid any more &bquo;petty, stupid problems.&equo; 
 The indictment of British nostalgia is more amiable than sharp, and the ideas are much less interesting than anything in Mackendrick's films. 
 But despite Mackendrick's creative vigour, Ealing didn't flourish at the end of the decade. 
 In 1955 Balcon sold the studios to the BBC to resolve a longstanding debt problem, moving his production unit on to MGM and then ABPC, but failing to find at either place the sort of working context that would re-energize his production programme. 
 Everywhere else, however, the late 1950s saw filmmakers of every hue turning to comedy as they struggled t to audiences and prevent their defection to television. 
 &bquo;It is safer to make comedies,&equo; explained Ken Annakin in 1958, &bquo;because they are the only pictures which, in Britain, bring back any profit at all to the people who put up the money.&equo;  
 Joan Greenwood and Alec Guinness in a quiet scene from The Man in the White suit  (1951) 
 The same scene before the cameras, and the spectators 
 Desperate film projectionist &mdash; Bill Travers gazes on Peter Sellers' confusion in the Smallest Show on Earth  (1957) 
 Thus Launder and Gilliatt launched their &bquo;Saint Trinians&equo; series with The Belles of Saint Trinians  (1954) and continued to produce films about mischievious schoolgirls until 1966. 
 They also made such one-off comedies as The Green Man  (1957), in which a vacuum cleaner salesman sets out to prevent a sour-faced captain of industry from being blown up. 
 The Boultings went from thrillers and melodramas to initiate a series of often strained films making fun of British institutions. 
 These take in the law ( Brothers in Law , 1956), the redbrick universities ( Lucky Jim , 1957), the foreign office ( Carlton-Browne of the FO , 1958) and the trade unions ( I'm All Right Jack , 1959). 
 The latter gains its incisive bite from a performance by Peter Sellers as the Machiavellian union chief Fred Kite, but too many of the other Boulting films take facile swipes at absent-minded professors or barristers, and ignorant, lazy bureaucrats. 
 In the same year as Genevieve , Rank found a bankable comedy series in the &bquo;Doctor&equo; series initiated by Doctor in the House  (1953), and Norman Wisdom introduced his winning blend of slapstick and sentiment with Trouble in Store . 
 Later came the &bquo;Carry On&equo; films, launched by Carry On Sergeant  (1958), films as defiantly un-Ealing as one could conceive, with their emphasis on the inability of institutions (army, hospital, school, etc.) to contain the animal natures and the sheer potential for vulgarity of the humans within. 
 In thus celebrating anarchy, the &bquo;Carry Ons&equo; put themselves as far outside critical respectability as the contemporary films being made by Hammer. 
 Some of the more interesting comedy films were made outside these generic contexts. 
 Top Secret  (1952), for example, touches on Cold War issues with its story of a sanitary engineer abducted to the Soviet Union in the belief that he is a bomb expert holding the secrets of a devastating new weapon. 
 All innocence, he calls out &bquo;Good old England. 
 Up the Empire!&equo; to a group of communist students from the UK gathered at the bar of his hotel, promises to do something about the &bquo;blooming awful&equo; state of Soviet plumbing and ends up making a deal with Stalin with the insouciance of George Formby addressing himself to Hitler. 
 Later in the same decade, when British filmmakers had lost their interest in international affairs, the same actor, George Cole, plays the inadequate gang-leader in Too Many Crooks  (1959), a film whose insights into the cold realities of contemporary marriage derives from the story of a kidnapped wife who plots revenge when her husband shows himself less than interested in paying over her ransom. 
 The film contains an extraordinary kidnapping scene involving a broken-down hearse and the not-very-firmly-sealed coffin that contains the victim. 
 Whereas the cinema of the late 1940s had forced audiences to confront the realities of post-war Britain, the mainstream films produced at the end of the following decade diverted their anxieties into laughter. 
 That was just how the circuit bosses liked things, believing that the best way to hold on to their audience was through &bquo;family entertainment&equo;, and arguing through the Cinematograph Exhibitors Association (CEA) that filmmakers should avoid treating themes and incidents that &bquo;were offensive to the reasonable taste and standards of those whose patronage was necessary to the health and future of the industry.&equo; 
 Although an X certificate had been introduced by the BBFC in 1951, only six such films were shown on the Rank circuit between 1951 and 1957. 
 Things hotted up thereafter, but the company's Annual Report of 1960 complained that X-films were being misused &bquo;to the detriment of cinema entertainment.&equo; 
 This assumption that films had to be bland to be entertaining, and refusal to acknowledge that movies could usefully enable audiences to deal with fears and nightmares, went along with an unwillingness to acknowledge that audience tastes and sensitivities were being shifted by television. 
 At every level, the major companies took a stand against the new medium. 
 Films were made which attacked the small screen. 
 Ealing's Meet Mr Lucifer  (1953) defined the new medium's effect on audiences as largely negative and, by distinguishing the communal address of cinema from television's attention to the individual, established a line of attack that was to be much used later. 
 Rank's Simon and Laura  (1955) pursued a different tack, mocking TV for the phoniness of its images of life through the story of a married couple in a TV soap, who are represented as cooing doves on the screen when in reality they always bicker and squabble. 
 Cinema, the film asserts, presents the more full-blooded experience. 
 It was a strange position for a Rank film to adopt and, after the launch of the Sunday night series, &bquo;Armchair Theatre&equo;, in 1956, television presented dramas with more grit in each minute than many feature films had in their whole duration. 
 Also, through documentaries and slots on magazine programmes, the medium opened up questions about class, colour and sex that many filmmakers seemed convinced could not interest an audience. 
 Inevitably, television's influence seeped into movies. 
 TV's initiative with Quatermass  brought two successful movies to Hammer and a change in its production policy, while sitcoms like Inn for Trouble  and Whacko!  became cheap features. 
 Films like Basil Dearden's Sapphire  (1959), dealing with racial prejudice and mixed Marriages, and Victim  (1961), which cast Dirk Bogarde as a homosexual barrister who decides to take a stand against social hypocrisy, would not have been possible if television had not already put such issues on the agenda. 
 Nor was the movement all one way. 
 Norman Wisdom was snapped by up Rank after he had proved what he could do on TV, and the cosy cop series Dixon of Dock Green  (1955&ndash;76) was clearly a lineal descendant of Ealing's The Blue Lamp . 
 These interconnections argued for a close symbiotic relationship between the two media. 
 The film companies, however, were pledged to fight the new medium to the last ditch. 
 Rank's policy of having nothing to do with television prevented Balcon from becoming involved in any of the bids to secure a commercial television franchise in 1955, and ensured that the film industry had no stake in the new medium. 
 And in 1958, when over eight million households had television licences, the various trade associations formed the Film Industry Defence Organization (FIDO) in an attempt to ensure that none of the nation's producers sold their films to television. 
 This really was an attempt to bolt the stable door after the horses had bolted. 
 Korda died in 1956, but he had sold a series of his films to ABC and, following the presale of London Films' version of Richard III  (1955) to a US network, had announced plans to develop films for pay-TV. 
 Korda had seen that producers would have to look to television as an alternative source of revenue. 
 FIDO simply ignored that fact, even as admissions slumped in 1957 to just above the 900-million mark. 
 Rank and ABPC were still the powers in the land but, when it came to 
 British filmmaking, they really weren't very interested anymore: their cinema revenues were considerably more important to them than film production. 
 Therefore, they decided to put their energy into a battle they could only lose, and not just because of television but also because they did so little on their own account to improve the cinemas, and to provide an environment which would lure potential audiences away from their increasingly comfortable homes. 
 Their economies ensured that the fleapits would remain forever fleapits, until the time came for them to close. 
 It was an uninspiring policy. 
 Dirty words and Pop 
 Given the timidity of British cinema in the late 1950s, it is easy to understand the anger with which Lindsay Anderson blasted British filmmaking for being &bquo;snobbish, anti-intelligent, emotionally inhibited, wilfully blind to the conditions and problems of the present, dedicated to an out-of-date, exhausted national ideal.&equo; 
 For the filmmakers of Anderson's generation, there was a double frustration: both that there was no vital British cinema they could celebrate as critics, and that the film industry had shrunk to the point where it offered no easy point of entry into the industry. 
 Finding it impossible to break into movies after the production slump of the 1940s, before television offered an alternative route to aspiring filmmakers, people like Anderson, Tony Richardson and Karel Reisz worked instead within sponsored documentaries, while writing about the sort of passionate, personal filmmaking that seemed to be possible in France, Italy, even India, but not in Britain. 
 Free Cinema, which had Anderson as its spokesman, was always more certain of what it was against than what it stood for. 
 He was brilliant at invective, and making general statements about the need to communicate a politically responsible set of values, but neither he nor any of his friends were screenwriters, nor were they motivated to work with writers on ideas that were their own. 
 Despite their rousing calls for a cinema that was &bquo;vital, illuminating,&equo; and their polemic against a national cinema divorced from contemporary realities, they turned to a series of novels set in the English provinces for material out or which to make their first movies. 
 Nor did this brief fashion for working-class subjects derive directly from their critical campaigns, except insofar as Richardson had directed Look Back in Anger  on the stage in 1956, and that production marked the cultural watershed from which a fashion for &bquo;realism&equo; seemed to flow. 
 It was Jack Clayton, a director trained in the traditional film industry, who persuaded Romulus Films to finance a version of John Braine's Room at the Top , a representative sample of the disillusioned provincial novel. 
 The resulting film, released in 1958, centres on a bright, ambitious young man, living in a charmless northern town, who marries out of his working-class background in a cynical pitch to advance himself. 
 The film was a big success, partly because of its openness about sex (made possible by the appointment of John Trevelyan to head up the BBFC), but also because the hero's class resentment brought to the surface emotions that British cinema normally repressed.  
 Jack Clayton and Laurence Harvey discuss whether there's Room at the top  (1958) 
 Clayton's film cleared the way for a cycle of films with proletarian heroes who, for all their bluster, see their dreams shrivel in melancholy and their little rebellions crash to the ground. 
 Defeat is built into the genre. 
 Typical is Arthur Seton in Saturday Night and Sunday Morning  (1960), described by the film's director Karel Reisz, as &bquo;a sad person, terribly limited in his sensibilities, narrow in his ambitions and a bloody fool into the bargain&equo; who ends up throwing a stone towards the housing estate that is his final destination, declaring with more bravado than honesty, &bquo;It won't be the last one I'll throw.&equo; 
 Vic Brown in John Schlesinger's A Kind of Loving  (1962) settles for telly-watching inanity within marriage, while Billy Liar in the same director's 1963 film turns away from the girl who offers him the chance to fulfil his ambitions in London. 
 The same actor, Tom Courtenay, plays the Borstal boy in Tony Richardson's The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner  (1962) who loses the race he's trained for as a way to spite the governor. 
 The directors of these films, tourists in working-class cultures for which they felt little sympathy, saw only what they wanted to see. 
 Worried about the impact of television on social habits, and disillusioned with British life, they constructed films depicting the destruction of traditional cultural forms, the dead-end nature of the proletarian life and the tawdriness of sexual relationships leading inevitably to closure in marriage. 
 The films had a sense of urgency that the rest of mainstream British cinema at the time largely lacked, but their directors didn't have enough personal contact with the lives of their characters to offer visions that rang true. 
 Standing apart from these films is Lindsay Anderson's feature d&eacute;but, This Sporting Life  (1963), where the director's jaundiced view of the world seeps into every frame of the film. 
 The prevailing mood is disgust; at the pathetic inarticulacy of the great ape on a rugby field, Frank Machin, and the blocked emotions of his landlady and lover, who has given up hoping for anything since her husband's death. 
 The film that results from the clash of wills between these two characters is a story of desperation that demonstrates the Gothic aspects of Anderson's Sensibility. 
 All the more pity, therefore, that, in his sweeping dismissals of British cinema where there seemed nothing to praise beyond Humphrey Jennings' poetic documentaries, he refused any engagement with the darker elements in the native cinematic culture. 
 He was sufficiently confused by the English way of repressing emotion to characterise kind Hearts and Coronets  as characteristic of Ealing movies in being emotionally quite frozen,&equo; and so fastidiously determined to stay aloof from bland commercialism that he took no interest in the horror genre (even though his later use of the Frankenstein story in his 1982 film Britannia Hospital  suggests how much of a contribution he might have made in this area).  
 Karel Reisz on the water to film a scene from Saturday Night and Sunday Morning  (1960) 
 Lindsay Anderson talks to Karel Reisz, his producer on This Sporting Life  (1963) 
 &bquo;Why no films,&equo; asked Anderson in 1958, &bquo;on Teddy Boys, nuclear tests, loyalty of scientists, bureaucracy, etc.&equo; 
 Why, one might ask in reply, did Anderson never develop stories that engaged with just these issues, even when Joseph Losey, an American who came to Britain in the early 1950s as a refugee from the communist witch-hunts, could deal with them in an assignment for Hammer. 
 The Damned  (1961, These are the Damned  in US) compares the violence of contemporary youth to the behaviour of a scientist who has locked up a group of children for experiments. 
 Losey's films during the 1950s and into the 1960s did just what Anderson seemed to be asking British films to do, posing questions about contemporary society in strong, engaging narratives. 
 Films such as The Sleeping Tiger  (1954), where a psychologist's efforts to reform the mugger he's picked up off the street are subverted by his own drives and the desires of his wife, The Criminal  (1960, The Concrete Jungle  in US), in which Stanley Baker plays a loner trapped between the violent prison system and the criminal underworld, or The Servant  (1963), in which butler is pitched against master, focus on tensions in British society much more interesting than anything opened up by Anderson's contemporaries. 
 The tepidity of most British cinema during the 1950s made Anderson resistant to the values of commercial filmmaking, and this cut him off from the possibility of developing his critical argument through filmmaking. 
 A concordat between Anderson and the horror genre was ruled out not only by Andemson's fastidiousness, but by the inability of Hammer Studios to provide an environment in which filmmakers with a strongly defined sense of individuality could flourish. 
 An iconoclast such as Anderson could never have settled into directing films about mummies, werewolves and vampires, and Hammer was too much a market-led company to encourage fresh approaches to the monstrous. 
 James Carreras, its salesman, would pitch projects to distributors on the basis of title and poster. 
 If they liked the idea, the film would go to script stage. 
 If they didn't, it would be dropped. 
 In this way, Hammer became a victim of its own phenomenal success, always going for the big thrills and unable to get away with offering anything less than what was expected from a &bquo;Hammer&equo; film. 
 Only for brief moments did the studio venture away from the formulae and try out different ideas, even when, as with The Damned , the studio cut the film in defiance of its director's wishes. 
 Among a series of films designed to cash in on the success of Hitchcock's Psycho  (1960), for example, was Seth Holt's The Nanny  (1965), made with the visual flair of his earlier Hammer picture, Taste of Fear  (1961), and telling the powerful tale of two sisters, both dependent in their own way on the woman who brought them up, who pay no attention to the declarations of their son and nephew that it was nanny who killed his sister and now wants to kill him.  
 Joseph Losey prepares a moving scene for The Sleeping tiger  (1954) 
 The success of Hammer encouraged other companies into working the same seam. 
 Anglo-Amalgamated, for example, enabled Michael Powell to make an astonishing, if short-lived, comeback with Peeping Tom  (1959), which was scripted by Hammer hand Leo Marks and follows the murderous career of a seemingly gentle young focus-puller who has been psychologically damaged by his father's pain experiments and gets his kicks from filming women in their death agonies, inflicted by the bayonet at the end of his tripod. 
 In the middle of the decade, Michael Reeves stamped his mark on the horror genre with Witchfinder General  (1968, The Conqueror Worm  in US), his last film made at the age of 23 for Tigon, set amidst the witch hunts of the English Civil War. 
 By the late 1960s, Hammer had ceased to become an effective production centre but its influence was still at work. 
 Films like Ken Russell's The Devils  (1971), with its hysteria and erotic frenzies, or Nic Roeg's Don't Look Now  (1973) would not have been possible without the developments in Gothic instigated at Hammer's Bray Studios (although Roeg had also worked, as a cameraman, on Roger Corman's The Masque of the Red Death  (1964)). 
 Both Roeg and Russell could engage with popular cinematic forms in a way that the directors around Anderson could not. 
 Reisz has recalled that when he broke ranks and made a melodrama, Night Must Fall  (1964), he was accused of selling out and going commercial. 
 This aesthetic refusal went along with an unwillingness to develop a strategy for ensuring a continued capacity to make their sort of films. 
 Woodfall, the company set up by Tony Richardson and John Osborne to exploit the profits from Look Back in Anger , with the aim of proving &bquo;that good films, ones that showed British life as it really is, could be made cheaply&equo;, nevertheless had no particular strategy for trying to bring down the budgets of films from the &pound;100,000 or so they were costing to the &pound;30,000 level that, for example, French filmmakers worked to. 
 Thanks to American investment, Woodfall was to flourish, but at considerable cost to its original brave intentions. 
 The lack of any programme for changing the industry is all the more striking given the obstacles that the likes of John Davis persistently put in their way. 
 Davis didn't think much of the &bquo;kitchen sink&equo; films, and asserted that a realistic minimum budget for a first feature was in the order of &pound;250,000 as a way to justify his blocking their exhibition on his company's circuit. 
 Rank, it is said, had to be &bquo;blackmailed&equo; into showing Woodfall's The Entertainer  (1960), even though Laurence Olivier had the lead role. 
 And it was proving almost impossible to secure any exhibition for Saturday Night and Sunday Morning  until a booking became available at a London showcase cinema, and the audience turnout proved this was a film with legs. 
 And Peter Brook's powerful adaptation of William Golding's Lord of the Flies  was a long time on the shelf before securing a release in 1963. 
 As Rank and ABPC's interest in production declined, their influence over exhibition in Britain increased. 
 Everyone was closing their the theatres, but the independents and smaller circuits closed proportionally more, thus shifting the proportion of the box office take in favour of the conglomerates which owned the larger and more salubrious houses. 
 In 1958, Rank had amalgamated the Odeon and Gaumont circuits, in defiance of an earlier undertaking not to do so. 
 The result was that producers wishing to secure a reasonable return from the British market had to persuade either the Rank or the ABPC booker to take their film. 
 With only two circuits to book, and programmes changing less frequently than hitherto, fewer films were required. 
 And while both conglomerates needed independent producers to supply them with quota films (they showed 49 British first features between them in 1963), the supply was sufficiently buoyant that they could pick and choose. 
 Even the films of Allied Filmmakers, a company formed by Bryan Forbes, Richard Attenborough, Basil Dearden and Michael Relph with backing from Rank, sometimes found it difficult to secure a circuit booking. 
 Peter Brook takes a child's eye view of the Lord of the Flies  (1963) 
 In 1963, many producers were having as much difficulty securing screenings for their films as their predecessors had in the early 1920s. 
 British Lion, the independents' major distribution channel, had 18 films awaiting release, a situation David Kingsley, the company's managing director, blamed on the hostility of the circuits to its policy of dividing films between the two of them. 
 However, the sort of routine farces and imitations of earlier successes being handled by British Lion were hardly a match for spectacular films like El Cid  (1961), Dr No (1962), The Longest Day  (1962) and Lawrence of Arabia  (1962) that were now coming down the line from American companies, with a &bquo;British&equo; tag on them. 
 It was a peculiarly difficult time for the independents. 
 The contracting industry of the 1950s had not nurtured new talent or new ideas, as happened in the 1930s and 1940s, so that, apart from the Free Cinema directors, it was mostly a case of the same old people trying to make films. 
 The need to compete with television, and with the sort of films the Americans were making, meant that producers had to make spectaculars, which they couldn't afford to do, or the sort of brave and adventurous pictures that the circuits were reluctant to accommodate. 
 And there was little hope that government intervention would bring about a more flexible cinema industry. 
 The Monopolies Commission was, in fact, asked to report into &bquo;the supply of films for exhibition in cinemas&equo; in 1963. 
 Its 1966 report, while confirming the claim that the &bquo;uniquely rigid&equo; two-release system &bquo;discouraged the production of certain types of films&equo;, concluded that there were &bquo;formidable and probably expensive practical problems in the way of adopting any of the proposals&equo; put forward for ameliorating the situation. 
 Something must be done, but nothing could be done, seems a fair summary of the commission's conclusion. 
 The lack of strong leadership in the independent sector reflected the absence of any new producer talent. 
 It was the veteran Michael Balcon who blocked Sydney Box's takeover of British Lion in late 1963, and had the unenviable task of trying to put an end to faction within the board. 
 And it was Balcon who, as part-time chairman, steered the policies of Bryanston, the main source of independent finance. 
 Seeing that the independents would be slowly strangled so long as they relied exclusively upon the British circuits, he sought to establish connections to Hollywood. 
 In 1961 he formed a link-up between Bryanston and an American company, Seven Arts, designed to build a US foothold and enable Bryanston to finance more ambitious projects. 
 Whereas the company had formerly been limited to films which cost between &pound;150,000 and 200,000, it could now stretch up to &pound;700,000. 
 The problem for Balcon and the Ealing cronies who mostly peopled the Bryanston board was how, after years of looking inwards to British themes, to define the international film. 
 In the event, they entrusted Alexander Mackendrick with a colourful story, Sammy Going South  (1963, A Boy Ten Feet Tall  in US), about the journey of a small boy, orphaned by an air-raid on his Port Said home, who crosses Africa on his own to find relatives in the south. 
 It's an intriguing, nicely-made film, but hardly calculated to excite the contemporary audience (even though John Davis would approve of its family entertainment value) or connect with the contemporary cultural ferment. 
 The pop explosion that eclipsed Sammy Going South  at the box office was the end of the road for Bryanston, and Balcon's career in commercial filmmaking. 
 Bryanston was sold to the TV company Associated Rediffusion in 1965 and the whole rickety infrastructure of an independent British film industry was simply swept under by waves or American finance, with AFM ceasing production in 1964 after Bryan Forbes' ponderous Seance on a Wet Afternoon . 
 The directors, however, were to flourish. 
 Thanks to American backing, they no longer had to worry about the small size of the British market, the limitations of the native cinematic culture or their responsibility to show Britain on the screen. 
 American companies took away all their troubles, offering substantial budgets, 100 per cent financing and access to world markets. 
 It was a fool's paradise, but they weren't to know that, and it was hardly surprising that few worried much about the maintenance of British-financed production. 
 By 1967, some 90 per cent of the films made in Britain were backed by American companies. 
 Established British companies had exploited the first whiff of pop vitality, with ABPC putting the saccharine personality of Cliff Richard through his paces in The Young Ones  (1961), a let's-have-a-show musical where all possibility of an interesting inter-generation clash is defused by the fact that its hero works for, and adores, his father, the property developer who wants to destroy the youth club; and Summer Holiday  (1962), in which Cliff and the Shadows drive a London bus to Rome, pursued by the mother of the teen star they are thought to have kidnapped. 
 But it was an American company, United Artists, which put together the talents of Richard Lester, a London-based American who had acquired fast-cutting wizardry on live TV shows, and a phenomenon far bigger than Cliff, the Beatles, for A Hard Day's Night  (1964). 
 Since setting up UA's London office in 1961, George Ornstein had already launched the &bquo;James Bond&equo; series with Dr No  (1962), From Russia With Love  (1963) and Goldfinger  (1964), establishing the world of glamour, action and intrigue in which the neo-thug Bond moved, each time taking on an evil villain bent on destroying and dominating the world, but always finding time to tryst with beautiful girls in exotic locations. 
 Ornstein also snatched Tony Richardson's Tom Jones  (1963) from under the nose of Bryanston, sealing the British company's fate and bringing UA a considerable return on an investment of only &dollar;1.3 million. 
 In March 1965 UA announced record profits. 
 After that, there was no holding back the flow of American capital into the British industry. 
 All the majors and two of the mini-majors set up production subsidiaries in London. 
 This was the ultimate culmination of all the measures since the 1927 Cinematograph Film Act that had been designed to involve American finance in British films. 
 The US companies hoped they had found a new seam of commercially-viable movies, but none thought too deeply about what they were buying into. 
 There was no deep pool of directorial talent to be drawn on, even though television was about to produce such interesting new faces as John Boorman and Ken Russell; there was no genre of pictures, outside the Hammer films, which had international appeal. 
 Nor had there been any sort of cultural rethink sufficient to justify the confidence American companies were now placing in British filmmakers. 
 The pop style of Tom Jones  was a development of Richardson's magpie approach to cinema aesthetics, already evident in The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner , even drawing upon some pantomime elements from the &bquo;Carry On&equo; films. 
 But the cinema Americans were interested in was the antithesis of the Free Cinema mode. 
 Where the early films of Reisz, Schlesinger and Richards had analyzed a class-ridden society, they were now being asked to celebrate classlessness. 
 Where the old cinematic heroes had beaten their heads against the wall in frustration at the limited range of possibilities offered to them, the new culture celebrated limitless potential. 
 Where the Free Cinema films articulated an animus against television and the pressure of mass culture on &bquo;authentic, cultural values, the new mode adopted styles from television advertisements. 
 And where the previous emphasis was on realism, the new approach emphasized fantasy and knowing nods to the audience. 
 The shift was not wholly imposed from the outside. 
 The two modes fight it out in Schlesinger's Billy Liar , where the hero escapes from the constraints of life in an undertaking business by fantasizing himself as variously a soldier, Winston Churchill, a gunman mowing down his family or an aristocrat living with obliging parents whose behaviour is strikingly different from that of the real screeching proletarians. 
 The summons he receives from a free-floating blonde &mdash; &bquo;Leave &bquo;em, Billy, they're not worth it. 
 The whole place isn't worth it. 
 You buy a ticket and get on a train. 
 That's all you have to do&equo; &mdash; has been read as a summons for a general change in British cinema. 
 But the shift in focus involved in the journey south did not necessarily reposition the directors who had once rediscovered northern grime into a world which they could explore with sympathy and understanding. 
 When Julie Christie, that blonde in Billy Liar , appears as the fashion model of the British-financed Darling  (1965), Schlesinger remains as distant from his central character, a woman who plays with the emotions of many men and destroys her own happiness by her quest for a good time, as he had from Vic or Billy. 
 What could directors who had drawn stories from the tensions in English society make films about when the sources of finance were no longer interested in &bquo;England&equo;, only in spy stories and lineal descendants of James Bond? 
 The dilemma is particularly evident in the films of Joseph Losey, who could create a masterpiece like The Servant  about the country's class structure, but seemed all at sea with his Bond spoof, Modesty Blaise  (1966). 
 There simply isn't any dramatic, conflict in a story about a purported villain who wears a Beatle cap, drinks from a huge glass with fish in it and gazes out from his island home on the great blue sea as he waits for his pursuers, a pair of handsome would-be lovers who sing songs like &bquo;We could of, we should of, perhaps we can. 
 It was as if to prove that it wasn't England that had changed that Losey went on to make Accident  (1967), a powerful triangle drama involving two very different Oxford academics and their exotic pupil, financed from English sources. 
 Lindsay Anderson showed his isolation from the Hollywood rush with If &hellip; (1968). 
 Set in a public school, it was a passionate call to arms against national institutions that stifled the individual's potential, and Anderson represented the films as a deliberate challenge to the new aesthetics: 
 The more what we might call trendy or eccentric or showy technique has tended to become in the last few years, the more I have felt I wanted to try and make films with as much simplicity and as much directness as possible. 
 It's the flashiness that makes so many of the British films of the mid-1960s almost unwatchable today. 
 Too many of them are visual firework displays without an emotional centre, or a coherent narrative structure. 
 The New Wave films that do work tend to be those built around a single, larger-than-life character, like Tom Jones  or Alfie  (1966), in which Michael Caine plays a cockney Don Juan who &bquo;don't believe in making anyone unhappy, not if you don't have to do it&equo; but is forever breaking the hearts of young girls, until the sight of one of his middle-aged victims going through an abortion forces him into repentance. 
 The formula can be extended to a pop group, as in Lester's Beatles films, or Boorman's Catch Us If You Can  (1965) centred on the Dave Clark Five, but it looks more than a little shaky when applied to a more complex, not to say maudlin, character like that written by Shelagh Delaney for Albert Finney in Charlie Bubbles  (1967).  
 Joseph Losey enjoys himself with Monica Vitti while filming Modesty Blaise  (1966) 
 John Schlesinger makes sure he's in control of Darling  (1965) 
 Under their new paymasters, filmmakers were no longer interested in the sort of inner tensions that work at the heart of the more intense and exciting British films. 
 Largely as a result, they had lost the ability to construct complex and resonant narratives. 
 There is a formlessness to the films of the period, which becomes most apparent in such big films as Richardson's The Charge of the Light Brigade  (1968), which culminates in one of the greatest anti-climaxes of cinema history, or Isadora  (1969), where the dancer's sublimely silly death offers a decisive, but hardly stirring, conclusion to the film's chronological narrative of her stormy loves, ideas about dancing and travels through Europe. 
 As historical re-creation or biography, these films were interesting, as cinema they were nowhere. 
 This drift towards incoherence can be seen also in the work of Dick Lester, the most &bquo;pop&equo; director of the decade. 
 For all that The Mouse on the Moon  (1963) is a slight film, its satirical swipes at the unprogressive nature of British institutions and the nation's difficulty in coming to terms with its global insignificance do find their target. 
 The film shows a small state under the benign tutelage of Margaret Rutherford, pitching to compete with the Russians and the Americans in the space race. 
 When this attempt by pseudo-Britain succeeds, the real British look desperately for evidence of their own national achievement in the first moon landing, and find it in the fact that one of the astronauts is wearing a British watch: &bquo;This is a great day for us. 
 Let no one say we are lagging behind.&equo; 
 While some of the same satirical zest is evident in The Bed Sitting Room  (1969), Lester's chronicle of a post-holocaust world where a stunned Ralph Richardson imagines he is turning into a bedsitter and a doctor tries to keep the old traditions alive by having someone read the BBC News, and the film shows evidence of a superabundant imagination, the narrative is too unfocused for the satirical barbs to hit home, and the result is often tedious to watch. 
 The Americans came to London and invested large amounts of money in local film production, but put nothing into the creative infrastructure. 
 They rode a wave for a while, thinking they saw a pool of talent that could be exploited and a cultural scene rich in potential stories which, together with the relative cheapness of British film production, would be enough to guarantee success. 
 They poured money into British films without doing anything to ensure the production boom they started would develop roots. 
 And while British filmmakers began to believe in the &bquo;decline of Hollywood&equo; as their guarantee that the increased popularity of their pictures would be permanent, they weren't disposed to tap the Americans on the shoulder and suggest that perhaps they should start thinking about film schools, new talents programmes, script competitions or anything of that sort.  
 Karel reisz in the water to direct Vanessa Redgrave in Isadora  (1968) 
 Spike Milligan and Dick Lester wonder whether there's life after the holocaust in The Bed Sitting Room  (1969) 
 Distinctive directors did emerge at the end of the decade. 
 The new talent came exclusively from television, with the exception of Nicolas Roeg, a cameraman who made his directorial d&eacute;but with Donald Cammell on Performance  (1970), about the weird results of a meeting between a strong-arm gangster and a drop-out pop star. 
 In TV, where films were being produced on a regular basis, ranging from the sort of imaginative documentary shorts produced for Huw Wheldon's Monitor  programme to feature-length plays, aspiring filmmakers could try out ideas, take advice from their peers and put enough films through the cameras to develop their own ideas on what they wanted to make films about, and how they would go about it. 
 Such opportunities were no longer available within the film industry. 
 Documentaries were the training ground for John Boorman, who went off to Hollywood after making his feature d&eacute;but with Catch Us If You Can . 
 Peter Watkins made his first feature, Privilege  (1967), for an American company, after his astonishing depiction of what would happen if a nuclear bomb fell on Kent, The War Game  (1965), had been banned by the BBC. 
 Another TV graduate was Ken Loach, whose UA-financed Kes  (1969), about a deprived schoolboy who finds some meaning to his life by befriending a kestrel, is a remarkable indicator of how far a Hollywood studio could be persuaded to go in looking for sellable films after the pop bubble had collapsed. 
 Another significant filmmaker who came out of television was Ken Russell, who continued working on his imaginative TV interpretations of the lives of such composers as Elgar, Delius and Richard Strauss while making his first, uneven, forays into cinema with French Dressing  (1963) and Billion Dollar Brain  (1965). 
 He went on to assert his first mature, outrageous, filmmaking style with a D. H. Lawrence adaptation, Women in Love  (1969), The Music Lovers  (1970), covering the life of Tchaikovsky, and The Devils , an extraordinary collage made up of images of ecstasy, violence and cruelty. 
 Ken Russell took the removal of restraint and stiff-upper-lip repression that American finance had encouraged and turned it into a distinctive aesthetic style. 
 His films were popular enough to ensure that he could attract US cash well into the 1970s. 
 Elsewhere, however, Britain's imitation of Hollywood was proving to be built on ground more insecure than the area around the San Andreas fault. 
 Penelope Houston had pointed out the dangers early on, in the pages of Sight and Sound : 
 This is picture-by-picture finance, depending on such chancy things as the tastes of producers and directors, or a type of story in vogue at the moment (a spy boom brings filmmakers to Europe; a Western boom could drive them home). 
 But there was nothing for filmmakers to do but plunge on, grab every chance that came their way and hope for the best. 
 No easy way could be seen to re-establish British finance for production.  
 Ken Russell in rocky landscape for The Devils  (1970) 
 Things weren't going well for the American studios, either at home or in the UK, and they became increasingly desperate, hunting around for the winning formula some had lost and others never found. 
 Universal was the worst case, making 13 British pictures at a cost of &dollar;30 million, not one of which was a substantial hit. 
 And, as the ideas became harder to find, film budgets spiralled upwards. 
 It cost United Artists a substantial &dollar;6.5 million to make The Charge of the Light Brigade . 
 Two years later, when MGM had the not-so-bright idea of remaking Goodbye Mr Chips  as a musical, and UA tried to bring back the British war film with The Battle of Britain  (1970), the bill for each picture was something like &dollar;12 million. 
 The films weren't doing business, the unprofitable US studios were being gobbled up by large conglomerates and &bquo;rationalized&equo;, changes in US fiscal policy implemented in 1967 to help in funding the Vietnam war now discouraged investment by US companies abroad, and the American unions had initiated a campaign in 1968 to &bquo;combat foreign production by American producers.&equo; 
 Some sort of retrenchment in US financing of British films was inevitable, especially given that American directors were now making films like Bonnie and Clyde  (1967), The Graduate  (1967), Easy Rider  (1969), or Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid  (1969), with the sort of freshness and sense of a connection to aspects of contemporary life which mattered to audiences, and these embarrassed British films off the screen. 
 Fox jumped ship after Modesty Blaise  in 1966. 
 Paramount closed down its London office in 1968, declaring that &bquo;we now feel that by coordinating and controlling our production activities in Hollywood we can effectively control a programme that will continue to draw from a talent pool all around the world.&equo; 
 The following year Universal closed up shop and MGM shuttered its Borehamwood Studios, disgracefully leaving Fred Zinneman to look after the bills for a cancelled production of Andr&eacute; Malraux's Man's Fate . 
 The director spent two years in the courts before the American company agreed to honour its commitments. 
 None of this meant that American companies were no longer interested in financing British filmmakers or even British ideas, but they were no longer committed to doing so, and didn't expect to be sufficiently involved to justify keeping offices in London. 
 Paramount, in fact, planned a British directors company, bringing together the talents of Reisz, Clayton, Schlesinger and Peter Yates, but dropped the idea when most of these directors emigrated to the US anyway. 
 Even as American investment slumped from &pound;100 million annually at its peak to around &pound;30 million at the beginning or the 1970s, the US companies were still doing a lot more for the British film industry than the British seemed able to do for themselves. 
 But if there wasn't much British money around for film investment, there were also clear signs of dwindling creative energy. 
 The de line of Hammer, the only British company to have benefited from the influx f American cash, was accelerated by the abandonment of its Bray Studios in 1968. 
 The company's films were increasingly expensive, but less and less commercially successful. 
 And although Bryan Forbes made a stab at backing British filmmakers as head or production for EMI, the company that had taken over ABPC in 1969, announcing 14 projects within months of taking over his new post, the line-up did not give the impression that he was in touch with any new sources of cinematic excitement. 
 The most coherent films to emerge from Elstree during this time were both set in the Edwardian era, Losey's glorious The Go-Between  (1970) and The Railway Children  (1970), with the latter aiming at that much-lamented but largely-departed family audience. 
 Of the contemporary subjects, And Soon The Darkness  (1970) was a determinedly routine chiller, while Mr Forbush and the Penguins  (1971), in which John Hurt alternatively woos Hayley Mills or talks to Antarctic penguins, is simply awful. 
 Meanwhile Nat Cohen, who had brought his Anglo-Amalgamated company under the EMI umbrella, brought to the company the slick thriller, Get Carter  (1971), directed by Mike Hodges, another TV graduate. 
 Cohen, it seemed, was much more in touch with the mood of audiences than Forbes and, when the latter resigned on 25 March, 1971, he took over EMI's production programme. 
 &bquo;I think if I had been allowed to go on, there would still be a British film industry,&equo; Forbes said in the late 1980s. 
 He was probably deceiving himself. 
 It was not only that the industry needed propping up, but the whole film culture had to be rebuilt, and Forbes had clearly not grasped the scale of what needed to be done. 
 The creative ferment set going at the beginning of the decade had petered out, as directors like Reisz and Richardson lost their sense of direction. 
 The writers whose work they had drawn upon had never become part of the filmmaking community. 
 While directors like Ken Russell and Nic Roeg carried on along their own idiosyncratic paths, and many of the directors who had flourished in the 1960s packed their bags for the trip to LA, there were no indications that those left behind had begun to face up to the economic realities of British film production, or what would have to be done to patch up the damage done to the craft of filmmaking, more particularly screenwriting, during the dead times of the 1950s and into the 1960s. 
 EXCLUSIVE! 
 JOAN COLLINS: HOW I LOOK FABULOUS AT 57 
 WIN! 
 WIN! &pound;5,000 WORTH OF FREEMANS FASHIONS MUST BE WON 
 SPEND! 
 SPEND! 
 THE HIGH PRICE OF BEING A SHOPAHOLIC 
 PLUS! 
 HOW TO GET THE BEST OUT OF YOUR HAIRDRESSER 
 100 NEW IDEAS 
 GREAT LOOKS AT HIGH STREET PRICES 
 Contents 
 EDITOR'S LETTER 
 Never mind the other man's grass. 
 As a teenager, I longed to have a curtain of hair like Paul McCartney's or John Lennon's. 
 What joy to be referred to as a mophead! 
 In the event, whenever I did try to grow it, it ended up looking like Jimi Hendrix's. 
 And it was no comfort having old ladies telling me how they wished they  had naturally curly hair. 
 I even resorted to going to a hairdresser who guaranteed  that I'd emerge with dead straight hair. 
 She failed. 
 But was that really her fault &mdash; or was I presenting her with an impossible task? 
 To find out both sides of the hairdressing story and discover how cutter and client can both emerge happy, turn to page 56. 
 And if you haven't yet found the right hairdresser for you, just turn to page 93 and a fantastic invitation from Wella. 
  Richard Barber  
 THE BOTTOM LINE 
 by Alison Everitt 
 HOW TO GET THE CUT YOU REALLY WANT&hellip; 
 FEATURES 
 4 20 WINTER WARMERS 
 Smart underwear for you &mdash; and him 
 12 LOOKS JUST LIKE THE REAL THING 
 Can't afford designer clothes? 
 With these you won't know the difference 
 20 YOU KNOW IT MAKES AN AWFUL LOT OF SCENTS 
 Why every woman should have a wardrobe full of perfume 
 24 ALL ABOUT JOAN 
 At last! 
 Discover the beautiful secrets of La Collins 
 28 KEEP IT SIMPLE 
 Classic shifts to take you anywhere and everywhere 
 30 THE HIGH PRICE OF BEING A SHOPAHOLIC 
 Meet the women who know &mdash; and the counsellors who've helped them 
 35 HOW WE HELPED YURI KEEP ONE JUMP AHEAD 
 The start of the Bolshoi shines brighter than ever 
 38 IT'S BETTY BOO-TIFUL! 
 The girl behind the singer 
 40 A DAY OUT IN CAMDEN 
 What people are wearing to market 
 42 THE CREAM OF THE CROP 
 Stylish sweaters, classy colour 
 48 ALL THINGS BRIGHT 
 A range of new looks to dazzle 'em! 
 56 HOW TO GET THE BEST OUT OF YOUR HAIRDRESSER 
 Yes it's all down to you&hellip; 
 60 TWINKLE TOES 
 Let patent go to your feet 
 62 HAPPINESS IS&hellip; 
 BEING JAKKI BRAMBLES 
 Find out why she's smiling 
 66 DO WE BRITS GET THE CLOTHES WE DESERVE? 
 The experts talk &mdash; and a chance for you to have your say 
 71 STEP INTO THE SIXTIES 
 &hellip; 
 See how we dressed up some visitors to Clothes Show Live 
 78 ME AND MY JEANS 
 Five winning ways to wear denim 
 85 THE ANCIENT ART OF BEATING STRESS 
 And the message is massage! 
 93 HAIR'S TO YOU! 
 Your opportunity to get a free haircut from Wella 
 94 YOU'RE LOOKING SWELL, BABY! 
 Some blooming marvellous star turns 
 REGULARS 
 7 UPFRONT FASHION 
 All that's new on the fashion front 
 8 UPFRONT BEAUTY 
 All that's new on the beauty front 
 76 YOUR VERY GOOD HEALTH 
 Dr Cathy Read on health matters 
 92 STOCKISTS 
 Where to buy our featured clothes 
 97 JOIN THE CLUB 
 Become a Priority Reader 
 98 ASK JEFF 
 Your fashion questions answered 
 OFFER 
 96 CLOTHES SHOW GEAR 
 Sweatshirts, T-shirts, jogging bottoms, caps&hellip; even carrier bags! 
 COMPETITION 
 90 WIN A WARDROBE 
 &pound;5,000 worth of fabulous Freemans fashions to be won 
 BEAT THE BIG CHILL 
 20 WINTER WARMERS 
 BRIEF NOTES 
 &bull; Marlon Brando became a star to underwear manufacturers when he greatly boosted their sales by appearing in a vest in the film &bquo;A Streetcar Named Desire&equo;. 
 &bull; Clark Gable, on the other hand, caused vest sales to drop drastically when he  took off his shirt in &bquo;It Happened One Night&equo;, to reveal a completely bare torso. 
 &bull; Madonna's always believed in the importance of underwear &mdash; even going to far as to exhibit it outside  her clothing. 
 upfront fashion 
 Fancy undies, glittering treasures and &mdash; for one of you &mdash; a unique waistcoat 
 WET LOOK 
 When is a swimming costume not a swimming costume? 
 When you don't have to get wet to wear it&hellip; 
 Yas Wear has produced a black, Fifties style costume &mdash; too nice to save for the beach. 
 It costs about &pound;30 from selected branches of Top Shop and Coppernob. 
 Call 071 323 0410 for your nearest branch. 
 JEWEL IN THE CROWN 
 Recently opened at the Museum of London's Treasury is &bquo;Treasures &amp; Trinkets&equo; &mdash; jewellery from pre-Roman times to the 1930s. 
 The collection includes Queen Victoria's jewelled parasol, plus trinkets from the Middle Ages. 
 The gold brooch shown here dates from the 1860s and is encrusted with diamonds and garnets. 
 The exhibition is open until February 1992, at the Museum of London, London Wall, EC2. 
 Call 071 600 3699; admission is free. 
 WHAT A WAISTCOAT! 
 Willie Ninja, World Champion &bquo;Voguer&equo;, arrived at the British Style Show in this waistcoat commissioned by Pimm's from Tom Gilbey. 
 The white silk/satin waistcoat emblazoned with the Pimm's logo (below) is a one-off, and we're giving it away to one lucky reader. 
 Send you name and address, before March 14, on a postcard to, Clothes Show Magazine  Waistcoat, 20&ndash;26 Brunswick Place, London, N1 6DJ. 
 OOPS! 
 In our January issue, we omitted to say that we could not have taken the photographs of readers in all the colours of the rainbow without the cooperation of Debenhams in Western Road Brighton. 
 Apologies &mdash; and many thanks. 
 IT'S A FREEBIE! 
 On release from February 11 is the video of Peter Greenaway's &bquo;The Cook, the Thief, his Wife and her Lover&equo;, (cert 18), in which the costumes are designed by Jean Paul Gaultier. 
 We've got 25 videos, worth &pound;14.9 each, to give away. 
 Call 0839 900 91 before March 14 and leave your name and address. 
 Calls charged at 33p/minimum cheap rate, 44p/minimum other times. 
 THIS YEAR'S MODEL 
 Adel Rootstein produces the most stylist shop mannequins. 
 Each year she chooses a famous personality to base the design on &mdash; past models included Twiggy and Joan Collins. 
 The mannequin, pictured below, will be unveiled in Selfridges in London. 
 After that, look out for it in department stores nationwide. 
 BE A SPORT 
 Famous for their unisex jeans, Joe Bloggs have now moved into ladies-wear. 
 Check out their sweat tops and bottoms in black or white with gold detailing &mdash; from &pound;25.99. 
 Call 061 831 7550 for stockist details. 
 UNDER COVER 
 Hennes want you to flaunt your underwear this spring. 
 Their new range includes patterned bodies, cycle shorts and wrap-around tops. 
 Ribbed cottons are decorated with pastel florals and shell motifs &mdash; available at branches of Hennes from the end of February. 
 upfront beauty 
 Gloss your hair, smooth your skin &mdash; and indulge in an everlasting kiss! 
 MUM'S THE WORD 
 Tease your Mum this Mother's Day &mdash; give her the new Pl&eacute;nitude Contour Regard from L'Or&eacute;al, for her ageing eyes! 
 The cream contains active liposomes to nourish the skin &mdash; and keep her youthful! 
 It costs &pound;5.99 for 15ml, available from leading chemists. 
 A more tactful idea would be a new Body Shop perfume. 
 Fuzzy Peach (ripe peach), Juba (lemon and orange) and Camomella (camomile) are on sale from February 18 &mdash; less ageist than a wrinkle cream! 
 SMOOTH OPERATOR 
 Hair removal can be a messy business, but Inverness now do a clever Roll-On Depilatory which is easy to apply and it doesn't drip. 
 Take advantage of our 50p off coupon on page 92 (reducing the cost to &pound;2.25). 
 Telephone 0628 776 217 for your nearest stockist. 
 NATURAL HIGH 
 Here's old-worth beauty with a modern approach &mdash; natural and cruelty-free. 
 Goodebodies products are handmade from traditional formulas. 
 Recommended is the Country Apple Conditioning Gel Shampoo &mdash; &pound;1.95 for 50ml. 
 Telephone 0423 500 206 for mail order and stockist enquiries. 
 SEALED WITH A KISS 
 Avon calling&hellip; with their Endless Kiss! 
 At long last you can possess an lipstick that never fades &mdash; due to certain capsules that release colour every time you press your lips together. 
 A strange idea, but it does save reapplying your lipstick after every cup of coffee. 
 Telephone Marion Darby on 0345 023373 to find out your nearest Avon representative. 
 IT'S A FREEBIE! 
 Sensitive skins need the gentle touch &mdash; Moistura fragrance Free products from Cyclax provide the perfect solution. 
 The range includes a cleanser, toner and moisturiser, which have been specially formulated for irritable complexions. 
 We have 250 travel packs to give away. 
 Call 0839 900092 before March 14 with your name and address. 
 Calls charged at 33p/minimum cheap rate, 44p/minimum other times. 
 GLOSS OVER IT 
 Expert Anthony Mascolo's hair flair can be seen on page 35. 
 The newest of his Tigi Linea products are those in the Gloss Concept range. 
 Best of all is the Pure Gloss lotion which smoothes and shapes hair, leaving it wonderfully soft and polished. 
 For stockists, call 081 569 9196. 
 SKIN DEEP 
 Anyone can enjoy a facial. 
 The Helena Harnik Clinic in London reports that 30 per cent of its clients are male &mdash; a sign that boys are changing their ideas and learning to respect their skin. 
 The Clinic is offering a 25 per cent discount on a facial and manicure package for readers of the Clothes Show Magazine  &mdash; male and female! 
 Normally &pound;47, take along this issue before March 14 and it will cost only &pound;35. 
 After the treatments, beauty products will be available at the clinic with a 15 per cent discount. 
 Helena Harnik Clinic, 19 Upper Berkeley Street, London W1 (071 724 1518). 
 looks like the REAL THING 
 Fancy designer labels tend to come with fancy price tags to match. 
 Want to know ho you can afford to buy the latest looks? 
 Then just read on&hellip; 
 RALPH LAUREN 
 Ralph Lauren, born in New York in 1939, formed his first company in 1968 to become the designer who most represents an archetypal American way of life. 
 His secret? 
 Designer separates which do not date and are eminently wearable. 
 The rural past provides inspiration for a lot of his clothes; a tweed jacket, drill jodhpurs and a white shirt are very  Ralph Lauren. 
 His collection for spring/summer 1991 combines a sporty feel with short, sexy dresses in fresh colours. 
 Attention to materials and cut can make his clothes ideal for an active, yet stylist life-style. 
 River Island provides our version with a red chiffon scarf for the finishing touch. 
 The original costs &pound;890 but you can look much the same for &pound;30 and go wild in accessories to add your own signature. 
 EMILIO PUCCI 
 Emilio Pucci has recently experienced a surprise resurgence of popularity in the fashion world. 
 Born into an Italian upper-class family, he boasts the title of marchese  and can claim Catherine the Great and de' Medici among his ancestors. 
 His clothes, originally worn by Lauren Bacall, Jackie Kennedy and Marilyn Monroe, were given a great boost recently when worn by the likes of Madonna and Deee-Lite. 
 With a signature print that resembles crazy paving and stained glass windows, Pucci clothing cannot fail to attract attention. 
 The outfit Madonna is wearing costs &pound;340, and Browns of South Molton Street, London, are the only stockists of it in England but, with a bit of confidence, you can spend a fraction of that. 
 Our &bquo;Pucci&equo; cost only &pound;42.99. 
 THIERRY MUGLER 
 Thierry Mugler designs clothes with impact. 
 Diana Ross sauntered down the catwalk this season wearing little more than a feather boa and a smile. 
 The likes of Naomi Campbell and Linda Evangelista were clad from head to toe in leather, rubber, latex and PVC. 
 Mugler, who was born in France in 1948 and started designing when he was 22, never fails to come up with collections that are outrageous and fun. 
 It is his show in Paris which attracts hoards of fans (some of whom are hardened fashion journalists) all keen to catch the first glimpse of Thierry's latest creations. 
 Fans are prepared to pay inflated prices for the Mugler style. 
 The catsuit in the picture above costs a cool &pound;1,760, but it isn't impossible to find cheaper alternatives. 
 Our version is by Pink Soda and costs just under &pound;60. 
 JOE CASELEY-HAYFORD 
 At just 34, Joe Caseley-Hayford is one of Britain's most consistent and respected designers. 
 He was nominated for Designer of the Year in 1989 and continues to produce the original, quality clothing. 
 His collection for this summer consists of simple shapes in chiffon and satin. 
 Stretch bra tops and slip dresses in pink and cream are painted with delicate flowers. 
 Leather gilets, chainmail dresses and leather biker jackets with hot pants are worn with huge Afro wigs for a funky Seventies feel. 
 But the slip dresses in the catwalk picture do not come cheap and to achieve this daring look you need to buy not one, but two dresses (not for the faint-hearted, being virtually see-through) making a total retail cost of &pound;522. 
 We created our Clothes Show  look by simply adding one dress on top of another with a satin body underneath. 
 Our outfit comes to &pound;211 &mdash; still expensive but these dresses are quality items each of which would look good on their own. 
 Unlike the Joe Caseley-Hayford outfit, our copycat dresses are made in a much less revealing fabric. 
 GIORGIO ARMANI 
 Giorgio Armani was born in Italy in 1934. 
 In 1975, together with Sergio Galiotti, he launched his own label. 
 By the end of the Eighties, he had opened Emporio Armani in London's Brompton Road, selling his younger, less expensive range. 
 Like many designers at the top end of the market, he has an impressive range of accessories, from scents to handkerchiefs &mdash; making the range slightly more accessible. 
 Probably best known for his classic suits, his entire collection exudes a cool elegance. 
 The predominant colour for spring/summer 1991 is being, cropping up on the catwalk in shift dresses, shorts and wrap-around sarong-style skirts. 
 The key to Armani's style is loosely cut clothes with simple accessories to create a beautiful timeless feel. 
 The suit in the picture above costs around &pound;600. 
 However, a similar outfit can be created with a silk camisole and flattering suit. 
 For that extra touch of mystique we've chosen a pair of dark sunglasses. 
 At &pound;164.99, it's still a sizeable investment but French Connection have a good reputation for making clothes that last &mdash; and any of these items could, of course, be teamed with other items. 
 Versatility equals value for money. 
 COCO CHANEL 
 Coco Chanel was born in France at the beginning of the century. 
 Throughout her career she successfully broke the rules of haute couture until her name became synonymous with French chic. 
 Responsible for Chanel No. 5 and the &bquo;little black dress&equo;, her genius has assured her name will never die. 
 Over-the-top accessories accompany all her collections, from fake pearl chokers to quilted handbags and gilt belts. 
 The inset shows a signature Chancel suit with a short skirt, in keeping with today's daring lengths, and the famous handbag. 
 Explore junk shops and markets for costume pearls and earrings to recreate this expensive look. 
 A Chanel suit alone costs over &pound;1000. 
 Our version cost &pound;60! 
 WHY EVERY WOMAN SHOULD HAVE A WARDROBE OF perfume 
 You don't always wear the same clothes wherever you go so why wear the same old fragrance? 
 With one to match every mood, you know it makes scents! 
 For those of us who are spared having to wear a uniform to work, the notion of getting out of bed and putting on exactly the same clothes, every day, is simply too boring to contemplate. 
 And &mdash; in 1991 &mdash; so it has become with fragrance. 
 For while your granny may have been content to envelope herself in a cloud of &bquo;Tweed&equo; each and every morning of her life &mdash; never daring to deviate from her &bquo;trademark&equo; perfume for so much as tea with the vicar &mdash; most of us, today, possess a positive wardrobe of perfumes to play with. 
 In fact, it could be said that the only women these days who sport one single fragrance, all the time, are those famous glamour-pusses &mdash; Joan Collins, Elizabeth Taylor, Paloma Picasso, and so on &mdash; who are paid several millions of dollars a year to endorse a &bquo;signature&equo; scent, on condition they never allow gossipy fellow lunchers in smart restaurants to get an illicit whiff of &bquo;Chanel No 5&equo; as they swan by. 
 These days, most women's lives are so varied that no single scent will take us from gym to office, from desk to dinner &mdash; let alone dawn till dusk. 
 Nevertheless, to be avoided at all costs is turning each day into a &bquo;patchwork quilt&equo; of conflicting perfumes. 
 Zooshing a citrus scent over an ultra-floral one finished off with a spritz of something exotic and musky before tonight's hot date, may leave your man more bewildered than bewitched by clashing notes battling for supremacy behind your earlobes. 
 Thanks to improved fragrance technology, perfumers are now able to offer us subtly differing strengths of the same scent for different moments during the day: eau de parfum (freshest of all) eau de toilette, parfum de toilette, esprit de parfum, parfum &mdash; or even, for some famous names, parfum extra, ideal for knocking 'em dead at several paces. 
 And don't forget all the &bquo;you-know-the-scent-now-try-the-bath-range&equo; opportunities. 
 Of course, possessing a wardrobe of perfumes can seem an expensive indulgence &mdash; but because scent stirs the senses so effectively, it is worth every penny, beaming us back, quicker than you can say &bquo;Tardis&equo;, to happy memories of holidays and favourite people. 
 Mercifully, these days, it's easier to avoid costly mistakes by splashing out on a large bottle of something which is transformed into &bquo;Eau de Old Socks&equo; by your skin's individual chemistry: if you ask politely in department stores, many perfume houses gladly hand out miniature sample vials of their wares, enabling you to make up your mind away from the high-pressure squirtings of over-zealous tester-bottle-wielders. 
 And with &bquo;perfumed strips&equo; now impregnated into the pages of so many magazines, it's possible to try new scents for a single day without venturing further than your friendly newsagent. 
 There is a logical &mdash; physiological &mdash; reason for changing your perfume frequently, too. 
 After a while, if we constantly wear the same, favourite scent, we can become immune to its charms. 
 In our brains, the cerebrum (the part connected to the olfactory, and other senses) controls our subliminal consciousness, determining the threshold of our sensory perceptions. 
 In time, spraying on the same scent habitually can make us completely insensitive to it. 
 By varying your perfume choice with the frequency you change your smalls, you never build up that resistance (and thereby avoid the risk of all but suffocating colleagues in a crowded lift with too much &bquo;Shalimar&equo; while you still can't smell a thing). 
 Also, hormonal changes during the month can alter the chemistry of a perfume on our skin, so what smells great today may be decidedly &bquo;iffy&equo; by next Thursday. 
 Of course, nowadays, fashions in fragrance do mirror those in clothes; it's no coincidence may of the world's best-sellers have been created by top designers. 
 The next big thing, you'll be interested to hear (and so will your gran), are nostalgic perfumes: anything by Caron or Mary Chess, Guerlain's early fragrances, and look out, too, for a revival of Schiaparelli's show-stopping &bquo;Shocking&equo;, in a bottle designed by painter Salvador Dali. 
 But just because your adored, powerful 1980s-style fragrance is now as d&eacute;mod&eacute; as a Dynasty-style shoulder-pad, that doesn't mean you should cast it aside. 
 Just as you keep much-lived garments in your closet slip into long after they've gone out of style, bottles of your favourite fragrance still have a place in your library of perfumes, too. 
 Most perfumes remain potent for around six months. 
 But don't for one moment feel you're fickle if you change your perfume constantly, on a whim. 
 Having a wardrobe of fragrances is as exciting as owning a vast array of stylish clothes (with the advantage, after you've made your initial choice, that perfumes always fit). 
 With so many contemporary scents to choose from, you can always find the right perfume for the occasion &mdash; and best of all, it's never held up a the dry cleaners! 
 SWEET SMELL OF SUCCESS 
 The character of a scent develops slowly on the skin as it notes come into play. 
 Tune into the harmony of your developing fragrance: Top Notes are the first scent you'll smell, but these are volatile and don't last. 
 Next come the Middle Notes, which permeate as the personality of the fragrance develops, interacting with your skin's natural chemicals. 
 A few minutes later, the Base Notes come through, and you're left with the final, true fragrance created by the Master perfumer, Guy Robert, creator of scents for Dior and Herm&egrave;s. 
 His &bquo;Exclusively Yours&equo; counter at Harrods offers an hour's consultation, during which he'll create your personal fragrance formula. 
 This is decanted into a crystal bottle and your initials etched into the glass stopper. 
 But, at &pound;150, it's not cheap! 
 Still, it's less than Joy  by Jean Patou, a mere &pound;568 for 30ml, contained in a crystal baccarat. 
 However, it does also come in an Eau de Toilette, at a more affordable &pound;23. 
 MAKE THE MOST OF IT 
 When trying out perfumes, limit yourself to four; after that, you'll become &bquo;fragrance blind&equo;. 
 Try not to rub at your skin after applying scent &mdash; you'll upset the balance of fragrance notes and spoil its character. 
 If unopened, perfume will keep for about a year. 
 But once a bottle is open &mdash; use it! 
 The air in half-empty bottles causes evaporation and deterioration. 
 An old fragrance that's past its prime will become oily, strong-smelling, and may look darker in colour. 
 Beware of over-doing it. 
 After a while, you can't smell your own scent &mdash; but everyone else certainly can! 
 Tuck empty scent bottles into your wardrobe and drawers, leaving the tops off so that your clothes can soak up the subtle aroma left in the bottles. 
 MEMORIES, MEMORIES&hellip; 
 Femme  by Rochas was originally created by Marcel Rochas in 1944 as a wedding present for his new bride. 
 No 5  by Chanel herself, from the fifth sample. 
 As five was also her lucky number, the perfume was named after it. 
 Said by Marilyn Monroe to be the only thing she worse in bed. 
 When Dior stunned the world with his &bquo;New Look&equo;, he also launched the equally revolutionary Miss Dior  in 1947. 
 Created in 1936, Blue Grass , by Elizabeth Arden, was inspired by fresh fields and blue skies of Grasse in France. 
 It was the forerunner of today's popular &bquo;sweet floral&equo; fragrances. 
 L'interdit  by Givenchy was created for Audrey Hepburn in 1957 by designer Hubert de Givenchy. 
 Originally, she had sole claim to it but now everyone can buy this classic scent. 
 MATCH THE MOOD 
 Here's our pick of the scents to match five very different outfits &mdash; and the women who wear them. 
 A SCENT OF MICHAELA 
 Choose a lively, spontaneous scent to match the carefree, natural look of blue jeans and casual top. 
 Try: 
 Eau de Patou  by Jean Patou, from &pound;15; Wrappings  by Clinique, from &pound;25; Cristalle  by Chanel, from &pound;15 (purse spray): Lauren  by Ralph Lauren, from &pound;30; Eau de Givenchy  by Givenchy, from &pound;16.75. 
 A SCENT OF JANE 
 Go for an intoxicating, soft fragrance to add to the drama of that special romantic ball dress. 
 Try: 
 Le Jardin  by Max Factor, from &pound;6.95; Femme  by Rochas, from &pound;24; Roma  by Laura Biagiotti, from &pound;22.50; L'Air du Temps  by Nina Ricci, from &pound;21; Tr&eacute;sor  by Lanc&ocirc;me, from &pound;30 (in Harrods from march, countrywide from May). 
 A SCENT OF BETTE 
 Find an extrovert perfume to complement your most outrageous outfit. 
 Try: 
 C'est la Vie!  by Christian Lacroix, from &pound;24; Les Parfums  by Salvador Dali, from &pound;20; Paloma  by Paloma Picasso, from &pound;25; Ma Libert&eacute;  by Jean Patou, from &pound;20; Ysatis  by Givenchy, from &pound;25; Capucci  by Capucci, from &pound;18. 
 A SCENT OF MICHELLE 
 Select a sophisticated, sensual scent to match your little black dress Try: 
 Coco  by Chancel, from &pound;31; Teatro Alla Scala  by Krizia, from &pound;30; Y  by Yves Saint Laurent, from &pound;21; Dioressence  by Dior, from &pound;31; Caroline Herrera  by Antonio Puig perfumes, from &pound;28.25. 
 A SCENT OF DIANA 
 Choose a perfume as confident and modern as your smartest suit. 
 Try: 
 Calandre  by Paco Rabanne, from &pound;21: Chamade  by Guerlain, from &pound;24.50; Escada  by Margaretha Ley, from &pound;29.50; Knowing  by Est&eacute;e Lauder, from &pound;32; Montanta  by Claude Montana, from &pound;20. 
 Halston Classic  by Halston, from &pound;16.25.  
 &bquo;If we constantly wear the same scent, we become immune to it&equo; 
 All about Joan 
 She'll be 58 in May &mdash; so how does  Joan Collins do it? 
 By Richard Barber 
 &bquo;I've got quite a lot of hair but it's fine so, to make it look good, I need to spend a great deal of effort on it. 
 Since time is something I don't have too much of these days I look for other solutions like hats, turbans, scarves or wigs and pieces. 
 I wore a short wig in the recent production of Noel Coward's Private Lives . 
 When I took it off afterwards, my hair was a mess, so I put on a turban or tied in back with a band, which is what I do every day. 
 I was my hair every other day and usually only go to my hairdresser before a party. 
 Actually, I didn't go to the hairdresser once during the five months I was in Private Lives  and my hair became healthier from not being subjected to heated rollers or setting lotion. 
 There's too much hype connected to most beauty products so I've never become a slave to any particular shampoo. 
 I spend more time on my face and skin than I do on my hair. 
 I use a bath oil in my bath &mdash; there's an American one I like &mdash; and then a moisturising body lotion: Vaseline Intensive Care or Nahema by Guerlain or, of course, Spectacular by Joan Collins! 
 I'm extremely lucky in that I have no cellulite. 
 I know girls in their twenties who do, so I realise how fortunate I am. 
 Part of the reason could be to do with my genes: my other and grandmother were both very beautiful women who looked after themselves. 
 Mummy instilled a beauty routine into me as a young girl which is as automatic to me now as brushing my teeth. 
 I am also extremely aware of what I eat. 
 I don't diet because I don't believe in it. 
 It's an old maxim but it's true: to a great extent, you are  what you eat. 
 I disapprove of diets so strongly because I think it's wrong suddenly to deprive your body of certain foods. 
 The likelihood is that you'll go back to your old ways so you'll have achieved nothing. 
 The better approach, in my opinion, is to eat the right foods in the first place. 
 There's no mystery about it. 
 It's just common sense. 
 Hamburgers, friend and processed foods, canned drinks, too much caffeine, too much starch &mdash; all of them are bad for you. 
 My weakness is chocolate but the occasional indulgence makes all the rest worth it. 
 And yes, I drink alcohol but only wine and champagne and usually only in the evening. 
 During the day I drink only mineral water, fresh fruit juice, coffee or tea. 
 I never drink anything out of a can and hardly ever eat anything tinned, either. 
 The exceptions are baked beans, tuna fish and, particularly, sardines which are so good for you. 
 I also love those individual dinners from Marks &amp; Spencer. 
 Their Chicken Kiev is delicious, and as for their garlic bread&hellip; fabulous! 
 When it comes to make-up, I'm absolutely convinced that cosmetics are the greatest protector of the skin yet devised. 
 All the women I know who have worn make-up all their lives have good skins. 
 But the women who haven't bothered with make-up &mdash; unless they've taken superlative care of their complexions &mdash; have now got skin that shows the ravages of time. 
 I think it's an old wives' tale that make-up ruins the skin. 
 As long as you remove it properly and moisturise and tone your skin, it's the very best way of preserving it. 
 Make-up definitely acts as a mask against the elements. 
 I like to use cosmetics as close to my natural skin colour as possible. 
 I always emphasise my eyes more than any other feature. 
 In fact, I arrived at a look I liked fifteen years ago and I have hardly changed it since then. 
 The only time I change the colour of my make-up is when I have a tan. 
 I don't deliberately put my face in the sun &mdash; but you can't help picking up a slight tan from reflected sunlight, particularly if, like me, you swim a lot. 
 It's merely a question of altering your foundation to match your skin colour. 
 I don't like exercising very much. 
 I can think of very little more boring than lying on the floor and doing sit-ups and leg lifts every morning. 
 So I don't. 
 All I do is 10 or 15 minutes of my own exercises every other day when I remember. 
 When it comes to clothes and the British high street, I think the standard has dropped radically in the last five years. 
 It's unbelievable how shoddily made most things have become and how expensive, too. 
 One of the few exceptions is Marks &amp; Spencer. 
 I bought my son a selection of clothes at Christmas and was really impressed with both the designs on offer and the reasonable prices. 
 I then tried Miss Selfridge for my two girls, Tara and Katy. 
 With the exception of some of the Lycra fashions, I was appalled at how hideous everything was. 
 I just don't like the styles for young women. 
 The skirts are far too skimpy and short, the shoes too clumpy. 
 Apart from Edina Ronay, Bruce Oldfield and Caroline Charles, British fashion today is sad. 
 I prefer to shop in Paris, or in America. 
 Vivienne Westwood, Designer of the Year? 
 I mean, please ! 
 Is it any wonder that more and more women resort to wearing jeans and anoraks? 
 I went into Harrods recently and I couldn't believe how revolting most of the clothes were &mdash; and they weren't cheap, either. 
 For &pound;200, I expect to be able to buy something that's good-looking and  well-designed. 
 I've settled now for a sort of uniform during the day of a skirt, silk shirt and a jacket, with a three-quarter length cashmere coat over it in winter. 
 I tend to wear black suits in the evening although I must admit I'm getting slightly bored with black now. 
 I buy most of them in America from designers like Anne Klein or Donna Karan &mdash; the choice in America is so much wider. 
 Walking through Saks or Bloomingdales in New York is great. 
 You can see every designer under the sun. 
 It's fabulous. 
 My weakness is costume jewellery &mdash; I have my own line &mdash; and anything for the hair: hats, headbands and scarves. 
 But when it comes to clothes, I'm absolutely ruthless. 
 If I'm going to spend several hundred pounds on an outfit, I make sure I get real value out of it and will wear it a lot. 
 I'm a hoarder when it comes to clothes &mdash; I still wear some of the clothes designed for Alexis in Dynasty . 
 As for perfume, I wouldn't dream  of wearing anything other than Spectacular by Joan Collins! 
 I am often asked whether I approve of cosmetic surgery &mdash; and I do not. 
 Too often, there can be real dangers attached. 
 In America, it's becoming ridiculous. 
 People as young as 30 are undergoing surgery. 
 And it doesn't always have the desired effect. 
 I saw some pictures recently of a famous movie star with a lift&hellip; frightening. 
 If you're unhappy with your face, I can see that you might be tempted. 
 But I don't think everyone is as aware as they should be of the after-effects. 
 I have seen too many people who have looked odd after cosmetic surgery. 
 And it doesn't always last. 
 A girlfriend of mine had the bags under her eyes removed but, two years later, she's acquired a new set. 
 So what is she to do? 
 Have cosmetic surgery every two years? 
 I wouldn't dream of letting a surgeon anywhere near my eyes. 
 I think it's incredibly dangerous. 
 My attitude to ageing is that it's inevitable so there's very little you can do about it. 
 I take care of myself, I eat sensibly, I try to maintain my face and body as best I can but I'm not obsessive about it. 
 And I know that I'm incredibly lucky to have such tremendous energy. 
 I feel no different whatsoever to how I felt when I was 30. 
 A lot of it is to do with attitude. 
 I had dinner with an actor the other night who managed to tell me three times throughout the meal that he was 50. 
 He's a very attractive man who looks younger than his age so why the hang-up? 
 I was told when I first entered this business that a pretty girl is on her way out at 23 and all washed up at 27. 
 Look at the starts of the films from the Thirties and Forties. 
 They were all teenagers or in their early twenties. 
 Well, I wasn't prepared to believe that my career would be over almost before it had started. 
 So I've looked after myself but I've worked hard as well because I like a certain lifestyle and it costs a fair amount to sustain. 
 I never, ever worry about my age. 
 It simply doesn't occur to me. 
 And, anyway, we're all aware of the alternative. 
 Death.&equo;  
 I emphasise my eyes more than any other feature 
 It's an old wives' tale that make-up ruins the skin 
 I love hats, headbands and scarves: I also wear wigs and pieces 
 I always wear Spectacular by Joan Collins! 
 My weakness is costume jewellery &mdash; I have my own line 
 I buy my clothes in America &mdash; British fashion today is sad 
 I use bath oil and moisturising body lotions 
 I don't like exercising much but I do swim a lot 
 &bquo;I never worry about my age. 
 It simply doesn't occur to me&equo; 
 &bquo;I feel no different now to how I felt when I was 30&equo; 
 Joan past and present. 
 Way back in 1955, a buxom young Joan took on Cleopatra in the film Land of the Pharaohs  (left). 
 With hands still firmly on hips, Joan went on to become the face that launched a thousand mannequins 
 The Doris Day era. 
 Bright and wholesome, as a cowgirl (left) and tropical temptress (above) 
 Far left: Sixties swinger &mdash; and forerunner of The Bitch ? 
 Left: as a Russian ballerina in Nutcracker . 
 Young and innocent in the film Sea Wife  (below left) and, more credibly, as the fiery Alexis in Dynasty  (below). 
 keep it simple 
 Not for nothing has the shift remained a timeless classic. 
 Here's our pick of the best. 
 the high price of being a shopaholic 
 We all joke about shopping till we drop but for some people it's a reality. 
 Josephine Fairly talks to two reformed shopaholics &mdash; and to the expert counsellors 
 Everyone likes an occasional splurge, some of us &mdash; like Imelda Marcos (she of the 3,000 pairs of shoes and 500 bras) &mdash; more than others. 
 Whether it's to reward ourselves for an achievement, or to lift our spirits, many women find little can compete with the rustle of tissue paper and the thrill of slipping into a pristine new outfit. 
 All of us probably envy the ability of Imelda, Ivana, Diana and co to indulge themselves with a glorious shopping spree whenever the desire grips them. 
 But, increasingly, with the availability of easy credit, it's possible to shop till you drop on a shoestring salary. 
 &bquo;Buy now, pay later,&equo; the banks exhort us. 
 For a number of shopaholics, however, that price turns out to be dizzyingly high &mdash; when shopping turns from a pleasure, or an occasional treat, into an uncontrollable obsession that chomps its way through the bank account, with sometimes disastrous effects. 
 Once upon a time, of course, when you craved new clothes, you had to save  for them &mdash; a quaint custom almost as outdated as horsedrawn carriages and farthingales. 
 I remember once thinking my mother was stark raving bonkers as she regaled me with a tale of the time she scrimped for six months to buy a pair of elbow length, white kid evening gloves, which set her back the equivalent of two weeks' wages. 
 But she certainly never suffered from that sick feeling in the pit of her stomach &mdash; familiar to many a credit-card flexer &mdash; when the post flops on the mat each morning. 
 &bquo;When everyone bought things for cash, if you couldn't afford something &mdash; well, it was tough luck,&equo; agrees Simon Gelsthorpe of Bradford Health Authority, who's worked with a wide range of adult emotional and psychological difficulties (including chronic addictions). 
 &bquo;But nowadays, it's all too easy to get carried away. 
 So many people have credit cards, because it is quite tough to get through daily life today without one.&equo; 
 That's not to say that everyone will succumb to the temptation to use their credit cards willy-nilly, but for addictive personalities credit cards can lead all too easily into temptation. 
 &bquo;Compulsive spenders suffer the same urge to go on a binge as compulsive drinkers, eaters or non-eaters,&equo; declares Dr Christopher Cook of London's Middlesex Hospital Psychiatry Unit. 
 &bquo;Addiction begins when shopping sprees become a means of relieving tension and anxiety. 
 People who feel unloved and depressed often alleviate those stressful feelings by going out and buying things. 
 However, shopping can eventually become an end in itself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just as there is comfort in eating, so there is comfort spending &mdash; buying things to make yourself feel better,&equo; observes Simon Gelsthorpe. 
 &bquo;In fact, they're very similar; the benefits are equally short term. 
 Most comfort eaters enjoy it while they're eating, but the downside is they soon start to pile on the pounds. 
 You may feel good when you get home and try on your new dress but, in the long-run, it too  can create more problems, piling on the debt.&equo; 
 There is, of course, a considerable difference between enjoying a passion for fashion and being a spendaholic. 
 Strange as it may sound, compulsive shoppers very often don't even wear  their look &mdash; in contrast, of course, to the average shopper who flaunts a new frock or jumper to death. 
 DIANNE'S STORY 
 Dianne is 26 and a (reformed) high-spender: &bquo;The joy was the act of shopping itself. 
 Often, I wouldn't bother to try things on &mdash; I'd look at the price tag and think &bquo;I've got to have this,&equo; especially if I thought it was a &bquo;bargain&equo; I might not see again. 
 More often than not, when I got my booty home, I'd never even hang it up; it would sit in the carrier bag or the shoe-box under my bed. 
 It didn't matter what  I bought; it still wouldn't have satisfied the continual, gnawing desire for more.&equo; 
 The first step on the path to beating the problem &mdash; as with any addiction &mdash; is to acknowledge it's there. 
 Quite often, there's a moment of truth &mdash; the realisation that there's no  way you can actually make all the minimum payments on your credit cards Then, the secret is to seek out the reason for your burning desire to go barmy in Benetton, or wherever your compulsion manifests itself. 
 In addition to those who shop to assuage feelings of &bquo;inner emptiness&equo; (commonly described by sufferers), obsessive spending can also be an aggressive act. 
 &bquo;If a woman isn't working, her husband's bringing home the pay cheque and it's seen very much as &bquo;his money&equo;, compulsive spending can be a way of getting back at him if she's angry,&equo; explains Simon Gelsthorpe. 
 &bquo;Alternatively, a woman may have low self-esteem, feeling she can only impress others or make them like her by buying status symbols or the latest fashions. 
 &bquo;The majority of compulsive spending is  comfort spending &mdash; and in order to cure it, it's necessary to confront the cause of your discomfort, the emotional pain which shopping only temporarily eases.&equo; 
 In the short term, he explains, &bquo;Confrontation can be even more  painful, but it's the only way, in the end, to treat the underlying reason for over-spending. 
 If you're unhappy and miserable because you're lonely, then you have to find other ways to address that than going out and buying something to wear, or getting drunk. 
 In the end, a new Lycra frock is never going to give you the warm, rosy glow of friendship.&equo; 
 Wherever possible, though, he recommends turning to family and friends for emotional help with the problem, rather than going it alone. 
 &bquo;But if partners or those around you aren't able to help, then it may be time to seek professional help.&equo; 
 Your GP may be able to point you in the right direction, and it's worth finding out if the psychology department of your local hospital takes referrals. 
 If you've slid into debt, there is also, crucially, the practical side to tackle &mdash; the going on a &bquo;financial diet&equo;. 
 People might consider destroying their credit cards or just leaving them at home.&equo; 
 Simon suggests, &bquo;only using a cheque book for household bills and so on. 
 Another step is never to go shopping without a list, and to be strict about only buying what's on it.&equo; 
 My own ruse was to &bquo;swap&equo; credit cards with an equally debt-ridden friend; for three months we had to travel halfway across London to retrieve our own card and ask &bquo;permission&equo; before making a purchase! 
 It worked a treat. 
 &bquo;That's fine for a short-term arrangement,&equo; insists Simon, &bquo;but, ultimately, people have to learn to take control of themselves .&equo; 
 The dreaded bank manager often turns out to be highly sympathetic, once a customer comes clean. 
 Arrangements can be made to consolidate debts and pay them off gradually. 
 Citizens' Advice Bureaux can also put compulsive spenders in touch with debt counsellors, who are able to assess their clients' finances and thus establish an escape from what can feel like a financial swamp. 
 The good news, meanwhile, is that reformed shopaholics almost always speak of a silver lining to the cloud which hung over their lives (and bank accounts). 
 Explains Dianne: &bquo;I value what I have now. 
 I enjoy going out to buy something, having saved up for it, far more than I ever did when my favourite phrase was &bquo;charge it, please&equo;. 
 I think  now about what I'm purchasing, whether it'll go with my other clothes and accessories. 
 My wardrobe may not be as current these days, and I hardly saw a movie for a year and a half while I was getting myself back on my feet financially. 
 But now, when friends talk about using credit cards, I say &bquo;do yourself a favour &mdash; cut them in half&equo;!&equo; 
 &bquo;And,&equo; she adds, &bquo;at least, they don't call me Imelda any more&hellip;&equo; 
 CATHY'S STORY 
 &bquo;I've been in love with new clothes ever since I can remember. 
 As a child, even though my parents were divorced and my mother didn't have much money, I would scream and shout whenever she tried to put me in some of my sister's hand-me-downs. 
 So, for me, the best thing about starting work was being able to go shopping every weekend and buy things without having to ask someone for money. 
 I'd wander down the high street, frittering away on whatever took my fancy. 
 I'd wear my shopping trophies on Saturday night, and over the next week&hellip; 
 But the following weekend, I'd have shopping fever again. 
 &bquo;It was fine while I was on weekly wages. 
 But then I got promoted at work and suddenly I had a salary to borrow against. 
 Store cards were the beginning of my downfall. 
 All my favourite high street shops seemed to be offering them if you just walked in off the street so I snapped up several. 
 You only had to pay back the five per cent minimum each month. 
 Within a couple of months I'd splurged about &pound;2,500 on all sorts of high-fashion clothes. 
 I worked hard all week and so felt that I deserved them, I suppose. 
 &bquo;Increasingly, the &bquo;thrill of the chase&equo; gripped me. 
 I was obsessed by new clothes to the extent that I'd lost interest in something if it was more than a few hours  old. 
 My sisters and friends loved  me; they were getting all these barely-worn cast-offs. 
 My mum kept telling me she thought I was spending too much, but I'd always tell lies about the price of things. 
 &bquo;I'd already stretched my credit to the maximum when the bank gave me a cheque guarantee card that was also a credit card. 
 So I used that to its limit, too. 
 By the time I was 22, I'd run up nearly &pound;4,000 in debt, and was beginning to fall behind with the payments because I rested sending money off to pay for clothes I'd fallen out of love with. 
 I was running up an unauthorised overdraft, too; I'd stopped opening statements ages before because they made my hand shake and my tummy wobble. 
 The crunch came when my bank asked for my credit card back and demanded I pay off the overdraft at once. 
 I had to ask Mum to lend me the money &mdash; it was the most humiliating moment of my life. 
 &bquo;She marched me off to see my bank manager. 
 I explained the situation to him and he arranged a single loan to pay off the store cards. 
 (I realised I had to cancel them, otherwise I'd get the balance down a bit, then get clothes fever again.) 
 Mum felt that she's failed me by not stopping me sooner, but it was me  who'd let us both down. 
 When we talked about it at length, I realised that I'd been using clothes to buoy myself up emotionally, ever since my father left when I was 10. 
 When I understood the reason  for my compulsive shopping, it became possible &mdash; though not easy &mdash; to stop. 
 I was lucky to have my family's support, and soon after, I met a really nice man at work; we've been seeing each other ever since. 
 The acid test was when I told him why I never had any money to spend, but he was very understanding. 
 I don't want to be &bquo;kept&equo; by him, so if I can't afford to go out we just stay in and read together or just watch television. 
 When we do go out, I've still got plenty of clothes and no longer feel I have  to have something brand new. 
 &bquo;Now I just draw out from the bank a spending allowance for the week &mdash; to pay mum back, to cover essentials and for a few little extras. 
 If I cut corners, I have something left on Saturday to go shopping with. 
 I've almost paid off the debt and soon I may have enough to put something aside for savings. 
 That'll  be a first.&equo; 
 ARE YOU A SPENDAHOLIC? 
 Below is a list of questions for you to ask yourself. 
 If you answer &bquo;yes&equo; to two or more of these questions, it's time for a little self-examination &mdash; you could have a problem. 
 Do you borrow for items you used to buy with cash? 
 Do you find that you are only able to make the minimum payments on your credit cards? 
 Is an increasing proportion of your weekly/monthly income being used to pay off your debts? 
 Is your cushion of savings small or non-existent? 
 Are you at, or near, your credit limit? 
 Do you take out a new loan before the old one is paid off? 
 Do you take out a new loan to pay off the old one? 
 Are you unsure how much you actually owe? 
 Are your monthly credit payments more than 15&ndash;20 per cent of your net income, excluding rent or mortgage? 
 Would you be in immediate financial difficulty if you lost your job? 
 &bquo;Compulsive spenders will binge in the same way as alcoholics&equo; 
 &bquo;By the time I was just 22, I had run up a clothes debt of nearly &pound;4,000&equo; 
 FASHION SOLUTIONS 
 How we helped Yuri keep one jump ahead 
 He may be the principal dancer at the Bolshoi Ballet but, when it came to fashion, Yuri Vasyuchenko was trailing way behind. 
 The Clothes Show Magazine  leapt to the rescue 
 When top Bolshoi ballet dancer Yuri Vasyuchenko strides through the streets of Moscow, his compatriots treat him like a rock star. 
 Small wonder, really, since he looks  like a rock star &mdash; of the Bon Jovi ilk, as it happens. 
 But somehow, now that the 34-year-old Yuri is spending more time away from his homeland &mdash; touring with the Bolshoi to Europe, America and the Far East, starring in Sleeping Beauty, Romeo &amp; Juliet  and Swan Lake , meeting politicians and top businessmen, even being presented to royalty &mdash; that shaggy, laid-back image doesn't sit so well on his broad shoulders. 
 &bquo;It is very difficult for us Russians,&equo; he explained, in a strong native accent. 
 &bquo;At home, we have no fashion magazines to help us. 
 When we come to the West, it's like Christmas &mdash; so many shops, so much to buy. 
 The problem is, we don't know how to put it all together. 
 I wish I could see more  magazines, to give me ideas and guidance.&equo; 
 Time for the Clothes Show Magazine  's expert team to step into the limelight and take a bow: award-winning hairdresser, Anthony Mascolo, from Toni &amp; Guy, and fashion assistant Saska Graville, who'd been chosen to work on Yuri's new look. 
 &bquo;This is great,&equo; he smiled. 
 &bquo;I love clothes &mdash; but I hate trailing round the shops.&equo; 
 The first big challenge was the dynamic dancer's hair, which we all agreed was bit like a Seventies pop star's. 
 &bquo;That's because I usually cut it myself,&equo; grinned Yurk, &bquo;and I'm a ballet dancer, not a hairdresser.&equo; 
 Because of the romantic roles that Yuri dances, however, it was very important not to alter his image too much, maintaining length but subtly improving both the shape and texture of his hair. 
 &bquo;Yuri's problem is that he has very fine hair,&equo; said Anthony, carefully snipping feathery layers into the rather worried-looking star's tresses. 
 (Well, you  try explaining the finer points of haircutting to a Russian whose grasp of English, while good, is far from perfect.) 
 &bquo;It will still look messy, the way he likes it &mdash; but much more modern, too&equo; declared the master scissor-wielder with confidence. 
 Not that Yuri need have fretted for a moment &mdash; as the softer shape emerged, a big smile spread across his strong features. 
 &bquo;Usually, I don't trust anyone else with my hair &mdash; but I like this very  much.&equo; 
 So keen was he on the results &mdash; secured into place with a handful of mousse (a completely new and highly intriguing concept to Yurk!) that he agreed to let Tony &amp; Guy's team work on the colour, later in the week. 
 &bquo;Yuri's been experimenting with bleach,&equo; observed Anthony. 
 &bquo;It's given him a slightly orangey colour. 
 What he really needs is to have some blond streaks to lift it a shade or two.&equo; 
 By now, Yuri was really beginning to enjoy himself. 
 Appropriately enough for a photo session with one of the fittest men in the world &mdash; capable of dancing for hours without a break &mdash; we'd taken over a corner of top London gym, The Peak, at the Hyatt Carlton Tower Hotel. 
 Yuri soon started tapping his sock-clad feet in tune to the beat of the music, while one floor below several women in leotards went for the burn. 
 &bquo;I don't just like to do ballet &mdash; I like disco dancing, too,&equo; he revealed to us. 
 In fact, the clothes Yuri had worn to our shoot &mdash; an American jacket and trousers with a grey shirt and fur-lined black trainers &mdash; wouldn't have looked at all of place on the dance floor of Stringfellows, but Yuri was after a smoother image. 
 At first, he expressed surprise at the colours Saska had picked for his new look &mdash; a sludgy, greyish-green suit by top Italian designer, Giorgio Armani, teamed with a dusty tobacco silk turtleneck and cardigan from Nicole Farhi, to encourage Yuri to break away from his preferred monochromes. 
 &bquo;I really don't think they're my colours at all,&equo; he commented. 
 &bquo;Usually, I wear black, grey, khaki. 
 But I'll give it a try&hellip;&equo; 
 Five minutes later and, having shrugged on Armani's uncluttered lines and the sensuous Nicole Farhi knitwear, Yuri was clearly thrilled with the result. 
 &bquo;Normally, I go for very sporty clothes,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;But I like this classic look. 
 If I walked through Moscow now, they wouldn't recognise me.&equo; 
 He smiled, giving us the impression that &mdash; after all the adulation he usually experiences &mdash; he might find that  something of a relief. 
 Clothes buying is hardly Yuri's preferred foreign pastime, though: &bquo;When I travel, I prefer to sneak off to look at cars and buy accessories for the ones I have at home &mdash; a Volvo, an Audi, a Volkswagen, a Japanese Micro bus &mdash; and my favourite, an old Chevrolet. 
 They're just what I would call my real  hobby,&equo; he confessed. 
 He also has a motorcycle, and owns up to a passion for all kinds of biker gear. 
 &bquo;I really love leather jackets and jeans.&equo; 
 Today, though, we were aiming to avoid that rock'n'roll gear in favour of a more relaxed, off-duty style. 
 Saska has chosen some soft denim jeans and a chunky silk Aran-knit. 
 &bquo;This would be great for travelling &mdash; and warm enough for those brutal Russian winters,&equo; said Saska, as our star slipped into something decidedly comfortable, and performed a rather more professional twirl than most make-over &bquo;guinea pigs&equo; can manage. 
 It's natural that Yuri should so enjoy dressing down , when for some much of his life he has been zipped into elaborate Bolshoi costumes, his cheekbones and eyes accented by thick, expertly applied theatrical make-up. 
 And in addition, of course, much of his time &mdash; several punishing hours each day, since childhood &mdash; is spent in well-worn practice gear. 
 So we thought we'd riffle through the rails of leading dancewear manufacturers to find something a shade more exciting than saggy tracksuit bottoms. 
 &bquo;This is great,&equo; he laughed, pleased with the new, more cosmopolitan Yuri he now saw reflected in the mirror. 
 &bquo;I must admit I was a little anxious before we started because I've looked the same for years &mdash; but now I'm very happy with my new style. 
 It's given me plenty of ideas for when I next go shopping in London, New York, Los Angeles, Bangkok, wherever. 
 Thank you!&equo; 
 Finally, as if rewarding us for our efforts, Yuri provided us with what was for us the highlight of the day &mdash; an impromptu performance (to a disco beat) which left us in no doubt at all as to why this tall, handsome athlete is Russia's leading ballet super-Tsar!  
 &bquo;If I walked through Moscow now, they wouldn't recognise me&equo; 
 INSIDE MY WARDROBE 
 It's Betty Boo-tiful! 
 Betty Boo is the hottest new singer in the British charts. 
 The girl behind her is Alison Clarkson. 
 Can you tell them apart? 
 From West London straight to the top end of the British pop charts, Betty Boo is a pop star who's definitely going places. 
 The girl behind the Boo persona is Alison Clarkson, a talented, highly original 20-year old from Shepherd's Bush, London. 
 She has created pop's answer to Barbarella, dressing her up in clothes fit for a material girl. 
 The Clothes Show Magazine  team invited Alison to show us some of her favourite outfits, as well as a selection of clothes that Betty wears. 
 Can you  spot the difference? 
 Alison arrived in what she described as her &bquo;old school tights&equo; and a pair of Jigsaw hotpants. 
 &bquo;I used to dress very casually, always wearing trainers. 
 Now I really love dressing up and I've given all my trainers away to my brother. 
 I've got a big wardrobe at the moment but it mainly consists of shoes &mdash; I bought these boots from Read or Dead.&equo; 
 For the next picture, it was on with the stage makeup and into something a little more outrageous &mdash; Betty's turn, in other words. 
 Alison complained of the constant temptation she undergoes to buy the clothes that are picked for Betty Boo. 
 Sure enough, she fell in love with the Arabella Pollen dress brought along by the Clothes Show Magazine . 
 &bquo;It's a perfect fit and I'm absolutely mad about it,&equo; said Alison. 
 She was true to her word. 
 Just a couple of weeks later, Betty popped up on the BRIT awards. 
 No prizes for guessing what she was wearing. 
 The final outfit was one that Alison had brought along with her. 
 Would she wear it off stage or was it strictly for Betty Boo only? 
 &bquo;Betty Boo would never wear anything that Alison Clarkson didn't like. 
 I love Betty's outfits &mdash; the clothes I wear have got to be out of the ordinary. 
 I haven't had a chance to wear this outfit to go out yet &mdash; but I will.&equo;  
 &bquo;I find it difficult to get shorts and trousers to fit me. 
 I've got more of an athletic figure than a womanly figure &mdash; and I've hardly any waist&equo; 
 &bquo;I hardly ever wear dresses as they never fit &mdash; you always see me in shorts. 
 I love this, though, because it gives me a waist 
 &bquo;This outfit is very cartoonish, very Mickey Mouse, and I like that. 
 I like to be flamboyant and have an excuse to dress up&equo; 
 Day out in CAMDEN 
 How do you spend your Saturday mornings? 
 The Clothes Show Magazine  went to Camden in north London to find out&hellip; 
 TAMA &amp; JESSIE 
 &bquo;We're here to recover from last night&equo; 
 JIMMY, STALLHOLDER &amp; CORINNA 
 &bquo;I've got my curlers in ready for tonight&equo; 
 PAUL, STALLHOLDER 
 &bquo;Some of these clothes are antiques; I've just spotted a stain on one of them!&equo; 
 RACHEL 
 &bquo;I love my poncho; it keeps me very warm&equo; 
 THE CREW FROM HUFFS FOOD STALL. 
 SPIKE (IN THE STRAW HAT) 
 &bquo;The hole in my hat is so I can easily scratch my head!&equo; 
 ALAN, CRAIG, FRANCINE &amp; MONIQUE, STALLHOLDERS 
 &bquo;Alan made Francine's jacket &mdash; we all end up swapping clothes from each other's stalls&equo; 
 SEAN, DANIEL JON &amp; JEFF 
 &bquo;We're here to buy clothes &mdash; Jon wants some Champion trainers&equo; 
 SOO SCOTT, STALLHOLDER 
 &bquo;I think more people should wear hats&equo; 
 ENRIQUE &amp; CHRISTINA 
 &bquo;The clothes here are cheap and brilliant&equo; 
 DANIEL 
 &bquo;I've done modelling before &mdash; will this be a funny shot of me?&equo; 
 EILEEN, STALLHOLDER 
 &bquo;I've lined this hat to keep my head warm&equo; 
 MR JAMESON &amp; CHARLOTTE 
 &bquo;We're just browsing &mdash; all this shopping has worn us out&equo; 
 KATHLEEN, BAR ARIZONA 
 &bquo;I shave my head once a week&equo; 
 the cream of the crop 
 From chunky cottons to delicate crochets, this season's newest knits come in the most chic of colours. 
 Here's the cr&egrave;me de la cr&egrave;me&hellip; 
 ALL THINGS BRIGHT 
 Cast off those winter blues and burst into spring with sizzling, vibrant hues. 
 Choose hot reds and golds, tangy lime or fresh floral prints &mdash; whatever you do, don't be dull 
 how to get the best out of your HAIRDRESSER 
 Having your hair cut in a professional salon can be even more traumatic than going to the dentist. 
 And more expensive, too. 
 So who's to blame? 
 Probably the hairdresser and  the client, as Sally Moulsdale discovered. 
 As every woman knows, her hair is her crowning glory, or rather she knows that it should be, but there are those of us who are unhappily aware that, too often, our looks fall down on the job. 
 The answer should be simple. 
 Go to a hairdresser, ask him or her to come up with a style that suits you, your hair, your lifestyle, and emerge looking and feeling great. 
 However, things are not that easy. 
 The relationship between a woman, her hair and her hairdresser can be fraught with complications. 
 &bquo;I remember one client who burst into tears before I'd taken the first snip,&equo; said top London stylist Trevor Sorbie. 
 &bquo;That's how emotional and intense it can be and I can understand that. 
 I believe that a haircut can change people's lives. 
 Certainly, a lot can be read into a hairstyle. 
 A woman with well-cut permanently glossy hair gives a good impression of being in control of her life. 
 Someone who's forever pushing her hair out of her eyes, or stuffing it up in a clip on top of her head simply looks harassed. 
 Not for nothing did Sue Ellen's hair flop when she became an alcoholic. 
 She was a fallen woman, and her hair knew it. 
 It doesn't end there. 
 Your hair may be well cut, but if you're a trendy executive and your latest hairdo is just that tiny bit mumsy, you may as well hibernate for a few months. 
 With such a lot riding on the snip of a scissor, it's not surprising that the breast beneath the hairdresser's gown is heaving with unrealistic expectations and conflicting emotions of hope and fear. 
 &bquo;I go into a hairdresser's hoping that a new me will emerge,&equo; said Barbara Scott, a mother of three who works part-time. 
 &bquo;I want someone to create a style that will make me look fabulous, and which doesn't need any care at all. 
 I believe that if it's cut well enough that should be possible. 
 Instead, I sit there while the stylist blow dries for an hour, thinking: &bquo;Oh God, another disaster&equo;. 
 I still live in hope, though, always changing hairdressers, praying the next one will give me my perfect style.&equo; 
 For Claire King, the European promotions manager for EMI, going to the hairdresser is worse than going to the dentist. 
 &bquo;My overwhelming emotion is fear. 
 I feel a victim as soon as I arrive in the salon. 
 My dream is for someone to say: &bquo;I understand your hair and your lifestyle; this cut will really suit you.&equo; 
 In reality, I feel I'm one up of I don't come out in tears.&equo; 
 So what is the problem? 
 Why do perfectly confident women feel intimidated as soon as they walk through the door of a salon? 
 The main problem is one of communication,&equo; said John Peers, who was voted Midlands Stylist of the Year at the latest British Hairdressing Awards. 
 His clients have been known to fly from Jersey to his Birmingham salon in order to have him tend their tresses. 
 &bquo;The consultation before the cut is so important. 
 The hairdresser must listen to the client, and vice versa. 
 They should chat until they come to a realistic agreement about a style that will suit her hair and lifestyle. 
 This preliminary chat should be much higher on the agenda than it is in many salons.&equo; 
 Trevor Sorbie is in complete agreement. 
 When first choosing a hairdresser, he strongly advises booking a consultation rather than an appointment. 
 &bquo;A hairdresser's not worth his salt if he's not prepared to give a consultation,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It's the best way of adverting a disastrous haircut. 
 At a consultation you're not in the vulnerable position that you are in a hairdresser's chair. 
 You're in a position of strength as a potential client who is checking out the service on offer. 
 You can find out a lot in a short chat, and you have the option of leaving with no harm done.&equo; 
 That could be a comforting thought when you have to contend with dominating hairdressers who think like Michael Rasser of the famous Michaeljohn salon (cut and blow-dry &pound;50). 
 He was recently quoted as saying: &bquo;I've got a terrible habit when people bring in a picture and say they want to look like that &mdash; I invariably tear it up in front of them. 
 They're usually terrified &mdash; but, in those circumstances, you have to establish your superiority right away.&equo; 
 While the hairdressers I spoke to admitted the cult of the dominating hairdresser was strong in the last decade, they all feel it's now on it's way out. 
 Trevor Sorbie thinks the patronising attitudes of some salons can be explained by the youth of the stylists. 
 A glamorous 20-year-old who spends two hours in front of the mirror each morning is unlikely to empathise with a working mother of three. 
 &bquo;Younger stylists are also under the impression that they're getting into an exciting and glamorous business,&equo; said Trevor. 
 &bquo;They tend to think they'll be cutting trendy hairstyles all day. 
 But real  people come in all shapes and sizes.&equo; 
 Edinburgh hairdresser Charlie Miller agrees, and any employee who thought differently would be out on his ear. 
 Charlie, Avant-Garde stylist of the Year, holds very strong views about client relations and they are like music to the ear. 
 I almost booked a flight and an appointment on the spot. 
 &bquo;There isn't a problem between a hairdresser and his client as long as the hairdresser can listen, understand and interpret what the client is saying. 
 Women want to walk out feeling good. 
 Their wellbeing is in our hands, so it's our job to ensure they leave feeling uplifted.&equo; 
 Charlie's personal idea of bliss is for a long-haired client to walk in an allow him to create one of his more advanced shapes, but he would never impose his styles on an unwilling customer. 
 &bquo;I'm just as happy to do a granny's hair,&equo; he said cheerfully. 
 &bquo;I think hairdressers have got a bad reputation as so many of them try to dominate the client. 
 Techniques in hairdressing have advanced enormously and it's fantastic what you can do, but unfortunately some hairdressers abuse that power. 
 I think that attitude has been very bad for the industry as a whole. 
 Too many people have been upset by their experiences at the hands of a hairdresser.&equo; 
 Annette Mieska is in the business of putting right the damage. 
 She runs ISM, business and training consultants to the beauty and hairdressing industry, and many of her courses are devoted to improving customer care. 
 &bquo;Good technical skills are not enough,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Training in client awareness is important, too. 
 Young hairdressers must learn to treat the client as a person, not a head of hair. 
 Often they see their profession as a creative art form, which is fine as long as they recall it is also a service industry.&equo; 
 Annette's courses teach students sensitivity to body language and facial expression as well as practice in interpretative skills. 
 &bquo;After all, words like &bquo;wispy&equo; and &bquo;short&equo; mean different things to different people,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I encourage hairdressers to avoid jargon, which can be very patronising. 
 I then teach them how to check they are both on the same wavelength. 
 I think the best way to teach hairdressers might be to make them become clients. 
 How would they like a stranger to be in control of the way they look for the next six months?&equo; 
 Annette also feels strongly that the &bquo;mystique of the salon&equo; should be dissolved. 
 &bquo;They're like secret societies,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;It can be a mystery to the client how the hairdresser made her hair look that way, and she has no idea how to achieve the same effect. 
 That's not good enough. 
 You're paying for the hairdresser's services and part of that is to receive whatever information about your hair you need. 
 You should be told how to keep that look for the next eight weeks.&equo; 
 It seems that we do have some rights after all! 
 We don't have to sit there and take whatever we get. 
 We can decide what we want. 
 We cant take time to talk to the stylist before they wield the scissors. 
 We can complain if we're not treated properly. 
 But at the back of my mind a little voice says, &bquo;He's the hairdresser, he knows best, let him do what he wants and I'll walk out looking like a princess.&equo; 
 Maybe I've found my perfect hairdresser. 
 Although John Peers is very willing to listen, to advise, to agree on a style, his favourite client is the one who walks in an says, &bquo;Do whatever you think is best&equo;. 
 Some day John, you, me and my once-blonde head of hair are destined to meet&hellip; 
 Next month: don't miss our 16-page supplement on curly hair &mdash; how to look after it if you've got it, how to get it if you haven't! 
 THE WORST THINGS YOU CAN SAY TO A HAIRDRESSER 
 Another perm, please. 
 The same as usual, please. 
 I'd like a complete change of style, but don't take off more than an inch. 
 What have you done? 
 This isn't what I meant at all! 
 I'd like a Princess Di hairstyle, please. 
 My old hairdresser used to do this style, only it looked much better when he did it. 
 THE BEST THINGS YOU CAN SAY TO YOUR HAIRDRESSER 
 &bquo;Can I tell you about my hair?&equo; 
 That way, you then get his attention and he is obliged to listen to you. 
 Take time to tell him something about your tastes and lifestyle &mdash; and the sort of style you think might suit you. 
 Listen carefully to what he has to say about your hair, and the sort of style he thinks might look good on you. 
 Ask for ideas and suggestions if none are given. 
 Before he gets out his scissors, repeat what you have agreed on, to check that you're both talking the same language. 
 Bring a picture of your preferred style. 
 At least it provides a starting point to the discussion, even if it can't be copied. 
 Dress well and wear make-up to the salon. 
 This will make a favourable impression on the stylist and you'll get a more stylish haircut. 
 Get some professional tips on how to look after your hair and how to maintain the style at home. 
 The architecture of hairdressing in the 18th century at the &bquo;Academie de Coiffure&equo; in Paris 
 &bquo;My overwhelming emotion is fear. 
 I feel a victim as soon as I arrive&equo; 
 Game, set and seduction. 
 Playboy Warren Beatty homes in with the dryer on Julie Christie in the film Shampoo . 
 Pictures: The Mansell Collection: The Kobal Collection 
 &bquo;The cult of the dominating hairdresser is at last on its way out&equo; 
 twinkle toes 
 Whether it's boots or shoes, slip-ons or sandals, you're bound to take a shine to the latest in leather. 
 It'd be patently absurd to ignore them! 
 happiness is&hellip; 
 Jakki Brambles 
 She's only 23, she's got her own daily show on Radio One and she's just got married. 
 No wonder Jakki Brambles can't stop smiling. 
 When most people of her age are just setting their first tentative steps on the bottom rung of life's ladder, Radio One's most successful &mdash; and, it must be said, best-looking &mdash; female disc jockey is riding high. 
 She's not exactly miserable at home, either. 
 But to start at the beginning. 
 Jakki Brambles never had any ambitions to be a disc jockey. 
 She went to drama school on a scholarship in the Isle of Wight &mdash; a long way from her home in Ayr. 
 Rather than go straight on to drama college, she decided to take a year out to travel. 
 That required money. 
 &bquo;I didn't want to work in a shop or a bank so I wrote to my local radio station, West Sound, asking if I could make the tea.&equo; 
 Jakki had been there a week when, in true fairytale fashion, one of the regular disc jockeys upped and left. 
 It was a small station in a rural area with very few employees. 
 A week later, and aged all of 19, Jakki Brambles was broadcasting live to the west coast of Scotland. 
 &bquo;And the terrifying thing I realised very quickly was that you have to be yourself. 
 Being an actress is relatively easy in that it's someone else's words you speak. 
 Being a DJ is all down to you.&equo; 
 With her parents' move to the Isle of Aran, Jakki had next to no money for food after she'd paid her rent. 
 &bquo;I used to run competitions offering a free T-shirt to the first person who arrived at the station with a burger and chips. 
 I'd have a mountain of food for supper!&equo; 
 Despite this dodgy sideline, the station renewed Jakki's contract after three months. 
 About a year later, her fairy godmother struck again. 
 The man who had run the neighbouring Radio Clyde in Glasgow moved south to London's Capital Radio. 
 He was looking for female voices, he remembered Jakki, invited her to submit some tapes and &mdash; presto! &mdash; she was offered a job in The Smoke. 
 By then she'd saved enough money to go to Australia, but decided in the end that she could always travel later. 
 She was at Capital for 18 months. 
 It wasn't a happy experience. 
 &bquo;It was very competitive with everyone stabbing everyone else in the back as they tried to become stars. 
 I didn't fit in. 
 I was only in it for a lark.&equo; 
 After a year, Jakki considered leaving and secured a job at a tiny radio station just off Australia's Great Barrier Reef. 
 &bquo;And then, blow me, I got offered a job at Radio One. 
 Again I thought, well, the world's there whenever I want it and I had  been presented with an incredible opportunity.&equo; 
 She's been there fore 18 months now and she loves it. 
 &bquo;They were on the look-out for a female DJ so everyone was very up for me from the word go. 
 I immediately got a lot of media attention &mdash; Radio One couldn't have made me fail.&equo; 
 With her own drive-time show every evening from Monday to Thursday, Jakki is thriving. 
 &bquo;After nine months of doing the early morning show and the Breakfast Show with Simon Mayo, I was half-dead. 
 I'd been existing on two or three hours' sleep a night. 
 Now I feel human again. 
 &bquo;The early evening is my best time of day; I can also play my type of music &mdash; Harry Connick Jnr to Oleta Adams to Jesus Jones. 
 I love Frank Sinatra. 
 I love Def Leppard. 
 My taste is pretty catholic!&equo; 
 From the start, Jakki popped up on Top of the Pops . 
 &bquo;I found it very hard at first, lacking confidence about how I looked. 
 But I'm beginning to enjoy it now and I positively like my regular spot on Going Live  because I have to interview people which I love doing.&equo; 
 Even so, all her powers were put to the test when she flew to America to interview Madonna. 
 Jakki had just returned from an idyllic holiday in America (more of which in a moment) when she was told to get back on a plane because the Material girl had finally agreed to give an interview on Radio One. 
 She'll never forget it. 
 &bquo;I was given a chauffeur-driven tour of Beverly Hills and then taken to the famous Sunset Marquee Hotel.&equo; 
 The day of the interview arrived &mdash; and Madonna cancelled. 
 &bquo;I felt so let down. 
 I'd come 7,000 miles at three days' notice &mdash; and for what?&equo; 
 At last, however, the Radio One crew were told they might  get 10 minutes maximum down at the Disney Studios where Madonna as rehearsing for her world tour. 
 Eventually, the summons came. 
 Jakki was ushered into the star trailer. 
 &bquo;And it was really tough. 
 For the first 10 minutes, she sat with her back to me and refused to turn round. 
 I was frantic. 
 I knew I was meant to get an hour's worth of broadcastable material. 
 &bquo;Luckily, I'm a big fan so I knew my stuff and, gradually, Madonna softened.&equo; 
 An hour and a half later, Jakki had a great interview in the can. 
 So who else has been a memorable interviewee? 
 Well, Janet Jackson was also a challenge but, again, Jakki felt she cracked her. 
 Paul McCartney was uncomplicatedly nice. 
 And Kylie's become a positive regular. 
 &bquo;She used to be a bit of a lost soul,&equo; says Jakki, &bquo;but she's changed a lot recently and I think that's all down to Michael Hutchence. 
 She's head over heels in love &mdash; but them so am I&hellip;&equo; 
 When Jakki's parents moved to Aran, a near neighbour, Jim Sherry, agreed to keep and eye on her. 
 In time, Jakki moved to London, Jim to America to work as an exhibitions organiser. 
 They kept in touch and then, last March, Jakki took up Jim's invitation to visit him for a week's holiday. 
 &bquo;It was extraordinary. 
 Within hours of landing, we were hopelessly in love. 
 We'd been friends for so long, we couldn't understand what was happening.&equo; 
 After a week together, Jakki flew back to Britain in floods of tears, only to fly back to the States again three days later to interview Madonna. 
 &bquo;I arrived in LA mid-afternoon on the Wednesday. 
 Jim flew down from San Francisco early that evening. 
 By midnight, he'd asked me to marry him.&equo; 
 They married at Christmas. 
 So how does Jim deal with is wife's celebrity? 
 &bquo;He handles the whole situation really well,&equo; says Jakki, &bquo;but then he doesn't have an ego problem. 
 He's happy for me and proud of me, too.&equo; 
 She smiles. 
 &bquo;But then, when my work's done and I go home, I'm happy to be his wife. 
 Very happy indeed.&equo; 
 Which is where we came in.  
 &bquo;I'd wear this to a meeting at Radio One &mdash; it's rare for me to look very smart but to be taken seriously you really do have to dress seriously&equo; 
 Winning smiles. 
 Jakki Brambles interviews Kylie Minogue for Radio One (above). 
 Seriously smart (left): jacket, Marks &amp; Spencer. 
 Black polo, Blazer. 
 Leggings, French Connection. 
 All Jakki's own 
 &bquo;Leggings and hi-tops are very me &mdash; verging on the scruffy. 
 Clothes like this are good for the location filming on Going Live  &mdash; warm, comfortable and bright, which is vital for TV 
 &bquo;For Top of the Pops , I make an effort to look glammed up but not too much &mdash; the knackered shorts tone the outfit down a bit&equo; 
 &bquo;When I do go out somewhere special I like to go completely over the top in the glamour stakes &mdash; different hairdo, glittery accessories and high heels&equo; 
 DO WE BRITS GET THE CLOTHES WE DESERVE? 
 Ever felt the clothes on sale in British high streets could be better designed and better made? 
 Ever felt the Europeans do it better? 
 Hilary Burden asked for some expert views &mdash; and, overleaf, we ask your  opinion 
 Last year, I treated myself to a &pound;40 fake fur mini skirt (British label) with the latest leopard print. 
 I wore it just about half a dozen times, during which the button came off and the lining split. 
 It's now somewhere in the back of my wardrobe, waiting for Oxfam. 
 For the wear I got out of it, I probably should have paid half the price. 
 How many times have you bought something that has let you down (and not complained) or worn a garment for just one season simply because it was the latest gimmick? 
 So why aren't we, the British public, demanding better quality from our fashion manufacturers and retailers? 
 In Britain, the top end of the fashion market is ridiculously designer-expensive. 
 At the lower end, the chain store boom of the last decade means the equivalent one-season wonders may be cheap but that's exactly how long they last &mdash; one season. 
 The problem is that there's little to offer in between; high street quality seems almost a contradiction in terms. 
 So, when the trade barriers come down across Europe next year, what will be the implications for our fashion industry? 
 It's an economic argument but it's also about image &mdash; and we all know how important that has become in stereotyping countries. 
 Just think of stylist Italians clad in leather, or of the French in anything chic-but-not-denim. 
 Peter York, management consultant and author of The Harpers &amp; Queen Sloane Ranger Handbook , fears that, come 1992, Britain's fashion status will suffer. 
 According to York, the rest of Europe has distinctively different ideas about what fashion is. 
 &bquo;The home market isn't demanding enough about the quality and finish compared with its European counterparts,&equo; says York. 
 &bquo;Compounding the problem is that, compared with German manufacturing, we're still very much a sweatshop sort of industry. 
 I wish I thought better about the opportunities 1992 has to offer, but realistically I don't think we've even begun to limber up for the competition.&equo; 
 Last year, Britain's clothing exports were worth &pound;2 billion (20 per cent up on 1989's figures). 
 Half of that went to countries in the European Community, but we still lagged behind other European countries. 
 British Fashion Council Chairman Sir Ralph Halpern cites &bquo;the limited horizons of our own-label manufacturers&equo; as one of the major weaknesses. 
 &bquo;There is quite a sameness in high street stores in Britain,&equo; he told the Clothes Show Magazine , &bquo;whereas what customers really  want is more individuality. 
 If the fashion industry responded by establishing better links through design and manufacturing to the high street, it would then be able to provide the customer with a more individual product.&equo; 
 Susan James, Head of the London College of Fashion, agrees. 
 Her students, she says, are well prepared for Europe, and have been for a long time. 
 The college has produced a dictionary of fashion terms in four languages, and has also established links with a fashion college in Germany in order to swap ideas and practices. 
 The problem, as she sees it, lies with manufacturing. 
 It's not good us training designers who then just sit and work in a creative vacuum. 
 The vast bulk of mainstream manufacturers in this country don't know how to use our designers. 
 There are a lot of missing links between design and product development because of manufacturing's hidebound attitude. 
 Good designers are forced to get their stuff made in other countries simply because they can't get the quality of manufacture that they want here.&equo; 
 Katharine Hamnett is one of them. 
 She is acutely disappointed by the government's lack of investment in the clothing industry in this country, and highly critical of the industry itself, which she says just doesn't realise the potential of its designers. 
 &bquo;It's such a cruel irony,&equo; says Katharine, &bquo;that British fashion is the base of European fashion. 
 Many of the big European names are being churned out by British design teams who have been trained at the expense of the British taxpayer. 
 We're actually funding European imports into Britain instead of British exports out of it. 
 Sir Ralph Halpern believes our manufacturing industry has a great deal to learn from labels such as Benetton and Hennes in Europe, and The Gap, Ralph Lauren and Calvin Klein in the States, in terms of creating brand and image. 
 &bquo;The total turnover of our top UK designers, who are so well-publicised,&equo; he says, &bquo;doesn't match even Ralph Lauren's. 
 There is no such high street equivalent in this country, which there should be. 
 &bquo;What we need is to put more focus on creating brand-consciousness &mdash; and by that I mean everything that makes up a brand, such as style, colour, fashionableness, image, price, quality. 
 We need brands that have relevance to both the high street and European market, which is far more brand-conscious than our own.&equo; 
 There is an inherent danger in all this for our clothing industry which is that, unless manufacturers wake up, there will continue to be far more opportunity for European merchandise to come here, and little for ours to get elsewhere. 
 This, of course, would be catastrophic for the industry. 
 It's Sir Ralph Halpern's view that if it hadn't been for the current worldwide recession, many more outside brands would have been introduced to the UK market. 
 This means the real fight begins once the recession is over (Halpern believes this will be in time for the next general election, coinciding with the introduction of the Single European Market in '92). 
 &bquo;It is only when European brands land on our doorsteps and people flock to buy them that manufacturers will respond to the competitive threat,&equo; explains Halpern, &bquo;because it's a fact that British society has become complacent and insular.&equo; 
 We have to ask ourselves, as consumers, exactly what part we have to play in all this. 
 Does a disorganised clothing industry with little commercial interest in quality simply reflect our own limited needs and aspirations? 
 It's interesting to note that, while the French and the English spend similar amounts of money on clothes, the French have by far the more stylist reputation. 
 A quick poll at the French Embassy in London established that the French spend more money on fewer items &mdash; looking for quality not quantity. 
 Mignon Matthews, who runs the international modelling agency Matthews and Powell, agrees that the French are definitely top of the chic list in Europe. 
 &bquo;British girls are fairly low-key and often lack confidence,&equo; says Mignon, who scours the country auditioning potential models. 
 &bquo;They tend to want everything handed on a plate to them instead of adding their own personal touch. 
 The French are far more inventive, as are the Italians. 
 I'm aware that Britain saw many style advances in the Eighties, thanks to the high street revolution at places like Next, Principles, Richards and Marks &amp; Spencer. 
 But what we really need is a sense of ourselves &mdash; which the French and Italians simply ooze.&equo; 
 Lesson learned? 
 Maybe I'll think twice about buying the fake-fur-leopard-print-whatever next time, and spend the money on an assertiveness course instead! 
 But seriously, let's get our message to the manufacturers clear. 
 Smarten up your act or we might just stop buying British, as the Europeans take over our high streets offering us fashions with a much better image, manufactured to a much higher standard. 
 NOW TURN THE PAGE AND HAVE YOUR SAY 
 IS BRITISH BEST? 
 PART A 
 FIRST, TELL US ABOUT YOURSELF 
 1 
 How old are you................................. 
 2 
 Which country do you live in?.................................................... 
 3 
 How much money do you spend on clothes (excluding shoes and lingerie) per month? 
 under &pound;20 
 &pound;21&ndash;&pound;40 
 &pound;41&ndash;&pound;60 
 over &pound;60 
 4 
 What influences you to buy clothes? 
 a girlfriend 
 your boyfriend 
 your mother 
 advertising 
 fashion magazines 
 how other people are dressed 
 the latest fashion shows 
 5 
 Which high street store do you buy most clothes from (excluding lingerie and shoes)?.................................................... 
 6 
 How often do you feel really satisfied with a brand new outfit? 
 always 
 usually 
 sometimes 
 rarely 
 never 
 7 
 What, for you, are the most important criteria when buying clothing? 
 (Score from 1&ndash;7, 1 being the most important) 
 quality 
 original/innovative styling 
 colour 
 comfort 
 fit 
 price 
 fashionableness 
 PART B 
 NOW TELL US WHAT YOU THINK 
 8 
 Do you feel high street stores are giving you what you want in clothing? 
 Yes, on the whole they do 
 Not really, but I tolerate them 
 No, I avoid them by shopping elsewhere or making my own 
 9 
 Do you think clothes are over-priced? 
 Yes, they're a total rip-off 
 Yes, if the quality was better, prices would be more acceptable 
 No, they're about right 
 10 
 Which country do you rate as the most stylish in Europe?.................................................... 
 11 
 How would you  rate Britain's image in terms of style? 
 (Marks out of 10)................................................. 
 12 
 Please add any additional comments you may have on a separate piece of paper, in no more than 100 words. 
 If you wish to enter our lucky draw, please fill in your name and address below. 
 We're giving away 15 great cotton sweatshirts from Joe Bloggs in various autumnal colours &mdash; one size fits all. 
 Send this form to: Clothes Show Magazine  /Brit Survey, Redwood publishing, 20&ndash;26, Brunswick Place, London, N1 6DJ. 
 Name......................................... 
 Address................................................................... 
 Postcode...........  
 &bquo;British fashion manufacturing is still a sweatshop industry&equo; 
 Above: Katharine Hamnett, top fashion designers, is acutely disappointed at the government's lack of investment in the industry. 
 Right: Peter York, author: &bquo;I wish I thought better about the opportunities that 1992 has to offer&equo; 
 Left: Mignon Matthews, head of Matthews and Powell model agency, thinks the French are top of Europe's &bquo;chic list&equo; 
 Right: Sir Ralph Halpern, Chairman of the British Fashion Council: &bquo;I think, to compete with Europe, we should focus on brand-consciousness &mdash; which means everything from style, colour and image to fashionableness, quality and price&equo; 
 &bquo;Highly talented designers end up working in a creative vacuum&equo; 
 CLOTHES ON THE ROAD 
 stepping into the SIXTIES&hellip;&hellip; at CLOTHES SHOW LIVE! 
 The snow may have fallen crisp and even on the NEC in Birmingham but that didn't dampen the enthusiasm of everyone who attended Clothes Show Live . 
 Inspired by the Sixties, we asked a few brave souls to take the plunge and dress up like latter-day Twiggys. 
 Find out what happened overleaf 
 A whirlwind tour of Sixties fashion. 
 Above: Twiggy, the girl who epitomised the Sixties &bquo;look&equo;. 
 Above centre: minis, donny caps and patent boots and shoes &mdash; all authentic Sixties style. 
 Above right: I can see right through you! 
 Plastics &mdash; that here leave little to the imagination &mdash; were widely used in fashion. 
 Right: the Op Art movement heavily influenced textile design. 
 Far right: beam me up! 
 Space travel was a reality and its influence was enormous. 
 Photographs: Camera Press, Rex Features 
 The Clothes Show Magazine  team recreate the Sixties at the NEC in Birmingham 
 Richard Curtis, 20, student (far right): &bquo;I prefer a more classical look although I do like the shirt. 
 But I wouldn't wear the trousers or the hat!&equo; 
 Shirt, about &pound;50, Johnsons. 
 Leather trousers, &pound;125, Johnsons. 
 Hat, &pound;24.50, The Hat Shop 
 Denise Noel, 11, sales rep (right), and Lara Johnson, 22, window-dresser (far right): &bquo;I love this look!&equo; said Denise. 
 &bquo;I'd wear this outfit to a club,&equo; said Lara. 
 Denise's leggings, &pound;70, Wet. 
 Top, &pound;29.95, Jigsaw. 
 Belt, &pound;12.99, Pink Soda. 
 Lara's bodysuit, &pound;34.99, Komodo. 
 Boots, &pound;54.99, Shelly's 
 Nicky Ritchie, 19, student (left): &bquo;I love the jacket.&equo; 
 All-in-one, &pound;55, Jigsaw. 
 Jacket, &pound;490, Joe Casely-Hayford. 
 Hat, &pound;50, The Hat Shop. 
 Earrings &pound;2.99, River Island. 
 Shoes, Nicky's own. 
 Gail Adshed, 18, student (right): &bquo;I'd buy all but the tights.&equo; 
 Skirt, Gail's own. 
 Boots, &pound;39.99, Shelly's. 
 Rights, &pound;7.99, Mary Quant. 
 Top, &pound;27.99; pendant, &pound;4.99; earrings, &pound;5.99, Pink Soda 
 Manjit Dedgun, 18, student (above): &bquo;I'm glad the Sixties look is back in fashion. 
 The hair and eye make-up are particularly flattering. 
 I'm not sure about these clothes, thought &mdash; they're a bit weird.&equo; 
 Dress, about &pound;19.99, Komodo. 
 Mac, about &pound;120, Toute Passe. 
 Glasses, &pound;8.99, Pink Soda. 
 Kerry Richards, 22, nanny, and Robyn Williams, 18 months (right): &bquo;I like the hair but the trousers are too tight and the shoes feel really clumpy. 
 Robyn loves her outfit, though.&equo; 
 Robyn's all-in-one, &pound;18.90, Benetton. 
 Kerry's top, &pound;19.99, Komodo. 
 Trousers, &pound;39.99, Monix. 
 Shoes, &pound;39.99, Shelly's 
 Ann Jefferson, 26, marketing executive (left): &bquo;I'm naturally blonde but I think I look better as a brunette &mdash; I'm absolutely stunned. 
 The make-up's brilliant &mdash; and I'd definitely wear this catsuit.&equo; 
 Halter-neck catsuit, &pound;35, French Connection. 
 Frilly shirt, &pound;55, Red or Dead. 
 Shoes, &pound;39.99, Shelly's. 
 Earrings, &pound;2.99, River Island 
 Margaret Dixon, 20, university employee (right): &bquo;I wouldn't wear the top but I like the leggings &mdash; they're nice and bright.&equo; 
 Leggings, &pound;15.90, Benetton. 
 Top, &pound;50, Rokit. 
 Pendant, &pound;29.99, Mary Quant. 
 Sunglasses, &pound;8.99, Pink Soda. 
 Sarah Bamber, 19, company secretary (left), and Jason Boore, 21, engineer (near left): &bquo;I don't think the hair's really me but the eye make-up is very striking. 
 I love the leggings,&equo; said Sarah. 
 &bquo;I'd wear the jumper and the trousers any time,&equo; said Jason. 
 Sarah's top, &pound;34.99, River Island. 
 Leggings, &pound;24.99, Top Shop. 
 Shoes, &pound;39.99, Shelly's. 
 Earrings, &pound;6.99, Pink Soda. 
 Jason's jumper, &pound;120, Chris Parry. 
 Ski pants, &pound;58.99, Johnsons. 
 Belt, &pound;57, S-Tek 
 Janet Bond, 42, hospital employee (left): &bquo;I remember all this from the first time round! 
 It's the false eyelashes I like best.&equo; 
 Coat, &pound;54.99, Dorothy Perkins. 
 Sunglasses, &pound;8.99; earrings, &pound;6.99, Pink Soda 
 Chris Goodenough, 19, student (above): &bquo;I prefer the Seventies style, although I would wear this top.&equo; 
 Shirt, &pound;35, Red or Dead. 
 Trousers, from a selection at Benetton. 
 Shoes, &pound;60, Red or Dead. 
 Sunglasses, &pound;39.50, Samco 
 Seema Dewitt, 19, sales assistant (left): &bquo;I like the eye make-up.&equo; 
 But what about the outfit? 
 &bquo;I'd never, ever wear it again!&equo; 
 Trousers, &pound;80; jacket, &pound;125, Wet. 
 Boots, &pound;39.99, Shelly's. 
 Earrings, &pound;6.99; belt, &pound;12.99, Pink Soda 
 Kelly Pearce, three (left): said Mum &bquo;Kelly loves dressing up. 
 I'd happily buy her this.&equo; 
 Jacket, &pound;32.90; pants, &pound;9.90, Benetton. 
 Shoes, &pound;6.99 Woolworths. 
 Laurence Stone, 27, blacksmith (right): &bquo;I wouldn't wear this every day on the street but it would be good fun for a club.&equo; 
 Trouser, &pound;125, Johnsons. 
 Jumper, from a selection at Benetton. 
 Belt, &pound;19.99; pendant, &pound;29.99, both Mary Quant. 
 Sunglasses, from a selection at Samco. 
 Photographs: Peter Brown. 
 Hair and make-up: Laurence Close at Camilla Arthur; Lisa Eldridge. 
 Stockists are on page 92 
 YOUR VERY GOOD health 
 Dr Cathy Read brings you the latest on health news and views, from the dangers of drastic exercise to the benefits of sensible sleeping &mdash; and a scary tale of birds 
 BIRD ALERT 
 If you still have those old-fashioned milk bottles delivered to your door &mdash; watch out for birds! 
 Researchers in Wales have linked a stomach bug known as campylobacter jejuni , with bird attacks on milk bottles. 
 Magpies and jackdaws appear to be the major culprits and the problem occurs most in the spring. 
 If the birds do peck through the foil bottle tops, doctors warn against drinking the milk as it could be contaminated with the bug. 
 LESSENING THE PAIN OF INFERTILITY 
 A friend of mine in her late thirties has spent the last five years building up a successful business. 
 However, she recently asked what it was all for if she could not have a child. 
 After years of tests she and her partner still don't know the cause of their infertility. 
 Because of the haphazard way infertility is managed, thousands of couples are in a similar situation. 
 Fortunately, help is at hand in the form of the Infertility Management Programme, devised by Mr Rajat Goswamy, Medical Director of The Churchill Clinic Fertility and IVF Centre in London. 
 The programme is designed to find the cause of a couple's infertility in just one month. 
 It involves five or six visits to a clinic or hospital for key investigations which include blood tests, semen analysis, an ultrasound examination and a minor operation to check that the woman's tubes are clear. 
 Once the problem has been identified, the couple can start appropriate treatment &mdash; with the right treatment, Mr Goswamy predicts, many more infertile couples will conceive. 
 The Churchill Clinic charges &pound;1,050 for the basic Infertility Management Programme. 
 Alternatively, the tests can be carried out free on the NHS, and although the NHS clinics and hospitals are unlikely to be able to provide an answer within one month, Mr Goswamy believes that, with proper organisation, a three month programme should be possible on the NHS. 
 Infertility Management Programme booklets are available from The Churchill Clinic, 80 Lambeth Road, London SE1 7PW (071 928 5633). 
 Couples can also request one of the clinic's booklets for their GP which explains how to get the same tests on the NHS. 
 SPORTS INJURY 
 If you're thinking of getting into shape, take it easy and build up slowly &mdash; a frantic training programme greatly increases risk of over-use injury. 
 So, always warm up thoroughly and remember, once you have an injury, pressing on only causes further damage. 
 One sports injury on the increase is sportsman's, or Gilmore's groin which occurs when tendons in the groin tear due to excessive stretching and twisting. 
 An operation is often the only cure for this painful condition. 
 In particular, footballers are prone to Gilmore's groin &mdash; Paul Barker and Bryan Robson have both made a successful return to the sport after the operation. 
 AIR QUALITY AND THE DOE LADY 
 Call the Department of Environment's air quality information line and a lady with a cheerful voice will most probably inform you that you have been breathing &bquo;good&equo; or &bquo;very good&equo; air for the previous 24 hours. 
 If not, she will tell you that the air quality has been &bquo;poor&equo; or &bquo;very poor&equo;. 
 What, you may ask, is the meaning of it all? 
 The DOE's air quality information, also published in newspaper and television weather reports, is based on three air pollutants. 
 They are nitrogen dioxide, mainly produced by car exhausts; ozone, from car exhaust fumes reacting with sunlight; and sulphur dioxide, produced by power stations and diesel engines. 
 If levels of any of these reach the &bquo;poor&equo; category, normally healthy people may suffer from headaches and irritation of the nose and eyes. 
 Asthmatics are more prone to suffer attacks when any one of these pollutants hits the &bquo;poor&equo; mark, and some sensitive people may even be affected when the air quality is describes as &bquo;good&equo;. 
 The government hasn't yet decided what advice to issue when air quality drops off. 
 But it makes sense to limit your activity &mdash; if you exercise outdoors when air quality is poor, you're more likely to suffer adverse effects. 
 STAYING SLIM 
 Most people who actively diet usually end up piling weight back on. 
 A study carried out at the University of California in Berkeley compared woman who maintained 20 per cent weight loss over two years with dieters who relapsed. 
 The former were patient, they set small goals they could meet, stuck to their personally-devised diet plans and took regular exercise. 
 Also, while eating more healthily, they did not completely  restrict favourite foods. 
 In contrast, relapsers tended not to exercise. 
 They had lost weight by taking appetite suppressors, fasting or going on highly restrictive diets they could not sustain, avoiding all favourite foods. 
 Not surprisingly, they felt deprived and easily resumed old eating habits, often in response to stress. 
 ME AND MY jeans 
 Young or old, rich or poor, famous or not, almost everyone, it seems, owns a favourite pair of jeans. 
 Helen Carey talked to five fans 
 Everyone loves jeans &mdash; they're tough, comfortable&hellip; and sexy. 
 When Nick Kamen took off his Levi's 501s in a launderette, jeans became one of the most potent sex symbols of the past decade. 
 And, ironically, the more worn they are, the more appealing they become. 
 Jeans are a staple part of everyone's wardrobe &mdash; from the boy next door to the rich and famous. 
 And now that they can be found in every colour under the sun, they're even more versatile. 
 Coloured, bleached, stonewashed, there's little that hasn't been done to denim. 
 So what's left for the Nineties? 
 According to Manchester's The Legendary Joe Bloggs Incorporated Co, trends go in cycles. 
 So, after instigating a revival of the widest flares since Slade and The Sweet first strutted their stuff, they're all set to do the same for drainpipes. 
 And customising is all part of the fun &mdash; cut-offs, fringes, holes, patches. 
 Designer of the Year Vivienne Westwood included ripped denim in her Spring/Summer 1991 collection. 
 Already a fashion favourite, you can bet it'll be the rage this summer, too. 
 Cowboys may wear them out of necessity and convicts in the USA may have been given them as part of their uniform, but one thing's for sure, whatever the reason, most people simply wouldn't live without them. 
 IN THE BEGINNING&hellip; 
 The word jeans originates from the place name Genoa where sailors from the port hit on the idea of making trousers from the sturdy sailcloth. 
 Denim is the name of the blue woven cloth first made in the French town of Nimes. 
 So now you know! 
 JEAN GENIES 
 Nick Kamen 
 Gloria Vanderbilt 
 James Dean 
 The Waltons 
 Brooke Shields 
 Status Quo 
 Anyone from Manchester! 
 FREE! 
 FREE! 
 Shake off those blues and put a little colour into your life. 
 Levi's is offering six lucky readers the chance to win a pair of Black Tab 408 coloured jeans, worth about &pound;40. 
 Available in white, green, red, black or mustard, you're spoilt for choice. 
 Send your name and address to Clothes Show Magazine  /Levi's Offer, Redwood Publishing, 20&ndash;26 Bruswick Place, London N1 6DJ. 
 The senders of the first six cards out of the back pocket on March 15 will be the winners. 
 Don't forget to include your waist size and colour preference.  
 KEN LEHRAIN, OWNER OF KEN'S WESTERN STORE, ROMFORD. 
 &bquo;These Wranglers are good for horse riding &mdash; in other words, plenty of bum room!&equo; 
 Ken has been into western styling since he was a child. 
 He's been running his shop for the past 30 years, selling everything from garters to saddles! 
 Basic Wrangler jeans, about &pound;29 
 PADRAIG, AGED 13 MONTHS. 
 Padraig's mum, designer Charlotte Squire, said, &bquo;I prefer them to look quite large and these are a good basic style. 
 He also has a great pair of extremely shabby second-hand jeans that look brilliant!&equo; 
 Jeans, &pound;7.99, Asda 
 JANE ANDREWS, EVENTS CO-ORDINATOR, WEMBLEY CONFERENCE CENTRE. 
 &bquo;White jeans are generally pretty unforgiving but I find these comfortable and not too unflattering! 
 Although nearly every person in the country wears jeans, I think there are quite a few who shouldn't!&equo; 
 Next jeans, &pound;29.99 
 DANIELLE CLARKSON, AGED 14. 
 &bquo;The Joe Bloggs flared jeans didn't really catch on in Peterborough where I live. 
 These new ones are great. 
 All my jeans are environmentally friendly &mdash; they don't get washed very often, which of course saves on detergent!&equo; 
 Jeans, &pound;29.9, The Legendary Joe Bloggs Incorporated Co 
 MATT ROSE, MODEL. 
 &bquo;I recently shot an advertising campaign for Levi's in San Francisco. 
 It was a brilliant job to do. 
 Not only did I get to model the clothes how I liked, I got to keep them all afterwards. 
 I nearly always wear baggy 501s, but these coloured jeans are pretty good, too.&equo; 
 Black Tag 408 jeans, about &pound;40, Levi's. 
 Stockists are on page 92. 
 Styling: Helen Carey. 
 Photographs: Mel Yates 
 the ancient art of beating stress 
 Pummel life's tensions away with a new book on the Oriental art of massage. 
 Josephine Fairley reports 
 They called stress the disease of the Eighties. 
 But now that the Nineties are in full swing, has anyone out there discovered that the phones have stopped jangling, their Filofax is miraculously blank, or the traffic clogging our roads has withered to a trickle? 
 Not flipping likely. 
 All these factors &mdash; and many, many more which are now a fact of our fast-paced, deadline-packed daily lives &mdash; are still helping to create symptoms of stress to the point where a single encounter with an apparently dyslexic British Telecom directory enquiries operator can all but tip us over the brink. 
 All of us have different levels of tolerance to the demands on our mental energy. 
 And, while a little pressure can do us good &mdash; without it some of us mightn't even bother to slither out from under the Slumberdown in the mornings &mdash; too much is definitely a bad thing. 
 Doctors' surgeries are filled with sufferers from countless illnesses which often fall into the category of &bquo;stress-related&equo;: high blood pressure, anxiety, ulcers, depression, tension, exhaustion, insomnia, phobias, skin conditions such as eczema; and PMT can also worsen when we're under intense pressure. 
 It's believed that stress can actually depress the immune system, leaving us pretty to every cold and bout of flu, and also to more serious complaints. 
 Not to mention the toll it inevitably takes on our looks! 
 So, it's vital to zap stress fast whenever  it threatens to overwhelm you. 
 Strangely enough the best stress-buster of all has been around for thousands of years: massage. 
 Long favoured by those long-lived Orientals, who recognise that touch can create powerful changes in our minds and bodies, massage is fast being acknowledged by more and more people in the West as a perfect antidote to our pressure-cooker lifestyle. 
 Now, thanks to an excellent new book called Massage for Total Relaxation , by Nitya Lacroix (Dorling Kindersley, &pound;9.99, published on April 25) all of us can learn to massage the stress away whenever it builds up. 
 Although many of the massage techniques in this illustrated guide are for two people to practise on each other, as you can clearly see from the simple techniques over the page, massage is something that you can successfully achieve alone. 
 Nor does the book confine itself to a run-down of the different massage strokes; it also ventures in to the territory of relaxation tips, body awareness exercises and meditation techniques to instill a sense of calm. 
 As Nitya Lacroix explains total  relaxation isn't merely physical &mdash; it's a harmony between body and spirit, an elusive state which surely all of us strive for. 
 But when it works, &bquo;beneficial change is brought to the vital organs, the mind is calmed, the emotions are settled, and our sense of wholeness is restored&equo;. 
 According to Ms Lacroix, all of us, in response to events in our lives, build up a &bquo;body armour&equo;, a personal pattern of tension and strain creating harmful postural habits. 
 Do you scrunch up your shoulders a lot? 
 Stand with your arms tightly clasped in front of your body? 
 All these things prevent the body's energy flowing smoothly, and those energy &bquo;road-blocks&equo; are not only the result of stress &mdash; they can also compound the problem. 
 Self-massage can help break through this built-up tension &mdash; and, luckily, the most effective zones for self-massaging are the hands and feet. 
 Without even being aware of it, tension &bquo;collects&equo; there &mdash; so when it all gets too much for your, you can slip off your shoes and unwind with a little self-massage, without getting too many strange looks from colleagues. 
 As a preventative, anti-stress technique, self-massage sets you up perfectly for the day ahead &mdash; and works brilliantly as an end-of-day treat. 
 Try it after a relaxing bath or shower when you can indulge in a little pampering with aromatic oils and lotions to make the whole experience more enjoyable. 
 Simply turn the page for the exercises we've chosen specially for you from Massage for Total Relaxation  &mdash; and then face the world with a new sense of inner calm. 
 Who knows, you may never blow your top in a traffic jam again! 
 Your step-by-step guide to self-massage 
 Simple, quick and satisfying, self-massage prepares you for the day ahead, restoring energy and easing tension from a weary body. 
 As well as being relaxing, it keeps your skin in good condition, and boosts your self-esteem. 
 Care for your body using the strokes below and regularly massage the different areas you can comfortably reach. 
 Pay attention to your hands and feet, which are constantly under pressure and strain, and you will find your whole body benefits. 
 MASSAGE STROKES 
 By applying tapping, pummelling and squeezing strokes to many different areas of the body, you will eventually feel both supple and relaxed. 
 The vibration created with tapping strokes revitalizes the body. 
 Pummelling invigorates by boosting the circulation towards the skin and stimulating the nerve endings, and it gives the body a glowing, toned look. 
 Squeezing strokes help restore you after a tiring day by alleviating tension from tight, sore muscles. 
 Tapping 
 This stroke is particularly good in areas where the flesh fits tightly over the bone, such as the scalp, forehead and upper chest. 
 Keep your wrists loose, elbows at right angles, and tap your fingertips quickly and rhythmically over the area. 
 When working on the scalp, start at the front of the head and move over the back, down the sides to the neck. 
 Pummelling 
 To break down tension in the shoulders and arms, buttocks and thighs, make loose fists and, keeping your elbows and wrists relaxed, drum quickly over the flesh. 
 Let the hand spring away as it touches the skin. 
 Use one hand on the arms, shoulders and neck, two on the lower part of your body. 
 Squeezing 
 To boost circulation in the thighs and calves, place your hands on the skin, fingers pointing away from you. 
 Press with the thumbs and fingers to scoop up flesh, squeeze gently but firmly, and slowly release. 
 FOOT MASSAGE 
 As well as relaxing the feet, a foot massage relieves the posture and back. 
 Sit on a stool and massage one foot at a time by placing it on your thigh, knee bent up at a right angle. 
 To relax the feet totally, start by soaking them in for 20 minutes in some herbal bath salts. 
 Close your eyes, breathe deeply and relax your body. 
 Dry each foot by wrapping it in a towel and squeezing all over. 
 At the end of the massage, briskly rub your feet to revitalize your energy. 
 Squeeze the calves to remove stiffness. 
 Rotate the ankle five times in each direction. 
 Stroke around the ankle bone with your thumb and fingers. 
 Next, hold the foot between both your hands for about a minute or two to soothe it. 
 Using a firm press-release motion, work alternate thumb pads rhythmically over the surface of the sole. 
 Start at the ridge at the base of the toes and work to outside edge of the heel. 
 Support the foot with one hand. 
 With the other thumb pad make tiny circles from the top of the arch to the inner edge of the heel. 
 Repeat three times. 
 Make a loose fist with your right hand and firmly slide your knuckles from the outside edge of the heel to the base of the toes. 
 Repeat this three times. 
 Now, gently stretch-pull each of your toes between your thumb and index finger. 
 HAND MASSAGE 
 To keep your hands supple and free from tension, massage them frequently. 
 This is very important if your work involves many repetitive movements, or pushing, pulling, typing and gripping tools. 
 Use your thumbs, fingers and the heels of your hand to stroke and stretch the muscles and tendons in the hands in wrists. 
 Invigorate your hands at the end of a massage by rubbing them together until vibrant, then relax them. 
 Flex your wrist up and down, and rotate it several times in both directions. 
 To massage your palm, support the back of your hand with your fingers and make small rotary motions with your thumb pad over one spot at a time. 
 Massage the mound at the base of the thumb very well. 
 Start below the lowest knuckle and pull along each finger and thumb with your other thumb and index finger. 
 Press the fingertips. 
 Then wiggle the finger and thumb joints. 
 Support the hand with your fingers. 
 Slide your thumb down between each tendon, from beside the knuckle to the wrist. 
 Using pressure from your thumb pad, squeeze the web of your hand with thumb and index finger, making rotary movements on one spot at a time. 
 To ease tight hands, place them together, palm facing palm, elbows at right angles. 
 Slowly raise elbows so your palms separate and fingers press together.  
 Fig 1 
 Fig 2 
 Fig 3 
 Fig 5 
 Fig 6 
 Fig 7 
 Fig 8 
 Fig 9 
 Fig 12 
 CLOTHES SHOW NEXT MONTH 
 100 NEW IDEAS TERRIFIC TROUSER SUITS&hellip; 
 RAINWEAR FOR KIDS&hellip; 
 CUT A DASH IN A CARDI&hellip; 
 HIGH GLAMOUR IN LUTON 
 WIN! 
 WIN! 
 WIN! 
 THE MAKEOVER OF A LIFETIME FROM BOOTS 
 SPECIAL REPORT OUR GUIDE TO BRITAIN'S TOP HEALTH FARMS 
 EXCLUSIVE A 16-PAGE SUPPLEMENT ALL ABOUT CURLY HAIR 
 PLUS! 
 GARY GLITTER JULIAN CLARY MICA PARIS 
 ON SALE MARCH 18 PRICE &pound;1 
 CLOTHES SHOW COMPETITION 
 WIN A WARDROBE! 
 &pound;5,000 worth of fabulous Freemans  fashions to be won 
 1st PRIZE 
 &mdash; Two first prize winners will each win &pound;1,000 of high quality fashion goods of their choice from the Freemans catalogue 
 2nd PRIZE 
 &mdash; Four runners-up will be spoilt for choice and each win &pound;500 to spend at Freemans 
 3rd PRIZE 
 &mdash; Five runners-up will each win &pound;200 worth of Freemans fashions &mdash; style at your fingertips! 
 ENTRY FORM 
 Shopping together 
 Cooking a meal for two 
 Arranging surprise weekends away 
 Remembering special occasions 
 Buying flowers 
 Sharing chores 
 Name 
 Address 
 Postcode 
 Tick box if you would like to receive a copy of the Freemans spring/summer 1991 catalogue 
 Please tick if you DO NOT want to receive further information linked to this competition 
 Send your entry to: Clothes Show Magazine , Freemans Competition, PO Box 43, St Leonards-On-Sea, TN38 9NM, to arrive by March 18, 1991 
 Age (please tick) under 20 20&ndash;25 25&ndash;30 30&ndash;40 40&ndash;50 50 plus 
 You can win a complete new wardrobe for yourself and your man, so read on! 
 Freemans and the Clothes Show Magazine  have got together to bring you this fantastic competition. 
 The two first prize winners can each choose &pound;1,000 worth of items from the Freemans catalogue, and there are fabulous second and third prizes to be won. 
 Shopping by mail order at Freemans is not only easy but pleasurable as well. 
 So, if your man baulks at the idea of trailing around the shops, then this is the competition for you and  him. 
 As well as offering high quality womenswear, Freemans has launched the 1991 spring/summer menswear collection with something for everyone. 
 The Freemans man wears pastels in up-to-date shades of blush pink, powder green and pale cream. 
 Tailored suits are teamed with polo-shirts and, if he's the outdoor type, there are pages of sports-inspired casual wear. 
 On the opposite page we've put together three outfits from the Freemans catalogue spring/summer collection &mdash; just to give you an idea of what you  could win. 
 Cool, refreshing pastel shades are just right for a long hot summer! 
 Using the unrivalled Freemans mail order service means a complete wardrobe could be delivered to your door without the hustle and bustle of the high street. 
 To complement the collection, Freemans offers its own exclusive brand names like B-90's jeanwear and the Club Clothing collection, alongside established labels like Ben Sherman, Reebok, Levi's and British Knights. 
 If you're interested in the new Freemans spring/summer 1991 catalogue, order by calling free on 0800 900 200 quoting X09. 
 The Freemans orderline is open 24 hours a day, seven days a week, and items are delivered free. 
 They also offer interest-free credit for up to 50 weeks. 
 It's easy shopping at your fingertips! 
 So why not put pen to paper and win a wardrobe of fashions. 
 Enter our fantastic competition &mdash; you'd be mad not to! 
 HERE'S WHAT TO DO 
 All you have to do is put the qualities for the Man of the Nineties listed on the coupon in order of what you consider to be important, from one to six. 
 So, if you think &bquo;cooking a meal&equo; is most important, write 1 in the relevant box on the coupon, and so on. 
 Competition rules are on page 92. 
 COMPETITION RULES 
 1 
 The competition is open to all readers resident in the UK, except employees of Freemans, Redwood Publishing Ltd, BBC, their families and agents. 
 2 
 Entries must be received no later than first post on Monday March 18, 1991. 
 3 
 No responsibility can be accepted for entries lost in the post. 
 4 
 Prizes are as stated only. 
 No cash alternatives will be given. 
 5 
 Only one entry per person. 
 Entries can be on a postcard laid out in the manner of the entry coupon. 
 6 
 The decision of the judging panel is final. 
 No correspondence will be entered into. 
 7 
 All entrants to the competition are deemed to have accepted the rules and agreed to be bound by them. 
 HAIR'S TO YOU! 
 Picture yourself with a fabulous change of image and, for some of you, it could come true &mdash; thanks to Wella. 
 Famous for their hair care products, Wella want you to experience their benefits to the fullest. 
 No fewer than 12 lucky readers, representing six different regions including Northern Ireland, will be invited to London to have their hair dramatically transformed. 
 We're looking for six pairs of women &mdash; friends, mother and daughter, sisters, it doesn't matter &mdash; both  y of whom would like to have a radical new haircut, maybe a perm, or even a change of colour. 
 It's not for the faint-hearted but, if you're prepared to put your hair in Wella's hands, we're sure you won't be disappointed. 
 You'll be invited to London, all expenses paid, on March 26 and 27 as one of the six couples, and you'll stay overnight in six comfortable twin-bedded rooms in the Regent Crest Hotel, situated in the West End. 
 And there's more! 
 On the evening of March 26 there will be a celebratory dinner at the Campana Restaurant in Marylebone High Street for everyone involved to really let their hair down. 
 All you have to do is to decide you want a complete transformation, find a partner who also wants one and send us a recent photograph of each of you (we'll return them if you enclose an SAE). 
 The successful candidates will also be able to see the finished results of their new look in the June edition of the Clothes Show Magazine . 
 For the chance of a lifetime, simply fill in the coupon and send it to the address below, together with your photographs, no later than Monday March 4, 1991. 
 APPLICATION FORM 
 Name 
 Address 
 Telephone 
 Northern Ireland 
 Scotland 
 The North 
 The Midlands/Wales 
 The South West 
 The South East/East Anglia 
 Please tick the region you represent 
 Send your entry form and photographs to: Clothes Show Magazine  /Wella competition, Redwood Publishing, 20&ndash;26 Brunswick Place, London N1 6DJ. 
 you're looking swell, baby! 
 Pregnancy is a condition, not an illness. 
 So there's no excuse for letting your appearance go to pot &mdash; as these star mums amply prove 
 Controversy may have raged round the royal head of Marina Ogilvy but she had the good sense to choose a dress she could wear after her baby was born 
 Yazz (right), the living embodiment of radiant motherhood, arrives, smiling, at the BRIT awards 
 If you're going to have one, then have a big one is the motto of Brigitte Nielsen (right) 
 Working girl she may be but, having turned 40, Sigourney Weaver (right) took time out for motherhood 
 &bquo;Well, ah declare!&equo; 
 Jerry Hall swaps maternal notes with Ursula Andress (left) 
 Anneka's challenge (below) was having a baby in exactly nine months 
 Pamela Stephenson (right) looks terrific with only moments to go &mdash; and she'll be able to wear the outfit later 
 &bquo;Lady&equo; Geldof (right) steps out in style in a little white number 
 Miami nice! 
 Don Johnson holds on to a chic Melanie Griffith (above) 
 Yep, even pregnant, the flawless Yasmin Le Bon (near left) looks fabulous 
 Oh dear! 
 A barely recognisable Bette Midler (left) breaks nearly every maternity-wear rule &mdash; and it shows 
 Sally Whittaker (left) and Gail Tilsley (above) before giving birth to a couple of cushions in Coronation Street  
 Sadie Kemp &mdash; wife of Gary (left) &mdash; didn't let impending motherhood cramp her fashion style 
 The Grand Young Duchess of Pork (right) before  she became Slimmer of the Year 
 CLOTHES SHOW offer 
 stylish sweatshirts, T-shirts, jogging bottoms, baseball caps, plus bags and catalogues 
 Due to popular demand, here is another chance to look great in our exclusive Clothes Show  casual gear. 
 Comfortable and stylish, the collection includes T-shirts, sweatshirts (with or without hoods), jogging bottoms and baseball caps. 
 They're made from a hardwearing cotton/polyester mix (black and white T-shirts are all cotton) and come in black, white or grey. 
 Choose any combination of colours to suit you. 
 Complete with the distinctive Clothes Show  logo, they're good-looking, practical and excellent value for money. 
 Plus, there's a unique opportunity for you to purchase a Clothes Show Live  carrier bag and catalogue. 
 Priced at &pound;3.50 at the NEC show, we're offering them for only &pound;2.50, inclusive of postage and packing. 
 You can't lose! 
 To order: complete coupon in block capitals and send to Clothes Show Magazine  Offer, Dept 6, Banaman, 97 King Street, Cambridge CB1 1LD. 
 Allow up to 28 days for delivery. 
 Enquiries phone 0223 314868. 
 Offer subject to availability and open to readers resident in the United Kingdom. 
 If not entirely satisfied, return within 14 days for a full refund. 
 All prices include VAT and p&amp;p. 
 CLOTHES SHOW CLUB 
 become a priority reader 
 Keep perfect time, have a passionate kiss, take a balloon trip and have your favourite magazine delivered to you! 
 Kiss-A-Glam 
 We've chosen the ultimate seductive gift &mdash; the world's first renewable lipstick, in passionate red. 
 All Club Members will receive an Endless Kiss lipstick in Eternal Poppy, to give their lips prolonged pulling power. 
 These new lipsticks contain thousands of colour fluid capsules which are released every time lips are pressed together &mdash; from drinking, or even from kissing! 
 Endless Kiss gives a smooth finish and it contains a protective sunscreen. 
 Although Club members will receive this luscious lipstick free of charge with their magazine, Endless Kiss lipsticks can be bought from Avon for &pound;2.99. 
 High Fliers 
 Our free-entry competition could whisk you away from it all on the romantic trip of a lifetime. 
 We've got together with Flying Pictures to take you and your partner on a hot-air balloon ride, drifting through the air with a bird's-eye view of the local countryside. 
 British Rail travel to the nearest take off point, and champagne will be included on the trip. 
 We're also giving away a cosy pair of totes Toasties &mdash; unique mittens for feet, with treaded soles &mdash; and a pair of gloves to keep you both warm on your flight. 
 50 runners-up will also receive a pair of Toasties. 
 See the Club letter for how to enter. 
 Timely Offer 
 Evening elegance can be let down by everyday watch wear. 
 But we have organised a massive discount from Lorus Quartz, to add glamour to your night-time fashion. 
 These classic ladies' wrist watches have a teardrop-shaped face and a delicate bracelet to grace your wrist. 
 Choose from a pearl bracelet with matching face, a patterned silver bangle, or a gilt-finished double strand bracelet. 
 All three models come complete with battery, gift box and a 12-month guarantee. 
 Reduced almost to half price, this is an offer to watch out for! 
 Normally priced at &pound;34.99, we are able to offer these beautiful watches at just &pound;17.99. 
 See the Club letter for details on how to take advantage of this great offer. 
 Join the Club 
 Don't miss out on the fun! 
 Join our Clothes Show  Club today. 
 It's great value &mdash; for &pound;15 you receive: 
 * 
 Your favourite magazine sent to your home each month for a year 
 * 
 Exclusive discounts off high street clothes and accessories 
 * 
 A host of free gifts sent to you throughout the year 
 * 
 Easy to win competitions 
 PRIORITY CLUB APPLICATION FORM 
 I wish to become a member of the Clothes Show  Priority Club 
 Name 
 Address 
 Postcode 
 Telephone 
 I enclose my cheque/postal order for &pound;15 for one year's membership to the Priority Club, payable to Redwood Publishing Limited. 
 Or debit my Visa/Access Card No. 
 Expiry Date.................. 
 I wish my membership to commence with the.................... 
 Issue (Please state month) 
 Return to: Clothes Show  Priority Club, 15 Moorhurst Road, Castleham Industrial Estate, St. Leonards-On-Sea, East Sussex, TN38 9NB.  
 A new world beckons. 
 Win a hot-air balloon trip for two &mdash; and some totes Toasties (below) 
 Keep elegant time with our Lorus Quartz dress watch offer (top) and sustain some passion with our Endless Kiss free gift lipstick (above) 
 Ask Jeff 
 Worried about your looks? 
 Jeff Banks is here to help 
 PETITE FEET 
 My biggest headache is shoes! 
 I am 5&ft; 1&ins; tall and a size 10&ndash;12, but only take size 2&frac12;&ndash;3 in shoes. 
 Please don't tell me to buy children's shoes as I already do so when I need a flat pair, but I like high heels and am finding it increasingly difficult to buy them. 
 I am also on a limited budget. 
 Any answers, please? 
  Mrs Jean Little, Leeds  
 I sympathise with your problem: being advised to wear children's shoes is not really the answer, is it? 
 However, all is not lost! 
 Marks &amp; Spencer have most of their styles in a size 3 for ladies, as do Dolcis branches nationwide. 
 Gamba, the dancewear shop, have a size 2&frac12; and 3 in ladies' evening shoes. 
 Phone them on 071 437 0704 for mail order. 
 FASHION FACE-LIFT 
 I'm sure you've heard it thousands of times before but I am fed up with the way I look. 
 I have dark skin and hair and am a size 16. 
 Working as an au pair I spend most of my time in the house with young children, so I dress casually &mdash; usually in tracksuits or jeans. 
 I need to be practical but would like to look feminine as well. 
 Shopping is restricted to my day off. 
 Can you solve my dilemma? 
  Ren&eacute; Margaux, Bradford  
 Firstly, think about your hair and make-up &mdash; maybe try a new hairstyle which could dramatically change you. 
 Look through magazines to find the kind of style you'd like. 
 For clothes, I suggest catalogues for a good selection. 
 Also, try Richard Shops or the latest Country Casuals range. 
 Go in and tell the assistant you just need to try things on before you start buying anything, and enjoy the experiment. 
 Fashion Extra is one excellent catalogue catering for larger sizes. 
 Call 0800 269396, or write to FREEPOST 5, London W1E 4NN. 
 LIP READ 
 My lips are often chapped and sore, which makes it difficult to apply lipstick as it won't stay on and looks unpleasant. 
 I use lipsalve but it doesn't seem to work. 
 What should I do? 
  Annabel Jules, Hendon  
 Lips chap in the cold and burn in the sun so they need constant protection. 
 Blisteze is good for this problem. 
 Use hourly or apply moisturiser every hour over a few days, with a touch of Vaseline to follow. 
 If you use a greasy lip block under your lipstick, the lipstick will just slide off. 
 Lipsalve is basically a wax which is okay to stop moisture loss but, for intensive healing, moisturiser and Vaseline are best. 
 Make your own natural remedy by melting 40g of beeswax in a double boiler, blending in 30g of honey and then 55g of sesame oil. 
 Finally whisk to a smooth consistency and stir &mdash; you'll find it works a treat! 
 ON THE PISTE 
 I'm going skiing next month for the first time. 
 I would really like to wear some fashionable clothes on the slopes but haven't got a clue where to start looking. 
 Do you know of any shops selling ski wear which looks good and is reasonably priced? 
  Antony Jevans, Guildford  
 Most good sports departments in the major stores sell ski war but there are some excellent specialists. 
 Try Ellis Brigham (081 890 6116 for details) and Snow and Rock (0753 830868 for mail order). 
 My tip is to go for really good quality ski pants in black with braces and team that with a jacket that suits your style. 
 I suggest starting with a cheaper jacket until you get hooked &mdash; and you can always wear it at weekends afterwards. 
 Layering is vital so good thermal vests and long johns are a must. 
 Make sure your ears are protected and get good gloves. 
 Alternatively, Ski World does a great hire service and you can buy on your return. 
 They are at 41 North End Road, London W14 (071 602 4820). 
 CARING FOR SUEDE 
 I recently purchased an expensive pair of brown suede shoes. 
 However, I find it difficult to keep them clean. 
 Can you suggest a special cleaner I can use that will not spoil the colour? 
  Paul Stockwell, Buckinghamshire  
 Suede shoes do take an effort to keep them looking good. 
 If you've just bought suede shoes I suggest you spray them with suede guard to prevent them getting dirty. 
 Punch make one for &pound;1.95. 
 Also, invest in a wire or rubber suede brush to lift the nap of the suede. 
 Then, give them a Meltonian shampoo (&pound;1.85) regularly. 
 All of these items can be bought from department stores. 
 I have a pair of brown suede brogues that are really worn and I prefer them in their frazzled state! 
 HAIR-RAISING! 
 I have long dark hair which I have to wear tied back for college. 
 I am fed up with French plaits and ponytails and refuse to wear my hair in a bun. 
 Any other ideas? 
  Juliet Leo, Hove  
 There's nothing wrong with a bun as long as you decorate it with a hair accessory. 
 Lots of hairdressers now have accessory counters so why not have a rummage? 
 Emma Peel hairbands are still okay, although they're becoming less fashionable, but snoods are upcoming. 
 A snood is like a hairband with a net attached to it. 
 Fenwicks of Bond Street in London have a great selection on offer. 
 EYE CONTACT 
 I wear contact lenses and find that eye make-up, particularly mascara, irritates my eyes. 
 Do you know of any good products &mdash; for example, a mascara that doesn't flake when it dries? 
  Danielle Clifford, York  
 Firstly, buy a good quality moisturising/conditioning mascara &mdash; avoid anything that has extra fibres to lengthen lashes. 
 Apply one coat only, as more than one coat encourages flaking. 
 Almay produce a hypo-allergenic range. 
 Try their new moisturising treatment mascara at &pound;6.95. 
 Elizabeth Arden also have an excellent mascara. 
 Both products are available from chemists and department stores. 
 If you have a fashion or beauty problem, write to Jeff Banks, Clothes Show Magazine , 20&ndash;26, Brunswick Place, London, N1 6DJ. 
 Sorry, no personal correspondence. 
 FREE! 
 A SAMPLE OF SENSIQ GENTLE BALANCED MOISTURISING LOTION 
 If not attached, see your newsagent 
 1OO NEW IDEAS SIZZLING SUMMER FASHION FROM THE HIGH STREET 
 WIN! 
 A WEEK AT A HEALTH FARM 
 EXTRA! 8 PAGES OF GREAT NEW HAIRSTYLES 
 PLUS! 
 GIORGIO ARMANI JEFF BANKS GLORIA ESTEFAN 
 Contents 
 EDITOR'S LETTER 
 June is for Giorgio, Jonathon, a couple of jolly clever patterns &mdash; and just about anything else you care to mention. 
 Meet the man with the surname everyone knows, Giorgio Armani, who arguably adorns more bodies worldwide than any other living designer. 
 But who is he? 
 Anthea Gerrie flew to Milan to meet the man in person, exclusively for the Clothes Show Magazine . 
 Jonathon Morris is a young man going places. 
 You'll know him as Adrian from BBC1's Bread . 
 But not for much longer. 
 Oh, he's not abandoning his most famous role; but he's about to pop up in all sorts of other places &mdash; and sporting a groovy new haircut&hellip; 
 Betty Jackson may well be a designer whose clothes you admire but whose price tags you can't afford. 
 Handy with a needle? 
 Then turn to page 18 and take advantage of two of her patterns offers from Vogue &mdash; both at a smart price &mdash; and produce six essential items for summer. 
 Plus, there's some really smashing fashion for you &mdash; and him; eight pages of terrific new hairstyles, courtesy of Wella, for 12 lucky readers; and your  chance to win a week at a fabulous health farm. 
 Like they say, June is busting out all over! 
  Richard Barber  
 FEATURES 
 4 20 SIZZLING SWIMSUITS 
 &hellip; to help you splash out in style 
 10 GIORGIO ARMANI 
 Meet the man behind the label 
 18 SIX EASY PIECES 
 &hellip; from two designer patterns 
 22 ALL ABOUT GLORIA 
 Why Ms Estefan has never felt better 
 26 WHAT AN OFFER! 
 Just the swimsuit for summer &mdash; and just the robe, too! 
 28 WELLA! 
 WELLA! 
 WELLA! 
 12 lucky readers get the hairstyle of their dreams 
 38 JONATHON MORRIS MOVES CENTRE STAGE 
 And even Adrian Boswell wouldn't recognise him! 
 42 AND THE LIVING IS EASY&hellip; 
 Pretty comfortable ways to while away the summer 
 50 FRENCH DRESSING 
 Pure chic for you &mdash; et lui 
 58 WHAT THEY'RE WEARING IN LEEDS 
 And where to go when you're there 
 61 BETTER BY DESIGN 
 We follow the fortunes of a Smirnoff Student Awards finalist 
 66 PEPSI AND SHIRLIE&hellip; 
 Striking a brand new pose 
 71 BURSTING INTO BLOOM 
 The Clothes Show Magazine  &mdash; and Pretty Polly &mdash; pop up in Manchester 
 78 AND THE BRIDE WORE&hellip; 
 Whiskers! 
 No kidding! 
 82 ME AND MY HAT 
 How to keep one step ahead 
 86 STRAW GALORE 
 Little extras that look a lot of fun 
 94 WHO WEARS WHAT ON THEIR WEDDING DAY 
 You'd be amazed! 
 REGULARS 
 7 UPFRONT FASHION 
 All that's new on the fashion front 
 8 UPFRONT BEAUTY 
 All that's new on the beauty front 
 64 YOUR VERY GOOD HEALTH 
 Dr Cathy Read with the latest medical news, views and research 
 80 JOIN THE CLUB 
 Become a Priority Member and reap the rewards 
 92 STOCKISTS 
 Where to buy our featured clothes 
 COMPETITION 
 94 WIN A WEEK AT A HEALTH HYDRO 
 &hellip; four times over! 
 THE BOTTOM LINE 
 by Alison Everitt 
 THE RECYCLED WEDDING&hellip; 
 DRESS WORN BEFORE. 
 GROOM MARRIED BEFORE.  
 SPLASH OUT! 
 20 SIZZLING SWIMSUITS FOR SUMMER 
 IN THE SWIM 
 &bull; Most professional male swimmers shave off their body hair to make them more streamlined and thus swim faster. 
 Of course, Duncan Goodhew doesn't have to &mdash; he's a natural winner. 
 &bull;: One of the world's best and most versatile swimming pools is Ponds Forge International Swimming Pool in Sheffield. 
 It's got two moveable walls to change the size and floating floors to change the depth. 
 &bull;: The 1930s saw the demise of the overly modest bathing costume, and the reason was sunbathing, not bathing. 
 Suddenly it was in vogue to have an all-over tan &mdash; so the barer the body the better!  
 upfront fashion 
 Stylish tips from us to you&hellip; from saving elephants to wrestling kids! 
 PURE JEANIUS! 
 Casualwear pioneer BSCO has crossed jeans with sweatshirt joggers and come up with Sweat Jeans. 
 These unisex classic jeans made from soft cotton jersey are cut just like their denim equivalents and have double stitching and metal studs. 
 Available in navy and black detailing, black with wine and vice versa. 
 Sweat Jeans cost only &pound;30 from BSCO stockists nationwide &mdash; call 081 451 2155 for details. 
 As a special offer, we've got 35 pairs of Sweat Jeans to give away. 
 Send your name, address, size (S, M, L) and colour choice to Clothes Show  /BSCO, 34 Bridge Road, London, NW10 9BX. 
 Offer closes June 14. 
 PLAIN &amp; SIMPLE 
 Classic styles in mouthwatering colours are the ingredients that make up Great Plains &mdash; a new range from French Connection. 
 Shapes are kept simple &mdash; shirts and T-shirts &mdash; and fabrics are pure cotton or silk. 
 From fern to sunflower, strawberry to maize, there's a kaleidoscope of shades &mdash; so why not try a new shade this summer? 
 REALLY WILD 
 Elefriends, the charity set up to help African elephants, is &pound;8,000 better off thanks to Monsoon. 
 It received &pound;1 for each &bquo;Viva Elephant&equo; T-shirt to support Greenpeace. 
 For more information on Elefriends call 0306 713320. 
 IT'S A FREEBIE! 
 This stripy suit for mini wrestlers is a heart-melting design from Manhattan Kids, and it's ideal for swimming and all kinds of sports. 
 We've got 13 of the red and blue striped cotton/Lycra suits, worth &pound;16 each, to give away. 
 Call 0839 900091 before June 14 with your name, address and child's age (from 6 months to 2 years). 
 Calls charged at 33p/minimum cheap rate, 44p/minimum other times. 
 Call 0388 420088 for a Manhattan Kids catalogue. 
 ONE STEP AHEAD 
 We've got five pairs of the new ladies' red suede Dance trainers from Matchstick, worth &pound;24.99, to give away &mdash; they come in black (right) and blue, too. 
 Send your name, address and shoe size on a postcard to Clothes Show Magazine  /Matchstick, 20-26 Brunswick Place, London, N1 6DJ. 
 Winners drawn on June 14. 
 Available from Freeman Hardy Willis, Barratts and Tandem. 
 SORRY! 
 In our May issue, we forgot to credit the jacket pictured in &bquo;Down Town Dressing Up&equo; (left). 
 It comes from Principles and costs &pound;95.  
 upfront beauty 
 From boys' own beauty to designers who make scents &mdash; all for you 
 IT'S A FREEBIE! 
 Finesse Intensive Conditioner is an ideal way of treating holiday hair, repairing damage done by sun, sea and chlorine. 
 We have 100 tubs, worth &pound;2.49 each, to give away. 
 Call 0839 0900092 before June 14 with your name and address. 
 Calls charged at 33p/minimum cheap rate, 44p/minimum other times. 
 HEAD START 
 Leading hairdressers have very clear designs on your head this summer. 
 Keith at Smile in London would like to be &bquo;shaving hair into strong shapes, styles that are forward-looking and not Sixties.&equo; 
 Pam Roscoe, UK Art Director at Vidal Sassoon says, &bquo;Styles will be more dishevelled and bohemian.&equo; 
 Antoinette, leading stylist at Trevor Sorbie, predicts: &bquo;The look will be soft and off the face.&equo; 
 A final tip from Charles Worthington at Worthington's: &bquo;In a recession people expect value for money. 
 They want a strong haircut that everyone will notice.&equo; 
 The choice is yours&hellip; 
 LIPSMACKING 
 New from Cosmetics To Go, &bquo;Mistress's Lipstick&equo; comes in a tin with sandpaper to sharpen the crayon. 
 New Gikaku lip creams include dark Gluhwein and iridescent Blue Pearl. 
 Call 0800 373366 for their catalogue. 
 OH BOY! 
 Beauty for boys is a growing business &mdash; it's not just the girls who enjoy pampering themselves. 
 Brylcreem cater for the complexion-conscious male with Sensus, five new skincare products &mdash; skin-sensitive Shaving Foam and Gel, soothing After Shave Gel and Mousse, plus a Moisturiser. 
 Clinique have a no-nonsense approach to men's skincare &mdash; dermatologically-tested products in simple packing. 
 Their range includes an Anti-Blemish cover-up cream &mdash; because, despite what they might say to the contrary, boys like to hide their spots, too! 
 As the ultimate luxury, hairdressers Molton Brown have created a men-only salon for boys to get a haircut in peace! 
 Molton Brown will also provide them with a deeply relaxing scalp massage at the same time. 
 Telephone 071 499 2046 for further details. 
 COVER STORY 
 To be kind to your skin, why not try the mild products from Sensiq's new collection of skincare products? 
 Developed for three skin types, the cleansers, toners and moisturisers are all pure and fragrance-free. 
 Test the gentleness for yourself with this month's cover gift &mdash; a fab sample of Sensiq's Gentle Balanced Moisture Lotion. 
 Enriched with Vitamin E, the lotion is light to apply and perfect for you sensitive skin sufferers. 
 Lovely stuff, lucky you! 
 HEAVEN SCENT 
 Paris fashions may be just for the rich, but the rest of us can enjoy beauty products from the designers. 
 C'est La Vie (above) from Christian Lacroix is a powerfully floral fragrance &mdash; not  for those who like a subtle smell. 
 And now, body and bath products have been added to the range. 
 Prices start from &pound;8.50. 
 Equit&eacute; from Christian Dior lends elegance to your cleansing routine. 
 Beautiful packaging and sensitive formulas make these six products a very classy way to clean your face. 
 Prices from &pound;7.95.  
 giorgio armani &mdash; the man behind the label 
 He's one of the most famous names in fashion but little is known of the man himself. 
 Exclusively for the Clothes Show Magazine , Anthea Gerrie flew to Milan to meet Giorgio Armani on his own home ground and put a face to the name. 
 As the rain beat a dull rhythm on Milan's sludge-coloured buildings this spring, Italian designers were proclaiming the return of brilliant colour behind the facades of the word's most industrial fashion capital. 
 Versace dazzled with psychedelic prints, Dolce &amp; Gabbana sent corsets disguised as frocks shrieking down the catwalk and even the conservative Genny showed micro-skirted green and orange checks instead of the restrained tailoring that made them, made Milan&hellip; made Italy the world's leading fashion force. 
 Only one Milanese was still proclaiming that &bquo;greige&equo; is good &mdash; and even he sent out token blasts of red, purple and pink to acknowledge a hankering for colour which he personally does not believe in. 
 Giorgio Armani wears navy, beige and more navy &mdash; punctuated with the occasional white T-shirt &mdash; and he has built an empire on the principle that nothing becomes a woman so much as every shade of sludge on the mud flats. 
 &bquo;I have taken to colour like a new lover,&equo; he pronounced unconvincingly over a cappuccino in the sparse urban palazzo that doubles as his office and town house. 
 &bquo;But it's colour that is filtered. 
 The violet, the green, the red in my collection, they're all underlined in beige &mdash; neutrals are still the foundation and women who can't wear strong colours shouldn't even try. 
 It's a sombre story for a colourful age, just as Milan is a dull home for Italy's finest designers &mdash; but the world buys it, and buys it big. 
 Armani's empire has an annual turnover of about &pound;400 million, growing constantly as devotees the world over continue to sport his exquisitely-tailored neutrals which are the  epitome of power-dressing in the late 20th century. 
 We are not just talking power-dressing for women; Armani makes men look even better than the fairer sex in a way that's so thoroughly macho it's no wonder the world's aggro merchants have taken him to their hearts as eagerly as Hollywood's glitterati. 
 Mafia henchmen, Wall Street asset strippers and football hooligans from Turin to Tokyo all love to give attitude in their Armanis. 
 &bquo;I'm aware that, for some, my clothes are a power statement,&equo; admits the man who dressed both the bad guys in The Untouchables  and good guy Don Johnson in Miami Vice . 
 Richard Gere, Tom Cruise and Harrison Ford love their Armanis &mdash; and so, interestingly, do rival designers, from John Galliano, Bruce Oldfield and Alastair Blair to Armani's own kinsman and fashion rebel, Moschino. 
 Maximum impact through minimum statement is what Armani is all about &mdash; and the maestro himself lives out the philosophy in his personal life. 
 Wearing &mdash; always &mdash; dead simple casual clothes that flatter his lightly-tanned complexion, pale silver hair and famous aquamarine eyes, he dines on spartan, spiceless fare in his minimalist palazzo on Via Borgonuovo, where blank corridors link white-walled offices with the plain, pictureless apartment where he lives alone while a bodyguard sleeps below. 
 &bquo;I'm going to carry on wearing navy myself,&equo; he adds, somewhat unnecessarily, as we discuss the newly-expanded spectrum of his professional palette. 
 There was once a good deal more colour and laughter in the life of this tight-lipped fashion genius, when a second apartment in the palazzo was occupied by his business partner and close friend Sergio Galeotti, who died in 1985. 
 The designer who today shows so little emotion was devastated and he still keeps a mural of revered fashion figures (Mary Quant and Vivienne Westwood are two of his heroines) with Galeotti at the centre situated behind the enormous, clutter-free desk that's one more powerful statement. 
 Armani shot down in flames those who thought the empire he founded in 1974 would die with the demise of the business half of his partnership; he learnt fast and today manages to be all money, all business, without sacrificing the brilliant creative edge which has made him fashion's greatest superstar for the past decade. 
 Giorgio Armani was born in Piacenza, a provincial town in northern Italy with was blitzed in the war. 
 He studied medicine for two years but the sight of  blood made him sick so, always a lover of shopping, he defected to the world of retail. 
 After a sound seven-year grounding as a buyer for La Rinascente &mdash; Italy's answer to Selfridges &mdash; he started designing menswear for Italian fashion giant of the Sixties and Seventies, Nino Cerruti. 
 In 1966, he met Sergio Galeotti, the man who was to shape his destiny, at the seaside resort of Forte dei Marmi &mdash; where Armani still has a beach house today. 
 The architecture student who believed anything was possible set up home with the designer &mdash; and put his dynamic business brain to use in helping Armani to launch his own label in 1975. 
 Now, Armani is Italy's new Great Dictator but his genius is that, having handed down his basic dictate &mdash; that both women and men look their best in unstructured tailoring applied to traditional menswear fabrics &mdash; he has succeeded in turning himself into the Great Listener. 
 The most important part of his empire in the recessionary Nineties is the lower-priced Emporio Armani line, sold both in London and Glasgow, which takes all its inspiration from the street. 
 &bquo;He's always keeping his eyes on what the kids are wearing and nudging us about what we see out there, what we hear them asking for,&equo; says Caroline Freeman, an Armanishly elegant stick insect who works on his British team. 
 Street fashion is big on pazzazz, low on subtlety. 
 Thus, while the Giorgio show bristled with understated elegance this spring, the Emporio extravaganza was a riot of wild colour and audacious shapes, featuring eye-popping tartans and sizzling satin trenchcoats along with the sludgy, tweedy garments which constitute the cut-price clothes of more typical Armani fashion 
 Emporio has brought Armani to the masses; Italian taxi drivers and British bovver boys alike fork out quite happily for sweaters, jeans and T-shirts featuring the world-famous winged emblem. 
 &bquo;Expanding Emporio is the most important aspect of my business plan for the next five years,&equo; says the maestro, confidently plotting his way to a bright future as less resilient designers wring their hands or close shop. 
 &bquo;As well as opening more boutiques in England, France and Germany, I'm working on ways of making the clothes cheaper. 
 &bquo;It's not a question of bringing them to more people &mdash; Emporio has never been for the poor &mdash; but of morals; with the Nineties there comes a new thinking about how much it's right to spend on clothes and I certainly go along with that.&equo; 
 Armani, pushing 60 but still dressing 25, seems to regard Emporio as a means of expressing his personal infatuation with youth. 
 He stocks his stores with fresh-faced young assistants to whom he hands down a rigid dress code like a strict father: no nail varnish, no high heels &mdash; no dark tights even. 
 In the office, he can be such a hard taskmaster that his closest  aide, Gabriella Forte, describes his attitude before each new collection as a &bquo;rape of the staff&equo;. 
 Still, they love him &mdash; and he loves them. 
 He surrounds himself with an entourage of loyal courtiers, some from the store, others from the office, taking several at a time for convivial weekends of dog-walking, tennis and log fires at his country villa on the River Po &mdash; a sharp contrast to the rather gloomy, solitary week nights he spends in the industrial wasteland of the Via Borgonuovo. 
 One of the highlights of Armani's recent dark and relatively joyless years since Galeotti's death was the opening of the London Emporio on the Brompton Road three years ago. 
 On this great day, when he cut the ribbon on a shop built to remind him of the Italian department stores of his childhood &mdash; &bquo;they always had a restaurant, because part of the treat of shopping was lunching out&equo; &mdash; he was so happy and relaxed that it was easy to swallow inhibitions and ask him whether he wasn't bothered about being known, through the films he has chosen to dress, as the creator of designer violence. 
 Instead of showing me the door, he roared with laughter: &bquo;So what if I clothe gangsters on the screen? 
 The Mafia wear my clothes in real life; it's all good business!&equo; 
 Indeed, among the more bizarre places to find an Armani are holes in the wall in the Sicilian hill villages around Corleone where unlaundered mafioso cash comes out at tea time every day in search of status-promoting glad rags &mdash; the same suits that turn up simultaneously in posh Paris bistros, Los Angeles lizard lounges and the boardrooms of the most respectable British banks. 
 Ironically, considering they are bought mainly by people who don't need to ask the price, Armani considers that the selling point of his signature clothes is that you can wear them forever. 
 &bquo; Nobody  who spends &pound;500 on a jacket wants to discard it the following year,&equo; he believes, insisting that no Armani design dates before it dies of old age. 
 Nonetheless, designs vary significantly from one year to the next, even if the subtle, sludgy fabrics remain essentially the same. 
 This year, Armani is pairing longer-than-ever cardigan jackets with tiny little shorts in matching suiting, sometimes weaving the two together in a one-piece coat-dress. 
 He is putting more structure into his clothes and using rather more natural fibres than man-made miracle fabrics. 
 He has acknowledged the Italian trend towards overtly sexy clothes by cutting flirty side slits on a curve in his short skirts and stitching a provocative little hitch into them. 
 &bquo;But that's a token compared to the sex circus on other catwalks in Milan this spring&equo; he sniffs. 
 And it's true that, without ever resorting to circus gimmicks, Armani manages to make the world's sexiest women &mdash; Michelle Pfeiffer and Julia Roberts head the list &mdash; even sexier. 
 If there is one danger facing Armani, it's that of becoming trapped in his own stereotype; when the day finally comes that he tires of the simple suit and sensational jacket, the world may just insist that he keeps on making them. 
 He confesses this is why he's started leaping out in uncharacteristic new directions which discomfit the regulars, playing with bright colours and polka dots when the world expects sludge and subtle stripes ad nauseam . 
 &bquo;I was becoming a prisoner of myself,&equo; he says frankly, &bquo;a prisoner of beautiful jackets. 
 I had to fight for the right to cut dresses as well as suits, to make evening dress as well as day wear and even now, when I've proved myself in those areas, I have to fight members of my own staff who believe I should still stick to producing powerful women's suits. 
 &bquo;The collection I showed this spring would have been unthinkable three years ago &mdash; so many dresses, so much evening wear. 
 But I really couldn't see the sense in women wearing Armani by day and then letting someone else dress them by night.&equo; 
 His early attempts at evening wear were often disastrous, inspiring groans at the Oscars when Michelle and Julia showed off their sludgy simplicity to an overdressed audience hungry for sparkles and sequins. 
 But he listened and learnt and for next winter he has harnessed Hollywood-style glamour to make evening wear that really works, adapting his tailoring to sequined, beaded and embroidered jackets of unbelievable opulence. 
 &bquo;I don't think the same way as other designers,&equo; he shrugs, shuddering at the billowing skirts, fussy bows and complicated ornaments that are characteristic of the set-piece ball gowns of the Paris couture. 
 &bquo;For me, sumptuousness of fabric is more effective than importance of shape.&equo; 
 His glorification of the subtle and simple cocks a snook at the overblown excesses that have given Paris couture the kiss of death. 
 Yet ironically, it is in  the couture &mdash; the dying art of dressing the world's 1,000 richest women &mdash; that he sees the seed of his own future as he tires of elevating ready-to-wear to an art form. 
 &bquo;As Emporio spreads and grows, I will concentrate more on doing a few limited pieces for the special clients who buy my signature line,&equo; he smiles, betraying a special fondness for those who grudge no expense for a new take on a shoulder-line, a fresh twist to this year's lapel that simply cannot be copied in a less fluid fabric at a lower price. 
 He takes an impish delight in shocking the press and dismaying the clients as he prepares to change direction: &bquo;To be provocative is important, and change is vital for personal survival. 
 &bquo;This spring collection is the most radical I've ever shown and in many ways it marks a new beginning for me. 
 I feel as though I am starting to write a new story in the book of Giorgio Armani.&equo;  
 &bquo;I have taken to colour like a new lover, but it's colour that's filtered&equo; 
 Classic Armani&hellip; exquisitely tailored clothes in every shade of sludge on the mud flats. 
 Him: suit jacket, &pound;680; striped shirt, &pound;190. 
 Her: checked jacket, &pound;595; silk chiffon scarf, &pound;105; gold earrings, &pound;60 &mdash; all by the maestro himself. 
 Styling: Karen McCartney. 
 Photograph: Martyn Thompson. 
 Hair and make-up: Val Garland at Gamilla Arthur. 
 Stockists are on page 92 
 Above: the many faces of Armani &mdash; from clothes to perfume and jewellery. 
 Sepia advertisements capture the timelessness of his art. 
 Photograph: Graeme Montgomery 
 Above, from top to bottom, Armani devotees: Don Johnson for Miami Vice , Anjelica Huston, the bad guys in The Untouchables , Harrison Ford, Michelle Pfeiffer, Julia Roberts. 
 Anthea Gerrie stayed in Milan courtesy of the four star luxury Jolly Hotel Milanofiore. 
 Phone: 0800 282 729 for information 
 &bquo;I was becoming a prisoner of myself &mdash; a prisoner of beautiful jackets 
 VOGUE PATTERNS 
 6 easy pieces 
 Create six essential items for summer at a snip with Betty Jackson's Vogue Patterns, here and over the page. 
 Betty Jackson is one of the most respected and successful designers in Britain, with a reputation for producing stylish, comfortable and versatile clothes. 
 She launched her own company, Betty Jackson Ltd, in October 1981 and has never looked back. 
 With a list of accolades under her no doubt stylish belt &mdash; including the prestigious British Designer of the Year Award in 1985 and an MBE in 1987 &mdash; she has certainly had an illustrious career. 
 Of course, true style doesn't come cheap. 
 For many of us, Betty Jackson's clothes are simply too expensive so we jumped at the chance to feature the latest Betty Jackson Vogue patterns. 
 This two-pattern wardrobe provides six exclusive designs. 
 Pattern No 2620 offers three loose-fitting shirts, while No 2621 offers a high-waisted skirt, narrow trousers and long collarless coat. 
 Both come in sizes 6&ndash;10, 12&ndash;16 or 18&ndash;20. 
 Alexander Fabrics kindly supplied us with a combination of cotton gingham, poplin, crepe de Chine, taffeta and silk dupion. 
 If you're using a delicate fabric, remember that it needs special care. 
 Always use a fabric conditioner such as Comfort Pure Silk after washing. 
 Now all you have to do is choose your fabric according to your pocket and create your own designer wardrobe. 
 VOGUE PATTERN OFFER 
 Your 1991 summer wardrobe starts here! 
 Vogue Patterns are delighted to offer these designer patterns by Betty Jackson at a special introductory price to Clothes Show Magazine  readers. 
 Buy one pattern for &pound;4.65 instead of the normal price of &pound;7.65 (a saving of 39 per cent). 
 Buy both patterns for just &pound;8.65 (a saving of 43 per cent). 
 Receive (if required) a list of professional dressmakers who are working in your area. 
 Pattern coupon on page 92 
 Styling: Marie Willey. 
 Photographs: Iain McKell. 
 Hair and make-up: Linda Burns at Camilla Arthur. 
 Stockists are on page 92. 
 Sizzle in vivid green and hot orange; cool down in gingham 
 all about Gloria 
 Miraculously recovered from a serious accident, singer Gloria Estefan tells how she tends her Latin looks. 
 &bquo;My husband Emilio and my stylist buy most of my clothes because I hate  shopping! 
 I feel most comfortable in what I call my &bquo;hang out&equo; clothes: jeans, T-shirts, sloppy sweaters and so on. 
 But I know it's important to look good on stage so all my stage clothes are custom-made for me by a man called Franco Carretti. 
 I've always had tremendous energy. 
 I've spent more than 15 years singing and touring and I still enjoy it but it's important to keep your body in good condition when you're on the road. 
 It's too easy to end up living off junk food. 
 I have a nutritionist who travels with me and works out a daily menu. 
 I'm not naturally slim, and any excess weight I do put on shows because I'm only 5&ft; 1&ins;. 
 I watch what Emilio and our 10-year-old son Nayib eat, too. 
 I don't drink any alcohol but I love papaya juice and drink tons of mineral water. 
 It helps keep your skin clear. 
 Living in a hot place like Miami takes its toll. 
 I do sit out in the sun occasionally, but I make sure I'm well protected. 
 Even though I come from Cuba and have naturally dark skin, it's very dry so I always carry my Must de Cartier body lotion with me. 
 A lot of people ask me if my hair is permed but it's just naturally thick and curly. 
 I have it cut every three months to keep it healthy. 
 I wash it every day and use plenty of light conditioner but I don't stick to one brand. 
 I think you should change your shampoo and conditioner once in a while to avoid product build-up. 
 I have to wear make-up on stage or on photo shoots. 
 Some people wear it all the time because they think it acts as a barrier against the weather but I believe in letting your skin breathe so I always wear as little as possible. 
 I don't stick to one particular brand but I would never be without my face powder and I usually go for the heavy Sixties-style eye make-up &mdash; lots of black kohl pencil and mascara. 
 I've lived in Miami since I was two years old but when Emilio and I started singing professionally, back in the late Seventies, we sang only in Spanish. 
 By the mid-Eighties we were singing in English too, and we began to catch on in English-speaking countries. 
 When our album Cuts Both Ways  was released in 1989, I couldn't believe how successful it was. 
 It sold more than a million copies in Britain alone and won me the Billboard  award for best singer/songwriter in America. 
 Right up until early last year everything was going so well. 
 All that was put on hold on March 20, 1990. 
 We were on a bus, on our way to a concert, when we were hit by a truck. 
 My son Nayib broke his collarbone and Emilio broke a rib and dislocated his shoulder. 
 I was thrown to the floor and broke my back. 
 I was in hospital for nearly three months and, at first, the doctors thought I might not be able to walk again. 
 But with the aid of two eight-inch metal rods fixed either side of my spine, and 18 hours' intensive exercise and physical therapy a week, I made progress. 
 Consequently, my exercise regime is a little more rigorous than most! 
 I have to spend three hours a day doing all sorts of muscle-building and strengthening exercises. 
 I also do a lot of aerobics and Emilio and I regularly play racketball. 
 Even before the crash I took a great deal of exercise &mdash; you have to work at staying in shape. 
 And I certainly don't believe in having cosmetic surgery. 
 I'm 33 now and I can't imagine a time when I would ever consider using it. 
 People should learn to like their bodies and live with their faults. 
 After all, I have had to live with a big bottom all my life! 
 My new album was written during my convalescence at home in Miami and, although the songs are a record of my experience, I don't want Into the Light  to turn into &bquo;the accident album&equo;. 
 The single Coming Out of the Dark  is a celebration of my recovery. 
 I'm now playing live again, and I want the audience to see my recovery as a positive thing. 
 No matter how bad a problem seems, you deal with it and go beyond it. 
 Every song on the album contains something of my own experience over the last year but the words are applicable to everyone.&equo;  
 I always go for heavy, Sixties-style eye make-up, though I'm not sure black does much for brown eyes! 
 I have to wear make-up on stage but I prefer to let my skin breathe and just wear the minimum 
 Too much sun is very drying &mdash; I use lots of Must de Cartier body lotion to keep my skin supple 
 Most of my clothes are chosen by Emilio, my husband, and my stylist &mdash; I hate shopping 
 It's a good idea to change brands of shampoo and conditioner to avoid a single product build-up 
 I have to work at keeping slim and limit my favourite food, a Cuban recipe of fried bananas! 
 Since my accident, I have to spend three hours every day doing muscle-building and strengthening exercises 
 &bquo;I want the audience to see my recovery as a positive thing&equo; 
 DOUBLE TAKE 
 Ever dreamed of placing your hair problems in the hands of the professionals? 
 It takes some pluck but, as you'll see, the results can be sensational! 
 12 readers get a colourful new look 
 As you'll recall, in the March issue of the Clothes Show Magazine , Wella offered our readers the fantastic opportunity to win a complete hair makeover. 
 From the hundreds of entries we received, 12 winners were finally chosen to represent six regions throughout the UK and you can see the stunning results over the next eight pages&hellip; 
 Sally Gilbert-Smith and Ruth Gilbert from Cornwall &mdash; Sally, 28, who works in Lloyds Bank in Newquay, entered herself and her mother for the competition because it seemed like the perfect opportunity for the experts to show them off to their full potential. 
 &bquo;We've always been too scared to have anything drastic done to our hair &mdash; until now,&equo; said Ruth. 
 Sally's long blonde hair was in real need of conditioning and re-colouring. 
 Louise Hignett, a stylist from Keith Hall the Hairdressers salon in Arnold, Nottingham, cut off the damaged ends and texturised it throughout to encourage the curl and take some of the weight out of it. 
 Colourist Chris Walton used Medium Blonde and Terra Rosa from Wella's Colour Touch range to change the tone and deepen the overall colour of Sally's hair at the same time as encouraging its  shine and improving the general condition. 
 Finally, hair was dried using the System Professional Curl Reactivator to enhance the curl and give extra body. 
 Ruth's hair was out of shape and didn't do justice to her strong bone structure so stylist Caroline Stacey, also from Keith Hall the Hairdressers, but from their Leicester salon, decided to take the weight out of the back leaving the top longer. 
 Kerry Hayden took care of Ruth's colour by partially covering the white with lowlights. 
 She alternated blonde colours from the Wella Koleston 2000 range to add subtle warmth. 
 Caroline then applied High Hair Volumising Mousse before blow-drying into a new, face-flattering shape. 
 Sally and Ruth were delighted. 
 &bquo;I feel like a million dollars&equo;, said Ruth. 
 Kukkay Sarn and Meera Patel from London &mdash; 24-year-old Kukkay works as a buyer for British Airways and her friend Meera is a 22-year-old student at the London College of Fashion. 
 &bquo;It was a spur of the moment idea to enter,&equo; explained Kukkay. 
 &bquo;I haven't had my hair cut for about a year and neither has Meera so I thought it was time for a change.&equo; 
 To give Kukkay's hair a more voluminous look, Chris used a Wella Optaform permanent wave on Molton Brown permers. 
 The result? 
 A spiral corkscrew perm that just has to be washed and left for a full-bodied look. 
 Once it was dry, Louise styled Kukkay's hair by twisting it up at the back to create fullness on top while still leaving it curly and &bquo;free&equo;. 
 Caroline cut the split ends off Meera's hair but decided she should keep the length. 
 As Meera is growing out her fringe, Caroline simply gave it more shape to tidy it up. 
 Meera was a little nervous about having her hair coloured so Chris used the non-permanent Colour Touch. 
 Caroline gathered the hair into a high ponytail and then barrel-curled it (turning under individual sections). 
 She used High Hair Soft Wax to keep it smooth. 
 Both girls were very pleased with their new styles. 
 &bquo;I feel so glamorous I can hardly recognise myself!&equo; said Meera. 
 Clare Macmahon and Elaine Duffy from Warwickshire &mdash; schoolgirls Clare and Elaine decided to enter the competition because they were bored with their hair and eager for a change. 
 Louise took a couple of inches off Clare's hair to tidy it up and get rid of the split ends. 
 Hair technician Kerry decided Clare's fine thick hair was ideal for a spiral perm. 
 Using Wella Optaform permanent wave lotion, and winding the hair on Molton Brown permers, she created a soft but strong style. 
 Elaine was perhaps the most adventurous of our Wella winners. 
 She gave the stylists the go-ahead to do whatever they wanted. 
 Caroline was delighted and set to work transforming her straight, shoulder-length hair into a glamorous new look. 
 She cut the hair close to the nape of the neck, leaving it long on top to keep it soft and then graduated at the back to create a heavy wedge. 
 Chris then used a permanent colour on the longer hair on top, and chose Natural Light Brown, Plum Brown and Medium Burgundy from the Koleston 2000 range. 
 By taking diamond-shaped sections and alternating the colours he gave Elaine's hair depth and shine and increased the &bquo;textured&equo; effect of the cut. 
 Caroline put the final touches to the style using High Hair Moulding Glaze for a firm hold and glossy finish. 
 Both Clare and Elaine couldn't have been happier. 
 &bquo;I'm so excited,&equo; said Elaine, &bquo;I didn't think a style like this would suit me but it does.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's so nice to have a new look&equo;, added Clare.  
 All 12 winners having met up the evening before for an Italian meal at The Campana in London's West End, followed by a night at The Regent Crest Hotel, the second half of the group arrived bright and early at the studio, ready for their  transformations the next day. 
 Jean and Becky Joplin from Yorkshire &mdash; mother Jean, 42, and daughter Becky, 19, both work in the family's marketing business. 
 The decided to enter the competition because they were thoroughly bored with their hair. 
 Jean had straight brown hair with a few layers cut into the top; stylist Patrick Cameron, Artistic Director for the Alan Paul group of salons, suggested a tousled look which would suit her heart-shaped face. 
 Keeping the length almost the same, he restructured the front with a textured cut for a more casual look. 
 Colourist Chris gave Jean an all-over permanent colour in Deep Velvet Brown mixed with Dark Blonde highlights for contrast through the front. 
 The hair was softly blow-dried onto the face using High Hair Volumising Mousse. 
 Jean was thrilled: &bquo;It's lovely to be pampered by the professionals!&equo; 
 Becky described her hair colour as &bquo;drab and boring&equo;. 
 She'd had a colour put in last autumn which was growing out, so Chris decided to enhance the natural warmth of the hair and add additional shine using a non-commitment colour, Natural Dark Blonde, mixed with persimmon from the Colour Touch range. 
 The result was a beautifully rich, uniform colour. 
 Becky wanted to keep her hair long but experiment with different styles. 
 Patrick began by blunt cutting the ends then, after blow-drying, he pulled the hair into a high ponytail which he lightly backcombed before splaying it out on the top of the head. 
 Using Wella's High Hair Form &amp; Finish Spray for extra hold, he pinned the hair and brushed it flat for a sophisticated Sixties style. 
 Becky was absolutely thrilled: &bquo;It's gorgeous! 
 I love it.&equo; 
 When asked if she was going out that evening, Becky replied, &bquo;Well, I wasn't, but I certainly am now!&equo; 
 Betty and Barbara Keys from County Antrim, Northern Ireland &mdash; mother Betty works part-time as a shop assistant and Barbara has an office job. 
 She's  also a member of the Clothes Show  club. 
 Entering the competition was entirely Barbara's idea and when the phone call came through to say they'd won, Betty was quite shocked to discover that she, too, was going to London to have a makeover &mdash; but she soon came round to the idea! 
 Stylist Patrick recommended a softer shape for Betty, instead of the severe brushed-back style she'd worn for years, as well as a complete reconditioning of the ends. 
 Patrick first cut her hair into a soft convex bob before Kerry, using a spatula and slide technique, coloured the hair with a selection of blonde and soft brown shades from Wella's Koleston 2000 range to help disguise the grey and give a variegated effect. 
 The hair was blow-dried to give lots of body using Wella's High Hair Volumising Mousse. 
 The new look was really striking and soft-spoken Betty was modestly delighted with her transformation. 
 Barbara was bored with the bob she'd had for the past four years and was ready for a complete change. 
 Patrick decided to give her a brand new bob, slightly concave at the back with an undetermined weightline, a heavy drop in the front and a definite fringe. 
 The end result was a sensational bob with a really Sixties feel to it. 
 Once Barbara had had a good look at her new style in the mirror, she was very pleased with the change. 
 To give soft lights to the hair, Kerry put some foil highlights in, using Blonde shades from Wella's Koleston 2000 range. 
 Only the top layers were done, as the contrast with the darker layers underneath added depth to the overall appearance. 
 Michelle Lynagh and Colette McIntyre from Ayrshire &mdash; despite their very different looks, these two are  sisters. 
 Michelle, 24, works in an electronics factory while Colette, 15, is still at school. 
 Michelle has an abundance of waist-length hair and although she was prepared for a radical cut, Patrick recommended keeping the length but blunt-cutting it to a clean, straight line: &bquo;You don't have to have mountains cut off to look different,&equo; he said. 
 A non-permanent colour added both warmth and shine to Michelle's hair &mdash; colourist Kerry opted for a mix of Havannah and Natural Dark Brown from the Colour Touch range. 
 Patrick then dressed Michelle's hair into a sculptured, Japanese-type style by twisting two ponytails up round each other on top of her head, holding the hair firm with Wella's High Hair Form &amp; Finish. 
 Michelle does put her hair up herself but said it usually slips out because &bquo;there's just too much of it, besides, it's just so  well-conditioned!&equo; 
 Patrick explained it should be stiff enough in the first place in order to stay up, achieved with the help of a product like the one he'd just used. 
 Michelle loved the new, warm colour of her hair but admitted, &bquo;I might take a little  more than 10 minutes to achieve this amazing sculptured style!&equo; 
 Colette's old perm had almost grown out and the rest of her hair was rather flat and needed a strong new shape to lift it. 
 Paul Cochrane, from the Alan Paul salon in Lambs Conduit Street, London, opted for a bob with a Sixties feel, slightly concave at the back through graduated cutting for a softer shape. 
 The bleached ends were growing out so new High Lift Natural Blonde highlights from the Koleston 2000 range were put in by Chris to soften the colour. 
 The hair was then blow-dried Sixties-style, softly flicked at the ends, using High Hair Sculpting Spritz. 
 The result was extremely smart. 
 Colette's initial reaction was: &bquo;This feels very  funny,&equo; but, as the minutes passed, she warmed to the new, much shorter style &mdash; and she loved the colour. 
 The transformations complete, all six readers were lined up for the final photograph. 
 As the smiles go to prove, it was the perfect ending to a perfect two days &mdash; and all thanks to Wella.  
 JONATHON MORRIS moves centre stage 
 Already famous as Bread  's Adrian Boswell, Jonathon Morris now wants to be well-known &mdash; as himself. 
 Jonathon Morris is a man in a hurry. 
 He's currently halfway through making the next series of BBC1's hit comedy, Bread . 
 But, given the demands on his time, it's a wonder that dreamy Adrian will get a look-in at all when the show returns this autumn. 
 Every week, Jonathon records a new edition of the quiz show The Movie Game  (BBC1, Weds). 
 And when he isn't belting up to Liverpool to rejoin the Boswells, he's busy rehearsing for what could be the biggest challenge of his career. 
 Taking on the title role originally created by Michael Crawford in the Seventies, Jonathon opens at the Opera House in Manchester in September as Billy . 
 Three weeks later, the show is scheduled to move to London. 
 &bquo;I've always danced and sung but I'm having intensive training for both now,&equo; says Jonathon. 
 He'll be putting his lungs to good use soon to record the album of the show. 
 A new song, written especially for Jonathon by John Barry (who won an Oscar for the musical score of Dance With Wolves ), will be released as a single in June. 
 Jonathon Morris, you will have gathered, is going places &mdash; and no one could be happier than the man himself. 
 But he's determined to get it right. 
 &bquo;I want people to come and see me  playing Billy , not Adrian Boswell, in the same way as they went to watch Michael Crawford, not Frank Spencer.&equo; 
 Time will tell. 
 Meanwhile,  Jonathon sleeps deeply at night even if sometimes for not quite long enough. 
 &bquo;But I'm not complaining. 
 I'm very happy with how things are going at the moment.&equo; 
 Nor does he wish to begrudge what Bread  has done for his career. 
 He's been in it for five years (only he and Jean Boht have been with the show from the beginning) and he's proud of that, he says. 
 During that time, his screen character has developed, but you just wait, says Jonathon, and see what happens to Adrian in the autumn. 
 He won't divulge what, but &bquo;it affects my appearance, too&equo;, and he points to his new haircut, a welcome improvement on Adrian's slightly leftover hippie look. 
 For someone who seems so firmly in control of his career, Jonathon Morris claims a surprising lack of confidence when it comes to his personal appearance. 
 &bquo;I just don't feel I've quite cracked it yet. 
 I don't like scruffiness &mdash; and I do like clothes. 
 I just want to be comfortable. 
 My ambition is to have a different look each day so that I can't be labelled.&equo; 
 Living near Chelsea's King's Road certainly helps, although Jonathon first got interested in fashion, he says, when he was living in Manchester. 
 &bquo;There's a shop there called L'Homme which I particularly like.&equo; 
 But the trouble with buying clothes, he finds, is that if you do it alone (he's single), you can get a bit blinkered. 
 &bquo;You only have your own narrow vision &mdash; and that's not usually a good thing. 
 But I know I wouldn't stop with a second opinion. 
 I'd want a third and fourth and so on.&equo; 
 When left to his own devices, Jonathon inclines towards Italian clothes because of their style (echoing the Fifties), their cut and their colour. 
 &bquo;I've got a slight frame so French clothes tend to hang a bit too loosely on me.&equo; 
 For someone who claims to be insecure about his appearance, he seems pretty well informed on the subject of fashion. 
 He smiles his gleaming smile: &bquo;Oh, don't get me wrong. 
 I love dressing up. 
 Since I spend most of my working life wearing clothes I wouldn't normally be seen dead in, it's one of my life's real pleasures.&equo; 
 Adrian Boswell, it seems, has a lot to answer for.  
 &bquo;I'm going to buy this. 
 I don't own anything like it. 
 I'd wear it to do Wogan .&equo; 
 Sand brush cotton chinos, &pound;70. 
 Polo Ralph Lauren. 
 Buttermilk jacket, &pound;79.99. 
 Next for men. 
 Cream short sleeve shirt, &pound;73, Reporter 
 &bquo;I wouldn't buy this because I think striped shirts have been overplayed &mdash; and I prefer black jeans.&equo; 
 Blue striped shirt, &pound;69, Paul Smith. 
 Jeans, &pound;29.99, Next Directory, No M34839 
 &bquo;This is my sort of everyday look &mdash; good for rehearsing in.&equo; 
 Cream sweatshirt, Jonathon's own. 
 Mustard bomber jacket, &pound;79. 
 Principles for Men. 
 Jeans, &pound;40, Paul Smith. 
 Shoes, Jonathon's own 
 &bquo;I'd wear this because it's a classic look with a slight difference &mdash; and I think the colour's great.&equo; 
 Petrol blue suit, &pound;169, Principles for Men. 
 Black crew neck, Jonathon's own 
 &bquo;I spend most of my working life wearing clothes I wouldn't be seen dead in,&equo; says Jonathon, seen above, far right, with the rest of the cast of Bread . 
 His own taste (left) is a zip sweater, &pound;150, from Polo Ralph Lauren. 
 Styling: Sian Banks. 
 Photographs: Martyn Thompson. 
 Grooming: Val Garland. 
 Stockists are on page 92 
 and the living is easy&hellip; 
 From loose fitting to loads of swing, the simple summer frock is back in style. 
 Wear it with a hat and a sunshine smile! 
 Free as a bird in a simple panelled ivory linen dress (this page), &pound;71, Hobbs. 
 Right: for that individual touch try a hand-printed dress, &pound;110, to order from Antoni &amp; Alison. 
 White straw hat, &pound;9.99, Miss Selfridge. 
 Far right: silk shift dress, &pound;59.99, Next. 
 Straw bag, &pound;72, Fred Bare. 
 Bracelet, &pound;7.50, Angie Gooderham 
 In the swing in an oyster slip dress (far left), &pound;29.99, selected branches of Miss Selfridge. 
 Daisy embroidered dress, &pound;24.99, Zygo. 
 Silver shell pendant, &pound;8.99, Oasis. 
 This page: cotton dress, &pound;20.50, French Connection. 
 Rough edged straw hat, about &pound;12, Sandra Philips 
 Easy, lazy days in a loose silk dress (this page), &pound;93. 
 Chinatown, worn over tight fitted shorts, &pound;70, Duncan &amp; Namara. 
 Right: chocolate dress, &pound;29.90, Benetton. 
 Plain straw hat, about &pound;10, Sandra Philips 
 Simple, summery, swinging. 
 This page: T-shirt dress, &pound;16.99, Gallery at Top Shop. 
 Straw hat with wooden beads, &pound;65, Fred Bare. 
 Large shell pendant, &pound;7.99, Pink Soda. 
 Right: mint dress, &pound;35, French Connection. 
 Styling: Karen McCartney. 
 Photographs: Keith Henderson. 
 Hair: Robert Johnson for Paul Mitchell Systems. 
 Make-up: Robert Johnson for Kanebo. 
 Shot in Florida. 
 Travel courtesy TWA; accommodation courtesy Horizon Holidays (021 632 6282). 
 Stockists are on page 92 
 french dressing 
 Seductive simplicity and relaxed elegance are the key to modern chic &mdash; and nobody flaunts it better than the French. 
 With continental classics in vogue, you can both follow suit. 
 Bonne chance! 
 CLOTHES SHOW PROMOTION 
 GET fresh! 
 Good grooming reaps instant benefits and, while you can't change your looks overnight or develop instant muscle, a sophisticated scent will speak millions for your confidence. 
 Celsius is a complete range of complementary products so you can build on your scent by degrees, from a stimulating shower gel to a refreshing splash of Celsius Aftershave. 
 So, while the stylish collection graces your bathroom shelf, Celsius will be enhancing your own natural charms&hellip; 
 Left: You don't need to spend a fortune to get fresh! 
 Kick the day into action with refreshing Celsius Body Splash 
 Opposite, below: keep your cool even when working up a sweat. 
 Co-ordinating deodorant, body spray and talc ensure that you smell good while you work on looking good. 
 Left: Celsius start every day off right with the fresh citrus top notes of lime and bergamot. 
 Pepper and cyprus oil spice up the day, while a hint of patchouli and sandalwood linger softly into the evening hours&hellip; 
 Props: Harvey Nichols, Lillywhites. 
 Photographs: Tony Chau. 
 Hair and make-up Robert Johnson at Terrie Tanaka. 
 Stockists are on page 92 (see Celsius) 
 what they're wearing in LEEDS 
 Saturday night and Yorkshire lads and lasses are ready for kick-off 
 Where it's at: Leeds is the third largest city in England, with a population of around three quarters of a million. 
 It's about halfway between London and Edinburgh, about level with Liverpool and Hull, and it's easy to get to by train, plane or automobile. 
 There's no shortage of things to do in Leeds, whether you're after high culture or street cool. 
 Nightclubbing 
 The Warehouse, 19&ndash;21 Somers Street (0532 468287). 
 Mr Craig's, 54 New Briggate (0532 42224). 
 The Gallery and Ricky's, 9 Merrion Street (no phone). 
 Two clubs in one place. 
 Eating 
 Hansa's, 72&ndash;74 North Street (0532 444408) &mdash; vegetarian. 
 La Grillade, Wellington Street (0532 459707) &mdash; French. 
 Bibi's, 16 Greek Street (0532 430905) &mdash; Italian. 
 Maxi's, 6 Bingley Street (0532 440552) &mdash; Cantonese. 
 Arts 
 Cinema &mdash; the Hyde Park Cinema (0532 752045) is independent and lit by gaslight. 
 Leeds International Film Festival takes place in October. 
 Theatres &mdash; West Yorkshire Playhouse (0532 222141): Civic (0532 455505); Grand Theatre (0532 440971): City Varieties Music Hall (0532 430808). 
 City Art Gallery, The Headrow &mdash; a fine collection of 20th century pieces, plus the Henry Moore Study Centre, Craft Shop and Design Centre &mdash; a visual feast. 
 Shopping 
 The Arcades &mdash; Thornton's, County, Grand and Queen's: all Victorian pedestrian areas. 
 Granary Wharf, Central Basin &mdash; diverse crafts from all over the world, reached by walking under  the City Station. 
 Corn Exchange and Waterloo Antiques, Crown Street &mdash; period clothing, furniture, prints, paintings, jewellery and bric-a-brac in two adjacent centres. 
 Dave, Andy and Gavin 
 &bquo;We've just borrowed this gear from a shop called Occi-Mizoki. 
 When our band The Joy get to Number One we'll come back and buy it all.&equo; 
 Tracy and Tracy 
 &bquo;Leeds is far too expensive for clothes, so we go to Manchester.&equo; 
 Andrea and Zoe 
 &bquo;We like wearing bright colours. 
 We're both wearing Benetton today.&equo; 
 Simon Crawford 
 &bquo;My duffle coat was bought for me in Manchester. 
 It doesn't have pockets but I liked it because of the red buttons.&equo; 
 Angela Sibbles 
 &bquo;I bought this gold parka in Leeds and the jeans are by Moschino. 
 I buy all my clothes here &mdash; there's no need to go to London.&equo; 
 Carmen and Nicky 
 &bquo;We would rather pay for designer labels than go to high street shops.&equo; 
 Sarah 
 &bquo;I had my top made for me and it cost &pound;70. 
 If it's well made I'll pay the price whatever it is.&equo; 
 Cathy and Stuart 
 Cathy: &bquo;I tend to buy most of my clothes from Next, but this top isn't &mdash; I'm not telling you where I bought it!&equo; 
 Stuart and Charlie 
 Stuart: &bquo;My jacket is by Colin Harvey from Brother to Brother in Sheffield.&equo; 
 Charlie: &bquo;There's life and death and in-between there's Leeds.&equo; 
 Katie and Donna 
 Katie: &bquo;I'm always buying new clothes.&equo; 
 Donna: &bquo;I don't spend much on clothes &mdash; i go to secondhand shops.&equo; 
 Steve 
 &bquo;I bought this because I wanted something brightly coloured for winter. 
 My other clothes at home are all by John Richmond.&equo; 
 Jo Williams 
 &bquo;My friend Sarah makes most of my clothes for me. 
 She does brilliant rip-offs for a snip of the real thing!&equo; 
 Words: Sian Banks, Debra Stottor. 
 Photographs: Johnny Greig. 
 During our stay in Leeds we visited: The county Arcade shopping centre; AMS Leeds Bowl, Merrion Centre (0532 451781); The Gallery; Mr Craig's; The Warehouse. 
 We stayed in Leeds courtesy of The Hilton Hotel, Neville Street (0532 442000). 
 The Hotel Metropole, King Street (0532 450841). 
 better by design 
 Ever wondered how a design gets from the sketchbook to the catwalk? 
 We found out by following the progress of one of this year's semi-finalists at the annual Smirnoff Fashion Awards &mdash; a competition which celebrates student design&hellip; 
 Beginning, Resourcing, Believing and Remembering are four stages in the &bquo;States of Man&equo;, the imaginative brief set for the 1991 Smirnoff UK Fashion Awards which take place in June as part of a week of college fashion shows. 
 Promostyl, a fashion forecasting bureau, presented the design ideas to fashion students nationwide. 
 Entrants had to pick one of the four sections and develop their design from the abstract ideas that they found there. 
 Three thousand students applied, all chasing the prestige of winning the world's largest student fashion competition. 
 It took a team of distinguished judges several hours to emerge with the final shortlist of 60 semi-finalists. 
 Jeff Banks guided the judges through the piles of paperwork. 
 Vivienne Westwood, current British Designer of the Year, had a very clear idea of what she was looking for: &bquo;Something unorthodox that people haven't seen before. 
 &bquo;Talent is a rare thing, not as universal as people seem to think &mdash; creativity is not something that can be taught,&equo; she says. 
 Alongside Vivienne were Kim Hunt, Fashion Designer of Elle , and Alan Couldridge, Deputy Course Director at the Royal College of Art. 
 Kim was learning more than she'd bargained for from the entries: &bquo;I hadn't realised that the all-in-one body had been such an immensely influential piece. 
 I was quite shocked by the thousands of variations on that theme.&equo; 
 Alan Couldridge was more philosophical about the entries. 
 &bquo;This competition brings out the best and the worst in fashion students. 
 It's a big stage event with a very abstract brief, very exciting but not a fancy dress show.&equo; 
 The Clothes Show Magazine  was present at this nail-biting stage  of the proceedings, ready to make a selection of our own. 
 It was semi-finalist Amy Moore's printed housecoat that won the approval of the magazine's Deputy Editor, Karen McCartney. 
 &bquo;Amy's drawing caught my attention because it was a simple but dramatic interpretation of the brief. 
 I felt the processes involved in the production of the fabric and star-fastening would be interesting to follow.&equo; 
 Amy's eye-catching gold and brown design was entered in the &bquo;Believing&equo; section of the competition. 
 The brief made diverse references to faith, South America and nostalgia. 
 Having tracked down Amy, we asked her to explain what attracted her to &bquo;Believing&equo;: &bquo;I'm obsessed with flamenco at the moment and that fitted with the &bquo;Believing&equo; references to exotic South American styles.&equo; 
 Amy had a wealth of ideas to inspire. 
 &bquo;I go to flamenco classes, collect pictures of elaborate dance costumes and I've been to lots of shows.&equo; 
 The stylised housecoat that Amy eventually submitted to Smirnoff is the result of endless refinements and changes to design. 
 We wanted to know exactly how the final garment evolved. 
 Amy explained: &bquo;I started off drawing a wrap covered in lots of tassels and big flowers &mdash; all very whacky.&equo; 
 The wrap developed into something more substantial and the full-length coat shape emerged. 
 This is when the pattern-cutting started and Amy produced the first calico toile. 
 This rough version of the finished garment is made to check that the design can be produced effectively. 
 &bquo;Calico is horrible to use but you have to make toiles to perfect your design. 
 After three different versions I decided on the plain raincoat shape, tied with a belt.&equo; 
 Having achieved the shape, Amy had to solve the problems of the pattern she had designed to decorate it. 
 &bquo;The brief for &bquo;Believing&equo; described patchwork effects and harmony through colours. 
 For this print, I was thinking back to the patterns of light and shade created by strong sunlight.&equo; 
 The dappled effect could be created through print or appliqu&eacute;, but each had drawbacks. 
 &bquo;The patterns get larger towards the bottom of the coat and this gradation is difficult to print. 
 It takes ages because the garment has to be done in sections &mdash; it's much easier if the shapes are all the same size.&equo; 
 Appliqu&eacute; was Amy's other option &mdash; cutting out the brown shapes, dying them and then sewing them back on individually. 
 &bquo;I thought it would take too long to do but it was easier than the problems of printing.&equo; 
 The final, crucial element of Amy's design was the starfish button. 
 &bquo;I saw it in a magazine and blew the picture up on a colour photocopier.&equo; 
 This unusual button presented a few problems. 
 &bquo;It had to be light so as not to pull the fabric around but something like polystyrene would have fallen apart.&equo; 
 The solution was a light wood, varnished to make it harder, and then carved into a perfect reproduction of Amy's photocopied design. 
 With the housecoat made up and endless hurdles overcome, it was time for the real test &mdash; replacing the clothes stand with a model. 
 Amy brought the complete outfit, including Lycra shorts &mdash; also her own design &mdash; to a photographic studio and saw her design move for the first time. 
 &bquo;At college, we have to find tall skinny people to try our designs on. 
 I've never seen any of my clothes on a professional model. 
 It's amazing to see the coat as part of a complete look &mdash; with the hair and make-up complementing it.&equo; 
 The final takes place on June 5, and the Clothes Show  will be there with the cameras, so you can see the event for yourself. 
 To Amy &mdash; and all the other finalists &mdash; good luck!  
 Above: the printed housecoat, designed by student Amy Moore, which was selected by the Clothes Show Magazine . 
 Left: Jeff Banks shows Amy's design to the judges 
 The Smirnoff competition judges: above, Kim Hunt and Alan Couldridge; left, current Designer of the Year, Vivienne Westwood. 
 Also on the judges' panel were Caroline Baker (Fashion Director, Mirabella , Lucille Lewin (Managing Director, Whistles), Myrene de Premonville (Fashion Designer) and Sebastien de Diesbach (Promostyl). 
 Left: Amy's design amidst other entries that reached the Smirnoff semi-finals 
 Reportage photographs: Flo Smith 
 The Smirnoff Student Fashion Week is from June 3&ndash;7, 1991. 
 The Fashion Awards are on June 5. 
 All events are at the Business Design Centre, London N1. 
 For tickets and information, call 071 379 4444 
 Slaving over the drawing board or the painstaking pattern-cutting stage (1,2). 
 Working on the calico toile, a rough version of the finished garment (3,4). 
 The final toile on the clothes stand (5) 
 Amy at the stove, experimenting with coloured dyes (6,7,8,9): &bquo;For this print, I was thinking of patterns of light and shade created by strong sunlight.&equo; 
 Painting the wooden starfish brooch (10), and the finished article (11). 
 &bquo;Having my design photographed like this has been a really exciting experience&equo; 
 The stunning final results of Amy's finished garment. 
 Shoes, Shelly's. 
 Words: Saska Graville. 
 This photograph: Martyn Thompson. 
 Hair and make-up Val Garland at Camilla Arthur 
 YOUR VERY GOOD health 
 Dr Cathy Read with the latest on the health front, from help for hay fever to odour-absorbent paint 
 THE HEALTHY ALTERNATIVE 
 Like it or not, alternative medicine often reaches parts of the body ordinary NHS treatment fails to reach. 
 Chinese herbalists have gained a reputation for treating eczema, masseurs for relieving the pain of some kinds of arthritis and cranial osteopaths for quietening crying babies. 
 Alternative medicine is also becoming increasingly popular &mdash; the latest figures show that one person in seven has seen a complementary practitioner within the past year. 
 Even so, finding your way around the alternative medicine maze may be a problem. 
 Few alternative therapies are available on the NHS, so you may have to find a practitioner yourself &mdash; and not everyone who practises complementary medicine is adequately trained. 
 Now a new book, The Reader's Digest Family Guide to Alternative Medicine* , has been published to help you find out when alternative medicine may be helpful and whether or not the claims made are valid. 
 And it also tells you how you can find a fully trained practitioner. 
 For instance, if you need an osteopath, look out for the letters MRO &mdash; this means that the osteopath has completed a four-year course and is registered to practise. 
 * The Reader's Digest Family Guide to Alternative Medicine  is available from bookshops at &pound;24.95. 
 THE END OF SNORING? 
 Do you wake up regularly to a deafening snore and feel there is no alternative but to give your partner a hefty prod? 
 According to Swedish ENT specialist Dr Bjorn Petruson a small plastic device could make all the difference to those noisy nights. 
 The Nozovent, which is worn just inside the nostrils at night, reduces snoring by making breathing easier. 
 Nozovent costs &pound;5.99 for a pair and is available from Inphormed at Worthy Park House, Abbots Worthy, Winchester, Hants SO21 1AN. 
 THE WONDERS OF FISH OIL 
 Oily fish is a topic this page has already covered in a previous issue, so you'll know that a regular meal of oily fish &mdash; herring, mackerel, trout and the like &mdash; can actually halve your risk of having a heart attack. 
 Fish oil supplements have also been found to help people suffering from psoriasis, arthritis and SLE &mdash; a disease which causes skin rashes and joint pains. 
 And that's not all. 
 Doctors now believe one of the constituents of fish oil &mdash; eicosapentaenoic acid &mdash; could help beat cancer. 
 Laboratory studies show that fish oil may prevent weight loss and cause cancers to shrink. 
 It also seems to work against cancers resistant to standard anti-cancer drugs. 
 Tests on patients are to go ahead this year. 
 If successful it will mean gentler treatments for cancer sufferers as many drugs currently in use have toxic side effects. 
 ODOURS NO LONGER LINGER 
 It looks as though sweaty locker rooms will be a thing of the past as Swedish scientists have developed a smell-absorbing paint. 
 In tests at Linkoping University the paint removed around 80 per cent of smelly chemicals &mdash; absorbing them through tiny pores. 
 Wallpaper also absorbs smells but, unlike the new paint, tends to retain them. 
 So, it could be goodbye to body odour &mdash; but only in the right room. 
 HAY FEVER 
 Watch out, hay fever season is approaching &mdash; and one in 10 of us will be affected. 
 Hay fever is really an allergy to pollen and the peak time is early June. 
 At the start of the season sufferers usually begin to experience problems when the pollen count reaches 50. 
 But that's just the start; counts of 200 are not uncommon and in summer 1984 the pollen count in central London reached a record 820. 
 Medical treatment for hay fever is now much better than it used to be. 
 Eye drops and nose sprays are among the most helpful treatments. 
 If you're expecting trouble it's worth consulting your doctor early as some treatments work best if started in advance. 
 Antihistamine tablets can be bought from the chemist without a prescription. 
 Make sure the ones you buy don't cause drowsiness and avoid any combination drugs. 
 And remember &mdash; if you're using eye drops for your hay fever, leave your contact lenses out. 
 WAIST NOT 
 If you're watching your weight the ideal period between weigh-ins is one to two weeks, says Dr Tom Sanders, Lecturer in Nutrition at the University of London. 
 Most people gain weight in cycles and too frequent or infrequent weighing will mean that you miss the tend. 
 The size of the problem? 
 According to a recent survey, 35&ndash;45 per cent of British adults are overweight and 8&ndash;12 per cent are very overweight. 
 And while a little plumpness may not do much harm, being very fat is a definite health hazard, increasing the risk of heart disease, gall bladder disease, some cancers and arthritis.  
 Pepsi &amp; Shirlie striking a pose 
 Gone is the girlie-girlie image of yesteryear&hellip; the dynamic duo Pepsi and Shirlie are back &mdash; with a new look and single to boot. 
 Four years ago Pepsi and Shirlie were enjoying considerable chart success and media attention. 
 The singles Heartache  and Goodbye Stranger  both reached the top 20, and countless magazines profiled their public and private lives. 
 This publicity did the girls harm as well as good &mdash; they were overexposed. 
 It was six months before their debut album was in the shops and by that time public interest in them had waned. 
 With a new single, Someday , written and produced by George Michael, Pepsi and Shrlie are relaunching themselves. 
 Determined not to repeat past mistakes they are doing things differently this time round. 
 The most striking change in the duo is their image &mdash; our pictures show Pepsi and Shirlie as you've never seen them before! 
 They've thrown away their frilly skirts and put on some more grown-up clothes. 
 Pepsi explained the transformation: &bquo;We were far too girlie-girlie before. 
 When we started off we were in our puffballs, but we're definitely not that dressy now.&equo; 
 Shirlie explained, &bquo;This time we wanted clothes that felt comfortable but also looked strong.&equo; 
 Pepsi outlined the problems behind their new style: &bquo;It was difficult coming up with a look that was original, that didn't look like Kylie or Madonna but retained their strength &mdash; I think we've cracked it though.&equo; 
 The girls spent a long time putting their new  wardrobe together. 
 They sketched their ideas and then looked for clothes to match. 
 Shirlie described the process: &bquo;We knew we wanted strong shapes, with big jackets. 
 I'm always happy when I'm wearing trousers and a jacket that covers my bum!&equo; 
 It's easy to forget that it's over eight years since Pepsi and Shirlie first sang with Wham! and Shirlie still laughs at the memories: &bquo;When we started out I had one dress and I wore it to every photo session &mdash; I couldn't afford any more!&equo; 
 It's not only her clothes that have changed &mdash; George Michael is now famous the world over. 
 &bquo;We've always been really good friends but hadn't worked together for a long time. 
 He's such a huge star now that I was actually nervous when I walked into the studio with him.&equo; 
 Pepsi and Shirlie may not have reached George's superstar status but they know the direction they're moving in &mdash; &bquo;We don't want to be bubblegum one-hit-wonders. 
 Our image is now very strong but we've also got the music to carry us through.&equo; 
 All we can say is don't look back!  
 Above: Pepsi and Shirlie four years ago, in the days of the puffball and the &bquo;girlie-girlie&equo; image. 
 Right, Pepsi: polka dot all-in-one and shirt, Jean Paul Gaultier; shirt, Plein Sud; tights, Wolford; gloves, Harrods &mdash; all Pepsi's own. 
 Below, Shirlie: top and skirt, Plein Sud; boots, Shelly's; necklace, S-Tek; tights, Wolford &mdash; all Shirlie's own 
 &bquo;This is one of the cutest outfits I've ever worn &mdash; I look like some kind of exotic jockey&equo; Pepsi, above 
 &bquo;The crossover back of this top looks really stunning when I've got a good suntan&equo; Shirlie, left 
 &bquo;This is me &mdash; this is how I dress up to go out&equo; Pepsi 
 &bquo;I'm in love with this belt at the moment, I wear it all the time&equo; Shirlie 
 Pepsi: Jacket and trousers, John Galliano; bra top, Dolce &amp; Gabbana; belt, S-Tek; boots, Office &mdash; all Pepsi's own 
 Shirlie: all-in-one, Jean Paul Gaultier; shirt, Dia Positive; waistcoat, John Galliano; belt, S-Tek: gloves, Harrods; tights, Wolford &mdash; all Shirlie's own 
 Right, Pepsi: coat and necklace, John Galliano: bra top, Joe Casely-Hayford; trousers, Plein Sud; belt, Next; boots, Office &mdash; all Pepsi's own. 
 Shirlie: jacket, top and skirt, Plein Sud; spotty shirt, Junior Gaultier; necklace, S-Tek: boots, Shelly's &mdash; all Shirlie's own 
 &bquo;This outfit's crazy &mdash; don't mess with me in this!&equo; 
 Pepsi 
 &bquo;I'm always happier when I'm wearing something that covers my behind&equo; Shirlie 
 Left, Pepsi: top, Dolce &amp; Gabbana; skirt, Plein Sud; necklace, John Galliano &mdash; all Pepsi's own. 
 Shirlie: jacket, Plein Sud; bra top, Joe Casely-Hayford; trousers, John Galliano; belt, S-Tek &mdash; all Shirlie's own 
 Words: Saska Graville. 
 Photographs: Tim Palmer. 
 Hair: Tracy Kurtulus at Vidal Sassoon Salons. 
 Makeup: Janet Dunford 
 &bquo;This top takes a while to put on properly but it's worth it in the end&equo; Pepsi, far left 
 &bquo;I love this outfit &mdash; I feel quite boyish in it&equo; Shirlie, left 
 CLOTHES SHOW ON THE ROAD 
 bursting into bloom 
 This spring, the catwalks were strewn with bold, beautiful flowers. 
 See what happened overleaf when we went north to practise our own floral wizardry on a few of those bright young Mancunians&hellip; 
 Julie Owens, 30, personnel assistant (right): &bquo;I'd rather the skirt was a bit longer and I prefer a court shoe. 
 I like the top &mdash; and I think the hair's great.&equo; 
 Chiffon shirt, &pound;16.99, Hennes. 
 Skirt, &pound;33.90, Stefanel. 
 Blue body, &pound;21.99, Pineapple. 
 Suede loafers, &pound;34.99, Jones Bootmakers. 
 Silvia Clear Sheers, &pound;2.30, Pretty Polly. 
 Kerry Hardman, 30, housewife, and Allanah, 5, (right): &bquo;I like this outfit. 
 It feels light and floaty &mdash; just right for summer. 
 And I think Allanah looks lovely &mdash; she can take lots of bright colours.&equo; 
 Kerry's shirt, &pound;22.99, Zygo. 
 Skirt, &pound;38, Jigsaw. 
 Allanah's dress, &pound;13.99, Blooming Marvellous. 
 Flower from a selection at John Lewis. 
 Mark Taylor, 19, student (left): &bquo;I like the shirt. 
 I'm not mad about the tie but it's quite smart.&equo; 
 Silk shirt, &pound;39.99, French Connection. 
 Silk tie, &pound;30, Rhiannon. 
 Joanna, 18, schoolgirl (left): &bquo;This dress is shorter and tighter than I usually wear.&equo; 
 Dress, &pound;75, Jigsaw. 
 Shoes, &pound;65, Red or Dead. 
 Earrings, &pound;11.99, Oasis. 
 Admiral Clear Sheers, &pound;2.30, Pretty Polly. 
 Georgina Brecker, 21, journalist (far right): &bquo;I don't think anything sleeveless is very flattering!&equo; 
 Sister Alexis, 18, student (right); &bquo;I'd wear the hot pants &mdash; without the flowers.&equo; 
 Georgina's jeans, &pound;30, French Connection. 
 Body, about &pound;29.99, Scruffs. 
 Hat, &pound;46.95, The Hat Shop. 
 Pendant, &pound;21.95, Fenwick. 
 Alexis's hot pants, &pound;30; top &pound;25, Juliette Spatchett at Hyper Hyper. 
 Earrings, &pound;12.99; ring, &pound;9.99, Zygo. 
 Barely Black Ultra Clear Sheers, &pound;2.55, Pretty Polly. 
 Caroline Yates, 16, schoolgirl (right): &bquo;I think the hat's brilliant &mdash; just right for now&equo;. 
 Dress, &pound;29.99, Zygo. 
 Hat, &pound;55, Fred Bare. 
 Espadrilles, &pound;29.99, Jones Bootmakers. 
 Silvia Clear Sheers, &pound;2.30, Pretty Polly. 
 Flowers, John Lewis. 
 Sonya Miller, 17, trainee hairdresser (right); &bquo;This is OK but I feel more comfortable in dresses.&equo; 
 Roselyn Wong, 17, student (far right): &bquo;This is just my style &mdash; especially if I was going out.&equo; 
 Sonya's top and leggings, about &pound;29.99 each, Scruffs. 
 Loafers, &pound;49.99, Jones Bootmakers. 
 Admiral Clear Sheers, &pound;2.30, Pretty Polly.  
 Toby Reader, 18, trainee engineer (above) with Anita Lawson, 18, student: &bquo;At first I didn't like this,&equo; said Toby, &bquo;but it's growing on me.&equo; 
 Said Anita, &bquo;I like this dress.&equo; 
 Toby's jeans, &pound;32.99, BSCO. 
 Shirt, &pound;42.99, Wild Woman at Ted Baker. 
 shoes, &pound;50, Red or Dead. 
 Flowers, from a selection at John Lewis. 
 Anita's dress, &pound;180, Karen Boyd. 
 Shoes, &pound;17.99, Manfield. 
 Two pairs of Sunblush Clear Sheers, &pound;2.30 each, Pretty Polly. 
 Andy Gordon, 19, student (right): &bquo;I like all of this stuff, no problem.&equo; 
 T-shirt, &pound;16, French Connection. 
 Shorts, &pound;32.50, Levi's. 
 Trainers, &pound;36.99, Wasp at Champion Sports. 
 Debra Phillip, 19, trainee designer (below): &bquo;This blouse is beautiful.&equo; 
 Shirt, &pound;46, Hobbs. 
 Skirt, &pound;67.20, Karen Boyd. 
 Shoes, &pound;39.99, Jones Bootmakers. 
 Ultra Clear Sheers, &pound;2.55, Pretty Polly. 
 Andrea Berry, 20, student (above): &bquo;The shorts and tights look good.&equo; 
 Body, &pound;21.99, Pineapple. 
 Shorts, &pound;17.99, Zygo. 
 Loafers, &pound;49.99, Jones Bootmakers. 
 Silvia Clear Sheers, &pound;2.30, Pretty Polly. 
 Lindsey Ahmet (far left) and Natalie Stirrup (left) both 3&frac12;, stole the show! 
 Lindsey's T-shirt, &pound;6.95, Blooming Marvellous. 
 Silk scarf (as skirt), from &pound;9.99, Tie Rack. 
 Pendant, &pound;14, Carol Bright at Hyper Hyper. 
 Natalie's A-line T-shirt, &pound;16.90, Benetton 012. 
 Pendant, &pound;18, Lanssa Kay at Hyper Hyper. 
 All socks, &pound;1.99, Littlewoods. 
 Flowers, from a selection at John Lewis. 
 Emma Jones, 16, student (right): &bquo;I think this is gorgeous; I'd definitely buy it.&equo; 
 Vest dress, &pound;26.99, Zygo. 
 Waistcoat, &pound;228, Karen Boyd. 
 Shoes, about &pound;45, Red or Dead. 
 Barely Black Ultra Clear Sheers, &pound;2.55, Pretty Polly. 
 SHEER GENIUS 
 Summer's here, hemlines are high: it's time to put your best foot forward and show off your perfectly dressed legs &mdash; and no-one knows how to flatter them more  perfectly than Pretty Polly. 
 Bright florals are the rage this season so you'll need a subtle shade of tights to complement rather than overpower your outfits. 
 Silvia, Admiral and Sunblush in the Clear Sheers range will go with virtually anything, or, for a darker but equally delicate look, choose Barely Black Ultra Clear Sheers. 
 And, just for fun, you can even mix your own palette by wearing two pairs at once to create a different shade.  
 On the Road in Manchester 
 Milan: high-waisted elegance by Krizia 
 New York: Linda Evangelista models for Bill Blass 
 Paris: chez  Chanel 
 Paris: tropical orange from Ungaro 
 Top designers said it with flowers this spring: a floral jungle by Bill Blass (above); black and floral trousers by Krizia (above left); a splash of colour from Chanel (far left) and Ungaro's tropical sarong-style fantasy (left). 
 Top left: Clothes Show on the Road  with Pretty Polly at the Arndale Centre, Manchester 
 Photographs: Peter Brown. 
 Hair and make-up: Ya'nina at Artistic Licence and Robert Johnson at Terrie Tanaka. 
 We stayed at the Britannia Hotel, Portland Street, Manchester (061 228 2288). 
 Stockists are on page 92 
 CLOTHES SHOW PROMOTION 
 Even a typical British summer can wreak havoc with your skin, so with the holiday months approaching, it's time to nurture a beauty regime that will guard against the sun's drying effects. 
 We cleared through the overgrowth of new products to find the secret of a truly rosy complexion! 
 natural BLOOM 
 Faced with shelves groaning with skincare products, each bearing baffling scientific claims, making the right choice can seem an impossible task. 
 And if your skin is sensitive and easily irritated, finding suitable products can be doubly difficult. 
 With these problems in mind, Sensiq has developed the ideal skincare range to complement their range of cosmetics. 
 Using only the mildest ingredients, all products are fragrance-free and suitable for sensitive skins. 
 And it's easy to find exactly which ones are right for your skin, as the entire range is colour-coded, using four pastel shades to identify the three different skin types, plus the Extra Care range. 
 Shell pink is the colour for dry skins in need of extra care and lots of moisture. 
 A light, creamy Gentle Purifying Cleanser softens as it cleanses and the Gentle Moisturising Cream is easily absorbed to sooth the skin and offer long-lasting protection. 
 Peach is the colour for normal and combination skins. 
 Gentle Clarifying Lotion offers thorough cleansing without stripping the skin of its natural moisture, while Gentle Balanced Moisture Lotion helps maintain the skin's natural elasticity. 
 Both products are designed to bridge the gap between the dry cheeks and the greasy central &bquo;T-zone&equo; that typify the normal and combination skin type. 
 Aqua has been specially designed for oily skins. 
 A refreshing Effective Cleansing Gell and Oil Free Hydrating Lotion help control excess oil gently but effectively, leaving skin shine-free but without over-drying it. 
 Powder Blue signifies the Extra Care range of products which can be used on all skin types. 
 The range consists of an Overnight Replenishing Treatment, a Soothing Skin Tonic and an oil-free pH balanced Effective Eye Make-Up Remover. 
 An uncomplicated and easy-to-use range, Sensiq's light-textured formulas are quickly absorbed and gentle on your skin, leaving it feeling much softer and smoother without a trace of stickiness. 
 The Sensiq skincare range has been extensively researched and screened, and most common allergens and irritants have been omitted. 
 In fact, when compared with another leading sensitive skincare brand in independent laboratory tests, the Sensiq Skin Care Collection was found to be seven times less likely to cause irritation. 
 For extra protection, some products contain a protective sunscreen plus Vitamin E to enrich and condition your skin. 
 Sensiq products are kind to your conscience, too. 
 None of them have been tested on animals and all bottles are recyclable. 
 What's more, the prices won't hurt your pocket, either; a small investment for a clearer, smoother skin.  
 Turn yourself into a natural beauty this summer by adopting a good skin care routine now with the help of Sensiq. 
 Proper cleansing and moisturising are essential to avoid the effects of sunbathing and those long, late summer nights. 
 Sensiq's lovely pastel colours reflect the sunny feeling and  identify your ideal skin products according to skin type. 
 And with prices in the collection starting at only &pound;3.32, Sensiq should leave your bank balance looking as healthy as your skin. 
 Photograph: Peter Underwood. 
 Hair: Gregory Cazaly at Satellite. 
 Make-up: Virginia Nicholls at Image 
 and the bride wore whiskers! 
 &hellip; 
 And the groom came as The Mad Hatter. 
 Sally Watkin talked to three adventurous couples who defied the tradition of the white wedding and opted for something completely different. 
 TREVOR AND ERIKA 
 &bquo;I'm late, I'm late, for a very important date&hellip;&equo; 
 If Erika Payers had failed to get to the church (registry office, actually) on time, it would have been entirely in keeping with her costume. 
 For when Erik and her husband, Trevor, from Oxford, eventually decided to tie the knot after living together for eight years, the prospect of a conventional white wedding didn't even enter their heads. 
 &bquo;We both dislike formality and stuffy weddings where everybody does what their parents want,&equo; explains Erika. 
 &bquo;My nickname was &bquo;Rabbit&equo; because of my prominent front teeth &mdash; so when we decided to get married, I instantly thought of dressing up as the White Rabbit in Alice in Wonderland . 
 And Trevor being the Mad Hatter in top hat and tails fitted in perfectly with my idea.&equo; 
 Ever since they met, the Payers have shared a love of fancy dress and playing practical jokes on their friends. 
 Their wedding was no exception. 
 Not wishing to put their nearest and dearest to enormous expense the happy couple omitted to mention on the invitations that they were getting married. 
 Instead, Erika and Trevor billed the big day as a going-away party. 
 They'd both jacked in their jobs (he's a computer programmer; she's a physiotherapist) and were planning to backpack round the world for a few months. 
 &bquo;We lured 150 people to a party by promising them lots of food and drink and a magical mystery tour,&equo; laughs Trevor. 
 Getting the guests to don fancy dress wasn't a problem. 
 &bquo;They were used to our mad schemes and wearing outrageous clothes for parties was normal in our crowd. 
 Everybody always enjoyed themselves when we dressed up &mdash; wearing peculiar clothes usually creates an instant talking point, even between total strangers,&equo; says Erika. 
 Far from being influenced by superstitions about her groom seeing her outfit before the big day, Erika enlisted Trevor's help in making it. 
 &bquo;He made the ears out of an old pair of mouse ears I'd used for a previous party,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;I bought a pair of white Wrangler dungarees and a Laura Ashley blouse I knew I'd wear again. 
 I borrowed a veil from my aunt, who said that, at the age of 50, she couldn't imagine herself needing it again. 
 It's just as well &mdash; I cut two holes in it for the ears! 
 The whole outfit only cost about &pound;75.&equo; 
 They did the deed in nearby Abingdon Registry Office, thanks to a very sympathetic registrar who managed to enter into the spirit of things. 
 &bquo;When he said, &bquo;This is a serious and solemn occasion&equo;, people started to laugh,&equo; remembers Trevor. 
 &bquo;And when he said, &bquo;I declare you man and wife&equo;, everyone threw their hats into the air!&equo; 
 After the ceremony, the newly-weds cycled the eight miles back to the reception (held in a friend's garden) on their tandem. 
 &bquo;We only hope that when our sons, baby Toby and Charlie, marry, they do it as outrageously as we did,&equo; say Trevor and Erika. 
 ANDY AND ALISON 
 Television presenter Alison Holloway wore white (well, cream, to be exact) twice to get married: for her first wedding to Alistair Watson, son of veteran British screen start Jack Watson, and second time around, when she got hitched to TV comedian Jim &bquo;Nick Nick&equo; Davidson. 
 Small wonder then that when, in December 1989, after two divorces, she finally married the man of her dreams, freelance TV producer Andy Ward, she decided to give tradition the elbow. 
 She met Andy while working on a production of Carmen  at Sky Television, and at their wedding, her two outfits stole the show. 
 For the Wandsworth Registry Office ceremony, Alison sported a fringed pair of extremely brief black shorts teamed with a great Jasper Conran jacket. 
 Later, she wore an extravagant Russian-style creation for the church blessing. 
 &bquo;I thought the clothes were great,&equo; says Alison, who combines a full-time job for British Sky Broadcasting, newsreading and presenting a current affairs/magazine programme with hosting the quiz show, Run The Gauntlet , for ITV. 
 &bquo;I fancied getting married in black because it seemed to throw tradition to the winds, and looked very dramatic. 
 I wanted to wear really bright red lipstick too, just  for the sheer hell of it!&equo; 
 Up until the day before the wedding, she was planning to wear the Jasper Conran jacket, teamed with matching long skirt. 
 &bquo;But then I thought, no, let's go crazy,&equo; says Alison, &bquo;so I went shopping and found the shorts in a shop on the King's Road that specialises in tight gear. 
 I wore them with a pair of black leather gloves trimmed with fake fur, and the jacket, which has padded shoulders and is trimmed with feathers.&equo; 
 As for the Russian angle, it came about because of a dream. 
 &bquo;A couple of months before the wedding, I woke up in the middle of the night worrying about the arrangements, and the only thought in my head was &bquo;Russia&equo;. 
 I wanted to get away from the boring white theme, but the only dress I really liked was one by David Fielden which had white fur and beading. 
 When I asked if they could make me an identical one trimmed with black fur and beading instead, they were horrified but they agreed in the end.&equo; 
 Alison was a little coy about how much her Russian dress cost, but, according to the staff at David Fielden, their cheapest frock is at least &pound;1,000. 
 To complete the outfit, Alison had a pair of Victorian ankle boots made in the same material as her dress, and got a local milliner to make her a stunning hat. 
 The unusual theme was carried through the entire wedding, with vodka and schnapps served at the back of the church. 
 The reception, complete with Thai barbecue, was held in a marquee in the back garden of their south London home, and the newly-weds jetted off for a honeymoon in New York. 
 Poor Andy knew nothing about the fact that his bride was planning to sport shorts for the most important vows of her life. 
 &bquo;The colour drained from his face when I pulled up in the wedding car dressed all in black,&equo; recalls Alison, grinning at the memory. 
 &bquo;And as I put one leg out of the door, he looked slightly taken aback, because he could see that my leg was bare. 
 His mouth just dropped open!&equo; 
 And Andy's response? 
 &bquo;Alison's got a very individual style, so I've learnt to expect the unexpected, I thought she looked fabulous.&equo; 
 NICK AND ALISON 
 Alison Cryer has always loathed the idea of white weddings with all the trimmings. 
 In fact, to start with, she wasn't even that keen on the idea of marriage itself! 
 &bquo;I don't really believe in marriage, but I didn't want to lose my husband either, so I gave in,&equo; she explains. 
 Alison, who runs a company specialising in marketing travel and tourism, has known Nick, an architect, for about 12 years, but they didn't get together until he became her lodger. 
 To start with, Alison planned to wear a white evening dress. 
 &bquo;But I showed one or two to Nick and he said, &bquo;I hope you're not wearing white; I expect you to wear something colourful.&equo; 
 So I went out to look for something else. 
 When I saw the red dress, I knew that was the one I wanted. 
 It's designed by Tomasz Starzewski, who made the dress that Viscount Althorp's wife, Victoria, wore for their wedding. 
 It cost just over &pound;1,500, which was about three times my budget, but I just had  to have it. 
 But I've already worn it lots of times since and I'll always wear it. 
 Not surprisingly, she was the centre of attention at her own wedding, two years ago, at Auchterader House in Gleneagles, a Scottish country house hotel. 
 &bquo;Word had got round that I was wearing red, but I think the guests were relieved when they saw me, and realised my dress wasn't too outrageous,&equo; says Alison. 
 The last word must go to Nick: &bquo;She said it was going to be different, but I didn't realise quite how different. 
 I have a vivid memory of her descending the stairs to the conservatory where we said our vows. 
 I was totally thrilled.&equo;  
 &bquo;We both dislike weddings that are stuffy and formal&equo; 
 Wedding in Wonderland. 
 The Mad Hatter and the White Rabbit (alias Trevor and Erika Payers) pose for the perfect shot (above) and then ride off in tandem to their reception, a distance of eight miles (left) 
 The Scarlet Bride. 
 Alison Cryer (below) in her red-hot wedding gown, with husband Nick Hyams, at the reception. 
 The bridal bouquet is somewhat out of the ordinary, too! 
 From Russia with Love. 
 Andy Ward and his bridge, Alison Holloway (above), dressed in a fur-trimmed David Fielden gown for the church blessing (suitable for Siberia, too.) 
 And for the registry office (below), Alison sports a brief pair of tassled black shorts teamed with a Jasper Conran jacket 
 CLOTHES SHOW CLUB 
 become a priority reader 
 Save &pound;50 on a Cover Girl makeover, try new slimline recipes, and keep your clothes clean on holiday 
 Sweet Nothings 
 A spoonful of sweetener helps the calories go down &mdash; replace one teaspoon of sugar with a teaspoon of Canderel Spoonful, a granular sweetener, and you'll save 18 calories. 
 Canderel is made with NutraSweet so, unlike some saccharin sweeteners, it doesn't have a bitter aftertaste. 
 It can be used just like granulated sugar, spoon for spoon, in drinks, desserts, cereals and some recipes. 
 And our free gift this month is a recipe leaflet showing you how to create delicious calorie-reduced meals. 
 We also have 200 jars of Canderel Spoonful and their recipe book called Sweet Thoughts  (worth &pound;11.84 in total) to give away. 
 See the Club letter for full details. 
 Picture This 
 Inside all of us there is a sultry, glamorous model just waiting to step under the studio lights. 
 Or so Cover Girl can prove with their amazing &bquo;before&equo; and &bquo;after&equo; shots seen above. 
 You provide the potential, they provide a professional make-up artist, stylist and photographer. 
 Et Voil&agrave; , a beautiful model emerges. 
 And you can show off the new you with a set of stunning pictures which are ready just two hours after the session. 
 The million dollar look usually costs &pound;95 for a session but Clothes Show  Club members can now get the star treatment with a massive saving of &pound;50. 
 Our special offer session will cost &pound;45. 
 You don't have to buy enlargements. 
 Photographs are available from &pound;30 a print, and collections of framed pictures from &pound;295. 
 The Cover Girl Studio is at 74 New Bond Street, London W1. 
 See the Club letter for details of this offer. 
 Wash Away 
 The last thing you want to lug on holiday is a full-size pack of washing powder, yet a few items always need a handwash. 
 That's where Dylon's Getaway travel wash comes in. 
 It's a concentrated cream detergent in a handy 100ml tube which should last for up to 20 washes. 
 Getaway is simple to use, suitable for all fabrics and works perfectly in hot, cold and even sea water. 
 A 100ml tube usually costs &pound;1.09 from department stores, supermarkets and chemists, but we have 100 to give away free to Clothes Show  Club members. 
 Details are in the Club letter. 
 Wella Way 
 Congratulations to Club member Barbara Keys who was chosen from hundreds of entries to have a makeover together with her mum, Betty. 
 We brought them over from County Antrim in Northern Ireland for an expenses-paid trip to London and an image transformation by haircare experts from Wella. 
 Turn to page 30 to see the stunning results. 
 Join the Club 
 Don't miss out on the fun! 
 Join our Clothes Show  Club today. 
 It's great value &mdash; for &pound;15 you receive: 
 * 
 Your favourite magazine sent to your home each month for a year. 
 * 
 Exclusive discounts off high street clothes and accessories. 
 * 
 A host of free gifts sent to you throughout the year. 
 * 
 Easy-to-win competitions. 
 ME AND MY HAT 
 You might be mad to wear one but, whether it's a creation for Ascot or a woolly pull-on number, there's a hat to top off any outfit 
 Hats are funny things &mdash; you either love them or you hate them. 
 There are people who never leave home without one, while others feel ridiculous wearing something on their head. 
 We found some people who are just mad about hats and discovered why they like their favourite headgear. 
 Thelma Speirs is a professional hatter, and one half of the design duo Bernstock &amp; Speirs. 
 She has been in the hat business since 1982 but a devotee for far longer. 
 &bquo;I've never been scared to wear hats, although I know some people are. 
 When I was a student, I wore some quite outrageous numbers &mdash; I remember a huge red velvet one with a big black bow on the front.&equo; 
 Nowadays, Thelma's hats are less flamboyant. 
 Making hats for a living and looking at them all day long has mellowed her taste somewhat. 
 &bquo;I'm much more restrained now in the hats I choose to wear. 
 I like classic hats &mdash; this baseball cap, for instance, or a bowler hat. 
 Bernstock &amp; Speirs' hats are designed to be easy to wear. 
 Daytime hats &mdash; that's my style these days.&equo; 
 Restrained is not the word you would choose to describe Caron Wheeler's style of dressing. 
 The extrovert singer, famous for her work with Soul II Soul, is a confirmed hatter, and her taste is for the exotic, never the ordinary. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't feel dressed without something on my head or a really good hairdo &mdash; it's got to be a hairdo or a hat!&equo; 
 Caron's love of hats is nothing new. 
 &bquo;I've always worn headgear of some sort or another. 
 I used to buy lots of hats at Oxfam, as well as headwraps and authentic African styles.&equo; 
 The cane hat that Caron is wearing here lets her show off her dreadlocks. 
 &bquo;It's taken me 10 years to grow them this long so I don't like hiding them completely under a hat.&equo; 
 The hat is a fragile structure that winds its way around Caron's head, spiralling upwards &mdash; unusual to say the least. 
 &bquo;It's a veil and I can then weave my hair through it. 
 It's perfect to wear when I'm on stage because it's not heavy.&equo; 
 Caron's philosophy is clear:  &bquo;Wearing a hat makes you feel complete &mdash; like a bottle with a lid on.&equo; 
 Rachel, Liz and Pieng share a flat and  a taste for handmade hats. 
 Here, they're wearing a matching floral set that Rachel made for them. 
 &bquo;I started making hats when I gave up my job and needed something to do. 
 My first successes were in fake fur &mdash; we had one each. 
 We all liked wearing them so I made everybody one in flowery silk.&equo; 
 How do Liz and Pieng feel about Rachel's creative streak? 
 &bquo;Her hats are beautiful and fun,&equo; they said. 
 Liz has good reason to be enthusiastic. 
 &bquo;I've got a tiny head and I could never find hats to fit. 
 Now Rachel tailor-makes them for me.&equo; 
 Have they ever gone out all together, a trio of matching flowery heads? 
 &bquo;We did once and we got loads of comments &mdash; Liz even got chased down the road by a tramp!&equo; 
 Daniel Halpin's favourite hat is designed by Bernstock and Speirs. 
 &bquo;What really attracted me to this hat was its shape &mdash; it reminded me of the ones American tourists wear.&equo; 
 He also had a more unusual reason for needing something on his head. 
 &bquo;When I bought this hat, I'd just had a horrible haircut so it covered up the mistake nicely.&equo; 
 His only reservation is the hat's colour. 
 &bquo;The blue is a bit too close to the sky blue of the West Ham football kit, and I'm not a fan!&equo; 
 Hats are a family favourite with Buster, Kim, Naomi and Jordan. 
 The straw hats they're seen in here are only a fraction of the collection they've amassed at home. 
 Family friends enjoy the hats, too. 
 &bquo;Whenever people visit our house, they try them on. 
 It often turns into a &bquo;hat party&equo; with friends sitting around wearing all sorts of styles while they have a drink.&equo; 
 It would seem from the variety of hats people wear that anything goes. 
 The materials used vary enormously &mdash; cane, straw, leather, satin &mdash; whatever takes your fancy And remember, if the hat (or cap) fits, then you know what they say&hellip; 
 A HAT FOR ALL SEASONS 
 Fancy a hat? 
 If you feel adventurous, you could follow Rachel's example and make one for yourself. 
 It's easy to do if you follow a pattern &mdash; and we've found a perfect one. 
 Marigold Hats have produced a simple pattern for a soft hat with a turned-up brim. 
 You can pick the material, and even use beads or sequins to liven up the design. 
 Send a postal order or cheque payable to Helen Furber, for &pound;2 (inc p&amp;p), to Marigold Hats, 4 High Street, Shrewsbury SY1 1SP.  
 Caron Wheeler: &bquo;This isn't exactly an everyday hat, it's far too delicate. 
 It's perfect for a special occasion or a video.&equo; 
 Thelma Speirs: &bquo;This hat is nice and cartoony, good for nightclubs. 
 If I wasn't a hat designer I'm sure I'd have loads of hats anyway.&equo; 
 Baseball cap with bow, about &pound;35, Bernstock &amp; Speirs 
 Liz (left), Rachel (right), Pieng (front). 
 Rachel: &bquo;I loved the print of this material but I didn't know what to make with it. 
 The hats emerged as a result of just messing around with it.&equo; 
 Daniel Halpin: &bquo;My last hat was a flowery one, the same shape as this but a bit more girlie.&equo; 
 Gaberdine and leather fisherman's hat, about &pound;55, Bernstock &amp; Speirs 
 Words: Saska Graville. 
 Photographs: Caroline Hughes. 
 Hair and make-up: Cathy Lomax at Elite. 
 Make-up for Caron Wheeler: Pat McGrath at Unique. 
 Styling: Wunmi. 
 Chairs from SCP Ltd (071 739 1869). 
 Stockists are on page 92 
 Buster (left), Kim (right), Naomi (front left), Jordan (front right). 
 Kim: &bquo;We've never all gone out in hats at the same time &mdash; we'd get far too many rude comments.&equo; 
 Kim's straw hat, about &pound;80, from a selection at UBU Hats. 
 Naomi's straw cap, &pound;3.50, Woolworths. 
 (The rest were bought years ago!) 
 straw galore 
 Brighten up those lazy hay-zy summer days with a rainbow of raffia and straw 
 Styling: Karen McCartney. 
 Photographs (of model): Tim Palmer. 
 Still-life photographs: Mel Yates. 
 Hair and make-up: Gilda White at Carol Hayes. 
 Stockists are on page 92 
 CLOTHES SHOW NEXT MONTH 
 ON SALE JUNE 17 PRICE &pound;1 
 FIND OUT HOW TO SHOW YOUR BODY TO ITS BEST ADVANTAGE 
 WIN! 
 YOUR GREAT CHANCE TO STAR IN A HAIR ADVERT 
 PLUS! 
 PAULA HAMILTON JOHN FASHANU GABRIELA SABATINI 
 NEW IDEAS 
 YOUR COMPLETE GUIDE TO HOLIDAY FASHION AND BEAUTY  
 CLOTHES SHOW COMPETITION 
 WIN A WEEK AT A HEALTH HYDRO 
 Four winners, and their partners, will enjoy a week at top health farm Springs Hydro &mdash; plus &pound;100 worth of treatments from beauty specialists DeCleor. 
 You could win a week at Springs Hydro &mdash; and bring a friend or partner along with you as a part of the prize. 
 And, as if that weren't enough, while you're there you can enjoy &pound;100 worth of additional treatments from DeCleor, who offer a comprehensive range of aromatherapy and plant-based beauty products. 
 Springs Hydro is one of the country's finest health farms, a haven of tranquillity where you can cast off the strains and stresses of life and feel thoroughly pampered &mdash; both mentally and physically. 
 The setting is idyllic &mdash; acres of landscaped gardens near the pretty spa town of Ashby de la Zouch in rural Leicestershire &mdash; and you'll feel immediately at one with your surroundings. 
 This purpose-built health hydro has been designed around the needs of the guest so your every whim is catered for. 
 Amid the peace and comfort of your surroundings, you can enjoy healthy and delicious food, natural therapies and treatments, and any exercise can be as rigorous or as gentle as you wish. 
 We're always told we are what we eat, and Springs provides delicious healthy cuisine with that in mind. 
 The food is well-balanced and freshly prepared, using organically grown produce wherever possible, and there are qualified dieticians on hand to advise you. 
 On arrival, you'll enjoy a relaxing body massage followed by a facial session. 
 And with the additional treatments from DeCleor you'll be glowing from top to toe by the end of the week. 
 There is also a wide range of sporting activities to enjoy: a gymnasium with the latest fitness and toning equipment, dance and relaxation classes, indoor swimming pool, sauna, steam rooms, plunge, whirl and splash pools, archery, tennis, cycling, croquet. 
 There's even a golf-driving range. 
 And there are highly qualified instructors on hand to advise you. 
 In fact, Springs boasts a one-to-one ratio of staff to guests. 
 But don't be intimidated by all this talk of exercise. 
 If it suits you, you can relax with a long refreshing drink on the poolside terrace &mdash; and drink in the atmosphere as well. 
 One of the beauties of Springs is that you dictate the pace. 
 For further information call 0530 73873, or write to: Springs Hydro, Arlick Farm, Packington, Nr Ashby de la Zouch, Leicestershire LE5 6TG. 
 HERE'S WHAT TO DO 
 It's easy! 
 All you have to do is answer the three multiple-choice questions (right) by circling the correct corresponding letter in the coupon and send, to the address given, by Friday June 14, 1991. 
 1 Daley Thompson is famous for which one of the following? 
 a 
 Decathlon 
 b 
 Pentathlon 
 c 
 Triathlon 
 2 What is a vegan? 
 a 
 A small animal that feeds on grass or plants 
 b 
 A person who doesn't use any animal products at all 
 c 
 Someone who excludes meat and fish from their diet 
 3 Which one of the following is aerobic exercise? 
 a 
 Weightlifting 
 b 
 Yoga 
 c 
 Brisk walking 
 COMPETITION RULES 
 1 
 The competition is open to all readers resident in the UK, except employees of Springs Hydro, Redwood Publishing Ltd, BBC, their families and agents. 
 2 
 Entries must be received by no later than first post on Friday, June 14, 1991. 
 3 
 No responsibility can be taken for entries lost in the post. 
 4 
 The prizes are as stated only and no cash alternatives will be given. 
 5 
 Only one entry per person. 
 Entries can be on a postcard laid out in the manner of the coupon. 
 6 
 The decision of the judging panel is final. 
 No correspondence will be entered into. 
 7 
 All entrants to the competition are deemed to have accepted the rules and agreed to be bound by them. 
 Springs Hydro is set in acres of landscaped gardens in beautiful rural Leicestershire (1). 
 The gymnasium is equipped with the latest fitness and toning equipment (2). 
 Tennis is just one of the many sports you can enjoy at Springs(3). 
 There are also plunge, whirl and splash pools (4)&hellip; and a fabulous indoor swimming pool (5). 
 Or just relax in the comfortable surroundings &mdash; it's a home from home (6). 
 Have tensions pummelled away with a relaxing body massage (7). 
 And, at all times of the day, look forward to delicious healthy cuisine (8). 
 who wears what on their WEDDING DAY 
 Everyone pushes out the boat to look their best on the Big Day &mdash; so imagine what it must be like if money's no object. 
 Now read on&hellip; 
 Anthea Turner (above) radiant after her marriage to Peter Powell &mdash; but what a shame no one told him about Head and Shoulders  
 And the bride wore&hellip; the sitting room curtains! 
 Victoria Lockwood (left) begins her sometimes bumpy marriage to Charles Althorp 
 Some women will do anything in the name of beauty&hellip; 
 Emma Samms (above) even had one leg chopped off to get into her bridal gown 
 Third time lucky? 
 Madeleine Gurdon (above), becomes Mrs Lloyd Webber, Mark III 
 Emma Thompson (below) is so busy these days, she had to stay in her panto costume to marry Kenneth Branagh 
 A touch of class: &bquo;Royal&equo; florist Jane Packer (above) bursts into bloom on her own wonderful wedding day 
 Les Dawson (left) on, um, the happiest day of his life 
 Round-the-world yachtswoman Tracey Edwards (right), after sailing down the aisle 
 The Moore, the merrier: Roger, of that ilk (below), puts his right leg in on daughter Deborah's big day 
 Frank Bruno (left) makes an honest woman of Laura &mdash; know what we mean? 
 Rod and Rachel (left), embarking on what will be the longest-surviving marriage in the history of the world. 
 Ahem&hellip; 
 No, Pauline and brother Pete (above) aren't  breaking the law. 
 This is Wendy Richard's real life big day with actor Peter Dean joining in the jollities 
 Leaving her screen baby behind in Coronation Street , Helen Worth (left) joins Michael Angelis in the world's most frequently recurring soap &mdash; marriage 
 Ask Jeff 
 Worried about your looks? 
 Jeff Banks is here to help 
 MAKING FACES 
 I feel I'm not making the most of myself because I can't apply my make-up well. 
 I'd love a true professional to give me some tips, particularly on which brands are best. 
 Do you know of anywhere that offers such a service? 
  Anna Teane, Bushey  
 Confidence is the most important thing when applying make-up and you must experiment with new colours, techniques and brands until you find what suits you. 
 I recommend you go to The Face Place where you can have a complete make-up for &pound;16 which lasts for an hour. 
 The idea behind it is that you can't achieve a total look with one brand but must combine products from both ends of the market for a contemporary image. 
 They make up half your face in colours to suit you, advising you on technique, and you make up the other half of your face to match. 
 So you get pampered and taught all-in-one! 
 If you want further information or to make an appointment contact Joan Price's Face Place, 33 Cadogan Street, London SW3 (071 589 9062). 
 MOTH-EATEN 
 I have an extremely voracious moth in my wardrobe which is gradually devouring all my clothes! 
 I hate the smell of moth balls and refuse to use them. 
 Do you know if there are any alternatives? 
  Jane Ireland, London N7  
 Moths can be a real pest but they needn't be a permanent one. 
 Vapona make &bquo;Moth Killer' which tends to be sweeter-smelling than moth balls. 
 It costs &pound;1.35 and is available from major department stores including John Lewis of Oxford Street. 
 You hang it in the wardrobe and although you may not find the smell unpleasant, the moth certainly will! 
 BELLE OF THE BALL 
 I'm going to a ball this summer and I have to wear a formal full-length dress. 
 I don't want to buy one as not only are they very expensive but I'm unlikely to wear it again. 
 Do you know of a reputable dress hire shop in my area who will be able to kit me out? 
  Tanya Woods, St Albans  
 Just For The Night  stocks a wide range of evening dresses in sizes 8 to 20, from the simple to the very glamorous. 
 Prices range from about &pound;40 to &pound;60 depending on the dress. 
 They also keep a basic court shoe in three heel sizes: low, medium and high, which they can dye almost any colour to match your chosen gown. 
 With their selection of jewellery, handbags and jackets as well, you need look no further. 
 Contact this excellent hire shop at 80 Sandridge Road, St Albans (0727 40759). 
 They're open from 9am to 4pm Monday to Friday; late (7pm) Thursday; 10am to 4pm Saturday, and also by appointment. 
 SAVING SPACE 
 I live in a one-bedroomed flat with very little cupboard space and I'm fed up with the piles of clothes and shoes I trip over all the time. 
 Please tell me how I can arrange my valuable wardrobe space so that I'm able to get the most out of it? 
  Charles Dash, Wolverhampton  
 The best thing to do when faced with cupboard traumas is to buy lots of clever accessories that hang from every available hook. 
 You will have to be organised or you'll never find anything but it is worth it. 
 Brimglade do a garment rail for about &pound;18 (plus &pound;9 carriage if ordered direct). 
 Call 04027 52085 to order or to get details of local stockists. 
 To keep your shoes off the floor why not get a hanging shoe rack with multi-purpose compartments? 
 It hangs over any thickness of wardrobe rail and fastens with Velcro. 
 Machine washable, this little life-saver can be found at Argos for &pound;6.90. 
 CAREER PROSPECTS 
 I'm studying for my A levels at sixth form college and am very interested in pursuing a career in fashion writing and styling. 
 However, I've no idea what qualifications I need or if there are any courses available. 
 Can you help? 
  Tara Rubins, London NW3  
 A good specific training is an asset to anyone interested in pursuing a career in the highly competitive fashion industry. 
 To be a fashion writer, you must have good writing skills &mdash; it's not enough simply to like clothes. 
 When it comes to styling, artistic flair and imagination are essential. 
 The London College of Fashion offers a variety of courses including a two year BTEC/Higher Diploma in Design for Fashion Writing and a two year diploma for Fashion Styling. 
 You need 5 GCSE O Levels (including Art) as well as an A Level pass in English (or a relevant BTEC diploma). 
 For further information write to Maria Holmes, Fashion Career Promoter, London College of Fashion, 20 John Princes Street, London W1M 0BJ (071 629 9401). 
 Central St Martin's College has a wide variety of BA degree courses. 
 Contact Wendy Dagworthy, Course Director, Central St Martin's College of Art and Design, Southampton Row, WC1B 4AP (071 753 9090). 
 LIFELESS LOCKS 
 I recently had a perm which I'm very pleased with. 
 However, my hair is beginning to look rather dull and I'd like to get it back to peak condition as soon as possible. 
 Do you have any helpful suggestions? 
  Anna Murphy, Ely  
 Perming is one of the main causes of lifeless hair but it is avoidable if you use the correct products to protect and moisturise it. 
 Using a shampoo specially formulated for permed hair is one way to combat the damage caused. 
 Daniel Field does a range of organic and mineral hair products, available from major Boots stores nationwide. 
 You should try the Remoisturising Shampoo (&pound;2.40 for 250ml), and condition with the Plant Remoisturising Treatment. 
 Both products have been produced specifically for permed, damaged hair and they replenish moisture lost in the perming process. 
 If you have a fashion or beauty problem, write to Jeff Banks, Clothes Show Magazine , 20&ndash;26 Brunswick Place, London N1 6DJ. 
 Sorry, no personal correspondence 
 Forget Kylie &mdash; here come the crisp bags Yorkshire students are making music for the ears of world famous composers with everything from sneezes to zips. 
 Martin Wainwright reports. 
 HUNCHED over something very similar to the control deck on Starship Enterprise, Sam Coombes slid up the tape-monitor levers and pressed a series of buttons marked &bquo;Remix&equo;. 
 The resulting squawk &mdash; actually a recording of Sam and five friends rubbing their fingers on a damp window pane &mdash; will soon be played to a dauntingly expert audience through 30 loudspeakers in Huddersfield town hall. 
 Amazingly famous music supremos Oliver Messiaen, Pierre Boulez and John Cage are coming to the Yorkshire town for the annual Contemporary Music Festival, Britain's highlight in the world of electro-acoustic chords and allied disharmony. 
 The six teenage composer-musicians from Fartown comprehensive, off the Bradford Road, have been chosen to join them, in a project designed to widen interest in a specialised and frequently off-putting field. 
 &bquo;Serious contemporary music is not a popular art form and electro-acoustic music is particularly unpopular, even among contemporary musicians,&equo; admits Robert Worby, one of two composers helping the Fartown team with their own three-minute piece. 
 The three celebrated composers visiting Huddersfield are all in their seventies. 
 They and their colleagues are particularly eager to generate interest among the young. 
 The humorous, self-mocking twist to much contemporary music is helping, according to Sam &amp; Co. 
 Hard, they say, to be too overawed by a character like Cage, whose music includes Roaratorios and a piece composed solely for the white keys on the piano. 
 Not to mention his composition Four Minutes 33 Seconds, technically described as a period of &bquo;apparent silence&equo;. 
 Performed in Fartown's Portakabin classroom, where 14-year-old Sam and his team are working, this would consist largely of the rhythmic hum of Kirklees education department's antiquated wall-heaters and 13-year-old Nicola Bradford's occasional sneeze. 
 &bquo;Perhaps those are sounds you could use in your own composition,&equo; speculates the school's head of music, Paul Chamberlain, whose quest for strange noises has led to the possibility of him poaching the National Curriculum's science of sound course from Fartown's physics department. 
 The piece prepared by the six young musicians includes a crisp packet being scrunched, playing cards flicked with the skill of a sharper and the zip on 14-year-old Sunjeev Singh's bag buzzing backwards and forwards. 
 But underlying the oddities is a competent musical framework; all six have reached either grade five or six in the conventional music syllabus. 
 They have benefited, too, from Kirklees council's encouragement of music in an area particularly strong in the brass and choral tradition. 
 Fartown's mixture of council estates and tree-lined avenues overlooking ICI's smoky chemical plant provides regular recruits for the Huddersfield choral society and local brass bands. 
 The group's clarinettist Tracy Redfern and flautist Philippa Bradford, Nicola's older sister, have just got back from a visit to Germany with Kirklees junior wind band. 
 Sunjeev's community &mdash; there are plenty of Asian-origin Yorkshire families in Fartown &mdash; is meanwhile beginning to add its own distinctive musical contribution. 
 Sam, who's a year above the others, has started on his GCSE in Performing Arts, a portmanteau course which covers video, dance and drama as well as music. 
 His five friends are likely to follow a similar route in 1990. 
 But the chances of a future Messiaen, Boulez or Cage being nurtured at the comprehensive seem slim. 
 A cautious &bquo;different&equo; was the most exciting adjective found by Nicola, Philippa, Sunjeev, Tracy and violinist Joanne Faley to describe contemporary music. 
 They have enjoyed the project, including working with practising composers like Robert Worby and Stephen Montague (who remembers meeting Stravinsky during his own schooldays). 
 But only Sam, asking hopefully if he can control the town hall's lights as well as the synthesiser, looks likely to follow Messiaen and Boulez rather than Kylie and Bros. 
 Huddersfield Contemporary Music Festival runs from November 16 &mdash; 26. 
 Details from the festival office, Huddersfield Polytechnic. 
 (0484 422288). 
 What's going on/Stephanie Nettell. 
 Should rainforests be used for hamburgers? &mdash; trees destroyed for cattle ranches &mdash; is the question asked by Takeaway, which combines music, dance and action in a show devised by nine- to 20-year-olds of Cambridgeshire. 
 Cambridge Arts Theatre until November 18 (tel: 0223 352000). 
 THE Cherub Company gives a black and hellish view of Webster's Jacobean classic, The Duchess Of Malfi, using the shadowy vaults of St George's Theatre, 49 Tufnell Park Road, London N7 (tel: 01-607 1128), until November 18. 
 POPULATION Concern, which runs 30 projects in 23 countries, asks sixth-formers to join a sponsored water-only fast for up to 24 hours between November 20 and December 3. 
 Last year St Wilfrid's School, Blackburn, raised &pound;2,500, and runners-up Antrim Grammar, Northern Ireland, raised &pound;1,828; they will receive their awards at Population Concern's Conferences in Harrogate and Warwick (November 13, 14). 
 Details from Population Concern, 231 Tottenham Court Road, London W1P 9AE (tel: 01-631 1546). 
 AN annual Stage Pass, &pound;12, allows under-30s to buy two tickets, discounted up to 50 per cent, for a range of concerts, operas, musicals, ballet, theatres and jazz, in Bristol, London and Newcastle upon Tyne. 
 Details tel: 01 379 6722, or write to Youth &amp; Music, 28 Charing Cross Road, London WC2 ODB with date of birth and day and evening telephone numbers. 
 Jackboots beneath the serge Television. 
 By Hugh Hebert 
 THERE was one point when the hair on the back of my head began to lift. 
 Not at Paul Hill's remembrance of beatings past, when he could hear the sound of steel-tipped boots running to take part in the fun, and once heard a principal medical officer, no less, telling colleagues: &bquo;Don't walk his face, don't walk his face.&equo; 
 Not even the time he was dunked head first in a tub of dubious liquid, and brought up gasping for breath: &bquo;Make him sing God Save the Queen!&equo; they shouted. 
 Brutality, as Hill describes and felt it, was a bitter part of his prison life; you just learnt to get down on the floor as fast as you could and cover up as best you could. 
 But it was Gerry Conlon's account of being interrogated after the Guildford bombings that made the scalp crawl. 
 We know your mother works at the Royal Victoria Hospital, they told him, we know where your sister works, and there are sectarian killings down there. 
 &bquo;They told me they could arrange an &bquo;accident&equo;. 
 And I believed they were capable of murdering my mother, I honestly believe they would have murdered my mother &mdash; that's why I signed the statement.&equo; 
 The account he gave just after his release was that the threat had been that a British soldier might &bquo;accidentally&equo; shoot one of the women. 
 A few months ago even, this would have seemed improbable. 
 You might have assumed this was the police bluffing and bullying. 
 Yet given what we have learned about links between the security services and the Loyalist paramilitaries in Northern Ireland, and the deep suspicion about surrogate murders, you can't shrug off the shiver Conlon's words bring. 
 There were daunting moments in last night's First Tuesday (Yorkshire), but few of them matched that hint of a jackboot under the blue serge. 
 It's right that the Guildford Four have told their stories now to Grant McKee and Ros Franey and First Tuesday, the programme and the producers who dug away, and did much to keep the case alive. 
 And they told it without on-screen questioning, though the programme is skilfully structured to give it a coherence it might have lacked. 
 Carole Richardson's is the most haunting face. 
 You have to hope that its blankness will slowly dissolve and let life in. 
 Just once a couple of tears rolled down. 
 It was when she described seeing film of the results of the bombing on television, and thinking: &bquo;They think I did that!&equo; 
 Armstrong seems the least permanently damaged on the surface. 
 He pays tribute to his treatment at Gartree prison, he apologises to the bomb victims' families that they have had to keep reminding them of their loss: &bquo;But we had to fight for our freedom.&equo; 
 Hill expresses the way time has cheated them: his daughter was born while he was remanded in custody, and is now 14: &bquo;She would change dramatically and I didn't feel a change in myself mentally. 
 I'm still 20 in my head. 
 Nothing's happened to me. 
 I haven't lived.&equo; 
 But again it was Conlon, the slightly wild-eyed Irish poet of the quartet, articulate, flamboyant &mdash; remember that extraordinary exit through the front door of the Old Bailey &mdash; who cut deep into the collective conscience. 
 He described being taken over the years to see his sick, and finally dying and almost certainly innocent father in another prison. 
 He was convicted with the Maguires in the parallel case of a &bquo;bomb factory&equo;. 
 And he tells how none of the assembled guards and officials could look his father in the eye as he protested his innocence. 
 Only the nurses could do that. 
 And at the end, Conlon drew the one hopeful conclusion: &bquo;If this stops capital punishment ever coming back, the time I've spent in prison will be well worth it. 
 If this stops another innocent person going to prison, it'll be well worth it&hellip; 
 &bquo;I've had numerous prison governors say to me, Yes, Conlon, we know you're innocent, but there's nothing we can do about it. 
 We get a custody order, and that's it. 
 What sort of system of justice is that?&equo; 
 IT wasn't the only programme last night to shine light into dirty corners. 
 Inside The Brotherhood (Granada), produced by Claudia Milne and Martin Short, dug into the most notorious area of Masonic influence, local government. 
 In Southend, where 3,000 of the 50,000 adult males are reckoned to be Masons, it went into the case of what you might call Preferential Allocation of Council Property, and the battle of one councillor, Christopher Hudson, to break the grip of the men on the Square: &bquo;We can't have a secret society operating within the framework of a democracy,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It's a paradox, it's a nonsense.&equo; 
 Though over the years, from Southend to Tyneside and the Government's own Property Services Agency, there's all too much evidence that this is exactly what we do have. 
 OPERA: Edward Greenfield finds the Medea at Covent Garden relentlessly loud Cool, but not Callas enough. 
 IT was Maria Callas who, a generation ago, singlehandedly dragged Cherubini's Medea back into the 20th century repertory. 
 This operatic adaptation of classical tragedy, Euripides and Seneca distantly viewed via Corneille, proved then to be a formidable vehicle for a great singing actress. 
 With her unique vehemence Callas built the crazed obsessions of the heroine into a memorable final scene, when in agony Medea murders her own children to spite Jason, the husband who has rejected her. 
 With Callas the piece had one's hair on end. 
 She recorded it at La Scala, and in 1959 gave five performances at Covent Garden in that same production borrowed from Milan. 
 Now with a soprano who has already successfully taken the role in a revival at the Buxton Festival, Rosalind Plowright, Covent Garden is staging its own new production directed by Mike Ashman with sets by Bernard Culshaw. 
 Sadly the whole evening tends to confirm just how single-handed Callas' achievement was back in the Fifties. 
 One distinct side of Plowright's voice has a Callas-like bite, a hard edge combined with vibrancy. 
 In her portrait of Medea &mdash; or Medee as she becomes in this staging of the original French version &mdash; this is what she uses consistently. 
 She is unrelentingly loud, making one long to hear the gentler, sweeter Plowright voice, if only to enhance (by contrast) the impact of the outbursts. 
 Her performance even brings a touch or two of Callas' distinctive &bquo;bottled&equo; tone, and under pressure on top the voice tends to spread in a rather similar way. 
 Yet there is no question of one's hair rising. 
 Plowright as an actress is no fire-eater, however hard she tries. 
 One basic trouble with Medea is the mediocre quality of invention in so much of Cherubini's score. 
 It is true that structurally his numbers, with solos and ensembles intermingled, have a freedom and originality that point forward directly to Berlioz and Wagner. 
 Yet when so much of the writing seems to have been done on automatic pilot, with dozens of sequential passages of unashamed banality &mdash; even at the opening of the overture &mdash; this is a score that demands some injection whether of fire or persuasiveness in the performers, to make one forget the musical flaws. 
 It does not help that Cherubini allows too little variety of pace, and that his lyrical gift is limited too. 
 Even when as in the Act 2 aria for Medea's servant, Neris, he attempts a flowing canzonetta and decks it with a distinctive bassoon obligato, he lets the number go on far too long, or so it seems when as here the bassoon roars out in determined competition with the mezzo, Claire Powell. 
 Medea's aria with the children before the murder in Act 3 also promises a higher musical flight, only to fall into squareness. 
 Mike Ashman has opted to set the piece firmly at the period of composition. 
 This 19th of Cherubini's 34 operas was conceived and written at the height of the Revolutionary Reign of Terror. 
 Tricolors abound and Jason is made up to look like Napoleon. 
 But the symbolic period point is overstressed to the verge of comedy, when in the final scene of destruction the figures of Marianne with her red cap of Liberty, the skeleton Death with his scythe and the Angel of Justice are hastily let down in tableau from the flies. 
 Otherwise the sets are based on a bare raked platform overlooked by a gallery, and with an enormous window let into the back wall for the offstage wedding scene of Act 2. 
 Perversely set designer Bernard Culshaw scatters the stage in Act 2 with great polystyrene rocks, and then removes them for Act 3, when the stage directions do specify just such rocks. 
 Did he get his acts mixed up, I wonder? 
 The Russian heroic tenor, Alexei Steblianko, from the Kirov in Leningrad is the least comfortable with a French accent, but then on the first night he was battling with a throat infection. 
 Robert Lloyd as King Creon is handsome of voice and person &mdash; the most assured principal &mdash; and the bright-toned American soprano, Renee Fleming, makes a promising Covent Garden debut in the disappointingly brief role of Glauce (Dirce in the French), Jason's new bride. 
 Mark Ermler draws generally crisp and lively playing from the Covent Garden Orchestra, but it is uphill work with such a score, hardly helped by what is happening on stage. 
 For third North only OPERA: Edward Greenfield on a loud Medea at Covent Garden Angry, not Callas. 
 IT WAS Maria Callas who, a generation ago, singlehandedly dragged Cherubini's Medea back into the 20th century repertory. 
 This operatic adaptation of classical tragedy, Euripides and Seneca distantly viewed via Corneille, proved then to be a formidable vehicle for a great singing actress. 
 With her unique vehemence Callas built the crazed obsessions of the heroine into a memorable final scene, when in agony Medea murders her own children to spite Jason, the husband who has rejected her. 
 With Callas the piece had one's hair on end. 
 She recorded it at La Scala, and in 1959 gave five performances at Covent Garden in that same production borrowed from Milan. 
 Now with a soprano who has already successfully taken the role in a revival at the Buxton Festival, Rosalind Plowright, Covent Garden is staging its own new production directed by Mike Ashman with sets by Bernard Culshaw. 
 Sadly the whole evening tends to confirm just how single-handed Callas' achievement was back in the Fifties. 
 One distinct side of Plowright's voice has a Callas-like bite, a hard edge combined with vibrancy. 
 In her portrait of Medea &mdash; or Medee as she becomes in this staging of the original French version &mdash; this is what she uses consistently. 
 She is unrelentingly loud, making one long to hear the gentler, sweeter Plowright voice, if only to enhance (by contrast) the impact of the outbursts. 
 Her performance even brings a touch or two of Callas' distinctive &bquo;bottled&equo; tone, and under pressure on top the voice tends to spread in a rather similar way. 
 Yet there is no question of one's hair rising. 
 Plowright as an actress is no fire-eater, however hard she tries. 
 One basic trouble with Medea is the mediocre quality of invention in so much of Cherubini's score. 
 It is true that structurally his numbers, with solos and ensembles intermingled, have a freedom and originality that point forward directly to Berlioz and Wagner. 
 Yet when so much of the writing seems to have been done on automatic pilot, with dozens of sequential passages of unashamed banality &mdash; even at the opening of the overture &mdash; this is a score that demands some injection whether of fire or persuasiveness in the performers, to make one forget the musi cal flaws. 
 It does not help that Cherubini allows too little variety of pace, and that his lyrical gift is limited too. 
 Even when as in the Act 2 aria for Medea's servant, Neris, he attempts a flowing canzonetta and decks it with a distinctive bassoon obligato, he lets the number go on far too long, or so it seems when as here the bassoon roars out in determined competition with the mezzo, Claire Powell. 
 Medea's aria with the children before the murder in Act 3 also promises a higher musical flight, only to fall into squareness. 
 Mike Ashman has opted to set the piece firmly at the period of composition. 
 This 19th of Cherubini's 34 operas was conceived and written at the height of the Revolutionary Reign of Terror. 
 Tricolors abound and Jason is made up to look like Napoleon. 
 But the symbolic period point is overstressed to the verge of comedy, when in the final scene of destruction the figures of Marianne with her red cap of Liberty, the skeleton Death with his scythe and the Angel of Justice are hastily let down in tableau from the flies. 
 Otherwise the sets are based on a bare raked platform overlooked by a gallery, and with an enormous window let into the back wall for the offstage wedding scene of Act 2. 
 Perversely set designer Bernard Culshaw scatters the stage in Act 2 with great polystyrene rocks, and then removes them for Act 3, when the stage directions do specify just such rocks. 
 Did he get his acts mixed up, I wonder? 
 The Russian heroic tenor, Alexei Steblianko, from the Kirov in Leningrad is the least comfortable with a French accent, but then on the first night he was battling with a throat infection. 
 Robert Lloyd as King Creon is handsome of voice and person &mdash; the most assured principal &mdash; and the bright-toned American soprano, Renee Fleming, makes a promising Covent Garden debut in the disappointingly brief role of Glauce (Dirce in the French), Jason's new bride. 
 Mark Ermler draws generally crisp and lively playing from the Covent Garden Orchestra, but it is uphill work with such a score, hardly helped by what is happening on stage. 
 Rosalind Plowright as Medea 
 For third South arts QEH.. 
 By Meirion Bowen Ligeti Festival. 
 WHETHER writing new pieces or extending old ones, Ligeti comes across &mdash; almost like Birtwistle &mdash; as a convergent musical thinker. 
 If all his mature compositions were laid end to end and glued together, they might well form one big work. 
 This unitary vision was particularly well-exemplified in the final, four-hour concert in the Ligeti Festival at the QEH, which featured the premieres of two further piano etudes and of the five-movement version of his Piano Concerto. 
 The first six etudes, completed in 1985, were stimulated by Ligeti's studies of rhythm in sub-Saharan music and the multi-layered polyrhythms in the pianola works of Conlon Nancarrow: and the two new ones drew partly on ideas from gamelan music. 
 But all this, along with his fascination with rhythmic displacements in Chopin and others, disappeared within a distinctively Ligetian interplay of line and colour. 
 It required from the pianist an unbelievable independence of hands and fingers, so that unevenly spread accents and criss-crossing figurations appeared to drop into place without obvious effort. 
 Volker Banfield here achieved all that was demanded of him technically. 
 But his playing was studiously uncommunicative and prosaic, unresponsive to the poetry behind the notes &mdash; e.g. in the cool Bartokian chords that closed the eighth study. 
 In the Piano Concerto it was, of course, an asset to have a soloist who could keep his head amid all the intricate polymetrical pulsations of the first and third movements. 
 Banfield extracted little drama, however, from the exchanges between the piano and different orchestral groups in the fourth and fifth movements. 
 In his hands, the work became a latterday baroque concerto grosso, with the pianist as one soloist among many, whereas the range of invention and harmonic emphasis in the work implied a far more provocative interaction of roles. 
 While the concerto had sounded complete and satisfying in its original three-movement format, the additional movements opened up new horizons and changed its structural proportions without distorting any of its existing perspectives. 
 If anything, its additional colours brought extra glitter to the music, and this quality was certainly seized upon by the London Sinfonietta under Elgar Howarth, who eagerly compensated for the pianist's lack of a trenchant or subtle delivery. 
 Reserve and reticence of expression, on the part of solo cellist Christopher van Kampen and the Sinfonietta, were more aptly applied in the context of Ligeti's Cello Concerto (1965), a sparsely-written, lapidaric work that discloses the absolute minimum within its unbroken span of 26 kaleidoscopic episodes. 
 This work made an effective bridge to the equally spare and fastidious Four Capriccios Opus 9 by Gyorgy Kurtag (whose music Ligeti has generously welcomed into his Festival, just as he insisted on having the composer share the stage at the end). 
 Kurtag is Ligeti's opposite &mdash; a divergent musical thinker whose every new work might be by another composer, were it not for the extreme compression that is constant to his style. 
 In the settings of four aphoristic poems by Istvan Balint for soprano and 14 players &mdash; which Kurtag began in 1972 and recently revised &mdash; the outside influences declared themselves quite readily, whether they were from East European folk music or Webern: and in this performance, the soprano Adrienne Csengery and Sinfonietta excelled themselves with sudden flashes of colour and bursts of intense virtuosity. 
 Man in the Moon. 
 By Paul Fisher Ironmistress. 
 IRONMISTRESS uses heavy metallic imagery to tell of Martha Darby, a character based on a real 19th century widow who inherited an iron works. 
 &bquo;His hand was welded to my back&equo;, she tells her daughter of the courtship with the paterfamilias now buried in an iron coffin. 
 During a comical lesson on how to catch her man, Little Cog is told she must weep not buckets but spoons. 
 The language also taps a Laurentian vein where mud, blood, heat and simmering violence are mashed together. 
 Read into it what you will: industrial fable, feminist tract, family psychodrama or a sly portrait of the modern Iron Lady. 
 Martha clangs about her business, her hair dragged into a tight bun, a bustle behind her and keys at her waist. 
 &bquo;The first time I held those keys, I put them in my mouth and felt my bones had turned to gold,&equo; she announces. 
 Her assimilation of a male world develops into a psychotic taste for swallowing pens and spoons. 
 It gives her tummy ache and she administers something similar when she flattens her daughter's body, locking it in the tightest of corsets. 
 After that scene there is little else that needs to be said about the strictures on Victorian women. 
 The daughter opens and closes the play on a swing, her hair free but a soundtrack of synthesised chords and foundry clatter emphasising this is no Fragonard. 
 Until a routinely hopeless marriage, Louise Waddington delivers Little Cog's speeches straight at the audience, up into the Gods. 
 Her pale eyes are everywhere. 
 Everything pours inwards as Gillian Brown's dead-eyed Martha discovers obsessive control can lead to personal dissolution. 
 While she celebrates market forces and a &bquo;world where you and me and God are a giant machine with separate bits&equo; she is forging fears of her own futility and death. 
 The director, Thomas de Mallet Burgess, delicately underlines the personal in April de Angelis's allusive script though he can't assert himself when the play slithers into magical realism. 
 At the end highway robberies, riots and an unspecified sense of comeuppance is what we are left with. 
 A heavy metal vision of post-Thatcherism, maybe. 
 Man in the Moon, Chelsea, 01 351 2876, to November 25. 
 Culture Shocked Feminist fans may be outraged by her apparent change of image, but it's no sell-out, as Michelle Shocked tells Lucy O'Brien. 
 THE recent release of Michelle Shocked's single On The Greener Side has sent seismic reverberations throughout the music industry. 
 She appears in the video wearing a lime green mini-dress, surrounded by impassive Schwarzenegger beefcake types in dinner suits, her face fully made up, her mouth gleaming with bright red lipstick. 
 From the gal who swore she'd rather be dragged across a plain by wild horses than wear lipgloss, this comes as something of a surprise. 
 It's not so much a reconstruction of image as proof that Shocked's confidence is growing. 
 Instead of being terrified of commercial mainstream pop, she's now manipulating its stereotypes. 
 The video is actually a parody of Robert Palmer, the slithering lounge lizard of pop who four years ago thought it cool to cast his videos with countless women dressed exactly the same, acting like mass-produced mannequins. 
 &bquo;Intuitively I know that's as misogynist as it gets,&equo; says Shocked. 
 She also knows that the media tendency to lump together women singer-songwriters in a &bquo;gee whiz, gosh, women are now making it&equo; syndrome is patronising, if not pernicious. 
 &bquo;They may as well call it &bquo;Women who don't wear make-up&equo;,&equo; she chuckles. 
 &bquo;It's less threatening for men to lump women together and deal with them as one, rather than pointing out the differences.&equo; 
 Shocked has taken a brave step. 
 Although she turns up for the interview her customary peaked-capped urchin self, she is worried that her feminist interpreters will consider her video a sell-out. 
 &bquo;If I soften the edges &mdash; whether I need to personally or whether it's being imposed on me &mdash; I feel I'll be letting down the revolution. 
 Whoever dictated this? 
 This is pure projection on my part! 
 At one time I was a nihilistic punk with a mohican and a ring in my nose. 
 I think in the course of time I'll find a middle If I soften the edges &mdash; whether I need to personally or whether it's being imposed on me &mdash; I feel I'll be letting down the feminist revolution. 
 ground, but I also carry that sense of responsibility. 
 I'm in a position to defeat stereotypes, to work for the greater good for women who don't enjoy the privileges that I have.&equo; 
 Far from letting down the side, Shocked is projecting a freshly combative image. 
 Her humour is a weapon that has pole-vaulted her out of the solid folk-roots category, an alternative scene that would have kept her firmly away from the mainstream. 
 Musically, too, she's been striding into new territory, celebrating all kinds of Forties swing on her latest LP, Captain Swing. 
 With its loud, luscious harmonies, raunchy guitar and full brass band, the record is commercial country blues peppered with lyrical bons mots and that female troubadour sensibility. 
 &bquo;The music warrants being filled out,&equo; Shocked says. 
 &bquo;It's about tension and relaxation, the interaction between musicians.&equo; 
 Speaking in a slightly formal Texan lilt, Shocked exudes a quiet charisma and wry stubbornness. 
 When under pressure, though, she is said to throw tantrums, to distance herself from those around her and just take off. 
 Inside Michelle Shocked there is a fierce loner. 
 Now 26, she spent many years after college hitchhiking around the world, drifting through the punk scene in San Francisco to demonstrations in Dallas, squats in Amsterdam and the women's peace camp in Cosmo, Italy, before a British producer recognised her itinerant musical talent and signed her up with the bestselling Texas Campfire Tapes LP. 
 Is Shocked still a wanderer? 
 &bquo;I've put it on the back burner, but have never given up the long-term goal of going round the world by sailboat. 
 When you hear about these floating islands of garbage in the Pacific, it makes it a little less appealing, but it feels like the sea is the only wilderness left. 
 Once you lose sight of land, you may as well be in space.&equo; 
 Shocked is making plans to sail with her father, who long ago began building a boat, until marriage and fatherhood distracted him from finishing it. 
 She is pleased at the rewarding relationship she has with him, though it's something she has had to fight to keep. 
 A young child when her parents divorced, she regained contact with him at 16, after she left her mother. 
 She hasn't spoken to her since. 
 &bquo;She threw me out. 
 It was very hard for me. 
 I was brought up in Gilmer, Texas, as a fundamentalist Mormon. 
 It was a closed community with the habit of passing down ultimatums &mdash; for example, you were created to be a wife and mother. 
 I'm never getting married, so where does that leave me? 
 There was no place for me. 
 My mother believed that if she was gonna get to heaven, I had to marry. 
 What kinda religion is it that would encourage the parent to shelter the child from any outside influences and punish it by putting it out in a world you never had any way of learning about?&equo; 
 Shocked's reponse was to learn, and fast. 
 She put herself through many risky experiences on the road, along with some vigorous political activity. 
 Her lifelong mission has been to counter fundamentalist hypocrisy in any form, but she admits she'd now like to resolve the conflict with her mother. 
 &bquo;She must be going through a lotta pain too.&equo; 
 Shocked looks glumly at the table, anxious to put her past behind her, yet concerned to put things right. 
 &bquo;It's as if she's dead,&equo; she says quietly. 
 Then she perks up. 
 &bquo;I find it interesting that there's this whole small town that claims me, that I want nothing to do with. 
 It's my revenge fantasy &mdash; &bquo;One day they'll be sorry!&equo;' 
 Shocked is coming to terms with her loss her own way. 
 After protecting herself during her travelling years by dressing like a boy, she is temporarily hanging up her hat and exploring her sensual, feminine side. 
 Hence the saucy video and red lipstick. 
 But Shocked the political animal is still very much intact. 
 Currently based in Los Angeles, she's active in the US urban homelessness campaign, organising the protesters so they can &bquo;squat on the White House lawn&equo;. 
 &bquo;This fall the homeless will be mobilising into one big movement with thousands marching on Washington. 
 I feel I'm in a position to push a more radical programme on them, to stay there and work with what I can.&equo; 
 Michelle Shocked begins a national tour on November 16. 
 Her album, Captain Swing, is out now on London Records. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE wom 
 The US sets its compass on two trading oceans Notebook. 
 By Edited by Alex Brummer 
 CANBERRA may seem an awful long way from exchanges on the floor of the House of Commons over the European Monetary System. 
 But were it not for the perceived economic might of a more unified Economic Community, the dozen or so nations of the Pacific Rim, who have been meeting in Australia, might not have bothered. 
 The first, albeit tenative, steps towards forming a new Pacific-based economic union display an astute awareness of the way events are moving within Europe: movements with which Number 10 has yet to come to grips. 
 Not so long ago it seemed as if the world was to divide into three main trading blocks: the EC based around the West German economy; a Northern American block based around the US-Canadian free trade area, and a Pacific unit incorporating the Asian tigers with Japan and the yen at the centre. 
 But the Metternich-like skills of the US Secretary of State, Mr James Baker, are ensuring that America maintains a strong stake in each forum. 
 It firstly boldly asked for a seat at the top table at the European Community: a suggestion rudely rebuffed. 
 The US has talked of a genuine North American free trade zone incorporating the US, Canada and Mexico which would have the best of all worlds with high-technology skills and a cheap labour force south of the Rio Grande. 
 Now it is making a third bid for influence. 
 It has turned up in Canberra with Japan to develop Asia Pacific Economic Co-operation (APEC) and a new 12-nation organisation which will mimic the role of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development in Europe. 
 Preliminary steps taken to conduct studies on trade, technology and investment flows in the region may seem insignificant. 
 But Mr Baker plainly views it as otherwise. 
 He noted that the Canberra meeting &bquo;is the start of something which could grow into a very significant development not only for the region but for the global economy.&equo; 
 If the more economically puny ASEAN countries (Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore, Brunei, Thailand and the Philippines) were to bury their reservations, then the high growth from other partners, including such tigers as Thailand and South Korea alongside the more mature economies of Japan and Australia, could mean a dynamic coalition. 
 It would then be up to the US and Canada to decide whether they want to face towards the Atlantic or Pacific &mdash; or be caught between two great trading oceans. 
 Heading for default. 
 THE QUESTION of just who would even want to be a partner with the US was underlined last night as the American Administration headed for default for the first time in its history. 
 Congress was frantically trying to complete a bill raising the federal debt ceiling in time for President Bush to sign today. 
 Leaders on Capitol Hill virtually put all other business on hold as it sought to hammer out a debt ceiling increase. 
 The Treasury Secretary Nicholas Brady, a level headed figure, warned that the imbroglio may lead to higher interest costs for the taxpayer. 
 What should have been a routine exercise in extending the Government's borrowing power to &dollar;3.1 thousand billion became bogged down in wrangling over legislative initiatives lawmakers wanted to attach to the bill. 
 As a result of the stalemate, the Treasury has been forced to postpone &dollar;40billion in debt auctions this week. 
 Lack of congressional action also forced the Treasury to suspend new sales of US savings bonds and of special securities for state and local governments. 
 This market sensitive dispute has taken place as President Bush and Congress continued to spar on a primary cause for government borrowing &mdash; the budget deficit. 
 At a press conference to mark his election victory a year ago, Mr Bush threatened to veto the budget unless it contained real cuts. 
 Otherwise Congress would have to face the consequences of automatic across-the-board cuts under the Gramm-Rudman-Hollings budget deficit reduction law. 
 America may have changed Presidents a year ago, but the fiscal thicket remains as inpenetrable as ever. 
 Political expediency. 
 NO LONGER can the Government disguise the crisis surrounding electricity privatisation. 
 Ministers have already had to pull Britain's fleet of Magnox reactors out of the float and delay the sell-off date by up to six months. 
 But it has now become clear that further drastic amendments are needed to flotation plans. 
 After months of turning deaf ears to warnings by the City and industry, the Department of Energy has at last conceded that nuclear plant cannot be included in the share float without state support. 
 This leaves the Energy Secretary, Mr John Wakeham, with two options: he can either agree to underwrite any cost escalations in nuclear handling costs after privatisation, or he can swallow his pride, and pull all nuclear plant out of the impending sale. 
 Whatever the outcome, the Government's willingness to continue pushing through the float during this Parliament shows how ministers are prepared to put political expediency before the interests of the industry. 
 For the nuclear element in electricity privatisation is the coping stone on which the flotation plans are based. 
 National Power was given 70 per cent of the CEGB's generating capacity in order to give it an economic mix of power. 
 The other 30 per cent is to be operated by PowerGen, the other CEGB successor company. 
 Take away or subsidise all nuclear power stations and you lose the commercial logic of the privatisation plans. 
 Electricity privatisation needs to go back to the drawing board. 
 At the very least, the CEGB should be divided into a wider range of generating companies to stimulate competition. 
 Is it worth sacrificing the long-term future of Britain's biggest state-owned industry to make political capital in the run-up to the next election? 
 Hanson puts crucial &pound;21m Morgan stake up for auction. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 APIVOTAL &pound;21million stake in besieged merchant bank Morgan Grenfell was yesterday put up for auction by Hanson as talks which could have heralded a Morgan-BZW merger broke down. 
 Hanson revealed that it had sold 100,000 shares in Morgan &mdash; but told investors it still owns 4.4million shares in the merchant bank. 
 The announcement was unnecessary under City disclosure rules and bank-watchers immediately interpreted the Hanson statement as an invitation to anyone with designs on Morgan to bid for the stake. 
 Morgan Grenfell, once the high-flyer of British merchant banking, now finds itself with few British allies. 
 The Hanson stake is up for sale. 
 Banque Indosuez of France already owns more than 10 per cent and wants to buy a further 9.8 per cent. 
 And with the ending of merger talks with BZW, it is hard to see how Morgan Grenfell can preserve its independence without falling into the hands of an overseas concern. 
 A possible bid could come from West Germany or Japan. 
 BZW's decision to break off talks came after a top-level meeting between executives at the investment bank and Morgan yesterday. 
 Discussions had been taking place since the middle of last week. 
 Morgan has been looking for a white knight for the last two weeks since insurance broker Willis Faber announced it was selling its 20 per cent stake in the merchant bank to Banque Indosuez, part of Compagnie Financiere de Suez. 
 Willis Faber is holding back almost half the shares until it receives shareholder backing for the sale at a meeting on November 29. 
 If someone wants to make a move on Morgan, the would-be predator will have to move before the Willis Faber meeting. 
 Shares in Morgan edged up 1p to 469p last night. 
 Tie Rack looks rather out of fashion as sales slow down Outlook. 
 By Roger Cowe 
 THE good news is that Tie Rack is in better shape than Sock Shop. 
 The bad news is revealed partly by the results for the first half year and partly by the company's prediction that its borrowings will only be down to half shareholders' funds even at the end-of-year low point after the Christmas rush. 
 The hole-in-the-wall tie and scarf retailer is going through a sticky patch in its drive to adorn the world's necks. 
 That is due partly to the sticky summer which saw Englishmen dare to walk open-necked in daylight. 
 Also partly to the time-honoured practice of coming unstuck in the United States. 
 And partly to the general malaise which afflicts the entire retail sector (except for Marks and Spencer, of course). 
 Tie Rack is the ultimate boom stock of the 1980s. 
 An entrepreneurial idea which took off. 
 A company launched on the stock market almost exactly at the top of the market in the summer of 1987 &mdash; and which has gone steadily down ever since, as the graph illustrates. 
 And one which found that its ambitious expansion plans were rather more difficult in practice than on paper. 
 Details are sparse, with the company not even revealing interest costs (which must be enormous, especially in this slow first half year). 
 But the picture is one of sluggish sales and high overheads. 
 The result is a warning from chairman Roy Bishko that full year results will be &bquo;significantly lower&equo;. 
 There are now 242 shops, 31 more than at the start of the year. 
 That increase accounts for the large sales increase, exaggerated by the initial stocks sold to franchises. 
 Comparable sales in shops which were open last year were in fact down. 
 In the UK, the company says that was because of the hot weather, and the train dispute which clearly affected traffic past their many shops in railway stations. 
 Tie Rack estimates that those factors cost it sales of between &pound;400,000 and &pound;500,000. 
 But things have now improved and sales in comparable shops are currently ahead of last year, if only by a neck. 
 The US, where Tie Rack now has 41 shops, has also been responsible for the first half loss. 
 About 30 of the shops are now profitable, according to Mr Bishko, but not profitable enough to cover overheads &mdash; which are rather higher than he had anticipated. 
 Mr Bishko says sales volumes need to rise by a fifth or a quarter for the US operation to break even, and more stores will be needed before it makes a satisfactory profit. 
 He is optimistic, naturally, on the basis of sales growth in the earlier stores, but there will be only one new store in the US this year. 
 Indeed the pace of expansion has slowed to a crawl everywhere, even though much of that expansion in the past has been financed by franchising. 
 The vast majority of the UK shops are franchised, as are the eight in Scandinavia and the seven in Eire. 
 Four in Holland and 13 in France have been developed with local partners, leaving 14 Australian and 23 Canadian shops owned by the group as well as the 41 in the US. 
 In retrospect the pace of international expansion may seem extravagant, especially since the franchising route which has eased the financial pain of UK expansion was not thought practicable abroad. 
 But that is all part of the prescription for these go-go (and now stop-stop) 1980s companies. 
 Will Tie Rack come to a full stop? 
 Probably not, even though the next couple of years will be tough and even though Mr Bishko has a habit of losing senior managers with an abandon bordering on carelessness. 
 Even at &pound;19.99 for a top-of-the-range silk masterpiece, ties are not exactly big ticket items. 
 And while (at least in my personal experience) men are more likely than women to stop buying such adornments when times are tough, gravy and similar substances will keep going astray, creating a steady replacement market. 
 It would be interesting to know how Mr Bishko's shareholders feel about the future. 
 But since half the shares are owned by the shadowy, South African-linked Vadep Holdings we (and even Mr Bishko) are unlikely to find out. 
 Although with no dividend increase and the shares languishing at just 46p after yesterday's fall, even the patience of anonymous South Africans must be sorely tested. 
 Wall Street hit by job fears as Shearson cuts 800 staff. 
 By Mary Brasier in New York 
 SHEARSON Lehman, the securities house, has sparked fears of a fresh wave of job cuts on Wall Street with a decision to make up to 800 employees redundant. 
 The cuts are the third time Shearson has laid off staff since the market crash of 1987, and are the highest on Wall Street this year. 
 They are expected to fall across the board among the firm's 38,500 employees but will be confined to New York. 
 A spokesman for Shearson said UK staff would not be affected and the group is not withdrawing from any area of business. 
 Shearson yesterday blamed the continued slowdown in market activity and excess capacity for the redundancies. 
 The market plunge on October 13 when the Dow Jones index fell 190 points was a factor, said spokesman Steven Fagan. 
 But Shearson like other Wall Street firms has been forced to review its payroll by the dearth of corporate finance fees on top of the chronic decline in market volume and commissions. 
 The cuts will remove another two per cent from the payroll following layoffs of 1200 last year and a further round which saw 300 jobs go. 
 After Black Monday, large firms like Shearson have built up their corporate finance departments and relied increasingly on them to generate earnings. 
 But the collapse of the United Airlines bid and the troubles of the junk bond market have blocked new deals. 
 The main axe is expected to fall on the firm's back office operations and among administrative staff in an effort to contain expenses. 
 Analysts say that Shearson is paying the price for overmanning during the market boom which ended in 1987. 
 Magnet finance chief quits. 
 Magnet's finance director Albert King has suddenly left the company, it was disclosed last night. 
 The company would not comment. 
 The troubled DIY group has been in talks with its bankers arranging a refinancing of the &pound;553million loans taken out at the time of the management buy-out. 
 US interest rates fall. 
 US interest rates fell yesterday as the Federal Reserve gave the first sign that it is prepared to ease monetary policy. 
 The Fed's injection of funds triggered a fall in rates from 8 &frac34; per cent to just over 8 &frac12; per cent. 
 The action sparked a rally in bond prices and the Dow Jones closed 14.96 up at 2597.13.. 
 Barclays' US move. 
 Barclays plans to sell part of its US finance arm, Barclays American Corporation, according to a report in the American Banker newspaper. 
 It said Barclays will sell part of the consumer and business finance company within the next few months. 
 Check on 737s. 
 Airlines have been asked to check new Boeing 737s after an alert by the US Federal Aviation Authority that a bolt may have been left off the plane's forward door during production. 
 The alert stems from a check by Boeing of its quality control records and covers 18 planes completed in the last two months. 
 Settlement pressure. 
 The pressure for an insurance market settlement of the &pound;305 million losses from Dick Outhwaite's syndicates has intensified after the &dollar;50million threat of legal action against the corporation of Lloyd's for breach of fiduciary duty from US investors. 
 Huhne runner-up. 
 Christopher Huhne, the Guardian's Economics Editor, was yesterday the runner-up in the press awards for articles on 1992 presented by Arrows, the Cheshire trade finance group. 
 Dan Atkinson, deputy city and economics editor of the Press Association was the winner, and Anthony Hilton, the financial editor of the Evening Standard came third. 
 Economics column, page 15. 
 Coniston in union talks. 
 Coniston Partners, the New York-based investment firm seeking to oust United Airlines' board, is due to meet the engineers union today to discuss its plans for the big US carrier. 
 It met the flight attendants' union on Monday and is also hoping to talk to the pilots' union. 
 Pembridge buys more. 
 Pembridge, Roland Franklin's vehicle for the &pound;697million bid for DRG, bought more shares yesterday. 
 It now claims to have 56 per cent of DRG, but Mr Franklin would not say when the bid would go unconditional. 
 He is waiting for the shares to be registered in Pembridge's name. 
 Docks hopes &bquo;dashed&equo;. 
 The transport union TGWU yesterday claimed the last hope of reviving the Manchester docks had been jeopardised by the Manchester Ship Canal company's indifference to obtaining a new shipping service which union officials valued at &pound;1.5million annually. 
 Buy-out move planned by B&amp;C. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 ALEVERAGED buy-out for British&amp;Commonwealth will be mounted by the company's management if an unacceptably low takeover offer is tabled, the chairman, John Gunn, pledged yesterday. 
 He admitted that with prevailing high interest rates he was not particularly keen to mount a management bid, but would do so if it was the only way to safeguard shareholder value. 
 B&amp;C, the one-time star of the financial services sector, is planning to raise at least &pound;130 million from the sale of its Gartmore fund management business which was announced yesterday. 
 Aetna, the large US insurance group is understood to be a front runner on the 20-strong list of potential buyers for Gartmore. 
 Analysts added, however, that the company was expected to attract interest from Japan and Europe. 
 Opening bids will have to be lodged by December 11 with a decision on the sale expected by the end of January 1990. 
 B&amp;C says it has received a stream of offers for Gartmore, the international group which employs about 500 people and has some &pound;6.4billion under management, over the past two to three years. 
 But Mr Gunn said other disposals should take that total to between &pound;400million and &pound;500million before the end of next year. 
 Disposals such as Woodchester, London Forfaiting, the three Gartmore trusts, and two divisions of Atlantic Computers should raise another &pound;225million, Mr Gunn said yesterday. 
 Analysts also expect the company to shed its large stake in merchant bank Singer &amp; Friedlander. 
 He said that although speculation was mounting that a bid for B&amp;C was on the cards, there was no evidence, so far, of stake-building and no offers had been received. 
 The business sales were designed to cut the 30 per cent of B&amp;C's borrowings which are currently under fluctuating interests rates &mdash; roughly &pound;200 million of its overall loans. 
 Mr Gunn said B&amp;C's predicament, with shares at the levels of roughly five years ago, was &bquo;a little embarrassing&equo; but he predicted the group would be back in City favour by the end of next year. 
 &bquo;The problem is that British&amp;Commonwealthstill has a credibility problem. 
 If Gunn said &bquo;I'm a human being&equo; half the analysts would say he was a cardboard cutout. 
 It is not a question of loathing &mdash; rather sanguine hatred following the dive in the share price,&equo; said one analyst. 
 Shares in British&amp;Commonwealth have dived from about 550p to 120p but Mr Gunn, said he is confident of captivating City confidence once more. 
 He admitted taking his hand off the tiller at the group but denied any boardroom rift over strategy. 
 Caparo raises offer price. 
 Swraj Paul's Caparo Automotive group raised its cash offer for Armstrong Equipment to 185p yesterday, valuing the fasteners manufacturer at &pound;98million, and promptly increased its holding to 46.7 per cent. 
 This tally is boosted by Caparo's purchase of JHFenner's 6.32 per cent holding. 
 Fenner, the Hull-based power transmission engineer, bought the stake when the original bid was announced and had offered to act as white knight to Armstrong and to distribute their fasteners through its own international network. 
 &bquo;It is no surprise that JHFenner has decided to sell their shares to us at our generous increased offer price,&equo; Dr Paul said. 
 The Armstrong chairman, Roy Watts, said the Caparo bid was too low by any standard. 
 &bquo;A bid of 185p clearly undervalues Armstrong and Dr Paul knows it,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It really is time he got on with running his own business and let us run ours. 
 Nobody benefits from all this.&equo; 
 During the day, holders of a further 11.1 per cent of Armstrong shares ignored the chairman's appeal and sold to Caparo. 
 Parkland holds steady. 
 Parkland Textiles, the Bradford-based woollen yarn spinner and clothing maker, yesterday showed a small increase in profits, despite a difficult six months trading. 
 Mr Michael Rowley, finance director, said the group had foreseen the problems and had made an effort to increase income from interest, which came in at &pound;64,000 as against a charge of &pound;78,000 at the halfway stage last year. 
 Pre-tax profits were up 7.5 per cent at &pound;1.48million on turnover marginally ahead at &pound;29.5million. 
 Cash in the bank stands at about &pound;1million, but the company has a &pound;2.6million loan at 10 per cent. 
 Chief executive Paul Hanson, with an eye on falling consumer demand in the UK, hopes to double exports by the end of the financial year. 
 Meanwhile, the interim dividend has been raised to 2.2p. 
 Steely effort from GEI. 
 GEI International, the packaging machinery and special wire and cutting steels manufacturer, lifted profit again in the first half of the year. 
 The search for internationally-oriented acquisitions in packaging goes on, backed by cash resources of about &pound;15million. 
 The Allspeeds drives and controls subsidiary is the only remaining poor performer, but its losses have been stopped. 
 Because of the Midland Bright Drawn Steel sale, after the Steel Stampings disposal to Parkland last year, turnover was reduced to &pound;33.7million, from &pound;636.2million in the six months to September 30. 
 Pre-tax profit rose to &pound;2.95million, from &pound;2.52million, excluding the extraordinary gain of &pound;249,000 on the sale. 
 Profitability in the main business rose further and Sanderson Kayser and other special steels held their ground. 
 The interim dividend is raised to 2.35p, from 2.14p net a share, covered by earnings up 0.75p to 4.97p. 
 In short&hellip; 
 KENNING Motor Group, a subsidiary of Ron Brierley's quoted UK motor dealership, Tozer Kemsley and Millbourn, achieved a slim increase in pre-tax profit to &pound;1.6million (against &pound;1.59million last year) in the six months to the end of June, although turnover fell from &pound;96.5million in 1988 to &pound;88.7million. 
 The markets. 
 Stock markets preferred to take notice of the continued strength of sterling, rather than Wall Street's fresh tumble of nearly 50 points. 
 So an early mark-down of a few pence was soon recouped, and by the close the FTSE index had reversed the initial fall of over nearly eight points as New York showed signs of a more stable performance. 
 Gilts improved a quarter as fears of another hike in interest rates receded. 
 For equities it was a day for special situations. 
 Mining stocks made the running as gold and kindred metal prices advanced afresh. 
 Insurances also did well, helped by a report in an American newspaper predicting higher premiums after the earthquake and hurricane disasters earlier this year. 
 Elsewhere price movements were small. 
 Stores were drab, unsettled by heavier-than-expected losses at Tie Rack, 47p, down 7p. 
 Storehouse, where brokers have been downgrading their forecasts almost monthly, slipped 6p to 106p ahead of tomorrow's figures. 
 In contrast, food retailers were supported ahead of today's interim statement from Sainsbury, but Iceland Frozen Foods plunged 39p to 280p as Hoare Govett and at least two other brokers downgraded their forecasts. 
 There was excitement in the merchant banking sector during the afternoon as talks between Morgan Grenfell and BZW broke down. 
 Morgan Grenfell shares, up 14p to 485p before the news, dropped immediately to 430p, before bouncing back almost as quickly to close unchanged at 468p. 
 Paris: Interest-rate concerns and the weak tone of US issues combined to send stocks lower in light trading. 
 CAC Index: 500.6 (511.1). 
 Frankfurt: Shares closed lower, following Wall Street's lead. 
 Hong Kong: Stocks fell. 
 Hang Seng index: 2,738.09 (2,756.12). 
 Tokyo: Stocks closed lower for the third consecutive trading day. 
 Nikkei index: 35,270.46 (35,434.00). 
 French trust group suspends dealings over pricing fears. 
 By Teresa Hunter 
 THE French-owned unit-trust company Dumenil has suspended dealings in its funds, worth &pound;33 million, after the disclosure that there may have been pricing errors in recent valuations. 
 This is the first time a unit trust company has had to suspend funds under the Financial Services Act's pricing regulations, which oblige it to cease trading once an error is suspected. 
 It means Dumenil's 12,000 investors are locked into their investments until the investigation is complete. 
 As the suspension of a unit trust over a pricing error is unprecedented, it is not known when units can be traded again. 
 One month has been suggested as a possible suspension period. 
 Dumenil, which specialises in single country European funds, claims it became concerned &bquo;very recently&equo; that its valuations on two funds in particular were out-of-line with general movements in the market. 
 The marketing director, Nigel Herrick, said: &bquo;The market would fall, but our prices would not show a corresponding movement.&equo; 
 Unit trust industry sources claim that rumours began circulating as long as three months ago that Dumenil had a problem with valuations. 
 The company stresses the problem has been very short-lived. 
 But as a precaution it has suspended all its funds, until an investigation pinpoints the root of the problem. 
 Unit trust prices are calculated on computers using market information supplied by the WM Company. 
 There is no suggestion that the WM data has been faulty. 
 Mr Herrick said: &bquo;This is an in-house problem. 
 Right now we do not know the extent of that problem. 
 We do not know which, if any, funds are affected and we do not know whether there has been an over valuation or an under valuation.&equo; 
 Dumenil has called in Touche Ross as independent accountants to assess the scale of the problem. 
 The regulatory bodies, including the Securities and Investments Board, the Investment Managers Regulatory Organisation and the Life Assurance and Unit Trust Regulatory Organisation are keeping a close eye on the investigation procedure. 
 If it is proved that unit holders who have traded units recently have suffered as a result of pricing errors, some form of compensation will be made available. 
 Midland Bank, one of the trustees of the Dumenil funds, stepped in to calm investors' fears. 
 A Midland spokesman said: &bquo;The assets of the trust have been and continue to be under the control of the trustee whose objective remains that of insuring that the interests of the investors are protected.&equo; 
 The aftershocks of the European row tell us that the big tremors are still to come Economics. 
 By Christopher Huhne 
 WHATEVER the hopes of the Conservative party's managers, the divisions over European policy are not going to go away. 
 There is bound, sooner or later, to be a battle royal over membership of the European Monetary System, the result of which will be either an almost unprecedented humiliation for Mrs Thatcher or the reshaping yet again of a Cabinet in her own image. 
 On present betting, there is a fair chance the pound will finally join the system by the end of next year. 
 Mrs Thatcher interprets the Madrid formula more as a pretext for not joining the EMS than as a set of three conditions for joining it. 
 Moreover, she has been advised by Sir Alan Walters that, once exchange controls have finally been removed by France and Italy in July 1990, the new freedom of capital flows will break the fixed exchange rate system apart. 
 On that fond hope, she is likely to be disappointed. 
 The remaining controls, mainly affecting restrictions on bank deposits, are small. 
 At some point in the second half of next year, and perhaps even earlier if President Mitterrand decides to bring forward the abolition of French controls, the Government is going to be faced with an inescapable decision. 
 Controls will have gone. 
 British inflation will be down (an odd condition, since one reason for the system is to help reduce inflation). 
 There will have been progress on the creation of a single European market, especially in financial services. 
 Reasonable people will decide that each of the Madrid conditions has been met. 
 At that stage, the pressures for full membership are bound to mount at home and overseas. 
 The pound may now stay at its new post-Lawson level or even decline further. 
 But at an exchange rate of, say, DM2.70 (instead of the present DM2.90) the trade-offs for the new Chancellor will begin to look different. 
 He will want to avoid a further decline for fear that import price rises will push up inflation. 
 For good electoral reasons, EMS membership will look an increasingly attractive alternative to a tighter monetary policy. 
 The going will be tough enough as it is. 
 The former Chancellor, Mr Lawson, gave a foretaste of the Treasury's Autumn Statement forecast when, in his resignation speech, he pointed out that &bquo;we are once again on the downswing and I see no need for any further policy tightening. 
 While this downswing will not be as sharp as the previous downturn (in 1979-81), not least given the very much lower level of inflation that we now have, a dull 1989 is bound to be followed by a difficult 1990.&equo; 
 The downturn will not, though, undermine the case for EMS membership. 
 A mild recession will correct but not eliminate the deficit, which is bound to remain high, and may even rise again as another pre-election consumer spree gathers pace. 
 Outside the EMS, the markets would become worried once again about the Government's real commitment to exchange rate stability. 
 They would insist on inflationary falls in the pound, or a deflationary tightening of monetary policy. 
 What better than EMS membership to reassure them? 
 The external pressures for EMS membership will also mount. 
 It will become increasingly clear that Britain is paying a high political price for its refusal to participate in the EMS, not least in the almost immediate reflex reaction against any British proposals to affect the design of a future monetary union. 
 No one watching the French reaction to the unfolding events in central Europe should doubt the political importance which the Elysee attaches to monetary union as a way of anchoring west Germany to this end of the Continent. 
 A single currency is also on the agenda because the balance of the economic argument has also swung sharply in its favour over the last decade, as Professor Michael Artis has pointed out (1). 
 He guesstimates that the existence of different European currencies cost about 1.5 per cent of Europe's total income each year, merely in terms of the losses incurred by traders and investors when they change currencies. 
 Even more important, the prospect of a single currency would eliminate an ormous source of uncertainty for businesses. 
 It would probably unleash another burst of investment as firms took advantage of opportunities which had hitherto been regarded as too risky. 
 After all, businesses can insure against the exchange rate risk on particular deals &mdash; for example, their exports to France &mdash; by accepting less sterling today in exchange for the known future quantity of francs. 
 But they cannot hedge investments in the same way (even if the markets looked far beyond a year or so, which they do not). 
 Assume, for example, that Jaguar had insured itself against a fall of the dollar by covering several years of earnings. 
 The fall of the dollar would still mean that every Jaguar car sold in the US was less profitable, although the company might have made lots of money on its foreign exchange transactions. 
 The rational company would cash in its profits on the speculation &mdash; and still cut production and investment as it was priced out of the US market. 
 Exchange rate uncertainty is thus bound to reduce investment. 
 Some idea of the potential gains from a single currency can be had by looking at previous historical periods when people really believed that exchange rates were fixed. 
 Mr Tam Bayoumi has calculated the average size of capital flows each year in the major economies under the Gold Standard from 1880 to 1913, and has shown that they were much larger than during the post-war period from 1965 to 1986. 
 Indeed, the average flow, as a percentage of GDP, for eight countries in the sample before 1914 was 3.25 per cent a year; the average flow for ten countries post-1965 was only 1 per cent (2). 
 The advocates of the Government's &bquo;competing currencies&equo; approach suggest that many of these gains would occur by merely moving to a &bquo;hard&equo; EMS in which currencies became progressively more fixed (3). 
 However, the evidence so far suggests that it is not enough to persuade businesspeople that rates will really be fixed forever. 
 Moreover, the process of establishing credibility is long drawn out. 
 The French, despite an exceptionally tough policy, still have interest rates above the German level because they are unable to persuade the markets they mean what they say when they rule out a devaluation. 
 Nor is it sensible to argue, as the Treasury has, that a European system of central banks in charge of a single currency might prove more inflationary than a fixed exchange rate system where each monetary authority competed to provide a stable benchmark of value. 
 It is impossible to make any such comparison without knowing what the institutional arrangements of the system would be. 
 If the system's charter allowed for a bank governor to be shot at dawn for every month the inflation rate exceeded 1 per cent, it might prove even more counter-inflationary than the Bundesbank. 
 The potential political and economic gains ensure that the impetus towards a currency union in Europe is likely to prove much stronger today than it did in the turbulent Seventies. 
 And that, in turn, is likely to feed back on the Government in the form of pressures from the most irresistible of all Tory constituencies, the City. 
 After all, what would be more likely to gain from a brave new world of free capital flows than the greatest financial centre in Europe? 
 This week has not seen the end of the row about Europe in the Conservative party, but merely a regrouping of forces for the battle still to come. 
 (1) &bquo;Europe without currency barriers&equo; Samuel Brittan, Michael Artis, The Social Market Foundation, London, &pound;5.00. 
 (2) &bquo;Savings-investment correlations: immobile capital, government policy or endogenous behaviour?&equo; 
 Tamim Bayoumi, International Monetary Fund working paper 89/66. (3) An evolutionary approach to EMU, HM Treasury, November 1989. 
 MPs begin Jaguar probe. 
 By Andrew Cornelius Industrial Editor 
 MPs today begin investigating the events which led to the Government dropping its golden share in Jaguar and the subsequent deal to sell the company to Ford. 
 The investigation by the all-party Trade and Industry Committee opens as Labour accuse the Government of &bquo;wiping its hands of the future of Jaguar, its workforce and the West Midlands car industry.&equo; 
 Mr Doug Henderson, Labour's trade and industry spokesman, made the accusation after discussing the Jaguar deal with Mr Derek Barron, chairman of Ford of Britain. 
 He said: &bquo;I am astonished that the Government, which hailed Jaguar as the flagship of the privatisation programme, has now wiped its hands of the future of the company, its workforce and the West Midlands car industry.&equo; 
 He had written to the Office of Fair Trading to ask if, in the absence of any interest by the Government, it would seek formal assurances from Ford on future investment levels, research and development expenditure, training, component sourcing and the development of the dealer network. 
 Jaguar shareholders will be sent details of Ford's &pound;1.6billion takeover terms in a circular due to be posted today to shareholders in the UK and also the US, where a simultaneous offer is to be made to investors holding Jaguar shares in the form of American Depository Receipts. 
 They will be invited to vote on the Ford takeover terms and also to change the company's articles of association to allow a single investor to buy more than 15 per cent of the shares at an extraordinary meeting scheduled for December 1. 
 The Government has promised to lift its protective golden share in the business, which would otherwise expire at the end of 1990, if 75 per cent of Jaguar shareholders vote in favour of this change. 
 Brittan attacks Thatcher on EMS. 
 By Larry Elliott Economics Correspondent 
 BRITAIN'S senior EC commissioner Sir Leon Brittan upped the stakes in the Cabinet row over Europe last night when he said the UK should join the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System within the next few months. 
 In a thinly disguised attack on the Prime Minister and her former adviser Professor Sir Alan Walters, Sir Leon said the countries which had become full members of the exchange rate mechanism had enjoyed lower interest rates and lower inflation. 
 &bquo;It really is a bit strange to have been arguing the merits of ERM membership in academic abstraction, when the practical effects are there for all to see. 
 Academics, like accountants, should be on tap, and not on top.&equo; 
 In a step-by-step assault on the softly-softly approach to Europe being peddled by Downing Street, the former Conservative cabinet minister also made it clear that Mrs Thatcher's hard-line opposition to the concept of monetary union with the other 11 EC nations was jeopardising the chances of London becoming the base for a European central bank. 
 &bquo;I see no reasons for us to shy away from the concept of a Federal Reserve-type of European Central Bank, operating as in the United States on a decentralised basis&equo;, Sir Leon said in a lecture in London. 
 &bquo;If it were based in London, which as Europe's financial powerhouse would be a natural home for it, the benefits to the City would be enormous. 
 But there will, of course, be no chance of that happening unless Britain were to show its enthusiasm for the project from the outset.&equo; 
 Sir Leon dismissed arguments that a pan-European central bank would mean the United Kingdom would have to surrender sovereignty and relinquish control over monetary policy. 
 Commenting on the increase in UK base rates to 15 per cent last month, he added: &bquo;What sort of expression of sovereignty is it to have to race after the Bundesbank within minutes of its unilaterally deciding to put up interest rates? 
 &bquo;Wouldn't we have more control over our affairs if the Bank of England had a major say in what happened, as part of a decentralised European banking authority?&equo; 
 Sir Leon said there was no need for the United Kingdom to wait for its inflation rate to reach the European average before joining the exchange rate mechanism, nor to hold back until the further removal of capital and exchange controls next summer. 
 &bquo;Joining the ERM is not a prize to be given to our partners when they come up to scratch, but a benefit to ourselves if only we would take it,&equo; he said. 
 Hopes rise for European compromise deal on greater telecoms competition. 
 By John Palmer and Peter Large 
 OUTLINES of a compromise deal to open Europe's telecoms industry to greater competition emerged in Brussels last night after a day-long meeting of EC industry ministers. 
 Earlier yesterday, the UK telecoms authority Oftel announced it was launching an inquiry into how effective competition had been in improving Britain's phone services. 
 Although any European agreement will not be reached before next month, it looks as though the Commission may be winning its battle to eliminate national protectionism. 
 Eight of the 12 EC governments remain opposed to attempts by the EC Commissioner for competition policy, Sir Leon Brittan, to impose greater competition on national telecoms authorities. 
 But they agreed with a proposal from the French Government, which is currently responsible for the EC Council of Ministers, to discuss an amendment which would allow the Commission to grant temporary exemptions to countries facing problems with liberalisation. 
 The Commission aims to open up the &pound;60billion telecoms industry as part of the 1992 single European market. 
 The strategy has been to abolish national protectionism in the sales of terminal equipment, to lay down one set of technical standards throughout the EC, to separate the regulatory and business sides of the telecoms authorities, and to open public purchasing of equipment to pan-European tender. 
 The British Industry Minister, Mr Eric Forth, said last night that the Commission's latest proposals were &bquo;a well balanced attempt to allay the fears of some delegations about the consequences of liberalisation for their national suppliers.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, in Paris, GPT, the &pound;1.8billion quasi-British telecoms combine, was launching a company to exploit the liberalisation of the French market. 
 Last year the trade in telecoms equipment between Britain and France barely reached &pound;20million, but today GPT alone has short-list bids for &pound;18million of French public contracts. 
 The new subsidiary, GPTelecom, is headed by Rupert Soames, son of the former British Ambassador to France and EC vice-president. 
 Mr Soames said that whatever the state of liberalisation elsewhere in Europe, the French market was moving at a pheneomenal rate. 
 GPT was formed to unite the telecoms businesses of GEC and Plessey, but as a result of the Plessey takeover it is now owned 60 per cent by GEC and 40 per cent by the German group, Siemens. 
 Siemens products for communications networks will be sold in France through GPTelecom, and Mr Soames said the agreement was likely to be widened so that all telecoms products of Siemens and GPT would be marketed in France through the single channel. 
 The new look at the effectiveness of British liberalisation was announced by Sir Bryan Carsberg, head of Oftel, at the annual meeting of the Telecoms Users' Association. 
 He said that after 3 &frac12; years of competition between British Telecom and the Cable and Wireless subsidiary, Mercury Communications, it was time to survey customers' experience and, if necessary, &bquo;identify practices which might still be inhibiting competition&equo;. 
 He needed to be sure that current arrangements were working as well as possible before the Government's review next year of whether competition in basic telecoms should be extended beyond the two companies. 
 Sir Bryan said he had received &bquo;some indications&equo; that BT's position as a designated maintainer of company phone exchanges could &bquo;inhibit progress for prospective Mercury customers&equo;. 
 He was also considering whether the code of practice which governs the quality of connections between private lines and the public phone network should be advisory rather than mandatory. 
 &bquo;It seems to me to be inconsistent with the spirit of liberalisation to have a mandatory code that necessitates a cumbersome and bureaucratic certification process.&equo; 
 BAT drops its French bankers. 
 By Financial staff 
 THE tobacco-to-insurance giant, BAT Industries, yesterday sacked one of its big bankers, Paribas, after the French finance group's decision to back Sir James Goldsmith's hostile &pound;13.4billion takeover bid. 
 BAT, which had refused to take action against its main French financial advisers at the time Sir James's assault was mounted, has decided to appoint Credit Lyonnais. 
 The large UK-based group retains roughly 70 international financial bankers and Paribas had acted as BAT's senior adviser in France when the company joined the Paris bourse. 
 BAT described Paribas's actions as &bquo;pretty fickle.&equo; 
 The French bank is the latest in a string of financial advisers to be sacked by British groups after backing hostile takeover bids. 
 Paribas had helped Axa Midi in plans to buy BAT's Farmers unit in America. 
 BAT is in the process of a restructuring programme which involves selling its US retailing operations, its paper businesses and other interests. 
 Perrier in &pound;250m soft drink sale. 
 By Financial staff 
 PERRIER, the French group which has come to epitomise &bquo;designer&equo; water, has put its soft drinks division up for sale for around &pound;250million. 
 The move follows the group's decision to concentrate on its most profitable business, mineral water, which it says is expanding &bquo;dramatically&equo; throughout the world. 
 Cadbury has been tipped to buy Perrier's soft drinks business, which includes Pchitt lemonade, Bali syrup, and the bottling of Gigi lemonade. 
 Cadbury, which declined to comment on speculation, recently acquired the Gigi brand name when it bought Crush from Procter&amp;Gamble, but it is understood it would be reluctant to pay much more than &pound;150million for the Perrier business. 
 An extra impetus for the disposal came at the start of the week when Pepsi decided to end its franchise relationship with Perrier, citing poor sales performance. 
 Some interpreted Pepsi's decision as a prelude to a bid for Perrier's soft drinks business, which analysts predicted might also attract offers from Coca-Cola, Suntory of Japan, or Guinness through its LVMH connection. 
 Marcel Richard, Perrier's financial director, declined to mention the impact of Pepsi's decision. 
 But it is understood that Pepsi's market share in France for cola drinks dropped from 18 per cent in the early 1980s to roughly 10 per cent despite an expanding market. 
 For Perrier the sale of soft drinks have become vastly less important than the revenue from bottled water. 
 Soft drink sales last year were &pound;115million, less than a tenth of the group's revenue. 
 Much of the upheaval in the world's soft drinks markets has been prompted by the US giants, Pepsi and Coke, which are now looking aggressively for expansion in Europe. 
 Coca-Cola is said to control around 80 per cent of the French cola market and Pepsi is keen to strike back. 
 Polly Peck sells textile arm to Hong Kong company. 
 POLLY PECK is selling its barely profitable textile subsidiary, Polly Peck Far East, to a Hong Kong-controlled British Virgin Islands registered company in preference to the privatisation proposals announced a month ago, writes Robin Stoddart. 
 After the repurchase of PPFE's Portuguese offshoot and a United States marketing business, along with its electronics section, &pound;27.5million will be realised from the deal, including a special dividend. 
 It will cover a further part of the purchase costs of Polly Peck's recent acquisitions of Del Monte, the American fresh fruit distributor and Sansui Electric of Japan, on top of the proceeds of the recent rights issue. 
 Brave Dragon, PPFE's buyer is owned by Wing Tai Exporters in partnership with Sung Hung Kai, the Hong Kong property giant. 
 It will offer holders of the outstanding 26 per cent of the PPFE capital the same terms and also make a fractionally higher cash offer than under the privatisation proposal to the larger number of warrantholders. 
 However, it intends to retain the Hong Kong share quotations. 
 A special dividend, worth &pound;17 million to Polly Peck, is being paid before the change of ownership. 
 The US, Portuguese and Shell Electric subsidiary repurchases are valued at &pound;10.8million. 
 After the offer closes, Mr Asil Nadir and other Polly Peck directors will resign from PPFE, though if it is not unconditional by December 14, the privatisation offer, worth 6 per cent less, will go ahead. 
 Polly Peck raised half of the &pound;560million Del Monte Fresh Fruit purchase cost through its three-for-seven rights issue, but it has just paid &pound;69million for control of Sansui. 
 Under the privatisation proposal it was offering almost &pound;14million for the rest of PPFE, which had made little progress since the Hong Kong flotation. 
 MP claims that Met fraud squad leaked Fraser report to Lonrho. 
 By Daniel John 
 THE copy of the confidential Department of Trade and Industry report into the House of Fraser takeover which was passed to the Observer newspaper was leaked by officers of the Metropolitan Police fraud squad, it was alleged yesterday. 
 According to a House of Commons motion, the leak was traced through a system of numbered copies of the 752-page document, which was sent out to the authorities investigating possible criminal proceedings resulting from the report's conclusions. 
 Mr Dale Campbell-Savours, Labour MP for Workington, claims that the leak inquiry, which followed publication of parts of the report in a special edition of the Observer, discovered that copy 26 had been sent to the paper's owners, Lonrho. 
 It is the first time the fraud squad has been directly accused of leaking the report. 
 The MP's motion and three parliamentary questions directed at the Attorney-General, Sir Patrick Mayhew, allege the copy was given to the fraud squad to help its investigations into the successful &pound;615million bid for Fraser by the Fayed brothers in 1985. 
 Two fraud squad officers, Detective Inspector Graham Gooch and Detective Sergeant Ken Morgan, were sent out to Egypt as part of the investigation being conducted alongside an investigation by the Serious Fraud Office. 
 However, they were later taken off the case and transferred to other duties. 
 Mr Campbell-Savours alleges that senior Scotland Yard officers then decided the team should not have any further contact with the Observer or Lonrho. 
 But his motion adds: &bquo;This House therefore questions why an officer chose to ignore that instruction by meeting the City editor of the Observer at least twice including on the eve of publication of the special edition&equo;. 
 The motion goes on to say that it draws the &bquo;natural and disturbing inference&equo; that the meetings and copy number 26 were linked. 
 And Mr Campbell-Savours called on the Lonrho chief executive, Mr Tiny Rowland, to relinquish control over the Observer. 
 The questions, listed for today in the Commons order paper, ask whether the fraud squad had the copy, if any disciplinary action had been taken against any officer and whether criminal inquiries are being pursued. 
 The SFO refused comment on the MP's allegations or on when it will decide if any prosecutions should follow from the Fraser takeover. 
 However, a decision is believed to be imminient and reports suggest the SFO will take no further action. 
 This would allow the report to be published as the Government has promised. 
 A Scotland Yard spokesman said no disciplinary action had been taken against any officers and that nobody had been suspended. 
 He said Scotland Yard could not pre-empt any Commons questions until they had been answered. 
 Mr Campbell-Savours last night withdrew his questions on procedural grounds but said he will retable them. 
 The Attorney General's office said: &bquo;They will be answered by the appropriate minister&equo;. 
 Publication of the report by the Observer in March this year caused a furore and prompted a special committee of Law Lords to decide whether Lonrho had been guilty of contempt of court before its appeal to the House of Lords on the Fraser bid. 
 They concluded the company, which has bitterly contested the Fayeds ownership of the stores group, had &bquo;taken the law into own hands&equo; but cleared it of contempt. 
 Lonrho last night reiterated its claim that it had received the copy of the report in a brown paper envelope. 
 &bquo;We have no knowledge of where it came from,&equo; said a spokesman. 
 Obituary: Carlo Verrri. 
 Heavy blow to Alitalia:. 
 CARLO Verri, the new president of the Italian state airline Alitalia, died on Monday night aged 50 in a macabre car crash in the southern suburbs of Rome. 
 He was on the telephone to his wife in Turin when his chauffeur (who also died) drove the armour-plated car through a red light into a bus. 
 An eye-witness saw Verri in the back seat gesturing towards the open telephone line and died shortly afterwards. 
 Unusually for Italy, Verri owed nothing to political connections for his appointment from the private sector only just over a year ago. 
 The airline's situation was too serious. 
 Alitalia was facing erratic profits, stagnating passenger traffic and heavy competition on its European and long-haul routes, with Verri's predecessor and the president of the state holding wrangling in public. 
 Strikes by pilots, cabin crew and ground staff, were compounded last winter by unusually persistent fog at under-equipped north Italian tourist airports. 
 Verri was not an airline man, but the president of the components group of the Swedish firm Electrolux. 
 In July he succeeded in settling two years' disruption at heavy labour cost (26 per cent) and in his all-too-brief career he also announced a 5.9 trillion lire investment programme to be completed in 1995, divided between fleet expansion (3.4 trillion lire) and ground upgrading. 
 However, the airline's firm orders for 20 Airbus A321 medium-range jets and 28 McDonnell Douglas jets will not be delivered until the mid-1990s, and unlike some other European airlines, Alitalia is thought vulnerable for want of international partners and a strategy for deregulation of the European market after 1992. 
 In the meantime, the airline will be run by its managing director, Giovanni Bisignani. 
 G.A. 
 and Reuter 
 Lebanon leader builds cabinet. 
 By Reuter in Beirut 
 LEBANON'S new President, Mr Rene Muawad, yesterday worked to weld old militia foes into a cabinet to govern his divided country while fellow Christians, demonstrating against him, shut half of Beirut. 
 Supporters of General Michel Aoun, staged noisy street protests in the Christian enclave. 
 About 1,000 marched on the French embassy to denounce support for the Arab peace plan which brought Mr Muawad to power on Sunday. 
 &bquo;France has deceived us,&equo; one poster said. 
 Another charged that Lebanon's Christians had been let down by President Franois Mitterrand. 
 Gen Aoun rejected the Arab peace pact for failing to ensure a clear, rapid timetable for the withdrawal of Syria's 33,000 troops from Lebanon. 
 Mr Muawad, a pro-Syrian Maronite Christian, met deputies in the village of Ehden in the Syrian-controlled north to consult them about forming a cabinet, due to be announced this week. 
 Analysts said Mr Muawad faced the task of uniting militia leaders who have been fighting each other for 14 years. 
 Mr Muawad has said nothing about the composition of his cabinet, but is expected to include Mr Selim el-Hoss, Prime Minister in a rival administration to Gen Aoun. 
 The anger expressed in East Beirut reflected a sense of betrayal in the Christian camp. 
 About half the deputies who defied Gen Aoun's attempts to block the presidential election are Christians like Mr Muawad. 
 Lebanon's presidential palace in Ba'abda is held by Gen Aoun, so Mr Muawad was expected to base the government in Syrian-held West Beirut. 
 Mr Muawad was quoted in the Syrian daily, al-Thawara, as saying he would work to promote ties with Syria. 
 &bquo;Although Lebanon and Syria are two countries they are one people of the nation&hellip; which was partitioned by colonialism.&equo; 
 PAGE 
 Pentagon could axe electronic warfare system. 
 By Mark Tran in Washington 
 PENTAGON budget officials are contemplating cancellation of a hi-tech joint Navy-Air Force electronic jamming system scheduled to be fitted in more than 2,000 new fighter and attack planes. 
 They blame budgetary pressures, persistent teething problems, and cost overruns. 
 The Airborne Self-Protection Jammer was described by the world's top electronics experts in the 1988-89 edition of Jane's Avionics as possibly the &bquo;most significant US electronic warfare system in the current decade.&equo; 
 But under intense congressional pressure the Defence Department says that it will kill the programme next year unless the services manage to iron out serious flaws. 
 The electronic jammer programme is at least four years behind schedule and may cost at least &dollar;1 billion more than estimated, according to one Pentagon report. 
 Still, the Pentagon has yet to bite the bullet and recently awarded &dollar;419 million in contracts to Westinghouse and ITT Avionics Division, which have developed the system, to build the first 100 production models for installation in the aircraft. 
 After 13 years of development the latest flight tests showed that the system, which costs an estimated &dollar;9 billion, was &bquo;marginally operationally effective and marginally operationally suitable,&equo; according to a recent declassifed navy report. 
 Defence experts say the services in their perennial pursuit of hi-tech gadgetry have once again dug a hole for themselves. 
 &bquo;These systems work well if they know the parameters of Soviet radar very well. 
 On the other hand they can fail catastrophically. 
 Simpler systems don't attempt as much, but are not going to fail so badly,&equo; said an analyst with the Centre for Defence Information, Mr Steve Kosiak. 
 Tests of the ASJP, to be installed on new models of the F-18, F-16, and F-14 fighters and the AV-8B Harrier, have been disappointing. 
 They reveal that the system has problems detecting, identifying, or jamming some enemy radars already in existence for decades. 
 The jammers, at a cost of &dollar;3.5 million per plane, are designed to identify radars, single out the most dangerous ones and then transmit electronic signals to deceive or interfere with the radars of the hostile air defence weapons. 
 The poor results have led to rifts within the Pentagon between military programme chiefs who want to persevere with ASJP and budget officials who want to cut losses now. 
 Current problems with avionics systems also threaten to seriously undermine the effectiveness of America's latest sophisticated bombers. 
 Development of the avionics system for the bat-shaped B-2 bomber is at least two years behind schedule and the system may not be fully developed by the time the aircraft is to be deployed in the middle of the next decade. 
 The intercontinental B-1B bomber's electronic countermeasure system will never have the full capabilities touted by the Reagan administration. 
 Indeed, because of deficiencies, the Air Force has had to change some of its plans for the bomber and may have to dish out an extra &dollar;1 billion to correct the problems. 
 Politicians and unions fear unrest over 600,000 arrivals Bonn &bquo;will benefit&equo; from refugee influx. 
 By Anna Tomforde in Bonn 
 WEST German economists are optimistic about the country's ability to absorb the hundreds of thousands of refugees from Eastern Europe this year. 
 They say the refugees will enhance productivity and economic growth. 
 This optimism, however, is not shared by many politicians and trade union leaders. 
 An estimated 600,000 German immigrants &mdash; ethnic Germans from Poland and the Soviet Union, and East Germans &mdash; are expected to settle in West Germany this year, making a 1 per cent growth in the country's population. 
 According to Mr Dieter Brauninger, an economist at Deutsche Bank in Frankfurt, the newcomers could not have arrived at a better time: a period of dynamic growth, when gaps created by the fall in the birth rate in the past two decades need to be filled. 
 &bquo;In the medium and longer term, we are optimistic that both productivity and consumption will rise, which in turn will have a beneficial effect on investment,&equo; said Mr Brauninger. 
 Economists believe that the boost to the labour force may be worth an additional 1 per cent a year in the early 1990s. 
 Such optimistic forecasts are described as &bquo;dangerous&equo; by the Federal Labour Office. 
 It says economists are ignoring the difficulties of integration, especially of ethnic Germans with large families and language problems. 
 However, the president of the labour office, Mr Egon Franke, said this week that unemployment among refugees &mdash; which has risen sharply in October &mdash; was still only a temporary phenomenon. 
 &bquo;The opportunities remain good, but miracles can not be expected overnight,&equo; he said. 
 The influx coincides with a boom in the building sector, which has been spurred further by the need for housing for the refugees themselves. 
 Yesterday, the Bonn government announced a DM8billion (&pound;2.7billion) package for housing construction for East German refugees, whose number has reached 190,000. 
 The number of ethnic Germans who have arrived so far this year is put at 260,000. 
 With accommodation increasingly hard to find, school gymnasiums, boats, converted cargo containers and some air shelters are now being used to house the refugees. 
 Sociologists agree that &bquo;economic integration&equo; of the refugees poses a minor problem compared with the &bquo;social aspect&equo;. 
 The high motivation, skills and adaptability of the new arrivals create social tensions that will be expressed in economic jealousy. 
 Recent warnings from politicians of all parties that the influx cannot continue indefinitely are therefore seen as being based primarily on fears that the established parties stand to lose votes to the extreme right, notably the Republican Party. 
 The trade unions fear that wage demands may have to be lowered because of the refugees' greater flexibility and readiness to work for less money. 
 A key factor behind the superficial perception that the new arrivals are &bquo;taking jobs&equo; from West Germany's 1.8million unemployed is that West German workers are less mobile and flexible. 
 &bquo;The problem here is that in West Germany we have an increasingly split labour market,&equo; Mr Brauninger explained. 
 Despite high unemployment in some areas there were large openings in sectors such as the electronics and engineering industries in the south. 
 The gap was being filled by the arrivals. 
 Nonetheless, short-term unemployment among the refugees is likely to remain high. 
 At present, about a third of the arrivals are unemployed. 
 Leader comment, page 22 
 Brittan steps into row on German unification. 
 By John Palmer in Brussels 
 SIR Leon Brittan, the senior British EC Commissioner, yesterday said that the European Community should welcome East Germany into the EC providing it was part of West Germany. 
 Sir Leon's intervention into the political minefield of intra-German relations followed the call earlier this week by his West German colleague, Mr Martin Bangemann, for a trade agreement between the EC and East Germany. 
 Sir Leon, who was giving the Grenada annual address in London yesterday, said that German reunification was becoming inevitable. 
 &bquo;It is natural for some of the countries of Western Europe to view the prospects of German reunification with anxiety,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;But such anxiety will not stop it happening if the Soviet Union should ever allow it to happen or be unable to stop it happening&equo;. 
 In a passage which is bound to be seen as highly controversial in the present situation in East Germany, Sir Leon said: &bquo;If Germany's partners give the impression of being opposed to reunification this will only increase what is at present a small risk: that some in Germany may be tempted to seek reunification on the basis of doing a unilateral deal with the Soviet Union, involving the setting up of a new unified German state outside the Community. 
 In other words, opposing reunification will make it more likely to occur in the form which we would least want&equo;. 
 This is in contrast with Mr Bangemann's declaration on Monday that West Germans should not be asked to choose between their desire to overcome Germany's division and their support for greater European integration. 
 Mr Bangemann explicitly appealed to other European leaders not to suggest that German reunification was an immediate political issue or one which could be decided without dramatic changes in the political and security situation in Europe as a whole. 
 Sir Leon said the Community should, in effect, support the integration of East Germany into the Federal Republic as a precondition for East German territory becoming part of the European Community. 
 &bquo;The Community as a whole should make it absolutely clear that it would warmly welcome East Germany joining West Germany on the basis that it was not admitting a new member state to the Community, but simply recognising the extension of the territory of an existing member&equo;, he stated. 
 &bquo;For that to be possible, it would, of course, be essential for what is now East Germany to accept fully both the liberal democratic institutions of the Federal Republic and the rights and obligations involved in being part of a member state of the European Community.&equo; 
 Although Sir Leon's approach will be welcomed by the nationalist-minded rightwing in the Federal Republic, it is unlikely to be endorsed by many ministers in the present Bonn coalition nor by opposition parties. 
 South holds key for Gandhi in close election. 
 By Derek Brown in Madras 
 EVER since independence, Indian elections have been won and lost in the north. 
 But in this month's poll, the southern states will play a greater role than ever, and perhaps a decisive one. 
 The four main states &mdash; Andhra Pradesh, Tamil Nadu, Karnataka, and Kerala &mdash; between them elect 129 members of the Lok Sabha, the lower house of parliament. 
 Pondicherry has just one MP. 
 The Prime Minister, Mr Rajiv Gandhi, was advised when he called the elections that his Congress Party was likely to win some 70 seats in the south. 
 That forecast, from party sources and from the intelligence bureau, which has become a wing of the Prime Minister's office, was crucial in the timing of the election, at least a month before it was expected. 
 Mr Gandhi needs to win at least 200 seats nationally to be reasonably certain of being called on to form the next government. 
 That is far short of a majority in the 543-member Lok Sabha, but with the opposition still technically divided into half a dozen factions, it would make Congress the biggest single party, and President Venkataraman would have to turn to it. 
 In that event, a hung parliament is bound to include large numbers of non-Congressmen who will shamelessly desert to Mr Gandhi, to be on the winning side. 
 Thus, with Congress under heavy pressure in its traditional heartland of the Ganges Plain, the southern results could be the key to Mr Gandhi's chances of continuing in office. 
 But according to observers, the Congress estimate could be optimistic &mdash; not wildly so, but enough to tip the balance in what may be the closest Indian election. 
 The ruling party's best chances of making gains are in the states of Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh. 
 In the former, the opposition is badly split between followers of Mr Ramakrishna Hegde, the charismatic former chief minister who heads the challenge for Janata Dal, and anti-Hegde dissidents. 
 The Janata Dal was formed last year in an attempt to unite the national opposition. 
 But there remains in Karnataka a substantial rump of the old Janata Party, which gave the country its only brief and disastrous respite from Congress rule from 1977 to 1979. 
 The two factions are now bitterly at odds, which gives Congress an excellent chance of a clear sweep. 
 In the last election in 1984, it scored 24 wins out of 28. 
 In Andhra Pradesh, the autocratic rule of the former film star, Mr N.T. Rama Rao, has led to a steady haemorrhage of defectors from his Telugu Desam party to the Congress. 
 Last time, Congress got just six seats out of 42 in a state it once claimed as its almost exclusive territory. 
 This time, it could get 15 or even 20. 
 These gains could be balanced out and even reversed in the remaining states. 
 Kerala has only 20 MPs, 17 of them Congress. 
 But now the state is ruled by a non-Congress coalition and Mr Gandhi's men are divided. 
 All elections in Kerala are notoriously close calls &mdash; in the last poll for the State Assembly, the winning left coalition scored just 0.79 per cent more than its Congress-led rival. 
 Congress was banking on at least 12 seats here, but most observers think they will be lucky to get 10. 
 In Tamil Nadu, the ruling party has done an audacious deal with a faction of the former regional force. 
 This group is led by Ms Jayalalitha, a former film star, and, more important, a former mistress of the late Chief Minister, Mr M.G. Ramachandran. 
 Overall, the south presents nothing like as bleak a picture for Congress as the north, at this stage of the campaign. 
 But it is universally accepted outside the ruling party that there is no question of a return to the golden days of 1980 and earlier elections, when Congress used to scoop up four-fifths of the seats. 
 Regional pride, the growth of language and caste-based movements, suspicion of the Hindi-speaking north, have eroded the support which national parties used to enjoy. 
 Aoun sees start of a revolution. 
 By David Hirst in Beirut 
 LEBANON'S newly elected President, Mr Rene Muawad, yesterday continued to try to form a government of national unity, but the Christian leader General Michel Aoun declared that a revolution had begun in his country. 
 Gen Aoun said Mr Muawad was no more than &bquo;a former deputy&equo; of a parliament which he had dissolved. 
 The whole Arab League peace plan, he said in effect, belonged to an existing order that was going to be swept away. 
 Mr Muawad began his consultations in his own fief in the Syrian-controlled northern part of the Maronite Christian heartland. 
 But he is expected to move soon to predominantly Muslim West Beirut. 
 While the implacable opposition of Gen Aoun is the main obstacle in his path, there are plenty of other difficulties. 
 The Druze leader, Mr Walid Jumblatt &mdash; who, like others in the Syrian camp, is far from happy with the Taif accord &mdash; accused the Arab League envoy, Mr Lakhear Ibrahimi, of interfering in Lebanon's internal affairs, almost as if &bquo;he wants to become prime minister himself&equo;. 
 At a press conference yesterday, an ebullient and seemingly confident Gen Aoun reiterated that there was &bquo;no president&equo; in Lebanon, only a &bquo;dissolved parliament&equo;, and that he headed the &bquo;only legal, sovereign and independent&equo; administration. 
 That had always been the constitutional position, he said, but the big demonstrations of the past few days had proved that he had a popular mandate too. 
 The demonstrations marked &bquo;the beginning of a revolution&equo;. 
 Evading questions about how he proposed to resist the will of virtually the whole Arab and international community, he said that Lebanon had not gone through 15 years of civil war, and given thousands of martyrs, for the dishonourable settlement the world was offering. 
 And he warned that if there was not an honourable settlement, that would &bquo;explode the whole region&equo;. 
 Asked about apparent defections from his cause, he claimed never to have said that he was counting on anybody. 
 Outsiders had proved to be &bquo;crooks and liars who covered their positions with empty slogans&equo;. 
 Lebanon had put its case to the Arabs but they were &bquo;unfair to us, so we turned them down&equo;. 
 As for the rest, &bquo;no one can expect us to sign our own death sentence. 
 That is suicide. 
 Let those who give us such advice sign it themselves.&equo; 
 Reuter adds from Washington: President George Bush yesterday angrily denounced followers of Gen Aoun and said a partition of Lebanon would be totally unacceptable to the world community. 
 Nationalists wreck regional celebrations of revolution. 
 By Reuter in Moscow 
 MOLDAVIAN nationalists fought police yesterday as growing unrest in the Soviet republics wrecked regional celebrations of the 1917 Bolshevik revolution. 
 Mr Yuri Roshka, a spokesman for the Moldavian Popular Front, said that several thousand people clashed with police after clambering over tanks and other military vehicles preparing to move into Lenin Square in Kishinyev. 
 Several people were hurt in the melee, Mr Roshka said. 
 The military parade was cancelled and members of the republic's leadership fled from the raised viewing podium. 
 Separatists tried unsuccessfully to disrupt a military parade in Lithuania. 
 Traditional celebrations in Georgia and Armenia were also cancelled. 
 Mr Roskha said of the trouble in Kishinyev: &bquo;Several thousand people from the Popular Front and other groups broke through cordons of police and climbed on to the tanks and armoured personnel carriers, waving banners and chanting slogans. 
 &bquo;When they got through into Lenin Square, the leadership of the republic climbed down from their viewing podium and ran off. 
 The main thing was that the parade by the military vehicles did not take place.&equo; 
 Mr Roshka said that several members of the 30,000-strong crowd were injured and several others detained by police. 
 Soviet strikes point to crisis of morale that threatens future of perestroika Broadcasts of parliament get more viewers than Agatha Christie films It is the first November 7 since the revolution that coal miners have been on strike. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 SOME people believed that the Soviet Union had nothing in particular to celebrate, observed Mr Boris Prokhorov, of the official Soviet news agency Tass, yesterday. 
 Commenting on the 72nd anniversary of the Russian Revolution, in the openly frank vein that is the hallmark of glasnost, Mr Prokhorov went on: &bquo;Well, one may think so, looking at the industrial down-swing, inflation, transport malfunctions, coal miners&equo; strikes and semi-barren shelves of shops. 
 Yes, all this exists. 
 These are the realities of the truly not easy days of our perestroika.&equo; 
 But for Mr Prokhorov, there is another side to things. 
 &bquo;The first genuinely free elections were held in the Soviet Union,&equo; he pointed out. 
 &bquo;The first Congress of People's Deputies was held and became a political sensation. 
 The first &bquo;real&equo; Supreme Soviet began to function.&equo; 
 And, he added, the broadcasts of parliamentary sessions attracted more viewers than films based on Agatha Christie novels. 
 Besides that, Soviet troops had withdrawn from Afghanistan and a whole range of nuclear missiles had been destroyed. 
 Mr Prokhorov said that the answer to the contradiction between political renewal and economic crisis lay in Marxism, which &bquo;teaches us that the superstructure is more mobile than the base, and that it is the first to react to a change of conditions.&equo; 
 He saw the political system as the superstructure and the economy as the base, which would change more slowly. 
 While there may be some truth in this analysis &mdash; a revolution from above &mdash; it fails to account for a far deeper malaise in Soviet society: a crisis of morale. 
 The anniversary of the Great October Socialist Revolution, celebrated on November 7 because the new Soviet state adopted the Western calendar, is the country's greatest national holiday. 
 This year, however, there is something different in the air. 
 It is, as far as can be remembered, the first November 7 since the revolution that coal miners have been on strike &mdash; the very core of the working class who made the revolution possible. 
 Up in the desolate Arctic region of Vorkuta, site of perhaps Stalin's most infamous Gulag camp, miners in nine of the area's 13 pits have been on strike for more than a week against dismal living conditions, and the bureaucracy of the Communist Party and Soviet government. 
 Among their complaints are not only that government promises to improve their conditions, after last July's pit strikes, have not been met. 
 They also have political demands &mdash; notably concerning article six of the constitution, which entrenches the Communist Party's monopoly of power. 
 In this the miners are at one with the demonstrators who set up another first in Moscow yesterday &mdash; the first rival march to the parade in Red Square which officially salutes the revolution. 
 Most of these demonstrators appeared to be intellectual, or at least what might be called middle class. 
 But the loss of faith in the Communist Party is now so nationwide that workers and intellectuals can be making the same demand to deprive it of absolute power. 
 What they have not yet done is to form a united organisation, or political party, to press that demand. 
 This loss of faith goes far deeper among the young than the old. 
 The old remember why the revolution was started and many still hold the original ideals dear, whatever may have happened in between. 
 The middle-aged may want to preserve an order they are accustomed to, or perhaps their careers. 
 But for the young, it is rather a question of the scales falling from their eyes, and having nothing to believe in any more. 
 And discovering that they have been told lies all their lives. 
 At a meeting in the Kremlin last Saturday, General Vladimir Kryuchkov, head of the KGB and one of the newest members of the politburo, implicitly admitted the lies that had been told about the role of the secret police in Stalin's repression. 
 But he said it would be quite wrong to say that the country's history had been one long mistake since the revolution. 
 His was the party's explanation: that Stalin was the one who distorted everything, and that Leninist ideals of socialism should be reinstated. 
 That, too, has been the message of this Revolution Day &mdash; back to Lenin and 1917, to a &bquo;radical renewal of socialism&equo; as one slogan put it. 
 But, of course, led by the party. 
 Can the party do it? 
 And if it can, do enough people believe it can? 
 Mr Prokhorov should have the last word. 
 &bquo;The main thing is perhaps the fact that we are now having a fresh look, without blinkers, at ourselves and our country,&equo; he said. 
 Voters queue for miles in Namibia poll. 
 By Patrick Laurence in Windhoek 
 THOUSANDS of Namibians stood in long queues, stretching nearly a mile in some cases, as they waited to vote on the first day of Namibia's five-day pre-independence election yesterday. 
 The length of the queues in Windhoek and Katutura, two of the most densely populated urban areas in Namibia, triggered conjecture that the poll might have to be extended an extra day. 
 Namibia's more than 700,000 residents are voting for a 72-member constituent assembly to draw up an independence constitution and prepare the way for full independence next year, perhaps as early as April. 
 Voters left two dominant impressions as they queued in the hot sun &mdash; their determination to cast their ballots in the first free election since Germany began the European conquest of Namibia more than a century ago, and their orderly, disciplined behaviour in the searing heat. 
 One of the first Namibians to cast his vote was the Swapo leader, Mr Sam Nujoma, aged 60. 
 As he entered a polling booth in Katutura, a black township outside Windhoek, he said: &bquo;Today, we are finally burying apartheid colonialism.&equo; 
 Mr Nujoma, wearing a pin-striped shirt and double-breasted jacket, was accompanied by Mr Andimba Toivo ja Toivo, Swapo's secretary-general. 
 Asked for his thoughts on armed struggle now that he was voting, Mr Nujoma said: &bquo;The colonialists imposed the war on us. 
 When we used the barrel of the gun, it was to facilitate the end which was the ballot box.&equo; 
 Earlier, the director of the United Nations Transitional Assistance Group (Untag), Irish-born Mr Cedric Thornberry, described the election as freer than any poll that has been held in West Belfast. 
 Mr Thornberry, who comes from Belfast, expressed two anxieties about the election: first, whether the technical arrangements made for the election would proceed smoothly; second, whether the use of symbols on ballot papers to enable illiterate voters to identify the party of their choice would work satisfactorily. 
 On the first issue, he said: &bquo;We &mdash; and the South Africans &mdash; are stretched alarmingly&hellip; stretched very thin.&equo; 
 If something did go wrong, if tempers flared and violence broke out, they could be hard put to control it.&equo; 
 The election is being administered by the South African-appointed Administrator-General. 
 It is, however, being scrutinised by UN officials. 
 Untag has 2,800 officials &mdash; including 1,100 policemen &mdash; scattered throughout Namibia to keep an eye on proceedings at 358 polling booths. 
 The symbol of each of the 10 contesting parties is printed on ballot papers for the illiterate voters who account for 60 per cent of the electorate. 
 One problem relates to a tactical blunder by Swapo. 
 It allowed a splinter party, Swapo-Democrats, to appropriate and register the symbol which Swapo used for nearly 30 years, a hand holding a flaming torch. 
 Swapo went into the election with a symbol which was only weeks old: a man with a raised fist. 
 The dangers of confusion for illiterate voters is compounded by two factors. 
 Firstly, the Swapo-Democrat emblem is placed just above the Swapo emblem on the ballot paper, meaning that it will be seen first. 
 Secondly, the raised fist in the new Swapo emblem is inconspicuous in the reduced size needed to squeeze Swapo's new symbol into the box on the ballot paper. 
 For all that, observers are unanimous that Swapo will emerge with a clear majority. 
 Its virtual monopoly on the allegiance of the Ovambo, who account for more than half Namibia's population of 1.3 million, all but guarantees Swapo more than half the voters. 
 That was conceded in an interview yesterday by Dr Kenneth Abrahams, a member of the National Front and a former Swapo man who was thrown into jail by Mr Nujoma. 
 Even if Swapo fails to get the two-thirds of the vote it needs to write its own constitution, it will have little difficulty in persuading one or another of the smaller parties to work with it. 
 It would thus still have a two-thirds majority in the constituent assembly. 
 &bquo;Some used electric sticks, some beat us over the head with handcuffs, some beat us with rifles&equo;. 
 MY religious name is XXX from XX nunnery. 
 My lay name is XXX. 
 I was born in Nyantren. 
 I am 18 years old. 
 On the evening of April 16, 1988 at about llpm we left the nunnery and stayed the night in a cave below. 
 The next morning we left for Lhasa where 12 of us demonstrated for one hour. 
 Why did we demonstrate? 
 For Tibetan freedom and for thousands of years of long life for His Holiness the Dalai Lama &mdash; and because the Chinese should leave Tibet. 
 After completing three rounds of the Barkhor we left to return to the nunnery separately. 
 On the way about 40 soldiers stopped us and we were all arrested. 
 We were taken to the XX hospital where they took many photos and asked questions. 
 We were then immediately all put into one prison vehicle. 
 We were kicked and shouted at and then thrown out of the vehicle. 
 We were then taken to Gutsa Prison. 
 There were three soldiers for every nun; they tied our hands and took us to a small room, two soldiers pushing each nun. 
 All of us were beaten very severely. 
 Then they attacked us one by one with electric sticks while our hands were handcuffed behind our backs. 
 Outside the door we were made to kneel on the ground. 
 Again there were about 30 soldiers. 
 Some used electric sticks, some beat us over the head with handcuffs, some kicked us, some pulled and pushed us, some beat us with rifles. 
 Then they tied blackboards around our necks with small, black Chinese letters on them and took photographs. 
 Then we were interrogated one by one: &bquo;Why did you demonstrate? 
 What was the aim of the demonstration?&equo; 
 I said: &bquo;First, Tibetans own Tibet and therefore the land of Tibet belongs to Tibetans. 
 Secondly, His Holiness the Dalai Lama should be given the ownership of Tibet.&equo; 
 Another question was: &bquo;Who asked you to demonstrate? 
 Who was behind you?&equo; 
 I answered: &bquo;No one asked me. 
 We came by ourselves.&equo; 
 &bquo;If no one is behind you, how do you know what to do, as you are only 18 years old? 
 Who is behind you? 
 You must tell us. 
 Tell us!&equo; 
 At this moment they beat me very badly. 
 Then I almost lost consciousness. 
 I was lying on the ground almost like a dead body. 
 At this moment about 11 people came up to me with two dogs. 
 Some of these people were on my left, some on my right. 
 They beat me with belts and electric sticks and ropes and rifles continuously for one minute. 
 Blood and white mucus came out of my mouth. 
 I could not speak although I was conscious. 
 At this moment two people grabbed me to try to make me get up but I could not get up, so they kicked me and stamped all over me from head to toe. 
 Another two or three men touched my body all over with about 11 burning cigarettes, continuously for two hours. 
 The Chinese used their belts so much that the metal buckle came off. 
 They broke a chair over me. 
 Then they had to stop for a rest because they were so tired. 
 After that dogs bit me on the feet. 
 Blood came out and my clothes were all ripped. 
 Then they took me to a room where I was in solitary confinement. 
 They gave me food with stones and yak dung, but it was still not enough and they put it in a urine container. 
 They gave me water in a small, broken cup. 
 Whenever the soldiers saw us they spat at us. 
 In the room there was no bed or mattress; nothing. 
 Every day we were interrogated and beaten. 
 I did not recover from the wounds inflicted by the dogs for two months, but because of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and kunchok sum &lsqb;Buddha, his teachings, and the monastic community&rsqb; I recovered. 
 After two months nine of us nuns were released. 
 So, from our nunnery four including me stayed in prison&hellip; 
 After eight months the Chinese said we were going to be tried, but one month before the trial we were released. 
 March 2, 1989 
 South Africa's rebel policeman sets up union. 
 By Reuter in Cape Town 
 THE rebel Coloured policeman, Mr Gregory Rockman, has formed South Africa's first trade union for police and prison warders in a renewed challenge to white authority. 
 &bquo;We are ready for any onslaught that the white authorities might try to launch against us,&equo; Mr Rockman said after the first meeting in his home on Monday of the Police and Prisons Civil Rights Union. 
 Mr Rockman, a lieutenant in the segregated Coloured suburb of Mitchell's Plain, announced the formation of the union days before a disciplinary hearing that could end his career. 
 He said that he had been charged with 10 counts of breaking police regulations by talking to reporters about police brutality. 
 A police spokesman said that Mr Rockman could face penalties ranging from a verbal reprimand to demotion or dismissal for ignoring a written gag order served on October 27. 
 He also has refused to halt publication of a book, due in December about his struggle against discrimination within the police force and by officers. 
 Mr Rockman became a folk hero in Cape Town's mixed-race suburbs after he flouted police discipline on September 6 to tell reporters about the alleged violence of white riot squad officers. 
 He said that they behaved like &bquo;wild dogs&equo; when they broke up a peaceful placard demonstration by schoolchildren, beating them with whips and clubs. 
 About 30 policemen and warders swapped stories during the inaugural meeting about discrimination and brutality in their services. 
 Warrant Officer Peter Loggenberg, a prison warder for 16 years, said he was motivated to join the union because he objected to the imprisonment of Coloured juveniles alongside adult prisoners. 
 &bquo;They are not in the same cells, but they come together in the trucks going to court and in the exercise yard where they are often subject to physical and sexual abuse,&equo; he said. 
 Several members of the prison staff said they expected to be victimised for helping to form the union. 
 PAGE 
 Communists plot survival tactics. 
 By Michael Simmons 
 THE Communists of Poland and Hungary are refusing to lie down and die. 
 Having been rejected after holding sway for so long, they are now seeking new ways of making friends and influencing people. 
 The leadership of the Polish Communist Party has this week approved changes committing it to altering its name and participating in free elections within a multi-party system. 
 It was not plain sailing and orthodox and &bquo;liberal&equo; Communists will be at each others' throats &mdash; at local level &mdash; until they hold a full congress next January to determine new policies once and for all and to approve new leaders. 
 Some party members are already disssatisfied with Mr Mieczyslaw Rakowski, who became leader only in August, for the way he went immediately to Moscow when the party was in trouble rather than work out a Polish solution. 
 According to these members, Mr Aleksandar Kwiasnewski, a &bquo;liberal&equo; who is much younger than Mr Rakowski and had a rapid rise in the last phase of the Communist government, could replace him. 
 The new party name is also a subject of debate. 
 At least 70 alternatives have been submitted, with that of Polish Socialist Labour Party the front-runner. 
 The new party would drop the old insistence on the dictatorship of the proletariat. 
 Whatever the changes, the new party could have a difficult birth. 
 It has been confirmed this week that political parties will no longer get financial subsidies, and the party urgently needs new sources of money. 
 Its newspaper, Trybuna Ludu, lost 1.7billion zloties (&pound;382,500) last year; this year it is expected to lose nearly five times as much. 
 In Hungary, Mr Karoly Grosz, general secretary until last month of the now defunct Hungarian Socialist Workers' Party (HSWP), wants to reorganise the party and start a new Communist newspaper. 
 Mr Grosz, seen by many Hungarians as a discredited hardliner, added that there was a need to propagate Communist ideas in Hungary. 
 He seems to be cashing in on the goodwill of those who regret the party's &bquo;new start&equo; last month when it renamed itself the Hungarian Socialist Party (HSP). 
 One objective of Mr Grosz is to see that the HSWP holds its party congress, as in &bquo;normal&equo; times, early next year. 
 The HSP leadership says, however, that since there is no HSWP, there can be no HSWP congress. 
 Red Star seeks tender mercy. 
 By Reuter in Budapest 
 HUNGARY'S Parliament is asking for tenders to remove a giant Communist star from the dome of the building as the country returns to multi-party democracy. 
 The Hungarian news agency MTI said yesterday that the 1.6 tonne steel star would be replaced by a weather vane. 
 Two months ago the government ordered the removal of all red stars from public buildings. 
 Since then the Communist Party has disbanded itself and all Stalinist elements have been removed from the Hungarian constitution. 
 MTI said church restorers had shown an interest in winning the contract. 
 De Klerk begins fresh round of discussions. 
 By David Beresford in Johannesburg 
 THE new South African administration of President F.W. de Klerk is holding talks across a wide spectrum of political opinion in what appears to be a fresh effort towards constitutional reform. 
 President De Klerk is expected to meet the neo-Nazi leader, Mr Eugene Terrebanche, while his Foreign Minister, Mr Pik Botha, is to hold talks in Umtata with the rebellious leader of the Transkei homeland, Maj-General Bantu Holomisa. 
 The meeting with Mr Terreblanche &mdash; &bquo;ET&equo; as he is popularly known &mdash; is seen more as a public relations gesture than a meaningful initiative. 
 The leader of the Afrikaner Weerstandsbeweging (Afrikaner Resistance Movement) has been largely discredited in far-right circles by the recent scandal over his relations with an glamorous English-language newspaper columnist. 
 He asked President De Klerk for a meeting after the National Party leader's recent talks with prominent anti-apartheid activists. 
 General Holomisa recently dealt himself into South Africa's reform game by moving towards a loose alliance with the outlawed African National congress and by announcing plans for a referendum on the &bquo;independent&equo; homeland's possible reincorporation into South Africa. 
 Mr Botha is expected to deal with both issues in Transkei tomorrow.. 
 Talks are also being held this week between two cabinet ministers and the general secretary of the South African Council of Churches, the Rev. Frank Chikane. 
 The Development Minister, Mr Stoffel van der Merwe, and the deputy foreign minister, Mr Leon Wessels, are to have talks with the church leader on the maltreatment of blacks in the Ciskei. 
 Meanwhile The South African authorities are also facing a challenge from the rebellious Cape police lieutenant, Gregory Rockman, who is setting up a police trade union in South Africa. 
 He made his announcement as his commanders prepared to begin disciplinary proceedings against him for his denunciation of racism and brutality in the force. 
 Tibetan nuns defy might of China. 
 By John Gittings 
 OUT OF the throng of Tibetan pilgrims on the sacred Barkhor street in Lhasa a few weeks ago emerged six young women in maroon gowns and bare heads. 
 The pedlars of shawls and prayer wheels and bottles of Indian hair-oil scattered, knowing what would happen next. 
 The six women &mdash; all nuns &mdash; cried out &bquo;Independence for Tibet&equo; and began to walk with short but determined steps around the clockwise circuit of the Barkhor temple. 
 They did not get far. 
 As the official indictment says, &bquo;officers on duty from the Lhasa Public Security Bureau seized them on the spot with the swiftness of a thunderbolt&equo;. 
 The nuns were charged with &bquo;splittist activity&equo; and condemned to three years' labour for being &bquo;extremely arrogant&equo;. 
 For a group of young nuns to challenge the full authority of the Chinese state, visibly expressed by the tin-hatted martial-law troops standing guard only a hundred metres away, is an act of calculated defiance. 
 In view of the treatment handed out to previous women demonstrators, it also displays remarkable courage, but it is not an isolated act. 
 The &bquo;heroic nuns&equo; &mdash; as they are described in the clandestine leaflets of the Tibetan resistance &mdash; have staged at least 12 protests in the past two years. 
 Nuns, and lay-women, were prominent in the 1959 demonstration before the Dalai Lama's flight to India, and during the 1969 Cultural Revolution. 
 The story of their latest protests is beginning to be pieced together from documents brought by travellers to Hong Kong and the West. 
 A list of the 14 nuns who demonstrated in March this year gives their ages between 18 and 32, with an average of 23. 
 Four of them were arrested. 
 &bquo;In prison they were intensively tortured, including electric sticks to the breasts and being beaten by rifles, sticks, handcuffs and chains.&equo; 
 It goes on to state that the cell had no electricity and no floor covering, the prisoners were allowed few clothes and they received only two meals a day, one consisting of a single very small momo (steamed bun) and the other of a small cup of wormy vegetables. 
 It also alleges that they were forced to put their heads into a bucket of urine and excrement. 
 Tibetan sources claim that two nuns who were seized after the March demonstrations were held in cells with male prisoners and raped. 
 One, who had an electric prod inserted in her vagina, has disappeared since their release and it is feared that she has committed suicide. 
 The written accounts suggest an array of special &bquo;female&equo; tortures, including the use of dogs, lighted cigarettes, electric prods and stripping prisoners naked. 
 One young Lhasa lay-woman, a secondary school teacher, was sentenced to two years' jail for writing a manifesto. 
 She was so badly tortured that the authorities had to send her to hospital. 
 They first extracted a written guarantee of good conduct from her uncle and aunt, who are now required to pay for the medical treatment which, if successful, will allow the woman to return to prison. 
 Nuns have been prominent in all the large demonstrations which culminated in the March 5 to March 7 demonstration this year and the imposition of martial law. 
 But they have also staged their own protests. 
 One was held in December 1987 and another five during 1988. 
 Despite the repression, seven protests have been staged so far this year. 
 It used to be possible to complete three circuits of the Barkhor before being detained. 
 Since martial law was imposed, with army checkposts everywhere, and a heavy plainclothes police presence, protests last only a few moments. 
 Nine nuns leapt on to the stage of a Tibetan opera at the Yoghurt festival in the Norbulinka Park on September 2 and were quickly seized. 
 According to more than one witness, one of the nuns had her shoulder broken. 
 Several came from Shung Sep nunnery, a day's walk from Lhasa, which had also supplied the heroic nuns of the March demonstration. 
 Another was seen later with a breast wound. 
 Others came from Ani Tsangkhang nunnery in Lhasa. 
 Although this has a militant reputation, the abbess is a Chinese appointee and nuns have been known to climb out of windows to take part in the demonstrations. 
 The nuns are young because fresh recruitment &mdash; of monks as well as nuns &mdash; was stopped during a decade of suppression and allowed only after reform in 1981 initiated by the then Communist Party secretary-general, Mr Hu Yaobang. 
 Mr Hu, whose death in April this year sparked off the student democracy movement in Beijing, was forced to resign in 1987. 
 The charges against him included that of being too soft on the Tibetans. 
 Most nuns come from the Tibetan countryside and may join the nunnery in their early teens or even when they are as young as nine or 10. 
 They reflect a tough tradition among rural women of shouldering a heavy economic burden and speaking their mind. 
 Their stand is not explicitly political, but the strands of secular and religious commitment to an independent Tibet, led by the Dalai Lama, are closely woven. 
 Women were active in March 1959 when thousands of Tibetans demonstrated in Lhasa believing that the Chinese were planning to kidnap the Dalai Lama. 
 Members of the Women's Patriotic Association &mdash; originally set up by the wife of the Chinese army general as a pro-Beijing front &mdash; gathered on March 12. 
 One participant, Rinchen Dolma Taring, wrote in her book, Daughter of Tibet: &bquo;The Lhasa women had made many anti-Chinese posters and when I joined them they were lined up around the Barkhor shouting slogans, &bquo;From today Tibet is independent&equo; and &bquo;China must quit Tibet&equo;. 
 &bquo;Our women were more fierce than our men. 
 It was frightening to walk through the Barkhor, where Chinese soldiers with machineguns were watching us from the roofs. 
 All the shops were shut and no one was on the streets except the shouting women.&equo; 
 In 1969, the destruction of monasteries and suppression of monks and nuns during the Cultural Revolution led to another desperate rising, largely unknown to the outside world. 
 Its most famous leader, according to the only available account, was a Buddhist nun who led more than 1,000 people in an attack on government offices in the western suburbs of Lhasa. 
 Defeated, the rebels fled to the mountains overlooking the Lhasa valley. 
 Blockaded by Chinese troops, the leader was captured and executed at a public meeting. 
 Some say that more people died that year than during the rebellion 10 years before. 
 The nuns' tales reveal that inhuman treatment was already standard practice before the declaration of martial law in March. 
 An Amnesty International report, published in February, documented torture of Tibetan men as well as women. 
 More first-hand accounts which have reached the Tibet Information Network in London have not been translated for lack of funds. 
 After recent mass arrests and tortures in Beijing, it has become even more difficult to claim that the government is unaware of the excesses committed in Lhasa. 
 Official doctrine, first proclaimed by Chairman Mao Zedong 40 years ago, insists that the state is entitled to use all the dictatorial weapons at its disposal to suppress its enemies. 
 In Tibet this means suppressing a growing number of brave young people whose only crime is to write a leaflet or shout a slogan. 
 The latest news from Lhasa is that six more nuns were arrested in mid-October. 
 They had committed the &bquo;counter-revolutionary crime&equo; of celebrating the Dalai Lama's Nobel Peace Prize. 
 Police yesterday arrested about 20 Tibetan women demonstrating outside the Chinese embassy and demanding independence. 
 Policemen struggled briefly with the women as they tried to get into the embassy. 
 Asset deal &bquo;could free hostages&equo;. 
 By Simon Tisdall in Washington 
 PRESIDENT Bush suggested yesterday that a US decision to return millions of dollars in frozen assets to Iran could help secure the eventual release of US hostages held in Lebanon. 
 At a White House press conference, Mr Bush said: &bquo;I carry the fate of the hostages with me every single day. 
 So of course I hope that Iran will use what influence it has to get those hostages released.&equo; 
 Asked whether the US return to the Bank of Iran of &dollar;567million held since the 1979-1980 Tehran embassy siege could become a catalyst for the freeing of the eight Americans, the President added: &bquo;They owe money&hellip; and vice versa. 
 I'd like to get this underbrush cleaned out now. 
 I think they have made some positive statements but I don't know whether it will work that way or not.&equo; 
 Mr Bush's remarks followed talks last week in The Hague between the State Department's legal adviser, Mr Abraham Sofaer, and Iranian officials, at which the return of funds was agreed. 
 The US still holds &dollar;243million to cover unresolved claims against the Iranians by North American banks. 
 Billions of dollars of Iranian assets remain frozen under former President Carter's 1979 edict. 
 A tribunal in The Hague is slowly resolving each country's claims against the other, including Tehran's demand for the return of &dollar;12billion in military equipment and spare parts which the regime says were paid for but never delivered. 
 State Department officials denied on Monday that the Iranian funds issue and that of the hostages held in Lebanon were linked. 
 But Mr Bush's remarks yesterday clearly indicated that the unfreezing of some of the assets was a gesture which certainly would not harm the hostages' prospects. 
 The Bush Administration has been extremely cautious in its relations with Iran, which has consistently denied that it controls the hostages' fate. 
 Last month, Iran's new leader, President Hashemi Rafsanjani, offered to work for the release of the American hostages held by Islamic extremists in Lebanon along with 10 other foreigners. 
 In return, Mr Rafsanjani sought the return of assets and/or help in locating three Iranians kidnapped in Lebanon. 
 US analysts speculated yesterday that Mr Bush's unscripted remarks reflected hope within the Administration that the election of the reputedly &bquo;moderate&equo; Mr Rafsanjani signalled a change of mood in Iran. 
 Tunisian leader shuts out main opposition force. 
 By Peter Hiett in Tunis 
 PRESIDENT Ben Ali of Tunisia has ruled out legalising the main opposition force in the country, the Islamic Fundamentalists. 
 The announcement came as a shock because they and other political observers had expected Mr Ben Ali to announce moves towards liberalisation in a speech he gave yesterday marking the second anniversary of his coming to power. 
 Mr Ben Ali had indicated some softening of his position towards the fundamentalists in an interview with visiting Arab journalists on Monday, saying that they had been offered the chance to open their own newspaper. 
 The President's announcement is bound to anger the fundamentalists. 
 Even standing as independents in April's elections, their candidates won about 13 per cent of the vote. 
 Only one other opposition party managed to break the 1 per cent barrier. 
 Embarrassingly for Mr Ben Ali, who likes to trumpet the virtues of Tunisian democracy, all the seats went to his own RCD party. 
 Since then, the fundamentalists have been waging a steady war on the government, at one point demanding the resignation of the Education Minister because of his plans for reforming the teaching of Islam in schools. 
 There was no comfort either in Mr Ben Ali's speech for the other opposition parties which, after their poor results in the elections, had been looking for government help. 
 There have been suggestions that they might be given state funding, or that some RCD members in the Chamber of Deputies might resign to allow the other parties a look in. 
 But Mr Ben Ali said he had already done enough for them. 
 He also told them to stop complaining about the electoral system. 
 Mr Ben Ali had a few minor constitutional changes to offer, but the absence of substantive concessions to the opposition parties has taken some of the gloss off his big day. 
 French army on catwalk for military style fashion parade. 
 By Paul Webster in Paris 
 WITH a swing in its step and pop music to match, the French army paraded its new uniform yesterday in traditional fashion-show style that hinted at love rather than war. 
 The uniform, designed more for seduction than aggression, was created by Mr Pierre Balmain who won a pre-podium skirmish with designers Lacroix, Lapidus and Cacherel. 
 Nearly 200,000 khaki uniforms will be traded in before 1991 for the Balmain number in a colour known as terre de France, a wordplay on the army's role in protecting French soil. 
 The exact shade was kept secret until yesterday's parade at the equivalent of the Army and Navy Club, but there was nothing in camouflage manuals to describe the exact tint. 
 &bquo;Perhaps it would be best described as pearly-grey with a hint of bronze,&equo; an army spokesman said. 
 &bquo;I think it's the nicest colour in any European army.&equo; 
 The relaxed style was less of a surprise because Pierre Balmain also designed the new national police uniform. 
 This replaced the jacket with a windcheater and the kepi with a Chicago-style police cap. 
 Much of the same inspiration could be seen in the army uniform, although soldiers will be allowed to choose between the kepi and a beret. 
 The uniforms were greeted with applause as nine models, including three blacks, marched along the podium. 
 The West Indians were brought in, according to the official notice, &bquo;to bring out the new colour scheme&equo;. 
 Women models displayed an air-hostess style ensemble of jacket, jupe-culotte, three-cornered hat and shoulder bag, before a series of other changes were revealed. 
 Soldiers will be allowed to abandon their jackets in the summer for the first time and wear an almond-green shirt with epaulettes. 
 Before the show, the uniforms were approved by 93 per cent of serving soldiers, but it needed a practised eye to seek out details that distinguished the new gear from smart civilian clothes. 
 The martial air, according to one general, was discreetly detectable in an apparently superfluous top pocket in the windcheater. 
 &bquo;You have to have somewhere to fix your ribbons,&equo; he said. 
 22COMMENT THE GUARDIANWednesday November 8 1989 More than just another disaster. 
 THIRTY FIVE people died and others were maimed for life in the Clapham rail disaster in December last year because work was done in a slovenly, haphazard way and was then left unchecked. 
 The disaster was all the more stunning because people had come to assume that such things didn't happen. 
 In most years, rail deaths are few: in some there are none at all. 
 Clapham, indeed, accounts for nearly half the 77 fatalities of the last ten years: compare that with the 5,000 deaths and 300,000 injuries every year on the roads. 
 Yet yesterday's report on the Clapham crash, confirming the picture which emerged throughout the Hidden inquiry, makes an event which seemed at the time totally unexpected look almost inevitable. 
 This was a system hopelessly under strain. 
 Under strain for a start because it was technically ill-equipped to avert disaster or to cope with the consequences when disaster struck; under strain from commercial pressures which, as the inquiry puts it, &bquo;compromised&equo; safety; under strain above all because the people on the spot couldn't or wouldn't cope, were weary from gruesome working hours (the senior signal technician who heads the list of the culpable had had only one day off in the past 13 weeks), lacked adequate training, or simply couldn't be bothered. 
 The bulk of the blame for all that is placed on British Rail, which knowingly permitted these things to continue. 
 Though individuals are nailed, the greatest villain of all is the system. 
 In a desperately competitive climate, where anyone bright and competent could go down the road and pick up a better paid job with kinder hours and more congenial working conditions from someone like British Telecom, the railways ran a service dependent on people who belonged to a narrow and inbred working culture, with outdated procedures of training and promotion, and an institutional reliance on overtime working, whose wholly disgraceful dimensions are symbolised by the fact that maximum weekly hours were only recently cut to 72 hours a week. 
 The Transport Secretary, Mr Cecil Parkinson, assured the Commons yesterday that financial considerations would not stand in the way of implementing Sir Anthony Hidden's 93 recommendations. 
 On the technical side, remedial work is in many cases already on the way. 
 But the job of lifting the standards of people employed, giving them proper training, and paying a wage which breaks dependence on overtime and lifts morale: this together must far exceed the costs of the technology, and it isn't by any means clear what the bill will be or where the money will come from. 
 All of which is not just a problem for a properly penitent British Rail: it's a problem for government too. 
 Government fixes the format in which BR has to work; and if, as the Hidden report attests, many of its problems today reflect lack of past planning, lack of farsighted investment, living from hand to mouth, then that is not just BR's doing. 
 Government compounds all these problems when it sets down working parameters which fail to reflect the value the country gets from a system that is run efficiently, can shift people to destinations with exemplary speed and safety &mdash; as Europe consistently demonstrates. 
 It is sad, and somewhat ominous, that so little of that should have been reflected in the sombre statement which Mr Parkinson made in the House yesterday.. 
 A service in chaos. 
 THE nation's ambulance service was in manifest chaos yesterday. 
 There was no service in London, with all 71 stations and 455 vehicles off the road. 
 The only accident and emergency relief was provided by the police, part-time St John ambulance volunteers running 20 vehicles, and the Red Cross. 
 Outside the capital, accident and emergency services were being provided in most areas, but the ban on emergency work was tightened. 
 The service was facing its biggest crisis since the ambulances came to a stop in the Winter of Discontent ten years ago. 
 Like Labour in 1979, the Conservatives have put military ambulances on standby. 
 They move in today. 
 What has gone wrong? 
 There are three key causes of the shambles: Mr Kenneth Clarke; the failure to separate emergency from non-emergency work; and the Whitley Council negotiating machinery. 
 The Health Secretary accused the unions of &bquo;posturing and pretending&equo; to run a 999 service yesterday. 
 He was right. 
 By refusing to keep open two-way radio links, the crews had effectively ended a proper emergency service. 
 The move was signalled last week and, true to their promised response, management suspended the workers involved in the disruption. 
 But &bquo;posturing and pretending&equo; went far beyond the unions. 
 Mr Clarke has been indulging in just that himself, putting up the luckless Duncan Nichol, chief executive of the health service, to take the initial flak under the pretence that the dispute is not his direct responsibility. 
 Yet it was Mr Clarke, not Mr Nichol, who was involved in the critical decisions &mdash; the cash limit for the NHS, the 6.5 per cent offer to ambulance workers (compared to seven per cent for nurses, eight per cent for doctors and nine per cent for ancillary workers); and today's introduction of military ambulances. 
 Ambulance workers on emergency work do deserve a much higher increase. 
 They have progressed far beyond routine first aid. 
 Their paramedical skills cover highly technical procedures: intubation, infusion and defebrillation. 
 The crews are able to resuscitate heart attack patients, replace fluid intraveneously after severe blood loss, and insert tubes to maintain air supplies in unconconscious casualties. 
 Yet the ambulance worker is only being offered &pound;10,000, when a fire officer is being given &pound;13,000 and a Metropolitan police constable can earn &pound;25,000. 
 But only two million out of the 20 million journeys which ambulance crews carry out each year are emergency calls. 
 Nine out of 10 are routine calls, many of which could be carried out by mini cabs. 
 Mr Duncan Nichol wants to separate the emergency from the non-emergency work. 
 He is right to pursue this line. 
 Wiltshire and Northumbria have already shown how much can be achieved. 
 The ramshackle Whitley Council negotiating machinery is the other reason why the ambulance workers have lost out. 
 Until this year, the three independent review bodies which make recommendations for nurses, doctors and the professions allied to medicine have given much higher awards than the Whitley Councils. 
 As Lord McCarthy noted some 13 years ago, the management side of the councils comprise &bquo;employers who do not pay and paymasters who do not employ.&equo; 
 A much more flexible system which would allow local managers to negotiate local rates &mdash; on a national pay spine &mdash; is needed. 
 A crisis; an agenda for reform and honesty. 
 One Mr Clarke cannot duck away from if he wants to avoid a second Winter of Discontent.. 
 Opening, closing. 
 PRINCE CHARLES is jolly good at opening things. 
 He needs to be for the next four days in Hong Kong, because he will be hard at work cutting ribbons and laying foundation stones. 
 The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology, the Hong Kong Island Divisional Headquarters of the Red Cross, the new Cultural Centre, and many more. 
 He is even re-opening the already opened Eastern Harbour tunnel and subway crossing. 
 It is all standard royal stuff, but not much help to the millions who fear that Hong Kong will not remain open after 1997. 
 The whole point of a visit to Hong Kong now, five months after Tiananmen Square, should be to declare with royal authority that Britain shares the concerns of the Hong Kong people and is determined to do something about them. 
 There was already a rather perfunctory air to the Queen's visit three years ago, as if it were just a required coda to her tour of China. 
 When the Prince and Princess of Wales quite rightly scrapped their tour of the mainland, they had the opportunity to make a contrasting point in Hong Kong. 
 Unless they can say something relevant in the next four days, the many Hong Kong critics who believe the visit is a waste of dollars will be absolutely right. 
 It did not help at all that upon arrival yesterday the royal couple instantly touched base in that comforting symbol of past British power, the Hong Kong and Shanghai Bank. 
 If there is a failure of imagination to use the royal visit creatively it will also be a failure of nerve. 
 Britain still cannot decide when to play the mandarinate game of silence with the Chinese and when to break the rules (as Beijing does all the time.) 
 The ideal tactics should be a mixture of both, but only if a clear message can be communicated to the Hong Kong people that someone is standing up for them somewhere. 
 Instead the latest developments in Sino-British relations have left them even more confused than before. 
 China claims that the Hong Kong Government recently gave a written commitment to limit the activities of the pro-democracy movement in the territory. 
 The government denies this, but has published the text of a letter from its Political Adviser to the New China News Agency (Beijing's embassy in Hong Kong) suggesting that it did. 
 In a tone of meek appeasement, the letter draws attention to the arrest by Hong Kong police of anti-China demonstrators outside the agency's National Day reception. 
 It also reminds Beijing that permission has been refused for local protesters to erect a replica Statue of Democracy on a permanent site. 
 It ends by assuring Beijing that the Hong Kong Government will have &bquo;a prudent regard for the special circumstances of Hong Kong and the interests and concerns of the Chinese Government.&equo; 
 Meanwhile the flood of letters of a very different sort from anxious Hong Kong citizens to this and every other newspaper office continues. 
 So do the Chinese press statements asserting that Hong Kong is &bquo;entirely a business between China and Britain&equo; and should not be discussed, formally or informally, at any international forum. 
 The only two Hong Kong legislators who consistently dare to speak out, Mr Martin Lee and Mr Szeto Wah, have been threatened with expulsion from the committee now drafting China's post-1997 Basic Law. 
 Our latest Foreign Secretary has yet to publicly pick up the file marked Hong Kong. 
 There is still endless dithering on how broad a &bquo;safety net&equo; Britain will extend to its citizens. 
 They may rightly feel that it is all really rather appalling. 
 Letters to the Editor 
 Black set to be US governor. 
 THE black Democratic candidate for Virginia state governor, Mr Douglas Wilder, was heading for an historic victory last night, writes Simon Tisdall in Richmond, Virginia. 
 If he wins, it will be the first time a black person has been elected to a US state governorship. 
 He is likely to be thrust into the national political limelight. 
 With 35 per cent of the precincts declaring, Mr Wilder had 51 per cent of the vote. 
 The Republican candidate, Mr Marshall Coleman, polled 49 per cent. 
 Mr Wilder won strong support among women and gained 44 per cent of the white vote, according to a CBS exit poll. 
 The poll also pointed to a clean sweep for the Democrats in elections for lieutenant-governor and attorney-general. 
 In New York, television computer projections suggested Mr David Dinkins, a Democrat, would become the first black mayor of the city, beating the Republican, Mr Rudolph Giuliani. 
 East German crisis grows after cabinet steps down. 
 By Anna Tomforde in Bonn 
 EAST Germany's embattled government resigned last night in a surprise step foreshadowing important changes in the make-up of the Communist Party's powerful politburo and policy shifts in response to continuing popular pressure. 
 The resignation of the Communist-dominated cabinet was announced at a press conference by the newly-appointed government spokesman, Mr Wolfgang Meyer. 
 As he spoke, several thousand East Germans demonstrated outside the central committee building in East Berlin where the politburo was locked in critical talks. 
 The government's resignation is the most sweeping political change in East Germany's 40-year history. 
 Commentators said Mr Egon Krenz, the new party leader and head of state, and the politburo would now have to act swiftly to call free elections as the only way out of the crisis. 
 The Bonn government said the resignation was insufficient and free elections must follow. 
 The stepping down of the government followed resignation calls from all five of East Germany's minor political parties, and from a deputy minister of culture. 
 They said the cabinet's resignation could only be a first step in an attempt to regain credibility. 
 Led by the Prime Minister, Mr Willi Stoph, aged 75, the government will continue in a caretaker role until a new cabinet is chosen. 
 The demonstrators again demanded that Mr Krenz should step down. 
 They also pressed for free elections. 
 It had become increasingly clear over the last few days that the anger of East Germans is focused on the Communist Party and that it can only be a question of time before the party has to relinquish its leading role and allow political competition. 
 The 160-member central committee today discusses changes in policy and the country's leadership. 
 The East German leadership's dilemma was underlined by mass demonstrations in a dozen cities on Monday night and the continuing flight of young East Germans yesterday through Czechoslovakia. 
 Since Saturday, 30,000 refugees have reached West Germany, crossing the border at a rate of about 200 an hour. 
 Mr Meyer implored East Germans to remain. 
 &bquo;Our Socialist fatherland needs each and every one.&equo; 
 A leading East Berlin churchman, Mr Manfred Stolpe, said he feared Mr Krenz's reform offers had already been overtaken by events and people's hopes. 
 Mr Stolpe said East Germans had recently discovered their power, and Mr Krenz had not succeeded in restoring the leadership's credibility. 
 In further pressure on East German leaders, academics at the influential Potsdam Academy sent an open letter to the central committee. 
 It said that &bquo;the party's ignorant and arrogant behaviour over the years towards reserved and moderate criticism provoked the crisis.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, there were signs last night that the Interior Ministry is about to recognise the country's biggest opposition group, New Forum. 
 For the first time last night, the official ADN news agency published a statement by the group, and a regional newspaper printed a &bquo;catalogue&equo; of New Forum demands yesterday. 
 An East German parliamentary committee yesterday dismissed a draft travel law, saying that the 30 days' travel to be granted a year in no way met people's expectations. 
 Mr Krenz has already announced the dismissal of five &bquo;old guard&equo; politburo members, including the hardline Interior Minister, General Erich Mielke. 
 But it is widely expected that further heads will have to roll if the discredited Communist Party is to retrieve the situation. 
 Challenge for Krenz, page 23 Bonn &bquo;will benefit from refugee influx&equo;, page 10 
 Army takes over in 999 dispute. 
 By Keith Harper, David Brindle and Patrick Wintour 
 TROOPS will be used to provide emergency ambulance cover in London from this afternoon in what the unions yesterday described as a political attempt by the Government to escalate the dispute. 
 Army ambulances were put on standby although government sources last night admitted they had no idea who would drive them. 
 A number of army drivers and some civilian Ministry of Defence drivers are available, but not enough to cover a 24-hour period. 
 Moreover, none of the possible drivers have any knowledge of inner London routes. 
 Health service managers fear the project will fail. 
 Union leaders said drivers would need police navigators. 
 The decision to use the army was taken by the Health Secretary, Mr Kenneth Clarke, despite the fact that ambulance staff are still offering emergency cover. 
 Mr Clarke's decision followed the suspension of 2,500 staff at 71 London stations for refusing to work normally. 
 The crews want an increase on a 6.5 per cent pay offer. 
 Ministers and unions last night said they despaired of ending the dispute. 
 A last minute attempt by the London employers to open talks this morning was turned down by union leaders. 
 Mr Duncan Nichol, the NHS chief executive, told the Guardian yesterday that the Government's negotiating position is that it wants to split the service so crews with medical skills can earn extra money and non-emergency services can be contracted out. 
 Mr Nichol said the Government wants to settle the dispute with a deal that would allow local managers to top up the pay of crews with paramedical skills in a move towards the separation of the 999 service from routine ambulance work. 
 It would give designated emergency crews the chance to achieve pay parity with firemen. 
 According to Mr Nichol, such a deal could increase pay rates in London by 30 per cent and elsewhere by 20 per cent. 
 It would be a step towards a likely decision to put non-emergency services out to contract. 
 This has already begun in some parts of the country. 
 The idea was immediately rejected by the main health service union, Nupe, which said last night the Government was trying to split the ambulance staff. 
 &bquo;We want a pay deal now to solve all our problems and a formula which would prevent us from taking action in future,&equo; a spokesman said. 
 The Government's formal negotiating stance on pay was set out by Mr Clarke, who said there was no question of increasing the general 6.5 per cent offer. 
 The troops will join the police, who were reluctantly involved yesterday after the London ambulance service said it could not cope. 
 The employers admitted troops would provide an inferior service. 
 Mr Clarke said: &bquo;I see no reason why the NHS management should give a higher offer in response to industrial action and then have to close down beds and reduce patient services to pay for it.&equo; 
 Mr Nichol, however, said there was &bquo;plenty to talk about&equo; including the idea of a local flexibility deal, put at the conciliation service, Acas, two weeks ago. 
 The proposed deal would be modelled on a settlement this year for 130,000 NHS administrative and clerical staff. 
 Mr Nichol said ambulance staff could receive pay premiums worth more than &pound;3,000, in recognition of extra training, local recruitment problems and other factors such as merit or long service. 
 Only 10 per cent of the 20 million annual ambulance journeys are emergencies. 
 At present, crews typically rotate between 999 and routine work, making it difficult to designate crews for higher pay. 
 It is the first time troops have been brought in during an industrial dispute since 1978. 
 Mr Clarke told the Commons he was doing it with great reluctance. 
 Mr Robin Cook, Labour's health spokesman, said Mr Clarke had given no good explanation for his precipitate action. 
 He advised arbitration. 
 Mr Chris Spry, for the London ambulance service, said the army's help was sought because crews were not answering radio emergency calls. 
 The police could only cover accidents, not doctors' referrals. 
 The action in London had an immediate effect elsewhere, particularly in Greater Manchester and Wales. 
 Soldiers in front line, page 3; Politics, page 6; Leader comment, page 22; Duncan Nichol interview, page 23 
 Black set to be US governor. 
 THE black Democratic candidate for Virginia state governor, Mr Douglas Wilder, was heading for an historic victory last night, according to a CBS exit poll, writes Simon Tisdall in Richmond, Virginia. 
 If confirmed, it will be the first time a black person has been elected to a US state governorship. 
 The poll of 60 voting precincts gave Mr Wilder 55 per cent of the vote. 
 The Republican candidate, Mr Marshall Coleman, polled 45 per cent. 
 Mr Wilder won strong support among women and gained 44 per cent of the white vote. 
 The poll also pointed to a clean sweep for the Democrats in elections for lieutenant-governor and attorney-general. 
 In New York, a high turnout convinced supporters of Mr David Dinkins, a Democrat, that he will succeed in his attempt to be the city's first black mayor. 
 Early exit polls suggested that he had a 10-point lead over Mr Rudolph Giuliani, a Republican. 
 News in brief: &bquo;Millions lost&equo; in Rover sale. 
 The Department of Trade and Industry may have lost millions of pounds over the sale of the Rover Group to British Aerospace, a National Audit Office report is thought to have concluded. 
 Page 24. 
 School funding campaign. 
 The National Union of Teachers has launched a multi-million pound advertising campaign to win public backing for greater investment in education. 
 Page 8. 
 Black MP on front bench. 
 The Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, has appointed Mr Paul Boateng to his front bench Treasury team, the first black MP to be given a front bench post. 
 Page 7. 
 CO2 freeze blocked. 
 Mrs Thatcher yesterday flew to the US to address the UN on the environment as Britain blocked a global freeze on carbon dioxide emissions. 
 Page 24. 
 Runcie swings synod. 
 A last-minute call for courage by the Archbishop of Canterbury yesterday pushed the General Synod to approve ordination of women priests. 
 Page 24. 
 Birmingham Six setback. 
 The Home Secretary will not reopen the Birmingham Six pub bomb case in spite of pleas by leading churchmen. 
 Page 2. 
 Nuclear safety cash loss. 
 More than &pound;20 million in research costs has been lost on an abandoned nuclear safety programme. 
 Page 2 
 Rail staff face disciplinary action as Clapham report criticises BR. 
 By Michael Smith and Alan Travis 
 DISCIPLINARY action is to be taken against 11 rail workers after the official report into the Clapham Junction train crash criticised British Rail for allowing working practices to slip to &bquo;unacceptable and dangerous&equo; levels. 
 The report by Sir Anthony Hidden QC, published yesterday, said there is a &bquo;collective liability which lies with British Rail&equo;. 
 The Director of Public Prosecutions will decide in the next few weeks if BR must face corporate manslaughter charges over the disaster on December 12 which claimed 35 lives. 
 The crash in south London was caused by faulty wiring undertaken by the 11 signal engineers and managers during the signal modernisation. 
 But Sir Anthony found no common link with later crashes at Purley and Glasgow. 
 However, the driver of a train involved in the Purley crash earlier this year has been charged with manslaughter. 
 He is due to appear in court on November 16. 
 While the report does not specifically link the disaster with cuts in government funds, ministers will be under pressure to demonstrate that safety is not being impaired by tight cash limits. 
 The results of recent behind-the-scenes attempts by Mr Cecil Parkinson, the Transport Secretary, to win extra funds from the Treasury for transport infrastructure are due to be unveiled this week. 
 The BR chairman, Sir Robert Reid, said last night the board accepted in full the findings and 93 recommendations of the Hidden report. 
 It catalogued &bquo;positively dangerous&equo; work practices, poor management, inadequate training and supervision and inherent weakness in the safety culture of BR in a list of 16 separate &bquo;relevant errors&equo; where things had gone wrong over a number of years. 
 Sir Anthony stopped short of blaming BR or the Government for creating the climate but added: &bquo;There must be a better way of doing things.&equo; 
 Mr Parkinson is to meet Sir Robert today for discussions on how to meet the &bquo;demanding schedule&equo; imposed by Sir Anthony's recommendations. 
 Mr Parkinson told the Commons yesterday that BR would be given three months to report on its progress. 
 Mr Parkinson has ordered BR to implement the safety recommendations, including installation of airline-type black boxes in rail cabs, more safety inspectors, train cab radios and research into rolling stock. 
 In a separate development, BR yesterday contacted the four rail unions asking for urgent talks on a review of pay and working practices in its signalling and telecommunications division. 
 It hopes to make a fresh attempt to limit excessive overtime, heavily criticised in the report. 
 Sir Anthony said the overtime system was &bquo;outdated and wasteful&equo;. 
 He also warned the present pay structure was failing to provide the correct size and quality of workforce. 
 Mr John Prescott, Labour's transport spokesman, condemned government transport policies, saying signalling staff cuts were a direct result of the 51 per cent cut in BR finances in the past five years. 
 Sir Anthony said BR should ensure the organisational framework exists &bquo;to prevent commercial considerations of a business-led railway from compromising safety&equo;. 
 Mr Parkinson told the Commons in response: &bquo;BR will need to consider what further expenditure will be required. 
 I can assure the House that finance will not stand in the way of implementation of the report.&equo; 
 Sir Robert last night rejected calls for his resignation and explained that 50 of the recommendations made by Sir Anthony were already in hand or implemented at an estimated cost of &pound;20 million. 
 &bquo;As I said after the accidents at Clapham and Purley, my job as I see it is to make sure that we implement all the recommendations.&equo; 
 But he also disclosed that the 11 BR employees singled out for specific criticism by the Hidden inquiry would face disciplinary action, ranging from reprimand to suspension or dismissal. 
 Ten have been moved to other jobs, including the senior signalman, Mr Brian Hemingway, who was named as being directly responsible for the faulty wiring at Clapham Junction. 
 Mr Clifford Hale, a senior employee in the signals and telecommunications division, resigned yesterday afternoon. 
 Sir Robert said Mr Hale, who had worked for BR for 30 years and was called the captain of the ship in the Hidden report, had indicated he wished to take early retirement. 
 The BR watchdog body, the Central Transport Consultative Committee, said last night it was evident the crash was caused by human error, although it became clear that arrangements for supervising and auditing the quality of work were &bquo;lamentably defective&equo;. 
 &bquo;Slipshod&equo; BR, page 5; Leader comment, page 22 
 Threat to sue by stewardess. 
 Mrs Lynn Hooper, aged 25, of Eastleigh, Hampshire, the British Airways stewardess alleged to have sold champagne to passengers, is to leave BA and accept &pound;9,500 compensation. 
 She is threatening to sue Mr Peter Owen, BA director of operations, unless he retracts a claim that the offer of her job back a &bquo;second chance.&equo;. 
 Children hurt in blast. 
 Twenty-seven schoolchildren were injured in an explosion at Hartsdown leisure centre in Margate, Kent, yesterday while watching firemen fighting a blaze there. 
 &pound;400,000 van hijack. 
 An armed man yesterday hijacked a security van and stole &pound;400,000 after his woman accomplice drove their car into the back of the Group 4 van in central London, police said.. 
 Liver patient improves. 
 The condition of the liver transplant patient Mrs Aisling Barnett has improved since she was given a Japanese drug, which is still undergoing clinical trials, to stop her body rejecting her new liver. 
 Girl snatched. 
 Police issued a nationwide alert after Emma Louise Hyde, aged six, a ward of court, was snatched from outside her school in Cheadle Hulme, Cheshire. 
 They want to trace her natural parents, Paul and Susan Gort.. 
 InkInc regains grant. 
 Sheffield University students have overturned the decision of their student union executive and voted to give a &pound;2,700 grant to the magazine InkInc, winner of this year's Guardian/NUS student media award for best magazine. 
 Waddington will vote for hanging. 
 By John Carvel Home Affairs Editor 
 THE Home Secretary has told colleagues that he expects a fresh Commons debate on the death penalty before the next election and that he would speak and vote for its restoration as a deterrent for some murders. 
 While Mr David Waddington does not intend to use his office to promote capital punishment, and will maintain the tradition of a free vote for MPs, his intervention in a renewed debate would provide the most passionate support for it from the Government front bench since it was abolished in 1965. 
 The vehicle for raising the issue again will be the Criminal Justice Bill which Mr Waddington expects to introduce in the 1990/91 parliamentary session. 
 The bill's main purpose will be to encourage non-custodial punishment in the community for less serious offenders, but ministers believe that the opportunity presented by debate on the measure will be taken to promote the cause of hanging. 
 In the Commons vote in June last year a majority of 123 was against any change, and MPs believed the issue had been settled for this Parliament. 
 Mr Waddington believes that the death penalty would offer the public protection in deterring some people from murder. 
 Whether he wants to limit the penalty to certain categories of murder or whether he favours leaving its use to the discretion of the courts and the Home Secretary is not clear. 
 He is understood to be pressing ahead with the rest of the agenda set by his predecessor, Mr Douglas Hurd, including a white paper proposing less use of imprisonment for non-violent offenders. 
 He is also expected to confirm Mr Hurd's decision to ignore the European Court's ruling against seven-day detentions under the Prevention of Terrorism Act. 
 Home Office crime statistics for 1988 published yesterday show that the peak age of offending by male offenders rose from 15 to 18, largely because fewer juveniles were charged with shoplifting. 
 Birmingham Six case stays closed. 
 By John Carvel and Paul Hoyland 
 MR DAVID Waddington, the Home Secretary, has decided not to reopen the Birmingham Six pub bombings case despite an appeal by the city's leading churchmen. 
 Mr Waddington is prepared to accept a request by Mr Gerry Collins, the Irish Foreign Minister, to discuss the case. 
 But Home Office officials indicated that, in the absence of new evidence, Mr Waddington would make it clear that he would be unable to take any initiative. 
 Campaigners for the Birmingham Six had hoped that a new Home Secretary might reconsider the convictions in the light of the discovery that the confessions of those convicted of the Guildford pub bombings had been fabricated, and the subsequent release of the four. 
 Mr Waddington is understood to take the view that the Court of Appeal last year reassessed the Birmingham confessions before concluding that they were properly taken and voluntarily given. 
 He stands by the decision of his predecessor, Mr Douglas Hurd, that there is no need for further investigation. 
 The question of whether the convictions were safe, and the need for a review to allay public anxiety in the light of the Guildford findings, is raised in a statement by the joint presidents of the Birmingham Council of Christian Churches: the Most Reverend Maurice Couve de Murville, Archbishop of Birmingham; the Right Reverend Mark Santer, Bishop of Birmingham; and the Reverend David Good, representing the Birmingham Free Churches. 
 They doubt whether the Court of Appeal would reach the same conclusion today as it had last year about the reliability of the convictions, since the Guildford case had raised questions on the adequacy of reviews of possible wrongful conviction. 
 They also note that an inquiry is being conducted into alleged malpractice by the serious crime squad of the West Midlands force. 
 &bquo;Justice is not served by even the slightest suspicion of injustice,&equo; the Rt Rev Santer said yesterday. 
 Twenty-one people were killed and 167 injured in the explosions at two Birmingham city centre pubs in 1974. 
 Kinnock reshuffle brings back Clare Short and puts more women into traditional male jobs Boateng first black to join a front bench. 
 By Patrick Wintour 
 THE Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, made history yesterday when he appointed Mr Paul Boateng to his front bench Treasury team, the first black MP to be given a front bench post in Parliament. 
 Mr Boateng's appointment was part of a reshuffle announced late last night by Mr Kinnock of his middle and junior ranking front bench spokesmen following the Shadow Cabinet elections last week. 
 Mr Kinnock also sprang a surprise by restoring Ms Clare Short to the front bench less than a year after she resigned as spokeswoman on Employment in an acrimonious row with Mr Kinnock over the party's stance on the Prevention of Terrorism Act. 
 Ms Short is to join the social security team, now led by Mr Michael Meacher. 
 Other important moves include the transfer from the Northern Ireland team of Ms Mo Mowlam, the MP for Redcar, who joins Mr Gordon Brown's new industry team as spokeswoman on City affairs. 
 Her promotion, following last week's appointment of Ms Margaret Beckett as shadow Treasury Chief Secretary, underlines Mr Kinnock's willingness to put women MPs into subject areas traditionally regarded as male preserves. 
 Mr Roger Stott, a member of the industry team moves to Northern Ireland in a straight swop with Ms Mowlam. 
 The other new appointees to the front bench are Mr Nigel Griffiths, a former whip who joins the trade and industry team, Mr Elliot Morley, the MP for Scunthorpe, who will speak on agriculture, and Mr Tony Worthington, the MP for Clydebank and sponsor of the Right of Reply bill, who joins the Scottish team. 
 Mr John Garrett, the former Industry spokesman and MP for Norwich South, has been a given a new job of trying to improve Labour's support in the South. 
 He will report directly to Mr Kinnock. 
 Mr Henry McLeish, who was a Scottish front bench spokesman, is transferred to employment under the leadership of Mr Tony Blair. 
 A total of 81 Labour MPs, including 11 women, now hold front bench posts, one of the largest numbers ever recorded. 
 No MP was dismissed in the reshuffle. 
 Attention however last night focussed inevitably on Mr Boateng's appointment. 
 The 38-year-old Methodist son of a Ghanaian cabinet Minister, Mr Boateng is a former solicitor who has become a strong supporter of Mr Kinnock's leadership since becoming an MP. 
 A GLC councillor from 1981 and chairman of its once villified Police Committee under the regime of Mr Ken Livingstone, he is one of four leftwing black Labour MPs elected in the l987 general election. 
 He enlivened his acceptance speech as MP for Brent South with the words &bquo;Brent today, Soweto tomorrow&equo;. 
 Since becoming an MP, he has used his acute brain and mischievous wit to ridicule Tory MPs. 
 His trademark is an endless supply of baggy designer suits, but his modernity belies an old fashioned belief in diligence and grasp of detail. 
 Favour was first bestowed upon him by Mr Kinnock in l987 when he was appointed to the policy review group on democracy for the individual and the community convened by Roy Hattersley. 
 Although he never made his views public, he is believed to have argued in favour of the review group supporting some form of electoral reform. 
 There was strong criticism amongst black Labour Party members last year when no black was appointed to the front bench in that year's reshuffle and again when Mr Alistair Darling, the MP for Edinburgh Central, was given the race relations brief. 
 Mr Boateng attracted some notoriety recently when he appeared on the front page of the News of the World wearing nothing but a G-string. 
 The photograph had been taken some years ago at a GLC panto. 
 &bquo;Millions lost&equo; in Rover sale. 
 The Department of Trade and Industry may have lost millions of pounds over the sale of the Rover Group to British Aerospace, according to a National Audit Office report. 
 Page 24. 
 Emissions freeze blocked. 
 Mrs Thatcher yesterday flew to the US to address the UN on the environment, as Britain blocked a global freeze on carbon dioxide emissions. 
 Page 24. 
 Black MP on front bench. 
 Mr Paul Boateng has been appointed to Labour's front bench Treasury team, the first black MP to be given a front bench post in Parliament. 
 Page 7. 
 Runcie swings synod. 
 A last-minute call for courage by the Archbishop of Canterbury yesterday pushed the General Synod to approve ordination of women priests. 
 Page 24. 
 Birmingham Six setback. 
 The Home Secretary will not reopen the Birmingham Six pub bombings case in spite of pleas by the city's leading churchmen. 
 Page 2. 
 War criminals' escape. 
 Evidence has been uncovered showing how Britain played a leading role in preventing hundreds of Italian war criminals standing trial. 
 Page 8 
 Army to take emergency calls. 
 By Keith Harper, David Brindle and Patrick Wintour 
 TROOPS will be used to provide emergency ambulance cover in London from this afternoon in what the unions yesterday described as a political attempt by the Government to escalate the dispute. 
 The decision to use the army was taken by the Health Secretary, Mr Kenneth Clarke, despite the fact that ambulance staff are not on strike. 
 They are still offering to provide an emergency service. 
 Mr Duncan Nichol, the NHS chief executive, told the Guardian that the Government's negotiating position is that it wants to split the service so crews with medical skills can earn extra money and non-emergency services can be contracted out. 
 Mr Clarke's decision followed the suspension of 2,500 staff at 71 London stations for refusing to work normally. 
 The crews want an increase on a 6.5 per cent pay offer. 
 A late night attempt to resume talks today by the London ambulance employers ended in failure just before midnight when the unions rejected the call. 
 The unions' chief negotiator, Mr Roger Poole, said earlier on television that emergency services would be guaranteed without conditions. 
 Mr Nichol said the Government wants to settle the dispute with a deal that would allow local managers to top up the pay of crews with paramedical skills in a move towards the separation of the 999 service from routine work. 
 It would give designated emergency crews the chance to achieve pay parity with firemen. 
 According to Mr Nichol, such a deal could increase pay rates in London by 30 per cent and elsewhere by 20 per cent. 
 The idea was immediately rejected by the main health service union, Nupe, which said last night the Government was trying to split the ambulance staff. 
 &bquo;We want a pay deal now to solve all our problems and a formula which would prevent us from taking action in future,&equo; a spokesman said. 
 The Government's formal negotiating stance on pay was set out by Mr Clarke, who said there was no question of increasing the general 6.5 per cent offer. 
 The troops will join the police, who were reluctantly involved yesterday after the London ambulance service said it could not cope. 
 The employers admitted troops would provide an inferior service. 
 Mr Clarke said: &bquo;I see no reason why the NHS management should give a higher offer in response to industrial action and then have to close down beds and reduce patient services to pay for it.&equo; 
 Mr Nichol, however, said there was &bquo;plenty to talk about&equo;, including the idea of a local flexibility deal, put at the conciliation service, Acas, two weeks ago. 
 The proposed deal would be modelled on a settlement this year for 130,000 NHS administrative and clerical staff. 
 Mr Nichol said ambulance staff could receive pay premiums worth more than &pound;3,000, in recognition of extra training, local recruitment problems and other factors such as merit or long service. 
 Only 10 per cent of the 20 million annual ambulance journeys are emergencies. 
 At present, crews typically rotate between 999 and routine work, making it difficult to designate crews for higher pay. 
 It is the first time troops have been brought in during a dispute since 1978. 
 Mr Clarke told the Commons he was doing it with great reluctance. 
 Mr Robin Cook, Labour's health spokesman, said Mr Clarke had given no good explanation for his precipitate action. 
 He advised arbitration. 
 The House was called to order at one stage by the Speaker, Mr Bernard Weatherill, after Mr Clarke accused crews of waiting at stations &bquo;pretending&equo; to be ready for work. 
 Mr Chris Spry, for the London ambulance service, said the army's help was sought because crews were not using their radios to answer emergency calls. 
 The police could only cover accidents, not doctors referrals. 
 He challenged the unions to lift restrictions on radios, the movement of staff between stations and the carrying of seriously ill patients. 
 If this was done, the army would not be employed. 
 The action in London had an immediate effect elsewhere as crews began to protest at the Government's intervention. 
 Greater Manchester shop stewards agreed to halt all routine work in protest against suspensions and Welsh crews promised to stage work-ins if suspensions went ahead. 
 Soldiers in front line, page 3; Politics, page 6; Leader comment, page 22; Duncan Nichol interview, page 23 
 Army needed &bquo;to aid police&equo;. 
 By Keith Harper and David Fairhall 
 THE South West Thames regional health authority requested the army be drafted in for ambulance work when it became clear the police could not cope, according to ambulance mangement. 
 Mr Chris Spry, for the London ambulance service, said the police were unable to meet the demand for accident services, particularly those phoned through to hospitals from family doctors. 
 About 50 military vehicles will supplement 53 from the police and voluntary organisations, such as the St John Ambulance. 
 The sickest patients will be carried by voluntary groups, the next by the army, with the least ill by the police. 
 The army will be based at police stations and will be allocated calls via the police. 
 Of the 103 vehicles in use, 60 will serve London north of the Thames, and 43 the south. 
 Normally the London ambulance service maintains 175 emergency ambulances on duty during the day and 75 at night. 
 All military and voluntary vehicles will be given some of London's equipment, including special orthopaedic stretchers and chairs. 
 Mr Tom Crosby, chief officer for London, agreed that the level of care would drop but insisted that the army crews had some medical training and were not basic infantry men pressed into service. 
 The unions were challenged to lift restrictions on radios, the movement of staff between stations and the carrying of seriously-ill patients. 
 If these concessions were made the army would not be employed. 
 Mr Chris Humphreys, London secretary of the National Union of Public Employees, warned that bringing in the troops would cause long delays and unnecessary suffering. 
 Army personnel did not know their way around London and would need police escorts. 
 He was sure that the army would not be welcomed by the public. 
 He said: &bquo;It is obvious that Kenneth Clarke intends to try to starve our members back to work. 
 The Government cannot pretend to be concerned with security at army barracks and then, without regard for the soldiers, put them on the streets of London as easy targets for the terrorists.&equo; 
 Management yesterday began suspending ambulance staff in retaliation to the work to rule tactics of the unions. 
 The troops' intervention in the ambulance strike is being authorised under a Whitehall arrangement which enables one department to request &bquo;military aid to the civil ministries&equo; from the Ministry of Defence and pay the bill afterwards. 
 This arrangement means there is no need for Mrs Thatcher to consider declaring a State of Emergency, as Mr Heath's government did during the 1973 miners' strike. 
 That would only be necessary if the troops had been requisitioning other people's equipment. 
 Mrs Thatcher has never declared a state of emergency. 
 Troops have been used more than 30 times since the second world war to replace striking workers. 
 During the 1970s they were called out to clear hundreds of tons rubbish from the streets of Glasgow during the 1975 dustmen's strike. 
 Two years later dozens of Green Goddess military fire engines were brought out of storage to cover the firemen's strike. 
 During Mrs Thatcher's administration, troops have found themselves involved in five industrial disputes &mdash; to operate prisons in 1980/81, to drive ambulances in 1981 and 1982, to cover for civil servants during a dispute at the Coulport submarine base in 1981, and to help with car parking during the rail strike of 1982. 
 Richard Norton-Taylor adds: Contingency plans for the use of troops in ambulance disputes were drawn up shortly after the Government came to power in 1979, Whitehall documents show. 
 They were drafted by the Ministry of Defence and Department of Health. 
 Department of Health officials wrote to regional administrators in 1980 with details of a new plan &mdash; code-named Bittern &mdash; providing for &bquo;the use of service ambulances and drivers in the event of an industrial dispute&equo; &mdash; the decision now taken yesterday by ministers. 
 Two other plans, not activated now, were also drawn up. 
 One, code-named Concord, dealt with how the armed forces would drive NHS ambulances, and the other, code-named Lionel, with a limited service in a strike involving certain ancillary workers. 
 Brittan rebuts Thatcher terms for EC progress. 
 By Michael White, Chief Political Correspondent 
 ANOTHER Conservative heavyweight was publicly aligned against Mrs Thatcher over Europe last night when Sir Leon Brittan, vice-president of the European Commission, denounced &bquo;the dangerous illusion of total sovereignty&equo; as an impediment in battles for a free-market Europe already largely won. 
 He called for British entry into the Exchange Rate Mechanism in months rather than years and the creation of a European central bank with &bquo;one pound equals &bquo;x&equo; ecus&equo; on bank notes. 
 He even envisaged the absorption of East Germany into the Twelve, not as a new state but as an &bquo;extension of the territory of an existing member&equo;. 
 As the Prime Minister reproached Mr Nigel Lawson for resigning the Chancellorship &bquo;with such suddenness and haste&equo; &mdash; and over personality not policy &mdash; her isolation was highlighted by the ex-minister whose enforced resignation in the Westland affair of 1986 is being likened by disaffected MPs to the recent sacrifice of Mr Lawson. 
 Delivering the annual Granada Lecture, Sir Leon outlined a programme for achieving a prosperous and non-bureaucratic European Community, but its main thrust amounted to a rebuttal of her highly-personalised terms for further progress towards economic and monetary union. 
 It is likely to intensify pressure for flexibility in the summit run-up. 
 &bquo;Sovereignty is not something that you either have or do not have, like a family heirloom which you take out and dust every now and then to make sure that it is still in your possession and still intact,&equo; Sir Leon said. 
 &bquo;Sovereignty, rather, is in today's world a severely practical concept&hellip; the ability to have the maximum possible say in determining one's own future, in circumstances that actually exist.&equo; 
 The former Home Secretary took common ground with Mrs Thatcher in opposing a Brussels-dominated and economically illiberal &bquo;Fortress Europe&equo; and went much further than Mr Lawson or the pro-European cabinet majority in calling for a central bank on the looser American rather than Bundesbank model. 
 But in even-handedly denouncing ardent Europhiles and Europhobes as &bquo;superannuated Sumo wrestlers&equo; he was, in effect, accusing Downing Street of being out of date &mdash; even on worker participation in industry and the Social Charter. 
 On both issues, he suggested, reality had long outstripped British rhetoric and Whitehall would do better bargaining on details than cold-shouldering the whole process. 
 Sir Leon's speech in London came as speculation bubbled away at Westminster about a possible challenge to Mrs Thatcher's leadership in the annual party election next month. 
 But the Conservative chairman, Mr Kenneth Baker, last night contrasted media talk of &bquo;a crisis of confidence&equo; with the &bquo;vote of confidence by the markets of the world&equo;. 
 Government whips discounted talk of a cabal of dissidents meeting privately last night and likely attenders were similarly reticent. 
 &bquo;Remember, it's like an occupied country for us,&equo; said one leftwing Conservative MP. 
 &bquo;People meet in cells of two or three.&equo; 
 Another backbencher, Sir Anthony Meyer, described himself as &bquo;a burnt offering&equo; who might stand against Mrs Thatcher if no one else would. 
 Unkind loyalists mocked him as &bquo;not so much of a stalking horse as a stalking donkey&equo; who would get only his own vote. 
 In the Commons Mr Neil Kinnock's demand that she tell the truth about Mr Lawson goaded Mrs Thatcher into saying: &bquo;If he had wanted to resign on a point of policy, I could have understood that&hellip; 
 But I find it totally incomprehensible that someone who has held the office of Chancellor with high standing for over six years should want to resign over a personality with such suddenness and haste.&equo; 
 Despite her entreaties he had been &bquo;determined to go and go that day&equo;. 
 The Prime Minister's hard-nosed stance to further challenges held the line with growls of loyalist support. 
 Sir Leon's was a more dangerous rebuttal. 
 Politics, page 7; Brittan on unification, page 10; Speech, page 14; Economics, page 15 
 Ministry knew of lead in milk &bquo;for weeks&equo;. 
 By James Erlichman, Consumer Affairs Correspondent 
 AGRICULTURE ministry and Milk Marketing Board officials knew for weeks that milk contaminated with lead was on sale, Whitehall sources indicated yesterday. 
 Mr John Gummer, the Agriculture Minister, said yesterday that swift action was taken last weekend after the Dutch authorities informed him that tonnes of cattle feed contaminated with lead had been shipped to Britain. 
 But it later emerged that the first of three contaminated cargoes arrived on October 5. 
 Restriction orders banning cattle movement and sale of milk and meat have now been imposed on more than 300 farms, mostly in Cornwall and Devon but also in the Midlands. 
 More than 20 animals, mostly calves, have died from lead poisoning. 
 Tests on milk have revealed lead levels of 20 parts a billion, higher than normal but within government guidelines of 50 parts a billion. 
 The milk board insisted yesterday it was not aware of any problem until last Friday. 
 But routine screening of milk for contaminants should have disclosed higher lead levels by mid-October. 
 Sources say the lead contamination was first identified by ministry and board officials in &bquo;mid to late October&equo;. 
 Rather than being thrown away, the contaminated milk was poured into tanks of clean milk to dilute the lead down to permissible levels. 
 The ministry said yesterday that it was first warned by the Dutch on November 1 that 550 tonnes of Indian rice bran contaminated with lead sulphate had come via Rotterdam to Teignmouth in Devon. 
 Fifty tonnes escaped a ministry ban and went to farms. 
 Dr David Clark, Labour's agriculture spokesman, said: &bquo;It was entirely irresponsible of the ministry to allow farmers for nearly a week to feed contaminated material to animals. 
 We suspect the problem is worse than Mr Gummer has admitted and we question why there was a delay in warning the public.&equo; 
 He called on the Government to ensure that no more contaminated meat or milk is allowed to enter the food chain and demanded that all test results be published. 
 The ministry has faced criticism for permitting the sale of milk produced by cows injected with the experimental, genetically engineered drug BST as the identity of farms and dairies taking part in the experiments is kept secret. 
 UN peace force for Central America. 
 By Jane Rosen in New York 
 THE UN Security Council voted unanimously last night to send a peacekeeping force to Central America to cut off infiltration by contra rebels, monitor elections in Nicaragua and watch over developments in other sensitive areas &mdash; especially Honduras and El Salvador. 
 This is the first time the UN has dispatched a force so close to American borders. 
 The 625-strong observer force, which will have a six-month renewable mandate, is the first in the Western hemisphere. 
 The force is also intended to block weapons shipments sent from Honduras to Salvadorean rebels. 
 The initial call for UN action came from foreign ministers of the five Central American countries last spring. 
 They asked the Secretary General to set up a group to monitor compliance with Central American commitments to halt aid to rebel movements and to prevent the use of one state's territory for attacks on other states. 
 The US finally agreed to support the force after six months of negotiations. 
 However, the American ambassador, Mr Thomas Pickering, told the council yesterday that Washington's approval was based on the assumption that the force would take steps to halt aid for Salvadorean guerrillas. 
 The force's immediate task is to ensure free elections in Nicaragua, and the Nicaraguan delegates said they expected to play &bquo;a very positive role&equo;. 
 The Nicaraguan ambassador said it should &bquo;contribute significantly to impeding the infiltration of contra forces into Nicaraguan territory&equo;. 
 The force is known as Onuca &mdash; a Spanish acronym for US Observer Group For Central America. 
 It will be composed of observers from Spain, West Germany and Canada and is scheduled to be deployed in the area by the end of the month. 
 The Secretary-General, Mr Javier Perez de Cuellar, said he would cautiously deploy the peace force in stages. 
 &bquo;The need for &lsqb;the operation&rsqb; is, if anything, greater now than before.&equo; 
 MPs postpone decision on King's Cross. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 THE King's Cross international railway terminal and property development was in the balance last night after MPs on the committee examining a private bill to approve the scheme decided to suspend a decision until December 5. 
 Their action comes three days after BR had to postpone for a year its bill to build a high-speed Channel tunnel rail link to central London. 
 The MPs had become increasingly sceptical of British Rail's demand that the bill go ahead before BR and Eurorail, the private-sector consortium, decide on the last section of the tunnel route. 
 Mr Bob Clay (Lab Sunderland N) asked what British Rail would do if it no longer ended in King's Cross and the terminal was not needed. 
 Mr Keith Welsby, a BR board member, argued that additional rail facilities would still be needed. 
 Labour filibuster move blocked Local Govt Bill. 
 Paul Nettleton. 
 THE GOVERNMENT moved last night to block a filibuster attempt by Labour MPs against the Local Government and Housing Bill which was threatening to extend Commons business into the small hours. 
 After lengthy backbench Opposition speeches had stretched out discussions, a government whip just after 11pm moved closure of debate, which Mr Bob Cryer (Lab. 
 Bradford S) condemned as &bquo;a deliberate act of censorship of the House of Commons.&equo; 
 The first vote of the evening was taken just before 10pm on a Labour amendment to keep down rises in council rents, and was lost by 289 votes to 201 (Government majority 88). 
 It was preceded by lengthy backbench Opposition speeches which prompted Mr Christopher Chope, junior environment minister, to point out that he was the first government speaker for some four hours. 
 Mr Chope argued that Labour MPs had misunderstood the implications for council rents of changes to the way the Government provides subsidies. 
 For Labour, Mr Clive Soley said that there was a housing crisis, with people being squeezed between the collapse of the housing market under the weight of mortgage interest rates, and the Government's failure properly to maintain the council housing stock while forcing councils to increase rents. 
 Serb accuses &bquo;war culprit&equo;. 
 LORD Aldington was yesterday pointed out in the high court as one of the &bquo;culprits&equo; guilty of sending thousands of Yugoslavs to their deaths in l945. 
 Dusan Zivkovic, aged 65, a Yugoslav Serb who was handed to the communists by the British but managed to escape, said he had come to court to find the culprits and &bquo;nail the bastards&equo; who had sent his fellow countrymen to their deaths. 
 Mr Charles Gray, QC, Lord Aldington's counsel, asked: &bquo;Have you come here to nail the bastards or to help to discover the truth?&equo; 
 Mr Zivkovic replied: &bquo;Are you saying I was not sent to my death?&equo; 
 Pointing at Lord Aldington across the courtroom, Mr Zivkovic said: &bquo;I don't know whether he is guilty. 
 Does he feel guilty? 
 I think he is guilty. 
 &bquo;My daughters said I should come here to help clear this thing up, to find who really did this because unless it is cleared up then history will say that we were sent to our deaths by Britain, and that means the British people and the British army and they don't deserve that because it is out of character.&equo; 
 Mr Gray said: &bquo;Don't poke your finger at Lord AldingtonDid you come here to nail him?&equo; 
 Mr Zivkovic: &bquo;I think he is guilty.&equo; 
 Mr Gray: &bquo;On what evidence?&equo; 
 Mr Zivkovic, who was asked by the judge to be more polite, said: &bquo;I think he is guilty if he was chief of staff of V Corps at the time of the handing over. 
 Someone must have sent the papers and I can't see that the corporals did it. 
 I lost 28 men, simple peasants who had never heard of Karl Marx or Toby Low.&equo; 
 Mr Zivkovic, a draughtsman who lived in Britain for 24 years after the war but now lives in Tasmania, Australia, was giving evidence for the defence in Lord Aldington's libel action over allegations by Mr Nikolai Tolstoy and Mr Nigel Watts that he is a war criminal responsible for the forced repatriation of 70,000 Cossacks and Yugoslavs. 
 Earlier, Mr Zivkovic, who was born in Croatia and witnessed the German and Italian invasions in 1941, said: &bquo;The Germans destroyed my country&hellip; they killed thousands of people. 
 The invasion was deadly, merciless and cruel.&equo; 
 The Slovenes were a &bquo;small nation being squeezed between Italy and Germany. 
 But if you did not &bquo;love&equo; the Germans then you had had it.&equo; 
 It made no sense for the British army to hand over Yugoslav royalists to Tito's communists, he said. 
 The hearing continues today. 
 War criminals kept from trial, page 8 
 Labour loses final bid to curb donations. 
 THE Government whipped its supporters into the Lords last night to defeat a final attempt by Labour to give shareholders the right to decide on company donations to political parties. 
 By 223 votes to 110 (Government majority 113) peers rejected an Opposition amendment to the Companies Bill, originally passed by the Lords but rejected later in the Commons. 
 This insisted that shareholders sanctioned such donations before they were made instead of only being able to discuss them afterwards. 
 Lord Williams of Elvel, Labour's trade and industry spokesman, said trade unionists could contract out of paying a political levy but shareholders could not contract out of paying a donation. 
 Lord Young, the deputy chairman of the Conservative Party, who piloted much of the bill through the Lords when he was Trade and Industry Secretary, said: &bquo;This amendment is only a mischievous attempt to gain party political advantage.&equo; 
 It would make the conduct of business more difficult. 
 Lawson resignation &bquo;incomprehensible&equo; Question time. 
 Martin Linton. 
 THE Lawson affair rumbled on in the Commons yesterday with the Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, asking the Prime Minister why she did not &bquo;tell the truth&equo; when she was asked why the former Chancellor of the Exchequer resigned by television interviewer Brian Walden. 
 The answer she gave was not that she didn't know Mr Lawson's stated reason for resigning, but that she found it incomprehensible. 
 &bquo;If he had wanted to resign on a point of policy, I could have understood that. 
 Policy is a matter for ministers,&equo; she said at question time. 
 &bquo;But I find it totally incomprehensible if someone has held the office of Chancellor with high standing for six years to want to resign over a personality &mdash; with such suddenness and haste.&equo; 
 The clash came as Mr Kinnock exploited the apparent contradiction between Mrs Thatcher's claim that she did not know why Mr Lawson resigned and the former Chancellor's assertion in last Sunday's Walden interview that he had made it quite clear to the Prime Minister that Sir Alan Walter's continued presence as her economic adviser was the only issue. 
 Mr Kinnock said: &bquo;You appear to be the only person left in the country who does not understand why the Chancellor resigned. 
 &bquo;Isn't the truth that the Chancellor said to you &bquo;either the adviser goes by the end of the year or I go now&equo;? 
 Why can't you admit to that truth?&equo; 
 Mrs Thatcher replied: &bquo;Policy is a matter for ministers &mdash; advice is not.&equo; 
 She added, referring to the two meetings she held with Mr Lawson on the afternoon before he resigned: &bquo;I tried to persuade the Chancellor not to go. 
 It was quite clear he was determined to go and go that day.&equo; 
 Mrs Thatcher later parried more questions when the Liberal Democrat Mr Charles Kennedy (Ross, Cromarty and Skye) asked her whether she felt her &bquo;diminishing credibility&equo; would be salvaged if she followed the advice of the former chairman of the Tory backbench 1922 Committee, Sir Edward du Cann, that a leadership challenge would clear the air. 
 &bquo;In the event of such a development does she think her position would be unassailable?&equo; he asked &mdash; echoing the Prime Minister's earlier comment that Mr Lawson's position was &bquo;unassailable&equo;. 
 But Mrs Thatcher retorted: &bquo;A party that can't even decide its name is hardly in a position to criticise anyone.&equo; 
 The Prime Minister has again denied that there had been any direct British assistance to the Khmer Rouge in Cambodia. 
 In a letter to Mr Kinnock released last night, she said: &bquo;You ask about support for the Khmer Rouge. 
 The Government's repugnance for that organisation and everything it stands for has been made absolutely clear on repeated occasions. 
 No form of British assistance, military or otherwise, has been, or will be, given to the Khmer Rouge.&equo; 
 But she did not reply directly to Labour's allegations that the Government had provided aid to others who were supporting the Pol Pot forces. 
 High cost of taking the strain Wednesday People. 
 Dennis Barker. 
 FIVE children lying bloody and broken in the road below a high tenement window in Glasgow helped substantially reinforce ambulanceman Jack Kirkland's belief that his colleagues should be treated as dedicated professionals and not as cab drivers. 
 Apolitical and never the holder of any union office, Kirkland had 36 years as a Glasgow ambulanceman before he retired last year. 
 He has sent to the Prime Minister and the Cabinet and Shadow Cabinet a copy of his book on his experiences. 
 Blue Lights and Bandages, just published at &pound;5.95 by the non-profit-making community publisher Seanachaidh and funded by Strathclyde council, asks the Government to remedy the neglect of past governments by recognising ambulancemen's right to a professional salary. 
 Yesterday he backed their case with the story of those children lying in the street. 
 &bquo;A woman had taken some children playing in the road up to a high room to &bquo;see her puppies.&equo; 
 She locked the door and started throwing each out of the window. 
 There were five of them; the sixth escaped when a man broke the door down. 
 &bquo;The five children were lying in the street. 
 Women were crying and some labourers were crying too. 
 But ambulancemen have to remain calm when everyone else is the opposite. 
 One little girl was squashed like a tomato, but we got the other four into an ambulance and they survived. 
 This is the emotional strain ambulancemen have day in, day out.&equo; 
 Kirkland claimed that vehicles, equipment, and training had all improved since he started, but the attitude to ambulancemen had not. 
 He has family experience to back this claim. 
 His grandfather was in the service; so was his uncle and two younger brothers; a nephew is still serving. 
 &bquo;After the Lockerbie disaster there were policemen who had to leave work. 
 But never a mention of the ambulancemen and women.&equo; 
 What was the way out? &mdash; &bquo;For the Government to relent to public opinion for once. 
 You are talking about 2 or 3 per cent, and the Government are putting people's lives in jeopardy.&equo; 
 Greenhouse gas freeze blocked. 
 By Paul Brown Environment Correspondent 
 BRITAIN was yesterday accused of undermining international efforts to combat the greenhouse effect, as Mrs Thatcher flew to New York to declare to the United Nations her concern about the environment and reveal a number of British initiatives. 
 Mrs Thatcher will today announce that she is to double the British contribution of &pound;3 million to the UN Environment Project in Nairobi and give new money to tropical rain forest schemes. 
 She is expected to place great emphasis on Britain's contribution to controlling the hole in the ozone layer and global warming. 
 But at a 72-nation conference in the Netherlands yesterday, Britain, the United States, Japan and the Soviet Union, which between them emit 50 per cent of the world's carbon dioxide, blocked a proposed freeze on emissions of the gas by the year 2000 and a 20 per cent reduction by 2005. 
 Instead, Mr David Trippier, the environment minister, insisted the target dates should be dropped as unrealistic and the words &bquo;as soon as possible&equo; substituted. 
 He said a number of large economies found it difficult to commit themselves to targets which had not been properly explored and before the International Panel on Climate Change reports scientific evidence next year. 
 This panel, with three committees chaired by Britain, the US and Soviet Union, is examining the evidence for the UN before recommending how to reduce gas emissions. 
 Environmental groups believe that because the big industrial nations control these committees and are anxious to avoid curbs on industry and car use, they are using this scientific research as an excuse for taking no action. 
 Mr Steve Elsworth, Greenpeace air pollution campaigner, said: &bquo;Britain's contribution at the Dutch conference was to undermine efforts to set any date or make any real targets to deal with global warming. 
 Mr Trippier then claims the conference as a success, which clearly it is not. 
 Britain is all talk and no action. 
 It is an internationally co-ordinated public relations exercise with no solid content in it.&equo; 
 Mrs Thatcher will today emphasise the central role of the UN in global environmental issues. 
 She will attack the Hague declaration, a French initiative signed on March 12, this year, where 24 heads of state proposed a UN agency empowered to impose sanctions on governments that did not reduce emissions of greenhouse gases. 
 Britain and the US ignored the conference. 
 Mrs Thatcher argues that sanctions are not the right course and only consensus will work. 
 This week, at the International Timber Trade Organisation's conference in Japan, Britain was supported by green groups when it suggested a labelling scheme for tropical hardwood so consumers could choose products manufactured from sustainable timber reserves. 
 But the initiative was rejected by the countries where tropical forests are being indiscriminately felled for quick cash profits. 
 Mrs Thatcher has now rejected the ITTO as the international forum to save the tropical forests, instead throwing her support behind the UN's Tropical Forest Action Plan being run from Rome. 
 This project gives advice to Third World countries on how to manage their farming, forestry and agricultural needs. 
 Mrs Thatcher has been convinced by her Environment Secretary, Mr Chris Patten, from his days at overseas development that there is an important role for Britain to play in helping countries like Brazil to manage its forests correctly. 
 &bquo;Millions lost&equo; by DTI in Rover sale. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 ALLEGATIONS that the Department of Trade and Industry may have lost the taxpayer millions of pounds over the sale of the Rover Group to British Aerospace are to be made by the National Audit Office, Parliament's financial watchdog. 
 A report to be published later this month is understood to detail a series of shortcomings in the rushed sale of the motor company to the group which was approved by Lord Young, the former Trade Secretary. 
 The company, with plants in the West Midlands, Oxford, Glasgow and Llanelli in south Wales, was sold for &pound;150 million which British Aerospace later recouped by floating its half share of DAF-Leyland on the stock market. 
 The report &mdash; which examines the civil servants' handling of the sale &mdash; is understood to question why British Aerospace was the only main bidder where detailed and full inquiries were made. 
 It also looks at the potential profits which British Aerospace may be able to make by selling redundant sites in Llanelli, Bathgate in Glasgow and the Cowley plant in Oxford which is due to close in the 1990s. 
 Whitehall sources indicated last night that the scale of the criticism in the report dwarfs the recent furore following the National Audit Office's investigation into the sale of land in Enfield, north London &mdash; owned by the Royal Ordnance Factories &mdash; to British Aerospace. 
 In this case, a row started over land worth &pound;3.5 million being possibly resold for more than &pound;30 million once the development potential of the closed factory sites had been realised. 
 Mr Terry Davis, Labour MP for Birmingham Hodge Hill, told the Guardian last night: &bquo;As a former employee of British Leyland and now a member of the Commons public accounts committee, I pressed for an inquiry into the sale. 
 &bquo;Although I have not seen the report, it does not surprise me that the Rover Group was sold for a song. 
 I believe the company was sacrificed. 
 &bquo;I shall be demanding that we have a full explanation from Department of Trade and Industry officials when they appear before the public accounts committee to be cross-examined on this report on December 4.&equo; 
 British Aerospace has already admitted that Rover's assets were undervalued by &pound;350 million at the time of the takeover. 
 The Government wiped out all Rover's debts as part of the deal, despite the company's annual profits of &pound;100 million. 
 Why Nigel just had to go Points of Order. 
 By Ian Aitken 
 POINTS of Order couldn't help visualising the scene in Number 10 Downing Street a week last Thursday, when the lad from next door burst in to say his piece. 
 If all the subsequent television and newspaper interviews are to be believed, the boy Lawson told Mrs Thatcher that he jolly well wasn't going to stay on as Chancellor unless she fired that rotter Walters as her &bquo;adviser&equo;. 
 The lad's message was quite clear. 
 It was: &bquo;Either he goes or I go&equo;. 
 And it is now equally clear that Mrs Thatcher's response to this ultimatum was similarly direct. 
 It could be summarised as: &bquo;In that case, Nigel, why don't you **** off. 
 And while you're at it, take your 7.6 per cent inflation rate with you.&equo; 
 There have been horrified reactions to this event. 
 Many people say that it demonstrates Mrs Thatcher's deplorable indifference to the relative importance of a senior Cabinet colleague and a mere half-cock academic adviser. 
 It shows, they claim, that she prefers personal favourites to ministers. 
 BUT suppose she'd reacted differently. 
 Suppose she hadn't invited Mr Lawson to **** off. 
 Suppose she'd said: &bquo;Dear Nigel, of course you must have your way. 
 Sir Alan will be fired before the goose gets fat. 
 You, and your 7.6 per cent inflation rate, and your 15 per cent interest rate, and your &pound;20 billion trade deficit, have my fullest confidence. 
 You must remain my Chancellor.&equo; 
 Would Mr Lawson then have resisted the temptation to trundle round his Cabinet colleagues, showing off his muscles and boasting that he alone had faced up to the Iron Lady and won? 
 And if he had made that boast, would it have remained privy to the colleagues? 
 And once it was out, where would Mrs Thatcher's authority have been? 
 BUT there are two further aspects to this affair. 
 For a start, didn't Mrs Thatcher have some justification for concluding that Mr Lawson had deliberately chosen the Walters row as an excuse for abandoning ship? 
 Certainly his resignation ensures that he will be in the clear when the economic roof falls in &mdash; an event which many people now regard as virtually inevitable. 
 The second aspect is the extent to which recent events prove that politicians should avoid expressing the obvious, because it always leads to trouble. 
 Take, for instance, the brouhaha which has followed Mrs Thatcher's hint that she will probably retire sometime between the next general election and the one after that. 
 This was made the payoff in the Sunday Correspondent's interview with the PM, though it has since emerged that the sequence of the conversation was altered. 
 But the weird thing about this supposedly &bquo;shock admission&equo; is that everyone made the most dreadful fuss when she said she intended to &bquo;go on and on and on&equo;. 
 Now she says that she won't go on for ever. 
 Result: an even more dreadful fuss. 
 Yet by normal standards her cautious words &mdash; she's 64, after all &mdash; were no more than simple common sense. 
 Just think what the reaction might have been if she's responded by saying she had no plans to quit. 
 Ever. 
 The same applies to poor Mr Peter Brooke's weekend remarks about the possibility of talking to Sinn Fein, if and when the IRA renounces the armed struggle. 
 Is there anyone who believes in a military victory over the IRA? 
 Yet the purest common sense proves, in the hypocritical world of Westminster, to be highly damaging. 
 KENNETH Clarke appears to have dropped out of the smart betting for the succession to Mrs T, no doubt because he has been landed with the mucky end of the Cabinet stick. 
 There aren't many votes in biffing the BMA, let alone ambulancemen. 
 But no news is good news, and Mr Clarke has been drawing some comfort from the fact that he hasn't heard from his own local family doctor. 
 Being in rude good health, he hasn't actually met the GP in question. 
 But he reckons he must be sympathetic, because he hasn't sent one of the BMA's pro-forma protest letters. 
 Yet. 
 FINGS ain't wot they used to be department: The recent ministerial reshuffle has stripped the rather snobby Home Office of three Old Etonians &mdash; Hurd, Renton and Hogg. 
 In return, it has acquired two lawyers &mdash; Waddington and Mellor &mdash; plus a Wykehamist peer, Lord Ferrers. 
 Is this a fair swap? 
 Army to take emergency calls. 
 By Keith Harper, David Brindle and Patrick Wintour 
 TROOPS will be used to provide emergency cover in London from 2pm today in what the unions yesterday described as a &bquo;political&equo; attempt by the Government to escalate the ambulance dispute. 
 The decision to use the army, even though ambulance crews are not on strike but still offering to provide an emergency service, was taken by Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, as Mr Duncan Nichol, the National Health Service chief executive, told the Guardian that the Government's negotiating position included a desire to offer extra pay to paramedical crews. 
 Mr Clarke's decision followed the suspension of 2,500 ambulance crew members at 71 London stations for refusing to work normally. 
 The crews want an increase on a 6.5 per cent pay offer. 
 Mr Nichol said that the Government wants to settle the dispute with a deal that would allow local managers to top up the pay of crews with paramedical skills in a move towards the separation of the 999 service from routine ambulance work. 
 It would give designated emergency crews the chance to achieve their goal of pay parity with firefighters. 
 According to Mr Nichol, such a deal could increase pay rates in London by 30 per cent and elsewhere by 20 per cent, and would be a step toward a &bquo;likely&equo; decision to put non-emergency services out to contract. 
 This has already begun in some parts of the country, including Wiltshire. 
 The idea was immediately rejected by the main health service union, Nupe, which said last night that the Government was trying to split the ambulance staff. 
 &bquo;We want a pay deal now to solve all our problems and a formula which would prevent us from taking action in future.&equo; 
 The Government's formal negotiating stance on pay was set out by Mr Clarke, who said there was no question of increasing the general 6.5 per cent offer. 
 Mr Clarke said: &bquo;I see no reason why the NHS management should give a higher offer in response to industrial action and then have to close beds and reduce patient services to pay for it.&equo; 
 Mr Nichol, however, said there was &bquo;plenty to talk about&equo; including the idea of a local flexibility deal, which was put at the conciliation service Acas two weeks ago. 
 The idea would be modelled on a settlement this year for 130,000 NHS administrative and clerical staff. 
 Mr Nichol said ambulance staff could receive pay premiums worth more than &pound;3,000, in recognition of extra training, local recruitment problems and other factors such as meritorious or long service. 
 Only 10 per cent of the 20 million annual ambulance journeys are emergencies. 
 At present, crews typically rotate between 999 and routine work making it difficult to designate crews for higher pay. 
 Today will be the first time troops have been brought in during an industrial dispute since 1978. 
 Mr Clarke told the House of Commons that he was doing it with the great reluctance. 
 The House was called to order at one stage by the Speaker, Mr Bernard Weatherhill, after Mr Clarke accused crews of waiting at stations &bquo;pretending&equo; to be ready for work. 
 Mr Robin Cook, the shadow Health Secretary, who advised the Government to call in the arbitrators rather than the army, said that Mr Clarke had given no good explanation for his precipitate action. 
 The troops will join the police, who were reluctantly involved yesterday after the London Ambulance Service said that it could not cope. 
 The employers admitted the troops would provide an inferior service. 
 Mr Chris Spry, for the London Ambulance Service, said the army's help was sought because crews were not using their radios to answer emergency calls. 
 Mr Roger Poole, the unions' chief negotiator, said the Government was putting Londoners' lives at risk. 
 All ambulance crews would continue to stand by at their stations for 999 calls. 
 &bquo;This is a crass decision by Mr Clarke and the Government is playing a dangerous game.&equo; 
 The action taken in London had an immediate affect elsewhere as ambulance crews began to protest at the Government's intervention. 
 Greater Manchester union officials agreed to halt all routine work in protest against suspensions, and Welsh crews promised to stage work-ins if suspensions went ahead. 
 Soldiers in front line, page 3; Leader comment, page 22; Duncan Nichol interview, page 23 
 Runcie plea pushes synod to back women priests. 
 By Walter Schwarz, Religious Affairs Correspondent 
 ALAST-MINUTE call for courage by the Archbishop of Canterbury yesterday pushed a tense and hesitant General Synod into a vote that clears the way for ordination of women priests. 
 The proposal will be debated in dioceses before being returned to the synod for final approval in 1991. 
 The vote, which excludes ordination of women as bishops, needed only a simple majority. 
 But final approval in 1991 will require a two-thirds majority in all three houses &mdash; bishops, clergy and laity. 
 Yesterday's majority, 323-170, failed to achieve that in any. 
 A split was avoided when the synod rejected proposals to allow a separate church of those who refused to accept women priests. 
 Nerves were calmed when Dr Robert Runcie said ordaining women was &bquo;development rather than revolution&equo;. 
 Another sharp prod came from the Bishop of Durham, Dr David Jenkins, who said women should not be the victims of &bquo;political voting&equo; by members who cared more about church divisions than justice for women. 
 He said such voting &bquo;makes women bear the burden of a political judgment. 
 I believe this to be indecent and to add to the already indecent burden women are having to bear.&equo; 
 The role of Dr Runcie, who has wavered in the past, was crucial. 
 Supporters of women priests feared his recent talks in Rome might have swung him into opposition. 
 But he said Roman Catholics and Anglicans &bquo;have to accept, for the moment, our different ways of reaching decisions&equo;. 
 The vote came five years after the synod called for draft legislation to introduce women priests. 
 A first draft, giving the clergy powers to block women priests, frightened members &mdash; including Dr Runcie &mdash; and risked a split. 
 Dr Runcie then proposed a committee of bishops modify the rules. 
 Dr Runcie said the new rules &bquo;tried to steer a course between what I described as legislative schism and a measure which would reduce to second class membership those who find themselves unable to recognise women priests&equo;. 
 Opponents kept a low profile and their leader, Dr Graham Leonard, Bishop of London, remained silent. 
 The opponents included Mr John Gummer, a synod member, who said: &bquo;For many of us this is a matter of life and death. 
 If this is passed some of us will no longer be active.&equo; 
 The Venerable David Silk, Archdeacon of Leicester, summing up the theological opposition, said that in ordaining women the Church of England would &bquo;cease to be part of the Catholic, apostolic church and would be behaving as if it were the whole of Christianity, or a mere sect&equo;. 
 Some opponents said later that since none of the houses managed a two-thirds majority, prospects for success in 1991 were thin. 
 But supporters were confident that decisive endorsement in the dioceses would create a new climate. 
 Vote paves way, page 2 
 News in brief: Ferries held up by gas leak. 
 Shipping, including Isle of Wight ferry and hydrofoil crossings, was halted on Southampton Water last night after inert gas leaked from the tanker Mobil Petrel as it discharged crude oil at the Fawley Esso oil refinery. 
 Firemen dealt with the leak, and there were no casualties. 
 The gas, from the ship's boilers, is used to fill the tanks as crude oil is pumped out. 
 &pound;21,000 in birth case. 
 Mrs Margaret Ashton, aged 30, who woke during a caesarean operation in 1980 at Billinge hospital, near Wigan, was awarded &pound;21,000 agreed damages at the High Court in Manchester. 
 Cell death ruling soon. 
 A High Court judge reserved judgment until later this week on a damages claim by the family of Paul Worrell, aged 21, who hanged himself at Brixton Prison, London, in 1982. 
 Banks' appeal date set. 
 An appeal by banks against last week's High Court ruling that Hammersmith and Fulham borough council's speculations with rates cash were illegal will be heard from January 15. 
 Panther alert. 
 Police are searching Ollersett Moor in the Derbyshire Peak District after a farmer reported seeing a panther in his field. 
 Overtime and pay concern prompts call for urgent talks. 
 By Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 BRITISH Rail has called on four rail unions to agree plans to limit excessive overtime worked by signals and telecommunications engineers as part of a radical review of pay and working conditions following the disaster. 
 The unions were invited to urgent talks in a letter yesterday. 
 Mr Nick Mitchell, the head of personnel for the signals and telecommunications section, said the board had come to certain conclusions about pay and conditions for its 7,000 S&amp;T engineers after a review of manpower and reward systems. 
 &bquo; 
 The point has now been reached where we need to finalise this work.&equo; 
 A crippling recruitment and retention crisis has seen BR lose vital engineering staff to better paid jobs for example in British Telecom and Mercury, where senior technicians' rates are up to &pound;60 a week more. 
 BR has had to rely on staff working excessive overtime to carry out maintenance and repair work. 
 Pay rates, overtime &mdash; central issues in this summer's pay dispute &mdash; and repeated restructuring of the S&amp;T division, are attacked in Sir Anthony Hidden's report. 
 BR accepts that measures imposed in mid-1988 to ease staff retention problems have failed. 
 Grading was simplified then and S&amp;T staff were offered an extra &pound;1,200 a year in skills allowances subject to satisfactory attendance and working, but skills shortages continue. 
 Mr Jimmy Knapp, general secretary of the National Union of Railwaymen, said yesterday that BR had since moved to stem excessive overtime by ordering a maximum working week of 72 hours. 
 The basic week is 39 hours. 
 He went on: &bquo;BR have not talked to us about limiting overtime, but it says a lot about the industry when limiting shifts to 12 hours a day is considered progress.&equo; 
 The consequence of the reduction had been to put resignalling work around Waterloo &mdash; which led to the Clapham disaster &mdash; two months behind schedule. 
 BR said it had taken steps to control overtime and to ensure engineers were taking breaks in the hard pressed Southern Region, where skills shortages are most acute. 
 On pay the Clapham report said it was &bquo;abundantly clear&equo; that pay levels had failed to provide BR with the &bquo;overall size, structure and quality of workforce&equo; it needed. 
 &bquo;Constraints on recruiting are constraints on safety and have to be removed.&equo; 
 The report also criticises the rail unions for &bquo;entrenched resistance to change&equo;. 
 Evidence, particularly Mr Knapp's, proved &bquo;how deep was the mistrust and suspicion employer had for union and union had for employer&equo;. 
 The BR chairman Sir Robert Reid told a press conference in London yesterday: &bquo;I accept all the inquiry's recommendations here and now. 
 We have taken steps to ensure that the circumstances that led to this tragedy can never be repeated.&equo; 
 British Rail is investigating the role of temporary hand-signalling in a head-on crash between two trains at Huddersfield which injured 17 people on Monday night. 
 No one was badly hurt in the accident between a trans-Pennine service and a local commuter train on track where modernised signalling is being installed. 
 Two newspapers appeal against Spycatcher book convictions for contempt. 
 TWO national newspapers, the Independent and the Sunday Times, yesterday asked the Court of Appeal to quash their convictions last May for contempt of court in publishing extracts from the Spycatcher book while a ban was in force against two other papers. 
 The contempt proceedings began in 1987 when the Attorney-General, Sir Patrick Mayhew, alleged that the newspapers' conduct in publishing material from Spycatcher, the memoirs of former MI5 officer Peter Wright, was intended, or was likely to, thwart the publication ban obtained by the Government in July 1986 against the Guardian and the Observer. 
 Mr Richard Aikens, QC, for the Independent, said that ironically the subject matter had now been held by the House of Lords not to have been confidential, in the sense that in October last year the Law Lords refused to grant permanent injunctions against the Observer and the Guardian, ruling in favour of freedom of speech. 
 Mr Aikens said that to prove contempt the Attorney-General had to establish that the published information was confidential. 
 It had to be proved that the papers had put into the public domain information which was not already there and which, in the context of the present case, it was in the public interest should not be there. 
 That was the test applied in October 1988. 
 The Attorney-General also had to establish that the information complained of was the subject matter of the pending action against the Guardian and the Observer. 
 Further, he had to show that the publication had the effect of destroying the subject matter and so depriving him of his rights in advance of trial. 
 The &bquo;touchstone&equo; would be if the Attorney-General was less able, by virtue of the actions of the Independent, to obtain or continue an injunction against the Guardian and the Observer. 
 Mr Aikens submitted that the Attorney- General did not attempt to establish any of those requirements. 
 The striking fact was that his ability to obtain or retain interlocutory injunctions against the Guardian and the Observer was &bquo;wholly unaffected&equo; by the Independent's publication of Spycatcher material in April 1987. 
 The proof the pudding was in the eating. 
 The Lords had initially upheld the interlocutory injunctions although the House subsequently refused to make the injunctions permanent. 
 The hearing continues. 
 Coleridge biography in the running for &pound;20,250 prize. 
 By Tim Radford Literary Editor 
 ANEW study of the poet of Xanadu and The Ancient Mariner has won the Whitbread Biography of the Year prize, earning its author &pound;1,750 and leaving him in the field for the Book of the Year &pound;20,250 prize, to be announced on January 24. 
 He is Richard Holmes, biographer also of Shelley, whose Coleridge: Early Visions has just been published by Hodder and Stoughton (&pound;16.95). 
 He took the award from a field dominated by studies of early 19th century poets. 
 Other contenders were Stephen Gill, for Wordsworth: A Life (Oxford), and William St Clair for The Godwins and the Shelleys (Faber). 
 The only non-literary life was One of Us, a &bquo;an elegant, shrewd, and wry analysis&equo; of Mrs Thatcher by the Guardian's Hugo Young. 
 In 1988 the Whitbread Novel of the Year was Salman Rushdie's The Satanic Verses. 
 This year, having described Martin Amis's novel London Fields &mdash; at first widely expected to win the Booker Prize &mdash; &bquo;as a fizzy, spiky, savagely satirical book&equo; which was &bquo;sometimes so horrible it makes you gag, so funny it makes you fall off your chair&equo;, the judges instead gave the prize to Lindsay Clarke for The Chymical Wedding. 
 This is a novel set in the 1840s and 1980s, published by Jonathan Cape (&pound;12.95): &bquo;a long, intelligent book about passion, poetry, pagan impulses, and the soul striving to escape its mortal fetters.&equo; 
 Other contenders were The Flint Bed, by Christopher Burns (Secker); My Chocolate Redeemer, by Christopher Hope (Heinemann), and The War Zone, by Alexander Stuart (Hamish Hamilton). 
 Prize for the Best First Novel went to James Hamilton-Paterson for Gerontius (Macmillan, &pound;12.95); and for the Best Children's Novel to Hugh Scott for Why Weeps the Brogan? 
 (Walker Books, &pound;7.95). 
 Poet of the Year is Michael Donaghy, an Irish-American now settled in Britain. 
 His first collection of verse, Shibboleth, is published by Oxford (&pound;5.95). 
 The chairman of the judges, Peter Porter, described him as being one of the &bquo;witty, but at the same time highly passionate, informed, moral, well-crafted poets. 
 America produces more of these than we do.&equo; 
 The category winners were chosen from a field of 400. 
 For the Book of the Year prize, the bookmakers William Hill have named Lindsay Clarke as 2-1 favourite. 
 Previous winners have been the poet Douglas Dunn, this year's Booker winner Kazuo Ishiguro, the handicapped writer Christopher Nolan, and the novelist Paul Sayer. 
 DPP to decide on manslaughter charge for BR within weeks. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 THE Director of Public Prosecutions, Mr Allan Green, QC, is expected to decide within a few weeks whether to press corporate manslaughter charges against British Rail, the Crown Prosecution Service said yesterday. 
 A senior QC is studying the British Transport police report and will recommend if any charges should be laid. 
 He will be sent a copy of Sir Anthony Hidden's report but will base his recommendations on the criminal investigation by British Transport Police, a CPS spokesman said. 
 But lawyers expressed doubts. 
 &bquo;They were very negligent but they were not criminally negligent,&equo; said one barrister. 
 A manslaughter conviction would require proof of recklessness or, possibly, gross negligence. 
 Corporate manslaughter charges were almost unknown in English law before the DPP decided last June to issue manslaughter summonses against P&amp;O European Ferries after the Zeebrugge disaster and there are still no firm judicial rulings on whether corporate manslaughter exists as a crime. 
 In Glamorgan in 1965 a company responsible for the collapse of a bridge was acquitted of manslaughter but the defence apparently never questioned whether a company can be guilty of manslaughter. 
 In 1972 the Law Commission concluded that the crime of corporate manslaughter &bquo;probably&equo; exists. 
 When the Zeebrugge families challenged the coroner in the High Court Lord Justice Bingham &bquo;tentatively&equo; accepted that a company could be guilty. 
 In September the DPP decided not to bring corporate manslaughter charges against British Rail after four people died in October 1987 when a river bridge at Glanrhyd, Dyfed, Wales, over which a train was travelling despite a red flood alert, collapsed. 
 Technicians' wiring mistake caused disaster Dangerous practices and communication failures contributed to 35 deaths BR's slipshod style &bquo;led to crash errors&equo;. 
 By David Sharrock. 
 AFAILURE of the signalling system &mdash; which occurred when a signal box wire that should have been removed was not, thus preventing the signal from turning to red &mdash; caused the Clapham rail disaster in which 35 people died last December 12, according to the report of the inquiry chaired by Sir Anthony Hidden, QC. 
 The 56-day public inquiry heard 122 witnesses. 
 The report lists &bquo;many faults&equo; inherent in the way the railway had been run for several years. 
 Noted as relevant to the Clapham accident were the factors that: Working practices were permitted to slip to dangerous standards and quality of supervision was permitted to slip to an equivalent degree; quality of testing did not meet BR standards; no proper system of training of installation and testing staff was in use, and there was no vetting of weekend staff to prevent excessive overtime; and there was failure to communicate both up and down lines of management. 
 The fault which caused the Clapham crash is traced to the final installation of a new signal, number WF138, on November 27, 1988, by Mr Brian Hemingway, a senior technician. 
 There was nothing new in signal WF138's concept or installation, the report says. 
 Mr Hemingway's task on the weekend of November 26-27 was to connect the circuit's new wires and disconnect the old wire at both its relay end and its fuse end. 
 &bquo;In fact, no disconnection was made at the fuse end, and although at the other relay end the old wire was disconnected, it was not cut back as it should have been, nor was it secured out of the way of its previous contact.&equo; 
 If the wrong circumstances arose, it was physically possible for the old wire to return to its old position. 
 &bquo;Those circumstances did arise.&equo; 
 Two weeks later, the day before the accident, Mr Hemingway was working on the signal again. 
 His efforts disturbed the positions of the wires. 
 &bquo;The consequences were not only unintended, they were disastrous. 
 &bquo;As long as there was a large enough interval between trains running into London, no train would be close enough to the one in front to be affected by the faulty signal.&equo; 
 Shortly before 8.10am on December 12, Mr Alex McClymont, driving the Basingstoke to Waterloo train, noted that the signal was at red. 
 He had &bquo;unwillingly become involved in an incident known in railway jargon as a SPAD (Signal Passed At Danger).&equo; 
 BR rules stipulated he must stop immediately and notify the signalman. 
 &bquo;When he did so, he would have been holding to an instinctive belief that the signal behind him would inevitably have gone to red. 
 That belief would have been tragically wrong. 
 &bquo;The direct cause of the Clapham Junction accident was undoubtedly the wiring errors made by Mr Hemingway,&equo; the report says, adding: &bquo;He has never sought to evade his reponsibility for the appalling consequences of his errors&hellip; not one word of excuse came from Mr Hemingway.&equo; 
 The blame for his &bquo;characteristic errors, since they were&hellip; his normal working practice&equo;, must be a shared one. 
 It is a collective liability which lies on British Rail.&equo; 
 The cause of Mr Hemingway's &bquo;uncharacteristic errors&equo; &mdash; failing to see that the old wire was detached at the fuse end and insulated at the relay end &mdash; is attributed to the long hours he worked. 
 &bquo;In the three months before the accident, he had one sole day off. 
 I find this totally unacceptable.&equo; 
 Bad wiring practices were compounded by a workforce which was adequate neither in size nor in skills. 
 The unions had to bear their share of responsibility for &bquo;attitudes of entrenched resistance to change&equo;. 
 Failure of arrangements for proper payment had also failed to provide BR with the overall size, structure and quality of workforce needed. 
 The inquiry said the deferment of projects involving large capital expenditure, frequency of reorganisation within BR, and lack of control of projects did not stem from any individual's decision, but &bquo;from the way in which the railway has come to do things.&equo; 
 Colony lionises royal couple. 
 By John Ezard in Hong Kong 
 FOR the 2,000-year-old art of lion jigging, &bquo;extraordinary strength is a prerequisite&equo; &mdash; but it must be combined with great delicacy of step, according to the Society for the Advancement of Chinese Folklore. 
 The same, as is increasingly being said by the colony's elder statesmen, is true of Hong Kong's present relations with China. 
 And so a thrilling, virtuoso display of the art was the first spectacle the Prince and Princess of Wales saw when they stepped ashore here last night to be greeted by a modest but affectionate crowd of 4,000. 
 Their trip from the airport in a launch (one of the perks of the Governor, Sir David Wilson) took them as close as they will be allowed to get this week to a Vietnamese boat people's detention centre &mdash; at Argyle Street, Kowloon &mdash; as well as past the harbour's backdrop of skyscrapers, mammoth neon advertisements, and mountains. 
 They disembarked at Queen's Pier, next to the town hall and the British garrison headquarters, for the 25-minute welcome ceremony. 
 Lion jigging, or dancing, originated in a vision of peace and prosperity dreamt by Emperor Qian Long, by casting lions in varying regional costumes. 
 Prince Charles, honoured by being momentarily cast a Chinese emperor, dabbed ink on the lion's eyes for luck. 
 The princess, whose casting was unclear, placed flowers on its head. 
 The ceremony was followed by a series of precise mimes, dances and songs by 400 children and kung fu gymnasts, merging traditional music and western beat. 
 Then the couple vanished to meet colony VIPs inside the steel maw of the Hong Kong and Shanghai Bank skyscraper, a vision created with prefabricated bridge-building techniques by one of Charles's less favourite architects, Mr Norman Foster. 
 Buckingham Palace had promised his remarks would be discreet. 
 Brooke tries to repair talks damage. 
 By David Hearst in Belfast 
 MR PETER Brooke, the Northern Ireland Secretary, last night attempted to repair some of the damage done by his reference last week to the possibility of talking to Sinn Fein if the IRA laid down its arms. 
 In a speech to ex-servicemen and women, Mr Brooke said that the security forces had shown that terrorism could not and would not succeed. 
 He went on: &bquo;Our overriding aim is to bring terrorism to an end so that the people of Northern Ireland may live in peace and stability and be able to take decisions about their own future in accordance with the principle of democratic consent and without fear or coercion.&equo; 
 Although he did not contradict what he said last week, except to apologise for his reference to Cyprus, the tenor of the remarks was clearly designed to redress the balance. 
 Last week he said it was impossible to defeat the IRA militarily, which left a policy of containment. 
 Family escapes, page 8 
 Army to take emergency calls. 
 By Keith Harper, David Brindle and Patrick Wintour 
 TROOPS will be used in London from 2pm today to take ambulance emergency calls in what the unions regarded last night as a &bquo;political&equo; attempt to escalate the dispute. 
 With the call-up of the troops by Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, came fresh revelations yesterday that the Government wants to settle the dispute with a deal that would allow local managers to top up the pay of crews with special paramedical skills. 
 The move would be a decisive step towards the separation of the 999 service from routine ambulance work. 
 It would give designated emergency crews the chance to achieve their goal of pay parity with firefighters. 
 Mr Duncan Nichol, the National Health Service chief executive, told the Guardian that division of the service and the putting out to contract of non-emergency work was &bquo;likely&equo;. 
 According to Mr Nichol, such a deal could increase pay rates in London by 30 per cent and elsewhere by 20 per cent. 
 It is already operating in Wiltshire and other parts of the country. 
 The idea was rejected by the main health service union, Nupe, which said last night that the Government was trying to split the ambulance staff. 
 &bquo;We want a pay deal now to solve all our problems and a formula which would prevent us from taking action in future.&equo; 
 The Government's formal negotiating stance on pay was set out by Mr Clarke, who told a press conference there was no question of increasing the general 6.5 per cent offer to the ambulance crews in the face of disruptive action. 
 The troops will join the police, who were reluctantly involved yesterday in the capital after the London Ambulance Service said that it could not cope. 
 The employers admitted that there would be an inferior service. 
 It is the first time that troops have been brought in during an industrial dispute since the firemen's strike in 1978. 
 Mr Clarke told the House of Commons that he was doing it with great reluctance. 
 The difference between 1978 and now is that ambulance staff are not on strike but are working to rule, and answering all emergency calls. 
 Mr Robin Cook, the shadow Health Secretary, who advised the Government to call in arbitrators rather than the army, said that Mr Clarke had given no satisfactory explanation for his precipitate action. 
 Mr Roger Poole, the ambulance unions' chief negotiator, said that the Government was putting the lives of Londoners at risk. 
 All ambulance crews would continue to stand by at their stations for 999 calls. 
 &bquo;This is a crass decision by Mr Clarke and the Government is playing dangerous game,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Chris Spry, for the London Ambulance Service, said that the South West Thames regional health authority had asked for the army's help. 
 About 50 military vehicles will supplement 53 from the police and voluntary organisations, such as the St John Ambulance. 
 The sickest patients will be carried by voluntary groups, the next by the army, with the least ill by the police. 
 The army will be based at police stations and will be allocated calls via the police. 
 The need to call in troops, according to Mr Spry, became apparent by mid-afternoon yesterday when the police could not meet the demand for accident services. 
 Mr Tom Crosby, chief ambulance officer for London, said the level of care would drop but insisted that the army crews had some medical training and were not basic infantry men. 
 Mr Chris Humphreys, London secretary of Nupe, said: &bquo;It is obvious that Kenneth Clarke intends to try and starve our members back to work. 
 The Government cannot pretend to be concerned with security at army barracks and then, without regard for the soldiers, put them on the streets of London as easy targets for the terrorists.&equo; 
 Management yesterday began suspending ambulance staff in retaliation to the unions' work-to-rule tactics. 
 Mr Clarke said the armed forces would be withdrawn as soon as the unions agreed to provide a normal emergency service. 
 The action taken in London had an immediate affect elsewhere as ambulance crews began to protest at the Government's intervention. 
 Greater Manchester union officials agreed to halt all routine work in protest against suspensions, and Welsh crews promised to stage work-ins if suspensions went ahead. 
 Soldiers in front line, page 3; Leader comment, page 22; Duncan Nichol interview, page 23 
 Soldiers in the front line of industrial strife David Fairhall on the discreet arrangement that has brought in the troops. 
 THE troops' intervention in the ambulance strike is not being authorised under the Emergency Powers Act, but under a Whitehall arrangement which enables one department to request &bquo;military aid to the civil ministries&equo; from the Ministry of Defence and pay the bill afterwards. 
 This discreet arrangement means, among other things, that there was no need for Mrs Thatcher to consider declaring a state of emergency, as Mr Heath's government did during the 1973 miners' strike. 
 That would only have been necessary had the troops been requisitioning other people's equipment, rather than turning out with their own ambulances. 
 Troops have been used more than 30 times since the second world war to replace striking workers. 
 During the 1970s they were called out to clear hundreds of tons rubbish from the streets of Glasgow during the 1975 dustmen's strike. 
 Two years later dozens of Green Goddess military fire engines were brought out of storage to cover the firemen's strike. 
 In 1974 military engineers stood by to operate power stations in Northern Ireland during the protest strike by the Protestant Ulster Workers' Council, though they could have done nothing without the help of at least the power station managers. 
 During Mrs Thatcher's administration, troops have found themselves involved in five industrial disputes &mdash; to operate prisons in 1980/81, to drive ambulances in 1981 and 1982, to cover for civil servants during a dispute at the Coulport submarine base in 1981, and to help with car parking during the rail strike of 1982. 
 Soldiers never like being asked to do somebody else's dirty work, especially if they have been called off leave to do it, and are likely to be accused of strike breaking in the process. 
 On the other hand they will readily respond to civil emergencies such as floods. 
 In this case the request for help falls somewhere between the extremes of the Glasgow dustmen's strike and straight humanitarian operations such as rescuing people from snowdrifts. 
 In the latest situation troops are being drafted in to do jobs they normally do and for which they are trained. 
 The crews are mostly &bquo;medical assistants,&equo; which means possessing more than just a knowledge of first aid. 
 Richard Norton-Taylor adds: Contingency plans for the use of troops in ambulance disputes were drawn up shortly after the Government came to power in 1979, Whitehall documents show. 
 They were drafted by the Ministry of Defence and Department of Health. 
 Department of Health officials wrote to regional administrators in 1980 with details of a new plan &mdash; code-named Bittern &mdash; providing for &bquo;the use of service ambulances and drivers in the event of an industrial dispute&equo; &mdash; the decision now taken yesterday by ministers. 
 Two other plans, not activated in the present dispute, were also drawn up. 
 One, code-named Concord, dealt with how the armed forces would drive NHS ambulances. 
 The other plan, code-named Lionel, related to limited service assistance in the event of a strike involving certain skilled and semi-skilled ancillary workers. 
 The circular makes clear that a decision to implement the contingency plans would be &bquo;subject to collective ministerial authority&equo;. 
 The Department of Health warned that the number of troops allocated may not be all forthcoming because of commitments elsewhere. 
 Any disclosure of information contained in the plans, it said, would be &bquo;extremely damaging to the Government's industrial relations policy&equo;. 
 Glasgoing to be the host of a &pound;60 million year-long cultural extravaganza. 
 EUROPE'S next cultural capital, successor to Athens, Florence, Amsterdam, Paris and West Berlin, yesterday prepared for action in 1990, writes Peter Hetherington. 
 &bquo;We have something to prove,&equo; said Bob Palmer, director of Britain's longest artistic extravaganza, a &pound;60 million year-long Glaswegian spectacle of music, opera, dance, street parties and the world's biggest fireworks display. 
 &bquo;Now we have to let people know our revival is real &mdash; that something is happening up here,&equo; said Mr Palmer. 
 The men from Saatchi and Saatchi have been doing their best in the glossy mags with the slogan &bquo;there's a lot of Glasgoing on in 1990&equo; &mdash; but yesterday provided the taste of things to come in a city which has borne more than its fair share of music hall humour and Billy Connolly. 
 After meeting the Soviet culture minister, and the musical director of the Bolshoi opera, Mr Palmer set off for a cellar club-cum-recording studio and gallery to hear a folk singer break the musical mould and, hopefully, erase the memory of the song (&bquo;I Belong To&hellip;&equo;) 
 Glaswegians love to hate. 
 Standing barefoot on the club stage with acoustic guitar, Carol Laula presented the new, official Glasgow song &mdash; winner of a competition sponsored by Glasgow District Council, which is organising next year's celebrations. 
 To the outsider there was no hint of Glasgow in the verses &mdash; but the message was powerful nonetheless. 
 With a hint of Joni Mitchell and Joan Baez, Carol brought the house down: &bquo;He has a family/He has a home/He's wearing some new shoes that he doesn't quite own/He doesn't have work yet/He's trying hard to get/But he'll give you his fortune when he has one to give.&equo; 
 Mr Palmer and the Labour council are doing their best to make next year a people's celebration. 
 Of course, the new &pound;25 million concert hall, the visit of the Berlin Phil, the Bolshoi Opera, Jessye Norman, Pavarotti and the rest provide what Palmer calls the &bquo;high culture&equo;. 
 But he is anxious to embrace the whole city, which is why the council is sponsoring a series of 40 commissions embracing artists, musicians and playwrights. 
 In one of the most lavish, Bill Bryden, the writer, will be presenting a theatrical and musical project called The Ship, a history of Clydeside shipbuilding, in a disused shipyard. 
 Synod vote paves way for women priests.. 
 By Andrew Culf 
 LEGISLATION enabling the Church of England General Synod to provide by canon for women to be ordained was overwhelmingly approved yesterday. 
 Voting was 30 to 17 in favour in the House of Bishops, 149 to 85 in the House of Clergy and 144 to 78 in the House of Laity. 
 The matter will now be referred to dioceses for consultation. 
 The Archbishop of Canterbury, Dr Robert Runcie, told the synod it should receive the report in favour of the ordination of women with a &bquo;steady nerve&equo;. 
 After two hours of debate the synod voted overwhelmingly to receive the report and moved on to detailed discussion of the legislation. 
 Dr Runcie said he put his trust in the resilience of the Church of England to handle the debate. 
 &bquo;I remain of the conviction that the ordination of women to the priesthood ought to be construed as an enlargement and extension of the historic Christian ministry,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It cannot be irrelevant to evangelism that so many unbelievers think the place we give to women in the Church is frankly absurd.&equo; 
 He still feared polarisation and the creation of monochrome dioceses where clergy opposed to women priests would leave dioceses where they were ordained, and women ordinands and deacons would leave dioceses where they could not become priests. 
 The legislation would have most impact on the dioceses, and Dr Runcie was anxious the debate should be extended to the grassroots. 
 The motion was moved by the Rev Canon John Dale (Worcester) who said it was five years since the request for legislation on women priests was made. 
 &bquo;The measure as revised by the committee tried as hard as possible to accommodate the views of those who object to women priests. 
 It creates space within the Church from which they can carry on their ministry for up to 20 years.&equo; 
 Speaking against the motion, the Rev David Holloway (Newcastle) quoted a Canadian theologian. 
 &bquo;If it should turn out to be true that God did intend males to exhibit strength in leadership roles and females to excel more as the guardians of society's emotional resources, why should this be viewed ipso facto as an evil arrangement?&equo; 
 Mr Michael Oakley (York), supporting the motion, said it was vital the matter was put out to the dioceses. 
 &bquo;If we do not send legislation down to the dioceses, it is almost analogous to a judge who fails to include a point of law in a summing up to the jury.&equo; 
 Canon Frances Briscoe (York) said failure to pass the legislation to the grassroots would be a &bquo;betrayal of women out in the dioceses, waiting in the wings&equo;. 
 Support for consulting dioceses came from the Bishop of Stepney, the Right Rev James Thompson, who said women priests would be an &bquo;enrichment to the Church&equo;. 
 He was only disappointed that the legislation bent over backwards to accommodate those against. 
 The Bishop of Durham, the Right Rev David Jenkins, asked why good, caring and conscientious priests opposed to ordination of women should trouble collective consciences more than the women excluded from the ministry, who were being treated &bquo;more and more as pawns in a political game&equo;. 
 However, the Right Rev Timothy Bavin, Bishop of Portsmouth, said there was no real agreement or consensus in the Church. 
 If the legislation was passed he would find it difficult to remain a diocesan bishop. 
 The Most Rev John Habgood, Archbishop of York, said the Church &bquo;must exercise patience and not use threats of walkouts and illegal actions&equo;. 
 Judgment day&hellip; 
 Onlookers in the public gallery at Church House in London listening to the General Synod's debate on the ordination of women yesterdayPHOTOGRAPH: GRAHAM TURNER 
 Likely buyer for New Statesman. 
 THE New Statesman and Society could soon have a new owner if negotiations with Mr Robert Holmes a Court, the Australian entrepreneur, are successful, writes Georgina Henry. 
 Mr Holmes a Court has put in a formal offer for the magazine, believed to be between &pound;2 and &pound;3 million. 
 He has an option to complete the deal before November 30, but a decision on whether to go ahead could be made next week. 
 The magazine is controlled by a private trust. 
 New Statesman and New Society were merged into a single publication 18 months ago. 
 The magazine is selling around 35,000 a week but lost almost &pound;200,000 in its last financial year. 
 It revealed in September that it was looking for either an outright buyer or a substantial injection of capital for a minority stake in order to expand the publication. 
 Nuclear safety cut costs &pound;20m. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 MORE than &pound;20 million in research costs has been lost on an abandoned nuclear safety programme for Britain's advanced gas-cooled reactors (AGR), the National Audit Office disclosed yesterday. 
 Auditors checking Department of Energy accounts have discovered that the ministry wrote off &pound;9.54 million spent on research which had to be cancelled following nuclear research cuts and plans for electricity privatisation. 
 An additional &pound;12.94 million in supporting research was also lost. 
 The United Kingdom Atomic Energy Authority said yesterday: &bquo;Government economies on nuclear research means we are having to close an experimental nuclear reactor called Pluto at Harwell next April. 
 The research commissioned by the Department of Energy was connected to the reactor and had to be abandoned. 
 We are holding an internal inquiry.&equo; 
 The auditors say that the Treasury originally gave the go- ahead in 1982, authorising &pound;1.95 million on research. 
 This was increased to &pound;3.95 million to cover additional safety requirements. 
 Another &pound;12.94 million was spent on back-up research. 
 The auditors say the department withdrew support for the project in March after &bquo;a series of delays in design, development, and preparation for installation&equo; of a loop to test the reactor. 
 By that time the ministry had already spent &pound;9.54 million on the project. 
 The authority said yesterday that the delays arose because the research amounted to what scientists called a &bquo;blue skies&equo; project because it involved going beyond the present capacity of the reactor design. 
 This made construction of the project more difficult. 
 Appropriation Accounts 1988-89. 
 Volume 4; Classes V and VI Trade and Industry and Energy; HMSO &pound;7.20 
 Bar embarrassed by cash row case. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 ADISPUTE over money split the barristers' chambers headed by Sir Ian Percival, QC, a former Conservative Solicitor-General, and forced members to choose between Sir Ian and another leading QC, the High Court heard yesterday. 
 In a case which is causing the Bar much embarrassment, Lord Justice Watkins and Mr Justice Garland were told that six barristers followed Sir Ian, while 11 decided to stay with Mr John Samuels, QC, who was in charge of chambers administration. 
 Sir Ian wants the court to order the Bar Council to bring charges of professional misconduct, which can lead to disbarment, against Mr Samuels. 
 He is applying for judicial review of a decision by the council's professional conduct committee to prefer the less serious charge of breach of proper professional standards, which leads to an admonition. 
 The court was told that Sir Ian complained to the Bar Council after discovering in 1987 that Mr Samuels had the year before put &pound;10,000 of chambers' money into a building society account without Sir Ian's knowledge. 
 When confronted, Mr Samuels had agreed to close the account and transfer the money into the chambers' bank account. 
 But Sir Ian later learned that Mr Samuels had put another &pound;15,000 of chambers' funds into the building society account in 1985. 
 When he closed the account, he transferred this to another account and used it to pay chambers' expenses. 
 Mr Michael Beloff, QC, representing Sir Ian, stressed that there was no suggestion Mr Samuels had sought personal gain. 
 At the heart of Sir Ian's complaint was Mr Samuel's alleged deliberate concealment of his activities after they had been partially unearthed. 
 Mr Beloff argued that a prima facie case of professional misconduct had been made out and should have been put before the barristers' disciplinary tribunal. 
 The hearing continues. 
 Brief encounter at despatch box sets Tory pulses racing Sketch. 
 By Andrew Rawnsley 
 ALMOST as soon as she got up, Tory backbenchers gave a big cheer for the blonde woman at the despatch box. 
 Mrs Thatcher? 
 No, they have gone a bit cool towards her. 
 It was Mrs Virginia Bottomley. 
 They are still in love with her. 
 Tory MPs have always had a crush on her. 
 It starts with her name. 
 Virginia, suggesting purity, appeals to the gents; Bottomley, suggesting something vaguely rude, appeals to the lads. 
 Occasionally flicking back a stray blonde hair, Mrs Bottomley comes to the despatch box as if she has just leapt out of a hair spray advert. 
 This was her debut as Health Minister. 
 &bquo;Mr Speaker,&equo; swooned James Paice, a Tory backbencher from Cambridgeshire, &bquo;can I first welcome my Honourable Friend to her first question time?&equo; 
 A huge cheer &mdash; somewhere between a wolf-whistle and a blown kiss &mdash; went up from the Tory backbenches. 
 Mr Paice asked for a date with the minister to discuss his concerns about a hospital in his constituency. 
 &bquo;I shall be more than happy to meet him,&equo; replied Mrs Bottomley, winningly. 
 &bquo;And discuss the matter in more detail.&equo; 
 Green-eyed colleagues oozed envy at a smug Mr Paice. 
 Before anybody complains that all this is very sexist and demeaning &mdash; I entirely agree. 
 Grown men shouldn't humiliate themselves like this. 
 James Pawsey, the Tory member for Rugby, also appeared to be hopelessly in love. 
 He cooed total infatuation for the well-proportioned figure at the despatch box. 
 &bquo;Can I give my Right Honourable Friend two big thank-yous!&equo;, he cried, in a tone suggesting that he would like to accompany them with two big kisses. 
 But the strange thing had happened. 
 The well-proportioned figure at the despatch box to whom Mr Pawsey was swearing his love was now Kenneth Clarke. 
 Still, the Health Secretary blushed becomingly at Mr Pawsey's expression of adoration. 
 On to Prime Minister's Question Time. 
 It was Mrs Thatcher's first since she ended years of political and medical speculation by making the shock revelation in the Sunday Correspondent that she is, after all, human. 
 She did not expect to be Prime Minister into the next millenium. 
 MPs were no doubt grateful for that ruling. 
 There might have been considerable constitutional difficulties if it had turned out that, for the last 10 years, Britain had been ruled by a Martian, or a robot, or a vampire. 
 The Tories gazed at her in a new light. 
 Many now realised, for the first time, that she may not be with them for that much longer. 
 Others secretly hoped that they were right. 
 Neil Kinnock and others pressed her for a while about Nigel Lawson's resignation. 
 To the suggestion that she hadn't told the truth some Tory MPs yelled &bquo;Rubbish!&equo;. 
 But only some. 
 On a distant Tory bench Cranley Onslow, the chairman of the backbench 1922 Committee, had been preparing to intervene. 
 His leader was in trouble. 
 So is he &mdash; his job threatened by a challenger. 
 An act of conspicuous valour, in the tradition of St George, might help both her and him. 
 Over a roar of jeering from the Opposition, Mr Onslow rushed to the rescue with a helpful question to the Prime Minister. 
 She smiled her thanks. 
 And valiant, it was. 
 Except that St George, according to the history books, rode to rescue the damsel, not the dragon. 
 . 
 SOCIAL Security Secretary Mr Tony Newton announced four steps to protect occupational pensions of people whose companies are involved in takeovers or mergers. 
 There will also be a pensions ombudsman and a tracing service to help people track down pensions held with previous employers, he told Mr Gerrard Neale (C. Cornwall N) in a written reply. 
 LABOUR'S health spokesman, Mr Robin Cook, claimed during health questions that eye tests were dropping so steeply since charges were imposed earlier this year that they were heading for a fall of three million, but health minister Mrs Virginia Bottomley said the Government had not yet reviewed the effect of charges. 
 MANY small businesses will no longer be required to send in detailed tax returns including accounts and balance sheets, the Treasury minister, Mr Peter Lilley, said in a written answer. 
 Total turnover, net profit and purchases will be accepted from traders with a turnover below &pound;10,000 from next April, he said. 
 SALE room prices of impressionist paintings have risen by 974 per cent over the last ten years, modern paintings by 880 per cent and English furniture by 314 per cent, arts minister Mr Richard Luce told Mr Mark Fisher (Lab. 
 Stoke Central) in a written answer. 
 Old master paintings had risen by 266 per cent in the same period, 19th century paintings by 254, Chinese ceramics by 204, English silver by 188, continental furniture by 169. 
 MR Calum Macdonald (Lab. 
 Western Isles) asked for an assurance at question time that bursaries for Project 2000 nurses would not be turned into loans. 
 The Health Secretary, Mr Kenneth Clarke, said he had no intention of moving student nurses on to loans. 
 THE Fabian Society announced the appointment of Mr Simon Crine, 34, as its new general secretary. 
 Director for the past five years of the National Campaign for the Arts, he previously worked for the former Labour minister, Mr Albert Booth, and the Low Pay Unit. 
 Mr Crine lives in Islington, north London, and succeeds Mr John Willman. 
 TODAY'S BUSINESS House of Commons: Environment questions; Employment Bill, Lords amendments. 
 House of Lords: Children Bill, Commons amendments; Trade Union Act (Amendment) Bill, committee; Apple and Pear Councils orders; Passenger and Goods Vehicles (Recording Equipment) rules. 
 Eleven men found to be responsible. 
 By David Sharrock 
 THE report singles out 11 people for criticism under the heading, Where Responsibilty Lies. 
 However, Sir Anthony stresses that, almost without exception, those who gave their evidence to the investigation did so with &bquo;conscientiousness, care, dignity and with a measure of frankness wholly to be admired&equo;. 
 Brian Hemingway: His wiring errors in the Clapham Junction &bquo;A&equo; relay room on Sunday November 27 &bquo;undoubtedly&equo; direct cause of accident. 
 Excessive overtime &bquo;blunted his working edge, freshness and concentration&equo;. 
 Derek Bumstead, supervisor: Failed &bquo;adequately or at all to monitor Mr Hemingway's working practices&equo;, or to plan satisfactorily work on weekend when fatal errors made. 
 Peter Dray, testing and commissioning engineer: &bquo;Manifested all problems produced by BR reorganisation; less than happy&equo; with his job, as shown by performance in days up to and including November 27; despite having facilities, time and assistance for an independent wire count of Hemingway's work, did not do this &mdash; far from being &bquo;the last defence&equo;, was no defence at all. 
 James Lippett, Bumstead's immediate superior: &bquo;Another of the casualties of reorganisation&equo;; saw bad practices in the relay room, but took no action &mdash; &bquo;believed it was their way of doing things&equo;. 
 Gordon Callander: Much too junior to have responsibilty for planning, but it &bquo;came to rest on his desk&equo;; nobody more senior ever reviewed plan he set out &bquo;in handwriting on a few sheets of paper&equo;. 
 Geoffrey Bailey, head of Southern Region Testing Team: &bquo;utterly and completely failed&equo; to raise standards or curb excessive overtime. 
 John Deane: Knew how much overtime needed for resignalling programme, but failed to ask for it to be extended. 
 Roger Penny, Deane's immediate superior: Admitted &bquo;out of touch with what was going on&equo;, and frankly accepted a degree of responsibility. 
 Robert Davies, signal works engineer: &bquo;failed completely to get on with the testing instruction&equo;. 
 Graham Brown, signals engineer: &bquo;an example of management by inactivity and inertia&equo;. 
 Clifford Hale, regional engineer: &bquo;Captain of the ship&equo; until day before the accident; his management &bquo;demonstrated the lack of communication which pervaded the department&equo;. 
 Last night he resigned. 
 Brian Hemingway: overtime blunted concentration' Clifford Hale&hellip; &bquo;lack of communication&equo; 
 Health Secretary fends off Commons accusations over decision to mobilise the army in ambulance dispute Strike-break jibe at Clarke. 
 By Patrick Wintour 
 THE Health Secretary Mr Kenneth Clarke yesterday rejected claims that he was trying to break the ambulancemen's strike when he told MPs he had decided the army would be mobilised to help to answer emergency calls in London. 
 He said neither management nor the Government had any other option once the National Union of Public Employees had reimposed the &bquo;appalling and disgraceful conditions designed to disrupt the accident service&equo;. 
 In a Commons statement, Mr Clarke said: &bquo;We would very much prefer to see a full accident and emergency service provided by trained ambulancemen, but that is impossible while the unions continue to insist on the 14 conditions which they have imposed. 
 &bquo;I must stress that the involvement of armed forces, the police and the voluntary services will cease once the trades unions agree, as they did two weeks ago, to provide normal accident and emergency service&equo;. 
 Mr Nigel Spearing (Lab. 
 Newham North East) shouted: &bquo;Disgraceful&equo;, when Mr Clarke claimed: &bquo;The men, although doing no work, are at the moment still in the ambulance stations. 
 It is, in fact, the case that the men are pretending to be prepared to operate the accident and emergency service. 
 The claim that today's difficulties have been somehow caused by the management is a sick joke being perpetrated by the unions.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;The Government will only use policemen or military personnel to protect the life and limb of citizens at risk. 
 There's absolutely no question of our using either the police force or the army for the purpose of strike-breaking&equo;. 
 Mr Robin Cook, Labour's health spokesman, said in every ambulance station in London there were staff ready and waiting to provide emergency cover. 
 &bquo;In those stations it is the management that has now refused to put through the emergency calls. 
 Is it not clear that it is not ambulance staff which have withdrawn the emergency cover from London, but the management?&equo; 
 He continued: &bquo;In eight weeks of this dispute he &lsqb;Mr Clarke&rsqb; has not once sat down with the staff side of the ambulancemen. 
 Would it not be better to talk to the ambulance staff before he talked to his colleages at the Ministry of Defence? 
 &bquo;Can the Secretary of State answer the question which has remained unanswered since this dispute began and remains unanswered. 
 If he is so right in offering the ambulance staff 6.5 per cent, if the ambulance staff are so unreasonable in rejecting it, what has he got to be so afraid of in going to arbitration which would end this dispute this afternoon? 
 Instead of calling in the army why does he not call in the arbitrators and give back London a proper service?&equo;. 
 Mr Charles Kennedy, the Liberal Democrat health spokesman, said public opinion was clearly behind the ambulancemen. 
 The offer &bquo;was seen everywhere but inside the Department of Health as an unjust offer in comparison with other emergency services. 
 It's a question of political will for him either to encourage arbitration or to make the funds available for a fair settlement.&equo; 
 Mr Jerry Hayes (C. Harlow) warned that &bquo;due to the regrettable and irresponsible behaviour of the unions, one man's pay dispute could soon degenerate into another man's loss of life&equo;. 
 However, he urged the Government to consider taking the ambulance staff's pay permanently outside the political arena by setting up a pay review body for ambulance staff Mr Clarke replied the NHS could not end up in a situation whereby group after group took industrial action and were rewarded by arbitration bodies. 
 &bquo;The result would be that the NHS management would be responsible for the pay and conditions of a million people, but actually arbitrators would dispose of the resources.&equo; 
 No cash limit on safety, says Parkinson. 
 By Paul Nettleton 
 MR CECIL Parkinson, the Transport Secretary, gave an assurance to the Commons yesterday that financial considerations would not stand in the way of implementing recommendations of the Clapham disaster report. 
 He was meeting the British Rail chairman, Sir Robert Reid, this morning to discuss prompt implementation of the 93 recommendations. 
 Mr Parkinson told MPs that he welcomed the report by Sir Anthony Hidden, QC. 
 &bquo;The investigation has revealed major defects in the way in which British Rail's Southern Region signalling and telecommunications department organised resignalling work, and supervised and tested completed wiring.&equo; 
 He was asking BR to report within three months on the recommendations. 
 He said BR would have to consider the spending required. 
 But he promised: &bquo;I can assure the House that finance will not stand in the way of the implementation of the report.&equo; 
 The report had recommended that railway legislation should be reviewed, and the powers of the Railway Inspectorate widened and clarified. 
 &bquo;We will introduce the necessary legislation as soon as a suitable opportunity arises. 
 Meanwhile, most of the changes can be implemented by administrative action.&equo; 
 Mr Parkinson said the report asked the Government to allocate sufficient frequencies for BR to operate cab radios effectively. 
 &bquo;We have now allocated five new frequencies to BR and given them access to two others.&equo; 
 The Health Secretary had accepted recommendations addressed to his department, and had already introduced a review of the health service's response to major incidents. 
 Mr John Prescott, the shadow Transport Secretary, said the report showed clearly that safety had &bquo;suffered at the expense of commercial considerations&equo;. 
 &bquo;This report surely demands a rethink by both the Government and the senior management of BR of the policies that they have adopted over the last 10 years.&equo; 
 Mr Prescott asked Mr Parkinson: &bquo;Will you adopt a new approach to management, investment and revenue support, so never again do we see tired, overworked, demoralised staff make a fatal error on a dark, cold Sunday evening as they rush to finish the work before the Monday morning rush hour?&equo; 
 Hidden calls for cab radios, black box recorders, and research into overcrowding and stronger carriages. 
 SIR Anthony Hidden's report makes 93 recommendations to prevent another such accident and promote a better &bquo;safety culture&equo; in British Rail, writes David Sharrock. 
 Among them are: 
 Rigorous standards in wiring and installation. 
 Overtime should be monitored to prevent excessive levels. 
 The Department of Transport and BR should ensure that &bquo;the cost-effectiveness of safe operation of the railway occupies its proper place in a business-led operation&equo;. 
 BR should prevent &bquo;commercial considerations of a business-led railway from compromising safety&equo;. 
 Overcrowding should be tackled, with loading criteria established. 
 BR should give priority to installing cab radios to link driver and signalman. 
 Black box-style voice recorders should also be introduced. 
 Timetable for installation of Automatic Train Protection system should be accelerated. 
 Driver training should emphasise signal failures and their reporting. 
 More research into the ability of carriages to resist major damage in collisions. 
 Communications with emergency services should be improved. 
 Declaration of a major incident by any service could then be passed immediately to other services. 
 The BR board's Total Quality Management Initiative, adopted in January 1988 to improve working practices and standards, should be fully implemented with the greatest urgency. 
 The Government is called upon to ensure that the Railway Inspectorate is adequately staffed and resourced for the increased responsibilities in the wake of the report. 
 Independent marchers reign on Gorbachev's parade. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 THOUSANDS of demonstrators marched through the Moscow streets yesterday calling for an end to the Communist Party's monopoly of power, in the first independent parade to be held on the anniversary of the Russian Revolution since Stalin imposed totalitarian conformity on the Soviet Union. 
 The greatest holiday in the Soviet calendar, November 7, is the day on which the country is supposed to celebrate its revolutionary leap into a higher form of society &mdash; socialism. 
 But early yesterday, several thousand people with different ideas assembled at the Dynamo Metro station, and began marching towards Red Square, where officials were putting the finishing touches to preparations for the usual annual parade. 
 At a crossroads three miles from the square that for centuries has represented the heart of imperial Russia, the independent marchers were told by police that Red Square was out of bounds. 
 A few hundred hotheads urged their comrades to break the police roadblock and march on the Kremlin, but were dissuaded by their leaders. 
 Instead, the demonstrators marched along a route agreed with the authorities to the Olympic Stadium, across the north of the city. 
 Representing a wide spectrum of radical reformers &mdash; some members of the Communist Party, some members of the Popular Front &mdash; as well as ecologists, dissident members of the armed forces and religious groups, they carried banners demanding democracy and a free press, a multi-party system and an end to the Communists' monopoly of power. 
 Meanwhile, in the Moldavian republic several people were hurt when nationalists battled with police as growing unrest in the country wrecked some regional celebrations of the Revolution. 
 Although there was no sign of him on the Moscow march, many of the demonstrators chanted support for Mr Boris Yeltsin, sacked as Moscow party chief but overwhelmingly elected last March as the city's representative on the new Congress of People's Deputies. 
 &bquo;Down with the KGB&equo; and &bquo;Down with Ligachev&equo; (Yegor Ligachev, the conservatives' leader on the party's politburo) were among the milder slogans carried by the demonstrators. 
 Others, reflecting popular frustration with empty shops and official bureaucracy after 72 years of socialism, were harsher. 
 &bquo;72 years on the road to nowhere,&equo; declared one. 
 But perhaps the most bitter was another which read: &bquo;Proletariat of all countries &mdash; Sorry!&equo;. 
 In Mr Gorbachev's Russia, all this is amazingly possible. 
 For his part, the President stood with the rest of the politburo on the mausoleum of the man who made it all happen &mdash; Lenin &mdash; and took the salute at the military and civilian parade through Red Square. 
 Unprecedentedly, he also gave a television interview from his vantage point as the workers filed by carrying red flags, banners and coloured balloons which they released into the cold, grey sky. 
 The leader of all the Russias admitted that the country's economic and social crisis amounted to a &bquo;sword of Damocles&equo; hanging over it. 
 But to go back to the old ways &bquo;would be a colossal mistake,&equo; he declared. 
 &bquo;We have to advance faster and faster towards new thinking.&equo; 
 The slogans on buildings round the square and carried by workers' groups reflected his new thinking. 
 Back to the idealism of Lenin and 1917, was their message. 
 Indeed, only Lenin's face appeared on the square this year; Marx and Engels were missing. 
 The party hardly got a look-in. 
 Of the very few banners that mentioned it, one from Moscow University called pointedly for &bquo;a faster rate of democratisation of the party&equo;. 
 As for the military parade, it was even more modest than last year. 
 In an evident effort to convince the West once again that military might is not what the Soviet Union is all about, the imposing array of missiles, rocket-launchers, self-propelled guns, and armoured vehicles were all &bquo;long in the tooth,&equo; according to a Western diplomatic source. 
 All the same, the military parade was the best of the show, with thousands of troops goose-stepping past the mausoleum, massed bands marching and counter-marching as they played, but then drowned out by the roar of armoured hardware. 
 And when Red Square echoed and re-echoed to the boom of a 21-gun salute as 800 bandsmen played the national anthem, the ghosts of the Tsars in the Kremlin could have recognised the Russia they lost. 
 Whatever Mr Gorbachev's intentions, November 7 on Red Square is still the celebration of a great power. 
 To get the feel of the people, you have to go outside. 
 Commentary, page 23; Parade cancelled, page 10 
 . 
 MONDAY morning, December 12 1988, and another week's commuting was beginning for those heading into London's Waterloo Station from the south-west, writes David Sharrock. 
 About 300 yards from Clapham Junction, Britain's busiest junction, the 7.18 Basingstoke to Waterloo train, with more than 900 passengers, stopped. 
 Driver Mr Alex McClymont got out to report a faulty signal by telephone. 
 Moments later the 6.14 service from Poole, Dorset, to Waterloo via Bournemouth, carrying more than 460 people, ploughed into the back of the stationary Basingstoke train. 
 The impact reduced the front part of the Poole train to twisted metal. 
 Some passengers died instantly. 
 Seconds later an empty train travelling away from London ran into the wreckage. 
 Thirty five people were killed, 113 injured. 
 A thousand lay sprawled in the broken trains. 
 It was the worst train accident in more than 20 years. 
 &bquo;Suddenly there was a big bang and a crash, and there was glass everywhere,&equo; said a survivor shortly afterwards. 
 &bquo;People seemed to disappear under debris, and we came to a rest. 
 Then people started shouting and screaming.&equo; 
 Within minutes of the crash rescue services were on the scene. 
 Some passers-by did not wait that long, leaping off buses and scrambling down the embankment to drag the injured out. 
 Nearby St George's Hospital, in Tooting, received the first call at 8.20. 
 By 8.30 the hospital was on red alert, with doctors ready in the accident and emergency receiving area and medical teams on the way to the scene. 
 In the following three hours the hospital took 123 victims. 
 Mr Roger Calvert, an orthopaedic consultant, described the scene of devastation, with severed limbs scattered and passengers still trapped: &bquo;Dispassionate is not the word one would use. 
 Obviously one would not want to see that scene again.&equo; 
 Crash survivor shuns front coach. 
 By David Sharrock 
 ONE regular on the early London-bound service counts his survival in the Clapham crash as incredible. 
 The man, a publishing consultant, said: &bquo;I was in the front coach of the Bournemouth train which took the full impact of the crash and where most of the 35 died.&equo; 
 Although he had been fortunate to have been sitting at the back of the coach he received a fractured spine. 
 &bquo;I was tremendously lucky that I was not paralysed.&equo; 
 He was in hospital for four weeks and had to wear a fibreglass jacket for 16. 
 Now he has two metal rods in his back. 
 He recalled: &bquo;There was an enormous hole rent in the top of the coach right above me, so in fact I was got out very quickly. 
 I have a very clear recollection of sitting there, not being able to move and hearing the approaching sirens. 
 &bquo;My young next door neighbour was sitting directly opposite me and he was completely unharmed. 
 He was holding on to the hand of one of the passengers who was bleeding rather badly. 
 That particular guy was the first person out, then I was just about the second out. 
 &bquo;It was desperately silent. 
 Just the odd cry for help. 
 There was a terrible stillness. 
 &bquo;I have not got back to my normal working routine, quite honestly. 
 I didn't start getting back up to London by train until April and even now I am not working as I am used to. 
 &bquo;But I am up on the train tomorrow. 
 I will never travel again in the front coach &mdash; that is my only superstitious qualm, or what ever you want to call it. 
 &bquo;We all suffered from our hair being absolutely jet-black from the dirt in the carriage. 
 They could not even think of washing my hair until I had had this operation to put the two rods in my back.&equo; 
 The counselling by social services had been an enormous help. 
 &bquo;One cannot speak too highly of Dorset social services. 
 We have had a support group in Bournemouth ever since just after the crash. 
 &bquo;Although fewer and fewer are now attending we still meet once a month and we find great strength from discussing problems and traumas. 
 My wife had individual counselling and that was tremendously helpful.&equo; 
 But life would never be the same. 
 &bquo;I think you do have a totally different approach to life than before. 
 When you have been so close to death and even closer to permanent serious injury then every day becomes a bonus.&equo; 
 NUT ads aim to boost cash for education *.. 
 By David Gow Education Editor 
 THE leadership of the National Union of Teachers yesterday launched a multi-million pound advertising campaign to win public backing for greater investment in education, emergency measures to reduce teacher shortages and to increase salaries in a significant shift of policy. 
 Supported by an opinion poll revealing extensive support among voters for extra resources for education, union leaders said the first phase of a prolonged press advertising campaign, launched in national newspapers today, would cost &pound;500,000. 
 The campaign could last until the next general election and will spread to systematic lobbying of backbench MPs, poster hoardings and pressure on ministers and their advisers. 
 It draws on similar campaigns by the British Medical Association and the Royal College of Nursing and is aimed at people in the ABC1 social class. 
 The campaign has been denounced by some leftwing union activists as a diversion from the need for industrial action. 
 However, Mr Doug McAvoy, the NUT's general secretary, dismissed them as unrepresentative &bquo;noisy ones&equo;. 
 The NOP poll, taken late last month on a sample of 1,000, including only 27 per cent of parents, showed 80 per cent of people already believe an effective education system is the key to economic success. 
 Mr McAvoy said the first phase was designed to raise that to 100 per cent. 
 Other findings were that 67 per cent think standards will decline in the next few years if things carry on as they are and that 77 per cent agree teachers do a good job in spite of everything. 
 Mr McAvoy said: &bquo;Ultimately, the campaign's purpose is to persuade the Government to change its existing policy on an issue which will become even more sensitive over the next 12 months.&equo; 
 Mr Gordon Green, a senior executive member, said the recent educational changes were doomed to failure unless the Government recognised the true value of teachers implementing them by improving pay and conditions. 
 An eight-point plan to beat teacher shortages was unveiled yesterday by Mr Jack Straw, Labour's education spoksman, who accused ministers of being &bquo;trapped in a torpor induced by ignorance&equo; about the true nature of the crisis. 
 Without urgent action, he added, British education would fall behind Spain, Italy, and Greece. 
 Britain kept war criminals from trial.. 
 By Richard Norton-Taylor 
 DETAILED evidence has been uncovered showing how Britain played a leading role in preventing hundreds of Italian war criminals standing trial in Yugoslavia, Greece, and Ethiopia at the end of the second world war. 
 Some 1,200 Italians &mdash; most of whom committed atrocities in Yugoslavia &mdash; were listed by the United Nations War Crimes Commission, but none was handed over. 
 Extradition from Britain was blocked for fear of unsettling the post-war anti-Communist government of Italy. 
 &bquo;Justice requires the handing over of these people, but expediency, I fear, militates against it,&equo; wrote a Foreign Office official in a report. 
 Another recorded that some held high positions in the Ministry of War: their arrest, the report added, would be &bquo;a political embarrassment&equo;. 
 Documents which disclose Britain's collusion have been found in UN, US and British archives by Dr Michael Palumbo, an American writer (who three years ago discovered the UN files on Mr Kurt Waldheim, the Austrian President). 
 His research forms the basis of a BBC 2 Timewatch programme, The Fascist Legacy, A Pledge Betrayed, to be broadcast tonight. 
 One of those named as a war criminal was Marshal Pietro Badoglio, wanted by Ethiopia for ordering the use of poison gas and the bombing of Red Cross hospitals after Italy invaded the country in 1936. 
 The FO noted that he had provided &bquo;valuable assistance&equo; to the allied cause as Prime Minister after Italy's surrender in 1943, and that it would be &bquo;inopportune&equo; to hand him over to the Ethiopians. 
 Most of the 800 named by the commission were wanted by Yugoslavia, and the FO secretly acknowledged that it had an excellent case. 
 Churchill, in particular, was concerned not to weaken the Italian Government and strengthen the hand of Communists who had dominated the wartime resistance movement. 
 &bquo;The longer we can procrastinate, the better for all concerned,&equo; wrote an FO official in 1946. 
 In 1947 Britain and the US said the matter should be left to the Italian courts. 
 One of those most wanted by Yugoslavia but allowed to go unpunished was General Mario Roatta. 
 An FO memo of 1943 noted &bquo;our information about Roatta confirms the information circulating about him&equo;. 
 One Italian who was executed for war crimes &mdash; General Bellomo &mdash; was the only anti-fascist army officer at a senior level; he was found guilty after one of his men shot an escaping British prisoner of war at Bari. 
 Police family escapes bomb. 
 ASENIOR police officer and his wife and two children escaped injury yesterday after a bomb containing up to 10lb of high explosive exploded at the back of their bungalow in Drumbo, south of Belfast. 
 Assistant Chief Constable David Mellor, aged 52, who is shortly to take up a post as deputy chief constable of South Wales, had just gone to bed when a device planted below the window of a living room exploded at 1.20am. 
 His two children, aged 18 months and seven months, were sleeping eight feet from the explosion, but were saved from injury by the bomb-proofing and reinforced glass that all VIPs in the province get in their homes. 
 The victim of Monday night's shooting in Derriaghy, Co Antrim, was named by police yesterday as Mr Robert Colin Burns, who converted to Roman Catholicism after marrying. 
 No claim has yet been made by any paramilitary group about his killing and the Royal Ulster Constabulary said yesterday they were not aware of any reason why he should have been a target. 
 The living room of the Mellor home yesterday after the blast which knocked out a reinforced-glass window. 
 The family escaped injuryPHOTOGRAPH: PAUL FAITH 
 When the pie was opened Letter from Lakeland. 
 By David Bean 
 NOVEMBER again. 
 The shrinking of daylight, the burgeoning triumph of black Chaos and night. 
 And hereabouts, of course, time once more for the consumption of the traditional Boggerthwaite November Owl Pie. 
 No one any longer recalls where this unusual dish had its origins; indeed some people have been unkind enough to suggest that it was but recently invented by Mr Rory McGurk at the Dehydrated Rambler, on finding himself with too much ageing shepherd's pie left on his hands. 
 It proved, even at the insolent price of &pound;5.95 a slice, to be even more popular than McGurk's other stock-in-trade, the Jumbo-Cumbo Boggerburger, and he has prepared a batch every November since. 
 So few of us were surprised when the other evening three strangers entered the Saddle Bar and ordered portions of the stuff. 
 That they were visiting shootists seemed pretty evident from the way they left the bar door open against the howling night, the loudness of their speech, and the muddy state of their boots. 
 Hikers are generally timid enough to leave their footwear and rucksacks in the porch; today's sporting fraternity always brings its mud with it as well as milling packs of steaming black labradors. 
 I do not know where they get these dogs. 
 They must hire them, for they are clearly not countrymen these days. 
 They talk not of rural matters (except of the possibilities of old barn conversions), but of stocks, shares, investments, and insurance. 
 They fail entirely to distribute largesse to the locals and leave the door open again on their loud departures. 
 I have gone into this rather lengthy description for two reasons: one, because it leads back into the folklore of the November Owl Pie, and two, because I can't stand the blighters at any price. 
 The Pie then. 
 &bquo;What's this, landlord?&equo; 
 The leader of the trio, an ample-bellied type with a tweed cap and one of those quilted waistcoats which look like half-inflated life jackets, sniffed the air as he studied the blackboard which serves the Rambler as a menu. 
 &bquo;November Oil Pie?&equo; 
 &bquo;Owl,&equo; corrected McGurk. 
 &bquo;Sir.&equo; 
 The stranger turned and raised an inquiring brow at his brethren, who nodded. 
 &bquo;Brace-and-a-half of that, then, landlord.&equo; 
 And when McGurk appeared to hesitate, &bquo;That's three.&equo; 
 &bquo;A quarter-of-a-dozen owl pies coming up,&equo; returned McGurk. 
 &bquo;That's three as well.&equo; 
 The dishes he filled seemed indistinguishable to my eye from run-of-the-mill cottage pie except they were rather blacker round the edges than is normal, and they were accompanied by the garnish of a quarter of a raw tomato, two cucumber slices, a sprinkling of cress (or maybe lawn clippings), and a tired, pre-chewed lettuce leaf without which no British pub meal is complete these days. 
 My first suspicion that these chaps were not what they seemed was aroused as I listened. 
 Their chat was not of high finance or property. 
 It was in fact non-existent. 
 They just chomped, and when they had finished, the podgy leader rose and quietly asked McGurk if there was somewhere they could talk to him in private. 
 We would have only McGurk's word for what happened subsequently if I had not positioned my ear by the keyhole of his office. 
 There was a little humming and hah-ing and &bquo;Now, gentlemen-ing&equo; from McGurk. 
 Then the leader introduced himself as an inspector from the Department of Health, and his colleague as from Trade and Industry. 
 The third, in a voice like a cross buzzard's, said he was from the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds. 
 It was not easy to hear all that followed, but a right old tangle developed. 
 Inspector: Was that really owl? 
 McGurk: In a manner of speaking, sir, no. 
 Inspector: I must warn that you may be liable under the Trades Descriptions Act. 
 RSPB man: It tasted like owl. 
 Second Inspector: If it was described as &bquo;November,&equo; what did that mean cooked in November, frozen in November, re-heated in November, to be eaten in November, or what? 
 Whichever, I have to warn that the use of the names of the months in describing food is no longer permitted by EEC regulations. 
 McGurk: What about Christmas pudding, then? 
 Inspector: Sarcasm will get you nowhere. 
 We are working on that one. 
 Why Charlotte Du Cann hates the use of kids as accessories Hip families Fear and loathing.. 
 YOU cannot look at anything these days without coming face to face with a picture of a blissful couple holding a baby. 
 The baby is the accessory of the moment, seen everywhere that is stylish: on the catwalk, on magazine covers, in major advertising campaigns (Next, above), in tough cop thrillers (Saracen). 
 Where once a Chanel handbag or bull terrier would have done, the fashionable woman now holds a smiling child. 
 This is said to be &bquo;getting real&equo;, being &bquo;very Nineties&equo;. 
 A baby says you care (read New Age), you are into the earth (misread green). 
 I have heard of some stupid fashion details in my time, but this is the pits. 
 A baby is not some final luxury item that consumers can afford (although this is obviously how the Government views it). 
 It does not guarantee you some privileged place on earth. 
 Nor, for that matter, can family life be a question of chic. 
 Yet this is how it is being sold. 
 Suddenly it is glamorous to appear nice and normal, and those who used to want to run the boardroom or run away to Paris now want to stay at home and watch programmes like Roseanne and Kate And Allie &mdash; new cult programmes that offer a cosy and entirely spurious view of family life. 
 The families themselves are presumed to be ordinary. 
 They are (even more trendily) mildly disadvantaged: the Cosby family are black, Kate and Allie are without husbands, Roseanne is neither rich nor thin. 
 Their lives revolve around the home, unlike in earlier cult shows like Dynasty (the office, the hotel lobby) or EastEnders (the community square). 
 Anything and everything happens around the kitchen table, and if anything nasty occurs, it is aired, talked about and solved. 
 If any among the new reality seekers had a slightly tougher memory, they would recall that there is no such thing as a happy family. 
 There are some good enough families, some fairly balanced families and a whole lot of families that resemble one of Mike Leigh's bleaker casts. 
 But a happy, ordinary family with an answer to every problem? 
 You show me someone who says they come from such a set-up and I will show you a very clever liar. 
 The most voiced reason for having a baby is that the parents can give what was not given in their own lives, to compensate for their own emptiness. 
 The child becomes their creation. 
 Of course this goes wrong. 
 A child is not born for reasons and it will not fit even the prettiest box assigned to it by its determined providers. 
 The child is itself. 
 Not only will it not be like its parents, it probably won't want to be. 
 Often the child doesn't even like them. 
 Nor they it. 
 None of this reality is dealt with in the happy family programmes, still less in the pictures of the beatific model parents and their angelic offspring. 
 These precedents for perfection are not only impossible to achieve, they also allow no place for rebellion. 
 Rebellion of child against adult. 
 And of adult against child. 
 A baby is neither a product nor an invention nor a necessary extension of one's wardrobe. 
 It is another human being. 
 Don't do it unless you mean it. 
 There are too many screwed-up, unloved babies already. 
 As there are rejected bull teriers and battered Chanel handbags. 
 Guardian Women is edited by Louise Chunn PAGE wom 
 Everyone's a capitalist The socialist councillor was intent on buying up Sheffield; and the YMCA, reports Geoffrey Beattie, is hoping to make a quick buck for Christmas. 
 HE WAS a socialist all right. 
 You could tell by his Scottish accent and his tie. 
 This may have been a conservative blue colour with an elegant stripe down the middle of it, but it was all skew-whiff. 
 And then there were his eyes, burning with a fervour, an intensity, as if he had his prey in his sights. 
 Hadn't he already described himself as &bquo;a political animal&equo; &mdash; &bquo;and with &pound;19.50p attendance money a day as a Sheffield councillor, on which I'm dependent by the way, I'd need to be a political animal.&equo; 
 And here he was with his eyes burning bright. 
 &bquo;Tiger, tiger, burning bright.&equo; 
 The lines stayed with me. 
 And as I looked at Jimmy Boyce, ex-industrial tiler, ex-foundry worker, ex-redundant foundry worker, I realised that it really was the law of the jungle here tonight. 
 The jungle of the night. 
 My eyes flitted around the table. 
 Here they all were &mdash; business, commerce, the big banks. 
 The political animal's eyes were burning again. 
 &bquo;I want the Midland Bank.&equo; 
 Nationalise the banks? 
 Outrageous! 
 But he didn't want to nationalise them, he just wanted them &mdash; for himself. 
 There was a long gap. 
 His neighbour cleared his throat. 
 His neighbour was the sales manager of the Midland Bank in Sheffield. 
 He looked at Jimmy Boyce, or rather he looked at his tie &mdash; all red and blue, almost patriotic, and yet the tie still hung at that curious angle. 
 It reminded him of shop stewards with their sleeves rolled up in those endless conferences when it was said that the country was being held to ransom. 
 It reminded him of the big shots in the trade union movement having sandwiches at Number 10 all those years ago. 
 &bquo;Never!&equo; he said as his mind returned to the present. 
 He cleared his throat again. 
 This time it wasn't so much a reflex action, an attempt to remove something nasty somewhere down his windpipe, as a deliberate social signal. 
 It seemed to be saying: &bquo;You and who else?&equo;, or &bquo;Do you think that you're really big enough?.&equo; 
 It acted as both a challenge and a rebuff. 
 It did its job. 
 Jimmy paused momentarily. 
 &bquo;But I don't want to overstretch myself.&equo; 
 The man from the Midland Bank looked rather pleased with himself. 
 His throat had stopped tickling, but then again perhaps it never had. 
 Yet this was no place for the faint hearted, and Jimmy knew it. 
 &bquo;What the hell. 
 It's for the people. 
 I'll go for it. 
 I've been through it all. 
 I was made redundant less than a year after I became a Sheffield city councillor, and I've never believed in those sorts of coincidences. 
 You have to fight and fight again.&equo; 
 Now, it wasn't just the man from the Midland Bank who was clearing his throat. 
 Everyone in the board room was either clearing his throat, or shifting position in his seat, or doing both at the same time, which is actually rather difficult. 
 Except Jimmy Boyce, that is. 
 Jimmy's audacious move was making everyone feel uncomfortable, except himself. 
 He had finally settled to his fate: socialist entrepreneur of the grand scale. 
 &bquo;It's early days yet,&equo; said Colin Appleby from the Midland, &bquo;early days&equo;. 
 He seemed to be saying it as much to convince himself as to convince all the rest. 
 They were still busy with their ticklish coughs. 
 But it was now Colin Appleby's move. 
 Fate had got him as far as a leading Sheffield estate agents, Blundells. 
 Colin gave that smile of familiarity, that smile of superiority, that certain smile that says it all. 
 &bquo;Ah, Mike's place. 
 Yes, I am interested in that. 
 I think I will purchase it.&equo; 
 It was like a red rag to a big, black bull. 
 Or, given that we were in a quasi-political domain, a black flag to a red bull. 
 &bquo;I want to buy up all of the city,&equo; said Jimmy. 
 The statement startled no one. 
 &bquo;I'll be happy with Mike's place for the moment,&equo; said Colin, again rubbing in that he knew a thing or two about some of Sheffield's leading businesses, and that there is no substitute for that kind of detailed and expert and intimate knowledge. 
 But now it was time for some wheeling and dealing. 
 Shares in the Sheffield Development Corporation were up for sale. 
 Richard Holmes, the sales and marketing officer of the YMCA in Sheffield, had managed to get his hands on some. 
 He needed to raise capital fast. 
 The man from the Midland Bank said he hadn't the kind of money required. 
 He would have liked to help him out, but&hellip; 
 All eyes were now on Jimmy Boyce. 
 He had the capital, but did he have the inclination to buy into yet another business in order to help one of the managers out? 
 The minimum bid was established. 
 Richard assumed that it would be doubled. 
 &bquo;It would be a bargain at twice that price.&equo; 
 Nobody doubted him, or failed to recognise his temporary financial embarrassment. 
 It's just that they were not inclined to help him out. 
 &bquo;If you can't stand the heat, Richard, old boy,&equo; an anonymous voice said. 
 Jimmy, however, did show some interest. 
 &bquo;I'm always in search of a bargain, sonny &mdash; for the people, you understand,&equo; he added after yet another of those pauses that suggested it might have been an after-thought. 
 He eventually offered Richard &pound;10 more than the asking price. 
 &bquo;Typical Socialist,&equo; someone muttered. 
 Jimmy heard the jibe. 
 &bquo;I'm a Scot, after all. 
 Never forget that, sonny. 
 And I'm not the one with all the money &mdash; just look at the pile that Colin Appleby's got. 
 A typical bloody banker, if you ask me. 
 Not a bit of wonder the country's in the state that it's in.&equo; 
 For readers already familiar with the transmogrification of Sheffield from the Socialist Republic of South Yorkshire to something altogether more &bquo;pragmatic&equo;, you could be forgiven for believing that the drama unfolding around the boardroom table was just one more step along this route, with committed socialists playing the stock market with the best of them. 
 But this was just a game, and before some one points out that the stock market is itself just a game (for somewhat privileged people), I should add that this was just a family game being marketed in Sheffield for Christmas. 
 It's called Sheffield Shares, a form of Monopoly for the late eighties. 
 Local companies are bought and sold, and the involvement and interest that the game generates, as I discovered, is quite intense. 
 Richard Holmes of the Sheffield YMCA told me about the background to the game. 
 The idea is that Sheffield companies pay real money for the privilege of being squares on the game &mdash; for the obvious advertising benefits. 
 The Midland Bank, as the major sponsor, is paying &pound;20,000 for the privilege of being two corners in the game, and having its name and logo on all the notes used in the game. 
 The sponsorship money for the 30 squares amounted to &pound;150,000 and paid all the production and advertising costs for the game. 
 All subsequent profits from sales of the game, which retails at &pound;13.99, go directly to the YMCA for its work in the community in Sheffield. 
 Several other British towns and cities are already committed to developing their own version of this game, with all profits going to the local YMCA. 
 Keith Wells, general secretary of the Sheffield YMCA, and the fourth player that night, explained that the idea originated in Norway, where 95 towns had produced the game to finance their local YMCA. 
 In the United Kingdom, Derry/Londonderry was the first and their game was called The Maiden City, presumably in order not to alienate that half of the community which did not approve of either the name Derry or Londonderry. 
 Keith Wells pointed out that the title Sheffield Shares is deliberately ambiguous &mdash; it can be taken to mean Sheffield's shares, as in &bquo;shares&equo; which are up for grabs by keen or greedy speculators (my interpretation), but it can also mean Sheffield shares as in &bquo;shares its wealth&equo; &mdash; &bquo;and that's basically what we are trying to initiate here. 
 We're trying to get big, local companies to plough some of their profits back into the community through the work of the YMCA.&equo; 
 So what kind of advertising do the companies get for their money? 
 On the share cards used in the game, not only the name of the company is printed, but also some succinct message about the firm. 
 Such messages could (at a push) be used by players to help them promote the value of the shares in that company in the interminable rounds of wheeling and dealing. 
 As in &bquo;How would you like to buy some shares in Stocksbridge Engineering Works &mdash; &bquo;Manufacturers of high integrity alloy, stainless and re-melted steels for the aerospace, energy, bearing and automotive industries. 
 The Strength Behind Engineering Progress&equo;.&equo; 
 Or the more punchy &bquo;How would you like to buy some shares in Gibbs Building Contractors &mdash; &bquo;Don't pick your contractor/ By throwing a dice/ Bring GIBBS into the game/ Ask us for a price&equo;.&equo; 
 Even if it is not read out in the endless rounds of buying and selling shares, then the message, passive though it might be, should still find its way into the living rooms of a high proportion of homes in the Sheffield region. 
 The plan is to sell 20,000 games in Sheffield over the Christmas period that is, 1 in 20 homes. 
 There are 4,000 advance orders. 
 A lot of families, it is hoped, are going to be hearing or reading about Stocksbridge Engineering Works, Gibbs Building Contractors, and a few other Sheffield firms this Christmas. 
 Colin Appleby, of the Midland Bank, is extremely pleased with the way the game has turned out. 
 He says that as well as being the major sponsor of the game, the Midland is the largest private sector employer in Sheffield, and the game provided another opportunity for the bank to demonstrate that it is prepared to invest in the city. 
 But what sort of person will make a good player at Sheffield Shares? 
 I'd already noted the very different methods of the four who had assembled. 
 It would have taken a blind man, or a very naive one, not to spot some connection between their style of play and the kinds of responsibilities and decisions they have to make in the outside world. 
 I asked Colin Appleby first. 
 &bquo;I liked Jimmy Boyce's play for his quick decisions. 
 Richard Holmes was something of an expert at the game, but he ended up as a down-and-out by the end. 
 I think the main ingredient for success is that you have to have a good sense of timing. 
 There is nothing wrong with being a bit conservative and building up financial resources, and not just jumping straight in. 
 Jimmy had a lot of flair but it didn't help him win.&equo; 
 Indeed it did not. 
 Colin's conservativism and steady timing had won him second place. 
 Richard Holmes thought that &bquo;the best man usually wins,&equo; despite the fact that he was last. 
 Jimmy Boyce put it down nearly all to luck &mdash; &bquo;with negotiation skills being very important.&equo; 
 Jimmy said he really enjoyed playing, but his slight worry about it was that at &pound;13.99 it might prove expensive for the unemployed. 
 But what did the winner of the game actually think &mdash; Keith Wells, the man who had brought the game to England but had never actually played it before? 
 There was a long pause, the kind of pause that winners always display as they create a little time to savour their victory. 
 &bquo;It's basically a fine balance between being a good steward of what you have already acquired, and being something of a visionary. 
 Rather like running the YMCA in fact, although I'd never thought of it like that before. 
 It was all jolly good fun as well, of course.&equo; 
 &copy; Geoffrey Beattie Richard Holmes, sales and marketing officer at the YMCA, watches the Sheffield Development Corporation change hands.PHOTOGRAPHS: GEOFFREY BEATTIE Jimmy Boyce: tie askew 
 Law Report. 
 Parliament urged to think again on housing issue:. 
 Queen's Bench Divisional Court Sandwell Metropolitan Borough Council v Bujok Before Lord Justice Watkins and Mr Justice Hutchison November 2 1989 
 IF a dwelling house is in such a state of disrepair as to be prejudicial to health or a nuisance, the tenant may lay an information against his landlord alleging the existence of a statutory nuisance under the Public Health Act 1936. 
 The tenant is not obliged to ensure that the landlord is aware of the defects in the premises or to give the landlord an opportunity to remedy the defects before commencing legal proceedings. 
 Although that is the position in law, the court emphasised that as a matter of commonsense a tenant should first complain to the landlord before exercising the right to prosecute. 
 The facts. 
 Mrs Bujok and her family occupied a house as council tenants. 
 In September 1988 Mrs Bujok laid an information against the council alleging the existence and continuance of a statutory nuisance under section 92(1) of the Public Health Act 1936. 
 It was alleged that the council, being the owners of the premises, were the persons by whose act, default or sufferance the nuisance arose. 
 Prior to laying the information Mrs Bujok had not served an abatement notice upon the council or informed them of the alleged defects in the premises. 
 The justices held Mrs Bujok was not required to ensure that the council were aware of the defective state of the property prior to laying the information. 
 The council appealed by case stated. 
 The legislation. 
 Section 92(1) of the 1936 Act defines &bquo;statutory nuisances&equo; as &bquo;any premises in such a state as to be prejudicial to health or a nuisance&equo;. 
 The decision. 
 Mr Justice Hutchison said the 1936 Act primarily envisages a system where the local authority has a power and a duty to try to secure that premises are not in a state which constitutes a statutory nuisance. 
 Action is initiated by the service of an abatement notice requiring remedial work. 
 If the person in default fails to comply with an abatement notice the local authority is obliged to make a complaint to the magistrates. 
 If the complaint is proved, a nuisance order is made requiring the defendant to get the necessary work done. 
 Effectively the sequence is that the person in default is told what is wrong and is required to put it right. 
 He is given an opportunity to do so, and if he does not, he is subject to sanctions by the court to compel him to do so. 
 The problem arises in connection with section 99 which adapts or applies the provisions to cases where an individual rather than the local authority wishes to make the complaint. 
 Need he serve an abatement notice? 
 The authorities plainly establish that he need not and cannot do so. 
 Does that mean he may lay an information and bring the matter before the magistrates without first putting the person alleged to be in default on notice of what is alleged? 
 The council argued that a landlord, particularly one such as a local authority, cannot realistically be expected to have a system of inspection of all its premises and in practice is entitled to depend upon notification by its tenants. 
 For Mrs Bujok it was argued that the 1936 Act was designed to secure in the interests of the community at large that statutory nuisances did not exist. 
 It was submitted that an owner cannot turn his back on his property because when he purchases and takes on the responsibility of letting, he knows the property will in the course of time deteriorate. 
 He must therefore satisfy himself on a regular basis that it does not constitute a statutory nuisance. 
 In Warner v Lambeth London Borough Council (1985) 15 HLR 45, 50, Lord Justice Glidewell said a private person could lay an information alleging the failure to abate a statutory nuisance without first giving notice requiring abatement. 
 Therefore in the present case the justices came to the correct conclusion. 
 His Lordship reached that decision without enthusiasm because it seemed that as a matter of common sense, notice should be given in such circumstances before criminal proceedings were launched. 
 Lord Justice Watkins said he agreed with reluctance. 
 It was surely repugnant to commonsense that in this area of legal activity a local authority should be prosecuted by one of its tenants without first being given the opportunity by that tenant to remedy the consequences of a neglect to repair the dwelling that the tenant occupied. 
 In law there was no doubt that Mrs Bujok was entitled to commence proceedings without giving notice of the state of the dwelling to the council. 
 But in every other conceivable way that action was entirely wrong. 
 Endless trouble to many people in courts and council offices and much money could be saved by the giving of notice of disrepair. 
 If the council did not react to that notice, then would be the time for the tenant to exercise the right to prosecute. 
 Parliament should give fresh thought to enacting a provision placing an obligation upon a council tenant to give notice to the council before being permitted to commence proceedings. 
 Appearances: John Cherryman QC instructed by Sherwood &amp; Co for the council; Elizabeth Norman instructed by Michael Arnold &amp; Co, Oldbury, for Mrs Bujok. 
 Shiranikha Herbert barrister 
 Input/Tim Radford We come to hit hypocrites with a brick, not to praise them. 
 PERHAPS there should be more hypocrisy in the world. 
 There's plenty in Britain. 
 The British go to night classes in it, and particularly savour high-class hypocrites. 
 They tend to admire people for how they hold themselves and what they say and then blame them more for being found out than for what they do. 
 After a while you get tainted with hypocrisy even if you try not to. 
 You begin to see that it's just another language. 
 You begin to enjoy the way people can say &bquo;The National Health Service is safe in our hands&equo; or &bquo;Nobody deplores apartheid more than we do&equo; or even &bquo;We do not have a shoot-to-kill policy&equo; and you know that another hospital is going to close and that there will be another stitch-up with Pretoria and that another shooting is going to be quietly forgotten. 
 It is, admittedly, refreshing to meet the occasional non-slippery politician. 
 &bquo;Frankly, Tim, we cocked that one up,&equo; an Antipodean politico said to me once. 
 &bquo;We made a real dog's breakfast of it.&equo; 
 It was quite a clever move on his part. 
 Suddenly I didn't have anything else to ask him. 
 Actually, politicians are never that frank, and never honest: the game isn't played that way. 
 And anyway, if somebody is too forthright and says what he really thinks you might feel impelled to hit him with a brick. 
 But then hypocrisy has grades, like judo. 
 In Britain they are all black belts. 
 The British murmur &bquo;You must come and stay with us some time,&equo; and when they part they say &bquo;Let's keep in touch&equo; and they certainly don't mean it, but it greases the wheels of intercourse. 
 And it stops you having to hit them with a brick. 
 There have been grade-A hypocrites all through history. 
 The Roman Emperors were much more slippery than anyone gives them credit for. 
 One of them once issued an edict against promiscuous kissing on New Year's Day. 
 He complained about the absurd cost of mullet and in a wild bid to introduce good housekeeping to Imperial Rome he served for dinner what was leftover from the banquet before. 
 He showed &bquo;excessive&equo; courtesy to the House of the Senate, saying once &bquo;You will, I hope, forgive me if I trespass on my rights as a senator by speaking rather more plainly than I should.&equo; 
 It was the Emperor Tiberius, one of history's unspeakable bounders. 
 Since this is a family newspaper, one shrinks from recounting the things he bounded round doing on Capri. 
 But they had nothing to do with cheap mullet. 
 Tiberius was one of those men you are warned to flee from and report to the police when they arrive offering sweets. 
 He was one of those men of whom the historian Edward Gibbon, who wrote the Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, reported their disgusting activities &bquo;in the decent obscurity of a learned language.&equo; 
 That meant he could say it in Latin, which, when you think about it, was another fundamental hypocrisy. 
 But fundamentalists are not usually hypocrites. 
 They are a different problem. 
 They believe in the truth and they aren't frightened of telling you about it. 
 Their truth of course, but they recognise no other. 
 Furthermore they don't know about &bquo;good form&equo; and &bquo;bad form&equo; and saying one thing and doing another. 
 But fundamentalists are also really dangerous, at least for a while, because hypocrites think that everybody is talking double talk, like them, and awful misunderstandings occur. 
 They don't have to be religious fundamentalists. 
 They can just be people who believe they ought to reshape society from top to bottom. 
 But they are just as difficult to read if you are used to political hypocrisy. 
 But then the British &mdash; or perhaps more properly the English &mdash; deal best with their own. 
 To them, hypocrisy is aggravated assault by other means. 
 They can execrate someone whom they decide is a useless clown and they do this by making him a Lord, giving him the chairmanship of a quango and telling the chaps at the Athenaeum to hand him non-executive directorships in 15 companies and a merchant bank. 
 It's the same as knee-capping, and everybody knows it, but much kinder. 
 Fundamentalists execrate someone for writing a book that they haven't read, and a famous novelist has to go into hiding for fear of his life. 
 Well, at least he knew, right there and then, that he had to go into hiding. 
 There is one thing in favour of total non-hypocrisy: at least you know where you stand, for as long as you are allowed to stand, and, of course, as long as you can be sure they aren't being a tiny bit hypocritical too. 
 Can the call of the wild stop a highway?. 
 Tom Shakeshaft, who is 15, reveals his dismay at plans to drive a dual carriageway right through the beautiful piece of countryside where he lives. 
 OUR family lives in a cottage in Scarisbrick (pronounced Scazebrick) that is more than 100 years old. 
 All the windows look out on fields. 
 It is a magic place, and safe. 
 There are skylarks and foxes and an owl sits in the apple tree staring at us by the fire in winter. 
 Scarisbrick is the largest parish in Lancashire with more than 8,000 acres of Grade 1 agricultural land and flat, with copses and woods. 
 The soil is rich, fertile and dark brown. 
 We were very upset when we found out that a dual carriageway might be built in the fields past the wild duck pond behind our home. 
 My sister Lucy is 18. 
 We've lived here since she was a baby. 
 There is also Laura, 17, me, 15, and William is 12. 
 William and I decided to write to Prince Charles because we know he loves the countryside. 
 Mrs Thatcher cares about the environment so we sent her a letter too. 
 A reply came thanking us for our letter and saying it is receiving attention. 
 We think a bypass would rip the heart out of Scarisbrick, the village where we live and some farmers would be ruined. 
 People all over the country eat vegetables grown in Scarisbrick. 
 The air smells lovely, of leeks and straw and the breeze from the sea five miles away. 
 Our MP Mr Ken Hind (Conservative, West Lancs) wrote to people in Scarisbrick saying that he has pushed the Department of Transport into accepting the need for a bypass between Ormskirk and Southport. 
 Now it is in the government's white paper. 
 Hundreds of residents had a public meeting in the village hall to hear Ken Hind explain about the bypass. 
 It will cost &pound;10 million and could be 13 years before it's built. 
 But it's in the white paper for road building throughout the country. 
 We know the main A570 is a busy road and accidents happen and people who live there think a bypass is a good idea. 
 It must be horrible for them when cars crash outside their homes. 
 But not everyone here thinks the answer is to dig up the fields and destroy the character of the community. 
 But the farmer down the lane is worried because he wanted his little lad, who is six, to be the fifth generation of the family to farm the moss land. 
 He says it is some of the best land in the country, if not the world. 
 William helps the farmer next to us and he is disappointed because he grows really good wheat and spuds and cabbages. 
 He was saving the farm for his grandchildren. 
 Our dad loves walking over the fields when he comes home tired from working in the city. 
 It helps him relax. 
 We go with him, and our sisters too, and sometimes a hare jumps out in front of us or a pheasant flies up from the ditch. 
 We love it here because it is unspoiled and old fashioned. 
 An old man called Mr Leatherbarrow used to grow prize-winning onions on the moss. 
 He had a patch of land he ploughed with a hand plough and he told us stories about coming home across the fields in snowdrifts with carthorses. 
 He had to carry a clothes prop to feel where the ditches where. 
 Once a horse drowned on the moss. 
 We bought our cottage from him. 
 There's a well in the garden. 
 If a dual carriageway is built the fields will be just concrete and we'll lie awake listening to cars zooming past and seeing flashing lights. 
 We'd like the people who want to build the bypass to visit the moss. 
 If they were lucky enough to find a skylark's nest they might not want to spoil the countryside for all of us. 
 What future for Britain's handicapped youth? 
 Michele Hanson examines the problems imposed by budget cuts and staff shortages, and looks at the need for long-term strategies. 
 And in the light of the recent Beverley Lewis tragedy, Adrienne Baker puts the case for self-help groups to relieve the isolation and enormous pressure felt by the mothers of handicapped children A special kind of need 
 THE 1970 Education Act opened a new world of opportunity for children with mental and physical handicaps. 
 It declared them educable, took them out of their own homes and hospitals and brought them into full-time schooling. 
 Bright new facilities and therapies were provided, plus enlightened teaching and special care. 
 In 1970 in one London borough alone, Islington, nine severely or profoundly handicapped children were born. 
 They have had the benefit of such an education and now it is over or about to end, together with almost all paramedical help. 
 At 19 these young people &mdash; and hundreds like them all over the country &mdash; are likely to be going home and staying there. 
 It means, as one parent said, &bquo;19 years of hard work down the drain&equo;. 
 Education is statutory, but once it is over such youngsters are legally entitled to nothing. 
 The Disabled Persons Act 1986 recommends, but does not legislate, that local authorities should define need and provide for it. 
 Adequate provision will probably not be made for Jonathan Rixon, one of the Islington children. 
 He has Seckels Syndrome, a rare disease that stunts growth. 
 He is microcephalic, blind, has severe curvature of the spine, scoliosis, no speech, cannot walk and weighs 3 &frac12; stone. 
 His knees frequently dislocate and he has a painful hiatus hernia which makes him scream. 
 His mother Stephanie holds him, rubs him, talks to him, kisses him, stretches his body out over her knee &mdash; anything to relieve his discomfort. 
 She must also change, bathe, feed, exercise, occupy, entertain and shave him. 
 &bquo;It's not hard work,&equo; she says, &bquo;just constant.&equo; 
 When Jonathan leaves school next year, this will be the pattern of their life. 
 Stephanie cannot duplicate the essential therapies and stimulation the school provides. 
 &bquo;What will happen to his small world when it all stops?&equo; she asks. 
 &bquo;He'll just have me.&equo; 
 Doctors say Jonathan will have a normal life-span and she is worried for the future and what will happen to him after her death. 
 There are community therapists, but not enough to go around. 
 They are poorly paid, mainly young and female, have little chance of career progression and no incentive to remain in the profession. 
 Those available will be busy rehabilitating stroke patients, who take priority. 
 Fears that handicapped youngsters will deteriorate are well founded. 
 Ian Squires, severely autistic, returned to Islington in 1986 from a residential school where he'd been happy. 
 He waited months for a day centre place; when he got one it was unsuitable and he refused to go. 
 He became very fearful of cars, buses and stairs, eventually shutting himself in his room, with the curtains drawn, for 14 months. 
 He began banging his head against the wall, vomiting up his food, lost a great deal of weight and was eventually taken to hospital. 
 Islington's provision is better than most, yet the Director of Social Services, John Rea Price, feels Islington has been penalised for attempting to carry out the Government's own directives on community care. 
 Rate capping has meant that for every &bquo;profligate&equo; pound spent on such provision, &pound;6 has been taken away. 
 Islington cannot even benefit from the &bquo;dowry&equo; system (money paid by a health authority to a local authority for each patient returning to the community from hospital) because their people never went to hospital. 
 Many local authorities have had their budgets cut by reductions in central government They've been given better education and higher expectations, but no future. 
 grants and now have a far greater shortfall of places than Islington. 
 A white paper is expected at the end of this month in response to the Griffiths Report, which recommended that authorities be given greater responsibility for the mentally handicapped. 
 &bquo;Unless Griffiths funding comes quickly to the rescue,&equo; says Rea Price, &bquo;there is no hope of extra resources.&equo; 
 A recent (and the first) report by the Social Services Inspectorate on day services for the mentally handicapped finds much to criticise. 
 It admits that funds are needed for training and basic equipment, and finds that the principles of community care have often not been fully understood. 
 Few middle management have direct experience of the service, need has not been quantified nor fed through to planners, very few local authorities have involved parents, let alone clients. 
 Staff feel undervalued and lack any sense of direction, joint philosophies between health and local authorities are rare, there are no long-term strategies to solve the problems and many centres are overcrowded, offering only shared, part-time places. 
 Centres for the physically handicapped have traditionally taken the elderly, and youngsters finding themselves there after leaving school may feel their adult lives have ended rather than just begun. 
 Mencap's Day Services campaign indicates that the most desperate need is for the severely handicapped and those with behavioural difficulties. 
 For those with more moderate disabilities there are YTS schemes, but these are generalised, not geared to individual needs. 
 The handicapped may be a minority group but it's a vast one &mdash; the last count, 10 years ago, totalled six million people with identified disabilities. 
 A hidden and forgotten problem rather than a small one. 
 &bquo;We're fighting a losing battle,&equo; says Richard Tomlinson, headmaster of the Thomas Delarue School for young people with cerebral palsy. 
 &bquo;It's not a cohesive group and has no political edge. 
 To get money you've got to present an image of disability that reinforces rather than changes the stereotype &mdash; flaxen-haired moppets in callipers. 
 If you actually show people in much greater need, young adults, they're not so attractive. 
 They might dribble. 
 We're articulate enough to fool ourselves that we're nice people, but there's a strong undercurrent to our thinking that encourages us to view people with a disability as lesser, and until we come to terms with that, we will never have a proper support system. 
 At present the whole thing is on guilt money: &bquo;I'm glad it's not my kids. 
 Here's a fiver.&equo;' 
 The present situation reinforces his ideas. 
 &bquo;No social services or Government department will deny that everyone is of equal value,&equo; says Mencap, &bquo;but the services don't support that. 
 Even if people are unattractive, aggressive, distorted, vomit and bite, they still have rights.&equo; 
 Things are, of course, better than they were. 
 In a few areas great progress is being made. 
 In Herefordshire, education, health, social services and voluntary groups are working together on a Lifestyles Project which enables students leaving college to have a life of their own within the community. 
 The Spastics Society has begun Alternative Lifestyles courses for disabled school leavers, &bquo;providing positive alternatives to paid employment and giving them the confidence to take charge of their own lives&equo;. 
 The Open University has begun a new course for people with learning difficulties. 
 Hopefully such ideas will spread to the rest of the community, but for the majority of this year's school leavers it will be too late. 
 They've been given a better education, a longer and healthier life and higher expectations, but no future. 
 LACK of communication is one of the saddest aspects of having a mentally handicapped child. 
 As a social worker, I met family after family and the isolation that having a &bquo;special&equo; child brings was a common theme. 
 The burden inevitably fell mainly on the mothers and it seemed that their loneliness could at least be lessened if they had a regular opportunity to share their experiences. 
 The group began with mothers responding to my invitation and deciding tentatively whether there was &bquo;anything in it&equo; for them. 
 Several women felt too vulnerable or exposed to remain; another left dramatically, announcing that her anger would destroy the group. 
 The beginning was also a time when I was asked if I, too, would soon let them down &bquo;like all the others&equo; and when being there was expressed for all by Janet: &bquo;I'm only here because my daughter is the way she is. 
 I'd rather not be here.&equo; 
 Or by Shirley, who cried soundlessly and then protested: &bquo;I'm not crying for myself; I'm crying for the others.&equo; 
 Gradually trust developed and themes emerged: sadness, &bquo;A grief with no end&equo;; anger, &bquo;Why did it happen to me?&equo;; and frustration with the professionals who could not fully understand their plight. 
 The subjective experiences of these mothers became the maintheme; for example, how rejected they felt by friends or neighbours who crossed the street, not knowing what to say. 
 They talked of their husbands' preoccupation with work, of their normal children's too-early maturing, of integrated and special schools, and of eating &mdash; the hoped-for miracle diet for their child or, often, the consolation they found in food. 
 These mothers had built a cocoon around themselves and their handicapped child which, while keeping away the hurtful comments, wrapped them in with their pain. 
 Then, one week, the quietest woman in the group said: &bquo;This is the only place where I can afford to be honest,&equo; and somehow it seemed the healing process had begun. 
 Leora personified the courage: I remember her trying to calm her screaming autistic son, taking him in her arms, rocking him, comforting him, until at last he became tranquil and quiet and she was left with his violence in her. 
 THEY were brave women and often poetic. 
 Zena, a sculptress, took on the responsibility of caring for her Down's Syndrome grand-daughter when the mother &bquo;upped and offed&equo;. 
 She described how she walked around for months &bquo;with a pain, almost a physical pain, in my heart&equo;; of how she avoided friends and pulled her hat over her face if she met them in the street; of how, at last, she knew she must express her thousand emotions about her little grandchild in the way she knew best, in clay. 
 And when she took this most precious creation to art school, the teacher said: &bquo;Zena, why didn't you tell us?&equo; 
 Then she could cry and let people comfort her. 
 Jean described a trip to the park. 
 While she queued for coffee, her friend held the handicapped child and Jean &bquo;made believe she wasn't mine.&equo; 
 The sadness came out week by week and we confronted it. 
 Incredibly, there was laughter, too, and companionship.We gained energy from each other and I determined that this strength must be used creatively. 
 Their frustration that they would always remain only a mummy could be challenged. 
 We considered how much we, ourselves, hold on to an eternally-caring-for-others role. 
 Stirrings of feminist vitality. 
 I wanted to help these women to &bquo;find a voice&equo; and no longer to place their needs at the bottom of the list of priorities. 
 Gradually we re-evaluated ourselves as women and looked at the way we had always put ourselves down. 
 One member had described the work she does as &bquo;just a little job&equo;. 
 The rabbi's wife had insisted it was her role to attend to their epileptic daughter several times each night; her husband must sleep to be strong for the community. 
 But there was change in the air: one woman began to study and others took their cue from her. 
 I encouraged them to write. 
 Together we compiled an article for publication. 
 It was raw, frank and eventually it appeared in print. 
 By now the time had come for me to hand back to these women responsibility to go it alone. 
 I knew that telling them would be hard but nothing prepared me for their anger and grief during our final month together. 
 &bquo;Was our sadness too much for you to bear?&equo; asked an Iranian woman. 
 &bquo;I too, would like the luxury of resigning,&equo; asserted another. 
 My leaving them was similar to their having to let go of their children. 
 My task had been to help these women to realise their own strengths and to speak out for themselves with courage and dignity. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE wom 
 Lunchtime sessions that pay dividends London's local authorities are enjoying a thaw in relations with the Commissioner. 
 EVERY six months, the Labour council leaders represented in the Association of London Authorities get together for beer and sandwiches with Sir Peter Imbert. 
 Alternately, the Commissioner and his most senior colleagues invite them to Scotland Yard, or visit them at the ALA building nearby. 
 According to Walter Easey, the ALA police policy advisor, &bquo;under Sir Kenneth Newman, this would have been quite impossible. 
 We don't make a big public fuss but he answers our questions, and we answer his. 
 We try to keep it low temperature. 
 It's a very good regular basis for discussing things.&equo; 
 The meetings are only the most visible signs of a thaw in the relationship &mdash; previously something close to undeclared war &mdash; between the Yard and the Labour authorities since Sir Peter's accession in 1987. 
 It affects relations at all levels. 
 Sir Kenneth, for example, set up multi-agency panels to deal with the cautioning of juveniles, designed to keep as many as possible out of the courts. 
 But in many boroughs, Mr Easey said, &bquo;we began to find that whatever we said, they'd go ahead and charge them anyway&equo;. 
 Several boroughs withdrew as a result. 
 The police attitude now, many councils have found, is more receptive, and the panels have been reconstituted. 
 Authorities have begun to find that multi-agency cooperation in other fields &mdash; notably racial violence &mdash; need not be a mask for police interference. 
 The recent attempt by Clive Pearman, the chief superintendent in charge of Notting Hill, to persuade the two local councils to cut off funds to voluntary orgnanisations which he considered inimical was an example of an approach whose shortcomings have come to be appreciated at the Yard. 
 The ALA has had a major influence in redesigning the police recruitment forms, which have gone through three drafts since the Met tried to interest Labour councils in their campaign to attract more ethnic minority officers. 
 The concept of indirect discrimination was, according to the councils, at first unfamiliar to police, who also saw no reason why black candidates might be put off by the former question three &mdash; which asked the country of origin of spouse or lover's parents. 
 These difficulties having been resolved, several former so-called &bquo;loony-left&equo; councils have mounted police recruitment exhibitions and meetings. 
 In part, the emerging entente must be attributed to the authorities' move to the right, towards the Kinnockite orthodoxy favoured by Margaret Hodge, the Islington and ALA leader. 
 But the Met has shown itself increasingly willing to respond to overtures, for example instituting procedures to check criminal records of applicant child-care workers and foster parents for sex offences. 
 Camden and Islington councils, meanwhile, have given the Met a free copy of LAFIS &mdash; a computer programme which they developed at a cost of &pound;15 million, and sold to other authorities for about &pound;2 million a throw. 
 It is now being adapted to give the Met its first method for running cost accounting in 150 years. 
 Five of the 13 Labour authorities still refuse to participate in local consultative groups, although Brent is about to reverse its policy and in Ealing the matter is under discussion. 
 But as the Labour parliamentary front bench scents the thaw, and surveys the possibility of government for the first time in a decade, the party pressures running in favour of detente are increasing. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE soc 
 An astonishing shift of power A crucial speech by Sir Peter Imbert underlines the extent of the differences between him and his predecessors. 
 THE EXTENT of the philosophical shift taking place at the top of the Metropolitan Police was illustrated in a speech delivered by Sir Peter Imbert to the International Police Exhibition and Conference in London at the end of September. 
 The brief reports which have appeared of this remarkable address dealt with Sir Peter's appeal for glasnost within the force. 
 &bquo;Openness must be central to the policing of a democratic and pluralist society,&equo; he said: all too often, the police had retreated behind &bquo;one of many walls of silence,&equo; giving one of a series of stock excuses to the press and public for refusing to disclose information. 
 But the depth of the speech's radicalism has not reached a wider public. 
 Sir Peter justified his call for openness in terms which would have been unthinkable from his immediate predecessor, Sir Kenneth Newman, and indeed from any predecessor: &bquo;Professions, including police, tend by definition to be monopolists of knowledge and through that knowledge, power. 
 Yet to set ourselves up in such a manner contradicts our cherished notion of being part of the community.&equo; 
 Key parts of the speech signalled a conscious, almost revolutionary departure from some of Sir Kenneth's most cherished notions. 
 Its full title was Preparing Police to Deal with a Multicultured Society, and it was on the subject of policing black communities &mdash; still the most vexatious and controversial for both police and their critics &mdash; that Sir Peter made his thoughts most plain. 
 The doctrines and policy of Sir Kenneth Newman were set out candidly in an unpublished, private lecture to the European Atlantic Group in 1983, entitled Public Order in Free Societies. 
 The text has achieved great influence, disseminated widely among senior officers, and taught formally at the Bramshill Police College. 
 Its terms and implications are unmistakably authoritarian. 
 All democratic societies, Sir Kenneth said, must strike a balance between order and freedom, and in &bquo;multi-ethnic societies,&equo; this posed an acute dilemma. 
 In Britain, as in Germany, the first generation of immigrants had been &bquo;relatively law-abiding,&equo; but discussion on ethnic minorities now centred on &bquo;crime and crime control&equo;. 
 As Lord Scarman, reporting after the 1981 riots, had pointed out, the underlying crisis was social and economic. 
 But this was outside the police remit, and meanwhile, they had to be careful not to jeopardise public tranquillity. 
 A permanent state of war with the community was untenable, but the law must be enforced. 
 In multi-ethnic areas, with their &bquo;symbolic locations&equo; like All Saints Road and Broadwater Farm, used for the sale of drugs and stolen goods, police could not act alone. 
 Sir Kenneth said: &bquo;It is not sufficient to think only in terms of crime control. 
 We need to lift the problem to a higher level of generality, encompassed by the expression &bquo;social control,&equo; in a benign sense, in order to provide a unifying concept within which the activities of police and other agencies can be co-ordinated.&equo; 
 Sir Kenneth's agent in this project was &bquo;multi-agency&equo; cooperation, a buzzword throughout the 1980s in police and Home Office circles. 
 But in his vision, the police would be giving the lead, laying down a &bquo;clear social policy&equo;. 
 It was crucial that the police maintain &bquo;operational independence&equo;. 
 Party political interference, he said, rejecting the possibility of a London police authority, was especially to be abhorred. 
 He was trying, he said, to avoid a shift in the balance between freedom and order. 
 But nevertheless: &bquo;We should not forget that an over-regard for individual liberties can put at risk that sense of order and security without which no community can be truly free.&equo; 
 Sir Kenneth concluded with a sideswipe at his critics. 
 It was in these very multi-ethnic areas with their myriad problems that &bquo;political agitators exploit civil liberties issues, and play down the issue of communal security&hellip; individual liberties are important, but we must not become so obsessed with them that we overlook the importance of communal freedom.&equo; 
 Like Sir Kenneth, Sir Peter Imbert recalled the riots of 1981 and 1985, and the conflict between police and ethnic minorities. 
 But the intellectual foundation of his proposed solution was diametrically opposed to that of his predecessor. 
 There were some &bquo;basic principles&equo; to be adopted in police/community relations, Sir Peter said. 
 But in seeking to broaden this perspective, there were &bquo;a number of propositions which police officers need to understand.&equo; 
 First, he said, &bquo;the community itself should be the primary focus, not the police.&equo; 
 The community was not homogenous, but made up of a multitude of different groups with different attitudes and beliefs, while &bquo;relations within the community, between different groups, are significantly outside the control of the police&equo;. 
 Sir Peter then tackled the Newman concept of an interventionist, social controlling police force directly. 
 &bquo;Members of the community are themselves in the course of events engaged in a great deal of informal social control,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It is the community who should, in the main, determine whether police are to be involved in resolving community conflicts.&equo; 
 As police, he went on, &bquo;we sometimes quite wrongly assume the monopoly of good ideas on good community relations and good policing&hellip; the public have a right to be actively involved in determining how policing is developed&equo;. 
 Sir Kenneth Newman's retreat behind &bquo;operational independence&equo; was cast out. 
 The major precepts of his philosophy Sir Peter declared to be: &bquo;Openness, access, power sharing and the sharing of responsibility.&equo; 
 Such precepts, according to one senior officer, were in the context of the previous 150 years of the Metropolitan Police, &bquo;simply astonishing&equo;. 
 Again, developing the idea of power sharing, Sir Peter implicitly criticised his predecessor and his vision of the multi-agency approach. 
 &bquo;If openness and access are problematic, power sharing is likely to be even more problematic. 
 Early efforts to become involved in multi-agency approaches to crime and associated topics were painful experiences&hellip; we wanted to maintain the lead in every forum, to be the gatekeepers of power and have the right of veto if decisons were made which did not suit us.&equo; 
 Those attitudes, Sir Peter said, still lingered. 
 Power sharing was not an easy path to tread. 
 But it &bquo;does not mean a surrender of power; rather it involves sharing of the knowledge which allows different interpretations and constructions to be placed on that information and which in turn can lead to a different conclusion and different solutions&equo;. 
 Police must &bquo;find out from our consumers what it is they require from us, how sensitive we are being to their needs and how satisfied they are with the service&equo;. 
 Polls of Asians, for example, had shown that they felt particularly vulnerable and dissatisfied: it was essential to &bquo;have the will to act&equo; on this information when allocating scarce resources. 
 The police, he concluded, must possess &bquo;an unswerving commitment to communication and consultation within which police and the community are equal partners.&equo; 
 Well-founded criticism could only be met with &bquo;a willingness to change&equo;. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE soc 
 An opening at the Met Despite resistance by its more conservative elements, the Metropolitan Police has begun a process of reform that should lead to improvements in the way it operates and encourage better relations with the public. 
 THROUGH the corridors of Scotland Yard, a wind of change is blowing. 
 The small faction of senior officers who believe that the police must undertake radical reform in order to remain viable has gained an increasingly confidentially in the shape of the Metropolitan Commissioner, Sir Peter Imbert. 
 Implicitly, they have accepted many of the criticisms made for more than a decade by Labour councils and civil libertarians: that a force which has dug itself in behind ramparts of elitist isolationism must begin to respond to demands of the public it serves and their political representatives. 
 Sir Peter speaks frequently of &bquo;power sharing,&equo; a notion which goes well beyond mere participation in the local consultative groups established by the Police and Criminal Evidence Act. 
 It is no coincidence that since Sir Peter became Commissioner in 1987, the relationship between Scotland Yard and London's 13 Labour authorities has seen a new detente. 
 With the new Home Secretary, David Waddington, displaying a marked lack of enthusiasm for Sir Peter's other pet project, the creation of a national detection agency, senior officers are beginning to consider the prospect of a Labour Home Office with equanimity. 
 They find themselves, for the first time, able to contemplate the two main features of Labour policy, greater independence in the investigation of complaints and a London police authority, with something less than total horror. 
 The signs of reform were stirring before the advent of Sir Peter. 
 The anonymous authors of the 1986 annual Met internal appraisal, for example, wrote in deeply critical terms of the effects of government economic policy on the inner city, and the consequences for policing. 
 But the seminal event was Sir Peter's decison to publish A Force for Change, the survey carried out last year by the Wolff Olins consultancy. 
 The report said that the Met was scruffy, rude, and operating from shabby police stations. 
 These important barriers in the fostering of a good realtionship with the public were bad enough: but the force was also undertrained, riven with internal struggle, and isolated from society &mdash; in a &bquo;state of siege&equo;. 
 Most policemen felt beleaguered and misunderstood, their isolation further deepened by criticism from politicians and the media. 
 Reforming and reactionary police officers are not unaware that public confidence in the police has meanwhile ebbed away. 
 Causes celebres like the Guildford Four are bad enough: &bquo;Frankly, we all know the criminal justice system is in tatters,&equo; one superintendent said last week. 
 But as demonstrated by a variety of research &mdash; including both internal police studies and external work like the 1985 Islington Crime Survey &mdash; more damaging still is the accumulation of the public's direct and disappointing contacts with police. 
 The publication of A Force for Change was crucial because it represented an important internal victory for the reformers, and established glasnost as the principle by which the Met was to be put right. 
 The conservatives at the Yard, who include the considerable figure of the Deputy Commissioner, John Dellow, believe that the Met has been reorganised quite enough recently and has been unsettled by a succession of commissioners, all with strong and mutually conflicting ideas. 
 In their opinion, the calling in of Wolff Olins was more of a symptom of this malaise than any kind of cure. 
 The Wolff Olins authors commented that the publication of their work represented a &bquo;profound cultural change&equo;. 
 This, they said, should accompany the &bquo;profound managerial change&equo; which must be next on the agenda, somehow to tackle Londoners' personal and local dissatisfaction with the police. 
 THE main public response to A Force for Change is the Plus Programme, a continuing series of measures drawn up by Deputy Assistant Commissioner Charles Pollard and Commander Alec Marnoch. 
 Reports of the programme have concentrated on its cosmetic aspects. 
 But its greater underlying significance is demonstrated by the fact that it, too, has been strongly opposed by Yard conservatives. 
 According to members of the reforming faction, some officers have attempted to use Sir Peter Imbert's apparent discomfiture over his role in the Guildford Four case to discredit the Plus Programme, with which he is closely identified. 
 At the heart of the strategy is a change of balance in the police's own perception of their role. 
 For 150 years, police have regarded their job as the control of crime and criminals, of coping with social deviancy. 
 Under the programme, what internal documents describe as the &bquo;public service tradition&equo; of the Met is to be emphasised as never before. 
 Aggressive behaviour is to be not only discouraged but monitored and disciplined: the public regarded as consumers, customers and paymasters of policing, not potential villains or troublemakers. 
 Accompanying the programme is To Serve and Protect, 10 commandments for everyday policing issued to every officer, after consultation over its text with MPs and community organisations. 
 The first &bquo;value of every member of the organisation&equo; is &bquo;to uphold the law fairly and firmly&equo;. 
 But some of the others are less familiar. 
 Stressing the need &bquo;to behave in a manner which is neither racist nor sexist,&equo; &bquo;to uphold individual rights,&equo; and &bquo;to cooperate and consult with the community and other agencies in pursuing our purpose&equo; has not gone down well with conservative officers. 
 It would be possible to dismiss the Plus Programme as merely an expression of a different style, without substance or commitment to institutional change. 
 Evidence that it is not is provided by a confidential, internal report on CID work circulated to senior officers earlier this year, the Crime Investigation Priority Project (CIPP). 
 Its authors, significantly, were not an outside firm but police officers. 
 Identifying many of the same failings as Wolff Olins, CIPP's first core recommendation was &bquo;that crime investigation should be made victim-focussed,&equo; and that CID departments give &bquo;higher priority to the victims of crime and witnesses&equo;. 
 The needs of victims, it continued, &bquo;can be clearly stated, are feasible and are not being met. 
 An orientation towards customers&equo; needs and rights is becoming a prevailing ethos in society which the police cannot ignore.&equo; 
 But, CIPP said, &bquo;a number of officers we interviewed do not understand these needs.&equo; 
 The report went on: &bquo;Victim satisfaction is not directly linked to the outcome of individual investigations. 
 It is much more closely concerned with how closely the police adhere to the kind of standards the public expects from any large organisation, including promptness, a sympathetic attitude which indicates individual attention, some conspicuous activity and clear information about what will happen next.&equo; 
 It was CIPP which first recommended the abolition &mdash; announced earlier this week &mdash; of the controversial system of crime screening, by which many offences were not investigated because of a lack of evidence. 
 It was &bquo;discouraging officers from investigating crimes fully&equo;, even those which could be cleared up. 
 The report made a series of recommendations on increasing CID strength, which has fallen sharply from 10 per cent of the force in 1973 to 7.4 per cent, despite an overall large increase in numbers and a recommendation by Her Majesty's Inspectorate that provincial CIDs should make up 12.4 per cent of police. 
 These are now being implemented. 
 But the most significant part of CIPP dealt with institutional change: the perestroika to follow Sir Peter Imbert's glasnost which, if implemented, would represent exactly the &bquo;profound managerial change&equo; recommended by Wolff Olins. 
 The height and extent of the inbuilt hurdles in the way of reforming a police force are not commonly appreciated. 
 The incoming chairman of a public company can swiftly dispose of dead wood, to arrange a board in sympathy with new policies. 
 But police officers can be dismissed only if severe disciplinary charges are proven against them. 
 It is possible to arrange retirements on spurious &bquo;medical&equo; grounds, but this practice was heavily criticised by the Commons Home Affairs select committee earlier this year. 
 The ensuing problems for a reforming commissioner begin at the top, with the Scotland Yard policy committee &mdash; the deputy, assistant and deputy assistant commissioners, by whom all major changes have, effectively, to be ratified. 
 The reformer, like a US president with a recalcitrant supreme court, can secure a majority in his favour only as they retire, die or move on to better things. 
 BROUGHT about by lifetime tenure The lack of accountability is analagous at divisional level. 
 Conservative CIDs, for example, have all sorts of tricks to frustrate an incoming radical chief superintendent, by which they can legally send clear-up rates into a tailspin &mdash; so leading to the rapid transfer of the reforming senior officer. 
 Incredibly, it is almost impossible even to return a detective to uniform simply on the grounds that he isn't very good. 
 CIPP grasped this nettle. 
 Supervision of subordinates &bquo;is focussed on bureaucratic procedures and not on the quality of service at the point of delivery to the public.&equo; 
 All supervising officers, including senior divisional managers &mdash; chief superintendents &mdash; &bquo;should not only hold themselves accountable, but be actively held accountable for the overall level of their subordinates&equo;. 
 To achieve these goals, senior police officers needed a weapon: what the CIPP report delicately called &bquo;deselection&equo;. 
 This might, it said, mean the removal of CID officers to uniform. 
 However, &bquo;many officers interviewed were in favour of administrative dismissal, not currently available under police regulations.&equo; 
 An overwhelming majority of those who still baulked at actual sacking favoured return to uniform, with the view that &bquo;CID officers who are lazy and incompetent were so primarily because of the absence of the eventual sanction of removal from specialist duty.&equo; 
 Sir Peter Imbert and the Yard reformers have important allies in the regional forces: Geoffrey Dear, the West Midlands chief constable, whose boldness at disbanding his serious crimes squad cannot be discounted, whatever his eventual career ambitions; and Paul Condon, the new Kent chief, formerly in charge of Met training and personnel. 
 But circumstances, and the perceived depth of public alienation, are driving even natural conservatives into their camp. 
 Presently underway is a huge opinion survey of police and their customers, covering policing priorities, the quality of service provided, screening and the image of the force. 
 Its co-sponsor is none other than the Police Federation, the junior officers' staff association, traditionally the organisation most wary of reform. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE soc 
 Skating. 
 Joanne Conway, who is hoping to become the first woman for more than 20 years to win five successive titles, made a strong start at the Skate Electic British championships in Basingstoke. 
 The 18-year-old from North Shields beat off eight opponents and a tendon injury to take the lead after the opening compulsory figures. 
 Soccer: Ball denies being &bquo;vulture&equo; over Mills. 
 By Russell Thomas 
 ONE former England international stepped into another's shoes yesterday when Alan Ball succeeded Mick Mills as managerial upheavals continued in earnest. 
 But Ball denied that he had trampled on Mills's feet since arriving at Stoke City less than three weeks ago. 
 The 1966 World Cup winner, starting his caretakership of the Potteries club, said: &bquo;I have not been a vulture on Mick's back &mdash; and he knows that.&equo; 
 Mills lost his first managerial job after seeing his side win only two Second Division games in the last 30 while spending more than &pound;1 million. 
 The results, especially the dooming 6-0 defeat at Swindon last Saturday, tell their own story, even if Ball's arrival at the Victoria Ground from Colchester as first-team coach pointed to his promotion. 
 But there was no treachery, said Ball. 
 &bquo;I came to work with him, shoulder to shoulder.&equo; 
 Ball, 44, says his aim is to be &bquo;the greatest coach and manager in the country&equo;, and he will be given another chance to achieve it if he turns Stoke around. 
 He must apply for the advertised post, which will attract their former England full-back Mike Pejic, Port Vale's first-team coach. 
 Hull are set to name their new manager at a press conference this morning. 
 Among the names touted to succeed the sacked Colin Appleton are Peter Reid, Cyril Knowles and Terry Dolan. 
 The Bristol Rovers chairman, Denis Dunford, said yesterday that the Third Division club would be &bquo;reluctant&equo; to part with their goalkeeper Nigel Martyn and the striker Gary Penrice. 
 Crystal Palace have offered &pound;1 million for Martyn, named in England's B squad on Monday, while Watford have had a &pound;500,000 offer for Penrice rejected but are thought to be considering a higher bid. 
 Andy Platt, England's latest recruit, has agreed a new deal with Aston Villa which will keep him at the club until 1994. 
 Birmingham face FA punishment after their managing director, Ken Wheldon, allegedly sold tickets before the trouble-torn match at Blackpool. 
 He is not named in the charge but the club are accused of breaking all-ticket rules on match-day morning. 
 The FA is taking no action against either club over incidents in the ground. 
 The Welsh Cup holders Swansea were surprisingly knocked out in the third round of the competition by the Vauxhall Conference side Merthyr Tydfil, who won 3-0 at the Vetch Field last night. 
 Littlewoods Cup third round replay: Bolton 1, Swindon 1 (aet) Shearer's instant reply forces third meeting. 
 By Cynthia Bateman 
 SEVEN minutes from the end of extra time Bolton broke the deadlock in their Littlewoods Cup third-round replay that had produced no goals for 113 minutes&hellip; only to let Swindon equalise two minutes later to take the tie to a second replay at Bolton next Tuesday. 
 A powerful 25-yard shot by Brown gave Bolton a justly deserved lead but Shearer's fine header robbed them of it almost immediately. 
 The town of Bolton has just announced that it is to make its football hero, Nat Lofthouse, a freeman of the borough. 
 The Wanderers' manager, Phil Neal, has some way to go before he can expect to be so honoured but he collected several brownie points after his side's spirited performance. 
 Bolton, still smarting from a controversial refereeing decision that denied them a penalty and, they believe, victory at the County Ground at Swindon, had their opponents well and truly cornered at the start. 
 The Swindon goalkeeper, Digby, was forced into throwing more punches than a boxer in his efforts to clear headers, shots and volleys from expertly delivered corner kicks by Comstive on the right. 
 Digby was kept under considerable pressure and at times was found wanting as Bolton, fed by full-backs determined to work their way forward, put everything into attack. 
 Reeves, the Bolton striker, was so certain his header had beaten Digby that he turned away to celebrate, but somehow the effort went wide. 
 And the goalkeeper made a brilliant save to tip Philliskirk's long-range shot over the bar. 
 Swindon lost Hockaday with a fractured cheekbone just before half-time as they were beginning to make an impression on the game. 
 Both sides have been soaring up their respective divisions. 
 Bolton play the same sort of attractive passing football as Swindon under the influence of Ossie Ardiles. 
 But the Lancashire side had the added ingredient of grit and some decisive tackling limited Swindon's chances to two in an hour. 
 The Second Division side seemed bereft of ideas until White suddenly found an opening. 
 His strike in the 68th minute, from a MacLaren pass, beat the Bolton goalkeeper but hit the upright. 
 Encouraged, Swindon at last began to take the initiative and Felgate saved Bolton by tipping Simpson's shot over the bar. 
 But Swindon had a similar close shave in the last seconds of full time as Philliskirk hit the crossbar and the game went into extra time. 
 Bolton Wanderers: Felgate; Brown, Cowdrill, Comstive, Crombie, Winstanley, Henshaw, Thompson, Reeves, Philliskirk, Darby. 
 Swindon Town: Digby; Hockaday, Bodin, McLoughlin, Calderwood, Gittens, Jones, Shearer, White, MacLaren, Simpson. 
 Referee: K Redfern (Whitley Bay).. 
 Bournemouth 0, Sunderland 1 Gabbiadini's dash makes the difference. 
 By David Foot 
 MARCO GABBIADINI, Sunderland's England Under-21 forward, eloquently provided the dash and style that made the difference between these two sides, and it was his sharply taken goal that won this Littlewoods Cup replay. 
 He had already scored in the first meeting at Roker Park. 
 And last night he eluded his two markers to decisive effect although they shadowed him well for much of the match. 
 Bournemouth searched spiritedly for an equaliser in the second half. 
 Their most energetic and impressive player, Shaun Brooks, hung his head when his 20-yard free-kick spun off the bar. 
 In a final gamble Bournemouth brought on a towering central defender, John Williams, as a striker &mdash; but Sunderland held on. 
 Two injury-ravaged sides understandably lacked precision and poise but Gabbiadini was always direct in his approach and it was appropriate that he should give Sunderland the lead six minutes before the interval. 
 He snatched at the ball inside the Bournemouth penalty area and, though confronted by four defenders, enterprisingly veered to his right before hitting the ball on the turn and in off the bar. 
 Sunderland should have scored just before this. 
 Within a frantic five-second period Kite and O'Driscoll blocked close-range shots from Armstrong and Pascoe. 
 The two main threats to Sunderland in the first half came from Brooks and Coleman. 
 Brooks's curling drive brought an equally adept save from Carter, while Coleman's thumping shot skimmed over &mdash; after Blissett had quick-wittedly overrun the ball as it came over from Shearer in one of the home team's brightest moves. 
 Bournemouth: Kite; Bond, Coleman, Teale, Peacock, Shearer, O'Connor, Moulden, O'Driscoll, Brooks, Blissett. 
 Sunderland: Carter; P Williams, Agboola, Bennett, Ord, Owers, Atkinson, Armstrong, Gates, Gabbiadini, Pascoe. 
 Referee: D Axcell (Southend). 
 Chess: England stumble to bronze. 
 ENGLAND tripped at the final hurdle of the world team championship in Lucerne last night, writes Leonard Barden, and finished as bronze medal winners behind the Soviet Union and Yugoslavia. 
 In the ninth and decisive round England could only draw 2-2 against China, so Yugoslavia, leading the US 2-1 with a favourable unfinished game, were assured of silver. 
 Nigel Short's defeat from a superior position swung the result against England. 
 The world No.3 over-pressed on the Queen's side and Ye Jiangchuan countered so strongly against the King that Short lost his Queen and resigned in 45 moves. 
 Ice Skating. 
 Steve Cousins, 17, skated an exciting free programme at the Skate Electric British championships at Basingstoke last night to become British men's champion. 
 In the women's event, the accident-prone Joanne Conway is in danger of being dethroned after suffering another tumble when she missed a combination jump in her original programme, leaving her behind Gina Fulton going into today's free programme. 
 The identical twins Jason and Simon Briggs both won junior titles. 
 Simon won the men's and Jason, with Kathryn Pritchard, the pairs. 
 Sailing: Sleighing in southern seas. 
 By Bob Fisher 
 IN WHAT is becoming a very fast ride across the wastes of the Southern Ocean, Lawrie Smith's Rothmans has moved into second place in the Whitbread Round the World Race. 
 Although the 80ft British sloop charged through the fleet yesterday morning, it is still 68 miles behind the leader, Fisher &amp; Paykel. 
 Less than 80 miles separates the leading six boats. 
 The wind has varied for them between 20 and 40 knots and it has, in the main, blown from the west, allowing them sleigh rides down the faces of the big waves. 
 Rothmans maintained an average of 14.2 knots throughout the morning while most of her close rivals slowed. 
 She is still on a latitude 60 miles to the north of the New Zealand ketch, whose skipper Grant Dalton was going even further south. 
 Dalton gained the lead by moving furthest south last week. 
 Smith was on course to cross ahead of Steinlager 2's track, the 84 foot ketch which won the first leg having slowed noticeably in the past two days. 
 Peter Blake, the skipper of Steinlager 2, has pinned his course to the 50th Parallel, doubtless in an effort to avoid the icebergs; Dalton seems willing to take greater risks. 
 Tracy Edwards and the all-girl crew of Maiden have increased their lead over their Division D rivals. 
 Maiden was 91 miles ahead of Rucanor Sport and 158 miles in front of L'Esprit de Liberte, the class winner of the first leg. 
 Rugby League: Featherstone Rovers 20, New Zealanders 44 Leota puts in his Test claim. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 THE New Zealanders might not have been unduly impressive in the early part of their tour but they have played some exhilarating football at the end, completing their final match against a club side with an emphatic victory, 44-20, over Featherstone Rovers at Post Office Road last night. 
 This was also the last opportunity for candidates to press late claims for a place in the third Test at Wigan on Saturday. 
 Most berths are, of course, already booked. 
 But once again Francis Leota was a highly dangerous, mobile prop, worthy surely of a place on the bench at least on Saturday. 
 At blindside prop George Mann, recruited from St Helens to ease mounting injury problems, ran with the enthusiasm of a man keen to catch the eye; and with Kuiti and Nikau generating a good deal of power in the second row, Rovers were hard pressed to close the gaps. 
 Rovers had a splendid start to the second half, reducing an interval deficit of 4-22 to 14-22 with tries from Trevor Clark and Manning, the result of an astute lofted kick from Sharp. 
 But they had a tiring game on Sunday, energy reserves began to run low and the tourists hit back with tries from Taewa (2), Leota and Kuiti. 
 Rovers enjoyed a heavy advantage in penalties before half-time but it did not do them a lot of good. 
 Smales was successful with two kicks at goal but by half-time the Kiwis looked to have the game well under control, scoring tries through Edwards and Watson by the 16th minute, and through Watson and Nikau in the three minutes before the interval. 
 The first 15 minutes of the second half reminded the tourists that the game was not yet won. 
 But just past the hour Taewa, after good centre play from Watson and Sherlock, reasserted their authority. 
 Two minutes later Leota was seen at his exciting best when he made a midfield break from 45 yards which took him clean through the Rovers defence, and when Taewa scored his second try in the 72nd minute Rovers looked to be subsiding fast. 
 In fact they still had enough resilience to manage a try from short range by Fisher but another highly satisfactory night for the Kiwis ended with Kuiti scoring in the 79th minute and Bancroft landing his sixth goal. 
 Featherstone Rovers: Bibb (S Newlove, 19min); Drummond, Ropati, Manning, Banks; Smales, Sharp; Bell, Clark, Dakin (Grayshon, h-t), Price, Smith, Fisher. 
 New Zealanders: Edwards; Taewa, Watson, Sherlock, Ewe; Clark, Bancroft; Leota, Wallace, Mann, Kuiti, Nikau, Tuuta. 
 Referee: A Bowman (Whitehaven).. 
 Regal return for Schofield. 
 GARRY SCHOFIELD plays his first game for Leeds for almost seven weeks in tonight's Regal Trophy preliminary round match against Ryedale-York at Headingley, writes Paul Fitzpatrick. 
 One of the game's most effective finishers, the Great Britain centre suffered a bad ankle injury playing for Yorkshire against Lancashire in September. 
 John Bentley moves to the wing to accommodate him. 
 Schofield returned home early from Great Britain's tour of Australasia last year and missed many games last season because of a damaged shoulder. 
 Craig Richards has been brought into Bradford's squad for tonight's Stones Bitter Championship match with Castleford, who are four points behind the leaders Wigan with two games in hand. 
 Andy Bateman of St Helens, who have serious forward problems, could be absent for a month after damaging a kidney in Saturday's game with Salford. 
 Hartlepool horrors, Darlington dreams David Hopps on a 20-mile abyss between the League's bottom and the Conference's top. 
 SHADES OF Michael Knighton at Hartlepool as John Smart, hounded last week from the chairmanship of the Football League's bottom club, savoured a memory of brief exhilaration. 
 Knighton juggled a football in front of the Stretford End to advertise his designs on Manchester United; last season Smart merely wandered out to draw the raffle before Hartlepool's FA Cup tie with Bournemouth, but the adrenalin surged just the same. 
 &bquo;I stood in the centre circle and waved my blue-and-white scarf. 
 The crowd chanted my name. 
 It was marvellous,&equo; Smart recalled. 
 Hartlepool drew that fateful tie 1-1, losing not only the replay but the potential salvation of a fifth-round journey to Old Trafford. 
 Long-term debts of around &pound;150,000 continue to finger the back of the club's neck as unpleasantly as a north-eastern sea fret. 
 Takeover talk now dominates with John Hall, the Tyneside entrepreneur and long-time combatant for control of Newcastle, emerging as a possible saviour of Hartlepool. 
 Back from holiday yesterday, he is due to meet the board. 
 Hall could break the embarrassing boardroom impasse at the Victoria Ground. 
 A Wearside businessman, Philip Benison, who precipitated Smart's resignation with talk of a &pound;300,000 takeover, looks unlikely to succeed after failing to persuade other directors at an emergency meeting that the club go into liquidation. 
 The temporary club chairman, Roland Boyes MP, returns to the Labour benches this week suspecting that, compared with a Hartlepool board meeting, the House of Commons is a scene of perfect unity. 
 Whoever takes control, loss of League status beckons an inexperienced team forced to learn on the run. 
 Hartlepool's 3-0 home victory against Wrexham on Saturday was only their second win of the season. 
 To aggravate the hurt, 20 miles down the road Darlington's rehabilitation bounds ahead. 
 Demoted from the League last spring, they are top of the GM Vauxhall Conference. 
 The rivals in adversity could shortly exchange places. 
 Smart's financial intervention six years ago saved Hartlepool from liquidation, but this summer the tide turned. 
 By the first match of this season, his days were numbered. 
 With Hartlepool 3-0 down at Halifax, the chairman tried to move his Rolls-Royce. 
 Jostling fans rocked his car and hurled verbal abuse. 
 &bquo;I don't need this aggravation. 
 If anybody wants to buy this club, they can have it,&equo; Smart stormed. 
 The Hartlepool Mail told of one emergency board meeting hastily convened on a Skipton pavement. 
 Meanwhile, in the manager's office at Darlington Brian Little had responded to the club'sfall from grace with a purge during the summer. 
 On one unsettling day 13 professionals were released, 12 of them on free transfers. 
 &bquo;Some were useful players but they did not gel,&equo; Little said. 
 &bquo;Their experiences at Darlington had left a bad taste in the mouth. 
 I could have got money for some of them, but that would have meant delays.&equo; 
 Little proceeded to recruit some impressive names for a total outlay of &pound;58,000. 
 Frank Gray, Sunderland's former Scottish international, was appointed player-coach. 
 Soon after came David Cork, an inventive inside-forward once with Arsenal and Huddersfield, and York's Kevan Smith, who two years earlier had played with Coventry. 
 In a move that particularly irked Hartlepool supporters, Little also bought Andy Toman. 
 Hartlepool collected a &pound;40,000 sponge to soak up some of their debts, Darlington took in exchange their outstanding midfield player. 
 A striker, John Borthwick, also changed allegiance. 
 Little's insistence that Darlington remain full-time (&bquo;more for advantages of preparation than fitness&equo;) won the support of the club's new chairman, Richard Corden, director of an industrial scaffolding company &mdash; and also, to his chagrin, a worthy candidate for the title of the unluckiest man in football. 
 Corden's playing career ended abruptly when he smashed his knee on his debut for Darlington. 
 His son, Stephen, suffered the same fate when he broke a leg in his first game for Middlesbrough. 
 When Corden joined the Darlington board, they immediately dropped out of the League. 
 But Corden won Darlington's ensuing boardroom kerfuffle, and both he and his new vice-chairman contributed &pound;60,000 to the cause. 
 Little assembled a squad of 20 professionals, many on terms which would make Hartlepool blanch. 
 A youth set-up, from nine years upwards, soon followed. 
 &bquo;It is a gamble,&equo; admits Corden. 
 &bquo;If no one comes through the turnstiles, we'll go bust.&equo; 
 Little speaks persuasively of the Conference's progressive attitudes. 
 Yeovil and Wycombe plan to move into new stadiums at the end of the season, and most clubs carry the stamp of middle-class wealth: Barnet, Cheltenham, Altrincham and Macclesfield. 
 The prospect of recovering League status has encouraged slicker organisation without the disadvantages of decaying grounds and long-term debts that bedevil many of their Fourth Division counterparts. 
 Little, anxious for Darlington to emulate Lincoln City by returning to the League at the first attempt, is convinced that the habit of the League's poorer brethren somehow surviving cannot last. 
 Merely the removal of about &pound;100,000 from the League annually in TV fees and sponsorship can cause an icy blast to the Fourth Division's infirm. 
 Hartlepool should be keenly aware of that danger. 
 After all, back in the Thirties even the holiday posters would tell of &bquo;Healthful Hartlepool &mdash; the most bracing air in the kingdom&equo;. 
 Brian Little has become the first man to win the Vauxhall Conference manager of the month award, worth &pound;250, for the second time in succession, for Darlington's unbeaten run throughout October. 
 Hockey: Reverse order favours England before extended sunshine break. 
 By Pat Rowley 
 IF ENGLAND qualify for the semi-finals of the seventh World Cup at Lahore next February, they will have a three-day rest before trying to qualify for their second successive World Cup final. 
 England get the long rest because their five group matches have been squeezed into seven days while other teams, like Pakistan, the hosts, have their pool games spread over eight. 
 Bernard Cotton, the England manager, is disappointed with the match scheduling. 
 He feels that, for such an important event, countries should have a day's rest between their games, as they did at the 1986 World Cup in London, where England lost in the final to Australia. 
 But Cotton has no complaints about the order for England's group matches. 
 His team would appear to be playing their opponents in reverse of their ranking order. 
 Ireland are England's first opponents, followed by Canada, Spain, Pakistan and West Germany. 
 Britain benefited from such a programme when they finished third at the Los Angeles Olympics and England did at the 1986 World Cup. 
 Cotton said: &bquo;In theory the games should get more difficult as we improve through the tournament.&equo; 
 Should England qualify, their semi-final opponents could be the holders or the Netherlands, who have twice scored five against England this year. 
 Korea, the Olympic silver medallists, duly qualified for the women's World Cup finals when they beat Italy 6-1 in their fourth match at the Intercontinental Cup in New Delhi yesterday. 
 Spain will also take part in the World Cup, at Sydney next May, after holding Japan, who qualified 24 hours earlier, to a 1-1 draw. 
 The last qualifying place is likely to be filled by China, though Ireland still have an outside chance. 
 DRAW: Pool A: Argentina, Australia, France, India, Netherlands, USSR. 
 Pool B: Canada, England, W Germany, Ireland, Pakistan, Spain. 
 Feb 12: Netherlands v France, USSR v India, Ireland v England, Pakistan v Spain. 
 Feb 13: Australia v Argentina, Netherlands v USSR, W Germany v Canada, Pakistan v Ireland. 
 Feb 14: India v Argentina, France v Australia, England v Canada, W Germany v Spain. 
 Feb 15: France v India, Spain v England. 
 Feb 16: Ireland v W Germany, USSR v Australia, Pakistan v Canada, Netherlands v Argentina. 
 Feb 17: Spain v Ireland, France v USSR, Pakistan v England, Netherlands v India. 
 Feb 18: Spain v Canada, France v Argentina, England v W Germany, India v Australia. 
 Feb 19: Ireland v Canada, USSR v Argentina, Pakistan v W Germany, Netherlands v Australia. 
 Feb 21: Semi-finals &mdash; 2nd Pool A v 1st Pool B; 1st Pool A v 2nd Pool B. Feb 22: Play-offs (minor placings). 
 Feb 23: Final and play-offs. 
 Hockey: Points of order may enable England to rest assured. 
 By Pat Rowley 
 IF England qualify for the semi-finals of the seventh World Cup at Lahore next February, they will have a three-day rest before trying to qualify for their second successive World Cup final. 
 England get the long rest because their five group matches have been squeezed into seven days while other teams, like Pakistan, the hosts, have their pool games spread over eight. 
 Bernard Cotton, the England manager, is disappointed with the match scheduling. 
 He feels that, for such an important event, countries should have a day's rest between their games, as they did at the 1986 World Cup in London, where England lost in the final to Australia. 
 But Cotton has no complaints about the order for England's group matches. 
 His team would appear to be playing their opponents in reverse of their ranking order. 
 Ireland are England's first opponents, followed by Canada, Spain, Pakistan and West Germany. 
 Britain benefited from such a programme when they finished third at the Los Angeles Olympics, as did England at the 1986 World Cup. 
 Should England qualify, their semi-final opponents could be the holders or the Netherlands, who have twice scored five against England this year. 
 South Korea duly qualified for the women's World Cup finals when they beat Italy 6-1 in their fourth match at the Intercontinental Cup in New Delhi yesterday. 
 Spain also made sure of their place by holding Japan to a 1-1 draw. 
 DRAW: Pool A: Argentina, Australia, France, India, Netherlands, USSR. 
 Pool B: Canada, England, W Germany, Ireland, Pakistan, Spain. 
 Feb 12: Netherlands v France, USSR v India, Ireland v England, Pakistan v Spain. 
 Feb 13: Australia v Argentina, Netherlands v USSR, W Germany v Canada, Pakistan v Ireland. 
 Feb 14: India v Argentina, France v Australia, England v Canada, W Germany v Spain. 
 Feb 15: France v India, Spain v England. 
 Feb 16: Ireland v W Germany, USSR v Australia, Pakistan v Canada, Netherlands v Argentina. 
 Feb 17: Spain v Ireland, France v USSR, Pakistan v England, Netherlands v India. 
 Feb 18: Spain v Canada, France v Argentina, England v W Germany, India v Australia. 
 Feb 19: Ireland v Canada, USSR v Argentina, Pakistan v W Germany, Netherlands v Australia. 
 Feb 21: Semi-finals &mdash; A 2nd v B 1st; A 1st v B 2nd. 
 Feb 22: Play-offs (minor placings). 
 Feb 23: Final and play-offs. 
 Rugby Union: All black over Ireland Charles Edwards explains how the game has acquired a dim profile with the public. 
 PSYCHOLOGICALLY the Aztecs were probably better prepared for the invasion of Cortes than Irish rugby is for the arrival of the All Blacks. 
 Two undistinguished international seasons, only token involvement with the Lions in Australia and bitter controversy about South Africa have combined to give the game in Ireland possibly the worst public profile it has had. 
 The visit to South Africa of several eminent Irish Rugby Football Union officers and their wives &mdash; among them the president, Ronnie Dawson &mdash; triggered off an acrimonious debate which looks likely to run on in spite of an IRFU statement regretting the safari. 
 The union's promise that no Irish team will be allowed to go to South Africa &bquo;whilst the remainder of the apartheid laws exist&equo; has not convinced many people, while drawing the wrath of their recent hosts down about the heads of Dawson and his fellow-travellers. 
 The IRFU's South African links have been criticised in the past, notably when Ireland toured there in 1981 amid a storm of public and governmental condemnation. 
 Now those critics have been joined by what entrenched IRFU committeemen may regard as the Enemy Within. 
 For the Irish rugby schools and clubs have loudly condemned the IRFU which, they say, purports to represent them yet made no efforts towards consultation before participating in the South African Rugby Board's centenary celebrations. 
 The absence of Dawson &mdash; or any deputy &mdash; from Ireland's recent tour to North America has also been deplored. 
 This courtesy might not be necessary, strictly speaking, but the fact that All the President's Men were in South Africa as guests of the SARB at the same time was not a help. 
 And the IRFU did nothing for its cause by not awarding caps for the matches against Canada and the United States and by refusing to pay the players the regulation daily allowance because the tour was one day short of the stipulated duration. 
 So the union &mdash; and the game &mdash; are held in low esteem at present. 
 And, in the battle for sporting hearts and minds, Irish rugby simply cannot afford that unhappy situation. 
 In terms of mass appeal rugby comes fourth after Gaelic football, hurling and soccer. 
 Many believe that playing standards will improve only when more young players are attracted to rugby, which means getting them into the clubs at youth level. 
 But, if and when Jack Charlton brings the national team to the World Cup, every boy in the country will be kicking a soccer ball about. 
 But that is in the future. 
 At present the advent of the All Blacks is concentrating the national rugby mind wonderfully and all four provinces have been in early-season action. 
 Munster, the only Irish team ever to defeat the New Zealanders, drew with Glasgow and District and overwhelmed Pontypool. 
 Leinster did a similar demolition job on Llanelli and lost narrowly to the South-west Division. 
 Ulster, the reigning inter-provincial champions and the most consistent province over the past five seasons, enjoyed an easy win over the Scottish Saltires. 
 But Connacht, traditionally the weakest of the provinces, had a disastrous start, losing heavily to Glasgow and District and also to the humble Scottish North-Midlands, whose victory was their first for seven years. 
 The inter-provincial championship went to Ulster for the sixth consecutive year, and Munster have shown good form. 
 But realistically it is hard to predict anything other than a 100 per cent success rate for the All Blacks in Ireland. 
 The international at Lansdowne Road in 10 days could be traumatic for Ireland, whose only successes since January 1988 have been achieved against weak opposition which, oddly enough, includes Wales at the Arms Park last February. 
 Ireland have decided not to introduce a string of new players against New Zealand. 
 And one of the two new caps, the Australian Brian Smith who takes over at fly-half from the injured Paul Dean, has had a less than spectacular season with Leinster. 
 And the captain? 
 Philip Matthews had a brief incumbency and was replaced for the North American tour by David Irwin, who in turn gave way because of injury to Willie Anderson. 
 Anderson captained Ireland on their short tour of France, led them to an unexpected victory over a French XV and keeps the job now but age and waning powers put a question-mark over his selection for the team at all. 
 Some almost see him as a non-playing captain. 
 An Irish audience saw the All Blacks for the first time when they trained at Donnybrook on Monday, and the first impression of Mick Quinn, the former international fly-half, was: &bquo;The omens are not good. 
 They train harder than we play.&equo; 
 A good international season is essential if Irish rugby is to regain lost ground, improve its image and win back popular support. 
 But in the present climate that is a somewhat pious hope. 
 Dawson must know how Montezuma felt as his Aztec empire began to crumble around him. 
 Hong Kong form is all Chinese to the average punter. 
 FOR THE second Wednesday running racing from Hong Kong will be screened by SIS in the betting shops this afternoon, with Southwell's all-weather fixture again appearing to be cold shouldered, writes Chris Hawkins. 
 SIS will also be covering Kelso, Newbury and greyhound racing from Bristol so the need to give punters the opportunity to additionally sample delights from the orient hardly seems necessary. 
 There has been some sharp criticism in some areas of the sporting press &mdash; principally on three counts: That the turnover generated does not contribute to the levy; that it is a snub to the all-weather experiment; that it is pure exploitation of the punter. 
 Terry Ellis, racing director at SIS, answered these points for me yesterday, commenting: &bquo;First of all it is factually incorrect to say that the turnover is not subject to levy. 
 All horse racing is. 
 I cannot understand how that misconception arose. 
 Secondly, the decision to screen 16 Hong Kong meetings between now and the end of March was taken last year before firm plans about all-weather racing had been drawn up. 
 Our yearly schedules are finalised in October by our users committee. 
 &bquo;We covered Lingfield's inaugural all-weather meeting because that simply replaced a flat fixture scheduled for that day. 
 Southwell's all-weather meeting last Wednesday was not on the original fixture list and neither is today's, but we will be covering meetings there on November 14 and 21 because there were ordinary jump meetings already scheduled. 
 &bquo;At the turn of the year we shall cover every all-weather fixture at Lingfield and Southwell in addition to the usual turf fixtures. 
 &bquo;The third point that we are merely exploiting the punter is unfair. 
 Although the major bookmaking firms are represented on the users committee, they were originally not keen on Hong Kong because it meant bringing in extra staff in the mornings. 
 &bquo;By arrangement with the sporting press we are providing full racecards and form for Hong Kong so punters are hardly betting blind. 
 And in any case, the punter has the final veto &mdash; no one forces him to bet.&equo; 
 This is true but Hong Kong form means nothing to the average punter. 
 It is like looking at the menu in a French restaurant. 
 Ellis declined to say how much the Royal Hong Kong Jockey Club is being paid for the service, but this is not money which British racing is missing out on, as a contract, subject to review after three years, was drawn up with the Racecourse Association at the beginning of SIS transmission. 
 Even so, the decision to cover Hong Kong has now been overtaken by developments. 
 The rapid strides made on the all-weather front really makes such betting fodder superfluous. 
 Leinster face an uphill task. 
 By Robert Armstrong in Dublin 
 THE ALL BLACKS begin the Irish leg of their 13-match tour at Lansdowne Road today against Leinster, who have never beaten a major touring side. 
 Leinster have named a team that looks strong on paper, including eight internationals, yet they recently lost to both Munster and Ulster in the Inter-Provincial Championship. 
 Such is the mood of pessimism here it is hard to find anyone who believes the All Blacks, having won their seven matches in Wales, will face any significant threat during the next fortnight. 
 Ulster, the provincial champions, may well fancy their chances on November 21, but Leinster look certain to face an uphill struggle even though the tourists have rested 13 of the team that beat Wales. 
 Leinster will be hard pushed to keep the score within the respectable margins of defeat set by their predecessors. 
 In 1964 the All Blacks defeated Leinster 11-5, they won 17-8 in 1972 and scraped home 8-3 in 1974. 
 However, during the Eighties Irish provincial rugby has assumed a Third World status in relation to New Zealand's. 
 Leinster have been undermined by their failure to secure prestige fixtures since the mid-Seventies. 
 When New Zealand last toured Ireland in 1978 Leinster were ignored. 
 The same thing happened in 1984 when the province was denied a fixture against the Wallabies. 
 Such neglect has done nothing for their confidence. 
 Even so, the All Blacks, who include seven capped players, will give today's opponents due respect. 
 As their coach, Alex Wyllie, remarked: &bquo;When we arrived in Wales we were told Cardiff were no damned good and look how well they played against us. 
 Leinster are quite capable of doing the same.&equo; 
 Wyllie is confident his Western Samoan wing, Va'aiga Tuigamala, will play although he is still niggled by an ankle injury received against Neath two weeks ago. 
 The Test flanker Alan Whetton, whose hamstring injury kept him out against Wales, will form a powerful back row with Kevin Schuler and the international No.8, Zinzan Brooke. 
 The tourists will field four backs aged 21 or under. 
 For their part, Leinster are boosted by the presence of four players already selected for Ireland to play New Zealand in Dublin on November 18. 
 They are Brendan Mullin, the Lions centre, Fergus Aherne, the scrum-half, and the two new caps, Nick Popplewell at loose-head and Brian Smith, the fly-half. 
 No doubt Smith, the Oxford University Australian, who won five caps for the Wallabies, will feel a bit closer to home facing the All Blacks twice in the next 11 days. 
 It will be fascinating to see how Smith, a gifted all-round footballer, shapes up in his prospective international partnership with Aherne. 
 Equally intriguing will be the line-out performance of the young London Irish lock, Neil Francis, who has been left out of the current Ireland squad. 
 Fortunately, Leinster's front five, which includes the experienced tight-head prop Des Fitzgerald, looks up to the task of scrummaging against the All Blacks. 
 However, real problems may arise once Leinster attempt to win the loose ball. 
 Leinster will be led by their third captain in as many matches, the centre Paul Clinch. 
 Leinster: F Dunlea; J Sexton, P Clinch (capt), B Mullin, P Purcell; B Smith, F Aherne; N Popplewell, N Kearney, D Fitzgerald, N Francis, B Rigney, P Kenny, K Leahy, A Blair. 
 All Blacks: M Ridge; J Timu, B McCahill, W Little, V Tuigamala; F Botica, B Deans; G Purvis, W Gatland, S McDowell, I Jones, G Whetton (capt), A Whetton, K Schuler, Z Brooke. 
 Racing: Scudamore nears Francome's record. 
 By Chris Hawkins 
 PETER SCUDAMORE is now only four short of John Francome's jumping record of 1,138 career winners after riding a short-priced double on Monaru and Huntworth, both trained by Martin Pipe, at Devon yesterday. 
 Monaru was bought in for a course record of 11,500 gns after winning the Carlsberg Selling Hurdle but Pipe had no complaints and said: &bquo;People don't have to run in sellers if they don't want to. 
 I think there should be more of them.&equo; 
 Huntworth, Pipe's only other runner at the meeting, provided Scudamore with his 71st success of the season when making all the running in the Happy Eater Restaurant Handicap Chase to make up for a string of disappointments. 
 It was only the third time Huntworth has got round in his last 13 races under Rules, but those three completions have brought three wins. 
 The biggest cheer in this race, however, was not for the winner, it was for Barry Wright, who finished last of the four on top weight Midnight Madness. 
 Barry was unseated at the fifth, but hung on to the reins, ran alongside Midnight Madness for a few strides and bounced back into the saddle to continue in pursuit. 
 Steve Cauthen rode his 163rd winner of the season on My Lord at Leicester, where ten races attracted a crowd of less than 600, and announced that he would not be riding again on the flat this season. 
 He also made it clear that he will not be participating in the all-weather racing. 
 Ray Cochrane has expressed similar sentiments. 
 Back to jumping and there is a divergence of opinion among the bookmakers about Saturday's Mackeson Gold Cup. 
 Hill's make Prize Asset favourite at 11-2 but Beau Ranger leads the market at the same price with Ladbrokes. 
 Beau Ranger, as expected, has top weight of 12st and must give 24lb to Prize Asset. 
 At Newbury this afternoon Richard Dunwoody, left behind with only 20 successes so far by the lightning Scudamore, should kick off with a winner on Atlaal, trained by John Jenkins. 
 Atlaal (12.30) has had an outing on the flat recently and should be fit enough, despite the fact that this is his first hurdles race since February. 
 Trainer in form, Josh Gifford, introduces a potentially high class recruit to the chasing ranks in French Goblin (1.0), who makes his first appearance over fences in the Cokethorpe Novice Chase. 
 French Goblin was a good staying hurdler last season and has the physique to do well over fences. 
 A similar remark applies to his stable-companion, Green Willow, who was even better over timber. 
 He makes his fencing debut in the Halloween Novice Chase but has a useful opponent in Young Snugfit (2.00), who may make experience tell, having jumped well and quickened impressively to beat Brave Defender by ten lengths at Kempton last month. 
 Reg Akehurst's horses are running very well and Solidasarock (1.30), ridden by Scudamore, should give the Epsom trainer his eighth winner from 13 runners this season in the Curridge Handicap Chase. 
 This chestnut was second to Royal Cedar at Newbury last month. 
 Any overnight rain will suit Duckhaven (3.30) in the concluding Chequers Conditional Jockeys Handicap Hurdle over an extended three miles. 
 This heavy ground specialist beat Lord Mustard (winner yesterday) at Hereford on his final effort last season over three miles and a furlong. 
 All-weather racing is again popular at Southwell, where there are nine races. 
 It should be worth waiting for the last in which Mick Ryan's Les Amis (3.40) is well drawn and must be fancied on her two lengths defeat of Quinta Royale at Folkestone. 
 The Jockey Club will be taking steps next season to try and make quality jump racing more competitive. 
 So often in conditions races we see just a handful of runners competing for good prizemoney, a situation which has prompted a reduction in Pattern races from 139 to 101 in the 1990-91 season. 
 A new Jump Pattern has been worked out and some new races created specifically for horses whose optimum trip is two and a half miles, a distance not previously catered for at championship level both over hurdles and fences, although there will still be nothing for novice chasers over that distance at the Cheltenham Festival. 
 Racecourses have been advised by the Jockey Club to make their own security arrangements against the use of sonic binoculars of the type allegedly used to frighten Ile De Chypre at Royal Ascot last season. 
 Cricket: Wise counsel needed in SA talks on tour. 
 By John Perlman in Johannesburg 
 WHEN 20 representatives of the South African Cricket Union and the National Sports Congress sit down together in a Johannesburg hotel tonight it is to be hoped that among them is someone with the wisdom of Solomon. 
 Both parties are taking the talks seriously and a commitment to resolving their diametrically opposed views of next year's rebel cricket tour by an English team is evident. 
 But a gulf in perception will have to be bridged, leaps of faith made and a deal struck. 
 And to do that will require individuals with the ability to clarify the issues and an acute sense of when they might advance by retreating a little. 
 The eve-of-talks optimism of the Sacu president, Geoff Daikin, was not even dented by the state-run television, which quoted him as saying that Sacu would push for the tour at all costs. 
 &bquo;They didn't even speak to me,&equo; he said. 
 Daikin said he had indications from &bquo;people involved in making a better South Africa&equo; that &bquo;if the tour were not to take place there are certain advantages that may flow from that decision, a highly attractive package for young South Africans of the future that involves more than cricket&equo;. 
 He would not go into detail on what he called &bquo;sensitive issues and sensitive talks&equo; but said: &bquo;I would be a fool to hinder this by insisting on a cricket tour.&equo; 
 He may first have to overcome the scepticism of some members of his own group. 
 Daikin believes that the two parties have an important starting point. 
 &bquo;We are all working for the same goal,&equo; he says. 
 But it will be crucial for them to move on quickly to those considerable differences &mdash; on politics, the boycott and the role of sport in social change &mdash; which have set them at odds and made tonight's meeting necessary. 
 &bquo;They must take serious note of the political dynamics taking place in the country,&equo; said the NSC's Krish Naidoo. 
 &bquo;It is an opportunity to spell out to them what these dynamics are.&equo; 
 Naidoo reiterated that the NSC was expecting Sacu to come to a decision and could not ease it for them by offering guarantees of future tours. 
 &bquo;We are asking them to become part of a process of change. 
 And in being part of that process you have to show good faith. 
 They must decide whether they want to be part of the decaying apartheid system or part of a new South Africa.&equo; 
 If Sacu is to choose the latter road, the NSC may have to give them a clearer idea of what they will meet as they travel along it. 
 Newport look for coaches to turn a falling tide. 
 By David Plummer 
 NEWPORT, who last week suffered the indignity of a record score by the All Blacks in Wales, are looking for two new coaches. 
 Keith James and Jim McCreedy, who had been in charge for an increasingly fraught 20 months, had their resignations accepted this week. 
 They made a verbal decision to go earlier this month after a 48-0 home defeat by Newbridge, and no effort was made to persuade them to stay. 
 James volunteered to stay on until the end of the season, and he remains in charge for tonight's visit to Cross Keys, but Newport are opting for a complete change. 
 The former Wales and Lions prop Charlie Faulkner, currently the Wales B assistant coach, who preceded James and McCreedy at Newport, has already announced his availability, though it is conditional on &bquo;certain changes being made&equo; &mdash; in other words, the resignations of those on the committee he fell out with two years ago. 
 Though one of Wales's traditional elite clubs, Newport, like the national team, have struggled through the Eighties with the exception of one season. 
 Matters are now coming to a head because of the advent of leagues next season. 
 Quietly, amid the fall-out of Saturday's defeat of Wales by the All Blacks, the Welsh Rugby Union and the Merit Table organisation meet on Monday night to discuss the issue. 
 Newport have lost 11 of their 14 matches this season, including the last eight. 
 Only Ebbw Vale have conceded more than their 431 points. 
 Newport have also been embroiled in allegations, by Glamorgan Wanderers and Penarth, of poaching. 
 The latter rumpus, still going on, emphasises Newport's plight: they were grateful for players from Welsh rugby's traditional whipping boys. 
 The danger after New Zealand is that players may want to leave. 
 The Wales B wing Damion Griffiths was refused a permit to play for Cardiff tonight. 
 At the heart of the matter is the direction Newport are to take. 
 Conscious of their tradition, they have jealously preserved the game's amateur ideals. 
 With the walls collapsing around them, however, many are urging that Newport forget history and get into the market place &mdash; or accept perpetual mediocrity. 
 World Cup fever comes to Trinidad and Tobago. 
 THEY were jostling in the streets of Trinidad and Tobago yesterday as 29,500 tickets for the decisive World Cup qualifier with the United States went on sale at six outlets nationwide &mdash; and sold out within two hours. 
 However, those who emerged empty-handed from all the pushing and shoving that went on should be able to see November 19's game on giant video screens which the government is hoping to install in three different locations. 
 The rush for tickets was sparked by Sunday's goalless draw between the US and El Salvador which left Trinidad needing only to draw against the Americans in the National Stadium to qualify for next year's finals. 
 AC Milan's Marco van Basten, in great form since his return from injury, is set to lead the Dutch attack in the decisive World Cup qualifier with Finland in Rotterdam on November 15. 
 The European Footballer of the Year, who came on as substitute in Holland's last qualifier against Wales four weeks ago, has been named in the squad and is certain to start the Group Four match as the Dutch seek the point they need to qualify for the finals. 
 Missing is the injured PSV Eindhoven striker Wim Kieft, his club colleague Adick Koot and the Roda JC striker John van Loen. 
 But Adrie van Tiggelen, the Anderlecht defender who missed the Wales game because of suspension, has been recalled to a 16-man squad which also includes AC's Frank Rijkaard. 
 But the European champions will again be without their injured captain Ruud Gullit, their third AC Milan player, who is still recovering from knee surgery, and the PSV midfielder Gerald Vanenburg, who has damaged knee ligaments. 
 Gullit is expected to play again in late December. 
 Portugal, who beat England 1-0 in the last World Cup, need to do a bit more than that next Wednesday to deny the Czechoslovakians a place in next year's finals &mdash; they need to win by four goals. 
 To add to the degree of difficulty in Lisbon, the Portuguese are without their outstanding striker Paulo Futre, banned for two matches after being sent off in an earlier game. 
 In an attempt to restore some threat on goal, the Portuguese have recalled to the squad Antonio Pacheco, billed as &bquo;a speedy winger&equo;, and Antonio Sousa, billed as &bquo;a free-kick specialist&equo;. 
 PSV Eindhoven's striker Romario, seems to have sorted out his problems with the Dutch champions. 
 Romario scored five goals in five days for PSV then said he was unhappy. 
 The Brazilian complained that some team-mates shunned him and criticised him behind his back, with Soren Lerby and Kieft the chief culprits. 
 But after talks with the coach, Guus Hiddink, and Lerby, differences were patched up. 
 Said Hiddink: &bquo;He hardly speaks Dutch and that leads to misunderstandings from time to time.&equo; 
 Littlewoods Cup third round replay: Bolton 1, Swindon 1 (aet) Shearer's instant reply forces third meeting. 
 By Cynthia Bateman 
 THE town of Bolton has just announced it is to make its football idol Nat Lofthouse a freeman of the borough. 
 Seven minutes from the end of this Littlewoods Cup third-round replay, it was beginning to look as though they should accord the same honour to the current Wanderers' manager, Phil Neal. 
 After 113 minutes of attacking football that had Second Division Swindon reeling from the start, Third Division Bolton finally took the lead through Brown. 
 But with only five minutes left Swindon equalised with a fine header from Shearer to force a second replay. 
 A toss of the coin &mdash; the Swindon manager, Ossie Ardiles, not knowing his heads from his tails &mdash; ensures Bolton will again have home advantage. 
 Ardiles's side were not sure whether they were on their heads or their tails as Bolton, still smarting from a refereeing decision they believed had denied them victory in the tie at the County Ground, swept forward. 
 Three perfectly placed corner kicks in the first 15 minutes had the Swindon goalkeeper, Digby, throwing more punches than a boxer as he beat out volleys, headers and rebounds, and his defenders helped clear off the line. 
 But Bolton, playing attractive passing football, with their two full-backs bringing the ball forward to give the strikers excellent service, were unable to capitalise, mainly due to the efficient marking by Gittens and Calderwood. 
 The home side were equally decisive in defence and it was a full hour before White suddenly found an opening. 
 His shot hit the upright but Swindon, encouraged, at last began to make an impression and Bolton survived a narrow squeak as Simpson's powerful effort was tipped over by a leaping Felgate. 
 Bolton refused to lie down and in the last kick of normal time a shot from Philliskirk cannoned off the crossbar. 
 Extra time was deadlocked until well into the second period when both Bolton full-backs moved up, Cowdrill passed square to Brown and a powerful long-range strike hurtled past Digby. 
 Almost before the home supporters in the crowd of 11,533 could catch their breath Swindon equalised with a powerful header from Shearer five minutes from the end. 
 Ardiles said afterwards: &bquo;It was a great game of football. 
 I enjoyed and suffered at the same time.&equo; 
 Swindon's right-back Hockaday went off with a fractured cheekbone just before half-time. 
 Bolton Wanderers: Felgate; Brown, Cowdrill, Comstive, Crombie, Winstanley, Henshaw (Came, 90min), Thompson, Reeves (Jeffrey, 108), Philliskirk, Darby. 
 Swindon Town: Digby; Hockaday (Cornwell, 44), Bodin, McLoughlin, Calderwood, Gittens, Jones, Shearer, White (Hunt, 107), MacLaren, Simpson. 
 Referee: K Redfern (Whitley Bay).. 
 Boxing: Penalosa flies in. 
 By John Rodda 
 AT a time when there are searching questions about the medical aspect of the sport, it may seem unfortunate that a man who suffers from a disability is fighting for a world title. 
 Dodie Penalosa from the Philippines, who challenges Dave McAuley for the International Boxing Federation's flyweight title at Wembley Arena tonight, suffered from poliomyelitis when he was a child and has been left with a weak left leg and restricted mobility. 
 This does not seem to affect his boxing, however, for he won the title for which he challenges tonight twice, and he held the light flyweight championship through three defences. 
 His championship-winning days began in 1983 and he lost the flyweight title two years ago, since when he has remained unbeaten. 
 There has been almost a hush about tonight's event. 
 Penalosa did not arrive in Britain until the weekend, apparently because of visa problems, while McAuley is disgruntled because he wanted the fight to be in Belfast, where it was originally arranged until he suffered an injury. 
 Penalosa's lack of mobility is counter-balanced by his southpaw stance and hard punch. 
 He may be surprised at encountering an opponent in this weight division who stands 5ft 8in and has something special in body punches. 
 One hopes he has properly overcome jetlag. 
 The London middleweight Rod Douglas, who has been in hospital since being beaten by the British champion Herol Graham two weeks ago, is expected to leave hospital &bquo;in a week or so&equo;, according to his manager Mickey Duff, who said last night: &bquo;He is going to make a complete recovery. 
 A second head scan was perfectly OK, thank God.&equo; 
 Jim McDonnell left Charing Cross Hospital in London yesterday after his defeat by Azumah Nelson in their world super-featherweight title fight on Sunday. 
 Sports Politics: Aid for Universiade John Rodda on a &pound;3 million boost for the student games. 
 UNIVERSIADE GB, the company organising the World Student Games at Sheffield in 1991, will today make room on its board for a new director. 
 That is the deal it must accept as a condition of a &pound;3 million grant from the Sports Council. 
 It is the biggest influx of support it has had. 
 In the Nelson Mandela room at Sheffield town hall yesterday Peter Yarranton, the chairman of the Sports Council, handed an envelope to Peter Burns, executive director of the organisation. 
 It did not contain &pound;3 million but it was, Yarranton said, a token of the Sports Council's commitment to make the games &bquo;a success story for Britain&equo;. 
 Burns will tell his board today that the Sports Council wants a non-voting member watching over the way the cash is spent. 
 The Sports Council already provides the Sheffield organisation with on-the-ground technical expertise in the area of sports organisation and architectural advice. 
 The Sports Council will await Universiade GB's concurrence with the deal before nominating their man, but it ought to be one of their members with business acumen &mdash; which means either David Simon of BP, who is most unlikely to have the time, Raymond Michel, formerly with a distillery, or Norman Jacobs, a partner in one of Britain's largest firms of solicitors. 
 While the construction of arenas bounds on &mdash; an enormous amount has been accomplished in the past month &mdash; the organisation side does not seem to show the same urgency. 
 That should change with the decision reached two weeks ago that Sheffield will have to pay for the host broadcasting operation of television. 
 The hope that the BBC or ITV would move into this job as they would for Commonwealth or Olympic Games was never realistic but it has taken Sheffield a long time to come to terms with the fact. 
 Now they hope to contain the basic costs of providing coverage of most of the 10 sports to &pound;1.4 million. 
 They will offer package programmes at minimal cost, in the hope of recovering their outlay and, most importantly, providing an inducement for a sponsor to put up &pound;6 million for world-wide exposure. 
 The BBC, Sky and BSB have all indicated that they want programmes. 
 That will help the marketing. 
 Densu, the largest advertising agency in the world, has asked to handle the entire marketing operations for Japan, where the World Student Games are more popular than anywhere else in the capitalist world. 
 The breakdown of an estimated &pound;30 to &pound;35 million for the organisational costs goes roughly like this: &pound;18 million from official suppliers, in kind, such as computers, copiers and clothing; &pound;6 million from ticket sales; &pound;3 million from the Sports Council and &pound;6 million from advertising. 
 The main events arena, yet to be named, is the source of one anxiety in the building programme, which is handled by Sheffield Council. 
 The negotiations with the American company that will run the facility after the Games have taken an inordinate amount of time by British standards, though not by American, and the completion date is now May 10, 1991, barely two months before the opening ceremony. 
 Manchester's attempts to stage the 1996 Olympic Games are being hindered by British sport's two-faced approach to South Africa, said Sam Ramsamy, chairman of the South African Non-Racial Olympic Committee, at a civic reception in Manchester yesterday, writes Michael Morris. 
 Rick Parry, director of the Manchester Olympic bid committee, commented that the city should overcome this difficulty by its record of opposition to apartheid, which already includes staging anti-apartheid festivals. 
 Egerton ready to fill Richards void. 
 DAVE EGERTON has the chance to emerge from the shadow of Dean Richards when England begin their Five Nations Championship campaign against Ireland at Twickenham on January 20. 
 Bath's No.8 is the favourite to take over from the British Lion after Leicester confirmed yesterday that Richards would miss the rest of the season. 
 Richards, injured in Leicester's Courage Clubs Championship game at Wasps in September, had an operation on his injured right shoulder last week. 
 Richards will have to rest the shoulder for at least four months following the operation to tighten up ligaments. 
 Egerton was impressive in England's win over Fiji last weekend and, with Wasps' Dean Ryan recovering from a broken arm, the Bath player is now the only realistic candidate for the No.8 position. 
 France's fly-half Didier Camberabero will undergo a knee operation next month and may also miss the start of the Championship. 
 Nick Farr-Jones, the Wallabies' scrum-half and captain, and Hugo Porta, the 38-year-old former Argentine stand-off, have been paired at half-back for Stanley's XV in the annual match against Oxford University. 
 STANLEY'S XV (v Oxford University, at Iffley Road, November 22): I Williams (Kobe Steel and Australia); A Underwood (Leicester), B Mullin (London Irish and Ireland, capt), T Hosokawa (Kobe Steel and Japan), R Vessey (Kew Occasionals); H Porta (Banco Nacional and Argentina), N Farr-Jones (Sydney Univ and Australia); A Everett (Univ of Capetown), P Coombes (Richmond), T Willis (Narbonne), J Howe (West Hartlepool), D Cronin (Bath and Scotland), G Taylor (Loughborough Univ), G Bertrand (Narbonne), C Sheasby (Harlequins). 
 Ice Skating. 
 Identical twins, Jason and Simon Briggs, completed a unique family double at the Skate Electric British championships at Basingstoke. 
 Jason, born eight minutes before his brother, collected the junior pairs title with Kathryn Pritchard. 
 Simon, a reserve for the world junior championship this month, won the junior men's event. 
 Sailing. 
 Lawrie Smith's Rothmans has moved into second place in the Whitbread Round the World Race. 
 But the 80ft British sloop is still 68 miles behind the leader Fisher and Paykel, writes Bob Fisher. 
 A Finnish syndicate plans to make the country's first challenge for the America's Cup. 
 Sail Finlandia aims to raise 48 million markka &mdash; around &pound;7 million &mdash; to fund the challenge in 1992. 
 Golf. 
 Three new tournaments and four new locations have been included on next year's PGA European Tour schedule. 
 The American Express Mediterranean Open at Las Brisas, Spain, on March 1-4, the Murphy's Cup at York on August 9-12 and the Austrian Open at Salzburg on October 11-14 push the schedule up to 45 tournaments. 
 Changing locations are the Volvo Open, to Florence on March 22-25; the Peugeot Spanish Open, to Madrid on April 26-29; the Benson and Hedges International Open, to St. Mellion on May 4-7; and the Lancia Italian Open, to Milan on May 17-20. 
 Snooker. 
 British Car Rental will sponsor the 1990 World Cup at Bournemouth from March 21 to 24. 
 England, whose three-man team comprises Steve Davis, Jimmy White and John Parrott, will defend their title against the best players from Scotland, Wales, Northern Ireland, the Republic of Ireland, Canada, Australia and the Rest of the World. 
 Boxing. 
 Paul Hodkinson will defend his British and European featherweight title in his home town of Kirkby against the No.1 contender, Italy's Salvatore Bottiglieri, on December 13. 
 Skiing. 
 A ninth women's World Cup slalom, at Hinterstoder, Austria on January 9, has been added to this winter's schedule. 
 The men's downhills at Chamonix, France, and Laax, Switzerland, have been rescheduled to February 3 and February 11. 
 Tennis. 
 Natalia Zvereva was defeated in the first round for the seventh time this year when the American Marianne Werdel beat the eighth seed from the Soviet Union 6-2, 6-3 in the Chicago tournament. 
 Ice Hockey. 
 Deeside Dragons, still searching for a point in the Heineken British League First Division, have released the Americans Tim McGee and Tim Caddo. 
 They have signed the Canadians Mark Harding and Marc White. 
 Athletics. 
 The Olympic hurdles finalist Jon Ridgeon has joined Belgrave Harriers following a move to South London. 
 Ridgeon, who missed most of the summer following an Achilles tendon operation, leaves for a seven-week training course at the Canberra Institute of Sport later this month. 
 Wright man for Gloucestershire. 
 By David Foot 
 TONY WRIGHT is to be the new captain of Gloucestershire in an attempt to foster a happier, more integrated dressing-room and lift morale. 
 He takes over from Bill Athey, who held the job for only one year. 
 Wright, the 27-year-old opening bat, is playing grade cricket in Australia. 
 He learned of his appointment in a telephone call yesterday from Phil August, the county secretary. 
 The other contender was Phil Bainbridge. 
 Gloucestershire will go into 1990, hoping for improved results on the field, with a new resolve &mdash; and very much a new look. 
 The chairman, Don Perry, is standing down (&bquo;I've had quite enough hassle&equo;) and the county will shortly name their coach to succeed John Shepherd. 
 Middlesex have reappointed Mike Gatting and John Emburey as captain and vice-captain despite their involvement in the unofficial winter tour to South Africa. 
 It will be Gatting's eighth season as captain since taking over from Mike Brearley. 
 Lancashire's Andy Hayhurst is to join Somerset on a three-year contract. 
 The 25-year-old all-rounder missed most of the 1989 season with a badly bruised thumb but has recovered after an operation in the summer. 
 Lake's injury gives Simpkin a quarter-final place. 
 VALDA LAKE retired with a back spasm from the LTA Women's Challenger tournament at Swindon yesterday. 
 Lake, facing Anne Simpkin, suffered the injury when 2-1 down in the second set and had to retire in the third, giving Simpkin a place in the quarter-finals with a 3-6, 6-1, 1-0 victory. 
 Lake said: &bquo;I was performing well and I am really disappointed as I have also had to withdraw from the doubles. 
 After some physiotherapy I hope to be fit to play next week in Telford.&equo; 
 Simpkin will now face the No.5 seed, Lisa Gregory from South Africa, who beat Julie Salmon 6-2, 6-4. 
 Austria's Beate Reinstadler took three hours 15 minutes to beat the qualifier Tracy Moreton, of Australia, 5-7, 7-5, 7-5. 
 Quote&hellip;. 
 PEOPLE in the West are talking about traps built into the proposed DDR travel liberalisation law. 
 There is good reason for this. 
 DDR citizens have a right to a passport but only conditional rights to a visa for departure. 
 Possible reasons for non-approval run the gamut from the usual to the astounding. 
 That a visa for travel to West Germany can be refused on &bquo;moral&equo; grounds is highly unusual; a regard for &bquo;national security&equo; is much more the norm&hellip; will it mean no visas for all &bquo;bearers of state secrets&equo;, a category which can be variously defined from one individual case to the next?&hellip; 
 Judging by the mood prevalent up till now in the DDR the planned freedom of travel will scarcely influence those who want to leave because their patience is at an end and their trust in the government has been destroyed. 
 Frankfurter Allgemeine 
 Zeitung, November 7 
 Diary. 
 By Andrew Moncur 
 FOR THE first time, to his knowledge, the forces of law &bquo;n&equo; order have been tampering with items mailed from the US to Maurice Frankel, director of the Campaign for Freedom of Information. 
 Twice on the trot packages have been opened for inspection by HM Customs. 
 Where, in both cases, did the correspondence come from? 
 The American Privacy Foundation, as it happens. 
 And the subject matter? 
 Interception of communications and the Official Secrets Act. 
 OUR CORINTHIAN Prince Charles (well, he's either surmounted by acanthus leaves or those are his ears) is making another film. 
 A follow-up to his epic Omnibus documentary A Vision Of Britain &mdash; known, to the vulgar masses, by the indelible subtitle: It Really Is Appalling. 
 This one is expected to be called A Vision Of The Earth. 
 Those involved at the BBC have adopted a more handy working title. 
 Inevitably, it's become known as Even More Appalling. 
 RESELECTION Corner, an exciting new service to diary readers. 
 Labour MPs are now, of course, thrashing through the business of submitting themselves winsomely to their local parties. 
 It seems sensible to start collecting the otherwise unreported trifles of this Important Democratic Process (all entries gratefully received). 
 Like these events in Knowsley North, where the sitting tenant is George Howarth. 
 A regional official, checking on progress, discovered that the reselection procedure was moving pretty slowly. 
 The blasted Fabian Society was insisting on a postal ballot of all its members there. 
 How much time was that going to take, for heaven's sake? 
 Oh, not long. 
 There are only three of them &mdash; and that includes George Howarth and his wife, Julie. 
 HERE'S a rather touching letter to the troops from Captain Robert Maxwell, headed simply: Our Home. 
 He's been taking soundings about the possibility of shifting Mirror Group Newspapers, lock, stock and Joe Haines's basket, south of the Thames to Great Dover Street while Maxwell House, his Holborn HQ, is flattened and rebuilt. 
 And he's decided against it. 
 &bquo;I have been most of all impressed by the contention that removal to such an area would be damaging to the morale of journalists.&equo; 
 Well, what can you say? 
 Meanwhile at Our Home the unspeakable ingrates seem bent on some sort of work-to-contract. 
 It's all to do with their continued wilful rejection of Captain Bob's morale-boosting pay and conditions package which, for some reason, they deplore. 
 Ooh, the ingratitude. 
 GREAT Corrections Of Our Time (No.198). 
 From Liverpool's public health annual report: &bquo;Page 6, figure 1: the drawing of the graph does not accurately reflect the figures quoted in the commentary and &bquo;births&equo; and &bquo;deaths&equo; have been transposed.&equo; 
 GETTING the Government's message across is all very well. 
 But having it dished up twice in just 19 days &mdash; in what seems suspiciously like identical form &mdash; seems to be going it a bit. 
 Compare and contrast (1) the speech made by a civil servant (acting in the absence of the late Lord Trafford) to the annual conference of the Independent Hospitals' Association in Birmingham, on October 19; and (2) the address by Mrs Virginia Bottomley, the new Health Minister, to yesterday's meeting in London, on the Private Health Care Sector After The White Paper. 
 Question: can you detect any difference? 
 Is recycling a sound idea? 
 Answers on a postcard, please, to: Department of Health, Whitehall, London SW1A 2NS. 
 YOU'LL recall that Tory MP Nicholas Soames was sighted in the Commons wearing an unlikely lapel badge: Tortoise Lovers Against Cruise. 
 He actually bumped into Her Indoors, who peered, looked bewildered and retired (if the use of this word has caused either &lsqb;a&rsqb; rejoicing or &lsqb;b&rsqb; total collapse in the markets, apologies). 
 Anyway, the badge was a gift from Labour's leading tortoise-fancier, Tony Banks. 
 Bunter Soames, vastly amused, has asked for others &mdash; which he also promises to wear. 
 Mr B was last seen hurrying to fetch a badge which reads: Fat Tory Bastards Against The Bomb. 
 Or, possibly, Loopy Old Bats Against ditto. 
 WET FISH enthusiasts will love this entertainment offered to residents, on special terms, by Westminster City Council. 
 February 15: Faust. 
 &bquo;Gounod's ever popular score and the dramatic story of the man who sells his sole to the devil.&equo; 
 Update. 
 By SALES of unleaded fuel continue to climb. 
 This week's figures suggest that one in three motorists are buying unleaded, despite the confusion which still exists about which cars can run on which fuel. 
 In an attempt to clarify the issue, Esso has brought out a new edition of their guide to motorists about which cars can run on unleaded fuel. 
 It is less ambiguous than the previous version but still suggests that if your car will run on standard unleaded petrol, it will run even better on Super Plus unleaded. 
 It ain't necessarily so, but you won't hurt the engine by trying &mdash; only your wallet. 
 By the way, I deplore the practice employed by some filling stations of having several premium unleaded pumps on the forecourt but tucking the standard and cheaper fuel, away in a corner. 
 P for safety. 
 TRIPS to Ireland recently have reinforced my view that the P (probationer) plate carried by those cars driven by people who have passed their driving test within the last year, are a good thing and should be adopted here. 
 Any parent with youngsters learning to drive would be reassured by such a plate and experienced drivers seeing the P-plate can treat the car with respect. 
 P drivers could even be limited to low speeds. 
 Opinions? 
 Glad to be male Hip-hop, body pop, rap, heavy metal &mdash; why do large chunks of pop get rubbished, ignored or mocked? 
 Paul Oldfield and Simon Reynolds reckon it all comes down to sexual politics. 
 TODAY THE right-on music press and the quality newspapers are embarrassed by many of the successful new sub-genres of pop. 
 That's because these musics are &bquo;masculinist&equo;, &bquo;sexist&equo;, &bquo;macho&equo;, even so it's said, &bquo;fascistic&equo;. 
 The offenders are legion. 
 There's hip-hop (e.g. Public Enemy's incendiary rhetoric and racism) and rap (superstuds like LL Cool J); there's European body pop (Front 242, DAF) and hard gay club music; and then there are the electronic-based bands who thrive on totalitarian and paramilitary imagery (Laibach, Nitzer Ebb). 
 And that's not to mention heavy metal, the original cock-rock, and all its new offshoots. 
 In this decade of &bquo;caring&equo; rock, with its explicitly raised political consciousness and its &bquo;new men&equo; like Geldof, Bono and Sting, such hard, macho musics easily seem anomalous and distinctly dubious in their appeal. 
 Papers like the NME and the Guardian can't ignore these masculine genres, but find it hard to understand or reinterpret them: instead they've devised several strategies for skirting round them. 
 First, the press hails the bands that sound more politically correct than others in the genre. 
 With a little effort, almost anybody can be construed as an exception to the rule. 
 Thus the papers are relieved by the new, softer, explicitly pacifist and green hip-hop, like De La Soul; or by reformed characters; or by rappers who turn out to be pillars of the community (Run DMC funding Sunday schools, or KRS-One starting a Stop The Violence campaign). 
 Another tactic for making the music palatable is to seek out women who work in these boys-own genres. 
 Girls can be praised for paying boys back in their own currency, for cutting them down to size, or for challenging the male domination of the music business. 
 The same critics who complain about male bragging and posturing manage to enjoy rudeness and limited musical ability when girls are involved: then it's irreverent and un-ladylike, a challenge to our stereotypes. 
 Roxanne Shante's put-downs of men are meant to be feminist; and suddenly we're meant to respect Salt'n'Pepa's greed, opportunism and exploitation of their own bodies. 
 When the press finally has to confront masculinist music head on, it gives up any attempt to reclaim it, and tries instead to deny its allure by poking fun at it. 
 Heavy metal is &bquo;pantomime stuff,&equo; only ever written up with voyeuristic superiority. 
 And rap or club musics are written off as repetitive, unimaginative and boring (as if rock and pop are beacons of literacy and complexity). 
 Machismo is neutered by being assumed to be synonymous with stupidity and tedium. 
 Grown-up critics manage to deny its appeal (probably the very same priapic excitement they derived from rock in their unreconstructed youth) because it seems to be at odds with their sexual politics. 
 All this means that most critics never get to grips with masculinity's perennial fascination. 
 Nor do they see how such music can, after all, be a deconstruction of machismo. 
 In fact, hip hop and body pop aren't so much concerned with pure aggression as with survival. 
 Throughout Western culture there's less sense of expanding opportunity (the original motor of youth music) and more fear, more sense of being embattles. 
 Urban life's now seen as a threat to our vulnerable individuality: the jungle of the ghetto, the &bquo;urban hell&equo; that rap music talks about, becomes a paradigm for all of us. 
 This feeling that we must fight to preserve ourselves against a hostile world is paralleled by deep male fears of losing bodily integrity and idenity. 
 Men harden themselves against outer threats and against inner weaknesses, against the femininity that lurks in us. 
 The survivalist culture of the ghetto insists that, instead of leading ever fuller lives, we should strip ourselves down for action and retaliation: it's a culture fascinated by war games, fitness, one-upmanship. 
 Hip Hop's bluster and brutalism makes sense in this context. 
 The New York graffiti craze, which meant just spray-painting your name again and again, was the most basic, single-minded assertion that you exist in an indifferent world. 
 The gladiatorial rapping, the sportswear, the symbolic confrontations (&bquo;dissing&equo;) are all about self-assertion. 
 And on a grander scale, there's the controversial battle-readiness and barricades rhetoric of acts like Public Enemy and Niggers With Attitude. 
 Here rappers become vigilantes or revolutionaries: machines for dispensing rough justice or revenge. 
 Hence the obsession with Kung Fu films and Judge Dredd comics. 
 The use of brute force for righteous ends appeals strongly to rap's adolescent male following, of course. 
 Such music can be distinctly ambiguous. 
 It's true that it seduces us with its pulse-quickening thrill, but it also serves as a privileged glimpse into the paranoia, loneliness and tunnel vision of the male survivalist. 
 Hip-hop tells us that city life is impoverished, that real violence, as opposed to the symbolic stare-downs, is horrific. 
 We'd compare this inside view of machismo with the deconstruction of masculinity in Scorsese's films: in Taxi Driver, for example, we're drawn into vicarious participation in a spectacular massacre, only for the camera to draw back and reveal the real carnage, suffering and shock that such an exercise of male power entails. 
 There's a similar drive to reduce yourself, to harden yourself, in another kind of pop: European body and club musics. 
 Here the emphasis is on bypassing your higher faculties and submitting to the fundamental, libidinous drives of your body. 
 Instead of making yourself a killing machine, now you make yourself a sex machine (look at titles like &bquo;Body To Body,&equo; &bquo;Drive&equo;). 
 Worse still, say the critics, the beats that mimic the will to power, the homoeroticism of the music, and the use of technology in the service of a new barbarism and strength-worship, make this &bquo;fascistic&equo; music. 
 Bands like DAF (&bquo;Do The Mussolini&equo;), Yugoslavia's Laibach (makers of &bquo;totalitarian art&equo;), and England's Nitzer Ebb practically invite misunderstanding by flirting so heavily with images of power, fascism and totalitarianism. 
 But in fact, they're as much about power over yourself and self-belief as they are about domination of others. 
 Nitzer Ebb especially think of life as one long siege, a purifying test of your inner strength. 
 And the heavy disco work-out of such bands (an influence on house and new beat music) sounds like body-building, the epitome of self-testing, of strength built up for its own sake. 
 If such music is totalitarian, that's because it's about total control and exploitation of your powers. 
 And, beyond that, we ought to see that some of the latest European music is only &bquo;fascistic&equo; in ways that are almost the opposite of male triumpalism. 
 The sturm und drang of current favourites The Young Gods is the sound of strength being expended. 
 This is the old Futurist ideal of living dangerously, of self-sacrifice. 
 According to some theorists, that's the only way men can let down their macho defences: in blood-letting, catastrophe, a suicidal willingness to put your life on the line. 
 In all these musics, we're allowed to thrill to the experience of super-masculinity. 
 There are dangers in that. 
 Some hip-hop or heavy metal fans might not see further than the pleasure of destruction, might be real-life misogynists and miscreants. 
 But for many of us, the music lets us get under the skin of maleness and see its impoverishment, numbness, struggles with weakness, and dangers, as well as the exhilaration. 
 Surely that's a better way to deal with machismo than trying to deafen ourselves to its allure. 
 Hip-hoppers Public Enemy&hellip; &bquo;controversial battle-readiness and barricades rhetoric&equo; Salt'n'Pepa.. challenge to stereotype or exploitation?. for tabloid arts p 20 
 Spreading the word Weekend attractions. 
 THE Birmingham Readers and Writers Festival, now in it's sixth year, is rightly regarded as a jewel in Birmingham's civic crown. 
 Featuring a range of performance and community events, it manages to combine top-of-the-range literary activity and discussion with more accessible events, giving the literary festival a broad appeal without losing its essential focus on words and the wordy. 
 This two-week festival starts today with the announcement of the winner of the Smarties Book Prize, a day of associated children's activities, and the beginning of an ambitious community event to construct the longest poem in the English language. 
 This evening, Perrier Award-winning stand-up comic Simon Fanshaw takes the stage at the Midland Arts Centre Studio (10pm) with his current-affairs based comedy show (10pm). 
 The latest works in Chatto and Windus's much maligned but nevertheless intriguing Counterblasts series come under the scrutiny of writer Marina Warner and anarchist author Colin Ward (tomorrow, 2.30pm). 
 Highlights of the rest of the Festival include: beat poetry readings by Michael Horovitz; the premier of Edward Bond's new play, Jackets; and the launch of the Book Trust's Out Of Africa anthology featuring work by, among others, Ebbon Dibba. 
 The Festival continues until November 25 and is based at the Midlands Arts Centre but events take place throughout the city. 
 Further details and booking on 021-440 3838. 
 Telling tales. 
 ONCE upon a time people indulged in the ages-old craft of telling stories to each other &mdash; but then television and video stepped in and took the words out of our mouths. 
 These days the practice of story-telling is so rare that it has acquired the status of an art form. 
 Hence the third International Storytelling Festival which takes root at the South Bank Centre before moving on, in various forms, to Leicester, York, Bristol, Reading, Manchester, Barrow-in-Furness and Llantwit Major. 
 It boasts a stirring menu of international wordsmiths including two Inuit Eskimos who will &bquo;throat dance&equo; &mdash; they stand nose-to-nose bouncing their voices off each other's throats to produce a bewildering array of sounds. 
 Another pair &mdash; Sheref Tasilova and Murat Cobanglu from Turkey &mdash; engage in &bquo;bardic duels&equo;. 
 One of these involves a competition of improvised verse where contestants have needles placed in their mouths to prevent the pronounciation of certain syllables &mdash; not a technique to practise at home. 
 Further details and full programme from the South Bank on 01-928 8800 Californian poet La Loca appears in the Birmingham Readers and Writers Festival, Birmingham University, next weekend THIS CAPTION FOR TABLOID PAGE38 Peter O'Toole and Sarah Berger in Keith Waterhouse's Jeffrey Bernard Is Unwell at the Apollo: see Theatre 
 Art for the asking Gallery. 
 THERE are many people who would love to buy the work of young British artists: there are plenty of young artists in Britain who would love to sell it. 
 Often, the main obstacle between them is the prospect of dealing with forbidding galleries charging forbidding commission fees. 
 The Gallery page in Weekend Guardian unites buyers and artists for no commission or fee at all. 
 It provides a unique display of modern British art for those who wish to shop &mdash; or simply window shop. 
 Anyone interested in buying a painting should contact the artist directly at the telephone number given. 
 Note to artists: Because of the overwhelming response we now have several weeks' supply of pictures for the Gallery page. 
 Please don't send us any more slides for the time being. 
 ABOVE: Decisions by John Wells (0344 772134 or 0227 711623). 
 Oil, 20ins x 30ins, &pound;200. 
 BELOW: Illusion de Beaute by P.A. Knight (969 3210). 
 Gouache, 17ins x 24ins, &pound;340. 
 LEFT: Scoraig by S. Hogan (031 5562618). 
 Oil, 6ft x 2 &frac12;ft, &pound;400. 
 PAGE t12 
 I WAS pleased to read the Image Makers column (Weekend Guardian, November 4). 
 However there is an error in it which should be corrected. 
 The Peace Pledge Union was not founded by Siegfried Sassoon in 1936. 
 It is true that Sassoon was prominent member from its early days, but the PPU was in fact founded by Dick Sheppard in 1934. 
 Peter Kennard's photomontages are powerful anti-war images and as such we should be pleased to have them around. 
 They are, as you quote John Berger saying, &bquo;effective&hellip; means of exposing official lies.&equo; 
 However, many of the &bquo;official&equo; lies are so deeply buried in the narrative of everyday life that they have become almost invisible. 
 So much so that they are seen as &bquo;natural.&equo; 
 Guns, real or toy, litter advertisements. 
 Power tools coming from the hip, gunslinger style, or British Gas portraying the contented family enjoying the warm glow of its new central heating. 
 Mother, daughter and father with son on his shoulders holding a toy gun at the apex of a neatly composed pyramid. 
 Just because not everyone may spot the toy gun in this ad and attach a certain symbolic significance to it, it does not mean that it is not there nor that it has no effect. 
 Despite the growing sensitivity about sexual and racial stereotypes and their effects on shaping attitudes, the role of and reference to weapons in advertising continues to be marginalised. 
 Nothing sinister is implied by the portrayal of weapons in advertisements, we are constantly told, they are simply props. 
 At this point in the twentieth century we should no longer be so innocent. 
 We know that images are not neutral. 
 &bquo;A picture is worth a thousand words&equo; precisely because it is a part of a complex, usually unconscious, web of references. 
 Unless we understand this process we will remain as superstitious and powerless to change the world for the better as were our forebearers. 
 The Remembrance ceremonies this coming weekend will be part of that myth-making process which, while acknowledging the horror of war, will also be justifying war as means of solving conflicts. 
 The British Legion's advertising campaign with jackbooted Germans marching in front of Parliament preys on our fears and offers a solution &mdash; namely we've got to be armed to our teeth to prevent such a thing from happening. 
 This is a neat piece of propaganda and perhaps we should remember where propaganda like this was honed to perfection. 
 Jan Melichar. 
 Dick Sheppard House, 6 Endsleigh Street, London WC1. 
 JULIE BOSTON raises several important points in her letter on African literature (Weekend Guardian, October 28). 
 I'm sure she will be pleased to learn about the formation of the Association for the Study of Caribbean and African Literature in French, which brings together a group of academics involved with the teaching of this literature at university level. 
 The limitations of a movement based around university French departments are obvious. 
 Nevertheless an important start has been made and some students are being exposed to a segment of African literature. 
 The diversity of papers produced for the conference in November 1988 which gave birth to the association, as well as the enthusiastic reception accorded to the novelist and film maker Sembene Ousmane when he addressed the participants, suggest that the teaching of African literature in French has not involved the depoliticisation of its content that often occurs when works of art become the object of academic study. 
 Moreover, the attention the association has paid to cinema has offered a space in which it has been possible to raise the issue of the production and distribution of narrative and dramatic works in African languages. 
 Finally, and outside the university context, it is perhaps worth mentioning that the Camden library service has a good loan collection of African writing. 
 Obviously, one hopes that other groups will attempt initiatives of this kind, or are already engaged in comparable initiatives of their own. 
 As Ms Boston suggests, we are all enriched by an engagement with Arican literature and culture. 
 James Leahy. 
 520 Ben Johnson House, Barbican, London, EC2. 
 NO DOUBT I shall not be the first person to point out to your wine buff Malcolm Gluck (Domaine Anthea &bquo;87, et al, Food &amp; Drink, October 28) that it was Althea &mdash; not Anthea &mdash; who received a note written from prison. 
 And that Colonel Richard Lovelace, not John Gay, wrote the note. 
 It is to be hoped that Gluck's judgments on wine are better than his knowledge of English poetry. 
 It's bad enough that he should get two things wrong about what is perhaps one of the best known poems in the English language. 
 But were your sub-editors asleep? 
 Presumably they are paid their fabulous salaries to spot errors such as these. 
 Eric Winter. 
 Mossley, Manchester. 
 I AM glad you publicised Victoria Stone's campaign for legislation to prevent learner drivers being supervised by, perhaps, an equally young but recently-qualified driver (Weekend Guardian, October 28). 
 But one fact was wrong: Kate Stone was not the supervising driver in the accident; Claire Powell was. 
 Both girls were killed outright. 
 (Mrs) Rita Hetherington. 
 Kingswinford, West Midlands. 
 MARIANNE MACDONALD (Weekend Guardian, October 28) obviously considers that no area of London is worth consideration outside the over-priced borough of Islington. 
 Surely she should be encouraging people to improve the quality of life in such areas as Tottenham, where housing can still be bought and rented at realistic prices. 
 We may not have many estate agents and delis in Tottenham, but I like it here. 
 T.D.Haws. 
 25 The Avenue, Tottenham, London N17. 
 This year's Reith lecturer, Jacques Darras, is an outsider in his own culture who believes in a cross-cultural unity. 
 Nina-Anne Kaye reports. 
 The poet breaking down the barricades Radio. 
 JACQUES Darras is a man of many parts: poet and translator, Dean and professor of English at the University of Picardy, publisher, linguist, and self-confessed outsider. 
 In Britain he is virtually unknown. 
 The irony of this is certainly not lost on him. 
 As this year's BBC Reith Lecturer, it is precisely this lack of cultural cross-fertilisation (and its origins) which he expounds as the major obstacle to a fully united Europe. 
 In his lectures entitled &bquo;Beyond the Tunnel of History&equo;, which take the French Bicentenary as a starting point, Darras plumbs and unravels the shared histories of Britain and France with their mutual misconceptions. 
 By guiding the listener through his very personal European museum, he endeavours to suggest ways in which a tangible partnership in 1992 and beyond may flourish. 
 European union is his leitmotiv. 
 Born in 1939 near Crecy in Northern France, his childhood was overshadowed by women, war and, inevitably, the Germans who occupied their village. 
 &bquo;I heard so much about resisting that I developed a very derisive concept about men at war,&equo; Darras explained, &bquo;strange for a boy of five.&equo; 
 When his father, frustrated after years as a POW, returned, he tried to lay down the law. 
 Young Darras rebelled. 
 &bquo;It took a very long time to reconcile myself with my father.&equo; 
 He admits to having wanted always to write poetry but doubts whether he can attribute that entirely to his rebellion. 
 &bquo;My tremendous love of language and languages must be the main reason and my love of nature and the North.&equo; 
 A conventional classics education at the equivalent of anOxbridge college brought him to Paris. 
 &bquo;The last thing I wanted to do was teach. 
 I didn't know what career I wanted which baffled the system so they sent me to Edinburgh for a year. 
 I did end up teaching &mdash; but not French.&equo; 
 Married by 20 with a child, he had to earn a living. 
 &bquo;I really do feel I sacrificed myself. 
 I just wanted to be a poet.&equo; 
 Darras is a tall man, with northern features, courteous in his manner and brimming with charisma. 
 &bquo;Poetry places me in a very special position &mdash; as someone who in the end came to terms with society but not enough to be socially acceptable.&equo; 
 Darras relishes the splendid isolation that his undisputed status as poet confers, and the power that language bestows. 
 Several other traits make Darras something of an outsider, set apart from French cultural orthodoxy. 
 Aside from his love of the open spaces, rugged land, and seascapes of the North and the diversity of its culture, his teaching of a non-Romance language is considered tantamount to a betrayal. 
 Moreover to advocate exposing French tradition to foreign literatures, citing Whitman, Williams, and Pound, as seminal influences, to translate them in addition to David Jones or Basil Bunting, and to deny any allegiance to the French poetic mainstream is received in some circles with incomprehension. 
 Darras is unrepentant. 
 His passionate love of the English language is absolute: his wit and fluency are its testimony. 
 In this centenary year of Lord Reith's birth, Daniel Snowman, chosen by the BBC mandarins to produce the 1989 lectures, decided to break with tradition. 
 He invited a non-native English speaker, one who could cast his net across several disciplines and one who would agree to talk freely from notes rather than the traditional script. 
 &bquo;I'm really making a plea in the lectures that if the British want to get involved in Europe, they should show a few signs, be prepared to learn other languages, open up to other cultures. 
 These aspects are never debated. 
 Yet they are the crux. 
 &bquo;Economics is much easier. 
 Everyone understands the common language of money. 
 Europe is such a priority to me. 
 I wouldn't mind English being the only language &mdash; it certainly makes me unpopular.&equo; 
 Darras' writing and translating have however been received with great acclaim. 
 Just published last year were his evocative chapters called Le Genie du Nord (Grasset, Paris), reflecting his preoccupation with the North, the fields of war, the detrimental effects of nationalism and his hopes for Europe, complemented by La Maye (Trois Cailloux, Amiens), a 500 page semi-autobiography in poetry and prose written in a variety of styles and voices. 
 &bquo;That really squares with my notion of polyphony &mdash; my guiding principle in art as in life.&equo; 
 The poems are intended to be read aloud as in the late middle ages, a period to which Darras is keenly attracted because national and linguistic boundaries had not yet hardened. 
 &bquo;We must return to multiplicity, where the single nation state is no longer supreme.&equo; 
 It is possible. 
 Darras and his wife live in English, as he calls it, one of his sons in German and when they go down the street, they live in French. 
 IDON'T want to be tied down by someone else's notion of nationality. 
 It's my fight against the Right. 
 I'm trying to divorce birth from place although I don't want to create a Communist society. 
 It must come from the people themselves: art and culture can play an enormous part.&equo; 
 It could be argued that Darras' vision is quixotic. 
 He is quite prepared to accept this criticism. 
 &bquo;It will take a long time, we are just emerging from the dark ages, but things don't happen if you don't make them. 
 People will have to shift &mdash; on their own basis and in their own lives through coaxing and imposing, disengaging themselves from nationality. 
 I know I demand a very high price. 
 It's the privilege of a poet.&equo; 
 The Reith Lectures, a series of six talks on BBC Radio 4, start on Wednesday, November 15 at 8.15pm. 
 Jacques Darras: &bquo;We are just emerging from the dark ages&equo;. 
 for tabloid arts p 21 
 3rd south arts Almeida.. 
 By Michael Billington I Miss My War. 
 I MISS My War at the Almeida is a first play in English by Iraj Jannatie Ataie, an exiled Iranian poet who was a political prisoner under the Shah's regime and whose A Cry With Sewn Lips (in Farsi) made a moving impression at the Theatre Upstairs four years ago. 
 His new play, about the corrupting effect of a patriarchal, militarist culture, is clearly written from the heart but it subordinates characterisation and structure to the promulgation of its message. 
 Its hero, Sya, is a crippled Iranian soldier who arrives in London with his sister, Sohy, seeking medical treatment. 
 We learn that he has not only killed his brother-in-law for opposing the Iranian government but that he unrepentantly believes that &bquo;war is the source of love and hope and satisfaction.&equo; 
 And in Britain he finds his views are strangely echoed. 
 His landlady, Penny (a slatternly version of Odysseus's Penelope), treats Sya as a substitute for her missing soldier-husband, while her lodger Burt, a footloose unemployed actor, yearns to swap his decadent native land for the iron certainties of Iran. 
 I get the impression that Mr Ataie has decided what he wants to say and then created characters to fit his theme. 
 Thus Sya, who announces that &bquo;one who believes in war believes in God&equo; and who beats his sister with a khaki belt, is an inflexible symbol of a militaristic ethos. 
 Equally, Penny remains on one level as a deluded fantasist who believes, very like an Iranian woman, that a wife's duty is to wait for her husband's return from the wars. 
 The only character who shows any internal conflict or dramatic progress is Sohy who gets a glimpse of Westernised freedom (symbolised by the abandonment of her veil) but who cannot easily shake off a lifetime of enslavement. 
 Not only are the characters walking symbols but Mr Ataie uses poetic metaphor (the text is filled with references to stallions and horses) as a means of camouflaging daily reality. 
 We never learn how Sya and Sohy have raised the money to come to Britain any more than we discover how the unemployed thespian lodger pays the rent. 
 And Mr Ataie's thesis that the British have a deep-seated reverence for war is too easily symbolised by having Penny make Remembrance Day poppies or court Sya in front of a military monument. 
 Mr Ataie writes with undoubted passion but insufficient technique. 
 His production for the Mazdak Theatre Group is, however, well designed by Penny Fitt whose set consists of teeming military icons. 
 Kulvinder Ghir as the iron-jawed Sya, Soudabeh Farrokhnia as his mutinous sister, Patti Love as the pining Penny and Sylvester McCoy as her drunken lodger all turn in perfectly good perform- ances. 
 But, though it is heartening to find an Iranian writer bravely grappling with the problems of exile and turning a critical eye on the values of both his native and adopted countries, Mr Ataie will write better plays when he admits the theatrical importance of contradiction and argument. 
 At the Almeida (01-359 4404) until November 25 and then on tour to Newcastle, Sheffield, Leeds and Manchester. 
 Town and Country Club. 
 By Steve Dodd The House of Love. 
 IT was an important homecoming for London's most chic guitar group. 
 The House of Love admitted it themselves, apologising for their shyness, because after all, this was the biggest gig yet. 
 An important occasion for the fans, too, whose allegiance to this post-psychedelic foursome borders on total dev- otion. 
 Tickets sold out weeks beforehand, and if you want to see the band now your best chance will be in some of the more obscure locations ever played. 
 Widnes, Blackburn and Greenock are on the list already, and the group invites suggestions from towns which don't often get to see bands. 
 John O'Groats, get your bid in now. 
 The House of Love inherit their particlar brand of psychedelia from early Echo and The Bunnymen and the Teardrop Explodes. 
 At times, the similarities are too close for comfort, edging towards the derivative. 
 Powerful, multi-layered chords pile up, the ornamentation provided by guitarist Terry Bickers's occasional inspired excursions through the harmonics. 
 The smart groups know this grand approach appeals to the twentysomethings, and from U2 and Simple Minds they have all done it before. 
 But the House of Love do offer something of their own &mdash; a willingness to play around with the pace of the music, cutting off the power to switch suddenly into a softer, more lyrical approach. 
 This is clear in their best songs like Christine and Love In A Car. 
 Live, their better work justifies some of the admiration the group have received in the music press, showing a quality the clinical approach of their record producers managed to suppress. 
 They are a humble, unassuming bunch on stage. 
 Only Terry Bickers seems to want to be a pop star, attacking the music with flailing arms. 
 Not full blown excess, but perhaps a demi-Pete Townsend. 
 Singer Guy Chadwick was all smiles and thanks, saving one little outburst of annoyance for the final encore, a solo semi-acoustic blues number, Secrets. 
 This is the B side of the new single and truly atrocious. 
 The twentysomethings sniggered so he told them to shut up, gaining an instant roar of approval from the same people. 
 Whimsy with bite, what could be cooler? 
 The new album is out early next year, and should provide another couple of minor classics. 
 With luck, a few years will bring a greatest hits compilation. 
 Now that would be worth having. 
 1st north arts Leeds.. 
 By Albert Hunt Troublesome Behviour. 
 PILOT Theatre is a community theatre group based in Wakefield. 
 Every year it devises (in its own words) &bquo;an issue-based play for 14-plus.&equo; 
 This means that its touring shows are normally only seen in secondary schools. 
 Two public performances this week at Leeds Polytechnic's Studio Theatre of the group's latest show, Troublesome Behaviour, have allowed theatregoers to see what they have been missing. 
 Troublesome Behaviour has been devised by four actors working with director, Martin McNicholas. 
 Set in a room in a student hostel in Sheffield, it explores the tensions between Jem, a student from Darlington, his Salvation Army father, his African Muslim room-mate, Musa, and a girlfriend, Trish. 
 Jem has been beaten up in the street by three men. 
 He has been injured and is clearly in a state of shock. 
 At the end of the play, he takes a box full of sleeping pills and washes them down with wine &mdash; both pills and wine have been affectionately supplied by Trish. 
 The apparently aggressive Musa, tenderly tries to keep him conscious until the ambulance arrives. 
 The play is very compelling &mdash; it would make a riveting hour on TV. 
 The characters are closely observed and sympathetically played. 
 Stephanie Gascoigne is particularly convicing as Trish, the girl who cares for Jem, but doesn't want to become emotionally committed. 
 The group's publicity suggests that the issue being dealt with is mental illness, which led a therapist in the audience to say that none of the characters seemed to him to be mentally ill. 
 (He added that in his hospital &bquo;the people who are mad are the attendants.&equo;) 
 To me, Troublesome Behaviour is about four people desperately trying to make contact with each other. 
 At Leeds the play made a very direct contact with the audience. 
 I hope that in future more of this highly professional group's work will be made available to the public. 
 Pilot Theatre tel: 0924 220406. 
 1st north arts Sheffield. 
 By Tim Brown Leonce and Lena. 
 READ any good Buchner lately? 
 Admittedly not, and while all his three plays are read more than seen, this one is read about more than read. 
 The fact is, however, that Leonce and Lena is more than a fizzled-out digression into comedy by the creator of Woyzeck. 
 Between the dud sections of melancholic philosophical banter the dialogue flares menacingly, crackling and spluttering like a damp 150-year-old firework that constantly threatens to go off. 
 By this fitful light you see Buchner, crazily ahead of his time, trying to invent the Theatre of the Absurd without much understanding of the essential carpentry of comedy. 
 Lindsay Posner's productiion in the Sheffield Crucible Studio gratefully propagates allusions to absurdist clasics. 
 The mad tinpot tyrant King Peter (Gerrard McArthur) &mdash; who can't pull up his own trousers &mdash; presides over the play from a gold-plated lavatory worthy of Ubu Roi. 
 The runaway Prince Leonce and his veminous, thieving philosphical sparring partner Valerio, after pawning their clothes for food, loaf about in the forest in long johns swapping paradoxes like two men waiting for Godot. 
 And Leonce (Adam Cotz) happens to look exactly like that potent influence in anarchist theatre, Hamlet. 
 What comes their way is not Godot but Princess Lena. 
 They marry and, in a deeply cynical pantomime ending, inherit the reins of tyrany. 
 There are two sharp Mervyn Peake caricatures &mdash; by Gillian Hanna in a brief, chilling appearance as Leonce's mistress, and by Derek Hutchinson, whose brutishly powerful Valerio is the main event of the evening. 
 But the rest of the act lacks this savagery and Posner should surely have aimed for more laughs earlier &mdash; at present the audience only relaxes, by the usual process of familiarity, around the half way mark. 
 Sheffield Crucible Studio until December 2. 
 Tel: 0742 769922. 
 1st north arts Buxton. 
 By David Ward King Lear. 
 THREE side-by-side playgoers in the Buxton Opera House dress circle followed the text in their Signet Shakespeares throughout this four-hour Lear. 
 They turned their pages in perfect harmony and experienced a decent run through of a difficult text rather than an intense spiritual journey. 
 Six out of ten to the Oxford Stage Company; could do better. 
 John Retallack is a bright director but keeps only a very light hand on the tiller here; this is not so much director's theatre as anonymous the- atre. 
 Which puts quite a burden on an uneven cast. 
 The Fool, played by Raymond Greenaway, is a follower of the Eddie Grundy method and contributes nothing. 
 Goneril and Regan (Deborah Findlay and Carla Mendona) wear smart haircuts and padded shouldered outfits but flounce and droop like exiles from The Importance of Being Earnest. 
 Edmund (John Kazek) is a ludicrous, ranting, kilted boor who seems to have strayed in from the Scottish play. 
 It's Lear and Edgar who rescue the night. 
 Simon Kunz manages all the baffling Poor Tom stuff with conviction and, in his scenes with Gloucester, generates the kind of anguish so often missing elsewhere. 
 Philip Voss overcomes some obstacles &mdash; including at one point being dressed in a Babygro &mdash; to chart the King's decline. 
 The battle with the tigerish daughters is managed with gathering incredulity, the storm and trial flounder a bit (mainly through limp direction), and the last scenes, culminating in the reconciliation with Cordelia, are honest and dignified. 
 Lear's death may not have been devastating, but I was sorry to see him go. 
 Helpful hint: skip the very long first half and take your seat after the interval. 
 At the Buxton Opera House tonight (Tel: 0298 72190 or 0298 78939). 
 Yul Brynner&hellip; the King on the treadmill at the London Palladium in 1979, and (right) Rock Brynner, in London this week PHOTOGRAPH: DAVID SILLITOE. 
 How does a son live his own life in the shadow of an overpowering father who is also a worldwide star? 
 Rock Brynner tells Helen Oldfield how he sprang the Hollywood brat trap The King and me YUL Brynner died in 1985. 
 For his son, Rock, who had spent most of his life adoring his father like a god, &bquo;it was somewhat like the feeling&hellip; it's late at night and you're alone on the Tube riding with a bunch of thugs and they get off your car.&equo; 
 And he quotes John Mortimer's kinder phrase from Voyage Round My Father about &bquo;the step into the sunlight when no one is taller than you.&equo; 
 Four years later he has written Yul's biography, which is partly a show biz life and partly a much sharper settling of accounts between father and son. 
 He untangles his father's early life &mdash; tangled chiefly by Brynner himself who always told interviewers a different story &mdash; from Switzerland to the farthest reaches of Russia and then to Paris as a teenager in the Thirties, where he joined a Romany gypsy troupe. 
 Brynner's life in America is better known: the movies, some outstanding, like The Magnificent Seven, many terrible; the wives; the lovers &mdash; Judy Garland, Marilyn Monroe, Marlene Dietrich, Joan Crawford (a businesslike woman in love as in other affairs, making their encounter &bquo;among the least erotic half hours&equo; in Brynner's life); and above all the role that he created and that in the end devoured him, the King of Siam. 
 The book is no Daddie Dearest, though the two were estranged for many years. 
 Rock became aware that the thrilling, magical father, who had taken his young son backstage, on the road, drinking, water-skiiing, was gradually becoming a resentful tyrant. 
 He was disappointed, too, that his father had given up artistic ideals in the pursuit of money. 
 From Brynner's point of view, Rock thinks, his son was both a living rebuke and a terrible financial failure, and his drinking didn't help either. 
 They were reconciled in the months before Brynner's excruciatingly painful death from cancer. 
 But the will, which Rock read in a newspaper, was at first hard to take. 
 Brynner had left virtually everything to his fourth wife, &bquo;the dancing girl&equo; as Rock invariably refers to her, and not one personal possession to his son or his four younger daughters. 
 Later he came to rationalise that, seeing it as part of a family pattern. 
 &bquo;He's abandoned everyone else in his life, from his mother and father and his sister, three wives and hundreds of girlfriends, to his acting coach. 
 He didn't single out his children for this. 
 And I had to my satisfaction traced it back to Jules and Boris &lsqb;Yul's grandfather and father, both of whom deserted their families&rsqb;.&equo; 
 One of the achievements of the book is to keep the bitterness that developed in later life wholly unsuspected in the early chapters. 
 Besides, he'd learned a long time before that you can love a person without loving what they do. 
 Towards the end, as the stage show of The King And I moved triumphantly from city to city, Rock began to feel like the boy who could see the emperor had no clothes. 
 &bquo;Nobody else could see that the man was on a financial treadmill, that his expenses were so huge he had to spend 50 weeks a year on the road to afford two weeks in his castle in Normandy.&equo; 
 Since the book appeared in America, Rock has been surprised by the letters he's received &bquo;from people who live in the suburbs or small flats where the father is the king, where his armchair is the throne. 
 The Archie Bunkers of the world. 
 I had not seen that it would would have that special resonance.&equo; 
 But Brynner was a star as well as a powerful personality and Rock's own life tells of the effect that had. 
 His childhood was concertina-ed (though he says now, gleefully, that it's never too late to have a happy childhood) &mdash; something he shared with his life-long friend Liza Minnelli. 
 &bquo;We were nine when we were sent to boarding shool. 
 I had my first car when I was 10, with a chauffeur. 
 We'd go out on the town, hit a few cocktail parties, go dancing, and I'd drop a few hundred quid on a weekend.&equo; 
 There's a bleak line in the book when, his parents divorcing, his father leaving for Europe, Rock quotes himself, aged 11, saying &bquo;I'll be OK, Dad, I won't need Mom so long as I can have the limo.&equo; 
 By the time he was 17, he was a student at Trinity College, Dublin, having already spent a semester or two at Yale, and well on his way to becoming an alcoholic. 
 I was in the same Mental and Moral Science class as him and I can't say I noticed. 
 He was the kid who went back to be Frank Sinatra's bar-tender in the vacation while the rest of us were toting Christmas mail for the Post Office. 
 Maybe he did splash out on exotic &bquo;boilermakers&equo; &mdash; beer with a Jack Daniels chaser &mdash; while the rest of us supped halves of Guinness, and his hands shook a little. 
 It was part of the mystique, or so we thought. 
 In a way, as Rock puts it, he was trying to relive his father's life on fast-forward. 
 After graduating he wrote and performed a one-man play, Opium, depicting Jean Cocteau's struggle to overcome addiction. 
 Years before, in Paris, Brynner had been a friend of Cocteau's and his opium dealer. 
 Brynner, too, studied philosophy briefly. 
 &bquo;Yul, as an acrobat, was a flying clown. 
 I, a generation later, became a street clown, albeit a hippy.&equo; 
 Yul drove Michael Chekhov's theatre company on tour and sparred with Sugar Ray Robinson. 
 Rock became roadie for The Band and was Muhammad Ali's bodyguard. 
 Yul was married four times, Rock already three. 
 PRESSED for the pros and cons of being the son of one of the famous, Rock replies: &bquo;I think I'm among the most blessed of people who ever lived and I think Liza is too. 
 There are others who are dead, Paul Newman's son, Mary Tyler Moore's son &mdash; there are a lot of casualties. 
 To be known as somebody else's something, whether it's husband of the prime minister or nephew of the chairman of the board, is to be like some kind of vestigial appendage. 
 &bquo;But let me add, Liza and I got a great education. 
 We travelled literally from the week we were born, we met millions of the most exciting and dynamic personalities. 
 Sal Mineo was like my big brother, James Dean was my buddy&hellip; 
 &bquo;Yul was determined that every question I asked be answered. 
 At 10 or 11, I read On The Beach, Neville Shute's book; I thought it was frightening, so he called in an air force general to explain it to me. 
 It was always so. 
 When I was 12, my great hero was Van Cliburn because he'd just won the Tchaikovsky Competition, so he was invited over and played on my spinet.&equo; 
 But do remarkable achievements make remarkable people? 
 &bquo;Well, there are some real schmucks out there.&equo; 
 The one thing he never wanted was an acting career &mdash; &bquo;I'd seen that&hellip;&equo; 
 And now he's broken free from the pattern and from the addictions, first alcohol then cocaine. 
 He's a writer and a historian, and he's growing his hair half-way down his back for his next one-man show. 
 He's &bquo;squeaky clean&equo; &mdash; he gets high flying his own plane. 
 &bquo;Alcohol did me the greatest favour, which is that it brought me down to earth. 
 I was otherwise condemned to be a Hollywood brat. 
 By the age of 23, I'd starred in a one-man show on Broadway and when the play closed I confronted the truth that if I wasn't the star of a play I couldn't feed myself. 
 So I became Red Hat the clown and travelled among the street people (in Europe), a little drunk, but not crazy drunk in those days. 
 I learned a thousand crafts. 
 I have a hundred different ways to earn a living. 
 I can function in the real world. 
 I was meant to grow up something like Desi Arnaz Jnr and that's not what happened.&equo; 
 Yul: The Man Who Would Be King is published by Collins, &pound;15. for tabloid arts p 19 
 Letters. 
 By PETER STANFORD is right in maintaining (Weekend Guardian, November 4) that Graham Greene is not alone in calling himself a &bquo;Catholic agnostic&equo;. 
 An earlier thinker who declined to see any mutual contradiction between similar terms was Leslie Weatherhead, psychologist and cleric, who published his Creed of a Christian Agnostic. 
 Weatherhead was honest enough to realise that there are many aspects of religion about which one has to remain uncertain, that is, agnostic. 
 These &bquo;difficult&equo; areas will vary from one individual to another. 
 As a self-confessed Christian agnostic he himself, however, was sure of a number of the major tenets of Christianity. 
 His &bquo;creed&equo; claimed (in part): &bquo;I believe that God exists&hellip; 
 I believe there is mind behind the universe&hellip; 
 Such a mind must be love rather than hate&hellip; 
 I believe in the divinity of Christ&hellip; 
 I believe that sin is a grisly fact in the world&hellip; 
 I believe that God's forgiveness is one of the most blessed and therapeutic experiences and that it is offered to all who seek it&hellip; 
 I believe that our relationship with God is the most important thing in the world&hellip; 
 I believe that each individual is precious to God.&equo; 
 Within this creed appear supportive rational arguments but also agnostic admissions, such as &bquo;I can understand little about that mind&equo; and &bquo;I do not know what &bquo;divine&equo; means&equo;. 
 I imagine that many honest people would sympathise with Weatherhead and happily echo his final paragraph: &bquo;All this gives me as much as I need, and seems to me the essential credo of Christianity. 
 About the rest I am content to be agnostic.&equo; 
 Michael J.Smith. 
 Southampton. 
 FROM HIS Fifth Dimension article, Peter Stanford sounds even further burnt out than Graham Greene who continues capable of grim religious fun when opportunities arise. 
 Indeed, Greene's latest revelations about his faith-non-faith appear quite knowingly hilarious. 
 There's such sad unenthusiasm, on the other hand, about the way Stanford confuses personal doubt with the existence of mystery, as if one engenders the other, and, in doing so, must be assuaged by performance of some farcical rites. 
 How boring! 
 How pointless; precisely! 
 Prayer, whether dramatised in a church or not, usually goes through futile-seeming passages. 
 But even when extreme and prolonged, they have a strange tickle of meaning in them that becomes more of a mystery as faith grows. 
 Olive Powell. 
 Manchester. 
 More letters Page 27 
 Extra charge prompts moan. 
 By Nick Pandya 
 THE Consumers' Association has complained to the Office of Fair Trading about building societies which charge an additional fee to borrowers who choose their own buildings insurance policy. 
 The association has found that mortgage lenders are charging fees of up to &pound;40 to those borrowers who choose their own buildings insurance policy. 
 Not all lenders charge, but among the ones which do the fees levied are completely arbitrary. 
 Some societies have a one-off fee of between &pound;5 and &pound;40, while others have an annual charge of between &pound;1 and &pound;25. 
 Complaints about these charges are the second most frequently lodged with Building Societies Ombudsman, Stephen Edell. 
 Concert parties- and how the Swiss roll in&hellip; 
 Saturday notebook. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 CONCERT parties sound so homely. 
 Other share-dealing terminology rings immediate alarm bells: insider dealing sounds fishy and the term fan club has a threatening sound &mdash; there are too many football connotations. 
 But concert party? 
 It conjures up images of Victorian family evenings round the piano. 
 How curious, then, that such a phrase should suggest something illegal. 
 How curious that it should be enshrined in the Companies Act. 
 How curious that last week's suggestion that a cabinet minister might have a link with such activities should bring the threat of damnation from a prominentlibel lawyer. 
 Let us be quite clear about terminology. 
 Just what does a concert party mean? 
 News that an investor has bought a significant stake in any company is likely to lift that company's share price. 
 The holding could become the platform for a bid. 
 Or it could be sold to someone else planning an assault. 
 And as we all know, bids push up share prices. 
 Hence the rule that anyone buying five per cent of a company must say so publicly. 
 The fact that one person owns a big chunk of shares is price-sensitive information. 
 We should be told. 
 A concert party simply describes an alliance between two or more investors. 
 Two business people may be chums. 
 They may work together. 
 Their respective companies may often work in tandem. 
 There is nothing wrong in that. 
 But if each buys, say, three per cent in a target company, then the five per cent declaration rule applies. 
 They are in concert so together they have six per cent. 
 From the market's point of view, this is no less significant than the stake's being in one pair of hands. 
 Being in a concert party whose members are buying shares is neither wrong nor against the law. 
 The illegality comes only if those buyers conceal their relationship. 
 Four people could each buy almost five per cent of a company. 
 As long as they pretend they have no alliance, none of the four needs say a word about the share-buying. 
 The stock market has no inkling a big stake is being amassed, so the target's share price need not rise. 
 Then one of the four buys the stakes of the other three: suddenly, that single investor emerges with almost a fifthof a quoted company; the stake &mdash; a high platform for any a potential bidder &mdash; has been built far more cheaply than if one person had bought alone. 
 This is where the Department of Trade comes in &mdash; and indeed where there is a tenuous and innocent link with Cecil Parkinson and last week's huffy statement from his lawyers. 
 If there is a suspicion that a group of individuals is buying shares in concert without declaring their ties, the DTI should investigate. 
 The best-known current investigation is into share-buying in companies where Mr David Abell's Suter engineering group has been active. 
 (As the Guardian showed last week, Mr Parkinson's unwitting connection was through having had his money used to buy 50,000 shares in Newman Industries &mdash; since renamed Avdel &mdash; where Suter's stake-building eventually prompted a takeover.) 
 But consider two things about any DTI inquiry. 
 First, to show something was amiss, it has to show there was an undisclosed agreement between two or more investors who built up separate stakes and then pooled resources. 
 The lack of disclosure is the easy bit: either our party-members told the world or they did not. 
 But did an agreement exist in the first place? 
 How on earth can such an agreement be shown to exist? 
 Maybe the parties foolishly signed a pact which then found its way into the hands of the DTI. 
 (Let's face it, this is unlikely.) 
 Or perhaps the DTI anticipated their wrong-doing and so planted a bug to record the conversation at which the agreement was struck. 
 Again, it's far-fetched. 
 Without proof of an undisclosed agreement, it is impossible for anyone to bring a successful prosecution. 
 From this follows the first point: the existence of illegal concert parties is enormously hard to prove. 
 Second, the British way of doing things makes it hard for a company to discover the identity of a suspected concert party-goer hiding behind a nominee. 
 Yes, there is section 212 of the Companies Act. 
 That allows a target company to demand the identity of the owner of shares registered in a nominee name. 
 If the nominee refuses to co-operate, the company can strip the shareholding of its votes. 
 But what use is that where a concert party is suspected? 
 The very purpose of a concert party is to allow the building of stakes (with an s) which will be later pooled on one person's hands. 
 If the heat is put on one shareholder, he, she or it can simply sell to the individual intended all along to emerge eventually with the key stake. 
 The 212s and threat of disenfranchisement does no more than hurry the process along. 
 In the case of the DTI inquiry into Suter-related companies, one name repeatedly emerges as the manager of various shareholdings &mdash; the Swiss-based Sterling Trust. 
 Buying Sterling Trust shareholdings has helped Suter build predatory stakes in various companies &mdash; including, incidentally, Avdell where Mr Parkinson's money was invested. 
 Official records show little except the names of Sterling Trust's directors. 
 David Abell has said he does not know who is behind Sterling. 
 His only known connection is that both he and Sterling have held shares in Winchmore, a small London company under DTI scrutiny. 
 Forget Suter and Mr Abell. 
 The important point is this: is the use of an overseas company like Sterling (where inquiries about the real ownership of shareholdings in threatened companies are met with a polite but firm snub) acceptable within a legalframework trying to ensure fair play? 
 In the Alexander Howden case, for example, Swiss authorities showed themselves surprisingly willing to lift the veil on bank accounts in Geneva or Zurich. 
 When America's Securities and Exchange Commission investigated insider dealing ahead of the takeover of Santa Fe, the Swiss also helped. 
 Yet still it appears impossible to discover the ownership of shares held through a minor Swiss bank which were used to help a second division British company build up stakes in several third division British companies. 
 That information could clear Mr Abell's name &mdash; assuming, as he says, he knows nothing about the control of shares held through Sterling Trust. 
 At Geneva airport, there is an advertising hoarding welcoming travellers &bquo;to a city where money talks but wealth whispers&equo;. 
 Sometimes, even a whisper would be welcome. 
 Saunders wins round in fight for legal aid. 
 By Financial Staff 
 FORMER Guinness chairman Ernest Saunders yesterday won another round in his battle to secure legal aid to fight the multi-million pound civil action brought against him by the company. 
 Two High Court judges ruled that a Department of Social Security assessment officer had taken an &bquo;erroneous&equo; view of the regulations which govern the means test for legal aid. 
 Lord Justice Watkins, sitting with Mr Justice Garland, also rejected criticism made by Mr Justice Henry at an earlier hearing that Mr Saunders had set up a trust fund to render himself less likely to face litigation and reduce his ability to pay legal costs. 
 The court, the judge said, had more material before it than did Mr Justice Henry. 
 There was nothing to suggest the reduction in capital was brought about with the deliberate intention to obtain legal aid to which he would otherwise not be elegible. 
 Lord Justice Watkins added: &bquo;I would not accept that he did so to deceive his creditors, present or future.&equo; 
 The judges ordered DSS officer Alan Scaife to reconsider Mr Saunders' case after he had &bquo;effectively barred&equo; him from receiving legal aid because he had put &pound;407,000 into a trust for his children. 
 The cash represented his half share from the sale of the family home in Buckinghamshire. 
 Mr Scaife decided that Mr Saunders, now unemployed, had deliberately deprived himself of cash resources. 
 But he never went so far as to say that his intention was to qualify for legal aid, the court said. 
 The DSS argued that intention did not matter and under legal aid regulations they were entitled to treat Mr Saunders as having a notional &pound;407,000. 
 However, Lord Justice Watkins disagreed and said he saw no difficulty in imposing upon the assessment officer the duty to discover what intention lay behind the reduction of capital. 
 To refuse legal aid was a serious step. 
 Assessment of capital very much influenced that, and it was &bquo;of the highest importance&equo; that it was at all times a proper influence. 
 Mr Saunders was not in court but his son James said: &bquo;This is a very fair and just decision.&equo; 
 The DSS is considering whether to appeal. 
 Mr Saunders has already been granted legal aid of up to &pound;275,000 to defend himself against fraud charges in the criminal courts, but he may have to pay whole or part of that money back if the trial judge so decides. 
 He also owes between &pound;300,000 and &pound;400,000 for legal advice received so far. 
 Coats cuts in Cornwall. 
 Coats Viyella says St Austell in Cornwall will lose 290 jobs when it closes its Van Heusen shirt factory there in February. 
 The work will be transferred to the group's factories in Northern Ireland although some workers may find jobs with the group in Plymouth. 
 Last week, Coats Viyella announced nearly 200 job cuts in the North, blaming a combination of pressure from high interest rates, the strong pound and cheap imports. 
 The group is closing the St Austell plant despite recent capital investment and numerous employment initiatives. 
 It says it cannot get or keep skilled labour. 
 Service industries, like new supermarkets, have increased in the area and while these may not pay better, people prefer the working environment so high staff turnover has put the factory at an increasing economic disadvantage. 
 The company has set up a job search unit to help employees find other jobs and hopes part of the reduction will be achieved through natural wastage. 
 Europe lifts Unilever. 
 Walls' ice cream and other frozen food sales in Europe featured prominently in the Uni-lever combine's third-quarter sales and profit growth of around a sixth. 
 Influenced by the lower pound, earnings jumped by 22 per cent during the period and over the nine months. 
 The big US cosmetics acquisitions came in and washed their interest cost face. 
 Shareholders in the British half of the Anglo-Dutch group benefit from both the profit and exchange rate gains with an interim dividend increase to 4.51p a share, from 3.89p. 
 European sales jumped by 18 per cent to just over &pound;3billion for the quarter, and on a similar rise the enlarged US activities passed &pound;1billion, the global total moving above &pound;5 billion. 
 The US operating margin was narrowly the highest, but the rise of over half in interest charges limited the rise in pre-tax profit for the whole group to 10 per cent, at &pound;427million. 
 The nine-month gain was 13 per cent. 
 Earnings were 14p for the quarter, just under 1p coming from currency changes, taking the running total for nine months to 39.4p net a share, against 32.3p. 
 Detergents made progress in the US and in the rest of the world the performances in Brazil and India are singled out. 
 In short&hellip; 
 WHITBREAD Investment Company, the offshoot of the eponymous brewing empire, increased its income 9 per cent to just over &pound;7million in the six months to the end of September. 
 WIC's investments include a 47 per cent stake in Abingdon brewer Morland, currently the focus of takeover speculation. 
 AQUASCUTUM held sales only a hairsbreadth short of the corresponding figure at &pound;23.6million in the six months to July 31, but pre-tax profit slid to &pound;616,000, from &pound;809,000. 
 After a lower tax burden, earnings were 0.3p down at 1.44p and the interim dividend stays at 1p net a share. 
 The markets. 
 Banks were particularly strong on further reaction to Thursday's debt provision moves at Lloyds and Natwest, removing worries of possible rights issues. 
 Barclays, whose exposure to Third World debts are lower than most, led the way ahead with a 22p gain to 518p. 
 Oils rallied several pence now that the anticipated lower-earnings from BP and Shell are out of the way. 
 Unilever helped sentiment by revealing third-quarter profits at the top end of expectations. 
 The shares recovered 18p to 637p. 
 Wellcome, reporting full-year results next Thursday, advanced 11p to 705p. 
 BZW think the figures will be largely academic, but there will be plenty of interest in the prospects for the anti-Aids drug Retrovir. 
 Gilts, after four days of rising quotations, softened an eighth as the pound took a breather. 
 SEAQ volume at 5pm was 480.7 million. 
 Main changes: Unilever 637p, up 18p; Rothmans Intl, 617p down 21p; Wellcome 705p, up 11p; Barclays Bank, 518p, up 22p; NatWest, 334p, up 10p; Bremner, 65p down 13p; Burmah, 688p, down 8p; Abbey National, 157p up 8p. 
 Tokyo: Prices firmer. 
 Nikkei index: 35,663.20 (35,657.42). 
 Hong Kong: Prices closed narrowly lower. 
 Hang Seng index: 2,776.86 (2,781.44). 
 Frankfurt: Stocks surged broadly higher in active trading. 
 FAZ index: 634.84 (623.07). 
 Paris: Prices were little changed in moderate trading. 
 CAC index: 507.2 (507.7). 
 Details of the charges faced by the accused 1. 
 Conspiracy to contravene Section 13 of the Prevention Of Fraud (Investments) Act 1958, contrary to Section 1 (1) of The Criminal Law Act 1977. 
 NatWest Investment Bank Limited, County NatWest Limited, UBS Phillips and Drew Securities Limited (then Phillips &amp; Drew Securities Limited), Charles Villiers, Jonathan Cohen, David Reed, Nicholas Wells, Martin Gibbs, Christopher Stainforth, Paul Smallwood and Timothy Brown. 
 Between the 1st day of July 1987 and the 15th day of October 1987 conspired together and with other persons fraudulently to induce persons to enter into agreements for acquiring or subscribing for securities, namely shares in Blue Arrow plc, by making statements which they knew to be misleading, false or deceptive or by dishonestly concealing material facts or by recklessly making statements which were misleading, false or deceptive namely: 1.1 By failing to notify the Company Announcements Office of the Quotations Department of the International Stock Exchange by way of a Class 2 announcement (as provided for by Section 6 of the Council of the Stock Exchange's admission of securities to listing) following the purchase of shares in Manpower Incorporated for a consideration in excess of 5 per cent of the consolidated net assets of Blue Arrow; 1.2 By concealing the fact that the level of Acceptances of provisionally allotted new ordinary shares in Blue Arrow was 38.04 per cent at the expiry of the offer by way of rights issue at 3pm on September 28, 1987; 1.3 By concealing the fact that 54,625,000 new ordinary shares in Blue Arrow were taken up after 3pm on September 28, 1987; 1.4 By falsely stating that, in connection with the rights issue of 504.4 million new ordinary shares in Blue Arrow, acceptances had been received in respect of 246.5 million shares which represented 48.9 per cent of the rights issue. 
 2. 
 Conspiracy to defraud, contrary to common law. 
 NatWest Investment Bank, County NatWest, UBS Phillips and Drew Securities (then Phillips &amp; Drew Securities), Charles Villiers, Jonathan Cohen, Stephen Clark, Elizabeth Brimelow, David Reed, Nicholas Wells, Alan Keat, Martin Gibbs, Christopher Stainforth, Paul Smallwood and Timothy Brown. 
 Between the 14th day of September 1987 and the 8th day of January 1988 conspired together and with other persons to defraud such persons who had or might have had an interest in dealing in shares in Blue Arrow, or National Westminster Bank, or in dealing on the Financial Times Stock Exchange 100 share index, namely: 2.1 By dishonestly concealing holdings of 19.39 per cent of the share capital of Blue Arrow; 2.2 By falsely stating that all remaining shares not taken up in the rights issue by existing shareholders had been sold in the market; 2.3 By falsely representing that 33,315,528 shares in Blue Arrow held by County NatWest Securities were held for the purposes of market making; 2.4 By falsely representing that 34,069,433 shares in Blue Arrow held by Phillips &amp; Drew Securities were held for the purposes of market making; 2.5 By dealing off market with Union Bank of Switzerland in 28,201,743 shares in Blue Arrow when by reason of their connection with that company they were knowingly in possession of un-published price sensitive information; 2.6 By creating a false instrument, namely a letter of indemnity dated 5 October 1987 from Nicholas Wells on behalf of County NatWest to Union Bank Of Switzerland; 2.7 By engaging in a course of conduct which created a false or misleading impression as to the market in the shares of Blue Arrow for the purpose of creating such an impression and thereby influencing persons who might deal in those shares; 2.8 By purchasing and retaining 2,150 Financial Times Stock Exchange 100 share index put option contracts to cover a risk of &pound;51,500,000 whilst concealing from the market the true position in relation to the rights issue and the subsequent placing of shares in Blue Arrow, where Blue Arrow and National Westminster Bank were both component parts of that index. 
 2.9 By transferring 1,000,000 new ordinary shares in Blue Arrow from NatWest Investment Bank to County NatWest Securities to account for a similar holding by Handelsbank NatWest and falsely representing that those shares were held by County atWest Securities Limited for the purposes of market making; 2.10 By failing properly to account for the acquisition, distribution and disposal of 66,600,000 shares in Blue Arrow held by NatWest Investment Bank and County NatWest in the records required for accounting purposes by NatWest Investment Bank and County NatWest; 2.11 By failing properly to account for the acquisition, distribution and disposal of 34,069,433 shares in Blue Arrow held by Phillips &amp; Drew Securities in the records required for accounting purposes by Phillips &amp; Drew Securities; 2.12 By falsely representing that County NatWest had become interested in 9.5 per cent of the issued capital of Blue Arrow on December 17,1987 and that the board of Blue Arrow had been informed of that interest; 2.13 By concealing the true position in relation to the rights issue from the Bank of England, the International Stock Exchange, National Westminster Bank and/ or the board of directors of Blue Arrow; 2.14 By falsely representing that the rights issue had been honestly and successfully completed by reason of their general skill, competence and diligence. 
 Rock on for lower rates. 
 THE latest crop of reduced rate home loans include a low start mortgage from the Northern Rock Building Society. 
 It is available on home loans of between &pound;40,000 and &pound;150,000, where payments are deferred on 20 per cent of the loan in the first year and 10 per cent in the second. 
 Borrowers start making repayments on the full balance in the third year. 
 The unpaid interest is rolled up and added to the total debt. 
 Meanwhile the Britannia is offering 0.6 per cent off its base mortgage rate of 14.5 per cent to borrowers who need at least &pound;40,000 which cuts the rate of its Superloan mortgages to 13.9 per cent (APR 15.60) for the first year of the loan. 
 And the Greenwich is offering mortgages of at least &pound;30,000 at 13.45 per cent for the first year. 
 Centralised lender National Home Loans has a cap &amp; collar deal where the mortgage interest rate will not rise above 14.49 per cent or fall below 10.99 per cent over the next five years.. 
 New bond from Lloyds. 
 ON the savings front Lloyds Bank has a fixed-interest bond paying 11.7 per cent net on minimum deposits of &pound;5,000. 
 The interest will be paid after six months from the date of opening. 
 If you are prepared to tie up at least &pound;1,000 for two years the National &amp; Provincial has launched Security Bond III which currently pays 11.75 per cent net. 
 The society pledges to keep the rate on the new bond at least 4 per cent net above its Ordinary Share rate for 2 years. 
 The Bristol &amp; West's Vantage Bond, which locks up your cash for 12 months, pays a fraction more at 11.8 per cent net but needs a minimum opening deposit of &pound;5,000. 
 For those savers who are prepared to lock up their minimum deposit of &pound;5,000 for six months there is the Interest Assured Bond paying at least 11.5 per cent net. 
 Meanwhile, the Wiltshire-based Regency and West of England has come to the aid of small savers with a minimum of &pound;500 to invest. 
 Its fixed-interest bond pays 11.50 per cent net provided the money is tied up for at least 12 months.. 
 Key move on cards. 
 BANK of Scotland has introduced Keycard Plus, a new multi-function debit card which guarantees cheques up to &pound;100, accesses cash machines and effects payments at point of sale terminals for both Switch and Eftpos card systems. 
 The bank has simultaneously raised the cheque guarantee limit to &pound;250 for its Premier Visa cardholders.. 
 In the money. 
 EDINBURGH-BASED fund managers Stewart Ivory has added the Managed Cash Fund to its stable of unit trusts. 
 The fund invests in money market deposits with a range of banks and financial institutions. 
 The minimum investment is set at &pound;500 with an initial charge of 5 per cent plus an annual fee of 1 per cent. 
 Meanwhile the Unit Trust Association has published its Customer Code which explains what to expect from an investment in unit trusts. 
 Free copies of the leaflet are available from UTA, 65 Kingsway, London WC 2B 6TD. 
 Salut! as long-running French drinks feud comes to an end. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 THE LONG-running feud between two of France's wealthiest drinks dynasties has been resolved with the decision to merge liqueur group Cointreau with Remy Martin, one of the country's leading makers of cognac. 
 The merger, creating an organisation with sales of more than &pound;600million a year, ends a 20-year battle for control over Remy, the third largest cognac firm and the supplier of Krug champagne. 
 It also follows a spate of takeovers for all the other big cognac houses in recent years when market leader Hennessy fell to LVMH, Seagram acquired Martell and Courvoisier was purchased by Allied-Lyons. 
 Remy, which lost out to Martini last year in a bid for Benedictine, is the world's third largest cognac firm and the only one which is still family owned. 
 The Heriard-Dubreuil dynasty holds a 51 per cent stake in the group whilst the Cointreau family, headed by Max Cointreau, owns the remaining 49 per cent. 
 A stalemate at Remy led to the group establishing a separate distribution company Remy &amp; Associes &mdash; which recently gained a second market listing for 33 per cent of its shares &mdash; in order to find new finance for expansion. 
 &bquo;They are both extremely attractive targets but because of the family control neither could have been taken over without consent and, to date, the families have shown no inclination to sell out,&equo; said one Continental drinks watcher. 
 It is understood that both companies will continue to operate independently and that will mean that arrangements such as Cointreau's joint venture with GrandMet's IDV as well as Cinzano will remain in place. 
 Although there appear to be few operational savings planned from combining the two groups, three major benefits are expected to result from the merger: 
 A united management means it is less likely that disaffected family members will seek to realise the value of their shareholdings; their financial and political clout should improve as each of the families ceases attempts to undermine the other's access to finance for expansion, and; two separate distribution networks working together should mean the companies can gain additional contracts from non-competitive brand names. 
 Remy, which last year acquired the Heidsieck champagne business, has an annual turnover of around &pound;340million which is expected to rise to roughly &pound;450million in the year to next March. 
 Cointreau is slightly smaller with annual sales in the region of &pound;300 million. 
 Cointreu is said to be the seventh most popular liqueur in the world. 
 Court ruling means planes stay grounded. 
 By Financial Staff 
 TWO planes used by the financially troubled Paramount Airways will remain grounded over the weekend after the Court of Appeal last night overturned a court ruling just two hours before freeing the aircraft. 
 The aircraft have been held for a week because Paramount owes Bristol and Birmingham International airports &pound;1.7million. 
 A High Court application by the airports for their continued detention was succesfully contested by Paramount's administrator, supported by two creditors. 
 But the appeal judges later approved an agreement between the two sides in the dispute, allowing the airports to continue the detention of the planes until &pound;350,000 security is paid into court or until a full appeal hearing takes place in ten days time. 
 The court was also told that a sale of Paramount was expected to be completed in the next fortnight for &pound;1.5million. 
 . 
 By Teresa Hunter 
 YOUNG Abbey National savers Benny and Laura Grant will soon be losing the Abbey habit after missing out on the flotation cash distribution to young investors &mdash; due to the advice of the society's staff. 
 Mr Adrian Grant opened accounts for both his children when they were born. 
 Benny, eight, now has around &pound;850 in his, while sister Laura, four, has &pound;520. 
 Although Mr Grant, of Barkingside, Essex, had made it clear these were children accounts he was twice advised his name should be put first. 
 Minors could not qualify for free shares under the terms of the recent Abbey conversion to a public limited company. 
 Instead, they were to receive 5 per cent of their balances by way of a cash distribution. 
 Mr Grant visited his branch before the flotation to ask whether his children would get the cash distribution and was informed they would. 
 However they received nothing when the cash distribution took place last week. 
 Mr Grant says: &bquo;I am absolutely appalled by this. 
 My children should have grown up into loyal Abbey national customers. 
 &bquo;I cannot understand how any financial institution can rob two small children of their rights, when all we did was follow the Abbey National's advice all along. 
 An Abbey spokesman said it was common practice to advise that a parent's name should be put first for an account of a very small child. 
 But the distribution rules said shares or discounts had to go to the first named. 
 French farce locks in unitholders. 
 By Margaret Hughes 
 AS IF volatile markets aren't enough to contend with, private investors who invest in unit trusts primarily to minimise the risk of equity investment have found just how uncertain that too can prove. 
 The 12,000 unitholders who have invested in any of the 11 funds managed by Dumenil Trust Management, the French-owned unit trust group, found themselves this week locked into their investments when the fund managers suspended all dealings because they believed there was an error with pricing. 
 But it appears that pricing is not the only problem affecting investors in the Dumenil group. 
 IMRO, the City watchdog responsible for regulating fund managers, has revealed that it was already probing Dumenil's administration following complaints from investors that they were receiving their income late. 
 Guardian reader Peter John, who has holdings in Dumenil's Swiss, French and Spanish funds, claims he failed to receive any dividends in June and November as he expected. 
 After receiving a letter last week informing him there would be no dividend from his Swiss holding, he decided to sell. 
 However, as he posted his letter on Monday, he has been caught in the suspension trap, and it could be at least a month, before there is any prospect of seeing his money. 
 He said: &bquo;I only have a few thousand invested, but it is very worrying when you cannot get your money back, and there is no way of knowing how long it might be or how much I will get back.&equo; 
 On the same day investors in the somewhat better known Gartmore heard that their fund management group was to be the latest to change hands. 
 Present owners British &amp; Commonwealth announced that it hoped to raise an estimated &pound;130 million by putting it up for sale. 
 Gartmore investors will have to wait until the end of January to know who the new owners will be although it will almost certainly be an overseas based group. 
 Gartmore management is anxious to assure unitholders, along with investment trust, pension and offshore investors that it is &bquo;business as usual. 
 &bquo;Chairman and chief executive Paul Myners claims that Gartmore would only be sold to a party acceptable to the management. 
 It was, he said, essential that the new owners keep the 80-strong management team in place. 
 Experience with other fund management takeovers would however tend to suggest otherwise. 
 Dumenil fund managers have called in accountants Touche Ross to investigate the pricing problems and say they are &bquo;optimistic&equo; that they will be resolved within this time frame but are giving &bquo;no guarantees&equo;. 
 The fund managers have said that any investors who have suffered because they bought or sold at incorrect prices will be compensated. 
 But there will be no compensation for those who might have wanted to deal during the suspension period. 
 Imro chief executive John Morgan rightly describes the supension as &bquo;extremely disturbing&equo; for unitholders but is hopeful that with Touche Ross on board the administration difficulties will be resolved along with the pricing problem in the time available. 
 As thoughts turn to booking a place in the holiday sun, Money Guardian looks at both the costs and savings of taking a break. 
 Getting away with an investment 
 The Holiday Property Bond aims to point you in the direction of a vacation. 
 Jill Papworth reports 
 Leon Brittan defends telecom move. 
 By Peter Large Technology Editor 
 PROTECTION of national telecoms monopolies by European Community governments &bquo;is not to be tolerated,&equo; Sir Leon Brittan, the Commissioner for competition policy, said in London yesterday. 
 Sir Leon was defending the compromise proposal that emerged at a meeting of the Community's industry ministers this week, whereby the Commission might grant temporary exemptions to countries facing problems in opening their markets. 
 He said that the Commission &bquo;has not wavered one iota&equo; in its determination to ensure competition. 
 The state telecoms monopolies wanted to retain their privileged positions, and that meant extending their privileges, since new technologies and services were springing up on every hand. 
 In too many cases telecoms authorities had persuaded their governments to defend them from the provisions of the Treaty of Rome. 
 &bquo;And that is not to be tolerated.&equo; 
 Key pensions victory for lucky 13 million New proposals are good news for employees, but a disappointment for directors. 
 Mihir Bose reports. 
 A MAJOR victory has been won in the long-running battle to protect the rights of approximately 13 million members of company pension schemes. 
 This week Social Services Secretary Tony Newton announced a wide ranging series of proposals that will strengthen the rights and privileges of company pension scheme members. 
 However these proposals may remove a very attractive pensions option for directors of small companies. 
 Trade unions, the Industrial Society, and the Occupational Pensions Advisory Service have been campaigning for years to improve employees' rights over their retirement income. 
 Major concerns included the millions of pounds of benefits lost because of difficulties claiming pensions earned early on. 
 Company takeovers, where a predator may try to raid the fund, were another area of concern. 
 Among the package of proposals meant to safeguard members of company pension schemes, Mr Newton plans to have a tracing service based on a register of pension schemes to help people track down pensions held with their previous employers. 
 And those who change jobs or whose firms get taken over will now get extra protection. 
 The proposals also have a safeguard in takeovers, where a preadator often has his eye on a rich pension scheme. 
 Employers will not be able to make bulk transfers of employees from one scheme to another unless certain conditions are met. 
 This should put a stop to the sort of attempt made by Hanson after it had successfully taken-over Imperial. 
 However the government has not gone as far as it might have. 
 It is not going to require all schemes to increase pensions in payment by up to a maximum of 5 per cent a year. 
 But then not even the Occupations Pensions Board, whose report has lead to the current proposals, suggested that. 
 The government hopes employers will do it voluntarily. 
 There is also to be a pensions ombudsman with statutory backing. 
 However the Occupational Pensions Board called for a pensions tribunal and Tony Thurham, chairman of the Association of Pensions Lawyers, said: &bquo;Many pensions lawyers would have preferred a tribunal since it would probably have had greater powers and more staff. 
 Despite this, these are impressive and long-needed safeguards for members of company pensions. 
 But directors of small companies who can have their own special pension arrangements will find that most of the benefits of such schemes have been removed. 
 These are schemes which have generally less than 12 members. 
 The most attractive feature is that the directors can borrow back half the money in the scheme and invest it in their business.The Revenue has for some time been concerned about what is done with the money. 
 Two years ago a consultative document from the Inland Revenue proposed that the loan-back be limited to 25 per cent. 
 But the government is now proposing that all schemes, including small ones, should not be allowed to invest more than 5 per cent of their money in their employer's businesss. 
 Small schemes were created in the 1970s as a result of an Inland Revenue concession but once these government proposals are enacted that concession will become history. 
 The Revenue conceedes that it will mean the virtual end of some 15,000 small schemes with &pound;3 billion in assets. 
 Sections of the pensions industry who advise such schemes have already started to protest. 
 But the Department of Social Security confirmed that the government is serious about this 5 per cent limit applying to all schemes and &bquo;envisage no exemption.&equo; 
 Money Guardian is edited by Personal Finance Editor Margaret Hughes 
 Winter in the sun and save money. 
 By Morag Campbell 
 NOW is the time of year when tour operators' thoughts turn to tempting the over-60s &mdash; and increasingly the over 55s &mdash; to spend their winters in the sun. 
 The brochures claim it can be cheaper than staying at home. 
 And anyway, the thought of spending January and February in Spain or Portugal for as little as &pound;10 a day seems attractive in its own right. 
 But if you want to escape the British winter and make substantial savings you have to plan ahead. 
 Obviously you will save on heating bills, petrol, and if you book in all-inclusive holiday, on what you would otherwise have spent on food at home. 
 Even if you spend the winter in a self-catering apartment, you may be able to save money by shopping in local markets and finding prices cheaper than at home. 
 But there are other less obvious savings which can be taken into account if you are prepared to write a few letters and fill out a form or two. 
 If you run a car, you are entitled to a rebate on your Road Find Licence for every complete month your vehicle is off the road. 
 But &bquo;off the road&equo; means just that. 
 Don't go off to the sun and leave it parked in the street. 
 Whether you have paid your &pound;100 fee for the full year or &pound;55 for a six-month licence, you entitled to a rebate of &pound;8.33 for each whole month left on the licence disc. 
 Be sure to apply before the first of the calendar month when you want the rebate to start. 
 If you apply on December 1, for instance, the rebate will not start until January 1 and you will lose a month. 
 Ask at your main Post Office for rebate form V14. 
 You may also get a rebate on your car insurance, provided it is off the road for at least 28 days. 
 Investigate whether your insurance will be partially suspended &mdash; that is leaving you with cover for fire and theft &mdash; entirely suspended or completely cancelled. 
 Remember, however, that on your return to the UK you will not have immediate use of your car. 
 Your Road Fund Licence and insurance will have to be renewed and getting these organised may well take a week or two, especially if your car is over three years old and your MoT certificate lapsed during your absence. 
 The AA doesn't offer a rebate on its breakdown and rescue services. 
 The RAC will suspend your membership while you are away, but only once a year. 
 If you are away for several weeks your phone bill should be much lower than normal and you will automatically receive a Low User Rental Rebate. 
 Some water authorities will give you a rebate on your water supply while you winter abroad. 
 But they will make a charge for disconnecting and reconnecting which may negate the saving unless you are out of the country for several months. 
 If you rent your TV and video you can save money by suspending or even cancelling your contract for the period you are away. 
 Since an empty house is more of a challenge to burglars and squatters than one where there is lots of activity, you can't expect a rebate on your house and contents insurance &mdash; in fact your insurance company may even charge an extra premium if you are away for more than30 days. 
 Finally, if there is a demand in your area for short-term property letting, you may be able to make a profit from renting out your home while you are away. 
 If the possibility appeals, make sure you take advice first from an accountant on the tax implications and go through a reputable property agent to handle the short-term rental contract. 
 Saga publishes a booklet, Saving and Spending on Longer Holidays Abroad, which not only details the savings householders of any age can expect to make while they take an extended holiday, but also gives advice to pensioners on how to ensure they get their pension while they winter abroad. 
 It is available from: Saga PR, The Saga Building, Middelburg Square, Folkestone, Kent CT20 1AZ. 
 (Tel: 0303 47523). 
 PAGE 
 Wall Street trading probe. 
 Allegations that recent sharp swings in share prices on Wall Street were aggravated by traders manipulating the stock and futures markets are being investigated in New York and Chicago, writes Mary Brasier in New York. 
 The New York Stock Exchange and the Chicago commodity exchanges are looking at programme trades carried out last July which may have flouted market rules and contributed to sudden movements in both the Dow Jones index and the S&amp;P 500 futures index. 
 Ford head retires. 
 Ford of America stressed yesterday that there would be no &bquo;significant&equo; changes in the way the company was run after announcing that Mr Donald Petersen, chairman for the past decade, is to retire. 
 Burmah mum. 
 Burmah, where Dutch industrial group SHV has built up a 9 per cent stake, refused to comment on rumours in New York that it was preparing a bid for American-based Quaker State Corporation which makes motor oils. 
 NYSE fire shut-down. 
 The start of trading on the New York and American Stock Exchanges was held up for an hour yesterday after a fire, caused by an electrical fault, broke out in the building housing the exchanges' computer systems, writes Mary Brasier in New York. 
 Last night, the Dow Jones Industrial Average added 21.92 points to 2,625.61, a 0.84 per cent rise. 
 ConsGold break-up. 
 Hanson yesterday began the break-up of the Consolidated Gold Field's empire when it sold ARC Construction to its management for &pound;6.3million. 
 ARC Construction last year had a turnover of &pound;75 million and pre-tax profit of &pound;350,000. 
 De Savary approval. 
 Peter de Savary's Canvey Island development has won approval from the local planning committee which voted 15 to one in favour of the plan to build a new community, against the advice of its chief planning officer. 
 Pembridge declares. 
 Roland Franklin's Pembridge group yesterday declared unconditional its &pound;697million break-up bid for the Sellotape to Basildon Bond group, DRG. 
 Plea for more power stations. 
 By Patrick Donovan and Michael White 
 BRITAIN faces the prospect of a huge energy shortfall of up to 25 per cent by the middle 1990s unless new generating plant is brought on stream to replace the abandoned Pressurised Water Reactor programme, sources claimed last night. 
 As pressure grows on Energy Secretary, Mr John Wakeham to increase competition in the privatised power market by breaking National 
 Power's generating monopoly, ministers have been warned that more power stations must urgently be brought on stream to meet projected demand. 
 The Government is also facing growing pressure from its own right wing to inject a more competitive structure into the generating industry in the wake of this week's withdrawal of nuclear power from the privatisation package &mdash; by breaking up the proposed duopoly of National Power and PowerGen. 
 Tory backbenchers who never liked the duopoly solution are determined to get the Energy department to unpick its handiwork, either by making National Power and PowerGen, more evenly sized companies or insisting that one or more new generating firms should be allowed to compete in the British market. 
 The loss of the PWR programme, coming months after the decision to scrap three major coal burning power stations, will reduce projected power supply by 13,000 mw &mdash; around 25 per cent of total supply &mdash; by the middle of the next decade. 
 Fears of an energy shortfall will lend new weight to calls by PowerGen, the smaller of the two Central Electricity Generating Boards, to take over a bigger share of the power market. 
 The company has appealed Mr Wakeham in a bid to dilute the market share promised to National Power which will retain a near 50 per cent interest in British generating plant even without its nuclear plant. 
 A Department of Energy spokesman last night said that there were &bquo;no plans to restructure the offer&equo;. 
 PowerGen, backed up by representations from more than 70 independent generating companies, has told ministers that National Power will monopolise the market. 
 Meanwhile, National Power Chairman, Lord Marshall is planning to resign on Monday. 
 He spent yesterday finalising terms of his payoff package with Treasury officials. 
 It is understood that British Petroleum chairman, Sir Peter Walters has been shortlisted to take over the job. 
 Sir Peter, stands down at BP in spring next year. 
 . 
 By Mihir Bose 
 INVESTMENTS could soon be sold like whiter-than-white washing powder if the latest Personal Equity Plan launch is anything to go by. 
 With much-ballyhoo, Scottish Mutual has announced the introduction, from December 1, of what it describes as the first &bquo;risk-graded&equo; Personal Equity Plan. 
 Investors will have a choice of three unit trusts: an income trust, a growth trust and an opportunity trust. 
 The income trust will invest in between 60 and 70 UK stocks &mdash; mainly blue chip companies like ICI &mdash; and will seek to maintain at least the current dividends levels in all but &bquo;the worst possible economic circumstances.&equo; 
 The growth trust will invest in a broad spread of between 60-100 UK stocks and the opportunity trust will invest in no more than 40 stocks which are special situations &mdash; smaller companies, possible bid targets, or short-term prospects. 
 Income trust is considered the safest, growth is a bit more risky and opportunity the chanciest. 
 The investor has to choose how much of their &pound;2,400 will go in each of them. 
 Anyone who feels he can afford to risk the lion's share of his &pound;2,400 could have most of it in the opportunity trust. 
 Switches can always be made although a charge of &pound;10 plus a 1 per cent bid/offer spread would be payable. 
 But what Scottish Mutual means by risk is volatility, and that idea is under fire. 
 Christopher Poll, managing director of Micropal statistics service warns: &bquo;People are confusing volatility with risk. 
 The result is that this whole question of measuring risk has became a mess. 
 &bquo;Volatility is only the first stage in measuring risk. 
 To the average investor risk is the loss of capital value whereas to the academics risk is calculation of a deviation from an index.&equo; 
 Scottish Mutual is asking investors to choose which type of unit trust they think will be more volatile. 
 Other unit trust managers have been using statistical tools to measure volatility as an aid to investment. 
 Micropal measures volatility for all unit trusts which have been going for three years. 
 Anything under three years, except money market funds, says Mr Poll, does not provide a proper statistical sample to measure volatility. 
 The risk-graded investment &mdash; be it under Scottish Mutual's calculations or the statistical tools used by other unit trust managers &mdash; can be no more than a guide. 
 The idea that there is an investment-equivalent of the detergent that washes whiter than white just does not work. 
 Meanwhile, other PEPs are coming on to the market. 
 Henderson Financial Management has launched an Investment Trust Equity PEP which will invest in Lowland Investment Company plc plus a selection of five quality UK companies. 
 The quality shares could include Hanson, Fisons, MRPC, Whitbread and LASMO. 
 Commercial Union is also looking at top flight equities and/or unit trusts with its CU Quilter Personal Equity Plan. 
 For confused investors, there is Shaw &amp; Co Ltd's Private Client PEP Club. 
 A &pound;60 joining fee and yearly management fee of 1 per cent of the value of the investment within he PEP gets clients a range of advice and options on their PEP investment. 
 &pound;1.1m bail for eleven in Blue Arrow case. 
 By Peter Rodgers City Editor 
 TEN City executives and a solicitor were yesterday bailed for a total of &pound;1.1million after appearing at Guildhall magistrates court on charges of conspiracy to defraud in the Blue Arrow rights issue. 
 Bail was set at &pound;100,000 each on condition that the defendants surrender their passports, do not discuss the case with a list of potential witnesses, and notify police of any change of address. 
 The defendants are to appear again on January 12. 
 Reporting restrictions were not lifted. 
 The 11 were arrested on Thursday morning and charged &mdash; along with NatWest Investment Bank, County NatWest Securities and UBS Phillips &amp; Drew Securities &mdash; on 14 counts of conspiracy to defraud persons dealing in the shares of Blue Arrow or NatWest Bank or in options on the FT-SE 100 index. 
 The three companies and eight of the defendants were also accused on four counts of fraudulently inducing purchases of shares in Blue Arrow and NatWest Investment Bank, County NatWest Securities and UBS Phillips &amp; Drew Securities. 
 The main charges relate to the creation of a false market in Blue Arrow shares between mid-1987 and January 1988, by giving a wrong impression that an &pound;837million rights issue and placing of Blue Arrow shares had been successful. 
 One charge related to dealing in options on the FT-SE 100 and alleges that the accused bought options with a face value of &pound;51.5million while concealing the failure of the rights issue. 
 Blue Arrow and NatWest Bank were component parts of the FT-SE 100 index. 
 All eleven including former County NatWest chairman Mr Charles Villiers, the firm's compliance officer, Ms Elizabeth Brimelow, County's finance director Stephen Clark and Mr Alan Keat, a partner in City solicitors Travers, Smith Braithwaite, left court immediately. 
 One of the defendants, former County NatWest chief executive Jonathan Cohen, later issued a statement through his solicitors &bquo;vehemently denying&equo; wrongdoing. 
 He said that in detailed investigation over 18 months by National Westminster Bank deputy chairman Sir Philip Wilkinson and by two Department of Trade inspectors &bquo;my actions and behaviour were exonerated completely and no ground for criticism or fault was found. 
 In these circumstances, the bringing of criminal charges in this way is, I believe, unfair and utterly baseless.&equo; 
 Twenty suspects in Ferranti fraud. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 FERRANTI, the troubled defence electronics group, said yesterday it has identified around 20 people involved with the alleged &pound;215million International Signal &amp; Control fraud against whom legal action may be launched. 
 The company, which has just concluded preliminary talks with 13 potential predators and is poised for big cuts in staffing costs, pledged to try to recover all the money lost through the ISC affair. 
 The FBI and Britain's Serious Fraud Office are investigating the scandal at its US offshoot, which is alleged to date back to 1983 and involve bogus defence contracts with Pakistan, China and South Africa. 
 A Ferranti spokesman would not give details of the individuals or organisations against which legal action may be taken but said: &bquo;We would hope in the not too distant future to take the necessary legal action to put everything right.&equo; 
 Progress on the ISC inquiry came as a mystery investor emerged in the company and as staffing cuts were introduced in an effort to offset the ISC losses and an overall decline in defence business. 
 Delaporte Establishment &mdash; the nominee company which emerged earlier this week with a significant shareholding in merchant bank Morgan Grenfell &mdash; yesterday disclosed a 1.13 per cent Ferranti stake. 
 The company denied huge redundancies at its Edinburgh plant although it admitted ax-ing Sunday and overtime working, banning non-essential recruitment and introducing voluntary early retirement. 
 If these strategems failed, redundancies of up to 400 people might be sought. 
 Ferranti's move came in the wake of complaints about a market turndown from rivals such as Racal and Thomson CSF &mdash; the French group which may bid for Ferranti with British Aerospace. 
 Yesterday it was also disclosed that Thorn EMI had failed to sell its defence business after trying for five months. 
 Joint ventures or mergers are now being sought. 
 . 
 By Teresa Hunter 
 THE deal between the Cheltenham &amp; Gloucester and Guardian building societies announced this week has changed the face of society mergers. 
 Guardian members are to receive an average &pound;520 cash windfall for voting &bquo;yes&equo; to the merger at a special meeting in December &mdash; the first time a bonus of this size has been paid out on a simple merger operation. 
 The Abbey National gave itsmembers a bonus in the form of 100 free shares when it became a public limited company in July. 
 However, this would not have been worth as much as the Guardian payout to the average investor. 
 There have been some 35 building society mergers over the past five years. 
 Although some bonuses have been paid they have been less than 1 per cent. 
 But the C&amp;G merger plan could mark a turning point. 
 If Guardian members receive an average &pound;520 for giving the nod to a plan to allow their society to remain a mutual &mdash; and to continue operating much as it has since the turn of the century &mdash; what price a vote to convert? 
 Now, other conversion plans could well depend on the size of the hand-out rather than the principles involved in surrending mutuality. 
 It is puzzling why the C&amp;G's managing director Andrew Longhurst feels he needs to pay Guardian members 4 per cent of their balances to get them to agree to the merger. 
 C&amp;G's 1 million-plus members, who will also have to approve the merger at a special meeting, will receive nothing for voting &bquo;yes&equo;. 
 More than 75 per cent of those voting must be in favour. 
 The Guardian, which has 80,000 investors, 35,000 borrowers and assets of &pound;1 billion, is an unusual case in that its reserves are higher than those of many societies. 
 The C&amp;G claims the cash distribution is merely designed to bring the reserves of the two societies in line. 
 However, as a major reason for the merger must be to improve the C&amp;G's capital position, it is curious for it to give away quite so much money. 
 It estimates the bonus and the mortgage discount will cost &pound;42 million. 
 The mortgage hand-out will cost a further &pound;5 million. 
 Guardian chairman Vic Dawson has announced that all the society's savers will receive 4 per cent of their balances on every account held. 
 This differs from the Abbey National share allocation, where just one share allocation was permitted per saver, regardless of the number of accounts held. 
 As the average Guardian balance is &pound;13,000, this gives an estimated average tax-free payout of &pound;520. 
 Guardian borrowers will enjoy a 0.5 per cent discount for one year, giving a saving of &pound;250 on a typical Guardian mortgage of &pound;50,000. 
 The normal merger procedure is to ask members of the society being transferred &mdash; in this case the Guardian &mdash; for permission to merge. 
 Members of the society which remains unchanged are not asked for their views. 
 However, building society merger rules, allow for a maximum 1 per cent of assets to be distributed among members in this case. 
 A larger distribution requires the consent of the members of the smaller society as well as those of the larger one. 
 Halifax general manager David Gilchrist says: &bquo;It has always been the belief that this process of consultation would be extremely cumbersome and costly. 
 However the C&amp;G plan could well show that such mergers are possible.&equo; 
 The Guardian distribution also has the advantage over the Abbey National share allocation in that it is tax-free and net of all osts. 
 Abbey National investors were forced to incur costs selling their shares. 
 Guardian investors will also receive hand-outs on a pro-rata basis. 
 The Abbey's share distribution caused much feeling with many investors. 
 And now societies still interested in the conversion possibility will be carefully weighing up the reception given to the Guardian scheme compared with Abbey's. 
 Alliance &amp; Leicester's general manager Peter White confirmed that his society remains committed to the possibility of converting to a PLC, once it finds it is unable to carry out its strategic plans as a mutual. 
 It denies that its proposed purchase of GiroBank necessarily postpones the conversion plans. 
 He said: &bquo;I could push the button today and we could convert in six months. 
 There are a number of options available for a cash distribution. 
 We would certainly strive for the most equitable route. 
 But in the Guardian's case they are fortunate to have such high reserves.&equo; 
 The Halifax's name always remains in the frame as a conversion possibility. 
 Mr Gilchrist points out the strategic difference between the Abbey and the Guardian distribution. 
 He says: &bquo;The flat hand-out is appropriate if you are seeking to mobilise the maximum numbers to vote.&equo; 
 The Guardian only needs to seek agreement from 75 per cent of those who vote, while the Abbey had to secure the vote of 20 per cent of all eligible investing members, with 75 per cent of those in favour and a majority vote in favour from eligible borrowers. 
 TSB hangs up on a telephone banking scheme. 
 By Teresa Hunter 
 THE TSB, the bank which likes to say &bquo;yes&equo;, has followed the Midland into direct banking &mdash; but it has said &bquo;no&equo; to launching a comprehensive telephone banking package. 
 TSB Direct will offer personal loans, mortgages and insurance advice to the TSB's seven million customers and customers of other banks who wish to apply. 
 There will be two direct channels &mdash; a fast-answer telephone service for sophisticated customers and a postal service for the less sophisticated. 
 The TSB claims it will offer better and cheaper financial services than can be bought over the counter in TSB branches. 
 Essentially three loan packages are available for different income groups. 
 They are: TSB Choice, which tailors interest rates to individuals credit scoring, UDT Direct, primarily for existing customers of the TSB's finance house, and TSB Direct. 
 Although there is some confusion, it seems UDT was designed for those earning more than &pound;8,500, TSB Direct, for those earning &pound;10,000 plus and TSB Choice for those earning more than &pound;12,000. 
 Pilot tests have been carried out for much of this year with both the Choice loans package and direct access, but TSB Direct was formally established on November 1. 
 TSB Direct managing director Philip Haynes said an all-singing all-dancing banking service, like Midland's First Direct, could follow &mdash; but only when he believed there was something &bquo;demonstrably better&equo; about a direct bank account compared with a traditional branch-based account. 
 He argued: &bquo;We don't believe the market is ready yet. 
 We prefer to convert customers a piece at a time. 
 Our research shows that people are happy to buy loans direct.&equo; 
 Midland believes that following 40,000 inquiries for First Direct in October, it will open 4,000 to 5,000 accounts during the first month. 
 But customers who deal direct are cheaper in the long run to process than those who buy through branches. 
 Therefore TSB Direct claims it will offer cheaper products than are available through the branches. 
 TSB Direct also claims loans can be turned round in five days from application. 
 However bank statements and a mortgage statement will be required. 
 TSB Choice is the fast-answer telephone service. 
 It tailors interest rates to match each individual customer's financial position. 
 But, broadly, charges are 21.9 to 25.3 APR for unsecured personal loans. 
 Secured loans will cost 17.8 to 19.9 APR, and the mortgage rate will be 14.75 per cent. 
 UDT has been selling car loans through the mail for more than 60 years and it will continue to sell loans through the post. 
 Its interest rates on unsecured loans range from 24.6 to 28.3 APR. 
 The cost of a loan secured against your home is 18.5 APR. 
 The third Direct package again will be promoted primarily through the mail. 
 It is designed for those who are not quite as sophisicated as Choice customers. 
 Its unsecured loan rates will range from 22.8 to 24.6 APR. 
 Secured loans will range from 18.5 to 20.9 APR. 
 ONE MORE increase in interest rates means yet another deluge of incentives from housebuilders aimed at enticing buyers out of their shells. 
 Discounts, buy-backs, chainbreaking, free carpets, mortgage subsidies &mdash; the list gets longer as the stock of unsold new homes rises. 
 But how effective are these bribes? 
 Recent research suggests that buyers are unashamedly mercenary in screwing the most out of a builder. 
 But they insist that the money goes into their own pockets. 
 Free legal and survey fees come top of the list, according to findings by Research Associates Stone. 
 Most unpopular are subsidies to attract a buyer to take over an existing home so the seller is released to trade up. 
 First-buyers can be excused for favouring discounts and cheap mortgages, because they have no existing place to unload. 
 Others should realise that their selfishness may be making their problems worse. 
 Most people can find cut-price deals which reduce mortgage payments to levels considered acceptable when prices were booming, so the cost of moving is not as severe as high interest rates might imply. 
 But they cringe at the idea that someone else may benefit at their expense. 
 Buyers will bargain hard to cut the cost of the house they want, but dig in their heels rather than reduce their own asking price. 
 That, as much as the cost of mortgages, is why the system has frozen solid, with hardly anyone buying or selling. 
 Most people sit tight rather than lose a slice of what they see as their rightful &bquo;profit&equo;. 
 And they look down their noses at schemes devised by builders which may offer &pound;100 a month to encourage a potential purchaser of their existing home. 
 Unless a lot of people start looking beyond the bottom of their pockets, many houses will remain unsold for at least another year, because the Government is unlikely to bring interest rates down until the run-up to the next general election. 
 It is a worry that will have builders scouring this report for ideas, although at &pound;295 a copy it is unlikely that any cost-conscious home owners will take the trouble to read about their prejudices. 
 Selling Houses in a Difficult Market, by Research Associates Stone (tel: 0785 813164) 
 ESTATE agents' boards are the unsightly flotsam on a rising tide of home ownership. 
 They clutter streets, smother blocks of flats and deface many homes. 
 Just about everyone hoped they would disappear without trace when that tide ebbed and frenetic buying and selling ground to a halt. 
 Instead, they have beached in a large stain across Britain's front gardens. 
 Anyone with a home proving difficult to sell &mdash; which means just about everyone &mdash; will be resigned by now to a peeling, semi-permanent board mated to the gatepost. 
 Flat-dwellers have probably forgotten what the front of their block looks like behind the forest of advertisments. 
 But be warned: if you own more than one sign, PC Plod could be knocking on the door with a warrant one day. 
 Strict regulations brought in this year banned multiple boards and restricted the size to something around the measurements of a large tea-towel. 
 Agents know they could face fines of up to &pound;400 for breaking the rules, but many keep taking the risk because they relish the free advertising. 
 And they will never pass on the fact that owners could be liable to the same punishment. 
 The problem arises mainly in the South, where it is customary for sellers to appoint several agents. 
 The new rules forbid more than one to put up a sign, a rule usually ignored by whoever is second or third on the list. 
 That sign must also be no more than half a square metre in area and all signs should be removed within two weeks of a sale being completed. 
 Central London councils like Westminster and Kensington &amp; Chelsea have cracked down on agents because they face particular problems through large blocks of flats permanently smothered with signs. 
 &bquo;Hit squads&equo; make regular weekend forays to pull down signs and fill notebooks with names. 
 But the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors is angry that some other local authorities are letting agents get away with murder. 
 It feels that cowboys are being allowed to give everyone else a bad name by scattering illegal signs. 
 Spokesman Jim Sutton says they should be &bquo;prosecuted with vigour&equo;, but he reminds owners that they could be liable to the same fate if planners ever get tough. 
 Westminster environmental protection officer Sid Geake says the council has just about cracked the problem of multiple signs, but is now going even further to curb the blight. 
 Most of the city is covered by conservation areas, so it is asking for special controls on large swathes where even single signs would detract from the historic appearance. 
 Parts of Maida Vale and Bayswater have already been subject to controls. 
 The council wants to renew these and extend them to the whole of those districts and also bring in Pimlico and Westbourne. 
 Stock Exchange rallies strongly in response to open border. 
 By Alex Brummer Financial Editor 
 THE Frankfurt Stock Exchange yesterday greeted the opening of the borders between the two Germanys with a strong and jubilant rally, despite fears on the foreign exchange markets that rapid political developments could weaken the Bundesbank's fight against inflation. 
 The DAX index of West Germany's 30 leading shares surged 33.73 points, or 2.3 per cent, to 1,496.69 in one of the strongest daily peformances in recent months. 
 Investors were elated by the prospect of a more buoyant West German economy as Bonn provides houses and jobs for arrivals from the East. 
 &bquo;The mood is super,&equo; a senior dealer said. 
 But the prospect of economic growth rising by a further half-point during the next six months raised fears on the international currency markets of an uncontrolled expansion and increased concern about inflation throughout Europe. 
 The Bundesbank has been seen until now as Europe's guardian against rapid price increases. 
 On the foreign exchanges, the mark fell more than a pfennig against the dollar and dropped against the currencies of West Germany's partners in the EMS exchange-rate mechanism. 
 With the West German economy growing fast already, the impetus from the East German migration and closer links across the border could hasten a rise in European-wide interest rates. 
 The West German Finance Minister, Mr Theo Waigel, ruled out a common German currency until economic reforms had been carried out in the East. 
 &bquo;A currency union can only be reached if there is convertibility, if the East German mark is brought into a sensible relationship with the West German mark, and if East Germany has undergone decisive monetary, financial and economic reform,&equo; he said. 
 Ashkenazy at ease in land of his birth. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 VLADIMIR Ashkenazy, one of the world's greatest pianists, said yesterday he felt far more at home in the Soviet Union now than when he departed under a cloud half a lifetime ago. 
 Returning to Moscow at the age of 52, for the first time since he left to live in London 26 years ago, Ashkenazy said: &bquo;In my modest way, I thought I could endorse what's happening in my country.&equo; 
 Although he was never a political defector, he said he probably would not have come back before President Gorbachev launched his perestroika policy. 
 In 1963 &bquo;there were some very unpleasant moments&equo;, he told journalists at the Soviet Culture Foundation. 
 &bquo;For many years in Moscow, I felt I couldn't leave the country.&equo; 
 But now, he said, &bquo;I see open faces. 
 People aren't frightened. 
 I feel at ease &mdash; much better than I did then.&equo; 
 The immediate reason for his return is to give two charity concerts with the Royal Philharmonic Orchestra this weekend for the victims of last year's Armenian earthquake. 
 The Soviet world of culture is not alone in regarding Ashkenazy as an immensely welcome guest. 
 His endorsement of perestroika will be music as sweet in the ears of Mr Gorbachev and his supporters, as the brilliant notes everyone confidently expects to hear from him. 
 To the media, he was engagingly modest and direct, with a warmth of personality that immediately won their hearts. 
 In his opening remarks in Russian, he said: &bquo;I don't like being the centre of a sensation, but I know I can't avoid it this time.&equo; 
 Asked why it had taken him 26 years to return, he said: &bquo;I wasn't invited till last year &mdash; though if I had been before perestroika, I would have thought not twice but 10 times about it, and I'm not sure I would have come.&equo; 
 Asked what he hoped for Soviet art and culture after long years of political oppression, he said there would be an enormous spiritual benefit, not least because of easier travel and contacts with the rest of the world. 
 &bquo;But then there's the counter-argument. 
 If Shostakovich was writing now, he wouldn't have had the same material. 
 Many of his symphonies dealt with desolation &mdash; no light at the end of the tunnel. 
 We wouldn't have had Symphonies eight and ten. 
 So who knows? 
 Some of the greatest works of art have been produced at the most difficult times.&equo; 
 And then a pause &mdash; and a thought for perestroika. 
 &bquo;But give me this any time,&equo; he laughed. 
 Court hears of plot to kill Zia. 
 By Kathy Evans in Lahore 
 ACOURT in the small Massachusetts town of Springfield heard an extraordinary tale last week of a &dollar;1 million plot to kill the late President of Pakistan, General Zia ul-Haq. 
 Mushtaq Malik, who is on trial in Springfield on heroin smuggling charges, claimed that he organised a plot on behalf of the Pakistan People's Party (PPP) which now rules Pakistan. 
 Zia was killed on August 7 last year along with 29 of his top generals and senior US officials in a plane crash in a remote part of Punjab. 
 An official inquiry by the Pakistan military and US army experts determined that sabotage had caused the crash and that Zia's pilots had been knocked out by a poisonous gas. 
 No one has been arrested. 
 Last week the Springfield court heard that Malik, known in Pakistan as the &bquo;Black Prince&equo;, had plotted to kill Zia together with a Jordanian drug associate, Sanir Hashemi. 
 Malik told the court he had paid Hashemi &dollar;1 million for preliminary expenses and to buy the necessary equipment for the assassination. 
 After several months of stalling, he believed Hashemi had tricked him and he went to the United States to retrieve his money &mdash; and save his face with his &bquo;superiors&equo; in the PPP. 
 Malik's claim took his defence lawyer, Stephen Ferrarone by surprise: &bquo;Not my idea of the best defence, believe me. 
 I would prefer not to have my guy stand up and say I may have been involved in an assassination.&equo; 
 Malik is being tried on charges of conspiracy to smuggle &dollar;10 million of heroin into the US. 
 Hashemi, who was found carrying two kilos of heroin, agreed to co-operate with US officials to entrap Malik. 
 In Islamabad, officials of the PPP government have vehemently denied any suggestion of involvement in the death of Zia. 
 An aide to the Prime Minister said Malik's statement was &bquo;another attempt by the drug mafia to discredit the government because of Benazir Bhutto's campaign against the drug trade&equo;. 
 However, relatives of the victims who died along with Zia have now demanded that Pakistan ask the US to extradite Malik for questioning. 
 At a press conference in Lahore yesterday, Zia's son, Mr Ijaz ul-Haq accused the PPP of being involved in &bquo;narco-terrorism&equo; and he claimed that he had evidence that the Al Zulfiqar group had been involved in the assassination. 
 The Al Zulfiqar group is believed to be based in Damascus and is said to be headed by Mr Murtaza Bhutto, the Prime Minister's brother. 
 Malik once served a short term in jail in Karachi where he was filmed by Dutch television living in the height ofluxury. 
 He claimed in court that he met Hashemi in jail. 
 Communists next in line if former Prime Minister fails Papandreou chance to form government. 
 By Helena Smith in Athens 
 MR Andreas Papandreou, the former Greek prime minister, was yesterday handed an exploratory mandate from President Christos Sartzetakis to form a government within three days. 
 The Socialist leader took charge of the mandate after the conservative New Democracy Party, which fell three seats short of an overall majority in the general elections last weekend, failed to drum up the extra support it needed to create a minority administration. 
 Mr Papandreou, aged 70, is under increasing pressure to reach a compromise solution with his political opponents as Greek voters have no desire to go to the polls again for a third time in less than six months. 
 Greece embarked on a fortnight of party negotiations following the failure of the two main parties to secure a clear majority in national balloting for the second time this year. 
 The worsening state of the economy &mdash; Greece's overall debt is expected to exceed the nation's gross domestic product for 1989 &mdash; has made the need for government even more acute. 
 In a last ditch effort to keep the public sector buoyant, bank credits to the private sector were yesterday frozen by the Governor of the Bank of Crete who ordered private enterprises to pay back state loans as soon as possible. 
 The measure was taken after the Governor, Mr Dimitris Chalkias, received an SOS from the National Economy Ministry saying the public sector had run out of money to pay civil servants &mdash; around 22 percent of Greece's entire work force are employed by the state. 
 Mr Papandreou, whose standing has risen steadily since his scandal-hit Panhellenic Socialist Movement (PASOK) increased its vote by almost two percent over the inconclusive election last June, said he will do his utmost to coax the Communist-led left coalition into forming a government of &bquo;democratic and progressive forces&equo;. 
 However, the Communists, who emerged for a second time as power broker despite their loss of seven seats in parliament, has made it clear that they will not collaborate with the Pasok leader whom they indicted for alleged wrongdoing during the interim left-right coalition government of Mr Tzannis Tzannetakis. 
 If, as expected, Mr Papandreou also fails to form a government, the mandate will automatically pass on to the Communists. 
 The Left Coalition has so far ruled out linking up with the conservatives again &mdash; the improbable alliance of last June has been blamed for much of their drop in support &mdash; but has already hinted that it would be willing to support a national unity government as proposed by the New Democrat leader Mr Constantine Mitsotakis. 
 The final say in such an administration would rest with the President who is obliged, within the framework of a fourth mandate, to call upon all three party leaders to sink their differences and create a tri-party administration. 
 Although a national unity government would not necessarily be the answer to some of Greece's problems it is the only way out of the current political impasse if the weary Greek voter is to be saved from going to the polls again. 
 PAGE 
 &bquo;A monument to inhumanity&equo;. 
 By David Gow 
 THE young man filmed in the early hours of yesterday delightedly taking a pick-axe to the top of the Berlin Wall was a potent symbol of the destruction of 28 years of affront to freedom and of the potential dismantling of the system presided over until only a few weeks ago by its architect, Mr Erich Honecker. 
 Just over three years ago Dr Helmut Kohl, federal chancellor, declaimed in the remains of the Reichstag that the Wall, stretching beyond the former capital of a united Germany around 100 miles in length, was &bquo;a monument to inhumanity which tears families apart and prevents human contact.&equo; 
 Yesterday they played on it with delirious joy. 
 The Wall had been hastily assembled. 
 First largely as an enormous roll of barbed wire held together by posts and only later as the ugly concrete brick barrier denounced by a spate of visiting Western leaders in the early hours of Sunday, August 13, 1961. 
 Its official purpose was not to keep East Germans in but &bquo;revanchist&equo; West Germans out. 
 Its erection came a month after the then 12-year-old state &mdash; in the face of a grave economic crisis &mdash; had been forced to reorganise its ministries and faced an outflow of its citizens to the West on a scale (200,000 in 1960 alone) mirroring this year's flood of refugees. 
 Watched by a demonstration of 5000 jeering westerners at the Brandenburg Gate, and by Mr Willi Brandt, the then Mayor of West Berlin who referred to &bquo;the vacant eyes of uniformed compatriots doing their duty on the other side&equo;, the soldiers completed the first barrier in only a few hours. 
 Armed guards told thousands of people with jobs in the western sector they should not report for work &bquo;for the time being&equo;, while a few were said to have turned a blind eye as scores of their fellow citizens ran for freedom. 
 Individuals were seen jumping from the windows of the buildings straggling the French and Soviet sectors of the city before they could be bricked up. 
 Soon, Mr Peter Fechter, aged 18, the first of nearly 200 East Germans killed in the last 28 years while trying to escape, was shot as he climbed over the Wall near Checkpoint Charlie. 
 In the intervening years it is estimated that 111 died while trying to escape and a further 77 lost their lives on the Berlin Wall itself, with most of these deaths occurring in the 1960s. 
 The shoot-to-kill policy was briefly suspended before and after Mr Honecker's visit to the Federal Republic two years ago and again this year. 
 The estimated number of people who fled through Mr Honecker's &bquo;anti-fascist defence barrier&equo; from 1961 until this year's sudden flood vary between 40,000 and 200,000. 
 Television showman taken off the air in Brazil election race. 
 By Jan Rocha in Brasilia 
 THE prospect that Brazil's next President could be a television showman with dyed hair and an ear-to-ear grin sewn in shape by plastic surgery has been firmly quashed by the seven wise men of the Supreme Electoral Tribunal. 
 Mr Silvio Santos's late entry into the race, hoping to bank on his huge popularity among the poor, was solemnly considered by the toga-clad judges in a courtroom drama followed by most Brazilians. 
 The judges decided 7-0 against Mr Santos on the grounds that the party he had joined at the last minute in order to stand, the little-known Brazilian Municipalist Party which was founded by Pentecostal preachers, had failed to register in time. 
 They also found the entertainer ineligible because it is &bquo;public and notorious&equo; that he is also the owner and controller of a television channel and could abuse that power. 
 Mr Santos replied that he was only a shareholder &mdash; with 98 per cent of the shares. 
 The elimination of Mr Santos, who had the support of President Jose Sarney has reduced the November 14 poll to a contest between the Workers' Party candidate, Mr Luis Inacio da Silva, and Mr Leonel Brizola of the Democratic Labour Party for a place in the second round. 
 The centre-right candidate, Mr Fernando Collor now seems assured of the other place. 
 Mixed feelings on the frontier. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 BERLIN was a city of tears and champagne yesterday, of joy and of sadness. 
 The unbelievable began to happen just after 1am, as East and West Berliners passed through the Brandenburg Gate, symbol of the divided city. 
 Some stormed across in jubilation, others in a mood closer to melancholy. 
 At the Invalidenstrasse crossing, an older man wept as he explained: &bquo;I'm going across for the first time since August 12, 1961. 
 I'm going to see my daughter, I'll come back,&equo; he said trembling. 
 &bquo;I can't believe this,&equo; said an East Berlin woman as she walked towards the arch of the Brandenberg Gate, the East German flag flying above. 
 &bquo;We have waited for this moment for 28 years. 
 This city has suddenly come alive,&equo; said her husband, an off-duty border guard. 
 Hundreds of young men and women, singing, shouting and beating pots and pans, scaled the eight-foot Wall from the Western side, dancing, letting off champagne corks and chanting: &bquo;The Wall has come down.&equo; 
 It had, for four short ecstatic hours at the Brandenburg Gate, before calm East German border guards sealed it off by forming solid lines. 
 &bquo;Citizens of the GDR, please use the regular crossing points of our capital,&equo; sounded the police megaphone. 
 A young girl from West Berlin had her bicycle lifted across the Wall. 
 As she cycled across the Pariser Platz on the Eastern side, her shrieks of joy echoed in the huge Doric columns of the Brandenburg Gate. 
 East German border guards stood aside in small groups, talking to jubilant and excited citizens. 
 Drawing nervously on his cigarette, a uniformed guard said: &bquo;What shall I say? 
 Nobody could foresee this.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you for this wonderful night,&equo; an emotional West Berliner said to him. 
 At the Invalidenstrasse crossing point, East German &bquo;Trabbi&equo; cars queued for a quick sightseeing trip West. 
 East and West met in a festive mood and border guards gave up checking documents. 
 &bquo;I cried today. 
 For 11 years they stopped me from coming back here. 
 My parents and my sister are still here,&equo; said a man in his forties. 
 &bquo;My daughter called me, Mummy, come across quickly,&equo; said a woman in a Trabbi. 
 &bquo;We shall celebrate through the night. 
 I have to be back here at work at 11 in the morning.&equo; 
 Most of the East Germans surging across said they just wanted to have a look at West Berlin, have a beer in a bar, or see a friend. 
 But a young couple with a seven-year-old daughter said they were leaving for good. 
 &bquo;We are all packed.&equo; 
 As night fell on East Berlin yesterday, the packed row of people squatting on top of the Wall in the West was growing bigger by the hour. 
 From the East, Berliners looked across. 
 A policeman, already working overtime, said calmly: &bquo;I hope there'll be no trouble tonight so that I can go home early. 
 Unified state more longing than reality David Gow on Germany's history of division, tribal wars and migrations. 
 THROUGHOUT history, Germany has been an idea or, more accurately, a longing (Sehnsucht) rather than a reality as a unified state. 
 Through conquest and defeat its borders have changed more dramatically and more often than those of any country in the past 100 years. 
 In the current, probably mistaken assumption that reunification is only a matter of weeks or months away it is often forgotten that a united Germany as such existed for only around 75 years, between 1870 and 1945, from Bismarck's ascendancy to Hitler's descent into suicide and defeat. 
 Its early history, before the rise of the Carolingian Empire around 800 under Charlemagne, is one of division, of tribal wars and migrations. 
 Even the Holy Roman Empire was a relatively loose structure of nations and warring princedoms. 
 The Reich ended in the Thirty Years War of the early seventeenth century. 
 The 1648 Treaty of Westphalia saw its dismemberment and division into more than 300 individual and sovereign states and principalities. 
 In subsequent decades the Prussians and Austrians struggled for supremacy over the German soul. 
 The Napoleonic wars and the 1815 Congress of Vienna saw Prussia's collapse and resurgence. 
 More importantly, they led to the establishment of a German confederation of 39 states which retained the bulk of sovereign power. 
 Finally, after the defeat of the Austrians in 1866, Bismarck's Prussia imposed national unity and, in January 1871, the Second Reich was proclaimed under Kaiser Wilhelm I. 
 The defeat of Wilhelmine Germany in the first world war led to the setting up of the Weimar Republic in 1919, a constitutional settlement many believe was doomed. 
 The Treaty of Versailles, imposing the loss of 27,000 square miles of territory and seven million inhabitants, was to be seized upon by Hitler as a national humiliation to be avenged. 
 The Nazis seized control early in 1933. 
 The Anschluss of Austria, the occupation of the Bohemian part of Czechoslovakia and, following the Molotov-Von Ribbentrop pact of August 1939, the invasion of Poland eight days later led to the second world war, the death of scores of millions and, on May 7, 1945, unconditional German surrender to the Allies. 
 Germany now no longer existed and its remaining people were governed by the four victorious powers &mdash; the US, Soviet Union, Britain and France. 
 The Yalta agreement of February 1945 had already enshrined the right of the Soviets to retain their forward positions in Eastern Europe and the Potsdam conference later that year further divided up the former Third Reich. 
 After the lifting of the Berlin blockade imposed by the Soviets in 1948 despite the Four Power agreement, the two Germanys were formally established as separate republics. 
 The Big Four retained, and still possess, the power to decide the German Question, eventual reunification, and exercise joint supreme authority over Berlin. 
 During the past 40 years the two Germanys have gradually come closer together economically while bolstering each other's separateness at the same time. 
 The two formally recognised each other in May 1970 while Britain and France granted recognition to East Germany in February 1973 and the US in September 1974. 
 Two years ago, Mr Erich Honecker, who succeeded Walter Ulbricht as East German leader in 1971, thought he had crowned the post-war settlement and division of Germany with the first official visit to the Federal Republic. 
 Polisario makes biggest attack. 
 The West reacted ecstatically on Friday to East Germany's opening of the Berlin Wall while the East bloc was noticeably muted. 
 New Ethiopian PM. 
 A top advisory body to China's communist party met on Friday, one day after senior leader Deng Xiaoping resigned from the party military commission, defying speculation of a further shake-up in the leadership. 
 Foreign diplomats said the lack of a further reshuffle after a meeting of the central advisory commission meant Deng had been unable to persuade other party elders to retire to smooth the transfer of power to his heir. 
 Smith order spurned. 
 West German Chancellor Helmut Kohl broke off his visit to Poland on Friday and flew home to deal with a dramatic political situation after East Germany opened its borders to the West. 
 Poland's official news agency PAP said Kohl flew home in the early afternoon. 
 Officials earlier said he had cancelled a lunch with Polish President Wojciech Jaruzelski. 
 cancelled a lunch with Polish President Wojciech Jaruzelski. 
 Coalition efforts fail. 
 Todd Bridges, a star of the television series &bquo;Diff'rent Strokes&equo;, has been released from jail after a court commissioner declared a mistrial on a charge that he attacked a man with a gun in a cocaine dealing house. 
 Test for Noll Scott 
 Euphoria poses problems for US. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 AFTER the euphoria of the day when the Wall came tumbling down, comes the hangover as the Bush Administration tries to work out what to do next in eastern Europe. 
 It is not a pretty sight. 
 This is not a government which likes to ask fundamental questions, nor does it like thinking on its feet and making strategic policy decisions almost overnight. 
 So far, policy is being made on the fly. 
 The first reaction is to reassure Mr Gorbachev that there was no bold US ambition to take strategic advantage of the collapse of Moscow's empire. 
 Without really thinking what the words mean in policy terms, the US has been parroting the &bquo;need for stability&equo;. 
 The second US reaction was to reassure the West Germans that Washington was happy to leave the details about what we might now call the eastern provinces in Bonn's hands. 
 While this spared the Bush Administration from the perils of thinking for itself, or heaven forbid, taking a policy decision for which it might get criticised, it naively ignored the danger that Bonn might have a large axe of its own to grind. 
 Having succeeded to Britain's traditional role as the maritime power, the US this century has inherited Britain's commitment to the balance of power in Europe. 
 Twice this century the US has joined our European tribal wars to ensure that our continent should not be dominated by any single power. 
 Having helped break the ambition of Nazi Germany, the US maintained a vast standing army on European soil for 40 years to thwart the ambition of Russia. 
 At this juncture, two crucially fundamental questions now emerge. 
 Are the ambitions of Russia truly finished, or simply in abeyance? 
 And if the Russian bear is back in his cave for good, is the renewal of German ambition, given the country's economic dominance of the EC, to be feared? 
 The problem is that the second question cannot be answered until Washington comes up with a consensus on the first. 
 But this is not an Administration which thinks as one, as we learned during the ongoing arguments about the Soviet Union. 
 The Pentagon and the National Security Council are openly sceptical of Mr Gorbachev's chances, and of his ambitions, while the Secretary of State, Mr Jim Baker, and probably Mr Bush, believe that there are trustworthy deals to be done. 
 Next month's summit-at-sea may see a resolution of the Bush Administration's schizophrenia over Moscow. 
 Only then can the US begin to think seriously about what kind of future security system and political structure it would like to see in Europe. 
 Kremlin rules republics have acted unconstitutionally Baltic states told to drop election laws. 
 By Peter Conradi in Moscow 
 THE Kremlin ordered four restive Soviet republics last night to drop a series of controversial new laws which it said contravened the constitution, Tass reported. 
 The announcement appeared a clear signal that Moscow was not prepared to extend to its 15 republics the free hand on domestic issues enjoyed by its Eastern European allies. 
 In a move likely to anger the independent-minded leaders of the three Baltic republics, the Kremlin told Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania that several laws &bquo;strengthening their economic and political independence&equo; would have to go. 
 The same order was given to Azerbaijan, whose leaders have also moved, under pressure from local nationalists, to assert the republic's independence from Moscow. 
 The laws were believed to include Lithuania's announcement last week of separate Lithuanian citizenship as well as new residence requirements for those standing for elected office in Estonia and Latvia. 
 The announcment appeared timed for sessions of the Estonian and the Latvian parliaments which began in their respective capitals, Tallinn and Riga, yesterday. 
 However, with parts of the new Soviet constitution not yet in place, it was not immediately clear how &mdash; if at all &mdash; the Soviet leadership could enforce such a ruling if the republics refused to toe the line. 
 Tass said the Praesidium of the Supreme Soviet noted at its meeting yesterday a &bquo;considerable activisation of legislative activity&equo; by republican parliaments in recent times. 
 The Praesidium, headed by President Gorbachev, said many of these laws were aimed at strengthening the &bquo;economic and political independence and ensuring the rights and freedoms of citizens&equo;. 
 &bquo;But, at the same time, some legislative acts of Azerbaijan, Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia contain norms which do not correspond to the constitution of the Soviet Union and contravene its international agreements,&equo; Tass said. 
 &bquo;On the basis of the&hellip; 
 Soviet constitution, it is proposed to the Praesidiums of the Supreme Soviets of these republics&hellip; to bring their republican laws into line with the Soviet constitution.&equo; 
 A spokesman for the radical parliamentary organisation, the Inter-Regional Group (MRG), said that Mr Gorbachev had also wanted the Praesidium to approve separate proposals curbing the republics' economic rights. 
 However, the spokesman, Mr Vladimir Mestensev, said Mr Gorbachev had been outvoted by several Praesidium members led by the former Moscow Party Chief, Mr Boris Yeltsin. 
 Yesterday, the Latvian parliament confirmed it would stick to a plan to introduce minimum five and 10-year residence requirements for candidates wishing to stand in local and republican elections. 
 The law, similar to one already introduced in Estonia, has angered many thousands of Russians who have moved into the republic in recent years. 
 The Estonian parliament agreed to postpone discussion of provisions of its election law amid disagreement over demands by Russians for a second chamber to represent local minorities. 
 -Reuter. 
 By Peter Conradi in Moscow 
 THE Kremlin ordered four restive Soviet republics last night to drop a series of controversial new laws which it said contravened the constitution, Tass reported. 
 The announcement appeared a clear signal that Moscow was not prepared to extend to its 15 republics the free hand on domestic issues enjoyed by its Eastern European allies. 
 In a move likely to anger the independent-minded leaders of the three Baltic republics, the Kremlin told Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania that several laws &bquo;strengthening their economic and political independence&equo; would have to go. 
 The same order was given to Azerbaijan, whose leaders have also moved, under pressure from local nationalists, to assert the republic's independence from Moscow. 
 The laws were believed to include Lithuania's announcement last week of separate Lithuanian citizenship as well as new residence requirements for those standing for elected office in Estonia and Latvia. 
 The announcment appeared timed for sessions of the Estonian and the Latvian parliaments which began in their respective capitals, Tallinn and Riga, yesterday. 
 But, with parts of the new Soviet constitution not yet in place, it was not immediately clear how, if at all, the Soviet leadership could enforce such a ruling if the republics refused to toe the line. 
 Tass said the Praesidium of the Supreme Soviet noted at its meeting yesterday a &bquo;considerable activisation of legislative activity&equo; by republican parliaments in recent times. 
 The Praesidium, headed by President Gorbachev, said many of these laws were aimed at strengthening the &bquo;economic and political independence and ensuring the rights and freedoms of citizens&equo;. 
 &bquo;But, at the same time, some legislative acts of Azerbaijan, Latvia, Lithuania and Estonia contain norms which do not correspond to the constitution of the Soviet Union and contravene its international agreements,&equo; Tass said. 
 A spokesman for the radical parliamentary organisation, the Inter-Regional Group (MRG), said that Mr Gorbachev had also wanted the Praesidium to approve separate proposals curbing the republics' economic rights. 
 However, the spokesman, Mr Vladimir Mestensev, said Mr Gorbachev had been outvoted by several Praesidium members led by the former Moscow Party Chief, Mr Boris Yeltsin. 
 Yesterday, the Latvian parliament confirmed it would stick to a plan to introduce minimum five and 10-year residence requirements for candidates wishing to stand in local and republican elections. 
 The Estonian parliament agreed to postpone discussion of provisions of its election law amid disagreement over demands by Russians for a second chamber to represent local minorities. 
 -Reuter. 
 Nationalists in Moldavia fought police and troops late yesterday and unofficial reports said dozens of people were injured, some seriously. 
 Witnesses said clashes erupted after several thousand ringed the Interior Ministry headquarters in Kishinyov, protesting against the detention of about 20 fellow nationalists who disrupted a 1917 anniversary parade on Tuesday. 
 Search for Britain's political vision William Wallace calls for an imaginative response from Westminster to the events which are changing Europe's landscape. 
 FUKUYAMA was wrong. 
 This is not the end of history: it is the return to history, after the long freeze imposed on European political development by the Cold War. 
 Old issues are re-emerging from our history books on to the political agenda: the status of Germany, the problems of the Balkans, the ambiguous relations of peripheral countries like Britain and Russia to the politics of Central Europe. 
 New issues crowd in to join them: environmental management, repairing the damage which socialist concentration on heavy industry has inflicted on Eastern Europe, technological competition in a world where the struggle for economic supremacy is replacing the struggle for military security, migration and refugee flows on an vast scale. 
 As Western governments struggle from decision to decision, making up instant policies as they react, the need is for vision and imagination: a willingness to think the previously unthinkable, to sort out in their minds what sort of Europe they would like to have created in 10 years' time. 
 Today's reactions to events in Hungary and the GDR, tomorrow's response to Austria's already-submitted application for EC membership or to Turkey's determined membership claims, can all too easily foreclose long-term options. 
 We need a different set of priorities for British foreign policy. 
 The pre-occupations which have dominated debates at Westminster for so long no longer make sense. 
 The magnetic attraction of the European Community for all of its neighbours &mdash; to the north and south as well as to the east &mdash; itself calls for some agonising reappraisal of the conventional wisdom of British foreign policy. 
 Hungarians, Poles, Yugoslavs, and in time Czechs, are not drawn to the EC in the hope that it may become wider and looser. 
 Nor could a looser grouping of sovereign states cope with the awkward trade-offs which the Western response to Eastern Europe will involve. 
 Financial support for East European economies will have to be allocated among Western countries: budgetary politics on a scale which will dwarf the arguments over existing Community expenditure. 
 Add to that arguments over which defence budget benefits most from conventional troop reductions, if as seems likely these are agreed in Vienna in the course of 1990, and we will find ourselves having to bargain over most of the central issues of foreign policy and public expenditure with our West European partners within the same political and institutional framework. 
 The European Community grew up in the shadow of the Atlantic alliance. 
 As the Western and Eastern alliances fade &mdash; as now looks increasingly likely over the next few years -the European Community will become the dominant focus for European foreign policy and security. 
 The politics of the European Community will revolve around those countries with the strongest economies, currencies, industrial and technological capacities: Germany above all, followed by France, Italy, Spain, and perhaps Britain. 
 The idea that Britain can insist on a European construction of its own design was fanciful even before Eastern Europe entered the equation. 
 Now that we are playing on an increasingly crowded stage, with 24 Western countries concerting economic assistance to Eastern Europe, and 35 countries negotiating over Europe's future security, we have to recognise that we are only one voice among many. 
 The logic of a tighter European Community, with a more explicit security dimension, a larger budget, and a huge and complicated foreign policy agenda, clashes with the insistent pressures from others to join. 
 Acceptance of Austria would provide a precedent which Sweden might well wish to follow. 
 More imaginatively, it might also provide a precedent for associating the DDR with its German-speaking neighbours within an EC without recreating a sovereign unified Germany. 
 Against that must be weighed the costs of absorbing new members into a Community already weighed down by the process of bargaining over policy among 12 member states. 
 The EC President, Mr Jacques Delors's preferred model, it appears, is of a Europe of concentric circles. 
 Its core would be those states which are committed to making European co-operation work across the board from security to social policy: Germany and its immediate neighbours. 
 Those within the existing Community who hesitate over future commitments would form the next circle. 
 The EFTA countries, the richest countries in Europe as a group, would be granted a privileged relationship in return for a full share in the burden of supporting the economic development of Eastern and Southern Europe. 
 The former socialist states of East Central Europe, and the &bquo;Mediterranean orphans&equo; &mdash; to use Mr Delors' sad phrase &mdash; would form the outer tier, politically associated but economically dependent. 
 Where will we draw the outer boundaries of this Europe? 
 Each imploring applicant wants to draw the line behind them: the Hungarians to exclude the Orthodox countries from a recreated Western Christendom, the Serbs to exclude Muslim Albania, the Turks to include all secular and modernising countries within the region. 
 The further east the boundaries are drawn, the more Britain will find itself on the Western periphery of a Germany-centred Europe. 
 But what do British politicians want to see? 
 It's sadly typical of the unreality of the British debate on foreign policy that Labour frontbenchers are declaring their continued commitment to high defence spending as the Vienna negotiations move towards major cuts, while Conservative ministers still use the language of an Atlantic world. 
 Where is Labour's vision of Europe in the year 2000, weaving together political, security, economic and industrial issues? 
 William Wallace is deputy director of the Royal Institute of International Affairs. 
 Parties join Thatcher in welcoming change. 
 By Michael White, Chief Political Correspondent 
 IN a rare display of harmony the British political Establishment last night united behind Mrs Thatcher in combining a euphoric welcome for the fall of the Berlin Wall with a note of caution about its profound implications for both Germany and the rest of the Continent. 
 But there was concern at British isolation from events. 
 Among politicians who have spent their lives working within the seemingly fixed assumptions of the Cold War came a sobering recognition of the speed and scale of events, which even prompted Mrs Thatcher to stress that talk of a reunited Germany was &bquo;going much too fast. 
 You have to take these things step by step.&equo; 
 The Defence Secretary, Mr Tom King, felt obliged to say that Nato must maintain its vigilance. 
 But the larger questions of how to anchor Germany to the West or watch it turn towards Central Europe, went unanswered. 
 With renewed talk of winding down both military alliances some ministers believe Nato must avoid stating the obvious: that the Warsaw Pact could cease to exist as a viable alliance. 
 While the Prime Minister immediately offered the use of British military camps in West Germany to help cope with the current surge of refugees, her Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, promised East Germany the kind of practical help in creating a more market-orientated economy which Britain has given Poland &mdash; some &pound;25 million of &bquo;Know How&equo; funds over 25 years and is pledged to give to ex-Communist Hungary. 
 Mrs Thatcher granted a brief photo-opportunity to the cameras in the rain outside Number 10 before lunch to proclaim &bquo;a great day for freedom, a great day for liberty&equo; and noted &bquo;the joy on people's faces&equo; as proof of the futility of attempts to stiffle freedom since 1945. 
 But in Whitehall officials were also frustrated at the marginalisation of the British role and lack of clear political direction &mdash; a far cry from the post-war reconstruction of West German institutions. 
 Speaking in Brussels, where the Community dimension of the drama is becoming a major debate, the Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, said: &bquo;Freedom is magnetic and it is natural that the people of Eastern Europe should lunge for it at their first chance.&equo; 
 But simultaneously he warned against &bquo;mass movements of people which will create pressures and can bring instability&equo;. 
 Labour wants the &bquo;closest possible consultations&equo; with Eastern bloc governments on their plans, a point the Liberal Democrats echoed with a motion critical of Mrs Thatcher's hostility to what Mr Paddy Ashdown called &bquo;closer integration with Europe&equo; that would expand Britain's ability to influence events. 
 Ministers actually grappling with policy are wary of Sir Leon Brittan's suggestion this week that East Germany be integrated into the EC, not as a new member, but as an extension of an existing member, West Germany, which already provides the Krenz regime with special access to the West. 
 &bquo;We are a bit of a way from that. 
 But I certainly believe, first of all, we have to give what help we can,&equo; said Mr Hurd. 
 Mrs Thatcher suggested that &bquo;had America stayed in Europe after the first world war and we had a Nato then, I do not believe we would have had a second world war. 
 Let us learn that lesson.&equo; 
 Mr Ashdown envisaged a &bquo;Europe on the march to reform, east and west.&equo; 
 Ortega rival meets Bush and Quayle. 
 By Simon Tisdall in Washington 
 THE leader of the Nicaraguan opposition coalition, Mrs Violeta Chamorro, will hold a series of meetings with West European leaders and financial backers next week to rally international support for her campaign to topple the Sandinista President, Mr Daniel Ortega, in elections planned for February 25. 
 Mrs Chamorro, who heads the recently formed 14-party National Opposition Union (UNO), held talks with the US Vice-President, Mr Dan Quayle, in Washington yesterday after meeting President Bush and other Administration officials, who have already pledged &dollar;9 million to the election process. 
 The Administration has publicly backed Mrs Chamorro's candidacy, prompting Sandinista protests about continuing US &bquo;meddling&equo;. 
 During her European tour, which includes a meeting with Mrs Thatcher on Monday and visits to Paris, Madrid, and Bonn, Mrs Chamorro will outline UNO's poll strategy and seek &dollar;6 million in campaign donations, according to her spokesman, Mr Antonio Lacayo. 
 Mr Lacayo said UNO would receive &dollar;2 million of the US aid. 
 He stressed the difficulties facing the coalition which according to one opinion poll, has the support of 42 per cent of Nicaraguans. 
 The coalition lacked campaign offices and vehicles, Mr Lacayo said, and faced intimidation, and restricted media access, from the Nicaraguan Government. 
 &bquo;We are absolutely confident we will win if the elections are fair,&equo; Mr Lacayo said. 
 &bquo;But we are not 100 per cent sure they will be clean and fair.&equo; 
 President Ortega had made his commitment to the February poll before UNO existed, Mr Lacayo said. 
 &bquo;The opposition was divided and he thought his would be the strongest party. 
 The reaction to Mrs Chamorro has been very strong and it's beginning to worry Ortega.&equo; 
 During her Washington visit, Mrs Chamorro attended the launch of a Committee for Free and Fair Elections in Nicaragua, sponsored by several members of Congress. 
 But Mr Lacayo rejected suggestions that American financial support would encourage Sandinista claims that the US &bquo;bought the election&equo;. 
 &bquo;This country is in ruins,&equo; Mr Lacayo said, claiming that most Nicaraguans recognised the need for external financial assistance. 
 Mrs Chamorro declined to give interviews while in Washington but in an article published this week, she wrote: &bquo;Ten years of living dangerously has brought civil war, an exodus of a fifth of our countrymen, an annual inflation of 30,000 per cent, 40 per cent unemployment and for the first time in our history, mass hunger. 
 Our industry and agriculture are paralysed. 
 We have gone from being the bread basket of Central America to being its basket case; an international beggar with the largest per capita foreign debt in Latin America. 
 &bquo;Even a government-commissioned survey has found consumption to have fallen by 70 per cent since the revolution. 
 Of course the Sandinista media shout that all this is due to Mr Reagan and now to Mr Bush. 
 But we Nicaraguans know full well that the shortages and the repression came before the war and the (US trade) embargo.&equo; 
 Mrs Chamorro appealed for close international scrutiny and support for the electoral process, and for observers to be sent to Nicaragua from unions and professional groups, as well as the UN and the OAS. 
 Concern about a possible cancellation of the parliamentary and presidential polls grew after Mr Ortega ended the ceasefire with the contra rebels on November 1. 
 In New York yesterday, talks between the two sides continued. 
 The contras are seeking a new ceasefire, a general amnesty and guarantees of safe conduct if they return to Nicaragua. 
 The Sandinistas point out that many thousands of rebels are already back inside the country, and that their alleged attacks necessitated the ending of the ceasefire. 
 The UNO coalition has distanced itself from the contras, as has the US Administration by ending military aid. 
 &bquo;We never left the country, we never embraced the armed struggle. 
 We are only interested in a democratic solution to the crisis,&equo; Mr Lacayo said. 
 Military plans awry as blocs fall apart. 
 By David Fairhall 
 EVERYTHING that happens within Nato's military machine, from routine field manoeuvres to nuclear strategy is predicated on the existence of an inner German border &mdash; the Iron Curtain dividing East from West. 
 The decision to open that border, and the prospect of German reunification, will virtually paralyse the military side of the alliance. 
 Even the Nato arms controllers meeting in Vienna, whose job it is to negotiate East-West reductions in conventional armed forces, can only pursue their objectives on the basis of confrontation between their alliance and the Warsaw Pact. 
 Although the proposed treaty will be signed individually by the 23 states in the two blocs, the reductions will be expressed as collective ceilings, to be enforced by the two integrated military commands. 
 Until now, this paradox was merely an awkward problem for the lawyers. 
 How do you arrange for sovereign democratic nations to constrain their defence programmes? 
 But now there is the further possibility that the two watertight military compartments will be breached. 
 Several members of the Warsaw Pact &mdash; particularly Hungary &mdash; are already trying to loosen military ties with the Soviet Union. 
 They will not want to be inhibited by arms control treaty commitments. 
 The pace of change that arms control has to match in Eastern Europe cannot be predicted, but it shows every sign of moving far faster than Nato can respond. 
 The crucial factor is likely to be how much Moscow continues to value the Warsaw Pact as a military buffer. 
 On this, there may be diffences betwen Mr Gorbachev's political reformers and the old guard of the Soviet general staff. 
 Mrs Thatcher is anxious to apply the brakes. 
 Before reunification was discussed, she said in a BBC radio interview, genuine democracy must be established in East Germany. 
 However, Nato's Secretary-General, Mr Manfred Woerner said that the promise of &bquo;an end to a divided Europe, and with it an end to the division of Germany, has never been brighter&equo;. 
 He felt it was &bquo;an inevitable process&equo;. 
 Unless the Soviet military intervenes, self-determination must surely lead to reunification. 
 To measure the paralysing effect of such a prospect on military planners, one has only to visualise the British and American tank divisions manoeuvring along the inner German border, while East Germans whose invasion they are supposedly repelling stream past westwards in their overloaded Ladas and Brabants. 
 Last week, the Supreme Allied Commanders staff officers were worrying about how to allocate Nato force cuts of 10 or 15 per cent; today the whole future of the 330,000 US troops in West Germany seems in question. 
 As for Mrs Thatcher's loudly voiced determination to force through a replacement of the Lance nuclear missile, nobody is listening. 
 It has been clear for some time that the demands of the arms control process would increasingly dominate military planning. 
 As Germany slides towards reunification, arms control will become even more central to military preoccupations, as the only way of matching armed forces to Europe's rapidly changing political structure. 
 40 years on: One nation or two?. 
 Young Germans may have less in common than is thought, writes Michael Simmons 
 SUDDENLY more Germans than ever are talking about the feasibility of reunification. 
 They are very audible. 
 Others, less audible, have sentiments that are not too fashionable in the current euphoria and can be summarised in one question: Just how compatible are we? 
 More than half the population of West Germany (60 million) and of East Germany (16 million) were born since the division was formalised in 1949. 
 A whole generation has grown up since the Wall was built in 1961. 
 Some may have visited the other side, but most have stayed at home living with political, economic and cultural systems that have very little in common except the original reason that they came into being &mdash; the biggest war the world had yet seen. 
 Both Germanys have been run in the name of the people &mdash; the GDR as a &bquo;socialist democracy&equo;, governed by the dictatorship of the proletariat, and the Federal Republic on the stated principle that &bquo;all authority emanates from the people&equo;. 
 In the GDR, the ruling Socialist Unity Party's politburo makes policies, and decisions of higher bodies are binding on lower ones. 
 In the Federal Republic, the parties participate in forming the will of the people. 
 The press in the GDR, not counting local periodicals and special interest magazines, is largely controlled by the party, though this matters little because almost all East Germans live on a diet of information provided by West German television and radio. 
 Defence is provided in West Germany by armed forces whose number totals close to half a million men and women. 
 The East German total, proportionately much larger, is more than 160,000. 
 West German soldiers swear &bquo;to defend the rights and freedom of the German people&equo; while their East German counterparts swear to defend their &bquo;fatherland&equo; against all enemies&equo;. 
 Both countries have managed to become the most visibly successful economies in what used to be called their respective &bquo;blocs&equo;. 
 But their principles of ownership and management could not be more different: private enterprise prevails in the West, while it represents only a tiny proportion in the East. 
 Management in the West tends to be on a collective basis; in the East by individuals appointed by the party or the central government. 
 Living is easier, but more expensive, for the West German family than for its Eastern counterpart. 
 Foreign exchange is hard to come by for imports into the GDR, and shortages and waiting periods, not so frequent in the West, are normal. 
 Wages in West Germany, for hard currency marks, are much higher than in East Germany (for soft marks). 
 Hours of work required to pay for everyday items, based on average wages, vary enormously: a pair of men's leather shoes means nearly six hours work in West Germany, and 28 hours in the East; a comparable colour television set, about 100 hours against 850. 
 Most basic foods (sugar, butter, milk, eggs) are cheaper, in man-hours, in West Germany, while rents, public transport and entertainment tends to be much more expensive. 
 More children (90 per cent) have pre-school education in the GDR than in the Federal Republic (about 80 per cent), but overall about the same proportion go to school. 
 In one field, the East Germans tend to sweep the West Germans out of sight. 
 That field is sport, where the East Germans think of themselves as a &bquo;world power&equo;, second only to the Soviet Union and the US. 
 UK faces choice between old fears and &bquo;reunification&equo;. 
 By Hella Pick Diplomatic Editor 
 BRITAIN, in the post-Iron Curtain era, will be confronted with tough and politically controversial options. 
 Viscerally, political leaders in all parties recognise that Germany is moving towards reunification, however uncomfortable that prospect may be for one of Germany's wartime adversaries. 
 The only realistic question that poses itself is whether Britain can help to determine the how and the when of reunification. 
 Mrs Thatcher could seize the high ground, providing strong leadership for a radical reassessment of Nato's role in the emerging new Europe. 
 But the Prime Minister may be more concerned to ward off the various demons she perceives on the horizon. 
 All her instincts are to keep up Britain's and Nato's defences. 
 The British Army on the Rhine, she will argue, should be cut back only in the context of an East-West agreement on Conventional Force Cuts in Europe. 
 She would be opposed to a wholesale withdrawal from West Germany. 
 Britain will have to decide with its wartime allies whether Berlin's status as an enclave under notional military government needs to be reviewed. 
 Some experts believe that Germany would be required to sign a treaty with Britain, France and the Soviet Union before they withdraw from Berlin. 
 King Hussein's liberal pledge. 
 King Hussein of Jordan yesterday promised a referendum on a plan to liberalise political life following a parliamentary election in which Islamic groups made striking gains. 
 The King described the election, the first for 22 years, as the start of a new phase in Jordan's life. 
 -Reuter. 
 Chinese confessions. 
 More than 36,000 Chinese people have turned themselves in for economic crimes during a 10-week grace period that ended last week. 
 -AP. 
 Norway's own goal. 
 Norway hit one of its own submarines with a dummy torpedo during a military exercise, the defence command said yesterday. 
 The torpedoes, which carry no explosives, are supposed to stop before hitting the target but this one kept straight on. 
 -Reuter. 
 Saudi beheadings. 
 Two Pakistani drug traffickers were beheaded yesterday in the eastern city of Dammam, Saudi Arabia, for smuggling heroin into the kingdom, the Interior Ministry announced. 
 -AP. 
 Iranian rampage. 
 About 20 Iranians burst into the Dutch embassy in Tehran and smashed furniture and equipment, causing considerable damage, the Dutch Foreign Ministry said yesterday. 
 -AP. 
 Businessman freed. 
 Derek Smith, the British businessman imprisoned last month after he tried to sell five and half pounds of uranium to Greece's Nuclear Research Centre, was yesterday set free on bail, writes Helena Smith from Athens. 
 The uranium ore he was carrying had not proved to be radioactive, his lawyer said. 
 Whaling expedition. 
 The mother ship of Japan's four-vessel whaling fleet left yesterday for the Antarctic, where officials say it will catch 300 whales in the third year of a controversial research programme. 
 -Reuter. 
 SA white hanged. 
 Pieter Coetzee, aged 62, on Thursday became the first white to be hanged in the South African tribal homeland of Bophuthatswana, for a double murder in 1987. -Reuter. 
 Europeans seek path out of divisive ideological camps. 
 By Hella Pick Diplomatic Editor 
 EVER since Mikhail Gorbachev launched his concept of a Common European Home, a good two years ago, there has been discussion about the shape and content of such a dwelling. 
 President Bush preferred to talk about a Commonwealth of European Nations. 
 Everywhere it has been high fashion to emphasise the importance of &bquo;managing change&equo;. 
 But until very recently, even though the politicians have actively participated, the debate has been largely academic. 
 Western leaders were content to rest on their laurels, convinced that Nato's &bquo;steadfastness&equo; had been crucial in bringing the Communist bloc in from the cold, that Western prosperity had been enough to convince the East of the hollowness of Marxism. 
 This will no longer do. 
 With the developments in East Germany and the prospect of German re-unification, the future organisation of Europe has become a live issue. 
 Nobody wants a return to the instability of the inter-war period. 
 For much of the post-war era, Nato and the Warsaw Pact provided the military and political framework for East-West relations. 
 The 1975 Helsinki Declaration gave neutral and nonaligned countries a more active role, but did not radically alter Europe's division into two ideological camps. 
 As recently as last July, when President Gorbachev addressed the Council of Europe, the Soviet leader assumed that socialism could be preserved throughout Eastern Europe. 
 He warned the West then that &bquo;overcoming the division of Europe must not be confused with overcoming socialism&equo;. 
 And in the German-Soviet Bonn declaration, signed this summer, Mr Gorbachev agreed that the Nato and the Warsaw Pact would be maintained and that the transatlantic members of the Western Alliance &mdash; the US and Canada &mdash; would play a vital role in the Common European Home. 
 Now, with the division of Germany almost at an end, there are uncomfortable questions about the future of the two alliances, and how, if at all, they can be fitted into a Europe that includes a re-unified Germany. 
 An interim &bquo;solution&equo;, already widely canvassed, would be the establishment of a German confederation, with East and West Germany sharing key parliamentary and political institutions. 
 But while the present Federal Republic would remain firmly anchored in Nato, East Germany would remain within the Warsaw Pact. 
 Although Nato and Warsaw Pact forces would be cut back under the terms of the Conventional Force Agreement now under negotiation in Vienna, each alliance would retain a military presence in its part of the German confederation. 
 This &bquo;one nation/two alliances&equo; model, it is argued, would buy time for the world to become adjusted to a re-unified Germany, and to decide whether Nato and the Warsaw Pact still served any useful purposes. 
 It would show whether the US and the Soviet Union really had a role to play in Europe and it would be up to Germans themselves to work out their international posture. 
 Most pundits, so far at least, rule out the prospect of a neutral unified Germany, if only because the Federal Republic is too deeply rooted in the West to distance itself from its allies. 
 A united Germany would be more likely to remain incorporated in the West's institutions. 
 Although Germany is central to any new European political framework, it must also sustain the other emerging democracies of Eastern Europe. 
 The Council of Europe will undoubtedly have a role in assimilating these countries into the new Europe. 
 Institutionalised co-operation between the countries of Central Europe &mdash; &bquo;Mittel-Europa&equo; &mdash; is a live prospect. 
 Italy has initiated another grouping with Hungary, Austria and Yugoslavia. 
 The European Free Trade Area, Efta, may be a pole of attraction. 
 But inevitably, the biggest magnet will be the European Community. 
 Will it remain a rich man's club, keeping Eastern Europe on the outer perimeter, linked by mere trade agreements, or, one step up, association agreements. 
 Or will it broaden its base and agree to enlargement? 
 No amount of crystal-gazing can show the outcome of this debate. 
 But already it is certain that the challenges ahead are at least as daunting as anything the Cold War produced. 
 Sikh gunmen open fire on students. 
 By Ajoy Bose in New Delhi 
 SUSPECTED Sikh terrorists yesterday shot dead 19 students and seriously wounded several others in Patiala, Punjab, raising fears of a fresh extremist offensive in the north Indian state before this month's parliamentary polls. 
 The students, all Hindus from colleges of the neighbouring states of Uttar Pradesh and Haryana, had come to Patiala for a students' festival and were sleeping in a dormitory when they were attacked yesterday. 
 The assailants, armed with automatic rifles, burst into the dormitory and opened fire on the students. 
 &bquo;Just a few hours ago we were dancing and enjoying ourselves but suddenly it had become a dance of death,&equo; said a survivor. 
 The killings are seen as an attempt by Sikh extremists to provoke Hindu-Sikh riots which could disrupt parliamentary polls in the state scheduled within a fortnight. 
 Groups demanding an autonomous Sikh state have already called for a boycott of the elections. 
 The Hindu rightwing Bharatiya Janata party yesterday condemned the massacre and called for a strike in Patiala today in protest against what a party spokesman in New Delhi described as &bquo;criminal neglect by the administration to protect innocent people&equo;. 
 The killings may deal a severe blow to the electoral prospects of the Congress Party of the Prime Minister, Mr Rajiv Gandhi, which is contesting all 10 parliamentary seats in Punjab. 
 They cast a shadow over his meeting yesterday in the state capital, Chandigarh. 
 The Punjab governor, Mr S.S.Ray, said yesterday: &bquo;Every time the Prime Minister comes to the state, such killings are organised but we will not succumb to such terror tactics.&equo; 
 An alert has been sounded in Punjab and neighbouring north Indian states to counter any terrorist offensive. 
 The Congress Party fears that a fresh outbreak of violence against Hindus may turn the community against it. 
 Sikhs in the state are already angry with the government for the storming of the Golden Temple and anti-Sikh riots after Mrs Indira Gandhi's assassination and are unlikely to vote for the Congress. 
 Meanwhile, the influential head priest of the Jama Masjid in New Delhi, Imam Abdullah Bukhari, yesterday charged Mr Gandhi with being in league with Hindu militants who laid the foundation stone of a temple next to a mosque in the north Indian state of Uttar Pradesh on Thursday. 
 Democracy welcomed to wilds of Damaraland. 
 By David Beresford in Sesfontein, Namibia 
 DEMOCRACY finally arrived in this remote corner of Namibia yesterday, to be greeted with determined enthusiasm. 
 Northern Damaraland is Africa as lovers of this continent picture it. 
 Abutting the Skeleton Coast, that legendary graveyard of mariners and ships, it is here that the last of the world's black rhino range free, while galloping hyenas and lunging kudu buck comprise the main traffic hazards. 
 It is also the Africa of poverty, deprivation, thirst and the memories of recent war. 
 In the roadside village of Waremquelle, on the way north to Sesfontein, the men wile away the days under the stinkwood trees, pools of shade and conversation amid the heat blazing off the surrounding sands. 
 &bquo;Life here is very hard,&equo; said Joshua Kangombe, the local headman who was sporting mirror sunglasses, a trilby hat and a leather tie. 
 &bquo;Most cattle are dead. 
 We have had no good rain since&hellip;&equo; 
 He paused, reflectively. 
 &bquo;Since 1983.&equo; 
 Under a nearby tree, a group of children were having their school lunch, feverishly jostling each other as they scraped the bottom of a three-legged pot with scraps of bread. 
 A dog snatched fallen morsels from the burning embers of the fire. 
 &bquo;I just don't want an apartheid government in Namibia,&equo; said Naftali Herunga, who confided that he had been a soldier, serving in 102 Battalion &mdash; an ethnic Herero unit &mdash; under the South Africans. 
 &bquo;I want a government where there is no difference between a black man and a white man.&equo; 
 Above us in the branches, dangled the flag of the National Patriotic Front, an alliance led by an ex-Maoist, Moses Katjiuongua, and a former white MP, Eben van Zyl. 
 &bquo;If Swapo becomes the government it is the same as death,&equo; said Mr Kangombe. 
 &bquo;They are almost Communists and I don't want a Communist ruling over me.&equo; 
 A few miles down the road, at the village of Sesfontein, a political rally was under way. 
 About 150 Damaras and Hereros watched a dozen young village girls dancing in skirts and T-shirts bearing the colours of Namibia's United Democratic Front, a broad alliance of eight political parties. 
 Chief Jeremiah Gaobaeb, resplendent in a blue kaftan with gold thread, took the megaphone to launch a fierce attack on Swapo. 
 &bquo;I thought they were the only party that could rule Namibia. 
 The Damaras were shocked awake. 
 Swapo thought they could still depend on the Damara vote. 
 But they took people in Angola and Zambia and they murdered and they raped them. 
 The Damara Council took their own path and said: &bquo;Goodbye Swapo, we want no part of you&equo;.&equo; 
 Then it was time for practical advice. 
 &bquo;Behave yourselves,&equo; he admonished. 
 &bquo;Put on the clothes you put on to go to church on Sunday. 
 You must look your best.&equo; 
 The mobile UN election team arrived in the evening, with their cardboard polling booths, to service the 435 registered voters of Sesfontein. 
 The number, of course, was appropriate. 
 They may not have much impact on the result of Namibia's election. 
 But the people will be well dressed, in tribute to the arrival of democracy in the wilds of northern Damaraland. 
 French fears not really assuaged. 
 By Paul Webster in Paris 
 ALTHOUGH only the Communist Party came out strongly against a possible reunification of Germany yesterday, the prospect will cause an upheaval in French international thinking particularly over France's role as the motor of the European Community. 
 The Gaullist RPR, which has played the leading historical role in helping German postwar political recovery &mdash; while opposing any military revival &mdash; has given the most unequivocal welcome to the idea that Germany could again be one nation. 
 The Party leader, Mr Jacques Chirac, said he regretted that reaction in France to events in East Germany were often cool because of the fear of difficult consequences for France, but the priority should be to support a victory of democracy over communism. 
 Forty years ago, one of De Gaulle's greatest admirers, the writer, Franois Mauriac, summed up typical French distrust after nearly a century of conflict by saying that he loved Germany so much that he was glad there were two of them. 
 The lesson since Bismarck has been that France cannot compete politically, militarily or economically with a united Germany. 
 Today the dominant question is whether a country that can draw on the manpower and technology of two advanced industrial countries could become too powerful to be accommodated inside the European Community where the leading nations, Britain, France and Italy, would have populations only half the size of a new Germany. 
 In recent years, former President Valery Giscard d'Estaing and President Franois Mitterrand were able to establish French leadership in the European Community because the separation of East and West had restricted German initiatives and recalled German guilt. 
 The French have tended to exploit a philosophical idea of reconciliation as the only way of restoring German acceptability inside Western Europe. 
 The Germans have had to accept some unpleasant facts such as French posession of nuclear weapons that are stationed on German frontiers as if their main purpose was to prevent a repeat of 1870, 1914, and 1940. 
 Mr Mitterrand has rarely missed an occasion to underline Germany's obligation to make amends by arranging joint ceremonies on Franco-German battlefields. 
 France is also obsessed by the German economic example and has modelled its own planning on achieving parity. 
 In the past fifteen years, the French inflation rate has been brought into line with Germany's, a trade imbalance has been reduced, and successive devaluations of the franc, that stressed German supremacy, have been halted. 
 The urgency to establish the EMS is, in part, a need to contain German domination of monetary policies. 
 PAGE 
 America loses one of its favourite hate symbols. 
 By Simon Tisdall in Washington 
 FOR a generation of Americans, schooled and nurtured on the doctrines of the Cold War, the Berlin Wall was the supreme symbol of Communism and all its evil works. 
 For the common people, as much as their political representatives, it was also the ultimate affirmation of the rightness of the American way, of the moral ascendancy of the United States. 
 As such a symbol, it will be sorely missed. 
 Every President since John Kennedy has used the Wall to dramatise the global Communist threat, to assert American leadership of the Western world, and to underpin fundamental foreign and security policy directions. 
 When President Reagan went to West Berlin and declared before the Brandenburg Gate, &bquo;Mr Gorbachev, tear down that Wall!&equo;, a number of familiar factors were in play. 
 First, Mr Reagan was returning, albeit obliquely, to his earlier Evil Empire theme. 
 Second, he was speaking as much to the American people as to the citizens of the divided Germanys. 
 It was an exercise in self-congratulation from the leader of the self-proclaimed Land of Liberty as much as an expression of solidarity with the oppressed. 
 Third, of course, Mr Reagan (like other presidents before him) had not the slightest thought that Mr Gorbachev might actually do what he asked. 
 It was rhetoric as familiar in American politics as apple pie. 
 Since the second world war, US foreign policy has rested largely on the identification of &bquo;goodies&equo; and &bquo;baddies&equo;, in the context of global superpower. 
 American presidential campaigns, above all, have reflected those simplistic assessments. 
 It is all getting much more complicated. 
 Party offers free polls 100,000 cross Berlin's border Army punches holes in Wall Kohl: We are one nation. 
 By Anna Tomforde and Michael Farr in Berlin 
 THE West German Chancellor, Dr Helmut Kohl, declared in Berlin yesterday: &bquo;Long live a free German fatherland, a free united Europe.&equo; 
 &bquo;We are and will remain one nation. 
 Step by small step we will find our way to a common solution,&equo; he told a crowd of some 20,000 Berliners outside the Schoneberg Rathaus, the seat of West Berlin's government. 
 This morning in Bonn, Dr Kohl will preside at an emergency cabinet meeting to discuss how West Germany should respond to the events of recent days. 
 His forthright emphasis on unity yesterday came as East Germany's bewildered and beleaguered leaders announced new reforms and a fresh round of sackings from the ruling politburo yesterday, coupled with a public promise of free elections. 
 During a day of extraordinary jubilation, more than 100,000 people poured through the increasingly open border to the West. 
 Most of them returned after a brief and long-awaited glimpse at the West. 
 In East Berlin, as the Communist Party's central committee continued in crisis session, the East German President, Mr Egon Krenz, declared: &bquo;We have a great task ahead of us&hellip; to carry through a revolution on German soil that will bring a socialism which is economically effective, politically democratic, and morally clean.&equo; 
 He and Dr Kohl are expected to meet next week following the swearing in of a new East German government on Monday. 
 Last night, Mr Krenz told a Communist Party rally that the new travel regulations, allowing East Germans to go to the West whenever they wish, should be taken as proof that the government was &bquo;serious about the policy of renewal&equo;. 
 His interior minister, Mr Friedrich Dickel, said the freedom to travel was &bquo;permanent and will be the foundation of a new travel law&equo;. 
 Last night, as amazed East Berliners looked on, East German soldiers and building workers began knocking down sections of the Wall. 
 Heavy mechanical equipment was being used to punch holes in the structure that has divided the city for 28 years. 
 Five new openings were the first of 18 new crossing points announced yesterday by the East German authorities. 
 Elsewhere along the frontier, another 40,000 East Germans crossed into West Germany, but only 2,500 decided to stay in the West, according to Bonn.The flight westwards is expected to rise significantly over the weekend. 
 The relatively small number of East Germans who have so far actually left their country permanently suggests that the leadership's decision on free travel was a shrewd move. 
 After a three-day crisis meeting, the Communist Party Central Committee revealed an &bquo;action programme for renewal&equo; which holds out the prospect of free elections, a democratic coalition government and parliamentary investigations into malpractices and abuses of power. 
 Four members and candidate members were sacked from the ruling politburo, elected only on Wednesday. 
 Two had been voted out of their top party positions by their district branches and the other two stepped down after pressure from the Central Committee. 
 A party control commission will begin investigation into &bquo;misconduct&equo; by two former politburo members, Mr Gunter Mittag and Mr Joachim Hermann, responsible for the economy and the media in the politburo. 
 East Germany's prosecutor general has suggested that a parliamentary committee should investigate charges of corruption and power abuse by state and party officials. 
 Mr Gunter Wendland said top party members had enjoyed unjustified privileges, enriched themselves, taken advantage of their positions and &bquo;squandered national wealth&equo;. 
 In view of the great significance and the extent of these malpractices the investigations should be tackled by parliament, the public prosecutor said. 
 The Volkskammer will meet in emergency session on Monday at which the Prime Minister-designate, Mr Hans Modrow, and the new East German government will be confirmed. 
 It is clear it was the reform-minded Mr Modrow and his supporters in the Central Committee who urged the leadership to press ahead swiftly with fundamental change, including the decision to allow free travel. 
 Mr Modrow told the Central Committee that the future government not only needed new faces. 
 It had to be &bquo;a real government which at a later point could even become a coalition&equo;. 
 The relationship between the party and the government had to be completely overhauled, Mr Modrow urged. 
 &bquo;We shall have to conduct parliamentary debates in a style the Communist Party has not yet seen in its entire history,&equo; Mr Modrow said. 
 Deputies had to become genuine representatives of the people. 
 The party newspaper, Neues Deutschland, in an outspoken editorial yesterday, conceded that Communist Party members were among those who had begun to question the party's leading role. 
 &bquo;Significant errors&equo; had been committed by the party &bquo;to the detriment of our country&equo;. 
 In West Berlin the huge crowd at the Rathaus, some of whom had crossed from the East to listen to the speeches, reserved their greatest enthusiasm for the former Social Democrat leader, Chancellor and Mayor of West Berlin, Mr Willy Brandt, who told them, to wild cheers: &bquo;Berlin will live and the Berlin Wall will come down.&equo; 
 Mr Brandt, who was mayor of West Berlin 28 years ago when East Berlin put up the Wall and who stood next to Mr Kennedy during his famous speech, said the barbed wire and wall were &bquo;against the flow of history&equo;, but added that it should remain as an &bquo;an historical monstrosity&equo;. 
 He said part of it should be kept as a monument. 
 &bquo;This is a beautiful day at the end of a long way, but we are not yet at the end of that way, a whole lot remains to be done,&equo; Mr Brandt said. 
 He said he was sure Presidents Bush and Gorbachev would approve of what was happening in Germany, and believed France and Britain, who had given such support during the long and difficult years as well as &bquo;our East European neighbours&equo; would understand. 
 The present Mayor of West Berlin, Mr Walter Momper, told the crowd: &bquo;We are now the happiest people in the world, but in this hour of happiness we should remember the many dead and injured and the pain caused by this wall. 
 &bquo;In East Germany a fascinating chapter of history is being written by the people. 
 We congratulate you on your peaceful and democratic revolution.&equo; 
 But Mr Momper, faced with accommodating those coming from the East, said that while everyone was welcome, the question should also be asked whether people were not needed &bquo;to create a better society in East Germany&equo;. 
 Coe selected for Cornish seat. 
 Olympic gold medallist Sebastian Coe, aged 32, was last night selected as the Conservative candidate for Falmouth and Camborne, in Cornwall. 
 The selection still has to be approved by the next full meeting of the constituency association but the chairwomen, Ms Anne Peck, said last night that this appeared to be a formality. 
 IRA two refused appeal. 
 Two Belfast men serving sentences of 17 and 20 years for plotting an IRA bomb campaign in Britain were yesterday refused leave to appeal. 
 The Appeal Court ruled there was nothing &bquo;unsafe or unsatisfactory&equo; in the convictions of Liam McCotter and Patrick McLaughlin. 
 Egg collector fined. 
 A car worker was yesterday ordered to pay almost &pound;10,000 in fines and costs for having the world's largest known illegal collection of birds' eggs. 
 John Hemmings, aged 54, was found guilty by magistrates at Dartford, Kent, of illegally possessing for sale 22,902 eggs. 
 Petrol price cut. 
 The petrol chain, Jet, will cut the price of a gallon by up to 6p from midnight tomorrow. 
 The top price for leaded four-star will be 179.6p. 
 Shell is to make a statement on prices next week. 
 RUC man dies. 
 Constable Ian Johnston, aged 31, a member of an elite Royal Ulster Constabulary unit trained in SAS tactics, died in hospital yesterday after being shot accidentally by one of his own team when they raided a Belfast house on Thursday. 
 Judgment reserved. 
 The Court of Appeal reserved judgment yesterday on appeals by the Independent and the Sunday Times against contempt convictions stemming from the Spycatcher ban. 
 &pound;1m for policing Tories. 
 The cost of policing the Labour and Conservative party conferences this year were &pound;4,000 and &pound;1 million. 
 THE END OF THE WALL. 
 Soviet Union welcomes change Jonathan Steele, page 24 
 The future shape of Europe Hella Pick, page 2 
 What the world is saying Former Bonn ambassador writes What it means for arms control All to hail, and all to play for WSLeader Comment, page 22 
 Not the time to talk of reunification, says Gerasimov Moscow welcomes collapse of the Wall. 
 By Jonathan Steele 
 THE Berlin Wall has long been more than the ugliest symbol of Europe's division. 
 It marked the western border of the Soviet empire. 
 But yesterday, in a reaction as unpredictable as everything that has happened during this tumultuous week, the Soviet Union welcomed its collapse. 
 As though he had always known the Wall should disappear, the Soviet Foreign Minister, Mr Eduard Shevarnadze, described as &bquo;wise and sensible&equo; the East German decision to open it up. 
 &bquo;It's a historic moment. 
 We hope it's for the best,&equo; said Mr Gennady Gerasimov, the chief spokesman, in pithy words which encapsulate the bold leap towards the Common European Home that Mr Egon Krenz, with Moscow's backing, has made. 
 President Gorbachev is as uncertain as everyone about what the future of the two &mdash; perhaps one &mdash; German states will be, but there is no doubt that the Gorbachev vision of a new Europe had to encompass the Wall's disappearance. 
 But instead of going at the end of the process of building the new Europe, the Wall has gone at the beginning. 
 Its opening is the key which must unlock the door to rapid decisions on ending 45 years of East-West confrontation, formally as well as in fact. 
 The future of the two alliances is in the balance, and the Soviet side is already eager to restructure the Warsaw Pact into something which may look more like the Commonwealth than the Moscow-dominated monolith of the still recent past. 
 But the Soviet Union is anxious for matching changes on the Nato side. 
 Nor does it want the German tail to wag the European dog. 
 German reunification should be part of a wider process of bringing a new peace order in Europe. 
 Mr Gerasimov stressed yesterday that the end of the Wall does not automatically remove the border between the two German states. 
 &bquo;The Federal Republic should take into account that policies aimed at changing borders would not suit any Government in Europe.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;Politically it is not the time to talk about re-unification. 
 The two Germanys belong to different military blocs.&equo; 
 One Soviet official commented yesterday on this summer's changes in Poland, Hungary, and now East Germany: &bquo;It's an ideological humiliation, but a political and strategic advantage.&equo; 
 That describes the measure of the Gorbachev revolution. 
 He realised that the Communist parties had lost touch with their peoples and that he could not logically denounce Stalinist terror and neo-Stalinist stagnation in his own country without accepting the same for the countries which Stalin forcibly incorporated into the Soviet empire. 
 No state has found it easy to give up an empire with dignity, but Mr Gorbachev is doing it now with extraordinary openness. 
 With hindsight, one can see how Mr Gorbachev has been preparing the ground for this week's changes. 
 He said this summer that the Warsaw Pact had to become a political rather than a military alliance. 
 He talked of each country's right to &bquo;freedom of choice&equo;. 
 He has called for the removal of all foreign troops and bases in Europe. 
 In East Berlin in October, in his speech marking the German Democratic Republic's 40th anniversary, Mr Gorbachev reminded the world that the Soviet Union had advocated the preservation of German unity after the second world war. 
 The end of the Wall gives a powerful impetus for new security thinking, which the West would be foolish to ignore. 
 The trick must be to allow the Soviet Union's ideological humiliation not to be turned into a strategic one. 
 The end of the Wall is no one's defeat. 
 The Kremlin has told four Soviet republics to drop controversial new laws on elections. 
 Baltic states censured, page 8 
 Lead alert hits 1,500 farms. 
 By James Erlichman, Consumer Affairs correspondent 
 ABOUT 1,500 farms have had their milk and beef sales halted since lead was discovered to have contaminated feedstuffs imported from Holland. 
 Another 117 were cleared for normal production after their milk samples showed levels of less than 50 parts of lead per billion for three successive days. 
 A check by officials on feed company records uncovered an extra 266 which had received contaminated fodder. 
 It came only hours after the Agriculture Minister, Mr John Gummer, said he was confident that most farms receiving lead-tainted animal feed had been tracked down. 
 Some of the farms put under restrictions yesterday have already supplied milk for public consumption, but officials were confident there had been no threat to health. 
 Farmers suffering losses from lead contamination were told yesterday their best hope of redress lay in court action against suppliers. 
 The advice came from the president of the National Farmers' Union, Mr Simon Gourlay, who discussed the matter with ministers. 
 About one million litres of milk, worth &pound;200,000, is being withdrawn from the market daily. 
 Fresh tests on milk samples released last night showed 70 per cent of 238 dairy farms analysed were producing milk with lead levels above the Department of Health's recommended safety limit, although 72 farms were within the limit of less than 0.05 milligrams of lead per litre. 
 The Ministry of Agriculture said yesterday it was hoped that next week would see the first dairy farms released from the restriction orders. 
 The ministry said it had only begun to take meat samples. 
 The first results would be ready next week. 
 Judgment was reserved yesterday on the first legal moves to pin the blame for the contamination. 
 A court in Rotterdam which heard submissions from two Dutch fodder companies is to announce preliminary findings on Monday. 
 Mother seeks leave to sue over girl's murder 11 years ago. 
 THE mother of a 16-year-old girl murdered 11 years ago sought a High Court ruling yesterday that would let her bring a civil damages action against two men she alleges were responsible. 
 No one was convicted of killing Lynn Siddons, whose mutilated body, with 40 stab wounds, was found near a canal at Barrow upon Trent, in April 1978. 
 But her mother, Mrs Gail Halford, of Derby, claims that Michael Brookes and his stepson, Fitzroy Brookes, killed her. 
 She was not advised she had a reasonable civil case until 1985. 
 Fitzroy, aged 15 at the time of the killing, was tried and acquitted. 
 His stepfather, then aged 33, gave evidence as a prosecution witness. 
 Yesterday's hearing before Mr Justice Schiemann was on the issue of whether the claim fell within the legal time limit. 
 Judgment was reserved, and will be given in Manchester. 
 Germans seize their moment of national opportunity Commentary. 
 By Martin Woollacott 
 THIS has been Germany's year. 
 From the crisis over Nato modernisation in March to the casting down of the Wall in November stretch an astonishing nine months in which Germans on both sides have reached out with increasing boldness to take their destiny into their own hands. 
 The rest of Europe has watched in fascination and sometimes in fear. 
 The international landscape with which we began 1989 &mdash; the old, familiar structures of the two alliances, the Anglo-American special relationship, the European Community's halting progress toward greater unity, and the newer but also beginning to be familiar element of reform in the Soviet Union &mdash; is being transformed, and it is Germany which is leading that transformation. 
 Insofar as the old remains, it is like an empty chrysalis, preserving the shape but not the substance of what existed before. 
 How distant now seem the quarrels of the spring over the introduction of new short-range missiles. 
 West Europeans and Americans were arguing angrily about whether the Soviet Union was conspiratorially seeking to gain military advantage by negotiating away the West's remaining tactical nuclear weapons and then stalling on conventional reductions. 
 Strange to recall, we were still thinking in terms of East bloc tank armies and fighter squadrons, still counting divisions on the map of central Europe, and still, some of us, acting as if the USSR remained a dangerous antagonist. 
 The revolt of the Bonn government against this antique thinking can be seen as the starting point for the great burst of German national assertion which culminated yesterday in the streets of Berlin. 
 Although Chancellor Kohl later agreed to an apparent compromise it was clear even then &mdash; how much more so now &mdash; that West Germany had killed the programme, and it had done so because it sensed far better than any of its Nato partners how completely President Gorbachev had changed the situation in Europe. 
 The West Germans had cast an unprecedented veto against new nuclear weapons. 
 They had done so after a period of co-operation and consultation with East Germany which looks in retrospect like a laying of the groundwork for what was to come in both Germanys. 
 The Federal Republic became the strongest advocate of arms control within Nato and the German Democratic Republic played the same role in the Warsaw Pact. 
 Here was the partial and still nuanced defiance of their respective Alliance masters that indicated both a German refusal of the role of victims in the superpower struggle and a sense in both German states that the room for manoeuvre was growing. 
 If the March crisis over missile modernisation now seems something from another era, so too do the fears of the summer. 
 Germans on both sides realised that the Soviet Union had made not one but two fundamental international decisions. 
 The first, of course, was to seek peace with the West. 
 The second was that force could not and should not be used to maintain Communist authority in Eastern Europe. 
 For East Germans, watching Poland and Hungary, the message was there: things were moving toward the point where you could leave the country without real risk, and you could criticise the party without real risk. 
 Out of that realisation came the explosive mixture of a massive emigration from East Germany and an overwhelming popular challenge to the party inside it. 
 The reaction of Americans and other Europeans to the summer exodus was, however, still embedded in the old thinking. 
 The Soviet Union would only permit a united Germany if that state was to be neutral, the argument went, and that way lay the old nightmare of a Germany swinging between East and West. 
 But the whole idea of neutralisation presupposes the continued existence of a world polarised between East and West, a world which is literally disappearing before our eyes. 
 It must now be clear that whatever form of unification or quasi-unification is eventually arrived at will not involve the neutralisation of West Germany in any meaningful sense. 
 Instead what we have before us is a German triumph that could not have happened without Gorbachev and Walesa, a triumph that was not planned and which is in many ways an accident, but which nevertheless has come about because both West and East Germans have seized the moment of national opportunity. 
 In doing so they have pointed the way to a European future in which Germany will be the single biggest power, economically, politically, and perhaps militarily, so far as that still matters. 
 For the rest of Europe this assertion of German nationhood has its unavoidably bitter dimension. 
 Britain has spent the last 100 years fighting against the facts of German power: indeed our modern national identity has to a great extent been forged in the fires of the great conflict with Germany while our sense of our moral worth rests in part on our role in the defeat of Nazism. 
 Even in the post-war period Britain's understanding of itself has continued to be fashioned by our taking a leading part in the containment of Germany that was the unspoken second function of the Nato Alliance. 
 For the French, too, the trauma must be a serious one. 
 Their recent history is also 
 Turn to page 24, col 8 
 Seizing their national moment continued from page one centred on conflict with Germany, but their solution has been a different one from that of the British. 
 Their post-war policy has been based on the effort to create an enduring Franco-German axis that would maintain French power in Europe. 
 Who can say now that this solution can survive in a larger Europe in which a unified or confederated Germany is the strongest element? 
 There are darker problems than these for all Europeans, problems that have a special anguish for Slavs and for Jews. 
 Can we entrust the future of Europe to a Germany which has still not wholly rid itself of a nationalism that hankers, whatever is said officially, over the &bquo;lost&equo; territories in the East, that still sees Germans as superior to other nations and races, that still relishes power over others? 
 The historian Golo Mann wrote 20 years ago that Germany's post-war recovery took place against &bquo;a historical background of which Germans had reason to be profoundly ashamed. 
 &bquo;Many were honestly ashamed; others said they were within limits; many were not.&equo; 
 The temptation for Germans now, even though the generation of which Mann was writing has largely passed away, is to see in the great breakthrough of the last few months simply a kind of vindication of Germany's efforts to achieve hegemony in Europe, to see the first and second world wars and what is happening now as three chapters of the same story. 
 There is no denying a basic sense in which this may be true, and yet the last chapter will surely be different. 
 Europe is a different place, Germany is a different country. 
 The international order the British presided over had no proper place for Germany, but that which the United States brought into being after 1945 has given the Federal Republic a privileged if somewhat constrained position. 
 And the closed cultural and political world of the old Germany has gone. 
 Germans now are Europeans in a way they were not before, and indeed the demand of East Germans that they be allowed to be Europeans, with the same wide-ranging and unquestioned rights to travel, study, and residence as the rest of us was both a catalyst and an indication of how much things have changed. 
 It is also true that the phenomenon of German power is not so recognisable inside Germany itself, where on both sides there is a sense of vulnerability and of continuing risk that militates against any revival of chest-beating nationalism. 
 We may have our worries about the different future we see opening up before us &mdash; it would be odd if we did not &mdash; but surely we must see what is happening at the Brandenburg Gate as a European as well as a German triumph. 
 Labour urges consumer watchdog for rail users. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 ASHAKE-UP of the management and finances of British Rail is proposed by Labour's transport spokesman, Mr John Prescott, in the wake of the report into the Clapham Junction rail crash. 
 Labour would establish a new Railway Act, encourage a more dynamic style of management, increase government funding and make the railways more accountable through a consumer regulatory framework. 
 &bquo;It is clear from the Hidden Report that BR is in desperate need not just of a new financial climate but a new managerial approach as well,&equo; Mr Prescott said yesterday. 
 BR management was &bquo;incompetent and unimaginative,&equo; he said If the chairman, Sir Robert Reid, were not due to retire in April, he should be sacked. 
 Mr Prescott also warned that simply pumping public money into the railways was not the sole answer. 
 &bquo;It would be naive to think that all a Labour government has to do is increase revenue support, encourage greater investment and Britain's railway system would automatically catch up with the best in Europe,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Labour will introduce a new Railway Act that will lay down in law the broad policy objectives that we expect BR to meet,&equo; he told the Centre for Local Economic Strategies in Sheffield. 
 &bquo;These will include tough quality of service targets to improve safety, reliability and passenger comfort.&equo; 
 The financial framework and policy objectives would be set by a Labour government. 
 An independent national regulatory body would monitor BR's performance, examine investment schemes, fare policies and management practices. 
 &bquo;There will be a consumer watchdog to deal with the whole range of consumer rights and needs,&equo; he promised. 
 Bus usage in leading English cities has fallen by a sixth since 1985/86 because of the Government's deregulation of bus operations, says a study for the Association of Metropolitan Authorities. 
 About 336 million fewer journeys are being taken in Greater Manchester, West Midlands, Merseyside, South Yorkshire, Tyne and Wear, West Yorkshire and Strathclyde. 
 The study by the transport economist Mr Bill Tyson also shows that fares have risen, and the overall savings to the tax-payer have been a modest &pound;23 million. 
 Mr Jack Meredith, chairman of the AMA's public transport committee, said that while bus patronage was declining prior to deregulation, the Tyson report showed that the fall in journeys was between 100 and 200 million more than would have been expected. 
 Mr Tyson says deregulation prompted fares to rise by 23 per cent in real terms in 1986/87, followed by a 3.7 per cent real increase in 1987/88. 
 Last year, fares rose slightly higher than inflation in most areas. 
 True fax revealed about Hockney art Martin Wainwright at a long-distance &bquo;happening&equo; of artistic technology. 
 DAVID Hockney's latest work of art arrived in his home city of Bradford last night in a welter of spray-on glue and sheets of fax paper, and to the sound of Wagner's Ride of the Valkyries. 
 Sheet by acid-sprayed sheet, 144 pieces of a huge jigsaw of tubes and angles beeped and fluttered from four laser facsimile machines in Sir Titus Salt's former alpaca mill, while at his home in California Hockney &mdash; already master of computer, photocopy, and snipped-photograph art &mdash; was feeding the composite picture into his own fax. 
 The sun was shining in Los Angeles, according to a Yorkshire TV crew out there filming the US end of the link-up. 
 Bradford, for all the Italian wine and canapes at the mill's art gallery, looked like a dank study by Hockney's northern predecessor L.S.Lowry. 
 The wet cobbles in the mill-yard only needed huddled operatives arriving for an 18-hour shift in their shawls, but instead it got art critics. 
 They took their places beside local worthies and the artist's mother, Mrs Laura Hockney, who watched her daughter Margaret join in the pasting up. 
 Another son, Paul, was at the other end of the link in Los Angeles. 
 Seven o'clock struck. 
 The fax peeped and began to flutter out the jigsaw sheets. 
 &bquo;We are starting now, love David&equo;, said the first sheet, which was promptly glued to the T of the great, gold SALT'S sign hijacked from the mill offices and hoisted above the 15 by 9 &frac12;ft frame divided into 144 sections for the fax picture. 
 Then the picture itself began to arrive. 
 Each slice was glue-sprayed and bundled up a pair of stepladders to be stuck into place. 
 Bent over the light-flashing, peeping fax machines, the mill and gallery's owner, Jonathan Silver, checked detailed assembly instructions previously faxed by the artist. 
 The picture turned out to be an abstract on a sporting theme, called Tennis, with nets and balls littered around but no sign of the swimming pools and rippling water favoured by Hockney. 
 Silver, a schoolmate of Hockney at Bradford grammar, sold the young artist's paintings through the chain of clothes shops he established in the North after taking his A levels. 
 Hockney has repaid the debt with numerous studies of Silver, two of which looked on among the gallery's 100 Hockneys, ranging from a teenage pencil sketch to oils done last Christmas. 
 While the fax winked and peeped on its artistic way, following in the steps of the great etchers and lithographers, tributes to fax from Hockney were passed round. 
 In a (faxed) letter to his old Bradford primary, he tells the pupils: &bquo;It seems to me fax will spread everywhere, as it is such a useful instrument and a wonderful way to communicate with each other.&equo; 
 In a (faxed) interview with a magazine in Brazil he argues: &bquo;Its first victim seems to be the totalitarian world. 
 You cannot buy an office copier in Eastern Europe because if you could you would have a free press.&equo; 
 Victims of modern faxitis, drowning in paper and worrying that the writing will disappear by 2000 AD had one reassurance. 
 Fax art is not valuable. 
 Each copy is a copy which anyone else can copy again, says Hockney. 
 &bquo;You can frame them, or you can throw them away.&equo; 
 Seizing the national moment continued from page one centred on conflict with Germany, but their solution has been a different one from that of the British. 
 Their post-war policy has been based on the effort to create an enduring Franco-German axis that would maintain French power in Europe. 
 Who can say now that this solution can survive in a larger Europe in which a unified or confederated Germany is the strongest element? 
 There are darker problems than these for all Europeans, problems that have a special anguish for Slavs and for Jews. 
 Can we entrust the future of Europe to a Germany which has still not wholly rid itself of a nationalism that hankers, whatever is said officially, over the &bquo;lost&equo; territories in the East, that still sees Germans as superior to other nations and races, that still relishes power over others? 
 The historian Golo Mann wrote 20 years ago that Germany's post-war recovery took place against &bquo;a historical background of which Germans had reason to be profoundly ashamed. 
 &bquo;Many were honestly ashamed; others said they were within limits; many were not.&equo; 
 The temptation for Germans now, even though the generation of which Mann was writing has largely passed away, is to see in the great breakthrough of the last few months simply a kind of vindication of Germany's efforts to achieve hegemony in Europe, to see the first and second world wars and what is happening now as three chapters of the same story. 
 There is no denying a basic sense in which this may be true, and yet the last chapter will surely be different. 
 Europe is a different place, Germany is a different country. 
 The international order the British presided over had no proper place for Germany, but that which the United States brought into being after 1945 has given the Federal Republic a privileged if somewhat constrained position. 
 And the closed cultural and political world of the old Germany has gone. 
 Germans now are Europeans in a way they were not before, and indeed the demand of East Germans that they be allowed to be Europeans, with the same wide-ranging and unquestioned rights to travel, study, and residence as the rest of us was both a catalyst and an indication of how much things have changed. 
 It is also true that the phenomenon of German power is not so recognisable inside Germany itself, where on both sides there is a sense of vulnerability and of continuing risk that militates against any revival of chest-beating nationalism. 
 We may have our worries about the different future we see opening up before us &mdash; it would be odd if we did not &mdash; but surely we must see what is happening at the Brandenburg Gate as a European as well as a German triumph. 
 PAGE 
 Firm offers to cut engineers' hours. 
 By Keith Harper Labour Editor 
 ATWO-HOUR reduction in the working week, from 39 to 37 hours, has been negotiated for 3,000 North-east workers in the most significant break in the engineering strike since it began a fortnight ago. 
 The deal, at Northern Engineering Industries, Newcastle upon Tyne, will be put to a mass meeting of workers today. 
 According to the unions, however, it contains a few minor strings, but nothing like the substantial changes in working practices being asked for nationally by the employers. 
 The engineering unions have been pressing for a 35-hour working week, but the deal at NEI &mdash; a subsidiary of Rolls-Royce &mdash; would satisfy their claim for a two-hour reduction in the working week. 
 Unions sources said last night that they think the move could have a knock-on effect at other firms, and could be seized on by unions at Ford &mdash; where the company has so far resisted demands to reduce the 39-hour working week, and whose workers at Southampton walked out yesterday in protest at the company's pay offer. 
 Ford unions have rejected a 9.5 per cent increase this year, and lightning walk-outs are likely to continue before the unions decide on their next step on November 20. 
 This is expected to be a ballot calling for industrial action. 
 A similar ballot at eight Lucas plants is to be held on November 22. 
 Miners' leaders attending a special conference of the National Union of Mineworkers in Sheffield yesterday backed away from a strike over the imposition of a 7.6 per cent pay rise by British Coal, when they realised there would be little support from members. 
 British Coal yesterday announced the loss of 450 white-collar jobs in Yorkshire. 
 A similar announcement was made in Nottinghamshire, but no figures were given. 
 Citizens of united city overcome their disbelief. 
 By Michael Farr in Berlin 
 YESTERDAY Berlin ceased to be a divided city. 
 Tens of thousands of East Berliners streamed to the West, unhindered for the first time since the Wall was put up 28 years ago. 
 Most crossed just for the experience of a freedom they had been denied so long. 
 They simply looked at shop windows, stopped at cafes on the fashionable Kudamm Street or visited friends. 
 As they came off the S-Bahn trains, drove their battered Trabants across the border crossing, or just walked through, they pinched themselves in disbelief. 
 Not one of the many East Berliners I spoke to at several crossing points said they meant to stay in the West. 
 They came with their spouses, friends and children for a historic stroll and perhaps some shopping. 
 Many more are expected to cross today, which for most is not a working day. 
 A group of East German workers still in their blue overalls in West Berlin's equivalent of Oxford Street, the Wilmersdorferstrasse, bought doughnuts and Western newspapers &bquo;to prove we've been here&equo;. 
 Getting off a packed S-Bahn carriage at the Zoo station, a woman pointed out to her husband the Kaiser Wilhelm Memorial Church: &bquo;Look! 
 I never thought we could see it like this.&equo; 
 An East Berlin policeman was on the platform to offer directions and give advice. 
 At the Invalidenstrasse crossing, West Berliners greeted those from the East with flowers and cheers. 
 Among the vehicles at the Bornholmerstrasse crossing, I saw two East German taxis with passengers. 
 One East Berliner was driven from the crossing to Charlottenburg, three miles away in the British sector, at the concessionary rate of 1 East Mark to 1 DeutscheMark, compared with the market rate of 10-1, highlighting the fact that the only constraint on East Germans is now financial. 
 East Berliners have been offered free tickets for a football match today in West Berlin as well as to a number of concerts and the opera. 
 Flying over the Bornholmerstrasse yesterday, I saw a scrum of East Berliners massing to cross its bridge. 
 Royal Military Police, responsible for the Wall along the British sector, maintained their patrols and Army Air Corps helicopters hovered overhead, monitoring the remarkable proceedings. 
 Huge crowds built up on the Western side of the Wall as West Berliners witnessed the historic developments, some even crossing over into the East for a walk. 
 In front of the Brandenburg Gate and elsewhere, they perched precariously on top of the Wall, clapping and calling for it to go. 
 It was unclear last night how many East Berliners planned to stay in the West, where facilities are increasingly being overstretched. 
 But as the West German cities of Bremen and Hanover said they could take no more refugees, Berlin was still offering a warm welcome. 
 &bquo;After all we are not just one people, we are also one city,&equo; said one West Berliner, who described the last 24 hours as &bquo;simply unbelievable&equo;. 
 Another added: &bquo;Now what the politicians have always called for has happened, we must rise to the occasion.&equo; 
 Bulgaria celebrates Zhivkov's fall. 
 By Mike Power and Denise Searle in Sofia 
 ON the day the Berlin Wall finally crumbled, one of East Europe's last bastions of conservatism faced upheaval with the resignation of Bulgaria's Todor Zhivkov. 
 East Europe's longest-serving leader, Mr Zhivkov was forced to quit by growing dissident activity and rumblings among senior party figures over his unbending hardline policies. 
 In a cleverly manoeuvred Central Committee coup, the Foreign Minister, Mr Petar Mladenov, gave Mr Zhivkov no alternative but to step down from his post as General Secretary of the Bulgarian Communist Party, politburo member and President of the State Council. 
 Mr Mladenov, the youngest member of the politburo at 53 and regarded as its most liberal figure, takes over as General Secretary. 
 Mr Zhivkov's resignation, which was announced at a meeting of the Bulgarian Communist Party's Central Committee, took Bulgarians and the diplomatic community by surprise. 
 It was greeted emotionally in the capital, Sofia, where a 150-strong rally of human rights activists in a rainy park erupted into cheers. 
 &bquo;It's pure joy,&equo; one dissident journalist said. 
 &bquo;Everyone is telephoning friends and family. 
 Maybe we'll really see some change now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mladenov is certainly the best of a bad bunch,&equo; said a respected biologist, Mr Petar Beron, a leading member of the dissident environment group Ecoglasnost. 
 &bquo;We'll now wait and see what democratic changes he comes up with.&equo; 
 Mr Zhivkov, aged 78, came to power in 1954. 
 He kept Bulgaria close to the Soviet Union, particularly during Brezhnev's time, but has been unable to cope with President Gorbachev's move towards democracy and openness. 
 Even some of the Bulgarian old guard became impatient with Mr Zhivkov's inability to dig Bulgaria out of its economic and political crisis and an important factor in yesterday's coup was that one of this group, the Defence Minister, Mr Dobri Dzhurov, sided with Mr Mladenov. 
 Mr Mladenov, who became Foreign Minister in 1971, had grown increasingly tired of facing criticism of Bulgaria at international meetings. 
 He resigned as Foreign Minister in late October, and secretarial staff got as far as clearing out his offices. 
 He was then persuaded to stay only by a last-minute promise of personnel changes at the top, but even senior Communist Party advisers had no idea how high-level these changes had been. 
 An important manoeuvre was a stop-off by Mr Mladenov in Moscow early this month on his way to an official visit to China. 
 Observers in Sofia are convinced that the Kremlin gave his proposed leadership bid its blessing. 
 The final straw, according to inside sources, was when Mr Zhivkov tried to bring his widely disliked son, Vladimir, who has a reputation as a drunkard and a womaniser, on to the politburo. 
 Mr Mladenov followed his appointment as Communist Party General Secretary with a speech clearly aimed at the country's dissident movement, which has been growing. 
 His biggest headache is likely to be the economy. 
 There is a &dollar;7billion (&pound;4.5million) foreign debt and there are increasing shortages even of staple goods such as cheese and sausage. 
 Mother bailed because of baby's illness. 
 By Owen Bowcott 
 THE Court of Appeal yesterday granted bail to a mother separated from her 13-week-old son because of the shortage of places in mother and baby units in prisons in England and Wales. 
 Ms Yvonne Mitchell, of Hackney, east London, was allowed bail with sureties totalling &pound;12,000 after medical evidence showed that continued breastfeeding was vital for the baby's safety. 
 The family had a history of cot deaths, and the baby had a heart condition. 
 Friends were trying to raise the bail money last night. 
 Ms Mitchell was jailed for three years on Wednesday at Cambridge crown court for possessing and supplying cocaine. 
 She was granted bail pending an appeal against the sentence. 
 The Home Office confirmed on Thursday that there was a waiting list for the 39 places in mother and baby units. 
 Ms Mitchell's solicitor, Mr Julian Lee, said: &bquo;It was a life or death situation for the child.&equo; 
 The baby had rejected milk given by the foster mother. 
 Ambulance unions pare down claim. 
 By Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 THE Government was under pressure last night to re-enter negotiations over the ambulance dispute as unions stripped away all but three elements of their pay and conditions claim in an attempt to force talks at the conciliation service, Acas. 
 Picking through the Health Secretary Mr Kenneth Clarke's references in Thursday's acrimonious emergency debate in the Commons, where he said the claim amounted to 20 per cent, union leaders publicly pared down their demands. 
 Mr Roger Poole, the chief union negotiator, said they would now be seeking an increase in the offer of 6.5 per cent on basic rates, an automatic pay formula for future years and the return of overtime payments. 
 The unions claim that 25 ambulance services around the country are now answering only emergency calls. 
 Mr Poole said national leaders would meet on Thursday to discuss ways to intensify pressure on health service managers to re-open talks. 
 &bquo;The Government should be under no illusion about our preparedness to see this dispute through,&equo; he said, adding there would be no threat to emergency services. 
 The unions have dropped from their claim the demand for increased annual leave, extra holiday and pay for long service, and reductions in working hours. 
 Adding these to the other elements of the claim and demands for extra London weighting, Mr Clarke had said in the Commons that ambulance workers were looking for &bquo;rather a lot more money&equo;. 
 The unions' move leaves unchanged the central issues of basic pay and a pay formula. 
 Two earlier attempts to find a solution at Acas failed. 
 The Department of Health said it would not comment until it received details of the proposals. 
 The move came amid calls from London Ambulance Service chiefs for staff to operate radios in line with procedures so that full 999 services, which have been almost paralysed, could be restored. 
 Mr Poole urged doctors, hospitals and the public to continue approaching suspended London crews directly for emergency services instead of relying on the police, the army and the voluntary services. 
 Staff in the West Midlands agreed yesterday to restrict radio use &mdash; the central issue in London &mdash; from Wednesday as part of an intensification of action around the country. 
 Letters, page 22 
 Veterans' memories cloud the good news from Berlin. 
 By Maev Kennedy 
 THE Arnhem veteran standing at the Cenotaph in Whitehall yesterday saw no good news, only a threat to everything he had fought for, in the torrent of people flowing through the remains of the Berlin Wall. 
 &bquo;Half of them are KGB, and I wouldn't trust the other half,&equo; he said bitterly. 
 &bquo;There'll be another Hitler,&equo; another veteran warned. 
 Young Londoners showed either indifference or elation yesterday to the extraordinary scenes in Berlin. 
 &bquo;Looks like a brilliant street party,&equo; said one young man. 
 Many of their elders wearing poppies, and most of those selling the poppies, found that reaction naive and worrying. 
 &bquo;I was in the war,&equo; the poppy-seller at Charing Cross said, to explain why he could not go along with the media insistence that this was a good news story. 
 The Arnhem veteran had come from Salisbury for a memorial service. 
 He was showing his wife, a Wren in the war, around London landmarks, and they had reached the Cenotaph, where the flagstaffs were being touched up with gold paint for Armistice Day. 
 &bquo;I have some experience of the Russians and you can't trust them,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'm against a united Germany. 
 I think we should watch out.&equo; 
 The poppy-seller, &bquo;one of the boys in the 8th Army&equo;, came out of the war with a bit of shrapnel in the back of his neck &mdash; and a more permanent suspicion of German reunification. 
 &bquo;I can see it's wonderful for the East Germans, and if it doesn't lead to reunification I've no objection to it. 
 But if it does, I'm against it. 
 It's too dangerous.&equo; 
 A man inspecting the crosses around the regimental emblems outside Westminster Abbey lived in the East End during the Blitz. 
 He remembered sitting on a wall with a cousin, watching the first German bombers fly over. 
 By the end of the war, he was in the RAF, and his cousin had died in Italy. 
 &bquo;The Germans started two world wars, didn't they?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If there's a united Germany today, there'll be another Hitler, and they'll start another war. 
 &bquo;They all look nice and happy on the television, and I've nothing against them as individuals. 
 It was the same with the German prisoners-of-war, they were just like you or me. 
 But a united Germany would get militaristic. 
 You can't forget if you've been through it, you can't.&equo; 
 There were other views. 
 Mrs Mona Spink, a former national standard-bearer for the British Legion, was selling poppies opposite the RAF chapel, St Clement's, in the Strand. 
 She worked in munitions in the war, and has since visited Berlin many times. 
 A friend there got an annual permit to visit her mother in East Berlin for one hour. 
 &bquo;The wall was a frightening sight, and a pathetic one,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;This is a fantastic day.&equo; 
 The war veteran selling memorial crosses at the Abbey beamed at the memory of the scenes on television. 
 &bquo;There are plenty of British Legion people about here today, and you'll find those who will tell you this is bad,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;But they're wrong. 
 Freedom was what it was all about, freedom for as many countries as possible. 
 I think it's wonderful news.&equo; 
 Left-wing MPs bear the brunt of constituency challenges. 
 By Patrick Wintour 
 LABOUR has begun its most intensive period for reselection. 
 So far the party executive has endorsed 71 candidates, of whom 57 are sitting MPs. 
 Eighteen of the 57 have faced challenges. 
 Only Mr Gerry Bermingham, MP for St Helens South and a member of the leftwing Campaign group, has been deselected. 
 Other MPs who came close to defeat were the Militant supporter Mr Pat Wall (Bradford North), and Mr Ron Brown (Leith), the left-winger who had the whip withdrawn for a month for dropping the Mace. 
 Most MPs who faced a challenge sailed through. 
 Ironically it has been the left, the architects of reselection, who have been under greatest threat. 
 The two remaining Militant supporters, Mr Dave Nellist (Coventry South-west), and Mr Terry Fields (Liverpool Broadgreen), are both in danger. 
 Mr Nellist is being pursued by Mr Ken Cure, the former engineering union official. 
 The result will be known on November 17. 
 Dr John Gilbert (Dudley East), scourge of CND, is trailing badly in nominations to Mr David Sparks, a former chairman of West Midlands county council. 
 The result will be known on December 7. 
 &bquo;Realist&equo; faces battle to hold sway over divided loyalties. 
 By Alan Dunn 
 FRANK Field's loyalty vote was holding up well yesterday along Park Road, Claughton, at the Labour heart of his Birkenhead parliamentary constituency. 
 But if, as expected, he fails to gain reselection by his local party next month and carries out his threat to resign and stand against the official Labour candidate in a byelection, he will have to work hard to swing the hearts and minds of many Labour voters. 
 A spot-check of voters walking alongside Birkenhead Park yesterday found Labour voters roughly divided. 
 Mr William Gleeson said: &bquo;I hope he doesn't lose reselection, but if he does I will still vote for him. 
 He did well for the likes of Cammell Laird and other plant closures, and has done well for the people at Rock Ferry.&equo; 
 But Mr Sam Hatton said: &bquo;I wouldn't vote for him, to be honest. 
 We never see him round here, nor any of the Labour councillors, if it comes to that. 
 I can't understand him. 
 One minute he is all for Labour policy, the next he is knocking it. 
 I'd vote for the party candidate.&equo; 
 Mr Robert Mayor wasn't too sure how he would vote in a council election, because of concern over reports of overspending by the hung Wirral authority and the effect on the poll tax. 
 But he would vote for the official Labour candidate in a parliamentary election. 
 His friend, Mr Derek Harrod, said: &bquo;I would vote for the official candidate. 
 We are all working class around here.&equo; 
 Mrs Catherine Eaton said: &bquo;I would hope Frank Field can stay as MP. 
 There is no one to replace him. 
 He is proven. 
 I am sorry if it means opposing the official candidate, but I would vote for Frank Field.&equo; 
 Mr Frank Leech said he hoped Mr Field would stand as an independent Labour candidate. 
 &bquo;I would vote for him. 
 He is a good MP, a Tam Dalyell-type, who is always there and has good views, many on things the Militants don't like him for. 
 He's a realist.&equo; 
 Among the &bquo;don't knows&equo; were Mr Paul Dean and Mr Andrew Bingham, who will be eligible to vote for the first time. 
 &bquo;I'm a solid Labour man. 
 But I haven't given much thought to it at the moment. 
 I'd want to vote for the official candidate, but Frank's not done too bad,&equo; said Mr Dean. 
 &bquo;I'm not all that interested in voting, but if I do I think I'll vote for Mr Field, but I'm not sure,&equo; said Mr Bingham. 
 Only one person, a young mother with her baby in a pram, refused political opinion. 
 &bquo;We are Jehovah's Witnesses and we don't vote &mdash; only for God's Kingdom. 
 I have some leaflets which might help you&hellip; &bquo; 
 10 years for acid party general. 
 AFORMER council youth leader known as the general was jailed for 10 years yesterday after organising three acid house parties at which hard drugs were openly available. 
 Robert Darby, 26, of the Isle of Dogs, east London, is the first person in Britain to be imprisoned in connection with the organistion of the parties. 
 Darby's conviction, after a six-week trial, was the first of its kind and Mr David Mellor, the Home Office Minister, said last night: &bquo;I am glad it has been demonstrated so clearly that luring youngsters into the crime of drug pushing carries with it a severe penalty. 
 &bquo;The party invitation offered these youngsters a &bquo;good trip&equo; rather than a good time. 
 Most people will welcome the good long trip he has had in return.&equo; 
 Mr Jeffrey Bayes, a solicitor, specialising in criminal law, commented: &bquo;It is obvious that the judge has it in mind to stamp out acid house parties right now.&equo; 
 Darby was convicted, along with his assistant Leslie Thomas, 26, also of the Isle of Dogs, at an earlier hearing on two counts of conspiracy to manage premises where drugs were known to be available. 
 Thomas, who was also due to be sentenced yesterday, jumped bail last October. 
 Judge Geoffrey Rivlin QC, sitting at Southwark Crown Court, said the case had disclosed a disturbing picture of the use of &bquo;a wide range of dangerous drugs&equo; by customers at Darby's parties. 
 The court was told of two warehouse parties &mdash; the first in Commercial Street, east London and the second in Cuba Street, Isle of Dogs, both in September last year. 
 The third was for about 200 people paying &pound;15 each on a Thames pleasure cruiser, the Viscountess, in the November. 
 Judge Rivlin, sentencing Darby, said: &bquo;I have no doubt that you were a leading light in the organisation of the first party and that you were the leading light in the second and third parties.&equo; 
 There was no question that Darby, a former part-time youth leader at George Green Youth Centre, Tower Hamlets, had merely turned &bquo;a blind eye&equo; to the drug-taking, he said. 
 The parties catered for such large numbers that &bquo;it made it virtually impossible to police these events and it gave drug users and drug pushers maximum protection from the police &mdash; and all of that was quite deliberate. 
 In organising these parties, you were targeting young people, among the most vulnerable in our society&equo;. 
 Police raiding the riverboat party had found cocaine, ecstacy tablets, amphetamines and cannabis resin. 
 Other drugs were thrown overboard. 
 Judges rule out jail for incest father. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 THE Court of Appeal yesterday quashed a suspended sentence received by a man convicted of indecent assault and incest with his 15-year-old daughter, despite submissions by the Attorney-General, Sir Patrick Mayhew, QC, that the sentence was too lenient. 
 The man, who pleaded guilty, received an 18-month suspended jail term at Truro crown court in July. 
 Rather than increasing the sentence, three appeal court judges substituted a three-year probation order requiring him to undergo treatment or counselling. 
 The case, referred under powers to challenge unduly lenient sentences introduced in February, is the first in which the Appeal Court has refused to substitute a stiffer sentence. 
 The court's decision signals its endorsement of Lord Justice Butler-Sloss's suggestion &mdash; made in the report into child abuse in Cleveland &mdash; that in some circumstances, abusers who admit their guilt and agree to treatment should escape prison. 
 Lord Lane, the Lord Chief Justice, said a bare recitation of the facts would seem to support the contention the sentence was too lenient. 
 The man had started indecently assaulting his daughter when she was 13, and progressed to intercourse shortly after her 15th birthday. 
 But Lord Lane said there were factors making the case wholly exceptional, and in all the circumstances the sentence could not be considered unduly lenient. 
 The trial judge's decision to suspend the sentence was taken in the interests of the victim and the family as a whole. 
 &bquo;Leniency is not in itself a vice,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;That mercy should season justice is a proposition as soundly based in law as it is in literature.&equo; 
 Lord Lane said there was a risk of the girl suffering further and perhaps more serious damage if her father went to prison, and of the family suffering hardship if he could work. 
 The girl, who was with foster parents, wanted her family re-united. 
 Her mother blamed her for what had happened, and the threatened break-up of the family. 
 There was a fear that a custodial sentence would hamper the counselling that social workers were giving the family. 
 There were also mitigating factors, Lord Lane said. 
 The man admitted the offences as soon as he was accused, and pleaded guilty. 
 A carpenter, he had a long record of hard work, and his family were dependent on his income. 
 It was also accepted that repetition of the offences was unlikely. 
 Lord Lane said that in its guidelines last July, the Appeal Court had fixed two to four years as the normal sentence for incest with girls aged 13-16. 
 However, circumstances varied infinitely, and sentencing should not involve &bquo;a rigid arithmetical approach.&equo; 
 Closed courts challenge fails. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 THE FIRST challenge under powers to appeal against judges' decisions to ban the press and public from court failed in the Appeal Court yesterday. 
 The Lord Chief Justice, Lord Lane, Mr Justice Macpherson, and Mr Justice Pill dismissed applications under the 1988 Criminal Justice Act by Mr Tim Crook, a freelance journalist, to reverse decisions by two Old Bailey judges to close their courts. 
 The National Council for Civil Liberties, which is backing Mr Crook's campaign for open justice, pledged to take the case to the European Commission of Human Rights. 
 Mr Crook called the decision &bquo;a very dangerous judgment which will only generate more secret justice and undermine the public's respect for the administration of justice.&equo; 
 He had asked the court for a ruling after Judge Robert Lymbery and Judge Kenneth Machin excluded the public from pre-trial hearings in September. 
 He accepted the point was now academic. 
 Lord Lane said it was clear the public could be excluded from court only if it was strictly necessary. 
 It was not sufficient that a public hearing would cause embarrassment to some or all of those involved. 
 He dismissed Mr Crook's argument that the judges should have made orders postponing publication until after the jury's verdict, instead of excluding the press and public. 
 Neither judge could be faulted for acting as he did, Lord Lane added. 
 In each case, the situation involved a procedural matter, not evidence in the trial. 
 They could not have known whether it would be prejudicial to the administration of justice if the facts were made public. 
 It was &bquo;wholly appropriate&equo; that information in these circumstances should in the first instance be given in the absence of the public. 
 Mr Crook's argument that the press should be allowed in court, even if the public was excluded, was rejected. 
 Officer &bquo;came close to disobeying Cossack order&equo;. 
 THE SON of a British Army officer yesterday described to the Aldington libel jury in the High Court how his late father told him of his &bquo;horror&equo; when he received the order to repatriate Cossacks at the end of the second world war. 
 Dr Francis Odling-Smee, a lecturer at Brunel University, Middlesex, said his father, when in his late 70s, told him he had never come closer to disobeying an order in his life. 
 Colonel Odling-Smee was the officer commanding the Fifth Buffs which were part of V Corps in southern Austria. 
 Dr Odling-Smee told the jury that in 1983 he read about his father's role in the repatriation of the Cossacks in Mr Nikolai Tolstoy's book Victims of Yalta. 
 After this they had conversations about it over three or four weekends, at his father's home in Devon. 
 &bquo;He had never been able to bring himself to talk about it before,&equo; he said. 
 His father told him he had never come closer to disobeying an order in his life, but he was finally persuaded to do so because it was pointed out to him that if the British Army did not send back the Cossacks, the Soviets would not send back British POWs. 
 &bquo;It was a kind of choice between saving his own and saving the Cossacks. 
 That's what it boiled down to.&equo; 
 The judge had earlier given leave for Dr Odling-Smee to be called to give evidence for the defence in Lord Aldington's libel action over allegations in a pamphlet that he is a war criminal responsible for the forced repatriation of 70,000 Cossacks and Yugoslavs who surrendered to the British in southern Austria in May 1945. 
 Mr Tolstoy, 54, who wrote the pamphlet, and Mr Nigel Watts, 51, who printed and distributed it, deny libel. 
 The hearing continues on Monday. 
 Water helps Tory HQ grow. 
 By Michael White 
 THE Conservative Party has doubled its headquarters' office space at a stroke by buying a lease from Thames Water next door. 
 But the five-figure sum paid for No 34 Smith Square, Westminster, will not reduce customers' water bills under privatisation rules laid down by the Government itself. 
 Though Tory Party chairman, Mr Kenneth Baker, announced the acquisition of the former London offices of Thames Water only yesterday, the soon-to-be-privatised company revealed the deal was struck before September 1 when new rules came into effect. 
 They provide that at least half the proceeds of surplus asset sales must go to reduce consumer bills and would affect the so-called &bquo;K-factor&equo; on which price rises are calculated. 
 The rules were imposed on privatised companies in the wake of political trouble over the lucrative sale of undervalued assets like British Aerospace's disposal of Royal Ordnance factories which had been in the public sector for centuries. 
 In this instance, Thames Water said the amount involved was &bquo;peanuts&equo; since the lease has fewer than 10 years to run &mdash; but the five-storey building is worth closer to &pound;99,000 than &pound;10,000. 
 Last night Conservative Central Office could provide no details on the lease it had bought, other than to say the freehold is owned by the Vauxhall Pension Fund. 
 Mr Baker plans to link numbers 32 and 34 Smith Square to provide conference and meetings facilities and room for staff housed outside Central Office. 
 The Prime Minister's press conferences have become increasingly crowded over the years in what has been dubbed The Blue Hole of Calcutta. 
 Police praised over bridge demo. 
 By Owen Bowcott 
 MOUNTED police were yesterday commended by the Police Complaints Authority for clearing student protesters from Westminster Bridge last November. 
 But the National Union of Students rejected the authority's report and called for an independent inquiry. 
 The clashes, on November 24 last year, followed marches organised by the National Union of Students in central London to protest against Government plans to replace maintenance grants with top-up loans. 
 At least 16 students were injured after mounted police cleared Westminster Bridge, the report says. 
 More than 90 officers were hurt by flying missiles. 
 About 4,000 students took part in the protest. 
 The report exonerates the NUS organisers and stewards who attempted to stop students crossing Westminster Bridge and approaching Parliament as prohibited by the Palace of Westminster's Sessional Order. 
 &bquo;The evidence of student organisers and the police is that among the marchers there were 2,000 or more members of militant groups who played a significant role in encouraging demonstrators to march towards Parliament and show aggression,&equo; the report says. 
 &bquo;The police have been criticised for acting prematurely. 
 In the authority's view that proposition is naive. 
 The police commander judged the cordon could not be relied upon to withstand the increasingly aggressive crowd. 
 The evidence of video films is that the police advanced at a trot and that at all times they were controlled. 
 No officer drew his baton. 
 &bquo;The decision to deploy horses and the way that they were used was perfectly proper. 
 We believe the police in general should be commended for the professional way they conducted themselves in the face of provocation.&equo; 
 Maeve Sherlock, the NUS president, said yesterday: &bquo;We are unhappy at the outcome of the PCA investigation and remain convinced there should have been a full independent inquiry. 
 We are pleased the NUS organisers have been exonerated. 
 The PCA may believe the use of horses was &bquo;perfectly proper&equo;. 
 We believe it endangered lives and should be condemned. 
 Those present from the NUS were unaware of any warnings given by the police prior to any charges. 
 &bquo;This result will not satisfy students, MPs, those injured, and the many arrested and subsequently acquitted.&equo; 
 The NUS is considering taking the matter further. 
 The investigation was carried out by Cambridgeshire Chief Constable, Mr Ian Kane. 
 Pressure mounts against government funding rethink of higher education Summit tries to rescue student loans plan. 
 By David Gow and Celia Weston 
 THE Prime Minister's senior advisers will meet this weekend to try to rescue the Government's student top-up loans scheme, as the clearing banks &mdash; which would run it on the Treasury's behalf &mdash; stiffen their opposition. 
 With only 10 days to finalise the proposals before they must be announced in the Queen's Speech, Mrs Thatcher's policy unit, chaired by her senior adviser, Professor Brian Griffiths, is also understood to be considering plans to make sharply increased tuition fees, rather than the block grant, the main means of distributing public money to higher education. 
 The fees would be paid direct to institutions on students' behalf by local education authorities. 
 However, the Treasury is known to be resisting this plan, because without a strict cash limit its control over public spending and manpower planning would be weakened. 
 This weekend's meeting is the latest in a series of conferences over the past two weeks during which ministers, their advisers, vice-chancellors, polytechnic directors and senior officials have been thrashing out strategies for expanding the higher education system. 
 Banking and Tory party sources say that ministerial proposals to charge students a proportion of their tuition fees and other more radical ideas have been abandoned in the face of tough Treasury opposition, the perceived weakening of Mrs Thatcher's position following Mr Nigel Lawson's resignation, and her declared intention not to serve a full fourth term if re-elected. 
 However, bigger special access funds to encourage poorer students, and a scholarship scheme for bright youngsters have not been ruled out. 
 The clearing banks, which are deeply sceptical about the commercial value to them of the loans scheme, have used the changed political climate to demand a higher price for their participation. 
 This is thought to include demanding a substantial fee for each transaction, indemnities against any change of government or government policy, and for the Government &mdash; not the banks &mdash; to be unequivocally identified as responsible for its introduction. 
 Labour has said it will scrap the system. 
 Legislation on the scheme is due to be unveiled in the Queen's Speech on November 21. 
 The scheme, to be introduced next autumn, would give every student an interest-free loan of up to &pound;420 a year, repayable over 10 or more years. 
 The policy unit will also discuss an alternative London School of Economics private sector scheme under which the financial institutions, rather than the Treasury, would lend students money, with repayments collected through National Insurance contributions. 
 This proposal has gathered significant support in recent weeks from higher education chiefs and Tory think-tanks such as the Centre for Policy Studies. 
 Conservative sources believe the Government's scheme will survive any backbench revolt in the Commons, but run into severe problems in the Lords. 
 However, they do not expect any radical revision to emerge in the run-up to legislation. 
 But one insider said yesterday that the banks could deal the scheme a mortal blow if they continued to up the price. 
 &bquo;There's a real chance that if the banks really push the price high, public spending becomes such that it would allow Mr John MacGregor, the education secretary, to reopen the whole argument.&equo; 
 In addition, vice-chancellors and students groups have warned the banks they would move their accounts to non-participating institutions. 
 Dr Nick Barr, senior lecturer in economics at the LSE and co-author of the alternative scheme, said: &bquo;It's very fragile, and there could be a repeat of the New Zealand situation where the banks simply changed their minds, refused to take part, and scuppered the scheme there.&equo; 
 Arsonist jailed for killing couple. 
 AMAN who hired two youths to firebomb his neighbours after they complained about his loud music was jailed for 12 years yesterday for manslaughter. 
 Mark Allen, aged 23, of Stockwell, south London, had been acquitted at the Old Bailey on Thursday of murdering Victor Johnson, 57, and his wife Audrey, 54, but convicted of manslaughter, incitement to arson and attempting to pervert the course of justice. 
 Mr Justice Jowitt told him: &bquo;You like to play your music regardless of your infliction of it on your neighbours. 
 They protested and you wanted rid of them so you decided to have their house set on fire. 
 &bquo;One of the appalling things is the way you joined your co-accused in your wickedness. 
 You obviously knew they were not the brightest of fellows.&equo; 
 The judge ordered that Paul Spencer, 17, and Alwyn Stephenson, 16, both of Stockwell, be detained for 4 &frac12; years. 
 They admitted manslaughter and gave evidence against Allen. 
 The judge told them: &bquo;You don't have to be bright to have a conscience.&equo; 
 He accepted they had thought the flat was empty and had been put under pressure by Allen to start the fire by squirting petrol through the letterbox. 
 Mr John Bevan, prosecuting, had said that the Johnsons had lived in the house for many years but feared fire and burglars. 
 They fitted smoke alarms to their home, put steel bars across the front door and screwed brackets across the fire escape which had disastrous consequences. 
 They died because security screens stopped firemen reaching their 17th floor flat quickly enough when the fire broke out in January. 
 Mr Bevan said Allen hired the two youths by promising them &pound;100 and giving them an extra &pound;10 to buy petrol. 
 Two days after the fire in which the Johnsons choked to death from fumes he held a party. 
 Dillons threat to book agreement. 
 By Andrew Culf 
 ALEADING chain of booksellers is about to launch a price-cutting war, which could spell an end to the trade's controversial Net Book Agreement. 
 The move by Dillons will not be officially announced until next week. 
 But it will deal a blow to the agreement, which allows publishers to set a minimum price for most books. 
 Last night other booksellers reacted with anger, saying it would damage small independent book shops and destroy a system which they believe had served the trade and book-buying public well. 
 Mr Terry Maher, chairman of Pentos, which owns Dillons, was yesterday unwilling to pre-empt the announcement. 
 But he said it &bquo;concerns a Christmas price promotion&equo; and would be seen as a &bquo;very important initiative&equo; in the book trade. 
 It is thought that the discounts could start next Saturday. 
 Dillons has more than 50 shops in the United Kingdom. 
 Mr Maher said he had received assurances from the Government that new legislation on increasing competition would apply to the book agreement. 
 His company was &bquo;simply giving a push in the same direction.&equo; 
 &bquo;Our mission at Dillons is to widen the market for books and break away from the elitism that has dominated the book trade and held back sales.&equo; 
 Pentos has about 6 per cent of the market, selling &pound;60 million worth of books a year. 
 W.H. Smith, which has a 20 per cent share of the market, said it would be watching Dillon's announcement carefully. 
 The group's chairman, Sir Simon Hornby, promised not to break the agreement first, but pledged a strong response if someone else did so. 
 He said that ending the agreement would jeopardise the future of small or family-run shops, lead to fewer books being published and increase prices of all but a few best sellers. 
 There was some scepticism at the Publishers Association about the likely extent of the breach. 
 A spokesman, Mr Ian Taylor, said Dillons may have struck a deal with one or more publishers to sell discounted books outside the NBA. 
 &bquo;If that happens it will be trumped up as the end of the NBA, but in fact it will only be a breach if Mr Maher discounts without the permission of the publisher,&equo; Mr Taylor added. 
 But he warned that, if discounting took place without publishers' permission, it would take out an injunction to prevent it. 
 Mr Tim Godfray, director of the Booksellers Association, said: &bquo;If you have a complete free-for-all, supermarkets will just cream off the top 30 bestsellers.&equo; 
 Mersey MP says he will force byelection if ousted by left Reselection tussle threatens Labour rift. 
 By Patrick Wintour Political Correspondent 
 THE Labour leadership is monitoring the imminent reselection procedure in Birkenhead, Merseyside, where Mr Frank Field, the independent-minded chairman of the Commons social services committee is under threat from a local leftwing trade union official. 
 Mr Field has said he will resign and cause a byelection if he is not reselected, a move which could divide the party nationally. 
 In the Commons Mr Field is widely regarded as one of the most thoughtful and persuasive MPs. 
 When he speaks on social issues MPs from all sides listen, but in Birkenhead, Labour left-wingers, including some former supporters, believe his free thinking has gone too far. 
 Few party members challenge his diligence as an MP, but they claim he has lost touch with the party and treats all critics as extremists. 
 Mr Field accepts there is tension between him and some Birkenhead activists about the role of an MP. 
 A supporter said yesterday: &bquo;What they want is to have somebody they can control,&equo; but Mr Field found it impossible to operate on that basis. 
 He has set himself the task of trying to discuss the agenda Labour needs to develop over the next two decades on issues such as training, education and poverty. 
 The ideas have come thick and fast &mdash; a basic tax at 12p in the pound with the abolition of all income tax allowances, a flexible school-leaving age between 14 and 18 so 14-year-olds would have the option of leaving for a job in which training is guaranteed, and the reintroduction of child tax allowances. 
 His chief challenger is Mr Paul Davies, a Transport and General Workers' Union district official. 
 Mr Davies has worked hard to affiliate 15 TGWU branches, and has written a pamphlet attacking Mr Field's views on social policy. 
 The reselection result will be announced on December 8. 
 Mr Field has acknowledged he might lose, but a good turn-out could save him. 
 If he is defeated and forces a byelection, the party would probably be obliged to expel him. 
 Mr Field believes he would win easily, and once returned to the Commons would ask the parliamentary party to give him back the Labour whip. 
 If he does cause a byelection, he will face the charge that he is not prepared to play by the rules laid down by the party conference. 
 &bquo;No one wants a byelection,&equo; said Mr Peter Roberts, the former local party chairman and a supporter of Mr Field. 
 &bquo;But if there is one the people of Birkenhead will support him.&equo; 
 Prince slips away as colony begins to accept destiny. 
 PRINCE Charles slipped out of Victoria Harbour on the royal yacht Britannia yesterday, watched only by office workers eating fast food lunches in the sunshine of Queen's Pier. 
 It was the end of his second, probably last, official visit. 
 For once, the optical illusion experienced by sailors leaving port seemed apt. 
 Not only was the boat moving away from land, but this 147-year-old colony is also beginning to move away from the Prince of Wales and the country he represents. 
 For the next couple of days, the Britannia will be anchored up the coast, where Prince Charles will work on a BBC film about the environment and talk to government radicals with whom it was considered impolitic for him to spend time during his official itinerary. 
 Among them will be Mr Martin Lee, expelled last week from the post-1997 Basic Law drafting committee because of Beijing's wrath over his joint leadership of the Hong Kong Alliance in Support of the Democratic Patriot Movement in China. 
 Last night political groupings which had been silent during the Prince's official visit resumed activity. 
 British Citizens for Hong Kong renewed its campaign for a last resort right-of-British abode for all. 
 At a separate gathering of councillors, a woman asked why Mrs Thatcher could not dismantle her Eastern equivalent of the Berlin Wall. 
 Mass reaction to the royals has been muted and distracted. 
 The Chinese author, Mr Han Suyin, described Hong Kong as &bquo;squeezed between giant antagonists crunching huge bones of contention.&equo; 
 The colony is now reluctantly but conclusively coming to accept its destiny under the nearer giant, China. 
 The royal couple's individual humanity, rather than their status, has made most impact; Charles's unflagging curiosity, reports of Diana shaking hands with a leper in Indonesia, her instinctive picking up of an old woman's dropped walking-stick. 
 Yesterday Charles visited a ginseng shop in the trading district of Nam Pak Hong. 
 He was shown a potion guaranteeing virility and many children, based on deer's horn. 
 &bquo;How does it work?,&equo; he asked for the sake of British tabloid papers. 
 He was cheered by 3,000 people, almost none of whom would qualify for abode or refuge under the current package. 
 That was one of the biggest crowds of a visit which has, at times, been discussed as a traffic nuisance. 
 Things would have kindled if they could have demonstrated, or if Prince Charles could have uttered a single sentence of political substance. 
 But neither course was considered prudent by Bejing and Downing Street. 
 Under the glitz, this is an ugly time in Hong Kong, with serious although scarcely reported unrest in the sealed-off boat people's detention centres throughout the week, and it could get worse. 
 Along the staircase of the Legislative Council building are old paintings of water buffalo and bamboo paddies. 
 The animals can now only be seen in the dwindling open fields of the new territories. 
 A woman at last night's councillors' gathering lamented that her nephew reached the age of three before seeing one. 
 The next few years look likely to take him closer to that kind of life, the life of his ancestors. 
 Governor to urge wide entry terms. 
 THE Governor of Hong Kong, Sir David Wilson, is likely to make a last-ditch attempt to influence the Government's package for giving the right of abode to the colony's British passport holders when he arrives in London on Tuesday. 
 He will also discuss plans for the mandatory repatriation of Vietnamese boat people. 
 The governor is to see the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, and the minister responsible for Hong Kong affairs, Mr Francis Maude. 
 Sources in Hong Kong say the British Government is finalising its package giving key Hong Kong people the right of settlement in Britain as a form of insurance in anticipation of the consequences of the Chinese takeover in 1997. 
 The Hong Kong Government has been trying to persuade Britain to make the package as wide as possible. 
 Sir David is likely to stress that proposals which are viewed in the colony as ungenerous would create difficulties for his administration's attempts to ensure a smooth transition to Chinese rule. 
 Sir David will be briefed about Mrs Thatcher's talks with President Bush concerning the mandatory repatriation of up to 44,000 Vietnamese boat people from Hong Kong. 
 The colony's preparations for the deportations are well advanced, but its government requires the go-ahead from London before it can send the first planeload to Vietnam. 
 The governor will probably be told to wait until later in the month, after a meeting organised by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees. 
 The Hong Kong Government has defended its decision to deny entry to two well known Chinese pro-democracy activists, Mr Chen Jun and Mr Wang Min, who were to take part in a seminar organised by students on the democracy movement in China. 
 Yesterday the Chief Secretary, Sir David Ford, denied that the colony had imposed a blanket ban on the entry of Chinese pro-democracy activists. 
 However, the government reserved the right to act within the law in respect of individual cases. 
 In a telephone interview with the government-run radio station, Mr Chen Jun claimed he had become a victim of political games between the Chinese and Hong Kong Governments. 
 There is little doubt that the colony's government is trying to improve relations with China, which have steadily deteriorated since the suppression of the democracy movement in June. 
 The ban on the Chinese dissidents appears to be part of this process. 
 Superplonk. 
 By Malcolm Gluck YOU CAN date your descent (or, if you prefer, ascent) into louche living from the moment champagne ceases to be merely sparkling wine of uniform effervescence and taste and becomes individual bottles of wine to be judged against others of like manufacture. 
 Your alloted space in purgatory is reserved the moment you decide, for whatever reason, that a bottle of excellent but inexpensive champagne (Safeway &pound;7.49) must make way for a grander counterpart like Bollinger &bquo;83 (Sainsbury's &pound;20.45) or, if the devil has really got to you, Dom Perignon &bquo;82 (&pound;44.99 at Tesco). 
 This latter is the most expensive champagne on any supermarket shelf. 
 It is not, of course, the only champagne at Tesco; this particular store has gone quite delightfully dotty this year and now has nearly 50 various champagnes from its own-label bottle (&pound;8.75) to the Dom Perignon. 
 I can, as yet, rate only the cheaper of these because I have yet to summon up the chutzpah to ask Tesco to send me all their other examples to sample. 
 I can only say that on the evidence of Tesco's cheapest, the rest will have a hard job keeping up. 
 It rates 15 points for its fullness and freshness. 
 Sainsbury's champagne at &pound;8.75 is also a fine example of decently mature fullness and ripeness yet freshness and fruit but scores a point more for greater elegance at no greater cost. 
 Even these unpretentious, non-vintage champagnes benefit from keeping for a time; the great champagnes repay keeping for years and years. 
 Sainsbury's own-label champagne I bought two years ago tastes even better now, developing greater fullness and depth of flavour without losing its keen edge or sparkling personality. 
 The very finest champagnes have a greater potential to age more interestingly since they start off with more. 
 One example my coal hole accommodated for nigh on ten years was a case of Krug I bought after a successful poker evening. 
 Marks &amp; Spencer and Waitrose both have champagnes which you could usefully treat in the same way if you have to cool dark hole to bung them in. 
 Each is, however, perfect for drinking now. 
 The M &amp; S example is a blanc de noirs. 
 It is well-balanced and full-nosed yet with a cleanness to tickle the most fastidious palate. 
 It costs &pound;9.99 and rates 16 points. 
 The Waitrose champagne is of the &bquo;83 vintage; it has a glorious style of its own, light yet biscuity, classy with the muted perfume of hollyhocks and it makes a superb apertif. 
 It whacks up a massive 17 points for all this. 
 It costs &pound;10.50. 
 At this sort of price, supermarket champagnes like that knock the famous marques with their absurd prices into every style of cocked hat you can imagine. 
 PAGE t18 
 Weekend special. 
 IT'S EARLY afternoon and the heat of the day hangs heavy in Rafiq's humble mud-floored shop. 
 On the walls, pictures of Mecca and General Zia mingle with gaudy Alpine scenes. 
 The only sound that breaks the afternoon stupor is the gentle pounding of the pastry roller as Rafiq lazily rolls out the hashish into six-inch strips for his local customers. 
 Stacked around the walls are sheepskins filled with hashish for the wholesale trade. 
 Rafiq says that storing hashish inside the skin of a freshly-slaughtered sheep is the only way to keep it from going stale. 
 He has about 200 kilos in his shop. 
 Rafiq sells mostly to Karachi businessmen who come to the village looking for wholesale quantities. 
 But he spends most of the day dreaming about getting just two kilos into London. 
 &bquo;I would be a rich man if I could. 
 Can you help me?&equo; he asks. 
 In the village of Dara, Rafiq is a legal businessman, one of 50 or so hashish traders operating side by side with the gun dealers. 
 His trademark is a sheepskin hanging outside the shop. 
 Pakistan and Afghanistan together produce something like 1,200 tons of hashish a year. 
 That's just an estimate &mdash; nobody really knows what the figure is because nobody bothers to calculate it. 
 The police say they haven't the time or resources to worry about hashish. 
 It is Pakistan's other export businesses &mdash; heroin and opium &mdash; which preoccupy them. 
 This is the opium-planting season for hundreds of thousands of farmers and peasants in north-west Pakistan and Afghanistan. 
 From here comes 80per cent of Britain's heroin and a quarter of the American supply. 
 (In the US, heroin is undergoing a resurgence in demand. 
 It is now mixed with crack to form &bquo;crank&equo;, which has a less devastating downside effect than unadulterated crack.) 
 Yet here in the Golden Crescent, as it is known, there are no Colombia-style confrontations. 
 Opium is grown and processed into heroin virtually unmolested by police or government. 
 For historical and political reasons, these border areas are among the most lawless regions in the world. 
 Trafficking is easy, lucrative &mdash; and thriving. 
 In Afghanistan the stalemate between the superpowers has ensured that no single authority rules. 
 In the opium areas the mujahedin fight the traffickers &mdash; and each other &mdash; for control of the business. 
 Much to the alarm of narcotics agents, cultivation is spreading as farmers seek cash to protect themselves from the hardships of war. 
 In Pakistan an old system dating from the British occupation has ensured that large parts of the North-West Frontier Province remain out of bounds to government officials. 
 The tribal areas retain their status &mdash; which means that to this day there is no law and no democracy. 
 In the last century the British deemed the wild mountainous regions of the Pashtuns too costly and too difficult to conquer. 
 British strategists decided the tribes were better left to themselves in &bquo;human nature reserves&equo;, to use the words of one military diarist of the time. 
 These regions, known as tribal agencies, are where Afghan and Pakistani opium is made into heroin, often in laboratories no bigger than the average bathroom. 
 However, no Pakistani official ever talks about the apparent hypocrisy of the government's claim to be fighting narcotics when it refuses to change the special status of these tribal areas. 
 Western drug enforcement agents are trying to persuade the Bhutto government to enter, but such a move threatens to spill the first blood of Benazir's fledgling democracy. 
 The pressure is discreet &mdash; after all, the survival of a key Western ally and a new democracy is at stake. 
 In Pakistan, political sensitivities take priority, for despite Prime Minister Bhutto's public commitment to a crusade against the drug barons, everybody knows that the new democracy is not strong enough to take them on. 
 Besides, eradication efforts in Pakistan have merely pushed the opium higher up in the hills and over the border into Afghanistan. 
 The Afghan crop is now four or five times that of Pakistan, and rising rapidly. 
 Estimates vary from 1,200 tons to 2,000 tons &mdash; few foreigners can enter, and satellite pictures cannot detect yield or winter crops. 
 The agricultural experts pushing crop substitution programmes may congratulate themselves on Pakistan's declining opium output, but the truth is that the country is now specialising more in processing and marketing. 
 Afghanistan's opium is cheaper and more plentiful. 
 Such is the abundance of heroin that prices are falling in Pakistan, with alarming implications for the West. 
 The changing role of Pakistan in the business has been devastating. 
 One million Pakistani heroin addicts consume 42 tons of the purest heroin a year. 
 In some villages on the drug route to the West, 5per cent of the population are addicts. 
 Then there is the effect of narco-politics. 
 Drug money has financed ministers and members of parliament and co-opted thousands of policemen and border guards. 
 Because both sides of the political divide are benefiting from the traffic, the issue is brushed under the carpet. 
 The tribal areas include some of the most wild and beautiful parts of Pakistan. 
 Rugged mountains, clear icy streams, and in springtime carpets of pink and blue opium poppies bending in the wind. 
 By the roadside stand the regimental outposts of British colonial history &mdash; the Khyber Rifles, the Baluchistan Scouts, the Frontier Corps. 
 In the Khyber agency bordering Afghanistan, there are Beau Geste-style forts belonging to the drug barons, all of them legally untouchable. 
 In the tribal agencies, government authority frequently ends a few feet from the road. 
 In Bajaur agency, the top opium and heroin producer in Pakistan, the government controls less than 36per cent of the district, leaving traffickers to go about their business peacefully and unimpeded. 
 This feels and looks like mafia-land, where men wear machine guns like jewellery. 
 In some towns there are more hashish and gun shops than grocery stores. 
 Just an hour from the capital, Peshawar, gun shops will sell you anything from a Chinese automatic machine gun to a rocket launcher. 
 There is no law, only Pakhtunwali, the code of the Pashtuns. 
 Fugitives from justice come here, kidnapped people are hidden here, and stolen cars are stored here before resale. 
 Some 7,000 wanted criminals live in the tribal areas, protected by a code of honour which requires a Pashtun to give protection to anyone who seeks it. 
 ASHINWARI or Afridi tribesman in Afghanistan grows the poppies and sends them by donkey or truck to his cousin a few miles away in Pakistan for processing. 
 For tribesmen and traffickers, there are no borders. 
 In the south, in Baluchistan, opium convoys are protected by rockets, guns and missiles &mdash; most of them supplied by the West to fight the holy jihad in Afghanistan. 
 So far, government efforts to eradicate poppy cultivation have been restricted largely to the &bquo;settled&equo; areas where government law exists, but actual control is minimal. 
 Even in the &bquo;settled&equo; areas, where the US and the United Nations Fund for Drug Abuse Control (UNFDAC) have been active, efforts to eradicate opium by crop substitution have run into trouble for one simple reason: in 30 years, no one has been able to come up with a product as lucrative and easy to market as opium. 
 The arithmetic is simple. 
 One acre of wheat equals &dollar;40, one acre of opium equals &dollar;400. 
 Such figures cause narcotics agents to wring their hands. 
 The North-West Frontier Province has only two businesses &mdash; guns and drugs &mdash; both of which Western pressure is now trying to curb. 
 One highly-paid aid official admitted: &bquo;We are forcing poor people at gunpoint to grow a crop which they know they cannot survive on. 
 How can that be right?&equo; 
 The last time foreign aid officials requested the Pakistan army to burn the fields, in 1985, the result was 13 dead. 
 In the Khyber agency, where 100 heroin labs are thought to operate, the mood is angry. 
 A tribal chieftain, Haji Ghulam, argues that with little or no government development, and rising unemployment, it is the right of tribals to grow opium and process it. 
 &bquo;Without heroin, there would be real hardship in this area.&equo; 
 Tribal members of parliament agree. 
 &bquo;All we have is dry hills. 
 No schools, hospitals, no work,&equo; says one. 
 All resent Western efforts to curtail the traffic. 
 A common response is: &bquo;You send us wine, why shouldn't we send you heroin?&equo; 
 Until now, efforts to stop the trade have depended on development programmes, but government reports readily concede that little has been achieved to create alternative employment. 
 Many farmers believe it is their right to have schools, hospitals and roads anyway, that such improvements are normal and unrelated to the way they make their living. 
 Until investment &mdash; private or state &mdash; can be lured to these remote poverty-striken areas, farmers will continue to view the government and its foreign advisors as aggressive forces who want to take away their only livelihood. 
 The Pakistan government is hampered by lack of resources in launching any large-scale projects, and in the last 13 years less than &dollar;120 million has been ploughed into crop substitution programmes by foreign aid organisations. 
 This year there are fears that, because of the prime minister's public commitment against narcotics, next spring will see a heavy toll in lives in the settled areas during the opium harvest season. 
 &bquo;Pakistan can no longer afford to continue this British romantic tradition of the tribal areas. 
 The threat to internal security, the judicial system, police and even its democracy is just too great,&equo; argues a US narcotics official. 
 &bquo;The very future of the country is at stake.&equo; 
 Officials in Pakistan recognise the validity of that argument, but the prospect of a military move on the tribal areas makes everyone's hair stand on end. 
 No government in the country's history has had the strength to make such a move and Benazir Bhutto's shaky administration can ill afford to rock the boat. 
 Even narcotics officials do not relish the idea of killing farmers. 
 Politically, the eight members of Parliament who represent the tribal areas are a key component to the PPP's Parliamentary coalition. 
 Ms Bhutto has only just survived a vote of no confidence by the opposition, when her slim and wavering majority was cut by half, partially because of the defection of four of the tribal members to opposition benches. 
 Any heavyhanded action by the frontier armed forces could place her remaining supporters in a sensitive position. 
 A move on the tribal areas could also unify the tribes against the Pakistan People's Party coalition government in the North-West Frontier Province. 
 The provincial coalition government is already shaky, with opposition members bought off with ministerial posts. 
 Any further strain and the provincial government could fall. 
 This would leave Ms Bhutto controlling only one of Pakistan's four provinces, and general elections would have to be held. 
 AMILITARY move could also risk a tribal war against government forces. 
 Police shudder at the prospect of facing a population which has anti-aircraft guns and rocket launchers at its disposal. 
 There are also foreign policy considerations, for the loyalty of the Pashtuns has proved flexible throughout history. 
 If any move is made by the army in the tribal areas, the result could be an alarm call to Kabul. 
 Khan Abdul Wali Khan, the most prominent Pashtun political leader, is known for his close ties with the Soviet-backed government in Afghanistan. 
 He also chairs the powerful Poppy Growers Association, which seeks to protect the interests of tribal people whose only living is opium and heroin. 
 Any move by the army in the region would only serve to strengthen Kabul's hand in the region and reinforce Wali Khan's position as an opposition leader. 
 In Baluchistan, the route for a major portion of Afghanistan's opium, the government is in the hands of the opposition. 
 The Bhutto government has little or no access and influence. 
 Federal interior minister Aitzaz Ahsan, whose portfolio includes narcotics control, believes that an armed intervention is not a panacea to end the traffic. 
 &bquo;We have to weigh the advantages and disadvantages of such an action, as well as our own interests. 
 We cannot rush into it.&equo; 
 The minister is confident that Pakistan could deflect Western pressure. 
 &bquo;We don't have to prove ourselves on our commitment to fight drugs,&equo; he says. 
 Ahsan claims that since coming to power the PPP has knocked out 12 of the 24 known heroin laboratories in Pakistan. 
 Narcotics agents believe a conservative estimate of the number of laboratories is between 200 and 300. 
 The most prolific refining and distribution areas is Ribat, which lies at the crossroads of three countries &mdash; Afghanistan, Pakistan and Iran. 
 Heroin labs are said by Afghans to be in the Chagool mountains, operated by fundamentalist mujahedin commanders belonging to the Hizbe Islami. 
 Just south, across the border, lies Gerdi Jangel, another major distribution and processing town. 
 Those few foreigners who have been there describe it as one of the most remote and desolate spots in the world. 
 These two heroin refining towns serve the most prolific of all the Afghan poppy areas, Helmund province, currently held by the mujahedin. 
 Traditionally the province has functioned as the country's breadbasket. 
 In the Seventies the US government initiated large farming projects to boost food production, but today those fields are growing mainly opium. 
 People who have seen the Helmund poppy fields speak of their beauty &mdash; mile after mile of even poppies, like the tulip fields of Holland. 
 Given the role of Helmund as a provider of food, the province is of key military importance. 
 Its mujahedin commander, Maulvi Nassim Akhundzadeh, is rated by drug enforcement experts as the &bquo;Mr Big&equo; of the Golden Crescent, responsible for at least one fifth of the country's narcotics traffic. 
 The fight to control the business has been deadly, as Akundzadeh has had continually fight off rival contenders. 
 Two weeks ago the battle spread to Gerdi Jangel in Pakistan, as his rivals attempted to bomb his processing network. 
 Akundzadeh has recently attempted to make political use of his opium business. 
 He is said by reliable sources to be negotiating with both the US and Iran for compensation to give up the business, playing one nation off against the other. 
 His current price is &dollar;2 million a month, funding for his own mujahedin forces, weapons, and a massive development programme for Helmund province. 
 Few foreign aid workers have dared to venture into Helmund province. 
 But in other poppy growing areas of Afghanistan such as Nangarhar and Badakhshan the first sounds of a debate on crop substitution projects have been heard. 
 Until now, foreign aid agencies have chosen to ignore the opium growing around them, or chosen to operate in areas where it is not cultivated. 
 The net result, say some officials, is that foreign money has frequently ended up fertilising or irrigating opium fields. 
 THE PACE of the debate has been forced by the UN's anti-drug organisation UNFDAC. 
 In the summer UNFDAC managed to secure agreement from aid agencies operating in mujahedin areas to agree to support an anti-poppy clause in all future aid projects. 
 The clause is relatively mild, requiring international agencies to commit themselves to support eradication efforts. 
 Aid agencies still fear that crop substitution projects will endanger the lives of their staff. 
 The experience to date has not been encouraging. 
 One leading international charity attempted a crop substitution project just across the border in Nangrahar province. 
 A few weeks after the first officials went into the remote poppy valley, the charity began receiving visits from Pakistani and Afghan tribesmen and landlords demanding large sums in &bquo;compensation&equo;. 
 Their visits were threatening and long, and eventually the agency gave up hope of substituting mulberry trees for opium. 
 Undeterred, the British charity Afghanaid is intending to try a crop substitution project in a nearby valley producing &dollar;50 million worth of opium a year. 
 Abdul Haq, a mujahedin commander, has recently been given the task of bringing peace and security in the areas liberated from government control. 
 He has the grand title of Head of the Gendarmes. 
 Fighting drug traffickers comes way down on his list of priorities. 
 First he has to create a neutral police force. 
 Then he has to seek agreement from all groups that the force can actually operate. 
 Before that can happen there has to be peace in Afghanistan, and that prospect looks as remote as the end to the drug traffic. 
 It would help, he says, if the United States cut military supplies to those commanders making money out of heroin. 
 But with Washington still committed to military victory in Afghanistan, cutting weapons supplies is a sensitive proposition. 
 Besides, aid workers argue that cutting any aid will only result in more poppies. 
 &bquo;We can try shaming them out of the drugs business and say how un-Islamic it is&equo; suggested Abdul Haq. 
 &bquo;But the problem about heroin is that the money is so good that even the good people do it&equo;. 
 Weekend Sport by Howard Donaldson: ATTITUDE: mental view or disposition, esp. 
 as it indicates opinion or allegiance. 
 (Collins). 
 Also a buzzword now, as in: &bquo;Man, you've gotta have attitude.&equo; 
 The original meaning, as defined by Collins, has certainly taken a mean whipping before re-release into this streetwise prose but we're talking the same thing here, aren't we? 
 In sport, attitude counts for everything. 
 Some have it, some don't &mdash; and it often makes the difference between success and failure. 
 May I submit that the Aussie cricketers of this year had it and our lot didn't. 
 These All Blacks have it. 
 Frank wishes he had a bit of Tyson's. 
 John McEnroe tried to take out a copyright on it, Becker's got more than a bit and Lendl's goes missing when he most needs it. 
 You get the drift. 
 Now I'm not saying Ian Rush missed the boat entirely, but he might find it pretty interesting when Gullitt and Van Basten discuss their life and work in Italy on Grandstand (BBC1, Saturday). 
 Rushie picked up a few lira and an Armani suit but it's probably fair to say our golden boy from St Asaph didn't exactly win the freedom of Turin. 
 Now these two Dutchmen have captured every Milanese heart and soul with their easy-going charm, their willingness to speak, eat and play Italian and have thrown in the odd spectacular goal or two too. 
 You get the impression Ruud and Marco could have taken their skills anywhere in the world, found success and made a few friends as well. 
 That's attitude. 
 Fergie would probably spend a few pounds on it &mdash; if he could find it. 
 Pallister, Ince, Wallace&hellip; lots of legs, a modicum of skill, but attitude? 
 I'll leave it to you. 
 Cloughie probably gets closest to it &mdash; not he himself but the No. 9 seems to have his head screwed on. 
 And he can play a bit, although he's missing the support of Webb these days. 
 Sheridan might have made a difference given the chance &mdash; but then we'll never know quite what sent the skilful midfielder packing to Sheffield Wednesday after hardly a sniff of the City Ground. 
 Any guesses? 
 No prizes. 
 Anyway, with the topsy-turvy results this season has thrown up, it's anybody's guess what we'll end up with after Man U v Forest has run its course on The Match on Sunday (ITV, 3.25pm). 
 PAGE t43 
 Jekyll by Hyde: Michael Hyde on the life of one of Britain's greatest gardeners, Gertrude Jekyll. 
 Living canvas by Bumps Gardening. 
 ACHINESE proverb has it that if you want to be happy for a week, get married; for a month, kill a pig; for a lifetime, plant a garden. 
 Though not piggishly chauvinistic enough to echo the first pronouncement, I heartily endorse the last. 
 And now that I am inclined to hear time's winged chariot hovering near, and see deserts of vast eternity not too far ahead, I am determined to make the most of my remaining years both in my secluded garden and on my open-space allotment. 
 Thanks to a very favourable, sometimes glorious, October, my 10-rod plot is now reasonably ship-shape &mdash; the grass paths trimmed for their winter sleep; the rubbish cleared; the gooseberry and currant bushes pruned; weeds cleared from overwintering onions, brassicas, and Swiss chard; and some digging done. 
 We oldies can find digging soothing and satisfying, even enjoyable &mdash; particularly if we take it in small doses and choose good weather and soil conditions. 
 We need to be well clad, of course, well shod, and equipped with spades of good balance to suit our size. 
 Thus occupied on this repetitive job, the mind is free to wander and daydream. 
 The other day, for instance, it was the portrait of Miss Jekyll, the lady gardener, that flashed before my inner eye. 
 She helped with the spadework in the early days of the Wisley garden, I had learned. 
 And then it was the charming picture of her Gardening Boots that I saw. 
 That picture I surmised, would look well if paired with Van Gogh's Chair. 
 Gertrude Jekyll (1843-1932) &mdash; G.J. for short and called Bumps by her friends &mdash; was fat, friendly and fearless. 
 Born of gentlefolk, she lived near Godalming in west Surrey. 
 As a child she roamed freely along the country lanes, knew the wild flowers by name and smell and the birds in dialect. 
 The green woodpecker was Yaffles, the wren Puggy, and the dragonflies skimming the pond Adder Spears. 
 She mixed with the villagers, admired their cottage gardens, learned their crafts, and made some of her own gardening tools at the blacksmith's forge. 
 And she appears to have been completely classless. 
 For instance, she helped by letter a Lancashire mill lad seeking advice on the use of his few square feet of soil (it seems to have been an attic window box in Rochdale) and followed this up with a postal package of plants, bulbs, and pebbles to complete his project. 
 Her ambition to be a painter was thwarted by acute shortness of sight which made her turn to gardening, &bquo;making pictures with living plants&equo; to use her own words; and she became famous for the gardens she created and the books she wrote. 
 Eminent Victorians and gardeners who visited her by now famous Munstead Wood home found her wearing two pairs of spectacles. 
 Far from moping about her painful and progessive myopia, she declared it to be an advantage because, having to peer so closely, she could detect objects that the well-sighted passed without noticing. 
 And her other senses were accentuated. 
 She could hear a hedgehog moving &bquo;noiselessly&equo; in the undergrowth, distinguish trees by the rustle of their leaves in the wind and the feel of their bark, and know of the nearness of flowers by their scents. 
 Lupins for her had a peppery smell, bracken a smell of the sea. 
 KNOWING this, I am stirred to re-educate my own neglected senses by moving about the allotment with eyes almost closed when no one is looking. 
 (Miss Jekyll used to jump five-bar gates when no one was looking.) 
 I can then learn by its tic-tic that the robin is at my feet, judge by smell that I have trodden on thyme or bumped into a rosemary bush, and tell by touch that the leaf in my hand is comfrey and not common dock. 
 Miss Jekyll's books are pleasantly readable and as uncluttered as their titles &mdash; Home and Garden; Wood and Garden; Children and Gardens; Old West Surrey&hellip; this last with 300 photographs to record early Victorian life in those parts. 
 Her articles too, written for magazines and journals (including the Guardian) are always readable and informative. 
 Some of these were reprinted in book form after her death &mdash; A Gardener's Testament, published by Country Life and Scribner, New York, in 1937. 
 Her books are still available in reference and some lending libraries, and there is a more recent biography, Miss Jekyll &mdash; Portrait of a Great Gardener, by Bessy Massingham, David and Charles, 1966. 
 The later years of her long and successful life were troubled, alas, by an excess of curious and unannounced visitors in addition to the genuine and eminent gardeners whom she welcomed. 
 &bquo;Many Americans, Germans and journalists,&equo; she noted sadly. 
 It would not be surprising if Japanese tourists now go in search of gardens she created, or of the grave into which her coffin was gently lowered by gardeners in 1932. 
 PAGE t25 
 A secret deep in the soil Oddjobbing. 
 By Hilary Applegate IF YOUR garden suffers from slow-draining surface water, slow plant growth or shallow rooting, it could pay dividends to find out whether a soil profile could provide you with a diagnosis. 
 This involves an area of about one square yard of currently uncultivated land, together with a sturdy spade and lots of energy, for you are seeking evidence of an impermeable layer, or hard pan, down below the ground. 
 You should dig a pit a yard deep; for comfort while digging, this will need to be about a square yard in area. 
 While excavating, take care to keep the different soil layers separate from each other, because each should be replaced at its original depth. 
 Having completed the pit, look for signs of compaction: vertical roots turning 90 degrees to the horizontal at a particular level, or a layer which just looks hard and compacted, or a wet, grey or blue band between one and six inches deep. 
 Such a pan usually arises at a depth of about six to ten inches, caused by digging (or more frequently rotovating) always to the same depth. 
 Repeated insertion of a fork to its full length is all that is needed to break up shallow pans. 
 Deeper hard pans require more drastic operations such as double digging; in established gardens you may prefer to delay the upheaval until each area affected is due for renewal and replanting. 
 PAGE t25 
 Chess. 
 By Leonard Barden THE EASY Soviet victory in this week's world team championship at Lucerne recalled the palmy days of the 1950s when the generation of Botvinnik and Smyslov, Bronstein and Keres, outclassed opponents. 
 The USSR won decisively against all their serious rivals, Yugoslavia, the US and England, in the first five rounds and only slackened at the end when the gold medals were assured. 
 It was an impressive performance with Kasparov and Yusopov absent and Karpov arriving late. 
 Russian chess has gained from glasnost. 
 Participation in the strong Western Europe and US opens has widened their pool of talent and brought closer contact with new ideas. 
 Final scores were USSR 27 &frac12; out of 36, Yugoslavia 22 &frac12;, England 21 &frac12;, Hungary 18 &frac12;, US and Switzerland 17, Cuba 16 &frac12;, China 15 &frac12;, Netherlands 12 &frac12;, Africa 11 &frac12;. 
 England recovered well from a slow start and their 3 &frac12;-&frac12; victory over the United States was their widest margin ever in matches between the two countries. 
 But in the final round England only drew 2-2 with China and Yugoslavia won the silver. 
 England have now won silver or bronze medals behind Russian gold five times out of five in the most recent world and Olympic team events, sufficient to establish Britain as world No. 2 chess nation. 
 There is still a basic problem which will not become any easier. 
 After the Dubai 1986 Olympics when England were unlucky not to win against a full-strength USSR, it seemed that gold would be there once the Russians had another off day. 
 But at Lucerne that happy event looked more distant than before, and meanwhile several of our grandmasters who have chased Soviet supremacy for a decade are now aged 30-35, a critical period for any Western professional. 
 It is difficult to improve further, younger rivals are appearing, contemporaries in other fields are in settled careers. 
 Nigel Short has realistic prospects of an individual world title match; Michael Adams may be the player of the 1990s, but for others our runner-up medals behind Soviet gold could trigger a motivation crisis. 
 GM Nigel Short (England &mdash; 
 GM Yasser Seirawan (US) 
 Modern Defence (Lucerne 1989) 
 1 e4&verbar;&verbar;d6&verbar;&verbar;2 d4&verbar;&verbar;g6&verbar;&verbar; 3 Be3&verbar;&verbar;Bg7&verbar;&verbar;4 NC3&verbar;&verbar;a6&verbar;&verbar; 5 h4&verbar;&verbar;Nf6&verbar;&verbar;6 f3&verbar;&verbar;b5&verbar;&verbar; 7 g4&verbar;&verbar;h5&verbar;&verbar;8 e5&verbar;&verbar;Nfd7&verbar;&verbar; Such a direct barnstorming attack against the strategic Modern Defence is rarely seen, and if successful threatens the viability of the opening. 
 Black has to consider 4.. c6 instead of a6, even 2.. 
 Nf6 instead of g6. 
 9 gxh5&verbar;&verbar;Rxh5&verbar;&verbar;10 e6! &verbar;&verbar;fxe6&verbar;&verbar; Black now becomes very passive &mdash; maybe 10.. 
 Nf8!? 
 11 Bd3&verbar;&verbar;Nf8&verbar;&verbar;12 f4&verbar;&verbar;Rh8&verbar;&verbar; 13 Qg4&verbar;&verbar;Bb7&verbar;&verbar;14 Rh3&verbar;&verbar;Bf6&verbar;&verbar; 15 0-0-0&verbar;&verbar;b4&verbar;&verbar;16 Ne4&verbar;&verbar;Bd5&verbar;&verbar; 17 Nf3&verbar;&verbar;Nc6&verbar;&verbar;18 Ne5! &verbar;&verbar;dxe5&verbar;&verbar; An attractive sacrifice, based on the BK's lack of flight squares. 
 19 fxe5&verbar;&verbar;Bxe5&verbar;&verbar;&verbar;&verbar;&verbar;&verbar; Or Bg7 20 Nc5 Kf7 21 h5 and the attack should win. 
 20 Nc5! &verbar;&verbar;Qc8&verbar;&verbar;21 Bxg6+&verbar;&verbar;Kd8&verbar;&verbar; 22 dxe5&verbar;&verbar;Nxe5&verbar;&verbar;23 Nxe6+&verbar;&verbar;Qxe6&verbar;&verbar; 24 Qxe6&verbar;&verbar;Nxe6&verbar;&verbar;25 Rxd5+&verbar;&verbar;Nd7&verbar;&verbar; 26 Bf5&verbar;&verbar;Nf8&verbar;&verbar;27 Bg5&verbar;&verbar;c6&verbar;&verbar; 28 Rd1&verbar;&verbar;Ke8&verbar;&verbar;29 Re3&verbar;&verbar;e5&verbar;&verbar; Black has survived with level material, but his king remains terribly exposed to White's rampaging rooks and bishops. 
 30 Rd6&verbar;&verbar;c5&verbar;&verbar;31 Rf3&verbar;&verbar;Ra7&verbar;&verbar; 32 Re6+&verbar;&verbar;Kf7&verbar;&verbar;33 Re7+&verbar;&verbar;Kg8&verbar;&verbar; 34 Rg3&verbar;&verbar;Resigns Mate by Bh6+ can be delayed only at ruinous cost. 
 One of Short's most brilliant games. 
 Problem No. 20884 
 Black (15 men) 
 Take in board 
 White (14 men) 
 I. Sokolov (Yugoslavia) v. V. Tseshchovsky (USSR), Wijk 1989. 
 Black (to move) has sacrificed a bishop for two pawns, and to some effect. 
 The white army is in scattered retreat from the incursion of Black's queen and knights. 
 How can Black force a win? 
 No. 2087: WK at d3, Q at a8, Rs at c5 and e5, Ps at a5, b3, d5, f2 and h6. 
 BK at d1, R at d6, P at a6. 
 Mate in three. 
 1 Qh8 (threat 2 Rc1+ Kxc1 3 Re1) Rc6 2 Qe3 (threat 3 Re1) Re6 3 Qh5. 
 If Re6 2 Qc8 Rc6 3 Qg4. 
 If Rf6 2 Re3 and 3 Qa1. 
 If Rxd5+ 2 Rcxd5 Kc1 3 Re1. 
 Eating in. 
 By Richard Ehrlich LIKE MOST parents of young children, I regularly face the dilemma of what to do with leftovers. 
 There are two sensible solutions to the problem. 
 One is to wrap them in clingfilm and put them in the fridge until the next meal. 
 The other is to throw them away. 
 I usually steer a middle course which avoids both waste and effort. 
 I eat the leftovers myself. 
 Recently however, something extraordinary happened. 
 Our older daughter Rebecca had left an unlikely farrago of peas, cottage cheese, baked beans and pasta in a tomato sauce. 
 I scoffed it down and found to my astonishment that it was delicious. 
 The incident set me thinking. 
 Did that commingling of unrelated flavours remind me of another dish, or had it produced a breakthrough in gastronomy? 
 A quick flip through my cookery books turned up some Italian and Middle Eastern dishes that bore a passing resemblance to what had happened on Rebecca's plate. 
 But nothing matched it precisely. 
 Thus does one get an idea for a new dish. 
 After a few experiments, I came up with a reasonable facsimile of Rebecca's accidental assemblage. 
 Cannelini beans replaced tinned and a bechamel mixed with Pecorino Romano from Lina Stores, Brewer Street, London W1, stood in for the cottage cheese, It was every bit as good as the original, if somewhat more sophisticated. 
 Now the question arises: have my taste-buds been ruined by the muck I've plucked from the mouths of babes? 
 See what you think. 
 The dish doesn't look like much, so it's for family meals rather than dinner parties. 
 But it's easy and cheap. 
 What's more, Rebecca ate every mouthful of leftovers and that's high praise indeed. 
 I look forward to receiving further cooking lessons from her. 
 Fusilli al Forno alla Rebecca 6 ounces cannelini beans 12 ounces fusilli 8 ounces frozen peas 500ml good tomato sauce 500ml thinnish bechamel 3 ounces Pecorino or mature cheddar, grated Soak the beans and cook them in water or chicken stock until just soft; drain them and heat gently in the tomato sauce, Preheat the oven to 400 (gas mark 6) and butter a shallow casserole or gratin dish. 
 Cook the peas and the pasta in the usual way. 
 Pour the pasta into the baking dish and scatter the peas on top, then mix the bean mixture with two ounces of the cheese and spread it over the peas. 
 Ladle on the bechamel, sprinkle the remaining cheese on top, and bake in the oven for 30 minutes or so, until piping hot. 
 If the top isn't browned, finish the dish under the grill and serve immediately with a green salad. 
 FORGET the million dollar man. 
 These are the million dollar models. 
 Only just out of their teens, they can &mdash; and do &mdash; earn millions of dollars a year, mostly with exclusive contracts to international cosmetic and fashion houses. 
 In New York this week they strutted the catwalks for major American designers like Calvin Klein, Ralph Lauren and Donna Karan. 
 This is the final leg of the fashion industry's month-long show of clothes, previewing what will be in shops next spring. 
 The experts claim it's not a vintage year, so the spotlight has shone firmly on the models. 
 Speculation on their colourful lives and enormous bank balances have provided much needed excitement in a sea of bland, beige tailoring. 
 Paulina Porizkova &mdash; a Czech who emigrated to the United States &mdash; is the biggest earner. 
 Her contract with with cosmetic company Estee Lauder is worth a total of &dollar;6million. 
 Like many mega-models, she's not content with just posing for pictures. 
 She's already made two films, one starring Tom &bquo;Magnum&equo; Selleck. 
 And &mdash; fulfilling another model cliche &mdash; she has a rock star boyfriend, Ric Ocasek of seventies pop group The Cars. 
 Linda Evangelista is, for the real fashion fiend, The Model of 1989. 
 Her unconventional face, with slightly hooked nose, has graced nearly every magazine cover. 
 The drastic boyish crop &mdash; first thought a disaster &mdash; is now a trend in itself, and Evangelista earns around &dollar;10,000 a day. 
 Christy Turlington, discovered as a Californian teenager, was signed to an exclusive contract for Calvin Klein's perfume, Eternity. 
 Reportedly worth &dollar;3million, it meant Turlington could only be photographed in Klein's clothes. 
 But over the past month she has graced the catwalks in Milan, London, Paris and New York, wearing the work of dozens of different designers, and fuelling rumours of a rift between her and Klein. 
 When the rates of pay are this high, the fighting can get very dirty indeed. 
 Turlington is one of two models being sued for &dollar;11million, over their switch to another agency. 
 As they say, it gets tough at the top. 
 PAGE f3 
 Sweeping the board by book or by rook The Polgar sisters, who this weekend are competing at the Barbican, are the most remarkable phenomenon in the history of chess. 
 They have rewritten the record books, stormed the male bastion of Grandmaster chess, and defied the laws of probability. 
 How can a family produce three geniuses?. 
 Peter Lennon went to Budapest to find out. 
 WHEN Laszlo Polgar, a Hungarian vocational school teacher, married his Ukrainian wife, Klara, in 1965 he carefully studied a number of books on &bquo;fathering&equo;. 
 Stepson of a rabbi and product of a broken home, Laszlo was brought up in an orphanage, and it is clear that from a very early age this intense, obstinate man sought not only to bring order to his own life but to control to an unprecedented degree the environment of his future family. 
 The result was the greatest phenomenon in the history of chess: three sisters, Zsuzsa, Zsofia and Judit Polgar, all of whom have achieved Grandmaster results in their teens. 
 Zsuzsa, who had been playing chess since the age of four, won her Master title in 1982 at the age of 13 (Karpov did not reach that standard until 15); she was an International Master at 18. 
 The two other Polgar girls were, by then, already astonishing the world. 
 Zsofia achieved International Master and Grandmaster results in l988, aged 14. 
 But it is Judit to whom the chess world most readily gives the title of genius: last year, aged 13, she achieved a Grandmaster norm and became the world's top-ranking woman player. 
 This beats even the great Bobby Fischer by a wide margin. 
 The mathematical probability of any family producing a chess Grandmaster was thought to be relatively low; the mathematical probability of producing three in a row goes off the chart. 
 A good chess player can be a bad contestant, but all three Polgar sisters are superb contestants. 
 Their stamina is remarkable. 
 In 1986 all three girls took part in a 24-hour chess marathon in Dresden. 
 The rules demanded that a hundred games had to be played within 24 hours; there was no time for sleep and only 20- minute breaks were allowed for snacks. 
 Moreover, they were playing after a 16-hour train journey. 
 The tournament was won by Zsuzsa, and the two younger girls also finished in the leading group. 
 Judit performed even better in the second half than the first. 
 The astounding point about the Polgar phenomenon is that Laszlo Polgar planned such results before the children were born. 
 The story of the Polgars is therefore much more one of educational techniques, a unique and deliberate experiment in environmental conditioning, than it is of chess. 
 Until recently, public interest in the West has centred largely on the performances of the girls, as it would in any competitive sport. 
 But now questions are being asked about the conditions in which the girls have been obliged to live to produce such results. 
 For years Polgar was the object of intense hostility from the Hungarian public because of his unorthodox and highly suspect educational methods. 
 Defying the authorities, he never allowed his children to go to school. 
 He, his ex-teacher wife and chess coaches provided their education at home. 
 The President of the Hungarian Chess Federation, Sandor Szerenyi (also a former Party Secretary) called him &bquo;a scoundrel and an anarchist.&equo; 
 Another of Polgar's battles is his refusal to allow his girls to play in women's tournaments, with the exception of the Olympics, where Zsuzsa triumphed. 
 To challenge male players they are obliged to play in teams. 
 Tomorrow and on Monday the Polgar sisters will be at the Barbican competing in an exhibition &bquo;rapid&equo; (all moves have to be completed within 30 minutes) against three of England's leading young male players, Michael Adams, David Norwood and Stuart Conquest. 
 The question many ask is: has Polgar turned his children into robots and marionettes? 
 THE POLGARS live on the eighth floor of a block of flats on Semmelweis Street, a workers' area in Budapest. 
 You walk along a narrow balcony over- looking a courtyard, much in the style of a British council estate, although in good repair. 
 With their recently acquired wealth from the girls' success, the Polgars have been able to buy an adjoining apartment to make one multi-roomed home. 
 The main rooms are box style and low-ceilinged, giving on to alcove-like bedrooms. 
 Judit's cassette-filled bedroom is no bigger than a standard bathroom. 
 The original apartment leads into an open-plan affair of bright yellow and red cut-price, Habitat-style furnishings and tubular partitions. 
 This is all a huge improvement on 10 years ago when the children practised their chess in a two-roomed flat with one wall reeking with damp. 
 Copiously furnished with crammed bookcases, shelves stacked with cassettes and 19th century lithographs tastefully dispersed across the walls, it seems at first glance to be a richly cultured environment. 
 But it is soon revealed to have a peculiar character. 
 Every single book is about chess; every cassette features chess games; most of the ornaments are chess trophies; even the framed prints depict chess scenes. 
 Occasional tables bear computer chess sets. 
 There is an encyclopaedia, but it is an encyclopaedia of endgames. 
 A card index of chess openings covers an entire wall from floor to ceiling; there is a computerised data bank of opening variations and middle game types. 
 There is a name index used to prepare against certain adversaries. 
 The entire home is a shrine to chess. 
 The only apparent relief from chess were two dolls and a golliwog on Judit's bunk bed. 
 Laszlo Polgar, who is 43, is a small, stocky man with a biblical beard. 
 At first his manner is reserved and defensive; there is an attitude that suggests he expects rebuke and is ready to fight. 
 Throughout there was a joyless kind of determination never to be proved wrong. 
 We spoke through an interpreter. 
 He produced the unpublished manuscript of a book he has written about his experiment, which he had just had translated into English. 
 From the outset it becomes apparent that the achievements in chess are incidental to Laszlo Polgar's obsessive theories of &bquo;genius rearing&equo;. 
 Chess was simply the most convenient route for demonstrating those theories. 
 Its attraction was that it has the advantage of any competitive sport, that measurable results can be easily obtained. 
 The cold-bloodedness of this experiment becomes apparent when we discover that chess was not one of Polgar's great interests; even now he is only a mediocre player. 
 So this was not the equivalent of a father wanting to pass on the passionate love of his hobby to his children. 
 Polgar told me that in the early days of his marriage he examined the childhood of many famous persons and saw that geniuses all specialised in a field very early. 
 He read that Yehudi Menuhin's father gave up his career as a teacher so that the family could live together and organise Yehudi's concerts. 
 Polgar resolved to do the same, although for years it resulted in severe poverty. 
 His wife, Klara, declared: &bquo;When I first met Laci &lsqb;Laszlo&rsqb; in 1965, I just listened and listened. 
 Sometimes I had the feeling that he was a man of fantasies, that it would be too much to believe even half of them. 
 Now it is Laci who initiates the great ideas, but I am always part of the realisation. 
 The thread follows the needle. 
 I am the thread.&equo; 
 Klara is a plump, good- natured woman who shares the duties of travelling with the girls and enjoying their endless tourist trips, although friends doubt if she has yet learned the moves in chess. 
 A school teacher, she speaks half a dozen languages moderately well. 
 She also gave up her profession to educate the girls. 
 There is no visible sign of rancour at the curious lifestyle imposed on her; she appears placidly resigned to her fate. 
 But she told me she would have been perfectly content if they had not taken this course. 
 Polgar met Klara in the traditional Jewish way. 
 His mother came home one day and said: &bquo;I have met a very nice young lady teacher. 
 Why don't you get acquainted with that nice lady teacher!&equo; 
 The influence in the home is very orthodox Jewish. 
 Laszlo once wanted to be a rabbi. 
 He said: &bquo;The Jewish religion prescribes for parents to teach their children from an early age. 
 The Talmud provides that the Jewish parents must be the first teachers.&equo; 
 Polgar is a Jew in a country with a foul history of anti- semitism. 
 The Hungarians deported 600,000 Jews during the war. 
 He attributes some of his difficulties with the Communist Establishment to anti-semitism. 
 Polgar is against conventional schooling, he says, because &bquo;it did not make learning a beloved activity.&equo; 
 Although he still speaks bitterly of the pressure put on him by the authorities, in fact they never succeeded in obliging him to send the children to school; he was not even fined as he would have been in Britain. 
 The children sit for normal exams at the local school and have so far maintained a necessary standard. 
 IN HIS unorthodox pilgrimage there has been more than a normal share of ill-will, resentment and litigation. 
 Polgar has sued four Hungarian newspapers and the national radio for real or imagined persecution. 
 Polgar's approach to teaching is, he says, that &bquo;the pleasure of the accomplishment must be several times as much as the experience of failure.&equo; 
 He claims to reject blind discipline. 
 &bquo;I achieve discipline&equo;, he says, &bquo;by kindling interest in, and love for, the subject. 
 I believe that early childhood is not at all early in respect of learning, not even of specialisation. 
 &bquo;In my opinion the period from three to six is the most important and should be utilised much better than it is today. 
 Children like to solve problems. 
 The richer the content of the problem solved the happier the child. 
 Learning was a greater pleasure for my children than sterile play for play's sake.&equo; 
 He accepts that his children play less than other children, but considers this is normal for children of high ability who demand more absorbing tasks. 
 He had thought of experimenting with three different subjects &mdash; maths, foreign languages and chess &mdash; but his financial circumstances in those days did not make it possible. 
 The three children would have needed three different teacher-trainers. 
 &bquo;True psychologists do not recommend siblings competing directly because they could become jealous and envious, and might even come to hate each other,&equo; says Polgar. 
 &bquo;This, however, cannot take place if they are brought up properly.&equo; 
 Mrs Polgar had offered some refreshments; saucissons, gherkins, and bread and coffee. 
 At the end of the collation the objects of this relentless pedagogical experiment were suddenly in the drawing room. 
 Polgar rations their appearances in a natural wish to protect them from the media. 
 They stood there in the room together, but at an angle to each other, half-smiling, the classical demeanour of shy youth being introduced to a stranger in their home. 
 Zsuzsa, the eldest, is effortlessly fluent in English; although her words are outgoing there is a certain watchfulness in her manner. 
 Her chess, too, is said to be more positional. 
 Zsofia, 15, has the air of a girl experimenting happily with young womanhood, enjoying her own attractiveness. 
 When I remarked that Karl Marx is reputed to have said: &bquo;Chess has one great quality &mdash; it teaches you to play chess,&equo; Zsofia laughed merrily. 
 But her father, in whom a sense of humour is not a very apparent virtue, remained reserved. 
 Judit, at 13 tall for her age, with russet hair, has that capacity of early teenage of one minute seeming like a woman and the next like a small child. 
 She has a tendency to hug herself tightly when grappling with a question, and at one point, when I asked her how she saw herself in the future, grown up and faced with decisions about her own children, she panicked for an instant and had to be consoled by the female interpreter. 
 I asked her if she did not feel deprived, having never experienced school life. 
 She told the interpreter that &bquo;although she had never been to school she liked the life she lived.&equo; 
 Hungarian chess players say that Judit is the most aggressive and inspirational of the three, and the most like her father, with a will of iron. 
 The girls admitted they did not go to discos, but said they had friends. 
 Zsuzsa swims with a friend at 7 every morning. 
 They all play ping-pong; Zsofia has reached competition standards. 
 The girls give the impression of children of a particularly sheltered family. 
 Polite, friendly, neither intense nor passionate in their responses, they do not appear to have strong opinions either about chess or about their own future. 
 They would just like to keep on playing, they claim, and if they have children they would probably use educational methods similar to their father's. 
 But it was clear that they had not given the subject much thought, nor did they feel there was any need to. 
 They have seen a lot of world now &mdash; Rome, London, New York and Paris &mdash; and like most girls of their age are not yet discontented with this necessarily tourist oriented relationship with the outside world. 
 If the girls do not appear to have an even average awareness of culture &mdash; a friend said that a couple of years ago Zsuzsa had never heard of 
 Beethoven's Fifth Symphony &mdash; neither do they appear to be in any way neurotic. 
 I asked Zsuzsa if she had a boy-friend. 
 She was very hesitant in her response. 
 &bquo;She is not sure,&equo; said her mother. 
 After a short while they retired to the back room and sat in a kind of play-pen atmosphere analysing Judit's most recent game with a young American visitor. 
 The Polgars are still a united and, in a quite humane way, isolated family. 
 The intransigence of the Communist 
 Government in not allowing them passports until 1985 might have protected the children at a crucial time in their development. 
 What will happen when other individuals lay claim to the girls' affection and loyalty is another question. 
 Polgar claimed that nothing would change; when the girls married, their husbands would become part of an extended family. 
 &bquo;He won't divide up the chess books,&equo; Mrs Polgar said. 
 &bquo;So they will always come back.&equo; 
 Has Laszlo Polgar really created geniuses? 
 It is possible he has unwittingly done something more subversive: totally demystified chess. 
 He has demonstrated that any obedient, healthy child, fed on an almost exclusive diet of chess, can become a Grandmaster. 
 Laszlo Polgar&hellip; he has constructed a shrine to chess and a laboratory for his obsessive theories of genius rearing PHOTOGRAPHS: TAMAS REVESZ Judit&hellip; inspirational Zsofia&hellip; experimenting Zsuzsa&hellip; watchful 
 Endpiece. 
 By Roy Hattersley 
 THE CATHEDRAL at Lyon stands back from the bank of the Saone, and, from the other side of the river, is half hidden by bland blocks of flats. 
 Even the two towers, which peer over the roofs that block their view, are camouflaged by scaffolding. 
 Walking across the Bonaparte Bridge, I looked in vain for what was marked by a giant cross on the tourist map. 
 But I looked for only a moment. 
 Then, my eyes were lifted up to the hill which overshadows the old city. 
 On its highest point is built another church. 
 It is a contender for the title of the Worst Building in the World. 
 From the bridge the church looked no worse than bizarre &mdash; a giant Christmas cake which, having risen too high in the oven, has been covered in over-decorated icing in order to obscure its deformity. 
 What seem to be four candlesticks &mdash; designed in the same sugary style &mdash; stand guard around it and a fifth, a little distance from the main confectionary, is crowned with a gilded figure. 
 Despite its pagan appearance the figure was put there in an act of Christian piety. 
 The thing on the hill is the basilica of Notre Dame, Fourviere. 
 Like Sacre Coeur in Paris, Notre Dame, Fourviere was built to commemorate the end of the Franco-Prussian war &mdash; a conflict in which France was conclusively defeated. 
 It would be easy to believe that both churches were imposed on the French as a punishment. 
 But, according to the guide book, Notre Dame was regarded by contemporary opinion as a masterpiece of 19th-century gothic architecture. 
 It took 20 years to build. 
 And anyone who is brave enough to venture inside will realise how the time was spent. 
 For Notre Dame, Fourviere is Sacre Coeur's vulgar sister &mdash; the member of the family who uses the most make-up and wears the gaudiest clothes. 
 In south Yorkshire during the forties, we were particularly disapproving of the sort of woman who &bquo;puts on every bit of cheap jewellery that she's got&equo;. 
 That woman is the real patron saint of Notre Dame, Fourviere. 
 It is for that reason that I include it on the shortlist for the Worst Building in the World title. 
 Far more wicked deeds are done under less decorated roofs and there is much greater misery behind less colourful windows. 
 I regularly see huge grey towers of concrete and steel which brutalise the landscape and recent ruins which have been shoddily built have slipped into early dereliction. 
 But I have never witnessed anything so triumphantly awful as Notre Dame, Fourviere. 
 It is appalling with malice aforethought. 
 A hundred years ago an architect took pride in designing every ghastly detail. 
 Consider the psychological condition of the man who conceived the pillars. 
 At ground level there are haloed birds with spread wings. 
 The columns which they carry on their backs have more fluting than a respectable column would accept and the Corinthian capitals have swirls and squiggles that would have been prohibited in Corinth. 
 But that is only the beginning. 
 More birds &mdash; wings folded, but halos identical to their restless kin below &mdash; perch upon them. 
 And standing on the resting birds are massive caryatids &mdash; each one as grim and unsmiling as might be expected of a lady who is balancing an arch on her head. 
 The pillars are no exception to the general style. 
 Mosaic pictures cover every inch of wall. 
 At the Council of Ephesus the Virgin is pronounced divine by priests with square Byzantine beards. 
 Louis proves himself to be saint as well as king. 
 Pio Nono insecure in a litter, above the crowd in St Peter's Square announces the Bodily Assumption. 
 Don John of Austria wins the battle of Lepanto with a bravura which far exceeds the brio described in G.K. Chesterton's poem. 
 It was the altar &mdash; stuffed with as much clutter as a belle epoque boudoir &mdash; that really made me think. 
 I was not worried by the griffins and sphinxes, though it is a strange church that features pagan allegories beyond its sanctuary steps. 
 It was the usual lamp, burning away to remind celebrants and sightseers that He is always here that perturbed me. 
 Could He, I wondered, possibly feel at home amongst all that ostentation. 
 The theological answer is that He feels at home anywhere because He is at home everywhere. 
 But another important question is less easily answered. 
 What sort of men (women, I suspect, having nothing to do with it) sought to worship God with such a display of blatant vulgarity? 
 And what sort of God did they believe was best worshipped in a basilica that leaves no lily ungilded? 
 Clearly they thought that Solomon in all his glory looked far better than anything which was likely to be found growing in a field. 
 Solomon spent money on his appearance and, to them, spending money was proof that a subject was being taken seriously. 
 I can hear them telling the architect not to spare a single sou. 
 Order the terrazzo by the square metre. 
 Buy whole treefuls of gold leaf. 
 Give every lion wings and make every caryatid an Amazon capable of carrying the whole world on her skull. 
 Nothing is too good (that is to say, too expensive) for God. 
 I hope that God does not look at life in quite that way. 
 If I am right, Notre Dame is really a temple to Mammon. 
 When in early Christian Rome they converted pagan temples into churches, they removed all the symbols of the old religion which could be torn out without endangering the structure. 
 It will be a hard task to perform in Notre Dame, Fourviere. 
 But the good people of Lyon should try. 
 La Manga golf clinic. 
 THERE WERE eight of us who had voluntarily submitted ourselves for treatment at the clinic: two lawyers, two Italian businessmen, two bankers, a fashion designer and me. 
 We were all in need of help. 
 With some it was the hands. 
 With some the feet. 
 With some the shoulders. 
 We were all, it is fair to say, hypochondriacs. 
 Most golfers are. 
 There is some bit of their game that is always sick. 
 There is always some magic remedy that will cure it, or some whizz-kid quack with a patent method. 
 And Vincente Ballesteros has a reputation as one of the finest surgeons in the business. 
 You may have heard of his kid brother. 
 They started off together hitting stones around the beaches of northern Spain with old sticks. 
 The kid brother went on to make a moderate fortune doing the same with golf balls and golf clubs. 
 Vincente caddied for him for a while but it was an awkward role for a big brother. 
 So Vincente ended up teaching most of the year at La Manga, a complex of world-class golf courses, villas and hotels on the Costa Blanca. 
 So it was that the eight of us ended up, kit gleaming in the spring sunshine, awaiting the arrival of the man who would diagnose our ills, administer a local anaesthetic and set us on the road to perfect health. 
 Between us we had even hired a video so that we could record this minor miracle of medical history for posterity. 
 None of us had reckoned on open-heart surgery. 
 None of us had predicted that the videos would end up like director David Cronenberg nasties. 
 None of us had foretold that our games would end up on life-support systems in intensive care. 
 BUT this is rushing ahead. 
 Vincente seemed a pleasant enough bloke when he turned up on that first morning. 
 He spoke in a pleasing linguistic mixture that seemed to acknowledge no boundaries between Spanish and English. 
 One soon picked up the basics. 
 There was el grip, el backthwing, el bunkershot, el drive and el putt. 
 Or, in my case, el airshot, el thlice, el hook, el shank, el cetera. 
 We lined up, dispatching practice balls into the shimmering blue yonder with ill-disguised pride and waited for the Master to work his way along, one of us on video duty all the while. 
 At last he reached me and asked me to demonstrate el thwing. 
 I thwung. 
 The ball soared away in a graceful arc. 
 I smiled. 
 Vincente frowned. 
 First of all he picked up my clubs, pronounced them useless and advised me to sell them forthwith. 
 He then grabbed my hands and, in the manner of a demented macrame expert, rearranged them around my condemned four iron. 
 &bquo;El grip,&equo; he said severely. 
 I whimpered and pathetically tried to move the little finger of my left hand, currently being squeezed bloodless by the lattice work of fingers he had somehow contrived along the handle. 
 &bquo;No, no, no,&equo; he said impatiently. 
 &bquo;This el grip. 
 You want to play with your grip, you go and have coffee. 
 Now hit it.&equo; 
 I swung the club and missed it. 
 &bquo;Hit it,&equo; he said, seizing el grip with a painful vice and swinging it from side to side. 
 I swung the club again and the ball shot off much as one had always imagined bats flee hell. 
 That was one of the problems. 
 While Vincente was there, glowering over you, radiating fitness and willpower, the ball seemed to behave in a dramatic way, as though fitted with miniature jet rockets. 
 But the moment Vincente's back was turned the ball tended to squirt off at eccentric angles &mdash; or, worse, refuse to move at all. 
 The other problem was the blisters. 
 Huge puffy ones started springing up all over the hands at the friction points in Vincente's system of finger knots. 
 Each night I soothed my hands with ice cubes from the mini-bar. 
 Each morning I swaddled them in cotton wool and boxes of Band-Aids. 
 Each day they grew larger. 
 The first night we went out to a restaurant along the coast. 
 It was a shell-shocked gathering. 
 Our golf had been perfectly OK until now, we all agreed. 
 Did this man know that he had ruined our game, our happiness, everything we held dear? 
 One by one we seized the cutlery to demonstrate to each other the blatant ludicrousness of el grip. 
 It flew in the face of the laws of physics, said the Irish banker, a learned man with a considerable library of golfing books. 
 The City lawyer nodded sagely and ordered another bottle of Rioja. 
 The second day Vincente announced that el thwing was wrong. 
 The clear fact was that he was having serious trouble knowing where to start. 
 He was plainly a kind man but his meaning was quite apparent. 
 If he played golf as badly as that he'd pack it in. 
 By now my mind was working along similar lines. 
 Coupling el grip with el thwing was like attempting the appendix to the Canadian Air Force Exercise Manual. 
 The results were pitiful. 
 Which was a shame, since each afternoon we sauntered round the beautifully manicured, palm-fringed courses at La Manga. 
 It is not quite the setting the founders of the game envisaged but it has something to be said for it. 
 Except when you are hobbling around dispatching shot after shot into the beautifully manicured lakes thoughtfully scattered around the landscape, leaving a trail of Band-Aids in your wake. 
 DINNER the second night was a bleak affair until one of the lawyers, emboldened by more than one aperitif, announced that he intended to junk the entire method &mdash; el grip, el backthwing, the lot &mdash; and return to his old ways. 
 There were gasps of shock and admiration. 
 The City lawyer nodded sagely and ordered another bottle of Rioja. 
 And another. 
 Much more of that and we'd have been making a block transfer to the Betty Ford clinic. 
 We all cheered up a bit after that. 
 We continued to contort our limbs into improbable postures when Vincente was directly overseeing us. 
 But whenever he wandered off el grip would loosen, el thwing would revert and the comfortable old mongrel ways would return. 
 I AM writing this some six months later. 
 For some time after the trip I have to report that my game remained on the critical list. 
 It was touch and go. 
 Then gradually twitches of life manifested themselves and it is now as well as can be expected. 
 El grip has been discarded, along with the last of the Band-Aids. 
 But I would not say I learned nothing from Vincente. 
 There are occasions, when the sun is shining and all is well with the world, when I fancy he might recognise the rudiments of el thwing. 
 And he was quite right about the clubs. 
 They turned out to be ladies'. 
 But I never have been able to bring myself to watch the video. 
 Marrakech. 
 IF I HAD to design a retreat for winter-weary travellers who want familiar hotels but in a different civilisation, I'd invent Marrakech. 
 I stayed there for a week in January and for once I found myself in the overworked brochure cliche: Marrakech is a city of contrasts and a fascinating blend of the old and new. 
 Well, not a blend exactly. 
 There are definite demarcation lines. 
 Inside the top hotels all is First World ordered calm: state-of-the-art swimming pools, satellite television and chocolates on the pillow at night. 
 The smell is Chanel and money. 
 The sound is international muzak and &bquo;would you care for ice with your martini, madame?&equo; 
 A step outside and I'm conscious of my bare head and arms. 
 Most Moroccan women show only their eyes. 
 The men are trying to catch mine and hook themselves on to me as &bquo;guides&equo;. 
 In the five minutes spent walking fast enough to shake them off, I'm in the crowds in the main square, Djemaa el Fna. 
 Here are acrobats, storytellers, letter writers, snake charmers and teeth pullers. 
 The smell is of woodsmoke and amber, stables and drains, grilling meats and spices. 
 The noise is drums and violins, mopeds and horses and: &bquo;Madame, you want to buy? 
 I give best prices. 
 Venez, s'il vous plait. 
 Very good prices. 
 Come.&equo; 
 It is possible to &bquo;do&equo; Marrakech in less than two days. 
 Many tour groups do and I timed their sightseeing. 
 It's four minutes per museum floor, half an hour in Djemaa el Fna (less for those scared of pickpockets and dirt), one hour round the city walls in a carriage at trotting pace and as much time in the souks as it takes to buy a rug, a leather coat and some fake Berber jewellery. 
 With a week to loaf around the town I had the luxury of time to get lost &mdash; not difficult in the souks, a vast hugger-mugger of alleys. 
 I drank mint tea in the carpet shops (and found Stefan Grappelli, Bryan Ferry and Ben Kingsley listed in one shop's order book). 
 I tried on buttersoft leather jackets and tried out &bquo;designer&equo; bags. 
 If Louis Vuitton were paid for every LV logo in the souks, he could surely buy Marrakech. 
 I fingered heavy silver and amber necklaces with starting prices of &pound;200 but I did not have the patience or the energy to haggle down to the real price. 
 Sometimes at night I'd find myself beyond the souks in narrow lanes between windowless houses. 
 Here the pestering to buy stops. 
 Veiled women carrying home shopping didn't give me a second glance. 
 Neither did the men gliding by in long jellabas and pointed hoods. 
 We'd squeeze to the dusty walls to let the horse-drawn carriages past. 
 Only mopeds and lads swapping cigarette cards stop the scenes being Sunday school posters. 
 It seems to my tourist eyes that Marrakech has survived French occupation pretty well. 
 French influence was limited. 
 They left alone the old town with its souks, square, palaces and its impressive Koutoubia minaret. 
 Instead they built their handsome new town with its wide tree-lined boulevards, outside the city walls. 
 One policy still enforced means that all but Moslems are banned from entering the mosques. 
 The most noticeable French legacies are their language and their food. 
 Breakfast at a pavement table in the new town is a leisurely Gallic affair. 
 A croissant warm from the oven, a cup of good coffee and a tumbler of just-squeezed orange juice costs under &pound;1. 
 An a la carte three-course supper for two with a bottle of very drinkable Moroccan red at, say, Le Petit Poucet comes to &pound;10 all in. 
 It's the sort of shabby restaurant you can still find in France: radishes and butter and spiced olives for nibbles, enormous roses plonked on the table and football on the TV in a back room are the setting for the very best pommes frites and memorable dishes of brains a beurre blanc and kidneys in garlic. 
 Moroccan food turned out to be an equally good treat. 
 The Moroccan restaurants that I tried were obviously set up for tourists. 
 Either that or the better-heeled locals enjoy female singers wailing purposefully at their table and moving away only when handed money. 
 Anyone like us who, after two hand-outs, tries pretending she's not there is eventually offered what sounds like a horrible curse. 
 Still the food is interesting and delicious. 
 Pastilla, for example, is a crisply baked cake of cooked pigeon &mdash; bones and all &mdash; layered between paper-thin pastry and sweetened with almonds and sugar. 
 Tajine is a stew of meats and vegetables, poulet au citron is nearly as you'd imagine but with sweet spices and lemon peel pickled in brine. 
 Two of us spent &pound;45 wallowing in the glorious splendour of Marrakech's best Moroccan restaurant at the Mamounia Hotel. 
 Another night at some scruffy place full of hooded locals, we spent &pound;15 on similar dishes. 
 The food there didn't taste too different and we were spared a cabaret but I reckon &pound;30 isn't too high a price for eating in a beautiful, traditional-style Moroccan room with the well heeled jet set, being served by obsequious waiters in costumes that would put to shame Aladdin's chorus at the Palladium. 
 On the way out, I swear I bumped into Barry Manilow. 
 That fancy feast at the Mamounia was a fitting end to a week spent loitering in hushed palace courtyards and lush palm-tree gardens, staring at the marble mosaic walls and the carved cedarwood ceilings in the palaces and in the Museum of Moroccan Art. 
 Each room is worth a 40-minute visit &mdash; not four. 
 Marrakech is worth not two days of a tourist's time but at least seven. 
 BRIEFCASE Travelscene sells four, five and seven-night holidays in Marrakech using Royal Air Maroc day flights direct from Heathrow. 
 Accommodation is in the five-star Meridien or the four-star Tichka, both in the new town (a five-minute cab ride or an interesting 40-minute walk to the old city centre) or in the truly de luxe Mamounia within the city walls. 
 (The recently-renovated 1930s Mamounia gets my vote for most beautiful rooms anywhere). 
 Mid-April prices for a four-night stay start from &pound;369. 
 High season prices (mid-July to mid-September) start from &pound;409 and low season (November and December) from &pound;339. 
 Flying time is three and a half hours and there is no time change. 
 The local currency is the dirham, currently 14.65 to the pound. 
 Importing or exporting dirham is not allowed. 
 Entry fees to palaces and museums are 3 dirham (20p). 
 Travel News. 
 By Trader Horn THE INTERNATIONAL Foundation of Airline Passengers Associations is demanding index-linked compensation for air crash victims and their families. 
 Payments were set by the Warsaw Convention, which, executive director Geoffrey Lipman complains, is 60 years out of date, although the protection guidelines are still valid. 
 &bquo;Inflation has reduced their value dramatically. 
 Most passengers do not realise their rights are limited &mdash; it takes a law graduate to understand the notice on the ticket.&equo; 
 The foundation which is based in Switzerland but also represents consumer groups in the UK, is also proposing a relieffund for victims of terrorist attacks on civil aircraft. 
 IFAPA, PO Box 462, 1215 Geneva 15 Airport, Switzerland. 
 Enabling act. 
 SOME 900 hotels in Scotland fall short of Scottish Tourist Board standards set to assess facilities provided for disabled guests, says STB's Tom Bland. 
 Over the last three years the board has contributed &pound;581,275 towards improving such facilities at tourist attractions, in hotels and self-catering apartments. 
 Open season. 
 FANS OF THE open-top jeep as a means of safari travel will have a wider choice in Zambia from next year, when the national airline's subsidiary, Africa Bound, will start regular game drives through South Luangwa and Kafue national parks &mdash; &pound;1,233 for a 10-day tour. 
 The company also operates beach holidays in other parts of Africa, with seven nights at the Mombasa Beach hotel in Kenya from &pound;794. 
 Details: 01-493 4388. 
 Cool in a crisis. 
 REVERSING the usual policy of hiring young, husky and single people for the strenuous job of courier, Carefree Camping, whose tents are mainly in France, says that these types need not apply for 30 such posts for next summer. 
 Instead they are looking for to recruit people between 45 and 65, who they feel are more likely to remain cool in the crises which plague, that kind of holiday. 
 Details: 09277-61311. 
 Speke speaks out. 
 THAT HORRIBLE gap at the weekend when the world's financial markets close and the investor suffers withdrawal symptoms, is to be filled by a gilt-edged scheme from stockbrokers Wise Speke. 
 At two Best Western hotels, the Ivy House at Marlborough and the Spa at Tunbridge Wells, they propose to bide time with theme weekends on structuring a portfolio and sorting out options and warrants. 
 Details: 0892-20331 (Spa) or 0672-55333 (Ivy). 
 Bullet proof. 
 IF EVER there was a country where budget ideas are welcomed it is Japan, and a useful one now emerges: those unable to afford the bullet train &mdash; shinkansen &mdash; should look to long-distance buses, which can produce a saving ofas much as 40per cent. 
 In the last year the number of scheduled routes has tripled to 55. 
 There is a further tactic: by using the night buses travellers are able to save on accommodation: the buses are well equipped with blankets and pillows and high-tech stereo headphones and telephones. 
 Just the ticket to see the sun rise. 
 Cool in a crisis. 
 REVERSING the usual policy of hiring young, husky and single people for the strenuous job of courier, Carefree Camping, whose tents are mainly in France, says that these types need not apply for 30 such posts for next summer. 
 Instead they are looking for to recruit people between 45 and 65, who they feel are more likely to remain cool in the crises which plague, that kind of holiday. 
 Details: 09277-61311. 
 UK Travel. 
 PRESTATYN seemed a dismal town. 
 Its grey buildings, mainly guest houses displaying &bquo;Vacancies&equo; at netted windows, looked bad enough but with a leaden sky and a seafront virtually devoid of life, apart from one or two hopefuls trying to find shelter from driving rain, it was almost guaranteed to sink one's spirits. 
 I just wanted to move on. 
 My reason for being there was that this particular bit of coast happens to be the northern end of the Offa's Dyke footpath, which winds for 168 miles along the English/Welsh border to Chepstow. 
 My plan was not to walk its length but to ride my mountain bike along minor roads as close as possible to the dyke. 
 As I rode out of town, past the railway station and its &bquo;Welcome to Prestatyn&equo; message, to alighting holidaymakers, I could not help thinking that they certainly were. 
 The Clwydian Hills, rising to the south and cloaked in cloud, looked wonderfully alluring: so I threw myself into the long climb with far more vigour than I might have done normally. 
 As I climbed, so the cloud lifted and I was soon able to shed my waterproofs. 
 Traffic was practically non-existent. 
 For much of the time the only sounds were the chatter of birds and the humming of my bike's knobbly tyres, but the wide panoramas changed constantly as the countryside unfolded around me. 
 I idled through tiny villages, little more than hamlets, with ever more unpronounceable names, like Llandyrnog and Llangynhafal and Llan-beder-Dyffryn-Clwyd. 
 It is the kind of area where keeping a close eye on the map is almost essential for peace of mind &mdash; asking the way could prove difficult, to say the least. 
 On the second day, I geared up for the Horseshoe Pass, three miles up followed by a long down to Llangollen. 
 But this was an A-road and I wanted to keep mainly to the minor routes, so half-way up I turned off behind the Ponderosa Cafe and joined the Old Horseshoe Pass. 
 Another rarely used road, hardly wider than a car, it has the merit of going down, while the new road goes up. 
 It emerges at the foot of Eglwyseg Mountain, a wild-looking spot described by my host of the previous night as &bquo;Injun country&equo;. 
 I knew what he meant. 
 It was quiet. 
 Much too quiet. 
 I hurried on, keeping an anxious, watchful eye on the skyline. 
 AT TREVOR, I crossed the Dee by Thomas Telford's Pontcysyllte Aqueduct, built nearly 200 years ago to carry barges on the Shropshire Union Canal across the deep valley; then cycled up past the church on steep Methodist Hill, built surely as a penance for sinning churchgoers. 
 Chirk, trying to retain a hint of character despite the volume of traffic that passes through it on the A5, came and went, then, across the River Ceiriog and out of Wales into England. 
 Until now, Offa's Dyke had not been much in evidence but from Chirk Castle beyond Oswestry's old racecourse there is a sizeable stretch. 
 A high bank with a ditch on one side, it was built between the estuaries of the Dee and Severn in the late eighth century by Offa, king of Mercia, not as a defence against the Welsh but to control trade across the border. 
 About 81 miles of dyke are still visible. 
 For a while, my route flirted with the border and after some easy going across the Severn Valley, I took to the hills again, following a roman road over Long Mountain. 
 At one point, a painted sign on the tarmac invited me to take a break. 
 &bquo;This way to the wedding party,&equo; it read, arrows pointing to a distant farmhouse. 
 But I resisted the temptation and pushed on to Montgomery and Knighton instead. 
 The road here crosses from England into Wales and back with increasing regularity. 
 Over Stonewall Hill, near Presteigne, it actually forms the border. 
 England fell to the left of me, Wales to the right. 
 Knighton provided a busy interlude, the bustle contrasting strongly with the tranquility of my journey. 
 I stopped long enough to recharge, then pedalled up the Arrow Valley, crossed a ridge of hills and then freewheeled all the way down to the largest second hand bookshop in the world at Hay-on-Wye. 
 Richard Booth opened his first bookshop there in 1961. 
 Pleasant to browse but unwise to buy as I could do without the extra weight of heavy tomes for the long haul after the town up past Hay Bluff to the Gospel Pass &mdash; a climb to more than 1,750 ft. 
 Not that I could see anything when I arrived &mdash; it was covered in cloud. 
 The only way I knew I had reached the summit was when I started downhill again. 
 THIS is a long descent &mdash; roughly 13 miles down a beautiful valley past the little church at Capel-y-ffyn and the ruins of Llanthony Priory to Llanfihangel Crucorney. 
 I freewheeled virtually all the way. 
 From there on, the topography is less demanding, the road undulating gently all the way to Monmouth. 
 There, I crossed the ancient Monnow Bridge and rode up the broad main street to Agincourt Square, where colourful umbrellas set before the inns give the place a continental air. 
 The last leg took me down through the fringes of the Forest of Dean along a narrowing spur. 
 To my right the Wye was there again, winding like a snake; to my left were the broad muddy reaches of the Severn. 
 Ahead, I could see the twin towers of the Severn Bridge, beneath which the two rivers meet before completing their journey to the sea. 
 The journey ended, six days on and a world of difference at Chepstow Bridge, just below the walls of the castle. 
 Pyrgic Puzzles. 
 By Christopher Maslanka 
 1. 
 Kugelbaum came across a football lying on the pavement. 
 &bquo;Clearly,&equo; he said to himself, &bquo;Each T on this ball is regular and of the same dimensions as each and every other T. Clearly also, each and every pentagon is regular and the same size as each and every other pentagon.&equo; 
 How many T's are there on the surface of the ball? 
 ILLUSTRATION: IAN ANDERSON 
 2. 
 What regular body would be obtained if the centres of all neighbouring pentagons were joined by straight lines and all other lines were erased? 
 3. 
 The word cuboid has six letters and represents a solid figure with six plane faces. 
 Can you think of another solid figure with the same number of plane faces as letters in its name? 
 4. 
 &bquo;I cannot think,&equo; remarked Russell, &bquo;Why laziness should have had such a bad press. 
 The whole progress of mankind ought to have consisted in this: the elimination of unnecessary work. 
 I have tried to inculcate in my pupils an attitude of intelligent laziness. 
 As an exercise in this practice, I invite your answer to this calculation: 81,624,324,048,566,472,808 x 12.5. 
 You have one minute to give an answer.&equo; 
 Well? 
 Solutions 
 1. 
 It is easy to see that there are 12 pentagons on the ball. 
 Each is surrounded by a ring of five Ts but each T is shared between three pentagons. 
 So there are a third of 12 x 5 Ts: i.e. 20 Ts in all. 
 2. 
 A regular icosahedron: a solid having 20 plane faces, all of them equilateral triangles. 
 3. 
 Dodecahedron will do. 
 Note that if you take Kugelbaum's football and let all the pentagons expand at the same rate and at the expense of the Ts until every T has shrunk to a point you will be left with a regular dodecahedron, having 12 pentagonal faces. 
 4. 
 Multiplying by 12.5 is the same as multiplying by 100 and dividing by 8. 
 The number is easy to divide by 8 as it consists for the most part of successive multiples of 8. 
 The answer is seen to be: 1,020,304,050,607,080,910,100. 
 Rover believes in catching them young as Judith Jackson discovered in Swindon The body shop Motoring. 
 THE Rover plant at Swindon is not a pretty place. 
 But behind this typical example of dreary industrial architecture, much is going on which should encourage us. 
 For Rover is busy introducing young people to engineering. 
 Engineering is not a glamorous pursuit, nor does Swindon produce the final glossy motor car which might lure potential workers. 
 But the pressings which come out of the plant for Cowley and Longbridge are essential. 
 In an area where unemployment struggles to reach 3 per cent, school leavers are spoiled for choice, so it is in a spirit of enlightened self-interest that the Swindon managers have embarked on programmes designed to tempt young people into engineering. 
 Ray Fletcher, the personnel manager at Rover's Swindon plant and Graham Spaull, the training manager, are concerned that to many youngsters engineering means long hours, tedious jobs and dirty hands. 
 Part of this myth is perpetrated by educationists who have been no nearer a press shop than a picture in a newspaper; parents also see their offspring in cleaner, more &bquo;respectable&equo; jobs. 
 So the success of 20 youngsters on a two-week work experience programme in the Swindon plant on Monday is crucial to the future of engineering in general and the motor industry in particular. 
 There will soon be a severe shortage of young people for any industry, so the motor industry needs to stake its claim fast. 
 This latest group of teenagers at Rover come from local schools. 
 Many may have already been to the Saturday morning Skills Club which introduces Swindon schoolchildren to a workshop, supervised by senior instructors and apprentices and teaching simple engineering skills. 
 The club, open for four hours on a Saturday morning, is enormously popular, particularly with girls who show an affinity for craft skills. 
 Ray Fletcher sees these programmes as getting realism into schools. 
 &bquo;We want the students to understand what we do &mdash; that these days engineering is a very sophisticated and hi-tech business which can be both interesting and rewarding. 
 It is vital for the industry to have young, skilled workers and that won't happen unless we encourage them.&equo; 
 Local schools profit too. 
 Dorcan School, just down the road from the plant, is about to open a Rover Room, dedicated to technology and funded by Rover. 
 Supervised by Rover apprentices, the pupils ripped out an old lecture theatre and are in the process of replacing it with a multi-purpose room which, it is hoped, will help to bridge the gulf between industry and education. 
 Patrick Hazlewood, of Dorcan School, agrees that teachers have a lot to answer for when it comes to explaining engineering to students. 
 &bquo;Teachers are often not aware of the possibilities and so links with local industry are extremely important. 
 We devised a sort of Great Egg Race for the children &mdash; Rover gave us some materials which would normally have gone on the scrap heap, lent us a hall and judged the competition. 
 It was a marvellous day and anything like that brings industry closer to the community.&equo; 
 WORK shadowing, a technique usually used for pupils to follow managers around their daily tasks, takes on a new aspect at Swindon, where teachers shadow apprentices on the press lines, and Rover management teaches in local schools. 
 Does it work? 
 Last year Rover took on 30 apprentices at Swindon and this year the figure will be 64. 
 What all the programmes indicate is that it takes commitment and enthusiasm on the part of Rover, the schools and their pupils, if such initiatives are to produce the engineers of the future. 
 And that engineering can be fun. 
 Bad Housekeeping. 
 By Dulcie Domum 
 MRS BODY'S mother-in-law, otherwise known as Tracey's Gran, dies in the middle of Neighbours, revealing herself as a woman of sensibility. 
 Spouse unable to refrain from observing that Mrs Body's body will soon be a-mouldering in the grave. 
 Recall, with misgivings, that what attracted me to Spouse originally was his wit. 
 Harriet plucks me by the sleeve and whispers, &bquo;Mummy, what will Tracey's Gran do now she's dead, if she wants to go to the loo?&equo; 
 Explain that loo becomes unnecessary &mdash; one of the many benefits of death. 
 Beyond time-share salesman, too. 
 Do not intend to join the older Mrs Body in Limbo quite yet, though. 
 Have got into nice little routine of Life Class every Thursday night and several naughty lunches a week, now Harriet is full time at school. 
 Naughty lunches usually wholefood take-aways eaten in Tom's friendly old nest of a bed. 
 Though wholewheat pastry in my opinion more suited as building material than sustenance. 
 Next naughty lunch, however, in country pub The Trout as Tom has big job on in nearby Pratworth Hall. 
 In meantime persevere with Truffaut season on Channel Four. 
 Cannot help feeling Truffaut's real talent lies in desserts: the conjuring up of trifles, and that what I want from cinema screen is more like roast beef. 
 Mere beefcake, in person of Gerard Depardieu, not enough. 
 Though addition of Depardieu to ingredients would certainly improve any film, or indeed trifle. 
 Go to bed wishing I could have bestowed an extra twenty years' active life upon Bunuel and Jane Austen. 
 Have frightful dream in which Elizabeth Bennett marries Mr Darcy, loses a leg, plays the piano in the nude and is pursued by flock of symbolic sheep from room to room of vast baroque mansion. 
 Awake fatigued and wonder about damage done to subconscious by education. 
 Eventually weekend shudders into oblivion. 
 Perk up at thought of dear Tom snatching hour to gaze into my eyes over Ploughman's Lunch at The Trout. 
 Whistle theme from The Trout as drive with carefree panache towards Pratworth. 
 Autumn tints splendid, and pub cosy. 
 Choose seat next to blazing log fire with back to light. 
 (When alone in Tom's attic recently, found his passport and discovered that when he was born I was already at Grammar School, doing Domestic Science &mdash; in vain, as it turned out). 
 Order large glass of dry sherry and feel its warmth penetrate toes, making up for rather painful new shoes. 
 Scrutinise ankles. 
 Fairly sure they at least are untouched by time. 
 Toes, however, dreadfully mangled. 
 Cannot understand why smallest toenails have turned to quartz and wish they would become pink and smooth again. 
 Pub fills up. 
 Chaps in tweed. 
 Expect Tom delayed by Lord Pratworth. 
 Some detail about old lead piping. 
 Order glass of white wine, forgetting head like sponge. 
 Must not drink any more as have to drive home and collect children en route. 
 Lurch to bar for peanuts. 
 Return with nonchalant air woman enjoying deliberately solitary lunch, but bark shin on chair. 
 Clock's fingers whizz round to 1.45. 
 Palpitations. 
 Fat bald man asks if he may join me, with unpleasant leer. 
 Give what I hope is curt nod, though double chins seem to go on flapping for ever. 
 Appetite has been replaced by anxiety; bread by kapok, Stilton by soap. 
 Fat bald man asks if it is not a bracing time of year. 
 Feel in urgent need of bracing and hear myself laughing loudly to show how relaxed I am. 
 Order large Perrier and hiccup mournfully for half hour while fat bald man laments Nigel Lawson. 
 Mentally remove five stones of body weight from Lawson and discover he could become Mr Darcy. 
 Worthwhile project for his retirement: profit not profiteroles. 
 Stagger out to car park as it is two thirty and, alone in car, ambushed by silly tears. 
 Have been stood up. 
 Possibly because of Pratworth heiress: Caroline, or Charlotte. 
 Drive eccentrically back to Rusbridge. 
 Answering machine winks cheerfully, but it is only Mrs Body excusing herself from work tomorrow because of the funeral. 
 Wonder if this might be right moment to make arrangements for my own. 
 Hunting dirty rats, nit wits and lousy comparisons. 
 JAMES Erlichman (&bquo;A lousy way to treat a child&equo;, Environment Guardian, November 3) must know the dictum of Paracelsus: &bquo;The dose alone makes the poison.&equo; 
 An occasional application of lindane at a concentration of 2 per cent to kill headlice is certainly likely to be more effective than breaking their legs with a nit comb and avoids the discomfort of literally feeling lousy. 
 The materials available to our grandmothers were either more toxic or less effective. 
 I am reminded by the recommendation for dealing with bed bugs published in The Vermin Killer in 1680 &mdash; &bquo;Take gunpowder, brush it well into the bedstead, light it, and keep the smoke in.&equo; 
 Presumably if it didn't kill them it gave them a very nasty headache. 
 The trouble with Quassia (Letters, November 7) is that the extract is unstable, so you need to boil the dry chips for two hours and strain off the liquid each time you need to use it. 
 Most schools had regular visits from &bquo;Nitty Nora&equo;. 
 In the ones where the classics were taught she was Diana &mdash; (The Huntress). 
 The main &bquo;problem&equo; caused by the pesticide that is questioned by Mr Erlichman in his article is that millions of people are alive today throughout the Third World who would otherwise have died from insect-borne diseases or from starvation because insects destroyed their crops. 
 Louse-borne typhus has killed more people than have died in warfare. 
 Do let us have a balance of such benefits against any alleged remote risks of lindane accumulating in the body fat of those who have the luxury of body fat. 
 The truest &bquo;greens&equo; are those who recognise that we need to be protected from aspects of the environment, of which the rat and the louse represent the unacceptable face. 
 P.L.G.Bateman. 
 (Director), Rentokil, Environmental Services Division, Felcourt, East Grinstead, West Sussex. 
 Morality and the modern. 
 ISUGGEST any of your readers who are confused about the aims of modernism (&bquo;The underbelly of an architect&equo;, November 4) should read Pevsner's Pioneers of Modern Design. 
 This is the clearest and most concise account of the rejection of fussy Victorian historicism. 
 I suspect that the current hostility towards modernism has to do with feeling reassured by what is old (we tend to value the patina of age regardless of quality) &mdash; and the sense of stability that this lends to our institutions. 
 There are many impressive Victorian buildings here in Hebden Bridge. 
 There is also the legacy of cramped, poorly lit housing. 
 It should be remembered that the modern movement was responsible for great moral and social improvements when one looks sentimentally at the past. 
 Andrew Hawkins. 
 10 Linden Road, Hebden Bridge, West Yorks. 
 Law Report. 
 A child's welfare must come first:. 
 Court of Appeal Re L (a minor) Before Lord Justice Balcombe and Mr Justice Harman August 25 1989 
 WHEN a court is determining whether a natural mother is unreasonable in withholding consent to her child's adoption, for the purposes of section 16 of the Adoption Act 1976, the court must judge the mother's reasonableness objectively, but must not simply substitute its own views for that of the mother. 
 A reasonable parent, however anguishing the decision, would put his or her own child's welfare in the forefront of the decision. 
 The court has to decide whether the mother's refusal was outside the band of what a reasonable mother might do. 
 If a judge, applying the correct test, comes to a decision which he is entitled to reach on the evidence before him, an appellate court will not interfere with that decision. 
 The facts. 
 The parents were married in 1983 when the mother was 17, and D was born in January 1984. 
 The parents separated from time to time and the father also served a prison sentence. 
 In 1986 the local authority became concerned about injuries which D had sustained and they obtained a place of safety order. 
 D was placed with long-term foster parents with a view to adoption, and the mother's access to her was suspended. 
 In 1988 the foster parents applied to adopt D. The parents refused to consent to the adoption. 
 In May 1989 Judge Wroath made an adoption order and ordered that the parents' consent to the adoption be dispensed with on the ground that it was being unreasonably withheld. 
 The mother appealed. 
 The decision. 
 Lord Justice Balcombe said the way in which section 16(2) of the Adoption Act 1976 was structured was that an adoption order &bquo;shall not be made unless&equo; the parent is withholding consent unreasonably. 
 The decision of the House of Lords in Re W &lsqb;1971&rsqb; AC 682 was the leading authority by which all lower courts were bound. 
 Lord Hailsham said the test was not culpability, callousness, self-indulgent indifference or failure of parental duty, but was the test of reasonableness in all the circumstances. 
 Reasonableness was to be judged by an objective test, although the court was not entitled simply to substitute its own view for that of the parent. 
 It was very difficult for a court to say what a reasonable mother would have done in circumstances which are almost hypothetical. 
 But Parliament had said that that was what judges had to do. 
 The court should not substitute its own decision for that of the parent but had to say whether the parents' decision was outside the band of reasonableness. 
 The welfare of the child was important in that sense, and the reasonable parent, however anguishing the decision, would put his or her own child's welfare right in the forefront of the decision. 
 In the present case the mother said that D was secure with the foster parents and that custodianship would be enough. 
 She said it was unnecessary for the legal relationship of parent and child to be broken when the child was already secure in her new family. 
 What the mother was really saying was, &bquo;I accept that D's immediate future lies with her foster parents. 
 There is no immediate prospect that I can ever have her back, but I would like to keep the door open for that. 
 In any event, something less than adoption, that is custodianship, would be enough&equo;. 
 Giving her reasons for that the mother said that she wished access to be resumed at some point in the future, that D remembered her as the natural mother, and there was a bond between them which would be cut off or damaged by adoption. 
 She thought adoption was not right for D because &bquo;adoption involved merely a loss to D &mdash; there is no real gain from it to her&equo;. 
 She said D was too young and that adoption should be postponed. 
 His Lordship said that the court fully understood the mother's feelings. 
 Any judge found cases of this type difficult because, whatever the decision, somebody was to be grievously hurt. 
 The child's welfare was the first consideration and then other tests had to be applied. 
 Judge Wroath was fully aware that he must not apply his own decision as to what D's welfare required. 
 He adopted the right test and asked whether in the circumstances this mother's decision was within the band of what a reasonable mother would do. 
 He was entitled to say that it was not. 
 The Court of Appeal should not interfere unless it was satisfied that the judge was wrong in law. 
 Judge Wroath had applied the right test and come to a decision which he was entitled to come to on the evidence before him. 
 The appeal was dismissed. 
 Appearances: Paul McCormick instructed by Anderton &amp; Co, Portsmouth for the mother; Barry Coulter instructed by Sherwin Oliver Portsmouth for the foster parents. 
 Shiranikha Herbert barrister 
 Wonder boy's eyes on Wembley. 
 Paddy Agnew charts the progress of the new wild card in Italy's World Cup pack. 
 AT FIRST glance, this boy would appear to have everything. 
 Roberto Baggio, the new &bquo;wonder boy&equo; of Italian soccer, is not only an outrageously talented footballer, but he is also intelligent and responsible, a player who on his own initiative has made a series of public anti-violence appeals. 
 On top of all that, he is blessed with terrific good looks. 
 This afternoon, in his home town of Vicenza, the 22-year-old Baggio will win his sixth Italy cap when he lines up to face Algeria in a game which Italy's manager, Azeglio Vicini, hopes to use as valuable preparation for next Wednesday's Wembley confrontation with England. 
 Baggio, however, the brightest new star in the Italian firmament, is also a problem for Vicini. 
 Until last September Vicini had no doubts about the likely composition of his 1990 World Cup side (injury permitting, of course). 
 In particular his midfield seemed very settled, with Fernando De Napoli on one flank and Roberto Donadoni on the other, and with Giuseppe Giannini calling the shots from a central position behind that pair. 
 Complementing the midfield, in the ball-winning, chasing and hounding role, was either Nicola Berti or Carlo Ancelotti. 
 All that was before Baggio's Five Greatest September Days. 
 On the Sunday he scored twice for his club, Fiorentina, against Diego Maradona and Napoli. 
 On the Thursday he scored twice for Italy in a 4-0 win over Bulgaria. 
 In both games he scored brilliant individual goals after running half the length of the pitch. 
 After the Napoli match the Italian press was hailing the birth of an authentic champion. 
 After the Bulgarian game he was being likened to such legends as Rivera, Mazzola, Zico and even Maradona. 
 Some pundits were, rather foolishly, speculating that he might prove to be better than all of them. 
 One month later Baggio was, as they say in these parts, &bquo;re-dimensioned&equo;. 
 In Italy's 1-0 loss to Brazil in their prestige encounter in Bologna, young Baggio rarely looked much better than your Uncle Jimmy in a Sunday park game, let alone like Zico, Maradona et al. 
 Despite that disappointment, Baggio remains something of a media favourite. 
 His silken touch, his ability to play off either foot, and his pace make him an obvious crowd-pleaser. 
 Thus, partly against his own will and out of a sense of fair play, Vicini gives Baggio another chance against Algeria this afternoon. 
 Given a good performance today he will clearly be in line for a place at Wembley. 
 Given a good performance at Wembley, Vicini's &bquo;Baggio Problem&equo; will have reached epidemic proportions. 
 Three serious question marks stand between Baggio and a first-choice place in Italy's World Cup team: One: as a small, light, &bquo;technical&equo; player, is he simply too fragile for an Italian midfield? 
 After all, Italian midfields have been able to look after themselves over the years. 
 Two: who has to go to make way for him? 
 Giannini as playmaker or Donadoni on the flank? 
 The argument is complicated by the fact that Giannini, after some poor performances for Italy, was one of the best Italians against Brazil. 
 Three: will Vicini change his four-year-old schemes to allow in Baggio? 
 This afternoon's game may answer some of these questions. 
 For the time being, Baggio seems to be more in opposition to Donadoni than to Giannini, since the last mentioned has always seemed to be a favourite son of Vicini, one of that select group of players who matriculated along with the manager from the Italian under-21 side to the senior team. 
 It appears that Vicini will recall Donadoni (back from injury) for at least the first half at Wembley. 
 As for who plays in the second half, that could depend on this afternoon. 
 It might be argued that the Algerians hardly present a severe test. 
 That, too, was what the West Germans thought prior to their opening 1982 World Cup finals game in Spain. 
 Soccer almanacs record the final score that day as 2-1 in Algeria's favour. 
 The Algerians were denied a second-round place in 1982 only because of their inferior goal difference to both Austria and Wst Germany. 
 The Algerians, too, remain in contention for &bquo;Italia &bquo;90&equo;. 
 Next Friday they play Egypt in Cairo in a play-off match. 
 Having held the Algerians to a 0-0 draw in the first leg of the tie, the Egyptians start favourites. 
 However experience is on the side of the Algerians. 
 Not that those considerations need worry Baggio, who has bought 52 stand tickets so that his entire family can watch him today. 
 In front of his own people (he was born near Vicenza), he will wish to erase the unhappy memories of two years' inactivity caused by serious knee injuries. 
 He will also want to prove just how much he has matured both as a player and as a man. 
 He claims that adopting certain Buddhist practices and yoga techniques has helped him find peace of mind. 
 Some indication of the new, mature Baggio came last weekend when, on his own initiative, he drove up to Genna from Florence to visit Ivan Dell &bquo;Oglio, a young Bologna fan hospitalised with serious burns after a bomb attack on a train before last June's Fiorentina v Bologna game. 
 After spending some time with the injured fan, Baggio said that if there was any violence during last Sunday's game between the same two sides he would ask to be substituted. 
 With an eye to Wembley next Wednesday, Baggio admits that he would love to play in what he and many of his team-mates regard as one of the &bquo;temples&equo; of world soccer. 
 &bquo;People say that Donadoni, not me, will be playing. 
 Myself, I always want to play, and then Wembley Stadium has a fascination all of its own. 
 Who wouldn't want to play there?&equo; 
 Over to you, Signor Vicini. 
 Brave Emeruwa resurrects his Wasps career. 
 By Ian Malin 
 SIX years ago Francis Emeruwa launched a promising career when he scrummed down with four Wasps colleagues in the London Division pack against the All Blacks. 
 For the All Blacks, nothing much has changed since that dank November day as they put various British sides in their place. 
 For Emeruwa, life has been turned upside down after an ankle injury in a sevens match in 1984. 
 The Nigerian-born flanker suffered such awful complications to the infected ankle that he considered legal action against one of the hospitals that treated him. 
 Two operations were needed to save his foot, and playing rugby again seemed as unlikely as Newport beating the All Blacks. 
 But this afternoon the 28-year-old makes the most spectacular comeback since Reggie Perrin when he lines up against Nottingham. 
 Emeruwa, a teacher, takes his place in a new-look Wasps back row which includes the former Cambridge University captain Steve Kelly and Mark Rigby, while the former England centre Kevin Simms plays his first Courage Clubs Championship game of the season. 
 Wasps jointly lead the First Division with Harlequins and Bristol, who meet today, and Bath, Saracens and Gloucester. 
 At the other end of the First Division the whipping boys, Bedford, who have conceded 190 points in their four games, include the 17 &frac12; stone No.8 Steve Harris at inside centre against Orrell. 
 Civil servant warns Close of crisis of confidence. 
 YORKSHIRE's cricket committee, chaired by Brian Close, is threatened with a vote of no confidence at the annual meeting at Sheffield City Hall in the New Year, writes David Hopps. 
 Robert Hand, a Leicester-based civil servant and Yorkshire member for 10 years, intends to move the vote unless &bquo;positive steps are taken to put things right&equo; at a meeting of the full committee on November 28. 
 At that meeting Close's committee will make wide-ranging recommendations, most crucially on the captaincy and a possible team manager. 
 Ali Bacher, managing director of the South African Cricket Union, has denied claims that dissenters within his committee still want the tour by Mike Gatting's unofficial England party aborted. 
 In Perth, a sixth-wicket partnership of 136 between Martin Crowe (87) and John Bracewell (86) lifted New Zealand to 271 for seven on the first day after they slumped to 97 for five against Western Australia. 
 Golf: Only small beer for leader. 
 By David Davies in Marbella 
 UNTO each pair, a plan. 
 The Benson and Hedges Mixed Greensomes Trophy, being played at Aloha, Marbella, has made its professional participants think a bit, for life is a little more complicated this week. 
 &bquo;We thought about the format,&equo; said David Llewellyn, &bquo;and we decided that the rule for the day was to keep two balls in play off the tee. 
 In the end, though, we mostly played my partner's tee shots, because we could find hers.&equo; 
 His partner, and captain, was Mickey Walker and her steadiness, combined with flashes of flair from Llewellyn, got them round in 69, three under par, for a two-round total of 137, one shot behind the leaders. 
 They were Gillian Stewart and Carl Mason, also round in 69 and also with a plan. 
 This involves a change of character for Mason, who has decided to become, in his words, a lager lout. 
 This merely involves a couple of beers in the evening, not even light training for the real thing of which Spain has seen far too much. 
 But it has worked. 
 Mason is relaxed and the two retained their overnight lead. 
 They reached the turn in level par, having birdied the 5th, where Stewart chipped to four feet, and bogeyed the ninth. 
 They were 18 feet away in two but then, said Mason, &bquo;I forgot it was downhill&equo; and he ran his first putt eight feet past the pin. 
 However, he holed from 40 feet at the 11th for a birdie before Stewart played the stroke of the round at the 12th. 
 She was faced with an eight-iron shot out of fluffy rough, with trees impeding her backswing. 
 Not only that, there was the auto-suggestion of two tiny Spanish brats splashing about in the pond in front of the green, fishing for lost balls. 
 The ball had to be struck perfectly and Stewart, who has an enviable rhythm at all times, concentrated on maintaining balance. 
 &bquo;It's easy to just have a go at shots like that,&equo; she said, &bquo;but you hit a better shot if you stay in balance.&equo; 
 She got the ball on the green, par was saved, and to celebrate Stewart holed from 25 feet for a birdie at the 14th. 
 She also holed from 40 feet for a birdie at the short 17th, but it was Mason who preserved their lead. 
 His drive was 173 yards from the 18th green; Stewart's 201 yards. 
 As both players would have needed a five-wood to reach the green, Mason elected to play. 
 As he had done in the first round, he reached the green and they got their par. 
 Llewellyn, relentlessly cheerful throughout his episodic golf career, has supplied the light relief for Walker this week. 
 The green at the 14th is so severely sloped that he knew he would need to leave her below the flag, and did so &bquo;by about two light-years&equo;. 
 Realistically, it was about 40 feet but, said Llewellyn, &bquo;straightforward really&equo;. 
 He had talked Walker into it, and she holed the birdie putt. 
 An eagle at the 16th, where Llewellyn hit a three-wood 250 yards to 10 feet from the hole, tied them for the lead, but they dropped a shot at the last. 
 Cricket: Yorkshire puddings face a championship bout Frank Keating gets a sneak preview of the war of words between two battling Tykes. 
 NEXT Tuesday evening, Yorkshire Television were hoping to transmit a debate on the latest calamities befalling the county: Brian Close, chairman of the club's cricket committee, versus the representative for the Wakefield district, Geoffrey Boycott. 
 Last night Brian Walsh, the Yorkshire chairman, did his best to put a block on the whole sorry business, but not before enterprising Guardian hacks were able to obtain a leaked copy of a classic example of the high-class cut and thrust of the debate. 
 It begins with John Helm of Yorkshire TV introducing the speakers: Helm: Right, gentlemen, we haven't won a championship title since 1967, but both of you know the rules &mdash; three falls or one submission and any knockdown and the one still standing retires to a neutral corner. 
 Close (growls with gum-chewing menace): If he wants to jive, he'll fall in five! 
 (Cheers and counter-cheers). 
 Boycott (fixes wan, wonky, ever-righteous grin in place): I am the People's Champ. 
 C: Chump, more like, lad. 
 B: My Wakefield branch is an improvement on Yorkshire's worst season in history &mdash; second bottom in the championship. 
 C: Wrong. 
 We were dead bottom in 1983 &mdash; when tha were playing. 
 B: In &bquo;83 we won the Sunday League, though. 
 C: No thanks to your snail stuff at top of order, lad. 
 B: No, &bquo;83 were a grand year. 
 I got me 2,000 and averaged 55, which were about 20 more than anyone else. 
 And all thanks I got was to be sacked at end of summer &mdash; though only for a few months, that is, 'cos of the revolution. 
 C: Aye, not the first nor the last you caused, neither. 
 B: If you'd left me as captain, none of it would have happened. 
 Since me you've had Hampshire, Old, Illy, Bairstow, Lamb and Hartley &mdash; and 10 bob to a tanner young Carrick will be smoked out within the fortnight, right? 
 Bet he'll play traitor and move to another county just like you did. 
 C: No other county would have you when you were sacked. 
 B: 'Cos I'm Yorkshire through and through. 
 Somerset? 
 Where's that? 
 We'll be signing that darkie, Viv Richards, next. 
 If I don't get me oar in, that is. 
 C: But in your autobiography, lad, you suggested we should play an overseas star. 
 B: That was before I was cognisant of the fact that my Wakefield caucus would only have one in over my dead body. 
 So they've changed my mind for me. 
 That's democracy, see. 
 C: So on the overseas-darkie-star issue, suddenly you and Fred Trueman see eye to eye? 
 B: Trueman! 
 What does he know? 
 Spends more time at Old Trafford than Headingley now, he does. 
 If that isn't traitorous to Yorkshire, what is? 
 C: Ee, lad, you're a po-faced poser, aren't you? 
 B: You, too, you madcap driver. 
 You'd rather have a day out at York racecourse than at Headingley if truth were known, wouldn't you? 
 C: Steady on, this is a public meeting. 
 Keep your hair on. 
 B: Look who's talking, baldy! 
 All them double scotches have made your hair fall out. 
 : I've more natural hair up my nostrils than you have in that knitted rug of yours. 
 B: Right, you started it. 
 If you want to get personal then two can play at that, and I swear on my lifelong friendships with the late Mrs Gandhi, Brian Clough and Michael Parkinson that I will burn my brand new membership card of the NUJ on the square at Headingley if you can name me the full Yorkshire team you're chairman of. 
 C: Give over, lad, easy peasy. 
 Right, Moxon, Metcalfe, Carrick, good old Arnie of course&hellip; er, that stocky lad who doesn't move his feet properly&hellip; um, let me see now: um, oh yes, that fellow who keeps getting backache, and then that off-breaker who can't turn it, and that so-called seamer with the funny hairstyle who just can't bowl at all&hellip; 
 B: For once, I agree with you there, Closey, old pal &mdash; and do you know, the buggers don't even practise, don't even know how to practise. 
 Why, I still have a long workout in my net every morning even before our first cuppa ginseng. 
 C: What net's that, Geoffrey, your hairnet? 
 B: Mr Chairman, I protest&hellip; (cheers). 
 C: See, told you I'd stuff him in open debate. 
 (Audience begin riot). 
 Roll captions. 
 Fade to black. 
 The Absolute End. 
 Fouroux plays a desperate hand. 
 By Martyn Williams in Lille 
 THERE have been few hiding places for the French coach Jacques Fouroux since the embarrassment of defeat against Australia at Strasbourg. 
 His team, World Cup finalists and dotted with household idols, were taken to the cleaners by a bunch of Australian students and farmers in the first Test, and the second Test at Lille promises to be not only a trial of Fouroux's incumbency as coach but also his tactical shrewdness in selection. 
 In dropping Pierre Berbizier (his captain and until last Saturday his likely successor as coach), Serge Blanco, Laurent Rodriguez and every commentator's nightmare, Jean Condom, Fouroux's guillotine has been severe. 
 Nine fancied Frenchmen were disposed of, yet, rather than introduce a new regime, Fouroux has opted in most cases for rejuvenated blood. 
 Erbani, Lorieux and Carminati in the pack are no strangers to the international arena with 75 caps between them, but Fouroux and his assistant coach Daniel Dubroca hope that the French will show willingness and enthusiasm for battle and put behind them the inept and inexplicable performance witnessed at Strasbourg. 
 Whereas Bob Dwyer, the Australian coach, was the man being criticised and under pressure before the Strasbourg match for lack of success and for Randwick club favouritism, he has been able to announce an unchanged team. 
 Fouroux, the subject of many a cartoon in the French dailies, battered, bruised and confused alongside a yawning French cockerel, knows that failure at Lille will sharpen knives, of which there are many, and increase the demands for a return to traditional French flamboyancy. 
 &bquo;We simply did not play rugby at Strasbourg,&equo; explained Dubroca. 
 &bquo;Our players were bad and tired because you must remember that we have toured in New Zealand, played the Lions, and now Australia.&equo; 
 He insisted that it was not the end for Berbizier and company, only a rest. 
 At half-back, Thierry Lacroix and Henri Sanz are relatively inexperienced compared with Australia's linchpins Lynagh and Farr-Jones. 
 Brendan Nasser and David Carter are well capable of disrupting French attempts at fluidity, but France's problem is possession and if Lorieux, Devergie and Erbani (a back-row man at lock) cannot provide authority, then Lynagh will surely punish Fouroux's selection at full-back of France's most capped centre, Philippe Sella. 
 There is more than a hint of desperation in this unlikely selection. 
 Altogether France will field three international hookers and four players out of position. 
 In the past the French have defied logic and answered their critics, but a second defeat by Dwyer's emerging Wallabies could well summon a black-hooded anonymous henchman. 
 FRANCE: P Sella; S Weller, J-M Andrieu, F Mesnel, P Lagisquet; T Lacroix, H Sanz; P Ondarts, L Armary, D Bouet, D Erbani, T Devergie, A Carminati, A Lorieux, E Champ. 
 AUSTRALIA: G Martin; I Williams, J Little, T Horan, D Campese; M Lynagh, N Farr-Jones; M Hartill, P Kearns, T Daly, P Fitzsimmons, T Gavin, B Nasser, R McCall, D Carter.. 
 The Soviet national team will play six matches in Australia next March. 
 Boxing. 
 Frank Bruno heads his Terry Lawless stablemate Gary Mason in the latest International Boxing Federation heavyweight rankings. 
 Bruno is rated as the No.7 challenger to Mike Tyson, with Mason, the British champion, at No.8. 
 The American Evander Holyfield tops the list of challengers. 
 Glenn McCrory, at cruiserweight, and Dave McAuley, flyweight, are the only British champions in the list, with Michael Watson at middleweight the only Briton regarded as No.1 challenger for a title. 
 Billy Hardy is No.2 bantamweight and Herol Graham No.3 middleweight contender. 
 Soccer 
 Jack Charlton has given the Swindon winger Tony Galvin permission to pull out of the Republic of Ireland's World Cup squad for next week's final qualifier in Malta. 
 Even though the Irish need a point in Valetta to clinch their first appearance in the finals, Charlton has agreed for Galvin to stay behind to play for the Second Division side in their Littlewoods Cup third-round second replay at Bolton. 
 Rugby Union 
 Kevin Ellis of Bridgend flew to the south of France last night to act as emergency cover for the Wales B team's scrum-half Andrew Booth. 
 The Cardiff and Cambridge University player twisted an ankle during training and will undergo a fitness test before tomorrow's game against France B in Arcachon. 
 Grobbelaar under renewed pressure from Hooper. 
 By Cynthia Bateman 
 THE Liverpool manager Kenny Dalglish has included two goalkeepers in Liverpool's 15-man squad for today's game at Queen's Park Rangers. 
 Mike Hooper, who replaced Bruce Grobbelaar for 25 games last season, is in &bquo;on merit&equo;, the manager said yesterday. 
 Hooper's inclusion is seen as a move by Dalglish to introduce the fear factor after three defeats in four games, in which Grobbelaar let in six goals, including four at Southampton. 
 That was Liverpool's heaviest defeat since Hooper conceded four at West Ham in the Littlewoods Cup last season. 
 The last time the 25-year-old Hooper was given a chance was when Grobbelaar contracted meningitis early last season. 
 The reserve goalkeeper held on to the place for four months, and was selected for several weeks after Grobbelaar returned to action with the reserves. 
 The Zimbabwean was so uncertain of regaining his place that in December he submitted a written transfer request. 
 It was refused, and by mid-January Grobbelaar, who has been with Liverpool for nine years, was again Dalglish's first choice. 
 Steve Nicol will be back in the defence today, but Dalglish must also be concerned about his strikers. 
 Liverpool have scored only twice in the past four games, and Rush, with six this season, has not hit the net since the middle of September. 
 Meanwhile John Aldridge, released by Liverpool at the start of the season, is apparently on song with his new club Real Sociedad, scoring in their defeat of the Spanish champions Real Madrid at the weekend. 
 Manchester City last night signed the Blackburn Rovers centre-back Colin Hendry for &pound;700,000, of which &pound;200,000 goes to his former club Dundee. 
 Hendry turned down earlier chances to join Chelsea and City when they would not meet his personal terms. 
 Guys and drolls Seventy summers. 
 By Tony Harman THE LAST November 5 was a perfect night for a bonfire. 
 The flames shot straight up into the sky, dispersing whatever fog was in the immediate area, and we sat around on bales, as we have always done, while some members of the family let off fireworks in the background. 
 As always, other people wandered in who were nothing to do with us. 
 You heard the odd voice in the darkness which you didn't know. 
 November 5 has always had a special significance for me. 
 Perhaps it is because I was married on November 5, and all the way down to a miserable, wet Bournemouth where we spent our honeymoon, there were village bonfires set out ready. 
 And if November 5 is one's wedding anniversary, one could hardly forget either event. 
 In times gone by, there were always lots of hedge trimmings available at the beginning of November, and it was easy to make a bonfire &mdash; with a big family you want a big bonfire. 
 Nowadays, the machines chew up the hedge trimmings so that they don't require burning; you just plough them in. 
 As well as the hedge trimmings, November 5 was used as an occasion for clearing up the farm and burning whatever was left lying about which wasn't any good. 
 Hemp bags with holes in them, paper, broken bits of wood and, I expect, old implements and things which would now be quite valuable. 
 I remember November 5, 1953, when a tendency to clear up had rather a disastrous consequence. 
 Our fourth child had been born 10 years previously and I don't expect anyone believed there would be any more, but my wife and I thought we were getting too old too quickly, so we would have another two; and on November 5 that year my wife went down to the bonfire which was already alight and saw on top of it a dropside cot she had been keeping, and which had served the four children, a relatively new carricot, and other items of that sort. 
 She didn't know what to do. 
 She protested that they shouldn't have been put on there without her authority, and the farm chaps laughed and said, &bquo;You won't be wanting that again.&equo; 
 She could hardly say, &bquo;I've just been told that I'm pregnant again,&equo; because it was only a matter of a week or two. 
 And so new cots and other things had to be bought the following June. 
 The nature of bonfire materials has changed over the years. 
 The hemp sacks with holes in have all gone, being replaced by plastic bags; they burn too, but with a nasty, acrid smell and lots of smoke. 
 And we've got a new source of burnable material to replace the hedge trimmings: lots of things are delivered on pallets, wooden pallets, not all of which are returnable. 
 And there always seems to be some shed which has been taken down somewhere, yielding very inflammable material, so we show no signs of running short. 
 If this annual clear up round the farm didn't take place, we should be in a hell of a mess by now. 
 Each year since the war &mdash; they were too young before that &mdash; the children have made a guy. 
 Each succeeding generation has made a guy in the semblance of somebody they didn't care for. 
 Because bonfires were banned during the war, Hitle wasn't burnt until 1945 when he was already dead. 
 They burnt on occasion a couple of Popes, or perhaps the same Pope twice; it wasn't anti-Catholicism, teenage daughters just objected to something he had said. 
 They wouldn't have dreamt of burning Pope John, for instance, he was far too nice. 
 But to show how ecumenical they were, they also once burnt an Archbishop of Canterbury; several Prime Ministers; Enoch Powell; Richard Nixon; Stalin; all sorts of people, even poor Mr Heath, not so much because he was a villain but because it is so easy to make a guy in the semblance of Mr Heath. 
 We used to cook potatoes and sausages in hot ashes after the fire had burnt down. 
 Now they bring them out ready-cooked. 
 I don't know whether it is just the advance of modern technology within the family, or whether it is because the type of material the fire is built with nowadays wouldn't let them taste quite so good. 
 Anyway, they taste much the same, and last year beetroot soup was added to the menu. 
 But for me, all the time, it is a reminder that for 49 years it replaced wedding anniversary celebrations, and the memory of all those bonfires on the way to Bournemouth on a drizzly November afternoon, all those years ago. 
 Tennis: David Irvine sees the French Open champion continue to confound his doubters at Wembley Chang thriving in fast company. 
 SINCE Michael Chang won the French Open in June, the suspicion has grown that, although the 17-year-old may have the game and resilience to thrive on clay, he lacks the power, size and serve to handle the game's big hitters on faster surfaces. 
 The theory would appear to be borne out by his subsequent record: only one further final appearance, at Los Angeles, and eight losses to players ranked below him on the computer. 
 Until they met yesterday in the quarter-finals of the &pound;275,000 Silk Cut Championships, their first encounter since the semi-finals in Paris, the Soviet No.1 Andrei Chesnokov believed that Chang was more susceptible to power on carpet and cement. 
 After losing to the little Chinese-American again, this time by 6-3, 6-4, he admitted that he had changed his mind. 
 &bquo;Now I know he is a tough tennis player on any surface,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I tried to attack him but I didn't have enough patience. 
 Now I think it was not the right way.&equo; 
 At under 10 stone, Chang certainly has the look of a lightweight. 
 Yet he passes with such unerring accuracy and hunts every ball with such determination that his opponents can rarely claim a winner until the umpire calls the score. 
 This was seen to notable effect at 3-3 and deuce on Chesnokov's serve in the second set. 
 He punched a volley which almost drove Chang into the court surrounds, yet the American not only reached it but responded at full stretch with a perfect lob; quick-witted as well as fleet-footed play. 
 Yet, as a match, it left something to be desired. 
 Chesnokov's tendency to go for winners produced a flood of errors. 
 &bquo;I told myself &bquo;Don't rush, don't rush&equo;,&equo; he said, but evidently he was not listening. 
 Chang felt that the surface, which offered an unusually high bounce for an indoor court, suited a baseliner like himself. 
 At the same time he said he had had to select his shots wisely to get the better of Chesnokov. 
 With 80 per cent of the seats in the arena again empty, it might have been a good opportunity to bus in the LTA's young hopefuls to see for themselves what success in the game requires. 
 At least they might have learned something about attitude, which John McEnroe believes to be the root cause of Britain's tennis predicament. 
 &bquo;For some reason I hate to lose,&equo; said Chang, &bquo;and that makes me more of a fighter. 
 When I don't achieve something that I want to achieve, I'll just keep on until I do. 
 Like when I used to play a seeded player, I didn't think &bquo;OK, I'm going to lose to a seed&equo; but &bquo;All right &mdash; this is my opportunity to beat a seed&equo;.&equo; 
 He was not prepared to preach to the British &mdash; &bquo;I don't really know too much about them&equo; &mdash; but he did say that no one could expect success without putting in a great deal of hard work. 
 Guy Forget, the French left-hander who missed five months of the summer season after knee surgery, claimed his semi-final place with a 7-5, 6-3 victory over Robert Seguso. 
 It was not the American's day. 
 Earlier he and Ken Flach were forced to default their doubles quarter-final because of Flach's ankle injury. 
 Forget, eager after his long break, was delighted to reach his first semi-final in a Super Series event for three years. 
 &bquo;I was very loose,&equo; he said. 
 Ten days ago his wife gave birth to a son. 
 &bquo;I wanted to win for them. 
 On the other hand, if I'd lost I could have gone home quicky.&equo; 
 The mighty continue to fall at the Stockholm Open. 
 On Thursday Boris Becker, the defending champion, lost to Jan Gunnarsson in the third round. 
 Yesterday it was the turn of Andre Agassi. 
 The fourth-seeded American looked sluggish as his serve was broken twice in the first set by the unseeded Swede Magnus Gustafsson, who went on to win their quarter-final 6-2, 7-6, clinching the tiebreak 7-4. 
 Gunnarsson, clearly feeling the effects of his epic match against Becker, was thrashed 6-3, 6-0 by Mats Wilander, who will meet Gustafsson in the semi-finals. 
 The 18-year-old Soviet girl Elena Briuhovec yesterday defeated Austria's Beate Reinstadler 6-2, 6-4 to win the LTA Challenger women's tournament at Swindon. 
 Table Tennis Soviet flair is still missing.. 
 By Richard Jago 
 ENGLAND scored their second big win in two days over the Soviet Union when they won 4-2 at Bexley Heath last night. 
 It was more emphatic than the 5-1 win on Thursday because little more than two hours after the start England had already achieved a 4-0 winning lead. 
 The visitors regained some pride when the Mazunov brothers won the two dead matches. 
 But so far neither has shown the tremendous flair with top-spin attacking that made them a major force in the world championships in Dortmund only seven months ago. 
 They have two more matches in which to do so. 
 Carl Prean and Alan Cooke in particular set out to magnify the Soviet shortcomings. 
 Prean, still unbeaten, showed that he is performing as well as at any time in his career when he outplayed Andrei up to 20-17 in the second game and then comfortably recovered from the disappointment of missing four match points to go on to a 21-8, 22-24, 21-13 win. 
 Kiwis deserve belated fruits Paul Fitzpatrick on New Zealand's quest for recognition. 
 THE New Zealand Rugby League tourists must envy the amount of publicity &mdash; and the financial rewards &mdash; currently being enjoyed by their countrymen from the unsullied &bquo;amateur&equo; world of Rugby Union as the latter grind their remorseless way around Wales and Ireland. 
 Earlier in the tour Hugh McGahan, the Kiwis' captain, expressed his surprise and delight at seeing his men given comparable prominence to the All Blacks &mdash; in some northern editions of the papers at least. 
 But in truth their tour, the English section of which ends with the third Test at Wigan today, has been persistently downbeat. 
 They must accept a share of the blame. 
 Basing themselves at York might have suited their training schedules and their travel arrangements, but it has been less than ideal for their public relations. 
 A quiet life is not necessarily a rewarding life. 
 That might not have mattered unduly, but their early form was so ordinary that a lack of impact off the pitch was compounded by a comparable shortage of flair on it. 
 They had been underestimated, as the first Test proved, but the damage had been done and the attendances for the first two Tests were depressing. 
 The optimist would point out that the aggregate attendance for the two Tests so far &mdash; 31,310 &mdash; compares very favourably with the aggregates for the first two Tests of 1980 (17,977), and 1985 (28,097). 
 But for a game that imagined it was losing its club-orientated mentality, a game convinced that the staging of high-class football in comfortable surroundings would bring in the punters in their thousands, Old Trafford and Elland Road were bitter disappointments. 
 Wigan's less grand Central Park should offer belated compensation. 
 Caution would probably be advisable until every spectator has been counted, but it will be a disappointment if the crowd falls short of 20,000. 
 What is happening, too late unfortunately, is that the Kiwis are starting to demonstrate what a fine squad of players they have. 
 Confidence has risen markedly since the defeat at Elland Road; the parts are falling neatly into place and some of their football in the last three games against Hull, Widnes and Featherstone has been exhilarating. 
 Poor France, where the Kiwis will spend the next three weeks, are now likely to suffer the consequences of this improvement. 
 Conversely, the French can use the two forthcoming Tests to show that reports of the imminent demise of the game there have been grossly exaggerated. 
 No New Zealand player has made an impression on this tour comparable with the impact made by many individuals in 1980. 
 Those tourists arrived with little reputation. 
 They went back respected, admired and ready to take New Zealand Rugby League into one of its finest eras. 
 There has been no Fred Ah Kuoi, Gary Prohm, James Leuluai, Gordon Smith or Dane O'Hara this time, no Gary Kemble, Graeme West, Mark Graham, Mark Broadhurst or Kevin Tamati. 
 And indeed it will be hard for any future Kiwi tourists to recapture the freshness of football that one associates with that side. 
 But when the present tourists have gone and we have seen the last of Gary Freeman and Duane Mann, Esene Faimalo and Francis Leota there will be a sense of regret. 
 And for those insular fans who shunned them in their thousands at Old Trafford and Elland Road, a sense of guilt would not be inappropriate. 
 A day to stay in one peace Talking Point. 
 By David Lacey 
 TODAY being Armistice Day, it would be nice to think that this afternoon's League programme can be completed without the police having to separate fighting footballers. 
 The odds are that it will. 
 Thankfully the brawl between Arsenal and Norwich City players at the end of last Saturday's match at Highbury was a rarity; hence all the fuss. 
 But it was hardly unique. 
 Last Boxing Day there was a similar incident at The Dell when Southampton played Coventry City. 
 The teams were involved in a goalmouth scrap and a player from each side was sent off. 
 In both cases the home team had been 2-0 down at half-time, Southampton fighting back, literally, to force a draw, Arsenal a win. 
 The Football Association did not feel it necessary to charge Southampton and Coventry with bringing the game into disrepute. 
 Yet with eight sendings-off in all that day there was a case for ending the old year by taking a stand on players' behaviour in time for the new. 
 One suspects that Arsenal and Norwich are facing disrepute charges partly because of TV coverage at home and abroad and partly because between Saturday afternoon and Monday morning various sections of the media had built up a fine head of steam in demanding that the FA take action. 
 Lancaster Gate awoke on Monday to find itself accused of doing nothing almost before it had had time to consider doing anything. 
 Ugly though it was, the fight at Highbury needs to be put into a general sporting perspective. 
 It hardly fell into the same category as the calculated thuggery of the last Lions tour or the almost casual butt which recently reduced the Great Britain Rugby League team to 12 men. 
 Nor did the players start fighting before the kick-off, as happened when Chile played Brazil in the World Cup. 
 The FA has taken the extraordinary step of bringing the clubs to book because of the tightrope football is walking between the laws of the game and the law of the land. 
 Had Saturday's scenes at Highbury taken place in Glasgow, some of the participants might be preparing to face the Sheriff's Court accused of disorderly conduct and conduct likely to cause a breach of the peace. 
 Similar motives prompted the FA to ban an Arsenal player, Paul Davis, for nine matches last season after a TV news camera had spotted him punching Glenn Cockerill behind the referee's back with such force that the Southampton player's jaw was broken. 
 Davis was on the Arsenal bench last Saturday &mdash; and stayed there. 
 There may be those who feel that, if the police had to charge anyone with causing a breach of the peace, they should have arrested the referee, George Tyson, whose two controversial penalty decisions against Norwich raised the temperature of the match. 
 But this raises the fundamental issue of players accepting referees' decisions. 
 Last season a referee allowed himself to be wired up for a League match at The Den to record some of the things he had to put up with from players. 
 The visitors were Arsenal and, while it still seems unfair to single out teams in this way, the intensity of attiude recorded by the referee's hidden microphone made it easier to understand what happened last Saturday. 
 Instead of coming down on players who, like Bryan Gunn, the Norwich goalkeeper, give rational views of incidents to newspapers, the FA might do better to examine the irrational attitudes created by some of those running the teams. 
 It might also be an idea to wire up a linesman one day to record the 90 minutes of bile emanating from both benches. 
 In their defence the managers are entitled to protest that the pressure for success, or at least avoidance of failure, comes from the boardroom and ultimately the supporters. 
 With three managers sacked in three days this week the point is a valid one. 
 But why is it that the League's longest-serving manager, the fan-bashing, clown-chasing old iconoclast at Nottingham Forest, has one of the best-behaved teams? 
 Ian Butterworth yesterday became the second Norwich player, after Gunn, to be punished by the club for newspaper comments about the brawl. 
 The nature of his punishment was not revealed. 
 WEEKEND HIGHLIGHTS. 
 Coventry v Southampton Having just won at Liverpool for the first time, Coventry ought to be in the mood to take Southampton even though the latter have lost only once in a dozen games. 
 Coventry, however, have not won at home in the League since mid-September and are without the suspended McGrath, Gynn taking over in midfield. 
 Southampton, moreover, have Rideout back in their attack after injury. 
 Crystal Palace v Luton Palace are again leaking badly at the back, hence the attempt to sign Martyn, Bristol Rovers' highly regarded young goalkeeper. 
 But he will not be there today to face a Luton side who have Wegerle, Williams and Black available after injury. 
 Burke may be back in the Palace defence, and Dennis is in their squad. 
 Derby v Manchester City Derby could do with a win after taking only one point from their last three League games. 
 But City have picked up a bit with a draw at Chelsea and a comfortable win against Crystal Palace, and with the suspended Morley replaced by Oldfield, who knows where the goal is, they will be confident today. 
 Everton v Chelsea Everton will be keen to get Sunday's humiliation at Villa Park out of their systems, but they still have injury problems, with Watson out and Whiteside doubtful. 
 Pointon should be back and the newly signed Beagrie may play, but Chelsea, the present First Division leaders, will probably field an unchanged side and if Dixon's revived form continues they should not lose. 
 Manchester U v Nottm Forest Tomorrow's television match is unlikely to produce another eight goals for the viewers, but it should be more of a contest as United strive to find a blend and a pattern against Brian Clough's tightly organised team. 
 Danny Wallace, recovered from a hamstring injury, replaces Sharpe in the United team. 
 Millwall v Arsenal Arsenal still have to find their form of a year ago but they continue to pick up points at regular intervals, and with Marwood fit and Groves recovered from a virus they should have the resources to beat a Millwall side again lacking Briley and looking for their first League win since September 23. 
 Norwich City v Aston Villa This should be one of the day's better spectacles. 
 With Rosario fit and Townsend available, Norwich are well equipped to improve on a home League record which has seen them win one game and draw the rest. 
 Villa's jubilation at last Sunday's result was cut short at West Ham on Wednesday and they are without Gage today. 
 But if Cowans is in form they could extend their unbeaten League run to six games. 
 QPR v Liverpool Draws at Nottingham Forest and Wimbledon offered QPR a modicum of encouragement but they have still not won a League match for seven weeks, which is hardly the sort of record to have when Liverpool are the visitors, even though Kenny Dalglish's team have lost three of their last four games. 
 Nicol should be back for Liverpool after missing three matches with a neck injury and Hooper, the reserve goalkeeper, is also in the squad. 
 Trevor Francis is keeping the QPR team a secret even from his own players. 
 Dalglish does that every week. 
 Sheffield Wed v Charlton After sliding towards the relegation area, Charlton have started to put another run together with seven points from three games. 
 They are unlikely to find easy pickings at Hillsborough, Wednesday having just won at Forest and with King and Sheridan making their first home appearances. 
 Worthington, his hernia operation postponed, should be there too, helping to take the strain. 
 Tottenham v Wimbledon Spurs have lost only one of their last seven League fixtures and that was at Anfield. 
 Wimbledon's win at Hillsborough was important for morale, but last week's goalless draw with QPR at Plough Lane only satisfied the nihilists. 
 Spurs have to decide whether to recall Stewart to their attack or stick to a successful formula. 
 West Ham v Newcastle Back to the Second Division grind for West Ham after Wednesday's ebullient win against Aston Villa in the Littlewoods Cup. 
 A win today would put pressure on the top three, but Newcastle will regard the draw as a safe option after being held at home by Middlesbrough last weekend. 
 Dillon is their only doubt. 
 The Hare shirt of Leicester fits comfortably on Liley Mike Selvey on a Tiger earning his stripes and kicking the goals at Welford Road. 
 IT HAS long been a precept at Leicester Rugby Club. 
 A successful recipe, as Mrs Beeton advocated, begins with catching your Hare. 
 It seems almost like the beginning of time when visitors to Welford Road first saw dear old Dusty tee up the ball, meticulously pace his couple of steps back and sideways, pause, take a deep breath, glance at the target and then, slick as clockwork, sidle up and caress the ball between the posts. 
 It became a way of Leicester life. 
 But Hare today, gone tomorrow. 
 After a lifetime and a zillion points, the inconceivable happened: Dusty notched up a record and retired to his farm. 
 Suddenly there was a gap, as if a favourite comfortable armchair had been removed from its cosy place by the fire. 
 It is strange, as Betjeman said, that those we miss the most are those we take for granted. 
 But wait. 
 What's this? 
 Suddenly another Tiger is burning bright. 
 For while Hare was playing out his dotage, the backroom was at work. 
 Word reached Peter Wheeler, the Leicester coach, of a young lad at Wakefield, a full-back, a slick-running full-back at that, who not only could kerplonk the ball like a metronome between the posts but could do it with either foot. 
 Well, they just had to have him, hadn't they? 
 This season John Liley, 22 years old, has been a revelation. 
 In 10 games he has scored 136 points, the most in the land by some way. 
 Twenty-seven of those came in the first match, against Pontypridd; Bedford took a similar caning and Coventry only four points less. 
 Six times he has burst into the line and over for a try. 
 Now, of course, he is going through the inevitable comparison with Hare, and it is hard following a legend. 
 There was even early, ridiculous talk of his passing Hare's incredible 438-point record, although at the equivalent stage last season the maestro had 17 more points. 
 &bquo;I can't win really, can I?&equo; says Liley. 
 &bquo;If I score points and do well, then I'll be set against Dusty. 
 If I don't match up then they'll say, oh, Dusty would have done this or that.&equo; 
 You have to sympathise, because all he wants to do is establish himself in his own right, in his own style and ultimately be recognised for that. 
 He cannot hide the pride, though, that he has in following Hare at Leicester. 
 He had only had the single season at Wakefield when the approach came. 
 &bquo;When Peter invited me to the club I knew that Dusty was retiring and that there would be a place up for grabs. 
 I was keen to give it a go because Leicester are one of the top clubs, and so it wasn't something I could refuse, was it? 
 In fact it's the best offer I've ever had, and in any case I always knew I could go back to Wakefield if it did not work out. 
 Better to have a go and fail than not to have a go at all.&equo; 
 So he went, hopping into his car and driving to Leicester every Monday and Thursday night for training, and Saturdays to play. 
 &bquo;It's a round trip of 190 miles so that's almost 600 miles a week. 
 I've got a new car and it's already got 23,000 on the clock, and three-quarters of that must be to the club.&equo; 
 Luckily it is not far to the swimming pool where he works. 
 He found the club welcoming, helped by the fact that it was a path south previously trodden by another Leicester stalwart, Les Cusworth, whom Liley remembers watching as a lad of seven or eight at Wakefield. 
 Liley spent a season playing in the second team with just half a dozen first-team appearances before the opportunity came this season, and so far it has gone remarkably well. 
 The style of play suits him. 
 &bquo;I haven't had to change, really. 
 It's similar to Wakefield, only quicker. 
 I like to run the ball and come into the line. 
 I enjoy that.&equo; 
 He also enjoys the training, which is just as well because it is so competitive. 
 &bquo;It's a lot keener than I'd been used to, because here you are not guaranteed a place. 
 It's very thorough, and if you are not producing the goods on the field you have to do it in training or you'd be out. 
 It's as simple as that. 
 They push you, and I like that.&equo; 
 But it is as a kicker that he has made his name. 
 He uses the soccer method, but unusually for a rugby player, or soccer player for that matter, has the facility to kick well with either foot. 
 He cannot think of anyone else currently playing who can do that. 
 &bquo;I've always been able to do it, probably because I used to play soccer. 
 I started using the technique at Wakefield and carried on ever since.&equo; 
 Basically this involves using the right foot to draw the ball into the post from the left side of the field and the left foot to do the same from the right side. 
 Only for distance &mdash; 30 metres or more and where the advantage of the draw is negated &mdash; does he favour right over left. 
 It is eminently practical, and he thinks he may have started a trend. 
 &bquo;Dusty was such a wonderful kicker that he didn't need to employ it. 
 But now he's retired I've heard that, when he plays in the odd charity match, he has a go now. 
 It's quite flattering, really. 
 They'll all be at it soon.&equo; 
 Rugby League: World Cup points give tasty Test an extra flavour. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 WITH only five sides in contention, it should be possible to devise a World Cup which takes less than three years to complete. 
 The last tournament ended with Australia beating New Zealand in Auckland last year in a game which created enormous interest in New Zealand. 
 But the formula which brought them together was widely, and justifiably, condemned as unwieldy and tedious. 
 Someone must have thought it was a bright idea, though. 
 The whole weary process started again in Auckland in July and continues today at Central Park where Great Britain meet New Zealand in the third British Coal Test. 
 This game &mdash; with the series level at 1-1 &mdash; was in no need of additional stimulus, but even the cynics will have to concede that the reward of two World Cup points has heightened the flavour. 
 It can be taken for granted that Australia will be one side contesting the 1992 World Cup final and that Great Britain or New Zealand will be the other. 
 But which one? 
 New Zealand have already suffered one World Cup defeat. 
 A second loss would be worrying for them &mdash; motivation enough to ensure that the errors of Elland Road are not repeated. 
 Great Britain, for their part, will be looking to recapture the many admirable qualities which brought them that improbable victory after Steve Hampson's early dismissal reduced them to 12 men. 
 Hampson is now serving a suspension, which means a recall for Alan Tait, who would have played at Elland Road but for injury. 
 The other major change sees the very useful Joe Lydon on the bench. 
 Since both sides in this series have now played exceptionally well and exceptionally badly, today's game is absorbingly poised and tantalisingly unpredictable. 
 Conditions are likely to be the heaviest of the season so far and the side &mdash; the pack particularly &mdash; that controls the ball and makes fewer mistakes could carry the day. 
 We saw in the first Test the damage of which Gary Freeman, working behind dominant forwards, is capable; in the second Test, behind a pack tackling itself to a standstill, Shaun Edwards dictated. 
 Both seem sure to be leading figures again. 
 GREAT BRITAIN: Tait (Widnes); Ford (Leeds), Newlove (Featherstone), Loughlin (St Helens), Offiah (Widnes); Edwards (Wigan), D Hulme (Widnes); Skerrett (Bradford N), P Hulme (Widnes), Platt (Wigan), Powell (Leeds), Goodway (Wigan), Gregory (Warrington). 
 Replacements: Lydon (Wigan), Fox (Featherstone), Hobbs (Bradford N), England (Castleford). 
 NEW ZEALAND: Kemp; Iro, Bell, Williams, Mercer; K Shelford, Freeman; Todd, D Mann, Faimalo, Sorensen, Stewart, McGahan. 
 Subs: Sherlock, Clark, Leota, Kuiti. 
 Referee: G McCallum (Australia).. 
 Athletics: Tunstall leads England's Euro Cup challenge. 
 THE European Community Cross Country Cup competition comes to Britain this weekend for the first time, with races at Hartsdown Park in Margate tomorrow, writes John Rodda. 
 British runners have for years plundered the prizes on the Continent most weekends of the winter. 
 The races are usually staged in smaller towns. 
 The Euro Cup competition links together a series of Continental races, with a points-scoring system producing an overall winner. 
 Last year Roger Hackney, the Olympic steeplechaser, took the top prize and Tim Hutchings was among the individual winners in the Christmas Day event at Ninove. 
 This is not, perhaps, the best year for Britain to act as host to open the series, for the entry tomorrow is clearly affected by Commonwealth Games training schedules as well as the fact that the English Cross Country Union has not found a sponsor who can provide the money for trust funds that might have enticed more prominent athletes. 
 Among the leading challengers from the home countries in the men's event will be Steve Tunstall, who stormed through the beginning of the cross country season a year ago with victories at Durham, Cardiff and Mallusk but was clearly weary when it came to the championships. 
 Paul Dugdale, Kevin Forster, Richard Neuraker and Craig Mochrie are among the other entries. 
 The Belgians are likely to provide the individual winner in either Vincent Rousseau, who dominated the Euro Cross from 1984 to 1988, or Joes Maes, a runner-up to Hackney last year. 
 A strong challenge will come from the Dutch, who include two strong contenders, Aart Strichter and Toni Dirks, in their line-up. 
 In the women's event, Jill Hunter, Alison Wyeth and Susan Dilnot are among the entries, with Markeen Redners, winner of the overall competition, leading the overseas challenge from Belgium. 
 The main events are at 12.25 (women) and 1.30 (men) in a day's programme comprising 12 races, the first of which is at 11.05. 
 Boxing: McDonnell fights back. 
 By John Rodda 
 JIM McDONNELL will return to boxing in the new year with determination similar to that he showed against Azumah Nelson in their world title fight last Sunday. 
 McDonnell, stopped in the final round, spent two nights in hospital under observation having his heart rate and pulse carefully monitored. 
 The pain which Nelson's blows caused has now receded and the bruises will go when he takes a week's rest in Spain. 
 But the wounds inflicted by the media will, it appears, take a long time to heal. 
 McDonnell, his promoter Barry Hearn and trainer Darkie Smith clearly believed that going into the final round McDonnell had a chance of winning the super-featherweight title on points. 
 Not many impartial observers agreed &mdash; two of the three judges had him trailing &mdash; and the trio showed their displeasure with such sceptics at yesterday's news conference. 
 Smith said that some of the reporters had been drinking before getting down to the job of covering the fight; Hearn is considering litigation. 
 All three thought it right that the fight continued in the eleventh round when McDonnell's right eye was all but closed, though the fighter admitted he could not see from that eye. 
 The only gain from what at times were acrimonious exchanges may be that the British Boxing Board of Control will renew its vigilance in the protection of its licensed boxers, before a campaign to stop boxing takes on a more menacing shape for those involved in the business. 
 Men like McDonnell are too brave for their own good. 
 Scottish round-up Nicol doubt. 
 By Patrick Glenn 
 ANDY ROXBURGH, Scotland's national coach, spent last night anxious over the availability of Steve Nicol, the Liverpool midfielder-defender central to his plans for the crucial World Cup match with Norway on Wednesday. 
 Nicol has strained neck muscles and, although a member of Kenny Dalglish's squad for today's match against QPR in London, he is unlikely to play. 
 &bquo;The problem is with heading the ball,&equo; said Roxburgh. 
 &bquo;The other day he seemed perfectly sound and was tried out, but as soon as he headed the ball he was in pain again. 
 &bquo;Of course we don't want to lose him. 
 We are already without Gary Gillespie and Richard Gough, and Stevie is full of experience. 
 But we may have to prepare ourselves for his absence. 
 &bquo;If Steve doesn't play for Liverpool he is obviously unlikely to play for us. 
 But if he and the club feel he is close enough to soundness to allow him to travel and let us decide, we will do that. 
 If it is a straightforward call-off, I would have to think of a replacement.&equo; 
 Roxburgh named only a 16-man pool last week. 
 Twelve arrived in Glasgow yesterday, with Dave McPherson (Hearts), Pat Nevin and Stuart McCall (Everton) and Nicol on duty today, and the Manchester United pair, Jim Leighton and Brian McClair, facing Forest tomorrow. 
 McPherson plays for Hearts against Dundee at Tynecastle in the only match in the Premier Division. 
 The Edinburgh side can go top on goal difference ahead of Dunfermline if they win by at least two goals. 
 Whether or not Ray Wilkins is to stay with Rangers or return to one of the London clubs chasing his signature will be known on Monday. 
 Graeme Souness, the Ibrox manager, has promised a statement then. 
 Nicol injury worries Roxburgh. 
 ANDY ROXBURGH, the Scotland coach, spent last night worrying about Steve Nicol, the Liverpool midfielder-defender who is central to his plans for the crucial World Cup match with Norway on Wednesday, writes Patrick Glenn. 
 Nicol has strained neck muscles and although he is in the squad to face QPR today he is not certain to play. 
 &bquo;The problem is with heading the ball,&equo; said Roxburgh. 
 &bquo;The other day he seemed perfectly sound and was tried out, but as soon as he headed the ball he was in pain again. 
 &bquo;We don't want to lose him. 
 We are already without Gary Gillespie and Richard Gough, and Stevie is full of experience. 
 But we may have to prepare ourselves for his absence.&equo; 
 Roxburgh named only an 18-man pool last week. 
 Twelve arrived in Glasgow yesterday, with Dave McPherson (Hearts), Pat Nevin and Stuart McCall (Everton) and Nicol on duty today, and the Manchester United pair Jim Leighton and Brian McClair facing Forest tomorrow. 
 McPherson plays for Hearts against Dundee at Tynecastle in the only match in the Premier Division. 
 The Edinburgh side can go top on goal difference from Dunfermline if they win by at least two goals. 
 Soccer. 
 The Greek champions, AEK Athens, have been banned from European competition for a year because of their fans' misbehaviour in a European Cup match at home to Marseille this month. 
 Judo. 
 Karen Briggs, the world bantamweight champion, has undergone surgery on the shoulder she dislocated in the world championships final in Belgrade last month. 
 Damage to the joint and tendons was more severe than expected, but the 26-year-old from Hull still hopes to compete in January's Commonwealth Games, which feature judo for the first time. 
 Boxing. 
 Noel Quarless, the Liverpool heavyweight, knocked out the American Phil Gilberti after only 2min 58sec at Everton Park sports centre last night. 
 Rowing. 
 Nottingham County seek their sixth straight win in the Fours Head from Mortlake to Putney which starts at 1.30 this afternoon, writes Jon Leyne. 
 The Nottinghamshire quadruple scull will lead off a procession of 500 crews. 
 Their strongest challenge is likely to come from a Leander quad containing the Olympic gold medallist Steve Redgrave. 
 Bishop fires Tranmere up into top place. 
 TRANMERE went back to the top of the Third Division on goal difference last night as they extended their unbeaten home League run to 26 games with a 2-1 win over Walsall. 
 McCarrick put them ahead in the eighth minute and they should have settled it in the 67th when Muir had a penalty saved, but Rimmer made no mistake from the spot to level the scores in the 83rd minute. 
 Tranmere's reply was instant and decisive, Bishop volleying the winner from a free kick. 
 Crewe's 2-1 win over Mansfield was their first in 10 games but they cut it fine, Cutler scoring the winner two minutes from time. 
 Southend's players flew off for a week's break in Spain after a 2-1 win at Halifax which put them five points clear at the top of the Fourth Division. 
 Ling and Martin were the scorers, and their goalkeeper, Sansome, saved a penalty before Juryeff's late consolation goal. 
 Andy Roxburgh, the Scotland coach, spent last night worrying about Steve Nicol, the Liverpool midfielder-defender who is central to his plans for the crucial World Cup match with Norway on Wednesday. 
 Nicol has strained neck muscles and although he is in the squad to face QPR today he is not certain to play. 
 Ian Ridley. 
 SUPPORTERS are merely necessary evils to some clubs, it seems. 
 The idea of their having a say in the running of a club appears to make officials recoil with horror. 
 Take Birmingham City, who you might think could hardly afford to alienate more of their fans. 
 In an attempt to widen share ownership, Matthew Cole, Blues fan and co-editor of the fanzine Tired and Weary, last year offered to surrender 49 of his 50 shares in the club, for just the small cost of the re-registration, to 49 other fans. 
 Surprisingly, some cynics might say, 49 people did take up the offer and the details were sent to the club to effect the paperwork. 
 Twelve months on, the club have yet to do so, despite numerous requests to the City secretary John Westmancoat. 
 &bquo;We suspect they don't want fans to become shareholders and bring up awkward matters at the annual meeting,&equo; says TaW's other co-editor, Steve Beauchamp. 
 &bquo;They seem to think we are troublemakers but we have women, children and people over 70 years of age.&equo; 
 Mr Westmancoat gave a &bquo;no comment&equo; when contacted about the issue this week. 
 He was being given the right of reply, it was pointed out, at which point he put the phone down. 
 THE appearance of the former Wolves defender Derek Jefferson in last week's column prompted a golden memory of 1975/76 from Iain Woods of Great Barr, Birmingham. 
 In those days Jeffo was assisting in the University of Warwick's soccer training. 
 &bquo;During one practice session,&equo; writes Iain, &bquo;I perpetrated the highest, latest and crudest tackle of my life on the first XI's star player, a footballer of considerable skill. 
 As I stood back to admire my handiwork, Jefferson stood back, shaking his head in disappointment. 
 &bquo;Not good enough, son,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;He's getting up&equo;.&equo;. 
 ANOTHER hard-man of the Seventies, Liverpool's Tommy Smith, recently surfaced in a tabloid newspaper, berating Nayim of Tottenham for an &bquo;Oscar performance&equo; when collapsing after being elbowed by Barry Venison in the televised match at Anfield. 
 &bquo;How can anyone justify such shameful behaviour?&equo; lamented Smith. 
 How indeed, writes P Kevan of Liverpool, who recalls a similar incident. 
 This one involved the very same T Smith, who claimed he was hit by a bottle thrown from the crowd as Liverpool's European Cup Winners' Cup hopes were ebbing away against Ferencvaros in Budapest 15 years ago. 
 Our reporter, Paul Fizpatrick, wrote at the time: &bquo;Smith, perhaps too theatrically, fell as if poleaxed.&equo; 
 Paul added that it rekindled memories of a Borussia Moenchengladbach v Inter Milan tie which had to be replayed after a similar incident two seasons earlier. 
 Neither the referee, who booked him, nor Uefa accepted Smith's version of the event. 
 He was later suspended for two European games for &bquo;unsporting behaviour&equo;. 
 ARECENT mention in this column of Brian Clough's belief in &bquo;clean sheets and good habits&equo; recalled, for Peter Gibbon of Sheffield, programme notes from a Sheffield Eagles Rugby League match. 
 As a result of the closure of Owlerton Stadium, they stated, supporters would &bquo;have to put up with a certain amount of incontinence&equo;. 
 LAST of the wine. 
 Many readers kindly recommend their favourite labels, Leicester's Peter Sjobergundy (Oliver Beamish, London E5) and Liverpool's Sammy Chablis (Mick Clark, Stockport), for example. 
 Others pointed to younger grapes such as Veuve Clicottee (Matthew Mainstone, Brighton), Vin den Hauwe &mdash; limited shelf life &mdash; (Michael Booth, Doncaster), Azay-le-Rideout (Colin Draper, Sheffield) and Cotes de Rushillon (Tony Heslop, Liverpool). 
 Tony also suggests that the Luton ground, where Kenny Dalglish regularly enjoys a good wine, should have an Application Controlee. 
 Chick Fowles of London SE3, moreover, feels that Charlton should have a Relegation Controlee. 
 And if Sheffield Wednesday (Owlsace &mdash; Ian Johnson of Vanlose, Denmark) are consigned to an early Graves, Peter Godfrey of Chorley thinks Ron Atkinson will get the Barsac. 
 Alan Duffy of Whitley Bay, who once returned a bottle in a restaurant because it was Alan Corked, says that Newcastle fans are now chanting &bquo;Vouvray The Lads&equo;. 
 Ian Charlton of London E5 says Clive Allen left Spurs because Bordeaux St Emilion (try it phonetically). 
 My thanks to all for a superior vintage. 
 Grobbelaar under renewed pressure from Hooper. 
 By Cynthia Bateman 
 THE Liverpool manager Kenny Dalglish has included two goalkeepers in his 15-man squad for today's game at Queen's Park Rangers. 
 Mike Hooper, who replaced Bruce Grobbelaar for 25 games last season, is in &bquo;on merit&equo;, the manager said yesterday. 
 Hooper's inclusion is seen as a move by Dalglish to introduce the fear factor after three defeats in four games, in which Grobbelaar let in six goals, including four at Southampton. 
 That was Liverpool's heaviest defeat since Hooper conceded four at West Ham in the Littlewoods Cup last season. 
 The last time the 25-year-old Hooper was given a chance was when Grobbelaar contracted meningitis early last season. 
 The reserve goalkeeper held on to the place for four months, and was selected for several weeks after Grobbelaar returned to action with the reserves. 
 Steve Nicol should be back in the defence today, but Dalglish must also be concerned about his strikers. 
 Liverpool have scored only twice in the past four games, and Rush, with six this season, has not hit the net since the middle of September. 
 Manchester City last night signed the Blackburn Rovers centre-back Colin Hendry for &pound;700,000, of which &pound;200,000 goes to his former club Dundee. 
 Gary Penrice, the Bristol Rovers striker, has moved to Watford for &pound;500,000. 
 The fee is just &pound;50,000 short of Watford's record of &pound;550,000, for Luther Blissett from AC Milan. 
 The Rovers directors meet this weekend in an attempt to end the dilemma over whether to sell the club's England Under-21 goalkeeper Nigel Martyn to Crystal Palace. 
 There have been snags over the asking price of &pound;1million, a record for a goalkeeper. 
 Mick Mills, replaced at Stoke by Alan Ball, has moved in the opposite direction, succeeding the caretaker manager by becoming Colchester coach. 
 He is expected to become Colchester's manager when Jock Wallace retires next year. 
 Table Tennis: Mason breaks Soviet spirit. 
 By Richard Jago 
 NICKY MASON, ranked No.5, showed during England's outstanding 5-1 victory over the Soviet Union at Worthing on Thursday night that he is pushing for regular inclusion in the England team. 
 He repeated the best win of his career &mdash; over the Soviet No.1, Andrei Mazunov, in Moscow last season &mdash; by saving a game point at 21-22 and going on to win 24-22, 21-12. 
 It put England 2-0 up and seemed to break the spirit of the world bronze medallists. 
 Alan Cooke and Carl Prean scored two wins each, with Prean again suggesting he is pushing Cooke for the England No.1 position. 
 Remarkably the Mazunovs, Andrei and Dmitri, sustained three defeats between them, with Cooke also beating Andrei. 
 Dmitri had beaten Prean in the semi-finals of the Austrian Open on Sunday before going on to take the title. 
 This time Prean coped with noise from the extractor fans, his opponent's booming backhand and an early 6-11 deficit before winning 21-16, 21-17. 
 Gomer and Javer discarded. 
 TWO of the top three women in Britain's national rankings, Sara Gomer and Monique Javer, have been left out of the British team for the European championships which take place in Nantes from November 23 to 26. 
 Clare Wood, who beat Gomer in the national singles final at Telford last weekend, replaces her in a team completed by Jo Durie and Anne Hobbs. 
 Britain's opponents in the First Division are the USSR, France, Italy, Sweden and the Netherlands. 
 Hendry makes his move but Martyn waits. 
 MANCHESTER CITY have completed the &pound;700,000 signing of the Blackburn Rovers defender Colin Hendry. 
 The 23-year-old Scot has signed too late to play at Derby today but should make his debut in City colours against Coventry reserves next week. 
 Gary Penrice, the Bristol Rovers striker, has moved to Watford for &pound;500,000. 
 The fee is just &pound;50,000 short of Watford's record, &pound;550,000 for Luther Blissett from AC Milan. 
 The Rovers directors will be meeting this weekend in an attempt to end the dilemma over whether the club's England Under-21 goalkeeper Nigel Martyn really is bound for Crystal Palace. 
 There have been last-minute snags over the asking price of &pound;1million, a record for a goalkeeper, and not every director favours the sale so soon after the departure of Penrice. 
 Mick Mills, replaced at Stoke by Alan Ball, has moved in the opposite direction, succeeding the caretaker manager by becoming Colchester coach. 
 Mills is expected to become Colchester's manager when Jock Wallace retires at the end of the season. 
 Ron Futcher has completed a &pound;60,000 move from Port Vale to Burnley &mdash; the 33-year-old striker's 12th club. 
 England could be sent to Sicily. 
 By Paddy Agnew in Rome 
 ENGLAND may not, as had been widely expected, play all their opening World Cup finals games in Sardinia next year. 
 With Spain pushing hard for one of the first six seeded places, England could find themselves unseeded and playing in Sicily too, as the side ranked No.2 in a Group F headed by Belgium. 
 In Rome, Italia &bquo;90's director-general, Luca Di Montezemolo, acknowledged that Spain were putting pressure on Fifa. 
 Were they, because of their political pull within soccer's international body, to be seeded, then that would be at the expense of England. 
 It had been believed that England would be seeded to head Group F and would thus be based in Calgiari, Sardinia. 
 Fifa, Italia '90 and the English FA are all agreed that the hooligan element among English fans could be better contained if England played their opening games on an island. 
 The key to the seeding argument is Article 24 of Fifa's World Cup rule book, which in effect allows it to use whatever criterion it thinks fit when allocating seeds. 
 Spain claim to be entitled to a seeding at England's expense because they finished seventh in the Mexico World Cup finals in 1986, one place ahead of England. 
 The Spanish candidacy is being supported by Turin, one of the six cities in which the six seeds will be based for the first round. 
 At the moment Italy (the hosts) will be based in Rome, Argentina (the holders) in Naples, Brazil in Milan, and West Germany in Verona &mdash; leaving Belgium, England or Spain for Turin and Calgiari. 
 As semi-finalists in 1986, Belgium seem guaranteed a seeded position. 
 Were England seeded, they would be sent to Calgiari, leaving Belgium to go to Turin. 
 This has not gone down too well with the Torinese, who want a more prestigious side to inaugurate their new stadium. 
 Luca Argentieri, an Italia '90 spokesman, said last night that for obvious security reasons it was still desirable to send England to an island. 
 Sicily is the only other island to stage World Cup matches. 
 He confirmed that in the event of Spain being preferred to England in the seedings, then Spain would play in Turin and Belgium in Calgiari. 
 England, therefore, would play two first-round games in Palermo and one in Calgiari. 
 The great onion disaster 
 FOR THE LAST three weeks, officials of the United Nations Fund for Drug Abuse Control (UNFDAC) have been trying to sell thousands of tons of onions. 
 They have been pestering other UN agencies, embassies and local traders, so far without success. 
 Last year, UN officials in the district of Dir, Pakistan's most prolific opium-growing region, advised thousands of local farmers to grow onions instead of the lucrative poppies. 
 Farmers were told they would make pots of money, more than the heroin processors in the neighbouring, largely tribal agency of Bajaur could hope to offer. 
 Moreover, they were told that if anything went wrong the United Nations would guarantee them a market for their onions. 
 Convinced by the foreigners &mdash; and the then high price of onions &mdash; the farmers took the plunge on a large scale. 
 Whole villages went over to onions, and narcotics officials beamed with pleasure and satisfaction. 
 Crop substitution was working. 
 The experience was enough to make an opium farmer weep. 
 UN officials were seemingly unaware of developments in Islamabad, the Pakistani capital. 
 The federal government decided that exports of vegetables were contributing to the soaring inflation rate, and banned them. 
 The result was a home market swamped with onions, and a halving of prices. 
 In Dir, unsold onions are rotting. 
 The local UN office has been inundated with angry farmers. 
 &bquo;They've been arriving in scores, each delegation with one appointed English speaker&equo; said an official. 
 &bquo;I don't blame them for their anger.&equo; 
 One young farmer, Shermani Yussef, said that for the first time in his life he had been forced to lease some of his land to cover his losses. 
 If he had grown opium on his half acre, he would have been guaranteed at least 20,000 rupees. 
 There would have been no trouble about marketing, as the Bajaur heroin processors obligingly collect the opium from the farm. 
 The likely result of the Great Onion Disaster is that the Dir district will return to its traditional crop of opium with a vengeance. 
 During the enforcement season the bumper crop will be burnt by the army. 
 And UN officials are being advised to leave. 
 Samizdat. 
 ON JULY 14 this year, Dai Qing, one of China's most prominent journalists, was arrested and her flat in Beijing ransacked. 
 She was a columnist with the Guangming Ribao (The Enlightenment Daily), a &bquo;quality&equo; newspaper, and an editor of Donggang Jishi (Chronicle of the East), a new journal about politics and literature. 
 At the time of her arrest, Dai Qing was working on a series of studies entitled Modern Chinese Intellectuals: From Liang Qichao to Fang Lizhi, in order, as she put it, to fill in some of the &bquo;memory holes&equo; of the history of the Chinese Communist Party. 
 Dai Qing was arrested two weeks after the Mayor of Beijing, Chen Xitong, had delivered a 15,000-word report to the standing committee of the National People's Congress (Parliament) on &bquo;checking the turmoil and quelling the counter-rebellion&equo; &mdash; the June clampdown on the pro-democracy movement. 
 Dai Qing's name was singled out as one of the &bquo;tiny handful of people&equo; who had &bquo;colluded with foreign forces, ganged up among themselves at home and made ideological, public opinion and organisational preparations for years to stir up turmoil in China, overthrow the leadership of the Communist Party and subvert the socialist people's republic.&equo; 
 On September 13 the Guangming Ribao, pilloried her on the front page under the headline, Dai Qing &mdash; the Rebellion &bquo;Reporter&equo;. 
 The opening paragraph described her as having &bquo;gone all out to play an extremely ignominious role by jumping around to establish ties, make outcries, agitate the people, fan the flames, and add fuel to them. 
 This was Dai Qing, a reporter of the Guangming Ribao&equo;. 
 Dai Qing's whereabouts, like thousands of others arrested since June, are not known. 
 If brought to trial, she can expect a long prison sentence, followed by &bquo;re-education through labour&equo; in a camp in Qinghai &mdash; &bquo;China's Siberia&equo; &mdash; an Area like the Sahara desert, in the west of the country, where the climate is notorious for its boiling heat in summer and freezing temperatures in winter. 
 &bquo;Counter-revolutionary&equo; crimes are serious offences punishable by a bullet in the neck in some cases. 
 Dai Qing, brought up in one of China's most privileged families, has an impeccable revolutionary pedigree. 
 Born in Chongqing in 1946, the daughter of a revolutionary martyr, she was adopted by the family of Ye Jianying, one of the famous 10 marshals of the People's Liberation Army. 
 Marshal Ye Jianying (now dead) was a member of the Standing Committee of the Party's Politburo. 
 Dai Qing is married, with a daughter. 
 After graduating from the Harbin Military Technology Institute, she worked at the People's Liberation Army General Staff headquarters. 
 Between 1979 and 1982, she worked at the Foreign Relations Office of the Chinese Writers' Association. 
 In 1982, she joined Guangming Ribao as a reporter, becoming known for her writings on women's issues and her interviews with leading intellectuals. 
 In the early 1980s, because of her past connection with the military establishment, intellectuals tended to shun her and rumours had it that she worked for the Chinese KGB, the Ministry of State Security. 
 She told one foreign reporter that she knew of the rumours and laughed them off, saying, &bquo;If my relationship with the General Staff makes me a secret agent, maybe I am!&equo; 
 Other sources say that she was an intelligence reject, mainly because of her rebellious and unpredictable personality. 
 She told another foreign reporter that she had spent most of her time at the General Staff learning English. 
 In August 1988, Dai Qing was invited to speak at a banquet in Hong Kong held in honour of Liu Binyan, the most famous &bquo;investigative reporter&equo; of the People's Daily, the official organ of the Chinese Communist Party. 
 Liu Binyan had been expelled from the party and dismissed from his post in 1987, and is living in exile in the US. 
 Now one of the most wanted men in China, Liu Binyan &mdash; whose faith in the Communist Party still endures &mdash; spoke of his writings as a &bquo;second kind of loyalty&equo; to the party. 
 Dai Qing shocked the audience by declaring: &bquo;I don't care what Binyang says about his second kind of loyalty; even the third, fourth or fifth kind of loyalty won't save China&equo;. 
 In February this year, Dai Qing was at the forefront of the campaign to stop the Yangtze River Three Gorges Dam Project. 
 She wrote: &bquo;The reason China is in the state it is today after four decades of &bquo;peacetime construction&equo; is that every time a situation arises when people should shout &bquo;No&equo; to avert a serious policy error, there is nothing but silence.&equo; 
 She became known as the Chinese &bquo;Green&equo; leader. 
 On March 14, Dai Qing and two friends wrote an open letter to the National People's Congress, which was signed by 40 intellectuals and supported earlier appeals for the release of Wei Jingsheng and other political prisoners. 
 For Guangming Ribao (September 13), this was proof of Dai Qing's determination to have a confrontation with the authorities and showed &bquo;Dai Qing's basic objective to influence society and intervene in politics with independent personal characters and independent thinking.&equo; 
 ON APRIL 26, Qin Benli, the editor of the Shanghai-based Shijie Jingjie Dao Bao (World Economic Herald) was sacked for publishing notes of a forum calling for the rehabilitation of Hu Yaobang, the former disgraced Communist Party's general secretary who died in April this year, and expressing support for the student demonstrations in Tiananmen Square. 
 It was Dai Qing who rallied other journalists to send messages of support for Qin Benli, urging his reinstatement. 
 This, and her close association with the World Economic Herald, were proof of her &bquo;bourgeois liberalism,&equo; according to the Guangming Ribao. 
 On May 3, Dai Qing and a number of Chinese intellectuals, marking the 70th anniversary of the May 4 Movement, called on the Party to continue with the liberal reforms and supported the demands of the students. 
 Dai Qing was often seen in Tiananmen Square talking to student demonstrators, and being interviewed by foreign journalists. 
 She became a mediator between the authorities and student leaders, and on a number of occasions tried to persuade students to end their hunger strike, leave Tiananmen Square and return to campus. 
 Some writers and journalists ridiculed her appeals, which were often received with hostility by militant students. 
 There were allegations that she was a &bquo;government agent.&equo; 
 In mid-May, she told one foreign reporter that bloody repression would be inevitable if the students did not withdraw. 
 This prediction, according to the same source, was based on her privileged knowledge. 
 However, for Guangming Ribao, all her appeals to students to end the demonstrations had an ulterior motive. 
 The paper quoted her speech to the students in Tiananmen Square on May 14 when she said &bquo;Attack when attack is called for&equo; and &bquo;withdraw is a must.&equo; 
 It said this really meant &bquo;withdrawing for the purpose of attacking again.&equo; 
 MARTIAL law was declared in Beijing on May 20, and the massacres in Tiananmen Square took place on June 4. 
 Outraged by the bloody repression, Dai Qing publicly resigned from the Communist Party and said that she would distance herself from politics to concentrate on her writings. 
 She was reported to be deeply depressed and feeling dejected. 
 What was remarkable about the long article on her in her own newspaper were the details of her whereabouts and all her speeches during her pro-democracy movement in the spring, which were selectively presented to incriminate her. 
 It was worthy of the Security Bureau. 
 Apart from the personal attacks, its indictment of her political and ideological ideas went back as far as 1978 when she published her novel Await. 
 Guangming Ribao concluded: &bquo;Dai Qing's various activities in the turmoil and counter-revolutionary riot in Beijing are not accidental. 
 They have their deep-rooted, ideological source. 
 They are the inevitable result of her stand in advocating bourgeois liberalisation over a period of time.&equo; 
 The article ended with the following paragraph: &bquo;Actually, how could Dai Qing be an elite of China's intelligentsia? 
 She is nothing but a pawn of reactionary forces at home and abroad who are trying to turn China into a bourgeois republic. 
 Dai Qing was a member of the rebellious group during the Cultural Revolution. 
 Her name was Fu Ming. 
 After the Cultural Revolution, she changed her name to Dai Qing. 
 However, although she changed her name her thought remained unchanged. 
 She only changed from an ultra-leftist to an ultra-rightist. 
 Whenever there is a chance, she and her partners will emerge and stir up trouble. 
 But they will never be able to achieve their goal. 
 The fact that the Chinese people have promptly quelled the counter-revolutionary riot in Beijing has completely shattered their fond dream.&equo; 
 Lek Hor Tan is Asia researcher of Index on Censorship, 39c Highbury Pl, N5. 
 Tel 359 0161 
 Sir Julian Bullard, former British Ambassador in Bonn, looks into a future full of fear and expectation in Central Europe and charts Britain's role The time to shed our illusions. 
 DURING my time in Germany (1984-88) the British Ambassadors in Bonn and East Berlin would twice a year set off on an official tour, once in his territory and once in mine, to gather impressions about the relationship between the two parts of the divided German nation and how it might develop. 
 Year after year we came home convinced that &bquo;all-German&equo; emotions, though officially discouraged on one side and dormant on the other, were far from dead, and that the post-war arrangements in central Europe were therefore a lot less permanent than they might seem. 
 So the East German events of this week were an earthquake waiting to happen. 
 Historians will argue over what was the causa causans and which the causa sine qua non. 
 My own choice for the single most influential factor would be the decision of the Hungarian Government to subordinate its very clear obligations under an agreement with the GDR to its general duty under the Helsinki Final Act of 1975 &mdash; a decision which blew a hole in the sealed frontiers of the GDR, and relegated to the past the comfortable slogans of the last three decades. 
 Since then it is events rather than governments that have been in command. 
 Gorbachev's warning to Honecker not to postpone the necessary reforms was a smoke alarm soon drowned by the blaze. 
 Krenz's programme of measures may have to make way for a more revolutionary alternative &mdash; and Krenz too. 
 So this is a time for shedding illusions and for staking up such relative certainties as exist. 
 I will list some of the latter: 1. 
 Whatever happens in Central Europe must pass the test of self-determination. 
 It saddens me to hear some people in Britain speak as if there were some way of keeping Germany divided whether or not this is what the Germans want. 
 That may be a tenable position for the Soviet Union, but not for Britain, which has committed itself repeatedly to accepting both self-determination for the German people and a re-united Germany if this is what self- determination leads to. 
 2. 
 But this does not mean accepting whatever kind of Greater Germany may come into being. 
 The four principal victors of 1945 retain responsibility for &bquo;Berlin and Germany as a whole&equo;. 
 They cannot exercise it without regard for the wishes of the German people, but neither can the German people act as if the &bquo;German question&equo; concerned nobody but themselves. 
 This is a matter of international law, and of politics too. 
 It was a Christian Democrat Chancellor of the Federal Republic (Kurt Georg Kiesinger) who said that a reunified Germany would be &bquo;a critical mass&equo;. 
 In other words, it would need to be held in place by a strong political framework. 
 It would be helpful if matching promises could now be made by Washington, London and Paris, that they will exercise their residual responsibilities only in the direction requested by the German people, and by Bonn, that the German right of self-determination will be exercised only in consultation with the three Western Allies. 
 3. 
 Reunification need not, and probably will not, come overnight. 
 But it could start overnight, and indeed it has already started. 
 The GDR's borders are now open, and the Government in Bonn poised to jump in with massive economic support for the process of political reform as it develops. 
 The West has money and know-how, the East has greenfield sites in plenty: the GDR is 60 per cent less densely populated than the FRG. 
 In a few years time the two German states could be virtually a single economic area. 
 4. 
 The European Community should recognise its limitations. 
 Current attempts to link its internal to its external development have something synthetic about them. 
 The coming battle for the soul of Central Europe will not be decided on the playing fields of EMU, nor by throwing in the sheepmeat regime at the decisive moment. 
 The GDR is already a country member of the EC, with free access to the markets of the FRG. 
 The EC could absorb the 16.5 million East Germans, if it came to that, more easily than it could the two countries whose applications already lie on the table in Brussels &mdash; Austria with her backward deck-cargo of neutrality, and Turkey, with her GDP well below that of Portugal. 
 But full membership must always be a complex package of rights and responsibilities, requiring, first, years of negotiations and then years of transition. 
 If the EC is looking for ways to help the reform process in Central Europe, it should dust off Article 238 of the Treaty of Rome, whose benign language allows &bquo;Association&equo; of almost any kind. 
 5. 
 Berlin, in the present context, is more symbolic than significant. 
 With all of the GDR's western frontier open, the Wall is the most convenient crossing point only for those who want to go no further than the Kurfurstendamm. 
 Cocooned in its Quadripartite Status, Berlin does nobody any harm at present. 
 If and when re-unification came about, the Four Powers would lift their hand from the city as they lifted it from &bquo;Germany as a whole&equo;. 
 Whether then Berlin became the national capital would be a matter for the German people to decide. 
 6. 
 The question of Germany's frontiers, still unsettled today as a matter of strict international law, will likewise fall into place as part of any new arrangement in Central Europe. 
 This means the definitive and final recognition of the present frontiers of Poland. 
 The territories beyond the Oder-Neisse line are already lost to Germany. 
 So the sacrifice will be more formal than real, and it will be in the general interest, and it must be made. 
 To approach the military aspect is to move from relative certainties to what the old joke calls &bquo;a higher level of ignorance&equo;. 
 The phrase &bquo;the two military alliances&equo; implies a resemblance which never existed, but today the fates of Nato and the Warsaw Pact do seem strangely linked, like Jacob and his cryptic antagonist in Genesis 32. 
 Alongside their traditional functions (which grow ever harder to explain to a public caught up in the excitement of recent developments), they offer a general reassurance against unpleasant surprises; a brake on events which could otherwise outstrip our power to control them. 
 But how exactly should the future of Nato and the Warsaw Pact be fitted together with the future of Central Europe? 
 An answer can only be given in the kind of perspective which the processes of East-West reconciliation and arms control may, in any case, create: a perspective in which the strategic factors progressively diminish in importance, until the 19 Soviet divisions now stationed in the GDR have no more significance than a knight or bishop stranded on a square of a chessboard which no longer figures in the game. 
 Uncertain, too, is the broad political picture that may emerge in Europe under the influence of the radical changes now in progress. 
 The West German Foreign Minister has spoken of a &bquo;new European Peace Order,&equo; Lord Callaghan of a new Concert of Europe. 
 Both ideas imply an arrangement transcending the present division between Nato and Warsaw Pact and neutrals, EC and EFTA and Comecon. 
 Here is a vision for the think-tanks to ponder and put some flesh on. 
 Meanwhile, there is a perilous stretch of water to be navigated. 
 President Gorbachev's record as fairy godmother to the cause of democratic revolution, first in Beijing and now in East Berlin, may have caught our fancy in the West, but to some in Moscow he must seem more of a wicked stepmother, turning the achievements of Socialism to dust wherever he goes. 
 When Khrushchev fell in 1964 his colleagues in the Politburu leaked an indictment of 29 charges against him. 
 It would be surprising if a similar tally were not being kept in Moscow now, against the day when Gorbachev may over-reach himself. 
 In the GDR, as in the Soviet Union, the reformist trend could certainly be checked, even if not reversed. 
 And in the West, the situation will require exceptional skills on the part of our present leaders &mdash; especially in West Germany, where a string of elections over the next 12 months will make it hard for those in power to preserve the calm and objectivity with which all these questions need to be discussed. 
 So the political maturity of the Federal Republic and its institutions will be tested as never before. 
 Anger at Caspar Weinberger award. 
 ON MONDAY November 13, the University of Leeds plans to award Caspar Weinberger an honorary degree in Law. 
 Are we to assume that he is to be honoured for his illustrious career as US Secretary of State for Defence? 
 The University appears, then, to have great admiration for the fact that, among other things, Caspar Weinberger: a) supported the Contra rebels in a war which led to the deaths of some 30,000 Nicaraguans and which was declared illegal by the International Court of Justice. 
 Ironically, it is with an honorary degree in Law that the University now wishes to recognise him; b) actively encouraged military spending in such areas as &bquo;Star Wars&equo;, chemical weapons and first-strike nuclear weapons systems; c) attempted to scupper all arms control agreements and moves towards detente with the Eastern bloc. 
 Given this, he is clearly not the servant to &bquo;Peace and Humanity&equo; that Leeds University has billed him, and there must surely be many people who deserve the honour more obviously. 
 The award also has deeper implications. 
 Leeds, like most universities, is watching its government grant shrink each year. 
 It would seem that Caspar Weinberger &mdash; apparently a strange choice on grounds of achievement &mdash; would be a useful contact in the lucratively immoral world of weapons research. 
 This is both a plausible theory and one with disturbing implications. 
 We object to the awarding by the University of Leeds of an honorary degree to such a man and urge the university authorities to reconsider. 
 We also most strongly oppose the increasing trend of greater military funding of higher education and the erosion of the independence of its institutions. 
 Eddie Goncalves (Co-Ordinator, Leeds University Union CND &amp; peace group), John Baruch (Yorkshire Convenor, Scientists Against Nuclear Arms), Gillian Anderson (General Secretary, Leeds University Union), Simon Hughes MP (Liberal Democrats Education Spokesperson), Meg Beresford (General Secretary, Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament), Julian Jacobs (General Secretary, Nicaragua Solidarity Campaign), Rob Evans (Campaign Against Military Research on Campus). 
 Walter Tkach:. 
 WALTER Tkach served three American Presidents as White House doctor &mdash; Eisenhower, Kennedy and Nixon. 
 He also ran the medical dispensary at General MacArthur headquarters in Tokio during the US occupation of Japan. 
 A doctor who liked a life of action, as an Air Force major general he spent the Korean War years as a surgeon and during the Vietnam War flew into combat zones to help the wounded. 
 It was typical of him that after serving as an assistant White House physician during the eight years of the Eisenhower Administration, he became restless after eight months with the more liberal Kennedy Administration and left the White House for service as a deputy surgeon with the Pacific Air Forces, becoming command surgeon of the 7th Air Force in South Vietnam. 
 He was a friend of Richard Nixon, however, and when Nixon was elected president in 1968, he returned to the White House as the president's physician. 
 After Nixon's resignation, he reverted to his other persona, and became command surgeon for the Air Force Systems Command at Andrews Air Force Base outside Washington DC, retiring in 1979. &mdash; W.J.W. 
 Breaking down the barriers to true freedom in East Germany. 
 EXAMPLES are not hard to find which prove that capitalism and democracy, though they may sometimes exist together, are certainly not synonymous. 
 In the midst of the dramatic events now taking place in East Germany, the demands for free elections in the GDR are usually linked with assumptions that these will result in a market economy on capitalist lines. 
 To presuppose this is both contradictory and dangerous; contradictory because the West cannot insist on a certain outcome from free elections and still uphold democracy; dangerous because, if the confusion of the two in the public mind persists, there will be many more instances of superpowers subverting elected governments because they have not opted for a market economy. 
 Nicaragua is a case in point. 
 There is, of course, a moral argument in favour of encouraging democracy in the countries of eastern Europe but the choice between a planned economy and an unfettered market must be left to them. 
 Above all, we must ourselves acknowledge that democracy is not incompatible with either. 
 Harvey Quilliam. 
 6 Poulevara House, West Oakhill Park, Liverpool. 
 AFTER the recent wonderful developments in eastern Europe, particularly the fall of the Berlin Wall, can we now have a bit more freedom &mdash; other than the freedom to spend money. 
 For example, a civil Bill of Rights and the introduction of a fair electoral system, namely proportional representation? 
 Sue Atkinson. 
 Castle Street, Stroud, Glos. 
 Obituary: Margarete Buber-Neumann. 
 MARGARETE Buber-Neumann lived and suffered much in the eye of the storm of history that tore Europe apart, and died just as the world was watching incredulously what seems to be the great schism's healing. 
 As a young socialist in Weimar Germany she shared her life and ideals first with Rafael Buber, son of the Jewish theologian and philosopher Martin Buber, then with Heinz Neumann, who was to become leader of the German Communist party until Stalin had him removed in 1932. 
 In 1935 they were summoned to Moscow by the Comintern and in April 1937 Neumann was arrested by the NKVD and disappeared for ever. 
 A year later, Margarete followed him into the darkness of Stalin's police underworld, but after a time in a Siberian camp had the honour of forming part of a present from Stalin to Hitler, being one of several hundred German political prisoners &bquo;of interest&equo; handed over to the Gestapo near Brest-Litovsk in 1940 after the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact. 
 This might seem more than enough for one life, but in the Ravensbruck concentration camp to which she was now sent she met the woman with whom she formed the other crucial relationship of her life, with Milena Jesenska, whose own life experience drew Margarete intensely, if vicariously, into another of the crucial Central European milieux of that period &mdash; the Prager Kreis of Willy Haas, Max Brod and Kafka, whose lover, and early translator, Milena was. 
 Margarete's memorialising book about Milena, published when the author was already in her late seventies, gives grimly graphic pictures of camp life, and underlines, as if it were needed, how the two womens' all too comprehensive experience of two totalitarian systems led Milena to declare that Stalinism and Hitlerism were indistinguishable (as a result of which the communists' leader in the camp declared that &bquo;after the liberation Milena Jesenska and Margarete Buber-Neumann would be stood up against the wall by the Red Army.&equo; 
 In the event, Milena died practically in Margerete's arms in 1944, and it was the Americans who liberated Ravensbruck. 
 Thereafter, much of Margarete's unquenchable energies were devoted to telling in books and lectures what she knew of the story which Solzhenitsyn would describe definitively in his Gulag trilogy, and to trying to inoculate the young against the totalitarian virus wherever she thought she saw the threat of it. 
 For all her tempering in the fires of history, she remained an impassioned idealist to the end of her long life, though with enough self-knowledge and self-irony to be able to record what Milena Jesenska said about the difference between them &mdash; &bquo;What an incurable girl guide you are. 
 I'm an inveterate city slicker&equo;. 
 W.L.Webb Margarete Buber-Neumann (nee Thuring), born Potsdam, October 21, 1901; died Frankfurt, November 6, 1989. 
 Clapham tragedy highlights transport policy dangers. 
 SIR ANTHONY Hidden QC has omitted one place to lay the blame for the Clapham disaster &mdash; the law lords who decided in the &bquo;Fares Fair&equo; case that an &bquo;economic&equo; transport system was one that made a profit or broke even on fares charged, rather than one that could expect support from ratepayers or taxpayers. 
 The result has been that &bquo;investment at the highest levels ever&equo; has come from fares, not from any public purse, and that an &bquo;economic&equo; system has become unsafe as BR and LRT weigh up commercial investment needs against the cost of safety measures and the cost of paying wages sufficient to maintain a safe level of staffing. 
 What the GLC were hoping to do with London's transport system now looks quite farsighted, and the learned judge's remark that Ken Livingstone &bquo;had made a naked grasp for power that must not be allowed&equo; just silly. 
 But the political spite it betrayed must at least rank as a contributory factor in the sequence of events that led to Clapham and King's Cross. 
 (Rev) S.Parish. 
 1A Fitzherbert Street, Warrington. 
 BRITISH RAIL already spend large sums of money on advertising. 
 Their TV adverts, which show contented passengers relaxing on clean, modern, uncrowded and efficient trains, whilst enjoying the attentions of friendly and caring staff, are far from the reality we all experience. 
 Behind the scenes they have been steadily resisting, for many years, the introduction of even the most basic and cheap safety measures such as cab radios. 
 I would have added a further recommendation to the Clapham conclusions: that British Rail should forthwith desist from any further advertising expenditure and re-route the money to the improvement of safety and engineering standards. 
 To spend corporate money telling us that &bquo;it isn't so&equo; when we all know that it is, insults our intelligence as well as endangering our lives. 
 V.P.Hill. 
 London NW3. 
 THE GOVERNMENT'S involvement in undermining attempts to freeze carbon dioxide emissions by the year 2000 (Guardian, November 8) should perhaps be viewed together with the Department of Transport's recently announced road-building programme, and projections that UK road traffic will increase by about 43 per cent over the next 20-30 years. 
 In the same issue, it is reported that Sir Anthony Hidden's investigation into the Clapham Junction rail crash criticises British Rail for not preventing &bquo;commercial considerations of a business-led railway from compromising safety,&equo; and asserts that excessive overtime should be ended, and that there should be curbs on overcrowding in trains. 
 &bquo;Can you give up your car?&equo; asked the Guardian not very long ago. 
 The answer has to be an emphatic &bquo;no&equo;; not until the Government is switches funding from road-building to investing in the railway infrastructure, which remains the most sensible alternative. 
 Geoff Palmer. 
 Stamford Bridge, York. 
 Emergency calls for action. 
 IN TRYING to split off nine-tenths of ambulance drivers' journeys as &bquo;non-emergency,&equo; Mr Kenneth Clarke attempts to separate the inseparable. 
 At any time, a &bquo;routine&equo; journey may become an emergency. 
 GPs probably spend a similar proportion of time on patients who are not in immediate danger. 
 They are paid, as ambulance drivers should be, for &bquo;being there&equo; (as the drivers still are) with their skill and know-how. 
 (Rev) Ernest Moore. 
 Harrogate, N. Yorks. 
 SO Mr Clarke says the ambulance dispute was caused by the ambulance crews' failure to accept their leaders' recommendation. 
 Had the recommendation been for industrial action and the crews voted against, I have no doubt Mr Clarke would have applauded the triumph of democracy. 
 He really cannot have it both ways. 
 This government has repeatedly talked about &bquo;giving the unions back to their members.&equo; 
 Very well: the union has behaved democratically. 
 Mr Clarke's reaction reveals the same double standard as did his reaction to the doctors' equally democratic verdict which he proceeded to dismiss. 
 Is it intelligence or integrity he lacks? 
 (Rev) M.L.Forster. 
 Buckminster Road Baptist Church, Leicester. 
 YOUR leader on the ambulance service dispute (November 8) is, unfortunately, highly misleading. 
 You compare the lowest figure for an out-of-London ambulance worker (on &pound;10,000) with the possible earnings of a Metropolitan police constable (&pound;25,000). 
 In fact, London qualified ambulance workers are being offered &pound;12,100, while to get anywhere near &pound;25,000 a Metropolitan police constable would have to be putting in a huge amount of overtime &mdash; the annual pay of a PC with three years' experience is &pound;12,756. 
 More to the point, you fail to mention the fact that the Government has offered talks on a pay structure which would ensure that those ambulance workers with a high skill level, who tend to be those who deal with the worst accidents, are paid more to reflect their training. 
 The obvious corollary of this is that less qualified ambulance workers, who are largely engaged in driving non-urgent cases, would not see their earnings rise by so much. 
 That is why NUPE and the other unions have been so unwilling to negotiate sensibly on this aspect of the dispute. 
 Yet it would seem to make perfect sense for higher qualified paramedics to be more highly paid, provided there was an acceptance that ambulance workers with lower skill levels would receive less. 
 John Marshall, (MP). 
 (Con, Hendon S), House of Commons. 
 WITH regard to the ambulance dispute, the Minister frequently says that they should accept the 6 &frac12; per cent, which has been accepted by other health service unions. 
 The ancilliary workers have accepted 9 per cent, the doctors 8 per cent and certainly my own union is at the moment balloting to decide on industrial action over the 6 &frac12; per cent offered to Medical Laboratory Scientific Officers. 
 Economical with the truth? 
 Ralph Baer. 
 27 The Drive, Amersham, Bucks. 
 IWISH to express my support for the ambulance men and women. 
 In 25 years of general practice I have had nothing but admiration and gratitude for their assistance. 
 Their level of expertise and commitment is at least on a par with that of the police and fire service. 
 Their unfailing good humour and propensity to reassure those in their care are a welcome support to the tired GP seeking to admit a patient at 3 am! 
 (Dr) S.Wyn Jones. 
 Wrexham, Clwyd. 
 YOU REPORT (November 7) that the president of the Police Federation is worried lest the use of the police in the ambulance dispute would jeopardise the idea of the impartiality of the police in the eyes of the public. 
 Let me put his mind at rest: any notion that the police were impartial disappeared with their behaviour in the miners' strike. 
 Esmond Smith. 
 Broad Street, Orford, Suffolk. 
 Sound Bites 
 I am sick of always being treated as part of the President's baggage. 
 Danielle Mitterrand on being the wife of the French leader. 
 I usually get rid of my men after 2 &frac12; years. 
 Tina Turner. 
 The players were acting like a bunch of women. 
 Police officer after the Arsenal v. 
 Norwich battle. 
 Women, with certain exceptions, have little to offer the House of Commons. 
 John Carlisle, Tory MP for Luton. 
 I think we should be told. 
 Mr Justice Michael Davies after Private Eye and Sonia Sutcliffe agreed that the amount of libel damages should remain undisclosed 
 Diary. 
 By Ann Clwyd 
 &bquo;CONGRATULATIONS,&equo; said one of my Welsh male colleagues &bquo;on getting on to the assisted places scheme.&equo; 
 He added quickly: &bquo;I didn't really mean it.&equo; 
 Since he is a man without malice, he was nevertheless probably accurately reflecting what some, if not many, male Labour MPs feel about reserving three places for women in Labour's Shadow Cabinet. 
 While we stood for election alongside the men, a decision taken in July by Labour MPs to bring more women into prominent positions in the party ensured that at least three women would be elected. 
 In the event, we got four and almost five. 
 People like Willy Brandt in West Germany pioneered similar systems years ago to get more women into Parliament. 
 According to the pundits, I was a &bquo;surprise&equo; result: a &bquo;rebel&equo; who had bucked the system. 
 As a former reporter I devour newsprint with the appetite of a motorised refuse truck, but some of the garbage that has been written about myself and other women MPs deserves instant binning. 
 The fact that the hordes of reporters who live in the burrows of the Palace of Westminster got it wrong &mdash; and have since tried to justify getting it wrong &mdash; has given me, and many of my friends who knew the score pretty accurately before the result, much quiet pleasure over the last few days. 
 It all happened too fast. 
 One moment we were sitting in a packed meeting of the Parliamentary Labour Party, hearts aflutter, waiting for the results. 
 The next, Jo Richardson, Joan Lestor, Margaret Beckett and myself were out on the terrace of the Commons among the cameras, the microphones, and the reporters, like rare butterflies pinned on a specimen board. 
 Interviews followed (for me in Welsh as well as English). 
 &bquo;When do you next expect to get sacked?&equo; was a favourite. 
 &bquo;How do you get on with Mr Kinnock?&equo; was another. 
 Then came the first Shadow Cabinet meeting. 
 Cameras, lights, and a red rose for all of us: all the women were asked to sqeeze round Neil. 
 Much laughter, jollity, and anticipation of a successful 12 months ahead with a government on the run. 
 As I walk through Mountain Ash on my way to my Saturday surgery, people call out on the street. 
 &bquo;Congratulations&equo;, &bquo;Well done&equo;. 
 An old man sitting on a seat in the town centre shouts: &bquo;Ann Clwyd, Ann Clwyd, congratulations. 
 Prime Minister next.&equo; 
 I laugh and think, &bquo;No thank you.&equo; 
 The warmth and obvious pleasure of everyone I meet and see in the Cynon Valley that day is humbling and exhilirating. 
 These are the people who made me Wales's only woman MP. 
 I have to repay them. 
 The letters have poured in this week. 
 From friends of long ago, from the European Parliament, and from names I could not decipher. 
 There have been the odd sour ones, from men who object to what they call sexism in the Labour Party, ie, &bquo;assisted places&equo; on the Shadow Cabinet. 
 With only 41 women out of 650 in Parliament, what a nerve! 
 CAMBODIA has been the main subject of my mailbag this week. 
 Other MPs the same. 
 All say they have had more letters on this foreign-policy subject than any other. 
 A Tory MP asks me whether the story is true about the UK training troops in secret bases in Thailand to fight alongside Pol Pot's Khmer Rouge. 
 I tell him to ask the Prime Minister. 
 After all, she has been asked the question several times over the past few days and will not say yes or no. 
 We all know the answer is yes. 
 I was last in Cambodia in September, my second visit in two years. 
 I watched the much-maligned Vietnamese troops leave. 
 People forget that it was they who freed the country from Pol Pot, otherwise many more would have died than the one million who were starved, tortured, and executed between 1975-78. 
 John Pilger's TV film last week has roused the conscience of the British people in a way that politicians like us have failed to do. 
 There is a real fear that Pol Pot will return to Cambodia. 
 Surely the world cannot stand idly by and watch this country of eight million people go through the agony of war yet again? 
 Because of the political impasse over the past ten years Cambodia, one of the poorest countries in the world, has received no UN development aid, nor any bilateral or multilateral development aid from the UK. 
 It is only the dedication of charities like Oxfam, which has a team of permanent aid workers in Cambodia, that enables the UK to hold up its head. 
 The British Government has blindly followed the American &bquo;bleed Vietnam white&equo; policy to justify its policy of ignoring Cambodia. 
 Now the Vietnamese are no longer there, it has no excuse. 
 It will of course still make one: a mirror-image again of the American claim that Vietnam has left one million settlers behind, and that the Cambodian government is communist. 
 Prime Minister Hun Sen of Cambodia has said many times: &bquo;Come and see for yourselves. 
 Send an international team which includes former Khmer people, so they can distinguish between the two peoples.&equo; 
 Repeatedly he has said he favours internationally supervised elections, and that his country wishes to be non-aligned. 
 On my two visits I met many ordinary people who have great respect and affection for their prime minister. 
 He is not the despot portrayed in the West. 
 AROUND my neck I wear a gold and ruby necklace from Pailin, a near-derelict town on Cambodia's mountainous border with Thailand. 
 The rubies come from there and the area has recently been fought over. 
 Government troops have been defeated and the Khmer Rouge now occupy Pailin. 
 I finger the necklace often these days as I think of my many friends in that country. 
 The Khmer Rouge was one of the bloodiest regimes in Asian history. 
 Yet recognition of the anti-Vietnamese resistance coalition, of which it is the dominant partner, will be maintained at the United Nations next week. 
 The British Government has acquiesed in an insane situation. 
 A lot of other people are deeply worried. 
 A retired diplomat who now spends all his time lobbying on Cambodia, has sent a 30-page fax from Los Angeles to my constituency office in Aberdare. 
 I send my secretary there an SOS and she spends a day clearing up and dumping my old files, generally tidying me up as well. 
 IWONDER what frail Madame Phiroun, Secretary-General of the Cambodian Parliament, is thinking now. 
 Pol Pot killed her entire family. 
 She was a former civil servant and escaped death only by telling her interrogators that she was a peasant. 
 As she has a deeply freckled skin, they believed her and she was sent to do hard labour in the paddy fields. 
 No hard-line communist is she. 
 One of her main interests is our Royal family. 
 She herself was educated in Paris with Prince Sihanouk, and she once entertained Princess Margaret and Lord Snowdon in Cambodia. 
 And her endless supplies of Paris Match keep her in touch with the Royals. 
 Then there is our gentle guide, Kan Phardidh. 
 He was training to be a teacher when the Khmer Rouge took over. 
 He was sent to work in the fields. 
 Now most of his family are dead. 
 What were his hopes now, I asked. 
 &bquo;All our hopes have changed,&equo; he said sadly. 
 Our Shadow Cabinet meeting on Thursday decided to use Labour's time on Monday to debate Cambodia. 
 I am delighted: it is an issue on which I have campaigned vigorously for more than two years. 
 Gerald Kaufman will open the debate and I will sum up. 
 It is my first appearance at the dispatch box in my new role, and it could not be a better issue. 
 Ann Clwyd, MP for the Cynon Valley, is Labour's new Shadow Secretary for Development and Co-operation. 
 MANY DESKTOP computers can generate high-quality digital sound, but apart from games and music programs, most software emits only beeps. 
 Bill Gaver has ideas which could change all that. 
 As a research project at Apple, Gaver added sound effects to the Macintosh's desktop interface to produce the SonicFinder. 
 Now at Rank Xerox's Europarc, in Cambridge, he is continuing his work on sound. 
 Gaver is not so much interested in musical instruments or laboratory oscillators as in whistling wind, splashing water and hurrying footsteps. 
 This is sound we hear with ears tuned by a billion years of evolution. 
 &bquo;Most of the sounds that we are surrounded by are not musical sounds,&equo; Gaver argues. 
 &bquo;When we hear such sounds we do not pay attention to things like pitch and timbre. 
 Instead we think about what made them.&equo; 
 On hearing footsteps, &bquo;I think &bquo;footsteps&equo;; and maybe even, &bquo;those are the footsteps of somebody walking quickly.&equo; 
 Maybe it's a man, maybe it's a woman. 
 I can tell what they are walking on, maybe; perhaps whether they are going upstairs or downstairs. 
 That is what I call everyday listening.&equo; 
 Gaver sees the possibility of establishing a new framework for talking about sound. 
 &bquo;Instead of talking about basic acoustics and the physics of sound itself, and then how that maps to our experiences of things like pitch and so forth, you can talk about sources of sound and the physics of sources of sound and how we experience those.&equo; 
 The precedent for this approach is the work done on vision by the psychologist James Gibson, from the 1950s onwards. 
 &bquo;He talks about things that are intuitively relevant to everyday life.&equo; 
 Gaver's recent doctoral thesis at the University of California, San Diego, included work on the use of sound in computer interfaces. 
 But he began by scouting out the field of timbre perception from a Gibsonian perspective. 
 Presenting data is not Gaver's prime concern. 
 &bquo;I am trying to give people information about what's happening inside their system,&equo; he explains. 
 This leads to the idea of auditory icons, which indicate the nature of objects inside the computer, by alluding to some object in the real world. 
 &bquo;Everything makes sounds,&equo; Gaver explains as he sits down at his Macintosh. 
 &bquo;If I select an object it's like hitting it. 
 And the kind of sound it makes depends on the kind of object it is. 
 A file makes a kind of dull wooden sound, folders make a slightly sharper sound, applications sound like metal. 
 Discs sound sort of hollow&hellip;&equo; 
 The sounds vary with the size of the object. 
 Little applications make a high-pitched &bquo;clink&equo; when probed with the mouse, big ones a beefier &bquo;clunk&equo;. 
 Folders (the icons for directories) have the same property. 
 &bquo;If a folder has a lot of stuff in it, it sounds bigger than one which is fairly small. 
 Discs make sounds which depend on how much space they have.&equo; 
 When you use the mouse to drag an icon to a new position, in copying a file for example, the sonic feedback continues. 
 &bquo;If I pick up something and drag it it makes this white noise sound,&equo; Gaver demonstrates. 
 It is a nondescript sound like the sigh of a carpet as furniture is shoved across it. 
 &bquo;That sound changes as I go from the window that I picked it up in, to a different window, or to the desktop.&equo; 
 The sighing changes in tone. 
 &bquo;If I hit a container like a folder or a disk while I am dragging, then the container makes its sound and the dragging sound stops. 
 That turns out to be very nice for finding targets.&equo; 
 Mac users will know how important it is to drag icons to the correct position. 
 &bquo;Dragging also depends on size, so if I pick up a bunch of stuff I get a lower dragging sound than if I pick up just one. 
 So that again is just to keep reality going. 
 &bquo;If I open the folder,&equo; Gaver continues, &bquo;I get this whooshing sound which also depends on the size of the folder.&equo; 
 Scrolling a file within a window generates a series of &bquo;plunks&equo; going down or up in pitch. 
 Resizing a window makes a tapping sound. 
 Selecting a window makes a glassy clink. 
 Is all this actually helping? 
 &bquo;The idea is just to associate sounds with as many events as possible, and to hold off worrying about how useful they are,&equo; Gaver replies. 
 It was not always easy to pick an appropriate sound effect. 
 One which caused trouble was the simple act of opening a window. 
 Gaver manoeuvred house windows and taped the noises and they sounded terrible. 
 &bquo;It took me a while to realise that of course I am not really opening a window: something is zooming forward and appearing out of nothing. 
 And that's something that does not happen in the real world.&equo; 
 PERHAPS the biggest challenge is to find the perfect sound to accompany an action which has no equivalent in real life. 
 Gaver's principle here is to look for plausible extensions of reality. 
 The film Star Wars demonstrates this perfectly, both in sound and vision. 
 Take the light sabre, the futuristic hand weapon which resembles a rod of roaring, incandescent gas. 
 &bquo;That of course does not exist,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;And yet you can look at the thing in Star Wars and the sounds it makes are just perfect for it.&equo; 
 As windows open and close on the Macintosh screen, the SonicFinder makes impressive whooshing sounds. 
 Apple has added the necessary &bquo;hooks&equo; for a sonic interface, in release 6.04 of the Macintosh system software. 
 But the all-important file of sound effects is not, at present, included. 
 However, Gaver reports that quite a few people within Apple use his SonicFinder in their daily work. 
 Maybe they like to know the computer is still doing something while they look away from the screen. 
 Maybe it helps to generate the sense of &bquo;direct engagement&equo; in your work that comes when you forget you are using a computer at all. 
 But if you do not think sound is important, try watching Star Wars with the volume turned down. 
 Randall Smith of Xerox PARC in California is another believer in the value of meaningful sound. 
 He has added sound to his Alternative Reality Kit (Computer Guardian, October 1, 1987), a simulated world where you, the user, can change the laws of physics. 
 There are thuds and boings when objects collide. 
 Sound &bquo;increases the sense of tangibility,&equo; says Smith. 
 In the new version, Shared Ark, you are likely to encounter other people doing their own experiments from their own workstations. 
 It doesn't matter that they may be 700 miles away at the other end of a data link. 
 At any time only a small part of Shared Ark's simulated world is visible on any one user's screen. 
 But in the background you can hear the murmur of other people's activity and this, Smith argues, is one of the things which makes Shared Ark work. 
 You don't have to pay attention, but you are likely to notice a sudden hush, or any sounds of special significance. 
 &bquo;Have you ever heard your name mentioned in a crowd?&equo; asks Smith. 
 In commercial computer applications, he believes sound will be particularly important in collaborative tasks, where people need to be alert to what colleagues are doing, without having it distractingly thrust upon their attention. 
 Tony Durham writes the Over the horizon column in Computing magazine. 
 Sound ideas: Bill Gaver. 
 &bquo;I am trying to give people information about what's happening inside their system'PHOTOGRAPH: MANNI MASONS. 
 Steve Cassidy hears the noises off. 
 SOUND on the Apple Macintosh has its roots in comedy. 
 Games have made noises through the Mac speaker ever since its introduction, and many early systems were afflicted with a true celebration of the typical Mac programmer's sense of humour. 
 This was a small operating system patch by the name of MacPuke, which made the innocuous little beige box belch in a particularly corpulent, beer-sodden way when the operating system decided to eject a floppy disc from the drive. 
 This and similar programs have spread through the Macintosh community's excellent Public Domain (PD) software network. 
 And nowadays, users of the newer Macs may benefit from larger speakers and earphone sockets, projecting sounds which the original machines mumbled. 
 One game, called Net Trek, which has recently made the transition from PD to commercial product, uses sounds sampled from the Star Trek television series to accompany the user's attempts to pilot around a galaxy of other Mac users, when all the machines are connected together by the network. 
 It is a very strange experience, walking the corridors of a large company, to hear loud blasts of phasers and the firing of photon torpedoes echoing to and fro from various offices. 
 Sounds may be provided as simple files, or built into Apple's free do-it-yourself hypertext program, Hypercard. 
 Many PD sources offer Hypercard &bquo;stacks&equo;, which are simply collections of sounds, accessed by pushing on-screen &bquo;buttons&equo; to play them. 
 Educorp, an American PD library, offers a wide range of these. 
 Some are simply short sound bites taken from classic cartoons. 
 Bugs Bunny screaming &bquo;Ooooh, Pru-NELLA!!&equo; can liven up many a telephone answering machine tape. 
 The Educorp catalogue also lists some more contemplative, or just curious, examples, including the Bogie Stack. 
 This features the most hackneyed sections of the soundtrack of Casablanca. 
 I can't think of a single occasion in which this might come in handy. 
 The pinnacle of Mac sound replayers is undoubtedly SoundMaster. 
 It takes up where MacPuke left off, offering a whole range of activities the computer is likely to perform, and the opportunity to attach any sound to them. 
 Thus your machine may start up with the HAL 9000 self-test (&bquo;I am completely operational and all my circuits are functioning perfectly&equo;) from Kubrick's 2001, or &bquo;Space, the Final Frontier&equo;, the striking lead-in to Star Trek, or &bquo;We're not in Kansas anymore, Toto&equo; from The Wizard of Oz. 
 Suppliers like Educorp and Somak Software bundle up discs containing SoundMaster and libraries of sounds, including the favourites mentioned above. 
 They cover a broad range of themes, with a heavy bias towards space opera, cartoons and Monty Python. 
 A machine which closes down with Michael Palin enthusing: &bquo;Ah, I see you have the machine which goes PING!&equo; and which signals errors by way of Eric Idle's angry, affronted &bquo;Ni!&equo; is very hard to accuse of alienation. 
 But one that has had the error beep replaced by a robotic voice screaming &bquo;Attention!&equo; is likely to have the opposite effect, as is one that ingests a floppy disc accompanied by a long drawn out grumble taken from a soggy passage in the Star Wars trilogy. 
 And if, when I turn my Mac on to upload this article, you hear James Brown screaming: &bquo;Fellas, I'm ready to get up an&equo; do MAH thang!&equo; don't fret. 
 It's only the computer. 
 The Educorp PD software catalogue is available from Translatum International, Saithaelwyd Ucha, Holywell, Clwyd CH8 8NU (tel: 0352 710276). 
 Sid Smith tests the Portfolio, Atari's new wallet-sized electronic organiser The pound in your pocket. 
 I KEEP a pretty exclusive pocket. 
 It's previously rejected the yuppie Filofax (too big), the Microwriter AgendA (nasty keyboard), and the Psion Organiser (both of the above). 
 Now the &pound;249 Atari Portfolio claims to offer crucial functionality to every inside pocket &mdash; or at least to replace its own bulk in existing inhabitants. 
 In computer terms, its bulk is certainly low. 
 The wallet-sized Portfolio weighs just over a pound, yet opens out to reveal a qwerty keyboard and an eight line by 40 column display. 
 The keyboard is minute: the tiniest typist I know couldn't squeeze all her fingers into the &bquo;home&equo; position. 
 But forget 10-digit typing and you're soon skipping across the keys with the irritating agility of people who never sweated in front of a Pitman's chart. 
 There's no tactile feedback from the square, shirt-button sized keys, but sufficient space between them to trap most errors. 
 There's no such justification for the LCD (liquid crystal display) screen: it's just small. 
 However, the display is good of its kind, and the hinge means that the screen can be tipped to whatever angle is convenient. 
 Along with its size, the Portfolio's claimed PC compatibility is its most eye-catching feature. 
 However, the machine has a basic memory of only 128K, a not-very-standard keyboard and screen, no disk drive, and an operating system called DOS, which stands for DIP Operating System, after the machine's British designers. 
 In short, it seems inevitable that most PC software will need some kind of re-write to run on the Portfolio, and some of it will never fit at all. 
 It's true that Atari is offering a card drive for desktop PCs, and battery-backed add-in memory cards, but these cost over &pound;1 per kilobyte. 
 It also says major applications will be made available on plug-in cards but, as always, computer buyers should only assess what they can see, not what might turn up who-knows-when. 
 However, Atari has at least launched a PC interface box, which adds one third to the Portfolio's size and cost. 
 Fortunately it works well, since the machine has an obvious role as the portable data capture device for a desktop PC. 
 Portfolio owners can also check whether the machine's five resident applications &mdash; calculator, diary, address book, text editor and spreadsheet &mdash; can challenge the current contents of their inside pocket, including those old-fashioned paper diary and address books. 
 Like most electronic diaries, the Portfolio's has no advantage beyond its Alarm. 
 Even word processing functions such as Search and Copy are hardly significant for the tiny quantity of text usually involved. 
 Address books are different. 
 There's more text, they get changed less often, and a Search function is genuinely useful if you can remember everything about a person except their surname. 
 Having said that, the not-outrageous address file on my desktop machine was over 40K long &mdash; requiring much juggling between the Portfolio's silicon drive and general memory. 
 ODDLY, the address file would not go into the address book application, for reasons (I assume) to do with the latter's format demands. 
 However, the text editor was more accommodating, and had all the utility of the address book except its auto-dialler, which only works with tone-phones (you hold the machine's tiny speaker against the phone) and anyway makes you look like an idiot. 
 The calculator is OK, but by itself wouldn't earn the machine pocket space. 
 It offers five memories, basic arithmetic functions, powers and factorials. 
 You can't save calculations, but you can track back through a chain of arithmetic, alter figures, and see the alterations reflected in the final sum. 
 The spreadsheet is 127 by 255 cells and has some level of Lotus 1-2-3 compatibility. 
 But if you're expecting to import data from a PC, then first check the long list of unsupported 1-2-3 commands, each of which generates an error message on the Portfolio. 
 And are you really sure you could do anything useful on a spreadsheet display only four cells by six? 
 All of which brings us to the text editor. 
 Forget touch typing and full-screen editing, of course: the Portfolio's keyboard and screen suit it only for note-taking, and its resident editing software is inadequate for anything more enterprising. 
 Nevertheless, the editor does offer several advantages over that of, say, Sir Clive Sinclair's Z88 laptop &mdash; notably the excellent undelete and block operations. 
 However the lack of a word count function is a grievous ommision in any machine with limited display space. 
 So could the Portfolio work its passage in the average pocket? 
 As always, only the individual user can tell. 
 But buyers most likely to be satisfied probably already own a desktop PC, perhaps with an important text file which they'd be glad to carry around for reference. 
 They probably also have some need of on-the-spot data entry, either in the form of text notes, or limited spreadsheet work. 
 In hardware terms, the Portfolio is the best electronic &bquo;Filofax&equo; currently available. 
 Its PC compatibility is a distraction for most users of standard applications, but the resident ones are as good as any available. 
 Pocket PC power: Sid Smith and the Portfolio &mdash; the best electronic &bquo;Filofax&equo; currently available? 
 PHOTOGRAPH: GRAHAM TURNER OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Will patients or the computer industry benefit as the new NHS contract forces GPs into the micro-chip age?. 
 As Jane Feinman reports, for many doctors the technogical revolution is already proving a nightmare Kicking and screaming 
 COMPUTERISATION has become an urgent problem for Britain's 36,000 family doctors. 
 Their new contracts, starting on April 1, 1990, are virtually unworkable without the use of information technology. 
 General practice is thus being forced kicking and screaming into the computer age. 
 But this revolution in what must be Britain's most valued public industry, is taking place in the market place. 
 Central planning has a noticeably low profile. 
 Less than six months before the contract is enforced, the Department of Health has still not issued specifications for software producers. 
 That means programs have still not been written for a whole range of complex new tasks that GPs will be asked to do. 
 Nor has the Department decided whether it is going to contribute towards the considerable capital cost of new computers, causing doctors to put off to the last minute a decision on which system to choose. 
 With only a third of Britain's 10,000 practices so far computerised, and practice systems costing on average well over &pound;20,000, 1990 will be a bonanza year for the computer industry. 
 Market research shows at least 3,500 practices plan to computerise in the next 12 months, and this is almost certainly a conservative figure. 
 Vamp, one of the three big companies specialising in the medical business, is currently placing 80 to 100 computers a month. 
 &bquo;We are gearing up to do 200 systems a month,&equo; said its marketing director, Ian Collins. 
 &bquo;Even so, we expect that there will be huge logjams.&equo; 
 An estimated 40 new firms have already joined the big three specialising in GP computers since the Government's controversial plans for a management orientated NHS were published in January. 
 With no regulation of the industry, there is no way to police the cowboy end of the market, which the experts say is now well represented. 
 Scores of computer consultants have appeared to provide &bquo;specialist&equo; help. 
 And rumours of takeovers of the small companies by giants such as IBM and Hewlett-Packard abound &mdash; so far with no foundation. 
 But for GPs the technological revolution is proving a nightmare. 
 &bquo;It is an absolute shambles,&equo; says Dr Glynn Hayes, a GP and president of the British Computer Society GP specialists' committee. 
 &bquo;The Government is railroading through a new contract which depends on the comprehensive computerisation of practices. 
 Yet most practices still do not have a computer, and the vast majority will start working the contract without the information technology expertise to manage it.&equo; 
 FAMILY practitioner committees, which both pay and monitor NHS independent contracts, are equally unprepared. 
 &bquo;FPC records of patient registration are inaccurate,&equo; warns Dr Hayes. 
 &bquo;Their recall systems for cervical cytology to enable GPs to carry out smears, - a major new task under new contract &mdash; are notoriously inadequate. 
 Practices are actually in danger of going bankrupt through computer errors on the part of the administrators.&equo; 
 One well-organised practice which is currently computerising its patient registers has taken the trouble to check the corresponding FPC register. 
 It took about 300 hours, but it was time well spent, the practice believes, because of the number of inaccuracies in the FPC register &mdash; around 40 per cent. 
 It will be one of the few practices that will be able to turn round and tell the FPC that it has got it wrong, claims its senior partner. 
 There are other complex tasks required of software which the suppliers admit they have not yet cracked, such as reaching targets for immunising all two-year-olds in the practice. 
 This is another requirement of GPs from April 1990, but many mothers are advised by the health visitor to go to a health authority clinic to be immunised. 
 The GPs' database will have to differentiate between infants who have not been immunised and those not immunised by the GP. 
 How the computer will get the data is an outstanding question. 
 With payment by results, in the absence of an answer, GP pay is going to be skewed. 
 The crisis has been caused partly by the reluctance of self-employed family doctors to invest the considerable sums needed to computerise. 
 Both the Department of Health and the Royal College of General Practitioners have signalled for years that good general practice should not ignore the microchip, but to little effect. 
 The benefits could be overwhelming. 
 Computerisation allows doctors to expand their largely reactive role of sitting in the surgery waiting for ill patients to come to them. 
 A computerised age/sex register enables the practice to carry out screening tests, and identify levels of morbidity in the community to facilitate planning and concentrate better levels of care on the elderly, the chronically ill and the disabled. 
 Computers can also enable hospitals and GPs to talk to each other far more quickly and efficiently, to book out-patient appointments, get the results of lab tests and receive information when a patient is discharged from hospital. 
 But it is not only the general practice units that are often mismanaged. 
 Hospitals are developing computer systems which are often not compatible with one another and are being used as little more than expensive word processors. 
 Of course, lack of funding for systems and training, capital costs and development are at the root of the malaise over computerisation &mdash; and this is not a new problem for the NHS. 
 If doctors are worried about entering the new era of &bquo;market medicine,&equo; it is partly because they feel under-equipped for it. 
 But is the private sector really going to provide the investment and planning needed for this sudden introduction of information technology? 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Microfile. 
 By Jack Schofield Computer editor 
 MULTI-PROCESSING Unix will soon be available as a standard product, SCO MPX, from the Santa Cruz Operation. 
 And applications programs won't need to be rewritten to take advantage of it. 
 MPX uses technology originally developed by Corollary, demonstrated by SCO on the Zenith Z1000 in February, and announced with the Compaq Systempro mini earlier this month. 
 It comes as an extension to SCO's Unix V (which is also part of the Open Desktop suite) for systems based on Intel's 80386 and i486 processors. 
 SCO's Doug Michels claims, &bquo;You can now build a PC-based workstation, server or departmental mini that will outrun virtually any computer based on today's Risc microprocessors or proprietary CPUs.&equo; 
 SCO MPX runs on the Corollary 386/smp and 486/smp, Compaq Systempro, Apricot VX FTserver, Zenith Z1000 and Mitac Series 500. 
 Each copy of SCO MPX supports one extra processor, up to a maximum of 16 processors on one machine, with 15 copies of MPX. 
 A two-processor system should support about 128 users. 
 SCO MPX will be available early next year and cost &pound;750. 
 Mach too. 
 AS EXPECTED, subscribers to the Open Software Foundation, a software house set up by IBM, DEC and others, have voted to change course. 
 Originally the OSF was to produce a version of Unix based on IBM's implementation, AIX. 
 Now that AT&amp;T is shipping the standard System V Release 4, why bother? 
 (If it is compatible with V.4, who needs it? 
 If it isn't, who wants it?) 
 Instead the OSF is to use the Mach 4.3BSD-compatible multi-processing version of Unix, developed at Carnegie-Mellon University. 
 This is best known from Steve Jobs' NeXT workstation, but the OSF will use code from Encore's implementation for its Multimax range. 
 &bquo;Significant portions of IBM's AIX will be incorporated.&equo; 
 Encore has been shipping Multimax superminis for over a year and has now sold (and shipped) two to the OSF's development lab in Boston. 
 The OSF/1 Unix will also aim for high security (B-1 level), but it is not now expected to appear before November 1990. 
 1-2-3 compatible. 
 LOTUS Development and Word Perfect Corp have announced a technology partnership under which they will develop a user interface for Lotus 1-2-3/G and Word Perfect for OS/2 Presentation Manager. 
 In effect, it seems Word Perfect will use program code written by Lotus. 
 Users will thus get the same menu commands on 1-2-3/G and Word Perfect PM, so the two products will look as though they are from the same company. 
 But there will still be differences. 
 For example, Lotus uses F1 for Help while Word Perfect uses F3. 
 Manuscript, Lotus's word processor, will not be rewritten for Presentation Manager, and there can't be much future for Plan Perfect, Word Perfect's spreadsheet, on OS/2 either. 
 X party. 
 THE inaugural meeting of the X User Group was held on Tuesday. 
 Its aims are to promote awareness of X and provide a forum for the discussion of technical issues. 
 A newsletter, an annual exhibition and a directory of X products are also planned. 
 For details contact Niall Mansfield at Unipalm Ltd in Cambridge (tel.: 0954 211797). 
 Comms course. 
 TEESSIDE Polytechnic is launching the UK's first computerised course in computer communications. 
 It will be taught using &bquo;distance learning&equo; methods, including printed materials, electronic mail and online conferencing. 
 Students on the part-time course will work from home, visiting Middlesbrough only for the final examination. 
 A 512K DOS-compatible PC with GEM is required, but other software will be provided. 
 The &pound;70 course, which starts in January, is aimed at secretarial and business staff, and can be taken by the disabled. 
 It will lead to a Certificate in Computer-Mediated Communication Systems. 
 Contact Paul Mayes on 0642 218121 ext 4367. 
 Mac Mag. 
 APPLE Macintosh users are, by convention, rich, so few will blanche at the arrival of Mac Publishing monthly magazine. 
 It costs &pound;10 per copy. 
 Still, it's very good, and subscribers get a disc containing at least one font with every issue. 
 In spite of the title, Mac Publishing also covers Macintosh presentations and multi-media. 
 It is published by Future Publishing, tel.: 0225 446034. 
 Real mouthful. 
 CHAIRSIDE Publishing of Seattle has written an &bquo;expert system&equo; for dentists. 
 The dentist feeds in the patient's record, and the program prints out from one to 10 pages of personalised explanation and advice in everyday language, for the patient to take away. 
 Chairside's president, Lee Zehrer, a trained dental hygenist, admits, &bquo;it's a fairly new application for dental offices.&equo; 
 The program was written using KnowledgePro, from Knowledge Garden Inc, and will be launched later this month at the Greater New York Dental Meeting. 
 It runs on DOS-compatible micros and will probably cost &dollar;14.95. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Jack Schofield on how MIT's networking system is throwing open the windows X marks the future. 
 EVERYONE agrees that computing in the 1990s will be dominated by client-server networks, but there is no agreement about the form these will take. 
 The microcomputer firms foresee networks of micros taking over, and the minicomputer firms see networks of minis, while IBM has come up with Systems Application Architecture (SAA), designed to maintain the mainframe's iron grip on corporate data processing's throat. 
 However, there is an alternative which doesn't presuppose the use of any particular kind of computer, or even any particular kind of network. 
 It was developed as part of Project Athena at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and goes under the unexciting name of X Window. 
 MIT wanted students on its campus network to be able to use a wide range of different host computers at the same time, but using only one terminal. 
 The system therefore had to be both hardware and network independent. 
 But the host computers also had different user interfaces, and students couldn't be expected to learn them all. 
 Therefore the workstation had to have software to manage the screen display too. 
 As MIT was using Sun and Apollo workstations, a user-friendly, mouse-operated graphical display was the obvious choice. 
 The solution was to create a &bquo;message-passing&equo; communications system with a window manager, which is basically all X Window is. 
 It defines the X Protocol which carries packets of data from the host computer to the terminal (which, in a workstation, can be in the same box). 
 A library of &bquo;primitives&equo;, called Xlib, is provided for drawing windows, graphics and text and controlling inputs. 
 The window manager is a specialised program which responds to X protocol requests. 
 The window manager is used with Xlib (or, at a higher level, the X toolkit, or an X toolkit with predefined objects called &bquo;widgets&equo;) to build a graphical user interface. 
 Examples include the Sun/AT&amp;T Open Look, the OSF's Motif, and DEC's DECwindows. 
 The confusing thing about X is that it reverses the nomenclature used in microcomputer networks. 
 In X Window, the host application (the one running on a supercomputer, mainframe or whatever) is the client, while the workstation or terminal (running the window manager) is the server. 
 X Window started from W, originally developed at Stanford University, and grew through various versions, with MIT eventually starting to license its code to other users. 
 By January 1987, when it was clear that X Window really worked across multi-vendor networks, there was a joint statement of support for it by Apollo, Data General, DEC, Hewlett-Packard, Masscomp, Siemens and Sony, amongst others (not IBM). 
 A year later the X Consortium was founded. 
 Its aim is to co-operate in the development of the X-standard and get it accepted by the International and US standards bodies, ISO and ANSI. 
 Firms such as AT&amp;T, IBM, Apple, Bull, Sequent and Sun are members. 
 The latest implementation, X Window Version 11 Release 3, emerged a year ago, and has been widely adopted by Unix suppliers and by DEC, with Unix (Ultrix) and VAX VMS versions. 
 X11R3 has also been adopted by the X/Open group which is driving the implementation of &bquo;open systems.&equo; 
 With an X workstation or terminal, you can open a window into any X application on any machine on the network. 
 Overlapping windows on the same screen could come from, say, a Cray supercomputer, a DEC mini and a Sun workstation. 
 A 386-based PC running Unix can also be used as a workstation using Locus's XSight, which is X11 server software. 
 This is included as standard in SCO's Open Desktop Unix suite. 
 For networked applications you can use an X terminal, which is, not surprisingly, a terminal designed for running X Window applications. 
 It has a its own memory and processor, and X Window server software, but no disc drive. 
 You use it just like a dumb terminal, the difference being that instead of a plain text screen, it provides a mouse-and-windows interface. 
 X terminals appeal for two reasons. 
 First, they are cheap. 
 (Acer's Xebra 100 X terminal costs about &pound;500.) 
 Second, they give users a microcomputer-style interface while leaving the applications, and the host computers on which they are running, in the control of the data processing department. 
 X terminals include the Network Computing Devices' NCD 16 and NCR's Towerview, both of which use Motorola 680x0 processors, and Acer's Xebra 100, which has an Intel 8086. 
 For some purposes a micro can be used with X terminal software. 
 Locus offers PC XSight, which is X terminal software for PCs running DOS &mdash; but it doesn't let you run DOS programs at the same time. 
 Similar software is available for the Apple Macintosh and, in Germany, the Atari ST. 
 So far, few X-applications are available (50 packages?) but enough to show promise. 
 Examples include the Uniplex office automation system (word processing, spreadsheet, database, electronic mail etc), Access's 20/20 spreadsheet, Owl's Guide hypertext system, Frame Technologies' FrameMaker desktop publishing package, Ixi's X Desktop and the X.Emacs editor. 
 X-compatible versions of Informix, Oracle and dBase have also been shown. 
 Vertical applications have just started to appear, one of the first being Cambridge Micro's package for estate agents (Computer, June 1). 
 X Window is certain to be a success because it allows for applications running on any manufacturer's machine and any multi-tasking operating system to be used by any X-based workstation or terminal. 
 It provides a graphical interface with &bquo;common user access&equo; without insisting on the use of an Intel or Motorola or particular Risc chip, or a particular operating system, or even an operating system at all. 
 So, X seems to offer more than IBM's SAA, over a wider field, quicker, with less effort, and at a lower cost. 
 It will be interesting to see what happens when data processing managers eventually notice it. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Video. 
 By Tim Pulleine 
 SELL-THROUGH, as the retail sector of the video market is obscurely known, is at the moment very much a bull market, and there has lately been a growing shift to releasing more recent movies in this way. 
 This has been capped by the well publicised current appearance of no less than Rain Man (Warner) for sale (&pound;14.99) as well as for rent, when hitherto the two spheres have tacitly been regarded as mutually exclusive. 
 But for all the changes, the prime emphasis in the retail market, so far as movies are concerned, still seems to be on the past, and predominantly on the mainstream Hollywood past. 
 Current refinements, no doubt with Christmas present buying in mind, include boxed sets of three or more related cassettes from Warners &mdash; for example, all three of James Dean's movies for &pound;29.95, or for the same price, Marilyn Monroe in The Prince and the Showgirl, The Misfits and (a bit of a scoop, since it has not been on video before) Some Like It Hot. 
 This kind of collection, though usually available individually, is increasingly and intelligently proving to be a marketing ploy. 
 For random instance, CBS/Fox has recently released (&pound;9.99 each) not only Cronenberg's 1986 The Fly and its far from negligible 1958 forerunner, but also the 1959 quick-buck sequel to the latter, Return Of The Fly, a collector's item, though not necessarily in qualitative terms. 
 And to move from B to Z movies, connoisseurs of the bizarre can now lay in their own copy of Edward Woods&equo; Plan 9 From Outer Space (Palace, &pound;14.99), once voted the most incompetent film of all time. 
 The rental sector meanwhile provides &mdash; along with all the box-office successes which nowadays transfer to tape within a few months and probably need no further introduction &mdash; the chance to catch up on a variety of (often more deserving) movies which have been less widely seen in cinemas here. 
 A prime example is Crossing Delancey (Warner), Joan Micklin Silver's deft and sympathetic comedy of Jewish New York life. 
 Or, still in New York, there is Peter Yates' The House On Carroll Street (Virgin), a gripping suspense story set against the background of the McCarthy inquisition. 
 For Queen And Country (Sony) is a tough and effective British &bquo;urban western&equo; confronting racism and inner-city deprivation in uncomplacently stylised terms. 
 Representing a more traditional form of British cinema, John Schlesinger's Madame Sousatzka (Virgin) has a stand-out performance by Shirley MacLaine and a keen eye for varied London locations, while A Time Of Destiny (Vestron) is a baroque romantic melodrama from Gregory Nava (El Norte), which despite the miscasting of William Hurt as a Basque immigrant's son seemed to me to have been unfairly downgraded. 
 Another flawed but striking recent movie is DOA (Buena Vista), an update from the creators of Max Headroom of the classic 1949 thriller of the same name, which may detrimentally alter the plot of the original but boasts nonetheless some arresting high-tech intimations of neo-expressionist atmosphere. 
 Needing no alibis, however, though it comes close to an exploitation concept, is the hard-driving Australian movie Shame (Vestron), with a dynamic central performance by Deborra-Lee Furness as the city woman caught up in Outback violence. 
 Speaking of exploitation, students of the genre might care to consider Trapper County War (Guild), an archetypal example of the backwoods nightmare, set in one of those supposed hillbilly communities where the locals, when not spitting out tobacco or imprecations, are banding together to hunt down interlopers and blast them to bits. 
 And for historically minded exploitation devotees, there is Terror Train (MGM/UA), made in 1980 and one of umpteen contemporaneous movies patterned after Halloween, but with the novelty of being almost wholly set aboard a train. 
 The star is Jamie Lee Curtis, who in those days, well before A Fish Called Wanda, was the acknowledged holder of the &bquo;scream queen&equo; title which had once rested on the shapely shoulders of Evelyn Ankers. 
 Another war of words? 
 Critic's view Cinema. 
 By Derek Malcolm 
 THE LONDON Film Festival &mdash; the largest ever mounted &mdash; grinds to a halt on Sunday with a performance of Ettore Scola's What Time Is It? 
 But before then there is another Guardian debate (Saturday, NFT1, 2.15) which, if it is half as argumentative as last weekend's about the South African cinema, ought to be well worth attending. 
 The subject is contentious enough in all conscience &mdash; the independent film. 
 Which means the kind of film that is not financed by the major American companies and is sometimes thought of as art rather than commerce. 
 In particular the debate focusses on the American variety of independent film, of which there have been a large number at this year's festival, ranging from Jim Jarmusch's annoyingly fashionable Mystery Train to Julia Cameron's God's Will, which cost only 31,000 dollars to make. 
 Incidentally, I am not sure that Cameron should admit this fact since it will make anyone who wants to buy her movie positively glow with pleasure at the thought of paying her practically nothing for it. 
 But that's another matter. 
 Anyway, the debate ought to be fun since what is certain is that American audiences, or at least distributors, have at least as much contempt as those here for independent features without bankable stars, car chases and expensive special effects. 
 It will be chaired by Steve Pinhay, the producer of ITV's Saturday Night At The Movies, a programme which keeps on sending me press releases saying how wonderful it is but, when I actually watch it, seems to ignore the independent cinema entirely, particularly the variety that actually dares to speak in a foreign tongue. 
 Someone ought to ask him about that. 
 Meanwhile I much enjoyed chairing the South African debate, since tempers flared throughout, including mine, which is always interesting. 
 I particularly enjoyed the contributions of Wally Serote, the black poet and writer who is now the ANC's cultural representative in London, and who never lost his cool once. 
 What he said was very significant &mdash; that the ANC wanted to encourage any film-maker, black or white, who tried to put on the screen images of black people that were recognisably human, and who also tried to give employment and encouragement to black technicians. 
 He spoke very movingly about this, and his lack of political inflexibility was cheering. 
 But I do wonder whether it is really necessary for the London festival, or any other, come to that, to clear any South African film they might want to show not only with the ANC but also with the South African Film and Allied Workers Organisation. 
 If you can't tell what is a racist film and what is not, you shouldn't be in charge of a festival in the first place. 
 This smacks of something akin to censorship, as one impeccably non-racist European festival director sadly pointed out to me. 
 And wherever that comes from, it is surely a bad thing. 
 Recommended films in London: Kieslowski's A Short Film About Killing, Greenaway's The Cook The Thief His Wife And Her Lover, Soderbergh's sex, lies and videotape, Russell's The Rainbow, Phil Noyce's Dead Calm, Spike Lee's Do the Right Thing, Kenneth Branagh's Henry V and Bertrand Tavernier's Life And Nothing But. 
 Independent director Jim Jarmusch: see Critic's view Youki Kudoh and Masatoshi Nagase in a scene from Jim Jarmusch's Mystery Train: see Critic's view Ian McElhinney and Carol Scanlan in Reefer And The Model (left) and Thomas F. Wilson and Lea Thompson in Back To The Future II: see Reviews, page 23 Julia Cameron's God's Will is one of the US independents screened at the London Film Festival: see Critic's view 
 From Dylan to Dexy, Prince to Propaganda-Sweeting's 20 for the 80s (in no particular order). 
 Dexy's Midnight Runners-Searching For The Young Soul Rebels (EMI, 1980). 
 THIS formidable collision of punk anger and soul fervour was Kevin Rowland's finest, most fanatical hour. 
 Just check the way he sneers &bquo;for God's sake, burn it down.&equo; 
 Bob Dylan-Biograph boxed set (CBS, 1985). 
 DYLAN'S albums in the Eighties have been disappointing, including the recent and much-overrated Oh Mercy. 
 But Biograph was a timely reminder of why he used to loom so large, featuring rare tracks, live recordings of familiar songs, and the best Dylan interview in 20 years in the booklet inside. 
 ABC-The Lexicon Of Love (Neutron, 1982). 
 STILL Martin Fry's most memorable achievement, and a record which stands up astonishingly well, thanks to Trevor Horn's ground-breaking production and Fry's songs. 
 The Look Of Love and All Of My Heart remain peerless. 
 Madonna-Like A Prayer (WEA, 1989). 
 MADONNA was already legendary when she made this record, but it was by far her most heartfelt, exuberant and accomplished set of songs. 
 Enough, even, to make you forget those dodgy movies. 
 Elvis Costello-King Of America (F-Beat, 1986). 
 I THINK Costello makes too many records for his own good, but here, he found a vein of country and swing which was peculiarly well suited to his wordplay and visual imagery. 
 In American Without Tears, he even sounded compassionate, for once. 
 John Hiatt-Bring The Family (Demon, 1987). 
 AFTER a familiar Eighties-style de-tox saga, Hiatt returned after years spent as the nearly-man with this scary, hilarious and durable collection. 
 As impressive as the emotional force of the songs was the way their author had learned to marry complex lyrics to tunes which never sounded forced or over-extended. 
 Bruce Springsteen-The River (CBS, 1980). 
 NOT a perfect album by any means (Point Blank is mere melodrama and I Wanna Marry You is a nauseous homily), but a breakthrough for Springsteen in terms of establishing the range of his vision. 
 Wreck On The Highway and Fade Away were bleak and enduring vignettes, while Independence Day and the title song were nothing less than monumental. 
 Sandie Shaw- &bquo;Hello Angel&equo; (Rough Trade, 1988). 
 IN WHICH the barefoot songstrel rewrote her life story for the late Eighties, and came back to claim what should have been hers years before. 
 Great performances, astonishingly strong songs, and a sense of humour too. 
 Prince-Sign O The Times (Paisley Park, 1987). 
 ALL Prince's albums have plenty to recommend them, even the somewhat two-dimensional Batman. 
 Sign O The Times offered the bleak social realism of the title song, an unusually piercing glimpse into the artist's soul on The Cross, plus fragments of incandescent musicianship. 
 The album's apparent randomness made more sense when you saw the movie. 
 Propaganda-Propaganda's Secret Wish (ZTT, 1985). 
 ONE and only outing from the unique German foursome, blending the Gothic, the Romantic and the operatic into a glittering technological whole. 
 Abba meets Kraftwerk. 
 Echo &amp; The Bunnymen-Heaven Up Here (Korova, 1981). 
 THE Bunnymen hit an early peak with this second album, achieving a distance, weight and mystery they would never quite match again. 
 The likes of A Promise brought a Northern Hemisphere chill to the band's stately romanticism. 
 Rosanne Cash-Rhythm &amp; Romance (CBS, 1985). 
 ROSANNE wasn't over-enamoured with this little lot when she'd finished it, considering it too sugary and poppy, but it stands up as her finest album to date. 
 She's in splendid voice on chart-friendly pieces like Never Be You, while Halfway House is a harrowing look at a marriage in transition. 
 Too good to be pigeonholed under &bquo;New Country.&equo; 
 Neneh Cherry-Raw Like Sushi (Circa, 1989). 
 THE shape of pop to come? 
 The outrageously self-possessed Cherry blends pop, soul, rap and the art of the remix into a fiendishly accomplished whole. 
 Makes Bobby Brown look like a novice. 
 Terence Trent D'Arby-Neither Fish Nor Flesh (CBS 1989) IT WON'T do to write D'Arby off as a pathetic Prince impersonator, because his roots are rather different-more Sixties London than Detroit funk. 
 Beneath the quirks of arrangement on this second album, D'Arby delivers resounding pop songs, some great vocal performances, and an idiosyncratic vision which will help him go far. 
 Guns'N'Roses-Appetite For Destruction (Geffen, 1987). 
 AXL ROSE and Co have worked hard at being the bad boys of metal, but their screams of anguish and unleashed hedonism from LA's underbelly strike a blow for freedom from the hegemony of the American mainstream. 
 Sordid and diseased, perhaps, but there's already a compelling and coherent vision at work. 
 John Cale-Music For A New Society (Ze, 1982). 
 THIS fractured and desolate album is often unbearably intense, and you sincerely wouldn't want to be in its author's shoes. 
 But Close Watch and Taking Your Life In Your Hands alone ought to be enough to guarantee it a place in the Immortal section. 
 UB40-Labour Of Love (Dep International, 1983). 
 SUBLIME set of reggae covers from the cunning Brummies. 
 They'll never better Please Don't Make Me Cry, and they know more about Neil Diamond's Red Red Wine than he does. 
 Wall Of Voodoo-Call Of The West (Illegal, 1982). 
 AS GOOD as it got for the deranged Los Angeles combo. 
 Stan Ridgway's distinctive Hollywood-flavoured world view was roaring at full blast on the big set pieces, Lost Weekend and the title track, while the Voodoos' one and only hit single, Mexican Radio, remains thrillingly bonkers. 
 New Order-Brotherhood (Factory, 1986). 
 IT WAS about here that the Mancunians really began to get to grips with the sheer scale of their music. 
 They deployed vast quasi-orchestral sweeps and some of their most memorable melodies (something they're sometimes short of) on their most consistent album. 
 Aerosmith-Permanent Vacation (Geffen, 1987). 
 RECENT live appearances have found the &bquo;Smiths in peak condition. 
 Permanent Vacation marked the start of their comeback, and it's stuffed with unforgettable songs, some of the finest riffs this side of Keith Richards, and above all, contagious good humour. 
 Metal with soul. 
 Win ENO Gala tickets:. 
 ENGLISH National Opera's acclaimed production of Puccini's Madam Butterfly receives a Royal Gala at the London Coliseum in aid of the RSNC's British Wildlife Appeal on December 8. 
 A raffle will also be held during the evening, which is organised around a Japanese theme, with the first prize a return trip for two to Nagasaki. 
 We have a pair of tickets to give away (normal price &pound;50 each) for the gala, plus special entry into the raffle, the winner of which will be announced on the night. 
 The Duchess of Kent will attend the performance at which Janice Cairns sings Butterfly and Edmund Barham sings Pinkerton. 
 To win the pair of tickets answer the questions below and send your answer, on a postcard, to Opera Offer, Listings Limited, 17 Berners Street, London W1P 3DD. 
 En- Janice Cairns as Butterfly tries must be received by first post on Wednesday, November 29. 
 Tickets for the gala can also be booked through 01-403 1960. 
 Which opera was Puccini working on at the time of his death? 
 In what year was Madam Butterfly composed? 
 Bruce Springsteen: Songs about relationships, growing older and social issues sat alongside primitive rock'n'roll revelry * U2'S BONO: From adolescent to messiah; MICHAEL JACKSON: Curtain call (of sorts) during a visit to London; BOB GELDOF: Live Aid mastermind; MADONNA: Durable as Bette Davis?. 
 It began with the murder of John Lennon and ended with the Rolling Stones back on the road. 
 Above all it was the era of Live Aid. 
 Adam Sweeting remembers an exhausting decade and selects 20 key albums Rockin' the Eighties 
 DECADES make convenient units of time for historians, sociologists and pundits of every stripe, but the people who live and work through them don't share the same enthusiasm for tying everything into bundles or stopping precisely at midnight on December 31. 
 You can process the musical history of the Eighties into any format you like-you could call it the decade of Dance, or of Conscience Rock, or of World Music. 
 It was the decade of Geldof and thrash metal. 
 It was the decade of Thatcher and Greenpeace. 
 It was the Sixties all over again. 
 It was unbundling and future technology. 
 It was bloody exhausting, frankly. 
 Some will argue that it was the decade when &bquo;real&equo; music was murdered by Stock, Aitken &amp; Waterman or rap, but on the other hand the &bquo;real&equo; musician of mature years had never had it so good-Chris De Burgh, Fleetwood Mac and Eric Clapton never sold so many tickets, or so many records. 
 It has been a decade divided irredeemably between dance clubs and rock arenas, between acid house and pomp rock, and between teeming fringe activity and an increasingly vast and immovable mainstream. 
 The Eighties began with the murder of John Lennon and Goodbye. 
 The Smiths Echo &amp; The Bunnymen Talking Heads Bros Husker Du. 
 ended with Lisa Stansfield. 
 The Eighties began with The Magic Of Boney M and ended with the never-ending saga of the Rolling Stones. 
 At the start of the decade the 2-Tone bands were keeping everybody up to scratch about racism, and by the end of it a member of Duran Duran had bought himself a house in South Africa. 
 Queen played at Sun City and were reviled, then played at Live Aid and were forgiven. 
 In 1980 U2 were four callow youths from Dublin, and in 1989 people come looking for miracle cures in Bono's front garden. 
 The Japanese now own CBS and a lump of Virgin Records. 
 Yet the way the decade would develop was, with hindsight, reasonably clear from the outset. 
 In 1981 the Human League released Dare, which promptly became a global electropop sensation. 
 Today, its technology sounds comically shrill and weedy, but songs like Seconds and Don't You Want Me still exert considerable force, and the album's focus on pop melody coupled to straightforward dance beats marked a conscious turning away from Punk, politics or the cerebral dogmatism of bands like Gang of Four. 
 Not that Dare was brainless-Seconds considered John Kennedy's assassination, and Don't You Want Me was as perceptive a snapshot of Eighties mores as pop would produce. 
 Yes, you could think and dance at the same time. 
 But while Human League had emerged from an ethic of post-punk avant-gardism, pop's new wave was narrower in outlook. 
 Before you knew it, we were knee-deep in New Romantics. 
 Spandau Ballet went everywhere in kilts and were, apparently &bquo;the applause for their audience.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, Steve Strange was forever drinking cocktails in nightclubs, while Ultravox perfected one of the least lovable recorded sounds of all time. 
 Most of pop's pretensions to offering social commentary for all were waning along with The Clash and the 2-Tone contingent, and a new ethic of dance-and-forget prevailed. 
 It was the shape of things to come. 
 It was only a short step from here to the so-called &bquo;New Pop&equo; of Duran Duran, Wham! and Culture Club, with ABC standing by as a rather aloof and better-dressed alternative. 
 Everybody stopped reading the music papers and switched to Smash Hits. 
 Rock began to look outmoded, and pop was sexy and young. 
 Yet, while the New Popsters produced a stream of memorable hit singles (Culture Club's Do You Really Want To Hurt Me, or Duran's Hungry Like The Wolf), within three years they'd all be defunct, or frantically searching for a new &bquo;adult&equo; audience. 
 George Michael would find it easiest to grow older gracefully, eventually launching his 1987 album Faith on to a perfectly-targeted audience of millions. 
 As pop's glitterati edged towards maturity, the Prince's Trust and Amnesty International, the thing called Rock pursued its own path. 
 Bruce Springsteen began the Eighties with The River, an uneven double album but one which staked out the broad territory over which he would roam in the ensuing years. 
 Songs about relationships, growing older and social issues sat alongside primitive rock'n'roll revelry and country idioms, telling you something about Springsteen's range as well as about the breadth of concerns which rock could now legitimately address. 
 Meanwhile, U2 kicked off their career with Boy, which introduced their scintillating guitar-based sound and the vaguely spiritual approach which would harden progressively into a kind of rock crusade as the Eighties wore on. 
 U2's progress has been a useful indicator of Eighties mainstream tastes (white). 
 On this evidence, audiences want expressions of compassion and concern and not too much materialism. 
 They want music which recalls rock's most exciting classic moments without quite turning into heavy metal (too crass). 
 They want emotional commitment, but no specific political affiliation. 
 They want to feel righteous, but they don't want to define exactly where they stand. 
 U2 are the world's most successful social democrats, the perfect spokesmen for the Live Aid era. 
 Sorry, Sting. 
 Above all, the Eighties has seen music becoming increasingly industrialised, and increasingly impersonal. 
 Like all large corporations, the big record companies and the major artists allocate a percentage of profits to charity and good causes. 
 As one is encouraged to endorse broad humanitarian concerns, one is also expected to respond not so much to specific songs or artists so much as to generic types of music. 
 For instance, Bon Jovi, Cher and Alice Cooper might easily swap places. 
 Alexander O'Neal, Freddie Jackson and Luther Vandross could substitute for one another if one of them got sick, while a new &bquo;Women&equo; category has been opened to accommodate Tanita Tikaram, Suzanne Vega, Tracy Chapman etc. 
 This is how the record companies want it, because if one act inexplicably runs out of steam it's no problem to find another. 
 Once, it was a pop cliche that the records which mattered most to you were the ones which marked your earliest sexual encounters or which signposted key events in your adolescence. 
 Now, music is so undifferentiated and ubiquitous that young lives are measured instead by TV commercials or computer games with Bomb The Bass backing tracks on them. 
 Music isn't for keeping and treasuring, it's for cutting up and feeding into a computer. 
 Hence, the great divide between music perceived to be &bquo;authentic&equo; and music held to be &bquo;manufactured&equo;. 
 Neither category contains meaning any longer, since we don't hear anything unfiltered by the business or the media. 
 But if you find yourself looking for authenticity, it means you're at least 32. 
 Thus, the irritatingly righteous World Music has become Hello. 
 Stone Roses &bquo;New&equo; Country 808 State R.E.M. 
 Soul II Soul. 
 a handy refuge for many punters fed up with processed pop, but the indigenous musics of Zimbabwe, Soweto or Venezuela will never serve the same purpose as Gimme Shelter or Relax for a British, French or American listener. 
 Meanwhile, big, butch rappers like LL Cool J and Public Enemy are held up as authentic voices of the Male Ghetto Experience (usually by middle-class white semioticians), but if anything rap is even more the product of flatulent ego and opportunist marketing than anything by Bros or Kylie Minogue. 
 Also, it isn't physically possible to sit and listen to a rap album all the way through. 
 Run-DMC sensibly provided a side order of heavy metal with their rantings and secured crossover success, while it's noticeable that LL Cool J has resorted to introducing unabashed Radio 2-style ballads into his repertoire. 
 For the Nineties, it's safe to predict that the nostalgia boom has a few years left to run, that Neneh Cherry, Roland Gift and Terence Trent D'Arby will become as big as they want to be, and that Bobby Brown's crafty commercialisation of rap, soul and a vast ego will give Wacko a run for his money quite soon. 
 Bruce Springsteen will return to smaller venues, having realised that the Born In The USA tour was a big mistake, and Madonna will prove to be as durable as Bette Davis. 
 Michael Jackson will be the first man on Mars, if he isn't already. 
 THE new issue of the Film Yearbook (Virgin, &pound;6.99) includes comments from several film-makers on the quality of the past 12 months' cinema. 
 The most trenchant is by the Dutch director Harry Kumel&hellip; &bquo;a terrible year &mdash; I have never seen one like it.&equo; 
 This seems to be pitching things a good deal too high, but the current London Film Festival, which continues until Sunday, tends to confirm the impression that 1989 has been a less than vintage year for the movies. 
 For one thing, there has been nothing in the festival from the really great names, save for Satyajit Ray, whose transposition of An Enemy Of The People seems to me, though hardly on the top level of his work, to be both eloquent and deeply felt. 
 And perhaps now Kieslowski must be counted among this elite: his A Short Film About Love can, like the Ray, be seen on Sunday. 
 But elsewhere, despite quite a bit of stodge, there has been evidence of lively and (that old critical standby) interesting, if not necessarily very innovative, work from a wide range of quarters. 
 And quite a lot of it, from sources ranging from Brazil to Finland, will be finding its way to a wider British audience fairly soon &mdash; evidence of the continuing courageousness of our specialised distributors in the face of considerable odds. 
 By contrast with this largesse, however, one area that nowadays seems rather under-represented on our screens is the mainstream cinema of western Europe. 
 But LFF evidence tends to corroborate suggestions that this may be because such film-making is just not very good at the moment. 
 Dark Woods, for instance, by the veteran French director Jacques Deray, offers a pretty discouraging experience. 
 Opulent decors and images only point up the jadedness, and the tale of a deracinated interloper (Beatrice Dalle) caught up in family plotting at the chateau turns into a risible cross between Edgar Allan Poe and Homes And Gardens. 
 Where Deray has been making films for 30 years, Pierre Jolivet's Force Majeure (complete with an eccentric appearance by a French-speaking Alan Bates) represents only his third feature. 
 Yet it seems hardly less lacking in vitality, and manages to make its commendably brief duration of 86 minutes feel like a great many more as it toils though a youthful crisis of conscience. 
 French-speaking cinema managed, though, to make considerable amends with Jean-Jacques Andrien's Australia, actually a Franco-Belgian-Swiss co-production, and set partly under the bright skies of South Australia but mainly among the mists of the Belgian city of Verviers, where the director was born. 
 The film, which stars Jeremy Irons and Fanny Ardant, is distinguished by an elliptically refined narrative structure and by the expressive cinematography of Yorgos Arvanitis, but above all by a real capacity to dramatise intimate emotions. 
 And it evinces a rather daring readiness to weave its fiction around the world of work, where private lives are inextricably bound up with talk of profit margins and raw materials. 
 The novelistic density of Andrien's film makes the well-meant Canadian picture Bye Bye Blues (director, Anne Wheeler), which touches on somewhat related themes though it is set during the war, seem merely novelettish. 
 But the disparity lies less in tone than in technique: like rather a lot of modern movies, Bye Bye Blues lacks the capacity to formulate its material rather than just present it to the audience and leave them to do the rest. 
 And speaking of Australia, one of the strangest films in the LFF has come from there: Malpractice, made by Bill Bennett, and echoing the semi-documentary style and probing of official attitudes of his earlier A Street To Die, except that here the recounting of a medical accident is fictitious. 
 The long opening sequence, detailing a mismanaged operation of a baby's delivery, is an extraordinary feat of simulation, yet it also tends to defeat realism because we know what we are seeing is not really happening. 
 But it should be added that at the press preview, I seemed to be only one of several spectators who chose to devote themselves during these scenes to a meticulous scrutiny of their shoes. 
 Books. 
 A special 12-page guide to Christmas books will appear in Saturday's edition 
 Too-easy rider Television. 
 By Hugh Hebert 
 AMERICANS will tell you anything, says Michael Palin, and half of me believes him. 
 The other half wants to hang dependent clauses; like &bquo;Americans will tell anything to an Englishman with a camera poking over his right shoulder when they are trapped on a long distance train.&equo; 
 Or, &bquo;Americans will tell anything to Michael Palin.&equo; 
 This may be partly because Palin is so patently and so very likeable, and, whatever his private doubts, always looks as though he believes every word. 
 Do you have problems with obesity, he asked the steward on the Desert Wind, the train so called not because of dietary angst but because it crosses the Mojave on the way from LA to Chicago. 
 &bquo;We treat obesity as a handicap,&equo; said the steward before launching into the story of the Fat Lady who lifted the toilet seat by mistake and was caught by the waste disposal system. 
 The system on this train-be warned-does not blow, it sucks. 
 Around the World in 80 Days (BBC-1) started by pulling eight million viewers and at the last count two weeks ago had more than 11 million. 
 That week it nestled at No 14 in this channel's Top Twenty. 
 You can see why, apart from Palin-for one thing, it is cunningly scheduled between the Nine O'Clock News, with its much increased audience, and Sportsnight. 
 It has also been running for the past three weeks against The Free Frenchman, which may turn out to be a turbo-tortoise but which started as the turn off of the week. 
 The world with Palin is armchair travel on the scale of the grand tour, in the company of an agreeable guide. 
 The worse things got for this cheerful pilgrim, the better to enjoy our home comforts. 
 It's all been a bit too easy on the ear and eye. 
 The Palin charm and good humour wash off without leaving any residue for all the 30,000 miles on the clock, and all the pounds on the budget, and Passepartout's diligent camera, and Roger Mills's direction. 
 Of the programmes I've watched-not all of them, let me confess-only the third, on the dhow in the Gulf seemed to enter into a wholly unknown, and dangerous environment, a way of life I could never have imagined. 
 And he seemed to get closer to these seamen because of that. 
 Maybe you can't engineer that sort of thing in advance, but I just wished it had happened more often. 
 Still, it was not, after all, a straight documentary, but a bet. 
 And Palin won, arriving back on the eve of his eightieth day, and finding the Reform Club, his starting point, closed to him-or at least to his cameras-and London in the grip of last Christmas's shopping rush. 
 On the train from Chicago to New York before joining his last ship, he met two women off on a trip to the Big Apple for the shops and the shows, and a night out at Chippindales. 
 This turned out to be a male stripper club (&bquo;Not naked!&equo; said one matron, with Mid-Western propriety). 
 And when you go home again, said Palin, is that an anti-climax? 
 They loved it. 
 But home to London, where a newsvendor would not serve him till he turned the camera away, was pretty anticlimactic too. 
 Brits won't tell you nothing. 
 THE planned Signals (C4) on the American wave of hate comedy has run into IBA trouble so instead we had Sue Judd's programme about the five finalists for the Vivian Ellis award for young writers of musicals. 
 There was one about 1930s radio shows: All I had to do was hear your voice, All at once I knew I had no choice&hellip; 
 There was one about lesbian leanings in a girls' school: Put on your navy knicks, Pick up your hockey sticks&hellip; 
 There was one based on Proust and one based on Zola, and the winner was about the ghosts of a haunted house being disturbed by an estate agent and a gang of would-be mortgage slaves. 
 Comment was dominated by the critic Mark Steyn who kicked opera in the teeth and said he'd take Frank Loesser in preference to Puccini any time. 
 And Lionel Bart was on hand with his native pith: &bquo;Stephen Sondheim's not afraid to show his emotions. 
 Such as they are.&equo; 
 Is musical theatre a bitchy profession or something? 
 It looked like a rock &bquo;n &bquo;roll shambles, then the Killer smelt blood. 
 Robin Denselow sees Jerry Lee Lewis in fighting form at Hammersmith Odeon Rock solid. 
 THERE are three main attributes in becoming a living legend. 
 It is useful (though not always vital) to have played a significant part in the development of popular music. 
 It is important to have been about for a very long time. 
 And it is desirable to act in a way that shall ensure long, unbelievable biographies. 
 On the last count alone, Jerry Lee Lewis has justified his status a hundred times over in the past few days. 
 The wildest white pianist of the rock &bquo;n&equo; roll era is now 54, and his early history is celebrated in a new film in which Dennis Quaid tries to play the younger Jerry Lee. 
 Perhaps it is an honour he has found hard to bear, for he has been acting very strangely even by his own standards. 
 Most artists would revel in such adulation, especially when the film is followed by a special concert that is to be televised and includes a whole gang of celebrities paying their musical respects. 
 The event was supposed to be staged a couple of weeks back, but was postponed because Lewis was said to be unwell and still in America. 
 He reached Britain this week, but then refused to turn up for several arranged interviews and acted aggressively enough to justify his old nickname, Killer. 
 The omens were bad, and when the Hammersmith show eventually got going it seemed we were in for an all-time rock &bquo;n&equo; roll disaster. 
 A distinguished backing band, including Dave Edmunds and Presley's one-time guitarist, James Burton, knocked out a few appropriate standards while a video crew wandered about on the stage shining lights at an audience that had not paid to be treated as studio extras. 
 Then, with no explanation, they wandered off. 
 It was a shambles. 
 Those predicting a no-show were proved wrong. 
 Lewis suddenly wandered on to the stage and started playing, hotly pursued by the band, who had not been tipped off. 
 He looked as mean as ever, a pallid, unsmiling figure in black-suede jacket and very shiny black shoes. 
 He seemed as tense as a newly released convict, and that tension was reflected in the percussive piano style with which he treated the opening up-beat R&amp;B and country selections, including Mean Woman Blues and You Win Again. 
 When he addressed the audience it was to remind them of &bquo;one of my lovely wives&equo; &mdash; a sly reference to the Fifties tour when he was hounded by the British press because he had married a 13-year-old. 
 Most would-be tough pop-stars are pussycats, but Lewis is still trouble. 
 Musically, he was heading for a standard, slightly throw-away show, when the first special guest appeared. 
 Van Morrison, arguably the second most difficult white performer in rock history, wandered on in a suit to start improvising round a punchy version of the old Weavers hit, Good Night Irene. 
 The staccato vocals, and Morrison's sudden interjections, utterly transformed the song, and the duo moved on to swap vocals to and fro in Lewis's hit, What'd I Say. 
 Suddenly, this had become a special event and Lewis knew it, for his playing took on a new intensity as he began to alternate between rock &bquo;n&equo; roll classics from his early career back in the Fifties Sun era to later country material. 
 By now he was joined by a motley army of British guitarists, including a delighted Dave Davies from the Kinks, a diffident Stuart Adamson from Big Country, the Moody Blues bassist, John Lodge, and Queen's Brian May, who was determined to startle the Killer with wailing heavy-metal solos. 
 They bashed efficiently through Jailhouse Rock, Tutti Frutti, and the rest, along (of course) with the Jerry Lee classics, Whole Lotta Shakin' Going On and Great Balls Of Fire, as well as a strange, up-beat Me And Bobby McGhee. 
 Jerry Lee still found time to criticise the bassist from his own backing band but was now in classic form. 
 He played standing up, with his feet and backside, and managed to sound dangerous. 
 There was fighting in the gangways and a young girl beat the bouncers to throw herself at his feet. 
 He may act at times like a nasty prat, but he is still a legend. 
 Jerry Lee Lewis&hellip; as tense as a newly released convictPHOTOGRAPH: DOUGLAS JEFFERY 
 Short films about success Krzysztof Kieslowski's reputation precedes him. 
 At Cannes last year, A Short Film About Killing took a major prize. 
 Now after ecstatic reviews it is playing to packed audiences in London. 
 Next year, his ten-film Decalogue of parables will be shown on TV. 
 Steve Goldman talks to the man widely regarded as Europe's best film-maker. 
 KRZYSZTOF Kieslowski has become the European film-makers' film-maker. 
 The 20-year overnight transformation from an obscure documentarist working with Krzysztof Zanussi's Tor unit to Poland's leading director came on November 26 when Kieslowski's A Short Film About Killing (Krotki Film O Zabijaniu) took the first European Oscar. 
 Contrasting the brutal murder of a taxi driver with the subsequent execution of the accused, A Short Film About Killing forms the first part of Kieslowski's Decalogue cycle &mdash; ten separate parables which draw thematically from the Ten Commandments and are linked by a common setting, an anonymous Warsaw housing estate. 
 Says Kieslowski: &bquo;The stories are set in Warsaw, the pictures made in Poland, but the situations described are universal. 
 The Commandments relate not only to religion, but to the intercourse between people, which is most interesting to me. 
 If something is well written, one should film it.&equo; 
 Seeking to tap Poland's two primary sources of finance, Film Polski, the state's governing film board, and Pol Tel, the national broadcast network, Kieslowki divided his productions into two groups. 
 Decalogue V and VI, A Short Film About Killing and A Short Film About Love were made for the cinema. 
 The remaining eight were made for Polish television. 
 The difference, apart from the lengths (the theatrical versions running at approximately 90 minutes, the television versions at 60), is negligible. 
 As Kieslowski, who cut his molars on more than 30 documentaries in the Seventies, told one French critic: &bquo;There's no difference between the two except that television pays you less and you have to work faster.&equo; 
 Remarkably, Kieslowski shot and edited the ten films back-to-back over a 21-month period using different cinematographers on each production. 
 &bquo;Making ten films is truly boring,&equo; he says &bquo;If I had worked continuously with the same cameraman, I wouldn't have been able to get up in the morning. 
 &bquo;The decision was to give them a lot of freedom, letting them take the pictures they liked so long as their interpretations were true to the general concept. 
 The result was a kind of competition with each trying to outdo the other.&equo; 
 A Short Film About Killing (Decalogue V) marked its premiere at the 1988 Cannes Film Festival where it was awarded the Jury and International Film Critic's prize. 
 September saw the premiere of the second film of the cycle, A Short Film About Love with top honours at San Sebastian. 
 By February 1989, following his success at the European Film Awards, Kieslowski had established a formidable reputation. 
 Disqualified from the official competition after &bquo;losing its virginity at San Sebastian&equo;, the German premiere of A Short Film About Love at the Berlin Film Festival played to packed audiences. 
 By May, Kieslowski was back in Cannes, this time as a member of Wim Wenders' Jury. 
 Again the films, Decalogues I, IX, and X (the first television versions to be screened), played out of competition to capacity attendance at the small Andre Bazin cinema. 
 The completed cycle was screened in its entirety for the first time at the Venice Festival this autumn. 
 Much has transpired in Poland since my two conversations with Krzysztof Kieslowki in Berlin and Cannes &mdash; a July election giving a popular mandate to Solidarity (of which Kieslowki is a member), President Bush's tour of the Eastern Bloc, the insubstantial pledge of debt reduction, and the growing economic crisis which now threatens the fragile new government. 
 Still, it is interesting that Kieslowki's pessimistic perceptions of the Polish state, and to a lesser extent its film industry, have remained unchanged. 
 &bquo;Of course, one can say a lot now,&equo; said Kieslowki last February in Berlin when asked about the impact of Glasnost. 
 But talking changes nothing, and for now it is only talk. 
 The autorities in Poland understand that talking will not harm them and this gives the Polish intellegentsia a feeling of freedom. 
 So they allowed it. 
 But it is only talk, only words. 
 &bquo;In Poland, the problem is that one can't buy toilet paper. 
 You have to collect old papers and find the special places where they swap them in return for new toilet paper. 
 For three rolls of old paper you get one new roll.&equo; 
 Similar chords of pathos are struck in Kieslowski's A Short Film About Love, where an adolescent voyeur becomes infatuated with an older woman living across the square. 
 Spying on the woman and her lover from afar with his telescope, he disrupts their encounter by reporting a gas leak in the apartment. 
 But when the gas board make their inspection, they check for the leak with a candle. 
 Similarly, when a rendezvous is finally arranged, a date at an icecream parlour, the couple arrive only to find the shop has run out of icecream. 
 &bquo;It's funny for you,&equo; says Kieslowski, &bquo;but for us it's not so funny any more. 
 I think people in Poland are losing their sense of humour and this is very dangerous.&equo; 
 Kieslowski's acerbic critiques of life under communism won little respect from the Party. 
 Few of his films were screened abroad and many suppressed within Poland. 
 Their fate now rests with Solidarity's new communications minister, Andree Drawice, who replaced the hardliner Jerzy Urban. 
 In Poland, the Decalogue has met with impressive results. 
 Kieslowski cites attendances of 200,000 for the initial run of A Short Film About Killing, and 400,000 within five months for A Short Film About Love. 
 Initially the Polish press labelled the films &bquo;boring&equo;, &bquo;insipid&equo;, &bquo;ill-made&equo; and &bquo;ill-played&equo;. 
 &bquo;They are now trying to draw back from earlier opinions, but this does not change my opinion of them.&equo; 
 Kieslowski&hellip; 
 &bquo; 
 One can say a lot now, but talking changes nothing, and for now, it is only talk&equo; 
 Testing time for Brecht Critics' view Theatre.. 
 By Michael Billington in London 
 DEBORAH Warner, who stunned us with her Titus Andronicus and Electra, makes her debut at the National directing Brecht's The Good Person of Sichuan in the Olivier. 
 Fiona Shaw stars in the double-role of Shen Te and Shui Ta and Bill Paterson and Pete Postlethwaite feature in a strong cast. 
 It will be intriguing to see how Brecht's play stands up at a time when Communism is loosening its ideological hold. 
 Stephen Poliakoff's Playing With Trains at The Pit examines our own troubled society and the move from the optimistic Sixties to the competitive Eighties. 
 Michael Pennington returns from the ESC to the RSC, Simon Russell Beale and Lesley Sharp also feature in Ron Daniels's production. 
 In the West End there are two major transfers. 
 Timberlake Wertenbaker's award-winning Our Country's Good moves from the Royal Court to the Garrick: if you haven't seen it already, not to be missed. 
 Andrew Davies's Prin, a hit at the Lyric Hammersmith, moves to the Lyric, Shaftesbury Avenue, with Sheila Hancock still in command as a Sparkish college principal. 
 At the Phoenix Trevor Nunn directs The Baker's Wife: an American musical by Stephen Schwartz and Joseph Stein based on the famous Marcel Pagnol comedy. 
 Alun Armstrong plays the baker, Sharon Lee Hill his wife. 
 Cheek by Jowl come to the Almeida with Lady Betty: the story of Ireland's first hangwoman written and directed by Declan Donnellan with music by Paddy Cuneen and Sally Dexter in the lead. 
 Nigel Planer appears in the jokey I, An Actor at Hampstead Theatre. 
 The Young Vic Studio presents Dario Fo's Can't Pay? 
 Won't Pay! in from a recent tour and directed by Romy Baskerville. 
 Recommended: 
 We, The Undersigned (Orange Tree, Richmond): Alexander Gelman's sharp, biting satire on Soviet graft, corruption and entrenched power: excellent production by Sam Walters, ingenious train set by Tom Piper. 
 Poor Beast In The Rain (Bush): Well-crafted Billy Roche play about the limited joys of life in Wexford: some of the best acting in London with Des McAleer outstanding as an ebullient, small-town fantasist. 
 Singer (The Swan, Stratford-on-Avon; today matinee and Saturday evening): Peter Flannery's tonic, audacious play about Rachmanism and the dangers of erasing the past: Antony Sher unmissable as the eponymous, chameleon hero. 
 Man, Beast and Virtue (Cottesloe: today until Wednesday). 
 Pirandello at his gayest: a blithe farce about marital masks zippily directed by William Gaskill. 
 By Robin Thornber in Manchester 
 ALAN AYCKBOURN is writing for children again, after the success of his Mr A's Amazing Maze Plays at Scarborough last Christmas (his earlier offerings to young audiences are now suppressed, at his insistence). 
 Or rather, he says, for family audiences (seven and upwards). 
 Invisible Friends &mdash; about a teenager whose make-believe friend materialises, complete with family &mdash; opens at the Stephen Joseph Theatre in the Round tonight, directed by the author. 
 The Wrestling School premieres Howard Barker's new play with a Last Supper theme, Golgo, at the Leicester Haymarket Studio tonight and the Haymarket Studio also offers its own production, directed by Nick Philippou, of Edward Bond's new play about class war in an unnamed rioting city, Jackets, from Wednesday. 
 Also on Wednesday, Jamaican women's theatre group Sistren bring their show, Buss Out, to Warwick Arts Centre in Coventry to round off the Midlands-based Kajoyo festival of black theatre before touring to Nottingham, Brixton and Cardiff. 
 Nabil Shaban in Nativity; Tricycle: see Theatre Seamus Newham, The Vanek Plays; Soho Poly: see Theatre Suzanne Packer and Clive Russell in Our Country's Good; Garrick: see Critics' choice Reg Stewart and Howard Crossley in Can't Pay? 
 Won't Pay!; 
 Young Vic: see Critics' choice 
 Birmingham.. 
 By Gerald Larner CBSO/Rattle. 
 A SURPRISING aspect of the first British performance of Sofia Gubaidulina's Violin Concerto, subtitled Offertorium, is that it provoked the odd walk-out in Birmingham Town Hall. 
 Certainly, it is an eccentric work and it is true that its spiritual elevation-signalled, Berg-like, by the entry of an instrumental chorale towards the end-cannot be anticipated in the early stages of its apparently disorganised single-movement construction. 
 It is, on the other hand, a highly eventful work, entertaining where not piercingly expressive and, though disconcertingly many-sided in character, it derives coherence from its peculiar devotion to the melody which inspired Bach's Musical Offering. 
 If there is another problem, in that the soloist seems less interested in that theme than the orchestra and prefers to go his own way, it is resolved before the end of the work. 
 Written eight years ago for Gidon Kremer and much revised since then, it has developed its shape from the pressure of the emotions within it and, in spite of the obvious parallel with Berg's Violin Concerto, is fundamentally like no other. 
 The performance, to which Simon Rattle and the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra made a contribution as passionate as the soloist's own, was preceded by an unscheduled opportunity (the first in this country) to hear a recent unaccompanied violin elegy, For Manfred, by Hans Werne Henze. 
 Beautifully played by Gidon Kremer, it would have been all the more welcome if, being the sort of work which doesn't invite applause, it hadn't been so closely associated with Offertorium as to seem to merge into it. 
 The other work in this boldly planned programme was Stravinsky's Rite of Spring, in an interpretation which is surely the product of much thought on Rattle's part. 
 It is as though he had analysed the failings in most other accounts of the work and had deliberately devised the means to obviate them. 
 The very evident tendency of the end of the first part to overshadow the final Sacrificial Dance is one problem he convincingly solved, partly by restraining the former but mainly by injecting an extraordinary degree of ferocity into the fragmented rhythms of the latter. 
 Sadler's Wells. 
 By Mary Clarke LCDT. 
 IT IS too soon to judge what impact upon London Contemporary Dance Theatre will be made by its new artistic director, Dan Wagoner, but the first programme of the Sadler's Wells season finds the dancers, all of them young, in excellent form even if the choreography is less rewarding. 
 Dan Wagoner's own new work, first staged in Plymouth in October, has a jokey title, Turtles All The Way Down, and has something to do with a Bertrand Russell lecture when it was suggested that the Earth is not round but carried on the back of a giant tortoise which stands on turtles all the way down. 
 The dancers engage in playful sport, dressed in simple turtle-coloured costumes, while Wagoner stands at the back as some kind of pondering philosopher figure. 
 It was superbly performed and I found it enjoyable, although it did seem to hark back to an earlier period of American modern dance. 
 Perhaps deliberately; the music is Aaron Copland's Piano Quartet. 
 It was preceded by a 25 minute work by Darshan Singh Bhuller called Ace of Spades which is about the Vietnam war, no less. 
 Lighting and setting are by Robert Cohan (who has known war experience) and there's no doubt of the work's deep sincerity and compassion for the American soldiers of its cast. 
 That does not, however, necessarily justify such a wallow from a young choreographer. 
 The first part of the programme consists of three short pieces: Cohan's clever solo for Bhuller in which he discards his garments, in front of Crickmay blow-up photographs, to Britten's Six Metamorphoses after Ovid; Bhuller's own Interlock, which is quite simply about an interlocked couple to the accompaniment of a sitar; and a dance by Jonathan Lunn, to Philip Glass music, called Doppelganger which is, as you might guess, about a chap confronted by a woman in identical costume whose stuttery movements gradually blend into his own. 
 Next week brings three more London premieres and may tell us more. 
 Sadler's Wells until Dec 2. 
 Battersea Arts Centre. 
 By Betty Caplan Macbeth. 
 WHAT would a visiting foreigner make of this production of Macbeth by The Raving Beauties? 
 She might come away understanding the first part of the company's title, but not the second. 
 She would be well and truly mystified by the sight of an elderly king who needs to be helped into his chair one minute, but can swing his cane around like a golf stick the next, and even more flummoxed by the depiction of a world in which the porter has closed circuit television, but the method of killing hasn't changed a jot. 
 As for Greg Hicks' delivery of his role, she might well consider it beautifully spoken, but would be hard put to find a glimmer of meaning in it. 
 She might imagine that to be quite an achievement. 
 She might even feel that he has at least lent a new understanding to such lines as &bquo;There's nothing serious in mortality.&equo; 
 Frances Viner, who both directs and designs, has set out to look at the &bquo;feminine&equo; qualities of the play and its spiritual nature. 
 Judging by the result, her search was in vain. 
 The witches are apparently a representation of the triple goddess: one looks old like the crone, another is the mother and the third is supposedly the Virgin because she carries her rag doll around with her. 
 This becomes a transitional object quite literally; when Lady Macbeth dies, Macbeth is suddenly seen clutching the very same doll. 
 Is it his anima? 
 His fetish? 
 Who knows? 
 Who cares? 
 And the clothes! 
 The porter has a kilt poking out from under his jacket, and Macduff is stuck with wearing a raincoat on top of his dinner suit for the whole show. 
 No wonder he can't bring himself to show much emotion at the news of his family's demise. 
 The weary visitor would sigh with relief that the production had at least been cut to two hours, and head for the nearest library where she might enjoy reading about the buried feminine aspects of the play. 
 At Battersea Arts Centre (01.223 2223) until December 3, and then on tour. 
 Festival Hall. 
 By Edward Greenfield LPO/Tennstedt. 
 YOU would never have known that Klaus Tennstedt had been ill in his life. 
 After so many forced cancellations over the years, it was a rare joy to welcome this vigorous, athletic figure back to conduct the LPO in what with most conductors would have been a run-of-the-mill Festival Hall programme, but which with Tennstedt in charge became an exhilarating drive. 
 Nothing confirms the stature of artists more clearly than the way they tackle the potboilers of the repertory, and here as soloist in the Grieg Piano Concerto we had another artist who can be unpredictable, sometimes nervily so, Radu Lupu. 
 I have rarely heard him sound more relaxed. 
 With nothing self-conscious in his manner, he and Tennstedt restored the mountain freshness to one great Norwegian melody after another. 
 The piece was played for all its worth, and more, but vulgarity disappeared, the sense of playing to the gallery that dogs the piece. 
 But it was Beethoven's Seventh Symphony after the interval that brought the greatest revelations. 
 In the slow introduction Tennstedt made it clear that this was to be a reading of high, dramatic contrasts, and that led to an account of the Vivace which with its sprung rhythms kept relaxing into pastoral moments without loss of pace or power. 
 In the remaining three movements Tennstedt's speeds were all on the fast side. 
 I have never known the Scherzo sound so like a dashing tarantella, and the headlong pace for the finale inspired exuberant playing from the LPO players, with the horns braying magnificently. 
 THEATRE: Michael Billington on an Expressionist Shaw at the Riverside Studios Death-wish down in Sussex. 
 WE endlessly re-interpret Shakespeare. 
 So why not Shaw? 
 One answer is that he was so explicit in his stage-directions that he leaves designers and directors little freedom of manoeuvre. 
 Boldly ignoring the Shavian prescription, Nancy Meckler's highly original Shared Experience production of Heartbreak House at the Riverside Studios has the quality of a fragmented dream, only occasionally marred by a sock-it-to-em over-emphasis. 
 Written between 1913 and 1919, Shaw's masterpiece famously &bquo;began with an atmosphere&equo;: that of cultured, leisured country-house England embracing the cataclysm of the first world war in a fevered death-wish. 
 Down in Captain Shotover's nautical Sussex retreat, civilisation is seen as a ship on the rocks. 
 The Utterwords and the Hushabyes represent, respectively, the last vestiges of Colonialism and Bohemianism. 
 Boss Mangan, the symbol of industrial and political might, is a love-stricken wreck easily manipulated by the go-getting Ellie Dunn. 
 Only Shotover, a Shavian figure seeking a &bquo;mind ray&equo; that will destroy his enemies, tries to unite wisdom and power; and even he is revealed at the last as a rum-soaked old poseur. 
 It is a great play precisely because it puts so much of England on the stage and because Shaw combines tragic pessimism with comic ebullience. 
 And what Ms Meckler and her designer, Dermot Hayes, have inventively done is to remind us that these characters are like people picknicking on the edge of Vesuvius. 
 Shotover's house is represented by a set of rusting iron arches filled with canvas sails. 
 Chahine Yavroyan's sound-design is a mosaic of distant gunfire, creaking hulks and elegiac music. 
 A British Tommy periodically intrudes into the action as a silent rebuke to the self-absorbed amorous cavortings of the Shotover household. 
 All this is far superior to the dressy emptiness of the last star-studded Haymarket revival. 
 Ms Meckler also decisively scotches the absurd myth that Shaw is a cold, passionless writer. 
 There is a moment here when Fred Pearson's Shotover (looking like a raffish, siren-suited version of Shaw himself) says of his daughter, Lady Utterword, that she is afraid that she has no heart to break: at which point Jennie Stoller's stately, voluptuous Ariadne throws himself at his feet with a wrenching poignancy. 
 Shaw, I suspect, deliberately created the mask of the witty, cerebral sage to conceal the strength of his own emotions. 
 Ms Meckler gives us all of Shaw's poetic tragedy: what she misses is his comic subtlety. 
 Like all first-rate comic writers, Shaw was fascinated by the gulf between appearance and reality. 
 Thus the joke about Boss Mangan, the industrial magnate and political adviser, is that he is frock-coated, careworn and commonplace. 
 But in Stephen Jameson's performance he looks like Beckett's Pozzo or a Daily Worker cartoon of a bloated capitalist: bounced around the stage at one point like a rubber doll, he becomes a figure from a comedy of humours rather than a semi-Chekhovian fantasia. 
 Likewise David Fielder's Mazzini Dunn has less &bquo;the language and appearance of a City missionary&equo; than a whey-faced, mime-show pathos. 
 In highlighting what she sees as the essence of the characters, Ms Meckler often misses their comic contradictions and ambiguities. 
 In acting terms, the production is in fact a strange mixture of precision and coarseness. 
 Mr Pearson's Shotover has exactly the right air of a rapt scientific experimenter trying to attain power through means of mind. 
 Annabelle Apsion's Ellie Dunn is no romantic dreamer but a tough pragmatist in white muslin weaving dance-patterns in front of Boss Mangan like a Sussex Salome. 
 Ian Gelder's Hector, wax-moustached and posturingly heroic, and Marty Cruickshank's Hesione, a bourgeois gypsy in full flight, also hit the right note. 
 I just found the Boss Mangan and the Randall Utterword so effortfully frantic I wanted to avert my gaze. 
 But at least Ms Meckler has rescued Shaw from museum-piece revivalism. 
 She has made him more of an Expressionist than he really was but she has realised an essential truth: that Heartbreak House is a deeply poetic play about the death of liberal hopes and the cracking-apart of a civilisation. 
 At the Riverside Studios (01-748 3354) until December 2. 
 Annabelle Epsion as Ellie 
 Plymouth.. 
 By Andrew Hoellering Richard Deacon. 
 RICHARD Deacon won the Turner prize in 1987 since when he has become one of the most respected of the new wave of British sculptors of the Eighties. 
 Recent exhibitions have been at the Whitechapel Art Gallery and abroad in Toronto, Paris, Pittsburg, Maastricht, Antwerp, Madrid and Los Angeles. 
 His new show is at Plymouth, where he studied as a schoolboy before going on to Somerset College of Art. 
 Deacon's work clearly stands on its own. 
 The challenge he sets himself grows from the nature of his materials and their relationship to an evolving form, and the outcome often involves a series of variations on known or familiar objects. 
 In Distance no Object, one of the five pieces in the show, the analogic form is the eye, in the form of a large protruding oval lip joined to three aluminium bands, the middle one of which is raised. 
 From the side the construction resembles a first world war tank. 
 The eye is of dark glass fibre contrasted in terms of colour and texture to the aluminium. 
 It reflects the viewer and is the negative version of the outside positve shape. 
 The fascination of the piece comes when one starts to compare positive and negative, or outside to inside. 
 The title refers ironically to the fact that the space is not an object but a vaccum which we endow with its physical attributes. 
 Another piece, Kiss and Tell, creates contrasts of surface, texture and colour as well as form. 
 Deacon's structure involves two complementary shapes joined at right angles; shapes that one has never seen before but one recognises as familiar. 
 The first shape is a stack of diminishing wooden ovals, and one looks into it as through the wrong end of an extended telescope. 
 The second shape comes out of the first like the extension of an igloo. 
 If the first shape is a series of rough-hewed approximations, the second is a shiny patchwork of beautifully stitched leather cut-outs. 
 Both parts can be seen as different versions of one another, but there is an absence of inner connection between them. 
 Hence their title. 
 Deacon both uses and transcends technology. 
 He merges the dividing line between natural and man-made materials, between organic and inorganic shapes; the separate traditions of Hepworth and Moore on the one hand and Anthony Caro on the other. 
 With him art does not so much represent nature as human nature creates through art. 
 The results are both impressive and disquieting, for unlike natural forms his do not seem to invite our participation, nor do they depend on us for their formidable originality and sense of completion. 
 Richard Deacon &mdash; New Sculpture, Plymouth Arts Centre until December 23. 
 Six more schools play out their scenes for The Wizard at Snape Maltings tonight at 6 pm. 
 Birmingham. 
 By Gerald Larner CBSO/Rattle. 
 A SURPRISING aspect of the first British performance of Sofia Gubaidulina's Violin Concerto, subtitled Offertorium, is that it provoked the odd walk-out from one or two places in Birmingham Town Hall. 
 Certainly, it is an eccentric work and it is true that its spiritual elevation-signalled, Berg-like, by the entry of an instrumental chorale towards the end-cannot be anticipated in the early stages of its apparently disorganised single-movement construction. 
 It is, on the other hand, a highly eventful work, entertaining where not piercingly expressive and, though disconcertingly many-sided in character, it derives coherence from its peculiar devotion to the melody which inspired Bach's Musical Offering. 
 If there is another problem, in that the soloist seems less interested in that theme than the orchestra and prefers to go his own way, it is resolved before the end of the work. 
 Written eight years ago for Gidon Kremer and much revised since then, it has developed its shape from the pressure of the emotions within it and, in spite of the obvious parallel with Berg's Violin Concerto, is fundamentally like no other. 
 The performance, to which Simon Rattle and the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra made a contribution as passionate as the soloist's own, was preceded by an unscheduled opportunity (the first in this country) to hear a recent unaccompanied violin elegy, For Manfred, by Hans Werne Henze. 
 Beautifully played by Gidon Kremer, it would have been all the more welcome if, being the sort of work which doesn't invite applause, it hadn't been so closely associated with Offertorium as to seem to merge into it. 
 The other work in this boldly planned programme was Stravinsky's Rite of Spring, in an interpretation which is surely the product of much thought on Rattle's part. 
 It is as though he had analysed the failings in most other accounts of the work and had deliberately devised the means to obviate them. 
 The very evident tendency of the end of the first part to overshadow the final Sacrificial Dance is one problem he very firmly and convincingly solved, partly by restraining the former but mainly by injecting an extraordinary degree of ferocity into the fragmented rhythms of the latter. 
 It was not a motor-driven electronically tuned performance (like a recent one by Salonen and the Philharmonia) but one which attempted to penetrate the mysteries of the slower sections, above all those at the beginning of the second part, and one which was thoughtful enough to seem to come to its violent conclusion in spite of itself. 
 Bury St Edmunds. 
 By David Nice The Wizard. 
 BRITTEN'S Miss Wordsworth, primmest of Suffolk schoolma'ms, would no doubt have balked at setting before the public eye any but her most promising music pupils. 
 The remarkable thing about Daryl Runswick's operatic project, following a tradition set by Britten himself and acknowledged as such by the generous support of the Aldeburgh Foundation, is that it involves whole classes from primary and middle schools around Suffolk, not just the few so prematurely labelled &bquo;musical&equo;. 
 Runswick claims a modest role in his &bquo;Write-Your-Own Opera for children to do themselves&equo;, providing the musical frame and a scenario which magics six classes through the ages and to the ends of the earth in search of ingredients for Mr Gandolfi's birthday cake. 
 The rest is up to the children, music included; as Runswick and music director Terry Edwards discovered on their rounds of the schools at an earlier stage in the project, the teachers had only to supervise, rarely to prompt or invent-solid preparation indeed for the GCSE's new emphasis on composition. 
 Eighteen schools are participating in the three performances, and invention from the six gathered in St Edmundsbury Cathedral on Tuesday ranged from dialogue with the odd splash of singing and recorder-music to fully composed masques using all available resources. 
 Howard Primary School, landing at Cambridge University Observatory, found time for a ballet of the night-sky to a background of synthesizer and a resourceful battery of percussion; and although improvisation and rhythm (rap a firm favourite) pushed melody to one side for the most part, Ixworth middle school beguiled the time outside Colman's Mustard Shop in Norwich with a garland of song. 
 Undoubtedly, though, the most spectacular results came from collaboration with Runswick (aka Mr Gandolfi) and Edwards on Prologue and Epilogue. 
 Learning by rote lines which, with their unexpected changes of stress and metre, might baffle a teenager confronting the printed page, combined forces found strength in numbers and support from the resourceful accompaniment. 
 The round still proves the soundest of methods: even given limited rehearsal time, there was much security in the warm-up sequence, a point surprisingly made with This Little Babe from Britten's A Ceremony Of Carols, and by the time we reached Runswick's final party ensemble not a single face on stage I could see registered anything less than complete involvement. 
 John Fordham on the Miles Davis session it's taken four years to release and the week's other albums Twisting, teasing trumpet Jazz. 
 MILES DAVIS: Aura. 
 (CBS 463351-1). 
 MARCUS ROBERTS: The Truth Is Spoken Here. 
 (RCA/Novus PL83051). 
 CHARLES ROUSE: Epistrophy. 
 (Landmark LLP1521). 
 STAN TRACEY: Genesis And More&hellip; 
 (Steam SJ/CD114). 
 MICHEL CAMILO: Why Not? 
 (King Records K32Y6031-CD). 
 MICHEL CAMILO: (CBS PRT463330-1). 
 PETER KING: Crusade. 
 (WEA/Blanco y Negro 2292 46 117-1). 
 VLADIMIR CHEKASIN: Anti-Show. 
 (Leo Records LR165). 
 MILES DAVIS, the late Gil Evans said, was blessed with a sensitivity to his &bquo;complete surroundings&equo; -not simply an awareness of what notes worked with what chord, what accents with what rhythm, but of an atmosphere and resonance about the sounds around him that go beyond their formal construction. 
 Aura, a CBS recording made in Scandinavia four years ago (Davis went to WEA for his last two albums, after 30 years with Columbia), is as good a demonstration of that as anything the trumpeter has recorded since his most famous collaborations with Gil Evans. 
 It is an orchestral session featuring Danish musicians plus Davis, John McLaughlin on guitar, and Vince Wilburn on drums playing the Scandinavian trumpeter's Palle Mikkelborg's concerto for his hero, recorded in Copenhagen to accompany Miles's receipt of the Sonning Music Prize, a tribute whose earlier recipients have been Stravinsky, Leonard Bernstein, and Isaac Stern. 
 The delay in issuing the album may well have been because of CBS's anxiety about how it would go with Davis's fusion fans. 
 Much of it is slow, contemplative, out of regular tempo, deploying distinctly unstreetwise exotic instrumentation. 
 Harps echo McLaughlin's scalding guitar figures, synthesisers unleash cascading peals of sound like church bells, sustained low trombone sounds throb beneath the horn and guitar like sensations from a distant engine-room. 
 Over it all, in nine parts named after colours Mikkelborg associates with Davis, the trumpet curls, wriggles, and lashes out. 
 On the last side's Violet, a reworked blues with references to Messiaen in it, some of Miles Davis's most exquisite slow playing is to be heard over slurred, sliding chords and the kind of empty space you hardly ever hear him loose in these days. 
 Mikkelborg's composition probably would not stand up without Davis, but then it was not designed to. 
 As Miles Davis, now 63, goes on developing, his most assiduous young admirer, Wynton Marsalis, goes on backtracking in search of his roots, taking other potentially excellent young players with him. 
 Marsalis appears on his pianist Marcus Robert's album of standards, originals that sound like standards, and tributes to Monk, The Truth Is Spoken here. 
 Roberts has long seemed one of the most interesting ingredients in Marsalis's bands, a young guardian of the traditions exhibiting both the smooth swing of a Wynton Kelly and the crabbiness of Thelonius Monk. 
 But, like many of the present batch of respectful &bquo;classical jazz&equo; sessions, the sense of inevitability about what is going to happen next overcomes the work of the most virtuosic players, even a supporting cast that includes Elvin Jones on drums and the tenorist Charles Rouse. 
 Rouse can be heard to better effect on a live recording from a San Francisco Monk tribute in October 1988, seven weeks before his death. 
 The broken, Monkish phrases, lean, understated tone with a faint quaver to it, and unerring sense of placement are to be heard on five Monk tunes, and the trumpeter, Don Cherry &mdash; a musician of whom it is distinctly difficult to say you know what is coming next &mdash; is available on some of them. 
 When Rouse came to England his favourite playing partner was Stan Tracey. 
 Genesis, Tracey's distinctly secular celebration of the Creation, has been reissued as a CD, with two of the composer's big-band classics (Afro-Charlie and Murdering The Time) added for good measure. 
 Genesis is exhilarating and exuberant orthodox big-band music of a kind rarely played with such punch any more and the sharpness of the CD enhances the brash, headlong momentum of it &mdash; Tracey's orchestras always sound as if they are going to work with the elan of Saturday night at the Savoy ballroom. 
 Another kind of piano-led exuberance comes from the Santo Domingo pianist, Michel Camilo, who made such an impact with his dancing, colourful Caribbean-dominated virtuosity at Ronnie Scott's earlier in the year. 
 Why Not? is a CD of a four-year-old recording, the CBS album being a session from last year. 
 The CD is the more tonally varied, featuring the excellent Lew Soloff playing a good deal of street-festival trumpet on some irresistible buoyant themes. 
 On the 1988 session Camilo's luxuriant piano plays with a different trio on each side, both displaying an absorption in the past without a hint of scholasticism. 
 The emphasis is on reflection. 
 In the new jazz climate, the anonymity of Peter King, one of the unsung great British saxophonists, has lifted a little &mdash; partly because one of his admirers is Ben Watt of Everything But The Girl, who is also the producer of Crusade. 
 Given that background, the album is unsurprisingly pop-influenced, with a velvety studio atmosphere, tunes by Smokey Robinson, Donny Hathaway and Joni Mitchell, even a funk version of Blue Monk. 
 It all represents King a little too effectively marketed to tingle the skin, but underneath it all there is the same fluidity, the same lightning double-time runs, the same sense of shape, declaring that repackaging cannot really cramp his style. 
 The opposite extreme is represented by the Russian saxophonist, Vladimir Chekasin, sometime member of the Ganelin Trio, caught here live on the Munster Jazz Festival. 
 It is a delicious jumble of free-improvising sound-effects (percussion shuffles like dogs sniffing, demented woodpecker noises, thumps like paperweights dropped on upstairs floors, sudden yelps and barks), manic pastiche of military marches, bolero music, and awards-ceremony pomposity, with Chekasin's raw, scorching horn slashing through it. 
 Miles Davis: exquisite slow playing PHOTOGRAPH: ALLAN TITMUSS OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Pleasures of Purcell Classical. 
 By Edward Greenfield GREENFIELD ST CECILIA GRAM PURCELL: Come Ye Sons Of Art, Welcome To All The Pleasures-Pinnock/English Concert and Choir (with Yorkshire Feast Song). 
 DG Archiv 427 663-2. 
 Parrott/Taverner Consort, Choir and Players (with Funeral Music for Queen Mary, Funeral Sentences). 
 EMI CDC7 49635-2. 
 PURCELL: Welcome To All The Pleasures, Arise My Muse, Now Does The Glorious Day Appear -King/King's Consort. 
 Hyperion CDA 66314. 
 HANDEL: Four Coronation Anthems, Royal Fireworks Music-King/New College Choir/King's Consort. 
 Hyperion CDA 66350. 
 Four Coronation Anthems, Chandos Anthem No. 9- Willcocks/King's College Choir/ ECO. 
 Decca 421 150-2. 
 PURCELL: Te Deum and Jubilate in D, Four Anthems-Preston/Christ Church Choir/English Concert. 
 DG Archiv Galleria 427 124-2. 
 ST CECILIA'S DAY this year has prompted not just one but two brand new recordings of Purcell's delightful Ode for celebrating that day in 1683, Welcome To All The Pleasures, while earlier this year there was yet a third. 
 Thanks to records above all we are no longer in danger of forgetting such joyous Purcell inspirations as this, pieces that have always been in danger of dropping out of the repertory simply for being &bquo;occasional music.&equo; 
 After all ceremonial and courtly pomp inspired many of the most important works not just of Purcell but of whole centuries of composers, and record companies, egged on by the period performance boom, are more and more investigating them. 
 The three versions of the 1783 St Cecilia Ode are all authentic performances on period instruments, but are nicely contrasted. 
 Both of the latest versions couple the 1683 Ode with the best-known of Purcell's Odes for Queen Mary's Birthday, the one for 1694, the year before both she and he died. 
 Andrew Parrott with the Taverner Choir and Players are more intimate-sounding than their rivals, Trevor Pinnock and the English Concert and Choir, but the voices are slightly distant. 
 In sheer sound Pinnock gains consistently from greater fullness, brightness and immediacy, and the weight of his forces goes with extra rhythmic resilience, lifting the music more. 
 Parrott is lively too, but the performances are gentler, and his often slower speeds-as in the first chorus of the Birthday Ode with its call to &bquo;Celebrate this triumphant day'-bring out the dancing rhythms less infectiously. 
 I prefer Pinnock's soloists too. 
 The countertenor duetting of Michael Chance and Timothy Wilson in the delectable &bquo;Sound the trumpet&equo; from that same Ode is unmatchable. 
 Interestingly in that duet Parrott has only one countertenor-Timothy Wilson again-with the second part taken by a high tenor, John Mark Ainsley. 
 Pinnock's coupling is the rarer and more generous too, the Yorkshire Feast Song, composed in 1690 for an &bquo;otherwise obscure annual gathering of York nobility.&equo; 
 The wonder is that Purcell, seemingly unable to turn out a pot-boiler even for minor events, produced ten substantial movements which in their vigour and imagination match the royal odes. 
 But don't expect much more than pompous doggerel in the words. 
 Parrott's coupling is less generous but both apt and well-contrasted, Purcell's two collections of Funeral Music. 
 In pursuit of authenticity he has eliminated the apparently spurious timpani part from the first movement of Queen Mary's Funeral Music, the well-known solemn slow march for slide trumpets-performed here on sackbuts. 
 That makes it dramatically far less effective than on some previous recordings, but the central anthem is beautifully done, and it is good too to have the three superb Funeral Sentence anthems of a few years earlier. 
 The third version of the St Cecilia Ode of 1683 comes on Hyperion from the King's Consort under Robert King using instead of a choir an octet of distinguished soloists (including James Bowman, Michael Chance and John Mark Ainsley). 
 With cunning recording balance ensuring that there is no lack of warmth or weight in the choral sound, this is a more relaxed account of the St Cecilia Day Ode, and is well coupled with two of the other Queen Mary Birthday Odes, the first two, dating from 1690 and 1691. 
 Also from the King's Consort is a highly enjoyable new recording of Handel's Four Coronation Anthems, again amiable and relaxed rather than incisively dramatic. 
 Simon Preston's DG Archiv version with the English Concert remains preferable, but Robert King evens the balance by providing as an extra the first period performance of Handel's Royal Fireworks Music to use the full complement of instruments that Handel demanded. 
 I am not sure that on record it makes all that much difference to have 24 baroque oboes, as here, instead of 12 or so, but the sound of so many along with 12 bassoons, nine trumpets, nine trumpets and four sets of timpani is mightily impressive, and the more attractive for a rhythmic bounce. 
 On the Hyperion label the disc comes at &bquo;upper mid-price&equo; - just under &pound;10-but it is worth remembering that Sir David Willcocks's vintage performances of the Coronation Anthems with King's College Choir at their brightest now come on mid-price CD in Decca's Ovation series, generously coupled with the magnificent, extended Chandos Anthem No. 9, O Praise The Lord With One Consent. 
 On the mid-price Archiv Galleria label-an invaluable source of excellent baroque material-DG has issued a selection from Simon Preston's splendid collection with the Christ Church Cathedral Choir and Trevor Pinnock's English Concert of Purcell's Anglican church music. 
 The great Te Deum and Jubilate in D are generously supplemented with four major verse anthems-My Heart Is Inditing, O Sing Unto The Lord, They That Go Down To The Sea In Ships and Praise The Lord, O Jerusalem. 
 The performances and recording are near-ideal. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 The team spirit Is Field Of Dreams really about baseball? 
 Derek Malcolm reviews Kevin Costner's latest film, and the other new releases. 
 IS Field Of Dreams (Cannon, Shaftesbury Avenue, PG) poetry or corn? 
 What you will think of it, I suspect, depends on your zodiac sign or whether you blubbed through the last few minutes of Peter Weir's Dead Poets Society. 
 It hangs on that sort of knife-edge. 
 In Phil Alden Robinson's adaptation of W.P.Kinsella's book, Kevin Costner, Hollywood's latest superstar, plays a New York boy with a hang-up about his father who has taken his wife (Amy Madigan) and daughter off to an Iowan farm to find themselves as a family. 
 Once there he hears a mysterious voice in his cornfields: &bquo;If you build it, he will come.&equo; 
 The &bquo;he&equo; is Shoeless Joe Jackson (Ray Liotta), a disgraced member of the Chicago team who threw the World Series back in his father's time. 
 Another message &mdash; &bquo;Ease his pain&equo; &mdash; sends the farmer off to Boston to find a reclusive novelist (James Earl Jones) and a third imprecation from the skies &mdash; &bquo;Go the distance&equo; has him looking for another old baseballer (Burt Lancaster) who played just once for the New York Giants before becoming a much-loved doctor. 
 Finally, they all progress back to the ranch for one last game where the farmer's father materialises to play catch with him. 
 The game the young man has been playing, however, is not baseball but exorcism. 
 And what he wants to exorcise are his bad feelings about the man who brung him up. 
 All this is exceedingly American and seems even more so at a time, in the cinema at least, where men love men best and occasionally try for sex with women. 
 But it is totally universal as well in that it is also a simple parable, like Dead Poets Society, about the necessity to follow your instincts and not get trapped by the drive to conform. 
 The Sixties versus the Eighties, in fact. 
 The question is &mdash; does it work? 
 Little niggles surface. 
 Baseball fans point out that Jackson bats right-handed and throws left instead of the other way round and was anyway more villain than hero, a theory the film never discusses. 
 More seriously, the film's remorseless romanticism has a smug and manipulative edge to it that some may find virtually intolerable. 
 All the same, it is something of an achievement, both in the solid craft of its making and the strength of its performances. 
 Costner can act very well, but it is his presence that really counts, a little like it did for James Stewart. 
 And there is no doubt that both James Earl Jones, as the sceptical writer, and Lancaster as the saintly doctor, are the sort of character players you never stop watching. 
 Field of Corn it may be, but at least the corn is not over-ripe. 
 Everyone involved seems to be scrupulously in tune with with the piece's pent-up emotions so that the small details consistently add to the whole rather than deflect from it self-consciously. 
 Besides, in the week of Back To The Future II (Empire PG), with its trailer for the third episode shamelessly tacked on to the end, and dozens of trade names shamelessly glaring through its mise-en-scene, Field Of Dreams seems positively purist in its appeal. 
 There is very little to say about the new Robert Zemeckis film that hasn't been said about the old one. 
 Except that it was made back-to-back with a third episode, and there is an extraordinary air of expediency about it. 
 The only difference I can find lies in the darker, more spiteful vision of the new film, and the fact that the cast seems almost manically inclined to get through it all as fast as possible and at as high a pitch as the Dolby Stereo can cope with. 
 Unless the sound setting at the press show was a mistake, I have seldom heard a noisier film nor one which seems to require its stars (Michael J. Fox and Christopher Lloyd again) to bellow their lines so startlingly over the din. 
 Whipping off in the Doc's DeLorean time machine to find 2015 in Hill Valley, California, a purgatorial version of its former self, with the old labouring under hormonal treatment that has fuddled their brains while rejuvenating their bodies and the young equipped with weapons of world-destruction, Marty McFly returns to discover the mid-Eighties in even worse disarray. 
 Blacks (perish the thought) now inhabit his old house and pitched battles between gangs and police make the streets untenable. 
 But the trouble with the picture is that it does absolutely nothing with its various prognostications except play the fool with them. 
 Joe Comerford's Reefer And The Model (Metro, 15) won the feature film prize at the Celtic Festival, the Europa Prize at Barcelona, and was nominated in three catagories in last year's European Film Awards. 
 Yet its original presentation at the Berlin Festival was by no means an unalloyed success. 
 There, the audience was very much divided as to its merits and there isn't much doubt that Comerford, certainly one of Ireland's most distinctive and challenging film-makers, will probably always get that reaction. 
 He is not into the business of making orthodox movies. 
 Reefer (Ian McElhinney), a disillusioned ex-IRA man, commands an old trawler running cargo that is just inside the law, and the Model (Carol Scanlan) is the homeless and pregnant woman whom he befriends and falls for. 
 Also on board are another ex-gunman and an army deserter and, when the trawler breaks down, a plan is forged to rob a bank. 
 At first it is difficult to know exactly where the film is going, either as a thriller or a romance. 
 Comedy obtrudes too to obfuscate matters still further. 
 Gradually, however, Comerford's designs upon his audience seem clearer. 
 He is after nothing less than a full-blown and not always approving commentary on Irish attitudes. 
 This is what so fascinated the European Film Award Jury (which included myself) &mdash; that conventional thinking about the Provos, the Ascendancy, religion, prostitution and homosexuality were so confidently challenged within the film's quite conventional framework. 
 Added to that, the imagination of the film-making was generally admired. 
 For instance, the whole episode of the homosexual's gingerly desperate &bquo;coming out&equo; in a hostile society is achieved in a genuinely moving manner, so that one can easily forgive the hesitancies and lack of narrative drive that is sometimes apparent elsewhere. 
 Reefer And The Model has its flaws, but it is trying for something extra. 
 And I would always prefer that to the smooth and empty professionalism one so often encounters these days. 
 This is also true of the Canadian A Winter Tan (ICA Cinema, 18), a cooperative effort by five film-makers that is even more challenging to received assumptions and inhabits an even more dangerous area &mdash; that of female sexuality. 
 Taken from the letters of Maryse Holder, posthumously published as Give Sorrow Words, the film graphically and with total honesty describes the writer's descent into a hell of her own making on a &bquo;Mexican vacation from feminism&equo; in search of happiness. 
 The film, set on the beaches, in the bars and discos and in the shabby tourist rooms of downtown Acapulco, is distinguished by a central performance from Jackie Burroughs (also one of the directors) that is an astonishing tour de force of which it is impossible to speak too highly. 
 That it is sustained almost to the point of embarrassment is exactly what is so good about it, since discomfort is the name of this film's particular game. 
 She and the film show us in corruscating detail the real difficulties of the character's position, and asks us not for approval but for understanding and perhaps the grace of mercy. 
 The fact that I've seen no film for some time that is more sexually honest is actually beside the point. 
 What isn't is A Winter Tan's capacity to move us in another way, in particular with a riveting and lacerating piece of acting that underlines and illustrates its argument. 
 You will not see a better performance than this all year. 
 A Private Life (Cannon, Tottenham Court Road, 15) is a British film made in South Africa and welcomed, just in case you wondered, by the ANC. 
 It is very simply made and no great shakes as a piece of cinema. 
 But it tells you more about the personal horrors of living under apartheid than many a flashier epic. 
 This is a true story of one of the many tragedies of apartheid &mdash; a white South African policeman falls in love with a woman of mixed race, resigns from his job and goes to live with her in Cape Town. 
 The woman, who has three children by him, is desperate to have her official designation changed from &bquo;coloured&equo; to white, so they can marry and become &bquo;respectable&equo;, and her struggle to live normally becomes impossible when the examining board refuses her request. 
 Her oldest son then gets a white girl pregnant, and the baby has to be aborted, as Government rules allow under these circumstances. 
 The acting in Francis Gerard's film is totally convincing (Bill Flynn and Jana Cilliers are the parents who, incidentally, were finally able to marry, but only after the suicide of their son) and, though it scarcely ever raises its voice, A Private Life shouts to the rooftops about the injustices it portrays. 
 For sheer daftness there's no beating the British Tank Malling (Cannons, Panton Street and Oxford Street, 18) which postulates a ludicrously megalomaniac semi-Fascist politico (Peter Wyngarde), backed by criminals, the police, bishops and the judiciary in his attempt to bring moral regeneration to the country, while at the same time feeding the dirty sexual desires of the great and the good who back him. 
 All that stands in his way is Mr Malling (Ray Winstone), an investigative journalist just out of jail and into booze. 
 But good bloodily triumphs at the end of a film made by James Marcus rather like a Warner Brothers gangster picture set incongruously in Soho and gone rather badly off-key. 
 Through it all strolls the one and only John Conteh, as a strong-arm man rendered practically speechless by the goings-on around him. 
 Which was lucky for him really, considering the script. 
 Jana Cilliers as Stella in A Private Life OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Obituary: Edward Bawden: A sardonic eye for detail from Essex to the desert. 
 EDWARD Bawden, one of the most prolific and perfectionist graphic artists of the century, has died aged 86. 
 He was very much an artist of East Anglia. 
 He was born and died in Essex and scarcely ever left the region, apart from his notably productive years of eastern travel as a war artist. 
 He was in a special sense a village painter, endlessly inspired by the quiet landscape and tenor of life in what he once described as &bquo;the very backbone of Puritan England.&equo; 
 His own chapel-going background gave him a feel for that. 
 He was one of the shyest people in the world. 
 Too shy to board a bus: as a solitary student in London, he walked miles around the streets, sharpening his observation. 
 Bawden's view of the passing scene is an outsider's: not exactly cruel but certainly sardonic. 
 Those highly populated, finely detailed human landscapes &mdash; Bawden's pullulating market places, pubs and railway stations &mdash; become more disquieting the closer one gets to them. 
 On the beach at Clacton the sunbathers wear blankets. 
 Early on, Bawden had been an admirer of Beardsley and something of Beardsley's precocity stayed with him: the finesse of the line drawing, the love of the macabre. 
 &bquo;Wonderful boy, Beardsley,&equo; he once said in an interview. 
 &bquo;No one has produced such pornography. 
 And pornography, to be good, has to be elegant.&equo; 
 Another influence was The Girls' Own Paper, which he liked much better than the Boys' Own version. 
 He loved the oddly ordinary: stories, buildings, decoration. 
 He saw the intense charm of bourgeois Victorian decor many years before the onset of Betjemania, and was an early collector of such objects of mild fantasy as waxen fruits in tall glass domes and crenellated jelly moulds. 
 He was at the Royal College of Art in the mid-1920s &mdash; a bumper year which included Moore and Hepworth. 
 He made immediate friends with Eric Ravilious, whose interests curiously paralleled Bawden's. 
 Since then their names have been inextricably linked (somewhat to Bawden's detriment). 
 Trained initially as a designer-letterer, he quickly found calligraphy too monkish. 
 He saw himself more in the Arts and Crafts tradition of the designer who can turn his hand to anything. 
 He wanted to be &bquo;an important chap like Morris,&equo; always his great hero. 
 Should one see him as the last of the Pre-Raphaelites? 
 He even looked Victorian, with his high domed forehead and his quizzical regard. 
 Certainly, Bawden's work ethic was Victorian. 
 His laconic manner concealed an immense energy in the mastery of techniques. 
 His first important commission, the mural for Morley College, meant starting from scratch, travelling to Italy to learn about the fresco. 
 So he went on, from one technique to another: watercolour drawings, line engravings, lithography, line cuts, designs for pottery. 
 For my twentieth century British Design retrospective exhibition, he lent me, with a good deal of fussing and commotion, his last remaining &bquo;Heartsease&equo; cup and saucer, a Wedgwood design of the early 1950s. 
 It stood out like a beacon in that rather murky period. 
 Whatever he concentrated on he did convincingly. 
 I find in my files Bawden's own account, written out in his finicky copperplate hand, of his own quasi-William Morris enterprise as a designer-manufacturer of wallpapers in the late 1930s: &bquo;The desire to do wallpaper designs arose from seeing a furnished room hung with William Morris's &bquo;Daisy&equo; at the Wembley International Exhibition. 
 &bquo;John Aldridge and I, who live in the same village, decided that we would try to print our own designs by the roll from our own blocks. 
 A few lengths were produced and these amateurish efforts were seen by a director of Coles who was passing through Braintree and happened to look in at an art exhibition in the Institute. 
 From then onwards we cut full-size wallpaper blocks faced with lino and passed on the blocks to Coles who printed and sold the designs.&equo; 
 Bawden loved his own work and found it soothing to live surrounded by it. 
 Those wallpapers, the &bquo;Bardfield Papers&equo;, were central to the mise-en-scene at Brick House in Great Bardfield, the gentle red-brick building Bawden and Ravilious discovered on their travels by bicycle round Essex. 
 Bawden lived in that house for 30 years, and no one who went there could forget its atmosphere, partly created by its English artists' eccentricity of decor. 
 The overflow of objects, at first sight rather ramshackle, came to look more poetical in its organisation. 
 In style Brick House almost resembled Charleston, but more cottagey, with Staffordshire ornaments on the chimney piece. 
 Brick House oddities and beauties were emphasised by the extraordinary contrast between tall, gaunt, silent Edward, in his menacing deep blue denim boiler suit, and his comfortable, comforting wife Charlotte. 
 I see her in my mind's eye always in a Fair Isle jersey. 
 Charlotte Epton, &bquo;laughing Charlotte&equo; in the memoirs of that circle, was a painter and a potter who had worked with Bernard Leach. 
 As a couple, they had the Jack Sprat symmetry of the man who eats no fat and the wife who eats no lean. 
 For a man so rooted in his domesticity the nomadic life of the Official War Artist was a gamble. 
 But some of his finest work was done in wartime, in the Western Desert and later in Saudi Arabia. 
 Even the small selection in The Penguin Modern Painters shows how much the role suited him, with his objectivity of vision and his sheer efficiency of technique. 
 He enjoyed the play-acting, too. 
 Jim Richards describes spotting him on the terrace of Shepheard's Hotel, Cairo. 
 He was wearing his captain's uniform with meticulous correctness but with a consciously satirical air, &bquo;as though he thought of it as fancy dress.&equo; 
 In the end, what does one remember Bawden best for? 
 Those enchanting illustrations for Ambrose Heath's Good Food books? 
 The Queen's Beasts? 
 The linocuts of Brighton, the town which appealed most to his strong sense of the fantastical? 
 The great heraldic mural for the Brussels Exhibition (now at the Royal College of Art in London)? 
 His pictures for Henneoo's grown-up children's story, the beauteous and curious Lady Filmy-Fern? 
 Impossible to choose. 
 He was terrified of boredom, and like other artists of great versatility (like Eric Gill for instance) he is difficult to pin down. 
 Like Gill he had his philosophic doubts about Art-nonsense. 
 But no one ever doubted that Bawden was an artist of a particular, peculiar directness. 
 As Eric Newton, later the Guardian's art critic, wrote about his paintings in 1938: &bquo;They are dry and worried and patchy. 
 But they are immensely serious. 
 &bquo;They break the rules because Bawden cares less for rules than for the things he has to say about the feel of a summer morning, the watery sunshine of an April afternoon, or the flurry of a February snowstorm.&equo; 
 Fiona MacCarthy Edward Bawden, born March 10, 1903; died November 21, 1989. 
 The recent Bawden exhibition at the Victoria and Albert Museum is over now, but another, drawn from the artist's permanent collection at the Cecil Higgins Museum in Bedford, is at the Holburne Museum, Bath (till December 10). 
 A large exhibition of paintings by Jackson Pollock (1912-1956) and Lee Krasner (1908-1984) has opened in Bern. 
 John Berger believes it raises more questions than meet the eye Photograph of Pollock in his studio by Hans Namuth The suicide of art Pollock and Lee Krasner: when they first met she was 34 and better known as an artist than he was. 
 &bquo;I had a comet by the tail,&equo; she said PHOTOGRAPH AT NORTH TRURO, MASSACHUSETTS BY BERNARD AND NINA SCHARDT suicide of art. 
 THE SUICIDE of an art is a strange idea. 
 Yet I am bound to start with it, if I'm to talk about the story of Jackson Pollock and his wife, the painter Lee Krasner. 
 Krasner outlived her husband by nearly 30 years and went on working as a considerable painter in her own right until 1984. 
 Now, however, I want to concentrate on the 15 years during which the two of them lived and worked together, and Pollock made a bid to change the course of what was then thought of as modern art. 
 Pollock died 34 years ago in a car accident near his house in Springs on Long Island in New York. 
 This wasn't the suicide. 
 He was 44 years old and he had already been acclaimed the First Great American painter. 
 The tragedy of his death, even if foreseeable, obscured for most the suicide of the art. 
 Born in 1912, Pollock was the youngest of five children of a poorish Irish/Scots Presbyterian family, living mostly in Arizona. 
 He revealed a clumsy but passionate talent early on. 
 Talent doesn't necessarily mean facility. 
 It's a kind of motor-activity within a temperament &mdash; a form of energy. 
 Pollock's talent was immediately recognised by his teacher, Thomas Hart Benton, the Country Folk painter. 
 Pollock was slim, handsome, aggressive, brooding: deeply ambitious to prove he was not a failure and perhaps to earn, at last, his stern mother's approval. 
 In everything he did there was a touch of charisma, and, following everything he did, a nagging doubt. 
 He was more or less an alcoholic before he was 20. 
 As a teenager he dropped his first name, Paul, and used only his second name, Jackson. 
 The change says a lot about the persona he was already being driven into. 
 Jackson Pollock was a name for fighting in the ring. 
 A champ's name. 
 His later fame as a painter produced the legend that at heart Pollock was a cowboy. 
 Compared to his first collector, Peggy Guggenheim, or to his first apologist, Clement Greenberg, or to the art critic, Harold Rosenberg who invented the term Action Painter for him, he was indeed a goy and a redneck. 
 He hated verbal theories, he didn't read much, he'd never travelled outside the states, he punched people up, and when he was drunk at parties he pissed into the fireplace. 
 But whatever miracles cowboys may achieve with lassoes, no cowboy could dream of controlling paint as Pollock did. 
 This needs repeating several times because with his notorious drip paintings he came to be thought of by some as a dripster, a drooler, a mere pourer. 
 Nothing could be further from the truth. 
 The suicide was committed with mastery, and the desperation was very precise. 
 Pollock found himself as a painter during the 1940s. 
 At that time most avante-garde painters in the US were interested in Picasso, surrealism, the Jungian unconscious, the inner self, abstraction. 
 Direct painted references to the objective visible world were usually dismissed as &bquo;illustrative&equo;. 
 The trip was inwards, an uneasy quest for the soul. 
 In 1943 the well-known painter, Hans Hofmann, asked the young Pollock how important nature was for his art. 
 &bquo;I am nature,&equo; replied Pollock. 
 The older painter was shocked by the arrogance of the reply and Pollock, sensing this, rubbed salt into the wound by adding: &bquo;Your theories don't interest me! 
 Put up or shut up! 
 Let's see your work!&equo; 
 The reply may or may not have been arrogant, but, more significantly, it carried within itself the fatality to come. 
 Six years later Harold Rosenberg, thinking of Pollock and praising him, wrote: &bquo;The modern painter begins with nothingness. 
 That is the only thing he copies. 
 The rest he invents.&equo; 
 AT THIS moment what was happening in the outside world, for a cultural climate is never separate from events? 
 The US had emerged from the war as the most powerful nation in the world. 
 The first atom bomb had been dropped. 
 The apocalypse of the Cold War had been placed on the agenda. 
 McCarthy was inventing his traitors. 
 The mood in the country that had suffered least from the war, was defiant, violent, haunted. 
 The play most apt to the period would have been Macbeth, and the ghosts were from Hiroshima. 
 The word Freedom was being bandied about a lot at the time and meant many different things. 
 It's worth considering three different kinds of freedom, for, put together, they may conjure up something of the stridency of the period. 
 Time was short in the US. 
 There was very little patience. 
 The stakes were down. 
 There was an inarticulate sense of loss, often expressed with anger or violence. 
 Vietnam was one of the historical tragedies which would eventually follow from this insecurity. 
 Freedom of the market. 
 The New York artists were working, more crudely than ever before, for an expanding free market. 
 They painted exactly what they wanted, the size they wanted, with the materials they wanted. 
 Their finished works, scarcely dry, were then put up for sale, promoted, sometimes bought. 
 Bought by collectors &mdash; and for the first time whilst, as it were, still wet &mdash; by museums. 
 The competition, however, was ruthless and aggressive. 
 The latest was always at a premium. 
 Gallery fashions changed quickly. 
 Recognition (being featured in Life magazine) was dramatic but short-lived. 
 The risks were high and the casualties many. 
 Gorky and Rothko killed themselves. 
 Kline, Reinhardt, Newman died young. 
 Nearly all the painters drank heavily to protect their nerves, for finally, their works, transformed into extraordinary property investments, benefited from far more security measures than their working lives. 
 They lived on success and despair. 
 Next, the freedom the artists were seeking within themselves. 
 As a mixed show catalogue statement put it: &bquo;The past decade in America has been a period of great creative activity in painting. 
 Only now has there been a concerted effort to abandon the tyranny of the object and the sickness of naturalism to enter within consciousness.&equo; 
 Entering into consciousness &mdash; an obscure phrase &mdash; meant trying to be oneself on the canvas, without the props of a single familiar reference, and thus to be free of rhetoric, history, convention, other people, safety, the past. 
 Perhaps in a foul world these men were seeking purity. 
 Then there was the freedom of the Voice of America, the freedom of the Free World. 
 By 1948 the US needed an international cultural prestige to offset its military and political power: it needed a sophisticated reply to the slogans of Yankee Go Home! 
 This is why the CIA during the 50s and 60s covertly supported a multitude of initiatives whose aim was to present the new American Art across the world as a promise for the future. 
 Since the works (de Kooning apart) were abstract they lent themselves to diverse interpretations. 
 In this way a mostly desperate body of art, which had at first shocked the American public, was transformed by speeches, articles and the context in which it was displayed, into an ideological weapon for the defence of Individualism and the right to express oneself. 
 Pollock, I'm sure, was unaware of this programme &mdash; he died too soon; nevertheless the propaganda apparatus helped to create the confusion surrounding his art after his death. 
 A cry of despair was turned into a Declaration for Democracy. 
 IN 1950 Hans Namuth made a film of Pollock painting. 
 Pollock puts on his paint-spattered boots &mdash; that appear as a kind of homage to Van Gogh &mdash; and then he starts to walk around the umprimed canvas laid out on the earth. 
 With a stick he flicks paint on to it from a can. 
 Threads of paint. 
 Different colours. 
 Making a net. 
 Making knots. 
 His gestures are slow but follow one another swiftly. 
 Next he uses the same technique but this time on to a sheet of transparent glass placed on trestles, which allows the photographer to film the act through the glass, so that we see the paint falling around the pebbles and wires already placed on the glass. 
 We look towards the painter from the painting's point of view. 
 We look out from behind to the front where everything is happening. 
 The way he moves his arms and shoulders suggests something between a marksman and a beekeeper putting a swarm into a hive. 
 It is a star performance. 
 It was probably this film which prompted the phrase Action Painting. 
 The canvas, according to this definition, becomes an arena for the artist's free actions, which the spectator relives through the traces they leave. 
 Art is no longer mediation but act. 
 No longer pursuit but arrival. 
 What we are slowly making our way towards are the pictorial consequences of Rosenberg's nothingness and the fatality. 
 PHOTOS of Lee Krasner and Jackson Pollock taken together somehow indicate how much theirs was a marriage of two painters. 
 It's on their clothes. 
 You can smell the paint. 
 Lee Krasner's first love was a Russian painter called Igor Pantuhoff. 
 She lived with him for 11 years. 
 When she first met Pollock she was 34 and better known as an artist than he was. 
 &bquo;I had a comet by the tail,&equo; she said afterwards. 
 What called out to her was surely what she felt to be Pollock's destiny as an artist. 
 He was inspired, probably more inspired than anybody she had ever met. 
 And for Jackson Pollock the champion, always fearful of losing, Lee was at last the judge he could trust. 
 If she told him that something he had painted worked, he believed it &mdash; at least at the beginning of their marriage. 
 Between them the ultimate in praise was: &bquo;It works.&equo; 
 A phrase between professionals. 
 From 1943 till 1952 &mdash; the period when Pollock produced all his most surprising work &mdash; the two of them were, in part, painting for each other: to see each other's surprise. 
 It was a way of communicating, of touching or being touched. 
 (Maybe there were not many ways of communicating with Pollock.) 
 During these years, Lee Krasner painted less than she did before or afterwards. 
 Pollock took the studio on the property they bought in Springs, and she worked in a bedroom. 
 Yet the argument that she sacrificed her art for his is as stupid as the argument about who influenced whom. 
 (In 1953 Pollock produced a canvas called Easter And The Totem which anybody might mistake for a Krasner.) 
 The truth is that as painters and as a man and a woman, they were engaged, during these years, in the same adventure which turned out to be more fatal than either of them realised at the time. 
 And today their canvases talk of it. 
 Lee Krasner's paintings were, by nature, sensuous and ordered. 
 Their colours and gestures frequently suggested flesh, the body: their order a garden. 
 Abstract as they are, one enters them to find, behind the colours or collage, a kind of welcome. 
 By contrast, Pollock's paintings were metaphysical in aim and violent. 
 The body, the flesh, had been rejected and they were the consequence of this rejection. 
 One can feel the painter, at first with gestures that are almost childish, and later like a strong, fully grown man, emptying his body of energy and liquids so as to leave traces to prove that he had physically existed. 
 On one occasion he put his handprints on the painting as if beseeching the canvas to acknowledge the exiled body. 
 There is an order in these works, but it is like that at the centre of an explosion, and all over their surfaces there is a terrible indifference to everything that is sentient. 
 When their paintings are hung together the dialogue between them is very clear. 
 He paints an explosion: she, using almost identical pictorial elements, constructs a kind of consolation. 
 (Perhaps their paintings said things to one another during these years that they could never say in person.) 
 Yet it would be wrong to give the impression that Krasner's paintings were primarily consolatory. 
 Between the two of them there was a fundamental issue at stake. 
 Time and again her paintings demonstrated an alternative to the brink which they sensed his were heading for. 
 Time and again her paintings protested against the art's threat of suicide. 
 And I think they did this as paintings whilst Lee Krasner as a person was being dazzled by the brilliance of his recklessness. 
 An obvious example would be a painting called Bald Eagle, made in 1955, one year before the car accident. 
 Here Lee Krasner took a canvas Jackson Pollock had abandoned &mdash; a bare hessian canvas with flicked black lines across it &mdash; and incorporated pieces of this canvas into a large colourful collage, a little suggestive of autumn and a bird soaring. 
 Thus her picture saved the lost gestures of his. 
 The example, however, is not typical, for it occurred after the suicide. 
 Before, he would splatter, and she would take the same pigment, the same colours, and assemble. 
 He would thrash; and she would make the same wound and stitch it. 
 He would paint flames; and she would paint fire in a brazier. 
 He would throw paint imitating a comet; and she would paint a part of the milky way. 
 Every time the pictorial elements &mdash; as distinct from the purpose &mdash; were similar, if not almost identical. 
 He would lend himself to a deluge; she would imagine water gushing into a basin. 
 But the messages of her paintings to his paintings were not about domestication. 
 They were about continuity, they were about the desire of Painting to go on living. 
 Unfortunately it was already too late. 
 POLLOCK had stood the art of painting on its head, reversed it, negated it. 
 The negation had nothing to do with technique or abstraction. 
 It was inherent in his purpose &mdash; in the will which his canvases expressed. 
 On these canvases the visible is no longer an opening but something which has been abandoned and left behind. 
 The drama depicted is something that once happened in front of the canvas &mdash; where the painter claimed to be nature! 
 Within or beyond them there is nothing. 
 Only the visual equivalent of total silence. 
 Painting throughout its history has served many different purposes, has been flat and has used perspective, has been framed and has been left borderless, has been explicit and has been mysterious. 
 But one act of faith has remained a constant from palaeolithic times to cubism, from Tintoretto (who also loved comets) to Rothko. 
 The act of faith consisted of believing that the visible contained hidden secrets, that to study the visible was to learn something more than could be seen in a glance. 
 Thus paintings were there to reveal a presence behind an appearance &mdash; be it that of a madonna, a tree or, simply, the light that soaks through a red. 
 Jackson Pollock was driven by a despair which was partly his and partly that of the culture which nourished him, to refuse this act of faith: to insist, with all his brilliance as a painter, that there was nothing behind, that there was only that which was done to the canvas on the side facing us. 
 This simple terrible reversal was the suicide. 
 The Jackson Pollock/Lee Krasner exhibition continues at the Kunstmuseum, Bern, until February 4, 1990. 
 COMMENT THE GUARDIAN Thursday November 23 1989 A great bet in a big bucket. 
 YESTERDAY's water privatisation is the taxpayer's bequest to the share punter. 
 And generous to a fault. 
 The Government is offering shares to investors at 240p each, which values the industry at &pound;5.24 billion. 
 But since it has already written off &pound;5 billion worth of debts and thrown in an extra &pound;1.6 billion &bquo;green dowry&equo;, that means that the entire industry &mdash; with thousands of miles of pipework, reservoirs, leisure land, sewage works and so forth &mdash; is being given away for minus &pound;1.4 billion. 
 The shares are extremely good value for investors, short of a stock market apocalypse. 
 They offer (for a safe monopoly) a very attractive average yield of 8.5 per cent, with scope for capital appreciation and perks (one free share for 10) for those investing in their local company. 
 Since only a part of the purchase price has to be put down now, this represents a likely return on capital of over 20 per cent in the first year. 
 This is not the proverbial free lunch. 
 It is a massive redistribution of wealth from one owner (the Government, on behalf of everyone in the country) to a much narrower segment of the population (the 4 to 5 million likely to take up the offer) who will be able to buy the assets at a discount. 
 The losers are those who, for reasons of poverty or principle, decline to partake. 
 In financial terms the sale will be justified if private sector ownership improves efficiency by more than the huge point-of-sale loss to the Government plus the &pound;175 million or so privatisation costs. 
 That will be an uphill battle, and difficult to prove anyway, because the industry under private ownership needs to earn a higher return on capital &mdash; by several percentage points &mdash; than in public ownership to attract shareholders. 
 So it has to improve its efficiency by a considerable amount just to stand still. 
 And in any case the main gains to efficiency will come not from privatisation, but from the legal necessity imposed by the EC (which would have happened anyway) to invest &pound;25 billion over 10 years to bring water up to drinkable standards. 
 Anyone who can separate the gains from the &bquo;dynamics&equo; of privatisation from those arising from capital investment or the companies' success in manipulating the pricing formula will deserve free water for life. 
 However, whether necessary or not, privatisation must be made to work. 
 Water is a precious commodity too long taken for granted in the West. 
 All the fresh water in the world's lakes and streams represents barely 0.01 per cent of the earth's total store of water, which is mainly saline. 
 It is a shrinking resource badly distributed around the earth's crust, as yesterday's warning of a continuing severe shortage in the south of England reminds us. 
 As well as generators of rising dividends, the new water companies are custodians of one of the most vital resources on earth. 
 They must never be allowed to forget that.. 
 Prague promises. 
 THERE WILL be no massacre; there will be no martial law. 
 Yesterday the Czech demonstrators were anxiously weighing Tuesday's assurance from Prime Minister Vladislav Adamec against the indications of an unresolved struggle within the leadership. 
 The Beijing massacre, after all, was preceded by just such a struggle. 
 For entirely practical reasons, Mr Adamec's view ought to prevail. 
 Most of the Czech Politburo consists of people who were &bquo;voted in by tanks&equo; in 1968. 
 A few days ago they were handed the Moscow black spot in the form of an invitation to reconsider history. 
 An island of Czech reaction cannot survive among its metamorphosed neighbours for more than a geopolitical instant. 
 The struggle has been between the Czech people and the security apparatus behind the Communist party. 
 If the army could not do the job unaided twenty years ago, it is even less likely to get involved now. 
 The Brezhnev Doctrine is dead: long live the Gorbachev Doctrine of the Soviet Union as just another European power, only bigger, which lets its neighbours go their own way. 
 It is all happening too fast for us to take anything quite for granted, neither becoming blase about the sight of ossified regimes crumbling at the knees, nor entirely ruling out the thought of some treacherous counter-current. 
 But we are very close now to the critical turning-point after which the political scene in Prague could be as rapidly transformed as among its neighbours. 
 If the leading dissident Mr Vaclev Havel is right, the current power struggle is not whether to resist change but who should succeed Mr Milos Jakes. 
 And with the force of example elsewhere, can the party will maintain its primacy for long? 
 The lingering conventional truths &mdash; that the Czech economy would be strong enough to cushion dissent, that the opposition does not have a sufficiently coherent voice &mdash; already look thin. 
 Mr Havel's Civic Forum may be some way behind East Germany's New Forum, but it can draw upon a reservoir of informally networked dissent which dates back more than a decade. 
 And if the miners of northern Bavaria do respond to the strike call for next Monday, the regime's social contract with them will be shattered. 
 As the tide sweeps on, the sight of President Ceausescu being applauded 67 times at his party congress &mdash; while Mrs Ceausescu sat in grim solitude &mdash; only highlights the increasingly anachronistic character of this European North Korea. 
 In Bucharest as in Pyongyang, it may well be that severe repression can in the first instance only be challenged by a well-aimed bullet. 
 But once the West no longer needed Mr Ceausescu's anti-Soviet services, his policy of deliberate isolation narrowed his options and led earlier this year to the first signs of internal party dissent. 
 Retracing the route from Berlin to Beijing &mdash; for let us not forget where people's power first flourished this year - we find a even more isolated regime with yet fewer options. 
 How long can it remain immune as the voices echo back from Eastern Europe?. 
 One loan clause. 
 MR CEAUCESCU, meanwhile, may have changed address. 
 He seems to be living in the Department of Education. 
 Yesterday the Department issued its student loans bill. 
 And how long was this measure, designed to embrace the principles of 48 pages of white paper and some 68 pages of analysis in two specially-commissioned Price Waterhouse reports? 
 Just four clauses. 
 Even that is a fourfold exaggeration of length. 
 There is only a solitary enabling clause. 
 As Jack Straw, the Labour Education spokesman, noted yesterday, this would be a constitutional outrage even in Romania. 
 How on earth does Parliament scrutinise an Act with only one clause? 
 No way. 
 What is the Government up to? 
 Alas, it is flying by the seat of its pants. 
 This student loans scheme has degenerated into open shambles. 
 That it would be unpopular with students or colleges was obvious. 
 But HMG totally underestimated the coolness of the banks. 
 From the beginning, they have been collectively unconvinced of the commercial value of the plan. 
 Three have already refused to take part. 
 With students threatening to run a Barclays-style boycott against any that participate, stand by for more to pull out. 
 Students are regarded by the banks as the ripest harvest of all: the people who will be earning the highest balances in the future and who are likely to stay loyal for life once signed up. 
 Why start on the wrong foot as collaborators in unpopular and spatchcock loans? 
 The best thing that could happen now would be for the scheme to be killed by another backbench Tory revolt, like the rebellion which quashed Sir Keith Joseph's 1985 effort to make student fees income-related. 
 There is the same motivation. 
 The new scheme will certainly hurt middle-income parents, with the present level of grant frozen until loans (or a combination of loans and parental contributions) make up 50 per cent of student finance. 
 But it will cause even more damage to low income parents, the very homes from which ministers had hoped to attract more students to achieve their target of doubling the proportion of children going to college by 2014. 
 This is simply perverse. 
 Only eight per cent of children from low income families (in the Registrar General's social classes four and five) go to university, even though they are guaranteed a free education through a full grant plus social security. 
 Now they are to lose their income support and housing benefit and allowed to borrow &pound;420 a year at inflation-rate interest. 
 Some incentive. 
 It can only reduce student numbers and make our education system more unequal. 
 It should shrivel in ineptitude.. 
 Prime target. 
 ONE Stalkinghorse cantered to the starting gate yesterday; though, in the most congenial of mixed metaphors, Sir Anthony Meyer prefers to call himself a &bquo;burnt offering.&equo; 
 He'll stand against Mrs Thatcher for the Tory leadership next month unless somebody else (Stalkinghorse 2; a medium rare slice of rump) slips out of the deep freeze paddock. 
 And that should now happen. 
 Sir Anthony is a disenchanted maverick of a wet and is not best placed to present a fair test of backbench opinion. 
 No chance of a Stalkinghorse winning, but a nag from the heart of the party, who manifests &mdash; in votes and abstentions &mdash; the coronary palpitations of the 1922 Committee, is called for. 
 The unease is not secret. 
 The issues are mostly in the open. 
 The fears of a dominant personality, away from the core of traditional values, driving the enterprise on to the electoral rocks, are manifest in speeches and in countless polls of public opinion. 
 And there is an obvious point of principle. 
 The Conservative Party has a fixed framework for the election of leaders. 
 The Party, and its current Leader, firmly believe in such elections. 
 (If they didn't, Mr Edward Heath would be a much happier man.) 
 Further, the Leader herself has spent many toiling hours of late calling on the peoples of Eastern Europe to hold elections and thereby demonstrate their attachment to the fundamentals of democracy. 
 What is sauce for Egon Krenz is just as much sauce for Mrs Margaret Thatcher. 
 Of course, a vote is all very tedious, and will be ritually accompanied by the most ferocious pressures upon this beleaguered electoral college. 
 Conservative MPs who know what a party election is like do not relish the sheer nastiness that accompanies it. 
 But the fury and the knife-work should be constrained. 
 Sir Anthony, boldly, with little to lose, is willing to provide a focal point for discussion and decision on absolutely legitimate matters of political concern. 
 He modestly and realistically hopes a better candidate can be found. 
 But he thinks, in present circumstances, that a straightforward test provides the best way of clearing the air. 
 That is the democratic way; and an embarrassed Conservative hierarchy should never forget it. 
 A bloc the West can do business with Eastern Europe has been something of a wasteland for EC investment but as Julian Bullard reports, all that is changing. 
 WHO would have thought that Eastern Europe could ever become so fashionable? 
 Since the war, or at least since the post-war pattern settled into what looked like immobility round about 1950, this had been a stony field to work in. 
 There seemed to be so little mutual interest, so little to build on. 
 The still small voice of the Great Britain-East Europe Centre at 31 Knightsbridge was a minority taste, like 14th century motets. 
 For the British at large, Czechoslovakia, compared with some of the others, was a not too far-off country of which we did know something: that distinctive spelling, those operas. 
 It was much the same story at the Foreign Office. 
 &bquo;Remind me why I am going,&equo; the minister would say on the outward aeroplane, and sometimes &bquo;Remind me why I went&equo; on the way back. 
 It took application and imagination to see the point of Eastern Europe, to see through the glacier to the contours underneath. 
 What with one thing and another, it was left to Sir Geoffrey Howe to become the first British Foreign Secretary to visit all the countries of Eastern Europe. 
 One of the problems was a certain sense of doubt about British and indeed Western objectives. 
 The watchword was always &bquo;differentiation&equo; which was plain enough up to a point: policy would not be made en bloc, but country by country, depending. 
 But depending on what? 
 At one time the answer was &bquo;independence of Moscow&equo;. 
 Those were the years when Romania carried off the prizes. 
 And earned them too: look at the Romanian record during the sixties and seventies, from the Sino-Soviet split through the invasion of Czechoslovakia to the Helsinki Conference. 
 The prize pupil, however, turned out to have another side to his character, and others took his place on the platform on prize day. 
 The test by this time was no longer &bquo;independence of Moscow&equo; but &bquo;Human Rights&equo;. 
 Ironically enough it was Helsinki which introduced the change. 
 After contributing so much to the proceedings in the Finnish capital, and to the 30,000 words of the final act, Romania became one of its victims. 
 For in one follow-up meeting after another, in Belgrade and Madrid and finally Vienna, the human rights standards laid down at Helsinki were refined and tightened, while Romanian internal policies either stood still or moved in the other direction, that is to say downhill. 
 This year, by refusing to negotiate with Bucharest on a new agreement, the European Community has shown that &bquo;differentiation&equo; can be applied negatively, too. 
 Does it count for nothing that Romania, according to her own claims, has repaid her entire hard currency debt and made future borrowing from the West illegal? 
 Evidently not. 
 Just at the moment, indeed, the chief beneficiaries of the EC's bounty are the two largest borrowers in Eastern Europe, Poland and Hungary, with gross debts of &dollar;41 billion and &dollar;17 billion and populations of 37 million and 10.5 million respectively. 
 It seems that &bquo;differentiation&equo; is being redefined once again, so as to include democratic institutions and a market economy. 
 There is talk of a billion dollar stabilisation fund for Poland and a large bridging loan for Hungary, to be organised jointly by Western banks, the EC and the IMF, together with aid of other kinds &mdash; all this on top of the billion dollar package inaugurated at the economic summit in Paris in July. 
 East Berlin, Sofia and Prague will draw their conclusions. 
 Obviously it is right for the West to be supporting any movement towards democracy in Eastern Europe, and obviously the EC should play its part. 
 Whether any amount of Western help can rescue the economies of Eastern Europe, much less the Soviet Union, is another question. 
 Their faults seem so deeply ingrained, from quantitative measures and bogus statistics to valueless currencies and not caring about the environment. 
 Even East Germany is believed to be two if not three electronic generations behind the Far East. 
 As to foreign trade in Eastern Europe, two thirds of it is within the Comecon area, and the absolute levels are low. 
 The whole of East-West trade is at present only a small piece of a small slice of a rather small cake. 
 Yet this is the sector which is supposed to invigorate the rest. 
 Will joint ventures succeed where counter-purchase and &bquo;economic co-operation&equo; failed? 
 Past experience is not encouraging. 
 What else ought the Community to do? 
 Aristotle wrote that the function of anything is what it alone can do or does best. 
 On this definition, the task of the EC is to continue to serve as the chief engine of economic growth in Europe, an engine characterised by high performance, high output, high quality and (agriculture excepted) low running costs. 
 If in the year 2000 the EC is able to pass these tests as well as it does today, but on the altogether higher plane which 1992 implies, the rest of Europe, like the rest of the world, will have cause to be grateful. 
 Meanwhile, as to Eastern Europe, there is one more sense in which &bquo;differentiation&equo; is relevant. 
 There was seldom if ever a time when all Western governments, or even all those within the EC, were equally active in relations with the East. 
 A kind of auto-differentiation was the normal pattern. 
 For some years after her exit from the integrated military structure of Nato, France was the pioneer in East-West relations. 
 The United States would dive in from time to time with a huge splash which, however, would soon subside. 
 Britain's innings began in 1984, when Gorbachev made his name as a man the West could do business with. 
 Now it looks as if nothing could stop West Germany taking the lead with her unbeatable combination of credentials: guilt, enthusiasm, material interest and money. 
 But there is no reason for Britain to differentiate herself into the sidelines. 
 Sir Julian Bullard was British ambassador in Bonn, 1984-88. 
 Results. 
 THE LATEST financial results from US computer companies are awash in red ink, due to a slowdown in US sales, restructuring and, in some cases, the devaluation of stock as component prices fell. 
 An Atari spokesman summed it up thus: &bquo;We did our best to take our lumps as we saw them.&equo; 
 Everyone expects better results in the next quarter. 
 Hewlett-Packard increased annual sales by 21 per cent to &dollar;11.9 billion. 
 Profits rose only two per cent to &dollar;829 million, but would have increased by 12 per cent without the purchase of Apollo earlier this year. 
 Fourth quarter sales jumped from &dollar;2.7 billion to &dollar;3.8 billion, including sales of Apollo equipment. 
 A &dollar;9 million charge was included for the costs of the October 17 earthquake. 
 Tandem's annual revenues grew by 24 per cent to &dollar;1.6 billion. 
 Profits rose by 25 per cent to &dollar;118 million. 
 Data General's annual revenues dipped from &dollar;1.36 billion to &dollar;1.31 billion, and net losses deteriorated from &dollar;15.5 million to &dollar;120 million, reflecting a restructuring charge of &dollar;80 million. 
 In the last quarter, however, sales increased from &dollar;341.5 million to &dollar;357 million. 
 Prime's third quarter revenues dropped from &dollar;391 million to &dollar;358 million, while a profit of &dollar;12 million turned into a &dollar;105 million loss. 
 Prime wrote off &dollar;130 million in a pre-tax restructuring charge. 
 Commodore's sales for the quarter fell by 17 per cent from &dollar;200 million to &dollar;165 million, and profits of &dollar;9.6 million turned into a &dollar;6.5 million loss. 
 Atari's quarterly sales also fell by 17 per cent from &dollar;99 million to &dollar;81 million, while profits of &dollar;7 million turned into a &dollar;5 million loss. 
 The company took a charge of &dollar;10 million against inventory, devaluing stocks of chips and disc drives. 
 Pyramid's annual revenues rose 30 per cent to &dollar;104 million. 
 Profits were fractionally down at &dollar;8 million. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Packer pressed to buy Bond Media. 
 By Ross Dunn in Canberra 
 FINANCIERS are pushing for Alan Bond's highly geared media group to be taken over by Australia's richest man, Mr Kerry Packer, and some leading institutions. 
 The behind-the-scenes manoeuvring came as the Bond corporate empire met renewed difficulties with the Australian Stock Exchange, which suspended trading in Bond Corp. 
 Holdings, the Bell Group and JN Taylor Holdings. 
 The suspensions resulted from the failure of the companies to lodge printed copies of their annual reports by the opening of trading yesterday. 
 The suspensions of Bond and Taylor, which the companies regarded as harsh because photocopies of the audited results were lodged with the Australian Stock Exchange last week, may be lifted today after the companies begin mailing reports to shareholders. 
 Mr Packer was being actively lobbied to take joint venture control of the Bond Media Channel 9 Network, which he sold to Mr Bond for more than A&dollar;1billion several years ago. 
 Mr Packer, who split the international cricket scene apart in the 1970s by forming his World Series Cricket competition, is still owed A&dollar;200million from the sale. 
 Bond Media has proposed to repay Mr Packer a reduced amount from a renegotiated bank facility or from asset sales with a rollover of the outstanding sum. 
 The Bond group of companies last month reported a loss of almost A&dollar;1billion last financial year, the worst result in Australian corporate history. 
 BP sells stake in SA coal. 
 British Petroleum is pulling out of South Africa with the sale of its &dollar;225million stake in coal mining businesses to the Anglo American corporation. 
 The deal, part of BP's plan to sell all of its worldwide coal assets, includes a 88.5 per cent holding in the South African Middelburg Mine Joint Venture. 
 Bill to Bush. 
 The US Congress yesterday sent the long-delayed &dollar;14.7 billion deficit reduction bill to the White House for President Bush's signature. 
 The administration has expressed satisfaction with the package which includes real cuts of &dollar;4.6billion and &dollar;6billion in taxes. 
 Unit trusts cashed. 
 Investors cashed in &pound;877.5million worth of unit trust holdings last month, the highest figure since the crash of October 1987. 
 Medirace bid. 
 Medical research company Medirace, which is trying to develop a drug to treat cancer and Aids, is more than tripling its size through an &pound;87million takeover. 
 It is buying Evans Healthcare, whose management bought the company from Glaxo three years ago. 
 Housebuilding slows. 
 A sharp slowdown in private housebuilding was behind a 9 per cent fall in new construction orders in the third quarter of 1989, figures from the Department of the Environment indicated yesterday. 
 Jobless fall. 
 The number of people out of work and claiming benefit for more than a year fell by 61,000 to a seven-year-low of 613,000 in the third quarter of the year, the Department of Employment said yesterday. 
 Merrill Lynch cuts. 
 Merrill Lynch, the largest US broking firm, is planning a restructuring which could mean hundreds of redundancies affecting its overseas offices as well as its domestic base. 
 The move quickens the pace of cutbacks on Wall Street. 
 Wall Street up. 
 The stock market, shaken earlier this week by sell-offs in defence issues and takeover candidates, regained its composure and moved higher. 
 At the close the Dow Jones Industrial Average had climbed 17.49 to 2,656.78. 
 Monopolies probe stalls Bupa deal. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 A&pound;92MILLION deal which would tighten Bupa's grip on the British private health market has been stalled by the government. 
 The Department of Trade yesterday ordered the Monopolies and Mergers Commission to investigate Bupa's proposed purchase of 10 British hospitals and seven nursing homes from the American-based HCA. 
 The commission has been told to report its findings by the end of February. 
 Bupa already has 16 hospitals. 
 Adding the HCA operations would give it over 1,500 beds &mdash; still less than 20 per cent of the private hospital beds in the UK. 
 Private Patients Plan, Britain's second largest health insurer, has been calling for government intervention to stop the HCA takeover since it was announced in June. 
 The Office of Fair Trading recommended a full monopolies inquiry because of the potential impact of the purchase on Bupa's buying-power when seeking bed-space in private hospitals. 
 The OFT found no evidence that Bupa has abused its buying power up to now, but felt that allowing the takeover could increase the risk of abuse. 
 Bupa has about 60 per cent of the private health insurance market. 
 And four-fifths of all treatment in private hospitals is paid for by insurance. 
 Private hospitals not owned by Bupa are reckoned to rely on patients who are insured by Bupa for half their business. 
 Before the HCA deal was announced, Bupa had bought several smaller private hospitals. 
 The other big hospital operator in Britain is AMI Healthcare, an offshoot of American Medical International. 
 Two-thirds of AMI Healthcare was put up for auction this week after the company's Los Angeles parent changed hands. 
 Mercury starts to reap profits. 
 By Tony May * 
 THE Prime Minister is one of the latest customers to be linked into Mercury, the Cable&amp;Wireless company which is BT's only mainstream rival. 
 The optical fibre cable recently laid to Number 10 Downing Street joined a network which the group cannot spread fast enough to meet demand. 
 The investment is huge with nearly &pound;1billion to be spent over the next three years. 
 The rewards are just beginning to come through with Mercury's contribution to C&amp;W trading profit leaping from &pound;4million to &pound;14million in the six months to September 30. 
 This will take time to catch soaring turnover &mdash; up from &pound;72million to &pound;142million &mdash; as the group pays fees to BT and other international carriers for calls using their lines. 
 Gordon Owen, the managing director in charge of Mercury, says the group is anxious not to more than double the network in a year as it is a case of &bquo;how fast you can go without falling over&equo;. 
 Mercury provides a tiny part of C&amp;W profits, which climbed 22 per cent to &pound;241million before tax. 
 C&amp;W claims to account for 7 per cent of UK invisible earnings. 
 Earnings a share rose 9 per cent to 14.4p and the dividend 10 per cent to 3.10p. 
 Three-quarters of profits still come from Asia and the Pacific, notably Hong Kong. 
 The group's finances are strong, with gearing at 40 per cent and group borrowings are being refinanced over 10 years. 
 The Government has an &bquo;indefinite&equo; golden share in C&amp;W but Jaguar's experience does not worry Lord Sharp, the chairman. 
 He said yesterday that its high cost and strong earnings would deter predators. 
 Government criticised on cable grid. 
 By Peter Large Technology Editor 
 COMPANY heads yesterday condemned the government for refusing to sponsor the recabling of Britain to provide the information infrastructure of the next century in step with global competition. 
 But at a Whitehall seminar there was no agreement on how that national grid of optical cables, bringing hundreds of new services to home and business, should be built. 
 Although speakers mentioned the &bquo;enormous potential&equo; to boost the economy, only British Telecom set an operational target: investment of up to &pound;20billion over 10 years. 
 Alan Rudge, BT's technology director, encapsulated the scope of optical communications with the statistic that two strands of glass, tiny enough to pass through the eye of a needle, already can carry thousands of phone calls and hundreds of video channels. 
 But BT's target depends on politics, regulation, standards, competition and public demand. 
 Mercury profits, page 12 
 Hanson confounds City with &pound;420m US sell-off. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 LORD Hanson, the crafty deal-maker who three months ago clinched Britain's biggest takeover bid by paying &pound;3.3billion for Consolidated Gold Fields, yesterday confounded the City with the &pound;420million sale of a US offshoot. 
 When the ConsGold takeover was announced, it was predicted that Hanson would dismember ConsGold and sell off everything &mdash; with the exception of the mining group's ARC operations which quarry gravel and other building materials in the US and the UK. 
 But yesterday, Hanson revealed it is selling ARC's four main American operations to Australian mining group CSR for &dollar;670million. 
 Hanson pocketed a further &pound;240million by selling an 8 per cent holding in Gold Fields of South Africa plus a string of stakes in more minor South African mining companies. 
 The sale severs ConsGold's century-old link with the South African gold industry. 
 Shortly after Hanson completed the ConsGold takeover, &pound;368million was raised by selling most of the British company's GFSA stake. 
 So now, Hanson has recouped well over &pound;1billion of the &pound;3.3billion it paid for ConsGold. 
 Even if Hanson holds on to the British end of the ARC operation, it still has a long list of ConsGold assets to offload including: 
 Half of American mining group Newmont 
 All of Gold Fields Mining Corporation, also based in the US; and 
 Half of Renison Goldfields Consolidated of Australia which produces not only gold but also tin, copper and the raw material for making titanium oxide. 
 In looking for buyers for the gold-producing assets, Hanson has been helped by the recent upturn in the gold price. 
 The price per ounce dipped below &dollar;360 in the summer, but has recently climbed above &dollar;400 and last night was nudging &dollar;410. 
 Most analysts are surprised at the price which CSR paid for the American ARC operations. 
 In the year to the end of June, they showed pre-tax profits of &dollar;47million on sales of &dollar;385million: these figures suggest CSR has paid well over 20 times annual net earnings to buy the business. 
 The American ARC operation embraces 48 quarries in six states producing limestone, sand and gravel. 
 There are also 40 plants making concrete pipes and other building products. 
 The Australian company plans to carry out a Hanson-style break-up of ARC America. 
 CSR managing director Ian Burgess said yesterday: &bquo;There are significant assets which are surplus to the current operations and these will be divested.&equo; 
 Yesterday's sales mean that Hanson now has virtually no net debt. 
 Further asset sales from breaking up ConsGold will put it in an even stronger position from which to launch further takeovers. 
 Shareholders have recently agreed to extend its borrowing powers, so, in theory, it could raise sufficient funds to bid for virtually any quoted company: only one of two of Britain's very largest companies &mdash; like BP and British Telecom &mdash; are beyond Hanson's grasp. 
 Hanson's share price rose 5p to 221 &frac12;p. 
 It's full steam ahead as investors get appetite for perks on a plate. 
 By Phillip Money 
 THE lure of 20 per cent off the cost of a portion of fish &bquo;n&equo; chips at Harry Ramsden's Yorkshire restaurant has proved irresistable to thousands of small investors. 
 The offer of shares in the group, which was listed on the USM this week, has been two and a half times oversubscribed. 
 This and other shareholder perks &mdash; or concessionary discounts as they are called in the stockbroking trade &mdash; are the icing on the cake for the growing army of small shareholders. 
 With a carefully selected equity portfolio you can get 10 per cent off a room at selected Hilton Hotels (Ladbroke Group), a cut price &bquo;exclusive&equo; two-week African safari, 15 per cent off two transatlantic voyages on the QE2 (Trafalgar House), and a free centre court ticket at Wimbledon (All England Lawn Tennis and Croquet) for every day tennis is played. 
 And when you get back down to earth, concessionary discounts can ease your domestic burdens. 
 Boots offers 10 &pound;1 vouchers for shareholders, BET offers discounts on Anglian Windows double glazing and Sketchley offers 25 per cent discount on dry cleaning and ancillary services. 
 For investors who also want a return on their perks, several housing companies offer discounts. 
 Barratt Developments takes &pound;500 off every &pound;25,000 you spend on a new home. 
 And Bellway gives &pound;600 per &pound;25,000 subject to a maximum discount of &pound;3,000. 
 However, with both companies you need to be on the share register for 12 months. 
 While the gloss of shareholder perks can be dazzling, remember, you get nothing for nothing. 
 Most companies demand a minimum shareholding before offering discounts and in most cases it is not worth buying the shares just to receive the perks. 
 For a pair of next year's Centre Court tickets at Wimbledon you must buy two &pound;500 debentures costing approximately &pound;4,500 each. 
 Also available from 1991 are tickets lasting five years, which involve an outlay of &pound;40,000 per seat. 
 BET's safari to Africa, while limited to shareholders, costs between &pound;1,355 and &pound;1,675. 
 Sketchley requires you to hold 300 ordinary shares, costing about &pound;3.71 each, to qualify for its discount. 
 According to Peter Hume, finance director of stockbrokers Seymour Pierce Butterfield, investors considering buying shares in a company offering concessionary discounts should only do so on the merits of the shares. 
 &bquo;To do so they should look at the yield of the shares and the strength of the company's management,&equo; he said. 
 Each year Seymour Pierce Butterfield publishes a guide to shareholder perks* which includes a list of 120 companies offering perks. 
 The next edition is being prepared now and will be published in early January. 
 Although he concedes that shareholder perks are primarily a marketing exercise, Mr Hume says they benefit both the company and shareholders. 
 He says the two main benefits for shareholders are that the perks are a &bquo;bit of fun&equo; that it &bquo;enables them to relate more to the company.&equo; 
 He adds: &bquo;These days there's always a vast gulf between management and the people who own the company.&equo; 
 This year, Mr Hume said, one perk which stands out is that offered by Lonrho. 
 For shareholders holding 100 25p ordinary shares, costing about 264p, the company's car franchises offer an extra one to two per cent discount on top of the normal 12 per cent trade discount, off the cost of a new Audi or Golf. 
 While most perks are a benefit for existing shareholders, P&amp;O has used them to boost its share register. 
 The 50 per cent discount that it offers shareholders on its ferry crossings boosted the number of shareholders by 60 per cent to 160,000 between 1981 and 1984. 
 One of the most prominent players in the share market, the Government, has used shareholder perks as a major plank of its privatisation programme. 
 It has offered bonuses in British Telecom, British Gas, British Airways and lately water privatisation Concessionary Discounts, available from January 1990 for &pound;2.50 from Seymour Pierce Butterfield, 10 Old Jewry, London, EC2R 8EA. 
 Pensions plug Courtaulds gap. 
 Courtaulds has called up &pound;11million from its pension fund surplus to fill a large part of the interim profit hole from the South African pulp sale. 
 The half year before the demerger of the textile division was otherwise remarkably stable. 
 Benefits from lower raw material prices and the falling pound are expected to provide a boost on top of the move into higher-margin chemical materials in the United States. 
 Pre-tax profit fell to &pound;85.6million from &pound;98.1million, though after lower tax and minority interests, reflecting the African withdrawal, earnings showed only a fractional decline. 
 Apart from the pension gain, more than half of which was taken in the form of lower interest charges, spinning rationalisation costs of almost &pound;10million were treated as an extraordinary levy. 
 The pension contribution will continue for many years. 
 Turnover was &pound;90million up at &pound;1.36billion, including two months of the US chemicals acquisition. 
 Textiles accounted for just over a third, after a slight increase that got through to profit. 
 Well over half of profit still came from overseas, and marine paint and powder coatings were narrowly the largest contributors. 
 In chemicals, cigarette filter acetate kept up its growth and in packaging-film, Cellophane's problems are being countered by a new polypropylene production line. 
 The interim dividend goes up a fraction to 3.1p, from 2.9p. 
 Although interest rates are set to jump after reinvestment in the US and on new plant, earnings of 17.3p, against 17.7p, a share provide a fair base for the two successor companies. 
 Textiles will have about a fifth of earnings. 
 Food giant gets fatter. 
 Ranks Hovis McDougall, the food giant rich in brand names, boosted profit on the back of fatter bread and flour margins and property gains in a year when the Goodman Fielder Wattie hands-off counterbid in Australia cost &pound;58million as an extraordinary post-tax charge. 
 Further brand upvaluations more than balanced it out. 
 Although bakery closures by the Mothers Pride, Mr Kipling and Bisto purveyor were reflected in slightly lower sales in this area, turnover was 7 per cent ahead at &pound;1.79billion. 
 Pre-tax profit rose nearly twice as fast, gaining &pound;20.5million to &pound;176.5million. 
 Milling and baking continued to account for over a third of these totals and grocery products, particularly the enlarged fruit juice business, made strong gains in both sales and profit, along with the United States branch after rationalisation and the tomato products acquisition. 
 Shops and restaurants slipped, along with Sharwood's mushroom business, in an over-supplied market and the hot weather adversely affected confectionery earnings. 
 Property profit more than doubled, to almost &pound;15million. 
 The dividend is lifted by a fifth to 12.74p, with a final 8.92p covered by normal earnings of 34.4p, up almost 4p a share. 
 BAT on course for &pound;2 billion. 
 Tobacco-to-insurance conglomerate BAT, awaiting a threatened bid from Sir James Goldsmith's Hoylake, yesterday unveiled nine-month profits up 17 per cent at &pound;1,228million, putting the group firmly on course for its promised &pound;2billion total by the year-end. 
 Farmers Group, the American insurer it bought last year, showed a surplus of &pound;205million in the nine months to September &mdash; and should now make more than enough money in the full year to cover the cost of its acquisition. 
 For the first time, BAT's financial services operation, which embraces Eagle Star and Allied Dunbar in Britain as well as Farmers in America, made more money than the tobacco business. 
 Since Hoylake launched its first &pound;13billion bid in the summer, BAT has promised shareholders that it will carry out its own partial break-up of the group. 
 The American retailers, Saks and Marshall Fields, will be sold. 
 And both the UK catalogue shop chain, Argos, and BAT's paper businesses, Wiggins Teape and Appleton, will be floated as separate companies. 
 Thomson gets travel sickness. 
 Thomson Travel's profit contribution to the Canadian parent was down &pound;10.7million to &pound;53.1million in the nine months to September 30 as a result of the squeeze on holiday prices and poor late sales. 
 Turnover rose &pound;155million to &pound;1.06billion following the Horizon acquisition. 
 Holiday numbers are now being reduced and the Britannia Airways subsidiary is leasing out surplus seats overseas and selling two older Boeing aircraft. 
 Cost-cutting will continue over the winter and in anticipation of weak summer sales next year. 
 The Thomson Corporation parent in Canada reported a strong advance in special publishing profit and higher North American newspaper circulations. 
 Lower advertising revenue in some US markets was offset by new publications and there have been more than 40 acquisitions so far this year. 
 Total earnings were well ahead and were further boosted by exceptional gains on the oil and gas disposal. 
 In short&hellip; 
 RADIO CLYDE'S profit rose 28 per cent to &pound;1.9million on turnover up 23 per cent at &pound;7.76million in the year to September 30. 
 The results include North of Scotland Radio, bought last December, which made a profit of &pound;218,000 against &pound;180,000. 
 METRO RADIO is in preliminary talks with a number of companies including Radio Forth. 
 The markets. 
 A false report of a bid for Williams Holdings by the Barclay brothers sent its shares leaping 55p to 280p before denials saw them crashing back to 239p. 
 British and Commonwealth was hit early in the day by &bquo;malicious rumours&equo; of a Fraud Squad investigation, falling 19p to 89p. 
 It ended the day 16p down to 92p, helped by a management reorganisation and strenuous management denials. 
 The Stock Exchange is investigating both cases. 
 Apart from rumours, equities did little all day as investors waited to see how bad today's trade figures would be and many were preoccupied with the underwriting of the water issue. 
 BTR, firmed 9p to 422p as KKR bid speculation revived. 
 Upton Southern shed 5p to 40p in reaction to the chairman's resignation over a policy disagreement. 
 Attwoods extended its rally to 29p at 448p, while Wyndham took its profits-inspired gain to 16p at 256p. 
 SEAQ volume at 5 o'clock was 324.2million shares, with the FTSE index closing 7.2 points up at 2,192.3 In properties, there was renewed interest in Rosehaugh, 20p higher at 553p, on hopes that Olympia and York will make an offer. 
 The group's results are due today. 
 A heavy stream of important trading statements made little lasting impression on the shares involved. 
 Cable and Wireless dipped 9p to 482p, the 22 per cent rise in interim profits. 
 The renewed strength of gold and the sale of ARC of America and South African assets helped Hanson rise 5p to 221p. 
 Stores were cautious in front of the Boots figures today. 
 Defence stocks remained depressed by recent downgradings following the &bquo;outbreak of peace&equo; and the current industrial unrest over a shorter working week. 
 SW Wood weakened another 8p to 49p as news of management resignations followed the losses announced on Tuesday. 
 Tokyo: Stocks closed at a new high for the second consecutive day. 
 Nikkei index: 36,286.92 (36,059.87). 
 Hong Kong: Share prices were mixed to softer in lacklustre trading. 
 Hang Seng index: 2,812.02 (2,817.19). 
 Paris: Stocks finished higher. 
 CAC index: 514.1 (515.4). 
 Courtaulds has called up &pound;11million from its pension fund surplus to fill a large part of the interim profit hole from the South African pulp sale. 
 The half year before the demerger of the textile division was otherwise remarkably stable. 
 Benefits from lower raw material prices and the falling pound are expected to provide a boost on top of the move into higher-margin chemical materials in the United States. 
 Pre-tax profit fell to &pound;85.6million from &pound;98.1million, though after lower tax and minority interests, reflecting the African withdrawal, earnings showed only a fractional decline. 
 Apart from the pension gain, more than half of which was taken in the form of lower interest charges, spinning rationalisation costs of almost &pound;10million were treated as an extraordinary levy. 
 The pension contribution will continue for many years. 
 Turnover was &pound;90million up at &pound;1.36billion, including two months of the US chemicals acquisition. 
 Textiles accounted for just over a third, after a slight increase that got through to profit. 
 Well over half of profit still came from overseas, and marine paint and powder coatings were narrowly the largest contributors. 
 In chemicals, cigarette filter acetate kept up its growth and in packaging-film, Cellophane's problems are being countered by a new polypropylene production line. 
 The interim dividend goes up a fraction to 3.1p, from 2.9p. 
 Although interest rates are set to jump after reinvestment in the US and on new plant, earnings of 17.3p, against 17.7p, a share provide a fair base for the two successor companies. 
 Textiles will have about a fifth of earnings. 
 Food giant gets fatter. 
 Ranks Hovis McDougall, the food giant rich in brand names, boosted profit on the back of fatter bread and flour margins and property gains in a year when the Goodman Fielder Wattie hands-off counterbid in Australia cost &pound;58million as an extraordinary post-tax charge. 
 Further brand upvaluations more than balanced it out. 
 Although bakery closures by the Mothers Pride, Mr Kipling and Bisto purveyor were reflected in slightly lower sales in this area, turnover was 7 per cent ahead at &pound;1.79billion. 
 Pre-tax profit rose nearly twice as fast, gaining &pound;20.5million to &pound;176.5million. 
 Milling and baking continued to account for over a third of these totals and grocery products, particularly the enlarged fruit juice business, made strong gains in both sales and profit, along with the United States branch after rationalisation and the tomato products acquisition. 
 Shops and restaurants slipped, along with Sharwood's mushroom business, in an over-supplied market and the hot weather adversely affected confectionery earnings. 
 Property profit more than doubled, to almost &pound;15million. 
 The dividend is lifted by a fifth to 12.74p, with a final 8.92p covered by normal earnings of 34.4p, up almost 4p a share. 
 BAT on course for &pound;2 billion. 
 Tobacco-to-insurance conglomerate BAT, awaiting a threatened bid from Sir James Goldsmith's Hoylake, yesterday unveiled nine-month profits up 17 per cent at &pound;1,228million, putting the group firmly on course for its promised &pound;2billion total by the year-end. 
 Farmers Group, the American insurer it bought last year, showed a surplus of &pound;205million in the nine months to September &mdash; and should now make more than enough money in the full year to cover the cost of its acquisition. 
 For the first time, BAT's financial services operation, which embraces Eagle Star and Allied Dunbar in Britain as well as Farmers in America, made more money than the tobacco business. 
 Since Hoylake launched its first &pound;13billion bid in the summer, BAT has promised shareholders that it will carry out its own partial break-up of the group. 
 The American retailers, Saks and Marshall Fields, will be sold. 
 And both the UK catalogue shop chain, Argos, and BAT's paper businesses, Wiggins Teape and Appleton, will be floated as separate companies. 
 Thomson gets travel sickness. 
 Thomson Travel's profit contribution to the Canadian parent was down &pound;10.7million to &pound;53.1million in the nine months to September 30 as a result of the squeeze on holiday prices and poor late sales. 
 Turnover rose &pound;155million to &pound;1.06billion following the Horizon acquisition. 
 Holiday numbers are now being reduced and the Britannia Airways subsidiary is leasing out surplus seats overseas and selling two older Boeing aircraft. 
 Cost-cutting will continue over the winter and in anticipation of weak summer sales next year. 
 The Thomson Corporation parent in Canada reported a strong advance in special publishing profit and higher North American newspaper circulations. 
 Lower advertising revenue in some US markets was offset by new publications and there have been more than 40 acquisitions so far this year. 
 Total earnings were well ahead and were further boosted by exceptional gains on the oil and gas disposal. 
 In short&hellip; 
 RADIO CLYDE'S profit rose 28 per cent to &pound;1.9million on turnover up 23 per cent at &pound;7.76million in the year to September 30. 
 The results include North of Scotland Radio, bought last December, which made a profit of &pound;218,000 against &pound;180,000. 
 METRO RADIO is in preliminary talks with a number of companies including Radio Forth. 
 The markets. 
 A false report of a bid for Williams Holdings by the Barclay brothers sent its shares leaping 55p to 280p before denials saw them crashing back to 239p. 
 British and Commonwealth was hit early in the day by &bquo;malicious rumours&equo; of a Fraud Squad investigation, falling 19p to 89p. 
 It ended the day 16p down to 92p, helped by a management reorganisation and strenuous management denials. 
 The Stock Exchange is investigating both cases. 
 Apart from rumours, equities did little all day as investors waited to see how bad today's trade figures would be and many were preoccupied with the underwriting of the water issue. 
 BTR, firmed 9p to 422p as KKR bid speculation revived. 
 Upton Southern shed 5p to 40p in reaction to the chairman's resignation over a policy disagreement. 
 Attwoods extended its rally to 29p at 448p, while Wyndham took its profits-inspired gain to 16p at 256p. 
 SEAQ volume at 5 o'clock was 324.2million shares, with the FTSE index closing 7.2 points up at 2,192.3 In properties, there was renewed interest in Rosehaugh, 20p higher at 553p, on hopes that Olympia and York will make an offer. 
 The group's results are due today. 
 A heavy stream of important trading statements made little lasting impression on the shares involved. 
 Cable and Wireless dipped 9p to 482p, the 22 per cent rise in interim profits. 
 The renewed strength of gold and the sale of ARC of America and South African assets helped Hanson rise 5p to 221p. 
 Stores were cautious in front of the Boots figures today. 
 Defence stocks remained depressed by recent downgradings following the &bquo;outbreak of peace&equo; and the current industrial unrest over a shorter working week. 
 SW Wood weakened another 8p to 49p as news of management resignations followed the losses announced on Tuesday. 
 Tokyo: Stocks closed at a new high for the second consecutive day. 
 Nikkei index: 36,286.92 (36,059.87). 
 Hong Kong: Share prices were mixed to softer in lacklustre trading. 
 Hang Seng index: 2,812.02 (2,817.19). 
 Paris: Stocks finished higher. 
 CAC index: 514.1 (515.4). 
 Pound sags as fears grow on October trade figures. 
 By Larry Elliott Economics Correspondent 
 THE prospect of a Tory backbench challenge to the Prime Minister and extreme twitchiness over the release today of the October trade figures left the pound sagging on foreign exchanges once again yesterday. 
 Sterling lost ground against a buoyant German mark as dealers took fright at the prospect of a fall in exports leading to a widening of the current account deficit last month. 
 However, the fact that the Bank of England refused to intervene when the pound came under pressure left some analysts speculating that predictions of an October shortfall of upwards of &pound;1.8billion were too pessimistic. 
 The Government's decision to price water shares at the expected 240p rather than 235p added weight to the theory that the authorities might have better-than-expected news in store to trap dealers who have aggressively sold sterling. 
 Mr Mark Brett, economist with Barclays de Zoete Wedd, said: &bquo;The risk has to be that the figures will be better than everybody is assuming. 
 The relaxed attitude of the authorities would certainly point in that direction.&equo; 
 He said depressed high street spending could reduce imports, while the recovery in North Sea oil output since the pipeline shutdowns earlier in the year should help boost exports. 
 Against the mark, sterling fell from 2.8505 to 2.8389, after hitting a low of 2.8280 at one stage. 
 The effective exchange rate ended 0.1 lower at 87.1 per cent of its 1985 value. 
 GM ponders massive jobs cuts. 
 By Mary Brasier in New York 
 IN A FURTHER sign of recession in the US car industry, General Motors is considering cutbacks in its management and salaried staff which could mean thousands of redundancies over the next five years. 
 GM, which like Ford and Chrysler is suffering falling sales amid growing Japanese competition, will not confirm the extent of the cutbacks. 
 Any cuts would be on top of production line redundancies and would come only a year after GM finished cutbacks which slashed its white-collar staff by 40,000 to 140,000 worldwide. 
 Old Joe gets rich on a false Stock Exchange rumour Notebook. 
 By Edited by Alex Brummer 
 ON A DAY when many people are wondering how to make a few bob out of water, somebody else showed how to make millions, in the worst possible City fashion. 
 The popular name for this particular activity is share ramping. 
 It has always happened, of course, but in the old days, when the stock market was a smaller and more human place, the intimacy of dealing lent some protection. 
 It wasn't that people did not spread false rumours. 
 But with personal contact through the old jobbing system on the floor of the Stock Exchange, experienced people could see Old Joe coming and knew what to expect &mdash; even if they might sometimes join in to make a little extra money. 
 Now that the trading floor has disappeared and everything is electronic that protection has been removed. 
 The market makers who replaced the jobbers rarely meet face to face, so one rumour is as good as another. 
 Because the source is less easy to trace it is more difficult to judge the legitimacy of the rumour. 
 Rumours range from the truth through analysts' exaggerations to blatant lies whose purpose is to make a profit or extract a dealer from an awkward position. 
 So in the past few years since Big Bang we have seen dealers chasing every hare, especially since dealing volumes declined and firms have been more desperate to do business. 
 It is all illegal, of course. 
 And always has been. 
 Creating a false market in shares carries a penalty of seven years imprisonment under Section 47 of the Financial Services Act. 
 One benefit of computerisation is that deals following such a ramp operation are easier to trace. 
 Stock Exchange surveillance computers pick up any unusual movement in share prices and the regulators follow up with visits to stockbrokers involved to discover who has been dealing. 
 But linking transactions to rumour-mongers is virtually impossible. 
 So there will always be ramping. 
 It will be worse when traders are desperate for business, as they are now. 
 Challenge for EC. 
 THE natural tendency to consider the West Germans as better Europeans than ourselves will be severely tested when the EC seeks to complete work on a common monopolies and competition policy in Brussels today. 
 German officials consider the Federal Republic's Cartel Office to be the most rigorous among the 12 EC countries, with a status (at least in their own minds) roughly akin to the Bundesbank. 
 Thus, in much the same way as the Bundesbank chairman, Dr Karl Otto Poehl, has been at pains to preserve the monetary integrity of the new Europe, so the Cartel Office is disturbed about abrogating to Brussels responsibility for all mergers involving a turnover of less than &dollar;5billion. 
 The Germans also want the right to scrutinise mergers of national interest to the Federal Republic. 
 While West Germany's objections are the most serious, it is not the only member cutting up rough in the final stages of the monopoly and competition edict. 
 The French, who have driven the merger and competition policy hard during their presidency, are seeking to maintain a measure of reciprocity. 
 That is, they want to be sure that the scrutiny of takeovers in third countries moving into the EC is as thorough and as fair as in the Community. 
 While superficially this sounds sensible enough, other countries including the UK are concerned that it will reinforce the suspicion across the Atlantic and in Asia that the EC's main preoccupation is to build a fortress Europe from which all others are excluded. 
 As the debate moves into the final stretch, Britain is not without its bargaining cards either. 
 The objection of Mrs Thatcher's government is to a prospective review process which eventually would lower the barrier on EC scrutinised mergers to a turnover of &dollar;2billions. 
 The UK argues that it would be wrong to make the rules for the review (which comes after four years) before it happens. 
 However, one suspects that British caution reflects traditional Thatcherite fears that the new Europeans will be reaching deep inside the British economy in studying mergers, thus diminishing the sovereignty of HMG. 
 These last-ditch problems aside, the odds point to a coherent EC policy on monoplies and competition by the end of this year, with some flexibility of mergers affecting the media and national security. 
 What is perhaps most interesting about the process is the nature of the German objections: the assumption which Bonn/Frankfurt seems to make that somehow its institutions must be better than those of the EC or its rivals. 
 It is an economic and commercial arrogance which sounds a quiet siren for the EC, particularly one in which the two Germanys, economically if not politically united, would be the dominant power. 
 Capitol gains. 
 IT is not just the EC which is currently embroiled in merger and acquisition policy. 
 Buried deep within the entrails of the US budget compromise is the first apparently successful attempt on Capitol Hill to come down heavily on junk bonds and leveraged buyouts (LBO). 
 As part of a &dollar;6billion tax package, Congress has decreed that companies involved in LBOs can no longer claim tax relief on losses caused by interest payments on debt issued to finance the deal. 
 Company's such as Campeau, which plunged too deeply into debt when it bought Bloomingdale's, will no longer be able to count on the US taxpayer to bail them out. 
 Last time the Democratic-controlled Congress sought to fiddle with the tax laws affecting mergers it was embarrassed when the White House sought to blame lawmakers for the October 1987 crash. 
 But in the wake of the United Airlines debacle it is recognised that the problem is with the financiers, not with Congress. 
 Murdoch and Reed in buying spree. 
 By Daniel John 
 RUPERT Murdoch and Reed International yesterday resumed their battle to carve up a large slice of America's publishing industry between them, by spending more than three-quarters of a billion dollars on two major companies. 
 Following the cosy deal in which Reed bought Travel Information Group from Mr Murdoch to help him alleviate his debt problems, the two have gone their separate ways to strengthen their competing US businesses. 
 Reed struck first by purchasing the US equivalent of Britain's Solicitors and Barristers' Directory, to add to its growing stable of professional publications. 
 The acquisition of Martindale-Hubbell has cost the British publisher &dollar;303million (&pound;194million) and takes its spending on magazines and directories this year to &pound;847million. 
 The price is equivalent to 10 times the asset value and 20 times Martindale-Hubbell's last year earnings of nearly &dollar;15million. 
 The City welcomed the purchase by marking Reed's shares up 9p to 410p, but was more surprised by News Corporation's acquisition of the textbook publishing arm of Time-Warner. 
 Mr Murdoch's empire recently admitted that mounting debts were taking a toll of its finances &mdash; an admission which analysts interpreted as a sign that the group, which owns five British national newspapers, would not be making any purchases for the time being. 
 Yesterday's agreement to buy Scott Foresman for &dollar;455million (&pound;291million) shows that Mr Murdoch remains relatively unworried about the group's ability to fund its expansion. 
 However, News Corporation is also taking on &dollar;48million of debt as a result of the transaction. 
 Reed has no such problems and has been gradually using the &pound;800million proceeds from its withdrawal from manufacturing to expand its publishing interests. 
 The latest buy follows that of the travel guides from Mr Murdoch for &pound;480million and TV Times from the ITV companies for &pound;125million. 
 New York-based Martindale-Hubbell publishes an eight-volume guide to the legal profession which contains entries for 700,000 lawyers and 44,000 law firms. 
 Reed says the guide is the definitive directory for the US legal profession. 
 Peter Davis, Reed's chief executive, said: &bquo;This offers us a unique opportunity to expand our subscription-based information publishing for the legal market, which we know well and where we are under-represented in the US.&equo; 
 Easing of MMC proposals allows Whitbread to keep breweries. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 THE Government's watering down of Monopolies and Mergers Commission proposals to weaken big brewers' grip on their pubs has persuaded Whitbread to drop ideas of selling its breweries. 
 When the commission unveiled its tough plans for shaking up the beer industry in March, many industry watchers predicted that Whitbread, forced into a choice between keeping its six breweries or freeing two-thirds of its 6,250 pubs from the obligation to sell its beers, would decide to keep full control of its pubs and pull out of production. 
 Company chairman Mr Sam Whitbread admitted yesterday that selling the breweries was one of the options it considered. 
 But now, with the Government having heavily modified the MMC's recommendations so brewers have to drop the tie from only half of the outlets they own over a 2,000-pub limit, Whitbread has decided to stick with brewing. 
 The company claims that in the year to September, its volume of beer production rose by 3.5 per cent although the beer market as a whole fell slightly. 
 Within the last two weeks, Whitbread has finalised the purchase of two breweries from Manchester-based Boddingtons. 
 That should nudge Whitbread's share of the British beer market up by about one per cent to about 14 per cent. 
 The company brews a range of bitters including Fremlins and Flowers and has a deal to sell Pedigree bitter from Burton brewer Marston's through Whitbread pubs. 
 Whitbread's pre-tax profits for the half year to August rose to &pound;128.5million against &pound;110.6million a year earlier. 
 The company's retailing arm, which includes managed pubs, Thresher off-licences and restaurants like Pizza Hut and Beefeater, showed a 17 per cent profits rise. 
 But managing director Mr Peter Jarvis admitted: &bquo;Because of the squeeze on spending, retailing, particularly in the South-east, is not doing so well as we had hoped.&equo; 
 Marston's pre-tax profits rose 17.5 per cent to &pound;9million in the six months to September. 
 Second judge throws out allegations of insider trading. 
 By Daniel John 
 THE Government's crackdown on insider dealing was dealt another blow yesterday when a former company director was acquitted of the allegations against him. 
 It is the second trial within two weeks that has failed after the judges in both hearings ruled that there was no evidence to prove the cases concerned. 
 In the latest case, Judge Wroath halted the trial at Southampton Crown Court at the end of the prosecution's submissions. 
 Piers Fitzwilliams, 29, of Pilley, Lymington, Hampshire, had been accused of four offences of dealing in shares in Centreway Industries while he was a director of corporate finance group City and Westminster Financial. 
 The allegations involved making use of unpublished, price-sensitive information when he bought shares in Centreway at the time he was negotiating on City and Westminster's behalf to buy a stake in Centreway. 
 But Judge Wroath told the jury yesterday: &bquo;I am satisfied the prosecution have not in this case produced evidence and as a matter of law have not proved the case to the requirements of the Act.&equo; 
 The jury formally returned verdicts of not guilty. 
 Mr Fitzwilliam's acquittal came two weeks after Mr John Briggs, deputy chairman of engineering group Wheway, was cleared of allegations of illegal share trading. 
 Mr Briggs had also denied the charge against him. 
 He said after the case that the Department of Trade and Industry had been &bquo;rather petty&equo; in prosecuting him in the first place. 
 The DTI has so far prosecuted 15 insider dealing cases involving 21 people since 1981 in which eight have resulted in not guilty verdicts. 
 At least 18 other investigations are underway while four further trials are due to take place within the next few months. 
 Hard times make underwriters take reduced margins Low commission on water sell-off. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 IN A move which highlights the hard times facing the City, more than 200 institutions yesterday agreed to take on the risk of underwriting the &pound;5.3billion water sell-off at commission rates worth a total of just &pound;33million. 
 Although the returns would have been regarded as uneconomic two years ago, government advisers will pay out the second-lowest bill for underwriting in the history of public sell-offs. 
 Such was the demand for business that institutions accepted rates for sub-underwriting at 0.17 per cent. 
 That is dramatically cheaper than earlier flotations such as British Telecom, which paid commission rates at 0.375 per cent. 
 The huge demand emerged despite City warnings that leading institutions would shy away unless better commissions were offered. 
 &bquo;This just shows how hungry institutions are for commissions,&equo; one banker said. 
 &bquo;The underwriting really went exceedingly well, given the size of the issue.&equo; 
 Institutions poured into the issue amid speculation that the flotation would start trading at a substantial premium. 
 Shares gained up to 24p in grey market trading. 
 An analyst yesterday said the issue &bquo;is set to get off to a good start&equo;. 
 But there were warnings that nobody should make any firm investment decision until just before the actual float as any fall in the market could wipe out chances of an opening premium. 
 There was disappointment, however, as it became clear that none of the 10 water companies are likely to get into the FTSE index of the hundred biggest companies. 
 The market had expected Thames, Severn Trent and North West to be listed, putting them at an immediate investment advantage to the rest of the sector. 
 This is because index-linked funds would automatically favour them over their smaller rivals. 
 Meanwhile an intense marketing campaign will continue to interest overseas investors in the 18.5 per cent of the issue earmarked for sale abroad. 
 The exact proportion sold to foreign buyers depends on demand for the UK retail market, financial advisers said yesterday. 
 Schroders, the merchant bankers, have set aside 52.6 per cent for Tokyo; 26.2 per cent for continental Europe; 11.9 per cent for Canada and 9.3 per cent for Wall Street investors. 
 If demand hits a pre-set level, one quarter of these shares will be clawed back to increase allocations from the small investors. 
 Just under 50 per cent will be available for the individual investor if demand warrants. 
 Clawbacks will be triggered if the public applies for more than 1.75 times the near-24 per cent of the issue provisionally reserved for small buyers. 
 If the &bquo;Sid&equo; allocation is oversubscribed 2.25 times, further shares will be scooped back from domestic institutions. 
 As in previous privatisation, activation of the clawback would give a massive fillip to the share price when dealings open next month. 
 It would put added pressure on institutions to make up their holdings by buying in the market. 
 Opening the offer, Schroders director Mr David Challen said: &bquo;The yields are attractive. 
 They range from 8.10 per cent to 9.68 per cent and the weighted average gross yield is over 8.5 per cent. 
 This is substantially higher than the average yield of shares quoted on the Stock Exchange. 
 &bquo;The offer price of 240p is spread over the longest instalment period ever on any privatisation. 
 We are delighted to be helping to create a major new investment sector by bringing these 10 companies to the market. 
 &bquo;The Government has placed these companies on a sound financial basis to develop their core businesses over the years to come.&equo; 
 Inquiry launched into share ramps. 
 By Financial Staff 
 THE Stock Exchange is investigating two blatant share ramps which for a while yesterday added &pound;178million to the value of conglomerate Williams Holdings, and knocked &pound;94million from financial services group British &amp; Commonwealth. 
 A newspaper report that the multi-millionaire Barclay brothers had built up a 3 per cent stake in Williams and were thinking of a full bid at 300p a share sent the price soaring 58p to 283p. 
 In contrast, shares in British &amp; Commonwealth at one stage dropped 25 per cent to 82p after unfounded rumours that Department of Trade and Industry inspectors had raided the offices. 
 Chairman John Gunn described the rumours as &bquo;malicious, gratuitous and unnecessary, reflecting badly on the market&equo;. 
 In the Williams incident, a caller giving a false name and claiming to be from brokers Hoare Govett rang the Guardian and other newspapers with a story earlier this week claiming that a stake of over 3 per cent had been built secretly by the Barclay brothers. 
 The bid was expected this week or next, with finance arranged through Manufacturers Hanover and Charterhouse, which acted for the brothers in the past. 
 The Guardian established that nobody of the caller's name worked at Hoare Govett. 
 After a denial from the Barclay brothers and from Charterhouse, the story was dismissed. 
 However, a detailed version appeared in another newspaper yesterday, which cited banking sources in the City. 
 Hectic trading in which 3.1 million shares &mdash; worth &pound;8million &mdash; changed hands was followed by a retreat to 238p when the Barclays vehemently denied that they held any shares in Williams. 
 Mr Nigel Rudd, chairman of Williams, said the company had received categorical assurances from the Barclay brothers that they had no intention of making an offer. 
 The Stock Exchange confirmed it was investigating the rumours and the share price movement. 
 The exchange has been asked by Mr Gunn, through his brokers BZW, to investigate the rumours which knocked his company's shares. 
 He has also written to the Bank of England to complain &bquo;in the strongest possible terms&equo; about the creation of a false market. 
 He said the City's ethical standards seemed to have disappeared. 
 B&amp;C shares recovered only part of their losses, closing 16p down at 92p, because the rumours coincided with downgradings of the company by three analysts. 
 The rumours also came on a day when B&amp;C reshuffled top management, with chief executive Peter Goldie moved sideways to concentrate on the disposal programme. 
 Violence erupts on Basque funeral day. 
 By John Hooper and Reuter in Madrid 
 PROTESTERS set fire to banks and offices of the ruling Socialist Party yesterday as Basques mourned the assassination of one of their leaders. 
 At least nine police were hurt and about 10 people detained in clashes between security forces, demonstrators and strike pickets in the Basque region and the neighbouring Navarre province, local government officials said. 
 Tens of thousands of mourners accompanied the coffin of Mr Josu Muguruza in a funeral procession through the centre of Bilbao, chanting &bquo;independence&equo; and &bquo;long live ETA&equo;. 
 Mr Muguruza was shot dead by masked gunmen as he dined with colleagues from Herri Batasuna (People's Unity) at a hotel in Madrid on Monday night.He had been elected last month to the Spanish Parliament and was murdered the night before he was to take his seat. 
 Mr Inaki Esnaola, another of Herri Batasuna's four deputies-elect, was seriously wounded in the attack. 
 Doctors said yesterday his condition had improved significantly, but that it was still serious. 
 Radicals hurled petrol bombs at several banks, set alight two offices of the Socialist Workers Party (PSOE) in Eibar and Lezo and ransacked the headquarters of a moderate Basque nationalist party. 
 More than 100 cars for export at the port of Pasajes were stoned. 
 Barricades and bomb threats paralysed public transport in the Basque region. 
 Most shops heeded Herri Batasuna's call for a 24-hour strike. 
 Herri Batasuna has called the killing a state crime and blamed the Socialist government. 
 Interior ministry sources said they suspected ultra-rightwing groups were responsible for the murder. 
 Ceausescu in call for Hitler treaties to be annulled. 
 By Ian Traynor in Vienna 
 AS the ideological gulf between Moscow and Bucharest yawns ever wider, the Romanian leader, President Nicolae Ceausescu, has raised the potentially explosive issue of former Romanian territories annexed by the Kremlin during the second world war. 
 In a speech to the Romanian Communist Party Congress earlier this week, he attacked the Stalin-Hitler pact of 1939 that carved up Poland and the Baltic states between them, but also ceded Bessarabia &mdash; then part of Romania and now the Soviet Republic of Moldavia &mdash; to Moscow. 
 Mr Ceausescu demanded that &bquo;all treaties with Hitler's Germany be annulled&equo; and &bquo;practical steps taken to reverse the consequences of those treaties.&equo; 
 His remarks came amid simmering nationalist tension in Moldavia, where the Communist leader was recently sacked. 
 The Kremlin dispatched security forces to the region 10 days ago, after demonstrators in the capital, Kishinev, attacked police headquarters. 
 President Ceausescu has generally kept quiet on the Moldavian issue, while routinely stressing Romanian national sovereignty and independence. 
 But Romania's official press has reported extensively on the ethnic unrest across the border, while, for example, failing to report on the radical reform and street demonstrations taking place in other Warsaw Pact countries. 
 Romania's near total isolation was further underlined at the congress in a series of attacks on perestroika. 
 Speakers denounced &bquo;anti-Communist theories that questioned the legitimacy of socialism.&equo; 
 Inquiry indicts SA squad. 
 By Patrick Laurence in Johannesburg 
 AN independent inquiry yesterday backed up allegations that a South African police &bquo;death squad&equo; had killed anti-apartheid activists. 
 The four-man team presented its report to the Attorney General for the Free State, Mr T.P. McNally, who has been mandated to investigate charges by a former policeman that as a member of a &bquo;police murder unit&equo; he took part in at least eight murders. 
 Set up on the initiative of the secretary-general of the South African Council of Churches, the Reverend Frank Chikane, the Independent Board of Inquiry into Informal Repression has investigated five episodes in which the &bquo;death squad&equo; was involved. 
 It found &bquo;significant corroboration&equo; of the charges made by the ex-policeman, Almond Nofomela. 
 He is on death row awaiting execution for a non-political murder. 
 On the murder of the human rights lawyer, Griffiths Mxenge, in 1981, the report noted that Nofomela's statements were substantially corroborated by those of two co-members of the same unit, Captain Dirk Coetzee and Mr David Tshikalanga. 
 Another attack in which Nofomela claimed to have taken part was in Swaziland in 1983, when the &bquo;death squad&equo; crossed the border to &bquo;hit&equo; a house occupied by African National Congress cadres with grenades and small arms. 
 At least two ANC men were killed in the attack. 
 The board of inquiry called yesterday for a full and open judicial inquiry into the alleged activities of the death squad, noting that the present McNally investigation was an inter-departmental inquiry behind closed doors. 
 It pledged to continue its own inquiry. 
 Meanwhile, violence continued in Natal, where a power struggle between Inkatha and pro-ANC organisations rages despite repeated appeals for peace. 
 Police reported yesterday that four black men were stabbed and hacked to death in a battle in Magoda township. 
 South Koreans question group of fleeing Chinese. 
 By Reuter in Seoul 
 TWELVE Chinese claiming to be fleeing persecution following the Tiananmen Square massacre have arrived by boat on a South Korean island, reportedly seeking to defect to Taiwan. 
 A Foreign Ministry spokesman in Seoul said the 12 Chinese arrived on Tuesday on Cheju Island, which lies about 60 miles off Korea's south-west coast. 
 The spokesman said they were being questioned. 
 He gave no further details. 
 Taiwan State Radio said the group, which includes one woman, was seeking asylum in Nationalist-ruled Taiwan. 
 The owner of a Chinese restaurant visited by the group supported this version of events. 
 But a South Korean Foreign Ministry spokesman was unable to confirm the asylum request. 
 The Yonhap news agency reported that the members of the group were aged between 17 and 40. 
 The report said they chartered a boat on the Chinese mainland and arrived early on Tuesday. 
 The agency reported that the group hid in a pine forest for several hours before heading for a town and finding the Chinese restaurant. 
 They asked their countrymen to inform the authorities of their arrival and pass on their request for asylum, the report added. 
 They claimed to be victims of political persecution following the military crackdown on student protesters. 
 Opposition groups fear Communist attempt to regain the initiative Krenz offers &bquo;round table&equo; talks on free elections. 
 By Anna Tomforde in Bonn 
 EAST GERMANY'S ruling politburo yesterday gave in to demands from independent opposition groups and said it was prepared to convene &bquo;round table talks&equo; about free elections and constitutional and electoral reform. 
 The offer, reported by the official ADN news agency, contained no date for such negotiations, nor did it specify which groups should take part. 
 It followed growing pressure from within the ruling Communist Party for a dialogue with the opposition, and came after newly elected Communist Party leaders in the provinces had already made contact with the biggest opposition group, New Forum. 
 This has happened in at least two cities, Halle and Karl-Marx- Stadt, where young party leaders have replaced their &bquo;old guard&equo; predecessors. 
 The politburo proposal resembles similar offers made by ruling Communist parties in Poland and Hungary last year. 
 But it also coincided yesterday with a pledge by Mr Egon Krenz, the party leader, that there &bquo;cannot and will not be an East Germany without a Communist Party.&equo; 
 Opinion polls have given the Communists up to 15 per cent in the event of genuinely free elections. 
 Calls for a round table have come from Social Democrat-inclined opposition groups, such as Democratic Awakening and Democracy Now, as well as from the newly founded Social Democratic Party, the SDP. 
 They were publicly endorsed yesterday by the Liberal Democratic Party, the LDPD, which is in alliance with the Communists. 
 But New Forum, the leading force in the independent opposition movement, remained sceptical yesterday, saying that the offer could be part of the Communists' attempt to regain the initiative. 
 The greatest fear of the opposition groups now is that the ruling parties will try to appease them and rush ahead with calling free elections before the opposition groups are properly organised. 
 Meanwhile, East Germany banned the export of antiques and second-hand goods, in an attempt to counter rising currency speculation. 
 Mr Krenz speaking to workers yesterday at the Bergmann-Borsig machine factory outside East Berlin &mdash; a hotbed of critical opposition and the birthplace of East Germany's first independent trade union &mdash; reiterated that he was prepared to have his position as party leader voted on by a new central committee. 
 The LDPD suggested yesterday that East Germany should reintroduce the post of State Presidency &mdash; for which the Liberals would propose a candidate &mdash; which would curtail Mr Krenz's treble power as party leader, head of state, and chairman of the National Defence Council. 
 East Germany was yesterday preparing further measures to counter a drastic fall in the value of its currency. 
 Mr Hans Modrow, the new prime minister, has told East Germans to be prepared for &bquo;unpopular measures&equo; which will be agreed by the government today. 
 Apart from the ban on the export of antiques and other goods, these are likely to include increased customs controls and measures to stop other &bquo;illegal transactions.&equo; 
 Buyers of certain subsidised goods could be required to show their identity cards in shops. 
 Kohl rules out one Germany before Europe itself unites. 
 By John Palmer in Strasbourg 
 APOSSIBLE framework for a pan-European organisation linking countries in Western and Eastern Europe was unveiled here yesterday as the West German Chancellor, Dr Helmut Kohl, formally ruled out any prospect of Bonn seeking German reunification outside the creation of a united Europe. 
 The new body &mdash; to be set up by the 12 countries of the European Community and the six countries of the European Free Trade Association &mdash; would be open to east European states who opt for democracy. 
 The attempt to put flesh and blood on the skeleton structure of a possible united Europe emerged during an unprecedented day in the history of the European Parliament. 
 Reflecting both the sense of momentous events in Eastern Europe and the desire to strengthen the political role of the European Parliament, MEPs were unexpectedly addressed yesterday both by Chancellor Kohl and President Mitterrand, President of the European Council. 
 The Commission's thinking about a wider European organisation was set out yesterday by its vice-president, Mr Frans Andriessen, in a report about the proposed European economic space with Efta in which capital, people, trade, and services would move freely. 
 In the short run this new body is seen by the Commission as a useful means of delaying or diverting the application of countries such as Austria which want to belong to the inner core of the 12 European Community states. 
 But Mr Andriessen conceded that the 18-country EES would be presided over by a council of ministers &bquo;shaping decisions by consensus&equo;. 
 Advocates of faster progress to European monetary union were encouraged yesterday by the unambiguous declaration made to the European Parliament by Chancellor Helmut Kohl yesterday that change in eastern Europe could not justify going slow on EC integration. 
 Others speculated that the foundations were being laid for a pan-European unity which might stretch from the Urals to the Atlantic. 
 The Chancellor also took the opportunity to nuance his support for German reunification in ways which will reassure those fearful that precipitate moves to unification might unsettle the Soviet Union and threaten the improvement in East-West relations. 
 Unlike his Foreign Minister, Mr Hans-Dietrich Genscher, Dr Kohl had first reacted to the changes in East Germany by highlighting German reunification. 
 While underlining the right of the East Germans to opt for unity with their fellow Germans in the Federal Republic, Dr Kohl said this was a matter for their own free choice. 
 &bquo;The people of the GDR do not need lectures on this subject from outsiders,&equo; commented Dr Kohl, adding that Mr Gorbachev's survival was vital for the wider movement to democracy and reform in eastern Europe. 
 He concluded that a &bquo;free and united Germany&equo; was conceivable only in &bquo;a free and united Europe.&equo; 
 The Chancellor stated that the priority now was for East Germany to move to free and secret elections, a press freed from bureaucratic political control, free trade unions, and the right to form independent parties, he said. 
 &bquo;The recent declarations of the GDR Prime Minister, Mr Hans Modrow, contain references which undeniably lead in this direction. 
 All now depends on how these announcements are implemented.&equo; 
 While making no secret of the Federal Republic's readiness to provide massive aid for a democratic East Germany, the Chancellor emphasised that virtually all of eastern Europe, from Poland to Yugoslavia, would have a claim of the support and solidarity of Western Europe. 
 For his part President Mitterrand reported on the steps taken in Paris last weekend by EC heads of government to bolster the crisis ridden economies of Hungary and Poland. 
 &bquo;Yugoslavia must also not be forgotton since Yugoslavia was one of the first East European countries to show courage in making change, although its economy has not necessarily benefited from this,&equo; said President Mitterrand. 
 News in brief: Row over Tory leadership. 
 The &bquo;near-certain&equo; commitment by backbencher Sir Anthony Meyer to stand against Mrs Thatcher for the Tory leadership brought the instant criticism of party leaders upon his head. 
 Back page. 
 Difference on defence. 
 Mrs Thatcher is set for a clash with President Bush tomorrow over proposed big cuts in the US defence budget. 
 She is to seek assurances that these will not erode the US military commitment to Western Europe. 
 Page 5. &pound;450m rent arrears. 
 Council tenants' rent arrears have risen to over &pound;450 million, and in some inner London boroughs two out of three tenants are in arrears, the Audit Commission reveals. 
 Page 6. 
 Siege ends quietly. 
 The Salvador hotel siege ended peacefully when 12 US Green Berets were freed after a seeming deal between guerrillas and the army. 
 Page 5. 
 E German concession. 
 The East German politburo told opposition groups it was prepared to hold talks on free elections and constitutional reform. 
 Page 4. 
 Dispute tension grows. 
 Tension in the ambulance dispute was heightened as management in London published a list of 999 calls which it claimed had not been answered. 
 Page 7. 
 Disclosure order. 
 A trade magazine journalist was ordered in the High Court to disclose the source of commercially sensitive information. 
 Page 7 PAGE 
 Communists &bquo;out of step&equo;. 
 By John Richmond 
 THE &bquo;new thinking&equo; in the Soviet Union has outstripped that of Mr Joe Slovo, Secretary-General of the South African Communist Party, whose view that President De Klerk's recent reforms were &bquo;new wrapping on an old package&equo; was published in the Guardian on Saturday. 
 Mr Boris Asoyan, a distinguished Africanist and a key figure in formulating Soviet policy on South Africa, believes the reforms are not simply cosmetic. 
 Writing in Pravda at the end of August, he added: &bquo;Over the last 11 years, reforms have substantively changed the situation of the country's political life.&equo; 
 Those comments prompted Mr Slovo to reply six weeks later that Mr Asoyan had characterised the African National Congress in terms in which Pretoria might sketch one of its propaganda pieces. 
 For example, an equal degree of responsibility was levelled at &bquo;extreme radicalism in the black community&equo; as at &bquo;white extremism.&equo; 
 In an exclusive interview, however, Mr Asoyan dismissed suggestions that the debate with Mr Slovo was evidence of a difference of views. 
 &bquo;Generally we agree on how the situation in South Africa looks today.&equo; 
 The difference was more apparent than real, a question of &bquo;words&equo; in which &bquo;all the details are important&equo; in a new &bquo;information environment&equo; &mdash; meaning his words ought to be read in the light of the special status of the Communist Party organ, Pravda, and of glasnost. 
 Mr Asoyan underlined the USSR's suport for the ANC's policy on attacks against so-called soft targets, adding his personal revulsion, and reaffirmed belief in the legitimacy of armed struggle and attacks on military and economic targets. 
 Asked whether a Bolshevik-style revolution in Africa by violent means that would miss the capitalist stage of development was possible, he said: &bquo;I don't think that revolution in this sense is possible.&equo; 
 It is on this point that the views of the SACP and some Soviet policymakers divide. 
 Mr Slovo, again in Pravda, accused Mr Asoyan of &bquo;underestimating the value of armed struggle. 
 Mr Asoyan places greater emphasis than Mr Slovo on the forces of social and economic transformation and notes the dissipation of consensus of white opinion. 
 Turning to the African population, he said in Pravda: &bquo;Botha's reforms opened the way to gradual transformation of purely racial into social barriers. 
 &bquo;In the black community, stratification is proceeding very fast, a rather substantial middle class is emerging that is interested in stability and peaceful means to resolve the present conflict. 
 Skin colour is losing its meaning as a factor in economic life.&equo; 
 Mr Slovo dismisses this as &bquo;made without reference to any statistics whatever.&equo; 
 Leningrad party boss goes too. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 WHILE the Communist Party's Moscow chief was being sacked on Tuesday, the same fate befell his counterpart in the Soviet Union's second city, Leningrad, &mdash; apparently for similar reasons. 
 In a report from Leningrad, Pravda revealed that the city's first secretary, Mr Anatoly Gerasimov, had been relieved of his post, which was taken over by the Leningrad regional boss, Mr Boris Gidaspov, combining the two jobs. 
 This was &bquo;to give greater flexibility to party work, and to remove unnecessary parallelism in the activity of the regional and city committees&equo;. 
 The decision was taken at a joint meeting of the two committees which adopted &bquo;a programme of party action to strengthen perestroika&equo;. 
 This is to be the party's platform for the elections to republican and local soviets early next year. 
 What Pravda did not say was that Mr Gerasimov failed to get elected by popular vote in the all-union congressional elections last March &mdash; just like Mr Lev Zaikov, the ousted Moscow party leader. 
 Mr Gidaspov, however, who is not a party apparatchik, was one of the few top Communists to retain popularity with the Leningrad electorate. 
 He took over as regional party leader in July in place of the hardliner Mr Lev Solovyov, a junior member of the politburo who also failed to get elected. 
 A professor of chemistry, Mr Gidaspov is expected to try to galvanise the party campaign, in the same way as Mr Yuri Prokofyev, the new party leader in Moscow. 
 A document circulated within the Leningrad regional party by its ideological commission, however, throws a new light the electoral campaign, indicating serious concern about the growing influence of the Popular Front and other radical groups, particularly among the rapidly expanding voters' clubs and associations. 
 PAGE 
 Leningrad party boss goes too. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 WHILE the Communist Party's Moscow chief was being sacked on Tuesday, the same fate befell his counterpart in the Soviet Union's second city, Leningrad, &mdash; apparently for similar reasons. 
 In a report from Leningrad, Pravda revealed that the city's first secretary, Mr Anatoly Gerasimov, had been relieved of his post, which was taken over by the Leningrad regional boss, Mr Boris Gidaspov, combining the two jobs. 
 This was &bquo;to give greater flexibility to party work, and to remove unnecessary parallelism in the activity of the regional and city committees&equo;. 
 The decision was taken at a joint meeting of the two committees which adopted &bquo;a programme of party action to strengthen perestroika&equo;. 
 This is to be the party's platform for the elections to republican and local soviets early next year. 
 What Pravda did not say was that Mr Gerasimov failed to get elected by popular vote in the all-union congressional elections last March &mdash; just like Mr Lev Zaikov, the ousted Moscow party leader. 
 Mr Gidaspov, however, who is not a party apparatchik, was one of the few top Communists to retain popularity with the Leningrad electorate. 
 He took over as regional party leader in July in place of the hardliner Mr Lev Solovyov, a junior member of the politburo who also failed to get elected. 
 A professor of chemistry, Mr Gidaspov is expected to try to galvanise the party campaign, in the same way as Mr Yuri Prokofyev, the new party leader in Moscow. 
 A document circulated within the Leningrad regional party by its ideological commission, however, throws a new light the electoral campaign, indicating serious concern about the growing influence of the Popular Front and other radical groups, particularly among the rapidly expanding voters' clubs and associations. 
 Tough realities face Eastern Europe's oldest industrialised country. 
 By Martin Myant 
 ONCE Czechoslovakia settles down from the current euphoria of people's power, its new leadership will have to take some hard decisions on how to overcome its economic difficulties. 
 Compared with some in Eastern Europe their position looks reasonably comfortable. 
 The Czechoslovak economy is not on the brink of collapse. 
 It is not plagued by shortages of basic consumer goods. 
 There are shortages, especially of electrical goods and cars. 
 There are also frequent problems with the range and quality of garments and footwear. 
 Behind this lies the problem of an economy that has been largely stagnant since the mid-1970s. 
 Official figures suggest reasonable growth rates &mdash; 5 per cent a year up to 1975, declining to between 2 and 3 per cent now &mdash; but they are almost certainly exaggerated by up to 3 per cent. 
 It seems that the system of central planning, adopted after the Communist Party took power in 1948, did bring some economic progress in the 1950s and even into the 1960s. 
 After that it had largely exhausted its potential. 
 One powerful argument attributes this stagnation to the economic structure set in the early 1950s. 
 Before the second world war Czechoslovakia was a producer and exporter of light consumer goods. 
 Once incorporated into Stalin's Soviet bloc, the economy was reorientated to rely on its own resources as much as possible, while exporting heavy machinery to the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe in exchange for raw materials. 
 The technology for these new industries was always backward by world standards, and it has never been possible to find secure markets outside the Soviet bloc. 
 This has left an economy largely isolated from the most advanced countries, with one of the world's highest levels of consumption per capita of energy and steel. 
 Domestic energy resources will only last another 30 to 40 years, while burning coal with an ever higher sulphur content is already destroying the forests on the mountainous Polish border. 
 The limitations to this structure were already clear by the 1960s, and an attempt was made to shift back towards lighter industries and consumer goods. 
 This new strategy was ridiculed by the Soviet leadership and opposed by the heavy engineering sector inside Czechoslovakia. 
 Among its firmest advocates was the young economist Mr Valtr Komarek, who fell from favour after 1968. 
 His star could only rise again with the economic stagnation of the early 1980s and, even more clearly, following the appearance of Mr Gorbachev. 
 Although nothing much changed in cultural policy, in the political system or in the media, steps were taken towards economic reform. 
 Mr Komarek became the director of a new research body, the Institute of Forecasting, given the task of advising on long-term development strategy. 
 He clearly had friends in high places, as he was able to take on prominent people who had been purged after 1968 and even some who had suffered after the takeover of 1948. 
 He has remorselessly plugged the necessity for structural change &mdash; referring at one time to the need to halve steel production from its current level of 14 million tonnes. 
 He has also taken up the case for a market-orientated reform, which has been started, but with far less vigour. 
 His basic case is that, with a shift towards producing more modern products, Czechoslovakia could quickly regain its place among the most advanced countries of Europe. 
 Mr Komarek may have some influential friends, but he also faces powerful enemies. 
 The traditional steel and heavy engineering sectors naturally have no sympathy. 
 Neither does the State Planning Commission, the vast organisation responsible for the day-to-day management of the economy. 
 Despite government and party documents since the early 1980s accepting much of Komarek's argument, nothing has changed in the structure of the economy. 
 The planners have, however, finally been shaken out of their complacency by a fall in orders from the Soviet Union. 
 The initial stimulus was a drop in the price of Soviet oil, which has meant that Soviet industry can no longer afford to buy so much Czechoslovak machinery. 
 The prospect for the future is that a modernising Soviet economy might even prefer to buy better quality equipment from elsewhere. 
 At the same time, Czechoslovakia has been hit hard by the Warsaw Pact arms reductions. 
 Figures on the extent of military production and exports have never been published, but much of the best of the Czechoslovak engineering industry is producing armaments. 
 There seems little alternative to a change in the economy's structure towards a new range of products. 
 The question is whether this can be achieved without some form of outside aid. 
 Government policy in the 1980s has been to oppose any increase in the country's dollar debt, which remains at the manageable level of &dollar;5.5 million. 
 Komarek hopes that substantial further borrowing may not be necessary. 
 His institute's estimates of the country's current economic level relative to Western Europe are high and he concludes from this that economic reform can be based largely on domestic resources. 
 A growing number of economists are sceptical of this. 
 If, as seems likely, the Czechoslovak economy has been largely stagnant for 15 years then it is hard to see how domestic resources could be enough. 
 Martin Myant is a writer and author of The Czechoslovak Economy &mdash; 1948-1988: The Battle for Economic Reform (Cambridge University Press) Leader comment page 18 
 Latest shuttle mission &bquo;aims to deploy new spy satellite&equo;. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 THE first black to command a US space mission, Air Force Colonel Fred Gregory, led a team of specialists aboard the space shuttle, Discovery, last night, for a secret mission believed to be the deployment of a spy satellite. 
 It will be the 32nd US space shuttle mission, and the seventh since the Challenger shuttle exploded in flight in 1986. 
 The satellite is to be deployed 22,300 miles above the equator, and has been variously described in the technical press as designed to monitor Soviet compliance with arms treaties and as an advanced eavesdropping satellite, able to monitor, record and re-transmit hundreds of Soviet communications channels, including voice, data and telemetry. 
 Nasa also took delivery yesterday of a report it had commissioned to put a timetable on President Bush's vague plan for a manned mission to Mars, which could now put four people on the planet by 2011. 
 The report spells out a series of options, and leans towards a plan which would put men on the Moon in 2001 to build a base there as a springboard for the Martian expedition 10 years later. 
 Although no cost analyses have been made in the Nasa report, a separate study by the White House Office of Management and Budget has put a tentative &dollar;400 billion price tag on the Mars venture. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 BREAKING two decades of silence in the Soviet media, one of Russia's most distinguished writers has denounced the Soviet invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968 as &bquo;collective murder&equo;. 
 In the latest issue of Moscow News, Daniil Granin said Czechoslovakia's efforts to create &bquo;socialism with a human face&equo; was &bquo;the first perestroika in socialist countries, and we crushed it and slandered it. 
 That was collective murder&equo;. 
 Mr Granin, who is also a much-respected parliamentary deputy and a war veteran, made his remarks in an open letter to his &bquo;Czechoslovak friends and readers&equo;. 
 Soviet leaders have made no direct comment about events in Eastern Europe &mdash; except to welcome reformist changes when they happen. 
 Mr Granin also commiserated with Czechoslovaks for their sufferings under the post-Dubcek regime. 
 Clash likely at Camp David meeting with Bush Thatcher to attack US defence cuts. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington and Hella Pick 
 THE Prime Minister, Mrs Thatcher, is preparing for a head-on clash with President Bush at Camp David tomorrow over American proposals for radical cuts in the US defence budget. 
 Deeply concerned at what she sees as a naive response to changes in the Warsaw Pact countries which could yet be reversed, Mrs Thatcher will seek a clear assurance from Mr Bush that any defence cuts will not erode the US military commmitment to Western Europe. 
 There must be no unravelling of the alliance's military posture. 
 Mrs Thatcher has reacted angrily to the surprise decision by the US Secretary of Defence, Mr Dick Cheney, to slash billions of dollars and seek a 3 per cent cut in the 1991 defence budget. 
 She had received no advance warning, and was all the more disturbed when Mr Cheney justified his move by declaring that the threat from the Warsaw Pact was diminishing. 
 Ideally, the Prime Minister would like President Bush to repudiate the Pentagon chief. 
 But she recognises that the Administration is under considerable domestic pressure to reduce the US budget deficit through substantial savings in expenditure. 
 Mrs Thatcher will have to be satisfied with the assurances she will receive from Mr Bush, who will tell her that, since defence cuts are politically inevitable, it is far better for modest and planned reductions to be proposed by his cabinet and the Pentagon than for swingeing cuts to be imposed by the US Congress, which is already chafing at the thought of the US budget deficit being deepened to pay for the defence of the wealthy Europeans. 
 Mrs Thatcher will also be assured that there will be no unilateral US cuts of its forces committed to Western Europe, that all will be done in consultations with Nato, and that there will be no grandiose new proposal for further US and Soviet troop cuts until the current Conventional Forces in Europe talks in Vienna are complete. 
 Mrs Thatcher has been alarmed over reports from Washington that President Bush is already contemplating follow-on talks from the present East-West negotiations on conventional forces. 
 She is also concerned by West German manouvres to revive the debate over the future of short-range nuclear weapons and to enlist US support to kill plans to modernise the Lance missiles deployed in the Federal Republic. 
 Mrs Thatcher remains totally opposed to the idea of a &bquo;third zero,&equo; the elimination of short- range nuclear weapons, and believes the Soviet Union has now rallied to her view. 
 She will insist that no immediate decision is called for on the modernisation of Lance. 
 But in a first hint that she may be prepared to modify her views, the Prime Minister will tell the President that, if the deployment of new short-range missiles in Germany becomes unrealistic, Britain is certainly prepared to consider the alternative of stand-off missiles carried on Tornados. 
 Mrs Thatcher is still seen in the United States as the staunchest of its allies. 
 Yet this cannot disguise the shifting assessment of US interests which has already seen Bonn replace London as the crucial European relationship. 
 Mrs Thatcher's staff will today be scanning Mr Bush's televised Thanksgiving address to the nation last night, in which the President emphasised the continued US commitment to the Nato alliance and the defence of Western Europe, stressing that Nato's fortitude has been a prime cause of the transformations in Eastern Europe. 
 But these phrases, like the assurances of Mrs Thatcher, were couched in general terms, without the copper-bottomed guarantees of American troops, airbases, and nuclear weapons modernisation programmes, which the Prime Minister would like. 
 Mrs Thatcher is being given the honour of an invitation to the President's private retreat at Camp David, in the Maryland hills north of Washington. 
 Talks with Mr Bush and his National Security Advisor, General Brent Scowcroft, are to be followed by a what is planned to be as informal a lunch as Mrs Thatcher's presence will permit. 
 His first formal policy speech on Eastern Europe since the crumbling of the Berlin Wall, the televised address also dwellt on Mr Bush's hopes for the forthcoming summit with Mr Gorbachev. 
 A speech in which the epochal scale of change in the East was acknowledged and yet also modified by President Bush's innate caution, it was meant to include nothing that would alarm Mrs Thatcher. 
 President Bush has already promised that no commitments will be made at the Malta summit, and last week agreed to fly on to Brussels immediately afterwards to brief Nato leaders. 
 A speechwriter's attempt to compensate for the public relations lapse in not going to the Berlin Wall, Mr Bush's prime time statement went out on all television channels on Thanksgiving Eve. 
 Syrians blame Gen Aoun for murder of Muawad. 
 By Reuter in Damascus 
 SYRIA yesterday denounced the assassination of the Lebanese President, Rene Muawad, 17 days after he took office, and pointed the finger of suspicion at General Michel Aoun. 
 Gen Aouncontrols Lebanon's Christian enclave and opposes the presence of Syrian troops in the country. 
 He rejected the authority of President Muawad, who was elected with Syrian backing. 
 &bquo;The hand of betrayal and treason has reached the martyr President Rene Muawad,&equo; the official Syrian news agency, Sana, said. 
 &bquo;This ugly crime against Lebanon and its legitimacy followed a series of threats by the rebellious officer (Aoun).&equo; 
 It said that Gen Aoun had threatened to destroy Beirut and kill deputies and leaders who approved an Arab-backed peace plan. 
 The US deplored the assassination as a &bquo;despicable act of terrorism against a man of peace.&equo; 
 President Bush, saying the murder was a &bquo;disgraceful happening,&equo; offered US assistance in finding President Muawad's killers. 
 Appealing for calm in Lebanon, the State Department spokesmen said that they had no indication who was responsible. 
 Mr Bush admitted the assassination was &bquo;a direct setback to the effort to bring peace to Lebanon.&equo; 
 Speaking on Capitol Hill, the Assistant Secretary of State for the Near East, Mr John Kelly, said that he hoped attempts to bring peace to divided Lebanon would continue. 
 France expressed horror at the assassination and appealed for unity to assure peace in the country it once ruled. 
 &bquo;I wish to express the shock of the French Government in the face of this horrible assassination and convey its condolences to all Lebanese people,&equo; the junior Foreign Minister, Ms Edwige Avice, said in a statement to Parliament. 
 The assassination has thrown Arab leaders and diplomats into despair and shattered the most hopeful and broadly supported joint Arab effort to resolve the conflict at the core of 14 years of civil war in Lebanon. 
 &bquo;It is a tragedy. 
 Whenever we take one step forward, we take five steps back,&equo; said an ambassador to the Arab League. 
 &bquo;It's shocking. 
 We're back to square one,&equo; said a senior official at Jordan's Foreign Ministry. 
 The bomb that killed President Muawad appeared to have defeated or at least set back for many months the Arab initiative spearheaded by Morocco, Algeria and Saudi Arabia. 
 &bquo;Where do we turn now?&equo; asked an official at the Tunis headquarters of the Arab League. 
 &bquo;This is terribly tragic, but all the more reason for Arab mediation to continue,&equo; an Egyptian diplomat said. 
 In Strasbourg, the 23-nation Council of Europe issued a statement expressing its indignation at the killing. 
 &bquo;By murdering President Rene Muawad, his assassins chose to strike down a man of dialogue and reconciliation,&equo; the secretary-general, Ms Catherine Lalumiere, said. 
 PAGE 
 Last stand for Communism and nostalgia at Renault birthplace. 
 By Paul Webster in Paris 
 ONE of Europe's symbolic Communist strongholds is preparing for its final battle after the decision yesterday of the state-owned Renault car company to close its 60-year-old Paris factory at Boulogne Billancourt in 1992. 
 The island site on the River Seine was a traditional centre of Communist led revolt, notably during the 1936 Popular Front, the 1947 national strikes and the 1968 unrest. 
 The Communist CGT trade union and party leaders warned that they would fight the decision, which threatens 4000 jobs. 
 The party newspaper, L'Humanite, said the firm was giving in to property sharks who want to develop 200 acres around the site where the Renault brothers built their first cars in the family garage more than 90 years ago. 
 The company says the plant, modernised at a cost of &pound;100 million ten years ago, cannot meet today's standards. 
 No factory has played a more central role in France's industrial and social development, particularly after Renault was nationalised in 1945 as a punishment for collaboration. 
 If trade unions can stir up support they will receive sympathy from non-Communists who cherish the five storey factory as part of the national heritage. 
 Many of France's most popular cars, including the postwar 4CV, 4L and 5, were designed and built at Billancourt. 
 Prague's &bquo;underground&equo; gets used to the glare. 
 By Michael Simmons in Prague 
 SOLIDARITY achieved Poland's revolution in church crypts and decaying technical colleges. 
 New Forum in East Germany uses churches and community hostels. 
 Civic Forum in Czechoslovakia chose an early 16th century house on a cobbled street in Prague converted into an avant garde art gallery. 
 Beneath a vaulted whitewashed ceiling and surrounded by strange blocks and squares which artists said were &bquo;pictures,&equo; the playwright, Vaclav Havel, met the world's press. 
 Crowds are difficult to count in Prague these days, but the crush was equal only to Wenceslas Square last Monday. 
 Hindsight may show this to have been a pivotal meeting. 
 In the suffocating heat of a dozen television arc lamps, messages of support for Civic Forum and the students' cause were read from a canning factory in the provinces and from other industrial plants. 
 An establishment economist was present standing in sports jacket and flannels in the crush. 
 &bquo;My presence is very important,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The Forum is not just actors and intellectuals.&equo; 
 Czechoslovaks must be the best fed and the best shod of Eastern Europe's new wave revolutionaries. 
 But the economist added: &bquo;Our analysis are much more negative even than the samizdat literature. 
 We need now to prepare the country's economy for &bquo;the day after&equo; and to be ready for the transition.&equo; 
 &bquo;You see,&equo; the next speaker said, &bquo;we are no longer dissidents now.&equo; 
 It fell to the diminutive and very tired Mr Havel to declare that a message had gone from the Forum to Presidents George Bush and Mikhail Gorbachev, urging them to look closely at 1968 and the invasion when they meet next month. 
 &bquo;If Mr Gorbachev rejects the invasion,&equo; the playwright said, &bquo;the existing leadership in Czechoslovakia will lose its legitimacy.&equo; 
 The case of Martin Smid &mdash; the student whom thousands believe was beaten to death by the riot police just down the road last Friday &mdash; was raised. 
 Petr Uhl, a dissident in prison facing charges of spreading false information, was said yesterday to be a victim of disinformation. 
 Perspiration poured from a hundred brows &mdash; though it was snowing steadily outside &mdash; as an official declared: &bquo;We ask you to tell the world about Petr Uhl. 
 &bquo;He is a hostage. 
 He would be here if he was not in prison.&equo; 
 But this is still Mr Milos Jakes's Czechoslovakia. 
 The government, said one speaker, did &bquo;nothing but spit at our past offers for dialogue&equo;. 
 The Stalinists, added another, were still considering armed intervention. 
 Referring to the petition for change, A Few Sentences, Mr Havel said the crisis would be resolved very quickly in one way at least. 
 &bquo;I appeal to Mr Jakes to sign this petition.&equo; 
 Everyone in the room forgot their discomfort and burst out laughing. 
 Mr Havel, who has a genius for pinpointing the absurd, smiled gently and sipped at some mineral water. 
 Dusty answers for villagers on road to the polls. 
 By Suzanne Goldenberg in Amethi, northern India 
 POLLING stations 83 and 84 for the village of Hath Qila lie down a dusty track that must be one of the few roads that has not been metalled in the five years that Mr Rajiv Gandhi has been cosseting his home constituency of Amethi. 
 More than 100 sullen villagers were muttering outside yesterday, afraid to approach the polling station where the assistant district magistrate and scores of police are trying to create the impression that polling is normal. 
 Just 20 minutes before, about 60 heavyweight Congress I supporters in three or four jeeps roared up to the unprotected station in a whirlwind of dust. 
 Firing shots in the air they descended on the station and carted away the metal ballot boxes, substituting three of their own. 
 The magistrate, Mr S.K. Upadhyaya, resplendent among the dusty villagers in a navy blazer and a silver-tipped walking stick, denied that there had been any attempt to intimidate voters. 
 He said that the polling had been interrupted because the polling officers shut down for lunch. 
 He produced one of the officials as proof. 
 Trembling visibly with fear under the watchful eye of Mr Upadhyaya and the police, the official also said that the hold-up was due to a lunch break. 
 His terrified colleagues chimed in and held up their plates. 
 But just around a bend in the road an opposition supporter who was frightened away from the station, Mr Ram Raj Upadhyaya, said: &bquo;We are all terrified and afraid to go anywhere near the polling station. 
 If he (the magistrate) is saying that everything is all right, than this is all lies.&equo; 
 Outside the polling station were bundles of legal ballot papers which had been discarded by the Congress I thugs. 
 According to dozens of villagers, journalists, and workers for the opposition candidate, the journalist grandson of Mahatma Gandhi, Mr Rajmohan Gandhi, who is no relation to the incumbent Prime Minister, there have been scores of such incidents in Amethi in systematic attacks that suggest that they have had sanction from higher authority. 
 Mr Jain, the opposition candidate campaign manager and a leading Indian economist, said that gangs of Congress I supporters, sometimes accompanied by non criminals and wearing masks, had attacked polling stations in 70 of the 150 in Amethi and carried away ballot boxes or stuff them with bogus votes. 
 All day long at the Janata Dal officers in Amethi yesterday, Mr Jain and his supporters scrambled to update the list of party workers and activists who were beaten up by Congress I supporters &mdash; many of them in the presence of a senior police officer. 
 At least three people were admitted to hospital. 
 By nightfall Mr Rajmohan Gandhi was calling for repolling throughout the entire constituency. 
 &bquo;This is a critical stage for Indian democracy,&equo; he said in an interview. 
 &bquo;I hope that what is happening here is not happening all over the country. 
 It's disgraceful that Mr Rajiv Gandhi has chosen this path for his exit from power.&equo; 
 Tigre faces starvation. 
 Up to four million Ethiopians in the north may face starvation next year as a result of drought, Peter Biles writes from Nairobi. 
 According to the UN's World Food Programme, twice as many people as originally estimated will need emergency food aid in 1990. 
 &bquo;We're particularly concerned about the situation in Tigre,&equo; the WFP's Director of Operations in Ethiopia, Mr David Morton, said. 
 &bquo;It's become clear that the crop failure there has been far worse than we realised.&equo;. 
 Rebels told to move. 
 Islamabad has told Afghan rebel groups to move arms dumps out of populated areas of north-west Pakistan where a huge explosion killed upto 40 people last week. 
 The order came as rebels announced plans to free two Soviet soldiers captured during the Soviet occupation. 
 -Agencies.. 
 Mandela meeting. 
 Nine South African activists will visit Nelson Mandela next week in the latest talks between the black leader and anti-apartheid campaigners. 
 -Reuter.. 
 Death threats. 
 A French headmaster, Mr Ernest Chenieres, who sparked a controversy by banning Islamic headscarves in the classroom, said yesterday he had received six death threats from Islamic extremists. 
 -Reuter. 
 Right gains in poll. 
 Denmark's far-right anti-tax Progress Party made gains in Tuesday's municipal elections at the expense of the ruling Conservatives. 
 -Reuter. 
 Poachers shot dead. 
 Kenyan wildlife rangers have shot dead six poachers in Meru national park, including the murderers of two French tourists, the Director of Wildlife, Mr Richard Leakey, said yesterday in Nairobi. 
 -Reuter. 
 Corruption triples. 
 China has uncovered 100,000 cases of bribery and corruption this year, triple last year's rate, said the country's top prosecutor, Mr Liu Fuzhi. 
 -AP. 
 Clean-up in Bulgaria. 
 The Bulgarian Communist Party politburo yesterday set up a top-level investigation into corruption under the deposed leader, Mr Todor Zhivkov, and fired his son as head of a party department. 
 -AP. 
 Green Berets walk free from Salvador siege. 
 By Simon Tisdall in Washington 
 THE siege of the Sheraton hotel in San Salvador ended without further bloodshed yesterday after 24 traumatic hours which underscored the difficulties and dangers bedevilling US policy in El Salvador. 
 The Salvadorean Government said the attack on the hotel was a bid to kidnap Mr Joao Baena Soares, secretary-general of the Organisation of American States, who was in the country on a peace mission, but the OAS chief said he did not believe this. 
 Mr Soares left the country on Tuesday evening. 
 Following an apparent deal between guerrillas of the Farabundo Marti National Liberation Front and the Salvadorean army, 12 US Green Beret commandos emerged unscathed from behind barricades in the hotel's VIP annexe. 
 President George Bush said yesterday that a special US anti-terrorist team had been sent to El Salvador on Tuesday but had not been involved in ending the siege. 
 The commandos, who belong to a 55-strong group of US military advisers in El Salvador, had held out on the sixth floor of the annexe during the siege.. 
 The soldiers, carrying pistols and M-16 rifles, got into a pickup truck outside the hotel and were taken to a Salvadorean military installation. 
 Reporters who approached the hotel just after dawn yesterday said there was no sign of the rebels who took over part of the hotel in the exclusive Escalon district of the capital. 
 In Washington, US Administration officials said the soldiers &mdash; members of the elite Green Berets &mdash; feared the rebels had left booby traps behind and waited for Salvadorean troops to work their way to the sixth floor, on which the soldiers were trapped. 
 The guerrillas, who stormed the hotel early on Tuesday morning, trapping 87 guests including the OAU secretary-general had already slipped away before dawn. 
 After the FMLN offensive which began 12 days ago and cost an estimated 1,300 lives, the capital was reported calm yesterday. 
 But many questions remained unanswered. 
 It was unclear why the Green Berets were in the hotel when the guerrillas attacked, whether the luxury hotel was their normal billet, and what their precise mission was supposed to be. 
 Also unclear was whether the commandos had, at one point, opened fire on the invaders, as claimed by the FMLN. 
 Under established rules of engagement, US military personnel in El Salvador may not fire unless fired upon. 
 Mystery also surrounded the status of a British &bquo;military adviser&equo; whom the guerrillas at one point claimed to hold captive. 
 Officially, Britain does not provide advisers to the Salvadoreans. 
 Tuesday's anguish in Washington about what was described as hostage-taking also seems to have been misplaced. 
 As the State Department and the White House both set crisis management operations in train, and President Bush urgently conferred with top officials, FMLN statements &mdash; that the guests, except for the armed Americans, were not hostages and were free to go as soon as a ceasefire was arranged &mdash; were almost ignored. 
 The guests were subsequently safely evacuated, in two groups. 
 The White House seemed unaware that not only were there no hostages, but that the trapped Americans were heavily-armed, elite troops trained to protect themselves in just such circumstances. 
 It fell to Pentagon officials to publicise this crucial information. 
 By that time, however, the President had already ordered the anti-terrorist Delta Force based at Fort Bragg on full alert, amid clear hints of full-scale US military intervention. 
 The US provides more than &dollar;1 million a day to the Salvadorean Government. 
 But by its actions and words on Tuesday, the Administration came close to admitting that its confidence in President Alfredo Cristiani's ability to defeat the FMLN was ill-placed. 
 The guerrillas' unexpected incursion into the exclusive diplomatic quarter of Escalon on Monday night had already shaken US confidence in the Salvadorean army, as had last week's murder of six Jesuit priests by uniformed intruders. 
 Bush pledges US troops will stay in Europe despite changes. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 PRESIDENT Bush last night pledged that US military forces &bquo;will remain in Europe as long as our friends want and need us&equo;, no matter how great the changes in Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union. 
 In his Thanksgiving address, Mr Bush said the US military commitment would stay &bquo;even if forces are significantly reduced on both sides&equo;. 
 He did not give figures for troops and hardware. 
 Mr Bush defended his cautious response to the crumbling of the Berlin Wall. 
 &bquo;A time of historic change is no time for recklessness. 
 The peace, and the confidence and the security of our friends in Europe &mdash; it is just too important,&equo; he said. 
 In a speech almost calculated to reassure Mrs Thatcher as she flies to Washington today, Mr Bush appealed to President Gorbachev: &bquo;America welcomes reform not as an adversary seeking advantage, but as a people offering support.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;Let us move beyond containment, and once and for all end the Cold War.&equo; 
 But he saw Central America as a new stumbling block. 
 He said he would urge Mr Gorbachev to end the arms supply to Nicaragua and, in an escalation of the war of words, Cuba. 
 Mr Bush sounded almost smug when he said the changes in Eastern Europe had come &bquo;because America is strong and 40 years of perseverance and patience are finally paying off&equo;. 
 Thatcher's worries, page 10 
 News in brief: Row over Tory leadership. 
 The &bquo;almost certain&equo; commitment by Sir Anthony Meyer to contest the Tory leadership brought the criticism of party leaders. 
 Page 20. &pound;450m rent arrears. 
 Council tenants' rent arrears have risen to over &pound;450 million, the Audit Commission reveals. 
 Page 2. 
 Siege ends quietly. 
 The Salvador hotel siege ended peacefully when 12 US Green Berets were freed. 
 Page 10. 
 Dispute tension grows. 
 Tension in the ambulance dispute was heightened as management in London published a list of 999 calls it claimed had not been answered. 
 Page 3. 
 Disclosure order. 
 A trade magazine journalist was ordered in the High Court to disclose the source of commercially sensitive information. 
 Page 3. 
 Arts, ReviewsWS24-26. 
 Computer GuardianWS27, 29. 
 Financial NewsWS11, 12, 14. 
 Guardian WomenWS38. 
 Home NewsWS2, 3, 20. 
 International NewsWS8, 10. 
 Law ReportWS39. 
 ListingsWS36, 37. 
 Movie GuardianWS22, 23. 
 ObituaryWS39. 
 PoliticsWS4, 6. 
 Review GuardianWS21. 
 Sports NewsWS15-17. 
 TV, Radio and WeatherWS40 
 Water sale terms &bquo;a giveaway&equo;. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 WATER shares last night soared to a premium of more than 20 per cent on the unofficial &bquo;grey market&equo; as it became clear that the privatisation is set to become the biggest investor give-away since the 1987 Stock Exchange crash. 
 Amid outcry from opposition politicians, ministers yesterday priced water shares in the 10 companies at 240p apiece, valuing the industry at &pound;5.24 billion. 
 Announcing the terms for the December 12 Stock Exchange launch, the water minister, Mr Michael Howard, refused to accept that the Government will face a paper loss of more than &pound;1.3 billion. 
 Mr Howard said this was a &bquo;misleading&equo; way to interpret the figures. 
 The Department of the Environment, however, has previously announced that the cost of preparing the industry for market sell-off by wiping off debt and meeting environmental standards will be around &pound;6.6 billion. 
 With more than 4.3 million people registered for shares, ministers expect that at least one quarter of the entire flotation will be bought by small British investors. 
 If demand is greater than expected more shares can be clawed back from allocations earmarked for institutional and overseas investors. 
 This could give the British public just under half the 2,183 million shares on offer. 
 With the issue priced right at the bottom of market expectations, analysts last night forecast that shares will start trading at a hefty profit. 
 Together with the lower than expected flotation price, the 10 companies have been given an attractive yield averaging as much as 8.55 per cent. 
 But experts warned that any market fall could still jeopardise the first day's trading. 
 The level of shareholders' return varies according to the investment attraction of the various companies &mdash; from 8.10 per cent for highly rated Thames to 9.68 per cent for South West, hit by a series of pollution incidents. 
 IG Index, a firm of &bquo;financial bookmakers&equo;, was last night quoting a grey market price in water shares, showing gains of up to 21 per cent. 
 Best performers were Thames, Southern, Wessex, and Severn Trent. 
 The shadow Environment Secretary, Mr Bryan Gould, maintained water was being sold at a loss. 
 &bquo;Every taxpayer is subsidising an unnecessary sell-off and then paying again when they get their water bill.&equo; 
 The terms were described as &bquo;a barrow-boy price&equo; by the GMB union. 
 In a statement, the union said: &bquo;This will encourage the worst type of speculation. 
 This is a terrible way to treat a vital public service.&equo; 
 Investors will have to apply for a minimum of &pound;240 worth of the shares, with an initial instalment of &pound;100. 
 Applications must be in by December 11. 
 Outlook, and further details, page 11; Leader comment, page 18 
 Tories move to halt Meyer challenge. 
 By Michael White, Chief Political Correspondent 
 THE Conservative Party juggernaut was last night rolling backwards and forwards across the person of Sir Anthony Meyer after he had virtually committed himself to standing against Mrs Thatcher when the annual leadership contest is formally declared open today. 
 Within hours of saying on BBC radio that his candidacy was &bquo;almost certain,&equo; Sir Anthony, MP for Clwyd North-west, was summoned by Mr Cranley Onslow, chairman of the backbenchers' 1922 Committee, who told him not to damage the party at a difficult mid-term juncture. 
 Sir Geoffrey Howe, Deputy Prime Minister and a potential successor, also signalled strong disapproval of what Sir Anthony last night called a challenge to &bquo;a leader who claims infallibility&equo; &mdash; and what some supporters likened to the mass Tory abstention which dislodged Neville Chamberlain in favour of Winston Churchill in 1940. 
 In today's Financial Times, the Conservative chairman, Mr Kenneth Baker, warns that a leadership challenge would be an &bquo;unnecessary and irrelevant distraction&equo;. 
 He comes close to ruling out a general election in 1991, saying: &bquo;I think we have to think in terms of 1992.&equo; 
 Sir Anthony said on the BBC's World at One: &bquo;I almost certainly will challenge her in the first round if no one else comes forward. 
 It's my expectation and my hope that someone much better qualified than I will come forward.&equo; 
 Who that will be he declined to say other than that he would be preferably an ex-minister, &bquo;somebody who has had a reasonably high profile&equo;. 
 The panic which followed Mr Nigel Lawson's departure from the Treasury has subsided, but tremors have been produced this week by tabloid press reports that Mr Nicholas Ridley, the Trade Secretary, regards Mrs Thatcher as a liability, leaving only four solid loyalists in Cabinet &mdash; Mr John Major, Mr David Waddington, Mr Cecil Parkinson and Mr Norman Lamont. 
 Although dissident Conservatives seem disorganised and fragmented, a nervous Conservative Central Office mobilised party chairmen across the country to organise support for the Prime Minister. 
 One rebel said: &bquo;The hounds of the whips&equo; office are unleashed.&equo; 
 No less an eminence than Lord Whitelaw echoed the loyalists' warnings when he invoked an old Willie-ism in appealing for &bquo;a stirring up of apathy as far as gossip, rumour and internal intrigue are concerned.&equo; 
 He told a Westminster press lunch: &bquo;I want to see a Conservative government returned at the next general election under Margaret Thatcher's leadership.&equo; 
 Ministerial jumpiness was further underlined last night when the junior energy minister, Mr Peter Morrison, demanded a public loyalty oath from all minsters. 
 He said in a letter to his Chester constituents that he would vote for Mrs Thatcher and called on constituency chairmen to ask their MPs how they intended to vote. 
 Something between 60 and 100 MPs are eager to clip Mrs Thatcher's wings by staging a show of disaffection or by forcing her into a second round when the first round votes are cast, on December 5 under the most likely timetable. 
 Then, the theory runs, the Meyer stalking horse would bring serious challengers like Mr Michael Heseltine into the race. 
 &bquo;It doesn't matter if the contestant gets one vote. 
 If there are 99 abstentions that is the point,&equo; said one dissident. 
 Last night some Conservatives argued that government whips should demand that Mr Heseltine urge retreat on Sir Anthony, who has said he would like to see the former Defence Secretary and ardent pro-European lead the party. 
 At today's meeting of the 1922 Committee Mr Onslow will declare a leadership election open. 
 That would lead to a quick secret ballot on December 5, just before the Strasbourg summit. 
 The leadership election has been uncontested since 1975. 
 Mrs Thatcher is rated a 1-3 chance by the bookmakers William Hill to lead the Conservatives into the next general election. 
 They offer 2-1 that she will be replaced by then. 
 Politics, pages 4 and 6; Commentary, page 19 
 Kohl insists European union must keep up pace. 
 By John Palmer in Strasbourg 
 THE West German Chancellor, Dr Helmut Kohl, yesterday killed any lingering hopes in Downing Street that the Federal Republic would join Britain in trying to slow the momentum of European union. 
 In an address to the European Parliament here Dr Kohl left no doubt that, at next month's European Community summit, he would support moves to prepare for economic and monetary union. 
 British ministers had assumed that Bonn's preoccupation with the situation in East Germany might lead it to oppose any move to begin drawing up a new treaty for European monetary union. 
 This now seems unlikely. 
 &bquo;Let it be made quite clear that there is no doubt about the position of my government; Germany stands fully behind the Single European Act and its objectives,&equo; Dr Kohl declared. 
 &bquo;We stand behind the destination of European union. 
 For us economic and monetary union is only a station on the way to full European political union.&equo; 
 Dr Kohl said the recent successes of European integration had &bquo;encouraged the process of reform in the states in Central and Eastern Europe&equo;. 
 He added that it would be &bquo;a grave error at this time of all times to remove the momentum for this process&equo;. 
 Yesterday the EC Commissioner for External Affairs, Mr Frans Andriessen, unveiled plans for an 18-nation body comprising the community and the European Free Trade Association to run the new &bquo;European economic space&equo;, which East European countries could join as they reformed. 
 His remarks were seen as a sign that the community accepts that there could be a 20- or even 22-member organisation by the end of the 1990s. 
 Asked whether Britain might opt for membership of this looser body if it rejected progress towards full European union, Mr Andriessen said: &bquo;It is always open to countries to go back to Efta if they wish.&equo; 
 This is bound to be seen as further evidence that Britain risks cutting itself off from the mainstream of European integration because of hostility both to economic and monetary union and to eventual political union. 
 In a separate speech to European Parliamentarians, President Mitterrand said that &bquo;an opening to the East is not in contradiction with but reinforces European unity. 
 We must strengthen the bonds of our union. 
 &bquo;We can do nothing for Eastern Europe if we fail among ourselves in a few days&equo; time to agree on economic and monetary union, social and environmental policies so that we can complete the European single market on time.&equo; 
 Senior West German officials here last night said that the Bonn cabinet had agreed to vote with President Mitterrand and other EC leaders to fix a date before the end of next year for the special conference of EC governments to begin drawing up a new treaty. 
 With the remaining doubters now likely to join the majority, Mrs Thatcher seems certain to end up in a minority of one in opposing the conference. 
 The significance of the conference has been increased by moves this week in the European Parliament to consider changes in the Rome treaty beyond economic and monetary union. 
 There is growing support for giving the European Parliament greater powers as part of an overhaul of all the community's decision-making institutions. 
 Meanwhile, European monetary experts fear that sterling's latest slide will strengthen Mrs Thatcher's determination to delay joining the exchange rate mechanism of the EMS. 
 The most she is expected to do is use slightly more positive words about Britain's aims. 
 Unification link, page 8; Pound sags, page 11; A bloc to do business with, page 19 
 Health changes to cost &pound;217m. 
 By David Brindle, Social Services Correspondent 
 THE Government's shake-up of the National Health Service will add at least &pound;217 million to its annual costs and require 4,000 extra administrators. 
 The official figures were revealed yesterday in the bill setting out the NHS proposals and the legislative changes for the community care white paper proposals, published last week. 
 Health ministers have denied that the market principles to be introduced into the NHS will mean an avalanche of bureaucracy and thousands more accountants. 
 But the health bill admits to a permanent increase, estimated to be 3,000, in the number of specialist staff in hospitals, including finance, personnel and information technology staff. 
 In addition an extra 835 staff will be needed by health and prescription authorities, as well as &bquo;a small increase&equo; in central government staff. 
 The annual costs estimate includes &pound;155 million for a &bquo;strengthening of management at all levels,&equo; &pound;10.5 million to pay members of health authorities, &pound;15.6 million for administering general practitioner budgets, and &pound;3.3 million for computers to monitor drugs spending. 
 The bill says the costs will be outweighed by the benefits of a more efficient NHS. 
 Mr Kenneth Clarke, Health Secretary, promised more government funding, less waste and a better service for patients. 
 He said that far from privatising the health service, he was aiming to &bquo;pose a very real problem for the private sector and serious competition for them&equo;. 
 The British Medical Association said the bill failed to offer people the assurances they wanted. 
 Dr John Marks, BMA president, said: &bquo;The public knows something nasty is going to happen to their health service, and here it is.&equo; 
 The 60-clause health bill contrasted starkly with a second bill of only one clause tabled yesterday on plans for student loans. 
 Its lack of detail provoked considerable protest. 
 Details, page 6 
 Dubcek urges Communist hardliners to stand down. 
 By Michael Simmons in Prague 
 CZECHOSLOVAKIA'S former reformist leader, Mr Alexander Dubcek, yesterday promised to meet anti-government protesters in Prague during the coming days and urged beleaguered Communist leaders to resign. 
 For the third day running, 200,000 or more blocked the centre of Prague, cheering Mr Dubcek's call on the hardline leadership to quit. 
 The demonstrators came despite pelting snow and rumours that tanks and armoured vehicles were lurking on the city outskirts. 
 There were warnings from the capital's Communist Party leader, Mr Miroslav Stepan, that &bquo;armed units&equo; of the People's Militia, the party's paramilitary force, were standing by. 
 Mr Vaclav Havel, the playwright, greeted the rally from the balcony of a newspaper office. 
 He announced to cheers that he had written to Presidents Gorbachev and Bush seeking support for what has been called Prague's polite revolution. 
 He also said he had exchanged messages of support with New Forum in East Germany, Solidarity in Poland, the Democratic Forum in Hungary, Ecoglasnost in Bulgaria, Free Romania and at least two groups in the Soviet Union. 
 The party leadership of Mr Milos Jakes was still clinging to the hope that it could separate &bquo;the workers&equo; from &bquo;the intellectuals&equo;, he said. 
 The People's Militia has been busy ripping down posters put up by the Civic Forum in factories and elsewhere. 
 They may yet have a marginal impact on the projected two-hour general strike, planned for next Monday, but by then it may already be too late to matter. 
 The strike is to last a maximum of two hours. 
 Ambulance workers will be exempt. 
 The stoppage is being organised by factory committees. 
 Mr Jakes will face his toughest test yet when he confronts an emergency meeting of the central committee this week. 
 It is not impossible, in this highly charged atmosphere, that the party leader will be replaced by the weekend. 
 Each demonstration this week has shown an increase in confidence which it will be very difficult to stop. 
 Mr Stepan's references to &bquo;criminalised elements taking advantage of a destabilised situation&equo;, like Mr Jakes's references to &bquo;ruthless manipulators&equo; sound oddly out of date. 
 Yesterday, Mr Dubcek's name was chanted at least as loudly as it was in the same square over 21 years ago. 
 Most of those who shouted &bquo;Long live Dubcek&equo; were not even born in 1968. 
 The old party leader with the enigmatic smile is 67 and has become a person of greater symbolic significance than of real political potential. 
 He appeared in his home town of Bratislava yesterday to attend the staged trial of Mr Jan Czarnogursky for anti-state activities and was greeted by thousands outside the courthouse. 
 No policeman seemed brave enough to bar his way. 
 Thousands of demonstrators turned out in the streets of Bratislava last night in what was said to be the biggest demonstration there in decades. 
 Participants said the city's main square was filled to capacity. 
 Factory workers threatened strikes and voiced solidarity with the striking students, while leading actors and actresses read out lists of demands for greater democracy. 
 Hundreds of television employees said they would strike if prevented from reporting the demonstration. 
 Mr Czarnogursky faces a Turn to page 20, col 3 
 Dubcek urges Communist hardliners to stand down continued from page one possible five-year jail term on charges of sedition in what is being seen as a test case of the regime's genuine commitment to a dialogue with the opposition. 
 Thousands ringed the court building to demand the release of Mr Czarnogursky. 
 There have been several protest meetings in the city every day this week, though not on the scale of the Prague protest. 
 Leading opposition figures in Bratislava say that they would like to see Mr Dubcek return to active, official politics. 
 They suggest that he could become the country's national president in any strongly reformist administration that might emerge. 
 A message from Mr Dubcek to the crowd in Prague, read by the economist who advised him in 1968, called for the resignation of all those in the present leadership who were resposible for the invasion and its aftermath. 
 Mr Jakes, it is not forgotten, purged 600,000 from the 1.5million party and many more from other sensitive positions. 
 Their children are still paying for their parents' &bquo;sins&equo;. 
 Long after the demonstration ended, groups of demonstrators, each of several hundred and some of a few thousand, were dotted about the square, cheering and chanting. 
 The demonstration itself was filmed live by Czechoslovak television &mdash; itself a highly significant breakthrough. 
 Tough realities, page 8; Leader comment, page 18 
 Driver averts tanker disaster. 
 The driver of a 5,000-gallon tanker, Darren Rushton, of Stoke-on-Trent, raced to warn three people in a cafe as burning fuel poured towards them when his vehicle exploded after a collision outside Oldbury oil terminal, West Midlands. 
 They reached safety seconds before the cafe was engulfed in flames. 
 Broadcast warning. 
 Powers claimed by the Home Secretary to intervene over the content of programmes would radically alter the constitution of broadcasting, Mr Anthony Lester, QC, told the Court of Appeal yesterday in winding up an appeal against the High Court refusal to outlaw restrictions on interviews with named groups, including Sinn Fein. 
 Judgment was reserved. 
 Welsh oil spill. 
 Anti-pollution vessels were last night tackling a mile-long oil slick after the 80,000-ton Texaco Westminster and a tug collided at Milford Haven. 
 Council uproar. 
 A Kensington and Chelsea council meeting was suspended and police called last night during uproar over plans to redevelop Portobello Road market when a motion to shelve plans pending consultation was voted down after stall-holders presented an opposition petition. 
 Mothers' campaign. 
 The Pre-School Playgroups Association yesterday launched a nationwide campaign to provide facilities so mothers can return to work. 
 Murder hunt. 
 A murder hunt was launched yesterday after a body, believed to be that of Monica Cantwell, aged 24, from Lingfield, Surrey, was found in New Zealand. 
 Listeria cases increase. 
 The number of listeria cases rose by a quarter in the first six months of this year, Dr Diane Roberts, of the Central Public Health Laboratory, told a London conference yesterday. 
 Help line for pensioners. 
 A group of charities yesterday launched the Winter Warmth Line telephone advice service for pensioners. 
 Doctor to be struck off. 
 London sex therapist Dr Brian Richards, convicted in the US of trying to have his partner killed, was yesterday found guilty of serious professional misconduct by the professional conduct committee of the General Medical Council, who ordered his name struck off. 
 Brown claims that Government has not faced the failures of the present Labour's &bquo;quack&equo; cures will damage patient &mdash; Ridley Queen's speech debate. 
 Paul Nettleton. 
 MR NICHOLAS Ridley defended the absence of any industry bills in the Queen's speech yesterday, saying the strength, success and increased productivity of manufacturers made legislation unnecessary. 
 But his Shadow, Mr Gordon Brown, said the Trade and Industry Secretary had taken his new cabinet post not to complete &bquo;unfinished business&equo;, but to finish the department. 
 Mr Ridley said that manufacturing output was now at a record level &mdash; 12 per cent higher than in 1979, and 6 per cent higher than the previous all-time peak in 1974, and accused Labour politicians of being like &bquo;quack doctors&equo; &mdash; claiming the country was ill and prescribing a cure that in reality would only make the country worse off. 
 Labour's proposed interventionist role for the DTI sounded depressingly familiar. 
 He recalled the Department of Economic Affairs and the National Enterprise Board. 
 &bquo;Where did they leave British industry? 
 Demoralised, shabby and afraid, stifled and battered by government strategies and priorities, and more and more subsidies.&equo; 
 Turning to Europe, Mr Ridley said that the Government was pressing other EC countries to reduce their industrial subsidies, for this was at the heart of a genuine single market after 1992. 
 He said Labour would be denied the opportunity to re-erect the interventionist policies promised in the policy review. 
 &bquo;To do so would run into deep trouble. 
 The European Commission are working for radical cuts leading to abolition of subsidies throughout the Community and we strongly support their efforts. 
 We shall join them in trying to root out open and covert subsidies on the Continent which work against the principle of the single market and which put British firms at a disadvantage.&equo; 
 Mr Brown claimed that the Government had failed to face the failures of the present, let alone the challenges of the future. 
 Mr Ridley should have said he would learn from the failure of a consumer and credit-based boom, end the exclusive reliance on interest rates that so damaged the industries he was supposed to represent. 
 He should ask the Prime Minister to open negotiations to enter the Exchange Rate Mechanism, and ensure a proper balance between consumption and investment to guarantee the long-term future of British industry. 
 Mr Brown added to this list investment in training, research, technology, innovation, and in the regions. 
 He mocked the Trade and Industry Department as &bquo;the department of abandoned responsibilities &mdash; not the business that likes to say yes, but the department that loves to say no.&equo; 
 Deploring Britain's trade deficit, now approaching &pound;20 billion, he said we were now in deficit with 76 countries, including Chile, Peru, East Germany, and Poland. 
 We were in surplus with a few, including Bulgaria, Vatican City and Andorra. 
 &bquo;We are in deficit, unfortunately, with all the major trading nations of the world with the exception of Canada. 
 New products are invented in Britain&hellip; but developed in Germany and Japan, and mass produced in Korea, Singapore and Taiwan.&equo; 
 The Government's response, he said, was to threaten to privatise the Export Credit Guarantee Department, cut support to small firms and cut the availability of export services to many businesses. 
 Mr Brown said Britain had become &bquo;the take-over capital of Europe,&equo; with a government which refused to help companies in trouble from asset strippers and junk-bond take overs. 
 Liberal Democrat spokesman Mr Malcolm Bruce said his party had now been completely vindicated in its opposition to nuclear power. 
 &bquo;Billions of pounds have been squandered that could have been invested in energy conservation and the development of alternatives.&equo; 
 If the Government wanted to have an effective environmental policy, it would have to put up the money. 
 &bquo;It would be nice to know where the greenbacks are that will fulfil the Government's promises,&equo; he said. 
 Labour's new environment spokesman, Mr Bryan Gould, attacked the price of shares in the water privatisation, saying it showed that the Government was prepared to accept on behalf of the taxpayer a loss of at least &pound;1.3 billion in order to sell off the water industry. 
 The Environment Secretary, Mr Chris Patten, said the new green bill would set in place the most sophisticated and comprehensive pollution control regulations anywhere. 
 &bquo;Industry shouldn't be seen as the problem but as a major part of the solution to environmental improvement,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There's a world market of over &pound;100 million a year in clean technology and I want to see British industry winning a much larger share of it.&equo; 
 The debate continues today with home affairs as the main topic. 
 Whitelaw warns on hasty bills. 
 By Alan Travis and Patrick Wintour 
 LORD Whitelaw, the former deputy prime minster, warned yesterday of the danger of producing low-quality acts of parliament by overloading the 15-bill Queen's Speech programme with additional &bquo;instant legislation&equo;. 
 Last year's programme began with 16 bills in the Queen's Speech, but ended with 33 Government measures being enacted. 
 Lord Whitelaw observed that there was greater pressure for bills in recent years, but said ministers had to remember that the quality of the legislation was of the utmost importance. 
 He told a Westminster press gallery lunch that the problem was not the properly prepared Queen's Speech programme of bills, but the demand for instant legislation following a serious event, with ministers being deemed failures if they did not promise a new bill. 
 &bquo;Nobody stops to consider the problems of drafting, or whether the new act of parliament is the best way of dealing with the problem at hand,&equo; he said. 
 The result is a hastily produced bill, heavily amended to correct its mistakes. 
 An example of an &bquo;instant&equo; bill in the last session was the one abolishing the dock labour scheme, which sparked a national dock strike. 
 The other danger arose from Government departments squeezing a small bill into the Queen's Speech: &bquo;They say it is just two or three little clauses and&hellip; it immediately turns out that the process is not nearly as simple as was promised. 
 It leads to ill-informed and ill-prepared new clauses and amendments which&hellip; then have to be amended again.&equo; 
 As if to illustrate Lord Whitelaw's point, an hour later Mr Nicholas Ridley, the Trade and Industry Secretary, announced a bill not contained in the Queen's Speech. 
 It will prevent brewers from evicting publicans in tied houses if they sell one &bquo;guest beer&equo;. 
 Delay over news code of practice. 
 By Georgina Henry Media Correspondent 
 THE simultaneous publication by national newspapers of a common code of practice and declaration of principles was postponed last night after the chairman and editors of Express Newspapers decided that they needed more time to examine the proposals. 
 National newspapers had been expected to publish the declaration, code, and announcement of a system of readers' representatives to take up complaints from the public in today's newspapers. 
 This followed a meeting on Tuesday between editors and representatives of national newspapers, which reached broad agreement on the measures they should take to meet public and parliamentary criticism of the standards of the press. 
 It appeared that other newspapers had been ready to publish the proposals which had been finalised by Mr Andreas Whittam Smith, editor of the Independent, after Tuesday's meeting, which he chaired. 
 Confusion over whether Mr Robert Maxwell, publisher of Mirror Group Newpapers, also had reservations were dismissed by him last night. 
 &bquo;I would sign it immediately. 
 I am waiting for the editor of the Independent to authorise its release,&equo; he said yesterday. 
 &bquo;There are some suggestions I made for changes but this would not prevent me signing it. 
 There is no dissent.&equo; 
 Mr Maxwell said that his alterations &mdash; which he would make for publication in his newspapers &mdash; were to substitute the term ombudsman for readers' representatives and to widen the clause in the code of practice which refers to non-payment of criminals to include those benefiting from a criminal act. 
 He also believed that the proprietor should be the arbitrator of how the proposals operated, but that this would not undermine the role of the Press Council as final arbitrator. 
 &bquo;Anyone who says I won't allow the Press Council to play its proper role is crackers,&equo; he added. 
 Last night Mr Nick Lloyd, editor of the Daily Express, who had not been present at Tuesday's meeting, said that the editors of Express Newspapers &mdash; the Daily and Sunday Express and the Star &mdash; and the publisher, Lord Stevens, had not had time to look closely at the proposals. 
 They would be meeting today to consider them. 
 &bquo;What's the rush? 
 We don't want to leap into this without being totally sure that every point is acceptable,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There is no reason why these proposals should be published this week or even next week, although obviously it would be sensible to publish them soon.&equo; 
 This did not mean that he and his colleagues were opposed to the plan. 
 &bquo;But we just want to think it through. 
 The first I knew about the plan to publish it in the newspapers tomorrow was a fax at midday today.&equo; 
 Cash offer to HIV haemophiliacs. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 THE Government is expected today to announce extra money for the 1,200 haemophiliacs infected with the HIV virus as a result of contaminated blood transfusions. 
 A delegation of five Conservative MPs yesterday met the Prime Minister and left Downing Street convinced they had made &bquo;enormous progress&equo; in persuading Mrs Thatcher to make a one-off ex-gratia payment to the victims. 
 Although the parliamentary campaign, backed by 350 MPs of all parties, originally asked for &pound;100 million to help the victims, the demands have been scaled down. 
 The MPs who saw Mrs Thatcher for half an hour were yesterday talking in terms of &pound;20 million to &pound;30 million being made available. 
 &bquo;If we get a figure of that magnitude it will be a substantial victory,&equo; said Mr John Hannam, chairman of the all-party disablement group, and MP for Exeter. 
 &bquo;I am just so relieved we are on the verge of getting a much more sensible system of payment to them after all this time.&equo; 
 Miss Emma Nicholson, MP for Devon West, a member of the delegation, said that would work out at about &pound;20,000 for each victim. 
 The Government up to now has ruled out direct compensation for the 1,200 haemophiliacs, 200 of whom are children. 
 So far 102 people have died. 
 The Government did give a &pound;10 million grant to the McFarlane charitable trust to meet the health and domestic needs of the victims. 
 So far &pound;1 million has been paid out on the basis of need. 
 The money announced today would be a one-off payment made automatically to the victims which would not imply any acceptance of liability on the part of the Government. 
 &bquo;This does not affect any claims for compensation. 
 Each person must be free to pursue their own case,&equo; said Miss Nicholson. 
 Action &bquo;soon&equo; on boat people Lords debate. 
 Martin Linton. 
 THE Government will soon have to tackle the thorny question of the &bquo;involuntary repatriation&equo; of Vietnamese boat people, Lord Brabazon of Tara, the Foreign Office Minister of State, told the House of Lords yesterday. 
 The 57,000 boat people in Hong Kong are taxing the colony's resources and nearly 90 per cent of new arrivals are unlikely to qualify as refugees, he said in the second day's debate on the Queen's speech. 
 &bquo;Unless action is taken more will continue to arrive &mdash; to be wretched and disappointed in their turn. 
 The only humane solution is for those who are not genuine refugees to return to Vietnam,&equo; he added. 
 In a wide-ranging foreign affairs debate he reaffirmed the Government's &bquo;total rejection of the Khmer Rouge&equo; and announced humanitarian aid for Cambodia and a visit by British officials to Phnom Penh. 
 He welcomed the rapid changes taking place in Eastern Europe but said Britain still needed a strong and united Nato. 
 &bquo;We must also avoid offering any challenge to legitimate Soviet security interests,&equo; he said. 
 Lord Cledwyn, the Opposition leader in the Lords, warned that destabilisation of Warsaw Pact countries might see history repeating itself in the balkanisation of Eastern Europe and in ethnic and territorial disputes. 
 Britain should pursue disarmament negotiations with greater urgency and greater hope of success. 
 There was a case now for adding short-range nuclear weapons to the agenda, he said. 
 For the Liberal Democrats, Lord Bonham Carter agreed that Britain's response to events must not appear to threaten the security of the Soviet Union or attempt to dissolve the Warsaw Pact. 
 Lord Home, the former Conservative prime minister, said if Mr Gorbachev's reforms were to show results, an enormous programme of reconstruction on the scale of the Marshall Plan after the second world war would be required. 
 That would be much more likely if Mr Gorbachev could reduce his conventional forces and weaponry in the Warsaw Pact. 
 Lord Callaghan, the former Labour prime minister, called for an all-European conference through a revival of the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Helsinki in 1973-1977 which could mark the beginning of what he called &bquo;a new Concert of Europe&equo; setting a new political framework. 
 Violence and poll-rigging mar Indian election Indian election. 
 Derek Brown and Ajoy Bose in Faridabad, Haryana. 
 NEARLY half a billion Indian voters yesterday started to choose their next government, in a general election clouded by violence and charges of poll-rigging. 
 At least 37 deaths were reported on the first of three days of polling. 
 Many of the killings were in Haryana, where rival groups fought with guns and stones. 
 There were also several incidents in the same state of booth-capturing: gangs of thugs taking over polling stations and stuffing the ballot box with votes for their favoured candidates. 
 In Amethi, the constituency of the Prime Minister, Mr Rajiv Gandhi, in the next state of Uttar Pradesh, his main opponent demanded a second poll in one area. 
 Mr Rajmohan Gandhi (no relation to the Prime Minister), a grandson of Mahatma Gandhi and candidate for the opposition Janata Dal party, accused the police of helping the ruling Congress party to intimidate voters. 
 Mr Rajmohan Gandhi made his demand after another leading Janata Dal politician, Mr Sanjay Singh, was shot and wounded in Amethi. 
 Last night, national officials of Janata Dal backed the call for the Amethi election to be declared void. 
 They also demanded a second poll in the East Delhi constituency, where they alleged &bquo;massive poll-rigging and booth-capturing&equo; by Congress. 
 The charges and the violence were far from one-sided. 
 In Congress-ruled Gujarat, on the west coast, the state Health Minister, Mr Vallabhbhai was attacked at a meeting on Tuesday and died yesterday in hospital. 
 In Haryana, the worst affected constituency, Bhiwani, saw pitched battles between Congress and opposition supporters which left three dead and scores injured. 
 The opposition candidate, Mr Dharam Vir, was charged yesterday with the murder of a Congress worker. 
 Elsewhere in the state, two women were killed by gunfire. 
 In the southern district of Faridabad there were visible pockets of tension, in spite of a strong presence of police and paramilitary forces. 
 After one outbreak of fighting, the main road running through the village of Rewasan was littered with bricks and stones. 
 Mr Abdul Rehman, the local polling agent for Janata Dal, told how his supporters had been attacked by a marauding band of Congress workers, some of them with guns. 
 &bquo;We were outnumbered, but we threw stones back at them and drove them away,&equo; he said. 
 The lone, unarmed, constable on guard could only close the polling station. 
 Five hours later, when police reinforcements finally arrived, the booth was still firmly closed. 
 Only 120 of the 820 electors had been able to vote. 
 Incidents of ballot-stuffing were reported from all over India. 
 It is now up to the Election Commission to decide whether the frauds will, in effect, cancel each other out, or whether new polls should be ordered. 
 In spite of the sporadic violence and cries of foul, polling was largely orderly. 
 A moderate to heavy turnout was reported from the 15 states and six union territories which voted yesterday. 
 The rest of India will vote tomorrow or Sunday. 
 Dusty answers, page 10 
 NEC approves strategy plan. 
 By Patrick Wintour 
 THE Labour Party National Executive yesterday endorsed a campaigning strategy for the next year in which the party will seek to popularise its policy review while focusing its opposition to the Government on health, the economy, the poll tax, teacher shortages, and transport. 
 The NEC heard details of research showing the party had won the trust of the public on the economy, but still needed a clearer positive identity. 
 A paper by Mr Peter Mandelson, the party's Director of Communications, said that the economy, industry and developments in Europe were likely to form the election battle ground. 
 The NEC refused to endorse Mr Brian Green as candidate for St Helens South in place of Mr Gerry Bermingham the sitting MP. 
 By Patrick Wintour 
 THE Labour Party National Executive yesterday endorsed a campaigning strategy for the next year in which the party will seek to popularise its policy review while focusing its opposition to the Government on health, the economy, the poll tax, teacher shortages, and transport. 
 The NEC heard details of research showing the party had won the trust of the public on the economy, but still needed a clearer positive identity. 
 A paper by Mr Peter Mandelson, the party's Director of Communications, said that the economy, industry and developments in Europe were likely to form the election battle ground. 
 The NEC refused to endorse Mr Brian Green as candidate for St Helens South in place of Mr Gerry Bermingham the sitting MP. 
 President dies in car bomb blast after only 17 days in office Arab League close to despair Lebanon leader killed. 
 By David Hirst in Jerusalem 
 LEBANON'S new president, Mr Rene Muawad, died yesterday in a huge car-bomb explosion after 17 days in office. 
 It is a devastating blow to the latest Arab League peace plan, which &mdash; with parliament's adoption of political and constitutional reforms and the election of the new president &mdash; had come to embody perhaps the most serious attempt of its kind to end the 14 &frac12;-year war. 
 &bquo;Where do we turn now?&equo; an official at the Tunis headquarters of the Arab League asked. 
 &bquo;It's a tragedy. 
 Whenever we take one step forward, we take five steps back,&equo; said another. 
 However, Lebanese observers say this blow is unlikely to lead to an immediate resumption of the war between the Christian leader, General Michel Aoun, and the Syrians and their Lebanese Muslim allies. 
 More likely, for the time being, is a return to political and constitutional deadlock &mdash; though with full and final partition of the fragmented country looming larger than ever. 
 A car rigged with an estimated 330lbs of explosive ripped through Muawad's motorcade as it passed through the Sanaya district of the predominantly Muslim West Beirut. 
 Unable to take up residence in the Baabda palace occupied by Gen Aoun, this was where he had been conducting his consultations for the formation of a government of national unity. 
 Twenty-three people were killed, including several Syrian and Lebanese soldiers. 
 Mangled remains were hurled 500 yards down the road. 
 Amidst scenes of carnage it was more than two hours before Muawad's death was officially announced. 
 A police officer said his corpse was so charred and mutilated that it took more than an hour to identify it. 
 Announcing the assassination, the Prime Minister, Mr Salim al-Hoss, levelled no specific accusation. 
 &bquo;Let the criminal know,&equo; he said, &bquo;that hands can assassinate a great soul like that of the martyr, Muawad, but they cannot assassinate the enormous national faith which Muawad brought to the presidency.&equo; 
 Inevitably Gen Aoun is the culprit as far as Syria is concerned. 
 &bquo;This ugly crime against the Lebanon and its legitimacy followed a series of threats by the rebellious officer,&equo; the official Syrian news agency said. 
 But it is always unwise to jump to conclusions about Lebanese atrocities. 
 This one does seem to be a great boost to Gen Aoun, who stood in lonely defiance of the Arab and international communities, his Muslim compatriots, and many in his own Maronite enclave. 
 His interim military cabinet said it held an emergency meeting &bquo;to examine initial information about the ugly crime&equo;. 
 &bquo;The cabinet expresses its deep regret for the assassination of one of north Lebanon's most distinguished leaders.&equo; 
 Some Lebanese argue that Gen Aoun's Syrian adversaries could benefit from the assassination. 
 Hardly had Muawad been elected than they detected signs that the Syrians were less than eager to give him the support he needed to impose his authority on the whole country. 
 There is a theory that the Syrians favour the perpetuation of the Aoun regime to give them a pretext for keeping an undiminished presence in the country. 
 The assassination may only have accelerated the inexorable drift towards partition. 
 For even before it, the new president's attempts to form a government of national unity had been faltering, thanks mainly to Gen Aoun's opposition. 
 But now all those Arab and Western powers that had invested such hopes in the plan will find it hard to sustain even a pretence that it remains a realistic proposal. 
 Only three days ago the American ambassador to Lebanon &mdash; who had evacuated his embassy, situated in Gen Aoun's enclave, last September &mdash; paid a one-day visit from Washington to the Syrian-controlled north Lebanon to present his credentials to the new president. 
 The ambassador called his election &bquo;the most important&equo; achievement of the Lebanon's long ordeal. 
 &bquo;It seems to us that like great ships you are in fact approaching the end of the storm.&equo; 
 He expressed surprise that the Lebanese Forces militia, Gen Aoun's ally, had not thrown its weight behind the new regime. 
 East Beirut officials and press called that a flagrant interference in the Lebanon's affairs, which could only strengthen Gen Aoun. 
 Among the Arabs, Saudi Arabia, which had invested great prestige in the plan, has suffered the biggest setback. 
 Arab peacemakers will presumably seek to find a successor to Muawad. 
 The Algerian foreign minister has said that the swift election of a successor would &bquo;show those who oppose national harmony that their enterprise is bound to fail&equo;. 
 But with the process of assembling Lebanon's surviving deputies so difficult last time, a repeat performance seems impossible. 
 Christian leaders who had been thinking of it have been backing off. 
 Fear of meeting Muawad's fate will surely diminish any would-be successor's ambition. 
 Syrians blame Aoun, page 10; Obituary, page 39 
 COMMENT THE GUARDIAN Thursday November 23 1989 A great bet in a big bucket. 
 YESTERDAY's water privatisation is the taxpayer's bequest to the share punter. 
 And generous to a fault. 
 The Government is offering shares to investors at 240p each, which values the industry at &pound;5.24 billion. 
 But since it has already written off &pound;5 billion worth of debts and thrown in an extra &pound;1.6 billion &bquo;green dowry&equo;, that means that the entire industry &mdash; with thousands of miles of pipework, reservoirs, leisure land, sewage works and so forth &mdash; is being given away for minus &pound;1.4 billion. 
 The shares are extremely good value for investors, short of a stock market apocalypse. 
 They offer (for a safe monopoly) a very attractive average yield of 8.5 per cent, with scope for capital appreciation and perks (one free share for 10) for those investing in their local company. 
 Since only a part of the purchase price has to be put down now, this represents a likely return on capital of over 20 per cent in the first year. 
 This is not the proverbial free lunch. 
 It is a massive redistribution of wealth from one owner (the Government, on behalf of everyone in the country) to a much narrower segment of the population (the 4 to 5 million likely to take up the offer) who will be able to buy the assets at a discount. 
 The losers are those who, for reasons of poverty or principle, decline to partake. 
 In financial terms the sale will be justified if private sector ownership improves efficiency by more than the huge point-of-sale loss to the Government plus the &pound;175 million or so privatisation costs. 
 That will be an uphill battle, and difficult to prove anyway, because the industry under private ownership needs to earn a higher return on capital &mdash; by several percentage points &mdash; than in public ownership to attract shareholders. 
 So it has to improve its efficiency by a considerable amount just to stand still. 
 And in any case the main gains to efficiency will come not from privatisation, but from the legal necessity imposed by the EC (which would have happened anyway) to invest &pound;25 billion over 10 years to bring water up to drinkable standards. 
 Anyone who can separate the gains from the &bquo;dynamics&equo; of privatisation from those arising from capital investment or the companies' success in manipulating the pricing formula will deserve free water for life. 
 However, whether necessary or not, privatisation must be made to work. 
 Water is a precious commodity too long taken for granted in the West. 
 All the fresh water in the world's lakes and streams represents barely 0.01 per cent of the earth's total store of water, which is mainly saline. 
 It is a shrinking resource badly distributed around the earth's crust, as yesterday's warning of a continuing severe shortage in the south of England reminds us. 
 As well as generators of rising dividends, the new water companies are custodians of one of the most vital resources on earth. 
 They must never be allowed to forget that.. 
 Prague promises. 
 THERE WILL be no massacre; there will be no martial law. 
 Yesterday the Czech demonstrators were anxiously weighing Tuesday's assurance from Prime Minister Vladislav Adamec against the indications of an unresolved struggle within the leadership. 
 The Beijing massacre, after all, was preceded by just such a struggle. 
 For entirely practical reasons, Mr Adamec's view ought to prevail. 
 Most of the Czech Politburo consists of people who were &bquo;voted in by tanks&equo; in 1968. 
 A few days ago they were handed the Moscow black spot in the form of an invitation to reconsider history. 
 An island of Czech reaction cannot survive among its metamorphosed neighbours for more than a geopolitical instant. 
 The struggle has been between the Czech people and the security apparatus behind the Communist party. 
 If the army could not do the job unaided twenty years ago, it is even less likely to get involved now. 
 The Brezhnev Doctrine is dead: long live the Gorbachev Doctrine of the Soviet Union as just another European power, only bigger, which lets its neighbours go their own way. 
 It is all happening too fast for us to take anything quite for granted, neither becoming blase about the sight of ossified regimes crumbling at the knees, nor entirely ruling out the thought of some treacherous counter-current. 
 But we are very close now to the critical turning-point after which the political scene in Prague could be as rapidly transformed as among its neighbours. 
 If the leading dissident Mr Vaclev Havel is right, the current power struggle is not whether to resist change but who should succeed Mr Milos Jakes. 
 And with the force of example elsewhere, can the party will maintain its primacy for long? 
 The lingering conventional truths &mdash; that the Czech economy would be strong enough to cushion dissent, that the opposition does not have a sufficiently coherent voice &mdash; already look thin. 
 Mr Havel's Civic Forum may be some way behind East Germany's New Forum, but it can draw upon a reservoir of informally networked dissent which dates back more than a decade. 
 And if the miners of northern Bavaria do respond to the strike call for next Monday, the regime's social contract with them will be shattered. 
 As the tide sweeps on, the sight of President Ceausescu being applauded 67 times at his party congress &mdash; while Mrs Ceausescu sat in grim solitude &mdash; only highlights the increasingly anachronistic character of this European North Korea. 
 In Bucharest as in Pyongyang, it may well be that severe repression can in the first instance only be challenged by a well-aimed bullet. 
 But once the West no longer needed Mr Ceausescu's anti-Soviet services, his policy of deliberate isolation narrowed his options and led earlier this year to the first signs of internal party dissent. 
 Retracing the route from Berlin to Beijing &mdash; for let us not forget where people's power first flourished this year - we find a even more isolated regime with yet fewer options. 
 How long can it remain immune as the voices echo back from Eastern Europe?. 
 One loan clause. 
 MR CEAUCESCU, meanwhile, may have changed address. 
 He seems to be living in the Department of Education. 
 Yesterday the Department issued its student loans bill. 
 And how long was this measure, designed to embrace the principles of 48 pages of white paper and some 68 pages of analysis in two specially-commissioned Price Waterhouse reports? 
 Just four clauses. 
 Even that is a fourfold exaggeration of length. 
 There is only a solitary enabling clause. 
 As Jack Straw, the Labour Education spokesman, noted yesterday, this would be a constitutional outrage even in Romania. 
 How on earth does Parliament scrutinise an Act with only one clause? 
 No way. 
 What is the Government up to? 
 Alas, it is flying by the seat of its pants. 
 This student loans scheme has degenerated into open shambles. 
 That it would be unpopular with students or colleges was obvious. 
 But HMG totally underestimated the coolness of the banks. 
 From the beginning, they have been collectively unconvinced of the commercial value of the plan. 
 Three have already refused to take part. 
 With students threatening to run a Barclays-style boycott against any that participate, stand by for more to pull out. 
 Students are regarded by the banks as the ripest harvest of all: the people who will be earning the highest balances in the future and who are likely to stay loyal for life once signed up. 
 Why start on the wrong foot as collaborators in unpopular and spatchcock loans? 
 The best thing that could happen now would be for the scheme to be killed by another backbench Tory revolt, like the rebellion which quashed Sir Keith Joseph's 1985 effort to make student fees income-related. 
 There is the same motivation. 
 The new scheme will certainly hurt middle-income parents, with the present level of grant frozen until loans (or a combination of loans and parental contributions) make up 50 per cent of student finance. 
 But it will cause even more damage to low income parents, the very homes from which ministers had hoped to attract more students to achieve their target of doubling the proportion of children going to college by 2014. 
 This is simply perverse. 
 Only eight per cent of children from low income families (in the Registrar General's social classes four and five) go to university, even though they are guaranteed a free education through a full grant plus social security. 
 Now they are to lose their income support and housing benefit and allowed to borrow &pound;420 a year at inflation-rate interest. 
 Some incentive. 
 It can only reduce student numbers and make our education system more unequal. 
 It should shrivel in ineptitude.. 
 Prime target. 
 ONE Stalkinghorse cantered to the starting gate yesterday; though, in the most congenial of mixed metaphors, Sir Anthony Meyer prefers to call himself a &bquo;burnt offering.&equo; 
 He'll stand against Mrs Thatcher for the Tory leadership next month unless somebody else (Stalkinghorse 2; a medium rare slice of rump) slips out of the deep freeze paddock. 
 And that should now happen. 
 Sir Anthony is a disenchanted maverick of a wet and is not best placed to present a fair test of backbench opinion. 
 No chance of a Stalkinghorse winning, but a nag from the heart of the party, who manifests &mdash; in votes and abstentions &mdash; the coronary palpitations of the 1922 Committee, is called for. 
 The unease is not secret. 
 The issues are mostly in the open. 
 The fears of a dominant personality, away from the core of traditional values, driving the enterprise on to the electoral rocks, are manifest in speeches and in countless polls of public opinion. 
 And there is an obvious point of principle. 
 The Conservative Party has a fixed framework for the election of leaders. 
 The Party, and its current Leader, firmly believe in such elections. 
 (If they didn't, Mr Edward Heath would be a much happier man.) 
 Further, the Leader herself has spent many toiling hours of late calling on the peoples of Eastern Europe to hold elections and thereby demonstrate their attachment to the fundamentals of democracy. 
 What is sauce for Egon Krenz is just as much sauce for Mrs Margaret Thatcher. 
 Of course, a vote is all very tedious, and will be ritually accompanied by the most ferocious pressures upon this beleaguered electoral college. 
 Conservative MPs who know what a party election is like do not relish the sheer nastiness that accompanies it. 
 But the fury and the knife-work should be constrained. 
 Sir Anthony, boldly, with little to lose, is willing to provide a focal point for discussion and decision on absolutely legitimate matters of political concern. 
 He modestly and realistically hopes a better candidate can be found. 
 But he thinks, in present circumstances, that a straightforward test provides the best way of clearing the air. 
 That is the democratic way; and an embarrassed Conservative hierarchy should never forget it. 
 Letters to the Editor 
 Education teaches students how to manage their overdraft. 
 By David Ward, Northern Education Correspondent With pix by Denis Thorpe &bquo;M. 
 OST students don't wake up till they are half way through the second year,&equo; said Paul Davies with the weary air of a man staring post-graduation penury in the face. 
 Paul, a third-year English student at Manchester Polytechnic, clearly despairs of his younger colleagues who leave home intent on making whoopee on a grant; he knows that it is almost inevitable that they will run smack into debt midway through their courses. 
 One floor down in the poly union's Mandela building, it was all studied unconcern. 
 &bquo;I've got through my grant plus &pound;500 of my savings this term,&equo; bragged Chris Singh, a first-year communications and media student with no regrets. 
 Who needs a loan when you can top up your income by despatch-riding in London at Christmas? 
 Look at it this way, said Chris's friend, Richard Lees. 
 Students should expect the Government to meet living costs, but not to cough up for the extra beer and nightclubbing which Richard regards as an important part of student life. 
 &bquo;If you're not seen to go out a lot, you're a failure,&equo; he said. 
 Mike Carter is another solvent fresher: &bquo;It's so cheap here,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The price of taxis and night clubs is astronomical in London.&equo; 
 Loans seem irrelevant to him. 
 Okay, so his grant will be pegged at its 1990 level; but he can't see himself borrowing from the loan scheme introduced by the Government through the major banks. 
 He'll make do with his interest-free &pound;250 overdraft from the listening bank. 
 But would he, out of solidarity with students opposed to loans, switch his account? 
 &bquo;If I get the same deal as I'm getting now, I'll stick with the Midland,&equo; he said. 
 Chris Singh thought he might be tempted to borrow. 
 &bquo;If I can take out a &pound;420 loan and have ten years to pay it back, I'll just pick up the cheque and go out and get ratted,&equo; he said. 
 Back upstairs, Paul Davies and his third-year colleagues, Patrick Quigley (history) and Geoff Smith (English) were in despair over their finances. 
 Paul's bank now allows him &pound;35 a week, and Geoff can withdraw no more than &pound;40. 
 Patrick is allowed enough to cover his weekly rent and no more &mdash; so he works in Safeway for 16 hours a week. 
 &bquo;I can't sleep at night because I'm worried: both about getting behind with my work, and about bouncing cheques,&equo; he said. 
 All three say the banks already have too much influence over students' lives, and that loans will strengthen the hold. 
 &bquo;I saw my bank manager at the end of last year and she asked me why I was spending so much on food. 
 I told her I was a big chap,&equo; said Geoff (height &mdash; 6ft 2inch). 
 &bquo;She told me I should find a rich girlfriend. 
 What kind of advice is that?&equo; 
 Geoff spent the summer on a building site and will be back there as soon as finals are over. 
 It's the only certain way to pay off an overdraft which he expects by then to have topped &pound;1,000. 
 He and his colleagues are convinced that loans will effect students' choice of courses. 
 &bquo;The three of us are doing non-vocational courses,&equo; said Patrick. 
 &bquo;If students are going to be landed with a debt at the end of three years, they are going to choose vocational courses so that they can be certain of getting a job when they graduate and so pay off the loan.&equo; 
 &bquo;The emphasis in working-class families will be on sons and daughters getting a career,&equo; added Paul Davies, &bquo;and that means courses like English will be left to students from middle-class families.&equo; 
 Loans find no favour with Paul Scriven, president of the student union at Manchester Polytechnic, Britain's biggest. 
 &bquo;We are spearheading a campaign here,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I have written to the chairmen of all the big banks to tell them that we will run a campaign to urge all students to boycott all banks which take part in the loans scheme. 
 We also have to argue what loans will mean for higher education. 
 Robbins said that access should be based on intellectual ability, not on students&equo; ability to pay. 
 &bquo;We are arguing not just for ourselves, but also for our younger brothers and sisters &mdash; and perhaps our own children.&equo; 
 THE Tory MP Mr David Tredinnick (Bosworth) provoked fury from the Liberal Democrats during the Queen's speech debate when he accused them of &bquo;doughnutting&equo; &mdash; sitting in a tight circle around their spokesman in order to give the impression on television that the Commons was full. 
 Thirteen of the 19 Liberal Democrat MPs were in the chamber &mdash; outnumbering both Tory and Labour MPs &mdash; and half of them had come in just to get on the cameras, he said. 
 MPs who had been waiting since the start of the debate didn't take kindly to &bquo;camera fodder&equo; coming in. 
 But the Liberal Democrats protested that their front bench spokesman had had to wait nearly five hours to be called by the Speaker instead of being called at the start of the debate like the Government and Opposition. 
 The former Liberal leader Mr David Steel said it was normal for MPs to support their party spokesman by coming into the chamber during his speech. 
 &bquo;It is nothing whatever to do with the cameras which are in any case not allowed to pan along the benches.&equo; 
 Water industry sale terms &bquo;an investor giveaway&equo;. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 WATER shares last night soared to a premium of more than 20 per cent on the unofficial &bquo;grey market&equo; as it became clear that the privatisation is set to become the biggest investor give-away since the 1987 Stock Exchange crash. 
 Amid outcry from opposition politicians, ministers yesterday priced water shares in the 10 companies at 240p apiece, valuing the industry at &pound;5.24 billion. 
 Announcing the terms for the December 12 Stock Exchange launch, the water minister, Mr Michael Howard, refused to accept that the Government will face a paper loss of more than &pound;1.3 billion on the sell-off. 
 Mr Howard said this was a &bquo;misleading&equo; way to interpret the figures. 
 The Department of the Environment, however, has previously announced that the cost of preparing the industry for market sell-off by wiping off debt and meeting environmental standards will be around &pound;6.6 billion. 
 With more than 4.3 million people registered for shares, ministers expect that at least one quarter of the entire flotation will be bought by small British investors. 
 If demand is greater than expected more shares can be clawed back from allocations earmarked for institutional and overseas investors. 
 This could give the British public just under half the 2,183 million shares on offer. 
 With the issue priced right at the bottom of market expectations, analysts last night forecast that shares will start trading at a hefty profit. 
 Together with the lower than expected flotation price, the 10 companies have been given an attractive yield averaging as much as 8.55 per cent. 
 But experts warned that any market fall could still jeopardise the first day's trading. 
 The level of shareholders' return varies according to the investment attraction of the various companies &mdash; from 8.10 per cent for highly rated Thames to 9.68 per cent for South West, hit by a series of pollution incidents. 
 I G Index, a firm of &bquo;financial bookmakers,&equo; was last night quoting a grey market price in water shares, showing gains of up to 21 per cent. 
 Best performers were Thames, Southern, Wessex, and Severn Trent. 
 The shadow Environment Secretary, Mr Bryan Gould, maintained water was being sold at a loss. 
 &bquo;Every taxpayer is subsidising an unnecessary sell-off and then paying again when they get their water bill.&equo; 
 Flotation terms were described as &bquo;a barrow-boy price&equo; by the GMB union yesterday. 
 In a statement, the union said: &bquo;This will encourage the worst type of speculation. 
 This is a terrible way to treat a vital public service. 
 The most likely outcome is that small investors will sell their shares very quickly, and the City institutions will mop up&equo;. 
 Labour's water spokeswoman, Mrs Ann Taylor, also condemned the sell-off terms. 
 &bquo;The Government is obviously extremely worried that they will not be able to sell these shares.&equo; 
 The industry could also be hit by changes in European Commission pollution legislation, she said. 
 Flotation advisers revealed that investors will be able to apply for a minimum of &pound;240 worth of the shares, with an initial instalment of &pound;100. 
 Application forms must be in by Monday December 11. 
 Outlook, and further details, page 11; Leader comment, page 18 
 Pig drug faces US cancer ban. 
 By James Erlichman, Consumer Affairs Correspondent 
 ADRUG widely fed to British pigs, and often found in pork in shops, faces a ban by American health authorities because it is suspected of causing cancer. 
 The drug, sulphadimidine, a prescription antibiotic used to control epidemics of respiratory disease in closely packed pig units, has been heavily and widely misused by UK farmers. 
 But Mr Keith Meldrum, the Government's chief veterinary officer, said yesterday that there were no plans to ban farm use of sulphadimidine in the UK. 
 Efforts to reduce residues in pork products had been partially successful, and government scientists had studied and discounted US cancer concerns. 
 The US Food and Drug Administration announced earlier this month that it was likely to initiate a ban against farm use of the antibiotic &mdash; known as sulfamethazine in the US &mdash; because two laboratory studies linked it to thyroid cancer in rats and mice. 
 Residues of the antibiotic have been an apparent problem in UK farming for years. 
 Pig producers receive no EC subsidies, and depressed pork and bacon prices have meant some farmers have fallen into drug misuse to keep animals alive long enough to reach slaughter weight. 
 The Ministry of Agriculture's latest published studies show that more than a quarter of pig kidneys sampled in 1985 had residues of sulphadimidine at average levels 11 times higher than the Government's safety limits. 
 Mr Meldrum said that an education campaign among farmers had reduced the problem. 
 One sample in seven contained residues in 1986 and the level had fallen to one sample in 20 in the first eight months of this year. 
 The biggest problem has been the failure of farmers to stick to the requirement to withdraw the drug at least 10 days before pigs are slaughtered. 
 Residues in meat may also cause allergic reactions in sensitive people. 
 The alleged cancer risk found in the American studies was re-examined and rejected by the Committee on Toxicity, a panel of scientists who work jointly for the Ministry of Agriculture and the Department of Health. 
 Professor Richard Lacey, the Leeds University microbiologist who has been an outspoken critic of the Government on many food hygiene issues, also believes that sulphadimidine residues present little if any risk to consumers. 
 &bquo;It is a drug used in medicine since 1935 and its serious side-effects are rare even when it is prescribed at high concentrations for long periods. 
 Either there is no cancer risk, or it is very small.&equo; 
 But Dr Alan Long, an organic chemist who is research officer of the Vegetarian Society, said: &bquo;Sulphadimidine fed to pigs is made to a cheaper and less pure commerical grade, which is not identical to the human drug.&equo; 
 Fighting to be god of the machine Commentary. 
 By Hugo Young 
 THE FINAL stage of television's take-over of British politics opens in the shadow of a paradox. 
 Television will infiltrate into the national consciousness even more copiously than is already the case the personalities of the two main party leaders. 
 Presidentialism will obtrude ever further into this supposedly parliamentary system, mitigated only by rare and welcome sightings of MPs never before displayed on the box. 
 And yet this is happening at a moment when the leaders in question stand exceptionally low in public esteem. 
 Each is in the same, painful fix. 
 Both Mrs Thatcher and Mr Kinnock are widely perceived to be liabilities to their parties. 
 More and more Conservatives, in and out of the House, are coming to believe that their chances at the election would be stronger under a different leader. 
 Fewer and fewer Labour people can any longer distract themselves from the common assertion that Mr Kinnock is surrounded by men who are more able and winning than he is. 
 Yet these are the two characters upon whom television will now confer a new and exalted benediction. 
 The television experiment will, among other things, be another interesting test of the medium's power to change existing reality. 
 It already seems obvious that Mr Kinnock will be the earliest beneficiary, and this for a simple reason. 
 It has little to do with the quality of his jokes or the televisual cut of his suiting, although adequate performance here is important. 
 What matters is that the Labour leader is suddenly there, reminding one how infrequently he has been there hitherto. 
 Compared with the Prime Minister, Mr Kinnock is hardly ever on the screen. 
 No law of equal time exists to ensure that he appears at as many international summits as she does. 
 I guess that over the last six years television has given him only a quarter of her exposure. 
 But in the House of Commons, equality suddenly descends. 
 Here is this man, never previously seen doing his public duty, always seen merely roaring at the Labour Party or being interviewed like any tuppeny-ha'penny minister, now occupying the despatch-box which is the only site that gives credibility to his claim to be a prime-minister-in-waiting. 
 At last Mr Kinnock achieves some formal stature, to match the fact that he will indisputably remain where he is. 
 Mrs Thatcher, on the other hand, gains little. 
 Arguably, she is already on the screen so much that further appearances only supplement the passionate irritation which she provokes even among those who have voted for her. 
 Also she is more vulnerable than she was. 
 Unlike Mr Kinnock, her confederate in unpopularity, she may face a challenge. 
 In only one circumstance, it seems to me, can such a challenge do the Conservative Party any good. 
 It needs to succeed, directly or indirectly, in ousting her. 
 For that to begin to come about, a challenger would need to attract at least 70 MPs to vote for him or abstain. 
 Sir Anthony Meyer does not look like the challenger, although this is a furtive world, where the unexpected might occur. 
 Unless someone more plausible comes forward, therefore, the challenge is likely to have two results. 
 First, a derisory vote, after a contest creating a lot of thoroughly unhelpful aggravation. 
 But second, enough of an overwhelming victory for the incumbent leader to rule out what has always been the more credible avenue through which change might occur: her own apprehension, reaching her by whatever means, that perhaps the time has come to quit &mdash; before the election rather than after it. 
 The case for her doing this, in the interests of the party, looks stronger after the Queen's Speech. 
 There has been a lot of theological argument about whether this programme constitutes Thatcherism or post-Thatcherism. 
 A shrewd retreat, as one sort of minister affirms. 
 Or proof of energies undimmed, as says the official line. 
 This seems an academic disputation compared with the salient fact that the programme, whichever way you look at it, would appear to have hardly a single vote in it. 
 Conceivably, the controls on litter and the promised crackdown on pollution will happen quickly enough to produce a political pay-off. 
 Maybe the Food Safety Bill will be useful damage-limitation: pre-empting public terror that almost nothing in the supermarket is safe to eat. 
 But look at the three vanguard social reforms through the eyes of a Conservative MP defending a small majority, and you will see naught for his comfort. 
 The reform of legal services, which may run into fiercer argument from the House of Lords than any measure for a decade, entirely passes the public by. 
 Unless they are unlucky, it will not touch even the fringe of their lives. 
 The contents of the Broadcasting Bill will, in the next two years, impinge only on two tiny elites: media people themselves, and the moguls who want to keep or buy a television station. 
 As for the reform of the National Health Service, it is already well established that every hour devoted to this subject plays into Labour's hands. 
 This is the measure of the legislative programme. 
 A lot of worthy efforts, from a Tory viewpoint, but creating more controversy than popular support: in a political context which may no longer fail to penalise such cavalier indifference to the priorities of the masses. 
 Beneath this programme, moreover, there beats the double anxiety about which the Queen had nothing important to say. 
 The irrelevance of new laws is accompanied by the alarming relevance of two old problems. 
 The laws are fairly insignificant when set beside the economic problem, and the near certainty that, even if all its present plans work out, the Government will be compelled to report a worse economic record in its third Parliament than its second. 
 If the interest rate treatment fails to work, and the failures of investment are added in, the record will look so spectacularly bad that the quality of Labour's promises will fade from the agenda. 
 It will be the prelude to the first election entirely focused on the record of the Government &mdash; and its all-mighty leader. 
 The second lurker is Europe: the issue which directly raises the problem of the leadership, and which will not go away. 
 This, as argued here before, is the one question capable of splitting the Tory Party, at least to the extent of creating factions with a passionate attachment to their prejudices, and no great reluctance to insist on them even at the cost of deep party division. 
 Mrs Thatcher's style almost obliges this division to get worse. 
 Unless she can find a concession to make, while terming the outcome victory, most Tories must be beginning to fear the worst. 
 We now watch these matters unfold, from a new seat at the ringside. 
 It is a long time since politics were more vibrant, at least for anyone who is not a professional Conservative. 
 For those who find themselves in that category, something extra is now needed, some adventitious stroke of fortune, something to upset the terms of the argument and create a world no longer dominated by a leader of proven unpopularity. 
 But will this goddess leave the machine? 
 Dubcek urges hardliners to stand down. 
 By Michael Simmons in Prague 
 CZECHOSLOVAKIA'S former reformist leader, Mr Alexander Dubcek, yesterday promised to meet anti-government protesters in Prague during the coming days and urged beleaguered Communist leaders to resign. 
 For the third day running, 200,000 or more blocked the centre of Prague, cheering Mr Dubcek's call on the hardline leadership to quit. 
 The demonstrators came despite pelting snow and rumours that tanks and armoured vehicles were lurking on the city outskirts. 
 There were warnings from the capital's Communist Party leader, Mr Miroslav Stepan, that &bquo;armed units&equo; of the People's Militia, the party's own paramilitary force, were standing by. 
 Mr Vaclav Havel, the playwright, greeted the rally from the balcony of an office. 
 He announced to cheers that he had written to Presidents Gorbachev and Bush seeking support for what has been called Prague's polite revolution. 
 He also said he had exchanged messages of support with New Forum in East Germany, Solidarity in Poland, the Democratic Forum in Hungary, Ecoglasnost in Bulgaria, Free Romania and at least two &bquo;independent&equo; groups in the Soviet Union. 
 The party leadership of Mr Milos Jakes was still clinging to the hope that it could separate &bquo;the workers&equo; from &bquo;the intellectuals&equo;, he said. 
 The People's Militia has indeed been busy ripping down posters put up by the Civic Forum in factories and elsewhere. 
 They may yet have a marginal impact on the projected two-hour general strike, planned for next Monday, but by then it may already be too late to matter. 
 Monday's strike is to last a maximum of two hours. 
 Ambulance workers will be exempt. 
 The stoppage is being organised by factory committees. 
 Mr Jakes will face his toughest test yet when he confronts an emergency meeting of the central committee this week. 
 It is not impossible, in this highly charged atmosphere, that the party leader will be replaced by the weekend. 
 Each demonstration this week has shown an increase in confidence which it will now be very difficult to stop. 
 Mr Stepan's references to &bquo;criminalised elements taking advantage of a destabilised situation,&equo; like Mr Jakes's references to &bquo;ruthless manipulators&equo; sound oddly out of date. 
 Yesterday, Mr Dubcek's name was chanted at least as loudly as it was in the same square over 21 years ago. 
 Most of those who shouted &bquo;Long live Dubcek&equo; were not even born in 1968. 
 The old party leader with the enigmatic smile is 67 and has become a person of greater symbolic significance than of real political potential. 
 He appeared in his home town of Bratislava yesterday to attend the staged trial of Mr Jan Czarnogursky for anti-state activities and was greeted by thousands who stood outside the courthouse. 
 No policeman seemed courageous enough to bar his way. 
 Thousands of demonstrators turned out in the streets of Bratislava last night in what was said to be the biggest demonstration there in decades. 
 Participants said the city's main square was filled to capacity. 
 Factory workers threatened industrial strikes and voiced solidarity with the striking students, while leading actors and actresses read out lists of demands for greater democracy. 
 Hundreds of television employees said they would strike if prevented from reporting the demonstration. 
 Mr Czarnogursky, meanwhile, faces a possible five-year jail term on charges of sedition in what is being seen as a test case of the regime's genuine commitment to a dialogue with the opposition. 
 Thousands ringed the court building to demand the release Turn to page 20, col 3 
 Dubcek urges Communist hardliners to stand down continued from page one of Mr Czarnogursky. 
 There have been several protest meetings in the city every day this week, though not on the scale of the Prague protest. 
 Leading opposition figures in Bratislava say that they would like to see Mr Dubcek return to active, official politics. 
 They suggest that he could become the country's national president in any strongly reformist administration that might emerge from the current upheaval. 
 A message from Mr Dubcek to the crowd in Prague, read by the economist who advised him in 1968, called for the resignation of all those in the present leadership who were resposible for the invasion and its aftermath. 
 Mr Jakes, it is not forgotten, purged 600,000 from the 1.5million party and many more from other sensitive positions. 
 Their children are still paying for their parents' &bquo;sins&equo;. 
 Long after the afternoon demonstration ended, groups of demonstrators, each of several hundred and some of a few thousand, were dotted about the square, cheering and chanting. 
 The demonstration itself was filmed live by Czechoslovak television &mdash; itself a highly significant breakthrough. 
 After the demonstration, television film crew members, who only yesterday morning were reported to be &bquo;under surveillance,&equo; were lecturing to their own crowds of supporters. 
 Tough realities, page 8; Leader comment, page 18 
 Trippier tries to pacify conservation body over split. 
 By Paul Brown 
 SIR William Wilkinson, chairman of the Nature Conservancy Council, castigated the Government yesterday for its decision to dismember the council without consultation. 
 His complaint, at the annual meeting of the NCC, led to an intervention by Mr David Trippier, the Environment Minister. 
 Mr Trippier said the Government had the best interests of nature conservation at heart and invited the NCC council to meet him before the Government makes the reoganisation details public. 
 Sir William, who was expressing a personal view because of internal differences over the reorganisation, said that to split the NCC into three would remove a strategic overview in formulating national policies. 
 &bquo;Separate country agencies for England, Scotland, and Wales, with their limited responsibilities and sectional place, could not carry &bquo;sufficient clout.&equo; 
 And the grant of &pound;40 million would need doubling to provide the same level of service. 
 The Government is to amend the Environment Protection Bill and is expecting a rough passage through the Lords where a select committee is already examining the NCC's scientific base. 
 Mr Trippier pledged that the NCC would not be worse off financially because of the reorganisation. 
 Car bomb blows up president after only 17 days in office Arab League close to despair Lebanon leader killed. 
 By David Hirst in Jerusalem 
 LEBANON'S new president, Mr Rene Muawad, died yesterday in a huge car-bomb explosion after 17 days in office. 
 It is a devastating blow to the latest Arab League peace plan, which &mdash; with parliament's adoption of political and constitutional reforms and the election of the new president &mdash; had come to embody perhaps the most serious attempt of its kind to end the 14 &frac12;-year war. 
 &bquo;Where do we turn now?&equo; an official at the Tunis headquarters of the Arab League asked. 
 &bquo;It's a tragedy. 
 Whenever we take one step forward, we take five steps back,&equo; said another. 
 However, Lebanese observers say this blow is unlikely to lead to an immediate resumption of the war between the Christian leader, General Michel Aoun, and the Syrians and their Lebanese Muslim allies. 
 More likely, for the time being, is a return to political and constitutional deadlock &mdash; though with full and final partition of the fragmented country looming larger than ever. 
 A car rigged with an estimated 330lbs of explosive ripped through Muawad's motorcade as it passed through the Sanaya district of the predominantly Muslim West Beirut. 
 Unable to take up residence in the Baabda palace occupied by Gen Aoun, this was where he had been conducting his consultations for the formation of a government of national unity. 
 Twenty-three people were killed, including several Syrian and Lebanese soldiers. 
 Mangled remains were hurled 500 yards down the road. 
 Amidst scenes of carnage it was more than two hours before Muawad's death was officially announced. 
 A police officer said his corpse was so charred and mutilated that it took more than an hour to identify it. 
 Announcing the assassination, the Prime Minister, Mr Salim al-Hoss, levelled no specific accusation. 
 &bquo;Let the criminal know,&equo; he said, &bquo;that hands can assassinate a great soul like that of the martyr, Muawad, but they cannot assassinate the enormous national faith which Muawad brought to the presidency.&equo; 
 Inevitably Gen Aoun is the culprit as far as Syria is concerned. 
 &bquo;This ugly crime against the Lebanon and its legitimacy followed a series of threats by the rebellious officer,&equo; the official Syrian news agency said. 
 But it is always unwise to jump to conclusions about Lebanese atrocities. 
 This one does seem to be a great boost to Gen Aoun, who stood in lonely defiance of the Arab and international communities, his Muslim compatriots, and many in his own Maronite enclave. 
 His interim military cabinet said it held an emergency meeting &bquo;to examine initial information about the ugly crime&equo;. 
 &bquo;The cabinet expresses its deep regret for the assassination of one of north Lebanon's most distinguished leaders.&equo; 
 Some Lebanese argue that Gen Aoun's Syrian adversaries could benefit from the assassination. 
 Hardly had Muawad been elected than they detected signs that the Syrians were less than eager to give him the support he needed to impose his authority on the whole country. 
 There is a theory that the Syrians favour the perpetuation of the Aoun regime to give them a pretext for keeping an undiminished presence in the country. 
 The assassination may only have accelerated the inexorable drift towards partition. 
 For even before it, the new president's attempts to form a government of national unity had been faltering, thanks mainly to Gen Aoun's opposition. 
 But now all those Arab and Western powers that had invested such hopes in the plan will find it hard to sustain even a pretence that it remains a realistic proposal. 
 Only three days ago the American ambassador to Lebanon &mdash; who had evacuated his embassy, situated in Gen Aoun's enclave, last September &mdash; paid a one-day visit from Washington to the Syrian-controlled north Lebanon to present his credentials to the new president. 
 The ambassador called his election &bquo;the most important&equo; achievement of the Lebanon's long ordeal. 
 &bquo;It seems to us that like great ships you are in fact approaching the end of the storm.&equo; 
 He expressed surprise that the Lebanese Forces militia, Gen Aoun's ally, had not thrown its weight behind the new regime. 
 East Beirut officials and press called that a flagrant interference in the Lebanon's affairs, which could only strengthen Gen Aoun. 
 Among the Arabs, Saudi Arabia, which had invested great prestige in the plan, has suffered the biggest setback. 
 Arab peacemakers will presumably seek to find a successor to Muawad. 
 The Algerian foreign minister has said that the swift election of a successor would &bquo;show those who oppose national harmony that their enterprise is bound to fail&equo;. 
 But with the process of assembling Lebanon's surviving deputies having been so difficult last time, a repeat performance seems to be impossible. 
 Christian leaders who had been contemplating such a move have been backing off. 
 Fear of meeting Muawad's fate will surely diminish any would-be successor's ambition. 
 Syrians blame Aoun, page 10 
 Rumbold snubs exam critics. 
 By David Gow 
 THE Government yesterday brushed aside growing pressure from business and higher education for radical reform of Alevels and called instead for greater use of contrasting A and ASlevels to provide breadth in sixth-form studies. 
 Mrs Angela Rumbold, Education Minister, said in a BBC Radio interview that there was no question of reviving the proposals put forward by the Higginson Committee for a &bquo;leaner and fitter&equo; five-subject Alevel. 
 &bquo;No, the Government is very clear about the importance of Alevels. 
 We do have to address the needs and requirements of very able youngsters,&equo; she said. 
 Professor Gordon Higginson, Southampton University vice-chancellor, who chaired the committee, said its proposals were quite modest and were bound to be implemented by the mid-1990s. 
 &bquo;I'm not opposed to specialisation, but certainly not at the tender age of 16.&equo; 
 Mrs Rumbold said at a London conference that it was imperative to secure broad and balanced curriculums for students of different abilities. 
 She indicated that this meant greater use of mixed arts/science Alevel programmes and of contrasting/complementary ASlevels, worth half an Alevel. 
 The independent schools inspectorate, HMI, in a report published yesterday on the &bquo;rather tentative start&equo; of AS levels, said a quarter of schools were using these for the wrong reasons, often as a safeguard for weaker Alevel candidates. 
 Pupils had found that the amount of work involved was more than half an Alevel and felt the exams had not proved credible with employers and higher education institutions. 
 Beaten girl &bquo;died in shock&equo;. 
 FIVE-YEAR-OLD Sukina Hammond died from the &bquo;pain, shock and exhaustion&equo; of a sustained beating, a Home Office pathologist told Bristol crown court yesterday. 
 Dr Richard Kellett said he had never seen a child as badly injured. 
 She suffered a minimum of 50 blows. 
 Her father, David Hammond, aged 25, allegedly beat Sukina to death in the family home in St Paul's, Bristol, last December 6 after he became annoyed when she would not spell her name. 
 Hammond denies murder. 
 The prosecution alleges Hammond attacked the girl with his hands, fists, a ruler and the flex from an electric kettle. 
 Dr Kellett, who gave evidence of his post-mortem examination, said most of the injuries were consistent with blows from the flex, either looped or in a straight line. 
 Some marks on her body appeared to match the plug ends of the flex. 
 He told Mr Justice Phillips he could not be certain of the specific cause of death. 
 &bquo;It was a combination of shock, pain and exhaustion and the overall effect of what had been done to her.&equo; 
 The injuries indicated she had been the victim of a sustained attack. 
 A contributory factor was there were so many bruises that they caused circulation problems. 
 The jury heard a tape-recording of an interview between police officers and Hammond, in which he sobbed repeatedly when the officers told him his daughter was dead. 
 The case continues today. 
 A teenage couple whose baby was taken to hospital with bruises and bleeding eyes seemed unconcerned when told he might die, the Old Bailey heard yesterday. 
 A consultant paediatrician, Dr Heather McKinnon, said Danny and Celia Palmer showed &bquo;little reaction&equo;, asked few questions, and did not cry. 
 The couple, from north London, deny murdering seven-month-old Christopher Palmer last December. 
 The case continues today. 
 Mandelson moves closer to Labour nomination. 
 By Peter Hetherington 
 LABOUR'S communications director, Mr Peter Mandelson, is near to becoming candidate for the Hartlepool constituency in Cleveland, with almost half the 67 nominations. 
 Last night six names went forward for next month's selection contest caused by the decision of Mr Ted Leadbitter to retire after 25 years. 
 Mr Mandelson's closest challenger, Mr Steve Jones, 31, the son of shadow Welsh secretary, Mr Barry Jones, has about 19 nominations. 
 A short list will be drawn up next week. 
 Mr Jones has criticised Mr Mandelson for announcing his candidature in a newspaper article and said that the spirit of the party's selection code, which says the media should not be used to promote a candidate, may have been broken. 
 Mr Mandelson was quoted in the article as saying: &bquo;This is not simply a career move. 
 I joined the Labour Party because I believed in its values.&equo; 
 Managers accuse crews in clash over emergencies Ambulance 999 calls &bquo;go unheeded&equo;. 
 By Keith Harper Labour Editor 
 THE intensification of the ambulance dispute yesterday was marked by increasing friction between management and crews, who were accused of putting lives at risk. 
 Ambulance services were hit in many areas, but the dispute remained centred on London, where management published a list of 999 calls which it said were not being answered. 
 Mr Tom Crosby, London chief ambulance officer, said that a &bquo;safe and reliable service&equo; could not be run in the capital under restrictions operated by crews. 
 The National Union of Public Employees, the main ambulance union, dismissed the claim as a &bquo;government inspired disinformation campaign&equo;. 
 It said that the ambulance control centre at Waterloo was in &bquo;chaos and confusion,&equo; and maintained that ambulance crews were continuing to answer 999 calls, even though they were suspended. 
 A ballot among 200 controllers at Waterloo resulted in a decision not to pass 999 calls through to the police or the military. 
 While some observed the decision, others were using fax machines to send details through to Scotland Yard. 
 Nupe said this was being done mainly by non-union personnel. 
 Considerable sums of money have been collected from the public, whose support, according to the unions, shows no sign of abating. 
 With no overtime being worked, even ambulance staff not suspended are beginning to feel the pinch as the dispute enters its 11th week. 
 A campaign, supported by well known people outside the trade union movement, is planned for next week, separate from one already launched by the unions and another started yesterday by the TUC. 
 Mr Norman Willis, the TUC general secretary, said its general council had agreed to make &bquo;a very big drive&equo; to raise money quickly. 
 Labour's national executive called for the dispute to be resolved by arbitration. 
 Waltham Forest health authority, which includes Mr Norman Tebbit's Chingford constituency, in Essex, has become the second health authority to call for an end to the dispute by either negotiation or arbitration. 
 Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, yesterday said that the latest pay offer made last Friday was worth 9 per cent and 11.55 per cent in London. 
 Nupe said the offer was the same made at the Advisory, Conciliation, and Arbitration Service, several weeks ago. 
 The Government had offered a 9 per cent deal over 18 months. 
 An extra &pound;5 million would be brought forward from next year to offset the extra cost, but it would not be made up next year. 
 Mr Clarke accused the crews of putting patients' lives at risk and going back on their promise to take all 999 calls. 
 But the unions' chief negotiator, Mr Roger Poole, dismissed the allegations as deceitful. 
 The five unions representing 22,500 staff have blacked all non-urgent work, with the exception of cases affecting children, expectant mothers, the terminally ill and cancer and kidney patients. 
 Leaders of the five unions meet today to review the situation. 
 The Transport and General Workers' Union complained last night after a driver employed at RAF Stafford died from a heart attack. 
 A military ambulance had been removed from the base to answer 999 calls elsewhere, and there was a 15-minute wait for a civilian ambulance to take the man to hospital. 
 Mr Tony Brighton, the TGWU's representative at RAF Stafford, said: &bquo;We cannot say whether the presence of the RAF ambulance would have made any difference to saving a life, but there was delay.&equo; 
 Councils' finance watchdog finds hard-pressed tenants owe &pound;450m Rent rises and benefit cut swell record arrears. 
 By Stephen Cook 
 RENT arrears among council tenants are reaching record levels, mainly because of rent increases and housing benefit reductions imposed by the Government in April last year, according to the Audit Commission for Local Authorities. 
 Arrears in 1988/9 increased by a third over the previous year to more than &pound;450 million. 
 In some inner London boroughs, two tenants out of three are in arrears and the amount owed to housing departments is nearly 15 per cent of the total sum due in rent. 
 The commission, which released its figures yesterday after a survey of 270 housing authorities, says housing managers should be following its guidelines to reduce arrears. 
 Poll tax officers and water authorities will have direct powers of debt recovery after April, increasing pressure on tenants to pay their rent bill last of all. 
 The poll tax is likely to be higher in areas which already have the worst arrears, the commission says. 
 After April, rents not collected at the end of the year will have to be paid for with a general rent increase because of the Government &bquo;ring-fencing&equo; of housing revenue accounts. 
 On current performance, the rise would be between two and three per cent. 
 The Association of Metropolitan Authorities welcomed the commission's conclusions, which it said confirmed its own survey last December showing soaring arrears in England's big cities. 
 But Mr Maurice Barnes, chairman of the AMA housing committee, said it was disappointing that the commission has not asked the Government to reverse the housing benefit changes. 
 &bquo;I will be calling upon the minister at the Housing Consultative Council to think again about the Government's policy of reducing housing benefits and increasing council house rents,&equo; he said. 
 The commission survey found that the housing benefit changes had short and long-term effects. 
 The immediate difficulties were caused by administrative and computer changes as local authorities took over the administration of the benefit. 
 In the long term, tenants who have had their benefit reduced or removed at a time of rising rents are having more difficulty in paying. 
 The commission's guidelines include setting a clear overall policy, making sure managers have up-to-date information on arrears, and telling tenants how much they owe and how debts will be recovered. 
 Specialist recovery staff and debt counsellors should be employed, and a firm and consistent approach to warning letters, evictions and legal action to seize and sell tenants' goods. 
 Mr Howard Davies, controller of the commission, said yesterday that local authorities should by now have overcome the administrative difficulties of housing benefit changes. 
 &bquo;It is up to them to put a high priority on bringing arrears quickly under control. 
 &bquo;The experience of those authorities who have contained the increase to manageable levels shows what can be done.&equo; 
 Larry Elliott adds: The average outstanding mortgage stands at &pound;21,300, according to the Building Societies Association's quarterly economics journal, Housing Finance. 
 In Greater London, where property is most expensive, the average debt was only &pound;30,800. 
 Wales, the region where people move least frequently, had the lowest average at &pound;13,200. 
 The latest figures from the building societies suggest that the size of the average new mortgage granted in 1988/9 was &pound;35,000. 
 The average mortgage outstanding to banks was &pound;29,400. 
 Survey of Local Authority Housing Rent Arrears, by the Audit Commission for Local Authorities in England and Wales; HMSO &pound;3.50. 
 Turning over a few leaves. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 TENS OF thousands of phantom azalea bushes and geraniums are believed to be alive and growing in the gardens of Northern Ireland after the discovery of alleged false accounting. 
 A government-financed horticulture nursery in Belfast falsified the value of its plants for 13 years to the extent that more than &pound;500,000 of public money has had to be written off. 
 The scale of the problem is thought to have allowed huge thefts but no one can be prosecuted because no records of the plants exist. 
 The saga of the Northern Ireland Housing Executive's 130 acre nursery in Dundonald, Castlereagh, to supply council estates with shrubs and bedding plants was revealed in a Commons Public Accounts Committee report published yesterday. 
 Most nurseries write off one in 10 plants, for failing to germinate, thrive or being destroyed by pests. 
 But figures produced for 13 years by the Dundonald nursery show that the nursey created one in 10 new plants every year instead. 
 In the best years four extra plants appear on the book for every 10 grown. 
 The figures could have been used to cover a fraud operation or could have have been the result of no-one ever checking the facts. 
 The final audit of the accounts found only &pound;45,220 of stock on the premises instead of the &pound;570,680 declared. 
 The disclosure has led to the closure of the nursery -but the stock could only be sold for &pound;26,246 because most growers had made their seasonal purchases. 
 One civil servant has retired on ill health grounds and two downgraded. 
 Thirty sixth report of the Committee of Public Accounts. 
 Further Matters relating to Northern Ireland. 
 HMSO &pound;6.20 
 Straw attacks law by diktat Student loans bill. 
 David Gow. 
 OPPOSITION spokesmen and student leaders last night denounced the Government's bill to introduce top-up loans from next autumn as a constitutional outrage and abuse of parliamentary democracy. 
 The Education (Student Loans) Bill, published yesterday, comprises only one enabling clause setting out ministers' broad intention to usher in loans and two schedules making plain that the Government will use regulations to dictate the size of the annual loan, level of interest rates, repayment periods, deferments and premiums to the banks administering the scheme. 
 The bill, expected to become law before Easter, contains virtually no details of the proposed scheme, which is still being worked out in negotiations with financial institutions. 
 It will prove difficult for MPs and peers to amend and rules out favoured alternatives. 
 Mr Jack Straw, shadow Education Secretary, said the procedure was &bquo;worthy of President Ceausescu of Romania&equo;. 
 The Government &bquo;had taken powers to establish a loans scheme by diktat.&equo; 
 The bill's first clause simply states: &bquo;The Secretary of State may make arrangements for enabling eligible students to receive loans towards their maintenance out of money made available by him for that purpose.&equo; 
 Mr Straw claimed that the lack of detail was a sign of the Government's desperation. 
 &bquo;They have got the banks peeling off and they don't know how it's going to operate&hellip; 
 I think many Tory MPs will be very worried about it.&equo; 
 The Government's scheme would offer all eligible students, defined as those on higher education courses lasting at least one academic year, an annual loan of &pound;420 tapering to &pound;310 in the final year. 
 The cumulative loan would be repaid through a private agency, the Student Loans Company, over a period of, say, 10 years. 
 Interest would accrue on a daily basis but would normally be pegged to the RPI so the real rate would be zero. 
 Grants and parental contributions would be frozen at 1990 levels and loans would eventually form half of a student's maintenance award. 
 Students would lose the right to social security benefits, but the Committee of Vice-Chancellors and Principals last night pledged to fight this element &mdash; only referred to in the bill's preface &mdash; throughout its parliamentary passage and the courts if necessary. 
 Ms Maeve Sherlock, National Union of Students president, said: &bquo;The bill would actually give the Government power to introduce a full loan scheme and destroy the grant system.&equo; 
 Leader comment, page 18 
 News in brief: Row over Tory leadership. 
 The &bquo;near-certain&equo; commitment by backbencher Sir Anthony Meyer to stand against Mrs Thatcher for the Tory leadership brought the instant criticism of party leaders upon his head. 
 Page 20. 
 Difference on defence. 
 Mrs Thatcher is set for a clash with President Bush tomorrow over proposed big cuts in the US defence budget. 
 She is to seek assurances that these will not erode the US military commitment to Western Europe. 
 Page 10. &pound;450m rent arrears. 
 Council tenants' rent arrears have risen to over &pound;450 million, and in some inner London boroughs two out of three tenants are in arrears, the Audit Commission reveals. 
 Page 2. 
 Siege ends quietly. 
 The Salvador hotel siege ended peacefully when 12 US Green Berets were freed after a seeming deal between guerrillas and the army. 
 Page 10. 
 E German concession. 
 The East German politburo told opposition groups it was prepared to hold talks on free elections and constitutional reform. 
 Page 8. 
 Dispute tension grows. 
 Tension in the ambulance dispute was heightened as management in London published a list of 999 calls which it claimed had not been answered. 
 Page 3. 
 Disclosure order. 
 A trade magazine journalist was ordered in the High Court to disclose the source of commercially sensitive information. 
 Page 3 
 FINAL details of the &pound;700 million relief scheme aimed at helping former ratepayers in the transition to poll tax were sent to local authorities yesterday, Mr Chris Patten, Environment Secretary, announced in a written answer. 
 One change to simplify the scheme, announced in October, will mean relief is divided equally in properties occupied by three or more chargepayers, rather than to two nominated inviduals. 
 THE Security Service Act will come into force on December 18, Mr David Waddington, Home Secretary, announced in a written answer. 
 The act, intended to prevent a repeat of the Spycatcher affair, puts the Security Service on a statutory basis and provides an avenue for investigation of complaints. 
 He named Lord Justice Stuart-Smith as the commissioner to oversee the service and Mr Justice Simon Brown as president of the complaints tribunal, with Sheriff John McInnes its vice-president and Sir Richard Gaskell the third member. 
 MR Nigel Lawson's resignation address as Chancellor of the Exchequer was yesterday rated the parliamentary speech of the year. 
 But when he received the Spectator-Highland Park award at a lunch in London, Mr Lawson declined to discuss his departure from the Government. 
 The award for the parliamentarian of the year went to shadow Chancellor Mr John Smith, who won it in 1986. 
 Other award winners: The MP to watch was Mr Charles Kennedy (Lib Dem. 
 Ross, Cromarty and Skye; Back-bencher of the year, Mr Eric Heffer (Lab. 
 Walton); Wit of the year, Mr Neil Hamilton (C. Tatton); and Debater of the year, Mr John Prescott, shadow Transport Secretary. 
 TOTAL construction orders in the third quarter of 1989 were 9 per cent lower than in second quarter and 3 per cent lower than in the same period of 1988, according to provisional figures from the Department of Environment. 
 Private housing orders were 18 per cent down on the quarter, 36 per cent on the year. 
 THE last staff handling employees income tax returns are to leave London by 1992 for Bootle, East Kilbride, Cardiff, Middlesbrough, Salford and Sunderland, the Inland Revenue announced yesterday. 
 The moving of 1,200 posts completes a plan launched when Harold Macmillan was prime minister in 1959. 
 FINAL details of the &pound;700 million relief scheme aimed at helping former ratepayers in the transition to poll tax were sent to local authorities yesterday, Mr Chris Patten, Environment Secretary, announced in a written answer. 
 One change to simplify the scheme, announced in October, will mean relief is divided equally in properties occupied by three or more chargepayers, rather than to two nominated inviduals. 
 THE Security Service Act will come into force on December 18, Mr David Waddington, Home Secretary, announced in a written answer. 
 The act, intended to prevent a repeat of the Spycatcher affair, puts the Security Service on a statutory basis and provides an avenue for investigation of complaints. 
 He named Lord Justice Stuart-Smith as the commissioner to oversee the service and Mr Justice Simon Brown as president of the complaints tribunal, with Sheriff John McInnes its vice-president and Sir Richard Gaskell the third member. 
 MR Nigel Lawson's resignation address as Chancellor of the Exchequer was yesterday rated the parliamentary speech of the year. 
 But when he received the Spectator-Highland Park award at a lunch in London, Mr Lawson declined to discuss his departure from the Government. 
 The award for the parliamentarian of the year went to shadow Chancellor Mr John Smith, who won it in 1986. 
 Other award winners: The MP to watch was Mr Charles Kennedy (Lib Dem. 
 Ross, Cromarty and Skye; Back-bencher of the year, Mr Eric Heffer (Lab. 
 Walton); Wit of the year, Mr Neil Hamilton (C. Tatton); and Debater of the year, Mr John Prescott, shadow Transport Secretary. 
 TOTAL construction orders in the third quarter of 1989 were 9 per cent lower than in second quarter and 3 per cent lower than in the same period of 1988, according to provisional figures from the Department of Environment. 
 Private housing orders were 18 per cent down on the quarter, 36 per cent on the year. 
 THE last staff handling employees income tax returns are to leave London by 1992 for Bootle, East Kilbride, Cardiff, Middlesbrough, Salford and Sunderland, the Inland Revenue announced yesterday. 
 The moving of 1,200 posts completes a plan launched when Harold Macmillan was prime minister in 1959. 
 Firm wins order forcing reporter to name source. 
 By Sarah Boseley 
 AJOURNALIST was yesterday ordered by the High Court to identify a source who gave him commercially sensitive information. 
 Giving judgment in a case that has so far been heard in camera, Mr Justice Hoffmann ruled that Mr William Goodwin, a journalist working for The Engineer, must hand over his notes of a telephone conversation with his source. 
 The judgment adds a new dimension to interpretations of Section 10 of the Contempt of Court Act, 1981, which says journalists can only be required to reveal their sources if it is necessary &bquo;in the interests of justice&equo;, or for &bquo;the prevention of crime&equo;. 
 Yesterday's ruling suggests companies seeking to protect their commercial secrets may have a case under Section 10. 
 After the judgment, Mr Goodman's solicitor, Mr Geoffrey Bindman, said his client would appeal. 
 He said: &bquo;It is the company's security that this is all about. 
 If the company doesn't look after its documents, does it give it a justification for a journalist being asked to reveal his source?&equo; 
 The company in question &mdash; which cannot be identified by order of the court &mdash; has this year been negotiating for a substantial loan. 
 On November 1, the accountants' copy of a business plan for this purpose &mdash; one of eight numbered copies each labelled &bquo;strictly confidential&equo; &mdash; disappeared from the company's premises. 
 The next day, Mr Goodwin's source telephoned him with information including the amount the company was trying to borrow, and the projected results for the current accounting year. 
 Mr Goodwin did not see the file and does not know if his source had access to the file. 
 Mr Goodwin then phoned the company to check his facts, and it took out an injunction to prevent his publishers, Morgan Grampian, publishing the information &mdash; which it said could severely damage confidence among customers and suppliers. 
 The judge rejected the argument that publication of the information in an article would be in the public interest. 
 He said: &bquo;It seems to me that business could not function properly if such information could not be kept confidential.&equo; 
 Ruling that Mr Goodwin must hand over his notes by 3pm today, Mr Justice Hoffmann said that there was strong prima facie evidence that the company would suffer serious commercial damage from publication. 
 In order for the company to know who took the document, to sue for recovery and damages, &bquo;disclosure is necessary in the interests of justice&equo;. 
 Later, in the Court of Appeal, Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, refused a stay in the order pending an appeal, but agreed to allow the notes to be given to the court in a sealed envelope, to be returned unopened if the appeal succeeded. 
 Last night Mr Goodwin was considering whether to comply. 
 Horror classics star bites off heads as the children watch Sketch. 
 By Andrew Rawnsley 
 ON day two of MP-TV Nicholas Ridley was scheduled to make a live appearance before the cameras &mdash; or, as it turned out from his speech, a dead appearance. 
 The star of a series of previous horror classics &mdash; the poll tax, water privatisation &mdash; came on to the despatch box at just before three in the afternoon. 
 This was highly insensitive scheduling to programme Mr Ridley's speech on industrial policy at a time when many young children, old folk, businessmen with heart conditions and Tory MPs with marginal seats might be watching. 
 It was a predictably shocking performance. 
 There was one particularly unpleasant scene, involving John Wilkinson, one of his own backbenchers. 
 Intervening to make a reasoned point about investment in space technology, Mr Wilkinson had his head bitten off in full view of the viewers. 
 The rest of the details are too grisly to describe. 
 Chris Patten, the sensitive young Environment Secretary, who would have to wind-up this section of the Queen's Speech debate, sat on the Government frontbench looking pale and terrified. 
 Mr Ridley was set against Labour's Gordon Brown, making an authoritative debut as Labour's industry spokesman. 
 This is another sign that, so far at least, the Opposition is rather getting the better of the ratings' war. 
 Mr Brown demonstrated that he has already utterly mastered the use of the sound-bite to get a headline phrase into the news bulletins. 
 They rolled off his speech. 
 Bite One: &bquo;The Secretary of State told us about the silver lining &mdash; he told us nothing about the dark clouds on the horizon.&equo; 
 Bite Two: &bquo;Not the department that likes to say Yes, but department that likes to say No.&equo; 
 Bite Three: &bquo;A Prime Minister and a Cabinet so busy trying to recreate the present in the image of the past that they have entirely missed out on the opportunities for the future.&equo; 
 It was another of Mr Brown's sparkling, faultless performances. 
 In fact, it is almost about time Mr Brown made a mistake. 
 People are beginning to wonder whether he is actually human. 
 Leaving the Chamber now and again to compare it with the live BBC-2 coverage, Mr Brown also looked very telegenic. 
 Mr Ridley looked the reverse &mdash; what you might call cinegelet. 
 Apart from an extra lick of oil on his hair, he had made no concessions to the cameras. 
 The fact that Mr Ridley looked awful on television is not entirely his fault. 
 After the novelty of the first day, the omissions and the limitations of the rules governing the coverage are beginning to look more glaring. 
 So are some of the absurdities. 
 Mr Ridley appeared against the surreal backdrop of a vast headless, legless belly floating over his shoulder from the bench behind. 
 Midway through his speech, the torso suddenly developed legs and walked off. 
 Later the belly bounced back into place. 
 Only after some time did the cameras finally establish that the belly had a head belonging to Nicholas Soames, the Industry Secretary's PPS. 
 The other frustration of watching on TV is hearing the low rumble of chatter, unexplained laughter, heckles and shouts, like the noises off in a Russian drama, but being unable to see the source. 
 MPs appear to be permanently enjoying a joke which the public is not allowed to share. 
 But hurrying back into the Chamber proved that the camera does not entirely lie. 
 Mr Ridley still looked awful. 
 Seaside salmonella earns beaches unclean tag. 
 By Paul Brown Environment Correspondent 
 BRITAIN cannot reach European standards for safe bathing beaches because of salmonella in the water, the Government's pollution watchdog, the National Rivers Authority, said yesterday. 
 Addressing the Commons environmental committee, Mr Rupert Grantham, the NRA tidal water officer for south-west England said the absence of salmonella, stipulated by the EC Blue Flag scheme, could not be guaranteed. 
 He said the NRA wanted to talk to the commission to &bquo;simplify&equo; the EC quality standards to make them more &bquo;meaningful and achievable&equo;. 
 He claimed scientific evidence had shown low levels of salmonella in water were not a risk to health. 
 In 1988, 123 out of 364 bathing beaches failed to reach European standards, but the NRA said the present compliance figures almost certainly gave an unrealistic optimistic view of the degree of compliance of bathing waters. 
 The commission wants Britain to build sewage works at the seaside to treat bacteria before it is pumped into the sea. 
 The chairman of the committee, Mr Hugh Rossi, was concerned about the Government's alternative plans to pump the sewage into the sea through long pipelines without treating the bacteria. 
 A scheme to spend &pound;1 billion to replace existing short sewage outlets with long ones is under way. 
 Government scientists believe the action of sea water will destroy the bacteria. 
 Mr Rossi said this might be shortsighted and could store up serious future problems. 
 He compared it with the scheme 30 years ago when Britain built tall chimneys to disperse pollution over a wide area. 
 Now we were having to tackle the problems of acid rain. 
 Similarly, we were relying on the vastness of the oceans to dilute and disperse whatever bacteria and viruses allowed into them; in 30 years we might be regretting it. 
 He urged the NRA to take a very aggressive stance and not to be put off. 
 European resolve to tax vehicle emissions. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 EUROPEAN transport ministers meeting in Paris will today be asked to approve radical plans for tax and financial incentives to curb vehicle emissions. 
 The recommendations, forming part of a programme of environmental measures, will be put to the 19 ministers gathered under the auspices of the European Conference of Ministers of Transport. 
 The meeting, chaired by Mr Michael Portillo, is the first such ministerial discussion on the effects of transport developments on the continent's climate. 
 Confidental documents obtained by the Guardian show that financial incentives proposed by the ECMT secretariat form a fundamental element of the programme. 
 Other measures proposed include action to tackle traffic flows, and greater environmental considerations of spending on new transport infrastructure. 
 The ECMT recognises that past policies and actions on transport and the environment are running behind the debate, and that future transport policies should be forced to consider environmental matters. 
 ECMT papers report that existing and planned emission controls are bringing about significant reductions in air and noise pollution levels. 
 But the secretariat is concerned that the growth of car and lorry ownership may overtake progress so far. 
 It recommends that further reductions in air and noise emissions be sought. 
 &bquo;Economic incentives are potentially powerful tools in bringing about changes in the purchase of cleaner vehicles,&equo; ECMT documents state. 
 They say that &bquo;changes in transport pricing and tax structures should be made which are more consistent with environmental objectives,&equo; and suggest: &bquo;A programme of action in this regard should be drawn up.&equo; 
 The precise nature of the tax incentives remains to be decided, but it appears the ECMT is proposing that motor manufacturers should be given clear incentives to make more environmentally friendly vehicles. 
 Although a communique will be issued later today, there are doubts about the commitment of all the countries, including Britain, to adopt the full programme of recommendations. 
 Mr Michael Portillo, the transport minister, is reportedly sympathetic to the wide-ranging proposals, but doubts exist over whether they will be carried through. 
 The ECMT, which is not part of the EC, is widely regarded as an ineffectual organisation. 
 It has no executive power, and its recommendations are not binding &mdash; which means in effect that the individual countries are being left to implement any proposals agreed at the meeting. 
 However, the meeting is bound to increase pressure on European governments to adopt a more forceful approach in seeking to improve the environment. 
 The debate takes place as pressure mounts on the Environment Secretary, Mr Chris Patten, to introduce a &bquo;green tax&equo; to help finance a cleaner environment. 
 The 19 ECMT countries are: Austria, Belgium, Denmark, Finland, France, West Germany, Greece, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, the United Kingdom and Yugoslavia. 
 Labour launches winter campaign. 
 LABOUR published six main amendments to the bill which they said would form the basis of the party's &bquo;winter campaign to save the NHS&equo;, writes David Brindle. 
 Mr Robin Cook, shadow Health Secretary, said: &bquo;We could not have chosen a better issue to put centre stage for the first televised session of Parliament.&equo; 
 One amendment would make any hospital opt-out plan subject to a ballot of local people. 
 A second would give patients a guaranteed right of access to the hospital of their choice, and general practitioners a right to refer patients to the consultant of their choice. 
 A third would give GPs an explicit right to prescribe the drugs their patients need without any cash limit, while a fourth would specify that all contracts for care must protect quality, not just promote cost competition. 
 The remaining two amendments apply to the community care plans. 
 One would &bquo;ring-fence&equo; or protect the grants to be given to local authorities so they could not be used for other purposes; the other would give elderly and disabled people in local authority residential homes the same social security rights as those in private or voluntary sector homes. 
 This last amendment would have the effect of removing the deterrent which local authorities will face if they place people in their own homes and have to meet the full cost. 
 Clarke says no provision in NHS bill to keep to budgets Doubts linger over drugs cash limits National Health Service bill. 
 David Brindle, Social Services Correspondent. 
 DOUBTS remained last night over whether the Government had honoured its promise not to impose cash limits on drugs expenditure in the bill to bring in National Health Service changes published yesterday. 
 Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, said in response to questioning by reporters that there was no provision in the measure to require regional health authorities to keep within their proposed firm drugs budgets. 
 This appeared to go back on the health white paper, which had stated in a detailed working document: &bquo;Legislation will be needed in order to require FPCs (family practitioner committees) and RHAs to keep to their drug budgets.&equo; 
 Mr Clarke said: &bquo;What we have got here is the legislation we require. 
 The legislation does not require other than what it's got.&equo; 
 The minister therefore seemed to have carried through the understanding reached with the British Medical Association in September. 
 He said then that general practitioners would remain free to prescribe whatever drugs their patients needed and would not be constrained by cash limits either at FPC or RHA level. 
 However, the bill does place a &bquo;duty&equo; on every RHA to ensure that its own and its constituent FPCs' spending, which will include GPs' indicative drugs budgets, &bquo;does not exceed the aggregate&equo; of its income. 
 The BMA was last night examining this provision to see what, if any, effect it could have on GPs' prescribing. 
 But it was heartened by a reference elsewhere in the legislation that GPs could exceed their drugs budgets if they had &bquo;good cause&equo; &mdash; a term which the BMA will interpret as patients' needs. 
 In other respects, the BMA said, the legislation left the public in the dark on key issues such as guaranteed local hospital services, public consultation on opting-out hospitals and quality of care. 
 The measure, the National Health Service and Community Care Bill, contains the legislation needed for both the NHS shake-up and enactment of the community care white paper, published only a week ago. 
 One of the few unexpected measures in the legislation is a clause removing the need for the Health Secretary to authorise private patient facilities in NHS hospitals. 
 The minister would retain only a right of intervention if hospitals or health authorities &bquo;abused&equo; their freedom to develop pay-beds at will. 
 Inclusion of the measure is bound to fuel the fears of critics who see the bill as paving the way for privatisation of the health service, particularly through the proposed opted-out, self-governing &bquo;NHS trust&equo; hospitals and other units. 
 Mr Clarke dismissed such fears. 
 He said that he did not see the point of a central control over pay beds which was a relic of the Labour governments of the 1960s. 
 Moreover, he did not envisage any circumstances in which he would exercise a right to intervene. 
 As expected, the bill provides for the main planks of the NHS shake-up &mdash; NHS trusts, indicative drugs budgets, optional practice budgets for some GPs and creation of an &bquo;internal market&equo; &mdash; though it does so in markedly less robust commercial terminology than was first applied. 
 It also leaves open the possibility of extending these measures. 
 Although practice budgets are being offered only to larger practices with 11,000 patients or more, the bill sets no such lower limit. 
 One issue clarified by the bill is that &bquo;NHS contracts&equo;, the contracts between purchasing health authorities or GPs and service-providing hospitals, will not be legally binding and will confer no contractual rights or liabilities. 
 Mr Clarke said ministers now accepted that the internal market would initially rely heavily on large-scale, block contracts. 
 Expectations that hospitals would be able to work up detailed costings had been revised. 
 Claiming that health workers' fears were being overcome and that there was now a much better understanding of the plans, Mr Clarke said: &bquo;There are volunteers all over the service waiting for Parliament to approve these provisions so we can get on with it from next summer onwards.&equo; 
 Jimmy's real-life drama will intensify over NHS reform. 
 By Martin Wainwright 
 JIMMY'S, the real-life hospital drama, is in for some exciting episodes next year. 
 St James's University Hospital in Leeds, where the TV series is filmed, is expected to take up the proposal for self-governing trusts in NHS hospitals which was given the go-ahead in the Queen's Speech. 
 But Leeds Eastern health authority and NHS unions will fight the plan. 
 The authority has already told the hospital's management to take no action.Yetdoctors such as Professor Richard Lilford, who will be at next Monday's national launch of the Health Reform Group, have got the bit between their teeth. 
 Management at Jimmy's, the largest hospital in Europe, is cautious on the issue. 
 The authority's line that it should not even do any homework on self-governing is considered impractical. 
 But close identification with reform carries risks in a profession vulnerable to political change. 
 The self-governing dynamo at Jimmy's has so far been strongly medical. 
 The initial expression of interest, backed by a ballot of consultants, went to the Yorkshire regional health authority from Mr Bill Shea, an orthopaedic consultant retired from clinical practice and now head of the hospital's medical management advisory committee. 
 A second ballot, on proceeding with a detailed prospectus, is likely to follow. 
 Doctors balance enthusiasm for more local control of funding as a self-governing trust against fears about clinicians finding themselves too close to budgetary responsibility. 
 &bquo;A clinician's first duty must be to the patient,&equo; said one. 
 &bquo;That could become difficult if he or she was also too close to handling the budget.&equo; 
 Supporters of a trust point to a trend towards self-governing apparent in measures such as the growth of cross-border charging for services. 
 Doctors are uncertain of what self-government would mean in detail. 
 But any suggestion that it could lead to leaving the NHS, whose headquarters move to Leeds next year, gets short shrift. 
 The health authority has agreed to hear a presentation on self-governing trusts at its next meeting on Monday. 
 Jimmy's camera crew will not be present &mdash; alas for viewers who like a bit of metaphorical blood on their sitting room floors. 
 Support for bill to outlaw hackers. 
 By Owen Bowcott 
 APRIVATE member's bill to criminalise computer hacking along the lines of the Law Commission's recommendations would attract active Government support, it was disclosed yesterday. 
 The announcement by the Department of Trade and Industry follows fierce criticism of the absence of legislative proposals on computer misuse in the Queen's Speech. 
 The minister, Mr Nicholas Ridley, had to leave out the expected bill because of the Government's heavy legislative programme. 
 &bquo;There may be an opportunity for a private member to introduce the bill,&equo; a DTI spokeswoman said yesterday. 
 &bquo;If that could be carried forward, the Government would be very glad to see it and would give as much help as possible.&equo; 
 In the summer, an anti-hacking private member's bill was withdrawn by Ms Emma Nicholson, Tory MP for Devon West and Torridge, in the belief that government action would follow. 
 She has been considering reintroducing her bill this session. 
 Rusting Chunnel fear &bquo;dismissed&equo;. 
 By Andrew Cornelius Industrial Editor 
 EUROTUNNEL, the Channel tunnel group, denied last night that the concrete linings of the Channel Tunnel could be contaminated by salt and fail prematurely. 
 Mr Colin Kirkland, its technical director, described as absolute nonsense a report in New Civil Engineer magazine that research into existing subsea tunnels shows that &bquo;Channel tunnel wall sections as used on the French side will not be able to resist corrosion for their 120-year design life.&equo; 
 The premature rusting of reinforcing bars in the lining segments could be prevented &bquo;but would have massive cost implications for either Eurotunnel or the UK and French governments&equo; depending on whether linings outlast Eurotunnel's 50-year concession period. 
 The magazine says that research by Mr Chris Ecob and Ms Elizabeth King, of Mott MacDonald, the civil engineering consultancy, on Danish tunnels showed that high quality concrete would not prevent the bars rusting in tunnel linings and their consequent &bquo;premature deterioration&equo;. 
 Mr Kirkland said: &bquo;If this were so the Safety Authority would not let us go ahead and build the tunnel. 
 We spoke to consultants in three countries. 
 We firmly believe we have the best available technology.&equo; 
 Michael Smith writes: Radical plans to privatise parts of the European railway system and help switch freight to rail has been proposed by the European Commission. 
 Mr Karel Van Miert, the Transport Commissioner, is asking member governments to approve a plan which would leave passenger services largely in the hands of state-owned monopolies but open up freight services to competition by permitting private operators to pay for the use of publicly-owned tracks. 
 He called for a single European standard for everything from track size to signalling and from staff training to rolling stock. 
 This would involve the governments in heavy expenditure but the commissioner said past neglect had reduced railways to a &bquo;Cinderella existence.&equo; 
 The restructuring proposals also involve co-ordinating the high speed rail network. 
 Ministers from six European countries, including Britain, have agreed to set up a high speed network by 1998 although there are doubts that Britaincan meet the timetable because of delays over the Channel tunnel. 
 critics fear increased congestion problems similar to those experienced by airlines because of air traffic control difficulties. 
 Healthier lifestyles lead shift towards alternative medicine. 
 By David Brindle, Social Services Correspondent 
 THE DESIRE for healthier lifestyles is leading to growing acceptance of alternative medicine in treating minor ailments, a report by Mintel market analysts claimed yesterday. 
 Eight in 10 women surveyed said that they would use &bquo;natural&equo; remedies and considered pharmacists as effective as doctors in treating minor ills. 
 One in five never visited a doctor for such complaints and preferred self-treatment. 
 Almost two in three of the 897 housewives surveyed in June believed homeopathy and acupuncture were effective. 
 Mr Peter Kraushar, chairman of Mintel International, said the findings were &bquo;stunning&equo;. 
 They showed people were questioning conventional cures. 
 Mr Bill Patterson, a market analyst with Mintel, said: &bquo;Consumers are saying: &bquo;If we are eating more healthily, why can't we mend ourselves more healthily too?&equo;' 
 Mintel, which is charging &pound;1,200 for a copy of the report, estimates that &pound;450 million will be spent on alternative medicine this year, mainly on consultation fees. 
 Another &pound;750 million is likely to be spent on self-medication, rising by 5 per cent a year over the next three years. 
 PAGE 
 Fast lady shows new turn of speed. 
 By Paul Hoyland 
 LADY Arran, a 71-year-old countess with a penchant for speed, put Britain back in the record books yesterday with a storming run in a hydroplane that made light of choppy conditions at the National Water Sports Centre at Holme Pierrepont, Nottingham. 
 Lady Arran, who in 1980 became the first person to top 100 mph in an offshore power boat, set the world speed record for an electric boat at just over 50 mph. 
 The previous fastest time recorded was 45 mph. 
 The gleaming white hydroplane, named An Stradag, Gaelic for The Spark, is being promoted by sponsors as an environmentally friendly boat, silent, efficient and pollution free. 
 A biting wind gusting to 30 knots threatened to blow the fragile, 15-ft fibreglass hydroplane off course as Lady Arran made two runs over a measured kilometre. 
 The judges stipulated that the boat's 12 batteries &mdash; which deliver 140 volts to electric motors &bquo;powerful enough to start a Harrier jump jet&equo; &mdash; had to be recharged within 20 minutes of the first run. 
 This left Lady Arran free to fortify herself with a large tot of rum. 
 &bquo;The rum made all the difference&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I was so cold I could only just press the stop button. 
 It's a lovely little boat to drive. 
 You could almost drink a gin and tonic in that boat.&equo; 
 Lady Arran has invested &pound;25,000 in her hydroplane, designed by Mr Lorne Campbell, one of the world's leading power boat designers, and built in the stable block of her Hertfordshire home. 
 After more than 20 years of power-boating achievements, yesterday's record attempt was billed as her graceful finale. 
 But on coming ashore Lady Arran decided retirement would have to wait. 
 &bquo;We can go faster still next year,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I never feel my age. 
 I love speed. 
 It's a relaxation to me, although one's nerve is bound to go sooner or later.&equo; 
 Pushing the boat out&hellip; 
 Lady Arran takes the controls for yesterday's record-breaking run that was to have marked her retirement. 
 &bquo;We can go faster still next year'PHOTOGRAPH: DAVID SILLITOE 
 A nose for environmental threat. 
 Thursday People. 
 Dennis Barker. 
 SOME 30 years ago, whenever Professor Wilfrid Bach ventured to blow his nose he faced a hazard which has affected his thinking for life. 
 A student at Sheffield university then, he recalls: &bquo;When you blew into your handkerchief, you got about three tons of coaldust. 
 I got very aware of environmental problems when I was 20.&equo; 
 Bach is now one of the world's leading climatologists, and director of the Centre for Applied Climatology and Environmental Studies at Munster University, West Germany. 
 He was in London yesterday to present a report to a conference of environmentalists, showing that most predictions of the greenhouse effect on the world's climate are too optimistic, and advocating a plan of &bquo;permissible&equo; emissions of carbon dioxide. 
 His plan would allow each country a &bquo;quota&equo; until the end of the next century &mdash; a quota Britain would use up in 42 years at its present rate of emissions. 
 Bach speaks of such things with the passion of a self-made man who has beaten personal adversity. 
 Born 53 years ago in Eisenach, now East Germany, the son of a haberdasher who fought in the war and died shortly after it, his family's lack of money meant he had to win scholarships to schools and university. 
 He chose Sheffield as within his means. 
 He wrote his PhD on the climate, moved to McGill university in Montreal, then to the universities of Cincinatti and Hawaii. 
 He did the first course anywhere in air pollution meteorology. 
 In Hawaii, he was chairman of the government review board which examined the impact of industry on the environment &mdash; a job in which he had one specific victory. 
 Hawaii has two huge roadways, and planners wanted to build a third. 
 The feeder roads for it now end in empty air. 
 &bquo;That was really the only project we managed to stop. 
 Your victories in this area are very small, you practically achieve nothing.&equo; 
 Did that upset him? 
 &bquo;That is a very interesting question. 
 Everyone gets once in a while his downs, his depressive periods. 
 But my personal philosophy is that I am not incredibly optimistic, but I am a realistic utopian or a utopian realist.&equo; 
 He clenched his fist and added: &bquo;If other people take no notice, if we achieve nothing, than we put in more engagement, we work more hard towards what we want!&equo; 
 Next month he meets West Germany's environment minister. 
 He has not yet written off the possibility of putting his ideas on a &bquo;four-eyes basis&equo; &mdash; a meeting of just two people &mdash; to Thatcher and Bush. 
 That climate would be lively. 
 Comfort offered to Crockford's critics. 
 By Walter Schwarz, Religious Affairs Correspondent 
 CRITICISM of the Archbishop of Canterbury in the 1987 Crockford's Preface was not taken personally by Dr Runcie, who comforted some critics during the row which followed, according to a book published today. 
 Dr William Oddie, fellow of St Cross College, Oxford, writes in The Crockford's File that Dr Garry Bennett, the author of the anonymously-published preface, who committed suicide during the row, received communion from Dr Runcie at Oxford on the Sunday before his death. 
 &bquo;Dr Runcie, to his eternal credit, remained his friend, though he had read the preface some weeks before and was certain in his own mind of its authorship. 
 &bquo;If the rest of the hierarchy had maintained the same level of charity and civilised control as Dr Runcie, Gareth Bennett might well be alive today.&equo; 
 The Archbishop of York, John Habgood, described the preface as a sour and vindictive outburst from a disappointed cleric. 
 Dr Bennett, a fellow of New College, Oxford, had accused Dr Runcie of leading a coterie of liberals who were weakening the Church's main beliefs. 
 The book says that, on the night Dr Bennett's body was found, Dr Runcie was comforting Mr Derek Pattinson, general secretary of the synod, who had commissioned the preface for the church's official Who's Who. 
 Father Philip Ursell, the principal of Pusey House, Oxford, told Dr Runcie of Dr Bennett's suicide. 
 &bquo;There was a long pause and Dr Runcie said: &bquo;Well, I always suspected it was he who had written it, but I never thought there was anything personal in it. 
 He had not written anything he had not already said to me at different times&equo;.&equo; 
 He spent 20 minutes comforting Fr Ursell. 
 Dr Oddie, an Anglican priest who shares Dr Bennett's views, accuses Dr Runcie of being &bquo;an ecclesiastical chameleon&equo;. 
 He writes that the issue of women priests had been a main cause of the Crockford's row. 
 After a synod debate on the issue, Dr Bennett had felt &bquo;quite panic-stricken. 
 It seemed to him that it was all up with the Church of England&equo;. 
 Explaining Dr Bennett's suicide, the book says that if his authorship of the preface was uncovered, he would become an outsider. 
 The Crockford's File; Hamish Hamilton, &pound;14.95 
 Runcie damns the Deal bombers. 
 THE KILLING of 11 Royal Marines bandsmen in the Deal Barracks explosion had put back the cause of the IRA, Dr Robert Runcie, the Archbishop of Canterbury, said during the memorial service to the victims at Canterbury Cathedral yesterday. 
 He described September's bombing as unjust, merciless, brutal and cowardly. 
 The congregation of 1,500 was led by the Duke of Edinburgh, the Prime Minister, Mr Neil Kinnock, leader of the Labour Party, Tom King, Defence Secretary, and senior military personnel, including Lt-Gen Sir Steuart Pringle, retired Commandant General of the Royal Marines and a former victim of an IRA bomb. 
 Members of the Royal Marines orchestra, including some bandsmen who were caught up in the bombing, played during the hour-long service. 
 The Archbishop said: &bquo;It is right and proper that we should bring our indignation with us to God's house. 
 &bquo;For indignation is not blind rage. 
 Nor is it foul temper which vents itself indiscriminately on anyone who happens to be within range. 
 Indignation is anger targeted precisely upon an action which deserves it and upon whoever has performed it.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;By murdering 11 men and injuring many others these people have polluted yet more the very cause which they claim to be serving. 
 And I have no doubt that they have set that cause back further than they ever know.&equo; 
 Dr Runcie described his visit to survivors in hospital the following day. 
 &bquo;I was struck by two things &mdash; the refusal of battered victims to give in to despair, those who could not speak gave me a thumbs up, and the insistence of sorrowing parents and girlfriends that &bquo;we'll never let them win&equo;,&equo; he said. 
 Dr Runcie stressed the terrorists should not have the last word. 
 &bquo;God permits no power on earth &mdash; neither terrorism, nor any form of evil, nor even death itself &mdash; to have the last word.&equo; 
 That should go to the rescue workers who took great risks to bring out survivors, the skill of the medical teams and the love expressed by those who cared for the injured and bereaved. 
 Relatives of all the victims were in the cathedral with many of the survivors, some still bearing the scars of their injuries. 
 The names of the dead were read aloud by Regimental Sergeant Major Bandsmaster Graham Harvey and a wreath was laid in the nave by the director of the Royal School of Music at Deal, Lt Keith Syvier, to a fanfare of trumpets. 
 The first lesson was read by the Duke of Edinburgh, the Captain-General of the Royal Marines, and the second by Admiral Sir Julian Oswald, First Sea Lord. 
 A Country Diary: CROOK, Co. 
 DURHAM 
 These are the quiet days before winter. 
 For most of this week the landscape has been draped on shifting fog patches. 
 On some days the top of Pea Hill has been bathed in brilliant sunshine, while the valley of the River Wear ahead has been awash in a sea of grey, with tentacles of fog creeping outwards along hedges and gulleys into fields. 
 We have yet to experience any hard frosts, so autumn leaves still cling to branches and there are still a few flowers of white dead nettle, red campion and yarrow to attract the last of the drone flies. 
 Hedgerows take on an additional dimension on foggy days; when the distant landscape is blotted out immediate surroundings assume a new prominence. 
 Hundreds of spiders' webs, suspended between twigs bearing yellowing leaves and clusters of scarlet rose hips are decorated with water droplets that sparkle in the weak sun that occasionally penetrates the murk. 
 Amongst the dead hogweed umbels and seed heads of willow herb there are clusters of ladybirds, packed into tight groups in every available crevice. 
 Ladybirds have done well out of the exceptional summer, as have sweet chestnut trees; this is the first year that I can recall collecting chestnuts locally that are large enough to eat. 
 The warmth and mildness has brought a fine crop of toadstools. 
 The most spectacular of these have been some magnificent specimens of Verdigris agaric, Stroparia aeruginosa, shown to me by Maureen Defty, a local farmer. 
 They had sprouted from buried wood in the vegetable garden and sported livid blue-green, slimy caps. 
 We had our first moderate snow fall in mid-November last year, but so far it looks as though this winter will be milder than ever. 
 One sign of approaching winter comes from the parties of siskins feeding on catkins of birch seeds, moving from tree to tree in noisy flocks. 
 PHIL GATES 
 Diary. 
 By Andrew Moncur 
 A STRANGE silence from the Government &mdash; the people who brought you the Spycatcher saga &mdash; as a book goes into print, giving the inside story of security activities and assorted hanky-panky in Northern Ireland. 
 Not a peep from the Treasury Solicitor; the D-Notice Committee obviously didn't (notice, that is). 
 Fred Holroyd, a former military intelligence officer, has written a detailed account of the dirty war in Ireland. 
 Cross-border operations, kidnapping involving loyalists hired for the purpose, the role of the SAS and infighting between the security services. 
 What more can you do to upset a woman? 
 His book, War Without Honour, (&pound;6.95) was released yesterday by a Hull-based independent, the Medium Publishing Co. 
 Mr Holroyd was attached to MI6 in the province between 1973 and 1975. 
 You might imagine that the Government doesn't want to disturb this particular can of invertebrate, limbless burrowing creatures. 
 WHACK. 
 Stan Bate, his worship the Lord Mayor of Stoke-on-Trent, drives off from the first tee to open officially the city's new municipal golf course at Weston Coyney. 
 Splendid. 
 Then he departs, leaving the course to the eager golfers. 
 Whack. 
 The first hole. 
 Thwack. 
 The second. 
 Kersmack. 
 The third&hellip; 
 Hang about. 
 There isn't an actual hole, as such, on the third green. 
 Nor on the fourth, the fifth, the sixth or the seventh. 
 This is, for a golf course, a bit of a drawback. 
 &bquo;They weren't cut because the course was opened earlier than expected,&equo; said a spokesman. 
 Well. 
 MUNICIPAL Oddities (Part II). 
 Tory-controlled Westminster City Council lays down strict rules for elected persons. 
 Page 30 of the Members' Manual says that it is not &bquo;appropriate for council stationery or postal facilities to be used to indicate the party allegiance of any member or group&equo;. 
 So, when Councillor Peter Bradley replied to a letter from a resident he was careful to describe himself only as a member of &bquo;the minority party&equo;. 
 She wrote straight back, asking &bquo;Which one?&equo; 
 His response: &bquo;You may not believe this but I'm not allowed to tell you on council notepaper.&equo; 
 She fired back: &bquo;Is this not bureaucracy gone raving mad?&equo; 
 So Mr Bradley asked the managing director (sic) of Westminster, Bill Phillips: &bquo;What am I to do?&equo; 
 He has now received this answer: If you wish to disclose your party, you must do so without using council facilities. 
 &bquo;I would ask you to note further that, in this connection, describing oneself as a member of &bquo;the minority party&equo; is in itself an indication of one's party allegiance, given that the political make-up of the council is widely known.&equo; 
 So you can't even say that. 
 Thank you very much. 
 PS: Mr Bradley is a L****r member. 
 THANKS to yesterday's Wall Street Journal for this comment, putting events in Berlin into true perspective. 
 US investors, it says, don't quite know what to make of the outbreak of peace. 
 &bquo;We were all joyous at the scenes of people climbing on the Wall but the problem is, how do you make money on this?&equo; said Charles Clough, chief investment strategist at Merrill Lynch. 
 THE LENGTHS they're prepared to go to, just to persuade Conservatives that there is a Europe out there, anchored somewhere off the coast of England. 
 Sealink British Ferries are running a special offer: a day trip to France for only &pound;7 (if you travel as a foot passenger). 
 The condition: you have to be a Tory party supporter. 
 US TRAVELLERS have seen democracy reaching new heights. 
 When bad weather threatened an American Airlines flight from Chicago to New York the pilot, it emerges, offered his passengers the choice: shall we turn back or go on? 
 Let's have a show of hands. 
 Stewardesses conducted the count. 
 The result: a heavy majority for pressing ahead. 
 Only four dissenters supported the Survival Party. 
 In the event, the plane was forced to land midway between the two cities anyway. 
 Oh, dear. 
 An inquiry follows. 
 ASMALL exchange overheard in the bang-up-to-the-minute House of Commons. 
 Sir Peter Blaker (Con. 
 Blackpool South): &bquo;Bless my soul, Alan. 
 What are you doing here?&equo; 
 A pause. 
 Sir Alan Urwick: &bquo;Actually, I'm the new Sergeant at Arms.&equo; 
 GOOD grief. 
 Prepare yourselves for Muhammad Ali, the fragance. 
 The once elegant bruiser is launching a brand of eau-de-Cologne, bearing his name. 
 Floats like a butterfly, stinks like a&hellip; 
 Katie Campbell talks talk Gift of the gab 
 GOSSIP. 
 I love it. 
 Unashamedly, unrepentingly. 
 Most people do, though few will admit it these days. 
 To gossip: to natter, to prattle, to chatter, to tittle-tattle, to jabber, to jaw. 
 As far back as 700 BC Hesiod was wary of it: &bquo;Gossip is mischievous, light and easy to raise, but grievous to bear and hard to get rid of.&equo; 
 In other words, mud sticks. 
 But gossip hasn't always had such bad press. 
 Even Oscar Wilde called it charming &mdash; granted he was one of history's great gossipers, but he was an even greater gossipee. 
 It has often been noted that while barbarians fight with hatchets, civilised men fight with gossip. 
 Well, frankly, I'd rather have a little mud than a hatchet thrown at my back. 
 And gossip needn't be malevolent; my Little Oxford Dictionary defines it simply as &bquo;informal talk, esp about persons.&equo; 
 In any case, when someone gossips well they are called a wit or a conversationalist; only those who gossip badly are tarred with the appellation &bquo;Gossip&equo;. 
 Good gossip must have an esential core of truth to it, and a dose of compassion, concern or at least good humour attached; it is bad gossip that has no basis in fact, that is driven obviously and primarily by maliciousness. 
 That sort of gossip certainly should be condemned; that is the sort Hesiod warned against. 
 But even he went on to say that gossip has &bquo;a kind of divinity&equo;. 
 And Seneca seven hundred years later spoke of &bquo;that most knowing of persons &mdash; (the) gossip&equo;. 
 The word gossip itself actually means &bquo;God's kin&equo;. 
 Originally it was a term of respect denoting a godparent &mdash; as Queen Elizabeth I was the gossip at the baptism of her godson James VI, or indicating friends with a common spiritual bond. 
 Following the peasant habit of referring to any elder as &bquo;Mother/Father&equo; or &bquo;Grandmother/Grandfather&equo;, the word was also applied to any gathering of older folk. 
 It was only when it began to be associated exclusively with women that gossip began its slippery slide into the gutter. 
 From denoting women friends or gossips, the word came to denote the speech of gossips. 
 And so it acquired its contemporary, pejorative connotation of idle chatter. 
 There is a theory that gossip is a form of speech particular to women &mdash; to women, old people, servants and slaves. 
 In other words, to the powerless. 
 But while Daisy and Rose were gossiping in the downstairs pantry, does anybody really doubt what Lord Bellamy was doing upstairs in the drawing room? 
 Discussing affairs of state &mdash; no doubt. 
 The sort of affairs that lose elections and topple governments. 
 Not philosophy, not theology, but &mdash; you guessed it &mdash; gossip. 
 A psychiatrist friend of mine recently returned from an international conference in Athens. 
 When I asked him what those eminent shrinks did with themselves in the evenings he explained that they gathered in the hotel bar. 
 &bquo;And what did you all talk about?&equo; 
 &bquo;Shop-talk: who's getting ahead, and how, and why; who's feuding with whom; who's working with whom; who's screwing with whom.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, you mean gossip.&equo; 
 &bquo;No!&equo; he protested, indignantly. 
 &bquo;We were talking shop; it was shop-talk, not gossip.&equo; 
 When Lawson resigned the pundits gathered, and mused, and offered up their conjectures and reflections, and it was called Political Speculation. 
 When women gather to do the same, it is called gossip. 
 When academics delve into someone's life it is called Biography; when therapists posit theories on human behaviour it is called Psychology; when sociologists ruminate on society it is called Sociology. 
 When women ponder on an individual, emotion or social phenomenon, it is called Gossip. 
 So what exactly is gossip &mdash; this thing that is so reviled and condemned? 
 Gossip is Speculation. 
 About human affairs, about human motives, actions and desires. 
 As women are largely responsible for the emotional wellbeing of society, it is hardly surprising that the shop-talk of women is gossip. 
 Gossip is Old Wives' Tales. 
 Women's wisdom has long been feared: Old Women, Witches, Sibyls, Seers. 
 Those who scorn or censure women's talk diminish women. 
 Or seek to. 
 Gossip is Stories. 
 Stories provide entertainment, but also instruction. 
 The best, most satisfying gossip is like the best, most satisfying art; it is cathartic. 
 Through gossip we learn from other people's lives without undergoing the pain or danger of their experiences. 
 In short, gossip is a chronicle of humanity. 
 As Ogden Nash put it, &bquo;Another good thing about gossip is that it is within everybody's reach/And it is much more interesting than any other form of speech&hellip;&equo; 
 Imagine if Colette or Jane Austen or Dorothy Parker or Chaucer or Shakespeare or Marcel Proust had lived in a world without gossip! 
 Their works would be skeletal; their insights would be meagre and mean. 
 You can keep your philosophers speculating on language or your theologians speculating on God, I'll speculate on the human heart &mdash; gossip's good enough for me.  
 PAGE wom 
 Figures of fun Open Space.. 
 I WRITE in response to Judith Raymont (November 16) who wrote of the cartoon Men &mdash; A User's Guide, &bquo;It is either insulting to men and should not be endorsed by publication, or it is witty and amusing, in which case we, as women, have no right to complain about equivalent portrayals of female stereotypes.&equo; 
 It does not matter if the cartoon is insulting to men. 
 The number of such cartoons is so small that, set against the insults to women broadcast by every newsagent and television channel, only a loony masculist would object to them. 
 Before Raymont works towards &bquo;ways of showing respect, understanding and affection to members of the opposite sex&equo;, she should realise that the opposite sex's obsession with &bquo;members&equo; is a problem of enormous gravity. 
 There is nothing respectful, understanding or affectionate about page three. 
 W J Gaskill (male) East Kilbride 
 IWOULD agree that male and female stereotypes portrayed in cartoons are equally abhorrent, were it not for the fact that, whilst one pokes fun at a powerful group in society (men), the other perpetuates the oppression of a powerless group (women). 
 In an ideal world, there would be no need for either, but for now I would rather see the frustration expressed in these light-hearted terms than in the sort of man-hating bitterness that has given feminism such a bad name. 
 Natalie Ford Brighton 
 MEN &mdash; A User's Guide is stupid, negative and insulting. 
 Am I, as a man, supposed to think that, if my body is hairy, it is &bquo;thick and bestial&equo;? 
 Or that my mind, which I consider intelligent and creative, is occupied only with sex, violence and car engines? 
 Is this funny? 
 What kind of hypocrisy allows you to (presumably) condemn a similarly degrading portrayal of women, whilst making your page a forum for this cartoon? 
 Jim Conwell London NW3  
 PAGE wom 
 Give and take. 
 I DISAGREE with Denise Scott Fears' contention that door-to-door collections cause &bquo;guilt and shame&equo; in many people. 
 I have never had any qualms about refusing to fund a cause I do not support, but am glad to have the chance to give to good causes I might otherwise have missed. 
 Having made a collection myself in a depressed area, I got &pound;2.30 in total. 
 I saw this small sum not as a personal insult but as a gain for the charity I was supporting. 
 Virginia Rudd Workington, Cumbria 
 WHILE I sympathise with Denise Scott Fears, I know the charity's response would be, &bquo;It's a cut-throat world out there and we've all got to grab our piece.&equo; 
 I once complained to Help The Aged about the way they got kids to compete for &bquo;badges&equo; by encouraging them to collect a target number of sponsors &mdash; and thus to pester neighbours. 
 Their response was that this method had greatly augmented their income. 
 If Denise Scott Fears has problems refusing adults, she'll feel even more of a &bquo;heel&equo; refusing that winsome child! 
 Melanie Kingsbury Nottingham  
 PAGE wom 
 Thanks, Hank. 
 CONGRATULATIONS on printing the extract from Hank Wangford's book (November 16). 
 He summed up so many unhelpful attitudes from male doctors. 
 Sympathetic and funny &mdash; the man speaks the truth! 
 A shame there aren't more male doctors like him. 
 Fiona Thompson London SE24 
 HANK Wangford echoes my own feelings after visiting Barts hospital with a friend who has lumps in her breasts. 
 She lay there, stripped and vulnerable, while the senior registrar stabbed a finger, clenched his teeth and shook with unspent rage at her questions. 
 His bedside manner was, in a word, menacing. 
 My friend had wanted specifically to talk to a specialist, so she could make up her own mind about surgery. 
 His message was clear: his own position was paramount and as there was a malignancy risk, it was his job to persuade &mdash; or bludgeon &mdash; her into the operating room. 
 It was an extraordinary performance. 
 Meanwhile, in another part of the hospital, a man lay dead in a lavatory, unnoticed for five days. 
 But then you don't have to be dead to be ignored. 
 Lesley Nelson London NW3  
 PAGE wom 
 Liliane Landor reports on an issue that has shaken the foundations of French politics and put the question of immigration firmly back on the agenda A country divided. 
 LEILA and Fatima Achaboun and Samira Saidani are the most talked-about schoolgirls in France. 
 For two months they have been relegated to their school's library, forbidden to attend classes or take part in any school activity. 
 Since they turned up on the first day of term wearing headscarves, their teachers, supported by the headmaster, have refused to teach them unless the girls remove the offending headgear. 
 The Gabriel-Havez school in Creil where they live stands in the heart of the town's industrial estate. 
 It's a sad grey prefab, put up some 20 years ago as a temporary measure and still servicing the needs of this economically depressed small town some 62km north of Paris. 
 The 825 youngsters who attend the school are mainly children of immigrants of over 25 different nationalities. 
 Today the school finds itself in the midst of a public debate which is shaking the foundations of French politics &mdash; some say ethics &mdash; has split Mitterand's Socialist Party down the middle and has put the questions of immigration and integration back on the agenda with a vengeance. 
 Mr Cheniere, the school's headmaster, is a practising Catholic of Martinican origin, a freemason whose authoritarian methods do not endear him to his students. 
 He is adamant that any open manifestation of religious or cultural identity at school goes against the principles of secular state education. 
 To his credit, Cheniere did attempt a conciliatory gesture when he suggested that the three adolescents could wear their scarves at school outside class hours. 
 The girls insist that it is their fundamental right to wear their scarves at all times, just as some of their fellow students wear skullcaps or the cross. 
 They say they do not understand why their headmaster is so intent on persecuting them when 20 Jewish students do not attend school on Saturdays, a normal part of the school week in France. 
 Confronted with this, Cheniere retorts that there are some differences that are more salient than others. 
 Let them wear their scarves at home, he adds; this school is French and secular. 
 The &bquo;Affair of the Scarf&equo;, as it has become known, has taken the French media by storm. 
 In the past month, not a day has gone by without national newspapers devoting reams of print to the issue, asking in big headlines, as Le Point put it, &bquo;Should we let Islam colonise our schools?&equo; 
 The left-leaning weekly Le Nouvel Observateur has invited anthropologists, philosophers of many persuasions, feminists (mostly French) and Muslim intellectuals (men) to pronounce their verdicts. 
 Opinion polls have been taken by Le Figaro and L'Evenement du Jeudi, with wildly differing results, readers have been encouraged to write and religious leaders of all shades have been called upon to give the benefit of their wisdom. 
 Today in France, the Koran is the flavour of the day as &bquo;specialists&equo; dissect its verses and explain the mysteries of Islam to the lay masses. 
 Yet it remains that, for the first time in 15 years and since the controversy over abortion, opinions are divided so haphazardly that traditional political alliances have ceased to operate. 
 No sooner had the Minister of Education, Lionel Jospin, stated that the scarves could not be a motive for excluding the girls from school than the teachers' union, traditionally close to the Socialist Party, called him a traitor and 50 of his deputies signed a petition publicly disaffiliating themselves from his line and asking for his resignation. 
 They found themselves rubbing shoulders with right-wing MPs, the same who in 1984 organised a million-strong demonstration in support of private schools and for the right of the parents to choose, and who today declare themselves staunch supporters of the state secular education system. 
 Mme Mitterrand's support of the girls, in the name of respect of religious cultures within the bounds of secularity, brought an angry reaction from French feminists. 
 Along with four other intellectuals, including Regis Debray, feminist writer Elisabeth Badinter signed an open letter to Mr Jospin, saying that the scarf is a symbol of Muslim women's oppression and warning him not to capitulate. 
 A compromise on this issue, they wrote, would damage all that the French Republic has stood for since the Revolution. 
 Remarkably, the voice of those primarily concerned by the issue, namely Arab women, has been totally missing. 
 Les Nanas Beurs, an organisation of women of North African descent, believe that the scarf battle has to be fought. 
 &bquo;As Arab feminists of Muslim culture, we believe that fundamentalism in all its forms is dangerous and that the scarf is oppressive,&equo; said spokeswoman Souad Benani. 
 &bquo;But it should not be used as a pretext to exclude 12- or 13-year-old girls from school when it is precisely these secular schools that should offer them the opportunity to learn, grow and make their own choices.&equo; 
 For her organisation, as well as for SOS Racisme, the mass movement of young French of immigrant descent, this debate hides another agenda. 
 What is really being debated, according to Hayat Boudjema, vice-president of SOS Racisme, is immigration and the integration of migrants and their children in French society. 
 Already the opposition has united to set up a working group on immigration, with a view to formulating a new bill. 
 Boudjema believes that the opposition parties are settling a score with the Socialist government and using the schoolgirls as a scapegoat. 
 There's more and more talk about the inability or unwillingness of the North Africans to adapt and conform. 
 &bquo;This controversy has been tainted by racism parading as a concern for the adolescents&equo; welfare,&equo; says Boudjema. 
 &bquo;The scarves are being used to fan the age-old fear of the Arab which has been dormant &mdash; simmering &mdash; since the Algerian war.&equo; 
 For her the real issue is the second generation's right to education, but not any old education. 
 &bquo;We are still being taught about &bquo;our ancestors, the Gauls&equo;. 
 The history of our countries of origin in Africa, Asia or the Arab world has remained totally obliterated.&equo; 
 Boudjema, who is of Algerian descent, says she was totally shocked when she first heard of the Affair of the Scarf. 
 &bquo;When women in North Africa and the Arab world are struggling so hard for equality and respect, it is ironic that here in France a fundamentalist minority is pushing them to conform to tradition. 
 But we can't sacrifice these girls on the altar of a sacrosanct secularity which, in my view, needs to be urgently redefined and adapted to a multiracial society.&equo; 
 As the debate goes on and the political parties bid for votes and support, Leila, Fatima and Samira are still confined to the library. 
 In the meantime, in the Paris suburb of Montfermeil, the mayor refused to register children of immigrant descent in his town's primary school, declaring that he'd filled his quota of foreign children. 
 Similarly, in the small town of Beaucaire in the South, a like-minded mayor refused to admit 40 new children of North African origin. 
 When forced by the Inspectorate of Education to retract his decision, the good mayor refused them access to the school canteen, controlled by the municipal services. 
 &bquo;As far as I'm concerned,&equo; he said, &bquo;they don't exist.&equo; 
 Guardian Women is edited by Louise Chunn  
 PAGE wom 
 Quentin Falk on how five minutes of TV documentary grew into a feature film Love among the bigots. 
 THE source material of A Private Life, one of the first theatrical projects funded by the BBC, derives to all intents and purposes from a five-minute segment in an award-winning BBC series from 1978 called The White Tribe Of Africa. 
 This disturbing profile of Afrikaners in their own backyard was drawn by David Dimbleby and directed by London-born but South Africa-educated Francis Gerard who, more than a decade later, makes his feature debut with A Private Life. 
 During his extended research for the TV series, he met a close couple, Ray and Diana de Proft, living in the Cape Town suburb of Maitland. 
 Recalls Gerrard: &bquo;Ray and Diana weren't married then, although they would dearly like to have been, because they were citizens of the Republic. 
 They had been living together across the colour bar for the best part of 30 years. 
 &bquo;They had met when he was a young and not tremendously enthusiastic policeman and she was a waitress in a seafront cafe. 
 He took her out, they fell in love and started to live together. 
 Then in 1950 the Population Registeration Act became law. 
 &bquo;And something they had never considered suddenly became very important. 
 Ray was white. 
 When Diana's classification came through, she had been designated Coloured. 
 At about the same time came the Immorality Act, which made sexual relations between different races a crime against the state.&equo; 
 So Ray then found himself in the position of spending a good many of his working hours enforcing a law which he was breaking himself and increasingly afraid of being arrested by one of his mates. 
 Their relationship became more and more covert; he left the police and they moved to a suburb where they &bquo;passed for white&equo; and began the long struggle called &bquo;trying for white&equo;. 
 When children arrived, matters became even more complicated and ultimatley more tragic. 
 &bquo;Ray and Diana weren't revolutionaries, nor were they political dissidents. 
 All they had done was to try to live an ordinary private life in South Africa with the dignity that we all take for granted,&equo; says Gerrard. 
 This extraordinary story was ruthlessly edited down to its allotted span and eventually tucked away in the last of four hour-long programmes. 
 But its impact far outweighted its tiny ration. 
 It made Gerard determined to try to tackle the material &bquo;at the length and depth &mdash; and with the budget &mdash; it deserved.&equo; 
 With the backing of the BBC, the guarded co-operation of the couple and the collaboration of a fine screenwriter, Andrew Davies, a full-length film drama was prepared and Gerard even secured permission to film in Cape Town. 
 Then a money crisis hit the BBC and A Private Life was one of the casualties. 
 The project went into cold storage, periodically resurfacing over the next six years only to sink once more. 
 Gerard confined himself to documentaries and it was while making a 90-minute update on South Africa, Back On The Frontier, for ITV in 1986, that he became fired up to press ahead again single-mindedly with the feature. 
 &bquo;With the Government slowly clamping down on all media coverage, unless I moved fast any chance of filming within South Africa would be gone and I did want the accuracy and flavour of the country itself to come through in the film.&equo; 
 The BBC still, happily, seemed keen to see the film produced and so Gerard budgeted it to be made as simply as possible in 16mm for television, with the hope that cinema distributors would find it irresistible and give it a release on the big screen. 
 On the eve of shooting, the co-production partner &mdash; an offshore bank &mdash; withdrew from the project. 
 The BBC itself, via its Enterprises section, rescued the day by coming up with the other half of a total &pound;450,000 budget. 
 With the same actors in tow anda thumbs-up from the African National Congress, Gerard cranked up again. 
 This time, and just four days before shooting, his cameraman, Ernie Vincze, was refused entry to the republic on the grounds he was an &bquo;undesirable alien&equo;. 
 After labyrinthine inquiries, it was discovered he once photographed a series of ducumentaries of which the Government disapproved. 
 A replacement was approved and shooting finally went ahead. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 American Football: Birmingham find a home. 
 VILLA PARK, the Aston Villa soccer club ground, will be the home of the Birmingham club competing in the new International League of American Football. 
 The team, yet to be named in full, will play their opening home game against Rome on April 16. 
 Last week Chelsea's Stamford Bridge ground was named as the London venue, and the Midland announcement completes the line-up for the six-nation competition, which will consist of a 12-game season which runs from April to July. 
 England and Italy will have two teams, with West Germany, the Netherlands, Spain and Finland represented by one. 
 Rugby Union: Oxford University 18, Major Stanley's XV 33 Revels expose Oxford's slack. 
 By Robert Armstrong 
 OXFORD badly need to brush up their slapdash act on the training ground before they meet Cambridge at Twickenham in just under three weeks. 
 Sloppy handling, poor co-ordination and a lackadaisical defence left them well adrift of Major R V Stanley's XV at Iffley Road yesterday. 
 Any match of nine tries (five by Stanley's) is bound to be entertaining but Oxford committed so many errors in every department that it was hard to keep a straight face while assessing their contribution. 
 In addition their captain Brian Smith persisted with his wayward goal-kicking long after it became apparent that he should pass the task to someone else. 
 Perhaps it was asking too much of Oxford, who have not won a game for a month, to exercise the same shrewd control at half-back demonstrated by Farr-Jones and Porta. 
 Injuries to key players have hampered their preparations and possibly undermined confidence. 
 In contrast Stanley's usually made the inspired calculations of a good invitation side out for a scoring spree. 
 Although they lost the Australian wing Ian Williams with a shoulder injury early on, their back division was outstanding, especially Mullin and the Canadian full-back Gareth Rees. 
 Farr-Jones was clearly in a mood to enjoy himself before joining the Barbarians to take on the All Blacks at Twickenham on Saturday. 
 Stanley's took the lead after two minutes with an opportunist try by Mullin, when Porta's attempted drop goal rebounded from a post. 
 Eight minutes later Mullin's perceptive cross-kick found Rees unmarked for an easy short-range try. 
 Stanley's, moving the ball wide with crisp facility, stretched their lead to 18-0 when Rees broke down the left and crashed over with muscular help from Watkinson. 
 Eventually Oxford, setting up a succession of strong drives down the middle, disrupted Stanley's confident rhythm and Reader dived over from an untidy ruck. 
 After the break Oxford maintained their forward impetus, scoring a push-over try, and thereafter the sides alternated tries, culminating in the best of the afternoon when Smith, Hein and Curtis combined in a 60-metre break down the right which produced a diving touchdown for Curtis. 
 It was the kind of romantic flourish that Oxford may have to produce several times over at Twickenham next month. 
 SCORERS: Oxford: Tries: Reader, Van Der Merwe, Okoli, Curtis. 
 Conversion: Smith. 
 Stanley's XV: Tries: Mullin, Rees 2, Porta, Farr-Jones. 
 Conversions: Porta 5. 
 Penalty: Porta. 
 OXFORD UNIVERSITY: M Oliver; G Hein, D Richards, D Curtis, S Okoli; B Smith (capt), S Taylor; M Jones, T Hayashi, D James, M Merrick, T Coker, J Fewtrell, M Reader, W van der Merwe. 
 MAJOR R V STANLEY'S XV: G Rees (British Columbia and Canada); I Williams (Eastwood and Australia; E Quist-Arcton, Harlequins, 13min), B Mullin (London Irish and Ireland, capt), A Watkinson (Kew Occasionals), R Vessey (Northampton); H Porta (Banco Nacion and Argentina), N Farr-Jones (Sydney University and Australia); A Everett (University of Cape Tn), M Howe (Bedford), T Willis (Narbonne), E Peters (Loughborough University), J Howe (West Hartlepool; D Wood, Kew, 49), D Cooper (Richmond), G Taylor (Loughborough University), G Bertrand (Narbonne). 
 Referee: R Quittenton (England).. 
 Fergus Aherne of Ireland and the Welshman Gary Jones have been brought in as replacements for Gary Armstrong and John Jeffrey in the Barbarians' team to play the All Blacks on Saturday. 
 Basketball: Spanish galleons sink the English. 
 By Robert Pryce 
 IN THE absence of Joel Moore (Achilles tendon) and Francis Drake (retired), the Spanish carried too much firepower in this European Championship match. 
 Apart from a shaky start and the threat of a squall in the second half, conditions in the Aston Villa Leisure Centre proved entirely to the liking of the bigger galleons, Spain beating England 99-83. 
 The 6ft 9in Antonio Martin (21 points) and the 6ft 10in Ferran Martinez (12 points) proved mobile enough to inflict irreparable damage to the English interior defences, and the 6ft 5in Jordi Villa Campa (22 points) sank everything in sight. 
 England's limited attacking options were reduced to the occasional fast break and the low-percentage shot. 
 Peter Scantlebury took an age to find his range. 
 From 15-14 down, Spain took control with a 26-6 burst. 
 Clark's burst saw off the Spanish zone and then a desperate English press reduced the margin to 11 points with seven minutes to go, but that was as close as England were to come. 
 Boxing: Jacobs spies the ladder. 
 By Jack Massarik 
 MOTHERWELL Civic Hall is a long way from Las Vegas, but when Gary Jacobs defends his Commonwealth welterweight title there tonight against Donovan Boucher, the Canadian champion, he will be aiming to take the international spotlight from old stagers like Lloyd Honeyghan and Kirkland Laing. 
 A 23-year-old Glaswegian based in London, the wiry southpaw with the swarming style was voted boxer of the year last season, when he travelled to Las Vegas and beat the Mexican Javier Suazo for the IBF International championship for boxers ranked between No.10 and No.30 in the world. 
 Last April he outpointed the fancied George Collins, and he takes a dim view of last week's easy win by Laing over Collins at Reading. 
 &bquo;I don't think people should read anything into that,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Collins was unbeaten when he faced me and he didn't look the same fighter coming off a loss.&equo; 
 After that, however, Jacobs was clearly outpointed by the former world champion James McGirt in New York. 
 &bquo;At no stage, though, did he look like knocking me out, like most of his opponents,&equo; said Jacobs. 
 &bquo;I learnt a lot that night and think I'm a better fighter for it.&equo; 
 Boucher, who has lost only three of his 23 fights and carries a powerful right-hand punch, will represent a fair test. 
 Paul Hodkinson, the undefeated British and European featherweight champion, faces a substitute European opponent in his home town of Kirkby on December 13. 
 Farib Benredjeb of France replaces Italy's Salvatore Bottiglieri, who is injured. 
 Najib Daho of Manchester defends his Commonwealth lightweight title against Carl Crook of Chorley in Preston on January 24. 
 Spurs away to the holders. 
 THE Littlewoods Cup holders Nottingham Forest were given another home draw in the quarter-finals, with Tottenham the visitors in the potential tie of the round if they can overcome Tranmere in a replay at home next week, writes Ian Ridley. 
 Oldham received scant reward for their exploits, being sent to the winners of the Swindon v Southampton tie next week. 
 Coventry are away again, either in the North-east against Sunderland or the South-west against Exeter. 
 West Ham will be at home to Derby, for whom their former striker Paul Goddard is such an important figure. 
 The matches are scheduled for the week beginning January 15. 
 LITTLEWOODS CUP: Quarter-final draw: Swindon or Southampton v Oldham, West Ham v Derby County, Exeter or Sunderland v Coventry City, Nottingham Forest v Tottenham Hotspur or Tranmere Rovers. 
 Demonstrations may disrupt SA tour &mdash; Barlow. 
 By David Foot 
 GLOUCESTERSHIRE's new acting manager and senior coach, Eddie Barlow, last night met the county's former skipper David Graveney, due to lead the rebel tour of South Africa, and told him he feared the tour fixtures might not be completed. 
 Barlow believes the tour risks nullifying the progress being made towards ending apartheid and that Graveney's party may be affected by demonstrations. 
 &bquo;I have my reservations about whether the tour will be completed as arranged,&equo; he said. 
 Graveney said: &bquo;Eddie is certainly entitled to his opinions. 
 I respect them, especially so as he has just come from South Africa. 
 But I have been in regular contact with Ali Bacher and he assures me there are no problems over the tour and that it is definitely on.&equo; 
 Barlow, a South African and former skipper of Derbyshire, was officially appointed yesterday on a three-year contract to take effect from 1990. 
 He had an &bquo;affable chat&equo; with Graveney and other members of the Gloucestershire team, who suffered from poor results and sagging morale last season. 
 Tony Wright will be the third captain in as many years. 
 David Lawrence will be staying with the county after signing a new four-year contract. 
 Kent had expressed interest in the pace bowler. 
 Courtney Walsh will be re-signing, and it looks increasingly likely that the Zimbabwean all-rounder Kevin Curran will also stay with Gloucestershire. 
 England's four-day match against the Leeward Islands on their West Indies tour has been switched to St Kitts and begins on February 2. 
 The one-day international in Guyana has been changed to March 7, with the second Test there now starting on March 10. 
 Leicestershire's Young England fast bowler Richard Edmunds has been seriously injured in a road accident. 
 Edmunds, aged 19, has undergone emergency surgery for chest injuries at Leicester's Groby Hospital where his condition was described as &bquo;serious but stable&equo;. 
 Marseille take option on mixed bag of Eurostars. 
 By Ian Ridley 
 MARSEILLE, the Manchester United of French football &mdash; except that they won their championship last year &mdash; have moved in advance of next summer's World Cup marketplace to strengthen their team for next season. 
 Chris Waddle's club, who this week took their spending for the season so far to &pound;14 million by signing the Nantes player Didier Deschamps, have signed agreements with four players which give them priority should they wish to sign any of them. 
 The players are Dragan Stojkovic of Red Star Belgrade, Argentina's Diego Latorre, the Dane Fleming Povlsen, of PSV Eindhoven, and Cologne's Thomas Hassler. 
 Ruud Gullit could also come on the market after the next World Cup. 
 The AC Milan player, who has not played since last May's European Cup triumph over Steaua Bucharest because of a knee injury, is involved in a contract dispute with the club. 
 The Dutchman is seeking an extension to his contract, which expires next summer, of three years and &pound;7 million. 
 The club however are believed to be in no hurry to agree until he proves his fitness. 
 He is expected to play again in January, specialists having approved his return to training, but is unwilling to turn out too soon, as he did against Steaua after surgery, for fear of jeopardising his chances of playing in the World Cup. 
 Milan denied, however, that they plan to cut his current salary, as they have a right to do under Italian rules when a player has been out of action for more than six months. 
 Gullit is one of several long-term casualties missing from the Milan side as they take on Barcelona in the Nou Camp stadium in the first leg of the European Super Cup tonight. 
 Another, their influential sweeper Franco Baresi, is to have a metal plate inserted in the left arm he broke in Sunday's derby win over Internazionale. 
 Milan, also without Carlo Ancelotti and Fillipo Galli, have only three fit reserves, in the midfield player Angelo Colombo, winger Marco Simone and striker Stefano Borgonovo, and the manager, Arrigo Sacchi, will have to reshuffle. 
 Diego Maradona, the only player in Italy to earn more than Gullit, played in Napoli's Uefa Cup third-round home leg against Werder Bremen yesterday after taking painkillers for a back injury, but was largely ineffective as his side lost 3-2. 
 The holders, who beat another West German side, VfB Stuttgart, to take the trophy last season, fell behind to goals by Neubarth and Riedle before their Brazilians Alemao and Careca struck to level the scores. 
 However Bremen's New Zealand striker Wynton Rufer secured victory in the dying seconds. 
 Uefa has announced that the European Cup final on May 23 will be played in Vienna, and the Cup-Winners' Cup final on May 9 in Gothenburg. 
 Sailing: Pressure on as speeds drop. 
 By Bob Fisher in Fremantle 
 THE leading yachts on the second leg of the Whitbread Round the World Race were almost in line abreast yesterday as they approached the finish at Fremantle. 
 Fisher &amp; Paykel was the most northerly of the line, which ranged through Steinlager 2, Rothmans and Merit to the south-east. 
 With 450 miles to go, an area of high pressure will decide the finishing order. 
 The New Zealanders Grant Dalton and Peter Blake, skippers of Fisher &amp; Paykel and Steinlager 2, agree that the winner will be decided in the final miles. 
 &bquo;It's a matter of who has the right line past the high,&equo; said Dalton. 
 Blake said: &bquo;Tacking the way through the lighter winds will decide who wins the leg.&equo; 
 The yachts are slowing down as they approach Fremantle and the effect of the high-pressure zone becomes apparent. 
 The two maxi-sloops, Lawrie Smith's Rothmans, of Britain, and Pierre Fehlmann's Merit, of Switzerland, could make a last-day attempt to overtake the two New Zealand ketches, swinging up the West Australian coast to make full use of the sea breeze. 
 Rugby Union. 
 The Welsh Rugby Union has appointed Ron Jones, a retired headmaster, as regional director for Wales for the 1991 World Cup. 
 He is honorary secretary of the Central Glamorgan RU. 
 Speedway. 
 The three-times world champion Erik Gundersen, from Denmark, has retired after receiving serious spinal injuries in a crash at Bradford in September. 
 Golf. 
 David Graham, the Australian former US Open and US PGA champion, plans to retire next year. 
 John Roger Jones, a 45-year-old Walker Cup selector, was yesterday named captain of the Welsh amateur team. 
 Swimming. 
 The East German Olympic champion Silke Hoerner, who won the 200 metres breaststroke gold medal at the Seoul Games, has retired. 
 Cyclo-cross. 
 Steve Douce, the British champion who missed the Nations Cup race at Wolverhampton with badly bruised ribs, is expected to be fit for the second round of the Falcon National Trophy series in Leeds on Sunday. 
 Rugby Union. 
 Leicester will be without their centre Paul Dodge and possibly the flanker Ian Smith for Saturday's Courage league game at Harlequins. 
 Dodge has suspected cartilage trouble and Smith a twisted ankle. 
 Hockey. 
 The unbeaten Welsh Premier Division leaders Whitchurch must travel to University College Aberystwyth in the quarter-finals of the Welsh Cup. 
 Chepstow or Northop Hall are at home to Swansea, Monsanto entertain Cardiff, and British Steel travel to Polytechnic of Wales in ties on December 10. 
 Tennis. 
 Ken Flach, a former Wimbledon doubles champion with his American partner Robert Seguso, is racing to get fit for the Nabisco World Doubles Championship at the Royal Albert Hall in London on December 6-10. 
 Flach, who left the court at Wembley in a wheelchair after spraining an ankle and tearing ligaments in the Silk Cut Championships, said in Missouri yesterday: &bquo;I have always viewed the Masters in London as the culmination of my tennis year.&equo; 
 Snooker: Clean-up break for Hendry. 
 STEPHEN HENDRY, beaten by Doug Mountjoy in last year's final, overwhelmed Barry West 9-1 in their best-of-17-frames fourth-round match in the Stormseal UK Open at Preston Guild Hall yesterday, writes Clive Everton. 
 The 20-year-old Scot's break of 141 robbed Andrew Cairns, a first-season professional from Blackpool, of the &pound;2,000 break prize for the pre-televised phase. 
 Tony Knowles had breaks of 72 and 127 and, in the last frame of the afternoon, a 68 clearance in taking a 6-2 interval lead over Tony Drago. 
 Steve Davis took a 6-2 lead over Cliff Wilson. 
 Davies recovers his deposit with a treble. 
 HYWEL Davies, who lost &pound;50 after an unsuccessful objection at Wolverhampton on Tuesday, recovered it handsomely yesterday with a 54-1 treble on Precious Link, Breakfast Car and Wizzard Artist at Plumpton. 
 It took his score for the season to 20 and, ironically, he was on the receiving end of an unsuccessful objection. 
 After Precious Link had led turning for home in the Peter Cazalet Memorial to score by six lengths from Super Express, Simon Earle, rider of the runner-up, complained that his mount had got unbalanced and made a mistake at the second last because Precious Link had taken his ground. 
 The stewards established there had been interference, but it was accidental and had taken place before the second last and thereby did not count under the rules. 
 Unlike Davies on Tuesday, Earle got his deposit back. 
 Precious Link was 2lb out of the handicap and trainer Bill Turner got a mild shock when he found that Davies was also putting up 3lb overweight. 
 The six-year-old was also bumped at the start and Davies's feet knocked from his irons. 
 The Sherborne trainer commented: &bquo;He had a lot of problems last year, a bit of leg trouble and he was breaking blood vessels, but I think we've cured both problems.&equo; 
 Breakfast Car was well fancied for the Car Parks National Handicap Chase despite an 11 month absence. 
 He took command three from home and won by ten lengths, but Davies, with a typical wisecrack at trainer Gardie Grissell, exclaimed: &bquo;I thought you could train &mdash; he blew up at the water.&equo; 
 The Heathfield trainer commented: &bquo;Breakfast Car bashed a leg in his last race and got a bit of heat in it, so we turned him away for the rest of last season. 
 Rest is now the accepted cure. 
 It's very hard to find a vet to fire a horse, they're liable to get prosecuted by the RSPCA. 
 Breakfast Car will probably have to go up a grade and go to slightly posher places.&equo; 
 Wizzard Artist, who ran on Lingfield's all-weather Flat course a fortnight ago, completed a great day for Davies with a slick, 12 lengths win in the Jevington Novices' Hurdle. 
 Davies, who will be 33 next month, enthused: &bquo;I'm still loving the game. 
 The Captain (Tim Forster) is very good to me and there's no pressure on either of us now that I'm no longer stable jockey. 
 That's my first treble this season, but I once had a four-timer and a second from five rides at Newbury.&equo; 
 Squash: Gregory bows to Jahangir. 
 JAHANGIR KHAN took 34 minutes to dismiss Paul Gregory, the last British survivor, from the Stuttgart Open, writes Richard Jago. 
 The top seed won 15-11, 15-11, 15-7 with a display of sustained violence that has been less characteristic of the heavier, more creative but slower Jahangir than the earlier version. 
 Gregory acquitted himself honourably but was increasingly on the retrieving end. 
 Jahangir now meets Chris Dittmar, who beat him twice in last month's world championships. 
 Today also sees another repeat, between Rodney Martin and Jansher Khan. 
 Martin came from two games down against his fellow Australian Chris Robertson. 
 He is more than the greatest of stroke-players and he was patient enough to take advantage of Robertson's flagging energy and win 12-15, 9-15, 15-5, 15-12, 15-8. 
 The same mixture of steel and sparkle could give him a hat-trick over Jansher. 
 Martin beat him when Australia took away Pakistan's world team title last month, and again in the US Open final on Saturday. 
 Skiing: Park City creates a fantasy on the carpet John Samuel reports from Utah on an artificial but nonetheless entrancing start to the World Cup season. 
 &bquo;THIS is the place,&equo; said Brigham Young as his wandering, persecuted tribe of Mormons finally set eyes on the Great Salt Lake and the Wasatch mountains rising in fairyland fantasy before the rising sun. 
 Today, America's Thanksgiving Day, it is certainly the place to be for the world's best technical and all-round skiers. 
 Never before has a main World Cup season opened so early. 
 Four races over the next four days &mdash; men's and women's giant and special slaloms &mdash; pick up where Australia and Argentina left off in August. 
 Often America has ended the main programme. 
 Two seasons of snow famine have changed all that. 
 Because of its advanced snow technology, it is America first this season. 
 And a fantastic sight it makes. 
 A barrage of snow cannons have laid 10 million gallons of snow in the Park City race area known as Willi's Face. 
 The first men's giant slalom racer out of the starting gate today will swing and glide over a carpet of manmade snow 80 centimetres deep. 
 It is woven as only the American artificial-snow industry knows how. 
 Without it there would be no party over the next four days. 
 For the mountains are sullenly short of the natural commodity, their dun-coloured pelts still autumnal. 
 &bquo;The worst since 1976 but that's not stopping the show,&equo; says the ski area chief, Craig Badami. 
 The local papers are full of hype. 
 &bquo;Hey, come to the ski party,&equo; they carol to Salt Lake City's quarter-million citizens, about 80 per cent of them Mormons. 
 &bquo;It's America's skiing Disneyland.&equo; 
 Mormons remain devout people. 
 Their sportsmen like Johnny Miller or Billy Casper give 20 per cent or more of their earnings to the church. 
 They do not touch hard liquor or even coffee. 
 But they know how to party. 
 Three years ago the first ever races here drew 12,000 fans for the flashing lights, thunderous music, fireworks, balloons &mdash; and, yes, the ski racing. 
 Park City, 25 miles out of Salt Lake, is an old mining town Brigham Young would hardly have cared for. 
 But it is a serious ski place, for years housing the US Ski Racing Association's head office, the heart of a fragile mountain area about 50 miles wide and 150 miles long with some of the best powder snow &mdash; when it does snow &mdash; anywhere. 
 Today the world's top giant slalom men lock for vital early points in the World Cup battle culminating in Sweden in March. 
 Scandinavia struck the early blows at Thredbo, Australia, with Lars-Borje Eriksson, perhaps the new Stenmark, winning from Norway's Ole-Christian Furuseth. 
 Last season's champion Marc Girardelli was fourth, Alberto Tomba, Italy's Olympic sensation, fifth. 
 The three times overall champion, Switzerland's Pirmin Zurbriggen &mdash; recently married &mdash; was sixth. 
 A devout Catholic, he has said this will be his last season while he devotes himself to his family. 
 Some Swiss wonder whether a family responsibility will perhaps work the other way, and he will stay on for the 1992 Olympics. 
 ither way, like the ebullient newly married Severiano Ballesteros of two years ago, he could ski to a new crest this season. 
 Technically the Austrians have come on strongly, Rudolph Nierlich winning two slalom golds at the Vail World Championships. 
 He was ill and below form in Australia, but has gone well in training here. 
 The Utes who once inhabited these regions handed down tales of gods as entities with a wry sense of humour, human faults and even a mean streak. 
 By Sunday the world's top skiers may share something of their understanding. 
 Nottingham Forest 1, Everton 0 Police escort for referee. 
 By David Lacey 
 THE Littlewoods Cup holders returned to the last eight of the competition last night in unusual and, Everton would claim, unjust circumstances. 
 Nottingham Forest had almost despaired of breaking down Everton's rebuilt defence in an entertaining tie at the City Ground when Lee Chapman won the match seven minutes from the end. 
 While there was nothing extraordinary about the goal, Chapman turning in a free-kick Clough had driven through a crowd of players towards the near post, the reason the free-kick was awarded left Everton disgruntled. 
 Their goalkeeper, Neville Southall, was preparing to clear the ball upfield and making no haste about it when the referee, George Tyson, booked him for time-wasting and awarded Forest the indirect free-kick which was to decide the match. 
 Not for the first time this season MrTyson needed a police escort as protesting losers surrounded him at the end. 
 Everton, still without their regular centre-backs Ratcliffe and Watson because of injury, again tried to make up for this by playing Snodin as a spare centre-back behind Keown and McDonald. 
 This gave them a cushion of safety but often meant that the opposition found it easier to make space in midfield. 
 However, it also meant that the sort of movements which normally flow through Clough had to be accurate to the point of perfection if they were not to be enmeshed in blue shirts. 
 Two minutes before the half-hour Forest appeared to have achieved this when Pearce exchanged passes with Clough and burst clear into the penalty area on the left. 
 Southall, who had earlier blocked a close-range shot from the England left-back taken from a similar angle, looked more vulnerable this time but Pearce drove the ball past the far post. 
 With so many players forced to defend, Everton found few opportunities to attack in any strength. 
 However, a free-kick from Nevin nearly brought them a goal immediately before Pearce should have given Forest the lead. 
 Keown nodded Nevin's kick square and Newell's diving header drew a smart save from Crossley, his first of the game. 
 Crosby's acceleration and close control were a frequent worry to Everton on the right but seven minutes before half-time the winger only seemed to have got past Snodin by fouling him. 
 The referee, however, allowed play to go on with Everton prostrate and protesting and when the cross came over the defence seemed to use less than legal means to stop Chapman reaching it. 
 Tyson, two of whose penalty decisions contributed to the recent battle of Highbury between Arsenal and Norwich, this time gave nothing, but by half-time he had cautioned Sheedy and Pearce for fouls. 
 Forest began to lose momentum in the second half and found themselves forced to defend for longer periods. 
 Nottingham Forest: Crossley; Laws, Pearce, Walker, Chettle, Hodge, Crosby, Parker, Clough, Chapman, Rice. 
 Everton: Southall; McDonald, Pointon, Keown, Snodin, Ebbrell, Nevin, McCall, Sharp, Newell, Sheedy. 
 Referee: G Tyson (Sunderland).. 
 Soccer: Rangers' mystery &pound;5 million backer. 
 By Russell Thomas 
 RANGERS have clinched a &pound;5 million sponsorship deal, the biggest in the British game, but aim to keep the identity of the backer a secret until a chosen launch date. 
 There has been strong speculation that Pepsi Cola are putting up the money but David Murray, Rangers' owner and chairman who bought the club exactly a year ago yesterday, is giving nothing away. 
 Murray confirmed only that the deal had been agreed and that it would go a long way towards cutting Rangers' overdraft of &pound;9.5 million. 
 The club are paying about &pound;30,000 a week in interest charges. 
 Murray said: &bquo;The aim is to have the overdraft cut to around &pound;3 million or &pound;4 million by the end of the year. 
 If we can achieve that, I will be reasonably pleased. 
 &bquo;There will be no trading loss this year despite the fact we have bought new players.&equo; 
 Aston Villa have raided the Caribbean for an 18-year-old striker that their manager Graham Taylor calls &bquo;a little gem&equo;. 
 Dwight York, who played for Trinidad and Tobago in Sunday's World Cup defeat by the United States, has agreed to sign a three-year contract with Villa, where he is due to arrive on December 13. 
 A &pound;5,000 fee has been agreed but the deal is subject to a work permit. 
 Taylor said: &bquo;We are hopeful that we have found something a bit special.&equo; 
 York had a five-week trial with Villa at the start of the seasan after being spotted when the club played two games in Trinidad in the summer. 
 An Australian striker, Alastair Edwards, has agreed to join Brighton in a deal worth about &pound;60,000 to Sydney Olympic. 
 Edwards, 21, has played for Australia youth and under-21s and, after appearing in the 1987 World Youth Cup finals in Chile, had 18 months with Rangers without breaking into the first team. 
 Brighton's reserve striker Martin Lambert has joined Wycombe Wanderers for &pound;15,000, and the GM Vauxhall Conference club's manager Jim Kelman has also made an offer for Aldershot's unsettled midfielder Glen Burvill. 
 Colin Morris, sacked by Scarborough, is to play for Boston United on a non-contract basis. 
 Watford's reserve goalkeeper Mel Rees has joined Southampton on a month's loan with a view to a permanent transfer. 
 Blackpool must pay &pound;35,000 for Nigel Hawkins, the 21-year-old striker signed from Bristol City, if he becomes a first-team regular at Bloomfield Road. 
 Blackpool, who offered just &pound;2,000 against City's valuation of &pound;70,000, will also have to hand over 25 per cent of any profit on a subsequent transfer. 
 Brentford have signed Bournemouth's central defender Paul Miller on a month's loan. 
 The 30-year-old player was a colleague of the manager Steve Perryman at Tottenham. 
 Notts County's defender Willie McStay, brother of the Scottish international midfielder Paul, has joined Hartlepool on a month's loan. 
 Middlesbrough's goalkeeper Stephen Pears is back in light training after eight months out through injury and illness. 
 He hopes to be challenging for the first team by Christmas. 
 Stan Mortensen, Blackpool's hat-trick scorer in the 1953 FA Cup final win over Bolton, is to be made an honorary freeman of the town. 
 Cricket: Red rose blooms in business David Hopps on how Lancashire reaped record profits. 
 LANCASHIRE announced record profits of more than &pound;306,000 yesterday, a staggering achievement which hardly reflects county cricket's traditional hand-to-mouth lifestyle. 
 Many counties remain so untouched by the commercial age that lost balls are still classified as a major item of expenditure. 
 Lancashire, by contrast, have invested heavily in the daily earning potential of Old Trafford, now the best equipped ground outside Lord's; in deepest Rawtenstall even that qualification would be judged unnecessary. 
 The county's turnover for the last financial year, close to &pound;2 million, differs markedly from counties less well blessed. 
 Derbyshire, for example, will struggle to reach one-third of that figure. 
 The assessment of Bob Bennett, the county chairman and an Isle of Man tax exile, would slip naturally into Financial Report. 
 &bquo;We have extended our operations in the business field,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Activity over 12 months of the year has been an important factor. 
 But the prospects that the North-west economy might not be as buoyant next year could affect our performance in 1990.&equo; 
 The Test and County Cricket Board hand-out rose in an Ashes summer from &pound;338,000 to a new high of &pound;473,000; and Lancashire's successful season on the field, fourth in the championship and winners of the Refuge Assurance League, almost doubled match income. 
 The TCCB will give serious consideration this winter to the damage to techniques caused by a preponderance of one-day cricket, yet Lancashire's last three Sunday matches at home accounted for almost &pound;80,000. 
 Only one bugbear remains: the members' obstinate refusal to grant full rights to Lancashire's women subscribers, including access to a pavilion which remains a bastion of male chauvinism. 
 At last year's annual meeting, 60 per cent of members supported the committee's plea for change; they will again seek the requisite two-thirds majority at Old Trafford on December 9. 
 Bennett has set out the supposed pros and cons in the annual report. 
 Why should Lancashire allow women members? 
 Numerous reasons are given. 
 Some are moral: the overcoming of inequality, and a woman's fundamental right to partake in club affairs. 
 Some are financial: the risk of deterring sponsors and the benefit of additional subscriptions. 
 The arguments against include: members should not be forced to share facilities with women, the pavilion may be too small, the pavilion has no women's toilets, women have adequate facilities of their own, some men wish to get away from women, and &bquo;lady subscribers&equo; might not wish to become full members. 
 Maureen Fitzgibbon, chairman of the women's steering committee, said: &bquo;This time we think we will do it.&equo; 
 Of those who responded to a questionnaire, 83 per cent of women subscribers supported the principle of full membership for women. 
 But only 62 per cent responded, and half wanted the option of staying women subscribers. 
 Rugby League: Leigh 6, Wakefield Trinity 24 Conway's heavenly touch inspires Trinity. 
 MARK CONWAY, a perky scrum-half with a nice line in inventiveness, did much to help Wakefield to this victory at Hilton Park last night, writes Edward Kennedy. 
 He played an important role in the first three tries as well as kicking four goals, one from the touchline. 
 It was an important win for Wakefield, lifting them over Warrington, Widnes and Sheffield into sixth place. 
 They began slowly, but dominated the second half. 
 Leigh, after impressive wins over Widnes and Featherstone Rovers, were very disappointing. 
 They were predictable in attack and, as was proved all too often in the second half, fragile in defence. 
 Just when it seemed that a try would be too much to hope for after 30 tedious minutes, the crowd were treated to two first-class efforts, from Ledger and Fox, playing his first game at Hilton Park since he left Leigh for Leeds three years ago. 
 Conway, whose delicate chip set up Fox's try, landed a splendid goal to make it 6-6 at half-time. 
 Wakefield soon took the lead for the first time when Conway's towering kick bounced over the line for Mason to touch down near the posts. 
 Three minutes later Jackson broke straight from a scrum and Perry's pace put him clear to score. 
 Although Thompson, the hooker, was sin-binned for 10 minutes for a foul in a tackle on Platt, Wakefield were never troubled and two minutes after he departed Wilson dribbled past a swarm of defenders to score by the posts. 
 Conway improved all three tries. 
 Leigh: Johnson (Platt, 72min); Ledger, Moimoi, Jeffrey, Standish; Ruane, Beardmore; Street, Ropati, Case (Brown, 68), Collier, Potter, Platt (Dean, 68). 
 Wakefield Trinity: Perry; Fox, Leuluai, Mason, Wilson; Jackson, M Conway; Kelly, Thompson (B Conway, 72), Glancy, Lazenby (Bell, 72), G Price, R Price. 
 Referee: A Burke (Failsworth).. 
 Skiing. 
 John Samuel at Park City, Utah, on the opening races of the new season Cannons put smile on Willi's Face &bquo;T HIS is the place,&equo; said Brigham Young as his wandering, persecuted tribe of Mormons set eyes on the Great Salt Lake and the Wasatch mountains. 
 Today, Thanksgiving Day, it is certainly the place to be. 
 Never before has a main World Cup season opened so early. 
 Four races over the next four days &mdash; men's and women's giant and special slaloms &mdash; pick up where Australia and Argentina left off in August. 
 Often America has ended the main programme. 
 Two seasons of snow famine have changed all that. 
 Because of its advanced snow technology it is America first this season. 
 A hundred snow cannon have laid 10 million gallons of snow in the Park City race area known as Willi's Face. 
 The first man out of the starting gate today will swing and glide over a carpet of man-made snow 80 centimetres deep. 
 Without it there would be no party, as the natural commodity is in short supply, the worst since 1976. 
 Today the world's top giant slalom men lock horns for vital early points in the World Cup battle which ends next March in Sweden. 
 Scandinavia struck the early blows at Thredbo, Australia, with Lars-Borje Eriksson, perhaps the new Stenmark, winning from Norway's Ole-Christian Furuseth. 
 Last season's champion, Marc Girardelli, having switched skis for a reported half a million pounds, was fourth, Alberto Tomba, Italy's Olympic sensation, fifth. 
 The three times overall champion, Switzerland's Pirmin Zurbriggen &mdash; recently married &mdash; was sixth. 
 A devout Catholic, he has said this will be his last season as he devotes himself to his family. 
 Some Swiss wonder whether a family responsibility will perhaps work the other way, and he will stay on for the 1992 Olympics. 
 Either way, like the ebullient newly married Severiano Ballesteros of two years ago, he could ski to a new crest this season. 
 Technically the Austrians have come on strongly, Rudolph Nierlich winning two slalom golds at the Vail World Championships. 
 He was ill and below form in Australia, but has gone well in training here. 
 The Utes who once inhabited these regions handed down tales of gods as entities with a wry sense of humour, human faults and even a mean streak. 
 By Sunday the world's top skiers may share something of their understanding. 
 Soccer: Littlewoods Cup, fourth round: Oldham Athletic 3, Arsenal 1 Double by Ritchie ends 66-year wait. 
 By Stephen Bierley 
 OLDHAM Athletic, who had never beaten a First Division side since they dropped into the Second Division in 1923, made up for 66 years of not altogether patient waiting with a pulsating victory over the League champions Arsenal at Boundary Park last night. 
 The Pennines fairly shook. 
 No supporter of the Latics dared dream it, but suddenly the improbable was a throbbing, joyous reality. 
 Two goals from the irrepressible Andy Ritchie, his 13th and 14th this season, and a third by the 20-year-old midfield player Nick Henry, and Arsenal were sunk with only the trace of a last-minute goal by Quinn. 
 Despite many and varied flurries of activity in the first 40 minutes, Arsenal seemed reasonably secure if not inspired. 
 They held their line and competed hard in midfield, damping down Oldham's initial verve and preparing themselves for more of the same in the second half. 
 Then Oldham struck. 
 Winterburn almost put the ball into his own net from Milligan's cross, O'Leary recovering an awkward situation. 
 Almost immediately Smith had an excellent chance for Arsenal but stumbled. 
 Oldham took up the attack again and Barlow, who had a fine match at left-back, totally containing Rocastle, floated in a deep cross beyond Winterburn. 
 The predatory Ritchie chested the ball down and hammered a volley past Lukic. 
 Arsenal had no choice but to attack as soon as the second half began. 
 A neat step-over by Rocastle sent Thomas hurtling in on goal but Rhodes moved sharply off his line to smother the shot. 
 From the resulting corner Rhodes made another fine save, hurtling to his right to deflect away Dixon's rising shot. 
 Finally, with Arsenal pressing hard, he clawed away Quinn's careful header from Thomas's drag-back. 
 Quinn held his head in disbelief. 
 Worse, far worse was to follow. 
 Bunn, who scored six goals in the previous round against Scarborough, this time turned into the provider, putting Milligan clear and free. 
 He was hauled back on the edge of the area by O'Leary, a &bquo;professional&equo; foul for which the Arsenal central defender was booked. 
 Holden's 64th-minute free-kick clattered the wall and the ball fell to Henry, who drilled a low shot from more than 30 yards inside Lukic's right-hand post. 
 In another 10 minutes any remaining Oldham doubts were dispelled. 
 Ritchie passed to Irwin and then ran on to head the cross past Lukic. 
 Arsenal were stitched and stuffed, with no question of a fluke. 
 Not for the first time this season their defence had been found wanting and Oldham exploited the weaknesses to the full, owing a special debt to the inspiration and tireless running of Henry and Milligan. 
 George Graham was not amused. 
 He called his team's performance &bquo;unacceptable&equo;. 
 But he also said: &bquo;Let's not take any credit away from Oldham. 
 They were tremendous, and outplayed us in the first half. 
 The plastic pitch is no excuse. 
 We trained on an artificial pitch for two days this week and we should have done a lot better.&equo; 
 Joe Royle, the Oldham manager, was full of praise both for Graham and his own team. 
 &bquo;George was brilliant,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;He could have blamed this and that but he said we deserved it. 
 The manager's attitude shows why they are champions. 
 He took it on the chin. 
 &bquo;One or two people will be ready to put this down to plastic but our goals were nothing to do with plastic. 
 This was a great performanc. 
 We rattled them from the first minute and didn't give them any breathing space. 
 We were helter-skelter for 90 minutes and we scored three great goals. 
 In the past we have had cup walks, not runs.&equo; 
 Oldham Athletic: Rhodes; Irwin, Barlow, Henry, Barrett, Warhurst, Marshall, Ritchie, Bunn, Milligan, Holden. 
 Arsenal: Lukic; Dixon, Winterburn, Thomas, O'Leary, Adams, Rocastle, Richardson, Smith, Quinn, Jonsson (Groves, 65min). 
 Referee: R Gifford (Llandradach).. 
 Soccer: Littlewoods Cup, fourth round:Oldham Athletic 3, Arsenal 1 Double by Ritchie ends 66-year wait. 
 By Stephen Bierley 
 OLDHAM Athletic, who had not beaten a First Division side since they dropped into the Second Division in 1923, made up for 66 years of not altogether patient waiting with a pulsating victory over the League champions Arsenal at Boundary Park last night. 
 The Pennines fairly shook, and Quinn's last-minute volley meant nothing. 
 Andy Ritchie put Oldham ahead just before half-time with a thumping volley and then, with Arsenal heaving and straining to equalise, Nick Henry struck a wonderful second goal in the 64th minute. 
 Oldham's joy was complete when, 10 minutes later, the effervescent Ritchie fed Irwin and then ran on to head home the full-back's cross for his second goal and Oldham's third. 
 At this point the Arsenal fans began to drift home, their evening well and truly over. 
 Oldham worked diligently to put Arsenal under maximum pressure from the start, and both O'Leary and Dixon had anxious moments as they strove to adjust to both the home attack and the artificial turf. 
 Arsenal's breaks were few but always threatening and Oldham, after a first flurry, found openings increasingly elusive. 
 Nevertheless as half-time approached Irwin struck an excellent shot from just outside the penalty area after Winterburn had headed out Marshall's cross. 
 Lukic must have seen the ball extremely late but still managed to get down well. 
 Shortly afterwards Milligan's cross was almost turned into his own net by Winterburn, O'Leary recovering an awkward situation, but Arsenal could do nothing when Barlow, having a fine match at left-back, floated a diagonal cross to the very back of Arsenal's defence. 
 The ball eluded Winterburn, and Ritchie, Oldham's leading goalscorer, chested the ball down and crashed a fierce volley beyond Lukic. 
 Arsenal had no option but to take the attack to Oldham in the second half and Rhodes had to save from Thomas, Dixon and Quinn, but when a magnificent ball by Bunn sent Milligan streaking for goal he was hauled back by O'Leary, who was booked. 
 Arsenal were to pay for it. 
 Holden battered the free-kick against the wall and after a scramble the ball fell to Henry, who struck a low shot from more than 30 yards past Lukic. 
 Oldham Athletic: Rhodes; Irwin, Barlow, Henry, Barrett, Warhurst, Marshall, Ritchie, Bunn, Milligan, Holden. 
 Arsenal: Lukic; Dixon, Winterburn, Thomas, O'Leary, Adams, Rocastle, Richardson, Smith, Quinn, Jonsson (Groves, 65min). 
 Referee: R Gifford (Llandradach).. 
 Golden performance wins him many Aintree friends. 
 By Ken Oliver 
 JOHN McConnochie and Arthur Stephenson were both satisfied with the outcome of the Edward Hanmer Memorial Chase after their horses fought out a thrilling finish in the three mile handicap at Haydock yesterday. 
 Victory went to McConnochie's Golden Friend, whose win puts him in line for a tilt at next year's Grand National, while Stephenson's The Thinker proved that he will again be a force to be reckoned with in the Cheltenham Gold Cup in March. 
 The big disappointment was Yahoo. 
 The even-money favourite was never moving in his best style and was pulled up before the 15th fence. 
 The stewards inquired into the running of Yahoo and accepted Tom Morgan's explanation that: &bquo;He lost his action and didn't feel right and there was nothing else I could do but pull him up.&equo; 
 David Nicholson was quite pleased with Charter Party. 
 The 1988 Gold Cup victor led until two out, where lack of fitness told, and he finished third, 11 lengths behind the winner. 
 Graham McCourt can do little wrong at the moment and he gave Golden Friend a superb ride. 
 He and Chris Grant, on The Thinker, jumped the last together, but it was always on the cards that McCourt would have the upper hand. 
 However, full credit must go to The Thinker, who, giving a stone, battled all the way to the line and was beaten only one length. 
 Arthur Stephenson thought that his 1987 Gold Cup winner would need the race and 20-1 about him repeating the feat at Cheltenham again looks good each-way value. 
 McConnochie, who trains at Stratford-on-Avon and was formerly assistant to the now retired Mercy Rimell, said: &bquo;I think Golden Friend is an exciting prospect for the National.&equo; 
 This was McConnochie's third success in his career and he gave a hint that there may be more to come in the Hennessy at Newbury on Saturday, saying: &bquo;Gala's Image should run well as long as the ground is not sticky.&equo; 
 With Bigsun missing the Hennessy, Richard Dunwoody replaces John White on Brown Windsor, the 5-2 favourite. 
 David Elsworth is still looking for a jockey for Ghofar. 
 The Elsworth stable had good news regarding Barnbrook Again, who worked with all his old zest yesterday and will run in the North Street Chase at Newbury on Saturday. 
 Martin Pipe has a tremendous record at Haydock. 
 The Wellington trainer, who has a strike rate of just over 37 per cent at the Lancashire course, landed a double there yesterday with all-the-way winners Tri Folene and Star's Delight, and it would come as no surprise if he doubled that score today. 
 He could well land the opening three races with Royal Wonder, Pertemps Network and Huntworth, while Star's Delight can make it two wins in as many days by taking the Rainford Conditional Jockeys Handicap Chase. 
 Royal Wonder (1.00) is in cracking form. 
 She completed a hat-trick with a 12 lengths victory over previous scorer Milleone at Nottingham last month and should prove too sharp for her rivals in the Northern Junior Hurdle. 
 Pertemps Network (1.30) has frightened off all but two rivals in the Makerfield Novice Chase. 
 The five-year-old won eight of his ten hurdles races last season and looks the ideal type to do extremely well over fences. 
 After throwing away certain victory at Ascot, Huntworth (2.00) gained consolation with a two lengths win over Glenside Jerry at Devon two weeks ago. 
 This fine jumper is fanced to end the winning sequences of both Nautical Joke and Conclusive in the Save And Propser Handicap Chase. 
 At Wincanton Imperial Brush (1.45) is awarded the nap in the Wessex Handicap. 
 He ran well when third to Highland Bounty in a hot handicap at Cheltenham recently. 
 Motor Sport: Toyota take a Short cut. 
 By Mike Greasley 
 SAVIOURS come in many forms. 
 Today Toyota are pinning their hopes on Phil Short, a 45-year-old Yorkshireman from Ilkley. 
 Short, who actually stands 6ft 6in tall, could prove the key to Spain's Carlos Sainz winning his first Lombard RAC Rally for Toyota. 
 Short was co-driver for the British hope David Llewellin, but on Tuesday their British-prepared Toyota Celica crashed out of the five-day, 2,000-mile event. 
 Last night, however, Short received a phone call. 
 The British team co-ordinator Alistair Roberts explained: &bquo;Nobody knows Yorkshire better than Phil. 
 It's worth getting him involved. 
 His knowledge could be crucial.&equo; 
 Sainz could have done with him yesterday, when his lead was slashed by a charging Pentti Airikkala. 
 On wind and rainswept stages in the rugged Border country, the Mitsubishi driver was fastest on nine of the day's 10 stages. 
 The 27-year-old from Madrid had started yesterday's penultimate leg with a comfortable lead of 1min 36sec, but when he arrived at Newcastle last night it had been trimmed to 31sec. 
 Enter Short. 
 Today's final 78 miles of stages are over the notoriously deceptive Yorkshire forest roads. 
 With long straights and blind brows often hiding corners, experience counts for a lot. 
 With more than 20 years of rallying behind him, Short could give Sainz, or more importantly his co-driver Luis Moya, extra information which could make all the difference between winning, losing, or, even worse, crashing. 
 Moya is on only his second RAC. 
 Sainz is doing his third. 
 &bquo;Last year was my first &bquo;blind&equo; rally, the first without having practised the stages,&equo; said Moya. 
 &bquo;I thoroughly enjoyed it but felt five years older after the experience.&equo; 
 Compare this with Airikkala. 
 He has won four international rallies based on today's RAC stages and has been rallying almost exclusively in Britain since 1975. 
 Airikkala, 44, has even forsaken his native Finland to live in Britain. 
 Airikkala's Irish co-driver Ronan McNamee knows the forests equally well, but points out that trying to read the roads from a map is not so easy, particularly at speeds of up to 130mph. 
 &bquo;Sometimes it works fine but other times it's a complete mess,&equo; said McNamee. 
 &bquo;But we do know Yorkshire well. 
 &bquo;We wanted to start the final day within a minute of Carlos. 
 Obviously we believe we can make up the time on roads we have been over quite a few times.&equo; 
 The pressure is all on Sainz, known as &bquo;The Matador&equo; for his attacking and courageous driving style. 
 A former Spanish junior squash champion, he is one of a new breed of southern European drivers challenging the traditional domination of the Finns and Swedes. 
 The leading British driver is Malcolm Wilson, whose Opel was just out of the top 10 last night in 11th place, two minutes ahead of Gwyndaf Evans in his Ford Sierra in 12th place. 
 Scotland's Jimmy McRae was an unlucky 13th after surviving transmission problems and a brush with a bridge in his Ford. 
 Nottingham Forest 1, Everton 0 Tyson at centre of new controversy. 
 By David Lacey 
 THE Littlewoods Cup holders returned to the last eight of the competition last night in unusual and, Everton would claim, unjust circumstances. 
 Nottingham Forest had almost despaired of breaking down Everton's rebuilt defence when Lee Chapman won an entertaining fourth-round tie at the City Ground with a smartly taken goal seven minutes from the end. 
 While there was nothing extraordinary about the goal itself, Chapman turning the ball in at the near post after Clough had driven an indirect free-kick low through a crowd of players, the circumstances in which the kick had been given were a little odd and left Everton looking apoplectic. 
 Neville Southall, whose saves had prevented Forest running away with the game in the first half, gathered the ball and started to think about clearing it but in the view of the referee, George Tyson, he had thought too long. 
 A bemused Southall found himself cautioned for time-wasting and a few seconds later had to pick the ball out of the net. 
 Not for the first time this season Tyson needed a police escort at the end as he was surrounded by protesting players. 
 Colin Harvey, the Everton manager, ushered his team away. 
 The TV playback showed that Southall had held the ball for 13 seconds, although it did not seem as long at the time. 
 Harvey said later that he thought the decision had been harsh and added that there had been no warning given about time-wasting before the game, although he accepted that Tyson could have mentioned it to the players during the match, a fact confirmed by the referee as he left the ground. 
 Just over a fortnight ago two of Tyson's more controversial penalty decisions had help spark a free-for-all at the end of the League match between Arsenal and Norwich City which led to both clubs being charged with bringing the game into disrepute. 
 On the balance of last night's play, Everton were entitled to feel that they had done enough to take Forest back to Goodison Park. 
 Although they were still deprived by injury of their regular central defenders Ratcliffe and Watson, they managed to defend efficiently by using Snodin as a spare centre-back behind Keown and McDonald. 
 Even this appeared unlikely to stop Nottingham Forest in the first half. 
 Hodge and Parker commanded the midfield, Crosby and Rice, strongly supported by Laws and Pearce, drove forward on the flanks and it seemed only a matter of time before the right sort of cross reached Chapman or Clough. 
 Nottingham Forest later lost their momentum and McCall and Sheedy were now able to establish lasting contact with Newell and Sharp. 
 Crossley had to move quickly to save a glancing header from Sharp and just when it looked as if Forest might be more grateful for a replay Chapman won the tie. 
 Just what constitutes time-wasting is a matter for the referee's discretion, and if Tyson felt that Southall was deliberately using up precious seconds he was entitled to award Forest that crucial free-kick. 
 But everybody knows that, in other games at other times with oter referees, goalkeepers will dally and dawdle to a greater degree and get away with it. 
 To be effective this kind of refereeing has to be consistent. 
 Otherwise the letter of the law is an ass. 
 Nottingham Forest: Crossley; Laws, Pearce, Walker, Chettle, Hodge, Crosby, Parker, Clough, Chapman, Rice. 
 Everton: Southall; McDonald, Pointon, Keown, Snodin, Ebbrell, Nevin (Cottee, 85min), McCall, Sharp, Newell, Sheedy. 
 Referee: G Tyson (Sunderland).. 
 Welling swelling. 
 ON A night of Littlewoods Cup upsets it was left to Welling to perform similar derring-do in the FA Cup, writes Jack Massarik. 
 A first-half header from their former Crystal Palace defender Mark Hone saw off Gillingham, their near neighbours of the Fourth Division, 1-0 in a first-round replay. 
 It was the GM Vauxhall Conference side's first win over League opposition. 
 Fulham became London's sole representatives in the second round when they beat Bath 2-1 at Craven Cottage. 
 When Gary Smart gave the Beazer Homes League side the lead things looked bleak for a team winless for 11 games, but John Marshall and John Watson sealed a determined victory. 
 The recalled Torquay striker Jimmy Smith celebrated his 20th birthday with two goals in three minutes during a 4-0 win which dashed Sutton's hopes of another upset. 
 Phil Lloyd headed the opening goal. 
 Dartford's hopes also crumbled rapidly when Exeter scored three times in an eight-minute spell in the second half. 
 The Fourth Division side ran out 4-1 winners. 
 Colin Johnson scored Dartford's consolation goal. 
 Burnley came from behind to beat Stockport 2-1 at Edgeley Park and could thank their new signing Ron Futcher for the equaliser after Edwards had given the home side the lead. 
 O'Connell seized on a bad back-pass to lob the winner. 
 In the Littlewoods Cup two goals by Derby's McMinn disposed of West Bromwich Albion, and Manchester City's misery continued when Coventry put them out with a 16th-minute goal from Regis after a Redmond error. 
 Rangers, beaten 1-0 by Aberdeen last night, yesterday announced a &pound;5 million sponsorship, the biggest in British football, but declined to name their backer until the deal is signed. 
 Their Glasgows rivals Celtic were held to a 1-1 draw by St Mirren. 
 Sailing: Leaders neck and neck. 
 By Bob Fisher in Fremantle 
 THE leading yachts on the second leg of the Whitbread Round the World Race were almost in line abreast yesterday as they approached the finish here. 
 Fisher &amp; Paykel was the most northerly of the line, which ranged through Steinlager 2, Rothmans and Merit to the south-east. 
 With 450 miles to go, an area of high pressure will decide the finishing order. 
 The New Zealanders Grant Dalton and Peter Blake, skippers of Fisher &amp; Paykel and Steinlager 2, agree that the winner will be decided in the final miles. 
 &bquo;It's a matter of who has the right line past the high,&equo; said Dalton. 
 Blake said: &bquo;Tacking the way through the lighter winds will decide who wins the leg.&equo; 
 The yachts are slowing down as they approach Fremantle and the effect of the high-pressure zone becomes apparent. 
 Fisher &amp; Paykel was the first to be affected as speeds dropped from more than 11 knots to only eight. 
 Athletics. 
 Tony Morrell dashed Steve Cram's hopes yesterday when he informed the AAA that he would be fit to compete for England in the Commonwealth Games 1500 metres. 
 Tennis. 
 The projected &pound;4 million Grand Slam Cup has brought the sport's international community to a state of deadlock, writes Alan Page. 
 At a meeting in Frankfurt, the West German Federation has refused to bow to mounting pressure from the Grand Slam committee to sanction the cup. 
 &bquo;We believe it is bad for German tennis,&equo; the federation's chairman, Claus Stauder, said. 
 Boxing. 
 Monty Wright landed the decisive win in England's 6-5 victory over Poland in the amateur international at HMS Nelson, Portsmouth, last night &mdash; a unanimous points triumph over Jan Kopreckocaika &mdash; in front of the England Commonwealth Games selectors. 
 He will be hoping his performance will earn him a place in the 10-strong squad for New Zealand in January. 
 Mark Edwards, the ABA middleweight champion already in the Auckland squad, also won the vote of all three judges against Robert Buda, but the England captain Richie Woodhall got through only on a majority decision against his fellow Olympic bronze medal winner at light-middleweight. 
 American Football. 
 Villa Park will be the venue for the Birmingham club in the new International League. 
 The opening home game is against Rome on April 16. 
 Rugby League. 
 St Helens have signed Tea Ropati, the New Zealand centre, who was invalided home with a knee injury early in the Kiwis' English tour. 
 The League board last night deferred a decision on a new contract for the Great Britain coach, Malcolm Reilly. 
 Hockey. 
 Rob Thompson, of Hounslow, is unable to travel with the England team leaving for Oman and Pakistan on Monday because of his law examinations, writes Pat Rowley. 
 England will play a Punjab XI between their two Tests against Pakistan in Lahore. 
 Ice Hockey. 
 As part of Britain's world championship preparations, a British Select will meet the Swiss club Davos at Nottingham on December 7, writes Vic Batchelder. 
 Davos play Durham Wasps a day earlier. 
 American Football. 
 Villa Park will be the venue for the Birmingham club in the new International League. 
 The opening home game is against Rome on April 16. 
 Rugby League. 
 St Helens have signed Tea Ropati, the New Zealand centre, who was invalided home with a knee injury early in the Kiwis' English tour, writes Edward Kennedy. 
 The League board last night deferred a decision on a new contract for the Great Britain coach, Malcolm Reilly. 
 Hockey. 
 Rob Thompson, of Hounslow, is unable to travel with the England team leaving for Oman and Pakistan on Monday because of his law examinations, writes Pat Rowley. 
 England will play a Punjab XI between their two Tests against Pakistan in Lahore. 
 Ice Hockey. 
 As part of Britain's world championship preparations, a British Select will meet the Swiss club Davos at Nottingham on December 7, writes Vic Batchelder. 
 Davos play Durham Wasps a day earlier. 
 Tennis: Germans reject Grand Slam. 
 By Alan Page in Essen 
 THE projected &pound;4 million Grand Slam Cup has brought the international tennis community to a state of deadlock. 
 At a meeting in Frankfurt the West German Federation refused steadfastly to bow to mounting pressure from the Grand Slam committee to sanction the cup. 
 &bquo;We believe it is bad for German tennis,&equo; the West German Federation's chairman, Claus Stauder, said in Essen yesterday. 
 &bquo;They tried everything to convince us but we didn't buy it. 
 They clearly didn't expect we would stand firm.&equo; 
 The Grand Slam committee, including the chairman of the Wimbledon committee Buzzer Hadingham, and the International Federation are now in the embarrassing situation of having their event outlawed by the most powerful federation in the game. 
 Stauder referred to &bquo;this exorbitantly rewarded and grotesque event which gives the winner more prize money than Boris Becker has made this year&equo;. 
 He admitted the federation could not stop the tournament. 
 &bquo;But we cannot and will not sanction it,&equo; he said. 
 German fears are fourfold: uncontrollably escalating prize money; a form of financial saturation-bombing of the wealthiest tennis market in the world; downgrading of the German Open, which has a tradition stretching back 80 years; and a clash with the ATP finals scheduled for Frankfurt three weeks earlier. 
 For Stauder, the solution may lie in a merger of the ATP finals and the Grand Slam Cup. 
 Tranmere Rovers 2, Tottenham 2 Tranmere flying high in pursuit of another scalp. 
 By Cynthia Bateman 
 THE Tranmere Rovers players were so high on good publicity before this match that their manager, John King, said he would have to pull them down from the ceiling. 
 Now they are going through the roof en route to the moon, having forced Spurs into a replay. 
 Terry Venables was left picking his side up off the floor. 
 The Third Division front-runners, who had already knocked Millwall out of this competition and have not lost at home for 12 months, refused to be intimidated, then turned the tables. 
 Spurs have never been the same in cup competition since Port Vale knocked them out of the FA Cup. 
 But Venables had promised that his men would be made of sterner stuff this time, and their first-half guile and style foiled Tranmere's honest endeavours. 
 On the half-hour Gascoigne, put through by Thomas, meandered through the open gate of Tranmere's back yard to take the lead with a low, hard shot into the right-hand corner. 
 Tranmere wasted a good deal of splendid midfield work in the first half with long-range speculative shots into the stand. 
 But six minutes into the second half their central defender Vickers, who appeared to be standing several yards offside, received a pass from Bishop and his close-range shot levelled the score. 
 A petulant Gascoigne tried by fair means and foul, to his own discredit, to twirl the Tranmere defence, but it was the sleek performance of Lineker, playing deep, that provided the few chances Spurs had. 
 Both Samways and Allen brought fine saves from Nixon, and Samways had a goal disallowed. 
 But Tranmere, cocky even before the equaliser, played with skill and tenacity. 
 They took the lead when Steel headed in Hughes's perfect cross as Spurs' formation began to look as ragged as a returning Battle of Britain squadron. 
 Spurs' humiliation was compounded when Lineker mis-kicked wildly a few feet in front of goal and fell flat on his back. 
 It looked as though Spurs had regained their self-respect a few seconds later when the England striker appeared to net a Samways cross, but in fact Tranmere's full-back Higgins had put the ball past his goalkeeper. 
 VIPs in the crowd of 13,789 retired to the Tranmere Suite, where the scroll of memorable matches includes Tranmere's 1-1 draw with Spurs in a 1953 FA Cup tie. 
 What it does not mention is that the little club from the wrong side of the Mersey crashed out 9-1 in the replay, their worst defeat. 
 Tranmere Rovers: Nixon; Higgins, Pike, Bishop, Hughes, Vickers, Morrissey (Malkin, 71min), Harvey, Steel, Muir, Mungall. 
 Tottenham Hotspur: Thorstvedt; Thomas, Polston, Bergsson (Stevens, 69), Howells, Mabbutt, Samways, Gascoigne, Stewart (Walsh, 80), Lineker, Allen. 
 Referee: L Shapter (Torquay).. 
 Tranmere Rovers 2, Tottenham 2 Spurs tossed a lifeline. 
 By Cynthia Bateman 
 TRANMERE ROVERS, of the Third Division, forced a replay against a shaken Spurs side who were rescued by a Higgins own goal in the 69th minute of this Littlewoods Cup fourth-round tie. 
 Rovers have never been the same since they knocked Newcastle and Wimbledon out of the Centenary Trophy. 
 Their manager, John King, said his players were so high on publicity that before this match he had to pull them down from the ceiling. 
 Terry Venables was left picking his players up off the floor after Tranmere, who have not lost at Prenton Park in 12 months, achieved a worthy draw against their lofty visitors. 
 The Tottenham manager had said that his team would be tougher than the ones that were overturned by Port Vale and Bradford in notorious FA Cup defeats, and better than the one that struggled against Southend in an earlier round of this competition. 
 But it was Spurs' guile rather than their aggression that earned them a first-half lead when Thomas put Gascoigne through. 
 He was able to meander past the Tranmere defence and finish with a low hard shot that spun past Nixon's outstretched hands. 
 Gascoigne, appearing riled by some of the rough-and-tumble of Tranmere's enthusiasm, teased and toyed with their defence, beating one, two and three defenders, only to fall foul of three more when a simple pass would have done the business. 
 Lineker showed him how it is done, playing deep and feeding Samways and Allen with slick passes that brought two excellent saves from Nixon, a disallowed goal by Samways, and a reaction from the Tranmere defence which was somewhat reminiscent of a metal crusher in a scrapyard. 
 But Tranmere were not all hustle and bustle. 
 They had their moments of flair but they wasted good midfield work with speculative shots into the stand. 
 Only one, a volley by Muir &mdash; released by Venables when he was manager of Queen's Park Rangers &mdash; caused Thorstvedt any anxiety. 
 Six minutes into the second half, Tranmere, always alert and certainly never overawed, equalised through a shot from their central defender Vickers who, viewed from the stand, looked offside by several yards. 
 Tranmere now were not only confident but cocky, and as Spurs deteriorated into a formation as ragged as a returning Battle of Britain squadron it was the Third Division side who found space and time. 
 In the 62nd minute Hughes crossed perfectly for Steel to head them into the lead. 
 A mis-kick in front of goal by Lineker compounded Spurs' humiliation. 
 But seconds later both the England striker and his team recovered their self respect when he netted a Samways cross &mdash; although it finally went down as an own goal by Higgins. 
 Tranmere Rovers: Nixon; Higgins, Pike, Bishop, Hughes, Vickers, Morrissey, Harvey, Steel, Muir, Mungall. 
 Tottenham Hotspur: Thorstvedt; Thomas, Polston, Bergsson, Howells, Mabbutt, Samways, Gascoigne, Stewart, Lineker, Allen. 
 Referee: L Shapter (Torquay).. 
 West Ham 1, Wimbledon 0 Dicks sent off, five booked on night of the steamers. 
 By Ian Ridley 
 AMESSY match disgraced by a series of violent tackles and subsequent scenes of inflamed confrontations between players was, quite out of context, settled by a breathtaking goal by Martin Allen 10 minutes from time. 
 West Ham had their captain Julian Dicks sent off and four other players were booked, as well as the Wimbledon physiotherapist. 
 Just when you thought it was safe to watch another Wimbledon game&hellip; 
 Their disciplinary record has slowly improved under Bobby Gould and they will point out, correctly, that West Ham played as great a part in the mayhem. 
 That cannot excuse them, however, and the FA will probably be interested in both teams' excuses. 
 It was the third time in three weeks that such ugly scenes had been witnessed at London grounds. 
 The referee, Alfred Buksh, who rarely had control of a game that at one point seemed unlikely to be completed, booked Wimbledon's Phelan, Wise, Young and the physiotherapist, Steve Allen, for treating an injured player without permission, and West Ham's Allen and Dicks, before his dismissal. 
 Forty three minutes of crass, artless thumping of a ball, just shaded by Wimbledon by virtue of Young's header being cleared off the line by Keen, preceded the first flare-up. 
 Wise fouled Dicks near a touchline and the West Ham left back responded with a retaliatory elbow. 
 Young led, in terrace parlance, the steaming in, which at one stage involved at least 10 players with punches appearing to be thrown. 
 The nearby crowd surged forward and police had to intervene. 
 Only Wise was cautioned &mdash; Phelan's earlier had been, curiously, for delaying a throw-in &mdash; and the referee missed an opportunity to establish his authority. 
 Five minutes into the second half Allen challenged Young late and this time Sanchez led the steamers, closely followed by Dicks. 
 This time Allen and Dicks were cautioned, Allen fortunate not to be shown a red card as he harangued the referee. 
 Another posse gathered around the referee in the 56th minute after Young's high challenge on Allen, for which the Wimbledon defender was booked. 
 Yet another occurred four minutes later after Dicks's scything tackle on Wise, for which a sending-off could be the only outcome. 
 All this was &bquo;played&equo; to a backdrop of police ejecting incensed supporters from terrace and stand. 
 The referee, who needed a police escort from the pitch, was pelted with missiles as he spoke to an officer. 
 His refusal of a penalty when Allen was fouled by Curle made matters worse, but he was correct in ruling that Brady had already fouled Segers. 
 Slater also had a shot cleared off the line by Joseph. 
 Poor Brady, a ballet dancer in a bearpit. 
 And then there was Devonshire, who at least attempted to get West Ham going. 
 The hype surrounding Justin v John Fashanu did not materialise but Justin came on, only to miss from a few yards as Sanchez intervened, leading to his injury and the booking of the Wimbledon physio. 
 Finally a goal came. 
 Slater sent Ward away on the left and his cross was met by Allen who unleashed a stunning volley into the net of which Marco van Basten would hve been proud. 
 Even then, Cork had a late chance to equalise but screwed his shot wide. 
 &bquo;There were four or five incidents which nobody is pleased to see,&equo; admitted Gould. 
 &bquo;I will be dealing with it in-house.&equo; 
 His West Ham counterpart, Lou Macari, was less open. 
 &bquo;I want to avoid it,&equo; he said of the &bquo;little incidents&equo;, but, when pressed, added: &bquo;You can't control footballers on the field.&equo; 
 Neither are West Ham fans likely to agree with his saying: &bquo;Our supporters are only interested in us getting into the next round.&equo; 
 West Ham: Parkes; Potts, Dicks, Strodder, Martin, Keen (Fashanu, 70min), Brady, Slater, Allen, Ward, Parris, (Devonshire, 41). 
 Wimbledon: Segers; Joseph, Phelan, Ryan, Young, Curle, Fairweather, Cotterill, Miller (Cork, 75), Sanchez (Scales, 70), Wise. 
 Referee: A Buksh (London). 
 Quote&hellip;. 
 TODAY, De Klerk talks about beach apartheid and Separate Amenities Act, but what about those pillars of apartheid like the Group Areas Act, the Population Registration Act and the very fundamental laws that govern the political life of our country? 
 What is the use of going to open beaches when we must return to segregated residential areas and schools and suffer under the laws that make the best medical treatment the prerogative of the whites only in our country? 
 What is the point of bathing together in the beaches when in fact we cannot sit together to make the laws of our country? 
 We have demonstrated against petty apartheid because we are taking on the entire system of apartheid on all fronts. 
 But these campaigns have never been isolated from the fundamental issue of power, the issue of who rules our country, who has this right to make and unmake the law. 
 ANC radio, Addis Ababa, 
 November 17 (BBC monitoring) 
 Obituary Rene Muawad. 
 Controversial conciliator:. 
 LEBANESE President Rene Muawad, killed in a car bomb assassination on Wednesday, was a conciliator who tried to restore Lebanese peace and unity after 14 years of civil war. 
 He was 64. 
 He was murdered one day after he told Lebanese, on the eve of their 46th independence anniversary, that their divided country was close to peace. 
 In the short period since his election by Parliament on November 5, Muawad tried in vain to spread his government's hold beyond Syrian-controlled regions and a part of the Christian enclave north of Beirut. 
 Muawad was elected during a Parliament session held at an air base in northern Lebanon. 
 The election was part of an Arab League-sponsored peace plan. 
 But he immediately faced opposition from a fellow Maronite, the Christian army commander Gen Michel Aoun, who denounced Muawad as a Syrian puppet and claimed his election was unconstitutional. 
 Muawad had been a member of the 99-seat Parliament since he was elected to represent his home region in 1957 at age 32. 
 An early advocate of national reconciliation, Muawad had taken part in the 20-member &bquo;national dialogue committee&equo; formed in September 1975 to find a settlement to the civil war, then five months old. 
 The Muawad family, and the Issa Khoury clan to which his wife Naila belongs, are allied with the powerful Franjiehs in the northeastern region. 
 The Franjiehs, who have their own Marada, or Giants, militia, are headed by former president Suleiman Franjieh, one of the last of the old-style Maronite warlords. 
 Muawad graduated from the French-affilated St. Joseph University in Christian east Beirut with a law degree in 1947. 
 He started his own practice in the northern provincial capital of Tripoli two years later, but gave it up when he entered Parliament. 
 But Muawad spent his first year in Parliament as an exile in the Syrian port city of Lattakia, after a member of a rival family accused him of taking part in an inter-clan clash in June 1957 near Zghotra in which 16 people were killed. 
 The House refused demands it stripped Muawad of his parliamentary immunity. 
 He returned to Lebanon in 1958, shortly after newly elected President Fuad Chahab dropped charges against him for &bquo;lack of undisputed evidence.&equo; 
 Later, the witness who had testified against Muawad withdrew his allegation, saying it was &bquo;politically motivated.&equo; 
 Muawad was Minister of Telegraphs and Telecommunications from 1961. 
 He was named Minister of Public Works in 1969 and Minister of Education in 1980. 
 While he held the Education Portfolio, Muawad sliced through sectarian hatreds to organise school examinations for Christian and Moslem youngsters whose studies had been interrupted by the war. 
 Muawad married Nayla Khoury on Feb. 11, 1965. 
 They have a daughter, Rima, 22, and a son, Michel, 17. 
 Muawad (right) meeting the Soviet Ambassador this month 
 The Russians are coming Faced with social turbulence and resurgent anti-Semitism, many thousands of Soviet Jews are emigrating to their spiritual home. 
 Ian Black in Tel Aviv asks whether Israel, willing but hardly prepared for the influx, can cope. 
 VALERY and Ina and their children were visibly tired as they traipsed into the Ministry of Immigrant Absorption reception hall at Ben Gurion Airport. 
 It had been a long, slow journey from Odessa and although it was already 1am there were still many more official forms to fill out before their new life in Israel could begin. 
 Victoria, aged 12, made a beeline for the reconstituted orange juice and sandwiches prepared by a pair of stout volunteer ladies who arrived from Russia themselves a few years back, and two-year-old Oleg was soon roaring about wildly on a plastic fire-engine in the playroom. 
 There were about 100 of them on Sunday's evening flight from Bucharest to Tel Aviv, unmistakably Soviet with their fur hats, cheap wintry clothes and suitcases and quiet, mechanical submission to the first taste of Israeli bureaucracy. 
 Fair-haired Jews from Moscow and Leningrad mingled with olive-skinned Georgians to read the Cyrillic slogans welcoming them and then sank down in rows of plastic chairs or gazed at the panoramic photograph of Jerusalem covering an entire wall. 
 A toothless old man from Baku, his double-breasted jacket beribboned with the medals of two world wars, looked dazed. 
 At 93, little remained of the liturgical Hebrew he had studied before the October Revolution, but he was pleased to be leaving his quarrelsome Armenian and Azerbaijani neighbours behind. 
 Dimitri Bogakovsky, a 36-year-old doctor from Kiev, was radiantly happy. 
 &bquo;I feel I have come home,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'm only sorry I didn't come to Israel 20 years ago.&equo; 
 Ina, a teacher, was more cautious. 
 &bquo;At the moment I can say I wanted to come here and not to America,&equo; she smiled. 
 &bquo;What I'll be saying in a year's time I don't know.&equo; 
 Several flights like these, some from Budapest and Vienna, are now arriving at Ben Gurion every week, their human cargoes eloquent testimony to the swelling numbers of Soviet Jewish emigrants and the vast changes that Mikhail Gorbachev's policies have wrought in their homeland. 
 Economic and political uncertainty and the rise of truculent local nationalisms from the Baltic to the Caspian have raised the ancient spectre of anti-Semitism, never far below the surface of Soviet life. 
 Under glasnost and perestroika, the last great untapped pool of world Jewry is on the move. 
 Exact numbers are unavailable: 2.5 to three million is the accepted figure, though 70 years of cultural and religious suppression, intermarriage and assimilation means that the real number &mdash; in Zionist terms those who qualify for automatic Israeli citizenship under the Law of Return &mdash; may be far higher. 
 Turbulence at home, combined with an American decision to restrict Jewish immigrants from the Soviet Union, mean that the stream of emigration is now directed almost exclusively at Israel. 
 The challenge is immense, and no one is sure whether it can be met. 
 According to the latest projections, 100,000 Soviet Jews will arrive in Israel over the next three years, and the numbers may be even higher if and when direct flights start from Moscow to Tel Aviv, the most important tangible sign of the rapid thaw in Soviet-Israeli relations. 
 In comparative terms, such an influx is the equivalent of the movement of three million East Germans to West Germany, a country (unlike Israel) with a healthy economy where difficulties of acclimatization for the newcomers will be at a minimum and language problems non-existent. 
 If the Russians do arrive on this scale it will be the largest single wave of what Israelis call aliya (literally &bquo;ascent&equo;) since the immediate post independence years in the early 1950s, a heady return to the heart of the Zionist idea at a time when the country &mdash; still fighting the Palestinian uprising, on a permanent war footing and its economy slipping into recession &mdash; is far from ready. 
 THE FIRST big wave of Russians came after the 1967 war, when Zionist feelings were awakened by Israel's six day victory and Soviet support for the Arabs. 
 Moscow underestimated the phenomenon, believing that if the hard core of &bquo;provocateurs&equo; were allowed to emigrate the vast majority would stay. 
 The emigration movement reached a peak in 1973 with 33,000 Jews leaving. 
 It dipped after the Yom Kippur war, rising again to 51,000 in 1979. 
 Until 1982 figures dropped steadily again, reaching a low point in 1986. 
 Even in the good years Israel had only a share. 
 Between 1968 and 1988 280,000 Jews emigrated, but only 165,000 came to Israel. 
 In 1988 the drop-out rate reached a staggering 92 per cent. 
 But in the first 10 months of 1989 alone over 7,000 have arrived, and there are expected to be 10,000 by the end of the year. 
 The new wave is not in the heroic mould of famous &bquo;refuseniks&equo; like Anatoly Scharansky, Ida Nudel and Josef Begun, who finally arrived in Israel after years of persecution, exile and imprisonment. 
 Few of the newcomers know any Hebrew and few have more than the vaguest idea about Israel. 
 Many would have preferred America. 
 With the Berlin Wall, the most famous barrier of all, falling, the more media-conscious activists among the Soviet Jews already here are warning that Israel is just not prepared for the influx. 
 &bquo;Israel's lack of preparedness for mass Soviet Jewish immigration is psychologically understandable but not politically forgivable,&equo; says Yuri Stern, a Muscovite who came in 1981. 
 &bquo;Its very difficult to appreciate a revolution, to see today as really qualitatively, dramatically different from the day before. 
 Its difficult to go beyond normal scepticism and see this huge number not just as a potential but as a reality.&equo; 
 Israelis are pleased with the change in the US regulations, which effectively signal an end to the drop-out phenomenon. 
 &bquo;Israel,&equo; says one senior official, &bquo;has never been interested in emigration as such, but in aliya &mdash; in having as many Jews as possible come to Israel.&equo; 
 In this perspective, places like the Ladispoli transit camp near Rome, where thousands of Soviet Jews are still awaiting visas to the US, are a disgrace. 
 A thriving Jewish life in New York's Brighton Beach will not reinforce Israel. 
 Freedom of choice is no longer on the agenda, especially now that American Jews have discovered that it is easier to raise money for absorbing Soviet Jews in Israel than it is for resettling them in the US. 
 The Israeli government has been agonisingly slow to take up the challenge, although it has calculated that US&dollar;3 billion will be needed over three years for housing, job creation and other aspects of large-scale immigrant absorption. 
 The bureaucracy certainly needs streamlining: the immigrants are met initially by the Absorption Ministry, but once in the country many of their needs are looked after by the Jewish Agency, the semi-private organisation that dates back to the early years of Jewish settlement in Palestine. 
 The two bodies are often at loggerheads, and there are constant disputes over methods: are the newcomers best served by direct absorption &mdash; being given money and subsidies for their first year and then left to cope on their own, or by being placed in one of the 38 Jewish Agency absorption centres. 
 LEARNING Hebrew is a priority for all, and places in the famous ulpan system are available at once. 
 But even after six months of intensive study many other problems remain. 
 A Soviet engineer who lost his job a decade ago after applying to emigrate needs to catch up. 
 Doctors need to retrain for eight months. 
 At the big Mevasseret absorption centre near Jerusalem, where there are 77 Russian families in different stages of acclimatization, only half the breadwinners are working. 
 Unskilled workers tend to do better than the professionals, enjoying the advantages of a free market for the first time in their lives. 
 On the positive side, the changes inside the Soviet Union will help: with the unprecedented flowering of Jewish cultural freedom, Hebrew classes are now a possibility; potential immigrants can now learn more about Israel before they come. 
 Another innovation is the stream of Jewish tourists visiting Israel from Russia: 25,000 have been since 1988, and the Jewish Agency sees this is a uniquely helpful way to win hearts and minds. 
 Forty thousand are expected next year. 
 The new arrivals, like their predecessors, tend towards the right of the political spectrum. 
 &bquo;Of course we thought about political problems, but everyone in Israel suffers from the same ones,&equo; says Igor, a railway engineer studying at the Mevasseret ulpan. 
 &bquo;I'm content to go into the army, and I'm definitely against giving up territory to the Arabs.&equo; 
 The veterans are pleased, but accept that the newcomers are coming here less out of choice than of necessity. 
 Haim Scheider, an economist who left Lithuania 10 years ago, has been unemployed for 18 months, but still has no regrets. 
 He visited his former homeland last summer and couldn't bear it. 
 &bquo;You make comparisons all the time and the comparison is in Israel's favour, there's no doubt about it. 
 People have achieved things here that they coudn't do in Russia, not even in their wildest dreams.&equo; 
 Haim, who speaks halting Hebrew with a heavy accent, still leads an intensely Russian life in the new West Bank settlement north of Jerusalem where he lives with his wife and two children. 
 &bquo;My son is already an Israeli,&equo; he laughs, &bquo;he prefers humus and felafel to gefilte fish.&equo; 
 Difficulties abound, but it seems that the Russians are coming anyway. 
 &bquo;In times of emergency we behave differently from normal times,&equo; says Meir Edlestein, the director of the Mevasseret absorption centre. 
 &bquo;This is a very Zionist answer.&equo; 
 More practical answers will have to be provided as the Jews pour in, huddled on the platform of rapidly changing history, anxious to change their lives in an imperfect world. 
 &bquo;The marriage between Soviet Jews and Israel is a marriage that is probably going to happen,&equo; argues Yuri Stern, &bquo;whether or not the bride and groom feel they are really ready for it.&equo; 
 And did those feet&hellip; predecessors of the new wave of Soviet Jews walking to Palestine in the 1930sPHOTOGRAPH: BBC HULTON PICTURE LIBRARY corrections page 19 
 Mailbox. 
 JACK SCHOFIELD's article (November 23) guesses that there are only 20 X Window products available. 
 We have had six products on the market for over a year. 
 All try to use the power of the workstation in general, and X in particular, to present information in a more effective way. 
 Perhaps the most dramatic example is our vdiff product which simply compares two files. 
 The House of Lords, who do a lot of comparing of information as Bills go through, bought a Sun workstation just to use it. 
 Peter Brown, Professor of Computer Science, University of Kent, Canterbury CT2 7NF. 
 AS PER normal on Thursday I bought the Guardian in order to read your computer pages. 
 I was pleased to come across an item in Microfile (November 30) about the launch of Teesside Poly's course on computerised communications using CMCS (computer-mediated communication systems) delivery. 
 I was slightly taken aback, however, to read that this was the &bquo;UK's first&equo; such course. 
 CECOMM (the Centre for Electronic Communications and Open Support Systems in Education) has been delivering courses in computerised communications via CMCS since 1987. 
 CECOMM is the UK's leading value-added provider in the application of CMCS to education and training, and has developed a set of formal communications-based methodologies, &bquo;Social Network Design&equo;, which allow organisations to evaluate and access this delivery mechanism both at LAN and WAN (local and wide area network) level. 
 Rather than reinventing the &bquo;virtual classroom&equo;, may I suggest the staff at Teesside Poly could have contacted CECOMM and availed themselves of our tutor-moderated training programme, and in the process saved themselves considerable time and angst. 
 Still, they are about to discover the very real difficulties of using this medium during the delivery of their first course. 
 Dick Davies, Coordinator HIT/CECOMM, Southampton Institute of Higher Education, Southampton SO9 4WW. 
 IREAD with interest the article on the introduction of information technology into the NHS (Kicking and screaming, November 23). 
 Our group is researching prototypes for an intelligent computerised information environment for use in general practice. 
 Two projects, Practitioners Enter Notes (Pen) and Practioners Access Data (Pad), funded by the Department of Health and the Medical Research Council respectively, are applying user-centred design strategies in the development of a human-computer environment for use within the GP's consulting room. 
 Bernard Horen, University of Manchester Medical Informatics Group, Dept of Computer Science, Oxford Road, Manchester M13 9PL. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Prototyping is crucial to systems development, argues Ian Richards Tailored to fit. 
 IN SYSTEMS development nothing is more fundamental than assessing user requirements. 
 If you don't know what the system is required to do; you don't know anything. 
 But many system developers are unable to assess requirements properly. 
 They seem to think that you can ask a businessman what his requirements are and get an answer that amounts to a draft system specification. 
 A doctor doesn't ask his patient what treatment to prescribe. 
 The patient can explain only what the problem is. 
 It is the doctor that provides the remedy. 
 If you ask a user what sort of system he wants you will be met with a blank look. 
 A user may have a deep knowledge of business problems, but knowing little about computers, has no idea how they should be tackled. 
 Yet, analysts are heard asking time and again, &bquo;Tell me what you want. 
 We've gone away from the days of systems imposed by the data processing department, this is going to be a system for the users.&equo; 
 But of course the users don't know what they want, so they end up getting another duff system. 
 An effective analyst provides the same service to the business as the doctor provides to the patient. 
 He finds out what the needs of the business are, and prescribes the cure. 
 The user tells the analyst what the problems are, and the analyst decides, at least in broad terms, what the user requires. 
 But the analyst has one great advantage over the doctor. 
 Once the user becomes familiar with the proposed system, helpful comments come thick and fast. 
 &bquo;Oh, this will be of great help in ordering raw materials, but sometimes we get part deliveries, could we have an extra facility to deal with those? 
 And sometimes non-standard discount is given, a pig to deal with on the old system, but if you could add one extra input box on that screen there&hellip; 
 And what about orders not delivered on time? 
 If we could list those we'd have advance warning of shortage problems on the assembly lines two months before they occur. 
 Now that would be a great leap forward.&equo; 
 Unfortunately you cannot reach this stage until you have developed a prototype system. 
 And you can't develop a prototype system because the users haven't got a clue what they want. 
 Most of them are probably muttering, &bquo;I'm too busy to get involved in this sort of thing. 
 What's wrong with the old system anyway?&equo; 
 The only way to develop a prototype is for the analyst to get inside the head of the user and, thinking like a user, decide what sort of system is required. 
 Of course, the initial system will not be perfect. 
 The analyst cannot hope to understand the business as well in a few weeks as the user does after many years. 
 But once the user sees the system, channels of communication will open. 
 Instead of persuading the user to specify requirements, the analyst will be driven by the user to meet key needs. 
 Good system development goes through two distinct phases. 
 Initially the analyst does all the work, leading the user towards a system he thinks is right for the business. 
 But once the user sees the potential of the system, a change in attitude takes place. 
 The process becomes demand driven by the user. 
 The analyst is then forced on the defensive, explaining why new features cannot be included because they are technically difficult or prohibitively expensive. 
 Traditionally, systems were validated by users agreeing functional specifications. 
 In theory, validation meant that the user had read the specification, imagined how the system would work in practice, and agreed the design. 
 It was only when using a &bquo;test&equo; version of the system (available just before the planned implementation date) that difficulties would come to light, and a host of change requests be issued. 
 The advent of fourth generation languages (4GLs) has made system development much easier. 
 With a 4GL an initial prototype can be put together quickly. 
 This means feedback is obtained early in the development process, and the system can grow around the user's requirements. 
 Crucial to the development process is the relationship built up between the analyst and the user. 
 The best systems arise when both have a deep understanding of each other's jobs. 
 Many developers use business analysts to ensure that the development team maintain a proper focus on business requirements. 
 But this can be counter-productive, as it cuts off communication between the systems analyst and the user. 
 Too much specialisation is bad for systems development; it feeds the temptation to get engrossed in technical difficulties and forget about the underlying business needs. 
 If you should stroll into a pub and meet an analyst and a user talking about work, and you cannot tell one from the other, they have probably developed a successful system together. 
 Ian Richards' book, How to Use a Computer to Improve Your Business, has just been published by Graham &amp; Trotman (&pound;8.95 paperback; &pound;16 hardback). 
 Tel: 01-821 1123. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Microfile. 
 By Jack Schofield Computer editor 
 ALPHA is a new master operating system designed to interconnect disparate and widely distributed systems to act as a single cohesive whole. 
 It is being financed largely by the US Department of Defense, and made available free. 
 Alpha is being developed for systems like the US Advanced Tactical Fighter, which has about 20 real-time computer systems on board, the NASA space station, and possibly the Strategic Defense Initiative. 
 The project is being led by Doug Jensen at the Concurrent Computer Corp., Massachusetts. 
 He originally developed Alpha as a research project at Carnegie-Mellon University. 
 Then General Dynamics used it to demonstrate a ground-based air defense application. 
 Alpha is written in C++ and will run initially on Concurrent's Mips-based multi-processor mini-supercomputers, which will be launched next month. 
 It co-exists with Concurrent's RTU (Real-Time Unix), and has an object-orientated user interface designed for the production of large, complex, real-time applications. 
 Alpha assumes the computing system is distributed, and it includes replication mechanisms to provide distributed programming and &bquo;survivability&equo;. 
 It manages tasks by setting deadlines for their completion, instead of using interrupts simply to start them going. 
 When deadlines can't be met, Alpha &bquo;gracefully degrades&equo; by meeting as many as possible of the most important ones. 
 Although the defence applications are obvious, Alpha could become important in &bquo;mission critical&equo; commercial systems. 
 Examples include factory automation and large on-line financial networks. 
 A &bquo;Baby Alpha&equo; will be developed, using VRTX, for smaller integrated systems. 
 The beta-test version of Alpha is due for release at the end of 1990, with the first commercial release in 1993. 
 Concurrent says the ultimate aim is to produce a supplier-independent, open operating system that will rank alongside Unix, and be complementary to it. 
 Concurrent is seeking European partners for the Alpha project via its UK office in Maidenhead (tel: 0753 77777). 
 More Mips. 
 NIXDORF and Tandem are developing a fault-tolerant mini based on Risc (Reduced instruction set computer) chips from Mips Computer Systems and the Unix operating system. 
 The new machine will be marketed by both firms next year. 
 Nixdorf is also co-operating with Pyramid Technology, whose technology is used in Nixdorf's Targon/35. 
 (Pyramid is yet another Mips reseller.) 
 Meanwhile, Control Data has signed an agreement to sell Mips' cheap Unix-based RC6280 mini/mainframe. 
 With a Risc processor rated at 55 mips (million instructions per second), this is the industry's fastest general-purpose computer. 
 Wizard. 
 IBM has announced the Wizard adaptor, which puts a 33MHz Intel i860 Risc 64-bit processor on an expansion card for 386-based PCs with MCA (Micro Channel Architecture) buses and the OS/2 operating system. 
 It will be used for oil industry and financial modelling and similar supercomputing tasks. 
 The card delivers about 27 mips and costs &pound;5,568 plus VAT, with the memory expansion at &pound;2,915. 
 Applications development tools, originating from Intel, cost an extra &pound;1,168. 
 Not super. 
 THE US and Japan have fallen out over supercomputer sales. 
 The Americans are complaining that the Japanese market is closed to them. 
 The Japanese are replying that the US market is closed to them. 
 To prove it, Fujitsu (which owns 46 per cent of Amdahl) has announced that Amdahl is to stop selling Fujitsu supercomputers in the US. 
 It has sold only two in the last four years. 
 XVision. 
 VISIONWARE has launched XVision, a standalone X server which allows X client programs to be displayed in MicroSoft Windows. 
 A PC can work as an X terminal on a network or connected to a minicomputer host, without sacrificing access to DOS programs. 
 SQL-Connect, a companion program, can link Windows applications with Unix databases to load data from Informix, Oracle or Uniplex into, say, MicroSoft's Excel spread-sheet. 
 VisionWare, based in Leeds, was formed recently as a management buy-out from Systime (tel.: 0532 529292). 
 16Mbits. 
 NEC IS starting up the world's first production line for 16 megabit chips in its Sagamihara factory, reports Ken Takahashi of Newsbytes. 
 Experimental operation should lead to samples of 16Mbit chips being delivered in 1991. 
 Each chip will be able to hold roughly 336,000 words or 80 pages of the Guardian. 
 Scroll on. 
 ADVENTURE software house Magnetic Scrolls &mdash; known for The Pawn and other popular games &mdash; has signed with Virgin Mastertronic, part of the Branson empire. 
 Scrolls' previous games were published on the Rainbird label before British Telecomsoft sold out to the US giant, Microprose. 
 Microprose is continuing to issue games on both the ex-BT Rainbird and Firebird labels. 
 But the latest Rainbird game being played here &mdash; First Contact, just out on the Atari ST &mdash; is packed in a green box instead of the blue ones loved by BT. 
 It doesn't seem quite right for a game where, for the first time, you meet intelligent alien life forms, and kill them. 
 The winner. 
 THE winner of Computer Guardian's Compaq Competition is Allan Kelly of Slough, Bucks, whose card was first out of the hat. 
 Answers: Adam Osborne was first to launch a portable (1b), but Compaq was first with an IBM PC-compatible model (2b). 
 These were mains-powered luggables, which led to smaller, battery-powered machines being called laptops (3c). 
 &bquo;Notebook&equo; PCs are even smaller, and several are available, but the Compaq LTE is the only one with a standard 3.5 inch disc drive (4c). 
 So far portables have about 10 per cent of the PC market (5b), and sales are growing for all the reasons given in the last question (6d), including &bquo;yuppies love them.&equo; 
 Allan's prize is a Compaq LTE/286 with 20 megabyte hard disc, worth &pound;2,850 plus VAT. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Jack Schofield provides a user-friendly guide to the home computers on offer this Christmas and picks the best-value buys Avoiding turkeys. 
 CHRISTMAS is coming, and the home computer companies are hoping to get fat. 
 Lots of machines have been nicely packaged for the market, but there are no bargains to be had. 
 Anyone who just wants to play arcade-type games might as well buy a games console. 
 These are relatively cheap, the games come on easy-to-load cartridges and are, on average, better than the home computer versions. 
 Atari invented the console, and its old 2600 is the cheapest on the market at &pound;40 or less. 
 But in the US and Japan, Nintendo has become the standard, with NEC and Sega being the main challengers. 
 However, with NEC's PC Engine not officially available in the UK, and the Nintendo system overpriced at around &pound;100, the Sega Master (&pound;80 or less) is the best choice. 
 It has good colours and, although it uses a Zilog Z-80 processor, like the Spectrum, the games are fast. 
 There are three points to bear in mind about 8-bit consoles. 
 First, all the suppliers are preparing superior but incompatible 16-bit versions, including the Nintendo Super Famicom and the Sega Megadrive (the latter having already arrived as an unofficial import, at &pound;200). 
 Second, games cost much more than those for 8-bit home micros. 
 Third, you can get a real computer for less. 
 Indeed, the cheapest &bquo;real computer&equo; has a dual nature. 
 The Atari XE is an &pound;80 games console which comes with dedicated cassette recorder and an add-on keyboard which can be used for word processing or, say, adventure games. 
 It is also available as the Atari 65XE home micro for about &pound;10 more. 
 The XE is a good machine, barely changed from the Atari 800 from 1979. 
 It has 64K of memory, an 8-bit 6502 processor and a poor Basic. 
 It is rather faster than a Commodore 64, and has similar graphics and sound, which makes the hardware good value. 
 You can add disc drives and printers for serious use. 
 However, the XE is not well supported by software houses, and although it still has a lot of games, most of these are very old. 
 Top 20 games are now almost never converted to run on it, which purchasers would find very frustrating. 
 Today's 8-bit standards are the Commodore 64, Spectrum +2 and +3, and Amstrad CPC-464 and 6128. 
 Of these, only the Commodore 64C is now worth buying, and only then if you never plan to add a disc drive. 
 The Commodore 64 also has a 6502-type processor, 64K, very good graphics and sound, and the worst Basic still fitted to a home micro. 
 But it is very well supported for games, since it is a standard in both the US and in Europe, whereas the Amstrad and Sinclair Z-80-based machines failed in the US. 
 The drawback with the C64 is that it is expensive at about &pound;150. 
 The price includes a dedicated cassette recorder, the C2N, which doesn't work particularly well, if at all, with today's fast-loading games. 
 It is much better to buy a naked C64 and one of the superior independent cassette players such as Mills Associates' Load-It. 
 Further, the price means it isn't worth upgrading a C64 by adding Commodore's slow disc drive. 
 You might as well buy an Atari ST, with its better built-in disc drive, to start with. 
 Nevertheless, the C64 is far superior to the Amstrad-made Spectrum, which is on sale at the same price. 
 The Spectrum +2, with its built-in cassette recorder, simply isn't worth &pound;150. 
 The +3 is better value at &pound;200, since this includes a built-in disc drive. 
 However, this is the 3-inch drive peculiar to Amstrad products, and you would be better off paying the extra &pound;35 for a discount Atari ST. 
 The Amstrad CPC, although quite a good micro, is also poor value now. 
 The CPC-464 comes with cassette recorder and mono monitor for &pound;200, which makes the C64 a better buy. 
 The CPC-6128 comes with a built-in 3-inch disc drive and colour monitor for &pound;400, which again makes an Atari ST a better buy, and the Commodore Amiga a tempting alternative. 
 Amstrad has held its CPC prices constant for over five years now, apart from throwing a few extra baubles (joystick, games) into the mix. 
 They used to be extremely good value; now they are eminently ignorable. 
 Is Alan Sugar happy to watch this range decline? 
 Of course, Atari has not cut the price of its ST micro for two years, but at least the raw 520ST-FM has a powerful 16/32-bit Motorola 68000 processor, 512K of memory, upgraded 720K disc drive and a mouse. 
 Also this &pound;300 machine is often sold for much less, and old models (which have a single-sided 360K drive) are available for as little as &pound;175. 
 The Atari ST has dominated the 16-bit market over the last couple of years as a &bquo;dual purpose&equo; machine. 
 It can be used for serious computing, as a &bquo;poor man's Apple Macintosh&equo;, with Atari's high-quality monochrome screen, and plugged into a TV set for games. 
 Recently, the Atari ST has been selling bundled with &pound;400-&pound;500 worth of games for &pound;399. 
 At this price it has come under increasing pressure from the Commodore Amiga, which starts at the same price and attracts similar discounts. 
 The Amiga also has a Motorola 68000, 512K, a built-in 3.5 inch disc drive and a mouse, but it has much better colour graphics and sound. 
 The Amiga's technical superiority counted for little when there were hardly any games for it, and hardly any of them used its facilities. 
 But after Commodore cut the price by &pound;100, and threw in the &pound;25 add-on TV adaptor, the Amiga took off as a games machine. 
 Now it is at least as well supported as the ST, and its advantages are finally starting to count. 
 Atari has announced an enhanced STE range with graphics and sound facilities more like the Amiga's, but at no extra cost. 
 However, the new facilities have yet to win any support from software houses, and you would be surprised to find an STE actually on sale. 
 The Amiga does not have as much serious software as the ST, nor does it have the equivalent of the ST's mono monitor. 
 However, it now has a reasonable range of productivity software (word processors, databases, etc), and in specialised areas &mdash; colour graphics, desktop video &mdash; it is well ahead. 
 At the lowest level, the 520ST still looks slightly better value than an Amiga, which has an operating system not everyone likes. 
 But for those willing to upgrade the A500 to one megabyte, and add an A590 hard disc and a colour monitor, it becomes a very attractive system. 
 Finally, there's the Acorn Archimedes A3000, which is by far the most powerful home micro available. 
 Instead of being made in Taiwan (Atari) or Hong Kong (Commodore) this is even made in the UK. 
 Unfortunately, it does not have a lot of software support, and the price &mdash; about &pound;750 &mdash; puts it beyond most people's reach. 
 In value-for-money terms, the Sega looks the best buy among the games machines, the Commodore 64 for a tape-based home micro, and then either the Atari ST or Amiga A500 &mdash; both disc-based systems &mdash; depending on specific needs and disposable income. 
 Boots: Nintendo. 
 Comet: Sega Master; Spectrum; Amstrad CPC; Commodore 64C and Amiga. 
 Dixons: Sega; Atari 2600, XE, 65XE and ST; Spectrum; Commodore 64C and Amiga. 
 Menzies: Sega; Spectrum; Atari ST; Commodore 64C and Amiga. 
 Tandy: Spectrum +2; Commodore 64C; Atari ST. 
 Toys R Us: Nintendo; Sega; Atari VCS, XE and ST; Spectrum; Amstrad CPC. 
 Woolworth: Sega; Spectrum; Atari VCS, XE and ST. 
 The Archimedes is stocked by selected branches of Dixons, Allders and John Lewis. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Why the M-word is baloney American columnist John C.Dvorak argues that multimedia is a sham &mdash; the old, failed teaching machine dressed up in new clothes. 
 ITHINK if we are ever to see grand hokum in the Mac marketplace we'll see it in the months ahead, as the M-word &mdash; multimedia &mdash; becomes the in thing to discuss in the 1990s. 
 Multimedia used to be defined as a fancy slide show that you sat and watched. 
 They were the ones with the bank of 40 computer-controlled projectors &mdash; popular at expositions and amusement parks. 
 I remember a multimedia show in the Iran pavilion at the world's fair in Spokane, Washington, in the early 1970s. 
 It was about the Shah and the glories of the country. 
 It seems that while the definition of the word multimedia has changed, the baloney factor hasn't. 
 Nowadays, multimedia means a computer using different media, such as a laser disc, a CD-ROM, cable TV and who knows what else. 
 The most-talked-about end use is as a grandiose teaching machine. 
 You remember teaching machines, don't you? 
 They were one of the biggest flops in educational history. 
 Not that they didn't work; it just seems that teaching machines have no charisma or charm. 
 I remember back when I was a college student. 
 One summer I went to California State University at Hayward and discovered that the school had a basement laboratory with about a dozen expensive teaching machines. 
 You could sign up for a series of courses, which you could take at your own pace. 
 The machine tested, paced and graduated you. 
 For the life of me I can't remember what courses I took &mdash; it was so boring. 
 Soon afterwards the famed Plato computerised teaching system was marketed by Control Data. 
 It included special terminals and was the be-all, end-all teaching machine. 
 I haven't heard about it for years. 
 The hot, hot multimedia system out there right now was developed by Robert Abel, the noted Hollywood middleman and go-getter extraordinaire. 
 Abel has put together a demonstration system called Guernica, which is a multimedia approach to learning about the famed Picasso painting that depicts the Nazi destruction of a peaceful Basque village by air attack during the Spanish Civil War. 
 Based mostly on using a laser-disc player controlled by a Mac II, the system allows a user to explore &mdash; as the developers like to say &mdash; the painting and its history. 
 Fronted by a HyperCard-like interface &mdash; SuperCard, actually &mdash; the system lets users click and move from point to point on the painting and get lectures and comments from old bores, ex-mistresses, &bquo;people who were there&equo;, dopey ex-Nazi pilots, Picasso mavens and all sorts of experts. 
 You can jump from the history of the town to a backgrounder on Spanish dance. 
 You can jump from that to something else. 
 The system is supposed to exemplify the potential of multimedia. 
 Bob Abel and his pals, when they show this system, make the mistake of using the word empower when describing the value of this approach to learning. 
 With me that rings a warning bell, since it's one of those suspicious New Age buzzwords that always portend a scam or screwball notion such as crystal therapy or out-of-body travel. 
 This system, he says, &bquo;empowers the individual.&equo; 
 This is presumably because it allows you to explore the knowledge contained therein. 
 The promoters tell us that it's not like a book in which someone is telling you something. 
 This new multimedia thingamajig allows you to discover things on your own through the wondrous use of the hypermedia approach to education. 
 Linearity is dead. 
 By the time the demo was over I was nearly nauseous at the presumptuousness of these notions and despondent over the lack of scepticism in the room. 
 In fact, nobody anywhere &mdash; as far as I can tell &mdash; has questioned any aspect of this nonsense. 
 Let's make some quick points that need to be made. 
 Multimedia education is nothing more than a new version of a teaching machine, albeit with real-time video, and teaching machines don't work. 
 Just try to learn French on your computer. 
 This multi- media concept is to education what a demo program is to software. 
 Teachers teach. 
 Computers compute. 
 With multimedia, people do not really explore and are not empowered. 
 The information provided on such a system is predistilled by the producers. 
 It's not a base of knowledge but a subset that can be easily manipulated. 
 Abel, for example, is obviously a Democrat, as he slipped more than a few anti-Reagan barbs into his presentation. 
 Video media, with its powerful images used inter- actively for teaching, will find its niche as a propaganda tool. 
 I get a bad feeling when I see this thing in action. 
 Especially when I look around at the bug-eyed gawkers staring, almost hypnotised, at the images. 
 Multimedia is, simply put, a sham. 
 A fancy sham, but a sham nonetheless. 
 It's promoted by the natural-born hucksters within Apple because it has all the earmarks of something trendy and fashionable. 
 It keeps people talking. 
 It keeps the excitement level high. 
 It generates interest in Apple and it sells hardware. 
 I'm not going to say that some of these projects, such as Guernica, won't be fun to play around with, assuming that you can afford to buy all the necessary - and expensive &mdash; hardware to add to your already expensive system. 
 Institutions, of course, will be the suckers conned into spending the big money for all this equipment. 
 It will all end up in those grim audio-visual departments where it will eventually be auctioned off for peanuts during a cost-saving period. 
 And for those of you who want to learn about Picasso, try the library or go to a museum. 
 &copy; Ziff Communications Company. 
 Reprinted from Mac Magazine, December 1989. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Tata for now India could become to software in the 1990s what Taiwan and South Korea are to electronics today. 
 Radhakrishna Rao reports. 
 IN THE popular Western imagination, India continues to be a country steeped in backwardness and poverty with very little to show by way of scientific innovation or technological achievement. 
 It has hardly been recognised that India is among the few countries in the world that has a proven capability to undertake orbital missions or detonate a nuclear device. 
 Indeed, with some 2.5 million fully qualified scientific and technical personnel, and several million more high school science graduates, India possesses the world's third largest pool of scientific and technical skill, after the US and the Soviet Union. 
 Its influence is felt as far away as the London Underground, which is having its new, networked, interactive time-tabling system, Cart, programmed by a Delhi firm, CMC. 
 The fluency of Indians in English, a legacy of British rule, has made India a lucrative hunting ground for US computer firms on the lookout for qualified computer manpower. 
 Areas in which Indian software professionals are particularly strong are systems software, CAD/CAM, expert systems, microcomputer software, telecommunications and applications software development. 
 This year at Cebit 1989, the huge electronics fair held in Hanover, the head of the government's electronics commision, P.S. Deodhar, &bquo;launched India into the European Information market.&equo; 
 The West German software industry, handicapped by an acute manpower shortage, responded by switching labour-intensive software engineering work to India. 
 West Germany needs about 4,000 electronic data processing specialists, and can fill this gap by using India's skilled and relatively inexpensive manpower. 
 The Indian software industry is growing at an average rate of 35 per cent a year. 
 Of the total 2,550 million rupees (&pound;100 million) earned by Indian software firms in 1988-89, exports accounted for almost a third. 
 More than 60 per cent of Indian exports are accounted for by the two Tata outfits, Tata Consultancy Services (TCS) and Tata Unisys Ltd, which employ around 1,500 professionals in Bombay and Bangalore. 
 Tata Unisys has a collaborative arrangement with MicroSoft. 
 Both the government and the industry are committed to boost its software exports, specialising in systems that overcome the problem of early obsolescence. 
 Thus India could become for the software scene in 90s what Taiwan and South Korea are to electronics today. 
 In July 1988, a new organisation, the National Association of Software and Services Company (Nasscom) was set up to serve the interests of software sector. 
 According to Nasscom Chief Executive, Prem Shivdasani, there are about 300 Indian firms devoted to computer software engineering. 
 The government has already set up technology parks in Bangalore and Pune, with two more expected in Chandigarh and Bubaneshwar, to boost software exports. 
 One feature of these parks is the facility for real-time transmission of software code through dedicated satellite channels to clients in the US and elsewhere. 
 Under a policy announced in 1986, a 50 per cent rebate is provided on customs duty payable for import of hardware used for software development. 
 Another feature of the new approach is that the software industry has been exempted from the licensing provision of the Industries Act: there are no constraints on the setting up of software houses, and programming is not treated as an industrial activity. 
 About 90 per cent of exports are to the US, where Indian software systems cost half as much as American ones.Two American companies with an eye on available and inexpensive manpower have set up software export units in the southern hill city of Bangalore, India's own Silicon Valley. 
 The &dollar;5 million Texas Instruments facility has a staff of 35 US-trained Indian engineers and exports software through a dedicated satellite link to its clients in the US. 
 DEC, in association with Hinitroan of India, exports its software via a Bangalore-Madras-Hong Kong satellite link. 
 At Bombay's Santacruz Free Trade Zone, Citicorp Overseas Software is generating software for the bank's worldwide use. 
 Hewlett-Packard is also planning to set up a software export unit in India. 
 Recently, TCS entered into an agreement with Lotus Development Corporation that gave them exclusive distribution rights for the whole range of Recently there was uproar in India following &bquo;body shopping&equo; by American software firms. 
 Recruitment of 40 top staff was the last straw. 
 Lotus PC software, while Thapar is planning a tie-up with Hitachi of Japan for setting up software units with 100 per cent buy-back arrangements. 
 Nearly 50 Indian software producers belong to the Engineering Export Promotion Council which is making vigorous efforts to find new markets, particularly in East Asia and Europe. 
 The Bombay-based Larsen and Toubro (L&amp;T), which has already exported software services to a number of countries, is negotiating with European countries for the supply of software engineering. 
 It is also contemplating tie-ups with software houses or large user organisations abroad. 
 However, only a few large companies &mdash; 25 of them &mdash; have been registered as software exporters with branch offices abroad. 
 Small local software firms, which can ill afford overheads like publicity and advertising, are worried that the increasing preference for tie-ups will stunt their growth. 
 Also, industry observers say Indian companies must put more money into research and development to ensure that quality remains uncompromised. 
 Indian companies tend to allocate at most two per cent of turnover to R&amp;D as against 15 per cent by US firms. 
 The Indian Department of Electronics says overseas computer firms can take advantage of the trained manpower available in India due to liberal economic policies and incentives provided by the government. 
 But India is itself likely to face an acute manpower shortage in the immediate future. 
 Courses aimed at training computer professionals have been started at nearly 250 institutions in the country. 
 But right now, about 3,000 professionals are available against the projected need for over 10,000 by the end of the decade. 
 Recently there was uproar in India following &bquo;body shopping&equo; by American software firms. 
 The recruitment of 40 top staff from Indian companies, including some from Bangalore-based Wipro Information Systems, proved to be the last straw. 
 The Indian government put severe restrictions on the flight of &bquo;talented brains&equo; to the US. 
 In a leader, the Economic Times, Bangalore, noted that at best, body-shopping by foreign firms &bquo;may be substituted by sub-contracting, and that too, to their own subsidiaries rather than Indian companies.&equo; 
 Thus Indian software houses, &bquo;will have to develop their own products based on indigenous R&amp;D. 
 But for this to happen&hellip; the government should come down heavily on piracy, which militates against domestic development. 
 A rapid growth of the home market must also be ensured. 
 In software particularly, exports will have to be led by the domestic market.&equo; 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 In search of presents without a future Rob Ainsley pinpoints those eminently disposable stocking fillers for the computer buff who has everything. 
 COMPUTERS are ideal for boring, repetitive and mind-numbing tasks &mdash; which makes you wonder why there isn't any artificial intelligence Christmas list-making software on the market. 
 However hard you think, you always end up buying something useless, so it's best to save time and decide on something useless straight off. 
 And you can always tell if something is useless because it will be described as for the person &bquo;with everything&equo;. 
 There are, unfortunately, few pieces of software that can be called useless. 
 Even obscura such as The Houseplant Disc (a database to help you pick the right ones for the right situations) or Bon Appetit (which suggests recipes based on your input of what you happen to have in the fridge) are, in the right situation, useful. 
 And however tasteless you may think a gift is, it doesn't automatically make it useless. 
 A case in point might be the Unabashed History of Pornography from InCat Systems of Milan, available on well illustrated CD-ROM. 
 In the US, there was once a blank disc marketed as Invisicalc, but that now seems to have vanished&hellip;. 
 So you're left with hardware. 
 Unkind critics of the Amstrad, er, Sinclair PC200 have suggested it would make the ideal present for someone with everything, as you wouldn't give it to someone who actually needed a PC. 
 Fortunately, however, there are plenty of cheaper options. 
 The computer catalogues are full of little hardware trinkets, no doubt all perfectly well intentioned and thoughtfully designed, but all excellent solutions in search of a problem. 
 And unlike software, they are not limited to one particular type of computer or disc format. 
 They are equally useless on all machines. 
 How often have you wanted to peer into your disc drive to see what's inside, for example? 
 This common urge can be fulfilled with a special torch boasting a fibre optic thread you can poke inside the drive to illuminate it. 
 Streamside Research sells them for &pound;2 (available in red, green or black). 
 Now perhaps they should produce an Apple Macintosh version, which would be exactly the same but cost twice as much. 
 Disc boxes and mouse mats are good stocking fillers, but what about something with a bit of class? 
 A wooden disc box from Supplier Action: not a greenhouse gas producer and not made from tropical hardwood. 
 The only layer it might put a hole through will be in your back pocket &mdash; it costs &pound;45. 
 For the mouse owner, what about a Mouse Cleaning Kit from Accodata for &pound;15.95, or a cover made in imitation fur in the shape of a mouse &mdash; Terra's Furry Mouse House? 
 (Sadly there are no imitation droppings available to complete the set.) 
 Owners of an Atari ST will no doubt be delighted to receive ISM's keyboard enhancer. 
 For just &pound;15 you can give them a set of springs that take just an hour or two to fit under each key and make the keyboard so much bouncier. 
 And much more fun than those puzzles you get in crackers. 
 However, for the DIY enthusiast who prefers a real challenge, ESL's No Noise is a better bet. 
 The &pound;75 unit fits in the back of a PC and runs the fan down to its ideal operating speed for the ambient temperature. 
 It's not suitable for owners of Amstrad PC-1512s and 1640s which have no fans &mdash; much like the company itself, apparently. 
 The Thingi, and The Thingi 2, are not another dreadful horror movie and its sequel, but more examples of plastic widgets for the person with everything. 
 The Thingi is a &pound;7.49 plastic arm that Velcros itself on to the top of your monitor and hangs over the side. 
 On to this you can clip an A4-sized object &mdash; such as a sheet of paper. 
 It's not actually useless, but as you can knock up an equivalent device with a ruler, bulldog clip and blob of Blu-Tack, it deserves a mention. 
 Of course, not all presents for the person-with-everything even require a computer. 
 You might try getting the games player a packet of Nintendo Breakfast Cereal from America. 
 It contains little edible figures from Nintendo games. 
 Or, for the games freak, how about a video? 
 Hot Shot's monthly releases gave you 45 minutes of video excerpts of the latest computer games for only &pound;5. 
 There's no player input at all, of course, and it's useless without a VCR, but ideal for someone with everything. 
 But there's no doubt as to the best stocking filler this Christmas &mdash; at least, for Apple Macintosh users. 
 Smack-a-Mac!, from the prosaically entitled Computer Accessories That Make Fun, San Diego, is a miniature smiling toy Mac filled with soft padding. 
 When the real Mac crashes and trashes your hard disc, you can take it out on the Smack-a-Mac! 
 Throw it around to your heart's content. 
 Of course, it doesn't recover any data, but it does wonders for your temper. 
 The UK supplier, Ambrit Ltd (tel: 0442 866294) ships it complete with 12-page User's Guide and Limited Unwarranty: &bquo;We do offer a 90-minute warranty. 
 If you can return it to us within 90 minutes, we will not only give you a new one, but we will give you two new ones.&equo; 
 Smack-a-Mac! is an idea with lots of potential. 
 One can imagine toys in the shape of Commodore Amigas, Amstrad keyboards, cassette datacorders, laptop LCD displays.&hellip; 
 Tempered aggression&hellip; how to use the Smack-a-Mac! 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 A dragon without fire Michael Billington misses the menace in the RSC's revival of Shakespeare's best political play. 
 IT is twelve years since the last Stratford Coriolanus: an absurd neglect of Shakespeare's best political play. 
 But the new production at the Royal Shakespeare Theatre, directed by Terry Hands and John Barton, has a lot going for it. 
 Pace. 
 Clarity. 
 The best Volumnia in years from Barbara Jefford. 
 But, in an ideal world, one would look for more dangerous animalism than one gets from Charles Dance's Coriolanus in order to sharpen the edge of political debate. 
 What makes this such a great play is Shakespeare's analytical power: as John Barton once pointed out, Shakespeare is neither right-wing nor left-wing but wing-less. 
 Coriolanus is seen as a magnificent warrior, a psychologically damaged mother-worshipper and a potential threat to an evolving republic. 
 The people, on the other hand, are suffering from famine at a time when the patricians are hoarding the grain-harvest but are themselves easily manipulated by the Tribunes. 
 Shakespeare does not so much take sides as show how the state is threatened by the tragic collision of opposing forces: for antique Rome read Jacobean England. 
 What is good about the current production is that it does not seek to tilt the play either way: it allows us to decide where we stand. 
 It also implies, rather than re-creates, the past: Christopher Morley's set consists of three mobile siege-towers with the Romans, in costume terms, veering to black leather, the Volscians to scarlet greatcoats. 
 And along the way the production makes a number of intelligent points. 
 The Tribunes are strongly contrasted, with Geoffrey Freshwater's bullish rabble-rouser of a Sicinius Velutus offset by the ineffectual moderation of Joe Melia's Junius Brutus. 
 The continuity of martial values is also brilliantly suggested at the end when Coriolanus's son ritually receives his father's sword from Volumnia while his mother looks grievingly on. 
 What I miss, however, in Charles Dance's Coriolanus is a sense of implacable danger. 
 Mr Dance gives us many of the man's essential qualities: his psychological dependence on his mother, his solitariness (he is constantly placed down front gazing over the audience's heads), his antique, tribal valour. 
 But there is a dragonish aspect to Coriolanus which Mr Dance has yet to catch. 
 He also throws away too many key phrases: &bquo;This Triton of the minnows&equo; is a magnificent epithet for Sicinius but it here gets lost and although in the great banishment-speech Mr Dance's body-language is good (as he hurls his coat to the ground in fine disdain) it is significant that the directors resort to an echo-chamber effect on &bquo;There is a world elsewhere.&equo; 
 Olivier, one wanly recalls, had his own built-in reverberations. 
 Without a dictatorial Coriolanus, Shakespeare's point about the implied threat to the republic is stated rather than felt. 
 But there is rich compensation in Barbara Jefford's magnificent Volumnia: why has this superb actress been given only two roles by the RSC in 30 years? 
 She is, essentially, a voluptuous Volumnia whose hold over her son is dangerously sexual. 
 Greeting him on his return from battle, she hands him over to his wife with palpable reluctance; seeking to calm him before his confrontation with the people, she shackles him in an iron grip; and, in the great plea with him not to sack Rome, she pinpoints the lines about him treading on his mother's womb &bquo;that brought thee to this world&equo;. 
 Volumnia can easily be played as a sexless harridan: Ms Jefford interprets her as a passionate woman who dominates her son physically as well as spiritually, even to the extent of giving his face a resounding slap when he is recalcitrant. 
 But the other key roles are also strongly cast. 
 Malcolm Storry's bullet-headed Aufidius is not simply a rude barbarian but an acute analyst of Coriolanus's character: Mr Storry has the priceless gift of making the language tangible so that when he says &bquo;I think he'll be to Rome as is the osprey to the fish&equo; the image comes resonantly alive. 
 Joseph O'Conor also makes Menenius infinitely more than a wily patrician: he seems the only one capable of communicating sanely with the several, warring factions. 
 In what is normally seen as a male-dominated play, it is also worth noting that Hands and Barton give the women unusual prominence. 
 Amanda Harris's Virgilia is no simpering wet but a loyal wife who vehemently thumps the tribunes for their banishment of her husband. 
 And Jane Maud's Valeria is characterised in the programme as &bquo;priestess of Diana&equo; and, in the final peace-mission, is given unusual symbolic weight. 
 That is a sign of how the play has been intelligently re-thought. 
 The production also takes on board the point Anne Barton makes in the programme that Shakespeare, following Livy, sees Coriolanus as a threat to the balance of the state. 
 But for the idea to be made manifest one needs a Coriolanus who is not only a truculent fighter but also a thrillingly horrific force of nature. 
 Charles Dance as Coriolanus&hellip; a threat to the republic? 
 PHOTOGRAPH: DOUGLAS JEFFERY 
 Ready for a huge family row Television. 
 By Hugh Hebert 
 GIRDING up for six hours with the Mahabharata is a long training. 
 At the weekend we had Peter Brook's approach via the South Bank Show (LWT) and through the foothills of Lear and the Marat/Sade to this Everest of an Indian epic. 
 Last night, there he was again between the sections of The Greatest Story (Signals, C4), a kind of Michelin guide to the Hindu poem generally said to be 15 times as long as the Bible; a fact I am not inclined to check. 
 To cut a long legend short, it's about the bloody rivalry between two branches of a Hindu royal family &mdash; the five Pandava brothers, who all marry the same princess, and the 100 Kaurava brothers. 
 Both sides know that eventually it will come to a fight. 
 Meanwhile, the leading Pandava brother is enticed into a dice game he knows he will lose but cannot resist. 
 Unable to quiet the gambling fever, he loses his kingdom, his family, their shared wife, and himself. 
 The Pandavas are banished to the forest for 12 years, but eventually the great war comes&hellip; 
 The South Bank Show was a help in understanding how and why Brook has spent 15 years bringing this great poem to the stage and now the screen. 
 It's the culmination of his development in the theatre since the mid-Sixties brought his unforgettable Lear with Paul Scofield; his Theatre of Cruelty season; and the sledgehammer, operatic impact of his Marat/Sade. 
 It also isolated how he has approached the tricky transfer to the screen: &bquo;Theatre is the art of suggestion and not of statement&hellip; the cinema has to produce complete images.&equo; 
 That is the key problem. 
 But it was Signals that offered just what we need before settling down on Saturday night with soft cushions and iron rations: a clear summary, and the chance to fix on the central characters in this huge dramatic tapestry. 
 Brook talked about that central game of dice that Yudishthira plays, &bquo;an ordinary, everyday action&hellip; it also has overtones, through the poetic to the metaphysical and the supernatural, and this is just as in Shakespeare. 
 It's as though you put together Coriolanus, Henry IV, Hamlet and the Tempest. 
 All these values are there simultaneously within the Mahabharata. 
 It explodes all conventional ideas of morality.&equo; 
 HERE in the West, episode two of Blackeyes (BBC-2) hardly advances the narrative at all and slowly picks at the same psychological scabs. 
 As the mysterious man following Blackeyes, Nigel Planer speaks at last, though he has damn all to say. 
 Blackeyes Bellman herself speaks some more, and says even less than. 
 A top model now, she also bestrides the unspeakable marketing man Jamieson (Colin Jeavons), a noisy commercial humping in a once-fashionable seaside hotel. 
 Down in the ballroom, Dennis Lotis is crooning Try A Little Tenderness to a dance floor awash with unsteady pensioners. 
 It's the most Potterish moment so far. 
 &bquo;Was that a real orgasm, d'you think?&equo; asks narrator Dennis, &bquo;No, all fake, of course. 
 But what happens to her, to me, if &mdash; made to pretend &mdash; we pretend too often?&equo; 
 Half way through the Blackeyes saga, it looks as though we are going to have to make do with a few set pieces of one-to-one hostility. 
 On Radio 4's Start the Week, Potter emphasised his characters' aloneness &mdash; separated by passages where the writer does his directorial exercises. 
 There was the interview in the morgue between Jamieson and Detective Blake, whom John Shrapnel has made into the one compulsively watchable character so far. 
 And there is Blackeyes herself undergoing her first trial by fire under the photographer's lights and lascivious eye. 
 &bquo;I dont think we should compromise here,&equo; he says as he lures her out of her bra, and the narrator repeats the theme as his camera pans round to give us an eyeful of the picture man getting down to nipple level. 
 And the narrator intones, &bquo;I'm compromised out of his dirty mouth.&equo; 
 Yet if anything compromises Potter here, it's not playing voyeur. 
 It's his failure to punch home his underlying theme. 
 Instead of recognising a commercial exploitation, we're invited to see male lust as the corrupting force. 
 As an admirer of Potter's plays, I wait to see the rabbit come out of the hat. 
 But we're running out of screen time. 
 Saddened Blackeyes's last line this time was: &bquo;Jesus, why weren't you a woman?&equo; 
 PAGE 
 In good faith Open Space.. 
 THE Gospel Truth? 
 (November 28) was interesting for the assumptions its author, Jayne Greenwell, deemed to be facts. 
 For example, &bquo;No child of practising religious parents will miss out on religious education &mdash; it will be provided at home.&equo; 
 Who says so? 
 It may be provided at Sunday school but I would think that the average Christian parents have the same feeling of unease about discussing faith with the children as they do about discussing sex. 
 Jayne Greenwell also assumes that the existence of God is not a fact but &bquo;a matter of opinion&equo;. 
 The truth is that people don't react to reality; they react to their perception of reality. 
 My perception of God is real and I can understand that for her he isn't. 
 What I can't understand is who she thanks when she wants to be thankful, for example when her son was born. 
 If God is not a fact, then what have atheists to fear if their kids learn about him? 
 If something is nothing, how can it affect anything? 
 Terry Wynn Member of the European Parliament Merseyside East 
 AS SOMEONE involved in religious education, I share Jayne Greenwell's concern, but cannot agree with her solution that RE be taken out of the curriculum. 
 It is too important in that it enables children to understand how religion influences individuals and societies, and to explore how people form their own beliefs and values &mdash; including atheism. 
 However, I would denounce the kind of RE she describes because it imposes beliefs rather than explores them. 
 In this respect it contradicts the approach to education in general which is to enable children to acquire critical skills and achieve the kind of understanding that makes knowledge their own, not that of their parents or society. 
 Ways of teaching RE to young children have received too little attention, and teachers are given woefully little training &mdash; consequently the one mentioned in the article is probably left to teach as she was once taught. 
 W Owen Cole Chichester 
 IWOULD urge Jayne Greenwell not to be concerned about her son's religious instruction. 
 My son, aged four, believes in God and Jesus, as I did as a child. 
 He also believes in fairies, witches, sea monsters and Father Christmas. 
 I am confident that when he reaches his teens he will challenge and possibly reject religion as he will earlier have rejected his other fantasies. 
 It was an aphorism of my parents-in-law that in order to respond to the arguments of the religious persuaders, it was essential to be thoroughly familiar with the content of the bible. 
 So don't worry, Ms Greenwell: your son's religious education lessons will provide him with the ammunition that he needs to oppose traditional religious beliefs. 
 Jane P Sutherland Reading 
 JAYNE Greenwell overlooks the fact that Christianity is the soil in which the roots of the ethnic British are grounded. 
 Most of the praise-worthy efforts to reflect minority cultures in our schools are based on religious festivals &mdash; Hindu, Moslem, Sikh or Jewish. 
 Our children have a right to know why we have Christmas and Easter, crosses on war memorials and a coronation service; why the centre of every English village is a parish church; and why English literature resonates with Biblical imagery. 
 They have even more of a right to know if they are not being told at home. 
 This is not the same as &bquo;force-feeding&equo; doctrine; one can sympathise with Jayne Greenwell's reservations, but we should be careful what gets thrown out with the bathwater. 
 Anne Kiggell Editor, Prep School London SW14 PAGE wom 
 Another day. 
 December 7, 1786: I am in a fair way of becoming as eminent as Thomas a Kempis or John Bunyan, and you may expect henceforth to see my birthday inserted among the wonderful events in the Poor Robin's and Aberdeen Almanacks, along with the black Monday and the battle of Bothwell Bridge. 
 (Robert Burns to Gavin Hamilton, Letters: 193l). 
 Revenge has no part in bid, says Mulcahy. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 GEOFF Mulcahy, the soft-spoken chief executive and chairman-elect of Kingfisher, insisted last night that in launching his &pound;460 million bid for Dixons, that revenge was the last thing in mind. 
 &bquo;This is a straight commercial exercise,&equo; he said, &bquo;We believe we can turn around this business. 
 The argument should not be confused by talk of revenge.&equo; 
 But there is a certain piquancy in Kingfisher now trying to turn the tables on a company from whose clutches its escaped by a whisker only three years ago. 
 In 1986, Dixons was the darling of the City. 
 It was cashing in a spectacular consumer boom. 
 Kingfisher &mdash; or Woolworths as it was then called &mdash; was still being reshaped under the guidance of Mulcahy and his team, who had spearheaded a buy-out of the company from its US parent four years earlier. 
 Now, it is Kingfisher which has become a favourite &mdash; not because the people at the helm have great shopkeeping flair but because their cautious and unflamboyant management style has created a retailing empire of solid reliability. 
 The Mulcahy approach could hardly be more different from that of Stanley Kalms, the creator and chairman of the Dixons empire. 
 Kalms is an instinctive entrepreneur. 
 He joined his father's portrait photography business at the age of 16 just after the war and soon realised that selling cameras was more lucrative than taking pictures. 
 The business grew Topsy-like as Dixons stacked its shelves with electrical and photographic equipment from low-cost suppliers in the Far East. 
 Currys was taken over in 1984, two years before the unsuccessful &pound;1.8billion bid for Woolworths. 
 Now, Dixons is suffering. 
 Profits, above &pound;100million in 1987/88, are likely to fall to &pound;45million in the year to next April. 
 The surplus will come from things like property development, financial services and the US electrical offshoot, Silo: the 350 Dixons and 600 Currys outlets are losing money. 
 Attempts to move Currys gradually out of the high street to larger edge-of-town and out-of-town stores and to tone down Dixons' garish image have yet to bear fruit. 
 Meanwhile, Kingfisher has prospered, embracing far more than the relics of the British end of Frank Winfield Woolworth's creation. 
 Woolworths opened its first British shop in Liverpool 80 years ago, thrived on its &bquo;nothing more than 6d&equo; formula until the second world war, lumbered through the the 60s and 70s and came into the embrace of Mulcahy's team with more than 1,000 outlets. 
 It has been cut back to 700 shops, each with just six departments. 
 Add in Comet, Superdrug and B&amp;Q, and that is Kingfisher, run with little of the flair which Dixons showed in its heyday but perfectly poised to withstand a downturn. 
 PAGE 
 Europe to drop Japan car curbs. 
 By Alan Hope in Brussels 
 QUOTAS which restrict imports of Japanese cars to Europe are to be dropped from the end of 1992, in return for greater access to the Japanese market for European carmakers, the EC Commission said yesterday. 
 The Commission also confirmed that there would be no repeat of the row, earlier this year, over the local content of Nissan cars built in Britain and exported to the rest of Europe. 
 &bquo;Cars produced in Europe are supposed to be European cars&equo;, Mr Frans Andriessen, the EC's External Relations Commissioner said. 
 Five countries currently maintain national quotas on imports of Japanese cars -France, Italy, Spain, Portugal and the UK. 
 According to the Commission, they should be progressively reduced as soon as possible &mdash; most likely from the start of 1991. 
 On January 1, 1993, quotas will disappear but Japanese exports will continue to be strictly monitored. 
 The Community will keep the option of introducing safeguard measures if imports produce too much of a threat to the European industry. 
 The decision on the Community's policy comes after months of debate in the 17-member Commission. 
 The Commission proposes that 1993 be the start of a transition period of indefinite duration, during which quotas will be lifted while imports are tightly monitored. 
 In any case, an open European market will make national quotas impossible to enforce. 
 The Japanese will be offered greater access to Europe, on condition that they open their domestic markets &mdash; not only for cars but for a whole range of industrial and service sectors &mdash; to European businessmen. 
 The Commission hopes that the threat of new restrictions on cars, this time on the Europe-wide level, will spur the Japanese to do more in this area than they have to date. 
 PAGE 
 Adjusting the Delors vision of a Social Charter to the needs of greater Europe Notebook. 
 By Edited by Alex Brummer 
 THE main focus of British angst at the Strasbourg Summit is likely to be the Social Charter. 
 But it is also plain that despite sterling's depreciation to a rate at which it might be reasonably competitive within the Exchange Rate Mechanism, Mrs Thatcher's team are no more ready to sign on the dotted line than they were in Madrid this summer. 
 The Strasbourg smokescreen will be different. 
 The Whitehall-propagated view is that the changes in Eastern Europe are so momentous they render European Monetary Union, a common fiscal policy and the charter obsolete. 
 Instead of focusing on the narrow agenda of Delors the new Europe should be more forward looking. 
 It should examine the relationship between Eastern and Western Europe and issues of global importance in Europe &mdash; such as pollution &mdash; rather than pussyfooting with the Social Charter. 
 As far as the charter is concerned they may be on the right track (if for the wrong reasons). 
 Although the aims of the charter are laudable, ensuring adequate social security, the right of employees to join a union and the right to strike, among other things, they could be unworkable if one assumes that some closer links between the emerging countries of the Eastern bloc and the West &mdash; including German reunification. 
 One obvious problem, pointed out in the most recent issue of the National Institute Economic Review, is the issue of relative labour costs. 
 A charter which encouraged the poorer countries to move towards the best practice in the richer nations would clearly affect competitiveness in the less well-off states. 
 If this already were true in traditional free market economies, imagine the gap to be closed with countries emerging from the iron hand of Stalinist control. 
 It would be clearly better for the UK, given its dismal failure on the inflation front, to be exposed to the discipline of the ERM irrespective of developments further to the East. 
 But when it comes to the Social Charter there may well be a case for slowing the grandiose Delors ideas. 
 Stateside bolt-hole?. 
 TIMING was not on the side of Thames Television yesterday as it unveiled the &pound;57million purchase of American TV production house Reeves. 
 Fresh in the market's mind was the shambles which has engulfed TVS following its expensive foray into the American television market. 
 The purchase of MTM is likely to wipe out the second-half profits of TVS this year. 
 Thames is also choosing to launch the transatlantic venture &mdash; its first major takeover &mdash; as all eyes are focused on the British market where the Government will today reveal the details of its new broadcasting legislation including proposals to force ITV contractors to compete in an auction for the renewal of their franchises. 
 Shares in Thames slipped on fears that the company may not be able to shake off the jinx which has dogged so many American acquisitions by British foragers. 
 But chairman Sir Ian Trethowan described it as a &bquo;cost effective&equo; way into the US market which will add the adolescent delights of sitcoms such as &bquo;Gimme a Break&equo; to Thames's programme library. 
 The company is also hoping to exploit the link to pump its own programmes out to the thousands of mainstream and cable stations in America. 
 Plunging into the midst of a soft US market may not look clever in the short term, particularly since Thames's own revenue is starting to feel the effects of the slowdown in advertising spending. 
 But America is still the largest television market and Thames now has a foothold. 
 If disaster strikes and the company is outbid by one of the many expected rivals for its lucrative London franchise &mdash; the largest in Britain &mdash; Reeves could provide a bolt-hole. 
 Law's delay. 
 THERE is a growing belief in Parliament and among the hapless investors of Barlow Clowes that the Ombudsman's report into the Department of Trade and Industry's role in the affair will, in part, be suppressed on sub judice grounds. 
 The legal fall-out of the &pound;190million scandal and the criminal cases which have resulted from it mean that, on grounds of fairness alone, it would not be right to pre-judge the trials due to start next year. 
 Sir Anthony Barrowclough's report could, indeed, be viewed in those terms and holding back some of the more sensitive parts would be consistent with the Serious Fraud Office's efforts to restrain some of the most recent civil court hearings on the affair. 
 However, the SFO's handling of its investigations has hardly been consistent and it already has set a precedent for the Barrowclough report to be published in full. 
 The best case in point is the publication of the DTI report into the Blue Arrow affair which came before the arrest and subsequent charging of the 11 defendants. 
 It is no wonder, therefore, that many people believe the current delay in publishing the Barrowclough investigation is for reasons of political expediency rather than legalistic necessity. 
 The crux of the matter is whether compensation should be paid to the investors: if Sir Anthony has thus decided, then the Government should duly oblige. 
 In these days of financial sweeteners, surely there are more votes in rescuing 18,000, mainly elderly, investors from dire financial plight just as there is ensuring that the UK's last home-grown car manufacturer remains in British hands? 
 PAGE 
 BNFL &bquo;to revive&equo; nuclear power. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 THE development of Britain's atomic power programme could be resurrected under plans being considered by British Nuclear Fuels which is looking at the feasibility of establishing itself as a major player in the post-privatisation electricity market. 
 Although the Government's recent decision to pull all atomic reactors from the sell-off programme and scrap the construction of three Pressurised Water Reactors was expected to freeze Britain's civil nuclear programme for at least five years, BNFL yesterday disclosed that it was looking at ways of diversifying into generating power. 
 Declaring that the Department of Energy's about-turn will result in &bquo;merely a temporary interruption&equo; to atomic development, chairman Mr Christopher Harding admitted that the nuclear industry's image has been damaged by fears about nuclear waste. 
 Despite the wealth of evidence that nuclear power can never under-price fossil fuel-generated electricity, BNFL is looking at ways of competing for supply in the open market. 
 Proposals involve the possible construction of up to four PWRs on existing BNFL sites at Calder Hall at Sellafield and Chapelcross in Scotland. 
 The new plant would have capacity of between 600 and 2,400 megawatts of power. 
 The company is also planning to expand the life of the existing Magnox reactors by another 10 years. 
 Development costs could be reduced by expanding these existing nuclear sites which are currently used primarily to produce fuel for military purposes. 
 Construction could be caried out as a joint venture with the new state-owned company set up to operate all existing nuclear plant. 
 Any BNFL output would have to compete on commercial grounds. 
 PAGE 
 Official figures are hard to credit as families fail to claim benefit. 
 By Mike George 
 ASTAGGERING number of the hard-up are failing to claim benefit under the Family Credit Scheme &mdash; despite a recent change in government calculations. 
 Families struggling on low incomes can get help from the scheme provided at least one adult is working at least 24 hours a week. 
 When it was introduced in place of the old family income supplement scheme last year, just 38 per cent of those entitled claimed family credit. 
 The government subsequently altered its estimate of those able to claim and came up with a 50 per cent take-up rate. 
 And now Tony Newton's social security department is hoping a recent &pound;7 million advertising campaign will boost that to 60 per cent. 
 Family credit is a means tested benefit paid on top of wages, or earnings from self employment. 
 It is almost always paid to a woman. 
 To qualify you must be responsible for one or more children aged under 16, or under 19 if they are still in full-time non-advanced education. 
 Your savings must total less than &pound;6,000 though &pound;1 of &bquo;notional income&equo; is added in when working out your income level for every &pound;250 (or part thereof) of savings over &pound;3,000. 
 Any children's savings are ignored, unless one of them has over &pound;3,000, in which case you can't get family credit for that child. 
 The scheme is based on a so-called &bquo;applicable amount&equo;, currently &pound;54.80 a week. 
 Anybody whose income is less than this will get full family credit. 
 The payments are based on set amounts: &pound;33.60 for a lone parent or a couple: &pound;23.30 for each child aged 18: &pound;16.35 for each child aged 16 or 17: &pound;12.90 for each child aged 11 to 15, and &pound;7.30 for each one up to 10 years of age. 
 If your income is above &pound;54.80 a week, 70 per cent of the additional amount is cut from the set payments. 
 Sheila is a lone parent with two children, aged 13 and 15. 
 She works part-time, averaging 28 hours a week. 
 After paying tax and national insurance she gets &pound;75 a week take home pay. 
 This is &pound;20.20 above the &pound;54.80 applicable amount, and 70 per cent of this is &pound;14.14. 
 Her set amounts are &pound;33.60 as a lone parent, plus &pound;25.80 for the children. 
 That totals &pound;59.40, but &pound;14.14 is deducted, leaving her total family credit at &pound;45.26 a week. 
 Child benefit payments, one parent benefit, housing benefit, income support and mobility and attendance allowances are all ignored as incomes for the purposes of family credit. 
 So Sheila's actual income is &pound;75 from earnings, plus &pound;14.50 child benefit (&pound;7.25 each), &pound;5.20 one parent benefit and &pound;45.26 from Family Credit. 
 Earnings are always taken net of tax and national insurance. 
 For those who are weekly paid, normal earnings are estimated by looking at the last five weeks pay, or the last two months for the monthly paid. 
 For the self-employed it is either the last 26 weeks or the last year's set of accounts which are used. 
 Self-employed child minders only have one third of their net earnings taken into account as income, the rest is ignored. 
 Family credit is also available on unemployment benefit, although this is counted as income. 
 Pam and Errol have two children, aged 13 and 16. 
 Errol is on unemployment benefit of &pound;34.70 a week, while Pam is bringing home &pound;75 a week. 
 This adds up to &pound;109.70, some &pound;54.90 above the applicable amount, and 70 per cent of that is &pound;38.43. 
 Their set amount for family credit is &pound;62.85, from which &pound;38.43 is deducted, leaving a final payment of &pound;24.42. 
 With child benefit included their income has been increased from &pound;124.20 to &pound;148.62 a week. 
 If one partner has been getting statutory sick or maternity pay for a continuous period of 13 weeks or more, this is counted as income. 
 Otherwise these payments are ignored. 
 Family credit lasts for 26 weeks at a time, then you will have to reapply. 
 However, it will end sooner if someone else claims income support or family credit in respect of a child who was included in your family credit award. 
 If you feel that your award is wrong in some way you can ask for the decision to be reviewed or make an appeal &mdash; details of how to do this are available from social security benefit offices. 
 If you're getting housing benefit this will be affected if you claim a family credit award, as your income will increase. 
 In some cases this may make the prospect of an award less attractive. 
 Some local authorities also assume you're getting family credit, even if you haven't claimed it, and so reduce your housing benefit. 
 PAGE 
 Interest rates hit Greene King. 
 By James Morrow 
 GREENE KING, the East Anglian brewers in which Elders IXL has a 13 per cent stake, announced flat half-time profits yesterday as interest charges began to bite. 
 Trading profits for the six months increased from &pound;6.9million to &pound;8.36million, but profit from property sell-offs fell and interest charges jumped from &pound;32,000 to &pound;461,000, leaving pre-tax profits just &pound;274,000 ahead at &pound;9.4million. 
 Greene King IPA bitter and Harp Lager have continued to increase substantial market share.Interim dividend is up from 2.6p to 2.9p. 
 PAGE 
 Jack Schofield on a company feeling more than the pinch of a weak US economy IBM in a downsizing squeeze. 
 IBM, once Wall Street's darling, is becoming its whipping boy. 
 Its shares slumped from around &dollar;170 before the October 1987 crash and instead of recovering with the Index have just touched a seven-year low at &dollar;96. 
 This week IBM unveiled plans to shed another 10,000 employees &mdash; about 4.5 per cent of its US workforce &mdash; saving &dollar;1billion a year and it will buy back another &dollar;4billion-worth of its own shares. 
 Unfortunately for IBM, its problems are not simply that it has too many staff. 
 Its problems are not even simple. 
 They include threats to its hardware, its software and its networking system, as well as the weakness of the US economy, which is affecting many other suppliers. 
 Although the US economy is not in recession, it has visibly slowed. 
 Profits have fallen for three consecutive quarters and capital spending has fallen in response. 
 Spending on information technology has also declined, demonstrating that the computer industry is no longer recession-proof. 
 Large suppliers such as IBM, DEC and Unisys have undoubtedly suffered. 
 But even in a bad market some firms do better than others. 
 Hewlett-Packard, for example, managed to grow its annual sales 21 per cent to &dollar;12billion, and Apple managed a 30 per cent increase to &dollar;5billion. 
 And Compaq, competing directly against IBM in desktop PCs, increased sales by 36 per cent and profits by 51 per cent, in its latest quarter. 
 This suggests IBM's problems may be more fundamental. 
 In fact, today's three major computer industry trends &mdash; towards &bquo;downsizing,&equo; portable operating systems and open networks &mdash; are all working against IBM. 
 &bquo;Downsizing&equo; simply means that firms are tending to buy smaller computers to do jobs which used to require big ones, and big computers are where IBM makes most of its money. 
 Downsizing has been made possible by the growing power of the microprocessor and the new &bquo;economies of small&equo;. 
 Given that microcomputer power costs a tenth of the price of minicomputer power, while minicomputer power costs a tenth of the price of mainframe power, a small shift in this direction can make a dramatic difference to revenues. 
 Portable operating systems, such as Unix, are also a threat to IBM and other companies which once prospered on proprietary ones, such as Wang and Data General. 
 Traditionally, computer manufacturers have used proprietary software to &bquo;lock in&equo; users, who would then find it impossible or prohibitively expensive, to move their applications to other manufacturers' machines &mdash; or even, in IBM's case, different machines from the same manufacturer. 
 This strategy is being made obsolete by Unix, an &bquo;open&equo; operating system that runs on hundreds of different computers from hundreds of different manufacturers, from micros and minis through mainframes to supercomputers. 
 Moving applications becomes relatively simple, and turns hardware into a commodity. 
 Manufacturers can no longer charge according to some idea of &bquo;value&equo; but must compete on price and performance. 
 This can have a dramatic effect on margins. 
 Open networking provides the means for computers from different vendors to be connected together using OSI (open systems interconnection) standards. 
 OSI enables all the different manufacturers to work to a common set of standards. 
 Again this works against IBM, which is irrevocably committed to its own proprietary networking system, SNA. 
 These changes are not just a matter of following technological devlopments, but reflect the way businesses are changing. 
 Major firms like General Motors and Heinz no longer see themselves as machines needing only periodic maintenance to run forever. 
 They are no longer isolated and no longer see computers as providing mainly internal services such as payroll and stock control. 
 Instead, large corporations are becoming more like living organisms, continually changing and adapting. 
 They must interact with the outside world, and networks of computers are the way to do it. 
 Examples include electronic data interchange (EDI) &mdash; ordering stocks and materials and paying bills electronically, instead of using paper &mdash; factory automation and JIT (just-in-time) production systems. 
 IBM wants to compete in all these markets and is apparently enthusiastic about AIX (its version of Unix) and OSI. 
 But open systems are backed by governments and controlled by committees, which means IBM cannot dominate or control them. 
 Also by competing it risks cannibalising its own best profit sources: IBM selling an AS/400 mini is a triumph if the buyer would otherwise have chosen a DEC VAX, but a financial disaster for IBM if it replaces an IBM mainframe. 
 Although one IBM manager recently got widespread publicity for pointing out that PCs were overtaking mainframes as IBM's largest source of revenues, this is misleading. 
 IBM's revenues from mainframe processors in calendar 1988 may have been only about &dollar;12billion, but sales of peripherals (&dollar;11billion), software (&dollar;8billion) and maintenance (&dollar;7billion) should be added to this. 
 Perhaps two-thirds of IBM's income and an estimated 75 per cent of profits are still tied up in this threatened area. 
 There's no way round that. 
 As one IBMer said: &bquo;You can't build a &dollar;60billion corporation out of selling &dollar;400 networking cards.&equo; 
 PAGE 
 Massive surge in traded options contracts before &pound;480 million offer attracts suspicion Kingfisher's bid for Dixons sparks insider dealing investigation. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 EVIDENCE of widespread insider dealing ahead of yesterday's &pound;480million bid for Dixons was being investigated by Stock Exchange officials last night. 
 Records show a huge surge in deals on the high-risk, high-return traded options market 24 hours before Kingfisher, the Woolworths-to-B&amp;Q retailing empire unveiled its takeover offer for the troubled Dixons group. 
 Last week saw an average 100 traded options contracts traded each day. 
 Each contract covers the right to buy or sell 1,000 Dixons shares at a given price in the future. 
 On Monday, activity was similarly subdued: 163 contracts were recorded. 
 But on Tuesday, Exchange records show that activity on the traded options market leapt to 2,601 contracts, covering 2.6 million Dixons shares. 
 The price of an option to buy a share in Dixons for 100p next March doubled between Tuesday night and yesterday afternoon when details of the Kingfisher bid were unveiled. 
 Speculators who bought the options before the bid and sold 24 hours later showed a 100 per cent profit. 
 There is no suggestion that people directly involved with Kingfisher profited from knowing that a bid was imminent. 
 But company executives accept that there must have been a leak as they put together a financing package to back their bid for Dixons. 
 After the price of Dixons shares staged a strong rise on Tuesday, Kingfisher felt obliged to broadcast a statement to the Stock Exchange first thing yesterday morning saying a bid was in the offing. 
 Kingfisher says that even if there had been no leak, the bid would probably have been launched this week. 
 Details of the takeover terms were announced yesterday afternoon. 
 Sources within the Stock Exchange confirmed yesterday that the sudden pre-bid surge in the traded options market is being examined by an insider dealing investigation team which looks at suspicious activity ahead of the release of price-sensitive information. 
 Kingfisher's bid comes little more than three years after it fought off a &pound;1.8billion takeover attempt by Dixons. 
 The Kingfisher group, whose name was changed from Woolworths earlier this year, includes about 720 high street shops under the Woolworths name, electrical retailer Comet with 307 outlets, Britain's leading DIY group, B&amp;Q, and Superdrug, the high street chain which last week announced that it is buying Medicare from the Gateway supermarket chain's new owners Isosceles. 
 The Dixons chairman, Mr Stanley Kalms, is expected to issue a formal rejection of the Kingfisher offer this morning. 
 Kingfisher risks having its bid held up by a Monopolies Commission investigation because of the grip it would have on the electrical retailing market if it controlled Dixons and Currys as well as Comet. 
 The company insists that a takeover would give it only 22 per cent of the total market for white and brown goods &mdash; everything from washing machines and fridges to video recorders and hi-fi &mdash; and small electrical appliances. 
 This would be below the level which normally triggers a monopolies probe. 
 However, figures from market researchers Verdict suggest that in 1988, Comet had 7.6 per cent of the market, Lasky's &mdash; since bought by Kingfisher &mdash; 1.2 per cent and Dixons almost 18 per cent. 
 That would mean a takeover would give Kingfisher over 26 per cent. 
 Dixons has been one of the first retail chains to suffer from the slowing of retail demand. 
 It has also been hit by the lack of new products to draw shoppers into its stores and the failure of satellite TV to take off as hoped. 
 Profits fell from &pound;103million in 1987/88 to &pound;78million last year and are expected to fall to &pound;45million in the current 12 months. 
 Kingfisher is offering 120p cash for each Dixons share, but analysts think that much more will be needed to win control. 
 Dixons shares stood at 141p last night. 
 Kingfisher says it would speed up the closure of small Currys outlets and the shift to larger out-of-town sites. 
 PAGE 
 British Land's shares soar on split-up plans. 
 By Larry Elliott Economics Correspondent 
 SHARES in John Ritblat's British Land soared yesterday after the property group announced it was splitting the company in two in an attempt to provide a better deal for shareholders. 
 A quarter of the group's assets worth &pound;339million will be sold to a new listed company, New British Land, which will operate in the manner of the old group and look to expand its portfolio of properties. 
 The remaining chunk of British Land's existing portfolio &mdash; including all its blue-chip investments such as Plantation House in the City of London &mdash; will be sold off. 
 Mr Ritblat said yesterday that he was prepared to sell the properties off piecemeal and had put no timescale on the disposal of assets, but that it was conceivable that a big foreign investor might move in to buy the portfolio in its entirety. 
 However, he stressed that the offer would have to be considerably more than the break-up value of the portfolio. 
 Along with the rest of the property sector, British Land's shares have been trading at a considerable discount to its assets per share, and yesterday's move is an attempt to close the 40 per cent gap which built up as institutions took a dimmer view of the market. 
 Government changes to the tax system in recent years had allowed the company to come up with a solution which would make shares which had been trading at less than &pound;3 last month to &pound;5, Mr Ritblat said. 
 Last night British Land shares closed at 403p, up 46p on the 357p they were trading at when suspended on Tuesday. 
 As part of the deal, British Land's existing shareholders will receive 13 shares in the new company for every 40 they own. 
 There will also be a tender offer to repurchase 10 per cent of British Land's shares at 420p, together with a voucher for the associated tax credit worth 89p. 
 Mr Ritblat said he and his fellow directors were showing their commitment to New British Land by investing almost &pound;12million in cash into the new company, which he said would concentrate on the UK but also look for overseas opportunities provided by the creation of the Single European market. 
 Analysts said they expected the group to have no big problems persuading shareholders to approve the restructuring plans at an extraordinary general meeting on December 21. 
 &bquo;The scheme is beautifully tax-efficient,&equo; one analyst said. 
 But the success of the restructuring depended on the speed and price of asset disposals. 
 PAGE 
 Fall in car sales. 
 UK car sales fell by 4.07 per cent to 143,323 last month compared with November 1988, according to the Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders, with Vauxhall's Cavalier taking the lead from Ford. 
 Johnson chief quits. 
 Eugene Anderson resigned as chief executive of platinum metals producer Johnson Matthey on the eve of the company's half year results. 
 &pound;158m deal. 
 CMB Packaging, the merged Metal Box Packaging and Carnaud group, is selling its tinplate division to France's state-owned Usinor-Sacilor group for &pound;158million. 
 Happy Isosceles. 
 Underwriters of the &pound;1.36 billion loans for Gateway owners Isosceles said they were comfortable with the syndication after 60 per cent of the debt was taken up. 
 Isosceles plans no further meetings with its bankers who say they are happy with its performance. 
 Pearson's new MD. 
 Frank Barlow, chief executive of the Financial Times, was appointed Pearson's new managing director. 
 Maxwell move. 
 Publishing tycoon, Robert Maxwell, and his family plan to buy out the shares they do not own in Pergamon AGB. 
 Wall Street down. 
 The Dow fell 4.91 points to close at 2,736.77. 
 PAGE 
 Perelman eyes stake in Shearson. 
 By Mary Brasier in New York 
 RONALD PERELMAN, the former corporate raider who heads the Revlon cosmetics empire, is being tipped to take a significant stake in Shearson Lehman, Wall Street's second largest broking firm. 
 Mr Perelman has been talking to Shearson and its parent, American Express, about buying a 20 per cent shareholding in the broking business. 
 Mr Perelman and Shearson will not comment but a share sale to the Revlon chairman could increase the upheaval within Shearson. 
 &bquo;Normally when people come in from the outside into the securities business they leave management alone. 
 If Shearson hope for a passive investor, it is not in Perelman's make up,&equo; says Perrin Long, a securities analyst at Lipper Analytical. 
 Shearson has reshuffled senior management and it plans to cut its US workforce in an attempt to restore its finances. 
 It also faces increased interest costs on its debt unless it improves its balance sheet in time to stave off a threatened downgrading of its debt by the Moody's credit rating agency. 
 Last week the firm said it hoped to agree a sale of part of the 61 per cent stake owned by American Express as part of a deal to inject new equity into the firm. 
 Mr Perelman previously attempted to buy a stake in Salomon Brothers, which rejected his approach. 
 PAGE 
 Saatchi plunges into red. 
 By Roger Cowe 
 SAATCHI and Saatchi, the world's largest advertising agency group, has plunged into the red after providing for &pound;78million of reorganisation and redundancy cost. 
 The company has slashed the dividend, which is being paid out of reserves. 
 The company admitted it had been &bquo;a tough year&equo; but said the second half had seen a &bquo;substantial recovery&equo; in performance of the main communications businesses as costs were controlled. 
 Central staff numbers have been cut by a quarter, including the closure of the office in Washington DC. 
 After those cuts, trading profits of the communications division were more than double those in the first half year and marginally ahead of the second half of last year as business held up. 
 But profits continued to fall in the troubled consultancy division which is up for sale. 
 And a &pound;27million swing in interest costs left trading profits before tax virtually halved at &pound;61million. 
 After tax, reorganisation costs and preference dividends that turned into a loss of &pound;58million, but despite the loss the company is paying a minimal final dividend. 
 &bquo;After careful thought it was decided that a final dividend of 1.6p be recommended,&equo; the board stated, &bquo;making a dividend of 9p for the year. 
 We believe this level to be sustainable.&equo; 
 The group is negotiating the sale of its remaining consultancy businesses and says this will leave it with a strong and focused base in advertising and marketing services. 
 Charles and Maurice Saatchi have stepped back from the top executive roles and have recruited Frenchman Robert Louis-Dreyfus as chief executive. 
 Despite the results and the dividend being lower than expected, Saatchi shares rose 15p yesterday on hopes of a takeover bid. 
 Outlook, page 13 PAGE 
 Saatchi crumbles as Thatcher's star wanes Outlook. 
 By Roger Cowe 
 IT IS grimly appropriate that as Mrs Thatcher's star wanes the fortunes of the advertising agency which shot her to stardom should also crumble. 
 It remains to be seen whether either can bounce back, and whether Saatchi and Saatchi will soon be fighting off a rather more vigorous takeover bid than Mrs Thatcher faced this week. 
 But for the moment there is precious little good news from the brothers who built the world's largest advertising agency from a standing start 19 years ago, in the process building Mrs Thatcher into a formidable vote-winner and doing themselves no end of good thereby. 
 The cracks were already beginning to show at the moment of their greatest triumph. 
 Even as Mrs Thatcher stood triumphant for the third time on the stairs at Central Office the applauding apparatchiks were already honing the knives for the Saatchi team which was blamed for various mid-campaign woes. 
 And as the Saatchi shares peaked ahead of the 1987 stock market crash the seeds of its financial decline had already been sown. 
 The shoots were pushing their heads above the ground even though the group was still able to claim record profits as late as January of this year. 
 In his statement with the annual report chairman Maurice Saatchi described the group as &bquo;the most successful company of the decade.&equo; 
 Two months later the truth was out. 
 At the annual meeting in March Mr Saatchi warned that profits would fall this year (although nobody expected they would fall nearly as much as they have done) and there would be disposals. 
 Business was bad in the main &bquo;communications&equo; division while the consultancy operation was in big trouble. 
 Costs everywhere were out of control. 
 Three years ago the agency was clearly struggling for profitability, coming well down the annual leagaue table for the industry prepared by accountants Spicer and Oppenheim. 
 The illusion of success was maintained only because the group's high share price enabled it to buy companies on the cheap and so keep pushing up total profits and earnings per share. 
 Now the illusion is well and truly shattered and the only reason the share price has not plunged much further than it has is the hope that some brave soul will put the group out of its misery with a takeover. 
 (In fact the share price rose 15p yesterday on just such hopes despite the fact that the results were much worse than expected). 
 The company was putting a brave face on it yesterday, as can only be expected. 
 The second half represented a substantial recovery, the company said. 
 Trading profits in the communications division were more than double the figure for the first half year thanks to the cost control programme. 
 New executives had been appointed. 
 Four consulting companies had been sold. 
 But in fact the worse may not yet be over. 
 The doubling of profits in Communications brings the level back only to what it was in the second half of last year. 
 Consultancy profits were down again from the poor first half level. 
 Interest costs ate a great hole in what profits were left and will continue at a high level unless the group can raise substantial sums from asset sales. 
 There is still no sign of a buyer for the main consultancy business, Hay, and uncertainty over whether an agreement is imminent on Gartner Group. 
 And executives are still leaving even before new chief executive Robert Louis-Dreyfus and his finance director have joined the group. 
 Their task is unenviable. 
 The whole rationale of a global advertising business is under question. 
 But quite apart from that the group faces difficult times. 
 Costs may now be under control, after 750 redundancies and the Washington office closed along with cuts in New York and London. 
 But now the pressure will shift to revenues as the advertising industry environment sours. 
 So far Saatchi and Saatchi has maintained its ability to win new business and remarkably has clung on to its status among advertisers, only recently being voted the best all-round agency. 
 But advertising is a mercurial business. 
 Much depends on the intangibles which produce whatever it is in the ether that allows creative sparks to ignite. 
 In the past those intangibles have been fed by the group's apparent invincibility. 
 But who knows what debilitating effect sackings and losses will have on those vital fluids. 
 Perhaps we will never know. 
 Foreign bodies have already appeared on the Saatchi share register and despite its problems the group would clearly be a juicy prize for someone such as the fast-expanding French. 
 It would be even more grimly appropriate for Saatchi to be swallowed by the French just as Mrs Thatcher lost her struggle to prevent the pound being swallowed into the European Monetary System. 
 PAGE 
 Tiphook confident. 
 Container group Tiphook yesterday said it was still confident of winning its joint &pound;643million bid for Sea Containers even though the battle has swung towards James Sherwood's ferries-to-trailers combine. 
 The offer from the Anglo-Swedish consortium formed by Tiphook and Stena AB is the subject of an appeal in the Bermudan courts which is aimed at overturning an earlier ruling allowing SeaCo to proceed with its &bquo;poison pill&equo; defence. 
 Tiphook, which yesterday unveiled a 124 per cent increase in half year profits to &pound;10million, hopes the court will block SeaCo's purchases of its own shares. 
 Alternatively, it may be able to muster enough support from SeaCo shareholders to halt the current disposal of assets by Mr Sherwood for its bid with Stena to be fully considered. 
 The cost of the bid to Tiphook is put at &pound;2million, which it says will have only a minor impact on full year results. 
 Increased demand for its road, rail and sea container fleets during the first half helped boost the latest figures. 
 This flowed through to earnings per share, up a half at 19.6p and shareholders receive a 25 per cent increase in the interim dividend to 2.7p. 
 The shares rose 9p to 443p. 
 Salvesen boost. 
 Christian Salvesen, the food process and distribution, generator hire and brick making group, raised pre-tax profits by almost 21 per cent to &pound;32.6million in the six months to September. 
 Aggreko generator hire, Salvesen's world market leader which provides power for customers from pop concerts to the oil industry, contributed strongly to a 37 per cent growth in trading profits in the industrial services division. 
 Oil slicks in Alaska and elsewhere helped Vikoma, the group's environmental cleaning equipment manufacturer, which specialises in separating oil from water, and although Salvesen brick, is suffering in the second half from a 30 to 40 per cent cut in demand as housebuilding nosedives, the first half was prosperous and full year trading profit should be on a level with 1988, says finance director Brian Fidler. 
 Almost a third of group profits are earned overseas, interest and tax charges are down on last year and gearing stands at 13 per cent. 
 Capital spending of &pound;43 million should reach a total of &pound;87 million for the full year. 
 The shares rose 10p to 170p. 
 Avon treads warily. 
 Shares in Avon Rubber have fallen sharply this year as a result of the weak demand for winter tyres and rights issue call to finance the move into US motor components. 
 The sale of most of the lossmaking tyre distribution business to Sumitomo, now also a minority shareholder in the only British-controlled tyremaker's plant, gives the board confidence in some improvement this year, despite a poor immediate outlook for the motor producers. 
 Pre-tax profit fell &pound;4.1million to &pound;12.2 million in the year to September 30, in line with the severely-reduced expecations after the Cadillac Rubber acquisition and rights issue in July. 
 Turnover was held at &pound;228.6million, an rise of about &pound;2million, by the earlier contribution from tyre distribution and the US replacement. 
 The final dividend goes up to 11.5p, making 16.5p, against 14p for the year. 
 Earnings crashed by a third to 41p. 
 There was an extraordinary gain of &pound;13.4 million, covering the Motorway Tyres disposal and more rationalisation costs. 
 In short&hellip; 
 WHESSOE saw pre-tax profit rise to &pound;4.78 million, from &pound;3.55 million, on sales of &pound;58 million down from &pound;100 million. 
 Earnings were level at 17.5p a share. 
 Dividends total 5p, up a penny, with a 3.75p final. 
 BTP's enlarged specialist chemicals activities boosted turnover to &pound;60.1million, from &pound;44.8million, in the September half and profit rose to &pound;9.6 million from &pound;5.6 million, including an exceptional &pound;3.1 million, from the Rizzi engineering sale in Italy. 
 Earnings without such gains were 1.9p higher at 6.8p a share. 
 The interim dividend is 2.75p, a rise of 10 per cent. 
 NORCROS, the property, building materials and printing group, saw profits crash from &pound;29million to &pound;18.3million. 
 However, the City had been expecting bad figures and the shares rose 15p to 239p. 
 HARDANGER, the retail property developer, posted pre-tax profits up &pound;1.3million to &pound;8.37million. 
 The final dividend is 26.5p, making a total of 37.5p, against 30p. 
 CRYSTALATE, the electronics product group, experienced a &bquo;serious disappointment&equo; in the second half and hence profits fell from &pound;5.6million to &pound;2.9million in the year to September. 
 The markets. 
 Kingfisher's &pound;461million bid for Dixon's led to a resurgence of speculative activity yesterday. 
 Dixons' shares jumped to 153p in early trading but ended the day at 141p, a 22p rise. 
 Other recently depressed stores, and companies with businesses similar to Dixons, rose in sympathy. 
 Gus A were particularly prominent at 1118p, up 28p ahead of today's interim figures. 
 Properties continued to shine as British Land produced a complicated scheme to release the value of its property portfolio. 
 British Land closed at 405p, a net gain of 48p. 
 Hammerson shot up 45p to 855p in sympathy. 
 Tokyo: Nikkei index: 37,654.29 (37,494.17). 
 Hong Kong: Hang Seng index: 2,756.39 (2,764.44). 
 Frankfurt: FAZ index: 695.74 (684.01). 
 Paris: CAC index: 542.6 (543.8). 
 PAGE 
 Chrysler to sell its &dollar;1bn technology arm. 
 By Mary Brasier in New York 
 US car maker Chrysler, in another move to reinforce its defences against recession, is to sell off its &dollar;1billion technology arm to concentrate resources on its core business. 
 Chairman Lee Iacocca yesterday said the proposed sell-off was part of Chrysler's plan to become the world's lowest-cost and highest-quality car manufacturer. 
 He promised to step up competition against the company's Japanese rivals. 
 Chrysler has already suspended production at one of its main assembly plants and cut back on managerial staff. 
 It has announced plans to cut &dollar;1billion from its budget next year to cope with a slump in car sales. 
 The decision to put the technology division up for sale marks an about-turn for Chrysler which has spent more than &dollar;1billion in the last four years on its policy of diversifying out of cars into related areas. 
 The technology businesses built up since 1985 include Gulfstream Aerospace, known for producing corporate jets. 
 Chrysler's retreat is the latest retrenchment among the US Big Three car makers. 
 Allen Paulson, who runs Gulfstream, has resigned from the Chrysler board to try to launch a buy-out of the technology business. 
 Ronald Perelman, the former corporate raider who heads the Revlon cosmetics empire, is being tipped to take a significant stake in Shearson Lehman, Wall Street's second largest broking firm. 
 PAGE 
 More than 600 claimants die awaiting compensation Barlow Clowes' death toll rises. 
 By Daniel John 
 MORE than 600 of the original 18,000 investors caught up in the collapse of the Barlow Clowes investment empire have died during the 18 month-long battle to secure compensation, it was revealed yesterday. 
 The death toll has worked out at the equivalent of seven a week since the two companies responsible for investing &pound;190million in government securities went into liquidation last June. 
 Many who invested in UK-based Barlow Clowes Gilt Managers and its Gibraltar sister operation, Barlow Clowes International, were elderly people whose plight has been made worse by the loss of their savings. 
 The latest number of deaths were released yesterday as the Barlow Clowes Investors Group (BCIG) sought to secure the release of the Parliamentary Ombudsman's report into the Department of Trade and Industry's role in the affair. 
 The draft written by Sir Anthony Barrowclough, the Ombudsman, is currently in the hands of the DTI for factual checking. 
 Investors have been expecting its publication for the last two weeks but are fearful it will be kept back for the week when Parliament goes into the Christmas recess. 
 That will prevent MPs scrutinising the report in detail and from questioning Trade Secretary Nicholas Ridley about the DTI's role in allowing Barlow Clowes to operate over the years leading up to its collapse. 
 There are also indications that the current criminal investigation into Barlow Clowes may prevent the most sensitive parts from being released. 
 BCIG representatives, including chairman John Dyer, yesterday lobbied key MPs in an effort to secure the report's earliest release. 
 An early day motion has also been put down in the House of Commons supporting their case. 
 A spokeswoman for the Ombudsman's office said the draft report was still in the hands of the DTI and that publication could not take place until it had been returned. 
 Labour's City spokeswoman Dr Marjorie Mowlam yesterday claimed the delay was part of a Government attempt to avoid further embarrassment over the affair. 
 The possibility that the report would not appear before Christmas would mean another miserable time for investors. 
 &bquo;How many more have to die before the report is published and they receive compensation,&equo; she said. 
 PAGE 
 New rules mean a set-back for army of casual workers. 
 By Linda Lennard 
 Unemployment benefit. 
 NEW rules to be introduced from tomorrow will hit many part-time workers receiving unemployment benefit. 
 Those who earn &pound;43 a week or more will lose benefit for the whole of that week &mdash; even if they work only part of it and are unemployed for the remaining days. 
 Only people who earn &pound;12 or less in any week will escape having their entitlement affected at all. 
 Anybody who earns between &pound;12 and &pound;43 in a given week may still be able to qualify for unemployment benefit on the days they are not working. 
 However, they will have to satisfy unemployment benefit officers that part-time work is not their usual pattern, and they are just doing it while looking for full-time employment. 
 In general, it has been accepted that people can take on part-time work in this way if it has not been their usual employment pattern. 
 But adjudication officers may eventually claim that part-time employment is your normal pattern, and that you should not be entitled to benefit on the days you don't work because you would not normally expect to be working anyway. 
 This so-called &bquo;full extent normal rule&equo; has come under considerable criticism from the Court of Appeal downwards. 
 The new rules coming in tomorrow effectively mean the end of the full extent normal rule for people earning &pound;12 or less in a week. 
 The government says the changes are interim measures and it intends to reconsider the whole question of the treatment of earnings received by people on unemployment benefit. 
 If you do any part-time work while on unemployment benefit and your earnings do not affect your benefit entitlement, you will still have to meet the rest of the conditions for this benefit on the remaining days. 
 These include a new stringent &bquo;actively seeking work&equo; test which was introduced this October, as well as showing that you are available for work the rest of the week. 
 As well as earnings from part-time work, other income can affect your entitlement to unemployment benefit. 
 If you are aged 55 or over and have a personal or occupational pension which is more than &pound;35 per week, the rest will be deducted from your benefit. 
 Money from a redundancy payment should not affect your right to this benefit. 
 Also note that if your partner earns more than &pound;21.40 the adult dependants increase will not be payable for her or him. 
 PAGE 
 Water shares &bquo;underpriced&equo;. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 MR MICHAEL Howard, the Water Minister, yesterday effectively admitted that water shares have been underpriced as he formally closed the deadline for application amid City predictions that the issue will open at a premium of up to 30 per cent. 
 As he waited to pose for photographers drinking a glass of water in a City bank, Mr Howard said the Government's calculations had been overtaken by the surge in the stock market. 
 Ministers however were not at fault because &bquo;nobody could tell that the stock market would go up 150 points since we priced the shares. 
 I don't feel any difficulty about that.&equo; 
 As flotation advisers suggested that as many as two million people could have applied for shares after a last-minute surge of applications, he added that the issue would be a big step towards the Government's goal of increasing the level of share-ownership. 
 Meanwhile Labour's water spokeswoman, Ms Ann Taylor, yesterday asked the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee to investigate &bquo;the loss suffered by taxpayers as a result of the privatisation of water.&equo; 
 She said: &bquo;Overall the loss to the taxpayer due to the write off of debt and injection of cash is &pound;1.291billion. 
 &bquo;The whole of the Government's political campaign to privatise water has been massively subsidised by taxpayers. 
 Throughout the year we have all had to pay huge amounts for advertising and for fees to PR firms and City advisers. 
 This has added insult to injury of a privatisation carried out against the wishes of the public. 
 &bquo;The industry has been massively undersold. 
 The price the Government has put on the water industry is a small fraction of the values of the assets shown in the prospectus.&equo; 
 The 500,000 acres of land held by the water companies would be prey to &bquo;massive exploitation.&equo; 
 PAGE 
 Saatchi plunges into red. 
 By Roger Cowe 
 SAATCHI and Saatchi, the world's largest advertising agency group, has plunged into the red after providing for &pound;78million of reorganisation and redundancy cost. 
 The company has slashed the dividend, which is being paid out of reserves. 
 The company admitted it had been &bquo;a tough year&equo; but said the second half had seen a &bquo;substantial recovery&equo; in performance of the main communications businesses as costs were controlled. 
 Central staff numbers have been cut by a quarter, including the closure of the office in Washington DC. 
 After those cuts, trading profits of the communications division were more than double those in the first half year and marginally ahead of the second half of last year as business held up. 
 But profits continued to fall in the troubled consultancy division which is up for sale. 
 And a &pound;27million swing in interest costs left trading profits before tax virtually halved at &pound;61million. 
 After tax, reorganisation costs and preference dividends that turned into a loss of &pound;58million, but despite the loss the company is paying a minimal final dividend. 
 &bquo;After careful thought it was decided that a final dividend of 1.6p be recommended,&equo; the board stated, &bquo;making a dividend of 9p for the year. 
 We believe this level to be sustainable.&equo; 
 The group is negotiating the sale of its remaining consultancy businesses and says this will leave it with a strong and focused base in advertising and marketing services. 
 Charles and Maurice Saatchi have stepped back from the top executive roles and have recruited Frenchman Robert Louis-Dreyfus as chief executive. 
 Despite the results and the dividend being lower than expected, Saatchi shares rose 15p yesterday on hopes of a takeover bid. 
 Outlook, page 13 PAGE 
 US hopes high of winning ballot to secure Pacific island nuclear base. 
 By A Correspondent 
 ISLANDERS in the tiny Pacific state of Palau vote in a referendum on February 6 for the seventh time on a deal with the United States which would give the US strategic military rights in the Western Pacific only 500 miles from the troubled Philippines. 
 Washington is optimistic that voters will at last consent to a treaty called the Compact of Free Association. 
 The US has been trying for a decade to clinch the deal, not least because it would give its nuclear forces control of what is seen as the strategically vital Pacific zone and a new set of options if its Philippine naval and air bases are threatened. 
 But the 11,000 island voters have rejected the treaty in six referendums since 1983. 
 Opposition to the deal is being led by Palau's small but powerful group of traditional women elders, who say the agreement would have a devastating social economic and political impact on Palau's society and culture. 
 The compact would grant the US options on exclusive military rights in and around the Palau archipelago for 50 years. 
 In exchange, Washington would provide Palau with &dollar;460 million in aid over 15 years. 
 Palau's constitution bans nuclear activity unless agreed by at least 75 per cent of voters. 
 All referendums so far have failed to reach the required majority, although more than half the electorate voted in favour. 
 Schizophrenic dance of Kids of Fame Simon Tisdall in Tegucigalpa reports on Honduras' love-hate relationship with the US and its addictive cultural trappings. 
 By Simon Tisdall in Tegucigalpa, Honduras 
 AT the store on the corner, three drunken men are trying to eat the same hot dog. 
 Across the road, an army conscript in battle fatigues watches. 
 Somewhere along the dark street, somebody is crying. 
 It is past midnight in down town Tegucigalpa, and it's time to go home. 
 And here, at last, come the Kids from Fame. 
 Chela and Urna are dancers at La Fama night club, a grotty little joint comprising one bar, 15 or so rickety wooden tables, and an illuminated picture of a woman's bottom which flashes on and off. 
 But La Fama has a stage. 
 And that is what really interests Chela and Urna. 
 Like the thousands of young people who crowd the narrow streets of Tegucigalpa, the Kids from La Fama are obsessed with the trappings of North American culture. 
 A fancy New York dance school it isn't, but for Chela and Urna the spotlit stage at La Fama is an alluring link with the much-emulated, much vilified empire to the north. 
 Such schizophrenia, when it comes to the &bquo;yanquis&equo; is common throughout Central America. 
 And in another way, the Kids from Honduras symbolise one of the region's most pressing problems &mdash; the population explosion. 
 Like its neighbour Nicaragua Honduras is growing beyond its means. 
 Last month, the IMF declared Honduras ineligible for further funds after it failed to repay debts of &dollar;16 million, bringing its overdue obligations to &dollar;26.5 million. 
 The World Bank has taken similar action because of &dollar;57 million arrears. 
 Through the Caribbean Basin Initiative, the US is attempting to encourage export industries in countries such as Honduras, in addition to direct financial aid. 
 But this, in turn, reopens the issue of national dependence on Uncle Sam. 
 And in any case, the particulars of such a seeming unequal struggle are of little immediate help, or interest, to the Kids from La Fama. 
 Since dancing cannot earn them a living, Chela and Urna are into self-help, and it is as humiliating in personal terms as any perceived national, cultural subservience to the US. 
 Urna is the most forward. 
 She sits at the table and smiles, asking firmly for a solo-brandy and coke in separate glasses. 
 She is young but not so young as Chela, who says she is 18 but looks 16 at the most. 
 Chela, too, has a solo. 
 When they suggest a dance to my companion, Wesley, there seems no harm &mdash; but it turns into a smooch. 
 Solos become doubles, and doubles trebles. 
 And the Kids from La Fama grow ever more possessive. 
 &bquo;Now we have to go,&equo; say Chela and Urna suddenly. 
 &bquo;But there is a problem.&equo; 
 The problem turns out to be the boss of the club, who says we must pay &dollar;8 if the girls are to leave. 
 Outside, I wait for Wesley, who is negotiating Chela and Urna's release. 
 Finally, here they come, the Kids from Fame, Honduras-style, giggling yet purposeful. 
 &bquo;Where do you want to go, we'll drop you in a taxi,&equo; I say. 
 All three now look at me incredulously. 
 And the penny drops. 
 &bquo;Back to the hotel, man, come on!&equo; says Wesley. 
 It took 30 minutes of argument, a great deal of soothing of apparently hurt professional pride, and not a little money to persuade Chela that it was time to call it a night, alone. 
 It was normal, argued Wesley. 
 It was expected, warned Urna. 
 It was very, very sad, thought I, as the army conscript across the road laughed at the prostitution of his country's future. 
 Christians say 40,000 were assembled against them Syria &bquo;planned mass assault&equo; on Aoun. 
 By David Hirst in Beirut 
 IT may never be known whether the Syrian army ever really did intend to seize Baabda Palace, drive out General Michel Aoun, and install the new President, Elias Hrawi, in his place. 
 But if it did, it was apparently to have been a big affair &mdash; no mere helicopter-borne &bquo;surgical strike&equo; &mdash; in which sheer weight of numbers and firepower could have been expected to guarantee ultimate success. 
 Very heavy Syrian casualties would apparently have been deemed a lesser price to pay than the probable failure of anything less than what the general's men say was planned: a full-scale armoured and infantry assault involving 40,000 men on five main axes along a 50-kilometre front. 
 The likelihood that, after all the fanfare and ultimatums, it is not going to happen, or at least not for the time being, is another boost for the &bquo;rebel&equo; general in his lonely defiance of Lebanon's Muslims &mdash; indeed, a good many of its Christians, too &mdash; much of the Arab world, and international communities. 
 The Tayif agreement was supposed to be a formula for peace, but last week it came close to becoming a recipe for one of the biggest, almost certainly the most ferocious, battles of the 14 &frac12;-year war. 
 It might be argued that historically the Maronite Christians have done much to bring this near calamity on themselves, that Gen Aoun is only the latest, probably the last, in a long line of revolts against an Arab and Mulsim environment to which this most stiff-necked of Arab minorities refuses to adapt itself. 
 Recently, one prominent, hitherto militant Christian commentator did argue that. 
 But last week such arguments looked academic: the Maronites were facing the first-ever full-scale invasion of their traditional mountain heartland, and the survival of &bquo;Christian Lebanon&equo; was at stake as never before. 
 There was no question but that the army, the Lebanese Forces militia, and a whole new wave of volunteers would have put up a desperate resistance. 
 Even if the new President had entered his official residence, he would have no standing in his own community, and what, after all, is the point of a Maronite President if it is not to integrate the Maronites within the traditional confessional system which &mdash; readjusted in the Muslims' favour &mdash; the Tayif agreement perpetuates? 
 If that agreement is already deeply ailing, the Syrian invasion would have killed it off. 
 The plain fact is that Syria, together with the principal promoters of the Arab League &bquo;peace plan&equo; such as the US and Saudi Arabia, and its reluctant supporters such as France, have taken fright at its enforcement. 
 In Malta, President Bush &mdash; in agreement with President Gorbachev &mdash; said there must be no more bloodshed in Lebanon. 
 France has said that it would support the side that restarted the war. 
 The Arab &bquo;troika&equo; has called for restraint by all parties. 
 In other words, they don't want Syria to strike. 
 But that puts them all in a real quandary. 
 For at the same time they still see no alternative to Tayif, and still see Aoun as the one great impediment in its way. 
 Yet, now more than ever, force would appear to be the only way of ousting the general, and Syria alone capable of supplying it. 
 There is fresh talk of a general blockade against the enclave. 
 The diplomatic one has already begun. 
 But Lebanon's inter-communal boundaries are so porous, so criss-crossed by reciprocal interests &mdash; with, for example, East Beirut controlling most of West Beirut's water and electricity supplies &mdash; that an economic blockade would probably require a much greater political will than the shambles which Hrawi's &bquo;legitimate&equo; administration could ever muster. 
 States don't advertise such intentions, but there can be no doubt that Syria, for one, is working overtime on a means of killing the general. 
 The other factor on which the architects of Tayif have been counting is divisions within the Christian community. 
 President Bush himself, no less, effectively called on Gen Aoun's loyalist troops to rise against him, but, though some senior officers oppose his high-risk strategies and resent his authoritarian style, they are unlikely to move in the recent climate of public adulation for the great new champion. 
 The same is true of those other centres of Maronite power, such as the Lebanese Forces militia. 
 On a one-day visit from Washington, where he now resides, the US ambassador expressed his exasperated surprise that the Lebanese Forces had not joined the &bquo;legitimate&equo; government. 
 The divisions are certainly latent, but the very manner in which, especially since President Muawad's assassination, Syria has been trying to enforce the peace plan &mdash; with such haste, threats and bluster &mdash; tends to blunt rather than sharpen them. 
 It is not the general who must go, his aides say, it is Tayif which must change. 
 And for all his stubbornness he is in fact hinting at his readiness for a deal. 
 He is ready, he says, to consider Syria's &bquo;vital interests&equo; in Lebanon, and by that he appears to mean that its army could stay in the Beka'a Valley, provided it is clearly intended for defence against Israeli attack and not for interference in Lebanon's internal affairs. 
 It is, on the face of it, a very considerable offer. 
 But it is very doubtful whether Assad could accept it: it would mean ditching Tayif and recognising the general. 
 But Aoun seems sure that, if he just hangs on regardless, some other miracle will in due course come to the rescue. 
 A continent with an identity crisis In the final page of the Guardian's pre-EC Strasbourg summit conference analysis of politics and society Martin Kettle argues against easy optimism. 
 LAST weekend, the BBC broadcast a documentary about the attempts of ballet historians to reconstruct Nijinsky's lost choreography for the 1913 Paris premiere of Stravinsky's The Rite of Spring. 
 The programme ended with a complete performance of the ballet as the historians think it must have looked on that epochal occasion. 
 Anyone who has read about the cultural life of that period knows that Diaghilev's Russian Ballet created a sensation throughout pre-1914 western Europe. 
 Watching the Nijinsky recreation it was suddenly possible to understand why. 
 For this was something which came from right outside the audience's experience or expectations. 
 It was barbaric, foreign, and, above all, Russian. 
 Today, it is no longer possible to imagine such a thing happening. 
 Nothing in European life, even in Albania, retains that capacity to shock, even to shock people who have never left West Cumberland in their lives. 
 Europe is still a continent of separate localities and traditions, but it is infinitely more homogeneous than it was. 
 Less than two centuries ago, when the English Romantics saw the Alps they could only stare with wild surmise. 
 Today, more than 100 million Europeans are gearing up for this winter's invasion of the ski-slopes. 
 Every year, more Europeans learn a little more about one another than their ancestors ever knew. 
 They take more foreign holidays. 
 They make more business trips. 
 In the last ten years the number of phone calls from Britain to other European countries has multiplied two and half times. 
 Even so, in countless places around Europe, people behave and think in ways which are totally distinctive. 
 Stand in a French village when the Tour de France goes by and you are participating in an event which is unambiguously French. 
 Go to a provincial Italian opera house and you enter a quintessentially Italian world where the relationship between performers and audience is a private ritual. 
 Talk to a Hungarian reformer about the political crisis and you will soon learn that he is literally obsessed with the situation in Budapest. 
 In every case, such encounters have their European dimension. 
 The Tour de France is now broadcast daily into most European countries and you can find 6-year-old children in London who will argue the merits of Fignon versus Lemond. 
 Opera, too, is beamed around the Continent like never before; tonight's Verdi first night at La Scala is on radio and television channels across Europe. 
 And persons of average political sensibility in many lands eagerly study the transformations in Hungary and seek to draw lessons from the changes. 
 Yet in all these random examples, which are each dimensions of the new Europe, it wouldn't occur to the participants for one second that they are being European. 
 The British are not in any sense unique, though they may be an extreme example, in their preoccupation with themselves and their own ways. 
 To expect Europe to become a single warm cultural bath is simply to mistake the nature of the European, and indeed any other, identity. 
 To be European in France is to think globally about a French-led political Europe which will challenge the power of Japan and America. 
 But to be European in Lithuania or Scotland is to assert your nationality and the wish to get Moscow or London off your back. 
 To be European in Italy is a logical extension of what is already assumed to be one's natural multiple identity within a family, a city, a region and a nation. 
 And to be European in southern England, is to make a political statement against Thatcherism, philistinism, and English insularity. 
 WHERE ARE the boundaries of Europe? 
 Before people talk of Europe from the Atlantic to the Urals, they ought to look at the map and understand what they are saying. 
 If you stand on the border of Hungary and the Soviet Union, you are nearer to Lisbon than the Urals. 
 If we truly share a common European home, then its logical capital is Kiev not Brussels. 
 The mental and emotional boundaries of Europe are even harder to draw. 
 Europe is both a fact of life and an aspiration. 
 It is a place we live in and an ideal to which some aspire. 
 There are Turks and Israelis who passionately consider themselves Europeans but there are Muslims and Jews for whom Europe is simply a hostile place where they live. 
 No nation and no government has been more conscious of the need, as they perceive it, to build barriers protecting European civilisation against American and Japanese audio-visual cultural imperialism than the French. 
 Yet this is also the government which has fought most ruthlessly to bring EuroDisneyland to Marne la Vallee in the early 1990s. 
 The embodiment of the new Europe is often said to be Mikhail Gorbachev. 
 But he is a man presiding over a collapsing economy and a discredited political system. 
 Looked at from the West, Franois Mitterrand or perhaps Karl-Otto Pohl, president of the Bundesbank, might seem more appropriate technocratic candidates. 
 But is there not a case for saying that we are currently witnessing the historic counter attack of Christian Democracy, which has summoned up the traditions of Eastern Europe to redress the balance of the West? 
 In that case, the most truly emblematic figure in the new Europe is actually Pope John Paul II and Gorbachev's visit to the Vatican last week was the new Canossa. 
 For there are many Europes and they are all dominated by history. 
 As 1989 ends, it is tempting to imagine that Europe is emerging into a wholly new identity, governed by peace not war, common aspirations rather than sectional concerns. 
 In this Europe there is a Benetton in every high street, Badoit and Czech Budweiser in every fridge, an Armani jacket in every wardrobe, Beaujolais Nouveau on every table, cable and satellite television channels in many languages in every living room, an Umberto Eco novel on every bookshelf, a Volvo in every garage, where CDs of The Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment lie casually next to Eurythmics, and where nipping across to Paris for the day is as natural as doing a day's business in London. 
 It's an attractive vision, up to a point, and it has a certain reality. 
 But it is basically an illusion and, what is more, a very old one. 
 THERE have been what Jacques Delors calls &bquo;European projects&equo; before. 
 Some have been religious, mostly conceived by or on behalf of the Papacy, attempting to impose Catholic hegemony over schism, protestantism, and even Judaism and Islam. 
 Others have been ideological in other ways, on behalf of the French Revolution and the Rights of Man, or the power of reactionary princes in the age of Metternich. 
 Mostly they have been military, the attempt of one nation to subdue the rest. 
 Philip II of Spain came close to achieving it, before he was defeated by, among others, half naked English mercenary soldiers who &bquo;for thieving and brawling had no equals&equo; &mdash; the ancestors of the football fans who are plotting next year's &bquo;English invasion of Italy&equo;. 
 Louis XIV had good try and Napoleon an even better one. 
 For the first half of the last century, most European nations assumed that France would somehow try to repeat the project. 
 After 1870, their attention switched to believing that Germany was a more dangerous antagonist, a belief which was borne out until 1945. 
 Since then, and until very recently, Europe has been united against the fear, which would have seemed as absurd in previous centuries as it still does to many in the 1980s, of Russia. 
 And now? 
 To hear some people talk, you would think such things are all in a jumbled undifferentiated past, much as the Louis XIV's palace of Versailles with its real hall of mirrors now also houses Jacques-Louis David's massive celebrations of Napoleon and of the revolution which brought down the Bourbons. 
 &bquo;A few years ago, many thoughtful men, in no way given to utopian ideas, had begun to hope that Western Europe would never again be the scene of the awful horrors of war. 
 Everything seemed to favour that belief. 
 Old feuds of race were diminishing, rivalries and prejudices were by degrees fading out.Such frequent and such intimate relations had thus been established between nations, that it seemed as if they must soon unite in one family, in one single federal state. 
 No nation in Europe, had the question been fairly put to them, would have answered that they wished war.&equo; 
 A few months later, as Emile de Laveleye goes on to say in this essay of 1871, the Franco-Prussian war broke out, setting in motion the sequence of European conflicts which led, ultimately, to the obliteration of the centre of Berlin in 1945. 
 It seems somehow presumptuous to believe that in 1989 Europe has emerged into a cloudless world in which such things are now no longer possible. 
 Berlin, the haunted city of Europe. 
 BERLIN is where old Europe died in 1945 &mdash; bombed into smithereens as no British city was ever bombed. 
 Yet Berlin is also where the new Europe of old ideals has been born again in 1989. 
 If you can understand Berlin then perhaps it is also possible to make some sense of what Europe may now become and of what it means to be a European. 
 But how does one make any sense of Berlin? 
 Like Europe itself, it is a place of ghosts and a hall of historic mirrors. 
 Its future, like the future of Europe, lies in understanding its immanent past. 
 Before November 9, the visitor to the derelict Potsdamer Platz, where no trams run on the ancient tramlines which now lead nowhere, could mount the viewing platform by the tourist kiosks on the western side and peer across the Grepo border guards' free fire zone at the drab buildings a quarter of a mile away in the east. 
 A little to the left in the no man's land in front of the buildings was a grass mound. 
 It was truly a funeral mound. 
 It is all that remains of Hitler's bunker, the place of Gotterdammerung. 
 Rabbits used to play on it, one of the few places in Europe where rabbits were in no danger of being shot. 
 Today the bunker mound is still there. 
 Only now it is more difficult to spot because they have taken away the visitors' platform and the view through the most celebrated new gap in the Berlin Wall is often obscured by the steady stream of tramping East Berliners and their Trabant cars. 
 Soon, you suspect, that grassy mound will become a skateboard park. 
 AS THE East Berliners cross into the West, they see some unusual sights. 
 All around them are the forestastes of the Europeannesswhich, even if they don't opt for it, is certainly the one they are going to get. 
 They are offered cups of tea from a steaming cauldron by British soldiers. 
 Little red leaflets headed Herzlich Wilkommen! are pressed into their cold hands; the leaflets give them the deeply resistible news that they that they can get discounts on all burgers at the BurgerKing shops across West Berlin. 
 At the back of a huge lorry, free samples of Bahlsen biscuits are being dispensed. 
 A queue at the Mercedes-Benz double decker bus waits patiently for more freebies as the Trabants double park with immunity. 
 On the edge of the crowd the inevitable party of Japanese tourists busily video the scene, turning history into home movies, acting out Andy Warhol's belief that the 20th century could only know a thing was true if it was on TV. 
 These past days have been matchlessly hectic in downtown West Berlin. 
 It's hard to tell yet which of West Berlin's identities attracts the &bquo;Ossies&equo; most. 
 Beacon of freedom? 
 Shop-window of capitalism? 
 The middle-class half of Prussia's lost capital? 
 The gay and risque nightlife? 
 West Berlin is all these things and more to the inhabitants of the GDR. 
 What we are witnessing is the eager consummation that follows a long and passionate seduction. 
 What will it look like after the honeymoon? 
 Berlin's brightly lit streets are swimming with happy people. 
 But along the margins the ghosts still lurk. 
 Here, in Tauentzienstrasse, where Isherwood lodged in different days, as the East Berliners queue for fruit and cheap stereos, a Turkish beggar sleeps in a doorway with a notice round his neck saying &bquo;Hunger.&equo; 
 IN Wittenbergplatz, the Christmas shoppers crowd into the Kaufhaus des Westens. 
 It is that same KaDeWe &mdash; you pronounce it &bquo;cardayvay&equo; &mdash; where 60 years ago a Hungarian band played popular dance music favourites in the chic top floor restaurant. 
 Their speciality was tunes like In Sans Souci &mdash; to remind Twenties Berliners of that nice Sunday afternoon tram ride they could take out to Frederick the Great's summer palace at Potsdam &mdash; a trip no West Berliner has been able to take for half a century. 
 The KaDeWe is a vast department store. 
 In the new Europe, where consumerism is the new religion, department stores are important temples. 
 They all manage to look much the same. 
 Go into Printemps in Paris, Rinascente in Milan, de Bijenkorf in Amsterdam, or the KaDeWe and you could be in any of the others. 
 Even more important, the products are the same too. 
 But if KaDeWe looks like the others inside, there is something very different about it outside. 
 By the Wittenbergplatz U-Bahn station there is something which looks like a very large public information notice, which in one sense it is, but which is in fact a memorial. 
 It says simply &bquo;Places Of Horror Which We Must Never Forget&equo; and then lists ten concentration camps from Auschwitz to Bergen-Belsen. 
 Anyone can see that the breaching of the Berlin Wall is a great symbolic event as well as an actual one. 
 One month on, November 9, 1989 is already enshrined as one of the key dates of 20th century German and European history. 
 Streets are being named after it. 
 But it is an easy event to oversimplify. 
 Many different things will eddy back and forth as the link between east and west Europe is reopened. 
 Without a knowledge of history, George Bush's wish to see the Olympic Games in Berlin in 2004 would seem unproblematically splendid. 
 But because we cannot escape history it also seems either naive or even wicked. 
 It is precisely because Berlin is such a true mirror of so much European history that it always seems to embody so much of the darker, subconscious side of the European identity. 
 GO DOWN to the Kreuzberg district of Berlin now and you get a more nuanced picture. 
 of the new Berlin and the new Europe. 
 Here by the Oberbaum bridge across the icy Spree is what used to be a quintessential Cold War Berlin scene. 
 Across the river in the east it is not far to the site of the Gestapo cells where the young Erich Honecker was locked up in March 1945 for organising Communist resistance against the Nazis. 
 Today Honecker is in custody again and the tradition over which he presided is said to have run its course. 
 On the western side this was always an area characterised by a militancy which is presumably going out of fashion now too. 
 A century ago, weavers and bricklayers in this working class district won some of the earliest strikes for the ten hour day. 
 Down the road at Kottbusser Tor, workers fought in the streets in 1920 to defend the Weimar Republic against the Kapp putsch. 
 Today in the Green Party stronghold of Kopernickerstrasse banners hang from windows. 
 They plead &bquo;Money for all Foreigners. 
 Neither Kohl nor Krenz. 
 No to reunification. 
 Fight together against both capitalists and bureaucrats.&equo; 
 But in the street below, the East German trippers pour back home laden with cans of Coca-Cola and Corn Flakes past smiling border guards all anxious to please. 
 This is Turkish Berlin, where the &bquo;guest workers&equo; whose predicament has been brought to wider notice by the brilliant investigations of Gunter Wallraff live in poor housing, on low wages, and amid great hostility. 
 For some of them, eagerly selling six-packs of beer on street corners, the new Berlin is full of opportunities. 
 Yet for many of these inhabitants of the new Europe, the breaching of the Wall is another nightmare, opening the gates into West Germany to a mass of high-skilled, low-wage workers who are white and German. 
 The great dream for Germany could be the great nightmare for Germany's Third World population. 
 But it is not just a question of Turks in Berlin or even Turks in West Germany. 
 For the Turks of Kreuzberg read the Maghrebins of Marseille, the Pakistanis of Bradford, or the Somalis of Rome. 
 The same issue exists in all the important societies of Europe. 
 For such people the European identity is a threat as much as a promise. 
 The need to face such things is never far away in Berlin. 
 On the walls of U-Bahn stations these days there are posters which have been put there by the Red-Green coalition which governs the city under Walter Momper. 
 The poster shows 25 faces of different ages and races. 
 Underneath it reads BerlinerInnen (the anti-sexist way of saying Berliners in German) aller Lander vertragt euch - Berliners of all countries get on together. 
 It could be a statement of fact, an expression of hope, or even an order. 
 Few cities anywhere in Europe can match the cultural richness of Berlin. 
 This is not just a liberal euphemism for the city's ethnic diversity. 
 Berlin's buildings &mdash; such of them as have survived &mdash; tell the story of the pioneering ages of modern design. 
 Its cabaret tradition and its popular music are unrivalled. 
 Its theatres are the stuff of legends. 
 It has an unmatchable symphony orchestra that seems to be the envy of the entire Japanese nation. 
 What place could better embody all that is best about the European identity? 
 THREE years ago, the Colorado-based Aspen Institute held a conference in West Berlin to discuss the development of multi-ethnic societies in western Europe. 
 It was a generally constructive attempt to discuss the fact that 2 or 3 per cent of the population of most big European countries is now from the Third World, something which those who rhapsodise about the &bquo;European identity&equo; often ignore. 
 The guests were put up in the Inter-Continental Hotel which overlooks the stretch of the Landwehr Canal into which the Freikorps threw the dead body of Rosa Luxembourg in 1919. 
 The conference was held at Wannsee, the place where the Nazis met to decide on the final solution. 
 MARTIN KETTLE 
 Obituary: J.P.M.Millar. 
 Plebs power 
 ALWAYS known by his initials, J.P.M.Millar for more than 40 years ran the National Council of Labour Colleges; an organisation which through classes, lectures, weekend and summer schools, and the massive number of correspondent courses organised by his wife Christine, provided shots and shell for the emerging Labour movement. 
 Catering for more than 100,000 students a year, the Millars had a major influence on the dissemination of socialist ideas. 
 When the rush of Labour MPs came into the Commons after the 1945 election, about two thirds were former students or tutors of the NCLC. 
 The NCLC was born out of a strike at Ruskin College in 1908 about the class bias of Oxford education. 
 Ten of the 54 strikers formed the nucleus of the Central Labour College, backed by the Amalgamated Society of Railway Servants, the South Wales Miners' Federation, and the Amalgamated Society of Engineers. 
 Hostility from Oxford landlords caused the college to move to Earls Court. 
 The students shared the cooking and domestic chores. 
 Millar came to the NCLC in 1923, first as press officer, but he soon became general secretary. 
 He continued until 1965, when the NCLC was handed over to the TUC. 
 The decision to wind up coincided with Millar's retirement, but owed more to the competition from the TUC's own education department and the Workers' Educational Association. 
 Millar said: &bquo;The WEA was subsidised by the state and we were not. 
 The WEA provided orthodox education, orientated to the capitalist system. 
 We provided a socialist system of education. 
 Would you expect the devil to be subsidised by heaven?&equo; 
 Millar was obstinately determined to change the content of education. 
 Though never a left-winger in current terms, he wanted the socialist viewpoint expressed in every facet of learning. 
 &bquo;Knowledge is power &mdash; the right kind of knowledge,&equo; he liked to say. 
 A strain of independent socialist thinking runs through his courses, pamphlets, and articles for Plebs, the NCL journal he edited. 
 Millar told me: &bquo;Labour's view of education has always been limited. 
 It wasn't so much as how to achieve a new social order, but how can I ensure that my son or daughter gets a better job than I did. 
 That was the object. 
 Before you can have a revolution you have to break down the existing system.&equo; 
 The Millars retired and moved to Dartmouth. 
 The house had a double garage which Millar turned into a study and office. 
 Jam-packed with a complete run of Plebs and sets of the TUC and Labour Party conference reports, it was here that he wrote his book The Labour College Movement. 
 Allen Saddler J.P.M. Millar, born April 17, 1893; died December 2, 1989 international page 23 PAGE 
 Israel suspends ban on intifada protest songs. 
 By Ian Black in Jerusalem 
 ON the eve of the second anniversary of the intifada, a row has broken out over two popular Hebrew songs which protest strongly about treatment of the Palestinians in the occupied territories and Israeli indifference to the situation. 
 The Minister of Education, Mr Yitzhak Navon, said yesterday that he was suspending a ban on the songs by the state-run Broadcasting Authority pending a final decision by the attorney-general. 
 The Broadcasting Authority voted on Tuesday to stop the playing of Apres moi le deluge, by Nurit Galron, and Had Gadya, by Hava Alberstein. 
 Likud members won after Labour representatives insisted that the vote was illegal. 
 Ms Alberstein's song is a powerful modern version of an ancient Aramaic ballad sung around the Passover &bquo;Seder&equo; table by Jews celebrating the Exodus from Egypt. 
 The singer was following an old tradition of adapting the ceremony to give it contemporary relevance, adding to the festival's famous &bquo;four questions&equo; about the meaning of Passover a new and troubling one. 
 &bquo;On all other nights I ask only four questions, / but tonight I have another one: / How long will this circle of terror continue? / Hunter and hunted, beater and beaten, / when will this madness end?&equo; 
 Some of the words of Ms Galron's song, which explores the theme of guilt and responsibility for the uprising while Tel Aviv makes merry, were read out in the Knesset yesterday in the course of a stormy debate marking the second anniversary of the intifada. 
 Mr Yossi Sarid, of the leftwing opposition Citizens Rights Movement, quoted from the lyrics: &bquo;Don't tell me about the girl who lost her eye. 
 Don't tell me about the girl who lost her childhood.&equo; 
 In other developments yesterday, the East Jerusalem Palestinian activist, Mr Faisal Husseini, was banned from entering the West Bank or Gaza Strip for six months. 
 Mr Husseini was accused of helping to co-ordinate rival Palestinian factions and encouraging civil disobedience campaigns. 
 The Israeli Peace Now movement condemned the decision, but defence sources said the order was based on detailed reports about Mr Husseini's political activities. 
 Mr Husseini insists that all his activities are peaceful. 
 Mr Husseini, the most senior supporter of the PLO in the occupied territories, has spent much of his time recently trying to prevent the killing of Palestinians suspected of collaborating with the Israeli authorities. 
 The High Court, meanwhile, rejected an appeal by a rightwing MP to deport two other leading Palestinians suspected of being involved in the leadership of the intifada. 
 They are Mr Sari Nusseibeh, professor of philosophy at Beir Zeit University, and Mr Radwan Abu Ayyash, chairman of the Palestinian Journalists Association. 
 Israeli troops yesterday clamped a curfew on the 650,000 Arabs in the Gaza Strip in an effort to avert unrest on Saturday. 
 An army spokesman said the curfew would continue until further notice, but army radio said it would be lifted on Sunday. 
 Journalists will only be allowed in the area under army escort. 
 Ten die in clash with Turkish security forces. 
 By Jane Howard in Ankara 
 NINE rebels and a soldier were killed in a clash with Turkish security forces near the Syrian border, Ankara authorities said yesterday, adding claims that Kurdish separatists receive foreign support. 
 The incident occurred 48 hours after three men and a woman were shot dead allegedly infiltrating up the River Tigris by boat. 
 Regional nerves have been strained by a plan to cut off water from Syria and Iraq for a month, and by the Syrian shooting down of a Turkish civilian plane in October. 
 More than 1,300 people have died in separatist fighting in the last three years for independence for Turkey's estimated nine million Kurds. 
 Ankara signed a security protocol with Syria two years ago in an attempt to tackle the problem of cross-border support. 
 In return, it promised not to play its one trump card &mdash; water. 
 The Euphrates River rises in Turkey and flows through Syria and Iraq into the Persian Gulf. 
 Syria especially needs the water for irrigation and electricity-generating turbines. 
 The Arabs are worried that if Turkey diverts water into massive hydro-electric and irrigation schemes they will be left without water. 
 At the weekend, Ankara revealed plans to divert the water for at least a month from January 13 to begin filling the huge Ataturk dam. 
 A hastily-assembled six-man Iraqi delegation arrived in Turkey yesterday to discuss the plans, which they fear could affect rice and wheat crops in central and southern Iraq. 
 Kremlin hold reins of the GDR army. 
 By David Fairhall and Michael Simmons 
 THE 120,000-strong GDR army, alone among the Warsaw Pact armies, is under the direct operational control of the Soviet forces stationed alongside them, who outnumber them by about three to one. 
 It can therefore be assumed that the Soviet commanders are fully aware of the situation, if not totally in control of it. 
 From Moscow, Mr Gorbachev is believed to have given personal orders that his troops should stay firmly in their East German barracks during recent demonstrations and not respond to local provocation. 
 There is no reason to suppose that the Russians are seeking trouble and the same has so far been true of the East Germans. 
 On that evidence, therefore, and in spite of last night's ominous phrases that the government would not tolerate &bquo;chaos and anarchy&equo;, it seems that the statement is more likely to be a specific warning &mdash; that people breaking in to armouries to steal weapons or ammunition could expect to be met by physical force &mdash; than a sign that the military are planning a political takeover. 
 Although the deposed Communist Party leader, Mr Egon Krenz, has been credited with countermanding orders to issue live ammunition to troops standing by to deal with the Leipzig demonstrations, other sources indicate that it was the military district commander who stepped in to avoid bloodshed. 
 There must be some question as to how reliable the East German troops would be in such a situation, bearing in mind that most of them are conscripts, and that about 30,000 of them have recently been released from military service to man understaffed factories. 
 If it came to straightforward riot control, the most appropriate force would probably be the 12,000-strong People's Police Alert units, under the control of the ministry of the interior. 
 East German defence spending, at around 11 per cent of the national budget, is marginally higher proportionally than in West Germany. 
 There are nearly twice as many military personnel in East Germany per 1,000 of the population. 
 West Germany said yesterday it had agreed to cut its armed forces by nearly a fifth to 400,000 by the mid 1990s if US and Soviet negotiators agreed on cutting conventional arms. 
 Plans to lengthen military service from 15 to 18 months will also be scrapped if the talks succeed. 
 The number of reservists will be increased from 28,400 to 40,000, while defence spending in 1990 is set to rise by 2.8 per cent. 
 Verdict near in Miami race trial. 
 By Mark Tran in Washington 
 ONE of Miami's most racially charged trials in recent years was nearing a climax yesterday, as the jury deliberated on the fate of a Hispanic policeman whose killing of two blacks sparked off rioting in January. 
 There are fears that the acquittal of William Lozano will set off renewed riots in a city fraught with racial tension between Hispanic and black communities. 
 Mr Lozano was charged with manslaughter when he shot and killed a black motorcyclist in the rundown neighbourhood of Overtown. 
 The single shot instantly killed 23-year-old Clement Lloyd, and his passenger, Allan Blanchard, who was 24, died of injuries after the motorcycle crashed. 
 The incident precipitated three days of violence and looting that tarnished Miami's reputation at a time when the city was preening itself for one of America's premier sporting events, the Super Bowl. 
 The presence of hundreds of journalists for the game ensured the kind of publicity that Miami preferred not to have. 
 Extraordinary precautions have been taken to defuse tempers in case of acquittal. 
 Key testimony has been broadcast live on television and radio to help keep the city fully abreast of the proceedings and to show the wheels of justice turning. 
 Mr Lorenzo contends he fired in self-defence because he was about to be run down by the motorcycle, which was being chased by a police car. 
 Mr Lloyd was carrying marijuana and &dollar;1,514 in cash, and his blood contained alcohol, marijuana, and traces of cocaine. 
 The prosecution argues that Mr Lorenzo was in no danger and could have stepped out of harm's way. 
 The case has again focused attention on tension between Miami's police force and the city's black community. 
 Twice in the last decade police shootings of blacks have set off extensive rioting. 
 PAGE 
 France backs Soviet plan for European conference. 
 By Reuter in Kiev 
 PRESIDENT Franois Mitterrand of France threw his weight yesterday behind a Soviet proposal to bring forward to next year a 35-nation conference to hammer out the future shape of Europe. 
 &bquo;President (Mikhail) Gorbachev floated the idea,&equo; Mitterrand told a joint news conference with the Kremlin chief after the two men met in Kiev. 
 &bquo;I cannot speak for the other 33 countries who are not here, but as for me, I would say if this happened in 1990 it would be good,&equo; he added. 
 Earlier, a Soviet official accompanying Mr Gorbachev said the Kremlin leader would express his support for an all-European conference next year to examine the burning issue of German reunification. 
 Mr Gorbachev proposed during a visit to Italy last week that such a conference be convened in 1990. 
 It was originally scheduled for 1992 as part of a series of follow-up meetings to the 1975 Helsinki conference on European security and co-operation. 
 The West German Foreign Minister, Mr Hans-Dietrich Genscher, on Tuesday gave his conditional backing for the conference, which would include the United States and Canada as well as all European countries with the exception of Albania. 
 He said Bonn was favourably disposed to such a conference if it were well prepared. 
 Pakistan arrests of opium farmers triggers protests. 
 By Kathy Evans in Peshawar 
 PAKISTANI authorities have for the first time begun arresting farmers in the North West Frontier Province who have been found planting opium for next year's harvest. 
 The farmers, in Buner, an area controlled by the government, were charged with the crime of growing opium. 
 Anti-narcotics agents see the arrests as test cases in the government's efforts to curb next year's harvest, which provides Britain with 80 per cent of its heroin supply. 
 Opium farmers' income is tiny compared with Pakistan's drug barons and owners of heroin laboratories, and they are regarded by many as the impoverished, innocent end of the country's narcotics business. 
 Their annual income on an acre of opium poppy is about &pound;300. 
 The arrests provoked a protest march led by a member of the provincial assembly and former government minister, Mr Abdul Karim Barbak, of the opposition Awami National Party. 
 The ANP is known to support poppy growers. 
 Its leader, Mr Khan Abdul Wali Khan, argues that in the absence of large-scale development in the area or alternative jobs, the government should compensate the farmers for their crop, or simply buy the whole lot. 
 The arrests occur amid allegations by Pakistan's leading suspected drugs trafficker, Haji Iqbal Baig, against a number of government ministers. 
 In an interview, Mr Baig alleged that during last year's general election campaign, three cabinet members had received financial assistance from him. 
 Mr Baig, a Lahore business man, was the subject of a BBC documentary four years ago about a Japanese heroin smuggler who was caught in Amsterdam and sentenced to 10 years' jail. 
 The BBC film alleged that his Pakistani supplier was Mr Baig. 
 Last summer, he surrendered to Pakistani authorities for an investigation, but he was freed on bail three months later because of lack of evidence. 
 His release highlighted how ineffective the campaign against drug traffickers by the Prime Minister, Ms Benazir Bhutto, has been. 
 Le Pen seeks to expel migrants. 
 By Paul Webster in Paris 
 THE National Front leader, Mr Jean-Marie Le Pen, yesterday called for the mass expulsion of coloured immigrants as the government announced emergency integration measures. 
 Mr Le Pen told Le Figaro that all immigrants who had entered France since immigration was officially stopped in 1974 should be repatriated and that immigrants' families should be refused entry. 
 Mr Le Pen also made an anti-Semitic attack on a Jewish government minister, Mr Lionel Stoleru. 
 He suggested that the police search the Sentier area of Paris, centre of the Jewish-run garment industry which depends on immigrant labour. 
 The cabinet announced 48 measures to speed up integration of the country's immigrant population, including a permanent inter-ministerial committee on integration. 
 However, the announcement was submerged by the controversy following Mr Le Pen's attacks. 
 He called for a general election. 
 The racist movement polled 61 per cent in the Dreux byelection on Sunday, compared to only 16 per cent a year ago. 
 A member of the Union for French Democracy and a former friend of the Le Pen family, Mr Jacques Dominati, told fellow centrist MPs that the National Front was &bquo;an extremely dangerous party. 
 &bquo;In Mr Le Pen's entourage there are racists, xenophobics, and anti-Semites. 
 That was why I broke all my links with them.&equo; 
 The only National Front MP elected in last year's general election, Mrs Yann Piat, said she resigned from the party a year ago because she &bquo;realised that the Front was a dead-end movement and a danger to our country.&equo; 
 The National Front's recent revival in national and local polls, after losing nearly all its 33 MPs in last year's general election, has thrown leftwing and opposition parties into disarray. 
 Bishop's ban hands victory to pro-abortion candidate. 
 By Chris Reed in San Francisco 
 AROMAN Catholic Democrat who supports abortion has won a California State Senate seat in a traditional Republican constituency, thanks to the unintentional help of her bishop. 
 Bishop Leo Maher, head of the San Diego diocese, banned Mrs Lucy Killea from communion after the 67-year-old grandmother began screening television commercials promoting her support of women's right to choose abortion. 
 Bishop Maher denounced them as &bquo;in complete contradiction of the moral teachings of the Catholic Church.&equo; 
 As the first Catholic public official in America to be banned in this way, Mrs Killea became an overnight celebrity, featured in newspapers and appeared on peak-hour television. 
 Her opponent, Mrs Carol Bentley, a 44-year-old Presbyterian Republican opposed to abortion, tried to ignore the fuss, relying on the area's 49 per cent registered Republicans, as compared with 38 per cent Democrats. 
 Feminists threw their weight behind Mrs Killea's campaign, and hundreds of students attended a rally in support of abortion rights. 
 Finally, Mrs Killea turned what had looked like a hopeless contest into a 51-49 victory. 
 The ballot gives further notice to conservative Republicans how dangerous the abortion issue has become for them. 
 Editor says black South African paper is threatened with closure. 
 By Victoria Brittain 
 ZWELAKHE Sisulu, the editor of South Africa's biggest black weekly newspaper, says the New Nation is under threat of closure. 
 Mr Sisulu, who obtained a passport after pressure from European Community ambassadors, is in London after visiting Holland and Belgium on a campaigning trip to save the paper. 
 &bquo;This is the most decisive phase of South African history and it is crucial that the New Nation should not be closed, because the political impact of information on our people is so great,&equo; Mr Sisulu said yesterday. 
 The son of Walter Sisulu, the recently released ANC leader, Zwelakhe Sisulu was detained without trial for nearly two years in the early days of the state of emergency. 
 Since his release a year ago, he has been prevented from working as a journalist. 
 His restrictions are among the most severe imposed on about 700 activists under emergency laws. 
 Speaking in public, as he cannot do at home, Mr Sisulu said that this weekend's conference in South Africa called by the Mass Democratic Movement to bring together all anti-apartheid forces was likely to call for intensified economic sanctions. 
 President De Klerk, he said, had not begun to address the central issue, &bquo;that is, the creation of a non-racial democracy in a unitary state&equo;. 
 Gorbachev proposed end to naval nuclear weapons Gorbachev proposed end to naval nuclear weapons. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 PRESIDENT Gorbachev formally proposed the abolition of all naval tactical nuclear weapons at the Malta summit, White House sources confirmed yesterday. 
 The proposal would have restricted nuclear weapons at sea to strategic missile submarines. 
 It was rejected out of hand by President Bush, who also refused to include the US Navy in conventional arms control agreements. 
 New details of the summit conversations are emerging in the course of White House briefings, including a surprisingly frank assessment by the Soviet leader of the looming economic crisis. 
 Mr Gorbachev told the Americans that the Soviet people would judge his perestroika by how quickly he could get food and consumer goods into the shops. 
 &bquo;This is my ultimate test,&equo; Mr Gorbachev told the US President over their long summit lunch on Saturday. 
 The Nato leaders also discussed Mr Gorbachev's economic crisis and the prospect of mounting civic unrest during their Brussels summit on Monday, White House officials confirmed yesterday. 
 The troubles of the Soviet economy are fast becoming a pre-occupation of the Western allies. 
 The fate of the rouble, rather than British interest rates, was the main topic of Mrs Thatcher's talk with the chairman of the Federal Reserve, Mr Alan Greenspan, during her recent Washington visit. 
 Although they were not explored during the post-summit press conference, many additional items were discussed by Mr Bush and Mr Gorbachev, including the traditionally vexed question of Star Wars, the Strategic Defence Initiative. 
 On the first morning of the summit talks, in the plenary session, the Soviet Foreign Minister, Mr Eduard Shevardnadze, presented a draft of a possible joint declaration to be issued after the summit. 
 This declared that the two sides haveagreed to launch more extensive discussions on anti-satellite weapons and other space arms issues. 
 The matter was dropped when the US objected to the idea of a joint declaration and, pleased by the generally positive tone of Mr Bush's presentation, the Soviet team did not return to it. 
 Mr Gorbachev never referred to the SDI in any of the other summit sessions, said US officials. 
 By contrast with the Geneva and Reykjavik summits between Mr Gorbachev and the former president, Mr Ronald Reagan, which were dominated by SDI, the issue has dropped down the superpower agenda. 
 The Malta summit also discussed an important American proposal to host an international conference on global warming next year. 
 This follows widespread criticism of the Bush Administration's scepticism at international conferences so far. 
 Mr Bush suggested an international meeting at the White House next spring of scientific, economic and environmental officials to discuss responses to global climate changes. 
 Inviting the Soviet Union to send participants, Mr Bush said he was ready to host another conference next autumn to negotiate a treaty, after the final report of the UN-sponsored Inter-Governmental Panel on climate change. 
 US officials believe they have not heard the last of the Soviet proposal for naval nuclear disarmament, which was carefully phrased to echo a similar plan put forward unofficially by the veteran US arms negotiator, Mr Paul Nitze. 
 The Soviet plan would scrap all nuclear mines, torpedoes and depth charges, as well as cruise missiles and nuclear bombs and missiles carried on naval aircraft. 
 There is a powerful body of opinion in the defence establishment which supports such a ban, on the grounds that the US Navy's superiority can only be reinforced if its Soviet counterpart is deprived of the only weapons which could be expected to destroy a US aircraft carrier with a single hit. 
 The US Navy is already retiring three types of short-range nuclear-tipped missiles, the Asroc anti-submarine missiles, the Terrier anti-aircraft nuclear missile and the submarine-launched Subroc missile, targeted against enemy submarines. 
 This would leave nuclear-armed bombers, cruise missiles and depth charges. 
 Mercenaries &bquo;set to stage Suriname coup&equo;. 
 By AP in Amsterdam 
 A GROUP of white, English-speaking mercenaries is apparently getting ready to overthrow the Suriname government, the country's former deputy premier, Mr Andre Haakmat, said yesterday. 
 Up to 30 armed men had commandeered a bus and were driving it towards Zanderij airport near the Surinamese capital, Paramaribo, according to Mr Haakmat. 
 Heavy fighting with government troops was expected to break out soon. 
 The men were believed to belong to the same group which attacked an army outpost near Kraka, 37 miles south of the capital, on Monday, killing seven people. 
 &bquo;There are several versions of what's going on, but one is that it's an attempt to overthrow the government&equo; of President Ramsewak Shankar, he added. 
 On Monday, the Suriname News Agency reported that a group of men had commandeered a bus carrying aluminum workers 60 miles south of Paramaribo. 
 Suriname radio said it was an apparent coup attempt. 
 But others in the Surinamese capital speculated the mercenaries could be connected with a Colombian drug baron, who escaped from custody last week, Mr Haakmat said. 
 The armed group was not believed to be connected with the Jungle Commando guerrilla group which has been fighting the Suriname Government on and off since 1986, he said. 
 France ends aid to Comoros. 
 France has decided to cut off aid to the Comoros Islands until the French mercenary, Mr Bob Denard, and his men, who seized control 10 days ago, leave the archipelago, government sources said yesterday. 
 France is the Comoros's chief funder. 
 The second largest backer, South Africa, said on Monday it was suspending aid and demanded the withdrawal of mercenaries. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Arabs drop UN vote. 
 The Arab group at the UN decided yesterday not to press for a vote on upgrading the PLO's UN status after the General Assembly President, Mr Joseph Garba of Nigeria, urged the sponsors to drop their resolution. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Contras continue. 
 The US said yesterday the contras should not disband this week, as required by a regional peace agreement, because Nicaragua has not fulfilled conditions of the pact. 
 The US will continue its &bquo;non-lethal&equo; assistance to the rebels until February. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Somali offensive. 
 Somali rebels said last night they had captured the country's second-largest city after &bquo;an all-out offensive&equo; that prompted many government troops to defect to their side. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Lenin under attack. 
 Polish protesters hurled paint and petrol on a monument to Lenin in Krakow and set it on fire yesterday before clashing with police, who used force to break up the second anti-Soviet disturbance in a week. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Government and opposition bargain over cabinet offices Czech PM threatens to quit unless he gets backing. 
 By Ian Traynor in Prague 
 MR Ladislav Adamec, the Czechoslovak Prime Minister, threatened to quit last night, as hard bargaining continued for a second day with the opposition over the shape of the new government. 
 Mr Adamec had talks with the opposition leader, Mr Vaclav Havel, on the cabinet lineup. 
 He later went on national television to state that he would stand down unless his new government gained public backing. 
 &bquo;If the government does not have these conditions, I cannot take any responsibility for what happens. 
 In this case there is only one honest situation &mdash; to ask the President to let me resign.&equo; 
 The opposition Civic Forum, which rejected the Communist- dominated cabinet unveiled by Mr Adamec at the weekend, is demanding a more representative government staffed mainly by experts. 
 Mr Adamec said that he was having trouble recruiting such experts into the cabinet. 
 The Prime Minister's threat appeared to seek a weakening of the opposition demands, but may also have been directed at hardline elements in the Communist Party reluctant to yield any further to the opposition. 
 &bquo;I cannot act under pressure of one group of citizens,&equo; Mr Adamec said in a televised address, referring to the Civic Forum group which has led resistance to the Communist-dominated government he announced five days ago. 
 Earlier, Mr Karel Urbanek, the new party leader, had his first talks with Mr Havel and, according to the latter, backed the opposition's call to rid the government of &bquo;discredited figures&equo; in favour of &bquo;young, able experts&equo;. 
 Mr Adamec is to reveal his proposed cabinet to the opposition tomorrow before making it public. 
 In what is a highly fluid situation, a senior opposition source said that he expected Forum ministers to be in office by the weekend. 
 The Forum source said that the Communists may retain half the cabinet seats, but that this was the absolute maximum the party could expect. 
 It was clear that the longer the current unstable crisis atmosphere persists, the stronger the opposition's bargaining position becomes. 
 If its demands for a &bquo;representative&equo; government are not met there is likely to be a general strike on Monday. 
 Mr Urbanec, who is to hold further talks with Mr Havel today &mdash; this time in front of television cameras &mdash; conceded that the party realised it was held in deep mistrust by the public, and accepted that henceforth it could only be part of the political spectrum. 
 But Mr Urbanec pointed to hardline resistance to change within the party by revealing to the opposition that he had spent three hours seeking, apparently in vain, to persuade regional party barons that their &bquo;policy of power&equo; could not continue. 
 As Mr Urbanec met the opposition for the first time, it appeared increasingly likely that his predecessor, Mr Milos Jakes, would eventually find himself behind bars. 
 The burgeoning opposition movement here has also extended itself to the army. 
 Military Forum was set up by more than 300 servicemen to demand an end to Communist control of and greater democracy within the armed forces. 
 Singh gives home affairs job to Muslim. 
 By Derek Brown and Ajoy Bose in New Delhi 
 IN a bold move to defuse rising communal tension in India, the new Prime Minister, Mr Vishwanath Pratap Singh, yesterday named a Muslim as home affairs minister. 
 The appointment of Mufti Mohammed Sayeed, aged 53, was the biggest surprise in a list of cabinet appointments notable for its ingenuity. 
 Mr Singh, who heads a minority centrist government supported from the outside by both right and left factions, has spent three tortuous days compiling the core of his administration. 
 The home minister's job was the most bitterly contested. 
 Some of the most formidable kingmakers in the National Front movement were keen on the post, including Mr Devi Lal, the deputy prime minister, Mr Arun Nehru, the party's leading strategist, and Mr Ajit Singh, the ambitious son of a former prime minister, Mr Charan Singh. 
 Mr V.P. Singh outwitted them all with his choice of the mufti, a gesture of reconciliation to the nation's 100million Muslims, who have been on the receiving end of bloody communal violence in north India. 
 At the same time, he has put a warning shot across the bows of the rightwing pro-Hindu Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), which has already committed its 88 members of parliament to supporting the minority government. 
 The BJP has indignantly denied charges that it is a communalist force. 
 For the Prime Minister, who had been thought a prisoner of factional forces inside and outside his party, the mufti's appointment was a resounding declaration of independence. 
 So too were several of the other key portfolios handed out yesterday, 18 hours after ministers were first named. 
 Mr Devi Lal, for example, who had been lobbying hard for the home ministry to add to his deputy premiership, had to content himself with the agriculture ministry. 
 As the self-appointed peasant patriarch of India, he had no choice but to accept this minor post. 
 Mr Devi Lal's younger but ferociously competitive rival, Mr Ajit Singh, was given industry, traditionally the most lucrative of all ministries. 
 But Mr Singh, with his clean reputation, is not expected to capitalise on his power to sanction or veto industrial projects. 
 Mr Arun Nehru, cousin of the last prime minister and a member of the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty, appears to have been marginalised. 
 He has been given commerce and tourism. 
 The foreign ministry goes to Mr Inder Kumar Gujral, an urbane and scholarly former information minister in the only other non-Congress government, that of the late 1970s. 
 Much is expected of him by India's neighbours, whose relations with New Delhi deteriorated in the last two years of Rajiv Gandhi's government. 
 The Sri Lankan President, Mr Ranasinghe Premadasa, has expressed the hope that relations will improve. 
 His foreign minister, Mr Ranjan Wijeratne, arrived in Delhi yesterday with a message of goodwill, no doubt accompanied by a plea for the remaining Indian &bquo;peace-keeping&equo; troops to be removed from the island. 
 The finance ministry, beset by mounting internal and external debt, has gone to Professor Madhu Dandavate, a sober and respected academic and parliamentarian. 
 He said yesterday his first priorities would be to tackle inflation and the widening trade gap. 
 More ministers will be appointed by the end of the week. 
 For the moment, Mr V.P. Singh has retained a number of portfolios, the most senior of which is defence. 
 That could be the carrot to dangle before the leading dissident in his party, Mr Chandra Shekhar, sulking in isolation after his weekend defeat in the leadership tussle. 
 Mr Shekhar has declared his undying loyalty to the new government, without revealing whether he would join it. 
 &bquo;Mr V.P. Singh is the Prime Minister. 
 I respect him and will offer him full co-operation,&equo; he said enigmatically. 
 Amid the intrigue and power-play, there is an endearing homeliness about the process of forming the Indian government. 
 The new Prime Minister was obliged, yesterday morning, to send a driver to find out the telephone number of one of his key ministers, before Mr Singh could pass on the good news of his appointment. 
 Philippine rebels lay down arms. 
 By Sheila Coronel and agencies in Manila 
 ABOUT 300 Philippine army rebels agreed early this morning to leave their fortified positions in the city's business district and voluntarily return to their barracks, the chief government negotiator said. 
 Brigadier-General Arturo Enrile was speaking after President Corazon Aquino declared a national state of emergency and banned broadcasts of rebel pronouncements in an attempt to contain the mutiny which has shaken her government. 
 The general said that the mutinous soldiers would abandon their positions, give up their ammunition and walk on foot to their camp at Fort Bonafacio about three miles away. 
 &bquo;They have agreed to return voluntarily,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;They will be treated humanely.&equo; 
 &bquo;We are going back to barracks. 
 It's finished,&equo; Lieutenant-Colonel Rafael Galvez said. 
 His 300 elite commandos would turn in their weapons and return to their base, he added. 
 Their ammunition will be given to government forces before the exodus begins. 
 The colonel looked tired. 
 Asked if the agreement to leave Makati was a defeat, he replied: &bquo;Tactically, yes.&equo; 
 Small pockets of rebel soldiers could be seen assembling in different parts of the area. 
 A Red Cross van drove across the rebel lines in front of the Intercontinental Hotel, followed by three army trucks and a government military contingent. 
 Under the state of emergency, the government can take over or direct the operation of public utilities and businesses. 
 In a separate directive, the government banned the broadcasting of rebel propaganda, comments, and interviews. 
 The state of emergency was declared five days after the mutinous troops seized three military bases and two television stations in an attempt to overthrow Mrs Aquino. 
 &bquo;This is not a declaration of martial law,&equo; an official said. 
 &bquo;It is a temporary measure while the emergency exists.&equo; 
 Thousands of foreigners and Filipinos trapped in hotels and flats in Makati were earlier evacuated to safer parts of the city. 
 The rebels had held Makati since Saturday, firing mortars and machine guns at government troops ringing the district. 
 On Monday they agreed to allow the evacuation of about 5,000 people. 
 Most of those caught in the siege of Makati spoke highly of the rebels. 
 &bquo;They're probably the best troops that the Philippine army has,&equo; said Mr Peter Choynowski, an executive of the Asian Development Bank from Canada, who lives in a high-rise flat shelled by mortars. 
 &bquo;They were all very determined and willing to die.&equo; 
 At an airforce base in Cebu, central Philippines, government troops delayed an assault on 200 rebels as negotiators led by Cardinal Ricardo Vibal tried to resolve the situation. 
 Mrs Aquino earlier appealed to Filipinos to attend a mass tomorrow to demonstrate their support for her government. 
 &bquo;I ask you to continue to support me,&equo; she said in an emotional television broadcast. 
 &bquo;You are my sole source of strength.&equo; 
 The mass will be held at a religious shrine on a road where, three years ago, hundreds of thousands of Filipinos gathered in the uprising which toppled the former president, Ferdinand Marcos, and installed Mrs Aquino in power. 
 The gathering was intended to show that the government, besieged by a rebellion started by the most elite units of its own armed forces, could still rely on &bquo;people power&equo; for support. 
 The emergency declaration was affirmed by 22 of the 23 members of the Senate in an apparent attempt to consolidate the various branches of government for what President Aquino said would be &bquo;the final blow in the final confrontation&equo; against the rebels. 
 The emergency powers also allow the government to tighten its grip on companies owned by opposition politicians and businessmen, who are believed to have encouraged and financed the mutiny. 
 In a meeting, Mrs Aquino said the rebels had a started a disinformation campaign to weaken her government. 
 Leader comment, page 18 
 SMILES are hard to find in Spitak. 
 A year after the Armenian earthquake, the only place where any sense of comfort and relief seems to be found is in the Italian Village, writes Jonathan Steele. 
 Proud tenants show visitors the beautifully designed prefabricated homes, with central heating, air-conditioning, and fitted kitchen, which a team from Italy completed in July. 
 It is temporary accommodation which puts most permanent local housing to shame. 
 Ariak Chopanyan and his wife offer coffee while four small children rush about the brand-new, single-storey house. 
 Two are her brother's children &mdash; their parents died in the disaster. 
 &bquo;We are supposed to move from here when our new flats are ready, but no one will want to go. 
 Besides, the new houses will be tall,&equo; he said. 
 The Italian Village is set in the open plain where the new town centre of Spitak is supposed to be. 
 But there is little evidence of it yet. 
 In sorry contrast to the Italian Village, several rows of two-storey brick houses are slowly rising from the ground. 
 Russian workers from Uzbekistan pour concrete and fit window frames but eight months after the earthquake, not one was ready to be handed over for use. 
 Sloth and bad organisation seem to be to blame, even though the builders are on high wages to work fast. 
 From September, the two-month Azerbaijani blockade of Armenia made rebuilding even more difficult. 
 Opposite the Italian Village, the Norwegians were building a hospital but had to leave because of lack of supplies. 
 A site where building was going on with real devotion when I visited the town in August was on the once bare hillside near the old cemetery. 
 The sound of hammering echoed round the valley. 
 Some 250 family plots had been carved out, with low walls and marble plinths. 
 Photographs of a mother and her three daughters, aged 10, seven and three, have been etched in the marble of one almost finished grave. 
 The faces stare blankly out. 
 Hrachya Asataryan paused awhile to explain they were his nieces. 
 His brother, the only member of the family to escape death, was off fetching materials but returned while we talked. 
 The two men wept. 
 Around us the sight was repeated scores of times. 
 Hard work, then sudden pauses as people were overwhelmed by what they were doing and why they had to do it. 
 The whole town was still in a state of shock. 
 Four thousand of its 22,000 people died in the tragedy. 
 Spitak was originally meant to have been entirely rebuilt within two years. 
 &bquo;That's just a dream,&equo; Sergei Grigoryan, the second secretary of the local party, said. 
 His office is a Portakabin given by the Armenian Community Centre in London. 
 &bquo;In May the politburo promised to send 4,000 prefabricated houses. 
 Three months later only 500 had arrived,&equo; he said. 
 The approach of winter has done nothing to create an official feeling of urgency. 
 Literaturnaya Gazeta yesterday brought the story up to date with an emotionally devastating report. 
 Throughout the earthquake zone, where half a million were made homeless, only 50,000 flats have been built. 
 In Leninakan, Armenia's second-largest city until the earthquake struck, half the new buildings are still only at the foundation stage. 
 The newspaper's reporter wrote: &bquo;The city's electricity service is in chaos. 
 I don't know how people are going to get through the winter. 
 If it is severe, we can expect serious dissatisfaction. 
 The situation is already tense, if not threatening.&equo; 
 The reporter said the town's new section was being put in the wrong place, in an area where tremors are likely again, instead of in a safer place across the valley. 
 The two-month blockade by Azerbaijan could not be blamed for everything. 
 Incompetence and irresponsibility were everywhere. 
 Literaturnaya Gazeta applied to interview the head of the department in charge of Armenian rebuilding in the Soviet Ministry of Building in Moscow, but he refused. 
 The newspaper asked to see any responsible official &mdash; none was available. 
 &bquo;They must have something to hide,&equo; the reporter ended. 
 Clarke bill faces Tory challenge. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 DISSIDENT Conservative MPs will stage a limited challenge to the Government's proposed National Health Service reforms during the two-day Commons second reading debate starting today. 
 But it is unlikely to develop into a full-scale revolt. 
 The Government's health record provoked one of the largest backbench rebellions during the last session of Parliament, with the Government's majority cut to eight over eye charges. 
 Despite the all-party Social Services Committee report which criticised the pace at which Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, intended to introduce the reforms, as much as the proposals themselves, Tory dissent is likely to be confined to those rebels with detailed knowledge. 
 Their pleas for pilot projects in the key areas of self-governing hospitals and GPs' budgets are likely to be replaced by demands at committee stage for safeguards to be written into the legislation. 
 But the decision to add the radical reform of community care to the bill is likely to sharply increase the number of Conservative critics. 
 Mr Nicholas Winterton, the Conservative MP for Macclesfield, a consistent Tory backbench critic of the reforms, said yesterday: &bquo;I think the number of us might swell once the bill gets underway.&equo; 
 A preview of the Commons debate was held in the Lords yesterday where Lord Ennals, a former Labour Health Secretary, warned the Government it could not push the proposals through the NHS in the knowledge that they were opposed by the medical profession's leaders. 
 Their co-operation was essential to the implementation of such reforms. 
 But a Conservative peer, Lord McColl of Dulwich, vice-president of the College of Health, said the original NHS Act had been passed in the teeth of BMA opposition. 
 Drug-linked bomb blast kills 50 in Colombia. 
 By Alma Guillermoprieto in Bogota 
 APOWERFUL bomb killed at least 50 people and wounded 500 in Bogota yesterday when it wrecked the headquarters of the Department of Administrative Security, the government agency charged with bringing Colombia's drug dealers to heel. 
 The blast came four months after the start of a determined government offensive against the country's cocaine traffickers. 
 On Tuesday, Judge Bernardo Jaramillo, who was investigating Medellin drug cartel activity, was shot dead as he was walking home. 
 Hidden in a bus and estimated to contain about half a ton of dynamite, the bomb ripped a wall of the nine-storey DAS building and badly damaged nearby buildings. 
 Mutilated bodies, some of them limbless, littered the area and pools of blood dotted pavements in the area. 
 Scores of employees who had been inside the building and nearby structures staggered from shattered shops and buildings, some of them weeping. 
 General Miguel Maza Marquez, chief of the investigative police and one of the traffickers' most vocal critics, escaped unharmed as he did from a car bomb attack last May in which seven people were killed and 50 wounded. 
 At noon, The Extraditables, a group of drug-traffickers, issued a statement saying the war would continue until the Senate put the issue of extraditing traffickers to the US to national referendum next month. 
 The five-page statement, delivered to radio stations in Medellin, did not specifically claim responsiblity for the blast. 
 But it was clear the statement was written yesterday because it hailed a vote by the House of Representatives on Tuesday night to make the extradition of drug traffickers a topic for a referendum. 
 Yesterday's blast was seen less as a direct attempt on the police chief who has most vigorously pursued Colombia's leading cocaine exporters, but as part of a campaign to terrorise non-combatants in the drug war into supporting negotiations and amnesty. 
 Most of the wounded were street-sellers and shopkeepers in the busy commercial sector behind the police buildings, who had arrived early to work eager for Christmas sales. 
 Hospital emergency wards were struggling to cope with the injured as radio announcers read lists of victims and broadcast anguished appeals from those who had not heard from relatives in the area near the explosion. 
 The government offensive against the drug cartel began in earnest on August 18 after the murders of a presidential candidate, Luis Carlos Galan, and the police chief in Medellin, where the leading drug traffickers are based. 
 Picture, page 7 
 Judges back TV ban on Sinn Fein. 
 By David Sharrock 
 THE Government's ban on broadcasting radio and television interviews with Sinn Fein and 10 other organisations in Northern Ireland was upheld in the Court of Appeal yesterday. 
 The decision was &bquo;fully open&equo; to the former home secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, in the exercise of his judgment and was not open to review by the courts, said Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, sitting with Lords Justice Ralph Gibson and McCowan. 
 The High Court ruled in May that Mr Hurd had acted reasonably and lawfully in imposing the ban in October last year. 
 The journalists challenging the High Court ruling at yesterday's hearing said they would pursue the case through to the European Court. 
 The journalists, BBC producer Mr Don Brind, Media Show producer Mr Alexander Graham, LBC producer Ms Victoria Leonard, former National Union of Journalists joint president Ms Scarlett MccGwire, Fred Emery, and Mr John Pilger, with Mr Thomas Nash, assistant to the NUJ general secretary, claimed the ban was unlawful, perverse and in breach of the European Convention on Human Rights. 
 The judges awarded the Home Office costs, but granted leave to appeal to the House of Lords. 
 Lord Donaldson ruled that Mr Hurd, in deciding whether to issue a directive, and in deciding its terms, was free to take account of the terms of the European Convention, but was under no obligation to do so. 
 The terms of the convention were irrelevant to the appeal's dismissal. 
 The journalists had argued that Mr Hurd, by breaching article 10 of the convention guaranteeing freedom of expression, had acted beyond his powers. 
 But Lord Donaldson said he did not interpret the power in the 1981 Broadcasting Act to mean that Parliament intended the home secretary to have authority either covertly to censor programmes or to require the broadcasting authorities to present news programmes other than with due impartiality and accuracy. 
 Although the power was &bquo;quite clearly all-embracing,&equo; there were exceptions. 
 For instance, it would be unlawful for the home secretary to require broadcasters to refrain from including a notice drawing attention to the ban. 
 The broadcasters' contention that the directives conflicted with the duty of the BBC and the Independent Broadcasting Authority to preserve &bquo;due impartiality&equo; misappreciated the nature of that duty. 
 The duty operated in the real world in which there would always be obstacles to giving every shade of opinion equal air time. 
 The directive was simply another obstacle which had to be taken into account by the broadcasting authorities. 
 It was &bquo;not self-evident&equo; that any duty of impartiality was owed to those who supported or excused attempts to achieve political change by terrorism. 
 Dismissing the argument that the directives were unreasonable, perverse or out of proportion, the judge said that perhaps the most startling feature of them was how little they restricted the supply of the &bquo;oxygen of publicity&equo; to the specified organisations. 
 ITN had said that in the 12 months before the ban was imposed, 0.01 per cent of air time would have been affected and these items could have been recast into a form which complied with the directives. 
 Lord Justice McCowan said he found it quite impossible to hold that Mr Hurd's political judgment &mdash; that the appearance of terrorists on programmes increased their standing and lent them political legitimacy &mdash; was one that no reasonable home secretary could make. 
 Afterwards, Mr Brind, head of the BBC Television Centre's NUJ Chapel, said: &bquo;I don't think anybody will be surprised. 
 Despite the length of the ruling it doesn't make a lot of difference to our prospects at the European Court of Human Rights.&equo; 
 The case would be pursued through the House of Lords, &bquo;but we recognise that our best hope is in the European Court of Human Rights.&equo; 
 Ms MccGwire said: &bquo;I think it's a terrible shame the judges are not upholding freedom of speech and the public's right to know, because that's what the case is all about.&equo; 
 hdhead18,80,2. 
 London road pricing scheme impractical, says Parkinson 
 Impratical to charge for cars in London, says Parkinson ufsquare, 2,22 ufby 
 Michael Smith 
 Transport Editor ufdrop 
 EASING London's increasing traffic congestion by means of road pricing has effectively been ruled out by the Transport Secretary, Mr Cecil Parkinson. 
 Road pricing schemes have been effectively ruled out by Transport Secretary, Cecil Parkinson as a means of tackling London's increasing traffic congestion. 
 He Mr Parkinson indicated in the Commons yesterday that Road pricing, a form of &bquo;smart card&equo; payment to drive through popular parts of London, would be impractical, and impinge on individual freedom. 
 Mr Parkinson told MPs on the Commons transport committee: &bquo;Road pricing has a lot of practical difficulties and &bquo;there is something fundamentally unattractive about pricing people off the road,&equo; he told MPs on the Commons transport committee..&equo; 
 He said There was no practical foreseeable possibility of a London-wide road pricing scheme. 
 being introduced on any foreseeable timescale. 
 Although Mr Parkinson did not entirely dismiss rule out road pricing, he will disappoint a the growing lobby wanting of those pressing for the Government to introduce schemes result in estimated charging s of &pound;3 to &pound;4 around &pound;3 &mdash; &pound;4 for to drive through central London. 
 Traffic flows would be cut, and the revenue Supporters of road pricing believe that the extra revenue raised by paying for journeys could fund help meet the bill for new investment in public transport, it is claimed. 
 and would cut down on traffic flows. 
 But Mr Parkinson pointed out yesterday that, while such a scheme would fail if all those motorists currently using the capital were willing to pay, a charge. 
 any scheme would fall down if all existing motorists into the capital agreed to meet the &pound;3 &mdash; &pound;4 charge. 
 Mr Parkinson said There would be &bquo;huge difficulties&equo; in tracking down those who failed to pay: for their journeys, estiamting that if only one in ten 10 motorists 10 per cent refused to pay their bill, the Government would need to collect 63 million times a year.be seeking payment for 63 million journeys a year.He told the Committee that Only Singapore had persevered with a road pricing scheme, and while Hong Kong had withdrawn its. 
 A scheme. 
 their system. 
 But A new one scheme road pricing system was being introduced in The Hague will be watched carefully, he Mr Parkinson promised. 
 the committee: &bquo;We will be watching the Dutch experiment closely.&equo; 
 Patrick Wintour adds: Motorists in London wanting to take their car into capital should be required to buy a &pound; 4 a day licence which would also give them access to free public transport in the City, The Liberal Democrats yesterday recommended a &pound;4 a day central London charge, to include free out-of-centre parking and a public transport pass. 
 yesterday. 
 Mr Paddy Ashdown, the party's leader, said the proposal was unique amongst the recent flood of proposals to reduce traffic congestion since it combined offering disincentives to using a car alongside positive benefits for those choosing not to do so. 
 The Liberal Democrats say the purchase of a London City Licence by a motorist wishing to drive into central London would entitle the driver to a &bquo;Freedom of the City&equo; pass which would give free travel to public transport in the central area and free car parking at out of centre park and ride sites. 
 Mr Ashdown said most projections suggested that on current trends avaerage mileage would drop from 11 mph to 9 mph, yet over 80 per cent of the population favoured sterner measures to restrict vehicle growth. 
 Receipts from the sale of the licences would be ploughed back into the provision of improved public transport. 
 The paper argues that &bquo;on grounds of environmental cost, loss of hosing and expense of construction, road building in urban areas is not an acceptable solution to traffic congestion&equo;. 
 ufend, 2 
 Swifter awards to crime victims. 
 By John Carvel Home Affairs Editor 
 PLANS to reduce chronic delays in paying compensation for criminal injuries are about to be announced by the Home Secretary, Mr David Waddington, after criticism that some victims are having to wait more than two years for an award. 
 The Criminal Injuries Compensation Board said yesterday that a 30 per cent increase in throughput last year failed to reduce its backlog. 
 The board's chairman, Lord Carlisle, said: &bquo;We are still marking time. 
 Put more starkly, with the current caseload and an intake of 50,000 new applications this year, even if we managed to exceed last year's output we would still have at least two years work in hand.&equo; 
 He asked for streamlined procedures to sift out frivolous applications and allow individual board members greater discretion to reduce the number of full hearings. 
 Mr Waddington is understood to have accepted the board's proposals and is about to announce a package to speed up its work for implementation early next year. 
 He has ruled that compensation for victims of violent crime must be &bquo;timely&equo;. 
 The problem emerged yesterday in the board's report for 1988/9 when it paid record compensation of &pound;69.4 million to 27,752 victims. 
 The highest award was &pound;307,781 to a computer expert who injured his back helping a store detective stop a suspected shoplifter. 
 Most cases take between a year and 18 months to process, but if the victim disputes the award a case can take another year for a full hearing. 
 Mr Waddington also announced that he has accepted a Commons home affairs committee recommendation that police officers should not be able to escape disciplinary proceedings by retiring on medical grounds. 
 A scheme to block the ploy has yet to be agreed with police representatives. 
 Young defends Rover deal. 
 By David Hencke 
 LORD Young, the former Trade Secretary, who secretly authorised the &pound;38 million &bquo;sweeteners&equo; paid to British Aerospace to buy Rover, last night launched a strong defence of the deal. 
 His defence came as the Commons Public Accounts Committee decided it would meet on Monday to hold an inquiry into the Guardian's disclosure of the &bquo;sweeteners&equo; which were revealed in a confidential memorandum sent to MPs by Mr John Bourn, the Comptroller and Auditor General. 
 Lord Young, speaking as deputy chairman of the Conservative Party, to shipping magnates at the London Hilton, told them: &bquo;I am proud of the situation in Rover today. 
 &bquo;When I left the private sector in 1979 to become Keith Joseph's special adviser, the car industry in this country was in ruins. 
 Twenty years of industrial strife had ensured that an industry where we were once world leaders was an object of pity and derision. 
 All because of the policies of those who shouted the loudest last week. 
 &bquo;To the 40,000 or so employees, the further 50,000 employed by their distributors, and some tens of thousands more employed by their suppliers I would say that I am delighted that Rover is part of British Aerospace.&equo; 
 &bquo;I am proud that during my stewardship of DTI I was able to finish the job that Keith Joesph started. 
 &bquo;In the nineties we will have a car industry competitive with any in the world.&equo; 
 Lord Young declined to comment on the revelations contained in the memorandum or the confirmation by Sir Peter Gregson, permanent secretary at the DTI, that Britain has kept the deal secret because &bquo;it would severely damage our relations with the European Commission&equo;. 
 He told them: &bquo;Well, Peter Gregson revealed all the facts during his marathon appearance before the Public Accounts Committee on Monday. 
 What I think of all this will have to await the publication of my book.&equo; 
 Lord Young has offered to give evidence to the Public Accounts Committee, which usually takes evidence from civil servants only. 
 Mr Robert Sheldon, chairman of the committee, has said the committee might consider him attending. 
 But a minister has not given evidence to the committee &bquo;in living memory&equo;. 
 &bquo;McCarthyite&equo; watch on pressure groups. 
 By Richard Norton-Taylor 
 ARANGE of pressure groups, including Christian Aid, Greenpeace, the Child Poverty Action Group, the Low Pay Unit and Oxfam, are considered &bquo;vehicles for subversion&equo; by the Economic League, a study of the employment vetting agency discloses today. 
 It was commissioned by the National Council for Civil Liberties and uses information from the league's records. 
 &bquo;Subversion&equo; as defined by the league extends beyond left-wing groups, says the study, and the league is extending its role. 
 To coincide with the study's publication, the council renewed its call for the Data Protection Act to be amended to enable individuals to see any file on them kept by the league. 
 An estimated 40,000 are held by it and other agencies, but since they are on paper, they fall outside the act. 
 &bquo;When the league is proposing to expand its secret files to include animal activists, football troublemakers, gays and lesbians, this new law would be a significant first step in curtailing the unacceptable activities of this unaccountable organisation,&equo; Mr Andrew Puddephatt, the council's general secretary, said yesterday. 
 In a political mood captured by Mrs Thatcher's determination to hunt down the &bquo;enemy within,&equo; said Mr Puddephatt, a stand should be taken against &bquo;a vicious form of McCarthyism.&equo; 
 The study discloses how workers were blacklisted after being quoted in the Morning Star. 
 A family was blacklisted after signing nomination forms for a relative standing as a Communist in a local election. 
 Information on employees is sometimes supplied by personnel officers of companies subscribing to the agency. 
 Executives from Ford, which has acknowledged subscribing to the league, have been called to appear at an industrial tribunal next month. 
 Mr Mick Gosling, former chairman of a union branch at Dagenham, contests his dismissal, saying he was blacklisted. 
 Mr John Lamidey, an officer of the Data Protection Registrar, concluded after visiting the league's London office that the data on computer was not that used for vetting, which &bquo;appears to be held on paper&equo;. 
 Mr Stan Hardy, the league's new director-general, said yesterday that anybody could ask for material that may be held on them. 
 Such information was &bquo;entirely accurate and provable&equo;, but the files themselves could not be inspected. 
 His predecessor, Mr Michael Noar, yesterday said that the emphasis had moved from &bquo;shop-floor subversion&equo; to education, the Civil Service and the media &mdash; &bquo;the commanding heights of philosophical power rather than industrial power&equo;. 
 The Economic League, The Silent McCarthyism, by Mark Hollingsworth and Charles Tremayne, NCCL, 21 Tabard Street, London SE1 4LA. &pound;3.95. 
 Bonn sets new deadline for full monetary union. 
 By John Palmer 
 NEW proposals to be put by West Germany to the European Community summit in Strasbourg this weekend will significantly increase pressures on Britain to agree to a full European Monetary Union. 
 The West German plan, which has been agreed in outline by President Franois Mitterrand, will fix June 1994 as the final date for the EC to move to full monetary union, including a supra-national central-banking system. 
 It will involve a deal to give greater powers to the European Parliament to control the EC council of ministers which, in turn, will supervise the proposed central bank on behalf of the 12 member governments. 
 That runs counter to Mrs Thatcher's opposition to any expansion of the parliament's democratic powers. 
 The only cause for rejoicing in Downing Street as a result of the new West German proposals &mdash; outlined in a letter sent to President Mitterrand this week - is that the Strasbourg summit will not now decide on a date when EC governments should begin negotiating a new treaty for monetary union. 
 That decision may be taken instead by the EC summit due to be held in Rome in 12 months' time &mdash; although the practical effect will be to delay the start of the intergovernmental conference by only a few months to early in 1991. 
 Chancellor Helmut Kohl's decision not to support the French proposal to fix the conference date in Strasbourg highlights his concern that the question of European monetary union and the inevitable transfer of powers from West Germany's Bundesbank to the new European central bank would get caught up in the German general election next autumn. 
 But others may see his move as evidence of a desire to use the election campaign to concentrate on moves towards reunification with East Germany. 
 There were signs of celebration in Brussels and in Paris last night that the West Germans had committed themselves to a closing date in return for a delay in starting the move to monetary union. 
 The president of the European Commission, Mr Jacques Delors, was said to be delighted that Bonn would throw its weight behind a more rapid move to the controversial, supra-national stages of economic and monetary union. 
 Equally, members of the European Parliament will welcome Bonn's decision to extend its role, which may encourage demands for an even greater transfer of powers from national parliaments to Strasbourg. 
 While Mrs Thatcher will welcome the proposed postponement of fixing a date for the conference, she will bitterly oppose the West German move to fix a closing date. 
 A senior commission official said last night: &bquo;From a British point of view, Mrs Thatcher may have gained a few months before the crucial business of changing the Rome treaty gets under way but she now faces a cut-off date beyond which the other EC governments are unlikely to delay their acceptance of monetary union.&equo; 
 It remains to be seen what precise form of words are agreed by the 12 heads of government to express their commitment to the next stage of monetary union. 
 But despite last night's developments, Mrs Thatcher is still likely to be in a minority of one &mdash; both on completion date for monetary union and on her continued opposition to the European Social Charter of workers' rights. 
 European identity, page 10 
 Latecomers sink or swim in the great flotation race. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 WITH moments to spare before the closure of the Government's Biggest Ever Share Give-Away, Sheila Ullman broke into a frantic sprint as she turned up Princes Street in the City of London. 
 Using a heavy Tesco bag to help batter her way through the TV crews and a gaggle of amused onlookers, she reached the National Westminster Bank just after water privatisation's witching hour of 10am. 
 More than 12,000 people, from company directors to filing clerks, had been streaming into the share sorting centre with last-minute applications since the doors opened at 7.45am. 
 Many clutched a commuters' breakfast of buttered bun and polystyrene cup of coffee, weighing up the dilemma of being late for work against the lure of easy money. 
 At one point the queue stretched four deep for more than a quarter of mile. 
 But all Mrs Ullman found was the intimidating bulk of three police constables. 
 And despite her best entreaties, this Woking housewife achieved instant fame as the first person to miss the deadline for the much-hyped water offer. 
 So what does it feel like to miss out on Mrs Thatcher's handout to anybody who can afford to pay for shares? 
 Mrs Ullman looked at her toes and said she really didn't know. 
 Still panting, she struggled to maintain a vestige of self-respect as the press demanded a full briefing of her domestic itinerary over the last 24 hours. 
 Yes, her husband had asked her to put in for &pound;500 worth of shares. 
 And no, she did not think it would jeopardise the marriage although he would, no doubt, be miffed at missing out on the latest freebie to the investing classes. 
 She may have put a brave face on it. 
 But with water shares expected to soar to a 30 per cent premium on the first day of trading, Mrs Ullman's delay on the Tube could have cost her as much as &pound;150. 
 Mr Michael Howard, the Water minister, wore a broad smile as he watched his mistress's vision of a share-owning democracy lining up. 
 Symbolically, a 12-ft statue of Ceres, the Greek goddess of plenty, presided over yesterday's extraordinary scenes from a pigeon-soiled vantage point in the bank's wall. 
 From his vantage point astride Fleet, a chestnut police horse, PC Schrosbree could afford to look happy as he presided over the slow-moving queue. 
 He was among the hundreds of thousands of people who had already posted their application forms. 
 Others, such as Eric Bremner, a 28-year-old physics teacher, had only decided to apply for water shares on the spur of the moment. 
 Scouring a crumpled bank statement, he worked out how much he could afford and wrote out the cheque on his girlfriend's back. 
 &bquo;I may be against this on principle but I don't see why I shouldn't be able to make a little bit of capital,&equo; he added. 
 A wide-boy type wearing a loud tartan suit said bluntly: &bquo;I'm out to make money. 
 Why else should I be here? 
 You're asking a lot of daft questions.&equo; 
 Discarded by the press, the hapless Mrs Ullman walked slowly back to the Tube station, still reeling from her brief moment of TV fame. 
 Report, page 11 
 Flu outbreak puts hospitals on alert. 
 By Nigel Williams Science Correspondent 
 BEDS are being cleared in several London hospitals because of the large increase in influenza patients in the capital over the past few days. 
 In Wales, more than 40 per cent of children in West Glamorgan and Dyfed have been struck by flu in the past three weeks. 
 Schools in Gwynedd and Gwent were reporting cases as the virus spread. 
 In Scotland, health chiefs said an epidemic was imminent. 
 Glasgow is one of the hardest-hit areas and in some Lanarkshire schools 25 per cent of pupils have been affected. 
 Parts of South-west England have been badly hit but reports of a national epidemic have been an exaggeration, according to the research unit of the Royal College of General Practioners. 
 A spokesman for the college said levels were about 30 per cent above the comparable period last year, but this was not exceptional. 
 Figures for the last week in November &mdash; the latest available &mdash; show about 30 cases per 100,000 population. 
 An epidemic is only declared when the number of cases reaches more than 100 per 100,000. 
 But the Beecham drug company, which produces a monitor of flu occurrence in Britain, says its scale of between 100 to 300 shows an epidemic rating of 200. 
 The Emergency Bed Service has issued a yellow warning to hospitals in the North-East and South-East Thames Regional Health Authorities in the hope of releasing sufficient beds to cope with the outbreak. 
 The shortage had been worsened by lack of staff at hospitals because of flu, Mr Graham Hayter, of the service, said. 
 Miss Christine Murphy, a spokeswoman for the Public Health Laboratory Service - a Government-funded but independent organisation which also monitors levels of illness &mdash; said: &bquo;This year's virus is a sub-type of a strain we have seen before and many of the cases are not severe. 
 Children and young people are at greatest risk as the older element of the population who have experienced this before will have a degree of resistance.&equo; 
 Vaccinations were recommended only for people at special risk. 
 The Queen was forced to cancel engagements because she had flu. 
 EC trading laws &bquo;flouted by Whitehall&equo;. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 AWHITEHALL investigation has been launched into allegations that the Government is secretly flouting European Community law by awarding contracts worth millions of pounds to British companies on an exclusive basis in advance of a privatisation sale next summer. 
 A routine audit is understood to have uncovered 120 furniture contracts, including orders destined for 10 Downing Street, which have been renewed without holding an open competition as required by European Community rules. 
 A disciplinary inquiry has also been launched after allegations that a senior civil servant and leading member of a management buy-out for the furnishing business accepted an invitation to attend the British Open golf championship from one of the main companies which benefited from the deal. 
 The investigation follows disclosures from Mr John Bourn, the Comptroller and Auditor General, that Britain has hidden from the EC a &pound;38 million package of sweeteners to British Aerospace to persuade it to buy the Rover Group. 
 Sir Leon Brittan, the competition commissioner, has started inquiries into the Rover deal. 
 The discovery of the discrepancies came during an audit of the Crown Suppliers, Whitehall's furniture, fuel, and transport providers. 
 A bill to privatise the agency received its second reading in the Commons yesterday. 
 The main allegations centre on contracts worth between &pound;100,000 and &pound;4 million awarded by ministries and Downing Street. 
 They are all above the &pound;92,500 ceiling which requires that they be advertised throughout the European Community. 
 All are said to have been renewed without seeking a competition for tenders or a dispensation from the EC required under EC Supplies Directive 77/62. 
 Lawyers in the Environment Department are said to have drawn to the attention of senior staff that renewal of the contracts was in breach of community rules. 
 Mr Christopher Chope, the junior environment minister and a member of the agency's board, told MPs on May 8 that the Crown Suppliers continued &bquo;to comply with established public procurement procedures and relevant EC/Gatt regulations.&equo; 
 The disclosures come at a time when there are three known bids by senior civil servants to buy out part of the Crown Suppliers when it is privatised next year. 
 Any contracts won on an exclusive basis could affect the price at which it is offered for sale. 
 Ministers are known to have been concerned about the level of orders for the Crown Suppliers, since ministries could order furniture elsewhere. 
 The National Audit Office confirmed last night it was auditing Crown Suppliers accounts, and was examining its prospects for privatisation. 
 A spokeswoman for the office said it had decided to hold a &bquo;value for money&equo; inquiry on the lines of recent inquiries into the Royal Ordnance and Rover sales. 
 Last night Mr Dale Campbell Savours, Labour MP for Workington, raised the allegations in a debate on the privatisation of the Crown Suppliers. 
 Mr Chris Patten, the Environment Secretary, said he was sure Mr Chope could reply comprehensively when he summed up the debate. 
 Day in Politics, page 6 
 GP loses challenge to advertising rule. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 A FORMER National Health Service doctor trying to build up a private holistic treatment practice yesterday lost his Appeal Court challenge to a General Medical Council rule against advertising. 
 Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, said he had some sympathy for Dr Richard Colman. 
 But the GMC's rule against advertising was not so irrational or unreasonable that the court would interfere. 
 This follows a Monopolies and Mergers Commission decision that to forbid advertising by GPs was against the public interest. 
 Lord Justice Ralph Gibson said arguments put forward had spelled out a powerful case for changing the rule. 
 But if the rule was reformed, this would not indicate that the former rule was unreasonable. 
 The court rejected arguments that it should take account of article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which guarantees free speech. 
 It would be in breach of the law to accept that argument, Lord Justice Ralph Gibson said. 
 It would impute to Parliament an intention to import the convention into domestic law &bquo;by the back door.&equo; 
 Dr Colman, of Fadmoor, north Yorkshire, sought GMC permission to place a factual, non-promotional advertisement in a local paper because he could find no other way to tell prospective patients of his services. 
 He hoped the Medical Defence Union would support a petition for leave to appeal to the House of Lords and the European Court. 
 Consultants win NHS review over spending on shake-up. 
 By David Brindle, Clare Dyer and Alan Travis 
 HOSPITAL consultants yesterday won permission in the High Court for a judicial review of the Government's right to spend money on its health service shake-up in advance of legislation. 
 Mr Justice Simon Brown said the case clearly merited consideration. 
 He ordered an expedited hearing, likely to be shortly after Christmas. 
 More than 3,000 consultants are backing the legal challenge, each having contributed at least &pound;10 and guaranteed a further &pound;100 towards the cost. 
 The case was brought in the name of Professor Harry Keen, director of clincial services (medicine) at Guy's hospital, London. 
 His counsel, Lord Irvine, QC, accused Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, of &bquo;jumping the gun without the authority of Parliament&equo; in authorising expenditure on the creation of self-governing hospital trusts. 
 The consultants calculate that ministers have put forward &pound;250 million for the shake-up. 
 Although not all the reforms require legislation, the trusts plan does. 
 Professor Keen is one of a group of Guy's consultants opposed to the hospital becoming a trust. 
 He also won leave to challenge decisions of the South East Thames regional health authority to allot money to district health authorities for work on proposed trusts, as well as the districts' decisions to spend such money. 
 Mr Rodney Graham, a fellow consultant at Guy's, said Professor Keen had started legal action after discovering that Guy's staff were being diverted to work on implementing the NHS proposals. 
 Mr Clarke yesterday showed no sign of giving ground on the reforms set out in the National Health Service and Community Care Bill, due for its second reading in the Commons today. 
 At the Sunday Times Hospital of the Year awards, he said quality of NHS care &bquo;depends very largely on the luck of the draw&equo;. 
 The rigidity and over-centralisation had been shown in the nurses' pay regrading exercise, which had been worth &bquo;nought out of 10 &mdash; useless&equo;. 
 No other organisation could have &bquo;made such a Horlicks&equo; of awarding an average 19 per cent pay rise. 
 In a Labour survey of 130 of the 191 district health authorities in England, 92 said they will have to make cuts in services and jobs totalling &pound;100 million by the end of the financial year, Mr Robin Cook, shadow health secretary said yesterday. 
 In a Commons written reply yesterday, Mrs Virginia Bottomley, the Health Minister, announced a &pound;33 million funds package to cut hospital waiting lists. 
 Day in Politics, page 6 
 Brooke raises Unionist hopes. 
 By David Hearst in Belfast 
 MR PETER Robinson, deputy leader of the Democratic Unionist Party, said last night that he was encouraged by a speech by Mr Peter Brooke, the Northern Ireland Secretary, about talks to break the political deadlock. 
 Mr Brooke said there appeared to be &bquo;some common ground&equo; between Unionists and nationalists for talks to get underway. 
 The agenda would not be dictated by Britain, Mr Brooke said. 
 &bquo;But I do believe there is some common ground: the parties who would be talking all reject violence; they all support devolution in some form, on a basis which involves both sides of the commmunity; and they all acknowledge the importance of the relationship between Northern Ireland and the Republic.&equo; 
 The Secretary of State also offered a local assembly which could scrutinise the legislation more effectively than Westminster &mdash; one of the key Unionist demands. 
 Last night, Mr Robinson said Mr Brooke's speech had gone some way to getting dialogue &bquo;back on the rails.&equo; 
 He was encouraged that there was a willingness to recognise the Unionist objection to the Anglo-Irish Agreement, which remained the key obstacle to talks starting. 
 But he added: &bquo;Everybody recognises that the Government has to hold on to an existing policy until the replacement is ready to put in place, and clearly the Secretary of State has to hold to his policy until an alternative has been agreed.&equo; 
 Sixteen loyalists, including a senior member of the Ulster Defence Association, were arrested early yesterday in Belfast and Londonderry by police investigating allegations of collusion between loyalist para-militaries and the security forces. 
 It was the second wave of arrests since an inquiry was launched in September. 
 GP loses challenge to advertising rule. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 AFORMER National Health Service doctor trying to build up a private holistic treatment practice yesterday lost his Appeal Court challenge to a General Medical Council rule against advertising. 
 Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, said he had some sympathy for Dr Richard Colman and there was no suggestion that he was a &bquo;quack&equo;. 
 But the GMC's rule against advertising was not so irrational or unreasonable that the court would interfere. 
 This follows a Monopolies and Mergers Commission decision that to forbid advertising by GPs was against the public interest. 
 Lord Justice Ralph Gibson said arguments put forward had spelled out a powerful case for changing the rule. 
 But if the rule was reformed, this would not indicate that the former rule was unreasonable. 
 The court rejected arguments that it should take account of article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights, which guarantees free speech. 
 It would be in breach of the law to accept that argument, Lord Justice Ralph Gibson said. 
 It would impute to Parliament an intention to import the convention into domestic law &bquo;by the back door.&equo; 
 Dr Colman, of Fadmoor, north Yorkshire, sought GMC permission to place a factual, non-promotional advertisement in a local paper because he could find no other way to tell prospective patients of his services. 
 He hoped the Medical Defence Union would support an appeal to the Lords. 
 Gala goes on as opera ban ends. 
 Dancers at the Royal Opera House yesterday called off their overtime ban in time for tonight's gala performance of the Prince of the Pagodas. 
 A spokeswoman for Equity said that management and the dancers will discuss pay and terms of contract later this week. 
 Two shows were cancelled because of the ban. 
 Car quota scrapped. 
 The European Community is to scrap quotas on Japanese car imports in return for greater openness in Japanese markets, the commission said yesterday.. 
 Testimony changed. 
 An ex-director and an employee of D M de Bruijn, the suppliers of lead-contaminated cow feed, were released from custody in Holland yesterday after a witness withdrew testimony. 
 Hotel for jury. 
 The Old Bailey jury trying Celia Palmer, 18, and her boyfriend Danny Palmer, 17, for the murder of baby Christopher Palmer was sent to a hotel last night despite asking to be allowed to begin deliberations. 
 PM's global warning. 
 Global warming could soon be accelerated dramatically due to a thinning of the sea ice, Mrs Thatcher said yesterday in the 50th anniversary lecture of the parliamentary and scientific committee at the Lords. 
 Mail &bquo;action&equo;. 
 Daily Mail journalists voted for industrial action over plans not to recognise the National Union of Journalists in a postal ballot. 
 In the dog house. 
 A flag worded &bquo;The dog that left this mess has an inconsiderate owner&equo; was launched yesterday by Fido, Fight Inconsiderate Dog Owners.. 
 Rape ruling reserved. 
 The Court of Appeal reserved judgment yesterday in the appeal by a physiotherapist, Kenneth Cain, against a High Court ruling that he raped a patient and must pay her more than &pound;25,000 compensation. 
 Cities get own minister &bquo;to cut red tape&equo;. 
 CITIES targeted by the Government are each to have a minister from a team of nine headed by the Inner Cities Minister, Mr David Hunt, to advise them on regenerating the urban environment They will work with City Action Teams and Inner City Task Forces already set up, Mr Hunt yesterday told a London conference, Business in the Cities. 
 &bquo;We shall be rolling up our sleeves and getting out into the communities. 
 We are determined to cut the red tape.&equo; 
 Manchester, Salford and Rochdale will have Mr Robert Atkins (Roads); Leeds and Bradford, Mr Tim Eggar (Employment); Tyne and Wear, Teesside, Hartlepool and Middlesbrough, Mr Douglas Hogg (Industry); Doncaster, Lord Henley (Social Security); Nottingham, Derby and Leicester, Lady Hooper (Health); Birmingham and Coventry, Mr Alan Howarth (Education); Liverpool and Bristol, Mr David Hunt; south London, Mr Colin Moynihan (Sport); and east and west London, Mr John Patten (Home Office). 
 Famine appeal cash floods in. 
 Credit card donations to the Ethiopia famine appeal on TV and radio reached &pound;377,882 within hours. 
 Donations can be mailed to Ethiopia Famine Appeal, PO Box 999, London EC2R 7ET, paid at banks/post offices, or by credit card on 01 200 0202. 
 Druids fight solstice ban. 
 Druids said they would pursue their case to the European Court against English Heritage's decision to close Stonehenge again next year at the summer solstice. 
 Ruling on oils reserved. 
 The Court of Appeal reserved judgment on the challenge by auctioneers Messenger May Baverstock of Guildford to a High Court ruling that they had been negligent in selling for &pound;840 two oil paintings that soon fetched &pound;88,000 at Sotheby's as works of George Stubbs. 
 Messenger May Baverstock were ordered to pay &pound;112,000 to the former owner. 
 Shilton wins tax round. 
 The Court of Appeal dismissed an Inland Revenue challenge to a High Court ruling that &pound;75,000 paid to England and Derby County goalkeeper Peter Shilton by Nottingham Forest when they sold him to Southampton in 1982 should be treated as a &bquo;golden handshake&equo;. 
 The Revenue was granted leave to appeal to the House of Lords. 
 Scholar wins libel award. 
 American art scholar Professor Frederick Hartt won &pound;7,500 libel damages at the High Court in London over two articles in the Independent on his attribution of a statuette to Michelangelo. 
 But in his judgment Mr Justice Morland said Professor Hartt had been &bquo;dishonourable and deceitful&equo; by posing as a disinterested scholar when he had a financial interest in the statue's sale. 
 U2 beam East. 
 The BBC and Ireland's RTE will beam the Irish rock band U2 live, via stereo radio satellite, to Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union on New Year's Eve as a tribute to &bquo;the massive recent changes&equo; in the Eastern bloc. 
 Rivers authority will have teeth drawn, says scientist Green Bill &bquo;damages pollution control&equo;. 
 By Paul Brown Environment Correspondent 
 THE Government's Green Bill would seriously damage the independent role of National Rivers Authority and its ability to clamp down on pollution, the organisation's chief scientist, Dr Jan Pentreath, said yesterday. 
 Dr Pentreath, speaking at the European Study Conference in London, said the teeth of the NRA were likely to be drawn by the bill before the organisation has a chance to use them. 
 The independent authority's direct responsibility would be given back to government. 
 &bquo;This we consider to be a retrograde and unnecessary step,&equo; particularly since these powers had only just been vested in the NRA under the Water Act, he said. 
 Under the Green Bill, the Government was introducing integrated pollution control, which the NRA endorsed, but at the same time was removing the independent monitoring of the system. 
 Instead of all the new controls being policed by the National Rivers Authority some of the responsibility was being handed over to Her Majesty's Inpsector of Pollution, with decisions being taken by the Department of Environment. 
 This would mean split powers, split registers of consents and split responsibilites for organising the schemes. 
 This particularly concerned the most dangerous &bquo;red list&equo; substances and their discharge. 
 &bquo;Policing the most indentified dangerous substances would no longer be independent of government control &mdash; they will be controlled by government,&equo; he said. 
 One of the most important provisions for raising public confidence promised in the bill was the registers of licences and pollution control for each area. 
 Dr Pentreath said there would now need to be two registers, each containing data derived from two organisations thus confusing the public and independent groups and undermining public confidence. 
 These comments, coming from the NRA's senior scientist a few days before the Government's Green Bill is due to be published, add more problems to the rough passage already faced by the legislation. 
 As well as the controversery over the dismembering of the Nature Conservancy Council the Government has been criticised for the low morale and undermanning in the pollution inspectorate. 
 The sudden death of the director Brian Ponsford this week, after the resignation of three top inspectors, has left the Government trying to rebuild public confidence in a service which is the cornerstone of its green proposals. 
 Lisa Buckingham writes: Chemical companies have finally secured insurance to help them pay the costs of cleaning up the long term damage they do to the environment. 
 The scheme, launched yesterday, is expected to provide each participating chemical firm with around &pound;5 million to meet claims. 
 It is the first time the industry has been able to purchase cover for long-term environmental damage although it does buy insurance against sudden pollution incidents or claims from disasters such as explosions. 
 The Chemical Industries Asociation, which has organised the new insurance cover, said stringent pollution tests would be applied to companies wanting to buy the cover. 
 But insurers have agreed to pay out if it is discovered in future that procedures which would now be classified as benign are found to cause environmental damage. 
 The chemical industry's efforts to secure insurance have been stepped up following the publication of a number of European directives suggesting a move towards much wider compulsory compensation for environmental damage. 
 Kidney doctor backs &bquo;gifts&equo;. 
 By Owen Bowcott 
 AWORLDWIDE shortage of kidneys for transplant might be resolved by a system of &bquo;rewarded gifts&equo;, a leading transplant surgeon and opponent of cash for human organs said yesterday. 
 This was &bquo;not an expression of approval by myself or my colleagues,&equo; Mr Robert Sells, a former president of the British Transplantation Society, told a hearing of the General Medical Council's professional conduct committee. 
 Mr Sells said data emerging from hospitals in Madras was offering an alternative where it was impractical and too expensive to treat large numbers of patients on dialysis machines. 
 &bquo;The Madras doctors called this rewarded gifts, which I would call sale by another name. 
 If applied on an institutional scale it could abolish the deficit of cadaveric transplants and could go a long way towards solving the moral problem that continues to exercise me and my colleagues.&equo; 
 Most kidneys for transplant come from those who have left their bodies for the organs to be used after death, but there were not enough. 
 Under the scheme in India donors were paid &pound;1,000, and 325 operations had already been carried out. 
 Mr Sells's statement came on the third day of the inquiry into allegations that three London specialists were involved in trafficking in kidneys. 
 The doctors accused are Mr Michael Bewick, a kidney transplant surgeon, Dr Raymond Crockett, a Harley Street kidney expert, and Mr Michael Joyce, a urologist at Guy's Hospital. 
 They deny serious professional misconduct. 
 Mr Bewick was criticised strongly yesterday by Mr Sells for carrying out too many operations rather than reflecting on the ethics involved. 
 Mr Rodger Bell QC, for Mr Bewick, suggested that his client had a &bquo;bee in his bonnet&equo; about surgeons being able to work anywhere at a drop of a hat. 
 Mr Sells said he had corresponded with Mr Bewick and asked why he had not joined the BTS and become involved in debates on transplants. 
 In May 1985 Mr Bewick had been duped into believing a kidney given by a living Indian donor was from a relative, Mr Sells said. 
 &bquo;If he had participated in that debate and gone through the moral and ethical gymnastics we were going through, I think things would have turned out very differently.&equo; 
 The hearing continues today. 
 Non-Communist becomes acting head of state Krenz quits as unrest fears grow. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 THE East German army last night intervened in the crisis gripping the country for the first time, warning that &bquo;chaos and anarchy&equo; would not be tolerated and calling on troops to protect military installations against possible attacks by demonstrators. 
 The warning, which followed an appeal by the government for people to refrain from storming installations of the National People's Army, came as the disgraced former Communist leader, Mr Egon Krenz, stood down as head of state and chairman of the country's Defence Council. 
 His place as head of state was taken by Mr Manfred Gerlach, the veteran leader of the Liberal Democratic Party. 
 ADN, the official news agency, said the military leaders had called on the armed forces to fulfil their constitutional task of defending East Germany &bquo;calmly and reliably during these fateful hours&equo;. 
 The military called on all citizens &bquo;to share our concern for securing peace and to support our efforts for this. 
 Only together can we maintain the sovereignty of the GDR and save our country from anarchy and chaos,&equo; it said. 
 The generals' statement was issued by ADN shortly after the government said there were increasing signs that citizens might attack army bases. 
 There have already been public attacks on the offices of the hated security police. 
 Meanwhile, the Communist Party, driven by the furious pace of events, brought forward to tomorrow a crucial party congress to debate its future. 
 Head of state and chairman of the National Defence Council were the last two posts that Mr Krenz, aged 52, held after resigning as Communist Party chief last Sunday. 
 He has been at the helm for six weeks. 
 The politburo and central committee also stepped down. 
 The five smaller parties represented in the new &bquo;coalition government&equo; yesterday withdrew their support for Mr Krenz, saying they did not believe his assurances that he was unaware of the large-scale corruption among the previous communist leadership. 
 Mr Krenz, who is certain to become the next target of popular calls for revenge following the corruption revelations, left office warning that &bquo;anti-democratic forces&equo; could now roll back the process of change he had tried to introduce. 
 He apologised for having failed to assess the extent of corruption and abuse of power. 
 Last Friday, Mr Krenz told parliament that he never enjoyed privileges under the old regime of his mentor, Mr Erich Honecker. 
 But a shop assistant in the elite government village where Mr Krenz also lived, told local television he had been a regular customer in the supermarket supplying top officials with luxury goods. 
 The special party congress, staged under the auspices of the 25-member &bquo;working committee&equo; that has taken over the functions of the Communist SED will last through the weekend. 
 It had initially been planned for next week. 
 The congress &mdash; taking place in an atmosphere of extreme vindictiveness among the SED rank and file following the corruption revelations &mdash; will determine the future of the Communist Party. 
 Representatives are due to elect a completely new central committee and politburo, but the party newspaper, Neues Deutschland, suggested yesterday that such &bquo;Stalinist institutions&equo; would perhaps no longer be required if the SED was transformed into a &bquo;truly democratic party&equo;. 
 The emergency SED leadership pledged that the congress would break with the &bquo;Stalinist system&equo;. 
 Among those tipped to become the new party chief is Mr Wolfgang Berghofer, Dresden's reformist mayor. 
 Mr Gerlach, the acting head of state, said later he was &bquo;not happy&equo; about taking over his new role and would not stand as a candidate in the necessary Volkskammer election. 
 Although his party has been the first of the smaller satellite parties to adopt a more independent role, Mr Gerlach, aged 61, clearly felt that he too may not survive the popular anger. 
 Citizens' Committees outraged by the scale of corruption that has emerged during the last week, have continued their crusade against state, party and security institutions. 
 Near the town of Gera, citizens forced their way into a secret bunker of the former Stasi secret police, where they discovered a &bquo;communications centre&equo;. 
 They reported that lorry-loads of files and documents had been taken from the bunker during the last few days. 
 They also found glowing ash as evidence that papers had been destroyed. 
 On Monday night, a teargas grenade was fired at angry demonstrators trying to storm the local Stasi building in the town of Suhl. 
 They were later allowed entry. 
 To defuse this near state of lawlessness, the Interior Ministry has ordered the abolition of the workers' militia in factories. 
 Members have been asked to hand in their guns, grenade throwers, anti-aircraft guns and armoured vehicles. 
 Virtually the entire leadership of the Stasi, renamed as the National Office for Security, has resigned. 
 An amnesty for convicts, including about 2,000 political prisoners, has been announced for December 12. 
 Manfred Seidel, the deputy director of the Communist Party's foreign exchange agency, the Commercial Co-Ordination agency, had been detained on suspicion of diverting 200 million marks (&pound;71.6 million) in hard currency earnings abroad, ADN reported yesterday. 
 An unidentified East German, arrested in a crackdown on corruption as he tried to flee with more than half a million marks (about &pound;180,0000), has hanged himself in his cell. 
 Leader Comment, page 18; Reunification outlook, page 19; Kremlin holds the reins, page 7 
 Non-Communist becomes acting head of state Krenz falls as unrest fears grow. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 THE East German army last night intervened in the crisis gripping the country for the first time, warning that &bquo;chaos and anarchy&equo; would not be tolerated and calling on troops to protect military bases against possible attacks by demonstrators. 
 The warning, which followed an appeal by the government for people to refrain from storming installations of the National People's Army, came as the disgraced former Communist leader, Mr Egon Krenz, stood down as head of state and chairman of the country's Defence Council. 
 His place as head of state was taken by Mr Manfred Gerlach, the veteran leader of the Liberal Democratic Party. 
 ADN, the official news agency, said the military leaders had called on the armed forces to fulfil their constitutional task of defending East Germany &bquo;calmly and reliably during these fateful hours&equo;. 
 The military called on all citizens &bquo;to share our concern for securing peace and to support our efforts for this. 
 Only together can we maintain the sovereignty of the GDR and save our country from anarchy and chaos,&equo; it said. 
 The generals' statement was issued by ADN shortly after the government said there were increasing signs that citizens might attack army bases. 
 There have already been public attacks on the offices of the hated security police. 
 Meanwhile, the Communist Party, driven by the furious pace of events, brought forward to tomorrow a crucial party congress to debate its future. 
 Head of state and chairman of the National Defence Council were the last two posts that Mr Krenz, aged 52, held after resigning as Communist Party chief last Sunday. 
 He has been at the helm for six weeks. 
 The politburo and central committee also stepped down. 
 The five smaller parties represented in the new &bquo;coalition government&equo; yesterday withdrew their support for Mr Krenz, saying they did not believe his assurances that he was unaware of the large-scale corruption among the previous Communist leadership. 
 Mr Krenz, who is certain to become the next target of popular calls for revenge following the corruption revelations, left office warning that &bquo;anti-democratic forces&equo; could now roll back the process of change he had tried to introduce. 
 He apologised for having failed to assess the extent of corruption and abuse of power. 
 Last Friday, Mr Krenz told parliament that he never enjoyed privileges under the old regime of his mentor, Mr Erich Honecker. 
 But a shop assistant in the elite government village where Mr Krenz also lived, told local television he had been a regular customer in the supermarket supplying top officials with luxury goods. 
 The special party congress, staged under the auspices of the 25-member &bquo;working committee&equo; that has taken over the functions of the Communist SED will last through the weekend. 
 It had initially been planned for next week. 
 The congress &mdash; taking place in an atmosphere of extreme vindictiveness among the SED rank and file following the corruption revelations &mdash; will determine the future of the Communist Party. 
 Representatives are due to elect a completely new central committee and politburo, but the party newspaper, Neues Deutschland, suggested yesterday that such &bquo;Stalinist institutions&equo; would perhaps no longer be required if the SED was transformed into a &bquo;truly democratic party&equo;. 
 The emergency SED leadership pledged that the congress would break with the &bquo;Stalinist system&equo;. 
 Among those tipped to become the new party chief is Mr Wolfgang Berghofer, Dresden's reformist mayor. 
 Mr Gerlach, the acting head of state, said later he was &bquo;not happy&equo; about taking over his new role and would not stand as a candidate in the necessary Volkskammer election. 
 Although his party has been the first of the smaller satellite parties to adopt a more independent role, Mr Gerlach, aged 61, clearly felt that he too may not survive the popular anger. 
 Citizens' Committees outraged by the scale of corruption that has emerged during the last week, have continued their crusade against state, party and security institutions. 
 Near the town of Gera, citizens forced their way into a secret bunker of the former Stasi secret police, where they discovered a &bquo;communications centre&equo;. 
 They reported that lorry-loads of files and documents had been taken from the bunker during the last few days, and found glowing ash &mdash; &bquo;evidence&equo; of destroyed papers. 
 On Monday night, a teargas grenade was fired at angry demonstrators trying to storm the local Stasi building in the town of Suhl. 
 They were later allowed entry. 
 To defuse this near state of lawlessness, the Interior Ministry has ordered the abolition of the workers' militia in factories. 
 Members have been asked to hand in guns, grenade throwers, anti-aircraft guns and armoured vehicles. 
 An amnesty for convicts, including 2,000 political prisoners, has been set for Tuesday. 
 Manfred Seidel, the deputy director of the Communist Party's foreign exchange agency, the Commercial Coordination agency, had been detained on suspicion of diverting 200 million marks (&pound;71.6 million) in hard currency earnings abroad, ADN reported yesterday. 
 His former boss, Alexander Schalck-Golodkowski, who fled abroad last week after he came under investigation for fraud, gave himself up yesterday in West Berlin, police said. 
 An unidentified East German, arrested in a crackdown on corruption as he tried to flee with more than half a million marks (about &pound;180,000) has hanged himself in his cell. 
 Leader Comment, page 18; Reunification outlook, page 19; Kremlin holds the reins, page 7 
 Non-Communist becomes acting head of state Krenz quits as unrest fears grow. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 The East German army last night intervened in the crisis gripping the country for the first time, warning that &bquo;chaos and anarchy&equo; would not be tolerated and calling on troops to protect military installations against possible attacks by demonstrators. 
 The warning, which followed an appeal by the government for people to refrain from storming installations of the National People's Army, came as the disgraced former Communist leader, Mr Egon Krenz, stood down as head of state and chairman of the country's Defence Council. 
 His place as head of state was taken by Mr Manfred Gerlach, the veteran leader of the Liberal Democratic Party. 
 ADN, the official news agency, said the military leaders had called on the armed forces to fulfil their constitutional task of defending East Germany &bquo;calmly and reliably during these fateful hours&equo;. 
 The military called on all citizens &bquo;to share our concern for securing peace and to support our efforts for this. 
 Only together can we maintain the sovereignty of the GDR and save our country from anarchy and chaos,&equo; the statement said. 
 The generals' statement was issued by ADN shortly after the government said there were increasing signs that citizens might attack army bases. 
 There have already been public attacks on the offices of the hated security police. 
 Meanwhile, the Communist Party, driven by the furious pace of events, brought forward to tomorrow a crucial party congress to debate its future. 
 Head of state and chairman of the National Defence Council were the last two posts that Mr Krenz, aged 52, held after resigning as Communist Party chief last Sunday. 
 He has been only six weeks at the helm. 
 The politburo and central committee also stepped down. 
 The five smaller parties represented in the new &bquo;coalition government&equo; yesterday withdrew their support for Mr Krenz, saying they did not believe his assurances that he was unaware of the large-scale corruption among the previous communist leadership of which he was a vital part. 
 Mr Krenz, who is certain to become the next target of popular calls for revenge following the corruption revelations, left office warning that &bquo;anti-democratic forces&equo; could now roll back the process of change he had tried to introduce. 
 He apologised for having failed to assess the extent of corruption and abuse of power. 
 Last Friday, Mr Krenz told parliament that he never enjoyed privileges under the old regime of his mentor, Mr Erich Honecker. 
 But a shop assistant in the elite government village where Mr Krenz also lived, told local television he had been a regular customer in the supermarket supplying top officials with luxury goods. 
 The special party congress, staged under the auspices of the 25-member &bquo;working committee&equo; that has taken over the functions of the Communist SED will last through the weekend. 
 It had earlier been planned for next week. 
 The congress &mdash; taking place in an atmosphere of extreme vindictiveness among the SED rank and file following the corruption revelations &mdash; will determine the future of the Communist Party. 
 Representatives are due to elect a completely new central committee and politburo, but the party newspaper, Neues Deutschland, suggested yesterday that such &bquo;Stalinist institutions&equo; would perhaps no longer be required if the SED was transformed into a &bquo;truly democratic party&equo;. 
 The emergency SED leadership pledged that the congress would break with the &bquo;Stalinist system&equo;. 
 Among those tipped to become the new party chief is Mr Wolfgang Berghofer, Dresden's reformist mayor. 
 Mr Gerlach, the acting head of state, said later he was &bquo;not happy&equo; about taking over his new role and would not stand as a candidate in the necessary Volkskammer election. 
 Although his party has been the first of the smaller satellite parties to adopt a more independent role, Mr Gerlach, aged 61, clearly felt that he too may not be able to survive the revolutionary climate of popular anger. 
 Citizens' Committees outraged by the scale of corruption that has emerged during the last week, have continued their crusade against state, party and security institutions. 
 Near the town of Gera, in the south, citizens forced their way into a secret bunker of the former Stasi secret police, where they discovered a &bquo;communications centre&equo;. 
 They reported that lorry-loads of files and documents had been taken from the bunker during the last few days, and said they had found glowing ash as evidence that papers had been destroyed. 
 On Monday night, a teargas grenade was fired at angry demonstrators trying to storm the local Stasi building in the town of Suhl. 
 They were later allowed entry. 
 To defuse what is almost a state of lawlessness, the Interior Ministry has ordered the abolition of the workers' militia in factories. 
 Members have been asked to hand in their guns, grenade throwers, anti-aircraft guns and armoured vehicles to the army and the police. 
 Virtually the entire leadership of the Stasi, renamed as the National Office for Security, has resigned. 
 An amnesty for convicts, including an estimate 2,000 political prisoners, was announced for December 12, after hunger strikes had spread throughout the country's jails. 
 The general public prosector has ordered the release of Mr Wolfgang Vogel, a prominent lawyer and former close aide of Mr Honecker who was detained on Tuesday on suspicion of &bquo;criminal blackmail&equo;. 
 The prosecutor apologised, saying the allegations were unfounded. 
 Leader Comment, page 18; Reunification outlook, page 19 
 Airline terrorism warning. 
 By Gareth Parry 
 AGLOBAL aviation security network is needed urgently to prevent another Lockerbie disaster, which could happen at any time, an expert on international terrorism warned yesterday. 
 Professor Paul Wilkinson of the Research Institute for the Study of Conflict and Terrorism was in London launching a report into the mid-air terrorist bombing of a Pan Am 747 above the Scottish town last December, which killed 270 people. 
 Governments and airlines had failed to learn lessons from the incident. 
 &bquo;We are way behind in taking the necessary measures that will help to prevent this kind of tragedy happening again. 
 Future Lockerbies can and will occur. 
 Next time it might come down over the centre of a large city.&equo; 
 Airport security was largely superficial, and outdated equipment could not detect plastic explosives. 
 Sophisticated screening equipment capable of detecting explosives like Semtex was already available, and should be introduced without delay. 
 A new hi-tech identity card should be introduced &mdash; by airlines if not governments &mdash; to supplement passports, which were more easily forged. 
 In addition, a European court to try international terrorists and drug traffickers should be set up, he said. 
 Methodists chide PM over poverty gap. 
 By Andrew Culf 
 METHODIST leaders yesterday accused the Prime Minister of increasing the gap between Britain's rich and poor. 
 In an open letter to Mrs Thatcher, the Reverend Dr John Vincent, president of the Methodist Conference, and former president, the Reverend Dr Richard Jones, said Tory policies had created an &bquo;underclass&equo; of deprived people. 
 The letter provided further evidence of the widening schism between the church and Downing Street. 
 It called for the repeal of legislation &bquo;which leads to the victimisation of the poor&equo;. 
 This included the poll tax and changes in health provision, unemployment and housing benefits and education. 
 Dr Vincent and Dr Jones delivered the message to Downing Street after Mrs Thatcher refused to see a delegation from the church, a decision which they described as an &bquo;affront&equo;. 
 They wrote: &bquo;It is not often that a major British church seeks such an interview, and the conference and our 500,000 members and 1 million community cannot but be offended. 
 &bquo;Your unwillingness indicates insensitivity to what must have been perceived as deeply held and deeply felt concerns and convictions of the Methodist people.&equo; 
 Methodist leaders sought the meeting with Mrs Thatcher after a resolution passed at the Methodist Conference in June last year, which declared outrage at the divisive effects of government policy. 
 The letter said: &bquo;We do not believe a nation can be rich or successful while some are ground down into an &bquo;underclass&equo; or are deprived of the means of contributing to society. 
 &bquo;We call for a priority to be given immediately to new legislation which will actively facilitate the re-entry into our society of those at present disadvantaged within it.&equo; 
 It also suggests Mrs Thatcher should initiate a public forum where the Methodist Church and others concerned about social issues could meet her and ministers to seek ways of overcoming the divisions within society, engendering a &bquo;new spirit of common commitment and enterprise.&equo; 
 Woody Allen season leads BBC's Christmas offering. 
 THE BBC's Christmas schedule features a season of films by Woody Allen, including Hannah and Her Sisters and The Purple Rose of Cairo, and films starring Meryl Streep, beginning with Out of Africa. 
 Others will include the TV premiers of Crocodile Dundee, starring Paul Hogan, Clockwise, with John Cleese, and Prizzi's Honor, with Jack Nicholson. 
 The schedule will include a Christmas special from Birds of a Feather stars Pauline Quirke and Linda Robson, and editions of comedies such as Only Fools and Horses, and Bread, which will be celebrating a &bquo;green&equo; Christmas. 
 There will also be special editions of Ever Decreasing Circles, with Richard Briers, Blackadder's Christmas Carol, Porridge, Dad's Army, and Some Mothers Do &bquo;Ave &bquo;Em. 
 Other Christmas shows include a Russ Abbot special and Warren Mitchell as Alf Garnett In Sickness and In Health. 
 Paul Daniels, Jimmy Savile, Les Dennis, and Les Dawson all have special shows, while Noel Edmonds will be reuniting families across the world in Noel's Christmas Presents. 
 Britain resists EC concession. 
 By Michael White and John Palmer 
 MRS THATCHER will fly to Strasbourg for the two-day European summit tonight with no intention of making a conciliatory gesture over the Social Charter or economic integration to lessen the likelihood of Britain being isolated from the development of the rest of the community. 
 Whitehall officials are putting their usual brave face on the prospect that, against British objections, a version of the Social Charter will be agreed and an inter-governmental conference arranged for late 1990 or early 1991 to consider amending the Treaty of Rome in the direction of a single central bank and currency. 
 They stressed London's constant theme of ever-more open markets which chalked up a success with this week's unexpected decision to break down restrictions on competition in the European airline industry. 
 Nonetheless, the dominant tone remains suspicious. 
 Dissident Tory MPs&equo; hopes that their 57-60 votes against the Prime Minister in Tuesday's leadership election would prompt her to trim her Euro-sails are unlikely to materialise quickly, if at all. 
 Pressure increased yesterday when a Lords report attacked &bquo;excessive&equo; government criticism of the draft Social Charter and Tory members of the European Parliament complained that the Government was falsely claiming their support. 
 In pre-summit manoeuvres, European trade union leaders also warned of the &bquo;danger of social strife&equo; if the 1992 market arrived without proper social protection for workers and criticised France for allowing the Charter to be watered down in a doomed effort to win Mrs Thatcher's support. 
 The MEPs will make their protests at a meeting with the Foreign Office minister, Mr Francis Maude, today. 
 Lord O'Hagan, the group's social affairs spokesman, said: &bquo;I object to being misrepresented and I want to make sure that this sort of thing does not happen again.&equo; 
 The MEPs' anger focuses on remarks in the Commons by Mr Maude and the drive by the Employment Secretary, Mr Norman Fowler, against the charter as a threat to jobs. 
 Whitehall last night confirmed the minimum-wage provisions have been deleted from the draft but insists working hours, statutory holidays and worker participation clauses will increase costs. 
 Cabinet ministers, including the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, who want British entry into the Exchange Rate Mechanism some time next year, if possible, are holding fire. 
 In today's Financial Times Mr Hurd says Britain would attend any conference to discuss changes in the Treaty of Rome and added: &bquo;The empty chair is not a British concept.&equo; 
 The Government's stance took a further knock yesterday when the Conservative Bow Group published a survey showing senior British industrialists were not as vehemently opposed to the Charter as ministers. 
 It showed 42 per cent believed it could prove a useful catalyst for improving social conditions with 45 per cent against. 
 However, the Employment minister, Mr Tim Eggar, last night insisted the most effective social dimension to Europe was the single market, not regulations on employment. 
 Meanwhile, the desire for community unity in Strasbourg in the face of events in Eastern Europe means a flexibly-interpreted communique will emerge from the summit on Saturday. 
 Inclusion of Britain's alternatives to the Delors version of economic and monetary union on the IGC agenda could be one face-saver. 
 Whitehall is anxious to deflect attention to two areas &mdash; the follow-up to last month's Paris summit to provide aid to Eastern Europe, and further efforts to liberalise the internal European market for 1992. 
 On the IGC, Whitehall insists more preparatory work is needed. 
 Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, won &pound;105 in a Tory sweepstake predicting votes in the leadership contest. 
 Politics, page 6; Commentary, page 19; City Notebook, page 11 
 MPs return to decent obscurity. 
 By Michael White, Chief Political Correspondent &bquo;A. 
 H well, back to obscurity,&equo; a Tory MP muttered to his colleague yesterday as they passed a journalist who failed to leap forward and solicit their views on the party leadership. 
 With microwave ovens, Manila and the flu epidemic suddenly dominating the news it was as if the event had never occurred except in Sir Anthony Meyer's imagination. 
 That is how Mrs Thatcher and her entourage are playing it and while many of the 57, probably 59, dissenters may disagree they, too, reinforced the Downing Street mood by prudently going to earth. 
 It perfectly caught the air of feebleness which has characterised months of desultory chatter. 
 Not one of the 33 No-voters, let alone the 24 abstainers, was prepared to go on television on Tuesday night to stand by Sir Anthony. 
 &bquo;You'd have thought one of them would have had the balls,&equo; said one wet who voted for Mrs Thatcher on the grounds that no serious candidate had come forward. 
 The Prime Minister may be almost as contemptuous of her wetter supporters as of outright opponents &mdash; the &bquo;hard core&equo; of enemies any leader, especially a &bquo;conviction politician&equo;, must acquire in nearly 15 years of leadership. 
 &bquo;Forty of them would have voted against her if the Lord God Almighty had come down and instructed them not to&equo; said one minister. 
 &bquo;Sixty-five of those who voted against her in 1975 are still in the House. 
 So 57 against her equals a net gain,&equo; said another So who wins from this week's mini-drama? 
 The Labour Opposition wins, possibly the Liberal-Democrats too if disaffected Tories drift their way rather than to the Greens. 
 Certainly Mrs Thatcher has not won, though the damage could have been much worse. 
 &bquo;I don't think she's been either strengthened or weakened,&equo; one Cabinet minister declared. 
 &bquo;I don't think it's made any difference.&equo; 
 Mr George Younger, the Prime Minister's campaign manager, says she will take criticisms to heart. 
 That remains to be seen: an 85 per cent mandate from her 374 voters is convincing by any standards. 
 The 1922 committee is almost certain to raise to 20 or more the number of MPs needed to sponsor a challenger in future. 
 After Tony Benn's defeat by Mr Kinnock, Labour raised the threshold from 15 per cent of MPs to 40 MPs &mdash; &bquo;too high&equo; one Tory whip said yesterday. 
 Mr Benn got 38 of the 221 MPs' votes cast in 1988 and, he ruefully noted this week, a much worse press. 
 &bquo;It's safer to be in the centre,&equo; he said. 
 What of the hopefuls? 
 Sir Geoffrey Howe, increasingly sidelined by events, must have lost his best moment when this week's challenge failed seriously to wound the Prime Minister. 
 Mr Michael Heseltine stayed &bquo;out of the process&equo; and must await his chance. 
 He is the bad news candidate, the party saviour if things go wrong. 
 But since he is Sir Anthony's choice he may have been harmed by the Meyer candidacy. 
 By the same token Mr Kenneth Baker, as loyally supportive of Mrs Thatcher as Mr Heseltine was not, may have helped himself. 
 For him, and even more so for potential runners in their 40s, Mr John Major, Mr Chris Patten and A.N.Other, the timing was all wrong. 
 Their hope is to succeed as the consolidator of post-Thatcherism after the fourth election win. 
 But in politics the unlikely can happen, a Meyer candidacy for example. 
 Epidemic alert as flu cases increase. 
 By Nigel Williams Science Correspondent 
 BEDS are being cleared in several London hospitals because of the large increase in flu patients in the capital over the past few days. 
 In Wales, more than 40 per cent of children in West Glamorgan and Dyfed have been struck by flu in the past three weeks. 
 Schools in Gwynedd and Gwent were reporting cases as the virus spread. 
 In Scotland, health chiefs said an epidemic was imminent. 
 Glasgow is one of the hardest-hit areas and in some Lanarkshire schools 25 per cent of pupils have been affected. 
 Parts of South-west England have been badly hit but reports of a national epidemic have been an exaggeration, according to the research unit of the Royal College of General Practioners which collects reports from more than 200 doctors at 62 practices throughout England and Wales. 
 A spokesman for the college said levels were about 30 per cent above the comparable period last year, but this was not exceptional. 
 Figures for the last week in November &mdash; the latest available &mdash; show about 30 cases per 100,000 population. 
 An epidemic is only declared when the number of cases reaches more than 100 per 100,000. 
 But the Beecham drug company, which produces its own monitor of flu occurrence in Britain, says its scale of between 100 to 300 shows an epidemic rating of 200. 
 The Emergency Bed Service has issued a yellow warning to hospitals in the North-East and South-East Thames Regional Health Authorities in the hope of releasing sufficient beds to cope with the outbreak. 
 The shortage had been worsened by lack of staff at hospitals because of flu, Mr Graham Hayter, of the Emergency Bed Service, said. 
 Miss Christine Murphy, a spokeswoman for the Public Health Laboratory Service - a Government-funded but independent organisation which also monitors levels of illness &mdash; said: &bquo;This year's virus is a sub-type of a strain we have seen before and many of the cases are not severe. 
 &bquo;Children and young people are at greatest risk as the older element of the population who have experienced this before will have a degree of resistance.&equo; 
 Vaccinations were recommended only for people at special risk. 
 The Queen was forced to cancel two engagements yesterday and another today because she has flu. 
 Gunman kills 13 at university. 
 A gunman wearing a hunting outfit killed 13 people at the University of Montreal yesterday before committing suicide. 
 The man, with a.22 rifle, rampaged through a classroom, hallways and the cafeteria &bquo;shooting at anything that moved&equo;. 
 He was one of three men who &bquo;wanted to get feminists&equo;. 
 The gunman had entered a classroom and ordered male students to leave. 
 Bonn deadline. 
 West Germany proposals to the EC summit will increase pressure on Britain to agree to full monetary union. 
 Page 20. 
 Water sale &bquo;underpriced&equo;. 
 Mr Michael Howard, the Water minister, effectively admitted that water shares have been underpriced. 
 Page 11; Eyewitness, page 20. 
 France backs forum. 
 President Mitterrand has backed Soviet proposals for a 35-nation conference next year to decide Europe's future. 
 Page 7. 
 Media ban upheld. 
 The Government's ban on media interviews with Sinn Fein was upheld in the Court of Appeal. 
 Page 4. 
 Saatchi losses. 
 Saatchi and Saatchi, the advertising agency, has plunged into loss. 
 Page 11; Outlook, page 13 
 Minister tells why he refused ban on killer toy. 
 By Paul Nettleton 
 AGOVERNMENT minister described yesterday how he agonised over whether to ban Kinder Surprise chocolate eggs after the death of the three-year-old Birmingham girl, Jennifer Ashton. 
 Mr Eric Forth, consumer affairs minister, told MPs he had been &bquo;very affected&equo; by the death but &bquo;on balance&equo; had decided a ban was not justified on a product which carried a warning on the packaging. 
 The girl died after choking on part of a toy inside one of the eggs. 
 Mr Nigel Griffiths, Labour consumer affairs spokesman, asked why Mr Forth had refused a ban on the eggs, which were still on sale. 
 Mr Forth said: &bquo;There are many other products and toys which also have small parts. 
 If we were to start banning every product which could be swallowed by a child, there would be very little left on the market in terms of toys.&equo; 
 Peers urge PM to back the charter. 
 By Patrick Wintour Political Correspondent 
 AN all-party committee of peers yesterday condemned government concern over the proposed EC Social Charter as &bquo;excessive&equo; and recommended that the Prime Minister treat it as a basis for an agreement with her Community partners at this weekend's Strasbourg summit. 
 &bquo;It is of great importance that the UK should not appear to turn its back on Europe, so that it can play its full part in negotiations,&equo; the peers say in a report rushed out yesterday ahead of the Strasbourg talks. 
 They also argue that the latest draft of the charter, drawn up by President Mitterrand, has already gone a long way to assuage Mrs Thatcher's legitimate fears about the loss of British sovereignty. 
 The committee, chaired by Lord Allen of Abbeydale, says: &bquo;The Government should accept the draft charter as a basis for negotiation. 
 The changes required are not so great that it should be rejected outright. 
 Indeed the latest text has gone a long way towards meeting the UK's objections.&equo; 
 The peers argue that if Britain fails to treat it at least as a basis for negotiation &bquo;the other 11 member states may well go ahead and sign the charter without any UK participation&equo;. 
 Such a move might release the UK from the moral obligation to support any legislation stemming from it, but the Commission would still be entitled to bring forward legal proposals. 
 The peers recommend the Government to seek only to ammend the charter in two respects. 
 First, unnecessary detail should be excised, leaving member countries to negotiate implementation of the charter's broad principles at a later stage. 
 Secondly, it should be clarified that the charter does not involve an extension of the Community's present powers or any presumption that nation states will have no freedom to implement the charter's principles in their own way. 
 The Employment Minister, Mr Tim Eggar, responded last night that the Government could not sign the charter in its present form. 
 He said the current charter still gives no clear division of responsibility between the Community and the member states. 
 He added: &bquo;We have never said we would never sign up to a charter, but we are convinced this proposal would mean Community interference in areas like industrial relations law which are much better dealt with in Community countries. 
 It would impose unnecessary red tape and above all it would destroy jobs.&equo; 
 Field &bquo;out on second vote&equo;. 
 By Patrick Wintour 
 OPPONENTS of Mr Frank Field, the Labour MP for Birkenhead, believe they succeeded in deselecting him at the secret ballot held last Tuesday. 
 The result will be formally announced tomorrow night to a meeting of the constituency party's general committee. 
 It will pose a serious dilemma for the Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, if Mr Field has lost and carries out his threat to cause a byelection. 
 Supporters of Mr Paul Davies, his chief opponent, believe he won on the second ballot. 
 Mr Field this week clarified his threat. 
 If he did not win a majority in the individual members' section of the ballot, he said, he would resign altogether. 
 If he won in the members' section, but still lost the ballot overall, due to heavy voting against him in the union section, he would cause a byelection. 
 He also promised to speak to Mr Kinnock before taking any action. 
 Under the party's rules 40 per cent of the votes in Birkenhead have been allocated to the unions and 60 per cent to individual members. 
 In the union section, Mr Davies's supporters claim he won 18 per cent, Mr Field 10 per cent and Ms Kathy Wilson, a Militant supporter, 7 per cent. 
 In the constituency section figures are less certain, but Mr Davies's supporters calculate around 23 per cent for him, 27 per cent forMr Field and 10 per cent for Ms Wilson. 
 On this basis, Mr Davies, a local Transport and General Workers Union official, will have captured the nomination if he took just over half of Ms Wilson's vote when it was redistributed in the second ballot. 
 Some 213 members attended the ballot meeting. 
 A further 68 members had postal votes, the vast majority of which went to Mr Field, who supports one person, one vote in reselection and has described the involvement of unions as corrupt. 
 Thatcher backs the market to save the environment. 
 By Patrick Wintour Political Correspondent 
 GLOBAL warming could soon be accelerated dramatically due to a thinning of the sea ice, Mrs Thatcher said yesterday. 
 If the 30 million square kilometres of sea ice separating the ocean from the atmosphere continued to thin due to the solar radiation falling on it, global warming would continue. 
 Mrs Thatcher, giving the 50th anniversary lecture of the Parliamentary and Scientific Committee at the House of Lords, said it was imperative to intensify efforts to model and predict climate change. 
 Mrs Thatcher said: &bquo;We have proposed a global convention &mdash; a sort of good conduct guide on the environment for all the world's nations on problems like the greenhouse effect.&equo; 
 But further research was needed on climate change: &bquo;Before we can translate this into practical policy and precise targets, there is a lot of work to be done as a matter of urgency.&equo; 
 Man had used the environment as a dustbin for decades. 
 She reiterated her view that humans could best be made to behave in an environmentally friendly way through the market, rather than regulation. 
 It was not regulation, but the decisions of individual consumers, and industry's response, which had led to the development of ozone-friendly products, bio-degradable plastics, and phosphate-free detergents.&equo; 
 Minister's opt-out decision rules out council-backed CTC. 
 By Celia Weston 
 APLAN by Berkshire county council to create a city technology college was ruled out yesterday by Mrs Angela Rumbold, the Education Minister, when she gave the go-ahead for one of the schools involved to opt out. 
 Berkshire planned to amalgamate the 300-pupil Southlands Girls' School in Reading with a neighbouring boys' school, selling the site for about &pound;7 million, putting up &pound;3 million of public money, and raising another &pound;3 million from commercial sponsors. 
 Commander Michael Porter, Tory chairman of the council's education committee, said he had hoped for a decision that would &bquo;provide us with a way to achieve the best possible education for pupils in south Reading, allowing us to set up a super new school designed for the demands of the 21st century, and a sixth form college.&equo; 
 Mr Stanley Goodchild, county director of education, said the decision would be considered carefully and a report made to the education committee on December 20. 
 The first ballot on opting out at Southlands failed to attract a vote from the required 50 per cent of parents. 
 In a second ballot, 61 per cent of those eligible voted, with 81 per cent of these in favour. 
 New BR chief nets &pound;400,000 pay packet. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 MR BOB Reid, head of Shell UK, yesterday agreed to take over the chairmanship of British Rail under a deal that will bring him &pound;2 million over five years. 
 Up to 20 other leading figures in industry and business had refused the job. 
 Mr Reid, aged 55, has been appointed at &pound;200,000 a year. 
 His earnings will be doubled by a pensions package from his former employers. 
 He replaces Sir Robert Reid who retires in March from his &pound;95,000 a year post after over 40 years in the railway industry. 
 Mr Reid will not be available to take up the full-time post until next October, although he becomes chairman-designate on January 1. 
 Mr Derek Fowler, vice-chairman, will hold the position between April and October, placing BR in the unusual position of having three chairmen in the space of six months. 
 The Department of Transport confirmed last night that Mr Reid had made no input into BR's new corporate plan which sets the blueprint and financial structure of the railways for the next three years, which is expected to show further cuts in government support. 
 Mr Reid denied last night that he was accepting the job solely for the money. 
 &bquo;I &bquo;m not doing it for the money. 
 I do not have to justify my salary. 
 I can earn &pound;400,000 elsewhere. 
 &bquo;The great thing about this job is the challenge. 
 I believe in the challenge.&equo; 
 His immediate tasks will be to restore morale on the railways, implement safety measures proposed after the Clapham Junction crash and match BR's operations to the strict financial regime imposed by the Government. 
 But some crucial decisions, including the siting of the high speed link from the Channel Tunnel, will have to be taken before he takes over. 
 Labour's transport spokesman, Mr John Prescott said the salary was a &bquo;kick in the teeth&equo; for railway workers who had to resort to industrial action to get an 8.8 per cent rise during the summer. 
 &bquo;Unless Mr Reid has demanded that the Government remove its financial straightjacket, BR will continue to suffer from poor morale, chronic overcrowding and growing passenger concerns about safety and reliability.&equo; 
 Mr Jimmy Knapp, general secretary of the National Union of Railwaymen, said what mattered was policies not personalities for the railways. 
 &bquo;We need a bold, imaginative strategy for the railways.&equo; 
 &pound;1billion price tag put on &bquo;care in community&equo; for mentally ill. 
 By Angella Johnson 
 ONE BILLION pounds must be spent on care in the community for mentally ill patients leaving hospital, the National Schizophrenia Fellowship said yesterday. 
 Ms Judy Weleminsky, director of the fellowship, said the Government should allocate the sum over the next four years to prevent patients &mdash; many suffering from schizophrenia &mdash; being discharged without proper supervision. 
 Often they ended up wandering the streets. 
 She told the junior Health Minister, Mr Roger Freeman, who was attending the fellowship's conference in London, that since 1971 more than 50,000 mental hospital beds have been lost; fewer than one in ten have been replaced by residential places in the community. 
 An estimated 12,500 beds will be lost in the next five years. 
 The fellowship welcomed the Government's white paper, said Ms Weleminsky, and its commitment to ensuring patients are assessed before leaving hospital, and the responsibility given health authorities and local authorities to meet needs. 
 But she did not believe it could become a reality unless much more money was forthcoming. 
 Mr Freeman said the level of spending was for local determination. 
 &bquo;But we hope to make things a little easier in respect of health authority capital and specific grants for social care.&equo; 
 Health takes biggest share of Scottish spending rise. 
 RISES in spending on health, education, transport, and housing in Scotland were announced yesterday when the Scottish Secretary revealed his public expenditure spending plans for next year. 
 The total budget will be &pound;9.5 billion &mdash; &pound;525 million higher than this year &mdash; and will rise to &pound;10.4 billion within three years, Mr Malcolm Rifkind told the Commons. 
 Health spending &mdash; a third of the budget &mdash; will rise by &pound;220 million, and education by 12 per cent to &pound;439 million. 
 It will be &pound;500 million in three years. 
 Support for students will rise by &pound;134 million in the next three years, allowing for an increase of 6,000 students next year and 8,000 in 1991-92. 
 There is another &pound;30 million for transport, bringing the programme to more than &pound;400 million in 1992-93. 
 Housing will receive an 11 per cent increase in funding (&pound;36 million), and provisional net allocations for council housing will increase by &pound;25 million, or 15 per cent. 
 Capital spending for water and sewage services would rise by more than &pound;100 million in the next three years. 
 For Labour, Mr Donald Dewar said the figures did not amount to a real increase and took no account of cuts in local authority spending in recent years. 
 Opposition burn their fingers on microwave Sketch. 
 By Andrew Rawnsley 
 JOHN Gummer came to the despatch box to give the new guidelines for safe cooking using microwave ovens. 
 But, as usual, what Mr Gummer was most interested in was sharing his recipe for spit-roasting members of the Opposition. 
 Fanny Gummer's recipe is an old one. 
 Take one opposition spokesman, simmer for an hour in a heavy sauce of sarcasm, season with scornful adjectives, throw in liberal amounts of contempt, add several pinches of disdain, and spice with invective. 
 Serve while hot. 
 Will comfortably feed about 100 Conservative backbenchers. 
 Yesterday Mr Gummer was roasting his Opposition shadow, Dr David Clark. 
 Labour's spokesman on food had come to the House thinking &mdash; unwisely as it soon turned out &mdash; that he was going to roast Mr Gummer. 
 Dr Clark had tabled a motion with the Speaker, demanding an emergency statement on the Government's failure to publish a list of the potentially unsafe microwaves. 
 The idea was to embarrass the Government. 
 When the time came for the statement, Dr Clark could be seen on the Opposition front bench, clutching a sheaf of notes. 
 They were almost certainly full of furious denunciations of the Government in general and Mr Gummer in particular. 
 But something about Mr Gummer's face &mdash; like the look of insufferable smugness - should have warned Dr Clark that it was all about to go horribly wrong for him. 
 For it was a far-from-embarrassed Mr Gummer who rose to the despatch box. 
 &bquo;The full list of every oven, together with updated instructions,&equo; he announced, &bquo;is being published by the manufacturers this afternoon.&equo; 
 Dr Clark's jaw dropped a foot. 
 &bquo;Anyone who has a microwave oven,&equo; went on Mr Gummer, &bquo;will be able to check against the list to see what steps, if any, they need to take to ensure their food is fully cooked.&equo; 
 Dr Clark's jaw put on another yard. 
 The House, Mr Gummer thought, &bquo;will be pleased to know that&equo;. 
 The House was pleased to know that, with the notable exception of Dr Clark. 
 Mr Gummer had &mdash; or at least appeared to have &mdash; already published the very list Dr Clark had come to demand. 
 Dr Clark was now seen hastily abandoning all those notes, containing all the furious denunciations that he had prepared earlier. 
 Rising to Tory jeers, he had no option but to thank Mr Gummer for the statement. 
 Gamely, but a bit limply, Dr Clark claimed they had only got it by getting Mr Gummer &bquo;dragged to the House&equo;. 
 The Tories laughed again. 
 Dr Clark was now oven-ready for Mr Gummer. 
 Rising again, he began to slice up the Opposition spokesman. 
 &bquo;Labour thought they were going to win a point today &mdash; they were rather disappointed when they found they had got it completely wrong.&equo; 
 Then he threw in the spice and seasoning: &bquo;By stirring up people's fears unnecessarily, jobs have been endangered by the Labour Opposition.&equo; 
 Conservative MPs found it delicious, though more refined palates will have gagged a bit at Mr Gummer's insistence on always over-salting the self-righteousness. 
 &bquo;I did not seek to make headlines,&equo; he said triumphantly, &bquo;unlike the party opposite.&equo; 
 The Agriculture Minister sat down, serene in victory. 
 Nobody could deny Mr Gummer this small triumph, but he might make more friends if he didn't always insist on making such a meal of it. 
 FT injury test case looms. 
 By Simon Beavis and Lisa Buckingham 
 ATEST case aiming to set new standards of compensation for journalists suffering from repetitive strain injury may be launched against the Financial Times. 
 Solicitors acting for the National Union of Journalists are considering whether to bring a &bquo;representative&equo; or class action case against the newspaper, whose staff has been among the worst hit by the industrial injury. 
 Unions representing workers in other industries have pursued RSI cases against employers. 
 A Midland Bank employee, stricken with RSI after using a word processor, was recently awarded &pound;45,000 in compensation by the courts. 
 RSI is a loose description of musculo-skeletal disorders associated with repetitive movements; causing severe trauma in muscles and tendons and, at worst, severe disability. 
 The problem is long-standing in some industries but is making fresh inroads with the spread of new technology and keyboards. 
 The problem has hit a number of British newspapers, including the Guardian. 
 Mr David Walker, FT managing editor, said that over 100 journalists, or nearly a third of the staff, had been referred to the company's medical department with possible RSI symptoms. 
 Twenty were either off work or on restricted working, while a number of others were receiving therapy. 
 The company has decided to remove editorial responsibilities from the deputy editor, Mr Richard Lambert, so that he can tackle the RSI outbreak. 
 The FT, in consultation with the Robens Institute of Health and Safety at Surrey University, is recommending changes in working practices to try to halt the spread of RSI. 
 The editor, Mr Geoffrey Owen, said in a memorandum to staff: &bquo;I accept that this could mean some fall in editorial quality; this is a lower price to pay than a continued RSI problem.&equo; 
 18COMMENT THE GUARDIANThursday December 7 1989 Egon, and forgotten in a rush of events. 
 THE KRENZ credentials were never all that brilliant: loyal hatchetman for Mr Erich Honecker, smooth operator of the security apparatus, apologist of the Beijing massacre, and owner of the phoniest smile in the entire East German politburo. 
 Yesterday he smiled for the last time and said he did not wish to obstruct the work of Prime Minister Hans Modrow &mdash; who now constitutes, with a small group of associates from Dresden, the only remaining acceptable face of reform within the East German Communist Party. 
 Mr Krenz's resignation as head of state &mdash; he stepped down from the party leadership three days ago &mdash; signifies what could be a terminal crisis for the party, as it desperately advances its special congress by a week to find new faces. 
 Perhaps the opening up of the secret police files, once Mr Krenz's little empire, was the final shove, combined with the resignation of all the security chiefs and the placing under house arrest of his former boss Mr Honecker. 
 (Who knows what personal skeletons may now be discovered in Mr Krenz's private cupboard?) 
 But the drama of this not very pleasant person is wholly overshadowed by the larger drama of an entire nation. 
 The Berlin Wall is not the only boundary to have been breached in the past seven weeks, and who can say where the process will end? 
 It certainly may not stop with Mr Manfred Gerlach, the moderately reform-minded leader of the formerly stooge-like Liberal Democratic Party, who now takes over as head of state. 
 Just a month ago Mr Gerlach found his tongue and announced that the concept of the perfection of socialist democracy in the past had been &bquo;absolutely wrong&equo;. 
 On behalf of the Liberal Democrats he now intended to work, in partnership with the Communist Party, for Genuine Socialism. 
 This sort of language already sounds ludicrously dated, even though a fair number of East Germans may still seek to redefine their society in different terms from the capitalist West. 
 Mr Gerlach himself may seem dated before too long. 
 Yesterday, even as he took over from Mr Krenz, he was speculating that he might soon lose his job if the East German parliament decided to replace the Council of State with an executive president. 
 The Liberal Democrats have finally emerged from the puppet-masters' box, but the crowds in the streets may decide they have left it too left. 
 Yesterday's events merely dramatised the fact that there can now be no certainty about the permanence of individuals, institutions or ideologies in present-day East Germany &mdash; not to mention other chunks of Eastern Europe. 
 Who knows, for example, whether the &bquo;complete restructuring&equo; this weekend of the East German Communist Party will save it from humiliation in next year's elections? 
 Heraclitus rules, and the state of flux is likely to get more, rather than less, dramatic. 
 Nato strategists may join with Kremlin regional specialists in feeling rather nervous about this excessively open-ended prospect. 
 We know that Mrs Thatcher feels jittery. 
 In spite of our own commitment to people-based change and transformation, we, too, may wonder where it is all going to finish. 
 But our hopes and fears are irrelevant as the train rushes on. 
 The task now imposed on everyone, and especially those preparing to spend the weekend in Strasbourg, is to think big and flexibly about Europe's future. 
 The lesson of Mr Krenz is that those who cannot cope get crushed by the engine.. 
 Single sympathy. 
 STAND by for a new moral crusade against single mothers. 
 This week's report from the General Household Survey shows that the decline in traditional family life is accelerating. 
 There has been a startling 25 per cent rise in the number of single mothers within the past year: from 12 per cent of all families with dependent children in 1987 to 15 per cent in 1988. 
 Maybe this is all that is needed to re-ignite calls for a review of the welfare benefits which single parents receive &mdash; a review actually under way earlier this year, but thankfully kicked into touch by Tony Newton when he took over from the hapless John Moore as Social Security Secretary last Summer. 
 Mr Moore had made it clear he wanted a sterner system. 
 No-one was ever able to locate the elusive and possibly mythical teenager who supposedly became pregnant in Mr Moore's constituency merely to jump the housing queue, but still he knew it was a serious issue. 
 So what is happening? 
 First, remember that unmarried mothers are only one of four categories of single mothers. 
 There are three other categories: widowed, separated and divorced. 
 Unmarried mothers &mdash; of all ages &mdash; account for only one third of the total number. 
 Two thirds derive from the break-up of marriage. 
 Then consider whether social security is really an incentive. 
 The current benefit for a single mother with one child is &pound;56-a-week plus housing benefit, or &pound;67.80 with two children under 11. 
 Think of it: a little over &pound;20-a-week per member of the family. 
 In fact, for a child under 11, a mother receives precisely &pound;l.68 a day to meet all needs: food, heating, light, clothes, shoes, entertainment, presents, fares. 
 It doesn't even buy a burger, shake and large fries in a fast food joint. 
 Look, too, at the hurdles which a single mother who wants to work must face. 
 Last year the Government abolished the allowance that mothers who moved from benefits to work could claim. 
 With child care costs added to reasonable travelling expenses, this alone would have been worth as much as &pound;40 a week now. 
 Instead, the old flat rate &pound;12 disregard was raised to &pound;15. 
 Then, finally, examine maintenance. 
 Only six per cent of single mothers can rely on maintenance as their main source of income. 
 Some 68 per cent of single mothers receive some maintenance, but less than half of unmarried mothers receive any. 
 An inadequate system has been made worse by the Government's decision that it will no longer accept responsibility for collecting maintenance unless there have been irregular payments. 
 Moreover, there are built-in disincentives on both aides for non-payment. 
 All maintenance is deducted in full from the welfare which the custodial parent receives; this, in turn, is a clear disincentive for the non-custodial parent to pay when the only body benefiting is the state. 
 Where should the Government move? 
 A comprehensive review, as against a cost-cutting populist exercise, would be welcome. 
 The people who would have suffered most from Mr Moore's penal approach are the 1.6 million children in one parent families. 
 Their interests need protection. 
 But the present, incoherent system does need reform. 
 There is every reason for more unmarried mothers receiving maintenance from the fathers of their children; but this is only a small part of the problem. 
 You have to scan wider. 
 All items need looking at: benefits, child care allowances, maintenance and the court procedures which make it so difficult to vary an order. 
 Over to you, Mr Newton.. 
 Chiller Manila. 
 WHO WILL guard the guardians in the Philippines, where it is rapidly becoming clear that President Aquino does not command her own army? 
 Despite her declaration of a state of emergency yesterday and the government's announcement early today that the rebels had agreed to return to their barracks, the events of the last six days can only be seen as a colossal confession of weakness on Mrs Aquino's part. 
 In military terms the problem should have been settled on the first day. 
 In the business district of Makati, not more than four hundred rebel troops were holed up yesterday in several unpromising locations with no possibility of reinforcement. 
 In the central Philippines, the airbase of Mactan was occupied by no more than two hundred rebels and surrounded by allegedly &bquo;loyal&equo; troops. 
 A swift exercise of constitutionally legitimate force should have been enough. 
 Yet no one, from Mrs Aquino downwards, could be sure that her orders would be obeyed. 
 The rebels in Makati calmly bargained for surrender terms which, they insisted, should include her own resignation &mdash; and the terms behind the government's report that they had gone back to barracks were not immediately clear this morning. 
 A planned military assault on Mactan yesterday was unaccountably delayed. 
 Meanwhile there was a growing silence from those on whom Mrs Aquino must rely &mdash; like her own Vice-President, and, it now seems, the United States. 
 Washington's policy of never negotiating with terrorists suffered a 180 degree change on the way to Manila. 
 US officials freely explained that &bquo;tremendous pressure&equo; was being brought upon Mrs Aquino. 
 They added that the foreigners were not hostages &bquo;in the normal sense of the word&equo; but merely &bquo;unable to move because of the rebel presence&equo;. 
 Hence negotiations which ended with the US Ambassador appearing to congratulate the rebels on their restraint. 
 The US administration has reined back its support from Mrs Aquino after the initial commitment of air support &mdash; now widely regarded in Washington as a move which further weakened her authority. 
 The State Department is murmuring that it is &bquo;premature to speculate&equo; on the long-term implications of the coup. 
 Mrs Aquino's advertisement for the democratic way of life is important to Washington. 
 So is the continuation of its lease on Subic Bay and Clark Air Base. 
 Realists may argue that the US has lived before with undemocratic regimes and can do so again. 
 It could, for example, live with the sort of civil-military coalition towards which the thoroughly disloyal Vice President, Mr Salvador Laurel, appears to be pointing. 
 Mr Laurel shares the Nacionalista Party leadership with the even more disloyal former Defence Minister, Mr Juan Ponce Enrile. 
 Yesterday the party called for non-renewal of the US bases agreement, but perhaps that should be seen as an opening bid. 
 The most depressing aspect of this latest coup crisis &mdash; the sixth since Mrs Aquino took office &mdash; is the absence in the streets of the people's power to whom she owes her own position. 
 The reasons for her loss of popularity is not hard to find. 
 &bquo;The economic recovery has restored old fortunes far more significantly,&equo; she admitted in this year's State of the Nation address, &bquo;than it has touched the lives of the vast majority of our people.&equo; 
 The lowest 30 per cent of the population remained mired in unchanging misery, she added. 
 &bquo;They think nothing has changed and I don't blame them.&equo; 
 Letters to the Editor 
 Thursday People. 
 Dennis Barker:. 
 Professor with a fatal fascination. 
 &bquo;I. 
 F passengers started voting with their feet, my goodness, that starts things happening on the security front!&equo; said Professor Paul Wilkinson yesterday. 
 My goodness? 
 It was typically quiet language from the man who, as director of the Research Institute for the Study of Conflict and Terrorism, is one of the world's leading self-made experts on the bloodstained subject. 
 He was launching his report, the Lessons of Lockerbie, marking the first anniversary of the Pan Am jumbo jet blast. 
 It emphasises that airlines should get together to find ways of combating terrorism. 
 The interest in terrorism of the man born 52 years ago at Harrow-on-the Hill, the son of a clerk to a Scottish distillery, seems unlikely. 
 It started when he was an officer in the RAF. 
 &bquo;I wrote about groups involved in protest, revolution and revolt in places like the Middle East &mdash; the sub-state actors rather than states. 
 &bquo;It started as a short project for an article but the whole subject took off and turned into a major research field.&equo; 
 The research &mdash; and terrorism &mdash; progressed when he was lecturing in politics at University College, Cardiff, and then reader at the University of Wales. 
 It turned into Political Terrorism, his first book on the subject. 
 Then he researched the problems of liberal democratic states trying to beat terrorism. 
 Terrorism and the Liberal State was published in 1977, and revised for a second edition in 1986. 
 A growth area indeed. 
 By the time he moved to Aberdeen University in 1979, becoming head of the department of politics and international relations, he was spending a third of his time researching and writing on it. 
 Wilkinson says his area is a difficult one, but no more so than for scholars writing about military strategy and intelligence. 
 His name once appeared in a diary of Colonel Oliver North during the Irangate hearings, though Wilkinson thinks that was because he was giving a lecture in Washington. 
 He says he &bquo;functions like most academics, from open source material&equo;, though informal contact with people on the inside could produce more insight. 
 Campaign to cut drink-driving. 
 By Andrew Culf 
 THE devastating impact drink-driving can have on family life was stressed yesterday at the launch of the Department of Transport's &pound;700,000 Christmas advertising campaign. 
 The message behind the television and radio campaign was reinforced by a mother who told of her only daughter being killed three years ago by a drunken motorist. 
 The Transport Minister, Mr Robert Atkins, said: &bquo;Christmas is a family time of year, but for some families Christmas is going to be unbearable, because a loved one has been killed by a drink-driver.&equo; 
 Government figures show that 10,000 people have died in drink-drive accidents in the past 10 years. 
 One road death in five is drink-related and every year about 900 people are killed and 17,000 injured in accidents where drivers are over the legal limit. 
 Speaking at the campaign launch at the Victoria Palace Theatre, London, Mrs Caroline Lock, now a member of the Campaign Against Drinking and Driving, recalled her daughter's death. 
 &bquo;Christmas will just be another bad time. 
 &bquo;I don't really have any good times any more. 
 This will be my fourth Christmas without my precious daughter Sandra, who was 11 years old.&equo; 
 Mrs Lock, of Formby, Merseyside, said the driver, who was jailed for two years, served eight months. 
 &bquo;But what is eight months? 
 Sandra is deprived of her life and I am deprived of her company, love, and laughter because some creature chose to drink six or seven whiskies and drove home.&equo; 
 Easing London's increasing traffic congestion by road pricing has effectively been ruled out by the Transport Secretary, Mr Cecil Parkinson who told the Commons transport committee that it would be impractical. 
 There was no foreseeable possibility of a such a scheme. 
 Writers rush to the aid of &bquo;blasphemy&equo; video. 
 By David Sharrock 
 MEMBERS of the literary establishment yesterday rallied to the support of a banned 20-minute video portraying the erotic visions of the patron saint of Spain, St Theresa of Avila. 
 Writers Fay Weldon and Marina Warner and Colin MacCabe, the former head of production at the British Film Institute, were among witnesses appearing before the Video Appeals Committee, called to examine a decision by the British Board of Film Classification to refuse a release certificate to &bquo;Visions of Ecstasy&equo;. 
 The video, produced by Axel Ltd, is the first film in 77 years to be rejected by the board on the grounds of blasphemy. 
 Yesterday's hearing, acted out below the chandeliers and stained glass windows of the Institute of Public Health and Hygiene in London, struggled with the concepts of blasphemy and the erotic language of 16th century Christian mysticism. 
 Ms Weldon, a member of the committee who was not asked to sit at the hearing, described the video as a serious attempt to deal with the bride of Christ notion. 
 &bquo;It didn't distress or alarm me in any way, certainly not as much as many other things that I have seen that have earned certificates&equo;. 
 Mr James Ferman, director of the British Board of Film Classifications, admitted he found the video, an exploration of the borderline between religious ecstasy and sexual passion, an interesting and legitimate subject. 
 But it was the unanimous view of the board that it manifested contempt towards the divinity of Christ by presenting him as a living man, not a symbol, and as the object of overt sexual passion. 
 Mr Ferman said he found offensive scenes where the figure of Christ was repeatedly inter cut with a lesbian scene between two nuns. 
 Describing the American feature film, The Last Temptation of Christ, to which he awarded a certificate, as a challenging religious film he said that acontroversial scene: &bquo;It indicated that Christ had sex, but it did not go on for 14 minutes.&equo; 
 Mr Geoffrey Robertson, QC, appearing for the film's director and producer, Nigel Wingrove and John Stephenson, argued that the board's grounds for banning the video rested upon very insecure foundations. 
 A recent Government statement following the controversy surrounding Salman Rushdie's novel The Satantic Verses stated that blasphemy prosecutions would be &bquo;damaging, divisive and inappropriate.&equo; 
 It was &bquo;almost inconceivable&equo; that the prosecuting authorities would bring a blasphemy case against Visions of Ecstasy. 
 Previous court rulings stated that blasphemy consisted of &bquo;the publication of words spoken or written. 
 No-one seems to have noticed that this is a silent film.&equo; 
 Throughout the appeal the video remained unseen. 
 &bquo;We're all very familiar with it,&equo; said VAC chairman, Mr Peter Barnes. 
 &bquo;I've certainly seen it three or four times.&equo; 
 Marina Warner, artistic director of the ICA and an expert on mysticism, told the hearing that mystical language derived from the overtly erotic Songs of Solomon. 
 St Theresa's writings were part of the tradition of Christian mysticism. 
 In her view the film had been &bquo;quite careful&equo; to show that it was an allegory and it reminded her of the British classic film Black Narcissus. 
 It was a poignant film, which she wished had been longer. 
 The hearing continues today. 
 Microwave oven danger list fails to satisfy critics. 
 By James Erlichman and Paul Nettleton 
 THE Government was accused yesterday of concocting a fudged list to gloss over the real dangers of microwave ovens found to be faulty in its own tests. 
 Dr David Clark, Labour's agriculture spokesman, who warned that potentially unsafe models remain on sale, said: &bquo;All we have is a sham.&equo; 
 The accusation came after Mr John Gummer, the Agriculture Minister &mdash; under fierce Labour and consumer group pressure &mdash; produced a list drawn up by the manufacturers on the 70 microwave oven models tested by Government scientists. 
 But it fell far short of providing the detailed model-by-model defect analysis demanded by Mr Gummer's critics. 
 The manufacturers' list describes 46 out of 70 models as &bquo;satisfactory&equo;. 
 But it does not concede that any of the remaining 24 models failed the Government's test, even though at least three have been withdrawn from the market. 
 Instead, it gives a few lines of new advice on better cooking methods. 
 The 24 failed to achieve the 70C uniform cooking temperature needed to ensure that all food poisoning bacteria, including listeria, were killed. 
 The Government insists that a promise of secrecy given to manufacturers prevents it telling 8 million microwave owners exactly what may be wrong with their machines. 
 Instead, Mr Gummer told the House of Commons the list drawn up by the manufacturers themselves contained new instructions which would make all the machines &bquo;perfectly safe in use.&equo; 
 &bquo;By seeking cooperation and not confrontation&hellip; the public has been more fully informed,&equo; Mr Gummer said. 
 The Consumers' Association, which first forced disclosure of the hazards last August, described the list as &bquo;a welcome first step, but inadequate&equo;. 
 The director, Mr John Beishon, said pressure had forced some disclosure. 
 But improved cooking instructions would neither identify or make safe those minority of models which even Mr Gummer admitted to needing &bquo;more substantial changes of oven design.&equo; 
 One high street retailer, Comet, announced that it would offer refunds to people who bought its own-brand and other manufacturers' models which failed the Government tests announced on Monday. 
 The full manufacturers' list of 24 models which were considered not satisfactory (and presumably failed the government test) is: Boots 500; Brother MF1200PW and MF3200DB; Electrolux NF4061, NF4065 and NF4076; Goldstar ER350ME and ER535ME; Hoover H6312; Matsui 260TC; Moulinex 059; Philips AVM625 and AVM734; Proline M3030; Russel Hobbs 8504; Samsung RE570D, RE576D and RE990CT; Sanyo EM2714BR; Sharp R-7A50M and R-8H50(B)T; Toshiba ER9610EW-1 and ER9630E; Tricity MH1081. 
 Clarke risks rebuff by non-TUC union. 
 By Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 THE Government was warned last night to expect a rebuff as the Association of Professional Ambulance Personnel prepared to ballot members on a deal rejected by the five TUC-affiliated unions for ambulance staff. 
 The association's leaders, who in two days of talks failed to secure any significant improvement in the the 9 per cent, 18-month offer thrown out last month, said that the ballot form would ask if members supported sanctions, possibly including action which would disrupt services to patients. 
 Although the association recommends acceptance, its leaders are sceptical that the 5,000 members will agree, and disappointed that the offer was not increased to 10 per cent during 22 hours of talks. 
 Mr Brian Bruno, a member of the association's executive, said: &bquo;There is a fair chance it could be turned down. 
 A lot of people expected a little bit more.&equo; 
 The outcome of an earlier association ballot was kept quiet while the talks lasted under an agreement with the Health Secretary, Mr Kenneth Clarke. 
 The ballot result is believed to have backed action over the original 6.5 per cent, one year offer. 
 Mr Clarke granted the eight-year-old association pay-bargaining rights only last Friday. 
 Rejection of the latest offer by the association would rob the Government of the legimitacy to be gained from imposing an agreed deal on the other five unions. 
 The 12-week dispute showed no signs of abating yesterday. 
 Crews in Greater Manchester are to be balloted on a 24-hour strike on December 20, despite union appeals to maintain accident and emergency cover. 
 Local officials said that the move could result in the police and army being used locally for the first time, but reflected members' anger and frustration. 
 Yesterday Mr Clarke again made it clear that the 9 per cent offer was final, and continued to attack the TUC unions &mdash; particularly the National Union of Public Employees and the unions' chief negotiator, Mr Roger Poole. 
 &bquo;He wants to play at politics. 
 He has set himself up as a left-wing leader taking on the Government,&equo; Mr Clarke said. 
 Doubts remain on Hanoi view of repatriation. 
 By Martin Linton 
 THE Government was unable to explain in the Lords yesterday what it will do if Vietnam refuses to accept the boat people to be repatriated from Hong Kong. 
 The Foreign Office Minister Lord Brabazon of Tara confirmed that Vietnam had &bquo;agreed to take these people back, provided forcible repatriation is not used&equo;, and that talks were still under way. 
 The Liberal Democrat peer Lord Bonham Carter asked whether the Government had any contingency plans if Vietnam refused to accept them, but Lord Brabazon could only say that &bquo;hopefully&equo; the standard procedures to be used would not involve force. 
 &bquo;Obviously if the Vietnamese considered the measures used to return these people involved the use of force, which is not our intention, we will use procedures in line with those used worldwide,&equo; he said. 
 He was confident that the Vietnamese authorities would find them &bquo;unobjectionable&equo;. 
 The Labour leader in the Lords, Lord Cledwyn, asked: If Vietnam's human rights record was bad enough for British aid to be cut off in 1979, why was it now good enough to merit forced repatriation? 
 If it was good enough, why didn't the Government restart aid? 
 TODAY'S BUSINESS House of Commons: Home Office questions; questions to the Prime Minister; National Health Service Bill, second reading. 
 House of Lords: Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill, second reading. 
 Bids for Crown Suppliers to be asked for soon. 
 By Martin Linton 
 PRIVATISATION of the Crown Suppliers will go ahead quickly once Parliament has passed the enabling bill which received its second reading yesterday, the Environment Secretary, Mr Chris Patten, told the Commons yesterday. 
 The merchant bank appointed to handle the sale, Samuel Montagu, will shortly invite bids for a business which had sales of &pound;168 million last year. 
 Mr Patten said privatisation of the Property Services Agency, which builds and furnishes Government offices, will not be practicable until the second half of 1992. 
 As an interim, the agency will be &bquo;untied&equo; from Whitehall from April 1990 &mdash; it will be able to take on private work, and ministries will no longer have to use it. 
 Parts of the privatisated agency will remain under Government control, including maintenance of Westminster and the ministerial car pool. 
 Mr Patten said he would welcome a management-employee buy-out bid for both. 
 Labour's spokesman, Mr Clive Soley, said the privatisations were neither necessary nor desirable. 
 Two Government reports had concluded they were not in the public interest. 
 Even Samuel Montagu had said the purpose of the Crown Suppliers was to provide for departments more efficiently than they could do it for themselves or from any other source. 
 &bquo;If that is their purpose and they are achieving that purpose, why is the Government privatising them?&equo; he asked. 
 As the junior Environment Minister, Mr Christopher Chope, wound up for the Government, Mr Soley accused him of ignoring the fact that the agency advised departments and the armed forces on security and vetting of staff. 
 Mr Chope said that it was not appropriate to discuss Westminster security, but the agency already contracted out most building work, including work with a high security content for the Defence Ministry. 
 The bill was given a second reading by 237 votes to 181, a Government majority of 56. 
 Dixons faces Kingfisher bid. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 KINGFISHER, the retailing group which controls Woolworth and B&amp;Q, yesterday launched a &pound;460 million takeover bid for Dixons, Britain's biggest chain of electrical shops. 
 Dixons' chairman, Mr Stanley Kalms, whose empire embraces 600 Currys outlets as well as 350 under the Dixons name, is expected to issue a rejection of the takeover attempt today. 
 Three years ago, his company failed in an attempt to buy Kingfisher, then called Woolworth, for &pound;1.8 billion. 
 Retailing analysts in the City believe Kingfisher will have to pay far more than the 120p a share now on offer for Dixons to have a realistic chance of winning its cash bid. 
 Kingfisher was forced to show its hand after rumours that a bid was in the offing began to circulate on Tuesday. 
 Stock Exchange insider dealing investigators have launched an inquiry into a suspicious surge in activity ahead of the bid on the traded options market: traded options allow dealers to bet on future share prices. 
 People who bought Dixons traded options on Tuesday and sold once news of the bid was released yesterday made a 100 per cent profit in 24 hours. 
 If Kingfisher succeeds, it would control stores which last year sold at least 22 per cent of all electrical goods retailed in Britain. 
 Some figures put the market share at more than 25 per cent which would normally trigger a monopolies inquiry. 
 Kingfisher runs 307 Comet outlets and has recently bought Laskys. 
 Dixons has seen its fortunes fall steadily since its abortive takeover assault on Woolworth in 1986. 
 Annual profits have slumped from over &pound;100 million to an expected &pound;45 million this year. 
 Retailing industry-watchers believe that Dixons' core businesses &mdash; the British electrical retailing operation &mdash; is currently showing a loss. 
 The group as a whole is in the black only because it has income from an American retailing chain Silo and from financial services and property deals in Britain. 
 Shops selling large electrical goods such as television sets, hi-fi and washing machines have been the first to suffer from the slowdown in spending, while large chains like Comet and Dixons have been losing market share to small independent shopkeepers. 
 Kingfisher's 700-plus Woolworth outlets and the Superdrug chain are better placed to weather the slowdown. 
 Three years ago, when Dixons was the bidder, the position was exactly the reverse: electrical retailers were cashing in on an unprecedented boom. 
 Dixons claims to supply one in every five TV sets sold in the UK &mdash; although Mr Kalms once described television &bquo;as one of the curses of our society&equo;. 
 He built up Dixons, with sales last year of over &pound;1.7 billion, after starting work at the age of 16 with his father's portrait photography business. 
 Reports, page 11 
 Drug-linked bomb blast kills 40 in Colombia. 
 By Alma Guillermoprieto in Bogota 
 APOWERFUL bomb killed at least 40 people and wounded 350 in Bogota yesterday when it wrecked the headquarters of the Department of Administrative Security, the government agency charged with bringing Colombia's drug dealers to heel. 
 The blast came three months after the start of a determined government offensive against the country's cocaine traffickers. 
 On Tuesday, Judge Bernardo Jaramillo, who was investigating Medellin drug cartel activity, was shot dead as he was walking home. 
 Hidden in a bus and estimated to contain about half a ton of dynamite, the bomb ripped a wall of the nine-storey DAS building and badly damaged nearby buildings. 
 General Miguel Maza Marquez, chief of the investigative police and one of the traffickers' most vocal critics, escaped unharmed as he did from a car bomb attack last May in which seven people were killed. 
 Yesterday's blast was seen less as a direct attempt on the man who has most vigorously pursued Colombia's chief cocaine exporters, but as part of a campaign to terrorise non-combatants in the drug war into supporting negotiations and amnesty. 
 Most of the wounded were street-sellers and shopkeepers in the busy commercial sector behind the police buildings, who had arrived early to work eager for Christmas sales. 
 Hospital emergency wards were struggling to cope with the injured as radio announcers read lists of victims and broadcast anguished appeals from those who had not heard from relatives in the area near the explosion. 
 Motor traffic was paralysed in much of the city. 
 There was no trace of the bombers, and no one has so far claimed responsibility. 
 The government offensive against the drug cartel began in earnest on August 18 after the murders of a presidential candidate, Luis Carlos Galan, and the police chief in Medellin, where the drug traffickers, Pablo Escobar and Jorge Luis Ochoa, are based. 
 The blast appears to have been timed to coincide with a political offensive. 
 Like the bomb which blew up a national airline flight last week, killing all 107 aboard, the bombing came in the shadow of a struggle between President Virgilio Barco and the lower house of congress to overturn emergency extradition procedures decreed by Mr Barco against traffickers wanted for trial in the US. 
 More than 10 have been extradited. 
 But opinion polls show strong nationalist sentiment against extradition and congress representatives voted last night to put the extradition decree to national referendum next month. 
 But the Senate may yet overturn this. 
 Picture, page 7 
 Gobbledegook &bquo;betrayed cheat&equo;. 
 ASTUDENT accused of cheating in his degree exam wrote complete gobbledegook which matched the examiners' draft solution to maths problems in the paper, an inquiry was told yesterday. 
 The case of Mr Francis Foecke, aged 31, began in June 1986, when the board of examiners alleged dishonest conduct in his maths and computer studies finals. 
 Mr Ian Karsten, for the board, told a Bristol University appeal committee hearing that there were passages in his script which were &bquo;bizarre and remarkable and which require explanation&equo;. 
 Mr Foecke has claimed he scored passes in 13 out of 13 final exam papers. 
 He denies the university's claim that he cheated in two papers through having advance knowledge of the questions. 
 He maintains he achieved his high pass rate by year-long cramming with similar papers. 
 But Mr Karsten told the committee chairman, Professor Michael Furmston: &bquo;In one striking case there is a passage which in mathematical terms is complete gobbledegook. 
 &bquo;By an astonishing coincidence in the examiners&equo; model solution precisely the same piece of goobledegook appears at precisely the same point.&equo; 
 Mr Peter Goldsmith, QC, for Mr Foecke, submitted that it was now too late for Mr Foecke to have a fair trial due to the passage of time. 
 The board had introduced new charges which it would be unfair for Mr Foecke to contest. 
 But Mr Karsten said almost two years had been lost due to Mr Foecke's unwillingness to continue with the university's internal appeal procedure. 
 He appealed unsuccessfully to the Privy Council, acting on behalf of the Queen, Bristol University's Visitor, and a High Court judge over the university's appeal procedures. 
 The university appointed a new appeal committee with a view to speeding up the hearing. 
 Professor Furmston said he would reserve judgment until next week. 
 Was Time magazine's recent dissection of feminism in fact a postmortem? 
 Nikki Finke reads between the lines Bad timing. 
 IS FEMINISM dead? 
 Well, Time magazine seems to think so. 
 And not since Newsweek's 1986 cover story &bquo;The Marriage Crunch&equo;, which professed that single women over 40 had a better chance of getting killed by a terrorist than getting married, has a general-interest magazine article caused such discussion among women. 
 Bannered &bquo;Women Face the '90s&equo;, the Time cover features a woman with a briefcase in one hand and a baby in the other -a symbol of those women who feel betrayed by feminism because, as the magazine says, they tried to have it all and now they've just plain had it. 
 Time doesn't define what feminism is supposed to be, yet claims to find a schism between the older generations of women who started the fight for economic, political and social equality and today's generations who seem complacent or angry about what women's liberation has achieved. 
 The reason, Time explained, is that women under the age of 30 picture a feminist, to quote one college senior, as &bquo;someone who doesn't shave her legs and is doing everything she can to deny that she is feminine&equo;. 
 Because of this, the magazine said, these women dismiss leaders like Gloria Steinem as &bquo;hopelessly outdated&equo;. 
 And as for women in their 30s and 40s, Time claims they feel the feminist movement betrayed them by failing to warn them about the sacrifices women had to make in exchange for equality and by pursuing the wrong goals &mdash; pushing more strongly for the equal rights amendment than for child care or flexible working hours. 
 Even more provocative is a poll that found that the vast majority of American women today don't even identify themselves as feminists. 
 To those that do, them's fightin' words. 
 &bquo;Feminism was the most significant social movement to have occurred in centuries,&equo; says Judy Auerbach, director of the University of Southern California's Institute for the Study of Women and Men. 
 &bquo;And what makes me mad is this flippant desire to dismiss it as dead.&equo; 
 In fact, Time magazine almost went with the coverline &bquo;Is Feminism Dead?&equo; according to the article's author, senior editor Claudia Wallis. 
 &bquo;The only reason we didn't was a pragmatic one: we had just used &bquo;Is Government Dead?&equo; and couldn't use it again.&equo; 
 Still, some feminists believe that the article, just by raising the question, could be as devastating to feminists as Time's infamous 1969 &bquo;Is God Dead?&equo; cover story was to the clergy. 
 Carole Hemingway, ardent feminist and a Los Angeles radio talk show host, is hoping for a backlash. 
 &bquo;Look what happened to God after that Time cover &mdash; fundamentalism began sweeping the world. 
 Now Time is asking if feminism's dead, and I say, &bquo;Watch out!&equo;' 
 In fact, the article seems to conclude that the women's movement is alive and well: it's just the concept of feminism that's expired. 
 A Time-CNN survey of 1,000 women across the country found that the vast majority think the women's movement has helped women become more independent and is still improving their lives. 
 Yet only 33 per cent would identify themselves as feminists and 76 per cent said they pay &bquo;not very much&equo; or &bquo;no&equo; attention to the women's movement. 
 What many feminists find most surprising about the article is its appearance at a time when the abortion issue has regalvanised women. 
 &bquo;A few years back, you could not get young women to be active,&equo; said Judy Miller, president of the Los Angeles-based Trusteeship, an organisation of influential women in business and the arts. 
 &bquo;Today they're coming forward as they see their rights being taken away.&equo; 
 Whatever the extent of the outcry against the story, no matter, because author Wallis is prepared to defend it. 
 Or is she? 
 &bquo;We started out asking questions that were being asked all over,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;This piece wasn't meant to denigrate feminism, and if it comes across that way, I think I failed.&equo; 
 PAGE wom 
 Law Report. 
 Broadcasting ban on terrorists upheld:. 
 Court of Appeal Regina v Home Secretary, ex parte Brind and others Before Lord Donaldson of Lymington, Master of the Rolls, Lord Justice Ralph Gibson and Lord Justice McCowan December 6 1989 
 THE Home Secretary's directives to the BBC and IBA banning the broadcasting of appearances or words spoken directly by members and supporters of proscribed terrorist organisations is not unlawful, and therefore the court is not entitled to interfere. 
 The facts. 
 On October 19 1988 the Home Secretary issued directives to the BBC and IBA &bquo;to refrain from broadcasting any matter which consists of or includes &mdash; any spoken words, whether in the course of an interview or discussion or otherwise by a person who appears or is heard&hellip; where (a) the person speaking&hellip; represents or purports to represent &lsqb;any organisation proscribed under the Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act 1984 or the Northern Ireland (Emergency Provisions) Act 1978 and Sinn Fein, Republican Sinn Fein and the Ulster Defence Association&rsqb; or (b) the words support or solicit or invite support for such an organisation&equo;. 
 The Home Secretary was acting under clause 13(4) of the Licence and Agreement between him and the BBC and section 29(3) of the Broadcasting Act 1981 both of which gave him power to give the broadcasting authorities notice in writing requiring them to refrain from broadcasting any specified matter or classes of matter. 
 The directives were approved by Parliament. 
 Mr Brind and other journalists sought judicial review to challenge the directives, but failed before the Divisional Court &lsqb;Guardian Law Report: May 27, 1989&rsqb;. 
 They appealed. 
 The decision. 
 One ground of challenge was that the Home Secretary had exceeded his powers by acting in breach of article 10 of the European Convention on Human Rights which relates to freedom of expression. 
 Lord Donaldson said the Home Secretary's powers under clause 13(4) and section 29(3) were unambiguous. 
 It followed that while the Home Secretary was free to take account of the terms of the Convention, he was not obliged to do so and that the terms of the Convention were irrelevant to the court's decision. 
 The Home Secretary's reserve powers were not intended to be used frequently and this was the first time they had been used. 
 His Lordship would hesitate long before holding that Parliament intended the Home Secretary to have authority either covertly to censor programmes or to require broadcasting authorities to present news programmes otherwise than with due accuracy and impartiality, but he did not so read the power. 
 That being so, there was no reason why the words of section 29(3) should not be given their natural meaning and so read, the power was clearly all-embracing, subject only to the qualification that the Home Secretary could not lawfully require broadcasters to broadcast matter involving them in a breach of their statutory duty. 
 The journalists submitted that the directives were unlawful because they conflicted with the duty of the BBC and IBA under section 4 of the 1981 Act to preserve &bquo;due impartiality&equo;. 
 Lord Donaldson said that misappreciated the nature of the duty in at least two respects. 
 First, that it operates in the real world where there would always be obstacles to giving every shade of opinion equal air time. 
 It was impossible to treat all parliamentary candidates alike without being either wholly uninformative or inordinately lengthy. 
 Principal contenders are rightly given more time than fringe candidates. 
 The directive is simply another obstacle which has to be taken account of by broadcasting authorities when giving effect to their duty to preserve due impartiality. 
 Second, the duty is to preserve &bquo;due&equo; impartiality. 
 It is for broadcasting authorities to determine what constitutes the appropriate degree of impartiality, and they must not lose sight of their obligation not to include in their programmes matter which is likely to encourage or incite crime or be offensive to public feeling. 
 It was not self-evident that any impartiality was due to those who supported or excused attempts to achieve political change by terrorism. 
 The decision whether or not to give directives involves the Home Secretary in making a delicate and difficult political judgment. 
 But it is a judgment to be made by him and not by the courts, whose right and duty to intervene arises only if the decision is untenable in the sense that irrelevant matters were taken account of, relevant matters were not taken account of, or that the decision was manifestly wrong. 
 Lord Donaldson said a startling feature of the directives was how little they restricted the supply of the &bquo;oxygen of publicity&equo; to the organisations specified. 
 The directives had no application to parliamentary proceedings or elections and allowed reported speech. 
 On the journalists' evidence, if the directives had been in force during the previous twelve months the effect on air time would have been minimal. 
 If the directives were to be criticised, it would have to be on the basis that any use of the power would damage the reputation of the British broadcasting authorities for independence and that that price was not worth paying for so small an effect. 
 His Lordship could not say the Home Secretary's decision was not one which was fully open to him in the exercise of his judgment. 
 Lord Justice McCowan said it was impossible to hold that the Home Secretary's political judgment was one that no reasonable Home Secretary could hold. 
 That was also the political judgment of the terrorists, or they would not be so anxious to be interviewed by the media or so against the ban. 
 In regard to giving &bquo;due impartiality&equo; to news presentation, the journalists had failed to give proper weight to the qualification of impartiality by the word &bquo;due&equo;. 
 The dictionary definition of &bquo;due&equo; was not merely &bquo;owing&equo; but also &bquo;merited, appropriate, rightful&equo;. 
 The directive was aimed at Sinn Fein and the UDA but it could not have been the legislators' intention that the broadcasting authority should be impartial between the terrorists and the terrorised. 
 The appeal was dismissed. 
 Appearances: Anthony Lester QC and David Pannick instructed by Stephens Innocent for the journalists; John Laws and Robert Jay instructed by the Treasury Solicitor for the Home Secretary. 
 Shiranikha Herbert barrister 
 Obituary: JPMMillar. 
 Plebs for the cognoscenti:. 
 ALWAYS known by his initials, JPM Millar ran the National Council of Labour Colleges for over 40 years; an organisation which through classes, lectures, weekend and summer schools, and the massive number of correspondent courses organised by his wife Christine, provided shots and shell for the emerging Labour Movement. 
 Catering for more than 100,000 students a year, the Millars had a major influence on the dissemination of socialist ideas. 
 When the rush of Labour MPs came into the Commons after the 1945 election, about two thirds were former students or tutors of the NCLC. 
 The NCLC was born out of a strike at Ruskin College in 1908 about the class bias of Oxford education. 
 Ten of the 54 strikers formed the nucleus of the Central Labour College, backed by the Amalgamated Society of Railway Servants, the South Wales Miners' Federation, and the Amalgamated Society of Engineers. 
 Hostility from Oxford landlords caused the college to move to Earls Court. 
 The students shared the cooking and domestic chores. 
 Millar came to the NCLC in 1923, first as press officer, but he soon became general secretary. 
 He continued as secretary until 1965, when the NCLC was handed over to the TUC. 
 The decision to wind it up coincided with Millar's retirement, but owed more to the competition from the TUC's own education department and the Workers Educational Association. 
 Millar said: &bquo;The WEA was subsidised by the state and we were not. 
 The WEA provided orthodox education, orientated to the capitalist system. 
 We provided a socialist system of education. 
 Would you expect the devil to be subsidised by heaven?&equo; 
 Millar was obstinately determined to change the content of education. 
 Though never a left-winger in current terms, he wanted the socialist viewpoint expressed in every facet of learning. 
 &bquo;Knowledge is power &mdash; the right kind of knowledge,&equo; he liked to say. 
 A strain of independent socialist thinking runs through his courses, pamphlets, and articles for Plebs, the NCL journal he edited for many years. 
 His quarrel with the TUC was about the narrow vision that Millar thought they applied to education, confining themselves to practical day-to-day union matters and ignoring socialist principles. 
 In the last full year of the NCLC there were 11,032 enrolled students, 9,119 on day or weekend courses, and 43,984 on the 74 postal courses. 
 The students were drawn from 88 trade unions, and some outside bodies. 
 Millar told me: &bquo;Labour view of education has always been limited. 
 It wasn't so much as how to achieve a new social order, but how can I ensure that my son or daughter gets a better job than I did. 
 That was the object. 
 Before you can have a revolution you have to break down the existing system. 
 The Labour Party has done precious little about the political education of its members&equo;. 
 The Millars retired and moved to Dartmouth. 
 His house on the hill had a magnificent view over the bay. 
 Millar who liked to play the canny Scot, always said &bquo;I've seen it whenever the view was mentioned&equo;. 
 Within three months of the move, the railway station was closed and Millar blamed Dr Beeching as the architect of his isolation. 
 The house had a double garage which Millar turned into a study and office. 
 Jam-packed with a complete run of Plebs and sets of the TUC and Labour Party conference reports, it was here that he wrote his book The Labour College Movement. 
 Allen Saddler JPMMillar, born April 17, 1893; died December 2, 1989 
 Diary. 
 By Andrew Moncur 
 INTREPID Peter Bottomley, former scourge of the dozy British motorist, has not abandoned his life's work just because Her Indoors shunted him from Transport to Northern Ireland. 
 In goodwill tours of the Six Counties he has been heard to ask for alcohol-free lager and other exotic drinks. 
 Dusty samples have had to be unearthed for his refreshment. 
 But his zeal knows no bounds. 
 Stopped at a traffic light by the SuperMac shopping complex on South Belfast's ringroad, Botters, by all accounts, spots a woman driving the adjoining car without her seat-belt fastened. 
 Out he leaps from his ministerial hot-rod to remonstrate. 
 The lady in question frames an elegant response: &bquo;Ferkauf, yer Brit eejut.&equo; 
 Or words to that effect. 
 The crestfallen minister turns to his security men. 
 &bquo;Why didn't you support me?&equo; 
 The tight-lipped reply: &bquo;We're supposed to protect you from the IRA, not the voters.&equo; 
 Or words to ditto ditto. 
 SO HOW did they break the news to a joyful populace, eagerly waiting to hear the outcome of Margaret Hilda versus The Fossil (&copy; the Sun)? 
 The scene: Committee Room 12 at the Commons. 
 Outside the south door, the world's Press. 
 From the north door emerges, with entourage, Cranley Onslow, chairman of the 1922 Committee, head down and making for the lift. 
 &bquo;Errh. 
 What about the press conference, old boy?&equo; says one of the senior Tories in the flying column. 
 The party does a smart about-turn. 
 The magnificent news is duly announced. 
 Well done. 
 AGHASTLY green (a sort of goose-droppings shade) note appears in this travel firm's bumf for 1990. 
 &bquo;Land Travel shares the concern for our environment,&equo; it says. 
 &bquo;Although we send brochures and personalised leaflets out to literally thousands of people, consuming large quantities of paper, all our paper supplies are made from timber from renewable forests.&equo; 
 PAY ATTENTION. 
 All this talk of peace and detente in the Med isn't being allowed to interfere with war games at Greenham Common. 
 Having packed off a double convoy of cruise launchers (still at large) the base is playing at being under nuclear attack. 
 An Operational Readiness Inspection, it seems. 
 Carry on. 
 SOME mistake here. 
 In goes a Commons motion, tabled by the Liberal Democrat Simon Hughes. 
 This ends with a robust attack on the Labour Party, saying that what's happening &bquo;in local government is a clear indication of the total unfitness of HM's Official Opposition to run the government&equo;. 
 Good knockabout stuff, apparently signed by nine MPs, eight of them Lib Dems. 
 The ninth? 
 Jimmy Wray, Labour MP for Provan, Glasgow. 
 Errh. 
 Can that be right? 
 YOU MAY have noticed that MPs, stung into action by last week's visit by President Roh Tae Woo, slapped in a motion deploring the South Korean habit of eating dog and chips, poodle with noodle and so on. 
 This coincided with publication of an altogether different motion (about closure of the BAT works in Liverpool) signed by loads of Labour MPs, including the member for Warrington North. 
 By unhappy chance, his name appeared in print as Mr Dog Hoyle. 
 This has, of course, sent them completely barking. 
 Doug has been having his paw pulled. 
 SOME more winning entries for the Vicar's Competition: newspaper captions for the nineties. 
 &bquo;The Sellafield crater (above). 
 No cause for concern, says BNFL.&equo; and &bquo;A HoseCo official negotiates with third storey inferno family before attempting an expensive rescue operation.&equo; 
 (both Steve Handsaker); &bquo;British intellectuals and workers demonstrate in central London demanding an end to the &bquo;leading role of the Conservative Party&equo;.&equo; 
 (Tom Seldon). 
 SOME VERY American news. 
 George Bush's three-year-old grandchild, Marshal, has been enrolled in an etiquette class, Petite Protocol. 
 Hugh Hefner has devoted a little bit of Playboy to his new bride, Kimberley. 
 Just 97 pages. 
 And Nancy Reagan's tendency to borrow designer dresses is, at this late stage, under scrutiny by the revenue. 
 Just when you thought it was safe to come out of the closet. 
 DID MY ears deceive me or was yesterday's BBC TV news saying that even the Queen has &bquo;flu? 
 As though in wonder that any virus, let alone a foreign one, would dare to get up the royal hooter. 
 I ask you. 
 Geoffrey Beattie hears of businessmen roaming the streets with half a million pounds in carrier bags and learns the difference between a mobster and a muppet. 
 &bquo;You don't go to the opera to hear the music but to be bundled together with similar people. 
 It's the same with nightclubs&equo;. 
 BOB IS big time, very big time. 
 He's worth several million. 
 He sipped his gin and tonic, and my eyes flitted to his gold watch and his gold bracelet. 
 I've seen them all: Rolexes, snide Rolexes that look better than the real thing. 
 Cartiers and snide Cartiers with the paint peeling off. 
 But his watch didn't make any attempt at the right label. 
 It might have been a Seiko, but I couldn't be sure. 
 Functional rather than ostentatious, for telling the time rather than for telling others who he was. 
 My eyes stayed on his wrists, and moved up to his starched cuffs, somehow more noticeable than all that gold, or gold paint in the case of the watch. 
 This was a man who liked order. 
 But I didn't think that order was the most important thing in building up a huge nightclub and casino empire, in a world full of sharks all wanting a slice of the action. 
 And what self-respecting shark doesn't want a piece of that action? 
 What has order got to do with any of it? 
 I wanted to find out. 
 So here we were a million miles away from his world of steak and more steak and steak Tartare and steak Bernaise and Moet and Lanson and Dom Perignon. 
 Here we were in a restaurant where books on croquet lay scattered around the place. 
 I wanted to disorient him. 
 It seemed to be working. 
 &bquo;Every time you take me for a meal, it's to a non-smoking restaurant,&equo; said Bob in a somewhat annoyed tone. 
 He looked around briefly at the women with the scraggy necks in the Laura Ashley dresses, and the men who all seemed to be wearing red ties, and probably Seiko watches &mdash; but for a different reason from Bob. 
 Then he tucked into the &bquo;pan fried calves liver with sauted apples served with a crisp stir fry of mange tout.&equo; 
 It wasn't prawn cocktail. 
 My mind wandered away from the disembowelled calves. 
 I've heard them all. 
 Small time burglars with the social skills of a potted shrimp telling me how they're saving all their readies to invest in a club one day &mdash; &bquo;Maybe Puerto Banus, maybe Chesterfield, I'm not sure yet.&equo; 
 I've spent hours listening to big time bullies, who like to saunter around clubs showing their bit-on-the-side exactly who they are, by demonstrating who they know, shaking every hand worth shaking. 
 &bquo;How are you, sir?&equo; they say as they compress your hand for good measure. 
 It's always &bquo;sir&equo;; their memory bank never quite matches their aspirations. 
 They've spent years doing this sort of thing, now they've decided that they want to do it for a living. 
 &bquo;I could run a club like this,&equo; they say in an expansive sort of way, leaning back as they enunciate every word ever so carefully. 
 They lean back until they look as if they are about to fall over, so that they can look around them, and perhaps check who's behind their back. 
 It's a trick they've learned, presumably to keep themselves safe in confined spaces. 
 &bquo;There's nothing to it really,&equo; they say. 
 And for a moment you don't know whether they're talking about this strange bodily posture or running a club. 
 But their philosophy comes pouring out, and you realise that they certainly haven't spent much time thinking about any aspect of their behaviour, or the kind of images they project, let alone strange and isolated postures. 
 &bquo;You just have to be able to identify the good punters,&equo; they say, &bquo;the really big hitters, and be able to talk to them, and that's it basically.&equo; 
 And the bit-on-the-side nods feverishly. 
 &bquo;I know all the big hitters around here. 
 Give me a line-up of blokes I've never met before, and I'll pick out the big hitter for you.&equo; 
 The bit-on-the-side's nods go into overdrive. 
 &bquo;Oh, he knows all the VIPs,&equo; she says, &bquo;and he's even introduced me to some of them. 
 I've met Jack who's got a gold VIP card, who's got that used car lot in Rotherham.&equo; 
 &bquo;And a lot more besides,&equo; adds the big bully. 
 &bquo;And Ken who's got the double glazing firm in Doncaster.&equo; 
 &bquo;And a conservatory business tacked on,&equo; adds grizzle again, &bquo;don't forget the conservatory business &mdash; a bit special is that.&equo; 
 &bquo;He knows them all,&equo; she says adoringly, &bquo;and they all drink shampoo &mdash; nearly every night.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's true,&equo; he says, &bquo;I do know them all. 
 All the shampoo set. 
 Lead me into a room and I could pick them out for you. 
 I've spent a lifetime meeting the right sort of people.&equo; 
 And a lifetime of line-ups by the sound of things, I say in a rather low voice. 
 But he ignores me. 
 &bquo;I'll sort out the big hitter from the two bob millionaires. 
 I haven't been selling snide Rolexes for nothing, you know.&equo; 
 MY MIND returned to the man with the starched cuffs. 
 &bquo;I'm a bit of a disappointment to you,&equo; he said eventually. 
 &bquo;You'd rather I was like Bob Hoskins in The Long Good Friday. 
 That's the kind of image the public have. 
 Either a right heavy, a real bully, or someone very crooked. 
 But it's just not like that. 
 The nightclub and gaming business is run on the same principles as any other business. 
 You're basically selling a product at a fair price. 
 In the case of nightclubs, what you're selling is an environment. 
 It's up to the punters what they use the environment for. 
 &bquo;A successful club has to be busy all the time. 
 You have to get the punters to pack in. 
 What makes them go? 
 In my view, it's the herd instinct. 
 The opera's just the same. 
 You don't go to the opera primarily to hear the music, you go to be bundled together with people similar to yourself, or people that you think you're like. 
 It's the same with nightclubs.&equo; 
 &bquo;But what about the sharks?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;How do you deal with them?&equo; 
 &bquo;The first thing to remember is that 99 per cent of the people you come into contact with are people whom you don't have to worry about at all. 
 There are a few people who are out to cause you any aggravation, whom you have to treat that seriously. 
 The rest are just muppets.&equo; 
 Now I've seen club owners in the movies, and I've listened to their talk in person, but I've never heard anyone using a word like muppet before. 
 But Bob's is a world of black and white: muppet and non-muppet. 
 The small time burglars are muppets, the big time bully boys are muppets, I'm a muppet. 
 In fact, I'm definitely a muppet. 
 I couldn't find the entrance to the restaurant that night for a start, and I spent the first half hour of the evening circling the outside of the building looking for a way in &mdash; in full view of all the diners. 
 I am not the kind of person to be treated seriously, in Bob's jargon. 
 &bquo;But how can you tell muppets from non-muppets?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 Bob looked at me as if only a muppet would ask a question like that. 
 &bquo;Put it this way, I was approached a few months ago by a couple of guys in one of my clubs who said that they wanted to see the gaffer. 
 They came straight out with it: they wanted to supply all the spirits for the club &mdash; at very reasonable prices. 
 I said that I couldn't fault their prices, but asked what would happen if I didn't pay. 
 They just said &bquo;Oh you'll pay, don't worry about that.&equo; 
 I said, &bquo;How many times?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, just the once.&equo; 
 These were guys you had to take seriously.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not muppets,&equo; I added helpfully. 
 &bquo;Definitely not muppets,&equo; said Bob. 
 &bquo;It was their manner that told me they had to be taken seriously. 
 Not all flash and threats. 
 Very quiet, a bit understated.&equo; 
 &bquo;A bit like yourself,&equo; I added. 
 Bob wasn't sure whether this was a compliment or not, but continued regardless. 
 &bquo;The only way of dealing with that sort of thing is not to get involved at all. 
 Not even a little bit &mdash; no matter how tempting it seems.&equo; 
 It was now time for the fillet of local fallow deer served pink, with spiced red cabbage and glazed walnuts. 
 Bob seemed relieved that there was no steak on the menu. 
 He seemed to be loosening up, only tensing slightly when he noticed the no smoking sign again. 
 &bquo;Two weeks ago we had a couple of so-called businessmen in the club, with their minder and the Roller parked down below. 
 Now they were muppets. 
 It was very late &mdash; after closing time, about 3am, and they came right out with it: &bquo;How would you fancy having a quarter of a million quid?&equo; 
 &bquo;I told them I wasn't interested, so it went up to half a million. 
 This guy just said, &bquo;I can bring it here first thing in the morning in a carrier bag, and don't be clever by saying that you don't want it.&equo; 
 So I said, &bquo;Look, I just don't want it,&equo; so he tells me not to be so clever. 
 He thought that I was trying to provoke him. 
 &bquo;You're just trying to be clever, and that's not too clever in itself, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;I told them that they were barred from the club from now on. 
 The secret is not to get involved. 
 There are too many club owners who think that they can play it both ways. 
 Some think that they can steal what the club makes, but it's still thieving, even if it's thieving from yourself. 
 You've still got bills to pay. 
 &bquo;Of course, incidents like this do put your blood pressure up. 
 And it just so happens that I mentioned to one of my doormen that particular night that I could do with one of those machines to keep a careful check on my blood pressure. 
 So he turned up with one the following day. 
 Don't ask me where he got it from. 
 We had a bit of a play about with it. 
 The only problem was that we nearly had a few fatalities. 
 After a day's work, it was a bit of light relief to use it. 
 There was no shortage of volunteers or helpers. 
 But it can be a bit dangerous if you've had a few drinks, because you keep pumping the thing up and forgetting about it.&equo; 
 At this stage in the evening I started to sweat. 
 It might have been the stories about businessmen roaming the streets with half a million pounds in carrier bags. 
 It might have been the stories about the blood pressure of inebriate volunteers being measured at 3am in the morning. 
 It might have been the blazing fire in the corner of this very upmarket restaurant. 
 Bob was not sweating at all. 
 &bquo;You know you could stop that if you'd any self-control,&equo; said Bob, noticing my state. 
 &bquo;Just pull yourself together. 
 Just tell yourself that you're cold.&equo; 
 I did, but nothing happened. 
 Beads of sweat continued to form and drip on to the table. 
 I noticed that the women with the scraggy necks were all sweating; so were the men in the red ties with the tight collars on their shirts. 
 Bob alone was cool. 
 He seemed to be freezing, in fact. 
 The fact that I had so little self-control seemed to be irritating him ever so slightly. 
 &bquo;I've met so-called intelligent people before,&equo; he said in a challenging way, &bquo;and I know a lot of questions that can baffle them.&equo; 
 He was staring right at me. 
 &bquo;OK, let's start with this one &mdash; what's the square root of minus 16?&equo; 
 He leaned back. 
 Bob was used to testing people, his whole life revolved around it. 
 Now it was my turn. 
 Unfortunately, the question seemed to me something of a nonsense, as it involved the square root of a minus quantity. 
 But was that the test? 
 To see how I would handle a bit of academic incompetence? 
 Was he trying to determine if I would correct him? 
 Or, heaven forbid, ridicule him? 
 I played it straight &mdash; instinctively, intuitively, without thinking &mdash; like a muppet. 
 &bquo;The square root of minus 16 doesn't exist,&equo; I replied, remembering my school mathematics. 
 &bquo;Any number squared gives you a positive number.&equo; 
 A look of glee swept across Bob's face. 
 He leaned back in his chair ever so slowly. 
 I had certainly failed the test at some level, whatever the test was. 
 It was the first time that night Bob had displayed any real emotion. 
 His eyes sparkled. 
 &bquo;That's where you're wrong, you see. 
 That one always get you so-called intelligent people. 
 The square root of minus 16 is J4. 
 Don't ask me how it's done, but that's the correct answer. 
 And don't argue with me. 
 It's part of a circle or something. 
 What's important is getting the right answer in the end, even if you don't understand how it's done.&equo; 
 I replied the same thing could be said about running a successful club, but Bob was off, back into the night. 
 &copy; Geoffrey Beattie. 
 Geoffrey Beatie: &bquo;I'm a muppet. 
 I'm definitely a muppet&equo; OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE gr1 
 &bquo;Stoke&equo; don St Michael's armour Jeremy Alexander recounts the exploits of Basingstoke, who do battle with Torquay United in the FA Cup on Saturday. 
 BASINGSTOKE's emblem has St Michael standing, with sword and long cross gules, over a dragon. 
 On Monday the football club were cast as dragon in a Hampshire Senior Cup match against Netley. 
 The dragon won. 
 On Saturday Basingstoke don the armour of St Michael as they take on Torquay at home in the second round of the FA Cup. 
 This, like most of Basingstoke itself, is new territory. 
 In the Sixties, said the lady at the museum, the old town was gutted. 
 Now the new town is being revamped. 
 From a distance it looks like Detroit. 
 Close up it is. 
 It is all ring roads, roundabouts and relocated offices. 
 &bquo;We are in the hi-tech corridor between the M3 and M4,&equo; said the lady, dishing out brochures proclaiming as advantages the town's high-speed escapes to Birmingham, Liverpool, anywhere. 
 And the club could be 90 minutes from Anfield, quicker than InterCity. 
 The way their luck has run in this year's competition it is no idle dream. 
 They have come through five rounds already, enough to take a First Division side to Wembley. 
 In their first match, at home to Bashley, they equalised in the 88th minute. 
 In the replay they left it to the 90th and won in extra-time. 
 Having disposed of Chertsey and Witney, they did much the same in the fourth qualifying round against Marlow, equalising at home in the 82nd minute and winning the replay 2-1 with a goal in the 90th. 
 Someone, possibly all angels, is smiling on them. 
 In the last round they won 3-0 at home to Bromsgrove of the Beazer Homes League. 
 Basingstoke moved from the Beazer to the Premier Division of the Vauxhall League in 1987. 
 They went straight down, came straight up again and, going into their third successive season in a different division from the one before, hardly knew where they were. 
 Visitors to the town know the feeling. 
 Currently the club lie eighth with matches in hand. 
 After Bromsgrove they lost three games in a row, so it was important to get back to winning, against St Albans last Saturday then Netley 3-0. 
 Whatever happens on Saturday there will be plenty to keep the interest afterwards. 
 As their manager Trevor Williams says: &bquo;We can really enjoy this tie.&equo; 
 They all say that, of course, and so they should &mdash; nothing to lose&hellip; except a dream. 
 Williams is in his first full season at the club. 
 He coached Fareham, then managed Gosport before arriving at Basingstoke for the last three games of last season. 
 After 10 days and three predictable victories they were promoted, thanks to Woking dropping a point. 
 He was named Manager of the Month. 
 If they win on Saturday it may be the freedom of the town. 
 Williams, grizzle-chinned and chirpy, teaches PE at Millbrook Community School, Southampton. 
 When he was at Cardiff College of PE he used to get Gareth Edwards to play. 
 Before that he had been at Lewis School, Pengam, when Neil Kinnock was house prefect. 
 It was all rugby there and Williams played fly-half for the school. 
 But a teacher, who had a contact at Cardiff City, got him a trial and before long he was representing Wales Under-18 against England at Elland Road, alongside John Toshack and marked by David Nish. 
 He remembers the school assembly when the honour was announced. 
 The headmaster was furious. 
 The boys chanted: &bquo;We want soccer.&equo; 
 Williams won amateur caps and once, with Hitchin in 1974, reached this same round of the Cup. 
 They lost to Boston United, who then held Derby to a draw. 
 He knows these chances do not come often. 
 Basingstoke once reached the first round, in 1971. 
 They lost 5-1 at home to Northampton. 
 Some of the fans remember it, their memory jogged by the 3p programme which the club reproduced for the last round against Bromsgrove. 
 &bquo;There was that Large, &bquo;e got two. 
 And Dixie McNeil. 
 I think &bquo;e scored.&equo; 
 There was also Phil Neal, later of Liverpool and England, wearing No.8. 
 The supporters fall into two categories, those who sound like John Arlott and those who are almost too young to have heard of him. 
 Together they number some 500, though the social club has had to call a halt on membership at 2,000 and has a turnover of &pound;2 &frac12; million. 
 For Bromsgrove the attendance was 2,361. 
 For Saturday the police have set a limit of 4,500. 
 Many junior matches have been postponed. 
 Television cameras will be there. 
 Even a full house would be piffling for a town with so vast a drawing area. 
 Forty years ago the population was under 20,000 but now it is seven times that. 
 The station on Saturday morning shows why. 
 It is thronged with the scarves of London clubs. 
 Offices may have been relocated, but not allegiances. 
 The big companies surely miss a chance by doing nothing for the club. 
 Most of the players are sponsored by individuals, garment by garment. 
 One, thanks to the groundsman, is kitted out by a pigeon club. 
 Fortunately the ground comes cheap, leased from the patron Lord Camrose on a peppercorn rent. 
 The club moved there in 1954. 
 It is cornered by a housing estate and has a 2ft slope at one end, nothing in Yeovil but a home advantage. 
 The programmes come easily, too. 
 The chairman, Gordon Hill, is a director of the Basingstoke Press. 
 On Monday night he rang from his car for the score. 
 It was 2-0 then. 
 Each came from a long cross by Jamie Webb. 
 Each was a hi-tech header from Nigel Mottashed, moving through the central corridor. 
 Basingstoke is noted for precision instruments. 
 Mottashed, the regulation fireman, is one of four players Williams brought from Gosport. 
 The others are Russell Davies (carpenter), Steve Greenwood (car salesman) and Steve Ingman (sheet-metal worker and central defender), who is fighting a hamstring injury. 
 Three of the team, Webb, Barry Blankley (full-back) and Leroy Whale (12 goals this season), have been on Southampton's books. 
 Brian O'Donnell played for Bournemouth and Torquay. 
 The heroes of the last round were perhaps Paul Clarkson and John Simpkins, the goalkeeper. 
 Simpkins, a double-glazing fitter who travels from the Isle of Wight, played on despite early injury. 
 Clarkson, a quality control inspector, scored two. 
 He will not worry about the quality if he does half as much on Saturday. 
 Tonight they have their final training session as usual, no doubt perfecting the set-pieces from which many of their goals stem. 
 They have a motto, abbreviated from the Epistles of Horace: &bquo;Vestigia nulla retrorsum&equo; &mdash; no footprints in reverse. 
 It refers to the fable of the sick lion and the wary fox, who is frightened at seeing all the footprints pointing towards the den and none the other way. 
 Torquay United are warned. 
 BASINGSTOKE's emblem has St Michael standing, with sword and long cross gules, over a dragon. 
 On Monday the football club were cast as dragon in a Hampshire Senior Cup match against Netley. 
 The dragon won. 
 On Saturday Basingstoke don the armour of St Michael as they take on Torquay at home in the second round of the FA Cup. 
 This, like most of Basingstoke itself, is new territory. 
 In the Sixties, said the lady at the museum, the old town was gutted. 
 Now the new town is being revamped. 
 From a distance it looks like Detroit. 
 Close up it is. 
 It is all ring roads, roundabouts and relocated offices. 
 &bquo;We are in the hi-tech corridor between the M3 and M4,&equo; said the lady, dishing out brochures proclaiming as advantages the town's high-speed escapes to Birmingham, Liverpool, anywhere. 
 And the club could be 90 minutes from Anfield, quicker than InterCity. 
 The way their luck has run in this year's competition it is no idle dream. 
 They have come through five rounds already, enough to take a First Division side to Wembley. 
 In their first match, at home to Bashley, they equalised in the 88th minute. 
 In the replay they left it to the 90th and won in extra-time. 
 Having disposed of Chertsey and Witney, they did much the same in the fourth qualifying round against Marlow, equalising at home in the 82nd minute and winning the replay 2-1 with a goal in the 90th. 
 Someone, possibly all angels, is smiling on them. 
 In the last round they won 3-0 at home to Bromsgrove of the Beazer Homes League. 
 Basingstoke moved from the Beazer to the Premier Division of the Vauxhall League in 1987. 
 They went straight down, came straight up again and, going into their third successive season in a different division from the one before, hardly knew where they were. 
 Visitors to the town know the feeling. 
 Currently the club lie eighth with matches in hand. 
 After Bromsgrove they lost three games in a row, so it was important to get back to winning, against St Albans last Saturday, then Netley 3-0. 
 Whatever happens on Saturday there will be plenty to keep the interest afterwards. 
 As their manager Trevor Williams says: &bquo;We can really enjoy this tie.&equo; 
 They all say that, of course, and so they should &mdash; nothing to lose&hellip; except a dream. 
 Williams is in his first full season at the club. 
 He coached Fareham, then managed Gosport before arriving at Basingstoke for the last three games of last season. 
 After 10 days and three predictable victories they were promoted, thanks to Woking dropping a point. 
 He was named Manager of the Month. 
 If they win on Saturday it may be the freedom of the town. 
 Williams, grizzle-chinned and chirpy, teaches PE at Millbrook Community School, Southampton. 
 When he was at Cardiff College of PE he used to get Gareth Edwards to play. 
 Before that he had been at Lewis School, Pengam, when Neil Kinnock was house prefect. 
 It was all rugby there and Williams played fly-half for the school. 
 But a teacher, who had a contact at Cardiff City, got him a trial and before long he was representing Wales Under-18 against England at Elland Road, alongside John Toshack and marked by David Nish. 
 He remembers the school assembly when the honour was announced. 
 The headmaster was furious. 
 The boys chanted: &bquo;We want soccer.&equo; 
 Williams won amateur caps and once, with Hitchin in 1974, reached this same round of the Cup. 
 They lost to Boston United, who then held Derby to a draw. 
 He knows these chances do not come often. 
 Basingstoke once reached the first round, in 1971. 
 They lost 5-1 at home to Northampton. 
 Some of the fans remember it, their memory jogged by the 3p programme which the club reproduced for the last round against Bromsgrove. 
 &bquo;There was that Large, &bquo;e got two. 
 And Dixie McNeil. 
 I think &bquo;e scored.&equo; 
 There was also Phil Neal, later of Liverpool and England, wearing No.8. 
 The supporters fall into two categories, those who sound like John Arlott and those who are almost too young to have heard of him. 
 Together they number some 500, though the social club has had to call a halt on membership at 2,000 and has a turnover of &pound;2 &frac12; million. 
 For Bromsgrove the attendance was 2,361. 
 For Saturday the police have set a limit of 4,500. 
 Many junior matches have been postponed. 
 Television cameras will be there. 
 Even a full house would be piffling for a town with so vast a drawing area. 
 Forty years ago the population was under 20,000 but now it is seven times that. 
 The station on Saturday morning shows why. 
 It is thronged with the scarves of London clubs. 
 Offices may have been relocated, but not allegiances. 
 The big companies surely miss a chance by doing nothing for the club. 
 Most of the players are sponsored by individuals, garment by garment. 
 One, thanks to the groundsman, is kitted out by a pigeon club. 
 Fortunately the ground comes cheap, leased from the patron Lord Camrose on a peppercorn rent. 
 The club moved there in 1954. 
 It is cornered by a housing estate and has a 2ft slope at one end, nothing in Yeovil but a home advantage. 
 The programmes come easily, too. 
 The chairman, Gordon Hill, is a director of the Basingstoke Press. 
 On Monday he rang from his car for the score. 
 It was 2-0 then. 
 Each came from a long cross (not gules but or) by Jamie Webb. 
 Each was a hi-tech header from Nigel Mottashed, moving through the central corridor. 
 Basingstoke is noted for precision instruments. 
 Mottashed, the regulation fireman, is one of four players Williams brought from Gosport. 
 The others are Russell Davies (carpenter), Steve Greenwood (car salesman) and Steve Ingman (sheet-metal worker and central defender), who is fighting a hamstring injury. 
 Three of the team, Webb, Barry Blankley (full-back) and Leroy Whale (12 goals this season), have been on Southampton's books. 
 Brian O'Donnell played for Bournemouth and Torquay. 
 The heroes of the last round were perhaps Paul Clarkson and John Simpkins, the goalkeeper. 
 Simpkins, a double-glazing fitter who travels from the Isle of Wight, played on despite early injury. 
 Clarkson, a quality control inspector, scored two. 
 He will not worry about the quality if he does half as much on Saturday. 
 Tonight they have their final training session as usual, no doubt perfecting the set-pieces from which many of their goals stem. 
 They have a motto, abbreviated from the Epistles of Horace: &bquo;Vestigia nulla retrorsum&equo; &mdash; no footprints in reverse. 
 It refers to the fable of the sick lion and the wary fox, who is frightened at seeing all the footprints pointing towards the den and none the other way. 
 Torquay United are warned. 
 Motor Racing Brabham for quick sale. 
 THE British-based Brabham team are up for sale because a company run by its owner Joachim Luhti is bankrupt, his lawyer said. 
 &bquo;I am empowered to sell Brabham,&equo; the lawyer, Beat Widmer, said. 
 He declined to specify the Formula One team's ownership structure, quote a price or nominate prospective buyers &mdash; though, as reported in Tuesday's Guardian, there is speculation that the team will be taken over by people who want to field an all-Italian line-up, with Emanuele Pirro displacing Britain's Martin Brundle and joining Stefano Modeno. 
 Luhti was arrested in August and is now in investigative custody on suspicion of embezzlement through his Swiss Adiuva Finanz AG investment company, declared bankrupt a week ago. 
 Swiss authorities are probing the alleged misappropriation of about &pound;60 million of investors' funds. 
 Widmer said he hoped to sell Brabham, founded in 1962 by the Australian triple world champion driver Jack Brabham, by the end of the year. 
 Luhti bought the team this year from the Swiss slot-machine magnate Walter Brun, who had bought it from Bernie Ecclestone, the head of the Formula One Constructors' Association (Foca). 
 The Brabham team won world constructors' championships in 1966 and 1967. 
 Their last world drivers' champion was the Brazilian Nelson Piquet in 1983. 
 The team finished equal eighth in this year's Formula One constructors' championship with eight points. 
 By Stephen Bierley 
 IT WAS after the Manchester City board appointed John Benson as manager in 1983 that Peter Swales, the chairman, announced: &bquo;It was a unanimous choice &mdash; which is unusual for us.&equo; 
 The unusual, to say nothing of the bizarre, seems always to lurk close by the main door of Maine Road. 
 Yet yesterday's appointment of Howard Kendall as manager seems, on the face of it, one of the most rational and sensible moves the Blues have made in recent years. 
 Kendall, aged 43, was City's initial choice after Mel Machin had been sacked, but discussions broke down when the former Everton and Athletic Bilbao manager insisted on a release clause in his contract should he be approached by England. 
 City then tried for Kendall's former Everton team-mate Joe Royle, the Oldham manager. 
 Royle refused, so City and Swales, having dug themselves a large hole, returned to Kendall and agreed to his terms. 
 The contract is for three years, with the annual salary thought to be &pound;130,000. 
 But should England do badly in Italy next summer, leading to Bobby Robson's resignation or sacking, Kendall might find his shoulder touched by those at Lancaster Gate in preference, say, to Graham Taylor or Terry Venables. 
 In this respect City's sixth manager in nine years might yet become another of their shorter-term employees. 
 Kendall has been in Spain this week but will watch his new club at Southampton on Saturday and take charge on Monday. 
 As fate would have it, his first match in charge will be at Everton a week on Sunday in front of the ITV cameras. 
 City are currently bottom of the First Division and Kendall spoke realistically about the task ahead. 
 &bquo;Obviously I would like to be as successful as I was at Everton,&equo; he said, &bquo;but you cannot do that in five minutes. 
 &bquo;It's no good talking about potential. 
 The most important thing is that next season Manchester City are in the First Division.&equo; 
 Swales has promised Kendall &bquo;the tools to do that&equo;. 
 Money is available for new players and he has a free hand to change the backroom staff. 
 If Kendall takes up that offer, he may appoint the former England midfielder Peter Reid, currently at QPR, as his player-coach. 
 The backroom staff might also include the former City stalwart Paul Power, who finished his First Division career at Everton after being signed by Kendall. 
 Tony Book, after his brief caretakership, will probably also stay. 
 Once Royle had turned City down, Swales and his board had little option but to agree to Kendall's terms. 
 The chairman said yesterday: &bquo;I sat down on Sunday and thought &bquo;I must be mad not to go for Kendall&equo; and I revived the deal on Monday.&equo; 
 The club badly need a manager of quality and stature and only two current First Division managers have an equal or better success rate, Liverpool's Kenny Dalglish and Brian Clough at Nottingham Forest. 
 City were no doubt further spurred by the discord at Old Trafford, where Alex Ferguson's future is uncertain. 
 Kendall has frequently mentioned United in his musings, so City had no time to waste. 
 It was in 1981 that Kendall left Blackburn to become Everton's eighth manager since 1946. 
 He is no City's 17th in the same timespan. 
 But he was not, their fans should note, an immediate success. 
 In 1981 Everton were haunted by Liverpool. 
 At least he will have no United ghost on his shoulder, although Ferguson's team is insubstantial enough. 
 Kendall was never afraid to spend money, signing Adrian Heath for a then club record of &pound;800,000 from Stoke, but many of his best buys came from the lower divisions: Neville Southall from Bury, Derek Mountfield from Tranmere and Bolton's Peter Reid. 
 City last won the championship in 1968 and the FA Cup in 1969, those champagne days of Mercer and Allison. 
 Book was the last manager to bring a senior trophy to Maine Road, the League Cup in 1976. 
 Born: Ryton-on-Tyne, May 22, 1946. 
 Playing career: Preston, Everton, Birmingham, Stoke, Blackburn. 
 Honours: League championship (Everton) 1969-70; FA Cup finalist 1964 (Preston); six England Under-23 caps. 
 Managerial career: Blackburn (1979-81), Everton (1981-87), Athletic Bilbao (1987-89). 
 Honours: (Blackburn) Promotion to First Division 1980. 
 (Everton): League champions 1985 and 1987; FA Cup Winners 1984; European Cup-Winners' Cup 1985. 
 Manager of the Year 1985 and 1987. 
 PAGE 
 Soccer Kendall gets his England clause and Swales gets his man. 
 By Stephen Bierley 
 IT WAS after the Manchester City board appointed John Benson as manager in 1983 that Peter Swales, the chairman, announced: &bquo;It was a unanimous choice &mdash; which is unusual for us.&equo; 
 The unusual, to say nothing of the bizarre, seems always to lurk close by the main door of Maine Road. 
 Yet yesterday's appointment of Howard Kendall as manager seems, on the face of it, one of the most rational and sensible moves the Blues have made in recent years. 
 Kendall, aged 43, was City's initial choice after Mel Machin had been sacked, but discussions broke down when the former Everton and Athletic Bilbao manager insisted on a release clause in his contract should he be approached by England. 
 City then tried for Kendall's former Everton team-mate Joe Royle, the Oldham manager. 
 Royle refused, so City and Swales, having dug themselves a large hole, returned to Kendall and agreed to his terms. 
 The contract is for three years, with the annual salary thought to be &pound;130,000. 
 But should England do badly in Italy next summer, leading to Bobby Robson's resignation or sacking, Kendall might find his shoulder touched by those at Lancaster Gate in preference, say, to Graham Taylor or Terry Venables. 
 In this respect City's sixth manager in nine years might yet become another of their shorter-term employees. 
 Kendall has been in Spain this week but will watch his new club at Southampton on Saturday and take charge on Monday. 
 As fate would have it, his first match in charge will be at Everton a week on Sunday in front of the ITV cameras. 
 City are currently bottom of the First Division and Kendall spoke realistically about the task ahead. 
 &bquo;Obviously I would like to be as successful as I was at Everton,&equo; he said, &bquo;but you cannot do that in five minutes. 
 &bquo;It's no good talking about potential. 
 The most important thing is that next season Manchester City are in the First Division.&equo; 
 Swales has promised Kendall &bquo;the tools to do that&equo;. 
 Money is available for new players and he has a free hand to change the backroom staff. 
 If Kendall takes up that offer, he may appoint the former England midfielder Peter Reid, currently at QPR, as his player-coach. 
 The backroom staff might also include the former City stalwart Paul Power, who finished his First Division career at Everton after being signed by Kendall. 
 Tony Book, after his brief caretakership, will probably also stay. 
 Once Royle had turned City down, Swales and his board had little option but to agree to Kendall's terms. 
 The chairman said yesterday: &bquo;I sat down on Sunday and thought &bquo;I must be mad not to go for Kendall&equo; and I revived the deal on Monday.&equo; 
 The club badly need a manager of quality and stature and only two current First Division managers have an equal or better success rate, Liverpool's Kenny Dalglish and Brian Clough at Nottingham Forest. 
 City were no doubt further spurred by the discord at Old Trafford, where Alex Ferguson's future is uncertain. 
 Kendall has frequently mentioned United in his musings, so City had no time to waste. 
 It was in 1981 that Kendall left Blackburn to become Everton's eighth manager since 1946. 
 He is now City's 17th in the same timespan. 
 But he was not, their fans should note, an immediate success. 
 In 1981 Everton were haunted by Liverpool. 
 At least he will have no United ghost on his shoulder, although Ferguson's team is insubstantial enough. 
 Kendall was never afraid to spend money, signing Adrian Heath for a then club record of &pound;800,000 from Stoke, but many of his best buys came from the lower divisions: Neville Southall from Bury, Derek Mountfield from Tranmere and Bolton's Peter Reid. 
 City last won the championship in 1968 and the FA Cup in 1969, those champagne days of Mercer and Allison. 
 Book was the last manager to bring a senior trophy to Maine Road, the League Cup in 1976. 
 Born: Ryton-on-Tyne, May 22, 1946. 
 Playing career: Preston, Everton, Birmingham, Stoke, Blackburn. 
 Honours: League championship (Everton) 1969-70; FA Cup finalist 1964 (Preston); six England Under-23 caps. 
 Managerial career: Blackburn (1979-81), Everton (1981-87), Athletic Bilbao (1987-89). 
 Honours: (Blackburn) Promotion to First Division 1980. 
 (Everton): League champions 1985 and 1987; FA Cup Winners 1984; European Cup-Winners' Cup 1985. 
 Manager of the Year 1985 and 1987. 
 By Mike Selvey 
 FRANK CHAMBERLAIN, the 64-year-old chairman of Northamptonshire, is to become the next chairman of the Test and County Cricket Board, succeeding Raman Subba Row who steps down next October. 
 At the TCCB winter meeting at Lord's yesterday, the chairmen and chief executives of the 17 first-class counties opted for Chamberlain rather than the only other candidate, Don Perry, the Gloucestershire chairman, and although no one was giving very much away at Lord's yesterday Chamberlain's majority, like that elsewhere the previous day, was believed to be substantial. 
 So a man who has hitherto led a quiet life, in terms of cricket administration, finds himself thrust into the forefront of the game's politics. 
 He must need his head testing. 
 Chamberlain's experience of first-class cricket is slim, confined to six matches for Northants shortly after the war. 
 Instead his working life has been devoted, as one might expect from that neck of the woods, to the shoe trade, helping build up the family firm into a multinational concern. 
 He is also on the board of a number of City companies, and for his sins is a former Master of the Worshipful Company of Pattenmakers. 
 He has been chairman of Northants since 1985, the year Subba Row took over his role at the TCCB, and has served on the board's finance comittee. 
 Subba Row, who will not have had a hand in this particular decision, sees him as a &bquo;good scout&equo;. 
 He will certainly need to be well prepared for the task which faces him, with international cricket politics becoming increasingly complex. 
 On the home front his business experiences should stand him in more than good stead: cobblers is the stock-in-trade of most cricket committees. 
 PAGE 
 Sheffield strengthen their hand by signing two New Zealand forwards. 
 SHEFFIELD EAGLES showed their enterprise again yesterday when they signed two forwards from New Zealand's recent tour, Francis Leota and Tawere Nikau, writes Paul Fitzpatrick. 
 Leota, more than 15 stone but a fast, mobile, strong second-row forward, and Nikau, a 22-year-old 6ft 1in loose forward, will fill the vacancies left by Bruce McGuire and Jeff Hardy when the Australians return home in January. 
 Both are members of the Otahuhu club in Auckland. 
 Gary Hetherington, Eagles' chairman and coach, said they maintain the club's tradition for signing young, skilful, enthusiastic players. 
 Leota, aged 25, was an exciting member of the party though his Test contribution was restricted to an appearance as substitute. 
 His contract runs until March 1991. 
 Nikau will remain until the end of the season with the option of staying for another. 
 St Helens have given another Kiwi, Teo Ropati (knee injury), until next Thursday to prove his fitness. 
 Squash Harassed Harris. 
 By Richard Jago 
 THE national championships begin in Newcastle today with Martine Le Moignan, the world champion, and Del Harris, the England No.1, defending their British titles in far less confident mood than would have been the case a few months ago. 
 On Monday Le Moignan was beaten by her old adversary Lisa Opie, and Harris lost to Paul Gregory, his closest friend on the circuit, two weeks ago. 
 Both have been suffering from a surfeit of squash, according to the man who manages them, Norman Norrington. 
 After eight years of competitive play, Harris is confronted by &bquo;a very serious&equo; career crisis, says Norrington, but another failure in the national championships would be a devastating blow to the 20-year-old's season and to his chances of making the top handful in the world in seasons to come. 
 He is seeded to meet Gregory in Monday's semi-finals. 
 Le Moignan has talked about retiring in two years' time, but that could be hastened if there were another loss to Opie, who has made a determined comeback after defeats in the world and British opens. 
 A more carefully prepared training programme and an easier tournament schedule have helped the world No.2 to win three important tournaments in recent months, whereas Le Moignan appears to have been struggling with her motivation. 
 Yet the world champion is so unpredictably gifted that one on-song display could easily enable her to sweep aside the opposition. 
 The two old adversaries are seeded to meet in Tuesday's final. 
 Livesey kicks his way into South-West side. 
 MARTIN LIVESEY, the Richmond fly-half, will make his first appearance for the South-West in the Toshiba Divisional Championship match against the holders, London, at Imber Court on Saturday, writes Robert Armstrong. 
 Livesey, who replaces Mike Hamlin of Gloucester, has been drafted in to give the West Countrymen greater control at half-back after their 21-9 defeat by the North in Bristol last Saturday. 
 The South-West, who beat London last year, have made a total of three changes, choosing the Plymouth wing Steve Walklin instead of Peter Blackett of Bath, and bringing in the Bath lock Nigel Redman in place of his club-mate John Morrison. 
 Mike Teague, the Lions flanker, will continue his representative comeback with his second divisional appearance this season. 
 Livesey, of Plymouth, is the third-top scorer in English rugby this season with a total of 140 points, all but four of them from his prolific goalkicking. 
 Last season he was Richmond's top scorer with 182 points. 
 London, who retain the side that defeated the Midlands last weekend, are favourites to clinch the title they won for the first time last year. 
 SOUTH AND SOUTH-WEST: J Webb (Bristol); J Fallon (Richmond), S Halliday (Bath), A Adebayo (Bath), S Walklin (Plymouth); M Livesey (Richmond), R Hill (Bath); A Sharpe (Bristol), K Dunn (Gloucester), R Pascall (Gloucester), N Redman (Bath), J Etheridge (Gloucester), M Teague (Gloucester), D Sims (Gloucester), A Robinson (Bath). 
 Replacements: J Callard (Bath), M Hannaford (Gloucester), M Hamlin (Gloucester), G Mann (Bristol), P Jones (Gloucester), S Newman (Harlequins). 
 Sean Robinson, Middlesex's full-back, scored two tries in the final five minutes to give them victory over Hertfordshire by one point, 22-21, in the Toshiba County Championship at Croxley Green to go into the London play-off. 
 Allan Martin, sacked as coach to Aberavon's forwards this week, believes that Welsh rugby is becoming too much like football with the current spate of hiring and firing based on league results. 
 &bquo;All the club is worried about is finishing in the top half of the Merit Table so they will be in the top division when leagues start next season,&equo; he said. 
 Livesey kicks his way into South-West side 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 CONTRARY to predictions, Malcolm Reilly was not installed as Great Britain's coach yesterday. 
 Although he seems sure to remain in the job, the delay has invited speculation. 
 In a terse statement the board of directors said it had &bquo;considered the Great Britain management set-up and individual talks will take place over the next few days before a formal announcement is made&equo;. 
 This could mean that the board and Reilly still have some bargaining to do before the contract is signed. 
 It could also indicate that there is uncertainty about Reilly's support team, which consists principally of Les Bettinson, the manager, and Phil Larder, the national director of coaching. 
 These three have worked together harmoniously and with some notable successes since Reilly took charge early in 1987 and it is certain that he would want them alongside him again for the hard year ahead, in which Great Britain play 10 Tests, including three World Cup games. 
 It could also be that Reilly, who has never knowingly sold himself short, is driving a hard bargain. 
 He knows that he has no serious rival for the job. 
 The board meanwhile has tried to dissuade players from choosing a contract with an Australian club over a place on the tour of Papua New Guinea and New Zealand next summer. 
 Any players pursuing such action, it says, will not be given clearance to play abroad. 
 A long-standing by-law has been invoked to support the stance of the board. 
 Bob Ashby, the chairman, said that international football was considered to be of paramount importance to the status of Rugby League and that selection for Great Britain must not be devalued. 
 Great Britain, he said, had emerged as a force once more after their victory over Australia in Sydney last year and their recent wins over New Zealand, and next summer's tour was a vital preparation for the visit of the Australians in the autumn of 1990. 
 &bquo;The board are extending a long-standing by-law which prevents a player who has rejected an international invitation from performing at club level during the summer period,&equo; said Ashby. 
 But can the Rugby League make it stick? 
 The spectre of restraint of trade rears its ugly head. 
 The issue is far from closed. 
 GB learn what coach Reilly wants. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 CONTRARY to predictions, Malcolm Reilly was not installed as Great Britain's coach yesterday. 
 Although he seems sure to remain in the job, the delay has invited speculation. 
 In a terse statement the board of directors said it had &bquo;considered the Great Britain management set-up and individual talks will take place over the next few days before a formal announcement is made&equo;. 
 This could mean that the board and Reilly still have some bargaining to do before the contract is signed. 
 It could also indicate that there is uncertainty about Reilly's support team, which consists principally of Les Bettinson, the manager, and Phil Larder, the national director of coaching. 
 These three have worked together harmoniously and with some notable successes since Reilly took charge early in 1987 and it is certain that he would want them alongside him again for the hard year ahead, in which Great Britain play 10 Tests, including three World Cup games. 
 It could also be that Reilly, who has never knowingly sold himself short, is driving a hard bargain. 
 He knows that he has no serious rival for the job. 
 The board meanwhile has tried to dissuade players from choosing a contract with an Australian club over a place on the tour of Papua New Guinea and New Zealand next summer. 
 Any players pursuing such action, it says, will not be given clearance to play abroad. 
 A long-standing by-law has been invoked to support the stance of the board. 
 Bob Ashby, the chairman, said that international football was considered to be of paramount importance to the status of Rugby League and that selection for Great Britain must not be devalued. 
 Great Britain, he said, had emerged as a force once more after their victory over Australia in Sydney last year and their recent wins over New Zealand, and next summer's tour was a vital preparation for the visit of the Australians in the autumn of 1990. 
 &bquo;The board are extending a long-standing by-law which prevents a player who has rejected an international invitation from performing at club level during the summer period,&equo; said Ashby. 
 But can the Rugby League make it stick? 
 The spectre of restraint of trade rears its ugly head. 
 The issue is far from closed. 
 JIM COURIER and Pete Sampras (top) lost their opening round-robin match against Darren Cahill and Mark Kratzman in the eight-team Nabisco Masters doubles championship at the Royal Albert Hall yesterday, but they are tipped to make an impact on the doubles game, writes Martin James. 
 As juniors the two American teenagers were mentioned in the same breath as Andre Agassi and Michael Chang as singles players, but neither has made quite the same impact as yet. 
 Sampras will finish the year in 81st place, Courier a more respectable 24th, but in doubles they have eclipsed their more renowned contemporaries and deserved to qualify for the Masters when Ken Flach and Robert Seguso were forced to withdraw at the last minute. 
 &bquo;We play doubles because we feel it will help us to become more complete players,&equo; said the 19-year-old Courier, who comes from the same stable as Agassi and has a similar big-hitting baseline game but a much more diplomatic air about him. 
 Sampras, 18, is equally controlled but in contrast is a serve-and-volley player. 
 He too believes his singles game can improve by playing doubles, and added: &bquo;It has also brought us closer together as friends. 
 It is nice to have someone else of your own age on the tour. 
 Chang doesn't really talk and Agassi is in a world of his own.&equo; 
 Yesterday Sampras and Courier were almost in a world of their own. 
 There were barely 300 people in the Royal Albert Hall when they opened the morning session against the more experienced Australian pairing of Cahill and Kratzman. 
 &bquo;It's a stunning setting but everyone was so silent it was like playing in a church. 
 There was no buzz. 
 It was like playing a practice match,&equo; said a disappointed Courier after he and his partner were well beaten 6-2, 6-2, 7-6 in their opening red-group match. 
 Clearly they have some way to go but they can still look back on 1989 with a glimmer of pride. 
 In only their second event together they reached the final of the Tournament of Champions in New York, and then captured the Italian Open in Rome. 
 &bquo;They are going to be very good but they need to learn to combine better,&equo; observed Cahill. 
 &bquo;They hit the ball as hard as almost anyone.&equo; 
 Sarah Loosemore beat Jennifer Santrock, ranked 95 places above her, 6-4, 7-6 on the first day of Great Britain's defence of the Maureen Connolly Trophy in Cardiff, but Valda Lake fell apart in the second set against the Australian Open junior champion, Kim Kessaris, losing 1-6, 6-4, 6-2. 
 PHOTOGRAPH: FRANK BARON 
 Racing: Punters in uproar after Bully Boy floors favourites. 
 By Ken Oliver 
 PUNTERS at Huntingdon yesterday were up in arms after Bully Boy, the outsider of three, stormed home by a distance in the Long Sutton Handicap Chase. 
 But victory ran true to racing's adage &bquo;there's nothing like experience&equo; because the winner was ridden by Pat Leech, who has ridden more than 150 winners, while the two market leaders were partnered by riders with less than a handful of winners between them. 
 Roddy Greene, on Market Leader (10-11), and Tom Cloke, on Vaguely Artistic (11-10), were content to sit and wait, while Leech sent Bully Boy into a commanding lead. 
 Bully Boy, who had been backed from 20-1 down to 9-1, was a fence clear by the time the third obstacle was jumped and, despite making a terrible blunder at the fifth, he never looked likely to be challenged. 
 Both Greene and Cloke were jeered as they passed the post and cries of &bquo;cheats&equo; greeted them as they rode their mounts back to the unsaddling enclosure and were hauled before the stewards. 
 Bully Boy's owner, Ron Taylor, who is involved in various interests in Lambourn, admitted to having &bquo;a nice punt&equo; on the six-year-old, who was tackling fences for the first time. 
 &bquo;We knew he wouldn't get caught,&equo; he exclaimed. 
 It was not only trainer Willie Brooks's first winner under National Hunt rules, but his first steeplechase runner. 
 All three jockeys gave evidence to the stewards, who, after hearing from the betting intelligence officer, accepted their explanations and took no further action. 
 So, to the amazement of many racegoers, the two young jockeys escaped without even a caution. 
 But for a young casual Tote employee the incident had a different ending. 
 He foolishly wrote on the results board in the Tote Credit office: &bquo;Was this fixed?&equo; and has been suspended. 
 Leech said that Bully Boy set off very quickly, but he was able to settle the gelding after the first two fences and went on to win unchallenged. 
 Cloke said his instructions on Vaguely Artistic were to sit upsides the favourite, Market Leader, and not to go to the front too quickly. 
 He was not concerned at the early pace set by Bully Boy, but he did become worried at the water jump, where he changed his hands and asked his mount to quicken with hands and heels, as he had dropped his whip. 
 Trainer Geoffrey Hubbard's assistant, Ferdie Murphy, said Vaguely Artistic was ungenuine and he was happy with the riding of the grey. 
 Greene told the inquiry, which was spread over three races, that his instructions were also to sit in behind and monitor Vaguely Artistic. 
 He felt Bully Boy had set out too quickly, but when he asked Market Leader to quicken in the back straight he got no response. 
 Richard Lee, who trains Market Leader, expressed himself happy with Greene's riding and said he felt Market Leader was a moderate animal. 
 Pakistan v India, third Test Shoaib cashes in. 
 SHOAIB MOHAMMAD completed a double century, his first in Tests, before the third Test at Lahore was allowed to subside into the inevitable draw yesterday. 
 Pakistan were 699 for five in reply to India's first innings score of 509 when the game was called off 10 overs into the final hour with Shoaib 203 not out. 
 Pakistan's score was the highest by any side in a Test in Pakistan, surpassing the 561 they made against New Zealand in 1955-56, and the highest in matches between the two countries. 
 Only two wickets fell yesterday, slightly below the game's average of three a day. 
 Krishnamachari Srikkanth, the Indian captain, was mildly critical of the Lahore wicket. 
 It was, he said, &bquo;not in the best interests of cricket&equo;. 
 Javed Miandad and Shoaib, resuming yesterday morning at 416 for three, carried their fourth-wicket stand to 246. 
 Miandad, 84 not out overnight, went on to make 145 in six hours &mdash; his 22nd century in his 100th Test &mdash; before being bowled by Ravi Shastri. 
 He hit a total of 10 fours in his 291-ball innings. 
 Shoaib, 90 not out overnight, reached his double century by hitting Shastri for his 19th four through the midwicket area. 
 He faced 369 balls. 
 Shoaib, whose previous highest Test score was the 163 he notched up against New Zealand at Wellington earlier this year, added 134 for the fifth wicket with his captain, Imran Khan. 
 Imran provided most of the day's highlights with his 66 off 95 balls, including two huge sixes off the left-arm spinner Maninder Singh, but Sanjay Manjrekar will also be able to recall this game with some fondness. 
 He scored 218 runs, won the Man of the Match award and caught Imran while standing in as the understudy wicketkeeper for Kiran More. 
 Shastri was the day's only wicket-taker. 
 Abdul Qadir, who finished unbeaten on 39, became the fourth Pakistani after Intikhab Alam, Imran Khan and Sarfraz Nawaz to achieve a Test double of 1,000 runs and 100 wickets. 
 He passed 1,000 when he reached 24. 
 With the first two Tests of the four-match series also ending in draws, the outcome of the series rests on the last Test match starting at Sialkot on Saturday. 
 Windsor Park for all-weather treble. 
 By Richard Baerlein 
 THIS time last year I struck one of the most unlucky ante-post bets of my whole racing career when taking the 16-1 Ten Plus for the Cheltenham Gold Cup. 
 He was going like a winner when he came to the third from home, fell and broke a leg. 
 With the present favourite, Carvill's Hill, 9-2 for next year's race there is no incentive to back him as he will not run if the ground is firm, while the 5-1 second favourite-last year's winner, Desert Orchid-is unlikely to run in any case. 
 Therefore, there must be value elsewhere and I have been studying the other prices. 
 There is no young chaser with quite the promise of Ten Plus among the unknowns. 
 Desert Orchid's stable companion, Barnbrook Again, will no longer be a 12-1 shot if he wins the King George V1 Chase on Boxing Day. 
 There must be a doubt about such a brilliant two miler staying the distance, but this does not appear to worry his connections. 
 Jenny Pitman has high hopes of the 16-1 chance Golden Freeze developing into a top class performer and he has plenty of scope. 
 He has been given time to develop and in a recent interview on TV the trainer was even talking in terms of a possible Grand National victory. 
 Martin Pipe's soft ground performer, Rusch de Farges, has made a rapid advance in the market, but is the weather ever going to change? 
 Pipe also has the 20-1 shot Bonanza Boy in the race. 
 He is on my short list as a possible Grand National winner. 
 The Thinker, already a winner of the race, stands at 20-1, but he is difficult to train and even more difficult to catch on the right day. 
 I have no doubt that if the ground is in his favour Carvill's Hill will start a good favourite and few will want to oppose him. 
 He did really well as a novice a year ago in some top class races in Ireland and, although he fell at the seventh in last year's Gold Cup, he should be a more mature horse and a better jumper this season. 
 But one must wait until one knows the ground before he can be supported. 
 Backers of favourites should have a profitable afternoon at Lingfield. 
 In particular, Windsor Park, who makes his hurdling debut in the Three Hostages Juvenile Novice Hurdle, should make no mistake. 
 Since he was claimed for &pound;18,000, this gelding, formerly owned by the Queen, has won twice and been second twice on the flat when trained by Roland O'Sullivan. 
 He appears to be something of a Lingfield specialist, having won twice on the all-weather flat track. 
 His inexperience over hurdles should not be a bar to victory here. 
 While Martin Pipe could have a couple of Lingfield winners in Celcius and Lonely Reef, his regular jockey, Peter Scudamore, has been claimed by Charlie Brooks, who hopes to have a double at Uttoxeter with Espy and Roscoe Harvey. 
 While Scudamore can score on Martin Pipe's Galwex Lady in the Burton Rubber Company Hurdle, I doubt if Espy will give 5lb to Rolling Dice, a very promising chasing recruit. 
 She beat Gambling Royale very easily last time out. 
 Boxing Desperate Duran the old favourite. 
 John Rodda in Las Vegas predicts that Ray Leonard will feel the strain of the advancing years more than his rival in tonight's big fight 
 AMID the fortune hunters who throng this city of make-believe, it is a simple step to imagine that tonight's event at The Mirage, the newest and brashest gambling hole on The Strip, is the sporting event of the Eighties. 
 Yet we all might wake up to realise that The Mirage is the most appropriate name for such a venue. 
 Sugar Ray Leonard and Roberto Duran, legends of the ring years before they reached this collision, will reach out and try to mist the reality that they are both beyond their peaks of power and reflex action. 
 Physical decay is setting in at 38 for Duran and 33 for Leonard, yet in the most hazardous of sports they persist, in the fashion of the times, in trying to defy the ageing process. 
 Muhammad Ali, Larry Holmes and soon no doubt George Foreman have shuffled into the ring like men with begging bowls, the clinking coin of television revenues their nursemaid. 
 Tonight's contribution is awesome in the decibels of that noise. 
 Going down a sporting memory lane has enticed some 16 million people to pay their cable-TV charge to watch the fight. 
 Millions more around the world will swell that figure to the largest gross revenue in boxing history, for a contest where both men admit their best days are behind them. 
 It is their third meeting, the first two having taken place within the space of five months in 1980. 
 That June, Duran clamped Leonard's artistry by drawing him into a slugging match in Montreal and inflicting on the American what was to be his only defeat in 37 contests. 
 Leonard avenged that reverse in New Orleans the following November in the notorious &bquo;no mas&equo; night of surrender which has haunted the Panamanian all the way to this bonanza. 
 His subsequent career has been a switchback which reached its nadir five years ago, when Thomas Hearns produced a devastating right to the chin to knock him out and send him into retirement. 
 But Duran's failure to control his cash flow had him ducking under the ropes again 18 months later. 
 There were some indifferent performances against indifferent opponents until in Atlantic City earlier this year he floored and outpointed Iran Barkley to win the World Boxing Council middleweight title, a surprise which opened the door to tonight's affair. 
 Leonard retired for the first time in 1982 with a detached retina which until recent times would have ended his fighting career permanently. 
 But modern technology now makes perfect repair work possible, so Leonard came back even though he now had a lucrative television career and had astutely invested his fortune. 
 He had one fight in 1984 and was knocked down for the first time in his career. 
 He retired again but returned in 1987 when, without any warm-up contest, he went straight into a world middleweight title fight with Marvin Hagler. 
 Whatever the arguments about the verdict, which Leonard took, his speed and fitness were astounding. 
 In the two fights since then, however, vulnerability has loomed. 
 Donny Lalonde, a tall, awkward fighter with a shoulder disability which foreshortened his left-hand hitting, knocked Leonard down. 
 Thomas Hearns did so twice in June of this year, but Leonard managed to retain his super-middleweight title with a draw. 
 The fight with Hearns brought a new questioning of boxing and this type of &bquo;golden oldie&equo; encounter. 
 Were they really trying? 
 Hearns had looked over-the-hill in his previous fight and the pair at times did not appear to have the earnestness which fighters normally show. 
 In a fight between men who are past their prime, the most telling factor surely must be motivation. 
 Leonard has again been saying this week that this is likely to be his final contest. 
 He admits that having taken the decision to box again, the regime of the work seems harder, the magnet of other interests and causes in life seems stronger. 
 He has even looked benignly bored in the final days of preparation; he has no need, other than to satisfy the boxing historians, to climb into the ring again. 
 Duran, in contrast, does need the fight &mdash; firstly to pay some tax debts, but above all to erase the memory of their last encounter. 
 This, like his last fight with Barkley, is a rare opportunity and as on that occasion he will fight until he drops. 
 Over 12 rounds the fleet feet and mind of Leonard will, I suspect, no longer be quick enough to escape. 
 In eight or nine rounds the referee should be stepping in to rescue the younger man, unless he is knocked out. 
 US Treasury officials have warned the promoter, Bob Arum, that he risks breaking the law by selling the fight to a Panamanian TV station. 
 Such deals have been made illegal in protest at the Noriega regime. 
 Rowing: Spracklen pulls out in dudgeon. 
 By Jon Leyne 
 MIKE SPRACKLEN, who coached British crews to gold medals at the last two Olympics, has taken a &pound;30,000-a-year job in Canadian rowing after alleging he was snubbed by the British sport despite offering his services free. 
 Spracklen, who has accepted the position of coach to the Canadian men's team, has been involved in a long-running disagreement with the director of international rowing, Penny Chuter. 
 A mutiny against the rowing establishment last summer by oarsmen being coached by him was patched up in time for the world championships in Yugoslavia, but at the end of the championships Spracklen declared that he had no future in British rowing. 
 After the trouble the Amateur Rowing Association decided to restyle Chuter's job as performance director and to advertise the post. 
 Chuter was widely expected to be offered the new position, and Spracklen believes that his offer to take it on unpaid was &bquo;an embarrassment&equo; to the ARA. 
 &bquo;They obviously didn't want me, so I won't apply,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I did write to them but I was just snubbed.&equo; 
 Spracklen believes the ARA deliberately delayed answering his inquiry until he had left for his interview in Canada. 
 The ARA will not now fill the post until the new year. 
 For those who believe rowing coaches are megaphone-wielding martinets, Spracklen's style has been refreshing: a quiet, almost whining drone of a voice, softly pointing out technical faults or a lack of commitment in a way which commands almost total respect from his charges. 
 That will be missed. 
 So will the way in which he championed the traditional principles of technique. 
 Spracklen, who is 52 and lives in Marlow, has been largely responsible for their revival, believing them as valid today as they were 100 years ago. 
 Above all his move means leaving behind the double Olympic gold medallist Steve Redgrave and his pairs partner Simon Berrisford, as well as a number of other promising young British oarsmen. 
 Although Spracklen was a gold medallist at the 1958 Commonwealth Games, his biggest contribution to British rowing has been his guidance of Redgrave from junior through to gold medals at two Olympics, in the coxed four at Los Angeles and in a pair with Andy Holmes at Seoul. 
 He is not altogether happy with what he is doing. 
 &bquo;I am British,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I would prefer to be coaching British crews. 
 It really hurts me to be going away.&equo; 
 And he added: &bquo;It is important to me that the boys know I offered to do it for nothing.&equo; 
 As well as coaching many of Britain's leading international crews, Spracklen is a key member of the Oxford University team, and he will be returning from Canada in March to look after them for the last fortnight before the Boat Race. 
 During the 1987 mutiny he was conspicuous in not giving wholehearted support to the then chief coach, Dan Topolski. 
 In his new job Spracklen could find himself working alongside a former Cambridge coach, Neil Campbell, who guided the Light Blues to their only recent Boat Race success, in 1986. 
 He faces a large task. 
 Although Canada won gold in the 1984 Olympics, government funding was cut following the Ben Johnson drugs scandal in Seoul and the country won no medals at this year's world championships. 
 Hockey Atkins makes sure that Cambridge miss out. 
 PUNTERS would undoubtedly have marked yesterday's Pizza Express London League match between Cambridge University and Maidenhead for a score draw. 
 Draw they did, but goallessly, a result that did nothing for Maidenhead but lifted Cambridge to sixth place, writes Pat Rowley. 
 The lively Priestley, on the right wing, created several Cambridge chances but they were either scorned or Maidenhead were rescued by their goalkeeper Atkins. 
 Perhaps all three universities in the league were still shell-shocked after being well beaten by the top Pizza clubs last Saturday. 
 Oxford wasted two penalties in the first 25 minutes against London at Paddington Rec but still prevailed 2-1. 
 They moved up to 11th place but left London in 17th and last place, without a win this term. 
 PUNTERS would undoubtedly have marked yesterday's Pizza Express London League match between Cambridge University and Maidenhead for a score draw. 
 Draw they did, but goallessly, a result that did nothing for Maidenhead but lifted Cambridge to sixth place, writes Pat Rowley. 
 The lively Priestley, on the right wing, created several Cambridge chances but they were either scorned or Maidenhead were rescued by their goalkeeper Atkins. 
 Perhaps all three universities in the league were still shell-shocked after being well beaten by the top Pizza clubs last Saturday. 
 Oxford wasted two penalties in the first 25 minutes against London at Paddington Rec, but still prevailed 2-1. 
 Grimes's pass gave Neal the opening goal with a remarkable reverse-stick shot. 
 Gleeson equalised for London when he met a cross at the far post from his fellow winger Wyke, but Ralph then gave Oxford their first win since they beat Cheam on October 21. 
 They moved up to 11th place but left London in 17th and last place, without a win this term. 
 Fighting mars late victory by Cologne. 
 ABAD-TEMPERED Uefa Cup game between Cologne and Red Star Belgrade last night ended with a last-minute winner for the West Germans, two players sent off for fighting, the Red Star coach involved in an after-match incident with an usher, and fighting between rival supporters. 
 Cologne, 2-0 down from the first leg in Belgrade, won through to the quarter-finals with two goals from Goetz, his equaliser coming seven minutes from time, and a last-minute winner from Ordenewitz. 
 Seconds later the referee sent off Red Star's Milos Drizic and Cologne's Uwe Rahn for fighting. 
 After the match, the Red Star coach Dragoslav Sekularac was involved in an incident with one of the Cologne ushers as he tried to approach the referee. 
 The Cologne president Dirk Johannwerner said that Sekularac punched the usher in the face. 
 But Sekularac said he had been pushed by the usher and pushed back after his glasses got knocked down to the ground. 
 He denied that he punched anyone. 
 Police detained 14 people when fighting broke out between Yugoslav and West German fans after the game. 
 They said one policeman was injured in the fighting. 
 Meanwhile, Red Star's captain, Dragan Stojkovic, has reportedly signed for Marseille for a French record fee of &pound;5.3 million. 
 The midfielder will join on a two-year contract after the World Cup in Italy. 
 Werder Bremen knocked the holders Napoli out of the Uefa Cup last night, 8-3 on aggregate after winning the second leg 5-1. 
 Karl-Heinz Riedle scored twice for Werder, while a half-fit Maradona was unable to keep injury-plagued Napoli afloat. 
 England and Spain were told yesterday by Fifa that there will be no appeal against the World Cup seedings to be announced in Rome today. 
 &bquo;There is absolutely no sense in anyone protesting against the decision when it is announced,&equo; said Fifa's head of competitions, Miguel Galan. 
 Cricket Chamberlain is TCCB chairman. 
 By Mike Selvey 
 FRANK CHAMBERLAIN, the 64-year-old chairman of Northamptonshire, is to become the next chairman of the Test and County Cricket Board, succeeding Raman Subba Row who steps down next October. 
 At the TCCB winter meeting at Lord's yesterday, the chairmen and chief executives of the 17 first-class counties opted for Chamberlain rather than the only other candidate, Don Perry, the Gloucestershire chairman, and although no one was giving very much away at Lord's yesterday Chamberlain's majority, like that elsewhere the previous day, was believed to be substantial. 
 So a man who has hitherto led a quiet life, in terms of cricket administration, finds himself thrust into the forefront of the game's politics. 
 Chamberlain's practical experience of first-class cricket is slim, confined to six matches for Northamptonshire shortly after the war. 
 Instead his working life has been devoted, as one might expect from that neck of the woods, to the shoe trade, helping build up the family firm into a multinational concern. 
 He is on the board of a number of City companies, and is a former Master of the Worshipful Company of Pattenmakers. 
 He has been chairman of Northants since 1985, the year Subba Row took over his role at the TCCB, and has served on the board's finance committee. 
 Subba Row, who will not have had a hand in this particular decision, sees him as a &bquo;good scout&equo;. 
 He will certainly need to be well prepared for the task which faces him, with international cricket politics becoming increasingly complex. 
 On the home front his business experiences should stand him in more than good stead: cobblers is the stock-in-trade of most cricket committees. 
 England invited to tour Soviet Union David Plummer greets the arrival at Twickenham of the first Soviet national rugby team to visit the British Isles. 
 GLASNOST reached Twickenham yesterday when the first Soviet national side to visit Britain startled the Rugby Football Union by inviting their hosts to tour the Soviet Union next year. 
 The Soviets, who had arrived at Heathrow the previous evening, were taken to Twickenham to train and practise, and it was there that their assistant manager Douglas Kavtalashvilli made the offer. 
 The invitation greatly surprised the RFU secretary Dudley Wood, who was listening. 
 &bquo;This has come out of the blue, and we are due to go to Argentina next summer,&equo; said Wood. 
 &bquo;But if a formal invitation is issued by the Soviet Union then of course it will be very much considered.&equo; 
 One possibility is that England could send their B team. 
 The Soviet tourists' opening game is against Cornwall at Redruth on Saturday, and the tour ends with a match against England B at Northampton on December 23. 
 The Soviets are largely unknown in the British Isles, but elsewhere they have established quite a reputation as fearsome yet fair opponents. 
 In particular their student team's victory over New Zealand Universities at the Students' World Cup in France in 1988 announced their birth as a rugby nation. 
 Not that the Soviets were totally unknown before that. 
 Their wins against France A, Romania and Italy in the continental competition, the Fira Championship, had been widely reported. 
 But no great impact had been made on this side of the Channel. 
 Rugby has been played in the Soviet Union since the end of the last century when a Scottish businessman organised a game between expatriates in Moscow. 
 But the game failed to excite the Russian elite and was eventually banned by the Tsars as a rowdy pastime. 
 After the revolution, in 1923, Moscow River Yacht Club challenged the Workers Fitness Club for what was recorded as the first rugby encounter in the history of Soviet sport. 
 But, for a variety of reasons, the game failed to gain support. 
 During the Thirties new attempts were made to re-launch rugby in the Soviet Union. 
 Games were organised as curtain-raisers before major soccer matches, and experts provided the crowd with a running commentary of the action on the Tannoy system, a habit preserved to this day. 
 In 1936 it looked as if the game had finally made a breakthrough when a national competition, involving teams from Gorky, Minsk, Baku and Moscow, was organised; but someone at the Kremlin decreed that rugby was a capitalist pastime, and the game sank into oblivion once again. 
 However, despite the setbacks, the game bounced back after the Second World War and, in a similar way to the developments in France and Romania at the turn of the century, it made inroads into Soviet universities. 
 By the mid-Fifties the game was already established in the Bauman Technological Institute in Moscow where several Romanian students organised two teams and translated the laws of the game into Russian. 
 The president of the Soviet Rugby Federation is Major General Vladimir Iliushin, a test-pilot hero of the Soviet Union and, like his father &mdash; the creator of the famous IL aircraft series &mdash; an aircraft designer of international fame. 
 &bquo;The Soviet Rugby Federation is trying to develop the game throughout the Soviet territory,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We have about 20,000 players in the country and we run a successful, well-structured league. 
 We suffer because of the huge distances between various centres and because of shortages of quality coaches. 
 &bquo;We are also short of money and of playing facilities. 
 Compared to other sports in the Soviet Union, rugby is a very poor game. 
 We suffer because we are not an Olympic sport. 
 In the Soviet Union most funds are channelled into Olympic sport, and because rugby does not take part in the Olympics we get a very small proportion from the budget.&equo; 
 Several members of the present touring party have made their reputations in the teams which have done so well in the Fira Championship. 
 The captain, Igor Mironov, is a versatile back of remarkable ability, and the No.8 Alexander Tikhonov, the centre Igor Necheaev and the wing Vladimir Varapaev are all players of considerable class. 
 Among the less experienced, youngsters like Serguei Molchanov, a prop, and the Georgian full-back Nougzar Dsagnidze were outstanding in the 1988 Students' World Cup. 
 SOVIET SQUAD: Backs: I Mironov (capt), I Frantzuzov, M Losabezidze, M Parshin, I Necheaev, V Kannna, E Zuev, V Varapaev, I Kuperman, N Dsagnidze. 
 Forwards: I Khoihlovs, R Malikov, S Molchanov, Z Bakuradze, S Sergeev, A Mishakov, N Plotnikov, A Sokolov, B Koroliov, A Malinin, A Tikhonov, V Negodin, R Khairulyn. 
 Officials: G Miranov (manager), D Kavtalashvilli (assistant manager), V Masiura (coach), V Grachav (assistant manager), A Yanshin (doctor), A Korshunov (physio). 
 ITINERARY: Dec 9 v Cornwall (Redruth); Dec 13 v Combined Services (Aldershot); Dec 16 v England Students (Stourbridge); Dec 19 v Northern Division (Aspatria); Dec 23 v England B (Northampton). 
 Spurs not as gilded as they are painted. 
 By Tony May 
 THE Tottenham Hotspur board confirmed yesterday that Terry Venables does not have a large budget for new players because of the high cost of bringing the ground up to the latest safety standards. 
 The 250 fans who packed the annual general meeting at White Hart Lane gave Paul Bobroff, the company chairman, an orderly hearing. 
 But there was laughter at his response to a question about a reported split among the directors when he said that the board was &bquo;united and happy&equo; with the direction the club was taking. 
 Bobroff did not deny reports that debts are high after the &pound;7 million rebuilding of the East Stand. 
 He estimated that executive boxes in the stand would bring in &pound;800,000 a year. 
 He noted that the club would need to do work on the North and South stands in the foreseeable future. 
 With the government's membership scheme coming &bquo;we may have all-seater stadiums for all-member clubs. 
 We will have no choice&equo;. 
 Peter Nicholas will be out of the Chelsea team for a month after a cartilage operation yesterday. 
 West Bromwich signed Graham Harbey, a full-back from Ipswich, for &pound;80,000; Port Vale spent &pound;60,000 on Swindon's centre-back Tim Parkin. 
 Two goalkeepers switched clubs. 
 Scarborough's Kevin Blackwell joined his former manager, Neil Warnock, at Notts County for &pound;15,000, and Reading's Gary Phillips went to Barnet for &pound;12,500. 
 Derby are offering trials to three Trinidad and Tobago internationals, Russell Latapy, Leonson Lewis and Philbert Jones, who all played in last month's World Cup defeat by the United States. 
 Stan Storton, Telford's manager, has resigned after eight years for family reasons. 
 He took the club to Wembley three times, winning the FA Trophy this year and in 1983. 
 The FA is to examine ways of encouraging more professional players to take up refereeing after they retire. 
 Proposals from the Professional Footballers Association that former players should be promoted more quickly will be considered at an FA referees' committee meeting on December 19. 
 Tom Hodgson, who led out Luton on their first Wembley appearance in the 1959 FA Cup final, has died in retirement in Hampshire. 
 He served Luton for 45 years as player, captain, acting manager, director, chairman and president. 
 By Tony May 
 THE Tottenham Hotspur board confirmed yesterday that Terry Venables does not have a large budget for new players because of the high cost of bringing the ground up to the latest safety standards. 
 The 250 fans who packed the annual general meeting at White Hart Lane gave Paul Bobroff, the company chairman, an orderly hearing. 
 But there was laughter at his response to a question about a reported split among the directors when he said that the board was &bquo;united and happy&equo; with the direction the club was taking. 
 Bobroff did not deny reports that debts are high after the &pound;7 million rebuilding of the East Stand. 
 He estimated that executive boxes in the stand would bring in &pound;800,000 a year. 
 He noted that the club would need to do work on the North and South stands in the foreseeable future. 
 With the government's membership scheme coming &bquo;we may have all-seater stadiums for all-member clubs. 
 We will have no choice&equo;. 
 Peter Nicholas will be out of the Chelsea team for a month after a cartilage operation yesterday. 
 West Bromwich signed Graham Harbey, a full-back from Ipswich, for &pound;80,000; Port Vale spent &pound;60,000 on Swindon's centre-back Tim Parkin. 
 Two goalkeepers switched clubs. 
 Scarborough's Kevin Blackwell joined his former manager, Neil Warnock, at Notts County for &pound;15,000, and Reading's Gary Phillips went to Barnet for &pound;12,500. 
 Derby are offering trials to three Trinidad and Tobago internationals, Russell Latapy, Leonson Lewis and Philbert Jones, who all played in last month's World Cup defeat by the United States. 
 Stan Storton, Telford's manager, has resigned after eight years for family reasons. 
 He took the club to Wembley three times, winning the FA Trophy this year and in 1983. 
 The FA is to examine ways of encouraging more professional players to take up refereeing after they retire. 
 Proposals from the Professional Footballers Association that former players should be promoted more quickly will be considered at an FA referees' committee meeting on December 19. 
 Tom Hodgson, who led out Luton on their first Wembley appearance in the 1959 FA Cup final, has died in retirement in Hampshire. 
 He served Luton for 45 years as player, captain, acting manager, director, chairman and president. 
 Mason finds Wills full strength. 
 By Jack Massarik 
 GARY MASON, whose avowed game plan is meet the world heavyweight champion, Mike Tyson, sometime in 1991, last night found himself in the nearest thing to a test against that granite-hard fighter that his supporters could hope to imagine. 
 That he won a points decision against the Californian Mark Wills at Wembley will give them some reassurance that the British heavyweight champion could give a reasonable account of himself against an opponent who will not crumple easily. 
 For, make no mistake, Mason landed a stream of his Sunday-best shots &mdash; round-arm right swings, full-blooded left hooks, and accurate short rights &mdash; to Wills's chin during the 10 hard-fought rounds. 
 Those were blows which against most of his previous opponents would have swiftly enhanced his knockout record. 
 Mason took his unbeaten record to 33 fights by a margin of 98 &frac12;-97, or three rounds, but rarely in a British ring have two heavyweights been so well matched. 
 Wills, who holds a victory over former world champion Greg Page and was no doubt encouraged by the fact that Derek Williams, whom he had floored and convincingly outpointed in New York this summer, became the new European champion after 55 seconds' work against Hughroy Currie on Tuesday night, went about his work with pride, determination, and remarkable endurance. 
 During the middle rounds, when Mason still believed one punch could end it, he outjabbed the Wandsworth man and opened a cut over his left eye, but Mason rallied well and the last session in particular left no doubt as to which way the verdict would go. 
 Johnny Nelson, the British cruiserweight champion, has been given the chance to succeed where his Brendan Ingle stablemate Herol Graham failed earlier this year, and bring a world title to Sheffield &mdash; and with home advantage. 
 The promoter Barry Hearn, expects a full house of 2,500 when Carlos DeLeon of Puerto Rico defends his World Boxing Council title against Nelson at Sheffield City Hall on January 27. 
 &bquo;Half a million dollars is being spent to bring this fight to Sheffield,&equo; declared the ambitious Hearn, whose last world title promotion &mdash; Michael Watson v Mike McCallum &mdash; fell through last month when Watson broke his nose while sparring. 
 &bquo;I have promised to take big fights all over the country and they come no bigger than a bout with a world title at stake,&equo; Hearn said. 
 Nigel Benn's next opponent, part of the Londoner's lucrative five-fight deal with the American promoter Bob Arum, will be the highest ranked middleweight he has yet met. 
 On January 14 in Atlantic City he faces Michael Olajide, the flashy Liverpool-born Canadian nicknamed The Silk who dabbles in male modelling and was outpointed by Frank Tate for the IBF title three years ago. 
 Derek Williams, who beat Hughroy Currie for the vacant European heavyweight title on Tuesday night, wasted no time yesterday in throwing a gauntlet in the direction of the British champion, Gary Mason. 
 &bquo;He gets all the press coverage but right now he is the No2 in Europe and I am the No1.&equo; 
 JIM COURIER and Pete Sampras (top) lost their opening round-robin match against Darren Cahill and Mark Kratzman in the Nabisco Masters at the Royal Albert Hall yesterday, but they are tipped to make an impact on the doubles game, writes Martin James. 
 As juniors the two American teenagers were mentioned in the same breath as Andre Agassi and Michael Chang, but neither has made the same impact as yet. 
 Sampras will finish the year in 81st place, Courier 24th. 
 But in doubles they have eclipsed their renowned contemporaries. 
 Though they went down 2-6, 2-6, 6-7 to the experienced Australians, they deserved to qualify for the Masters when Ken Flach and Robert Seguso were forced to withdraw. 
 In only their second event together they reached the final of the Tournament of Champions in New York, and then won the Italian Open. 
 &bquo;They are going to be very good but they need to learn to combine better,&equo; observed Cahill. 
 &bquo;They hit the ball as hard as almost anyone.&equo; 
 Courier, aged 19, comes from the same stable as Agassi and has a similar big-hitting baseline game but a more diplomatic approach to court etiquette. 
 Sampras, an 18-year-old serve-and-volleyer, is equally controlled. 
 &bquo;We play doubles because we feel it will help us to become more complete players,&equo; said Courier. 
 &bquo;It has also brought us closer together as friends,&equo; said Sampras. 
 &bquo;It is nice to have someone else of your own age on the tour. 
 Chang doesn't really talk and Agassi is in a world of his own.&equo; 
 Yesterday Sampras and Courier were almost in a world of their own. 
 There were barely 300 people in the Royal Albert Hall when they opened the morning session. 
 &bquo;It's a stunning setting,&equo; said Courier, &bquo;but everyone was so silent it was like playing in a church. 
 There was no buzz.&equo; 
 John Fitzgerald and Anders Jarryd, the Wimbledon champions, took nearly three hours to win their opening match 6-3, 6-7, 6-1, 7-5 over Paul Annacone and Christo van Rensberg. 
 Jarryd then revealed that a troublesome right calf may force him to withdraw from the Swedish team to face West Germany in the Davis Cup final next week. 
 &bquo;I thought it was getting better,&equo; he said, &bquo;but the last couple of days it seems to have got worse.&equo; 
 Sarah Loosemore beat Jennifer Santrock, ranked 95 places above her, 6-4, 7-6 on the first day of Great Britain's defence of the Maureen Connolly Trophy in Cardiff, but Valda Lake fell apart in the second set against the Australian Open junior champion, Kim Kessaris, losing 1-6, 6-4, 6-2. 
 PHOTOGRAPH: FRANK BARON 
 Next Thursday Chileans will go to the polls to elect a successor to General Pinochet, who has ruled with an iron fist since the overthrow of Allende in 1973. 
 Whoever wins will face a dilemma &mdash; whether to prosecute military personnel for human rights abuses. 
 During the 1970s Andres Valenzuela, right, served in a death squad which hunted and killed Chilean Communists. 
 Most were tortured before they died. 
 Valenzuela now lives among other exiles in France. 
 Iain Guest talked to him there Portrait of a torturer. 
 NEXT Thursday's elections will mark a red letter day for tens of thousands of Chileans who have been exiled by Pinochet's harsh rule. 
 Many are already eagerly making plans to return home. 
 But for one Chilean exile, Andres Valenzuela, Thursday will be much like any other day &mdash; long, boring and lonely. 
 It will pass in a succession of aimless walks and endless glasses of beer in the picturesque little French town where he has sought refuge. 
 It's only when you've heard his extraordinary story that you realise this is no ordinary man. 
 I found myself surreptitiously studying him. 
 Does he face show courage and conviction &mdash; or does it betray guilt? 
 Are those eyes shifty, or merely tired? 
 Certainly, he seems too slight of stature to have handcuffed heavier men and hauled them up by their wrists to hang, agonisingly, from hooks. 
 Too unsettled to have been a torturer. 
 During the past 16 years, by conservative estimates, 782 Chileans have disappeared, another 2,000 have been killed, and several thousands have been tortured. 
 Valenzuela took an active part in this dirty war. 
 He served in a shadowy military death squad that kidnapped and murdered scores of Chileans. 
 But he has also confessed, and this makes him special. 
 Valenzuela could be a star witness for the prosecution in the event of any inquiry into human rights abuses by the next Chilean government. 
 Torturer. 
 The word is bald, impersonal. 
 But what of the person behind the label? 
 How did Andres Valenzuela get sucked in, and what prompted his change of heart? 
 These were the questions I wanted to put when I sought him out in France. 
 I'm not sure I have all the answers. 
 He was direct and helpful, but he also steered me away from his personal life. 
 He knows that words, too, can wound. 
 His disclosures have already caused several deaths, and every time he talks it reminds the world of his unsavoury past. 
 Other Chilean exiles in France still find it hard to accept him. 
 As he says, &bquo;I have very few friends.&equo; 
 How does a torturer get started? 
 Valenzuela's experience suggest &mdash; disturbingly &mdash; that it could happen to anyone. 
 He was born into a lower-class family in the small seaside village of Papudo where his father caught conger eels for the tourist restaurants. 
 It was, remembers, Andres, a happy, uncomplicated upbringing. 
 In April 1974, seven months after the coup which brought Pinochet to power, he arrived at the Air Force base of Colina on the outskirts of Santiago to begin his two years of military service. 
 He was just 18. 
 After three months at Colina the young recruit was posted to the Academy of Aerial War in an affluent Santiago suburb. 
 Valenzuela's dirty war was about to begin. 
 He was assigned to what was vaguely described as &bquo;guard duty,&equo; warned not to talk about his work and taken down to the basement to start. 
 &bquo;I was very, very frightened&equo; he recalls. 
 Blindfolded, handcuffed prisoners were crammed into dormitories and passages, many wearing Air Force uniforms. 
 These officers had been loyal to Allende. 
 The young conscript was broken in slowly. 
 He did not attend torture personally, but he found his natural aversion to mistreating a defenceless person gradually being eroded. 
 The prisoners in the basement were dehumanised, blindfolded, anonymous &bquo;subversives&equo;. 
 It was in the War Academy that Valenzuela learned how to detain, interrogate, and exploit the fears of prisoners &mdash; while psychologists looked for weakness in the young draftees and weeded out those who seemed sentimental. 
 Valenzuela himself was promoted from guard duty to acting as a back-up in kidnapping operations. 
 These early months gave him a brutally clear idea of what lay ahead. 
 He knew that kidnap and torture were a blatant violation of the Chilean military code and that under the same code he was entitled to register any reservations with a superior officer. 
 But he never protested. 
 Why? 
 &bquo;What could I have said? 
 That I was not in agreement? 
 I would have been killed.&equo; 
 In Mid 1975, the counter-intelligence services of the Navy, Air Force and Police linked up to form the &bquo;Joint Command against Subversion&equo;, and began working out of two suburban safe-houses, or &bquo;nests&equo;. 
 The Command's strength rarely exceeded 25 men, but they were carefully selected for their ferocity and reliability. 
 The man who commanded the Air Force unit, Roberto Fuentes Morrison, was a fanatical anti-Communist known as &bquo;Wally&equo;. 
 He was ruthless with anything short of total obedience. 
 The Joint Command began to hunt down prominent Communists, and on August 28, 1975, they seized a Young Communist leader named Miguel Rodriguez Gallardo. 
 Gallardo had pulled himself up from poverty by sheer force of personality, tapping the electricity lines that ran above the shanty town and reading Marx by the light. 
 He was mercilessly tortured, blindfolded and trussed up in a cupboard for four months, but he refused to break. 
 Valenzuela was fascinated by Gallardo's willpower, and as their relationship changed Gallardo established a subtle ascendancy over his young captor. 
 On one occasion, Valenzuela arrived in a torture room to find Gallardo hanging by handcuffs from a hook and whimpering. 
 Valenzuela touched his arm: &bquo;I'll let you down.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't,&equo; replied Gallardo. 
 &bquo;Wally might come in, and you'd be in trouble. 
 I'll stick it out.&equo; 
 One important Communist still eluding capture was Jose Weibel, Secretary General of the Young Communists, and the Joint Command decided to try and locate him through his brother Ricardo, a bus driver. 
 Ricardo Weibel was seized and brought to the base for 12 days of rough treatment, before being released and sent home. 
 Then an order came to pick up Weibel again &bquo;I had to hide my dismay when Weibel was bought back without a blindfold &mdash; a sure sign that he was to be killed.&equo; 
 Sure enough, soon afterwards Weibel and Gallardo were pushed into a van. 
 VALENZUELA was told to burn their ID cards, wallets and spectacles. 
 Before they left, Gallardo shook Valenzuela's hand and thanked him for the cigarettes he had given him in captivity. 
 It was a wrenching moment. 
 &bquo;I admired Gallardo the most&equo;, says Valenzuela. 
 &bquo;He was brave until the very last moment.&equo; 
 Valenzuela's only real friend was another recruit named Bratti Cornejo who had been drafted at the same time. 
 Within weeks of Gallardo's murder, Valenzuela found himself taking part in Bratti's execution. 
 Bratti had been discovered spying for a rival security service. 
 He was drugged, bundled into the boot of a car and driven to a canyon on the outskirts of Santiago. 
 As Valenzuela took off Bratti's handcuffs his friend murmured, &bquo;It's cold tonight&equo;. 
 Valenzuela choked out a reply and watched while Bratti was shot by &bquo;Fifa&equo; Palma Ramirez, one of the most savage officers. 
 They pushed the body off the cliff, but it caught in bushes. 
 Valenzuela, holding on to the killer's hand, dislodged his friend's corpse. 
 &bquo;I looked down and thought he'd let me fall too.&equo; 
 The Joint Command began taking risks. 
 Jose Weibel, Ricardo's brother, was snatched off a bus in broad daylight while travelling with his family. 
 The man who succeeded him as Secretary General of the Young Communists, Carlos Contreras Maluje, was picked up after putting up a struggle in the street. 
 As people crowded round, Valenzuela and the others bundled Maluje, kicking and screaming, into a car. 
 The injured man was taken back and beaten up before being taken off and killed. 
 With this, the freewheeling murder came to an end. 
 Maluje's spirited resistance had provoked such an uproar that the muzzled Supreme Court issued a habeas corpus order to locate him &mdash; the first against the Air Force since 1973. 
 But did Valenzuela himself participate directly in torture? 
 He was certainly present on many occasions. 
 Every detainee was tortured, irrespective of age, sex or background. 
 Valenzuela admits to beating prisoners at the moment of their detention, hauling them to the torture rooms, watching them writhe and holding them down. 
 He also handcuffed prisoners, swung them up on hooks and watched them dangle. 
 All this constitutes torture under international law. 
 But he also insists that his main task was to deliver the prisoner to the torturers, who were specialists in interrogation with long experience in the service. 
 Not all the interrogators were veterans. 
 The ferocious &bquo;Wally&equo; Fuentes Morrison only joined up after the 1973 coup. 
 Bratti tortured. 
 Even a prisoner named Carol Flores, who turned informant, tortured. 
 Valenzuela himself was instructed in interrogation techniques. 
 Whatever his personal misgivings, Valenzuela hid them well and when his compulsory military service ended he signed on for a permanent career in the Air Force. 
 In 1978, in an attempt to wipe the slate clean, Pinochet declared an amnesty to cover all human rights abuses since the coup. 
 Valenzuela felt reassured. 
 Between 1976 and 1983, he rose steadily through a series of promotions and posts in Air Force security. 
 Then in September 1983, &bquo;Wally&equo; Fuentes Morrison let him know that his skills were once again required for a special operation. 
 Several members of the left wing Revolutionary Movement, MIR, were hiding out in a residential safe-house. 
 On the evening of September 7 a small army of security agents, including Wally and Valenzuela, began converging on the house. 
 Around 9 pm they opened fire with a heavy machine gun. 
 At the same time, Andres Valenzuela shot out the street lights. 
 The attackers then called by loudhailer on those in the house to surrender. 
 A young man came out with his hands in the air. 
 Two agents ran up and shot him dead. 
 As soon as the shooting stopped, Valenzuela was told to pull the body away from the house. 
 He then went in and found the body of a young woman. 
 By the time he had pulled the corpse out into the street, Valenzuela's clothes were stained with blood. 
 IT WAS a full year before he made the break &mdash; but eventually, on August 21, 1984, he went over to one of the more independent local magazines, Cauce, and asked for its leading journalist Monica Gonzalez. 
 The resulting interview was heavy going for both of them. 
 Monica had been a close friend of Ricardo and Jose Weibel. 
 Now she was listening to their kidnapper. 
 What she remembers most was his self-disgust and terror. 
 Monica rang lawyers at the Vicariate of Solidarity, which had been set up by the Catholic Church in 1975 and was by now Chile's leading human rights organization. 
 The lawyers took Valenzuela off to record his testimony. 
 A few days later, Valenzuela went underground. 
 After several months in hiding he crossed into Argentina and left for France. 
 Monica's interview was published in December 1984 and its impact was swift and savage. 
 First to suffer were the relatives of those who had been kidnapped by the Joint Command. 
 They now knew the terrible truth, even though without a body they still could not mourn. 
 They gave Valenzuela little credit for speaking out. 
 The impact on the Vicariate of Solidarity was even more violent. 
 The Valenzuela file had passed to Jose Manuel Parada, a senior Vicariate official. 
 On March 29 1985, Jose Manuel's inquiry came to a brutal end. 
 He was picked up with two other Communists. 
 The following morning, the three bodies were found near Santiago airport, with the throats cut. 
 Chilean justice was not totally intimidated. 
 Judge Carlos Cerda from the Santiago Appeals Court was investigating the disappearance of several leading Communists and Valenzuela's testimony was the first solid proof that the security forces had been involved in kidnapping. 
 Cerda interviewed those named in his testimony, including Wally Fuentes Morrison, and then threw down the gauntlet to Pinochet. 
 Ignoring Pinochet's 1978 amnesty, he described the Joint Command as an &bquo;illegal association&equo; and charged 40 of those implicated with &bquo;illegal deprivation of liberty.&equo; 
 They included Andres Valenzuela. 
 The judge's colleagues in the Judiciary, however, had no wish to confront Pinochet. 
 The Supreme Court charged Cerda himself with &bquo;lack of discipline&equo;, suspended him on half pay for two months, and replaced him by another judge who dutifully closed his case. 
 Judge Cerda points out that the case remains technically open until he personally closes it. 
 He strongly implies that this loophole could allow him to resume the case after elections, in which case Andres Valenzuela could be a key witness. 
 If, that is, Valenzuela can ever return to Chile. 
 This has been open to doubt since June 8, 1989 when an extreme left-wing group pumped 20 bullets into Valenzuela's former chief, &bquo;Wally&equo; Fuentes Morrison. 
 Valenzuela's testimony had confirmed Wally's involvement in several brutal killings, and Valenzuela's first reaction was that he had unwittingly taken yet another life. 
 His second reaction was gut terror that his former comrades would come looking for him. 
 Valenzuela insists he's willing to return to Chile. 
 &bquo;There is&equo;, he says, &bquo;a lot more to tell.&equo; 
 By a strange twist of fate, the first Chilean to welcome Valenzuela to his new home in France was Castro, a &bquo;Mirista&equo; who was captured in broad daylight and stripped to his underwear back in December 1974, while Valenzuela stood guard at the corner. 
 Castro has swallowed his doubts and hired Valenzuela as a cook in his small restaurant. 
 It is one of the few gestures of real friendship encountered by this lonely man in his long and tormented odyssey. 
 Iain Guest is the reporter in next Sunday's BBC-1 Everyman programme, Called To Account (10.20pm), which examines justice in Chile. 
 Gallardo, the Young Communist leader who was tortured then killed - &bquo;I admired him most&equo;, says Valenzuela 
 Truck or treats? 
 Brandwagon. 
 By Richard Longworth 
 DIESEL engines are the most fuel efficient vehicle power source available. 
 Trucks, buses and most taxis use them, and 40 per cent of vehicle fuel sold in the UK last year was diesel. 
 But diesel engines also have very dirty exhaust emissions. 
 While not having the concentrations of poisonous gases found in petrol engine exhausts, they give out far more &bquo;particulates&equo; (soot). 
 Diesel engine manufacturers have long maintained that these are harmless, but recently they have been found to contain polyaromatich hydrocarbons (PAH), which can cause cancer when breathed deeply. 
 Soot was first connected with cancer by a London doctor in 1774. 
 Diesel engines also produce nitrous ocxides (NOx), which return from the skies as acid rain. 
 It is small wonder that the truck and bus manufacturers based in areas hit worst by acid rain, Volvo and Scania in Sweden and MAN in Bavaria, are working hardest to cut pollutants. 
 While many politicians have only recently seen their green light many diesel engine manufacturers have looked further ahead, and have been developing cleaner engines, principally in response to stringent American legislation. 
 The result will be a common level of NOx and particular emissions from vehicles (measured in grammes per kilowat hour) from vehicles sold in Europe after 1991. 
 NOx be cut to 11.8g/Kw/hr, and particulates to 11.8 g/Kw/hr, That level will still be significantly higher than US levels, but much lower than vehicles currently being sold. 
 There is also a further cut in the pipeline, but this second phase of diesel pollution is running into technical problems. 
 While the first level of cuts can be reached using existing levels of technology, the second stage, likely in 1994, will require a new generation of engines. 
 These will be electronically controlled, a technical task far harder on a diesel engine than on its petrol counterpart. 
 The exhaust will also have to be fitted with filters to trap the particulates and their carcinogenic PAHs. 
 However these are cumbersome, complicated and expensive. 
 The problem is that they clog up. 
 Some manufacturers such as MAN and DAF have solved the problem by fitting filters which clean themselves with a small furnace as the vehicle is in operation. 
 Volvo on the other hand is testing buses fitted with filters like dustbins, which are cleaned at the end of a day. 
 For there to be a Europe-wide common standard of emissions, there must also be a common standard for fuel, as some types of fuel smoke worse than others. 
 Talks are currently in progress in all the EC states, to try to distill some common requirements from fuel suppliers and their customers. 
 Unlike lead, which the fuel companies eventually proved only too pleased to take out of petrol, sulphur does nothing for either the performance or longevity of diesel engines and it contributes to acid rain. 
 Currently, diesel fuel sold in the EC contains 0.3 per cent sulphur, except in West Germany where the level is 0.25 per cent. 
 Klaus Schubert, technicaldirector at MAN, says his company would like to see it reduced to 0.02 per cent, but recognises that 0.05 per cent is a more realistic level. 
 However John Bullock, retail fuels technical manager at Shell UK, says the price of the fuel would rise significantly, because extra crude would have to be refined to run the hydro-desulphurisation process. 
 There is, however, a chasm between what is becoming technically possible, and the reality of what is likely to happen to the air on our city streets, where, according to Friends of the Earth, pollution levels regularly exceed WHO standards. 
 London buses, for example, are exempt from traffic lawsaffecting other vehicles, which in the competitive deregulated world of modern bus operation, include expensive pollution control. 
 There are also buses at least 30 years old still being run, so it is likely to be decades before the fleet is replaced. 
 With over a quarter of the UK fleet of rigid (urban delivery) vehicles over eight years old, high street deliveries are also destined to smell for years. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE en2 
 Whose flu?. 
 THIS year's flu forecasters got it right. 
 The flu strain reported this week to be hitting offices, factories and schools throughout Britain has been identified as A/Shanghai; the flu vaccine now available from doctors protects against it. 
 The cocktail vaccine is &bquo;mixed&equo; by the world's flu forecasters at a meeting in Geneva in February each year to discuss the international traffic in flu strains. 
 This winter's vaccine also protects against A/Singapore and B/Yamagata. 
 Dr John Watkins, a GP in Rogerstone, Gwent, who has made a special study of flu, stressed yesterday that it was not too late for high-risk groups to be vaccinated. 
 These include the elderly, people with chronic respiratory disease, chronic heart disease, kidney disease and diabetes, and health service staff. 
 These are the groups most at risk from developing secondary complications. 
 Flu vaccine &bquo;take-up&equo; in Britain is low compared with other EC countries. 
 This is partly due to a belief that flu jabs do not offer much protection. 
 In fact, they are 70 to 80 per cent effective. 
 Another factor influencing take-up is public perception of flu. 
 It is not seen as a &bquo;deadly disease&equo; in the same way as it is in France. 
 A third factor is that there has not been a major epidemic in Britain for 20 years. 
 The public has a very short memory. 
 An epidemic this winter &mdash; and it is still questionable whether we will have one &mdash; would trigger heavy demand for vaccine next year. 
 If you succumb to the Shanghai flu, reconcile yourself to four or five days in bed with a high fever, followed by a further four or five days with a cough and a runny nose. 
 Take paracetamol to keep your temperature down. 
 Lots of fluids are also essential. 
 Don't try any heroics. 
 Returning to work before you are fit could infect others and delay your recovery. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Water sports on reservoirs are threatened as more evidence emerges of the blue-green algae, which feed on pollution and were first seen in Britain this summer. 
 Paul Brown reports on a problem which will cost the privatised water companies a fortune to clean up Blue-green and deadly. 
 BLUE-green algaes, which killed sheep and pet dogs at Rutland Water this summer, are a serious and growing threat to sailing, water sports and fishing in all lakes and ponds in Britain as man made pollution feeds their growth. 
 Large areas of still water used for recreation are likely to be routinely closed in the summer months, just at the point of maximum use, in order to protect the public from toxic poisoning. 
 Otherwise they risk the same fate as 20 officer cadets who were ill, two seriously, after canoeing on a lake in Leek, Staffordshire, this summer. 
 The case, not reported at the time, was the first documented of human victims of this phenonemum in Britain. 
 Research is now being intensified at Dundee University, which has the world's leading expertise on the subject, in an attempt to understand what makes the algae release the potentially fatal toxins. 
 They want to find if there is any way to predict it and possibly prevent it. 
 Monitoring and attempting to prevent the pollution will cost millions over the next few years and will be passed directly to the consumer as an unforseen expense. 
 While the hazards of the algae have been documented since the beginning of the century in places such as Australia and the United States, it has only become a serious problem in Europe recently. 
 Scandinavian countries were the first to have to close waterways because of poisoning problems and now Britain has a potential crisis. 
 The hot summer and low water levels made the problem worse but it is Britain's farming and sewage practices that are the key to the problem. 
 The algae feeds on nitrogen and phosphates which come into the water from agriculture and sewage. 
 Rutland Water, where water is used for human consumption, is a classic case. 
 Water is pumped in from the River Nene, which is rich in farm nutrients, and sewage from Oakham, rich in phosphates from washing powders, goes direct into the reservior. 
 This, plus sunlight, makes a perfect soup on which the blue-green algae thrives. 
 Anglian Water Authority claims that the water drawn off from the lake is still safe despite these problems because of the treatment it gives the water before it reaches people's taps. 
 Last night the people who live and work round Rutland Water held a protest meeting to decide how to tackle this threat to their health and their jobs. 
 Since the reserviour was built it has become an important tourist and recreational centre but now none of the businesses can be sure they have a future. 
 Mr Nick Cox, who runs a sailing centre, marina and yacht chandlers on the lake has issued a writ for damages against Anglain Water Authority. 
 He is one of 35 local people who is considering suing the authority for loss of business because of the algae. 
 He blames the authority for creating the conditions in which the algae can thrive. 
 It is a growing problem partly and one that is likely to be with us for a long time. 
 &bquo;We are all extremely worried here. 
 It is not just the six weeks we were shut down this summer and the loss of trade since, we are worried about the future. 
 Do we have any, or is this going to happen again.&equo; 
 Anglian Water refused to attend last night's meeting and Mr Cox accused them of a &bquo;stone wall of silence.&equo; 
 He said a total of 24 dogs had died and despite many samples being taken away the local people had never been given any results. 
 &bquo;We have been given reassurances that the water is safe to drink and it was just the long hot summer but we are not so sure. 
 You can still see the algae in the water, and I am still drinking bottled. 
 We just do not have the information to go on.&equo; 
 The National Rivers Authority, the new post privatisation watchdog for the water industry, is proud of its role in publicising the problem of blue-green algae. 
 &bquo;We do not believe the public would have been told at all but for us,&equo; said a spokesman. 
 &bquo;The problem is that very little is really known about the problem. 
 We know that nutrients added to the water by humans make the algae grow, this combined with the sunlight causes blooms, but beyond that we do not understand much about the toxins.&equo; 
 Anglian Water Authority refused to attend the meeting of residents in Oakham because of rules preventing them discussing matters that might depress the share price during privatisation, and because there was little information available. 
 Professor Geoffrey Codd of Dundee University said an in depth study of the algae and what made them produce toxins was needed. 
 The algaes were very unpredicable. 
 One week the algae could be clear of toxins and the next week very toxic but no one yet know why. 
 This meant testing had to be done frequently and the waters closed down as a precaution once the blooms appeared. 
 &bquo;It is a serious and growing problem partly because of the man made nutrients which aid the growth of the blooms. 
 It is likely to be with us for a long time to come.&equo; 
 Mrs Shelley Howard, senior biologist of the Severn-Trent Region said the officer cadets had been involved in strenuous exercises which involved repeatedly going under the water. 
 The authority had coincidentally tested the water for toxins on about the same day as the officer cadets had used it. 
 Subsequently the scientists had advised the local environmental health officer of the dangers and he closed the water. 
 By that time the officer cadets were in hospital. 
 Two, who were most seriously ill with vomiting and other symptoms, were released after a week. 
 Mrs Howard said: &bquo;Unless we are given a lot more resources we will not be able to carry out the weekly monitoring required. 
 So far we do not know what is going to happen about this.&equo; 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE en2 
 Please believe ME, I'm ill ME sufferers are sick of doctors not taking them seriously and have made a cinema ad to win support for their case. 
 John Illman examines the problems they are facing. 
 WE ALL like to be taken seriously, especially when we are feeling ill. 
 It is easy enough if you have chicken pox or some other common illness with well-defined physical symptoms. 
 But it is not so easy if you have a condition which is not susceptible to diagnosis and has no clear-cut signs or symptoms. 
 You may be written off as a malingerer or a neurotic or, perhaps even worse, as someone who must be gently humoured back to health. 
 Alternatively, you may be shown the door with a few sharp words more in keeping with a tyrannical consultant than your friendly neighbourhood GP. 
 We have all heard stories about GPs alleged to have given patients short shrift with remarks like: &bquo;Throw away your crutches. 
 It's your head that needs them, not your legs.&equo; 
 &bquo;Women of your age imagine aches and pains &mdash; are you sure you're not attention seeking?&equo; 
 &bquo;We all have to die sometimes.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not prepared to do any tests. 
 They cost money.&equo; 
 &bquo;You are a menace to society &mdash; a pest. 
 I wish you'd take yourself away from me.&equo; 
 &bquo;You middle class women have nothing else to worry about.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's one of those things you silly young women get.&equo; 
 &bquo;Stop feeling sorry for yourself. 
 I have patients with real illnesses &mdash; patients who are dying from cancer.&equo; 
 &bquo;Go home and have more babies.&equo; 
 Surgery encounters like these have become increasingly common over the past 30 years with the erosion of the traditional divisions between sickness and health, which have led to, among other things, the medicalisation of &bquo;anxiety.&equo;. 
 Until the launch of the so-called &bquo;minor tranquillisers&equo; in the early Sixties, anxiety was seen as an inevitable everyday experience, and, moreover, as a valuable psychological spur compelling us to take stock of things if they went wrong. 
 It was not something you took to the doctor &mdash; until Valium and Librium arrived on the market. 
 Since then the fashion has changed again. 
 Doctors are now increasingly reluctant to prescribe tranquillisers for fear of being sued by patients who become addicted to them. 
 What this means is that good old fashioned self-reliance could become a new health vogue of the Nineties. 
 The anxious and the worried may seek solace outside the surgery. 
 According to one theory, held by some psychiatrists, patients may find doctors increasingly unsympathetic to their plight. 
 This theory has it that, as a breed, doctors like to be masters of every possible situation, and that this may even be a factor in their selection of medicine as a career. 
 But this, it is claimed, may make them more vulnerable than most to negative emotions when they are shown to be powerless. 
 This may result in swift and brutal treatment of patients with complaints which are difficult to diagnose. 
 Admittedly, some may have totally unrealistic expectations of the NHS's power to keep them fit. 
 They may be neurotics or malingerers or both. 
 But others may be worthy candidates for the very best of the NHS. 
 Patients claiming to have Myalgic Encephalomyelitis (ME) may come into the latter category. 
 Symptoms include fatigue, night sweats, weight loss and exhaustion. 
 While some doctors recognise the condition, others question its existence, attributing problems to causes such as depression. 
 The ME Action Campaign is waging a major campaign to validate ME as a disease. 
 The alleged remarks by doctors to patients quoted above were taken from an Action Campaign survey highlighting &bquo;bad&equo; treatment. 
 This week the ME Action Campaign released stills from a forthcoming cinema commercial. 
 Featuring a teenage girl whose life is totally disrupted by ME, it is designed to win public support for ME sufferers. 
 The Action Campaign is also seeking support from medical journalists, and I have been asked repeatedly if I was going to add to the &bquo;adverse&equo; ME publicity. 
 Having heard conflicting views, I am not taking sides. 
 But I am sure about one thing. 
 A little humility in the medical debate would not go amiss. 
 It might even help deserving patients to be taken seriously. 
 Before and after&hellip; new cinema commercial features a teenage sufferer whose life is totally disrupted by ME OVERNIGHT FILE 
 In search of the most valuable GEMs of all Malcolm Smith on the importance of genetically-engineered micro-organisms. 
 LOSING your favourite gems may be a personal disaster. 
 But losing GEMs could have much farther reaching implications. 
 GEMs are genetically engineered micro-organisms and finding them again could prove vital. 
 So far, none are known to have been released in the UK. 
 But several are in the pipeline and there have been trials. 
 The reluctance of UK Authorities to sanction their release &mdash; for such agricultural purposes as extending the range of plants which harbour nitrogen-fixing bacteria in their roots &mdash; is understandable. 
 Once out you can never round them up. 
 Detecting their presence is as much as is practical. 
 Even that is far from straightforward. 
 Alun Morgan and Dr Jon Saunders of the department of genetics and microbiology at the University of Liverpool, working with Dr Roger Pickup of the Institute of Terrestrial Ecology, Windermere, form one of a number of groups of scientists developing techniques to spot a GEM. 
 There are so many bacteria everywhere that picking out a GEM is a bit like looking for a candle amongst Blackpool's illumination. 
 Soil, for example, can easily have millions of bacteria &mdash; of very many different species &mdash; in just a gram. 
 A second problem is that many bacteria living &bquo;in the wild&equo; are not always easy to culture in the laboratory. 
 Many have fickle requirements and others lie dormant until very precise conditions happen to come along. 
 As a result, it's been estimated that not many more than one per cent can be cultured at any one time. 
 The researchers have devised a suite of methods based on detecting a marker gene engineered into the GEM. 
 They've used one that codes for an enzyme called catechol 2,3-dioxygenase (C230 for short). 
 It converts catechol &mdash; a naturally occuring substance in ordinary metabolism &mdash; to a vivid yellow compound. 
 The gene is very uncommon in nature so any intense yellow colonies of bacteria isolated from the wild &mdash; and cultured &mdash; are almost certainly the lost GEMs. 
 It's not the only way of checking for C230. 
 The enzyme can be tested for chemically, even in dilute water samples or by using other more complex, state of the art, tricks like DNA amplification. 
 Using catechol is relatively simple and cheap. 
 But the snag is that first you have to be able to recover the GEMs to culture them to do the catechol yellowing test. 
 To develop a recovery method, Morgan, Saunders and Pickup used a Gem called Pseudomonas putida mt-2, a modified common soil bacterium which may have wide applications for destroying toxic substances. 
 Their method has been designed for recovering a GEM from water &mdash; not easy because any bacteria in it are much less abundant than, say in soil. 
 This GEM &mdash; like most bacteria &mdash; isn't the smooth cell shape that it looks. 
 Tiny protein structures protrude &mdash; like flagellae to help it move and pili to attach itself to surfaces. 
 Their composition differs from one species of bacterium to the next. 
 So mt-2's purified pili and flagellae were injected into animals so that they rapidly produced antibodies specific to them. 
 These were then collected from their blood and purified. 
 The next step was to chemically link these highly specific antibodies to small magnetised polystyrene spheres. 
 Suspended in water, only the GEM for which the antibodies were specific will attach to the beads. 
 The beads plus GEM are recovered with a magnet. 
 The accuracy of the recovery process hinges on just how specific the flagellae/pili antibodies are. 
 Once you have the GEMs on the polystyrene spheres they can be washed off and cultured for testing with catechol or other techniques. 
 According to the researchers, highly specific antibodies have ensured that the technique is a success. 
 No confusion was found when they tested them against 200 different isolates of the same, but genetically unmodified, bacterium taken from lake water. 
 This research, to enable identification of a released GEM &mdash; and its whereabouts &mdash; is essential because of the risks involved in letting GEMs out of the laboratory. 
 There are concerns that, once released, GEMs might exhibit some previously unknown pathogenicity, might take over from some naturally occurring bacteria or pass on some perhaps unwanted trait to indigenous bacteria. 
 There are also fears that a genetic mutation &mdash; over which there could be no control &mdash; could suddenly produce a GEM with some nasty trick up its sleeve. 
 There may be ways around this, at least in part, as Jon Saunders points out. 
 Engineering a time delayed &bquo;lethal gene&equo; into a GEM to give it a finite life &mdash; making it sensitive to low air temperatures so that frost kills it &mdash; is one way. 
 Doubling up on &bquo;lethal genes&equo; &mdash; by making a GEM both frost susceptible and ultraviolet light sensitive &mdash; is a belt and braces approach. 
 But none of these tricks can insure against a mutation. 
 Official concern was voiced at the EC's Environment Council in September attended by Chris Patten, the UK's Environment Minister. 
 Reporting to the House of Commons, he said: &bquo;Agreement was reached on a directive concerning the deliberate release&hellip; of genetically modified organisms. 
 The directive requires member states to establish systems for the national regulation of releases. 
 It also establishesa system for the review and clearance of products containing genetically modified organisms so that conditions can be established for their marketing.&equo; 
 Reliable detection is an essential part of the precautions. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sci 
 Weedy but powerful The Environment Bill, published later this month, will tackle the perils of genetic engineering. 
 Here Stephen Young considers the problem of herbal terrorists. 
 EVER SINCE mankind first began to till the soil, weeds have been practising their unique brand of herbal terrorism. 
 Two thousand years ago, the biblical farmer was tormented by tares and Virgil was denouncing what he called the lazy thistle. 
 Today, weeds are responsible for a 12 per cent reduction in the world's harvests. 
 The consequences of any increase in their activities are all too clear. 
 With such thoughts uppermost in their minds, ecologists are preparing for the arrival of genetically-engineered crops. 
 What concerns them is the risk that engineered plants might acquire weedy traits and escape from cultivation. 
 The effects on agriculture and the environment could be profound. 
 In a recent report, the Royal Commission on Environmental Pollution concluded that potatoes, for example, might become troublesome weeds if they were engineered to be tolerant of frosts, blight and herbicides. 
 According to ecologist Kathleen Keeler, of the University of Nebraska, the creation of new weeds is the most serious risk attaching to plant biotechnology. 
 The point is that crops and weeds are in a sense kindred spirits, with several traits in common. 
 The dividing line is tenuous in the extreme. 
 Many of the world's crops double as weeds. 
 This is as true of guavas and pomegranates as it is of maize and rice, as true of lettuce and asparagus as it is of cabbages and carrots. 
 At the same time, weeds often see service as crops. 
 Of the world's 17 worst weeds, 13 are exploited by mankind, often as animal fodder, medicines, or potherbs. 
 Five of those are cultivated. 
 Keeler has been musing on the nature of weediness and the likelihood of it evolving among engineered crops. 
 Weediness is widely held to reside in a set of 13 traits, bearing on such matters as general hardiness, competitiveness, reproductive habits and germination of seed. 
 Keeler wondered how many of these traits were needed to transform a well-behaved plant into a pest. 
 To find the answer, she turned to a published league table of the world's worst weeds. 
 She analysed each member of this roll of dishonour, looking for the 13 hallmarks of weediness. 
 The average score was 11, with one contender, the purple nutsedge, gaining full marks. 
 Keeler's conclusion is that a weed must bear 10 or 11 of the tell-tale traits to be seriously weedy. 
 The argument now takes an ingenious turn. 
 Suppose, says Keeler, that we apply the same analysis to other groups of plants &mdash; crops, say &mdash; and tot up their score on the scale of weediness. 
 Subtract that figure from the score notched up by the weeds and we shall then be in a position to predict the number of traits that an average crop plant would have to acquire in order to become weedy. 
 (The word &bquo;average&equo; is important: the results of the analysis do not apply to any specific case.) 
 To complete the picture, Keeler also took the measure of a group of 20 randomly chosen wild plants from the British flora. 
 The wild flowers managed an average score of 7 &frac12; out of a possible 13. 
 For a random selection of 20 crops, the score was 5. 
 Ordinary wild plants, it seems, are weedier than crops, but both have a long way to go to catch up with the real pests. 
 On average, it would take at least five or six genetic changes to turn a crop into a dangerous weed. 
 Such a major transformation is highly unlikely. 
 Many crops are grown from seed every year and so all the necessary genetic mutations would have to happen to a single plant within one growing season. 
 On average, the chances of weediness emerging by accident are vanishingly small. 
 Yet this generalisation will not bear too much weight. 
 Weedy strains already exist in at least six of Keeler's 20 randomly chosen crops &mdash; notably oats, sunflowers, rice and sweet potatoes. 
 This is despite the fact that they carry only a minority of the 13 stigmata of weediness. 
 Small genetic changes might conceivably aggravate their nuisance value. 
 The tomato and the strawberry are more problematic. 
 Although awarded seven marks apiece &mdash; making them weedier than that old stalwart, the creeping thistle &mdash; they are not widely viewed as potential threats. 
 As these examples suggest, there is more to weediness than meets the eye. 
 A plant can be an obedient herb in one habitat and a rumbustious weed somewhere else. 
 The botanical annals are full of examples of plants that were introduced into a novel area, only to become seriously weedy &mdash; witness the prickly pear's progress in Australia and South Africa, or the rhododendron in Britain. 
 Weediness, it would seem, cannot be fully described simply by totting up a score. 
 It is also necessary to understand the subtle interactions between the plant and its surroundings &mdash; interactions which, if upset, can transform a civilised Jekyll into a rampaging Hyde. 
 Some ecologists see a parallel between introduced plants and engineered ones. 
 The resemblance could be particularly close if breeders were installing some trait that allowed the crop to thrive in a new habitat, or one that shielded it from parasites or diseases. 
 To predict the fate of such a crop &mdash; and its prospects of proving weedy &mdash; research must focus on the plant's most intimate dealings with its environment. 
 At Imperial College's field station at Silwood Park, Mick Crawley is setting up a series of such experiments as part of Prosamo, a research programme funded by the Agricultural and Food Research Council, the Department of Trade and Industry and a consortium of companies. 
 Prosamo (which stands for planned release of selected and modified organisms) is sponsoring a wide range of studies on the behaviour of genetically engineered organisms in the environment. 
 Crawley will compare the ecology of engineered and conventional varieties of three crops: potatoes, oilseed rape and sugar beet. 
 In carefully designed field trials, he will explore whether the engineered plants behave normally or abnormally towards their pathogens, competitors, herbivores and the physical environment. 
 The eventual aim is find out whether engineered genes render a crop plant more aggressive than its traditional relatives &mdash; and more likely to decamp from cultivation. 
 It is an important experiment and one that could play a key role in securing public approval, or disapproval, for genetic engineering. 
 Character defect&hellip; even the vibrant sunflower contains weedy strains OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sc 
 Introns. 
 Dice rolling with the times. 
 Electronics John Webb. 
 THE centuries-old five-dice game of liardice &mdash; or liar's dice as it is called in North America &mdash; has a modern problem. 
 It needs space to throw the dice and this is not practical in planes and trains where it can do most to relieve the boredom of a long journey. 
 This dilemma for a game with millions of followers worldwide has proved to be a &bquo;bunch of sixes&equo; opportunity for Welsh inventor Don Hughes, a self-confessed liardice buff, who claims to have beaten the Far East electronics industry literally at its own game by developing an electronic version that is hardly bigger than a credit card. 
 The tiny instrument is an interesting example of the latest gate-array-chip technology. 
 It generates the random numbers for the dice from reading the device's internal clocks at the instant the &bquo;roll&equo; button is pressed. 
 Mr Hughes believes it is the only such electronic game aimed at an adult market and the only one not designed and manufactured in the Far East. 
 It could prove to be a good roll of the dice, for Mr Hughes has also written a book on the mathematics of five-dice games and devised special packaging to exploit the game's addictiveness by allowing it to be played while it is hanging from the supermarket shelf. 
 Mapping the universe. 
 Astrophysics Piyush Ojha. 
 MARGARET Geller and John Huchra of the Harvard-Smithsonian Centre for Astrophysics have discovered a thin sheet of galaxies measuring at least 200 million by 500 million light years, which stretches across the sky like a giant canopy. 
 They call this structure &bquo;The Great Wall&equo;. 
 Its existence casts doubt on the current astronomical theory of the distribution of galaxies and the large-scale structure of the universe. 
 The observation of the Great Wall has come from an ambitious project to map the positions of all visible galaxies which are brighter than a specified minimum. 
 The survey &mdash; &bquo;mapping the universe&equo; &mdash; which Geller and Huchra began a few years ago is not yet complete but they have seen enough to conclude that &bquo;the size of the largest structures we detect is limited only by the extent of the survey&equo;. 
 Astronomers know that the early universe was uniform because a remnant of that period, the cosmic microwave background radiation which bathes the Earth from all directions, is remarkably uniform. 
 The problem in understanding the present structure of the universe is that, after evolving for 10 billion years following the big bang, it has become very clumpy and matter has aggregated into galaxies and clusters and superclusters of galaxies. 
 An acceptable theory must explain in detail how this clumping of matter has occurred in the time available for it. 
 The larger the largest structure in the universe the more difficult it becomes to reconcile it with the uniform distribution of matter in the early universe. 
 (Science, vol 246, page 897). 
 Secrets of the flying lizards. 
 Zoology Mike Taylor. 
 THE butterfly lizard leiolepis bellani lives near beaches and sandy areas in tropical South-east Asia. 
 Its main claim to fame is its elongated ribs with which the lizard can extend a short fringe of skin along either side of its body, at the same time flattening its body. 
 The beast, it has been alleged, flies away from trouble: if surprised away from its burrow, it starts running, then opens its fringes to take off and glide for up to 20 yards. 
 J.B.Losos, T.J.Papenfuss and J.R.Macey of the University of California took a critical look at this notion by putting a team of 40 butterfly lizards through full athletic trials. 
 Their captive specimens could not be persuaded to leap horizontally for over two yards. 
 When the lizards were dropped, they held their legs and tails out like good free-fall parachutists. 
 Their fringes slowed their rate of descent by 5 per cent compared to other lizards of the same size. 
 But those other species also adopt the &bquo;free-fall&equo; position, so there is nothing very special about the butterfly lizard's aeronautical abilities. 
 Losos and his colleagues now believe that the fringes have several other uses. 
 The lizards seem to use their fringes to absorb heat while basking in the sun. 
 Lizards frightened by a predator also spread them to make themselves seem bigger than they really are, and more difficult to eat. 
 Males have brightly striped fringes and flash them at each other when displaying during combat. 
 The scientists' work confirmed their initial suspicions: that the undoubted improvement in parachuting ability was a fortuitous result of the development of the fringes for these other purposes. 
 But if the lizards ever took to forest or crag life, the fringes would be a preadaptation to leaping and parachuting, and &mdash; perhaps &mdash; a nudge towards the evolution of gliding, independently of the modern flying lizard draco volans. 
 (Journal of Zoology, vol, 217, 559-568) OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sci 
 Rapidly growing environmental fears have made climate research more important then ever &mdash; and Europe is forging ahead in the field with the planned launch of the ERS-1. 
 As Nicholas Booth reports, Britain is playing a prominent role in a complex satellite which could unveil the mysteries of the Earth's resources The Euro-eyes of the world. 
 IN THE YEAR that saw mankind's first wave of planetary exploration reach a glorious climax with Voyager 2's passage of Neptune, it is clear that new space efforts will concentrate on the third planet from the Sun. 
 Already trumpeted as &bquo;A Mission To Earth&equo; by Nasa, climate research has gained new prominence, chiming with the rise in environmental concerns the world over. 
 It's an area in which Europe has forged ahead and which, against all the odds, is actively supported by our very own government. 
 For once, the UK is in the good books of the European Space Agency (ESA) for our support of the European Remote Sensing (ERS) programme, which will use the most complex satellites it has ever attempted to build. 
 &bquo;It's one of the most important projects we have for the 1990s,&equo; says Philip Goldsmith, head of Earth observation at the European Space Agency. 
 ERS-1 is currently under test in Toulouse, scheduled for launch next October, at least two years before any other satellites as part of an international monitoring programme for the 1990s. 
 Whilst other space agencies have equally ambitious plans, they remain as blueprints, or, as one European scientist puts it, &bquo;pie-in-the-sky-eyes-in-the-sky.&equo; 
 ERS-1 has five instruments which will scan the Earth at microwave wavelengths to monitor ocean, ice and land resources. 
 Microwave techniques will enable ERS-1 to return data continuously: they can &bquo;see&equo; through cloud and operate at night. 
 Orbiting the Earth at 780 kilometres altitude, ERS-1 will fly over the poles on each orbit and its instruments will cover the whole of the globe during three days. 
 So for oceanographers, used to data returned from ships in commercial shipping lanes, ERS-1 will give a totally global picture of the seas. 
 Two of the ERS instruments have been provided by the UK. 
 The Active Microwave Instrument radar system, built by Marconi Space Systems, is significant because it can be used over land or ocean: it will return vital information about how the wind interacts with waves. 
 How the wind affects the ocean and modifies the heat exchanged with the atmosphere is not well understood, but is of paramount importance to weather forecasters who cannot wait for ERS-1 to begin operations. 
 Though ESA admits there have been electronic problems with one of the system's processors, it's hardly surprising. 
 &bquo;It's the most complex instrument we've ever built,&equo; says Joe McCaughey, Marconi's project manager. 
 &bquo;ERS as a whole is a quantum leap for Europe.&equo; 
 The Rutherford Appleton Laboratory in Oxfordshire has provided the Along-Track Scanning Radiometer, an infrared instrument which will measure sea surface temperatures down to 0.3C. 
 &bquo;There are Americans who'd give their eye teeth for this sort of data,&equo; says one ERS project scientist at the laboratory. 
 This greater accuracy will allow the heat transfer between the oceans and the atmosphere to be better computed. 
 Commercially, the ATSR data will allow fishing vessels to &bquo;home in&equo; on the edges of sea currents where fish congregate to feed on nutrients brought up from the ocean floor. 
 But the emphasis for ERS-1 is science, as the ERS programme is ESA's contribution to Woce, the World Ocean Circulation Experiment, an important part of global climate research in the 1990s. 
 The way in which the atmosphere interacts with the oceans remains a last great unknown in Earth science. 
 Similarly, the mechanisms for heat transport in ocean currents is also mysterious, as the amounts of both heat and water within them is not well defined. 
 Nearly 10 per cent of the Earth's surface is covered by ice, which remains as terra incognita to climatologists as it was to 17th-century explorers. 
 Ice coverage limits the exchange of heat between the atmosphere and ocean, effectively &bquo;insulating&equo; polar regions from sunlight during summertime. 
 &bquo;You'd be amazed how little we know about the polar regions,&equo; says Dr Preben Goodmandsen of the Technical University of Denmark. 
 &bquo;During the wintertime, there's no sunlight. 
 ERS, with its microwave sensors, will give us the best view we've ever had.&equo; 
 There are no exact figures for the rates at which ice melts and refreezes, mechanisms which have affected sea level changes. 
 ERS-1 is expected to return the first quantitive data on these processes at the poles. 
 &bquo;The key to the ERS programme is continuity,&equo; says Guy Duchossois of ESA headquarters. 
 The agency has plans to launch a second craft in April 1994, at about the time that the first satellite reaches the end of its operational life. 
 Climate modelling and assessing environmental change will need more than three years' data if it is to be enhanced. 
 After refusing to sanction the project, the UK is now providing funding. 
 Perhaps more importantly, governmental space sources relate that Margaret Thatcher is behind ERS-2. 
 &bquo;She knows about ERS-2 and is enthusiastic about it,&equo; says one. 
 At present, only France has not given its go-ahead for ERS-2 funding. 
 Dr Issac Revah, of the French space agency CNES, says: &bquo;We too are behind the project. 
 It's just a matter of finding the money.&equo; 
 Next week, in Paris, ESA's governing body of national representatives meets to discuss ERS-2 amongst other future plans. 
 While France prevaricates, other nations are expressing interest in the ERS programme. 
 India, Pakistan, Indonesia, Brazil and Kenya have asked to receive data from ERS-1, which will be made available to them within three hours of it being transmitted from the satellite. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sc 
 Birth of hope Television. 
 By Nancy Banks-Smith A child, more than any other thing, Brings hope with it and forward looking thoughts Wordsworth 
 AYEAR ago yesterday 25,000 people died in Armenia in 41 seconds. 
 I had forgotten. 
 Astrik was still shaking. 
 Both her children died in the earthquake, her parents, her husband's parents, her brother's wife, his children. 
 &bquo;To us it feels like yesterday. 
 We can't talk about anything else. 
 Nothing interests us in life.&equo; 
 Her face was the candlelit colour of tallow. 
 She was heavily pregnant. 
 A home movie taken at a party just before the earthquake showed her dancing, a pretty young woman, a little overweight, a little overdressed. 
 &bquo;Before the earthquake I used to dress in bright colours. 
 I had all the cosmetics a woman could want. 
 I liked to dress up and go out a lot. 
 The earthquake changed everything. 
 Now I can't wear any colour but black. 
 Black is my colour now.&equo; 
 To say she was beautiful now is frivolous. 
 She was biblical. 
 &bquo;My pain is unbearable,&equo; she said, her voice thickened with salt like the Dead Sea. 
 &bquo;They have gone and we can't get them back. 
 There is no God. 
 Let no-one blame me. 
 There is no God for us.&equo; 
 Armenia is a profoundly Christian country, gnawed at by Muslim neighbours. 
 When the bells rang and the bishop blessed the people and her cousin, Gayane, went to church, holding a child by each hand, Astrik turned her waxen face away. 
 Gayane had lost no children. 
 But on the Day of the Dead she went to the cemetery and cried out over the sound of her own deep sobbing &bquo;Mama, you are lucky not to see us so unhappy. 
 Where are you, my Gohar?&equo; 
 Gohar was her four-year-old daughter. 
 At times she seemed actually demented. 
 &bquo;Tell Uncle Ashot you want to bring Gohar back,&equo; she said to Gayane's little daughter. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said the child, startled. 
 &bquo;I will go to bring my Gohar back in five days,&equo; Astrik went on dreamily. 
 &bquo;Can you count five on your fingers? 
 I'm going to the cemetery. 
 Will you come with me?&equo; 
 Her baby was due in five days and it had tasted nothing but tears. 
 &bquo;I am impatient but worried. 
 Suppose something is wrong with her mind.&equo; 
 She and her husband never doubted it would be a girl. 
 They were going to call her Gohar. 
 She would change their lives. 
 The hospital in Leninakan is bare as a garage. 
 The red robe they gave her there was the first bright colour she had worn. 
 Husbands are not allowed in the hospital so her husband Ashot &mdash; a big man, mostly moustache &mdash; waited outside. 
 It was a strong baby, bedraggled and bloody, as if pulled from some ruin. 
 Swilled quickly in a tin bath, it hung over the nurse's hand like a wet sock. 
 She slapped it. 
 It cried. 
 &bquo;A beautiful baby girl,&equo; she said and swaddled it tightly as is the custom. 
 The camera moved slowly up the side of the hospital. 
 First three nurses, wearing their strange tall hats. 
 Then Astrik, smiling dazzlingly, holding up Gohar to show her husband in the street below. 
 After the earthquake a neighbour told her &bquo;Don't cry. 
 Your daughter is in the hospital.&equo; 
 It was not true. 
 At the time. 
 This 40 Minutes Special (BBC 2) was produced by Agnieszka Piotrowska, who never makes a bad programme and hasn't made a better one than this. 
 It was, not inappropriately, made in association with Try Again Ltd. 
 THE delicious Victorian Kitchen (BBC 2), successor to The Victorian Kitchen Garden, ended with a bit of a blow out. 
 The only reason affluent Victorians did not physically explode like Henry VIII (after he was dead, naturally) was their habit of heaping the dinner table with exotic greenery. 
 Sometimes you could not see the food for the trees. 
 A banquet could evidently develop into a nasty clash between the cook and the gardener. 
 &bquo;We can't let them get away with that,&equo; said Mrs Mott eyeing Harry Dodson's looped festoons of smilax, positively growing before her eyes. 
 &bquo;We've got to do as good as they have.&equo; 
 Steam issuing out of her ears like a kettle, she went back to the kitchen and spun sugar with some gusto. 
 It hung glittering like early morning cobwebs on her rolling pin. 
 There will be a third series, The Victorian Flower Garden, in two years. 
 Well, I know but roses won't be rushed. 
 Stratford. 
 By Michael Billington The Duchess of Malfi. 
 SHAW dubbed Webster &bquo;the Tussaud laureate&equo;. 
 But Bill Alexander's powerful new production of The Duchess of Malfi at The Swan treats him not as a lurid Jacobean sensationalist but as a sombre, death-haunted melancholic. 
 The production doesn't have the imagistic verve of Adrian Noble's great Royal Exchange version in l980 but it is beautifully acted and rivets our attention on the fierce particularity of Webster's language. 
 Instead of opting for generalized decadence and satanic luxury, Mr Alexander and his designer, Fotini Dimou, locate the action in a precise world: Naples in 1504 under Spanish rule and Catholic sway. 
 It is a milieu of distant anthems and religious iconography. 
 Even when the lubricious Cardinal is titillated by his chair-straddling mistress, it is in the shadow of an overhanging jewelled crucifix. 
 What Mr Alexander establishes is the vital contrast between external sanctity and order and the lust, violence, madness and panic that fuel the characters' actions. 
 He also clearly makes a point I had never considered before: that Bosola, the eternal outsider and masterless man, is not simply some rogue assassin but the author's moral spokesman. 
 Nigel Terry plays him most intelligently, not just as a mercenary hit-man but as a soft-spoken scholar obsessed by mortality. 
 His gravitas, offset with a flickering irony, gives the production a strong moral centre. 
 But it is the Duchess herself who most obviously embodies those qualities of courage and fidelity that act as an antidote to the surrounding evil. 
 Harriet Walter plays her excellently as a woman who combines a strong sexuality with a defiant nobility of character. 
 She woos Antonio with tremulous lip and speaking eye; she stands up to her incestuously possessive brother, Ferdinand, with blazing authority. 
 But, interestingly, she treats &bquo;I am Duchess of Malfi still&equo; not as a ringing, operatic cry but as a simple statement of fact. 
 Ms Walter offers us not a contralto tragedy-queen but a real woman passionately attached to her husband (to whom Mick Ford lends a shy goodness) and children. 
 But the whole thrust of this production is to undercut rhetoric and to give Webster's pithy, metaphysical images their due weight. 
 Bruce Alexander thus plays the lycanthropic Ferdinand not as some howling lunatic but as a haunted, guilt-ridden creature. 
 Conscience, in fact, is still alive in this world of Neapolitan terror so that even Russell Dixon's Cardinal, having murdered his mistress (the fetching Patricia Kerrigan) on a poisoned Bible, ritually crosses himself and gently caresses her hair. 
 Instead of melodrama, we get tragedy. 
 Instead of the medical materialism of Hammer horror, we get a surprisingly restrained treatment of the play's fuliginous cruelties: even when the Duchess is invaded by a chorus of madmen, they are ushered in one at a time by a beady-eyed supervisor wielding a corrective cane. 
 My one reservation is that Mr Alexander denies himself expressive use of light and sound to convey atmosphere and leaves us with few memorable images. 
 In striving for sobriety, his production is just a shade dry. 
 Coliseum. 
 By Edward Greenfield Love for Three Oranges. 
 EVERY year the English National Opera at the Coliseum makes a shrewd choice of pieces for the Christmas season, pantomimes mainly for adults. 
 This year as well as a revival of the updated Hansel and Gretel in two weeks time, we have the most fizzing pantomime in years, Prokofiev's Love for Three Oranges. 
 It is the co-production with Opera North first seen in Leeds just over a year ago. 
 Under David Atherton's direction the Coliseum presentation fizzes musically from first to last. 
 The amazing thing is how well it has been translated to the large expanses of the Coliseum, not an easy place to raise laughs in. 
 Michael Druiett as the Herald, formally introducing the piece and explaining how the smell-cards (courtesy of Givenchy) will work, gets a winning tone of voice from the very start. 
 Admittedly the fun relies too relentlessly on schoolboyish anal humour &mdash; amusing at first, quickly a bore. 
 But the sheer high spirits, the idea of an over-the-top romp, matches the spiritedness of the music. 
 This was the exiled Prokofiev's very Russian response to the fantastic Gozzi fairy-tale of the hypochondriac prince who goes in search of three oranges, each containing a princess. 
 The wit and elegance of the Glyndebourne production with its sets by Maurice Sendak may be missing, but there is ample compensation in the sheer exuberance of this entertainment with its riproaring belly-laughs. 
 The Herald began the evening with the extra duty of announcing that one of the principals, Bonaventura Bottone as the clown Truffaldino, was suffering from severe flu. 
 But as it emerged, his was the performance which caught fire quicker than any, helped by the deftly-timed efforts of a double doing spectacular somersaults. 
 Bottone, looking like a cross between Woody Allen, Harold Lloyd and Billy Bunter, was in brilliant form, whatever his temperature. 
 It helped to have two such formidable singers taking the two female dragon roles: Anne Collins as a fruity Princess Clarissa, tyrannical in a general's uniform of black leather, and Jane Eaglen as Fata Morgana, like Katisha in Mikado only more so. 
 Richard Angas, physically monstrous as the Mikado in the ENO production, and equally as Jupiter in Offenbach's Orpheus, is ideally cast here as the gigantic cook, protecting the three oranges. 
 Alan Woodrow sings with trumpet tones as the Prince. 
 And when the third and surviving princess emerges from her orange, Lesley Garrett immediately makes up for lost time, singing ravishingly. 
 Best of all is Donald Maxwell, marvellously sinister as the hunchback Prime Minister, Leander, sidling on in a way to chill the blood. 
 PAGE 
 Just colour me Jesse Arts diary. 
 By David Rowan 
 ANEW portrait of Jesse Jackson, showing him as a blond, blue-eyed white man, attracted more than aesthetic interest when it was displayed on a Washington street corner last Wednesday. 
 Ten black men took a sledge-hammer to the work, and knocked off a large part of his face. 
 Jackson, who described the action as an &bquo;artistic&equo; response to racism, said that the painting-How Ya Like Me Now? by David Hammons-should be put back on display together with the sledge-hammer. 
 THE people at the Museum of the Moving Image are becoming rather excited about a new exhibit being installed on Monday Dec 11: a full organza dress, lined with peach silk crepe de chine, and decorated with ivory re-embroidered lace, crystal beading, peach silk chiffon and some hand-dyed rosettes. 
 Not a Julian Clary costume-but Charlene's wedding dress from Neighbours, as worn by Kylie Minogue. 
 Indeed a moving image&hellip; 
 THE National Theatre is breaking its long repertory tradition next March to stage a straight 16-week run of the Sondheim musical Sunday In The Park With George. 
 It will be the show's British premiere, but critics have expressed fears that the long run may set a precedent, making the National like any other West End theatre. 
 The decision was an &bquo;effective way of helping our situation&equo; when the National was expecting a mere two per cent rise in its Arts Council grant, according to a spokesman. 
 Since then, however, funding has been increased. 
 &bquo;There's nothing sinister about it,&equo; the spokesman said yesterday. 
 &bquo;We're doing it because it's one of the great modern musicals&hellip;. 
 It is more expensive to stage than a straight play. 
 Although we're not talking Miss Saigon&hellip;.&equo; 
 LAST week Guardian readers voted Terry and June the television sitcom they would least like to see revived. 
 This week Robin Nash, responsible for sitcoms including Terry and June, was appointed the new head of comedy at BBC television. 
 Let no politician claim that there is a bias within the corporation towards the Guardian. 
 BRIGHT young things used to kill to break into theatre. 
 Nowadays not even luncheon vouchers can attract them, according to the Royal Court Young People's Theatre. 
 It is trying to find 30 young unemployed people to join a 16-week project exploring attitudes towards HIV and Aids, and is even offering &pound;10 a week above unemployment benefit, travel expenses, luncheon vouchers, and &pound;50 a week for child care. 
 Hannah Vincent, a young playwright, will write a play based on the group's workshops, and it will be performed throughout Westminster, Brent and North Kensington. 
 &bquo;It's an amazing opportunity to break in to theatre, but we've had virtually no response from Jobcentres,&equo; a spokeswoman says. 
 But then the starving thesp always had more street cred than the vouchered&hellip; 
 STEPHEN Hawking, Lucasian Professor of Mathematics at Cambridge, is to star in a Stephen Spielberg television film based on his book A Brief History Of Time. 
 Spielberg, accustomed to close encounters in the extra-terrestrial sphere, has offered to be creative consultant on a drama-documentary loosely based upon the book, which has sold over 300,000 hardback copies in the UK and has been reprinted fourteen times. 
 &bquo;There's been nothing like it since the Bible,&equo; said an obviously excited spokesperson for the book's publishers, Transworld. 
 Hawking meanwhile, has a simple explanation for its success: &bquo;Someone told me that each equation I included in the book would halve the sales. 
 I therefore resolved not to have any equations at all.&equo; 
 Gloomy prospects for retail trade. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 BRITAIN'S shopkeepers are gloomier than at any time since the early 1980s, according to a survey published yesterday. 
 Retailers, wholesalers and motor traders all expect their businesses to become worse over the next three months. 
 Higher mortgage rates have already had an impact on spending, according to the latest survey of distributive trades from the Confederation of British Industry. 
 Many borrowers whose mortgage repayments change only annually will feel the impact of higher interest rates only next month. 
 Those sectors closest to the housing market, including builders' merchants and retailers of furniture, carpets and household goods were the most pessimistic. 
 Among DIY and hardware retailers, only one in a hundred expects business to get better in the next three months. 
 Figures from Grand Metropolitan yesterday also show that higher interest rates have had a big impact on people's willingness to eat out. 
 The company said that the number of people eating in its Chef &amp; Brewer and Berni restaurants had fallen by about 10 per cent. 
 The CBI survey revealed that the majority of distributors feel that their stock levels are at an uncomfortably high level. 
 As they try to cut stocks, this is likely to make a big dent in orders to manufacturing industry and importers. 
 Few retailers expect their orders with suppliers this month to be higher than in December 1988. 
 For the first time since the survey was started six years ago, retailers, wholesalers and companies in the motor trade expect to cut investment in the coming year. 
 Only confectioners, tobacconists and newsagents remain optimistic: every other retailing sector identified in the CBI survey expects business to get tougher over the next three months. 
 Representatives from developers Olympia&amp;York and high street retailer Marks&amp;. 
 Spencer yesterday inspecting progress in the construction of the main shopping block at the &pound;4billion Canary Wharf development, which will include a new 13,000-square foot M&amp;S food hall. 
 M&amp;S is the first big retailer to move to Canary Wharf and its announcement yesterday to take space in the building is a boost of confidence for the 71-acre London Docklands project. 
 Once complete, it will provide 10 million square feet of office space and 250 shops within 500,000 square feet of retail area by 1997. 
 So far, a third of the office space in the first phase of eight buildings has been booked. 
 M&amp;S will join Texaco as one of the big-name occupiers of Canary Wharf, and Olympia&amp;York says it expects to announce several other tenants shortly. 
 However, the development has attracted criticism in the past months as a possible white elephant following the effect of the steep rise in interest rates on the economy. 
 Critics have also pointed to the lack of transport links to the development, but Olympia&amp;York denies that there will be a problem given the proposed extension of the Jubilee Line, increased capacity of the Light Docklands Railway, and the building of new roads. 
 Photograph: Martin Argles 
 As the season of goodwill gets into full swing, Jill Papworth looks at some presents which will still be appreciated on Boxing Day. 
 Counting the cost of mailing money 
 THE problem with sending Christmas gifts to children living overseas is that postage can double the price of the presents. 
 If you opt instead to send relatives and friends money to spend as they wish on their children, it's worth shopping around as costs differ considerably for the various methods. 
 All the banks and the Post Office strongly advise against sending cash. 
 route. 
 Likewise, sending British or Eurocheques can cause problems, delay and heavy charges for the recipient when he or she tries to cash them at a foreign bank. 
 The cheapest way is to buy and send postal orders in various denominations which are acceptable in around 60 countries. 
 Bought over the Post Office counter, postal orders are both traceable and give you a counterfoil to prove they have been sent. 
 A &pound;20 order, for example, will cost 62p. 
 International money orders, available in sterling or US dollars from Barclays, or dollars only from Lloyds and the Royal Bank of Scotland, are the next best bet. 
 The Royal Bank's new American Express-backed orders, valued up to &dollar;1,000, cost just &pound;3 each and can be cashed by the recipient at any Amex travel office. 
 The drawback is that both the sender and the recipient, if living outside the US, are at the mercy of prevailing exchange rates and foreign banks may charge a commission. 
 Banker's drafts come a little more expensive but can be bought in any currency. 
 Girobank charges a flat fee of &pound;5 per draft and Barclays &pound;9. 
 NatWest, Lloyds and RBS all charge 0.25 per cent of the value but with varying minimum fees. 
 Midland, the only bank to restrict its sending cash abroad service to existing customers, charges &pound;6 on drafts of up to &pound;100 and 0.5 per cent of the sterling value with a minimum charge of &pound;9 over that amount. 
 The above three methods, while allowing you to send a tangible piece of paper as a gift, do mean you incur postal costs and are reliant on UK and foreign postal systems. 
 Barclays, RBS and Midland all offer guaranteed methods of transferring money direct to a foreign recipient's bank through their own mailing systems, costing a minimum of &pound;7.50, &pound;6 and &pound;9. 
 But you have already missed the last postal dates for some countries, including Australia and New Zealand. 
 Monday is your last chance to send things by post to the US, Italy and Spain and Wednesday for the rest of Europe. 
 Your only option when sending money at the last minute to arrive by Christmas is to use the banks' electronic money transfer services which take from 24 hours to around five days depending on the bank and whether you use an express transfer. 
 Charges and services offered vary among the main high street banks, though using the example of sending &pound;50 abroad NatWest and RBS work out the cheapest at &pound;6 for a standard transfer taking around 48 hours. 
 Girobank charges a flat fee of &pound;5 whatever the transfer value, but only to specific foreign banks and taking up to 10 working days. 
 Johnson Matthey hit by second departure. 
 By Financial Staff 
 JOHNSON MATTHEY, the precious metals to chemicals group, was given a respite from takeover speculation yesterday after its biggest shareholder, Charter Consolidated, said it had no plans to change its 38 per cent stake. 
 The news came as Johnson Matthey announced a second top-level boardroom departure within 24 hours. 
 On Wednesday night, the group announced that its chief executive, Mr Eugene Anderson, had resigned and yesterday Johnson Matthey said its chairman, Mr Neil Clark, would be retiring from the board at the end of the year. 
 A Johnson Matthey spokesman dismissed any suggestion of a boardoom rift and said that the two departures were &bquo;not particularly connected&equo;. 
 Mr Clark will be succeeded by Mr David Davies, who is currently deputy chairman of Charter Consolidated and a former chief executive of merchant bank Hill Samuel, now owned by TSB. 
 The role of chief executive has gone to executive director, Mr Joe Stevenson. 
 Mr Anderson, who joined the group in 1985, will remain a consultant. 
 Yesterday Johnson Matthey &mdash; which announced pre-tax profits of &pound;33.5million &mdash; said it &bquo;has been authorised by Charter to say that Charter has no present intention of either buying or selling shares in the company.&equo; 
 Profits climb at GUS. 
 Great Universal Stores, the biggest of the mail order firms, raised pre-tax profit by &pound;8million to &pound;171million in the six months to September, although catalogue sales and retail earnings slumped by &pound;8million. 
 A &pound;7million rise in trading profit came from the financial services division and from investment income, both lumped together in the accounts. 
 Financial services rose on the back of increased consumer spending on cars, according to the group, and was &bquo;almost buoyant&equo; in the half year although it has dropped back since September. 
 GUS has an unspecified cash pile and no borrowing, so is a beneficiary of high interest rates. 
 Mail order is suffering from the public's current reluctance to part with cash for non-essential goods. 
 &bquo;People seem prepared to buy food and cars but not clothes&equo;, says GUS's Trevor Spittle. 
 Property profits, &pound;4.8million in the six months against &pound;4.9 million last year, reflect the group's continued wish to weed out unwanted retail premises which are not on prime town centre sites.. 
 GWR issues warning. 
 Independent radio group, GWR, which joined the USM in March and recently merged with Consolidated Radio Holdings, has warned the media sector not to talk down the buoyancy of the industry. 
 The company, whose profits for the year to September rose by 16 per cent to &pound;1.66 million, said commercial opportunities, particularly for radio, were about to be expanded significantly. 
 The group's turnover rose from &pound;8.1 million to &pound;9.66 million and a final dividend of 9p a share was declared. 
 Setback for Archer. 
 The slump in insurance rates in the shipping and aviation market has hit the financial results of Lloyd's underwriting group, A J Archer, for the second year running. 
 Thanks to higher interest income, the group managed to nudge pre-tax profits &pound;227,000 ahead to &pound;6.3 million, but both turnover at &pound;7.5 million and operating profits were lower. 
 Archer, whose earnings per share in the year to September climbed from 15.6p to 17.1p, raised its final dividend from 4.25p to 5p. 
 Lovell advance. 
 YJ Lovell, which is currently bidding &pound;137million for fellow builder Higgs &amp; Hill says it is too soon to comment on current trading but its profits for the year to September 30, rose from &pound;24.4million to &pound;33.3million. 
 Chairman Andrew Wassell, who has been asked by the Takeover Panel to clarify his comments to the Guardian on Wednesday about the level of acceptances, said: &bquo;It is much too soon to know but I am encouraged by the efforts we are making in winning support for our bid.&equo;. 
 De La Rue retreats. 
 De La Rue's sale of the Crosfield Electronics printing equipment business did not relieve it of other losses in advanced security equipment and in spite of the new cash surplus, the interim results are grisly. 
 The main printing and payment systems activities are performing strongly and the new chief executive, Mr Jeremy Marshall, ex-BAA, needs time to show his worth. 
 Sales were no problem as the reduction in turnover to &pound;161 million, from &pound;247million in the corresponding half to September 30 translates wih the help of currency gains into a rise of 18 per cent in the businesses retained. 
 Pre-tax profit skidded to &pound;16.6 million, from &pound;23.4million. 
 There was more difficulty over the high tax charge and ACT relief and the interim dividend stays at 3.25p covered less than twice by almost halved earnings.. 
 In short&hellip; 
 UK PAPER, which is recommending a &pound;263million takeover bid from the Finnish Metsa-Serla group, has forecast that its profits for 1989 will be up from &pound;13.9million to &pound;15million and that its surplus land has been revalued at &pound;16.9million, which is equal to 17.4p a share. 
 PHOENIX TIMBER'S profit fell from &pound;995,000 to &pound;479,000 in the half year to September 30 after some pressure on mrgins. 
 BUNZL is raising &pound;55.6million from the sale of its US electrical products distributor EESCO. 
 The markets. 
 The market paused for breath yesterday with the FTSE index dipping seven points to 2346.7. 
 Trading statements and bid situations continued to provide plenty of work for analysts and recent buoyant sectors like properties, insurances, and stores ran into profit-taking. 
 Alphameric was the day's major casualty with its shares plunging 32 per cent to 23p as hopes for its profit recovery faded. 
 On results, Grand Metropolitan rose 19p to 581p but De la Rue lost 26p at 311p. 
 Hong Kong: Firmer. 
 Hang Seng index: 2,770.00 (2756.39). 
 Tokyo: Record highs. 
 Nikkei index: 37,858.11 (37,654.29). 
 Frankfurt: Slightly higher. 
 FAZ index: 714.00 (695.74). 
 Paris: Mostly higher. 
 CAC index: 547.8 (542.6). 
 Dixons set to seek bid probe. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 DIXONS, the electrical retailing giant, looks certain to launch a vigorous campaign for a Monopolies Commission investigation of the &pound;461million bid for the company by Kingfisher. 
 In mounting his assault on Wednesday, Kingfisher chief executive Geoffrey Mulcahy claimed a successful takeover would give the group 22 per cent of the British retail electrical market. 
 Kingfisher already owns 307 Comet electrical stores. 
 But Kingfisher's claim contradicts figures from independent market researchers Verdict. 
 They show that in 1988, Dixons had almost 18 per cent of the electrical market, Comet 7.6 per cent and Lasky &mdash; whose 58 outlets are now owned by Kingfisher &mdash; 1.2 per cent. 
 That suggests a successful Dixons takeover would give Kingfisher more than 26 per cent of the market &mdash; above the 25 per cent threshold which normally triggers a monopolies inquiry. 
 It emerged yesterday that Kingfisher's 22 per cent was derived by counting the rental of new televisions, video recorders and other hired electrical equipment in the market total. 
 &bquo;Buying, renting and various options in between are simply different ways of obtaining a piece of electrical equipment,&equo; said Mr Nigel Whittaker of Kingfisher. 
 &bquo;They are all part of the same market.&equo; 
 Mr Robert Schrager of Dixons said last night: &bquo;We would treat the Kingfisher figures with some scepticism. 
 It is up to the authorities to decide.&equo; 
 Dixons chairman Mr Stanley Kalms formally rejected the Kingfisher bid saying &bquo;it is making an opportunist bid during a downturn in the economic cycle.&equo; 
 Kingfisher yesterday tried to counter the view that its 120p-a-share bid for Dixons is only a sighting shot. 
 &bquo;They are blaming their current woes on the state of the market, when in truth, we would do a better job than the Dixons management in restructuring and repositioning the business,&equo; said a Kingfisher executive. 
 EMS &bquo;could spell mass unemployment&equo;. 
 By Mark Milner 
 BRITAIN could face a decade of high unemployment if it became a full member of the European Monetary System without a sharp fall in the pound, according to a pressure group, the Campaign for Work. 
 In a robust assessment of the relative merits of joining the exchange rate mechanism, it argues the ERM will not provide a &bquo;soft option&equo; compared with other methods of slowing down the economy. 
 Though the group believes Britain should join, it warns that it should only do so at an exchange rate of around DM2.40 to the pound &mdash; involving a 15 per cent devaluation from the current DM2.79. 
 &bquo;A high exchange rate and the monetary policy which underpins it is just as tough an instrument as domestic credit controls, tax increases or cuts in public expenditure.&equo; 
 The campaign argues that the use of high exchange rates to squeeze inflation &mdash; by hitting corporate profits and therefore companies abilities to award inflationary pay increases &mdash; is &bquo;not a subtle process&equo; but is simply the &bquo;brutal and old fashioned one of deflation.&equo; 
 It claims there is no evidence that ERM membership offers a less painful way of suppressing the spiral of wages and prices chasing each other higher. 
 The campaign also argues that Britain's trade deficit is unsustainable. 
 But though high interest rates will achieve an economic slowdown, they will also ensure that the inevitable devaluation of the pound will be more severe. 
 Official figures are hard to credit as families fail to claim benefit. 
 By Mike George 
 ASTAGGERING number of the hard-up are failing to claim benefit under the Family Credit Scheme &mdash; despite a recent change in government calculations. 
 Families struggling on low incomes can get help from the scheme provided at least one adult is working at least 24 hours a week. 
 When it was introduced in place of the old family income supplement scheme last year, just 38 per cent of those entitled claimed family credit. 
 The government subsequently altered its estimate of those able to claim and came up with a 50 per cent take-up rate. 
 And now Tony Newton's social security department is hoping a recent &pound;7 million advertising campaign will boost that to 60 per cent. 
 Family credit is a means tested benefit paid on top of wages, or earnings from self employment. 
 It is almost always paid to a woman. 
 To qualify you must be responsible for one or more children aged under 16, or under 19 if they are still in full-time non-advanced education. 
 Your savings must total less than &pound;6,000 though &pound;1 of &bquo;notional income&equo; is added in when working out your income level for every &pound;250 (or part thereof) of savings over &pound;3,000. 
 Any children's savings are ignored, unless one of them has over &pound;3,000, in which case you can't get family credit for that child. 
 The scheme is based on a so-called &bquo;applicable amount&equo;, currently &pound;54.80 a week. 
 Anybody whose income is less than this will get full family credit. 
 The payments are based on set amounts: &pound;33.60 for a lone parent or a couple: &pound;23.30 for each child aged 18: &pound;16.35 for each child aged 16 or 17: &pound;12.90 for each child aged 11 to 15, and &pound;7.30 for each one up to 10 years of age. 
 If your income is above &pound;54.80 a week, 70 per cent of the additional amount is cut from the set payments. 
 Sheila is a lone parent with two children, aged 13 and 15. 
 She works part-time, averaging 28 hours a week. 
 After paying tax and national insurance she gets &pound;75 a week take home pay. 
 This is &pound;20.20 above the &pound;54.80 applicable amount, and 70 per cent of this is &pound;14.14. 
 Her set amounts are &pound;33.60 as a lone parent, plus &pound;25.80 for the children. 
 That totals &pound;59.40, but &pound;14.14 is deducted, leaving her total family credit at &pound;45.26 a week. 
 Child benefit payments, one parent benefit, housing benefit, income support and mobility and attendance allowances are all ignored as incomes for the purposes of family credit. 
 So Sheila's actual income is &pound;75 from earnings, plus &pound;14.50 child benefit (&pound;7.25 each), &pound;5.20 one parent benefit and &pound;45.26 from Family Credit. 
 Earnings are always taken net of tax and national insurance. 
 For those who are weekly paid, normal earnings are estimated by looking at the last five weeks pay, or the last two months for the monthly paid. 
 For the self-employed it is either the last 26 weeks or the last year's set of accounts which are used. 
 Self-employed child minders only have one third of their net earnings taken into account as income, the rest is ignored. 
 Family credit is also available on unemployment benefit, although this is counted as income. 
 Pam and Errol have two children, aged 13 and 16. 
 Errol is on unemployment benefit of &pound;34.70 a week, while Pam is bringing home &pound;75 a week. 
 This adds up to &pound;109.70, some &pound;54.90 above the applicable amount, and 70 per cent of that is &pound;38.43. 
 Their set amount for family credit is &pound;62.85, from which &pound;38.43 is deducted, leaving a final payment of &pound;24.42. 
 With child benefit included their income has been increased from &pound;124.20 to &pound;148.62 a week. 
 If one partner has been getting statutory sick or maternity pay for a continuous period of 13 weeks or more, this is counted as income. 
 Otherwise these payments are ignored. 
 Family credit lasts for 26 weeks at a time, then you will have to reapply. 
 However, it will end sooner if someone else claims income support or family credit in respect of a child who was included in your family credit award. 
 If you feel that your award is wrong in some way you can ask for the decision to be reviewed or make an appeal &mdash; details of how to do this are available from social security benefit offices. 
 If you're getting housing benefit this will be affected if you claim a family credit award, as your income will increase. 
 In some cases this may make the prospect of an award less attractive. 
 Some local authorities also assume you're getting family credit, even if you haven't claimed it, and so reduce your housing benefit. 
 Ferranti and Germans &bquo;reach deal&equo;. 
 By Mark Milner 
 TROUBLED defence electronics group Ferranti International Signal is reported to have reached a compromise with West Germany's Telefunken Systems Teknik over their rival bids to supply the radar for the European Fighter Aircraft. 
 However there were indications yesterday that it may be limited to proposals as to how the two would cooperate if they were ordered to combine their efforts by the NATO European Fighter Management Agency, which is responsible for purchasing the system. 
 There were also suggestions that Telefunken is already going cool on the terms of the compromise because they would not allow the West German group a large enough share of work on what is regarded as one of the key military avionics technologies. 
 The two firms are said to have indicated to NEFMA they would be able to work on the basis of Ferranti using a Telefunken-made data processor in its ECR-90 radar, he said. 
 The EFA radar contract is thought to be worth around &pound;1.5billion to the consortium which wins the contract. 
 Of the four partners in the EFA project, Britain, Italy and Spain are thought to favour the Ferranti consortium &mdash; which also includes West Germany's Siemens &mdash; but the West German government prefers the Telefunken option. 
 The deadlock has meant the award of the contract is now well behind the original schedule. 
 The outcome is crucial to the future of Ferranti in the wake of the discovery of bogus contracts at its ISC Technologies subsidiary which forced the group to write off more than &pound;200million. 
 Not only would winning the order mean around some &pound;60 million worth of work a year for the next decade for Ferranti, but it would give a successful bidder or partner for Ferranti access to crucial next-generation radar technology. 
 Analysts do not expect any move for Ferranti until the radar contract is awarded, though one possible bidder &mdash; British Aerospace &mdash; has already ruled itself out. 
 Industry sources however suggest that the contract is extremely important to Telefunken, which is now part of the giant Daimler-Benz industrial combine. 
 Daimler has increasingly concentrated its defence activities on aerospace and the loss of the EFA radar contract would be a severe blow. 
 Reports of the compromise emerged on the same day the contract for the EFA's main electrical generator was awarded to a consortium including Ferranti and Telefunken. 
 Defence firms must take different tack in the new Europe Notebook. 
 By Edited by Alex Brummer 
 AFTER the string of contract calamities, which has sent the Serious Fraud Office globetrotting, Sir Derek Alun-Jones and his beleaguered Ferranti team must now see a small chink of light. 
 Instead of prolonging the dogfight with West Germany's Telefunken over their rival bids for the radar contract for the European Fighter Aircraft, the two hi-tech defence manufacturers have decided to do the really European thing and co-operate; Ferranti would use the Telefunken data-processor in its ECR-90 radar. 
 If this outline deal is approved by the authorities, it may put into question British Aerospace's abrupt decision to pull out of its Ferranti offer &mdash; or at least seek to renegotiate the deal. 
 But while the ups and downs of Ferranti's future remain of keen interest, not least to its management, workers and shareholders, there are wider questions to be addressed as the Nato European Fighter Management Agency plunges into its final decisions on the European Fighter Project. 
 What appeared an important strand in forward-looking European defence planning only a few years ago &mdash; when the new Europe sought a measure of independence from the US defence umbrella &mdash; looks more questionable now. 
 Who exactly is the Euro-fighter meant to defend Britannia and our European allies against now that the Berlin Wall is down, the Soviet Union is rushing towards disarmament and the Warsaw Pact has suddenly become the best investment opportunity since the post-war Marshall Plan? 
 Before embarking on what will inevitably be a huge investment, would it not be better to wait and see just how the next round of arms negotiations comes out. 
 If the after-Malta optimism is anything to go by, Europe may end up selling its costly fighter to Middle Eastern potentates. 
 This would almost certainly be at a loss. 
 Far better, perhaps, to concentrate on civil aviation. 
 US carriers and Lufthansa, among others, are champing at the bit for new Berlin and East German air routes now that the air corridors, carved out in 1948, are becoming obsolete. 
 The East German airline Interflug and even Aeroflot have placed modest orders for the Airbus, which could quickly become vast were air corridors and airports to be opened and hard currency loans to become more freely available as Western economic assistance begins to flow. 
 Far better to build more advanced Airbuses for a new market than a Euro-fighter to take on a non-existent enemy which is increasingly an economic partner. 
 We must not let our defences down, Mrs Thatcher and other cautious voices would argue. 
 They are right. 
 There may well be new instabilities. 
 Even so, it would still be far cheaper to do what Europe had planned, before an upsurge of Euro-nationlism, and buy US 
 F-15s and F-16s off the shelf rather than waste vast development costs which could be better deployed in the commercial sector. 
 It may not be what Ferranti wants to hear. 
 But for others in civil aviation, from BAA (which has been looking at airport facilities in Budapest) to carriers such as KLM and Interflug, which are anxious for the markets, it would be just the thing. 
 Running risks. 
 THE Lloyd's of London insurance market has an unhappy knack of slipping on banana skins. 
 That probably accounts for some of the scepticism after the decision to ape stock market precedent and end business barriers between underwriters. 
 Few would question Lloyd's determination to win business which now walks past its door and intorivals such as Commercial Union. 
 No one would doubt the market's need to deploy its &pound;11billion capacity more effectively &mdash; some marine syndicates work at less than half strength while syndicates in different businesses are pushing their limits. 
 Lloyd's needs to get a grip on more &bquo;safe&equo; business to offset its increasing tendency to be at the wrong end of big disasters such as Piper Alpha. 
 And the market needs to establish its credentials in Europe unless it wants to risk being a perpetual also-ran to the likes of Generali, Allianz or Swiss Re. 
 But occasional forays by underwriters into unknown territory have thrown up some of the market's most spectacular disasters &mdash; the 1,600 investors facing &pound;305million of losses on Dick Outhwaite's syndicate bear eloquent testimony to that. 
 Professional qualifications in the market are few, although basic examinations are being introduced. 
 Lloyd's is insisting underwriters must join the market association for the class of business they undertake, but quality policing will fall on the shoulders of managing agents. 
 In practice, the hoped-for package business will probably be handled by composite syndicates formed from the merger of existing specialists, so the quality of underwriting judgment should not deteriorate. 
 But it is unlikely &mdash; despite disclosure of business rules &mdash; that the less aware will not find themselves on a spectacularly high-risk syndicate which had in the past played safe. 
 Abolition of the business class regulations is a potentially liberating move. 
 The market must hope, however, that its business units do not emulate the mistakes which occurred after the City's Big Bang and that the risky business of being a Lloyd's investor becomes no more precarious. 
 Taking heart. 
 INFLATION causes havoc, we all know that. 
 But there is havoc and havoc. 
 First, there is the kind that keeps the UK out of the exchange rate mechanism (ERM) of the European Monetary System. 
 Then there is the South American strain. 
 Glass maker Pilkington yesterday bit the bullet over the Latin variety yesterday, taking a &pound;4.4million write down against its Argentinian assets. 
 The reason? 
 A burst of hyperinflation that Pilkington's mathematicians reckon hit 73 million per cent per annum. 
 However, they are taking heart that it is now back to a comfortable 250 per cent. 
 Erm&hellip;! 
 Graduates in engineering shun profession Frontiers of work. 
 Andrew Cornelius Industrial Editor. 
 THE recruitment and image crisis facing British industry was cruelly exposed yesterday by a report which revealed that two out of three university engineering students graduating this year decided against a career in engineering. 
 A huge proportion of students, many sponsored by companies, were actually &bquo;turned off&equo; an engineering career by their experience of working in engineering firms. 
 According to the survey, 44 per cent of the sponsored students among the 14,000 engineers graduating in 1989 claimed that their work experience, averaging 13 months, has discouraged them from a career in engineering. 
 Further questioning showed that 58 per cent said they &bquo;knew nothing&equo; about the average engineering company and only 8 per cent felt &bquo;well informed.&equo; 
 According to students, company recruitment presentations were often &bquo;downright boring&equo;, made either by people who do not understand engineering, or engineers who are &bquo;past it&equo;. 
 Around 60 per cent accused companies of issuing &bquo;untruthful&equo; recruitment brochures. 
 The survey arose because two final year students at Imperial College gambled with &pound;6,000 of savings to establish a research company to plug the information gap between engineering industry and the students they wish to recruit. 
 Introducing the report, which was eventually sponsored by 12 top companies, including BP, Hewlett Packard and ICI, Lord Caldecote said that the study was the first &bquo;to present a student's eye view of the ills and problems surrounding a career in engineering&equo;. 
 He said it had to be seen in the context of the UK's &pound;25billion a year deficit on trade in manufactured goods, a 22 per cent fall in enrolment for engineering courses since 1985 and the forecast decrease in the number of 16- to 24-year-olds by the mid-1990's. 
 Mr Bruce Hepburn, the 24-year-old former student who helped found the Imperial Ventures company which commissioned the survey, said if companies did not improve their image &bquo;they will go out of business&equo;. 
 He said some of Britain's top engineering companies were among those criticised by students. 
 The best-received firms were in the information technology and electronics sectors; the worst in traditional engineering sectors and construction. 
 The IVL report was based on a sample of 1,854 students, or one in 14 of the 14,000 who graduated this year. 
 It showed that only 35 per cent of the survey sample intended to pursue careers as engineers in industry. 
 A similar percentage opted for management careers, with a further 12 per cent opting for careers in commerce, management consultancy, accountancy or the City. 
 Sexual discrimination is also seen to be an important factor in turning female graduates away from engineering. 
 The survey showed that there was &bquo;unofficial&equo; discrimination against them in industry and 59 per cent said the engineering career structure worked against women succeeding. 
 Tourist Board faces probe. 
 The Welsh Tourist Board's system of recommending self-catering holiday accommodation is to be investigated by the Office of Fair Trading for &bquo;possible anti-competitive practices&equo;. 
 The board only markets accommodation which has passed an inspection for which it charges a fee. 
 Chairman, Prys Edwards, said the scheme aimed to protect holidaymakers. 
 Cable&amp;Wireless boost. 
 The contract to operate a mobile telephone service in West Germany has been awarded to the Mannesmann-led consortium, which includes Britain's Cable &amp; Wireless. 
 Macarthy bows out. 
 Pharmacy chain Macarthy has dropped attempts to have a sales promotion scheme by drugs retailer UniChem declared illegal. 
 Eagle Trust move. 
 Eagle Trust, the beleaguered mini-conglomerate being investigated by the Serious Fraud Office, obtained High Court approval to remove the vote from a further 80,000 shares to add to the 67,420,000 already disenfranchised. 
 PowerGen deal. 
 PowerGen, one of the two CEGB successor generating companies, has struck the first direct sale power contract before privatisation. 
 The &pound;50 million deal involves supplies to Toyota's new factory in Derbyshire. 
 Casino talks off. 
 Stanley Leisure has broken off talks with Leisure Investments &mdash; now at the centre of a bid from Bear Brand &mdash; over the planned purchase of Aspinall's Casino in London. 
 Short and sweet. 
 Short Brothers has won two orders worth &pound;40 million for its Javelin close-air defence weapon system from the Ministry of Defence and an unnamed country. 
 Going Down Under. 
 A sharp rise in the number of Australian companies appointing receivers and liquidators has been reported by the National Companies and Securities Commission. 
 Wall Street falls. 
 The Dow Jones Industrial Average closed down 15.99 points at 2,720.78. 
 Overseas comfort for Pilkington. 
 By Mark Milner 
 AS CLOUDS gather over the UK economy, glass maker Pilkington yesterday drew comfort from the international spread of its windows and windscreens to contact lenses operations. 
 Chairman Antony Pilkington acknowledged concern that high interest rates were beginning to hit some UK customers. 
 But he added that, with three-quarters of the company's business now overseas, foreign exchange rates were moving in the right direction. 
 At the interim stage, Pilkington turned in pre-tax profits up 6per cent to &pound;147 million and a 10per cent increase in the dividend to 2.93p a share. 
 &bquo;We regard it as a very satisfactory half year, bearing in mind that the world's economies are not quite as clear cut as they were a year ago. 
 We think this is a solid performance.&equo; 
 The core flat and safety glass business ground out another steady improvement, with Pilkington seeking to add value with products such as its &bquo;K&equo; glass. 
 Though the outlook for the UK is not as bright as it might be and the US is likely to take a knock from an end of price discounting in the car market, Europe looks set to turn in another strong performance. 
 The visioncare business, which Pilkington has been nurturing for three years and where it now ranks in the world's top three, increased its operating profits by &pound;4.4 million to &pound;18.8 million. 
 Though Mr Pilkington cautions against over-optimistic expectations, he is confident that the visioncare business is firmly on track. 
 There have been hiccups &mdash; the UK government decision to introduce eye tests, for example, brought a bulge in demand which has been followed with a corresponding flat patch &mdash; but the group reckons the long term is promising as ageing populations and greater access to markets such as India and China boost demand. 
 However, the defence related optronics business hit a sticky patch and lost &pound;4.8 million &mdash; though Pilkington said the bulk of that stemmed from redundancy costs. 
 The group is still looking for possible partners for its optronics operations, though it insists that so far there have only been talks, not negotiations. 
 The group's jointly-owned South African business produced another strong performance and Mr Pilkington is dismissive of suggestions that his group might consider disinvestment. 
 Better for the employees and pensioners, he said yesterday, for Pilkington to stay and run the business as it runs its UK operations. 
 Going crackers over Christmas? 
 Then give your gift ideas a financial flavour. 
 FINANCIAL gifts could be the answer for friends and relatives who've got everything this Christmas. 
 Telephone savings stamps at &pound;1 each, TV licence stamps in 50p denominations, or water bill savings stamps, at &pound;1 and &pound;2 each are a good idea for elderly hard-pressed relatives. 
 The post office is also the place to buy Premium Bonds; minimum &pound;10 for those aged under 16 or &pound;100 for those aged 16 or over. 
 The Royal Mint sells modern coins from a keepsake set of all seven uncirculated 1989 coins at &pound;5.75 to expensive commemorative sovereigns. 
 Old and antique coins can be bought from specialist dealers like Spink and Son in London (Tel: 01-930 7888). 
 A famous Bun penny in mint condition or a King Henry II penny sell for around &pound;50. 
 A 2,000-year-old Roman coin or and Elizabeth I sixpence go for just under &pound;100, while a William the Conqueror silver penny is a little more. 
 Spinks also sell old English banknotes, which are more likely to rise steadily in value. 
 A black and white &pound;5 note, printed between 1920 and 1956, costs from &pound;20. 
 Those in mint condition have doubled in value over the last two years to around &pound;50. 
 More plentiful are Second World War &pound;1 notes going for &pound;4 to &pound;5, while the rarer 10 shilling notes cost around &pound;10. 
 Tim Robson of auctioneers Sotheby's says that Latin American railways bonds depicting trains and elaborately coloured Chinese bonds are some of the prettiest notes around. 
 Both are available for under &pound;20 from dealers such as Westcombe Investments (P.O.Box 84, Leatherhead, Surrey KT22 ODC). 
 You can find out more from the Bond and Share Society (secretary Peter Duppa-Miller on 0305-262697) or through the largest UK dealer Michael Veissid (06944-268). 
 Presents that will help with financial planning include two books from the Consumers' Association: Which? 
 Way to Save and Invest (&pound;10.95) and Getting the Best Deal for Your Money (&pound;6.95), both published by Hodder &amp; Stoughton. 
 Money gifts for children include cash deposited in special children's building society and bank accounts which usually have free gifts when new accounts are open. 
 But do not be dazzled by the free pens, badges, money boxes and radios. 
 Gross-paying accounts are best for most children as long as their gross annual income does not exceed their personal tax-free allowance; &pound;2,785 for the tax year 1989/90. 
 While tax deducted at source from certain investment income, such as UK share dividends, is reclaimable by non-taxpayers, the composite-rate tax deducted at source from interest paid by banks and building society accounts is not. 
 Therefore, for a child, compare the net interest rate paid out by the banks and building societies with the gross rate paid by others, notably National Savings products. 
 Parents, however, should remember that if they give their child an investment that produces over &pound;5 annual income, it will usually be taxed as their own unless the child is over 18 or married. 
 Although no incentive frills are attached to a National Savings Investment Account, the variable interest rate paid gross (currently 11.75 per cent) tends to be around 3 per cent higher than the best net rates offered by the major competitors. 
 An account can be opened at any post office with a minimum of &pound;5. 
 As with most child accounts, children cannot make withdrawals until they are seven. 
 This is the best deal, although it differs from the bank and building society accounts in requiring one month's notice for withdrawals. 
 Parents opening accounts will find that The Royal Bank of Scotland's Rainbow Savings account comes out top of the major high street banks, paying 8.25 per cent net, followed by the Bank of Scotland's Supersaver at 7.82 per cet. 
 Both require a minimum investment of &pound;1, give instant access and include gifts. 
 Of the larger building societies, Chelsea is offering 10.25 per cent net and Britannia 8.5 per cent. 
 It is also worth looking at the smaller, regional building societies. 
 Some offer comparable, even higher, net rates than the Investment Account's gross rate, though there can be a small catch. 
 The Sheffield, for example, currently offers the best rate at 12.36 net, but only children whose parents or grandparents are existing savers may open an account and there is a maximum investment of &pound;500. 
 The latest survey by Which? magazine rates accounts from Leek United &amp; Midland, and Harpenden, paying net rates of 11.44 and 11.41 respectively, as the next best deals. 
 For longer-term investments, a good guaranteed rate for non-taxpaying children is offered by National Savings Capital Bonds. 
 Left untouched for five years, a minimum investment of &pound;100 in the Series A bond is guaranteed to grow to &pound;176.24; a compound rate of 12 per cent gross per year. 
 Leaflets on all National Savings products are available at post offices. 
 To compare the latest rates and conditions on children's accounts, look at Blay's Money Master monthly tables at your local reference library. 
 An alternative could be high coupon gilts as the tax can be reclaimed. 
 But with the present high interest rates they do not form a great investment. 
 Curiously, the unit trust industry &mdash; usually quick to hype its products &mdash; has been rather slow to attract children. 
 This may be because nobody under 18 can own unit trusts in their own names. 
 Parents could buy units for their children but there is only one group that has tried to target children &mdash; the MIM Rupert Trust. 
 Even so, all that can be done here is designate a unit holder under 18, the child is only a beneficial owner. 
 However to attract parents and others to invest on behalf of the child the initial investment is &pound;50, with additional payments of &pound;25 or a monthly savings plan of &pound;10. 
 The charges of a 5 per cent initial fee, 1.25 per cent annual, are standard. 
 The plan can be attractive to anybody other than a parent making a gift to a child. 
 In that case the tax deducted on the dividends can be reclaimed provided it is meant for a non tax paying child. 
 But if parents buy it for the child the dividend is considered part of the parents income. 
 As for direct exposure to the stock market, the advice of Malcolm Roberts of Montague Fleming is: &bquo;It would not be advisable to buy shares in the name of a child under 16. 
 You get all sorts of practical problems like can they sign transfer forms and many Registrars would refuse to accept them. 
 What parents can do is buy in both their names with an account designation of up to three letters which would be the child's initial. 
 They should not mark it as trustee because Registrars would not accept it.&equo; 
 Money Guardian is edited by Personal Finance Editor Margaret Hughes 
 Costs of sending &pound;50 abroad by various methods 
 BarclaysLloydsMidland&verbar;ONatWestRBS International Money Order&pound;5 &pound;4-- &pound;3 Banker's Draft&pound;9 &pound;8 &pound;6 &pound;7 &pound;6 Electronic Transfer standard &pound;12.50 &pound;8&pound;15 &pound;6 &pound;6 express &pound;12.50&pound;15&pound;15 &pound;7&pound;10 Note (1): Services offered only to existing customers. 
 Mint turns the clock back to a time when sovereign was king of coins. 
 By Morag Campbell 
 FIVE hundred years ago King Henry VII instructed the officers of his Royal Mint, then in the Tower of London, to produce &bquo;a new money of gold.&equo; 
 Partly a public relations exercise to enhance the king's status, the coin was intended to convey the majesty of the throne and the dignity of the monarch &mdash; hence the name sovereign. 
 The present Royal Mint, now in Wales, has issued a set of commemorative coins to celebrate that 500th anniversary. 
 The original sovereign continued to be struck until 1603, when James I ascended the throne, but was revived in 1817. 
 Although this sovereign was half the weight and half the diameter of the original one, such was the international respect it enjoyed that people could travel through Europe confident that the coins would be welcomed wherever they went. 
 &bquo;Originally worth 20 shillings,&equo; the Royal Mint says, &bquo;the sovereign was the country's first pound coin.&equo; 
 Today, the price of a sovereign is &pound;149.95p, including VAT. 
 For that price, you get 7.98 grammes of 22 carat gold. 
 However, you would not get &pound;149.95p each if you fell on hard times and wanted to sell your sovereigns. 
 Rarity, the quality of the design, historical associations and, particularly, melt value all determine the maket value of gold coins. 
 In popular mythology, gold is regarded as a good investment. 
 In our collective folk memory &mdash; or possibly as a result of seeing too many old Hollywood movies &mdash; we think of gold in the form of coins as eminently portable in times of national emergency. 
 National emergencies, however, may not necessarily coincide with times of personal emergency and gold is an erratic investment. 
 In February 1980, for instance, 24 carat peaked at &dollar;850 an ounce. 
 Currently it stands just above &dollar;400 an ounce having tumbled in May this year to its lowest level since August 1986. 
 The popularity of South Africa's kruggerrand was due largely to the fact that collectors were buying a precise quantity of gold at only a fraction over the actual cost of the precious metal. 
 The imposition of VAT on the kruggerrand and other gold coins meant that gold had to rise by at least 20 per cent on their initial investment before a private collector could show a profit. 
 In similar fashion the bottom fell out of the illustrious 1817 sovereign market in the mid-1970s when investors realised that they were paying 50 per cent over the melt price for a coin minted in millions. 
 The three-coin set of Quincentenary commemorative gold coins &mdash; double-sovereign, sovereign and half-sovereign struck in 22 carat gold &mdash; is limited to an issue of 10,000 and costs &pound;499.95 including VAT. 
 Individual sovereign coins can also be bought separately. 
 While a collector may be happy to pay over the odds for such interesting issues, an investor would have to be confident of rising gold prices to show a profit on resale. 
 If you don't feel bold or rich enough to take a gamble on sovereigns, for only &pound;7.25, you can buy a presentation folder containing one each of the &pound;2 coins issued to commemorate the 300th anniversary of the Bill of Rights and the Scottish Claim of Rights. 
 And for &pound;9.95 you can purchase a Baby Pack &mdash; colour co-ordinated in pink or blue to the sex of the recipient &mdash; which not only includes a set of brilliant uncirculated 1989 coins but space to record baby's important details. 
 All coins issued by the Royal Mint can be viewed at 7 Grosvenor Gardens, London SW1. 
 Mail order is available through the Royal Mint Coin Club, Freepost, P.O.Box 500, Cardiff CF1 1YY. 
 Telephone 0443-223880. 
 TCS helps to bridge the gap between gown and town. 
 By Martyn Halsall Northern Industrial Correspondent 
 STUART RILEY, a marketing specialist at the University of Lancaster, recognised his role in industrial change when he was asked to wear a suit for factory visits. 
 Staff at the BICC wiring division headquarters on Merseyside crossed their divide when Riley recommended casual clothing for a discussion day he had arranged in the Lune Valley. 
 Such details are hardly at the heart of &bquo;introducing major operational change&equo;, which the Government's Teaching Company Scheme (TCS) proposes, but they form intriguing by-products. 
 They also illustrate the widening agenda of a project set for radical expansion before 1993. 
 The scheme was established by Labour in 1975 to harness the creativity of graduates, aged between 22 and 28, to companies seeking technological development. 
 It aims to echo in industry the teaching hospital experience available to young doctors. 
 After slow growth initially and reassessment under the Conservatives, the number of schemes expanded to around 350, employing 750 post-graduates today. 
 The target is 500 schemes by 1993, with a switch of emphasis towards small- and medium-sized companies. 
 Stuart Riley, at ease in Lancaster's academic village in a baggy woolly and corduroys, is part of the new wave. 
 He is helping to supervise three post-graduate associates in a marketing exercise for BICC, which marks a broadening of the scheme's primary role in manufacturing. 
 Mr Riley speaks highly of the BICC management team and the relationship between the company in gritty Prescott and the university on a rural hillside. 
 Any company involved in such a scheme has to be brave, Mr Riley says. 
 &bquo;Maybe they buy it for the wrong reason; they can get a lot of research they would otherwise not carry out. 
 But they have got to be able to say: &bquo;We will open ourselves up to a change agent&equo;&hellip; and change is painful.&equo; 
 His colleague Peter Spillard &mdash; his suit trousers sharply creased for a trip to the industrial heartland &mdash; adds: &bquo;They have to answer questions they have not needed to answer before.&equo; 
 Messrs Riley and Spillard &mdash; like another lecturer at Lancaster, Stuart Burge &mdash; stress the practical usefulness of their contact with TCS and its value in their teaching. 
 Companies profit from access to a network of university expertise far beyond individual scheme programmes and graduate associates mature rapidly, Dr Burge. 
 &bquo;I am frequently amazed at the change in them.&equo; 
 Experience from a two-year TC scheme could equal 10 or 15 years on the conventional industrial ladder. 
 Mal Gibb joined a Lancaster scheme after a degree in systems modelling at Sheffield Polytechnic and is now helping to develop computerised production at Nairn Kingfisher, a wallpaper plant on the Lancaster quayside. 
 He has appreciated the freedom to develop his work, the experience of dealing with everything from factory floor practicalities to board-room presentations, and the additional training which is 10 per cent of any scheme programme. 
 &bquo;The main benefit is that I've enjoyed it; that's my yardstick.&equo; 
 His supervisor, engineering and operational research lecturer Jean Tunnicliffe-Wilson, says much of the satisfaction is not only in suggesting ideas but having them tested in practice. 
 &bquo;I don't get the same satisfaction just publishing ideas &mdash; I like to see them happening.&equo; 
 Yet publishing ideas could be a barrier to TCS expansion, says George Steele, head of technology with the Departmnt of Industry in the North-west. 
 &bquo;Academics get on by publishing papers and TCS by it's very nature isn't research; it's technology transfer and doesn't give the same opportunity for publishing&hellip; 
 So some academics fear they might fall behind in the promotion race if they get involved with TCS.&equo; 
 Not all universities or academics agree. 
 Dr Burge has valued schemes as a source of research and some universities are now promoting both industrial contact and research experience. 
 The economic climate in higher education is also a constraint, says George Steele. 
 Higher education is very interested, &bquo;but they are strapped for resources and one of the problems of TCS is that it will cover all their costs, but it's not a way that a university or poly is going to make money.&equo; 
 For all its popularity, TCS is essentially a shoe-string operation with an annual government input of &pound;12million and an equal contribution from industry. 
 The goal for 1993 is that 60 per cent of participants will be companies with fewer than 500 employees. 
 People from European Community countries can be recruited on to British TC schemes but as yet the EC offers no equivalent. 
 Frontiers is edited by Peter Large 
 Insurance market's &bquo;momentous&equo; decision will spark head-on confrontation with leading corporate rivals Lloyd's of London rewrites its rules to take on the European competition. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 THE &pound;11BILLION a year Lloyd's of London insurance market is abandoning rules forcing underwriters to specialise in particular types of business so as to compete more effectively in Europe and against the big insurance companies. 
 The decision, described by investor representatives as &bquo;momentous&equo;, will bring Lloyd's into head-on competition with leading insurers such as Commercial Union, Prudential and Allianz. 
 In what is being seen as Lloyd's &bquo;Big Bang&equo;, the change should allow the giant insurance operation to move in on a growing slice of business which it has found elusive. 
 The move was interpreted by some as a concession to Lloyd's brokers who supply the market with its business. 
 It will mean that wide-ranging corporate risks will be able to be placed with just one underwriter. 
 For Lloyd's entire 300-year history its underwriters have been forced to specialise in one of the four traditional classes &mdash; marine, non-marine, aviation and motor. 
 But from now on underwriters will be able to take on risks in any sector and brokers will no longer be forced to traipse around the market to place different strands of business with individual underwriters. 
 Lloyd's has become acutely aware that it is losing business to large companies, notably in Britain and Europe. 
 Many of its syndicates are operating at less than 50 per cent of their capacity. 
 It admitted being hit by the growing trend of big companies to place all their insurance business on a single policy. 
 Senior market official, David Coleridge, said recently that Lloyd's had lost out to Commercial Union on a multi-million- pound contract from Trafalgar House because it was unable to offer a &bquo;package deal&equo;. 
 Bob Keville, chairman of the Lloyd's Insurance Brokers Committee, predicted the change was &bquo;bound to lead to more business coming Lloyd's way in future.&equo; 
 Sturge, the largest underwriting group at Lloyd's, said the ability to drop barriers &mdash; which will not be compulsory &mdash; would lead to mergers between syndicates and an improved use of capacity. 
 Boutique syndicates are likely to remain, however. 
 But independent analysts in the market predicted disaster. 
 They pointed to cases in the past when underwriters had incurred huge losses by moving into an unfamiliar area of business. 
 And they forecast that profits could be reduced even if the overall income level rose because of new business. 
 Anthony Haynes, chairman of the Association of Lloyd's Members &mdash; which represents market investors &mdash; said, however, he felt underwriting standards and the disclosure of syndicate business would improve. 
 &bquo;The barriers had ceased to be an effective protection for Names as those losing their shirts on marine syndicates are only too painfully aware,&equo; he said. 
 Lloyd's is keen not only to increase its market share but to broaden its spread of risks. 
 It wants to be less reliant on the depressed shipping industry but it also wants to shake off the tag of being the world's market of last resort and is determined to win safer contracts. 
 Apart from the big insuance companies around the world, Lloyd's already faces strong competition from the Institute of London Underwriters &mdash; a grouping of the marine underwriting departments of international companies &mdash; and is about to face further pressure with the establishment of the London Underwriting Centre, a similar company amalgam specialising in Lloyd's mainstream reinsurance business. 
 An executive in the London companies market dismissed the likely threat from Lloyd's. 
 &bquo;We already operate in a competitive market and Lloyd's is unlikely to make that much more difficult.&equo; 
 But we have been in this type of business for longer and will score on our expertise and we will also benefit from the ability we have through branch offices to handle claims.&equo; 
 The changes will not come into force until 1991 and Lloyd's stressed that it was attempting to introduce safeguards to ensure the market's underwriting standards did not deteroriate. 
 Agents, who are responsible for the underwriting syndicates, will be compelled to inform investors specifically about the type of business being handled and underwriters will be obliged to join the market association responsible for any class of insurance written. 
 The agency companies will also be responsible for ensuring that syndicates are capable of handling the business they take on. 
 John Gordon, chairman of the Lloyd's Underwriting Agents Association said his members welcomed the move. 
 &bquo;It will give the market extra flexibility and make it more attractive. 
 It also puts the responsibility for ensuring competence where it belongs &mdash; with the managing agent,&equo; Mr Gordon said. 
 New rules mean a set-back for army of casual workers. 
 By Linda Lennard 
 Unemployment benefit. 
 NEW rules to be introduced from tomorrow will hit many part-time workers receiving unemployment benefit. 
 Those who earn &pound;43 a week or more will lose benefit for the whole of that week &mdash; even if they work only part of it and are unemployed for the remaining days. 
 Only people who earn &pound;12 or less in any week will escape having their entitlement affected at all. 
 Anybody who earns between &pound;12 and &pound;43 in a given week may still be able to qualify for unemployment benefit on the days they are not working. 
 However, they will have to satisfy unemployment benefit officers that part-time work is not their usual pattern, and they are just doing it while looking for full-time employment. 
 In general, it has been accepted that people can take on part-time work in this way if it has not been their usual employment pattern. 
 But adjudication officers may eventually claim that part-time employment is your normal pattern, and that you should not be entitled to benefit on the days you don't work because you would not normally expect to be working anyway. 
 This so-called &bquo;full extent normal rule&equo; has come under considerable criticism from the Court of Appeal downwards. 
 The new rules coming in tomorrow effectively mean the end of the full extent normal rule for people earning &pound;12 or less in a week. 
 The government says the changes are interim measures and it intends to reconsider the whole question of the treatment of earnings received by people on unemployment benefit. 
 If you do any part-time work while on unemployment benefit and your earnings do not affect your benefit entitlement, you will still have to meet the rest of the conditions for this benefit on the remaining days. 
 These include a new stringent &bquo;actively seeking work&equo; test which was introduced this October, as well as showing that you are available for work the rest of the week. 
 As well as earnings from part-time work, other income can affect your entitlement to unemployment benefit. 
 If you are aged 55 or over and have a personal or occupational pension which is more than &pound;35 per week, the rest will be deducted from your benefit. 
 Money from a redundancy payment should not affect your right to this benefit. 
 Also note that if your partner earns more than &pound;21.40 the adult dependants increase will not be payable for her or him. 
 Water shares: public dive in. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 THE public has applied for more than half of the &pound;5.3billion water privatisation issue, with more than 1.4 million people signing cheques for an average of &pound;2,000. 
 Although counting of applications continues, the issue is 1.75 times oversubscribed so far, forcing financial advisers last night to &bquo;claw back&equo; shares promised to overseas institutions so as to meet small investor demand. 
 This will increase the shares on offer to the public from 23.5 per cent to nearly 30 per cent of the issue. 
 With 500 share sorters working round the clock, however, small investors could see their allocation rise to a ceiling of nearly 50 per cent if the issue is 2.25 times oversubscribed. 
 Prospects for the highest-rated shares to open at a premium of up to 30 per cent continued to look good as the stock market held steady yesterday. 
 Thames Water was trading on a &bquo;grey market&equo; price of up to 132p. 
 Other companies attracted prices between the 122p to 129p opening price on the 100p partly-paid shares. 
 Flotation advisers declined to predict the total number of applications. 
 But only those applying for small amounts of shares are likely to see their allocation met in full. 
 &bquo;It seems inevitable that almost everybody will only get some of the shares they wanted,&equo; one analyst said. 
 Analysts forecast an extra fillip to early water dealing with a wave of institutional buying from foreign buyers starved of stock. 
 The clawback mechanism has reduced the 18.5 per cent water holding intended for Japan, US, Canada and European institutions to around 12 per cent. 
 Any further &bquo;clawback&equo; will reduce shares allotted to institutions and brokers in the City. 
 All water companies have been &bquo;oversubscribed&equo; but advisers conceded that there were &bquo;regional buying differences&equo; between them. 
 Analysts were increasingly optimistic about the prospect of share price premiums in early trading as it became clear that professional buyers will be starved of stock. 
 The main casualty of yesterday's &bquo;clawback&equo; will be the Japanese institution Daiwa, which is to take most of the overseas allocation. 
 &bquo;We could see Japanese interest,&equo; said Mr Stephen Doe, of brokers Smith New Court. 
 &bquo;It does look exciting for the aftermarket.&equo; 
 But he conceded that Tokyo had held back in the aftermarket of British Gas. 
 In the US, buyers will have to hold back for 90 days after the issue because of Securities Exchange Commission restrictions on overseas dealings. 
 But heavy buying could be expected from Wood Gundy, which is handling the issue in Canada, and Credit Suisse First Boston, issue co-ordinator for the European markets. 
 A spokesman for Schroders, the Government's merchant bankers, said: &bquo;We have found that the average number of shares has increased as we have gone through the applications.&equo; 
 But he said that it was too early to make firm forecasts about demand. 
 All forms are being checked by Price Waterhouse computer systems to weed out illegal multiple applications. 
 Sophisticated &bquo;fuzzy matching&equo; technology is being used to spot attempts to disguise similar names and addresses. 
 Experts last night were unsure over whether any of the water companies would qualify for the FT-SE index, a crucial point in assessing their investment potential. 
 &bquo;Latest indications are that they will miss out, but it isn't impossible,&equo; said a spokesman for Schroders. 
 Thames, North West and Severn Trent are the most likely candidates. 
 Singh steps out for peace in Sikh heartland. 
 By Derek Brown in New Delhi 
 THE new Indian Prime Minister, Mr Vishwanath Pratap Singh, travelled to the heart of battle-scarred Punjab yesterday to score an emotional public-relations victory. 
 Huge crowds turned out to cheer as the Prime Minister, spurning elaborate security precautions, rode through the city of Amritsar to the holiest shrine of the Sikhs, the Golden Temple. 
 He told the throng: &bquo;The people of Punjab have given me a lot of love&hellip; 
 I will now move in an open jeep instead of a bullet-proof car.&equo; 
 At the temple, Mr Singh prayed alongside his deputy, Mr Devi Lal, and his Punjabi foreign minister, Mr Inder Kumar Gujral. 
 Masses of Sikhs jostled and crowded round him as he made his parikrama, the ritual clockwise walk around the marble margins of the sacred lake. 
 This was the gesture which leading Sikhs had pleaded in vain for the previous Prime Minister, Mr Rajiv Gandhi, to make. 
 And although there is as yet no solid evidence that a political settlement of the Sikh question is in sight, the change of government has brought a new spirit of reconciliation on both sides. 
 Mr Singh pledged yesterday that his administration would &bquo;move very fast&equo; to bring peace to Punjab. 
 He had come to pray, he said, not to make a political or official visit. 
 &bquo;With the love and co-operation of Punjabis and the strength of God, I am confident that peace will once again return to the state,&equo; he said. 
 For most of the Eighties, Punjab has been wracked by vicious conflict between the security forces and half a dozen incoherent but well-armed groups ostensibly fighting for a free Sikh state of Khalistan, the Land of the Pure. 
 The violence was dramatically stepped up after the storming of the Golden Temple in mid-1984 by the Indian army. 
 For the past few years, the death count has been running at roughly 10 a day, with blood feuds and general gangsterism adding to the mayhem. 
 The previous Congress Party government tried to lay part of the blame on Pakistan, saying that Khalistan terrorists had been trained and armed across the frontier. 
 Most observers, however, believe the problem started with cynical Congress intrigues to split the main Sikh Party, the Akali Dal. 
 The manoeuvre succeeded, though at a dreadful cost. 
 There are now at least half a dozen Akali factions, both moderate and militant. 
 The former tried to reach an accord with New Delhi, but their state government was replaced by direct rule following the assassination of the Akali leader, Mr Harchand Singh Longowal. 
 The strongest Akali faction by far is now that led by Mr Simranjit Singh Mann. 
 He and his followers won 10 of the state's 13 parliamentary seats in last month's general election, with Mr Mann himself scoring a dramatic victory from his prison cell. 
 On the day his result was announced, he was released after five years of detention without trial, still defiantly declaring his faith in the Sikh cause. 
 But in the short and euphoric interval, even Mr Mann has softened his approach, indicating that he was now prepared to accept the constitution of India, and distancing himself from the latest demands by the ultra-belligerent Sikh student movement for an alternative government. 
 In the wake of the Mann group's victory, and the strident noises from the Student Federation, some reports from Amritsar had spoken of a return of terrorism to the temple itself, scene of bloody battles in 1984 and again last summer. 
 One of the direst warnings, pleading for immediate though unspecified action, came from the state Governor, Mr S.S. Ray. 
 But already, as a staunch Congressman, he knew his time was up. 
 Yesterday he resigned and was replaced by Mr Nirmal Kumar Mukarji. 
 Mr Ray's last warning was both unheeded and unnecessary. 
 As Mr V.P. Singh paid his humble respects at the seat of Sikh pride and piety, the militants' guns and the swords were put away. 
 The police security guards too were discreet, and allowed the people of Punjab, both Sikh and Hindu, to surge round their Prime Minister. 
 Jews split over women's group. 
 By Mark Tran in Washington 
 ADECISION by B'nai B'rith International to expel its women's affiliate threatens to tear apart the world's largest Jewish organisation. 
 The simmering dispute erupted in public when the B'nai B'rith International board of governors adopted a motion to expel the 120,000-member B'nai B'rith Women unless the affiliate relinquishes its autonomous status. 
 B'nai B'rith Women, legally incorporated as a separate entity in 1962, also faces legal action challenging its right to use the B'nai B'rith name. 
 &bquo;B'nai B'rith International's decision-makers now seek total control over their empire. 
 They will brook no independence,&equo; said the president of B'nai B'rith Women, Hyla Lipsky. 
 Expulsion of the women's group would mean a significant drop in the total membership of 500,000 at a time when numbers joining are declining. 
 The president of B'nai B'rith International, Mr Seymour Reich, said the organisation made the expulsion threat reluctantly and after several years of negotiation. 
 He believes that B'nai B'rith Women's determination to remain autonomous works against the trend of creating a new organisation for the 21st century comprising men and women. 
 He sees the decision to fully integrate the women's arm into the organisation as a way of boosting membership. 
 &bquo;It's ironic,&equo; said Mr Reich. 
 &bquo;Here we are offering them full equality with men in B'nai B'rith, and their leadership is rejecting that offer.&equo; 
 Although not a political organisation, B'nai B'rith Women has taken high-profile stands on contentious political issues. 
 The organisation, against the wishes of B'nai B'rith International, took a public stand against the nomination of Judge Robert Bork to the Supreme Court because of his anti-abortion stance. 
 Poland sees Council as first step to membership. 
 By AP in Brussels 
 THE chairman of Poland's foreign affairs committee said yesterday his country would request membership of the European Community and all other European institutions. 
 &bquo;Yes, Poland is seeking a place in all European institutions,&equo; Mr Bronislaw Geremek said after meeting with the presidents of the Commission. 
 Mr Geremek said as a first step Poland would soon seek full membership in the Council of Europe. 
 In November, Hungary became the first East European nation to apply for membership to the council based in Strasbourg, France. 
 A condition for membership of the EC is that the country must be a full parliamentary democracy. 
 Mr Geremek said he had told EC officialsthat &bquo;the process of democratisation in Poland is irreversible&equo;. 
 PAGE 
 Mass murder was &bquo;revenge on feminists&equo;. 
 By Penny MacRae in Montreal 
 POLICE say a young loner who claimed feminists had ruined his life was responsible for a bloody shooting spree at a Montreal university in which 14 women were killed. 
 Thirteen others &mdash; nine men and four women &mdash; were wounded in the rampage on Wednesday that shattered the festive end-of-term mood at the French language Universite de Montreal, Quebec's largest. 
 Details began to emerge yesterday of the gruesome attack &mdash; the biggest mass murder in Canadian history. 
 Police said the gunman, in his early 20s and identified only as Marc, carried a hit list with the names of 15 women in a letter found on his body. 
 The gunman shouted &bquo;I want the women&equo; as he roamed the engineering buildings at the university, spraying bullets before turning his semi-automatic rifle on himself. 
 The dead, 13 of them students, were on three different floors of the building. 
 In one classroom, the gunman divided the students by sex to separate sides of the room and then started shooting the women. 
 &bquo;He told them, &bquo;You're women, you're going to be engineers. 
 You're all a bunch of feminists, I feminists&equo;,&equo; said one student, Robert Leclerc. 
 &bquo;My friend Natalie replied, &bquo;No, it's not true, we're not feminists,&equo; but the gunman fired into the group.&equo; 
 Police said the three-page letter found in the killer's back pocket blamed women for the disappointments in his life. 
 &bquo;All the words he uses are what you would call anti-feminist,&equo; said a police officer. 
 The letter indicated the killer had been rejected by the Canadian armed forces for being anti-social, police said. 
 Distraught parents kept an all-night vigil at the university where a temporary morgue was set up. 
 One police officer arrived at the scene to find his daughter dead on the floor. 
 &bquo;It was just like Rambo,&equo; said one of the scores of horrified students who fled from the university after the massacre. 
 The Quebec premier, Mr Robert Bourassa, condemned the killings as a &bquo;barbaric carnage&equo; and declared three days of official mourning. 
 Food pledge for Ethiopia. 
 By Reuter in Brussels 
 THE Community yesterday promised 44,000 tonnes of new food aid for Ethiopia in an effort to save millions of people threatened by starvation. 
 The pledge brings total EC food aid to Ethiopia to 175,000 tonnes, after a 30,000-tonne gift of cereals in November, officials said. 
 Under a special programme, aid worth about 10 million ECUs (&pound;8 million) would also go on transport and other urgent supplies. 
 Ethiopia has asked for 377,000 tonnes of food to fend off famine in Eritrea and Tigre. 
 United Nations experts say as many as four million people are facing famine after a severe drought and crop failure. 
 PAGE 
 Mojahedin &bquo;plot against republics&equo;. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 AFGHAN guerrillas have been infiltrating Soviet Central Asia with &bquo;narcotics, arms and other instruments of subversion&equo; in an attempt to overthrow Soviet rule and set up Islamic governments, according to the KGB chief in the Soviet republic of Tadjikistan. 
 It has long been a nightmare in Moscow that the region could be highly vulnerable to Islamic militants from the indigenous population's ethnic and religious brothers across the borders in Afghanistan and Iran. 
 These fears have grown apace since the Soviet intervention in Afghanistan gave rise to bitter hostility towards the Russians among many Afghans. 
 Under Mr Gorbachev's policies of glasnost and perestroika, Central Asians have also begun to express their resentment at what they see as Russian exploitation of their land during the Stalin and Brezhnev eras. 
 Now, in the first detailed account of what were apparently serious efforts by the Mojahedin to subvert Soviet power, Tass has quoted Mr Vladimir Petkel, the head of state security in Tadjikistan, as saying the situation had become considerably worse since the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Afghanistan. 
 &bquo;Over the past few months, state security organs and border guards exposed and suppressed several attempts by special agencies of Afghan armed opposition forces to recruit Soviet citizens,&equo; he said. 
 They were to be induced to carry out &bquo;hostile activities on Soviet territory with the help of foreigners penetrating into Tadjikistan across the border&equo;. 
 A number of Afghan agents, as well as some of their Soviet contacts, were caught, according to Mr Petkel. 
 One, named as &bquo;Engineer Bashir&equo;, was described as &bquo;a field commander, head of an intelligence centre and deputy leader of the Islamic Party of Afghanistan&equo;. 
 Bashir and an assistant named Mirahmad were said to have recruited Afghans from the border provinces of Badakshan and Kunduz who &bquo;underwent a special training course in the armed opposition camps&equo;. 
 These agents &bquo;were to induce Soviet citizens to collaborate in the delivery of narcotics, arms and other instruments of subversion into Soviet territory. 
 Their final goal was to create bases in the Tadjik Republic from which to destabilise the situation in Soviet Central Asia, and to mobilise forces aiming to overthrow the system existing in the Soviet Central Asian Republics&equo;. 
 An arms cache was found in the house of &bquo;a certain Azimov&equo; who was alleged to have been recruited by Bashir's agents. 
 Tass said journalists were shown money and hand grenades seized from him and a tape recorder &bquo;with the text of the oath Soviet citizens were expected to take when recruited&equo;. 
 Two Afghans, among several arrested trying to cross the border, &bquo;admitted that they belonged to an intelligence group entrusted with the organisation of an underground anti-Soviet movement in Tadjikistan, whose purpose was to turn the republic into an Islamic state&equo;. 
 A number of people had been put on trial, Mr Petkel said. 
 But the Tass report had a happy ending &mdash; from the Soviet point of view. 
 &bquo;Two criminal cases, involving one Soviet and one Afghan citizen who openly confessed and repented their actions against the Soviet Union, have been discontinued.&equo; 
 Trade accord sought in Gulf. 
 By Reuter in Nicosia 
 COMMISSIONER Abel Matutes, visiting Gulf Cooperation Council states, said yesterday that the EC and GCC were discussing the possibility of a trade agreement as a step toward free trade. 
 The EC runs a &dollar;4.4 billion trade surplus with the GCC, an economic alliance linking Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Oman, Qatar, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates. 
 Most EC goods enter almost duty-free. 
 Members are pressing for freer European access for the products of their petrochemical industries. 
 Mr Matutes, who is EC commissioner for Mediterranean policy and Latin American relations, arrived in Muscat from Saudi Arabia. 
 PAGE 
 Pretoria to halve military service. 
 By David Beresford in Johannesburg 
 SOUTH Africa is to cut national service for young whites by half, as part of a reduction in the country's reliance on the military establishment. 
 The State President, Mr F.W. de Klerk, announced yesterday that conscripts would do only one year full-time military service, instead of two. 
 Speaking at the opening of a new headquarters for the state arms-manufacturing corporation, Armscor, he said other cuts in the military establishment would be disclosed next year. 
 The announcement follows the dismantling of the National Security Management system &mdash; the &bquo;shadow&equo; system of government by security chiefs &mdash; and ties in with plans to reduce the military budget by about 15 per cent, or &pound;375 million. 
 The moves will be seen as further evidence of Mr De Klerk's commitment to a political, rather than a military, solution to the country's long-running crisis. 
 The latest decision will immediately affect about 35,000 young white men due to begin service next February and more than 15,000 scheduled to start in August. 
 Other race groups are not required to do national service. 
 The news was welcomed yesterday by the End Conscription Campaign, which has been running an increasingly effective protest against national service on the grounds that servicemen are used to oppress the country's majority population. 
 Recently 771 conscripts publicly announced their refusal to do military service as part of a national defiance campaign by the anti-apartheid community. 
 Several young whites are already serving terms of imprisonment for refusing to serve. 
 The Afrikaans weekly newspaper, Vrye Weekblad, has named a South African conscript who, it says, was required to do his military service as a spy. 
 A report in today's edition says that the youth, aged 19, was sent to the Netherlands by Military Intelligence to infiltrate an anti-apartheid group, the Committee of War Resisters. 
 Nicaraguans see red over economic ruin Grinding poverty, not revolutionary zeal, is the real election issue, Simon Tisdall writes from Masaya. 
 NICARAGUA suffered an attack of &bquo;Red Dizziness&equo; this week &mdash; in the Spanish, Marea Roja, a bug caught from eating tainted sea food. 
 But in a week that marked the opening of the campaign for February's elections, the red dizziness was not confined to restaurants. 
 In Masaya, a dusty, impoverished town to the south-west of Managua, supporters of the Sandinista National Liberation Front (FSLN) turned an election rally into a raucous, joyful rampage on Wednesday night. 
 With the blue and white Nicaraguan flag fluttering amid the Sandinistas' red and black banners, a jeep-borne President Daniel Ortega led an anarchic procession to the accompaniment of bands, singers, dancers, and the alarmed squeals of a tethered pig. 
 The message for the Nicaraguan opposition was simple: On February 25 &bquo;we will bury you!&equo; 
 The revolution which triumphed in 1979 would triumph again. 
 A second revolution may well be on the way in Nicaragua, but one not to the liking of the FSLN. 
 President Ortega faces the most potent challenge to his leadership since the Sandinistas took full control in 1981. 
 The challenge comes not from the US, not from the contra rebels, nor from hostile neighbouring countries, but from within. 
 In short, the government is being called to account for the economic disaster that is present-day Nicaragua. 
 As a Managua businessman put it, &bquo;I used to sell fridges. 
 Nobody bought them so I began to repair fridges. 
 But nobody has their fridges repaired any more, they can't afford it. 
 So all the fridges stay rusted, and I have no work.&equo; 
 For many Nicaraguans, the deciding election issue will have little to do with the rhetoric of purist revolutionary solidarity. 
 They are no longer proud to be poor. 
 Official figures show that private consumption under Sandinista rule has fallen by 70 per cent. 
 Real wages have fallen by 90 per cent since 1981. 
 Unemployment is rising, with the industrial sector expected to contract by 20 per cent this year. 
 The flight from the countryside has compounded the misery of the urban poor, traditionally the bedrock of Sandinista support. 
 Government measures to peg back inflation have deepened the recession. 
 The Sandinista campaign slogan, &bquo;Everything will get better&equo;, seems in this context an admission of defeat. 
 Their platform emphasises their achievements in reducing child mortality and enhancing rural education, and seeks to present the FSLN as an experienced, united party. 
 The main opposition alliance, the 14-party Nicaraguan Opposition Union (UNO), is portrayed as opportunist and divided and infiltrated by pro-contra, Somoza-era hangovers. 
 But a series of opinion polls have suggested, very roughly, a 30-30 split with 40 per cent of the electorate undecided. 
 If the Sandinistas have their problems, so too does UNO. 
 Its presidential candidate, Mrs Violeta Chamorro, brings to the fray a symbolic appeal as the widow of the murdered publisher of La Prensa, but lacks any political experience &mdash; a fact that becomes embarrassingly clear when she appears in public. 
 UNO's acceptance of US campaign fund donations and Mrs Chamorro's appointment of the former contra director, Afredo Cesar, as her adviser, has opened her to charges of collaborating with the US. 
 The main theme of the UNO campaign is reconciliation. 
 The alliance plays on the prospect of an end to the US trade embargo and increased foreign aid in the event of an UNO victory. 
 It has pledged to end the deeply unpopular draft and to reduce the 80,000-strong army. 
 The US and the Soviet Union have publicly backed the electoral process, which was agreed last February. 
 Moscow continues as the main Sandinista financier, pumping in about &dollar;465 million in economic aid. 
 But given the democratic revolution on its own doorstep, the Soviet Union is now distanced from its long-time proteges. 
 For the US, the emphasis is on securing a free and fair election, which the State Department seems to believe will result in an opposition victory. 
 The US has alleged intimidation by turbas divinas &mdash; pro-Sandinista thugs and claims to have evidence of voter intimidation by the army. 
 Washington has also threatened not to recognise the poll result if Congressional observers are barred from joining those of the UN, the OAS, and the Jimmy Carter foundation. 
 It is unclear whether a democratically defeated FSLN would relinquish power. 
 After 10 tumultous years of substantial achievement and disastrous mistakes, the Sandinistas control the army, the unions, the youth movements, much of the media and the money &mdash; what there is of it. 
 Did Daniel Ortega struggle so hard and so long, suffer seven years in jail, and defy the mighty US at such cost to his country, only to drive his jeep into the sunset? 
 It is a dizzying thought. 
 European Community Hungary granted &pound;800m loan deal. 
 By Reuter in Brussels 
 THE European Commission on Wednesday approved an EC loan of one billion Ecus (&pound;800 million) to help Hungary overcome severe balance of payments problems, the first organised for a non-EC country. 
 EC Commissioner Henning Christophersen said the five-year loan was highly exceptional, &bquo;but then we're in a highly exceptional situation&equo;. 
 It was conditional on Budapest agreeing a structural adjustment programme with the International Monetary Fund and implementing market-based economic reforms. 
 It should also not take the place of fresh funds from Western banks, Mr Christophersen said. 
 &bquo;The loan would be another concrete expression of the Community's support &lsqb;for&rsqb; Hungary's progress towards democracy and a market economy.&equo; 
 Mr Christophersen urged EC governments and the European Parliament to give speedy approval to the loan, which will be paid in three instalments. 
 The operation to raise the money on international markets could start next February if there were no procedural difficulties, he added. 
 Because of the EC's standing in markets, the loan would be raised on the best possible terms, but it would not be a subsidised, &bquo;soft&equo; loan, Mr Christopherson emphasised. 
 The Community would monitor Hungary's programme to restructure its economy on more market-oriented lines, and disburse the second and third tranches of the money only if satisfied about progress. 
 The Community was working in close cooperation with the IMF, and the loan was intended to complement its efforts. 
 PAGE 
 . 
 By Simon Tisdall in Tegucigalpa, Honduras 
 AT the store on the corner, three drunken men are trying to eat the same hot dog. 
 Across the road, an army conscript dressed in battle fatigues watches. 
 Somewhere along the dark street, somebody is crying. 
 It is past midnight in Tegucigalpa, and it's time to go home. 
 And here, at last, come the Kids from Fame. 
 Chela and Urna are dancers at La Fama night club, a grotty little joint comprising one bar, 15 or so rickety wooden tables, and an illuminated picture of a woman's bottom. 
 But La Fama has a stage. 
 And that is what really interests Chela and Urna. 
 Like thousands of young people who crowd the narrow streets of Tegucigalpa, the Kids from La Fama are obsessed with the trappings of North American culture. 
 A fancy New York dance school it isn't, but for Chela and Urna the spotlit stage at La Fama is an alluring link with the much-emulated, much vilified empire to the north. 
 Such schizophrenia, when it comes to the &bquo;yanquis&equo; is common throughout Central America. 
 Through the Caribbean Basin Initiative, the US is attempting to encourage export industries in countries such as Honduras, in addition to direct financial aid. 
 But this reopens the issue of national dependence on Uncle Sam. 
 And the particulars of such a seeming unequal struggle are of little immediate help to the Kids from La Fama. 
 Since dancing cannot earn them a living, Chela and Urna are into self-help, and it is as humiliating in personal terms as any perceived national, cultural subservience to the US. 
 When they suggest a dance to my companion, Wesley, there seems no harm &mdash; but it turns into a smooch. 
 Solos become doubles, and doubles trebles. 
 And the Kids from La Fama grow ever more possessive. 
 &bquo;Now we have to go,&equo; say Chela and Urna suddenly. 
 &bquo;But there is a problem.&equo; 
 The problem turns out to be the boss of the club, who says we must pay &dollar;8 if the girls are to leave. 
 Outside, I wait for Wesley, who is negotiating Chela and Urna's release. 
 Finally, here they come, the Kids from Fame, Honduras-style, giggling yet purposeful. 
 &bquo;Where do you want to go, we'll drop you in a taxi,&equo; I say. 
 All three now look at me incredulously. 
 And the penny drops. 
 &bquo;Back to the hotel, man, come on!&equo; says Wesley. 
 PAGE 
 Iraq launches own missile. 
 Iraq said yesterday it had launched a 48-tonne three-stage rocket into space and announced the local manufacture of new long-range missiles. 
 The minister in charge of weapons manufacture, Mr Hussein Kamel Hassan, said in a message broadcast by Baghdad radio, that the 80ft rocket was launched from al-Anbar space research base west of Baghdad on Tuesday. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Slovenia alliance. 
 Three main opposition groups in Yugoslavia united yesterday to contest Slovenia's first free elections scheduled for next March, Tanjug news agency reported. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Mugabe allays fears. 
 The Zimbabwean President, Mr Robert Mugabe, yesterday reiterated earlier pledges to resettle hundreds of thousands of black families, but allayed white farmers' fears that their land would be seized with minimal compensation to mark the tenth independence anniversary. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 El Salvador kidnap. 
 Leftwing rebels in El Salvador held an American civilian overnight and lectured him on US intervention while keeping his thumbs tied behind his back before letting him go, the US Embassy said yesterday. 
 Meanwhile, leftwing guerrillas renewed their assault on the capital, setting up positions in at least seven neighbourhoods. 
 &mdash; Agencies. 
 Boat people appeal. 
 US Republicans asked President Bush, in a letter released yesterday, to call on Britain to reconsider its policy of repatriating Vietnamese boat people in Hong Kong. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Racist gamble. 
 Caesars Hotel Casino in Atlantic City was fined &dollar;250,000 on Wednesday for removing black women from a dice table for a high-stakes gambler who wanted to gamble only with white, male dealers. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Comoros protest. 
 The Comoros presidential guard yesterday used teargas and clubs to disperse about 1,000 student protesters demanding that the French mercenary, Mr Bob Denard, and his men go home. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Rebels attacked. 
 Planes bombed a second rebel-held town in southern Sudan, in the latest of a number of bombing raids since peace talks between the Sudanese Government and Sudan People's Liberation Army rebels collapsed earlier this week, a UN official and rebel spokesmen said yesterday. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Bidding for red star. 
 Eighteen companies are bidding for the contract to remove the red star from the dome of Hungary's Parliament, writes Michael Simmons. 
 The government has decreed that, from the end of this month, only the national colours and the coat of arms of the new republic can can be displayed. 
 Officials say removing the star will not be easy. 
 Warning on free market. 
 By Reuter in Brussels 
 THE 12 Community governments have speeded up implementation of rules to create their barrier-free market but are still far behind schedule, the Commission said yesterday. 
 The single market programme requires each member state to turn 279 rules and regulations into national law. 
 More than half have been approved by ministers already. 
 But in a report for EC leaders at Friday's summit in Strasbourg, the commission said only 14 of 86 measures that should have come into force by mid-November had been fully implemented by all 12. 
 That, however, was an improvement compared with the seven out of 68 in mid-August. 
 PAGE 
 Territory for peace no longer an impossible dream on eve of anniversary Intifada forces sea change among reluctant Israelis. 
 By Ian Black in Jerusalem 
 YITZHAK Rabin was looking even more than usually impassive on Wednesday night as he watched Israel Television's special programme marking the second anniversary of the outbreak of the Palestinian uprising. 
 The Defence Minister barely flinched as the camera zoomed in for a close-up of his face as they ran the famous film clip from mid-December, 1987, in which he promised that it would all be over by Christmas. 
 No one could have predicted then that the unrest in the West Bank and Gaza Strip would still be going on two years later, so Mr Rabin was playing fairly safe when he said in a brief interview at the end of Wednesday's programme that the uprising would probably continue well into 1990. 
 Israel can cope. 
 The mass demonstrations of the first year are rare these days and the army and Shin Bet security service have been chalking up success after bloody success in hunting down the masked youths who throw petrol bombs and kill collaborators. 
 Many soldiers would prefer to be fighting a &bquo;real&equo; war against armed guerrillas in south Lebanon, but no more than 95 men, mostly reservists, have refused to serve beyond the pre-1967 green line. 
 Intifada draft-dodging barely exists. 
 So far, the military situation is tenable: the army shifts its men around, from the Lebanon border, to training exercises, to the West Bank and Gaza, and then back to Lebanon again. 
 The general staff is unhappy and the squaddies disgruntled, but no more than that. 
 The economy can stand the strain too: a 5 per cent drop in the GNP this year is deemed manageable. 
 Palestinians still come to work in Israel, industry has adjusted and tourism shows signs of recovering. 
 The legal system, many feel, is being eroded. 
 Fifty thousand Palestinians have been through the prisons since the intifada began; scores of Arab children have been shot dead. 
 But rough justice on one side of the green line does not necessarily mean rough justice on the other. 
 Not yet, anyway. 
 Subtly, though, in other, more subterranean ways, the uprising has changed &mdash; and is still changing &mdash; Israeli society. 
 Arabs are no longer seen as cowardly and loathsome terrorists; their determination and solidarity has impressed their enemies. 
 Even the most hawkish Israeli cannot ignore the readiness for sacrifice that the Palestinans have displayed. 
 Mr Yitzhak Shamir, the Likud Prime Minister, seems to recognise this too. 
 His refusal to deal with the PLO is practical, not emotional. 
 Palestinians can still seem demonic. 
 The cruel killings of real or imagined collaborators have helped restore this image, yet who has forgotten that Jews executed traitors during their own struggle for national liberation? 
 Mr Shamir's Stern Gang was no exception. 
 For the 20 years between the 1967 war and the start of the intifada there was coexistence of sorts between Arabs and Jews, even if, in the words of Moshe Dayan, it was the uneasy coexistence of a rider and his horse. 
 That no longer exists. 
 &bquo;The achievement of the uprising,&equo; says the journalist Nahum Barnea, &bquo;is that the vast majority of Israelis who were happy with the status quo are now much more unhappy with it.&equo; 
 This has created a new sense of potential fluidity in political attitudes. 
 Apart from the hard core of settlers and Greater Israel ideologues, many ordinary people have become more open to discussion of the future of the West Bank and Gaza. 
 Territory for peace is not an impossible dream. 
 But this does not preclude extreme and non-peaceful solutions. 
 Those who believe in the &bquo;transfer&equo; of Palestinians now believe in it more openly. 
 At the same time, though, there are more people who can, perhaps for the first time since 1967, imagine that the Jews could go west, back into the green line, or into new borders adjusted to rid themselves of their Palestinian burden. 
 It would be premature &mdash; and misleading &mdash; to try to translate these slowly shifting attitudes into a readiness for dramatic change. 
 All Israel's responses to the intifada have so far been dictated externally, by the Palestinians or the Americans. 
 There is still no substantial domestic pressure on Mr Shamir to make concessions. 
 The Labour Party is still a partner in the national unity government. 
 Anniversaries are arbitrary events, and nothing will change when the uprising's third year begins tomorrow. 
 Yet Wednesday's decision by Egypt &mdash; in close consultation with the PLO &mdash; to accept a US mediation plan means that an Israeli-Palestinian meeting is now likely in the New Year. 
 A long, hard struggle lies ahead to convert the achievements of the intifada into real movement towards a diplomatic settlement. 
 West Bank elections and an Israeli withdrawal still seem a remote possibility. 
 The uprising is certainly an historic event, but the conflict over Palestine has been going on for a century now. 
 A lot of international help will be needed to get things moving. 
 In a rapidly changing world, preoccupied by Eastern Europe, the American Administration may not have the time or patience to devote to Israelis and Palestinians. 
 The war may well just go on and on. 
 Both sides remain stubborn. 
 The Palestinians are tired but still defiant after their long struggle and most Israelis, like Mr Rabin, remain confident that they can cope, even if their doubts are beginning to nag. 
 It is a dangerous moment, pregnant with hope teetering on the edge of despair. 
 Miami relaxes as policeman is found guilty of killing blacks. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 THE tension that has gripped Miami began to ease yesterday as a policeman, William Lozano, was found guilty of manslaughter over the killing of two young black men on a motorcycle in January. 
 Three days of rioting by Miami's black community followed the killing, and police and city officials were on full alert yesterday for a resumption of the riots if the jury acquitted the Hispanic-American policeman. 
 All police leave and holidays were cancelled. 
 Two police armoured cars stood outside the courthouse. 
 The six-person jury unanimously found that Lozano had improperly used his gun. 
 Lozano had claimed that the motorcycle was aimed at him, and that he had no time to leap out of the way. 
 His shot killed the motorcyclist, and the passenger died of injuries after the bike crashed. 
 Lazano, who has been in the force five years, will be sentenced on January 24. 
 He faces a maximum term of 60 years. 
 East Berlin pursues pillars of the old establishment. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 IN East Germany two men, formerly regarded as untouchable pillars of the old regime, have, rightly or wrongly, become the focus of over-zealous and sometimes bizarre persecution by the legal authorities and an indignant public. 
 Mr Alexander Schalck-Golodkowski, the previous state secretary for foreign trade gave himself up early yesterday to the police in West Berlin, where he is now under arrest. 
 He is accused by East Berlin, which has asked for his extradition, of embezzlement, corruption, and illegal dealings in arms and foreign currency. 
 A glittering figure on the international financial circuit, he not only provided East Germany with much-needed foreign currency but also played a central part in all political and economic exchanges with West Germany over the past 30 years. 
 He has protested his innocence, saying that before fleeing East Germany last weekend he dissolved the GDR's hard-currency accounts in Switzerland and transferred the sum of Dm60 million (&pound;22 million) to East Germany's state bank. 
 He said he had always worked for the benefit of his country and could not be held responsible for how the hard currency he procured was spent by its leaders. 
 Sources here said that if Mr Schalck-Golodkowski was put on trial his inside knowledge of life under Mr Erich Honecker could prove highly detrimental to the already disgraced former East German leaders. 
 But while Mr Schalck-Golodkowski's innocence or guilt must remain a matter for the courts, the detention of his friend and lawyer, Mr Wolfgang Vogel, clearly was in breach of the law. 
 It demonstrated the excesses that are possible in the present climate of confusion and for which the chief public prosecutor has apologised. 
 Mr Vogel, detained on Tuesday and held for 10 hours in a solitary cell, was arrested because the prosecutors believed he would reveal the whereabouts of Mr Schalck-Golodkowski. 
 For almost 30 years he was a key negotiator for East Berlin on &bquo;humanitarian questions&equo; and a confidante of Mr Honecker. 
 Spy swaps, prisoner exchanges, and negotiations to free the thousands of East Germans that this summer sought refuge in West German embassies, were his domain. 
 He said yesterday: &bquo;I was told that the buying-out of political prisoners by West Germany and the spy swaps were immoral and against the law.&equo; 
 Summit offers chance to improve British image in EC Hurd faces test of beliefs on Europe. 
 By Michael White in Strasbourg and Hella Pick 
 THE Strasbourg summit, which begins this morning, will prove a critical test of the political skills of the new Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, six weeks after he inherited the post in which Mrs Thatcher has tormented and overruled his predecessors. 
 Mr Hurd, who dared to speak French on French Radio this week, is as instinctive a European as the Prime Minister is not. 
 But loyalty and prudence will require him to do good by stealth this weekend if he is to restore Britain's tarnished European image. 
 Apart from last month's Elysee supper-summit, this is his first outing with Mrs Thatcher. 
 Tensions over the degree of British commitment to eventually joining the Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) during the Madrid summit in June contributed to Sir Geoffrey Howe's removal from the Foreign Office in July. 
 During Mr John Major's brief tenure he was made to look foolish on his one co-starring trip &mdash; the Commonwealth conference in Kuala Lumpur &mdash; by the Prime Minister's repudiation of the South African statement he had negotiated. 
 Unlike Mr Major, Mr Hurd is an experienced former diplomat and a Foreign Office Minister of State who has sounded made-for-the-job since day one, which is why he would probably not have got it but for the Lawson affair. 
 In what are often highly technical arguments where tone matters a lot, he sounds like a politician who would join the ERM as soon as practicable &mdash; possibly by the end of next year &mdash; just as Sir Geoffrey, Mr Heseltine and Mr Lawson would. 
 Mrs Thatcher does not sound that way. 
 Labour, which wants immediate negotiation on its own four-point terms of entry into ERM, now paints Mr Major as a Thatcher poodle on the issue. 
 That may be wrong. 
 And a Hurd-Major axis could prove crucial if the Prime Minister is to be dragged in when inflation, and the exchange rate, have drifted down far enough. 
 Meanwhile, Mr Hurd loyally reflects the cabinet line on Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) embodied in the treasury's &bquo;competing currencies&equo; paper issued on November 2 as an alternative to the Delors report's Stage II and III &mdash; the creation of a single central bank and currency. 
 Labour, too, rejects the independent central bank concept run by what Shadow Chancellor, Mr John Smith, has called &bquo;central bankers who inhabit a world comfortably insulated from European electorates&equo; &mdash; in other words undemocratic and deflationary. 
 Mr Hurd has no trouble stressing the need for a liberalisation of European markets in which Britain has often led the way. 
 He protests that the French-backed Intergovernmental Conference (IGC) to promote Delors II and III is premature when the consequences of Stage I &mdash; including next July's abolition of French and Italian exchange controls &mdash; are far from clear and the preparatory work not done. 
 He is less conspicuous in opposing the Social Charter as a costly threat to jobs if the standards of Germany are to be imposed on countries like Britain. 
 And, like Sir Geoffrey and Mr Heseltine, he routinely sets up federalism as a straw man to knock down. 
 But he does not use the harsh, emotive language of the Prime Minister. 
 In a speech in Oxford last weekend he stressed voluntary co-operation and diversity. 
 &bquo;European union is not a goal or an event. 
 It is a process. 
 Against that background I do not believe that the path of federalism is the right one for the Community.&equo; 
 Such use of the word &bquo;union&equo; is un-Thatcherite. 
 So Mr Hurd will use his diplomatic skills &mdash; and his French &mdash; in Strasbourg to keep the temperature down and take the rough edges off disagreement, while advancing with pragmatic caution greater British involvement in the rapidly evolving structure of the Community. 
 He does not favour its enlargement but does favour new forms of association for EFTA and the emerging democracies of Eastern Europe. 
 By contrast, Mr Major was a novice Foreign Secretary whose skills and stamina were tested to breaking point when &mdash; alone &mdash; he tried to modify the draft South African statement in Kuala Lumpur. 
 Mr Major won enough useful points in support of Britain's well-advertised aversion to punitive sanctions to have been able to brief Sunday papers about a &bquo;British victory&equo;. 
 It is not clear whether he knew then that Mrs Thatcher had decided to sign the statement and then issue her own alternative. 
 Informed sources say that Mr Major was informed &bquo;rather late&equo; when much of the Thatcher outburst had already been drafted by Charles Powell, her private secretary, who had accompanied her to the weekend retreat of Lankawi. 
 When Mr Major gave an unhappy press conference late on the Sunday night, his permanent secretary, Sir Patrick Wright, and other FO officials sat at the back of the room, suggesting either moral reinforcement or a watchdog role. 
 Mr Hurd needs no minders, but the 60 Tory MPs who declined to support Mrs Thatcher for leader last week, plus MEPs, this week's Lords report and many industrialists will be looking to him for a more emollient performance in difficult circumstances. 
 He has at least one advantage over his three predecessors, including Mr Francis Pym. 
 As things stand he does look &bquo;unassailable&equo;. 
 China slates reform wave. 
 By Stephen Vines in Hong Kong 
 THE Chinese Premier, Mr Li Peng, yesterday made what is believed to be his most forthright attack yet on the reforms sweeping Eastern Europe during a private meeting with a delegation from Hong Kong. 
 According to delegation sources, Mr Li said that Beijing was fortunate to have had the foresight to crack down on its democracy movement in June, preventing China from being thrown into the &bquo;turmoil and confusion&equo; now prevailing in Eastern Europe. 
 China has shown some restraint in commenting on events in Eastern Europe and has made its views evident only in oblique ways. 
 For example, the Chinese Communist Party pointedly sent a warm message of support to the conference of the hardline Romanian Communist Party. 
 However, events in Eastern Europe were evidently uppermost in Mr Li's mind during his meeting with the Hong Kong delegation which was in Beijing to discuss the future of the British colony. 
 Simon Long adds from Beijing: China seems to be retreating into a diplomatic posture reminiscent of the Cultural Revolution, at odds with both Washington and Moscow, and firing frequent broadsides against all-comers for alleged interference in its internal affairs. 
 Yesterday, East Germany was in the firing line for having received the Dalai Lamai, exiled spiritual leader of Tibet, in East Berlin on Wednesday. 
 China also &bquo;could not tolerate&equo; the award given to the Dalai Lama in Paris, and &bquo;condemned&equo; France for permitting the exiled democracy campaigner, Yan Jiaqi, to &bquo;conduct activities against the Chinese Government&equo;. 
 China was similarly indignant about plans for the awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to the Dalai Lama on Sunday, the anniversary of last year's demonstrations in Lhasa. 
 Star Watch A comet for Christmas:.. 
 By Alan Pickup 
 THE newly-found Aarseth-Brewington comet should brighten rapidly this month as it sweeps southwards through Ophiuchus in our morning sky, perhaps to become a naked eye object before it dips too far south to be seen from Britain. 
 Its path is plotted on our star map, with its position marked every fifth morning. 
 The stars near the middle of the map rise in the east at 05.00 tomorrow and at 04.00 on Christmas Day, climbing to reach the places shown above the ESE to SE horizon at daybreak tomorrow and by 07.00 on Christmas Day. 
 Most of the brighter stars plotted are of the second magnitude, while the fainter ones are of the fourth. 
 The comet was close to the ninth magnitude on November 16 when it was discovered by amateur astronomers in Norway and the United States. 
 As it moves towards Perihelion on December 27, 45m km from the Sun and 140m from the Earth, it is doubling in brightness every four days or so. 
 The path is definite, but predictions of its brightness and appearance are very uncertain, although it is likely to develop an upwards pointing tail. 
 It may reach the sixth magnitude by December 10 and the fourth on about December 20 when it moves inside Mercury's orbit and passes the star Zeta Ophiuchi. 
 It may be brighter than the third magnitude by Christmas morning, but by then it will be low and difficult in the SE twilight. 
 Egypt accepts US talks plan. 
 By Deborah Pugh in Cairo 
 AFTER two months of agonising diplomatic wrangling, Egypt, with the apparent tacit agreement of the PLO, has agreed to the five-point formula of the US Secretary of State, Mr James Baker, for talks between Israel and the Palestinians. 
 The next step will be a round of preliminary talks between the Egyptian and Israeli Foreign Ministers and Mr Baker to be held in Washington early next month. 
 The aim of these talks will be to set up a dialogue between Palestinians and Israelis in Cairo on elections in the occupied territories. 
 The Washington talks will centre on the crucial issue of who will represent the Palestinians. 
 On the official level, the PLO is still insisting that &bquo;it is ready to accept to deal with the Baker plan&equo; but only if the composition of the Palestinian delegation is publicly selected by the PLO. 
 Egyptian insistence on this position would lead to a withdrawal of Israeli participation, given the refusal of the Prime Minister, Mr Yitzhak Shamir, to deal directly with the PLO. 
 The Egyptians, while insisting that they do not speak for the Palestinians, appear ready to fudge the principle of PLO selection of the Palestinian delegation to ensure Israeli participation. 
 A source close to the Egyptian foreign ministry said: &bquo;We are trying to circumvent the ideological issue. 
 We will choose PLO delegates. 
 Any Palestinian who speaks will have to have the approval of the PLO, but this will not be said publicly because we don't want to give Shamir the chance to withdraw, which we think he's looking for an excuse to do.&equo; 
 Reports from Jerusalem yesterday showed the usual split in government reaction. 
 The Defence Minister, Mr Yitzhak Rabin, welcomed the Egyptian acceptance of the Baker plan, while Mr Shamir's aide, Mr Avi Pazner, gave a restrained response. 
 &bquo;We are waiting to receive the content of the Egyptian response from the United States,&equo; Mr Pazner said. 
 &bquo;When we receive it we will study it carefully and later decide how to react.&equo; 
 The Americans are clearly hoping that it will be possible to bring the Palestinians and Israelis around the negotiating table without confronting the contradictions and achieve an historic breakthrough. 
 The PLO leader, Mr Yasser Arafat, who was in Cairo earlier this week, appears to be giving tacit support to the Egyptian strategy. 
 He has, at least, not publicly opposed Egypt's diplomatic initiatives. 
 The Egyptian Foreign Minister, Dr Esmat Abdel Meguid, yesterday undercut recent reports that a rift was developing between the PLO and Egypt. 
 He said in Tunis that Egypt had held consultations with the PLO before officially accepting the Baker plan. 
 Hrawi will resign unless Aoun goes. 
 By Reuter in Beirut 
 PRESIDENT Elias Hrawi has threatened to resign if he fails to topple General Michel Aoun, whom he accused of blocking his way to unite and bring peace to Lebanon. 
 &bquo;I did not come to the presidency to become a president who will consolidate partition or to manage a crisis,&equo; he said yesterday. 
 &bquo;I have come to restore Lebanon's unity and extend the sovereignty of the government over Lebanese territory. 
 &bquo;When my patience runs out with all the mediation and when I exhaust my capabilities I will issue a statement to all Lebanese and apologise. 
 I will tell them &bquo;this is your actual situation&equo;, and leave.&equo; 
 Mr Hrawi has not been able to move into the presidential palace in the Beirut suburb of Baabda because it is occupied by Gen Aoun. 
 He said foreign mediators had asked him not to use force to break Gen Aoun's control of the enclave. 
 He refused to set a time within which he would step down, saying he was giving diplomacy time to solve the crisis peacefully. 
 It was essential to act quickly to avert the partition of Lebanon into religious cantons. 
 &bquo;The country is living on a volcano, in a field of mines,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I am against war and operations which disrupt peace and cause death and destruction,&equo; Mr Hrawi said. 
 But he added that patience had limits and he might wait a few days or two weeks. 
 Syrian forces, Lebanese troops, and militiamen have been poised for a week for an attack to seize the palace. 
 Diplomatic sources said Syria had increased its troops in Lebanon from about 30,000 to 45,000 since Mr Hrawi's election. 
 Mr Hrawi said no decision had been taken yet for a military showdown. 
 He accused Gen Aoun of using as &bquo;sandbags&equo; the thousands of Christians who have gathered outside the palace to deter an attack. 
 Spain swears in unchanged cabinet. 
 By John Hooper in Madrid 
 THE Spanish Prime Minister, Mr Felipe Gonzalez, decided against reshuffling his cabinet to stabilise a political climate which had become increasingly unpredictable since the October 29 general election, sources close to him said yesterday. 
 The unchanged team was sworn in yesterday by King Juan Carlos. 
 Fresh elections are pending in three of Spain's 52 constituencies after judges annulled the results, citing widespread irregularities. 
 The quasi-liberal Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, which topped the poll six weeks ago, is now one seat short of an overall majority in the Congress of Deputies. 
 The Socialists suffered a sharp drop in votes and seats. 
 Mr Gonzalez managed to win a vote of confidence in the first round only with the support of a Canary Islands deputy who is widely regarded as a parliamentary spokesman and lobbyist for the Tenerife banana planters. 
 Mr Luis Mardones was the only deputy elected for the Independent Groupings of the Canaries (AIC). 
 An unchanged cabinet had been widely expected, but only as a temporary measure because of the uncertainty caused by the courts. 
 The verdicts gave up to three months for new polls to be held. 
 Government sources, however, suggested that that the Prime Minister would not necessarily change his team after the final outcome became known. 
 Several opposition parties interpreted Mr Gonzalez's attitude as defiance of public opinion. 
 A spokesman for the largest opposition group, the People's Party, said the Prime Minister was acting &bquo;as if nothing had changed&equo;. 
 Mr Gonzalez has also come in for criticism from within his own party. 
 A leader of Socialist Left, a radical pressure group, said the confirmation in office of the old team was &bquo;a serious mistake, because it signals the endorsement of an economic policy criticised by a lot of people&equo;. 
 Mr Mardones cast his decisive vote, on Tuesday night, after the Prime Minister promised to &bquo;consider&equo; his tiny group's demands. 
 Soviet Union appears to accept reunification of two states is inevitable Kremlin agrees to plan for German confederation. 
 By Hella Pick Diplomatic Editor 
 THE Soviet Union accepts in principle confederation between East and West Germany, and expects that this key move towards German reunification will be ratified next year at the summit meeting of the 35 signatories of the Helsinki Declaration. 
 This has emerged from briefings by the West German Foreign Minister, Mr Hans-Dietrich Genscher, to members of the German Bundestag about his visit to Moscow earlier this week. 
 It represents an important clarification of the Soviet position on German unity, after Mr Eduard Shevardnadze, the Foreign Minister, and other senior Soviet spokesmen took issue with Chancellor Helmut Kohl's 10-point plan for German reunification. 
 It seems to show that the Soviet Union has already accepted the inevitability of a drawing together of the two Germanys. 
 The Soviet leader's main aim for the summit, apart from celebrating the conclusion of a treaty on conventional arms cuts in Europe, would be to discuss the German question within the context of the momentous changes in East-West relations. 
 Mr Gorbachev insists, as a condition to German confederation, that the 35 &mdash; which include the US and Canada, as well as the two Germanys and all other European states except Albania &mdash; must formally reaffirm the permanence of the Oder-Neisse line, the present Polish-German border. 
 This would also bind an eventually merged Germany, which the Soviet Union recognises might be born when Nato and the Warsaw Pact give way to a new European security system. 
 President Bush also came away from his talks with Mr Gorbachev in Malta convinced that the Soviet leader recognised that German reunification may turn out to be unavoidable, but that it must come as part of a wider European endeavour to end the post-war division of Europe. 
 The Soviet leader's main concern is to avoid an &bquo;artificial&equo; acceleration of the process. 
 But, as Mr Gorbachev said at his Malta press conference, &bquo;in order to remain realists, we should say that history decides the processes and fates on the European continent, and also the fates of those two &lsqb;German&rsqb; states.&equo; 
 Mr Gorbachev first called for a Helsinki 2 summit next year in Rome last week. 
 He envisaged a &bquo;commonwealth of sovereign democratic states&equo; to give substance to his concept of a common European home. 
 President Franois Mitterrand voiced strong support for the idea after his meeting with President Gorbachev in Kiev on Wednesday. 
 President Bush has agreed that the conventional arms treaty should be signed at summit level, and the Americans know that this means in practice that Mr Gorbachev will have his Helsinki 2. 
 Although only the 23 Nato and Warsaw Pact countries are directly involved in the arms negotiations, the treaty will come under the umbrella of all Helsinki Declaration countries. 
 Nato and Warsaw Pact foreign ministers are expected to meet in Vienna in March to review progress of the conventional arms negotiations. 
 The two Germanys do not need foreign approval before moving towards confederation, the head of Chancellor Kohl's Christian Democrat party, Mr Volker Ruehe, said in an interview published today. 
 Rebel troops end siege of Manila area. 
 By Sheila Coronel in Manila 
 ABOUT 400 rebel soldiers returned to their barracks yesterday morning, ending the siege of Makati after they had occupied the capital's affluent business district for six days. 
 The mutineers, all members of an elite scout-ranger regiment, marched to a nearby army camp, defiantly saying that they did not surrender to the government. 
 &bquo;We have won some victories,&equo; said Capitain Danilo Lucas, a West Point graduate who took part in the rebellion. 
 &bquo;We are not surrendering, we are voluntarily going back to barracks.&equo; 
 In the central Philippine city of Cebu, meanwhile, negotiations with the 200 army rebels who seized an air force base are at a stalemate. 
 The air force general leading the mutineers refused to give up control of the base even as the seige of Makati ended. 
 As the military mutiny dragged on for the sixth day, President Corazon Aquino asked Filipinos to &bquo;join hands and consolidate our resources to rebuild what we have destroyed&equo;. 
 Military officers said more disruptions by mutinous soldiers were still possible. 
 &bquo;I can not guarantee that there will be no more coup attempts,&equo; said the armed forces spokesman, Brigadier-General Oscar Florendo. 
 During a meeting yesterday, Mrs Aquino told her cabinet &bquo;to take a long, hard look at ourselves in order to see what it is we did wrong and what else needs to be done so we can all benefit from this tragic experience in our lives&equo;. 
 She is expected to implement measures to address the popular grievances that have helped to fuel the mutiny. 
 In the past month, Mrs Aquino's popularity has declined, and there was growing disenchantment with her government's ability to provide adequate transport and power, and to contain corruption. 
 Government officials say that state of emergency declared by Mrs Aquino on Wednesday should make it easier for the government to control prices and improve transport and other services. 
 The decree allows the government to take over public utilities and businesses. 
 A cabinet reshuffle is expected to follow. 
 Replacing cabinet secretaries who are popularly perceived as ineffective was &bquo;part of the stocktaking that has to be done&equo;, the press Secretary, Mr Adolfo Azcuna, said. 
 At the same time, Mrs Aquino is mobilising popular support for her beleaguered government. 
 In an emotional television appeal yesterday, she called on Filipinos to bring their families to a mass today at a religious shrine on a main motorway in suburban Manila. 
 The spot marks the place where where hundreds and thousands gathered in February 1986 for a popular uprising that overthrew the late President Ferdinand Marcos, and made Mrs Aquino the President. 
 Cardinal Jaime Sin, the influential Archbishop of Manila, who called on Filipinos to support the uprising against Marcos, joined Mrs Aquino's appeal. 
 &bquo;The future of the nation is in your hands,&equo; he said in a radio broadcast. 
 The rebels left Makati after negotiations with military officers and marched back to their barracks with rifles, bazookas, and machine-guns, chanting: &bquo;No surrender, the fight goes on.&equo; 
 Brigadier-General Arturo Enrile, the government negotiator, said the mutineers had initially demanded Mrs Aquino's resignation, but eventually &bquo;reason prevailed over whatever political or ideoligical convictions they had.&equo; 
 Gen Enrile went on: &bquo;I told them they would be treated fairly, justly and humanely but they must be man enough to take the consequences of their actions.&equo; 
 At the camp, the rebel troops were welcomed with a banner that read: &bquo;Welcome home.&equo; 
 They shook hands and embraced government soldiers. 
 &bquo;We will not surrender even if it takes forever,&equo; said Corporal Roy Bantung. 
 &bquo;The government must change. 
 The president must change her policies.&equo; 
 France ends aid to Comoros. 
 France has decided to cut off aid to the Comoros Islands until the French mercenary, Mr Bob Denard, and his men, who seized control 10 days ago, leave the archipelago, government sources said yesterday. 
 France is the Comoros's chief funder. 
 The second largest backer, South Africa, said on Monday it was suspending aid and demanded the withdrawal of mercenaries. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Arabs drop UN vote. 
 The Arab group at the UN decided yesterday not to press for a vote on upgrading the PLO's UN status after the General Assembly President, Mr Joseph Garba of Nigeria, urged the sponsors to drop their resolution. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Contras continue. 
 The US said yesterday the contras should not disband this week, as required by a regional peace agreement, because Nicaragua had not fulfilled conditions of the pact. 
 &bquo;Non-lethal&equo; assistance will continue until February. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Somali offensive. 
 Somali rebels said last night they had captured the country's second-largest city after &bquo;an all-out offensive&equo; that prompted many government troops to defect to their side. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Lenin under attack. 
 Polish protesters hurled paint and petrol on a monument to Lenin in Krakow and set it on fire yesterday before clashing with police, who used force to break up the second anti-Soviet disturbance in a week. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Bogota truck bomb. 
 A truck bomb exploded yesterday in Bogota, hour, killing and injuring hundreds of people, destroying stores and damaging the federal police headquarters. 
 Police blame the cocaine cartels. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Cuban war dead. 
 Cuba said that more than 2,000 of its soldiers were killed while fighting abroad over the last three decades, nearly all of them in Angola. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 PAGE 
 Thatcher refuses to budge on unity. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 BRITAIN yesterday took comfort from reports of an alleged overnight breach between the West German Chancellor, Dr Helmut Kohl, and the French on the need to set a date for a Community monetary union conference. 
 Before she left for Strasbourg, Mrs Thatcher refused to budge in her hostility to the EC Social Charter and the Delors plan for economic and monetary union. 
 Senior ministers last night emphasised that the British position had remained unchanged since the Madrid summit, where they had stressed that adequate preparation had to be made long before stages II and III of the Delors plan could be settled. 
 They took comfort from Dr Kohl's apparent embrace of the need for more detailed discussion of the Delors proposals and more powers for the European Parliament and restated their belief that a conference on economic and monetary union should not be held hastily. 
 The ministers interpreted Dr Kohl's statement as a move towards their position. 
 The Prime Minister gave no hint during her performance in the Commons yesterday that her language at Strasbourg will be any less caustic than the manner she has adopted at recent Commonwealth summits. 
 She said she believed the adoption of the Social Charter would &bquo;cause a great increase in unemployment not only in this country but in others as well, and would probably end in Fortress Europe&equo;. 
 Despite warnings, Mrs Thatcher stressed her leadership role in Europe, saying that it was Britain which had put up an alternative scheme to the Delors plan and had taken the initiative over the idea of associate EC status for East Germany. 
 These would be considered alongside the Delors plan, would go beyond its stage I, and would not require any central bank or common currency, but would result in more consistent monetary policies, Mrs Thatcher insisted. 
 The Labour front bench exploited the recent disclosures over hidden subsidies to sweeten the sale of the Rover Group, telling Mrs Thatcher that she went to Strasbourg with a tarnished reputation. 
 But her more confident mood was sustained by an intervention during the House of Commons prime ministers' question time by the former Labour cabinet minister, Mr Peter Shore. 
 An unreconstructed anti-Marketeer, he punctured Labour's new pro-European image by describing the Kohl move as a &bquo;welcome respite from the headlong rush into European union&equo;. 
 To loud Conservative cheers, he demanded a serious study of the constitutional and economic consequences of monetary union, adding that it should not be a study confined to European central bank governors. 
 Blue Peter makes NHS insomnia pill Sketch. 
 By Andrew Rawnsley 
 IT IS a revealing commentary about the state of the National Health Service that this year's Blue Peter charity appeal asks its viewers to collect tin cans for intensive care units for children. 
 Presumably the viewers' discarded baked bean cans are not for actually building the intensive care units, but are to be recycled for money to fund them. 
 Yet this added the one element of excitement to yesterday's speech by the Health Secretary, introducing the second reading of the NHS Bill. 
 In Blue Peter tradition, Mr Kenneth Clarke might demonstrate how to further help your local hospital using items to be found around the home. 
 Make your own kidney dialysis machine using an old cereal packet, some Sellotape and a used toilet roll. 
 Find a plastic straw and a squeezy bottle &mdash; there, you have a saline drip. 
 Keep those milk bottle tops: with a bit of ingenuity, and an empty egg box, you can fashion them into a pacemaker for granny. 
 Unfortunately, Mr Clarke only delivered another speech lauding the Government's plans for the NHS. 
 The speech was all too unexciting, having travelled the country for the past year, and not noticeably improving with age. 
 Nor was the speech by his Labour opposite number, Mr Robin Cook, that much more uplifting. 
 This is not meant to be ungenerous toward the two, who, on their day, can be a couple of the finest debaters in the Commons. 
 It is just that they have both been at it too often recently. 
 As Mr Cook reminded us: &bquo;The Secretary of State and I have frequently jousted with each other.&equo; 
 They are running out of rude things to say about each other, or new things to say about the NHS. 
 So Mr Clarke routinely hailed his bill as giving the NHS &bquo;a new lease of life&equo;. 
 And Mr Cook routinely railed that it would &bquo;destroy the NHS.&equo; 
 Both speeches were a bit tired. 
 Both men were betraying one of the most feared occupational hazards amongst MPs &mdash; debater's droop. 
 But both Mr Cook and Mr Clarke also seemed determined to make up in duration what they lacked in originality. 
 Mr Cook's speech alone was the length of a short story. 
 Mr Clarke's speech was the length of a novel. 
 The Health Secretary began with the now-familiar defence of his proposals. 
 &bquo;I've been accused of wanting to send people 60 miles down the road to hospitals they don't want to go to&hellip; of doctors not having enough money to pay for drugs&hellip; of going to close down vital wards&hellip; 
 &equo; This part of the Health Secretary's speech would have been better set to some wailing violins. 
 After half-an-hour of this sort of thing, it suddenly began to dawn on everybody that Mr Clarke had only got to clause one of the actual legislation. 
 It did not take a mathematical genius to work out that &mdash; with 59 clauses still to go &mdash; this was not brilliant progress. 
 Labour MPs began to protest. 
 Dennis Skinner gave an ostentatious yawn. 
 &bquo;Wind him down,&equo; yelled his deputy heckler, Brian Sedgemore. 
 But Mr Clarke showed no signs of winding down. 
 If anything, he had only just got wound up. 
 Another 30 minutes passed. 
 &bquo;Come on &mdash; an hour's enough,&equo; shouted Mr Sedgemore, to no avail. 
 So he and Mr Skinner started pointing at Tory MPs, appearing to be arguing about precisely how many of them had fallen asleep during the Health Secretary's speech. 
 I would like to give a definite answer. 
 But I must have nodded off at the time. 
 Patten warning on council rents. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 PUBLIC sector rents should go up to reflect the higher value of houses or flats in desirable areas, Mr Chris Patten, the Environment Secretary, said yesterday. 
 Mr Patten hinted that extra cash for public sector housebuilding will go where shortages are greatest. 
 However, Labour's housing spokesman, Mr Clive Soley, claimed that local authorities faced a 24 per cent cut in their housing investment programmes next year because of financial restrictions coming into force in April. 
 He said a survey had disclosed a gloomy picture of growing waiting lists, homelessness, and repair problems. 
 Mr Patten told the National House Building Council in London that his aim in the public rental sector was not to move to market-level rents or to end rent subsidies for the less well off. 
 &bquo;But we do want to create a pattern of rent differentials that will reflect rather better the relative values of different houses and flats. 
 &bquo;It cannot be right that a tenant in Middlesbrough, where housing is cheap, pays more than a tenant in Camden, where costs are very much higher, where well-paid jobs are much easier to come by, and there is such a concentration of commercial facilities.&equo; 
 He said better-off council tenants living in better properties in desirable and expensive areas would pay higher rents, while tenants in poor properties in cheap areas would face only modest rent rises. 
 Mr Patten said the best way to tackle housing shortages and homelessness was to build more homes, but the extra money, to be channelled through housing associations rather than councils, had to be concentrated in areas of most acute shortage. 
 &bquo;That may mean some shift in the regional balance of expenditure. 
 But we should be able to achieve that without cutting back in those regions where needs, though still real enough, are rather less acute.&equo; 
 Victory for war widows. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 THE Government is to produce a scheme before Christmas to improve the position of pre-1973 war widows the Prime Minister indicated yesterday. 
 Mrs Thatcher confirmed in the Commons that ministers were reconsidering their opposition to a sustained campaign by an all-party group of MPs. 
 The group regards the treatment of war widows before 1973, as an injustice when compared with the benefits paid to those widowed after that date. 
 There appears to be disagreements within Whitehall about whose budget should finance the estimated &pound;200 million for a scheme now under discussion. 
 This would raise the weekly pension of a widow of a second world war private from &pound;57 to more than &pound;100. 
 They would still not have equal treatment with Falklands war widows, who receive about &pound;124 a week. 
 The Prime Minister is expected to chair a cabinet sub-committee to settle which department should pay the bill. 
 She said the Government hoped to make a further statement &bquo;before Christmas&equo;. 
 How welfare net could not save Christopher.. 
 By Sarah Boseley 
 THE SHORT, tragic life of Christopher Palmer illustrates the difficulty of devising a welfare net that would catch all babies at risk of serious harm from their parents. 
 For the first five months of his life, Christopher was happy, well-adjusted and a trifle fat. 
 Two months later, he died of terrible injuries. 
 There were warning signals in between, and as a result he was placed on an at-risk register three weeks before he died. 
 But the parental attacks which led to the baby's death were unpredictably ferocious and sudden. 
 Social workers say they never had enough evidence of maltreatment to go to court for a care order. 
 An internal inquiry has been carried out by Ealing social services, in whose area Christopher lived for most of the last weeks of his life, but no serious professional errors were found. 
 An independent review, to be funded by Ealing council and Ealing health authority, has been commissioned. 
 Celia Palmer was 16 &frac12; when she gave birth to Christopher. 
 For five months, the two of them lived with her mother in Brighton. 
 In October, she and the baby moved to London to join her former boyfriend, Danny Palmer, also then 16, who may have thought he was the father. 
 Blood tests later proved he was not. 
 Danny was living in a children's home. 
 He left and found a squalid flat in Brentford, which they shared with another couple and their children. 
 Within two weeks, the Palmers brought Christopher to Ealing hospital, saying he had gone blue, stopped breathing and had blood round his nose. 
 Doctors could find nothing wrong, and sent them home. 
 They moved to Celia's father's house in Southall. 
 On November 8, James Ball, Celia's father, and his fiancee heard a loud thump upstairs. 
 Celia came down holding the baby, who had gone blue and stopped breathing. 
 She said that the baby had suffered a fit, and she had fallen on top of him. 
 A paediatric registrar at Ealing Hospital suspected the baby's injuries could be non-accidental. 
 Ealing social services department was alerted on November 9. 
 A second registrar examined Christopher, but decided it was possible Celia and Danny were telling the truth. 
 The baby was put through extensive tests during a 10-day stay but they failed to find any signs of the fits complained of. 
 Celia and Danny visited the hospital infrequently. 
 On November 17, the two registrars, nursing staff, social workers and the police decided there were insufficient grounds to start care proceedings, but put Christopher's name on the Child Protection Register. 
 Celia took the baby home next day. 
 Social workers visited Celia and Danny to arrange sessions at a family centre, but the couple announced they were going to spend two weeks in Hackney with Danny's mother. 
 A health visitor went to the house and the family GP called twice before they left. 
 None saw further cause for concern. 
 Ealing social services informed Hackney social workers and the health visitor that the family would be temporarily in the borough. 
 Within days of their arrival in Finsbury Park, Christopher had been brutally attacked. 
 He died in hospital on December 6. 
 Setting the scene for radical change. 
 FIVE years of debate culminated yesterday in a bill which sets the scene for the most dramatic transformation of British broadcasting since the launch of ITV in 1955, writes Georgina Henry, Media Correspondent. 
 A new commercial television channel, up to three new national commercial radio stations and numerous local TV and radio stations are among the proposals. 
 Their driving force is the government's determination to open up the market; to increase choice for viewers and listeners; to allow new entrepreneurs access to a highly regulated system; and to appease the advertisers, whose protests about the cost of TV advertising have reached a crescendo. 
 For television, what began with the appointment in March 1985 of Professor Alan Peacock to chair a committee looking at the financing of the BBC, has turned into a radical shake-up of commercial TV which, for the moment, leaves the BBC largely unscathed. 
 Since the white paper on broadcasting was published in November 1988, the debate has raged over whether the proposals will mean real choice for the public, or simply undermine what is best about the present system. 
 Opposition to the proposals has centred on plans to sell ITV franchises to the highest bidder, and the reduction in programme obligations for commercial TV. 
 Critics also argue that little account has been taken of changes already forced on commercial broadcasting before legislation. 
 Technological change has introduced commercial competition in the form of satellite TV. 
 ITV &mdash; condemned by the Prime Minister as the &bquo;last bastion of restrictive practices&equo; &mdash; has undergone a revolution in industrial relations, with tough new working practices imposed throughout the network in the last year. 
 Independent producers, whose dogged campaign to get into the BBC and ITV as well as Channel 4 has bitten deep into the old structures of the companies, now form an established and vibrant third force in television. 
 New ideas and working methods are beginning, for the most part, to revitalise the system &mdash; introducing competition for talent, and forcing broadcasters towards greater efficiency and realistic accounting. 
 Illness of 20 army cadets highlights algae problem Pollution risk to life hits leisure waters. 
 By Paul Brown Environment Correspondent 
 LAKES and reservoirs used for public recreation may have to be shut during peak demand in the summer as increasing pollution causes toxic algae blooms. 
 An unreported incident in which 20 army officer cadets were taken to hospital during the summer after canoeing in a lake at Leek, Staffordshire, has convinced the National Rivers Authority that Britain faces a serious algae problem. 
 Many businesses based on inland waters for yachting and other recreation now face an uncertain future as the water they depend on for their livelihood is likely to be closed during peak demand. 
 Partly because of water privatisation the problem has been played down because it will cost millions of pounds to solve. 
 The blue-green algae blooms of last summer were blamed on sunshine and drought but the underlying cause is the phosphates and nitrogen from sewage and farming. 
 Rutland Water, one of the country's largest reservoirs, where sheep and dogs died after drinking water close to the blue-green algae, is a classic case. 
 Water contaminated by nutrients from intensive farming is drawn from the river Nene into Rutland Water and sewage containing phosphates is pumped in from Oakham town. 
 The Anglian Water Authority, which said it had been constrained from discussing the problems because it might affect the price of shares during privatisation, refused last night to attend a meeting of local people worried about the problem. 
 Mr Nick Cox, a marina owner and yacht chandler, is one of a number of businessmen who has issued a writ against the authority for damages. 
 He said: &bquo;We have met with a wall of silence over this business. 
 We are very worried about our future. 
 We do not know whether the lake is safe for our customers to fall into.&equo; 
 Mr Michael Latham, Conservative MP for Rutland and Melton, went to see Mr Michael Howard, the minister responsible for water, on behalf of his constituents. 
 &bquo;I am very dissatisfied with everything I have seen and heard so far. 
 There is no satisfactory explanation of what happened, no co-ordination between the NRA, the Department of Environment and the water authority.&equo; 
 He said he was given explanations in the summer of the cause of the problem which were clearly wrong. 
 Man-made pollution appeared to be to blame. 
 &bquo;We need proper compensation for those who have lost sheep and beloved dogs and face financial difficulties because of their business losses. 
 Most of all we need action to find a long term solution. 
 I have written to Mr Howard demanding action.&equo; 
 Mrs Shelley Howard, senior biologist for the Severn Trent Authority, said there were 21 sites affected in her area. 
 The authority had not found out about the incident involving the cadets at Leek until they were in hospital, but tests on the water taken about the same time showed toxics from algae present. 
 The lake was closed by the British Waterways Board. 
 Professor Geoffrey Codd, a microbiologist from Dundee University and expert on blue-green algae said two cadets had been seriously ill and were detained in hospital for a week. 
 There case would be written up in medical journals &bquo;because we have eliminated every other possible cause.&equo; 
 The problem of toxics and blue-green algae had been known for a century in countries like Australia and the US where it occurred naturally. 
 The problem had hit Britain now because we were feeding the algae with phosphates and nitrates and causing blooms. 
 Environment Guardian, Page 27 
 News in brief: Sardinia to host England. 
 England have been seeded for next summer's World Cup and will play their three first-phase games in Sardinia, soccer's governing body, Fifa, announced. 
 Mr Bert Millichip, FA chairman, said the decision was made on the grounds of footballing ability, but the island was ideal for isolating the hooligans among England's travelling fans. 
 David Lacey, page 20; Trattoria talk, page 24. 
 Reservoirs fear. 
 Lakes and reservoirs may have to be shut during the summer as increasing pollution causes toxic algae blooms. 
 Page 2; Environment, page 27. 
 Scene of change. 
 Five years of debate has culminated in a bill which sets the scene for the most dramatic transformation of British broadcasting since the launch of ITV in 1955. 
 Page 10; Reaction, page 24; Leader comment, page 22. 
 Legal monopoly to go. 
 The bill to reform the legal profession and abolish barristers' monopoly rights in the higher courts will pave the way for solicitors to appear in any court, up to the House of Lords. 
 Page 9; Split widens, page 24; Leader comment, page 22. 
 Embryo fears &bquo;mistaken&equo;. 
 The Archbishop of York said in the Lords that opposition to human embryo research was based on biological, theological and philosophical mistakes. 
 Page 6; Letters, page 22. 
 BBC libel payout. 
 The reputation of one of the last of the Hi-de-Hi style holiday camps was vindicated when the BBC agreed to pay &pound;250,000 compensation for a libellous item on Esther Rantzen's That's Life programme. 
 Page 2. 
 Kidney donor &bquo;misled&equo;. 
 A Turkish print worker alleged a Harley Street doctor paid &pound;2,500 for him to donate a kidney to a patient he believed was a fellow countryman. 
 Page 3. 
 Water oversubscribed. 
 The &pound;5.3 billion water privatisation issue is 1.7 times oversubscribed so far, forcing financial advisers to &bquo;claw back&equo; shares promised overseas to meet public demand. 
 Page 16 
 News in brief: Five face leak charges. 
 Five people arrested in connection with alleged leaks of information to Loyalists have been charged with terrorist-related offences. 
 Three men will appear before Belfast magistrates today on charges of intimidation. 
 A fourth will be charged with having information likely to be of use to terrorists. 
 The fifth, a woman, was remanded on the same charge yesterday.. 
 Sardinia to host England. 
 England have been seeded for next summer's World Cup and will play their three first-phase games in Sardinia, soccer's governing body, Fifa, announced. 
 David Lacey, page 20. 
 Reservoirs fear. 
 Lakes and reservoirs may have to be shut during the summer as increasing pollution causes toxic algae blooms. 
 Page 2; Environment, page 27. 
 Scene of change. 
 Five years of debate has culminated in a bill which sets the scene for the most dramatic transformation of British broadcasting since the launch of ITV in 1955. 
 Page 10; Reaction, page 24; Leader comment, page 22. 
 Legal monopoly to go. 
 The bill to reform the legal profession and abolish barristers' monopoly rights in the higher courts will pave the way for solicitors to appear in any court, up to the House of Lords. 
 Page 9; Split widens, page 24; Leader comment, page 22. 
 Embryo fears &bquo;mistaken&equo;. 
 The Archbishop of York said in the Lords that opposition to human embryo research was based on biological, theological and philosophical mistakes. 
 Page 6; Letters, page 22. 
 BBC libel payout. 
 The reputation of one of the last of the Hi-de-Hi style holiday camps was vindicated yesterday when the BBC agreed to pay &pound;250,000 compensation for a libellous item on Esther Rantzen's That's Life programme. 
 Page 2. 
 Water oversubscribed. 
 The &pound;5.3 billion water privatisation issue is 1.7 times oversubscribed so far, forcing financial advisers to &bquo;claw back&equo; shares promised overseas to meet public demand. 
 Page 16 
 Spillage from nuclear sub. 
 Thirty gallons of contaminated cooling liquid from a nuclear submarine has been spilt into the VSEL shipyard in Barrow in Furness, Cumbria, it was disclosed yesterday. 
 The spillage occurred on Monday, when a hose connecting HMS Talent to a facility barge burst. 
 Punishment shootings. 
 The Royal Ulster Constabulary said that punishment shootings by republican and loyalist paramilitaries in Northern Ireland more than doubled to 155 this year, compared with 66 in 1988.. 
 Driving ban on MP. 
 Mr Michael Knowles, aged 47, Conservative MP for Nottingham East, was at South Western magistrates court in London yesterday fined &pound;200 and banned for 12 months after he admitted a drink driving offence. 
 Rape sentence cut. 
 Lee Anthony Roberts, aged 20, the sex offender scarred for life when his five-year-old victim's mother poured boiling water over his trousers, had his nine-year youth custody sentence for rape, imposed at Exeter Crown Court in November last year, cut to six years yesterday by the Court of Appeal. 
 Life for axe killer. 
 Leroy Pearson, aged 52, of Mitcham, Surrey, who axed his 30-year-old wife Leigh to death, was jailed for life at the Old Bailey yesterday.. 
 Girl, 11, murdered. 
 Police said yesterday that they could find no motive for the murder of 11-year-old Tasleen Akhtar, whose body was found in an alley near her home in Sparkhill, Birmingham. 
 Soldiers drown. 
 Two soldiers of the Queen's Own Hussars drowned and two escaped when their Chieftan tank rolled over into a canal at Hohne in West Germany on November 27. 
 Corporal Paul Moreton, 28, of Nuneaton, and Trooper Denis Brownhill, 20, of Birmingham were named after relatives had been located. 
 Heralding another TV channel, competitive tendering, and a boom in radio, yesterday's bill sets a new agenda for British broadcasting The sound and vision of market forces. 
 *. 
 By Joanna Coles 
 THE MAIN proposals contained in the 167 clauses of the Broadcasting Bill include: 
 A new Independent Television Commission to replace the Independent Broadcasting Authority and Cable Authority as a &bquo;light touch&equo; regulatory body without the IBA's detailed involvement in scheduling but with wider powers to enforce licence conditions and ownership rules. 
 Replacement of the present ITV system by a regional based Channel 3; and the issuing of 10-year franchises by the ITC to the highest bidder who passed a quality threshold unless &bquo;exceptional circumstances&equo; prevail. 
 The Home Secretary may, however, refuse to grant a franchise if he suspects the funding arrangements, or feels &bquo;it would not be in the public interest&equo;. 
 Channel 4 will be allowed to continue its current remit, ensuring a range of minority-interest programmes. 
 Appointments to the ruling body will be made by the ITC, and will require government approval. 
 Channel 4 will also sell its own advertising, but will have a financial safety net from Channel 3 if its revenue falls below 14 per cent of independent terrestrial TV revenue. 
 A new channel, Channel 5, will also be allocated by competitive tender reaching about 70 per cent of the UK. 
 High quality news coverage on Channels 3 and 5, by one or more news providers nominated by the ITC. 
 Safeguards for quality programming. 
 Licensees must provide a diverse programme service appealing to a wide variety of taste and interest, high quality news and current affairs and a reasonable proportion of other programmes of high quality. 
 Channel 3 has a statutory duty to provide regional programmes. 
 At least 25 per cent of original programmes will now come from independent companieswith a proper proportion of European origin. 
 Failure to meet programme promises could mean losing all or part of a substantial performance bond. 
 The creation of a new Radio Authority, which willallocate three new national radio licences by competitive tender, subject to a diversity requirement. 
 In the next three years, 300 more local radio stations could be set up, catering for local tastes, to &bquo;broaden the range of programmes available&equo;. 
 Rules ensuring media ownership is not concentrated in a few hands, with restrictions on cross media holdings. 
 The Broadcasting Standards Council is placed on a statutory footing, and will draw up a code &bquo;giving guidance&equo; on violence, sex and &bquo;standards of taste and decency&equo;. 
 The code will not be binding, but broadcasters will be asked to &bquo;reflect the general effect&equo; relevant to the programmes in question. 
 As well as being responsible for all viewers' and listeners' complaints, the council will also monitor programmes from outside Britain but received here. 
 The bill extends to other bidders the traditional competition between the BBC and ITV for screening certain events; while party political broadcasts will have to be shown on Channels 3,4, and 5. 
 Commenting on the proposals, Mr Alan Sapper, general secretary of the Association of Cinematograph, Television and Allied Technicians, said: &bquo;The bill spells a disastrous future. 
 We will get muck instead of public service broadcasting on our screens.&equo; 
 Mr Tony Hearn, general secretary of the Broadcasting and Entertaining Trades Alliance, warned that the introduction of greater competition and less regulation would lead to a &bquo;terminal decline in programme quality and diversity&equo;. 
 The Campaign for Press and Broadcasting Freedom claimed that the franchise auctions would drain cash from programme production into Treasury coffers. 
 Mr Steve Byron, of the Community Radio Association, said the bill would not deliver the diversity on the airwaves that the government had promised. 
 Manchester High School for Girls. 
 MANCHESTER High School for Girls, an independent institution, was not the subject of a photograph on page 3 of yesterday's Guardian which showed buckets being used to collect water from a leaking roof. 
 The accompanying caption should have identified the school as the North Manchester Girls' High School. 
 The Guardian apologises for the inadvertent omission of the word &bquo;North&equo; and for any impression that the premises of Manchester High School for Girls were not in good repair and in an appropriate condition for the education of its pupils. 
 Christians are not required to believe that humanness is created in an instant, Dr Habgood tells House of Lords debate Opposition to embryo research mistaken, says archbishop Embryology Bill. 
 Paul Nettleton. 
 THE ARCHBISHOP of York said yesterday that opposition to human embryo research was based on biological, theological and philosophical mistakes. 
 Dr John Habgood, speaking in the Lords during the second reading debate on the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Bill, said: &bquo;Christians are no more required to believe that humanness is created in an instant than we are required to believe in the historical existence of Adam and Eve.&equo; 
 He drew an analogy with the theory of evolution to argue that life was created by a cumulative process. 
 He said the alternative view was to take the standpoint of a fully-developed person looking back to some point marking the moment of creation. 
 He said: &bquo;If we are to give full moral worth to such persons, runs the argument, then we have to give full moral worth to the whole history from its very first moment. 
 This is a fine ideal but it seems to me to rest on biological, theological and philosophical mistakes. 
 &bquo;Despite the views of some, it does not in my view represent a view which is necessarily and unquestionably Christian.&equo; 
 Peers, and later MPs, will be offered in committee stage a free vote either to permit licensing of research for up to 14 days after creation of an embryo in vitro, or an absolute ban. 
 This was described by the Lord Chancellor, Lord Mackay, as a &bquo;drafting innovation&equo; as he outlined the arguments on both sides. 
 He said many scientists and doctors argued that further research could lead to improved treatment of infertility, find the causes and prevent the passing on of genetic diseases, improve contraception, and establish the causes of miscarriage. 
 But for opponents, embryo research was quite simply repugnant. 
 &bquo;Significant sections of religious opinions in this country take this view&hellip; because an embryo has the potential to become a child.&equo; 
 Lord Mackay, who like other party spokesman said he was speaking personally, added he would determine his own position after hearing the full debate. 
 He said: &bquo;We need to balance conflicting interests of those most closely concerned: the childless couple desperate for children, those who stand to gain from new scientific research, the human embryo with its potential for development. 
 To achieve the right balance we each of us need deep thought and inner quietness.&equo; 
 Lord Ennals, Labour health spokesman, said it was wrong for people not directly concerned to deny others &bquo;on the basis of a doctrine&equo; the benefits of carefuly controlled research. 
 But he feared the bill could be lost because the Government, by including the words &bquo;any subsequent development of such embryos&equo; in the bill's long title, was permitting debate on abortion time limits. 
 He urged the Government to make time for Lord Houghton of Sowerby's Abortion (Amendment) Bill, which peers debate next Thursday, to permit a separation of the issues. 
 The former Lord Chancellor, Lord Hailsham, said he believed the scientific community to be a responsible one. 
 &bquo;I would seriously ask the question of those who would impose an absolute prohibition, what kind of right in a free and liberal democracy do they think they have to say no to that group of people? 
 I can only say that I see no right whatsoever.&equo; 
 The Social Democrat, Lord Kennet, the first opponent of research to speak, said: &bquo;Those who say that this full-stop-sized mini-blob is not a human being must answer which part of the question they object to: human or being? 
 It's being. 
 It's also alive and and its made from human cells. 
 If it were not human you would not want it for research and if it was not human no one would deny you having it for research.&equo; 
 He was supported by the Duke of Norfolk, a Conservative and leading Roman Catholic, who said the white paper had offered a clear choice, while the bill would allow a choice between experiments up to 33 hours or up to 14 days and should be amended. 
 &bquo;My position is that an embryo should only be created for insertion into a specified woman and should receive the maximum protection from the moment of its creation and no non-therapeutic research should be allowed,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I consider that ethically a human person is created when the sperm of a male fertilises the ovum of a woman, thus creating an embryo&hellip; either in the fallopian tubes or in vitro. 
 &bquo;A proper regard for human dignity leads to proper respect for human life from its origin, which IVF itself demonstrates is at fertilisation. 
 The only safe course is to protect human life from the beginning.&equo; 
 Baronness Warnock (Ind), whose 1986 report forms the basis of the bill, said it would be a paradox if &bquo;we democratic and increasingly educated people should&hellip; put ourselves back into the 17th century, when the question of whether or not Galileo and indeed Descartes might pursue and publish their scientific findings was regulated not by scientific considerations, but by religious considerations.&equo; 
 We were now in the 20th century irrevocably, &bquo;part of an age where we must be allowed to take the possible risks of our own knowledge.&equo; 
 Legal split widens over bill to end monopoly. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 THE two branches of the legal profession last night remained split over the abolition of the barristers' monopoly in the higher courts as the Government published its Courts and Legal Services Bill, overturning centuries of lawyers' traditions. 
 The Law Society, representing solicitors, hailed the bill as &bquo;a modern statutory foundation for the legal profession of the future, in which outdated restrictions will have no part&equo;. 
 Mr David Ward, the society's president, said it would mean &bquo;an end to unnecessary double-manning&equo;. 
 But Mr Desmond Fennell, QC, chairman of the Bar, claimed there was a danger that many people needing legal help would have access only to a &bquo;more expensive Jack of all trades,&equo; while specialist skills were reserved for the privileged few. 
 Rules to be drawn up by the Law Society for solicitor advocates will need approval by four senior judges, all former barristers. 
 But the bill sets out a tight framework which will limit the judges' scope for blocking extra advocacy rights for solicitors. 
 The judges, heads of the High Court's four divisions, will have to take account of advice from a lay-dominated advisory committee. 
 Each will have to notify the Lord Chancellor in writing if he fails to approve the rules, giving reasons. 
 Approval can only be refused if the judge believes the rules are incompatible with a statutory objective and a general principle spelled out in the bill. 
 The statutory objective is that there should be new ways of providing legal services and a wider choice of providers. 
 The general principle is that advocates' rights should be determined only by whether they are properly trained and members of a professional body whose rules of conduct are &bquo;appropriate in the interests of justice in relation to the court or proceedings concerned&equo;. 
 The framework would allow the Law Society to seek judicial review in the High Court if a judge refused to approve the rules. 
 Introducing the bill yesterday, the Lord Chancellor, Lord Mackay, said it was anomalous that solicitors could not appear before judges in the crown court who were former solicitors. 
 Under the bill, many cases now dealt with by the High Court will be moved down to the county courts, currently plagued by staff shortages and a backlog of work. 
 Court staffing levels would be increased by 400 in the next financial year and an extra &pound;2 million had been allocated to the court service for this financial year. 
 Other changes include allowing banks, building societies and insurance companies to carry out conveyancing for home buyers; &bquo;no win, no fee&equo; agreements between lawyers and clients; and the creation of a legal services ombudsman. 
 Reports, page 9; Leader comment, page 22 
 Consumers group welcomes conveyancing competition. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 CONSUMERS should get a better deal as the Courts and Legal Services Bill opens up greater competition, Mr David Tench, legal officer of the Consumers' Association, said yesterday. 
 Giving banks and building societies the right to handle conveyancing might not make the service cheaper, but the competition should mean that it was done better. 
 The bill makes it a criminal offence, punishable by a &pound;1,000 fine, for a lender to try to force a mortgage applicant to use the lender's own services. 
 Banks and building societies offering conveyancing will be subject to a strict code of conduct and will have to make it clear that they are not offering independent financial advice. 
 About 10 per cent of solicitors &mdash; around 6,000 &mdash; might want to conduct cases in the higher courts, Mr David Ward, president of the Law Society, has estimated. 
 This would double the number of advocates and could make fees more competitive. 
 Proposals to allow cases on a &bquo;no-win, no-fee&equo; basis are unlikely to increase access to justice. 
 Lawyers already informally take on certain winners on this basis, and the reward proposed &mdash; a small uplift on normal fees &mdash; will not induce them to accept chancy cases. 
 Litigants should benefit from changes recommended by the Civil Justice Review to speed up and simplify civil cases. 
 Czech PM goes after opposition demands. 
 By Ian Traynor in Prague 
 CIVIC Forum, the Czechoslovak opposition movement, reacted in fury last night to the resignation of the Prime Minister, Mr Ladislav Adamec, accusing him of being entirely to blame for a &bquo;political crisis&equo;, and of citing &bquo;untrue facts&equo; in earlier threatening to resign. 
 The government and opposition traded invective and plunged the country's three week-old &bquo;peaceful revolution&equo; into uncertainty. 
 &bquo;By resigning today he is trying to avoid responsibility for the political crisis,&equo; said Mr Jiri Dienstbier, Forum spokesman. 
 Mr Dienstbier said the new Prime Minister, Mr Marian Calfa, did not yet appear to be a &bquo;strong and flexible politician&equo;, and indicated he would be acceptable in the post only on condition that President Gustav Husak step down, to be replaced by a non-Communist head of state. 
 Mr Vaclev Havel, Civic Forum leader, and Mr Alexander Dubcek, the former Communist leader, are two strong contenders for the presidency. 
 Mr Adamec cited pressure from the opposition in bargaining over the shape of a new government as his reason for stepping down. 
 The opposition rejected these claims entirely. 
 His resignation was followed by the expulsion from the Communist Party of its former leader, Mr Milos Jakes. 
 The politburo also expelled Mr Miroslav Stepan, former head of the party in Prague. 
 Both men were expelled &bquo;for gross political mistakes in tackling social tension, especially the events of November 17, 1989&equo;, when police clamped down on a pro-democracy demonstration. 
 Last night, Mr Havel held talks with Defence Ministry officials on the crisis, as President Husak moved swiftly, authorising the Deputy Prime Minister, Mr Calfa, to form a new government. 
 A government spokesman said that Mr Adamec's decision to quit was taken because of &bquo;unacceptable demands&equo; from Civic Forum, which earlier rejected the charge that it was putting undue pressure on the Prime Minister. 
 Mr Jan Urban, a leading activist of Forum, arguably the most potent political force in the country, indicated that a Communist prime minister was acceptable to the opposition but that the Forum would now demand a new non-Communist president to replace Mr Husak. 
 &bquo;We now face an extremely complicated 24 hours,&equo; said Mr Urban. 
 He expected talks last night between Forum and the small non-Communist parties to see what were the possibilities. 
 Mr Calfa, aged 43, has taken part in this week's negotiations between the government and opposition on the new cabinet line-up. 
 He was promoted from Minister without Portfolio to Deputy Prime Minister in the government unveiled by Mr Adamec last Sunday. 
 That cabinet came as a huge disappointment to the public and opposition, contributing much to the present unstable atmosphere. 
 Mr Adamec held talks with the small Socialist Party yesterday, after which the Socialist leader, Mr Bohuslav Kucera, announced that the Prime Minister was quitting because he wanted someone younger to handle the &bquo;compromise&equo;. 
 On Wednesday night, Mr Adamec went on national television to warn that he might quit because of intolerable &bquo;ultimatums, deadlines and strike threats&equo; from the opposition. 
 But yesterday Forum rejected the criticism and said it had put seven names to Mr Adamec for the cabinet posts. 
 Youth detained for murder of lover's baby. 
 By Susan Tirbutt 
 AYOUTH was sentenced to be detained at Her Majesty's pleasure at the Old Bailey yesterday for the murder of baby Christopher Palmer while the mother was convicted of cruelty but cleared of murder and manslaughter. 
 The jury also found Danny Palmer, aged 17, guilty of grievous bodily harm with intent and cruelty to the seven-month-old baby who died in Whittington Hospital, north London, last December from a fractured skull and other injuries. 
 He was also given concurrent youth custody sentences of five years, three years and one year. 
 Sentence was delayed on the mother, Celia Palmer, aged l8, who was remanded to stay in the hostel where she has been living during the trial while social and probation reports are prepared. 
 Mr Justice Ian Kennedy said he wanted to know about arrangements for her supervision over the next two years. 
 &bquo;My main concern is that, when the process of grieving starts &mdash; as it must &mdash; she will have full support.&equo; 
 He said that one would not expect a person found guilty of treating their own child cruelly to be allowed their liberty at once. 
 But Celia Palmer, who took her lover's name when she moved in with him, had been acquitted of all the gravest charges &bquo;hanging over her head this long time&equo;. 
 When the judge heard Celia hoped to live with her mother in Birmingham, he asked probation officers to report to him. 
 &bquo;I want to know what is going on in Birmingham, chapter and verse.&equo; 
 Miss Ann Curnow, QC, for Danny Palmer, in mitigation asked the judge to bear in mind his desperately unhappy background. 
 His act was an unpremeditated matter and was the culmination of a weekend of some considerable frustration. 
 Palmer had spent most of his life in and out of children's homes and was in care himself when he became stepfather to the baby. 
 Counsel said that there was evidence that Palmer liked to cuddle and play with the baby and how proud he was to be the baby's father, as he thought. 
 The court had heard that the baby died from terrible injuries including three skull fractures measuring 10 inches in total, two broken wrists and multiple bruising. 
 He was battered on the head with something like a bannister rail or rounders bat and probably slammed against a wall, the prosecution alleged. 
 Both defendants maintained to police that the baby suffered fits and had done so during the weekend he died. 
 They said they tried to revive him and that all the injuries were inflicted accidentally. 
 Turk kidney donor &bquo;misled on recipient&equo; *. 
 By Gareth Parry 
 ATURKISH print worker alleged yesterday that a Harley Street doctor paid &pound;2,500 for him to donate a kidney to a patient whom he believed was a fellow countryman. 
 Mr Ferhat Usta, a Muslim, said he realised minutes before the operation that his kidney was going to a Briton. 
 &bquo;I suddenly got out of bed half naked. 
 I realised I was being deceived,&equo; he told the General Medical Council's professional conduct committee. 
 Mr Usta, aged 34, who lives with his wife, mother and three daughters in a shack in an Istanbul shanty town, described how he came to London last year, attracted by a newspaper advertisement offering money to kidney donors. 
 He wanted to raise &pound;2,000 to treat one of his children who suffered from a tubercular hip infection. 
 Mr Usta was examined by Dr Raymond Crockett, a Harley Street physician specialising in kidney disease. 
 Dr Crockett, Mr Michael Bewick, a leading kidney transplant surgeon, and Mr Michael Joyce, a urologist at Guy's Hospital, deny professional misconduct over their involvement in transplanting kidneys from four living Turks, all of whom were paid for the organs. 
 Mr Usta recalled how two brothers, described as &bquo;kidney brokers&equo;, handed him &pound;2,500 in cash on the night before the operation in July 1988. 
 Speaking through an interpreter, Mr Usta said: &bquo;As far as I can figure it out, one day before the operation the cheque was given by Dr Crockett, it was changed and the money given to me that night.&equo; 
 On Monday, the first day of the hearing, Mr Roger Henderson QC, for the GMC, said Dr Crockett's notes included a bill for &pound;20,000 for a Mr B, described as a Briton living in Israel who was suffering from a disease affecting his kidneys. 
 Mr Usta said he had come to London under the impression that his kidney was to be donated to one of the &bquo;broker&equo; brothers, Ata Nur Kuntar. 
 He had said to Mr Kuntar: &bquo;You could have told me the truth from the very beginning. 
 Because I am a very poor man you made me accept a figure like six million lire (&pound;2,500). 
 An Englishman, if he is going to have an operation in a hospital like that, I am sure he would have at least &pound;5,000 in his pocket. 
 &bquo;I told him that I wanted &pound;5,000 from him. 
 He then accepted this and he told me he was going to pay me the other &pound;2,500 in Turkey in Turkish money.&equo; 
 He said he never received the extra money. 
 The hearing continues today. 
 Banks launder &pound;1,800m drugs money, say MPs. 
 By John Carvel Home Affairs Editor 
 AN ESTIMATED &pound;1,800 million of drugs money is circulating through the legitimate banking system in Britain, says a report yesterday by the Commons home affairs committee. 
 This could have a destabilising affect on smaller financial institutions. 
 The British money markets had become an international laundering centre for profits from illicit drug trafficking but the response of the Bank of England had been &bquo;passive.&equo; 
 The Home Office is planning tougher powers against laundering by adding extra clauses to the Criminal Justice (International Co-operation) Bill after its second reading this month. 
 But it is not clear whether this will satisfy the committee. 
 The committee quotes evidence from the National Drugs Intelligence Co-ordinator, Mr Barry Price, that the US, Canada, and some other countries regarded the United Kingdom as &bquo;an offshore banking system.&equo; 
 Britain continued to be &bquo;a major centre for money laundering&equo; in spite of tougher controls in the Drug Trafficking Offences Act 1986. 
 This legislation had been hailed as a powerful weapon with which to seize drug barons' fortunes but up to May last year police and Customs investigators had only been able to confiscate &pound;11 million. 
 The committee is &bquo;extremely concerned&equo; that the Bank of England and Committee of London and Scottish Bankers seemed &bquo;passive&hellip; in responding to the significant threat facing financial institutions from money laundering.&equo; 
 The bank should examine the scale of the problem and suggest remedies. 
 It recommends tighter controls against drug money, which is sometimes being carried in and out in suitcases and carrier bags. 
 US customs officials told the MPs this was a &bquo;significant loophole.&equo; 
 Anyone importing or exporting large sums in cash should be obliged to declare it and Customs officers should have power to seize the money if they suspected it was derived from crime. 
 Dame Janet Fookes, Tory MP for Plymouth Drake, said sums over &pound;5,000 should be declared. 
 The report recommends relaxation of the ban on police acting as agents provocateurs to permit US-style &bquo;sting&equo; operations to trap traffickers. 
 Officers should be allowed &bquo;to take part in conspiracies to import drugs so long as they withdrew prior to importation.&equo; 
 Mr Wheeler said police already went to public lavatories to detect sex offenders. 
 It was time they transferred their attentions from &bquo;the municipal privy&equo; to suites at top hotels where those sort of drugs deals are carried out. 
 Officers would perform excellent service if they could put themselves in a position to receive information which could be translated into proceedings before a jury. 
 Home Affairs Committee 7th report 1988/9; Drug trafficking and serious crime; HMSO &pound;7.40 
 Paris and Bonn seek to avert monetary split. 
 By John Palmer European Editor in Strasbourg 
 ON the eve of the most significant European Community summit of recent years, the French and West German governments moved quickly yesterday to avert a damaging split over plans to move to full European economic and monetary union. 
 Following some intense telephone diplomacy between Bonn and Paris, Chancellor Helmut Kohl and President Franois Mitterrand agreed that the Strasbourg EC summit, which opens here today, should after all agree a date for revising the Treaty of Rome and preparing for supra-national monetary union. 
 Earlier reports that Chancellor Kohl had suggested delaying fixing the date for a special EC conference on monetary union for a year had led to a stark and none too veiled warning from the President of the European Commission, Mr Jacques Delors, that this might plunge EC relations with West Germany &bquo;into a serious crisis&equo;. 
 The displeasure of President Mitterrand, host here for the two-day summit, was also made known, and within hours the Bonn government had backed off any confrontation with its French allies. 
 At a press conference in Bonn, a senior official in the Chancellery said the West German and French governments had agreed that the inter-governmental conference on monetary union would begin at the end of next year &mdash; as Paris had originally insisted. 
 Mr Lutz Stavenhagen said that he expected 11 out of the 12 EC leaders in Strasbourg to endorse the proposal &mdash; a reference to the renewed isolation of Mrs Thatcher over the issue. 
 Bonn officials last night played down the extent of the last-minute rethink of their tactics at Strasbourg and one said that it had all been a &bquo;silly misunderstanding&equo;. 
 But Chancellor Kohl appears to have been startled by suggestions that his letter to President Mitterrand last week implying an intention to go slow on EMU might have been inspired by a desire to play the German unity card in the West German general election next year. 
 President Mitterrand took the opportunity of his visit to President Gorbachev in Kiev this week to spell out his insistence on the inviolability of Germany's frontiers with its eastern neighbours and emphasise East German democratisation rather than German reunification. 
 All the signs are that President Mitterrand's approach is supported by Chancellor Kohl's foreign minister, Mr Hans-Dietrich Genscher. 
 Not all the differences in approach to economic and monetary union have been ironed out between the French and the West Germans but they concern the speed and extent of the shift to a supra-national system, for running the community's economy. 
 The West Germans want the revision of the Rome Treaty and national parliamentary endorsement of an EC central bank and other institutions to be in place by the time of the next European Parliament elections &mdash; in June 1994. 
 The French President and some other EC governments believe the new system should be ready for operation by the end of 1992 when the single barrier and frontier free European market is due to be completed. 
 While the French and West Germans believe a supra-national system for regulating the EC economies should be subject to democratic scrutiny by the European Parliament, Chancellor Kohl wants this agreed and in legal form before other changes are made to the Treaty of Rome to create the proposed EC central bank or to give the EC Council of Ministers powers to override national governments. 
 All of this is bad news for Mrs Thatcher. 
 The Prime Minister objects to a guillotine date for the treaty revision conference even more than to setting of an opening date for the inter-governmental conference where she is resigned to be outvoted. 
 And she made clear only last week the depth of her opposition to giving the European Parliament more power. 
 Hurd's test of beliefs, page 12; Leader comment, page 22; E German poll deadline, page 24 
 That's Life made to pay for cheap jibe against &bquo;last of the Hi-de-Hi camps&equo;. 
 By Sarah Boseley 
 THE reputation of one of the last of the Hi-de-Hi style holiday camps was vindicated yesterday when the BBC agreed to pay record compensation of &pound;250,000 for a libellous item on Esther Rantzen's That's Life programme. 
 After a programme broadcast in June attacking the inexpensive facilities offered at the Majestic Holiday Camp in Barry Island, Wales, nearly 10,000 people cancelled their bookings. 
 Mr Frederick Wright, chairman of Barry Island Resort Ltd, which bought the camp three years ago, said the BBC later received 30,000 postcards from holidaymakers who had enjoyed their stay. 
 The programme alleged that the living conditions and communal facilities at the resort, built by Billy Butlin in the 1960s to offer a week's holiday for a week's pay, were &bquo;so squalid and dangerous&equo; that no sensible person would spend time or money on a holiday there. 
 A week's accommodation costs between &pound;15 in low season and &pound;48 a person. 
 Mr Wright's solicitor, Mr Alasdair Pepper, yesterday told Mr Justice Michael Davies in the High Court that the programme gave a false impression of the resort, misrepresenting the quality and nature of the facilities. 
 There was no truth in any of the allegations, which Miss Rantzen and the BBC now recognised, he said. 
 The resort's advertisements were accurate and all the entertainment and leisure facilities described as free were indeed absolutely free. 
 About 25,000 people &mdash; over a third of the holidaymakers who stayed at the holiday camp this year &mdash; had rebooked for next year, he said. 
 The BBC's solicitor, Mr Sean McTernan, said they accepted that the allegations were false and should not have been broadcast. 
 He explained that the programme makers had relied on a handful of people whose experience and view of the holiday camp were not representative of the resort as a whole or the experience of the vast majority of holidaymakers. 
 In a statement afterwards, the BBC said it had &bquo;apologised to Mr Wright and his family and expressed their regret for the damage and distress caused&equo;. 
 A retraction would be broadcast when a new series of the programme begins in January. 
 The corporation will pay the estimated &pound;250,000 costs of the action, which had been due for trial in January. 
 The settlement is believed to be the largest compensation payment the BBC has ever made, topping the &pound;75,000 paid in April 1982 to Dr Sydney Gee, who ran a Harley Street slimming clinic. 
 The costs in that case, which went to trial, came to &pound;1.2 million. 
 Although Dr Gee was also libelled by That's Life, the BBC said yesterday no inquiry into the programme would take place. 
 Mr Wright said after the settlement that not only his resort, which he described as &bquo;the last of the Hi-de-Hi holiday camps in Great Britain&equo; but also Barry Island, which had some of the finest beaches in the UK, had been vindicated. 
 &bquo;The BBC received 30,000 postcards from happy holidaymakers telling them they had got it wrong. 
 That kind of people power has brought about the result today.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;I think Esther Rantzen does a tremendous amount of good work, but she is a media star and I would hope that she will realise that people accept what she says as gospel truth. 
 &bquo;The BBC has always been classified as the station which tells the truth and they should make sure their research has been properly done before they publish anything else.&equo; 
 Heralding another TV channel, competitive tendering, and a boom in radio, yesterday's bill sets a new agenda for British broadcasting The sound and vision of market forces. 
 *. 
 By Joanna Coles 
 THE MAIN proposals contained in the 167 clauses of the Broadcasting Bill include the formation of a new Independent Television Commission to replace the Independent Broadcasting Authority; the replacement of the present ITV system by Channel 3; and the issuing of 10-year franchises by the ITC to the highest bidder unless &bquo;exceptional circumstances&equo; prevail. 
 However, although the ITC will allocate licences to all TV channels, it is intended as a &bquo;light touch&equo; body, not involved in detailed programming, but with wider powers to enforce ownership rules than the IBA. 
 In the event of two or more applicants for the same franchise, both parties will be able to submit higher bids. 
 The Home Secretary may, however, refuse to grant a franchise if he suspects the funding arrangements, or feels &bquo;it would not be in the public interest for the licence to be awarded&equo;. 
 Channel 4 will be allowed to continue its current remit, ensuring a range of minority-interest programmes and keeping its &bquo;distinctive character.&equo; 
 Appointments to the ruling body will be made by the ITC, and will require government approval. 
 Channel 4 will also sell its own advertising, but will have a financial safety net under Channel 3 if its revenue falls below 14 per cent of independent terrestrial TV revenue. 
 The bill also refers to a new channel, to be known as channel 5. 
 Again it says licences will be allocated by competitive tender, as for Channel 3, but as yet it is unlikely Channel 5 will be broadcast nationwide. 
 The bill also lays down provision for detailed news coverage by both Channels 3 and 5. 
 It says &bquo;the commission shall, in the case of any nominated news provider, review the performance of that body as a nominated news provider&equo;, and says that if the commission is not satisfied with the news coverage other suppliers should be found. 
 This is likely to mean ITN will face competition for the first time. 
 The bill also provides safeguards for quality programming. 
 Not only will this be considered in the initial bids for franchises, but there will be statutory duties to show both educational and regional programmes. 
 At least 25 per cent of original programmes will now come from independent companies according to statute, with a certain proportion of European origin. 
 Part three of the bill examines major changes to radio services, first outlined in the 1986 green paper. 
 Most significant of these is the creation of a new Radio Authority of Independent Radio Services, which will be able to allocate three new national radio licences by competitive tender. 
 In the next three years, 300 more local radio stations will be able to set up &mdash; but franchise applicants must cater for local tastes and &bquo;broaden the range of programmes available&equo;. 
 National stations will also be encouraged to cater to local tastes where &bquo;practicable&equo;, and radio broadcasters failing to answer the remit will be liable to fines by the Radio Authority. 
 Both the ITC and the Radio Authority are to enforce rules ensuring media ownership is not concentrated in a few hands. 
 No organsisation outside Europe will be able to bid. 
 The bill also says the Broadcasting Standards Council will draw up a code &bquo;giving guidance&equo; on violence, sex and &bquo;standards of taste and decency&equo;. 
 The code will not be binding, but broadcasters will be asked to &bquo;reflect the general effect&equo; relevant to the programmes in question. 
 As well as being responsible for all viewers' and listeners' complaints, the council will also monitor programmes from outside the United Kingdom which can be received here, &bquo;to ascertain how violence and sexual conduct are portrayed&equo;. 
 In addition, the bill also extends to other bidders the traditional competition between the BBC and ITV for screening certain events; while party political broadcasts will have to be shown on Channels 3,4, and 5. 
 ASMALL bronze statue entered for a sale of garden furniture because its elderly owners wanted to &bquo;clear up the garden&equo; fetched a record &pound;6.8 million at Sotheby's yesterday, writes Joanna Coles. 
 The Dancing Faun (above), by the Dutch sculptor Adrien de Vries, lay at the bottom of the couple's garden in West Sussex for 35 years turning green. 
 Depicting a muscular young man, naked and balancing on his left leg, it is thought to be more than 370 years old and the most significant example of Renaissance sculpture to come up for auction. 
 It is the first time a sculpture from the period has fetched such a sum. 
 Inspired by the Uffizi faun in Florence, the statue was originally entered for auction in a sale of outdoor furniture in West Sussex. 
 It was spotted by Sotheby's head of European Arts Department, Miss Elizabeth Wilson (pictured with the auctioneer Mr George Hughes-Hartman). 
 Miss Wilson, who has worked for the auctioneers for 25 years, suspected it was worth more than its modest &pound;1,200 estimate. 
 She removed the statue to London where it was identified. 
 &bquo;We are absolutely thrilled,&equo; she said last night. 
 &bquo;It is an absolute masterpiece and it is wonderful to do justice to an early master. 
 &bquo;This is a once in a lifetime find. 
 I knew as soon as I saw it in the garden sale catalogue, it was unmistakeable.&equo; 
 She added that the faun's condition was good although &bquo;it has been outside for 35 years and is a bit green.&equo; 
 Last night, Mr Cyril Humphris, a dealer, who fought several last-minute telephone bids to secure the statue for an anonymous client, said he was delighted. 
 &bquo;In my 35 years of dealing this is the greatest sculpture that has ever come on to the market,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Adrien de Vries is now considered to be the greatest sculptor of his time and his work has a timeless quality.&equo; 
 Standing a mere 30 inches, the faun amazed Sotheby's and dealers by far exceeding its &pound;1-&pound;1,500,000 estimate. 
 Its height suggests that it was unlikely to have been intended as a garden sculpture. 
 Indeed, highly finished details and the gentle lines of the face coupled with the oval base suggest it was designed as a cabinet piece. 
 The couple who sold the statue have asked to remain anonymous. 
 PHOTOGRAPH: GRAHAM TURNER 
 Wee Wee Free who started an almighty row. 
 By David Sharrock 
 THE Lord Chancellor, Lord Mackay of Clashfern, has been strangely at odds with the law during this year. 
 Firstly, having broken the rules of the Free Presbyterian Church of Scotland by attending Catholic mass, he found himself suspended and denied the sacraments. 
 For a man with many God-fearing years with the Wee Wee Frees, the decision to leave must have been difficult. 
 But it was perhaps nothing compared with the hostility he faced over his plans to reform the legal profession. 
 Scarcely known in the south until Mrs Thatcher appointed him Lord Chancellor in 1987, he was the outsider with a brief to sweep away restrictive practices. 
 The roasting he received during a marathon debate in the House of Lords in April, with the criticism emanating from all quarters, reached epic proportions. 
 The late Lord Elwyn Jones remembered the days of Nazi Germany. 
 According to Lord Lane, the Lord Chief Justice: &bquo;Oppression doesn't stand on the doorstep with a toothbrush moustache and swastika armband, it creeps in insidiously.&equo; 
 As well as facing overt pressure from the Bar and prominent judges, Lord Mackay was opposed in the initial stages by leading Tory backbenchers, and the Attorney-General, Sir Patrick Mayhew. 
 But the white paper, published in July after five months of lobbying, still amounted to the most radical shake-up of the legal profession this century. 
 In May, more than 100 senior judges castigated his plans as a serious threat to the quality of justice. 
 Their response to the Lord Chancellor's green papers, sent to him by the Judges' Council, broke a long-standing convention that the judges made no comment as a group on proposed changes in the law. 
 Lord Mackay accused critics of &bquo;throwing down their own stones&equo; in their anxiety to find concealed horrors under them. 
 Changes to make civil litigation cheaper and quicker Barristers' rights go in strategic reform. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 THE BILL to reform the legal profession and abolish barristers' monopoly rights in the higher courts will pave the way for solicitors to appear in any court, up to the House of Lords. 
 Lord Mackay, the Lord Chancellor, described the Courts and Legal Services Bill, which was published yesterday, as a &bquo;vital part of the government's overall strategy to improve the administration of justice&equo;. 
 The bill also incorporates proposals from the Lord Chancellor's Civil Justice Review, which recommended an overhaul of civil court procedure to speed up and simplify cases and make litigation cheaper. 
 The central plank of the proposals is to give the county court the power to deal with a substantial numbers of cases, particularly injury cases, reserving the High Court for complex and specialist cases. 
 The county court will be able to grant all the remedies now available in the High Court. 
 The bill's most contentious provision, which has polarised the profession's two branches, sets up a framework for solicitors to appear in the higher courts, now the barrister's preserve. 
 Rules are to be drawn up by the Law Society, subject to approval by the Lord Chancellor and four senior judges. 
 Lord Mackay conceded that the judges should have a say in approving the rules for solicitors advocates after his original, more radical, green paper proposals drew unprecedented public criticism from the judiciary. 
 Solicitors feared the judges' veto might result in rules limiting their new rights, but the bill lays down a tight framework which will restrict the room for manoeuvre. 
 In approving the rules, the Lord Chancellor and the judges will have to take advice from a new lay-dominated Advisory Committee on Legal Education and Conduct, chaired by a senior judge. 
 The other members will be: two barristers, two solicitors, two law teachers and eight lay members. 
 Solicitors who gain rights to appear in the High Court will be eligible for High Court judgeships, as will circuit judges who were formerly solicitors. 
 The bill will also remove the statutory ban which prevents lawyers taking cases on a &bquo;no-win, no-fee&equo; basis. 
 Lawyers will not be able to take an American-style slice of the damages if successful, but they will be able to ask for an extra percentage on top of their normal costs, with a maximum to be fixed by the Lord Chancellor. 
 Banks, building societies, and insurance companies will be allowed to offer homebuyers a &bquo;one-stop&equo; service including conveyancing, subject to safeguards against unfair competition and conflicts of interest. 
 The Lord Chancellor originally intended that lenders should be self-regulating, but since publishing the white paper he has decided to set up a new Authorised Conveyancing Practitioners' Board, with consumer representatives, to police lenders offering conveyancing services. 
 A conveyancing appeals tribunal will be set up to hear appeals against the decisions of the board. 
 Also new is the provision for a Conveyancing Ombudsman to investigate complaints against lenders doing conveyancing. 
 The bill also creates a Legal Services Ombudsman to oversee complaints procedures against solicitors and barristers. 
 The ombudsman will have power to recommend that a lawyer or professional body pay compensation, but not to compel payment. 
 The Law Society will have powers to suspend a solicitor convicted of a serious crime from practice before taking disciplinary proceedings, and to intervene in the practices of solicitors who are incapacitated or have abandoned their practices. 
 Solicitors will lose their monopoly on applying for grants of probate to deal with wills. 
 Banks, building societies and insurance companies will be able to apply for probate if they have a proper complaints handling scheme. 
 The bill envisages that non-lawyers belonging to professional bodies may be given rights in future to appear in court and conduct litigation in some types of cases. 
 Magistrates will be given the same immunity from claims for costs or damages over their actions in court as judges now enjoy. 
 Solicitors will have the same immunity as barristers from legal actions over the way they conduct cases in court. 
 Judges will have powers to fine litigants for failing to turn up at court hearings. 
 The Lord Chancellor will be given power to make rules allowing magistrates to disallow a solicitor's costs or order him to pay costs if he fails to act reasonably competently or expeditiously. 
 The bill also allows the Lord Chancellor to make rules restricting the present automatic right of appeal to the Court of Appeal in some types of case. 
 Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, has suggested that family cases should require leave of the court before an appeal could be launched. 
 A spokesman for the Lord Chancellor's Department said there would be wide consultation before any restrictions on the right of appeal. 
 The statutory ban on solicitors entering into partnership with other professionals, such as accountants, is to be lifted. 
 But the Law Society and the Bar are free to retain professional rules which prevent barristers and solicitors from practising in partnership with each other or with other professionals. 
 Banned video &bquo;imagines desire in St Theresa's subconscious&equo;. 
 By Nicholas de Jongh Arts Correspondent 
 VISIONS of Ecstasy, the 20-minute video in which St Theresa of Avila imagines herself touching Christ, neither reviled Jesus nor cast aspersions on him, the Board of Film Censors heard yesterday. 
 Mr Geoffrey Robertson, QC, submitted that the scenes which had caused the board to ban the video were to be seen as &bquo;manifestations of a woman's subconsciousness&equo;. 
 Mr Robertson told the second and final day of a hearing by the board's video appeal committee that St Theresa was portrayed in mystical ecstasy &mdash; using pain to place herself at the mercy of her subconscious and thereby contemplate Jesus on the Cross. 
 A second, &bquo;more menacing&equo; image rendered in black symbolised her carnal instincts in the guise of another woman. 
 The scene dealing with her adoration of Christ went no further than &bquo;a few motions of the lips&equo; &mdash; St Theresa's moment of ecstasy was rendered by the image of Christ's hand closing over hers. 
 Earlier, Mr Richard du Cann, QC, for the British Board of Film Classification, defined blasphemy as an intention to outrage &bquo;because of the contemptuous tone, style and spirit of the material&equo;. 
 The committee's judgment will be given later. 
 Women face &bquo;three times&equo; HIV sex risk. 
 By Nigel Williams 
 WOMEN are three times more likely than men to contract HIV through sex with an infected partner, a study claimed yesterday. 
 Men having intercourse once a day with an infected woman would become HIV-positive after an average of 33 months. 
 But women having sex once a day with an HIV-infected man would on average become infected within a year, the study found. 
 The study, based on thousands of cases in Britain and the US, was carried out by the Aids-prevention charity, Lifeshield Foundation. 
 But the charity stresses that infection can occur on first contact with an infected partner or needle. 
 The results also show that for couples with one infected partner and having sex three times daily, the woman is on average likely to become infected within four months, and the man within a year. 
 However, receptive anal intercourse is shown to be the riskiest sexual behaviour. 
 Once-a-day activity with an infected person leads to infection on average within six weeks. 
 Drug-users sharing needles contaminated with HIV are likely to be infected within less than five years if they inject once a week, and within three months if injecting 20 times a week. 
 Ms Jenny Wilson, a trustee of the charity, said research has shown that men have modified their sexual behaviour towards each other, but few towards women. 
 &bquo;Women should not be complacent,&equo; she said. 
 The study also warns: &bquo;If you are starting a new sexual relationship, we estimate the chances that your partner is HIV-positive at 1-in-300. 
 &bquo;If you share a needle when you inject drugs, the chances of the needle being infected are 1-in-eight. 
 &bquo;If you are a health-care professional who gives injections, your chances of injecting an infected person are about 1-in-500.&equo; 
 British firm buys rights to sell pictures from Russian spy satellites. 
 By Nigel Williams Science Correspondent 
 WARNINGS about traffic jams building up on Britain's motorways may soon come courtesy of Soviet spy satellites, following a deal struck yesterday. 
 For at a conference in London, Russian space scientists awarded a British company the first foreign franchise to sell pictures from their most powerful orbiting cameras. 
 The conference, Earth Mission 2000, reflects a shift in emphasis in Russian space policy back to Earth; and the deal with the British company Sigma Products is the latest attempt to capitalise on their space programme &mdash; the world's biggest. 
 &bquo;The space station Mir is available to rent,&equo; said a Soviet embassy spokesman. 
 Potential British users of the satellite photographs are port authorities, offshore oil and gas operators, mining concerns, agriculturists and transport authorities. 
 Dr David Baker, managing director of Sigma Projects, said the Russian pictures are the best available, with resolution down to 5-10 metres, or better with computer enhancement. 
 He added: &bquo;The best pictures&hellip; from the US Landsat system have an average resolution of 30 metres, while those from the competitive French system called Spot have a resolution of 10-20 metres.&equo; 
 Nowadays, the Russians will also take commissions. 
 &bquo;Satellites can be programmed to take pictures at the customer's request,&equo; Dr Baker explained. 
 But &bquo;photographs of the Soviet Union will not be for sale,&equo; he said. 
 Lithuania defiantly votes to cut the party down to size. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 THE parliament of Lithuania yesterday followed eastern Europe in abandoning the political supremacy of the Communist Party in favour of a multi-party system in what conservative Russian Communists will see as a brazen act of defiance. 
 By 243 votes to one, the Lithuanian Supreme Soviet deleted a clause in Article 6 of the Baltic republic's constitution describing the party as the &bquo;leading and guiding force of Soviet society&equo;. 
 This was substituted by a new clause which stated that &bquo;parties, mass organisations and mass movements are set up under a procedure established by legislation, and function within the framework of the constitution and law&equo; of the republic. 
 Along this trail, blazed by Lithuania, others will also tread. 
 The next is almost certain to be its fellow Baltic republic of Estonia, whose Communist Party is determined to follow suit, according to its ideology secretary, Mr Mikk Titma. 
 In an interview with the Tallinn weekly Maaleht, he said the Estonian Party would do this even though it &bquo;will obviously find itself in conflict with certain forces in the Soviet Communist Party&equo;. 
 Reports from Tallinn yesterday said that the local party's central committee had approved the measure, which will be brought before the Estonian parliament. 
 There is also strong pressure for the same action in Armenia, where thousands of angry demonstrators surrounded the Supreme Soviet in Yerevan all night on Monday, because they had refused to abolish the party's leading role in the republic. 
 However, in Lithuania the principle has been established. 
 According to Audrjus Siaurusevicius, a journalist in the capital, Vilnius, the entire party leadership voted for the change. 
 Many of the 39 abstentions were representatives of the Russian and Polish minorities. 
 Parliament will soon put flesh on the bones of the principle by drafting a law on such practical matters as the registration of parties and the conditions under which they operate. 
 In fact, a number of political parties and movements have been operating in Lithuania for some time, as in Estonia and Latvia; the constitutional change merely recognises the existing situation. 
 But, as Mr Titma told Maaleht in Estonia, &bquo;the political weight of this question is immense, and it will make a radical difference in legal terms&equo;. 
 It could also radically affect relations with Moscow, where the question of the party's leading role is also a hot potato. 
 A month ago, the all-Union Supreme Soviet voted against discussing the issue by only the narrowest of margins. 
 Dr Andrei Sakharov and other leading radicals have called for a two-hour general strike on Monday to put pressure on the Congress of People's Deputies, the country's supreme legislative body. 
 The strike demand has been totally ignored by the Soviet media, although posters and leaflets about it have been widely distributed through voters' clubs and associations, and other informal groups. 
 The abrogation of article 6 was also a key demand of striking miners in the Arctic coalfields. 
 The Lithuanians are to make an even more serious challenge to Moscow at a special republican party congress later this month, which is expected to restore its pre-war independence from the Soviet Communist Party. 
 Mr Siaurusevicius said that this might split the Lithuanian Party, with the majority approving the proposal, and a minority remaining members of the All-Union Party. 
 &bquo;But if the Lithuanian Party doesn't move with public opinion, it will soon cease to exist here.&equo; 
 Can Father keep the family together, page 23 
 Transplants from animals &bquo;near&equo;. 
 By Angella Johnson 
 DOCTORS hope to announce an experiment next month that could lead to the use of animal organs for human transplants within the next five years. 
 Dr Tim Higenbottam, a chest consultant at Papworth hospital, Cambridge, said yesterday it might soon be possible to transplant heart, kidney, liver, and lungs from one animal species to another. 
 Research groups in Europe and the US have been concentrating on altering the genetic structure of certain animals to make their organs more acceptable to the human body. 
 Dr Higenbottam, who is attending a two-day symposium of the British Thoracic Society in London, said: &bquo;There is only a finite number of human organs available because we have to wait for someone to die. 
 At least one-third of patients on the waiting list die each year because of this shortage. 
 &bquo;However, it is recognised that, even with a totally effective referral system for donation of organs following death, there will not be sufficient organs for the people needing life-saving transplants. 
 So we will have to start preparing people for the day when animals will be widely used.&equo; 
 Scientist were considering five different methods of research. 
 Dr Higenbottam suggested that because of their size pigs and cows would be ideal. 
 There were no plans to take organs from primates but it was likely that certain species would be genetically engineered to be used specifically for human transplant. 
 Mechanisms already existed to oversee ethical questions. 
 &bquo;All I am trying to do now is prepare people for the breakthrough by introducing the concept and start discussions on how we address any problems which may result.&equo; 
 Cows and pigs are already widely used for valve replacement in heart operations and in the production of insulin for diabetic conditions. 
 Weekend Guardian Tomorrow With events in Eastern Europe throwing much of contemporary political ideology into turmoil, the French philosopher Andre Gorz &mdash; whom Le Monde calls &bquo;one of the most important thinkers of our time&equo; &mdash; blends the ideas of the Greens and of the uprisings in East Germany and Czechoslovakia to map out a &bquo;third way&equo; politics for the 21st century, in defiance of socialism and capitalism. 
 Plus&hellip; the security operation behind the Christmas shopfronts on Oxford Street, Prue Leith on Christmas turkeys, new evidence on the massacre of six Jesuit priests in San Salvador and rock &bquo;n&equo; roll East German style.. 
 Wets squabble in wake of Meyer Points of Order. 
 By Ian Aitken 
 IT is difficult to tell whether Tuesday's leadership ballot in the Conservative Party has caused bad blood among the Thatcherites; the Downing Street bunker is too well insulated for any sounds of strife to be audible outside. 
 Not so among the Tory wets, however, who are now falling out noisily with each other over their role in the Meyer saga. 
 To the visible delight of Tory rightwingers, those who refused to vote for Mrs T are loudly accusing those who didn't of cowardice, or sycophancy, or both. 
 Those who didn't are responding by pointing out that some of those who did ought to have stood as candidates if they wanted a real revolt. 
 At least one exceedingly wet Old Etonian baronet (oh, all right then: Sir George Young) has received a rude note from another even wetter Old Etonian baronet (yes, you're right: Sir Ian Gilmour) deploring his decision to vote for Mrs Thatcher. 
 Sir Ian was one of those who considered putting himself forward as a candidate, but didn't when Sir Anthony Meyer declared himself. 
 Sir George didn't vote for Sir Anthony because he couldn't take him seriously. 
 Others followed, but for different reasons. 
 Among them was Jonathan (no relation) Aitken, who is hostile to the European Community and may well have preferred Mrs Thatcher's approach to Sir Anthony's Euro-fanaticism. 
 Other's have considerably more convoluted explanations for voting for Mrs Thatcher. 
 Some take the profoundly defeatist view that the kicking and screaming which would accompany a successful revolt would do even more damage than sticking with the lady. 
 Others claim they want to fine-tune the timing the real challenge, so as to enhance the prospects of Chris Patten as an eventual leader. 
 It is all deeply confusing to those accustomed to reporting leadership contests in the Labour Party. 
 Socialists stab each other in the chest in broad daylight. 
 IAN Gow, the Conservative member for Eastbourne, is famed for three things: a doglike devotion to the Prime Minister, a deadpan sense of humour, and his quixotic resignation as housing minister because he disapproved of the Anglo-Irish Agreement. 
 He has not hitherto displayed an compendious knowledge of 19th Century philosophy. 
 Not until Wednesday, that is, when his speech on the privatisation of government property services was interrupted by Labour's Tam Dalyell, another Old Etonian baronet. 
 Black Tam delphicly reminded Mr Gow that John Stuart Mill had coined the phrase &bquo;the deep slumber of a decided opinion&equo;. 
 Scarcely pausing for breath, Mr Gow declared that he would quote some Mill back at Mr Dalyell. 
 And he proceeded to do so, off the top of his head at considerable length, to the admiration of all present. 
 The passage, however, included a bit about small men being unable to accomplish great things. 
 This caused Sir Giles Shaw, the diminutive member for Pudsey, to rise indignantly to his full five feet or so. 
 Mr Gow made it clear that he was not referring to small men in any literal sense. 
 THE Yorkshire Post, which should know, says Glenda Jackson is seriously considering the offer of a nomination to stand for selection as Labour candidate in Leeds East in succession to Denis Healey. 
 The Oscar-winning actress told the YP: &bquo;To follow Denis Healey's act you would need to be a genius.&equo; 
 Unabashed by this thought, she adds that she is thinking seriously about it, and is prepared to meet party officials to discuss it. 
 Andrew Faulds may have a co-star yet. 
 Certainly the advent of MP-TV provides a strong argument for choosing actors as members of Parliament. 
 The only difficulty is that thespians are not, on the whole, accustomed to making up their own lines. 
 Mr Faulds is better known for the way he says things (ie very loudly indeed) than for what he says. 
 FURTHER intelligence about the amazing Mr Humphrey Berkeley, who left the Conservative Party after bequeathing it an elective system for choosing its leaders, joined Labour, then moved on to the SDP, only to resign from it, too. 
 He is now thought to have rejoined the Labour Party, and to have composed an &bquo;open letter&equo; to Neil Kinnock hinting that he should be helped to find a suitable constituency. 
 Conservative Party next stop? 
 More choice for viewers &mdash; at a price. 
 By Georgina Henry 
 WALL to wall Dallas? 
 Or something, at last, to watch on Saturday nights? 
 Around such alternatives have views polarised in the heated debate over what the bill means for viewers. 
 There now is, and will be more, choice of channels for those investing in satellite dishes: already four channels of Sky TV, plus MTV, Screensport, Lifestyle and the Children's Channel. 
 In March, those prepared to buy a second dish will be able to receive five channels of British Satellite Broadcasting. 
 Satellite TV has been able to offer dedicated viewing which the existing channels cannot: 24-hour news from Sky News, for example, two sports channels, and now comprehensive coverage of the House of Commons. 
 But as a Which? report this week revealed, those with satellite TV still mostly watch BBC and ITV. 
 They tune into satellite for the extra choice, not the quality of programmes. 
 The effect of the bill on the existing channels is therefore of greatest concern. 
 The Government argues there will still be three channels &mdash; BBC1, BBC2 and Channel 4 &mdash; carrying on as before, and charged with providing public service broadcasting. 
 Change in ITV will not come overnight: ITV franchises still have three more years to run under contracts requiring them to offer factual programmes in peak hours, and a host of other public service obligations. 
 But ITV is already reshaping its schedules to build its peak-time ratings: investment in children's programmes and single documentaries has been cut. 
 After 1993, when these obligations and constraints are lifted, and competition from a new commercial channel, Channel 5, begins, the trend will be accelerated. 
 Auctioning franchises will mean less money for programmes, and programmes that are expensive but attract lower audiences will be squeezed; more light entertainment, sport and bought-in programmes are likely. 
 This is why the Campaign for Quality Television is calling for the money bid in the auction to go into programmes, rather than to the Treasury. 
 A key question is which of the existing ITV companies will win back their contracts &mdash; and what happens to their programmes if they don't? 
 By then, all the companies will have divided their businesses into separate profit centres. 
 So if, for example, Granada loses its franchise, it could fall back on its programme-making and its library to provide a business. 
 Coronation Street's 20 million viewers would, for instance, be unlikely to be deprived &mdash; but they may need a satellite dish if Granada sold the show to BSB. 
 Current affairs programmes will have a tougher time: if Thames wins back its franchise, it will probably continue to make This Week. 
 But without the obligation to show current affairs in peak time, it may be pushed into a less attractive slot. 
 Sports fans will notice a difference too. 
 The government's decision to scrap the &bquo;listed events&equo; provision, which gave the BBC and ITV the right to match the highest bid for events like Wimbledon or the FA cup final, will mean a scramble to obtain the rights. 
 Satellite TV will almost certainly be prepared to outbid the others in order to boost audiences. 
 Broadcast shake-up &bquo;threatens standards&equo;. 
 By Georgina Henry Media Correspondent 
 THE Broadcasting Bill, which will radically reshape the face of commercial television and radio, was published yesterday amid criticism that standards would be threatened. 
 The Government said it would widen choice for viewers and listeners, safeguard quality programming and bring greater competition and efficiency. 
 The most disputed proposals in the bill &mdash; to cut the public service obligations of ITV and to auction ITV franchises to the highest bidder &mdash; were attacked by Mr Roy Hattersley, Labour's deputy leader, who said: &bquo;Television franchises are to be sold like second-hand motor cars. 
 Companies with cash to offer will be able to control television stations as long as they pay lip-service to the observance of minimum standards &mdash; standards which are wholly inadequate.&equo; 
 Mr Richard Dunn, managing director of Thames Television and chairman of the ITV Association, said the auction was the &bquo;fatal flaw&equo; in the bill. 
 It should be amended &bquo;to allow the Independent Television Commission &lsqb;the new regulatory body&rsqb; to judge the quality of programmes and the size of the cash bid in tandem&equo;. 
 Broadcasting unions and consumer groups said the bill spelt the end of public service broadcasting and promised pressure to get key points amended. 
 Advertisers said they were delighted to see many of their proposals reflected in the Government's approach. 
 Among the new provisions in the 167-clause bill is a government power of veto of members of the new Channel 4 Corporation, to be appointed by the Independent Television Commission. 
 Channel 4 last night declared its &bquo;unequivocal opposition&equo; to the proposal. 
 Sir Richard Attenborough, chairman of Channel 4, said it was &bquo;utterly improper that any government should have direct control over the appointment of who will run Channel 4&equo;. 
 The bill includes proposals for a new television channel, three new national commercial radio channels and numerous local services. 
 The Government faces opposition from its backbenches on the question of quality. 
 Almost 60 Tories have signed two early day motions calling for quality to be as important as money in franchise allocation. 
 Mr David Mellor, the Home Office minister who will pilot the bill through Parliament, yesterday dismissed criticism. 
 &bquo;It is the most absurd caricature to suggest that those with the biggest cheque book will get over the strengthened quality threshold,&equo; he said. 
 He defended the Government's decision that its rules on cross-media ownership should not apply to Mr Rupert Murdoch's Sky Television. 
 It was not for the Government to pull the plug on a venture which was running and had cost Mr Murdoch &bquo;vast amounts of money&equo;. 
 Broadcasting market, page 10 Leader comment, page 22 
 Forum ups the ante as Czech PM quits. 
 By Ian Traynor in Prague 
 THE Czechoslovak opposition raised the stakes in the battle for power in the country last night after the resignation of the Prime Minister, Mr Ladislav Adamec. 
 Blaming Mr Adamec for sparking a &bquo;political crisis&equo; by his act, the Civic Forum opposition movement said the ruling but discredited Communist Party had to forfeit the prime ministership or the presidency. 
 The Forum reacted furiously to Mr Adamec's resignation, virtually accusing him of lying to the public. 
 A day of drama that also saw the expulsion from the Communist Party of Mr Milos Jakes, the former leader, and Mr Miroslav Stepan, until recently the Prague party chief, plunged the country's three-week old &bquo;peaceful revolution&equo; into great uncertainty. 
 Mr Jiri Dienstbier, the Forum spokesman, responded coolly to the appointment of the new Prime Minister, Mr Marian Calfa, and said that were the Communist Mr Calfa to remain in office the president would have to be a non-Communist. 
 &bquo;At this moment he &lsqb;Calfa&rsqb; does not have the support of the Civic Forum,&equo; said Mr Dienstbier. 
 &bquo;So far he has not had the opportunity to appear to us a flexible and strong politician.&equo; 
 The opposition leader, Mr Vaclav Havel, made much the same point about the new Prime Minister by stating that he had failed to attract much attention over two years in government office. 
 Mr Calfa, aged 43, is a Slovak, as is President Gustav Husak, whose imminent departure is all but certain given his association with the Warsaw Pact invasion of the country in 1968. 
 With the existing ethnic balance between Czechs and Slovaks in senior positions, the new president has to be a Czech, thus ruling out Mr Alexander Dubcek, the leader of the Prague Spring of 1968, who is also a Slovak. 
 The obvious contender is Mr Havel, the Forum leader and the most popular man in the country. 
 Pressed last night on the issue, Mr Havel conceded that in the last resort he would accept the post as head of state. 
 &bquo;If, God help us, the situation develops in such a way that the only service I could render my country would be to do it &lsqb;accept the presidency&rsqb;, then I would do it,&equo; Mr Havel said. 
 As the country found itself on the brink of a constitutional crisis, Mr Havel said the best way to avert such a crisis would be for President Husak to quit and for a strong prime minister to assume his authority temporarily, as the constitution permits. 
 The Forum also revealed it was proposing Mr Jan Czarnogursky, the prominent Slovak lawyer and human rights activist who only last month under the old regime was put on trial, for the post of prime minister or first deputy prime minister. 
 In addition, the opposition demanded the foreign ministry and five other cabinet posts. 
 In tendering his resignation, Mr Adamec cited undue pressure from the opposition in the haggling this week over a new cabinet as the main reason. 
 The Forum rigorously denied this. 
 A government spokesman said that Mr Adamec's decision to quit was taken because of &bquo;unacceptable demands&equo; from the Forum. 
 Mr Dienstbier retorted that this was nonsense. 
 Mr Adamec had asked the Forum for its proposals concerning the new government. 
 After receiving the proposals and before responding, Mr Adamec had gone on national television on Wednesday night to threaten to quit. 
 Mr Dienstbier accused Mr Adamec of stating untruths on television. 
 Concessions ease advocacy fears. 
 THE BILL'S concessions to the concerns of barristers and judges about extended rights of audience in the higher courts were welcomed yesterday by Mr Desmond FennellQC, chairman of the Bar. 
 He said on BBC Radio's The World at One that the Lord Chancellor, Lord Mackay, &bquo;has listened to our comments, and he has recognised our expertise by giving the Bar the fast track&equo; on rights of advocacy. 
 On the same programme, Lord Mackay said he believed the bill was a full response to the protests he had received since he announced the proposed changes. 
 A key change was to &bquo;remove that part which the Bar told me implied undue interference by the Lord Chancellor, as a minister of the Crown, with the processes of justice. 
 &bquo;Instead, I have given the Law Society the power to grant rights of audience in the higher courts, but subject to regulations relating to competence and conduct, which will require the approval of senior judges as well as myself.&equo; 
 Mr Fennell did not believe the change would lead to people being represented in courts by a solicitor only. 
 &bquo;It's rather fanciful to think you will be able to walk into a solicitor's office in Carlisle, engage one lawyer, then argue your case up to the highest court in the land. 
 It simply doesn't happen.&equo; 
 The debate should not be distracted from the main issue of giving ordinary people easier access to the courts and making legal aid available to the 10 million people no longer eligible for it, he said. 
 The Law Society, representing 50,000 solicitors in England and Wales, saw the bill as an improvement on the original proposals. 
 Its president, Mr David Ward, said: &bquo;We have secured, first, a modern framework giving solicitors rights of audience and, second, stronger controls to protect home buyers if estate agents and big financial institutions provide conveyancing.&equo; 
 Referring to barristers' opposition to the extension of rights of audience, he said Lord Mackay had withstood enormous pressures. 
 The Law Society would support his aim to ensure, by public demand, an end to unnecessary double-manning. 
 On conveyancing, Mr Ward said the Government had recognised the need for proper consumer protection, and had provided safeguards against conflicts of interest. 
 The Association of Independent Conveyancing Advisers said the bill's publication put the decision on the future of its members into Parliament's hands. 
 The state-funded National Consumer Council said: &bquo;If these legal reforms go through, ordinary people in England and Wales will stand a much better chance of getting real justice.&equo; 
 Faulty roads catch out the taxpayer. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 THE Department of Transport was severely criticised yesterday for failing to apply proper sanctions against contractors who have cost taxpayers &pound;70 million through poor workmanship and inadequate supervision of nearly 130 roads and bridges built since 1970. 
 The National Audit Office, Parliament's financial watchdog, in a report published yesterday estimates that another &pound;330 million has had to be paid out to cover &bquo;premature maintenance.&equo; 
 This includes the cost of traffic congestions and inconvenience and delay for millions of motorists. 
 The auditors also discovered delays and large variations in the department's reporting procedures which are supposed to alert the ministry to problems. 
 Delays varied between six months and two years. 
 &bquo;Widespread problems with concrete bridges had also not been identified through the defect reporting procedures.&equo; 
 The auditors find fault with every stage of the ministry's work and call for a review of site research for road improvements after the cost of improving the A6 at Chapel-en-le-Frith, Derbyshire, had jumped from &pound;17 million to &pound;36 million when an embankment and retaining wall collapsed. 
 Widespread faults have also been found in the wet mix and concrete materials for roads. 
 Some &pound;16 million was lost through cracks, rutting, and slippage on the A38 between Exeter and Plymouth, Devon, the A64 Malton, Yorkshire, by-pass, the A49 at Callow Hill, and the A17 Heckington, Lincolnshire, by-pass. 
 On concrete roads the abandonment of ministry research on water leaks coincided with substantial problems after water seeped into the joints. 
 Heavier traffic flows caused by lorries on bridges and roads also added to the ministry's problems. 
 Design difficulties, problems, chloride contamination, and inadequate waterproofing of materials have caused major problems for bridges &mdash; leaving the ministry with an &pound;800 million repair bill over the next 15 years. 
 Chloride contamination &mdash; caused when de-icing salts seep into concrete coverings &mdash; has cut the notional life of bridges from 120 to 20 years. 
 The worst example is the A465 Taf Fawr bridge in south Wales, replaced after 18 years at a cost of &pound;3 million. 
 The auditors save their most stringent criticism for poor workmanship and inadequate supervision by the ministry. 
 They call for a review of the procedures, noting no proper guidance on sanctions against contractors and that the ministry, the Scottish Office and the Welsh Office have all had problems &bquo;recovering any significant proportion of the costs of remedial work.&equo; 
 In nine cases costing some &pound;7 million the Department of Transport recovered only &pound;200,000. 
 Out of 72 cases only 20 resulted in the ministry obtaining compensation or remedial work at no cost to themselves. 
 The report noted that over the past few years the government departments had introduced competitive fee bidding for the appointment of consulting engineers leading to lower fee rates. 
 MPs on the Commons Public Accounts Committee who will be examining the criticisms are to question the ministries on the report on January 24. 
 Quality Control of Road and Bridge Construction; Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General; HMSO &pound;4.60. 
 Traffic congestion caused by &bquo;premature maintenance&equo; can cost millions but does not always get reported in time PHOTOGRAPH: MARTIN ARGLES 
 Bungles blamed for &pound;400m bill. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 POOR workmanship, inadequate supervision and slipshod design standards have led to the &pound;400 million bill for extra repair and maintenance on roads and bridges. 
 The National Audit Office says that poor workmanship led to remedial work on 20 roads and 62 bridges while inadequate supervision accounted for problems on 14 roads and 33 bridges at a total cost of &pound;70 million. 
 Some 7,800 cracks on the Leatherhead to Reigate section of the M25 were caused by poor workmanship, materials and specification. 
 But only 20 of the 72 cases of compensation claims outstanding against contractors and consulting engineers in 1988 resulted in payment to the Department of Transport. 
 The cost of essential repair work on the Severn Bridge has increased to around &pound;70 million after cracks and faults were uncovered in the 23-year-old construction. 
 Inadequacies in the design contributed to a &pound;10 million bill for replacement of bearings on the A19 Tees Viaduct and annual maintenance costs of &pound;5 million are expected because of design defects on the M5/M6 link at Spaghetti Junction. 
 Routine checks by department inspectors also found 165 confirmed and a further 300 potential cases of alkali-silica reaction, commonly known as concrete cancer. 
 They estimate this will require work costing &pound;3.9 million up to 1992. 
 Several bridges on the A38 Exeter to Plymouth road have been affected, including the Marsh Mills viaduct where the bill for replacement was estimated at &pound;5 million in 1983. 
 Chloride contamination, which stems from de-icing salts seeping into concrete coverings, was discovered in 144 of 200 bridges selected at random by department inspectors and more than half of the difficulties stemmed from poor workmanship. 
 At the Angel Road rail bridge on the A406 the cost of remedial work is put at &pound;1.2 million, partly because the department did not install water-proofing until 1983, about 15 years after the problems were identified. 
 The office warns that up to 4,250 of the 5,900 concrete bridges could be contaminated, which would require &pound;800 million to be spent over the next 15 years. 
 It catalogues 17 roads with defective concrete, requiring &pound;43 million of repair work, including a &pound;3.7 million bill on the M25 for narrow joints between junctions 24 and 25. 
 The office also identified four cases where difficulties with the now banned wet mix will cost &pound;16 million, including &pound;11 million for parts of the A38. 
 Prince's plea fails to save statue. 
 THE Government yesterday refused to take action to prevent the loss to the nation of a statue said to be worth &pound;7.6 million. 
 The Prince of Wales signed a petition this week on the back of a menu to keep the Three Graces, by the 19th century Italian sculptor Antonia Canova, in Britain. 
 Formerly at Woburn Abbey, it is due to be sold to the Getty Museum in California. 
 A six-month ban on its export expires on Tuesday. 
 The impromptu petition was apparently drawn up at a dinner given by the Society of Dilettanti and sent to the Arts Minister, Mr Richard Luce. 
 Yesterday Mr David Trippier, the Environment Minister, announced in a Commons written reply to Mr Neil Hamilton (C. Tatton) that Mr Chris Patten, the Environment Secretary, had &bquo;considered the question of the Three Graces very carefully following a request from the Office of Arts and Libraries for a view as to whether the statue was included in the listing of Woburn Abbey&equo;. 
 On the evidence before him Mr Patten had decided not to take the listed building enforcement action needed. 
 Critics fear money will oust quality Georgina Henry reports on doubts over programme standards, public service obligations and controls on ownership. 
 THE main points of contention are: Franchise allocation for ITV (Channel 3) and Channel 5 &bquo;There must be a better way.&equo; 
 The remark by Lord Thomson of Monifieth, then chairman-designate of the Independent Broadcasting Authority, as he emerged from the exacting process of awarding the franchises in the 1980/81 round, has come back to haunt ITV. 
 The Government argues that the old system, whereby Southern Television, to take the most dramatic example, was summarily axed in favour of the newcomer TVS, was arbitrary. 
 It says it wants a fairer system of awarding contracts and also seeks to ensure that the taxpayer, via the Treasury, gets a proper return for the use of a scarce resource. 
 But its better way, whereby once bidders pass a quality threshold franchises are awarded to the highest bid, has been almost universally condemned for putting money before quality of service, and as a ludicrous attempt to avoid exercising judgment over a vital decision. 
 ITV has accepted that competitive tendering is a proper way of allocating franchises, but argues that in no other area of business are judgments made without trade-offs between quality and price. 
 It is feared that the process will lead to overbidding by outsiders hungry to get into television, which will oust existing contractors intending to invest more money in a wider range of programmes and with a more realistic view of the cost of running a service. 
 It will favour companies with the deepest pockets, rather than those with television experience, the argument runs. 
 Advertisers agree with the ITV companies that an auction will take too much money out of programme making. 
 The concession that the proposed Independent Television Commission can reject the highest bid in &bquo;exceptional circumstances&equo; is seen as a recipe for protracted court challenges. 
 Regulatory authorities and programme requirements Bringing all commercial television services &mdash; ITV, Channel 5, cable and British Satellite Broadcasting &mdash; under a single authority has been welcomed, as has the establishment of a separate authority for radio. 
 The crucial difference between new and old is that publishing responsibility passes to the television and radio operators: the ITC and Radio Authority will not have the power to preview programmes or vet schedules. 
 Given the criticism directed at the often heavy-handed and discretionary approach of the IBA, most have supported the new &bquo;light touch&equo; regulatory structure. 
 There is concern, however, over the removal of many of the public service programming obligations formerly imposed on ITV. 
 The bill requires franchise holders to provide a reasonable proportion of high quality programmes and a diverse service to appeal to a wide variety of interests, and sets a performance bond to guarantee promises are kept. 
 It specifies regional programmes and high quality news and current affairs. 
 But there is no specific protection for religious, children's, documentaries, science or other minority programmes. 
 The commission will not be responsible for promoting a network: the extent to which companies form a network, particularly one that as at present subsidises the smaller contractors, is a matter for them. 
 Channel 4 Relief greeted the Government decision, announced in the spring, that Channel 4 had escaped privatisation after a battle fought on its behalf by Mr Douglas Hurd against the more vigorous free-marketeers in the cabinet committee on broadcasting. 
 It was inevitable that Channel 4 would be split from ITV, after sustained pressure from the advertising lobby anxious to see competition in the sale of air time. 
 But its remit to be distinctive has been endorsed, and its funding guaranteed by a financial safety-net set at 14 per cent of the net advertising revenue of all commercial terrestrial channels. 
 The decision to turn it into an independent corporation has been welcomed, although the government's power to veto members less so. 
 The main concern now is whether it can generate enough advertising revenue in a more competitive market to stave off programming and scheduling compromises to make it more popular and to build its audience. 
 It is hard to see how Channel 4 Daily, for example, the morning show at present heavily subsidised by TV-am, could ever pay its way. 
 Ownership Tough restrictions on cross-media ownership will prevent national newspaper owners holding more than a 20 per cent stake in television companies, with a similar limitation on cross interests between commercial televison, satellite television and national radio channels. 
 This does nothing, however, to restrict Mr Rupert Murdoch's ownership of five national newspapers and four channels of Sky Television since Sky is transmitted on a non-UK satellite frequency: a loophole the Government will come under pressure to close. 
 There is also opposition to the principle that companies can bid for more than one commercial television licence: the IBA has warned the government this will make management of the network between now and 1993 very difficult. 
 Companies in other EC countries can own franchises, if they pass the quality threshold, and takeovers will be allowed. 
 Channel 5 Everyone wants more choice, and Channel 5 has been driven by technological developments. 
 The Government's view is that the market will decide if it is viable. 
 But to begin with it will cover only 70 per cent of the country, excluding large chunks of the south coast where the cost of air time is highest and the pressure for competition greatest. 
 Little thought has gone into what kind of service it should provide. 
 For example, will start-up costs mean a diet of bought-in popular programming, or is it an opportunity to offer something entirely different? 
 Radio Deregulation will mean a dramatic increase in choice for listeners: the Government's view is that the market will decide if it is sustainable. 
 It points to the 540 &bquo;expressions of interest&equo; in the recently awarded incremental contracts as evidence of the desire for change. 
 BBC radio will face national competition for the first time with the establishment of up to three national channels. 
 Between 200 and 300 new commercial stations could come on air in the 1990s and intense competition for advertising revenue is inevitable. 
 Broadcasting Standards Council Broadcasters accept they have to live with the new watchdog. 
 But unease continues over the powers it will have to enforce its code. 
 Police threaten crackdown at start of round-table talks East Germans set deadline for poll. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 EAST Germany last night took a big step towards early free elections against the background of growing instability and fresh appeals for calm. 
 A joint declaration by opposition groups and government parties issued after the country's first round-table talks said that free elections should be held by next May 6 at the latest. 
 The recommendation is subject to approval by parliament which is, however, likely to accept the proposal although only it can set the final date. 
 Free elections, which could result in the Communist Party being reduced to playing a junior role, are seen as the only realistic way forward to end East Germany's political and economic crisis. 
 A new electoral law is to be passed by the end of January. 
 Meanwhile, East Germans, outraged by disclosures of corruption among their former Communist leaders, continued their drive to uncover the scale of offences while the government called for a &bquo;security partnership&equo; between the people and state institutions to expose the extent of abuse. 
 &bquo;If there is chaos, the process of renewal cannot be continued,&equo; Mr Wolfgang Meyer, the government spokesman, said. 
 It was yet another desperate appeal aimed at stopping East Germany from sliding into anarchy, reinforced yesterday by an ominous warning from the secret police that they could intervene: &bquo;The threshold to escalation is now only very low.&equo; 
 Lieutenant-General Wolfgang Schwanitz, the head of the Stasi political police and secret service, renamed the Office for National Security, warned that attacks on his organisation could no longer be tolerated, and that order would be restored if necessary. 
 Asked whether a state of emergency was an option, he said: &bquo;That question has not yet arisen.&equo; 
 Gen Schwanitz said that national security offices in Cottbus, Dresden, Suhl, and Rostock had to be closed after his staff were attacked by angry crowds. 
 Several of his staff had been injured in clashes with &bquo;justly indignant&equo; citizens and in Dresden 100 people stormed the local office of the security police on Monday night. 
 Reports from the provinces said that former members of the Stasi are playing an active part in the crusade for revenge. 
 &bquo;It reminds me of the worst period in German history when members of certain institutions are held collectively responsible for what we now know was a misguided security doctrine,&equo; Gen Schwanitz said. 
 He had instructed his staff to stay calm and repel intruders with &bquo;physical force&equo;. 
 They were under orders &bquo;not to fire aimed shots&equo;, implying that warning shots would be permissible. 
 &bquo;In the present situation, it would be enough if one individual lost his cool,&equo; Gen Schwanitz added. 
 The Stasi remains one of the most hated institutions in East Germany. 
 It employed an army of staff and volunteers who spied on their fellow citizens. 
 Gen Schwanitz's appeal, however, is unlikely to work because he was one of the deputies of Mr Erich Mielke, the now disgraced former minister for state security. 
 Gen Schwanitz conceded that he had made a &bquo;psychological mistake&equo; by ordering the shredding of Stasi files, which had prompted the attacks on police offices. 
 The appeal for calm, linked with the threat of a crackdown, followed similar warnings on Wednesday by the armed forces and the government. 
 &bquo;We want transparency, but current developments could lead to unpredictable consequences for our people and this country,&equo; Gen Schwanitz said. 
 Meanwhile, at the round-table talks, chaired by the Protestant and Catholic churches, the seven opposition groups, including New Forum, yesterday demanded the immediate abolition of the Office for National Security. 
 The Communist SED, represented at the talks by Mr Wolfgang Berghofer, the mayor of Dresden, and Mr Gregor Gysi, a respected lawyer, has presented a position paper for today's emergency party congress in which the party accepts &bquo;full responsibility&equo; for the crisis in East Germany. 
 Kremlin agrees to German confederation, page 11 
 Labour says that bill will destroy public sector ethos of the health service Critics &bquo;trying to scare life out of patients'-Clarke Health bill. 
 Martin Linton. 
 THE Health Secretary, Mr Kenneth Clarke, denied in the Commons yesterday that his new NHS and Community Care Bill was a first step towards privatisation and accused his critics of trying to &bquo;scare the life&equo; out of patients. 
 Introducing a two-day debate on the bill, he said it was firmly based on the principle of the NHS as a great public service, free for the patients, regardless of means, and financed out of taxation. 
 The bill would give the service a &bquo;new lease of life&equo; and put it in good shape to provide an even better service by setting up a new system of financial management and creating new incentives to efficiency. 
 It would deal with wasteful prescribing and wide variations in performance to be found between one hospital and another, which could not be put down simply to lack of resources, he said. 
 In the best 10 per cent of hospitals only one operating theatre session in 77 had to be cancelled, but in the worst 10 per cent the figure was one in six, he said. 
 In the best hospitals they dealt with five patients per operating session, in the worst just over three. 
 Mr Clarke said that at present no one in the service had any particular incentive to reduce waiting lists. 
 For some consultants, a waiting list was a badge of status and district health authorities weren't too anxious to get rid of them because they were used by MPs to reinforce claims for more resources. 
 He said that &bquo;everybody accepts the need for better resources management in the health service.&equo; 
 &bquo;In the public service you must expect the clock to go somewhat slower than in any other organisation. 
 But sometimes in the health service people want to make the clock crawl round and contemplate years of discussion before implementing such obvious improvements as a new system of financial management.&equo; 
 &bquo;Most people in the health service suffer from the feeling there are far too many layers of authority above them and far too many constraints about what people can do when it comes to running their own unit better. 
 This bill will give much more autonomy to those people who are delivering the care to patients on the ground,&equo; he said. 
 The shadow Health Secretary, Mr Robin Cook, said Labour was fundamentally opposed to the principle of the bill and would vote against it because it would destroy the public sector ethos of the NHS and was designed to do so. 
 The bill claimed to be &bquo;putting the patient in the driving seat&equo;, but it did not even allow patients to be consulted if a hospital decided to opt out of regional health authority control, he said. 
 It claimed it would ensure that money in the health service &bquo;followed the patient&equo;, which Labour was not opposed to, but in fact the bill meant the patient would have to follow the money and the contracts. 
 It claimed patients would have more choice over which hospital they went to, but in fact they would have less because they would have to go to the hospital with which their district health authority had placed a contract, he said. 
 &bquo;I do not want a health service of spot markets and predatory hospitals and product lines. 
 I want a health service run as a public service to meet the need for health care, not to cater for market demand. 
 The Liberal Democrat spokesman, Mr Charles Kennedy, quoted a letter from the Department of Health which admitted patients were in a weak position to make meaningful comparisons or to shop around, so the NHS could not always rely on competition to make sure that its internal and external markets worked effectively. 
 MPs knew the Health Secretary did not listen to the patients or the nurses and doctors, he said, but &bquo;at least we can seek reassurance in the fact that he doesn't pay a blind bit of notice to what his own department is saying either&equo;. 
 Mr Nicholas Winterton (C. Macclesfield) announced that he would not be supporting the bill in Monday's vote because it was &bquo;severely flawed&equo;. 
 The aim of making the NHS more cost-effective was laudable but the other reforms &bquo;may undermine the NHS as we know it&equo;. 
 &bquo;Nothing in way of bombing inquiry&equo;. 
 By Alan Travis and Martin Linton 
 HOME Office minister John Patten yesterday opened the way to a possible full-scale official examination of the conviction of the Birmingham pub bombers. 
 Mr Patten, speaking at question time in the Commons, told Mr Anthony Beaumont-Dark (C. Selly Oak) that there was nothing to prevent the current investigation into the West Midlands Serious Crimes Squad looking into &bquo;any other matter&hellip; if there are grounds for suspicion&equo;. 
 The MP had asked him whether the inquiry under the Assistant Chief Constable of West Yorkshire could be extended to the four members of the Serious Crimes Squad who were involved in preparing the case of the Birmingham pub bombing in 1974. 
 The inquiry is limited to events after 1986, but Mr Patten appeared to be saying that it was up to the head of the inquiry, under the oversight of the Police Complaints Authority, to decide whether to extend it. 
 DR John Gilbert, the rightwing Labour MP for Dudley East, was reselected by his constituency party last night, despite a strong challenge from a local councillor, Mr David Sparks, writes Paul Hoyland. 
 Announcing the result of the ballot after a general management committee meeting, the constituency secretary, Mrs Mary Whitehouse, said Dr Gilbert, who is 62 and a former defence minister, had polled 62 per cent of the votes cast. 
 Mr Sparks received 27 per cent and another councillor Mr Phil Wall, polled eight per cent. 
 THE Prime Minister told Mrs Ann Clwyd (Lab. 
 Cynon Valley) in a written reply yesterday that she has received 6,900 letters on Cambodia over the last month. 
 In a reply to Mr Keith Vaz (Lab. 
 Leicester E) she said there were no direct telephone line between 10 Downing Street and the head of government of any other country. 
 THE Commons rises for the Christmas recess on Thursday, December 21, the Leader of the Commons, Sir Geoffrey Howe, announced yesterday. 
 MPs will return on Monday, January 8. 
 The House of Lords also rises on December 21 but does not return until a week later, on January 15. 
 NEXT WEEK'S BUSINESS House of Commons &mdash; Monday: Welsh questions; National Health Service and Community Care Bill, second reading; debate on the 1990 EC Budget and on EC research and development. 
 Tuesday: Health questions; questions to the Prime Minister; debate on war crimes; Electricity Supply (Amendment) (Northern Ireland) Order; Ministerial and other salaries Order; opposed private business (still to be announced). 
 Wednesday: Environment questions; debates on mortgage costs and housing and on the Ethiopian famine; Education Reform (Northern Ireland) Order. 
 Thursday: Northern Ireland questions; questions to the Prime Minister; Debate on EC fisheries arrangements; Landlord and Tenant (Licensed Premises) Bill, second reading; Supply of Beer (Tied Estate) and (Loan Ties, Licensed Premises and Wholesale Prices) Orders; Friday: Backbench debates: Future of Socialism &mdash; Neil Hamilton (C. Tatton) House of Lords &mdash; Monday: Debates on EC transport infrastructure and on aid to Poland. 
 Tuesday: Criminal Justice (International Co-operation) Bill, second reading; Contracts (Applicable Law) Bill, second reading; Teachers' Pay and Conditions Act 1987 (Continuation) Order; Medicines (Intermediate Medicated Feeding Stuffs) Order; debate on the disbandment of the COI's photographic library. 
 Wednesday: Debates on changes in rural and suburban communities, on the state of museums and art galleries and on Chinese behaviour towards the Tibetans. 
 Thursday: Greenwich Hospital Bill, second reading; Northern Ireland Orders &mdash; Appropriation and Education Reform; Abortion (Amendment) Bill, second reading. 
 Friday: Not sitting. 
 TODAY House of Commons: Debate on misuse of drugs. 
 House of Lords: Not sitting. 
 Sunday trade counter attack. 
 By Martin Linton 
 LABOUR'S deputy leader, Mr Roy Hattersley, accused Government ministers of &bquo;palpable ambivalence&equo; about the enforcement of the Sunday trading laws since the European Court ruling against the DIY chain B&amp;Q. 
 He asked Office minister David Mellor whether he still wished or instructed local authorities to enforce the law as it now stands. 
 But Mr Mellor replied said that &bquo;thank goodness in this free society&equo; it was not part of his job to decide whether prosecuting authorities should prosecute. 
 In this case it was a matter for local authorities. 
 Mr Paul Murphy (Lab Torfaen) asked the minister whether he would condemn B&amp;Q for flouting the law and whether he welcomed the action of Torfaen district council in prosecuting them. 
 But Mr Mellor said he must leave it to the people of Torfaen to judge whether that was a proper matter. 
 &bquo;All I can say is that the law is the law and its enforcement requires no commendation from me.&equo; 
 Mr Ivor Stanbrook (C Orpington) said it was imperative the law should be applied and those encouraging breaches ought to be prosecuted for the common law offence of incitement to commit a crime. 
 But Mr Mellor said many local authorities found the restrictions imposed by the 1950 Shops Act outmoded and &bquo;rightly or wrongly have refused to enforce it.&equo; 
 Programme obligations for independent television services. 
 SOURCE: Home Office. 
 Ulster van bomb wrecks shops near army HQ. 
 By David Hearst in Belfast 
 AT LEAST 20 people were injured, none seriously, when an IRA van bomb containing 500lb of explosives devastated a busy shopping street in the centre of Lisburn, Co Down yesterday. 
 Christmas shoppers were given 25 minutes to evacuate the area before the van exploded in Market Street only half a mile away from the headquarters of the British Army in Northern Ireland. 
 The town has always been a primary IRA target but this is the first time in many years that it has singled out the commercial centre. 
 The bomb exploded as police were trying to clear the area and most injuries were due to shock or cuts. 
 The IRA said later that businessmen could not escape &bquo;the reality of oppression in nationalist areas of Belfast&equo; and they called the Lisburn street a prestige economic target. 
 It was outside a clothing shop but the damage extended 400 yards either side. 
 Court bill &bquo;vital part of plan to improve justice&equo;: Barristers' rights go in strategic reform. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 THE BILL to reform the legal profession and abolish barristers' monopoly rights in the higher courts will pave the way for solicitors to appear in any court, up to the House of Lords. 
 The Lord Chancellor, Lord Mackay, described the Courts and Legal Services Bill, which was published yesterday, as a vital part of the Government's overall strategy to improve the administration of justice. 
 The bill also incorporates proposals from the Lord Chancellor's Civil Justice Review, which recommended an overhaul of civil court procedure to speed up and simplify cases and make litigation cheaper. 
 The central plank of the proposals is to give the county courts the power to deal with a substantial numbers of cases, particularly injury cases, reserving the High Court for complex and specialist cases. 
 The bill's most contentious provision, which has polarised the profession's two branches, sets up a framework for solicitors to appear in the higher courts, now the preserve of barristers. 
 Rules are to be drawn up by the Law Society, subject to approval by the Lord Chancellor and four senior judges. 
 Lord Mackay conceded that the judges should have a say after his original, more radical, green paper proposals drew unprecedented criticism. 
 Solicitors had feared the veto might limit their new rights, but the framework restricts the judges' room for manoeuvre. 
 In approving the rules, the Lord Chancellor and the judges will have to take advice from a new lay-dominated Advisory Committee on Legal Education and Conduct, chaired by a senior judge. 
 The other members will be two barristers, two solicitors, two law teachers and eight lay members. 
 Solicitors who gain rights to appear in the High Court will be eligible for High Court judgeships, as will circuit judges who were formerly solicitors. 
 The bill will also remove the statutory ban on lawyers taking cases on a &bquo;no-win, no-fee&equo; basis. 
 They will not be able to take an American-style percentage of the damages if successful, but will be able to ask for a slightly larger than normal fee. 
 Banks, building societies and insurance companies will be allowed to offer homebuyers a &bquo;one-stop&equo; service including conveyancing, subject to safeguards against unfair competition and conflicts of interest. 
 The Lord Chancellor originally intended that lenders should be self-regulating, but has now decided to set up a policing Authorised Conveyancing Practitioners' Board. 
 Also new is the provision for a Conveyancing Ombudsman to investigate complaints against lenders doing conveyancing. 
 The bill creates a Legal Services Ombudsman to oversee complaints against solicitors and barristers. 
 The ombudsman will have power to recommend that a lawyer or professional body pay compensation, but not to compel payment. 
 Solicitors will lose their monopoly on applying for grants of probate to deal with wills. 
 Banks, building societies and insurance companies will be able to apply for probate if they have a proper complaints handling scheme. 
 The bill envisages that non-lawyers belonging to professional bodies may be given rights to conduct litigation in some types of cases. 
 Magistrates will be given the same immunity over their actions in court as judges now enjoy. 
 The bill also allows the Lord Chancellor to restrict the automatic right of appeal to the Court of Appeal. 
 Lord Donaldson, the Master of the Rolls, has suggested that family cases should require leave of the court before an appeal. 
 IRA &bquo;exploit link&equo; to Birmingham 6. 
 By Paul Hoyland 
 SPECULATION linking the Birmingham Six and the inquiry into the West Midlands serious crime squad is being used as propaganda for the IRA, the force's Chief Constable, Mr Geoffrey Dear, claimed yesterday. 
 At a press conference confirming his promotion to regional inspector of constabulary from April 1, Mr Dear denied he was leaving at an inappropriate time. 
 The inquiry begun by him was now being conducted by West Yorkshire Police. 
 But as inspector of constabulary he would be responsible for its proper conduct. 
 The squad was disbanded in June after trials collapsed amid allegations that officers fabricated evidence. 
 Fifty-two were transferred to other duties. 
 Three have since been charged. 
 &bquo;The implications of the serious crime squad problem are great, but are well under control,&equo; Mr Dear said. 
 Preoccupation with the squad was being used as a propaganda ramp for the IRA. 
 Reporters should distinguish between publicity and &bquo;hard news which clearly needs exploring vis-a-vis the Birmingham Six&equo;. 
 He went on: &bquo;Every gratutitous headline that you put out is money into Noraid's collecting boxes in pubs here and on the east coast of America. 
 There is a lack of balance in some quarters.&equo; 
 Mr Dear repeated that, although the six were interviewed by the squad, there was no link he could see, although he understood the well-placed concern &mdash; &bquo;which must be highly confused now, given the way in which the pro-Provisional propaganda machine is running, fogging the issue&equo;. 
 The inquiry into the squad's practices went back to 1984, but Mr Dear was confident that the events of 1974, when the Birmingham bombings took place, would be re-examined if new evidence was found: &bquo;If it was there&hellip; 
 I would be one of the first to say re-open it.&equo; 
 The Birmingham case differed from the Guildford one, he said, with evidence over and above uncorroborated statements. 
 Beating of maid by princesses not as bad as painted, jury told. 
 ABARRISTER for two Arab princesses yesterday agreed that they had beaten their maid with a horse whip. 
 But &bquo;things were not as bad as they were painted&equo; in Mrs Laxmi Swami's damages action. 
 Mr Alistair MacDuff told a High Court jury that Princesses Faria and Simiya Al Sabah had meted out dreadful treatment to her on a 1983 visit to their Bayswater home in London. 
 Though they admitted a whole series of assaults over the previous three years, they disputed their frequency, he said in his closing speech. 
 Mrs Swami, who is in her 40s and lives in Kingsbury, north-west London, claims she was beaten almost daily by the two sisters of the Emir of Kuwait. 
 Mr MacDuff agreed that the jury should award fair damages to compensate her for what she had gone through. 
 But the two defendants (who were not in court) had in 1985 pleaded guilty to assault and received suspended sentences, fines and an order to pay compensation. 
 &bquo;To that extent they have already been punished.&equo; 
 Mr MacDuff asked jurors to ignore what they felt about the princesses' awful behaviour, and think about fair compensation. 
 He said he was not suggesting that Mrs Swami had tried deliberately to mislead the jury about the number of beatings. 
 She must have gone through a terrible period in her life; looking back, she genuinely believed it to be worse than it really was. 
 The hearing continues today. 
 Tactical talk in the trattoria After 4,000 years of turbulent rule, the prospect of a fortnight's foraging by English fans is barely worth a shrug to the Sardinians, says Erlend Clouston of the World Cup qualifying match preparations. 
 THE Bar Marius, on the corner of Viale Trento, is the magical delicatessen-cum-drinking den run by Mario Mariosardara, the 65-year-old president of the Cagliari supporters' club. 
 Walls are covered with grainy blow-ups of sleek-jawed Latin athletes. 
 The shelves bristle with Sardinian champagne, Ferrero Rocher chocolates, boxes of luxury Huntley and Palmer biscuits. 
 Beer is dispensed by a man with a bow tie. 
 How much of Bar Marius, and probably the man with the bow tie, will remain at the end of June is open to speculation. 
 Yesterday's announcement that England are to play their three World Cup qualifying round matches in Sardinia will take some time to sink in, but Mario marches towards his apotheosis with touching geniality. 
 &bquo;Ropson good! 
 Linker good!&equo; he chuckles after the routine mentions of Albertosi and Domengini and introducing the life-size statue of Riva (43 caps, 35 goals,) which he keeps behind the cake counter. 
 &bquo;Ooligans very drink. 
 But no violenza here!&equo; 
 Mario's secret plan for a carefree summer seems to involve an extremely large banner saying English Supporters Welcome. 
 Despite the British media's gleeful acceptance of its role as Prophet of Destruction (there are two television crews and several war correspondents here), the average Cagliari businessman appears very relaxed about it all. 
 This is partly thanks to the free insurance provided by one of the World Cup sponsors and partly historical perspective. 
 Yes, all the trattoria owners in the Via Roma will be irritated by however many broken windows and cracked heads come their way. 
 But when you have a 4,000-year history of being ruled by Phoenicians, Carthaginians, Romans, Goths, Spaniards and British (1718), a fortnight's foraging by the bleached denim wing of the industrial proletariat is barely worth a shrug. 
 The man charged with keeping the foragers in check is Mr Carlo Porceddu, security chief for the local World Cup Organisation. 
 A lawyer, he lives in one of the swish apartment blocks which sprang out of the rubble left by the last act of licensed hooliganism to hit Cagliari, namely the second world war. 
 On his desk sits a soap packet-sized book labelled Il Nuove Codice Procedura Penale. 
 &bquo;That,&equo; he says, tapping the blue hard-backed cover, &bquo;contains everything we need to handle the English.&equo; 
 Basically, Mr Porceddu intends to jail every troublemaker in sight &mdash; a minimum of two days for offensive drunkenness, automatic detention until at least the first round is over for anything more serious. 
 Scotland Yard is lending Mr Porceddu 10 officers to help him to keep tabs on the 100 ooligans whose names have flashed up on Fifa's ticket computer. 
 Was the Heysel catastrophe an element in the security equation? 
 Mr Porceddu flexed his moustache. 
 &bquo;Italians don't forget, but they don't seek revenge. 
 Anyway, Sardinian people aren't interested in this problem!&equo; 
 The local World Cup representative is Andrea Arrica. 
 It has been his job to knock on the head any mutterings about this summer's circus, notably those emanating from the Partito Sardo D'Azione, the Sardinian nationalist party, which proclaims sarcastically that it thought Sardinia's days as a penal colony were long past. 
 Mr Arrica rubbishes this view because he comprehends the essential decency of all things English, a truth revealed to him in the form of a Burberry raincoat bought from George Best's Manchester boutique circa 1965. 
 &bquo;Still magnifico,&equo; he sang, herding a squad of Fifa inspectors through the disconcertingly tall grass in the Sant' Elia stadium, &bquo;So warm, so dry, so English!&equo; 
 Mr Arrica's proselytising has been impeccable. 
 The walls of Cagliari are bare of anti-English graffiti. 
 At the top end of the Via XXIV Maggio, a blue aerosol script waltzes along an adobi terrace: &bquo;We are Kaos &mdash; Ultras.&equo; 
 Ultras is the menacing brand name adopted by all fractious Italian fans, but exactly who is getting at whom in this lazy Mediterranean alleyway remains unclear. 
 There are rumoured to be some hard men in town. 
 Their signature crops up here and there &mdash; &bquo;Sconvols,&equo; meaning, roughly, head-cases. 
 But no one is too worried about them. 
 Sconvols are Sardinian and Sardinians are a calmer model of Italian, less fiery than Neapolitans, less classy than the Milanese. 
 &bquo;They have a certain aloofness and reserve,&equo; D.H. 
 Lawrence wrote when in Cagliari 70 years ago. 
 This is one explanation for why there are still many tickets available for the matches in England's group. 
 Another is the Great Orange Riot of 1971 when an Italian team, playing Spain in Cagliari, but tactlessly, without any Cagliarian representatives, was chased off the pitch by Outspan-wielding Sconvols. 
 Result: no more internationals for the Sant' Elia and a frigidity on footballing relations between Ireland and the continent that lingers to this day. 
 The insult was particularly deep because the year before, Cagliari had won its first and only Italian championship. 
 Even today, it is impossible to debate the weather or the honey crop with the average Cagliaritano without the conversation drifting round to the campioni del settanta. 
 &bquo;Ah! 
 Domengini! 
 Albertosi! 
 Riva!&equo; 
 Lawrence put his money on the islanders: &bquo;In the end, the strange, sinister spirit of the place&hellip; will smash our mechanical oneness into smithereens.&equo; 
 But he was writing from a world in which Riva only meant coastline and Best was something worn on Sundays. 
 David Lacey, page 20 
 Young &bquo;deception&equo; over Rover. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 LORD Young, the former Trade Secretary, wrote to British Aerospace asking it to choose how to hide the &pound;38 million &bquo;sweeteners&equo; from Parliament and the European Commission 48 hours before he announced the sale of Rover, confidential letters revealed yesterday. 
 The latest disclosures, a week after the Guardian published the National Audit Office's memorandum to MPs revealing the existence of the sweeteners, led to a third clash between Labour and the Prime Minister on the Government's involvement in what Labour called the &bquo;calculated deception of Parliament and the European Commission&equo;. 
 Mrs Thatcher stonewalled her way through Question Time, repeatedly arguing that the Rover deal had been in the best interests of the taxpayer. 
 The correspondence, leaked to Labour's Trade spokesman, Mr Gordon Brown, discloses for the first time that Lord Young appeared to plan with Professor Roland Smith, chairman of British Aerospace, to hide the figures rather than simply leaving the information to be &bquo;scattered&equo; in obscure documents in the hope that Parliament would not notice it. 
 The letters reveal there is a private letter attached to the British Aerospace deal allowing the company to sell Rover without penalty within five years &mdash; although the published terms say the company would have to pay back &pound;650 million. 
 The letters show Professor Smith wanted the Government to increase the ceiling on foreign holdings in BAe to 30 per cent &mdash; to boost the value of the company &mdash; and that Lord Young knew then tax concessions still to be agreed with the Inland Revenue on the deal could amount to nearer &pound;65 million than the &pound;25 million suggested to the commission. 
 Mr Brown last night wrote to Mrs Thatcher demanding she publish the final agreement on cash, assets and tax signed between the Government and BAe. 
 He asked that all the correspondence between the company and Lord Young during July 1988 be made available. 
 Mr Robert Sheldon, chairman of the Commons Public Accounts Committee, said yesterday he was seeking more documents from the Department of Trade after Monday's hearing when he cross-examined Sir Peter Gregson, the permanent secretary at the ministry. 
 Details of Lord Young's involvement emerge in an exchange of letters between him and Professor Smith on July 12, 1988 &mdash; two days before he made his announcement to the House of Lords of the Rover sale. 
 It shows Professor Smith's anger at Lord Young's apparent refusal then to agree to what later became known as the &pound;38 million sweeteners &mdash; accusing him of altering terms to &bquo;British Aerospace's disadvantage&equo; and of putting forward points &bquo;which neither I nor my advisers can understand&equo;. 
 Lord Young replies the same day, discussing in detail how to avoid parliamentary and commission scrutiny. 
 On the secret deal deferring payment for Rover until next March, Lord Young writes: &bquo;I can offer three possibilities, in ascending order of risk that the deferment will be picked up by the commission, in which case they might require repayment of the notional interest saved. 
 &bquo;The possibilities are: Payment on 31 December 1988. 
 The payment would appear in your 1988 accounts, and in the Government's accounts for 1988/89, just as if it had been made in August. 
 &bquo;Payment on 31 March 1989: The payment would still appear in the Government's accounts for 1988/89 but would appear in your 1989 accounts. 
 &bquo;Payment on 31 August 1989. 
 The deferment would be apparent from both the Government's accounts and your own. 
 In addition, to avoid seriously misleading Parliament, when we table the revised estimate for the cash injection on the day of the statement, we cannot include the &pound;150 million as a receipt due this year. 
 The omission is likely to be spotted by at least some members.&equo; 
 He concludes: &bquo;I am content to take whichever of these options you prefer.&equo; 
 In the event Lord Young backed down further and agreed to March 30, 1990. 
 The next paragraph says that not only did Lord Young cut the published penalty clause for BAe from &pound;650 million to &pound;400 million as disclosed in the National Audit Office memorandum, but offered &bquo;a private side-letter&equo; waiving the penalty &bquo;the text of which would be agreed with BAe in advance&equo;. 
 On the &pound;15 million acquisition costs to buy out the private Rover shareholders, Lord Young writes: &bquo;I have had further discussions with Commissioner Sutherland &lsqb;Sir Leon Brittan's predecessor in charge of competition policy&rsqb;. 
 The latter has said that he could not necessarily turn a blind eye to this&hellip; especially if there were complaints from other parties; as you are well aware the commission have the power to seek repayment. 
 This underlines the need to avoid unnecessarily raising the profile of the issue.&equo; 
 He goes on: &bquo;Since these costs&hellip; would have to be paid by a grant&hellip; and since a grant of above &pound;10 million requires affirmative resolution &lsqb;and thus debate&rsqb; in the House, it seems there are two choices: to cap the BAe grant at &pound;9.5 million; or set the ceiling at &pound;13.5 million and for you to accept the greater risk of challenge and thus repayment being required.&equo; 
 In the event &pound;11 million was paid out &mdash; split into two payments to avoid Parliamentary scrutiny. 
 Lord Young felt less able to help increase foreign shareholding limits since the commission was investigating Rolls Royce's foreign shareholding arrangements. 
 A Country Diary. 
 NORTHUMBERLAND: Roe deer are among the most difficult wild creatures for humans to succour and rehabilitate. 
 Abandoned fawns have been reared on a bottle, only to die within a few months. 
 So it was interesting to hear this week from Mrs Bolton of Wildlife In Need in the north of our country that she has recently saved the life of a six-month old roe doe fawn. 
 The little deer was seen staggering in a distressed and bloated condition, captured with difficulty and taken to a vet who pumped fermented corn from the stomach &mdash; presumably the fawn had gorged herself on pheasant feed. 
 Mrs Bolton kept her in a pen where, despite remaining in a very frightened state, the little beast recovered and started eating small amounts of hay. 
 After three days, when scouring had stopped, she was tagged, put in a sack and taken to a field which a neighbour was certain her siblings frequented. 
 &bquo;It was wonderful to see her reaction,&equo; said Mr Bolton. 
 &bquo;She shot up the field and then paused, stood her ground although we were still quite close and suddenly began to eat grass.&equo; 
 She knew that she had come home. 
 A few days later the doe was seen in the company of her mother and twin sister. 
 At present an agoraphobic shag is languishing at the wildlife centre and, despite every inducement, Mrs Bolton cannot persuade him even to get his feet wet. 
 She has five hedgehogs hibernating in mounds of leaves and a kestrel which was left on her doorstep with a damaged foot. 
 It has been a bad autumn for birds of prey and five kestrels have been brought into the sanctuary in an emaciated condition. 
 Worms are a staple diet and these have been in short supply due to the summer drought. 
 VERONICA HEATH 
 Divers dangers The dramatic rise in diving's popularity has led to fears for the safety of people new to the sport. 
 John Illman reports. 
 THE spectacular beauty of coral is attracting an ever increasing number of people to scuba diving. 
 Many Britons undergo training in the UK after trying the sport abroad and then continue diving in our colder UK waters. 
 The British Sub Aqua Club (BSAC) has just reported a record-breaking year, with the number of dives off the UK coast estimated at about two million &mdash; 100 per cent up on the previous year. 
 But medical diving experts are concerned that many newcomers to the sport are diving too deep, especially in the UK, exposing themselves to life-threatening injury from &bquo;the bends&equo; or decompression sickness. 
 Writing in Diver Magazine, BSAC's &bquo;incidents adviser&equo;, Chris Allen, warns: &bquo;The statistics show that too many divers are still diving deeper than indicated by their abilities, ignoring commonsense recommendations or simply failing to plan their dives properly.&equo; 
 The longer a diver remains under water and the greater the depth, the more nitrogen is absorbed. 
 When pressure is reduced during ascent, this nitrogen must be slowly eliminated through breathing, or bubbles will form in the bloodstream, giving rise to the bends. 
 A diver absorbing excessive nitrogen must ascend to a designated depth to reduce the pressure and remain there for a specified time for what is known as a &bquo;decompression stop.&equo; 
 But Allen warns: &bquo;A number of cases of decompression sickness have resulted after required decompression stops have been missed due to divers running out of air towards the end of their dives.&equo; 
 Some are diving to 50 metres or more. 
 Surgeon Commander James Francis, senior medical officer (diving medicine) at the Institute of Naval Medicine, says: &bquo;I would have thought that 30 metres was a reasonable depth for most sports divers. 
 Below that your &bquo;bottom time&equo; &mdash; the time between leaving the surface and commencing your ascent &mdash; is so limited that it's hardly worthwhile.&equo; 
 Despite the dangers, BSAC, whose training is among the most rigorous in the world, insists that diving compares favourably with other sports. 
 This year there were 12 fatalities linked to diving. 
 BSAC spokesman Kendal McDonald claims that this compares with the 35 fatalities a year associated with angling, 39 with boating, and 44 with swimming. 
 The club is pressing for recognition of decompression sickness as an NHS liability. 
 Many health authorities have been refusing to pay for treatment, arguing that divers should take out decompression insurance. 
 Treatment can cost anything from a few hundred pounds to up to &pound;15,000 in exceptional circumstances. 
 BSAC medical officer Dr Peter Wilmhurst, of St Thomas' Hospital, London, says: &bquo;Divers are entitled to treatment under the NHS Act in the same way as a skater who breaks a leg on the ice or a rider who breaks his back falling off a horse. 
 It would be a false economy not to treat divers. 
 If you have a diver with spinal bend, and you don't recompress them, you have someone paralysed from the waist down. 
 The cost to society of treating them is immense.&equo; 
 Depth of experience&hellip; tyros must avoid going down too far OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Good sense and justice sought in immigration issue:. 
 Queen's Bench Division Regina v Immigration Appeal Tribunal, ex parte Rafique Before Mr Justice Simon Brown December 7 1989 
 WHEN a man applies to come to the United Kingdom to marry a woman settled here, it is not necessary for him to be able to state specifically whether he intends to settle in this country forever or whether he wishes to marry and return to his own country. 
 If an applicant is uncertain as to his plans after marriage, the entry clearance officer should treat it as an application for settlement, and consider whether all the requirements for settlement are satisfied. 
 The facts. 
 Abid Hussain, a Pakistani, is engaged to be married to Miss Rafique, a British citizen, and they want to be married in England. 
 Mr Hussain was refused entry clearance to come to England, mainly because he could not say what were his long term intentions. 
 When interviewed Mr Hussain said he had not decided whether, following marriage, he, or his fiancee, would wish to remain in England or return to Pakistan. 
 The entry clearance officer (ECO) said he was not satisfied that the primary purpose of Mr Hussain's intended marriage was not to obtain admittance to the UK. 
 Mr Hussain appealed. 
 The adjudicator concluded that Mr Hussain's application was for a short-term stay and dismissed the appeal after hearing evidence from Miss Rafique that she had no intention of living in Pakistan. 
 The immigration appeal tribunal said the onus was on an applicant to bring himself within the specific immigration rule, and if he was unable or unwilling to do so he could not expect to succeed. 
 Mr Hussain appealed. 
 The Rules. 
 Rule 41 of the Statement of Changes in Immigration Rules (HC 169) provides: &bquo;A man seeking to enter the UK for marriage to a woman settled here and who intends to settle here thereafter&equo; will be refused entry clearance unless the ECO is satisfied that it is not the primary purpose of the marriage to obtain admission to the UK. 
 Under rule 17 a man may apply for entry clearance to the UK for marriage where he and his wife will leave the UK after the marriage. 
 The decision. 
 Mr Justice Simon Brown said that shortly before the tribunal came to its decision in this case a tribunal chaired by Professor Jackson took a different approach in a similar case, Syed Jabar Hussain Shah. 
 That tribunal said that to force an applicant to state whether he intends to live here forever, or for a period of not less than six months, invites deceit and was somewhat removed from reality. 
 That tribunal said that where there was uncertainty as to the duration of the stay it was proper to consider the application as if ordinary residence was contemplated. 
 Mr Justice Simon Brown said he greatly preferred the approach adopted by Professor Jackson's tribunal. 
 It accorded with good sense and justice, and also properly reflected the important impact of the House of Lords' decision in Shah v Barnet Borough Council &lsqb;1983&rsqb; 2 AC 309 upon the statutory definition of settlement for Immigration Act purposes. 
 In Shah's case Lord Scarman said, &bquo;All that is necessary is that the purpose of living where one does &lsqb;eg, for education, employment, health, family or merely love of the place&rsqb; has a sufficient degree of continuity to be properly described as settled&equo;. 
 Why should an applicant, who must in any event be prepared to satisfy the primary purpose test, be worse off because he contemplates the possibility of a relatively short stay in the UK than one who had the fixed intention of permanent UK residence? 
 It was logical to construe the phrase &bquo;intending to settle&equo; in rule 41 differently from the contrasting phrase &bquo;admitted for settlement&equo; which appears elsewhere. 
 There was no possible good reason why rule 41 should not encompass those genuinely undecided as to their long term ambitions. 
 Accordingly the tribunal in Mr Hussain's case fell into error. 
 They categorised all applicants, genuine or otherwise, who were unable or unwilling to specify their long term intentions, as necessarily falling outside the ambit of the rules and thus doomed to inevitable failure when applying for entry clearance. 
 The essence of what Mr Hussain said was that following the marriage he would remain in England on a settled basis as a married man for just so long as his wife dictated. 
 And for good measure, it should be noted that the ECO long ago expressed his own conclusion that settlement in the UK was the intention in this case. 
 The tribunal's decision was quashed and the appeal restored for hearing as an appeal against a refusal of entry clearance under rule 41. 
 The crucial issue still to be determined was whether the primary purpose of the marriage was to obtain admission to the UK. 
 If the immigration authorities concluded that Mr Hussain's assertion that he was undecided as to his long term intentions was pretended rather than genuine, clearly that would weigh against him in the primary purpose issue. 
 That was a general possibility and there was no reason to suppose that that would be the conclusion. 
 Appearances: Ramby De Mello instructed by Bean McDonald, Birmingham for Mr Hussain and Miss Rafique; John Laws instructed by the Treasury Solicitor for the Home Secretary. 
 Shiranikha Herbert barrister 
 Warren Tute:. 
 A MAN of many parts, Warren Tute was thought by those who knew him only slightly to be a good raconteur and a popular member of the Garrick. 
 However, he was a writer with a number of plays to his credit, none of them great successes but all worthy of note. 
 After leaving the Navy he also wrote much fiction, and as a novelist in the early post-war years his first published work, The Felthams (1950), was thought highly of and his bestseller, The Rock (1957), served to establish him as a writer of more than a little promise. 
 With such biographical works as Admiral Cochrane, Earl of Dundonald (1965), and his absorbing record of those 1940 operations involving the French fleet, The Deadly Stroke (1973), he broke into non-fiction too. 
 Tute was educated at Wrekin College, joined the Navy as a paymaster-cadet and served his apprenticeship throughout the thirties, becoming secretary to the Captain of the Fleet, Mediterranean. 
 He took part inthe naval landings in North Africa, helped plan further landings in Sicily, and towards the war's end he became deputy secretary to the chief of combined operations. 
 After the war, Tute worked in a variety of jobs where his skills as both sailor and writer were much in demand &mdash; broadcasting, film-making, and as script editor for London Weekend Television. 
 He also had a finger in theatrical production and I first knew him when he was associated with Elspeth Cochrane's literary management during the 1960s. 
 One of his most enterprising productions was Little Mary Sunshine in 1962. 
 Happy and novel and thoroughly charming, it gave several talented artists their first big chance, going on to bigger, if hardly better things. 
 None was so sweet (without being cloying) as that burst of theatrical sunshine at the Comedy Theatre in the West End during a fatal summer heatwave which put paid to the show's box office takings as well as Warren's plucky managerial debut. 
 His tenacious belief in the venture by keeping it running cost him heavy personal financial loss and his &bquo;nursing&equo; of this satire on operetta that has rarely been equalledis largely forgotten (but not by me). 
 Peter Cotes Warren Tute born February 22, 1914; died November 26, 1989. 
 Edoardo Amaldi. 
 Ragazzi of distinction:. 
 IN December, 1943, the men working feverishly to create the first American atomic bomb sent a team of &bquo;spooks&equo; to Naples. 
 One of their main assignments was to contact Edoardo Amaldi, a physicist thought to be in hiding near Rome. 
 Six months later, the day before Rome's liberation by the Allies, Amaldi was found. 
 He was interviewed by Moe Berg, then one of the most famous baseball players in America. 
 Berg was also an agent of the Office of Strategic Services, which was later to give birth to the CIA. 
 His job was to convince Amaldi to pack his bags because there was a ship waiting at Naples to take him to the United States. 
 Amaldi's presence there had been sought by two other Italian colleagues, also physicists. 
 His mentor, Enrico Fermi, later to be called &bquo;the father of the bomb&equo;, and Emilio Segre (who died in California earlier this year). 
 Amaldi dodged the American invitation, perhaps because (with Rome liberated) Fermi's mantle in physics had fallen on his young shoulders and there were younger minds to teach. 
 He wore that mantle well at Rome University until his retirement in 1978. 
 But Amaldi never really retired nor grew old. 
 He kept regular hours in the university's physics building, spoke at scientific meetings this year in Moscow and Washington. 
 As President of the Accademia Nazionale dei Lincei he had delivered the welcoming address on Tuesday to a symposium of scientists. 
 He then ordered a car to call for him the next morning for a similar occasion and was felled by a stroke while waiting for the lift. 
 Amaldi grew up in a small town in Lombardy, and took his doctorate in physics from Rome at the remarkably early age of 21. 
 In 1929, he became one of the ragazzi di Via Panisperna &mdash; the street where Fermi's &bquo;kids&equo; carried out their own experiments under the master in their own under-financed lab. 
 Emilio Segre was one kid, and Bruno Pontecorvo, later to defect from Britain to the Soviet Union, another. 
 It is interesting to note that the &bquo;pope&equo; &mdash; as the kids called Fermi &mdash; &bquo;because he's always right&equo;, was only seven years older than Amaldi. 
 Amaldi astounded his group in October 1934 with his discovery that by slowing down, rather than accelerating, neutrons, he could provoke intense nuclear reactions. 
 He held a chair in physics from 1937 until his retirement publishing more than 150 papers on atomic and nuclear physics. 
 He was awarded honorary degrees by Algiers, Glasgow and Oxford. 
 He became a founder, and active executive, of the European Centre for Nuclear Research in Geneva. 
 I had the pleasure of two long talks last year with Professor Amaldi about his knowledge of what the German physicists were doing with their atoms during the war years. 
 Apart for his incongruously white hair, Amaldi seemed to have the mental lucidity and expected energy of a man half his age. 
 His modesty, considering his world-wide fame in his field, was endearing. 
 I knew almost nothing about physics but we shared some jokes about the Rome telephone system. 
 In 1949, Amaldi wrote to the Italian prime minister asking for permission to produce and sell sealing wax for letters, &bquo;so that we may raise needed funds for our physics lab&equo;. 
 The reply came from an under-secretary who said that the present funding was considered adequate and the commercial undertaking would be ill-advised. 
 It was signed by Giulio Andreotti, the present prime minister. 
 George Armstrong Edoardo Amaldi, born Carpaneto Piacentino September 5, 1908; died Rome, December 5, 1989. 
 In the US, workers can now lose their jobs through drug tests. 
 Will the same procedure be introduced here? 
 Richie Denenberg reports Putting jobs on the line. 
 BUILDING work on a new county jail in Florida was falling woefully behind schedule, despite the critical need for additional space to house the many arrested as suspected drug offenders. 
 Pressed to account for the delay, an embarrassed local official explained that the project was lagging because too few construction workers could pass the drug test required of all job seekers. 
 The Florida county's ironic predicament illustrates the extent to which drug testing is relied upon by some US employers to screen the workforce. 
 The growing propensity to sample bodily fluids for contraband chemicals has engendered a bitter legal struggle over an employee's right of privacy, a conflict which could spread to Europe along with fear of &bquo;crack.&equo; 
 For many workers, the ability to survive a drug test, most commonly a urinalysis for illicit chemicals such as cannabis and cocaine, is becoming a prerequisite to getting and holding a job. 
 On orders from the White House, perhaps as many as a million federal government emloyees are now subject to testing. 
 Wielding its regulatory stick, Washington is compelling the aviation, rail and trucking industries to test thousands of pilots, train crews and lorry drivers. 
 A survey by the US Department of Labor revealed that about a fifth of private-sector workers, mainly employees of large corporations, are already subject to testing. 
 Job applicants are spurned if they register &bquo;positive&equo; on a test, often without learning the reason for their rejection. 
 Successful applicants may be subjected to surprise random testing once they are hired -names of those who must provide a urine specimen are picked in a computerised lottery. 
 Others are tested when an industrial accident occurs, on the theory that it creates a &bquo;reasonable suspicion&equo; of drug impairment, even though faulty equipment or poor weather conditions may more plausibly account for the mishap. 
 Still others are tested if they apply for promotion to positions which are deemed &bquo;sensitive.&equo; 
 Refusing to be tested or coming up positive usually results in immediate sacking. 
 Many unfair dismissal hearings centre on the arcane testimony of forensic chemists, toxicologists and psychopharmacologists (specialists in mood-altering substances). 
 The testing boom has been resisted vigorously by civil liberties groups and trade unions, who view this aspect of the &bquo;war on drugs&equo; as a frontal assault on a worker's dignity and entitlement to due process. 
 The obligation to urinate on demand offends many employees, particularly when an offical monitor &mdash; given the Orwellian title of &bquo;Collection Site Person&equo; in government regulations &mdash; stands by to guard against deceptive practices. 
 Urine advertised as free of detectable drugs is on offer by mail-order to anxious test takers, who could try to substitute it for their own. 
 Last spring, the US Supreme Court dealt the unions a blow by ruling, in a suit brought by treasury employees and rail workers, that for critical occupations (such as a customs agent) testing does not curtail constitutional rights. 
 Applying a balancing test, the court held that the danger posed by drug abuse outweighed the individual's expectation of privacy. 
 Despite that setback, opponents strive to contain the spread of testing through further litigation. 
 An argument often made in their briefs, against random testing in particular, is that it reverses the normal presumption of innocence: an employee is deemed guilty unless he can prove himself innocent by producing &bquo;clean&equo; urine. 
 Unlike the familiar blood alcohol tests in motoring cases, urinalysis does not demonstrate that the employee is impaired by drugs. 
 It merely detects residues of drugs ingested as much as weeks in the past, when the worker may well have been off-duty or on holiday. 
 An official of the American Civil Liberties Union has protested: &bquo;Firing people who come to work sober because of their condition on Saturday night is of debatable value.&equo; 
 The civil libertarians argue that testing permits the employer to delve deeply into an employee's personal life; a specimen can be analysed, without the subject's knowledge, to reveal confidential medical conditions, such as epilepsy or pregnancy. 
 Drug testing also may disproportionally victimise members of racial minority groups whose subcultures sanction casual marijuana smoking, reversing much of the progress that has been made in eliminating employment discrimination. 
 AKEY ISSUE in the litigation is the accuracy of the analytical technology. 
 Testing has created a gold rush for the &bquo;diagnostics industry&equo;, the largely unregulated private laboratories in which boxes of specimen jars, resembling crates of milk bottles, are processed in assembly-line fashion. 
 Errors sometimes occur, in part because an innocuous substance may trigger a positive. 
 Poppy seeds sprinkled on bread as a flavouring have a disconcerting tendency to react chemically in the same way as the extract of the opium poppy, so that a worker could be mistaken for a heroin user because of what he ate for breakfast. 
 The government's own Center for Disease Control discovered serious reporting errors when quality verification samples were posted to a number of laboratories as an experiment. 
 Although the government has since promulgated guidelines to standardise analytical methods, doubts remain about whether laboratories can be relied upon not to make technical and clerical mistakes which could result in someone's discharge. 
 When mistakes are made, they can prompt complex law suits. 
 An electricity generating company in California sued a laboratory which failed to properly document its analysis; the company was trying to recover from the laboratory the costs of settling a suit for unfair dismissal brought by an employee who lost her job because of the test. 
 Appearing as witnesses in court, some physicians have suggested that it is foolhardy to jeopardise a person's livelihood because of a laboratory report when the worker appears to be performing his job normally. 
 No doctor would order surgery or other treatment on the basis of a single test result, they point out, without corroborating clinical evidence. 
 Job-related performance testing, such as use of flight simulators to check the condition of pilots, has been suggested as a preferable substitute for the drug hunt. 
 There is a theory that even if drug testing is flawed, it at least deters drug use. 
 Yet addiction specialists scoff at the notion that someone who already faces death through overdose or through contracting Aids from hypodermic needles is likely to change his behavour because of a drug test. 
 And, although the Supreme Court upheld testing of customs agents, a few members of the bench doubted that a drug-imbibing agent would be deterred by a test if he was not already fearful, as one put it, that he &bquo;may be shot dead in unequal combat with unimpaired smugglers.&equo; 
 TESTING for a short list of illicit drugs has been labelled as myopic, since the working population as a whole tends to abuse a vast pharmacopoeia of legal but impairing substances, many of them heavily promoted by distilleries and pharmaceutical firms. 
 A consumer group recently forced the withdrawal of a medical advertisement which invited doctors to prescribe tranquilizers for air traffic controllers suffering from job stress as they pore over their radar scopes. 
 The addiction specialists urge that the emphasis be shifted to eliminating underlying conditions, such as job stress and tedium, against which workers often seek to medicate themselves. 
 Rather than focusing on a few substances which are painted in lurid colours, the specialists say, the goal should be a workplace free of compulsive chemical use of all kinds. 
 Since testing is typically used not to facilitate treatment of addicted workers but to sack them &mdash; a process sardonically referred to as &bquo;dismissal therapy&equo; &mdash; the upshot could be a &bquo;recriminalisation&equo; of addiction. 
 That would undo decades of effort to have chemical dependency recognised as a treatable disorder rather than as a moral lapse deserving of punishment. 
 Even though drug testing has attracted the most controversy, it is merely part of a broad movement in America toward a Darwinian worker-selection policy, which has been dubbed &bquo;employment of the fittest.&equo; 
 Employees are routinely subjected to psychological screening and polygraph tests to evaluate their honesty. 
 Character is probed by handwriting analysts. 
 Genetic screening, to determine if the worker's chromosomes render him vulnerable to occupational illness, looms on the horizon. 
 Multiple layers of screening, much of it of dubious scientific validity, may become a routine feature of working life unless restraints are imposed by law, as some states have begun to do. 
 While it approved some types of drug testing, the Supreme Court did leave the anti-testing forces a glimmer of hope for ultimate legal containment. 
 It held that in principle a drug test is a &bquo;search&equo; within the meaning of the Fourth Amendment in the Bill of Rights. 
 Since the amendment bans &bquo;unreasonable searches and seizures,&equo; the possibility remains that a test may be found unreasonable if the job is so non-critical that public needs fail to outweigh individual privacy interests. 
 Drug testing opponents may also take comfort from the surprising dissent by arch-conservative Justice Antonin Scalia. 
 He disparaged the customs service testing programme as mere display, a gesture of solidarity with the President's anti-drug campaign. 
 Sacrificing civil liberties, Justice Scalia sneered, &bquo;cannot be the means of making a point.&equo; 
 R. V. Denenberg, a former editor at the New York Times, is the author of Understanding American Politics (Fontana Press). 
 Dismissal therapy&hellip; the use of drug tests has lead to a US legal battle over workers' privacy rights PHOTOGRAPH: N. SAGANSKY 
 FOR EUROPE ENVIRONMENT ONLY Power without the people. 
 By Koy Thompson 
 SPANNING four continents and 70 countries, it is hardly surprising that the causes, and hence solutions to tropical forest destruction shift from region to region. 
 Common threads nonetheless emerge. 
 Tropical forests are almost always in developing countries suffering from varying degrees of poverty and debt. 
 Economic pressures on forests are immense, placing them on the cutting-edge of the reconciliation between environment and development. 
 So, how do we save them? 
 Prevalent conservation orthodoxy advocates protection through production. 
 Show that forests have a tangible value kept as forests, for example for timber, and countries will manage them for a sustained cash yield. 
 This top-down approach is favoured by the two major institutions charged with saving the tropical forests, the International Tropical Timber Organisation, and the World Bank and UN backed Tropical Foresty Action Plan. 
 Their solution offers money and resources to the powerful. 
 Technically sweet and politically acceptable, it avoids accusation of moral hypocrisy by using economic arguments to appeal to self interest. 
 Unfortunately the timber industry is shot through with economic inefficiency. 
 Weak forestry services are subordinate to production figures and dominated by wealthy elites, often politicians, who stand to gain tremendously from short-term liquidation of forest assets. 
 The benefits to the poor are trifling, and for native peoples, invariably negative. 
 This dire situation exists despite a welter of management plans, royalties, taxes, and fees. 
 Putting your tropical forest conservation eggs in the hardwood basket is a high risk strategy. 
 Some argue for weaning countries from timber centrism by showing the higher economic value to be had from non-wood products harvested without harming forests. 
 But despite detailed studies in Amazonia, Malaysia and Indonesia, there is little evidence that this persuasive economic argument has turned countries away from logging or forest conversion. 
 The failure is not in the argument, which is powerful and important, but in the approach. 
 It would take an heroic leap of imagination to suppose that those same forestry services with a proven inability to manage just one product, timber, could presently perform the economic and administrative gymnastics necessary to fully value and manage forests for multiple benefits. 
 Sometime in the future, sophisticated economic valuation may be critical for striking a global bargain for forest conservation between north and south. 
 But right now what is needed is a bottom-up approach; entrusting the forests to those increasingly organised peoples whose survival has depended for generations on environmental knowledge. 
 These forest peoples movements, the Indians, the rubber trappers, and ural unions, are well known in Brazil, but exist widely, for example in Kenya, India, the Phillippines and Malaysia. 
 They are organised and prepared to resist the destruction of the forests. 
 Involving people directly in decision making about forest development, and in their active management, recognises the social, political, and economic roots of the forest crisis. 
 Econmomic arguments are useful but sustainable development is fundamentally a moral concept, based on the common good, justice, and equity. 
 Koy Thomson is International Rainforest Campaigner with Friends of the Earth. 
 Standing up to be counted Commentary. 
 By Melanie Phillips 
 AN extraordinary scene took place this week. 
 Mr Jack Hibbert, the head of the Government Statistical Service, appeared in front of some 300 statisticians at a public meeting to defend the reputation and integrity of his service and the official information it purveys. 
 It was an unprecedented public appearance by the ultimate grey man in front of a deeply critical and anxious audience of greyish men (and a few women). 
 So sensitive was the occasion, approval had to be given by none other than the Cabinet Secretary and the Permanent Secretary to the Treasury before Mr Hibbert could be exposed to the harsh winds of public controversy. 
 For official statistics have become tainted by more than disagreement: the charges being levelled against the service amount to the politicisation of knowledge, a form of intellectual corruption and a scandalous abuse of power. 
 Concern has been growing for some time now, voiced not only by the media but also by some high-powered academics, ex-civil servants and former senior government statisticians, that official information which should be wholly objective is being distorted, suppressed or otherwise interfered with to serve the political ends of the government. 
 This anxiety has been fuelled by, for example, changes to the basis of counting the numbers of unemployed people, changing the index for measuring poverty or using official figures to claim that the health service is enjoying unprecedented prosperity. 
 In addition, the Rayner review of the service introduced not only cuts but a new philosophy that official figures, which previously had been for the service of the nation as a whole, were now to be tied far more closely to the requirements of the government of the day. 
 The statisticians are rightly extremely troubled by the loss of public confidence in official figures. 
 Official information provides the basis on which voters can decide on the record of the government and accordingly make an informed electoral choice. 
 As custodians of objective facts, statisticians know that the priceless asset of the truth must never be squandered in the interests of political expediency, not least because the public will then refuse to believe information that is actually true. 
 The grave claim that politicians are muddying the clear statistical waters has been made on a mumber of occasions now by Sir Claus Moser, a former head of the government statistical service. 
 He repeated his worry this week about the changes to the unemployment and poverty registers and the apparent wish to change the basis of the retail price index. 
 Professor Sir David Cox of Nuffield College, Oxford, an expert on &mdash; among other things &mdash; Aids statistics, no doubt had uppermost in his mind the Prime Ministerial axing of the Lifestyle Aids survey when he referred to increasing political pressure and lamented the sinking reputation of official statistics. 
 And a former deputy head of the Office of Population, Censuses and Surveys, Mr Philip Redfern, trenchantly criticised his erstwhile colleagues for lacking the openness and courage to swim against the political tide. 
 Faced with all this, Mr Hibbert's speech was a masterpiece of sanitised complacency which looked pitifully inadequate as a response to such well-placed anxieties. 
 The statistical service, said Mr Hibbert, was completely open about its methods. 
 Yes, said his critics, but it was a different story if anyone tried to get access to the information behind those methods. 
 The recent report by Profesor Richard Benjamin, for example, had castigated the government for deliberately obstructing access to certain data such as the Family Expenditure Survey. 
 Then there was the troublesome question of the unemployment statistics. 
 Publishing the old figures compiled from Job Centres, said Mr Hibbert, alongside the new ones might have been a good idea just to show how misleading the old ones had been. 
 For good measure, up popped Mr Peter Stibbard, Director of Statistics at the Department of Employment. 
 Mr Stibbard appeared outraged by any suggestion of impropriety. 
 The change in the figures appeared to be due to things like administrative convenience. 
 Total professional integrity! he smoothed. 
 But then up popped Mr Geoffrey Penrice, one of Mr Stibbard's predecessors. 
 In 1979, he said, the incoming government had felt the unemployment figures were too high. 
 Ministers wanted to change their presentation and their content. 
 The expression on Mr Hibbert's face didn't change. 
 He continued to nod and smile. 
 But Mr Penrice had given the game away. 
 The figures had been changed for political reasons. 
 The crucial distinction drawn by Mr Hibbert and others is between the figures themselves, simon pure as they are, and the possibly misleading use made of them by politicians and others. 
 In other words, the statisticians are anxious to prove that their hands are clean, however stained politicians may be. 
 But it's not as simple as that. 
 To say, as Mr Hibbert did, that statisticians cannot publicly dispute any misleading use politicians may make of official information is a weaselly argument. 
 They have a duty to set the record straight, otherwise they are conniving at falsehood. 
 Philip Redfern suggested it should become standard practice for statisticians to put their professional advice on the record. 
 There is no valid argument against such an obvious improvement to the democractic process. 
 But to speak out publicly without fear of retribution statisticians must become wholly independent of government, as happens in many other European countries. 
 And this august body of quintessential back-room people must now press loudly and firmly for this to happen. 
 It's not enough to imply, as Jack Hibbert did, that protests are being made to ministers behind the scenes. 
 It's understood that he has now been twice to complain to the Prime Minister that ministers are trying to make his staff do things he finds improper. 
 Brownie points for guts, if true; but public confidence is not going to be restored in the integrity of official information unless it is seen to be properly independent of the government machine that is now exerting its improper pressures behind closed doors. 
 Deaths: Sammy Fain: in Los Angeles aged 87: one of the last tunesmiths who peddled their songs from the back of trucks and in the dingy hallways of Tin Pan Alley. 
 Like Irving Berlin, Fain became part of that group of early 20th-century American songwriters with a talent for producing simple melodies that remained popular decades after they were first heard. 
 His evergreens include I'll be Seeing You, Katie, Dear Hearts and Gentle People, and I Can Dream, Can't I. Among films he scored or wrote for are Hellzapoppin, Anchors Aweigh, Love is a Many Splendored Thing, and Myra Breckinridge. 
 Robert Vidalin, a voice of resistance during the second world war, in Paris aged 86. 
 A Comedie Franaise actor, he joined the Underground and found his way to London and the B.B.C. to become one of the best known announcers on Les Franais Parient aux Franais, banned by the Nazis but heard throughout France. 
 Vidalin was among many who transmitted coded messages to the Resistance. 
 Birthdays. 
 Peter Blake, 38, David Carradine, 53, James MacArthur, 52, Maximilian Schell, 59, actors; Sir Ralph Carr-Ellison, chairman, Automobile Association and Tyne Tees Television, Lord-Lieutenant of Tyne and Wear, 65; Julian Critchley MP, 59; Sammy Davis jun, entertainer, 64; Sir Roger Elliott, Wyckeham Professor of Physics, Oxford, 61; Lucien Freud, painter, 67; James Galway, flautist, 50; Jennie Linden, actress, 49; Lord Prys-Davies, solicitor, 66; Paul Rutherford, singer, 30. 
 Another day. 
 December 8, 1924: I am at the moment just recovering from a heavy bout of drinking. 
 I had a good drinking evening with Alec, Terence, and Richard Greene. 
 Exactly a week later I suddenly went to Oxford by the most impossible train which stopped at every station. 
 I arrived at 10.30 and drove to 31 St Aldate's where I found an enormous orgy in progress. 
 Billy and I unearthed a strap and whipped Tony. 
 Everyone was hideously drunk except strangely enough myself. 
 Next day I moved to 40 Beaumont Street and began a vastly expensive career of alcohol. 
 I had a dinner party. 
 I arrived quite blind after a great number of cocktails at the George with Claud. 
 Eventually the dinner broke up and Claud, Roger Hollis and I went off for a pub-crawl which after sundry indecorous adventures ended up at the Hypocrites where another blind was going on. 
 Poor Mr Macgregor turned up after having lain with a woman but almost immediately fell backwards downstairs. 
 I think he was killed. 
 Next day I drank all the morning from pub to pub. 
 I ate no lunch but drank solidly. 
 I then drank double brandies until I could not walk&hellip; 
 I fell out of a window and then relapsed into unconsciousness punctuated with severe but well-directed vomitings. 
 I dined four times at various places and went to a drunk party at Worcester in someone's rooms I did not know. 
 On Wednesday I was sober. 
 Next day I lunched with Hugh &lsqb;Lygon&rsqb; and drank with him all afternoon and sallied out with him fighting drunk at tea-time when we drank at the New Reform until dinner. 
 (Diaries of Evelyn Waugh: Weidenfeld and Nicolson, 1975). 
 Eco Soundings. 
 By John Vidal 
 It's all terribly well the BBC congratulating themselves on their magnificent wildlife films but the huge &bquo;movie theme park&equo; they are planning for Rainham Marshes in Essex should comprehensively destroy yet another Site of Special Scientific Interest. 
 What is now home to the rare hen harrier, the short-eared owl and 170 species of birds, will shortly become the habitat of mechanical gorrillas, robot sharks and cheap imitations of nature as more than 70 per cent of the the 1200 acres are developed with prime riverside housing, studios and hotels. 
 Sounds like one for the Natural History Unit. 
 Think we've got problems? 
 A beach clean-up along 300 miles of Texas shoreline has turned up 15,600 plastic six-pack rings in 3 hours. 
 Magna charter. 
 EXTREME embarrassment in the lower orders of the DoE and DHSS by the Government's snub of the World Health Organisation's first-ever European Conference on Environment and Health. 
 While most of the 32 member states have sent very senior ministers to Frankfurt, the British have despatched Roger Freeman. 
 Who's he? 
 Oh, yes, the nonentity of a junior health minister. 
 And no-one at all from the DoE. 
 All this may have something to do with the conference's unpublicised preliminary meeting which was held in London at the beginning of October. 
 There, many Europeans could hardly believe their ears with the excuses of why the British would not want to sign a European Charter on Environment and Health. 
 &bquo;They kept talking about the Magna Carta. 
 Their ideas were at least 100 years old&equo;, complained one senior German at the time. 
 Free time. 
 FUNNY how religion is creeping into the environment debate. 
 Here's Mrs Thatcher molesting the Bible this week in a speech about pollution to a committee of legislators, industrialists and scientists: &bquo;Like the Garden of Eden to Adam and Eve anything which is given free is rarely valued&hellip;&equo; 
 Vox Pope. 
 AND, just for the record, here's the Pope's first pronouncement on the environment. 
 &bquo;It is manifestly unjust that a privileged few should continue to accumulate excess goods, squandering available resources while masses of people are living in conditions of misery. 
 Responsibility for protecting the environment and for limiting damage already inflicted, lies with the entire human community. 
 The right to a safe environment is ever more insistently presented today as a right that must be included in an updated Charter of Human Rights.&equo; 
 Since you ask, nothing at all about population. 
 GREAT statistics of our time. 
 Americans receive enough junk mail in one day to produce enough energy to heat 250,000 homes. 
 And 44 percent of it is never even opened or read. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE en2 
 Check-Up. 
 THE National Society for Epilepsy is offering a &bquo;respite care&equo; service for relatives providing round-the-clock care for a parent, son or daughter with epilepsy. 
 The service comprises one to two weeks at the Society's centre in Chalfont St Peter, Buckinghamshire. 
 Charges are &pound;375 per week. 
 Help with payment may be available from social services. 
 Details from Sunsan Milward, senior clinical nurse, Chalfont Centre for Epilepsy, Chesham Lane, Chalfont St Peter, Bucks (Tel: 02407 3991). 
 THE National Information Forum is drawing up a directory of hospital-based services for disabled people. 
 Details to the Disabled Living Foundation, 380-384 Harrow Road, London W9 2HH (Tel: 01-289 2791). 
 ALEAFLET on how to help a diabetic person with an insulin reaction is now available (20p plus SAE) from the British Diabetic Association, 10 Queen Anne Street, London WIM OBD. 
 Self Help. 
 (An alphabetical directory of self-help groups) British Kidney Patients Association, Bordon, Hampshire GU35 9JP (Tel: 04023 2021/2) Aims: To give information and support to patients and their families. 
 Also operates holiday dialysis centres. 
 British Library of Tape Recordings for Hospital Patients (now known as the National Listening Library), 12 Lant Street, London SE1 1QH (Tel: 01-407 9417). 
 Aims: To provide tapes to all hospitals, residential homes and homes for the handicapped. 
 For &pound;15 a year members receive as many tapes as they want. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Low-pressure pubs for a high old time Daedalus. 
 By David Jones 
 ONE OF the few things you can do more efficiently in an aircraft than anywhere else is get drunk. 
 The cabin is usually stabilised at less than atmospheric pressure, so its air has less oxygen than usual. 
 Your body burns alcohol more slowly, so a little drink can get you seriously sloshed, and you stay that way longer. 
 No wonder the airlines vie with each other to advertise their copious offerings of wine. 
 To bring the same advantages to earthbound drinkers, Daedalus is inventing a low-pressure pub. 
 The building will need to be carefully leak-proofed against the outside air, and customers will have to enter by an air-lock. 
 The beer, its bubbles expanded by the reduced pressure, will be fizzier than ever and magically intoxicating. 
 Rowdy customers will be hard to throw out through the double pressure doors of the air-lock, but at closing time Daedalus will reverse the pumps and take the pressure up above atmospheric. 
 Not only will the beer suddenly go flat: the extra oxygen in the high-pressure air will rapidly burn the alcohol out of the client's bloodstreams. 
 Experienced topers will leave promptly, before their merry glow is chilled into doom-laden sobriety. 
 But Daedalus goes further. 
 He points out that an animal's life span is linked to its metabolic rate. 
 If you slow its metabolism by restricted diet, it will mature more slowly and live longer than normal: the clock of its life will slow down. 
 Since reduced pressure also slows the metabolic rate, it too should slow and lengthen a creature's biological career. 
 And if the principle works with man as well, then by spending your whole life in a cruising aircraft you might live to be a hundred. 
 Or perhaps it would only seem like that. 
 So Dreadco's physiologists are setting up a variable-pressure metabolic laboratory to study the matter. 
 Animals and human volunteers will be maintained at various atmospheric pressures and oxygen concentrations while their biochemistry is monitored. 
 Daedalus expects that his under-pressured volunteers will lose appetite and be quite happy on two meals a day, especially if he provides airline food. 
 But how to judge their rate of ageing? 
 Dreadco is appealing for middle-aged identical twins, one to live in the low-pressure laboratory and one outside, while microscopic examination compares the rate at which grey hairs appear on their scalps. 
 The effects of high pressures should also be interesting. 
 Metabolism may speed up sharply, so that obese volunteers would be swiftly &bquo;burnt down&equo; to normal weight. 
 Animals might mature faster: a pressurised poultry house, for example, could hurry chickens to earlier adulthood. 
 But apart from aircraft and submarines, few human environments could incorporate such refinements into their normal operations. 
 Daedalus is designing a novel house extension, a variable-pressure bedroom, which may purchase an extra few years of life for its proud owners by slowing the metabolic rate of that third of their lifetime which they spend asleep. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sc 
 Benn learning fast at new school. 
 By John Rodda in Las Vegas 
 THE maturing of Nigel Benn is an appropriate tale for the season of the transformation scene. 
 Before he was knocked down and beaten &mdash; for the first time &mdash; by Michael Watson, he was a brash product of black anger, a ghetto-blaster of the ring whose pantomime craftsmanship was redeemed by the crunching power of both fists. 
 But Watson did both Benn and British boxing a service. 
 Reassessment followed that defeat and brought a new direction with new people and a contract of &dollar;2 million for four fights over the next two years. 
 Benn was eager to get the taste of American boxing before he met Watson and the urge to find new experience brought the break, sad but needed, from the trainer who had brought him through from his amateur days, Brian Lynch. 
 While Lynch had developed his punching power, Benn needed boxing lessons and the time-honoured way of getting them is in sparring. 
 Under Lynch that was not part of the regime, which is regarded as a curious omission in most gyms, and it did not work for Benn. 
 Since moving into a gymnasium in Florida and working with Vic Andreetti, a former British champion from the East End of London, Benn has taken on a new mantle. 
 Now he is just flattered by the label &mdash; &bquo;the British Marvin Hagler&equo; &mdash; which Bob Arum, the American promoter investing that &dollar;2 million, has tagged on him; previously he would have been angry that he himself had not invented it. 
 &bquo;After a few days in the gym here I would wake up and hope that the sparring partners would not turn up. 
 It was hard and they hurt, but you soon learn to accept it and respect them as they do you. 
 All that tap, tap work in England was no good; there I was always the governor, now I'm learning all the time, nicking moves from everyone,&equo; he said. 
 Last weekend he despatched Jose Quinones, a shot fighter, in one round. 
 Next month he faces another man who has seen better days, Michael Olajade, a Nigerian born in Britain. 
 Olajade was going places until he was badly beaten by Michael Nunn, but he will provide Benn with fighting experience. 
 &bquo;From now on my home is in England, but the business of boxing will be here,&equo; he said. 
 The Arum plan is for him to fight Iran Barkley in London in April, but that is dependent upon his dealing competently with Olajade and Barkley defeating Doug de Witt in Atlantic City the night Benn's contest takes place there. 
 Dutch plan for sitting room only. 
 THE Dutch plan to do away with standing room at national league grounds within the next 10 years. 
 As part of their attempt to rid themselves of a growing hooligan problem, the clubs agreed on Wednesday to begin converting their grounds into all-seat stadiums and to petition the government for grant aid. 
 &bquo;We're going to do away with standing places, with a 10 per cent cut in the number each year over the next decade,&equo; a Dutch association official said yesterday. 
 There is only one all-seat stadium in the Netherlands &mdash; at Utrecht &mdash; and many grounds have extensive standing areas. 
 PSV Eindhoven's stadium, for example, has standing room for 12,000 supporters out of a capacity of 28,000. 
 Dutch football has been increasingly dogged by hooliganism over the past few years. 
 This season Ajax Amsterdam were banned from European competition for a year after fans hurled iron stakes on to the pitch and forced the abandonment of a Uefa Cup tie in September. 
 The following month 14 fans were injured when Feyenoord fans threw fragmentation bombs at Ajax supporters at a game in Amsterdam. 
 Japan wants to stage the World Cup in 2002. 
 The Japanese FA is to initiate a programme of stadium-building before the choice is made in seven years' time. 
 World Cup amnesty. 
 WORLD Cup organisers have granted an amnesty to players who received yellow cards for fouls and other offences during qualifying matches. 
 Hermann Neuberger, the chairman of the International Football Federation World Cup organising committee, said players who had been shown the yellow card once during qualifying games would not have to carry it over to the finals. 
 Players with two yellow cards would be able to sit out the subsequent one-match suspension during an international friendly before the 24-nation tournament, Neuberger added. 
 But he said that the amnesty would not cover players who had been shown the red card and sent off for serious offences during qualifying games. 
 They will have to sit out remaining match suspensions when the finals begin on June 8. 
 Fifa officials could not immediately say how many players would benefit from the yellow-card amnesty, but confirmed that at least three players would be suspended for one World Cup match after receiving red cards. 
 They were named as Romario of Brazil, Stanislav Griga of Czechoslovakia and Gheorghe Hagi of Romania. 
 Two other players, Abdul Razaq Ibrahim Albalooshi, of the United Arab Emirates, and Mehmed Bazdarevic, of Yugoslavia &mdash; who has a year's ban &mdash; could also be suspended for red-card offences if appeals were unsuccessful, the Fifa officials added. 
 Beardsley, Pearce and Adams are the three England players who received yellow cards during qualifying matches. 
 Ireland had six offenders: Whelan, Townsend, Aldridge, Stapleton, McCarthy and Houghton (two). 
 The amnesty is particularly good news for Houghton, who picked up his second yellow card of the qualifying tournament in Malta last month and feared that he could miss the opening game in Italy. 
 Now it seems likely that he will instead miss Ireland's next match, against England in Dublin on March 28. 
 Rickett rises from depths. 
 KATIE RICKETT, the surprise selection in Britain's team to play the United States in the Maureen Connolly Trophy match at Cardiff, was beaten 1-6, 7-6, 5-7 by Elly Hakami yesterday. 
 At one time Hakami was ranked 32nd in the world, and her 21-year-old opponent from Birmingham often looked out of her depth, especially in a 27-minute first set. 
 Rickett, to the surprise of the gallery, turned the match round by winning a marathon second set after leading 3-1 and trailing 3-4 before Hakami served for the match at 5-4. 
 She failed, only for Rickett to miss five set points in the 12th game. 
 PAGE 
 Japan doubles Van Rensburg's troubles. 
 By Martin James 
 CHRISTO VAN RENSBURG, one of the world's leading doubles players, went on court at the Albert Hall yesterday believing he would be competing for the last time in the official season-ending doubles championship. 
 But not of his own volition. 
 Next year the Nabisco Masters doubles changes its name to the ATP doubles finals. 
 It also changes venues, and that is where Van Rensburg thinks his problems could lie. 
 The event has been staged at the Royal Albert Hall for four years. 
 Next year it will move to either Japan or Australia. 
 &bquo;As a South African I am not allowed to play in Japan,&equo; said Van Rensburg, who partners Paul Annacone. 
 &bquo;I understand it's hard for the organisers because they have to go where they can find the biggest sponsor. 
 But South Africa is not going to change because of me.&equo; 
 Van Rensburg and other South Africans on the tour are barred from playing in more than 20 countries. 
 However, late last night the organisers were still considering the Australian bid. 
 The South African-American pair are virtually out of contention for this year's title. 
 Yesterday they lost for the second time when they fell 6-7, 7-6, 6-3, 6-4 to Todd Witsken of the United States and Jorge Lozano of Mexico. 
 They now have only one round-robin group match left to make amends. 
 It was not a good day for the more established pairings. 
 The defending champions Jim Pugh and Rick Leach also lost their second successive round-robin group encounter and were left to play off for the minor placings. 
 In the early hours of yesterday morning they were beaten in four sets by Patrick McEnroe and Jim Grabb, and then some 13 hours later they fell 6-3, 7-6, 7-6 to the Australians Darren Cahill and Mark Kratzman, who as a result qualified for the semi-finals. 
 The Australians' red group counterparts, McEnroe and Grabb, also reached the last four when they brushed aside their fellow Americans Jim Courier and Pete Sampras 6-2, 6-3, 6-3. 
 Snooker Mountjoy deepens Thorne's gloom. 
 By Clive Everton 
 THE Everest World Matchplay Championship, restricted to the 12 players who earned most ranking points last season, began at the Brentwood International Centre yesterday with Doug Mountjoy trouncing Willie Thorne 9-2. 
 Thorne, the world No.9, admitted after a lacklustre display last night: &bquo;This has been the worst year of my life.&equo; 
 Terry Griffiths beat Clive Thorburn 9-5, the first time he had beaten the Canadian in nine attempts. 
 The televised phase of the competition begins tomorrow with Steve Davis opening the defence of his title against the winner of today's match between Dean Reynolds and Tony Meo. 
 A repeat of the Stormseal UK final between Davis and Stephen Hendry is on the cards. 
 Gavin Lightman QC, the World Professional Billiards and Snooker Association's one-man disciplinary tribunal, announces his findings today on two charges of bringing the game into disrepute. 
 Alex Higgins brought a complaint against his former manager, Howard Kruger, and Higgins himself is the defendant in a charge arising from recent incidents at Stoke and Reading. 
 Rusch de Farges will take his chance on fast ground. 
 By Chris Hawkins 
 IF MARTIN Pipe has a Gold Cup horse in his yard this season it is probably Rusch de Farges and there will be plenty of interest in this exciting young horse when he reappears in tomorrow's A.F. Budge Gold Cup at Cheltenham. 
 Despite worries expressed by connections last weekend about the fast ground, a stable spokesperson confirmed yesterday that Rusch de Farges will run under top weight of 11st 10lb. 
 This means an all round rise of 4lb, with the original top weights, Barnbrook Again and Golden Freeze, coming out, both on account of the ground. 
 Rusch de Farges, an ex-French gelding, won two of his six races last season both in soft ground and put up his best effort when beaten three lengths by Barnbrook Again at levels in the Arlington Chase Final over two and a half miles at Cheltenham last January. 
 He has some improving to do if he is to develop into a genuine Gold Cup hope but being only a six-year-old and trained by the man who has turned the joke &bquo;the impossible we do at once, miracles take a little longer.&equo; 
 into reality, he is quite likely to make the grade. 
 The dry weather continues to affect racing and Oliver Sherwood will not run Tonights The Night in the A.F. Budge Chase. 
 A decision on Cruising Altitude's participation in the Bula Hurdle will be made after the trainer has spoken to the jockeys at today's meeting. 
 Cruising Altitude was so impressive in beating Morley Street at Newbury that he has been backed down to 8-1 for the Champion. 
 A race betweeen him, Beech Road and Floyd in the Bula would have been particularly informative but of that trio only Floyd is a certain runner now. 
 At Cheltenham this afternoon the big race is the Final of the BMW Chase series. 
 Once again the ground has ruined what promised to be a good contest and only four of the 15 entries go to post. 
 Nicky Henderson's Wont Be Gone Long (2.20) has top weight but is not badly treated considering he beat Lockwood Prince by 15 lengths at Chepstow last May and meets him here on the same terms. 
 As he showed all his form on fast ground last season he will not be bothered by the going but he has to give 15lb to Bonnie Artist. 
 It is dangerous to oppose any of Arthur Stephenson's runners at the moment but Bonnie Artist, although he has won four in a row, has not beaten anything of real ability. 
 Stephenson also sends Durham Edition down for the Food Brokers Ferrero Rocher Handicap Chase but due to defections the weights go up 14lb and he is topweight with 11st 10lb. 
 Durham Edition ran a fair race to finish just under eight lengths fourth to Ghofar in the Hennessy and he must come into the reckoning, although the weight rise seems to give an advantage to Royal Cedar (2.55), who was originally 8lb out of the handicap. 
 Royal Cedar, trained by John McConnochie, who has taken him over from the now retired Mercy Rimell, is another who is perfectly at home on fast ground, winning here over three and a half miles and at Newbury this season. 
 On his reappearance run when ooking backward, he led until falling seven out in the race won by Seagram, who meets him on 2lb better terms now and is thus entitled to start favourite. 
 Doncaster has been similarly decimated and only seven go to the post in three races worth a total of &pound;11,246. 
 Croghan Star (2.00) and On Tap (2.30) should prove too good for their solitary opponents, while Wigtown Boy (3.05) has only two to beat in the Red Alligator Handicap Chase. 
 Devon is always a happy hunting ground for Pipe, who has saddled twice as many winners as any other trainer in the last five years here. 
 He should score with Blake's Progress (12.45), Maintown (1.15) and North Lane (2.45) today. 
 After three winners yesterday, he is only seven short of his century, while Jonothan Lower maintained his strike rate on the Pipe horses with a Taunton double on The Leggett and Ambassador, giving him 21 winners from just 34 rides. 
 Worthless words from mumbling shamateurs The Keating Column. 
 By Frank Keating 
 SAVING the punchline till last, just about the best joke of a pretty unfunny decade comes in its dying days. 
 A suited smart alec, riding shotgun on rugby union's suddenly careering shamateur bandwagon, this week told a group of British international players that they should soon be able to charge &pound;1,500 for a solitary interview. 
 The mind boggles. 
 I cannot remember us jabber of journos enjoying a joke more. 
 Press interviews with the rugger-buggers are almost a contradiction in terms &mdash; even the official, collective, post-match post-mortems after home internationals, down in the bowels of Twickenham or Cardiff, say. 
 These occasions are only for humorists who enjoy the captains' and coaches' mumbled no-comments, and pusillanimous platitudes from grown men. 
 OK, it might be a trifle unfair to cite such post-game bunfights. 
 But what about the one-on-one interview? 
 Any journalist will tell you that British rugby union players, with two or three beguiling exceptions, are hardest to get anything out of worth printing. 
 Few seem to have anything remotely interesting to offer on the philosophy, flavours, fads or fancies of their game. 
 Yet now they are told they can expect to pocket &pound;1,500. 
 They'd better get their act together first. 
 Perhaps they are thinking of the soaraway end of the market? 
 Even more of a no-go area, I'm afraid. 
 Very few of those who write the terrible tabloids, let alone those who read them, are likely to have heard of these &bquo;internationally famous&equo; sportsmen, so I doubt if they'd make half of &pound;1,500 even for such tales as Flanker Star Ate My Goolie During Scrum, by England's Ugliest Prop; or Sexy Secrets in the Showers, by Welsh Tea Lady. 
 What, anyway, makes British rugby players plan to price themselves at such a princely paypacket? 
 Just for one interview, dammit. 
 Like other fellow scribblers whose squiggles seriously abuse the very title &bquo;shorthand notebook&equo;, I have nevertheless been generously given hours, sometimes even days, by sportsmen happy enough to rabbit on without so much as a penny piece being mentioned. 
 Start with the beginning of this decade if you like, when the one and only Muhammad Ali personally escorted me round every nook and cranny of his Deer Lake log-cabin home. 
 Not the slightest mention of money, either, for an interview in depth from, offhand, Gavaskar, Richards, Botham, Willis, Marshall, McEnroe, Connors or Borg &mdash; though the latter, I must admit, was expecting me to stay the day, yet by elevenses we agreed there was not much more to say to each other except &bquo;My game's in pretty good shape&equo;. 
 Did Nicklaus ask for &pound;1,500 for a chat? 
 No, he asks you to please stay for supper and we'll go on in the morning. 
 Did Lee Trevino say &bquo;How much?&equo; 
 Of course not. 
 Nor anyone &mdash; not one &mdash; down the years, when I've approached such luminaries of the lore as, well, Ashe, Stewart, Prost, Platini, Charlton, Best (he even cooked me breakfast), Coe, Thompson, Cauthen, Francome&hellip; 
 This year alone &mdash; the sad one in which British rugby players are apparently rubbing their hands in greedy but pitful expectation &mdash; I've relished long, doubtless tedious (for them) but totally gratis and generous interviews with the likes of Scudamore (on his most precious mid-season afternoon off), Offiah, Gower, Gooch, Border, Simpson, Jacklin, Robson, the teenage millionaire Chang; and even Mansell took a day off to drive me round and round Silverstone. 
 So why is this international superstar of the scrummage, who I agree is a household name and all that (although he is known even in the next village as either Whatsit? or Thingymabob), suddenly being advised he has the (to coin a phrase) clout and muscle to alter the long-established formulas and ethics of sports journalism? 
 In other words, just who do these jokers and the jerks pulling their purse-strings think they are? 
 Oh dear, even before they open it, poor Twickenham's can of beans is beginning to pong something rotten. 
 The hilarity induced, however, should run and run. 
 Mason cuts a battered but defiant figure. 
 GARY MASON, booed, bruised and bloodied from his encounter with a &bquo;hand-picked&equo; opponent, will allow Terry Lawless to choose his next bout. 
 But he says he would welcome another Mark Wills or a match with Derek Williams. 
 Mason needed an X-ray on his right hand and repairs around both eyes after being taken the full distance by Wills on Wednesday night, but his heart and ambition remain undamaged. 
 He still wants to fight Mike Tyson in about 18 months. 
 And he was encouraged by the way he came through the first 10-round contest of his 33-fight unbeaten career. 
 &bquo;People didn't believe I could go beyond seven or eight rounds without blowing out,&equo; said Mason. 
 &bquo;I wasn't 100 per cent sure myself. 
 But I have now, and it has enhanced my confidence.&equo; 
 The X-ray showed nothing more than bruising. 
 And the video recording he watched yesterday morning revealed to him rather fewer weaknesses than his critics had discerned. 
 &bquo;I'm disappointed with the criticism I got, stuff like I looked light years away from Tyson,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It was a battle, but I wanted a battle and I want more of them.&equo; 
 His hand, the same one he injured in April last year, needs at least two weeks' rest, but he should be back in the ring in February. 
 Jarvis Astaire, the Wembley director and promoter, is hoping for an opponent like Trevor Berbick or James &bquo;Bonecrusher&equo; Smith, both former world champions. 
 Williams, who beat Trevor Currie on Tuesday night to add the European championship to his Commonwealth title, may have to wait for his shot at the British champion, though Mason rises to his former sparring partner's rhetoric. 
 &bquo;I would like to beat him because of what he has been saying about me,&equo; Mason said. 
 &bquo;All I'll say is that only a foolish dog barks at a flying bird.&equo; 
 Even at his fittest the 17 &frac12;-stone Mason would have difficulty passing as a flying bird. 
 If he ever goes in with Tyson, he could be taken for a foolish dog. 
 Hockey Lahore XI 1, England XI 1. 
 Cotton fumes as England are suffocated by umpires 
 ENGLAND's visit to Pakistan may well be remembered mostly for the umpiring. 
 England felt they suffered again yesterday. 
 Bernard Cotton, the England manager, forcefully expressed the view that England failed to beat the Lahore XI because the Pakistani umpires did not award them the penalty corners and strokes they had earned. 
 &bquo;We created enough opportunities to have won handsomely,&equo; he said. 
 England rested Potter and Clift and played Soma Singh at centre-half against largely unknown opponents. 
 The team played better but failed to profit from their many spells of domination. 
 Rob Hill, one of England's relative newcomers, gave them the lead, following up at a 10th-minute penalty corner, but the team allowed themselves to become rattled by the umpiring and Lahore equalised after 50 minutes. 
 Cherzeel scored with a close copy of England's goal. 
 The coach, Norman Hughes, said he was pleased with the play of Soma and much of England's build-up play and felt the second-half changes made a significant impact. 
 Garcia and Potter came on for Leman and Halls in the 45th minute and Welch replaced Williams seven minutes later. 
 England play Pakistan again today in the final match of the tour, writes Pat Rowley. 
 England players involved in the postponed fourth-round cup ties on Sunday will have about 30 hours to recover from their overnight journey home. 
 It will be interesting to see how that affects the players of the First Division clubs East Grinstead, Havant and Hounslow. 
 Nearly half the Havant team are in Pakistan. 
 Their home tie with Barford Tigers, a team who have had excellent results in the Midlands League in recent weeks, may require them to recover quickly from their overseas exertions. 
 Hounslow, the holders, who will welcome back Jon Potter and Martyn Grimley, face a first meeting with another Middlesex club, the new Second Division side, Lyons. 
 Lyons' cause cannot have been helped by the red card received by one of their skilful full-backs, Jasminder Matharu, in the league last Saturday. 
 Matharu is likely to incur a suspension of two or three months. 
 The other cup tie on Sunday pits Eastcote of the South League against East Grinstead at Feltham School. 
 The fitness of Clift and Leman, who has had influenza in Pakistan, is important for Grinstead. 
 Eastcote, who have just acquired an Australian coach, Mark McCrea, have a team who are almost entirely the product of their successful colts scheme. 
 The other outstanding cup tie, between Old Loughtonians and Broxbourne, has been arranged for Sunday week because Broxbourne are involved in the last of the East qualifiers for the Royal Bank English Indoor Championship. 
 Hull put Proctor on list at &pound;15,000. 
 HULL yesterday placed their forward Wayne Proctor, who toured with Great Britain in 1984 and was substitute against Papua New Guinea, on the transfer list for &pound;15,000, writes Paul Fitzpatrick. 
 Also on offer, at the same price, are Neil Puckering, who played four times for the Great Britain Under-24 side, and Alan Tomlinson. 
 Swinton have reduced the asking price on six players, including the winger Derek Bate, who has had his price cut from &pound;45,000 to &pound;35,000. 
 Castleford have placed their winger Chris Chapman on the transfer list at &pound;45,000. 
 Squash Absent Cumings faces disciplinary action. 
 By Richard Jago in Newcastle 
 ALISON CUMINGS, a former British title-holder, faces disciplinary action from the Squash Rackets Association for withdrawing from this year's national championships at Newcastle yesterday &bquo;because of an unfavourable draw which might have meant me losing money on the week.&equo; 
 Her action has again raised the issues of lack of sponsorship and reduced prize money which have preoccupied many leading players. 
 Geoff Williams, another former holder, and Phil Whitlock, an England international, have both declined to play because they are disappointed with the marketing of the championships and by the fact that the prize fund has descended from &pound;16,780 to &pound;9,000 despite the presence of television. 
 Another international, who preferred to remain anonymous, claimed that two thirds of the top 24 would have gone on strike had they been asked, and that a players' union will soon be formed to help deal with matters such as prize money, rankings, training and selection. 
 Four years ago seven leading men threatened to boycott the event because they considered the prize money too low. 
 If a union creates a better understanding, so much the better. 
 The SRA has put several thousands of pounds into this year's event and believes that the failure to acquire a sponsor is related to an adverse market. 
 &bquo;Over the years the players have done incredibly well from the national championships and have had higher prize money than a lot of international events,&equo; said the SRA's squash manager, Andrew Shelley. 
 &bquo;We are mystified at Alison's action because she had already entered. 
 I'm afraid I don't regard being unable to make money from the event as a reasonable excuse.&equo; 
 One of the North of England's leading women players, Julie Woodcock, 23, the Cheshire champion, from Northwich, has been killed in a car accident near Buxton, Derbyshire. 
 Jones searches for chinks of light in a dark age for women's tennis David Foot on a former champion and her bright sparks aiming high in Cardiff. 
 WOMEN's tennis in this country is apt to be seen as a jokey disaster area, lost cause and eternal outlet for false and flimsy dreams. 
 Amid these cliches, sly slanders and unavoidable realities, Ann Jones sits at the net and ponders. 
 She has watched and sighed at the conveyor belt of busted rackets and aspirations &mdash; as successive decades of dewy-eyed schoolgirls have emerged from the manicured suburban court retreats in the romantic search for more than strawberries at Wimbledon. 
 The National Sports Centre for Wales, Sophia Gardens, Cardiff is temporarily deserted between matches in the Maureen Connolly Trophy. 
 Ann Jones is the Great Britain captain, soon we imagine to succeed Sue Mappin as national women's team manager. 
 She is both martinet and mother hen. 
 And she is engagingly old-fashioned in her concepts. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid we've gone a bit too soft,&equo; she says with almost Blimpish fervour. 
 &bquo;Girls come up against an obstacle or two, maybe on tour, and they tend to give way instead of trying to overcome them.&equo; 
 She contemplates a surprisingly bellicose analogy: &bquo;sport in its own way is another war &mdash; somehow we must regenerate the old fighting spirit.&equo; 
 She is privately perturbed, though not entirely unsympathetic one suspects, with recent words of disenchantment from Valda Lake, the 21-year-old Devonian who feels there may in future be more joy, if less money, in being an art student. 
 Lake's sentiments looked pretty damning in print. 
 But in the artificial, unrelenting competitive world of perpetual travel and token nods across the net, there isn't too much time &mdash; or inclination &mdash; left over for real friendship. 
 Who can see Martina sharing a dinner party with Steffi? 
 Jones, Wimbledon winner, respected referee and, just as significantly, mother of three, confines herself to: &bquo;It's very tough, not helped in our girls&equo; case by the computer. 
 Those in the States may have to travel long distances for tournaments but it's still in their own country.&equo; 
 On the broader issue of Britain's minimal success &mdash; despite two successive triumphs against the rankings in the Maureen Connolly Trophy, at the Queen's Club, London, and at Dallas &mdash; the captain spreads her hands, searching one empty base-line and then the other for the elusive answer. 
 &bquo;If only we knew why, we'd do something about it. 
 Whatever some think, we don't sit back. 
 People criticise the LTA but we've really tried. 
 It's been very gratifying to win these last two trophies &mdash; yet disappointing that there hasn't been improvement in the general standard of our girls&equo; tennis afterwards.&equo; 
 The captain has the kind of severe, rather schoolmarmy face that readily softens. 
 &bquo;Just like Sue, she doesn't mince words,&equo; someone says under her breath. 
 But she's refreshingly strong on psychology. 
 &bquo;In a team event like this, the difficulty from my point of view is the varying personalities of the girls as they go into the consecutive matches. 
 Val, for instance, needs chatting up&hellip; 
 Sarah needs concentration&hellip; 
 Clare is well motivated, one of those who takes advice quite well.&equo; 
 Off court, handling the obligatory press conference, these still young competitors are almost without exception pleasant and self-possessed. 
 The same goes for Americans like 16-year-old Kim Kessaris. 
 Sarah Loosemore is Britain's youngest at 18, just back from her three A levels and injury, eager to prove she has never really been away. 
 Her home is 10 minutes away, here in Cardiff. 
 Her parents, dad a solicitor and mum a former Welsh international, are watching with her brother as she beats Jennifer Santrock. 
 Lake, who is getting out, has taken a bit of a battering and feels that her spontaneous outpourings the other day were probably misconstrued. 
 &bquo;The trouble is that there is such a high level of expectancy,&equo; she says. 
 This was compounded in her case when she jumped 20 places on the world computer in 1987 after reaching the third round at Edgbaston. 
 Today Great Britain's No.1 for the Trophy, Clare Wood, a vicar's daughter from Sussex, takes on Amy Frazier, who is 140 places above her in the rankings. 
 She's heartened by her win over the Americans' No.2 Audra Keller, who also outranks her, on Wednesday. 
 &bquo;I desperately wanted to go on the circuit &mdash; I still find the life terrifically exciting. 
 It's difficult to keep in touch with friends and I know I can't go wild socially. 
 But as long as I go on improving and enjoying myself I'll play. 
 &bquo;I've noticed the difference in the mental approach of the foreigners. 
 They seem much more secure, happier with themselves. 
 They don't worry like we seem to but don't ask me why. 
 I was a bit surprised at what Valda said. 
 Relationships are often shallow but that's inevitable, especially between the countries. 
 There has got to be rivalry and life can be very frustrating.&equo; 
 Women's tennis has always had its administrative uncertainties. 
 This week the future structure of the Wightman Cup is being discussed. 
 But here at Sophia Gardens, a nap hand of British girls have in their different ways been doing their best to tell us something about the game they play&hellip; and offering a few hints of hope for the future. 
 Dave Whelan, 53, who played for Blackburn Rovers and broke a leg in the 1960 FA Cup final, has offered &pound;100,000 to any youngster born within 10 miles of Wigan parish church who wins the junior Wimbledon title in the next 10 years. 
 Whelan, now a millionaire businessman, said: &bquo;A town that can produce world class rugby league and swimming stars should also be able to produce a tennis legend of the future.&equo; 
 Soccer Sardinia ceded to England's record. 
 By David Lacey in Rome 
 ENGLAND made their expected landfall in the 1990 World Cup yesterday, leaving Scotland and the Republic of Ireland to drift towards whatever fate the draw has in store for them in Rome tomorrow. 
 Bobby Robson's team, having been seeded at the head of Group F, will play their three first-round matches in Cagliari on the island of Sardinia. 
 Andy Roxburgh's Scots have been placed in the second-draw section, along with Spain, the Soviet Union, Austria, Yugoslavia and Holland. 
 Jack Charlton's Irish, in the finals for the first time, join Colombia, Uruguay, Czechoslovakia, Romania and Sweden in the third pool. 
 In the end, and in spite of prolonged speculation to the contrary, there was never much doubt either that England would be seeded or that they would begin the World Cup in Cagliari. 
 Turning Sardinia into a Mediterranean Alcatraz to prevent hooliganism would have looked a little silly if Belgium had gone there instead. 
 Bert Millichip, the FA chairman, claimed that the decision to seed England in Cagliari had been made purely for footballing reasons. 
 &bquo;It had nothing to do with security,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There was never any doubt that England would be seeded&hellip; &lsqb;it&rsqb; was based on our record in the last two World Cups. 
 &bquo;With all our problems, we have to be happy with the situation. 
 Sardinia is a lovely island. 
 Let's hope it's still a pleasant place when we leave it.&equo; 
 Spanish attempts to get themselves seeded ahead of England came to nothing. 
 &bquo;If Spain were upset,&equo; said Millichip, &bquo;they didn't say anything. 
 In fact on the basis worked out for the seedings, we came fifth out of six.&equo; 
 In spite of what Millichip believes, the need to minimise the possibility of trouble from England's fans has everything to do with their playing in Sardinia. 
 The Italian interior minister had already stipulated that this was the only way he could guarantee the security of the World Cup. 
 However, if England do progress beyond the opening round &mdash; and with the first two from each group plus the four best third-placed teams going through, it is going to take some wretched performances to fail &mdash; they will then travel to Bologna, Genoa or Turin for the second phase, with the prospect of visits to Naples, Rome or Florence in the quarter-finals. 
 The semi-finals will be in Naples and Turin with the final in Rome on July 8, so the further England go the more complex the security problem will be. 
 No England team have ever gone beyond the last eight in a World Cup played abroad, and the significance of their seeding this time will only become clear after tomorrow's draw. 
 However, they do know that winning Group F might give them an easier game in the second round (against the runners-up in Belgium's group) than they would earn by finishing second, when they would face the second-placed side in Argentina's group. 
 If they finish third they might have to play Brazil. 
 &bquo;There has been no manipulation of the seeding,&equo; Millichip insisted, sounding like a character from a Bateman cartoon (&bquo;The Man Who Thought The Draw Was Straight&equo;). 
 Maybe yesterday's groupings were not aually bent, just massaged to satisfy World Cup convention. 
 For example, Uruguay were put in the third pool to avoid a possible conflict of South American interests with Colombia. 
 Nobody will want Uruguay as third team in a group, least of all Scotland after their Mexican experience against them. 
 The Republic of Ireland could be in England's group, as they were in last year's European Championship. 
 Robson may prefer Colombians, Czechs or Romanians, and at least with the Swedes you can be reasonably sure of a goalless draw. 
 All the top seeds will want to avoid Holland, the European champions, and the Soviet Union, who finished runners-up. 
 But nobody will complain if they get Austria or Scotland, and Spain would be preferred to Yugoslavia. 
 Cameroun and South Korea are the teams to avoid from the fourth pool. 
 Certainly England will not complain if they are confronted with Costa Rica, and 1950 is a sufficiently dim memory now not to have bad vibes about the United States. 
 Yesterday's proceedings were not entirely cut and dried. 
 The organising committee took four hours to announce the seedings and draw order, much of the time being taken up trying to persuade West Germany, who had assumed they were going to Verona, to switch to Milan at the last moment. 
 The problem stemmed from Turin's &mdash; and therefore Fiat's &mdash; demand for an attractive seed to grace the city's new stadium. 
 Belgium did not fit the bill so it was decided to move Brazil (who were to have played in Milan) to Turin, bring West Germany to the rebuilt San Siro Stadium and send the Belgians to Verona. 
 The West Germans objected strongly but it was all smoothed over and so they will have a trio of Internazionale players &mdash; Matthaus, Klinsmann and Brehme &mdash; starting the World Cup on their home ground while Belgium, who at one stage were being threatened with Sicily, are at least promised the occasional cooling breeze in Verona. 
 Golf Hare coursing for a 66. 
 Rob Bonnet on the ordeal of qualifying school at La Manga 
 AT THE La Manga club in Spain this week there is not a hacking holidaymaker in sight. 
 Two hundred and eight golf professionals &mdash; some reigning champions, others young rookies &mdash; have been competing for 50 places on next season's full European Tour. 
 By Wednesday the 208 had been reduced by 100 after four rounds, the cut having come at four over par. 
 Later this morning, after two more rounds, a further 58 will be excluded. 
 Some of the 50 who win their cards are likely to have done so by surviving a sudden-death play-off: careers are launched, and sometimes sunk, on the accuracy of a three-foot putt on the 109th green. 
 Bad weather has prolonged the tension by half an extra day. 
 Among those already out of their misery is Richard Fish. 
 He is used to it, though; this is his 11th failure in 12 years of trying. 
 He missed the four-round cut by two strokes, but he left the course with a cheery &bquo;See you next year&equo;. 
 Jackie Nicklaus carries the burden of his father's name and knows it does not hit golf balls for him. 
 He too will have to try again. 
 Failure has driven some in the past to tears, but for the moment the 22-year-old Andrew Hare, from Sleaford, Lincolnshire, is quietly showing the bright-eyed optimism of the first-timer. 
 He made the cut by three strokes, and in qualifying for the final two rounds he has already guaranteed himself a place on next season's growing satellite tour, Europe's golfing second division. 
 That is already progress. 
 He only turned professional 12 weeks ago after helping to beat the United States in the Walker Cup this summer. 
 His amateur career started at the age of 12 with a father's encouragement and a set of women's irons. 
 Two and a half years later he was a four-handicapper, but then he broke his leg in two places playing football and missed a whole season. 
 His handicap went up to six. 
 He has not turned out for the village team since. 
 Hare's sights are set high, but he thinks it best not to listen to those who predict a bright future for him. 
 &bquo;I had a bonus at this year's Open, a practice round with my hero Bernhard Langer. 
 You expect fire to come out of the back of his ball when he hits it, but his ball's flight is no different to mine. 
 So it brings you on level terms.&equo; 
 Hare did admit to Ian Wright, who caddied for Seve Ballesteros, that he would feel intimidated if Wright carried for him at La Manga. 
 Wright told him: &bquo;Don't be so silly; it's immaterial.&equo; 
 His caddie instead is &bquo;Baldrick&equo;, Richard Owens from Sleaford who got his nickname from Hare's request on the practice ground for more ammunition. 
 Owens may not know the course intimately, but he knows Hare's game, which relies on consistent direction off the tee and accuracy on the green. 
 Here the latter has been wanting: &bquo;I know it sounds daft. 
 I've putted well but haven't holed anything.&equo; 
 Today's final cut for the last 50 seems likely to fall at one under par. 
 Hare will need a three-under in his final round to make it, but is aiming for a six-under 66. 
 As for the game itself, Hare has a philosophy which might make the rest of us win. 
 &bquo;No disrespect to a 20-handicapper. 
 When you watch them you think it almost looks pointless. 
 But it isn't; it's the good rounds that bring you back. 
 My lowest ever is a 62; my aim now is a 61. 
 The better you get, the more you want to play. 
 I love the game.&equo; 
 After yesterday's fifth round, four players shared first place. 
 Heinz Peter Thuel of West Germany, Steven Bowman of the United States and England's David Ray and Christopher Williams were 15 under par on 345. 
 Rob Bonnet is the BBC TV News sports correspondent. 
 South Africa's David Frost and the Americans Scott Hoch and Tim Simpson scored five-under-par 67s yesterday to share the lead after the first round of the Million Dollar Challenge at Sun City, Bophuthatswana. 
 Frost scored five birdies on the back nine to catch Hoch and Simpson. 
 They each had 32s on the front nine, including eagles at the par-five 9th, and 35s coming in. 
 No one else in the field broke par. 
 Wembley cuts ticket prices. 
 WEMBLEY has cut some of its ticket prices by half in an attempt to ensure a respectable crowd for England's friendly against Yugoslavia next Wednesday. 
 Seats in the new Olympic Gallery, which cost &pound;40 each for last month's game against Italy, have now been reduced to &pound;20. 
 The maximum price for other seats is &pound;15, with the cheapest at &pound;5. 
 Richard Gough will make his comeback for Rangers tomorrow only six weeks after shattering his jaw in four places. 
 The defender, hurt in a collision with Hibernian's Pat McGinlay, will be in the Scottish champions' line-up against Motherwell at Ibrox. 
 Boxing White Hopes like Cooney do not have a prayer of toppling Tyson. 
 John Rodda meets Max Schmeling, 85, and ponders: Where are his peers today? 
 THE oldest fight story of them all, the Great White Heavyweight Hope, has turned up here again. 
 Max Schmeling, who became the darling of the Nazi Party by being the first man to defeat Joe Louis, was feted in one of those boxing nostalgias which try, on the side, to thumb the nose at the American Medical Association and other such clinical societies concerned about brain damage. 
 Schmeling, a sprightly, dignified 85-year-old, is certainly an argument that some fighters come to no harm, even those who suffer the sort of beating Louis meted out when the pair met again. 
 Among those at the party was Muhammad Ali, who unlike Louis has, so far, not sunk to being doorman at Caesars Palace; he just stands in the Mirage Hotel at the head of a never diminishing human snake, signing his autograph. 
 Parkinson's Disease seems to be marking time at the moment. 
 With Ali at the honouring of Schmeling was Mike Tyson, a reminder that these days there is not much hope for any White Hope. 
 But a mile off The Strip, on a trading estate, the Top Rank gym bubbles with fighting action and gossip and, with a bit of a strain, the White Hope theory is being nurtured. 
 At 33, Gerry Cooney is cranking up to beat another golden oldie, George Foreman, who is 41, in Atlantic City next month under the promotion banner The Preacher and The Puncher. 
 Foreman, winner of three world heavyweight title fights in the early Seventies, is best remembered for his part in the one he lost: &bquo;The rumble in the jungle&equo; in Kinshasa, Zaire, when Ali knocked him out. 
 Now he is a minister of a church in Houston, where among the prayers he offers is one to be allowed to fight Tyson for the world title. 
 There are thousands, not of his flock, who are praying that he will not. 
 Cooney can fulfil their wish by cutting him down in their Atlantic City conflict, without inflicting the harm of which Tyson is capable. 
 Cooney always seemed a reluctant fighter, a man more pushed into the business by parental desire and promoters who saw the advantage of his size &mdash; 6ft 7in &mdash; rather than his personal predicament. 
 It is 2 &frac12; years since he lost in a world title match to Michael Spinks and just as he did after a similar fight, with Larry Holmes, he brooded for a long time, finally overcame problems with drugs, and went into business, part of which was as a fight promoter. 
 He put on one of the Foreman return contests &mdash; though even he would admit now that the word contest is stretching credibility. 
 For this latest return to the ring he has linked with Foreman's former trainer, Gil Clancy, who admits it is going to be hard getting Cooney back into shape. 
 He is using middleweight and light-heavyweight sparring partners in an attempt to make Cooney work faster, but in the session I watched he was not quick enough. 
 &bquo;It was one of those rough days,&equo; Cooney admitted with a bruise under his left eye and a shining, tight patch of skin on his very large nose. 
 His monotone drawl made one feel he is not yet convinced that he has the mental application to match his great physical ability. 
 Cooney cuts out talk about Tyson with: &bquo;I'll take one fight at a time.&equo; 
 But toppling Foreman will start a bandwagon at a time when, with one exception, the heavyweight division is bereft of talent and ability. 
 Territorial encroached on all fronts. 
 THE end may be in sight for the annual Territorial Championship, whose post-Christmas slot is the least acceptable in the women's fixture list. 
 The once eagerly awaited tournament, a highlight because of its purpose as England trials, is suffering the effects of progress, writes Janet Ruff. 
 No longer used for England selection purposes, the event has been trimmed, condensed and diminished, and apart from upholding a vestige of regional pride is now becoming lost in the mists of tradition. 
 The England training squad, with the World Cup on their minds, have been barred, and other players are pursuing alternative attractions during a well earned Christmas break. 
 The venue, Silksworth, near Sunderland, is as usual for this championship neither central nor convenient for the majority. 
 This year there is one further change, the backing of a sponsor, and the NatWest Cup to play for. 
 The tournament, which starts on December 28, is run concurrently with the Under-21 Territorial Championships, an event that has rather more significance as an England trials showcase. 
 The East, who have won the title for the past two years, are the defending champions and they select their squad this weekend, as do the South. 
 With their squads already chosen, the North, Midlands and West get down to concentrated coaching. 
 Rugby League Bettinson dismissal leaves doubt over Reilly. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 THE management team which has built the most successful Great Britain side since the Seventies was broken up yesterday with the dismissal of the 54-year-old Les Bettinson, team manager since 1985. 
 Malcolm Reilly, reported to be &bquo;shocked&equo; by Bettinson's dismissal, has been offered an up-graded title of coach/ manager while Maurice Lindsay, the Wigan chairman, replaces Bettinson and assumes the title of tour director and business manager. 
 Bettinson, a director of education in Stockport, had booked an appointment with his superior yesterday to ask for the unpaid leave he would have needed to complete the tour of Papua New Guinea and New Zealand next summer. 
 He was under the impression that the renewal of his contract was a formality. 
 Bettinson is a man of considerable dignity, diplomatic and not given to emotional language. 
 But he was a hurt and disillusioned man yesterday. 
 &bquo;Now I know how Julius Caesar felt on the steps of the Senate before he was stabbed in the back,&equo; Bettinson said. 
 There will be no shortage of sympathy for him. 
 Bob Ashby, the chairman, said that Bettinson's contract had expired &bquo;and we wanted the best man for the job&hellip; and that is Maurice. 
 His position on the board of directors is immaterial. 
 Maurice has a proven track record with Wigan&equo;. 
 Lindsay, who said that he had no idea he would be offered the job, pledged his support to Reilly, saying that he was &bquo;firmly behind the decision to ask Malcolm to continue as he is obviously the best man for the job&equo;. 
 Lindsay said that Reilly could rely on his &bquo;unswerving support as he is a man I have the highest respect for&equo;. 
 But will Reilly now accept the post? 
 What seemed a formality on Wednesday looked less certain 24 hours later, and he himself hinted at a possible obstacle when he said he would have to get the permission of his employers, the brewers John Smith. 
 If that permission were not forthcoming, he said, he would have to reject the job. 
 Then there is Phil Larder, the third member of the management team which led Great Britain to victory over Australia in Sydney last year and to a 2-1 series win over New Zealand recently. 
 It is not now certain that he will be invited to join the tour next summer, nor is it certain that he would accept if he were. 
 Rugby Union Harriman coughs, Smith wings in. 
 THE England and Wasps wing Simon Smith has been called up by London for their divisional match against the South-West at Imber Court tomorrow. 
 He replaces Andrew Harriman, of Harlequins, who became another flu victim. 
 Smith should have been on the bench for London's game against the Midlands last Saturday but had to drop out with the same complaint. 
 Midlands have also made a late change. 
 Tim Buttimore replaces Gary Hartley in the centre against the North at Moseley. 
 Hartley has infected vocal cords. 
 Buttimore has only recently returned to top rugby in England after two summers in Australia. 
 While there he was called up by the England squad when the touring team ran into injury trouble last summer. 
 Nigel Heslop of Orrell replaces Tony Underwood, who broke his jaw against the South-West last weekend. 
 The Neath lock Mike Whitson has been given an eight-week ban after being sent off in a Schweppes Cup tie against South Glamorgan Institute. 
 He was dismissed by the Brecon referee David Cherry for punching. 
 Whitson, who was also sent off while playing for Newbridge three years ago, will miss the next tie against Ystrad Rhondda and seven Merit Table club games. 
 Cricket Sky and BSB are at home. 
 By Mike Selvey 
 THE tentacles of satellite television are spreading even wider, even unto the English domestic scene. 
 Yesterday at Lord's the Test and County Cricket Board announced separate deals involving both Sky TV and British Satellite Broadcasting for the transmission of a large segment of the domestic game for the next three years. 
 In what can only be considered a plan of Baldrickian cunning, not only will the Board's coffers be groaning with the weight of money but &mdash; and here is the really clever part &mdash; fewer people than ever will now be able to observe what a mess the game is really in. 
 The deals are in fact important in the way the game is to be projected in the future in this country. 
 Already Sky TV is exclusively showing the winter series live from West Indies (with Geoff Boycott the newest recruit to the broadcasting team). 
 Now both Sky and BSB have extended their interests to include the 1990 and 1991 domestic seasons as well. 
 Perhaps the more significant of the deals is that involving BSB, which launches five new channels in the spring. 
 In a two-year deal, believed to be worth more than &pound;1 million, they will enjoy, if that is the right word, exclusive live coverage of the Benson and Hedges Cup as well as a highlights package including all England's home Tests, one-day internationals and the NatWest competition. 
 The latter package is designed to be broadcast during the peak viewing hours of 8pm and 10pm when the BBC has traditionally been unable to do it. 
 Andrew Croker, head of BSB's sports channel, sees this as a bonus for cricket fans. 
 &bquo;With the highlights package, now at last they will be able to see the best cricket at the time they will want to watch it.&equo; 
 Peter Lush, who handled the TV negotiations on behalf of the TCCB, added his support. 
 &bquo;The deal will benefit both the cricketing public and the Benson and Hedges competition, with more matches covered live and viewers enjoying a wider choice during peak hours.&equo; 
 The BBC still has its live coverage of the international matches and the NatWest Trophy, and it will also be screening highlights of the other matches but of necessity these will appear at the usual anti-social hours. 
 It is debatable whether Sky for its part has bought a pig in a poke. 
 It will be reviving memories of summers past by transmitting ball-by-ball coverage of the Refuge Assurance Sunday League. 
 In previous years this was how the BBC treated the competition, but gradually, with its revamped Sunday Grandstand, cricket took a back seat to free-fall dominoes and the like. 
 This appeared to please neither public nor sponsor. 
 Now Sky, with promised aggressive coverage, can put it back on an equal footing with the other competitions, although a more compelling argument for reviving the Sunday afternoon walk in the country it is hard to imagine. 
 Testing baptism for Chamberlain. 
 IF Frank Chamberlain, chairman elect of the Test and County Cricket Board, had any qualms about taking on the job next October, they will have been magnified by his introduction to the massed press at Lord's yesterday, writes Mike Selvey. 
 The first question he was asked was how he intended to overturn the &bquo;deceit and deception&equo; rife in the TCCB. 
 This turned out to be a reference to the secrecy surrounding the use of Ossie Wheatley's power of veto as chairman of the cricket committee to block the reappointment of Mike Gatting rather than David Gower as England captain last summer. 
 Chamberlain coughed politely and said he was sure it would be cleared up by the time he took over. 
 He said he would be trying to bridge the gap between the board and the counties, who he thought &bquo;perhaps felt they weren't having enough say.&equo; 
 Not least, it had been surmised, with the veto. 
 However the board's chief executive, Alan Smith, was able to say that unlike yesterday's press conference the issue at the board meeting did not occupy a major part of the time. 
 &bquo;They fully endorsed the right of Wheatley to use the veto at his discretion.&equo; 
 Smith added that the board did not subscribe to the view that the authority of Ted Dexter, chairman of the England Committee, and Micky Stewart, the team manager, had been undermined by the veto. 
 The nub of the meeting had been a lengthy discussion on the merits or otherwise of four-day cricket, while matters decided on were the 25-point penalty for producing inferior pitches, retained with wider definition to include over-grassed pitches; overseas players (counties may register up to two for next season only); a return to 15-yard run-ups in the Sunday League; and the making up of lost time in Tests to a maximum one hour. 
 Sport in brief Athletics. 
 Steve Jones will run for the first time in the Morpeth-Newcastle, Britain's oldest road race, on New Year's Day.. 
 Skiing. 
 Vreni Schneider, Switzerland's defending World Cup overall champion, could be out for two weeks after suffering a knee injury during downhill training in Colorado.. 
 Golf. 
 Britain's Chris Moody is joint second after yesterday's first round of the Australian Classic in Melbourne, where Peter Senior extended his remarkable run with eight birdies to lead with a seven-under-par 65. 
 Senior has won the Australian Open and Australian PGA title in the past month. 
 PAGE 
 Birdman Reed will not duck the issue David Hopps on the Aylesbury &bquo;Rambo&equo; who is set to ruffle Northampton's feathers. 
 THE only Aylesbury Ducks likely to be found at The County Ground tomorrow will be an increasingly celebrated strain decked in green and white hoops. 
 Aylesbury's footballers have progressed to the second round of the FA Cup &mdash; and an away tie at Northampton Town &mdash; without a flutter of recognition from the whiter-than-white duck which provides their nickname. 
 &bquo;Duckie&equo; Weston, a renowned local breeder, was an Aylesbury follower in his time, and one confused bird did waddle aimlessly around the ground a few seasons ago, but according to the club's chief executive, Tony Graham, &bquo;they are a devil of a mascot to parade about.&equo; 
 Could there be, though, a more sinister reason for tomorrow's absence of the Aylesbury duck? 
 Prepare for a far-fetched tale of a prospective bird-breeder called &bquo;Rambo&equo;, a burly former Yorkshire miner who admits he prefers his ducks buried under a mountain of cranberry sauce. 
 It was the fate of countless unfortunates a few seasons ago to become the terraces' substitute for Sylvester Stallone. 
 One jolting tackle and the link was made with the big screen's violent he-man. 
 Northampton Town's followers bestowed the well-meant, if dubious, honour on Graham Reed, a vigorous and gritty right-back. 
 Reed disarmingly describes himself as &bquo;nearly six feet tall and 13 stones when I'm at my best&equo;, but the banners appeared in force all the same. 
 Northampton romped away with the Fourth Division championship in 1986-87 and whenever Reed had an off-day his manager, Graham Carr, loved to scoff: &bquo;Rambo? 
 More like Bimbo.&equo; 
 Reed proved not indestructible. 
 His League career ended prematurely last season when he lost three pieces of bone in an operation on his right ankle. 
 Daily training became too demanding but non-League football offered an alternative outlet for a player approaching his 28th birthday and, in June he moved to Aylesbury. 
 With too much spare time suddenly on his hands, he reverted to a hobby enjoyed in his early non-League days with Frickley Athletic. 
 In Brixworth village, just outside Northampton, he has built an aviary at the bottom of the garden. 
 He keeps canaries, diamond doves and a pair of quails. 
 Aylesbury were taking stock of a cheerless season when Reed was signed by Trevor Gould, the elder brother of Wimbledon's manager, Bobby. 
 The club's first experience of the Vauxhall Conference had brought immediate relegation. 
 Traditionally members of the Southern (now Beazer Homes) League, they were allotted a place in the Vauxhall League, which they head by two points, and Gould takes a healthy smattering of former Northampton players back tomorrow. 
 The manager played more than 100 matches for the Cobblers in the early Seventies and, living three miles from the ground, he remains conveniently placed to keep tabs on potential signings. 
 Two months ago he paid Northampton a club record fee of &pound;15,000 for Glenville Donegal, and the striker's winning goal against Southend United in the FA Cup first round ensured an immediate homecoming. 
 Donegal was hardly overcome by romantic notions. 
 &bquo;My friends all say what a great draw it is, but I'm not sure,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I quite fancied going somewhere different.&equo; 
 Under Gould's guidance, Aylesbury's FA Cup record could hardly be more consistent. 
 They have reached the first round for the fifth successive year, although once admitted they initially quailed like nervous party-goers. 
 Watford drew a crowd of 7,500 to Turnfurlong Lane in 1951 and, by the time Gould broke a 34-year abstinence, plans were being formulated to turn the evocatively named ground into a housing estate. 
 Aylesbury lost a home replay to Slough in 85-86, fell at Bath the following year, then made a respectable 1-0 exit at Ashton Gate against Third Division Bristol City. 
 Last year they went one better, overcoming Waterlooville before losing 1-0 at home to Sutton in the second round. 
 Gould, a self-employed builder, put his craft to good use when Aylesbury transferred four years ago to waste ground off Buckingham Road, on the outskirts of the town. 
 The manager built both dugouts. 
 He must be a fair-minded fellow. 
 Rival managers have been relieved to confirm that the away dugout does actually face the pitch. 
 Crowds hover a touch above 1,000 this season but up to twice that number will make the trip to Northampton. 
 At least one banner will proclaim: &bquo;Rambo rules.&equo; 
 It will be carried by one of Reed's neighbours, a Northampton supporter. 
 He is still a child, but old enough to understand about old times' sake. 
 FOREST PEOPLE: Environment Guardian profiles Antonio Batista de Macedo Chico by the score. 
 By Alexander Shankland in Sao Paulo 
 TO THE Indians, he is Txai, a blood brother &mdash; the highest honour that can be conferred on a white man. 
 To the rubber-tappers, he is simply &bquo;Nosso Macedo&equo; &mdash; Our Macedo. 
 To both communities in Acre, the remote region of the Brazilian Amazon which achieved world wide notoriety when the union leader and ecologist Chico Mendes was murdered there almost a year ago, Antonio Batista de Macedo is the champion who carries the hope of salvation for their rainforest home. 
 More than anyone else, it was Macedo who made possible the realisation of his friend Chico Mendes's dream &mdash; the Forest People's Alliance. 
 The Alliance united the traditional communities of Amazonia (Indians, rubber-tappers, Brazil nut gatherers, fishermen) in a crusade to save the great forest with which they had lived in harmony for generations. 
 It was Macedo who brought together the Indians and Seringueiros (rubber-tappers), communities kept apart by a century of violence and mistrust. 
 A short, weatherbeaten 37 year old, Macedo speaks with the quiet deliberation which is the mark of the Amazonian. 
 He describes growing up in the village of the Kxinawa Indians by the Parauaca River, listening to tales of the massacres which marked the occupation of Acre a century ago at the height of the rubber boom. 
 And he describes the last 14 years of his life dedicated to overcoming the bitterness accumulated since the &bquo;rubber barons&equo; first reached the region, bringing with them thousands of labourers from Brazil's impoverished Northeast, who they set to work as Seringueiros in lands wrested from the Indians. 
 The message Macedo carried to the villages &mdash; most of them accessible only by boat or along tortuous jungle trails and scattered over an area larger than England &mdash; was that the forest's people should, in uniting, take control of their own destiny. 
 Indians and seringueiros alike had become the virtual slaves of the rubber barons and their descendants, who suppresed the indigenous people's culture and kept the imported labourers in debt bondage. 
 In 1975 Macedo, then in the employ of the government Indian service FUNAI (he left in 1980 after constant clashes with the agency's corrupt and deskbound chiefs), arrived in the remote Jurua valley, near the foothills of the Andes and Acre's western frontier with Peru. 
 He found a scene effectively unchanged since the rubber-seekers first arrived there at the turn of the century. 
 The Jurua was still distant from the devastation and conflicts brought by cattle ranchers from the South to eastern Acre, around Chico Mendes's home town of Xapuri. 
 It remained frozen in a feudal system which had decayed but not died with the end of the rubber boom. 
 Since Macedo's arrival, things have changed. 
 Under his tutelage, the Indians began to demand the rights over their lands which they had been guaranteed by Brazil's Constitution. 
 Over 60 descendants of the rubber barons, who continued exploiting the inhabitants, have been forced to leave. 
 Macedo's vision of preservation for the forest and its peoples is very different from the Utopian fantasies of many in the developed world who profess a passionate concern for Amazonia. 
 &bquo;Amazonia is nature's great monument,&equo; he says, &bquo;and we have to save her. 
 But it's crazy to want to preserve her people as they are now &mdash; poor, exploited, without schools or health care.&equo; 
 Macedo believes that uniting development and preservation is not only possible, but essential. 
 The symbol of this approach is the Extractive Reserve. 
 First championed by Chico Mendes, Extractive Reserves are areas where the forest is preserved for the use of its traditional inhabitants. 
 They harvest its riches without destroying the ecological balance. 
 Macedos's most ambitious project is the creation of such a reserve in the basin of the River Tejo, an area of rubber-rich forest in the Jurua which borders Indian lands and a newly-created national park. 
 The project is currently awaiting a green light from the government in Brasilia &mdash; which, aware of the need to counteract a reputation as the world's ecological villain has given it a favourable hearing. 
 If legal recognition is granted, the reserve and its neighbouring area will together represent a stretch of rainforest half the size of Wales, home to 10,000 families of seringueiros and Indians, set aside for preservation. 
 But Macedo's ideas go beyond that. 
 He insists that the Extractive reserves are viable economically as well as socially. 
 A market for these plants is opening up both in Brazil and abroad, and he urges investment in researching the forest's untapped potential. 
 Development will come, he says, but built on an understanding of the forest and not a brutal sacking of its riches. 
 Macedo's line is that of Chico Mendes, for whom saving the rainforest went hand in hand with saving the way of life of its people and improving their lot. 
 It is a line which has stirred up against Macedo the same emnities which led to Chico Mendes's murder. 
 He has already survived two attempts on his life. 
 Is he worried his end will be the same as Chico's? 
 &bquo;Yes, but in the end what can you do? 
 When they killed Chico, they transformed us into thousands of Chicos.&equo; 
 22COMMENT THE GUARDIANFriday December 8 1989 The last chance to join the team. 
 JACQUES Delors got the thrust of what needs to be done absolutely right yesterday. 
 We must, he said, speed up the construction of our &bquo;common home.&equo; 
 There was a clear imperative for the Strasbourg summit. 
 &bquo;We have to maintain the Community as a pole of attraction, as a stabilising factor. 
 It is our duty, and in our interest, to meet our historic responsibilities.&equo; 
 But the fact that Mr Delors is right does not mean that events will prove him right. 
 To the contrary, there is a growing, glum chance that events will pass him and the European Community by, for the speed of change in Eastern Europe &mdash; an East German head of state deposed on Wednesday, a Czechoslovak Prime Minister gone yesterday &mdash; has a bewildering momentum that quite outdistances the ability of any Council of Ministers to react. 
 Yet we are all prey to this speed of change. 
 Consider the coalition politicians who rule the economic core of the Community, West Germany. 
 They have an election to fight, next year. 
 The emotions unleashed as the Wall is dismantled are incalculable. 
 Who can wonder if they wobble back and forth between ten-point plans for confederal re-unification and loyalty to an immobilised Nato structure; between pounding on with monetary union and waiting to see what happens? 
 West Germany, as a nation, is being asked the most profound questions about the shape of things to come on its borders. 
 It would not, frankly, be totally surprising if &mdash; somewhere between Strasbourg this weekend and an EMU vesting date in the middle nineties &mdash; the tide of history began to dissolve the fabric of a Community built up over decades. 
 Nationalism &mdash; from Prague to Paris, from Berlin to Budapest &mdash; is a potent, perilous brew. 
 But it is, in this common enterprise, an enemy. 
 And here Britain may be the spectre at the Strasbourg feastings. 
 Mrs Margaret Thatcher has struck three notes since the Communist world began to disintegrate. 
 That this is Her Victory (self-serving grandiosity). 
 That what she said at Bruges, before any of it happened, was a tablet of stone &mdash; so that the nation state is the foundation of her Europe. 
 And that, frozen for ten or fifteen years, the countries of the East must painstakingly provide full democratic credentials before she allows them to move forward. 
 This is dangerous and foolish delusion. 
 No one, this week, can foresee the mood of East Germany next week. 
 No one can tell whether a corrupt and collapsing Communist party can retain any share in power. 
 And no one can predict whether free elections next year would not &mdash; the apotheosis of the Thatcher doctrine &mdash; produce a huge nationalist vote for confederal re-unification in fifteen months, not fifteen years. 
 History, said Mr Delors six weeks ago, &bquo;cannot wait.&equo; 
 It isn't waiting. 
 And none of us can slow it down. 
 Do not over-estimate the cards that Britain has to play at Strasbourg. 
 They are low value, from a peripheral hand. 
 The summit will not be all about Mrs Thatcher's ritual denunciation of the Social Charter, her contempt for the potential of the European Parliament, her denial that the time is right, her isolated war against any truck with monetary union. 
 The core for Europe is common cause between France and Germany as the &bquo;stabilising factor.&equo; 
 The question for Britain is one for us. 
 Do we want a role? 
 The broad Bruges argument is over. 
 It is lost. 
 It has no relevance to unfolding events. 
 That does not mean, for Britain, that all is lost, that we have no voice in affairs and no part to play. 
 We do &mdash; quite practically and with useful influence &mdash; if we choose to cast ourselves as a vigorous, amending, debating part of the European team. 
 But our Prime Minister has cast herself, and us, as something different: as the ranting outsider, as the pox on all other houses. 
 That is no part at all any longer. 
 It muddles facile loathing of a parody bureaucracy with the great issues of statesmanship. 
 Strasbourg is Mrs Thatcher's last chance to signal that she has seen the point and joined the team. 
 This time, history really cannot wait.. 
 Airing the bids. 
 MR DAVID MELLOR, the Home Office minister handling the Broadcasting Bill, is a civilised chap, the sort of Government minister you will find on a Friday night addressing the Putney Music Club on brilliant young musicians (Cantelli, Lipatti, Ginette Neveu) struck down in their prime. 
 As a television viewer his tastes run to Bruckner rather than Cilla Black. 
 So even if ministerial loyalties make it hard to admit it, he probably shares the apprehension which haunts many others as they contemplate this Bill: that though, at the end of the day, quantity will increase, quality will diminish; or to put it in a form of words which trips easily off Conservative lips on other occasions &mdash; that More is going to mean Worse. 
 The cause of this apprehension comes mainly from two linked provisions which, if the sceptics are right, will reinforce each other. 
 One is the requirement that contracts in the independent sector should go from now on (except in &bquo;exceptional circumstances&equo; and subject to minimum standard requirements) to the highest bidder: the other is the reduction in the programme obligations which at present safeguard the claim of minority programmes to television time. 
 The present system of allocations, in which some stately committee offers the franchise to the most persuasive (or plausible) claimant on the basis of pledges which may never be fulfilled, is, all agree, very near indefensible. 
 But a system in which those with the biggest moneybags automatically outpace others of greater experience, imagination, talent and future potential falls short of perfection too. 
 Some 60 per cent of Conservative MPs who took part in a recent Gallup survey thought standards would fall, not improve, if these changes took place. 
 Even the party leadership doesn't really believe that de-regulation is the best guarantee of the public good: if it did, it wouldn't have needed to call up Lord Rees-Mogg to police TV decency. 
 It would make better sense if the money which new contractors raised to sustain their bids were to go, as the Campaign for Quality Television (CQT) urges, into programme-making. 
 That might be some guarantee of bigger, better, more varied and more daring programming. 
 But so far the reverse is the case. 
 The substantial sums which back the successful bids will be pocketed by the Treasury. 
 The contractors, having racked themselves to the limit to fight off all other comers, may be forced to cut back on programme spending, to the detriment of exactly the kind of endeavours which may give delight to many but have no great appeal to the masses. 
 This is not just some fanciful theory. 
 Australian TV is at present in turmoil precisely as a result of desperate overbidding. 
 Mr Mellor may well be attracted by the CQT compromise, though the Treasury certainly won't be. 
 But if 60 per cent of Conservative members really believe that standards may suffer, the remedy's in their hands: they must use their corporate power to change the Bill for the better. 
 And if Mr Mellor insists, as he has done so far, that the auction solution is not open to revision, let them ask him, kindly but firmly, if such crude competition is really the format to put on his Saturday screen the modern successors of Cantelli, Neveu and Lipatti. 
 At the most, it's a desperate risk, and one that a civilised chap should think long and hard before taking.. 
 Adding up the Bill. 
 THERE is one simple test by which the Court and Legal Services Bill published yesterday should be judged. 
 Who gets most out of the Bill: the lawyers or the consumer? 
 By that yardstick, the Bill is a success. 
 There are five ways in which the consumer will benefit: a new legal Ombudsman to strengthen the present inadequate systems for handling complaints against solicitors and barristers; cheaper conveyancing through banks and building societies being allowed to provide a one-stop house purchase service; a new right for consumers to negotiate &bquo;no-win no-fee&equo; agreements with their legal advisers; and more access to justice both by redistributing chunks of High Court work to county courts, plus extending solicitors' rights of audience to the higher courts. 
 Yet, as the Legal Action Group (LAG) noted yesterday, the Bill may be promising more than it can deliver. 
 LAG worried on three fronts: the side-step taken by the Bill on extending solicitors' rights of audience; the gamble on the redistribution of High Court business when the county courts are already over-stretched; and the unknown risks of the conveyancing changes until the new code is published. 
 The Lord Chancellor's concessions to the Bar over solicitors' rights of audience are understandable but mistaken. 
 The initial Government proposal for a single accreditation system for advocates was the correct approach. 
 There would have been different levels of accreditation according to competence, but each level (Crown, High Court, Appeal Court) would have been open to both solicitors and barristers. 
 The thunder with which this was greeted from the senior judiciary &mdash; every one a former barrister &mdash; forced the Lord Chancellor to produce his fudge: separate systems of accreditation with four senior judges given a veto over solicitors' rights. 
 If the Opposition were smart, they would put down amendments now restoring the original provision. 
 Sadly, neither Labour nor the Liberal Democrats will produce such an amendment because, fatally, both leave reform of legal services to their lawyers, the last people who should be in charge. 
 The redistribution of court business is long overdue. 
 The present system frequently results in simple cases being set before the High Court while much more complicated issues are being decided by the county courts. 
 The Bill will give the Lord Chancellor the power to ensure that appropriate categories of cases &mdash; according to complexity, value and legal importance &mdash; are placed before the appropriate court. 
 Lord Mackay was cautious yesterday about the speed of change. 
 And with good reason. 
 In many areas of the country, the county courts are already overcrowded. 
 The interval between the start of county court proceedings and the trial of a contested case can be well over two years. 
 The 270 courts issued two million summonses, 1.3 million warrants and 180,000 divorce petitions last year. 
 Finally, it is a pity that a Bill designed to end restrictive practices should extend one of the worst in the book: but barristers' immunity from negligence claims looks set to be extended to solicitors. 
 That, perhaps, sums up the entire package: a slightly addled Lord Chancellor's egg. 
 PAGE 
 Max Grundig, 81, died yesterday in Baden-Baden. 
 He opened his shop in Nurenburg selling radios and producing transformers in 1930, and in 1945 he was allowed by the Allies to relocate his business in Furth, where it was one of the first to produce FM radios, then television sets &mdash; and high fidelity reel-to-reel tape recorders which serious musicians felt obliged to pay serious money for. 
 Appreciation: Goran Jarvefelt: Operatic fabulist. 
 GORAN Jarvefelt's opera productions were essentially naive &mdash; like Ingmar Bergman's Magic Flute film, shot at the Drottingholm court theatre built by Gustav III. 
 For Jarvefelt, opera needed to be illustrated like a children's story-book of fables. 
 He was decidedly not a deconstructionist. 
 His gentle, conservative aim was to support the singers and make the story clear. 
 This did not mean a lack of thought about the philosophical agenda behind. 
 His Magic Flute for the Welsh National Opera, which introduced him to British audiences in 1979, avoided the sort of in-jokes that Mozart's pop entertainment often elicits (authentically enough, as Schikaneder was a Rowan Atkinson figure). 
 Instead he treated the story as an emotionally credible tale of initiation, involving real people in real situations. 
 It achieved &bquo;affectionate laughter and spiritual joy&equo;. 
 His Parsifal for the 1981 Holland Festival was similarly touching. 
 The difference between Jarvefelt and, say, Peter Hall &mdash; who also likes to keep to the basic narrative &mdash; was that Jarvefelt was innocent, cool and sober. 
 He remained a Scandinavian puritan, less humourous than Bergman, certainly more covert about sexuality generally. 
 This approach, putting the music first, explains why Jarvefelt's career blossomed at Santa Fe and in Sydney and also his appeal for the New York Met: operatic naturalism and story-telling are still the predominant aesthetic in all these places. 
 Jarvefelt was an actor in Stockholm for five years before he got into opera, and &mdash; like many theatre people &mdash; he was disinclined to challenge the presumed limitations of opera singers as actors. 
 He assisted Bergman on The Dance of Death in 1976, and periodically still did plays: Lysistrata and The Tempest in Stockholm, The Dream Play very successfully in Adelaide. 
 But the bulk of his work, normally in collaboration with the German designer Carl Friedrich Oberle, was operatic. 
 Like the conductor Arnold Ostman, he started at the Vadstena Academy. 
 They worked together frequently, starting with a Swedish television recording of Stradella's Salome. 
 In Gelsenkirchen, where Jarvefelt became principal stage director in 1977, he tackled mainstream operatic classics: Don Carlos, Falstaff, Ariadne auf Naxos, Hansel and Gretel. 
 Falstaff was a favourite subject. 
 He even produced a Salieri version. 
 There was also a lot of Richard Strauss, which his Rosenkavalier at Cardiff in February would have capped. 
 Jarvefelt showed an early interest in Monteverdi and the baroque repertoire, though the constraints of &bquo;authenticity&equo; dulled him. 
 His Gluck Iphigenie this summer, first of a planned Drottningholm cycle, was self-consciously unobtrusive, almost rough in its stage manners &mdash; and as unexciting as his Don Giovanni from the same stable seen in Brighton. 
 Of his modest Welsh Ring cycle he said, &bquo;I aimed to strip away all the burdens that philosophers have put on everybody's shoulders about the Ring, and take a very fresh, sensuous look at it.&equo; 
 By sensuous, Jarvefelt meant working closely with the cast to make reactions and relationships on stage seem natural and believable. 
 He was against &bquo;a very static kind of Wagner where the set is the concept&equo;, to the neglect of intellectual excitement and engagement. 
 Perhaps his best production in this country was the WNO Ballo in Maschera, a scrupulously organised and visually attractive treatment that benefited from the by now traditional repatriation of Verdi's subject to its Swedish origin. 
 Tom Sutcliffe Goran Jarvefelt born August 3, 1947; died November 29, 1989. 
 Sheppard sets the night alight John Fordham on the UK Jazz Awards at the Queen Elizabeth Hall. 
 THE flashiest UK Jazz Awards proceedings yet, this time co-sponsored by your favourite newspaper, saw few surprises from the poll winners but some of the best live music ever to support this four-year-old event. 
 It was appropriate to the spirit of jazz (and a useful antidote to the inevitable toe-curling staginess of awards ceremonies in general) to present two bands of joint American-British instrumentalists who had not worked together before to see what would happen. 
 The first, featuring the American adolescent altoist, Christopher Hollyday, was uneven &mdash; Hollyday's famous virtuosity sounding faintly stiff and cramped by comparison with the local prodigy, Jason Rebello's. 
 But the headlining act &mdash; a quartet splicing the former Miles Davis guitarist John Scofield with the British saxophonist Andy Sheppard &mdash; struck fireworks that went a long way towards helping the audience breathe out after some dodgy moments during the presentations. 
 Those musical orbits described by the fertile planets of Loose Tubes and the Jazz Warriors dominated the polls, with Andy Sheppard continuing to make his individual mark as he has in the past two years. 
 Loose Tubes won the Best Band category, and the Jazz Warriors alumni, Cleveland Watkiss and the vibra harpist, Orphy Robinson, won the Best Vocalist and Best Newcomer awards. 
 Best New Band was the smooth and highly wrought funk ensemble, Roadside Picnic (it would be nice to think that the more raw-boned but full-blooded Pinski Zoo had run them close), Andy Sheppard walked off with both Best Instrumentalist and Best Album prizes (the latter for Introductions In The Dark), and Stan Tracey picked up Best Composer. 
 The Guardian's own Milestones Award for long-term creative commitment to the music went to the veteran George Russell, whose greeting from the crowd was as affectionate as it should have been and a services-to-jazz prize sponsored jointly by Wire and Carlsberg/Elephant lager went to John Surman, one of the most gifted members of that talented and ill-rewarded generation of musicians that came between Stan Tracey's and the new young heroes. 
 The show ended with John Scofield and Andy Sheppard's memorable first live meeting. 
 The guitarist's taste and absence of flamboyance and Sheppard's alternating quirkiness and abrasiveness were perfect foils and the drummer, Mark Mondesir &mdash; the most improved percussionist on the British scene by light-years &mdash; was nothing short of sensational. 
 Andy Sheppard: quirkiness 
 Obituary: Professor Norman Davis. 
 Scholar worth his dinars:. 
 PROFESSOR Norman Davis was one of the finest English historical philologists of this century. 
 A New Zealander, born in Dunedin and a graduate of Otago University, he went to Merton College, Oxford, in 1934 as a Rhodes Scholar, where he took a First in English. 
 There followed a period of university teaching abroad: first in Lithuania, then in Bulgaria. 
 After the War, he returned to teach in London and Oxford. 
 In 1949 he became Professor of English Language in Glasgow, and in 1959 succeeded J. R. R. Tolkien as Merton Professor of English Language of Literature at Oxford. 
 The honours that came to him were richly deserved. 
 His scholarly achievement was remarkable. 
 The great edition of the Paston Letters is his most obvious monument, but beside this there stand an edition of the non-cycle plays, a series of influential articles (notably one which unobtrusively undermined the theory of R. W. Chambers on the &bquo;continuity of English prose&equo;), and two modestly entitled &bquo;revisions&equo; (really new editions) of Sweet's Anglo-Saxon Primer and of Tolkien and Gordon's Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. 
 His mentor, Tolkien, had brought a touch of genius to the art of the glossary, and Norman Davis followed him with distinction in the glossary to Bennett and Smithers, Early Middle English Verse and Prose and in the Chaucer Glossary, for which he enlisted the help of three Oxford colleagues. 
 He excelled in a kind of &bquo;collabortive&equo; scholarship, ranging from the Oxford History of English Literature through the Early English Text Society volumes produced while he was Director, articles for the Review of English Studies, and the offerings of his devoted students. 
 He kept up an unrelenting gentle moral pressure on his authors or collaborators, and as a commentator, like Tolkien he selflessly put much of himself into the work of others. 
 But a list of his achievements does not do full justice to Norman Davis as scholar and person. 
 He had a wide and humane range of interests, and, as one of his old New Zealand friends once wrote, &bquo;a natural sense of what scholarship is&equo;. 
 He was a excellent linguist, and took an intense delight in linguistic minutiae &mdash; his friends remember many entertaining dinner-table disquisitions on etymologies, sometimes punctuated by visits to the OED. 
 He was also a superb phonetician, and a master of mimicry, a technique which he used to the full as a raconteur. 
 He was not unusual (at least in Oxford) in being a New Zealand philologist, but unlike his countrymen who are alleged to mark dates by rugby Test matches, he marked them by exactly remembered dinners and the wines which had accompanied them. 
 He was also unusual among philologists in having had a price on his head. 
 In his Who's Who entry there is a characteristically discreet phrase &bquo;Government service mainly abroad, 1939-46&equo;. 
 Unlikely though it seemed to students and friends of the scholarly and bespectacled professor, he had at this period worked for what became SOE (a kind of work for which his precision of mind, excellent memory and linguistic ability pre-eminently qualified him: he contrived among other exploits to smuggle the leader of the Bulgarian Peasant Party out of the country into Turkey in a truck). 
 Hostile Bulgars (it seems) placed a bomb on the train carrying the rest of the British Legation to Istanbul. 
 With further lack of efficiency, he was fond of recalling, it had not exploded until the party's luggage had reached the hotel, where it &bquo;made as fearful mess and damaged the odd Turk&equo;. 
 He was rewarded for this and more with a Bulgarian sentence of death and a British MBE. 
 But this, as he would say, is a long story, and happened a long time ago. 
 Norman Davis will be remembered by many with affection not only as a very great scholar but also as a most delightful and faithful friend. 
 D.G. Norman Davis: born May 16, 1913; died December 2, 1989. 
 Princely power It's complex, inventive and rich. 
 And if first-night reaction is any indicator, Prince Of The Pagodas will also prove to be successful. 
 Mary Clarke was at Covent Garden. 
 IT IS difficult, almost impossible, to judge a new, full evening ballet on the evidence of a first-night gala performance. 
 But if the cheering at the end on Thursday evening &mdash; and I mean the cheering from upstairs, which is what matters &mdash; is a portent, then Kenneth MacMillan's Prince Of The Pagodas is a success. 
 He and Colin Thubron have devised a new scenario which remains true to the basic premise of Cranko's original story and Britten's score &mdash; namely that redemption comes through compassion &mdash; while giving a more cohesive dramatic shape to the work. 
 Aided by the fresh designs of Nicholas Georgiadis, they place the action in an Elizabethan fantasy setting &mdash; and how cleverly Georgiadis adapts period dress to the needs of ballet. 
 The story, basically, is about an aged emperor who divides his kingdom equally between his elder, nasty, daughter, Princess Epine, and her young, innocent half-sister, Princess Rose, thus incurring the wrath of Epine and requiring Rose to journey through a twilit world to find, with the help of the court Fool, her Prince who has been transformed into a salamander. 
 It is when she feels compassion, rather than revulsion, for the salamander and kisses him that the spell breaks. 
 It's another telling of Beauty And The Beast. 
 An innovation has been to introduce four kings, representing the four corners of the earth, who come to woo Epine and win the kingdom she has seized, are entranced by Rose but rejected by her because the North is uncouth, the East too vain, the West too cynical and the South too violent. 
 This gives MacMillan the opportunity in the first act, which is brilliant, to introduce his characters in solos of vivid personality while Rose's vision of her lost Prince provides a poetic pas de deux. 
 Thereafter we witness Rose being guided by the Fool towards Pagoda-land, where she finds the salamander, then back to the court where her kindness to both the salamander and her persecuted old father is rewarded by the transformation of the Prince to his real shape and his victory over all contenders to win Rose, rescue her father and banish Epine. 
 MacMillan has said from the first announcements that it would be a big company ballet, involving a large cast, and he has provided just that. 
 He seems anxious to re-affirm the dramatic and classical potential of the troupe by giving all the dancers choreography of the utmost complexity, requiring from them performances of total physical and emotional commitment. 
 In Darcey Bussell and Jonathan Cope he has ideal interpreters for the principal roles &mdash; the writing for the salamander is some of his most inventive &mdash; while Fiona Chadwick blazes as Epine, Anthony Dowell dodders as the emperor, the four kings seek to outshine each other, and Tetsuyu Kumakawa as the Fool seems even more at ease in the air than on the ground. 
 First impressions, therefore, are of a fascinating and challenging work, so full of choreographic riches that it will take more viewings fully to savour them. 
 And wonderful to hear the score in the Opera House again, its beauties safe in Ashley Lawrence's conducting. 
 The Prince Of The Pagodas will be danced at Covent Garden on Monday and then on December 13, 14, 15, 19 and 20. 
 Princess Rose (Darcey Bussell) resists unwanted advances in Kenneth MacMillan's Prince Of The Pagodas 
 When Thomas met Sally Television. 
 By Hugh Hebert 
 COMEDY-thrillers could have a hard time without small black books that disappear containing the clue to mysterious fortunes. 
 Effete southern alternatives-fat Filofaxes or electronic Psions-lack dramatic resonance and spoil the line of the jacket. 
 Happily for Geoff McQueen's Stay Lucky (Yorkshire) small black notebooks containing solid gold clues are still common currency in Leeds. 
 Stephen's book has disappeared after he died in bed with his accountant's wife, engaged in urgent cash flow analysis. 
 This at least showed some foresight, since the number of beds in which Stephen might have missed a heartbeat and a vital document were legion. 
 Stephen's feisty Yorkshire wife Sally (Jan Francis) thereafter is harried by the accountant's heavies, while the accountant (James Grout) is being hounded by a second set of heavies on the track of a very expensive painting. 
 Sally's unlikely and unwanted ally in the battle of North v. 
 South wits is Thomas (Dennis Waterman), a Cockney wide-boy on the run from the third set of heavies, Triads. 
 They caught him in delicto with Mr Big's oriental treasure. 
 Given McQueen's London track record-Big Deal, The Bill-Waterman would get the more complex lines, mostly aimed at Francis's nutcracker verbal style. 
 (&bquo;Bet your gums are relieved when the rest of you goes to sleep.&equo;) 
 She contents herself with short, heartfelt abuse of the dickhead kind. 
 Directed by David Reynolds it's an amiable addition to ITV's moribund Friday night; but no need to stay home. 
 Thomas and Sally meet on a drenched A1 as he is trying to hitch northwards. 
 Miles Kington found that most of the Burma Road (Great Journeys, BBC-2) is even wetter. 
 It is not a continuous road but a route, and a lot of it is the wide, slow Irrawaddy River. 
 The film was made in 1987 and turned out to be the last chance for outsiders to trace the old route to China before Burma's political blow-up of 1988. 
 It was the route by which Buddhism reached China, and down which Kubla Khan swept south. 
 In the Second World War it was Chiang Kai-shek's lifeline. 
 The famous China convoys brought supplies from the storehouses of Burma to Kunming, the centre of Chinese resistance to the Japanese invaders. 
 Kington's river trip was eight days on a slow boat in the company of U Thien San, who guided the writer on matters like whether it is customary to talk while eating with the Burmese, and whether the monk sharing their cabin was really a spy. 
 This is not as wild a question as you might suppose in a country where every Buddhist is a monk some time in their lives, and can slip into the habit again at any time. 
 Kington comes across as a natural traveller, just as Colin Thubron did in the Silk Road programme in David Wallace's series. 
 His Burmese isn't as good as Thubron's Chinese, but he gets on terms with the locals without patronage, and his wit gets us through the potentially boring bits. 
 In Mandalay, Kington drove round with an Australian who took a detached interest while overtaking a pair of cyclists in line abreast, pedalling hand-in-hand all over the road. 
 Oncoming bikers seemed intent on taking the short cut up and over the Aussie's Nissan. 
 His laconic comment was &bquo;Nearly got that one,&equo; while the petrified Kington giggled nervously. 
 After the river, he took a train as far as the Burmese would allow foreigners to go, about a hundred miles short of their guerrilla war, and after that there was a vintage plane over mountains to the real Burma Road; the road whose legend occupies an odd corner of the memory, like Hannibal's Alpine venture. 
 Chiang Kai-shek built it with forced labour, and dusty antique-model lorries still ply it, driven by young men in white gloves. 
 Somewhere here, Kington found a village of the ancient China, with story-tellers reciting to an audience of old men, with chess players in the street, among the chickens and the black piglets and the heavy feeling of lost centuries. 
 BAe-Thomson weapons merger nears as UK picks Euro missile. 
 By David Fairhall and Mark Milner 
 PLANS by British Aerospace and France's Thomson-CSF to merge their guided weapons businesses moved a step closer yesterday after the United Kingdom's Ministry of Defence opted for a European missile for the new generation of anti-aircraft frigates. 
 The choice of the European Family of Anti-Air Missiles (Fams), rather than a rival American system, is likely to influence the French Government's views about the BAe-Thomson link. 
 Thomson is state-owned and though there has been no overt policy statement from the French Government, it is widely accepted that its attitude towards the merger will be at least coloured by the MoD's decision. 
 BAe said yesterday it welcomed the decision as a major opportunity for future business and an important step in European industrial co-operation. 
 &bquo;In addition, the decision should now enable BAe Dynamics and Thomson-CSF to progress their detailed negotiations.&equo; 
 On the stock market, BAe shares responded to the news &mdash; and reports that a consortium of international banks were about to provide some kind of support package to help to finance the massive Saudi Arabian defence order &mdash; with a 27p jump to 553p on brisk turnover. 
 Announcing the MoD's decision to the House of Commons yesterday, the Under Secretary for Defence Procurement, Michael Neubert, said: &bquo;The choice between these two programmes has been an extremely difficult one because both offer the prospect of a highly capable ship defence system. 
 &bquo;On balance, it has been concluded that, of the two projects, Fams offers the better prospect of providing an affordable and capable system within the timescale.&equo; 
 Gloomy prospects for retail trade. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 BRITAIN'S shopkeepers are gloomier than at any time since the early 1980s, according to a survey published yesterday. 
 Retailers, wholesalers and motor traders all expect their businesses to become worse over the next three months. 
 Higher mortgage rates have already had an impact on spending, according to the latest survey of distributive trades from the Confederation of British Industry. 
 Many borrowers whose mortgage repayments change only annually will feel the impact of higher interest rates only next month. 
 Those sectors closest to the housing market, including builders' merchants and retailers of furniture, carpets and household goods were the most pessimistic. 
 Among DIY and hardware retailers, only one in a hundred expects business to get better in the next three months. 
 Figures from Grand Metropolitan yesterday also show that higher interest rates have had a big impact on people's willingness to eat out. 
 The company said that the number of people eating in its Chef &amp; Brewer and Berni restaurants had fallen by about 10 per cent. 
 The CBI survey revealed that the majority of distributors feel that their stock levels are at an uncomfortably high level. 
 As they try to cut stocks, this is likely to make a big dent in orders to manufacturing industry and importers. 
 Few retailers expect their orders with suppliers this month to be higher than in December 1988. 
 For the first time since the survey was started six years ago, retailers, wholesalers and companies in the motor trade expect to cut investment in the coming year. 
 Only confectioners, tobacconists and newsagents remain optimistic: every other retailing sector identified in the CBI survey expects business to get tougher over the next three months. 
 Boeing in &dollar;4bn project to rival Airbus jetliner. 
 By Andrew Cornelius in London and Mary Brasier in New York Industrial Editor 
 BOEING, the world's biggest aircraft maker, last night gave the go-ahead for a &dollar;4billion development of a new wide-bodied 350-seater jet, to be called the 777. 
 The new jet, which will be ready for launch in 1995 to compete head-on with the European Airbus A330, where British Aerospace has a 20 per cent stake, and the McDonnell Douglas MD-11 trijet, will be the last major new passenger jet to be launched this century. 
 It will be offered at a price of &dollar;70million-plus into a booming sector of the market for civil aircraft, which is expected to generate &dollar;110billion of sales by the year 2005. 
 Boeing said the new plane, which is derived from the 767X project, would have a wider body than the existing 767 plane used by British airlines and new wings. 
 Decisions on whether Rolls-Royce engines are fitted to the jets will probably be left until customers decide to place orders. 
 Boeing said that no planes would be built until the first firm orders were placed by customers, signalling the start of a bitter fight with the Airbus consortium for orders. 
 However, the Boeing commercial airlines president, Dean Thornton, said in Seattle yesterday that eight airlines had expressed strong interest in the new jet and that 12 more might consider placing orders. 
 The project faces up to eight months of discussions between Boeing and its customers to finalise design details of the plane. 
 One of the first battles between the giants of the world aerospace industry will be for a &dollar;2billion order from British Airways for either the 777 or the A330 to replace its ageing fleet of Tristars. 
 BA's chairman, Lord King, admires the airline's relationship with Boeing. 
 However, during the summer Lord King warned that Boeing had &bquo;better get going&equo; if it was to beat Airbus to the order. 
 Other airlines regarded as potential launch customers for the new plane are United Airlines, American Airlines and Japan Airlines. 
 Boeing is in discussions with European and Japanese companies about bringing in a 25 per cent equity partner into the development. 
 Suggestions that Boeing might collaborate with the Japanese on another jet development project have raised protests in Washington about the transfer of technology in an industry where the US maintains a strong lead over the Japanese. 
 A Boeing spokesman, Craig Martin, said that finding an equity partner for the 777 project was not a prerequisite to launching the new plane, and that the company might fund development costs from its own cash resources. 
 Attempts to revive the buyout of United Airlines are meeting with little enthusiasm on Wall Street and a new bid &mdash; possibly with the support of Jay Pritzker, the Chicago financier &mdash; is unlikely to get off the ground before early 1990. 
 Representatives from developers Olympia&amp;York and high street retailer Marks&amp;. 
 Spencer yesterday inspecting progress in the construction of the main shopping block at the &pound;4billion Canary Wharf development, which will include a new 13,000-square foot M&amp;S food hall. 
 M&amp;S is the first big retailer to move to Canary Wharf and its announcement yesterday to take space in the building is a boost of confidence for the 71-acre London Docklands project. 
 Once complete, it will provide 10 million square feet of office space and 250 shops within 500,000 square feet of retail area by 1997. 
 So far, a third of the office space in the first phase of eight buildings has been booked. 
 M&amp;S will join Texaco as one of the big-name occupiers of Canary Wharf, and Olympia&amp;York says it expects to announce several other tenants shortly. 
 However, the development has attracted criticism in the past months as a possible white elephant following the effect of the steep rise in interest rates on the economy. 
 Critics have also pointed to the lack of transport links to the development, but Olympia&amp;York denies that there will be a problem given the proposed extension of the Jubilee Line, increased capacity of the Light Docklands Railway, and the building of new roads. 
 Photograph: Martin Argles 
 As the season of goodwill gets into full swing, Jill Papworth looks at some presents which will still be appreciated on Boxing Day. 
 Counting the cost of mailing money 
 THE problem with sending Christmas gifts to children living overseas is that postage can double the price of the presents. 
 If you opt instead to send relatives and friends money to spend as they wish on their children, it's worth shopping around as costs differ considerably for the various methods. 
 All the banks and the Post Office strongly advise against sending cash. 
 route. 
 Likewise, sending British or Eurocheques can cause problems, delay and heavy charges for the recipient when he or she tries to cash them at a foreign bank. 
 The cheapest way is to buy and send postal orders in various denominations which are acceptable in around 60 countries. 
 Bought over the Post Office counter, postal orders are both traceable and give you a counterfoil to prove they have been sent. 
 A &pound;20 order, for example, will cost 62p. 
 International money orders, available in sterling or US dollars from Barclays, or dollars only from Lloyds and the Royal Bank of Scotland, are the next best bet. 
 The Royal Bank's new American Express-backed orders, valued up to &dollar;1,000, cost just &pound;3 each and can be cashed by the recipient at any Amex travel office. 
 The drawback is that both the sender and the recipient, if living outside the US, are at the mercy of prevailing exchange rates and foreign banks may charge a commission. 
 Banker's drafts come a little more expensive but can be bought in any currency. 
 Girobank charges a flat fee of &pound;5 per draft and Barclays &pound;9. 
 NatWest, Lloyds and RBS all charge 0.25 per cent of the value but with varying minimum fees. 
 Midland, the only bank to restrict its sending cash abroad service to existing customers, charges &pound;6 on drafts of up to &pound;100 and 0.5 per cent of the sterling value with a minimum charge of &pound;9 over that amount. 
 The above three methods, while allowing you to send a tangible piece of paper as a gift, do mean you incur postal costs and are reliant on UK and foreign postal systems. 
 Barclays, RBS and Midland all offer guaranteed methods of transferring money direct to a foreign recipient's bank through their own mailing systems, costing a minimum of &pound;7.50, &pound;6 and &pound;9. 
 But you have already missed the last postal dates for some countries, including Australia and New Zealand. 
 Monday is your last chance to send things by post to the US, Italy and Spain and Wednesday for the rest of Europe. 
 Your only option when sending money at the last minute to arrive by Christmas is to use the banks' electronic money transfer services which take from 24 hours to around five days depending on the bank and whether you use an express transfer. 
 Charges and services offered vary among the main high street banks, though using the example of sending &pound;50 abroad NatWest and RBS work out the cheapest at &pound;6 for a standard transfer taking around 48 hours. 
 Girobank charges a flat fee of &pound;5 whatever the transfer value, but only to specific foreign banks and taking up to 10 working days. 
 Counting the cost of mailing money. 
 THE problem with sending Christmas gifts to children living overseas is that postage can double the price of the presents. 
 If you opt instead to send relatives and friends money to spend as they wish on their children, it's worth shopping around as costs differ considerably for the various methods. 
 All the banks and the Post Office strongly advise against sending cash. 
 route. 
 Likewise, sending British or Eurocheques can cause problems, delay and heavy charges for the recipient when he or she tries to cash them at a foreign bank. 
 The cheapest way is to buy and send postal orders in various denominations which are acceptable in around 60 countries. 
 Bought over the Post Office counter, postal orders are both traceable and give you a counterfoil to prove they have been sent. 
 A &pound;20 order, for example, will cost 62p. 
 International money orders, available in sterling or US dollars from Barclays, or dollars only from Lloyds and the Royal Bank of Scotland, are the next best bet. 
 The Royal Bank's new American Express-backed orders, valued up to &dollar;1,000, cost just &pound;3 each and can be cashed by the recipient at any Amex travel office. 
 The drawback is that both the sender and the recipient, if living outside the US, are at the mercy of prevailing exchange rates and foreign banks may charge a commission. 
 Banker's drafts come a little more expensive but can be bought in any currency. 
 Girobank charges a flat fee of &pound;5 per draft and Barclays &pound;9. 
 NatWest, Lloyds and RBS all charge 0.25 per cent of the value but with varying minimum fees. 
 Midland, the only bank to restrict its sending cash abroad service to existing customers, charges &pound;6 on drafts of up to &pound;100 and 0.5 per cent of the sterling value with a minimum charge of &pound;9 over that amount. 
 The above three methods, while allowing you to send a tangible piece of paper as a gift, do mean you incur postal costs and are reliant on UK and foreign postal systems. 
 Barclays, RBS and Midland all offer guaranteed methods of transferring money direct to a foreign recipient's bank through their own mailing systems, costing a minimum of &pound;7.50, &pound;6 and &pound;9. 
 But you have already missed the last postal dates for some countries, including Australia and New Zealand. 
 Monday is your last chance to send things by post to the US, Italy and Spain and Wednesday for the rest of Europe. 
 Your only option when sending money at the last minute to arrive by Christmas is to use the banks' electronic money transfer services which take from 24 hours to around five days depending on the bank and whether you use an express transfer. 
 Charges and services offered vary among the main high street banks, though using the example of sending &pound;50 abroad NatWest and RBS work out the cheapest at &pound;6 for a standard transfer taking around 48 hours. 
 Girobank charges a flat fee of &pound;5 whatever the transfer value, but only to specific foreign banks and taking up to 10 working days. 
 PAGE 
 Johnson Matthey hit by second departure. 
 By Financial Staff 
 JOHNSON MATTHEY, the precious metals to chemicals group, was given a respite from takeover speculation yesterday after its biggest shareholder, Charter Consolidated, said it had no plans to change its 38 per cent stake. 
 The news came as Johnson Matthey announced a second top-level boardroom departure within 24 hours. 
 On Wednesday night, the group announced that its chief executive, Mr Eugene Anderson, had resigned and yesterday Johnson Matthey said its chairman, Mr Neil Clark, would be retiring from the board at the end of the year. 
 A Johnson Matthey spokesman dismissed any suggestion of a boardoom rift and said that the two departures were &bquo;not particularly connected&equo;. 
 Mr Clark will be succeeded by Mr David Davies, who is currently deputy chairman of Charter Consolidated and a former chief executive of merchant bank Hill Samuel, now owned by TSB. 
 The role of chief executive has gone to executive director, Mr Joe Stevenson. 
 Mr Anderson, who joined the group in 1985, will remain a consultant. 
 Yesterday Johnson Matthey &mdash; which announced pre-tax profits of &pound;33.5million &mdash; said it &bquo;has been authorised by Charter to say that Charter has no present intention of either buying or selling shares in the company.&equo; 
 Chevron readies its defences against potential predator. 
 By Mary Brasier in New York 
 ALEGAL and financial fight erupted between two of the world's largest oil companies yesterday as Chevron rushed to raise its defences against a potential bid from smaller rivals Pennzoil. 
 Chevron's swift counter-attack came a day after Pennzoil announced it had spent &dollar;2.1 billion to build up a nine per cent share stake in Chevron and said it planned to continue investing in the oil giant as a passive shareholder. 
 Casting aside Pennzoil's claims that it had no intention of launching a bid, Chevron moved into top gear to protect itself against a takeover which could be worth &dollar;35billion and would revive memories of some of the biggest corporate battles of the 1970's and 80's. 
 Deploying all of the ritual tactics of a US bid battle, Chevron, founded by the Rockefeller family, filed a lawsuit to remove Pennzoil as a shareholder claiming it had violated anti-trust laws with its share purchases. 
 Chevron also introduced new measures &mdash; popularly known as shark repellants &mdash; to prevent an unwanted takeover, introduced a new rule which would prevent Pennzoil from calling a shareholders' meeting and asked the courts to approve its actions. 
 In a further move, Chevron said it had set up a &dollar;5billion agreement with international banks to provide a fighting fund to fend off its rival. 
 Profits climb at GUS. 
 Great Universal Stores, the biggest of the mail order firms, raised pre-tax profit by &pound;8million to &pound;171million in the six months to September, although catalogue sales and retail earnings slumped by &pound;8million. 
 A &pound;7million rise in trading profit came from the financial services division and from investment income, both lumped together in the accounts. 
 Financial services rose on the back of increased consumer spending on cars, according to the group, and was &bquo;almost buoyant&equo; in the half year although it has dropped back since September. 
 GUS has an unspecified cash pile and no borrowing, so is a beneficiary of high interest rates. 
 Mail order is suffering from the public's current reluctance to part with cash for non-essential goods. 
 &bquo;People seem prepared to buy food and cars but not clothes&equo;, says GUS's Trevor Spittle. 
 Property profits, &pound;4.8million in the six months against &pound;4.9 million last year, reflect the group's continued wish to weed out unwanted retail premises which are not on prime town centre sites.. 
 GWR issues warning. 
 Independent radio group, GWR, which joined the USM in March and recently merged with Consolidated Radio Holdings, has warned the media sector not to talk down the buoyancy of the industry. 
 The company, whose profits for the year to September rose by 16 per cent to &pound;1.66 million, said commercial opportunities, particularly for radio, were about to be expanded significantly. 
 The group's turnover rose from &pound;8.1 million to &pound;9.66 million and a final dividend of 9p a share was declared. 
 Setback for Archer. 
 The slump in insurance rates in the shipping and aviation market has hit the financial results of Lloyd's underwriting group, A J Archer, for the second year running. 
 Thanks to higher interest income, the group managed to nudge pre-tax profits &pound;227,000 ahead to &pound;6.3 million, but both turnover at &pound;7.5 million and operating profits were lower. 
 Archer, whose earnings per share in the year to September climbed from 15.6p to 17.1p, raised its final dividend from 4.25p to 5p. 
 Lovell advance. 
 YJ Lovell, which is currently bidding &pound;137million for fellow builder Higgs &amp; Hill says it is too soon to comment on current trading but its profits for the year to September 30, rose from &pound;24.4million to &pound;33.3million. 
 Chairman Andrew Wassell, who has been asked by the Takeover Panel to clarify his comments to the Guardian on Wednesday about the level of acceptances, said: &bquo;It is much too soon to know but I am encouraged by the efforts we are making in winning support for our bid.&equo;. 
 De La Rue retreats. 
 De La Rue's sale of the Crosfield Electronics printing equipment business did not relieve it of other losses in advanced security equipment and in spite of the new cash surplus, the interim results are grisly. 
 The main printing and payment systems activities are performing strongly and the new chief executive, Mr Jeremy Marshall, ex-BAA, needs time to show his worth. 
 Sales were no problem as the reduction in turnover to &pound;161 million, from &pound;247million in the corresponding half to September 30 translates wih the help of currency gains into a rise of 18 per cent in the businesses retained. 
 Pre-tax profit skidded to &pound;16.6 million, from &pound;23.4million. 
 There was more difficulty over the high tax charge and ACT relief and the interim dividend stays at 3.25p covered less than twice by almost halved earnings.. 
 In short&hellip; 
 UK PAPER, which is recommending a &pound;263million takeover bid from the Finnish Metsa-Serla group, has forecast that its profits for 1989 will be up from &pound;13.9million to &pound;15million and that its surplus land has been revalued at &pound;16.9million, which is equal to 17.4p a share. 
 PHOENIX TIMBER'S profit fell from &pound;995,000 to &pound;479,000 in the half year to September 30 after some pressure on margins. 
 BUNZL is raising &pound;55.6million from the sale of its US electrical products distributor EESCO. 
 The markets. 
 The market paused for breath yesterday with the FTSE index dipping seven points to 2346.7. 
 Trading statements and bid situations continued to provide plenty of work for analysts and recent buoyant sectors like properties, insurances, and stores ran into profit-taking. 
 Alphameric was the day's major casualty with its shares plunging 32 per cent to 23p as hopes for its profit recovery faded. 
 On results, Grand Metropolitan rose 19p to 581p but De la Rue lost 26p at 311p. 
 Hong Kong: Firmer. 
 Hang Seng index: 2,770.00 (2756.39). 
 Tokyo: Record highs. 
 Nikkei index: 37,858.11 (37,654.29). 
 Frankfurt: Slightly higher. 
 FAZ index: 714.00 (695.74). 
 Paris: Mostly higher. 
 CAC index: 547.8 (542.6). 
 BICC acquires Sterling. 
 BICC, the Balfour Beatty construction to electrical equipment combine, yesterday continued the build up of its cable making business with a &pound;38million acquisition. 
 The purchase of Sterling Greengate, from the US group, Raytheon, is the latest in a series of cable companies bought by BICC. 
 Last year, for example, it bought Italy's biggest cable maker Ceat Cavi for &pound;90million and followed that with the purchase of a stake in the Spanish company, Grupo Espagnol General Cables. 
 Earlier this year BICC paid &pound;106million for BRIntec in the US. 
 Sterling Greengate, which makes power, armoured, elastomeric, electronic and control cables, has plants in Warrington in Cheshire and Aldermaston in Berkshire. 
 In the year to the end of November, Sterling Greengate made a pre-tax profit of &pound;1.6 million on sales of &pound;42million. 
 Net assets are put at &pound;32.7 million.. 
 Burns profit edges ahead. 
 Burns-Anderson, which can boast Sir John Harvey- Jones as its chairman until he retires next June, nudged its profit up from &pound;4.2million to &pound;4.6million in the year to September 30. 
 Unlike other recruitment companies, Burns has not found trading becoming more difficult. 
 Turnover on a like-for-like basis is currently ahead of last year. 
 However the board has no doubt that 1990 will prove a more difficult year for the UK economy as a whole. 
 Banking services and finance companies continued to trade profitably in spite of higher interest rates and the group's network of independent financial advisers, has made good progress, although slower than envisaged. 
 Sir John is confident that the group has never been stronger and has sound businesses and a management with the determination to achieve further success. 
 Red ink at Ross. 
 Ross Group turned a half-year profit of &pound;150,000 into a loss of &pound;220,000, underlining the task which faces the new management. 
 It aims to turn the headphones radios and television group into a mini-conglomerate and says that in the five weeks since new board was appointed, &bquo;considerable progress has already been made.&equo; 
 The management has been restructured and refocused with responsibilities clearly defined, the annual cost base of the business has been reduced by some &pound;280,000, and marketing plans are currently being put in place for next year. 
 Cash generation has assumed its full priority and Roger Shute, the chairman, reports that the first benefits of this policy have already been seen with bank borrowings reduced from &pound;5.6million to &pound;3.6million. 
 He is confident that a further cut in borrowings will be reported in the next report to shareholders. 
 In short&hellip; 
 HICKING PENTECOST's profit fell back to &pound;153,000 from &pound;415,000 as pressures on the textile industry intensified in the six months to September 30. 
 The interim dividend stays at 0.5p. 
 Its major shareholders, J Lister and J Carlson, are taking over management control of the Nottingham knitter and dyer, whose turnover rose to &pound;11.1million from &pound;10.5million. 
 The markets. 
 Buying for the new account, took the FTSE 100 index up 16.8 points to 1,363.5. 
 Volume levels held well above 400million. 
 Oils continued their rise in the wake of the firm crude price. 
 Enterprise was particularly favoured at 679p, up 23p, excited by revived speculation of a possible bid from Elf Aquitaine. 
 Properties and insurances gave back some of the sharp gains of the past two weeks, but building stocks were supported. 
 A grim report from the CBI put paid to excitement in the stores sector. 
 In breweries, Scottish and Newcastle was nervous ahead of Monday's interim results, easing 3p to 349p. 
 Tokyo: Shares retreated as investors took profits. 
 Nikkei index: 37,724.06 (37,858.11). 
 Hong Kong: Prices closed lower in sluggish trading. 
 Hang Seng index: 2,754.11 (2,770.00). 
 Frankfurt: Prices closed broadly lower in moderately active trading. 
 FAZ index: 691.26 (714.00). 
 Paris: Prices rallied to end the week broadly higher in moderate trading. 
 CAC index: 547.6 (547.8). 
 Cashpoints 
 Growth. 
 Clive Woodcock. 
 THE ABILITY of small firms to continue the past decade's rapid growth into the 1990s could suffer from increasing problems with what is now being called the &bquo;people gap&equo;. 
 But the problem can take different forms, one of which is now receiving political attention, while the other &mdash; the demographic shift &mdash; is probably neither fully recognised nor understood by small and medium enterprises. 
 The importance of the &bquo;people factor&equo; in bringing the small business sector's share of the UK's economic activity up to that of other advanced countries is a theme which the new Small Firms Minister, Tim Eggar, intends to pursue. 
 The reason behind the emphasis is an admission that not enough has been done to help the small, growing company and a belief that a key element in the failure of many growing enterprises to expand beyond a certain size is the lack of links with the right people to provide help in the major decisions faced at that stage. 
 The encouragement of the growth of such networks, encompassing larger businesses, the education sector and other institutions &bquo;tapping the many skills in the community&equo;, is seen as a priority rather than introducing new measures or rationalising existing ones. 
 The message of the need for more small business counselling, which is now being promoted, is aimed particularly at improving the performance of businesses in the 20-50 employee size range, which are seen to have problems. 
 The aim was expressed at the launch of a new report reviewing the role and prospects of the small firms sector in the economy, Small Firms in Britain, a publication which in some ways is the government's answer to pressure for a regular &bquo;report on small business&equo;, similar to the weighty volume published annually in the United States. 
 The difficulties faced by firms are highlighted by figures in a report to be published next year. 
 That study, by Prof Colin Gallagher of Newcastle University, looked at the job creation performance of firms during 1985-87. 
 It showed that the bulk of job gains came from enterprises employing five to 19 people &mdash; some 290,000 compared with only 20,000 from firms with more than 20 people. 
 The big problem arose with the substantial net job losses recorded in the size range 20-49 employees, because those in the 50-1,000 range all showed increases. 
 The blip in the graph occurs at a crucial stage of development in firms which until that point were among the fast growers, sharply reducing the number which move on to become medium and larger firms. 
 Some of the cause may lie in technological changes or takeovers of small firms with growth prospects. 
 It can, of course, reflect managerial or technical shortcomings, the &bquo;people gap&equo; which is now being targeted. 
 The kind of problem to which this leads is illustrated by research by Colin Barrow, of the school of management at Cranfield Institute of Technology, among relatively young and mostly successful companies. 
 They are around 10 years old, employing about 25 people, with sales of &pound;2million a year. 
 Their plans for growth are threatened by their apparent inability to find, retain and manage key staff &mdash; in fact, they rate the problem higher than the level of interest rates. 
 Unfortunately, the research revealed a high tendency for them to recruit the wrong people. 
 Three out of five key appointments failed to work &mdash; two-thirds of them within a year. 
 Such problems can quickly develop into the situation revealed among the 20-50 employee size range in the job generation study &mdash; and perhaps could be improved by the development of support networks. 
 A failure to recognise the implications of demographic change for the labour market as a whole is a further factor which could seriously affect the competitive position of smaller businesses. 
 A study by the West Midlands Regional Management Centre found employers were generally unaware of the impact of demographic changes, particularly its effect on young people entering the employment market, and were failing to look beyond traditional sources of labour. 
 Suggestions that small and medium enterprises are going to find life particularly difficult in the labour market of the next few years are also made in a study of recruitment problems by the Local Economy Research Unit at Hatfield Polytechnic. 
 It found employers &bquo;hopelessly ill-prepared&equo; for the future, with &bquo;knee-jerk reactions rather than strategic planning being the order of the day&equo;, and small and medium-sized firms facing a wage spiral and a lack of education links. 
 Smaller firms in the past have tended to recruit younger people, especially those not continuing in full-time education. 
 The fall in the number of young people entering the labour market because of the drop in the birth rate, combined with a rise in those going into further and higher education, will contract that source significantly. 
 It has been suggested that the move to a loans-based higher educational system will provide small firms with a supply of labour, as in the US, but this is unlikely to have a major effect other than on the demand for temporary workers. 
 The Hatfield study found an uncritical expectation that returning women workers &mdash; women already make up a substantial part of small firm employment &mdash; would fill the gap left by young people. 
 But the recruitment policies of larger firms, and their strategies for retaining staff, could well diminish this source. 
 In fact the corporate sector is already developing policies to meet potential labour shortages, such as career break and return-to-work schemes for women as well as creche facilities, attractions with which smaller firms find it difficult to compete. 
 Another alternative is for the smaller firm to tap into the growth of the older population &mdash; those over 55 &mdash; arising from early retirement and redundancy policies of large firms in recent years and other factors. 
 But retirement and redundancy could be replaced by retention and recruitment by larger firms in the future as the labour market tightens, leaving the smaller firm out in the cold. 
 The trend seems likely to force small firms to compete with the large corporate sector on pay, training and fringe benefits, putting further pressure on their ability to cope with the strains of growth. 
 The extent to which the sector as a whole has grown dramatically in recent years is underlined in new figures produced for the government's report by the research group, Graham Bannock and Partners. 
 These show an accelerating rate of growth, not only in the rate of increase in VAT registered businesses, to a net average of 1,200 a week in the past year &mdash; 50 per cent up on the previous year &mdash; but also in the self-employed, who rose from just under two million to more than three million. 
 Mr Bannock estimates that these increases have led to substantial gains in employment, with three million more people working in businesses with fewer than 1,000 staff. 
 Self-employment contributed only a quarter of these jobs, contrary to widely held views that they dominate. 
 But the pressures on the growing small firms from the different elements of the &bquo;people gap&equo; could make it difficult to maintain the recent rate of expansion. 
 It just doesn't pay to lag behind the hitech revolution Technology. 
 AILING firms most in need of technological investment in order to compete more effectively are the least likely to innovate, and many small businesses are lagging behind in the technological revolution, writes Clive Woodcock. 
 These gloomy conclusions are reached in a study of small businesses and their use of new technology by Christine Edwards of Kingston Polytechnic, who interviewed small business owner-managers on the process of adopting and implementing new technology and the benefits and difficulties experienced. 
 Even though industrial sectors where there was little or no potential for technological innovation were not included in the study, one-quarter of firms had not bought any kind of new technology in the five previous years. 
 The average spending on new equipment was generally very modest but the majority of firms reported major benefits in terms of increased efficiency, quality, output, and in the range of products or services they could offer. 
 The uses to which equipment was put, however, were very limited with few realising the full potential of the investment. 
 Most computers were used either for word processing or simple information storage tasks; very few were used for analysing business trends or problems. 
 There were, in spite of that, some quite complex applications, such as monitoring and scheduling the progress of orders and jobs, warehouse and stock control and networking. 
 Most of the high technology services firms were working at the frontier of computer usage, developing new software packages or sophisticated interactive training models for business. 
 No firms mentioned reducing their dependence on skilled labour as a reason for introducing new technology &mdash; though a significant minority saw it as a way of reducing labour costs. 
 In fact, nearly half found their dependence on skilled labour had actually increased, suggesting that the &bquo;deskilling&equo; effect of new technology may have been exaggerated. 
 One of the major costs of implementing new technology was the need to train for new skills, but Ms Edwards found that once new technology was adopted it was often under-used or misapplied because of the lack of expertise and investment. 
 Three out of five firms had spent nothing on training associated with new technology in the past five years. 
 &bquo;The consequence of the combined decision not to recruit expert staff or to invest in extensive training could be considerable. 
 Firstly, there could be a tendency to go for the &bquo;lowest skill&equo; option in the selection of new technology, in order to reduce training costs and to ensure that existing employees can cope. 
 &bquo;Often, operatives who are self-taught or who have minimal instruction will use the equipment for a very limited range of tasks, never realising its full potential. 
 In this way, the firms will be unlikely to reap the full benefits of their equipment.&equo; 
 The main reason given for restricting investment in new technology was cost. 
 Most owner-managers expected to finance all or part of their purchases from within the firm. 
 But the study was carried out at a time of economic expansion and three out of four of the firms had experienced growth in the year prior to the study. 
 Despite the positive benefits that most had derived from their investment, few were willing to borrow in order to expand their use. 
 Yet they also said that they had managed to increase output without increasing the workforce and had been able to grow more effectively. 
 New Business is edited by Clive Woodcock 
 Dixons set to seek bid probe. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 DIXONS, the electrical retailing giant, looks certain to launch a vigorous campaign for a Monopolies Commission investigation of the &pound;461million bid for the company by Kingfisher. 
 In mounting his assault on Wednesday, Kingfisher chief executive Geoffrey Mulcahy claimed a successful takeover would give the group 22 per cent of the British retail electrical market. 
 Kingfisher already owns 307 Comet electrical stores. 
 But Kingfisher's claim contradicts figures from independent market researchers Verdict. 
 They show that in 1988, Dixons had almost 18 per cent of the electrical market, Comet 7.6 per cent and Lasky &mdash; whose 58 outlets are now owned by Kingfisher &mdash; 1.2 per cent. 
 That suggests a successful Dixons takeover would give Kingfisher more than 26 per cent of the market &mdash; above the 25 per cent threshold which normally triggers a monopolies inquiry. 
 It emerged yesterday that Kingfisher's 22 per cent was derived by counting the rental of new televisions, video recorders and other hired electrical equipment in the market total. 
 &bquo;Buying, renting and various options in between are simply different ways of obtaining a piece of electrical equipment,&equo; said Mr Nigel Whittaker of Kingfisher. 
 &bquo;They are all part of the same market.&equo; 
 Mr Robert Schrager of Dixons said last night: &bquo;We would treat the Kingfisher figures with some scepticism. 
 It is up to the authorities to decide.&equo; 
 Dixons chairman Mr Stanley Kalms formally rejected the Kingfisher bid saying &bquo;it is making an opportunist bid during a downturn in the economic cycle.&equo; 
 Kingfisher yesterday tried to counter the view that its 120p-a-share bid for Dixons is only a sighting shot. 
 &bquo;They are blaming their current woes on the state of the market, when in truth, we would do a better job than the Dixons management in restructuring and repositioning the business,&equo; said a Kingfisher executive. 
 More misery for Dumenil holders. 
 By Mihir Bose 
 THE back office problems that lead to last month's supension of Dumenil unit trusts were identified six months ago in a document that put the group up for sale. 
 The near 50-page document told prospective buyers that there were certain administrative problems but that they were being sorted out by a consultant. 
 Although the document did not mention him, this was believed to be Chris Burrows, previously with Henderson Adminstration. 
 The document &mdash; widely touted around unit trust groups &mdash; raises serious questions about the role of the managers and the trustees in informing the unit holders of the problems. 
 The 12,000 investors whose right to deal in the units were further suspended this week until February 5 did not hear from the managers until two weeks after the funds were first suspended on November 6. 
 Even that letter was written after pressure from the Investment Management Regulatory Organisation (IMRO) whose chief executive John Morgan is critical of the way the managers have reacted. 
 He says: &bquo;Dumenil was at fault in not communicating. 
 They should have written as soon as the suspension was announced. 
 Unit holders would have felt a sense of reassurance if the management and the trustees had written promptly to tell them that their units had been suspended. 
 It is communication that is necessary.&equo; 
 This week's extension of the suspension has lead to a further letter to unit trust holders.But it gives no indication that the pricing problems may have had a long history. 
 In October 1988 the administration of the funds was transferred from the Manchester Unit Trust Administration to an in-house system. 
 However the in-house system had not been properly tested and by early this year problems had started. 
 It was only in late October this year that it was discovered there were discrepancies between the cash the trustees were holding and the cash the managers thought the trustees were holding. 
 It was this that suggested that there had been pricing errors which lead to the suspension of the trusts. 
 Unit trust experts are mystified why this discrepancy should have taken so long to identify and the role of the trustees, Midland Bank and Coutts, who are supposed to hold the assets and keep a check on the sales and purchases. 
 The latest letter from Dumenil managers refers to their &bquo;intention&equo; of putting forward a &bquo;proposal&equo; to allow unit holders to realise their units. 
 But John Morgan says: &bquo;Dumenil may have put forward some thoughts that might help unit holders, but it needs a lot of thought before it turns into a proposal. 
 At this stage they are talking of a concept. 
 When back office problems lead to a suspension they cannot be sorted out in short order.&equo; 
 This leaves unit holders with vague promises of release from investments they have already been locked into for over a month &mdash; and may well be for a further two months or more. 
 Investors appear to have been effectively abandoned by both the fund managers, with whom they entrusted their investments, and also by the trustees whose main role is to safeguard these investments. 
 They may have to turn to the courts for satisfaction. 
 More misery for Dumenil holders. 
 By Mihir Bose 
 THE back office problems that led to last month's suspension of Dumenil unit trusts were identified six months ago in a document that put the group up for sale. 
 The near 50-page document told prospective buyers that there were certain administrative problems but that they were being sorted out by a consultant. 
 Although the document did not mention him, this was believed to be Chris Burrows, previously with Henderson Administration. 
 The document &mdash; widely touted around unit trust groups &mdash; raises serious questions about the role of the managers and the trustees in informing the unit holders of the problems. 
 The 12,000 investors whose right to deal in the units were further suspended this week until February 5 did not hear from the managers until two weeks after the funds were first suspended on November 6. 
 Even that letter was written after pressure from the Investment Management Regulatory Organisation (IMRO) whose chief executive John Morgan is critical of the way the managers have reacted. 
 He says: &bquo;Dumenil was at fault in not communicating. 
 They should have written as soon as the suspension was announced. 
 Unit holders would have felt a sense of reassurance if the management and the trustees had written promptly to tell them that their units had been suspended. 
 It is communication that is necessary.&equo; 
 This week's extension of the suspension has lead to a further letter to unit trust holders.But it gives no indication that the pricing problems may have had a long history. 
 In October 1988 the administration of the funds was transferred from the Manchester Unit Trust Administration to an in-house system. 
 However the in-house system had not been properly tested and by early this year problems had started. 
 It was only in late October this year that it was discovered there were discrepancies between the cash the trustees were holding and the cash the managers thought the trustees were holding. 
 It was this that suggested that there had been pricing errors which led to the suspension of the trusts. 
 Unit trust experts are mystified why this discrepancy should have taken so long to identify and the role of the trustees, Midland Bank and Coutts, who are supposed to hold the assets and keep a check on the sales and purchases. 
 The latest letter from Dumenil managers refers to their &bquo;intention&equo; of putting forward a &bquo;proposal&equo; to allow unit holders to realise their units. 
 But John Morgan says: &bquo;Dumenil may have put forward some thoughts that might help unit holders, but it needs a lot of thought before it turns into a proposal. 
 At this stage they are talking of a concept. 
 When back office problems lead to a suspension they cannot be sorted out in short order.&equo; 
 This leaves unit holders with vague promises of release from investments they have already been locked into for over a month &mdash; and may well be for a further two months or more. 
 Investors appear to have been effectively abandoned by both the fund managers, with whom they entrusted their investments, and also by the trustees whose main role is to safeguard these investments. 
 They may have to turn to the courts for satisfaction. 
 Money page 14 EARLY PRICES. 
 Grey market price (p) Yield (p) P/E ratio Anglia124-1298.515.8 Northumbrian127-1328.913.4 North West121-1268.735.6 Severn Trent125-1308.254.5 Southern125-1308.355.4 South West121-1269.683.9 Thames127-1328.105.8 Welsh123-1289.314.1 Wessex125-1308.455.0 Yorkshire123-1288.575.4 Grey market price: unofficial trading of shares ahead of issue. 
 Yield: dividend income relative to price paid. 
 P/E ratio: the price of shares relative to their current earnings. 
 PAGE 
 Foreigners eye British TV. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 FOREIGN media groups are expected to mount a major assault on Britain's television industry following the publication of proposed broadcasting legislation which removes constraints on European takeovers and investments. 
 According to media analysts at the large accounting and management consultancy group, Deloitte Haskins &amp; Sells, &bquo;a major influx&equo; of foreign investment is likely. 
 George Eccles, of Deloitte, predicted that major groups such as Germany's Bertelsmann and interests controlled by magnates such as Silvio Berlusconi and Carlo de Benedetti would bid for television franchises. 
 The British media market is considered attractive to European groups whose own domestic expansion is hampered by national cross-ownership rules. 
 UK television advertising is also regarded as more sophisticated and predictable than elsewhere in Europe, making it an appealing source of revenue. 
 The Broadcasting Bill removes constraints on European companies wanting to own television companies or bid on their own for a Channel 3 franchise. 
 And Deloitte says it is unlikely that British companies will be favoured over European rivals in the franchise round which will be open to public scrutiny. 
 Mr Eccles says non-EC groups are also looking at the new regulations to identify &bquo;schemes that overcome the more onerous ownership restrictions&equo;. 
 American firms, for instance, may set up EC subsidiaries. 
 Already major US media groups have carved an impressive stake in the peripheral broadcasting sector of independent production companies, cable and satellite channels. 
 And TVS, for instance, has 20 per cent of its shares in French hands. 
 It has been estimated that around 70 consortia in all are arranging finance to participate in the auction for major independent television franchises, with the most attractive regions such as Thames, LWT, Granada, Central, TVS and Anglia likely to draw the toughest competition. 
 Deloitte predicts that European groups &mdash; many of which have far greater financial fire-power than the relatively small British television contractors &mdash; will be ready to pay substantial premiums to gain a foothold in the UK market. 
 The independent radio sector is also thought likely to attract foreign interest. 
 UK groups, such as Crown Communications &mdash; parent of LBC which yesterday sold its 12 per cent stake in Chiltern &mdash; are already forging Continental links. 
 EMS &bquo;could spell mass unemployment&equo;. 
 By Mark Milner 
 BRITAIN could face a decade of high unemployment if it became a full member of the European Monetary System without a sharp fall in the pound, according to a pressure group, the Campaign for Work. 
 In a robust assessment of the relative merits of joining the exchange rate mechanism, it argues the ERM will not provide a &bquo;soft option&equo; compared with other methods of slowing down the economy. 
 Though the group believes Britain should join, it warns that it should only do so at an exchange rate of around DM2.40 to the pound &mdash; involving a 15 per cent devaluation from the current DM2.79. 
 &bquo;A high exchange rate and the monetary policy which underpins it is just as tough an instrument as domestic credit controls, tax increases or cuts in public expenditure.&equo; 
 The campaign argues that the use of high exchange rates to squeeze inflation &mdash; by hitting corporate profits and therefore companies abilities to award inflationary pay increases &mdash; is &bquo;not a subtle process&equo; but is simply the &bquo;brutal and old fashioned one of deflation.&equo; 
 It claims there is no evidence that ERM membership offers a less painful way of suppressing the spiral of wages and prices chasing each other higher. 
 The campaign also argues that Britain's trade deficit is unsustainable. 
 But though high interest rates will achieve an economic slowdown, they will also ensure that the inevitable devaluation of the pound will be more severe. 
 British companies are divided over timing of EMS entry, survey shows. 
 By Mark Milner 
 ALMOST nine out of ten British businesses believe Britain should become a full member of the European Monetary System, but they are deeply divided about the timing, according to a survey published yesterday. 
 Only one in four favours the idea of Britain joining the exchange rate mechanism immediately, compared with more than 40 per cent who believe entry should be delayed until inflation has &bquo;substantially dropped&equo;. 
 The survey, which covered 93 of the UK's top 500 companies and 21 financial services groups, was carried out for accountants Ernst &amp; Young last month because of concern about level of understanding among business leaders of the issues involved in ERM membership. 
 According to Clive Williams, the managing partner of Ernst &amp; Young's management consultancy group, the conclusions have reinforced that concern. 
 &bquo;The survey demonstrates that the debate over membership of the ERM has become clouded by issues of personalities and politics. 
 &bquo;What has not been recognised is the difficulty of maintaining a stable exchange rate within the ERM unless British industry's costs rise no faster than those of our EC competitors.&equo; 
 Official figures are hard to credit as families fail to claim benefit. 
 By Mike George 
 ASTAGGERING number of the hard-up are failing to claim benefit under the Family Credit Scheme &mdash; despite a recent change in government calculations. 
 Families struggling on low incomes can get help from the scheme provided at least one adult is working at least 24 hours a week. 
 When it was introduced in place of the old family income supplement scheme last year, just 38 per cent of those entitled claimed family credit. 
 The government subsequently altered its estimate of those able to claim and came up with a 50 per cent take-up rate. 
 And now Tony Newton's social security department is hoping a recent &pound;7 million advertising campaign will boost that to 60 per cent. 
 Family credit is a means tested benefit paid on top of wages, or earnings from self employment. 
 It is almost always paid to a woman. 
 To qualify you must be responsible for one or more children aged under 16, or under 19 if they are still in full-time non-advanced education. 
 Your savings must total less than &pound;6,000 though &pound;1 of &bquo;notional income&equo; is added in when working out your income level for every &pound;250 (or part thereof) of savings over &pound;3,000. 
 Any children's savings are ignored, unless one of them has over &pound;3,000, in which case you can't get family credit for that child. 
 The scheme is based on a so-called &bquo;applicable amount&equo;, currently &pound;54.80 a week. 
 Anybody whose income is less than this will get full family credit. 
 The payments are based on set amounts: &pound;33.60 for a lone parent or a couple: &pound;23.30 for each child aged 18: &pound;16.35 for each child aged 16 or 17: &pound;12.90 for each child aged 11 to 15, and &pound;7.30 for each one up to 10 years of age. 
 If your income is above &pound;54.80 a week, 70 per cent of the additional amount is cut from the set payments. 
 Sheila is a lone parent with two children, aged 13 and 15. 
 She works part-time, averaging 28 hours a week. 
 After paying tax and national insurance she gets &pound;75 a week take home pay. 
 This is &pound;20.20 above the &pound;54.80 applicable amount, and 70 per cent of this is &pound;14.14. 
 Her set amounts are &pound;33.60 as a lone parent, plus &pound;25.80 for the children. 
 That totals &pound;59.40, but &pound;14.14 is deducted, leaving her total family credit at &pound;45.26 a week. 
 Child benefit payments, one parent benefit, housing benefit, income support and mobility and attendance allowances are all ignored as incomes for the purposes of family credit. 
 So Sheila's actual income is &pound;75 from earnings, plus &pound;14.50 child benefit (&pound;7.25 each), &pound;5.20 one parent benefit and &pound;45.26 from Family Credit. 
 Earnings are always taken net of tax and national insurance. 
 For those who are weekly paid, normal earnings are estimated by looking at the last five weeks pay, or the last two months for the monthly paid. 
 For the self-employed it is either the last 26 weeks or the last year's set of accounts which are used. 
 Self-employed child minders only have one third of their net earnings taken into account as income, the rest is ignored. 
 Family credit is also available on unemployment benefit, although this is counted as income. 
 Pam and Errol have two children, aged 13 and 16. 
 Errol is on unemployment benefit of &pound;34.70 a week, while Pam is bringing home &pound;75 a week. 
 This adds up to &pound;109.70, some &pound;54.90 above the applicable amount, and 70 per cent of that is &pound;38.43. 
 Their set amount for family credit is &pound;62.85, from which &pound;38.43 is deducted, leaving a final payment of &pound;24.42. 
 With child benefit included their income has been increased from &pound;124.20 to &pound;148.62 a week. 
 If one partner has been getting statutory sick or maternity pay for a continuous period of 13 weeks or more, this is counted as income. 
 Otherwise these payments are ignored. 
 Family credit lasts for 26 weeks at a time, then you will have to reapply. 
 However, it will end sooner if someone else claims income support or family credit in respect of a child who was included in your family credit award. 
 If you feel that your award is wrong in some way you can ask for the decision to be reviewed or make an appeal &mdash; details of how to do this are available from social security benefit offices. 
 If you're getting housing benefit this will be affected if you claim a family credit award, as your income will increase. 
 In some cases this may make the prospect of an award less attractive. 
 Some local authorities also assume you're getting family credit, even if you haven't claimed it, and so reduce your housing benefit. 
 Ferranti and Germans &bquo;reach deal&equo;. 
 By Mark Milner 
 TROUBLED defence electronics group Ferranti International Signal is reported to have reached a compromise with West Germany's Telefunken Systems Teknik over their rival bids to supply the radar for the European Fighter Aircraft. 
 However there were indications yesterday that it may be limited to proposals as to how the two would cooperate if they were ordered to combine their efforts by the NATO European Fighter Management Agency, which is responsible for purchasing the system. 
 There were also suggestions that Telefunken is already going cool on the terms of the compromise because they would not allow the West German group a large enough share of work on what is regarded as one of the key military avionics technologies. 
 The two firms are said to have indicated to NEFMA they would be able to work on the basis of Ferranti using a Telefunken-made data processor in its ECR-90 radar, he said. 
 The EFA radar contract is thought to be worth around &pound;1.5billion to the consortium which wins the contract. 
 Of the four partners in the EFA project, Britain, Italy and Spain are thought to favour the Ferranti consortium &mdash; which also includes West Germany's Siemens &mdash; but the West German government prefers the Telefunken option. 
 The deadlock has meant the award of the contract is now well behind the original schedule. 
 The outcome is crucial to the future of Ferranti in the wake of the discovery of bogus contracts at its ISC Technologies subsidiary which forced the group to write off more than &pound;200million. 
 Not only would winning the order mean around some &pound;60 million worth of work a year for the next decade for Ferranti, but it would give a successful bidder or partner for Ferranti access to crucial next-generation radar technology. 
 Analysts do not expect any move for Ferranti until the radar contract is awarded, though one possible bidder &mdash; British Aerospace &mdash; has already ruled itself out. 
 Industry sources however suggest that the contract is extremely important to Telefunken, which is now part of the giant Daimler-Benz industrial combine. 
 Daimler has increasingly concentrated its defence activities on aerospace and the loss of the EFA radar contract would be a severe blow. 
 Reports of the compromise emerged on the same day the contract for the EFA's main electrical generator was awarded to a consortium including Ferranti and Telefunken. 
 Bass sells off luxury hotel. 
 Bass, poised to become the world's biggest hotelier with the takeover of Holiday Inns in North America, is selling its Villa Magna luxury hotel in Madrid to Shirayama of Japan for &pound;50million. 
 Moody reviews debt. 
 Moody's, the influential US credit-rating agency, is reviewing its opinion of &dollar;248million worth (&pound;157million) of Dixons debt in the wake of this week's bid for the electronics retailer by Kingfisher. 
 Wall Street. 
 On Wall Street, the Dow Jones index closed 10 points up at 2,731.23. 
 Defence firms must take different tack in the new Europe Notebook. 
 By Edited by Alex Brummer 
 AFTER the string of contract calamities, which has sent the Serious Fraud Office globetrotting, Sir Derek Alun-Jones and his beleaguered Ferranti team must now see a small chink of light. 
 Instead of prolonging the dogfight with West Germany's Telefunken over their rival bids for the radar contract for the European Fighter Aircraft, the two hi-tech defence manufacturers have decided to do the really European thing and co-operate; Ferranti would use the Telefunken data-processor in its ECR-90 radar. 
 If this outline deal is approved by the authorities, it may put into question British Aerospace's abrupt decision to pull out of its Ferranti offer &mdash; or at least seek to renegotiate the deal. 
 But while the ups and downs of Ferranti's future remain of keen interest, not least to its management, workers and shareholders, there are wider questions to be addressed as the Nato European Fighter Management Agency plunges into its final decisions on the European Fighter Project. 
 What appeared an important strand in forward-looking European defence planning only a few years ago &mdash; when the new Europe sought a measure of independence from the US defence umbrella &mdash; looks more questionable now. 
 Who exactly is the Euro-fighter meant to defend Britannia and our European allies against now that the Berlin Wall is down, the Soviet Union is rushing towards disarmament and the Warsaw Pact has suddenly become the best investment opportunity since the post-war Marshall Plan? 
 Before embarking on what will inevitably be a huge investment, would it not be better to wait and see just how the next round of arms negotiations comes out. 
 If the after-Malta optimism is anything to go by, Europe may end up selling its costly fighter to Middle Eastern potentates. 
 This would almost certainly be at a loss. 
 Far better, perhaps, to concentrate on civil aviation. 
 US carriers and Lufthansa, among others, are champing at the bit for new Berlin and East German air routes now that the air corridors, carved out in 1948, are becoming obsolete. 
 The East German airline Interflug and even Aeroflot have placed modest orders for the Airbus, which could quickly become vast were air corridors and airports to be opened and hard currency loans to become more freely available as Western economic assistance begins to flow. 
 Far better to build more advanced Airbuses for a new market than a Euro-fighter to take on a non-existent enemy which is increasingly an economic partner. 
 We must not let our defences down, Mrs Thatcher and other cautious voices would argue. 
 They are right. 
 There may well be new instabilities. 
 Even so, it would still be far cheaper to do what Europe had planned, before an upsurge of Euro-nationlism, and buy US 
 F-15s and F-16s off the shelf rather than waste vast development costs which could be better deployed in the commercial sector. 
 It may not be what Ferranti wants to hear. 
 But for others in civil aviation, from BAA (which has been looking at airport facilities in Budapest) to carriers such as KLM and Interflug, which are anxious for the markets, it would be just the thing. 
 Running risks. 
 THE Lloyd's of London insurance market has an unhappy knack of slipping on banana skins. 
 That probably accounts for some of the scepticism after the decision to ape stock market precedent and end business barriers between underwriters. 
 Few would question Lloyd's determination to win business which now walks past its door and into rivals such as Commercial Union. 
 No one would doubt the market's need to deploy its &pound;11billion capacity more effectively &mdash; some marine syndicates work at less than half strength while syndicates in different businesses are pushing their limits. 
 Lloyd's needs to get a grip on more &bquo;safe&equo; business to offset its increasing tendency to be at the wrong end of big disasters such as Piper Alpha. 
 And the market needs to establish its credentials in Europe unless it wants to risk being a perpetual also-ran to the likes of Generali, Allianz or Swiss Re. 
 But occasional forays by underwriters into unknown territory have thrown up some of the market's most spectacular disasters &mdash; the 1,600 investors facing &pound;305million of losses on Dick Outhwaite's syndicate bear eloquent testimony to that. 
 Professional qualifications in the market are few, although basic examinations are being introduced. 
 Lloyd's is insisting underwriters must join the market association for the class of business they undertake, but quality policing will fall on the shoulders of managing agents. 
 In practice, the hoped-for package business will probably be handled by composite syndicates formed from the merger of existing specialists, so the quality of underwriting judgment should not deteriorate. 
 But it is unlikely &mdash; despite disclosure of business rules &mdash; that the less aware will not find themselves on a spectacularly high-risk syndicate which had in the past played safe. 
 Abolition of the business class regulations is a potentially liberating move. 
 The market must hope, however, that its business units do not emulate the mistakes which occurred after the City's Big Bang and that the risky business of being a Lloyd's investor becomes no more precarious. 
 Taking heart. 
 INFLATION causes havoc, we all know that. 
 But there is havoc and havoc. 
 First, there is the kind that keeps the UK out of the exchange rate mechanism (ERM) of the European Monetary System. 
 Then there is the South American strain. 
 Glass maker Pilkington yesterday bit the bullet over the Latin variety yesterday, taking a &pound;4.4million write down against its Argentinian assets. 
 The reason? 
 A burst of hyperinflation that Pilkington's mathematicians reckon hit 73 million per cent per annum. 
 However, they are taking heart that it is now back to a comfortable 250 per cent. 
 Erm&hellip;! 
 Graduates in engineering shun profession Frontiers of work. 
 Andrew Cornelius Industrial Editor. 
 THE recruitment and image crisis facing British industry was cruelly exposed yesterday by a report which revealed that two out of three university engineering students graduating this year decided against a career in engineering. 
 A huge proportion of students, many sponsored by companies, were actually &bquo;turned off&equo; an engineering career by their experience of working in engineering firms. 
 According to the survey, 44 per cent of the sponsored students among the 14,000 engineers graduating in 1989 claimed that their work experience, averaging 13 months, has discouraged them from a career in engineering. 
 Further questioning showed that 58 per cent said they &bquo;knew nothing&equo; about the average engineering company and only 8 per cent felt &bquo;well informed.&equo; 
 According to students, company recruitment presentations were often &bquo;downright boring&equo;, made either by people who do not understand engineering, or engineers who are &bquo;past it&equo;. 
 Around 60 per cent accused companies of issuing &bquo;untruthful&equo; recruitment brochures. 
 The survey arose because two final year students at Imperial College gambled with &pound;6,000 of savings to establish a research company to plug the information gap between engineering industry and the students they wish to recruit. 
 Introducing the report, which was eventually sponsored by 12 top companies, including BP, Hewlett Packard and ICI, Lord Caldecote said that the study was the first &bquo;to present a student's eye view of the ills and problems surrounding a career in engineering&equo;. 
 He said it had to be seen in the context of the UK's &pound;25billion a year deficit on trade in manufactured goods, a 22 per cent fall in enrolment for engineering courses since 1985 and the forecast decrease in the number of 16- to 24-year-olds by the mid-1990's. 
 Mr Bruce Hepburn, the 24-year-old former student who helped found the Imperial Ventures company which commissioned the survey, said if companies did not improve their image &bquo;they will go out of business&equo;. 
 He said some of Britain's top engineering companies were among those criticised by students. 
 The best-received firms were in the information technology and electronics sectors; the worst in traditional engineering sectors and construction. 
 The IVL report was based on a sample of 1,854 students, or one in 14 of the 14,000 who graduated this year. 
 It showed that only 35 per cent of the survey sample intended to pursue careers as engineers in industry. 
 A similar percentage opted for management careers, with a further 12 per cent opting for careers in commerce, management consultancy, accountancy or the City. 
 Sexual discrimination is also seen to be an important factor in turning female graduates away from engineering. 
 The survey showed that there was &bquo;unofficial&equo; discrimination against them in industry and 59 per cent said the engineering career structure worked against women succeeding. 
 Boesky back in town. 
 By Mary Brasier in New York 
 IVAN Boesky, the former Wall Street takeover speculator sentenced to three years in prison for insider trading, has been released from his California jail and is living within commuting distance of Wall Street, looking for a new job. 
 Mr Boesky's return to his old haunts comes with four months of his sentence still to run. 
 The once powerful arbitrageur, who dominated the takeover scene on Wall Street until his arrest in November 1986, is living in a Federal centre in the suburbs of Brooklyn, known as a halfway house between prison and the outside world. 
 The centre boasts fewer sporting facilities than the Lompoc prison camp in California, which offered inmates the chance to improve their tennis and basketmaking skills. 
 The Brooklyn house provides a gym, a library and television. 
 Mr Boesky is free to leave the centre during the day to look for work or meet his lawyers, but has to report back by 6pm. 
 Speculation that he had turned his back on the fast world of Wall Street finance was fuelled by reports that he has spent his time in prison studying the Jewish religion. 
 The financial community was also shocked by a recent photograph showing him looking like a down and out with flowing locks and a long white beard and wearing dirty jeans and trainers. 
 When Mr Boesky arrived at the Brooklyn centre earlier this week, he was seen wearing a suit, carrying a duffel bag and with his hair short and his face shaven, although the sleek look of his heyday in the early eighties was gone. 
 If he finds a job, it is not likely to be on Wall Street and he would have to hand a quarter of his earnings back to the Brooklyn centre. 
 The fallen arbitrageur has already paid &dollar;100million in fines for his offences and faces further costs from angry investors who are suing him, claiming they were cheated by his insider dealing. 
 Now Outhwaite strikes a deal. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 BELEAGUERED Lloyd's underwriter, Dick Outhwaite, has struck a &dollar;62million deal with the syndicate run by market chairman Murray Lawrence which settles the largest disputed claim against him. 
 Murray Lawrence &amp; Partners, which stressed that Mr Lawrence had not been involved in recent negotiations, said it would receive &dollar;20 million next January, another &dollar;20.8million in July and &dollar;22 million in January 1996. 
 Representatives of the 1,600 investors on Mr Outhwaite's syndicate, who face losses of &pound;305 million, welcomed the settlement, although spokesman Peter Nutting feared it would increase total losses. 
 &bquo;The fact that this is being paid up to 1996 is not good news,&equo; said Mr Nutting. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't have expected claims to become due before 2005 or 2010, so the payment has been accelerated.&equo; 
 The investors suspect that accelerated payments are the price Mr Outhwaite has had to pay to settle the disputes with other syndicates. 
 By paying claims in advance, they fear Mr Outhwaite could pay more in the long term. 
 Investors were also warned recently that the falling value of the pound might affect syndicate performance. 
 They fear the deterioration of the value of the pound against the dollar may mean Mr Outhwaite is poised to demand another &pound;60 million in cash from them &mdash; cash calls totalling &pound;168 million have already been paid. 
 Three major contracts and another 19 minor ones are outstanding, but Mr Outhwaite yesterday declined to say whether he would have to increase the &pound;305 million reserves he has set aside. 
 Under the latest settlement, which follows large payments to other syndicates, Mr Outhwaite will be entitled to reimbursement from Murray Lawrence &amp; Partners if the eventual claims level falls below &dollar;62million. 
 New blow for Bond's crumbling empire. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 THE KEY company in Australian tycoon Alan Bond's crumbling empire was yesterday threatened with receivership by a rival entrepreneur, John Spalvins, who heads the Adelaide Steamship group. 
 Mr Spalvins holds a crucial 20 per cent stake in Bell Resources and asked Australia's High Court to appoint a receiver to the company. 
 He also threatened to call in the receiver to Mr Bond's master corporation and to his private family company, Dallhold Investments &mdash; the firm which sits at the top of the whole debt-laden business structure. 
 &bquo;The assets of Bell Resources are in serious jeopardy if a receiver is not appointed in the very near future,&equo; said Adelaide Steamship's lawyer, George Palmer. 
 The move came as the Bond group disclosed that the fifth deadline for its A&dollar;2.5billion brewing deal with New Zealand's Lion Nathan had passed without agreement, and that the basis of talks was to change. 
 Bell Resources is a crucial element in the deal, since Mr Bond planned to sell it his Australian brewing interests &mdash; including Castlemaine XXXX &mdash; and then launch a bid for the enlarged group with the backing of Lion Nathan. 
 The shuffling of Mr Bond's brewing assets is considered pivotal to the Bond Corporation's ability to resolve its A&dollar;8billion debt crisis and to the survival of his brewing, property and media empire. 
 But his group also faces the threat of liquidation proceedings over a A&dollar;150million disputed indemnity agreement. 
 Mr Spalvins &mdash; one of the few Australian entrepreneurs still to hold his head high &mdash; declared his intention of imposing five directors on Bell Resources. 
 Initially Mr Bond gave his approval, but it is understood that sanction has subsequently been withdrawn. 
 Mr Bond's attempts to use the cash in Bell Resources &mdash; acquired from the toppled Australian raider, Robert Holmes a Court, last year &mdash; have been hampered from the start by Mr Spalvins. 
 The Bond organisation, however, succeeded in securing a &bquo;deposit&equo; of A&dollar;1.2billion from Bell Resources for the brewery business, which Mr Spalvins has insisted must be repaid if the Lion Nathan deal does not go through. 
 The original agreement with Lion Nathan was disclosed on September 19 and has subsequently been postponed five times. 
 Tourist Board faces probe. 
 The Welsh Tourist Board's system of recommending self-catering holiday accommodation is to be investigated by the Office of Fair Trading for &bquo;possible anti-competitive practices&equo;. 
 The board only markets accommodation which has passed an inspection for which it charges a fee. 
 Chairman, Prys Edwards, said the scheme aimed to protect holidaymakers. 
 Cable&amp;Wireless boost. 
 The contract to operate a mobile telephone service in West Germany has been awarded to the Mannesmann-led consortium, which includes Britain's Cable &amp; Wireless. 
 Macarthy bows out. 
 Pharmacy chain Macarthy has dropped attempts to have a sales promotion scheme by drugs retailer UniChem declared illegal. 
 Eagle Trust move. 
 Eagle Trust, the beleaguered mini-conglomerate being investigated by the Serious Fraud Office, obtained High Court approval to remove the vote from a further 80,000 shares to add to the 67,420,000 already disenfranchised. 
 PowerGen deal. 
 PowerGen, one of the two CEGB successor generating companies, has struck the first direct sale power contract before privatisation. 
 The &pound;50 million deal involves supplies to Toyota's new factory in Derbyshire. 
 Casino talks off. 
 Stanley Leisure has broken off talks with Leisure Investments &mdash; now at the centre of a bid from Bear Brand &mdash; over the planned purchase of Aspinall's Casino in London. 
 Short and sweet. 
 Short Brothers has won two orders worth &pound;40 million for its Javelin close-air defence weapon system from the Ministry of Defence and an unnamed country. 
 Going Down Under. 
 A sharp rise in the number of Australian companies appointing receivers and liquidators has been reported by the National Companies and Securities Commission. 
 Wall Street falls. 
 The Dow Jones Industrial Average closed down 15.99 points at 2,720.78. 
 UAL in new bid talks. 
 By Mary Brasier in New York 
 NEW ATTEMPTS are underway to revive Wall Street's most celebrated failed deal &mdash; the buyout of United Airlines which collapsed spreading chaos on the stock market two months ago &mdash; with little enthusiasm for a revised offer for the company before next year. 
 UAL chairman Stephen Wolf, who is under pressure from the rest of his board to deliver the company from its limbo state since the original &dollar;6.75billion buyout plan was dropped, began another round of talks this week with the airline's employees and union leaders to raise support for a bid likely to be worth as little as &dollar;4.5billion. 
 Wall Street is not holding its breath waiting for a new deal. 
 The latest talks, which began with a meeting planned between the flight attendants union and management on Wednesday to discuss a new labour contract are not expected to produce firm proposals and the next bid for United Airlines may not get off the ground until well into 1990. 
 Mr Wolf is involved in negotiations with Chicago financier Jay Pritzker, whose interests include the Hyatt hotel chain and who has considered bids for other US airlines such as Eastern and NWA in the past year. 
 But financing for a fresh bid remains the main hurdle. 
 Wall Street is sceptical that a link with Mr Pritzker will materialise, leaving UAL to find an equity partner to replace British Airways, which had agreed to put up &dollar;750million for a 15 per cent stake in the buyout consortium. 
 BA is keeping its distance from attempts by Stephen Wolf and Jay Pritzker to revive the bidding consortium, but there are still hopes in the US that it could be persuaded to step in at the last minute to add weight to a new bid. 
 BA still has a marketing agreement with United, which it is keen to preserve and the appointment last week of Sir Gordon White of Hanson Industries to the BA board is seen as improving the airline's negotiating skills in the US. 
 PAGE 
 Overseas comfort for Pilkington. 
 By Mark Milner 
 AS CLOUDS gather over the UK economy, glass maker Pilkington yesterday drew comfort from the international spread of its windows and windscreens to contact lenses operations. 
 Chairman Antony Pilkington acknowledged concern that high interest rates were beginning to hit some UK customers. 
 But he added that, with three-quarters of the company's business now overseas, foreign exchange rates were moving in the right direction. 
 At the interim stage, Pilkington turned in pre-tax profits up 6per cent to &pound;147 million and a 10per cent increase in the dividend to 2.93p a share. 
 &bquo;We regard it as a very satisfactory half year, bearing in mind that the world's economies are not quite as clear cut as they were a year ago. 
 We think this is a solid performance.&equo; 
 The core flat and safety glass business ground out another steady improvement, with Pilkington seeking to add value with products such as its &bquo;K&equo; glass. 
 Though the outlook for the UK is not as bright as it might be and the US is likely to take a knock from an end of price discounting in the car market, Europe looks set to turn in another strong performance. 
 The visioncare business, which Pilkington has been nurturing for three years and where it now ranks in the world's top three, increased its operating profits by &pound;4.4 million to &pound;18.8 million. 
 Though Mr Pilkington cautions against over-optimistic expectations, he is confident that the visioncare business is firmly on track. 
 There have been hiccups &mdash; the UK government decision to introduce eye tests, for example, brought a bulge in demand which has been followed with a corresponding flat patch &mdash; but the group reckons the long term is promising as ageing populations and greater access to markets such as India and China boost demand. 
 However, the defence related optronics business hit a sticky patch and lost &pound;4.8 million &mdash; though Pilkington said the bulk of that stemmed from redundancy costs. 
 The group is still looking for possible partners for its optronics operations, though it insists that so far there have only been talks, not negotiations. 
 The group's jointly-owned South African business produced another strong performance and Mr Pilkington is dismissive of suggestions that his group might consider disinvestment. 
 Better for the employees and pensioners, he said yesterday, for Pilkington to stay and run the business as it runs its UK operations. 
 Going crackers over Christmas? 
 Then give your gift ideas a financial flavour. 
 FINANCIAL gifts could be the answer for friends and relatives who've got everything this Christmas. 
 Telephone savings stamps at &pound;1 each, TV licence stamps in 50p denominations, or water bill savings stamps, at &pound;1 and &pound;2 each are a good idea for elderly hard-pressed relatives. 
 The post office is also the place to buy Premium Bonds; minimum &pound;10 for those aged under 16 or &pound;100 for those aged 16 or over. 
 The Royal Mint sells modern coins from a keepsake set of all seven uncirculated 1989 coins at &pound;5.75 to expensive commemorative sovereigns. 
 Old and antique coins can be bought from specialist dealers like Spink and Son in London (Tel: 01-930 7888). 
 A famous Bun penny in mint condition or a King Henry II penny sell for around &pound;50. 
 A 2,000-year-old Roman coin or and Elizabeth I sixpence go for just under &pound;100, while a William the Conqueror silver penny is a little more. 
 Spinks also sell old English banknotes, which are more likely to rise steadily in value. 
 A black and white &pound;5 note, printed between 1920 and 1956, costs from &pound;20. 
 Those in mint condition have doubled in value over the last two years to around &pound;50. 
 More plentiful are Second World War &pound;1 notes going for &pound;4 to &pound;5, while the rarer 10 shilling notes cost around &pound;10. 
 Tim Robson of auctioneers Sotheby's says that Latin American railways bonds depicting trains and elaborately coloured Chinese bonds are some of the prettiest notes around. 
 Both are available for under &pound;20 from dealers such as Westcombe Investments (P.O.Box 84, Leatherhead, Surrey KT22 ODC). 
 You can find out more from the Bond and Share Society (secretary Peter Duppa-Miller on 0305-262697) or through the largest UK dealer Michael Veissid (06944-268). 
 Presents that will help with financial planning include two books from the Consumers' Association: Which? 
 Way to Save and Invest (&pound;10.95) and Getting the Best Deal for Your Money (&pound;6.95), both published by Hodder &amp; Stoughton. 
 Money gifts for children include cash deposited in special children's building society and bank accounts which usually have free gifts when new accounts are open. 
 But do not be dazzled by the free pens, badges, money boxes and radios. 
 Gross-paying accounts are best for most children as long as their gross annual income does not exceed their personal tax-free allowance; &pound;2,785 for the tax year 1989/90. 
 While tax deducted at source from certain investment income, such as UK share dividends, is reclaimable by non-taxpayers, the composite-rate tax deducted at source from interest paid by banks and building society accounts is not. 
 Therefore, for a child, compare the net interest rate paid out by the banks and building societies with the gross rate paid by others, notably National Savings products. 
 Parents, however, should remember that if they give their child an investment that produces over &pound;5 annual income, it will usually be taxed as their own unless the child is over 18 or married. 
 Although no incentive frills are attached to a National Savings Investment Account, the variable interest rate paid gross (currently 11.75 per cent) tends to be around 3 per cent higher than the best net rates offered by the major competitors. 
 An account can be opened at any post office with a minimum of &pound;5. 
 As with most child accounts, children cannot make withdrawals until they are seven. 
 This is the best deal, although it differs from the bank and building society accounts in requiring one month's notice for withdrawals. 
 Parents opening accounts will find that The Royal Bank of Scotland's Rainbow Savings account comes out top of the major high street banks, paying 8.25 per cent net, followed by the Bank of Scotland's Supersaver at 7.82 per cent. 
 Both require a minimum investment of &pound;1, give instant access and include gifts. 
 Of the larger building societies, Chelsea is offering 10.25 per cent net and Britannia 8.5 per cent. 
 It is also worth looking at the smaller, regional building societies. 
 Some offer comparable, even higher, net rates than the Investment Account's gross rate, though there can be a small catch. 
 The Sheffield, for example, currently offers the best rate at 12.36 net, but only children whose parents or grandparents are existing savers may open an account and there is a maximum investment of &pound;500. 
 The latest survey by Which? magazine rates accounts from Leek United &amp; Midland, and Harpenden, paying net rates of 11.44 and 11.41 respectively, as the next best deals. 
 For longer-term investments, a good guaranteed rate for non-taxpaying children is offered by National Savings Capital Bonds. 
 Left untouched for five years, a minimum investment of &pound;100 in the Series A bond is guaranteed to grow to &pound;176.24; a compound rate of 12 per cent gross per year. 
 Leaflets on all National Savings products are available at post offices. 
 To compare the latest rates and conditions on children's accounts, look at Blay's Money Master monthly tables at your local reference library. 
 An alternative could be high coupon gilts as the tax can be reclaimed. 
 But with the present high interest rates they do not form a great investment. 
 Curiously, the unit trust industry &mdash; usually quick to hype its products &mdash; has been rather slow to attract children. 
 This may be because nobody under 18 can own unit trusts in their own names. 
 Parents could buy units for their children but there is only one group that has tried to target children &mdash; the MIM Rupert Trust. 
 Even so, all that can be done here is designate a unit holder under 18, the child is only a beneficial owner. 
 However to attract parents and others to invest on behalf of the child the initial investment is &pound;50, with additional payments of &pound;25 or a monthly savings plan of &pound;10. 
 The charges of a 5 per cent initial fee, 1.25 per cent annual, are standard. 
 The plan can be attractive to anybody other than a parent making a gift to a child. 
 In that case the tax deducted on the dividends can be reclaimed provided it is meant for a non tax paying child. 
 But if parents buy it for the child the dividend is considered part of the parents income. 
 As for direct exposure to the stock market, the advice of Malcolm Roberts of Montague Fleming is: &bquo;It would not be advisable to buy shares in the name of a child under 16. 
 You get all sorts of practical problems like can they sign transfer forms and many Registrars would refuse to accept them. 
 What parents can do is buy in both their names with an account designation of up to three letters which would be the child's initial. 
 They should not mark it as trustee because Registrars would not accept it.&equo; 
 Money Guardian is edited by Personal Finance Editor Margaret Hughes 
 Going crackers over Christmas? 
 Then give your gift ideas a financial flavour. 
 FINANCIAL gifts could be the answer for friends and relatives who've got everything this Christmas. 
 Telephone savings stamps at &pound;1 each, TV licence stamps in 50p denominations, or water bill savings stamps, at &pound;1 and &pound;2 each are a good idea for elderly hard-pressed relatives. 
 The post office is also the place to buy Premium Bonds; minimum &pound;10 for those aged under 16 or &pound;100 for those aged 16 or over. 
 The Royal Mint sells modern coins from a keepsake set of all seven uncirculated 1989 coins at &pound;5.75 to expensive commemorative sovereigns. 
 Old and antique coins can be bought from specialist dealers like Spink and Son in London (Tel: 01-930 7888). 
 A famous Bun penny in mint condition or a King Henry II penny sell for around &pound;50. 
 A 2,000-year-old Roman coin or and Elizabeth I sixpence go for just under &pound;100, while a William the Conqueror silver penny is a little more. 
 Spinks also sell old English banknotes, which are more likely to rise steadily in value. 
 A black and white &pound;5 note, printed between 1920 and 1956, costs from &pound;20. 
 Those in mint condition have doubled in value over the last two years to around &pound;50. 
 More plentiful are Second World War &pound;1 notes going for &pound;4 to &pound;5, while the rarer 10 shilling notes cost around &pound;10. 
 Tim Robson of auctioneers Sotheby's says that Latin American railways bonds depicting trains and elaborately coloured Chinese bonds are some of the prettiest notes around. 
 Both are available for under &pound;20 from dealers such as Westcombe Investments (P.O.Box 84, Leatherhead, Surrey KT22 ODC). 
 You can find out more from the Bond and Share Society (secretary Peter Duppa-Miller on 0305-262697) or through the largest UK dealer Michael Veissid (06944-268). 
 Presents that will help with financial planning include two books from the Consumers' Association: Which? 
 Way to Save and Invest (&pound;10.95) and Getting the Best Deal for Your Money (&pound;6.95), both published by Hodder &amp; Stoughton. 
 Money gifts for children include cash deposited in special children's building society and bank accounts which usually have free gifts when new accounts are open. 
 But do not be dazzled by the free pens, badges, money boxes and radios. 
 Gross-paying accounts are best for most children as long as their gross annual income does not exceed their personal tax-free allowance; &pound;2,785 for the tax year 1989/90. 
 While tax deducted at source from certain investment income, such as UK share dividends, is reclaimable by non-taxpayers, the composite-rate tax deducted at source from interest paid by banks and building society accounts is not. 
 Therefore, for a child, compare the net interest rate paid out by the banks and building societies with the gross rate paid by others, notably National Savings products. 
 Parents, however, should remember that if they give their child an investment that produces over &pound;5 annual income, it will usually be taxed as their own unless the child is over 18 or married. 
 Although no incentive frills are attached to a National Savings Investment Account, the variable interest rate paid gross (currently 11.75 per cent) tends to be around 3 per cent higher than the best net rates offered by the major competitors. 
 An account can be opened at any post office with a minimum of &pound;5. 
 As with most child accounts, children cannot make withdrawals until they are seven. 
 This is the best deal, although it differs from the bank and building society accounts in requiring one month's notice for withdrawals. 
 Parents opening accounts will find that The Royal Bank of Scotland's Rainbow Savings account comes out top of the major high street banks, paying 8.25 per cent net, followed by the Bank of Scotland's Supersaver at 7.82 per cent. 
 Both require a minimum investment of &pound;1, give instant access and include gifts. 
 Of the larger building societies, Chelsea is offering 10.25 per cent net and Britannia 8.5 per cent. 
 It is also worth looking at the smaller, regional building societies. 
 Some offer comparable, even higher, net rates than the Investment Account's gross rate, though there can be a small catch. 
 The Sheffield, for example, currently offers the best rate at 12.36 net, but only children whose parents or grandparents are existing savers may open an account and there is a maximum investment of &pound;500. 
 The latest survey by Which? magazine rates accounts from Leek United &amp; Midland, and Harpenden, paying net rates of 11.44 and 11.41 respectively, as the next best deals. 
 For longer-term investments, a good guaranteed rate for non-taxpaying children is offered by National Savings Capital Bonds. 
 Left untouched for five years, a minimum investment of &pound;100 in the Series A bond is guaranteed to grow to &pound;176.24; a compound rate of 12 per cent gross per year. 
 Leaflets on all National Savings products are available at post offices. 
 To compare the latest rates and conditions on children's accounts, look at Blay's Money Master monthly tables at your local reference library. 
 An alternative could be high coupon gilts as the tax can be reclaimed. 
 But with the present high interest rates they do not form a great investment. 
 Curiously, the unit trust industry &mdash; usually quick to hype its products &mdash; has been rather slow to attract children. 
 This may be because nobody under 18 can own unit trusts in their own names. 
 Parents could buy units for their children but there is only one group that has tried to target children &mdash; the MIM Rupert Trust. 
 Even so, all that can be done here is designate a unit holder under 18, the child is only a beneficial owner. 
 However to attract parents and others to invest on behalf of the child the initial investment is &pound;50, with additional payments of &pound;25 or a monthly savings plan of &pound;10. 
 The charges of a 5 per cent initial fee, 1.25 per cent annual, are standard. 
 The plan can be attractive to anybody other than a parent making a gift to a child. 
 In that case the tax deducted on the dividends can be reclaimed provided it is meant for a non tax paying child. 
 But if parents buy it for the child the dividend is considered part of the parents income. 
 As for direct exposure to the stock market, the advice of Malcolm Roberts of Montague Fleming is: &bquo;It would not be advisable to buy shares in the name of a child under 16. 
 You get all sorts of practical problems like can they sign transfer forms and many Registrars would refuse to accept them. 
 What parents can do is buy in both their names with an account designation of up to three letters which would be the child's initial. 
 They should not mark it as trustee because Registrars would not accept it.&equo; 
 Money Guardian is edited by Personal Finance Editor Margaret Hughes PAGE 
 Costs of sending &pound;50 abroad by various methods BarclaysLloydsMidland&verbar;ONatWestRBS International Money Order&pound;5 &pound;4-- &pound;3 Banker's Draft&pound;9 &pound;8 &pound;6 &pound;7 &pound;6 Electronic Transfer standard &pound;12.50 &pound;8&pound;15 &pound;6 &pound;6 express &pound;12.50&pound;15&pound;15 &pound;7&pound;10 Note (1): Services offered only to existing customers. 
 Us generation will be on the lookout for Our Shop Saturday notebook. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 WATCH OUT for another public display of City myopia. 
 Over the next two months, we will be subjected to a barrage of argument, statistics and plain propaganda from Woolworths (yes, call it Kingfisher if you want, but most people will still think of it as Woolies) and from Dixons. 
 From Dixons, we will hear that the company should retain its independence because its current trading woes are a product of a consumer squeeze over which it has no control and because it will make lots of money when times get better and we have more spare cash with which to buy new tellies, video recorders, fridges etc. 
 From Woolworths, we will hear that the Dixons management have brought their troubles on themselves, that their attempts to cope with the downturn have been lamentable and that only a new team &mdash; with a more analytical approach than the pile-it-high philosophy which did Dixons so proud when times were good &mdash; can engineer the necessary closure of small high street outlets in favour of a move to larger ones on the edge of town. 
 This is how the argument will be fought. 
 And it is on these grounds that the City will make up its mind about whether to give Dixons' Stanley Kalms a chance or to pocket the &pound;460million on offer from Woolworths' Geoff Mulcahy. 
 The City will bang a few numbers into its computers, mutter something about sector relative p/e ratios and come up with an answer: yes or no. 
 It will fail to ask the rather broader and much more important question about retailing: how is the great British public likely to be doing its shopping in five or 10 years' time? 
 Will every British high street look the same, with the same familiar handful of names dominating the shopfronts from Penzance to Perth? 
 Extrapolate the trends of the last 40 years and such a depressing scenario looks like a dead cert. 
 (Mind you, if you had extrapolated the trend of Dixons sales in the mid-80s, you would have concluded that by the year 2020 we would be spending every penny of our income on consumer electronics.) 
 But wait. 
 Look at what Geoff Mulcahy was saying earlier this year: that within electronics retailing as a whole, the big national chains were losing market share to independent, one-person operations. 
 So although he was able to boast that his own Comet (which, with Woolies, B&amp;Q and Superdrug, makes the four retailing legs of the Kingfisher group) was taking market share from other national chains, its share of the total electrical market was actually falling. 
 And that raises the first crucial question: in which branches of retailing do economies of scale give a real benefit to the big players? 
 In supermarkets, the evidence is all one way. 
 We apparently like large stores with lots of choice and a car park. 
 (The idea that supermarkets win customers because their goods are cheaper is passe; the battle for trade is now won or lost on range and convenience.) 
 And the Sainsburys, Tescos and Safeways of the world are the people with the financial clout and organisational know-how to spend the &pound;15million or so which it takes to buy the land, negotiate the planning hurdles, employ a builder and stock the shelves to open a new superstore on a good site. 
 Hence, Britain's five biggest supermarket groups now account for more than 60 per cent of all grocery sales. 
 In food retailing, bigger is better. 
 But with non-food shops, the picture is far less clear. 
 Electrical retailing provides one example where the one-person shop with its promise of good advice and after-sales service can score over the anonymity of a Dixons or a Comet. 
 With clothes, most of us like to believe that our tastes are idiosyncratic, which suggests that we will often go out of our way &mdash; and pay through the nose &mdash; to buy something a bit different. 
 Of course, there will always be room for a reassuring and reliable M&amp;S, Boots or WHSmith as a shop of last resort. 
 But as we move into the gentler, more thoughtful 1990s, Britain's big retailers &mdash; and the people who invest money in them &mdash; should bear three things in mind. 
 First, there always has been and always will be room for a small shopkeeper with a bright idea. 
 Big companies are vulnerable to such upstarts. 
 National chains rarely dream up new, successful and really different ventures themselves; they only ape &mdash; doubtless quite efficiently &mdash; the ideas of small innovative entrepreneurs. 
 Boots didn't think of Body Shop; it just copied the packaging. 
 WHSmith didn't create Our Price; it just took over the business. 
 Second, shoppers are a fickle lot. 
 Look at the high street favourites of five years ago and ask how well they're doing now: in the nineties we could be saying bye-bye Next and cheerio Habitat. 
 And third, if &mdash; and admittedly, this is a huge if &mdash; the next decade sees a retreat from the brash consumerism of the mid-1980s, one cannot resist the thought that it is small, local businesses which will better cope with, pander to and profit from the change in mood. 
 Big organisations are terribly bad at making a customer feel he or she is the most important person in the world. 
 In the nervous nineties, when the Me generation has grown into the Us generation, we will be looking for Our Shop rather than just an emporium where they stock personal stereos by the thousand. 
 And where will that leave Dixons &mdash; whoever owns it? 
 Mint turns the clock back to a time when sovereign was king of coins. 
 By Morag Campbell 
 FIVE hundred years ago King Henry VII instructed the officers of his Royal Mint, then in the Tower of London, to produce &bquo;a new money of gold.&equo; 
 Partly a public relations exercise to enhance the king's status, the coin was intended to convey the majesty of the throne and the dignity of the monarch &mdash; hence the name sovereign. 
 The present Royal Mint, now in Wales, has issued a set of commemorative coins to celebrate that 500th anniversary. 
 The original sovereign continued to be struck until 1603, when James I ascended the throne, but was revived in 1817. 
 Although this sovereign was half the weight and half the diameter of the original one, such was the international respect it enjoyed that people could travel through Europe confident that the coins would be welcomed wherever they went. 
 &bquo;Originally worth 20 shillings,&equo; the Royal Mint says, &bquo;the sovereign was the country's first pound coin.&equo; 
 Today, the price of a sovereign is &pound;149.95p, including VAT. 
 For that price, you get 7.98 grammes of 22 carat gold. 
 However, you would not get &pound;149.95p each if you fell on hard times and wanted to sell your sovereigns. 
 Rarity, the quality of the design, historical associations and, particularly, melt value all determine the maket value of gold coins. 
 In popular mythology, gold is regarded as a good investment. 
 In our collective folk memory &mdash; or possibly as a result of seeing too many old Hollywood movies &mdash; we think of gold in the form of coins as eminently portable in times of national emergency. 
 National emergencies, however, may not necessarily coincide with times of personal emergency and gold is an erratic investment. 
 In February 1980, for instance, 24 carat peaked at &dollar;850 an ounce. 
 Currently it stands just above &dollar;400 an ounce having tumbled in May this year to its lowest level since August 1986. 
 The popularity of South Africa's kruggerrand was due largely to the fact that collectors were buying a precise quantity of gold at only a fraction over the actual cost of the precious metal. 
 The imposition of VAT on the kruggerrand and other gold coins meant that gold had to rise by at least 20 per cent on their initial investment before a private collector could show a profit. 
 In similar fashion the bottom fell out of the illustrious 1817 sovereign market in the mid-1970s when investors realised that they were paying 50 per cent over the melt price for a coin minted in millions. 
 The three-coin set of Quincentenary commemorative gold coins &mdash; double-sovereign, sovereign and half-sovereign struck in 22 carat gold &mdash; is limited to an issue of 10,000 and costs &pound;499.95 including VAT. 
 Individual sovereign coins can also be bought separately. 
 While a collector may be happy to pay over the odds for such interesting issues, an investor would have to be confident of rising gold prices to show a profit on resale. 
 If you don't feel bold or rich enough to take a gamble on sovereigns, for only &pound;7.25, you can buy a presentation folder containing one each of the &pound;2 coins issued to commemorate the 300th anniversary of the Bill of Rights and the Scottish Claim of Rights. 
 And for &pound;9.95 you can purchase a Baby Pack &mdash; colour co-ordinated in pink or blue to the sex of the recipient &mdash; which not only includes a set of brilliant uncirculated 1989 coins but space to record baby's important details. 
 All coins issued by the Royal Mint can be viewed at 7 Grosvenor Gardens, London SW1. 
 Mail order is available through the Royal Mint Coin Club, Freepost, P.O.Box 500, Cardiff CF1 1YY. 
 Telephone 0443-223880. 
 Mint turns the clock back to a time when sovereigns were king coins. 
 By Morag Campbell 
 FIVE hundred years ago King Henry VII instructed the officers of his Royal Mint, then in the Tower of London, to produce &bquo;a new money of gold.&equo; 
 Partly a public relations exercise to enhance the king's status, the coin was intended to convey the majesty of the throne and the dignity of the monarch &mdash; hence the name sovereign. 
 The present Royal Mint, now in Wales, has issued a set of commemorative coins to celebrate that 500th anniversary. 
 The original sovereign continued to be struck until 1603, when James I ascended the throne, but was revived in 1817. 
 Although this sovereign was half the weight and half the diameter of the original one, such was the international respect it enjoyed that people could travel through Europe confident that the coins would be welcomed wherever they went. 
 &bquo;Originally worth 20 shillings,&equo; the Royal Mint says, &bquo;the sovereign was the country's first pound coin.&equo; 
 Today, the price of a sovereign is &pound;149.95p, including VAT. 
 For that price, you get 7.98 grammes of 22 carat gold. 
 However, you would not get &pound;149.95p each if you fell on hard times and wanted to sell your sovereigns. 
 Rarity, the quality of the design, historical associations and, particularly, melt value all determine the maket value of gold coins. 
 In popular mythology, gold is regarded as a good investment. 
 In our collective folk memory &mdash; or possibly as a result of seeing too many old Hollywood movies &mdash; we think of gold in the form of coins as eminently portable in times of national emergency. 
 National emergencies, however, may not necessarily coincide with times of personal emergency and gold is an erratic investment. 
 In February 1980, for instance, 24 carat peaked at &dollar;850 an ounce. 
 Currently it stands just above &dollar;400 an ounce having tumbled in May this year to its lowest level since August 1986. 
 The popularity of South Africa's kruggerrand was due largely to the fact that collectors were buying a precise quantity of gold at only a fraction over the actual cost of the precious metal. 
 The imposition of VAT on the kruggerrand and other gold coins meant that gold had to rise by at least 20 per cent on their initial investment before a private collector could show a profit. 
 In similar fashion the bottom fell out of the illustrious 1817 sovereign market in the mid-1970s when investors realised that they were paying 50 per cent over the melt price for a coin minted in millions. 
 The three-coin set of Quincentenary commemorative gold coins &mdash; double-sovereign, sovereign and half-sovereign struck in 22 carat gold &mdash; is limited to an issue of 10,000 and costs &pound;499.95 including VAT. 
 Individual sovereign coins can also be bought separately. 
 While a collector may be happy to pay over the odds for such interesting issues, an investor would have to be confident of rising gold prices to show a profit on resale. 
 If you don't feel bold or rich enough to take a gamble on sovereigns, for only &pound;7.25, you can buy a presentation folder containing one each of the &pound;2 coins issued to commemorate the 300th anniversary of the Bill of Rights and the Scottish Claim of Rights. 
 And for &pound;9.95 you can purchase a Baby Pack &mdash; colour co-ordinated in pink or blue to the sex of the recipient &mdash; which not only includes a set of brilliant uncirculated 1989 coins but space to record baby's important details. 
 All coins issued by the Royal Mint can be viewed at 7 Grosvenor Gardens, London SW1. 
 Mail order is available through the Royal Mint Coin Club, Freepost, P.O.Box 500, Cardiff CF1 1YY. 
 Telephone 0443-223880. 
 PAGE 
 Standard Chartered City HQ sold for &pound;145m. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 STANDARD Chartered Bank, the group with an uncomfortable level of exposure to the troubled Australian entrepreneur, Alan Bond, has sold its prestige headquarters building for &pound;145million as part of efforts to shore up its capital ratios. 
 The glitzy building &mdash; boasting an address on Bishopsgate, now one of the City's favoured streets &mdash; was opened just three years ago but became an obvious target once the bank needed to put the family silver up for auction to improve its financial standing. 
 The eight-storey office is being sold to the Japanese group, Kumagai, for a price which appears to belie the downturn in London's commercial property market. 
 Known for its gleaming and airy entrance lobby, bedecked with trees and tropical plants which became a night-time illumination, the building was regarded as one of the more tasteful and less controversial of the City's recently constructed edifices. 
 Dubbed by some as &bquo;the imperial palace&equo;, Standard's Bishopsgate offices were opened by the Queen and it is understood there was no shortage of potential bidders. 
 The bank, which paid &pound;70million to have its headquarters constructed, said it was &bquo;delighted&equo;, although it declined to say exactly what book profit it had made on the deal. 
 The transaction compares with other headline City property deals, such as the &pound;143million sale of the listed Financial Times building to Obhayashi and the &pound;140million sale of the River Plate building at Finsbury Circus. 
 The building group, Taylor Woodrow, has launched a joint venture with the major Japanese contractor, Mitsui Kensetsu, to develop top of the market UK residential and commercial property. 
 New blow for Bond, page 13 
 Move to scupper James Sherwood's defence plan. 
 By Daniel John 
 THE Anglo-Swedish consortium bidding for Sea Containers, the Sealink ferries-to-Orient Express group, yesterday raised its hostile offer to &dollar;1.036billion (&pound;659 million) in a move to scupper James Sherwood's defence plan which involves selling the Isle of Wight service and the port of Harwich. 
 Temple Holdings &mdash; the bidding vehicle being used by UK container company Tiphook and ferry operator Stena &mdash; moved to equal the share buy-back offer put together by SeaCo president Mr Sherwood after the Bermuda courts blocked its latest attempt to overturn the rescue terms. 
 The addition of another &dollar;7 a share to Temple's bid levels out the fight and gives SeaCo shareholders a straight choice between the existing management and the ambitious consortium who plan to split the assets between them. 
 The new offer was accompanied by a call for SeaCo to put Mr Sherwood's proposal to sell several assets to a vote of shareholders whose support is crucial to the &bquo;poison pill&equo; defence plan going ahead. 
 Deals have already been struck to dispose of &dollar;641million worth of businesses to American and UK buyers and any decision by shareholders to block them would be a fatal blow to the recapitalisation of the SeaCo group. 
 Mr Sherwood has offered to raise &dollar;1.1billion from the sell-offs, and would use at least half the proceeds to buy back stock from shareholders at &dollar;70 a share. 
 Attempts by Temple to have the plan and purchases of SeaCo shares by the group's subsidiaries ruled illegal have so far failed in the Bermudan courts. 
 By increasing its offer, Temple has taken the fight directly to SeaCo's shareholders. 
 It also put pressure on Mr Sherwood to call the company's long-delayed annual meeting to consider the bid by saying it would demand an extraordinary meeting in an attempt to vote in a new board of directors. 
 In a joint statement, Robert Montague, Tiphook's chairman, and Dan Olsson, chief executive of Stena, said Mr Sherwood should allow shareholders to decide SeaCo's future. 
 &bquo;We are confident that they will prefer our immediate all cash offer to the SeaCo board's highly conditional alternative to purchase half the shares at some unspecified future date.&equo; 
 Most of the cash top-up for the Temple bid is being provided by Stena which would end up with Sealink's lucrative cross-channel ferry business if the offer succeeds. 
 Tiphook, which has chipped in &dollar;14.8million towards the &dollar;103million &bquo;sweetener&equo;, will get the container operations. 
 Mr Sherwood reacted by saying that the new terms from Temple had once again delayed SeaCo's intention to set a date for the shareholder meeting. 
 Its board had planned to do that yesterday but this had now been postponed &mdash; a move the SeaCo president regretted. 
 Temple's decision to increase its offer had not come as a surprise, he said, and the SeaCo board would meet next week to consider its response. 
 However, it seems almost certain that Mr Sherwood and his team will reject the bid, which he has described as &bquo;inadequate&equo;. 
 SeaCo itself may come back with a slightly better offer as the sale of assets agreed so far is thought to have raised more money than was planned. 
 The biggest deals have involved the purchase of its cargo container business by the US giant, Genstar, for nearly &dollar;400million and the disposal of the IoW ferries to a company formed by the Cazyer and Iliffe families in Britain for &pound;107million. 
 A buyer has yet to be announced for Harwich, where SeaCo recently announced proposals for a &pound;200million industrial, leisure and residential development. 
 Midland to swap debt for Argentina equity stakes. 
 By Mark Milner 
 MIDLAND Bank is planning to swap a chunk of its &dollar;1.3billion Argentinian debt for stakes in some of the country's most important infrastructure projects. 
 The Argentinian Government, under President Carlos Menem, has announced ambitious plans to privatise large sections of the country's public sector, including its telephone system, Entel; the national airline, Aerolineas Argentinas; as well as road, rail, port and petro-chemical facilities. 
 Midland is linking up with an affiliate of the World Bank, International Finance Corporation, Banco Rio de la Plata &mdash; Argentina's largest bank &mdash; and the Bank of Tokyo, to set up an initial &dollar;500million fund which would swap existing debt for stakes in newly privatised operations. 
 Midland is expected to put &dollar;100million of its debt portfolio into the scheme but it will not be putting up any new money. 
 The move is seen as a way of helping to get the Argentinian privatisation programme off the ground and to make some inroads into the country's foreign debt, which currently totals some &dollar;60billion. 
 Debt-for-equity swaps have been used before in a number of South American countries, including Argentina, as banks have sought different ways of tackling the region's chronic debt problem. 
 Midland has already swapped a substantial part of its Chilean debt exposure for equity and has also been involved in similar, private sector, schemes in Argentina. 
 However, this is the first scheme in Argentina which involves equity stakes in privatisations. 
 Though debt-for-equity swaps represent one way for banks to recover part of their developing country debt exposure, they still stand to lose money and look likely to have to wait for some years before they can cash in their equity stakes. 
 Midland has currently made provisions against just over 50 per cent of its South American debt exposure, in line with Bank of England guidelines. 
 However, loans to Argentina are said to change hands at between 12 and 15 per cent of their face value in the secondary debt market. 
 Midland estimates that it will be able to trade its debt for equity stakes at between 30 per cent and 40 per cent of the face value of the loans &mdash; getting equity stakes valued between &dollar;30million and &dollar;40million in exchange for an existing &dollar;100million loan. 
 It is likely to be up to 10 years before the banks would be able either to sell their stake on the local stock market or to pass on their holdings to other investors. 
 The likely swap rates are also below existing provision levels. 
 However, a Midland Bank spokesman said the group expected the dividend flow from the investments acquired to be preferable to the dividend flow from its Argentinian loan portfolio. 
 TCS helps to bridge the gap between gown and town. 
 By Martyn Halsall Northern Industrial Correspondent 
 STUART RILEY, a marketing specialist at the University of Lancaster, recognised his role in industrial change when he was asked to wear a suit for factory visits. 
 Staff at the BICC wiring division headquarters on Merseyside crossed their divide when Riley recommended casual clothing for a discussion day he had arranged in the Lune Valley. 
 Such details are hardly at the heart of &bquo;introducing major operational change&equo;, which the Government's Teaching Company Scheme (TCS) proposes, but they form intriguing by-products. 
 They also illustrate the widening agenda of a project set for radical expansion before 1993. 
 The scheme was established by Labour in 1975 to harness the creativity of graduates, aged between 22 and 28, to companies seeking technological development. 
 It aims to echo in industry the teaching hospital experience available to young doctors. 
 After slow growth initially and reassessment under the Conservatives, the number of schemes expanded to around 350, employing 750 post-graduates today. 
 The target is 500 schemes by 1993, with a switch of emphasis towards small- and medium-sized companies. 
 Stuart Riley, at ease in Lancaster's academic village in a baggy woolly and corduroys, is part of the new wave. 
 He is helping to supervise three post-graduate associates in a marketing exercise for BICC, which marks a broadening of the scheme's primary role in manufacturing. 
 Mr Riley speaks highly of the BICC management team and the relationship between the company in gritty Prescott and the university on a rural hillside. 
 Any company involved in such a scheme has to be brave, Mr Riley says. 
 &bquo;Maybe they buy it for the wrong reason; they can get a lot of research they would otherwise not carry out. 
 But they have got to be able to say: &bquo;We will open ourselves up to a change agent&equo;&hellip; and change is painful.&equo; 
 His colleague Peter Spillard &mdash; his suit trousers sharply creased for a trip to the industrial heartland &mdash; adds: &bquo;They have to answer questions they have not needed to answer before.&equo; 
 Messrs Riley and Spillard &mdash; like another lecturer at Lancaster, Stuart Burge &mdash; stress the practical usefulness of their contact with TCS and its value in their teaching. 
 Companies profit from access to a network of university expertise far beyond individual scheme programmes and graduate associates mature rapidly, Dr Burge. 
 &bquo;I am frequently amazed at the change in them.&equo; 
 Experience from a two-year TC scheme could equal 10 or 15 years on the conventional industrial ladder. 
 Mal Gibb joined a Lancaster scheme after a degree in systems modelling at Sheffield Polytechnic and is now helping to develop computerised production at Nairn Kingfisher, a wallpaper plant on the Lancaster quayside. 
 He has appreciated the freedom to develop his work, the experience of dealing with everything from factory floor practicalities to board-room presentations, and the additional training which is 10 per cent of any scheme programme. 
 &bquo;The main benefit is that I've enjoyed it; that's my yardstick.&equo; 
 His supervisor engineering and operational research lecturer Jean Tunnicliffe-Wilson, says much of the satisfaction is not only in suggesting ideas but having them tested in practice. 
 &bquo;I don't get the same satisfaction just publishing ideas &mdash; I like to see them happening.&equo; 
 Yet publishing ideas could be a barrier to TCS expansion, says George Steele, head of technology with the Department of Industry in the North-west. 
 &bquo;Academics get on by publishing papers and TCS by it's very nature isn't research; it's technology transfer and doesn't give the same opportunity for publishing&hellip; 
 So some academics fear they might fall behind in the promotion race if they get involved with TCS.&equo; 
 Not all universities or academics agree. 
 Dr Burge has valued schemes as a source of research and some universities are now promoting both industrial contact and research experience. 
 The economic climate in higher education is also a constraint, says George Steele. 
 Higher education is very interested, &bquo;but they are strapped for resources and one of the problems of TCS is that it will cover all their costs, but it's not a way that a university or poly is going to make money.&equo; 
 For all its popularity, TCS is essentially a shoe-string operation with an annual government input of &pound;12million and an equal contribution from industry. 
 The goal for 1993 is that 60 per cent of participants will be companies with fewer than 500 employees. 
 People from European Community countries can be recruited on to British TC schemes but as yet the EC offers no equivalent. 
 Frontiers is edited by Peter Large 
 Insurance market's &bquo;momentous&equo; decision will spark head-on confrontation with leading corporate rivals Lloyd's of London rewrites its rules to take on the European competition. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 THE &pound;11BILLION a year Lloyd's of London insurance market is abandoning rules forcing underwriters to specialise in particular types of business so as to compete more effectively in Europe and against the big insurance companies. 
 The decision, described by investor representatives as &bquo;momentous&equo;, will bring Lloyd's into head-on competition with leading insurers such as Commercial Union, Prudential and Allianz. 
 In what is being seen as Lloyd's &bquo;Big Bang&equo;, the change should allow the giant insurance operation to move in on a growing slice of business which it has found elusive. 
 The move was interpreted by some as a concession to Lloyd's brokers who supply the market with its business. 
 It will mean that wide-ranging corporate risks will be able to be placed with just one underwriter. 
 For Lloyd's entire 300-year history its underwriters have been forced to specialise in one of the four traditional classes &mdash; marine, non-marine, aviation and motor. 
 But from now on underwriters will be able to take on risks in any sector and brokers will no longer be forced to traipse around the market to place different strands of business with individual underwriters. 
 Lloyd's has become acutely aware that it is losing business to large companies, notably in Britain and Europe. 
 Many of its syndicates are operating at less than 50 per cent of their capacity. 
 It admitted being hit by the growing trend of big companies to place all their insurance business on a single policy. 
 Senior market official, David Coleridge, said recently that Lloyd's had lost out to Commercial Union on a multi-million- pound contract from Trafalgar House because it was unable to offer a &bquo;package deal&equo;. 
 Bob Keville, chairman of the Lloyd's Insurance Brokers Committee, predicted the change was &bquo;bound to lead to more business coming Lloyd's way in future.&equo; 
 Sturge, the largest underwriting group at Lloyd's, said the ability to drop barriers &mdash; which will not be compulsory &mdash; would lead to mergers between syndicates and an improved use of capacity. 
 Boutique syndicates are likely to remain, however. 
 But independent analysts in the market predicted disaster. 
 They pointed to cases in the past when underwriters had incurred huge losses by moving into an unfamiliar area of business. 
 And they forecast that profits could be reduced even if the overall income level rose because of new business. 
 Anthony Haynes, chairman of the Association of Lloyd's Members &mdash; which represents market investors &mdash; said, however, he felt underwriting standards and the disclosure of syndicate business would improve. 
 &bquo;The barriers had ceased to be an effective protection for Names as those losing their shirts on marine syndicates are only too painfully aware,&equo; he said. 
 Lloyd's is keen not only to increase its market share but to broaden its spread of risks. 
 It wants to be less reliant on the depressed shipping industry but it also wants to shake off the tag of being the world's market of last resort and is determined to win safer contracts. 
 Apart from the big insrance companies around the world, Lloyd's already faces strong competition from the Institute of London Underwriters &mdash; a grouping of the marine underwriting departments of international companies &mdash; and is about to face further pressure with the establishment of the London Underwriting Centre, a similar company amalgam specialising in Lloyd's mainstream reinsurance business. 
 An executive in the London companies market dismissed the likely threat from Lloyd's. 
 &bquo;We already operate in a competitive market and Lloyd's is unlikely to make that much more difficult.&equo; 
 But we have been in this type of business for longer and will score on our expertise and we will also benefit from the ability we have through branch offices to handle claims.&equo; 
 The changes will not come into force until 1991 and Lloyd's stressed that it was attempting to introduce safeguards to ensure the market's underwriting standards did not deteroriate. 
 Agents, who are responsible for the underwriting syndicates, will be compelled to inform investors specifically about the type of business being handled and underwriters will be obliged to join the market association responsible for any class of insurance written. 
 The agency companies will also be responsible for ensuring that syndicates are capable of handling the business they take on. 
 John Gordon, chairman of the Lloyd's Underwriting Agents Association said his members welcomed the move. 
 &bquo;It will give the market extra flexibility and make it more attractive. 
 It also puts the responsibility for ensuring competence where it belongs &mdash; with the managing agent,&equo; Mr Gordon said. 
 New rules mean a set-back for army of casual workers. 
 By Linda Lennard 
 Unemployment benefit. 
 NEW rules to be introduced from tomorrow will hit many part-time workers receiving unemployment benefit. 
 Those who earn &pound;43 a week or more will lose benefit for the whole of that week &mdash; even if they work only part of it and are unemployed for the remaining days. 
 Only people who earn &pound;12 or less in any week will escape having their entitlement affected at all. 
 Anybody who earns between &pound;12 and &pound;43 in a given week may still be able to qualify for unemployment benefit on the days they are not working. 
 However, they will have to satisfy unemployment benefit officers that part-time work is not their usual pattern, and they are just doing it while looking for full-time employment. 
 In general, it has been accepted that people can take on part-time work in this way if it has not been their usual employment pattern. 
 But adjudication officers may eventually claim that part-time employment is your normal pattern, and that you should not be entitled to benefit on the days you don't work because you would not normally expect to be working anyway. 
 This so-called &bquo;full extent normal rule&equo; has come under considerable criticism from the Court of Appeal downwards. 
 The new rules coming in tomorrow effectively mean the end of the full extent normal rule for people earning &pound;12 or less in a week. 
 The government says the changes are interim measures and it intends to reconsider the whole question of the treatment of earnings received by people on unemployment benefit. 
 If you do any part-time work while on unemployment benefit and your earnings do not affect your benefit entitlement, you will still have to meet the rest of the conditions for this benefit on the remaining days. 
 These include a new stringent &bquo;actively seeking work&equo; test which was introduced this October, as well as showing that you are available for work the rest of the week. 
 As well as earnings from part-time work, other income can affect your entitlement to unemployment benefit. 
 If you are aged 55 or over and have a personal or occupational pension which is more than &pound;35 per week, the rest will be deducted from your benefit. 
 Money from a redundancy payment should not affect your right to this benefit. 
 Also note that if your partner earns more than &pound;21.40 the adult dependants increase will not be payable for her or him. 
 Water shares: public dive in. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 THE public has applied for more than half of the &pound;5.3billion water privatisation issue, with more than 1.4 million people signing cheques for an average of &pound;2,000. 
 Although counting of applications continues, the issue is 1.75 times oversubscribed so far, forcing financial advisers last night to &bquo;claw back&equo; shares promised to overseas institutions so as to meet small investor demand. 
 This will increase the shares on offer to the public from 23.5 per cent to nearly 30 per cent of the issue. 
 With 500 share sorters working round the clock, however, small investors could see their allocation rise to a ceiling of nearly 50 per cent if the issue is 2.25 times oversubscribed. 
 Prospects for the highest-rated shares to open at a premium of up to 30 per cent continued to look good as the stock market held steady yesterday. 
 Thames Water was trading on a &bquo;grey market&equo; price of up to 132p. 
 Other companies attracted prices between the 122p to 129p opening price on the 100p partly-paid shares. 
 Flotation advisers declined to predict the total number of applications. 
 But only those applying for small amounts of shares are likely to see their allocation met in full. 
 &bquo;It seems inevitable that almost everybody will only get some of the shares they wanted,&equo; one analyst said. 
 Analysts forecast an extra fillip to early water dealing with a wave of institutional buying from foreign buyers starved of stock. 
 The clawback mechanism has reduced the 18.5 per cent water holding intended for Japan, US, Canada and European institutions to around 12 per cent. 
 Any further &bquo;clawback&equo; will reduce shares allotted to institutions and brokers in the City. 
 All water companies have been &bquo;oversubscribed&equo; but advisers conceded that there were &bquo;regional buying differences&equo; between them. 
 Analysts were increasingly optimistic about the prospect of share price premiums in early trading as it became clear that professional buyers will be starved of stock. 
 The main casualty of yesterday's &bquo;clawback&equo; will be the Japanese institution Daiwa, which is to take most of the overseas allocation. 
 &bquo;We could see Japanese interest,&equo; said Mr Stephen Doe, of brokers Smith New Court. 
 &bquo;It does look exciting for the aftermarket.&equo; 
 But he conceded that Tokyo had held back in the aftermarket of British Gas. 
 In the US, buyers will have to hold back for 90 days after the issue because of Securities Exchange Commission restrictions on overseas dealings. 
 But heavy buying could be expected from Wood Gundy, which is handling the issue in Canada, and Credit Suisse First Boston, issue co-ordinator for the European markets. 
 A spokesman for Schroders, the Government's merchant bankers, said: &bquo;We have found that the average number of shares has increased as we have gone through the applications.&equo; 
 But he said that it was too early to make firm forecasts about demand. 
 All forms are being checked by Price Waterhouse computer systems to weed out illegal multiple applications. 
 Sophisticated &bquo;fuzzy matching&equo; technolog is being used to spot attempts to disguise similar names and addresses. 
 Experts last night were unsure over whether any of the water companies would qualify for the FT-SE index, a crucial point in assessing their investment potential. 
 &bquo;Latest indications are that they will miss out, but it isn't impossible,&equo; said a spokesman for Schroders. 
 Thames, North West and Severn Trent are the most likely candidates. 
 Premiums could be as high as 30p when dealings start on Tuesday. 
 Patrick Donovan explains why 
 2.2million in queue for shares as public gets water on brain. 
 By Andrew Cornelius Industrial Editor 
 NEARLY &pound;5billion has been put up by 2.2million private investors chasing water shares, it was confirmed last night, making the sale one of the most popular privatisations. 
 Only the British Gas sale, which attracted 4.5million applications from small investors, and BAA with 2.5million applications, attracted more interest from members of the public. 
 British Telecom and Rolls-Royce each attracted only 2.1million applications. 
 Public response to the controversial share sale was so strong that virtually all the &pound;5.3billion of shares could be sold without offering any to financial institutions or overseas investors. 
 Government advisers said the public element of the offer was four times subscribed, ensuring that shares allocated for foreign investors were &bquo;clawed back&equo; for private applicants, who will now be allocated virtually 30 per cent of the entire sale. 
 This meant that by last night individual investors had written cheques for at least &pound;4.8billion, with counting still to finish. 
 If public applications reach 2.25million, a further clawback will be triggered to give individuals 50 per cent of the shares. 
 But those watching the count late last night believed that the final tally would fall just below this figure. 
 Final allocations will be announced on Monday morning. 
 On the grey market IG Index, the City firm which &bquo;bets&equo; on the opening value of new share issues was predicting healthy profits on the 100p partly-paid shares. 
 Predicted opening prices ranged from 128p for Northumbrian Water, 127p for Thames, 126p for Southern, 126p for Wessex, 125p for Severn Trent, 125p for Anglian, 124p for Yorkshire, 124p for Welsh, 123p for South West and 122p for North West. 
 All 10 water authorities have been oversubscribed, but interest has varied between regions. 
 IG Index has noticed a weakening of interest in Thames, with interest growing in South West. 
 A spokesman for IG Index said the indications were that all 10 water companies would &bquo;generate healthy profits&equo; when trading opened next Tuesday morning. 
 One of the main factors underpinning the share price was an anticipated shortage of water shares, because of the decision to scale down overseas allocations to increase the public offer from 23.5 to nearly 30 per cent of the offer. 
 Money Guardian looks in detail at the flotation and at what investors can expect in terms of allocation, yields and first-day prices &mdash; page 14. 
 Would-be sellers will have to wait. 
 By Teresa Hunter 
 MOST ordinary investors in water shares will have to wait for at least another week &mdash; and probably until after Christmas &mdash; before they can sell. 
 Stockbrokers, particularly those offering a cut-price service, will generally only deal with proof of ownership, such as letters of allocation. 
 These will not be sent out until December 20. 
 An exception is the Norwich and Peterborough building society which has a flat rate dealing fee of &pound;8, (plus VAT) and allows up to four members of a family to trade their combined holdings in a single deal. 
 It is providing an early dealing service to society members, allowing them to deal on the first day the shares are traded. 
 Provided savers have &pound;1 per share in any N&amp;P account, they will be able to sell their shares after the allocation is announced on Monday, before letters of allocation arrive. 
 Non-members can take advantage of the low dealing costs by calling into one of the Norwich &amp; Peterborough's 65 branches, but only once they have received their allotment letters. 
 But the best deal of all is available to Leeds Permanent customers with &pound;2,000 in a Liquid Gold or Solid Gold savings account. 
 The society has linked with the Debenhams Investment Services stockbroking arm of the Burton Group to offer free dealing. 
 The first qualifying 10,000 customers who apply through one of the society's branches will get a voucher guaranteeing no stockbroking commission. 
 Any other Leeds customer can take advantage of the Debenhams special water rate of &pound;10. 
 Shares can be sold through the Debenhams share shops. 
 Manchester stockbrokers Piling &amp; Co are another good buy.They will sell water shares for &pound;7 plus &pound;1 extra for members of the family up to a maximum of four. 
 Independent Professional Advisors Services, of Shakespeare Road, London has fixed its bargain dealing costs at &pound;9 plus VAT. 
 Barclayshare, Barclays Bank's retail stockbroking arm, has a nationwide share-dealing service which charges &pound;12.50. 
 Sharelink, the telephone dealing service, is charging 1 per cent commission with a minimum of &pound;12.50 and maximum of &pound;50. 
 Its special water dealing line will open on December 18 and will run until January 30. 
 Shareholders should pre-register with ShareLink by telephoning 0922 744500. 
 NatWest's 275 instant dealing branches offer immediate settlement with a contract note and cheque on the spot from December 18. 
 But investors will need letters of allocation to deal. 
 Savers with Cheltenham &amp; Gloucester, Eastbourne and Mornington building societies will be able to re-invest returned with no loss of interest. 
 Would-be sellers will have to wait. 
 By Teresa Hunter 
 DEALING in water company shares begins on Tuesday. 
 But most ordinary investors will have to wait for at least another week &mdash; and probably until after Christmas &mdash; before they can sell. 
 Most stockbrokers, will only deal with proof of ownership, such as letters of allocation. 
 These will not be sent out until December 20. 
 An exception is the Norwich and Peterborough building society which has a flat rate dealing fee of &pound;8, (plus VAT) and allows up to four members of a family to trade their combined holdings in a single deal. 
 It is providing an early dealing service to society members, allowing them to deal on the first day the shares are traded on the stock market. 
 Provided savers have &pound;1 per share in any N&amp;P account, they will be able to sell their shares after the allocation is announced on Monday, before letters of allocation arrive. 
 Non-members can take advantage of the low dealing costs by calling into one of the Norwich &amp; Peterborough's 65 branches, but only once they have received their allotment letters. 
 But the best deal of all is available to Leeds Permanent customers with &pound;2,000 in a Liquid Gold or Solid Gold savings account. 
 The society has linked with the Debenhams Investment Services stockbroking arm of the Burton Group to offer free dealing. 
 The first qualifying 10,000 customers who apply through one of the society's branches will get a voucher guaranteeing no stockbroking commission. 
 Any other Leeds customer can take advantage of the Debenhams special water rate of &pound;10. 
 Shares can be sold through the Debenhams share shops. 
 Manchester stockbrokers Piling &amp; Co are another good buy.They will sell water shares for &pound;7 plus &pound;1 extra for members of the family up to a maximum of four. 
 Independent Professional Advisors Services, of Shakespeare Road, London has fixed its bargain dealing costs at &pound;9 plus VAT. 
 Barclayshare, Barclays Bank's retail stockbroking arm, has a nationwide share-dealing service which charges &pound;12.50. 
 Sharelink, the telephone dealing service, is charging 1 per cent commission with a minimum of &pound;12.50 and maximum of &pound;50. 
 Its special water dealing line will open on December 18 and will run until January 30. 
 Shareholders should pre-register with ShareLink by telephoning 0922 744500. 
 NatWest's 275 instant dealing branches offer immediate settlement with a contract note and cheque on the spot from December 18. 
 But investors will need letters of allocation to deal. 
 The Cheltenham &amp; Gloucester Eastbourne and Mornington building societies will allow savers to re-invest returned water share cheques without loss of interest. 
 THE price of water shares is expected to leap by up to 30 per cent when dealings start at 9.00am on Tuesday. 
 But the last minute flood of applications may mean most small investors will probably be allocated fewer than 400 shares. 
 Analysts disagree about the precise size of any likely premium, and the speed with which this will be reached. 
 That premium will anyway differ from company to company depending on the level of regional oversubscription. 
 However the IG index of prices on the grey market &mdash; where shares are traded unofficially before issue &mdash; indicates that the more popular companies, such as Thames and Northumbrian, could open with at least a 30p premium, while the premium on the less popular North West and South West could be as low as 21p. 
 Investors may have to wait longer than they anticipate before enjoying maximum premiums. 
 Nigel Hawkins of Hoare Govett estimates initial dealings will see prices at between only 110p to 125p, while Robert Giles of Laing &amp; Cruickshank believes the opening price could level around 105p to 110p. 
 He argues: &bquo;I have little doubt that on average we will see a premium of about a third, but it could take a few weeks to get there. 
 I know there is a public perception that everyone should sell their shares at the first opportunity, but I think this could be a big mistake.&equo; 
 With counting incomplete, triumphant water minister Michael Howard has already announced that up to 1.4 million people have applied for water shares &mdash; and the figure could well top 2 million. 
 If demand reaches the 2.25 oversubscription level, and both the foreign and institutional clawbacks are triggered, UK personal investors would qualify for nearly 44 per cent of the entire float &mdash; around 1,000 million shares. 
 Some criterion must then be devised for dividing these shares between the potentially more than 2 million investor applications. 
 All this will effect the private investor in two ways. 
 The institutional shortage will inflate further the expected premium on first day's trading. 
 Most of the buying is likely to come from Japan. 
 On the negative side, the small shareholder may find himself scaled down to such a small stake that a sizeable portion of profits would be wiped off by share-dealing costs. 
 In either event, small shareholders should think carefully before selling any holding. 
 For the long term benefits of the &bquo;loyalty share bonus&equo; together with a first year's yield of around 20 per cent makes the investment an attractive income stock. 
 The first dividend is payable in March, &mdash; one third of the total dividend &mdash; while the second instalment is not due until July. 
 The stock market's recent steady performance in the run up to the water issue has helped ensure the success of the flotation. 
 However there are concerns that the market is rather high at present, which could see a fall in prices generally in the new year. 
 If prices rise as high as 135p to 140p Robert Giles recommends selling for non-priority shareholders. 
 But for priority shareholders &mdash; customers of companies who will qualify for the 10p discount on each of the subsequent 70p part-payments should only sell when the price has risen as high as 150p to 160p. 
 On fundamentals, the shares also look cheap. 
 The water companies' average prospective price earnings ratio is around five. 
 The p/e ratio measures the amount of money you have to spend on shares to have a given amount of earnings next year and is a key gauge used by te City in assessing the price of shares. 
 In broad terms, a high p/e ratio suggests a share is expensive; a low one means it is cheap &mdash; although the p/e will also reflect not only next year's likely performance but also the outlook for the company beyond that. 
 On a typical p/e of five, water shares look bargain-basement compared to oil companies which span the nine to 10 range. 
 British Gas is selling at eight times earnings while British Telecom commands a 9.5 rating. 
 Options in Thames Water are to be sold on the London Traded Options Market from Tuesday. 
 The vital dates are: December 11 &mdash; allocation of shares to be announced by 5pm. 
 December 12 &mdash; first dealings begin at 9am. 
 December 20 &mdash; certificates to be dispatched. 
 March 1990 &mdash; interim dividend, a third of total. 
 July 31, 1990 &mdash; payment of second instalment (70p). 
 October 1, 1990 &mdash; final dividend, two thirds of total. 
 July 30, 1991 &mdash; payment of final instalment (70p). 
 PAGE 
 Water, water everywhere with the shares set to soar Premiums could be as high as 30p when dealings start on Tuesday. 
 Patrick Donovan explains why. 
 PAGE 
 Singh steps out for peace in Sikh heartland. 
 By Derek Brown in New Delhi 
 THE new Indian Prime Minister, Mr Vishwanath Pratap Singh, travelled to the heart of battle-scarred Punjab yesterday to score an emotional public-relations victory. 
 Huge crowds turned out to cheer as the Prime Minister, spurning elaborate security precautions, rode through the city of Amritsar to the holiest shrine of the Sikhs, the Golden Temple. 
 He told the throng: &bquo;The people of Punjab have given me a lot of love&hellip; 
 I will now move in an open jeep instead of a bullet-proof car.&equo; 
 At the temple, Mr Singh prayed alongside his deputy, Mr Devi Lal, and his Punjabi foreign minister, Mr Inder Kumar Gujral. 
 Masses of Sikhs jostled and crowded round him as he made his parikrama, the ritual clockwise walk around the marble margins of the sacred lake. 
 This was the gesture which leading Sikhs had pleaded in vain for the previous Prime Minister, Mr Rajiv Gandhi, to make. 
 And although there is as yet no solid evidence that a political settlement of the Sikh question is in sight, the change of government has brought a new spirit of reconciliation on both sides. 
 Mr Singh pledged yesterday that his administration would &bquo;move very fast&equo; to bring peace to Punjab. 
 He had come to pray, he said, not to make a political or official visit. 
 &bquo;With the love and co-operation of Punjabis and the strength of God, I am confident that peace will once again return to the state,&equo; he said. 
 For most of the Eighties, Punjab has been wracked by vicious conflict between the security forces and half a dozen incoherent but well-armed groups ostensibly fighting for a free Sikh state of Khalistan, the Land of the Pure. 
 The violence was dramatically stepped up after the storming of the Golden Temple in mid-1984 by the Indian army. 
 For the past few years, the death count has been running at roughly 10 a day, with blood feuds and general gangsterism adding to the mayhem. 
 The previous Congress Party government tried to lay part of the blame on Pakistan, saying that Khalistan terrorists had been trained and armed across the frontier. 
 Most observers, however, believe the problem started with cynical Congress intrigues to split the main Sikh Party, the Akali Dal. 
 The manoeuvre succeeded, though at a dreadful cost. 
 There are now at least half a dozen Akali factions, both moderate and militant. 
 The former tried to reach an accord with New Delhi, but their state government was replaced by direct rule following the assassination of the Akali leader, Mr Harchand Singh Longowal. 
 The strongest Akali faction by far is now that led by Mr Simranjit Singh Mann. 
 He and his followers won 10 of the state's 13 parliamentary seats in last month's general election, with Mr Mann himself scoring a dramatic victory from his prison cell. 
 On the day his result was announced, he was released after five years of detention without trial, still defiantly declaring his faith in the Sikh cause. 
 But in the short and euphoric interval, even Mr Mann has softened his approach, indicating that he was now prepared to accept the constitution of India, and distancing himself from the latest demands by the ultra-belligerent Sikh student movement for an alternative government. 
 In the wake of the Mann group's victory, and the strident noises from the Student Federation, some reports from Amritsar had spoken of a return of terrorism to the temple itself, scene of bloody battles in 1984 and again last summer. 
 One of the direst warnings, pleading for immediate though unspecified action, came from the state Governor, Mr S.S. Ray. 
 But already, as a staunch Congressman, he knew his time was up. 
 Yesterday he resigned and was replaced by Mr Nirmal Kumar Mukarji. 
 Mr Ray's last warning was both unheeded and unnecessary. 
 As Mr V.P. Singh paid his humble respects at the seat of Sikh pride and piety, the militants' guns and the swords were put away. 
 The police security guards too were discreet, and allowed the people of Punjab, both Sikh and Hindu, to surge round their Prime Minister. 
 Berlin army joins people's cause. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 IN the more radical mood that has now gripped East Germany's revolution, the question of where the army would stand in the event of conflict has emerged as a key issue. 
 As citizens continue to storm offices of the secret police, stern warnings have come from the government and the army that the line would be drawn at any attempts to enter barracks. 
 Clearly, behind the appeals for calm has been the fear that the army is now threatened by disintegration, something that has become evident in increasingly frank discussions. 
 It is not only the soldiers who express in East German television programmes their outrage at the revelations of corruption of former political leaders. 
 Officers have said they tolerated the old conditions for too long. 
 A staff meeting in East Berlin's Defence Ministry, attended by the Defence Minister, Admiral Theodor Hoffmann, heard Captain Uwe-Jens Karl say that the political scandals had &bquo;also discredited the whole army&equo;. 
 He read out a statement saying: &bquo;We and our families are no longer prepared to make sacrifices for those who have brought the army into disrepute. 
 &bquo;A renewed National People's Army needs the public and all social forces, it needs the people. 
 We want finally to be a people's army.&equo; 
 East German television was this week allowed into the barracks of a crack guards regiment at Karlshorst. 
 &bquo;If you hadn't come to us, we would have come to you,&equo; the colonel receiving the journalists said. 
 After the television crews were greeted with frantic applause from soldiers and officers of the Feliks Dzherzhinsky Regiment, privates spoke freely of the conflict they had reconciling their duty of protecting top leaders and central committee members with ever increasing revelations of corruption. 
 The senior officer said: &bquo;Even as a colonel I feel as cheated and betrayed as you do.&equo; 
 Jews split over women's group. 
 By Mark Tran in Washington 
 ADECISION by B'nai B'rith International to expel its women's affiliate threatens to tear apart the world's largest Jewish organisation. 
 The simmering dispute erupted in public when the B'nai B'rith International board of governors adopted a motion to expel the 120,000-member B'nai B'rith Women unless the affiliate relinquishes its autonomous status. 
 B'nai B'rith Women, legally incorporated as a separate entity in 1962, also faces legal action challenging its right to use the B'nai B'rith name. 
 &bquo;B'nai B'rith International's decision-makers now seek total control over their empire. 
 They will brook no independence,&equo; said the president of B'nai B'rith Women, Hyla Lipsky. 
 Expulsion of the women's group would mean a significant drop in the total membership of 500,000 at a time when numbers joining are declining. 
 The president of B'nai B'rith International, Mr Seymour Reich, said the organisation made the expulsion threat reluctantly and after several years of negotiation. 
 He believes that B'nai B'rith Women's determination to remain autonomous works against the trend of creating a new organisation for the 21st century comprising men and women. 
 He sees the decision to fully integrate the women's arm into the organisation as a way of boosting membership. 
 &bquo;It's ironic,&equo; said Mr Reich. 
 &bquo;Here we are offering them full equality with men in B'nai B'rith, and their leadership is rejecting that offer.&equo; 
 Although not a political organisation, B'nai B'rith Women has taken high-profile stands on contentious political issues. 
 The organisation, against the wishes of B'nai B'rith International, took a public stand against the nomination of Judge Robert Bork to the Supreme Court because of his anti-abortion stance. 
 Poland sees Council as first step to membership. 
 By AP in Brussels 
 THE chairman of Poland's foreign affairs committee said yesterday his country would request membership of the European Community and all other European institutions. 
 &bquo;Yes, Poland is seeking a place in all European institutions,&equo; Mr Bronislaw Geremek said after meeting with the presidents of the Commission. 
 Mr Geremek said as a first step Poland would soon seek full membership in the Council of Europe. 
 In November, Hungary became the first East European nation to apply for membership to the council based in Strasbourg, France. 
 A condition for membership of the EC is that the country must be a full parliamentary democracy. 
 Mr Geremek said he had told EC officialsthat &bquo;the process of democratisation in Poland is irreversible&equo;. 
 PAGE 
 Mass murder was &bquo;revenge on feminists&equo;. 
 By Penny MacRae in Montreal 
 POLICE say a young loner who claimed feminists had ruined his life was responsible for a bloody shooting spree at a Montreal university in which 14 women were killed. 
 Thirteen others &mdash; nine men and four women &mdash; were wounded in the rampage on Wednesday that shattered the festive end-of-term mood at the French language Universite de Montreal, Quebec's largest. 
 Details began to emerge yesterday of the gruesome attack &mdash; the biggest mass murder in Canadian history. 
 Police said the gunman, in his early 20s and identified only as Marc, carried a hit list with the names of 15 women in a letter found on his body. 
 The gunman shouted &bquo;I want the women&equo; as he roamed the engineering buildings at the university, spraying bullets before turning his semi-automatic rifle on himself. 
 The dead, 13 of them students, were on three different floors of the building. 
 In one classroom, the gunman divided the students by sex to separate sides of the room and then started shooting the women. 
 &bquo;He told them, &bquo;You're women, you're going to be engineers. 
 You're all a bunch of feminists, I feminists&equo;,&equo; said one student, Robert Leclerc. 
 &bquo;My friend Natalie replied, &bquo;No, it's not true, we're not feminists,&equo; but the gunman fired into the group.&equo; 
 Police said the three-page letter found in the killer's back pocket blamed women for the disappointments in his life. 
 &bquo;All the words he uses are what you would call anti-feminist,&equo; said a police officer. 
 The letter indicated the killer had been rejected by the Canadian armed forces for being anti-social, police said. 
 Distraught parents kept an all-night vigil at the university where a temporary morgue was set up. 
 One police officer arrived at the scene to find his daughter dead on the floor. 
 &bquo;It was just like Rambo,&equo; said one of the scores of horrified students who fled from the university after the massacre. 
 The Quebec premier, Mr Robert Bourassa, condemned the killings as a &bquo;barbaric carnage&equo; and declared three days of official mourning. 
 Food pledge for Ethiopia. 
 By Reuter in Brussels 
 THE Community yesterday promised 44,000 tonnes of new food aid for Ethiopia in an effort to save millions of people threatened by starvation. 
 The pledge brings total EC food aid to Ethiopia to 175,000 tonnes, after a 30,000-tonne gift of cereals in November, officials said. 
 Under a special programme, aid worth about 10 million ECUs (&pound;8 million) would also go on transport and other urgent supplies. 
 Ethiopia has asked for 377,000 tonnes of food to fend off famine in Eritrea and Tigre. 
 United Nations experts say as many as four million people are facing famine after a severe drought and crop failure. 
 PAGE 
 Mojahedin &bquo;plot against republics&equo;. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 AFGHAN guerrillas have been infiltrating Soviet Central Asia with &bquo;narcotics, arms and other instruments of subversion&equo; in an attempt to overthrow Soviet rule and set up Islamic governments, according to the KGB chief in the Soviet republic of Tadjikistan. 
 It has long been a nightmare in Moscow that the region could be highly vulnerable to Islamic militants from the indigenous population's ethnic and religious brothers across the borders in Afghanistan and Iran. 
 These fears have grown apace since the Soviet intervention in Afghanistan gave rise to bitter hostility towards the Russians among many Afghans. 
 Under Mr Gorbachev's policies of glasnost and perestroika, Central Asians have also begun to express their resentment at what they see as Russian exploitation of their land during the Stalin and Brezhnev eras. 
 Now, in the first detailed account of what were apparently serious efforts by the Mojahedin to subvert Soviet power, Tass has quoted Mr Vladimir Petkel, the head of state security in Tadjikistan, as saying the situation had become considerably worse since the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Afghanistan. 
 &bquo;Over the past few months, state security organs and border guards exposed and suppressed several attempts by special agencies of Afghan armed opposition forces to recruit Soviet citizens,&equo; he said. 
 They were to be induced to carry out &bquo;hostile activities on Soviet territory with the help of foreigners penetrating into Tadjikistan across the border&equo;. 
 A number of Afghan agents, as well as some of their Soviet contacts, were caught, according to Mr Petkel. 
 One, named as &bquo;Engineer Bashir&equo;, was described as &bquo;a field commander, head of an intelligence centre and deputy leader of the Islamic Party of Afghanistan&equo;. 
 Bashir and an assistant named Mirahmad were said to have recruited Afghans from the border provinces of Badakshan and Kunduz who &bquo;underwent a special training course in the armed opposition camps&equo;. 
 These agents &bquo;were to induce Soviet citizens to collaborate in the delivery of narcotics, arms and other instruments of subversion into Soviet territory. 
 Their final goal was to create bases in the Tadjik Republic from which to destabilise the situation in Soviet Central Asia, and to mobilise forces aiming to overthrow the system existing in the Soviet Central Asian Republics&equo;. 
 An arms cache was found in the house of &bquo;a certain Azimov&equo; who was alleged to have been recruited by Bashir's agents. 
 Tass said journalists were shown money and hand grenades seized from him and a tape recorder &bquo;with the text of the oath Soviet citizens were expected to take when recruited&equo;. 
 Two Afghans, among several arrested trying to cross the border, &bquo;admitted that they belonged to an intelligence group entrusted with the organisation of an underground anti-Soviet movement in Tadjikistan, whose purpose was to turn the republic into an Islamic state&equo;. 
 A number of people had been put on trial, Mr Petkel said. 
 But the Tass report had a happy ending &mdash; from the Soviet point of view. 
 &bquo;Two criminal cases, involving one Soviet and one Afghan citizen who openly confessed and repented their actions against the Soviet Union, have been discontinued.&equo; 
 Trade accord sought in Gulf. 
 By Reuter in Nicosia 
 COMMISSIONER Abel Matutes, visiting Gulf Cooperation Council states, said yesterday that the EC and GCC were discussing the possibility of a trade agreement as a step toward free trade. 
 The EC runs a &dollar;4.4 billion trade surplus with the GCC, an economic alliance linking Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, Oman, Qatar, Kuwait and the United Arab Emirates. 
 Most EC goods enter almost duty-free. 
 Members are pressing for freer European access for the products of their petrochemical industries. 
 Mr Matutes, who is EC commissioner for Mediterranean policy and Latin American relations, arrived in Muscat from Saudi Arabia. 
 PAGE 
 Pretoria to halve military service. 
 By David Beresford in Johannesburg 
 SOUTH Africa is to cut national service for young whites by half, as part of a reduction in the country's reliance on the military establishment. 
 The State President, Mr F.W. de Klerk, announced yesterday that conscripts would do only one year full-time military service, instead of two. 
 Speaking at the opening of a new headquarters for the state arms-manufacturing corporation, Armscor, he said other cuts in the military establishment would be disclosed next year. 
 The announcement follows the dismantling of the National Security Management system &mdash; the &bquo;shadow&equo; system of government by security chiefs &mdash; and ties in with plans to reduce the military budget by about 15 per cent, or &pound;375 million. 
 The moves will be seen as further evidence of Mr De Klerk's commitment to a political, rather than a military, solution to the country's long-running crisis. 
 The latest decision will immediately affect about 35,000 young white men due to begin service next February and more than 15,000 scheduled to start in August. 
 Other race groups are not required to do national service. 
 The news was welcomed yesterday by the End Conscription Campaign, which has been running an increasingly effective protest against national service on the grounds that servicemen are used to oppress the country's majority population. 
 Recently 771 conscripts publicly announced their refusal to do military service as part of a national defiance campaign by the anti-apartheid community. 
 Several young whites are already serving terms of imprisonment for refusing to serve. 
 The Afrikaans weekly newspaper, Vrye Weekblad, has named a South African conscript who, it says, was required to do his military service as a spy. 
 A report in today's edition says that the youth, aged 19, was sent to the Netherlands by Military Intelligence to infiltrate an anti-apartheid group, the Committee of War Resisters. 
 Aquino tries to rally loyal Filipinos. 
 By Sheila Coronel in Manila 
 THE Philippine President, Mrs Corazon Aquino, lashed out at her enemies and mobilised popular support behind her beleaguered government yesterday at a rally attended by thousands of Filipinos. 
 &bquo;These people want to show how brave they are. 
 Just because I am a woman they belittle me,&equo; she said to loud cheers. 
 The rally was held as the government managed to contain a week-long military rebellion that came dangerously close to succeeding. 
 Mrs Aquino spoke at the highway intersection where thousands of people defied President Ferdinand Marcos's tanks and troops nearly four years ago. 
 Yesterday's event was intended to be a re-creation of the &bquo;people power&equo; uprising that swept Mrs Aquino to office. 
 This celebration of the triumph of democracy coincided with a congressional debate on the curbing of civil liberties under the state of emergency declared on Thursday. 
 With the emergency, Mrs Aquino hopes to address some of the social and economic grievances of her people by controlling prices, improving public services, and cushioning the effects of sagging confidence among investors. 
 The measures may include restrictions on political rights to control the dissent that has thrived in the Philippine's democracy, sometimes to the point of anarchy. 
 Mrs Aquino now has to decide whether she should be magnanimous in victory or punish those behind the mutiny. 
 She is damned if she does and damned if she doesn't. 
 If she decides to forgive and forget, as she did after previous takeover attempts, she might not be able to rein in the military. 
 On the other hand, cracking down on the rebels could widen the fissures within the army and encourage disgruntled officers to plot more coups. 
 Yesterday, Mrs Aquino aimed her sharpest barbs at her civilian enemies. 
 She did not even mention the military involvement in the rebellion or the officer widely believed to have led it, the cashiered Colonel Gregorio Honasan. 
 In the past, Mrs Aquino has taken a conciliatory stance towards ambitious factions in her armed forces, but, instead of appeasing mutineers, this policy has stoked rebellion in the barracks. 
 Under the Marcos dictatorship, the army was allowed to exercise vast powers. 
 With the restoration of democracy in 1986, the monster that Marcos had unleashed refused to be caged. 
 Even now, although the latest rebellion has been contained, military leaders say another coup attempt is possible. 
 Military officers have tried to seize power six times since Mrs Aquino became President three years ago. 
 The latest attempt is timed with growing popular dissaffection with the government's inability to provide basic services and curb corruption and rising prices. 
 Worrying for the government, however, is that the troops who launched the rebellion last week were the cream of the Philippine military. 
 These elite forces are the best equipped and trained and the most disciplined in a 150,000-strong army famous for its incompetence. 
 Even if it failed, the attempted takeover was remarkably well planned and executed. 
 Although Mrs Aquino survived, she is now even more beholden to the military faction, led by the Defence Secretary and former Chief of Staff, Mr Fidel Ramos, that defended her government. 
 The problem is Mr Ramos has become a focus of discontent among younger officers who see the retired general as politically ambitious and militarily incompetent. 
 To defuse future rebellions, reshuffling the top brass may be necessary. 
 &bquo;But how can President Aquino overhaul the leadership of the armed forces after she has already commended them for putting down the coup?&equo; asks a congressman and former military officer, Mr Bonifacio Gillego. 
 In the aftermath of every previous coup attempt, Mrs Aquino gave the army more concessions, including a reprieve on investigations into their abuses of human rights, a tougher anti-Communist policy, a purge of left-leaning cabinet secretaries and higher pay. 
 This time she asked Congress to approve a 100 per cent increase in soldiers' daily allowance. 
 And it is expected that in the next few days she will address the military's other grievances. 
 Smarting from the coup attempt, in which her official residence was bombed from the air and the capital's financial heart seized for five days, Mrs Aquino came swinging back yesterday. 
 &bquo;Maybe it is time for me to get angry and fight back at those who are fighting me,&equo; she said. 
 The crowd roared as Mrs Aquino said her former Defence Secretary, Senator Juan Ponce Enrile, should be investigated for complicity in the coup attempt. 
 Mrs Aquino also hinted that her Vice-President, Mr Salvador Laurel, and her first cousin and a Marcos associate, Mr Eduardo Cojuangco, were involved in the plot. 
 She added: &bquo;Our next election is not until 1992. 
 Those who want to be president will have to wait until then.&equo; 
 Nicaraguans see red over economic ruin Grinding poverty, not revolutionary zeal, is the real election issue, Simon Tisdall writes from Masaya. 
 NICARAGUA suffered an attack of &bquo;Red Dizziness&equo; this week &mdash; in the Spanish, Marea Roja, a bug caught from eating tainted sea food. 
 But in a week that marked the opening of the campaign for February's elections, the red dizziness was not confined to restaurants. 
 In Masaya, a dusty, impoverished town to the south-west of Managua, supporters of the Sandinista National Liberation Front (FSLN) turned an election rally into a raucous, joyful rampage on Wednesday night. 
 With the blue and white Nicaraguan flag fluttering amid the Sandinistas' red and black banners, a jeep-borne President Daniel Ortega led an anarchic procession to the accompaniment of bands, singers, dancers, and the alarmed squeals of a tethered pig. 
 The message for the Nicaraguan opposition was simple: On February 25 &bquo;we will bury you!&equo; 
 The revolution which triumphed in 1979 would triumph again. 
 A second revolution may well be on the way in Nicaragua, but one not to the liking of the FSLN. 
 President Ortega faces the most potent challenge to his leadership since the Sandinistas took full control in 1981. 
 The challenge comes not from the US, not from the contra rebels, nor from hostile neighbouring countries, but from within. 
 In short, the government is being called to account for the economic disaster that is present-day Nicaragua. 
 As a Managua businessman put it, &bquo;I used to sell fridges. 
 Nobody bought them so I began to repair fridges. 
 But nobody has their fridges repaired any more, they can't afford it. 
 So all the fridges stay rusted, and I have no work.&equo; 
 For many Nicaraguans, the deciding election issue will have little to do with the rhetoric of purist revolutionary solidarity. 
 They are no longer proud to be poor. 
 Official figures show that private consumption under Sandinista rule has fallen by 70 per cent. 
 Real wages have fallen by 90 per cent since 1981. 
 Unemployment is rising, with the industrial sector expected to contract by 20 per cent this year. 
 The flight from the countryside has compounded the misery of the urban poor, traditionally the bedrock of Sandinista support. 
 Government measures to peg back inflation have deepened the recession. 
 The Sandinista campaign slogan, &bquo;Everything will get better&equo;, seems in this context an admission of defeat. 
 Their platform emphasises their achievements in reducing child mortality and enhancing rural education, and seeks to present the FSLN as an experienced, united party. 
 The main opposition alliance, the 14-party Nicaraguan Opposition Union (UNO), is portrayed as opportunist and divided and infiltrated by pro-contra, Somoza-era hangovers. 
 But a series of opinion polls have suggested, very roughly, a 30-30 split with 40 per cent of the electorate undecided. 
 If the Sandinistas have their problems, so too does UNO. 
 Its presidential candidate, Mrs Violeta Chamorro, brings to the fray a symbolic appeal as the widow of the murdered publisher of La Prensa, but lacks any political experience &mdash; a fact that becomes embarrassingly clear when she appears in public. 
 UNO's acceptance of US campaign fund donations and Mrs Chamorro's appointment of the former contra director, Afredo Cesar, as her adviser, has opened her to charges of collaborating with the US. 
 The main theme of the UNO campaign is reconciliation. 
 The alliance plays on the prospect of an end to the US trade embargo and increased foreign aid in the event of an UNO victory. 
 It has pledged to end the deeply unpopular draft and to reduce the 80,000-strong army. 
 The US and the Soviet Union have publicly backed the electoral process, which was agreed last February. 
 Moscow continues as the main Sandinista financier, pumping in about &dollar;465 million in economic aid. 
 But given the democratic revolution on its own doorstep, the Soviet Union is now distanced from its long-time proteges. 
 For the US, the emphasis is on securing a free and fair election, which the State Department seems to believe will result in an opposition victory. 
 The US has alleged intimidation by turbas divinas &mdash; pro-Sandinista thugs and claims to have evidence of voter intimidation by the army. 
 Washington has also threatened not to recognise the poll result if Congressional observers are barred from joining those of the UN, the OAS, and the Jimmy Carter foundation. 
 It is unclear whether a democratically defeated FSLN would relinquish power. 
 After 10 tumultous years of substantial achievement and disastrous mistakes, the Sandinistas control the army, the unions, the youth movements, much of the media and the money &mdash; what there is of it. 
 Did Daniel Ortega struggle so hard and so long, suffer seven years in jail, and defy the mighty US at such cost to his country, only to drive his jeep into the sunset? 
 It is a dizzying thought. 
 European Community Hungary granted &pound;800m loan deal. 
 By Reuter in Brussels 
 THE European Commission on Wednesday approved an EC loan of one billion Ecus (&pound;800 million) to help Hungary overcome severe balance of payments problems, the first organised for a non-EC country. 
 EC Commissioner Henning Christophersen said the five-year loan was highly exceptional, &bquo;but then we're in a highly exceptional situation&equo;. 
 It was conditional on Budapest agreeing a structural adjustment programme with the International Monetary Fund and implementing market-based economic reforms. 
 It should also not take the place of fresh funds from Western banks, Mr Christophersen said. 
 &bquo;The loan would be another concrete expression of the Community's support &lsqb;for&rsqb; Hungary's progress towards democracy and a market economy.&equo; 
 Mr Christophersen urged EC governments and the European Parliament to give speedy approval to the loan, which will be paid in three instalments. 
 The operation to raise the money on international markets could start next February if there were no procedural difficulties, he added. 
 Because of the EC's standing in markets, the loan would be raised on the best possible terms, but it would not be a subsidised, &bquo;soft&equo; loan, Mr Christopherson emphasised. 
 The Community would monitor Hungary's programme to restructure its economy on more market-oriented lines, and disburse the second and third tranches of the money only if satisfied about progress. 
 The Community was working in close cooperation with the IMF, and the loan was intended to complement its efforts. 
 PAGE 
 Thatcher outgunned on Treaty of Rome summit Community closes ranks against Britain. 
 By John Palmer in Strasbourg 
 THE other 11 heads of state and government of the European Community last night closed ranks in an impressive display of unity against the sole opposition of Mrs Thatcher, to hold a special conference next year to amend the Treaty of Rome and open the way to economic and monetary union. 
 The conference will be held as part of the European summit in Rome next December and the aim will be to agree far-reaching changes to the Community's constitution to achieve Economic Monetary Union (EMU) as soon as possible after 1992. 
 The united front put up by the other EC leaders was made possible by the West German Chancellor, Dr Helmut Kohl, who abandoned any attempt to slow down the decision on an inter-governmental conference. 
 He said that the Italian Government, which takes over the presidency of the EC Council of Ministers, in July should &bquo;convene and open&equo; the treaty revision conference before handing over its presidency in December next year. 
 The West German Chancellor also fell into line with his French allies by agreeing that the Community should try to be ready to implement the economic union when the single market came fully into operation on January 1, 1993. 
 Last week he had hinted that it might be better to get an agreement by the time of the next European Parliament elections in June 1994. 
 There was barely a chink of light between the 11 over the speed with which the European Community should move towards a semi-federal economic and monetary system. 
 Chancellor Kohl spoke in almost identical terms to President Franois Mitterrand and the others in arguing that &bquo;instability and uncertainty in the outside world&equo; made it imperative for the EC to accelerate economic integration. 
 For her part, Mrs Thatcher gave a relatively low key presentation of her alternative &bquo;evolutionary&equo; approach to economic and monetary union. 
 The Prime Minister emphasised that even she shared the goal of monetary union, eschewing on this occasion the expression &bquo;economic and monetary reform&equo; which she has preferred in the past. 
 &bquo;We have been in favour of this objective since 1962,&equo; she said. 
 Mrs Thatcher told her fellow summiteers that, in the end, it might be quicker and more secure if they worked with market forces in moving towards monetary union. 
 The first phase of economic union would only begin next July. 
 Mrs Thatcher insisted it would make more sense to wait and see how it worked out in practice before preparing moves to the more controversial second and third stages of EMU &mdash; including a central bank and a single currency. 
 However, Mrs Thatcher did not go into any detail about how the suggested British scheme for allowing different currencies to compete freely throughout the Community would necessarily produce the kind of central bank and co-ordinated monetary and economic policies which the others believe is essential. 
 And she neither volunteered nor was asked for any new statement of intent about how soon the British would agree to sterling joining the fixed exchange rate regime of the European Monetary System. 
 Until almost the last moment there were lingering hopes in the British camp that the West German Chancellor might signal some differences with his French allies. 
 But having politely listened to Mrs Thatcher's remarks and having promised to pay due attention to Whitehall's alternative strategy, the summit made it clear that their strategy for monetary union would broadly follow the blueprint laid down. 
 It will fall to the Italian Presidency to get agreement on the precise terms of reference for the EMU conference. 
 One problem will undoubtedly be the growing demands of the European Parliament, backed by Chancellor Kohl and President Mitterrand, to be given a bigger say with the Council of Ministers in setting broad Community economic objectives and in holding a future EC central bank to account. 
 The Danish Prime Minister, Mr Poul Schluter, insisted that the future union could not be restricted to purely monetary issues but would have to involve an increasing convergence of economic policies and objectives for growth, inflation, and employment. 
 Several prime ministers made it clear that they would want to see a radical extension of the Community powers and resources to help poorer regions and social groups as they moved to monetary union. 
 Shortly afterwards Mrs Thatcher found herself similarly isolated in a one to 11 minority when the other heads of government endorsed a Declaration of Social Rights. 
 Although Mrs Thatcher's opposition will prevent the declaration having any legal force, the Commission President, Mr Jacques Delors, made it clear he would be coming forward with detailed proposals on a range of minimum social rights for workers in the 1992 single market over the next 12 months &mdash; some of which would have binding legal force throughout the Community. 
 Businesses divided, page 11 
 By Simon Tisdall in Tegucigalpa, Honduras 
 AT the store on the corner, three drunken men are trying to eat the same hot dog. 
 Across the road, an army conscript dressed in battle fatigues watches. 
 Somewhere along the dark street, somebody is crying. 
 It is past midnight in Tegucigalpa, and it's time to go home. 
 And here, at last, come the Kids from Fame. 
 Chela and Urna are dancers at La Fama night club, a grotty little joint comprising one bar, 15 or so rickety wooden tables, and an illuminated picture of a woman's bottom. 
 But La Fama has a stage. 
 And that is what really interests Chela and Urna. 
 Like thousands of young people who crowd the narrow streets of Tegucigalpa, the Kids from La Fama are obsessed with the trappings of North American culture. 
 A fancy New York dance school it isn't, but for Chela and Urna the spotlit stage at La Fama is an alluring link with the much-emulated, much vilified empire to the north. 
 Such schizophrenia, when it comes to the &bquo;yanquis&equo; is common throughout Central America. 
 Through the Caribbean Basin Initiative, the US is attempting to encourage export industries in countries such as Honduras, in addition to direct financial aid. 
 But this reopens the issue of national dependence on Uncle Sam. 
 And the particulars of such a seeming unequal struggle are of little immediate help to the Kids from La Fama. 
 Since dancing cannot earn them a living, Chela and Urna are into self-help, and it is as humiliating in personal terms as any perceived national, cultural subservience to the US. 
 When they suggest a dance to my companion, Wesley, there seems no harm &mdash; but it turns into a smooch. 
 Solos become doubles, and doubles trebles. 
 And the Kids from La Fama grow ever more possessive. 
 &bquo;Now we have to go,&equo; say Chela and Urna suddenly. 
 &bquo;But there is a problem.&equo; 
 The problem turns out to be the boss of the club, who says we must pay &dollar;8 if the girls are to leave. 
 Outside, I wait for Wesley, who is negotiating Chela and Urna's release. 
 Finally, here they come, the Kids from Fame, Honduras-style, giggling yet purposeful. 
 &bquo;Where do you want to go, we'll drop you in a taxi,&equo; I say. 
 All three now look at me incredulously. 
 And the penny drops. 
 &bquo;Back to the hotel, man, come on!&equo; says Wesley. 
 PAGE 
 Iraq launches own missile. 
 Iraq said yesterday it had launched a 48-tonne three-stage rocket into space and announced the local manufacture of new long-range missiles. 
 The minister in charge of weapons manufacture, Mr Hussein Kamel Hassan, said in a message broadcast by Baghdad radio, that the 80ft rocket was launched from al-Anbar space research base west of Baghdad on Tuesday. 
 -Reuter. 
 Slovenia alliance. 
 Three main opposition groups in Yugoslavia's united yesterday to contest Slovenia's first free elections scheduled for next March, Tanjug news agency reported. 
 -Reuter. 
 Mugabe allays fears. 
 The Zimbabwean President, Mr Robert Mugabe, yesterday reiterated earlier pledges to resettle hundreds of thousands of black families, but allayed white farmers' fears that their land would be seized with minimal compensation to mark the tenth independence anniversary. 
 -AP. 
 El Salvador kidnap. 
 Leftwing rebels in El Salvador held an American civilian overnight and lectured him on US intervention while keeping his thumbs tied behind his back before letting him go, the US Embassy said yesterday. 
 Meanwhile, leftwing guerrillas renewed their assault on the capital, setting up positions in at least seven neighbourhoods. 
 -Agencies. 
 Boat people appeal. 
 US Republicans asked President Bush, in a letter released yesterday, to call on Britain to reconsider its policy of repatriating Vietnamese boat people in Hong Kong. 
 -Reuter. 
 Racist gamble. 
 Caesars Hotel Casino in Atlantic City was fined &dollar;250,000 on Wednesday for removing black women from a dice table for a high-stakes gambler who wanted to gamble only with white, male dealers. 
 -Reuter. 
 Comoros protest. 
 The Comoros presidential guard yesterday used teargas and clubs to disperse about 1,000 student protesters demanding that the French mercenary, Mr Bob Denard, and his men go home. 
 -AP. 
 Rebels attacked. 
 Planes bombed a second rebel-held town in southern Sudan, in the latest of a number of bombing raids since peace talks between the Sudanese Government and Sudan People's Liberation Army rebels collapsed earlier this week, a UN official and rebel spokesmen said yesterday. 
 -AP. 
 Bidding for red star. 
 Eighteen companies are bidding for the contract to remove the red star from the dome of Hungary's Parliament, writes Michael Simmons. 
 The government has decreed that, from the end of this month, only the national colours and the coat of arms of the new republic can can be displayed. 
 Officials say removing the star will not be easy. 
 Warning on free market. 
 By Reuter in Brussels 
 THE 12 Community governments have speeded up implementation of rules to create their barrier-free market but are still far behind schedule, the Commission said yesterday. 
 The single market programme requires each member state to turn 279 rules and regulations into national law. 
 More than half have been approved by ministers already. 
 But in a report for EC leaders at Friday's summit in Strasbourg, the commission said only 14 of 86 measures that should have come into force by mid-November had been fully implemented by all 12. 
 That, however, was an improvement compared with the seven out of 68 in mid-August. 
 PAGE 
 Britain makes slow progress in talks on Hong Kong. 
 By Stephen Vines in Hong Kong 
 BRITISH hopes of returning to normalcy in negotiations with China over the future of Hong Kong appeared to have been thwarted yesterday as the 14th round of Sino-British talks ended with only limited signs of progress. 
 Mr Anthony Galsworthy, the leader of the British Joint Liaison Group (JLG) delegation, said that the four-day meeting &bquo;certainly marks a return to business, but not necessarily as normal&equo;. 
 He added: &bquo;It is no secret that the atmosphere in the past few months has not been easy. 
 I would say that it is better in many respects than it was&equo;. 
 While British officials were busy trying to put the best face on the evident lack of progress at the talks, the Chinese delegation was eager to emphasise the differences between the sides. 
 A senior Chinese official said that Beijing was still worried by British attempts to &bquo;internationalise&equo; the Hong Kong question. 
 He explained that this meant that Britain was raising the matter in international forums and placing unnecessary pressure on China. 
 The official also said that Britain had failed to account for its decision to move the colony's main naval base out of the centre of Hong Kong, a move which he believed would have serious repercussions for the stationing of the Chinese military in the territory after the 1997 transfer of power. 
 British officials said that no more than a quarter of the meeting had been taken up with the &bquo;general issues&equo; raised by the Chinese. 
 The bulk of the discussion focused on basic issues. 
 It seems that China is still smarting over Britain's decision to suspend the work of the JLG in the wake of the Tiananmen Square massacre. 
 Last September's JLG meeting in London ended with acrimony on both sides. 
 This meeting has at least concluded with a semblance of good will. 
 Pretoria refuses demands for judicial inquiry into assassination squads De Klerk reformist image suffers as cover-up feared. 
 By David Beresford in Johannesburg 
 SOUTH Africa's State President, Mr FW de Klerk, yesterday suffered the first serious blow to his reputation as the great reformer by appearing to acquiesce in a cover-up of political murders carried out by state agencies, including the police. 
 Opposition parties reacted indignantly to Mr De Klerk's overnight announcement that he would not set up a judicial inquiry. 
 The Democratic Party repeated its demand for an inquiry, saying it was necessary to establish whether cabinet ministers and the former President, Mr PW Botha, were privy to the murders. 
 The South African Council of Churches said &bquo;it is clear the issue of the death squads is going to be covered up&equo;, and described Mr De Klerk's rationale for refusing a commission as &bquo;cynical and spurious&equo;. 
 Mr De Klerk justified his decision on the curious grounds that an inquiry would take too long and would create &bquo;a climate of suspicion and distrust&equo; which &bquo;the country can ill afford at this stage in its history&equo;. 
 The &bquo;tried and respected prosecution mechanisms of the state&equo; would instead be followed. 
 Mr De Klerk's announcement was accompanied by a statement from his Justice Minister that prosecutions would immediately be launched &mdash; against the two men responsible for disclosing the fact that the police have been carrying out officially sanctioned murders. 
 The minister, Mr Kobie Coetsee, said that a prosecution would be brought against the former security branch policeman on death row, Almond Nofomela, for the police murder of the civil rights lawyer, Griffiths Mxenge. 
 It was Nofomela who broke the scandal by confessing to his part in the Mxenge killing, 24 hours before he was due to hang for an unrelated murder of a white farmer. 
 Mr Coetsee said a warrant would also be issued for the arrest of Captain Dirk Coetzee, the former head of a police murder squad who confirmed and amplified Nofomela's disclosures, claiming that the killings had been approved at the highest level. 
 The government will seek to extradite him if he was outside the country, Mr Coetsee said. 
 The SACC characterisation of Mr De Klerk's statement, as &bquo;cynical and spurious&equo;, is likely to be regarded as something of an understatement in many legal and political circles. 
 With strong evidence that the disclosures to date represent only the tip of the iceberg, the State President's claim that a commission of inquiry would create a climate of distrust verges on self-parody. 
 There is no known reason why a commission should not sit in parallel with criminal proceedings. 
 There have been past instances where commissions have issued interim reports recommending immediate criminal proceedings, while continuing their work. 
 Many will see Mr De Klerk's decision as a back-handed tribute to the independence of the judiciary. 
 It will be widely assumed that the cabinet fears it would be unable to control a judicial inquiry. 
 In the last government scandal &mdash; the Muldergate affair in the late 70s &mdash; Mr Botha, was forced to fire a judicial inquiry because the judge refused to cover up corruption. 
 Husak symbolises 21 lost years The Czechoslovak President has become one of Europe's old men with nowhere left to go. 
 Michael Simmons examines his career. 
 POLITICAL demonstrators in Czechoslovakia's streets have not hesitated to shout their views of President Gustav Husak. 
 He has become one of the most ridiculed members of the leadership. 
 A student with a punk haircut and a goose (husa in Czech) strapped into his rucksack was greeted with applause all round as he insolently walked the length of Wenceslas Square. 
 The crowds have not spat out his name with quite the virulence they showed for Mr Milos Jakes and Mr Miroslav Stepan, the Prague party supremo, in their last days, but there has always been an underlying, almost universal contempt. 
 He has become an expendable symbol of the 21 years lost by Czechoslovaks since the invasion of August 1968, for he had taken over, apparently without compunction, from Mr Alexander Dubcek as Communist Party leader when the latter was humiliated at the beginning of 1969. 
 Replacing the highly popular Mr Dubcek was no easy task, but on the grounds that Janos Kadar salvaged something in Hungary when he took over after the popular uprising of 1956, Mr Husak might have achieved something. 
 In fact, he achieved nothing. 
 For Mr Husak, this is something of a personal tragedy. 
 Like Erich Honecker, a man of similar vintage in East Germany, he spent his formative political years fighting for Communism against the Nazis. 
 At the end of the second world war he was one of a small band which went to Moscow to negotiate with Stalin an agreed programme for &bquo;liberated&equo; Czechoslovakia. 
 Soon after the Communist takeover, he fell foul of the ultra-Stalinists and, as a Slovak, was sentenced to life imprisonment for &bquo;bourgeois nationalism&equo;. 
 He was released in 1960 and rehabilitated three years later. 
 After working, and studying law, for some years as a rank-and-file party member, he was appointed &mdash; at the height of the Prague Spring &mdash; deputy federal prime minister. 
 He became a member of the emasculated politburo when the invasion took place taking over from the wretched Mr Dubcek in April 1969 after branding him and his team &bquo;extremists and rightwing forces.&equo; 
 He was one of the first in the battered political hierarchy to head for Moscow voluntarily for negotiations with Brezhnev. 
 From that moment on, the Kremlin saw him as a &bquo;realistic&equo; politician &mdash; in other words, as one who urged the people to accept the invasion. 
 On the first anniversary of that invasion, when thousands of Czechoslovak demonstrators were dispersed on Mr Husak's orders by the police with military support, he was awarded the Order of Lenin, the highest honour the Russians could give him, and his acceptance of it sealed his fate once and for all Within two years of becoming party leader he purged all but 26 of the central committee members who had been in office before the invasion. 
 When President Mikhail Gorbachev came to power in Moscow in early 1985, Mr Husak became one of the disoriented old men of Eastern Europe, and when Mr Gorbachev reached Prague, in the spring of 1987, Mr Husak looked out of his depth. 
 The writing on the wall for Mr Husak became apparent in the adulation which ordinary Czechoslovak citizens showed for Mr Gorbachev, and in the pages of the Soviet Communist Party newspaper, Pravda, where a series of articles harshly critical of Mr Husak's patron, Leonid Brezhnev, began to appear. 
 Having watched the ignominious departure of Mr Jakes, the president himself &mdash; which Mr Husak had become &mdash; can hardly have been surprised that his own head was now being demanded on a platter. 
 There were rumours after he had a stroke last March that he was on the brink of retirement and that he wished to go. 
 Nothing that has happened in Czechoslovakia or in the wider world since that time has diminished the willingness of the Czechoslovak people to accede to this wish. 
 Territory for peace no longer an impossible dream on eve of anniversary Intifada forces sea change among reluctant Israelis. 
 By Ian Black in Jerusalem 
 YITZHAK Rabin was looking even more than usually impassive on Wednesday night as he watched Israel Television's special programme marking the second anniversary of the outbreak of the Palestinian uprising. 
 The Defence Minister barely flinched as the camera zoomed in for a close-up of his face as they ran the famous film clip from mid-December, 1987, in which he promised that it would all be over by Christmas. 
 No one could have predicted then that the unrest in the West Bank and Gaza Strip would still be going on two years later, so Mr Rabin was playing fairly safe when he said in a brief interview at the end of Wednesday's programme that the uprising would probably continue well into 1990. 
 Israel can cope. 
 The mass demonstrations of the first year are rare these days and the army and Shin Bet security service have been chalking up success after bloody success in hunting down the masked youths who throw petrol bombs and kill collaborators. 
 Many soldiers would prefer to be fighting a &bquo;real&equo; war against armed guerrillas in south Lebanon, but no more than 95 men, mostly reservists, have refused to serve beyond the pre-1967 green line. 
 Intifada draft-dodging barely exists. 
 So far, the military situation is tenable: the army shifts its men around, from the Lebanon border, to training exercises, to the West Bank and Gaza, and then back to Lebanon again. 
 The general staff is unhappy and the squaddies disgruntled, but no more than that. 
 The economy can stand the strain too: a 5 per cent drop in the GNP this year is deemed manageable. 
 Palestinians still come to work in Israel, industry has adjusted and tourism shows signs of recovering. 
 The legal system, many feel, is being eroded. 
 Fifty thousand Palestinians have been through the prisons since the intifada began; scores of Arab children have been shot dead. 
 But rough justice on one side of the green line does not necessarily mean rough justice on the other. 
 Not yet, anyway. 
 Subtly, though, in other, more subterranean ways, the uprising has changed &mdash; and is still changing &mdash; Israeli society. 
 Arabs are no longer seen as cowardly and loathsome terrorists; their determination and solidarity has impressed their enemies. 
 Even the most hawkish Israeli cannot ignore the readiness for sacrifice that the Palestinans have displayed. 
 Mr Yitzhak Shamir, the Likud Prime Minister, seems to recognise this too. 
 His refusal to deal with the PLO is practical, not emotional. 
 Palestinians can still seem demonic. 
 The cruel killings of real or imagined collaborators have helped restore this image, yet who has forgotten that Jews executed traitors during their own struggle for national liberation? 
 Mr Shamir's Stern Gang was no exception. 
 For the 20 years between the 1967 war and the start of the intifada there was coexistence of sorts between Arabs and Jews, even if, in the words of Moshe Dayan, it was the uneasy coexistence of a rider and his horse. 
 That no longer exists. 
 &bquo;The achievement of the uprising,&equo; says the journalist Nahum Barnea, &bquo;is that the vast majority of Israelis who were happy with the status quo are now much more unhappy with it.&equo; 
 This has created a new sense of potential fluidity in political attitudes. 
 Apart from the hard core of settlers and Greater Israel ideologues, many ordinary people have become more open to discussion of the future of the West Bank and Gaza. 
 Territory for peace is not an impossible dream. 
 But this does not preclude extreme and non-peaceful solutions. 
 Those who believe in the &bquo;transfer&equo; of Palestinians now believe in it more openly. 
 At the same time, though, there are more people who can, perhaps for the first time since 1967, imagine that the Jews could go west, back into the green line, or into new borders adjusted to rid themselves of their Palestinian burden. 
 It would be premature &mdash; and misleading &mdash; to try to translate these slowly shifting attitudes into a readiness for dramatic change. 
 All Israel's responses to the intifada have so far been dictated externally, by the Palestinians or the Americans. 
 There is still no substantial domestic pressure on Mr Shamir to make concessions. 
 The Labour Party is still a partner in the national unity government. 
 Anniversaries are arbitrary events, and nothing will change when the uprising's third year begins tomorrow. 
 Yet Wednesday's decision by Egypt &mdash; in close consultation with the PLO &mdash; to accept a US mediation plan means that an Israeli-Palestinian meeting is now likely in the New Year. 
 A long, hard struggle lies ahead to convert the achievements of the intifada into real movement towards a diplomatic settlement. 
 West Bank elections and an Israeli withdrawal still seem a remote possibility. 
 The uprising is certainly an historic event, but the conflict over Palestine has been going on for a century now. 
 A lot of international help will be needed to get things moving. 
 In a rapidly changing world, preoccupied by Eastern Europe, the American Administration may not have the time or patience to devote to Israelis and Palestinians. 
 The war may well just go on and on. 
 Both sides remain stubborn. 
 The Palestinians are tired but still defiant after their long struggle and most Israelis, like Mr Rabin, remain confident that they can cope, even if their doubts are beginning to nag. 
 It is a dangerous moment, pregnant with hope teetering on the edge of despair. 
 Intifada enters year three under curfew. 
 By Ian Black in Jerusalem 
 AS Israeli leaders met to discuss the latest Middle East peace moves, nearly a million Palestinians were placed under curfew in the occupied territories to forestall trouble during today's second anniversary of the intifada. 
 The country's senior politicians decided to send the Foreign Minister, Mr Moshe Arens, for talks in Washington next month with his American and Egyptian counterparts, drawing immediate criticism from rightwingers. 
 The decision follows Wednesday's conditional acceptance by Egypt of a US mediation plan to bring Israelis and Palestinians to the negotiating table in Cairo to discuss holding elections in the West Bank and Gaza Strip. 
 The Likud Prime Minister, Mr Yitzhak Shamir, proposed holding the elections last May, but he is resolutely opposed to any role for Mr Yasser Arafat's Palestine Liberation Organisation, which he insists is still committed to terrorism. 
 Rightwingers in his own party, however, fear that by embarking on a dialogue under US auspices, Israel will eventually be pushed, despite its own reservations, into talks with the PLO and advance the creation of an independent Palestinian state. 
 One of the most truculent of his critics, the super-hawkish Mr Ariel Sharon, said yesterday that he would be consulting like-minded colleagues about what he called &bquo;the dangerous deterioration in the political situation&equo;. 
 Considerable political turmoil can be expected until the Washington meeting takes place, and sources here predict that Mr Arens wil be taking a very hardline position that will preclude any participation by the PLO. 
 In advance of today's intifada anniversary, meanwhile, security measures were stepped up throughout the occupied territories, with curfews in force throughout the Gaza Strip and in large areas of the West Bank, including Nablus. 
 Friday prayers in the mosques of Jerusalem's Old City passed without incident, although large numbers of troops and paramilitary border police were on hand. 
 West Bankers and Gazans were unable to enter the city. 
 Israeli groups are planning protests over the weekend, with special attention focusing on a march in Jerusalem by the Peace Now movement in which demonstrators will carry pictures of some of the 130 Palestinian and four Jewish children under 16 who have been killed during the unrest. 
 All Israeli newspapers, which produce weekend editions on a Friday, yesterday carried long articles and in some cases special supplements marking the start of the uprising's third year. 
 Yediot Ahronot ran a piece by the novelist David Grossman, author of the acclaimed Yellow Wind, widely seen as the finest single literary work about the occupation when it was published in 1987. 
 His description of the intifada is entitled Land of the Masked Men. 
 Palestinian view of the intifada, Page 23 
 Miami relaxes as policeman is found guilty of killing blacks. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 THE tension that has gripped Miami began to ease yesterday as a policeman, William Lozano, was found guilty of manslaughter over the killing of two young black men on a motorcycle in January. 
 Three days of rioting by Miami's black community followed the killing, and police and city officials were on full alert yesterday for a resumption of the riots if the jury acquitted the Hispanic-American policeman. 
 All police leave and holidays were cancelled. 
 Two police armoured cars stood outside the courthouse. 
 The six-person jury unanimously found that Lozano had improperly used his gun. 
 Lozano had claimed that the motorcycle was aimed at him, and that he had no time to leap out of the way. 
 His shot killed the motorcyclist, and the passenger died of injuries after the bike crashed. 
 Lazano, who has been in the force five years, will be sentenced on January 24. 
 He faces a maximum term of 60 years. 
 Thatcher &bquo;risks blocking the spread of democracy&equo;. 
 By Jean Stead in East Berlin 
 BRITAIN could lose a valuable opportunity to help the growth of democracy in Eastern Europe by failing to give total commitment to the European Community, the Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, said in East Berlin yesterday. 
 Mrs Thatcher risked impeding democratisation by not giving the Community total commitment, he said. 
 Mr Kinnock has ended two days of talks with opposition leaders in East Berlin, including New Forum and the East German Social Democrats. 
 He has also met Senate leaders in West Berlin. 
 He said he had heard calls for unity on every side, but for a unity of common interests, attitudes and culture shared by the two Germanys. 
 This was completely different from any idea of grandiose constitutional changes. 
 The opposition leaders he met agreed that the question of reunification of Germany was not one for the German people alone, but was the rightful concern of their European neighbours. 
 Some might see dangers and difficulties in discussing reunification, but it could not be left off the agenda. 
 Mr Kinnock said that the opening of the Berlin Wall made him &bquo;feel joyous about the future&equo;. 
 He presented the mayor of West Berlin with a statuette of a woman holding a dove of peace and then walked through Checkpoint Charlie. 
 Sri Lanka finds cheer in Delhi's new government. 
 By Derek Brown in New Delhi 
 INDIA'S troubled relations with Sri Lanka have improved markedly since the change of government last weekend. 
 Mr Ranjan Wijeratne, the first foreign minister to visit Delhi since the general election, flies home to Colombo today with renewed assurances that India will withdraw its remaining &bquo;peace-keeping&equo; forces from the island, and work for closer co-operation. 
 There are 2 &frac12; divisions of Indian troops still in the north and east of Sri Lanka &mdash; up to 30,000 men &mdash; and little prospect of the withdrawal being completed by the original target date of December 31. 
 But after talks with the Prime Minister, Mr Vishwanath Pratap Singh, Mr Wijeratne ruled out any formal extension of the deadline. 
 &bquo;The Prime Minister told me he would discuss the details with his officials and come back to us. 
 There is no new timetable,&equo; he said. 
 Was it realistic to hope that these thousands of 0troops, with their equipment, could be pulled out in just three weeks? 
 &bquo;Where there is a will, there is a way. 
 I trust the leadership of India,&equo; Mr Wijeratne added. 
 The latest talks, which also involved the new Indian Foreign Minister, Mr Inder Kumar Gujral, also covered prospects for the South Asia Association for Regional Cooperation (Saarc). 
 The much-delayed Saarc summit has been provisionally arranged for early next March in Colombo. 
 Whether it is held, will depend on improvements in the dire security situation in Sri Lanka. 
 The Colombo government believes it has broken the back of the rebellion in the south by leftwing Sinhalese guerrillas, but is still faced with near anarchy in the Tamil north and east. 
 There, the provincial government installed as part of the 1987 Indo-Sri Lanka Accord, is increasingly defiant of Colombo. 
 It has raised its own private army, which is already engaged in a two-front minor war with Sri Lankan government forces and with Tamil Tiger guerrillas, who, though badly mauled, have survived a bloody, two-year battle against vastly superior Indian forces, killing more than 1,150 of them. 
 Scots to mark Chariots of Fire runner's last resting place. 
 By Simon Winchester in Hong Kong 
 NEXT St Andrew's Day, if all goes to plan, a delegation of Scots, with a lone piper, will arrive at a forlorn old garden in the town of Weifang in eastern China, to bring to an appropriately dignified conclusion one of the more remarkable sports stories of the century. 
 The grave of the athlete Eric Liddell, the man who refused to run in the Olympics on the Sabbath in 1924 and whose story was immortalised in the film Chariots of Fire, has at last been found, unmarked. 
 A Hong Kong-based Scottish engineer and historian, Mr Charles Walker, is behind the scheme to inscribe a gravestone and place it at the spot where Liddell is known to have been buried. 
 The athlete, a devout Christian and, like his parents, a missionary in China, died in 1945, in a Japanese internment camp, in Shandong province. 
 A Hong Kong legislator interned with him, Mr H.K. Cheng, was able to help Mr Walker and a Canadian internee, Mr David Michell, to pinpoint the site, in the grounds of what is now Weifang Middle School. 
 Beijing is co-operating. 
 The Foreign and Commonwealth Office sees the gesture as &bquo;one small but symbolic way of rebuilding some of the bridges destroyed after Tiananmen Square&equo;, a diplomat said. 
 Mrs Jenny Somerville, Liddell's sister, has sent a verse from Isaiah to inscribe on the granite headstone: &bquo;They soar on wings like eagles; they run and grow not weary.&equo; 
 Mr Walker is quietly optimistic. 
 &bquo;If we can raise the money, and get the permissions, we will be there next St Andrew's Day. 
 It will be a sad little ceremony, but the right end, I think, for a much admired man.&equo; 
 East Berlin pursues pillars of the old establishment. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 IN East Germany two men, formerly regarded as untouchable pillars of the old regime, have, rightly or wrongly, become the focus of over-zealous and sometimes bizarre persecution by the legal authorities and an indignant public. 
 Mr Alexander Schalck-Golodkowski, the previous state secretary for foreign trade gave himself up early yesterday to the police in West Berlin, where he is now under arrest. 
 He is accused by East Berlin, which has asked for his extradition, of embezzlement, corruption, and illegal dealings in arms and foreign currency. 
 A glittering figure on the international financial circuit, he not only provided East Germany with much-needed foreign currency but also played a central part in all political and economic exchanges with West Germany over the past 30 years. 
 He has protested his innocence, saying that before fleeing East Germany last weekend he dissolved the GDR's hard-currency accounts in Switzerland and transferred the sum of Dm60 million (&pound;22 million) to East Germany's state bank. 
 He said he had always worked for the benefit of his country and could not be held responsible for how the hard currency he procured was spent by its leaders. 
 Sources here said that if Mr Schalck-Golodkowski was put on trial his inside knowledge of life under Mr Erich Honecker could prove highly detrimental to the already disgraced former East German leaders. 
 But while Mr Schalck-Golodkowski's innocence or guilt must remain a matter for the courts, the detention of his friend and lawyer, Mr Wolfgang Vogel, clearly was in breach of the law. 
 It demonstrated the excesses that are possible in the present climate of confusion and for which the chief public prosecutor has apologised. 
 Mr Vogel, detained on Tuesday and held for 10 hours in a solitary cell, was arrested because the prosecutors believed he would reveal the whereabouts of Mr Schalck-Golodkowski. 
 For almost 30 years he was a key negotiator for East Berlin on &bquo;humanitarian questions&equo; and a confidante of Mr Honecker. 
 Spy swaps, prisoner exchanges, and negotiations to free the thousands of East Germans that this summer sought refuge in West German embassies, were his domain. 
 He said yesterday: &bquo;I was told that the buying-out of political prisoners by West Germany and the spy swaps were immoral and against the law.&equo; 
 Summit offers chance to improve British image in EC Hurd faces test of beliefs on Europe. 
 By Michael White in Strasbourg and Hella Pick 
 THE Strasbourg summit, which begins this morning, will prove a critical test of the political skills of the new Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, six weeks after he inherited the post in which Mrs Thatcher has tormented and overruled his predecessors. 
 Mr Hurd, who dared to speak French on French Radio this week, is as instinctive a European as the Prime Minister is not. 
 But loyalty and prudence will require him to do good by stealth this weekend if he is to restore Britain's tarnished European image. 
 Apart from last month's Elysee supper-summit, this is his first outing with Mrs Thatcher. 
 Tensions over the degree of British commitment to eventually joining the Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) during the Madrid summit in June contributed to Sir Geoffrey Howe's removal from the Foreign Office in July. 
 During Mr John Major's brief tenure he was made to look foolish on his one co-starring trip &mdash; the Commonwealth conference in Kuala Lumpur &mdash; by the Prime Minister's repudiation of the South African statement he had negotiated. 
 Unlike Mr Major, Mr Hurd is an experienced former diplomat and a Foreign Office Minister of State who has sounded made-for-the-job since day one, which is why he would probably not have got it but for the Lawson affair. 
 In what are often highly technical arguments where tone matters a lot, he sounds like a politician who would join the ERM as soon as practicable &mdash; possibly by the end of next year &mdash; just as Sir Geoffrey, Mr Heseltine and Mr Lawson would. 
 Mrs Thatcher does not sound that way. 
 Labour, which wants immediate negotiation on its own four-point terms of entry into ERM, now paints Mr Major as a Thatcher poodle on the issue. 
 That may be wrong. 
 And a Hurd-Major axis could prove crucial if the Prime Minister is to be dragged in when inflation, and the exchange rate, have drifted down far enough. 
 Meanwhile, Mr Hurd loyally reflects the cabinet line on Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) embodied in the treasury's &bquo;competing currencies&equo; paper issued on November 2 as an alternative to the Delors report's Stage II and III &mdash; the creation of a single central bank and currency. 
 Labour, too, rejects the independent central bank concept run by what Shadow Chancellor, Mr John Smith, has called &bquo;central bankers who inhabit a world comfortably insulated from European electorates&equo; &mdash; in other words undemocratic and deflationary. 
 Mr Hurd has no trouble stressing the need for a liberalisation of European markets in which Britain has often led the way. 
 He protests that the French-backed Intergovernmental Conference (IGC) to promote Delors II and III is premature when the consequences of Stage I &mdash; including next July's abolition of French and Italian exchange controls &mdash; are far from clear and the preparatory work not done. 
 He is less conspicuous in opposing the Social Charter as a costly threat to jobs if the standards of Germany are to be imposed on countries like Britain. 
 And, like Sir Geoffrey and Mr Heseltine, he routinely sets up federalism as a straw man to knock down. 
 But he does not use the harsh, emotive language of the Prime Minister. 
 In a speech in Oxford last weekend he stressed voluntary co-operation and diversity. 
 &bquo;European union is not a goal or an event. 
 It is a process. 
 Against that background I do not believe that the path of federalism is the right one for the Community.&equo; 
 Such use of the word &bquo;union&equo; is un-Thatcherite. 
 So Mr Hurd will use his diplomatic skills &mdash; and his French &mdash; in Strasbourg to keep the temperature down and take the rough edges off disagreement, while advancing with pragmatic caution greater British involvement in the rapidly evolving structure of the Community. 
 He does not favour its enlargement but does favour new forms of association for EFTA and the emerging democracies of Eastern Europe. 
 By contrast, Mr Major was a novice Foreign Secretary whose skills and stamina were tested to breaking point when &mdash; alone &mdash; he tried to modify the draft South African statement in Kuala Lumpur. 
 Mr Major won enough useful points in support of Britain's well-advertised aversion to punitive sanctions to have been able to brief Sunday papers about a &bquo;British victory&equo;. 
 It is not clear whether he knew then that Mrs Thatcher had decided to sign the statement and then issue her own alternative. 
 Informed sources say that Mr Major was informed &bquo;rather late&equo; when much of the Thatcher outburst had already been drafted by Charles Powell, her private secretary, who had accompanied her to the weekend retreat of Lankawi. 
 When Mr Major gave an unhappy press conference late on the Sunday night, his permanent secretary, Sir Patrick Wright, and other FO officials sat at the back of the room, suggesting either moral reinforcement or a watchdog role. 
 Mr Hurd needs no minders, but the 60 Tory MPs who declined to support Mrs Thatcher for leader last week, plus MEPs, this week's Lords report and many industrialists will be looking to him for a more emollient performance in difficult circumstances. 
 He has at least one advantage over his three predecessors, including Mr Francis Pym. 
 As things stand he does look &bquo;unassailable&equo;. 
 MEPs set out their agenda in European power game. 
 By Michael White in Strasbourg 
 THE European parliament yesterday signalled renewed determination to use the drive for economic integration to close the &bquo;democratic deficit&equo;, producing a 10-point plan which, despite the suspicions of Conservative and Labour front benches, could have profound implications for Westminster. 
 Addressing the 12 heads of government at the start of the Strasbourg summit, Mr Enrique Baron, the Spanish Socialist who is Lord Henry Plumb's successor as president of the parliament, urged the leaders to go all the way towards full European union provided it is &bquo;based on the characteristics which we share in common &mdash; those of parliamentary democracy&equo;. 
 His blueprint for evolving &bquo;a genuine parliamentary democracy&equo; will be discussed at a preparatory conference next spring which the European parliament will hold with the Council of Ministers and the bureaucratic Commission. 
 Its aim, with the likely support of West Germany and the Commission President, Mr Jacques Delors, will be to ensure that institutions of democratic accountability are developed in parallel with the supra-national instruments of economic and monetary policy-making like the proposed central bank. 
 The development would run in tandem with the inter-governmental conference. 
 MPs at Westminster are increasingly aware of the pervasive impact of Europe on their activities which barely see a week pass without some debate on EC directives. 
 There is no automatic membership of the relevant Commons committees &mdash; let alone votes &mdash; for MEPs as there is in Bonn and elsewhere. 
 The Commons scrutiny committee proposed better procedures last month for vetting, or resisting, the flow from Brussels and Mr Michael Heseltine has urged the creation of an upper house at Strasbourg &mdash; a European senate &mdash; drawn from among MPs in national parliaments to bridge the current gap. 
 Its powers are not clear, a reflection of the confusion which exists. 
 Mr Baron's 10 points yesterday were not fleshed out either, but they go further than MEPs have yet done. 
 They include a proposal that the European Parliament have the right to initiate legislation, albeit perhaps jointly with the Commission; and what is called &bquo;a joint decision-making by Parliament in any new areas introduced under the new treaties&equo;. 
 That is a roundabout way of suggesting a form of political accountability to elected MEPs when the central bank starts evolving macro-economic policies for all 12. 
 There is also a suggestion that the Council of Ministers meet in public when it is acting as a legislative body, a suggestion which some parliamentarians first attribute to Mr Tony Benn in his days as Energy Secretary. 
 Like Mr Benn, Mrs Thatcher asserts national sovereignty and democratic accountability though in reality a determined prime minister with a pliant majority at Westminster has more unfettered power than in most Community countries. 
 Labour, which has swung round to supporting Europe, is worried by the unaccountability of a central bank despite last week's assurances from Mr Delors. 
 Mr Bryan Gould is generally rated less European than the Shadow Chancellor, Mr John Smith; and Mr Gerald Kaufman, the Shadow Foreign Secretary, has swung round from gut anti-Europeanism to a conviction that powerful central institutions are unavoidable &mdash; and Britain should play its full part. 
 Yesterday, Mr Baron said that strict justice demanded that &bquo;the European Parliament cannot go on being regarded as a marginal institution, able only to speak but not to take decisions&equo;. 
 He stressed: &bquo;It is peoples who, by their demonstrations and actions, point the way forward for their governments. 
 Would it not have been a pipedream only six weeks ago to think that the Berlin Wall would be knocked down?&equo; 
 Ortega hinges peace offer on disbanding of contras Simon Tisdall in Managua looks at prospects for a Nicaraguan proposal at the Central American presidents' summit this weekend. 
 THE Nicaraguan Government is expected to launch an all-out attempt to secure the demobilisation of the contra rebels when the Central American presidents gather at San Jose in Costa Rica tomorrow for a summit meeting crucial to the future of the peace process. 
 In return for &bquo;visible progress&equo; towards disbanding the Honduran-based contras by the end of the year, the Sandinistas will offer to use their influence with the leftwing rebels of the Farabundo Marti National Liberation Front (FMLN) to halt the fighting in El Salvador. 
 According to West European diplomats in Managua, President Daniel Ortega is running out of time in his attempts to present himself to the Nicaraguan electorate on February 25 as the &bquo;peace maker&equo; who ended the contra war. 
 To that end, the Sandinistas will drop their earlier insistence on a firm deadline of December 30 if a UN, or OAS-supervised demobilisation, is making discernible headway in disarming or relocating the rebels, the diplomats said. 
 Nicaraguan sources here say that the summit meeting is likely to witness an angry denunciation by the Salvadorean president, Mr Alfredo Cristiani, of the Sandinista arms supplies to the FMLN rebels, especially last month's alleged deliveries by aircraft of Sam-7 anti-aircraft missiles. 
 Mr Cristiani suspended ties between the two countries in the wake of the incident and threatened to boycott tomorrow's summit meeting unless it was moved away from its planned Managua venue. 
 According to the sources, Nicaragua will, as usual, deny the allegations but propose instead &bquo;realistic negotiation&equo; between the US-supported Salvadorean Government and the FMLN. 
 &bquo;In the Nicaraguan view, a military solution in El Salvador is impossible,&equo; a western diplomat said. 
 &bquo;Realistic&equo; seems to mean negotiation acceptable to the FMLN and to the Salvadorean army, which would have to participate to ensure that any subsequent deal should stick.&equo; 
 An attempt by Mr Cristiani to put the Sandinistas in the dock at San Jose is likely to prompt Mr Ortega to raise the human-rights record of the Salvadorean Government, especially the murder on November 16 of six Jesuit priests, probably by a renegade army unit. 
 &bquo;They &lsqb;the Sandinistas&rsqb; were very concerned after the Sam-7 aeroplane incident&equo;, one analyst said. 
 &bquo;They could see it was distracting attention from their own priorities over contra demobilisation. 
 Now they are much more relaxed and hope to turn it to their advantage while still denying involvement.&equo; 
 By offering to use their influence with the FMLN, which maintains offices and a radio station in Nicaragua, the Sandinistas may also point to Mr Cristiani that a summit meeting which supported negotiations would strengthen his hand with his own, powerful army commanders. 
 &bquo;It is a poker game&equo;, one senior western diplomat commented. 
 &bquo;But Ortega is cleverer than the other and he works harder.&equo; 
 In his quest for a solution to the contra insurgency, Mr Ortega dramatised the situation at the end of October by cancelling a 19-month-old ceasefire and resuming offensive operations. 
 He concentrated the Sandinista troops along the Honduran frontier; offered to end arms imports until after the election; gave assurances of safe conduct to returning rebels; and then said he was ready to reinstate the ceasefire he had only just abrogated. 
 As the issue assumes greater urgency, the Sandinistas may be willing to undercut, or at least put on hold, the FMLN insurgency in El Salvador, sources here suggest. 
 The Nicaraguans will try to increase the involvement of third parties in the peace process when the two-day summit meeting convenes. 
 As well as UN and OAS units, the Sandinistas have proposed arbitration, within the peace process itself, by the foreign ministers of Argentina, Mexico and Venezuela. 
 That has been opposed by Mr Oscar Arias, President of Costa Rica, who will chair the summit meeting. 
 For Managua, the greater the involvement of Latin countries and independent agencies, the greater is the pressure on Washington to support contra demobilisation. 
 The five-country meeting at San Jose has assumed a critical atmosphere because of the possible breakdown of last August's Tela accord, which agreed contra demobilisation in exchange for democratic Nicaraguan elections. 
 Other accords under the peace process, chiefly the denial of support for regional insurgency, have also been threatened by recent events. 
 The impending retirement of Mr Arias, Nobel prize winner and the main motivator, has increased uncertainty. 
 Although the American Government supports the peace process, it has urged the contras to remain in Honduras until after the Nicaraguan election and has continued to provide them with non-military funds. 
 The contras, for their part, have consistently rejected calls to disband. 
 After the contra field commanders' rejection of their exiled political leaders, and as a result of Washington's loss of leverage, the estimated 12,000-strong force has become an even more unpredictable element in a complex equation. 
 For that reason alone, according to sources here, Mr Ortega's summit game plan could come to naught, leaving the Sandinistas to fight an election and a war, and the peace process close to collapse. 
 China slates reform wave. 
 By Stephen Vines in Hong Kong 
 THE Chinese Premier, Mr Li Peng, yesterday made what is believed to be his most forthright attack yet on the reforms sweeping Eastern Europe during a private meeting with a delegation from Hong Kong. 
 According to delegation sources, Mr Li said that Beijing was fortunate to have had the foresight to crack down on its democracy movement in June, preventing China from being thrown into the &bquo;turmoil and confusion&equo; now prevailing in Eastern Europe. 
 China has shown some restraint in commenting on events in Eastern Europe and has made its views evident only in oblique ways. 
 For example, the Chinese Communist Party pointedly sent a warm message of support to the conference of the hardline Romanian Communist Party. 
 However, events in Eastern Europe were evidently uppermost in Mr Li's mind during his meeting with the Hong Kong delegation which was in Beijing to discuss the future of the British colony. 
 Simon Long adds from Beijing: China seems to be retreating into a diplomatic posture reminiscent of the Cultural Revolution, at odds with both Washington and Moscow, and firing frequent broadsides against all-comers for alleged interference in its internal affairs. 
 Yesterday, East Germany was in the firing line for having received the Dalai Lamai, exiled spiritual leader of Tibet, in East Berlin on Wednesday. 
 China also &bquo;could not tolerate&equo; the award given to the Dalai Lama in Paris, and &bquo;condemned&equo; France for permitting the exiled democracy campaigner, Yan Jiaqi, to &bquo;conduct activities against the Chinese Government&equo;. 
 China was similarly indignant about plans for the awarding of the Nobel Peace Prize to the Dalai Lama on Sunday, the anniversary of last year's demonstrations in Lhasa. 
 Star Watch A comet for Christmas:.. 
 By Alan Pickup 
 THE newly-found Aarseth-Brewington comet should brighten rapidly this month as it sweeps southwards through Ophiuchus in our morning sky, perhaps to become a naked eye object before it dips too far south to be seen from Britain. 
 Its path is plotted on our star map, with its position marked every fifth morning. 
 The stars near the middle of the map rise in the east at 05.00 tomorrow and at 04.00 on Christmas Day, climbing to reach the places shown above the ESE to SE horizon at daybreak tomorrow and by 07.00 on Christmas Day. 
 Most of the brighter stars plotted are of the second magnitude, while the fainter ones are of the fourth. 
 The comet was close to the ninth magnitude on November 16 when it was discovered by amateur astronomers in Norway and the United States. 
 As it moves towards Perihelion on December 27, 45m km from the Sun and 140m from the Earth, it is doubling in brightness every four days or so. 
 The path is definite, but predictions of its brightness and appearance are very uncertain, although it is likely to develop an upwards pointing tail. 
 It may reach the sixth magnitude by December 10 and the fourth on about December 20 when it moves inside Mercury's orbit and passes the star Zeta Ophiuchi. 
 It may be brighter than the third magnitude by Christmas morning, but by then it will be low and difficult in the SE twilight. 
 Egypt accepts US talks plan. 
 By Deborah Pugh in Cairo 
 AFTER two months of agonising diplomatic wrangling, Egypt, with the apparent tacit agreement of the PLO, has agreed to the five-point formula of the US Secretary of State, Mr James Baker, for talks between Israel and the Palestinians. 
 The next step will be a round of preliminary talks between the Egyptian and Israeli Foreign Ministers and Mr Baker to be held in Washington early next month. 
 The aim of these talks will be to set up a dialogue between Palestinians and Israelis in Cairo on elections in the occupied territories. 
 The Washington talks will centre on the crucial issue of who will represent the Palestinians. 
 On the official level, the PLO is still insisting that &bquo;it is ready to accept to deal with the Baker plan&equo; but only if the composition of the Palestinian delegation is publicly selected by the PLO. 
 Egyptian insistence on this position would lead to a withdrawal of Israeli participation, given the refusal of the Prime Minister, Mr Yitzhak Shamir, to deal directly with the PLO. 
 The Egyptians, while insisting that they do not speak for the Palestinians, appear ready to fudge the principle of PLO selection of the Palestinian delegation to ensure Israeli participation. 
 A source close to the Egyptian foreign ministry said: &bquo;We are trying to circumvent the ideological issue. 
 We will choose PLO delegates. 
 Any Palestinian who speaks will have to have the approval of the PLO, but this will not be said publicly because we don't want to give Shamir the chance to withdraw, which we think he's looking for an excuse to do.&equo; 
 Reports from Jerusalem yesterday showed the usual split in government reaction. 
 The Defence Minister, Mr Yitzhak Rabin, welcomed the Egyptian acceptance of the Baker plan, while Mr Shamir's aide, Mr Avi Pazner, gave a restrained response. 
 &bquo;We are waiting to receive the content of the Egyptian response from the United States,&equo; Mr Pazner said. 
 &bquo;When we receive it we will study it carefully and later decide how to react.&equo; 
 The Americans are clearly hoping that it will be possible to bring the Palestinians and Israelis around the negotiating table without confronting the contradictions and achieve an historic breakthrough. 
 The PLO leader, Mr Yasser Arafat, who was in Cairo earlier this week, appears to be giving tacit support to the Egyptian strategy. 
 He has, at least, not publicly opposed Egypt's diplomatic initiatives. 
 The Egyptian Foreign Minister, Dr Esmat Abdel Meguid, yesterday undercut recent reports that a rift was developing between the PLO and Egypt. 
 He said in Tunis that Egypt had held consultations with the PLO before officially accepting the Baker plan. 
 Bulgaria politburo purged ahead of protest rallies. 
 By Denise Searle and Mike Power in Sofia 
 BULGARIA'S new leader, Mr Petar Mladenov, yesterday purged many hardliners from the Communist Party's ruling politburo and central committee, while heaping blame for the country's political and economic crisis on the former leader, Mr Todor Zhivkov. 
 At a hurriedly called top-level Communist Party meeting, Mr Mladenov said he was responding to public pressure and requests from Communist Party members by removing Mr Zhivkov from the central committee. 
 The meeting also withdrew the vote of thanks given to Mr Zhivkov when he was forced to resign as Communist Party and state leader on November 10. 
 &bquo;Todor Zhivkov was involved in a painful period for the Communist Party,&equo; said an official statement. 
 &bquo;We would not be living up to our responsibilities if we did not listen to ordinary party members.&equo; 
 This is the second significant Communist Party clear-out in the four weeks since Mr Mladenov seized power. 
 He has steadily distanced himself from Mr Zhivkov's heavy-handed policies and introduced more tolerance in Bulgaria. 
 Most of the population have welcomed Mr Mladenov's reforms, although he has been criticised for leaving some of Mr Zhivkov's supporters in prominent positions. 
 Yesterday's clear-out removed the last of the hardliners from the politburo. 
 A key addition is the liberal, Mr Alexander Lilov, who was dismissed from the politburo in 1983, without explanation, for differing with Mr Zhivkov. 
 Similar radical changes have been made in the central committee, with 20 old faces going, including the deputy Foreign Minister, Mr Ivan Ganev. 
 The reshuffle clears the decks before Monday's crucial scheduled central committee's meeting which is expected to reveal alarming details about Bulgaria's ailing economy and to tackle the problem of Mr Zhivkov's internationally comdemned assimilation policy against the country's Turkish minority. 
 The changes also anticipate many of the demands which were expected to be made at opposition rallies tomorrow in Sofia and the provinces where calls are expected for the resignation of many of the figures ousted yesterday. 
 The old guard hit back at the newly formed, broad-based Union of Democratic Forces, which is organising tomorrow's demonstrations. 
 Posters have appeared around the city giving the wrong date, time, and place, and the central committee secretariat has written to every Communist Party organisation in the country criticising the Union of Democratic Forces. 
 A Union of Democratic Forces spokesman, Mr Georgi Spassov, said: &bquo;This demonstrates that we have a long way to go before we have true democracy in Bulgaria.&equo; 
 Hrawi will resign unless Aoun goes. 
 By Reuter in Beirut 
 PRESIDENT Elias Hrawi has threatened to resign if he fails to topple General Michel Aoun, whom he accused of blocking his way to unite and bring peace to Lebanon. 
 &bquo;I did not come to the presidency to become a president who will consolidate partition or to manage a crisis,&equo; he said yesterday. 
 &bquo;I have come to restore Lebanon's unity and extend the sovereignty of the government over Lebanese territory. 
 &bquo;When my patience runs out with all the mediation and when I exhaust my capabilities I will issue a statement to all Lebanese and apologise. 
 I will tell them &bquo;this is your actual situation&equo;, and leave.&equo; 
 Mr Hrawi has not been able to move into the presidential palace in the Beirut suburb of Baabda because it is occupied by Gen Aoun. 
 He said foreign mediators had asked him not to use force to break Gen Aoun's control of the enclave. 
 He refused to set a time within which he would step down, saying he was giving diplomacy time to solve the crisis peacefully. 
 It was essential to act quickly to avert the partition of Lebanon into religious cantons. 
 &bquo;The country is living on a volcano, in a field of mines,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I am against war and operations which disrupt peace and cause death and destruction,&equo; Mr Hrawi said. 
 But he added that patience had limits and he might wait a few days or two weeks. 
 Syrian forces, Lebanese troops, and militiamen have been poised for a week for an attack to seize the palace. 
 Diplomatic sources said Syria had increased its troops in Lebanon from about 30,000 to 45,000 since Mr Hrawi's election. 
 Mr Hrawi said no decision had been taken yet for a military showdown. 
 He accused Gen Aoun of using as &bquo;sandbags&equo; the thousands of Christians who have gathered outside the palace to deter an attack. 
 Iraq sets off own rocket Delhi minister's daughter seized. 
 Separatist Muslim militants kidnapped the daughter of an Indian minister yesterday and are demanding the release of five jailed colleagues as ransom, police said. 
 They said Rubaiya Mufti, daughter of the Home Minister, Mr Mufti Mohammed Sayeed, was seized in the city of Srinagar by the Kashmir Liberation Front, a group demanding the secession of Jammu-Kashmir state from India and its assimilation into Pakistan. 
 -Reuter.. 
 Record cocaine haul. 
 Police in Rotterdam have seized 726lb of cocaine in the biggest-ever haul in Dutch criminal history. 
 -Reuter. 
 Torture claims. 
 The New York City Bar Association claimed in a report released yesterday that torture has been commonly used in Turkish police stations and that the Turkish legal system has failed to respond to it. 
 -AP. 
 Dissidents' asylum. 
 Taiwan will grant political asylum to 12 Chinese dissidents who went to South Korea fearing persecution for involvement in the pro-democracy movement in China, an official of the Exit and Entry Bureau said yesterday. 
 -Reuter. 
 Consular ties. 
 The Soviet Union and South Korea have set up consular offices in each other's capitals, Seoul's foreign ministry said yesterday. 
 -Reuter. 
 Bank blast. 
 Nine people were wounded when two bombs exploded after hours at the Banco Popular in central Lima, and another bomb was deactivated at the home of a well-known television journalist, police said yesterday. 
 Two suspects have been held. 
 -Reuter. 
 Search for survivors. 
 Rescue workers found no sign yesterday of 39 crew members from two large container ships that disappeared after sending out distress signals during a fierce storm in the Gulf of St Lawrence. 
 A coastguard vessel, fighting huge seas and high winds, picked up two empty life rafts and the wreckage of a third near the area where the ships ran into trouble. 
 -Reuter. 
 Spain swears in unchanged cabinet. 
 By John Hooper in Madrid 
 THE Spanish Prime Minister, Mr Felipe Gonzalez, decided against reshuffling his cabinet to stabilise a political climate which had become increasingly unpredictable since the October 29 general election, sources close to him said yesterday. 
 The unchanged team was sworn in yesterday by King Juan Carlos. 
 Fresh elections are pending in three of Spain's 52 constituencies after judges annulled the results, citing widespread irregularities. 
 The quasi-liberal Spanish Socialist Workers' Party, which topped the poll six weeks ago, is now one seat short of an overall majority in the Congress of Deputies. 
 The Socialists suffered a sharp drop in votes and seats. 
 Mr Gonzalez managed to win a vote of confidence in the first round only with the support of a Canary Islands deputy who is widely regarded as a parliamentary spokesman and lobbyist for the Tenerife banana planters. 
 Mr Luis Mardones was the only deputy elected for the Independent Groupings of the Canaries (AIC). 
 An unchanged cabinet had been widely expected, but only as a temporary measure because of the uncertainty caused by the courts. 
 The verdicts gave up to three months for new polls to be held. 
 Government sources, however, suggested that that the Prime Minister would not necessarily change his team after the final outcome became known. 
 Several opposition parties interpreted Mr Gonzalez's attitude as defiance of public opinion. 
 A spokesman for the largest opposition group, the People's Party, said the Prime Minister was acting &bquo;as if nothing had changed&equo;. 
 Mr Gonzalez has also come in for criticism from within his own party. 
 A leader of Socialist Left, a radical pressure group, said the confirmation in office of the old team was &bquo;a serious mistake, because it signals the endorsement of an economic policy criticised by a lot of people&equo;. 
 Mr Mardones cast his decisive vote, on Tuesday night, after the Prime Minister promised to &bquo;consider&equo; his tiny group's demands. 
 British nuclear test in Nevada. 
 A British nuclear weapon was detonated under the Nevada desert yesterday, the US Energy Department said. 
 The blast, which registered 5.4 on the Richter scale, caused ripples in highrise buildings in Las Vegas, 105 miles away. 
 The explosion, the 21st British test at the Nevada site, was conducted under an agreement with the US. -AP. 
 Somalia rebel claim. 
 Somalia has denied a claim by rebels that they have captured Hargeisa, a war-torn provincial capital in the north. 
 -Reuter. 
 Polish jail deaths. 
 Three Polish prisoners were killed when riots broke out in five jails after parliament excluded habitual offenders from an amnesty. 
 -Reuter. 
 Pisa tower open. 
 Despite calls for its closure on safety grounds, the Leaning Tower of Pisa is to remain open for the time being, the mayor said yesterday. 
 -Reuter. 
 Soviet ship fire. 
 Two Russian seamen died but 80 crew members were rescued yesterday when a Soviet fish factory ship caught fire in the Bay of Biscay, the British coastguard said. 
 -Reuter. 
 Benin reforms. 
 The leadership of Benin, West Africa, facing popular discontent and unable to pay its bills, has formally denounced Communism and promises constitutional reforms by early next year. 
 -Reuter.. 
 Journalists expelled. 
 European mercenaries ruling the Comoros Islands expelled 11 foreign correspondents after seizing their notebooks, film and cassette tapes and accusing them of inciting anti-government demonstrations, said one of the reporters. 
 -Reuter.. 
 Flooding relief. 
 Global warming will cause less coastal flooding than originally predicted, US scientists say. 
 The sea level will rise by about 14 inches instead of 39. -AP. 
 Soviet Union appears to accept reunification of two states is inevitable Kremlin agrees to plan for German confederation. 
 By Hella Pick Diplomatic Editor 
 THE Soviet Union accepts in principle confederation between East and West Germany, and expects that this key move towards German reunification will be ratified next year at the summit meeting of the 35 signatories of the Helsinki Declaration. 
 This has emerged from briefings by the West German Foreign Minister, Mr Hans-Dietrich Genscher, to members of the German Bundestag about his visit to Moscow earlier this week. 
 It represents an important clarification of the Soviet position on German unity, after Mr Eduard Shevardnadze, the Foreign Minister, and other senior Soviet spokesmen took issue with Chancellor Helmut Kohl's 10-point plan for German reunification. 
 It seems to show that the Soviet Union has already accepted the inevitability of a drawing together of the two Germanys. 
 The Soviet leader's main aim for the summit, apart from celebrating the conclusion of a treaty on conventional arms cuts in Europe, would be to discuss the German question within the context of the momentous changes in East-West relations. 
 Mr Gorbachev insists, as a condition to German confederation, that the 35 &mdash; which include the US and Canada, as well as the two Germanys and all other European states except Albania &mdash; must formally reaffirm the permanence of the Oder-Neisse line, the present Polish-German border. 
 This would also bind an eventually merged Germany, which the Soviet Union recognises might be born when Nato and the Warsaw Pact give way to a new European security system. 
 President Bush also came away from his talks with Mr Gorbachev in Malta convinced that the Soviet leader recognised that German reunification may turn out to be unavoidable, but that it must come as part of a wider European endeavour to end the post-war division of Europe. 
 The Soviet leader's main concern is to avoid an &bquo;artificial&equo; acceleration of the process. 
 But, as Mr Gorbachev said at his Malta press conference, &bquo;in order to remain realists, we should say that history decides the processes and fates on the European continent, and also the fates of those two &lsqb;German&rsqb; states.&equo; 
 Mr Gorbachev first called for a Helsinki 2 summit next year in Rome last week. 
 He envisaged a &bquo;commonwealth of sovereign democratic states&equo; to give substance to his concept of a common European home. 
 President Franois Mitterrand voiced strong support for the idea after his meeting with President Gorbachev in Kiev on Wednesday. 
 President Bush has agreed that the conventional arms treaty should be signed at summit level, and the Americans know that this means in practice that Mr Gorbachev will have his Helsinki 2. 
 Although only the 23 Nato and Warsaw Pact countries are directly involved in the arms negotiations, the treaty will come under the umbrella of all Helsinki Declaration countries. 
 Nato and Warsaw Pact foreign ministers are expected to meet in Vienna in March to review progress of the conventional arms negotiations. 
 The two Germanys do not need foreign approval before moving towards confederation, the head of Chancellor Kohl's Christian Democrat party, Mr Volker Ruehe, said in an interview published today. 
 Temple raises bid for SeaCo to &dollar;1.036bn 
 EC leaders give spur to single market reforms. 
 By Larry Elliott Economics Correspondent 
 LEADERS of the 12 European Community nations yesterday added impetus to progress towards a single market in 1992, while admitting that several important issues remained to be solved. 
 Although much of the attention at the summit was inevitably focused on the changes in Eastern Europe and the drive towards monetary union, the starting point for the talks, particularly from the British delegation's viewpoint, was the need to speed up the 1992 reforms. 
 The troubled programme has been bedevilled by the tardiness of some countries in implementing the 278 proposals required to remove all internal frontiers to business, and Mrs Thatcher found herself in the slightly unusual position of being praised by Mr Jacques Delors, the president of the European Commission, for being in the vanguard of the reform process. 
 Britain has already implemented 60 per cent of the required changes, sharing with Denmark the best record among the 12, and the Prime Minister put pressure on her EC partners to move faster. 
 The West German Chancellor, Dr Helmut Kohl, indicated that he was prepared to make concessions on his country's merger and anti-cartel controls, one of a number of key obstacles to meeting the January 1, 1993 deadline for the single market. 
 There is now hope that the meeting, later this month, of ministers responsible for the creation of the single market will be able to finalise the discussions on competition policy. 
 The 12 also chipped away at one of the other stumbling blocks, the need to harmonise tax laws across the Community. 
 It appeared from yesterday's talks that there was general agreement on a VAT system, based on the principle of &bquo;the exporter pays&equo;, although the vexed subjects of VAT rates and Custom duties remained unresolved. 
 There also appeared to be less dissension on state aid and subsidies, a subject given added poignancy by the recent revelations about the UK Government's &bquo;sweeteners&equo; to British Aerospace at the time of the takeover of Rover. 
 Mrs Thatcher's call for a &bquo;level playing field&equo; was found &bquo;somewhat ironic&equo; by other delegations, in the light of the domestic row the sale caused. 
 The agreement on the liberalisation of air travel earlier this week was also seen as a promising step towards 1992, as was the compromise deal on telecommunications reached on Thursday. 
 President Mitterrand emphasised that improvements to the European infrastructure and the transport network had not yet gone far enough, a view echoed by Mrs Thatcher. 
 Research and development and financial services are two further areas where progress is still slow. 
 Although the 1992 reforms are intended to create a single market for labour, as well as goods and services, both the French and West German delegations expressed doubts about the need to control an influx of immigrants. 
 Rebel troops end siege of Manila area. 
 By Sheila Coronel in Manila 
 ABOUT 400 rebel soldiers returned to their barracks yesterday morning, ending the siege of Makati after they had occupied the capital's affluent business district for six days. 
 The mutineers, all members of an elite scout-ranger regiment, marched to a nearby army camp, defiantly saying that they did not surrender to the government. 
 &bquo;We have won some victories,&equo; said Capitain Danilo Lucas, a West Point graduate who took part in the rebellion. 
 &bquo;We are not surrendering, we are voluntarily going back to barracks.&equo; 
 In the central Philippine city of Cebu, meanwhile, negotiations with the 200 army rebels who seized an air force base are at a stalemate. 
 The air force general leading the mutineers refused to give up control of the base even as the seige of Makati ended. 
 As the military mutiny dragged on for the sixth day, President Corazon Aquino asked Filipinos to &bquo;join hands and consolidate our resources to rebuild what we have destroyed&equo;. 
 Military officers said more disruptions by mutinous soldiers were still possible. 
 &bquo;I can not guarantee that there will be no more coup attempts,&equo; said the armed forces spokesman, Brigadier-General Oscar Florendo. 
 During a meeting yesterday, Mrs Aquino told her cabinet &bquo;to take a long, hard look at ourselves in order to see what it is we did wrong and what else needs to be done so we can all benefit from this tragic experience in our lives&equo;. 
 She is expected to implement measures to address the popular grievances that have helped to fuel the mutiny. 
 In the past month, Mrs Aquino's popularity has declined, and there was growing disenchantment with her government's ability to provide adequate transport and power, and to contain corruption. 
 Government officials say that state of emergency declared by Mrs Aquino on Wednesday should make it easier for the government to control prices and improve transport and other services. 
 The decree allows the government to take over public utilities and businesses. 
 A cabinet reshuffle is expected to follow. 
 Replacing cabinet secretaries who are popularly perceived as ineffective was &bquo;part of the stocktaking that has to be done&equo;, the press Secretary, Mr Adolfo Azcuna, said. 
 At the same time, Mrs Aquino is mobilising popular support for her beleaguered government. 
 In an emotional television appeal yesterday, she called on Filipinos to bring their families to a mass today at a religious shrine on a main motorway in suburban Manila. 
 The spot marks the place where where hundreds and thousands gathered in February 1986 for a popular uprising that overthrew the late President Ferdinand Marcos, and made Mrs Aquino the President. 
 Cardinal Jaime Sin, the influential Archbishop of Manila, who called on Filipinos to support the uprising against Marcos, joined Mrs Aquino's appeal. 
 &bquo;The future of the nation is in your hands,&equo; he said in a radio broadcast. 
 The rebels left Makati after negotiations with military officers and marched back to their barracks with rifles, bazookas, and machine-guns, chanting: &bquo;No surrender, the fight goes on.&equo; 
 Brigadier-General Arturo Enrile, the government negotiator, said the mutineers had initially demanded Mrs Aquino's resignation, but eventually &bquo;reason prevailed over whatever political or ideoligical convictions they had.&equo; 
 Gen Enrile went on: &bquo;I told them they would be treated fairly, justly and humanely but they must be man enough to take the consequences of their actions.&equo; 
 At the camp, the rebel troops were welcomed with a banner that read: &bquo;Welcome home.&equo; 
 They shook hands and embraced government soldiers. 
 &bquo;We will not surrender even if it takes forever,&equo; said Corporal Roy Bantung. 
 &bquo;The government must change. 
 The president must change her policies.&equo; 
 Syrians move in to quell fighting. 
 By Agencies in Beirut 
 SYRIAN troops opened fire in Muslim West Beirut yesterday to enforce a ceasefire after more than 24 hours of fighting between rival Shi'ite groups. 
 Syrians moved into at least five neighbourhoods where the Syrian-backed Amal militia and the pro-Iranian Hezbollah have been fighting since noon on Thursday. 
 Twelve people are thought to have been killed and 20 wounded since Thursday, including two militiamen killed by Syrian troops yesterday. 
 Police said the dead included four children less than eight years old shot by snipers in their homes overnight. 
 Hassan Hamdan, aged seven, was shot in the head by a sniper when he switched on the light at his bedroom in Mossaitbeh, a poor residential district controlled by Amal. 
 Syrian troops are believed to have rounded up many militiamen in the Bourj Abou Haidar area, where the fiercest fighting erupted. 
 Residents began to leave their bomb shelters as the Syrian presence quelled fighting. 
 One, Wisal Wehbeh, said: &bquo;I will never feel safe until militias are disbanded for good because the minute the Syrians go away, the militiamen come back.&equo; 
 Aminah Mu'asher, who lives in Bourj Abou Haidar, said: &bquo;I heard a militiaman shout Allah-o-Akbar (God is great) when he was shot&hellip; 
 His blood is still on the pavement. 
 &bquo;We're living in hell. 
 This fighting has no meaning. 
 It only brings more destruction. 
 &bquo;Brothers are killing each other. 
 People have no logic or human values left.&equo; 
 The fighting dealt another blow to the government of President Elias Hrawi, striving to impose his authority on General Michel Aoun, the Christian leader, who opposes Syria's presence in Lebanon. 
 Gen Aoun has rejected the Arab League-brokered peace accord under which Mr Hrawi was elected last month. 
 The government, in an effort to tighten the grip on Gen Aoun, dismissed Lebanon's ambassador to the US, Mr Abdallah Bouhabib, who has been supporting the general's policies for more than 15 months. 
 A government statement said a replacement for Mr Bouhabib will be named soon. 
 Syria has reinforced its troops facing the Christian enclave where Gen Aoun is entrenched, but has said it plans no immediate attack. 
 The Syrian Information Minister, Mr Mohammed Salman, said: &bquo;The only reason Syria has so far discounted the military option to end Gen Aoun's rebellion is its desire to avert huge losses among civilians in the eastern sector of Beirut. 
 &bquo;The Syrian forces could, if they wanted, speedily resolve the problem of Gen Aoun in Lebanon through military means, but the Syrian leadership is fully convinced there will be no need to resort to this as Gen Aoun's removal is a matter of time and will take place quickly through political means.&equo;. 
 The three foreign ministers of the Arab League committee on Lebanon are to visit Damascus today at the start of a new drive to end the crisis caused by Gen Aoun's defiance. 
 They are also due to visit Iraq, France and the Vatican. 
 France ends aid to Comoros. 
 France has decided to cut off aid to the Comoros Islands until the French mercenary, Mr Bob Denard, and his men, who seized control 10 days ago, leave the archipelago, government sources said yesterday. 
 France is the Comoros's chief funder. 
 The second largest backer, South Africa, said on Monday it was suspending aid and demanded the withdrawal of mercenaries. 
 -Reuter. 
 Arabs drop UN vote. 
 The Arab group at the UN decided yesterday not to press for a vote on upgrading the PLO's UN status after the General Assembly President, Mr Joseph Garba of Nigeria, urged the sponsors to drop their resolution. 
 -Reuter. 
 Contras continue. 
 The US said yesterday the contras should not disband this week, as required by a regional peace agreement, because Nicaragua had not fulfilled conditions of the pact. 
 &bquo;Non-lethal&equo; assistance will continue until February. 
 -AP. 
 Somali offensive. 
 Somali rebels said last night they had captured the country's second-largest city after &bquo;an all-out offensive&equo; that prompted many government troops to defect to their side. 
 -AP. 
 Lenin under attack. 
 Polish protesters hurled paint and petrol on a monument to Lenin in Krakow and set it on fire yesterday before clashing with police, who used force to break up the second anti-Soviet disturbance in a week. 
 -AP. 
 Bogota truck bomb. 
 A truck bomb exploded yesterday in Bogota, hour, killing and injuring hundreds of people, destroying stores and damaging the federal police headquarters. 
 Police blame the cocaine cartels. 
 -AP. 
 Cuban war dead. 
 Cuba said that more than 2,000 of its soldiers were killed while fighting abroad over the last three decades, nearly all of them in Angola. 
 -Reuter. 
 PAGE 
 Thatcher refuses to budge on unity. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 BRITAIN yesterday took comfort from reports of an alleged overnight breach between the West German Chancellor, Dr Helmut Kohl, and the French on the need to set a date for a Community monetary union conference. 
 Before she left for Strasbourg, Mrs Thatcher refused to budge in her hostility to the EC Social Charter and the Delors plan for economic and monetary union. 
 Senior ministers last night emphasised that the British position had remained unchanged since the Madrid summit, where they had stressed that adequate preparation had to be made long before stages II and III of the Delors plan could be settled. 
 They took comfort from Dr Kohl's apparent embrace of the need for more detailed discussion of the Delors proposals and more powers for the European Parliament and restated their belief that a conference on economic and monetary union should not be held hastily. 
 The ministers interpreted Dr Kohl's statement as a move towards their position. 
 The Prime Minister gave no hint during her performance in the Commons yesterday that her language at Strasbourg will be any less caustic than the manner she has adopted at recent Commonwealth summits. 
 She said she believed the adoption of the Social Charter would &bquo;cause a great increase in unemployment not only in this country but in others as well, and would probably end in Fortress Europe&equo;. 
 Despite warnings, Mrs Thatcher stressed her leadership role in Europe, saying that it was Britain which had put up an alternative scheme to the Delors plan and had taken the initiative over the idea of associate EC status for East Germany. 
 These would be considered alongside the Delors plan, would go beyond its stage I, and would not require any central bank or common currency, but would result in more consistent monetary policies, Mrs Thatcher insisted. 
 The Labour front bench exploited the recent disclosures over hidden subsidies to sweeten the sale of the Rover Group, telling Mrs Thatcher that she went to Strasbourg with a tarnished reputation. 
 But her more confident mood was sustained by an intervention during the House of Commons prime ministers' question time by the former Labour cabinet minister, Mr Peter Shore. 
 An unreconstructed anti-Marketeer, he punctured Labour's new pro-European image by describing the Kohl move as a &bquo;welcome respite from the headlong rush into European union&equo;. 
 To loud Conservative cheers, he demanded a serious study of the constitutional and economic consequences of monetary union, adding that it should not be a study confined to European central bank governors. 
 This is a copy of Countryd Top copy sent to OBITS Country Diary for Saturday December 9th Machynlleth: For me a frequent delight in many years of hill-walking in Wales has been to come upon that lively, eye-catching bird the wheatear which so loves to play hide and seek among the rocks. 
 But I have seldom got very close to these quick, nervous birds. 
 From a distance I have managed to see something of their spectacular courtship frolics that take place both on the ground and in the air and I have listened to their songs which, though not rich in melody, seem just right for a world of cliffs and screes. 
 But with such a wide-awake bird as the wheatear you will discover very little else about its private life unless you really get down to the job. 
 And 40 years ago that is just what Peter Conder, soon to be assisted by his wife, Pat, set out to do. 
 He has been gathering his facts on and off ever since and now they are available to us all in his book The Wheatear, a truly classic study of every aspect of the wheatear's lifestyle. 
 It seems fair to claim this attractive book as a product of Wales because although the author lives in Eastern England and has observed wheatears in many far-flung places, the foundation studies were made on the Pembrokeshire island of Skokholm and Peter Conder has often returned there to keep fresh the memory of his pioneering researches. 
 Thorough in all its countless details his book is well written and easy to read, its charm further enhanced by many true to life sketches made in the field by John Busby. 
 The publisher is Christopher Helm, the price &pound;19.95. 
 PAGE 
 Acid house man jailed. 
 Leslie Thomas, a leader of a gang that organised acid house parties in London, was jailed at the Old Bailey yesterday for five years and three months after being convicted in his absence of plotting to permit premises to be used for the supply of drugs. 
 Thomas, aged 27, who fled to Tenerife before his trial ended, was rearrested on his return to England last month. 
 Andrew Culf Three ambulance crews from Fulham dealt with emergencies yesterday after the 999 calls were put through to them. 
 But after taking their patients to hospital, the six ambulancemen involved were all suspended without pay for refusing to work normally. 
 They joined the rest of their colleagues &mdash; most of whom had already been suspended &mdash; in the rest room of Europe's largest ambulance station, where they were watching a video of A Bridge Too Far. 
 The choice of film seemed appropriate on the day the simmering dispute boiled over with growing frustration and bitterness among the staff, many of whom attended the Clapham train disaster and are veterans of dealing with the aftermath of IRA bomb blasts. 
 Outside the station a banner fluttered in the wind carrying the plaintiff message: &bquo;We are not on strike&equo;. 
 Inside, the crews expressed their willingness to answer emergency calls and, despite being suspended, said they had no intention of going home. 
 Graphic evidence of their commitment to the 999 service came as three separate emergency calls were received at Fulham and crews responded to two road accidents and a medical collapse. 
 Mr Alan Thomas, who has been in the service for 28 years, took a motor-cyclist with leg injuries to Charing Cross Hospital after an accident in Kensington. 
 &bquo;The call came through in the normal way and we dealt with it as we normally would,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Several minutes after we returned, my station officer called me in to his office and warned me that as I was not working by London Ambulance Service guidelines I would be stood down without pay.&equo; 
 He said: &bquo;They seemed to be using us as a last resort. 
 It seems they could not find anyone else to answer the call, so they came to us.&equo; 
 Mr Charles Sawyer, an ambulanceman for five years, was also suspended on his return from taking an elderly woman to hospital following a crash in Chelsea. 
 &bquo;I told them I was prepared to answer emergencies for no pay and I'm staying on until the end of my shift. 
 We are willing to work,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Bob White, acting shop steward, said there was no animosity towards the police or St John Ambulance, who were handling calls. 
 &bquo;We have even offered to go out with the police in their cars to help.&equo; 
 There would be no antagonism towards troops, who would simply be acting under orders. 
 He said the offer of 6.5 per cent was insulting and denounced management's inclusion of London weighting to artifically boost the offer to 9.3 per cent in the capital. 
 The union simply wanted arbitration. 
 Mrs Elaine Wake said her 18-year-old brother takes home &pound;205 a week working in a supermarket. 
 After five years service, she clears &pound;515 a month. 
 &bquo;Will Kenneth Clarke tell my five-year-old daughter why she will not get a bike or a doll's house for Christmas? 
 Let us hope that it is Mr Clarke who needs an ambulance that has been stood down.&equo; 
 The scale of the opposition to the health secretary became clear as the staff crowded round the lunchtime television news. 
 As Mr Clarke was interviewed, his answers were greeted with cries of outrage. 
 One ambulanceman summed up the mood as he threw his hands up in disgust and muttered: &bquo;Absolute rubbish. 
 It is all just so frustrating.&equo; 
 PAGE 
 . 
 The Government would find it hard to design a student loan system more socially unjust and more likely to deter potential students from less privileged backgrounds, Sir John Kingman, vice-chancellor of Bristol University, said yesterday. 
 It was, however, misguided to object to loans on principle and MPs should amend the bill to devise a more equitable system which applied to part-time students, too. 
 &bquo;A student whose education enables him later in life to earn a higher income should return some of that income.&equo; 
 Higher education could not rely on the taxpayer as its only source of funds, he told the annual meeting of the university's court of governors. 
 If students were not to share the cost of tuition fees as well, the system would continue to transfer resources from the average taxpayer to the predominantly middle-class student body. 
 &bquo;For most of the last 1,000 years, the universities have been an engine of social mobility; they are now, thanks to the funding system, a means to ensuring that the graduate class is hereditary,&equo; Sir John said. 
 PAGE 
 LIBEL DAMAGES FOR MP'S WIDOW An elderly London widow agreed at the High Court today to accept substantial undislosed damages for a Sunday Times article alleging her twin children were the result of an affair with the father of Jacqueline Kennedy-Onassis. 
 The front page article published on May 21 this year claimed that Mrs Ann Plugge's children Gale and Greville were not fathered by her husband, Captain Leonard Plugge, who was Conservative MP for Chatham, but by Jack Bouvier. 
 Mr Andrew Stephenson, solicitor for Mrs Plugge, who lives in Dovehouse Street, Chelsea, told Mr Justice Brooke sitting in London, that the newspaper, and the writer of the story, Rosemary Collins, now accepted that was not true. 
 Mr Alastair Brett, for the journalist and Times Newspapers Limited, said: &bquo;The defendants, having made extensive inquiries into the allegation, are quite satisfied that Mr Bouvier was not the father of the plaintiff's twins and very much regret that the allegation was ever published. 
 &bquo;Through me the defendants tender their sincere apologies to the plaintiff for the distress she was caused by the publication of the article.&equo; 
 The article, headed &bquo;Tragic Secrets of Jackie's British Brother and Sister&equo;, said that in 1972 Gale, 27, was stabbed and buried alive in Trinidad by henchman of the late Michael X a former black power leader and racketeer in London. 
 The man was hanged for her killing. 
 A few months later Greville was killed in a car crash in Morocco. 
 Captain Plugge died in 1981. 
 The defendants also agreed to pay costs incurred by Mrs Plugge who is in her late 70's. end ab PAGE 
 5m claimants to be worse off under poll tax, says Meacher. 
 MORE than five million adults receiving income support will lose out when the poll tax is introduced in England next April, Labour's social security spokesman, Mr Michael Meacher, claimed yesterday, writes Alan Travis. 
 He argued at a Westminster press conference that in only 35 out of 403 local authority areas would any claimants gain or break even, despite Mrs Thatcher's pledge in July 1987 that they would not be adversely affected. 
 Claimants on income support are now required to pay a 20 per cent contribution to rates or poll tax bills. 
 But the Government has provided compensation allowances in income support payments equal to the average poll tax bill in each council area. 
 Mr Meacher claimed yesterday that next April the value of those allowances would not be enough to cover even the most conservative forecasts of average poll tax payments. 
 On the Government's safety-netted forecast of &pound;272 a head in England, the compensation amount is 75p a week short of the amount a couple are likely to pay in poll tax. 
 However, Mr Meacher's figures were challenged by the Department of Social Security, which claimed the compensation amount for couples this year had been 95p a week more than Labour's estimate. 
 Mr Meacher in turn claimed that this was only notional and had already been clawed back. 
 His claim came as local authorities lodged final returns for poll tax registration. 
 These are expected to show that four-fifths of councils in England have achieved more than 95 per cent registration, compared with the official population figures for their area. 
 But some councils have returned forms claiming 110 per cent registration, indicating how out of date are some Office of Population Censuses and Surveys estimates of population. 
 Labour's poll tax spokesman, Mr David Blunkett, last night said this provided yet another reason to doubt the Government's projection of poll tax bills. 
 New backbench revolts simmer for Thatcher. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 MRS THATCHER faces a series of Conservative backbench challenges to her legislative programme. 
 Although not all the Tory dissidents now discussing tactics over individual bills were among the 60 who withheld their votes from her last Tuesday, the arithmetic of the leadership election does raise the question of whether she can rely on her Commons majority in the coming battles. 
 The party's vice-chairman, Mr Peter Morrison, betrayed the Tories' nerves: &bquo;It would have been extremely surprising if, after 15 years as party leader and over 10 years as prime minister, there had not been some dissenting voices. 
 Tough policies and resolute leadership always create enemies.&equo; 
 In a speech last night in Birmingham, he noted that, in the end, &bquo;dissenting voices were remarkably few and remarkably quiet&hellip; 
 Now we must turn away from conflict. 
 There are so many important tasks ahead &mdash; tasks to be tackled with unity and resolve.&equo; 
 Such putative loyalty will be tested by this session's bills, particularly broadcasting, legal reform and the NHS shake-up. 
 Mr Nicholas Winterton, MP for Macclesfield, has served notice he intends not to support the NHS bill at its second reading on Monday night. 
 He will find support on the Conservative benches, as members of the Commons Social Services Select Committee seek to refer the bill to a standing committee. 
 This would allow the select committee, under its chairman, Mr Frank Field, to take evidence from all interested parties, including the British Medical Association, before line-by-line scrutiny of the bill begins. 
 On the broadcasting bill, 58 Tory MPs have signed two early day motions criticising the thrust of the Government's legislation. 
 The first, initiated by a former minister, Sir Geoffrey Pattie, calls for tendering to allow the size of the bid and the programming quality to be judged in tandem when awarding contracts. 
 The second is put down by a another sacked minister, Mr George Walden, who opposes the bill in principle. 
 He also voices concern about loss of quality once the bill is put into practice. 
 A third group of backbenchers is concerned at cross-media ownership in the new channels under the bill. 
 The combination should result in a rebellion at the second reading on Monday week. 
 The Government's legal reforms are likely to produce a crop of backbench critics, with the Bar Council pressing to amend solicitors' new rights to handle court cases. 
 The contingent of barristers on the Tory benches will lobby to keep &bquo;a strong and independent&equo; Bar. 
 Ministers still face difficulties over last year's programme. 
 Sir Rhodes Boyson, MP for Brent South, next Thursday leads a delegation to the party chairman, Mr Kenneth Baker, demanding further action on the poll tax. 
 He and others fear that &bquo;safety net&equo; losses to be suffered by some areas will cost them key metropolitan councils in next May's elections. 
 Mr David Wilshire, MP for Spelthorne, last year a staunch supporter on the Commons committee examining the tax, is now so alarmed at how it works that this week he asked ministers to scrap the &bquo;monstrously unfair&equo; community charge. 
 &bquo;Unanswered questions&equo; remain over Rover deal. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 LABOUR'S Trade and Industry spokesman, Mr Gordon Brown, yesterday continued to press the Government over the alleged deception surrounding the Rover Group sale. 
 He said 18 parliamentary questions he had put down remained unanswered, after the Prime Minister claimed that all the financial details of the car company's sale to British Aerospace had been released. 
 The questions, to the Trade and Industry Secretary, Mr Nicholas Ridley, are designed to establish the full cost to the taxpayer of the Rover deal. 
 They centre on a request for details of &bquo;a private side-letter&equo; alongside the final funding agreement from Lord Young, the then Trade and Industry Secretary, to British Aerospace. 
 The letter allegedly offered additional guarantees to BAe beyond any final contract. 
 The demands for further information follow disclosures that Lord Young wrote to BAe asking it to choose how to hide the &pound;38 million &bquo;sweeteners&equo; involved in the sale from Parliament and the European Commission. 
 Mr Brown's requests suggest there were further hidden subsidies which have yet to be disclosed officially. 
 &bquo;I want to see the correspondence between the European Commission and the Government over subsidies and over guarantees about the future of Rover's activities and jobs,&equo; Mr Brown said. 
 &bquo;I want to know what discussions took place during the Rover negotiations on other civil and military issues; on launch aid for the Airbus; and on the general tax affairs of British Aerospace. 
 &bquo;I want to know what tax concessions the Government believed they had made to British Aerospace. 
 &bquo;These answers are required so that the full cost of the Rover deal can be assessed,&equo; Mr Brown said yesterday. 
 Labour's Trade and Industry spokesman has put down questions about whether, as part of the final contract, BAe's advisor's fees were paid from public funds. 
 He also would like all correspondence about the future of the Government's &bquo;golden share&equo; in Rover to be published. 
 FATHER JAILED FOR BREAKING BABY'S BONES A father who broke his baby son's bones in six places was jailed for four years today. 
 Nottingham Crown Court was told that by the age of nine weeks, the child had fractures to both collar bones, both legs and an arm as well as a broken skull. 
 Mr Peter Joyce, prosecuting, said the offences came to light when the baby, who was not named in court, was taken to a health centre for treatment to an elbow injury inflicted by his father five days earlier. 
 Factory worker Robert Brooks, 33, of Pleasant Row, Hyson Green, Nottingham, admitted six charges of causing grievous bodily harm to his son and one charge of child cruelty. 
 The prosecution accepted a not guilty plea by the baby's mother, Sharon Peel, 28. 
 Mr Joyce said the child, now 17 months old, was in care and very fit and healthy. 
 Defending, Mr Noel Philo, said Brooks loved his son and did not mean to harm him, but he was an inadequate father who could not cope. 
 Judge Thomas Heald said he took into account the family's cramped living conditions and financial difficulties. 
 end tp PAGE 
 MAN LEAVES CAT AND &pound;43,000 TO CHARITY Sooty the black cat has brought a &pound;43,000 windfall to a charity. 
 Her owner, an anonymous Suffolk man, left the cash in his will to the National Society for Epilepsy on condition it gave Sooty a home. 
 Now the 16-year-old cat is settling in at the society's headquarters at Chalfont St Peter, Buckinghamshire. 
 &bquo;Poor Sooty was very unsociable when she was first brought here,&equo; said house manager Jean Coleman. 
 &bquo;She went under a desk and didn't come out for four days. 
 But she is settling in much better now and looking forward to the best Christmas dinner money can buy.&equo; 
 end nh PAGE 
 News in brief: Havel may get presidency. 
 Mr Vaclav Havel, the Czechoslovak opposition leader, and the still ruling Communist Party were immersed in crisis talks on the shape of a new coalition government as the prospect of Mr Havel becoming the next president appeared to strengthen. 
 Page 24. 
 Kidney &bquo;theft&equo;. 
 Mr Ahmet Koc, aged 34, a Turkish peasant farmer, described to the General Medical Council's professional conduct committee how a Harley Street doctor had allegedly, under the pretext of giving him a blood test, stolen his kidney to be used in a transplant. 
 Page 2. 
 Cocaine seizures rise. 
 Cocaine seizures by Customs have risen by 50 per cent this year, the Home Office minister, Mr David Mellor, told the Commons during a debate on the misuse of drugs. 
 Page 6. 
 Aquino rallies support. 
 President Corazon Aquino of the Philippines lashed out at her enemies and mobilised popular support behind her beleaguered government during a rally attended by thousands of Filipinos. 
 Page 10. 
 Damages for maid. 
 A maid who was whipped and beaten by two Arab princesses for whom she worked was awarded &pound;300,000 damages in the High Court. 
 Page 4. 
 Microwave health alert. 
 Microwave cooking creates potentially dangerous substances in baby milk which may damage the brain, liver and kidneys, doctors said. 
 Page 24. 
 Leonard retains title. 
 Sugar Ray Leonard won his world middle-weight title fight with Roberto Duran. 
 Page 19. 
 Grants victory. 
 An historic legal decision will give tens of thousands of European students who could not afford British college fees the right to apply for discretionary grants. 
 Page 4. 
 2.2m queue for shares. 
 Nearly &pound;5 billion has been put up by 2.2 million private investors chasing water shares, it was confirmed, making the sale one of the most popular in the Government's privatisation programme. 
 Page 11. 
 Aids vaccine hope. 
 A step towards producing an Aids vaccine was announced by researchers. 
 Page 3 
 PAGE 
 Poor public response prompts BT to cut number of cheap-rate days. 
 THE number of cheap-rate days for telephone users is to be cut from eight to five next year because not enough people took advantage of it, British Telecom announced yesterday. 
 A company spokesman said: &bquo;We introduced cheap rates to stimulate telephone traffic. 
 But our experience has shown the public didn't take advantage of the facility except over the Christmas and New Year period.&equo; 
 From next year, all dialled local and national calls, and most direct-dialled international calls will be charged only at cheap rates on Christmas Day, Boxing Day and New Year's Day. 
 Previously, in England and Wales, concessionary days also included Good Friday, Easter Monday, May Day Holiday, Spring Bank Holiday and Summer Bank Holiday. 
 In Scotland they included Christmas Eve, December 27, December 28, December 29 and January 2; and in Northern Ireland, Easter Monday, Easter Tuesday, May Day Holiday, July 12, and July 13. 
 When one of the three dates falls on a weekend when cheap-rate calls apply, the concession will be transferred to another day. 
 But next year, none of the concessionary days is on a weekend. 
 The move will not affect existing weekend rates or the weekday 1pm and 6pm cheaper rate periods. 
 Father jailed for injuring child. 
 A father who broke his nine-week-old son's bones in six places, was jailed for four years at Nottingham Crown Court yesterday. 
 Robert Brooks, a factory worker, fractured his son's collar bones, legs and an arm, and broke his skull. 
 The child, now 17 months old, is in care. 
 Athlete to be freed. 
 Stephen Pinsent, a former weightlifting champion who was jailed last month for supplying anabolic steroids, had his three-month sentence reduced to 28 days by the Court of Appeal yesterday. 
 Lost master sold. 
 A painting which hung in Blairgowie Scottish Episcopal Church for 40 years yesterday fetched &pound;825,000 at Christie's in London. 
 The Liberation of St Peter, by Mattia Preti, went to an anonymous buyer. 
 Councillor case dropped. 
 A case against Mr Naren Dave, a Labour councillor in Barnet, north London, who allegedly used threatening behaviour during a visit in June by Mrs Thatcher to her constituency, was dropped yesterday. 
 Party plotter jailed. 
 Leslie Thomas, aged 27, who organised acid house parties in London, was jailed for five years at the Old Bailey yesterday. 
 Thomas, of east London, plotted to permit premises to be used for the supply of drugs. 
 N-dust judgment delay. 
 Judgment was reserved at the High Court in London yesterday on a claim by Mr Christopher Merlin, aged 48, and his wife, Christine, of Broughton-in-Furness, Cumbria, that their former home was contaminated with plutonimum dust from the Sellafield plant. 
 Maxwell boycott. 
 The National Union of Journalists yesterday launched a worldwide campaign to boycott products from Mr Robert Maxwell's Pergamon Press publishing company in Oxford. 
 The union is fighting to reinstate 23 sacked journalists. 
 Crusader who provoked left Saturday People. 
 Andrew Culf. 
 FRANK Field, whose political career stood at the crossroads last night, was first elected to the House of Commons in May 1979. 
 Mr Field, aged 49, has won cross-party admiration at Westminster for his crusading stance on poverty and social inequality. 
 As chairman of the influential social services select committee, he has regularly won headlines for the Labour Party on welfare issues. 
 He is the second casualty of Labour's current round of re-selections. 
 But in the case of the St Helens South MP, Mr Gerry Bermingham, the national executive committee has ordered the ballot to be re-run. 
 The fight in Birkenhead was not the first time that Mr Field had crossed swords with the Labour left. 
 His political career began in 1958, when he joined the Young Conservatives. 
 A year later he switched to Labour, and within six years he had won a seat on Hounslow borough council. 
 His first parliamentary contest was in 1966 when he unsuccessfully fought South Buckinghamshire. 
 In 1979 he won Birkenhead, succeeding Mr Edmund Dell, and at the last general election his majority was 15,372. 
 Before entering Parliament, he was director of the Child Poverty Action Group and the Low Pay Unit. 
 The same interests have dominated his 10 years at Westminster, and it is claimed that he has redistributed more than &pound;60 million from the taxpayer to the poor by challenging the DHSS in test cases. 
 Frank Field: redistributed &pound;60 million to the poor 
 Helping hand of laser man Saturday People. 
 Dennis Barker. 
 DISABLED children throughout the world had cause yesterday to be grateful to a man who has proved that Great British Characters are not extinct. 
 Paul Cook, professor of laser technology at Brunel and inventor of a laser system which detects causes of night blindness and other eye defects, recently formed and became president of the British Science and Technology Trust. 
 The trust organised the first Children of Science Awards, bringing together in London yesterday 150 incapacitated children from Europe, the Soviet Union, the Middle East, and Australia who have been helped by science. 
 Five children received awards at a ceremony at the Soviet Embassy. 
 At first Professor Cook, aged 55, failed to get the Russians interested. 
 But finally President Gorbachev sent two children, one of whom, Yalya Butko, aged eight, got an award. 
 She has had skin grafts since being badly burned in the Siberian train disaster. 
 &bquo;My idea is protection of the environment through science and technology, and it is my aim to have every youngster in the country sign the pledge to become a PEST,&equo; said Cook yesterday. 
 &bquo;We must demonstrate to youngsters that science and technology can in their many ways find the answers and should not always be viewed as the culprit.&equo; 
 Cook left school at 14 to become an apprentice, got involved with radar and electronics during National Service, and graduated from Queen Mary College, London. 
 He is now chairman of his company, Scientifica-Cook, adviser to the Royal National Institute for the Blind, and laser consultant to British Aerospace. 
 Cook has in his garden in Acton, London, a lake full of Japanese fish. 
 Blind and disabled children who flow through his home are encouraged to feel the fish as a tactile experience. 
 His work for these children has opened doors internationally. 
 President Bush has sent presents. 
 &bquo;I feel quite capable of using the miracle of science to forge links of friendship and do a great deal of good throughout the world,&equo; Cook said. 
 Minister warns against &bquo;open frontiers&equo; with EC states 50pc rise in cocaine seizures this year *. 
 By Martin Linton 
 COCAINE seizures by Customs have gone up by 50 per cent this year, Home Office minister Mr David Mellor told the Commons yesterday during a debate on the misuse of drugs. 
 Declaring himself &bquo;deeply troubled&equo; by the rise &mdash; from 264kgs last year to 392kgs so far this year &mdash; he said some people were underestimating the problem because there had not yet been an influx of misusers to drugs clinics. 
 But he warned against drawing false comfort from that. 
 He said the growth in Britain was through the derivative crack, which could easily be made from cocaine and a readily available ingredient, and then smoked. 
 Seizures had risen from 12 in 1987 to 27 last year to 124 this year. 
 He said America bitterly regretted its failure to take action earlier against cocaine, which now has 5-6 million regular users and caused more than 1,000 deaths last year. 
 But he said figures showed that international traffickers were targeting this country as never before, and &bquo;it's simply a question of time&equo; before that fed through to the streets. 
 He said that imports through European Community countries now account for half of cocaine seizures, and &bquo;the practical reality is we cannot afford to have open frontiers with countries like the Netherlands, because the consequence is that drugs in increasing numbers come into our countries.&equo; 
 However, Mr Mellor said that only measures to reduce the demand would stop trafficking. 
 &bquo;However professional the police and Customs are, there will always be a way through.&equo; 
 Labour spokesman Mr Barry Sheerman said it was no good trying to stop the Peruvian peasants who grew the coca by defoliating their forests. 
 Britain should stop giving &bquo;piffling&equo; sums of aid to Latin American countries and help them find alternative crops. 
 He also criticised the Prime Minister for suggesting drug abuse was a &bquo;problem of prosperity&equo;. 
 That was &bquo;a million miles from reality&equo;, he said. 
 Ms Diane Abbott, Labour MP for Hackney North and Stoke Newington, said the inner cities needed a war on drugs &bquo;that enlists and involves the community, not a war that leaves the community feeling that it is under threat&equo;. 
 Three doctors deny removing kidneys for cash, as &bquo;donor&equo; insists he wouldn't sell one &bquo;for the whole of Istanbul&equo; Turk tells of transplant &bquo;theft&equo;. 
 *. 
 By Gareth Parry 
 ATURKISH peasant farmer wept yesterday as he described how a Harley Street doctor had allegedly, under the pretext of giving him a blood test, &bquo;stolen&equo; his kidney to be used in a transplant. 
 Mr Ahmet Koc, aged 34, told the General Medical Council's professional conduct committee in London that after coming to England with the promise of employment last year, he had first been taken to the surgery of Dr Raymond Crockett for what he believed to be a medical examination for a job. 
 Then he said he had been checked into what he thought was an hotel for the blood test, and was given an injection. 
 &bquo;The door opened and I saw Dr Crockett. 
 After that I didn't remember anything. 
 When I awoke, I was without pants and there were lots of tubes and bottles and I had pain&equo;, he said, giving evidence through an interpreter. 
 The committee heard that the &bquo;hotel&equo; was in fact the Wellington Humana Hospital in London. 
 Mr Koc recalled asking Mr Ata Nur Kuntar, one of the Turks who had brought him to Britain, what had happened. 
 &bquo;He said: &bquo;You are sick and you have had your appendix out.&equo; 
 I did not believe it, I said I was healthy and then all of a sudden, this happened. 
 Then I became suspicious of the injection.&equo; 
 Three days later, Mr Koc said he was taken from his room at the hospital to another room where a man was lying in bed watched by his wife and six-month-old baby. 
 The woman offered him chocolates. 
 Mr Kuntar, one of two alleged &bquo;kidney brokers&equo;, came into the room and told him his kidney had been given to this man. 
 &bquo;He said: &bquo;You are going to be given a lot of money and your life is safe.&equo; 
 I started crying. 
 I cried a lot and said: &bquo;How could you do this?&equo; ' said Mr Koc. 
 Three doctors are before the committee charged with professional misconduct for their alleged involvement in removing kidneys from four Turks who were paid for the organs. 
 The doctors, who deny the charge, are Dr Crockett, a Harley Street physician specialising in kidney disease, Mr Michael Joyce, a urologist at Guy's hospital in London, and Mr Michael Bewick, a leading kidney transplant surgeon. 
 Mr Koc told Mr Roger HendersonQC, counsel for the GMC, that the &bquo;broker&equo; brothers Mr Ata Nur and Mr Riza Kuntar had promised him he would be getting a job when he was brought to England. 
 He was examined several times by Dr Crockett in his surgery, but was never told a kidney would be removed. 
 Mr Henderson asked him three times if he had any idea what a kidney was for. 
 Mr Koc replied: &bquo;No. 
 I didn't know what a kidney was, that it would be worth money. 
 They stole one of my kidneys.&equo; 
 Mr Koc said on a visit to Dr Crockett's surgery he saw him hand a cheque to Mr Ata Nur Kuntar. 
 Mr Koc remained in hospital for six days, and was then taken back to the small hotel where he had been staying since his arrival in London. 
 By then his eyes and hands were swelling, he was feeling nauseous and could not lie down at night because of the pain in his back. 
 He said he was not given any medicine, and no doctor saw him. 
 Mr Koc said he was taken to the airport by Mr Ata Nur Kuntar and given a packet containing &pound;2,500, plus an envelope with three &pound;50 notes in it as pocket money. 
 When he got back to Istanbul and changed one of the notes he realised how much he had been given. 
 The money was equal to 8 million Turkish lire. 
 Mr Koc had been earning 50p a day doing winter work on a building site in the Turkish capital before he was taken to London. 
 Later, when he contacted a third brother, Mr Tunc Kuntar, and threatened to complain to the authorities, Tunc said: &bquo;If you do you must be aware of the consequences of that.&equo; 
 Mr Koc contacted a lawyer in Istanbul and they wrote to the Public Prosecutor's office. 
 Tunc was prosecuted and jailed for two years, but he testified that Mr Koc knowingly sold his kidney. 
 Mr Koc said Tunc was given an 18-month suspended sentence for this allegation. 
 Mr Anthony ArlidgeQC, counsel for Dr Crockett, read out an advertisement from a Turkish newspaper in which it was stated that Mr Koc was selling his kidney. 
 The advert, placed in April last year, gave an address and telephone number of an Istanbul bakery where Mr Koc was living. 
 Mr Koc said he had known nothing about the advertisement. 
 Mr Arlidge asked: &bquo;Supposing a man came to the bakery and said, &bquo;Mr Kuc please sell me your kidney&equo;.&equo; 
 Mr Koc said: &bquo;If you gave me the whole of Istanbul I would not do anything like that. 
 I was only making my living by my own strength, now I can't work and I have become disabled.&equo; 
 The hearing continues on Monday. 
 Peasant farmer weeps as he alleges that &bquo;blood test at hotel&equo; led to him becoming an unwilling kidney donor Turk tells of transplant &bquo;theft&equo;. 
 *. 
 By Gareth Parry 
 ATURKISH peasant farmer wept yesterday as he described how a Harley Street doctor had allegedly, under the pretext of giving him a blood test, &bquo;stolen&equo; his kidney to be used in a transplant. 
 Mr Ahmet Koc, aged 34, told the General Medical Council's professional conduct committee in London that after coming to England with the promise of employment last year, he had first been taken to the surgery of Dr Raymond Crockett for what he believed to be a medical examination for a job. 
 Then he said he had been checked into what he thought was an hotel for the blood test, and was given an injection. 
 &bquo;The door opened and I saw Dr Crockett. 
 After that I didn't remember anything. 
 When I awoke, I was without pants and there were lots of tubes and bottles and I had pain&equo;, he said, giving evidence through an interpreter. 
 The committee heard that the &bquo;hotel&equo; was in fact the Wellington Humana Hospital in London. 
 Mr Koc recalled asking Mr Ata Nur Kuntar, one of the Turks who had brought him to Britain, what had happened. 
 &bquo;He said: &bquo;You are sick and you have had your appendix out.&equo; 
 I did not believe it, I said I was healthy and then all of a sudden, this happened. 
 Then I became suspicious of the injection.&equo; 
 Three days later, Mr Koc said he was taken from his room at the hospital to another room where a man was lying in bed watched by his wife and six-month-old baby. 
 The woman offered him chocolates. 
 Mr Kuntar, one of two alleged &bquo;kidney brokers&equo;, came into the room and told him his kidney had been given to this man. 
 &bquo;He said: &bquo;You are going to be given a lot of money and your life is safe.&equo; 
 I started crying. 
 I cried a lot and said: &bquo;How could you do this?&equo; ' said Mr Koc. 
 Three doctors are before the committee charged with professional misconduct for their alleged involvement in removing kidneys from four Turks who were paid for the organs. 
 The doctors, who deny the charge, are Dr Crockett, a Harley Street physician specialising in kidney disease, Mr Michael Joyce, a urologist at Guy's hospital in London, and Mr Michael Bewick, a leading kidney transplant surgeon. 
 Mr Koc told Mr Roger HendersonQC, counsel for the GMC, that the &bquo;broker&equo; brothers Mr Ata Nur and Mr Riza Kuntar had promised him he would be getting a job when he was brought to England. 
 He was examined several times by Dr Crockett in his surgery, but was never told a kidney would be removed. 
 Mr Henderson asked him three times if he had any idea what a kidney was for. 
 Mr Koc replied: &bquo;No. 
 I didn't know what a kidney was, that it would be worth money. 
 They stole one of my kidneys.&equo; 
 Mr Koc said on a visit to Dr Crockett's surgery he saw him hand a cheque to Mr Ata Nur Kuntar. 
 Mr Koc remained in hospital for six days, and was then taken back to the small hotel where he had been staying since his arrival in London. 
 By then his eyes and hands were swelling, he was feeling nauseous and could not lie down at night because of the pain in his back. 
 He said he was not given any medicine, and no doctor saw him. 
 Mr Koc said he was taken to the airport by Mr Ata Nur Kuntar and given a packet containing &pound;2,500, plus an envelope with three &pound;50 notes in it as pocket money. 
 When he got back to Istanbul and changed one of the notes he realised how much he had been given. 
 The money was equal to 8 million Turkish lire. 
 Mr Koc had been earning 50p a day doing winter work on a building site in the Turkish capital before he was taken to London. 
 Later, when he contacted a third brother, Mr Tunc Kuntar, and threatened to complain to the authorities, Mr Kuntar said: &bquo;If you do you must be aware of the consequences of that.&equo; 
 Mr Koc contacted a lawyer in Istanbul and they wrote to the Public Prosecutor's office. 
 Mr Tunc Kuntar was prosecuted and jailed for two years, but he testified that Mr Koc knowingly sold his kidney. 
 Mr Koc said Mr Kuntar was given an 18-month suspended sentence for this allegation. 
 Mr Anthony ArlidgeQC, counsel for Dr Crockett, read out an advertisement from a Turkish newspaper in which it was stated that Mr Koc was selling his kidney. 
 The advert, placed in April last year, gave an address and telephone number of an Istanbul bakery where Mr Koc was living. 
 Mr Koc said he had known nothing about the advertisement. 
 Mr Arlidge asked: &bquo;Supposing a man came to the bakery and said, &bquo;Mr Kuc please sell me your kidney&equo;.&equo; 
 Mr Koc said: &bquo;If you gave me the whole of Istanbul I would not do anything like that. 
 I was only making my living by my own strength, now I can't work and I have become disabled.&equo; 
 The hearing continues on Monday. 
 Party congress proposes reformist as new leader Ex-leaders held in East German purge. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 ASERIES of arrests of former leaders preceded yesterday's opening of an emergency congress in East Berlin &mdash; at which a reformist, Mr Gregor Gysi, was proposed as party chairman late last night. 
 Mr Erich Honecker, aged 77, the disgraced former party chief, is among six ex-politburo members now under investigation for abuse of office, corruption and personal enrichment. 
 Four were arrested on the orders of the chief public prosecutor, but Mr Honecker was let off because of ill health. 
 He was described as neither fit for questioning nor detention, but remains under house arrest. 
 Mr Hermann Axen, the former politburo member responsible for foreign policy, is in Moscow for an eye operation and so avoided arrest. 
 Mr Willi Stoph, the previous prime minister; General Erich Mielke, former head of the Stasi secret police; and two less prominent figures, Mr Gunther Kleiber and Mr Werner Krolikowski, completed the list of arrests. 
 The Communist SED which, in round-table talks with opposition groups, has agreed to hold the first free elections in East Germany since 1946 &mdash; planned for next May &mdash; is seriously threatened by a split or even dissolution. 
 Formal election of Mr Gysi, a 41-year-old lawyer, and a 100-member party board is expected today. 
 Mr Gysi has spoken out for sweeping political and economic reforms and has acted as lawyer for the opposition New Forum. 
 Delegates at the congress, in East Berlin's Dynamo sports hall, last night called for a &bquo;grassroots renewal&equo; and said they were bitter and disappointed over the &bquo;criminal acts&equo; of their former leaders. 
 One of the 2,700 delegates said 80 per cent of his factory colleagues had left the SED.in recent weeks. 
 &bquo;The number of members has, over the last few days and weeks, dropped more dramatically than a barometer before an impending typhoon.&equo; 
 Amid predictions that the emergency meeting could be the SED's last party congress, the Communists have accepted &bquo;full responsibility for the deepest crisis in the history of the GDR&equo;. 
 They want to give the party a new name and place the emphasis on &bquo;international socialist traditions,&equo; including pacifism and social democracy. 
 It is expected that the congress, organised by the party's interim leadership after the politburo and central committee resigned last Sunday, will immediately elect a new leader and central committee. 
 The politburo could well be abolished. 
 Mr Wolfgang Berghofer, the 46-year-old mayor of Dresden who had been tipped to become the new party chief, said yesterday that he and a renewed party stood for a break with Stalinism and instead wanted socialism with a human face. 
 By having to concede free elections at the round-table talks on Thursday night, the Communists have, in effect, accepted they will in future be only one partner in a pluralist political system. 
 If the party splits into a Communist and Social Democrat wing, it would risk extinction, with the already founded Social Democratic Party likely to swallow up social democrat-inclined members. 
 In the last free elections in what is now East Germany, in 1946, the SED, after its forced alliance with the SPD, won on average 45 per cent of the vote. 
 Today the share is likely to stand below 20 per cent. 
 The eleven-hour round-table talks, which ended early yesterday, were termed a remarkable success by churches, opposition groups and the official parties. 
 Apart from recommending free elections, the discussion group also demanded that the secret police should be dissolved. 
 The next round-table meeting has been set for December 18. 
 Army joins the people, page 7 
 Muslims may step up action on Rushdie Joanna Coles finds Islamic community still raging at The Satanic Verses. 
 BRITISH Muslims are being encouraged to renew their battle against the author Mr Salman Rushdie and to step up their efforts to achieve a ban on his novel, The Satanic Verses. 
 The appeal, to be made by the Umalah (Muslim clergy) next Friday in Britain's 1,000 mosques, comes after a period of relative quiet among campaigners and is being interpreted as a shift towards Mr Rushdie's more vigorous opponents, including Dr Kalim Siddiqui. 
 Dr Siddiqui caused a furore in Manchester two months ago when he asked a meeting of Muslim activists to raise their hands in agreement with the death sentence imposed on Mr Rushdie by the late Ayatollah Khomeini. 
 His speech, tapes of which the BBC was forced to surrender, is being considered by the Director of Public Prosecutions. 
 A decision is expected shortly on whether Dr Siddiqui will be prosecuted for incitement to murder. 
 But according to the Association of Sunni Muslims, Friday's Day of Solidarity will also herald a new, nationally co-ordinated anti-Rushdie campaign. 
 Mr Abdul Chishti, the association's secretary, said the campaign would continue for &bquo;five, 10 years&hellip; until the British Government bans the book. 
 The media thinks we have gone quiet but we have not&equo;. 
 New tactics will include picketing London's Saudi and Kuwaiti embassies and targeting leading Muslim businessmen to put pressure on the secular business community. 
 A full-time pressure group is likely to be set up in the new year. 
 &bquo;Muslims are organising themselves on a nationwide scale,&equo; Dr Mohammed Ghayas, editor of Muslimedia, a news service of the Islamic movement, said. 
 &bquo;The mosques are now being politicised. 
 There have been many meetings and there are many programmes under discussion. 
 We are very disappointed by the Government's failure to respond to our position and we intend to keep the issue alive,&equo; said Dr Ghayas. 
 But Dr Hesham El-Essawy, a prominent moderate and chairman of the Islamic Society for the Promotion of Religious Tolerance, preaches caution. 
 He has consistently denied that most British Muslims support Iran's fatwa (religious edict) &mdash; a belief borne out by a BBC2 survey for the Public Eye programme which showed only 28 per cent of British Muslims in favour. 
 But even Dr El-Essawy talks of tempers boiling over. 
 &bquo;The young ones born here are the most militant, they are pushing the elders to revive the campaign,&equo; he said. 
 One of the most significant recent developments is the emergence of Muslim youth groups, united by their desire to see Islam enjoy the same protection as Christianity. 
 Mr Mohammed Siddique, aged 33, is president of the newly-formed Muslim Youth Movement of Great Britain. 
 Based in Bradford, it has only 100 members but claims to be linking up with branches throughout the country. 
 Mr Siddique estimates there are now some 200 groups and last week he wrote to Mrs Thatcher warning her that &bquo;Bradford may turn into Beirut&equo;. 
 Mr Siddique said his members understood that Mr Rushdie was protected under British law, but said: &bquo;I would welcome the opportunity to kill him myself if he was in an Islamic country.&equo; 
 The publishers of The Satanic Verses, Viking Penguin, who still receive death threats, have already spent &pound;2 million on extra security. 
 A spokesperson said there were no immediate plans to publish the book in paperback but, when that happened, the novel would appear without prior publicity. 
 One of Mr Rushdie's friends said the sooner the paperback appeared the better. 
 &bquo;The cycle of the book will then be completed.&equo; 
 Dr El-Essawy, of the more moderate Muslims, said Mr Rushdie only had to withdraw the book and Muslims would give up their campaign. 
 &bquo;He is not doing much to help himself,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;But he is probably safer now than he will be in 10 years&equo; time. 
 A nut will get him. 
 It only takes one.&equo; 
 Summit maps out strategy for German unity 
 continued from page one a bigger role for the European Parliament from the Rome Treaty review process. 
 In practice, the first session of the inter-governental conference will be attached to the Rome EC summit next December, although serious bargaining will only start some months later. 
 Chancellor Kohl wants this process finished by 1991, which could mean that Britain would have to choose between agreeing on a new treaty for a supranational monetary union or risk being left behind by the rest of the EC months before the next British general election. 
 When Chancellor Kohl said he would prefer the December inter-governmental conference to be held after the West German election, Mrs Thatcher intervened and said: &bquo;But Mr Chancellor, my elections are due the following year.&equo; 
 What is less certain is whether the whole complex machinery for monetary union will be in place by the start of 1993, as most EC leaders want. 
 On the other hand, they were more optimistic yesterday than for many months that the long legislative process to make the single market a reality by December 31, 1992 would be finished on time. 
 Britons favour greater European integration and are increasingly critical of Mrs Thatcher's stance on the subject, according to a Gallup poll for the Daily Telegraph. 
 The poll also shows the Tories have cut Labour's lead from nine to six points over the past month. 
 Popular usage decimates literary elite. 
 By John Ezard 
 AN elite corps of transatlantic guardians of the English language has thrown in the towel. 
 Its rearguard battle to discourage solecisms such as the use of &bquo;aggravate&equo; to mean &bquo;irritate&equo; and &bquo;decimate&equo; to mean &bquo;slaughter most of&equo; is to be abandoned. 
 The panel of 175 distinguished authors, scholars, broadcasters and public figures regards correct usage as no longer worth fighting for and trivial, according to a poll of its views to be published on January 8. 
 The turnabout is expected to be seen as disastrous news by purists &mdash; not only in the United States but here in Britain, because of the speed with which language fashions cross the Atlantic. 
 A review of the poll says the panel's decision to waive rules on which previously it insisted reflects a sense among experts of &bquo;a precipitate decline in the importance of humanist classicism and&hellip; cultural literacy&equo;. 
 The experts, a veteran &bquo;usage panel&equo; regularly consulted by the Random House Dictionary, include journalists William F. Buckley and the Guardian's former Washington correspondent, Alastair Cooke; writers Jessica Mitford, Louis Auchincloss, Garrison Keillor, Paul Theroux, Fay Weldon, Eudora Welty, Isaac Asimov and Carl Sagan; academics Jacques Barzun, Daniel Boorstin, John Kenneth Galbraith and Susan Sontag; and politicians Jeanne Kirkpatrick and Eugene McCarthy. 
 In 1969 they took a hard line. 
 Only a quarter tolerated the common misapprehension whereby to decimate has ceased to mean, as in the Roman legions, to slaughter one in 10. 
 Now two-thirds accept its usage as meaning to kill most of. 
 Seventy-one per cent were prepared to allow &bquo;aggravating&equo; for &bquo;irritating&equo; compared with 43 per cent in 1969. 
 Half approved &bquo;anxious&equo; as a synonym for &bquo;eager&equo; (23 per cent in 1969). 
 Fifty-eight per cent passed the use of &bquo;transpire&equo; for &bquo;occur&equo;. 
 Half felt the error was so common that they voted to give up its etymological origin &mdash; &bquo;to become public&equo;. 
 Asked about grammar, the panelists strongly resisted confusions of singular and plural, as in &bquo;anyone who isn't happy can take their grievance to the arbitrators&equo;. 
 But half agreed to tolerate split infinitives &mdash; as in Startrek's &bquo;to boldly go&equo;. 
 The American linguist, Geoffrey Nunberg, writes of the poll: &bquo;What is new is the sense that the study of grammar is irrelevant. 
 We now think of an insistence on grammatical correctness as a conservative position. 
 It is hard for us to understand how these same principles could have been part of the radical political programme of writers as diverse as Cobbett and Gramsci.&equo; 
 The State of the Language, 1990, edited by Christopher Ricks and Leonard Michaels, published by Faber and Faber on January 8 (&pound;17.50). 
 Havel may get presidency. 
 By Ian Traynor in Prague 
 MR Vaclav Havel, the Czechoslovak opposition leader, held talks with senior Communist Party figures last night on the shape of a new cabinet amid growing signals that he could become the country's next president. 
 The outcome of the talks remained unclear but leading figures in the opposition Civic Forum were optimistic that the Communists will be reduced to a minority in the new coalition government. 
 In a separate development, the Foreign Ministry told the Soviet embassy here that it wanted talks as soon as possible on the withdrawal of the 75,000 Red Army troops based in the country. 
 The Forum sought to link the creation of the new government to the stepping down of President Gustav Husak, a key demand of the opposition. 
 But a Communist Party spokesman said that the two issues should be dealt with separately. 
 The Forum leadership is believed to have discussed putting Mr Havel's name forward for president yesterday. 
 Father Vaclav Maly of the Forum said that he wanted Mr Havel to be president. 
 A source at the meeting would not deny that Mr Havel's candidacy was being actively considered. 
 Another leading Forum activist said that last night's talks, in which the Communists were lead by the politburo member, Mr Vasil Mohorita, and in which the small political parties also took part, could produce a quick agreement. 
 The new cabinet could be finalised over the weekend following the crisis produced by the resignation of the prime minister, Mr Ladislav Adamec, on Thursday, the source said. 
 It was notable that Mr Adamec's replacement as Prime Minister, Mr Marian Calfa, did not take part in the talks. 
 Opposition sources describe the new Prime Minister as &bquo;faceless&equo;. 
 The sources also reacted favourably to a statement published yesterday by the erstwhile Communist satellite, the People's Party, calling for the Communists to be restricted in effect to around a third of a new cabinet. 
 Under this scheme, half the seats would be shared between the established political parties, and the other half would go to &bquo;non-party&equo; people. 
 Were this plan to go into efect, it would make the opposition the strongest group in the government. 
 Non-party seats would go to the Forum and their supporters. 
 The Forum could also count to a large extent on the backing of their Socialist and People's parties. 
 &bquo;The People's Party statement is very important,&equo; a senior opposition figure said. 
 &bquo;It is quite clear that the Communists have to be in a minority in the new government. 
 This happened with the Czech &lsqb;regional&rsqb; government. 
 The federal government cannot be different.&equo; 
 While the seeming inexorable logic of events points to Mr Havel being named president, opposition figures stressed that the presidency issue was secondary to the priority of swiftly forming a new, stable and strong government. 
 Constitutionally, the prime minister may assume the functions of the head of state for two weeks. 
 Were President Husak to quit over the weekend and a new government be formed, the presidential issue could be deferred while efforts were made to defuse the threat of instability. 
 The Forum also insisted that the price of supporting Mr Calfa as Prime Minister was to have the leading Slovak human rights activist, Mr Jan Czarnogursky, as first Deputy Prime Minister. 
 Leader comment, page 22; Husak profile, page 7 
 Opposition floats Havel as next president. 
 By Ian Traynor in Prague 
 MR VACLAV Havel, the Czechoslovak opposition leader, and the still ruling Communist Party were immersed in crisis talks on the shape of a new coalition government late last night as the prospect of Mr Havel becoming the next president appeared to strengthen. 
 The opposition Civic Forum earlier described the talks as constructive, amid growing opposition optimism that the Communists would be reduced to a minority in the new government. 
 But the results of the talks with the party politburo member Mr Vasil Mohorita remained unclear. 
 At a meeting yesterday to draft tactics after the resignation of the Prime Minister, Mr Ladislav Adamec, the Forum's leaders were believed to have discussed putting Mr Havel's name forward for the post of head of state. 
 One of the opposition's chief demands is that President Gustav Husak should step down because of his association with the Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia in 1968. 
 A source at the meeting did not deny that Mr Havel's candidacy was discussed, while Father Vaclav Maly, a leading Forum activist, said he wanted to see Mr Havel as head of state. 
 Mr Ladislav Lis, of the Forum, said the talks, in which the smaller political parties were also taking part, could produce quick agreement. 
 The new cabinet could be finalised over the weekend, he said. 
 The opposition sought to link the creation of the new government to Mr Husak stepping down. 
 A Communist Party spokesman said that the two issues should be dealt with separately. 
 But leading Forum figures emphasised that the issue of the presidency was secondary to the priority of quickly forming a new, strong and stable government. 
 Constitutionally, the prime minister may assume the functions of head of state for a fortnight. 
 Were President Husak to resign over the weekend and a new government be formed, the presidential issue could be deferred. 
 Opposition sources reacted favourably to a statement by the former Communist satellite, the People's Party, calling for the Communists to be restricted in effect to about a third of the cabinet seats. 
 Under such a scheme half the seats would be shared among the established political parties; the other half would go to &bquo;non-party&equo; people. 
 Were the plan to come into effect, it would make the opposition the strongest group in the government. 
 Non-party seats would go to the Forum and its supporters. 
 The Forum could also count to a large extent on the support of the Socialist and People's Parties. 
 &bquo;The People's Party's statement is very important,&equo; a senior opposition figure said. 
 In a further signal of the changes sweeping the country, President Husak abolished the crime of subversion and a host of other political offences. 
 Other developments included the Foreign Ministry calling for prompt talks with Moscow about the withdrawal of the 75,000 Red Army troops stationed in the country and signs that the diplomatic corps was about to be purged. 
 Leader comment, page 22; Husak profile, page 7 
 &pound;300,000 for princesses' beaten maid *. 
 By Andrew Culf 
 AMAID who was regularly whipped and beaten by two Arab princesses for whom she worked was yesterday awarded &pound;300,000 damages in the High Court. 
 Mrs Laxmi Swami, who told the court her employers wrenched out two of her gold teeth and kept her without food for days, was awarded the damages, and costs estimated at &pound;100,000, against Princesses Faria and Simiya Al Sabah, sisters of the Emir of Kuwait. 
 After three-and-a-half hours' deliberation, the jury awarded Mrs Swami, aged 49, of Kingsbury, north-west London, &pound;240,000 for the assaults, and &pound;60,000 for false imprisonment. 
 Last night, Mrs Swami said: &bquo;I am stunned at the award.&equo; 
 Her solicitor, Mr Rohit Sanghvi, added: &bquo;The award reflects the outrage which this jury felt and which any decent person would feel at the treatment of my client. 
 To describe her treatment as barbaric would be to put it mildly.&equo; 
 During the five-day hearing, the jury heard Mrs Swami suffered frequent mistreatment at the princesses' house in Bathurst Street, Bayswater, London, between 1980 and 1983. 
 She said she was beaten almost daily with a horse whip or flex until she bled, forced to sleep on the floor and kept without food, sometimes for two or three days. 
 She had to work night and day and survive on two hours' sleep. 
 She said fear prevented her escaping. 
 The daughter of an Indian labourer, Mrs Swami was deserted by her husband and had to support four children on her own. 
 After going to work in the Gulf states she was offered a job with the princesses. 
 The princesses, who were not in court, admitted assaulting Mrs Swami but contested the frequency of the beatings. 
 They admitted interfering with her gold teeth, but denied she was kept prisoner, made to sleep on the floor with only two sheets and kept without food. 
 In 1985, when they pleaded guilty at Knightsbridge crown court to assaulting Mrs Swami, they received suspended sentences, were fined and ordered to pay &pound;2,000 compensation. 
 Mr Alistair McDuff, for the princesses, told the court Mrs Swami's treatment in the summer of 1983 was dreadful, but in previous years things were not as bad as painted by her. 
 Interest of &pound;19,200 will be added to the award. 
 Mr Justice Popplewell said &pound;85,000 paid into court in offer of settlement would be paid immediately, and refused an application for a stay on damages above &pound;85,000, pending a possible appeal. 
 Land release boosts forestry... 
 By Paul Brown Environment Correspondent CHANGES in government policy are about to release large areas of land for commercial forestry and halt the feud between the timber trade and environmental groups over the conservation of upland areas. 
 The Scottish Office, after five years of lobbying by the timber trade, and prompted by European Community farm surpluses, has agreed that marginal farmland previously kept for agriculture can now be used for forestry. 
 It will also instruct all the regions in Scotland to produce a forestry strategy which earmarks land for tree planting. 
 This would exclude land of scientific or ecological value and identify large areas where commercial growers could plant forests. 
 The combination of the two policies, which are likely to be extended to the rest of Britain, means that land which can support far greater numbers and variety of trees will be available to foresters. 
 This will divert forests from disputed uplands where foresters are frequently held up or defeated in long battles with environment groups. 
 It is ironic that the changes are being adopted just after the dismemberment by the Government of the Nature Conservancy Council, mainly at the instigation of Scottish Office. 
 Forestry interests and landowners in Scotland had been lobbying the Scottish Office to draw the teeth of the NCC because it had been too successful in defending the uplands from conifers. 
 Mr Vincent Goodstadt, of the department of physical planning at Strathclyde regional council, has devised a map to identify areas with potential for forestry. 
 Mr Goodstadt says: &bquo;Until recently, further opportunities for planting were becoming increasingly restricted to the residue of highly sensitive uplands, where contentious applications conflicted with the interests of wildlife, landscape and water resources.&equo; 
 The policy will attract forestry investment to the areas most suitable in climate, soils, accessibility, land price and availability which were unconstrained by conservation issues. 
 Mr Ronald Williams of the Forestry Industry Committee of Great Britain said the land being released would enable foresters to grow a greater variety of trees in a more attractive way. 
 Army ambulance cover for S Yorks. 
 SOUTH Yorkshire yesterday became the fifth health authority to call in the army and police to take over its emergency services. 
 Military vehicles were on standby in the county from 6am. 
 The chief ambulance officer, Mr Don Page, said last night that they had been very busy all day, and that their use would continue indefinitely &mdash; &bquo;until ambulancemen and women in South Yorkshire resume normal working&equo;. 
 He said no staff had been suspended, but they were not being paid. 
 The county joins London, Lincolnshire, Bedfordshire and Hertfordshire in having military ambulances answering calls. 
 The London branch of the Association of Professional Ambulance Personnel, the non-TUC union, meets on Monday to consider resigning. 
 &bquo;They are rapidly becoming a leadership without a membership,&equo; said a spokesman for Nupe, the biggest of the five TUC ambulance unions. 
 Hundreds of members have already left the association after its leaders recommended acceptance of the 9 per cent, 18-month pay offer rejected a month ago by the unions. 
 The whole Hertfordshire branch resigned on Thursday night. 
 Glasgow ambulance staff yesterday voted to observe TUC guidelines after management had warned that those on patient transfer would have their pay docked by three quarters unless they worked normally, and accident and emergency staff would lose half their pay unless they worked within the guidelines. 
 Microwaves may cause dangerous molecular changes in milk, meat and fish. 
 By James Erlichman, Consumer Affairs Correspondent 
 MICROWAVE cooking creates potentially dangerous substances in baby milk which may damage the brain, liver and kidneys, doctors said yesterday. 
 Research published in the Lancet casts doubt on the safety of using microwave ovens to heat other foods such as cheese, meat or fish, which contain amino acids, the building blocks of proteins. 
 Doctors at the paediatrics department of the University of Vienna heated samples of infant milk formula for 10 minutes in a microwave used for warming baby food and compared it with milk heated in a water bath to 80C. 
 The conventionally heated milk showed no abnormal molecular changes, but all the microwaved samples contained two abnormal amino acids, D-proline and cis-hydroxyproline. 
 The Vienna doctors say that D-proline is neurotoxic, which means that it can kill brain and other nerve cells. 
 It is also toxic to liver and kidney cells. 
 Cis-hydroxyproline, when used by the body to build protein, may cause &bquo;structural, functional and immunological effects&equo;, according to the Lancet letter. 
 Professor Merton Sandler, an expert in infant nutrition at Queen Charlotte's Maternity Hospital in London, said yesterday that the report appeared to be significant and should be more fully explored. 
 Earlier this week government research was published showing that 32 out of 102 ovens failed to heat food uniformly to at least 70C, the temperature necessary to kill listeria, salmonella and other food poisoning bacteria. 
 Microwaves create very short, high energy radio-waves which agitate and heat water molecules on or near the surface of foods. 
 Cooking works by conduction, as heat from the surface is drawn in. 
 The concern is that this high energy agitation can transform healthy amino acids into toxic &bquo;mirror images&equo; of themselves. 
 It was announced last night that urgent talks are to be held with public health officials after a survey by the Institution of Environmental Health Officers showed 2,858 out of 5,622 restaurants, pubs, and other outlets investigated were using microwave ovens designed for home kitchens. 
 The Agriculture Minister, Mr John Gummer, said: &bquo;This is obviously a cause for concern. 
 I shall be following up this survey.&equo; 
 . 
 Cocaine hauls rise. 
 Cocaine seizures by Customs have gone up 50 per cent this year, the Home Office minister, Mr David Mellor, told the Commons during a debate on the misuse of drugs. 
 Page 6. 
 Grants victory. 
 An historic legal decision will give tens of thousands of European students who could not afford British college fees the right to apply for discretionary grants. 
 Page 4.. 
 . 
 MR TREVOR Clay, retired general secretary of the Royal College of Nursing, was yesterday awarded &pound;8,000 High Court libel damages over a Daily Mirror story, which he claimed accused him of working &bquo;with an eye on getting a plum job with the Government&equo;. 
 But because he turned down an out of court settlement of &pound;10,000 in August, his financial backers, the RCN, now face paying a large share of a costs bill of around &pound;25,000. 
 The jury decided unanimously that Mr Clay, aged 53, of Swiss Cottage, north London, was libelled in the article, published in November 1988, during nursing pay negotiations. 
 Afterwards Mr Clay, who retired as General Secretary in September, said he felt &bquo;totally vindicated&equo;. 
 &bquo;I don't regret bringing this libel action. 
 I took the advice of my lawyers not to accept the &pound;10,000 offered by the Mirror. 
 I wanted an apology and I was not given one. 
 The jury has found in my favour. 
 These things are expensive but the crucial thing is that both my name and the name of the RCN has been cleared.&equo; 
 Later, Mr Clay, who retired as general secretary in September, said he did not know whether he would receive the &pound;8,000 or whether it would be used to offset the costs bill. 
 mfl ab During the two-day hearing, Mr Clay said the 285,000-member RCN had been frequently attacked for its industrial relations policy. 
 As the only no-strike nurses union, it had often been accused of being a Government &bquo;lackey&equo;. 
 But the Mirror article, read to him over the phone while he was in Korea, was a personal attack. 
 He complained through the College on the same day. 
 Mr Milmo said that it was &bquo;utterly and completely false&equo; to suggest that Mr Clay had been influenced by the prospect of some plum job when he retired. 
 He was not aware of any post being sought for him by the Government and, if offered one, would have turned it down. 
 Instead of apologising for the article, the Mirror, in an act of &bquo;pure undiluted hypocrisy&equo;, published a second article &bquo;Maggie's Clay Test&equo; and a leader on the subject the following day. 
 Headlined &bquo;This Sick Idea&equo;, the leader recorded the fact that Mr Clay was unaware of what Mrs Thatcher was trying to do and asked whether she had not realised that &bquo;by seeking to reward the only general secretary who treated her with kid gloves, she would end up by blackening his name&equo;. 
 &bquo;Didn't she understand that it might look like she had bought him off with bribery?&equo; the leader asked. 
 It ended by saying that Mrs Thatcher should apologise for trying to find Mr Clay a job and withdraw her request that he be given one. 
 Mr Clay said he saw the second article on the plane flying home. 
 &bquo;I wondered with horror if the thing might be dragging on. 
 I was amazed at the content of the Daily Mirror page that day,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I think it was incredible that they took the line that they did by seeking to say it was the Prime Minister who should apologise and not the Daily Mirror.&equo; 
 Mr Clay added: &bquo;I have spent 35 years serving the nursing profession, most of that time as a member of the College. 
 &bquo;There have never been any thoughts in my mind that I would get something from the Government.&equo; 
 Guarantee bill set for success. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 ABILL improving guarantees on cars and household goods has a good chance of becoming law because it is being introduced by the MP who topped the ballot for private members' bills. 
 The Consumer Guarantee Bill, to be introduced by Mr Martyn Jones (Lab Clwyd SW), has been drafted by the National Consumer Council. 
 It will lay down minimum terms for a new manufacturer's guarantees. 
 Makers will not be obliged to offer the guarantee but those who decide not to will have to display a prominent notice saying &bquo;no consumer guarantee&equo;. 
 Under ordinary sale of goods law, consumers have the right to reject faulty goods and demand a refund, but only if they act quickly. 
 There is no right to repairs or a replacement. 
 Existing guarantees offer extra rights but vary from maker to maker. 
 The new guarantee, good for the first year after purchase, would entitle consumers to free repairs, a replacement on loan or compensation if the product is not repaired within five days (three for motor vehicles), the choice of a refund or replacement if the fault cannot be put right in three attempts, or if the product is under repair for 30 days in any 12-month period. 
 A National Consumer Council opinion poll this year found 98 per cent thought it important that consumers should have a legal right to demand a replacement or refund if a product cannot be repaired reasonably quickly. 
 The bill, based on similar guarantees in the US, has widespread support from manufacturers, retailers, trading standards officers and consumer advisers. 
 Channel 4 veto dispute. 
 By Georgina Henry Media Correspondent 
 SIR Richard Attenborough, the chairman of Channel 4, yesterday warned he would resign if the Government insisted on a right to veto appointments to the new body which will run the channel. 
 Sir Richard described the proposal in the Broadcasting Bill as &bquo;state control of a commercial channel &mdash; surely the antithesis of everything this government is opposed to&equo;. 
 He said his board was united in its opposition. 
 A government veto would impinge not only on the funding arrangements but on editorial autonomy. 
 &bquo;I think if the clause received royal assent I would not wish to continue as chairman.&equo; 
 Under the bill the Independent Television Commission &mdash; whose members are appointed by the Government &mdash; will make appointments &bquo;subject to the approval of the Government&equo; to the new Channel 4 Corporation. 
 This will take over the running of Channel 4 at the beginning of 1993. 
 The Government argues that its bill enshrines Channel 4 as part of the system of public service broadcasting and that therefore it should have a final say in the appointment of who runs it. 
 Mr David Mellor, the Home Office Minister with responsibility for broadcasting, said the Government could have directly appointed members as it does with the BBC and the ITC, but decided &mdash; after pressure from Channel 4 &mdash; not to do so. 
 &bquo;What we are saying is that the ITC will put up the name. 
 All we have the right to do is look at these names and if anyone or two are unsuitable, we will say so,&equo; he told Channel 4 News on Thursday. 
 Mr Michael Grade, the channel's chief executive, yesterday called on the Government to explain why it could not trust ITC appointments. 
 &bquo;If this is not direct political control of a broadcasting network I do not know what is,&equo; he said. 
 Girl, 16, died after taking single tablet of Ecstasy. 
 A16-year-old girl became Britain's first fatal victim of the drug Ecstasy after taking only one tablet of it in a night club, an inquest in Manchester heard yesterday. 
 Clare Leighton, of Cannock, Staffordshire, developed massive internal bleeding and died in hospital 36 hours after being admitted in a delirious condition. 
 She had taken a tablet of the drug &mdash; one of a group of amphetamine-based substances &mdash; on a visit to the Hacienda club in Manchester in July. 
 She had taken it only once before, on a visit to the same club two months earlier. 
 Coroner Mr Leonard Gorodkin recorded a verdict of death by misadventure after hearing that Clare developed what was called an &bquo;idiosyncratic reaction&equo; to the drug. 
 Dr James Freemont, pathologist, of Manchester Royal Infirmary, said Clare died after developing internal bleeding which made her major organs fail. 
 After her death, he carried out research showing that there were only two fatal cases in the world, both in the US, directly related to the drug. 
 Protest as Jews lose assembly. 
 By Education Staff 
 ALEADING independent day school for girls with a large number of Jewish pupils has provoked a row by replacing the weekly Jewish assembly with a non-denominational, multi-faith gathering of the entire school. 
 South Hampstead High School in north London has some 200 Jews among its 510 pupils, but a steady inflow of Muslim and Hindu girls has prompted the headteacher, Mrs Averil Burgess, to cancel the Friday Jewish assembly from January. 
 Some angry parents and a visiting rabbi have accused Mrs Burgess of failing to consult them, and want the Chief Rabbi, Lord Jakobovits, to intervene. 
 They fear the assembly will in effect be Christian, and derpive Jewish pupils of knowledge about Judaic faith, practices, history and ethics. 
 EC forges ahead on currency International bank plan for East bloc. 
 By John Palmer in Strasbourg 
 EUROPEAN Community leaders last night hammered out an historic strategy for achieving economic and monetary union by the mid-1990s and seeking a peaceful and more united Germany in close co-operation with the Soviet Union. 
 Late last night they were also reported to have agreed to establish a supranational bank to finance the reconstruction of Eastern Europe &mdash; a strategy Mrs Thatcher has doubts about. 
 She had already found herself in isolation over progress to monetary union and the endorsement of a social charter of workers' rights, and it became clear that the new European Community order would be built on an even closer alliance of France and West Germany. 
 Any lingering doubts about the closeness of that alliance were dissipated when Chancellor Helmut Kohl gave his ringing support for President Franois Mitterrand's call for a special inter-governmental conference next December, to begin revising the Rome Treaty and opening the way to full economic and monetary union. 
 The West German leader, far from seeking to slow down the process leading to monetary union, said the treaty revision should be agreed by the end of 1991 and put into force by the time the EC single market was completed at the end of 1992. 
 Leaders of the other 11 EC countries paid scant regard to Mrs Thatcher's ritualistic denunciation of the Social Charter as a threat to business competitiveness, and to the unity conference as premature. 
 But she did have the satisfaction that no sooner were the two decisions taken, than the entire Palais de Congress, housing the summit, the media and several thousand attendants and officials, was plunged into darkness by a five-minute power failure. 
 Last night, the 12 heads of state and government were discussing a text on the situation in Eastern Europe which gave unambiguous but qualified support to the right of the German people to self-determination &mdash; and by implication to some form of unity. 
 But the declaration makes it clear this can only be achieved within the process of European integration, in the context of a close East-West cooperation and dialogue. 
 Earlier, a big split was threatened over the language to be used about German reunification &mdash; with President Mitterrand and the Italian Prime Minister, Mr Giulio Andreotti, expressing opposition to a simple reference to German &bquo;self-determination&equo;. 
 They spoke about the &bquo;concerns and worries&equo; President Gorbachev had expressed about the developments in East Germany in recent days. 
 Early this morning work was continuing on getting the wording right. 
 Although all sides denied that a deal was being done on Germany, there was no mistaking the willingness of the French and West Germans to accommodate each other's political needs. 
 Chancellor Kohl will return to Bonn with the backing of his Community partners for some kind of confederal link between the two Germanys. 
 In return, he gave the clearest commitment yet that the government in Bonn would not permit any tampering with the Oder-Neisse line, the border between East Germany and Poland. 
 The agreement on a supranational Bank of Europe, for which a US and Japanese input would be invited, to help Eastern Europe was announced by the French Foreign Minister Mr Roland Dumas. 
 The British backed the plan but are less enthusiastic than the French. 
 Mrs Thatcher's aides were keen to put a brave face on the undoubted diplomatic setback she suffered here yesterday. 
 &bquo;The battle of ideas only begins now, and we will produce our ideas and have them fully debated,&equo; the Prime Minister's press secretary, Mr Bernard Ingham, said. 
 &bquo;We shall look forward to it.&equo; 
 The British government will find it even harder to win support for its alternative road to monetary union based on a free-for-all competition between different currencies. 
 The Italian government, which takes over the EC presidency from Ireland next summer, will use the three-stage Delors strategy for monetary union as the basis for considering changes to the Treaty of Rome. 
 This calls for the establishment of a single European Community central bank, and eventually a single currency. 
 At the same time, the president of the European Parliament, Mr Enrique Baron, described to the summit the list of demands for increased powers for MEPs to turn to page 24, col 2 
 EC goes ahead on currency continued from page one control ministers and central bankers. 
 Mrs Thatcher, although she has criticised the Delors monetary union plan for being &bquo;undemocratic,&equo; is determined to try to exclude consideration of a bigger role for the European Parliament from the Rome Treaty review process. 
 In practice, the first session of the inter-governmental conference will be attached to the Rome EC summit next December, although serious bargaining will only start some months later. 
 Chancellor Kohl wants this process finished by 1991, which could mean that Britain would have to choose between agreeing on a new treaty for monetary union or risk being left behind months before the next British general election. 
 When Chancellor Kohl said he would prefer the inter-governmental conference to be held after the West German election, Mrs Thatcher said: &bquo;But Mr Chancellor, my elections are due the following year.&equo; 
 What is less certain is whether the whole complex machinery for monetary union will be in place by the start of 1993, as most EC leaders want. 
 On the other hand, they were more optimistic yesterday than for many months that the long legislative process to make the single market a reality by December 31, 1992 would be finished on time. 
 Britons favour greater European integration and are increasingly critical of Mrs Thatcher's stance on the subject, according to a Gallup poll for the Daily Telegraph. 
 Firm's engineers win 37-hour week. 
 By Keith Harper Labour Editor 
 A 37-HOUR working week agreed yesterday for a group of engineering workers may become a benchmark in the national engineering dispute, now in its second month. 
 The agreement at Smiths Industries, Cheltenham, ending a three-week strike at the plant was accepted overwhelmingly at a mass meeting yesterday. 
 It gives the 3,200 staff a 7.6 per cent pay increase. 
 The two-hour reduction will be introduced in phases, with the second becoming effective in November 199l. 
 The engineering unions have been seeking either a 35-hour week or a two-hour reduction. 
 Attention will now focus on negotiations at Rolls-Royce and British Aerospace. 
 Mr Derek Jackson, Smiths' managing director, said that the agreement would not increase unit costs and would enable the company to &bquo;bid prices&equo; which won business. 
 Staff would have new opportunities to gain additional skills and benefit from greater flexibility. 
 At Vauxhall the unions are divided on a two-year offer of a 9.7 per cent rise plus a lump sum payment of &pound;200 in the first year and inflation-plus-&pound;5 in the second. 
 Members of the Amalgamated Engineering Union voted for but Transport and General Workers' staff have voted against and yesterday held another one-day strike. 
 Grant case opens door to students. 
 By Celia Weston, Chief Education Correspondent 
 NEW regulations forced on the Government will give tens of thousands of European students who could not afford to come to college in Britain the right to apply for discretionary grants to finance their studies. 
 The new rules came in after Treasury solicitors agreed to settle the case of a German law student who was granted a judicial review of the Government's refusal to reimburse EC students' tuition fees. 
 The review was of the Government's failure under the Treaty of Rome to ensure equal treatment for EC and British nationals who apply for grants to pay the cost of their fees to study in this country. 
 In addition, the Treasury has offered an ex gratia payment of &pound;580 to Ms Anouschka Zagorski, studying law at King's College, London, to reimburse the cost of her fees for the last academic year. 
 All EC students will now be able to compete for polytechnic and university places, and for money from local education authorities, on the same basis as British nationals. 
 Poorer EC students will be able to apply for board and lodging grants as well as their fees, on the same basis as British students. 
 From next September, the Government is to raise the cost of tuition fees, paid by local education authorities on behalf of students, from &pound;607 to &pound;1,675. 
 However, it has made no provision in its spending plans for the influx of EC students which is likely to follow. 
 More than 10,000 EC students came to study in Britain in 1987, the last year for which figures are available. 
 Of these, 2,602 were Greek, 2,378 German, and 1,876 French. 
 Between 800 and 1,200 students came, in each case, from the Irish Republic, Italy, and Spain. 
 The change conceded by the Government and the Department of Education and Science will also allow thousands of British students to apply for grants to study in EC countries. 
 Byelection fear for Kinnock. 
 By Alan Dunn and Alan Travis 
 THE Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, was last night facing the possibility of an embarrassing byelection after the maverick Labour MP Mr Frank Field learned he had lost his reselection fight in his Birkenhead constituency. 
 The long-time social crusader said he had been ousted by the trade union block vote and had won the majority support of the individual members of the Birkenhead constituency who took part in the secret ballot on Tuesday. 
 After the vote was announced, Mr Field said he would be seeing Mr Kinnock on Monday. 
 He has previously suggested that if he lost the reselection vote he would resign, thus provoking a byelection. 
 &bquo;I said that if I was turfed out by the trade union vote I would see Neil Kinnock and we would then both issue a statement afterwards,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The Labour Party will have to very quickly make up its mind: does it want a Labour Party clearly led by Neil Kinnock, as I do, or one run by Ron Todd? 
 It is intolerable that Labour MPs who are also accountable to all the voters in their town should be turfed out by the block vote. 
 There was a clear majority in the earlier ballot for me. 
 The Trotskyist Militant vote moved en bloc to defeat me by a handful. 
 &bquo;This has been going on for ten years,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;Ten years of their trying to undermine the Member &mdash; not a bad result at all.&equo; 
 When the result was officially declared at a general committee meeting of the Birkenhead party last night, Mr Field had already won the first round of the ballot in the individual members section with 159 votes against his two challengers, Mr Paul Davies, a local Transport and General Workers' union official, who secured 75 votes and Militant supporter, Ms Kathy Wilson, with 48 votes. 
 In the trade union section, which is allocated 40 per cent of the total vote, Mr Davies came first with 25 votes, Field second with 15 and Wilson last with 11 votes. 
 But in the second round, when Ms Wilson was eliminated, Mr Davies had 35 trade union votes against Mr Field's 16. 
 It was sufficient to outweigh Mr Field's 165 to 113 second-round victory in the individual members' section. 
 Mr Field, MP for Birkenhead for 10 years, will see Mr Kinnock next week before deciding his next move. 
 &bquo;I said if I lost the membership vote I would have resigned quietly, but I had a clear and commanding lead.&equo; 
 He forecast Mr Davies would never stand as candidate, &bquo;because if the Labour Party allows him to go forward this seat will actually be won by the Liberal Democrats. 
 We may have problems in the Labour Party but we ain't that barmy.&equo; 
 But Mr Davies disputed the claim that Mr Field had the backing of a majority of the individual members of the party. 
 &bquo;If you add up the people who voted for him and those who voted against him and those who didn't vote, you have to decide if that is a vote of confidence in him or not.&equo; 
 A Labour Party spokesman said if a complaint was received, the selection process &bquo;would be scrutinised in every respect. 
 The process will only be complete when the national executive endorses the candidate. 
 &bquo;Any claims of infiltration, if properly substantiated, will be fully investigated and dealt with by the NEC,&equo; the spokesman said. 
 The Labour MP Mr Chris Mullin was last night reselected as candidate for Sunderland South, winning 63 per cent of the vote against his opponent Mr Les Scott's 34 per cent. 
 People, page 2 
 . 
 The past is another country. 
 EVERYTHING has to go, at ridiculous prices. 
 In East Germany that includes the flag with its hammer and compass, the current national anthem, and quite possibly over this weekend the Communist Party as well. 
 In Prague, where one Prime Minister has already resigned, his successor has been awarded only conditional co-operation by the opposition. 
 Mr Ladislav Adamec went because he was handed a list of non-Communist names to fill his government's portfolios. 
 Mr Marian Calfa is pleading for more time on the grounds that he has been given an even longer list. 
 Meanwhile President Gustav Husak's ultimatum to go expires on Sunday. 
 There is a suggestion that the Soviet Union would not object if Mr Alexander Dubcek succeeded Mr Husak. 
 It looks increasingly as if Moscow has no time for such trivial questions. 
 The Soviet Central Committee has been summoned to meet today apparently to consider some tricky agenda items for the Congress of People's Deputies next week. 
 These may include calls to follow the Lithuanian lead and abolish from the Soviet Constitution as a whole the clause which guarantees the Communist Party a leading role in society. 
 As a communist leader who has, in his own way, resisted change said before ordering the tanks to go in, &bquo;If you give a first step, it is never the last.&equo; 
 The current whirlpool of political trial and experimentation in Eastern Europe comes as a tonic contrast to the years of ideological stagnation for almost everyone except Mr Deng, President Ceausescu and, regrettably, President Fidel Castro. 
 (However we should still heed Mr Castro's warning that nothing now happening in Europe is going to help the desperate problems of the Third World. 
 ) There is a heady feel to the discussion paper produced for the East German congress by the working group running the leaderless party. 
 Throw Stalinism overboard, it declared, and build on the &bquo;socialist, social democratic, communist, anti-fascist and pacifist traditions&equo; of the past. 
 The only problem is whether everything is going to get sucked down in the process. 
 We applaud the initiative of the East German citizens in liberating their secret police headquarters and share their regret that vital papers were destroyed in the shredder. 
 (Just in passing we might reflect on the likely reaction in Curzon Street or around the Euston underpass if our own citizens took it into their heads to peer behind MI5's muslin curtains.) 
 But, with simultaneous political vacuums this weekend in Prague and East Berlin, there must be some apprehension as to what may happen if either or both implodes. 
 It is also very hard for apparatchiks at the grassroots of the party to understand. 
 It is perhaps not so difficult to accept the overthrow of an individual &mdash; a Honecker or a Jakes: that been done before. 
 It is the catastrophic slippage in public respect which blows the minds of the apparatus. 
 The new party secretary in Czechoslovakia, Mr Karel Urbanek, has complained that he is quite unable to persuade district and regional party leaders to understand that the party's leading role has gone. 
 In the one Eastern Europe country where the communists had some claim to popular legitimacy in the past, opposition spokesmen freely proclaim: &bquo;Czechoslovakia has never been a communist country. 
 Czechoslovakia was a country in which the Communist Party implemented its totalitarian power.&equo; 
 In East Germany the party has been forced to hold &bquo;round table&equo; talks with the opposition groups, and to concede free elections not just sometime but next May. 
 It was the round table approach which sunk the Polish Communist Party. 
 Bertolt Brecht's aphorism has been dramatically reversed while we pause for breath. 
 For years the government had attempted to dissolve the people and elect another. 
 Now the people are taking their revenge.. 
 No trouble on the terraces. 
 THE CHOICE of Sardinia &mdash; now confirmed as the venue for the opening stages of England's 1990 World Cup campaign &mdash; satisfies the requirement laid down by Britain's Minister for Sport, Mr Colin Moynihan, that these matches ought to be played &bquo;on an island where the problem can be contained.&equo; 
 The problem wasn't specified &mdash; but then it hardly needs to be. 
 It is, of course, the loud-mouthed, oathmongering, lager-swilling, foreigner-baiting, Union-Jack-encrusted British football yob. 
 Sardinia is a land whose past is riddled with bloody brigandry and often inexplicable feuding; a land which at various times in the past has bowed the knee to such untoward arrivals as the Vandals and the Goths (not to mention the supreme midfield general of his day, Napoleon Bonaparte). 
 So Sardinia knows what it faces and is fully prepared. 
 &bquo;Our island will be as if in a state of war&equo; one senior official was quoted as saying yesterday. 
 &bquo;We will use tear gas, helicopters &mdash; anything we believe is necessary to keep our island from being damaged.&equo; 
 &bquo;England's army of thugs were told last night: &bquo;cause any aggro and we'll jail you and throw away the key&equo;&equo; it was reported yesterday in The One That Most Of Them Read. 
 &bquo;Italian security chiefs.. have pledged to lock up the yobs in Sardinia's notorious Buoncamino Prison and leave them there until AFTER the World Cup ends.&equo; 
 Buoncamino, the Sun went on to warn its potential customers, is &bquo;a sinister survivor of the mediaeval past with few modern facilities&hellip; the Sardinians treat their criminals ruthlessly &mdash; and there will be no relaxation of their hard regime for the English.&equo; 
 While the Daily Star held out the glittering prospect of &bquo;dark, damp, rat-infested dungeons in a medieval castle where troublemakers will be left to rot.&equo; 
 But Sardinia is only the start. 
 If Mr Moynihan is prudent, he will already be thinking ahead to the World Cup of 1994. 
 That will be staged in the United States, with stadiums designated in those areas where soccer is strongest, like California. 
 Mr Moynihan should even now be pressing the football authorities to cast around for an island where The Problem can be contained. 
 One obvious candidate suggests itself: the island of Alcatraz. 
 Its qualifications for taming England supporters look from this distance more compelling than even Sardinia's. 
 It is smaller than Sardinia (just 22 acres, or roughly 13 football pitches, against Sardinia's 16,000 square miles, or six million pitches) which for purposes of containment ought to be counted pure gain. 
 There are no public bars or outlets for purchasing lager, and the only route for escaping the forces of law and order is a taxing swim through a shark-infested bay. 
 Best of all, of course, the place has a built-in prison to put Buoncamino to shame, for though Alcatraz closed its doors to its regular customers 27 years ago it is still preserved as a tourist attraction. 
 It may not be rat-infested, but any good entrepreneur could swiftly see to that. 
 If Mr Moynihan is keen to hang on to his job he should get on to FIFA now and tell them to make the booking. 
 What was good enough to contain Al Capone, he could then assure the Prime Minister, should be right for the English yob. 
 PAGE 
 Lawyers' advert &bquo;misleads&equo;. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 THE Law Society has been forced to reconsider the wording of a &pound;70 million national advertising campaign. 
 The Legal Action Group, which campaigns for better legal services, has threatened to report the society to the Advertising Standards Authority for actively misleading the public. 
 The director of the National Consumer Council, Mr Maurice Healy, has also written to the society expressing concern that the advertisements might confuse. 
 The advertising is designed to promote solicitors subscribing to Solicitors Financial &amp; Property Services, a company set up by the society last year to help small legal firms win mortgage, pension and insurance business. 
 Readers are told to complete a coupon &bquo;for a list of solicitors providing advice on mortgages, pensions and other financial products.&equo; 
 However, financial advice is not provided by the solicitors who are not registered under the Financial Services Act but by a firm of insurance brokers, Sedgwick, which has a contract with the company. 
 Individual firms avoid having to register as financial advisers under the act by providing advice through a &bquo;permitted third party&equo; who fulfils the act's requirements. 
 Mr Roger Smith, the Action Group's director, said the advertisement &bquo;would have actively misled the public into thinking solicitors were providing advice when it was in fact coming from someone else. 
 It is vitally important that the integrity of solicitors is not jeopardised by their drive for new markets to compensate for the possible loss of conveyancing.&equo; 
 Mr Andrew Lockley, head of the society's legal practice directorate, said: &bquo;The present text of the advertisements was settled after taking very careful advice. 
 But we are going to review it in the light of the criticism.&equo; 
 Outcrop of worry in Dales. 
 By Martin Wainwright 
 ASOFTLY-SOFTLY approach is to be taken to the owners of one of Britain's strangest threatened landscapes, the Clint-and-Gryke limestone pavements of the Yorkshire Dales. 
 Seamed by deep fissures (the Grykes) into large, often fantastically shaped, blocks of stone (the Clints), the pavements shelter a unique flora and create eerie patterns on the fells. 
 But the national growth of interest in gardening, and hunt for novelty, has revived a threat last seriously seen in Edwardian times. 
 Clints have been quarried for rockeries at a markedly increasing rate in the last 20 years, according to a Dales National Park report. 
 A sample taken by the Institute for Terrestrial Ecology found only 3 per cent wholly intact. 
 A full survey of the 150 pavements in the park is under way, and a conference on the subject, involving the Nature Conservancy Council and the Countryside Commission, will be held next May. 
 But meanwhile the park has agreed to seek protection orders in consultation with landowners, rather than risking conflict and long legal proceedings. 
 Prey for collectors&hellip; 
 A limestone pavement above Malham, North Yorkshire, the future of which is worrying conservationists PHOTOGRAPH: DENIS THORPE 
 Minister ducks Commons battle over higher education loans. 
 By Celia Weston, Chief Education Correspondent 
 MR JOHN MacGregor, the Education Secretary, has distanced himself from the Government's loans scheme for students by appointing the two most junior ministers at the Department of Education and Science to sit on the parliamentary committee discussing the Education (Student Loans) Bill. 
 Mr MacGregor, who supports strongly the principle of loans for students, is believed to be embarrassed by the controversy created by Mr Robert Jackson, the junior minister for higher education, who devised a top-up scheme which has angered backbench Tories and the banks that are supposed to administer it from next September. 
 The committee, which meets for the first time next Tuesday, is expected to end its deliberations in January. 
 Mr Jack Straw, Labour's shadow education secretary, said last night that it was the first time in his 10 years in Parliament that responsibility for piloting such an important piece of legislation through committee had been left to such junior departmental politicians. 
 It was extraordinary, he said, given the bill's political sensitivity, &bquo;that Mr MacGregor has decided not to serve on the committee. 
 He is leaving Jackson to swing in the wind&equo;. 
 Mr Alan Howarth, who joined the DES only in the July reshuffle and has little experience of and no responsibility for higher education, will be Mr Jackson's back-up. 
 Waddington cuts back on parole. 
 By John Carvel Home Affairs Editor 
 THE Home Secretary, Mr David Waddington, yesterday proposed a cut in prisoners' parole rights as a main ingredient of a shake-up of the criminal justice system to be set out in a government white paper next month. 
 Mr Waddington said prisoners should serve at least half their sentences rather than the present minimum of one-third. 
 All offenders should be supervised after their release and returned to prison to serve out their full sentences if they re-offended. 
 Penal reformers estimate the package will add about 4,000 to an average daily prison population of 48,500 unless it is balanced by compensating changes in sentencing policy by judges and magistrates. 
 Mr Waddington, who hopes to eliminate prison overcrowding within three years, now appears to be satisfied that other sections of his white paper will reduce the number of less-serious offenders sent to prison. 
 Sentencers are to be provided with a range of tougher non-custodial punishments. 
 Home Office ministers and officials are currently wooing judges and magistrates to the new approach. 
 The parole reforms will please the judges who believe time served should more closely reflect sentence given. 
 The package adopts almost all the recommendations of a review committee chaired by Lord Carlisle of Bucklow and jettisons changes introduced by Mr (now Sir) Leon Brittan when he was Home Secretary in 1983. 
 Sir Leon extended early parole to many more short-sentence prisoners and virtually abolished it for long-term offenders convicted on drugs, sex, arson, and violence charges. 
 The policy of releasing prisoners into the community without a transitional period of supervision was challenged earlier this year following the case of David Evans, who murdered the schoolgirl Anna Humphries shortly after his release. 
 Mr Waddington, who was addressing the Lancashire business school, said that prisoners serving short sentences &mdash; defined by Lord Carlisle as under four years &mdash; should be granted parole automatically after serving half their sentences. 
 At present most are eligible for a discretionary parole review after serving one-third of their time, or six months, whichever is longer. 
 &bquo;But where the sentence is substantial the offence will be grave, the risk the offender represents to the public can be significant and the difference which decision to grant or not to grant parole makes, may be more than a few months. 
 It is my view that there should be no automatic parole for people serving substantial terms of imprisonment.&equo; 
 Parole for these longer-term prisoners should remain discretionary. 
 The minister disagreed with Lord Carlisle's recommendation that the Home Secretary should give up his veto over decisions by the Parole Board in cases involving &bquo;the worst kind of offenders&equo;. 
 The Carlisle report said that sentence lengths would have to be reduced by 5 per cent if its package was not to increase the prison population. 
 Mr Harry Fletcher, assistant general secretary of the National Union of Probation Officers, said later, parole and greater risk of offenders breaching longer periods of supervision could add at least 4,000 to the prison population. 
 There was no certainty sentencing practices would change. 
 Pace of flu attack hits 14-year high. 
 By Nigel Williams Science Correspondent 
 FLU is sweeping across Britain at the highest rate recorded for 14 years, according to figures published yesterday. 
 In the first official recognition of the extent of the outbreak, Dr Douglas Fleming, deputy director of the Birmingham research unit of the Royal College of General Practitioners, said there is now a &bquo;substantial epidemic&equo; which is likely to get worse. 
 The official definition of an epidemic is 100 cases per 100,000. 
 During the week ending last Tuesday 109 people in every 100,000 of the population had flu, and 154 had flu-like illnesses. 
 Compared with the previous week, there was a trebling in the rate of flu and a doubling of the rate of flu-like illness. 
 The rate of increase during the past three weeks is comparable with that seen in 1975, when infection levels rose to an average weekly rate of 350 per 100,000 population. 
 The research unit collates information on communicable diseases and respiratory tract infections from a network of 228 family doctors in 62 practices across England and Wales. 
 Figures indicate the spread is occurring nationwide, with children under 14 at highest risk. 
 In Wiltshire, a doctor has died from the flu virus. 
 A post-mortem examination on Dr Magdalene Weld, aged 52, found she died on Wednesday from bronchial pneumonia brought on by influenza. 
 At Southampton General Hospital, where 90 out of 360 nurses are off sick, management appealed for volunteer nurses. 
 The hospital is refusing to take non-emergency patients. 
 Two weeks ago 24.6 people per 100,000 were reporting flu, and 51.7 had flu-like illness. 
 The subsequent week's figures were 29.9 and 80.0. 
 The highest level of epidemic influenza ever recorded by the unit was 918.1 per 100,000 in the winter epidemic 20 years ago. 
 Monkey tests lift hopes for Aids vaccine *. 
 By Nigel Williams Science Correspondent 
 ACRUCIAL step towards the production of an Aids vaccine was announced yesterday by researchers who have successfully immunised eight of nine monkeys against infection with one strain of an HIV-like virus. 
 Dr David Tyrell, a scientist working on the Medical Research Coucil's Aids programme, described the results at Tulane University, Louisiana, as &bquo;very important and encouraging.&equo; 
 Some researchers had become so daunted by the devious nature of the virus, which can hide within the cells of the body, that they felt a vaccine would be impossible. 
 This vaccine is a chemically inactivated preparation of the whole simian immunodeficiency virus, or SIV. 
 The monkey virus is the closest animal counterpart of HIV. 
 It also causes a fatal Aids-like illness in some species of monkey. 
 The findings, reported in the US journal Science, extend previous reports of limited success in immunising monkeys against much higher doses of SIV at the New England regional primate centre in Massachusetts and at the University of California. 
 Dr Tyrell stressed that the results do not mean that a similar vaccine can be made for HIV &bquo;but at least the road now does not look like a dead end&equo;. 
 So far, the vaccine has been tested against the same viral strain that the monkeys were immunised against. 
 Developing a vaccine that protects against diverse strains is essential, because humans can be infected by many strains of HIV. 
 In addition, a chemically inactivated virus is unlikely to be safe enough for human use because of concerns that some live viral particles would survive the chemical treatment. 
 Preliminary vaccine tests in humans have largely involved so-called &bquo;sub-unit&equo; vaccines, made from parts of HIV, which are not infectious. 
 Such vaccines are less likely to be toxic than a whole virus vaccine but some researchers believe that they are also less likely to work. 
 A vaccine against HIV is still likely to be many years away but Dr Michael Murphey-Corb, who led the Tulane team, said he hoped &bquo;to see something in five years.&equo; 
 The nine monkeys received a series of three vaccine injections as well as a booster injection one year later. 
 Two weeks after their booster, nine were given intravenous injections of SIV. 
 The amount injected was 10 times the minimum amount of SIV required to infect and cause the Aids-like illness. 
 News in brief. 
 Acid house plotter jailed. 
 Leslie Thomas, aged 27, who organised acid house parties in London, was jailed for five years and three months at the Old Bailey yesterday. 
 Thomas, of the Isle of Dogs, east London, was found guilty of plotting to permit premises to be used for the supply of drugs. 
 Life for killers. 
 Ryan Monks and Paul Mill, both 21, were jailed for life at Perth High Court yesterday for hacking gunshop manager Mr Gordon Johnston, aged 54, to death during a raid at his shop in Dundee. 
 Sunday trading appeal. 
 A conference of more than 150 representatives of local authorites in London yesterday backed an appeal to the Attorney General, Sir Patrick Mayhew, to act against retailers and DIY chains which flout Sunday trading laws. 
 Bakers raise pay offer. 
 The Federation of Bakers yesterday made an increased pay offer of 9.5 per cent to bakery workers to save threatened Christmas bread supplies. 
 The Bakers, Food and Allied Workers' Union had threatened a series of one-day strikes. 
 N-dust judgment delay. 
 Judgment was reserved at the High Court in London yesterday on a claim by Mr Christopher Merlin, aged 48, and his wife, Christine, of Broughton-in-Furness, Cumbria, who claim their former home was contaminated with plutonimum dust from the Sellafield plant. 
 Maxwell boycott. 
 The National Union of Journalists yesterday launched a worldwide campaign to boycott products from Mr Robert Maxwell's Pergamon Press publishing company in Oxford. 
 The union is fighting for the reinstatement of 23 sacked journalists. 
 Press Council reform plan.. 
 By David Sharrock 
 ASLIMMER Press Council should speed up its handling of complaints against newspapers and act firmly against unacceptable intrusions of privacy, according to a review conducted by its chairman, Mr Louis Blom-Cooper QC. 
 His report, which it is understood will be considered by the council next Tuesday, recommends that the body be reduced in size from 36 to 24 members, plus an independent chairman, divided equally between members of the press and public. 
 Significant changes in the working of the complaints procedure would be made by shortening the process, giving each side one opportunity to state its case. 
 The existing complaints department would have a new role directly investigating complaints by telephone, correspondence and, if necessary, face-to-face interviews. 
 The absolute right of an editor or journalist to opt for a personal hearing before a complaints committee would be removed. 
 An individual suspecting that an unwarranted invasion of privacy may about to be published would be able to approach the council's director, who, when satisfied of this, &bquo;should instantly contact the editor and put him on notice of the complaint. 
 &bquo;Publication should remain a matter for the editor's discretion, but if a complaint is subsequently upheld the council may feel justified in strengthening criticism.&equo; 
 The council would publish a code reflecting commonly-accepted good journalistic practice, to come into effect by next March. 
 All proprietors and editors would be asked to publish the code and abide by it. 
 The code emphasises privacy. 
 Publishing information about the private lives of individuals without their consent &bquo;is not acceptable, unless there is a public interest overriding the right of privacy&equo;. 
 The code also covers accuracy and sources. 
 &bquo;Journalists have a professional obligation to protect confidential sources of information.&equo; 
 The council should &bquo;in appropriate cases&equo; add to an adjudication a recommendation that an apology be made to the complainant. 
 To maintain public confidence in the ability of the press to regulate itself, the Press Council believes it necessary for proprietors or publishers &bquo;to give a positive commitment to uphold the principles stated in the council's declarations of principle and in the code of practice&equo;. 
 Siege mentality fails to stop time marching on Summit sketch. 
 By Michael White 
 AS BEFITS one of the great revolutionary years of modern European history, the police were taking no chances with the Strasbourg summiteers yesterday. 
 Even by the standards of French provincial life, there were flattering numbers of flics, plain-clothed flics and bored CRS riot-flics hanging round the respectable northern suburbs. 
 It could only mean one thing: they suspected that the sleek Strasbourgeois citizenry might be planning to outdo Warsaw, Budapest, Berlin and Prague by marching up the Avenue de la Paix to overthrow 12 governments at once. 
 Fat chance. 
 This was an incongruously comfy setting for such momentous deliberations. 
 The Palais des Congres, an undistinguished lump of modernism, is situated amid solid villas which look like Alsatian mutations of Ealing or Didsbury. 
 Gothic mock Tudor is what Dorking would look like if the Kaiser had won. 
 Incongruous, too, because La Dame de Fer and her redoubtable overseas mouthpiece, British Sources, spoke much as they did six months ago in Madrid when the Berlin Wall stood firm and Alexander Dubcek was still an obscure forestry official. 
 These are heady times. 
 But did they talk headily around the conference table? 
 Of course they did. 
 Bliss was it in that dawn to be alive, but to be a full member of the Exchange Rate Mechanism was very Heaven. 
 Unless you are British. 
 In which case bliss was it to be soft-peddling on EMU, EMS, German reunification (10 to 15 years) and the Karl Marx Memorial Social Charter. 
 &bquo;In the real democracy which we inhabit in the United Kingdom&equo;, we see things differently, as British Sources are wont to put it. 
 A crushing piece of condescension that, worthy of a Spanish grandee in about 1700, too proud to notice that the world has moved on. 
 In its way it is magnificent: shades of heroic defiance of reality, like Dunkirk in 1940. 
 Except that in 1989 the European skies are bright, not dark. 
 Franco-German battles are fought with press release, not tank division, and the general idea is to keep the Huns firmly inside French territory &mdash; not the other way round. 
 Mrs Thatcher wore red, Mr Hurd wore grey and sat between her and Mr Jacques Delors, the traditional French enemy. 
 British Sources wore a truculent glower and insisted that we were &bquo;true Europeans&equo;. 
 The press wore magnificent shoulder bags stuffed full of Alsatian free gifts which some of you will be getting for Christmas. 
 Thus bribed, the media steadily worked their way through mountains of free food and the occasional libation. 
 From time to time, national spin doctors &mdash; or &bquo;medecins du spin&equo;, as we say around here &mdash; would emerge to say something or nothing at inordinate and chauvinistic length. 
 The inter-governmental conference which British Sources had refused to countenance all day was duly nodded through. 
 After lunch, Madame Edith Cresson, Mr Mitterrand's French Source, was pounced upon by the Broadcasting Bill's finest and made to admit that La Dame de Fer had said something positive. 
 She hinted of an important secret still to be divulged. 
 In mid-afternoon the lights went out. 
 But the expected Strasbourg Uprising did not occur. 
 Outside, the city shivered under nine TV channels and an oppressive blanket of prosperity which includes Habitat, Marks and Sparks and Burtons. 
 If only these people would adopt real democracy and the unfettered free market, this place could be as prosperous as Southampton. 
 Inside the briefing room of the Royaume Uni we hovered on the edge of Dunkirk as usual. 
 Jovial inquiries about illegal subsidies to industry, Rover for instance, got short shrift. 
 The Duchess of Finchley's Light Infantry was trapped behind enemy lines, but it was digging in. 
 French press releases overran our positions, German amendments raked us with deadly fire. 
 But down in our trench we could take it. 
 We still had the Dutch on our side. 
 Sorry, cancel that last report. 
 The Dutch appear to be wavering. 
 British Sources insisted throughout that &bquo;we shall be our constructive selves&equo; or &bquo;play our full and constructive argumentative part&equo;. 
 Suggestions that we were non-communautaire was the fault of the British press. 
 Alas, Liberation's headline yesterday was &bquo;L'eternelle solitude de la Dame de Fer&equo;, while the local paper, which is called DNA (Dernieres Nouvelles d'Alsace, silly) inexplicably reported that she was &bquo;plus anti-communautaire que jamais&equo;. 
 Where do they get it from? 
 Community closes ranks against UK, page 7 
 A Country Diary: MACHYNLLETH: For me a frequent delight in many years of hill-walking in Wales has been to come upon that lively, eye-catching bird the wheatear which so loves to play hide and seek among the rocks. 
 But I have seldom got very close to these quick, nervous birds. 
 From a distance I have managed to see something of their spectacular courtship frolics that take place both on the ground and in the air, and I have listened to their songs which, though not rich in melody, seem just right for a world of cliffs and screes. 
 But with such a wide-awake bird as the wheatear you will discover very little else about its private life unless you really get down to the job. 
 And 40 years ago that is just what Peter Conder, soon to be assisted by his wife, Pat, set out to do. 
 He has been gathering his facts on and off ever since and now they are available to us all in his book The Wheatear, a truly classic study of every aspect of the wheatear's lifestyle. 
 It seems fair to claim this attractive book as a product of Wales because although the author lives in eastern England and has observed wheatears in many far-flung places, the foundation studies were made on the Pembrokeshire island of Skokholm and Peter Conder has often returned there to keep fresh the memory of his pioneering researches. 
 Thorough in all its countless details his book is well written and easy to read, its charm further enhanced by many true to life sketches made in the field by John Busby. 
 The publisher is Christopher Helm, the price &pound;19.95. 
 WILLIAM CONDRY 
 Athletics Christie's winter sprint. 
 By Sandy Sutherland 
 ALTHOUGH three English Commonwealth Games representatives, Peter Elliott, Derek Redmond and Phil Brown, have withdrawn, Linford Christie's presence should do much to enliven the Scottish Indoor Championship in the Kelvin Hall, Glasgow, today and tomorrow. 
 Christie arrived back from warm-weather training on Thursday, but confirmed yesterday through his coach, Ron Roddan, that he would be flying north to attempt a sprint double, even though the 200 metres is scheduled for today and the 60 metres tomorrow. 
 The presence of the Seoul 100 metres silver medallist might have attracted a few more through the turnstiles had the Scottish AAA not agreed to keep his entry a secret at the request of the athlete himself, a fact which inevitably leaked out leaving the promoters somewhat embarrassed. 
 Christie will face a strong line-up, including Michael Rosswess, the Birchfield Harrier who won both his international 60 metres races in Glasgow last winter but could not clinch his Auckland trip. 
 Scotland's Jamie Henderson and Elliot Bunney, who are both Auckland-bound, will be there for the sprints, but with neither Brown nor Brian Whittle competing, the 400 metres has lost much of its appeal. 
 Chris McGeorge is in the 800, though, and Northern Ireland's Mark Kirk defends the 1500 against Tony Morrell, who has a point to prove about his fitness. 
 Alistair Currie will attempt the Scottish Commonwealth selection standard of 7min 48sec in the 3,000 metres despite the absence of Elliott, who has flu. 
 Benn learning fast at new school. 
 By John Rodda in Las Vegas 
 THE maturing of Nigel Benn is an appropriate tale for the season of the transformation scene. 
 Before he was knocked down and beaten &mdash; for the first time &mdash; by Michael Watson, he was a brash product of black anger, a ghetto-blaster of the ring whose pantomime craftsmanship was redeemed by the crunching power of both fists. 
 But Watson did both Benn and British boxing a service. 
 Reassessment followed that defeat and brought a new direction with new people and a contract of &dollar;2 million for four fights over the next two years. 
 Benn was eager to get the taste of American boxing before he met Watson and the urge to find new experience brought the break, sad but needed, from the trainer who had brought him through from his amateur days, Brian Lynch. 
 While Lynch had developed his punching power, Benn needed boxing lessons and the time-honoured way of getting them is in sparring. 
 Under Lynch that was not part of the regime, which is regarded as a curious omission in most gyms, and it did not work for Benn. 
 Since moving into a gymnasium in Florida and working with Vic Andreetti, a former British champion from the East End of London, Benn has taken on a new mantle. 
 Now he is just flattered by the label &mdash; &bquo;the British Marvin Hagler&equo; &mdash; which Bob Arum, the American promoter investing that &dollar;2 million, has tagged on him; previously he would have been angry that he himself had not invented it. 
 &bquo;After a few days in the gym here I would wake up and hope that the sparring partners would not turn up. 
 It was hard and they hurt, but you soon learn to accept it and respect them as they do you. 
 All that tap, tap work in England was no good; there I was always the governor, now I'm learning all the time, nicking moves from everyone,&equo; he said. 
 Last weekend he despatched Jose Quinones, a shot fighter, in one round. 
 Next month he faces another man who has seen better days, Michael Olajade, a Nigerian born in Britain. 
 Olajade was going places until he was badly beaten by Michael Nunn, but he will provide Benn with fighting experience. 
 &bquo;From now on my home is in England, but the business of boxing will be here,&equo; he said. 
 The Arum plan is for him to fight Iran Barkley in London in April, but that is dependent upon his dealing competently with Olajade and Barkley defeating Doug de Witt in Atlantic City the night Benn's contest takes place there. 
 Dutch plan for sitting room only. 
 THE Dutch plan to do away with standing room at national league grounds within the next 10 years. 
 As part of their attempt to rid themselves of a growing hooligan problem, the clubs agreed on Wednesday to begin converting their grounds into all-seat stadiums and to petition the government for grant aid. 
 &bquo;We're going to do away with standing places, with a 10 per cent cut in the number each year over the next decade,&equo; a Dutch association official said yesterday. 
 There is only one all-seat stadium in the Netherlands &mdash; at Utrecht &mdash; and many grounds have extensive standing areas. 
 PSV Eindhoven's stadium, for example, has standing room for 12,000 supporters out of a capacity of 28,000. 
 Dutch football has been increasingly dogged by hooliganism over the past few years. 
 This season Ajax Amsterdam were banned from European competition for a year after fans hurled iron stakes on to the pitch and forced the abandonment of a Uefa Cup tie in September. 
 The following month 14 fans were injured when Feyenoord fans threw fragmentation bombs at Ajax supporters at a game in Amsterdam. 
 Japan wants to stage the World Cup in 2002. 
 The Japanese FA is to initiate a programme of stadium-building before the choice is made in seven years' time. 
 World Cup amnesty. 
 WORLD Cup organisers have granted an amnesty to players who received yellow cards for fouls and other offences during qualifying matches. 
 Hermann Neuberger, the chairman of the International Football Federation World Cup organising committee, said players who had been shown the yellow card once during qualifying games would not have to carry it over to the finals. 
 Players with two yellow cards would be able to sit out the subsequent one-match sus pension during an international friendly before the 24-nation tournament, Neuberger added. 
 But he said that the amnesty would not cover players who had been shown the red card and sent off for serious offences during qualifying games. 
 They will have to sit out remaining match suspensions when the finals begin on June 8. 
 Fifa officials could not immediately say how many players would benefit from the yellow-card amnesty, but confirmed that at least three players would be suspended for one World Cup match after receiving red cards. 
 They were named as Romario of Brazil, Stanislav Griga of Czechoslovakia and Gheorghe Hagi of Romania. 
 Two other players, Abdul Razaq Ibrahim Albalooshi, of the United Arab Emirates, and Mehmed Bazdarevic, of Yugoslavia &mdash; who has a year's ban &mdash; could also be suspended for red-card offences if appeals were unsuccessful, the Fifa officials added. 
 Beardsley, Pearce and Adams are the three England players who received yellow cards during qualifying matches. 
 Ireland had six offenders: Whelan, Townsend, Aldridge, Stapleton, McCarthy and Houghton (two). 
 The amnesty is particularly good news for Houghton, who picked up his second yellow card of the qualifying tournament in Malta last month and feared that he could miss the opening game in Italy. 
 Now it seems likely that he will instead miss Ireland's next match, against England in Dublin on March 28. 
 Rickett rises from depths. 
 KATIE RICKETT, the surprise selection in Britain's team to play the United States in the Maureen Connolly Trophy match at Cardiff, was beaten 1-6, 7-6, 5-7 by Elly Hakami yesterday. 
 At one time Hakami was ranked 32nd in the world, and her 21-year-old opponent from Birmingham often looked out of her depth, especially in a 27-minute first set. 
 Rickett, to the surprise of the gallery, turned the match round by winning a marathon second set after leading 3-1 and trailing 3-4 before Hakami served for the match at 5-4. 
 She failed, only for Rickett to miss five set points in the 12th game. 
 PAGE 
 Rugby League Crackdown on headhunters. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 THERE has been a considerable outcry from St Helens supporters over the eight-match ban imposed on the club's Kiwi loose forward Shane Cooper two weeks ago. 
 A previously blameless disciplinary record should have entitled Cooper to more lenient treatment, they argue. 
 But Cooper was unfortunate to appear before the disciplinary committee at a time when it was under increasing pressure to eradicate the high, late tackle that has been such a scar on the game this season. 
 Those irate fans, however, may be mollified if the committee continues to deal consistently with all such offenders. 
 Thursday brought further heavy punishments with eight players being banned for a total of 66 games. 
 One of them, Mark Fairbank of Keighley, was suspended for 10 matches while Hussein M'Barki, the first Fulham player to be dismissed since April 1987, was banned for eight games. 
 The campaign has been given additional clout this weekend, with referees under instruction to dismiss instantly anyone guilty of head-high tackles on or off the ball, and not to send them to the sin-bin where they have gone too often in the past. 
 The League cited &bquo;any tackle involving an attack to the head&equo;. 
 Wigan and Widnes will be the first sides to come under scrutiny when they meet in today's televised second-round Regal Trophy game at Central Park. 
 Generally, however, discipline has not been a problem between them in recent years and there have been some pulsating contests. 
 One disappointing absentee is Jonathan Davies, who has been playing with such verve at full-back recently but has not recovered from his damaged hamstring, allowing Alan Tait to revert to full-back. 
 Shaun Wane and Adrian Shelford come into a Wigan side now without their Australians, Les Davidson and Phil Blake. 
 For Bradford's visit, Leeds &mdash; whose squad has been strengthened by the arrival from Barrow of the Australian forward Cavill Heugh &mdash; have dropped the Great Britain prop Lee Crooks. 
 In dispute with the club earlier in the season, Crooks is having weight and fitness problems. 
 Bradford's pack will miss Kelvin Skerrett, while John Hamer and Paul Medley are also doubtful. 
 Salford have signed the 24-year-old full-back Martin Birkett from the Cumbrian amateur club Frizington on a three-year contract. 
 A student at Leeds Polytechnic, Birkett could be one of the substitutes tomorrow at Halifax. 
 Warrington, redundant this weekend, are reported to be keen on signing the Bridgend rugby union half-backs Kevin Ellis and Aled Williams. 
 Ellis, a member of the Wales B squad, has scored eight tries this season, his fly-half colleague 13. 
 In addition to the bans on Fairbank and M'Barki, there were eight-match suspensions for Neil Geary (Warrington), Phil Southward (Runcorn), Frank Simpson (Huddersfield), Mick Hughes (Dewsbury), Richard Mead (Halifax) and Derek Bridgeman (Sheffield). 
 Alan McMullan (Workington) was suspended for four matches, and Graham King (Hunslet) for two, but Mike Fletcher (Hull KR) was ruled not guilty when the committee accepted his explanation that his alleged trip last weekend on the S Helens forward Paul Forber was accidental. 
 Martin Thorpe. 
 CALLS for an independent, unbiased &bquo;Ombudsfan&equo; to investigate supporters' complaints were amplified this week by the outcome of the case involving an Everton supporter, Dave Clarkson. 
 Clarkson says that on August 19, the opening day of this season, he, his wife and two mates arrived at Highfield Road at 2.15pm with &pound;9.50 stand tickets for the Coventry v Everton game, kick-off 3pm. 
 He claims there were only four turnstiles to admit thousands of Everton supporters and as a result he and his party were still queuing, in crushed conditions, at 3.10. 
 After going to the ticket office and being refused a refund, he finally got into the ground at 3.35pm. 
 Coventry, however, claim the queues were caused by late-arriving supporters, and that there is no way Clarkson can have arrived at 2.15 and not have been in the ground by 3.10. 
 When Clarkson, a social worker, got home he sent Coventry a recorded-delivery letter, again asking for his money back. 
 Coventry replied by offering four tickets for the corresponding fixture next season. 
 That did not satisfy Clarkson. 
 &bquo;If you go to the theatre and miss the start because of the queue to get in, you would get your money back,&equo; he argues. 
 His MP Eric Heffer even wrote to Coventry on Clarkson's behalf. 
 Nothing happened. 
 Clarkson decided to go to the small claims court. 
 Coventry decided that it would cost more to contest the claim than pay it; so Clarkson will get &pound;74 for the party's four tickets and travelling expenses. 
 But nobody has &bquo;won&equo;. 
 Clarkson got his refund &bquo;because I refused to give up&equo;, not because Coventry believed his story. 
 The rights and wrongs of the case remain unresolved. 
 IT TAKES a GM Vauxhall Conference side to show how supporters should be treated. 
 When Welling, who today take on Reading in the FA Cup second round, beat Gillingham at Priestfield in the last round, there was some confusion over the price of entry for juniors. 
 Welling were originally told &pound;2.70, but when young Welling fans arrived for the match they found it was &pound;3.90. 
 When the Welling director Graham Hobbins and his brother Barry, the secretary, found out, they immediately went outside and paid every kid the difference. 
 MERTHYR, who visit Hereford in the Cup today, have something of a celebrity board. 
 The chairman John Reddy is the 1980 Wales and West Slimmer of the Year. 
 At his heaviest he was 18st 3lb, and he lost seven stone in 10 months. 
 He now runs 30 miles a week. 
 The club's vice-chairman is Lyn Mittel, a comedian with shows on Welsh TV and radio. 
 His alias is Owen Money. 
 Since becoming vice-chairman four months ago he has thought of changing it to Owen More Money. 
 THE Brazilian Soccer Confederation has filed a suit against the supporter who shot the signal flare in the Brazil v Chile World Cup game, seeking about &pound;16,000 for costs incurred in defending Brazil's case before Fifa in Zurich. 
 The fan, Rosenery Mello, has become a celebrity since the incident and posed for the cover of the November edition of Brazilian Playboy. 
 ACCORDING to John Popham, Radio Nottingham's commentary for the recent Forest game at Manchester City revealed that one player had elbowed another in the face &bquo;quite unnecessarily&equo;. 
 WE ASKED last week for predictions for the Nineties. 
 Phil Domingo predicts: Trevor Francis will become management consultant to the Royal Institute of Midwives. 
 Ronnie Whelan's left foot will qualify for unemployment benefit (what, he asks, goes to Wembley every year and is never used &mdash; Whelan's left foot); Emlyn Hughes will be lead singer of the Communards and the FA and Football League will be able to act with the benefit of hindsight. 
 Brian Keighley sees the game going in a different direction. 
 A match would involve three teams instead of two, playing on a triangular pitch with three sets of goals. 
 Teams would be free to form liaisons with each other depending on the state of the game, so bringing new skills to the game such as negotiation and selling techniques. 
 Specialist positions such as goalkeeper and striker would be joined by the mediator and even ambassador. 
 Then there is the second ball&hellip; 
 Argentina. 
 WC apps: 9 Winners: 1978, 1986 Runners-up: 1930 The holders will again take their cue from Maradona, who is becoming increasingly unpredictable. 
 Burruchaga, who scored their winner in the 1986 final, is still there and Caniggia, who like Troglio plays for Verona, is very quick. 
 But they need Maradona as a match-winner and a talisman &mdash; and he knows it. 
 Seeded 
 England. 
 WC apps: 9 Winners: 1966 Nobody has scored a World Cup goal against England since Maradona left the defence looking like a broken washing line in 1986. 
 Shilton's goalkeeping and extra pace in the back four should make them hard to beat next summer, but goals will be a problem if Lineker does not rediscover his finishing touch and the team as a whole lacks subtlety and imagination. 
 Seeded 
 Holland. 
 WC apps: 5 Runners-up: 1974, 1978 After their European Championship victory and Milan's orange-tinted European Cup triumph, Holland will be expected to do well in Italy. 
 But a lot depends on the state of Gullit's knee and the speed at which other injury problems are solved. 
 Still, Van Basten did return late from the treatment room to score crucial goals in West Germany last summer. 
 Second group 
 Italy. 
 WC apps: 12 Winners: 1934, 1938, 1982 Runners-up: 1970 The most strongly fancied host nation since Argentina in 1978, Italy still need to make up their minds about Baggio and the best striker to partner Vialli. 
 But the foundations look impressive. 
 Baresi is one of the world's best liberos, Italian technique is as good as ever and home advantage still counts for much. 
 Seeded 
 Republic of Ireland. 
 WC apps: 1st time Jack Charlton is still riding the wave of optimism that bore the Irish through the European Championship. 
 Omnipotent in Dublin, the Republic have the players &mdash; Whelan, Houghton, Aldridge, Cascarino, Sheedy, O'Leary &mdash; to see off a large part of the opposition in Italy. 
 They will not win the World Cup, but going further than England would be the next best thing. 
 Third group 
 Romania. 
 WC apps: 5 This is the Romanians' first appearance in the finals since 1970 and after Steaua Bucharest's supine performance against Milan in last season's European Cup final it might be unwise to expect too much. 
 Nevertheless Hagi, Camataru and Dumitrescu are quality players and if Romania, given the political situation in Eastern Europe, have the right appetite they could cause the odd upset. 
 Third group 
 Scotland. 
 WC apps: 7 The Scots are in their fifth successive World Cup and would presumably go along with the Olympian sentiment about taking part being more important than winning. 
 This is because they have only won three matches in a World Cup proper. 
 On paper the side compares poorly with its predecessors, but if McCoist and Johnston are inspired Scotland may yet exceed expectations. 
 Second group 
 South Korea. 
 WC apps: 3 South Korea seem the most likely side from the Third World to achieve a surprise or two this time. 
 In 1986 they lost narrowly to the Italians and held Bulgaria to a draw in torrential rain. 
 Park Kying-Hoon, Choi Soon-Ho and Kim Joo-Sung have survived from Mexico. 
 You must remember them. 
 Fourth group 
 Soviet Union. 
 WC apps: 7 Some observers thought the Soviet Union were a better all-round side than Holland in the 1988 European Championship. 
 Certainly they offered a number of impressive portents for 1990 and England are still trying to forget the way Aleinikov, Mikhailichenko and Zavarov reduced their defence to rubble in Frankfurt. 
 Protasov and Litovchenko will catch the eye in Italy. 
 Second group 
 Spain. 
 WC apps: 7 Spain were unimpressive in the last European Championship and the nucleus of the side remains unchanged. 
 With players of the quality of Butragueno, Michel, Martin Vazquez, Sanchis and Chendo available they should do better, but a big improvement is needed if they are going to make an impact in Italy. 
 Second group 
 Sweden. 
 WC apps: 8 Runners-up: 1958 After flirting with failure, the Swedes came through to the finals with a point to spare after a 2-0 victory in Poland in their last qualifying game. 
 Hysen, Thern, Ekstrom and Magnusson give the side a strong backbone, but they are suspect defensively on the flanks. 
 Third group 
 Austria. 
 WC apps: 6 Austria gladdened a few hearts in 1978 when they beat West Germany but lost a lot of friends in 1982 when they conspired with the West Germans in the cynical exercise which froze out Algeria. 
 A bit of an unknown quantity now, their most crucial result in the qualifiers was the goalless draw with the Soviet Union in Vienna. 
 This suggests they will be hard to break down in Italy. 
 Second group 
 United Emirates. 
 WC apps: 1st time The United Arab Emirates qualified against expectations; even their Brazilian coach, Mario Zagalo, was surprised. 
 They owe their place in Italy to Qatar, who beat China in Singapore in the final Asian play-offs. 
 While they will do well to emulate Morocco, no side organised by Zagalo should be taken lightly. 
 Fourth group 
 United States. 
 WC apps: 4 The Americans only just managed to take advantage of the enforced absence of Mexico &mdash; banned after fielding over-age players in a World Youth Cup &mdash; by winning their decisive qualifier in Trinidad by the odd goal. 
 They are an honest, hard-working but rather dull team redeemed by the goalkeeping qualities of Meola and creative midfield play, when he is fit, of Perez. 
 Fourth group 
 Uruguay. 
 WC apps: 9 Winners: 1930, 1950 If they really have got their act together and manage to cut out the cynical stuff, Uruguay could achieve much more this time. 
 Francescoli, Perdomo and Sosa are among the world's most exciting players and Uruguay's technically adroit, close-passing, possessive style will always make them awkward opponents. 
 Third group 
 West Germany. 
 WC apps: 12 Winners: 1954, 1974 Runners-up: 1966, 1982, 1986 The Germans ran Argentina close in the 1986 final with a team past its prime. 
 Now, with players like Hassler, Reuter and Moller emerging, Klinsmann confirming his European Championship promise and Augenthaler re-emerging from the shadows as libero, the side has a nice balance between youth and experience. 
 Seeded 
 Yugoslavia. 
 WC apps: 8 Once more Yugoslavia are being talked of as dark horses but they faded in 1974 and flopped in 1982. 
 However they still have good players &mdash; Zlatko Vujovic, Stojkovic and Susic for example &mdash; and England will have an opportunity to check them out at Wembley next week. 
 So many Yugoslavs are based across the Channel that French football will virtually be represented in Italy by proxy. 
 Second group 
 Belgium. 
 WC apps: 8 The Belgians tend to be ignored until they suddenly turn up in the latter stages of major tournaments &mdash; the final of the 1980 European Championship and the semi-finals of the last World Cup. 
 Ceulemans is still in their attack and Van der Elst continues to orchestrate the midfield. 
 A team to be watched, even if they are not crowd pullers. 
 Seeded 
 Brazil. 
 WC apps: 14 Winners: 1958, 1962, 1970 Runners-up: 1950 After last summer's disastrous European tour, Brazil won the South American championship and reached Italy with little fuss apart from the Chile fiasco. 
 Bebeto and Romario could be one of the best attacking combinations next summer and, with most of the team based in Europe, Brazil will have no problems acclimatising. 
 Seeded 
 Cameroun. 
 WC apps: 2 Cameroun's big moment came in Spain in 1982 when they held Peru, Poland and Italy to draws and went out of the tournament proud of their unbeaten record. 
 This time Cameroun only lost one qualifier in the African group and their decisive defeat of Tunisia in the final play-off augured well for Italy. 
 Fourth group 
 Colombia. 
 WC apps: 2 The Colombians delighted a small Wembley crowd 18 months ago with the spontaneity and ingenuity of their football. 
 Valderrama is still their main inspiration and, as they showed in the play-off against Israel, their team is well organised at the back with the ability to strike quickly on the break. 
 Third group 
 Costa Rica. 
 WC apps: 1st time Costa Rica qualified early from the Concacaf play-offs, leaving the rest to fight it out among themselves. 
 Their manager, Marvin Rodriguez, promises a &bquo;conservative game&equo; in Italy, but Cayasso and Coronado are a couple of forwards to watch provided the defence can get the ball away. 
 Fourth group 
 Czechoslovakia. 
 WC apps: 8 Runners-up: 1934, 1962 The Czechoslovaks have only been seen twice in the tournament proper since they reached the 1962 final and on neither occasion were they able to win a match. 
 Bilek, Moravcik and Skuhravy look like giving their attack a cutting edge, they qualified without much difficulty and if the team takes its cue from the state of the country anything might happen. 
 Third group 
 Egypt. 
 WC apps: 2 Mike Smith, the former manager of Wales and Egypt, takes a lot of credit for giving the Egyptians the impetus to reach the finals for the first time. 
 They made sure by defeating Algeria, which says a lot for their prowess. 
 Most of these fourth-rated teams have learned how to defend in depth. 
 Diddymen are now thin on the ground in world football. 
 Fourth group 
 Japan doubles Van Rensburg's troubles. 
 By Martin James 
 CHRISTO VAN RENSBURG, one of the world's leading doubles players, went on court at the Albert Hall yesterday believing he would be competing for the last time in the official season-ending doubles championship. 
 But not of his own volition. 
 Next year the Nabisco Masters doubles changes its name to the ATP doubles finals. 
 It also changes venues, and that is where Van Rensburg thinks his problems could lie. 
 The event has been staged at the Royal Albert Hall for four years. 
 Next year it will move to either Japan or Australia. 
 &bquo;As a South African I am not allowed to play in Japan,&equo; said Van Rensburg, who partners Paul Annacone. 
 &bquo;I understand it's hard for the organisers because they have to go where they can find the biggest sponsor. 
 But South Africa is not going to change because of me.&equo; 
 Van Rensburg and other South Africans on the tour are barred from playing in more than 20 countries. 
 However, late last night the organisers were still considering the Australian bid. 
 The South African-American pair are virtually out of contention for this year's title. 
 Yesterday they lost for the second time when they fell 6-7, 7-6, 6-3, 6-4 to Todd Witsken of the United States and Jorge Lozano of Mexico. 
 They now have only one round-robin group match left to make amends. 
 It was not a good day for the more established pairings. 
 The defending champions Jim Pugh and Rick Leach also lost their second successive round-robin group encounter and were left to play off for the minor placings. 
 In the early hours of yesterday morning they were beaten in four sets by Patrick McEnroe and Jim Grabb, and then some 13 hours later they fell 6-3, 7-6, 7-6 to the Australians Darren Cahill and Mark Kratzman, who as a result qualified for the semi-finals. 
 The Australians' red group counterparts, McEnroe and Grabb, also reached the last four when they brushed aside their fellow Americans Jim Courier and Pete Sampras 6-2, 6-3, 6-3. 
 No let-up by McEnroe Minor. 
 AS A singles player Patrick McEnroe languishes below Aki Rahunen and Ville Jansson in the world rankings, writes Martin James. 
 As a doubles player he leaves even Boris Becker behind. 
 Yesterday he endorsed his doubles standing when he and his partner Jim Grabb, already through to the semi-finals of the Nabisco Masters doubles championship at the Royal Albert Hall, finished their round-robin group matches unbeaten when they defeated the Australians Mark Kratzmann and Darren Cahill 7-6, 6-1, 6-4. 
 McEnroe, ranked 19th in doubles to Becker's 39th (although the German has played only seven tournaments) but only 359th in singles, is proud to be part of a successful partnership but would be happier still to make an impression as a soloist. 
 &bquo;My game is suited to doubles because I return well,&equo; he said yesterday, &bquo;but my priority is to do well as a singles player.&equo; 
 Today's semi-finals will feature John Fitzgerald and Anders Jarryd against Cahill and Kratzmann and McEnroe and Grabb against Piet Aldrich and Danie Visser. 
 The Association of Tennis Professionals yesterday announced that its end-of-season doubles championship next year will take place at the Sanctuary Cove resort near Brisbane in Australia. 
 The event will be worth &dollar;1 million. 
 Snooker Mountjoy deepens Thorne's gloom. 
 By Clive Everton 
 THE Everest World Matchplay Championship, restricted to the 12 players who earned most ranking points last season, began at the Brentwood International Centre yesterday with Doug Mountjoy trouncing Willie Thorne 9-2. 
 Thorne, the world No.9, admitted after a lacklustre display last night: &bquo;This has been the worst year of my life.&equo; 
 Terry Griffiths beat Clive Thorburn 9-5, the first time he had beaten the Canadian in nine attempts. 
 The televised phase of the competition begins tomorrow with Steve Davis opening the defence of his title against the winner of today's match between Dean Reynolds and Tony Meo. 
 A repeat of the Stormseal UK final between Davis and Stephen Hendry is on the cards. 
 Gavin Lightman QC, the World Professional Billiards and Snooker Association's one-man disciplinary tribunal, announces his findings today on two charges of bringing the game into disrepute. 
 Alex Higgins brought a complaint against his former manager, Howard Kruger, and Higgins himself is the defendant in a charge arising from recent incidents at Stoke and Reading. 
 Rusch de Farges will take his chance on fast ground. 
 By Chris Hawkins 
 IF MARTIN Pipe has a Gold Cup horse in his yard this season it is probably Rusch de Farges and there will be plenty of interest in this exciting young horse when he reappears in tomorrow's A.F. Budge Gold Cup at Cheltenham. 
 Despite worries expressed by connections last weekend about the fast ground, a stable spokesperson confirmed yesterday that Rusch de Farges will run under top weight of 11st 10lb. 
 This means an all round rise of 4lb, with the original top weights, Barnbrook Again and Golden Freeze, coming out, both on account of the ground. 
 Rusch de Farges, an ex-French gelding, won two of his six races last season both in soft ground and put up his best effort when beaten three lengths by Barnbrook Again at levels in the Arlington Chase Final over two and a half miles at Cheltenham last January. 
 He has some improving to do if he is to develop into a genuine Gold Cup hope but being only a six-year-old and trained by the man who has turned the joke &bquo;the impossible we do at once, miracles take a little longer.&equo; 
 into reality, he is quite likely to make the grade. 
 The dry weather continues to affect racing and Oliver Sherwood will not run Tonights The Night in the A.F. Budge Chase. 
 A decision on Cruising Altitude's participation in the Bula Hurdle will be made after the trainer has spoken to the jockeys at today's meeting. 
 Cruising Altitude was so impressive in beating Morley Street at Newbury that he has been backed down to 8-1 for the Champion. 
 A race betweeen him, Beech Road and Floyd in the Bula would have been particularly informative but of that trio only Floyd is a certain runner now. 
 At Cheltenham this afternoon the big race is the Final of the BMW Chase series. 
 Once again the ground has ruined what promised to be a good contest and only four of the 15 entries go to post. 
 Nicky Henderson's Wont Be Gone Long (2.20) has top weight but is not badly treated considering he beat Lockwood Prince by 15 lengths at Chepstow last May and meets him here on the same terms. 
 As he showed all his form on fast ground last season he will not be bothered by the going but he has to give 15lb to Bonnie Artist. 
 It is dangerous to oppose any of Arthur Stephenson's runners at the moment but Bonnie Artist, although he has won four in a row, has not beaten anything of real ability. 
 Stephenson also sends Durham Edition down for the Food Brokers Ferrero Rocher Handicap Chase but due to defections the weights go up 14lb and he is topweight with 11st 10lb. 
 Durham Edition ran a fair race to finish just under eight lengths fourth to Ghofar in the Hennessy and he must come into the reckoning, although the weight rise seems to give an advantage to Royal Cedar (2.55), who was originally 8lb out of the handicap. 
 Royal Cedar, trained by John McConnochie, who has taken him over from the now retired Mercy Rimell, is another who is perfectly at home on fast ground, winning here over three and a half miles and at Newbury this season. 
 On his reappearance run when ooking backward, he led until falling seven out in the race won by Seagram, who meets him on 2lb better terms now and is thus entitled to start favourite. 
 Doncaster has been similarly decimated and only seven go to the post in three races worth a total of &pound;11,246. 
 Croghan Star (2.00) and On Tap (2.30) should prove too good for their solitary opponents, while Wigtown Boy (3.05) has only two to beat in the Red Alligator Handicap Chase. 
 Devon is always a happy hunting ground for Pipe, who has saddled twice as many winners as any other trainer in the last five years here. 
 He should score with Blake's Progress (12.45), Maintown (1.15) and North Lane (2.45) today. 
 After three winners yesterday, he is only seven short of his century, while Jonothan Lower maintained his strike rate on the Pipe horses with a Taunton double on The Leggett and Ambassador, giving him 21 winners from just 34 rides. 
 Worthless words from mumbling shamateurs The Keating Column. 
 By Frank Keating 
 SAVING the punchline till last, just about the best joke of a pretty unfunny decade comes in its dying days. 
 A suited smart alec, riding shotgun on rugby union's suddenly careering shamateur bandwagon, this week told a group of British international players that they should soon be able to charge &pound;1,500 for a solitary interview. 
 The mind boggles. 
 I cannot remember us jabber of journos enjoying a joke more. 
 Press interviews with the rugger-buggers are almost a contradiction in terms &mdash; even the official, collective, post-match post-mortems after home internationals, down in the bowels of Twickenham or Cardiff, say. 
 These occasions are only for humorists who enjoy the captains' and coaches' mumbled no-comments, and pusillanimous platitudes from grown men. 
 OK, it might be a trifle unfair to cite such post-game bunfights. 
 But what about the one-on-one interview? 
 Any journalist will tell you that British rugby union players, with two or three beguiling exceptions, are hardest to get anything out of worth printing. 
 Few seem to have anything remotely interesting to offer on the philosophy, flavours, fads or fancies of their game. 
 Yet now they are told they can expect to pocket &pound;1,500. 
 They'd better get their act together first. 
 Perhaps they are thinking of the soaraway end of the market? 
 Even more of a no-go area, I'm afraid. 
 Very few of those who write the terrible tabloids, let alone those who read them, are likely to have heard of these &bquo;internationally famous&equo; sportsmen, so I doubt if they'd make half of &pound;1,500 even for such tales as Flanker Star Ate My Goolie During Scrum, by England's Ugliest Prop; or Sexy Secrets in the Showers, by Welsh Tea Lady. 
 What, anyway, makes British rugby players plan to price themselves at such a princely paypacket? 
 Just for one interview, dammit. 
 Like other fellow scribblers whose squiggles seriously abuse the very title &bquo;shorthand notebook&equo;, I have nevertheless been generously given hours, sometimes even days, by sportsmen happy enough to rabbit on without so much as a penny piece being mentioned. 
 Start with the beginning of this decade if you like, when the one and only Muhammad Ali personally escorted me round every nook and cranny of his Deer Lake log-cabin home. 
 Not the slightest mention of money, either, for an interview in depth from, offhand, Gavaskar, Richards, Botham, Willis, Marshall, McEnroe, Connors or Borg &mdash; though the latter, I must admit, was expecting me to stay the day, yet by elevenses we agreed there was not much more to say to each other except &bquo;My game's in pretty good shape&equo;. 
 Did Nicklaus ask for &pound;1,500 for a chat? 
 No, he asks you to please stay for supper and we'll go on in the morning. 
 Did Lee Trevino say &bquo;How much?&equo; 
 Of course not. 
 Nor anyone &mdash; not one &mdash; down the years, when I've approached such luminaries of the lore as, well, Ashe, Stewart, Prost, Platini, Charlton, Best (he even cooked me breakfast), Coe, Thompson, Cauthen, Francome&hellip; 
 This year alone &mdash; the sad one in which British rugby players are apparently rubbing their hands in greedy but pitiful expectation &mdash; I've relished long, doubtless tedious (for them) but totally gratis and generous interviews with the likes of Scudamore (on his most precious mid-season afternoon off), Offiah, Gower, Gooch, Border, Simpson, Jacklin, Robson, the teenage millionaire Chang; and even Mansell took a day off to drive me round and round Silverstone. 
 So why is this internationalsuperstar of the scrummage, who I agree is a household name and all that (although he is known even in the next village as either Whatsit? or Thingymabob), suddenly being advised he has the (to coin a phrase) clout and muscle to alter the long-established formulas and ethics of sports journalism? 
 In other words, just who do these jokers and the jerks pulling their purse-strings think they are? 
 Oh dear, even before they open it, poor Twickenham's can of beans is beginning to pong something rotten. 
 The hilarity induced, however, should run and run. 
 Washbrook: composure and constancy at a jaunty angle Frank Keating dares to wish a four-square and formidable hero a very happy birthday. 
 HAPPY BIRTHDAY, Mr Washbrook, sir. 
 &bquo;You're late, boy.&equo; 
 Sorry, sir, you said any time after six; it's only quarter past; thought you might like to listen to the news headlines first. 
 &bquo;All right, all right, can we get on with it. 
 What do you want to know, I'm a busy man, you know.&equo; 
 I know, sir, all I wanted was to wish an old hero a happy birthday. 
 Have you been flooded with greetings all day, sir? 
 &bquo;Yes, as it so happens, various people have wished me congratulations; very kind; though didn't recognise most of them, I must say.&equo; 
 Washbrook, the four-square and fearless warrior with the faded, jaunty-peaked, blue cap of both Lancashire and England, was 75 on Wednesday, the day I dared my many happy returns, and still as robust, hale and healthy as ever. 
 Oh dear, I thought, he reckons I'm wheedling my way in, not for birthday greetings, but for contentious sexist matters &mdash; to grill him about tonight's Lancashire cricket club annual meeting when the agenda is topped by a proposal that women should at long last be allowed full membership entitling them to mix with men in the pavilion. 
 Another right bitchy ding-dong is in prospect. 
 Mr Washbrook read my thoughts. 
 &bquo;Don't even think of asking me about female membership,&equo; barked the old Sgt-Major. 
 &bquo;I'm president of the club. 
 I've no comment whatsoever to make. 
 I'm not even discussing it with you. 
 The club will decide, right?&equo; 
 I assured him I was only on a romantic, misty-eyed mission, though secretly I was wishing I'd sent the birthday card instead to Winston Place. 
 Fade to childhood and music and Hovis-type ad: &bquo;This is the BBC Light Programme and here is the county cricket scoreboard. 
 Another undefeated opening stand of exactly 150 by Washbrook and Place again put Lancashire in an unassailable position today&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes, Winston. 
 Staunch man. 
 No, I never see him these days, never comes to Old Trafford. 
 Yes, we had a very happy partnership. 
 A great stalwart, though he never thought he was all that good, oddly enough; at the wicket, I mean.&equo; 
 The endearingly diffident but prolific Place retired to a sweetshop-newsagents in 1955, then became an umpire. 
 He and Washbrook once put on 350 for the first wicket against Sussex. 
 Mind you, that wasn't Washbrook's best opening stand &mdash; and I passed on greetings on Wednesday from Surrey, where Sir Leonard Hutton lives. 
 Says Sir Len: &bquo;Cyril was my best and favourite opening partner: the ideal: technique, composure and a firm friend, too.&equo; 
 This message from his old comrade who faced the whizzbangs in the frontline trench obviously moves the birthday boy, though you sense he tries to hide any emotion. 
 He sniffs for a split-second. 
 &bquo;That's very kind of him. 
 Well, we were a real partnership, weren't we? 
 All based on a perfect understanding between the wickets &mdash; and him not telling me what to do and me not telling him. 
 We simply had innate confidence in each other. 
 &bquo;I remember to this day coming out after tea at Jo'burg, 1948-49, going down on to the ground with Len; vast crowd, and this fellow comes out of it and says &bquo;only 30 more for the record, boys&equo;. 
 Len looks at me andmutters, &bquo;What's he on about?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not a clue,&equo; I say. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; says Len, &bquo;we'd better get 30 more then and see what record it is, eh&equo;.&equo; 
 It remains England's highest opening partnership &mdash; 359, both men not out. 
 In 1951 Washbrook was dropped by England. 
 Five years later &mdash; the Ashes series &mdash; he was a Test selector. 
 England miserably one down after two. 
 The selectors met at London's Bath Club for Sunday lunch. 
 The chairman, Gubby Allen, asked Washbrook to leave the room, then argued fiercely with the new young captain, Peter May. 
 Gubby had a hunch. 
 Naturally he prevailed. 
 They called back Washbrook, now 41, and told him to get up to Headingley with his bat and pads. 
 He was staggered. 
 So was the press. 
 Vindictive, more like it. 
 The Daily Express even printed a sneering open letter on the front page at the gall of a selector picking himself. 
 On Thursday morning at Leeds the vultures smugly unscrewed their fountain pens at 11.34am when, with reeling England 17 for three, the commanding, middle-aged man, shirt as ever of more rich, creamy, Blackburn flannel than anyone else, cap-peak more defiantly wonky than ever, strode steadfast to the wicket to join young May. 
 &bquo;Seventeen for three. 
 I'll remember those figures till my dying day. 
 The Yorkshire crowd gave me the most overwhelming reception, you know. 
 It was my greatest moment. 
 No, I wasn't nervous, not unduly worried. 
 Just got down to it.&equo; 
 He and May put on 187 &mdash; a stand that turned the match and indeed the whole rubber. 
 For all his 76 centuries (seven doubles) and 35,000 runs, that 98 at Leeds was, he says, &bquo;my proudest 98 ever&equo;. 
 And he still cannot resist, all these years later, a spiky dig &mdash; &bquo;but most gratifying of all was that the journalists who condemned me were proved so utterly wrong&equo;. 
 Which reminds him of me and he is fast out of his reverie. 
 &bquo;Now look here, I'm a busy man. 
 One more question and that's it, right?&equo; 
 The best he ever faced? 
 &bquo;Lindwall.&equo; 
 Has there been anyone, Lillee or Holding or Marshall to match him since? 
 &bquo;Pphh!&equo; if that's how you record a dismissive grunt. 
 &bquo;Is that it then?&equo; 
 Same goes, I supposed, for today's batsmen; though didn't he play on better pitches? 
 &bquo;Yes, we had better pitches, sure, but we were correspondingly better players. 
 I'll say one other thing before you go. 
 What cricketers need now is a dose of the amateur captain, you know, one who was the boss and everyone knew it, even in the committee room. 
 He was king; he stood on his own; he was an example. 
 Right, is that all? 
 I really must get on with other things.&equo; 
 After some seasons as Lancashire's first professional captain, he had a spell as team manager. 
 He ruled the new generation with a rod, boys who had worshipped the hero as kids and tried to emulate him in their tennis-ball pick-up games &mdash; &bquo;Bags I be Washy!&equo; 
 When they first met for real the fierce, cold, autocratic, heroically self-made man's beady eye and cockily addressed him as &bquo;Washy&equo; to his face, well, petrification set in, sometimes terminal. 
 &bquo;Well, that's it then, please. 
 No more.&equo; 
 Sorry, sir, thank you, sir. 
 Very good of you, sir. 
 Why hadn't I gone to gentler old Winston's place instead. 
 No, not at all. 
 I take that back unreservedly. 
 It is richly good to greet the real heroes of your youth &mdash; and once I was out of earshot I found myself skipping about merrily, humming &bquo;Happy Birthday, Washy&equo; over and over again. 
 And, no doubt about it, very many happy returns, sir. 
 Mason cuts a battered but defiant figure. 
 GARY MASON, booed, bruised and bloodied from his encounter with a &bquo;hand-picked&equo; opponent, will allow Terry Lawless to choose his next bout. 
 But he says he would welcome another Mark Wills or a match with Derek Williams. 
 Mason needed an X-ray on his right hand and repairs around both eyes after being taken the full distance by Wills on Wednesday night, but his heart and ambition remain undamaged. 
 He still wants to fight Mike Tyson in about 18 months. 
 And he was encouraged by the way he came through the first 10-round contest of his 33-fight unbeaten career. 
 &bquo;People didn't believe I could go beyond seven or eight rounds without blowing out,&equo; said Mason. 
 &bquo;I wasn't 100 per cent sure myself. 
 But I have now, and it has enhanced my confidence.&equo; 
 The X-ray showed nothing more than bruising. 
 And the video recording he watched yesterday morning revealed to him rather fewer weaknesses than his critics had discerned. 
 &bquo;I'm disappointed with the criticism I got, stuff like I looked light years away from Tyson,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It was a battle, but I wanted a battle and I want more of them.&equo; 
 His hand, the same one he injured in April last year, needs at least two weeks' rest, but he should be back in the ring in February. 
 Jarvis Astaire, the Wembley director and promoter, is hoping for an opponent like Trevor Berbick or James &bquo;Bonecrusher&equo; Smith, both former world champions. 
 Williams, who beat Trevor Currie on Tuesday night to add the European championship to his Commonwealth title, may have to wait for his shot at the British champion, though Mason rises to his former sparring partner's rhetoric. 
 &bquo;I would like to beat him because of what he has been saying about me,&equo; Mason said. 
 &bquo;All I'll say is that only a foolish dog barks at a flying bird.&equo; 
 Even at his fittest the 17 &frac12;-stone Mason would have difficulty passing as a flying bird. 
 If he ever goes in with Tyson, he could be taken for a foolish dog. 
 Scottish preview Newcastle's Aitken bid &bquo;too low&equo;. 
 By Patrick Glenn 
 NEWCASTLE United yesterday sent a written offer to Celtic for Roy Aitken reportedly so low that it is likely to be returned to St James' Park unopened. 
 The bid, understood to be only around &pound;300,000, has no chance of acceptance by the Glasgow club. 
 While they have consistently refused to name their price, they value their captain much higher than that. 
 Jim Smith, the Newcastle manager, would not disclose the amount, saying: &bquo;We are sending an offer in writing to Celtic today. 
 After that it's up to them.&equo; 
 Aitken, 31 and capped 50 times, is battling to be fit for the Premier Division match against Hibs at Easter Road. 
 He injured his groin during the friendly with Ajax on Wednesday, but was improved yesterday. 
 Aitken's fellow international midfielder Paul McStay misses the match because of suspension, while Hibs recall their international goalkeeper Andy Goram. 
 Aberdeen, the league leaders, are at home to Dundee United and Alex Smith, their manager, is contemplating &bquo;at least one change&equo; after last week's defeat by Celtic which took away the points advantage they held over Rangers. 
 Partick Thistle have signed Hearts' 31-year-old midfielder Ian Jardine as player-coach. 
 Treble for artistic Dunwoody. 
 By Chris Hawkins 
 ONE OF THE anomalies of National Hunt racing this season is the comparative paucity of winners for the artistic Richard Dunwoody, the jockey who most resembles that supreme stylist John Francome among the current crop of riders. 
 At Cheltenham yesterday, however, Dunwoody did something to put the record straight with a 26 &frac12;-1 treble on Remittance Man, Wont Be Gone Long and Royal Cedar to take his score to 34, but only marginally improve a strike rate of 15 per cent. 
 Dunwoody was surprised when the judge called him the winner on Remittance Man in the opening Bristol Novice Hurdle, believing Peter Scudamore had got back in the final strides on the favourite Regal Ambition after being headed halfway up the run-in. 
 Remittance Man deserved this change of luck as he has never been out of the frame in his seven previous starts but had only managed one win. 
 By Prince Regent, out of a mare by Run The Gantlet, he has a flat race pedigree but never ran on the level. 
 He has the size to make a chaser but has yet to fill out. 
 This was the first leg of a double for trainer Nicky Henderson whose Wont Be Gone Long won another nip and tuck affair to take the BMW Chase Final. 
 Dunwoody made all the running on Wont Be Gone Long, keeping something up his sleeve to repel the challenge of Bonnie Artist, who ranged upsides rounding the home turn. 
 The pair were in the air together at the last, but Bonnie Artist stumbled on landing and could never quite peg back the leader who held on by threequarters of a length. 
 Wont Be Gone Long was making a belated seasonal reappearance due to a nasty cut on a hind leg, but now fully recovered, he loves this fast ground and obviously jumps for fun. 
 The Coral Welsh National may be his next race, although he is a long way out of a handicap. 
 The sponsors offer him at 33-1, which could be generous, while making Ghofar and Bonanza Boy joint favourites at 5-1. 
 Dunwoody completed his treble with a beautiful performance on Royal Cedar, the 6-4 favourite, in the Food Brokers Ferrero Rocher Handicap Chase. 
 After making the running for the first circuit, he let Royal Cedar take a breather going down the back for the last time, with Seagram and Durham Edition leading him down the hill. 
 You could see Dunwoody was conserving Royal Cedar's energy, however, and asking for an effort approaching the second last he rose fractionally in front and was well on top at the line, having 2 &frac12; lengths to spare over the gallant Durham Edition who was trying to give 18lb. 
 Royal Cedar was a fourth winner from only eight runners for first season trainer, John McConnochie, who clearly paid a great deal of attention when assistant to Mercy Rimell. 
 The Seagram Grand National looks to be an ideal race for Royal Cedar, who jumps economically without being spectacular and never put a foot wrong here. 
 &bquo;He's a bit on the small side but very agile and loves fast ground, so we shall have to think seriously about the National,&equo; said McConnochie, who at this stage also intends to run Golden Friend, who runs at Haydock on Wednesday. 
 Martin Pipe weighed in with his usual daily double, Royal Wonder and Vagog, both ridden by Peter Scudamore, but fortune certainly smiled on them in the Coral Golden Hurdle Qualifier. 
 Vagog was struggling in fourth place at the last where Lady Westown, going the best, fell and brought down Parlezvousfrancais. 
 This left Ambegate in front but he weakened up the hill and never-say-die Scudamore forced Vagog up in the last few strides. 
 At Cheltenham this afternoon, CRUISING ALTITUDE (1.20) should be more at home on the ground than the champion hurdler Beech Road in the Bula Hurdle, while his Newbury victim, MORLEY STREET (2.30) looks good in the Mercury Communications hurdle. 
 David Elsworth has changed his mind about running BARNBROOK AGAIN (1.55) in the A.F. Budge Gold Cup and even with 12st, this high class chaser should be hard to beat. 
 Doncaster staged it's first meeting since the abandonment of the St Leger fixture but it was a disappointing turnout with a total of only 29 runners, which included a walk-over by Tebitto, who won &pound;4,491 because of the defection of Tap On in the Sea Pigeon Handicap Hurdle. 
 Charlton v Millwall There is a relegation ring about this derby, with Charlton 19th and fast-falling Millwall only two points above them after no win in their last six games. 
 Lennie Lawrence could give a first League start to the striker Kenny Achampong and names the trainee Jason Lee in the home squad, while Millwall are without the injured striker Teddy Sheringham and the suspended midfielder Terry Hurlock. 
 Coventry v Arsenal Arsenal return to one of the few grounds where they were beaten last season, with their match winner against Manchester United, Groves, likely to partner Smith up front again. 
 George Graham's defending champions have lost four of their last five away games and Coventry, with Regis rediscovering scoring form and McGrath likely to return in midfield after five matches out, is no easy place to improve that record. 
 Liverpool v Aston Villa The greatest test yet of Villa's remarkable resurgence. 
 Cynics will say this will be brief, but Graham Taylor's team can start to prove them wrong if they win today and, most probably, go top. 
 The visitors, seeking their ninth win in ten League games, are likely to switch McGrath from centre-back to midfield to combat McMahon's aggressive runs. 
 Liverpool hope Barnes will recover from hamstring trouble but are again without a shoal of injured defenders. 
 Manchester U v C Palace This could be the day when Alex Ferguson finally loses patience with one of his expensive front axis. 
 Statistically, McClair rather than Hughes is the likely victim after only four goals this season &mdash; and the Scot has not scored since October. 
 &bquo;I am thinking of making a change up front. 
 I am worried about the partnership,&equo; says United's manager. 
 Palace, still without an away win, attempt to shore up the division's worst defence by giving a debut to Thorn. 
 Nottingham Forest v Norwich Norwich's manager Dave Stringer was playing the last time his team won at Forest &mdash; in 1974. 
 Fleck should be back soon to sharpen that attack, but for today Stringer names an unchanged squad of 13 to meet a side which has Sutton back in goal after five games' absence at the expense of Crossley. 
 QPR v Chelsea This is likely to be Peter Reid's last appearance in a Rangers shirt, with Loftus Road seemingly resigned to the midfielder's becoming Howard Kendall's player-coach at Manchester City. 
 Reid's midfield partnership with another former England midfielder, Wilkins, may trouble Chelsea, who give the defender Johnsen, their &pound;306,000 recruit from Bayern Munich, his debut. 
 Sheffield Wednesday v Luton Wednesday include their new &pound;375,000 Swedish right-back, Nilsson, in their squad to face Luton and await fitness checks on Shakespeare and the captain Pearson. 
 Luton, without an away First Division win in 12 months, may give Cook a League debut with Kennedy and Black doubtful. 
 Southampton v Manchester C Howard Kendall watches from the stand as his new charges attempt to resist the First Division's most prolific attack. 
 City's caretaker Tony Book prepares for the assault by bringing back Hinchcliffe at full-back. 
 Oldfield is set to replace Brightwell.. 
 Tottenham v Everton Two former Evertonians, Lineker and Van den Hauwe, prepare to meet their former team. 
 Everton have Ratcliffe back in defence but Beagrie and Atteveld must take tests. 
 Wimbledon v Derby County Wimbledon leave out Fashanu for the fourth successive game, keeping faith with the veteran Cork. 
 Indeed Bobby Gould is likely to stick to the team that won startlingly at Chelsea last Saturday. 
 Derby, with six successive wins, could have both Blades and Goddard back after injury. 
 Middlesbrough v Leeds With Sheffield United off duty until tomorrow Leeds can go top, at least for a day, but have Sterland (bruised ribs) and Haddock (calf) taking tests this morning. 
 Middlesbrough's teenage defender, Mohan, is suspended. 
 Ipswich v Sunderland Ipswich will put together their best run for five years if they avoid defeat against Sunderland. 
 John Duncan's side are likely to lose Stockwell from midfield, with Wark returning, against unchanged visitors. 
 Russell Thomas 
 Snooker Higgins is docked &pound;3,000. 
 By Clive Everton 
 ALEX HIGGINS escaped suspension but was fined &pound;3,000 yesterday for bringing the game into disrepute. 
 The Irishman said he had had &bquo;a very fair hearing&equo; from the World Professional Billiards and Snooker Association's one-man disciplinary tribunal, Gavin Lightman QC, who &bquo;took great account of the mitigating circumstances&equo;. 
 Higgins had failed to attend a post-match press conference at Stoke in September, and also admitted using foul and abusive language towards two WPBSA officials and three journalists in a late-night incident in a Reading hotel bar in October. 
 Lightman took into account the Irishman's current financial situation, which he described as &bquo;in pretty bad shape&equo;. 
 The QC also considered &bquo;his attempts to put his life in order and adopt a more responsible and sincere approach to his affairs&equo;. 
 Higgins has now been fined a total of &pound;17,700 during his tumultuous 18-year professional career. 
 When he last appeared before Lightman he was fined &pound;12,000 and suspended from five tournaments for head-butting Paul Hatherell, the WPBSA tournament director, during the 1986 UK championship. 
 The twice world champion's case was considered by Lightman immediately after one in which Higgins was the complainant in a disrepute charge against his former manager, Howard Kruger, who resigned from the association's board last weekend. 
 Lightman ordered that Kruger be publicly reprimanded on two counts. 
 First, that he allowed Framework Management Ltd to go into liquidation admitting it owed &pound;21,000 to Higgins (who claimed he was owed &pound;51,000); and, second, that he had caused to be issued in 1988 &bquo;a press release regarding a tournament to be held in Peking stating, and telling Mr Higgins in order to induce him to take part in the tournament, that the first prize was &pound;35,000 when in fact it was not&equo;. 
 A number of other allegations made by Higgins against Kruger were either not proceeded with or found not to constitute conduct bringing the game into disrepute. 
 Hockey Lahore XI 1, England XI 1. 
 Cotton fumes as England are suffocated by umpires 
 ENGLAND's visit to Pakistan may well be remembered mostly for the umpiring. 
 England felt they suffered again yesterday. 
 Bernard Cotton, the England manager, forcefully expressed the view that England failed to beat the Lahore XI because the Pakistani umpires did not award them the penalty corners and strokes they had earned. 
 &bquo;We created enough opportunities to have won handsomely,&equo; he said. 
 England rested Potter and Clift and played Soma Singh at centre-half against largely unknown opponents. 
 The team played better but failed to profit from their many spells of domination. 
 Rob Hill, one of England's relative newcomers, gave them the lead, following up at a 10th-minute penalty corner, but the team allowed themselves to become rattled by the umpiring and Lahore equalised after 50 minutes. 
 Cherzeel scored with a close copy of England's goal. 
 The coach, Norman Hughes, said he was pleased with the play of Soma and much of England's build-up play and felt the second-half changes made a significant impact. 
 Garcia and Potter came on for Leman and Halls in the 45th minute and Welch replaced Williams seven minutes later. 
 England play Pakistan again today in the final match of the tour, writes Pat Rowley. 
 England players involved in the postponed fourth-round cup ties on Sunday will have about 30 hours to recover from their overnight journey home. 
 It will be interesting to see how that affects the players of the First Division clubs East Grinstead, Havant and Hounslow. 
 Nearly half the Havant team are in Pakistan. 
 Their home tie with Barford Tigers, a team who have had excellent results in the Midlands League in recent weeks, may require them to recover quickly from their overseas exertions. 
 Hounslow, the holders, who will welcome back Jon Potter and Martyn Grimley, face a first meeting with another Middlesex club, the new Second Division side, Lyons. 
 Lyons' cause cannot have been helped by the red card received by one of their skilful full-backs, Jasminder Matharu, in the league last Saturday. 
 Matharu is likely to incur a suspension of two or three months. 
 The other cup tie on Sunday pits Eastcote of the South League against East Grinstead at Feltham School. 
 The fitness of Clift and Leman, who has had influenza in Pakistan, is important for Grinstead. 
 Eastcote, who have just acquired an Australian coach, Mark McCrea, have a team who are almost entirely the product of their successful colts scheme. 
 The other outstanding cup tie, between Old Loughtonians and Broxbourne, has been arranged for Sunday week because Broxbourne are involved in the last of the East qualifiers for the Royal Bank English Indoor Championship. 
 Hull put Proctor on list at &pound;15,000. 
 HULL yesterday placed their forward Wayne Proctor, who toured with Great Britain in 1984 and was substitute against Papua New Guinea, on the transfer list for &pound;15,000, writes Paul Fitzpatrick. 
 Also on offer, at the same price, are Neil Puckering, who played four times for the Great Britain Under-24 side, and Alan Tomlinson. 
 Swinton have reduced the asking price on six players, including the winger Derek Bate, who has had his price cut from &pound;45,000 to &pound;35,000. 
 Castleford have placed their winger Chris Chapman on the transfer list at &pound;45,000. 
 Squash Absent Cumings faces disciplinary action. 
 By Richard Jago in Newcastle 
 ALISON CUMINGS, a former British title-holder, faces disciplinary action from the Squash Rackets Association for withdrawing from this year's national championships at Newcastle yesterday &bquo;because of an unfavourable draw which might have meant me losing money on the week.&equo; 
 Her action has again raised the issues of lack of sponsorship and reduced prize money which have preoccupied many leading players. 
 Geoff Williams, another former holder, and Phil Whitlock, an England international, have both declined to play because they are disappointed with the marketing of the championships and by the fact that the prize fund has descended from &pound;16,780 to &pound;9,000 despite the presence of television. 
 Another international, who preferred to remain anonymous, claimed that two thirds of the top 24 would have gone on strike had they been asked, and that a players' union will soon be formed to help deal with matters such as prize money, rankings, training and selection. 
 Four years ago seven leading men threatened to boycott the event because they considered the prize money too low. 
 If a union creates a better understanding, so much the better. 
 The SRA has put several thousands of pounds into this year's event and believes that the failure to acquire a sponsor is related to an adverse market. 
 &bquo;Over the years the players have done incredibly well from the national championships and have had higher prize money than a lot of international events,&equo; said the SRA's squash manager, Andrew Shelley. 
 &bquo;We are mystified at Alison's action because she had already entered. 
 I'm afraid I don't regard being unable to make money from the event as a reasonable excuse.&equo; 
 One of the North of England's leading women players, Julie Woodcock, 23, the Cheshire champion, from Northwich, has been killed in a car accident near Buxton, Derbyshire. 
 Jones searches for chinks of light in a dark age for women's tennis David Foot on a former champion and her bright sparks aiming high in Cardiff. 
 WOMEN's tennis in this country is apt to be seen as a jokey disaster area, lost cause and eternal outlet for false and flimsy dreams. 
 Amid these cliches, sly slanders and unavoidable realities, Ann Jones sits at the net and ponders. 
 She has watched and sighed at the conveyor belt of busted rackets and aspirations &mdash; as successive decades of dewy-eyed schoolgirls have emerged from the manicured suburban court retreats in the romantic search for more than strawberries at Wimbledon. 
 The National Sports Centre for Wales, Sophia Gardens, Cardiff is temporarily deserted between matches in the Maureen Connolly Trophy. 
 Ann Jones is the Great Britain captain, soon we imagine to succeed Sue Mappin as national women's team manager. 
 She is both martinet and mother hen. 
 And she is engagingly old-fashioned in her concepts. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid we've gone a bit too soft,&equo; she says with almost Blimpish fervour. 
 &bquo;Girls come up against an obstacle or two, maybe on tour, and they tend to give way instead of trying to overcome them.&equo; 
 She contemplates a surprisingly bellicose analogy: &bquo;sport in its own way is another war &mdash; somehow we must regenerate the old fighting spirit.&equo; 
 She is privately perturbed, though not entirely unsympathetic one suspects, with recent words of disenchantment from Valda Lake, the 21-year-old Devonian who feels there may in future be more joy, if less money, in being an art student. 
 Lake's sentiments looked pretty damning in print. 
 But in the artificial, unrelenting competitive world of perpetual travel and token nods across the net, there isn't too much time &mdash; or inclination &mdash; left over for real friendship. 
 Who can see Martina sharing a dinner party with Steffi? 
 Jones, Wimbledon winner, respected referee and, just as significantly, mother of three, confines herself to: &bquo;It's very tough, not helped in our girls&equo; case by the computer. 
 Those in the States may have to travel long distances for tournaments but it's still in their own country.&equo; 
 On the broader issue of Britain's minimal success &mdash; despite two successive triumphs against the rankings in the Maureen Connolly Trophy, at the Queen's Club, London, and at Dallas &mdash; the captain spreads her hands, searching one empty base-line and then the other for the elusive answer. 
 &bquo;If only we knew why, we'd do something about it. 
 Whatever some think, we don't sit back. 
 People criticise the LTA but we've really tried. 
 It's been very gratifying to win these last two trophies &mdash; yet disappointing that there hasn't been improvement in the general standard of our girls&equo; tennis afterwards.&equo; 
 The captain has the kind of severe, rather schoolmarmy face that readily softens. 
 &bquo;Just like Sue, she doesn't mince words,&equo; someone says under her breath. 
 But she's refreshingly strong on psychology. 
 &bquo;In a team event like this, the difficulty from my point of view is the varying personalities of the girls as they go into the consecutive matches. 
 Val, for instance, needs chatting up&hellip; 
 Sarah needs concentration&hellip; 
 Clare is well motivated, one of those who takes advice quite well.&equo; 
 Off court, handling the obligatory press conference, these still young competitors are almost without exception pleasant and self-possessed. 
 The same goes for Americans like 16-year-old Kim Kessaris. 
 Sarah Loosemore is Britain's youngest at 18, just back from her three A levels and injury, eager to prove she has never really been away. 
 Her home is 10 minutes away, here in Cardiff. 
 Her parents, dad a solicitor and mum a former Welsh international, are watching with her brother as she beats Jennifer Santrock. 
 Lake, who is getting out, has taken a bit of a battering and feels that her spontaneous outpourings the other day were probably misconstrued. 
 &bquo;The trouble is that there is such a high level of expectancy,&equo; she says. 
 This was compounded in her case when she jumped 20 places on the world computer in 1987 after reaching the third round at Edgbaston. 
 Today Great Britain's No.1 for the Trophy, Clare Wood, a vicar's daughter from Sussex, takes on Amy Frazier, who is 140 places above her in the rankings. 
 She's heartened by her win over the Americans' No.2 Audra Keller, who also outranks her, on Wednesday. 
 &bquo;I desperately wanted to go on the circuit &mdash; I still find the life terrifically exciting. 
 It's difficult to keep in touch with friends and I know I can't go wild socially. 
 But as long as I go on improving and enjoying myself I'll play. 
 &bquo;I've noticed the difference in the mental approach of the foreigners. 
 They seem much more secure, happier with themselves. 
 They don't worry like we seem to but don't ask me why. 
 I was a bit surprised at what Valda said. 
 Relationships are often shallow but that's inevitable, especially between the countries. 
 There has got to be rivalry and life can be very frustrating.&equo; 
 Women's tennis has always had its administrative uncertainties. 
 This week the future structure of the Wightman Cup is being discussed. 
 But here at Sophia Gardens, a nap hand of British girls have in their different ways been doing their best to tell us something about the game they play&hellip; and offering a few hints of hope for the future. 
 Dave Whelan, 53, who played for Blackburn Rovers and broke a leg in the 1960 FA Cup final, has offred &pound;100,000 to any youngster born within 10 miles of Wigan parish church who wins the junior Wimbledon title in the next 10 years. 
 Whelan, now a millionaire businessman, said: &bquo;A town that can produce world class rugby league and swimming stars should also be able to produce a tennis legend of the future.&equo; 
 Squash Jansher jolted by fine and forfeit. 
 By Richard Jago 
 JANSHER KHAN narrowly avoided a ban but was fined for the second time in six weeks by the International Squash Players Association yesterday &mdash; and lost ranking points which may cost him his world No.1 spot. 
 The world champion may not be worried about the &pound;500 fine handed out for throwing the last game of his bizarre straight-games loss to Jahangir Khan in the final of last month's Stuttgart Open, but he should be more concerned at the zero computer points assigned him for the Stuttgart tournament, which may enable Jahangir to overtake him in the New Year rankings, plus the fact that any further misdemeanour will probably mean draconian punishment. 
 The ISPA says it is determined to take &bquo;strong action&equo; against individuals who &bquo;fail to commit themselves to raising the image of professional squash players&equo;. 
 Jansher, who was already on probation after being fined &pound;200 for walking out of the Kuala Lumpur World Open dinner in October, has clearly reached a point of no return with his conduct. 
 Meanwhile, the British national championships at Newcastle saw their first upset when the England international Martin Bodimeade fell 9-5, 9-2, 9-3 in the second round to the Scottish No.2, Colin Keith. 
 Later Jason Nicolle, the 10th seed and one of England's world team bronze medallists, also went out, losing 10-8, 9-2, 6-9, 9-4 to the 18-year-old Peter Marshall. 
 After their match the victorious Welsh No.1, Adrian Davies, and the British under-21 champion, Stephen Meads, complained about their referee, Ed Johnson, and alleged that the financial cutbacks because of sponsorship problems had affected the standard of officiating. 
 &bquo;The best referees ought to be here, but some of them are not because the SRA is cutting back on everything,&equo; said Davies. 
 Soccer David Lacey in the Eternal City on the hopes, fears and ephemera surrounding this afternoon's World Cup lucky dip. 
 INTO THE HAT &mdash; 24 NATIONS WITH THEIR EYES ON ROME 
 Nobody gets to be drawn until the fat guy sings 
 THERE is something rather symbolic about the presence of Sophia Loren at today's draw in Rome for the 1990 World Cup. 
 One or two of Miss Loren's films have been more notable for the depth of cleavage displayed than any profoundness of plot. 
 Similarly the draw will attract as much interest for those it keeps apart as those it brings together. 
 The seedings have already lessened the chance of the principal characters in next summer's month-long soap opera getting in each other's way until the latter stages. 
 The placing of Uruguay and Colombia in the third pool has satisfied the South Americans, and what used to be called the Iron Curtain countries cannot complain. 
 All that remains now is for the draw, which will be made in the Rome Sports Palace late this afternoon, to avoid such minor irritations as Holland joining England in Sardinia, thereby doubling the security problem; Scotland renewing hostilities with Uruguay, whom they have refused to meet in friendlies since the 1986 World Cup; and Austria playing West Germany, which would revive memories of the cynical conspiracy in 1982 which froze Algeria out of the second phase. 
 Rest assured that whatever happens the proceedings will be above board. 
 &bquo;Innocent fans,&equo; said Sepp Blatter, the general secretary of Fifa, would be making the draw from an assortment of pots. 
 Luciano Pavarotti will be there to strike the right note for an occasion of speeches, publicity films and general hype that is costing &pound;1 million and will be seen by a worldwide television audience of 500 million. 
 The draw itself is expected to last no more than 10 minutes, although there is always the chance of the sort of hiccup that occurred before the 1982 tournament when Belgium and Scotland ended up in the wrong groups &mdash; and there was the embarrassed re-examination of screwed-up slips of paper such as might be seen when the vicar's wife wins both the turkey and the hamper in the Christmas raffle. 
 By the time the draw takes place the audience will have had an eyeful of Loren and an earful of Pavarotti, who was once a deep-lying centre-forward and is now roughly the same shape as the ball. 
 If England could organise the draw to their liking they would probably play Austria, Colombia and Costa Rica in the first round. 
 However, they are just as likely to get the Soviet Union, Uruguay and South Korea. 
 The Scots would be extremely unlucky to get a 1990 equivalent of Mexico's &bquo;Group of death&equo; when they found themselves facing Uruguay, West Germany and Denmark. 
 Andrea Arrica, head of the local World Cup organisation in the Sardinian capital Cagliari, has dismissed worries about English hooliganism, saying that England's prestige as a footballing nation meant more to Sardinia than a potentially troublesome minority. 
 Cagliari is calling the exercise Operation Friendship; the local gaol awaits dissidents. 
 Fifa gives Chile World Cup boot and life bans. 
 By David Lacey in Rome 
 CHILE were thrown out of the 1994 World Cup by Fifa yesterday after forcing their decisive 1990 qualifier against Brazil to be abandoned in Rio when their players walked off claiming that the Chilean goalkeeper, Roberto Rojas, had been injured by a flare. 
 Fifa banned Rojas from all football for life and announced a list of suspensions of Chilean officials, culminating in the ban from the next World Cup, which will be hosted by the United States. 
 Sergio Stoppel, president of the Chilean FA at the time, has been banned from involvement in football for life. 
 Orlando Aravena, the national team coach, has received a life ban from international soccer and a five-year ban at domestic level. 
 The team doctor, Daniel Rodriguez, gets a life ban for submitting a fraudulent medical certificate detailing Rojas's &bquo;injury&equo;; and Fernando Astengo, Chile's vice-captain who led the players off the pitch in the Maracana, has been suspended for five years. 
 The team physiotherapist, Alejandro Koch, has been banned for a year because, in Fifa's words, he was &bquo;an accomplice of the doctor&equo;, as has the kit man, N Maldonado, because &bquo;he got rid of the gloves and jersey of the goalkeeper&equo;. 
 Fifa is awaiting action from the IOC and the Chilean government against the doctors of the Chilean Olympic Committee and the national forensic medical service, all accused of supplying phoney medical certificates. 
 The Chilean FA has also been fined &pound;42,000. 
 Fifa had already fined the Brazilians a minor sum for crowd disorder. 
 Brazil, who had drawn a stormy match 1-1 in Santiago in mid-August, were leading 2-0 in Rio in September when a woman fan released the flare which landed near Rojas but plainly did not hit him. 
 Nevertheless the goalkeeper played dead, blood appeared from somewhere and the Chileans refused to continue. 
 Sepp Blatter, the secretary general of Fifa, has described Rojas as &bquo;a mediocre actor&equo;. 
 The 1991 World Youth Cup, which was going to Nigeria until they were caught fielding someone over age, will now take place in Portugal. 
 Argentina will not enter the Rous Cup in May, leaving England to play only Uruguay at Wembley. 
 Both countries will be hoping to avoid one another in today's World Cup draw. 
 England will play two friendlies in Sardinia, when they will hope to drum up local support, before their final warm-up against Tunisia on June 2. 
 Soccer Sardinia ceded to England's record. 
 By David Lacey in Rome 
 ENGLAND made their expected landfall in the 1990 World Cup yesterday, leaving Scotland and the Republic of Ireland to drift towards whatever fate the draw has in store for them in Rome tomorrow. 
 Bobby Robson's team, having been seeded at the head of Group F, will play their three first-round matches in Cagliari on the island of Sardinia. 
 Andy Roxburgh's Scots have been placed in the second-draw section, along with Spain, the Soviet Union, Austria, Yugoslavia and Holland. 
 Jack Charlton's Irish, in the finals for the first time, join Colombia, Uruguay, Czechoslovakia, Romania and Sweden in the third pool. 
 In the end, and in spite of prolonged speculation to the contrary, there was never much doubt either that England would be seeded or that they would begin the World Cup in Cagliari. 
 Turning Sardinia into a Mediterranean Alcatraz to prevent hooliganism would have looked a little silly if Belgium had gone there instead. 
 Bert Millichip, the FA chairman, claimed that the decision to seed England in Cagliari had been made purely for footballing reasons. 
 &bquo;It had nothing to do with security,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There was never any doubt that England would be seeded&hellip; &lsqb;it&rsqb; was based on our record in the last two World Cups. 
 &bquo;With all our problems, we have to be happy with the situation. 
 Sardinia is a lovely island. 
 Let's hope it's still a pleasant place when we leave it.&equo; 
 Spanish attempts to get themselves seeded ahead of England came to nothing. 
 &bquo;If Spain were upset,&equo; said Millichip, &bquo;they didn't say anything. 
 In fact on the basis worked out for the seedings, we came fifth out of six.&equo; 
 In spite of what Millichip believes, the need to minimise the possibility of trouble from England's fans has everything to do with their playing in Sardinia. 
 The Italian interior minister had already stipulated that this was the only way he could guarantee the security of the World Cup. 
 However, if England do progress beyond the opening round &mdash; and with the first two from each group plus the four best third-placed teams going through, it is going to take some wretched performances to fail &mdash; they will then travel to Bologna, Genoa or Turin for the second phase, with the prospect of visits to Naples, Rome or Florence in the quarter-finals. 
 The semi-finals will be in Naples and Turin with the final in Rome on July 8, so the further England go the more complex the security problem will be. 
 No England team have ever gone beyond the last eight in a World Cup played abroad, and the significance of their seeding this time will only become clear after tomorrow's draw. 
 However, they do know that winning Group F might give them an easier game in the second round (against the runners-up in Belgium's group) than they would earn by finishing second, when they would face the second-placed side in Argentina's group. 
 If they finish third they might have to play Brazil. 
 &bquo;There has been no manipulation of the seeding,&equo; Millichip insisted, sounding like a character from a Bateman cartoon (&bquo;The Man Who Thought The Draw Was Straight&equo;). 
 Maybe yesterday's groupings were not actually bent, just massaged to satisfy World Cup convention. 
 For example, Uruguay were put in the third pool to avoid a possible conflict of South American interests with Colombia. 
 Nobody will want Uruguay as third team in a group, least of all Scotland after their Mexican experience against them. 
 The Republic of Ireland could be in England's group, as they were in last year's European Championship. 
 Robson may prefer Colombians, Czechs or Romanians, and at least with the Swedes you can be reasonably sure of a goalless draw. 
 All the top seeds will want to avoid Holland, the European champions, and the Soviet Union, who finished runners-up. 
 But nobody will complain if they get Austria or Scotland, and Spain would be preferred to Yugoslavia. 
 Cameroun and South Korea are the teams to avoid from the fourth pool. 
 Certainly England will not complain if they are confronted with Costa Rica, and 1950 is a sufficiently dim memory now not to have bad vibes about the United States. 
 Yesterday's proceedings were not entirely cut and dried. 
 The organising committee took four hours to announce the seedings and draw order, much of the time being taken up trying to persuade West Germany, who had assumed they were going to Verona, to switch to Milan at the last moment. 
 The problem stemmed from Turin's &mdash; and therefore Fiat's &mdash; demand for an attractive seed to grace the city's new stadium. 
 Belgium did not fit the bill so it was decided to move Brazil (who were to have played in Milan) to Turin, bring West Germany to the rebuilt San Siro Stadium and send the Belgians to Verona. 
 The West Germans objected strongly but it was all smoothed over and so they will have a trio of Internazionale players &mdash; Matthaus, Klinsmann and Brehme &mdash; starting the World Cup on their home ground while Belgium, who at one stage were being threatened with Sicily, are at least promised the occasional cooling breeze in Verona. 
 Rowing Red Alligator over its hurdle as The Banshee falls at the first. 
 By Jon Leyne 
 CAMBRIDGE University's Boat Race trials were derailed yesterday when one of the three crews hit a floating sleeper on the Thames at Putney, tearing a long gash in the hull. 
 But with a third crew, in the shape of a freshmen's eight, participating for the first time, the race was restarted and the freshmen were beaten by the surviving senior eight by just over two lengths from Putney to Mortlake. 
 The three crews, all named after former Grand National winners, made their first attempt at the unsocial hour of eight in the morning. 
 On Surrey, The Banshee contained the president, Paddy Mant, while this year's other remaining Blue, Guy Pooley, was in Red Alligator in the centre. 
 The freshmen, on Middlesex, were named after Foinavon, the 100-1 outsider that came through to win the National after most of the runners had fallen. 
 It was a jibe that nearly became a prophecy, though Cambridge were left with more of a one-horse race. 
 The Banshee came to grief two minutes off the start while lying third, a length down on the leader, Red Alligator. 
 Its rudder and fin were both knocked out, and a four-foot-long gash in the shell meant even repairs on the bank were out of the question, reinforcing complaints about the lack of driftwood clearance on the river this year. 
 After the restart it took Red Alligator longer to break clear of the freshmen. 
 The Red crew gained a length by the mile post and 2 &frac12; by Hammersmith Bridge, but the freshmen hung on to lose by about the same margin, six seconds behind Red Alligator's winning time of 19min 46sec. 
 Mark Lees, the Cambridge coach, knows the Light Blues face a serious deficit of talent this year, compared with Oxford's three world bronze medallists and strong supporting cast. 
 He may be tempted to poach some of his promising-looking freshmen to strengthen Goldie, or even the Blue boat. 
 Meanwhile, Oxford and London Universities are to put their goods on view in trials next week. 
 Golf Hare coursing for a 66. 
 Rob Bonnet on the ordeal of qualifying school at La Manga 
 AT THE La Manga club in Spain this week there is not a hacking holidaymaker in sight. 
 Two hundred and eight golf professionals &mdash; some reigning champions, others young rookies &mdash; have been competing for 50 places on next season's full European Tour. 
 By Wednesday the 208 had been reduced by 100 after four rounds, the cut having come at four over par. 
 Later this morning, after two more rounds, a further 58 will be excluded. 
 Some of the 50 who win their cards are likely to have done so by surviving a sudden-death play-off: careers are launched, and sometimes sunk, on the accuracy of a three-foot putt on the 109th green. 
 Bad weather has prolonged the tension by half an extra day. 
 Among those already out of their misery is Richard Fish. 
 He is used to it, though; this is his 11th failure in 12 years of trying. 
 He missed the four-round cut by two strokes, but he left the course with a cheery &bquo;See you next year&equo;. 
 Jackie Nicklaus carries the burden of his father's name and knows it does not hit golf balls for him. 
 He too will have to try again. 
 Failure has driven some in the past to tears, but for the moment the 22-year-old Andrew Hare, from Sleaford, Lincolnshire, is quietly showing the bright-eyed optimism of the first-timer. 
 He made the cut by three strokes, and in qualifying for the final two rounds he has already guaranteed himself a place on next season's growing satellite tour, Europe's golfing second division. 
 That is already progress. 
 He only turned professional 12 weeks ago after helping to beat the United States in the Walker Cup this summer. 
 His amateur career started at the age of 12 with a father's encouragement and a set of women's irons. 
 Two and a half years later he was a four-handicapper, but then he broke his leg in two places playing football and missed a whole season. 
 His handicap went up to six. 
 He has not turned out for the village team since. 
 Hare's sights are set high, but he thinks it best not to listen to those who predict a bright future for him. 
 &bquo;I had a bonus at this year's Open, a practice round with my hero Bernhard Langer. 
 You expect fire to come out of the back of his ball when he hits it, but his ball's flight is no different to mine. 
 So it brings you on level terms.&equo; 
 Hare did admit to Ian Wright, who caddied for Seve Ballesteros, that he would feel intimidated if Wright carried for him at La Manga. 
 Wright told him: &bquo;Don't be so silly; it's immaterial.&equo; 
 His caddie instead is &bquo;Baldrick&equo;, Richard Owens from Sleaford who got his nickname from Hare's request on the practice ground for more ammunition. 
 Owens may not know the course intimately, but he knows Hare's game, which relies on consistent direction off the tee and accuracy on the green. 
 Here the latter has been wanting: &bquo;I know it sounds daft. 
 I've putted well but haven't holed anything.&equo; 
 Today's final cut for the last 50 seems likely to fall at one under par. 
 Hare will need a three-under in his final round to make it, but is aiming for a six-under 66. 
 As for the game itself, Hare has a philosophy which might make the rest of us win. 
 &bquo;No disrespect to a 20-handicapper. 
 When you watch them you think it almost looks pointless. 
 But it isn't; it's the good rounds that bring you back. 
 My lowest ever is a 62; my aim now is a 61. 
 The better you get, the more you want to play. 
 I love the game.&equo; 
 After yesterday's fifth round, four players shared first place. 
 Heinz Peter Thuel of West Germany, Steven Bowman of the United States and England's David Ray and Christopher Williams were 15 under par on 345. 
 Rob Bonnet is the BBC TV News sports correspondent. 
 South Africa's David Frost and the Americans Scott Hoch and Tim Simpson scored five-under-par 67s yesterday to share the lead after the first round of the Million Dollar Challenge at Sun City, Bophuthatswana. 
 Frost scored five birdies on the back nine to catch Hoch and Simpson. 
 They each had 32s on the front nine, including eagles at the par-five 9th, and 35s coming in. 
 No one else in the field broke par. 
 Vauxhall in the vanguard. 
 By Russell Thomas 
 VAUXHALL LEAGUE teams could well be in the vanguard of the non-League assault on England's top clubs when the FA Cup third-round draw is made on BBC1 tomorrow night. 
 With three clubs &mdash; Aylesbury, Basingstoke and Woking &mdash; in today's second round, the Vauxhall League boasts the same number of representatives at this stage as the GM Vauxhall Conference. 
 The BBC cameras will concentrate on the games at Basingstoke and Whitley Bay, but there is plenty of opportunity for non-League rejoicing elsewhere. 
 Northampton's County Ground could be the scene of one upset for the visit of several old boys &mdash; including the manager, Trevor Gould &mdash; in the ranks of ambitious Aylesbury, the Vauxhall Premier leaders. 
 Gould, brother of Wimbledon's Bobby, has just signed a new five-year contract. 
 He reckons his best chance of managing a Football League team lies in &bquo;taking Aylesbury there&equo;. 
 Basingstoke's Camrose ground is preparing for a record 4,000-plus crowd for the visit of Torquay, whose chances of survival have been reduced by the flu bug in their camp. 
 Trevor Williams, Basingstoke's manager, can call on a full-strength squad apart from the defender Sandy Baird, injured in the last round. 
 Fred Callaghan, the Woking coach and London cabbie, directs his Vauxhall team to Cambridge United confident that his full-strength squad will not lose their way as they did last season in falling 4-1 to the Fourth Division side. 
 Whitley Bay attempt to take the HFS Loans League banner into tonight's draw at the expense of Preston. 
 Even without the suspended Chris Scott, whose goal gave them their win at Scarborough, the home side's manager Bobby Graham believes his men will claim another League victim. 
 Fulham have been ordered by the FA to go ahead with their tie at Bristol City, even though flu has claimed most of the first team. 
 Ray Lewington has named a squad of 14 although, he said, &bquo;in normal circumstances only three would be considered. 
 I'll be playing, so will &lsqb;assistant manager&rsqb; Gary Peters, and neither of us should be near the team sheet.&equo; 
 Wembley cuts ticket prices. 
 WEMBLEY has cut some of its ticket prices by half in an attempt to ensure a respectable crowd for England's friendly against Yugoslavia next Wednesday. 
 Seats in the new Olympic Gallery, which cost &pound;40 each for last month's game against Italy, have now been reduced to &pound;20. 
 The maximum price for other seats is &pound;15, with the cheapest at &pound;5. 
 Richard Gough will make his comeback for Rangers tomorrow only six weeks after shattering his jaw in four places. 
 The defender, hurt in a collision with Hibernian's Pat McGinlay, will be in the Scottish champions' line-up against Motherwell at Ibrox. 
 Neath banned from touring. 
 By David Plummer 
 THE Welsh Rugby Union has banned Neath from touring abroad for three years because they walked off the pitch in a pre-season friendly in France last August. 
 Neath were playing against Brive in a quadrangular tournament involving Toulouse and Bath. 
 Three forwards were believed to have been sent off, two from Neath and one from Brive. 
 At the time Neath said they walked off in disgust after 35 minutes because their lock Gareth Llewellyn was told he could continue until the interval but would then be sent off. 
 Two players had allegedly already been banished for fighting. 
 But when the French official submitted his report to the WRU, only Llewellyn was cited for foul play. 
 On the basis of that report the union has disciplined Neath. 
 However, the WRU is seeking clarification from the French Rugby Federation before dealing with Llewellyn. 
 It wants a more detailed report, but Llewellyn, though free now to continue playing, will eventually be subject to the same disciplinary measures as a player sent off at home. 
 If the union found against him, that would indicate a minimum four-week ban, ruling him out of Wales's opening home championship match against France next month &mdash; unless, that is, his case were dealt with within the next fortnight. 
 The WRU has appointed a four-man committee of inquiry to look into the events surrounding the centenary tour of South Africa last August. 
 It will be chaired by a QC, Vernon Pugh, with the union's honorary solicitor John Evans as his assistant. 
 The other members will be two erstwhile presidents of the union, Desmond Barnett and Glyn Morgan. 
 The WRU has ruled that none of its players will be given permission to take part in the centenary tour of Natal planned for next summer. 
 Fit again Barnbrook can give the weight away. 
 By Richard Baerlein 
 TODAY'S excellent programme at Cheltenham has not been ruined by the hard ground to the extent which at one time appeared likely and there are two bonus runners, namely the champion hurdler, Beech Road in the Charles Heidsieck Champagne Bula Hurdle, and the Queen Mother Two Mile Champion Chase winner Barnbrook Again in the A.F.Budge Handicap Chase. 
 David Elsworth is lucky to have such a superb performer as Barnbrook Again in his string at the same time as Desert Orchid. 
 Barnbrook Again was unbeaten last season and there was something radically amiss when he fell on his reappearance at Kempton for which there has never been a satisfactory explanation. 
 However, he fully redeemed himself next time out at Newbury when he gave 2st to Springholm and beat him with a bit in hand. 
 Barnbrook Again is being trained for the King George on Boxing Day, when he will take on Desert Orchid. 
 Today's event is his tuning-up race and he has not got an easy task. 
 However, he will be fitter and more able to cope with the ground than the form book danger, Rusch de Farges, whom he beat three lengths last season, but the latter has an 8lb advantage. 
 Earlier in the week Pipe was not sure to give his Gold Cup candidate a race on the firm ground but the stable is in tremendous form and the inmates do not seem unduly affected by the state of the ground. 
 Clever Folly has made great improvement this season, winning three of his five races and he is only 1lb out of the handicap. 
 He has already proved he can win on the ground and he beat Repington five lengths at Huntingdon last week. 
 Joint Sovereignty won over the course and distance winner when getting up to beat the smart Golden Freeze a neck in the Mackeson Gold Cup. 
 He finished three lengths in front of Dudie, who is 4lb better off. 
 The top chasers have a habit of being able to give weight and a beating to their more humble rivals and although Barnbrook Again appears to have been given a stiff task in conceding 8lb to Rusch de Farges, his two runs already this season should give him the advantage. 
 The Bula Hurdle is likely to have a considerable influence on the ante-post market for the Champion Hurdle, for which Beech Road at present shares the 5-1 favourite spot with Kribensis. 
 The latter started favourite for last year's Champion but proved no match for Beech Road, though he is expected to become a stronger horse this season. 
 For one who is better with some give in the ground and who is having his seasonal debut, Beech Road will find a super-fit Cruising Altitude, receiving 6lb, a big task. 
 Cruising Altitude has put up two really smart performances this season both at Newbury. 
 First he beat Tom Troubadour, who has won since, and then he slammed Morley Street in the Gerry Fielden. 
 As a result he is down to 7-1 third favourite for the Champion and the way he is improving he could end up shorter still. 
 Barry Hills is expecting his Cesarewitch winner Nomadic Way to reach the top in due course but his one run this season hardly suggests he will beat Cruising Altitude receiving only 4lb. 
 He is only 1lb better off for about ten lengths. 
 Osric gets 12lb from Beech Road and 6lb from Cruising Altitude, which puts him in with a chance. 
 Past Glories suggested he is on the way back when third to Kribensis in the Fighting Fifth at Newcastle, while Floyd is not quite up to it in the highest class these days. 
 As Cruising Altitude is at his very best and is favoured by the weights they will find him very difficult to beat. 
 The Mercury Communications Challenge Hurdle has tempted Jonathan Sheppard, the leading N.H. trainer in America for the past 17 years, to bring over Jamaica Bay together with his 21 year old college girl rider, Blythe Miller. 
 The challenge began last year when the Americans could not win here and the English could not win in America. 
 Now Jamaica Bay can collect a &dollar;100,000 bonus for winning the Sport of Kings Challenge on both sides of the Atlantic. 
 He won the first leg at Nashville. 
 Blythe Miller, in her first full season, is proving a very able rider. 
 Although Jamaica Bay likes the fast ground, he faces a very formidable rival in Toby Balding's Morley Street. 
 This five-year-old was only beaten once in five outings last season. 
 On his seasonal debut he was beaten six lengths by the very fit Cruising Altitude. 
 Martin Pipe saddles Tel-Echo, who looked a promising prospect last season when only given two outings. 
 He was second on his debut at Leicester but went back to that track to win by 20 lengths. 
 He could be a danger. 
 Deep Sensation is a horse with a future, probably over fences, but I doubt if any of them will be able to beat Morley Street. 
 At Doncaster Mr Frisk, who came to the last fence in front in the Hennessy Gold Cup, should gain compensation in the Constant Security Handicap Chase, and Red Ruddel can gain his fourth consecutive victory of the season. 
 Richard Baerlein's selections: Nap: Cruising Altitude (1.20 Cheltenham). 
 Next best: Morley Street (2.30 Cheltenham). 
 PAGE 
 Leonard keeps more money than friends in a farce of fistic folly John Rodda in Las Vegas on how the battle between two greats ended as a sad stalemate. 
 ASTRATEGY for winning, but not winning friends, took Sugar Ray Leonard to the prize and to his first &dollar;100million from boxing. 
 But his world super-middleweight title fight with Roberto Duran, ushered in with an awesome display of fireworks to mark the opening of the largest resort in Las Vegas, turned out to be a stalemate in styles, a fistic folly in which the two outstanding exponents of the Eighties brought the decade to a close amid booing and jeering. 
 Nine years ago when the pair met in Montreal, Leonard taunted his opponent to the limits of frustration and Duran walked out after eight rounds calling: &bquo;No mas.&equo; 
 There were derisory calls of a similar kind from the crowd long before the eighth round on Thursday as the fighters went to their corners after another three minutes of little more than dancing. 
 Strip the argument for boxing down to its bare elements and you find Leonard producing exactly the fight required. 
 But somewhere along the line the input of those on the other side of the ropes, many there for the price of &dollar;800 (&pound;500), has to come into the account and the argument is faulted. 
 Boxing at this level is up on stage with show business and this kind of performance does not count as entertainment. 
 A pair of young fighters who come into the ring and fight a contest of this kind would have had the referee boxing their ears and offering such terse words as &bquo;get in there and fight&equo;. 
 Indeed Bob Arum, the promoter, who put it all down to a conflict of styles, recently dismissed his ranked middleweight Michael Nunn for such a negative performance. 
 But this was a world-title fight by two of the greatest world champions and the only contribution from the referee, Richard Steele, was to pull them apart. 
 This brought the bitter words from Duran, &bquo;How can I win in America &lsqb;a hint that the political climate between Panama and the United States is also manifested in boxing&rsqb; when Leonard's Siamese twin is the referee?&equo; 
 Although that is overkill in defence of his part, Duran had some cause to grumble that the referee instantly pulled the pair apart when Duran forced a clinch. 
 It was from those situations that he was likely to salvage something and draw Leonard into a fight. 
 Each round was a photocopy of the previous one, Duran edging forward, Leonard moving backwards and the space between them constant. 
 The speed of hands stamped the most vivid contrast on the encounter, for in each session Leonard took time out in his backtracking to whip in the jab and later the left hook to win the judges' favour. 
 Nine years ago and several times since, Duran had shown the difficulty he has in fighting someone who is on the retreat. 
 This time his 38-year-old legs were not quick enough to cut off the corners and trap his quarry for even the slightest roughing-up. 
 Yet if Leonard's fleet feet were still part of his youthfulness, there were signs of bodily frailty; he bore the only real wounds of the contest, a cut to the lip sustained early on and a more serious one over the left eye in the 11th round. 
 But it was a fight in which no one &mdash; apart from the punters &mdash; suffered any real pain. 
 By the third round Leonard was producing a replay of their last contest, taunting Duran by thrusting his head forward, safely out of range, and then winding up his right hand with the threat of a bolo punch. 
 He stared wide-eyed, then turned aside and looked disdainful while the grizzled, worn features of Duran were screwed up to hide his frustration. 
 By the fourth round the crowd was jeering. 
 It turned to booing and some chanted expletives by the eighth, when Leonard, clearly mastering the fight, won points with some superb counter-shots but then pulled back from driving in the wedge. 
 He caught Duran with a solid left hook and when Duran grabbed for cover Leonard wanted to get out and back to his sniping post. 
 That is when the crowd felt cheated; Duran had come to fight, Leonard only to win, and since the tactic was working why change it? 
 &bquo;By the third round I knew the fight was going my way,&equo; Leonard said. 
 The judge, Jerry Roth, gave every round but the final one to Leonard. 
 Bob Logist had the first and the last round drawn and the remainder for Leonard, while Joe Cortez gave the fourth, fifth, ninth and 10th rounds to Duran to produce the narrowest margin, 116-111. 
 The statistics showed the disparity in more stunning form: Duran connected with only 84 punches in the 12 rounds but threw 588, a percentage of 14.3. 
 Leonard's workrate overall produced 438 punches, of which just over half hit the target. 
 According to The Mirage Resort, the gate receipt from the crowd of 16,000 was a world record of &dollar;9.1million (&pound;6m), which seems slightly suspect since that works out an average of &dollar;500 before one takes account of the undisclosed figure of complimentary tickets. 
 The most resilient part of the boxing business is the promotional side, and no doubt it will recover from the barrage of criticism that will pour on this contest. 
 But modern boxing has a more sensitive audience, one that never goes to the arena but watches at home on the television. 
 If they switch off and the closed-circuit figures drop, the present heady economics of it all begin to crumble. 
 No one this time was talking about the next fight. 
 &bquo;I want to go home to my family and Christmas,&equo; Leonard said. 
 Positive thinking will have to wait a while, but it augurs well for one of the young ringsiders who turned up in his smartest suit and said: &bquo;What a disgusting fight; I wish I'd worn my tracksuit.&equo; 
 This was fighting pride from Nigel Benn of Britain, who produces the sort of middleweight action the punters want to see: knockout punching. 
 Whether the men of the Eighties want to risk their ageing bodies against such threats, only the Nineties will reveal. 
 Boxing White Hopes like Cooney do not have a prayer of toppling Tyson. 
 John Rodda meets Max Schmeling, 85, and ponders: Where are his peers today? 
 THE oldest fight story of them all, the Great White Heavyweight Hope, has turned up here again. 
 Max Schmeling, who became the darling of the Nazi Party by being the first man to defeat Joe Louis, was feted in one of those boxing nostalgias which try, on the side, to thumb the nose at the American Medical Association and other such clinical societies concerned about brain damage. 
 Schmeling, a sprightly, dignified 85-year-old, is certainly an argument that some fighters come to no harm, even those who suffer the sort of beating Louis meted out when the pair met again. 
 Among those at the party was Muhammad Ali, who unlike Louis has, so far, not sunk to being doorman at Caesars Palace; he just stands in the Mirage Hotel at the head of a never diminishing human snake, signing his autograph. 
 Parkinson's Disease seems to be marking time at the moment. 
 With Ali at the honouring of Schmeling was Mike Tyson, a reminder that these days there is not much hope for any White Hope. 
 But a mile off The Strip, on a trading estate, the Top Rank gym bubbles with fighting action and gossip and, with a bit of a strain, the White Hope theory is being nurtured. 
 At 33, Gerry Cooney is cranking up to beat another golden oldie, George Foreman, who is 41, in Atlantic City next month under the promotion banner The Preacher and The Puncher. 
 Foreman, winner of three world heavyweight title fights in the early Seventies, is best remembered for his part in the one he lost: &bquo;The rumble in the jungle&equo; in Kinshasa, Zaire, when Ali knocked him out. 
 Now he is a minister of a church in Houston, where among the prayers he offers is one to be allowed to fight Tyson for the world title. 
 There are thousands, not of his flock, who are praying that he will not. 
 Cooney can fulfil their wish by cutting him down in their Atlantic City conflict, without inflicting the harm of which Tyson is capable. 
 Cooney always seemed a reluctant fighter, a man more pushed into the business by parental desire and promoters who saw the advantage of his size &mdash; 6ft 7in &mdash; rather than his personal predicament. 
 It is 2 &frac12; years since he lost in a world title match to Michael Spinks and just as he did after a similar fight, with Larry Holmes, he brooded for a long time, finally overcame problems with drugs, and went into business, part of which was as a fight promoter. 
 He put on one of the Foreman return contests &mdash; though even he would admit now that the word contest is stretching credibility. 
 For this latest return to the ring he has linked with Foreman's former trainer, Gil Clancy, who admits it is going to be hard getting Cooney back into shape. 
 He is using middleweight and light-heavyweight sparring partners in an attempt to make Cooney work faster, but in the session I watched he was not quick enough. 
 &bquo;It was one of those rough days,&equo; Cooney admitted with a bruise under his left eye and a shining, tight patch of skin on his very large nose. 
 His monotone drawl made one feel he is not yet convinced that he has the mental application to match his great physical ability. 
 Cooney cuts out talk about Tyson with: &bquo;I'll take one fight at a time.&equo; 
 But toppling Foreman will start a bandwagon at a time when, with one exception, the heavyweight division is bereft of talent and ability. 
 Hockey Pakistan 4, England 1. 
 English defence again porous 
 ENGLAND suffered the same fate in the second Test with Pakistan in Lahore as they did in the first, losing heavily. 
 A 4-1 defeat was marginally better than the 5-1 setback on Tuesday against the side who will be England's key rivals for a semi-final place in their World Cup group in February. 
 Martyn Grimley (Hounslow) scored England's goal with a well-struck penalty corner shot in the 54th minute, immediately after England had conceded a third goal. 
 Both teams included their second goalkeepers and made two other changes from the first Test. 
 England were able to start with their captain Richard Leman and gave an outing to Don Williams. 
 Pakistan brought in Qasim Khan and Zahid to their attack. 
 English observers felt England had improved and that they dominated periods of the game but were let down by defensive errors. 
 The forwards exerted pressure from time to time, with Thompson and the substitute Garcia both going close to scoring. 
 Once again the umpiring, by two Pakistanis, left something to be desired, but Pakistan are a fit and talented young side with players of flair. 
 Bhopali, breaking through the middle, gave them the lead after 16 minutes, and England again conceded a goal immediately after the interval. 
 An unforced error by Faulkner gave away a penalty corner which was converted by Saeed Anjum. 
 In the 52nd minute England had two chances to clear before the second-half substitute Qamar Ibrahim scored. 
 He added his second goal four minutes from time. 
 PAKISTAN: Shahid Ali Khan; Qasi Mohib (capt), Khalid Bashir; Saeed Anjum, Farhat Khan, K M Junaid; Qasim Khan (Qamar Ibrahim, 47min), Tahir Zaman, Arif Bhopali, Zahid Sharif (Shahbaz, 31), Wasim Feroze. 
 ENGLAND: S Rowlands (Havant); P Bolland (Hounslow), D Faulkner; R Hill (both Havant), J Potter, M Grimley (both Hounslow); D Williams (Havant; R Garcia, Havant, 47), R Leman (East Grinstead, capt; Soma Singh, Southgate, 55), C Mayer (Cannock), R Clift (East Grinstead), N Thompson (Old Loughtonians). 
 Umpires: Rashid Ali Khan and K N Bajwa (both Pakistan). 
 Today three of the feeder competitions for the National League &mdash; the East, North and West Leagues &mdash; complete their pre-winter break fixtures, writes Pat Rowley. 
 Firebrands have a six-point lead in the West before meeting Swindon. 
 Chelmsford must beat Pelicans to be sure of heading the East League at the break. 
 For Preston, the North leaders, merely beating Bradford will be no guarantee of retaining top place in the AW Yarns competition since Ben Rhydding and Alderley Edge have the same number of points. 
 Territorial encroached on all fronts. 
 THE end may be in sight for the annual Territorial Championship, whose post-Christmas slot is the least acceptable in the women's fixture list. 
 The once eagerly awaited tournament, a highlight because of its purpose as England trials, is suffering the effects of progress, writes Janet Ruff. 
 No longer used for England selection purposes, the event has been trimmed, condensed and diminished, and apart from upholding a vestige of regional pride is now becoming lost in the mists of tradition. 
 The England training squad, with the World Cup on their minds, have been barred, and other players are pursuing alternative attractions during a well earned Christmas break. 
 The venue, Silksworth, near Sunderland, is as usual for this championship neither central nor convenient for the majority. 
 This year there is one further change, the backing of a sponsor, and the NatWest Cup to play for. 
 The tournament, which starts on December 28, is run concurrently with the Under-21 Territorial Championships, an event that has rather more significance as an England trials showcase. 
 The East, who have won the title for the past two years, are the defending champions and they select their squad this weekend, as do the South. 
 With their squads already chosen, the North, Midlands and West get down to concentrated coaching. 
 Rugby League Bettinson dismissal leaves doubt over Reilly. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 THE management team which has built the most successful Great Britain side since the Seventies was broken up yesterday with the dismissal of the 54-year-old Les Bettinson, team manager since 1985. 
 Malcolm Reilly, reported to be &bquo;shocked&equo; by Bettinson's dismissal, has been offered an up-graded title of coach/ manager while Maurice Lindsay, the Wigan chairman, replaces Bettinson and assumes the title of tour director and business manager. 
 Bettinson, a director of education in Stockport, had booked an appointment with his superior yesterday to ask for the unpaid leave he would have needed to complete the tour of Papua New Guinea and New Zealand next summer. 
 He was under the impression that the renewal of his contract was a formality. 
 Bettinson is a man of considerable dignity, diplomatic and not given to emotional language. 
 But he was a hurt and disillusioned man yesterday. 
 &bquo;Now I know how Julius Caesar felt on the steps of the Senate before he was stabbed in the back,&equo; Bettinson said. 
 There will be no shortage of sympathy for him. 
 Bob Ashby, the chairman, said that Bettinson's contract had expired &bquo;and we wanted the best man for the job&hellip; and that is Maurice. 
 His position on the board of directors is immaterial. 
 Maurice has a proven track record with Wigan&equo;. 
 Lindsay, who said that he had no idea he would be offered the job, pledged his support to Reilly, saying that he was &bquo;firmly behind the decision to ask Malcolm to continue as he is obviously the best man for the job&equo;. 
 Lindsay said that Reilly could rely on his &bquo;unswerving support as he is a man I have the highest respect for&equo;. 
 But will Reilly now accept the post? 
 What seemed a formality on Wednesday looked less certain 24 hours later, and he himself hinted at a possible obstacle when he said he would have to get the permission of his employers, the brewers John Smith. 
 If that permission were not forthcoming, he said, he would have to reject the job. 
 Then there is Phil Larder, the third member of the management team which led Great Britain to victory over Australia in Sydney last year and to a 2-1 series win over New Zealand recently. 
 It is not now certain that he will be invited to join the tour next summer, nor is it certain that he would accept if he were. 
 Rugby Union Harriman coughs, Smith wings in. 
 THE England and Wasps wing Simon Smith has been called up by London for their divisional match against the South-West at Imber Court tomorrow. 
 He replaces Andrew Harriman, of Harlequins, who became another flu victim. 
 Smith should have been on the bench for London's game against the Midlands last Saturday but had to drop out with the same complaint. 
 Midlands have also made a late change. 
 Tim Buttimore replaces Gary Hartley in the centre against the North at Moseley. 
 Hartley has infected vocal cords. 
 Buttimore has only recently returned to top rugby in England after two summers in Australia. 
 While there he was called up by the England squad when the touring team ran into injury trouble last summer. 
 Nigel Heslop of Orrell replaces Tony Underwood, who broke his jaw against the South-West last weekend. 
 The Neath lock Mike Whitson has been given an eight-week ban after being sent off in a Schweppes Cup tie against South Glamorgan Institute. 
 He was dismissed by the Brecon referee David Cherry for punching. 
 Whitson, who was also sent off while playing for Newbridge three years ago, will miss the next tie against Ystrad Rhondda and seven Merit Table club games. 
 Rugby Union Romanians relish their underdog role. 
 By Robert Armstrong 
 SCOTLAND meet Romania at Murrayfield today in a match which should be a useful warm-up for the forthcoming Five Nations Championship. 
 Given the substantial gap in standards between Scottish club rugby and the international arena, the Scots, who do not play their next game until February 3, clearly need all the match practice they can get at the highest competitive level. 
 While the form and ability of the players in action today is probably too well known to give this fixture the aura of a trial, Scotland will relish the chance to test their mettle against Romania's key areas of strength. 
 Traditionally the East European side offers a solid challenge in the set-pieces and keeps theoretically superior opponents under pressure with prodigious line-kicking from their experienced fly-half, Ignat. 
 It will be intriguing to see whether Romania's rather conservative tactics will be altered under their new manager, Mircea Paraschiv, and new coach, Florin Popovici, who both took over last month. 
 Defeat by the Soviet Union in the autumn was a traumatic experience for the Romanians, who responded by dismissing their coach, Theodor Radulescu, who is also the father of Alexander, the captain of the beaten side. 
 Paraschiv, a former international scrum-half who was involved in a 28-22 victory over the Scots in Bucharest five years ago, believes that Romania have more potential than this year's mediocre results indicate. 
 Wins against Western Samoa and Zimbabwe at the start of this season helped to restore a little confidence after the 58-3 humiliation by England in Bucharest last May. 
 It remains to be seen whether the role of unfancied underdogs suits Romania at Murrayfield as their manager appears to think. 
 This year Scotland have won all their home games, against Wales, Ireland and Fiji, scoring nearly 100 points in a style brimful of colour and movement. 
 Today's target will be a minimum of 30 points. 
 Of course, since the early Eighties, Romania have demonstrated periodically that they are capable of upsetting complacent opponents with a committed, well organised pack, allied to the ability to kick long-range goals. 
 Their 15-9 victory over Wales at Cardiff Arms Park last December was beyond dispute the most significant result they have ever achieved on foreign soil. 
 The Scots, though, are more likely to recall their 12-6 victory over Romania on their last visit to Murrayfield in 1981. 
 That score was close enough to justify Scotland's decision to accord the game full international status but it will be a considerable surprise if they fail to win by at least 20 points today. 
 Meanwhile the Toshiba Divisional Championship moves into its second phase with the holders, London, playing host to the South-West at Imber Court while the Midlands entertain the North at The Reddings. 
 If London and the North both win, as expected, then the stage will be nicely set for a north-south shoot-out in their final game at Otley next Saturday. 
 South-West were dealt a blow yesterday when their England flanker Andy Robinson pulled out after falling victim to the &bquo;flu epidemic. 
 He is replaced by Ian Smith who completes an all-Gloucester back row. 
 It will be crucial how Redman and Etheridge perform in the line-out against London's Ackford and Edwards. 
 The pressure on the Richmond fly-half, Martin Livesey, who makes his first appearance for the South-West, will also be significant. 
 The North have both the motivation and the coordination behind the scrum to brush aside a rebuilt Midlands team. 
 Dewi Morris and David Pears form a half-back partnership of genuine enterprise and aggression &mdash; exactly the qualities needed to feed the northern taste for fast-moving attack on a broad front. 
 The Midlands hooker Brian Moore returns after injury and the 6ft 10in lock Martin Bayfield should also have something to say when Dooley and Kimmins stake their obtrusive claim in the line-out. 
 SCOTLAND: G Hastings (London Scottish); A Stanger (Hawick), S Hastings (Watsonians), S Lineen (Boroughmuir), L Renwick (London Scottish); D Wyllie (Stewart's-Melville), G Armstrong (Jedforest); D Sole (Edinburgh Academicals, capt), K Milne (Heriot's FP), P Burnell (London Scottish), C Gray (Nottingham), D Cronin (Bath), J Jeffrey (Kelso), D White (London Scottish), F Calder (Stewart's-Melville). 
 ROMANIA: M Toader; B Serban, A Lungu, G Sava, S Chirila; G Ignat, D Neaga; G Leonte, V Ion, G Dumitrescu, S Ciorascu, C Raducanu, O Sugar, I Doja, H Dumitras (capt). 
 Referee: S Hilditch (Ireland). 
 Cricket Sky and BSB are at home. 
 By Mike Selvey 
 THE tentacles of satellite television are spreading even wider, even unto the English domestic scene. 
 Yesterday at Lord's the Test and County Cricket Board announced separate deals involving both Sky TV and British Satellite Broadcasting for the transmission of a large segment of the domestic game for the next three years. 
 In what can only be considered a plan of Baldrickian cunning, not only will the Board's coffers be groaning with the weight of money but &mdash; and here is the really clever part &mdash; fewer people than ever will now be able to observe what a mess the game is really in. 
 The deals are in fact important in the way the game is to be projected in the future in this country. 
 Already Sky TV is exclusively showing the winter series live from West Indies (with Geoff Boycott the newest recruit to the broadcasting team). 
 Now both Sky and BSB have extended their interests to include the 1990 and 1991 domestic seasons as well. 
 Perhaps the more significant of the deals is that involving BSB, which launches five new channels in the spring. 
 In a two-year deal, believed to be worth more than &pound;1 million, they will enjoy, if that is the right word, exclusive live coverage of the Benson and Hedges Cup as well as a highlights package including all England's home Tests, one-day internationals and the NatWest competition. 
 The latter package is designed to be broadcast during the peak viewing hours of 8pm and 10pm when the BBC has traditionally been unable to do it. 
 Andrew Croker, head of BSB's sports channel, sees this as a bonus for cricket fans. 
 &bquo;With the highlights package, now at last they will be able to see the best cricket at the time they will want to watch it.&equo; 
 Peter Lush, who handled the TV negotiations on behalf of the TCCB, added his support. 
 &bquo;The deal will benefit both the cricketing public and the Benson and Hedges competition, with more matches covered live and viewers enjoying a wider choice during peak hours.&equo; 
 The BBC still has its live coverage of the international matches and the NatWest Trophy, and it will also be screening highlights of the other matches but of necessity these will appear at the usual anti-social hours. 
 It is debatable whether Sky for its part has bought a pig in a poke. 
 It will be reviving memories of summers past by transmitting ball-by-ball coverage of the Refuge Assurance Sunday League. 
 In previous years this was how the BBC treated the competition, but gradually, with its revamped Sunday Grandstand, cricket took a back seat to free-fall dominoes and the like. 
 This appeared to please neither public nor sponsor. 
 Now Sky, with promised aggressive coverage, can put it back on an equal footing with the other competitions, although a more compelling argument for reviving the Sunday afternoon walk in the country it is hard to imagine. 
 Testing baptism for Chamberlain. 
 IF Frank Chamberlain, chairman elect of the Test and County Cricket Board, had any qualms about taking on the job next October, they will have been magnified by his introduction to the massed press at Lord's yesterday, writes Mike Selvey. 
 The first question he was asked was how he intended to overturn the &bquo;deceit and deception&equo; rife in the TCCB. 
 This turned out to be a reference to the secrecy surrounding the use of Ossie Wheatley's power of veto as chairman of the cricket committee to block the reappointment of Mike Gatting rather than David Gower as England captain last summer. 
 Chamberlain coughed politely and said he was sure it would be cleared up by the time he took over. 
 He said he would be trying to bridge the gap between the board and the counties, who he thought &bquo;perhaps felt they weren't having enough say.&equo; 
 Not least, it had been surmised, with the veto. 
 However the board's chief executive, Alan Smith, was able to say that unlike yesterday's press conference the issue at the board meeting did not occupy a major part of the time. 
 &bquo;They fully endorsed the right of Wheatley to use the veto at his discretion.&equo; 
 Smith added that the board did not subscribe to the view that the authority of Ted Dexter, chairman of the England Committee, and Micky Stewart, the team manager, had been undermined by the veto. 
 The nub of the meeting had been a lengthy discussion on the merits or otherwise of four-day cricket, while matters decided on were the 25-point penalty for producing inferior pitches, retained with wider definition to include over-grassed pitches; overseas players (counties may register up to two for next season only); a return to 15-yard run-ups in the Sunday League; and the making up of lost time in Tests to a maximum one hour. 
 Sport in brief Cricket. 
 Geoff Boycott is one of an 11-strong coaching team assembled by the England manager, Micky Stewart, to help prepare this winter's touring sides to West Indies and Zimbabwe. 
 The team, which also includes the former England players Alan Knott, Don Wilson, Geoff Arnold, David Lloyd, Bob Cottam and Norman Gifford, will conduct a five-week programme at six indoor centres. 
 Golf. 
 Hopes of golf making an Olympic comeback in 1992 failed yesterday when the IOC ruled against its inclusion as an exhibition sport in Barcelona. 
 Athletics. 
 Linford Christie, back from warm-weather training, runs in the 60 and 200 metres at the Scottish indoor championships in Glasgow this weekend. 
 Billiards. 
 Peter Gilchrist, a 21-year old Teessider, retained the British Open championship by beating the former world champion Norman Dagley 1,166-1,008 in the four-hour final in Leeds. 
 After breaks of 222, 213 and 116 in the afternoon his best was 73 in the evening but he held off Dagley, who had one of 252. 
 Sport in brief Athletics. 
 Steve Jones will run for the first time in the Morpeth-Newcastle, Britain's oldest road race, on New Year's Day.. 
 Skiing. 
 Vreni Schneider, Switzerland's defending World Cup overall champion, could be out for two weeks after suffering a knee injury during downhill training in Colorado.. 
 Golf. 
 Britain's Chris Moody is joint second after yesterday's first round of the Australian Classic in Melbourne, where Peter Senior extended his remarkable run with eight birdies to lead with a seven-under-par 65. 
 Senior has won the Australian Open and Australian PGA title in the past month. 
 PAGE 
 Reynolds earns Davis return. 
 By Clive Everton 
 DEAN REYNOLDS, whitewashed by Steve Davis in the Rothmans Grand Prix final, made a break of 112 to clinch his 9-7 win over Tony Meo last night which gives him a return meeting with Davis in today's quarter-final of the Everest World Matchplay Championship at the Brentwood Centre. 
 Dennis Taylor recovered from 1-4 to beat Mike Hallett 9-5 and will play John Parrott. 
 Birdman Reed will not duck the issue David Hopps on the Aylesbury &bquo;Rambo&equo; who is set to ruffle Northampton's feathers. 
 THE only Aylesbury Ducks likely to be found at The County Ground tomorrow will be an increasingly celebrated strain decked in green and white hoops. 
 Aylesbury's footballers have progressed to the second round of the FA Cup &mdash; and an away tie at Northampton Town &mdash; without a flutter of recognition from the whiter-than-white duck which provides their nickname. 
 &bquo;Duckie&equo; Weston, a renowned local breeder, was an Aylesbury follower in his time, and one confused bird did waddle aimlessly around the ground a few seasons ago, but according to the club's chief executive, Tony Graham, &bquo;they are a devil of a mascot to parade about.&equo; 
 Could there be, though, a more sinister reason for tomorrow's absence of the Aylesbury duck? 
 Prepare for a far-fetched tale of a prospective bird-breeder called &bquo;Rambo&equo;, a burly former Yorkshire miner who admits he prefers his ducks buried under a mountain of cranberry sauce. 
 It was the fate of countless unfortunates a few seasons ago to become the terraces' substitute for Sylvester Stallone. 
 One jolting tackle and the link was made with the big screen's violent he-man. 
 Northampton Town's followers bestowed the well-meant, if dubious, honour on Graham Reed, a vigorous and gritty right-back. 
 Reed disarmingly describes himself as &bquo;nearly six feet tall and 13 stones when I'm at my best&equo;, but the banners appeared in force all the same. 
 Northampton romped away with the Fourth Division championship in 1986-87 and whenever Reed had an off-day his manager, Graham Carr, loved to scoff: &bquo;Rambo? 
 More like Bimbo.&equo; 
 Reed proved not indestructible. 
 His League career ended prematurely last season when he lost three pieces of bone in an operation on his right ankle. 
 Daily training became too demanding but non-League football offered an alternative outlet for a player approaching his 28th birthday and, in June he moved to Aylesbury. 
 With too much spare time suddenly on his hands, he reverted to a hobby enjoyed in his early non-League days with Frickley Athletic. 
 In Brixworth village, just outside Northampton, he has built an aviary at the bottom of the garden. 
 He keeps canaries, diamond doves and a pair of quails. 
 Aylesbury were taking stock of a cheerless season when Reed was signed by Trevor Gould, the elder brother of Wimbledon's manager, Bobby. 
 The club's first experience of the Vauxhall Conference had brought immediate relegation. 
 Traditionally members of the Southern (now Beazer Homes) League, they were allotted a place in the Vauxhall League, which they head by two points, and Gould takes a healthy smattering of former Northampton players back tomorrow. 
 The manager played more than 100 matches for the Cobblers in the early Seventies and, living three miles from the ground, he remains conveniently placed to keep tabs on potential signings. 
 Two months ago he paid Northampton a club record fee of &pound;15,000 for Glenville Donegal, and the striker's winning goal against Southend United in the FA Cup first round ensured an immediate homecoming. 
 Donegal was hardly overcome by romantic notions. 
 &bquo;My friends all say what a great draw it is, but I'm not sure,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I quite fancied going somewhere different.&equo; 
 Under Gould's guidance, Aylesbury's FA Cup record could hardly be more consistent. 
 They have reached the first round for the fifth successive year, although once admitted they initially quailed like nervous party-goers. 
 Watford drew a crowd of 7,500 to Turnfurlong Lane in 1951 and, by the time Gould broke a 34-year abstinence, plans were being formulated to turn the evocatively named ground into a housing estate. 
 Aylesbury lost a home replay to Slough in 85-86, fell at Bath the following year, then made a respectable 1-0 exit at Ashton Gate against Third Division Bristol City. 
 Last year they went one better, overcoming Waterlooville before losing 1-0 at home to Sutton in the second round. 
 Gould, a self-employed builder, put his craft to good use when Aylesbury transferred four years ago to waste ground off Buckingham Road, on the outskirts of the town. 
 The manager built both dugouts. 
 He must be a fair-minded fellow. 
 Rival managers have been relieved to confirm that the away dugout does actually face the pitch. 
 Crowds hover a touch above 1,000 this season but up to twice that number will make the trip to Northampton. 
 At least one banner will proclaim: &bquo;Rambo rules.&equo; 
 It will be carried by one of Reed's neighbours, a Northampton supporter. 
 He is still a child, but old enough to understand about old times' sake. 
 Sole at the heart of Scotland for many years to come Robert Armstrong on the consummate skills of the new national captain. 
 WHEN Ian McGeechan made his oft-quoted remark in Australia last summer that David Sole was &bquo;a player 10 years ahead of his time&equo;, the Lions' coach neatly summed up the collective view of the touring party. 
 Sole is one of those rare front-row forwards whose remarkable range of skills not only makes him a complete footballer but also brings fresh possibilities to the way the game can be played at the highest level. 
 In short Sole is a front-row radical for the Nineties. 
 Talk to Finlay Calder, the man Sole has succeeded as captain of Scotland, and you are left in no doubt about the respect Sole enjoys among his peers. 
 &bquo;We are all very proud of David,&equo; says Calder. 
 &bquo;You name it, he's got it: courage, skill, pace, commitment, the lot. 
 He is probably the most complete player I have ever seen and certainly the best front-row forward in the world. 
 &bquo;Some players may be stronger than David but nobody can live with him in terms of all-round ability. 
 His pace is astonishing. 
 When I first came across him in 1982 he was playing for Exeter University in a sevens game at Twickenham. 
 I thought, &bquo;Who is this awkward little bastard?&equo; 
 If Scotland had eight David Soles in their side today I for one would not be there.&equo; 
 Clearly Sole, at 27, is young enough to double or even treble his total of 20 caps. 
 Given the small nucleus of genuine international players at Scotland's disposal, his influence as leader and player will be crucial in the Five Nations Championship. 
 In Scotland's club atmosphere the captain invariably creates the prevailing mood. 
 He emerged as a shrewd captain in Australia, leading the Lions to victories over New South Wales B and an Anzac XV. 
 When his friend Calder took an autumn break, Sole skippered Scotland for the first time, in a 38-17 win against Fiji at Murrayfield. 
 Last month he combined the roles of coach and captain on behalf of the Barbarians who lost 22-10 to the All Blacks at Twickenham. 
 Characteristically he reflects: &bquo;It was no bad thing that the Baa-Baas had to prepare without an official coach: it forced the players to think a great deal more for themselves. 
 We could have used more than a couple of training sessions, though, to prepare to meet a team of the All Blacks&equo; calibre.&equo; 
 Sole will renew auld acquaintance with the Kiwis when Scotland tour New Zealand next May. 
 When you put it to Sole that his approach to captaincy is more intellectual than gung-ho he laughs: &bquo;Well, I am not a Finlay Calder by any means. 
 But the job of captain remains the same: you have to work in with the coaches, motivate the players and gain their respect. 
 It's nice to have the same players available from last season, but I think it will be a lot harder this time because the other home countries have got to know us better.&equo; 
 Sole, of course, came to the attention of leading English players some time before he won his first cap against France (an 18-17 win) at Murrayfield in January 1986. 
 In his final year at Exeter, where he took a degree in economics and agriculture economics, he joined Bath just as the Avon club started to take off on its four-year domination of the John Player Cup. 
 &bquo;It's a good place to learn your rugby,&equo; recalls Sole. 
 &bquo;Everyone wanted to beat Bath, and the games were always hard. 
 &bquo;I played in the 1987 cup final win against Wasps, but I don't remember much about that game because I got concussed in the opening 10 minutes. 
 When I came back to Scotland I found that generally the standard of club rugby was lower.&equo; 
 Even so Edinburgh Academicals have provided Sole with a solid platform from which he has gone from strength to strength, culminating in three Tests and a series triumph for the Lions. 
 In his first season as an international Scotland shared the championship with France, and in the 1987 World Cup Sole gave a prodigious performance in a 20-20 draw with the eventual finalists France. 
 McGeechan believes that Sole has set standards of performance with his pace and mobility in the loose which only a handful of British players, such as Brian Moore of England, are currently emulating. 
 &bquo;David has very high skill levels, and his driving is as good as anything else in his game,&equo; he explains. 
 &bquo;In the past 12 months his play has come more and more to dominate phases of the game, especially against Wales and Ireland. 
 Quite often David has stepped up the tempo and provided tries for someone else. 
 I think he will do well as captain.&equo; 
 Off the field Sole also recently switched roles, resigning from his job with an Edinburgh wine merchant to work as a grain buyer for United Distillers. 
 Ultimately he hopes to return with his wife and infant son Jamie to Aberdeenshire where his father &mdash; who used to captain Cambridge at hockey &mdash; runs a small farm. 
 Meanwhile the Sole family plan to spend a fortnight's holiday in Florida before David girds up for Scotland's challenge in the Five Nations. 
 &bquo;It's always a fantastic experience to pull on a Scotland jersey and run out at Murrayfield: I get a tremendous buzz from that,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;But I am very competitive, and I love winning too, though it's very important how you win.&equo; 
 As far as winning in style is concerned, Scotland can be sure their future is secure in the hands of David Sole. 
 A cosmetic change to alter the face of the offside rule Talking point. 
 By David Lacey 
 FROM time to time Fifa, the governing body of world football, comes up with ideas for improving the game, some better than others. 
 So far nobody has taken up the suggestion that since goalkeepers have become bigger, scoring would be made easier if the goals themselves were enlarged. 
 This week Fifa revealed the possibility of a less spectacular but rather more sensible change of law. 
 From next season an attacking player who is in line with the last defender when the ball is played up to him may no longer be offside. 
 Perhaps the alteration appears slight, no more than cosmetic, but it would make a considerable difference to defensive attitudes, especially in Britain, without undermining the spirit of the offside law. 
 At the moment the defender organising the line in a flat defence finds it easy to catch an opponent offside. 
 He knows that as long as everybody stays level with the leading attacker they can just step up when the ball is played and the linesman's flag will be raised. 
 Supposing, however, the defence has to cope with attackers pushing up just far enough to catch them on the turn and stay onside. 
 Playing the offside game would become a riskier business, especially against forwards with the pace of Lineker or Rush, who would be given the benefit of the doubt which at present goes to defenders. 
 The increased speed of the modern game and the athleticism of the participants has led to more crowded play so that linesmen are apt to flag when a forward suddenly breaks clear to receive a pass. 
 This happened when England played Italy at Wembley last month. 
 Donadoni split the England defence with a beautifully timed lob and Carnevale darted through to beat Shilton, only to find the flag against him. 
 Television showed he was onside and under the revised law it would have stood a better chance of being allowed. 
 Occasionally fans write in to demand that offside be abolished altogether. 
 This might be an understandable reaction in someone who has endured an afternoon of flag and whistle, but it misses the point of why the law was framed. 
 If there was no offside, games would be confined to packed goalmouths and creative football disappear. 
 The last major alteration to the offside law was made in 1925 when it was decided that, instead of needing three opponents between himself and the goalline to stay onside, an attacker would need only two. 
 The initiative for the change was British: full-backs, working in tandem, were catching forwards offside so often that games were becoming boring and gates were going down. 
 The proposal to change the law in 1925 came from the Scottish FA which, by coincidence, is drafting the measure which is likely to be put before the International Board, the game's law-making body, during the World Cup next summer. 
 The four British associations each has a vote on the board, with Fifa having four of its own, which gives it the power of veto but guards against the laws being riddled with crackpot theories &mdash; such as making the goals bigger. 
 Another area of the offside law under examination concerns interfering with play. 
 There is a feeling that if the wording were changed to &bquo;seeking to interfere with play&equo; it would spare the player who is in an offside position but making a genuine attempt to stay onside by, for example, running back towards the halfway line. 
 However, this would demand a fine sense of judgment by referees. 
 Remember the riot that broke out at Leeds towards the end of the 1970-71 season when Ray Tinkler allowed a West Bromwich goal to stand, ruling that Colin Suggett, standing offside when the attack crossed the halfway line, had not been interfering with play. 
 Even if the word &bquo;seeking&equo; had been added, the bottles would still have been thrown. 
 Tennis Frazier finishes off Britain. 
 By Our Correspondent 
 GREAT BRITAIN last night handed the Maureen Connolly Trophy back to the United States after Anne Simpkin and Clare Wood, with contrasting performances, lost in the singles at Cardiff. 
 Britian went down 7-4 overall. 
 The match in which Simpkin lost 7-6, 6-2 to Audra Keller was a wretched affair, something to be endured rather than enjoyed. 
 The players' serving was appalling, with Simpkin reduced to an underarm on one occasion. 
 In the ninth game, with the score 4-4, the American hit four double faults. 
 Even so she almost got away with it, and four times had game point. 
 But Simpkin finally broke her to lead 5-4, then had two set points. 
 However, an excellent Keller volley and Simpkin's missed passing shot lost those. 
 Wood's match was of far higher quality, and although the Briton lost 3-6, 7-6, 6-3 to Amy Frazier she came within three points of defeating an opponent ranked 33 in the world. 
 Like Simpkin, Wood was let down by an erratic serve. 
 But she moved extremely well and rallied consistently with precision and confidence. 
 Her game shows enormous improvement from a year ago, and the indications are that her breakthrough into the top 100 will come soon. 
 Ann Jones, the team captain, is confident that Sarah Loosemore, who won both her singles, will join her there. 
 &bquo;The game is about guts and determination and the drive not to lose, and Sarah has the instincts to go for those shots,&equo; said Jones. 
 &bquo;She looks and moves like a winner.&equo; 
 The future of the Scottish grass-court championships, one of the warm-up events for Wimbledon, is in doubt after the Bank of Scotland yesterday withdrew its sponsorship because of &bquo;soaring costs&equo;. 
 Wolves go up for sale at &pound;4m. 
 By Russell Thomas 
 WOLVERHAMPTON Wanderers are up for sale at &pound;4million, just three years after the club were saved from extinction. 
 Wolves' owners, the Birmingham builders Gallaghers, earlier this week had a firm offer for the club, including a plan to develop Molineux. 
 Gallaghers bought the club for &pound;1.25million in 1986 after the receiver had been called in. 
 Now, with planning permission secured for a supermarket next to the ground, the site's value has soared. 
 The ground itself, owned by Wolverhampton council, is unlikely to be sold. 
 But the council would welcome offers to update the two sections closed for safety work. 
 Charlton's campaign to return to The Valley has hit a further problem with Greenwich borough council urging the club to revise their redevelopment proposal and come up with measures to protect the environmental needs of residents near the ground. 
 Roger Alwen, the club's joint owner, said: &bquo;We have given Greenwich the opportunity to lead British football into the 21st century. 
 After all their talk of wanting Charlton back, I'm amazed the decision-making process is so slow.&equo; 
 Charlton's directors hope to meet the leader of the council on Thursday to clarify the position. 
 Celtic are to reject a written offer from Newcastle, believed to be worth &pound;300,000, for Roy Aitken. 
 The Scottish club want considerably more. 
 Midwife at the birth of a state. 
 THE INTIFADA is a people's unarmed revolution against occupation. 
 Its two main slogans, repeated countless times in the directives issued by the underground leadership, are freedom and independence. 
 It has employed a dual strategy to achieve these two objectives. 
 First, a comprehensive civil disobedience campaign was begun by which people severed, or minimised, all the contact points by which they were bound to the Israeli occupation authority. 
 This campaign included resignations of Palestinian officials from public posts, the boycott of Israeli goods and products, and the refusal to pay taxes and fines. 
 Partial and full strikes, demonstrations, sit-ins, conventions&hellip; all these have in fact only constituted the outer layer of an inner mechanism of civilian rebellion. 
 The second, and complementary, part of the Intifada strategy concentrated on the construction of an indigenous national authority. 
 As Israel's authority was being lifted, the population began creating an alternative authority of their own. 
 Popular committees were established in villages, refugee camps, suburbs, streets, in fact in every community. 
 Some headway was made in expanding self-sufficiency, whether through utilising more land for agriculture, developing home economies, or encouraging local manufacturers and products. 
 Villages and refugee camps were thus being developed into &bquo;liberated&equo; or &bquo;independent&equo; areas, if not militarily, then at least psychologically, politically and infrastructurally. 
 Bloody clashes would occur whenever armoured units raided these villages, storming through makeshift defensive road blocks and responding to rocks being thrown with live bullets and tear gas; but no sooner would these army units be gone than authority would revert to the village residents. 
 Palestinian flags would be raised on minarets and church spires, road blocks would again be erected, and life in all its aspects would once again be run by the local leadership. 
 The structure of the developing national authority has been both diffuse enough to prevent it from being destroyed by any one single sweep of arrests (there have been more than 50,000 arrests since the Intifada's outbreak), and coherent enough to allow for the existence of a unified resistance strategy. 
 While the entire network of popular committees, local institutions and the general public constitute the field commanders in the battle of civilian disobedience and of constructing a political infrastructure, a rotating Unified National Command acts in the role of field-general, issuing a bi-monthly directive outlining policy and determining specific resistance programmes. 
 A high level of mobility in the structure allows for continuous interchange of roles and ideas, and retains for the Unified National Command the closeness to grass roots that is required to make it truly reflect people's wishes and sentiments. 
 THIS expanded network of popular committees and institutions making up the Unified leadership is infused by tens of thousands of activists who belong to, or identify with, the different factions of the PLO. 
 In effect, therefore, the PLO exists at all levels of organisation within the occupied territories. 
 Thus the Palestinian national movement both inside and outside the occupied territories is an organic whole. 
 The pattern of the Intifada has been cyclical. 
 Thrusts of resistance (mass demonstrations, resignations, tax rebellions, etc) would come in crests. 
 The pattern is determined by a wide variety of factors, including what the Israeli army does. 
 But the relation is complex, not uni-directional. 
 Harsh measures &mdash; putting an entire community under an absolute curfew for a continuous lengthy period of time, demolishing homes, uprooting olive or citrus trees, physical intimidation and terror tactics employed by raiding army units, shooting, killing, cutting off water or electricity supplies and telephone links to villages or towns, mass arrests, intimidatory interrogation techniques &mdash; can either create a temporary lull or activate an eruption. 
 The army never knows which it will be. 
 It is as if it is walking through a minefield. 
 The wave-like pattern of the Intifada, its pains and sufferings, are all reminiscent of the process of birth. 
 The metaphor is apt, as Palestinians regard themselves as engaging in a process of giving birth to their independent Palestinian state. 
 Through their revolution, the masses are both mother and midwife to the birth of this state. 
 The Intifada is the midwife of freedom. 
 Through it, Palestinians are struggling on a daily basis to shake off Israel's authority and to construct their own. 
 The struggle reflects a revolution in mass consciousness, by which people have come to realise that ideas and aspirations must be embodied in manifest acts if reality is to be changed. 
 Thus, wherever one looks, one finds people engaged in the construction of the blocks that will make up the Palestinian state. 
 It is a conscious effort. 
 The masses are being engaged in the craft of state-masonry. 
 In this process of state building, many stages have been covered. 
 The Declaration of Independence issued by the Palestine National Council (PNC) on November 15 last year constitutes a major landmark along this road. 
 Its significance lies in its double message: that the aim of the Palestinian struggle is the establishment of Palestinian independence, and that this independence is regarded as being not at Israel's expense. 
 This has been a constant theme of Intifada policy: that we wish to build (Palestine), not to destroy (Israel); that we wish to achieve freedom (for our people), not to deprive others (Israelis) of it; that we wish to protect and save lives (ours), not to endanger the lives of others (Israelis). 
 In one of several Intifada leaflets written in Hebrew and addressed to the Israeli soldiers on duty in the occupied territories, the message was repeated: Soldier, go home. 
 Return to your family and children. 
 Be with them in peace so that we may remain with our family and children in peace. 
 We do not wish to harm you, or your state. 
 We wish to be unharmed, in our own state. 
 How can the process of state building be developed? 
 If the PNC Declaration of Independence constituted a major landmark in this process, the time has come to embark on another major step, that of declaring the setting up of a state or government structure. 
 AN ESCALATION of the Intifada in this direction would serve two purposes at once. 
 First, it would consolidate the structures of the developing national authority which is competing to replace the occupation authority. 
 Second, it would consolidate the image and essence of the Intifada as a constructive, not a destructive, force. 
 Naturally, to embark on such a step is not necessarily to succeed immediately in realising it. 
 Rather, it is a challenge. 
 It will be a further challenge to Israel's occupation, conceived in the image of earlier challenges of the Intifada. 
 But it will also be a challenge to us, Palestinians, summoning us to work more energetically towards the idea's fulfilment. 
 It would be a natural extension of the Intifada's dual strategy towards disengagement from Israel, and the corresponding process of state building. 
 It would further naturalise and legitimise the evolving skeletal form of Palestinian independence. 
 It would provide the multitudinous popular committees and activities with a more advanced form of organisation and structure. 
 It would enable better planning and performance. 
 It would maximise civilian tactics of resistance and defuse the natural potential for violence, containing and eventually eliminating the marginal but intrusive phenomenon of collaborator activation by Israeli security authorities and collaborator execution by local Palestinians. 
 It would create a further fact that would put Israel on the spot. 
 Israel's reaction, however hostile, could only further our cause. 
 Arresting or deporting the tens of thousands of Palestinian professionals who would be employed in perfectly apolitical, harmless and humanitarian jobs can only further isolate the Israeli Government. 
 Half-way measures can only imply half-way success. 
 A modus vivendi would also imply success. 
 In general, our policy should be to proceed with building our state block by block, without waiting to be given a gift of it through negotiations. 
 We should regard negotiations rather as the means by which we could establish formal agreements between our state and Israel. 
 Such agreements can range from the issue of borders to the issue of free wave-lengths for our future television and radio networks. 
 In the meantime, we have the capacity to bring coherence and organisation to a whole range of activities, further consolidating the institutional linkage between the people in the occupied state and the PLO leadership. 
 Entire departments can be set up, in health, foreign affairs, agriculture, trade, finance, education, justice, religion, information and social welfare. 
 A pyramid administrative structure, establishing links from popular committees in villages right up to the Executive Committee of the PLO (in its capacity as a Cabinet), can be established. 
 During the Intifada the people have been engaged in building the side walls. 
 A government would provide the roof which would bring these walls together. 
 It would add another necessary touch in the process of creating a Palestinian home. 
 Sari Nusseibeh, a leading Palestinian intellectual, is professor of philosophy at Bir Zeit, the West Bank university closed by the Israelis early last year. 
 His ideas are widely influential among Palestinians. 
 Nusseibeh&hellip; 
 &bquo;The Palestinian national movement inside and outside the occupied territories is an organic whole&equo; PHOTOGRAPH: DAVID SILLITOE 
 The Intifada, now two years old, has brought the first chance for a civilised end to the Arab-Israeli conflict. 
 Could it be the last?. 
 Stones that shook the world &bquo;Patience, patience, patience&equo; said Yasser Arafat this week &mdash; the question is how long can patience endure? 
 David Hirst traces the development of the Palestinian uprising, and below Sari Nusseibeh, a leading West Bank intellectual, points to one way forward. 
 LIKE MANY great upheavals, it all began inconspicuously enough. 
 Two years ago today, an Israeli lorry driver ran over and killed four Palestinians in the Gaza Strip. 
 Youths took to the streets in protest. 
 They hurled stones, and thereafter stones &mdash; in place of the Kalashnikov &mdash; became the prime weapon and symbol of the &bquo;blessed&equo; Intifada which has transformed the whole nature of the Arab- 
 Israeli struggle. 
 If the outside world did not at first grasp its significance, the Israeli leadership positively refused to do so. 
 Defence Minister Yitzhak Rabin forecast that it would be all over &bquo;in one or two weeks.&equo; 
 A leading Israeli journalist was soon to ascribe that misjudgment to the &bquo;historic blindness&equo; that has always bedevilled Israeli governments and public, ensuring that developments which, to outsiders, might seem all but pre-ordained come as a very disagreeable shock to them. 
 It was particularly unfortunate this time. 
 The Intifada was perhaps the most convincing refutation ever of the time- honoured, complacent dogma that &bquo;the status quo can last as long as we want it to.&equo; 
 True, it was not so spectacular as earlier assaults on it, such as the Arab-Israeli war of 1973, so it is hardly surprising that Israeli leaders should have so contemptuously dismissed it, so patently failed to understand its revolutionary import: that, for the first time, the enemy was offering the prospect of the civilised, peaceful, negotiated settlement for which Israel had clamoured since its foundation. 
 In a very timely book, Israel's Fateful Decisions, published shortly before the Intifada broke out, the Israeli scholar, General Yehoshavat Harkabi, wrote that for a settlement to be possible, both sides must first renounce their respective dreams or &bquo;grand designs&equo; &mdash; for the Zionists, the &bquo;redemption&equo; of all the Land of Israel, for the Palestinians, the &bquo;liberation&equo; of all the territory that once was theirs &mdash; and thereby end what he calls the absolute, &bquo;existential&equo; nature of the struggle. 
 The &bquo;moderates&equo; on both sides, moved by their &bquo;common fear of the hell&equo; that otherwise awaits them, had to gain the upper hand. 
 That is precisely what, with the Intifada, the Palestinians have done. 
 Two years on, the Intifada shows little sign of abating. 
 It is a cliche to say that it has become a way of life, and that the stone-throwing is only the public, propaganda face of a whole political, social, economic and psychological transformation &mdash; the Palestinians' own perestroika &mdash; which both sustains the Intifada and lays the groundwork for the eventual transition to statehood. 
 It is deemed unthinkable that it should stop. 
 Too much hope, to much sacrifice, has been invested in it. 
 Two years on, the Intifada's aim &mdash; the two-state solution -remains &bquo;moderate&equo;, and, by and large, so do its non-armed methods. 
 Yasser Arafat sticks doggedly to the infinitely tortuous &bquo;peace process&equo;, never saying &bquo;no&equo; to the Americans, even though it is obvious to him that what the Israelis want is surely unique in the history of peace negotiations: to both set their agenda and to appoint the other side's representatives. 
 The basic trouble is that the Palestinians' historic espousal of &bquo;moderation&equo; has not won its indispensable and commensurate Israeli response. 
 Polarisation in Israel there certainly is, but if one applies the same broad definition of &bquo;moderate&equo; and &bquo;extremist&equo; to the Israelis as one does to the Palestinians, one cannot but conclude that precisely the reverse situation prevails among them, that it is their Jibrils and Abu Musas &mdash; or religious fundamentalists in the Hamas mould &mdash; who hold sway. 
 The &bquo;moderates&equo; are a small minority, while into the category of &bquo;extremists&equo; falls that whole band of opinion ranging from the tougher section of the Labour Party, through the Likud, to the outright fanatics, nationalist and religious, of the far right. 
 It is the outcome of a process which, for Harkabi, has its origins in the Israelis' overwhelming, intoxicating victory in the 1967 Arab-Israeli war. 
 It was then, just as the first signs of Arab flexibility appeared, that in Israel the notion took root that the renunciation of &bquo;grand designs&equo; was erroneous in its minimalism. 
 And judging by the public discourse, the government's negotiating strategy, and the army and settlers' day-to-day behaviour in the territories, the Intifada has made many &bquo;extremists&equo; more extreme than ever. 
 There is the growing allure of apocalyptic solutions. 
 Harkabi described the idea of a &bquo;transfer&equo; &mdash; the mass expulsion of Palestinians &mdash; as just the kind of project that is calculated to lend the struggle its absolute, &bquo;existential&equo; character. 
 One year after the Intifada began, some 49 per cent of the population favoured it; according to the latest poll, the number has now risen to 52 per cent. 
 AS FOR the government's negotiating strategy, Harkabi forecast that nothing would scare the &bquo;extremists&equo; like a readiness to talk from the other side. 
 Shamir and company persist, mulishly, in their contention that Arafat will always be Arafat; thus, according to the Deputy Foreign Minister, Benyamin Netanyahu, &bquo;the PLO says&hellip; flat out&equo; that it seeks &bquo;Israel's annihilation. 
 They don't say it on American television and maybe not in French, but they say it plainly in Arabic every day.&equo; 
 There is no evidence for this, which is probably why the quality of their argument can fall so low, with Shamir saying of perhaps the most influential and long-standing of PLO &bquo;moderates&equo;, Khalid Hassan, that &bquo;when you see his face you know he cannot be trusted.&equo; 
 If, as some Israeli &bquo;moderates&equo; argue, terrorism always was a marginal question, it is certainly infinitely less serious for Israel's future than the mass popular unrest of the Intifada, but by continuing to lump everything they can &mdash; such as children throwing stones &mdash; under its general rubric, the &bquo;extremists&equo; seek to &bquo;de- legitimise&equo; the Intifada, and evade any necessity for looking at its real causes. 
 The ordinary, everyday behaviour of army and settlers flows quite naturally from a government and a public which hold such views. 
 It is the ingrained contempt, the impulse, apparently deliberately inculcated, to humiliate which, in the eyes of enlightened Israelis, is perhaps more revealing, more frightening in its ultimate implications, than all the well-documented brutalities. 
 It is completely and increasingly &bquo;normal&equo; for soldiers to break into houses and mix food with cement; to leave excrement lying around; to turn the male population out in the middle of the night to clean the streets and sprinkle them with rose water. 
 Settler children shout at bus drivers: &bquo;Run them over, they are Arabs.&equo; 
 Graffiti says: &bquo;We shall eat the Arabs out of tins.&equo; 
 Those Israelis whom this behaviour most appals have long been likening it to the earlier stages of Nazism, an analogy that found startling vindication with the recent disclosure that some units in the occupied territories draw on Nazi precedents for their own self-image, one calling itself the &bquo;Mengele detachment&equo; and another &bquo;the Auschwitz company&equo;. 
 Palestinians who have tried to reason with the Israelis about the meaning of the Intifada find all this dispiriting. 
 But is hardly less distressing to Israeli &bquo;moderates&equo;, not merely because they find oppression of another people morally wrong, but because of its dangerously divisive effect on Israeli society itself. 
 One really wonders whether the wilder fringe of Israeli &bquo;extremists&equo; loathe their own &bquo;moderates&equo; any less than they do the Palestinians. 
 According to a recent poll, 58 per cent of Israelis believe there will eventually be civil war. 
 It is hardly surprising, in such a climate, that Israeli &bquo;moderates&equo;, like their Palestinian counterparts, should now look so earnestly to the third party, the US, as the only possible way of saving Israel from itself. 
 But will it? 
 So far, it seems to the Palestinians that the US listens less to the &bquo;moderates&equo; of both sides than it does to Israel's still very powerful, if increasingly defensive, champions, the Jewish lobby, its knee-jerk supporters in the Congress and the media, who are still ready to parrot the Israeli &bquo;extremist&equo; line that Arafat is, indeed, still Arafat. 
 It is not as if the Administration really believes that any more. 
 Weary of Israel's ceaseless importuning, it recently produced a long and scholarly &bquo;confidential report&equo; which concludes that, since Arafat told the UN General Assembly last December that he recognised Israel's right to exist and &bquo;renounced&equo; terrorism, the PLO has not been speaking with &bquo;forked tongues&equo; and its declarations have &bquo;for the most part been consistent, regardless of the media in which they appear.&equo; 
 Yet despite that authoritative vindication, the moment the PLO makes what might at first sight appear a slight regression to its old-style militancy, the US promptly joins the Israeli &bquo;extremists&equo; in pronouncing it a serious setback for the peace process. 
 Under pressure from Congress, &bquo;renouncing&equo; terrorism is no longer enough; the sincerity of the conversion has to be proved too. 
 The Palestinians do, however, acknowledge signs of change for the better in US Jewry, Congress and the Administration, and that it is up to themselves to push them forward in much more effective ways than they have managed hitherto. 
 IF AT long last, thanks to US pressure on Israel, there is real, discernible progress in the &bquo;peace process,&equo; the Intifada will probably continue much as it is. 
 If not, it is unlikely to change its aims, but it may very well change its non-armed methods. 
 So far the senior, underground leadership is against that. 
 But among the younger ones impatience is growing. 
 It is partly sheer anger at the daily brutalities and humiliations; it was just such spontaneous personal vengeance that inspired a young Palestinian to force an Israeli bus over a precipice last summer, killing 14 people. 
 It is partly the cold calculation that the Israelis must be made to realise that there can, in the end, be no such thing as &bquo;the low-cost&equo; occupation they like to imagine there is. 
 There will be no terrorism, Palestinians forecast, and no systematic &bquo;armed struggle&equo; against Israeli soldiers, but there will probably be a growth in occasional, selective operations &mdash; like the recent killing of two soldiers in Gaza &mdash; intended to add a judicious edge of real pain to the innocuous rebellion of the stones. 
 But that kind of carefully calibrated escalation could easily get out of hand. 
 A key feature of the Intifada is that, after long years of trans-frontier or inter-state conflict between largely faceless enemies, it brought the conflict back to where it essentially belongs, to Palestine itself. 
 That is why it is very effective, but also why, in the absence of a settlement, it is very dangerous. 
 For it is an ethnic conflict, between peoples who see each other at close range. 
 It is &bquo;natural&equo;, Harkabi warned, that such conflict should always get worse. 
 Entering the third year of the Intifada, it is more than ever clear that time is of the essence: how to keep it going long enough at a level which does not yield to the temptations of ruinous, reciprocal escalation, but still disturbs the outside world enough to get them to bring the Israeli extremists to heel. 
 &bquo;Patience, patience, patience,&equo; exhorted Arafat this week. 
 &bquo;We shall not tire, we can go on another two years, and another two years after that.&equo; 
 But patience is becoming hard to sustain. 
 If the Israeli &bquo;extremists&equo; are allowed to persist in their grand design, their Palestinian counterparts will eventually succeed in re-imposing their own, with the &bquo;moderates&equo;, including Arafat himself, reverting to the belief that Zionism remains the all-or-nothing, demoniac creed they used to say it was. 
 It will become, on both sides, an &bquo;existential&equo; struggle once again. 
 The Intifada may be the first chance for a civilised settlement of the Arab-Israeli conflict; it is also, many Palestinians believe, the last. 
 And there is surely a limit to the time which this historic opportunity can endure. 
 In exile and under attack&hellip; the princess Draupadi in The Mahabharata The realm of grand illusion TELEVISION: Hugh Hebert and Michael Billington consider Peter Brook's achievement in bringing his production of The Mahabharata, the longest poem in the world, to the screen. 
 ILLUSION runs right through the text and texture of The Mahabharata (C4). 
 There's the primary illusion created by the poet/narrator of this epic of war between rival branches of a royal family. 
 He sets the scene, intervenes, sums up. 
 The royal seat of power is &bquo;a palace of illusions&equo;. 
 The great warrior Arjuna has battlefield doubts whether he may make war on his own kin, and his mentor Krishna tells him victory and defeat are the same, and he must fight without desire. 
 Arjuna asks: &bquo;How can one reach the truth if one is born in illusion?&equo; 
 All-wise Krishna may be, but you wouldn't buy a used chariot from him. 
 When at the end the victor is stranded in limbo, the poet tells him there is no paradise and no hell, no enemies and no family. 
 &bquo;Here words end like thought. 
 This was your last illusion.&equo; 
 Maybe a word is just the name of a mirage. 
 Peter Brook's central achievement in the television version is to seize on the screen's ability to make a seamless connection between two senses of &bquo;illusion&equo;, the philosopher's and the magician's. 
 The most magical moments encompass both. 
 After the game of dice where Yudhishthira gambles away his kingdom, and finally his shared wife Draupadi, the winner from the rival family, seizes and tries to strip her. 
 But as he pulls at the silk of her sari, it just unwinds endlessly in a cloud of colour until he falls bundled in fabric. 
 Draupadi still kneels untouched, covered, her dignity intact. 
 For her attacker, possession itself is illusory. 
 Brook sees the great Hindu myth as full of Shakespearean themes, though it's short on Mr W S's gutsy comedy. 
 It shares the conventions of ancient drama: unbreakable vows, divided kingdoms, miraculous births, meddlesome and slippery gods. 
 After the first half hour I was hooked by its beautifully lucid narrative, but thrown by the guffaw factor in some scenes. 
 In one, during the Pandava brothers' exile, Arjuna, cursed and unmanned by a woman he has rejected, dances and camps it up like a drag-queen in warpaint. 
 Sometimes too Brook is misled by his distinction between the theatrical art of suggestion, and the screen's need for &bquo;complete images&equo;. 
 He mistrusts television's ability to handle the empty spaces that he loves so much on stage, and that's mistrusting the viewer's imagination-an error he also made in his Carmen triptych for Channel 4. 
 To which, incidentally, many garlands for its courage in presenting the Mahabharata. 
 The flaws are only minor cracks in the huge achievement of Brook and his collaborator Jean-Claude Carriere in bringing the longest poem in the world to television, to explore and exploit its illusions in gripping narrative and dazzling images.H.H. 
 PETER Brook's television film of The Mahabharata is the best transposition of a stage work to the screen I have ever seen. 
 Brook has not simply plonked the cameras in front of his original production: he has re-conceived it in filmic terms, making obvious concessions to cinematic literalism while retaining the sense of wonder. 
 I recall that two years ago at the NFT he announced that his great ambition as a young man had been to become a movie director: now (aided by director of photography William Lubtchansky and production designer Chloe Obolensky) he has made a landmark television film. 
 Inevitably, you win some, you lose some in transposing a work to another medium. 
 In theatrical conditions (whether in an Avignon stone-quarry or a Zurich boathouse) the production's basic ingredients of earth, fire and water acquired both a real and symbolic property: a standing-pool started as the source of creation and ended, by the time of the cosmic conflict, as a mud-caked river through which warriors heedlessly splashed. 
 But the point is that it was permanently visible. 
 In the theatre, a single chariot-wheel propelled across the stage stood for a whole army: in the film version, you have horses, chariots, contending extras. 
 But, oddly, the thing I miss most of all is the extraordinary sense of release that accompanied the stage version. 
 At the end, the characters informally assembled to share food and drink, a sitar gently played, after nightmarish destruction the world seemed to renew itself. 
 It was intensely moving: all the more so in Zurich as the back wall of the theatre was lowered to reveal the morning sun glittering on the lake. 
 A television film cannot be a communal experience. 
 But what Brook has retained is the clarity and magic that characterised the original. 
 Time and again the images have a distilled beauty: the simple two-shot before the battle in which Krishna explains to the warrior Arjuna that &bquo;Victory and defeat, pleasure and pain are all the same&equo;, the sight of the nagaswaram (the shawm-like musical instruments) echoing their peals to the skies, Karna's golden lance speeding through the air on its momentous flight to pierce the green-bellied Ghatotkatcha. 
 Some of the performances also come into sharper definition before the camera. 
 Bruce Myers's Krishna is extraordinary: serene, benevolent, all-seeing. 
 Vittorio Mezzogiorno's Arjuna looks to have been sculpted out of rock until his moment of Hamlet-like irreso-lution before the great battle. 
 And Andrzej Seweryn's Yudhishthira has an Olympian calm betrayed by a vicious mole of nature in the form of compulsive gambling. 
 Does it work better on stage or screen? 
 In a sense the question is irrelevant. 
 The point is that Brook and his co-adaptors (Jean-Claude Carriere and Marie-Helene Estienne) have made the story available to a mass-audience. 
 But they also prove to me that television is capable of handling myth and that, in confining the medium largely to information and ephemeral diversion, we underestimate its aesthetic potential.M.B. 
 IMF hopes for quota boost to aid Eastern Europe. 
 By Alex Brummer Financial Editor 
 OFFICIALS from the Group-of-Seven largest seven market economies will gather in Frankfurt today to put the finishing touches to a plan designed to lead to a &dollar;35billion increase in the resources of the International Monetary Fund. 
 A substantial increase in the IMF's quotas, which determine its lending power, is seen as particularly urgent given the heavy financial needs of Eastern Europe. 
 According to montary sources, the IMF is close to signing a Letter of Intent on the management of the Polish economy which will unlock a loan of up to &dollar;700million. 
 It has also held discreet discussions with the Hungarian Government -although progress is slow. 
 The Frankfurt meeting of officials is expected to prepare the way for a full meeting of the Interim Committee of Finance Ministers at IMF headquarters in Washington in January. 
 Such an extraordinary session of Ministers is unusual but the Americans, among others, are anxious that the thorny issue of the quota increase be resolved. 
 Now that the US, the IMF's largest shareholder, has agreed a quota increase the main dispute is a wrangle over rankings in the IMF hierachy with the Japanese demanding their place as an economic superpower be fully recognised. 
 Negotiations have been complicated by the refusal of the developing countries to cede any of their voting power to the Group of Seven. 
 In September agreement was held up when the then Chancellor, Mr Nigel Lawson, seemed reluctant to allow any change in the IMF's structure which resulted in a drop in Britain's position as the second largest shareholder within the Fund, even though it is now the sixth largest market economy. 
 It is becoming increasingly clear that once the IMF has agreed short-term adjustment strategies with the major Eastern European governments, the way will be paved for the kind of large scale Western assistance which leaders such as Poland's Mr Lech Walesa have called for. 
 As part of the West's action plan for Poland, a series of steps will follow the IMF's Letter of Intent. 
 These will include a bridging loan of &dollar;500million from the World Bank to International Settlements in Basle; debt relief from the Paris and London clubs; a World Bank credit of up to &dollar;1.7billion together with up to &dollar;1billion in funding from the EC. 
 Aid on a similar scale is also being put together for Hungary. 
 The Organisation of Economic Co-operation and Development is to launch a review of the Eastern European economies, starting with Poland. 
 A team of experts hopes to create a blueprint for the development of countries moving from Communist control to the free market. 
 The need for the West to respond to Eastern Europe has quickened the pace of the desultory debate on IMF quotas. 
 Bond's empire in the balance. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 THE future of Alan Bond's shaky worldwide brewing, property and media empire may be decided today when the Australian courts are expected to rule on whether to appoint a receiver to the three crucial group companies. 
 If the court goes against Mr Bond he could become the most spectacular corporate failure in Australia's business history and one of the largest industrial collapses in the world. 
 John Spalvins, the head of Adelaide Steamship which holds a key 20 per cent stake in Bell Resources, has asked the Western Australian Supreme Court to appoint a receiver to that company along with Mr Bond's master company, Bond Corporation, and his private family concern, Dallhold Investments. 
 The first move in the latest court assault against Mr Bond &mdash; which he says he will contest vigorously &mdash; came after the market closed on Friday. 
 If share dealers beat a rapid retreat this morning, Bond's bankers &mdash; already at the end of their tether &mdash; may be forced to move in on the whole group. 
 Mr Spalvins' attack on Bond comes amidst a number of other problems. 
 Bond has missed a fifth deadline for the A&dollar;2.5billion joint venture brewing deal with the New Zealand group, Lion Nathan, and the Western Australia State Government Insurance Commission has said it is considering winding-up proceedings. 
 Kerry Packer has launched a complex, lowly valued and hostile bid for Bond's media interests whilst efforts to pass on stakes in British Satellite Broadcasting and Airship Industries have so far failed. 
 Without key asset disposals, the brewery deal and further respite on about A&dollar;8billion of debt, Bond's business empire will fail. 
 The receivership of Bell Resources would force Bond Corporation to repay a &dollar;A1.2 billion loan which could spark a domino collapse of other debt agreements. 
 Has the Boesky show trials boom overplayed itself? 
 American Notebook. 
 By Mary Brasier 
 IVAN Boesky is back on the streets of New York City. 
 The doyen of insider trading may be a shadow of his former power after paying fines of &dollar;100million and spending two years in prison, but his legacy lives on in criminal trials on both sides of the Atlantic. 
 New York has always been the place to come for a good show trial. 
 In this land of the lawyer, there is no more appropriate place for picking up the social, business and political threads of the city than a spectacle viewed from the public benches of a federal court. 
 Hotel queen Leona Helmsley drew bigger crowds than some Broadway plays, and the periodic trials of corrupt city officials get better viewing ratings than some television sit-coms. 
 But for the sheer number of performances, there has been nothing to compare with the serial trials of white collar criminals. 
 Most have stemmed from evidence provided by Boesky three years ago when he was caught making millions on hot tips from his network of investment bankers, lawyers and brokers. 
 To minimise his sentence, Boesky pointed the finger at people he had dealt with. 
 He walked around for weeks wired to a police tape recorder, and spent hours admitting his past indiscretions to investigators in the US and UK in an outpouring probably not rivalled since Don Juan went into the confessional. 
 His admissions have provided New York with a regular diet of charges against the newly rich and recently humbled as stockbrokers, arbitrageurs and merchant bankers have paraded through the Manhattan courts. 
 Watching Gucci-shoed bankers hauled off trading floors in handcuffs is a viewing sensation which falls somewhere between Dynasty and Keystone Kops. 
 And like all popular American programmes, British audiences are not being spared the export version: in the new year the Guinness trial begins. 
 Defending charges which range from insider trading to more obscure practices like stock parking and failure to comply with statutory regulations, those indicted in New York and London have become players in a wider drama, witnesses to a bigger crime in which business ethics were corrupted by a decade which praised money-making not morality. 
 This may be smugly satisfying to those of us who sit on the sidelines, but even ardent moralists must soon start to wonder whether the Boesky boom in show trials has overplayed itself. 
 One reason is a case which dragged painfully towards a close in Manhattan last week. 
 The GAF trial is famous for its longevity. 
 The case has already resulted in two mistrials, and with GAF III, prosecutors are making what must be a final attempt to get their men. 
 The essence of the case is that GAF and its vice-chairman, James Sherwin, tried to manipulate the price of Union Carbide, in which GAF had a shareholding which it subsequently sold. 
 The star witness at this trial (if you ignore Swedish actress Liv Ullman who played a cameo part last week) is Boyd Jefferies, former head of a Wall Street broking firm. 
 Mr Jefferies is helping the US Government prosecute GAF not merely because he is a public spirited citizen but in order to be able to swap a prison sentence for the privilege of teaching children to play golf in Aspen, Colorado. 
 Mr Jefferies featured strongly in the confessions of Ivan Boesky and he is quoted in an American magazine this month as saying: &bquo;If the government was going to bring me down for something like this, I am going to bring down a lot of other people with me&equo;. 
 This domino method of criminal justice has been repeated elsewhere with dubious results. 
 The prosecution's success rate does not augur well for the two trials which will really test the quality of Boesky's information and the deal that he pulled off with government lawyers. 
 In March, Boesky is the star witness at the trial of Michael Milken, the junk bond king who faces 98 charges of securities fraud and who worked closely with the disgraced arbitrageur. 
 Milken's indictment was the prize that Boesky delivered to his prosecutors &mdash; it was even cited by his lawyer when he tried unsuccessfully to have Boesky's three-year prison sentence commuted earlier this year. 
 Milken refused to play the game of domino justice, so the case against him will stand or fall on its own merits. 
 There are no spin-off trials of conspirators fingered by Milken which can comfort the prosecution if it loses. 
 And there are many who think that is what will happen. 
 When it comes to Guinness, can UK prosecutors do better than their American counterparts in putting Boesky's tipoffs to good use? 
 There are some striking parallels between the show trials of New York which have stemmed from the Boesky confessions and the Guinness case. 
 They range from the UK equivalent of plea bargaining to the curiosity that while Boesky, a confessed criminal, can arrange special deals with the prosecution, those charged with lesser offences have to spend three years keeping lawyers in clover while waiting for their turn at justice. 
 And in the best New York tradition, Guinness too will be a show trial &mdash; handing out not merely verdicts on the defendants in the dock but on the City at large. 
 Can the Crown avoid the excesses and mistakes of which white collar crime fighters in the US are accused? 
 As for the GAF trial, it will probably live as a symbol of prosecution farce and the flaws of the Boesky boom. 
 The Wall Street Journal, which talked this week of the &bquo;absurdity of the charges&equo; in the GAF trial, concluded: &bquo;What's on trial as much as GAF is whether federal prosecutors in the Wall Street cases know whom to prosecute, with whom to plea bargain, and whom to leave alone.&equo; 
 It is to be hoped that the Guinness trial will show that the UK authorities do know just that. 
 Water shares scaled down. 
 Millions who applied for the minimum 100 shares in the great water sell-off are likely today to be told their applications are being met in full despite a huge oversubcription to the &pound;5.24billion privatisation. 
 But applications for larger numbers of shares are likely to be scaled back substantially after the offer was oversubscribed by 4.7 times.. 
 Director's pay boost. 
 The highest paid director at Mr Kipling-to-Bisto group, Ranks Hovis McDougall, was awarded a 22 per cent salary increase to &pound;269,000 in the year to September despite the group being under continued takeover threat. 
 Chairman Stanley Metcalfe also saw his pay rise by 17.4 per cent to &pound;142,000. 
 The boardroom rises at the company compare with a rise in profits of 13 per cent. 
 Resignations rumoured. 
 Sir Derek Alun-Jones, chairman of Ferranti, and some other directors of the troubled group are said to be ready to resign in February once a share issue to raise &pound;187 million in finance for the group is agreed by shareholders.. 
 Edelman in trouble. 
 Asher Edelman &mdash; the US corporate raider who has stalked the Bhs to Habitat group Storehouse &mdash; has run into big financial reversals on both sides of the Atlantic. 
 Arbitragers said Edelman had lost &dollar;40million to &dollar;50million on a stake he had taken in Storehouse and is facing financial problems at Datapoint which he heads. 
 US warned on foreign investor curb. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 FRESH legislation to curb the growing level of foreign ownership in American industry should be avoided, a study from the prestigious Washington-based Institute for International Economics has warned. 
 But it is becoming increasingly important that an accord on foreign corporate investment is negotiated between leading industrial nations. 
 And there may be cases when the US Government should, in the national interest, take extraordinary powers over foreign-owned companies, the report states. 
 According to the high level survey, carried out by two senior government advisers, foreign-owned companies in the US are &bquo;virtually indistinguishable &bquo;from domestic organisations in terms of wages, value added per worker and the amount of research and development undertaken in the United States. 
 And it argues that, despite growing public concern following deals such as the sale of Columbia Pictures and New York's Rockefeller Centre to the Japanese, there is no need for tough new legislative curbs. 
 But the officials do accept the controversial point that the American Government may take action against overseas-owned groups in its own national interest. 
 &bquo;To protect national security by ensuring access to critical foreign technologies, the US may have to condition defence procurements from foreign countries or mandatory licensing of their technology to US firms, or mandatory investment in the US by such foreign companies,&equo; the IIE report says. 
 Written by MIT Professor Paul Krugman, formerly on the staff of the White House Council of Economic Advisers, and Professor Edward Graham, formerly in the office of international investment at the US Treasury, and later at the OECD in Paris, the report will be scanned carefully as indicating the current thinking of the Washington policy-making establishment. 
 &bquo;Much public attention has been focused on foreign puchases of real estate, however, foreign ownership of banking and manufacturing is much more important&equo;, the report argues. 
 And while the bulk of public controversy has focused on Japanese investment, Britain plays by far the biggest role, accounting for 31 per cent of all foreign investment in the US, as much as the next two investors, the Dutch (14.9 per cent) and the Japanese (16.1 per cent) combined. 
 Britain's eminence is likely to be brief. 
 Nine years ago, the Dutch played the biggest role, with 25 per cent of investment, compared to Britain's 16.6 per cent. 
 Just as Britain pumped the proceeds of North Sea Oil into the US economy, the Dutch in the 1960s and 1970s were investing the proceeds of North Sea gas. 
 With the oil running down, the Japanese are poised to overtake the British investment share in the near future. 
 In the financial sector, huge increases in the assets of Japanese affiliates, due largely to purchases of highly-leveraged US financial firms, have quickly enabled assets of Japanese-controlled firms in the US to exceed those of other countries. 
 But this is mainly a balance sheet phenomenon. 
 Measured by value added or employment, Japanese investment is modest. 
 The surge in foreign acquisitions of US firms since 1986 is attributed to the fall in the dollar, and to the reform of corporation tax in the same year. 
 Between 1981-6, corporate tax rates were much harsher on US affiliates of foreign owned firms, who found their low US taxes offset by the reduction of tax credits in their home countries. 
 This meant that a US-owned company paid less net taxes. 
 In 1987, the last year for which complete figures are available, foreign investment accounted for 7.6 per cent of US stocks (up sharply to 8.9 per cent last year), while foreign share of US manufacturing was 12.2 per cent, and of US employment a much smaller 3.5 per cent. 
 Foreign Direct Investment in the US, by EdwardMGraham and PaulRKrugman, Institute for International Economics, 11 Dupont Circle NW, Washington DC 20036. &dollar;11.95 
 Battle lines are drawn for control of the Norfolk Capital hotels group. 
 By Tony May 
 TODAY will see the opening shots in a fierce &pound;130million battle for control of the Norfolk Capital hotels group, best known for its St James Club in London. 
 Mr Peter Tyrie is trying to oust Norfolk's managing director, Peter Eyles, through a mangement buy-in using a 12.6 per cent stake, acquired from the Mount Charlotte group, for &pound;17million, as a springboard. 
 The Norfolk board meets today and Mr Eyles is confident it will reject what he terms, Mr Tyrie's &bquo;preposterous attempt at personal aggrandisement.&equo; 
 Mr Tyrie's buy-in package includes a management contract linked to future movement's in Norfolk's share price which is described as &bquo;lavish.&equo; 
 After an initial payment of &pound;500,000, Mr Tyrie and his partners would receive a lump sum of &pound;2million if Norfolk's shares reached 50p and a further &pound;5million if they topped 60p. 
 On Friday its shares jumped 2p to 32p as the market got wind of some kind of deal, valuing the group at &pound;130million. 
 Solicitors' firms are caught out by the housing market collapse. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 SIGNS are beginning to emerge that the survival of some firms of solicitors is being threatened by the collapse of the housing market. 
 Many law firms have already laid off employees: a large Midlands firm has got rid of 35; a firm in East Anglia is about to shed some conveyancing staff; and the Law Society's Young Solicitors Group has set up a helpline to provide counselling and advice for young lawyers who have been made redundant. 
 One medium-sized firm of solicitors in East Anglia has written to its staff asking them to forgo their pay for December. 
 The firm says it simply cannot find the cash to meet its wage bill. 
 East Anglia has been particularly affected by the fall in the property market. 
 House prices there boomed in 1987 and the first-half of 1988 and have since fallen more sharply than in most other areas. 
 The Law Society says it is not aware of any firms, so far, which have gone under because of the property slump. 
 Recent figures for conveyancing are not available. 
 In 1986, about 1.78million properties worth &pound;73billion changed hands. 
 In 1987, there were 1.96 million conveyances worth &pound;103 billion. 
 Estimates suggest that since then, the number of house sales has fallen by about 40 per cent. 
 For a small firm of solicitors in a market town, conveyancing has accounted for about half of all fee income. 
 So the recent fall in house-moving business would have cut gross income by about a fifth and net income by much more. 
 The housing slump has also had a major impact on removal firms. 
 The British Association of Removers, which represents 750 removal companies across the country, believes housemoving business is down about 40 per cent. 
 &bquo;There is a temporary blip in the market because some people are trying to press ahead with their moves before Christmas,&equo; said Mr Eric Bourne of the BAR. 
 &bquo;But generally speaking, it has been difficult since September 1988. 
 &bquo;Some firms have reduced their staffing levels substantially, but people in the industry are generally trying to hold on to experienced staff.&equo; 
 Some one-person removal firms have disappeared, said Mr Bourne. 
 &bquo;But within our association there has been no noticable number of bankruptcies. 
 &bquo;It has gone on for 15 months and so far most firms have managed to survive, but they can't go on like this for ever.&equo; 
 Racal on line for double figures This week.. 
 By Robin Stoddart 
 THE outlook for retail sales is seen by Midland Montagu Research to be of &bquo;pivotal importance to the economy.&equo; 
 Sales are usually much bigger in the run-up to Christmas than in the rest of the year, and low sales would indicate that consumer's confidence is broken and would also harm business confidence. 
 Leading lights of the service sector, headed by Racal, could produce results that go some way towards alleviating the gloomy economic prospects again this week, even if Friday's poor inflation figure can't be glossed over. 
 Some top exporters, notably English China Clays and Dowty, are also delivering interim statements. 
 Racal Telecom's progress in car telephone and data transmission is expected to double six month's profit, tomorrow, from the previous &pound;30.6million.This will be instrumental in boosting the Racal Electronics parent to just over &pound;80million, from &pound;62.4million. 
 Dowty may be able to show a near &pound;10million profit gain to about &pound;42million, against &pound;32.5million although the shares have been moving uncertainly in the face of the engineering strikes and concern over defence expenditure. 
 Granada will report profits of &pound;160million, against &pound;143million, also tomorrow, if brokers have revised their estimates right in line with deteriorating TV retailing and rental trends. 
 The North-West programme franchise remains highly lucrative, with under three years to go before renewal or a reshuffle. 
 English China Clays has been downgraded on the stock market because of its housebuilding stakes, but quarrying and the main international paper industry supply business are far more important. 
 Only a few millions extra profit on the previous year's &pound;145million are likely to be revealed today. 
 TODAY &mdash; Interims: Berkeley Group, Philip Harris Holdings, JLI Group, Learmouth and Burchett Management Systems, Marling Industries, Scottish and Newcastle Breweries, Waterglade International, Whitecroft. 
 Finals: Airtours, Carlton Communications, English China Clays, Eurocopy, Hardys and Hansons, Holmes and Marchant Group, Venture Plant Group, Wolverhampton and Dudley Breweries. 
 Economic statistics: Food Facts (3rd quarter) Producer price index numbers (Nov-provisional) Retail sales (November) TOMORROW &mdash; Interims: BSS Group, Creighton's Naturally, Dowty Group, Halma, Melville Street, Racal Telecom, Turnbull Scott Holdings. 
 Finals: Archimedes Investment Trust, Blick, J A Devenish, Granada Group, Mining and Allied Supplies, Polar Electronics, Richards, Shaftesbury, TMD Advertising Hldgs, Titon Holdings, Vaux Group. 
 WEDNESDAY &mdash; Interims: Authority Investments, HP Bulmer Holdings, Charter Consolidated, Fuller Smith and Turner, London Securities, Benjamin Priest, Stewart and Wight. 
 Finals: Baggeridge Brick, Chemring Group, GW Thornton THURSDAY &mdash; Interims: Brown and Tawse Group, Eliza Tinsley, Eve Group, Fine Art Development, GM Firth, Gold Greenless Trott, Hunter Saphir, London Merchant Securities, Alexander Russell. 
 Finals: Associated Paper Industries, City Site Estates, Compass Group, Hoskyns Group, Johnson and Firth Brown, Arthur Lee and Sons, Shoprite Group, Speyhawk, UK Land, Watson and Philip. 
 Economic statistics: Labour market statistics: average earnings. 
 FRIDAY &mdash; Interims: Asda Group, Booth Industries, Brasway, Bristol Evening Post, British Build and Engineering Appliances, CHIndustrials, Compco Hldgs, John J Lees, TGI, Wellman. 
 Finals: Grainger Trust, Guinness Mahon Holdings, London Scottish Bank, McCarthey and Sons, Strata Investments. 
 Economic statistics: Retail prices index.. 
 Bulgarian opposition scents victory. 
 By Mike Power and Denise Searle in Sofia 
 ABOUT 50,000 people packed Sofia's Alexander Nevesky Cathedral square yesterday to demand round-table talks between the Bulgarian Government and the new opposition grouping, the Union of Democratic Forces, to solve the country's economic and social crisis. 
 Similar rallies in many towns called on today's crucial Community Party central committee meeting to give up immediately the party's leading role in society and introduce multi-party democracy. 
 In freezing temperatures and light snowfall, the enthusiastic and emotional crowd in Sofia heard Bulgaria's most radical demands so far and called for the ousted leader, Mr Todor Zhivkov, to stand trial for fraud and mismanagement. 
 One speaker, Mr Nikolai Vassilev, urged &bquo;a Nuremberg trial of Zhivkov and other criminals from East European totalitarian states like East Germany and Czechoslovakia&equo;. 
 The Union of Democratic Forces, launched last week, is equivalent to East Germany's New Forum or Czechoslovakia's Civic Force. 
 Its organisers increased their demands after last Friday's central committee meeting accepted a key demand of the union and ousted many Zhivkov supporters from the Community Party leadership. 
 &bquo;If the new party leader Petar Mladenov thinks this action will pre-empt our demonstration and weaken us,&equo; said the union's secretary, Mr Petar Beron, &bquo;then he is wrong. 
 If we can achieve so much before the demonstration is even held then much more is possible.&equo; 
 The rally called for the resignation of the central committee and municipal party bosses; the disbanding of Communist Party control bodies in work places, the legal system, militia and armed forces; and the separation of party and state finances. 
 Speakers called for immediate action to reverse Mr Zhivkov's national and religious assimilation policies towards the ethnic Turks and Bulgarian Muslims. 
 Mr Mikhail Ivanov, of the Committee for Reconciliation, said: &bquo;Ethnic and cultural rights and traditions must be respected.&equo; 
 Members of the minorities arrived in Sofia two days before the demonstration fearing they would be stopped from attending. 
 Reports reached rally organisers that 1,000 Muslims were turned back at Gotse Delchev on their way to Sofia. 
 &bquo;A special commission on Bulgaria's ethnic conflicts is needed to expose the guilty people,&equo; said the union president, Mr Zhelyu Zhelev. 
 He went on: &bquo;The round-table negotiations that we proposed should include the Communist Party, the government and our union, and should agree on a new constitution. 
 Free elections would then be possible in a year's time when all parties could participate equally.&equo; 
 Mr Zhelev fears that elections may be called before alternative platforms and candidates are ready, giving the Communist Party a clear run. 
 Economic reform will dominate today's central committee meeting. 
 A special commission under Mr Mladenov's deputy, Mr Andrey Lukanov, will report on &bquo;defamations in economic and social policy&equo;. 
 This will include revelations about corruption in the Zhivkov regime. 
 On Saturday the trade union paper Trud revealed that Mr Zhivkov's grandson began a five-year study course in Switzerland last October at a cost to the state of over &pound;1,000 a month. 
 Election fever in Brazil as worker closes poll gap. 
 By Jan Rocha in Sao Paulo 
 BRAZIL could be within a week of electing Latin America's first worker President, Mr Luis Inacio da Silva, commonly known as Lula. 
 Although opinion polls still show the centre-right's candidate, Mr Fernando Collor, leading by five million votes, the difference between them has dropped from 13 to six points in one week. 
 A World Cup-like atmosphere grips the country. 
 On buses, in bars, markets and queues can be heard only &bquo;Lula or Collor?&equo; 
 An audience of over 60 million watched last week's first television debate between the two. 
 A poll showed that Mr Da Silva won it, burying the myth that as an ex-factory worker with only a few years schooling he is unqualified for the presidency. 
 He is also winning the televison propaganda war, cleverly mixing attacks on his adversary with humour and straightforward appeals to help change Brazil. 
 Over 100 leading actors, actresses and singers have joined his campaign. 
 Voters recognise household names from their favourite soaps, singing the campaign song, Lula La (Lula There &mdash; in the presidential palace). 
 After a hesitant start, the other leftwing and progressive parties who were defeated in the first round have joined Mr Da Silva's campaign, along with the Socialist and Communist parties, which already supported him in the Popular Front coalition. 
 Mr Collor, badly rattled by the spreading pro-Lula mood, and the rapid erosion of his lead in the polls, cancelled his rallies this weekend, sacked his propaganda co-ordinator and called his advisers to an emergency meeting in Brasilia to replan strategies. 
 Mr Collor's problem is that although money is no obstacle to his multi-million dollar campaign, it does not make up for the thousands of enthusiastic party militants campaigning for his rival. 
 Mr Collor's National Reconstruction Party was created as an election vehicle and has only a handful of members. 
 His attempt to win southern gaucho voters by playing up family links there backfired when he got his regional expressions muddled up. 
 His campaign now seems to be down to its last card &mdash; to brand Mr Da Silva as a dangerous radical who is bent on introducing Stalinist communism into Brazil. 
 &bquo;They will replace the green and yellow of the national flag with red,&equo; he warns. 
 Fear of communism has worked in Brazil before, but it is questionable whether in today's world it will still do so. 
 In any case, Mr Collor has only one week before the election on December 17, to put this message across. 
 Brazil's President, Mr Jose Sarney, is required by the constitution to leave office by March 15. 
 He has said repeatedly that he will serve out his term, but the pressures on him to quit early are expected to grow after next Sunday's vote. 
 Under his government, inflation rose by 41.4 per cent in November alone. 
 Czech leaves jail to join leadership. 
 By Tyler Marshall in Prague 
 THE pace of political change has been rapid here, but for no one has it been faster than for Mr Jan Carnogursky, who will be a deputy prime minister. 
 In the space of only two weeks, the Slovak lawyer has moved from dissident to defendant to government minister. 
 For him, life began to turn on a Sunday evening two weeks ago in his Bratislava prison cell after he had been pardoned by the country's president, Mr Gustav Husak. 
 &bquo;The warder came and told me to dress and led me to an officer of the court,&equo; the small, self-effacing lawyer recalled in an interview on Saturday. 
 &bquo;He said I had been pardoned by the president.&equo; 
 Mr Carnogurksy was charged with subversion for organising a pro-democracy petition, but was found not guilty by a Bratislava court on November 23. 
 The prosecutor appealed and Mr Carnogursky was returned to prison. 
 On Friday, Mr Husak announced a widesweeping amnesty which included a general pardon for those charged with subversion under the notorious Article 98 of the penal code often used to stifle political protest. 
 &bquo;I am very pleased to accept the pardon,&equo; Mr Carnogursky said with a smile. 
 While he had known of the groundswell of resistance to the regime, experiencing it outside of jail was something else. 
 &bquo;Of course I'd had newspapers, but I wasn't able to feel inside the atmosphere outside. 
 &bquo;I was released late in the evening. 
 I took a tram home. 
 I saw posters that said &bquo;free elections.&equo; 
 When I was arrested in August, one charge against me was that I said I wanted free elections,&equo; said Mr Carnogursky, aged 45. 
 The next evening he addressed a large anti-government rally in Bratislava and within 48 hours of his release, he was negotiating with the prime minister about political change. 
 On the eve of his ministerial appointment, Mr Carnogursky said he was not interested in revenge. 
 &bquo;Members of the secret police and wardens behaved in a correct way towards me,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'm a lawyer. 
 I'm used to suppressing my feelings.&equo; 
 His swearing in by Mr Husak will bring together the two opposite poles of Czechoslovak politics &mdash; the unyielding dissident and the man most closely connected with the hard-line Communist regime that followed the Soviet-led 1968 invasion. 
 Still, Mr Carnogursky said he would feel little bitterness when he shook hands with the man who symbolised the state apparatus. 
 &bquo;Even Husak has spent many more years in jail than I have,&equo; he said. 
 -Washington Post 
 SA anti-apartheid groups vow to step up struggle. 
 By Patrick Laurence in Johannesburg 
 THE biggest gathering of anti-apartheid organisations in South Africa's history ended at the weekend with a commitment to intensify the &bquo;struggle against apartheid and exploitation&equo; and a sharp denunciation of the government's reform policies. 
 However, delegates from the Black Consciousness Movement (BCM) failed to endorse the resolutions which had been hammered out in hours of debate and decided instead to take them back for further discussions by its supporters. 
 The convenors of the conference were drawn from two ideological camps in South Africa's extra-parliamentary opposition: the Mass Democratic Movement (MDM), which is ideologically aligned to the outlawed African National Congress, and the BCM, which was founded by Steve Biko and sees itself as a third force between the ANC and the banned Pan-Africanist Congress (PAC). 
 Co-operation between these two forces in organising the conference &mdash; which was attended by more than 4,660 delegates, representing nearly 2,140 organisations &mdash; was in itself an achievement, as Mr Murphy Morobe, of the MDM, noted. 
 It was a further achievement that delegates from these two, until recently hostile, camps could clash sharply in debate during the conference without acrimony, although black consciousness delegates from Natal threatened to walk out at one stage. 
 The key resolution called on representatives to approve the Harare declaration on negotiations with the government of Mr F.W. de Klerk. 
 Although adopted by the Organisation for African Unity, the declaration was originally drafted by the ANC in consultation with its allies in South Africa. 
 With BCM delegates reserving their position, the remaining delegates adopted the Harare declaration and further resolved to call for a &bquo;constituent assembly, established on a non-racial basis and representing all the people of South Africa, to draw up a new constitution for our country&equo;. 
 They declared that the &bquo;only way to defeat apartheid is by broadening the base of anti-apartheid forces&equo;. 
 Their statement reflected, in part, the determination of the MDM to selectively recruit forces and organisations serving in government-approved institutions, including legislative assemblies in the &bquo;black homelands&equo; and town councils in the black townships. 
 But, dating back to Biko's days, the BCM has a strong tradition of &bquo;non-collaboration,&equo; which means shunning all contact with &bquo;collaborators&equo; serving in government-established institutions. 
 Any move in that direction may raise resistance in BCM circles and exacerbate misgivings about the MDM's &bquo;flirtations&equo; with bantustan leaders like General Bantu Holomisa of the Transkei and Mr Enos Mabuza of KaNgwane. 
 The conference exposed other rifts in the black community. 
 The Africanists, whose ideological sympathies lie with the PAC, decided not to attend, asserting they had not been invited to serve on the convening committee. 
 Also not represented was the Zulu-based Inkatha movement, led by Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi. 
 Aides' night flight attracts heavy congressional fire. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 THE US Secretary of State, Mr Jim Baker, yesterday sought to fend off the growing criticism of the new US initiative towards Beijing, arguing that the priorities were to prevent China from retreating further into isolation, and to show support for moderates in the government. 
 &bquo;And they are going to have to help us, if we are going to preserve this relationship,&equo; Mr Baker said, signalling expectation of Chinese concessions on human rights. 
 This has aroused hopes that the Chinese dissident physicist, Mr Fang Lizhi, who has been given sanctuary in the US Embassy in Beijing, might be released under a Chinese guarantee that he will not be arrested. 
 Democrats in Congress led the condemnation of the surprise arrival of two senior Bush Administration aides in Beijing. 
 But Republicans, too, were concerned that the Administration's now legendary caution in foreign affairs, and its unwillingness to move far from the sentiments of the opinion polls, should have been cast aside in such a cause. 
 &bquo;It is another example of the President's tendency to kowtow to Beijing in spite of the failure on the part of their government to relax the repression they have imposed,&equo; Mr Stephen Solarz, chairman of the House foreign affairs subcommittee on Asian and Pacific affairs, said yesterday. 
 Washington was startled by the 2am White House announcement of the visit to Beijing by the National Security Adviser, Admiral Brent Scowcroft, and the Deputy Secretary of State, Mr Lawrence Eagleburger. 
 Both are proteges of Dr Henry Kissinger, who began the US rapprochement with China nearly 20 years ago. 
 &bquo;The night flight to Beijing makes everything we have said about our disgust and revulsion at the Chinese Government's action into empty words,&equo; complained a congresswoman, Ms Nancy Pelosi, sponsor of the law vetoed by President Bush, which would have allowed Chinese students to remain in the US after their visas expired. 
 Republicans began to express concern yesterday that the President's personal commitment to China, where he was ambassador in 1972, was putting him at odds with public opinion still revolted by the brutal repression in Tiananmen Square. 
 Responding to the criticism, Mr Baker said isolating China would only &bquo;compound the tragedy&equo;. 
 Gorbachev says party must not oppose change John Rettie reports from Moscow on Gorbachev's attempt to retain the power of the Communists. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 PRESIDENT Mikhail Gorbachev has warned his Communist Party colleagues that if they delayed in dealing with &bquo;overdue changes,&equo; they could suffer the same &bquo;excesses&equo; as their brothers in Eastern Europe. 
 His warning was couched in elliptical terms, in a wide-ranging speech to the party's central committee on Saturday. 
 He pointed out that in many countries of Eastern Europe, Communists had been forced into coalition or out of government. 
 &bquo;The truth, about which we spoke so often in the past few years, has been reaffirmed once again &mdash; where there is a delay in dealing with overripe problems, excesses are inevitable,&equo; Gorbachev said in the Tass transcript of his speech. 
 And although he passionately rejected demands from radical Soviet reformers to abandon the party's monopoly of power, at least at this moment, he insisted that only the most far-reaching changes could solve the Soviet economic crisis. 
 The depth of this crisis persuaded members of the radical Inter-Regional Group of congressional deputies to abandon their call for a two-hour strike today, in demand of a revision of Article 6 of thr constitution which enshrines the party's monopoly. 
 Instead, a meeting of just under half the 400-strong group, an alliance of reform-minded parliamentarians, adopted a compromise resolution allowing each of its members to take independent political action. 
 &bquo;The Inter-Regional Group called on all voters to adopt resolutions at rallies and meetings and to send letters and telegrams and find other ways to support the demand,&equo; Tass reported. 
 The strike call was originally made by the human rights activist, Dr Andrei Sakharov, and two other leaders of the radical Inter-Regional Group, who want the Congress of People's Deputies, which meets tomorrow, to discuss the amendment of Article 6 of the constitution, which guarantees the party its dominant position. 
 But at a meeting of the party's central committee on Saturday, Mr Gorbachev hotly opposed &bquo;any attempt to diminish the importance of the party, or undermine its authority.&equo; 
 He denounced efforts to &bquo;organise a political strike on the eve of the congress&equo;, the country's supreme legislative body. 
 Those who did so were &bquo;trying to demoralise Communists, reduce their effectiveness at a turning-point for perestroika, and set the workers against the party&equo;. 
 Significantly, though, the Soviet leader added that since a new constitution was being prepared, any article could come up for review, and this included Article 6. 
 There was, he pointed out, no such article in the first Soviet constitution, adopted in Lenin's time. 
 Mr Gorbachev's clear message was that the time had not yet come to abolish the party's monopoly of power, but that it might well do so when a new political structure had been worked out, and the present economic crisis overcome. 
 To force the pace now was irresponsible, and could lead to a power vacuum. 
 The establishment of a new political system based on law was a highly complex matter and needed careful consideration, he said. 
 The new constitution under consideration would be discussed by the crucial party congress to be held in October next year. 
 Mr Gorbachev reportedly offered to resign at Saturday's meeting after Kemerevo party chief Alexander Melnikov &bquo;really let himself get carried away and said something like this: &bquo;Is it proper to go bowing to the capitalists? to go asking a blessing from the Pope?&equo; ' according to a conservative Central Committee member. 
 The source said Mr Gorbachev &bquo;was touched on the raw&equo; by the criticism of his moves to make peace with the West, and offered to resign if the full Central Committee agreed with Mr Melnikov. 
 Mr Gorbachev was immediately supported and Mr Melnikov wound up apologising. 
 Mr Gorbachev also had a sharp message for the Lithuanian party, which is planning to break away from the Soviet Communist party. 
 &bquo;We regard the CPSU &lsqb;Soviet party&rsqb; as a consolidating, uniting force,&equo; he said, &bquo;as the guarantor of this Soviet land, of the protection and increase of its power, and of the strengthening of its international authority.&equo; 
 The entire party leadership is also clearly worried about the party's prospects for the forthcoming elections to soviets at both local and republican level. 
 The old revolutionary slogan &bquo;All power to the Soviets&equo; is as much Mr Gorbachev's as that of the radical reformers. 
 He wants the party to stop running the country, but merely to inspire and guide it. 
 If, however, the party is rejected at the polls, it could be left without any role at all. 
 The election period, which will last about six months, was launched yesterday in Estonia and Latvia, where voters elected local soviets. 
 Because the polling system is new and complex, the results will not be known for several days, but most observers expect the local party's candidates to come in far behind the Popular Front and other unofficial groups. 
 But what happens in the Baltic, or indeed many of the smaller among the country's 15 republics, pales into insignificance compared with how the party fares in Russia. 
 White House envoy's visit is bid to repair rift with China Washington breaks the ice in Beijing. 
 By Simon Long in Beijing 
 PRESIDENT Bush's National Security Adviser, Admiral Brent Scowcroft, was greeted warmly by the Chinese leader, Mr Deng Xiaoping, yesterday during an unannounced weekend visit to Beijing which tacitly buried the US ban on high-level governmental contacts with China. 
 &bquo;I believe this visit of yours is a very important one,&equo; said Mr Deng during a meeting in the Great Hall of the People. 
 &bquo;In spite of the disputes and differences between us, after all, Sino-US relations have to be improved. 
 This is something that is necessary for world peace and stability.&equo; 
 Admiral Scowcroft's visit at the head of a senior delegation including the Deputy Secretary of State, Mr Lawrence Eagleburger, seemed to offer China's leadership a face saving way to patch up its rift with Washington, with whom China's relations have been at their lowest ebb since Mr Nixon's trail-blazing 1972 trip to Beijing. 
 Ostensibly, Admiral Scowcroft's mission was to brief China's leaders on the Malta summit. 
 But the visit amounted to an urgent appeal from Washington to stop what has seemed an inexorable downward slide in its relations with Beijing since the bloody crackdown on anti-government protests in June. 
 The admiral said he had come &bquo;to bring new impetus and vigour into our bilateral relationship&equo;. 
 China rolled out the red carpet for him and his team. 
 After a lengthy discussion with the Foreign Minister, Mr Qian Qichen, they met the Prime Minister, Mr Li Peng, and the Communist Party leader, Mr Jiang Zemin. 
 Significantly, Mr Deng once again gave the lie to any impression that his &bquo;retirement&equo; last month is to be taken literally. 
 His formal meeting with the US delegation ignored the pledge he made then only to meet &bquo;old friends&equo; from abroad privately and not to discuss politics. 
 He asked Admiral Scowcroft to tell the President: &bquo;There is a retired old man in China in the Orient, who is concerned about the improvement and development of Sino-US relations.&equo; 
 Mr Deng's personal appeal to President Bush was as close as China came to reciprocating the one the United States had made in sending the mission. 
 In June, Washington imposed a package of sanctions on China. 
 Military exchanges, subsidised government loans, and high-level official contacts with the Chinese Government were frozen. 
 President Bush has come under congressional pressure to step up the sanctions. 
 Instead, he has lifted one. 
 The White House spokesman, Mr Marlin Fitzwater, explained that while the President &bquo;deplores the tragedy of Tiananmen Square last June&hellip; 
 China, nevertheless, remains part of the world around us&equo;. 
 Since June, China has reverted to the rhetoric of an earlier era in its diatribes against the US. 
 Mr Deng himself has accused the United States of being &bquo;too deeply involved&equo; in the anti-government protests. 
 On Friday the US charge d'affaires in Beijing was summoned to the Foreign Ministry to hear a &bquo;strong protest&equo; about President Bush's decision to execute by administrative means the provisions of a congressional bill he had vetoed, allowing some of the estimated 40,000 Chinese students in the US to extend their visas. 
 Until last month heavily armed soldiers stood guard outside the US embassy in Beijing, where China's best-known dissident, the astrophysicist, Professor Fang Lizhi, and his wife took refuge in June. 
 Ex-president Nixon came to Beijing at the end of October, in what appeared to be a fence-mending expedition which backfired. 
 Unused to the candid expression of American outrage which Mr Nixon voiced, China's leaders only stiffened their attitude. 
 They insisted that the massacre was China's internal affair, that China had done nothing to harm the United States' interests, and that it was up to the US to take the initiative in repairing relations. 
 So it is not surprising that China's leaders have welcomed President Bush's envoy. 
 But it remains unclear what the next step could be. 
 Two of the main issues in bilateral relations &mdash; Professor Fang and his wife, and the Chinese students in the United States &mdash; are not susceptible to easy compromise. 
 What is puzzling is why the United States should hand such a diplomatic prize to China at a time when the original strategic basis of the friendship, mutual hostility to the Soviet Union, seems more tenuous than ever. 
 The spectre of an isolated, xenophobic China is one that neither Washington nor Moscow welcomes. 
 And, for all the cordiality surrounding the Malta summit, the US is probably anxious to retain its satellite intelligence stations in China. 
 If the US team were hoping to hear that martial law may soon be lifted, they may have been forestalled by a tiny but significant demonstration on the streets of Beijing. 
 Witnesses say that six protesters unfurled two banners outside the Ministry of Radio, Film and Television on Saturday afternoon. 
 One read &bquo;Why is China so poor?&equo; 
 It was the first reported public protest in Beijing since June. 
 Next year &bquo;is crucial for Delors plan&equo;. 
 By John Palmer in Strasbourg 
 THE European Community has 12 months in which to achieve a breakthrough to full economic and monetary union or the whole project may have to be put on ice until the end of the next decade. 
 This is the view of many EC experts and officials after the weekend summit here. 
 The decisions taken by the heads of government &mdash; in the face of Mrs Thatcher's lone opposition &mdash; mean that the Community will deliberately accelerate progress to supra-national monetary union. 
 But EC governments will have to agree on what changes to make to the Treaty of Rome by the end of 1991, if the timetable is not to be derailed. 
 &bquo;Events in the outside world, as well as within the Community, give us an exceptional window of opportunity at present,&equo; a senior European Commission official said yesterday. 
 &bquo;Realistically, those same political developments could turn sour unless we maintain a clear sense of forward momentum. 
 Loss of momentum could mean a return to the stagnation which prevented the Community evolving in the 1970s.&equo; 
 Agreement on revisions to the Rome Treaty by the end of 1991 would allow a further 12 months for the delicate business of securing the endorsement of all 12 national parliaments. 
 This would allow the council of ministers and the putative EC central bank to move ahead with the supra-national second and third stages of the three-stage European monetary union (EMU) strategy of the European Commission president, Mr Jacques Delors, at, or very soon after, the beginning of 1993. 
 The West Germans still talk about a full EMU not being operational before the summer of 1994 &mdash; when the next direct elections to the European Parliament are due. 
 But success or failure for the entire project may have been determined long before then. 
 Preparations for the special inter-governmental conference on a new European monetary treaty will begin almost immediately. 
 The main responsibility will fall on the Irish Government, which takes over the presidency of the EC council of ministers at the end of the month, and the Italians, who take over in July. 
 There are two important issues to be resolved before the character of the economic and monetary union will be determined. 
 The first is whether the union will be almost exclusively monetary, with the EC central banking system being closely modelled on the narrow counter-inflationary objectives of the largely non-accountable Bundesbank, and with other economic objectives left exclusively in national hands. 
 Bonn, The Hague and London would much prefer the Community to keep to this narrow route to EMU, although the British Government still does not see that even its competing currencies alternative leads to a European central bank. 
 But a majority of Community governments, particularly among the poorer countries, will insist on a much broader definition of economic union and one which involves a huge increase in resources for the less productive and competitive regions of the EC. 
 This in turn links with the second great issue: just how, and to whom, should the council of ministers &mdash; and, by extension, the EC central bank &mdash; be accountable. 
 Although Mrs Thatcher insists that accountability should exclusively be through national governments to national parliaments, this is not favoured by others. 
 The European Parliament will not be slow in following up the demands put to the summit by Mr Enrique Baron, the Parliament's president, for it to be given sweeping new powers by the inter-governmental conference next year. 
 Hiding behind the future role of the European Parliament is the spectre &mdash; as seen from London &mdash; of the bandwagon for full European political federalism. 
 The fact that Mrs Thatcher talks less today about the dangers of &bquo;national&equo; sovereignty from the Delors version of EMU and more about the &bquo;threat to national parliamentary accountability&equo; has not been lost on MEPs. 
 They will also certainly invite MPs from all 12 national parliaments, as well as governments and the commission, to special constitutional reform hearings to be held probably next summer. 
 Some leading MEPs believe an alliance with reform-minded MPs must be struck if leaders like Mrs Thatcher are to be prevented from setting up an economic and monetary union, which is essentially uncontrolled by any democratically-elected body. 
 One suggestion is to create a European Parliament senate or upper house, consisting of delegations of MPs in proportion to their strength in their national parliaments. 
 Only when all these questions have been answered will the 12 governments decide whether to recommend the amended Rome Treaty to their parliaments. 
 That will require unanimity. 
 But all the signs are that if Britain still withholds its endorsement, the other 11 will conclude an agreement among themselves outside the formal EC framework. 
 Leader comment, page 18; Splendid isolation, page 19 
 Britain banks on German doubts. 
 By Economics Correspondent 
 ALTHOUGH few summits ever produce clear-cut decisions, the main outcome of Strasbourg could be the reshaping of the European economy in the 1990s, with a process set in train which aims to create a third homogeneous bloc to challenge the United States and Japan by the end of the century. 
 At the nuts and bolts level, significant progress was made towards achieving a full internal market by January 1, 1993, with member countries heeding the warning of the Europen Commission president, Mr Jacques Delors, that further delays in implementing the raft of legislation could cause real problems. 
 On the single market, there was little dissension. 
 The summit unanimously agreed that a market of 320 million people would improve growth prospects and trade. 
 It was when the 12 started to discuss what would happen next that differences started to appear. 
 For the British delegation, the pace of change proposed was far too hasty. 
 With Eastern Europe in turmoil and the single market far from complete, it was risky to start talking about European Monetary Union and the social charter. 
 Mrs Thatcher sees nothing in the single market which cuts against the grain of her policies over the past decade, since it should promote the free enterprise culture within the EC. 
 However, most of the other members saw the social charter as a necessary counter-balance. 
 But, even more significantly, they viewed the goal of Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) as the logical next step of a single market. 
 The inter-governmental conference set up at Strasbourg to look at EMU will consider two main sets of proposals. 
 On the one hand, the British Government is championing the idea that currencies and economies should be left to compete against each other within a system which encourages both monetary co-operation and national autonomy. 
 The Treasury believes its plan would lead to a convergence of inflation at a lower rate and evolution towards fixed exchange rates. 
 On the other hand, there is the blueprint for EMU laid down in stages two and three of the Delors report, a far more ambitious scheme which would mean a European central bank, a single currency, a framework for budgetary policy and, in effect, pave the way for political union. 
 For many members of the EC, that would not be a problem. 
 They have acknowledged that the West German economy is by far the strongest in Europe and that as members of the exchange rate mechanism their interest rates are already affected by the Bundesbank's decisions. 
 Some countries &mdash; such as France &mdash; see EMU as a way of winning back some power from the West Germans, since a European central bank would mean all the members of the EC having a say in how policy is conducted. 
 As a result, President FRanois Mitterrand's support for Chancellor Helmut Kohl's policy on German reunification at Strasbourg was dependent on the West Germans agreeing to set up the government conference by the end of next year. 
 However, the Italians, currently running an enormous budget deficit, may not be happy with constraints on fiscal policy, while the less-developed nations will want structural reforms to ensure that the major economies do not cream off all the benefits. 
 The Bundesbank sees little virtue in surrendering power to a European central bank. 
 Mrs Thatcher believes that an Anglo-German alliance could be forged to scupper some, if not all, of stages two and three of the Delors report. 
 According to some West German sources, a softening of Whitehall's hardline on the social charter would help that process. 
 . 
 By Larry Elliott Economics Correspondent 
 THE chances of British entry into the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System before the next election were significantly reduced at the Strasbourg summit, as the Prime Minister maintained her hard-line opposition. 
 Despite the pressure which has been building up on the government in recent months, including growing dissent within her own party, she reiterated her old misgivings about the monetary system and added a new one for good measure. 
 Speaking at the end of the two days of talks, Mrs Thatcher said it had helped some countries combat inflation. 
 But she doubted whether it would work as well once the system, dominated by West Germany, was diluted by other countries less committed to the policy of bearing down on prices. 
 Its success had been that both the people of West Germany and its central bank, the Bundesbank, had a deep-seated fear of inflation. 
 They had known the effects of hyper-inflation and &bquo;were more fearful of it than anything else&equo;. 
 There was a danger that the anti-inflation tendencies of the Bundesbank would be watered down by other European countries where control of prices was less of a priority. 
 &bquo;The moment you go from the rigid and valuable discipline of German bank and people to mixing it up with other disciplines, other views, other &bquo;let's have a bit of inflation here and there&equo; economies, you lose the very thing which leads you to want to join.&equo; 
 Observers saw Mrs Thatcher's comments as little more than the latest in a series of delaying tactics. 
 They pointed out that economies prepared to allow &bquo;a bit of inflation here and there&equo; would include Britain, where the inflation rate is already one of the highest in the European Community and set to rise from 7.3 per cent to around 8 per cent later this week. 
 Indeed, the other EC countries put little pressure on the British delegation to speed up the ERM process, concluding that the time for concessions to Mrs Thatcher's doubts was now over. 
 New challenges face Civic Forum. 
 By Jon Bloomfield in Prague 
 THE announcement yesterday of Czechoslovakia's first majority non-Communist government since February, 1948 was a dramatic victory for the umbrella opposition group, the Civic Forum. 
 In the three weeks since its formation, the Forum has toppled the Stalinist old guard regime and negotiated a broad-based coalition government, including several of its own nominees. 
 It now faces the harder and more protracted task of ensuring a smooth and efficient transition to free elections and a democratically-elected government. 
 After the recent heady events, the Forum is now entering a new phase. 
 The qualities that have stood it in such good stead will now need to be applied in a different context. 
 Mr Jan Urban, one of the Forum's inner core, readily acknowledges the shift. 
 &bquo;We can't continue with this anarchist democracy, with everything based on goodwill and working 22 hours a day. 
 We shall have to change into a proper, organised, political force. 
 &bquo;We shall have to prove able to provide professionally competent people for government posts. 
 It's easy enough to find a President, but not everybody can improve the economy.&equo; 
 Stalinism is dead politically but it still dominates the security and state apparatus. 
 &bquo;We have to stay together until the dragon is slain&equo;, says Mr Urban. 
 But with the lure of free elections that is already proving difficult. 
 The jockeying for position has begun and the Civic Forum's statement that it intends to contest those elections has met with opposition from within its ranks. 
 The People's Party and the Czechoslovak Socialist Party, which functioned as proper political parties before 1948 and have since had a satellite existence, have begun to flex their muscles. 
 In Slovakia, Christian Democratic clubs have been formed before the establishment of a party, and it is expected that counterparts in Bohemia and Moravia will follow. 
 Following a large congress of agricultural co-operatives last weekend, preparation is in hand to form a new Peasants' Party. 
 And the Greens have also set themselves up. 
 Most significantly, perhaps, given the very deep commitment here to social justice and equality, moves are under way to establish a modern Socialist party. 
 Logic points to the emergence of a party that draws on both the Marxist traditions of the Prague Spring and on the social-democratic movement that was forcibly amalgamated with the Communists after 1948. 
 While understandable, these developments bring dangers. 
 As Mr Urban says: &bquo;Everyone wants to look colourful and be a leader but I am afraid of it. 
 I fear a political Balkanisation.&equo; 
 It is that fragmentation that the Forum has to strive to avoid. 
 Yet the skill it has shown in the last three weeks suggests it is well equipped for the tricky tasks ahead. 
 . 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 BY electing new and reform-minded leaders, East Germany's Communist party hopes to have won a breathing space in its battle for credibility and survival, six months before the first free elections are due to be held. 
 The new chairman, Dr Gregor Gysi, told an emergency party congress at the weekend that the SED had made a start in &bquo;breaking with Stalinism,&equo; but added that there was still a long way to go in &bquo;overcoming Stalinist structures&equo;. 
 By electing Dr Gysi by an overwhelming majority, the SED rank-and-file made a radical break with the past, rallying behind the party and its call for a &bquo;democratic renewal of socialism&equo;. 
 The SED underlined its willingness to leave behind old structures and traditions by abolishing both the politburo and the central committee. 
 It now has a chairman, four deputies and a 100-member executive. 
 The reforming trio of Dr Gysi, Mr Hans Modrow, and Mr Wolfgang Berghofer, the Mayor of Dresden, is now heading the party. 
 But in East Berlin and other East German cities yesterday, thousands joined protest marches and demanded a fundamental cleansing of the SED and thorough investigation of corruption charges against former party leaders. 
 Posters said the SED stood for Sauwirtschaft (piggery), Egoismus (selfishness) and Diebstahl (theft). 
 The party has lost half a million members since the fall of the old leaders under Mr Erich Honecker in the middle of October, and recent disclosures of corruption and economic mismanagement. 
 Its membership now stands at 1.78 million. 
 It was only after a stirring call for unity from Mr Modrow, the Prime Minister, that the 2,700 delegates rejected proposals for the SED to be dissolved and a new party founded. 
 However, the party will give itself a new name when it resumes the congress next weekend. 
 In a symbolic gesture to underline the grassroots drive for renewal, the delegates handed Dr Gysi an outsize broom with which to continue the purge of those still rooted in old thinking. 
 In a closed session, Mr Modrow appealed to the delegates not to allow the party to disintegrate. 
 He said that during his recent visit to Moscow, President Gorbachev had given a warning that the failure of East Germany's reform process would not only destabilise the GDR but also have &bquo;serious repercussions&equo; for perestroika in the Soviet Union. 
 Mr Modrow also criticised the party's former leader, Mr Egon Krenz, who he said had been far from honest in saying he was a reformer. 
 Mr Krenz, sitting dejected among the delegates in the penultimate row of the sports hall where the congress was held, stepped down as party leader a week ago. 
 The party congress apologised to East Germans, saying that the previous SED leaders were responsible for plunging the country into deep crisis which threatened its existence. 
 It promised to adopt more democratic structures and said it would be an equal partner with other political parties. 
 Dr Gysi pledged that glasnost and democracy would become features of East German society, but added that he did not underestimate the difficulties the party faced in regaining a measure of popular trust. 
 &bquo; 
 First of all, we have to learn how to trust one another again.&equo; 
 PAGE 
 Tough job ahead for new party chief. 
 By Our Correspondent in East Berlin 
 DR Gregor Gysi, East Germany's new Communist party (SED) chairman, was shunned as a dangerous idealist reformer by the country's discredited leaders only a few weeks ago. 
 But now the party faithful have appointed him crisis manager of a party still threatened by disintegration. 
 The defence lawyer, aged 41, who comes from an old Berlin Jewish family, has impressive qualifications for what may become his most difficult case so far. 
 His proven integrity, the inquisitorial style of the anti-corRuption drive he has led, and a combination of wit and considerable self-confidence are qualities badly needed by a party that has lost almost all credibility. 
 Dr Gysi made his attempt at power before 2,700 demoralised party delegates at this weekend's emergency congress as if delivering an impassioned plea in court, throwing up his arms and heaving his shoulders as he made a point. 
 The only candidate, he received 95 per cent of the votes. 
 He will head the party at least until a regular party congress confirms the new leadership structure ahead of East Germany's first free elections next May. 
 Dr Gysi had the advantage of being a completely new face in mainstream East German politics, after previously concentrating on defending dissidents and fighting for the recognition of opposition groups. 
 With his tie awry, an alert pair of eyes sparkling behind gold-rimmed spectacles, he impressed the party by coming to the point rather than indulging in what he called the prefabricated speeches he had always hated. 
 Dr Gysi, who has worked as a lawyer since 1971, and is divorced with two children, is the son of Dr Klaus Gysi, a former East German minister of culture, ambassador to Rome, and state secretary for church affairs. 
 The father opposed Hitler and spent a year in a Nazi concentration camp in occupied France, then returned to Berlin in 1945 to help build a new Germany. 
 The younger Dr Gysi used a term from the 1920s when he said he stood for a &bquo;third path between Stalinism and capitalism&equo;. 
 Recalling that &bquo;this country was built on ruins&equo;, he added that it remained his aim to strive for a classless society. 
 &bquo;I would describe myself as a Communist but other Socialist traditions are also important.&equo; 
 Points of accord. 
 By Reuter in Strasbourg 
 THE European Community leaders attending the summit here agreed to: 
 Help Eastern European countries embracing democracy, and declare support for the reform policies of President Mikhail Gorbachev; 
 Endorse reunification of the two Germanys 
 Accelerate the EC's drive towards economic and monetary union andmeet in the second half of 1990 to consider creating a single currency and a European central bank; 
 Adopt, with the exception of Britain, a charter guaranteeing workers' rights in the single European market to be created in 1992. 
 Dalai Lama warns Chinese. 
 By AP in Oslo 
 THE Dalai Lama, accepting the Nobel Peace Prize yesterday, warned he is reconsidering proposals to China to end the 40-year political struggle and occupation of his Himalayan homeland, Tibet. 
 The exiled spiritual and political leader of Tibet was awarded the prize for his advocacy of non-violence in seeking an end to Chinese rule. 
 He said China's rejection of his 1987 plan, which drew criticism from his own supporters as being too conciliatory, was forcing him to rethink his approach. 
 But &bquo;our struggle must remain non-violent and free of hatred,&equo; he added. 
 The Dalai Lama, who fled to exile in India after a failed uprising in 1959, has called for Tibetan autonomy over domestic affairs, with China retaining control over military and diplomatic affairs. 
 Beijing has rejected his formula. 
 In Beijing, the Communist Party's official newspaper People's Daily sharply criticised the Dalai Lama and the Norwegian Nobel Committee for its choice. 
 China's Foreign Ministry spokesman, Mr Jin Guihua, said the peace prize served only to encourage Tibetan separatists in their attempt to undermine the unity of the Chinese nation. 
 He called the Nobel decision &bquo;gross interference in China's internal affairs&equo;. 
 The Dalai Lama sent a message of encouragement to the democratic movement in China, which was suppressed with tanks in Tiananmen Square. 
 &bquo;In China the popular movement for democracy was crushed by brutal force in June this year. 
 But I do not believe the demonstrations were in vain, because the spirit of freedom has been rekindled among the Chinese people,&equo; he said. 
 Mitterrand in immigrant call. 
 President Franois Mitterrand of France yesterday called for the deportation of illegal immigrants and for sanctions against their employers, but said he believed guest workers should have voting rights. 
 His remarks, in a television interview, followed big electoral gains by the anti-immigrant far-right National Front. 
 -Reuter. 
 Roof kills Briton. 
 A British tourist, Mr Edward Gait, and a West German were crushed to death and 12 other foreigners were injured when a restaurant roof collapsed in Arona, Tenerife, police said yesterday. 
 -Reuter. 
 Food crisis. 
 The Sudanese Government said yesterday that three towns &mdash; including Juba, the biggest in the south &mdash; are about to run out of food. 
 Brigadier Dominic Kassiano, a member of the ruling junta, told the army newspaper Guwat al-Mussalah that food supplies in the towns of Juba, Wau, and Malakal would not last long. 
 -Reuter. 
 Belgian canonised. 
 The Pope yesterday canonised a Belgian cleric and teacher, Mutien Marie Wiaux, who died early this century. 
 -Reuter. 
 Troop pullout plan. 
 Fighting erupted in Beirut yesterday shortly after President Elias Hrawi was quoted as saying that Syrian troops would leave parts of Lebanon as soon as he had overcome the resistance of troops of General Michel Aoun in the Christian enclave. 
 -Reuter. 
 Taiwan anniversary. 
 Thousands of Taiwanese rallied yesterday to mark the 10th anniversary of an anti-government riot and demand the release of dissidents involved in the 1979 incident. 
 Opposition leaders made speeches during the gathering in the southern city of Kaohsiung, and some planned to walk along the route where the disturbances occurred. 
 -Reuter. 
 Operation for PM. 
 The Israeli Prime Minister, Mr Yitzhak Shamir, went into hospital yesterday for a hernia operation. 
 -Reuter. 
 Bus crash deaths. 
 At least 19 people were killed when a bus skidded off the road into a ditch in India's northeastern Assam state yesterday, the Press Trust of India reported. 
 -Reuter. 
 Passports promise. 
 MPs demanded yesterday that the Jordan Government free all political detainees. 
 The Prime Minister, Mr Mudar Badran, responded with promises to return passports confiscated from people suspected of political offences and amnesties for opponents. 
 -Reuter. 
 Chad elections. 
 Voters lined up before dawn in Chad yesterday to participate in the first national election in 20 years in this war-torn former French colony. 
 A &bquo;yes&equo; vote is expected in the referendum on a new constitution. 
 -Reuter.. 
 Malaysia visit. 
 Sir Michael Quinlan, Britain's permanent under-secretary of defence, arrived in Kuala Lumpur yesterday for three days of talks about purchases of military equipment. 
 -Reuter. 
 Superpower talks mooted in C America. 
 By Simon Tisdall in San Jose, Costa Rica 
 THE United States and Soviet Union will be invited to take part directly in resolving the conflicts in El Salvador and Nicaragua, under proposals worked out by the foreign ministers of the five Central American peace plan countries in a pre-summit meeting here. 
 The plan envisages &bquo;dialogues&equo; between the rebels of the Farabundo Marti National Liberation Front and the Salvadorean government, and between Nicaragua's Sandinista Government and the contras. 
 The talks would be held under the auspices of the UN International Commission for Support and Verification (CIAV), perhaps in the context of an international conference attended by the secretary-generals of the UN and the Organisation of American States. 
 The US and the Soviet Union would send representatives to both sets of talks. 
 In San Salvador, meanwhile, the FMLN issued a communique setting down its conditions for a truce. 
 The communique, sent to the Central American meeting through Venezuela's President Carlos Andres Perez, called for an immediate ceasefire, but demanded that several high-ranking military officers be scrapped and recent anti-terrorist laws be repealed. 
 The rebel terms were immediately rejected. 
 The plan to involve the superpowers is said to have the backing of President Oscar Arias of Costa Rica, the main motivator of the peace process. 
 The invitation to the superpowers, if approved at the Central American summit which opened belatedly here yesterday, could provide a way out of the continuing confrontation between the US and the Sandinistas and ensure free elections in Nicaragua in February. 
 The US could also use its influence with the Salvadorean Government and army to achieve a ceasefire and eventual settlement, it was suggested. 
 Central America is the only remaining area of foreign policy dispute between the superpowers. 
 Bringing in the superpowers, however, would force an unwilling Washington to confront the problems caused by its continuing non-military support for the contras. 
 On the other hand, Sandinista backing for the FMLN rebels would be likely to prove untenable. 
 So far the US, like the European Community, has preferred to leave the Central American leaders to work out their own solutions. 
 Last Friday, the US rejected a Soviet suggestion that the two superpowers act as guarantors of the peace process. 
 The discovery of 24 Sam-7 anti-aircraft missiles in the debris of a light plane which crashed in El Salvador last month threatened to wreck the summit and led the Salvadoreans to suspend relations with Nicaragua. 
 The issues of weapons shipments, attempts to achieve a ceasefire in El Salvador, and the stalled demobilisation of the contras were expected to dominate the two-day summit, which Mr Arias described at the weekend as critical to the future of the peace process. 
 Mr Arias, and the Honduran and Guatemalan presidents appeared pessimistic about prospects for the meeting. 
 Their gloom was deepened by exchanges at the foreign ministers' meeting, when Nicaragua accused Costa Rica and Honduras of conniving in support of the contras. 
 Sharp exchanges were also expected between the presidents of El Salvador and Nicaragua, Mr Alfredo Cristiani and Mr Daniel Ortega, over the missiles affair. 
 On arrival, however, Mr Cristiani said he was looking for reconciliation and wanted a ceasefire in El Salvador. 
 Mr Arias said at the weekend that the &bquo;mimimum for success&equo; was an agreement for an end to military operations by both sides in El Salvador. 
 The other main subject of discussion will be the refusal of the contras to demobilise under the terms of the Tela accord signed by the presidents last August. 
 Although the Sandinistas have repeatedly pledged democratic elections in February, Mr Arias was said to be fearful that a failure to disarm, relocate or disband the contras could provoke a Sandinista cross-border sweep against the rebels and cancellation of the polls. 
 Military &bquo;no coup&equo; pledge. 
 By Reuter in Sargodha, Pakistan 
 PAKISTAN'S army chief pledged yesterday that the day of military coups there was over and he sought no role in government. 
 Speaking to reporters during Pakistan's biggest military manoeuvres, General Mirza Aslam Beg said the army was dedicated to forging itself into a formidable fighting force and had no ambitions to meddle again in politics. 
 &bquo;If I had any political objectives I would have been sitting in my cantonment (barracks) scheming and planning,&equo; Gen Beg said. 
 Pakistan's history has been punctuated by army coups and periods of martial law, but Gen Beg has played a major stablising role since the death of military president Mohammad Zia-ul-Haq in August last year. 
 There were fears that the army would take over after Gen Zia died in an unexplained air crash, but Gen Beg made it clear that he favoured holding the elections that brought Benazir Bhutto to power. 
 Briefing reporters at the control headquarters for the Zarb- e-Momin exercises near Sargodha, he said the army &bquo;is not going to repeat the same history again&equo;. 
 Pakistan's military appears instead to be concerned with the country's neighbour and traditional foe &mdash; India. 
 Under the present Prime Minister, Ms Benazir Bhutto, relations have warmed but Pakistan's military remains unconvinced. 
 All Pakistan's military resources, bolstered by 150,000 troops freed in February from the eastern border with Afghanistan, are directed at India. 
 India and Pakistan have fought three wars since independence from Britain in 1947. 
 Emergency Communist party congress makes radical break with the past East German leader pleads for time to reform state. 
 By Anna Tomforde in East Berlin 
 BY electing new and reform-minded leaders, East Germany's Communist party hopes to have won a breathing space in its battle for credibility and survival, six months before the first free elections are due to be held. 
 The new chairman, Dr Gregor Gysi, told an emergency party congress at the weekend that the SED had made a start in &bquo;breaking with Stalinism,&equo; but added that there was still a long way to go in &bquo;overcoming Stalinist structures&equo;. 
 By electing Dr Gysi by an overwhelming majority, the SED rank-and-file made a radical break with the past, rallying behind the party and its call for a &bquo;democratic renewal of socialism&equo;. 
 The SED underlined its willingness to leave behind old structures and traditions by abolishing the politburo and the central committee. 
 It now has a chairman, four deputies and a 100-member executive. 
 The reforming trio of Dr Gysi, Mr Hans Modrow, and Mr Wolfgang Berghofer, the Mayor of Dresden, now heads the party. 
 But in East Berlin and other East German cities yesterday, thousands joined protest marches and demanded a fundamental cleansing of the SED and thorough investigation of corruption charges against former party leaders. 
 Posters said the SED stood for Sauwirtschaft (piggery), Egoismus (selfishness) and Diebstahl (theft). 
 The party has lost half a million members since the fall of the old leaders under Mr Erich Honecker in the middle of October, and recent disclosures of corruption and economic mismanagement. 
 Its membership now stands at 1.78 million. 
 It was only after a stirring call for unity from Mr Modrow, the Prime Minister, that the 2,700 delegates rejected proposals for the SED to be dissolved and a new party founded. 
 However, the party will give itself a new name when it resumes the congress next weekend. 
 In a symbolic gesture to underline the grassroots drive for renewal, the delegates handed Dr Gysi an outsize broom with which to continue the purge of those still rooted in old thinking. 
 In a closed session, Mr Modrow appealed to the delegates not to allow the party to disintegrate. 
 He said that during his recent visit to Moscow, President Gorbachev had given a warning that the failure of East Germany's reform process would not only destabilise the GDR but also have &bquo;serious repercussions&equo; for perestroika in the Soviet Union. 
 Mr Modrow also criticised the party's former leader, Mr Egon Krenz, who he said had been far from honest in saying he was a reformer. 
 Mr Krenz, sitting dejected among the delegates in the penultimate row of the sports hall where the congress was held, stepped down as party leader a week ago. 
 The party congress apologised to East Germans, saying that previous SED leaders plunged the country into deep crisis which threatened its existence. 
 It promised to adopt more democratic structures and said it would be an equal partner with other political parties. 
 Dr Gysi pledged that glasnost and democracy would become features of East German society, but added that he did not underestimate the difficulties the party faced in regaining a measure of popular trust. 
 &bquo; 
 First of all, we have to learn how to trust one another again.&equo; 
 Aquino calls for harsh penalties. 
 By Reuter in Manila 
 PRESIDENT Corazon Aquino yesterday called for tough sentences against coup leaders while the military launched a big manhunt to track down those still at large. 
 &bquo;We have to make sure that justice is done, that those who are guilty will be meted out the full penalty,&equo; she told reporters after attending a funeral service for a pilot who died wiping out the rebels' air support in last week's attempt to overthrow her. 
 Her call came after the surrender of the last group of rebels holding out at a military air base at Mactan in the central Philippines. 
 A military spokesman said that a batch of 120 had been put on a ship to return to their units in Cagayan de Oro on the southern island of Mindanao. 
 The maximum penalty for mutiny in the Philippines is a life sentence, but in five previous coup attempts the most severe punishment for leaders was 12 years' hard labour. 
 Urging the country to unite behind her after the trauma of the sixth uprising against her government in less than four years, Ms Aquino said she was determined not to allow &bquo;any aggressor to wrest our freedom and democracy away from us. 
 Two air force helicopters dropped flowers from the sky during the service for air force Major Danilo Atienza, who died after destroying rebel planes which had attacked Ms Aquino's palace on December 1. 
 The military said it had launched a big manhunt for army coup leaders who escaped when their men surrendered. 
 The armed forces chief-of-staff, General Renato de Villa, told reporters the military was asking President Aquino to offer cash rewards to those who turn in rebel leaders. 
 Around 400 leftwing priests, students and human rights activists staged a demonstration near Ms Aquino's palace yesterday and condemned her for seeking US help to crush the coup attempt. 
 They urged people to join Communist guerrillas to overthrow her government and later marched to the US embassy where they chanted &bquo;out with US bases&equo; and mocked President George Bush for offering military aid to Aquino. 
 An armed forces spokesman, Mr Oscar Florendo, said about 1,800 rebel officers and men had surrendered since the six-day coup attempt was snuffed out in Manila last Thursday. 
 Still at large were several of the top men, including cashiered Colonel Gregorio Gringo Honasan, leader of a coup attempt against Ms Aquino in August 1987, and Lieutenant-Colonel Rafael Galvez, who led a siege of Manila's business district. 
 Kashmir set to give in to kidnappers. 
 By Derek Brown in New Delhi 
 FRANTIC attempts were being made last night in the northern state of Jammu and Kashmir to negotiate with the secessionist rebels who kidnapped the daughter of the Indian Home Minister, Mufti Mohammed Sayeed. 
 Ms Rubiya Sayeed, aged 21, has not been seen since Friday night, when she was seized by seven gunmen from a minibus in the state capital, Srinagar. 
 The kidnappers, claiming to belong to the Jammu and Kashmir National Liberation Front (JKNLF), later demanded the release of five imprisoned militants. 
 They said Ms Sayeed would be killed unless the five were freed by 7pm today. 
 But last night, JKNLF leaders in Pakistan, where the movement maintains its headquarters in exile, said they would postpone the execution until it became &bquo;unavoidable&equo;. 
 Mr Amanullah Khan, chairman of the JKNLF, told a press conference in Rawalpindi that Ms Sayeed should not be condemned for the crimes of her father, whom he denounced as a traitor. 
 Mr Khan was deported from Britain some years ago, after Kashmiri militants killed a Birmingham-based Indian diplomat. 
 He denied that he had prior knowledge of Ms Sayeed's abduction, but confirmed that the JKNLF leadership was in contact with its &bquo;field workers&equo;. 
 Last night, the Jammu and Kashmir Minister, Mr Mangat Ram Sharma, said the state government would comply with the kidnappers' demand. 
 But negotiations had been complicated by the militants changing the names of the men they wanted out of prison. 
 Mr Sharma told the United News of India agency: &bquo;I am sure an agreement will be reached with the militants tonight or tomorrow morning, as we will release the terrorists demanded by them.&equo; 
 Three of the five men named in the latest militant list were brought to Srinagar last night. 
 Two others are imprisoned in the state capital. 
 The kidnap poses a severe test for the infant government of the Prime Minister, Mr Vishwanath Pratap Singh, which has been in power only nine days. 
 The appointment of the mufti was applauded as a bold gesture of reconciliation to the Muslim community. 
 Delhi's response has been complicated by the existence of the lame-duck Kashmiri state government of Dr Farooq Abdullah, who fought last month's general election in alliance with the then governing Congress party, and which is deeply unpopular in the valley. 
 To augment the state machinery, the central government has rushed senior officials and team of troops from the Black Cat commando unit to Srinagar. 
 Meanwhile, there has been a torrent of condemnation of the kidnapping, including several from Indian Muslim groups, who denounced it as grossly un-Islamic. 
 Ms Sayeed, a third-year medical student, was not involved in the turbulent politics of the Kashmir Valley. 
 The JKNLF and several other militant groups have stepped up their campaigns of civil unrest, strikes, and outright terrorism, to press their demands for a free Kashmir or union with Pakistan. 
 Delhi has blamed the unrest on Islamabad, accusing it of arming, training and inspiring the subversives, a charge Pakistan denies. 
 Superpower talks mooted in C America. 
 By Simon Tisdall in San Jose, Costa Rica 
 THE United States and Soviet Union will be invited to take part directly in resolving the conflicts in El Salvador and Nicaragua, under proposals worked out by the foreign ministers of the five Central American peace plan countries in a pre-summit meeting here. 
 The plan envisages &bquo;dialogues&equo; between the rebels of the Farabundo Marti National Liberation Front and the Salvadorean government, and between Nicaragua's Sandinista Government and the contras. 
 The talks would be held under the auspices of the UN International Commission for Support and Verification (CIAV), perhaps in the context of an international conference attended by the secretary-generals of the UN and the Organisation of American States. 
 The US and the Soviet Union would send representatives to both sets of talks. 
 In San Salvador, meanwhile, the FMLN issued a communique setting down its conditions for a truce. 
 The communique, sent to the Central American meeting through Venezuela's President Carlos Andres Perez, called for an immediate ceasefire, but demanded that several high-ranking military officers be scrapped and recent anti-terrorist laws be repealed. 
 The rebel terms were immediately rejected. 
 The plan to involve the superpowers is said to have the backing of President Oscar Arias of Costa Rica, the main motivator of the peace process. 
 The invitation to the superpowers, if approved at the Central American summit which opened belatedly here yesterday, could provide a way out of the continuing confrontation between the US and the Sandinistas and ensure free elections in Nicaragua in February. 
 The US could also use its influence with the Salvadorean Government and army to achieve a ceasefire and eventual settlement, it was suggested. 
 Central America is the only remaining area of foreign policy dispute between the superpowers. 
 Bringing in the superpowers, however, would force an unwilling Washington to confront the problems caused by its continuing non-military support for the contras. 
 On the other hand, Sandinista backing for the FMLN rebels would be likely to prove untenable. 
 So far the US, like the European Community, has preferred to leave the Central American leaders to work out their own solutions. 
 Last Friday, the US rejected a Soviet suggestion that the two superpowers act as guarantors of the peace process. 
 The discovery of 24 Sam-7 anti-aircraft missiles in the debris of a light plane which crashed in El Salvador last month threatened to wreck the summit and led the Salvadoreans to suspend relations with Nicaragua. 
 The issues of weapons shipments, attempts to achieve a ceasefire in El Salvador, and the stalled demobilisation of the contras were expected to dominate the two-day summit, which Mr Arias described at the weekend as critical to the future of the peace process. 
 Mr Arias, and the Honduran and Guatemalan presidents appeared pessimistic about prospects for the meeting. 
 Their gloom was deepened by exchanges at the foreign ministers' meeting, when Nicaragua accused Costa Rica and Honduras of conniving in support of the contras. 
 Sharp exchanges were also expected between the presidents of El Salvador and Nicaragua, Mr Alfredo Cristiani and Mr Daniel Ortega, over the missiles affair. 
 On arrival, however, Mr Cristiani said he was looking for reconciliation and wanted a ceasefire in El Salvador. 
 Mr Arias said at the weekend that the &bquo;mimimum for success&equo; was an agreement for an end to military operations by both sides in El Salvador. 
 The other main subject of discussion will be the refusal of the contras to demobilise under the terms of the Tela accord signed by the presidents last August. 
 Although the Sandinistas have repeatedly pledged democratic elections in February, Mr Arias was said to be fearful that a failure to disarm, relocate or disband the contras could provoke a Sandinista cross-border sweep against the rebels and cancellation of the polls. 
 Slave debate revived in US. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 THE long-mocked idea of reparations to compensate black Americans for the slavery experienced by their ancestors is now before the US Congress, and its supporters say the &dollar;1.25 billion package to compensate Japanese-Americans who were interned during the second world war has created a legal precedent. 
 Mr John Conyers, a black Democratic congressman from Detroit, has introduced legislation to establish a federal commission to study the impact of slavery upon blacks and to recommend to Congress a range of appropriate remedies, including possible reparations. 
 A full reparations bill has no realistic chance of being enacted, but it promises to re-open a potentially bruising debate about the black experience in the US. 
 In the last session, Congress passed a bill to give some 60,000 Japanese-Americans compensation of about &dollar;20,000 (&pound;12,500) each for having been interned, without trial, simply for being Japanese, after the 1941 Japanese assault on Pearl Harbour. 
 Lawyers are already claiming there is no real precedent, because the Japanese being compensated are those who personally experienced internment, whereas no US black can claim direct and personal damage by &bquo;the peculiar institution&equo;. 
 &bquo;Reparations has been on the agenda for almost every generation of black Americans,&equo; said Mr Walter Fauntroy, the District of Columbia's representative in Congress. 
 &bquo;It helps promote and stimulate more thinking about making adequate restitution for black slaves.&equo; 
 Mr Kwame Afo, a leader of the Provisional Government of the Republic of New Africa, one of the nationalist groups prominent in the campaign for reparations, estimated the costs to the US Government of proper reparation at some &dollar;4.1 trillion &mdash; close to a full year of the US gross national product. 
 Mr Afo's organisation also demands that Congress grant blacks the five southern states of Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Louisiana, and South Carolina to be established as a separate nation. 
 Security police wait for boot as people's power arrives. 
 By Reuter in East Berlin 
 EAST Germany's vast security police apparatus, once a fearsome state within a state, looks like becoming the next centre of Stalinist power to fall to the country's &bquo;people power&equo; revolution. 
 The hulking headquarters of the Office for National Security, which has branches across the country, stands behind a high wall, cameras on its roof trained on the streets all around. 
 But on the inside, the revolution has already arrived. 
 Police stand guard, not to keep people out but to ensure nothing is taken away as investigators sift through secret files, looking for evidence of official misdeeds. 
 The security apparatus, known as Stasi by the people who feared it, is on its last legs after 39 years of running agents, snooping on dissidents and harassing critics of the ruling Communist party. 
 Its former head, Mr Erich Mielke, for years the man who knew all the secrets and pulled all the strings, is under arrest and facing corruption charges. 
 The new head, Lieutenant-General Wolfgang Schwanitz, has rushed to polish its tarnished image by opening its doors to citizens demanding entry and cutting staff by 50 per cent. 
 Those who do leave are having problems finding employers who will take them on, or being accepted by new colleagues. 
 &bquo;This office has been so discredited that I think it has to be disbanded,&equo; the party's new reformist leader, Dr Gregor Gysi, said at the weekend. 
 The exact size of its staff is secret but was estimated at about 20,000 in the early 1980s. 
 The final decision on their fate lies with the government. 
 East Germans expect it to scrap the security police wing while shifting its intelligence work to the interior ministry or a new agency. 
 Gorbachev tough over German unity. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 IN HIS strongest warning yet that Moscow would brook no attempt to reunify the two Germanys, President Gorbachev has pledged that the Soviet Union would ensure &bquo;no harm&equo; came to East Germany. 
 The German Democratic Republic &bquo;is our strategic ally and a member of the Warsaw Pact,&equo; he told a Central Committee meeting on Saturday. 
 In an implicit reminder that 380,000 Soviet troops were still stationed on East German soil, he said: &bquo;We firmly declared that we will see to it that no harm comes to the GDR.&equo; 
 The Soviet Union was doing everything possible to &bquo;prevent interference from outside and to neutralise attempts at such interference&equo; in socialist countries undergoing dramatic political change in Eastern Europe, notably East Germany. 
 But &bquo;some western countries cannot resist the temptation to influence the processes under way.&equo; 
 Noting that Communists were either sharing power or had lost it in several countries, he promised Moscow would not interfere in the internal affairs of any east European nation, since it believed in the free right of all states to choose their own system. 
 But, he warned, &bquo;they are not only our allies, but also our friends and neighbours. 
 We seek to ensure progress and stability in every way, as well as the inviolability of the post-war frontiers of all European states.&equo; 
 Post-war realities had to be recognised, and this meant the existence of two sovereign German states, members of the United Nations. 
 &bquo;Departure from this threatens to destabilise Europe.&equo; 
 However, Mr Gorbachev made clear this did not mean the entire relationship between the two Germanys had to be frozen for ever. 
 &bquo;Peaceful co-operation between them can and must develop. 
 As for the future, it will take shape in the course of history,&equo; within a European framework. 
 Speaking approvingly of his recent meetings with various European leaders, Mr Gorbachev singled out President Mitterrand, whom he met in Kiev last week, for special praise, particularly because of his &bquo;respect for present realities and the inviolability of established borders.&equo; 
 He spoke optimistically about better relations between East and West in Europe, as well as improving ties with the United States. 
 This not only gave good grounds for peace and stability in Europe, but also opened up the prospect for bigger cuts in military spending. 
 This should do much to ease the burden the arms race had put on the Soviet economy. 
 Important differences with Washington remained, &bquo;but it is important that a different, more businesslike and reasonable approach has appeared. 
 Accordingly, we are now taking a more optimistic view on prospects for a peaceful settlement.&equo; 
 No compromise, says deselected Labour MP. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 THE Labour MP, Mr Frank Field, who was deselected by his Birkenhead constituency party on Friday night, is expected to tell Mr Neil Kinnock today that he will not compromise on his demand for one member, one vote in the party. 
 Mr Field, MP for Birkenhead since 1979, won a majority of the individual members' votes in last week's secret ballot. 
 He is unlikely to be satisfied with an offer to re-run the reselection procedure if it can be proved that there have been any serious breaches of the party's rules. 
 Mr Field lost the nomination to a local Transport and General Workers' union official, Mr Paul Davies, because he failed to secure sufficient votes in the trade union section. 
 A Labour Party spokesman said yesterday that Mr Kinnock would ask for evidence of Mr Field's claims of Militant activity in the Birkenhead party when he meets the MP today. 
 &bquo;In order to be valid, the reselection in Birkenhead had to be run in accordance with the rule book,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;If there is evidence to the contrary, then the National Executive Committee will act. 
 All that is material to this case is what substantial evidence Frank has to back up his claim about Militant infiltration. 
 Everything else is immaterial.&equo; 
 The Labour leadership is keen to separate the issues of one member, one vote and the controversy surrounding the reselection in Birkenhead which has been run under the local electoral college rules approved by the party conference. 
 Senior party figures argue that it is impossible for the rules to be changed to restore the nomination to the sitting MP. 
 Any retrospective rule change would place a question mark over the reselections of Mr George Galloway in Glasgow Hillhead and Mr Ron Brown in Edinburgh Leith, who were both nominated on a majority of trade union votes. 
 Mr Field has agreed not to make any statement about his next course of action before his 11.30am meeting with Mr Kinnock, but he said that his supporters in Birkenhead had told him they did not want to see a fudge. 
 Mr Field has previously threatened to force a byelection if he won a majority of the individual votes. 
 &bquo;My supporters in Birkenhead have been telling me I should not be in a mood to compromise,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They do not want a fix but a resolution of the issues, that the Labour Party moves to becoming more democratic and an immediate resolution of the situation on Merseyside. 
 &bquo;When you have the Russian empire collapsing within a matter of weeks it seems ridiculous to say we cannot move faster.&equo; 
 Although Mr Kinnock and leading party figures have publicly backed moves towards one member, one vote in the party the annual conference is not due to discuss the issue until 1991. 
 The influential soft-left pressure group, the Labour Co-ordinating Committee, yesterday issued a statement saying that unless impropriety could be proved the result in Birkenhead should stand. 
 &bquo;The only way to resolve this problem is for the leadership to announce its intention to propose rule changes for next year's party conference to introduce straight, undiluted one member, one vote for the selection of party candidates,&equo; it added. 
 &bquo;In the meantime everyone in the party has a responsibility to stick to the rules agreed by the party conference.&equo; 
 Mr Davies yesterday offered to re-run the contest under the party's 1985 rules when the matter was decided at the party's general management committee by delegates elected by wards and the trade unions. 
 &bquo;I am not interested whatsoever in causing any damage to the Labour movement,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It is my life. 
 As he &lsqb;Mr Field&rsqb; was elected and then reselected under the old 1985 procedure and he accepted those victories with a certain amount of good grace, I would hope he would accept that procedure. 
 If he loses I hope he would accept it with equal good grace and if he wins I will be a good loser and help him out in the general election.&equo; 
 But Mr Field immediately rejected the offer, saying he was not surprised that Mr Davies had not suggested re-running it on a vote of the individual membership. 
 &bquo;Birkenhead has finished the block vote,&equo; he added. 
 Mr Field has also written to Mr Rod Todd, general secretary of the TGWU, demanding an inquiry into the union's branches on the Wirral, Merseyside, before the selection procedure was under way. 
 Mr Todd made clear at the weekend that he thought Mr Field was a bad loser, saying he appeared to think he was God's gift to Birkenhead. 
 The reselection went to two rounds. 
 The first round result was: Individual members' section: Frank Field 159, Paul Davies 75, Cathy Wilson (Militant supporter) 48. 
 Trade union section: Field 15, Davies 25, Wilson 11. 
 On the second round Ms Wilson was eliminated. 
 Individual members' section: Field 165; Davies 113. 
 Trade Unions: Field 16, Davies 35. 
 Since the trade union votes count for 40 per cent of the local electoral college, Mr Davies was declared the nominee. 
 Some 282 of the 410 members of the Birkenhead party voted in the contest. 
 Final bid to salvage &pound;5bn plan for station. 
 ALAST ditch attempt to salvage the &pound;5 billion scheme to redevelop King's Cross station will be made by British Rail tomorrow, writes Michael Smith. 
 A special committee of MPs meets to decide the fate of a controversial bill under which the main line and underground stations would be transformed and a new terminal and platform built for Channel Tunnel trains. 
 The committee, chaired by Mr Neil Hamilton, Tory MP for Tatton, was forced to delay a decision last week when two Labour MPs, Mr Bob Clay (Sunderland North) and Mr George Galloway (Hillhead) could not attend. 
 Tomorrow's meeting is seen as the last opportunity to decide on the bill which would allow redevelopment to commence in 1991. 
 BR regards the 120-acre project as a unique opportunity to relieve congestion on crowded suburban commuter services, upgrade InterCity facilities, and provide the necessary increase in capacity to cope with the Channel Tunnel rail link. 
 Postponement would mean a two-year delay in improving services from King's Cross and the nearby St Pancras station and the implementation of safety measures arising from the King's Cross underground fire in 1987. 
 Local residents and the London boroughs of Camden and Islington want the redevelopment shelved until the Commons has seen the delayed bill for the high speed rail link, not now due to be resubmitted until next November. 
 The boroughs also express fears that redevelopment will mean worsening traffic congestion and the loss of homes and jobs. 
 BR is expected to argue that the location of the Channel Tunnel terminal at King's Cross is secondary to the major improvement in domestic services and will call the BR Property Board chairman, Sir James Swaffield, and London Regeneration Corporation chief, Mr Godfrey Bradman, to back up its case. 
 Safe drink limit is challenged. 
 By Stephen Cook 
 DRINKING limits currently recommended by doctors are challenged in a book which says an extremist &bquo;anti-alcohol lobby&equo; has become too influential. 
 One contributor to Drinking to Your Health, published today, says that most men can drink up to 70 measures of alcohol a week without seriously affecting their health, but 42 measures would be safe. 
 Dr Thomas Stuttaford, a former Conservative MP who works for the private health group, Bupa, also says moderate drinking can reduce stress, prevent heart disease, provide nutrition, and help relaxation. 
 The medical Royal Colleges recently agreed that 21 measures a week for men and 14 for women is sensible. 
 Damage to liver, brain and muscles begins above that, they say. 
 A measure is a half pint, a glass of wine, or a pub spirit. 
 The book is published by the Social Affairs Unit, a rightwing pressure group headed by Dr Digby Anderson. 
 His introduction says that experts' recommendations will soon amount to teetotalism. 
 He said yesterday that there was studies of harm from alcohol varied greatly, and the basis for 14 and 21 was &bquo;not all that solid.&equo; 
 Other contributors say that informal social restraints on drinking are more effective than government control, advertising does not induce excessive drinking, and random breath testing might reduce drink-driving. 
 Education about alcohol in schools cannot compensate for home and community, it is argued, and education should value alcohol use and encourage individual responsibility. 
 Mr Don Steele, spokesman for Action on Alcohol Abuse, said the book tried to revive arguments that the industry lost three years ago. 
 He defended the 14 and 21 figures, which most people stayed under. 
 &bquo;We're not anti-alcohol, but we're worried about health and marketing. 
 Twenty per cent of people in hospital are there because they drink too much.&equo; 
 EC to soothe Moscow on Germany. 
 By John Palmer in Strasbourg 
 EUROPEAN Community leaders will move quickly this week to reassure the Soviet Union that their support for the future &bquo;unity&equo; of the German people at the weekend EC summit is conditional on the maintenance of peace and stability in Europe. 
 President Franois Mitterrand will spell out the conditions for unification set by the European Community governments to President Gorbachev. 
 The same message will be delivered when the ambassadors of the Four Powers &mdash; Britain, France, the United States and the Soviet Union &mdash; meet in Berlin today. 
 The meeting, believed to have been suggested by the Soviet Union, is the first such encounter since 1971. 
 This implies a dramatic shift in Moscow's non-committal stance on the Western allies' 1987 Berlin Initiative, which is expected to be the main subject of today's talks. 
 The plan calls for Berlin to be made a centre for international conferences and youth exchanges and for improving air traffic to the city. 
 It also suggests picking Berlin as an Olympic Games site. 
 The summit declaration on Germany, which spoke about &bquo;unity&equo; rather than &bquo;reunification&equo;, was reached after a protracted and at times acrimonious debate among the 12 EC heads of government. 
 Although the summit unanimously endorsed the declaration, one foreign minister said later: &bquo;We leave Strasbourg with some sense of unfinished business over the German question.&equo; 
 There was a sense of nervousness about the evolution of the East German situation. 
 &bquo;The fact that the regime has so quickly and so completely imploded in East Germany could risk a reunification of Germany almost by default before long,&equo; one diplomat said. 
 &bquo;The key question is how will the Federal Chancellor and his government play this whole issue in their own general election next year?&equo; 
 &bquo;If they are tempted to play the nationalist card to ensure their re-election and counter the far right Republicans, that could make the Soviet Union very uneasy indeed,&equo; he went on. 
 &bquo;If the process is allowed to achieve a more relaxed rhythm of its own and we are given enough time to handle the international consequences, the Soviet leadership probably could live with the kind of confederal links between the two Germanys which are under discussion now.&equo; 
 For her part, Mrs Thatcher emphasised that the references to future German unity in the declaration was &bquo;a very carefully drafted section and we spent a very long time on it&equo;. 
 The summit declaration said: &bquo;We seek the strengthening of the state of peace in Europe on which the German people will regain its unity through free self determination. 
 This process should take place peacefully and democratically, in full respect of the relevant agreements and treaties and in all the principles defined in the Helsinki Final Act, in the context of dialogue and East-West co-operation. 
 It has also to be placed in the perspective of European integration.&equo; 
 The summit also agreed to aim at completing an ambitious co-operation agreement with the new government in East Germany before the middle of next year. 
 This could lead to a democratic East Germany moving on a &bquo;fast track&equo; to a privileged form of associate membership of the Community ahead of other reforming East European states by virtues of its very close economic links with West Germany. 
 turn to page 20, col 4 
 EC reassures Moscow on unity continued from page one The Soviet Foreign Minister, Mr Eduard Shevardnadze, is expected in Brussels on Wednesday to sign a trade and co-operation agreement with the EC, French officials said. 
 The 12 EC foreign ministers will, on the same day, join a meeting of the 24 Western industrialised nations to review emergency aid to Hungary and Poland. 
 While accelerating moves towards faster internal integration, the Strasbourg summit also set an equally tight timetable for setting up a common &bquo;European economic area&equo; by the end of next year with the six countries of the European Free Trade Association. 
 The commercial aspect of this 18-nation common market are relatively uncontentious but what remains to be resolved is how far the EFTA governments will be consulted before decisions of the EC Council of Ministers. 
 The Irish Government, which takes over the Presidency of the European Community at the end of the month has expressed its determination to give higher priority to environmental issues. 
 Having simply ignored Mrs Thatcher's opposition to economic and monetary union and the Social Charter, EC leaders were at pains not to underline her complete isolation. 
 President Mitterrand spoke of his &bquo;respect&equo; for her arguments, Chancellor Kohl said she had &bquo;not refused her co-operation&equo;, and Mr Haughey said she had &bquo;participated fully&equo;. 
 Given Mrs Thatcher's relatively non-confrontational stance at Strasbourg, they hope by the time key decisions have to be taken over EMU next year, the British Government will have reviewed its EC strategy. 
 Delors plan, page 7; Leader comment, page 18; Michael White on splendid isolation, Elie Wiesel on German reunification page 19 
 Fast moves on soccer draw. 
 By Staff Reporters 
 THE English soccer authorities have moved with uncharacteristic speed to try to minimise possible fall-out from the World Cup meeting of England and Holland, the European teams whose supporters are most associated with hooliganism, in the Sardinian capital of Cagliari next summer. 
 Cagliari &mdash; population 225,000, stadium capacity 38,800 &mdash; is a city with its own strong soccer culture, and its own football hero, Luigi Riva (pictured below, and, left, as celebrated by a lifesize statue in a local bar), who played for Cagliari as a left-winger when they won their one Italian league title in 1970 and was a prodigious scorer. 
 After the World Cup draw at the weekend, which paired teams to play in Sardinia, the Football Association chief executive, Mr Graham Kelly, spoke with his Dutch counterpart and said there would be close liaison in the next few months. 
 Ticket allocations will be of particular concern. 
 &bquo;We have to get it all battened down very tightly,&equo; he added. 
 Mr Millichip has also held discussions with officials of the Irish Republic &mdash; also drawn in the same group. 
 Mr Kelly said that everything would be strictly controlled in Cagliari. 
 &bquo;The points of entry will be very closely watched and we will co-operate fully with the authorities in Sardinia. 
 &bquo;We started talking and planning months ago. 
 Now the build-up will become intense.&equo; 
 The pairing was the one feared most, because of painful memories of violence at last year's European championship in West Germany. 
 But Mr Kelly said: &bquo;A lot of people are applying to join our travel club. 
 We are hopeful that it will be a true festival of football.&equo; 
 Not only do the World Cup organisers have to keep England's and Holland's supporters apart, they will also have to cope with Ireland's peaceful &bquo;green army&equo;, which could number 20,000. 
 But the FA pointed out that Holland and the Irish Republic would be based primarily in Sicily and would play only one game each in Sardinia. 
 Mr Colin Moynihan, the sports minister is expected to visit Italy again in early spring, perhaps travelling to Sardinia. 
 Fifa, soccer's world governing body, played down the pairing. 
 A spokesman, Mr Guido Tognoni, said: &bquo;I have the feeling everyone expects hooligans, but we are being more positive.&equo; 
 Mr Roberto Dal Cortivo, the Cagliari official responsible for sport, sounded optimistic. 
 &bquo;We are not worried about violence. 
 Every city wanted these teams &mdash; they pull in a big crowd.&equo; 
 Mr Antonio Matarrese, head of the Italian Olympic Committee, suggested that having the match in Sardinia might be something of a blessing. 
 &bquo;That way the supporters can be more readily controlled, by being sent to islands where they can be neutralised.&equo; 
 However, Irish centre-back Mick McCarthy predicted misery for Irish supporters who would have to hop between Sardinia and Sicily. 
 David Lacey, page 14 
 Photographs: Toby Glanville 
 Agency &bquo;neglecting safeguards&equo; on fish farms. 
 By Rob Edwards 
 THE European Commission is to investigate complaints that the Government has neglected its environmental responsibilities towards fish farming in Scotland. 
 The Marine Conservation Society, a national organisation, alleges in a 54-page document that Britain has failed to meet the terms of a European directive requiring an assessment to be carried out where a proposed development is likely to have a significant environmental impact. 
 The society says that the Crown Estate, the governmental agency responsible for leasing the seabed to fish farmers, is an inappropriate overseer because it has a financial interest in promoting the industry. 
 The estate is criticised for lacking ecological expertise, being undemocratic and largely unaccountable. 
 It is said to have made no provision for the protection of sea lochs, to operate without an overall development plan, and to have made little attempt to monitor the farms it has approved. 
 The estate's guidance notes on environmental assessments are called &bquo;vague and minimal&equo; and some criteria &bquo;arbitrary and extreme&equo;. 
 There is no requirement to prevent or reduce any significant adverse effects on the environment. 
 Mr Martin Gravestock, the estate's chief official in Scotland, rejects the accusations. 
 &bquo;The Crown Estate is a public body which is fully accountable for its actions. 
 We are able to stand aside and not have regard to financial implications,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We do have a clear strategy. 
 We carry out all our assessments in a professional way, using professional staff who have to balance many things including environmental and ecological issues.&equo; 
 A spokeswoman for the European Commission said that the complaint would be investigated. 
 Previous complaints by environmental organisations, like those on drinking water, have resulted in the Government being prosecuted. 
 Since the directive came into force in July last year only one fish farming application has been subject to an environmental assessment: a plan last October by Marine Harvest for salmon cages in Lamlash bay on the island of Arran. 
 The society argues that the assessment was inaccurate and inadequate, particularly as it made no mention of potentially toxic chemicals. 
 The assessment was accepted and the application granted by the Crown Estate, although the area of the farm was reduced and the number of salmon cages cut from 58 to 30 for other reasons. 
 Mr Gravestock denied that the environmental assessment was inadequate, but added: &bquo;We do accept that there were lessons to be learnt.&equo; 
 Two children die, as number of cases triples in a week Hospitals on brink of &bquo;red alert&equo; for flu. 
 By Gareth Parry 
 HOSPITALS in many parts of England and Wales may be put on &bquo;red alert&equo; and ban non-emergency admissions from today as the worst flu epidemic for 14 years sweeps the country, increasing admissions and seriously depleting nursing staff. 
 The Royal College of General Practitioners' research unit has designated the virus H3N2, English Flu, as having reached epidemic proportions, affecting more than 100 people in every 100,000. 
 The number of cases have more than tripled in a week, registering the highest increase since the 1975-76 epidemic &mdash; when a peak of 350 cases per 100,000 were recorded and 1,283 people died. 
 As thousands of schoolchildren have been kept at home in south Wales and the West Country, the epidemic is already believed to have claimed two young victims &mdash; Daniel Warrior, aged seven, from Bracknell, Berks, who died after his younger sister and mother both had flu last week, and 16-month-old Louise Allen, from Hemel Hempstead, Herts, who died in hospital on Saturday. 
 Children are believed to be more vulnerable than adults, who are thought to have built up an immunity after a similar, but much less virulent virus appeared last year. 
 Many hospitals in the north, south and west of England and in south Wales have already closed wards, unable to accommodate people with bronchial complications, like pneumonia. 
 Others have appealed for retired nurses to help bridge staff shortages. 
 The district general hospital in Barnsley, south Yorkshire called for such volunteers when 100 staff went sick. 
 Wards have been closed and admissions restricted in Southampton, Sheffield, Scunthorpe, Derby and Nottingham. 
 Many hospitals have brought in agency nurses. 
 The London Emergency Bed Service, which monitors the availability of hospital beds, yesterday recorded an increase of up to 50 per cent in demand. 
 It will decide whether to impose a &bquo;red alert&equo;, for the first time since 1975, after collating the latest figures today. 
 Last week the service issued half of London with its first &bquo;yellow&equo; alert (one stage before &bquo;red&equo;) for 11 years. 
 &bquo;We are asking hospitals to mix up their specialities so that ENT (ear, nose and throat) patients are on wards with patients with other complaints,&equo; said Ms Sandra Mead, a senior watchkeeper. 
 &bquo;A number of hospitals have had problems because of the nurses that have been hit by the epidemic. 
 King's College is facing some difficulty today and the Whittington had problems yesterday. 
 Hospitals are always working at near-capacity, so anything that upsets the balance automatically causes more strain.&equo; 
 She added that the situation had got worse &bquo;almost overnight&equo;. 
 Victims of English Flu suffer the classic symptoms of chestiness, weakness, fever and aching limbs. 
 Like other strains of flu, there is no known cure. 
 A Department of Health spokeswoman said: &bquo;Doctors are advising people with high temperatures to take analgesics and hot drinks to relieve the symptoms and keep warm.&equo; 
 Patients usually recover after two or three days in bed. 
 FoE condemns Britain's environment record, but says PM has pushed issue to top of world agenda Downing St plays down meeting with Porritt Praise and blame for &bquo;green&equo; Thatcher. 
 By Paul Brown Environment Correspondent 
 TEN years of Conservative government has produced a poor record on environmental issues, but Mrs Thatcher's &bquo;conversion&equo; in the past year has meant she has done more than any other world leader to push the issue to the top of the political, business, and economic agenda, says a Friends of the Earth report. 
 In a comprehensive critique of the Government's record, FoE says the claim made by Mr Nicholas Ridley as Environment Secretary that &bquo;Britain had taken the lead&equo; on environmental issues was absurd. 
 Mr David Gee, director designate of FoE said: &bquo;Recycling rhetoric won't save the planet. 
 Unless Mrs Thatcher starts the 1990s with specific targets and timetables for energy efficiency, greenhouse gas reductions, ozone layer protection, pollution controls, and Third World debt cancellation, the children of the next millenium will never forgive her.&equo; 
 It is likely that the main tenets of the report were passed to Mrs Thatcher during talks at Number 10 this month with Mr Jonathan Porritt, director of FoE. 
 A Downing Street spokeswoman yesterday sought to play down the significance of the meeting, saying: &bquo;The Prime Minister sees all sorts of people from time to time to talk about issues that interest her.&equo; 
 The &bquo;green bill&equo; was welcome but was not sufficient, although it does mark the beginning of the end of the Government's doctrine of deregulation, the report says. 
 Mrs Thatcher, urged on by her more forward-looking environment ministers, is struggling to adapt to the political imperatives that environmental protection have produced. 
 The report says her conversion appears genuine and points to the cabinet-level environment committee she set up to convert the &bquo;ungreen and powerful&equo; Treasury, transport, and energy ministries, but time was running out. 
 Actions on environment &bquo;fail to back up good intentions&equo;. 
 REVIEWING Government policy and achievements in several areas of concern, the Friends of the Earth report finds &bquo;some good intentions but relatively few actions to back up the words&equo;. 
 Farming. 
 Environmentally-sensitive areas have been established to restrict the use of chemical fertilisers, though fewer than half those recommended by the Nature Conservancy Council (NCC). 
 Tax incentives removed for commercial forestry, but the Government failed to list Scotland's Flow country under the World Heritage Convention, and rejected most of the 1987 NCC report, which was to ensure new forests did not harm wildlife. 
 Deadlines to enforce provisions of 1986 regulations to control use of pesticides have been missed, and help to develop organic farming refused. 
 Planning. 
 The EC's Habitats Directive to give threatened species greater protection has been blocked. 
 Only 40 internationally-important wetlands have been designated, instead of the recommended 120; and only 25 per cent of sites suggested under the EC's Birds Directive declared protected. 
 Sites of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) not protected from damage. 
 Planning rules weakened, making it easier to build on greenfield sites. 
 Energy. 
 Plans to build a series of nuclear pressurised water reactors halted, although Sizewell B will still be completed; funding on promoting energy efficiency has been halved; insulation programmes cut by 60 per cent; 100 times more spent on research into nuclear power than on renewable energy. 
 After Chernobyl the public was not given adequate warnings, and radiation fallout was underestimated by 40 times. 
 No coherent policy on radioactive waste disposal. 
 Overseas aid. 
 &pound;1 million given for tropical conservation work for Worldwide Fund for Nature, and another &pound;100 million pledged for tropical forests. 
 Britain's aid budget has fallen to 0.32 per cent of gross national product, less than half UN's target of 0.7 per cent. 
 Most tropical forest aid has gone to industrial forestry and has done little to aid the poor or protect the environment. 
 Transport. 
 Spending on new roads has increased by a third since 1979, and is planned to double again; Okehampton bypass built through Dartmoor National Park; 110 SSSIs are threatened with road schemes. 
 The number of new cars is expected to rise as much as 142 per cent by 2025. 
 The Government has cut public transport subsidies. 
 Air pollution. 
 Ozone-damaging CFCs are being phased out, but not other equally-damaging chemicals in common use. 
 The Government hosted an international conference on ozone depletion. 
 It shelved the Clean Air Bill in 1987, but will tackle some problems in forthcoming Environmental Protection Bill. 
 Attempts to control power station emissions in Europe were blocked for five years. 
 The Government gave way in 1988, then went back on deal to cut nitrous oxide emissions by 30 per cent. 
 Water. 
 National Rivers Authority set up and &pound;1 billion spent to control sewage discharges. 
 Drinking water frequently fails to meet EC standards; discharge limits relaxed for at least 1,800 sewage works to facilitate privatisation. 
 Water companies advised not to report breaches of EC rules on pesticides in drinking water. 
 Britain dumps more than seven million tonnes of sewage a year in the North Sea; 125 out of 338 bathing beaches failed to meet EC standards chiefly because of sewage pollution. 
 Waste hazards. 
 Inspectorate of Pollution under-financed and under-staffed. 
 It took threat of legal action from EC to implement directives on trans-frontier shipments of hazardous waste. 
 Moves to ban waste shipments to Third World countries blocked 
 Recycling. 
 Experiments as the Sheffield Recycling City have been backed, but the Government has refused to introduce recycling laws in line with EC directive on beverage containers. 
 Taxes on raw materials intended to spur recycling resisted. 
 Warming. 
 Mrs Thatcher recognised the gravity of the situation and helped focus world attention on the subject, but, with US and Japan, undermined moves to set targets for reduction of carbon dioxide emissions, and failed to adopt energy efficiency policies. 
 Research. 
 Centre for prediction of climate change set up. 
 Long-term research funding cut, with 500 scientists going at Natural Environment Research Council since 1983. 
 One in five marine science posts lost in 1989; in five years to 1987 research into renewable energy halved. 
 Big investment planned, but passengers ask when conditions will improve on peak-hour trains BR facing &pound;500m bill for safety. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 BRITISH RAIL is conducting a separate detailed study of new safety measures, which are estimated to cost up to &pound;500 million, after the inquiry into the Clapham Junction crash. 
 The report is expected to be given to the Transport Secretary, Mr Cecil Parkinson, in February after BR has assessed the scale and effect of the changes demanded by Sir Anthony Hidden's inquiry into the Clapham disaster last December, in which 35 people died. 
 However, the BR safety study is likely to be conducted outside the scope of the Government's financial targets for the railways which will be unveiled next week, at least two months before the safety report is published. 
 There will be considerable pressure on Mr Parkinson to ensure that safety is not compromised by lack of funds, and he has promised that money would be no obstacle to improving safety. 
 The Hidden report made 93 recommendations to improve safety procedures on the railways, in the emergency services and in government policy. 
 Of these, a total of 71 safety proposals were made for the railways. 
 But there is a widespread belief that the travelling public will be forced to meet a substantial share of the new safety costs through higher fares, because of the Government's policy of reducing taxpayers' support for the railways. 
 While BR has implemented some of the safety measures demanded by Sir Anthony, steps like the introduction of computerised signalling will require extensive design and testing work. 
 The new signalling system, known as automatic train protection, will be the biggest single item of expenditure arising from the crash, and is aimed at coping with the conflicting demands of high-density commuter trains and faster InterCity traffic on the same lines. 
 Trials for the signalling system have been accelerated as BR examines the feasibility of introducing it on the entire 11,000-mile network. 
 So far, BR has put into effect 19 of the 71 measures. 
 Twenty-two others are being implemented, and plans are in hand for a further nine. 
 BR has already begun the installation of aircraft-type &bquo;black box&equo; data recorders on new Network SouthEast trains, and is examining whether to make them a standard fitting in all trains. 
 It is also speeding up the installation of cab radios linked to signal boxes, and is adopting major changes in management practice to ensure that the safety measures are properly implemented. 
 More funds urged for troubled watchdog. 
 By Andrew Culf 
 THE Government was urged yesterday to tackle staff shortages and poor morale in Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution, as concern grew over its ability to cope with the demands of the Environmental Protection Bill. 
 Labour's environment spokeswoman, Mrs Ann Taylor, said the inspectorate was &bquo;expected to perform miracles&equo; with insufficient staff and funding. 
 Concerns over its future surfaced a year ago and were heightened last week by the death of its director, Mr Brian Ponsford, whose body was found in a car at his north London home. 
 An inquest was opened and adjourned last week. 
 The Environment Minister, Mr David Trippier, said yesterday that a newspaper report linking Mr Ponsford's death with HMIP's staffing problems was irresponsible and a &bquo;thoughtless incursion into the domestic grief of his widow and family&equo;. 
 He said morale at the inspectorate was improving, salaries had been increased by 30 per cent, and a recruitment drive was succeeding. 
 Mrs Taylor said she had been urging the Government for months to make public a report by Mr Ponsford confirming the morale problems. 
 She had not pressed for a statement at Westminster out of respect to his family. 
 &bquo;There is no doubt that the new green bill is going to put a lot of extra pressure on HMIP,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;The Government is simply not providing the money to allow them to carry out their monitoring duties.&equo; 
 The bill receives its first Commons reading in a fortnight. 
 The Environment Secretary, Mr Chris Patten, intends to introduce a system of integrated pollution control. 
 HMIP's policing function will be crucial in bringing to book companies that pollute air and waterways. 
 Mr Tam Dalyell, Labour MP for Linlithgow, yesterday wrote to Mr Patten demanding a full statement on the inspectorate in the wake of Mr Ponsford's death. 
 He asked whether senior officers who had resigned had given falling pollution standards as the reason and whether staff shortages were responsible for the failure to carry out half the tests that should have been performed. 
 Mr Dalyell also asked whether work on controls over radioactive emissions, particularly at Aldermaston, Amersham and Burghfield, was being hampered, and for the reasons for the recruitment difficulties. 
 The National Audit Office is investigating the inspectorate's efficiency, while the National Society for Clean Air said recent restructuring had &bquo;resulted in confusion and disaffection and seems unlikely to achieve any improvement in pollution control&equo;. 
 Three key staff have resigned in the past year, and there have been frequent complaints that its establishment of 240 is too low. 
 Mr Trippier said a number of inspectors had left because of offers from the private sector, but morale had improved recently. 
 Parents criticise Press Council over Guardian adjudication. 
 By Andrew Culf 
 APRESS Council adjudication on a complaint against the Guardian has been criticised by the parents of missing London estate agent Suzy Lamplugh as &bquo;quite extraordinary&equo;. 
 Paul and Diana Lamplugh complained about an article by Andrew Stephen, author of a book about their daughter's disappearance. 
 They claimed it was inaccurate, misleading and constituted a breach of journalistic ethics. 
 In an adjudication published today, the Press Council does not uphold the complaint, saying it represented a re-run of complaints made by the Lamplughs about Mr Stephen's book and was likely to &bquo;reopen and prolong a dispute which might be better left unpursued.&equo; 
 Mr and Mrs Lamplugh said: &bquo;We are naturally disappointed that the council has refused to express a view on the statements we complained about, but has not upheld our complaint because they consider it was not appropriate.&equo; 
 They added: &bquo;We consider the grounds on which the Press Council make their decisions are wrong and their press releases even contain a number of inaccuracies which they are unwilling to correct.&equo; 
 They are urging a reformed Press Council to provide &bquo;effective and fair machinery&equo; to help those complaining about inaccurate and misleading statements. 
 Personal, page 33 
 Three charged in Ulster inquiry. 
 By David Hearst in Belfast 
 A FORMER Ulster prison officer was charged last night with collecting, recording and possessing information which could be useful to terrorists planning murders. 
 Dennis McGookin, aged 33, of County Londonderry, appeared at a special sitting of Belfast magistrates' court with two other men after being arrested by detectives investigating alleged security leaks to loyalist paramilitaries. 
 Roy Lambe, aged 25, of Belfast, was charged with having two rifles, a pistol and ammunition with intent to endanger life; possessing information likely to be useful to terrorists and raising money for the illegal loyalist group the Red Hand Commandos. 
 James Stewart, aged 23, of Belfast, was accused of having documents on IRA suspects likely to be of use to terrorists planning murder. 
 All three were remanded in custody until December 29. 
 Their court appearance brings to 26 the number of men charged by the inquiry team headed by Cambridgeshire deputy Chief Constable John Stevens, who was called to Northern Ireland three months ago to investigate allegations of collusion between security forces and Protestant paramilitaries. 
 The inquiry, due to be completed at the end of next month, has resulted in serious tension between the police and the Ulster Defence Regiment. 
 Twenty-eight UDR members were arrested during house searches in October; 22 of them were released without charge, and senior UDR officers are bitterly critical of the police operation using hundreds of officers. 
 The officers said innocent men's lives had been put at risk and their families had been forced to move house because identities had been disclosed. 
 But Mr Hugh Annesley, the RUC Chief Constable, who asked Mr Stevens to make his inquiry, has defended his actions, saying the surprise operation was the only way houses could be searched ensuring the security of the officers involved. 
 MI5 book gets go-ahead. 
 By Richard Norton-Taylor 
 THE head of MI5, Mr Patrick Walker, has allowed a former senior officer to publish a book that includes strong criticism of the Government's refusal to agree to independent oversight of the Security Service. 
 It is the first time a former officer has been given permission to write about MI5 since Sir Percy Sillitoe, the post-war head of the service, published his memoirs in 1955. 
 The book is by Mr John Day, who left MI5 in 1982 after 24 years in K Branch, responsible for countering the activities of Communist-bloc intelligence agents in Britain. 
 He was a member of MI5's fluency committee, set up to investigate allegations of Soviet penetration of MI5. 
 It was chaired at one time by Peter Wright, author of Spycatcher. 
 Mr Day was threatened with an injunction last year when he completed the final draft of his book, most of which deals with his career in the Royal Marines and as a civil servant during the Emergency in Malaya. 
 He agreed to take out what he calls two innocent chapters on his work in MI5 but insisted on keeping in his views on the need for oversight. 
 Three months after Mr Day sought official clearance, Mr Walker has given the go-ahead. 
 Mr Day proposes the appointment of Security Service commissioners to monitor MI5. 
 They would have &bquo;virtually free access to personnel and papers&equo;, he said yesterday. 
 They would report to the Home Secretary and could be former armed forces officers, diplomats, academics, or even trade union officials. 
 Their annual report to the Home Secretary would be debated by the House of Commons. 
 &bquo;Experience has shown that the Home Secretary on his own simply cannot carry out oversight of MI5,&equo; Mr Day said. 
 A similar proposal by the Tory backbencher Mr Jonathan Aitken &mdash; who wrote the foreword to Mr Day's book &mdash; during the Commons debate on the Security Service Act this year, was rejected by Home Office ministers despite growing support inside Whitehall for a system of independent oversight. 
 Hundreds dead in birds cargo. 
 The Dutch airline KLM is investigating why &bquo;many hundreds&equo; of birds out of a cargo of 15,000, including flamingoes, were found dead on arrival from Dar es Salaam at Heathrow, en route to Miami. 
 An RSPCA spokeswoman said it might prosecute: &bquo;This tragedy indicates the danger of trade in exotic birds.&equo;. 
 Football fans injured. 
 Injuries to five spectators at Middlesbrough's home match with Leeds United were caused by a surge rather than overcrowding, police said. 
 Four die in crash. 
 A fourth person died yesterday after an M1 crash involving two cars and a coach near Milton Keynes on Saturday. 
 &pound;1.8m lottery win. 
 Miss Philomena Conneely, 21, today collects a cheque for IR&pound;1,940,852 (&pound;1,860,000) in Dublin after her 50p ticket won the Irish National Lottery. 
 Party cancelled. 
 Police arrested 11 men with sound equipment on their way to a Saturday night acid house party in the New Forest. 
 Body in garden. 
 Police are consulting missing persons' lists to try to identify the body of a teenage girl found in a shallow grave in the garden of a Cardiff house. 
 Canal to be searched. 
 A stretch of the Grand Union Canal in London is to be dredged today after a severed leg wrapped in plastic was seen floating near Regent's Park. 
 NUT appeals to business in merit pay row. 
 SCHOOLS cannot be run like assembly lines, the National Union of Teachers says in a booklet being sent tobusiness executives to ask their help in opposing any move to pay teachers according to classroom performance. 
 The union fears that the Government intends to link merit pay and promotion to an appraisal scheme, and believes that instead it should be used to improve professional skills. 
 In September the Education Secretary, Mr John MacGregor, said heads and governors could appraise performance in deciding promotion and pay &mdash; just as managers in industry do. 
 He postponed implementing a scheme until more groups, including industry and business, were consulted. 
 Yesterday Mr Doug McAvoy, the union's general secretary, urged the CBI, the Institute of Directors and the Industrial Society to &bquo;build an alliance&equo; between education and business against performance-related pay in schools. 
 &bquo;Education is much more difficult than many industrial and commercial processes to measure in a way that makes comparison possible,&equo; he said. 
 Elderly care crisis warning. 
 By David Brindle, Social Services Correspondent 
 BRITAIN will face a spiralling demand for long-term residential care of the elderly unless funds are made available for the rapid development of community services, a report warns today. 
 The warning that Government community care policies may fail to halt the residential care boom comes from Professor Nick Bosanquet, professor of health policy at the University of London, and Dr Alistair Gray, a research associate at Wolfson College, Oxford. 
 They calculate that the ageing population is adding 1 per cent annually to health service costs. 
 Between 1986-95, they estimate a 33 per cent rise in the number of over-75s hospitalised for short-stay treatment alone. 
 As a result, they say the health service must quickly adjust to big shifts in demand among specialities: while general surgery patients will rise by just 4 per cent between 1986-95, those in geriatric medicine will increase by 35 per cent, and those in urology by 42 per cent. 
 However, the report &mdash; commissioned by the National Association of Health Authorities and the Society of Family Practitioner Committees &mdash; warns that the main danger is a spiralling of demand for long-term residential care. 
 It says that without building on existing community services, residential care will expand even faster than the &pound;1 billion growth in the 1980s, as measured by social security costs. 
 Claiming the 1980s have been wasted in the development of elderly-care services, it suggests a three-year programme of community services development costing &pound;700,000 &mdash; or another 1 per cent extra funding &mdash; in each health district. 
 Will You Still Love Me? &mdash; New Opportunities for Health Services for Elderly People in the 1990s and Beyond; NAHA, Birmingham Research Park, Vincent Drive, Birmingham B15 2SQ; &pound;15 
 Expulsions set to go ahead. 
 The forced repatriation of Vietnamese boat people from Hong Kong was expected to begin this week as the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, restated his intention to go ahead with the expulsions. 
 Page 20. 
 Flu sweeps country. 
 Hospitals in many parts of England and Wales may be put on red alert and ban non-emergency admissions as the worst flu epidemic for 14 years sweeps the country. 
 Page 4. 
 Treasury break-in. 
 Detectives are investigating a burglary at the Treasury, in which it is believed secret papers may have been photographed and proofs of potentially valuable coins taken.. 
 Rover inquiry grows. 
 Secret tax concessions offered to British Aerospace to secure the sale of the Rover Group could take the &bquo;hidden sweeteners&equo; involved to a sum much greater than the &pound;48 million already uncovered, it was claimed. 
 Page 2. 
 FoE praises Thatcher. 
 Mrs Thatcher's green &bquo;conversion&equo; has meant she has done more than any other world leader to push the environment to the top of the political, business, and economic agenda, say Friends of the Earth. 
 Page 3. 
 The Guardian. 
 We apologise to those readers who did not receive the Guardian on Saturday when mechanical problems at our London printing plant affected some later editions.. 
 Arts, ReviewsWS31. 
 CartoonsWS33. 
 Classified AdvertisingWS22-29. 
 CrosswordsWS20. 
 EntertainmentsWS29. 
 Financial NewsWS11, 12. 
 Home NewsWS2-4. 
 International NewsWS6-10. 
 LettersWS18. 
 ListingsWS30. 
 Media GuardianWS21, 23. 
 ProfileWS17. 
 ObituaryWS33. 
 Sports NewsWS13-16. 
 StyleWS32. 
 TV, Radio and WeatherWS34 
 Rail passengers face fares leap. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 GOVERNMENT plans to slash subsidies for British Rail's South-east commuter and provincial services threaten to bring vast increases in rail fares in the 1990s. 
 Mr Cecil Parkinson, the Transport Secretary, has told BR that all subsidies for commuter services on Network South East &mdash; currently &pound;141 million a year &mdash; will be removed by March 1993. 
 Tax-payers' backing for the loss-making provincial operation, now &pound;400 million a year, will be cut by 25 per cent in the next three years, according to Mr Parkinson. 
 The decision means that annual government support for the railways will have dropped from well over &pound;1 billion to around &pound;300 million in 10 years. 
 The loss of government subsidies will be covered almost entirely by dearer fares for passengers. 
 Mr John Prescott, Labour's transport spokesman, has warned that the Department of Transport has already built the big increases into future planning requirements. 
 Mr Prescott said yesterday that separate DoT assessments for new transport facilities in London had assumed increases &mdash; after taking account of inflation &mdash; in southern rail and Tube fares of more than 40 per cent in the next 10-15 years. 
 &bquo;London will be the only capital city in Europe where rail services are expected to make a profit,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;It is a policy that could lead to economic and environmental chaos.&equo; 
 While Mr Parkinson will be anxious over the next few days to emphasise the benefits of BR's &pound;3 billion investment programme, it is clear passengers will be paying increasingly more towards new rolling stock and equipment. 
 Mr Parkinson now faces the challenge of selling to the electorate a controversial policy of lower subsidies and higher fares. 
 The cuts in government support, to be unveiled in the next 10 days, will prompt protests from travellers, railway unions, environmentalists and opposition MPs, who will see the decision as fresh evidence that the Government is fundamentally anti-rail. 
 BR's fares have been raised by 1.5 per cent above inflation during much of the 1980s and the Government's proposals imply increases to four points over inflation in the 1990s. 
 Government backing for the railways has halved to around &pound;550 million in the 1980s and the new calculations of support have been struck before taking into account the estimated cost of safety measures demanded after the Clapham Junction disaster. 
 Cuts in Network South East grants will increase the Government's pre-election risk of alienating Conservative voters in the South-east commuter belt where rail travellers are already unhappy over rail services. 
 There will also be concern that cuts in support for provincial services will threaten the viability of many rural rail lines. 
 Mr Parkinson recently signalled ministerial concern by blocking BR's plans for a 14 per cent fare rise in February. 
 Mr Prescott warned that rail passengers would pay for the grant cuts by higher fares and poorer service. 
 &bquo;BR fares are already the highest in Europe, but further increases of this scale will be inevitable without a change in Government policy,&equo; he added. 
 Silver Fox rallies to Sally Ann. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 MRS Barbara Bush has stepped up her relentlessly engaging campaign to become America's version of the Queen Mum by dashing to the rescue of a much-loved and out-dated institution &mdash; the Salvation Army. 
 In the nearest modern marketing has come to the skin-flintery of Ebenezer Scrooge, a growing number of American shopping malls have picked the Christmas season to ban the Salvation Army from ringing its bells and asking for money for its traditional Big Red Kettle collection boxes. 
 Mall operators argue that the Sally Army must be banned, or the precedent would allow a flood of other charitable panhandlers to invade their territory, and solicit a little of the money which should by rights be the monopoly of the retailers. 
 Learning of this affront to the Christmas Spirit from the Washington Post, the First Lady rallied her forces, put some bills into her handbag, summoned the Secret Service and sallied forth to Mazza Galleries, one of the few places in town which still allows the Sally Army to function. 
 Probably the highest-priced mall around the capital, Mazza contains a branch of Nieman-Marcus, the Texas-based department store whose prices are beyond belief and whose Christmas catalogues contain such essentials as solid gold swizzle sticks and stuffed toys with diamonds for eyes. 
 The First Granny, as Mrs Bush is becoming affectionately known, marched up to the uniformed bell-ringers beside the big Christmas tree, put ten bucks into the Big Red Kettle, and loudly announced how much she preferred patronising a mall that had the sense to permit the Salvation Army. 
 Colonel Jack Waters, the Salvation Army's Washington commander, estimates that the bans in the other malls will cost the charity at least &dollar;100,000 this Christmas. 
 But he will still be organising 13,000 volunteers into bringing some kind of Christmas to 125,000 needy, lonely or down-and-out people. 
 There will be toys, food baskets, mince pies and soup kitchens. 
 Mrs Bush, known to the President as the Silver Fox, seems to have started something. 
 In up-market Georgetown Park Mall, a retailers' revolt is now under way against the management, appealing directly to Colonel Waters to send in his troops, bells and all. 
 Steel shutdown revives fears. 
 By Peter Hetherington 
 AN EERIE silence will descend on the steel town of Motherwell next weekend when the big Ravenscraig strip mill winds down for a long and unwelcome seasonal break. 
 As the 3,200 workers leave the works for an uncertain future, British Steel will begin cooling down its three blast furnaces in a risky operation which has been attacked by a cross-party alliance, including the Scottish Secretary, Mr Malcolm Rifkind. 
 Although BSC says it is halting production for three weeks because of a sharp drop in demand, unions and all Scottish parties fear the unprecedented break could be a prelude to something much worse. 
 The steel unions are in no doubt that political pressure from the former Scottish Secretary, Mr George Younger, saved the plant, one of the Corporation's big five complexes, from closure in 1982. 
 Now Mr Rifkind has written to the BSC chairman, Sir Robert Scholey, asking for further assurances after meeting anxious union leaders. 
 BSC accuses the powerful Scottish lobby of interfering with market conditions. 
 &bquo;The scale of the protest is totally disproportionate to the size of the problem,&equo; a spokesman said. 
 &bquo;To the best of my knowledge the plant will close for three weeks and then come back.&equo; 
 But over the past two years Ravenscraig's position has weakened. 
 In 1986, BSC closed its modern hot rolling mill, at nearby Gartcosh, with the loss of 800 jobs. 
 Recently, a modest &pound;10 millions investment package was shelved. 
 Two main competitor plants &mdash; Llanwern and Port Talbot in south Wales &mdash; are being loaded to full capacity over the Christmas period. 
 In previous years, work had been shared during a slump in demand. 
 Mr Tommy Brennan, stewards' convenor, says they worked during the 1984-1985 miners strike &mdash; incurring the wrath of the NUM &mdash; after management warned that any cool down would threaten the works. 
 &bquo;We believed it then and we still do today. 
 Engineers have told us that the blast furnaces are at risk. 
 If there is a cold spell we could be in trouble.&equo; 
 By common consent, Ravenscraig has been kept alive since 1982 because workers have broken all production records. 
 BSC refuses to give unions a cost comparison with the other plants on the grounds that it is &bquo;commercially confidential&equo;. 
 Mr George Quinn, the union steward representing craftsmen, says many workers are alarmed by an abrupt turnaround. 
 &bquo;On November 1 they told us that normal Christmas arrangements would apply &mdash; that we would work for most of the holiday period &mdash; then they dropped this bombshell on November 22 and said we would be off for two weeks. 
 And then last week out of the blue they put production start-up back by another seven days. 
 Do you blame us for being worried?&equo; 
 How the position of Communist Parties is changing in Eastern Europe SOVIET UNION: The party's guaranteed right to rule is under unprecedented challenge, particularly in the Baltic states. 
 Mr Gorbachev is resisting centrifugal pressure, but leaving the door open for future change in party's status. 
 POLAND: The party in effect lost its leading role in June when Solidarity's triumph resulted in Warsaw Pact's first, and still its only, non-Communist prime minister. 
 HUNGARY: First party in eastern Europe formally to abandon its leading role early this year. 
 At an emergency congress in October, the Communist Party voted to dissolve itself and become the Hungarian Socialist Party. 
 EAST GERMANY: Parliament dropped the party's constitutional right to rule last month after sudden revolution from below swept the old leaders aside. 
 At the weekend, a demoralised party elected a new leader and abolished the old centralised power structures of the politburo and central committee. 
 Party to be renamed next week. 
 CZECHOSLOVAKIA: Taking its cue from East Germany, parliament last week dropped the leading-role clause from the constitution after the growth of public protest. 
 Emergency party congress in nine days' time. 
 BULGARIA: Despite moves by reformist Communist leaders, the party clings to its leading role, but a burgeoning opposition movement is demanding an end to its monopoly of power. 
 ROMANIA: Leading role of party and of Nicolae Ceausescu does not appear under threat. 
 YUGOSLAVIA: Party's role central to argument between north and south over ethnic and ideological differences. 
 US to ship bomb-grade uranium to Romania. 
 By Alan George 
 THE US is planning to ship bomb-grade uranium to Romania despite fears that it may be working on a nuclear weapons programme. 
 The shipment of 16.48 kilograms of 93 per cent enriched uranium is destined for a 14-megawatt research reactor at Potesti, which was supplied by the California-based General Atomics company in the 1970s. 
 The material, manufactured by General Atomics about 10 years ago, has been in storage with the Department of Energy (DOE). 
 The US provided 38.7 kilograms of enriched uranium for Potesti in 1978. 
 This is now spent and the new consignment is needed to keep the reactor running. 
 Romania's State Committee for Nuclear Energy approached the DOE and the US Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) for the new supplies early last year. 
 An export licence was issued in August last year, and this has now been extended until August 31, 1990. 
 Washington's nuclear collaboration with Romania dates from the 1970s, when the West was vigorously encouraging President Nicolae Ceausescu to pursue policies independent of the Soviet Union. 
 At the same time, Britain concluded a series of major contracts with Bucharest, including a deal for the supply of Rolls Royce engines for a locally-produced fighter aircraft. 
 Although Romania is a signatory to the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, Mr Ceausescu boasted earlier this year that his country had the capacity to produce nuclear weapons. 
 Last summer, Romania reportedly warned neighbouring Hungary it was working on nuclear weapons and a ballistic missile system. 
 Engineers on Iraq's Condor-2 ballistic missile programme claim to have worked on a similar project in Romania. 
 Whatever Romania's military aspirations, Bucharest certainly has a record of carelessness with nuclear materials. 
 In 1986, Norway supplied Romania with 12.5 tons of heavy water, on the strict understanding that it would not be re-sold. 
 But Romania transferred the water either to Israel or India, prompting a formal protest from Oslo in May last year. 
 The US uranium shipment is being arranged by a Washington-based nuclear fuel management company, Edlow Inc. 
 Its International Vice-President, Mr Rod Fisk, asked whether the company was concerned over how the uranium might be used, said: &bquo;That's a question you have to address to the US Government.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sweeteners&equo; Rover inquiry may widen *. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 SECRET tax concessions offered to British Aerospace to secure the sale of the Rover Group could take the &bquo;hidden sweeteners&equo; involved in the deal to substantially more than the &pound;48 million already uncovered, it was claimed yesterday. 
 The Commons Public Accounts Committee will today consider extending its investigation into the &pound;150 million Rover Group sale, and may decide to examine Inland Revenue officials. 
 Lord Young, Trade and Industry Secretary at the time of the sale, offered at the weekend to appear before the committee to explain his role in the deal. 
 Labour's trade and industry spokesman, Mr Gordon Brown, who claimed at the weekend to have uncovered a further &pound;10 million in sweeteners above the &pound;38 million disclosed last week, continued yesterday to press the Prime Minister for details of the tax benefits offered to BAe, and to explain why Parliament has been deceived for more than 16 months about the true cost of the sale. 
 &bquo;The confidential papers I have seen demonstrate that what were called various tax benefits were central to negotiations. 
 It is clear that at a meeting on July 4 between Lord Young and BAe, discussions included various tax benefits for Rover, to be achieved through the removal of the ring fence on tax losses and sympathetic revenue treatment. 
 &bquo;In his letter of July 6 following the meeting, the BAe chairman, Professor Roland Smith, called for the removal of the ring fence around Rover capital allowances, capital losses, and trading losses, and asked the DTI to intervene with the Inland Revenue for &bquo;written rulings in advance to certain proposals to be made by BAe with a view to optimising the tax benefits&equo;,&equo; Mr Brown said. 
 &bquo;On July 12 Lord Young confirmed that tax agreements had been made with the Inland Revenue, and there had been an exchange of letters &bquo;on terms satisfactory to BAe&equo;.&equo; 
 As originally disclosed by the Guardian, the estimated value of the tax concessions alone offered at one point during the negotiations was close to &pound;35 million, while the European Commission was led to believe that BAe would benefit by only &pound;25 million from the easing of tax restrictions. 
 Some of the suspicions raised by Mr Brown, particularly questions surrounding the tax treatment of trading losses, suggest the final figure could be substantially higher. 
 He is to table a new series of questions in the Commons today which ask for details of the proposed package. 
 They include asking whether various capital losses could be written off against property companies owned by BAe; whether the Government was aware of BAe's attempts to use leasing companies to defray indirectly further tax bills; and what was the total trading tax loss written off. 
 The chairman of the committee, Mr Robert Sheldon, said yesterday he was awaiting detailed answers from the DTI to questions posed on Monday during his committee's examination of its permanent secretary. 
 The nature of those replies, which are expected to include details of the tax matters, will determine whether the committee decides to ask the National Audit Office to re-open its investigation of the sale, and whether it is necessary to summon Lord Young. 
 Less bulk and more brawn for kids. 
 CHILDREN born in the next decade will be slimmer, shorter, and better proportioned adults because of healthier eating habits, says a survey published today. 
 The new woman will be built like a dancer and &mdash; about 5ft 4in tall. 
 Within the next two generations a man over six feet will be an oddity rather than a subject of envy. 
 People born since the 1890s have been unnaturally large because they have eaten too much protein believing it to be essential for growth, says survey author Geoffrey Cannon in New Woman magazine. 
 &bquo;Meat and animal-based foods were put forward as the most nutritious form of sustenance and this propaganda changed the shape of generations. 
 &bquo;On a milky, fatty, meaty diet British girls and boys became taller, fatter, and broader than nature intended.&equo; 
 But, as a direct result of their parents eating lots of fresh vegetables, fruit, and cereals, the children of the 1990s &bquo;will look very different from the bulky people bred in Britain since the 1890s.&equo; 
 The new generation would be more intelligent, enjoy better health, and possess more energy. 
 Labour rules out &bquo;blanket&equo; credit control. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 THE shadow Chancellor, Mr John Smith, promised yesterday that the party's credit controls policy would not be designed to cover everything and &bquo;hermetically seal the economy.&equo; 
 He told Channel 4's Answering Back that &bquo;a touch on the brake to reduce excess demand&equo; was all that was needed. 
 His remarks came as Labour employment spokesman, Mr Henry McLeish, denied reports that the party was considering replacing the automatic payment of welfare benefits with a policy which would require many unemployed either to find a job or to accept full-time training or higher education. 
 Mr McLeish said the report was &bquo;misinformed and mistaken. 
 There is absolutely no question of overturning the policy review in this or any other area.&equo; 
 Mr Smith made clear that Labour's first response would be to seek entry to the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System and that its spending priorities would be pensions and child poverty. 
 Many spending commitments were achievable &bquo;in the lifetime of the next Labour Government if it runs the full term.&equo; 
 Earlier this year Labour's policy review talked of &bquo;substantial changes&equo; to the EMS before joining. 
 Mr Smith believed a limit on bank lending could be agreed but, if not, banks would be required to deposit money with the Bank of England which was not available for lending. 
 Ambulance union leaders fight to stifle escalation. 
 By Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 LEADERS of the five TUC-affiliated ambulance unions will meet regional representatives today to ensure that action is sustained in the nearly 13-week dispute, but to stifle any calls for escalation. 
 Both sides underlined their well-established positions on BBC radio yesterday. 
 The Health Secretary, Mr Kenneth Clarke, insisted that the latest 9 per cent offer &mdash; tilted towards extra payments for highly-trained staff &mdash; was both &bquo;fair and constructive&equo;. 
 A petition carrying 4.5 million signatures collected from the public by ambulance crews is to be placed before Parliament with the help of the Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, this week, calling for the dispute to be referred to arbitration, which Mr Clarke still opposes. 
 Today's meeting of the TUC-unions &mdash; NUPE, Cohse, TGWU, GMB, and Nalgo &mdash; is likely to concentrate on efforts to sustain support for the action through the Christmas period. 
 Leaders insist that only pockets around the country support escalation, but are aware of increasing frustration that the dispute remains unsettled. 
 Members of the non-TUC Association of Professional Ambulance Personnel will today begin receiving ballot forms and a letter from their ruling body explaining why APAP leaders agreed to recommend acceptance of an 18-month, 9 per cent deal thrown out by other unions. 
 APAP members in London &mdash; believed to be seriously disaffected by the association's stance in the dispute &mdash; will be met by an executive member, Mr Peter Kenney, in the first of a series of meetings to rally support for the union amid threats of a revolt following the resignation of the 132-strong Hertfordshire chapter last week. 
 He is to travel to Exeter and Derby in the next two days. 
 An APAP spokesman, Mr Brian Bruno, played down the revolt, saying as many staff were applying to join as were resigning. 
 Wry humour fails to ease daily trial of commuters. 
 Joanna Coles samples peak-hour service and discovers what all the fuss is about.. 
 THE railwayman at Charing Cross was surprisingly forthcoming about return routes to Hastings. 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; he said, &bquo;what I'm telling you is strictly illegal. 
 You shouldn't be doing this at all. 
 You're supposed to come back by any reasonable route &mdash; but reasonable is not defined. 
 You can go all over the place. 
 It's worth the risk; you won't get caught unless you get a very alert conductor.&equo; 
 He laughed. 
 &bquo;And you won't find one of those.&equo; 
 Such effusive collusion from any company employee would suggest that something, somewhere, had gone wrong. 
 This was British Rail, and as any passenger will tell you, something has gone very wrong. 
 &bquo;It's a bloody disgrace &mdash; the whole service,&equo; said Mr Gary Constable, aged 32, a company director. 
 &bquo;This station is an absolute disaster trap. 
 They've been building it for God knows how long, cancelling trains, people can't get on or off the platforms. 
 It can take 10 minutes to get off the train.&equo; 
 A commuter from Crayford on Network SouthEast's Sidcup line, Mr Constable pays about &pound;700 a year for his ticket but rarely gets a seat. 
 His colleague, Mr Peter Grove, is more determined: &bquo;I get to the station two trains before I need to. 
 You can't get a train otherwise. 
 The staff at Eltham are very pleasant, but the ones here are another matter. 
 Last week they got so fed up with commuters crowding round their screens to find out the train times &mdash; because the computer board wasn't working &mdash; they just switched them all off. 
 It was chaos.&equo; 
 Mr Constable added: &bquo;There could have been a commuter rebellion last week. 
 If someone had got up a petition for that bloke who refused to pay his ticket because the heating didn't work, I would have signed it. 
 &bquo;He'd better earn his &pound;200,000, this new guy &mdash; sounds like we're going to pay for it.&equo; 
 Mr Jeff Moore, an insurance broker based in Tunbridge Wells, agreed that it was equally difficult to get a seat on his train. 
 &bquo;Two years ago my wife changed to first class to ensure a seat &mdash; it's another &pound;700 &mdash; but she still doesn't get one.&equo; 
 Once aboard the 17.01 to Tunbridge Wells the guard was in lively form. 
 &bquo;This train is due to arrive at Tunbridge Wells sometime later today,&equo; he crackled over the tannoy. 
 At Tonbridge a fellow train man &mdash; as BR now prefers to call its conductors &mdash; announced: &bquo;This train is bound for London Bridge, fingers crossed.&equo; 
 But the humour is not matched by efficiency, according to Mrs Maureen Allason, a housewife from Rotherfield in east Sussex, an ex-commuter. 
 &bquo;Station staff at Charing Cross are a total disaster,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Even if they know what you want to know, they won't tell you. 
 They can't understand the timetables.&equo; 
 Her accusation was borne out by a driver at Tonbridge who contradicted the guard's timetable advice. 
 &bquo;That little chap? 
 He don't know nothing &mdash; he's only been here 10 years.&equo; 
 One year after the Clapham crash, safety also worries passengers. 
 When a conductor spilt a cup of boiling water over Mrs Allason's mother there was neither a first aid box on board nor a phone to call for help. 
 She was awarded &pound;500 damages. 
 Mr David Wickert, a charity's aid organiser who commutes from Kent four times a week, said: &bquo;Hurtling along at 60 mph with the train crammed full is terribly dangerous. 
 I don't see why there aren't seat belts.&equo; 
 He was not impressed by BR's public relations campaign. 
 &bquo;If they gave hard facts instead of patronising advertising it would be better. 
 &bquo;You need to be a genius to know what ticket to use. 
 They should have consultative groups where passengers could give their opinions.&equo; 
 Mrs Allason agrees. 
 &bquo;British Rail should train their staff as to what they're supposed to do. 
 BR should acknowledge it's a service industry. 
 And I'd rather they did something about the service instead of advertising that they're getting there when they're patently not.&equo; 
 First expulsions of Vietnam boat people may start this week. 
 By Steve Vines in Hong Kong and Alan Travis, Political Correspondent 
 THE forced repatriation of Vietnamese boat people from Hong Kong was expected to begin this week as the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, restated his intention to go ahead with the expulsions. 
 One Vietnamese man was killed and three injured early yesterday amid indications of rising tension at Hong Kong's detention centres. 
 Speculation about the deportations have reached fever pitch in Hong Kong. 
 Although officials remain resolutely silent, there is a widespread belief that the British Government will authorise the colony's administration to go ahead with the first batch of mandatory repatriations this week. 
 Mr Peter Haliday, the district police commander for the area surrounding the Whitehead Detention Centre, Hong Kong's largest camp for boat people, said the victims were attacked in their sleep by 10 men. 
 He said that he thought the attack arose out of a personal dispute. 
 Although it is impossible to be sure what happened, this latest incident follows a developing pattern of violence in the camps. 
 Aid workers, the only independent sources of information who have direct access to the camp inmates, say that fears about deportation are creating a tense atmosphere and that the Vietnamese are making preparations to avoid and resist attempts to send them home. 
 The Hong Kong Government is keen to start the deportations to deter new arrivals when conditions for sailing from Vietnam improve early next year. 
 &bquo;It is important that mandatory repatriation is put in place before we face the prospect of another influx of boat people next year,&equo; Sir David Ford, Hong Kong's Chief Secretary, said. 
 A senior Hong Kong Government official said the deportations would either have to begin this week or wait until the new year. 
 The government was not prepared to invite the bad publicity that would be generated by starting deportations during the Christmas period, he added. 
 Extensive preparations are being made for the transport of the boat people back to Vietnam. 
 Previous departures of volunteer returnees have been handled by the colony's Dragonair airline. 
 But the government is now talking to Cathay Pacific Airways, which has a far larger fleet, and is investigating the possibility of using redundant British cross channel ferries for larger groups. 
 The major stumbling block is the unwillingness of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees to monitor the well-being of the returned boat people in Vietnam. 
 Britain still hopes it can persuade the UN agency to change its mind when a special committee on refugees from Indo-China resumes its meetings in mid-January. 
 Voluntary aid agencies in Vietnam have also rejected the task, leaving it to Britain's tiny embassy in Hanoi. 
 The Vietnamese authorities are as keen as Britain and Hong Kong for the start of the deportation programme. 
 They see it as the first stage in widening contacts with Western Europe. 
 In London, the Foreign Office yesterday refused to confirm reports that the deportations would start as early as next Saturday and would only repeat the formula that they would take place sooner rather than later. 
 As Mr Hurd restated yesterday, the aim is to dissuade any further influx of boat people when the sailing season begins again in February. 
 Of the 57,000 Vietnamese in Hong Kong, some 17,000 would be resettled as genuine refugees, but the remaining 40,000 would have to go back. 
 &bquo;In a year, 630 have returned voluntarily, which is good. 
 But none of these volunteers has yet come from those screened out &mdash; only 27 have volunteered out of the 4,000 who have gone through the process and been found not to be refugees,&equo; he told the Sunday Express. 
 &bquo;At this rate returning the boat people will take years. 
 So my predecessors said we must face the sad business of obliging people to return home. 
 I looked at it afresh and came to the same conclusion.&equo; 
 The Labour foreign affairs spokesman, Mr George Foulkes, yesterday demanded a government statement announcing it was abandoning the plan. 
 He accused ministers of subjecting innocent and terrified Vietnamese to a form of psychological warfare. 
 &bquo;Instead of employing these appalling tactics with these families, it would be statesmanlike and more courageous to press the United Nations to lift its economic boycott of Vietnam now that Vietnamese forces have left Cambodia,&equo; he said. 
 A statement is expected before Christmas on how many of Hong Kong's 3 million British passport-holders are to be granted the right of residence in the United Kingdom. 
 Snooker: Reynolds scales Davis peak. 
 By Clive Everton 
 DEAN REYNOLDS, whitewashed 10-0 by Steve Davis in the final of the Rothmans Grand Prix in October, beat him 9-7 to reach the semi-finals of the Everest World Matchplay Championship at the Brentwood Centre late on Saturday. 
 The Grimsby left-hander's semi-final opponent on Wednesday will be Jimmy White, who won the last seven frames in a row to turn a 5-2 deficit into a 9-5 win over Doug Mountjoy. 
 Reynolds, 15th in the world rankings at the start of the season, has improved provisionally to eighth. 
 He had a gilt-edged opportunity to beat Stephen Hendry, so far the man of the season with four first prizes, in the Stormseal UK Open at Preston, but missed a simple pink when leading 22-0 in the deciding frame and did not have another shot. 
 Davis came to Brentwood a 16-12 loser to Hendry in the UK final and is going through a patch where he is making more unforced errors than usual. 
 &bquo;There are certain times that are better than others,&equo; said Davis. 
 &bquo;I'm a very good player. 
 I can't be perfect.&equo; 
 Davis swept to 3-0 but missed the easiest of blues on the brink of 4-0. 
 Reynolds won that frame, the next on the pink, two more on the black, and the last of the afternoon to lead 5-3 at the interval. 
 He made it 6-3 with a 90 break, and after 52 minutes of tactical battling potted the pink for 7-3 and ran away with the next to go five up with six to play. 
 After this extraordinary eight-frame losing streak, Davis won four in a row to close to only 7-8, but two elementary mistakes in the following frame, failing to reach the yellow when rolling up behind it for a snooker, and failing to pot a red at close range along the top cushion, prefaced a run of 48 with which Reynolds secured his most notable scalp. 
 PAGE 
 Judo: Stevens justifies selection. 
 By Edward Ferrie 
 THE British National Championships at Crystal Palace at the weekend once again saw Wolverhampton dominate the proceedings, with their fighters Elvis Gordon, at heavyweight, Densign White, at middleweight, Fitzroy Davies, at light-middleweight, and Owen Pinnock the bantamweight all taking gold medals. 
 There was, however, no Wolverhampton presence in the category which generated the greatest interest this weekend &mdash; the light-heavyweight. 
 Following the Olympic bronze medalist Denis Stewart's decision to retire from competition after a poor performance in the world championships in Belgrade, two months ago, the No.1 spot was up for grabs. 
 Stewart's bitter rival, the veteran Nicholas Kokataylo, the 33-year-old from Denton, in Manchester, was favourite for the gold medal, but a strong challenge was expected from newcomer to the weight, Ray Stevens, 26, of the London Budokwai. 
 The reigning Commonwealth middleweight champion Stevens was forced to move up to the heavier weight following a knee injury and a prolonged viral infection. 
 Stevens's superior speed and technique combined with superb fighting spirit carried him through to the final. 
 Kokataylo and Stevens was an all-action affair with the Manchester fighter scoring with a leg throw in the opening seconds which almost finished the bout. 
 A half point was awarded but Stevens fought his way back into the contest scoring with a spectacular sacrifice throw and almost arm locking the much taller and heavier Kokataylo. 
 Stevens, despite losing the bout, clearly did enough to justify his pre-event selection for the Commonwealth Games. 
 PAGE 
 Rugby Union Scotland 32, Romania 0 Tea and sympathy for the poor. 
 By Robert Armstrong 
 IT WAS a melancholy experience to contemplate the poverty of the Romanians on and off the field at Murrayfield on Saturday. 
 Their antiquated reliance on set-pieces was predictable enough; less obvious to the scattered crowd of around 10,000 were the penny-pinching circumstances that surrounded this international sponsored by the Royal Bank of Scotland. 
 As every sports writer visiting Bucharest knows, the Romanian Rugby Federation is virtually bankrupt. 
 Indeed, their first trip to Scotland since 1981 would not have been possible without the assistance of four British-based companies trading in Eastern Europe who at the eleventh hour put up a total of &pound;10,000. 
 That sum may seem like a lot of lei (the Romanian currency that purchases next to nothing abroad) but it still left the Romanians treading a financial tightrope. 
 They had to journey from Heathrow to Edinburgh by overnight coach and check out of their Edinburgh hotel two hours before the kick-off because they could not afford to remain there after the match. 
 Even then, there was the embarrassing prospect that the Romanian players might have to walk the dark streets between having a bath at 3.30pm and the official dinner at 7.30pm. 
 Fortunately, the Scottish Rugby Union bridged the gap by serving the party with tea, and the hospitable Heriot's club followed that up with something a little stronger. 
 To their great credit, Romania looked far from demoralised on the field, driving the Scots on to the back foot for much of the first half and restricting the scoreline to 3-0 until the 39th minute. 
 If the East Europeans could have offered a bit more in the loose and a great deal more behind the scrum, they would have reaped some reward for their excellent work in the line-out. 
 As it was, Scotland took the game by the throat with four tries in a devastating 17-minute period either side of the interval. 
 Romania's inability to provide quick ball and their fumbling loss of possession often allowed the Scots to counter-attack from deep positions with the same instinctive fluency that has earned them 130 points in four games at Murrayfield this year. 
 No one impressed more than the 21-year-old Hawick wing Tony Stanger whose hat-trick of tries boosted his tally to five in two internationals. 
 Stanger has an appetite for apparently lost causes that rarely allows opponents to commit errors without getting punished. 
 The foundation of Scotland's success was laid in the loose by the captain, David Sole, and the No.8, Derek White, whose pace often confounded the Romanian back row, as well as bringing each man a second-half try. 
 But the disparity between the sides really emerged with a vengeance in the back division where Armstrong, Lineen and the Hastings brothers showed superior speed of thought, hand and foot. 
 Gavin Hastings kicked 12 points, including two touchline conversions. 
 Scotland's coach, Ian McGeechan, made the pertinent point that fixtures against Fiji and Romania had provided a valuable contrast of styles, expansive and then forward dominated, that were useful preparation for the Five Nations Championship. 
 &bquo;We had five or six extra training sessions together with a match at the end of them,&equo; said McGeechan. 
 On the evidence of the autumn action &mdash; and last summer's Lions tour to which Scots made a huge contribution &mdash; Scotland can win the championship, especially as they play their &bquo;difficult&equo; games against France and England at Murrayfield. 
 Their own opening game, against Ireland in Dublin, is on February 3 &mdash; which gives the fly-half, Craig Chalmers, plenty of time to recover from a troublesome knee injury. 
 SCORERS: Scotland: Tries: Stanger (3), White, Sole. 
 Conversions: G Hastings (3). 
 Penalties: G Hastings (2). 
 SCOTLAND: G Hastings (London Scottish); A Stanger (Hawick), S Hastings (Watsonians), S Lineen (Boroughmuir), L Renwick (London Scottish); D Wyllie (Stewart's-Melville), G Armstrong (Jed-Forest); D Sole (Edinburgh Academicals, capt), K Milne (Heriot's FP), P Burnell (London Scottish), C Gray (Nottingham), D F Cronin (Bath), J Jeffrey (Kelso), D White (London Scottish), F Calder (Stewart's-Melville). 
 ROMANIA: M Toader; B Serban, A Lungu, G Sava, S Chirila; G Ignat, D Neaga; G Leonte, V Ion, G Dumitrescu, S Ciorascu, C Raducanu, O Sugar, I Doja, H Dumitras (capt). 
 Referee: S Hilditch (Ireland). 
 Basingstoke 2, Torquay United 3 No more fairytales. 
 IN Ruddigore, Mad Margaret could be snapped out of her raving by the password &bquo;Basingstoke&equo;. 
 For a moment on Saturday it looked on the cards that the same word might forever snap the players of Torquay United the other way. 
 But it was only for a moment. 
 Immediately after Blankley's rocketing near-post header put Basingstoke ahead in the 40th minute, Elliott equalised. 
 Three minutes into the second-half the non-Leaguers' obligatory fireman, Mottashed, instead of shooting himself in the foot, set fire to himself with a jittery own goal and Loram shortly made it 3-1, deader than dead. 
 Clarkson's consolation was too late to make Torquay sweat. 
 As pantomime punters know, giants are no fun and no-one's friends unless they are killed. 
 Torquay, though, can now look forward to their home tie against West Ham when the seven-league boot will be on the other foot. 
 Basingstoke will inevitably look back. 
 Kipling wrote the famous &bquo;If&equo; but the FA Cup is always updating its own version. 
 They should remember that it would all have ended seven matches earlier if it had not been for an 88th-minute equaliser against Bashley on September 16. 
 Basingstoke can look back with pride, not only in a record crowd of 4,091 but in extending the reputation of non-League clubs for friendliness. 
 Even new towns may have a heart and Basingstoke's is beating warmly. 
 On the field Webb stood out for composure, O'Donnell's experience was invaluable, and their overseas player, Simpkins &mdash; he travels from the Isle of Wight &mdash; was brave and solid in goal. 
 Watership Down may be up the road, but Basingstoke proved no rabbits. 
 Scorers: Basingstoke: Blankley (40 min), Clarkson (90). 
 Torquay: Elliott (42), Mottashed (og, 48), Loram (54). 
 Basingstoke: Simpkins; Blankley, Davies, Wiltshire, Ingman, Webb, Greenwood, Whale, Clarkson, Mottashed, O'Donnell (Cameron, 77). 
 Torquay United: Veysey; Holmes, Lloyd, Elliott, Taylor, Joyce, Loram, Edwards, Smith, Uzzell, Weston (Davies, 74). 
 Referee: J Ashworth (Leicester). 
 Colchester United &mdash; beaten 2-0 by Birmingham City at Layer Road &mdash; donated 20p of the price of every programme to the fund for Sergeant Andy Mudd, the soldier who lost both his legs in the IRA bomb attack near the ground a fortnight ago. 
 Cornwall 12, Soviet Union 12 Mironov lands place in the history books. 
 By Ian Malin 
 AT 2.18 on Saturday, Igor Mironov, an air force pilot from the Gagarin Academy, put the ball into orbit. 
 It went clean through the Redruth posts and the Soviet Union's first tour of England had been well and truly launched. 
 Two hours later players rubbed bruises, swapped jokes and drank pints in the clubhouse in much the same way as anywhere else. 
 Tonight the Soviets attend a reception at the House of Commons and another tiny barrier will be broken down on Wednesday when the Combined Services provide the opposition at Aldershot. 
 On the evidence of Saturday, the captain Mironov is a prodigious kicker and beautifully balanced fly-half. 
 But the game was something of an anti-climax. 
 The Soviet Union had beaten Romania this autumn but were often on the back foot against players mainly culled from junior clubs. 
 Sergeev and Mishakov won heaps of line-out possession but they were often poorly supported at the set-pieces by the rest of the pack, while Tikhonov was a forceful No.8. 
 Graham Dawe, the Bath hooker, was impressed. 
 &bquo;They scrummed well and it was as hard a match as I've played in this season. 
 The only thing they really lacked was that extra bit of meanness that you need to impose yourself on a game.&equo; 
 Barry Trevaskis, who had six stitches put in a horrible wound under his left eye after being stamped on in a ruck, might not agree that the Soviets lacked meanness, but had their half-backs Chapman and Rule not missed six penalties between them, Cornwall could have brought off an unexpected win. 
 After Mironov and Chapman had twice exchanged penalties in the first half, Chapman's smart 30-yard dropped goal five minutes after the break put Cornwall ahead for the first time while Mishakov was off the field with a shoulder injury. 
 But the Soviet Union managed to fashion the only try of the game at Hellfire Corner. 
 The huge Tikhonov brushed aside two tackles and powered 15 yards from the back of a scrum to fingertip the ball over the line. 
 Cornwall rallied with some sweeping drives, the Soviets losing their discipline and Rule slotting over the equalising penalty 13 minutes from time. 
 The roar might have been heard on the other side of the Tamar Bridge. 
 SCORERS: Cornwall: Penalties: Chapman (2), Rule. 
 Dropped goal: Chapman. 
 Soviet Union: Try: Tikhonov. 
 Conversion: Mironov. 
 Penalties: Mironov. 
 CORNWALL: K Thomas (Redruth); B Trevaskis (Bath), C Alcock (capt), S Rogers, D Weeks; D Chapman, D Rule (all Camborne); J May (Redruth), G Dawe (Bath), A Ellery (Richmond), A Reed (Plymouth Albion), P Thomason (Redruth), A Bick (Bath), J Polglase (Camborne), G Williams (Redruth). 
 SOVIET UNION: E Zuev; I Kuperman, M Paarshin, I Necheaev, V Varapaev (Losabezidze, 70min); I Moronov (capt), I Frantzuzov; S Molchanov, R Malikov, I Hohlov, A Mishakov, S Sergeev, A Sokolov, R Khairulin, A Tikhonov. 
 Referee: A Speadbury (Somerset). 
 Coventry City 0, Arsenal 1 Merson repays club's belief. 
 By Russell Thomas 
 PAUL MERSON'S self-destructiveness banished him to football's margins for several weeks. 
 One moment of astonishing creativity in the dying seconds on Saturday transported him to the centre of Arsenal's universe. 
 Reputations are not changed overnight, but one of the most audacious goals of this or any other season can hardly hinder the rehabilitation of the young Arsenal striker, who has had plenty of time to repent at leisure past off-field indiscretions. 
 Suspended for a week by the club, fined &pound;2,000 and dropped following misbehaviour at a supporters' dinner, Merson spoke of the 89th-minute winner that restored Arsenal to the top as a personal thankyou to Arsenal's players and staff for assisting him on the road to recovery. 
 &bquo;I took a lot of stick from the press,&equo; said the England Under-21 player, &bquo;but the lads backed me and so did the manager. 
 I've paid them back. 
 The only way to do that is by scoring goals.&equo; 
 Then Merson departed, chivvied along by a watchful captain Tony Adams, for the team bus. 
 That left an embarrassed home goalkeeper Ogrizovic to explain how all 6ft 4in of him was beaten by a chip by Arsenal's substitue from 20 yards and from a daunting angle. 
 Ogrizovic came out, checked back, but in retreat still did not think the chip would float in. 
 &bquo;I couldn't believe it when the ball went in.&equo; 
 Anger followed astonishment as the ball entered via the far upright. 
 &bquo;I wanted to kick the post down.&equo; 
 George Graham was amazed, too, after seeing another high-octane Arsenal performance lack only the finishing touch against a weakened Coventry side who manfully tried to keep pace with the champions. 
 But his bold substitution &mdash; putting on Merson after 70 minutes to give his side a third orthodox striker &mdash; provided the missing ingredient. 
 Merson has not started in the last six games and his dramatic goal will not change Graham's thinking overnight. 
 &bquo;It doesn't guarantee Paul a place, and he knows it,&equo; said the manager. 
 But at least Merson is being judged solely on form. 
 &bquo;He's only 21 and he knows that he did wrong,&equo; said Graham. 
 &bquo;As far as we are concerned the incident is now forgotten.&equo; 
 SCORER: Arsenal: Merson (89min). 
 Coventry City: Ogrizovic; Borrows, Downs, MacDonald, Billing, Dobson, McGrath, Emerson, Regis, Drinkell, D Smith. 
 Arsenal: Lukic; Dixon, Winterburn, Thomas, O'Leary, Adams, Rocastle, Richardson, A Smith, Groves, Marwood (Merson, 70). 
 Referee: J Worrall (Warrington).. 
 Manchester United have joined Nottingham Forest in the competition for Grimsby's highly promising centre-back Andy Tilson. 
 Forest have had a &pound;175,000 offer rejected by the Fourth Division club who are unwilling to sell the former Kettering player while still in the FA Cup. 
 FA Cup third-round draw Petrifying Forest. 
 By Stephen Bierley 
 THE Cup draw was made rather late on Saturday and, no doubt, minds were a little muddled. 
 Hence one Sunday paper, commenting on the pairing of Nottingham Forest and Manchester United, described them as &bquo;two of the game's most successful clubs in recent years&equo;. 
 Half right, perhaps, depending on how you define &bquo;recent&equo;. 
 After a lousy annual meeting and a lousy result against Crystal Palace, Alex Ferguson might reasonably have hoped for a change of fortune. 
 Nobody loves you when you're down and out and if United go down to Forest, as they did in last year's sixth round, Ferguson may well be out. 
 The glory of the third round, of course, is the glory of the non-League clubs. 
 Whitley Bay are the current darlings, but found no love in the velvet bag, being despatched to Spotland. 
 &bquo;I'm obviously very disappointed for the players,&equo; said the manager, Bobby Graham. 
 &bquo;Rochdale are just Mickey Mouse compared with Liverpool.&equo; 
 Hard cheese. 
 Darlington fared no better, but Welling, Gloucester, Bishop Auckland and Aylesbury will replay with brimming hopes and bursting hearts this week. 
 Liverpool, the holders, get the chance to play European opposition, namely Swansea, who flirted briefly with the Cup Winners' Cup this season, losing to Panathinaikos almost before they could pronounce it. 
 As Liverpool have been all Greek to most First Division clubs for a decade, Swansea's chances do not seem that brilliant, but&hellip; and that &bquo;but&equo; is the delight of the FA Cup. 
 FA CUP: Third round: Stoke v Arsenal; Reading or Welling v Sunderland; Watford v Wigan; Brighton v Luton; Bristol City v Swindon; Maidstone or Exeter v Norwich; Sheffield Utd v Bournemouth; Port Vale v Derby; Cambridge Utd v Darlington; Leeds v Ipswich; Torquay v West Ham; Hull v Newcastle; Plymouth v Oxford Utd; West Bromwich v Wimbledon; Blackburn v Aston Villa; Manchester City v Millwall; Cardiff or Gloucester City v QPR; Wolverhampton v Sheffield Wednesday; Nottingham Forest v Manchester Utd; Birmingham v Oldham; Huddersfield v Grimsby; Chelsea v Crewe Alexandra or Bishop Auckland; Northampton or Aylesbury v Coventry; Leicester v Barnsley; Hereford v Walsall; Middlesbrough v Everton; Swansea v Liverpool; Tottenham v Southampton; Rochdale v Whitley Bay; Charlton v Bradford City; Crystal Palace v Portsmouth; Blackpool v Scunthorpe or Burnley. 
 To be played Jan 6. 
 Squash Davies show hits buffers. 
 By Richard Jago 
 ROBERT OWEN, a largely unconsidered left-hander from Avon, became a surprise semi-finalist in the British National Championships for the second successive year at Newcastle yesterday. 
 He did so by skilfully, beating Adrian Davies, the Welsh No.1, 9-6, 9-3, 4-9, 8-9, 9-4. 
 Davies had become the most controversial player of this tournament. 
 He has been an outspoken critic of the Squash Rackets Association's economic stringency at this unsponsored event and made an official complaint about Friday's referee, Ed Johnson. 
 And while upsetting the seventh-seeded England international, Jamie Hickox, on Saturday, Davies told the referee that Hickox did not deserve a let because the ball had been &bquo;tight, very tight, as tight as the SRA&equo;. 
 Yesterday, told his sponsor's logo was too large, he wore his shirt inside out. 
 Davies, an entertaining character, was lucky to escape unpenalised for joking and arguing disruptively yesterday. 
 Owen was warned for throwing his racket. 
 Owen today plays Del Harris, the favourite, who again played well while beating an England squad member, Mark Cairns, 9-5, 9-4, 9-2. 
 The other top seed, Martine Le Moignan, also won comfortably, 9-1, 9-3, 9-2 against another Welsh player, Tracey Thomas. 
 Later the reigning champion, Paul Carter, beat the second-seeded former champion, Phil Kenyon, 10-8, 9-7, 9-1 to earn himself a semi-final today with another former champion, Bryan Beeson, whose magnificent recovery overcome the England international Chris Walker 8-10, 8-10, 9-5, 9-0, 9-7. 
 GROUP A Italy Austria United States Czechoslovakia June 9 Italy v Austria, Rome 20.00 local time. 
 10 USA v Czech, Florence 16.00. 14 Italy v USA, Rome 20.00. 15 Austria v Czech, Florence 16.00. 19 Italy v Czech, Rome 20.00; Austria v USA, Florence 20.00. 
 GROUP D West Germany Yugoslavia United Arab Emirates Colombia. 
 June 9 UAE v Col, Bologna 20.00. 10 WG v Yugo, Milan 20.00. 14 Yugo v Col, Bologna 16.00. 15 WG v UAE, Milan 20.00. 19 WG v Col, Milan 16.00; Yugo v UAE, Bologna 16.00. 
 GROUP B Argentina Cameroun USSR Romania Fixtures: June 8 Argentina v Cameroun, Milan 17.00. 9 USSR v Romania, Bari 16.00. 13 Argentina v USSR, Naples 20.00. 14 Cameroun v Romania, Bari 20.00. 18 Argentina v Romania, Naples 20.00. 18 Cameroun v USSR, Bari 20.00. 
 GROUP E Belgium South Korea Uruguay Spain. 
 June 12 Bel v S Kor, Verona 16.00. 13 Urug v Sp, Udine 16.00. 17 Bel v Urug, Verona 20.00. 17 S Kor v Sp, Udine 20.00. day 21 Bel v Sp, Verona 16.00; S Kor v Urug, Udine. 
 GROUP C Brazil Sweden Costa Rica SCOTLAND June 10 Braz v Swe, Turin 20.00. 11 C Rica v Scot, Genoa 16.00. 16 Braz v C Rica, Turin 16.00; Swe v Scot, Genoa 20.00. 20 Braz v Scot, Turin 20.00; Swe v C Rica, Genoa 20.00. 
 GROUP F ENGLAND REPUBLIC OF IRELAND Holland Egypt. 
 June 11 Eng v R of Ire, Cagliari 20.00. 12 Holland v Egypt, Palermo 20.00. 16 Eng v Holland, Cagliari 20.00. 17 R of Ire v Egypt, Palermo 16.00; Eng v Egypt, Cagliari 20.00. 21 R of Ire v Holland, Palermo 20.00. 
 Snooker: Reynolds scales Davis peak. 
 By Clive Everton 
 DEAN REYNOLDS, whitewashed 10-0 by Steve Davis in the final of the Rothmans Grand Prix in October, beat him 9-7 to reach the semi-finals of the Everest World Matchplay Championship at the Brentwood Centre late on Saturday. 
 The Grimsby left-hander's semi-final opponent on Wednesday will be Jimmy White, who won the last seven frames in a row to turn a 5-2 deficit into a 9-5 win over Doug Mountjoy. 
 Reynolds, 15th in the world rankings at the start of the season, has improved provisionally to eighth. 
 He had a gilt-edged opportunity to beat Stephen Hendry, so far the man of the season with four first prizes, in the Stormseal UK Open at Preston, but missed a simple pink when leading 22-0 in the deciding frame and did not have another shot. 
 Davis came to Brentwood a 16-12 loser to Hendry in the UK final and is going through a patch where he is making more unforced errors than usual. 
 &bquo;There are certain times that are better than others,&equo; said Davis. 
 &bquo;I'm a very good player. 
 I can't be perfect.&equo; 
 Davis swept to 3-0 but missed the easiest of blues on the brink of 4-0. 
 Reynolds won that frame, the next on the pink, two more on the black, and the last of the afternoon to lead 5-3 at the interval. 
 He made it 6-3 with a 90 break, and after 52 minutes of tactical battling potted the pink for 7-3 and ran away with the next to go five up with six to play. 
 After this extraordinary eight-frame losing streak, Davis won four in a row to close to only 7-8, but two elementary mistakes in the following frame, failing to reach the yellow when rolling up behind it for a snooker, and failing to pot a red at close range along the top cushion, prefaced a run of 48 with which Reynolds secured his most notable scalp. 
 PAGE 
 McNeill insulted by Newcastle offer for Aitken. 
 By Patrick Glenn 
 THERE would appear to be no future in Newcastle United's courtship of Roy Aitken, the Celtic captain, following yesterday's disapproval of the affair by Billy McNeill, manager of the Glasgow club. 
 McNeill referred to Jim Smith, his counterpart at St James' Park, as &bquo;insulting&equo; and accused him of conducting private business in public. 
 It had been reported that Smith was to send a written offer to Celtic for Aitken, and although Smith would not specify the amount it became common knowledge that it was for around &pound;300,000. 
 McNeill said: &bquo;I have been waiting for two days for this supposed written offer. 
 Jim Smith seems intent on doing private business in public. 
 If that is the case, I'll talk to him the same way. 
 If he is insulting enough to make an offer for Aitken of the amount I have seen quoted, he needn't bother waiting for an answer. 
 &bquo;Smith seems determined to tell me what I want for Roy Aitken, when in fact he has never asked me. 
 He is simply jumping on a publicity bandwagon.&equo; 
 This is not the stuff of which marriages are made, and it is quite clear that if United do not improve what Celtic consider to be a derisory offer for the Scotland captain, who has made 50 international appearances, there will be no union. 
 Celtic are in no hurry to sell, and if they continue the form they showed in the 3-0 victory over Hibernian at Easter Road they will be quite happy not to have any calls from potential buyers at least until the end of the season. 
 The breathtaking goals which the Polish pair, Dziekanowski and Wdowczyk, scored before the interval were supplemented by Walker's score 20 minutes from the end. 
 Wdowczyk, after only four competitive matches, looks one of the best players to have come to the Premier Division in years. 
 The points, however, made no impact on the joint leaders, Aberdeen and Rangers, who also enjoyed good victories. 
 Aberdeen, who retain the edge on goal difference, took the points from Dundee United at Pittodrie with goals by Nicholas and Mason, while Ally McCoist established a Premier Division scoring record in Rangers's 3-0 home win over Motherwell. 
 He scored the second, taking him past Frank McGarvey's 127. 
 PAGE 
 Hockey Clift paves way for East Grinstead. 
 By Pat Rowley 
 ENGLAND's players endured a nine-hour delay on their overnight trip back from Pakistan on Saturday, but it proved no handicap to the 10 who played in the Nationwide Anglia English Cup, yesterday. 
 Hounslow, the holders, Havant and East Grinstead all gained clear-cut victories to qualify for away ties against other First Division sides in the eighth finals, and an England player scored for each of them. 
 Robert Clift, playing in his England position of inside-left, scored his first two goals of the season for East Grinstead, who beat Eastcote 3-0 at Feltham. 
 The first came after 10 minutes with a fine flick shot. 
 With the England captain, Richard Leman, in excellent form, Grinstead were too powerful in midfield for an Eastcote side without their skipper, Gary Tucker. 
 Chris John completed the scoring. 
 Hounslow had to wait until the second-half before England's Martyn Grimley scored their first goal in a 3-0 win over Lyons, the Poundstretcher Second Division side. 
 Nick Gordon and Rob Thompson added the others. 
 Havant, with five England men on duty, beat Barford Tigers, 5-2 but, after leading 3-0, allowed the Midland League club to cut the deficit to 3-2 early in the second half with corner goals by Mohamed. 
 Dave Roberts (two), Garcia, Seabrook and Gary Roberts scored for Havant. 
 Only two of the leaders in the regional leagues, Firebrands and Chelmsford, were victorious. 
 Firebrands beat Swindon 3-0 to extend a seven-point lead at the West League's winter break. 
 Chelmsford are four points clear in the East League after a penalty by Adrian Heelis proved decisive against Pelicans. 
 In the London League, Hampstead and Spencer overtook Surbiton, who snatched a draw at Purley; Ben Rhydding, beaten 3-2 by Sheffield, were overhauled by Preston and Alderley Edge in the North; while Trojans, held 2-2 by Anchorians, were joined by Chichester at the top of the South. 
 . 
 ONLY a month before the publication of Lord Justice's Taylor's full report on football safety there were disturbing suggestions yesterday that some clubs have failed to implement interim recommendations made in the wake of the Hillsborough disaster, writes David Hopps. 
 A crowd crush at Ayresome Park on Saturday forced Middlesbrough's match with Leeds United to be suspended for 15 minutes, and so alarmed the Leeds manager, Howard Wilkinson, that he clambered on to the perimeter fencing to appeal for calm. 
 Yesterday, Bob Schofield, treasurer of the Leeds supporters club, alleged: &bquo;People were very disturbed. 
 There was no exit in the perimeter fence and the gates in the side fence were locked. 
 Anyone trying to climb the fence could have been impaled on spikes the size of joiner's nails. 
 Clubs are not acting upon the Taylor report.&equo; 
 Cleveland police will hold an inquiry. 
 Chief Supt Terry Tasker stressed there was no crowd fighting, adding: &bquo;Some Leeds supporters bought tickets for other parts of the ground and they were flushed out and taken to the enclosure set aside for them.&equo; 
 The capacity of the south-east corner is only 2,108 and such was the demand for tickets in Leeds that 8,000 fans watched the match on close-circuit TV at Elland Road. 
 The crush was eased by moving some fans to an empty, condemned section of the ground. 
 All five spectators taken to Middlesbrough General Hospital were released yesterday, one with a broken leg. 
 Ten had treatment on the side of the pitch. 
 PAGE 
 Judo: Stevens justifies selection. 
 By Edward Ferrie 
 THE British National Championships at Crystal Palace at the weekend once again saw Wolverhampton dominate the proceedings, with their fighters Elvis Gordon, at heavyweight, Densign White, at middleweight, Fitzroy Davies, at light-middleweight, and Owen Pinnock the bantamweight all taking gold medals. 
 There was, however, no Wolverhampton presence in the category which generated the greatest interest this weekend &mdash; the light-heavyweight. 
 Following the Olympic bronze medalist Denis Stewart's decision to retire from competition after a poor performance in the world championships in Belgrade, two months ago, the No.1 spot was up for grabs. 
 Stewart's bitter rival, the veteran Nicholas Kokataylo, the 33-year-old from Denton, in Manchester, was favourite for the gold medal, but a strong challenge was expected from newcomer to the weight, Ray Stevens, 26, of the London Budokwai. 
 The reigning Commonwealth middleweight champion Stevens was forced to move up to the heavier weight following a knee injury and a prolonged viral infection. 
 Stevens's superior speed and technique combined with superb fighting spirit carried him through to the final. 
 Kokataylo and Stevens was an all-action affair with the Manchester fighter scoring with a leg throw in the opening seconds which almost finished the bout. 
 A half point was awarded but Stevens fought his way back into the contest scoring with a spectacular sacrifice throw and almost arm locking the much taller and heavier Kokataylo. 
 Stevens, despite losing the bout, clearly did enough to justify his pre-event selection for the Commonwealth Games. 
 PAGE 
 Adams awaits Robson's call. 
 By David Lacey 
 TONY ADAMS could make an unexpected return to the England team against Yugoslavia at Wembley on Wednesday. 
 Terry Butcher and Mark Wright have picked up injuries and are doubtful starters. 
 At the moment, Adams, who won his last full cap in Saudi Arabia 13 months ago, is set to lead the England B side against Yugoslavia B at Millwall tomorrow night. 
 But if Butcher, who damaged a knee playing for Rangers on Saturday, and Wright, who aggravated a neck injury playing for Derby County, have to drop out, the Arsenal captain will be promoted back to the senior squad. 
 &bquo;Wright is the more doubtful of the two,&equo; Bobby Robson, the England manager, said last night. 
 &bquo;He hurt his neck last Thursday and the club have admitted taking a risk playing him on Saturday. 
 That couldn't have done him any good.&equo; 
 Wright has not played for England since the European Championship game against Holland 18 months ago but Robson has been sufficiently impressed by his League form to recall him to the squad. 
 Butcher has missed only one of England's last 13 matches. 
 John Barnes, who incurred a hamstring injury at Anfield on Saturday, is out of the Yugoslavia game. 
 Robson, who is expected to bring Steve Bull and David Platt into the attack for Beardsley and Lineker, can play Hodge on the left in Barnes's place and keep Waddle on the right, where he performed so well in the goalless draw with Italy last month. 
 Robson confirmed last night that England's friendly with the Republic of Ireland, due to be played in Dublin on March 28, was now in doubt with the teams drawn together in the same World Cup group. 
 &bquo;It will be a joint decision by Jack Charlton and myself,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We don't intend to pull out until we are certain it is the right thing to do. 
 We both need a match on that date and getting replacements will not be easy.&equo; 
 The Irish have already sounded out Sweden as possible alternatives. 
 The B fixture against England in Cork on March 27 will go ahead. 
 David Lacey on the World Cup draw A case of deja vu for England and Ireland. 
 THE draw for the 1990 World Cup has been kind to the host nation, Italy, but hard on the holders, Argentina, easy on the West Germans and Brazilians and fair to the Scots but mean to Belgium, Uruguay and Spain. 
 It has also left England, Holland and the Republic of Ireland staring at one another in blank disbelief. 
 These teams were drawn together in the European Championship in West Germany last year, when England lost to the other two. 
 Now they will play each other in Group F of the World Cup, with England, the top seeds, in Sardinia and the Dutch and the Irish based in Sicily. 
 The one consolation is that the fourth team are Egypt rather than the Soviet Union. 
 The bad news is that the side finishing second in this group could well meet the Soviets in the opening phase of the knockout stage, which is when the World Cup begins in earnest. 
 England seem to have come an awfully long way simply to discover that it's a small world, and the Irish did not need reminding about Murphy's Law. 
 Yet if football was the only factor the prospect would be a fascinating one &mdash; the 1988 show transferred from the summer thunderstorms of West Germany to the clinging heat of Palermo and Cagliari, in which the Egyptians will be the only players who feel at home. 
 Unhappily, the pairing of England and Holland will be the centre of attention for all the wrong reasons, not least a repetition of the media hyperbole which accompanied their European Championship match in Dusseldorf 18 months ago. 
 That game was billed as football's Armageddon and the fact that there was no trouble between rival fans in the Rheinstadion did not get in the way of a good hooligan story. 
 Bert Millichip, the FA chairman, withdrew England's application for the clubs to be allowed back into Europe largely because of the way incidents involving English fans, the Dusseldorf police and young Germans looking for trouble had been reported by the press and TV back home. 
 There is now the danger that the same media circus will be dispatched to Sardinia next summer looking for the same headlines which will produce a similar outcome. 
 However, it should be remembered that the Holland football supporter abroad is a different character altogether to the wreckers of Ajax and Feyenoord, Utrecht and Den Haag. 
 There was no trouble, for example, when thousands of Dutchmen descended on Wrexham in October for the World Cup qualifier against Wales. 
 Moreover, the Dutch visit to Cagliari on June 16 will be fleeting; a lot of their fans will travel in and out on the day. 
 Nevertheless, it would be naive to suggest that the draw has not presented Sardinia with an even bigger security problem than it had bargained for. 
 Glen Kirton, the FA's assistant secretary, said that Les Walker, in charge of England security, and his Dutch opposite, Robert de Bakker, would be going to Sardinia soon to examine the situation. 
 In case it has been forgotten, the real purpose of England's visit to Italy is to attempt to raise the watershed of previous English achievements in World Cups played abroad beyond the quarter-finals. 
 To stand the best chance of doing this they need to win the group, which would bring them a match in Bologna against the runners-up from Group E. 
 This group is to be contested by Belgium, Uruguay and Spain with South Korea threatening to surprise any one of those three. 
 While nobody would suggest that Uruguay, for example, might represent easy opposition for Robson's players the likely alternatives in the second phase are alarming. 
 Should England come second they would then go to Genoa to play the runners-up from Group B, who are more likely to be Argentina or the Soviet Union than Romania or Cameroun, although this does look the toughest, tightest group of all. 
 Finshing third, provided they were one of the four successful stragglers, would leave England to play the winners of Group D, West Germany's group, in Milan or Group C, probably Brazil, in Turin. 
 Before all that, however, England have to readdress themselves to the problem of defeating the Irish and the Dutch, who beat them in Stuttgart and Dusseldorf last year. 
 England have more in their favour this time: as many as three go through, rather than one, and they will play all their opening matches in Cagliari whereas their rivals all have to shuttle back and forth from Palermo. 
 Jack Charlton, the Republic of Ireland manager, did not attend Saturday's draw in Rome but seemed more upset on TV back home than did Bobby Robson, who made all the right diplomatic noises in the Palazzo dello Sport without giving much away. 
 Thijs Lijbregts, who took over from Rinus Michels after Holland won the European Championship, has the additional pressure of managing one of the fancied teams while his best player, Ruud Gullit, is struggling to recover from a knee injury that has so far necessitated four operations and is threatening his career. 
 &bquo;We have other good,&equo; Lijbregts pointed out on Saturday. 
 The Irish, making their first appearance in the World Cup finals, could have hoped if not for something better then at least something different. 
 Their manager's distress on hearing the draw could have something to do with the fact that Messiahs are not usually expected to rework old miracles. 
 England are due to play a friendly in Dublin on March 28 and even before the draw Lansdowne Road was assured of a sell-out. 
 But neither Robson nor Charlton may be too keen now to expose their teams to the little nuances and shifts of psychological advantage that could have a bearing on the game in Cagliari on June 11. 
 Egypt's best recent result is their 1-0 win over Bulgaria in Cairo in March last year. 
 England have played them once, in a warm-up before the 1986 World Cup when they won 4-0 in Cairo. 
 It is considered preferable to play the easiest opposition last. 
 Scotland, on the other hand, open the World Cup against Costa Rica in Genoa &mdash; shades of Dortmund in 1974 when they sauntered to a 2-0 win over Zaire and did not realise that this was the game to build up a healthy balance of goals. 
 Nevertheless the draw has dealt more sympathetically with the Scots than it did before the 1986 World Cup, when they found themselves grouped with West Germany, Uruguay and Denmark. 
 Unless there is a cock-up against Costa Rica, who they meet in their first match, Andy Roxburgh's team should reach the second phase. 
 This will be Scotland's third World Cup encounter with Brazil; they drew 0-0 in 1974 and Brazil won 4-1 in 1982. 
 Austria, Czechoslovakia or Italy seem to be Scotland's most likely opponents if they make the second phase. 
 England could play Italy in Rome in the quarter-finals, in which case the security problem would be even more acute. 
 They could also play Argentina or the Soviet Union at this stage. 
 Wherever you look England appear likely to encounter the sort of quality of opposition that has usually ended their World Cup ambitions in the past. 
 But first they have to solve the Irish problem, see off the Dutch, and remember how Egypt looked to an Englishman before Suez. 
 The draw ceremony was conducted seductively by Sophia Loren, operatically by Pavarotti, efficiently by Joseph Blatter, the Fifa general-secretary, and set against a background of studied chaos which would have done credit to a film by Fellini. 
 The only people who really matter, the players, were conspicuous by their absence. 
 Women win at last. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 THE third serious attempt in recent years to have women admitted to full membership of Lancashire County Cricket Club was successful at the AGM on Saturday, with a 68 per cent vote in favour. 
 This gives women equal access to a pavilion that has been a male preserve for 125 years and leaves Lord's as English cricket's last bastion of discrimination. 
 The early acquiescent mood suggested that the predictions of a &bquo;stormy&equo; meeting would be inaccurate. 
 Accounts were adopted without question, rule changes without demur. 
 But by the end of a long morning, this show's reputation for unrivalled unpredictability and entertainment was still intact. 
 And a unique flavour was provided by the appearance of Stephanie Anne Lloyd (formerly Kenneth Hull), &bquo;by a technicality your first full female member&equo;. 
 Sex-change operations are more than some Lancashire members can cope with, and a bewildered silence descended on the Tyldesley Suite as Ms Lloyd, who runs a string of shops for transvestites, appealed for a &bquo;more enlightened approach in future&equo;. 
 Some of the hardliners made their last-ditch appeals to sway the meeting. 
 There was some particularly strong stuff from two members from Southport, and there were references to &bquo;Emily Pankhurst and her floosies&equo; and, inevitably, to Mrs Thatcher &mdash; &bquo;We've all seen what can happen when women get control&equo;. 
 But even visions of breastfeeding could not stem the tide this time. 
 For the Lancashire committee the vote (2,046 in favour, 961 against) will have come as a relief, and for John Brewer in particular as something of a triumph. 
 He was campaigning on behalf of women 13 years ago. 
 Rugby League Regal Trophy, second round: Leeds 27, Bradford Northern 8 Leeds start and end with a flourish. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 LEEDS opened and finished this Regal Trophy second-round game at Headingley with tries of such quality as to mollify their followers for all the dross in between. 
 Bradford showed little of the enterprising approach that has been helping them shed a dour image this season, but it was not until the 64th minute that they began to slide out of the contest. 
 All that separated the sides at that point was a low bullet of a drop goal from Schofield that had put Leeds ahead 9-8. 
 They had been marginally the more dangerous side, but there was nothing then to suggest that Bradford might not complete their third win of the season over Leeds. 
 Soon afterwards Bradford were on their way out when exemplary support play &mdash; not a notable Leeds feature this day &mdash; by Izzard, Lord and Gibson sent Maskill, the man of the match, sprawling over the line. 
 Maskill improved his own try and Leeds were 15-8 in front. 
 Even better followed when the intelligent Coleman, always capable of rising above the mundane, made a marvellous break that was followed by a superb inside pass to Divorty. 
 So inviting was the gap created that the loose forward was able to score at the back of the posts, leaving Maskill with another simple kick. 
 Wilson, in the last minute, then broke from full-back, came full speed on to Coleman's pass, and the Bradford defence was cut open again. 
 Maskill improved the try and Leeds were home with a comfort which flattered them. 
 Leeds's opening try in the 12th minute had also been a fine effort, spread over 70 yards and involving Schofield, Maskill and Izzard before Coleman went for the corner. 
 Such excellence threw the next hour into even sharper relief with two sides growing increasingly scrappy. 
 Three penalties by Hobbs kept Bradford firmly in contention and another soon after the interval levelled the scores at 8-8. 
 Hobbs could have put Bradford 9-8 ahead with his easiest kick of the afternoon, but he struck a post and six minutes later Maskill scored the try which started that late rush of Leeds points. 
 Leeds: Wilson; Fawcett, Schofield, Gibson, Ford; Heron, Coleman; Izzard, Maskill, Dixon, Powell (Gunn, 61min), Laurie (Lord, 29), Divorty. 
 Bradford Northern: Wilkinson (Johnson, 68); Cordle, McGowan, Mackay, Francis; Henjak, Harkin (Richards, 59); Hobbs, Barraclough, Fairbank, Roebuck, Pendlebury, Stewart. 
 Referee: R Whitfield (Widnes). 
 Liverpool 1, Aston Villa 1 Villa besieged after the fall of Barnes. 
 By Stephen Bierley 
 NOBODY heard a sound. 
 One second John Barnes was all taunt and tease; the next he stopped dead, like a shot pheasant, and twirled slowly to the Anfield earth. 
 Not a snap or a twang, but the hamstring had gone for the second time in successive matches. 
 England will feel the immediate loss. 
 And Liverpool, already up to the physio's ceiling with assorted aches, strains and pains, notably those of Nicol, Gillespie and Hansen, may find December and the New Year decidedly awkward. 
 Dalglish wore the demeanour of a man who had just discovered the cat had been sick in his slippers. 
 &bquo;We have,&equo; he said through a zipped mouth, &bquo;a few favours to come.&equo; 
 The rest of the First Division, to twist WC Fields slightly, will be anxious not to give an injury-hit Liverpool an even break. 
 Aston Villa, with eight wins from their previous nine League matches, managed to nudge Liverpool's writing arm in the first half every time a cogent word or telling flourish was about to be penned. 
 Liverpool fretted and Villa scored, Ormondroyd touching on a Spink clearance via Daley to Olney, whose fierce shot burst through Grobbelaar's attempted save. 
 Neither Olney nor Ormondroyd are pretty players, being more giraffe than gazelle. 
 But once on the move they are devilishly difficult to stop, as is Villa's right winger, Daley. 
 &bquo;We posed them quite a few threats in the first half,&equo; said Graham Taylor, while conceding the second belonged to Liverpool. 
 Villa were quite unable to get out of their own half after the interval, with Whelan's precise, perceptive passing aways likely to unhinge them. 
 &bquo;We would have liked to support Olney more,&equo; said Taylor, but as Liverpool plundered the middle ground Daley became increasingly peripheral, while Ormondroyd and Platt were needed to contain rather than construct. 
 Mountfield, veteran of many a Merseyside derby, Nielsen and McGrath were magnificently combative, the more so after Beardsley had equalised. 
 This was probably not the most significant draw on Saturday, but at least it was not reliant on a Lancaster Gate sell-out to televison or Sophia Loren's fingers. 
 &bquo;I shall not be taking my holidays in Sardinia,&equo; Taylor quipped. 
 Nobody mentioned anything Italian to Barnes, least of all Parma ham. 
 SCORERS: Liverpool: Beardsley (64); Aston Villa: Olney (21) Liverpool: Grobbelaar; Hysen, Staunton, Ablett, Whelan, Molby, Beardsley, Houghton, Rush, Barnes (Tanner, 38), McMahon. 
 Aston Villa: Spink; Price, Gray, McGrath, Mountfield, Nielsen, Daley, Platt, Olney, Cowans, Ormondroyd. 
 Referee: K Redfern (Whitley Bay). 
 Toshiba Divisional Championship: London 28, South-West 12 Incisive midfield sets up fine finale. 
 By David Frost 
 BY defeating the South-West at Imber Court, London ensured that the Toshiba Divisional Championship will have a proper climax at Otley on Saturday when the two unbeaten sides meet &mdash; London and the North. 
 London's chief strengths are the driving mauls of their forwards and the incisiveness of their midfield trio of Andrew, Carling and Clough. 
 In addition, Paul Ackford and Neil Edwards won important possession from the line-outs, and Andrew was successful with six out of nine kicks at goal. 
 The South-West forwards tried to play a similar mauling game, but with Teague far short of his true form they seldom made much headway and only occasionally produced clean possession for Hill. 
 Even so, Hill had another highly impressive game, passing crisply, nosing out openings, supporting assiduously and doing much useful work in defence. 
 Much of the game was taken up with mauls which an alert French referee often had to turn into scrums. 
 But London won enough of the ball for Carling to display his acceleration and his priceless ability to time a pass. 
 The strong running of Clough was an ideal complement to the subtlety of Carling; and Pilgrim, until handicapped by a blow on the thigh, showed how much improved he is. 
 London created two tries through running and passing and got another from a pushover. 
 The South-West's late try came when Clough was sent a hospital pass and Fallon booted the loose ball over the line. 
 The London captain, David Pegler, said afterwards he was disappointed that his team did not play to their full potential, and their coach, Dick Best, felt the same. 
 &bquo;We didn't get out of second gear,&equo; he said, &bquo;but we are looking to get into third gear and, hopefully, top for next Saturday.&equo; 
 SCORERS: London: Tries: Pegler, Pilgrim, Clarke. 
 Conversions: Andrew 2. 
 Penalties: Andrew 4. 
 South-West: Try: Fallon. 
 Conversion: Livesey. 
 Penalties: Livesey 2. 
 LONDON: S Pilgrim (Wasps; J Buckton, Saracens, 69min); S Smith (Wasps), F Clough (Wasps), W Carling (Harlequins), E Davis (Harlequins); R Andrew (Wasps), S Bates (Wasps; C Luxton, Harlequins, 39); J Leonard (Saracens), J Olver (Harlequins), J Probyn (Wasps), N Edwards (Harlequins), P Ackford (Harlequins), D Pegler (Wasps, captain), B Clarke (Saracens), M Skinner (Harlequins). 
 SOUTH-WEST: J Webb (Bristol); J Fallon (Richmond), A Adebayo (Bath), S Halliday (Bath, capt), S Walklin (Plymouth Albion); M Livesey (Richmond), R Hill (Bath); A Sharp (Bristol) K Dunn (Gloucester), R Pascall (Gloucester), N Redman (Bath), J Etheridge (Gloucester), I Smith (Gloucester), D Sims (Gloucester), M Teague (Gloucester). 
 Referee: F Casteret (France).. 
 First Division Manchester United 1, Crystal Palace 2 United stocks lower. 
 By Cynthia Bateman 
 AS UNITED were booed off the pitch, a supporter leaned into the director's box and tried to thrust a &pound;5 note into the hands of Amer Midani, urging him to buy out the chairman, Martin Edwards. 
 He declined the offer. 
 United are rapidly reaching the stage where you would be lucky to give them away. 
 Give Palace's manager Steve Coppell the dosh and he will show you what to do with it. 
 Nigel Martyn, the goalkeeper he bought from Bristol Rovers for &pound;1 million, has turned out to be a snip, his acrobatics saving the day when United penetrated Palace's back four, newly shored up by the strapping Andy Thorn. 
 The Palace defence, once as leaky as MI5 (remember the 9-0 defeat by Liverpool) was under pressure most of the time but withstood it, and the striker Bright, on the three occasions he was given a chance, hit the bar once and scored twice, with characteristic headers, giving Palace their first away win in the League this season. 
 United's manager, Alex Ferguson, must despair. 
 He cannot put a foot right. 
 His decision to drop Hughes to see if McClair could recover his striking form of the season before last proved to be popular only with Palace. 
 Apart from a header comfortably collected by Martyn, McClair could only chase the game. 
 When Hughes, who had been cheered every time he warmed up, was brought on with United 2-1 down, Ferguson again incurred the crowd's wrath by bringing off Sharpe, who like all United's young players is popular with the supporters. 
 Wallace, who had been playing up front with McClair to no devastating effect, moved out to his usual position on the left wing, with similar results. 
 It was left to another youngster, Russell Beardsmore, playing so tiny he looks like a mascot among the big central defenders, to show United the way. 
 Lethal as a sliver of glass, he scythed a flying header through a ruck of defenders' armpits to put United ahead after nine minutes. 
 Robson chipped cleverly, delightfully and frequently; Ince, at right-back, cut diagonal gashes across midfield; Pallister, safer going forwards than backwards, swept Palace aside. 
 Unfortunately, they never did it all in one move. 
 United are a variety show when they should be the movie. 
 But The Mad Axeman could be coming soon. 
 Forest loom in the FA Cup in the New Year, and if United, who had their lowest League crowd of the season on Saturday and are now only six points ahead of the bottom club City, still cannot see the wood for the trees, somebody will be in for the chop. 
 SCORERS: Manchester United: Beardsmore (9min). 
 Crystal Palace: Bright (40, 55). 
 Manchester United: Leighton; Beardsmore, Martin, Bruce, Phelan (Blackmore, 80), Pallister, Robson, Ince, McClair, Sharpe (Hughes, 56), Wallace. 
 Crystal Palace: Martyn; Pemberton, Dennis, Gray (Barber, 78), Hopkins, O'Reilly, Thorne, Thomas, Bright, Wright, Pardew. 
 Referee: T Simpson (Halifax). 
 Bridgend 16, Neath 22 Close encounter. 
 By Martyn Williams 
 THE SIEGE mentality suddenly occupies all thoughts at Neath. 
 Denied access to Europe and elsewhere by the Welsh Rugby Union, awaiting a lengthy ban on the international lock Gareth Llewellyn, they battled against Bridgend within the confines of a 20 square yard area. 
 Few games have been played in such restricted space yet provided so much furious forward movement and pace. 
 If the approach was to impress the reported carloads of northern scouts, they would have returned home with the memory of short explosive bursts, close support play and dogged determination, but little else. 
 Glen Webbe, of international fame and a target for League clubs, might just as well have stayed home decorating his Christmas tree for what he was called on to do. 
 Little of the frantic and customary Neath 15-man handling movements were seen and until late in the game, three-quarters and full-backs stood motionless, until they also found the driving maul and battering game too appealing. 
 All four of Neath's tries were close-to-the-line affairs, including a penalty try award. 
 Mark Jones at No.8, impressive within the legal bounds of the game, less so outside them, scored two, Paul Williams the other, with Paul Thorburn contributing three conversions. 
 Such a pulsating close battle required firmer handling than administered by Brian Wallis, for there were quite a few personal grudges raging. 
 As soon as the Bridgend flanker, Gerald Williams, triumphantly &bquo;spiked&equo; the ball, American Football-style, after scoring his team's opening try, his card was marked. 
 And so it proved, with a blood-stained Williams replaced by John Berrington in the second half. 
 Gareth Williams, celebrating his 500th appearance for Bridgend, fears for the game's future, if the thuggish element is not removed. 
 The durable former Wales and Lions forward accepts controlled aggression but recognises the need for attractive rugby. 
 Much to their credit in launching a spirited assault on the Neath lead, Bridgend did attempt to spread the ball wide. 
 Even they, though, found the battering-ram principle too convenient yet unproductive. 
 Had they followed the example of Aled Williams, who scored a scintillating try around the Neath cover, the game might have released itself from the siege strangehold. 
 Neath's formula has destroyed most opponents this season. 
 It is to Bridgend's credit, their pack and the battling scrum-half Kevin Ellis, that they did not wilt when others would have submitted. 
 SCORERS: Bridgend: Tries: G Williams, A Williams. 
 Conversion: A Parry. 
 Penalty goals: A Parry 2. 
 Neath: Tries: M Jones 2, P Williams, penalty try. 
 Conversions: P Thorburn 3. 
 Bridgend: A Parry; G Webbe, L Evans, J Apsee (capt), R Diplock; A Williams, K Ellis; D Austin, L Phillips, C Connolly, N Spender, Gareth Williams, S Apsee, S Bryant, Gerald Williams (J Berrington). 
 Neath: P Thorburn; C Higgs, C Laity, J Ball, J Riggs; P Williams, C Bridges; B Williams, K Phillips (capt), J Pugh, Glynn Llewellyn, Gareth Llewellyn, R Phillips, M Jones, D Pickering. 
 Referee: B Wallis (Cwmbran). 
 Midlands 9, North 17 Hodgkinson put in a position of weakness as North march on. 
 By David Irvine 
 AS England's selectors nowseem happy, or spoiled for choice, in all positions bar full-back and No.8, it was perhaps inevitable that Saturday's irrelevance at The Reddings should broaden the hunt and thrust Messrs Hodgkinson, Langford, Rodber and Charles Cusani into the spotlight. 
 Inevitable, yet a pity too. 
 For while Baldwin offered a rare but masterly dislay of two-handed catching; the ever-active Hitchen a taste of the modern hooker's arts; and Packman, Heslop, Wells and Buckton some excellent individual touches, the four candidates with the best chance of recognition fell some considerable way short of hopes and expectations. 
 Though the North scored three tries to nil for their 11th win in their last 12 matches in the competition, it would not be far-fetched to suggest that with Hodgkinson at stand-off &mdash; and, overall, he produced more thrust than any other midfield player &mdash; the Midlands might well have won. 
 Unfortunately he failed to impress as a full-back. 
 His positional play and line kicking were poor. 
 Opposite him Langford made some thundering tackles but then blotted his copybook with a stupid kick which, but for Underwood's timely intervention, might have cost his side the match. 
 Rodber looked raw while Cusani's insistance on picking the ball up at every second scrum was one of the main reasons why the North's centres never made much headway. 
 The North's match with London at Otley next Saturday will decide the championship &mdash; as if anyone cares. 
 Certainly there was little at Moseley to suggest anyone does. 
 As a contest it was neither designed to set the pulses racing nor win converts. 
 Without Underwood's pace &mdash; he overhauled Evans three times when the Midlands wing looked clear &mdash; Pears, who squandered possession and missed five kicks, could have sealed his side's fate. 
 Instead the day was saved by some unexpectedly strong finishing. 
 Underwood got the first try, following a searing diagonal run by Heslop, and then returned the compliment by giving Heslop the scoring pass for the second. 
 Morris claimed the third from short range. 
 SCORERS: Midlands: Penalties: Hodgkinson (3). 
 North: Tries: Underwood, Heslop, Morris. 
 Conversion: Pears. 
 Penalty goal: Pears. 
 MIDLANDS: S Hodgkinson (Nottingham); B Evans, T Buttimore, I Bates (all Leicester) F Packman (Northampton); A Sutton, B Gabriel (both Nottingham); G Pearce (Northampton), T Thacker (Leicester), M Linnett (Moseley), M Bayfield (Bedford), D Hindmarsh (Nottingham), J Wells (Leicester), G Rees (Nottingham), T Rodber (Northampton). 
 NORTH: S Langford; N Heslop (Orrell); G Childs (Northern), B Barley (Wakefield), R Underwood (Leicester); D Pears (Harlequins), D Morris (Liverpool St H); M Whitcombe (Sale), N Hitchen, S Southern (Orrell capt), D Baldwin (Sale), D Cusani (Orrell), S Hodgson (Sale), P Buckton (Liverpool St H), C Cusani (Orrell). 
 Referee: E Morrison (Gloucestershire). 
 Basketball Riders gallop on last legs. 
 By Robert Pryce 
 THERE are only six Leicester Riders left in the saddle, but yesterday they came within a basket of carrying off the weekend's biggest surprise. 
 The Sunderland 76ers, who are surging up the Carlsberg League table, almost came a cropper at the Granby Halls. 
 Though Clyde Vaughan (24 points), Scott Wilke (23) and Russ Saunders (20) were all firing, they struggled to put away the weakened Riders, 89-88. 
 With just under two minutes left, Leicester led 88-83. 
 Then Saunders stole twice from Mike Landell, Vaughan sank four free throws and Sunderland had nicked the points. 
 Cat Johnson, the Leicester player-coach, has injured an ankle, Dave Harris is out with a recurring leg injury, and Pat Morrison was released last week. 
 In their absence, Jerry Jenkins, a veteran so aged that his court time is usually handed out in short and widely spaced passages, was required to carry a heavier load. 
 He responded with 20 points, his best haul of the season. 
 The 6ft 10in Scott Paterson led the Riders' scoring with 26 points. 
 Landell and Whitney Dabney contributed 14 each. 
 Though Perry Bromwell (12 points) returned yesterday to the London Docklands line-up after injury, the Eastenders had no answer to their visitors from the royal borough of Kingston. 
 The Kings did not need to be at their pearly best to win 111-77. 
 Micah Blunt and Martin Clark led the league leaders' scorers with 20 points each. 
 Balding's Beech Road appears to be on the right trail for a Champion double. 
 By Richard Baerlein 
 TOBY BALDING returned home to his Weyhill stables after racing at Cheltenham on Saturday secure in the knowledge that in Beech Road and Morley Street he trains the two best hurdlers in the country. 
 In the Champion Hurdle, which he won at 50-1 and in the Sandeman Hurdle at Liverpool, where at 10-1 he gave weight and a beating to some of the best hurdlers in training, Beech Road established himself as an outstanding champion, and although he did not win the Charles Heidsieck Champagne Bula Hurdle on Saturday, he confirmed his position at the top of the tree. 
 For his seasonal debut on going which was too fast for him, it came as no surprise that he drifted from 7-2 to 5-1. 
 Yet his storming finish carried him into third place, a head and 1 &frac12; lengths behind two super-fit hurdlers, Cruising Altitude (rec 6lb) and Nomadic Way (rec 10lb). 
 As the winner of both his races this season, Cruising Altitude was fully entitled to start favourite at the weights and he set a course record beating the time of Run For Free in the opener who had himself just broken the previous record. 
 Cruising Altitude passed the pacemaking Floyd as they crossed the final hurdle and he looked all set for a comfortable victory. 
 Then Nomadic Way brought the stamina which enabled him to win the Cesarewitch two years ago into play and finishing well up that final testing hill, he failed by only a head to catch Cruising Altitude. 
 When they met at Newbury on November 25th, Nomadic Way finished 10 lengths behind his rival, and now, on only 1lb better, Nomadic Way improved about ten lengths. 
 No doubt he will make further progress but how either of them are going to hold Beech Road when they all meet at levels is answered by the new prices on the Champion. 
 Corals offered him at 5-1 but soon had to come down to join Ladbrokes at 4-1. 
 Both firms moved Kribensis out to 6-1 and Cruising Altitude to 8-1. 
 If all goes well, Beech Road will start at 2-1 or less at Cheltenham as there is no mistaking his superiority. 
 Morley Street, against weaker opposition, was even more impressive. 
 The winner of five of his six races as a novice last season and probably an unlucky loser of the other, where he made mistakes at two consecutive hurdles, Morley Street was ridden with considerable discretion by Jimmy Frost, who brought him on the scene with a double handful between the last two flights, jumping to the front at the last, which he hit quite hard. 
 He still managed to finish seven lengths ahead of Deep Sensation of whom much more will be heard. 
 By March, Morley Street will probably be good enough to win any normal champion hurdle, but Balding does not relish the idea of running two in the race. 
 His next race will be at Chepstow in two weeks time. 
 After that it will be decided whether or not he goes chasing in the New Year. 
 I understand he has already been schooled over fences with considerable success. 
 He is ideally bred for the job being by the champion sire, Deep Run, from a granddam, Matchboard, who won 11 chases and five point-to-points. 
 Morley Street cost the bargain price of 14,000gns as a yearling. 
 The A.F. Budge Gold Cup Handicap Chase, produced a field of six and unless it rains soon even that number will be welcomed by racecourses. 
 David Elsworth chose this race to give Barnbrook Again his preliminary for the King George VI and the topweight winner of all his four races last season was made the 2-1 favourite, though some optimistic betting forecasts had him as a ridulous 8-1 chance. 
 The ground and the weight seemed too much for him and he had retired from contention before the penultimate fence. 
 By this time Clever Folly had shaken off all opposition and proceeded to break the course record by 4.7 seconds in spite of 4lb overweight. 
 Welsh Oak stayed on to finish ten lengths second and there was another six lengths to Barnbrook Again. 
 David Elsworth seemed quite satisfied with the performance of Barnbrook Again, observing that he still had 17 days before the big race. 
 Martin Pipe's Rusch de Farges was never going well. 
 This is proving a vintage year for Cumbrian trainer, Gordon Richards, whose Clever Folly was winning for the fourth time. 
 Over in Ireland Jim Dreaper gave Carvill's Hill his seasonal debut in the Durkan Brothers International Punchestown Chase, where he was beaten three lengths by last season's Irish Grand National winner Maid Of Money, who was receiving 5lb and started favourite. 
 It was a two-horse race but there is no doubt Carvill's Hill's jumping has improved since last season when he won all the four races in which he finished. 
 He unseated his rider once and fell at the 7th in the Cheltenham Gold Cup. 
 Again Corals had to reduce their early odds of 6-1 on Carvill's Hill for the Gold Cup to 5-1. 
 This would be generous if the ground proved soft but as he will not run if it is firm, there is no point in betting before the day. 
 Maid Of Money, 12-1, will also go for the Gold Cup but they are likely to meet again in the Black and White Gold Cup at Leopardstown. 
 RICHARD BAERLEIN'S SELECTIONS: NAP: Woodchester Glen (12.45 Edinburgh). 
 NEXT BEST: Between The Sheets (3.30 Warwick). 
 AAA to see lawyers. 
 By John Rodda 
 AN accusation made yesterday that the British Amateur Athletic Board was manipulated into bankruptcy, is to be examined by the solicitors of the Amateur Athletic Association. 
 The charges were made by Derek Johnson of Southern Counties, a silver medal winner at the Olympic Games in 1956, who told the board's annual meeting that he wanted to correct the record on how the board came to be wound up in 1987 and its financial affairs taken over by the AAA. 
 Johnson wanted to read papers relating to sponsorship and televised meetings. 
 But the chairman, Ewan Murray, said that he could not do so without permission from the AAA. 
 Johnson told the meeting that the board was &bquo;bullied out of &pound;300,000. 
 It is important for history to show that despite what happened the board was responsible in its conduct and its financial affairs&equo;. 
 Sir Arthur Gold, the former president of the European Athletic Association, a life vice-president of the board and now chairman of the British Olympic Association and supported Johnson, saying there had been &bquo;wicked distortions&equo;. 
 The board confirmed that Les Jones, is to continue as Britain's team manager until the 1992 Olympic Games with Joan Allison leading the women's team. 
 Matthew Belsham, of Sale Harriers has been added to England's Commonwealth Games team, in the pole vault, taking the place of Michael Edwards, who was withdrawn on grounds of misconduct. 
 Romania lock asks to stay. 
 By Donald Stewart 
 CHRISTIAN Raducanu, the 22-year-old Romanian lock, disappeared from the party after his team's 32-0 defeat by Scotland at Murrayfield on Saturday. 
 He arrived at Edinburgh's Blair Street station early yesterday and told police he wanted to stay in Britain. 
 Raducanu attended the official dinner that followed the international but then left his team-mates. 
 He was not in the aeroplane when the Romanian players and officials went home from Heathrow yesterday. 
 Several Scottish players said that there had been talk at the dinner about the possibility of one of the Romanians hoping to stay in Scotland. 
 &bquo;It is not a police matter but an immigration matter, and he is being interviewed,&equo; a Home Office spokesman said. 
 &bquo;He told police he wanted to extend his stay. 
 We do not know yet whether he wants to extend his visit for a short time to see friends, or become a student, or stay permanently.&equo; 
 Two members of Wales's championship side last season, the Bridgend prop, Mike Griffiths, and the Newbridge outside-half and captain, Paul Turner, are being linked with Cardiff and Newport respectively, writes David Plummer. 
 Griffiths, who has not played for a month because of a rib injury, watched Cardiff overwhelm London Welsh on Saturday and is expected to train with the club next week. 
 He was linked with Cardiff in the summer when he decided to stay at the Brewery Field. 
 Turner may have finally made up his mind to move after being dropped from the Newbridge side which travelled to Swansea on Saturday after Newport announced he was on his way to Rodney Parade. 
 He is expected to transfer by tomorrow. 
 Turner has been offered employment by the company of Newport's new coach, Gareth Evans, at a better salary than he currently enjoys. 
 And he is no stranger to Rodney Parade, having spent a couple of seasons there from 1985, moving from Newbridge, before flirting briefly with London Welsh. 
 His impending move brings the punitive changes to the amateur regulations into a sharp focus. 
 In the past, reasons for changing clubs have been couched in euphemistic terms, such as the need for a fresh challenge. 
 Now, it is a players' market. 
 The North expect to have Peter Winterbottom back for next Saturday's Divisional Championship decider against London at Otley. 
 The England flanker showed he has recovered from a rib cartilage injury by playing in Harlequins' 57-10 victory over Bedford. 
 The Midlands will make one change against the South-West at Bath, recalling the England hooker Brian Moore, who has twice withdrawn from the side late on with a twisted knee. 
 Athletics: Morrell dispels fitness doubts. 
 By Sandy Sutherland 
 THERE was a resounding message sent to Steve Cram, the man England have left out of the Commonwealth Games team, from the Scottish Indoor Championships yesterday. 
 It came from Tony Morrell, the Hartlepool-based athlete who has been preferred to Cram in the 1500 metres and whose fitness had been queried in some quarters. 
 Morrell won the 1500 metres at the Kelvin Hall with an impressive display of strength in 3min 44.09sec, then declared: &bquo;It was an easy run &mdash; I came prepared to run 3min 40sec and that should show people whether there's anything wrong with my calf.&equo; 
 Morrell's race plan was upset when Gerry McCann, from the local Glasgow University club, set off at a suicidal pace. 
 He was eventually caught with three laps left and as the pack came past him he unfortunately caught the heels of another member of England's Commonwealth Games team, Ikem Billy, who dropped out. 
 Morrell went on for a comfortable victory over three seconds clear of the defending champion, Mark Kirk, of Ballymena. 
 A trio of English runners featured in the women's 1500 metres where the two 800 metres runners got the better of the specialist at the distance, Christina Cahill. 
 Diane Edwards made a long run for home to defeat Ann Williams in a modest 4min 19.46sec with Cahill just unable to get back on terms. 
 There was nothing modest about the manner of Linford Christie's 60 metres victory. 
 The Seoul 100 metres silver medallist, who had won the 200 metres unpressed in 21.30sec on Saturday, had more formidable opposition in the 60 metres from Michael Rosswess. 
 The 24-year-old Birchfield Harrier failed to win selection for Auckland and has turned his attention instead to the European Indoor Championships to be held in Glasgow in early March. 
 Christie, too, wants to run in the European, preferably in both sprints and not just the 60 metres for which he has been pre-selected. 
 Christie was away smoothly out of his blocks and never looked like being caught, though the bustling Rosswess pulled clear of the remainder of the field, including the two Scottish Commonwealth Games representatives, Jamie Henderson, who was third, and Elliot Bunney. 
 Christie's time was a championship record of 6.64sec. 
 Mark Breland took less than four rounds to come through the third defence of his WBC welterweight title yesterday in Tokyo, opening up a bad cut above the right eye of his Japanese challenger, Fujio Ozaki. 
 Lachie Deuchar, the world Real Tennis No.2, won the French Open Championship at Bordeaux yesterday, but was kept on court for 3 &verbar;C hours by an amateur, James Male, the world rackets champion. 
 Deuchar won the final 3-6, 6-2, 6-5, 4-6, 6-5. 
 The European champion, John Whitaker, won the &pound;15,000 Frankfurt Grand Prix on Next Milton yesterday, improving his chances of taking the Renault series which conludes at Grenoble next Sunday. 
 Peter Senior took his third Australian title in four weeks yesterday, collecting his biggest purse in the process, by winning the Australian Classic in Melbourne. 
 The Queenslander won by five shots from the world No.1 Greg Norman, who finished on seven under par, with Britain's Howard Clark one stroke further back in third. 
 David Frost of South Africa took the sport's richest prize when he took the &dollar;1 million winner's cheque in the Sun City Challenge. 
 Whitley Bay 2, Preston 0 Draw dampens Bay's party. 
 By David Hopps 
 FOR Whitley Bay, the hangover arrived several hours too soon. 
 A night of beer-swilling revelry was abruptly deflated at 11.30pm when someone switched on the television for the draw for the FA Cup third round. 
 The proudest moment in Whitley Bay's history, the conquering of Preston North End, twice Cup winners, had been loudly celebrated. 
 But the sober, clipped tones of the FA representatives told that the party was over: the reward, if reward it could be called, was an away tie at Rochdale. 
 Away at Rochdale. 
 Enough to make the room swim, send the beer flat and the chicken legs glutinous. 
 If the adventure had to end, no one among the HFS Loans League side dared to imagine that it might end in less than a month's time in front of a few thousand at Spotland. 
 How Preston had been sent packing. 
 They were brought up on Deepdale plastic, gleaming under powerful floodlights. 
 In the murky shadows of Hillheads, on a yielding surface which Whitley diehards reckoned was more clarty than claggy, their appetite for a fight soon deserted them. 
 A crowd of 4,500, packed into the tiny ground just behind the ice rink, roared its approval at every stout tackle, every lung-bursting sprint. 
 Preston's preference for two wingers allowed Bay to clamp the midfield, and they soon set in motion a stream of direct attacks of surprising accuracy. 
 The goals were roughly hewn. 
 The central defender Peter Robinson, a student teacher, struck the first from 10 yards in the 33rd minute after Lawrie Pearson's low shot had scudded against the heels of another Bay player, Kevin Todd. 
 Todd's follow-up on the hour, from similar range, arose from Pearson's cleverly squirted pass, but only after Atkins, swinging wildly, had made a hash of his clearance as Dawson's barnstorming run down the right seemed sure to be betrayed by a poorly-struck cross. 
 Whitley's goalkeeper Brian Dickson, a chef for a hospital catering company, bubbled away underneath the flat, old-fashioned crossbars. 
 He only regained his place when Tony Harrison broke an arm in the second qualifying round, but his two saves around the half-hour, first scrambling Hughes's shot around the post, then pawing away Joyce's looping header, left Preston's brightest period unrewarded. 
 There was so much to savour, much of it blissfully recalled in an hilarious after-match comedy entitled, I'm Sorry We've Left The Tannoy On. 
 As spectatators streamed from the ground, the public address crackled out its satisfied message: Whitley Bay had stuffed &bquo;em, good and proper. 
 So they had. 
 SCORERS: Whitley Bay: Robinson (33min), Todd (60). 
 Whitley Bay: Dickson; Liddle, Teasdale, Robinson, Gowens, Johnson, Walker, Dawson, Chandler (Gamble, 80), Todd, Pearson. 
 Preston North End: Kelly; Williams, Swann, Atkins, Joyce, Hughes, Mooney (Flynn, 67), Ellis, Bogie, Patterson, Harper. 
 Referee: W Burn (Scarborough).. 
 The League's bottom club Hartlepool have named Cyril Knowles as manager in succession to Bobby Moncur, who resigned a fortnight ago. 
 Southampton 2, Manchester City 1 City ripe for Kendall salvation if Swales gives him the time. 
 By Martin Thorpe 
 MANCHESTER United get through money; City get through managers. 
 Nobody gets success. 
 Today Maine Road welcomes its tenth manager in 16 years. 
 Step forward, Howard Kendall. 
 The former Everton manager is swapping a reign in Spain for the pain of a reign at Maine. 
 Time will tell which ended better. 
 Statistics show that bringing in a new manager tends not to be a pancea. 
 Last season there were 35 changes of manager in the League. 
 None of the clubs involved won promotion, and seven were relegated. 
 But it all depends on who your new manager is. 
 If the City chairman had sacked Mel Machin to bring in a John Bond or Malcolm Allison then heads really would have been shaking in wonderment at another Peter Swales masterstroke. 
 But in Kendall, City seem at last to have hired a manager with the credentials to match the club's aspirations. 
 Looking at City at Southampton on Saturday and thinking back to the Everton sides that twice won the championship, Kendall appears just the man to implant the discipline and experience needed around some otherwise exciting talent. 
 Already the former Everton manager is being linked with old colleagues such as Peter Reid, Adrian Heath and Kevin Sheedy, plus Mark Hughes and Scott Sellars. 
 Looking at City's first-half performance at The Dell, he must have wondered if any change was needed at all. 
 Though bottom of the First Division, City played intelligent, skilful soccer, full of simple passes, with players such as Bishop and Lake comfortable enough on the ball to create space, and a striker in Allen sharp enough to take the half-chance that put City deservedly ahead. 
 But City are prone to concede goals in the last quarter of an hour and bang on the 75th minute the impressive young Dodd fed a wonderful 30-yard pass to Rod Wallace, who held off two defenders to equalise. 
 It was a quality goal nearly upstaged five minutes later by a 25-yard screamer from the substitute Horne. 
 But the signs at City are encouraging. 
 Swales might, at last, have made a wise decision &mdash; if he does not go back on it at the first sign of failure. 
 SCORERS: Southampton: Wallace (75min), Horne (80). 
 Manchester City: Allen (11). 
 Southampton: Flowers; Dodd, Benali, Case, Ruddock, Osman, Le Tissier, Cockerill, Shearer (Moore, 73), Rideout (Horne, 73), Wallace. 
 Manchester City: Dibble; Seagraves, Hinchcliffe, Bishop, Hendry, Redmond, White, Morley, Allen, Oldfield (Ward, 87), Lake. 
 Referee: D Elleray (Harrow).. 
 Crowd crush renews fears. 
 ONLY a month before the publication of Lord Justice's Taylor's full report on football safety there were disturbing suggestions yesterday that some clubs have failed to implement interim recommendations made in the wake of the Hillsborough disaster, writes David Hopps. 
 A crowd crush at Ayresome Park on Saturday forced Middlesbrough's match with Leeds United to be suspended for 15 minutes, and so alarmed the Leeds manager, Howard Wilkinson, that he clambered on to the perimeter fencing to appeal for calm. 
 Yesterday, Bob Schofield, treasurer of the Leeds supporters club, alleged: &bquo;People were very disturbed. 
 There was no exit in the perimeter fence and the gates in the side fence were locked. 
 Anyone trying to climb the fence could have been impaled on spikes the size of joiner's nails. 
 Clubs are not acting upon the Taylor report.&equo; 
 Cleveland police will hold an inquiry. 
 Chief Supt Terry Tasker stressed there was no crowd fighting, adding: &bquo;Some Leeds supporters bought tickets for other parts of the ground and they were flushed out and taken to the enclosure set aside for them.&equo; 
 The capacity of the south-east corner is only 2,108 and such was the demand for tickets in Leeds that 8,000 fans watched the match on close-circuit TV at Elland Road. 
 The crush was eased by moving some fans to an empty, condemned section of the ground. 
 All five spectators taken to Middlesbrough General Hospital were released yesterday, one with a broken leg. 
 Ten had treatment on the side of the pitch. 
 Swindon Town 0, Sheffield United 2 United victory marred as Duffield breaks leg. 
 By Jeremy Alexander 
 SHEFFIELD UNITED, deposed on Saturday by Leeds, reclaimed the summit of the Second Division yesterday with their sixth away victory of the season and their second 2-0 defeat of Swindon. 
 Since their infatuation with Bolton in the Littlewoods Cup, Swindon, still lying ninth, have lost their way in the League with only two points from four games. 
 United made a marvellous start, scoring after six minutes, but the goal was costly as well as precious. 
 Bodin's pass back was under-hit, Duffield and Gittens seized on it and, while Gittins did what Duffield was intending, sliding the ball under the advancing Digby, Duffield stayed down and was carried off with a broken leg. 
 United looked like traffic controllers, directing the flow straight down the arterial routes towards Swindon's goal. 
 Before they scored, they carved a golden chance but Booker won no prize for his volley over the stand. 
 Swindon's approach was more along the byways, with frequent midfield pauses to check the map or signposts. 
 It was all in the darting style of their manager, Ossie Ardiles, without the penetrating vision. 
 After the interval, Swindon sharpened their wits and began to make the heart of United's defence look ponderous. 
 Shearer and White, each fed by Jones, were denied by Tracey's spread and agility but the traffic had turned about, although five minutes from time, Jones cracked another shot against the bar. 
 By then, though, in a rare escape from their own half, United had scored their second. 
 From a free-kick on the left, Gannon swung the ball deep and Morris, not as heavy as he had appeared from the previous half-hour, made the game safe with a soaring header. 
 Swindon: Digby; Kerslake (Cornwell, 60min), Bodin, McLoughlin, Calderwood, Gittens, Jones, Shearer, White, MacLaren, Foley. 
 Sheffield United: Tracey; Hill, Rostron, Booker (Lake, 87), Stancliffe, Morris, Bradshaw, Gannon, Duffield (Francis, 6), Deane, Bryson. 
 Referee: D Axcell (Southend). 
 Young McEnroe saves his best until last. 
 By Martin James 
 PATRICK McENROE not only revived an old family tradition at the Royal Albert Hall yesterday but also managed to give his watching parents a welcome 33rd wedding anniversary present when he added his name to the Nabisco Masters doubles trophy. 
 Considering he was joining an honour roll that included his big brother John, it was somehow fitting that Patrick played the leading role in the two-hour 48-minute finale to the grand prix circuit which saw the younger McEnroe and Jim Grabb dismiss the more experienced Anders Jarryd and John Fitzgerald 7-5, 7-6, 5-7, 6-3. 
 Throughout the week, McEnroe MkII was impressive in everything he tried. 
 Even his serve, which he does not really rate as a weapon, could hardly have been faulted. 
 Going into the final he had surrendered it just once. 
 It appeared just as impregnable yesterday as he survived the first two sets without being broken. 
 Ironically, however, at 5-5 in the third set with the match almost in the Americans' grasp, he faltered, losing his delivery to 30. 
 Fitzgerald then served out for the set to turn the match into a real struggle, or so we thought, but Grabb and McEnroe stepped up a gear midway through the fourth set to take control. 
 It made Patrick cringe of course, but the inevitable comparison with his brother was high on the agenda when, clutching his share of the &pound;45,000 winners' cheque and &pound;15,000 for finishing eighth in the Nabisco points table, he walked into the interview room. 
 Fitzgerald, who lost his rag with John McEnroe at Wimbledon, had already offered his view of the pair. 
 &bquo;They're like chalk and cheese. 
 He's a very very pleasant young fella. 
 You have got to give him credit. 
 It is very difficult to play under the shadow of an older brother who's had so much success. 
 But he's developed his game over the last couple of years very well. 
 Now he's a very accomplished player,&equo; the Australian Davis Cup stalwart said. 
 &bquo;I am obviously very pleased about winning but it was also great that my parents were here. 
 It was a special week for all of us,&equo; said Patrick, who was only 11 when brother John won the first of seven successive Masters doubles titles in 1978 with Peter Fleming. 
 Victory would have secured Jarryd his place at the top of the points table, a feat worth &pound;110,000. 
 Instead, he came second and had to make do with &pound;80,000. 
 The final yesterday was the last under the auspices of the Men's Tennis Council, which had controlled the Grand Prix circuit since 1970. 
 Next year the Association of Tennis Professionals takes command. 
 Imran joins the 350 club. 
 IMRAN KHAN became the fifth player in Test history to take 350 wickets &mdash; joining Richard Hadlee, Ian Botham, Dennis Lillee and Kapil Dev &mdash; when he held on to a fine one-handed return catch to dismiss Ravi Shastri yesterday as India lost their last seven wickets for 143 on the second day of the fourth and final Test in Sialkot. 
 In a day that saw 100 minutes of playing time lost, first to crowd trouble and then to the weather, Wasim Akram finished with five for 101 after the tourists had gone from 181 for three overnight to 324 all out. 
 Play was briefly suspended at the start of the Pakistan innings when Sachin Tendulkar, fielding on the boundary, was pelted with fruit by the crowd. 
 A public appeal restored calm, and the home side were 23 for one when bad light and more rain drove the players off an hour early. 
 In Brisbane, Sri Lanka ground out their highest score in the three Tests they have played against Australia, adding 194 in six hours yesterday to end the third day of the first Test on 275 for six. 
 Aravinda de Silva anchored the tourists with an unbeaten 75, but their progress in reply to Australia's first innings of 367 was painfully slow on a hot day, with the first session yielding only 50 runs. 
 Richard Edmunds, the 19-year-old Leicestershire left-arm pace bowler who suffered severe chest injuries in a car crash last month, has died in hospital. 
 He made his first-class debut for his county last season and played for Young England. 
 Thatcher erect new barrier to monetary unity. 
 By Larry Elliott Economics Correspondent 
 THE chances of British entry into the exchange rate mechanism of the European Monetary System before the next election were significantly reduced at the Strasbourg summit, as the Prime Minister maintained her hard-line opposition. 
 Despite the pressure which has been building up on the government in recent months, including growing dissent within her own party, she reiterated her old misgivings about the monetary system and added a new one for good measure. 
 Speaking at the end of the two days of talks, Mrs Thatcher said it had helped some countries combat inflation. 
 But she doubted whether it would work as well once the system, dominated by West Germany, was diluted by other countries less committed to the policy of bearing down on prices. 
 Its success had been that both the people of West Germany and its central bank, the Bundesbank, had a deep-seated fear of inflation. 
 They had known the effects of hyper-inflation and &bquo;were more fearful of it than anything else&equo;. 
 There was a danger that the anti-inflation tendencies of the Bundesbank would be watered down by other European countries where control of prices was less of a priority. 
 &bquo;The moment you go from the rigid and valuable discipline of German bank and people to mixing it up with other disciplines, other views, other &bquo;let's have a bit of inflation here and there&equo; economies, you lose the very thing which leads you to want to join.&equo; 
 Observers saw Mrs Thatcher's comments as little more than the latest in a series of delaying tactics. 
 They pointed out that economies prepared to allow &bquo;a bit of inflation here and there&equo; would include Britain, where the inflation rate is already one of the highest in the European Community and set to rise from 7.3 per cent to around 8 per cent later this week. 
 Indeed, the other EC countries put little pressure on the British delegation to speed up the ERM process, concluding that the time for concessions to Mrs Thatcher's doubts was now over. 
 Solicitors' firms are caught out by the housing market collapse. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 SIGNS are beginning to emerge that the survival of some firms of solicitors is being threatened by the collapse of the housing market. 
 Many law firms have already laid off employees: a large Midlands firm has got rid of 35; a firm in East Anglia is about to shed some conveyancing staff; and the Law Society's Young Solicitors Group has set up a helpline to provide counselling and advice for young lawyers who have been made redundant. 
 One medium-sized firm of solicitors in East Anglia has written to its staff asking them to forgo their pay for December. 
 The firm says it simply cannot find the cash to meet its wage bill. 
 East Anglia has been particularly affected by the fall in the property market. 
 House prices there boomed in 1987 and the first-half of 1988 and have since fallen more sharply than in most other areas. 
 The Law Society says it is not aware of any firms, so far, which have gone under because of the property slump. 
 Recent figures for conveyancing are not available. 
 In 1986, about 1.78million properties worth &pound;73billion changed hands. 
 In 1987, there were 1.96 million conveyances worth &pound;103 billion. 
 Estimates suggest that since then, the number of house sales has fallen by about 40 per cent. 
 For a small firm of solicitors in a market town, conveyancing has accounted for about half of all fee income. 
 So the recent fall in house-moving business would have cut gross income by about a fifth and net income by much more. 
 The housing slump has also had a major impact on removal firms. 
 The British Association of Removers, which represents 750 removal companies across the country, believes housemoving business is down about 40 per cent. 
 &bquo;There is a temporary blip in the market because some people are trying to press ahead with their moves before Christmas,&equo; said Mr Eric Bourne of the BAR. 
 &bquo;But generally speaking, it has been difficult since September 1988. 
 &bquo;Some firms have reduced their staffing levels substantially, but people in the industry are generally trying to hold on to experienced staff.&equo; 
 Some one-person removal firms have disappeared, said Mr Bourne. 
 &bquo;But within our association there has been no noticable number of bankruptcies. 
 &bquo;It has gone on for 15 months and so far most firms have managed to survive, but they can't go on like this for ever.&equo; 
 Determined to write herself out of her poverty, Buchi Emecheta launched herself on the book world with an autobiographical account of life in London for a young Nigerian single parent. 
 Now, however, she's writing for her soul. 
 Drawing on life PAGE wom 
 A dead-eyed kick Bookshop. 
 By Stephanie Nettell 
 ROGER MILLS's Bad Fun (Lions Tracks, &pound;2.50) takes a bitter look at the aftermath of a left-wing demonstration in which a teenager is killed. 
 What his mate, who has never bothered much with politics, discovers about our police on the one hand and lawyers on the other, forces him to take over the activist role in this tough political thriller. 
 I'd Rather Be Famous, by Pete Johnson (Methuen, &pound;4.95) might seem like candy-floss in comparison but this book is sardonic in its view of romance and the dreams of telly fame that follow an appearance in a Blind Date type of show. 
 But Mick Gowar's funny, touching poems So Far So Good (Penguin Plus, &pound;1.99), about school and work, families and first love, get right to the real heart of a teenager's life. 
 Brilliant. 
 Young Guardian is edited by Melanie McFadyean 
 Allay it with Flowers Critics' choice Visual art.. 
 By Mary Clarke 
 ANGELA FLOWERS is celebrating her gallery's 25th birthday and her Print Show 1989, at the new premises in Hackney, is a genial round-up of her artists and &mdash; a festive hint for the harried &mdash; a good place to buy Christmas presents. 
 From a very large number of works, I recommend prints by Basil Beattie, Prunella Clough, Terry Frost, Patrick Hughes, Trevor Jones, Jane Joseph, John Loker, Bruce McLean, June Redfern and Michael Rothenstein. 
 The other interesting mixed show this week is the Bluecoat Christmas Annual, in which one may sense the up-and-coming nature of work in all media by Liverpool artists. 
 Look out for Phyllis Mahon, Clem McAleer, Richard Roberts and Gary Perkins. 
 This has been the year of Russian exhibitions, generally better the older the art. 
 We may weary of them soon, so finish 1989 with visits to the excellent survey of Aleksandr Rodchenko and Varvara Stepanova at the Serpentine Gallery and Transformation &mdash; The Legacy Of Authority at the Cleveland Gallery in Middlesbrough, which has a broad range of contemporary Soviet painters, from the socialist realist Nandalbayan to the Western-influenced would-be American superstar Sergei Shutov. 
 At the Ikon Gallery in Birmingham are plotted-out paintings by Pam Skelton and exuberant, over-the-top sculptures and drawings by Simon Moller. 
 Could each learn from the other? 
 We're supposed to learn a lot from Folly And Vice, which opens on Saturday at the Bolton Museum. 
 This South Bank touring show surveys the field of satire and social criticism from Hogarth to Grosz, in 135 prints and drawings. 
 I don't like artists who think they can scold the rest of the world, but this show will certainly include historic material. 
 In London, Silvia Ziranek has an installation of her zany feminist sculptures at the Watermans Arts Centre. 
 Karsten Schubert shows an interesting collection &mdash; with mega-interesting prices &mdash; of rare catalogues and books by artists of the last 20 years 
 Dance. 
 By Mary Clarke 
 SADLER'S WELLS Royal Ballet open their Christmas season at the Wells next Tuesday with a programme of ballets by Kenneth MacMillan which continue the celebrations of his 60th birthday. 
 The first programme consists of his first commissioned ballet, Danses Concertantes, the early whimsical Solitaire, and the powerful Las Hermanas made originally for the Stuttgart Ballet in 1963, remounted for SWRB in 1976 and not seen at the Wells since 1984. 
 Marion Tait and Joseph Cipolla dance the leading roles. 
 At Covent Garden, the Royal Ballet gives five more performances of The Prince Of The Pagodas &mdash; tonight, tomorrow and Friday and then next Tuesday and Wednesday. 
 Tonight a second cast will take over with Viviana Durante, Michael Cassidy and Deborah Bull in the three principal roles. 
 Tonight until December 16 The Scottish Ballet will be dancing the popular Peter Pan &mdash; The Ballet (with pretty flying effects) at the Theatre Royal, Glasgow. 
 Box office 041 331 1234. 
 Folly And Vice&hellip; 1796 etching by Richard Newton; satirical South Bank touring show; Bolton Museum: see Critics' choice Home bleak home&hellip; 
 Silvia Ziranek with feminist sculpture; Watermans Art Centre: see Critics' choice Marion Tait; Sadler's Wells Royal Ballet; Critics' choice Joseph Cipolla; Sadler's Wells Royal Ballet: Critics' choice A scene from Solitaire; Royal Opera House: Critics' choice 
 What's going on. 
 By Stephanie Nettell 
 FAST-MOVING comic-strip spoof on US life and politics, Phoenix Beam's cult American Eagle lands at Willesden Green Library Centre, 95 High Road, London NW10 (tel: 01 451 0294), December 15-16, before zooming off to the Lyric Theatre, Hammersmith (01 641 2311), with open workshops and signed performances for the deaf, Dec 19-Jan 13. 
 THE Witch And The Magic Mountain is a new musical play based on folk legends from around the world, performed by the Oxford Stage Company at the Arts Centre, University of Warwick (0203 417417), until Dec 16, then Dec 26-Jan 13 before national tour (details: 0865 723238). 
 THE 18-month-old Young Vic Youth Theatre has fought back from the threat of funds-starved closure to launch new season with Brecht and Weill's The Threepenny Opera. 
 Dec 21-Jan 13, 7.30pm, The Studio, 66 The Cut, London SE1 (01 928 6363). 
 THE Cannon Hill Puppet Theatre will use, for the first time in Britain, puppets hand-crafted in the Japanese style Bunraku, to present Andersen's The Snow Queen at the Midlands Arts Centre, Cannon Hill Park, Birmingham (021 440 3838), until Jan 3. 
 CAPTAIN Stirrick is at the Lilian Baylis Theatre, Sadler's Wells, London, until Jan 6. 
 The Captain's band of child criminals invite you to mingle with the 1807 action in Bartholomew Fair, Smithfield (box office: 01 278 6563). 
 THE Tricycle Youth Theatre puts a different slant on Christmas shows with The Cobweb, &bquo;a journey into the hidden underbelly of the human psyche&equo;: 269 Kilburn High Road, London NW6 (01 328 1000), Dec 20-22, 8pm. 
 SHOULD young people speak out more for their rights? 
 On January 9 the Children's Legal Centre is holding a Young People's Congress for different interest groups (Young Guardian will be covering the event). 
 Two groups are still undersubscribed. 
 If you are trans-racially fostered or adopted, or feel the legal system mistreated you when your parents separated, phone 01 359 9392. 
 Or write to: Children's Legal Centre, 20 Compton Terrace, London N12 UN. 
 TWO DAYS left for Radio 1's Information Campaign on Housing and Leaving Home. 
 Free confidential helpline 8am-10pm: 0800 500 800. 
 Free booklet from Home And Dry, Radio 1, London W1A 4WW. 
 Obituary: Madalena Perdigao. 
 Promoting the arts:. 
 MADALENA Perdigao, a respected figure in the Portuguese art world and an administrator of the Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation, has died aged 66. 
 Mrs Perdigao was born in northern Portugal. 
 She graduated in mathematics from Coimbra University with distinction in 1944, but opted for a musical career. 
 However, her future as a concert pianist was forestalled by an injury to her left hand and she then began her life's work of promoting musical appreciation. 
 In 1958 she was invited to work for the Gulbenkian Foundation where, as Director of Music she initiated an ambitious programme of activities, including the formation of the Gulbenkian orchestra, choir and ballet company. 
 At a time when Portugal was still living under a dictatorship in which homespun nationalist values were lauded, she was criticised for lavishing large budgets on a series of international music festivals. 
 She introduced the Portuguese public to figures such as Rostropovich and Penderecki and supported projects such as Peter Brook's international centre for theatre studies. 
 After the 1974 revolution the polemic about her musical activities continued. 
 This was a tumultuous time, when many public figures came under political scrutiny. 
 But, although the situation may have been exploited by the Communist party, it was a purely cultural debate in which her defenders claimed, with justification, that her contribution to the promotion of music was inestimable. 
 She had the majority support of her staff, but decided to leave, to ensure that the position of her husband Jose Azeredo Perdigao would not be jeopardised as the Foundation's director. 
 She returned after a ten year absence, this time as director of ACARTE, an arts education programme linked to the Gulbenkian's Centre of Modern Art, consolidating the respect she held as one of Portugal's cultural leaders. 
 In 1987 President Mario Soares awarded her the Order of the Sword of Santiago. 
 In 1988 she was involved in another controversy, in a row over nomination for Portugal's candidate as &bquo;European Woman of the Year&equo;, a prize sponsored by the EC. 
 The presiding jury claimed they had not chosen her, as she alleged, but Elina Guimaraes, an 84-year-old former suffragette. 
 As the picture shows, Mrs Perdigao (right, with the wife of President Mario Soares, left, at the prize-winning ceremony) took the view that turning up is the key to victory. 
 On hearing of her death, Prime Minister Cavaco Silva described her as a person &bquo;of exceptional quality who contributed with vigour and impartiality to the appreciation of culture in Portugal and the presentation of Portuguese culture abroad.&equo; 
 Jill Jolliffe Madalena Azerado Perdigao, born Figueira da Foz, April 28, 1923; died Lisbon, December 5, 1989. 
 Melanie McFadyean on a Lloyds Bank/Young Guardian fashion winner Divine little number, possum!. 
 THE LLOYDS Bank Fashion Challenge invited young people to design outfits for celebrities to wear to the shops, a nightclub or a visit to their bank manager. 
 About 500 schools sent in entries from people aged 14-18. 
 Competitors designed clobber for Di to wear to a nightclub, Joan Collins for a shopping spree and Kylie Minogue to see her bank manager. 
 One of the winners is 16-year-old Sally Peattie, who took the Young Guardian prize, part of the Lloyds competition. 
 Her entry was for a suit for Dame Edna Everidge to wear to visit her bank manager. 
 Dame Edna would probably think it a caring, sharing sort of suit, and would doubtless lob a backhanded compliment Sally's way, possums. 
 Sally explains: &bquo;I designed a cropped pin-stripe jacket which I thought I would sequin but it was too heavy, so I have put bright, luminous shiny pink and purple braiding on to a man's pin-stripe suit material. 
 It has large capels with a pound sign on one and a dollar sign on the other. 
 I should write to Barry Humphries and explain that the reason I chose him was because I find his style of dressing very amusing and loud, different from everything else.&equo; 
 Sally wins trips to Paris and London to see the fashion shows, and &pound;500. 
 &bquo;I suppose I'll spend the &pound;500 on having a nice time in Paris. 
 I've never had that much before. 
 I don't get pocket money, my parents just get me things I need. 
 I work at a hardware store on Saturdays and save the money. 
 &bquo;I'm hoping to do textile design at art college and fashion design when I leave.&equo; 
 Sally didn't choose to dress Princess Diana for a disco because she thinks Diana is &bquo;a bit boring really&equo;. 
 Nor did she choose Kylie Minogue, because her clothes are also &bquo;a bit boring&equo;. 
 Sally is into high street leisure wear and casual daytime things rather than glitzy disco gear. 
 Edna is hardly your obvious casual daytime high street dresser, lounging around in jeans or velour tracksuits though, is she? 
 &bquo;I chose Dame Edna, because she takes the mickey out of fashion. 
 I thought it would be fun to do it, she's a man but her own person and very outrageous.&equo; 
 But Sally's aim in life isn't to design outrageous clothes for outrageous people. 
 &bquo;I'm very tall and have trouble finding clothes. 
 I'd like to design clothes for people who aren't &bquo;perfect&equo; &mdash; tall people, short people, fat and thin people. 
 You dress to impress, the clothes you wear say a lot for you.&equo; 
 Yet Sally's no slave to fashion: &bquo;I think fashion should be fun and you should wear what you feel comfortable in, not what people say you should wear. 
 You've got to have a price range the public can buy. 
 It's no good designing wonderful outfits only certain people can afford. 
 I'm interested in normal high street clothing which is fun and not expensive.&equo; 
 Sally is studying for Art A-level and doing computer courses to take her into the high tech world of 1990s textile design. 
 But for today she is &bquo;over the moon&equo; about her prize. 
 Winning entries will go on display in the Lloyds Bank Fashion Challenge Regional Roadshow early in the New Year. 
 Angel Mae, The Big Concrete Lorry by Shirley Hughes (Walker, &pound;5.95) The question is &mdash; can Shirley Hughes do no wrong? 
 Turning her attentions to a community, Trotter Street, her two new books are about the arrival of a real baby around the time of the Street's nativity play and the building of an extension on to the house of the boisterous Pattersons. 
 Hughes' cityscape is as exciting for the children in her books as the bluebell woods and dingle dells of 50 years ago, and this optimism may be the greatest gift a modern writer can give young readers. 
 Critics of the Hughes style fulminate against an imagined cosiness, a certainty about the nuclear family, the facility with which tenderness always binds childish wounds. 
 But attempts at social engineering usually lead to downfall. 
 The Hughes oeuvre, now increased by the invention of a new community, avoids that ghastly trap; her literary and illustrated world is one that children love. 
 Top three 
 Are You My Mother? by PDEastman 
 The Complete Grimms Fairy Tales (Routledge Kegan Paul) 
 The Mouse And His Cold by Russell Hoban LINDSAY MACKIE (mother of Isabella, 6, and Lizzy, 3) PAGE wom 
 Deaths: William Pedley: 80, formerly Regional Controller of the Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries, put agricultural workers in his debt through his research into their working conditions, carried out under the supervision of Dr C.S.Orwin and published under the title of Labour on the Land (1942). 
 The book was influential in the abolition of the tied cottage in the years following the war. 
 He was educated at New College, Oxford, as one of a small band of mature students sponsored in 1937 by the Oxford Delegacy for Extra-mural Studies, got a soccer Blue, and became a lifelong worker for the WEA. 
 Lindsay Crosby: 51, youngest son of the singer Bing Crosby, found dead in his Los Angeles home after apparently shooting himself in the head with a smallbore rifle. 
 With his brothers Gary, Phil and Dennis, he was once part of a fresh-faced showbusiness act, the Crosby Boys, which lasted until 1959. 
 Young Vic.. 
 By Frank Barker Michael Davis/Nelson Harper. 
 SATURDAY'S first pantomime was entitled Nightmare On The Northern Line and came courtesy of London Transport. 
 It featured a cast of hundreds in just one train carriage. 
 Not forgetting the tree which one crazed Christmas shopper had hauled aboard. 
 Anyway, we punters deserved our money back. 
 I was not, then, full of the joys of Christmas when, crushed, creased and cross, I bailed out at Waterloo. 
 I'd missed the World Cup draw on TV to boot. 
 All that said, A Christmas Carol was worth it. 
 Dickens' timeless story, now coming up to its 146th Christmas, has been adapted with affection by David Holman and directed with dash by Gwenda Hughes. 
 It has verve and vitality. 
 The star of the show, of course, was Ebenezer Scrooge, the greedy, grasping grouch with a heart as hard as left-over Christmas pud. 
 Colin Farrell's lovely performance had humour-inevitably the kids loved his &bquo;Humbugs!&equo; -and not a little pathos as the old skinflint was made to see the error of his ways. 
 In this, of course, he was helped by Jacob Marley, his dead partner doomed to roam through eternity in chains. 
 A rattling good performance this from Will Tacey. 
 The entire cast were delightful but a special mention for Mark Jax as the faithful Bob Cratchit and Glen Kinch as the cheery cockney Tupper. 
 Two hours flew by before Justin Feltham's Tiny Tim brought down the curtain with his &bquo;and God bless us, every one.&equo; 
 Then we were off home-by taxi. 
 At the Young Vic, The Cut, London SE1 until January 6. 
 Box office: 01-928-6363. 
 Wigmore Hall Michael Davis/Nelson Harper. 
 By Frank Barker 
 THE audience that turned up for the recital of British violin sonatas was scarcely more than a sprinkling, which made one despair of our unadventurous public. 
 Only the Franck and Kreutzer sonatas, it seems, can guarantee a reasonable house in our capital city with all its colleges of music; Walton and John Ireland, even played by such distinguished advocates as violinist Michael Davis and pianist Nelson Harper could draw no more than 40. 
 Happily, this band of devotees were generously rewarded with an evening of unusually imaginative and refined music-making. 
 Both players are individually most sensitive and accomplished, while as a duo they seem to play with single mind. 
 The warmth and elegance of Davis's style was made immediately apparent in the first movement of the Ireland Sonata No. 1, with its engagingly lyrical main tune which almost sits up and begs to be liked. 
 He coaxed it along with flawless control of line and colour as it was developed with equal measures of logic and charm. 
 With its equally seductive central Romance it is unaccountable that this sonata has not become as popular a success as the ubiquitous Franck. 
 Davis, a fastidious master, brought out all its natural sweetness without ever suggesting the saccharine or slipping into the over-sentimental. 
 Both players responded alertly to the capricious nature of the Wilfred Josephs Sonata No3, a work dedicated to them by the composer, displaying no lack of brilliance to meet its formidable technical demands. 
 Davis was admirable, too, in his interpretation of Walton's wayward Sonata, eloquent in its romantic melancholy and perticularly compelling in the variations movement with its difficult changes of mood. 
 He was convincing, too, in getting maximum mileage out of the ingenious variations on what seems at first a not very promising theme. 
 Bush Vark's First Day Out by Charles Fuge (MacMillan, &pound;6.95) Winner of The Mother Goose Award and the MacMillan Prize 1988 Three pairs of creaturely eyes stare out from the deep black inside covers of Bush Vark's First Day Out, whetting young appetites for nocturnal mystery and the pleasurable horrors encountered by Charles Fuge's cheery little vark, with his slippery passivity and plain good fortune. 
 Things just keep happening to him. 
 Trotting confidently out of his burrow into a jungly, prehistoric world, he is rescued by bats from slimy, groping creatures, only to fall into cavernous waters and swim out to sea, from where he is plucked by a vulture-like bird whose hungry chicks he has &bquo;fun&equo; avoiding before tumbling safely home. 
 The text seems dully at variance with the fantasy of the illustrations and falls between two stools. 
 Its undemanding vocabulary and flat rhythms seem suited to the very young, for whom it is unnecessarily long, yet a five year old, who would still delight in the pictures, would be disappointed by its lack of wit and thin story. 
 Top three 
 Goodnight Moon by Margaret Wise Brown and Clement Hurd 
 The Monster Bed by Jeannie Willis and Susan Varley 
 Dangerous Journey: The Story of Pilgrim's Progress arranged by Oliver Hunkin and Yorkshire Television ANTONIA AMIS (mother of Louis, 5, and Jacob, 3 &frac12;) PAGE wom 
 A Piece of Cake by Jill Murphy (Walker Books, &pound;6.95) This is currently my four-year- old son Leo's favourite book, having overtaken Jill Murphy's two other illustrated books about the everyday life of the elephant family Large. 
 In A Piece of Cake Mrs Large, the hard-pressed mother, has decided to get the family slim and trim. 
 &bquo;From now on, it's healthy eating,&equo; she announces to her underwhelmed offspring and insists that they and their father go jogging and serves up watercress soup for tea. 
 &bquo;Perhaps elephants are meant to be fat,&equo; says her son Luke plaintively. 
 Leo and I sympathise. 
 Our responses to Five Minutes' Peace are more at odds. 
 Mrs Large's escape to the bathroom for &bquo;five minutes&equo; peace from you lot&equo; is sabotaged by her children who gang up to disturb her. 
 I asked Leo if I could have five minutes' peace. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he said, &bquo;because you're not an elephant.&equo; 
 All In One Piece finds Mrs Large in another situation which is not entirely unfamiliar as she tries to get ready to go to Mr Large's office dinner and dance. 
 &bquo;Can't I have just one night in the whole year to myself? 
 One night when I am not covered in jam and poster-paint?&equo; she pleads. 
 Meanwhile her lads Lester and Luke are cramming her tights with toys and the baby is smearing lipstick all over himself. 
 He has, however, also latched on to granny elephant's words of approval to Mrs Large: &bquo;You look like a film star.&equo; 
 That was the compliment I got for putting on red nail varnish. 
 As these books are supposed to be read by adults to children, I don't think it matters that some of the jokes are probably lost on four year olds. 
 They are not lost on mothers. 
 Top three 
 Pinocchio by Carlo Collodi, illustrator Roberto Innocenti 
 The Nursery Peter Pan by JMBarrie 
 Lulu and the Flying Babies by Posy Simmonds MARY ROBSON (mother of Leo, 4) Matilda by Roald Dahl (Puffin, &pound;3.50; Cape, &pound;8.50) Winner of Children's Book Of The Year award 1989 There's no mystery why Roald Dahl is a best-selling children's author. 
 He ignores grown-ups. 
 He cuts out the middle men and women &mdash; the dreaded parents &mdash; and goes straight for the hearts and minds of kids. 
 To say that he doesn't patronise them is a laughable understatement. 
 More than any other modern author, you can actually imagine Roald Dahl reading his stuff to children, holding them enthralled at his feet. 
 Matilda is another winner because it is a perfect parable of Good versus Evil, of a brilliant child triumphing over the cowardly and perverse world of grown-ups. 
 In Dahl's universe, the adults are bent on creating hell on earth. 
 The adults who occupy Matilda's world do their best to destroy her. 
 With the exception of just one &mdash; her teacher, Miss Honey. 
 There's always one. 
 An angel there to prove that not everyone over the age of 12 is totally screwed up. 
 My son, Ben, says I must not forget the illustrations by Quentin Blake &mdash; writer and illustrator are here a perfect match. 
 Ben also confirmed the view expressed at the beginning of this piece when he said, quite unprompted, that Roald Dahl's stories, like no other writer's, spoke directly to him. 
 What more could a child ask for? 
 Top three 
 Where's Wally by Martin Handford 
 Tog The Ribber by Paul Coltman, illustrated by Gillian McClure 
 The BFG by Roald Dahl NIGEL WIGMORE (father of Ben, 8) Can't You Sleep, Little Bear? by Martin Waddell and Barbara Firth (Walker Books, &pound;6.95) Winner of the Kate Greenaway Medal A simple, poetic tale about fear of the dark, a subject that tends to hit the spot in even the toughest child. 
 Repetitive enough to appeal to Matthew, 4, who asked for it at bedtime four nights running, and with sophisticated touches appreciated by William, 6, normally a boy of the He Man persuasion. 
 Big Bear is reaching an interesting part in his book. 
 &bquo;Hey, that's good &mdash; he's reading the same book that we are,&equo; noticed Matthew. 
 Little Bear, who is supposed to be asleep, keeps interrupting him &mdash; he's scared of the dark and not even the biggest lantern from the cupboard can light up the night looming beyond the cave. 
 Finally Big Bear takes Little Bear out to show that the darkness isn't as black as it seems &mdash; and he falls asleep in it, in Big Bear's arms. 
 &bquo;It doesn't look very dark,&equo; said William. 
 &bquo;Only about seven o'clock.&equo; 
 Then Big Bear can read right to&hellip; 
 The End, and his book and ours finish together. 
 Top three 
 Charlie and the Chocolate Factory by Roald Dahl 
 The Amazing Adventures of Ulysses retold by Vivian Webb and Heather Amery 
 Where The Wild Things Are by Maurice Sendak MARKIE ROBSON-SCOTT (mother of William, 6, and Matthew, 4) PAGE wom 
 Once upon a time book-buying parents could rely on the classics to keep the kids quiet. 
 Now that there are hundreds of new children's titles published every year, it's increasingly difficult to tell the best from the rest. 
 There are 20-odd literary prizes for children's books, but is a gold medal stuck to the cover any more than a clever marketing ploy? 
 We asked a group of consumers &mdash; parents and their children &mdash; to assess 10 books chosen from both this year's prize-winning lists and the latest offerings from best-selling authors. 
 What they really want for Christmas PAGE wom 
 Journey's friends Television. 
 By Nancy Banks-Smith 
 AS THE bright, white, Scottish baronial of John o' Groats shone at the end of the road, Alan Holly (Joss Ackland) said, choking on a laugh or a sob or a pun, &bquo;There it is, the Holy City&equo;. 
 In Michael Frayn's First and Last (BBCI) Holly walked from Land's End shedding, without really intending to, the paraphernalia of life. 
 Friends, family, money, medicine. 
 For all that, you felt he was not alone. 
 There was a host of shadowy companions around him. 
 Everyman, who also undertook a long journey. 
 Xenophon's 10,000 men who, with the dust of a 1,000 mile march in their throats, shouted &bquo;The sea! 
 The sea!&equo; 
 Christian, who also sought the Holy City. 
 And everyone who ever lived and died. 
 As Holly, tired to death, stumbled along the last long stretch, a backpacked figure appeared in the distance which looked like his own image coming to meet him. 
 It was a much younger man taking the same journey in the opposite direction. 
 At John o' Groats there is a line across the road which says Finish. 
 On the other side it says Start. 
 Holly carries a great freight of metaphor in his rucksack. 
 Ray McAnally played him first. 
 Having got to Bristol, he went home for a short holiday and died. 
 This fine actor's last work will be pieced together for his family. 
 Joss Ackland took over the part of Holly, which is increasingly haunted by thoughts of mortality. 
 Ackland seems the sort of man who could hammer a nail in with his clenched teeth so he never begins to look like a tentative nonentity. 
 Of course, by the end of the road, he is not. 
 &bquo;This world of ours is full of strange and wonderful people with strange and wonderful things to tell you. 
 Take me&hellip;&equo; says a chap with a cap in Cornwall, the one whose pal had a foot off. 
 &bquo;Well, nice to talk,&equo; says Holly, legging it lithely away despite blisters. 
 Travellers hear such interesting tales, don't they? 
 Well, look at Chaucer. 
 But when you think about it, Holly hardly talks to anyone or, if he does, they do not answer. 
 A tramp of extravagant delapidation, who attaches himself like a dog, punctuates silences with spit then suddenly, on the crest of a belch, intones in an astonishingly cultivated voice, &bquo;Agnus Dei, qui tollis peccata mundi, miserere nobis&equo;. 
 He takes shelter at a Pennine farm where the man's daily conversational output is &bquo;Two more dead i&equo; beck&equo; and the woman listens to Holly's soliloquy like a raggedy Miranda, astonished as the sound of a human voice. 
 The last man Holly meets is dead. 
 When his wife (Pat Heywood) meets him at John o' Groats, they do not speak at all or, if they do, we cannot hear them as if they were already far away. 
 The cast was exceptionally fine. 
 All have done well and all shall have prizes. 
 I was particularly taken by Patricia Routledge, unmistakeable even looking through a letter box, and by Lionel Jeffries for his affecting rendition of: The troops are ready to mutiny, The colonel is missing or dead, When up steps a bold, young lieutenant And places himself at the head. 
 Did I forget to mention, by the way, that First and Last is funny? 
 The aggressive style of mainland cabaret comedy is only now reaching Northern Ireland. 
 Jay Rayner finds out why&hellip;. 
 Jokes on the firing line 
 DURING a gig in Coventry recently Irish comedian Sean Hughes was heckled. 
 Nothing unusual there; comedians are used to being shouted at by the audience. 
 It's part of the job. 
 What is unusual, in the defiantly liberal world of stand-up comedy, is that the heckler was attacking Hughes because he was Irish. 
 For his part the comedian says he understands why the man was so upset, though not his racism. 
 Hughes had reached the part of his act where he introduces the odd joke about the Sinn Fein, the political wing of the IRA. 
 At an Oscar type ceremony, an award winner decides to use his international platform for political purposes by asking a member of Sinn Fein to collect the award for him. 
 After a cursory &bquo;Ireland will be free,&equo; the politician then adds with glee &bquo;but what I really want to say is thank you mother, thank you father, thank you&hellip;&equo; and heads off into the normal &bquo;thank you auntie Doreen&equo; award winner's speech. 
 The heckler said his cousin had been killed by the IRA and that he hated all Irish. 
 It turned into a 15-minute rant. 
 &bquo;I was trying to tell him that there are only 300 members of the IRA but he wouldn't listen,&equo; says Hughes. 
 &bquo;But I think the audience were generally with me. 
 I finished my set on &bquo;Three members of the RUC were killed yesterday when their car crashed into a tree. 
 The IRA said they planted it&equo;. 
 And I got a massive round and an encore.&equo; 
 Hughes had been wounded on the cutting edge of stand-up comedy. 
 In recent years the defiantly right-on stance of the comedy circuit had been booted out by a brand of no-holds barred humour. 
 A few weeks, sometimes only a few days after a major disaster or tragedy &mdash; Hillsborough, Piper Alpha or Zeebrugge &mdash; there's bound to be a gag about it. 
 But Northern Ireland has remained untouched by all but a few Irish comedians. 
 Perhaps, it's the nature of the violence that puts people off. 
 The deaths in disasters like Hillsborough are certainly tragic but they also fall into the realms of normal human experience. 
 If you understand a death in a car crash &mdash; the product of accident and/or misadventure &mdash; you'll understand the concept of death in the sinking of a passenger ferry. 
 The sectarian violence of Northern Ireland is a different matter altogether. 
 It's dependent on the purposeful pulling of triggers and setting off of bombs. 
 It shouldn't happen. 
 Jokes about the subject suggest the punch-line might be followed by the odd shattered knee cap. 
 Northern Irish comedian Owen O'Neil has a simple maxim he includes in his act: &bquo;There's dangerous comedy, very dangerous comedy and jokes about the IRA.&equo; 
 But O'Neil's line is more for effect than to express any real fears. 
 Terrorist organisations are usually too busy with other things to go around killing comedians. 
 Instead of comedy, Northern Ireland has almost exclusively become the subject of thrillers, a background for cops and robbers style drama created in London. 
 Northern Irish film-maker and writer Niall Leonard, fed up with the humourless stereotyping of his birthplace, has tried to break away from that image. 
 &bquo;When I see things like the series Confessional on TV I feel like a black person must have felt watching the Black and White Minstrel show. 
 It's an insult to dramatists to portray terrorists as psychopaths. 
 Whether you agree or disagree with what they do, you have to accept that they've worked out a very complicated system of values. 
 There are tribal things going on there that you wouldn't know about unless you lived there.&equo; 
 His TV play Rotten Apples, to be shown over Christmas, is a black comedy set within a Northern Irish police station. 
 Bigoted detective sergeant Robert Spallen sets out to bring a notorious IRA terrorist to book. 
 In his manic enthusiasm he arrests an innocent man, the bear-like Dan Maguire, and sets about framing him. 
 Northern Ireland is the context rather than cartoon style backdrop to Leonard's piece. 
 &bquo;There's a strong seam of black humour running through the Northern Irish people and it's ignored.&equo; 
 Owen O'Neil agrees: &bquo;There's no major comedy circuit in Northern Ireland in the way there is in London, but people have survived for a very long time on the strength of their own sense of humour.&equo; 
 The reason for there being no circuit in Belfast is simple: it's too small. 
 Almost all the Northern Irish comedians have gone to London to find work. 
 At the recent Belfast Festival there were three Irish comedians on the bill. 
 All live in London. 
 For many years, old time Northern Irish comedian Jimmy Young did work there, cutting across the divide with a brand of comedy that hit at both sides. 
 But he died before the troubles began. 
 There is still that sense of humour on both front lines. 
 On a wall in the Shankhill Road in Protestant Belfast is a piece of graffiti which reads &bquo;We'll never forget you Jimmy Sands.&equo; 
 On another wall in the Catholic part of the city is a second legend that reads, &bquo;Ulster says NO, but the man from Del Monte says YES &mdash; and he's an Orangeman.&equo; 
 Similarly a new story is now doing the rounds in the wake of the release of the Guildford Four. 
 Irish Premier Charles Haughey was at the motor show where he was approached by a journalist. 
 &bquo;What do you think of the Renault 5?&equo; the hack asked him. 
 &bquo;They're innocent,&equo; the Irish premier replied. 
 &bquo;What about the Audi 100?&equo; 
 &bquo;They can't all be guilty,&equo; said Haughey. 
 Skilled comedians will be walking a delicate line. 
 What's abhorrent one week will be funny the next. 
 It's all about testing the mood of the populace. 
 As Victoria Wood said, if it's in bad taste it's not funny but if it's funny it's not in bad taste.&equo; 
 Rotten Apples is on Channel 4 at 10.15pm on Boxing Day. 
 women's page. 
 Bye Bye Baby by Janet and Allan Ahlberg (Heinemann, &pound;5.95) Bye Bye Baby nearly sent me bye-byes. 
 Not that it's boring, just depressing. 
 The foreword says &bquo;A sad story with a happy ending&equo;, and it's about a little baby who has no Mummy and so goes off to find one. 
 Having met a cat, a teddy, a hen and an uncle, he finally finds a Mummy without a child and they all live hapily together until the uncle reminds him that he has no Daddy&hellip; 
 It does have a happy ending, but what if the child reading had only one or no parents? 
 As for the iron test, my child sat holding on to Mummy while being read to. 
 Definitely not the book to read before bye-byes. 
 Top three 
 Peepo and 
 Each Peach Pear Plum, both by Janet and Allan Ahlberg 
 Winnie the Pooh by AA Milne ANGELO ABELA (father of Lucia, 2) Why Weeps the Brogan? by Hugh Scott (Walker Books, &pound;7.95) A nuclear disaster leaves Saxon and Gilbert believing that a buried museum is their world and that beyond its great doors lies only dust and darkness. 
 Their ritualled life is interrupted only by Saxon's unclear memories of what used to be, along with the movement of the grotesque Brogan in the &bquo;upper world&equo;. 
 Eventually they become frustrated with their limited existence and Saxon decides to venture outside&hellip; 
 Although the book was gripping, it was confusing at times and some events seemed detached from the story. 
 Perseverance is required to understand the story and one had to read between the lines to find the book's full meaning. 
 Top three 
 The Catcher in the Rye by JDSalinger 
 To Kill a Mockingbird by Harper Lee 
 The Dark is Rising Sequence by Susan Cooper BEN McCABE (15) PAGE wom 
 Bohemian rhapsody Everybody was having a good time on the Left Bank after the war, but the art was surprisingly thin, argues Tim Hilton. 
 Greco: voice of cafe society 
 THE abiding fascination of the existentialist years in post-war Paris may depend on myth. 
 But it's a myth that's still potent. 
 It's still not uncommon to meet people who declare that if one were seated in a Parisian cafe, rather than a British pub, then the conversation would be on a different level. 
 The talk would take in all the great political and aesthetic themes: Jean-Paul Sartre would join in, for he would be sitting at the next table: together, artists and intellectuals would conquer life's essential absurdity; and from such discussions tomorrow's painting would be born. 
 This sort of belief in French intellectual life, once so common in England, is interestingly tested by the exhibition St-Germain-des-Pres 1945-50 at the Pavillon des Arts in the Forum des Halles. 
 One visitor went there expecting obfuscation, for I have read Sartre on art and think that Sartre on cricket would be just as illuminating. 
 But in fact the show is rather jolly. 
 Rightly or wrongly, the Pavillon des Arts has decided to emphasise the festive spirit of the time. 
 The exhibition features not only the cafes that belonged to the intelligentsia but also the clubs: and the Tabou, the Lorientais and the Rose Rouge belonged to anyone who could get in. 
 There's a bande sonore in the show that endlessly plays the music of the day, by Sidney Bechet, Boris Vian, Tadd Dameron, the Miles Davis/Charlie Parker 1945 Savoy Sessions. 
 And above all there's Juliette Greco singing Si tu t'imagines, which is a Raymond Queneau poem, and Sartre's Rue des Blancs Manteaux, perhaps the worst pop lyric ever, which she just about manages to save. 
 There's lots of information in this exhibition, not much thought. 
 The intellectuals in the night clubs, we learn, can be spotted because they don't dance. 
 So much for them. 
 But their haunts and their comrades are carefully recorded. 
 In the sixth arrondissement, between the Boulevard Saint-Michel and the Rue des Saints-Peres, the Seine and the Luxembourg, about one hundred folk are traced, as they moved their operations from the Flore to the Deux Magots to the Brasserie Lipp or from the brothels of the Rue Gregoire de Tours to the cheap hotels, La Madison and La Lousiane but especially Le Montana. 
 It was considered bourgeois to own or rent an appartement, so the artistic community of St-Germain-des Pres lived in hotels, paying daily for their night's &mdash; or day's &mdash; rest, flitting from one to the next as circumstances demanded. 
 Obviously this is the reason why the people concerned were all so visible to each other. 
 Indeed, I think that the painters, just because they needed to work in studios, may have been the least prominent members of this society. 
 When has the manufacture of literature been so public? 
 The new post-Occupation magazines and publishing houses were run from bars. 
 Towards the end of the Occupation the upstairs room of the Flore resembled a classroom. 
 Sartre wrote Les Chemins de la Liberte at one table, de Beauvoir was busy at another. 
 Sartre and de Beauvoir had to go elsewhere after the Liberation. 
 They became so celebrated that they were disturbed by tourists. 
 It occurs to me that the St-Germain-des Pres scene was the first bohemia to have become an immediate media success. 
 Blown-up extracts from contemporary Paris newspapers, on panels larger than the works of art on display, suggest that the district's sudden fame was not so much to do with art or philosophy, but the novel phenomenon of la jeunesse. 
 They had been subdued in the Occupation years, but now went into the sixieme for a good time. 
 The proximity of the university quarter and the Ecole des Beaux Arts must also have had an effect, especially since the new lot of teachers were often not much older than their daytime pupils. 
 So what would be the prospects for a young artist who worked and had his friends and comrades in St-Germain-des Pres in 1945? 
 First of all, that young artist would generally be a painter, and male. 
 Secondly, any training he had received would have been conventional or vapid, as a result of German supervision of art education. 
 Thirdly, our young painter would not know of any other artistic centre beside Paris and would not imagine that such a place might exist. 
 Fourthly, he would pick up ideas from the avant-garde of poetry, or of jazz, rather than from the living old masters of the classic school of Paris. 
 There seem to have been a lot of people who took up painting for a while and then dropped it: often enough, like the young Roger Vadim, to become a cineaste or a designer in the lively world of small theatres (which are also extensively documented in the Pavillon des Arts.) 
 Edgar Gillet, who at that period was an interesting painter, recalls that he lost practically all of his friends to other, and easier, artistic disciplines. 
 He stuck with the difficult business of painting, and with a difficult set of non-rules to follow. 
 When he began to paint, during the Occupation, he had looked to Matisse and Bonnard. 
 In 1945 they seemed no longer relevant. 
 Gillet was influenced in the liberation years by the cafe conversation of Jean Fautrier, who had said that he wanted painting in which everything previously learnt would be discarded. 
 It would be badly drawn, badly composed, with gross textures and no subject at all: almost anyone could do it. 
 Though it does not mean to, the one thing this exhibition actually proves is that new Parisian painting after Hitler's war had no benefit (except commercial good fortune) from the surroundings of the new bohemia. 
 Whatever their wild ambitions, here was a generation of painters who look extraordinarily safe and tasteful. 
 The uncomposed art informel of Gillet and his friend Maurice Ronet (who left art for the theatre) has its moments, or rather its small passages, but this is not painting that makes one reconsider painting. 
 Wrong in purpose and direction, minor Parisian avant-grade art was a tributary trying to run uphill. 
 This said, one has some pleasure from two paintings by Jean-Michael Atlan. 
 He was a poet, a teacher of philosophy, and a man with a terrible recent history. 
 Arrested by the Germans in 1942, he had saved his life by pretending to be mad and had been interned in the Saint-Anne asylum until the liberation. 
 His paintings are gentle, as though painted under water. 
 Jacques Doucet has a pleasant collage from 1948 which depicts the Bal Negre in the rue Blomet. 
 Jean-Paul Riopelle's encrusted abstraction is &mdash; what can I say? &mdash; promising, and there are standard works by Poliakoff, Georges Mathieu, Hans Hartung (who died only last week) and Maria Elena Vieira da Silva. 
 St-Germain-des Pres took over from the previous Parisian art centres in Montmartre and Montparnasse, and brought much of the old guard to the new cafes. 
 Beside the surrealists, there were the groups known as the Bande a Prevert (poets, mainly), the Famille Sartre (which included Greco), the commmunists, the painters, the existentialists, and such minor gatherings as the lettristes, followers of the self-styled genius and concrete-poetry manufacturer, Isidore Isou. 
 Plenty of material for a party. 
 Why then the desperate or more generally pessimistic nature of the art they made? 
 Why is it all so thin and unachieved? 
 The most beautiful paintings in the show, and a more humane sadness, belong to Picasso. 
 He observed St-Germain-des Pres from a little distance, was distressed by its tendency towards abstraction, took his new mistress Francoise Gilot from its fringes, and so thought to teach a lesson in painting to both her and her contemporaries. 
 They didn't listen, or look. 
 Pavillon des Arts, Forum des Halles, Paris, until January 7. 
 Le Tabou&hellip;. hangout for the jeunesse doree in St-Germain-des Pres in the post-war years 
 ESSENTIAL BOOKS Lindsay Fraser from Heffers Children's Bookshop in Cambridge makes sure she always has these titles in stock:. 
 The Baby Catalogue by Janet and Allan Ahlberg (Viking Kestrel, &pound;6.99) 
 The Very Hungry Caterpillar by Eric Carle (Hamish Hamilton, &pound;1.99) 
 B.F.G. by Roald Dahl (Jonathan Cape, &pound;7.95) 
 Flat Stanley by Jeff Brown (Methuen, &pound;6.95) 
 Animals of Farthing Wood by Colin Dann (Pan, &pound;2.99) 
 The Jolly Postman by Janet and Allan Ahlberg (Heinemann, &pound;7.95) 
 The Tale of Peter Rabbit by Beatrix Potter (Frederick Warne, &pound;3.99) 
 Revolting Rhymes by Roald Dahl (Jonathan Cape, &pound;5.95) 
 The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe by CSLewis (Fontana Lion, &pound;2.25) 
 Fairy Tales by Terry Jones (Puffin, &pound;1.95) CHRISTMAS BEST-SELLERS Based on last week's sales in the children's department of Waterstone's in Edinburgh: 1 Rhyming Stew by Roald Dahl (Jonathan Cape, &pound;7.95) 2 Oi Get Off Our Train by John Burningham (Jonathan Cape, &pound;7.95) 3 Matilda by Roald Dahl 4 The Lion, The Witch and The Wardrobe by CSLewis (Fontana Lion, &pound;2.25) 5 Prince Caspian by CSLewis (Fontana Lion, &pound;2.25) 6 Almost Everything There Is To Know by Tim Hunkin (Pyramid Books, &pound;4.95) 7 The Complete Tales of Beatrix Potter (Frederick Warne, &pound;20) 8 Budgie The Helicopter by HRHDuchess of York (Simon &amp; Schuster, &pound;4.95) 9 The Way Things Work by David MacAuley (Dorling Kindersley, &pound;14.95) 10 Peace At Last by Jill Murphy (Walker, &pound;6.95) THE YEAR'S BEST-SELLERS Supplied by Jane Churchill at Children's Bookcentre in Kensington, London: 
 Where's Wally series by Martin Handford (Walker Books, from &pound;2.99 paperback) 
 A Christmas Story by Brian Wildsmith (Oxford University Press, &pound;6.95) 
 We're Going On A Bear Hunt by Michael Rosen and Helen Oxenbury 
 Bye Bye Baby by Janet and Allan Ahlberg 
 The Eleventh Hour by Graeme Base (MacMillan, &pound;7.95) 
 Matilda by Roald Dahl 
 The Fantastic Dinosaur Adventure by Gerald Durrell (Conran Octopus, &pound;7.99) 
 The Hodgeheg by Dick King-Smith (Puffin, &pound;1.99) 
 Elmer The Elephant by David McKee (Andersen, &pound;5.95) 
 A Piece of Cake by Jill Murphy ONE FOR ALL Sonia Benster of the Children's Bookshop in Huddersfield divided her choice into categories: 
 Best Christmas book: The Christmas Story by Brian Wildsmith (OUP, &pound;6.95) 
 Best picture book: Paddiwak and Cosy by Berlie Doherty and Teresa O'Brien (Methuen, &pound;5.95) 
 Best poetry: Heard in the Playground by Allan Ahlberg (Kestrel, &pound;2.50) 
 Biggest phenomenon: Where's Wally: The Fantastic Journey by Martin Handford (Walker, &pound;7.95) 
 Best teenage book: The True Confessions of Adrian Albert Mole by Sue Townsend (Methuen, &pound;5.99) 
 Best-selling local author: Crafty Ideas From Nature by Myrna Daitz and Shirley Williams (Exley, &pound;3.99) CHILDREN'S CHOICE This alphabetical list of Britain's best-selling children's authors was compiled from sales at school book clubs: 
 Allan and Janet Ahlberg 
 Judy Blume 
 Enid Blyton 
 Roald Dahl 
 Shirley Hughes 
 Dick King-Smith 
 CSLewis 
 Jill Murphy 
 Beatrix Potter 
 Jill Tomlinson WRITE ON Letterbox Library, a mail order book club offering non-sexist, multi-cultural books, lists its 10 most popular titles: 
 Picture Word Book by Jane Salt and Sarah Polley 
 Through My Window by Tony Bradman and Eileen Browne 
 Co-operative Sport and Games Book by Terry Orlick 
 An Early Start to Science by Roy Richards, Margaret Collis and Doug Kincaid 
 Paperbag Princess by Robert MMunch 
 I Don't Want To! by Bel Mooney 
 But Martin by June Counsel and Carolyn Dinan 
 Woman in the Moon and Other Forgotten Folk Tales by James Riordan and Angela Barrett 
 Planet of the Monsters by Stephan May 
 My Grandmother's Cookie Jar by Montzalee Miller and Katherine Potter 
 Thanks to the Children's Book Foundation for their help in putting together this report PAGE wom 
 We're Going on a Bear Hunt by Michael Rosen, illustrated by Helen Oxenbury (Walker Books, &pound;9.95) Winner of the Smarties Award 1989 After one reading, Rosa gave this large format, handsome book her highest accolade; she briskly wrote her name in the front and asked if she could take it to school &bquo;to show Olga&equo;, her favourite teacher. 
 Michael Rosen understands that rhythm makes language memorable for children, and what's remembered can be possessed and loved. 
 Bear Hunt is based on a traditional rhyme. 
 Four children and their father set off on a bear hunt in high spirits, but by the time they've forded a river, squelched through mud, survived a snowstorm and a wild wood to penetrate the bear's dark cave, all they are capable of is running home again, with bear in hot pursuit. 
 The final sequence is a familiar bad dream as the family dash in the house and upstairs in the nick of time, only to find they haven't shut the door behind them&hellip; 
 But everyone ends up hiding under the sheets, not too terrified, and a philosophical bear lollops back along the beach to his cave. 
 I did wish this book were longer, but it's a perfect short bedtime read which cheers tired eyes and ears. 
 Top three 
 Lulu and the Flying Babies by Posy Simmonds 
 This is the Bear by Sarah Hayes and Helen Craig 
 The Jolly Postman, or Other People's Letters, by Janet and Allan Ahlberg MAGGIE GEE (mother of Rosa, 2 years, 11 months) The Babar Books by Jean de Brunhoff (Methuen, &pound;2.95 to &pound;12.95; Magnet Paperbacks, &pound;2.50) Get ready for the Babar revival. 
 In the Conran shop Thirtysomethings are snapping up bendy Babars at &pound;10 a pop; Liberty stocks Babar children's wear; there's a film and TV series on the way. 
 But this isn't just another crass commercialisation of a fictional character. 
 This is the epic tale of the king of the beasts, the best-dressed elephant in the jungle. 
 The Babar books are not sentimental. 
 In fact, the series starts when Babar's mother is shot dead by a hunter. 
 He runs away to the city where he is taken in by The Old Lady. 
 She takes him to a tailor (hence the gorgeous green suit and bowler hat), hires a tutor and even buys him a car. 
 But Babar is homesick and succumbs to the call of the wild (and has loads more adventures). 
 Written in the Thirties, the six Babar stories have been available in English ever since, but Methuen now publish three sizes of Babar. 
 The facsimile editions are worth the &pound;12.95 price tag for the Frenchified handwritten text and superb colour printing. 
 But avoid the pocket hardbacks (&pound;2.95): &bquo;All the best bits are gone,&equo; said Charlie, sadly. 
 Top three 
 The Tale of Peter Rabbit by Beatrix Potter 
 Not Now Bernard by David McKee 
 Fred by Posy Simmonds LOUISE CHUNN (mother of Charlie, 3 &frac34;, and Alice, 1 &frac12;) Bill's New Frock, by Ann Fine (Methuen, &pound;6.95) Winner of Smarties Book Prize 89 (6-8 years category) Bill's an obliging little boy. 
 When his mother rigs him out in a pretty pink frock to wear to school (&bquo;What's a frock?&equo; said my son. 
 &bquo;A dress, you ignoramus&equo;), all he does is look in the mirror and say, &bquo;This cannot be true!&equo; 
 It's the start of a dreadful day. 
 Mean Malcolm whistles at him, an old lady helps him over the road, teacher expects his writing to be tidy and he has to read the part of the spineless Rapunzel. 
 At that point, I'm thinking this is going to turn into a junior Tootsie &mdash; you know, it takes a man to be a real feminist. 
 Little Bill in drag strikes a blow for the downtrodden girls. 
 In fact he doesn't. 
 Ann Fine is subtler and quirkier than that. 
 It's still a child's guide to sexism: children may be unconvinced, especially by the boys' latent gallantry (&bquo;They'd kick her, I mean him&equo;), and adults may find the story a touch contrived, but it's a good read. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't be a girl for five trillion pounds.&equo; 
 Aha, the message has got through. 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't be a footballer when you grow up and the girls&equo; toilets are messy.&equo; 
 Top three 
 The Never Ending Story by Michael Ende 
 Any Hardy Boys adventure by Franklin WDickson 
 The Secret Garden by Frances Hodgson Burnett HELEN OLDFIELD (mother of Jane, 9, and Richard, 8) PAGE wom 
 Bond's rescue deal with rival is under threat. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 THE embattled Australian entrepreneur, Alan Bond, yesterday struck a deal with a rival businessman, John Spalvins, in an attempt to save his teetering business empire. 
 But immediately the plan to carve up the boardroom of Bell Resources ran into trouble with Australia's corporate watchdog, the National Companies and Securities Commission (NCSC). 
 Mr Spalvins, who heads the Adelaide Steamship group which holds a 20 per cent stake in Bell Resources, called off his legal action to appoint a receiver to the company. 
 Mr Bond is desperate for the deal to stand, since Bell Resources is crucial to his A&dollar;2.5billion brewery deal with New Zealand's Lion Nathan which may underpin a debt restructuring plan for his entire media, property and brewing group, currently labouring to reduce around A&dollar;8billion of debts. 
 But the national securities regulator said it was unhappy about the deal over boardroom seats, whereby Mr Spalvins nominates four of the six directors at Bell Resources. 
 The Bond camp, which owns 58 per cent of Bell Resources, has also agreed to appoint an independent chairman and not to vote off the Adsteam representatives until a A&dollar;1.2billion loan from Bell Resources to Mr Bond's master Bond Corporation is repaid. 
 The NCSC says the agreement may contravene the takeover code by effectively changing control of Bell without shareholder approval. 
 It said it would return to the Australian supreme court today to ensure the agreement was in the interest of shareholders. 
 Inquiry into coffee price. 
 The cost of coffee is being investigated by the Office of Fair Trading after claims that price falls on international markets have not been matched in the shops. 
 Nestle pledge. 
 Nestle Foods Corporation said it would not buy Salvadoran coffee for 30 days in response to a consumer group campaign against the war in El Salvador. 
 New bank chief. 
 Deutsche Bank has named Hilmar Kopper as chief executive, replacing Alfred Herrhausen, who was killed by a terrorist car bomb a fortnight ago.. 
 Hilton auction. 
 Hilton Hotels, owner of the US Hilton chain and casinos in Las Vegas, could be sold to JMB Realty, a Chicago-based investments adviser, which bought the UK property company, Randsworth Trust, for &dollar;416million in July. 
 JMB is among more than six bidders in the &dollar;5billion-plus auction. 
 Green sells stake. 
 Michael Green, chairman of media group, Carlton Communications, yesterday sold about 20 per cent of his stake in the company for more than &pound;10.5 million. 
 Shares in Carlton slumped by 20p to 832p on news of the sale which leaves Mr Green's private company with a holding of around 5.3million shares. 
 His stake was sold at 820p a share. 
 Pennzoil order. 
 US oil company, Pennzoil, has been ordered by the courts to produce documents before Christmas to prove it does not intend launching a takeover bid for its bigger rival, Chevron. 
 ICI in talks. 
 ICI is discussing the sale of its Savlon antiseptic over-the-counter business, Care Laboratories, to the Swiss pharmaceuticals group, Ciba-Geigy. 
 The Swiss company said it would guarantee the jobs of all but 24 administrative staff if the sale goes through. 
 Wall Street higher. 
 On Wall Street, across-the-board buying in the oil sector sparked a rally. 
 Traders said some futures-related buy programmes also added to the market's gain. 
 The Dow Jones Industrial Average climbed 23.89 points to 2752.13, with advancing issues leading declines by about eight to seven. 
 MMC to probe Civil Aviation Authority. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 THE Monopolies and Mergers Commission is to launch an investigation into the Civil Aviation Authority. 
 The inquiry, the latest in a series of MMC investigations into public sector bodies, was announced by the Consumer Affairs Minister, Mr John Redwood. 
 He said the MMC, which last conducted an inquiry into the CAA in 1983, must report back within five months. 
 It is expected that the MMC investigators will be particularly interested in the CAA's air traffic control operations which have been the centre of a long-running controversy involving aircraft &bquo;near misses&equo;, poor morale among controllers and equipment break-downs. 
 The inquiry will encompass the full range of the CAA's activities. 
 The MMC will want to assess the effectiveness of the CAA's management in implementing a planned &pound;600million programme to modernise Britain's air traffic control system. 
 Granada brightens. 
 Demand for satellite television has been greatly exaggerated, the TV equipment rental and leisure group Granada said yesterday. 
 The company, which has a major share stake in Sky's rival British Satellite Broadcasting but which rents receiver equipment for Rupert Murdoch's operation, said around 30,000 dishes a month are being sold or rented. 
 In addition to that, direct Murdoch promotions are boosting sales, but Granada warned that estimates for total demand should be taken &bquo;with a certain pinch of salt.&equo; 
 Granada has a &pound;63million stake in BSB and said there had been several approaches for Alan Bond's major stake in the venture. 
 It was hoped that sale of the stake would benefit the consortium. 
 The company said its Manchester-based television firm was well placed to recapture its franchise in the coming auction and is seeking overseas TV opportunities. 
 Granada yesterday unveiled profits of &pound;164million &mdash; up 15 per cent &mdash; for the year to September. 
 The downturn in television and electrical rental business appeared to be tailing off and, despite a substantial write-off, the sale of Lasky &mdash; where the group admitted its timing was wrong &mdash; was beneficial.. 
 Strikes hit Dowty. 
 Dowty's three-pronged attack in areas of high technology where profit has often been elusive is proceeding better than the interim results suggest. 
 Turnover grew by a quarter and margins would have been maintained but for strikes and other special factors mainly affecting the aerospace business. 
 Defence equipment's share of sales, if not yet profit, is declining. 
 Excluding the mining machinery business that contributed &pound;85million in the corresponding period, before disposal, turnover put on almost &pound;70million to &pound;337.5million. 
 This is a tiny fraction of order books and likely contracts of &pound;2billion, although strikes at home lasting several days and the subsequent long stoppage at Boeing has limited the prospective gain above the &pound;230million aerospace turnover achieved last year. 
 Information technology sales doubled to &pound;92million as a result of the CASE takeover, though it is taking time to bring profitability up to the levels elsewhere in the group. 
 Polymer engineering, on the other hand made further strides, particularly in cost control. 
 Pre-tax profit was only 13.5 per cent ahead at &pound;37million after the &pound;2million estimated strike cost and &pound;1.6million reduction in property gains to &pound;1.6million. 
 Interest was that amount lower at &pound;3.6million, offsetting most of the &pound;2million mining and industrial hydraulics contribution in the six months to September last year. 
 The interim dividend is 3.5p, against 3.2p, while earnings stayed at 9.2p on the higher capital. 
 Only just over a third of sales were military and well over half were overseas, so steady progress is attainable for a prolonged period.. 
 Solid gains at Triplex. 
 Triplex Lloyd, the steel fabrications and foundries group with enlarged motor and electrical distribution activities as a result of the Christy Hunt acquisition, made solid gains on most fronts in the latest six months. 
 Weak demand for windows for homes is being offset elsewhere and the West Midlands property developments and disposals are helping to keep the leap in interest charges within bounds. 
 The interim dividend is being boosted by nearly half although the final payment is weightier. 
 Including CH's Deritend subsidiaries the power and defence division took the lead in raising turnover to &pound;85.6million, from &pound;59.5million, before some further disposals. 
 It was still more prominent in the rise in pre-tax profit to &pound;5.14million, from &pound;2.83million. 
 Motor and engineering margins were hit by relocations, rather than any slackening in demand. 
 Interest charges nearly quadrupled to &pound;1.7million, but the Wednesbury development, which will include an IKEA furniture superstore, promises to keep property revenues rising. 
 The interim dividend is 2.5p, against 1.75p and earnings were 0.5p higher at 8.2p after a slightly lower tax burden. 
 Trading continues quite strong in most areas, the chairman, Mr Lewis Robertson, reports.. 
 In short&hellip; 
 BSS turnover soared to &pound;8l.4million, from &pound;61.8 million, while pre-tax profit climbed to &pound;6.63million, from &pound;5.62million. 
 Although interest charges were sharply up at &pound;386,000, smaller acquisitions to enlarge the network can easily be financed by the high cash flow. 
 Earnings were 3.3p ahead at 22.6p a share. 
 The interim dividend is being raised by 15 per cent to 5.75p. 
 RICHARDS rationalised the Spence Bryson textiles acquisition and sold its Belfast head office for &pound;1.6million after the year end. 
 Pre-tax profit rose to &pound;2.76million, from &pound;2.45million after exceptional outlays in the previous year to September 30. 
 The increased final dividend of 2.75p takes the total to 3.75p, from 3.5p, covered by earnings up in line to 9p. 
 TMD Advertising Holdings reported an 81 per cent rise in profits to &pound;2.2million after including first results from TMD Manchester, together with Yershon Group, Horizons Media Outdoor, Harrison Salinson and Michael Jarvis which were all acquired during the year to August. 
 The markets. 
 The water issues accounted for more than half the business on the heaviest days trading since January. 
 Seaq volume at 5pm was 800.4million of which water accounted for 433million. 
 The FTSE Index was 18 points up at 10pm but this was later halved before a later rally saw it close 12.1 points up at 2363.5. 
 The firmer pound helped gilts gain a quarter, but most equities were down. 
 British Aerospace lost 12p later in the day at 561p on market rumours that the Rover 2000 production plant was closing early for Christmas because of low-level business. 
 Tokyo: Closed firmer in moderate trading. 
 Nikkei index: 37,803.53 (37,752.67). 
 Hong Kong: Surged in the strongest trading volume in over a month. 
 Hang Seng index: 2,809.58 (2,763.33). 
 Franfurt: Closed mixed in active trading. 
 FAZ index: 693.14 (693.97). 
 Paris: Closed narrowly mixed in quiet trading. 
 CAC index: 549.5 (551.3). 
 Buying spree for regional brewers. 
 By Tony May 
 THE regional brewers, Devenish and Vaux, unveiled ambitious expansion plans yesterday in the wake of the Monopolies Commission report into the industry. 
 Devenish is to spend up to &pound;180million to more than double its pub chain. 
 Its chairman, Michael Cannon, said yesterday that he relished the challenge of buying between 400 and 600 pubs, mostly in the Midlands and North, from the big brewers for between &pound;250,000 and &pound;300,000, and expects this to take three months. 
 Mr Cannon is not the only regional brewer planning a big expansion. 
 The Sunderland-based Vaux wants to buy 100 or more pubs but is being choosy. 
 It expects its gearing to rise from 10 per cent to 20 per cent. 
 Vaux, which already receives most of its profit from hotels, yesterday announced the &pound;27.3million purchase of the Gosforth Park Hotel, Newcastle from Mount Charlotte Hotels for shares. 
 To finance its &bquo;once in a lifetime&equo; opportunity, Devenish has unused borrowings and the &pound;26million proceeds of the April rights issue. 
 Gearing will be pushed up from the present 13 per cent and the board will then seek some longer-term financing. 
 These expansion moves were announced yesterday alongside a 22 per cent rise in Devenish's profit to &pound;14million for the year to September 30. 
 The Dorset, Devon and Cornwall holiday areas benefited from the good summer weather and from the upgrading of pubs carried out over the last few years. 
 Vaux's profits jumped 20.5 per cent to &pound;31.5million in the same period. 
 Its Swallow Hotels have had a good year, helped by the first full year's trading at Peterborough and Waltham Abbey. 
 The current year's plans involve expenditure within the group of &pound;70million, excluding acquisitions of which &pound;43million will be on hotels and &pound;6million on care homes. 
 East European changes are chance for historic bargain Economics. 
 By Christopher Huhne 
 THE ministerial meeting of the Group of 24 industrial market economies in Brussels today will provide the first test of whether the West is ready to rise to the occasion in Eastern Europe. 
 The Group itself has already been overtaken by events, since it was mandated by the Paris summit to co-ordinate measures to help Poland and Hungary. 
 Since then, both East Germany and Czechoslovakia have lined up with equally convincing claims. 
 Even Bulgaria is not far behind. 
 The scale of economic assistance which will be required if these economies are to be integrated into the world financial and trading system is without any recent parallel. 
 The nearest precedent is the extraordinarily generous Marshall Plan for the reconstruction of Western Europe after the second world war. 
 Some &dollar;12.8billion was funnelled through the plan between April 1948 and June 1952, but there was also US aid through other agencies and to other parts of the world, including a substantial slice for Japan. 
 &bquo;During the period 1946 through 1953&equo;, the Randall commission of the US Congress on foreign economic policy reported*, &bquo;the United States transferred through gifts and loans &dollar;33billion of goods and services, exclusive of military items. 
 This was equal to more than one-fourth of all American exports&equo;. 
 Aid today in a similar proportion to American exports would amount to some &dollar;130billion, an unimaginably large figure. 
 That comparison is exagerrated by the enormous increase in world trade which has occurred in the post-war period, and which has largely by-passed the Eastern European countries. 
 It may thus be fairer to compare the Marshall programme with the scale of Eastern European imports rather than American exports. 
 For example, Britain received &dollar;3.2billion of the &dollar;12.8billion Marshall money &mdash; worth just over 7 per cent of all our imports of goods and services over the five years. 
 A similar boost to the imports of Eastern Europe (excluding the Soviet Union) would be worth some &dollar;7.5billion a year for five years. 
 If the Soviet Union were included, the total should be doubled to &dollar;15billion a year. 
 These are figures which dwarf those currently being discussed in the G24. 
 The International Monetary Fund letter of intent for Poland will release about &dollar;700million. 
 The once-off economic stabilisation fund for Poland is meant to be worth &dollar;1billion. 
 There will be money from the World Bank. 
 European Investment Bank loans guaranteed by the EC budget may amount over 1990-2 to &dollar;1.1billion for Poland and Hungary. 
 Bilateral credits pledged to Poland and Hungary amount to nearly &dollar;1.5billion. 
 The European Development Bank, agreed at the Strasbourg summit, will have a capital and lending power of 10billion ECUs, or some &dollar;8.7billion. 
 Not only will these flows take time to build up, but they will also be mainly loans rather than grants, unlike Marshall aid. 
 Moreover, they come on top of an unhappy experience with foreign currency borrowing for most of the Eastern European countries during the Seventies. 
 Eastern Europe's total convertible currency debt is estimated at &dollar;134billion, of which some &dollar;43billion is owed by the Soviet Union; &dollar;39billion by Poland; &dollar;17billion by Hungary; and &dollar;22billion by East Germany. 
 Unless the Paris Club, which manages official debt to Western governments, proves much more generous than its past record suggests, a considerable slice of the new money will go merely to service the old loans rather than provide fresh finance for imports and investment goods to support genuine reform. 
 You do not, of course, solve problems merely by throwing money at them. 
 So much is obvious from the record of the countries which received Marshall aid. 
 Contrary to popular misconception, Britain received more than any other Western European country, yet its subsequent economic record proved to be less impressive. 
 Yet it would be a grotesque misrepresentation to suggest that the Marshall plan consisted merely of cash handouts which enabled the recipients to fund a higher level of imports, and hence to run a higher pressure of domestic demand without serious inflationary problems. 
 General George C. Marshall, the US Secretary of State, was far from a League of Nations idealist. 
 He was out for long term gains. 
 His historic speech at Harvard University on June 5, 1947, came at a time when it was increasingly clear that there was a fundamental imbalance between the US economy, which had emerged bigger and stronger from the war, and the destitution of Europe. 
 He wanted to rebuild Western Europe, both as the commercial partner of the US and as a bulwark in a peaceful settlement of a continent. 
 It was self-consciously a reversal of the Versailles policy, after the first world war, of exacting war reparations from the defeated. 
 His words have a surprising resonance in today's Eastern Europe. 
 &bquo;The town and city industries&equo;, he said, &bquo;are not producing adequate goods to exchange with the food-producing farmer&hellip; people in the cities are short of food and fuel. 
 So the governments are forced to use their foreign money and credits to procure these necessities abroad&hellip; 
 It is logical that the United States should do whatever it is able to do to assist in the return of normal economic health in the world, without which there can be no political stability and no assured peace&hellip; there must be some agreement among the countries of Europe as to the requirements of the situation and the part those countries themselves will take in order to give proper effect to whatever action might be undertaken by this government. 
 This is the business of the Europeans. 
 The initiative, I think, must come from Europe.&equo; 
 Ernest Bevin, then the Foreign Secretary, leapt at the opportunity to convene, with his French counterpart, a conference of European nations in Paris. 
 It was clear from the start that American aid would only take place in the context of commitments to economic reform within Europe. 
 The Europeans were encouraged to devalue, and to open up trade between themselves before freeing their exchanges with the US. 
 Some of the most effective parts of the Marshall plan were precisely those which concentrated on improving public policy, company management, the use of investment, and output per person. 
 But it was necessary, too, that the trade deficits run by Europe were properly financed. 
 The effects of the total programme &mdash; advice, reform and finance &mdash; in improving both output and productivity were dramatic. 
 In the participating countries, industrial production rose by 39 per cent between 1948 and 1952. 
 The access to American know-how and management techniques, including both advice from the US missions in each country and visits to plants in the US, helped to lift productivity growth to an altogether more rapid rhythm. 
 During the Fifties, output per person grew in the US by 2.4 per cent a year. 
 The growth was 4.1 per cent in Italy; 3.9 per cent in France; 6 per cent in West Germany. 
 Only in Britain, with 2 per cent, was the catch-up less effective. 
 Here there are important parallels and dissimilarities with Eastern Europe. 
 The greatest difference is that the Marshall plan was reviving economies which, even in the case of Germany, had experienced bureaucratic control for a relatively short period. 
 The instincts of the entrepreneur have been suppressed in Eastern Europe for 44 years, and in the Soviet Union for 72. 
 No one can say how quickly the taste for risk and reward, the essential motor of a free market economy, will come back. 
 Unlike many Third World countries, though, the Eastern European economies are industrial and have been capitalist. 
 Moreover, they have maintained relatively high standards of education. 
 One parallel with the Marshall period is the appetite for advice to both government and enterprises. 
 This is an area where the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development, through its committees of member state experts, needs to give generously. 
 For example, the Soviet Union is committed to moving from its odd system of Net Material Product (which disregards services) to a standardised system of national accounting on United Nations lines. 
 It will need a lot of technical assistance. 
 Autonomous enterprises, for instance, will no longer yield their surplus automatically to the central government (one of the reasons for the collapse in the Soviet tax base and the widening budget deficit). 
 The government needs advice on constructing a tax system for a decentralised economy. 
 For example, the Eastern Europeans will need to construct, almost overnight, a whole system of company law, contract and accounts. 
 A final difference with the Marshall era is the lack of spare capacity in the developed world. 
 The expenditure of Marshall dollars on US exports did not create inflationary pressures within the US because of the wartime demobilisation and the ability of its plant and manpower to produce more. 
 If there were to be a programme of comparable generosity to the new democracies, it would be necessary to reduce some category of expenditure within the industrial countries. 
 The obvious candidate is defence spending. 
 The greater the economic success of the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe, the greater will be our security. 
 The elements of an historic bargain are there: our peace for their prosperity Quoted in Robert Solomon, The International Monetary System 1945-1981, New York, 1982. 
 The top job that no one wants. 
 By Teresa Hunter 
 FINANCIAL advisers converging on the Wembley Conference Centre today will be wondering who will take the job which no one wants and step into the shoes of Lord Elton at the head of Britain's most important investor protection body. 
 The public flogging anticipated at the annual general meeting of the City watchdog, Fimbra, may well fail to materialise. 
 In the way of the City, the old boys have done their deals behind the scenes. 
 Members' anger has been placated by the announcement that Lord Elton will retire early next year. 
 Fimbra's executive and members must now restore public confidence in the organisation responsible for policing advisers who tell investors where to invest their money. 
 That Fimbra has reached this impasse comes as no surprise to anyone with a knowledge of the chequered history of this organisation responsible for policing many of the black sheep of the financial world. 
 To its credit, Fimbra has done a good job weeding out some of the black sheep. 
 Membership was never granted to about a third of firms which originally applied. 
 Since 1987 a further 100 firms have been suspended. 
 Although it is perhaps a cause of some concern that of the 8,000 trading member firms, some 4,000 have not yet received a compliance visit. 
 But Fimbra's rigid policing style has alienated many of the firms which have passed the test of being responsible, well-conducted businesses. 
 Fimbra itself is now beginning to admit some of its rules and regulations may have been &bquo;too onerous&equo;. 
 The problem is seen to have been exacerbated by appointing both a chairman, Lord Elton and a chief executive, Ray O'Brien, from outside the broking world. 
 Mounting discontent came to a head over a professional insurance scheme which Fimbra attempted to force on all its members. 
 But this was an excuse for confrontation rather than a cause. 
 Fimbra members are by their nature small businesses. 
 The Financial Services Act was putting pressure on them from all sides. 
 It prohibited them from accepting research and other support services traditionally provided by the life companies. 
 It also required them to disclose any commissions they earn to the client &mdash; guaranteeing a more difficult sale. 
 Then the Fimbra straitjacket of rules and regulations descended. 
 Against this the Barlow Clowes fiasco, in which small investors lost up to &pound;100million, reflected most critically on Fimbra members, who had recommended the company. 
 Fimbra will today decide what sort of leader can forge a united path for all its members. 
 But if the rumour that Lord Elton was on a shortlist of one is true, that replacement may be hard to find. 
 Kingfisher chief says offer is fair as Dixons &bquo;is in serious decline&equo;. 
 By Peter Rodgers City Editor 
 DIXONS, the electrical retailer, was yesterday accused of beefing up its results through &pound;31million undisclosed profits from property sales, and of making more from insurance and credit deals than from selling goods. 
 Geoff Mulcahy, Kingfisher chief executive, detailing the Woolworth, Comet and B&amp;Q group's &pound;460million offer, said Dixons faced a &bquo;bleak future&equo; in its present form and he called the 120p a share he is bidding &bquo;very serious for a business in serious decline.&equo; 
 City analysts have said the offer is too low. 
 Stanley Kalms, the Dixons chief whose own bid for what was then called Woolworths was repulsed three years ago, said the offer document did not disguise an attempt to acquire his company on the cheap. 
 &bquo;Everyone knows that we, like Comet, have been suffering a temporary downturn. 
 Kingfisher's latest published interim statement showed that Comet has suffered a 60 per cent fall in profits,&equo; added Mr Kalms. 
 The Kingfisher offer document, says Dixons, has not disclosed the extent of property disposal profits, or where they have been taken. 
 The bidder's estimate is that at least &pound;31million of the property profit has been taken above the line, and Kingfisher also questions whether Dixons made any profit at all in 1988-89 from selling electrical goods in the UK. 
 Mr Mulcahy said Dixons' claim that its results were due to the downturn in the electrical market was untrue. 
 They had begun to decline while the market was still growing. 
 Dixons' market capitalisation had also fallen &pound;1billion, or 72 per cent, more than all bar one other non-food retailer. 
 He argued that Dixons' approach to electrical retailing was &bquo;fundamentally flawed.&equo; 
 Mr Mulcahy, who has made a formal presentation to the Office of Fair Trading, was dismissive about suggestions that the bid would be referred. 
 Kingfisher claims the combined company would have a market share of 22 per cent, though other estimates are that it would be above the 25 per cent threshold for a reference. 
 With a stock exchange investigation under way into heavy trading in Dixons' options ahead of the announcement, it emerged that as many as 300 people would have known of the bid shortly beforehand, many of them on the credit committees of lending banks. 
 But Kingfisher director, Mr Archie Norman, said he had total confidence in brokers Phillips and Drew, despite the fact that much of the trading had been done through them. 
 &bquo;We kept the details of our bid extremely tight. 
 Our brokers knew nothing until 4pm the day before our announcement. 
 By that time the trading had been done.&equo; 
 Kingfisher denied that the borrowings classified the deal as highly leveraged. 
 The investors' watchdog may have had its day Notebook. 
 By Edited by Alex Brummer 
 THE investor protection system set up under the Financial Services Act is creaking under the strain, less than three years after it swung into operation. 
 The first rule books devised by the Securities and Investments Board (SIB) led to a torrent of complaints from the City and the replacement of the first chairman, Sir Kenneth Berrill by the Bank of England director, David Walker. 
 Sir Kenneth's rules were a bit daft in places and far too detailed to work without the risk of continual recourse to the courts. 
 So there was a case for revising them. 
 But what sticks in the mind is how easily the City was able to use the self-regulatory nature of the investor protection system &mdash; &bquo;we pay for it, so get him off our backs&equo; &mdash; to twist the arm of the government. 
 If Sir Kenneth had done a better piece of work, and been disliked by the City simply for being too tough in representing the interests of investors, would that have been enough to keep his job? 
 We will never know. 
 But the debacle at Fimbra, the watchdog responsible to SIB for regulating independent financial advisers, suggests that exactly the same tensions between self-regulation and investor protection continue. 
 With its large and unruly membership of mainly small firms, Fimbra has had problems since the beginning of the new system. 
 Ignoring the rights and wrongs of Lord Elton's disagreements with some of his members, the fact is that a body meant to protect investors has been overshadowed by policy rows with the investment firms which make up its membership. 
 There is now a serious possibility that this bastardised version of self-regulation will gradually crumble away, under the combined assault of Brussels, European preferences for statutory regulation and the sheer impossibility of resolving the underlying tension between practitioners and investors. 
 The great benefit to the government of the present system is that the City finances it and receives a large share of the blame when things go wrong. 
 A statutory system based on the SIB is beginning to look a distinct possibility for the 1990s. 
 It would be better for government, City and investors. 
 Ghastly sight. 
 THERE are some disasters that are so ghastly that even the voyeur averts the eyes. 
 Just such an episode has been playing itself out on the American financial stage. 
 The damage to the integrity of the US banking system caused by the feckless management of the savings and loans system &mdash; which before US financial deregulation did much the same job as our own building societies &mdash; has been so extensive that its impact often goes unstated. 
 President Bush was admirably fast in identifying the problem inherited from the laissez faire Administration of his predecessor, and was quick to put together a &dollar;164billion rescue package &mdash; by far the largest in the history of finance. 
 Less than a year later it appears even this will be inadequate. 
 The gloomiest analysts' estimates suggest that the eventual bill could be as much as &dollar;100billion higher. 
 The chairman of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, who inherited supervisory responsibilities as part of the rescue plan, now admits the problem could costs tens of billions more than anticipated. 
 He is currently preparing a plan to unlock more working capital by the New Year. 
 Almost as dramatic as the financial scale of the mess is the growing political fallout. 
 The problems of one particularly sick savings and loan, Lincoln Federal, has already cost the head of the Federal Home Loans Bank, his job and could take some senior elected officials, including Democratic Senator Alan Cranston down, too. 
 It is also besmirching the reputation of the chairman of the Federal Reserve Board, who was peripherally involved. 
 The savings and loan saga provides a startling illustration of how badly matters can go wrong when institutions are cut loose from regulation without proper supervision. 
 It can only be hoped that the newly aggressive financial players of the Thatcher era manage to avoid the same errors. 
 New strains. 
 FRANCE'S decision to sweep away exchange controls to mark the Euro decade of the 1990s is important enough to have caused even Mrs Thatcher to give some ground in her opposition to the Exchange Rate Mechanism. 
 Slowly, but surely, the panoply of conditions the Prime Minister erected is being swept away. 
 This, conveniently, is at a time when sterling has fallen far enough against the Deutschemark to make it potentially competitive within ERM. 
 But this did not prevent Mrs Thatcher from exposing another potential problem in her Financial Times interview: accommodating a trading and reserve currency such as sterling within a mechanism where the Deutschemark has no serious challenger. 
 Britain's entry could change that substant-ially. 
 The Bank of England's recent survey of the London foreign exchange market showed that trading in sterling for dollars, or greenbacks for German marks, amounts to almost half the daily turnover. 
 By contrast, dollars for lira and dollars for the French franc &mdash; the other main ERM currencies &mdash; total only 4 per cent. 
 Even allowing for the pound being on home ground that is a sizeable difference. 
 It does not take much to imagine a situation in which the world's foreign exchange markets are pushing the pound in one direction and the mark in the other. 
 Even a wider fluctuation band of, say, 6 per cent might (the same as Italy) be swept away in the hurricane. 
 Given the current differing economic performance of Britain and West Germany, putting sterling in the exchange rate mechanism could well subject it to new strains. 
 At worst, it could force ERM into a raft of destabilising realignments. 
 With her recognition of the unusual role of sterling and London in the international financial system, Mrs Thatcher makes a more credible argument against participation. 
 Cameron-Webb appeal fails. 
 By Financial Staff 
 PETER Cameron-Webb, one of the men at the centre of the largest Lloyd's scandal in history, yesterday failed in the Appeal Court to overturn a judgment against him for &pound;5million. 
 Lord Justice Parker together with Lord Justice Bingham and Sir John Megaw, dismissed Mr Cameron-Webb's appeal against an earlier ruling. 
 Mr Cameron-Webb was the manager of the PCW Underwriting Agency whose business resulted in a &pound;135million market-wide settlement at Lloyd's. 
 Although the PCW affair first came to light nearly nine years ago it remains the single largest City controversy on record. 
 In February Mr Justice Saville had ruled in favour of Lloyd's who had claimed &pound;2.1 million plus &dollar;4.5million and 22,000 Swiss francs from Mr Cameron-Webb. 
 The former Lloyd's underwriter has lived in America since 1981 but faces charges over the affair if he ever returns to Britain. 
 Refusing leave to appeal to the House of Lords, Lord Justice Bingham said the sums claimed by Lloyd's represented money out of which Mr Cameron-Webb had tried to cheat syndicates for which he acted. 
 The court was told between 1968 and 1982 money had been syphoned out of syndicates as purported reinsurance premiums to overseas companies controlled by Mr Cameron-Webb. 
 Appearing in court for the Corporation of Lloyd's, Stephen Ruttle said: &bquo;Mr Cameron- Webb is marginally short on merits. 
 He would be unlikely to give the Archangel Gabriel a run for his money and he should not be allowed to run to the House of Lords.&equo; 
 Mr Cameron-Webb, on whose syndicates investors such as tennis star Virginia Wade lost millions of pounds, can still appeal directly to the House of Lords for a fresh hearing. 
 Losses from the PCW case were eventually settled after contributions were made by Lloyd's, the syndicate investors, brokers and other agents in the London insurance market. 
 Peru ends IMF debt revolt. 
 By Mike Reid in Lima 
 PERU has reached a preliminary agreement with the International Monetary Fund that signals a softening of the country's four-year debt rebellion. 
 The agreement was accompanied by a &dollar;42.3million payment to the Fund by the Peruvians &mdash; the first since 1986 &mdash; to cover repayments due between September and December, according to an announcement in Washington on Monday. 
 Peru owes a further &dollar;760million in arrears on its repayments of past loans from the Fund. 
 The country has now committed itself to stay up to date with future payments. 
 In return, the IMF will send a mission to Lima to collaborate in drawing up a medium-term economic programme, and will seek financial support for Peru. 
 The four-point agreement follows more than a year of contacts with the Fund by Peru's foreign debt negotiator, Abel Salinas, and is an about-turn by President Alan Garcia. 
 He stopped payments to the Fund shortly after taking office in 1985, as part of a unilateral policy to restrict payments on Peru's &dollar;18billion foreign debt, which stands at 10 per cent of export earnings. 
 Mr Garcia has said the IMF has become more &bquo;flexible&equo;, particularly in accepting that any economic programme for Peru would require &bquo;concessional&equo; financing in view of the country's depressed economy and political problems. 
 But the agreement has been interpreted here as a bid to stave off a likely request that Peru leave the Fund because of its violation of the rules. 
 Closer collaboration with the IMF, and fresh money, will almost certainly have to await a new government, due in March. 
 It will also require willingness by creditors to advance a bridge loan to enable Peru to clear its account with the Fund. 
 It has the largest arrears of 10 countries which have been declared &bquo;ineligible&equo; for further Fund loans. 
 The Racal twins: their share prices just do not add up Outlook. 
 By Roger Cowe 
 RACAL is the company which proves beyond a shadow of doubt that share prices say nothing about what a company is worth. 
 Just as you cannot add up all the prices in a shop to arrive at what it would cost to buy the shop, nor can you add up the price of all a company's shares to arrive at what the company is worth. 
 Racal proved this conclusively when it announced last spring that it was planning to sell off part of the Vodafone mobile telecoms operation. 
 Racal's share price suddenly shot up by almost a third, despite the fact that the partial flotation would have absolutely no effect on the already-excellent prospects for Vodafone. 
 Another way of looking at this conundrum is to compare the market value (the total value of all the shares) of the two companies. 
 The parent company, Racal Electronics, is currently valued at &pound;3.1billion, as the table shows, while Racal telecom, the Vodafone company, is valued at &pound;4billion. 
 Nothing wrong with that, you might think, even if it does represent more than 70 times last year's earnings &mdash; a price-earnings ratio of Japanese proportions. 
 But the parent owns 80 per cent of Telecom, which works out at &pound;3.2billion. 
 In other words, it is not only cheaper to buy the parent company's shares, buying them gets you a share of the non-telecom activities for less than nothing. 
 That might seem fair enough considering the profitability of those businesses, but they are not quite so bad that people should be paid for taking them away. 
 The chart shows that in total the non-telecom activities made less profit in this half year than last time. 
 But there are some profitable and growing businesses among them. 
 Security, being mainly the results of the Chubb acquisition in 1984, is the largest division. 
 With the help of acquisitions, sales and profits grew substantially, despite the effect of the housing downturn on the Chubb locks business and of worries about Halon on the fire extinguisher operation. 
 Apart from Security, though, there was little good news in the figures for the non-telecom businesses. 
 Defence activities are suffering at Racal as everywhere, although the order book was boosted to &pound;250million by two orders from West Germany announced yesterday. 
 The chairman, Sir Ernest Harrison, promised that the first half loss would be reversed in the second half, but pressure on margins is not going to go away. 
 Radio Communications is sufferring similar pressures, since its traditional customers are military. 
 Here Racal is compensating by cultivating paramilitary forces, and has become the Government's nominated supplier of secure mobile radios to UK police forces. 
 Data Communications, where Racal is investing heavily in various kinds of electronic networks, saw profits slip by &pound;2 million to &pound;11.6million. 
 This was partly the result of good news such as winning the contract for the government department data network and a voice network for the department of social security. 
 Start-up costs on these projects and a US satellite network soaked up &pound;6.6 million. 
 This neatly demonstrates the Racal approach which has produced Vodafone: invest heavily in value-added services whose growth can compensate for difficulties in traditional product areas. 
 This strategy was invented seven years ago as Mr Harrison, as he then was, saw Racal's difficulties in competing with the defence industry giants even after the takeover of Decca. 
 It is easy to say now that the potential for cellular telephones made it easy to focus on that business. 
 But how many people even knew what a cellular phone was seven years ago. 
 The uncertainty is illustrated by the fact that even five years ago Vodafone profits were forecast at around &pound;40million by the end of the decade. 
 In fact Racal Telecom has made &pound;73million in just six months. 
 Even allowing for inflation, that is probably beyond the wildest dreams even of Sir Ernest. 
 And it is that uncertainty which limits the value the City can put on Sir Ernest's other risky ventures, and explains why the share prices do not add up. 
 Volvo in huge asset swap deal. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 VOLVO is taking a &pound;2.4billion stake in the Swedish state-controlled industrial conglomerate, Procordia, in exchange for the motor giant's Provendor food division and a 29 per cent holding in the Pharmacia drugs company. 
 In a move intended to rationalise Volvo's interests outside its core activities of car and truck manufacture, the company will then hold a 40 per cent stake in Procordia. 
 The impact of the deal, the biggest ever in the Swedish market, will turn Procordia into one of Europe's 20 largest pharmaceutical companies, with more than 48,000 employees and a yearly turnover approaching &pound;3.5billion. 
 It will also become a market leader in several food areas within Scandinavia. 
 The asset swap, which was unveiled in Stockholm last night, puts Volvo on an equal footing with the Swedish Government, which previously held an 80 per cent share stake in Procordia. 
 Having taken control of Volvo's 29 per cent Pharmacia stake, which carries nearly half of the voting rights in Sweden's biggest drugs company, Procordia is expected to launch a full takeover bid of at least &pound;1billion. 
 &bquo;It's likely that Procordia is going to make a bid for Pharmacia in order to get hold of its drugs division to combine it with KabiVitrum,&equo; (its pharmaceutical subsidiary), said a financial analyst at Stockholm broker, United Securities. 
 The sale of Provendor, which is Volvo's third most profitable division, making products ranging from mineral water to frozen snacks, will come as a surprise to the market when trading opens today. 
 Shares in the three companies concerned in the swap were suspended yesterday in advance of the evening statement. 
 After the swap, Volvo's only other asset outside of engineering and motor manufacturing will be its 20 per cent holding in Saga, the Norwegian oil exploration company. 
 A Volvo spokesman last night refused to go into the reasons behind the deal. 
 But the market expects it to prelude news of a major link-up with Renault of France. 
 Volvo confirmed recently that both companies had been holding &bquo;discussions&equo; over possible joint ventures in the European motor market. 
 The sale of Volvo's Pharmacia holding, bought in 1985, follows a slump in the drug company's fortunes. 
 With the share price peaking in July at 200 crowns, the company's share capital was worth 13 billion crowns. 
 The restricted B-share has since fallen to 161, reducing the total market capitalisation to 10.7 billion crowns. 
 Pharmacia had pre-tax nine-month profits of 545 million crowns (&pound;54million) this year, down 14 per cent. 
 Former Bolivian minister in US court. 
 By Mark Tran in Washington 
 THE wheels of justice began turning yesterday for the former Bolivian Interior Minister, Mr Luis Arce Gomez, when he appeared before a Miami magistrate following his arrest and deportation from Bolivia. 
 Mr Arce Gomez, who once enlisted the services of the former SS officer Klaus Barbie to advise Bolivian death squads, was seized by a joint force of Bolivian commandos and US drug officials while attending a family party on a ranch outside Santa Cruz. 
 He was put on a US Drug Enforcement Administration plane and whisked to Miami on Monday. 
 Held amid tight security at the federal correctional centre south of Miami, Mr Arce Gomez faces a 1983 indictment on allegations of conspiracy to distribute cocaine. 
 The present Interior Minister, Mr Guillermo Capobianco, said his predecessor &mdash; who is also wanted in Bolivia on murder charges in connection with a 1980 coup &mdash; was sent to the US despite the absence of a formal extradition treaty between the two countries. 
 Calling the deportation a sovereign act, Mr Capobianco said the move was &bquo;a demonstration before the international community&equo; of Bolivia's commitment to the war against drugs. 
 The US welcomed the co-operation of the Bolivian authorities. 
 &bquo;The arrest of Arce Gomez sends a message that the President will work with other governments to pursue vigorously individuals who traffic in drugs,&equo; said a White House statement. 
 Known in Bolivia as the &bquo;minister of cocaine&equo; after he allegedly created a paramilitary squad to confiscate cocaine from drug dealers who refused to pay him bribes, Mr Arce Gomez also has a grisly human rights reputation. 
 Human rights group say he was in charge of Bolivian death squads responsible for murdering hundreds of journalists, political and labour leaders, and church officials. 
 He is accused of hiring Barbie to advise the country's paramilitary forces on torture techniques. 
 Gorbachev wins on party role. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 GUIDING deputies with a firm hand, President Gorbachev yesterday got his way at the opening session of Congress, which duly voted against a proposal by the poet Yevgeny Yevtushenko to discuss the Communist Party's monopoly of power. 
 But the price for this success was an entire day spent on discussing the agenda for the 10-day meeting, and a debate with much friction between Baltic delegates and the Russian majority. 
 On behalf of the Inter-Regional Group of some 400 radical deputies, Mr Yevtushenko moved to include on the agenda discussion of Article 6 of the constitution, which enshrines the &bquo;leading and guiding role&equo; of the party. 
 The proposal was supported by many delegates from Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania, as well as Moldavia and reformist delegates from Russia and elsewhere. 
 They included the human rights activist, Dr Andrei Sakharov, whose efforts to call a strike in support of discussing Article 6 were sharply criticised. 
 Replying to Mr Yevtushenko, the President briskly appealed to deputies not to take &bquo;hasty decisions&equo;. 
 He had already clearly laid down his view in his opening speech to the session, in which he recognised that perestroika had so far made little impact on the acute social and economic crisis. 
 &bquo;The transition to a new economic system is proving difficult. 
 The results on which we counted have yet to come,&equo; he said. 
 That was why the Congress of People's Deputies was being recommended to give priority to the government's report on the economy. 
 People would judge it &bquo;by how it considers questions of revitalising the economy, curbing shortages and improving the life of the workers,&equo; he said. 
 The implication was clear: to discuss Article 6 would be an irresponsible aberration. 
 By 1,138 votes to 839, with 58 abstentions, the delegates agreed. 
 In the afternoon session there was an equally irritable wrangle over a proposal to adopt a law on compliance with the constitution, and to set up a committee for the purpose. 
 Deputies from the Baltic republics, some of which have passed laws denounced by Moscow's Supreme Soviet as unconstitutional, saw this as an attempt to limit their sovereignty. 
 Some described the existing &bquo;Brezhnevite&equo; constitution as outdated, and said it would be undemocratic to enforce compliance with it. 
 An Estonian history professor, Arnold Palm, said Balts regarded their status within the Soviet Union as &bquo;political, not juridical&equo;, and &bquo;by no means definitely established&equo;. 
 But representatives of the Russian minority in the Baltic accused Baltic republican government of violating the Soviet constitution. 
 Rush to find defence team after sudden arraignment Hit-squad informer faces murder trial. 
 By David Beresford in Johannesburg 
 THE man responsible for uncovering South Africa's hit-squad scandal, the condemned security branch policeman Almond Nofomela, is being brought to court tomorrow by the authorities who are seemingly intent on hurrying him on to his postponed appointment with the hangman. 
 Mr Nofomela is to appear in a Natal magistrate's court to be charged with the murder of the Durban civil rights lawyer, Griffiths Mxenge. 
 It was Mr Nofomela's confession to the killing &mdash; the day before he was due to be executed for the murder of a white farmer &mdash; which led to the disclosures that the force has been running professional death squads. 
 The civil rights organisation, Lawyers for Human Rights, was yesterday hastily making arrangements to find a defence team for Mr Nofomela. 
 A director, Mr Ahmed Motala, said they had been informed by the Attorney General's office &bquo;that no request for a postponement will be entertained&equo;. 
 So far as is known, nobody else has been arrested or charged in connection with the murder of Mr Mxenge The State President, Mr F. W. de Klerk, last week refused to order a judicial commission of inquiry into the death-squad allegations on the ground that it would be faster to use the &bquo;tried and respected prosecution mechanisms of the state&equo;. 
 He said it was crucial that the matter be settled quickly so that the police could &bquo;continue unhindered with the important tasks that lie ahead&equo;. 
 An opposition MP, Mr Jan Van Eck, yesterday accused the police of complicity in the latest fighting to break out at the Cape Town squatter camp, Crossroads. 
 Mr Van Eck said that he had recorded documentary evidence that police &mdash; some in plain clothes &mdash; had been shooting supporters of local headmen who had broken away from the committee running Crossroads, alleging fraud and corruption. 
 Five people have died in the violence, which broke out on Sunday night. 
 In townships outside Durban another three deaths were reported yesterday in continued fighting between supporters of the Zulu leader, Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi, and the United Democratic Front &mdash; bringing the weekend death toll to 21. 
 The violence appears to been started by an offensive against the UDF by Zulu warlords which began in the early hours of Saturday morning. 
 In Johannesburg two men died in overnight bomb explosions at the city's main railway station. 
 Police said they believed the men &mdash; Yusuf Akhalwaya, aged 23, a fourth-year student at the University of the Witwatersrand, and Prakash Napier, aged 24, a part-time student &mdash; were carrying landmines which exploded prematurely. 
 A Soviet-made pistol was found at the scene of the explosion and a large arms cache &mdash; including 17 mines, assault rifles and hand grenades &mdash; was later discovered at the home of the two men. 
 Another bomb blast was reported on a railway line outside Cape Town. 
 The explosions may have been linked with a particularly violent six-week strike by railway workers in which seven people have died. 
 Much of the violence has been blamed on mysterious &bquo;vigilantes&equo; who have attacked township commuters refusing to pay their fares in solidarity with the strikers. 
 President De Klerk will visit Maputo on Friday for talks with the Mozambican President, Mr Joaquim Chissano, the national news agency, AIM, said yesterday. 
 No details of the agenda were immediately available. 
 UN agency anger as first repatriates fly out. 
 By Iain Guest 
 OFFICIALS at the office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in Geneva reacted with resigned anger to the news of yesterday's forcible repatriation of 51 Vietnamese from Hong Kong. 
 The public response has been muted because of the power vacuum at the head of the agency after the resignation of Mr Jean-Pierre Hocke as High Commissioner. 
 But there is a growing fear here among diplomats and UN officials that Britain's policy &mdash; aimed at deterring any new arrivals in Hong Kong &mdash; could backfire badly. 
 By forcing the pace on compulsory repatriation, Britain could, it is feared, jeopardise the package of measures agreed here by governments in June. 
 It could also set a precedent for other governments &mdash; like Thailand and Malaysia &mdash; which have both pushed boat people back out to sea. 
 In addition, some diplomats based in Switzerland predict riots and worse in the camps of Hong Kong if more Vietnamese are sent back against their will. 
 The principal concern at the UNHCR is that Britain has not given voluntary repatriation time to work. 
 So far, 637 Vietnamese have returned voluntarily, and more than 1,000 have indicated willingness to go back. 
 This may not seem much in terms of Hong Kong's caseload of more tha 40,000 Vietnamese, but set in a historical context it is an achievement. 
 No one expected to reverse the pull of 14 years of refugee resettlement overnight, and there is little doubt that voluntary repatriation would pick up speed if the Hong Kong authorities used quiet persuasion instead of the big stick. 
 Every time the camps are invaded and Vietnamese taken out, resistance grows. 
 On October 31, 200 police in riot gear dragged 48 Vietnamese out of the camp of Chi Ma Wan, injuring several children. 
 Applications for voluntary repatriation virtually dried up. 
 The 51 Vietnamese sent back yesterday were all reviewed by the UNHCR, which is satisfied that none was a refugee. 
 So far, 3,115 Vietnamese in the colony have been refused refugee status and had appeals turned down. 
 Two hundred and forty individuals have been accepted. 
 The conference here in June agreed that voluntary repatriation should be given time to work and that only then would &bquo;alternative measures&equo; &mdash; including compulsory repatriation &mdash; be considered. 
 Governments are expected to meet again here on January 18 to review the past six months, and many, particularly the US, are expected to argue that it is far too soon to be sending Vietnamese back against their will. 
 Yesterday's action has probably ended any prospect of the UNHCR helping to monitor any compulsory repatriation to Vietnam. 
 Quiet reaction in camps masks desperation of boat people. 
 By Our Correspondent in Hong Kong 
 JAMES CLEMENTS, a jovial rotund Englishman who runs the Sek Kong detention centre for Vietnamese boat people, could barely contain his satisfaction when telling reporters that nothing out of the ordinary happened when camp inmates heard news of the first deportations from Hong Kong. 
 The Sek Kong centre, planted uncomfortably in the middle of the colony's only military airfield, has a reputation for riots, murders and wide-scale intimidation. 
 Forty policemen were drafted in &mdash; just in case &mdash; but they were not needed. 
 But an aid worker who has daily contact with camp inmates does not believe this means that the Hong Kong government has managed to persuade the Vietnamese to quietly accept their fate. 
 &bquo;You can't see anything, it's all under the surface,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;It was a big shock to all the people. 
 When they heard the news they didn't know what to.&equo; 
 Joan Summers, who runs the Save the Children Fund programmes in the camps, says she is not surprised at the lack of overt reaction. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't expect any dramatic response initially,&equo; she says. 
 She believes that protests will soon emerge. 
 Most of the Vietnamese in Hong Kong arrive in tiny boats with barely enough space to stretch out while sleeping on the decks. 
 After landing, they are given a number and expected to conform quickly to an institutional existence in conditions worse than many of Hong Kong's prisons. 
 They can forget about privacy and often fall prey to gangs operating a regime of intimidation. 
 Camp authorities are either unaware of this or turn a blind eye. 
 Hong Kong authorities believe that most boat people will acquiesce rather than violently resist attempts to send them back to Vietnam, but this apparent passivity can be deceptive. 
 Violent rioting has broken out in the camps many times in recent weeks. 
 No one can confidently say that the initial calm which has greeted the news of the deportations will not give way to a far more vigorous reaction. 
 Call made for a second EC constitutional conference Delors seeks wider parliament powers. 
 By John Palmer in Strasbourg 
 ONLY days after the European Community summit agreed to convene a conference next year to change the EC constitution and prepare for monetary union, demands were raised by EC leaders yesterday for a second such conference to extend the powers of the European Parliament even further. 
 The president of the European Commission, Mr Jacques Delors, said yesterday that, quite apart from the issues of democratic accountability raised by European economic and monetary union, the role of the European Parliament should be extended. 
 Both, he said, would require changes to the Treaty of Rome. 
 &bquo;I am a partisan of the idea of two inter-governmental conferences, one dealing with economic and monetary union and related institutional reform by the end of 1991, and another which deals with European political union, one or two years later or even at the same time,&equo; Mr Delors told MEPs in Strasbourg yesterday. 
 &bquo;I believe that if we deal with both of these subjects in one such conference we risk overloading the boat.&equo; 
 Mr Delors said that in the short run MEPs should be given greater powers to hold the EC executive responsible when national governments transferred powers to Brussels &mdash; under a new European treaty for economic and monetary union. 
 But as the Community moved towards the goal of political union the European Parliament would have to give greater co-legislating powers to the Council of Ministers. 
 The majority of EC governments support Mr Delors in using the impulse of the moves to democracy in Eastern Europe, and the overwhelming backing for EMU shown at last weekend's Strasbourg summit, to secure a bigger role for the parliament. 
 Some MEPs want ultimately to take over from the council the main responsibility for passing EC laws, while others want to concentrate on the right to appoint the European Commission. 
 However, Mr Delors's suggestion of not one but two inter-governmental conferences is also designed to prevent any unnecessary obstacle delaying the advent of supra-national economic and monetary union. 
 Mr Delors' upbeat report to MEPs on the Strasbourg summit was also reflected by the French Foreign Minister, Mr Roland Dumas, in giving his end-of-term report on the French presidency of the European Council of Ministers. 
 Although progress in passing European single market laws was painfully slow during the first months of the French presidency, Paris hands over to Dublin this month amid a last-minute rush of important agreements. 
 These have covered telecommunications liberalisation, taxation, decontrolling air fares, common financial services, and the protection of the environment. 
 In the remaining working days of this month there are hopes that the council will also agree measures to control trans-national mergers. 
 Moreover, in a clear indication of the growing influence of the European Parliament, Mr Delors assured MEPs yesterday that the commission would bring forward three important measures to improve the rights of Europe's workers. 
 They will form part of the European Social Charter, which was endorsed by the weekend summit here, and deal with working hours, rights to information and consultation, and measures to protect temporary workers. 
 Last month the European Socialist group, the largest in the European Parliament, threatened to sack the entire commission because the charter had been watered down in a vain attempt to secure Mrs Thatcher's backing for it at the Strasbourg summit. 
 Commentary, page 23 
 Baker urges EC to help shape emerging Europe. 
 THE call by the US Secretary of State, Mr James Baker, for an enhanced European Community role in the new Europe emerging from the disintegration of the Eastern Bloc was made during an address to the Berlin press club. 
 This is an edited version: The new &lsqb;European&rsqb; architecture must continue the construction of institutions &mdash; like the EC &mdash; that can help draw together the West while serving as an open door to the East. 
 The future development of the European Community will play a central role in shaping the new Europe. 
 This experiment has succeeded because it held out the goal of political as well as economic barriers overcome, of a Europe united. 
 As Europe moves towards its goal of a common internal market, and as its institutions for political and security co-operation evolve, the link between the United States and the European Community will become even more important. 
 We see no conflict between European integration and an expansion of co-operation between the European Community and its neighbours to the East and the West. 
 The European Community is already an economic pillar of the transatlantic relationship. 
 It will also take on, perhaps in concert with other European institutions, increasingly important political roles. 
 Indeed, it has already done so, as evidenced by the Community's co-ordination of the Western effort to support reform in East Europe. 
 And as it continues to do so, the link between the US and the European Community should become stronger, the issues we discuss more diversified and our common endeavours more important. 
 At the same time, the substantive overlap between Nato and the European institutions will grow. 
 This overlap must lead to synergy not friction. 
 Working together, we must design and gradually put into place a new architecture for a new era. 
 This new structure must accomplish two special purposes. 
 First, as a part of overcoming the division of Europe there must be an opportunity to overcome through peace and freedom the division of Berlin and of Germany. 
 Second, the architecture should reflect that America's security &mdash; politically, militarily and economically &mdash; remains linked to Europe's. 
 The charge for us all then is to work together toward the New Europe and the New Atlanticism. 
 We have moved significantly closer to concluding an agreement limiting conventional armaments from the Atlantic to the Urals. 
 In Malta, President Bush proposed a summit meeting to sign such an agreement in 1990. 
 Today, I further propose that the ministers of the 23 Nato and Warsaw Pact nations take advantage of our February meeting in Ottawa, where we will launch the Open Skies negotiations, to give a further push to the Vienna talks on conventional forces. 
 I invite Allied governments to consider establishing a Nato Arms Control Verification Staff. 
 Such a new staff would be able to assist member governments in monitoring compliance with arms control and confidence-building measures in Europe. 
 It could provide a clearing-house for information, contributed by national governments. 
 Regional conflicts &mdash; along with the proliferation of missiles and nuclear, chemical and biological weapons &mdash; present growing dangers. 
 Intensified Nato consultations on these issues can play an important role in forming common approaches to these threats. 
 Nato should also begin considering further initiatives, through the CSCE process in particular, to build economic and political ties with the East, to promote respect for human rights, to help build democratic institutions, and to fashion, consistent with Western security interests, a more open environment for East-West trade and investment. 
 Leipzig church calls for calm as unity movement gathers strength. 
 By Anna Tomforde in Bonn 
 CHURCHMEN and intellectuals in East Germany, worried about the new, aggressive tone that has crept into the emotional issue of reunification, yesterday warned against confrontation and called for a temporary end to mass street demonstrations. 
 Meanwhile, evidence has emerged that the West Berlin branch of Chancellor Helmut Kohl's Christian Democratic Union party (CDU) has been active in stirring pro-unity emotions in Leipzig, supplying demonstrators with West German flags and handing out stickers in the black, red, and gold of the two German flags with the slogan: &bquo;We are one people.&equo; 
 Mr Stefan Heym, the East German author, warned yesterday that the dream of a democratic revolution could turn into a nightmare. 
 At demonstrations, he had seen faces &bquo;filled with hatred&equo; which reminded him of the months preceding Hitler's rise to power in 1933. 
 Leipzig's Protestant Church leader, Mr Friedrich Magirius, called on East Germans to turn next Monday's demonstration into a silent march for the victims of Stalinism, and to suspend protests over Christmas to gain a &bquo;pause for reflection&equo;. 
 Pro-reunification protestors dominated Leipzig's Karl Marx Square on Monday, shouting down other groups who spoke out for an independent and socialist East Germany. 
 These, in turn, screamed &bquo;Nazis out&equo; in an atmosphere described by participants as explosive. 
 There can be no doubt that the momentum in favour of German unity, as one state or a confederation, has been growing in East Germany. 
 But there were also a fair number of &bquo;imported&equo; protesters, in Leipzig on Monday, including rightwing skinheads and supporters of the CDU youth wing. 
 In Bonn yesterday, the CDU's Secretary-General, Mr Volker Ruehe, dismissed suggestions that his party was interfering in East Germany. 
 &bquo;East Germans see our slogans on Western television. 
 Why shouldn't there be slogans that are mutually stimulating?&equo; 
 Only obeying orders, page 23 
 International protest fails to sway Foreign Office. 
 By Michael Simmons 
 THE government's programme of forcibly repatriating Vietnamese boat people will proceed despite the international outcry provoked by the first removal operation on Monday night. 
 Officials said in London last night that the programme would take &bquo;months, if not years&equo; to carry though. 
 It was denied that force had been used in the initial operation. 
 Foreign Office officials said uniformed men seen on television film wearing riot gear and carrying protective shields were correctional unit staff &bquo;on stand-by&equo; but they had &bquo;played no part in the evacuation&equo;. 
 &bquo;It went off pretty quietly,&equo; a spokesman said last night. 
 &bquo;What we did yesterday was a perfectly normal removal of people who are refused the right to stay. 
 It is uncomfortable for us all, but it happens all over the world, every day of the week.&equo; 
 Asked why the operation had been conducted in the middle of the night, officials said: &bquo;We wanted to avoid riots and disturbance in the camp. 
 There is a lot of aggravation and frustration there, and anyway they are understaffed.&equo; 
 It was confirmed that, under the terms of a confidential agreement with the Vietnamese, independent monitoring &bquo;arrangements&equo; will be set up in Vietnam, and the hope was expressed that the UN High Commission for Refugees will play a full part in this. 
 No such arrangement seems to be in place. 
 One official said last night: &bquo;It would be disingenuous to rely on the Vietnamese. 
 We don't have a very high regard for the regime.&equo; 
 Government concern is to develop what the Foreign Office called a mechanism to turn people round more quickly and prevent them from arriving at a destination where they were unwanted. 
 Officials said talks would be held next month to see if other methods of repatriation could be employed, but vetting procedures to determine who was and who was not a refugee prevented &bquo;international migratory chaos&equo;. 
 Concern was expressed that large numbers of would-be boat people would start paying cash to &bquo;unscrupulous people&equo; when the sailing season started in February. 
 A spokesman said last night that all the Vietnamese lifted out of Hong Kong on Monday night had been screened to determine that none was of refugee status. 
 Each had appealed against this finding, and each appeal had been turned down. 
 The Foreign Office said last night that most of the people in the camps were fishermen and farmers from the north seeking a better life. 
 &bquo;They are chasing a dream that doesn't and can't exist,&equo; a spokesman said. 
 &bquo;We hope that Monday evening's operation will act as a catalyst to get others to volunteer to go back,&equo; an official said. 
 &bquo;Otherwise, if they keep coming in at the same rate, Hong Kong will be totally swamped and will not be able to cope. 
 We want to get people back in as orderly, humane and unstressed way as possible.&equo; 
 Zhivkov's image takes a tumble. 
 By Mike Power and Denise Searle in Sofia. 
 SENIOR Bulgarian Communist Party leaders yesterday offered to resign after high-level accusations that they were closely associated with the fallen hardline leader, Mr Todor Zhivkov, and had implemented few changes since coming to power. 
 The harshest criticism came from the party ideologist, Mr Stoyan Mihailov, who was dismissed from the central committee last year following disagreements with Mr Zhivkov. 
 He told the central committee that the new party leader, Mr Petar Mladenov, and many members of the ruling politburo were little better than the old regime. 
 Mr Mladenov then offered his and the politburo's resignation and suspended proceedings. 
 The meeting was hurriedly recovened and the resignation threat withdrawn. 
 The central committee meeting was also told by the head of its history department, David Elazar, that &bquo;Todor Zhivkov lied about his prominent role in the party's history and wartime anti-fascist struggle&equo;. 
 The Communist Party newspaper, Rabotnichesko Delo, revealed that unknown sums of convertible currency had been paid to foreign publishers to produce Mr Zhivkov's books. 
 Pergamon Press, owned by Robert Maxwell, handled publishing in Britain. 
 Sofia Press Agency, the state publishers, has paid Mr Zhivkov 190,000 levs (about &pound;150,000) since 1980. 
 His two most recent books on Bulgaria's political and economic restructuring netted him 42,000 levs, which is a 14-year salary for an average Bulgarian. 
 Mr Zhivkov's 44-volume collected works has disappeared from Sofia's bookshops since he was removed. 
 Sofia's International Peace Foundation, named after Mr Zhivkov's late daughter, is being investigated following allegations by a central committee member that it was used to send convertible currency abroad for the family's use. 
 Opposition groups are preparing to take on the Communist Party in Bulgaria's first free elections for more than 40 years which are to be fixed by next May, but dissident leaders have called for a postponement. 
 &bquo;We want these elections, but we must have equal access to the media, and time to organise,&equo; said Dr Petar Dertliev of the newly reformed Social Democratic Party. 
 &bquo;The Communist Party still controls everything and a quick election will not be truly free.&equo; 
 Ecoglasnost, the dissident environmental movement, is considering running independent &bquo;green&equo; candidates if the elections are pushed through. 
 Peruvian officers jailed for killings. 
 By Mike Reid in Lima 
 TWO police officers are to go to jail for their part in the massacre of guerrilla prisoners in a Lima prison in June, 1986. 
 Another 76 other police and troops, including an army general, were absolved by the military court after a 15-week trial. 
 The charges focused on events at Lurigancho prison, where 124 inmates died &mdash; 89 of them shot in the head &mdash; after they had surrendered, according to an investigation by Peru's Congress. 
 The massacre occurred at night after President Alan Garcia ordered the security forces to put down a co-ordinated rebellion in three jails by prisoners associated with the Maoist guerrilla movement, Sendero Luminoso, on the eve of a Socialist International congress here. 
 Mr Garcia, who accepted that &bquo;excesses&equo; had been committed, said of those reponsible: &bquo;Either they all go or I go.&equo; 
 The case, however, moved to trial only after Mr Garcia himself proposed the use of military courts against guerrilla suspects, because of their alleged greater efficiency. 
 The court sentenced Colonel Rolando Cabezas of the Republican Guard police to 15 years for murder, while Lieutenant Javier Marquina got seven years. 
 Both men plan to appeal. 
 The court also absolved General Jorge Rabanal, who led the operation, on the grounds that from his post he could not see the slaughter of the prisoners. 
 Many other defendents were released for &bquo;lack of proof&equo;. 
 Witnesses at the trial described how Col Cabezas had urged his men to kill the unarmed prisoners. 
 A minority report, signed in 1987 by opposition members, accused President Garcia and his cabinet of choosing to stage a &bquo;violent reprisal&equo; against the prisoners. 
 A total of 49 people are reported to have been killed by the Maoist Sendero Luminoso in attacks on villages in the central Andes. 
 Many of the dead were said to be members of anti-guerrilla vigilante self-defence organisations. 
 US army plan to reduce European forces by half. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 SPURRED on by the prospect of imminent defence cuts, the US Army has drawn up plans for cutting its forces in Europe by half, and recasting the army of the future into a rapid-deployment force, able to intervene in Third World trouble spots, in terrorist situations and to fight the war on drugs. 
 Under the title Strategic Force for the 1990s and beyond, and drawn up by army chief of staff General Carl Vuono, the plan calls for an entire army corps to be withdrawn from Europe, and for the US Army to be cut from 764,000 men to 630,000. 
 One of a great flurry of plans being prepared in the Pentagon as the politicians on Capitol Hill sharpen their knives to carve the &bquo;peace dividend&equo; from the budget, the plan will arouse great controversy, since it invades the functional territory of the US Marine Corps. 
 The plan was leaked to the New York Times yesterday, in time for the strategy hearings of the Senate Armed Services Committee, and the hearings on possible defence cuts before the Senate Budget Committee. 
 Mr Paul Wolfowitz, under-secretary for defence policy, warned against trying to cash in the potential defence savings too early, by bringing home the troops and scaling down the armed forces before the situation in Europe had stabilised to the point where a sensible long-term policy could be drafted. 
 &bquo;The magnitude of the changes we are seeing introduces a fundamental unpredictability on to the situation in Europe. 
 Paradoxically, these momentous changes in the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe open up great uncertainties, along with great possibilities,&equo; Mr Wolfowitz argued. 
 The army plan envisages a corps of about 150,000 US troops remaining in Europe. 
 They would be a classic mix of tanks and infantry and artillery, capable of fighting a conventional war on the traditional Nato-Warsaw Pact frontier. 
 But back in the US, the army would be transformed into three different groups. 
 There would be special forces, based on the current Ranger Battalions and Green Berets, trained to rescue hostages and conduct counter-terrorist operations. 
 The second unit would be based around the XVIII Airborne Corps, and include a division of paratroops, an air cavalry division equipped with helicopters, light infantry divisions and a mechanised division equipped with tanks and mobile artillery, and all available for rapid deployment. 
 The third unit of the future army would be the traditional armoured and mechanised infantry divisions, available to reinforce a European front, or fight an all-out conventional war elsewhere. 
 Mr Wolfowitz faced a difficult panel yesterday. 
 The committee chairman, Senator Sam Nunn, was clearly furious at a report in this week's Washington Post that showed the Pentagon and White House sitting on intelligence reports showing cut-backs in Soviet defence spending, even while the Senate was being assured that the Soviet defence budget was still growing and the US had to match it. 
 Japan split on plutonium imports. 
 By Kevin Sullivan in Tokyo 
 JAPAN's ruling party is deeply divided over a proposal to use armed naval escorts to guard shipments of plutonium from terrorist attack. 
 Japan's post-war constitution forbids the use of its navy outside territorial waters, but there are concerns to safeguard the imports of plutonium, which are intended to deal with Japan's approaching energy crisis. 
 The ruling Liberal Democratic Party's National Defence Committee is split over whether to use the navy, or to spend 15 billion yen (&pound;68 million) on a new vessel for the coastguard to escort the ships. 
 The coastguard is designated a non-military organisation under the constitution, and its use as an escort would therefore not be as controversial. 
 Japan's Atomic Energy Commission had planned to begin the shipments of imported plutonium from Europe from the autumn of 1992. 
 Japan does not have the facilities to produce as much plutonium as it needs and plans to import 153 tonnes of the highly volatile material from Britain and France between 1992 and 2000. 
 Japan, which has no fossil fuel reserves of its own, wants to stockpile plutonium because it believes that it can develop the technology to transform it into plentiful and cheap electricity. 
 About 140 rightwing members of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party believe that the Maritime Self-Defence Force, the Japanese navy, should accompany the shipments of plutonium. 
 They insist that because the warships would be protecting Japanese property, they would not be contravening clauses in the post-war constitution which forbid the use of armed forces outside territorial waters. 
 However, their opponents warn that other Asian countries are bound to protest if the Japanese navy once again takes to the high seas, whatever its reasons. 
 The Prime Minister, Mr Toshiki Kaifu, favours the construction of a 6,000-tonne coastguard armed patrol vessel, specifically for protecting plutonium shipments. 
 The coastguard or Maritime Safety Agency, is designated a non-military force, and its use would circumvent the constitutional stipulation against foreign military operations. 
 However, the navy and many MPs are likely to oppose Mr Kaifu's plan, currently the government's official position, when next year's budget comes before parliament on the grounds that it is too expensive. 
 Japan currently sends irradiated uranium imported from the US to Sellafield in Britain and Le Havre in France for processing into plutonium. 
 The US, as the country of origin for the uranium, had originally insisted that shipments be made by air, but the Japanese do not have containers which would withstand impact in the event of a crash. 
 Washington then agreed to allow transport by sea. 
 A spokesman for the opposition Socialist Party contended that transportation of plutonium was dangerous, whether by air or by sea and in itself. 
 He claimed that importing plutonium contravened Japan's non-nuclear constitution. 
 &bquo;Making plutonium is not 100 per cent safe,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;There have been nuclear accidents in Japan before and there could be accidents again if the government persists in using this technology.&equo; 
 Leaders call for rebels to disband. 
 By Scott Wallace in San Jose, Costa Rica 
 THE five presidents of Central America kept the beleaguered regional peace process alive yesterday with an agreement that bolstered the governments of Nicaragua and El Salvador by calling for the demobilisation of rebel forces in both countries. 
 &bquo;Everybody is a winner here,&equo; the Nicaraguan government adviser, Mr Paul Reichler, told reporters. 
 &bquo;Nicaragua is certainly very pleased with the progress made towards demobilisation &lsqb;of the contras&rsqb;&hellip; and I think the government of El Salvador is very pleased.&equo; 
 The presidents agreed on a number of points relating to the 10-year-old civil war in El Salvador and the sanctuary given to Nicaraguan contra rebels in Honduras. 
 The meeting called for the immediate demobilisation of the contras and urged that funds approved for the Nicaraguan rebels be channelled through a commission they had established earlier. 
 The appeal appears to be aimed at preventing further American &bquo;humanitarian aid&equo; to the contras. 
 The presidents of Guatemala, Honduras, Costa Rica, and Nicaragua expressed their &bquo;decided support&equo; for El Salvador's President Alfredo Cristiani and issued an &bquo;urgent call&equo; to the leftwing rebels of the Farabundo Marti National Liberation Front (FMLN) to cease hostilities and return to the bargaining table. 
 The FMLN should &bquo;publicly renounce all violent action that directly or indirectly affects the civilian population&equo;, the accord said. 
 The agreement &mdash; which condemned terrorism and the use of violence to achieve political ends &mdash; was seen as crucial to the peace process. 
 But observers were sceptical about the prospects of an end to rebel military activity in El Salvador and the call for a larger United Nations role in verifying compliance with the accord and aiding in the disarming of rebel forces. 
 The agreement called on El Salvador and Nicaragua to renew contact aimed at re-establishing diplomatic relations, suspended by Mr Cristiani last month amid allegations that Nicaragua had sent surface-to-air missiles to the FMLN guerrillas. 
 Diplomats said the agreement has strengthened the Cristiani government in El Salvador at a time when it was besieged by a rebel offensive and extreme rightwing elements within the armed forces and the ruling Nationalist Republican Alliance party. 
 Mr Cristiani appears to have succeeded in isolating the FMLN, but it is unclear whether the agreement will have any impact on the guerrillas' military activity. 
 The rebels have vowed to keep up the pressure on Mr Cristiani until his government agrees to negotiation that would lead to full guarantees for human rights and civil liberties, as well as the dismissal of several high-ranking army officers. 
 The government has set demobilisation of the guerrillas as a condition for reforms. 
 The meeting dragged into the early hours of yesterday morning as the Honduran President, Mr Jose Azcona, stormed out of the session after Nicaragua's President Daniel Ortega refused to withdraw his suit to the International Court of Justice in The Hague over the continuing presence of contras in Honduras. 
 Salvadorean guerrillas yesterday rejected the agreement. 
 &bquo;We indignantly reject the declaration by the presidents because, contrary to the international trend and the demands of democratic, social and religious forces inside the country, it unconditionally supports the main violator of human rights in the region,&equo; the rebel FMLN said in a statement, referring to the government. 
 Children &bquo;die as money goes on debt and arms&equo;. 
 By Our Foreign Staff 
 THIRD World governments are allocating half their total spending to armaments and debt servicing, at a cost of nearly &dollar;1 billion or &dollar;400 for every family, according to Unicef's annual report, The State of the World's Children, published yesterday. 
 At the same time, the report says, about 40,000 children are dying each day &mdash; nearly one every two seconds. 
 Of these, nearly 8,000 children die because they have not been immunised, nearly 7,000 from dehydration caused by diarrhoea, and nearly as many again from pneumonia. 
 &bquo;Death and suffering on this scale,&equo; says Mr James Grant, executive director of the UN Children's Fund, &bquo;is simply no longer necessary.&equo; 
 In his annual report, he states that the cost of immunising these children and providing the medicines necessary to treat the dehydration and pneumonia would be about &dollar;2.5 billion. 
 &bquo;It is a great deal of money,&equo; he adds. 
 &bquo;It is as much as the Soviet Union has been spending on vodka, as much as US companies have been spending on advertising cigarettes, or 10 per cent of the EC's annual subsidy to its farmers.&equo; 
 The report notes that if present trends continue, more than 100 million children will die needlessly in the next 10 years. 
 &bquo;Assuming some progress in resolving the debt crisis,&equo; Mr Grant says, &bquo;then even a 5 per cent or a 10 per cent diversion of military spending could provide the additional &dollar;50 billion or so each year which is needed to end absolute poverty on the planet within the next 10 years.&equo; 
 Unicef argues that only high-level political commitment can put low-cost solutions into practice on the scale that is needed. 
 To this end, it is calling a World Summit for Children to be held at the UN in New York next September, bringing together heads of state for the first time to discuss an important social issue. 
 Mr Grant adds: &bquo;It is time that the needs of children were given this kind of priority. 
 &bquo;Protecting the physical and mental development of children is the most important of all investments in the social and economic development of our societies.&equo; 
 The State of the World's Children, 1990, is published by OUP, price &pound;3.50p. 
 Colony spends &dollar;1,000 to send back each Vietnamese Thailand may start own deportations. 
 By Stephen Vines in Hong Kong 
 THAILAND may soon follow Hong Kong's example in deporting Vietnamese boat people not considered to be genuine refugees, reports reaching here suggest. 
 Diplomatic sources say that other South-east Asian countries which, like Hong Kong, have offered a port of first asylum to the fleeing Vietnamese, are closely watching the mandatory repatriation programme. 
 Thailand is keen to follow Hong Kong, but has reservations about the sums of money being paid for the resettlement of the boat people. 
 Yesterday, the Hong Kong Government confirmed that it was spending about &dollar;1,000 per head for those deported. 
 The cost will be shared equally between Britain and Hong Kong. 
 This sum includes transport to Vietnam and a &bquo;reintegration assistance package&equo; of &dollar;620 paid to the boat people once they are back in Vietnam. 
 Each adult in the group of 51 who were sent back yesterday was given &dollar;30 pocket money, and each child &dollar;15. 
 The deportations drew a strong protest from Mr Robert Van Leuween, the head of the United Nations High Commission for Refugees office in Hong Kong. 
 He said that he had been given no information about the departure and even late yesterday, had been unable to reach government officials responsible for refugee matters. 
 Mr Van Leuween described the deportations as premature and argued that more time should have been given to establish whether the voluntary repatriation programme was working. 
 He said that the deportations could jeopardise international negotiations aimed at finding a long-term solution to the boat people problem. 
 However, Sir David Wilson, the Governor of Hong Kong, yesterday accused the critics of the mandatory repatriation policy of failing to &bquo;put forward practical alternatives&equo;. 
 He said the deportations had been carried out only &bquo;after a great deal of heart-searching&equo;. 
 The government had concluded &bquo;that it is quite wrong that we should build up artificial hopes&equo; by allowing boat people to remain in the colony in the belief that they would be resettled. 
 China has welcomed the British action. 
 The Vice-Foreign Minister, Mr Zhou Nan, told Hong Kong reporters that China wanted the Vietnamese problem solved by 1997 when it resumes sovereignty. 
 He said that mandatory repatriation would help to achieve this. 
 Members of the colony's legislature welcome the deportations, supporting any policy which will help reduce the Vietnamese population. 
 A rare voice of dissent came from the leading liberal legislator, Mr Martin Lee, who argued that the deportations would give Hong Kong a bad name. 
 A small group of Christians also expressed their opposition by demonstrating outside the government's headquarters. 
 The Hong Kong Government emphasises that its deportation policy for the Vietnamese is no different from its policy of sending illegal Chinese immigrants back across the border. 
 Some 60 to 100 Chinese are sent home every day. 
 The Chinese, many of whom have friends in Hong Kong, do not have the opportunity to prove they are genuine refugees by taking part in a screening process. 
 The contrast in treatment between the Vietnamese and Chinese helps to explain the depth of bad feeling towards the boat people. 
 Details of the operation to remove the boat people are now emerging. 
 It is understood that unarmed policemen accompanied the returning Vietnamese, and that two very senior government officials were on the plane when it landed in the Vietnamese capital, Hanoi. 
 Now that the first batch of boat people has successfully been dispatched, the government intends to move swiftly to step up the deportations. 
 Leader comment, page 22 
 ERM outlook for Britain brightens. 
 By Alex Brummer Financial Editor 
 THE prospects for British membership of the Exchange Rate Mechanism (ERM) appeared to improve yesterday when the French government announced it would abolish exchange controls on January 1, clearing away one of the key obstacles Mrs Thatcher has cited in her opposition to entry. 
 However, Mrs Thatcher showed little sign, in comments to the House of Commons, of relenting over early participation in ERM. 
 She told MPs: &bquo;Stage one will not be completed until 1993,&equo; leaving open the possibility that Britain could stay out until after the next election. 
 Government sources said, however, that in the end it was the conditions which would eventually determine timing of British participation. 
 Aside from abolition of exchange controls by the other major economies, the Government insists that Britain's inflation rate be brought more in line with that of her trading partners, before Britain takes the ERM plunge. 
 As a result of recent mortgage rate rises, inflation in November could be as high as 8 per cent, compared with 3.2 per cent in West Germany. 
 Mrs Thatcher's reticence in the Commons contrasted with her more favourable tone toward the ERM in an interview with the Financial Times, in which she hinted at entry before the next election. 
 It was a development which boosted the value of the pound on the foreign exchanges, particularly against the US dollar. 
 The New York foreign exchanges took Mrs Thatcher's remarks as a sign that the deep-seated split in her government over Britain's role in the EMS is healing and that the challenge to her leadership on this issue may be over. 
 The pound climbed strongly against the dollar, jumping nearly three cents to &dollar;1.61 in New York trading, but in Europe it fell back almost three pfennigs against the Deutschmark after an initial boost from ERM speculation. 
 The French finance minister, Mr Pierre Beregovoy, had sent a flutter of excitement through the international financial markets when he announced at mid-morning that all remaining exchange controls would be swept away. 
 Abolition of exchange controls is a key facet of European Monetary Union and all the leading economies are obliged to remove them by next July. 
 Although France abolished controls over capital movements in March, it had left in place controls which among other things prevented French residents from holding foreign currency accounts in, for example, sterling or dollars. 
 Mr Beregovoy said that the French government's decision showed &bquo;our desire to accelerate economic and monetary union&equo;. 
 Mrs Thatcher was apparently informed of the French decision during the Strasbourg session on monetary union last weekend and it may well have encouraged her to believe that Britain's European partners are now ready to take the difficult decisions which are a prelude to monetary union. 
 Of the leading economies within the Exchange Rate Mechanism, only Italy still has exchange controls in place. 
 Some of those close to the Prime Minister have argued that if the artificial barrier posed by exchange controls were removed, the French franc and Italian lira would be forced to face the reality of the free market. 
 There was little indication from the reaction of the French franc yesterday that market forces were about to unleash fresh instability on ERM. 
 The main factor in yesterday's currency trading was less the French decision to remove controls and more the underlying strength of the DM. 
 The West German currency continues on its upward path, in expectation of tightening of credit conditions by the Bundesbank early next year, and the buoyant prospects for the domestic economy. 
 The rush towards economic, if not political, integration for the two Germanys has led economists substantially to upgrade growth prospects for an even more prosperous Germany. 
 This has to some extent demonstrated the pivotal role the DM will play even in an enlarged ERM which includes sterling. 
 Politics, page 6; City Notebook, page 13 
 Government rift over 999 dispute *. 
 By Alan Travis and Political Correspondent Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 THE first split in the Government's ranks over the ambulance workers dispute appeared last night when it was disclosed that Mr David Trippier, the Environment Minister, had written to the Health Secretary saying he could see the logic in the ambulance workers' case. 
 Mr Trippier, who was said to be expressing the views of his constituents, wrote to Mr Kenneth Clarke on November 24 asking him to look again at the original 6.5 per cent pay offer, saying it was not fair. 
 He refused to publish the letter. 
 Hopes of a settlement at tomorrow's peace talks were dispelled yesterday when Mr David Rennie, chairman of the management side of the Whitley Council pay bargaining forum, ruled out any chance of a fresh offer to the ambulance unions. 
 Mr Roger Poole, chief union negotiator, accused Mr Clarke, of sabotaging the talks after the statement made it clear that the 9 per cent 18 month offer would not be improved. 
 It was stressed last night that Mr Trippier, once Mr Clarke's parliamentary private secretary, was unaware that a 9 per cent &bquo;final offer&equo; had been made a week before his letter. 
 Mr Clarke, speaking on ITN's News At Ten last night, tried to limit the damage from the disclosure, saying: &bquo;All ministers, including David Trippier, agree with me that it cannot be right that National Health Service pay can be determined by industrial action of this kind taken by militant trade unions. 
 &bquo;I do not accept that David Trippier is supporting the action of the trade unions, or is asking me to go to arbitration, or expects that the management, having made a final offer, should move from that final offer.&equo; 
 But the disclosure is nevertheless damaging to the Government as the lock out of ambulance workers continues towards Christmas. 
 Mr Robin Cook, the shadow Health Secretary, said the letter showed the Government could not defend the position. 
 &bquo;David Trippier has dissented from the Government's position,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Maybe he should consider his position.&equo; 
 Talks aimed at settling the baggage handlers strike over work rosters, which has shut down Manchester Airport to passenger flights for two days, ended last night with a deal in sight. 
 The airport was set to remain closed today as talks continued, but a spokesman said the management was &bquo;fairly hopeful&equo; of a successful outcome. 
 Ministers face criticism on Barlow Clowes *. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 THE Ombudsman's report on the Barlow Clowes affair in which 18,000 investors lost &pound;100 million is expected to be highly critical of ministers' role in the affair. 
 It is likely to be submitted to the Commons before the Christmas recess begins next week. 
 The Ombudsman, Sir Anthony Barrowclough, is telling MPs that the report is being finalised, though an early draft is believed to recommend that not all the investors should be compensated for the losses they suffered when the investment group crashed 18 months ago. 
 It is believed that the report will criticise successive corporate affairs ministers at the department of Trade and Industry, despite a claim last year by Lord Young, the former Trade and Industry Secretary, that an internal investigation concluded his department could not be held responsible, and could even throw the spotlight on the role of Lord Young. 
 The case turns on whether the department was legally responsible for supervising the group's unauthorised offshore arm, Barlow Clowes International, where most of the losses were incurred. 
 Some 11,000 investors had money in the offshore fund. 
 The report &mdash; which has taken more than a year to prepare in one of the most complex inquiries undertaken by Sir Anthony's office &mdash; will address the question of when the department first became negligent if it is shown to have been aware of the possible difficulties. 
 The report will also examine the department's decision to license Barlow Clowes's United Kingdom fund. 
 The report has been with the department's accountants for more than three weeks as they check its factual accuracy. 
 The exercise has enabled the officials involved in the original decisions to respond to the findings. 
 The Government will publish its response when the report is released. 
 Sir Anthony wrote yesterday to Mr Alf Morris, Labour MP for Manchester, Wythenshawe, two of whose constituents were the subject of a test case. 
 The couple, in their mid-70s, lost their life savings of &pound;65,000 and had to sell their home. 
 Mr Morris said: &bquo;Many of the investors in Barlow Clowes were elderly people and some 500 have died since they lost their money. 
 &bquo;If the Ombudsman's report recommends that compensation should be paid, the Government should act urgently and honour it.&equo; 
 Business rate &bquo;will add 1pc to prices&equo;. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 THE &pound;8 billion national business rate will add 1 per cent to the retail price index and provoke political protests, Mr John Banham, the Confederation of British Industry director, predicted yesterday. 
 The full impact will become apparent early next month when the Inland Revenue publishes the results of its first revaluation of commercial rateable values for 15 years. 
 Mr Banham warned an Association of Metropolitan Authorities conference in London yesterday: &bquo;There may well be half a million furious business people, either with severely disappointed expectations because they expected to see their rate bills cut by half, or facing a succession of real increases of 20 per cent in their annual rates bills. 
 &bquo;What seems now a cloud no bigger than a man's hand could turn out to be yet another inflationary and political storm for a government that could do without either.&equo; 
 The introduction of a national business rate from April 1 is part of the Government's changes in local government finance which include the poll tax. 
 The rate will be fixed by Whitehall rather than local authorities. 
 Mr Banham accused Conservative MPs of failing to wake up to the issue, and of being &bquo;intellectually absent by command of the whips. 
 It was safe to assume, he said, that no more than a dozen MPs knew whether they should be reaching for the champagne or the shotgun when the Government announced last month that the business rate was to be set at 36p in the pound last month. 
 Mr David Hunt, the Local Government Minister, tried this week to blunt some of the anger in the business world by announcing a small concession in arrangements to ease the rate's introduction. 
 According to Inland Revenue estimates for England some 500,000 businesses, mainly in the South and West, will see their rates bills rise by 20 per cent in real terms for at least the next two years. 
 Nearly 200,000 of them will face such rises for at least five years. 
 Some 100,000 businesses, mainly in the North and the Midlands, which were expecting their rate bills to fall by at least 50 per cent, will see no significant change, said Mr Banham. 
 His stance was supported yesterday by the British Chambers of Commerce, which demanded that the Treasury rather than businesses in the North and Midlands should finance the three-year safety net to cushion the rate's impact in the South. 
 Mr Bryan Gould, the shadow Environment Secretary, predicted that the &bquo;nationalisation of the business rate&equo; would mean that businesses would not be interested in keeping local poll tax bills down, but would instead lobby hard for as much poll tax money to be spent on local services for them. 
 He said: &bquo;We can therefore expect, on government logic, local Conservative Associations to be taken over by business ratepayers bent on winning control of councils to promote spending on services and goods they either supply or would benefit them. 
 &bquo;Housing, education and social services would obviously take a back seat.&equo; 
 News in brief: French to drop exchange control. 
 The French smoothed Britain's way to accepting the Exchange Rate Mechanism by announcing the dropping of exchange controls. 
 Page 24. 
 Tapping the market. 
 More than 2.7 million water investors made a paper profit of nearly &pound;400. 
 Page 13. 
 Grains of truth. 
 The Government and its chief medical officer disagreed over whether sugar is unhealthy. 
 Page 4. 
 Price of change. 
 April's introduction of a new business rate could add 1 per cent to inflation, the CBI said. 
 Page 5. 
 Deaths plea. 
 Forty thousand children are dying needlessly every day in the Third World and should be saved by international efforts, says Unicef. 
 Page 10. 
 Ambulance hopes fade. 
 Hopes of tomorrow's talks on the ambulance dispute producing a settlement before Christmas faded when the management side ruled out any new offer. 
 Page 3 
 Twelve held in crack raids. 
 Police, accompanied by community leaders, made 12 arrests yesterday after a three-week undercover operation in Notting Hill, west London, following complaints about an increase in gangs supplying the cocaine-based drug crack. 
 Prisoners escape. 
 Two prisoners escaped over the wall of Oxford prison last night by tying clothes together.Police warned against approaching Richard Sean Hyland, 26, from Kentish Town, London, who was serving four years for armed robbery. 
 His accomplice was Steven Patrick Raymond, 44, from Highbury, London. 
 Drink-drive probation. 
 Jeremy Smith, 26, unemployed, of Leicester, was put on probation yesterday and banned from driving for 30 years after being convicted of his eighth drink-driving offence.. 
 CND leader jailed. 
 Mr Robert Cole, a CND vice-chairman, was jailed for 14 days at Blaenau Ffestiniog, Gwynned, for refusing to pay a &pound;150 fine imposed after he chained himself to a container of nuclear waste last August.. 
 NUM loses appeal. 
 In the Court of Appeal yesterday the National Union of Mineworkers failed to overturn an injunction granted to its South Wales area in May, banning the union from issuing ballot papers for an election for a new national vice-president because of an &bquo;unlawful&equo; ruling by Mr Arthur Scargill. 
 Statue wins reprieve. 
 The Government yesterday extended by three months an export ban on Canova's marble statue The Three Graces, to give time to raise &pound;7.6 million to prevent it going to the Getty Museum in California.. 
 Habitat overcharged. 
 The Habitat store chain was yesterday fined &pound;8,800 at Basingstoke for overcharging. 
 In January Habitat was fined &pound;3,600 for similar offences in Croydon, south London. 
 Flowers but no remedy at Clapham a year on. 
 By Owen Bowcott 
 EXACTLY a year to the day after the Clapham rail disaster, the 6.20am Wessex Electrics express from Poole drew into Waterloo station without a two-way radio in the driver's cab. 
 Jumping down at the end of his journey, the driver admitted: &bquo;I still haven't got a phone. 
 I have to use one by the side of the rails.&equo; 
 The driver of the same express was killed a year earlier when his locomotive careered into the rear of a stationary train from Basingstoke which had stopped to report a signals fault. 
 &bquo;The only thing I'm worried about is getting up in the morning,&equo; said yesterday's driver, who asked not to be named. 
 His guard, Mr Robert Woodford, aged 23, explained: &bquo;We don't talk about the crash a great deal.&equo; 
 Installing direct communications between drivers and signalmen was one of the recommendations of the report by Sir Anthony Hidden QC into the crash on December 12 1988, which killed 35 people. 
 On board the same early morning express yesterday from Poole &mdash; via Bournemouth, Southampton and Basingstoke &mdash; few passengers marked the anniversary of the disaster. 
 In a buffet car a group of five regular commuters toasted the memory of absent friends with glasses of champagne while they tucked into quails' eggs. 
 &bquo;We are toasting missing colleagues who were with us in the buffet and who would have preferred us to do it this way, instead of being sombre,&equo; said Mr Christopher Reeves, a consultant engineer who joined the train at Southampton Parkway station. 
 &bquo;Whenever the train brakes hard nowadays it shakes you up. 
 You do sweat a bit.&equo; 
 His companion, Mr David Gilks, aged 41, who works in an insurance company, added: &bquo;This is how our friends would have liked us to remember them, rather than being stone-faced around a memorial.&equo; 
 Mr Gilks was in the buffet car when the crash occurred. 
 He was knocked unconscious. 
 When he came round he saw the side of the train had been ripped open. 
 He clambered out and was taken to hospital suffering from cuts and bruises. 
 At Poole the contingent of reporters, sent out to jog the nation's memory into reliving the disaster, outnumbered legitimate travellers by nearly four to one. 
 In the darkened carriages most commuters, snatching another hour's sleep before dawn or reading newspapers, seemed unaware of the anniversary. 
 &bquo;I think a lot of those people who remember most strongly are not turning up today,&equo; said an accountant from Poole. 
 &bquo;Most people who use the train regularly know everyone who gets on at the first few stops. 
 There are some regulars missing.&equo; 
 At Southampton a man in a pin-striped suit said he would prefer not to talk about the crash. 
 By then the tireless extroverts had gravitated to the buffet cars and were cracking jokes. 
 The train did not slow at the scene of the accident. 
 On the embankment up which rescuers had carried survivors, a small group had gathered to pay their respects. 
 Wreaths were laid at the base of a marble memorial. 
 Among those present was Mr Gordon Pettit, general manager for Southern Region. 
 He placed a wreath of yellow and white carnations with the message: &bquo;With deepest sympathy, from all those who work in British Rail Southern Region.&equo; 
 Two ambulancemen, Mr Alan Woods and Mr Rob Lloyd of Putney Ambulance Station, who were among the first to arrive at the scene of the disaster a year ago, watched the morning trains speed by. 
 Mr Woods said: &bquo;It all comes flooding back. 
 We were the second crew on the scene and we did not leave the crash site all day.&equo; 
 Ten minutes late, the overcrowded 6.20am express rumbled past Clapham Junction. 
 By that stage, passengers were already standing. 
 Later British Rail explained that the programme to fit radio telephones in all drivers' cabs was to be completed in January 1993. 
 It may be speeded up, a spokesman added. 
 MPs vote 3-1 to support war crime prosecutions. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 MPS LAST night voted by an overwhelming majority to support moves to allow the prosecution of alleged Nazi war criminals living in Britain. 
 The 348 to 123 vote, a majority of 225, is likely to provide irresistible pressure on the Cabinet when it decides within the next few weeks whether to press ahead with the necessary legislative changes. 
 It is possible that an enabling bill will be brought before Parliament next year, and the first trial could be within a year. 
 Such a decision would bring Britain in line with America, Canada, and Australia. 
 The prospects of cabinet endorsement of the change were enhanced by the personal backing of the Home Secretary, Mr David Waddington, and the support of the Prime Minister. 
 Cabinet members voted nine to three in favour of allowing prosecutions to proceed, with 10 not voting. 
 Sir Bernard Braine, the Father of the House, who moved last night's proposal, said after the vote: &bquo;It was a startling majority. 
 We are very pleased. 
 &bquo;The Hetherington report said we should get moving quickly. 
 Now we must. 
 The majority of people in this country have no idea of the awfulness of what was done.&equo; 
 The emotional three-hour debate centred on whether to allow prosecution in this country of people who are now British citizens for acts of murder and manslaughter, or culpable homicide, committed as war crimes in Germany and German-occupied territory during the second world war. 
 MPs were given a free vote. 
 Their decision was in sharp contrast to last week's discussion in the Lords, where opinion fell heavily against proceeding against alleged war criminals. 
 This month's parliamentary debates follow the report of the war crimes inquiry, headed by the former Director of Public Prosecutions, Sir Thomas Hetherington, which followed up 301 allegations. 
 It was set up after a three-year campaign by an all-party war crimes group. 
 The report investigated seven cases in detail, and in four of them said there was sufficient evidence to mount a prosecution. 
 It said 122 other cases deserved further investigation. 
 An unpublished appendix to the report details allegations of the mass murder of Jews in the Baltic states, Byelorussia, and the Ukraine during the war by the Nazis and their collaborators. 
 The Home Secretary stressed last night that the Government had not yet decided whether to bring forward legislation, but he said he did not believe the Hetherington report could just be interred. 
 &bquo;Sometimes one is brought face to face with facts which cannot be buried. 
 The terrible stories revealed in its pages, the evidence of foul deeds which is presented, cannot just be put aside or ignored.&equo; 
 But as in last week's debate in the House of Lords concern was expressed about retrospective legislation and the practical difficulties of prosecuting alleged war criminals. 
 The former Prime Minister, Mr Edward Heath, opposed changing the law on these grounds, arguing that the main figures had been dealt with at Nuremberg. 
 &bquo;There has been enormous pressure on this, and it has all come from California. 
 We know all about that,&equo; said Mr Heath, referring to the headquarters of the Simon Wiesenthal Centre, which has collected evidence of Nazi war criminals. 
 Politics, page 6 
 Chief medical officer disputes government statement Sugar report sparks clash on health risk. 
 By James Erlichman, Consumer Affairs Correspondent 
 THE Government and its chief medical officer clashed yesterday over the dangers of sugar. 
 Baroness Hooper, the Government's junior health spokeswoman, put her name to a press release which effectively said people could eat sugar without worry. 
 The press release accompanied a report on Dietary Sugars and Human Disease, which took a government-appointed panel of experts more than two years to prepare. 
 But Sir Donald Acheson, the Government's chief medical officer, highlighted paragraphs of the report which link sugar consumption with obesity, diabetes, high blood pressure, heart disease, and gallstones. 
 Sir Donald intervened after journalists at a Department of Health press conference questioned the veracity of remarks attributed to Baroness Hooper. 
 She said the report, from the Committee on the Medical Aspects of Food Policy (Coma), &bquo;does not support the view, as some people would have us believe, that sugars, at usual intake, have a direct adverse effect on general health.&equo; 
 But Sir Donald said the report's advice was unequivocal. 
 &bquo;Everyone should restrict sugar intake generally,&equo; he said. 
 The advice was not restricted to the prevention of tooth decay. 
 He described the &bquo;indirect link&equo; between sugar and a number of serious diseases and drew specific attention to the report's conclusion that sugar may contribute to excess food consumption and obesity. 
 Obesity, in turn, plays an important part in the development of a number of diseases, including diabetes, raised blood pressure, hyperlipidaemia (raised cholesterol), and arterial disease (disease of the heart and arteries) and gallstones, the report said. 
 Professor Harry Keen, the chairman of the Coma report, concurred with Sir Donald's assessment. 
 It would be &bquo;almost mischievous&equo; to blame sugar directly for causing heart disease, but it has a &bquo;seductive quality&equo; without offering any nutrients other than calories. 
 &bquo;If people are trying to reduce weight gain, especially because obesity affects blood fats and they want to protect their coronary arteries, then reducing sugar would be a good idea,&equo; he said. 
 The sugar industry has campaigned to separate sugar from medical conditions other than tooth decay, and has suggested that natural sugars, carbohydrates and frequency of consumption are more important to cavities than sugar itself. 
 The industry contributes widely to academic research. 
 Professor Keen denied yesterday that natural sugars were a significant cause of tooth decay. 
 Added sugar was the prime cause and levels of tooth decay, which had fallen from bad to mediocre, could not fall further until people, and especially children, cut back more on sugar, he said. 
 The British are among the biggest sugar consumers in the developed world, eating around 100grams or 4oz a day. 
 Consumption is not falling because cutbacks in the home have been offset by greater use of sugar in prepared foods and takeaways. 
 The Coma report recommends a general cut in sugar consumption and a substitution of fruit, vegetables and starchy foods. 
 It urges manufacturers to label sugar on foods but stops short of demanding legislation. 
 The Coronary Prevention Group yesterday welcomed the report. 
 &bquo;I was astonished when I read the press release which bore no relation to the real recommendations in the report,&equo; said its assistant director, Ms Anne Hueghan. 
 The Sugar Bureau said yesterday that the report had dispelled myths and had concluded that sugar, apart from tooth decay &bquo;poses no threat to health&equo; at present consumption levels. 
 27,000 jobs on move to regions. 
 By David Lawson 
 COSTS and labour shortages are forcing a growing number of companies to flee from London. 
 More than 7,000 jobs were moved in 1989 and almost 20,000 more are due over the next two years with the government in the van, say researchers Jones Lang Wootton in a survey published yesterday. 
 Twenty companies moved this year, 49 are set to go by 1993 and another 23 are considering moving &mdash; and not just to the suburbs. 
 Half are going to the regions, especially the south-west. 
 Office rents have soared in London over the past couple of years but political factors are also significant as government departments make up more than a quarter of moves. 
 The Ministry of Defence is decamping staff to Newcastle while the Department of Social Security is sending 350 jobs to Belfast. 
 Among the private groups BP Exploration transferred 400 jobs to Glasgow this year. 
 Next year Chase Manhattan is sending 480 to Bournemouth and Barclays 1,000 to Coventry. 
 Embryo research backed. 
 By Nigel Williams Science Correspondent 
 STRONG support for research on human embryos up to 14 days old came from the Medical Research Council yesterday, which adds its voice to that of the Royal Society, the Royal Colleges, and the medical charities opposing a ban. 
 The issue is the key feature of the Human and Embryology Bill which has just had its second reading in the House of Lords. 
 Dr Martin Johnson, a scientist speaking for the MRC, said the council spent &pound;5 million last year on embryo and related research to help the 275,000 couples in Britain who have fertility problems at some time. 
 Central to the debate is the status of the human egg after fertilisation. 
 The council, like most scientists, argues that only after 14 days do the cells that will become the embryo become distinct from those of the surrounding tissue. 
 The term &bquo;pre-embryo&equo; is used to describe this stage, and would be the limit of any research. 
 The bill presents alternative clauses on whether or not to permit strictly-controlled research on early embryos, now carried out under the control of the Voluntary Licensing Authority. 
 Speaking at the launch of the MRC's annual report, Dr Johnson said the consequences for infertility treatment were serious if research was banned. 
 &bquo;The capacity of the medical profession to improve treatment would stand still; it would be unethical to try to improve techniques. 
 &bquo;Doctors involved with treating the infertile will leave the field or leave the country; many countries are only too willing to tap our expertise.&equo; 
 Students face disruption over rejected pay deals. 
 By Celia Weston, Chief Education Correspondent 
 THOUSANDS of students could have their studies disrupted following the decision by the largest lecturers' union last night to reject the latest pay offers for staff in further and higher education colleges and polytechnics. 
 The decision provoked the polytechnics to say they would review the future of national bargaining, a move which has been gaining support among employers since the polytechnics gained their independence earlier this year. 
 The Government supports greater pay flexibility through local bargaining. 
 The National Association of Teachers in Further and Higher Education, which represents staff in both sectors, last night rejected an improved offer for further education staff and decided to go ahead with a one-day strike tommorrow and to begin boycotts of marking and examination setting. 
 Natfhe also rejected the interim pay offer from the Polytechnic and Colleges Employers' Forum for polytechnic and higher education college lecturers. 
 The decision could disrupt the studies of more than 350,000 students. 
 Like their colleagues in further education, the 17,000 lecturers in the sector have voted for a marking and exam boycott. 
 Mr Neil Fletcher, leader of the local authority employers, said Natfhe should cancel its strike and postpone the marking and exam boycott to give lecturers time to consider the new deal. 
 &bquo;If this is responsible trade unionism, I'm a banana,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Roger Ward, chief executive of the Polytechnic and Colleges Employers Forum, said it was regrettable that Natfhe seemed determined to take on the employers right across the sector. 
 &bquo;We will be convening a conference on Friday with the heads of all our institutions to review the future of national pay bargaining,&equo; he said. 
 The employers yesterday increased their offer to further education lecturers from 5.3 per cent for the year to April, to 8 per cent, with a &pound;700 one-off, lump sum payment for the 17 months to September next year. 
 They gave Natfhe and the other unions until January 31 to accept or forfeit the offer. 
 Half the lump sum would be paid then and the other half on April 1. 
 The interim offer from the Polytechnic and Colleges Employers Forum included a 6 per cent pay rise from April to September this year and early negotiations on a further pay rise backdated to September 1. 
 Natfhe's executive last night recommended rejection of the offer because it was conditional on lecturers accepting changes to their working hours and because the &pound;700 lump sum would not be included in basic pay calculations next year. 
 The employers are adamant that an agreement on working hours must be part of the deal. 
 Mr Geoff Woolf, Natfhe general secretary, said the offer amounted to only a 4.67 per cent increase with strings for the year to January. 
 Ministers consider green energy policy. 
 By Paul Brown Environment Correspondent 
 RADICAL changes in Government energy policy are being considered by a Cabinet committee which is fashioning the promised white paper on environmental issues. 
 Mr Christopher Patten, the Environment Secretary, using &bquo;value for money&equo; as his argument, is believed to be challenging the traditional thinking of the &bquo;ungreen&equo; transport, energy, and treasury ministers. 
 Some measures may be in train before the white paper is published. 
 Mr John Wakeham, the Energy Secretary, is considering eleventh hour changes to electricity privatisation to allow new private power companies to make money from energy conservation as well as electricity generation. 
 Under the current wording of the legislation, companies can only make profits from supplying electricity and building new power stations. 
 Mr David Gee, director-designate of Friends of the Earth, published a report yesterday supporting Mr Patten, who he described as a &bquo;radical green&equo;. 
 Getting Out of the Greenhouse shows that strict economic criteria could be used to modify energy policy to cut Britain's output of carbon dioxide gases, the biggest contributor to the greenhouse effect. 
 Using the Government's own research, Dr Tim Jackson, an environmental consultant, shows that carbon dioxide emissions could be cut by 46 per cent in 15 years without building any nuclear power stations. 
 He studied 17 ways of saving carbon dioxide emissions, in order of cost-effectiveness, and nuclear power came 15th. 
 Mr Simon Roberts, the FoE energy campaigner, said this illustrated the Government's ramshackle approach to energy policy. 
 The Department of Energy discovered the true costs of nuclear power after months of considering electricity privatisation. 
 &bquo;They were not in control of energy policy. 
 They simply did not know what was going on. 
 They were in the hands of vested interests, not in possession of the facts,&equo; said Mr Roberts. 
 The report demands that the Government adopt value for money as its criteria, set targets for reducing carbon dioxide emissions, and assess environmental taxation schemes. 
 Transport planning should be integrated with energy policy. 
 Switching from electricity to gas for heating, the most cost-effective way of reducing carbon dioxide emissions, should be obligatory in new buildings. 
 Improved efficiency in electrical appliances could be encouraged by making labelling on new items mandatory so consumers could choose the &bquo;greeenest model&equo;. 
 Other cost-effective ways of reducing emissions included combined heat and power for housing, factories and hospitals, and lighting efficiency. 
 Some utilities in the United States had reduced electricity demand by giving low energy light bulbs to poor families. 
 Resources were finite and the &pound;1million a day cost to the taxpayer of building the Sizewell B pressurised water reactor could be diverted to more cost-effective alternatives. 
 VAT should be removed from energy-efficient products. 
 Mr Gee said: &bquo;Scientists keep telling us that the situation is far more urgent than politicians are admitting. 
 We have 10 years to make the decisions which could save the planet. 
 We are banking on Mrs Thatcher realising this. 
 She could go down in history as the leader who pulled us back from the brink.&equo; 
 Kidney donor tells of pain. 
 By Gareth Parry 
 TWO TURKS who sold kidneys for transplants in London were in so much pain when they were discharged that one had to carry the other out of the hospital, the General Medical Council's disciplinary committee heard yesterday. 
 Mr Coskun Yenici, aged 28, who sold his kidney for &pound;3,000 to finance medical treatment for his father, had to carry the other donor, Mrs Hatice Anutkan, out of the Wellington Humana hospital after the surgery last November. 
 Mr Yenici told the committee in London he had believed he would be in the private hospital at least a month, but was &bquo;in and out within a week&equo;. 
 Speaking through an interpreter, Mr Yenici &mdash; the last of four Turkish donors to give evidence &mdash; told Mr Roger HendersonQC, for the GMC: &bquo;We were suffering, in pain. 
 I left hospital at the same time as Mrs Anukan. 
 Her pains were far more severe. 
 I was carrying her in my arms out of hospital. 
 We went to a cold boarding house.&equo; 
 Mr Yenici had put a Kidney for Sale advert in an Istanbul newspaper. 
 It was answered by a Turkish &bquo;kidney broker&equo;, who said the &pound;5,000 he was asking was too much. 
 Mr Yenici said he accepted &pound;3,000 when the broker assured him his organ would be transplanted into a poor person in England. 
 The broker, Tunc Kunter, brought to London Mr Yenici and Mrs Hatice Anutkan, who had been left to raise two children alone and wanted money to meet debts. 
 The committee had heard she sold her kidney for &pound;3,265. 
 Dr Raymond Crockett, a Harley Street kidney specialist, Mr Michael Joyce a urologist at Guy's Hospital, and Mr Michael Bewick, a leading kidney transplant surgeon all deny professional misconduct for their roles in removing single kidneys from the Turks and transplanting into private patients at the hospital in London. 
 The hearing continues today. 
 Mobile clinic cuts toll of Aids. 
 THE incidence of sexually-transmitted diseases among Plymouth's prostitutes has been cut by Britain's only mobile Aids clinic, which hands out free condoms and needles to intravenous drug users. 
 The service, which costs about &pound;2,000 a year, also includes injections of donated Hepatitis B vaccine. 
 Mr Terry Roberts, a district public health adviser, started the Aids Truck, as it is known by its clients, two years ago. 
 The old Bedford ambulance is staffed by 10 trained volunteers, and patrols twice weekly in the red light district. 
 &bquo;All signs are that it is making a real impact in reducing the spread of Aids,&equo; Mr Roberts said. 
 &bquo;The most effective way to spread the message about safe sex is through prostitutes. 
 A good hooker can reach a wide audience. 
 &bquo;Now we have some of the best-informed prostitutes in the country, and they have educated their clients.&equo; 
 Since the service started the incidence of all types of sexually-transmitted diseases among prostitutes has fallen sharply. 
 Only two cases of gonorrhea were reported in the first 19 months, compared with four a week previously. 
 Prostitutes waiting their turn for treatment at the mobile Aids clinic in Plymouth's red light districtPHOTOGRAPH: ROGER BAMBER 
 Tang horse fetches record &pound;3.7 million. 
 APOTTERY horse (left) made in China in the eighth century was sold at Sotheby's in London yesterday to a Japanese dealer for a &pound;3.7million, a world auction record for any Chinese artefact, writes Donald Wintersgill. 
 The horse was sent last month to Hong Kong for exhibition, but was stolen from a warehouse there on November 14. 
 Police recovered it from a flat in Hong Kong on December 2 and arrested three men. 
 The figure, which is slightly damaged, was made during the Tang dynasty (681-907 AD), and put in a tomb. 
 The seller was the British Rail Pension Fund, which invested &pound;40million in the 1970s on art and antiques, which are being sold off. 
 Huddersfield pours out the hard sell. 
 By Martin Wainwright 
 EAU d'Huddersfield, until now submerged among gritty northern brews like dandelion and burdock, is about to mount an assault on the Perrier market for continental mineral water. 
 Natural water from two 300ft boreholes beneath Huddersfield, West Yorkshire, is for the first time to be bottled, and sold to France. 
 A Pennine Spring label, depicting Mag Beck waterfalls behind Ben Shaw's Huddersfield drinks factory, will advertise a &bquo;pure, hard water&equo; previously available only in a sugary and distinctly un-French range of fizzy pops. 
 &bquo;We've always used the bore water for our soft drinks, like dandelion and burdock and Irn Brew,&equo; said Mr Nigel Smith, Shaw's managing director. 
 &bquo;It has taken the rise in bottled water drinking to make it practicable to sell it on its own.&equo; 
 Judge adjourns decision on contempt to await House of Lords ruling over magazine writer who has refused to reveal his source Jail reprieve for journalist. 
 By Joanna Coles 
 ADECISION on whether a trainee journalist should be jailed for contempt of court was yesterday adjourned until next month pending a hearing in the House of Lords. 
 Mr Justice Hoffman said in the High Court that he had decided to suspend judgment until he knew how soon the House of Lords was likely to hear an appeal against an order forcing Mr William Goodwin, aged 23, who works on the Engineer magazine, to reveal confidential information. 
 After being assured by Mr Geoffrey Robertson, QC, defending, that the appeal process would be dealt with this week, he said he had decided to suspend judgment until January 15. 
 Earlier yesterday, the Court of Appeal refused an application by Mr Goodwin's employers, the publishers Morgan Grampian, to revoke the order forcing him to hand over notes containing confidential financial information concerning a company, which cannot be named for legal reasons. 
 The company alleges that the information came from a stolen document, and wants to take action against the source. 
 Mr John McDonnell, QC, for the company, had urged Mr Justice Hoffman to exercise the court's power to the full, saying that it might take a year for the case to be heard by the House of Lords. 
 The judge agreed that &bquo;it would be a denial of justice&equo; if the case took a year, but was told by Mr Robertson that an appeal would be dealt with this week. 
 Mr Robertson said it was &bquo;a reasonable prospect&equo; to suppose the House of Lords might take a different view of the case, and that should be taken into account. 
 Justice should be done but not in superabundance, he added. 
 Mr Goodwin said afterwards that he was glad to be spending Christmas at liberty. 
 The journalist's solicitor, Mr Geoffrey Bindman, added that he was &bquo;very satisfied&equo; at the outcome, not only because of the merits of the case but because his client had not had a chance to put his case against Mr Justice Hoffman's earlier ruling to give up his notes. 
 Rejecting Morgan Grampian's appeal earlier, Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, said he &bquo;most emphatically&equo; refused to grant a stay on the contempt proceedings because Mr Goodwin was not prepared to comply with any order to disclose his notes. 
 Sitting with Lords Justices Gibson and McCowan, he said: &bquo;If he has no intention of disclosing his source, whatever the House of Lords, which is the ultimate court of justice in this country, may say, then we see absolutely no reason why we should assist him.&equo; 
 Morgan Grampian has given a court undertaking not to publish the information. 
 Lord Donaldson said that Mr Goodwin was a very young trainee journalist who only left university this summer. 
 &bquo;His investigative talent, which he displayed in this instance, will no doubt stand him in good stead in the future and I hope that he will have a long and distinguished career,&equo; he said. 
 But it was the duty of the courts to enforce the laws made by Parliament. 
 The long-standing claim by journalists to be bound by honour to protect their sources should be subject to the law, as were those of doctors and bankers. 
 Four years for New York's hotel queen. 
 By Mary Brasier in New York 
 MRS Leona Helmsley, the hotel queen dethroned earlier this year by a New York court that convicted her as a tax cheat, was yesterday sentenced to four years' imprisonment and fined &dollar;7 million (&pound;4.5 million). 
 Mrs Helmsley, aged 69, stood stony-faced as Judge John Walker sentenced her on 33 counts of tax evasion and conspiracy to evade taxes. 
 He said the terms should run concurrently so that she would serve four years. 
 She was found guilty by a jury on August 30. 
 Her 80-year-old husband, Harry, had been declared mentally unfit to stand trial. 
 Mrs Helmsley, dressed in black, had earlier walked to the front of the court and sobbingly begged the judge not to impose a prison term. 
 &bquo;Your Honour, I'm more ashamed than anyone could ever imagine. 
 I beg you: don't let me lose Harry, too. 
 Please don't. 
 All my life has been work and each other.&equo; 
 She is also to serve three years' probation and do community service at Hale House in Harlem. 
 In addition, Mrs Helmsley has to repay the taxes with interest to the Federal Government and New York state. 
 By the judge's reckoning, this comes to close to &dollar;2 million. 
 Mrs Helmsley will appeal against her conviction and sentence. 
 She was released on bail and driven to her Park Avenue flat. 
 If the conviction is upheld, the hotel queen's new palace could be a women's prison in Connecticut, about 20 miles from the &dollar;11 million mansion she refurbished at the taxpayers' expense by charging repairs to her business. 
 Mrs Helmsley was found guilty after a trial replete with tales of how she bawled out employees and charged &dollar;12 department store brassieres to her hotel. 
 &bquo;Only the little people pay taxes,&equo; she told her housekeeper. 
 Love to loathe, page 24 
 Effect of student loans &bquo;unknown&equo;. 
 ATORY MP yesterday made the first admission that the Government does not know whether children from poorer backgrounds will be put off higher education by the introduction of top-up loans, writes Celia Weston. 
 Under the Government's scheme, the Treasury will meet the costs of setting up and running a private company owned by banks to administer it. 
 Public money will be used to lend up to &pound;420 a year to students in full-time higher education, which they will pay back at an inflation-linked rate of interest. 
 Critics of the Education (Student Loans) Bill, say that incurring debts will particularly discourage children from working-class families from going into higher education. 
 The Government says loans, to be introduced from next autumn, will share the burden of student maintenance more fairly between taxpayers, parents and students. 
 Mr Alastair Burt, MP for Bury North, told the first meeting of the committee examining the bill, that no one knew if it would be a disincentive or not. 
 &bquo;There is evidence on both sides,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Burt is a former parliamentary secretary to the previous Education Secretary, Mr Kenneth Baker. 
 The Government alone could not provide the money for the further increase in student numbers it wanted. 
 &bquo;If we were talking about tuition fees, not maintenance, then talking about serious disincentives would carry a great deal of weight,&equo; he said. 
 But the bill only concerned maintenance. 
 Mr Jack Straw, Labour's education spokesman, earlier failed to convince the committee that the decision not to include Mr John MacGregor, the Education Secretary, on the committee was treating parliamentary procedures with contempt. 
 Thatcher eases her line on ERM. 
 By Michael White, Chief Political Correspondent 
 MRS Thatcher last night coupled a softening of her hostility to British membership of the European exchange rate mechanism (ERM) with a combative restatement of her intention to fight all the way against implementation of the Social Charter, the later stages of the Delors monetary union plan and greater powers for the Strasbourg parliament. 
 With senior cabinet colleagues making discreetly plain their desire to enter the ERM as soon as practicable, the Prime Minister ceased to give the impression that she wants to add further conditions to those announced at the Madrid summit in June. 
 Those conditions still stood, she told MPs, &bquo;but no one is suggesting that we dot every &bquo;i&equo; and cross every &bquo;t&equo; before we look at it.&equo; 
 The Prime Minister's routine report to the Commons after the European Community Council of Ministers' summit in Strasbourg last weekend produced modest evidence of what one Tory called a &bquo;softer and subtler&equo; tone towards the European project. 
 But Mr Neil Kinnock, the Opposition leader, insisted that &bquo;the rational and constructive&equo; tone of the Strasbourg communique occurred &bquo;in spite, not because of her.&equo; 
 Mr Paddy Ashdown, the Liberal and Democratic leader, said the other community members had &bquo;not found her irritating only because they found her totally irrelevant.&equo; 
 But the gratitude of pro-Market backbenchers was offset by the assurances she offered to anti-Marketeers like Tory Jonathan Aitken, and Labour's Peter Shore. 
 She sidestepped Mr Shore's demand for a select committee inquiry into the &bquo;enormous&equo; threat to Westminster's powers posed by the last two stages of the Delors plan, centralised banking and budgetary controls. 
 But she stressed her belief that Britain is winning allies for opposing what was only &bquo;a blueprint&equo;. 
 &bquo;We are in the early stage of what will be a long debate in Europe,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;A number of different viewpoints are already beginning to emerge. 
 Britain will play a full and constructive part in the debate while reflecting the view expressed in all parts of the House that stages two and three of the Delors proposals are not acceptable.&equo; 
 Contrary to the French view that the forthcoming inter-governmental conference on EC unity will complete its agenda by late 1991, the Prime Minister insisted &bquo;no time limit is set for its work.&equo; 
 Consistent with her belief that the single market is the key to European prosperity and &bquo;closer integration&equo; as well as &bquo;an example and opportunity&equo; to Eastern Europe, Mrs Thatcher stressed it at the expense of Delors and the Social Charter &mdash; for which she predicted &bquo;considerable difficulties&equo; from many countries when detailed proposals emerged. 
 There was widespread support in the Commons for the summit's cautious formula on German reunification, which couples self-determination with respect for treaties and borders. 
 Dairy council and Boots rebuked over advertising. 
 THE Advertising Standards Authority yesterday rebuked two organisations for making bogus claims about the health advantages of milk, writes James Erlichman. 
 The National Dairy Council was reprimanded for an advertisement headlined: &bquo;Worried about Osteoporosis? 
 Consult a Specialist.&equo; 
 The poster featured a milkman, implying that the calcium in milk could help overcome osteoporosis, a brittle-bone condition which afflicts some women after menopause. 
 The authority, which received five complaints, concluded that the claim was not justified. 
 Calcium might reduce the risk of osteoporosis but &bquo;there was no conclusive evidence demonstrating that calcium supplementation resulted in a regeneration of lost bone&equo;. 
 The authority upheld a complaint in 1987 against Unigate over a similiar claim made for a calcium-enriched milk called Calcia. 
 The National Dairy Council had previously been criticised for a campaign suggesting that milk could protect children's teeth from decay, but a claim that the vitamin A in milk improved night vision was permitted. 
 In a separate adjudication yesterday, Boots was rebuked for claims made for its Farley's Junior Milk, a formula it recommends for babies over six months old. 
 Advertisements showed a cow's udder next to a bottle of the prepared milk, and claimed the Department of Health had recommended the product as better than cow's milk for babies older than six months. 
 The Department of Health said its guidelines did not justify the claim. 
 Ms Patti Rundall, of the Baby Milk Action Coalition which opposes unnecessary use of infant formulae, said: &bquo;We are delighted with the ruling, but Boots has not been chastened.&equo; 
 Her organisation is preparing a complaint about a Boots advertisement for Ostermilk featuring a bra with two Ostermilk tins inside, which claims: &bquo;Any closer to breast milk and we would have to change the packaging.&equo; 
 Hurd delays repatriation of boat people for a week PM rejects outrage on refugees. 
 By Michael White, Steven Vines cw-2Mark Tran and Patrick Wintour 
 THE Government last night signalled its determination to ride out the political storm surrounding its compulsory repatriation of Vietnamese refugees and said it would deport as many as necessary to convince thousands more would-be boat people not to seek refuge in Hong Kong next spring. 
 As a sop to angry opposition MPs and international agencies, the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, told the Commons that no more Vietnamese would follow the 51 deported during Monday night until the issue had been debated in the House on Tuesday. 
 The expulsions seem certain to resume, probably before Christmas. 
 Mrs Thatcher, in Commons exchanges with Mr Neil Kinnock, rejected criticism in Hong Kong and Britain and took a swipe at foreign critics by urging them to help accommodate the boat people. 
 Such criticism included a US call for an end to forced repatriation. 
 &bquo;The United States deeply regrets the forcible repatriation of Vietnamese asylum seekers from Hong Kong to Vietnam. 
 We believe the British government should not proceed further with mandatory repatriation from Hong Kong,&equo; said the State Department spokesman, Mr Richard Boucher. 
 The US Secretary of State, Mr James Baker, had unsuccessfully tried to persuade Mrs Thatcher to relent when they met earlier this week. 
 Official US censure came amid strong condemnation from Capitol Hill. 
 The chairman of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, Mr Claiborne Pell, called the expulsion a &bquo;disgrace&equo; and compared it to Britain's decision to forcibly return Cossacks to Stalin's Russia after the second world war. 
 In Hong Kong, expectations of violence in the camps did not materialise but aid workers believed the initial passivity would probably not last. 
 Eight men, 17 women and 26 children were flown from Hong Kong to Hanoi's Noi Bai airport. 
 A Vietnamese airport official said they went through the usual passport and customs procedures and then boarded buses to Soc San reception centre which was also the first stop for almost 600 boat people who returned voluntarily from Hong Kong earlier this year. 
 There are about 1,200 genuine volunteers in the Hong Kong camps awaiting repatriation. 
 In its need to show a determination to repatriate boat people, the Government decided it could not wait to send the volunteers home first. 
 That would have taken them past the vital February sailing time along what Whitehall claims is an organised escape route. 
 The United Nations High Commission for Refugees in Geneva called the British action &bquo;premature&equo; while other avenues were still open. 
 The steering committee on refugees resumes in Geneva next month. 
 In London, the British Refugee Council issued a damning attack on the Government's action following an emergency general meeting in London. 
 It was issued as Mr Hurd cited the council in his support when defending the repatriation to MPs. 
 Mr Hurd said the council had endorsed the screening procedure. 
 But the council said the Government's decision to repatriate had profound implications for asylum seekers all over the world and added that it was &bquo;utterly appalled&equo; by the action taken furtively in Hong Kong. 
 The action was &bquo;morally wrong, unworkable in practice, degrading to all involved and certain to provoke serious and justified criticism on the UK, the country ultimately responsible&equo;. 
 It added that the procedures which have been in force since June 1988 for the screening of Vietnamese arrivals should be suspended forthwith. 
 In the Commons, Mr Kinnock accused Mrs Thatcher of &bquo;defending the indefensible&equo; by &bquo;giving instructions that in the middle of the night armed riot police raid children, women and men, shove them into cages and forcibly deport them to the country from which they fled&equo;. 
 But, with the near-unanimous support of the Tory backbenches, the Prime Minister insisted over and over again that it was &bquo;perfectly in order&equo; to send illegal immigrants home. 
 And in an oblique swipe at her critics in the Bush Administration she added: &bquo;Those countries protesting at their return would do better if they offered to take some of them.&equo; 
 Though some ministers are plainly more embarrassed than Mrs Thatcher appeared to be, the Government believes that the opposition has produced no serious alternatives to its blunt deterrent policy. 
 The numbers of non-political refugees could double to 80,000 when the sailing season starts in the South China Sea in February, the Government argues. 
 Ministers are convinced that unless they stand firm against economic migrants, the West faces &bquo;chaos and great unhappiness&equo; and they privately cite peremptory US treatment of unwanted immigrants from countries like Mexico and Haiti. 
 The unstated part of the equation is that they must be tough on the Vietnamese boat people because they are poised to be tough on Hong Kong's own claims to British passports. 
 Mr Hurd also announced that former Labour cabinet minister, Lord Ennals, would accompany Mr Timothy Raison, a Tory ex-immigration minister, to Vietnam next month to act as independent observers, bolstering the efforts of Britain's tiny diplomatic mission in Hanoi to monitor the 51's safe return. 
 Both men have been identified as broadly supporting the repatriation policy and Mr Hurd, who again appealed for voluntary agencies, including the United Nations, to end their boycott of the monitoring process, may be willing to expand the delegation. 
 The deportations have already been postponed several times under international pressure and Mr Hurd is the third Foreign Secretary to review a policy first outlined 15 months ago. 
 But there was little he or Mrs Thatcher in earlier exchanges, could do to mitigate what Mr Paddy Ashdown, the Liberal Democrats' leader, called &bquo;a shameful example&equo; of human rights policy and what the shadow Foreign Secretary, Mr Gerald Kaufman, said was &bquo;a policy of the three o'clock knock by police&equo;. 
 Opposition leaders believe that more could have been done in Geneva to find an international solution. 
 Politics, page 6; Thailand may start own deportations, page 9; Leader comment, page 22 
 New code of practice for press. 
 THE recommended code of practice, which the Press Council hopes to operate from March 1 1990, is much fuller than that published recently by national newspapers, writes Georgina Henry. 
 It is based on &bquo;commonly accepted general principles of good journalistic practice&equo; built by council adjudications over many years. 
 The code states: Newspapers and journalists have a duty to defend the freedom of the press in the interests of the public, and to resist censorship. 
 The achievement of this objective is jeopardised by unethical conduct. 
 ACCURACY It is the duty of newspapers not to publish deliberately or recklessly inaccuracies or statements designed to mislead and to correct promptly and with due prominence significant inaccuracies which they have published, apologising for these where appropriate. 
 OPPORTUNITY TO REPLY It is the general duty of newspapers to allow a fair opportunity for reply when reasonably called for. 
 In particular it is the duty of newspapers to allow people or bodies they attack editorially a reasonable opportunity to reply. 
 PRIVACY Publishing information about the private lives of individuals without their consent is not acceptable unless there is a public interest overriding the right of privacy. 
 It is the duty of editors to ensure that inquiries into people's private lives are not undertaken, and information or pictures about their private lives are not published, unless inquiry or publication can be justified as being necessary in the public interest. 
 The Press Council's Declaration of Principle on Privacy should be observed. 
 COMMENT AND FACT Newspapers should not express comment on conjecture as fact and should distinguish between them, but they are free to be partisan. 
 SUBTERFUGE Newspapers and journalists serving them should use straightforward means to obtain information or pictures. 
 Their use of subterfuge can be justified only to obtain material which ought to be published in the public interest and could not be obtained by other means. 
 PAYMENT FOR ARTICLES Payments or offers of payment for stories, pictures or information should not be made to witnesses or potential witnesses in current criminal proceedings or to people engaged in crime or their associates except where the material concerned ought to be published in the public interest, and the payment is necessary to enable this to be done. 
 The Press Council's Declaration of Principle on Payment for Articles should be observed. 
 INTRUSION INTO GRIEF Newspapers and journalists serving them should avoid intruding into personal grief except where this is justified in the public interest. 
 In such cases inquiries should be carried out and approaches made with sympathy and discretion. 
 INNOCENT RELATIVES Newspapers should avoid identifying relatives of persons convicted or accused of crime unless the reference to them is directly relevant to the matter reported. 
 INTERVIEWING CHILDREN Journalists should not interview a child in the absence, or without the consent, of a parent or other adult who is responsible for the child at the time. 
 CHILDREN IN SEX CASES Save in exceptional circumstances where it is in the public interest to do so, newspapers should not, even where the law permits it, identify children as victims, witnesses or defendants involved in cases concerning sexual offences. 
 RAPE VICTIMS Newspapers should not identify victims of rape, or publish material likely to contribute to such identification. 
 PICTURES Newspapers should refrain from publishing pictures which are likely to exacerbate grief or cause distress, unless their publication is in the public interest. 
 RACE AND COLOUR Newspapers should not publish material likely to encourage discrimination on grounds of race or colour, and should avoid references to people's race or colour in prejudicial or pejorative contexts unless they are directly relevant to the story. 
 INSIDER DEALING Journalists should not use for their own profit financial information they receive professionally in advance of its general publication. 
 The Press Council's Declaration of Principle on Financial Journalism should be observed. 
 HOSPITALS Journalists should not use subterfuge to gain admission to hospitals or similar institutions. 
 They should identify themselves to a responsible official before entering, except in very rare cases where information which ought to be disclosed in the public interest could not otherwise be obtained. 
 CONFIDENTIAL SOURCES Journalists have a professional obligation to protect confidential sources of information. 
 Patten promises to strengthen hand of pollution agency. 
 By Paul Brown Environment Correspondent. 
 HER Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution will receive the necessary resources to police the controls in the forthcoming green bill, the Environment Secretary, Mr Chris Patten, said yesterday. 
 Speaking at an Association of Water Officers conference in London, he said he realised the credibility of the agency rested on the resources at its disposal. 
 Central to the green bill is the introduction of integrated pollution control. 
 Mr Patten said this meant that all releases of waste from large industrial processes would be considered together before a discharge licence was granted. 
 The pollution inspectorate, which is expected to oversee the process, is currently understaffed and personnel are suffering from low morale. 
 Industry has already complained to the Department of the Environment that controls will not be effective unless the inspectorate is respected and cowboy companies are aware that they will be prosecuted. 
 The inspectorate's director, Mr Brian Ponsford, who was found dead in his fume-filled car last week, had written a report outlining the difficulties of his department. 
 One of the problems, he said, was that staff were resisting a plan to relocate them from local offices, where they were in touch with industry, to remote district offices. 
 Mr Rod Perriman, the former chief inspector, resigned last year because senior inspectors were upset about the plans. 
 Five months later, Mr David Mills, deputy chief inspector for water and waste, resigned, too. 
 Mr Mike Thayer, director of the newly-created Western Region, resigned last month. 
 Press watchdog designs its teeth for the 1990s. 
 By Georgina Henry, Media Correspondent 
 THE Press Council yesterday unveiled wide-ranging proposals to improve its efficiency and win public and political confidence in voluntary regulation of the press. 
 The proposals include a detailed code of practice for journalists. 
 The 119-page report is the result of a 10-month review led by the Press Council's chairman, Mr Louis Blom-Cooper, who after meeting the full council yesterday said he expected it to take until next summer to reach final agreement on the recommendations. 
 Consultation with the council's constituent bodies and other interested parties will begin immediately, but the council is expecting considerable opposition &mdash; particularly from some national newspapers &mdash; to key recommendations. 
 Those likely to prove controversial include the new method of appointing press members of the council, the plan to directly involve proprietors in enforcing the code of practice on their editors, and the question of increased funding for the council. 
 But Mr Ken Morgan, director of the council, said yesterday he believed the recommendations would be supported. 
 The review follows persistent criticism that the Press Council is an ineffective body which commands little respect. 
 Its recommendations come two weeks after national newspapers published their own declaration of principles and code of practice designed to improve self-regulation and avoid legislation &mdash; an initiative supported by Mr Blom-Cooper. 
 Mr Peter Preston, editor of the Guardian, yesterday said: &bquo;This has been a long time coming and there are things in it like the enhanced role for proprietors that I'm not very keen on,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;But it is infinitely the best show in town at a time when legislation threatens press freedom and we shall do everything we can to support it through the arguments ahead.&equo; 
 The main recommendations of the report are: 
 Membership: The size of the council will be reduced from 36 to 24, plus an independent chairman, split equally between press members and public members. 
 The Appointments Commission which selects public members will in future also select press members from names proposed &bquo;at large&equo;, instead of being nominated by the constituent bodies. 
 Complaints procedure: The four-part procedure &mdash; complaint, response, comments and final rejoinder &mdash; will be retained for appropriate cases but a shorter and speedier process giving each side one opportunity to state its case should be introduced. 
 A &bquo;radical&equo; new procedure, under which complaints staff make inquiries by telephone or face to face with the parties to produce a summary for the complaints committee, is proposed. 
 The absolute right of an editor or journalist to opt for a personal hearing should be removed. 
 Privacy: an individual who believes a publication due to appear may constitute unwarranted invasion of privacy should be free to ask for the council's help. 
 If satisfied, the director should instantly contact the editor and put him on notice of a complaint. 
 Publication should remain at the editor's discretion. 
 Code of practice: Far-reaching proposals go much further than the code published by national newspapers. 
 Enforcement: The direct enforcement, by judicial or contractural means, of adjudications &bquo;is neither necessary nor desirable in the public interest&equo;. 
 However, in appropriate cases an apology should be added to an adjudication. 
 The council should have the power to recommend the return of documents. 
 The council may recommend the nature and form of a reply or correction &bquo;including, in appropriate cases, where in the paper it should be published&equo;. 
 Proprietors' or publishers' obligations: A positive public commitment to upholding the council's principles should be given. 
 The council expects its censure or serious criticism &bquo;to discredit editors and journalists at whom it is aimed and to be weighed by their employers&equo;. 
 Complaints will in future be registered against individual editors by name. 
 Staffing and funding: Staffing should be increased and the council wants at least &pound;1 million in 1991 (it expects &pound;700,000 next year). 
 Code of conduct and other reports, page 2; Leader comment, page 22 
 Peaceful face of law-abiding Ulster. 
 By David Hearst 
 NORTHERN Ireland was one of the most peaceful regions of the United Kingdom last year, according to a government report published yesterday. 
 It had a lower recorded crime rate per 100,000 people than any of the 41 police areas in England and Wales. 
 According to a commentary on the report, Northern Ireland Crime Statistics, published by the Northern Ireland Office, the province was the ninth most peaceful in terms of crimes of violence against the person and had the lowest rate in the country for theft. 
 But it does have seven times the number of homicides. 
 The commentary urges caution when comparing the province's crime rate with others, but says: &bquo;The level of criminal activity in Northern Ireland is less than in some ostensibly more peaceful countries.&equo; 
 In the category, &bquo;crimes of dishonesty&equo;, the province was considerably more honest than England and Wales and a paragon of virtue compared to the United States. 
 The Royal Ulster Constabulary is solving twice as many crimes as it did 10 years ago. 
 The number of crimes which result in charges before a court has more than doubled in the last 10 years. 
 Last year, 45 per cent of recorded crime was cleared up &mdash; more than double the average rate in the United Kingdom. 
 Some of the biggest successes were recorded against scheduled offences. 
 More than 70 per cent of murder cases were solved in 1988 and the highest rates of detection were recorded among &bquo;offences against the state&equo;, including the Northern Ireland Emergency Provisions Act and firearms legislation. 
 The report says attitudes towards the RUC have changed. 
 Forty-five per cent of Roman Catholics thought the police understood local problems, compared to 68 per cent of Protestants. 
 No more will be sent back before debate next week. 
 Labour attacks &bquo;three o'clock knock&equo; Hurd defends repatriations Boat people. 
 Paul Nettleton. 
 NO further repatriations of Vietnamese boat people will take place before a Commons debate on the issue next Tuesday, the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, told MPs yesterday. 
 He said the 51 people flown back from Hong Kong early yesterday had been removed &bquo;in line with procedures used worldwide to remove people refused permission to remain in a territory. 
 No firearms were carried and no force was used&equo;. 
 But his shadow, Mr Gerald Kaufman, said: &bquo;The fact is that what this Government has adopted is the policy of the three o'clock knock by police.&equo; 
 Mr Hurd won Tory cheers as he said: &bquo;Unless it is clear to people in Vietnam that those who do not qualify as refugees will be returned to Vietnam, Hong Kong faces the prospect of tens of thousands more arrivals in 1990. 
 That is simply not an acceptable prospect.&equo; 
 Vietnam had agreed to the arrangements for repatriation and aid would be given to assist resettlement, Mr Hurd said. 
 Later he told Mr Michael Jopling (C. Westmorland and Lonsdale) that this amounted to US&dollar;60 per person to help with transport, food, medicines, training and tools. 
 Mr Hurd still hoped the UN High Commissioner for Refugees would agree to help the Hanoi embassy in monitoring conditions for returnees, and said he had already asked British non-governmental organisations for co-operation. 
 Meanwhile Mr Tim Raison (C. Aylesbury) and the Labour peer, Lord Ennals, would visit Vietnam next month as independent observers. 
 Further discussions will be held with Vietnam &bquo;about ways of screening new arrivals quickly, as they reach Hong Kong, so that those who are not refugees can be returned quickly and safely to Vietnam&equo;. 
 The Government would seek international co-operation on checking the inflow of boat people at January's Geneva conference meeting. 
 Mr Kaufman asked why the operation had been carried out &bquo;under the veil of a news blackout. 
 If force was ruled out as you say, why were 150 riot police equipped with riot helmets, shields and batons needed to remove 51 people, of whom 43 were women and children?&equo; 
 Mr Kaufman asked why there was no independent process of appeal under the screening procedures and why, if the Government objected to free movement of &bquo;economic refugees&equo; from Communist countries, &bquo;did the Government applaud the movement of such migrants from East to West Germany before the opening of the Berlin Wall?&equo; 
 Mrs Thatcher, he said, was setting conditions on attending President Gorbachev's conference on human rights in Moscow. 
 &bquo;The Prime Minister has shown herself completely unfit not only to attend any conference on human rights anywhere, but even to utter the very words.&equo; 
 Sir Peter Blaker (C. Blackpool S) applauded Mr Hurd for his &bquo;courageous and correct step&equo; although Mr Hurd told him: &bquo;It was also unwelcome.&equo; 
 Mr Hurd said the essential distinction was &bquo;between people who quite understandably want to move&hellip; somewhere else in order to achieve a more agreeable life, and people who are actually forced to do so by the well-founded fear of persecution. 
 &bquo;Those who blur over that distinction do not understand its crucial importance for the successful handling of a whole series of intractable problems of which this is just, at the moment, the worst.&equo; 
 For the Liberal Democrats, Mr David Steel said: &bquo;The feelings of people at what happened last night really vary from unease to repugnance that a British government should stoop to use a device which we have consistently condemned in others &mdash; namely the knock on the door in the middle of the night.&equo; 
 Offering Mr Hurd his support, Mr Michael Heseltine (C. Henley), said: &bquo;It's quite impossible to explain to the Chinese population in Hong Kong that we're putting their relatives back across the frontier with the mainland day after day, and allowing boat people from Vietnam to remain in Hong Kong.&equo; 
 Tory MPs want inquiry into TV job adverts &bquo;bias&equo;. 
 By Paul Nettleton 
 ATORY MP yesterday wrote to the Home Secretary, Mr David Waddington, the BBC chairman, Mr Marmaduke Hussey, and the IBA chairman, Mr George Russell, demanding an urgent investigation into the preponderance of broadcasting recruitment advertising placed with the Guardian. 
 Mr Graham Riddick, MP for Colne Valley, said he was reminding the chairmen &bquo;of their duty to political impartiality&equo;. 
 It was time for them to put their houses in order, &bquo;and for the Home Secretary to insist they do&equo;. 
 With Mr Norman Tebbit, the former Cabinet minister, he has sponsored an early-day motion, tabled yesterday and signed by 111 Tories. 
 This says that the BBC and ITV companies place four times as much recruitment advertising in the Guardian as in the Times and Independent. 
 The MPs have concluded this could explain the leftwing bias they allege in some TV programmes. 
 The motion states: &bquo;To recruit almost exclusively from the narrow minority group of Guardian readers whose views are predominantly leftwing is contrary to the spirit of the obligations of political balance in broadcasting and is an explanation of the self-righteous and unctuous hostility of broadcasters towards the present Government.&equo; 
 A BBC spokesman said vacancies were advertised in other publications. 
 But the Guardian was &bquo;first in the field and remains the market leader in media advertising.&equo; 
 The IBA said the Guardian was &bquo;an extremely effective advertising medium&equo; long before the Independent's launch. 
 Young's letters give details of Rover tax breaks. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 THE Government yesterday took the unprecedented step of releasing more confidential correspondence between Lord Young and British Aerospace, revealing new details of secret tax breaks and private concessions given by ministers over the Rover deal. 
 The disclosures reveal that Professor Roland Smith, chairman of BAe, wrote to Lord Young, then Trade Secretary, on the day the sale was announced, saying he intended to claim he was unaware of the secret correspondence between them on how to hide the &pound;38.8 million &bquo;sweeteners&equo; deal from the European Commission and Parliament. 
 &bquo;We propose continuing to completion on the basis that all material disclosure of relevant facts and circumstances has been made&hellip; and there is no foreseeable risk of subsequent invalidation of the European Commission's approval of state aid as being incompatible with Treaty requirements.&equo; 
 The disclosures, which follow a fortnight of leaks sparked off by the Guardian's revelation of the sweeteners scandal &mdash; show how far Lord Young was prepared to go to sell Rover to the private sector. 
 The letters were placed in the House of Commons library, with a covering note from Mr Nicholas Ridley, the present Trade Secretary, to Mr Gordon Brown, Labour's trade spokesman, saying he had done this in view of the public interest. 
 The ministry said yesterday that it has had to hand over the file to the European Commission, which is investigating the Rover deal. 
 The Commons public accounts committee and trade and industry select committee have also been sent the documentation. 
 The disclosures show how British Aerospace won a further concession from Lord Young to fight &bquo;vigorously&equo; if BAe decided to scrap Rover's corporate plan to introduce new models and the European Commission sought to demand taxpayer's money back. 
 Lord Young sent to BAe a confidential Foreign Office memorandum of the talks between Sir David Hanney, Britain's ambassador to the European Community, and Mr Peter Sutherland (Sir Leon Brittan's predecessor as competition commissioner) on this point. 
 This revealed that the EC would only challenge BAe to honour Rover's plans if there were significant variations, and even then would limit the amount to be reimbursed by the company. 
 Details of the tax deal emerge in a confidential letter from Peat Marwick Mitchell, BAe's tax advisers, showing that the company could offset Rover's losses for tax purposes for three years without fear of a challenge from tax officials. 
 The letter said the Board of Inland Revenue would need to meet before any action could be taken, and BAe and Rover were guaranteed a hearing before action was taken. 
 The Revenue also agreed that if BAe set up a leasing company to take over new Rover plant, rental charges would be tax deductible. 
 Mr Ridley, in his covering letter to Mr Brown, defended the concessions. 
 &bquo;Under normal tax law, these would have been available to the enlarged group under the same conditions and to the same extent as for any other UK group.&equo; 
 However, the original terms of the Rover sale proposed to limit the tax concessions by &bquo;ring fencing&equo; the gain, because of the huge losses Rover had previously made. 
 The offer to back BAe if it changed Rover's corporate plan followed agreement by Lord Young to the &pound;38 million package and further pressure from Professor Smith. 
 Mr Brown said last night that the fresh evidence still left the central question unanswered. 
 &bquo;What is the true financial cost to the public of this deal, and why we have been deceived for 16 months?&equo; 
 Late plea for Kent Opera. 
 By Nicholas de Jongh Arts Correspondent 
 LAST minute efforts to save Kent Opera from liquidation will be made tomorrow when members of the Arts Council's advisory music panel, led by Robert Ponsonby, the former BBC Controller of Music, meet Luke Rittner, the council's secretary-general. 
 The meeting comes amid fresh allegations from members of the music panel that they were press-ganged into rubber- stamping the council's decision to withdraw all subsidy from Kent Opera, although full information about the company was kept from them. 
 It has emerged that the council had been compelled to discuss the future of Kent Opera at its two-day meeting at Leeds Castle in November because the company had explained that it was on the verge of closure and insolvency. 
 A spokeswoman for the Arts Council said that Kent Opera's three-year plan had been rejected by a group including Mr Peter Palumbo, the council's chairman, Mr Rittner, and Mr Ken Baird, the council's music director, before the music panel met. 
 The Arts Council denied that the panel's opinions were not taken seriously and pointed out the council's method of work. 
 &bquo;The panels advise. 
 The (governing) council (appointed by the Minister for Arts) decide.&equo; 
 A leading member of the music panel said that they had not been informed in advance that the future of Kent Opera would be discussed in November. 
 He had never seen such a sparsely attended panel meeting; the panel had not been given any written papers outlining Kent Opera's financial position. 
 The Arts Council says the information was available. 
 The music panellist said: &bquo;If there had been a full panel meeting and if we had known certain things which were kept from us the decision might have been different. 
 &bquo;Our conclusion was based on a (spoken presentation) by people who had already decided that Kent Opera would lose its subsidy.&equo; 
 Another panel member said they been &bquo;lamentably under-informed&equo;. 
 Cut by a royal blue pencil Points of Order. 
 By Ian Aitken 
 MOST journalists have become inured to the ministrations of sub-editors, a nocturnal breed in traditional green eye-shades who tip our carefully-honed words into the paper. 
 Subs on the Guardian are relatively light-handed, but reporters on some tabloids often have difficulty recognising their own work &mdash; especially if it clashes with the view of the proprietor. 
 But MPs aren't used to that sort of treatment. 
 So it came as something of a shock to Labour's Brian Wilson when he found that a Commons motion he had tabled had been&hellip; well, subbed a bit by the authorities of the House. 
 The motion congratulated the Australian Labour Party on defeating the amazingly right wing Sir Johannes Bjelke-Petersen after 32 years of power in Queensland. 
 But it then went on to make some disparaging remarks about the bestowal of a knighthood on such a person. 
 This represented the honours system at its most farcical, said Mr Wilson's original text. 
 The draft duly appeared on the Commons order paper last Tuesday. 
 But in spite of its long history of resistance to the throne, the Commons still bans direct criticism of the monarch, and it was evidently decided that Mr Wilson's motion implied criticism of the Queen for dubbing Sir Johannes. 
 So an embarrassed clerk in the table office wrote to Mr Wilson, advising him of proposed amendments to his motion. 
 The changes made it clear that it was Bjelke-Petersen, rather than Her Majesty, who was at fault. 
 The changed version appeared on the following day's order paper. 
 Mr Wilson now finds himself declaring his belief that it was &bquo;the conduct of Sir Johannes and his cronies&equo; which discredited the honours system, not the granting of the original accolade. 
 That is no doubt perfectly all right, but it makes you wonder why King Charles ever found it necessary to burst into the Commons with his soldiers, in search of the five rebel members. 
 Why weren't they ruled out of order before they transgressed? 
 TRAINED observers in the press gallery have been rather surprised that the behaviour of MPs has changed so little as a result of the television cameras' arrival. 
 By and large, the nice ones are just as nice and the nasty ones not much nastier. 
 Two members, however, seem to have undergone a major personality change. 
 One is the Prime Minister, who now bills and coos where she used to bellow. 
 The other is Mr Jerry Hayes, the Conservative member for Harlow. 
 Mrs Thatcher's transformation may have more to do with her political circumstances &mdash; i.e, isolation in a predominantly pro-European Cabinet &mdash; than with television. 
 But she certainly underwent pre-TV training, and so did Mr Hayes. 
 Readers of this column will be aware that Mr Hayes was once a fierce critic of the Government's running of the health service. 
 He has now become a passionate enthusiast for the Clarke reforms, and he made a speech of spectacular sycophancy in support of the health service bill on Monday. 
 But it isn't just his translation from rebel into loyalist which is startling, it is also his physical change. 
 He used to wear yellow ties and trendily-cut suits in eye-catching colours. 
 He appeared before his peers on Monday in the darkest of clerical grey. 
 This seems to be the deplorable advice which the image builders are giving to their political clients. 
 No unusual views and definitely no unusual gear. 
 ROGER STOTT, one of Labour's Northern Ireland spokesmen, was sipping a nightcap in a Belfast hotel recently and listening with genuine appreciation to a guitarist, when someone started taking flashlight snaps. 
 The guitarist stopped, throwing up his hand protectively. 
 &bquo;No pictures for security reasons,&equo; he barked. 
 Then he added: &bquo;Social security reasons.&equo; 
 DENNIS SKINNER, the Bolsover MP who has terrorised generations of ministers from his place below the gangway, has made a little bit of history this week. 
 Breaking the habit of a lifetime, he has joined a Commons standing committee. 
 This means that Mr Skinner, who voted in more Commons divisions than any other MP last session, will have to absent himself occasionally from the chamber. 
 And why is he depriving himself of voting regularly? 
 Because Mr Skinner is a former miner and the committee he has joined will be dealing with a bill to give the private sector a bigger share in the coal industry. 
 No fair share-out in privatisation. 
 By David Brindle, Social Services Correspondent 
 PRIVATISATION sales have only partially extended share ownership to all social groups, suggests the first comprehensive survey of shareholding. 
 Although the proportion of people owning shares has trebled, from 7 per cent to 21 per cent between 1984 and 1987, the typical investor in privatisations is a middle-aged professional man in the South-east. 
 Share ownership among young people, women, manual workers, people in the North, Wales and Scotland, and non-homeowners remains relatively low. 
 This detailed picture of the much-vaunted new share-owning democracy is presented in the 1987 General Household Survey, conducted by the Office of Population Censuses and Surveys, published yesterday. 
 Questions about shareholdings were put in 1987 for the first time, at the request of the Treasury, anxious to confirm and expand the conclusions of previous surveys by market research groups. 
 The 21 per cent figure for share ownership compares with estimates of 19 or 20 per cent produced by such surveys. 
 Eight per cent &mdash; more than a third of all shareowners &mdash; had investments only in privatised companies. 
 A quarter of men owned shares but only 17 per cent of women; 29 per cent of people aged 45-54 and 30 per cent of those aged 55-64 had shares, but only 18 per cent of those aged 25-34. 
 More than half all adults earning more than &pound;350 a week were shareowners. 
 The average weekly income of a shareowner was &pound;196, compared to &pound;118 for the survey sample as a whole, although the average of those owning shares in privatised companies alone was &pound;168. 
 Of this latter group, 39 per cent were classified in manual occupations, compared to 33 per cent for shareowners as a whole and 28 per cent of those who owned non-privatisation shares. 
 Only 8 per cent of people owning privatisation shares alone rented their home from a local authority or housing association, compared with 6 per cent of those owning other shares, although 25 per cent of the sample were such tenants. 
 Share ownership is shown to be most common in London and the South-east, both in general and for those holding privatisation shares alone. 
 General Household Survey 1987; HMSO; &pound;13.90 
 Man from the FO scuttles two dreams at a stroke Sketch. 
 By Andrew Rawnsley 
 HOW terrible it can be when your dreams come true. 
 For years Douglas Hurd had a dream. 
 In that dream he saw a vision of loveliness: himself as Foreign Secretary. 
 Moreover, a humane, liberal, decent sort of Tory Foreign Secretary. 
 For years the Vietnamese boat people had a dream. 
 In that dream they saw a new life in a humane, liberal, decent West, run by people like Douglas Hurd. 
 They escaped tyranny, risked drowning and piracy, endured years in stinking, cholera-infested camps, in pursuit of their dream. 
 In pursuit of his, Mr Hurd endured several years in the worst jobs in Mrs Thatcher's Cabinets. 
 One day Mr Hurd woke up to find that he was the Foreign Secretary, pinched himself, and found that his first big job was forcibly deporting the boat people in Hong Kong back to Vietnam. 
 That's where their dream ended, too. 
 It was an untypically uncomfortable Foreign Secretary at the despatch box yesterday. 
 The hands that normally give the despatch box a confident caress gripped it in white-knuckled nervousness. 
 The usual pepper-grinder voice sounded unconfident and a little furtive. 
 The Prime Minister, at question time, was also very defensive. 
 Pressed to explain themselves, both Mr Hurd and Mrs Thatcher were full of injured guilt. 
 Neither he, nor she, could quite bring themselves to use the bald words &bquo;forcible repatriation&equo; for the planeloads of refugees being flown back to Hanoi, 30 Hong Kong dollars a head, cash on delivery. 
 &bquo;It's perfectly in order to return illegal immigrants to their country of origin,&equo; she said. 
 Deportations had been, he said, &bquo;in line with procedures used worldwide to remove people refused permission to remain in a territory&equo;. 
 Both had clearly spent the morning raiding the dictionary of euphemism. 
 Neil Kinnock and Gerald Kaufman had been as busy on the thesaurus of outrage. 
 &bquo;Tyrannical&hellip; indefensible&hellip; shameful,&equo; from Neil Kinnock. 
 &bquo;The policy of the three o'clock knock by police,&equo; from Gerald Kaufman. 
 &bquo;What would you do?,&equo; shouted the Tories. 
 A fair question, which didn't get much of an answer. 
 Mr Kinnock was at his best when going easier on the general outrage, and harder on the specific details of the operation. 
 &bquo;What excuse,&equo; he asked Mrs Thatcher, &bquo;have you got for giving instructions that in the middle of the night, armed riot police raid children, women and men, shove them into caged lorries and forcibly deport them to the country from which they fled?&equo; 
 &bquo;The police were not armed,&equo; she replied. 
 Ah, that's all right then. 
 What the Government really could have done without were attempts by some of its backbenchers to actually extract some moral credit from this episode. 
 Sir Peter Blaker, the Conservative MP for Blackpool South, wanted the Foreign Secretary to &bquo;accept my congratulations on taking a courageous and correct step&equo;. 
 Michael Heseltine offered his praise for this &bquo;very lonely and courageous decision&equo;. 
 This was a novel definition of courage from the Blaker-Heseltine dictionary. 
 Courage: to use riot police to round up and deport women and children against their will. 
 Mr Hurd had the grace to turn down their praise. 
 &bquo;We now,&equo; announced the Speaker, &bquo;come to the debate on War Crimes.&equo; 
 Just one of those unfortunate coincidences. 
 Let's hope. 
 Britain trails in right of confidence. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 JOURNALISTS in some European countries and in America have stronger rights to protect sources of confidential information than their British counterparts. 
 Sweden goes furthest, with legislation focusing on informers' rather than journalists' rights, and imposing an obligation on those working in the media to protect sources of confidential information. 
 &bquo;Very serious grounds are needed to infringe anonymity, and it is generally accepted even by the Swedish judiciary that the public's right to be informed takes precedence over law and order considerations,&equo; said Ms Frances D'Souza, director of Article 19, the International Campaign against Censorship. 
 Similar laws are being considered in Norway. 
 In America 26 of the 50 states have published &bquo;shield&equo; laws allowing journalists to protect their sources, with certain exceptions which generally apply only if the information is relevant, cannot be obtained in any other way, and public interest is better served by disclosure than by keeping the source confidential. 
 In Britain the Contempt of Court Act 1981 allows a court to order disclosure if necessary in the interests of justice or national security, or for the prevention of disorder or crime. 
 Justice in this context has been defined in one case as &bquo;the administration of justice in the course of legal proceedings in a court of law&equo;. 
 This could allow the court, as in the Goodwin case, to order a reporter to reveal his notes so the company whose information was leaked would know who to sue. 
 The US Supreme Court ruled in the 1970s that a black journalist had to reveal his source of information about the Black Panthers to a criminal grand jury. 
 A journalist in the US would rarely be subpoenaed to testify except in a fairly serious criminal case, according to Mr James Michael, senior lecturer in communication and information law at University College, London. 
 &bquo;A company would be highly unlikely to get a journalist into court for the purpose of getting information about someone they had a claim against,&equo; said Mr Michael, an American lawyer specialising in international media law. 
 &bquo;It would also be almost impossible for the plaintiff in a civil action to get an anonymity order for himself, as the company has in the Goodwin case.&equo; 
 In America a journalist was sent to prison for refusing to disclose information which could have revealed the innocence of a person on trial, but prison would not normally be an option in a civil case. 
 There is a growing trend towards greater protection for journalists' sources in Europe, according to Ms D'Souza. 
 &bquo;In West Germany, for example, journalists can refuse to give testimony, and Spain has incorporated the right to protect sources in its new constitution.&equo; 
 A West German journalist who interviewed a man claiming to be an IRA terrorist won a court ruling last week upholding his right to protect his sources and forbidding the federal prosecutor's office from questioning him. 
 US outlines vision for new Europe. 
 By Anna Tomforde in Bonn and John Palmer in Strasbourg 
 THE US yesterday linked support for East Germany's new leaders with a new vision for a changing Europe in which Nato would adopt a more political role and Washington's ties with the European Community would be enhanced. 
 After outlining Washington's response to the recent changes in Eastern Europe, the Secretary of State, Mr James Baker, made an unscheduled visit to East Germany where he held talks with the new Prime Minister, Mr Hans Modrow. 
 It was the first time that a US Secretary of State held official talks with East German leaders on their own territory, underlining Washington fears that a collapse of the East German reform process could imperil developments throughout Eastern Europe. 
 In what he called &bquo;a new architecture for a new era&equo;, Mr Baker outlined closer co-operation between Western Europe and the US which would bind the West closer together while at the same time &bquo;opening up the doors to the East&equo;. 
 Washington, he said, stood by its commitment to overcome the division of Europe, Germany and Berlin, but this had to come about in a gradual process which satisfied German aspirations and met the &bquo;legitimate interests&equo; of all concerned. 
 Mr Baker declared his support for the EC &bquo;taking on increasingly important political roles&equo;. 
 His remarks &mdash; to the Berlin press club &mdash; were received gleefully by senior EC officials in Strasbourg as evidence of US support for their view about how the community should evolve in the new European situation. 
 His views appear to contradict Mrs Thatcher's statement to the House of Commons that US policy towards European integration had not changed under President Bush. 
 In Potsdam &mdash; where the Prussian kings had their summer seat and where the wartime allies in 1945 decided the future of defeated Nazi Germany &mdash; Mr Baker assured Mr Modrow of US support for East German reforms. 
 &bquo;We wanted to let the people of East Germany know about our support for the reforms taking place in this country,&equo; Mr Baker said later. 
 Mr Modrow said German reunification was not discussed at the one-hour meeting but the two sides had agreed to turn their dialogue &bquo;into co-operation&equo;. 
 In his West Berlin speech on a New Europe and a New Atlanticism, Mr Baker, who had earlier held talks with Chancellor Helmut Kohl, proposed strengthening Washington's links with the EC, possibly through a new treaty that would give the US a formal presence in EC institutions. 
 Overlaps between Nato and European institutions would inevitably grow, Mr Baker said. 
 Nato should be transformed into a political body capable of building a new security structure for Europe. 
 &bquo;In our view there is no conflict between the process of European integration and an extension of the co-operation between the European Community and its neighbours in East and West.&equo; 
 He described Nato as a forum where Western countries would work together to negotiate agreements between East and West and see that they were implemented and verifiable. 
 As Nato's military role was reduced, the European Security Conference could become the &bquo;most important forum of East-West co-operation&equo;. 
 In a passage likely to upset Mrs Thatcher's belief in a &bquo;special relationship&equo; between London and Washington, he suggested that the US and the EC &bquo;work together to achieve, whether in treaty or some other form, a significantly strengthened set of institutional and consultative links. 
 We suggest that our discussions about this idea proceed in parallel with Europe's efforts to achieve by 1992 a common internal market so that plans for interaction turn to page 24, col 2 
 Baker outlines new vision continued from page one would evolve with changes in the community,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Baker also proposed establishing a permanent Nato arms control verification staff to monitor compliance with arms reduction and confidence building measures. 
 After his talks with Mr Baker, Chancellor Kohl toned down his enthusiasm for moves toward German unity. 
 One day after the four wartime allies underlined their interest in stability, he stressed Bonn's &bquo;vital interest in stability&equo;. 
 In East Berlin, Pastor Rainer Eppelmann, chairman of Democratic Awakening, called for a transitional government to be installed before Christmas. 
 The Communist Party newspaper, Neues Deutschland, in a draft proposal for a new party programme, admitted that &bquo;state-administered socialism&equo; had proved a failure. 
 EC urged to help, page 8; Wider powers sought, page 8; Commentary, page 23 
 22COMMENT THE GUARDIANWednesday December 13 1989 The grim cargo of lost dreams. 
 EVERY day of the year, blue Hong Kong police buses with barred windows climb to the border with the Peoples Republic. 
 There, without ceremony and possibility of reprieve, an average of 50 men and women, the day's catch of illegal immigrants, are bundled back into China. 
 The number repatriated in this way has amounted to tens of thousands annually since 1980, when the present rules were instituted &mdash; a figure not too far from that of the boat people whom Britain and Hong Kong governments expect to send home to Vietnam. 
 It is a comparison which should give pause to those tempted automatically to condemn the Government. 
 Every day of the year, all over the world, governments work to control and manage the flows of migrants that wars, disasters, and, above all, the magnetic pull of centres of economic and cultural power, keep in constant motion. 
 Sometimes this means making extraordinary efforts to deal with desperate human need on a mass scale. 
 Sometimes it means making judicious individual decisions about marriages and family relationships. 
 And sometimes &mdash; often &mdash; it means sending people back, by force if necessary. 
 Heart and head pull against each other. 
 There can be no reasonable argument about migrants if one side takes the position that nobody should ever be sent back to anywhere, that the mere act of emigration in itself constitutes grounds for supposing that circumstances were unbearable in the country of origin. 
 But that is the position which some of the Government's critics seem now to occupy. 
 It is particularly illogical that this kind of argument should be coming from politicians who, in other contexts, would be the first to argue, and rightly, that Vietnam is not some kind of monster State, but merely a ramshackle and inefficient one that has lost its way. 
 It is a miserable and heart-breaking business to take peasant families who left Vietnam's poor northern provinces with visions of a new life in America dancing in their heads, who endured dangerous sea voyages, and who believed that Hong Kong's camps, however dreadful, were a way station to their dream &mdash; to take these families and to return them to the red dirt farms and meagre fishing villages from which they came. 
 And of course they will suffer consequences &mdash; at the very least those of wasted time and lost opportunities. 
 But neither London nor Hong Kong can legislate for dreams which are no longer capable of realisation. 
 The United States will not take these people. 
 Other affluent Western countries, which the migrants would accept as second best, won't take them either. 
 It is no good saying that, if Britain made a special effort, it might be able to persuade the United States and other countries to change their minds. 
 About this 40,000, maybe; but not about the next 40,000 who would fill the camps as soon as they were cleared. 
 Indeed, at root, that is what this dismal affair is all about. 
 It is about sending a clear signal to the villages of Quang Ninh and Ha Giang and Lang Son that there is no longer a road to Los Angeles by way of Hong Kong or, for that matter, of Thailand or Malaysia. 
 That road came into being after the end of the Vietnam war in 1975. 
 Along it came, at first, ex-soldiers and civil servants of the losing regime, men escaping detention or worse, middle class families pushed to the margins of society by new authorities with more ideology than common sense, southern farmers stripped of their affluence by misguided economic programmes. 
 America led the way in setting up an international system for dealing with the Indochina refugees. 
 The United States wished to discharge its debts to those with whom it had fought during the war; but it also came to see the volume of refugees as a kind of continuing proof that it had waged a just struggle against evil forces. 
 That is how a system for dealing with genuine refugees &mdash; the losers in Indochina's civil wars &mdash; became insensibly a system for turning North Vietnamese peasants into New York waiters. 
 As the number of former South Vietnamese army majors and persecuted intellectuals drifted down to infinitesimal proportions and the number of economic migrants grew, the United States looked the other way. 
 Vietnam was an evil State, the number of boat people coming out proved it; therefore any measures to discourage the refugees would be wrong. 
 It is a measure of hypocrisy that, at the same time, the United States took fewer and fewer of the migrants. 
 But, since last year's Geneva conference on Indochina refugees, all of the concerned countries, including the United States, have agreed that the flow of economic migrants from Vietnam should be stopped. 
 The only difference is between those countries, naturally not the most directly affected, who can pretend that voluntary repatriation will work, and those, like Hong Kong, who know it will not. 
 The inevitable short-term aim is to affect the decisions of would-be migrants. 
 There is, in glum reality, only one thing that will affect that: the knowledge that they will be sent back. 
 That has been the dilemma for Hong Kong &mdash; the necessity of staunching the flow &mdash; and they deserve understanding for a decision that carries all manner of risks for their own future as 1997 nears. 
 But it needs to be said clearly, too, that there is a longer term. 
 That, in an age of wonders in the Communist world, involves a fresh Western approach to the heart of the matter, the hopeless poverty of Vietnam. 
 Nobody should be too blithe here either. 
 Mr Douglas Hurd in the House yesterday shuffled uneasily between Washington wrath and Hanoi despair. 
 Nonetheless, as the Government endures months of opprobrium, there is a clear imperative to begin addressing the long-term, and small ways to make a start. 
 Vietnam, remember, shares with Argentina the distinction of being a country where the British Government doesn't match the aid resources of non-governmental relief organisations like Oxfam. 
 Getting moving here won't mitigate the despair; but it would at least show some capacity to think beyond the sourly inescapable. 
 Hot off the press. 
 YESTERDAY, by neat irony, featured the morning of the Master of the Rolls and the afternoon of the Press Council. 
 Before lunch, Lord Donaldson pronounced further on the case of William Goodwin, 23-year-old journalist for The Engineer. 
 &bquo;Notwithstanding the general need to protect journalistic sources,&equo; he said, &bquo;this is a case where the balance comes down in favour of disclosure.&equo; 
 After tea, the Press Council published &mdash; for further discussion &mdash; its 119-page self-reforming review, including a new code of practice. 
 In that code you will find the following injunction. 
 &bquo;Journalists have a professional obligation to protect confidential sources of information.&equo; 
 A general need: a professional obligation. 
 Two texts for our increasingly beleaguered times. 
 The Press Council review has seemed an age in gestation; and it is not in all respects wonderful. 
 Those who fought through the months to make it a much leaner, quicker body exercising true peer group pressure will be a touch disappointed. 
 The prospective councillors will number two dozen (rather than the sparse but active dozen originally sought); there will continue to be a rather odd balance of journalists and lay members, selected rather than nominated by a quangoid committee. 
 The weight of bureaucracy still hangs a trifle heavy. 
 Nevertheless, the review represents substantial progress. 
 It holds out the promise of swifter verdicts. 
 It appends that promise to a clear and comprehensive code of conduct (one that builds helpfully on the recently published Fleet Street set of principles). 
 And it adds to the sanctions the Council may take &mdash; positioning of judgements in offending papers; a privacy hot line; and, more controversially, hauling in proprietors to discipline editors. 
 The Council, in sum, is seeking most of the tools it needs to relaunch itself as an active, respected self-regulator. 
 It sees ways of making certain that small points of correction are dealt with speedily, and thus the chance of devoting extra energy to the broader guidelines and the delineation of greater issues. 
 This is the crucial change. 
 Through most of its existence, the Council has viewed itself as a slightly pettifogging, rather legalistic arbitrator. 
 But there was an introversion to that which meant that too few readers of too many newspapers knew what it was there for. 
 That was bad for newspapers and bad for the Council: but, worst of all, it meant that there was no independent body able to speak up for press freedoms under threat. 
 Perhaps, as the review gathers steam, this can now change. 
 It needs to. 
 The entrails of the law have been choking press freedoms throughout the nineteen eighties. 
 (Look back to the supposedly liberalising 1981 Contempt of Court Act and ask yourself whether its parliamentary proponents intended the general outcome that Lord Donaldson now proclaims). 
 The future &mdash; and the hope of escaping yet more damaging legislation &mdash; rests on greater attention to the Council and greater respect for its findings. 
 In short, professional regulation for a rough trade aspiring to become a profession (with the professional responsibilities invoked above). 
 This is not, in all respects, an appealing road. 
 Journalists aren't barristers or doctors. 
 They are imperfect players in an imperfect democracy; and they are there, from time to time, to write and investigate things that the closed worlds of the British professions would grind their teeth over. 
 A truly free press is a press which irritates and infuriates along the way. 
 A reformed Press Council, by these lights, tugs in the wrong, conformist direction (and, see its proferred code, is a sight too deferential to great and good bodies, like itself, who want to make papers toe the line). 
 But such philosophical dissent, at this point, is the stuff of dreams in a dreamworld. 
 As the Fleet Street editors themselves recognised a couple of weeks ago, many British papers have forfeited the strength on which their freedom depends: they are not seen as the defenders of freedom by their own readers. 
 With that relationship gone, they are at the mercy of more laws and more political meddling. 
 In which case, the only respite is too regain vestiges of trust; and the only clear mechanism for that is the over-arching responsibility of the Press Council. 
 Louis Blom-Cooper and his team made a reasonably promising start yesterday. 
 They deserve a brisk and supportive response from the industry. 
 They want to be the court of principle and last resort for British press standards. 
 It is crucial that they be given a wholehearted, well-funded chance; for otherwise the court of last resort may turn out to be the one where the Master of the Rolls holds sway. 
 Letters to the Editor PAGE 
 &bquo;Tyrannical&equo;, says Kinnock Question time. 
 Martin Linton. 
 THE Prime Minister yesterday defended the deportation of boat people from Hong Kong against a combined attack from opposition leaders. 
 &bquo;It's perfectly in order to return illegal immigrants to their country of origin, otherwise there would be international chaos,&equo; she told MPs at question time. 
 Those countries which were protesting about the repatriation would do far better if they offered to take some of the boat people themselves. 
 The Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, said she was trying to defend the indefensible. 
 &bquo;What excuse has she got for giving instructions that, in the middle of the night, armed riot police raid children, women and men, shove them into caged lorries and forcibly deport them to the country from which they fled? 
 &bquo;Doesn't the Prime Minister realise that she is the only person in this whole shameful episode that can't make the excuse that I was only obeying orders, because she was the person giving the orders &mdash; and the orders are tyrannical.&equo; 
 But the Prime Minister dismissed his remarks as &bquo;feeble and nonsense&equo;. 
 The police were not armed and there was nothing unusual about returning illegal immigrants. 
 They put something like 30,000 Chinese refugees back over the border each year and it was a custom of international law that such immigrants are received back, she said. 
 Mr Kinnock could not go on &bquo;inflicting his anger on the people of Hong Kong&equo;. 
 They were the people who were already &bquo;suffering greatly from having some 57,000 boat people there and more and more and more would come when the season came for them to leave Vietnam.&equo; 
 The Liberal Democrat leader, Mr Paddy Ashdown, asked her to reconsider the &bquo;shameful example&equo; set by her Government's actions not only in sending the riot police in at the dead of night but in the blanket of secrecy surrounding the appeals tribunals which decided who were refugees. 
 People had been condemned without any rights to attend the tribunals, to have legal representation, to judicial review, or even to know why decisions had been taken against them. 
 Was this was &bquo;a good example to be setting to the Chinese Government&equo;? 
 But the Prime Minister replied that each person had a right of appeal against tribunal decisions and that a report by the British Refugee Council had indicated how excellent the system was. 
 &bquo;Those countries which have shown anger about it have not even agreed to take any of the 13,000 genuine refugees for whom we are still seeking a home.&equo; 
 MPs support war crimes trials. 
 By Martin Linton 
 MPs voted by 348 votes to 123 last night in favour of legislating to allow the prosecution of alleged war criminals now living in Britain for crimes committed in Germany or German-occupied territory during the last war. 
 The Home Secretary, Mr David Waddington, said the Government had not yet decided whether to go ahead with a bill, but his personal view was that it should accept the report of the War Crimes Inquiry to change the law. 
 The report by Sir Thomas Hetherington, the former Director of Public Prosecutions, and Mr William Chalmers estimated that there were three cases in Britain where the evidence was sufficient to bring a prosecution and up to 124 cases worthy of investigation. 
 His wish was not to rake over the past of men who had lived peacefully in this country since they came to Britain as refugees after the war, he said. 
 But the facts in the Hetherington report could not be buried. 
 &bquo;We are not talking of excesses or cruelty by soldiers on soldiers in the heat of battle. 
 We are talking about premeditated acts of cold-blooded mass murder perpetrated upon defenceless citizens.&equo; 
 Mr Roy Hattersley, the shadow Home Secretary, said he was deeply uneasy about rushing legislation through Parliament to try suspects who had already been named. 
 He questioned whether it would be possible to prosecute them with any chance of success with the present rules of evidence and he would be against proceeding if it meant changing the way in which the courts worked. 
 But he believed in principle the prosecutions should continue. 
 The former prime minister, Mr Edward Heath, said he had not heard one convincing argument which would lead him to support legislation to change the whole legal system in order to bring these alleged war criminals to trial. 
 The Tory Party had always opposed retrospective legislation. 
 &bquo;If we had wanted to deal with it at the time, we should have taken the action then.&equo; 
 In a free vote, cabinet members who supported the proposal were: Mrs Thatcher, Mr Kenneth Clarke, Mr Douglas Hurd, Mr Norman Lamont, Mr John MacGregor, Mr Cecil Parkinson, Mr Chris Patten, Mr Malcolm Rifkind and Mr Waddington. 
 Against were: Mr John Major, Mr Tony Newton and Mr Nicholas Ridley. 
 Most Labour MPs voted for the motion, most Liberal Democrats, including Mr Paddy Ashdown, voted against &mdash; as did Dr David Owen. 
 Europe airlifting flu vaccines to replenish British stocks. 
 By Stephen Cook 
 AN EMERGENCY airlift of flu vaccine from Europe was under way last night as stocks dwindled in Britain and the epidemic showed no sign of abating. 
 The Department of Health said tests would begin today on the vaccines to make sure they met British standards. 
 About 180,000 doses are expected within the next few days. 
 But the Influenza Monitoring and Information Bureau in London said the Department could waive or accelerate the tests if the vaccines had been adequately tested in other countries. 
 Three more hospitals in the north began taking only emergency cases &mdash; the Newcastle-upon-Tyne general hospital, the Newcastle Royal Victoria Infirmary, and the Derbyshire Royal Infirmary. 
 Some hospitals have lost 15 per cent of their nurses and in the south Ashford hospital, Surrey is using Red Cross volunteers. 
 About one in 10 health districts have hospitals on &bquo;red alert&equo; &mdash; admitting emergencies only. 
 Many others are on &bquo;yellow alert&equo; &mdash; limited routine operations. 
 A survey by the drugs company Beecham shows the incidence of flu is between 25 and 71 per cent higher than at this time last year. 
 The North and Scotland are worst hit. 
 Veteran looks back in anguish Wednesday People. 
 Dennis Barker. 
 WHEN he was 28, Dick Trafford went to work in Ormskirk as an ambulance driver in a workhouse, where the elderly poor worked for their keep. 
 When he was 50, he and his wife took over, as superintendent and matron, the old Oldham workhouse which had by then, under the National Health Service, become the Westlands Old People's Home. 
 He and most others thought workhouse conditions gone for good. 
 But yesterday, on his 91st birthday, Trafford, whose wife died in sheltered accommodation four years ago, told a community nursing conference in London that, though a Tory voter all his life who thought most of what Mrs Thatcher was doing was good, he saw a danger that old people might be heading back towards the workhouse if the Government went ahead with NHS cuts and changes in community care. 
 The spokesman for the First World War Veterans' Association, Trafford joined up at 15 on the first day of the war, giving his age as 18. 
 In the King's Liverpool Regiment, he went through Loos, the Somme, and Passchendaele and was wounded twice &mdash; a thumb torn off by shrapnel, his neck pierced by a bullet. 
 In 1926, when he became an ambulance driver at Ormskirk workhouse &bquo;conditions were not tip-top&equo;. 
 Men had to wear rough cotton shirts and white corduroy jackets and trousers, to be easily visible. 
 The able-bodied had to saw up old railway sleepers and then chop up the pieces for sale as firewood. 
 One day a week, the men were allowed a dark suit to go out for the day to visit friends or relatives. 
 They were given an ounce of twist tobacco a week and two at Christmas, when they were also given a pint of beer. 
 &bquo;Old people get pensions now, so much pocket money in old people's homes and better clothing. 
 But the government is cutting down. 
 I should think it is working the way of bringing back the workhouse through having too much economy.&equo; 
 If Tories like him are wobbling, can softer voters be far behind? 
 Dick Trafford: fears for the elderly 
 Bakery workers begin voting on series of one-day strikes. 
 CHRISTMAS bread supplies will be at risk if bakery workers, who started voting on a pay offer yesterday, reject the deal. 
 Mr Joe Marino, general secretary of the Bakers, Food and Allied Workers, predicted a close vote. 
 He said no bread would be baked this Sunday in the first of a series of one-day strikes if the 9,000 workers who produce nearly 80 per cent of loaves throw out the deal. 
 Shop stewards have recommended accepting the offer of just under 9 per cent &mdash; worth &pound;10 a week to most bakers &mdash; two extra days' holiday by April 1991 to make five weeks a year, and other benefits, including better sick pay. 
 The employers on Friday increased their offer of 7.6 per cent and one extra day's holiday, in answer to a 10 per cent demand with two extra days now. 
 The employers, the Federation of Bakers, are dominated by British Bakeries and Allied Bakeries. 
 Party host guilty of killing friend. 
 BENJAMIN Bream, stepson of the guitarist Julian Bream, was yesterday found guilty of stabbing a friend to death during an argument at a party. 
 An Old Bailey jury convicted Bream, aged 28, of the manslaughter of a building worker, Mr Sean Foster. 
 Bream, an antiques restorer of Barnes, south London, was cleared of murder. 
 His co-defendant, Alison O'Leary &mdash; Foster's girlfriend &mdash; was convicted of wounding Bream and assaulting a woman guest. 
 Both Bream and O'Leary, aged 21, will be sentenced today by Mr Justice Judge. 
 Mr James Curtis, for the prosecution, told the court the stabbing took place during a row at the party held at Bream's flat in January this year. 
 Bream stabbed Mr Foster, aged 24, so violently through the heart that the tip of the knife blade was bent against his spine. 
 At the start of the trial, Mr Curtis said the stabbing was &bquo;an example of the tragedy that can follow when people in anger resort to the use of knives&equo;. 
 Bream, who had been adopted by Mrs Margaret Bream before she married the guitarist, had been drinking with friends at local pubs on the day of the killing. 
 They took a crate of beer back to his flat in his mother's home. 
 O'Leary accused her boyfriend of flirting. 
 When Bream intervened, he found himself locked in a &bquo;major battle&equo; with Foster. 
 Bream armed himself with a knife. 
 After the stabbing, the jury heard, Bream was seen holding a bloodstained bread knife &mdash; but it was not the fatal weapon. 
 Mr Foster, also of Barnes, was found lying on the floor with the knife that had killed him under his body. 
 Neither Bream nor O'Leary gave evidence. 
 Bream's counsel, Mr Charles Tilling suggested in his closing speech that another person at the party had carried out the fatal knife attack. 
 RSPB gains High Court hearing on Medway estuary dredging. 
 THE Royal Society for the Protection of Birds was yesterday given leave to challenge in the High Court a development scheme which it fears will damage the environment. 
 The scheme involves dredging the main channel of the Medway estuary to provide a storage base for import-export cargoes. 
 Mr Justice Hodgson, ordering an early judicial review rejected the argument of Swale borough council, which gave the planning permission in August, and the Medway Ports Authority, that the hearing could cost millions in disruption to works contracts, lacked a proper legal basis, and had not been brought promptly enough. 
 The reclamation would involve dumping the dredged material on the estuary's Lappel bank. 
 Dr Michael Clarke, the society's south-east England regional conservation officer, said yesterday: &bquo;The Medway estuary is recognised internationally as a conservation area, particularly for birdlife, and that is why we have taken this step of seeking judicial review.&equo; 
 The society will argue at the full hearing that it had a legitimate expectation that it would be consulted by the council. 
 Part of the area has been designated as a site of special scientific interest under the 1981 Wildlife and Countryside Act and special protection has been sought under the Ramsar Convention on Wetlands of International Importance. 
 The society says that, before planning permission could be given, the development proposal should include an environmental assessment report under the 1988 town and country planning (assessment of environmental effects) regulations. 
 No report was obtained by the ports authority. 
 Another day. 
 December 13, 1915, Hotel Beau Rivage, Bandol, to J.MMurry: My dear Heart, a week ago today you went. 
 The day seemed very long yesterday. 
 After giving your letter to my &bquo;bonne&equo; yesterday I gave up the fight and retired in good order to bed, where I am still. 
 The day seemed very long yesterday but I must say my &bquo;bonne&equo; was very good to me. 
 She gave me an extra pillow, kept me supplied with boiling bottles, brought me Vichy, and my meals on a little round table, actually produced a bottle of alcool camphre &amp; frictioned me &amp; gave me some lime flower tea before I went to sleep. 
 Not counting the number of times she put her fat face round the door &amp; said, nodding and smiling as only a Frenchwoman can, with an air of delighted gaiety (!) 
 &bquo;Vous souffrez toujours&equo;. 
 Shes the only creature I've seen&hellip; 
 Kay's money has come and as I am spending nothing else it will be perfectly alright. 
 It is such a beautiful day today. 
 There seems to be a ring of light round everything &mdash; It is still and sunny &mdash; so still you could hear a spider spin. 
 I dreamed last night that I sat by a fire with Grandmother &amp; my brother &amp; when I woke up I still felt my brother's hand. 
 That is true. 
 For my hands were not together &mdash; They were holding another hand &mdash; I felt the weight and the warmth of it for quite a long time&hellip; 
 (The Collected Letters of Katherine Mansfield, Oxford, 1984: her only brother had been killed in France two months before.) 
 December 13, 1956: Dear Bunny, There are some delightful, first-rate pieces in your book, such as the one about your father and the first of the two about the Jews, but I am as always distressed by your conception of Russian history, which is all wrong, being based on the stale Bolshevist propaganda which you imbibed in your youth. 
 I cannot understand how you, who appreciate so much Russian writers of the Nineteenth Century, can combine this appreciation with a complete ignorance of the obshchestvennoe dvizhenie (liberal movement) that started in the time of Alexander I, was conspicuously present throughout the century (despite absolutism), and was deliberately played down by the Leninists and Trotskyists for propaganda reasons. 
 We have been always frank with each other, and I know that you will find my criticism exhilarating. 
 The Nabokov-Wilson Letters 1940-1971, edited by Simon Karlinsky (Weidenfeld &amp; Nicolson, 1979) 
 A Country Diary: OXFORDSHIRE: When, during the October gales, the ground beneath my Sturmer Pippin was strewn with windfalls, I attempted to harvest the remnant, but found that they were still firmly affixed to their spurs, and that those which had fallen had been wrenched off, spurs and all. 
 This fine old variety, raised in Suffolk about 150 years ago, owes its aromatic flavour to another good old apple, Ribston Pippin, which was one of its parents. 
 But, as a commercially viable variety in our climate, it has two drawbacks, firstly its lateness in ripening, and, secondly, in normal British weather, a dull russety-greenish colour which does not suggest the hidden flavour. 
 But, thanks to the sunny summer, many of the topmost specimens on my tree are as flushed with orange and pink as the imported stock from Australia. 
 Although it is assumed that birds have not a highly developed sense of taste, both tits and blackbirds, despite any flamboyant coloration to attract them, recognise Sturmers as worthy of attention, and those out of reach, when harder weather prevails, will, as in former winters, attract both fieldfares and winter-visiting blackcaps. 
 In his comprehensive Apples Of England, Dr Taylor states that &bquo;In England this variety only reaches full maturity in years of hot summers,&equo; and goes on to say that &bquo;Indeed, November- December-picked Sturmers are the best,&equo; and, with a basket-full of fine specimens picked for the first time ever in the latter month, I agree. 
 A further bonus, as I now live alone and do my own catering, is that Sturmer is an excellent cooker. 
 W. D. CAMPBELL 
 Obituary: Dr Jack Kahn. 
 A cure for Job:. 
 ONE of the luminaries of child psychiatry has left us. 
 Jack Kahn graduated with honours at the University of Leeds in 1928 and achieved an MD from the same university. 
 Influential in child psychiatry for over thirty years, Kahn moved into that field from the excellent springboard of general practice. 
 He served with distinction in the child psychiatry section of the Royal College of Psychiatrists and was a Founder Fellow of that body. 
 His monument in clinical practice was the model child guidance service in the then Borough of West Ham. 
 To involve related professions as closely as he did was an innovation at that time. 
 So was his emphasis on the preventive aspects of psychiatry. 
 A phenomenon that tried clinicians was absenteeism from school. 
 Kahn's study of the subject was a landmark. 
 It resulted in a widely read book &bquo;Unwillingly to School.&equo; 
 His father was a rabbi and a biblical text was to create another well known work by the son, &bquo;Job's Illness &mdash; Loss, Grief and Integration.&equo; 
 His interest in child development led to his book &bquo;Human Growth and Development&equo; which is in its third edition. 
 He also wrote extensively in the scientific literature. 
 With marked philosophical leanings, he was an erudite conversationalist &mdash; often with a historical flavouring. 
 He felt keenly about social issues, national and international. 
 To all he gave of himself &mdash; warmly, considerately, and empathically. 
 John Howells Jack Harold Kahn, born March 2, 1904; died December 4, 1989. 
 Archery English will miss S African golds. 
 THE most Anglo-Saxon of games has been found to be compromising with apartheid. 
 The Commonwealth Games Council for England has told archers to end a 30-year tradition of competing with a South African organisation. 
 The council has asked the Grand National Archery Association to stop its member counties from holding &bquo;postal shoots&equo; with the Natal Archery Society. 
 It seems that although English greenswards remained innocent of South Africans, score cards from agreed events were exchanged through the mails. 
 John Middleton, the GNAA chief executive, told News From The Centre, an archery magazine, that the Commonwealth Games organisation had &bquo;deemed&equo; the competition &bquo;acceptable&equo; six years ago, but had changed its mind &bquo;due to a minority of British archers bringing politics into sport&equo;. 
 Rugby League Bamford tries to repeat the magic. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 WHEN he resigned from the Great Britain coaching job almost three years ago, it was inevitable that Maurice Bamford would occupy a much less prominent place in Rugby League life. 
 But as he proved at Knowsley Road on Sunday, although he may have descended into relative obscurity he still possesses exceptional powers of motivation, with his Dewsbury side producing the most impressive performance of the Regal Trophy so far. 
 St Helens went into the game having won their previous nine matches. 
 The bookmakers, showing unusual generosity, gave them a 44-point advantage on the handicap betting list. 
 Instead, with only 10 minutes left, Dewsbury led 12-6 and a genuine upset was in the offing. 
 A try from David Tanner levelled the scores, saving the St Helens players from embarrassment but not from the inevitable verbal roasting from their coach, Alex Murphy. 
 Dewsbury almost won, according to Bamford, because they stuck rigidly to their game plan, using a persistent kicking game and cutting off the supply lines to the St Helens backs. 
 The question is: can they get it to work a second time? 
 The likelihood is that St Helens will have had their minds wonderfully concentrated by the experience and should win the replay at Wakefield Trinity tonight to go through to a meeting with Oldham in the quarter-finals on Sunday. 
 With their experienced hooker David Watkinson still struggling for fitness, Dewsbury are likely to retain the same side as Sunday. 
 Their consolation this time is likely to be financial, with a crowd of 3,500 expected &mdash; four times Dewsbury's normal gate. 
 For St Helens, Tea Ropati, the New Zealand centre who was invalided home from the recent tour after only two matches, could make his debut. 
 He was given an ultimatum by Murphy to prove his fitness by Friday but went well in training on Monday. 
 Jonathan Griffiths, the former Welsh rugby union half-back, will play his first full game since September 24 in place of the injured Neil Holding, and Tommy Frodsham could be in contention after recovering from knee ligament damage. 
 But there are doubts about Paul Loughlin, the Great Britain centre, and Tanner. 
 FA Cup second-round replay: Burnley 1, Scunthorpe Utd 1 (aet) Burnley's opening is slammed shut by Daws. 
 By Cynthia Bateman 
 SCUNTHORPE, down to 10 men for more than an hour, equalised, forced extra time and then held out for a second replay. 
 The only thing they lost was the toss of the coin that decided they would play at Turf Moor again on Monday. 
 Scunthorpe's faithful few in a crowd of 7,682 had huddled on the terraces like penguins on an ice floe as the dankness seeped down the Pennine valleys. 
 Their team froze in the face of the opening blast from Burnley, which brought a 27th-minute goal from Roger Eli. 
 He came on for the injured Mumby and headed in a perfect Measham cross to score his first goal for the club. 
 Litchfield, who had kept Scunthorpe in the competition by saving a late penalty in the game at Glanford Park, almost gave this one away in the opening minutes when he dropped the ball at the feet of Ronnie Futcher. 
 But the angle was too acute for the veteran striker. 
 Understandably on an East Lancashire night as cold as a tomb, Scunthorpe took a while to warm up. 
 But just before half-time the blood started to circulate as Hamilton and Marshall had close-range shots blocked by the reflex responses of Pearce. 
 Scunthorpe's Stevenson was cautioned and then sent off in the space of 60 seconds, and while Burnley tried to take advantage the visiting 10 seemed as vulnerable as green bottles. 
 But a lull in Burnley's flurries saw Tony Daws leap on to a bad back-pass, skip round a defender and the converging goalkeeper and equalise just after the hour. 
 Scunthorpe survived largely because Futcher thought he was offside when he wasn't and Deary was when he shouldn't have been &mdash; his 81st-minute goal being disallowed to the despair of the home fans and the delight of those setting off across the black hills. 
 Not a night of vintage claret. 
 Burnley: Pearce, Measham, McGrory, Deary, Farrell, Davis, White, Mumby (Eli, 6min), Futcher, Jakub, Atkinson (Hardy, 103). 
 Scunthorpe: Litchfield, Smalley, Longden, Ward (Hodkinson, 40), Lister, Stevenson, Lillis, Taylor, Daws (Flounders, 103), Hamilton, Marshall. 
 Referee: K Lupton (Stockton-on-Tees). 
 Salford lose their bargain-buy prop for at least six weeks. 
 IAN SHERRATT, who has played outstandingly at prop for Salford since his summer signing from Oldham, could be out for the rest of the season, writes Paul Fitzpatrick. 
 The 24-year-old, who has proved excellent value for his price of &pound;25,000, suffered ruptured knee ligaments and cartilage damage at Halifax on Sunday and will be in plaster for at least six weeks. 
 Although Lee Crooks, the Great Britain forward, was taken off Leeds's transfer list recently, a move still seems likely with Castleford the likeliest destination. 
 Crooks was in dispute with Leeds earlier in the season and was put on offer at &pound;250,000, by far the biggest sum demanded for an English rugby league player. 
 He then appeared to settle his differences and played twice but was dropped for Sunday's match with Bradford. 
 David Ward, the Leeds coach, was not happy with Crooks's fitness or his weight. 
 Rochdale's home game with Oldham at Spotland on Boxing Day is all-ticket with a crowd limit of 9,500 because of exceptional interest within the town. 
 Racing: Playschool back on the Gold Cup trail. 
 By David Hadert 
 BETTING on the Cheltenham Gold Cup could be overhauled after today's Tommy Whittle Chase at Haydock. 
 The race has been won in the past two years by a Gold Cup winner-The Thinker 12 months ago after being successful at Cheltenham the previous season, while the 1985 Gold Cup hero Forgive &bquo;N&equo; Forget won here in 1987. 
 The Thinker looks certain to start favourite to land the race again, particularly after his battling one length second to Golden Friend, when conceding a stone over this course and distance last month. 
 The pair meet at level weights today. 
 The main danger to The Thinker must be Playschool, but he is having his first race since breaking down at Cheltenham in November, 1988. 
 On that occasion he was three lengths clear at the last, but his injury allowed Golden Friend, who was receiving 19lb, to overhaul him on the line to win by a head. 
 Golden Friend also meets him on equal terms today. 
 At his peak Playschool would have claims to being the best chaser in the country. 
 He had an outstanding 1987/88 season, winning the Hennessy Gold Cup, the Coral Welsh National and the Vincent O'Brien Irish Gold Cup at Leopardstown. 
 On that form he started favourite for the 1988 Cheltenham Gold Cup but ran a listless race before being pulled up. 
 His trainer, David Barons, is convinced the horse was &bquo;got at&equo; but whatever the reason for Playschool's failure it has taken all Barons's skill and experience to get him back in racing condition after his latest setback. 
 If he is back to his best, Haydock racegoers are in for a thrilling contest, but I prefer to wait until Playschool has shown his old sparkle before backing him. 
 The Thinker (1.45), we know, is near his peak and he looks a banker bet for trainer Arthur Stephenson, who, with 58 winners to date, is second only to Martin Pipe in the trainers' table. 
 Whether or not the Haydock crowd witnesses the next Gold Cup winner, there are many astute racereaders who consider there is a future Gold Cup winner on view today in the shape of Blazing Walker, who contests the Arlington Premier Chase Qualifier. 
 He, too, is trained by Stephenson, for whom he has won his last four races in smart style, albeit with a tendency to jump right. 
 Today's event should show if he has what is needed to take him to the top for he comes up against a very useful opponent in Sabin du Loir (1.15). 
 This Martin Pipe-trained 10-year-old ran up to Waterloo Boy in the Arkle Challenge Trophy at Cheltenham last March and will provide an excellent yardstick to Blazing Walker's ability. 
 Sabin du Loir reverted to hurdling last time out when a disappointing fourth to Nodform at Ascot. 
 He can be forgiven that lapse and should recover losses at the expense of the Gold Cup pretender. 
 I have it on good authority from the owner's husband that Homme d'Affaire will take a lot of beating if the going comes up soft for the Waterloo Handicap Hurdle. 
 However, I take a chance that all is well with Jabrut (2.15), who has his first outing since landing a gamble in novice company here last November. 
 Lord Hartington, the senior steward of the Jockey Club, sounded off about stable lads' conditions in his speech at last night's Gimcrack Dinner. 
 &bquo;No industry can function effectively without a work force which is content and properly looked after. 
 I hope the current wage negotiations will shortly come to a satisfactory conclusion,&equo; said Hartington, adding a warning to owners that they must expect higher training fees to permit lads to be properly paid. 
 FA Cup second-round replay: Gloucester City 0, Cardiff City 1 Scott makes headway to a date with Rangers. 
 By David Foot 
 MORRYS SCOTT, the 18-year-old whose two late goals stopped Gloucester's talented side in their tracks on Saturday, last night scored the only goal of the replay to give Cardiff a third-round tie at home to Queen's Park Rangers. 
 His header, in injury time before the interval, brought a hardly deserved Cup exit for the &pound;60-a-week part-timers on a night when Gloucester proved there really was sporting life locally beyond Kingsholm. 
 This was the first time they had reached the second round and it was reflected in the atmosphere, though the official attendance of 3,877, a record for the purpose-built Meadow Park ground, was hardly accurate. 
 The kick-off was put off for 15 minutes because there were long queues outside. 
 According to the police at least 600 supporters had to be turned away for safety reasons. 
 But a gate was broken down in the frustration and many spectators, mostly from Cardiff, got in without paying. 
 Cardiff were never allowed to demonstrate clearly that they were the fitter and more composed League team, despite an early assault when they forced five corners. 
 There was little sign of lethal finish. 
 They won because Gloucester, brave and energetic and often on top in the second half, took too long to close down on the former Eire winger Jeff Chandler. 
 He supplied the cross for Scott's decisive goal. 
 When Chandler nearly scored himself near the end, Shaw, the former First Division goalkeeper with Bristol City, made the best save of the evening. 
 Before that Gloucester, in an inspired spell, twice came close to equalising, through the lorry driver Steve Talboys, up at 5am so that he could play, and Townsend. 
 It was still a memorable night for Gloucester. 
 Gloucester City: Shaw; Hedges, Williams, Payne, Green, Steel, Talboys, Hughes, Morrison, Townsend, Noble. 
 Cardiff City: Wood; Rodgerson, Daniel, Barnard, Abraham, Gibbins, Morgan, Scott, Pike, Kelly, Chandler. 
 Referee: A Buksh (London).. 
 Snooker: Hendry flat out for win. 
 By Clive Everton 
 STEPHEN HENDRY, brimming with confidence after beating Steve Davis in the final of the Stormseal UK Snooker Open, inflicted an 8-0 session whitewash on Terry Griffiths before beating him 9-3 in their best-of-17-frame quarter-final of the Everest World Matchplay Championship at Brentwood yesterday. 
 In the first seven frames Hendry had breaks of 86, 129 &mdash; the highest of the tournament &mdash; 60, 44, 69, 81, 57 and 55. 
 Griffiths, who took Hendry to 9-7 in the UK semi-final, made an academic 46 break at the conclusion of the first frame. 
 But in the next six frames he aggregated only 51 points. 
 The Welshman had two chances at the pink to win the last frame of the afternoon but it was Hendry, with pink and black, who went through to play John Parrott in tomorrow's semi-final. 
 &bquo;Stephen didn't give me a chance,&equo; Griffiths said later. 
 &bquo;He plays a different type of game to Steve Davis. 
 Davis strangles you very slowly. 
 Hendry just comes up and knocks you flat. 
 &bquo;You think he can't keep potting balls but he does. 
 He had a tremendous first session. 
 I could have won a couple of the frames but he just played too well for me. 
 He won't win games through safety but he's so consistent at potting balls that it hardly matters.&equo; 
 Today's semi-final brings together Dean Reynolds, who ousted Davis on Saturday, and Jimmy White. 
 Mountainous volumes lend their weight to dreams of a snow-bound Christmas John Samuel slaloms through this year's selection of books for the skiing enthusiast. 
 SKI racing this season celebrates major anniversaries of its two senior classics. 
 Kitzbuhel's Hahnenkamm is 50 years old and Wengen's Lauberhorn 60. 
 Both figure in new books, Ranulf Rayner's The Story of Skiing and Arnold Wilson's Top 50 Resorts, in rather different ways. 
 On the one hand, Kitzbuhel is Austria's queen of the travel brochures; a walled, medieval town offering lederhosen, dirndl skirts, fig-flavoured coffee and konditorei cream-cake. 
 In addition it has snow (I quote Arnie Wilson) which at its floor level of 2,494 feet it has no right to expect. 
 Because the terrain so lends itself to visual spectacle, the grand prix races draw crowds from Vienna, Salzburg and Innsbruck like no other. 
 Its atmosphere is inviolable. 
 Wilson sees another Kitzbuhel. 
 Four main ski areas &mdash; Hahnenkamm, Kirchberg-Fleckalm, Kitzbuhelerhorn and Jochberg-Pass Thurn &mdash; offer more than 112 miles of prepared holidaymaker pistes which 200 &bquo;Red Devil&equo; instructors may help you to ski. 
 He highlights the more challenging places, but says that the skiing tends to be on the tame side. 
 He likes the Gilbert and Sullivan of some of the ski names &mdash; Barenbadkogl, Wilde Hag, Giggling. 
 It is nice to have a survey of resorts, necessarily selective, from a good, experienced skier who can weigh so many aspects. 
 Ranulf Rayner first skied as a child between the legs of a Bavarian guide in 1939. 
 He runs an adventure centre in south-west England, and commissioned a young artist, Robert Guy, to match his words with paintings reflecting the moods of mountains and skiing. 
 If you cannot afford the coffee table then you cannot afford the book. 
 It is enormous, with a price &mdash; &pound;35 &mdash; to match. 
 But then Robert Guy, we are told, is a weightlifter. 
 Rayner cannot resist the British crow that they started downhill at Montana, Switzerland, in 1911; or that the Wengen Swiss are everlastingly grateful to the Downhill Only Club (otherwise, not too literately, the DHO) for teaching them how to race and how to lose. 
 The Swiss, by and large, have grown out of it, though it is 1981 since Thomas Burgler last won the Lauberhorn downhill and the slalom keeps evading them. 
 The appeal of the book is primarily visual. 
 Rayner's potted history is racily told but many of the usual English sources are apparent. 
 The subject awaits a major multilingual research. 
 Successful Skiing by Konrad Bartelski seeks to distil the experience of Britain's pioneeringly successful World Cup skier for the benefit, primarily, of beginners and intermediates. 
 His subsequent career in equipment and clothing has kept him in close touch with needs, and there is no PE jargon in his down-to-earth advice. 
 Totally Piste, Barry Waters's third essay into survival skiing, now takes aboard heli- and mono-skiing and powder. 
 For example: &bquo;Going off piste is usually more for the instructor's sake than yours.&equo; 
 And there is plenty more of that. 
 A potential breakthrough in ski publishing is a set of Ski Guides for eight Swiss regions by a London-based pair of designers, Steve Littlejohns and Mark Packham, which do for skiers what pocket-sized, weatherproofed, hole-by-hole guides achieve for golfers. 
 A full page is devoted to each run, pinpointing steepness, mogul fields, trees, buildings, and the like, the object being to keep the skier within the limits of his or her capability. 
 Toilets, restaurants, SOS phones and potential avalanche slopes are all marked, while a master map shows the &bquo;card of the course&equo;. 
 The pilot year saw 21,000 sold through Switzerland. 
 Areas featured this year are Crans-Montana, Davos-Klosters, Gstaad, Jungfrau, St Moritz, Verbier, Villars and Zermatt. 
 Reviewed: Thomas Cook International top 50 Ski Resorts (Arnold Wilson; Webb and Bower, &pound;15.95); The Story of Skiing (Ranulf Rayner, paintings Robert Guy; David and Charles, &pound;35); Successsful Skiing (Konrad Bartelski; Sackville Books, &pound;4.95); Totally Piste (Pelham Books, &pound;6.99); Ski Guides (Creative Approach, 28 Hatton Wall, London, &pound;3.95). 
 Videos: Ski Perfect I and II (Scottish instructional guru Ali Ross teams with the Sunday Times editor Andrew Neill and staff for beginner-intermediate easy-learn techniques. 
 Back to you, Harry Evans). 
 Equestrianism: Brothers benefit. 
 By John Kerr 
 JOHN and Michael Whitaker, European gold and silver medal winners, are the principal beneficiaries of Britain's biggest showjumping sponsorship. 
 The deal with Henderson Unit Trust Management, announced yesterday, is worth more than &pound;1.5 million over three years. 
 During the seven years of their previous patronage by Next, the brothers have reached the pinnacle of the sport. 
 John's grey, Milton, his European Championship partner, is close to winning a record &pound;150,000 for the year. 
 Last September, Michael, on Monsanta, won the Calgary Grand Prix, the world's most lucrative event, worth close to &pound;90,000. 
 The Henderson deal also includes sponsorship for a Horse of the Year Show event and &pound;80,000 for a new series of eight grands prix at county shows. 
 John Whitaker will take a day's leave from this week's Olympia show to ride Gammon in the final event of the Renault series in Grenoble. 
 After his win in Frankfurt on Sunday, he lies second in the series just behind Michel Robert. 
 Soccer: Bull and Lineker to be twin scavengers. 
 By David Lacey 
 ENGLAND's team for tonight's friendly against Yugoslavia at Wembley revives the wishful thought that international goal-scorers can be cloned. 
 Gary Lineker is joined by Steve Bull as Bobby Robson tries to end a run of three goalless draws. 
 Altogether the England manager has made four changes from the side that drew with Italy at Wembley a month ago. 
 Bull comes in for Beardsley, Thomas replaces McMahon in midfield and is joined on the right by his Arsenal team-mate Rocastle. 
 Waddle switches to the left for the injured Barnes and Parker plays at right-back instead of Stevens. 
 Because this is England's last match for at least 3 &frac12; months, Robson had to balance his desire to try out a few options with the need to retain the basic framework of his World Cup team. 
 Thus the backbone of the side remains the same, running from Shilton in goal through Walker and Butcher at centre-back and Bryan Robson in midfield to Lineker up front. 
 It makes sense to retain Lineker, for though his rate of scoring may have dropped considerably over the past two years he remains the only England striker of sufficient class to succeed in Italy next summer. 
 And the only way a goal scorer can regain his touch is to keep playing. 
 Yet the choice of Bull as a partner is an odd one, for he and Lineker are essentially penalty-area predators and past experience has shown that when two such players are used together they tend to be like dogs after the same bone. 
 Robson said yesterday that he hoped Bull would be a foil for Lineker; he also thought Lineker might be a foil for Bull. 
 What do two foils make &mdash; a foible? 
 Lineker has appeared 45 times for England and scored 29 goals; Bull has played for 60 minutes and scored one, a smartly taken opportunity against Scotland in May. 
 Wolves provide Bull, who has yet to play in the First Division, with passes over the midfield and crosses from overlapping full-backs. 
 He will be fortunate to receive a similar service this evening against some of the toughest and most knowledgeable defenders in Europe. 
 Robson did think of playing Platt alongside Bull but rejected the idea of using two inexperienced players at the same time. 
 Maybe Platt will come on to join Lineker if Bull looks out of his depth. 
 Moving Waddle from the right wing, where he performed so imaginatively against the Italians, in order to accommodate Rocastle, whose form has been patchy all season, is another selection open to doubt. 
 Even when Barnes is missing there is still apparently no room for Hodge, who is playing consistently well for Nottingham Forest. 
 England will need frequent penetration on the wings if they are to make the most of Lineker and Bull. 
 Waddle may give them this on the left, but it would surely have done no harm to start the match with Dorigo's dash instead of the perennial, peripheral Pearce. 
 Thomas last played in the full England side 13 months ago when he won his first cap in Saudi Arabia and did little of consequence. 
 Since then he has turned in some useful performances for the under-21 and England B sides but he has some way to go before becoming a player of real international class. 
 Parker, a defender of genuine quality, is at his best when playing sweeper. 
 Since England do not use a sweeper he has to come in at right-back, a position which tends to emphasise his limitations going forward. 
 Yet England are short of a cover for Stevens &mdash; and that is some shortage &mdash; so Parker's appearance tonight makes a bit of sense. 
 Robson needs a win tonight. 
 As he said himself: &bquo;We don't want to be sitting on a bad result for the next 3 &frac12; months.&equo; 
 One explosion from Bull and some serious sniping by Lineker could do the trick, but Yugoslavia have only lost twice in 20 matches since England routed them 4-1 in Belgrade in the European Championship two years ago and that wound was deep. 
 Just over three years ago England defeated them 2-0 at Wembley, but Yugoslavia might have drawn or even won that game had they taken their chances. 
 Last month they held Brazil 0-0 in Sao Paulo and tonight they field what is likely to be their World Cup team, including the fast and skilful Skoro and the experienced Stojkovic, bound for Marseilles. 
 For England, another barren draw would end the year with a groan and put them in the position of having to begin the final run-in to the World Cup after nine months without a goal. 
 No wonder the manager got het up with one of the tabloids yesterday for printing a picture of Bryan Robson yawning behind his back in training. 
 It is enough to give anybody the World Cup willies. 
 ENGLAND: Shilton (Derby); Parker (QPR), Walker (Nottingham Forest), Butcher (Rangers), Pearce (Nottingham Forest), Thomas (Arsenal), Robson (Manchester United), Rocastle (Arsenal), Lineker (Tottenham), Bull (Wolves), Waddle (Marseille). 
 YUGOSLAVIA: Ivkovic (Sporting Lisbon); Stanojkovic, Spasic (Partizan Belgrade), Brnovic (Metz), Hadzibejic (Sochaux, capt), Vulic (Real Mallorca), Skoro (Torino), Susic (Paris St Germain), Mihajlovic (Bayern Munich), Stojkovic (Red Star Belgrade), Savevski (AEK Athens). 
 Subs: Maroviv, Prosinecki (Red Star Belgrade), Panavic (Zagreb).. 
 JOHN PARROTT, who won the European Open title last February, has made a disappointing start to the season and he suffered some anxious moments before clinching a 9-6 win over Dennis Taylor last night in the quarter-finals of the Everest World Matchplay Championship at Brentwood, writes Clive Everton. 
 A spell of what Parrott described as &bquo;the best snooker I've played this season&equo; enabled him to take a 6-2 interval lead which he then increased to 8-2 before Taylor showed his renowned tenacity by winning the next four frames. 
 &bquo;I took a liberty at 8-2 and got punished for it,&equo; said Parrott. 
 &bquo;It did get to me,&equo; he said of Taylor's prolonged rearguard action. 
 &bquo;Dennis played some great safety.&equo; 
 However that was where the comeback ended and it was with much relief that Parrott eventually clinched victory, taking the 15th frame 64-11. 
 He now meets either Stephen Hendry or Terry Griffiths, who play today. 
 However that was where the comeback ended and it was with much relief that Parrott eventually clinched victory, taking the 15th frame 64-11. 
 Tennis &pound;400,000 for appearing. 
 By David Irvine 
 APPEARANCE fees, accepted as a legitimate means of attracting top players to world series events on the Association of Tennis Professionals' inaugural tour next year, will match the &pound;400,000 prize money on offer at the Stella Artois indoor championship in Milan from February 5 to 11. 
 Tournament officials, though unwilling to say precisely how the appearance money will be distributed, confirmed they expect to pay out &pound;400,000 to ensure a quality 32-man field. 
 And it seems safe to say the three main beneficiaries will be Ivan Lendl, John McEnroe and Jimmy Connors. 
 Appearance money or guarantees previously were illegal &mdash; though not unknown &mdash; and under the new system it has been estimated that some top players (Lendl and Boris Becker make around &pound;1.5 million a year) could increase their annual earnings by 40 per cent. 
 This year's Milan tournament, won by Becker, offered &pound;230,000 in prize money &mdash; of which the champion took &pound;50,000. 
 Neither Becker nor Stefan Edberg is likely to enter Milan next year as it comes directly after a Davis Cup week. 
 Championship series events, tournaments offering &pound;625,000 or more in prize money, cannot offer appearance fees but are guaranteed six top-10 players. 
 With each man in the top 10 required to play 11 championship events, competition for their services in world series tournaments will be fierce. 
 Milan, perhaps significantly, announced it would have Lendl for the next three years. 
 Pat Cash and Darren Cahill were yesterday named in the Australian Davis Cup squad for the first-round tie with France despite their injury troubles. 
 Cash is recovering after an Achilles tendon operation and Cahill is set to have exploratory knee surgery, but Australia hope they will be fit for the match on Perth's grass courts from February 2 to 4. 
 Stoltenberg, Kratzmann, Fitzgerald, Masur and Woodforde complete the squad. 
 Squash Soutter finds a style that suits. 
 By Richard Jago 
 LUCY SOUTTER, the 22-year-old former champion who nearly gave up the game this year after long-lasting viral problems, unexpectedly reclaimed the British national title at Newcastle yesterday by beating Suzanne Horner 9-3, 9-5, 9-3 in a final lasting only 43 minutes. 
 Soutter, the fourth seed, thus beat the player who caused her exclusion from England's world title-winning team, in a final that for the first time since 1979 contained neither of the Guernsey girls, Martine le Moignan and Lisa Opie. 
 Horner, in her first final, looked the edgier. 
 Her nerves were not smoothed by two mistimed drives that sailed over the side walls, hurtled under the bleachers and were lost from sight. 
 On each occasion it took time to warm a new ball. 
 There were two jangling mistakes from Horner giving away early penalty points to Soutter, and after only 11 minutes the former champion had pocketed the first game with a good backhand drop from a short ball. 
 Horner's fierce forehand had been her best weapon, but Soutter was able to contain it with steady and accurate driving and a calm mind. 
 The crisis came at 5-5 in the second game, by which time Horner had begun to dig in. 
 Service changed hands eight times and there were four lets in between until Soutter broke the deadlock with a tight drop that created an opening and a lovely cross-court forehand slice that zipped away for a winner. 
 Those two shots were indicative of the extra variety Soutter has added to her game since she was last at the top of the English heap four years ago. 
 She is no longer simply a steady rallier and scampering retriever but can tie opponents up and utilise the openings created. 
 It was this that eventually scuppered Horner. 
 PAGE 
 Cricket Australia v Sri Lanka: first Test, fifth day. 
 Taylor repairs seam weakness 
 ALLAN BORDER settled for a draw with Sri Lanka at the Gabba yesterday. 
 Though his batsmen dominated most of the final day, they failed to silence a grumbling chorus. 
 Australia batted all day to reach 375 for six. 
 Sri Lanka, who had lost their previous two Tests against Australia by an innings, were never put under pressure. 
 Border chose not to expose his all-seam attack, so ineffective in the first innings and in the recent draw with New Zealand, to the chance of further indignity. 
 For the next Test, starting at Hobart on Friday, Peter Sleep, the veteran leg-spinner, has been called into the squad at the expense of Geoff Lawson, who took one wicket in this Test. 
 Geoff Marsh has also been recalled. 
 Merv Hughes hit an enormous six and Mark Taylor made 164 to become the first player to score 1,000 runs in the course of his first season of Tests, but Australia's batsmen did not escape the day without damage from an attack weakened by injury to both its opening bowlers. 
 Tom Moody, a century-maker in the first innings, wasted his chance to secure the Test place offered to him by Marsh's injury when he sliced Asoka de Silva to first slip. 
 In one spell in the last session the Sri Lankans took three wickets for eight runs. 
 And Taylor, who survived an early stumping chance off De Silva, was out in circumstances that would bring a smile to all but the most partisan lips. 
 Shortly after tea Champaka Ramanayake complained about the ball to the umpires. 
 When Taylor was asked if he was happy with its shape he said he was seeing it clearly. 
 Next ball Ramanayake had him lbw. 
 Taylor had plundered 17 fours and two sixes in his 425-minute innings. 
 This was the third century in 10 Tests for the left-handed opener, who made his debut in the fourth Test against the West Indies in January and hit 839 runs in the Ashes series. 
 University Match: Cambridge 22, Oxford 13 Davies brothers light upon Dark Blue gifts. 
 By Robert Armstrong 
 CAMBRIDGE survived a frantic succession of alarms and excursions to win the 108th University Match and lift the Bowring Bowl for the second time in five seasons at Twickenham yesterday. 
 It was an afternoon of high drama and low farce in which Cambridge all but threw away a 15-0 lead before Oxford, with a plethora of errors, nullified two fine tries by their American wing Hein. 
 Ultimately Cambridge were well worth their victory by two goals, a try and two penalties to a goal, a try and a penalty because they displayed a predatory instinct for making the most of their chances. 
 The Davies brothers, Adrian (who scored 14 points) and Graham (four), exercised an important creative influence on Cambridge fortunes while their flankers Holmes and Pool-Jones were full of fire and tenacity in the loose. 
 This was one of the most ragged performances Oxford have given in recent memory with their captain, Smith, responsible for several mistakes. 
 Oxford's forwards were slow and scattered in getting to the breakdown. 
 If anything their backs were worse, sometimes dropping the ball, at others slinging passes into eager Cambridge hands. 
 One quality Oxford possessed in abundance, though, was spirit, which enabled them to claw their way back. 
 They were assisted by the referee, Clive Norling, who added on nine minutes' injury time despite the lack of an injury stoppage worth the name. 
 Five of those minutes came at the end of the first half, allowing Hein to score the first of his morale-boosting tries for Oxford in the right corner. 
 Remarkably, Cambridge let the initiative dribble away in the third quarter despite spending most of that period camped in the Oxford half. 
 Hein's second try and a marvellous penalty goal by Smith from the left touchline brought Oxford back to 13-15 but, with a quarter-hour left, a fatal lack of composure undid Oxford again. 
 First they killed the ball, enabling Adrian Davies to kick a short penalty goal, his side's first score of the half. 
 Then the Oxford prop Jones was warned for stamping, another penalty was awarded and Cambridge swept to the other end to seal the match with an opportunist try by Adrian Davies. 
 The Welsh fly-half hacked on after a sloppy pass by Bray went to ground and two defenders were beaten to the touchdown. 
 In the remaining 12 minutes (four by the grace of Norling) Oxford were too spent for a second comeback, but Cambridge were no doubt relieved that their efficient rucking and slick passing established such dominance in the first half. 
 They had taken the lead after two minutes with a simple move that found the Oxford defence in disarray. 
 When Booth sent a short chip into the left corner Graham Davies made a deft pick-up and ran round the rear of the Oxford defence to score at the posts. 
 Adrian Davies converted. 
 Cambridge increased their lead on the half-hour when Simms intercepted an ambitious cut-out pass by Smith inside his own half and sprinted 70 yards down centre-field to score between the posts. 
 Davies's conversion made the score 12-0. 
 After 40 minutes Adrian Davies established a three-score advantage with a short penalty goal when Oxford killed the ball. 
 Oxford began their comeback with a try in the 44th minute, Smith sending another cut-out pass to Hein, who burst 15 yards to score at the flag. 
 Oxford sustained their aggressive driving at the start of the second half and forced Cambridge back on their own line. 
 A ruck was set up to the left of the Cambridge posts and, when Smith flicked the ball out to the right, Hein charged through on the overlap to score behind the posts. 
 Smith converted. 
 Once Smith's penalty goal had cut the Cambridge lead to two points Oxford appeared to be in the driving seat. 
 But their old propensity for self-destruction surfaced again, much to the joy of Adrian Davies, and an exciting though careless game ended as it began &mdash; with Cambridge on top. 
 SCORERS: Cambridge: Tries: G Davies, Simms, A Davies. 
 Conversions: A Davies 2. 
 Penalties: A Davies 2. 
 Oxford: Tries: Hein 2. 
 Conversion: Smith. 
 Penalty: Smith. 
 CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY: A Buzza (Hughes Hall, capt); S Bell (Clare), N Simms (Robinson), P Reed (Magdalene), G Davies (Magdalene); A Davies (Robinson), A Booth (Hughes Hall); J Foster (Robinson), J Ashworth (Homerton), S Wordley (Downing), J O'Callaghan (Sidney Sussex), A MacDonald (Hughes Hall), R Pool-Jones (Magdalene), S Holmes (St Edmund's), J Wilby (St Edmund's). 
 OXFORD UNIVERSITY: K Bray (Mansfield); G Hein (St Anne's), J Elliott (St Anne's), D Curtis (St Anne's), D Cooke (Christ Church); B Smith (St Anne's, capt), S Taylor (University); A Jones (St Anne's), E Norwitz (University), D James (St Anne's), J Fewtrell (St Anne's), T Coker (Lady Margaret Hall), M Egan (St Anne's), W Van der Merwe (St Anne's), R Horrocks-Taylor (St Peter's). 
 Referee: C Norling (Wales). 
 Racing: Playschool back on the Gold Cup trail. 
 By David Hadert 
 BETTING on the Cheltenham Gold Cup could be overhauled after today's Tommy Whittle Chase at Haydock. 
 The race has been won in the past two years by a Gold Cup winner-The Thinker 12 months ago after being successful at Cheltenham the previous season, while the 1985 Gold Cup hero Forgive &bquo;N&equo; Forget won here in 1987. 
 The Thinker looks certain to start favourite to land the race again, particularly after his battling one length second to Golden Friend, when conceding a stone over this course and distance last month. 
 The pair meet at level weights today. 
 The main danger to The Thinker must be Playschool, but he is having his first race since breaking down at Cheltenham in November, 1988. 
 On that occasion he was three lengths clear at the last, but his injury allowed Golden Friend, who was receiving 19lb, to overhaul him on the line to win by a head. 
 Golden Friend also meets him on equal terms today. 
 At his peak Playschool would have claims to being the best chaser in the country. 
 He had an outstanding 1987/88 season, winning the Hennessy Gold Cup, the Coral Welsh National and the Vincent O'Brien Irish Gold Cup at Leopardstown. 
 On that form he started favourite for the 1988 Cheltenham Gold Cup but ran a listless race before being pulled up. 
 His trainer, David Barons, is convinced the horse was &bquo;got at&equo; but whatever the reason for Playschool's failure it has taken all Barons's skill and experience to get him back in racing condition after his latest setback. 
 If he is back to his best, Haydock racegoers are in for a thrilling contest, but I prefer to wait until Playschool has shown his old sparkle before backing him. 
 The Thinker (1.45), we know, is near his peak and he looks a banker bet for trainer Arthur Stephenson, who, with 58 winners to date, is second only to Martin Pipe in the trainers' table. 
 Whether or not the Haydock crowd witnesses the next Gold Cup winner, there are many astute racereaders who consider there is a future Gold Cup winner on view today in the shape of Blazing Walker, who contests the Arlington Premier Chase Qualifier. 
 He, too, is trained by Stephenson, for whom he has won his last four races in smart style, albeit with a tendency to jump right. 
 Today's event should show if he has what is needed to take him to the top for he comes up against a very useful opponent in Sabin du Loir (1.15). 
 This Martin Pipe-trained 10-year-old ran up to Waterloo Boy in the Arkle Challenge Trophy at Cheltenham last March and will provide an excellent yardstick to Blazing Walker's ability. 
 Sabin du Loir reverted to hurdling last time out when a disappointing fourth to Nodform at Ascot. 
 He can be forgiven that lapse and should recover losses at the expense of the Gold Cup pretender. 
 I have it on good authority from the owner's husband that Homme d'Affaire will take a lot of beating if the going comes up soft for the Waterloo Handicap Hurdle. 
 However, I take a chance that all is well with Jabrut (2.15), who has his first outing since landing a gamble in novice company here last November. 
 Lord Hartington, the senior steward of the Jockey Club, sounded off about stable lads' conditions in his speech at last night's Gimcrack Dinner. 
 &bquo;No industry can function effectively without a work force which is content and properly looked after. 
 I hope the current wage negotiations will shortly come to a satisfactory conclusion,&equo; said Hartington, adding a warning to owners that they must expect higher training fees to permit lads to be properly paid. 
 Squash Soutter finds a style that suits. 
 By Richard Jago 
 LUCY SOUTTER, the 22-year-old former champion who nearly quit the game after a long illness, unexpectedly won back the British national title at Newcastle yesterday when she beat Suzanne Horner 9-3, 9-5, 9-3 in a final lasting less than 45 minutes. 
 Thus the fourth-seeded Soutter gained revenge over the player who denied her the last place in England's world-title winning team this year, with a hint that her rehabilitation might now be complete. 
 Kisses afterwards from her parents, her coach Ian Robinson and her manager Ian Mackenzie contained relief as much as celebration. 
 &bquo;That's helped turn her career around,&equo; said Mackenzie. 
 Horner, in her first final, was understandably the more nervous player. 
 She was not helped by two long delays in the first game when the ball flew out of the court and was lost under the bleachers. 
 It was not until 5-5 in the second game that Horner settled herself and dug in. 
 Eight changes of serve followed until Soutter broke the deadlock with a drop that created a gap for a lovely cross-court forehand sliced winner. 
 The shots were indicative of the extra variety that Soutter has added to her game since she was last British national champion four years ago. 
 She is no longer simply a steady rallier and scampering retriever, but can tie opponents up and make use of the openings created. 
 It was this that finally scuppered her opponent. 
 The men's title was won by the favourite, Del Harris, although he lost his car, stolen from the nearby street earlier in the day. 
 He nearly had the match purloined from him too because Bryan Beeson, who captained England's world bronze-medal winning team, took the first two games with some astutely controlled slow drives that induced the 20-year-old England No.1 to make errors. 
 Beeson also reached 4-0 in the third game before his energy ran out. 
 He knew before the match that his marathons with Chris Walker and Paul Carter in the quarter and semi-finals had left him low on gas. 
 &bquo;I was 10 minutes from the title,&equo; he said ruefully afterwards. 
 Harris still needed character, hard work and some spectacular court coverage to get him home by 1-9, 6-9, 9-4, 9-2, 9-3 against the local hero who got good support from the crowd to the bitter end. 
 The International Squash Rackets Federation will introduce random drug testing at next year's world championships. 
 Ten of the 16 quarter-finalists were checked for drugs during the World Open in October and proved negative. 
 Reid set to rejoin Kendall. 
 By Cynthia Bateman and Russell Thomas 
 PETER REID is about to become a vital part of the new Manchester City regime by teaming up again with Howard Kendall. 
 Kendall said last night: &bquo;I have had long talks with Peter and I am optimistic that I can get him to come to City. 
 We will be having further talks tomorrow.&equo; 
 The former England midfielder, who is expected to be player-coach, said before leaving for the talks: &bquo;I would be happy to come back north and it will be great to be working with Howard again.&equo; 
 Queen's Park Rangers earlier yesterday granted Kendall permission to approach Reid, who joined the London club from Everton on a free transfer in February, and said they would ask no fee for the 33-year-old player in recognition of his &bquo;marvellous attitude&equo; in his time at Loftus Road. 
 Roy Wegerle, the &pound;1 million Rangers newcomer who has declared himself available to the United States, was last night offered the chance of an alternative route to the World Cup next summer by Bobby Robson. 
 &bquo;If Wegerle's interested in playing for England, I'll put him in my next B squad,&equo; said Robson. 
 Leicester have offered &pound;150,000 for Barnet's 21-year-old striker Andrew Clarke. 
 Kidderminster Harriers want at least &pound;40,000 for Kim Casey, their prolific scorer, who is transfer-listed. 
 West Ham are interested in taking Manchester United's reserve goalkeeper Gary Walsh on loan. 
 Charlton, who are meeting Greenwich Borough Council officials tomorrow night over the projected return to The Valley, are unhappy at being told recently by the council that it wants the club's proposals to be revised dramatically to take account of environmental requirements. 
 They had hoped to be back at the beginning of next season but it now looks unlikely to be until half-way through it. 
 B international: England 2, Yugoslavia 1 Understudies shine as Gascoigne cuts the clowning. 
 By David Lacey 
 THE England B team, looking bright, brisk and keenly balanced, sharpened their appetite for bigger things last night at The Den after dominating large parts of the match. 
 Wise and Newell scored in each half as England demonstrated the simple virtues of producing accurate crosses and getting someone on to the end of them. 
 Yugoslavia faded after an imaginative start and did not offer a serious threat until late in the game, when Mladenovic curled in a free-kick. 
 England's performance confirmed the impressions they made in the second half of their 1-1 draw with Italy at Brighton last month. 
 Wise and Beagrie gave their movements speed and width and, once Newell had replaced the persevering but internationally inexperienced Wright, the attack gained a sharper cutting edge. 
 Adams showed the authority and leadership you would expect from a defender who has won 17 caps at senior level but in World Cup terms the most significant performance came from Gascoigne, who cut out the asides and showed some of the tactical discipline he has to acquire if he is to make the most of his natural talent in international football. 
 In the first half his passing had the right weight and direction to give Williams and Wright opportunities to use their speed against the Yugoslav defence and bypass the sweeper, Petric. 
 In the second half he moved forward more often and eventually created England's second goal. 
 Bobby Robson, suitably impressed, said: &bquo;Gascoigne gave a very reasonable performance. 
 He did all the things we know he is capable of doing and he behaved himself as well.&equo; 
 Dave Sexton, the B team manager, said Gascoigne's was &bquo;the perfect midfield performance&equo;. 
 Gascoigne enjoyed good support from Batty, who had another busy game in midfield and rarely allowed the opposition to establish the sort of rhythm they tried to set up at the start, when Boban and Suker tested Woods with low shots after some swift exchanges of passes had succeeded in outmanoeuvring England's defence. 
 Yugoslavia's poise lasted seven minutes. 
 Forsyth forced a corner on the left, Beagrie swung the ball towards the near post, Adams nodded it on and Wise forced in England's first goal at the far post. 
 A minute later Dixon, sent through a gap by Gascoigne, hit the bar with a well-struck left-footed shot. 
 After that England always looked the likely winners. 
 Sexton made four changes at half-time, replacing Woods with Martyn, Dixon with Sterland and Linighan with Pallister and bringing Newell on for Wright. 
 However the direct, positive pattern of England's football remained the same. 
 Yugoslavia became ragged as their football grew increasingly unproductive. 
 Just past the hour Suker, their only effective forward, worked his way to the left-hand byline and shrugged disconsolately when nobody ran through the middle to meet his pass. 
 In the 64th minute Gascoigne performed a similar duty for England but, after he had crossed from the right-hand byline, Newell rose to head past Lekovic, the substitute goalkeeper. 
 The two moments summed up the difference between the teams. 
 ENGLAND B: Woods (Rangers); Dixon (Arsenal), Forsyth (Derby), Batty (Leeds), Linighan (Norwich), Adams (Arsenal), Wise (Wimbledon), Gascoigne (Tottenham), Wright (Crystal Palace), Williams (Charlton), Beagrie (Everton). 
 YUGOSLAVIA B: Omerovic; Brnovic, Marovic, Bogdanovic, Petric, Bozovic, Mihailovic, Mladenovic, Penacev, Boban, Suker. 
 Referee: J Spillane (Rep of Ireland).. 
 Hockey: A wealth of inexperience. 
 By Pat Rowley 
 ONLY five of the 12 players selected to represent England in this weekend's annual HDM international indoor tournament at The Hague have played for the indoor team before &mdash; and England will be defending the title. 
 The squad have just 52 caps between them and 31 of those belong to the new captain, Andy Halliday of St Albans. 
 England are forced to field such an inexperienced team because none of the World Cup players or reserves is available. 
 England would have had six existing internationals in the team but Kevin Stamp was accidently hit in the mouth by a stick at the training weekend and has withdrawn. 
 His place has gone to Paul Krishman, a new cap who is joined by the goalkeepers Andy Forshaw and Martin Langston, John Roberts and three Teddington players, Jason Laslett, Philip McGuire and Neil Barker. 
 ENGLAND SQUAD: A Forshaw (Formby), M Langston (Wakefield); A Halliday (St Albans, capt), J Roberts (Bournville), M Riley (Teddington), G Wisher (St Albans), J Laslett (Teddington), P Krishman (Old Loughtonians), P Nail (Havant), N Barker, P McGuire (both Teddington), I Jennings (Old Loughtonians). 
 Manager: I McIntosh. 
 Coach: R Clarke. 
 ENGLAND UNDER-21 (for Mid-shires tournament, Birmingham December 14-16): J Barrow (Indian Gymkhana), D Luckes (East Grinstead); S Organ (Firebrands), J Barber (Old Loughtonians), J Lee (East Grinstead), S Osborne (Gloucester City), P Capper (Formby), A Degun (Barford Tigers), S Avery (Havant), R Stokes (Wakefield), G Banbury (Slough), J Chana (Bournville). 
 Leicester offer &pound;20,000, car, and pension as bait for coaching director. 
 LEICESTER are set to make club history by appointing a paid director of coaching. 
 Having failed to lure the former coach Chalky White away from the Rugby Football Union, the Tigers are to advertise the post with a salary of around &pound;20,000, plus a pension and car. 
 The secretary, John Allen, said: &bquo;We need to expand our coaching organisation because people are finding it more and more difficult to do what is needed. 
 This will take some of the load off our coaches.&equo; 
 Northampton were the first to go down this road when they appointed Barrie Corless last year. 
 Unlike Corless, who is involved in all aspects of the club, the man Leicester appoint will be involved purely on the coaching side. 
 Adrian Davies, Cambridge's stand-off yesterday, has been included in the Wales Under-21 training squad in Cardiff on December 28-29. 
 Steve Crandon, the Cardiff and Wales B centre, seems ready to rejoin Newbridge. 
 He played 130 games for the Gwent club before switching to Cardiff two years ago. 
 The England prop Andy Mullins and Dave Thresher have dropped out of the London divisional squad to play for Harlequins against Rugby at Rugby on Saturday. 
 Skiing Girardelli injured. 
 SWITZERLAND's Pirmin Zurbriggen yesterday won his first race in over a year in the World Cup Alpine super-giant slalom down Sestriere's fast and slippery Kandahar course, while the overall champion, Marc Girardelli, crashed and was taken to hospital. 
 Girardelli, Austrian-born but racing for Luxembourg, fell heavily 30 seconds into the 2,525-metre course, which was condemned as &bquo;dangerous&equo; by Zurbriggen. 
 &bquo;It was almost like a downhill in places and there was not enough security for us in case of falls. 
 It was definitely a dangerous race,&equo; he said. 
 Girardelli suffered severe bruising to his hip and the small of his back and has been advised to rest for a month and so could miss six World Cup races. 
 The men's downhill, his strongest event, begins in Val Gardena in Italy with races on Friday and Saturday. 
 He joins an already impressive list of casualties, which includes Italy's Alberto Tomba and Michael Mair, Tamara McKinney of the US, Martin Hangl and Vreni Schneider of Switzerland, and Austria's Helmut Mayer. 
 Zurbriggen, the Olympic downhill champion and World Cup super-giant titleholder, swept to his first victory since November 1988 in the ninth World Cup race of the current programme in 1min 37.39sec. 
 Lars-Boerje Eriksson of Sweden, the winner of the opening giant slalom in Thredbo, Australia, in August, was second, 0.11sec behind Zurbriggen. 
 The Olympic super-G champion, Franck Piccard of France, finished third in 1.37.86 after being second in the season's first super-G in Val d'Isere, France, on Sunday. 
 The World Cup leader, Ole Christian Furuseth of Norway, finished down the field but remained top of the standings on 118 points. 
 But Zurbriggen moved up to second from third on 101 points and could overtake Furuseth in Val Gardena, where the Norwegian slalom specialist will not compete. 
 The men's World Cup downhill scheduled for Saalbach-Hinterglemm on December 21 has been switched to Schladming because of a lack of snow. 
 Random drug tests &bquo;mandatory&equo; at next year's world championships. 
 RANDOM drug testing will be introduced at next year's world championships. 
 Prasad Pillai, secretary of the International Squash Rackets Federation, said 10 of the 16 quarter-finalists were checked for drugs during the World Open in Kuala Lumpur in October. 
 All 10 proved negative, but he added: &bquo;That was something of a dry run. 
 From now on it will be mandatory.&equo; 
 PAGE 
 Lendl leads the way down under. 
 IVAN LENDL, No.1 in the computer rankings, heads a list of 12 of the world's top 20 players who have entered next month's Australian Open. 
 Also entered are the Wimbledon and US Open champion Boris Becker, the Masters champion Stefan Edberg, the fourth-ranked John McEnroe, his fellow American Aaron Krickstein, No.8 in the world, and the former Australian Open winner Mats Wilander. 
 Among those missing from the first Grand Slam event of the year are Andre Agassi and Jimmy Connors, who has not played the Australian Open for more than a decade. 
 The French Open champion Michael Chang is injured. 
 Rebuked Toshack in Real danger of losing job. 
 THE chances of John Toshack completing his two-year contract as Real Madrid's manager look thin, with speculation growing in the Spanish capital that he will go by next summer. 
 According to the influential El Pais newspaper, Real's president Ramon Mendoza has rebuked Toshack on a number of counts and is already seeking a replacement for the Welshman hired only last summer on a &pound;1 million contract. 
 The report said Mendoza had met Toshack to censure him over stormy relations with his players and high-handed treatment of the media. 
 It was a sharp reminder of Real's expectations after their latest failure to win the European Cup, the only trophy that matters to the Spanish champions. 
 By Russell Thomas 
 DON HOWE started one of his busiest weeks by completing the &pound;1 million signing of Ray Wegerle for Queen's Park Rangers, seeking to borrow a goalkeeper for the club and, in between, helping out with England matters. 
 Rangers' chief coach says Wegerle &bquo;will have to force his way in&equo; to a side that has scored seven goals in two games, but that did not prevent the club's managing director Clive Berlin hailing the South African-born striker as &bquo;the new Rodney Marsh&equo;. 
 Wegerle has two ambitions after a move that is a record for both Rangers and the sellers, Luton. 
 The first is to take up Howe's challenge, the other to play in the World Cup with the United States. 
 The 25-year-old, who started his career with Tampa Bay Rowdies, says of the Americans: &bquo;I feel more loyalty to them because it's my wife's country.&equo; 
 Howe still needs a goalkeeper on loan because David Seaman has only a slender chance of returning on Saturday and his two deputies are injured. 
 The sale of Wegerle leaves Luton with a &pound;925,000 profit in 18 months on the player bought from Chelsea. 
 Luton will use it strengthen their central defence. 
 They are likely to renew interest in a former player, Manchester United's Mal Donaghy, while keeping an eye on Brian Gayle's progress under new management at Manchester City. 
 At Maine Road, Howard Kendall was installed as City's manager amid rumours that Alex Ferguson had resigned as United's manager &mdash; denied at Old Trafford but tantalising given earlier speculation that. 
 Archery: English will miss S African golds. 
 THE most Anglo-Saxon of games has been found to be compromising with apartheid. 
 The Commonwealth Games Council for England has told archers to end a 30-year tradition of competing with a South African organisation. 
 The council has asked the Grand National Archery Association to stop its member counties from holding &bquo;postal shoots&equo; with the Natal Archery Society. 
 It seems that although English greenswards remained innocent of South Africans, score cards from agreed events were exchanged through the mails in what is said to be a contravention of the Gleneagles Agreement. 
 John Middleton, the GNAA chief executive, told News From The Centre, an archery magazine, that the Commonwealth Games organisation had &bquo;deemed&equo; the competition &bquo;acceptable&equo; six years ago, but had changed its mind &bquo;due to a minority of British archers bringing politics into sport&equo;. 
 PAGE 
 Boxing: Hodkinson takes a European view. 
 By Jack Massarik 
 PAUL HODKINSON, who recently feared that he would never box again, returns to action in front of his home-town supporters at Kirkby Sports Centre tonight to defend his European featherweight title against Farid Benredjeb of France. 
 Myopia, or short-sightedness, is the 24-year-old Liverpudlian's problem &mdash; if indeed it is a problem for someone with 15 professional wins, all but one inside the distance, and one draw. 
 But such is the pressure on professional boxers to prove their absolute fitness that the British Boxing Board of Control last month ordered Hodkinson to undertake full medical tests, and he was cleared only after being examined by four ophthalmic surgeons. 
 &bquo;I had a few sleepless nights,&equo; confessed Hodkinson, whose draw, which he later avenged, came against Thomas Arguelles two years ago. 
 &bquo;I have watched videos of Benredjeb and he will be a tough opponent, but he is just my height and should be perfect for me,&equo; he said after sparring with Arguelles at the Belfast gym of his manager, Barney Eastwood. 
 Hodkinson, a fighter noted for accuracy and stamina, took the British title from Peter Harris of Wales 18 months ago and added the Lonsdale Belt with two successful defences. 
 The 29-year-old Frenchman went the distance with the former European champion Jean-Marc Renard, of Belgium, last year. 
 He also outpointed Raymond Armand, the Frenchman from whom Hodkinson took the European title in two rounds. 
 Billy Hardy, the British bantamweight champion, has been offered a world title fight next month, and in his home town. 
 Hardy, who has twice failed to win the European title, can feel somewhat fortunate to be matched with the International Boxing Federation champion, Orlando Canizales of Mexico, in Sunderland on January 24. 
 It will be the third world title fight in the North-east in six months, following two IBF cruiserweight fights won by Glenn McCrory of Co Durham. 
 Canizales, who is 24 and has lost only one of his 24 fights, lives in Houston, and Hardy's manager, Dennie Mancini, said it had cost &bquo;certainly far in excess of &pound;100,000&equo; to entice him to Sunderland. 
 It has been confirmed that Steve Collins, an Irish-American middleweight from Brockton, Mass, will challenge Mike McCallum of Jamaica for the WBA title in Dublin on February 3. 
 Collins replaces London's Michael Watson, who broke his nose while sparring. 
 Table Tennis: Prean opts out. 
 By Richard Jago 
 CARL PREAN has written to the English Table Tennis Association asking to be omitted from future ranking lists because of the way they are determined. 
 The 22-year-old, who is based in West Germany, is upset that many of his overseas results count for nothing. 
 If they were included he would surely return to No.1 for the first time in six years. 
 The latest list, released yesterday, shows Alan Cooke still at No.1. 
 Cooke was due to slip below Prean on the next list, which should appear at the start of the New Year, but unless there is a rapprochement between the player and the ETTA, whose chairman is Prean's father John, the rankings will have lost much of their meaning. 
 Such an agreement is not out of the question. 
 Even though Prean senior has chosen to sit out from executive committee meetings discussing his son's request, there is a favourable attitude towards reform. 
 The defects of the present set-up were inherited from the previous regime and those who see Prean's point of view and are aware of the dissatisfaction of many players at the way in which computer points are calculated had already been planning a more advanced system. 
 There is, for instance, likely to be different &bquo;weighting&equo; for results. 
 Points for winning a critical match in the European League may no longer be the same as for victories in a three-star tournament; defeats may be taken into account as well as victories; and victories in the European Club Cup should also be included. 
 But Carl Prean may not be accommodated on one issue, the exclusion of German Bundesliga results, which account for most of his successes. 
 They are thought to introduce too many complications. 
 Desmond Douglas and Nicky Mason are ranked next behind Cooke. 
 There are two new names in the top 10: Chris Oldfield has risen 10 places to seventh and Michael O'Driscoll moves from 14th to eighth. 
 COMMENT THE GUARDIAN Wednesday December 13 1989 The grim cargo of lost dreams. 
 EVERY day of the year, blue Hong Kong police buses with barred windows climb to the border with the Peoples Republic. 
 There, without ceremony and possibility of reprieve, an average of 50 men and women, the day's catch of illegal immigrants, are bundled back into China. 
 The number repatriated in this way has amounted to tens of thousands annually since 1980, when the present rules were instituted &mdash; a figure not too far from that of the boat people whom Britain and Hong Kong governments expect to send home to Vietnam. 
 It is a comparison which should give pause to those tempted automatically to condemn the Government. 
 Every day of the year, all over the world, governments work to control and manage the flows of migrants that wars, disasters, and, above all, the magnetic pull of centres of economic and cultural power, keep in constant motion. 
 Sometimes this means making extraordinary efforts to deal with desperate human need on a mass scale. 
 Sometimes it means making judicious individual decisions about marriages and family relationships. 
 And sometimes &mdash; often &mdash; it means sending people back, by force if necessary. 
 Heart and head pull against each other. 
 There can be no reasonable argument about migrants if one side takes the position that nobody should ever be sent back to anywhere, that the mere act of emigration in itself constitutes grounds for supposing that circumstances were unbearable in the country of origin. 
 But that is the position which some of the Government's critics seem now to occupy. 
 It is particularly illogical that this kind of argument should be coming from politicians who, in other contexts, would be the first to argue, and rightly, that Vietnam is not some kind of monster State, but merely a ramshackle and inefficient one that has lost its way. 
 It is a miserable and heart-breaking business to take peasant families who left Vietnam's poor northern provinces with visions of a new life in America dancing in their heads, who endured dangerous sea voyages, and who believed that Hong Kong's camps, however dreadful, were a way station to their dream &mdash; to take these families and to return them to the red dirt farms and meagre fishing villages from which they came. 
 And of course they will suffer consequences &mdash; at the very least those of wasted time and lost opportunities. 
 But neither London nor Hong Kong can legislate for dreams which are no longer capable of realisation. 
 The United States will not take these people. 
 Other affluent Western countries, which the migrants would accept as second best, won't take them either. 
 It is no good saying that, if Britain made a special effort, it might be able to persuade the United States and other countries to change their minds. 
 About this 40,000, maybe; but not about the next 40,000 who would fill the camps as soon as they were cleared. 
 Indeed, at root, that is what this dismal affair is all about. 
 It is about sending a clear signal to the villages of Quang Ninh and Ha Giang and Lang Son that there is no longer a road to Los Angeles by way of Hong Kong or, for that matter, of Thailand or Malaysia. 
 That road came into being after the end of the Vietnam war in 1975. 
 Along it came, at first, ex-soldiers and civil servants of the losing regime, men escaping detention or worse, middle class families pushed to the margins of society by new authorities with more ideology than common sense, southern farmers stripped of their affluence by misguided economic programmes. 
 America led the way in setting up an international system for dealing with the Indochina refugees. 
 The United States wished to discharge its debts to those with whom it had fought during the war; but it also came to see the volume of refugees as a kind of continuing proof that it had waged a just struggle against evil forces. 
 That is how a system for dealing with genuine refugees &mdash; the losers in Indochina's civil wars &mdash; became insensibly a system for turning North Vietnamese peasants into New York waiters. 
 As the number of former South Vietnamese army majors and persecuted intellectuals drifted down to infinitesimal proportions and the number of economic migrants grew, the United States looked the other way. 
 Vietnam was an evil State, the number of boat people coming out proved it; therefore any measures to discourage the refugees would be wrong. 
 It is a measure of hypocrisy that, at the same time, the United States took fewer and fewer of the migrants. 
 But, since last year's Geneva conference on Indochina refugees, all of the concerned countries, including the United States, have agreed that the flow of economic migrants from Vietnam should be stopped. 
 The only difference is between those countries, naturally not the most directly affected, who can pretend that voluntary repatriation will work, and those, like Hong Kong, who know it will not. 
 The inevitable short-term aim is to affect the decisions of would-be migrants. 
 There is, in glum reality, only one thing that will affect that: the knowledge that they will be sent back. 
 That has been the dilemma for Hong Kong &mdash; the necessity of staunching the flow &mdash; and they deserve understanding for a decision that carries all manner of risks for their own future as 1997 nears. 
 But it needs to be said clearly, too, that there is a longer term. 
 That, in an age of wonders in the Communist world, involves a fresh Western approach to the heart of the matter, the hopeless poverty of Vietnam. 
 Nobody should be too blithe here either. 
 Mr Douglas Hurd in the House yesterday shuffled uneasily between Washington wrath and Hanoi despair. 
 Nonetheless, as the Government endures months of opprobrium, there is a clear imperative to begin addressing the long-term, and small ways to make a start. 
 Vietnam, remember, shares with Argentina the distinction of being a country where the British Government doesn't match the aid resources of non-governmental relief organisations like Oxfam. 
 Getting moving here won't mitigate the despair; but it would at least show some capacity to think beyond the sourly inescapable. 
 Hot off the press. 
 YESTERDAY, by neat irony, featured the morning of the Master of the Rolls and the afternoon of the Press Council. 
 Before lunch, Lord Donaldson pronounced further on the case of William Goodwin, 23-year-old journalist for The Engineer. 
 &bquo;Notwithstanding the general need to protect journalistic sources,&equo; he said, &bquo;this is a case where the balance comes down in favour of disclosure.&equo; 
 After tea, the Press Council published &mdash; for further discussion &mdash; its 119-page self-reforming review, including a new code of practice. 
 In that code you will find the following injunction. 
 &bquo;Journalists have a professional obligation to protect confidential sources of information.&equo; 
 A general need: a professional obligation. 
 Two texts for our increasingly beleaguered times. 
 The Press Council review has seemed an age in gestation; and it is not in all respects wonderful. 
 Those who fought through the months to make it a much leaner, quicker body exercising true peer group pressure will be a touch disappointed. 
 The prospective councillors will number two dozen (rather than the sparse but active dozen originally sought); there will continue to be a rather odd balance of journalists and lay members, selected rather than nominated by a quangoid committee. 
 The weight of bureaucracy still hangs a trifle heavy. 
 Nevertheless, the review represents substantial progress. 
 It holds out the promise of swifter verdicts. 
 It appends that promise to a clear and comprehensive code of conduct (one that builds helpfully on the recently published Fleet Street set of principles). 
 And it adds to the sanctions the Council may take &mdash; positioning of judgements in offending papers; a privacy hot line; and, more controversially, hauling in proprietors to discipline editors. 
 The Council, in sum, is seeking most of the tools it needs to relaunch itself as an active, respected self-regulator. 
 It sees ways of making certain that small points of correction are dealt with speedily, and thus the chance of devoting extra energy to the broader guidelines and the delineation of greater issues. 
 This is the crucial change. 
 Through most of its existence, the Council has viewed itself as a slightly pettifogging, rather legalistic arbitrator. 
 But there was an introversion to that which meant that too few readers of too many newspapers knew what it was there for. 
 That was bad for newspapers and bad for the Council: but, worst of all, it meant that there was no independent body able to speak up for press freedoms under threat. 
 Perhaps, as the review gathers steam, this can now change. 
 It needs to. 
 The entrails of the law have been choking press freedoms throughout the nineteen eighties. 
 (Look back to the supposedly liberalising 1981 Contempt of Court Act and ask yourself whether its parliamentary proponents intended the general outcome that Lord Donaldson now proclaims). 
 The future &mdash; and the hope of escaping yet more damaging legislation &mdash; rests on greater attention to the Council and greater respect for its findings. 
 In short, professional regulation for a rough trade aspiring to become a profession (with the professional responsibilities invoked above). 
 This is not, in all respects, an appealing road. 
 Journalists aren't barristers or doctors. 
 They are imperfect players in an imperfect democracy; and they are there, from time to time, to write and investigate things that the closed worlds of the British professions would grind their teeth over. 
 A truly free press is a press which irritates and infuriates along the way. 
 A reformed Press Council, by these lights, tugs in the wrong, conformist direction (and, see its proferred code, is a sight too deferential to great and good bodies, like itself, who want to make papers toe the line). 
 But such philosophical dissent, at this point, is the stuff of dreams in a dreamworld. 
 As the Fleet Street editors themselves recognised a couple of weeks ago, many British papers have forfeited the strength on which their freedom depends: they are not seen as the defenders of freedom by their own readers. 
 With that relationship gone, they are at the mercy of more laws and more political meddling. 
 In which case, the only respite is too regain vestiges of trust; and the only clear mechanism for that is the over-arching responsibility of the Press Council. 
 Louis Blom-Cooper and his team made a reasonably promising start yesterday. 
 They deserve a brisk and supportive response from the industry. 
 They want to be the court of principle and last resort for British press standards. 
 It is crucial that they be given a wholehearted, well-funded chance; for otherwise the court of last resort may turn out to be the one where the Master of the Rolls holds sway. 
 PAGE 
 Diary. 
 By Andrew Moncur 
 WE STILL don't know which Tory backsliders dared to second Sir Anthony Meyer's nomination papers in his bid for ultimate power. 
 But we do know that while the votes were being counted Her Indoors was in the company of a notorious Tory wet and dissident. 
 Viz. HM the Queen. 
 One version circulating at the Palace is that Her Majesty realised that Her Other Majesty didn't yet know the result when she arrived for their weekly get-together. 
 So HM spun out the agony. 
 Yes, we've seen it on TV but &mdash; oh, dear &mdash; we can't remember the figures. 
 Margaret Hilda was left in nail-biting tension until Sir William (no relation) Heseltine, the Palace's chief bag-carrier, popped his head round the door with the vital data. 
 IT'S TIME to announce the Diary Press Awards for 1989. 
 These mark some remarkable achievements. 
 It's also an opportunity to say that the US supermarket papers are streets ahead when it comes to headline writing. 
 For instance: &bquo;Man Explodes On Operating Table&equo; (The Globe, California). 
 Well done. 
 The judges are breaking new ground this year by bestowing the diary's Bon Mot Trophy on a piece of work as yet unpublished. 
 Namely, the Christmas issue of Radio Times. 
 It gives details of Radio 4's New Year Day item based on the Lady Chatterley trial, with this note by Michael Green, the controller: &bquo;It's not just a seminal piece of history&hellip; &bquo; 
 THE SPECIAL Kurt Waldheim Award for War Reporting goes to Paul Johnson for his Spectator column (February 18). 
 This suggested, basically, that machine-gunning prisoners-of-war is OK. 
 Specifically, in the case of Anthony Miers, the Royal Navy submariner who finally came in for a teeny bit of criticism over his methods of disposing of German seamen who rather inconveniently surrendered. 
 &bquo;We could have fought an honourable, Observer-Guardian-style war with the Ludovic Kennedys in charge, but we would have lost it and Britain would have been enslaved,&equo; he wrote. 
 &bquo;Miers could not take the German prisoners on board his sub, and if he had left them to paddle ashore they would immediately have gone back into the German forces&hellip; 
 So, whether or not they were armed, or he believed they were armed, he was right to kill them.&equo; 
 Jolly good. 
 NEXT, the diary's award for Strictly Objective Reporting. 
 Rupert Murdoch's Sun used a splash story on November 30, headlined TV Licence Sensation. 
 &bquo;Battling Barry Neal won an astounding legal victory yesterday &mdash; giving viewers the right to watch Sky TV without a telly licence&hellip; &bquo; 
 THIS YEAR'S Peregrine Worsthorne Memorial Trophy is awarded to Peregrine Worsthorne. 
 His Sunday Telegraph column of October 29 was written after the case of the Guildford Four. 
 It dwelt on the problems arising when Irish suspects, caught in police trawls, turned out to be only Republican sympathisers rather than terrorists. 
 They might not positively help the IRA but they're not, properly speaking, innocent. 
 &bquo;In the light of these realities, is it really reasonable to expect the police to apply to the Irish population in this country the presumption of innocence that they apply to other citizens? 
 I don't believe that it is&hellip; &bquo; 
 THE LEADER Writer of the Year award goes, again, to the Sun. 
 It worked up a fair frenzy over the Tory leadership contest, describing Herself's terribly threatening opponent as, variously, a &bquo;dotty baronet&equo; (November 29); &bquo;the Bufton Tufton of the Tory back benches&equo; (November 30); and &bquo;The fossil&equo; (December 1). 
 But the winning entry was the leader of October 24: &bquo;Thank God for our bobbies. 
 Their image has been severely damaged recently. 
 But how many of the Guildford Four were driving ambulances in London yesterday?&equo; 
 ANEW title. 
 The citation reads: &bquo;Today, the Murdoch tabloid, has distinguished itself chiefly by its self-description throughout 1989 as &bquo;Newspaper of the Year&equo;. 
 That title relates, in fact, to 1987. 
 The judges hope that Today will adopt the accolade now bestowed: Not The Newspaper of the Year.&equo; 
 NOW, JUST one winning entry for the Vicar's Competition: captions for the nineties. 
 &bquo;Jubilation in North-East as Sunderland is chosen for Japanese nuclear test zone.&equo; 
 (A.Hird) 
 AFINAL, topical word. 
 The Common Cold research unit, in Salisbury, was hard pressed to deal with inquiries yesterday. 
 Yes. 
 F-L-U. 
 PAGE 
 Quote&hellip;. 
 COMPARED with the changes sweeping through Eastern Europe, Fidel Castro seems a Marxist museum piece &mdash; staging show trials, jailing dissenters, resisting any dilution of dogma. 
 Now he edges closer to an open break with his Soviet benefactors. 
 In a tirade Thursday, he complained that Mikhail Gorbachev's reforms were &bquo;slandering socialism, destroying its values, discrediting the party and liquidating its leading role&equo;&hellip; 
 As if to prove he cannot be ignored, Mr Castro boldly tests the limits of Moscow's tolerance. 
 He simultaneously dismisses all reforms as a surrender to capitalism, and undermines a fragile peace pact in Central America. 
 But he can play the spolier only with Soviet aid. 
 This leaves an opening for President Bush&hellip; 
 Fidel Castro may bark, but his bite depends on Communist allies he now scorns. 
 New York Times, December 11 
 Only obeying orders &mdash; forty years on Why are East Germans bent on punishing their former leaders? 
 Anna Tomforde reports. 
 WHAT East Germans are now openly calling their &bquo;revolution&equo; is far from over. 
 It has only just begun. 
 Seen from the outside the nature, and above all, the neck-breaking speed of achievements over the past two months may seem remarkable. 
 But in East Germany, getting rid of old leaders, abolishing the Communist Party's monopoly of power, and securing free elections is not enough. 
 The word widely used to describe the sequel is Konsequent. 
 It translates literally as &bquo;consistent&equo; but means more that things must be seen through. 
 Hence, the large broom that party members handed to the new Communist leader, Doctor Gregor Gysi, to enable him to pursue &bquo;radical renewal&equo;. 
 It is a revolution more obviously compared with the French than with any other revolution because of its stages of progression, even though it has so far been peaceful despite the anger. 
 Nonetheless cries of &bquo;Kill them &lsqb;the Communists&rsqb;&equo; have been heard on the fringes of the Leipzig demonstrations as protesters stormed the offices of the hated secret police. 
 One Stasi officer shot himself in front of intruders in the southern town of Suhl. 
 Whereas in other countries the old guard is pushed into oblivion, here it is put behind bars to prepare what could become the show trials of the 1990s. 
 In Hungary, Janos Kadar was almost gently pushed aside, in Poland the Communists were swept from power, and in Czechoslovakia Mr Husak retired &mdash; but nobody called for his arrest. 
 In East Germany, Mr Honecker, gravely ill, is under house arrest for which the prosecutor admitted there was no basis in law. 
 &bquo;The justification is the will of the people,&equo; he said. 
 General Erich Mielke, the much-decorated veteran of the Spanish Civil War, in his 80s, is now languishing in prison. 
 And as for Mr Willi Stoph, the former prime minister, a major mark against him is that 100 different brands of whisky were found in his cellar &mdash; in other countries that would be admired. 
 None of this is being said to arouse, in any way, pity for East Germany's former Communist leaders, who have so thoroughly disappointed their people and betrayed the ideals of socialism. 
 It is said only to underline the specific nature of the German revolution. 
 At East Berlin's Rosa Luxemburg Platz underground station, the post-First World War posters urging &bquo;Kill Luxemburg &mdash; kill Liebknecht&equo; come as a chilling reminder of the past. 
 In the course of the present campaign against corruption, East German newspapers, wireless and television have published urgent appeals to citizens, complete with addresses and telephone numbers to turn to, to report any signs of abuse and malpractice. 
 There is also a north-south division in East Germany's revolution. 
 In 1946, the more moderate people of the north long resisted the southern fervour for the confiscation of private land, and the forced alliance between the Social-Democratic and Communist Parties. 
 This, the revolutionaries in the south, in Dresden, Leipzig, and Karl-Marx-Stadt, have not forgotten. 
 Visitors from the north find that they are denied petrol at garages and that their cars are sprayed with &bquo;Traitor&equo; slogans. 
 But both the period of the ancien regime and the period of change in East Germany have revealed another German characteristic &mdash; that of going along with authority. 
 Lieutenant-general Wolfgang Schwanitz, the new head of the Office for National Security, the former Stasi, was asked the other day why he had not opposed and exposed excesses when he was deputy head of the organisation. 
 He replied: &bquo;We had our orders and they would have shot me if I had resisted.&equo; 
 It sounds a familiar excuse, marking the darker chapters of recent Germany history. 
 Last Saturday, some 30 children of former Stasi officers held a demonstration in East Berlin's Lustgarten. 
 They held up posters rejecting the idea that their fathers were anything like the Gestapo, and calling for &bquo;full social security&equo; for Stasi officers expected to lose their posts in the process of trimming the service. 
 &bquo;Our fathers were no criminals, they just obeyed orders,&equo; a young boy said in a discussion. 
 Doctor Gysi, also calling for &bquo;social integration&equo; of Stasi members, told the party's congress: &bquo;There were many honest comrades in the Stasi who loyally fulfilled their duties and who were not able to choose the tasks they were given.&equo; 
 The past also played a part at the Communist Party's congress. 
 A high-ranking army officer confessed: &bquo;We showed too much discipline, too much blind obedience.&equo; 
 An ordinary delegate said he rejected the idea of blaming only the previous leaders for past mistakes. 
 &bquo;It is as in 1945. 
 Too many of us now say that they didn't know what was going on, and that they were long opposed to what was happening. 
 There are similarities between National Socialism and Stalinism: the methods are almost the same,&equo; the delegate added in an unusually frank contribution. 
 East Germany's revolution also has an extremely puritanical and Protestant streak. 
 An interesting parallel for this is provided by an exhibition that has just opened in East Berlin, commemorating the 500th anniversary of the birth of Thomas Muntzer, the theologian and Protestant reformer, who led the 16th-century Peasants' Revolt. 
 The prints and drawings on display by Durer, Cranach, and others reveal the cruelty and revenge inflicted on both sides during the uprising, and in Muntzer's execution in 1525. 
 With German exactness, they show in elaborate detail the instruments of torture and execution. 
 When Mr Honecker chaired a meeting of the exhibition committee last February, he adopted Thomas Muntzer's central demand that &bquo;all power shall be given to the common people&equo;. 
 Eight months later, Mr Honecker was chased from office and in disgrace. 
 A slightly comique night at the opera. 
 The opening of the Opera de la Bastille is now firmly promised for March &mdash; after years of political and artistic tumult. 
 In the end President Mitterrand chose his friend Pierre Berge, head of a fashion house, to sort out the mess. 
 Peter Lennon reports from Paris. 
 IN PARIS a certain elite will refer to the new Opera de la Bastille with pinched disdain as &bquo;tres TNP&equo;. 
 Very Theatre National Populaire &mdash; the noble soup kitchen of theatrical nourishment at Chaillot created by a saint of the Left, Jean Vilar; probably the most successful example in French cultural life of persuading the hoi polloi to vary their entertainment diet. 
 In fact President Mitterrand's grandiose opera house &bquo;modern and popular&equo; was originally an idea of Vilar's &mdash; an opera with immense auditoria to replace the old Palais Garnier. 
 Vilar's report, produced in 1968, went the Humpty Dumpty way of most projects that revolutionary year. 
 This week the Opera de la Bastille finally announced an opening date, March 17, and revealed its opening programme, a full performance of Berlioz's six-hour Les Troyens. 
 So after an unsuccessful attempt by a right wing government to have the Opera buried; a series of firings and resignations &mdash; Barenboim, Boulez and a rupture with Nureyev &mdash; the Bastille is preparing to open. 
 Mr Pierre Berge is now supremo of President Mitterrand's grandiose project &mdash; an auditorium seaing 2,700; a smaller salle modulable with from 600 to 1,300 places, a studio with 280 places, rehearsal rooms for dancers and choir, bars and a Tour d'Argent resturant. 
 However it will not open too wide. 
 At the press conference at the Bastille on Monday Mr Berge was only offering a &bquo;petit saison&equo;. 
 At the conference Mr Berge was flanked by Daniel Bareboim's replacement, the Korean conductor, Myung-Whun Chung Mr Berge's role was to be cocky and confident and dismiss scepticism about the chances of the opera house becoming a permanent reality. 
 This was no great problem for Mr Berge; being cocky and confident comes naturally to him whether he is presiding over his other little empire, the Yves Saint Laurent fashion house, or standing over a gaping hole in credibility. 
 None of the French journalists embarrassed him by pointing out that this first &bquo;petit saison&equo; of the Opera &mdash; and even the next season &mdash; fall far short of the target for the Opera de la Bastille, which is 250 performances a year. 
 Mr Berge, appointed in September last year by his friend President Mitterrand, opened the conference with the declaration that despite the jealous and envious reports of the foreign press they now had at the Opera a &bquo;welded team&equo; and were in a condition of being &bquo;resonant and reasonable&equo;. 
 Mr Berge asked what could be more appropriate than to open with a French composer? 
 There is a particular kind of French personality who always pronounce the word francais as if it were a football he is heading towards less privileged mortals. 
 Mr Berge's tossing delivery is a classic of this kind. 
 Later that afternoon I had an audience with the opera's new boss. 
 Mr Berge is one of those Frenchmen, his manner distrait, who gives you the impression that you have outstayed your welcome before you have even sat down. 
 The exchanges were exceptionally unfruitful because of Mr Berge's way of delivering every reply as if it were the last word any resonable man would wish to hear on that particular matter. 
 We sat facing across a desk in a rather denuded office in Carlos Lott's building which resembles an unravelling hat box. 
 I sought clarification on a point he had made at the press conference. 
 Did you actually say that the Paris opera ballet was the best in the world? 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; Mr Berge retorted, surprised that the matter needed checking. 
 You said it was incontestably the best? 
 &bquo;It is incontestably the best.&equo; 
 Moscow? 
 &bquo;No, no.&equo; 
 New York?. 
 &bquo;No, no. 
 They don't have the tradition we have.&equo; 
 Shouldn't you be a little more&hellip;? 
 &bquo;Modest?&equo; 
 Mr Berge anticpated, making it clear that he could see no necessity for such an attitude. 
 Aged 59, born in the Ile d'Oleron, Pierre Berge in his teens was a close friend of Jean Cocteau. 
 In 1949 he founded a magazine, La Patrie Mondiale, which published contributions from Camus, Raymond Queneau, Breton and Sartre. 
 In 1950 he met the painter Bernard Buffet and was his business manager for 8 years. 
 But it was in 1958 that he formed the central personal and business partnership of his life. 
 He met Yves Saint Laurent, then at Dior, and helped him found his own fashion house. 
 Berge is known for his fierce defence of Saint Laurent. 
 He has been known to ban from his salon journalists who have criticised Saint Laurent's more feeble efforts. 
 You edited a journal once? 
 &bquo;It was a political journal. 
 That was just after the war, 1949, and I was passionately interested in all the political movements.&equo; 
 You are left-wing? 
 &bquo;Always! 
 Very left even. 
 But I was never a Communist. 
 I have never been a Marxist. 
 I have realised an equilibrium between Left and Right by being an anarchist.&equo; 
 An anarchist? 
 &bquo;An anarchist.&equo; 
 What do you mean by anarchist? 
 &bquo;I had an anarchist education.&equo; 
 Who did you read? 
 &bquo;Is this a philosophical interview?&hellip; 
 I read Bakunin &mdash; people like that.&equo; 
 Mr Berge's special brand of anarchy seems to be particularily suited to capitalism. 
 Founder of one of the most successful fashion houses in Paris, he is also founder and President of the Syndicate of Designers and Creators of Ready-to-Wear which brought haute couture into the open market place, particularly in America. 
 But well heeled Frenchmen often wear political allegiances like fragrant button holes: it is part of their personal decoration rather than a constraint on their way of life. 
 DO ANY singers still boycott&hellip; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Mr Berge interrupted. 
 Not a single one? 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Did you say something about Mr Boulez perhaps returning to work at the opera? 
 It was Boulez who last January led a boycott by international singers and conductors following Barenboim departure. 
 &bquo;Mr Boulez has been associated with the project from the very first days so I say he can consider this house his home. 
 If he comes he is welcome.&equo; 
 When I spoke to his assistant she told he had said his last word on the subject and did not want to hear of it again. 
 &bquo;It's up to him,&equo; Mr Berge retorted. 
 You are also President Director General of the Saint Laurent fashion house. 
 Is it much the same there as in an opera &mdash; panic, temperament, drama? 
 &bquo;Exactly the same. 
 I work in fashion certainly but I could work in many things. 
 There is no difference for me between working in a fashion house and working in an opera. 
 Mr Chung is only Musical Director? 
 &bquo;Only?&equo; 
 Mr Barenboim had a more authoratative title, Artistic Director? 
 &bquo;Mr Barenboim had all the titles. 
 It is precisely because he had many titles that we did not see agree, he and I. Voila.&equo; 
 The Barenboim affair is complicated. 
 Despite the initial support of the boycott by international operatic stars &mdash; most of whom were at the time on contract to work with him &mdash; Barneboim's case did not excite much public sympathy in France. 
 It was discovered that the five year contract he had signed with the right wing government three days before the general elections entitled him to &pound;724,000. 
 For this he only had to spend four months in France, thus profiting from considerable tax concessions for non residents. 
 When the Socialist government came to power there was a furious public row. 
 The contract was declared null and void. 
 Berge offered Barenboim less than half the money. 
 Barenboim could not back down and the great exodus, Boulez, Chereau, began. 
 You said that the international press had written some disagreeable things about the opera? 
 What were you referring to? 
 &bquo;To a lot of things. 
 The French press is not as bad as the English. 
 We don't have gossip papers in France while in England you have many. 
 When we have a little technical problem they transform it into a big one.&equo; 
 What are the present technical problems? 
 &bquo;The elevators in the main auditorium for scene changing don't work well and they have to work well. 
 We have asked the people who constructed this building to take over the theatre in January until March. 
 They will give the theatre back to us for the opening and then we will give it back to them for the Summer during which they should solve the problem.&equo; 
 Why did you choose Mr Chung? 
 &bquo;I chose him because he is a very great conductor. 
 Because Mr Karajan told me he was a very great conductor &mdash; that was the last message he gave me.&equo; 
 What was the problem with Barenboim's programme? 
 &bquo;There was no audacity. 
 While I will put on Les Troyens, which is perhaps the greatest piece of audacity in the history of opera. 
 Voila!&equo; 
 At the press conference Mr Berge had declared that they were not &bquo;frileux or ashamed&equo;. 
 The exact sense of frileux had slipped my mind; I asked Mr Berge for clarification. 
 He drew an imaginary scarf across the bridge of his nose. 
 Suffocating? 
 I suggested. 
 Covered? 
 It began to feel like a night at the Marx Bros opera where you had to guess what Harpo was trying to say. 
 Veiled! 
 I shouted? 
 Veiled, Mr Berge agreed. 
 At the Opera de la Bastille they do not have to veil themselves in shame because they are resonant and reasonable: that is the message. 
 By Clare Colvin 
 IN THE dim half-light of a winter's afternoon, the gradual incline of Cranley Gardens in Muswell Hill stretches bleakly ahead, bringing to mind the lonely victims of the street's most notorious resident, Dennis Nielsen. 
 Two-thirds of the way down is Buchi Emecheta's house, built in the anonymous style of 1930s ribbon development. 
 On the porch a notice announces that the occupier takes part in the neighbourhood watch scheme, despite which Emecheta opens the door without checking, providing the first feeling of welcome in the slough of despond. 
 She has the bulkiness of a mother figure, plaited Afro braids and, at first, a cautious smile that only gradually gives way to full-hearted laughter. 
 Buchi Emecheta is best remembered for her first book, In the Ditch, an autobiographical account of life in 1960s London for a young Nigerian woman with five children. 
 It was like Poor Cow or Cathy Come Home except that the woman at the sharp end of the social services was also the author. 
 Emecheta determined then that she would write herself out of her poverty. 
 Her eleventh novel, Gwendolen, has just been published and she says that for the first time she is writing for her soul. 
 Unlike many of her earlier books, set in her birthplace of Nigeria, Gwendolen is in Britain of the recent past. 
 Gwendolen is a Jamaican girl who is sexually abused first by an &bquo;uncle&equo; in Jamaica and then, when she joins her parents in London, by her father. 
 She becomes pregnant by him and is forced to leave home but is determined to keep the child. 
 &bquo;I have met girls like Gwendolen,&equo; says Emecheta. 
 &bquo;A few years ago I gave a lecture at Preston Polytechnic and afterwards nine black girls, some of them with toddlers, stayed behind and we began to talk. 
 All but two of them had been abused and I remember one girl saying to me, &bquo;By the time I was nine I knew what it was all about.&equo; 
 I wanted to bring their story out into the open.&equo; 
 She has set her book in Tottenham of the 1970s &mdash; a pressure point for racial tension between white and black, and between African and Caribbean. 
 As an Ibo from Nigeria, Emecheta's antennae for racial differences are acute. 
 When she was first looking for rooms to rent, she had to pretend to be Yoruba rather than Ibo in order to persuade a Nigerian landlord to accept her as a tenant. 
 Most of Emecheta's life has been a fight to get what she feels is her due. 
 Born in Lagos in 1944, she was brought up by relatives after her father died as a result of war service in Burma and her mother returned to Ibo. 
 Emecheta insisted that although she was a girl she wanted an education and managed to get a scholarship to the Methodist Girls' High School. 
 An early marriage and five children would have tempered most women's ambitions and had Emecheta's marriage been happy, she might have settled for domestic life. 
 But after they arrived in England her husband became a perpetual student and their life deteriorated. 
 Five months pregnant with her fifth child, Emecheta fled and ended up in a council block for problem families, which became the setting for In The Ditch. 
 She wrote it as a series of articles and sent the first three to Richard Crossman, then editor of the New Statesman. 
 An encouraging letter from him was followed by six weeks' silence, so eventually she walked into his office and confronted him. 
 He was none too pleased at her unheralded visit, but the series Life In The Ditch began, and was later published as a book by Barrie and Jenkins. 
 Emecheta followed its success with Second-Class Citizen and The Bride Price but when her publishers, Allison and Busby, went broke, she decided to publish the hardbacks herself and sell on the paperback rights. 
 It was very much a cottage industry: she and her two sons would drive around with books in the car, being their own distributors. 
 Only now has she come in from the cold with her eleventh book being published by Collins (at &pound;10.95). 
 Writing has always been fitted in before other demands on her time &mdash; two hours in the morning before the children were awake when they were living at home. 
 She took a BSc honours degree in Sociology at London University, worked as a community counsellor for one-parent families in Camden and was on the literature panel of the Arts Council until their decision to return to the Government some money designated for writers' bursaries led her to resign in disgust. 
 In 1980 she was appointed Senior Research Fellow at the University of Calabar, Nigeria, is now a Fellow at London University and takes creative writing groups at Goldsmiths College. 
 &bquo;If I was starting out today I would have found it much more difficult,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;For a start, there are no private landlords now who would take in a 22-year-old mother with five young children. 
 I would probably end up in a bed and breakfast hostel, in which it would be impossible to write.&equo; 
 Despite her success, Buchi Emecheta still feels about this country much as she did when she first arrived 30 years ago, on a grey March morning in Liverpool. 
 A country that gave her a cold welcome, in which the To Let signs specified &bquo;No Coloureds&equo;, and of which she wrote in Second-Class Citizen, &bquo;If I had been Jesus I would have passed England by and not dropped a single blessing.&equo; 
 In Gwendolen she writes of the way a black woman like Sonia, Gwendolen's mother, is treated, either with polite indifference or as if she is not there. 
 &bquo;In England people just leave you alone because you are black. 
 At first you resent it, but then you get used to it, and it is good for being a creative writer. 
 I have spent my adult life here but because of little pinpricks I feel I don't belong. 
 There is a much more welcoming feeling in America or Holland.&equo; 
 Her Nigerian roots are still very much part of her.She goes back therefrequently, and whenever she returns she takes books to distribute in the villages &mdash; they are highly prized in Nigeria, where it takes half an average month's salary to buy a hardback. 
 The collection of mementos on her mantelpiece sums up the different strands of her life. 
 In the centre is a model of the Statue of Liberty, which represents an award from an American university. 
 There is a diploma from another university and several children's photographs. 
 Perched to the left of them is a bulky wooden figure which came from her village of Ibusa. 
 This, Emecheta explains, is a very strong goddess of the Ibos, so strong that Hausa soldiers dare not attack her for fear of being made impotent. 
 Somehow you are not surprised to learn that Emecheta borrowed the goddess' name, Ogwuguwu, for her publishing imprint. 
 It seems appropriate. 
 Guardian Women is edited by Louise Chunn PAGE wom 
 Small change for a great two-way favour Input / Nigel Fountain. 
 AT LAST week's meeting of European Community leaders, the rich countries of Western Europe decided to provide funds to help develop the economies of their neighbours to the east. 
 A development bank is to be set up, Poland will get more than &dollar;500,000,000 from the EC, and Hungary too is getting assistance. 
 Now wait for the gripes to start. 
 Despite the enthusiasm which greeted the revolutions in the East, some people will probably complain about greedy foreigners hogging our hard-earned cash. 
 Such views are daft. 
 At last the Eastern Bloc nations might have a chance of catching up with the West, and we owe them a debt. 
 Another daft view is that all the woes which have beset the Soviet Union and its satellites are because these countries didn't know how to run their economies. 
 Sure, there is inefficient production, horrific pollution, shortages and corruption from East Berlin to the Soviet Union's Pacific coast. 
 A lot can be blamed on years of dictatorship and rotten planning &mdash; but not all. 
 The Soviet Union paid the highest price for the Allies' victory over Hitler's Germany in 1945. 
 The Soviet dictator, Stalin, hadn't wanted to fight the Nazis, and panicked when they invaded in 1941. 
 But one of the great ironies of the second world war was that the freedom and democracy that was won back in Western Europe was largely paid for by the blood of Russians. 
 While the West recovered and prospered, the peoples of the Soviet Union were left with another four decades of dictatorship. 
 By 1945 the Russians had lost more than 20 million people (British losses were 400,000) and 25 million people were homeless. 
 The country was devastated, but ruled by a regime with the world's largest army, which dominated Eastern Europe. 
 Western rulers were scared of the Soviet Union. 
 And that was one reason why the United States was willing to aid European countries. 
 The aid the US &mdash; and Canada &mdash; gave to Western Europe dwarfs anything on offer to the East today. 
 Between 1948 and 1952 more than &dollar;55 billion was provided. 
 Did the scheme &mdash; the Marshall Plan &mdash; work? 
 Look at the evidence. 
 There is plenty of poverty in Western countries but there are democracies too, and Western Europeans are amongst the richest, and most productive people in the world. 
 Attempts to extend the Marshall Plan to Eastern Europe failed, largely, but not entirely, because of Stalin's hostility to US influence within his &bquo;empire&equo;. 
 Instead he looted Eastern Bloc countries to rebuild Russian industry. 
 Up to a point his ruthlessness succeeded. 
 The Soviet Union and the countries it controlled have recovered from the war and, compared with the peoples of the poorer countries of the southern hemisphere, even the Poles are well off. 
 Fears of what might happen in the East are one reason EC leaders have been willing to offer some help to those on the other side of the broken Berlin Wall. 
 But they are often pretty mean about it. 
 Lech Walesa was probably more popular when he was a freedom-fighter in Poland than when he came here recently and complained about the low level of enthusiasm for investing in his country.Today the only country to spend more than 1 per cent of its output on aid is Norway, with Holland and Denmark close behind. 
 Britain shells out only 0.3 per cent, and the US 0.2 per cent. 
 Events like Live Aid showed we are prepared to assist our fellow world citizens &mdash; even if there's a hefty dose of self-congratulation about how noble we are. 
 But without proper government action, they only scratch at the problem. 
 They are also fogged by the dumb idea that we are just doing someone else a favour. 
 A shrewd aid programme does us a favour. 
 It would prevent the destruction of rain forests and save our climate. 
 And it can open up new export markets. 
 It does something else too. 
 Hitler and Stalin emerged from war, revolution, inflation and famine. 
 Help to prevent these conditions and you help to stop another Hitler or Stalin. 
 Law Report: Solicitors must pay for their negligence Queen's Bench Division Dickinson v Jones Alexander &amp; Co Before Mr Justice Douglas Brown October 16 1989. 
 Awife whose solicitors have been negligent in negotiating a financial settlement in her divorce proceedings is entitled to damages against the solicitors. 
 The measure of such damages should be calculated by assessing the amount that a court could have ordered the husband to pay to the wife under the statutory provisions. 
 She is also entitled to damages for her mental distress caused by the solicitors' negligence. 
 The facts. 
 A wife, who had been married for six years, consulted the defendant firm of solicitors about her divorce proceedings. 
 Her husband was a wealthy man who belonged to a family that owned a successful printing and publishing business, and the parties had enjoyed a comfortable life-style during the marriage. 
 When the marriage broke down the husband asked the wife to leave the matrimonial home. 
 The defendants' articled clerk handled the wife's affairs and negotiated a financial settlement with the husband's solicitors. 
 The wife was told that the only asset available to her was the matrimonial home and she agreed to take a lump sum of &pound;12,600 with &pound;2,473 maintenance for the two children. 
 A consent order was made in those terms. 
 The articled clerk then advised the wife to buy a small house in an unsuitable area with a mortgage in order to obtain mortgage relief, even though she had no taxable income against which she could claim relief. 
 A senior partner of the defendants endorsed the articled clerk's advice: the wife later went to other solicitors, and proceedings were issued claiming damages for negligence against the defendants in handling the financial provision side of her divorce. 
 The decision. 
 Mr Justice Douglas Brown said that the defendants were negligent (1) in failing to appreciate that they were dealing with a husband of substantial means who might well be able to afford to pay, not only a lump sum, but also substantial periodical payments; (2) in failing to obtain full disclosure of the husband's financial affairs; (3) in failing to realise that because of family trusts and wills the husband had an expectation of further assets; (4) in advising the wife to obtain a mortgage when she had no taxable income; (5) in recommending a settlement which removed the wife's undoubted right to maintenance; and (6) in failing to use ouster proceedings to remove the husband from the matrimonial home. 
 The damages should be assessed as such sums as represented what a judge or registrar in the Family Division would have ordered the husband to pay or transfer under the provisions of section 25 of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. 
 It was argued for the defendants that the wife would not be liable to tax on the damages she received, while her lost income would have been taxable in her hands, and that therefore she should be awarded damages in respect of her net loss after deducting tax. 
 His Lordship said that it was quite likely that the Revenue would seek to argue that all or some of the award was liable to tax. 
 In his Lordship's view, the wife should receive the full sum and in due course account to the Revenue for any tax due. 
 It was also argued for the defendants that the example of judges in personal injuries cases should be followed, and the wife should give credit for amounts of supplementary benefits received. 
 His Lordship rejected that argument and said that there was here no true analogy with personal injuries cases. 
 The wife also claimed damages for mental stress, vexation and strain caused by the defendants' negligence. 
 The defendants accepted that damages could be awarded for mental distress and that the wife actually suffered mental distress. 
 But they submitted that the damage was too remote. 
 His Lordship said the defendants were employed, so far as professional skill could, to relieve the wife from the pressures of her matrimonial situation. 
 They performed that task so unskilfully that the wife's pressures and problems were exacerbated rather than relieved. 
 In the light of the defendants' knowledge of her state of health it was reasonably foreseeable that that would happen if they were negligent and did not obtain a satisfactory resolution of her affairs. 
 The wife was entitled to compensation for her vexation, anxiety and stress which were the direct and foreseeable result of the defendants' negligence. 
 The wife was awarded &pound;10,000 as a lump sum, &pound;103,608 for loss of past maintenance, &pound;203,000 for loss of future maintenance, &pound;6,100 for inadequate property settlement, &pound;2,500 for loss on mortgage payments and &pound;5,000 for mental distress: a total award of &pound;330,238. 
 Appearances: Donald Hart QC and John Haig-Haddow instructed by Irwin Mitchell, Sheffield for the wife; Nicholas Davidson instructed by Willy Hargrave, Leeds for the defendant solicitors. 
 Shiranikha Herbert barrister 
 The Dowager Duchess of Rutland:. 
 THE death of the Dowager Duchess of Rutland has taken from us the last and most loved of our nieces (for niece she was, although older than the present writers by five and ten years). 
 Her father, Frank Tennant, one of the &bquo;Souls&equo;, was our half-brother. 
 Sir Charles Tennant the industrialist, later Lord Glenconner, was her grandfather and our father. 
 This unusual relationship gave us the joy of knowing her very well. 
 Kakoo, as she was always known, was a unique person, one of the loveliest girls we ever saw, and all her life she remained beautiful, with a marvellous sense of humour and a true enjoyment in everything she did and everyone she knew. 
 Lady Diana Cooper, one of her sisters-in-law, called her as &bquo;lovely as an anemone&equo;. 
 She had a wonderful memory and recalled much that happened in both world wars. 
 (One of her brothers was killed in the first.) 
 Another of her aunts was Margot Asquith. 
 Winston Churchill stayed with her at Belvoir Castle and she entertained many friends with wide-ranging interests, among whom were many writers and artists. 
 Belvoir was not her only house, for her late husband the 9th Duke restored Haddon Hall where she took particular pleasure in the rose terraces. 
 Her public life lay largely in the country in which she lived. 
 She did much for the Red Cross, Girl Guides and the Royal Society for the Blind, and was a magistrate for many years. 
 Visiting her in her London house was always a joy. 
 She took such a keen interest in politics, in literature, and the various lives of her children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren. 
 She was always accompanied by her green parrot, who showed his pleasure, or displeasure, when her guests arrived as he followed her about. 
 Kakoo's life spanned almost a century and her wonderful memory made everything so vivid for all the generations who knew her. 
 She was loved by everybody she met. 
 We never heard anyone say an unkind word about her. 
 She will remain a happy memory with us always. 
 Dame Margaret Wakehurst Elliot of Harwood Kathleen Tennant, Dowager Duchess of Rutland, born January 30, 1894; died December 4, 1989 
 Edmund Garvey. 
 Hard on the gardai:. 
 EDMUND Garvey was an old-fashioned policeman who became a controversial head of the Irish Republic's force during one of its most turbulent periods. 
 Commissioner of the Garda Siochana for little more than two years in the 1970s, he presided over a force struggling to cope with a surge in urban crime and the spillover violence of the IRA campaign in Northern Ireland. 
 His response was to try and impose tough discipline and demand greater results at the same time. 
 The result was to create disaffection in the ranks and lead to accusations of police brutality from Amnesty International among others and to Garvey's sacking. 
 A career policeman, Garvey had spent most of his life as a detective in Dublin, becoming assistant commissioner in charge of the anti-terrorist C3 section in 1973. 
 He was appointed commissioner in 1975 and was quickly identified with the tough law and order stand of the then coalition government. 
 During his leadership, the gardai had to deal with major acts of IRA-related violence, including the assassination of the British Ambassador to Dublin, Christopher Ewart Biggs, and the kidnapping of Dutch industrialist Tiede Herrema. 
 Both events led to controversy: fingerprints found at the assassination site were not, as claimed, those of an IRA suspect but of a detective; Herrema's release after a lengthy siege followed an agreement with his kidnappers, signed by Garvey but repudiated by the gardai. 
 Persistent allegations of ill-treatment of suspects and discontent with his old-style discipline left him in the cold. 
 He was dismissed by the Fianna Fail government and challenged the decision in court. 
 He was awarded damages and drew his salary to retirement age. 
 But his career was finished. 
 Joe Joyce Edmund Garvey, born Bradford, 1915; died Dun Laoghaire, November 29, 1989. 
 20 Blowing warm and cold on Europe News round-up. 
 By us75Melanie McFadyean 
 LAST WEEK the Seasick Summit, this week the Strasbourg summit, which saw Mrs Thatcher, so often the scourge of Europe, being polite and conciliatory, eliciting applause from the other 11 members of the EC. 
 But she hasn't altered her position against economic and monetary union (EMU) or the exchange rate mechanism (ERM). 
 Germany and France did a deal to accelerate the process by which these will come about, in exchange for France supporting West Germany's drive towards re-unification with East Germany. 
 President Mitterrand of France (and he's not alone in this) has been anxious that too swift a move to reunify the two Germanys could destabilise Gorbachev, something that could spell disaster not only for the West but for the balance of world power. 
 Mrs Thatcher was in a minority of one voting against the Community's Social Charter, a concession to European workers facing greater competition when the European market is completely open. 
 For Mrs Thatcher, at loggerheads with many of her own party over European issues, this summit was crucial, as it set the tone for debates leading up to 1992 &mdash; not only for European unification but for the next British election in which Europe will be a deciding factor. 
 BOB REID took over from Bob Reid as chairman of British Rail, a job described as a poisoned chalice since there is much trouble on the railways. 
 The name may not have changed but the new Bob will earn &pound;200,000 a year, the old Bob had to make do with quite a few bob less &mdash; &pound;93,000. 
 &bquo;I'm not doing it for the money,&equo; said the new Bob. 
 &bquo;I can earn &pound;400,000 somewhere else.&equo; 
 THE Broadcasting Bill, to be debated by MPs tomorrow, directly affects the future of independent broadcasting. 
 Controversy rages over government proposals to sell new franchises to the highest bidders. 
 Many fear that quality will be sacrificed for cheap and easy quantity, envisaging a fifth channel dominated by low-cost imported programmes. 
 A recent poll showed that 60 per cent of Conservative MPs think standards will fall if some of the proposed changes take place. 
 But advertisers love it &mdash; it means more air time to sell products because the more popular a show is, the more people watch the ads. 
 But what is more important? 
 Advertising revenue or quality? 
 Many &bquo;minority&equo; viewing programmes &mdash; such as children's, documentaries, religious, educational and scientific &mdash; may not attract huge audiences, or lots of advertising, but they reach parts quiz shows, soap operas, American series and adverts don't. 
 ELLO Ello Ello&hellip; 
 Ever been to Shawdicth, Sidnum, County Kork, Redding or Hybry Corner? 
 Ever heard of anyone stealing a Grandfather, an England Goalkeeper worth &pound;31, a four-birth tent, a navel telescope or a Bathoven music book? 
 Perhaps you've seen a man with large plates in his hair, or a brusie on his arm. 
 Maybe he was wearing a leather berry or a pale blue suite. 
 Who was the burglar breaking in through an entryphone? 
 Perhaps he was in cahoots with the one who got in through a skylark? 
 There were 48 mistakes of this sort in crime sheets written by police constables at the same police station. 
 AFIVE-year-old father of 100,000 was spared a horrible fate. 
 Had it not been for human kindess he would have ended up in a pork pie. 
 Instead he celebrated his fifth birthday with a pig-shaped cake. 
 Why pig? 
 Because he is Britain's most venerable pig. 
 He has retired with a Jersey cow, 10 cats and some geese to a cosy smallholding. 
 But his new owners intend to keep the porky Casanova away from the young female pigs. 
 LITTERBUGS: 15,600 plastic six-pack beer rings were found in three hours along 300 miles of Texas shoreline. 
 Letterbugs: Americans get enough junk mail in one day to produce energy to heat 250,000 houses. 
 Forty-four per cent of the junk mail is never even opened. 
 Having a real say in Europe * Commentary. 
 By John Palmer 
 MRS THATCHER is right. 
 The gathering speed of the movement to European union following the Strasbourg summit does pose a potentially serious threat to democratic accountability and hence to the future of Parliamentary government. 
 Ignore for a moment the contradiction in the Prime Minister's simultaneous espousal of an essentially unaccountable German Bundesbank system for future European monetary union and her insistence that the Delors plan for EMU violates Parliamentary control of EC decision making. 
 Her senior officials and expert advisers coyly describe this as &bquo;a contradiction in reality which will take time to work through.&equo; 
 The fact remains that the &bquo;democratic deficit&equo; in European Community affairs is already too great and is set to grow unless some very radical changes are made to the way the EC institutions operate. 
 In a sense what we are witnessing are the birthpangs of &bquo;a European bourgeois state without the usual trappings of bourgeois democracy&equo; as 19th century historians described the emergence of the newly united Kaiser's Germany. 
 This may partly explains why the West German centre-right Conservative led government is adamant that there can be no further move to supra-national European Union that is not accompanied by a demonstrable system of Parliamentary accountability. 
 They will look with justified suspicion, therefore, at Jacques Delors's suggestion yesterday, that there should be two constitutional conferences next year &mdash; one to transfer powers from the national state to the EC on economic and monetary policy and the other, later, to tackle democratic control. 
 Downing Street strategists planning their tactics as the battle for hearts and minds over monetary union enters a crucial phase would be wrong, therefore, to assume that Bonn is a natural ally. 
 Nor is it the case that the Federal Republic is using the issue of democratic accountability to drag its feet on EMU. 
 Moreover the British Government and the Federal Republic mean something quite different about democratic accountability. 
 Where London sees this in terms of restoring some increased role to Westminster MPs, Bonn envisages a much greater role for Members of the European Parliament. 
 The truth is that national Parliamentarians lost their powers to control the Brussels embryo government the moment their governments signed the Treaty of Accession on joining the Community. 
 The Single European Act, signed by Mrs Thatcher and the other EC leaders in 1986, went a significant step further in removing powers from national Parliaments. 
 What Westminster MPs tend not to understand is that the beneficiaries of this process have not been their cousins in the Strasbourg Parliament, nor even the European Commission, but the Council of Ministers. 
 The Council is, thanks to the SEA, more than ever the true &bquo;Parliament&equo; of the European Community in that it &mdash; rather than the Strasbourg assembly &mdash; passes the Community's laws and does so, moreover, behind closed doors in ways which would not be tolerated in any individual national member state. 
 Where does the Government stand on this? 
 Will UK ministers now demand that when the Council meets to legislate its sessions are open to public and Parliamentarians alike? 
 That said, there is no future in trying to make an increasingly supra-national executive (the Council and the Commission) answerable merely to national Parliaments. 
 This might have made sense when all Council decisions that mattered were passed on the basis of unanimity. 
 But more and more decisions are now taken by qualified majority vote. 
 The importance of majority voting will increase since more and more European economic and social legislation will be deemed necessary because of the single European market. 
 To this extent, the Council is literally unaccountable to anyone, even where individual governments remain &mdash; in theory &mdash; answerable to their national Parliaments. 
 The only effective control over an expanding European embryo-government can be exercised by the directly elected European Parliament. 
 That does not mean, however, that there is no role for MPs (and other national legislators in the EC) as we move through a transitional phase from a mainly inter-governmental type of Community to a more fully fledged federal union. 
 Indeed MEPs in Strasbourg would be well advised, as they prepare their demands for greater powers under EMU, to strike a united front with their national colleagues. 
 The way Westminster now treats MEPs is little short of a disgrace. 
 They have no rights in the Palace at all and are, at almost every opportunity, shunned by MPs who mistakenly believe that the European Parliament (and not the Council) is their natural adversary. 
 This contrasts with the situation, elsewhere and notably in West Germany, where MEPs sit along side Bundestag deputies on their EC legislation vetting committee, with full speaking rights. 
 Both West German federal and regional Parliamentarians also want a bigger say over EC legislation but they believe this should be assured by being made members of a new, upper house of the European Parliament. 
 This is similar to the proposals made by the Conservative MEP, Mr Bill Newton-Dunn and latterly by Mr Michael Heseltine. 
 Some Labour MEPs and independent socialists have long argued this is the way to prevent a stranglehold over European integration being exercised by national governments. 
 Ironically Tory MEPs may secure a better working relationship with their Westminster cousins than the Labour party, thanks in part to the respect the Tory MEPs have won for refusing to buckle under Thatcherite pressure over European union. 
 At a recent Labour national executive meeting the leader of the Labour group in the European Parliament failed to get a seconder from either left or right for a motion to have this whole issue discussed by the party conference. 
 Yet Labour has a bigger vested interest in there being a European Parliament which &mdash; during the transition to a more federal union &mdash; co-legislates with the Council, rather than exists as a largely powerless consultative assembly. 
 A stronger European Parliament would be a powerful ally in ensuring that social rights, the environment, a peace oriented foreign policy and democracy itself, are forced higher up the European political agenda. 
 The first step in forging an alliance of Euro-Parliamentarians would be for national MPs to be invited to the special hearings on changes to the Rome Treaty being organised by the European Parliament. 
 But there must first be a common line of action worked out by MPs and MEPs in the political parties. 
 If Westminster MPs are too haughty to consider a role for themselves as a junior revising chamber of the European Parliament and too short sighted to invite Strasbourg experts on to their own select committee on EC affairs, they, not the MEPs will be the eventual losers. 
 Tenants' association club on the Sparrow Farm estate&hellip; it is alleged that people who had been drinking at the club attacked the family in the off-licence opposite PHOTOGRAPHS: KENNETH SAUNDERS Bitter questions of racial violence Ramesh K and his family were hounded out of their Feltham off-licence by 18 months of abuse and attacks, during which time they became pawns in a battle between the local council, the police and two rival race relations bodies. 
 David Rose reports. 
 AT SPARROW Farm, a bleak post-war council estate in Feltham, deafeningly close to the runways of Heathrow Airport, the off-licence in the little parade of shops has changed hands again. 
 Ramesh K, who took on the lease two years ago, has sold up and moved out. 
 In the preceding 18 months, Mr K and his family were repeatedly attacked. 
 They suffered internal injuries and broken bones, had racist slogans daubed on their premises and racist posters thrust into their faces by the perpetrators of previous assaults. 
 The Ks &mdash; who have asked not to be named in full &mdash; are now physically safe. 
 But their case has been the catalyst for a bitter political row, raising fundamental questions about society's ability to deal adequately with racial violence. 
 It has brought claims that the police have failed even to recognise the nature of the problem, much less contain it. 
 It has led the head of the local police, Chief Superintendent Alastair McLean, to accuse Sparrow Farm's owners, Hounslow Borough Council, of left-wing extremism and bad faith towards the police, and Scotland Yard of failing to provide support. 
 It has involved the police in other, hotly contested local struggles: between the Hounslow Community Relations Council, a cautious, conservative organisation, and the Southall Monitoring Group, a body which attempts to support the victims of racial attacks. 
 In both 1988 and 1989, combatting racial violence has been a priority for the Metropolitan Police. 
 Scotland Yard's policies have become ever more sophisticated, backed by expensive publicity campaigns. 
 The Ks' story illustrates the pitfalls which lie in the way of practical implementation. 
 The Commissioner, Sir Peter Imbert, has stated that the police must now be ready to share knowledge and power: to respond to local authorities and other organisations with an &bquo;unswerving commitment to communication and consultation, within which the police and the community are equal partners.&equo; 
 The Ks' case demonstrates that his intention may not be easily carried out. 
 According to Mr K, it all started with an argument with a customer over a faulty toy in an Easter egg last year. 
 The customer's brother &mdash; who cannot be named for legal reasons &mdash; came into the shop a little later and started an argument. 
 He headbutted Mr K and broke his nose. 
 Worried about security, Mr K fitted steel grilles to his windows. 
 Next day, the building and pavement outside were thickly painted with the slogan &bquo;Sieg Heil Sparrow Farm&equo; and swastikas. 
 Through the summer there were less serious, though very unpleasant, incidents &mdash; and all the while, despite Mr K's frequent requests to Hounslow Borough Council, no one came to remove the racist graffiti. 
 Glue was squirted into Mr K's locks, and windows were broken. 
 A youth clambered on to the roof at the back of the shop for a dare and fell through. 
 On December 1 last year, four youths attacked the Ks outside the shop. 
 Later that evening, one returned with his father, John Finn, who was armed with a baseball bat. 
 He turned the shop upside down, smashing stock, breaking bottles. 
 Anoup K, aged 16, suffered broken ribs, internal bleeding and damage to his kidneys. 
 He was hospitalised for a week. 
 Finn senior was convicted of criminal damage, wounding and possessing an offensive weapon. 
 He was sentenced to a year's imprisonment, suspended for 12 months, and ordered to pay &pound;500 costs and compensation. 
 For the next six months, the harassment returned to lower, more manageable, levels: frequent racist abuse, according to Ramesh K, but no violence. 
 On May 29, a window was broken by a stone. 
 A youth was charged and convicted. 
 On July 2, the attacks began again in earnest. 
 Ramesh was punched in the face, and the premises damaged. 
 From then until the middle of August, there were incidents at least once a week. 
 On several occasions, people who had been drinking in the Sparrow Farm tenants' association club opposite the shop left the club and attacked the Ks, both inside the off-licence and, sometimes, as they left after closing for the night. 
 At least four people have been charged with offences in relation to the events of July and August. 
 The last straw came on August 17. 
 Two men entered the shop and insisted that the Ks display two posters. 
 One consisted of a photograph of Salman Rushdie and the slogan &bquo;Rushdie in, Pakis Out.&equo; 
 The other was a photograph of Enoch Powell and the message &bquo;Enoch says keep the Farm white.&equo; 
 Up to that point, says Mr K, &bquo;we couldn't let them win. 
 We could have just put the shutters up, but they'd have said, &bquo;yeah, we got the Pakis out.&equo; 
 We had to keep going, not let them see how we felt.&equo; 
 But now the fight went out of the family: &bquo;What would you do? 
 Would you stay there when you were getting attacked night after night?&equo; 
 Within a month, Mr K had found a buyer for the lease. 
 &bquo;It made money, but not a great deal,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;I thought we could move up through the shop, better ourselves. 
 We had our dreams. 
 Now I'm not interested.&equo; 
 Chief Superintendent McLean says that last summer the resources he allocated to the protection of the Ks were greater than those given to anything, other than really serious crimes such as murder, in the two years he had been in charge of Hounslow division. 
 He admits that at times incidents were not handled perfectly. 
 But, he maintains, 24-hour protection for the Ks was simply not possible. 
 Even before the final wave of incidents, the police operation had been sharply criticised, principally by the Southall Monitoring Group (SMG). 
 First funded by the Greater London Council in 1982, the SMG operates a 24-hour helpline for the victims of racial harassment. 
 It is headed by Suresh Grover, who, like many associated with the organisation, has been active in radical Asian politics since the mid-1970s and the bitter campaign which followed the death of Blair Peach from a police truncheon blow in 1979. 
 FOR YEARS, the SMG has claimed that the police do not deal effectively with racial attacks, that they are slow to respond, reluctant to arrest, and ineffective in presenting the case against alleged assailants in court. 
 It has not been slow to go to the press. 
 The group has also mounted numerous demonstrations and police station pickets. 
 As its name implies, the SMG is based not in Hounslow but in the huge Asian community of Southall, in the neighbouring borough of Ealing. 
 In 1987, the SMG was the subject of a report by PC J. E. Black, the Ealing police intelligence officer. 
 It noted that Ealing Council, which, like Hounslow, is Labour-controlled, had made a grant of &pound;50,000, and listed a number of events: &bquo;April 1986, organised a meeting at Southall Town Hall on the seventh anniversary of Blair Peach's death, called for full inquiry&hellip; 
 August 1986, Labour councillor Pandura Perera cites SMG as example of political cell set up by GLC ostensibly as community group&hellip; 
 January 1987, unnamed spokesman of SMG quoted in Asian Times attacking Commissioner's initiative on racial attacks, doubting motives and intentions.&equo; 
 The report concluded: &bquo;In general the group have continued their efforts to link with the militant left-wing trade unionists on campaigns and demonstrations. 
 They actively seek to expand their influence and would appear to be aiming to cover most of west London&hellip; the group can be expected to continue in their attempts to undermine the police, but are unlikely to be successful except in conditions of widespread disorder, general strike, etc, when they might have a potential for destabilisation.&equo; 
 There are contradictory versions of how the SMG came to work in Hounslow, eventually receiving funding from Hounslow Council 18 months ago. 
 According to Suresh Grover, it began to be active there in 1987, as a result of a serious racial violence case. 
 The organisation's persistent lobbying of the council led, he says, to pressure for new policies in the borough, and eventually further funding for the SMG. 
 Chief Superintendent McLean has an alternative explanation. 
 Hounslow Labour group, led by Dave Wetzel, once the architect of the GLC low fares policy, is controlled by the left. 
 The purpose, he says, &bquo;was not to give succour to the victims of harassment, but to polarise the ethnic minorities and the police.&equo; 
 The attraction of the SMG to the left was not, he believes, its commitment to monitoring racial violence and assisting its victims, but its second stated purpose of monitoring and campaigning on cases of alleged &bquo;police harassment.&equo; 
 Hounslow councillors say they had been under the impression that relations between them and the police were slowly improving, although Mr Wetzel and John Connolly, the influential chair of housing, continue to boycott the statutory police consultative group. 
 Mr Wetzel finds labels like &bquo;extreme left-wing&equo; &bquo;paranoic and outmoded.&equo; 
 In the case of the Ks, the SMG claimed the police had been slow to take statements and prepare cases, and that, inexplicably, weeks elapsed before anyone was charged with the December attack on Anoup K although there had been clear identification. 
 The group also said that the police had failed properly to appreciate the seriousness of what was taking place: that despite the racist nature of the attacks, local beat officers had lectured the Ks themselves on their &bquo;attitude problem.&equo; 
 The victims, according to the SMG, were being partly blamed for the actions of their assailants. 
 EXACTLY such a view of the attacks is now espoused on Sparrow Farm. 
 Among the estate's residents, the fact that several people have been charged or convicted of offences against the Ks cuts no ice: the estate version is that what took place was no more than a personal vendetta, between Ramesh K and the man who broke his nose. 
 &bquo;It was never racial,&equo; says Helena Bagwell, secretary of the tenants' association club where some of the Ks' attackers used to drink. 
 &bquo;It was a situation between a white person and a coloured person. 
 There is no racialism on this estate.&equo; 
 Mrs Bagwell says she bears no responsibility for the club's role in the attacks. 
 &bquo;We condemn what they did, but we can't stop them drinking. 
 You can't blame the whole estate for what they did.&equo; 
 But, she hints, there were &bquo;two sides to the story.&equo; 
 In the newsagent, run by an Asian family, next door to the off-licence, Henry, aged 14, echoes this view: &bquo;They had an attitude problem. 
 If you told them to fuck off, they'd tell you to fuck off back.&equo; 
 Was that not what he expected from Asian shopkeepers, and did that justify breaking their bones? 
 &bquo;I dunno.&equo; 
 What about those who attacked them, were they racists? 
 &bquo;I'm not saying anything. 
 Because I don't want to get smacked in the mouth.&equo; 
 The newsagent Asians have spent 10 years at Sparrow Farm, without being attacked. 
 &bquo;You've got to have a laugh with the kids,&equo; says the proprietress, &bquo;they're alright.&equo; 
 The new occupants of the off-licence, also Asian, have not been attacked since moving in three months ago. 
 This, say Mrs Bagwell and her supporters, the swastikas and posters notwithstanding, is the final proof that the attacks on the Ks were not racially motivated. 
 Their doubts are shared by Chief Superintendent McLean. 
 There was a racial element in the attacks, he says. 
 &bquo;But you've got to ask the questions: why didn't the other shopkeepers have a problem, why haven't the new owners of the off-licence? 
 You've got to be able to draw your own conclusions, that this was to an extent a personal vendetta.&equo; 
 According to the policy of the Metropolitan Police, an incident is classified as racial if the victim, or any other person, alleges a racial motive. 
 The policy states: &bquo;Police action alone cannot achieve positive results,&equo; and they must adopt a &bquo;multi-agency&equo; approach. 
 All racial incidents are carefully monitored at divisional and area level, and senior officers are instructed to be vigilant of possible rising trends. 
 At the beginning of August, a new political dimension entered the Ks' story. 
 Inder Uppal is the senior officer at Hounslow Community Relations Council (HCRC), funded by the borough and the Commission for Racial Equality. 
 Mr Uppal took pleasure in inviting the former Home Secretary, Douglas Hurd, to Hounslow last year, presenting the borough as a harmonious model of good race relations. 
 Locally, however, the skids are under him. 
 &bquo;Mr McLean is a very good friend of mine,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;I can say that the police are definitely trying to stamp out racism. 
 I have yet to come across a police officer who is not interested in stamping out racism.&equo; 
 But, as he admits, Mr Wetzel and his colleagues want to &bquo;disarm me completely.&equo; 
 Council funding of an HCRC cultural centre and other projects has been cut off, and vacant staff posts frozen. 
 Mr Wetzel says: &bquo;I'm looking forward to a reformed HCRC in 1990.&equo; 
 Mr Uppal would have no role in such a body. 
 The scene was now set for the final explosion. 
 In August, the SMG began to press Mr McLean for a meeting to discuss the case, claiming that police protection was ineffective. 
 He replied on August 15, suggesting that the SMG's Balwinder Gill telephone the community liaison officer, adding &bquo;should you wish to meet with me in the meantime, again this can be arranged.&equo; 
 HER REPLY on August 21 appears to have tipped him over a political brink. 
 Apparently disregarding his offer, she wrote: &bquo;We are concerned that you do not consider the above case to be serious enough to warrant a meeting.&equo; 
 Detailed criticism of his handling of the case ensued. 
 There was a further element to Mr McLean's rapidly boiling anger: the sudden arrival of Mr Uppal, who hitherto had taken no interest in the case. 
 Mr Uppal regarded the SMG as an extremist organisation which manipulated racial violence on behalf of his enemies in the council Labour group. 
 He saw their referral of cases to the SMG as a further way of undermining him, and he was determined to fight back. 
 After an initial visit to the Ks from Mr Uppal, the SMG claimed in a letter to him and Mr McLean that the Ks did not want Mr Uppal to become involved in their case. 
 He again went to see them and persuaded them to accompany him to a meeting at the police station with Mr McLean on August 24. 
 Mr Uppal now claims to have been an &bquo;old friend of the family.&equo; 
 Ramesh K says that he had not met Mr Uppal before, and his brother, Kewal K, says that he briefly met Mr Uppal some years ago. 
 &bquo;He said, &bquo;let's try my method, you've had the SMG, now try going to the top person and everything will be OK,&equo;' says Ramesh K. &bquo;After the amount of hassle we'd had, we thought we'd give it a go.&equo; 
 Most of the police station meeting was taken up by discussion between council officers and the police on security for the Ks and ways of dealing with the club &mdash; to which the council, just to complicate matters further, had indemnified a &pound;100,000 loan. 
 Mr McLean made his hostility to the SMG plain. 
 Ramesh K was then brought in for a few minutes. 
 To his surprise, he was not asked for McLean: &bquo;Widening gulf&equo; details of the attacks, but about the origins of the SMG's involvement with the case, which had originally been referred to the SMG by the council. 
 Later that day Mr Grover of the SMG hand-delivered a letter from the K brothers to Mr Uppal, copied to the council and police. 
 It told him to have nothing more to do with them: &bquo;We have reached this decision as a result of the meeting with you and the police this morning.&equo; 
 At the meeting, however, Mr K had told Mr McLean that he had no view about Mr Uppal's involvement. 
 To Mr McLean, this was the last straw: proof that the SMG was &bquo;manipulating its clients.&equo; 
 He had no inkling that Mr Uppal's relationship with the family was other than he had claimed. 
 He wrote immediately to the SMG, cutting off all contact: &bquo;I am not interested in agencies who politic and posture for no other reason than to promote themselves&hellip; secondly, as I am not presently able to place any trust in you, I must insist that any further matters you wish to raise are channelled through to a suitable agency, viz the local council or HCRC.&equo; 
 The SMG make an identical charge against the police and Mr Uppal: &bquo;The Ks were just being used.&equo; 
 Mr Uppal says much the same about the council and the SMG: &bquo;They are using racial harassment for their own ends.&equo; 
 And so in correspondence, in the local press, on local radio and in various public forums the row has raged on. 
 But of all the participants, it is Mr McLean who goes furthest. 
 The affair, he believes, is evidence of a deep-seated political campaign against the police, of which the most recent evidence is the fact that Balwinder Gill, late of the SMG, has now taken up an appointment as a race officer with Hounslow council. 
 In one of the most outspoken statements ever made by a Metropolitan Police officer of his rank, he says: &bquo;The council has been ensuring that as many cases as possible are referred to the SMG, a pernicious organisation spewing out lies and propaganda in pursuance of their own ideological aims. 
 The sad fact is that the SMG is financed by two boroughs, Ealing and Hounslow, members of which are sympathetic to their aims. 
 What results is not a better deal for victims, but a widening of the gulf between the ethnic minorities and the police. 
 To my mind, any council which actively engenders support for such an organisation is in breach of the trust and duty placed in them by the electorate.&equo; 
 Mr McLean goes still further. 
 The senior management of the force has required him to involve himself in politics, to deal with an authority out to undermine him, without adequate resources or support: &bquo;I am conscious that this job gives no backing to senior officers who are libelled, and as far as I am concerned, the job is derelict in its duty to police chiefs.&equo; 
 An active member of the police Superintendents Association, Mr McLean says that at a recent meeting disgust was expressed at the Met's failure to hit back at criticism of this kind &mdash; such as the comment by Bernie Grant, MP for Tottenham, that the divisional chief in his constituency was &bquo;incompetent.&equo; 
 He adds: &bquo;I have to get into the political arena without support. 
 I have to say that I am now prepared to act as I see it: with the same political cunning as any politician.&equo; 
 Faced with Mr McLean's fury, Suresh Grover professes himself stunned. 
 &bquo;We are prepared to work with the police and to provide the information needed to bring the perpetrators of attacks to justice,&equo; he says, adding that he would like to see Mr McLean in the hope of building a relationship. 
 He accepts that the letter which provoked the final breach with Mr McLean, with its confusion over the proposal to meet, &bquo;may have been a misunderstanding.&equo; 
 But he says: &bquo;He used this case to get at us.&equo; 
 Mr McLean will have none of the stirring signs of contrition on the part of the SMG. 
 Admitting that the August 21 letter was a mistake was &bquo;purely for the benefit of the Guardian,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;The Ks were absolute pawns in a very dirty game.&equo; 
 To them must belong the last word. 
 The SMG, says Ramesh K, &bquo;did not use us. 
 We're the ones who used to ring them up in the middle of the night. 
 We used them. 
 We were always looking for someone who could give us help. 
 Because they are Asian they give extra help. 
 Being the same colour, you feel more at home. 
 They put in a bit of effort.&equo; 
 Grover: &bquo;We are prepared to work with the police&equo; OVERNIGHT FILE 
 The costing of care&hellip; the NHS White Paper's plans for ensuring competition will mean integrating medical and nursing staff into the management processPHOTOGRAPH: ROBIN LAURANCE Reform's long haul to health Agenda. 
 By Chris Ham 
 THE Government's health service reforms are running into difficulties. 
 The source of these difficulties is not the campaign of opposition waged by the British Medical Association, nor is it an incipient revolt among backbench MPs. 
 More modestly, and yet in many ways more significantly, it derives from the practical challenge of implementing the reforms outlined in the NHS White Paper, and the failure to convince those who work in the health service of the need for change. 
 At the heart of the Government's programme is the introduction of competition into the provision of health services. 
 By separating responsibility for funding services from their provision, the Government hopes that providers will compete for contracts from health authorities, GP budget holders and private buyers of care. 
 The aim is to turn health authorities into discriminating purchasing agencies, seeking the best deal for their residents by buying services from a range of public, private and voluntary providers. 
 GPs who volunteer to hold practice budgets will act in a similar way for those services for which they are responsible. 
 This process will be carefully regulated to ensure that appropriate services are available in each locality. 
 Managed competition, rather than a free market in health care, is the leitmotif of the reforms. 
 Yet for managed competition to work, a number of conditions have to be met, and this is where difficulties have arisen. 
 First, health service managers must be able to price their services reasonably accurately for trading purposes. 
 At present, this is just not possible in the vast majority of NHS hospitals, because the quality of management information systems is so poor. 
 Work going on as part of the resource management initiative is designed to overcome this problem, and eventually it will produce the information that is lacking. 
 But for the next three to four years at least managers will have to rely more on their judgment than on hard data in deciding what to charge for their services. 
 Second, the purchasers of care need to be skilful in negotiating with providers and in specifying service contracts across the full range of NHS provision. 
 As ministers have emphasised, contracts should deal with quality of care as well as quantity and cost. 
 Although there is some experience of contracting in such services as catering and cleaning, the scale of the programme set out in the White Paper is of a different order. 
 Initially, most contracts are likely to include only a broad specification of the service being purchased. 
 The finer details will have to be added at a later date when experience of operating in a contract culture has been gained. 
 Third, before entering negotiations about contracts, purchasers will have to make an assessment of the services required to meet the health needs of their population. 
 This involves analysing patterns of illness and mortality, as well as conducting market research to discover what local people perceive to be their needs. 
 On this basis, health authorities will be able to establish a picture of the health of their population, and they can then draw up specifications of the services they wish to buy. 
 An important element of this process will be to evaluate the effectiveness of the services on offer in tackling the needs that are identified. 
 The skills required to carry out these tasks are in short supply, even though assessing health care needs and evaluating service effectiveness have long been the responsiblity of directors of public health and their predecessors. 
 A significant increase in the range and quality of staff in areas such as community medicine and health economics is required to enable health authorities to discharge their new purchasing function effectively. 
 A fourth challenge is to develop management arrangements within hospitals to support the introduction of competition. 
 If managers are to deliver on the contract they negotiate with purchasers, there needs to be a means of integrating medical and nursing staff into the management process to ensure that the terms of these contracts are met. 
 This requires that each major service area within hospitals has a designated chief who can negotiate on behalf of colleagues with the hospital manager. 
 The arrangement evolving at a number of the resource management pilot sites, in which a doctor acting as clinical director takes on this role with assistance from a nurse manager and a business manager, indicates the likely direction of change. 
 Where these arrangements co-exist with planning agreements for service areas, as at Guy's Hospital, there is a basis for linking these negotiations with external contracts. 
 However, most NHS hospitals are not yet in this position, and experience at Guy's and other hospitals indicates that the process of giving doctors and nurses a bigger role in management cannot be rushed. 
 Given these difficulties, implementing the White Paper is likely to be a long haul. 
 The period between now and the next election will be spent developing the instruments to enable competition to take place. 
 Much of the responsibility for this will rest with health authorities who will play the key role in demonstration projects recently announced by the Government. 
 These projects, covering issues such as information requirements and the purchasing role of health authorities, are designed to work through the implications of the White Paper at a local level. 
 The aim is to learn from experience gained in the demonstration districts and regions and to disseminate the lessons throughout the NHS. 
 While this work is proceeding, and while the first wave of self-governing trusts and GP budgets are established, competition will be limited to a narrow band of services, such as waiting list surgery. 
 The full impact of the reforms will not be felt until the mid-1990s. 
 And that, crucially, depends on the Government winning a fourth term of office. 
 With opinion polls showing Labour ahead of the Conservatives, many health service managers are biding their time, not prepared to press forward rapidly with changes which could soon be reversed and which in any case they are reluctant to endorse. 
 The failure of ministers to persuade many of those who work in the NHS of the need for reform thus emerges as the key factor shaping the pace of implementation. 
 Despite the blaze of publicity which accompanied the launch of the White Paper, the Government has not been successful in generating support for its proposals. 
 This poses as much of a challenge for a future Labour government bent on reform as for Kenneth Clarke and his colleagues. 
 Although the NHS represents remarkable value for money when viewed in the international context, it has a number of weaknesses, including limited incentives for efficiency and a lack of responsiveness to consumers. 
 Managed competition represents a clear if ambitious strategy for tackling these weaknesses. 
 The Labour Party will need to develop a plausible vision for the future of the NHS if it is to be seen as a credible alternative to the present government. 
 With the status quo no longer an option, the question is how should health services be reformed, not whether. 
 Chris Ham is a policy analyst at the King's Fund Institute and a Fellow of the King's Fund College. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE soc 
 for 1st and 3rd south arts Half Moon.. 
 By John Connor Circus Moon. 
 NEW Circus &mdash; the mixture of traditional skill matched to modern theatrical interpretation &mdash; has been a growing world movement since the beginning of the Eighties. 
 Four years ago, at the Albany Empire, the first British production was tried by Circus Senso. 
 It was gawky, hesitant, and brash. 
 But it was a start. 
 Now, with the same director, part of the original company, and an influx of the new wave of circus talent that has surged up from the streets something magical has happened. 
 For once, the Half Moon's design is actually an asset &mdash; a Cortina is revealed crashed into the back wall. 
 Out of the cracks and the shadows a company comes to play &mdash; juggling, magic tricks, tumbling, and slapstick fill the stage. 
 The eye cannot rest on one thing, as in traditional circus, but you are constantly seeking the next thrill. 
 It is the trick of the big-stage musical number but applied to circus with finesse and much tongue-in-cheek humour. 
 The pace never slackens, even though on the night their big set-piece, the cloud swing, had to be cancelled because the performer had injured herself: not from doing what is actually one of the most dangerous of aerial tricks, but as is so often the way of circus, from doing something offstage unthinkingly, in this case, dancing. 
 What is most remarkable about this piece is its level of pathos &mdash; the company are battling to perform against the wishes of the big, bad man (on stilts) in a suit. 
 It is above all a joyous celebration of all who break down barriers between people set up by authority. 
 Covent Garden. 
 Der Freischutz. 
 By Tom Sutcliffe 
 GOTZ Friedrich's 1977 staging of Der Freischutz, soberly revived at Covent Garden by Wolfgang Bucher, makes a straightforward and unambitious introduction to Weber's melodious nervy masterpiece about the young huntsman who tries to cheat his way to the head ranger's job and daughter with magic bullets. 
 Schneider-Siemssen's blasted post-Thirty Years War landscape catches well the insecure mood of the opera, conceived in the aftermath of the Napoleonic wars. 
 But the projections for the Wolf's Glen scene are feeble, compared with Achim Freyer's raw satire on German red-cheeked feather-hatted nationalism, in Stuttgart. 
 Friedrich's narrative simplicity disturbs few interpretational skeletons in the closet. 
 This is a wonderful score for Colin Davis's long-limbed, affectionate, supremely musical conducting. 
 A pity that the orchestra lacked polish and that the chorus (and even Gwynne Howell's Hermit) were inclined to rush ahead regardless. 
 Davis's way with the overture was beautifully supple, his gradual unfolding of the emotions of the work deeply moving. 
 Covent Garden field a strong cast, especially Rene Kollo's marvellous Max. 
 Dramatic interpretation in a revival of such an old staging is inevitably not fresh, but Kollo sings with supreme verve and flexibility for such resonant heldentenor. 
 Perhaps it's his ideal part, though at times too low. 
 Top notes present thrillingly, and Kollo's technique is in mint condition after nearly 25 years. 
 Wonderful to hear. 
 Hartmut Welker's dark, neat and precisely turned Caspar is less obsessive than WNO's remarkable Richard Paul Fink was, but makes a rather depressed servant of the dark. 
 Karita Mattila started on the flat side, but eventually developed the right glow and intensity. 
 Her cavatina had gorgeously relaxed sweeping lines. 
 Judith Howarth's Annchen was chirpily sung, if overplayed. 
 Wigmore Hall. 
 Gerard McChrystal. 
 By Edward Greenfield 
 WE OWE it above all to the example of John Harle, himself still young, that the saxophone is fast shedding its jazz/pop image. 
 Here as one of the latest winners of the Ivan Sutton Recording Prize was a former pupil of Harle, the Irishman, Gerard McChrystal, a performer of such striking personality that, given the right backing, he might become the James Galway of the saxophone, though not every musician would want to. 
 It was daring of McChrystal to start with Bach on the saxophone, even if this sonata &mdash; normally for violin or flute &mdash; is of very doubtful authenticity. 
 What emerged was quite a revelation. 
 He drew from the high soprano instrument sounds totally different from what we think of as saxophone tone, remarkably pure and wide-ranging in timbre and dynamic. 
 His natural musical imagination silenced any lingering doubts, and when it came to music expressly written for the instrument &mdash; a brilliant showpiece sonata by the American, Paul Creston; a new work commissioned from the young Irishman, Kevin O'Connell; and Dave Heath's vigorous fantasy, Rumania &mdash; McChrystal could not have been more persuasive, brilliantly supported by his accompanist, Kathryn Lenahan. 
 McChrystal was one of the two young musicians, just leaving music college in 1988, whom I and two other judges chose earlier this year as the latest Sutton Recording Prizewinners on the basis of tape recordings they had made. 
 The other outstanding candidate on tape was the violinist, Simon Smith, and he too emerged just as impressively in live performance. 
 Accompanied by Sophia Rahman, he made a most imaginative choice of programme &mdash; the surprisingly neglected Schumann A minor Sonata, Dallapiccola's Two Studies and, best of all, Szymanowski's Nocturne and Tarantella. 
 Smith's technical mastery blossomed in the hushed mystery of the Nocturne but above all in the fireworks of the Tarantella. 
 Hammersmith. 
 By Adam Sweeting Marillion. 
 THE departure of their vocalist Fish might have caused Marillion something of a mid-life crisis. 
 Fish used to lumber and shamble around the stage like a confused and wounded animal, bellowing out his lyrics as if only this could ease his pain. 
 He also liked the occasional drink, for much the same reasons. 
 He was the band's figurehead, but the head grew too heavy for the body to bear. 
 In his place, the band have hired Steve Hogarth, a frail-looking fellow with lank black hair who addresses the audience with vaguely timorous deference. 
 He refers back to the Fish era as if in awe, and introduces the other Marillionauts with grovelling reverence. 
 They're only a bunch of old musos, for God's sake. 
 But any doubts about Marillion's future were clearly ill-founded. 
 While Hogarth is much less of a presence than his aqueous predecessor, his arrival has caused Marillion to bind closer together as a unit. 
 Remember Genesis. 
 Once Peter Gabriel quit, they got really big. 
 Marillion are now looking like the full-scale international merchants of pomp they've always aimed at being. 
 They release albums in lavish Seventies-style gatefold sleeves. 
 The songs are carefully arranged, played with the anonymous perfection we've come to expect from people like the Floyd, and last about a quarter of an hour. 
 And for all that, there's something endearing about them. 
 Sludgeful though they may be in pieces like The Space&hellip; (complete with pseudo-planetarium backdrop), and while Warm Wet Circles keeps receding and then returning like some particularly tiresome romantic symphony, Marillion sometimes achieve genuine vastness. 
 The heavy, overripe Season's End soars plaintively off into the distance, and Holloway Girl has a sort of oceans-and-mountains quality you won't find in, say, the music of Debbie Gibson. 
 They don't fare quite so well in their efforts to &bquo;rock out&equo;. 
 Incommunicado, which Hogarth saw fit to sing from the top of a heap of loudspeakers, blustered along with lots of fists punching the air, but was basically turgid. 
 But this was what the fans had come to hear, from the downy-cheeked chaps in jeans with their shirts hanging out, to the heavy metal chicks and rock'n'roll babes in their sleeveless leather jackets, chains and biker boots. 
 White pants black looks Outloud. 
 By us75Lucy Steggle 
 IWAS seven in 1980 and the main excitement was the arrival of a baby brother. 
 In 1981 I was an avid spectator of Charles and Di's wedding. 
 Other international news holds more relevance now. 
 But adolescence, apart from the inevitable emotional roller-coasters, has been fun. 
 From Madonna, stick-on earrings and sobbing over the phone about best friends, to Suzanne Vega, CFC-free hairspray and sobbing over the &bquo;phone about boyfriends&hellip; 
 How far have we really come? 
 Margaret Thatcher seems to have been Prime Minister all my life, and the Falklands War is just a vague and fearful memory of someone else's brother going off to fight. 
 The problems of Russia suddenly became topical two years ago at school, and although I'd grown up with a faint mistrust of &bquo;Commies&equo;, in 1988 I started writing to Murat, a young Russian. 
 In 1985 everyone was into the youthful exuberance of Wham! and white trousers and bleached fringes. 
 At the end of the decade it seems we're either yearning for an American Fifties image or sinking into a nihilism of all-black clothes. 
 Is this significant? 
 With the spirit at mass events like Band Aid and Mandela Day, it would be easy to see the Eighties as a humane, caring decade. 
 But sometimes you can look at the Third World, animal slaughter, pollution and so on and just feel the depressing resignation that &bquo;young&equo; people are supposed to kick against the establishment. 
 My elder brother, one of the last O-level year, pretends to sneer at my GCSE passes, but I'm glad we didn't have to go through all the cramming and regurgitation of the old exams. 
 Well, it's nearly the Nineties, and frankly I'm disillusioned. 
 My little brother is quite revolting. 
 Thanks to the several hundred Young Guardian readers who wrote their accounts of Growing Up In the Eighties for the Outloud column. 
 As we go into the 1990s we'll run your articles about bullying. 
 If you have been bullied, witnessed bullying or been a bully yourself, write about it. 
 Send 400 words to Young Guardian, The Guardian, 119 Farringdon Road, London EC1R 3ER. 
 Where you can help the good guys to win every time *Input / Nigel Fountain. 
 IWENT to the theatre last week. 
 This is rare in itself. 
 I grew up on movies and have always believed that if cameras had been invented before Ur and Og first trod the stone age boards then no one would ever have bothered to invent plays, they would have just leapt straight into the cinema. 
 Films always seem more realistic to me. 
 This just shows what a Philistine I am. 
 But last week's production had everything. 
 Robbery, rebellion, cooking, football (in small doses), infants threatened with death, song and dance, Maid Marion and Robin Hood. 
 It was, of course, a pantomime, a very good one, Babes in the Wood at the Hackney Empire in east London. 
 You might ask (I'll ask for you) what the Babes in the Wood have to do with Robin Hood. 
 Well, they all wandered around forests, chased by villains, and won through in the end. 
 The programme suggested that maybe the Babes were based on the Princes in the Tower, allegedly murdered by Richard III. 
 But that is another story, and anyway poor old Richard was framed. 
 These Babes were being pursued by the Sheriff of Nottingham. 
 He got big, so the legend goes, while good King Richard I was off crusading, leaving King John (not a good man) and the villainous Sheriff to take care of business. 
 This story went over big with the seven and five-year olds in my party. 
 It went over big with me too. 
 I was booing and hissing the bad guys with the best of them, and I usually hate audience participation. 
 One of the production's virtues was that, although it had TV stars, it wasn't just a succession of tacky TV turns. 
 A friend once told me of a Northen Ireland tour back in the 1970s, by a group of bogus Wombles. 
 In those days Womblemania stalked these islands, and so a large audience had gathered to witness Uncle Bulgaria and Co as they strutted their stuff. 
 It soon rumbled the furry frauds' deceit. 
 &bquo;Shove off!&equo; they shouted. 
 &bquo;You aren't real Wombles! 
 Don't think you can fool us!&equo; 
 Amid the weeping of small children and the anger of adults the pseudo-Wombles fled, leaving only the sound of Remember You're a Womble echoing through the theatre. 
 No such scenes marred the Empire. 
 Like all good pantomimes it scrambled history and myth with some good topical jokes. 
 The Sheriff had a sideline flogging water shares, while Richard I was depicted as the England football manager off to play, as I recall, Saracens FC. 
 A neat bit of rewriting there; the real Richard was one of the leaders of the Second Crusade which laid waste to Palestine, before ending up with a score-draw against the Arabs whose land he was invading. 
 The Middle East often intrudes on old English stories. 
 Genies and lamps, Ali Baba and the 40 Thieves, and Sinbad the Sailor all come out of that civilisation and end up singing Neighbours down at theatres across the land. 
 That, to get gloomy, left me brooding on two other things. 
 The two small children I went with loved the show because it was, I suspect, magic. 
 I realised why I was wrong about good theatre, about how it can enthrall in a way cinema and television rarely does. 
 It was much deeper and bigger than most of what we pick up on screens, our primary source of entertainment today. 
 And the other point? 
 It is great to have pantomime villains, heroines, and heroes to boo and cheer. 
 Off the stage of the Hackney Empire they don't exist. 
 The Jerusalem that Richard tried to capture 700 years ago is proof of that. 
 It remains a holy city for Muslims, Christians and Jews, all of whom for the very best of reasons &mdash; they are the good guys &mdash; have slaughtered each other within its walls. 
 And they didn't get up and take a bow afterwards. 
 Lee Van Cleef. 
 A lucky talent for looking mean:. 
 THE screen persona of Lee Van Cleef suggested that if he met a rattler, the snake would come off worse. 
 From the mid-sixties, Van Cleef's face became instantly recognisable &mdash; pencil-thin moustache, prominent nose, slitted eyes and the head of a baldvulture descending to pick the scraps off a corpse in the badlands. 
 &bquo;I just look mean without even trying&equo; he once said. 
 He might also have considered himself a very lucky man, as an actor of limited range who made his screen debut in the classic High Noon (1952), playing the harmonica-playing member of the gang out to kill Gary Cooper. 
 His impact was such that it led to further villainy &mdash; as the probably gay hit man in the Big Combo (1955), as a rapist and murderer in Ride Lonesome (1959), as Lee Marvin's psychotic side-kick in The Man Who Shot Liberty Vallance (1962) as well as more conventional heavies in Gunfight at the OK Corral (1956), The Tin Star (1957) and How the West Was Won (1962). 
 He rarely survived to the final reel, because the notion of Van Cleef nobly agreeing to a duel in a deserted street was ridiculous. 
 He shot people in the back and expected nothing less for himself. 
 Following Liberty Vallance he suffered a heart attack which forced him out of movies and into a career as a composer and painter, in the way that many Hollywood tough guys conceal a private sensitivity. 
 Then came the call from Sergio Leone. 
 Leone had problems casting his spaghetti westerns: stars like Henry Fonda, James Coburn and Lee Marvin were too busy, too expensive or both. 
 Clint Eastwood was cheap and available. 
 &bquo;Then I remembered Van Cleef,&equo; said Leone. 
 &bquo;When I went to see him, he had been very ill for three years. 
 I saw him from some way away, and was struck by his seductive silhouette. 
 He was perfect for my character.&equo; 
 Van Cleef was cast opposite Eastwood in For A Few Dollars More (1965) and The Good, The Bad and The Ugly (1966) and immediately became a major star and a poster pin-up. 
 Oddly enough, it is not the silhouette one remembers from the Leone films but the extreme close ups, the sweat and the twitching mouth. 
 Van Cleef was wonderfully evil and perhaps not a little of Eastwood's taciturn appeal lay in the compelling menace of his adversary. 
 After the two pictures for Leone, Van Cleef stayed in Europe to make pale imitations of them and only returned to Hollywood in 1970 for El Condor which unwisely made him a sympathetic character. 
 In his final years he tried to revive his career in an American television series about martial arts called The Master (1986) but it failed and another series never got beyond the pilot stage. 
 But his finest hour in the Leone films is to be on television next week. 
 Adrian Turner Lee Van Cleef, born Somerville, New Jersey, January 9, 1925; died Oxnard, California, December 16, 1989. 
 Paul Collaer, the Belgian pianist, conductor and musicologist, died in Brussels on December 18, aged 98. 
 A friend and promoter of the music of Hindemith, Satie, Honegger, Alban Berg and Milhaud, he wrote well-received books on Milhaud and Stravinsky, and was for 15 years director of Belgian State Radio's music programmes. 
 He received the Unesco International Grand Prix for his work in musicology in 1985. 
 Collision culture The Other Story at the Hayward is told by many different voices. 
 The once common factor is the frustration of being a Black artist in Britain, argues Tim Hilton. 
 THE title of the exhibition of African, Asian and Caribbean art at the Hayward Gallery is The Other Story, as though it were an account of an alternative and continuous tradition, independent of Western European and American modern art. 
 There are many such traditions, of course, and in fact the Hayward show has little to do with any of them. 
 It's about collison of cultures in Britain since the end of the war, and it looks at the way that some artists of non-British origin have come to terms with modern art &mdash; or, rather, have made a personal art by calling on ways of expression that might have been absolutely native to them in other countries than this. 
 The result is a mixed and discontinuous exhibition, full of surprises, but also a record of frustration and disappointment. 
 It seems that scarcely one Black artist in Britain has had the benefits of an extended professional career: a dealer, regular exhibitions, interested critics, sales and the support of one's peers. 
 So the occasional gallery owner prepared to support a Black artist gets much credit in this show. 
 Curiously enough, there's even a hint of a good age for Black artists: in the 1950s, before the Notting Hill race riots of 1958 and before the era of public subsidies, when Denis Bowen of the New Vision Centre and Victor Musgrave of Gallery One consistently showed unknown international artists, many of whom had turned up in London in the post-coronation years because they had heard of the Commonwealth. 
 One of these was Francis Newton Souza, who arrived in Britain from India in 1949 and had some success, nationally and internationally, in the Fifties and early Sixties. 
 Souza's commitments were no doubt the more complicated because he had been raised as a Catholic, and had been taught that the eroticism of Hindu religious philosophy was wicked. 
 Much of Souza's work can be interpreted as a sort of attack on the mixed nature of his upbringing, as though a restless and pugnacious way with paint might overcome all circumstances and proclaim the painter alone. 
 This highly characteristic Fifties attitude makes Souza's work look as if it belongs to a time rather than a place. 
 His Mr Sebastian of 1955 and the interesting Red Road of 1962 might have been painted in France or Germany rather than London. 
 On the other hand his most impressive contribution, the Black Nude of 1961, has many design elements of English painting of the day, if treated with some passion. 
 Souza has lived in New York for the last 20 years. 
 A recent painting is The Game, which mingles the imagery of sport and political repression. 
 Social themes are not of major importance in the first part of the exhibition. 
 The Hayward's lower galleries are mainly devoted to personal contributions, to semi-abstract painting (and the absence of sculpture in this section suggests that it was easier to join international art by painting rather than sculpting). 
 Avinash Chandra's canvases reveal that, even while he was still in India, he felt the attraction of Soutine and Van Gogh. 
 Chandra came to England in 1955. 
 He made accomplished paintings for some years thereafter, but his recent work, like Souza's, disappoints. 
 Although one cannot believe that times were good for immigrant artists in the 1950s, a quantity of painting seems to belong to the period, though done a decade or more later. 
 This is so of Aubrey Williams, who came to Britain from Guyana in 1952; of Ahmed Parvez, a Pakistani who arrived in London in 1955, and of Iqbal Geoffrey, a highly uneven artist whose splashings and fuzzed calligraphy have genuine feeling for improvisation. 
 Geoffrey's conceptual work, on the other hand, appeals only to curiosity. 
 It tells us about his pride, humour, fixation with the Royal Family, longing for justice: but in pieces of this sort he loses touch with his gifts. 
 Here is a crucial point of the exhibition. 
 The overbearing sophistication of conceptualism and minimalism did not guarantee success in art for anyone. 
 The organiser of The Other Story, Rasheed Araeen, has made much study of the art criticism of the early Seventies and the post-modernist theories of the Eighties, and his work looks as though it has no knowledge of the world not gleaned from art magazines. 
 The minimal sculptures by Araeen and Avtarjeet Danjal have a dated, anonymous air. 
 To my surprise, the space devoted to the kinetic sculptures by David Medalla had a lively and progressive atmosphere. 
 The old Signals Gallery, largely Medalla's creation, was one of the last places where one found the undirected avant-guardism of post-war years. 
 By 1965 or so this had all gone, but Medalla himself has been too bouncy and inventive to obey the arid strictures of minimalism. 
 Rasheed Araeen writes a lot, very confidently, about modernism. 
 Strange, isn't it, or perhaps not so strange, that the word is so much used by theoreticians and so little used by artists themselves? 
 I would like to have read more on the subject by Frank Bowling, whose views seem not to be harmonised with Araeen's somewhat dogmatic viewpoint. 
 Bowling resembles a number of older artists in the exhibition in that he came to England (from Guyana, in his case) to be an artist, had some success, then moved to and fro between London and New York when his public career went downhill in the Sixties. 
 Could it be that there was then more racism in the art world, and that Black artists were being squeezed out at just the time when young working-class artists from the British provinces were finding unprecedented and immediate public fortune? 
 Hard to know. 
 In any case, the commercial record of Black artists in recent years is a minor and unimportant part of the general Black experience of British life. 
 I'm less interested in Araeen's assertions about modernism than in the following questions: what are the differences between the older artists who came here as immigrants and the young artists who were born in Britain? 
 Of the British-born Black artists, who went to art school, how did they get in and how did they get on? 
 Does it matter, in 1990, whether a Black artist goes to art school? 
 It looks to me as if-in accord with our country's culture generally-recent Black art is harsher, more hurt, more despairing. 
 The work of Eddie Chambers (born 1960, Wolverhampton) and Keith Piper (born 1960, Birmingham) comes in the form of angry collage, taking elements from, for instance, National Front posters. 
 Both went to art school: neither needed art school to learn how to do the work they have put up in the Hayward. 
 Sonia Boyce (born 1962, London) is a far more skilful artist: but her very accomplishment inclines her towards the illustrational and sentimental. 
 There are many worrying aspects of Araeen's exhibition. 
 One is summed up by Boyce's statement &bquo;I have a problem with my success&equo;. 
 Nearly all the artists at the Hayward have some standing within the &bquo;art establishment&equo; that Araeen says he has stormed. 
 I think the show would have been less timid if he had sought out more of the artists in their 20s who nowadays keep coming up in mixed exhibitions in Liverpool, Birmingham, Leeds, Whitechapel and so on. 
 But perhaps he could not have attracted them to The Other Story. 
 As we know, this latest generation of Black, British-born artists wants to exhibit alongside people of any colour. 
 At the Hayward Gallery until February 4. 
 A restless and pugnacious way with paint&hellip; 
 Francis Newton Souza's Girl With Goat (1949). 
 Obituary: Stella Gibbons. 
 Much for our comfort:. 
 IT'S rotten luck for a prolific writer of talent to be known for only one work, a masterpiece which overshadows any later writing. 
 Such was the fate of Stella Gibbons. 
 She wrote more than 30 novels and collections of verse. 
 A friend of mine who is a keen admirer has not read 25 of her books. 
 I would guess that most of her readers have not read 29. 
 But the one that they have read, Cold Comfort Farm, they have probably read to destruction. 
 The yellowing pages of the Penguin edition will be crumbling, the spine will have collapsed, the signatures will be disintegrating but what the hell? 
 But the old comfort farmer will hardly need the physical object any longer. 
 It's one of those rare books of comic genius that imprints itself on the brain and can never afterwards be eradicated. 
 What is Stella Gibbons's rating in the academic Eng. 
 Lit. world I do not know. 
 It ought to be high. 
 (Not least is Cold Comfort Farm to be treasured for the fact that an American literary critic took it straight, commenting that some of the characters were overdrawn.) 
 Her hilarious novel achieved at least four things. 
 On the level of popular literature it demolished Mary Webb and Precious Bane (Stanley Baldwin's favourite). 
 On the higher literary level it rubbished quite a bit of Hardy and much of D.H.Lawrence. 
 It introduced to the language the phrase about &bquo;something nasty in the woodshed&equo;. 
 And finally, it brought on that rich cast of wooden-topped rustics, the Starkadders, with Aunt Ada Doom in the star part, not to speak of the simpleton whose main pleasure in life was doing the washing up, or as he called it, clettering the dishes with his liddle mop. 
 Then there was Big Business the bull, and Our Graceless, a three-legged cow with a wooden leg. 
 Perhaps I take a special pleasure in Cold Comfort Farm from the fact that I was myself brought up in a rural setting, surrounded by wild-eyed manic depressives of the Starkadder school, while I was reading the works of D.H.Lawrence and F.R.Leavis, whose loam-laden versions of country life didn't quite chime with mine. 
 That of Stella Gibbons did. 
 She herself, incidentally, came from a family which was violent both emotionally (they lived on rows and scenes) and physically (her father threw knives). 
 Moreover, &bquo;They were all madly highly-sexed like the Starkadders&equo;, she told an interviewer earlier in the decade, &bquo;and I think a lot of the laughing at that kind of thing in Cold Comfort Farm comes from a &bquo;distaste&equo;&hellip; if you have it thrust on you from an early age, with divorces left, right and centre and people chasing each other round tables&hellip; well.&equo; 
 But gosh, that book is still funny. 
 One of her innovations was to put asterisks in the margins whenever a piece of particularly fine writing came up. 
 Style of Michelin or Baedeker guides. 
 She gives herself two stars for &bquo;The cries from the little hut had stopped. 
 An exhausted silence, brimmed with the enervating weakness which follows a stupendous effort, mounted from the stagnant air in the yard, like a miasma&hellip;&equo; 
 And so on. 
 I'd give it three stars, or (as Michelin says) vaut le detour. 
 Richard Boston Stella Gibbons, born January 5, 1902; died December 19, 1989. 
 Dimples before bedtime. 
 By Robin Thornber in Manchester 
 THERE was a time when the television variety spectacular threatened to take over popular entertainment completely, so that pantomime and seaside summer shows would be indistinguishable, all one poor man's Palladium. 
 But the tide must have turned when even a big commercial panto like this at the Manchester Palace &mdash; one of 21 that Paul Elliott is producing this year &mdash; rediscovers its roots in traditional storytelling. 
 Tudor Davies's script has the style of an authentically naff pre-1914 original, up-dated by a sharper intelligence. 
 For once it doesn't treat the audience as idiots. 
 This Aladdin goes right back to the 1,001 Nights, showing us Scheherezade (Eartha Kitt) being turned into the Genie of the Ring and the Caliph of Baghdad (Sylvester McCoy) into the Slave of the Lamp by the Grand Vizier Abanazer (Peter Blake as a deliciously over-the-top wicked uncle). 
 Miss Kitt makes even her gauche opening line &mdash; &bquo;The amount of stars are infinitesimal&hellip;&equo; &mdash; sound sensible and exotically sexy; from there on she slinks effortlessly through the role, prowling like a panther caged in a pet shop. 
 Paul Nicholas dimples charmingly as Aladdin, which gets the girls screaming; Paul Shane holiday-camps around as Widow Twankey; and the Simmons brothers' double act as the Chinese Policemen is actually quite funny. 
 Their sword cabinet routine can't have come from MFI &bquo;because there aren't any bits left over&equo;. 
 The special effects work, the special appearance of that awful kitsch cat, Garfield, is written in, and the choreography by director Carole Todd is slick. 
 It doesn't drag on beyond bedtime but you feel you had your money's worth. 
 Manchester Palace (061 236 9922) until February 25. 
 Another disturbing chapter in the history of the DTI Notebook. 
 By Alex Brummer 
 THERE will be those who portray the report of the Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration on the Barlow Clowes Affair as a triumph for the British system of financial regulation. 
 Yes, of course, they will say, there is clear evidence that the Department of Trade and Industry fouled up badly &mdash; maladministration as the Ombudsman likes to call it. 
 But what is really important, it will be argued, is that the system triumphed. 
 As a result of the Ombudsman's vigorous and admirably speedy deliberations, the hapless 18,000 investors who put their faith in the DTI imprimatur will be fully compensated and the integrity of the UK's investment apparatus has been preserved. 
 Moreover, if there was maladministration it is of little consequence now in that the new regime established by the Financial Services Act of 1986 has rendered the DTI's role in this matter redundant. 
 Such muddled thinking partly explains the complacency of the Corporate and Consumer Affairs Minister, Mr John Redwood, who accepted the findings &bquo;without prejudice.&equo; 
 This cool response almost certainly reflects legal caution, but also a bland faith in the regulatory system. 
 Even before the report went to the printers, the Ombudsman, Sir Anthony Barrawclough, was told by the DTI's most senior officer that it intended to give its own view, in a separate document, on the responsibilities of regulators. 
 This is the kind of self-righteous behaviour at which Mrs Thatcher's Government excels. 
 The DTI's record in regulatory matters is not an honourable one. 
 Few drivers who bought car insurance policies from Dr Emil Savundra's Fire Auto &amp; Marine in the mid-1960s will forget the culpability of then Board of Trade. 
 Nor will those investors and depositors who in the mid-1970s found themselves caught in a hurricane sweeping throught the secondary banking system after the collapse of Gerald Caplan's London and County Securities. 
 Suffice it to say that the DTI was the supervising authority for such fringe banks. 
 More recently its inconsistent behaviour over the publication of DTI reports into important City scandals has also raised questions of judgment, undue political influence and its due care to the public interest. 
 Tiny Rowland may have become a bore with his obsession over DTI's failure to publish the report on the House of Fraser &mdash; but on this occasion he is on the side of the Gods. 
 There can be no sense in the DTI's refusal to publish the House of Fraser report on the grounds that it might prejudice a Serious Fraud Office inquiry when it took the opposite course over Blue Arrow. 
 And while one is busy throwing the rotten eggs, who can forget the duplicity of the DTI over the disposal of Rover to British Aerospace. 
 It would be nice to write that despite these lapses of judgment, not to mention the occasional maladministration, investors and other stakeholders in business do not have to worry because of the safety superstructure which has been built since. 
 But there is little in the current regulatory structure which is designed to inspire the confidence of investors. 
 Indeed, even if supervision of Barlow Clowes had passed seamlessly from the DTI to the Financial Intermediaries, Managers and Brokers Regulatory Association (FIMBRA) there can be no guarantee the warning signs at Barlow Clowes, from intermingled funds to accounting inconsistencies, would have been unearthed. 
 With its unwieldly band of almost 8,200 members FIMBRA is an organisation in serious distress. 
 It is engaged in internecine warfare over the general provision of indemnity insurance for investors. 
 But this dispute, which has seen FIMBRA's Lord Elton off the field, is evidence of systemic problem. 
 The organisation, concerned with financial probity, is continuously in debt because its members refuse to pay the bill for self-regulation. 
 Moreover, its attempts to weed out the next Barlow Clowes are not considered impressive. 
 When suspending members for alleged wrongdoing it tends to act in the dark of night, refusing generally to explain its actions. 
 FIMBRA's incontinence is evidence of a system of self-regulation under stress. 
 With the populous FIMBRA offshoot of the Securities &amp; Investment Board (SIB) bucking against the post-Financial Services Act regime, the whole concept of self-regulatory organisations is brought into question. 
 The Stock Exchange, for instance, has been remarkably successful in doing its own policing &mdash; witness the quick action taken in the case of the alleged share ramp at Williams Holdings. 
 But in contrast, the DTI has not been notably successful in bringing prosecutions against insiders based on the dossiers provided &mdash; as the Geoffrey Collier case demonstrates. 
 Even the SIB itself appears to be having self-doubts about the unwieldly monster it has created, particularly at a time when the City's self-regulation will have to be grafted on a more legalistic European Community framework. 
 The most interesting observations by the Ombudsman in the Barlow Clowes report concern the DTI's vision of regulation. 
 It points out that the licensing functions were lowly regarded and observes that protection of investors by definition requires a &bquo;rigorous and inquiring approach&equo;. 
 Such comments about the DTI's effectiveness as a corporate policeman could have been made almost at any time over the last 30 years and in a multitude of cases. 
 Similarly, successive attempts by the City to regulate itself have, as in the case of FIMBRA, ended in disappointment. 
 It is easy to forget, for instance, that the Bank of England is still nursing along the remains of that 1970s darling, Slater-Walker. 
 Financial shenanigans clearly will not be eliminated by new, even tougher legislation to protect investors. 
 There is more than enough statutory law around. 
 What is needed are effective regulators and that is the common thread which runs from John Bloom and Bernie Cornfeld to Peter Clowes and Guinness. 
 Investors deserve a stronger, simpler and more tenacious system of enforcement than self-regulation can provide. 
 It is up to government to finance and provide it &mdash; but as far from the DTI as possible. 
 Bond tells shareholders his empire will survive. 
 By Jan Mayman in Perth and City staff 
 AUSTRALIAN entrepreneur Alan Bond yesterday appealed for the support of his shareholders, saying his debt-burdened brewing, property and media group would survive. 
 &bquo;We have a mountain to move. 
 We can move it together,&equo; he told the annual meeting of his flagship Bond Corporation. 
 He was sensitive about questions of telephone tapping. 
 Australia is in uproar over allegations that one of his former executives organised the bugging of Robert Holmes a Court and leading Australian financial journalist, Terry McCrann. 
 Yesterday the Perth Daily News also claimed that the former executive who organised the alleged tapping approached the CIA in an attempt to discredit Lonrho, one of Mr Bond's most vociferous critics. 
 Mr Bond told the meeting: &bquo;I'm not going to discuss that sort of allegation &mdash; it's rubbish.&equo; 
 In the face of the group's &pound;4billion debts, he said: &bquo;We believe this company can be turned around again and prosper.&equo; 
 The company's share price has fallen from A&dollar;1.87 in January to 14 cents on Tuesday. 
 Asked after the meeting if the current year could be worse, he said: &bquo;I can't imagine a worse one.&equo; 
 Mr Bond said the company had sold its half-share in its headquarters, the RandI Bank Tower, for &pound;54million. 
 The company hoped for early completion of a stalled &pound;1.25billion sale of Australian brewing assets to New Zealand brewer Lion Nathan. 
 The only tough questions at the meeting came from three Dutch investment advisers who were representing family trusts with about &pound;25million of Bond group convertible bonds. 
 The rich-poor gap widens. 
 The 1980s have been a decade of poverty for the poorly paid, with almost two out of every five full-time workers in Britain &mdash; nearly six million in all &mdash; now earning wages below the decency threshold set by the Council of Europe, the Low Pay unit says (writes Larry Elliott). 
 Its look at the 1980s shows a widening gap between rich and poor, with the low paid relatively worse off than when figures were first collected in 1886. 
 Including part-time workers, the LPU said almost 10million people were low paid and pay rises of 25.8 per cent would be needed to restore them to their relative position in 1979. 
 The Council of Europe defines the low paid as someone earning less than &pound;163 a week in 1989. 
 Digest goes public. 
 Readers Digest is to go public in February, offering 21 per cent of its shares to investors worldwide. 
 The monthly magazine, founded in a garage by an American husband and wife, has a readership of 100million but will offer only four million shares outside the US. 
 RD's UK circulation is 1.5 million. 
 The flotation has been triggered by a group of US charities who were given shares by the magazine's founders and now want to cash in their holdings. 
 Banks' pact. 
 Standard Chartered and Westdeutsche Landesbank Girozentrale yesterday signed a co-operation agreement to expand jointly in Europe. 
 Carron in talks. 
 Carron Phoenix, the Scottish sink manufacturer, is involved in talks which may produce a bid above the agreed 60p-a-share offer from Bene of France. 
 Bid rejected. 
 Sea Containers last night rejected the higher, hostile takeover bid from Anglo-Swedish rival Temple Holdings in favour of its own restructuring plan which involves it selling more than &dollar;1billion of assets. 
 Stake raises &pound;116m. 
 John Gunn's debt-ridden financial services group, British &amp;Commonwealth, has raised &pound;116million from the sale of its stake in the Irish office equipment to merchant banking group Woodchester. 
 Credit Lyonnaise, the French bank, has bought B&amp;C's remaining 29.85 per cent stake. 
 EMAP turns radio dial. 
 EMAP, the publishing group, has increased its investment in local radio with the &pound;1.41million purchase of Crown Communications' shareholdings in Radio Broadland and Suffolk Group Radio. 
 Appeal fails. 
 Abdul Shamji, chairman of the Gomba Group of Companies, yesterday lost his appeal against a 15-month jail sentence for giving perjured evidence about his personal fortune. 
 Shamji, who was also ordered to pay &pound;28,960 costs, had asked the Appeal Court to reduce the sentence imposed on him at the Old Bailey on October 30. 
 Manx Chancellor goes. 
 The Isle of Man's Chancellor of the Exchequer, Mr David Cannan, was dismissed yesterday in the Manx government's first ever Cabinet reshuffle. 
 Mr Cannan blamed personality clashes. 
 Column held over. 
 Christopher Huhne's economics column has been held over until tomorrow. 
 Squeeze hits Greenall. 
 Warrington-based Greenall Whitley yesterday became the latest brewer to complain that the squeeze on spending is starting to hit beer sales. 
 The volume of beer sold through Greenall's pubs over the last couple of months has shown a fall on 1988 levels, said the group financial director, Mr Michael Davis, as he unveiled profits up 10.5 per cent to &pound;52million for the year to September. 
 But there is no sign of a slowdown in bookings at Greenall's De Vere hotels chain. 
 There are now 25 De Vere hotels, after deals to buy the University Arms in Cambridge and the Grand in St Helier, Jersey. 
 The acquisitions &mdash; and the cost of converting scores of Greenall pubs into Premier House outlets providing food and with budget accommodation &mdash; pushed up the company's interest charge by 40 per cent to nearly &pound;20million in the year. 
 Two thirds of Greenall's profits growth came from higher gains from selling pubs. 
 But the company insists that property profits will probably continue to rise as it buys and sells assets to reshape its business. 
 Around 50 pubs are currently on the market. 
 A revaluation of the brewer's 1,600 pubs showed that they are now worth &pound;255million more than their book value. 
 Fletcher wraps up UK paper. 
 New Zealand pulp and paper makers Fletcher Challenge is well on the way to taking over UK Paper after its surprise 375p a share bid. 
 By late yesterday afternoon Fletcher had bought about 42 per cent of UK Paper, including the 4.5 per cent stake of former bidders Metsa-Serla. 
 Fletcher, one of New Zealand's biggest companies, said that everything was going to plan and that the UK Paper management team, including chairman Tom Wilding, will be staying on to run the company. 
 The bid values UK Paper at &pound;299million. 
 Beaming Yorkshire. 
 Yorkshire Television, the independent broadcaster and programme maker, brightened shareholders' screens yesterday with a full year's pre-tax profits up from &pound;15.64million to &pound;18million and a dividend payout of 11.3p for the year as against 9.6p last time. 
 Income from the TV Times jumped from &pound;1.4million to &pound;2.1million with interest receivable more than doubling to &pound;3.2million. 
 But the Exchequer Levy increased by &pound;2million to &pound;8.9million. 
 In short. 
 HARMONY Leisure, the pubs and hotels group where former GrandMet chairman Sir Stanley Grinstead is to join the board, has bounced back into the black. 
 Pre-tax profits for the six months to October 1 came in at &pound;134,000 as against a full year's loss of &pound;128,000 and a previous half time profit of &pound;258,000. 
 MEDIRACE is raising &pound;81.8million through a rights issue to cover most of the cost of the Evans Healthcare acquisition, which will propel it into a much bigger league. 
 Hong Kong: Shares lost ground in quiet trading. 
 Hang Seng Index: 2,879.42 (2900.21). 
 Tokyo: Stocks closed easier. 
 Nikkei Index: 38,439.10 (38,586.18). 
 Frankurt: Shares higher in lively trading. 
 FAZ index: 688.47 (686.12). 
 Paris: Stocks closed lower on continued interest-rate worries. 
 CAC index: 538.7 (541.6). 
 Diary of a financial fiasco 1973: Barlow Clowes &amp; Partners formed by Peter Clowes and Elizabeth Barlow to deal in gilts. 
 1978: Mrs Barlow retires. 
 1984: DTI shows interest in Barlow Clowes and its &bquo;bond-washing&equo; activities. 
 DTI believes it is operating without a licence under the Prevention of Fraud (Investments) Act 1958. 
 November: Initial application for a licence submitted by the partnership. 
 December: DTI gets agreement to examine its books. 
 1985: February: Barlow Clowes incorporated and begins trading five months later. 
 March: Budget outlaws the &bquo;bond-washing&equo; scheme. 
 April: DTI writes to Barlow Clowes' solicitors expressing &bquo;concern&equo; about its business: Trade Secretary, Norman Tebbit, says he is &bquo;mindful to serve notice of his intention to refuse a licence&equo;. 
 May: Full and formal application for a licence by Barlow Clowes. 
 October: After &bquo;prolonged negotiations&equo; DTI grants the licence. 
 1986: October: Licence renewed. 
 December: Barlow Clowes misses DTI deadline for submission of monitoring returns. 
 Deadline extended until February, which is met, but DTI queries the return. 
 1987: March: James Ferguson Holdings agrees to buy Barlow Clowes for &pound;10million. 
 November 13: DTI appoints inspectors to investigate Barlow Clowes Gilt Managers. 
 1988: May 7: Peter Clowes resigns from the board of James Ferguson, parent of BCGM and Gibraltar-based Barlow Clowes International. 
 May 23: Securities and Investments Board orders BCGM to cease trading. 
 May 27: Official Receiver appointed provisional liquidator; special managers Cork Gully move in. 
 June 7: Ernst &amp; Whinney appointed as provisional liquidators of BCI. 
 June 13: Trade Secretary Lord Young announces inquiry in DTI's handling of Barlow Clowes. 
 June 14: Shortfall revealed of up to &pound;100million of investors' funds. 
 June 15: Peter Clowes arrested. 
 July: Investors group and legal steering committee formed. 
 October 20: Sir Godfray Le Quesne's inquiry is judged by Lord Young to have found no grounds for concluding that the Government's actions caused the losses. 
 November 8: The Parliamentary Ombudsman announces investigation of alleged maladministration into the DTI's involvement. 
 December 8: Peter Clowes and three associatesappear on theft charges arising from the affair. 
 1989: June: Liquidators sue Peter Clowes for the return of &pound;84million alleged to be owed to 18,000 investors. 
 July: Lord Young is replaced by Nicholas Ridley. 
 October 25: Gibraltar lawyer James Levy appears in court on charges of conspiracy involving the use of false accounting departments. 
 November 1: Investment and Pensions Advisory Service &mdash; which received secret payments from Barlow Clowes having channelled &pound;65million of investors' money into the business &mdash; wound up by the High Court. 
 Shares jump as financial discussions get underway Saga family in bid to go private. 
 By Mark Milner 
 SAGA, the tour operator for the over sixties, may soon follow in the footsteps of the likes of International Leisure Group and Richard Branson's Virgin Group by going private. 
 The De Haan family, which owns 63 per cent of the travel to financial services company, said it was considering an offer to buy the remainder of the shares at about &pound;3 each. 
 At that price the whole company, which came to the stock market 11 years ago, would be valued at just over &pound;54million. 
 Saga shares jumped 66p to 293p after news of the approach. 
 A bid would be subject to the family raising the &pound;20million needed to finance the purchase of the shares it does not already own, but Mr Roger De Haan, who is leading the bid approach, said discussions were already under way with a bank and he was confident the money would be available. 
 Mr De Haan, who is also chairman of Saga, said the group could not enjoy one of the most important advantages of being publicly quoted &mdash; using its shares to fund acquisitions &mdash; because the family was determined not to dilute its controlling interest. 
 The company was founded by Mr De Haan's father and two of his brothers also work for the group. 
 &bquo;We built it up, it is our baby,&equo; he said, adding that if the family allowed its interest to fall below 50 per cent it would risk being taken over by a hostile bidder. 
 &bquo;We just don't want to be in that position.&equo; 
 As a result &bquo;we have not been able to take advantage of what the City has to offer.&equo; 
 On the other hand, however, Mr De Haan said the company had to put up with what it regarded as disadvantages of being publicly quoted. 
 There were occasions, for example, when the board felt a conflict between the need to distribute profits to meet the short term aspirations of the City and making medium and longer term investments in the business. 
 &bquo;We think it would be better as a private company, without that pressure&equo;, said Mr De Haan, though he said the move did not reflect any disenchantment with the City. 
 Mr De Haan said the original reason for going public was his father's concern that as a private company, with no market in its shares, the family might one day be faced with the prospect of having to sell the entire business to meet death duties. 
 The group got underway as a holiday company when Mr De Haan senior, who owned a Folkstone hotel, began arranging holidays for pensioners in the &bquo;off season&equo;. 
 Since then it has widened its scope considerably, with packages ranging from the traditional fortnight at an English seaside resort to treks through the Himalayas and month-long tours in South America. 
 It is believed to sell about 250,000 holidays a year. 
 In recent years it has added to the services it provides for the retired to include financial services, retirement homes and magazine publishing. 
 In the six months to the end of July the group made a profit of &pound;1.18million &mdash; 4.4 per cent down on the same period last year. 
 Saga has about 1,500 shareholders, with institutions accounts for around half the shares not held by the family and the remainder held by private investors. 
 Mr De Haan said a &pound;3 a share offer would represent a 25 per cent compound annual growth for investors who had bought shares when the company first came to the stock market. 
 &bquo;We believe it is a fair and generous price.&equo; 
 The three independent directors on the Saga board said last night that they had noted the possible offer, adding that discussions &bquo;are at an early stage&equo; and a further announcement would be made &bquo;as soon as practicable&equo;. 
 In the meantime shareholders were advised not to take any action. 
 An end to 19 months of torment. 
 By Daniel John 
 DELIGHT, elation and relief greeted the news of the government's decision to compensate investors for the bulk of the losses they had suffered in the collapse of Barlow Clowes. 
 For George Tyson and his wife, Rosie, it meant the release from a tormenting 19 months which saw their &pound;15,000 savings put at risk. 
 &bquo;I had given it up as lost,&equo; said Mr Tyson, who lives in South Ruislip, Middlesex. 
 &bquo;We have lost money but at least we have got the bulk of it back. 
 At the same time, I'm elated and I can go back to the vices I did have,&equo; said Mr Tyson. 
 The 68-year-old former Clerk of Works at Harrow Council in London does not smoke, drink or gamble and has suffered two heart attacks. 
 &bquo;I can go back to trout fishing with impunity.&equo; 
 The Tysons should receive about &pound;13,000 from the government, which will now be invested in a building society for him and his wife and their grandchildren. 
 For Betty and Trevor Lee of Stevenage, Hertfordshire, yesterday's decision should see them recoup just over &pound;10,000 out of the &pound;12,000 investment in Barlow Clowes International. 
 Before the government's retreat, their hopes were low. 
 &bquo;My husband said that if we got 50 per cent back it would be something but this is very good news,&equo; said Mrs Lee. 
 And there was praise for the Barlow Clowes Investors Group, which, with Manchester solicitors Alexander Tatham, were at the forefront of the battle for compensation. 
 &bquo;I don't think they could have done any more than they did. 
 They all worked very hard.&equo; 
 Retired teacher Mary Simmonds of Blackwood, Gwent, greeted the news with &bquo;much relief. 
 I'm pleased but it's not compensation for all of the trauma we have suffered or the money we have lost if we had invested it elsewhere. 
 But we should be grateful for small mercies.&equo; 
 She had &pound;8,000 in the Gibraltar fund, a substantial slice of which was providing her with a monthly income. 
 &bquo;I've had to be very, very careful and say &bquo;you can't afford it&equo;.&equo; 
 As for the future, she said she wouldn't speculate again but quickly corrected herself. 
 &bquo;I didn't think I was speculating&equo; she said in a rebuke to the Government's attitude towards the advertised high-return, low-risk investment offered by Barlow Clowes. 
 It was the same and supposedly &bquo;safe&equo; haven which attracted former TV director Ray Elton from Belsize Park, London, to put &pound;96,000 into BCI. 
 Along with 252 other investors, he is included in the &pound;50,000-to-&pound;100,000 category who the DTI says will get 80 per cent of their money back. 
 But while pleased, Mr Elton was scathing about Trade Secretary Nicholas Ridley's response to the Ombudsman's report to which the Government refused to accept responsibility for the affair. 
 &bquo;It is an enormous relief but I think they have been very clever.&equo; 
 The fixing of the amounts of compensation made it very difficult for the investors to refuse and it was aimed at defending the DTI from outright criticism as well as preventing public uproar, he said. 
 &bquo;It is enough to prevent us taking them the court.&equo; 
 As for the investors' representatives, businessman John Dyer and his committee at BCIG and Antony Gold and David Pine at Alexander Tatham yesterday represented almost the end of a daily nightmare. 
 Having lived with it for 19 months, John Dyer, an unlikely champion of investors' rights and one of the few &bquo;fortunates&equo; not hit hard by the collapse, was fulsome in his praise for BCIG's supporters. 
 &bquo;They have made the best of a bad situation.&equo; 
 Antony Gold described the compensation proposals as excellent, particularly for BCI investors &bquo;who could have been left out in the cold&equo;. 
 Satisfaction was also expressed by Michael Jordan at Cork Gully and Nigel Hamilton at Ernst &amp; Young, the joint liquidators of the two funds, who have so far recovered &pound;60 million of the &pound;190 million but knew from the beginning that anything like the Government pay-out for BCI was impossible. 
 And last night, Ian Burton, the solicitor representing Peter Clowes, the former head of the collapsed investment business, summed up his client's feelings. 
 &bquo;He has all along been very concerned, irrespective of what people have said about him, about the plight of the investors. 
 He only hopes compensation will be sorted out as soon as possible.&equo; 
 The day thrift turned into a nightmare. 
 By Daniel John 
 GEORGE Tyson is not a gambling man nor does he take unnecessary risks. 
 He doesn't smoke or drink, and even if he wanted to, two heart attacks and a by-pass operation have made the decision for him. 
 By his own account, Mr Tyson is thrifty and states quite proudly that neither he or his wife Rosie are a burden on any form of social or government support. 
 But that is why, at the age of 68, Mr Tyson is not enjoying what he had hoped would be a comfortable retirement. 
 A life of saving had, by 1985, given them a small nest-egg of &pound;15,000 on which the interest would help supplement their pensions. 
 To the Tysons, that meant nothing extravagant &mdash; just an extra &pound;135 a month to make life at home in South Ruislip, Middlesex easier. 
 That money was invested as might be expected of the Tysons. 
 And for three years, it earned its return, every month. 
 Until one morning in June 1988 when George Tyson turned on the radio to hear a small, investment business called Barlow Clowes had collapsed. 
 &bquo;It was about 8.30am and I was just getting dressed when it came over on the news,&equo; said Mr Tyson, a former clerk of works at Harrow council, London. 
 Investors in Barlow Clowes since 1985, the Tysons had orginally put &pound;10,000 into the UK fund and &pound;5,000 in Gibraltar-based Barlow Clowes International (BCI). 
 Fate determined that a short while before the businesses failed, they transferred the &pound;10,000 to BCI because of the better returns being offered. 
 In the days that followed, the Tysons found that they and 18,000 other investors had been the victims of a financial crash of global proportions. 
 Of the &pound;190million invested in both funds, BCI investors faced a shortfall of up to &pound;100million. 
 After the initial shock and disbelief, the Tysons grew angry &mdash; at the advisers who convinced them about Barlow Clowes, at the Midland bank manager who gave verbal assurances of its security, at the regulatory authorities responsible for the investment community and at the Department of Trade and Industry which allowed the company to trade. 
 &bquo;I felt it was so safe, they were so professional,&equo; said Mr Tyson. 
 &bquo;I feel appalled by the way these professional guardians have treated us. 
 If you were a gambling man it would not affect you, it would just be lost. 
 But this was not a gamble.&equo; 
 Like so many investors, Mr Tyson found himself having to go back to work to ease the financial strain he had hoped to avoid. 
 Ironically, it was the Government which he partly blamed for the affair that gave him the chance to return to work after retirement. 
 A change in the tax rules affecting pensions was shortly followed by a job with the Department of Environment's Property Services Agency, a post which carries him through to March and may see him stay until he is 70. 
 Putting it as politely as he can, Mr Tyson said the whole affair &bquo;encouraged&equo; him to return to paid employment. 
 &bquo;I hadn't planned to work at all.&equo; 
 And like all of the other investors, he and his wife were in a quandry. 
 They wanted to do something but felt powerless. 
 Pursuing legal action would have cost them money they didn't have (unless it meant selling their house which was not an option) but doing nothing left them with the feeling that justice wasn't being done. 
 So they compromised and gave &pound;100 to the Barlow Clowes Investors Group which was formed last July to represent the investors' interests and co-ordinate the fight for compensation. 
 That, says Mr Tyson, has been their only blessing. 
 &bquo;They are dedicated people who clearly know what they are talking about and have guided us through it. 
 Those people are victims, too, but they have certainly kept us together.&equo; 
 That aside, the last year has brought little respite from their own, very personal, crisis. 
 The Tysons have yet to see any cash payment from the liquidators who have been winding up BCI's affairs. 
 What little money has been recovered remains the subject of a legal tussle in the courts which may yet take months to resolve. 
 They have been told that their claim may only amount to around &pound;11,000 of their &pound;15,000 as capital gains tax is likely to be deducted from the total. 
 But until they get any money back, the Tysons find themselves in the position of the gambler who gambled all and lost. 
 Except that the Tysons don't gamble. 
 Monotype: Maxwell may bid. 
 SHAREHOLDERS in Monotype, the typesetting and graphic arts equipment maker, should soon be put out of their misery as Robert Maxwell looks ready to make a bid (writes James Morrow). 
 Monotype said yesterday it had received an approach &bquo;which may or may not lead to an offer&equo; from Mirror Group Newspapers. 
 There would be meeting this morning. 
 Monotype has already agreed to a 150p-a-share offer made by the US-based Pointplus. 
 Monotype shares closed 3p up at 158p. 
 Privatisation that got away shows how to share the corporate bounty Outlook. 
 By Roger Cowe 
 NFC stands as a monument to the irrelevance of both nationalisation and denationalisation; and as a monument to the vision of Sir Peter Thompson and his colleagues whose commitment to employee involvement has made the transport group, which was floated in February, the one privatisation that got away. 
 But only a hiatus at National Carriers caused by the closure of British Rail's door-to-door parcels service in 1980 stopped NFC going the way of other privatisations &mdash; into the pockets of disinterested individuals and institutions. 
 The resulting delay allowed Sir Peter to develop and lead the employee buy-out of the Pickfords and BRS group. 
 As a company with a heart and a determination to maintain employee control it is clearly a rogue among the 1980s herd of quick-buck, knock-down sales. 
 But it remains to be seen whether NFC is a throw-back to the 1970s or a model for the 1990s. 
 Whatever else it is, though, it has been successful in conventional business terms, although not as successful this year as the table suggests. 
 Reported profits soared by a third. 
 But the profits increase was helped by a suspension of pension fund contributions (shared with employees, unlike most companies) and other special effects. 
 Without those benefits the profits would have been lower than last year, although the core transport and distribution divisions did much better. 
 But the property profit is expected to continue growing. 
 Similarly the pensions holiday will continue for several years. 
 At any rate NFC (unique among public companies in giving a profits forecast) believes profits will grow by another 10 per cent in the current year. 
 That is good news in the light of worsening market conditions for the removals and holiday businesses. 
 The travel agency business has slumped into loss in the face of disappearing package holidays and market leader Lunn Poly's price-cutting tactics. 
 The worst is unlikely to be over yet. 
 NFC's caring approach makes it more reluctant than most companies to show employees the door. 
 But Sir Peter and his colleagues have also demonstrated their commitment to what the mission statement describes as &bquo;a participative and results-oriented management style&equo; (my italics). 
 Staff in the travel business have already been cut by 15 per cent. 
 And the crunch comes next month when the company has to face the possibility of closing down or selling off the whole business &mdash; although this will be a last resort and an acquisition or joint venture may be more likely. 
 Such hard decisions must be made easier by the better outlook elsewhere in the group. 
 Contract hire and the managed distribution business known as &bquo;logistics&equo; have both done well. 
 And the property development operation more than doubled profits. 
 That does not prove that Sir Peter's participative style is reponsible, but it does prove that it is not irresponsible &mdash; as many bosses would claim. 
 The style includes a consultation exercise on future strategy, culminating in endorsement (presumably) at the annual meeting. 
 Objectives include &bquo;seeking improved employment opportunities&equo;. 
 Sir Peter even suggested yesterday that business was not just about making profits. 
 &bquo;It is about how you share them and who does well out of them.&equo; 
 Many of Sir Peter's fellow company chairmen will scoff at such socialist sentiments. 
 But they might ponder whether such sentiments are more in line with the German and Japanese approaches that will probably dominate the 1990s rather than are their traditional capitalist values that have dominated the 1980s. 
 Strong words and clear rulings from a hard-hitting legal eagle. 
 By Daniel John 
 STRONG words and a tendency to make unambiguous rulings have epitomised Sir Anthony Barrowclough's five-year tenure in the office of Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration. 
 Popularly known as the Parliamentary Ombudsman, Sir Anthony has been surprisingly open about his work given the secrecy that pervades Whitehall. 
 Firm judgments of the cases he has investigated have often been accompanied by hard-hitting comments about the problems his office has encountered. 
 This is very much a product of his legal background which, in a career spanning 40 years as a lawyer, has seen him spurn a more lucrative profession to concentrate on the injusticesthat accompany bureaucracies like the Civil Service. 
 Born in 1924, his ambitions were delayed by the outbreak of the second world war in which he served in the Royal Naval Reserve from 1943, first in Coastal Forces and then on minesweepers, rising to the rank of lieutenant before being demobilised three years later. 
 He resumed his studies in 1948 at New College, Oxford, where he took a first class honours degree and was called to the bar a year later. 
 A steady rise up the legal ladder took him into the commercial law field and a range of broader experience as a member of both the Monopolies and Mergers Commission (1966 to 1969) and a legal member of the mental health tribunal for 22 years until 1982. 
 By then, he had been a Recorder for ten years and had become a QC in 1974, continuing in active practice until January 1985, since when Sir Anthony &mdash; he was knighted last year &mdash; has acted as both Ombudsman and Health Service Commissioner. 
 Both roles have involved handing out criticism, a task he has not held back from especially in this, the last year before he retires. 
 But for all of the work he has carried out, Barlow Clowes has proved to the largest and most complex in the office's 22 year history. 
 Even before he intervened last November, Sir Anthony had indicated the DTI might have a case to answer. 
 Yesterday, his uncompromising conclusions left no one in doubt that it did. 
 Names urge settlement. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 REPRESENTATIVES of 1,600 Lloyd's of London names who lost hundreds of millions of pounds through syndicates run by Mr Dick Outhwaite yesterday appealed for an out of court settlement of a threatened legal wrangle. 
 Mr Peter Nutting, chairman of the association which represents people who lost out when Mr Outhwaite pledged their money to meet US asbestos and pollution insurance claims, formally announced that writs have been served claiming negligent and reckless underwriting. 
 But he added: &bquo;We don't want our day in court&hellip; we would like to see a settlement.&equo; 
 The writs are against 81 firms of Lloyd's members' agents and against the RM Outhwaite underwriting agency itself. 
 More than 1,600 names &mdash; the people whose personal wealth is pledged to meeting insurance claims &mdash; lost money when they found themselves having to meet huge bills for asbestosis and pollution claims after Mr Outhwaite agreed to take on the risks from other Lloyd's syndicates in 1982. 
 The committee headed by Mr Nutting has issued the writs on behalf of 814 names but hopes that more will join the action. 
 &bquo;We are totally convinced as a committee that the losses that we are facing &mdash; losses on an unprecedented scale &mdash; are a result of reckless and negligent underwriting,&equo; said Mr Nutting. 
 The group maintains that by the time Mr Outhwaite agreed to take on the US risks, the dangers of asbestosis were already known: a Lloyd's working party had been set up in 1980 to look at the issue. 
 If the Outhwaite investors get their way in court, much of the burden of the claims could fall on other Lloyd's underwriters who sell &bquo;errors and omission&equo; policies, designed to cover against losses because a professional simply made a mistake. 
 A court hearing is unlikely before the end of next year. 
 &bquo;I found very questionable that it was no (or little) concern that investors&equo; capital might be being eroded' 
 &bquo;A regulatory agency ought, to my mind, by definition adopt a rigorous and enquiring approach&equo;. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 A PICTURE of incompetence, lack of urgency and eagerness to hide anything which might embarrass Whitehall is revealed in yesterday's 170-page report by the Ombudsman, Sir Anthony Barrowclough, on the the Department of Trade's handling of Barlow Clowes. 
 Most of the facts about how an investment group could be allowed to draw in tens of millions of pounds of people's savings for years after regulators had first spotted that things were amiss at Barlow Clowes were revealed in a report by Sir Godfray Le Quesne commissioned last year by the then Trade Secretary, Lord Young. 
 The Le Quesne report was published 14 months ago. 
 It reported only the facts of the affair and drew no conclusions. 
 But yesterday's document from the Ombudsman is specific in pinpointing the areas where the Department of Trade Industry was at fault. 
 And its findings lay the foundations for Sir Anthony's conclusion that investors who lost money in Barlow Clowes should receive compensation from the Government. 
 The DTI showed &bquo;lack of a sufficiently rigorous and enquiring approach&equo; when looking at the activities of the investment group. 
 Most damningly of all, Sir Anthony concludes that in 1985 the Department already knew that Barlow Clowes did not maintain proper records, that it had been trading without a licence and that investment watchdogs were worried about the group's activities. 
 The DTI could have closed down the investment business there and then. 
 Instead, Barlow Clowes was granted a licence. 
 The DTI said it wanted to avoid the risk of a &bquo;disorderly collapse&equo; which would have threatened the savings of those people who had already put money into the funds. 
 Yesterday's report says: &bquo;The attractions of granting a licence, as a shield against accusations that the Department had &mdash; with the knowledge that the partnership was unlicensed &mdash; allowed them to carry on taking investors&equo; money, were allowed to cloud the thinking within the Department.&equo; 
 It goes on: &bquo;Too little thought was given to the question of whether a legitimising licence would have been beneficial to investors. 
 &bquo;If proper thought had been given to that, I think the conclusion must have been that it would not be beneficial&hellip; 
 I consider also that the decision in question was flawed to a degree by undue weight being given to the question of a disorderly collapse.&equo; 
 Had Barlow Clowes been shut down in 1985, the total investment at risk in the offshore funds would have been less than &pound;31 million. 
 By the time it was eventually closed in 1988, new investors had brought the total to &pound;116 million. 
 Administrative and clerical errors by the DTI between 1975 and 1981 meant that the Clowes business was unlicensed. 
 On two occasions, once in 1980 and once in 1982, the DTI failed to act when it was told that Barlow Clowes was apparently dealing in investments without a licence. 
 And the department ignored the fact that a warrant for the arrest of Mrs Elizabeth Barlow, one of Barlow Clowes' founders, was issued in 1981 in connection with the collapse of a stockbroker. 
 &bquo;The fact that the Department had, in effect, advised the partnership that it did not need a licence made it difficult for the Department to point a finger of blame at them,&equo; says Sir Anthony. 
 The lack of a licence in Barlow Clowes' early years may or may not have made a difference to the way investors' funds were handled during that time. 
 But if the British Barlow Clowes operation had been within the licensing net, it is more likely that the Department of Trade would have found out at a much earlier stage that Mr Peter Clowes was running a parallel offshore operation &mdash; first in Jersey and then in Gibraltar. 
 &bquo;Matters of concern would have included the extent to which United Kingdom residents were investors in the Jersey funds, how they had come to be investors in those funds, how those funds were managed, whether they were kept separate from the United Kingdom funds or whether there was intermingling &lsqb;the switching of money between UK and offshore funds&rsqb;&hellip; and, ultimately, whether the Jersey funds as well as the United Kingdom funds could be properly accounted for.&equo; 
 Sir Anthony goes on: &bquo;The information I have been given by the joint liquidators of BCGM &lsqb;the British fund&rsqb; and BCI &lsqb;in Gibraltar&rsqb; indicates that in the period up to December 1984 there had been frequent movements of money or securities between the United Kingdom funds and the Jersey funds and, most important of all, that at December 1984 the gilt-edged securities and cash held for the Jersey funds were at least some &pound;3.65 million less than the funds&equo; obligations to investors. 
 &bquo;But I think it highly unlikely that Mr Clowes could have found any means of ensuring that investigation of the matters in question was averted, while at the same time satisfying the Department that his operations could properly be licensed. 
 &bquo;To my mind, it is a virtual certainty that the partnership's operations would have been brought to an end, in one way or another, within a relatively short time after&hellip; 
 December 1984.&equo; 
 But it is in 1985 and subsequent years that Sir Anthony finds the Department of Trade's behaviour most lacking. 
 The central mistake was the Department's decision to grant Barlow Clowes an investment licence in 1985. 
 The DTI had plenty of ammunition to back a decision to withhold a licence. 
 The Department had evidence of &bquo;the very unsatisfactory state of affairs which existed within the partnership.&equo; 
 Most importantly, the DTI asked Barlow Clowes to have its auditors, Spicer &amp; Pegler, look at the accounts. 
 But the DTI did not appreciate that the accountants' study missed the central point of the Department's inquiry: the auditors were not asked to answer the simple question of whether there was enough money in Barlow Clowes' coffers to cover the amount owned to investors. 
 Sir Anthony says: &bquo;The Department were at fault in failing to appreciate that the instructions given to Spicers to carry out an audit of the partnership's client accounts would not, at least as regards some important Barlow Clowes portfolios, have enabled any reassurance to be gained on the score of the concern that the partnership could not make the payments of income they had guaranteed without eroding clients&equo; capital. 
 &bquo;The portfolios which gave rise to this problem were those under which, besides guaranteed income payments, there was a guarantee that a stated sum would be repaid to the investor at the future maturity date of his chosen stock.&equo; 
 After Barlow Clowes was granted its licence in 1985, warning signs kept reappearing. 
 And by summer 1987 &mdash; still a year before Barlow Clowes was closed &mdash; it was obvious that something was seriously wrong. 
 The Stock Exchange investigated Barlow Clowes because the company wanted to become a stockbroker. 
 It found some alarming evidence. 
 The Exchange spotted that Barlow Clowes' accounts were silent on the question of whether its investors' funds were sufficient to cover what savers were entitled to. 
 Specifically, the SE found that although Barlow Clowes claimed to deal only in government stock, &bquo;evidence of their dealing in equities also had been found.&equo; 
 The Stock Exchange concluded that the accounts could be regarded as suspect because they made no reference to such business, according to Sir Anthony. 
 The Inland Revenue had told the SE that Barlow Clowes' advertising literature appeared misleading about the tax implications of investing in certain funds. 
 Clients did not receive regular information on where their money was invested or what their funds were now worth. 
 The Ombudsmansays of the SE's findings: &bquo;Among the authors&equo; conclusions was the view that &bquo;there must be substantial doubts as to whether the Barlow Clowes and James Ferguson companies and their directors can be considered fit and proper&equo; for membership of the Stock Exchange.&equo; 
 There was evidence that Barlow Clowes investors' money had been put into shares in James Ferguson, run by Mr Clowes' ally Guy von Cramer. 
 Sir Anthony says: &bquo;The paper concluded that the applications for membership could not be supported and that there should be a full inquiry ihnto the takeover activities and share dealings of James Ferguson and its related companies and connections, including the Barlow Clowes Group.&equo; 
 The Stock Exchange's damning report was sent to the Bank of England and to the Department of Trade's Licensing Unit, which had responsibility for allowing financial groups to stay in operation. 
 The letter to the DTI was sent on July 2, 1987. 
 There was a further letter eight days later. 
 Sir Anthony says: &bquo;In his letter to the Licensing Unit principal, the Stock Exchange representative said that he was sceptical of the &bquo;bad guys becoming clean&equo; touch and was concerned about the future of the UK portfolio clients and the extent of resources within the portfolios.&equo; 
 In the months leading up to the Stock Exchange's damning findings, the DTI's lack of concrete action was probably forgiveable. 
 Once the DTI knew of the Stock Exchange's findings in July 1987, there was no excuse for delay. 
 &bquo;Nevertheless, it was not until September 18 that a decision was made that a section 105 investigation should be recommended by the Minister and the submissions to that effect did no reach him until October 13,&equo; says Sir Anthony. 
 &bquo;The delays involved were altogether unacceptable in my view and I had no doubt that they amounted to maladministration.&equo; 
 Late in September, the DTI Licensing Unit was given a heaven-sent opportunity to act. 
 Accountants Touche Ross asked for an extension of time for the filing of a &bquo;monitoring return&equo; giving details of Barlow Clowes' finances which was due by the end of that month. 
 The DTI could have responded by saying that the absence of the monitoring return was a serious matter, that it would allow a short extension, but that &bquo;consideration would need to be given to revoking the licence if a satisfactory and duly verified monitoring return were not received by the specified date.&equo; 
 Sir Anthony concludes that the DTI did not adopt this tactic &bquo;as a matter of urgency&equo; because of the &bquo;inadequate grasp within the Licensing Unit of the detail of their powers under the Act which they had the task of administering.&equo; 
 In other words, the DTI had failed to understand fully its own legal powers with which it could have put pressure on Barlow Clowes. 
 In the event, the DTI only launched a secret inquiry. 
 It took a further eight months before Barlow Clowes was closed down. 
 Sir Anthony concludes: &bquo;A regulatory agency &mdash; which is what the Department were, at the time, in relation to the protection of investors &mdash; ought, to my mind, by definition adopt a rigorous and enquiring approach as regards material coming into its possession concerning an undertaking about which suspicions have been aroused, and also as regards representations made to it on the part of the undertaking in question. 
 &bquo;And it was, in my view, the lack of sufficiently rigorous and enquiring approach which led not only to the failure to appreciate that there was a Jersey partnership but also to some other of the faults I have identified.&equo; 
 Ombudsman slams DTI on Barlow Clowes affair &bquo;Government ignored all warning signs for years&equo;. 
 NICHOLAS Ridley offered &pound;150million in ex gratia payments to investors in Barlow Clowes, but said the Government did not accept the main findings of the Ombudsman's report into the DTI's handling of the affair, writes Paul Nettleton. 
 The Trade and Industry Secretary told the Commons: &bquo;The Government is not asserting that the conduct of the department was beyond criticism, given the benefit of hindsight. 
 &bquo;But in the Government's view the Department's handling of the case was within the acceptable range of standards reasonably to be expected of a regulator.&equo; 
 The payments would be made &bquo;without admission of fault or liability&equo;. 
 Mr Ridley said: &bquo;I give notice of our intention to pursue vigorously any claims which show prospects of reducing the cost to the public purse of these payments.&equo; 
 He said recent legislation and jurisprudence made clear that regulators are not liable to investors. 
 &bquo;The Government does not believe that it would be right for this case to be treated as a precedent.&equo; 
 Mr Gordon Brown, shadow trade secretary, asked: &bquo;Why have we had to rely on the Ombudsman to confirm the mismanagement, the maladministration and incompetence that was widely known more than a year ago?&equo; 
 It was strange that he was prepared to pay out &pound;150million &bquo;and yet he continues to deny the Government's responsibility for mistakes and does not even apologise for his department's role&equo;. 
 The reason for the payments was &bquo;not the fecklessness, gullibility or incompetence of the small investor, but the fecklessness, gullibility and incompetence of the Government, which for months and for years ignored all warnings&equo;. 
 He asked: &bquo;Who in the Government intends to take responsibility for this negligence on a vast scale, that is now costing vast sums of public money?&equo; 
 Mr Ridley said that of the five charges of maladministration the Ombudsman only attached &bquo;great significance&equo; to one which was a new point about the Jersey partnership. 
 The first criticism of the DTI dated from 1975, he said, adding that Mr Brown should not seek to make party political points. 
 He said the gross cost of the scheme would be &pound;150million, but the liquidators expected to be able to return over &pound;60million and the net cost would be reduced still further if sums were received from third parties. 
 Backbench MPs largely welcomed the compensation announcement, but insisted the Government must learn the lessons of the affair. 
 Mr Ian Stewart (C. Hertfordshire N) said Mr Ridley had announced a &bquo;handsome scheme of recompense&equo;. 
 But he added: &bquo;It didn't require a great deal of insight in 1985 to appreciate that the business of Barlow Clowes was not at that time being run in a fashion which made it an obvious candidate for a licence.&equo; 
 Mr Alf Morris (Lab. 
 Wythenshawe) welcomed a step forward for the victims of a &bquo;huge and vile swindle&equo;. 
 Two of his elderly constituents had lost not only their life savings, but their homes. 
 But they had received a further &bquo;hammer blow&equo; with a demand yesterday &bquo;for thousands of pounds from the Inland Revenue for taxation which they had been told by Barlow Clowes had been deducted at source. 
 Shares tumble after Wall Street slump. 
 By Mark Milner 
 SHARE prices in London shrugged off Monday's sharp fall on Wall Street but then succumbed to fresh falls in New York late in the day. 
 Monday's 46 point drop in the US market meant a nervous opening in London but the fall in FTSE 100 index was confined to to single figures until mid-afternoon. 
 Then the index fell by almost 20 points below Monday's close after Wall Street turned a tentative opening into a 25 point slump. 
 The subsequent rally in New York came too late to help London shares. 
 At the close of trade, the Dow Jones index was 1.92 points lower at 2,695.61. 
 The FTSE 100 index finished 16.4 points lower at 2,342.1. 
 However, one share dealer commented that with many institutional investors reluctant to open aggressive new positions ahead of the new year, losses were expected to be contained. 
 On the foreign exchanges, the pound was a fraction down at &dollar;1.6020 but gained more than a pfennig to DM2.7760. 
 Jordan lifts 22 years of martial law. 
 By Wafa Amr in Amman 
 JORDAN'S Prime Minister, Mr Mudar Badran, yesterday announced the freezing of martial law for the first time since 1967 as a prelude for formally revoking most of its provisions and abolishing it. 
 Mr Badran, who was seeking a vote of confidence from the newly elected parliament, said: &bquo;I announce that martial law is now considered frozen&hellip; until such laws are constitutionally abolished in the near future.&equo; 
 Under martial law, which was imposed by King Hussein after the 1967 Arab-Israeli war, freedoms have been restricted and the Jordanian constitution was practically suspended. 
 Almost all candidates in last month's general elections, which were also the first in more than 22 years, called for lifting of martial law and defence laws and demanded the freedom of the press, freedom of association, and the legalisation of political parties banned by law since 1957. 
 Almost all aspects of life suffered under martial law which was used by consecutive governments to ban large public meetings and to crack down on any political groups and political parties working underground. 
 Martial law courts replaced civilian courts and government decisions were immune from trial. 
 Many people were arrested for their political affiliations. 
 Such restrictionsled to the resignation of former Prime Minister Zaid Rifai's government after bloody rioting in the southern parts of the kingdom last April. 
 Last week, Mr Badran ordered the return of confiscated passports to their owners and promised further amnesties for political prisoners after the recent release of 48 political detainees. 
 Sources estimate the number of confiscated passports at around 33,000. 
 In his ministerial programme submitted to parliament for the deputies' vote of confidence on December 30, Mr Badran said his government will study the legal and economic effects of martial law after taking steps to return suspended passports, restore the elected boards to the three Arabic dailies and abolish a previous martial law order to dissolve the Jordanian Writers Association. 
 Yasser Arafat arrived in Jordan yesterday for talks with King Hussein, Reuter adds, as part of the American-backed effort to promote Israeli-Palestinian peace talks. 
 This comes ahead of a proposed meeting in Washington next month between the foreign ministers of the US, Egypt and Israel. 
 At the top of the agenda is Israel's insistence that the PLO should have no role in the peace talks. 
 March elections &bquo;will cripple opposition for ever&equo;, merger congress told Zimbabwe must be single party state, says Mugabe. 
 By Andrew Meldrum in Harare 
 PRESIDENT Robert Mugabe yesterday made an impassioned call for a Marxist-Leninist single party state in Zimbabwe. 
 His plea came in a speech to nearly 5,000 delegates at a congress marking the final stage of the two-year process to merge his ruling Zanu-PF party and Joshua Nkomo's Zapu. 
 His emphasis on a one-party state surprised many Zimbabwean political analysts, who expected the issue to be quietly forgotten. 
 Earlier this week, Mr Ibbo Mandaza, a prominent intellectual and head of the government's Parastatals Commission, said: &bquo;The one party state is a thing of the past. 
 International events have shown that there is an inherent contradiction between a one-party state and mass democracy. 
 That lesson from eastern Europe has been learned here in southern Africa.&equo; 
 Others within the newly united Zanu-PF, including the Provincial Chairman, Mr Eddison Zvobgo and Mr Dumiso Dabangwa, have gone on the record against a one-party state and it is known that many in Mr Nkomo's Zapu, as well as several middle level Zanu officials, are also opposed. 
 Mr Mugabe asked the conference: &bquo;Is our development path to be that of socialism or capitalism? 
 I am a Socialist, but what are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Socialist, Socialist,&equo; shouted some of the crowd in answer. 
 Mr Mugabe said he would be part of the debate with the delegates. 
 They, not he, would make the decision. 
 &bquo;What I find unbearable and cannot brook as leader is those who, after we make that decision, will deviate and not comply with our decision,&equo; he said. 
 The debate will take place today and tomorrow behind closed doors, but party insiders say that it is very unlikely that Mr Mugabe will face serious opposition. 
 The delegates, largely from Zimbabwe's rural areas, are expected to endorse enthusiastically Mr Mugabe's call. 
 Mr Jonathon Moyo, lecturer in political science at the University of Zimbabwe, said: &bquo;The selection of delegates has been done carefully. 
 These rural people know a great deal about the land issue and agriculture, but the implications of a one party state do not affect them directly. 
 Those who are likely to complain about a one-party state have been left out of the delegations. 
 &bquo;The argument against a one-party state is shared by many intellectuals, including those in the party and who work for the state, but those in power are for it. 
 Mugabe and (Minister of Foreign Affairs Nathan) Shamuyarira are for it and they are in a position to effect it.&equo; 
 Mr Mugabe announced yesterday that the national elections are expected to be held in March. 
 The establishment of a one-party state may come very quickly after that. 
 He said the electoral defeat of opposition parties &bquo;will be so massive and crippling that they will not rise again&equo;. 
 The Mozambican President, Mr Joaquim Chissano, has announced general elections for 1991 but hinted they would be single party only, the Portuguese news agency, Lusa, said yesterday. 
 &bquo;Democracy can exist in a one-party as well as in a plural-party system,&equo; he told a summit of five African nations on Monday in the Cape Verde capital, Praia. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Argentina drops market controls. 
 By Jeremy Morgan in Buenos Aires 
 ARGENTINA's new Finance Minister, Mr Antonio Erman Gonzalez, has quickly plunged into the free market economics President Carlos Menem promised when he took power in July. 
 Within minutes of being sworn in on Monday evening, Mr Gonzalez announced a nine-point economic package ending government price controls and foreign-exchange regulations. 
 He also reversed a decision by his predecessor, Mr Nestor Rapanelli, who resigned last Friday, to raise export taxes by 11 per cent. 
 Foreign bankers and economists cautiously welcomed the minister's initiative, but warned that he and President Menem should steel themselves for a &bquo;very rough ride&equo; during the next few weeks. 
 Unofficial forecasts for inflation this month alone now range between 25 and 60 per cent &mdash; and companies will be free to set whatever prices they like from now on. 
 Argentina's currency, the austral, has plummeted since it was devalued by more than 50 per cent a week ago. 
 Financial markets remained closed by government order yesterday but will reopen today. 
 Nobody has forgotten the rapid descent into currency chaos, rampant inflation and food riots which greeted a short-lived move to decontrol prices and foreign exchanges during the closing stages of the previous government last spring. 
 In private, officials concede that Mr Gonzalez's measures are a high-risk gamble, and President Menem has already said as much in public. 
 &bquo;We are in the eye of the storm,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We've all taken off together on this flight and there aren't any parachutes in this aircraft. 
 He who wants to jump out should jump out now.&equo; 
 Concern about the outlook for Mr Gonzalez's policy focuses on the attitude of not only businessmen, but also union bosses who control the dominant right wing of the ruling Peronist mass movement, and large swathes of Argentina's obstructive bureaucracy. 
 Both President Menem and Mr Gonzalez scorned the endlessly complex theories which had plagued economic policy in Argentina for decades, persuading one government after another to impose controls on everything. 
 Mr Gonzalez abandoned another long-running tradition by which Argentine finance ministers unveil their measures in tedious explanations of elementary economics. 
 He revealed his plans briefly, and in simple language. 
 The delivery was as different as the policy. 
 Bush's China syndrome comes under attack. 
 By Simon Tisdall in Washington 
 THE White House was under intense pressure yesterday to demonstrate positive results from its secret, high-level contacts with the Chinese Government, or face sweeping sanctions against Beijing when Congress reconvenes next month. 
 The leaked disclosure on Monday that the National Security Adviser, Mr Brent Scowcroft, and the Deputy Secretary of State, Mr Lawrence Eagleburger, met Chinese leaders in Beijing last July, only a month after the Tiananmen Square massacre, has compounded the furore over this month's furtive Beijing foray by the two men. 
 The controversy extends to the US Administration, where many officials were kept in the dark over the White House initiatives. 
 After the massacre, the US suspended all high-level contacts with Beijing. 
 President Bush, now stands accused of duplicity in his dealings with Congress, and of exercising a double standard over human rights in China, compared to the Soviet bloc. 
 The Senate Majority Leader, Mr George Mitchell, demanded &bquo;full disclosure&equo; of the contacts with the Beijing regime, adding that &bquo;the visits make a mockery of our profession of concern for human rights&equo;. 
 The Democratic Party chairman, Mr Ron Brown, said that &bquo;there has not been such a decision so out of touch with American values since the sale of arms to the Ayatollah. 
 This is realpolitik run amok.&equo; 
 The President has also been criticised from the right, with Republicans mystified at Mr Bush's demarche. 
 Mr Bush, a former US diplomat in Beijing, has countered by hinting that when his traducers were fully acquainted with the facts, his actions would be justified &mdash; and typically he has been angered by the &bquo;personal&equo; nature of the criticism. 
 According to sources here, unless significant, reciprocal Chinese gestures are forthcoming, demands for permanent economic sanctions against Beijing are likely to gain momentum. 
 In the case of Professor Fang Lizhi, the dissident leader who is still holed up in the US embassy in Beijing, Mr Bush has been unable to say when or whether the Chinese may allow him to leave for a third country, as reportedly urged by Mr Scowcroft. 
 A recent Chinese assurance on ballistic missile sales to Middle Eastern countries, accreditation for a Voice of America journalist, and discussions of a possible resumption of the Fulbright academic exchange programme, have been dismissed here as inadequate. 
 If the US has demanded an ending of martial law, freeing of jailed dissidents, and an amnesty for fugitives, then these demands remain unmet. 
 Mutually important issues such as Cambodian instability, the security of Taiwan and Hong Kong, and tensions on the Korean peninsula (which may have prompted the visits) could have been handled through diplomatic channels without resort to secrecy, Mr Winston Lord, US ambassador to China until this year, pointed out yesterday. 
 As an &bquo;old China hand&equo;, Mr Bush apparently prides himself on his personal understanding in dealing with the Chinese; and as a former CIA director, he is not averse to secrecy. 
 But according to several Washington commentators and analysts, in sending senior aides to China, Mr Bush may have signalled that the Administration gave priority to continuity in relations over moral outrage, and thus helped to shore up the repressive Beijing regime. 
 In the absence of a substantive response, Congress is also expected to move to extend the visas of 40,000 Chinese students in the US, many of whom fear persecution should they return home. 
 Mr Bush effectively vetoed this measure but supporters of the bill are confident that they will have enough votes next month. 
 Unrest set off by silencing of cleric. 
 By Ian Traynor in Budapest 
 THE seeds of popular revolt that appear to be taking root across Romania were sown last Thursday in the north-western town of Timisoara when President Nicolae Ceausescu's security forces moved to evict the Protestant pastor, Laszlo Tokes, who has long been a thorn in the side of the regime. 
 Under a court ruling, Pastor Tokes was to be shifted east after pressure was put on church elders who acceded to the regime's order to move the troublesome clergyman away from the town. 
 When the security forces sought to empty the pastor's house of its possessions, a human chain of several dozen formed around the house, setting in train a flood of protest that was to escalate into what appears to have been a massacre on Sunday. 
 The growing volume of eye-witness accounts emerging from the firmly sealed region make it possible to gain a clearer picture of how the protests grew. 
 By Friday night, according to the prominent Paris-based Romanian human rights activist, Mr Mihnea Berindei, the chain around the pastor's house was 200 strong. 
 It was at this point that police initially peacefully and totally unsuccessfully, sought to persuade the protesters to disperse. 
 But their numbers grew throughout Saturday. 
 By the evening, many Romanians joined the ethnic Hungarians and the first cries of &bquo;wake up Romanians&equo; were heard. 
 Another prominent call was for libertate, the Romanian word for freedom. 
 It appears that although the initial protest was by ethnic Hungarians seeking to protect Pastor Tokes, himself a Hungarian, Romanians were quick to join the demonstrations. 
 There are reported to have been minor clashes with security forces on Saturday evening, but no notable casualties. 
 It was on Sunday that the scenes turned ugly. 
 The crowd swelled to around 10,000, making it the biggest protest in the country since the bread protests in Brasov in 1987. 
 Eye-witnesses say that the demonstrators marched on the local government offices and occupied them. 
 They tore down pictures of President Ceausescu, cut the Socialist emblem from the national flag, and set on fire any red flags they came across. 
 A Hungarian, Ms Erszebet Varga, who returned from Timisoara on Monday, told Hungarian television that on Sunday pregnant women taking part in the demonstration approached the bayonet wielding soldiers and, pointing to their swollen bellies, demanded that the unborn children be killed immediately as they would only starve to death when they were born. 
 A speaker at the demonstration compared the situation in Romania unfavourably with the dramatic events unfolding across Eastern Europe and demanded an end to the Ceausescu dictatorship. 
 Shop windows containing the Romanian dictator's portrait were also smashed and vehicles overturned and set alight. 
 By then Pastor Tokes had disappeared and has not been heard of since. 
 But by then, the show-down had come from one of support for the clergyman to one of outright resistance to the regime. 
 The response of the security forces was first to bring in police. 
 As demonstrations escalated, water cannon and fire engines appeared. 
 Some accounts say that the fire engines were attacked, overturned, and set alight. 
 It was at this stage that tanks and troops wielding guns and naked bayonets were introduced and gunfire was heard. 
 By Monday the protests had spread across the region, and smaller demonstrations were reported in Arad, Cluj, Oradea and Brasov, while the security forces were mobilised across Transylvania and all the borders sealed. 
 Magazine &bquo;can prove&equo; secret burial of Seveso dioxin. 
 By Paul Webster in Paris 
 AFRENCH magazine has promised to publish more proof of an allegation that dioxin from the 1976 Seveso disaster in northern Italy was secretly buried in a central French town where the inhabitants have been suffering from fumes from a toxic waste dump. 
 The magazine, Politis, claimed it had more evidence after the French Environment Ministry dismissed the report but adding that it was dangerous to dig in the recently closed dump because it &bquo;would be like opening a tomb&equo;. 
 Mr Michel Moussel, the pollution director at the ministry, said that there was no question of checking the allegations by digging in the dump at Montchanin in the Saone et Loire department even if it was proved that the dioxin was buried there. 
 &bquo;This would be the worst solution possible,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Apart from anything else the waste would have to be got rid of somewhere else.&equo; 
 The Politis editor, Mr Jean-Paul Besset, said his magazine had carried out a long investigation into dangerous waste dumping, including the discovery in 1983 of barrels of earth impregnated with dioxin from Seveso that were illegally shipped to northern France by an independent contractor. 
 The owners, Hoffmann-La Roche, were forced to transfer the waste to Switzerland for destruction. 
 According to Politis, 200 grammes of dioxin have not been accounted for. 
 EC joins plans for common market including East Europe economies. 
 By John Palmer in Brussels 
 THE foreign ministers of 19 West European countries yesterday laid the foundations for what they hope will emerge as a pan-European association joined by the reforming countries of Eastern Europe. 
 The 12 members of the European Community and the six members of the European Free Trade Association, plus Lichtenstein, aim to create a 19-nation European Economic Space by the end of next year in which virtually all barriers to the free movement of goods, services, capital, and people will be removed. 
 The EC-EFTA meeting in Brussels was overshadowed by the visit of the Soviet Foreign Minister, Mr Eduard Shevardnadze, who this week unveiled plans for a &bquo;common European home&equo; based on links between the EC, EFTA, and Comecon. 
 However, while the EC is reluctant to upgrade links with Comecon, at least until the impact of economic reform in Eastern Europe is clearer, the Commission yesterday published proposals for wide-ranging trade and economic co-operation with East Germany and signalled a readiness to conclude similar agreements with Bulgaria and Czechoslovakia. 
 Clearly working under the pressure of the speed of events in central Europe, the West Europeans have decided to go all out to form a united economic bloc, if possible by the end of next year, but at all costs by January 1992 when the EC internal market is due to be completed. 
 However, significant differences remain between the EC and EFTA about sharing political responsibility for the EES. 
 The European Commissioner for External Affairs, Mr Frans Andriessen, said in Brussels yesterday that the Community would not compromise its autonomy and the supremacy of its political institutions. 
 However, the Icelandic Foreign Minister and president of the EFTA Council, Mr Jon Baldvin Hannibalsson, made it clear that EFTA wants parity with the EC in deciding all new directives. 
 Moreover, while the EC countries want EFTA to be subject to the rules of the European Court of Justice, EFTA governments would prefer a new legal structure consisting of judges from both sides. 
 If these political differences are overcome, a common market of more than 350 million people, will be created. 
 Largely at the insistence of the EFTA countries &mdash; Austria, Finland, Iceland, Norway, Sweden, and Switzerland &mdash; the EES will also tackle common social, environment protection, research, and development issues. 
 Under the pressure of the EC's decision to accelerate its own internal integration, the sovereignty-conscious EFTA countries have agreed to give their association greater political authority to negotiate on their behalf as a united front. 
 However, Austria has already submitted its request for full membership of the EC and this might be followed by Norway and Sweden if the attempt to negotiate a wider West European unity breaks down. 
 Neither side is clear about when and how to involve the reform-minded East Europeans. 
 EFTA does not want to be a &bquo;kindergarten&equo; for East European countries embarking on the path to market economies, but the looser 23-nation Council of Europe &mdash; to which Hungary has already sought entry &mdash; might be asked to play this role once democratic elections are held in individual east European countries. 
 Meanwhile, Turkey's Foreign Minister, Mr Ali Bozer, said yesterday that the European Commission's rejection of Turkey's application to join the EC until after 1992 did &bquo;not fully correspond to Turkey's aspirations&equo;. 
 Mr Bozer said Turkish public opinion expected &bquo;a further and more positive approach&equo;. 
 The government welcomed Brussels' confirmation of Ankara's eligibility for eventual membership of the EC and proposals to strengthen economic links with Turkey. 
 Havel rise to presidency endorsed by Czech PM. 
 By Foreign Staff 
 CZECHOSLOVAKIA's playwright-turned-politician, Mr Vaclav Havel, moved a step nearer to the presidency yesterday when the country's Communist Prime Minister, Mr Marian Calfa, recommended that he should be installed by the end of the year. 
 Mr Calfa also said that all domestic operations of the dreaded secret police have been halted. 
 &bquo;It is one of our priorities to adjust the work of the Interior Ministry to the new social conditions and turn this ministry into a component of state administration based on democratic principles&hellip; 
 As of today the operations of the police force in the field of internal intelligence have been stopped,&equo; Mr Calfa said. 
 Turning his attention to Mr Havel, the Prime Minister said, &bquo;It is the government's opinion that there is no alternative &lsqb;to him&rsqb;.&equo; 
 According to the constitution, Mr Havel should be elected by December 24 &mdash; within two weeks of the resignation of President Husak. 
 However, there were indications last night that some Communist deputies may seek to complicate the vote, by not turning up in sufficient numbers, or to delay it, possibly by as much as three weeks, to allow their own party to re-group after its recent humiliations. 
 An &bquo;extraordinary&equo; Congress to elect a new Party leadership opens in Prague today. 
 Mr Havel, himself a victim of the secret police, has spoken frequently of the never-ending threat of a house search, the knowledge that every visitor was photographed and every conversation bugged by the Communist regime. 
 Mr Havel's house was continously monitored from a nearby tower of the Manes gallery in central Prague, and cameras were installed by the secret police in other streets where dissidents lived. 
 During the 41 years of Communist rule, an as yet undisclosed number of secret police agents were involved in continuous surveillance operations against citizens and were responsible for the interrogation and harassment of dissidents. 
 Meanwhile, the Socialist Party, one of the four smaller parties represented in the assembly, announced last night that it would also be backing Mr Havel's candidacy. 
 While these constitutional niceties were being debated, a crowd of students gathered in the rain a few hundred yards away in Wenceslas Square to demonstrate support for Mr Havel. 
 Balloons were released and Czechoslovak flags were waved as passing motorists sounded their horns in noisy support. 
 The chances of the man who was seen as a contender for the presidency until a few days ago, the former leader, Mr Alexander Dubcek, winning the post are now seen as receding. 
 Unconfirmed reports say he could become Speaker, a position of some honour but no great responsibility. 
 Mr Calfa went on to outline an economic programme which would be operational until free elections can be held. 
 &bquo;The economic system of the last few decades has failed,&equo; he said. 
 The long legislative road to Hong Kong's lost passports Stephen Vines explains when a passport is not a passport as he unravels the laws which forbid the colony's residents to come to Britain. 
 UNTIL 1948 Hong Kong people were regarded as British citizens with the same right of abode in the United Kingdom as anyone born in Britain. 
 The 1948 British Nationality Act renamed them Citizens of the United Kingdom and Colonies (CUKCs), but the people of Hong Kong retained their right of abode in Britain and during the 1950's were positively encouraged to go to the &bquo;Mother Country&equo; to fill job vacancies. 
 The 1962 Commonwealth Immigrants Act changed this, and only those born in Britain were henceforth automatically given the right of abode. 
 Others were treated as aliens, although in practice it was easier for CUKCs to emigrate to Britain than other foreigners for purposes of family reunion. 
 The right of entry was further reduced by the 1971 Immigration Act which introduced the concept of &bquo;patriality&equo;. 
 Admission was only granted to those born in Britain or having an ancestral link stretching back two generations, those who had lived in Britain for five years, and spouses of patrials. 
 This law was widely criticised as racist because it effectively barred entry from the so-called new Commonwealth while allowing continued emigration from the predominantly white old Commonwealth countries. 
 By 1981, the distinction between patrials and non-partials was drawn even more distinctly by the British Nationality Act. 
 All patrial CUKCs were renamed as British citizens while all non-patrials became British Dependent Territory Citizens (BDTCs) who only had the right of abode in their territories of residence. 
 However, exemptions were made for Gibraltarians and residents of the Falkland Islands who can become British citizens. 
 The population of Hong Kong is officially given as 5.7 million, however it is probably around 6 million. 
 Of this, 3.28 million are eligible for a BDTC passport, but only some one million people possess this document. 
 The rest of the population (excluding expatriates which at most make up two per cent of the population) hold either Certificates of Identity (CIs) or Documents of Identity (DIs). 
 The DI is given almost exclusively to new immigrants from the Chinese mainland. 
 Last year, 28,000 people came to Hong Kong as legal emigrants from China. 
 The same number are expected to arrive this year. 
 After remaining in the colony for seven years they can apply for a CI which is a more widely recognised travel document and enables them to become British Dependent Territory Citizens. 
 Before the fears of the 1997 Chinese takeover began to mount, most people did not bother to change their registered status. 
 Nor have many responded to the offer of the new British National (Overseas) passport which was introduced to overcome problems of national status derived from China's insistence that all &bquo;Chinese compatriots&equo; in Hong Kong are Chinese nationals. 
 Britain introduced this new passport two years ago. 
 It will be available after 1997 and is essentially a travel document whose validity has been questioned by a number of countries. 
 Less than 70,000 Hong Kong people carry this passport. 
 Hong Kong people, like others considered to be aliens under British law, can also apply to emigrate to Britain under very limited criteria. 
 People of independent means with assets exceeding &pound;150,000 and an annual income exceeding &pound;15,000 per year who have a close connection with Britain can make an application. 
 Those with assets exceeding &pound;500,000 can also apply, as can businessmen willing to invest over &pound;150,000 and create new employment. 
 Besides those of proven wealth, the immigration laws only allow entry to specific categories of employees who are required to fill jobs which cannot be filled by the existing labour force. 
 Under these conditions Hong Kong emigration to Britain has been very small. 
 Last year 1,150 people from the colony settled in Britain, in 1987 the number was 920, and only 860 in 1986. 
 Jordan lifts 22 years of martial law. 
 By Reuter in Amman 
 THE Jordanian Prime Minister, Mr Mudar Badran, wooing the newly elected parliament, lifted martial law yesterday after 22 years and promised to fight corruption. 
 Mr Badran, who took office two weeks ago, said that martial law imposed during the 1967 Arab-Israeli war had been &bquo;frozen&equo; and would soon be formally scrapped. 
 Stealing the thunder of Islamic fundamentalist and leftwing MPs, he promised sweeping measures to curb official graft, saying top public servants would have to declare their wealth. 
 &bquo;The government will co-operate with your council to uncover the various facades of financial corruption and will not tolerate corruption or lax behaviour,&equo; he declared, drawing loud applause from the packed public galleries. 
 Mr Badran, a former intelligence chief, has bowed to public pressure to bring in democratic reforms and investigate people blamed for the country's economic crisis. 
 He has already reversed many measures taken by previous governments, which used martial law over economic matters and to detain political opponents or ban them from work or travel. 
 The government is reviewing the cases of about 60 people sentenced for political or security offences to see if they might qualify for pardon. 
 The pace of political concessions has surprised even liberal Jordanians, some of whom express concern that the government, in its anxiety to win a parliamentary vote of confidence, has left itself little room for manoeuvre. 
 &bquo;There's a difference between cleaning your nails and pulling them out,&equo; one civil servant said. 
 &bquo;We are still in the Middle East and one day the government might need teeth.&equo; 
 The lower house, chosen on November 8 in Jordan's first general election in 22 years, was not expected to give the government programme an easy passage. 
 The Muslim Brotherhood, with 22 seats, could combine with leftwing and other disaffected MPs in no-confidence motions. 
 Parliament meets for the confidence vote on December 30. 
 Soon afterwards, the Finance Minister will present an austerity budget for 1990. 
 Jordan's treasury, burdened by a foreign debt of about &dollar;8 billion, has little to give away and parliament is bound to attack the government on rising prices and unemployment. 
 Mr Badran promised to continue to subsidise basic foods and not to raise taxes, though he said the government would reform taxation and spread the tax burden more evenly. 
 PAGE 
 Popular revolt begins to shake Romania, the last domino of Eastern Europe Hero of heroes turns Stalinist dinosaur. 
 By Michael Simmons 
 PRESIDENT Nicolae Ceausescu, once regarded as the world's pet Communist, is a changed man. 
 Twenty years ago, to almost universal applause, he defied the Kremlin; ten years later he was an honoured guest, staying at Buckingham Palace; today, he is seen as a Stalinist dinosaur who deserves little better than assassination. 
 The Shining Light of the World, the Hero of Heroes, the Genius of the Carpathians, has turned 70, and is not in good health. 
 &bquo;Ceausescu is a madman,&equo; the Romanian-born playwright, Eugene Ionesco, declared yesterday. 
 &bquo;His wife, thirsty for power, is also mad and his son is an idiot. 
 It's these three who are being allowed to freely torture 23 million people.&equo; 
 An area of consistency has been President Ceausescu's obsession with Romania's sovereignty. 
 Intermittently, for more than 20 years, he has accused the Soviet Union of meddling in Romania's affairs and infringing its sovereignty. 
 In 1968, within five days of the Soviet-led Warsaw Pact invasion of Czechoslovakia, in which Romania refused to participate, he declared that the &bquo;legal&equo; Prague Government should be reinstated. 
 Romanian troops braced themselves for a Soviet invasion. 
 Then he switched to seeking friendship and co-operation with all. 
 He even tried to mediate between the Soviet Union and China, then engaged in frontier disputes. 
 China responded with help for Romanian flood victims, and a warm welcome when Mr Ceausescu went to Beijing in mid-1971. 
 But that same summer, he began to demand more Communist Party purity and discipline. 
 His &bquo;open door&equo; to the West appeared to be closing, and the taste for the Western way of life was firmly discouraged. 
 Logically, within a few weeks, he also began declaring that &bquo;the Communist movement can no longer be led by any centre&equo;. 
 Leadership purges occurred with increasing frequency. 
 In 1972, the cult of his personality began to take off, and his wife, Elena, was suddenly prominently at his side on big occasions, staking out a role for herself as a formidable political force. 
 In 1974, he became President and Elena was First Lady; but there were straws in the wind that something had turned sour. 
 He talked of becoming party leader &bquo;for life&equo;, and when it did not come off, he sacked the Prime Minister, Mr Ion Gheorghe Maurer, after 14 years in the job. 
 He travelled widely in the early 1970s, probably more widely than any other world leader. 
 A month in Africa and five weeks in Latin America were not unusual, nor was an effusive reception in Paris or Bonn. 
 But then came a row with the aged President Tito over the sort of reception he might expect on a visit to Belgrade. 
 Leadership purges became more frequent. 
 By his 60th birthday in January, 1978, the personality cult was in full flower. 
 Awards were deluged on him, as were titles, praise and eulogies in the national press. 
 Books about him and ostensibly by him began to fill bookshop windows &mdash; they still do. 
 The US President received him in 1978 and so did the Queen &mdash; but the purges went on. 
 Then criticisms of him began to be heard and there were unconfirmed reports of assassination attempts. 
 Then the row blew up with Hungary over the enforced assimilation of ethnic Hungarians, involving plans to raze their villages. 
 Distinguished Romanian emigres began to speak of their erstwhile leader as a dictator and a clown. 
 A new obsession, to eliminate the national debt, became overriding. 
 But, at the same time, his isolation as an obsolete Communist and policy-maker increased, roughly coinciding with Mr Gorbachev's emergence as the new-style Communist of world stature. 
 Romanian politburo and central committee meetings have become empty rituals of automated applause, but almost no discussion. 
 Often they have degenerated into bullying harangues for harder work and more discipline from Mr Ceausescu or, occasionally, his wife. 
 President Ceausescu now argues that it is &bquo;inconceivable&equo; that production units should be autonomous. 
 &bquo;No one can conceive of a revolutionary party saying that it will let enterprises or economic sectors manage themselves,&equo; he says. 
 But the people trying to implement policies remain human, and therefore fallible, like the rest of us; cases of &bquo;indiscipline&equo;, corruption and general inefficiency now surface with embarrassing frequency. 
 One result is that ministers are now routinely sacked by the handful. 
 Earlier this year, six Romanian party veterans sent him a message full of criticism of his policies; there was talk that he might step down. 
 Mr Ceausescu responded with house arrests. 
 Now he still trundles out cliches about &bquo;powerful expressions&equo; of &bquo;revolutionary worker democracy&equo;, but only his wife and his closest retainers believe them any more. 
 Baltic republic defies Kremlin pleas for solidarity Lithuania poised for party independence. 
 By John Rettie in Moscow 
 LITHUANIA'S leader, Mr Algirdas Brazauskas, yesterday called for a united front to establish statehood at the opening of a crucial congress of the republic's Communist Party. 
 The Congress is virtually certain to declare itself independent of the Soviet Party. 
 Mr Brazauskas, First Secretary of the republic's party, said all political forces and ethnic groups should agree on a consensus that would fight for this goal, as well as social justice, human rights, and democracy. 
 &bquo;Our first goal is the promotion of democracy&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Our second is the re-establishment of Lithuania's statehood, and the third is an independent Lithuanian Communist Party.&equo; 
 The draft document on declaring the party independent says this would not mean breaking off relations with the Soviet party, but would establish a new relationship of partnership instead of subordin-ation. 
 President Gorbachev and other Politburo members have angrily, and at times desperately, appealed against such a move, for fear it would lead to a breakup of the Soviet Communist Party and, ultimately, of the Soviet Union. 
 But the Lithuanian party is nonetheless likely to vote in favour of such a declaration today. 
 Another draft document said Lithuania's continued membership of the Soviet Union depended on the country being made a fit place to live. 
 In the draft party statutes, one rule specifically states that once the Lithuanian party has declared itself independent, members will have until the 28th Soviet Party Congress next October to decide whether to stay with the Lithuanian party, or leave it and join the Soviet party. 
 The statutes specifically state that a Lithuanian party member cannot belong to any other party. 
 The motive behind the Lithuanian party's decision to move ahead against all the pressure from Moscow was made clear by Mr Donatas Morkunas, secretary of the Siauliai regional party. 
 &bquo;To stay in the Soviet Communist Party would mean the final loss of the Lithuanian party's authority,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;In my region, only one third of members will stay in the party if it does not become independent.&equo; 
 In an interview with the Guardian Mr Valerionas Baltrunas, one of the party's ideology secretaries, said he thought Mr Gorbachev quite understood this. 
 Lithuania, he declared, strongly supported Mr Gorbachev's idea of a &bquo;European homeland&equo; and it wanted &bquo;a good flat in it.&equo; 
 Reuter adds: The Soviet parliament yesterday approved a government programme to rescue the country's ailing economy in what was a virtual vote of confidence in the Prime Minister, Mr Nikolai Ryzhkov. 
 After several days of heated debate, the Congress of People's Deputies passed the programme, outlined by Mr Ryzhkov last week, without amendment. 
 It was opposed by 419 deputies. 
 Winding up the debate, President Gorbachev warned that any attempt to amend the proposals would spell rejection of the whole programme. 
 &bquo;Either you support the programme or you amend it, which means you do not support it at all,&equo; he said. 
 The Soviet Communist Party's ideology chief denied on Monday that the entire ruling Politburo had offered to resign or faced calls to resign at a key party meeting this month. 
 But Mr Vadim Medvedev also indicated there were no plans to set the record straight about what happened at the December 9 meeting of the Central Committee &mdash; which was by all accounts a turbulent one &mdash; by publishing the minutes. 
 Several people who attended have reported a fierce clash between Mr Gorbachev and hard-liners and some said he offered to step down. 
 Terror clamp on dissent. 
 By Foreign Staff 
 ABOUT one in every four of Romania's 23 million population is thought to be a member of the security service, the Securitate. 
 Officials in Bucharest laugh at such a figure, but ordinary Romanians are so afraid of reprisals for even talking to foreigners that verification is impossible. 
 The ruthless and indiscriminate way the weekend protests were suppressed is one side of its operation. 
 Another, equally sinister, is the way in which most public meeting places and telephones are assumed to be bugged; even the family is no longer a safe environment in which to talk. 
 The service's brief is extremely wide, and its members can, and do, act against any activity they deem &bquo;hostile to the Socialist system and the interests of the working people&equo;. 
 The service's efficiency can be gauged by the fact that the country's dissident movement is small to the point of being tiny and that the cult of President Ceausescu's personality has been unassailable. 
 There are no reports in the authorised press of anti-regime demonstrations, or of political arrests or trials. 
 Total censorship restricts information about people who are arrested or imprisoned. 
 Amnesty International says it has learned of &bquo;only a fraction&equo; of the cases in which people were imprisoned for their beliefs. 
 It claims that &bquo;several hundred, whose names are unknown,&equo; are believed to be in prison. 
 It is not clear to what extent the Securitate is now a &bquo;state within the state&equo; and to what extent it is directly answerable to President Ceausescu, but it is odd that the service's worst excesses have occurred when the head of state is on an official trip abroad, in this case to Iran. 
 In 1967, when Mr Ceausescu had only been in power two years, he complained about the security forces taking unjustified measures against the people. 
 He also warned the service against what he called &bquo;abuses and transgressions&equo; of Socialist legality. 
 How he will now speak of the methods used last weekend by the security services could become clear in the next few days. 
 Britain shares Soviet fears on pace of unification. 
 By Hella Pick Diplomatic Editor 
 BRITAIN shares the Soviet Union's concern that there should be no headlong rush into German reunification, the Prime Minister, as well as the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, told the Soviet Foreign Minister, Mr Eduard Shevardnadze yesterday. 
 In a speech made during his two-day stay in Brussels, Mr Shevardnadze raised the questions about the consequences of a reunified German colossus that have also been posed in private discussions among Western officials. 
 But in London, as in Washington or Paris, there is an increasingly fatalistic view that there is very little governments can do to prevent popular pressure for reunification. 
 The Former West German Chancellor, Mr Willy Brandt, has said that any party in East Germany that decides to run on a reunification plank is virtually assured of a runaway victory at the general elections set for next May. 
 Western diplomats have concluded that the Soviet Union's proposal to stage a &bquo;Helsinki II&equo; summit next year is primarily aimed at eliminating any ambiguities about the &bquo;inner-German&equo; frontier, and enshrining the existence of the two German states in the Helsinki Declaration in a way that would virtually rule out reunification. 
 Mrs Thatcher told the Soviet minister yesterday that Britain is not opposed to the idea of a pan-European summit, but the participants must agree on how it will fit into the building of the &bquo;new European architecture.&equo; 
 The Prime Minister, with Mr Shevardnadze at her side, declared herself well satisfied with the two hours of talks. 
 She agreed with Mr Shevardnadze on the importance of &bquo;retaining the stability on the Nato and Warsaw Pact structures and of the Helsinki declaration&equo;. 
 Ski Weather High-tech happiness:.. 
 By Rosemary Burns Ski Club of Great Britain 
 THE LACK of snowfall in most European resorts over the last two winters has made all skiers aware of the advantages of artificial snow-making machinery. 
 The sudden, sharp increase in cross-Atlantic skiing traffic owes much to the claims of some American resorts that they can guarantee snow cover, even if as much as 75 per cent of it may be man-made. 
 None of the European resorts has yet gone in for the wholesale investment in snow-making which we see in the United States, mainly because the capital outlay is enormous and the running costs extremely high. 
 Many of the American resorts are owned by wealthy investors and expenditure decisions are easier to reach than where several different commercial concerns are involved. 
 Killington, Vermont, on the east coast of the United States, boasts the world's largest snow-making system. 
 All its 18 lifts, on six mountains, with inter-connecting &bquo;trails&equo; (runs, to us), are serviced by snow- making machinery. 
 Over the past six years the ski season has averaged 223 days (more than months) per year. 
 It is possible to run all lifts on machine-made snow and this means that Killington has been able to open for skiing from October to June every season since 1982. 
 Killington also boasts the East Coast's largest fleet of snow-grooming vehicles which, in a single mid-winter night, groom the equivalent of seven interstate highway lanes from Boston to Killington. 
 The piste groomers work around the clock to grind up the snow which, because it possesses a denser molecular structure than the real thing, compacts easily into ice. 
 Killington renders it back almost into its original powder form &mdash; leaving only a few &bquo;death cookies&equo; (rock-hard lumps) to trap the unwary. 
 Another East coast resort, Lake Placid, can pump 3,500 gallons of water per minute, along with 19,500 cu ft of compressed air, through 15 pumps and 14 air compressors. 
 They use four pumping stations and move their equipment around Whiteface Mountain to make maximum use of 60 snowmaking guns. 
 Stowe, in Vermont, claims that the energy used to pump its snow (up to 19,500 kw) far exceeds that used to light and heat the entire town down in the valley. 
 Further west, the resorts of Vail in Colorado, and Calgary in Canada averted what could have been a disastrous Winter Olympics last February by making extensive use of artificial snow. 
 In most cases, the Americans have the advantage of ready access to water, which is collected from rivers, lakes and reservoirs and pumped through pipes to emerge from cannon on the slopes. 
 At the same time, air is piped under pressure from enormous compressor units, housed in central pumping stations. 
 The two are mixed in the gun (as in an artist's airbrush) and, given the correct air temperature, the resulting mist which is squirted out crystallises, falling as snow. 
 One big problem with snowmaking is a high air temperature. 
 Here, again, the American East Coast resorts have the advantage over Europe in that they experience very low temperature during the winter months. 
 The cold current off the coast, combined with a prevailing westerly wind can often result in bitterly cold temperatures but a dry atmosphere. 
 Moscow sets terms for unity debate Following are extracts from an address to members of the European Parliament given yesterday by the Soviet Foreign Minister, Mr Eduard Shevardnadze. 
 ONE of the principal components of the German question, and of the entire European situation, is the recognition of the fact that the question of European borders has been solved in a definitive and irrevocable manner. 
 Of course, each German state retains the right to self-determination, but it can be only exercised in the context of other norms and principles of international law. 
 Furthermore, the very notion of self-determination implies the need to exclude any outside pressure on a country. 
 Any appeals or advice to exercise self-determination or prescriptions as to how and when to change the GDR government are not only inappropriate but may raise doubts about the authenticity of the eventual allegedly free choice. 
 Right until the time that the FRG was included in Nato, the Soviet Union favoured a united, democratic, and demilitarised Germany and was of the view that unification of the two German states was possible. 
 Since the refusal of the FRG to accept free elections throughout Germany in 1952, and the inclusion of the FRG in the system of closed Western military-political and economic blocs, circumstances have changed and new realities have evolved. 
 The question of self-determination of the German states has recently become a subject of heated debate. 
 The appeals to the GDR to join the FRG have aroused concern, not only among political parties and people in the GDR who are being advised to renounce their statehood and to make the GDR a part of Nato. 
 The neighbours of the GDR and FRG are also concerned. 
 Firstly, where are the political, legal, and material guarantees that German unity would not eventually create a threat to the national security of other states? 
 Secondly, will such a hypothetical Germany be ready to accept the existing borders in Europe and renounce any territorial claims? 
 The FRG has avoided answering that. 
 Thirdly, what would be the place of such a national German entity in the military-political structures existing on our continent? 
 After all, one cannot seriously expect the status of the GDR to change radically while the status of the FRG remains the same. 
 Fourthly, what would be the military potential of such a new entity, its military doctrine, and the structure of its armed forces? 
 Will it be ready to accept demilitarisation, adopt a neutral status, and fundamentally restructure its economic and other relations with Eastern Europe? 
 Fifthly, what would be the attitude to the presence of allied troops on German soil, to continued functioning of military liaison missions, and to the 1971 four-party agreement? 
 Sixthly, how would the possible creation of such a German unity fit in with the Helsinki process, and would it promote a constructive evolution of that process in the direction of ending the division of Europe and progressing toward integrated legal, economic, ecological, cultural, and information environments in Europe? 
 Seventhly, if the German states were to express themselves for initiating movement toward German unity, would they be ready to take into consideration the interests of other European states and to seek, on a mutually acceptable collective basis, answers to all questions and problems that might arise in that regard? 
 Surely the peoples of the Soviet Union are entitled to know what any changes in Central Europe would mean for their future and security. 
 We paid the price of 20 million lives for existing European stability. 
 Toxic leak kills Soviet miners. 
 Toxic chemicals seeping from a defence plant have killed three miners and led to the closing of the Gorlovka pit, one of the largest in the Donbass, Jonathan Steele writes from Moscow. 
 Survivors said 26 miners and 123 rescuers are in hospital suffering from poisoning. 
 Yugoslavia setback. 
 Yugoslavia's efforts to tackle its economic crisis received a blow yesterday when Serbia, the largest republic, and Vojvodina province rejected the government's emergency recovery plan. 
 The republics of Slovenia, Croatia, and Bosnia-Herzegovina have accepted the programme. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Drug seizure. 
 US narcotics agents have arrested 14 people and seized 2.5 tons of cocaine and &dollar;2.75million (&pound;1.83million) in drug profits during raids in California. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Grenada PM dies. 
 The Grenadan Prime Minister, Herbert Blaize, who hailed the 1983 US-led invasion as a &bquo;rescue mission&equo;, died yesterday, aged 71, after suffering from prostate cancer. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 War crimes trial. 
 An immigrant to Canada from Byelorussia, Mr Michael Pawlowski, aged 72, appeared in the Ontario Supreme Court yesterday on charges of murdering 490 Jews and non-Jewish Poles during the second world war. 
 &mdash; AP.. 
 Guerrillas killed. 
 At least 43 Tupac Amaru Revolutionary Movement guerrillas were killed when army troops took them by surprise in the central Peruvian province of Oxapampa, a military spokesman said yesterday. 
 &mdash; Reuter.. 
 Helicoper shot down. 
 Unita rebels shot down an Angolan military MI-17 helicopter, injuring two crewmen, the official news agency Angop said yesterday. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Palme suspect claim. 
 Christer Petersson, who was acquitted of the 1986 murder of the Swedish Prime Minister, Mr Olof Palme, is demanding two million kronor (&pound;213,000) compensation for the 10 months he spent in jail, news reports said yesterday. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Life sentence. 
 A New Zealand man was yesterday sentenced to life imprisonment for the murder of an English tourist, Monica Cantwell. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 FMLN leader killed. 
 The Salvadorean Marti Farabundo National Liberation Front said a senior rebel leader and seven lower-ranking commanders were killed in the five-week-old offensive. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Race bombings. 
 Police yesterday disarmed a parcel bomb at a black human rights office in Florida, the latest in a rash of mail bombings in the South that have killed a judge and a civil rights lawyer. 
 The FBI said white supremacists might be behind the attacks. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Breakthrough in Aids cure hunt. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 THE first serious prospect of a cure for Aids, rather than a treatment which delays its effects, has emerged when no trace of the Aids virus was found during the post mortem on a patient who had been treated with the standard AZT drug and a bone marrow transplant. 
 Doctors at the Johns Hopkins medical school in Baltimore say that after intensive tests they believe for the first time the Aids virus had been eradicated from the patient's body before he died from a separate lymphoma cancer. 
 The researchers warn that they will have to treat many more patients before they can report a cure, and that the expense and difficulty of obtaining bone marrow are likely to limit the number of possible treatments. 
 Further tests are under way at Baltimore, in California and at Seattle's cancer research centre, to see if the treatment can be repeated on other patients, and may eventually include some Aids sufferers who do not have cancers. 
 Lymphoma, a cancer of the immune system, often occurs in Aids victims, and bone marrow transplant is a standard treatment for sufferers from lymphoma and leukaemia. 
 The new treatment is based on the combination of the bone marrow and the AZT drug, which is being widely used on Aids victims. 
 Bone marrow is the source of immune system cells, and the transplant of new marrow was given after the patient's own bone marrow had been destroyed by doses of radiation and chemotherapy. 
 Simultaneously, the patient was given the AZT drug. 
 Writing in the current issue of Annals of Internal Medicine, Dr Rein Saral and Dr Kent Holland report that the new bone marrow grew and remained free from the Aids virus. 
 Tests on the 32nd day after the transplant showed no trace of the virus in the patient's bone marrow, nor in his blood. 
 Nine days later, the patient died. 
 &bquo;No one has ever seen anything like that before,&equo; Dr Saral said. 
 &bquo;Within the limits of detection, we have got rid of the Aids virus.&equo; 
 Patten tackles Labour on second home curbs plan. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 THE Environment Secretary, Mr Chris Patten, yesterday wrote to Mr Neil Kinnock, the Labour Party leader, demanding that he dissociate himself from proposals designed to stop the growth of second homes. 
 The move came as the Labour Party's housing spokesman, Mr Clive Soley, yesterday complained to the Press Council over newspaper reports that his party was proposing to ban second homes. 
 A Labour group reviewing planning law has proposed that local authorities be allowed to decide whether new second homes should need change of use planning consent. 
 Existing homes would not be affected. 
 The aim is to give councils some control over the future growth of second homes. 
 Mr Patten described it yesterday as a &bquo;spiteful and impractical and authoritarian plan&equo;. 
 But Mr Soley defended the policy in an interview with the Guardian: &bquo;The problem is most acute in rural areas, such as the South-west, where there is a growing problem of ghost villages where 70 per cent of the houses are only occupied at weekends or during the summer,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;At the same time there is lack of accommodation for local people. 
 We have to offer the local authorities some way of restricting the growth of second homes,&equo; said Mr Soley. 
 He said the demand for such a policy came from within planning circles and from some Conservative-controlled councils in the South-west, Cumbria and North Wales. 
 Under the Labour plans, property owners who wished to convert their house to second home status would need to secure planning permission first from the local council. 
 Similarly it would be stated in the estate agents' particulars whether permission had been granted for a house which is up for sale to be sold to someone who wanted to use it as a second home. 
 At present such change of use consent is needed to convert a house into an office. 
 &bquo;It would not be applied to someone who uses the house as their family home but works away from home for most of the week,&equo; said Mr Soley. 
 He added that in countries such as Italy the authorities charged double rates for the installation of such amenities as telephones, electricity and gas in second homes. 
 Mr John Wilkinson (C. Ruislip Northwood), who came sixth in the private members' bills ballot, yesterday announced a measure to make it obligatory to apply for planning permission before a dwelling house is demolished. 
 Mr Wilkinson, whose bill has a good chance of reaching the statute book, believes such a measure is necessary to curb growing surburban problem of overdevelopment through luxury blocks of flats being built by developers on plots previously occupied by a single house. 
 &pound;31m to assess doctors. 
 By David Brindle, Social Services Correspondent 
 MINISTERS yesterday announced that &pound;31 million will be available next year to develop computer systems to assess hospital doctors' success in treating patients. 
 Only &pound;2 million is being spent this financial year but Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, said the extra would do more for the quality of patient care than any other aspect of the Government's health reforms. 
 Under the scheme, doctors will enter details of patients, their illnesses, their treatments and the results. 
 The announcement came as ministers tried to head off criticism that the reforms fail to address quality of care. 
 Earlier yesterday Mr Clarke told a London conference of health authority leaders that the district authorities emerge from the reforms as the &bquo;patients&equo; friends&equo;, by assessing the health of their populations and meeting those needs when purchasing care from competing hospitals. 
 Mr Duncan Nichol, health service chief executive, said districts would in time need to draw up strategies for their populations, and specify measurable improvements. 
 The contracts between authorities and hospitals would not specify detailed quality criteria. 
 The &pound;31 million will finance micro-computer terminals, ultimately one for every four doctors, and an eventual 1,360 monitoring staff. 
 Consultants' leaders are expected today to agree how results will be given to hospital managers. 
 Patients' names will not be passed on, and Mr Clarke said disclosure to district authorities, to inform care purchasing, was &bquo;some way down the track&equo;. 
 Cuts in temporary nurses and overtime have been agreed by West Lambeth health authority, London, after its running deficit tripled to &pound;1.5 million in a month. 
 Welsh way to health, page 19 
 Artists record anthem to aid boat people 
 Seumas Milne 
 The campaign against the repatriation of Vietnamese refugees from Hong Kong has become the latest cause celebre in the ufdrop 
 ARECORD in the Band Aid tradition of charity singles is this week being recorded this week to raise money for the Vietnamese boat refugees facing repatriation from Hong Kong. 
 by a group of pop musicians under the banner of &bquo;Rock Against Repatriation.&equo; 
 The Bob Geldof of the &bquo;Rock Against Repatriation&equo; project is Steve Hackett, former Genesis ly guitarist, with who has assembled a group that includes ing Brian May of Queen, Mike Rutherford of Genesis, members of Tears for Fears and Marillion, Howard Jones and Bonnie Tyler to record Rod Stewart's 1970s hit, Sailing, made famous in the 1970s by and written by the Sutherland Brothers. 
 Recording begins in earnest today (thursday) in Peter Gabriel's studio in Bath, and and Hackett promises an &bquo;anthemic&equo; rendition. 
 But He says the record will be &bquo;less cameo-like and more cohesive&equo; than Geldof's Do They Know It's Christmas, Time, which ousted Paul McCartney to become the best-selling British record of all time in 1984. release is scheduled for mid-January. 
 The money is going to the British Refugee Council and the Save the Children Fund, but Hackett rules out giving passing any of the money to projects in Vietnam, where the refugee problem originates. 
 He also insists it Rock Against Repatriation will not be making just another showbiz charity record, but &bquo;This is going to be a protest record and a &bquo;symbol of hope&equo;. 
 Hackett says no other issue has ever touched him as deeply as the forced repatriation of the Vietnamese. 
 and that he has &bquo;nightmares of Red Guards beating people to death. 
 &bquo;Repatriation is evil, it smacks of the final solution. 
 Britain should find countries willing to take them,&equo; he said. 
 He believes that Britain should negotiate with other countries, the EEC and the United States, to take the Vietnamese. 
 &bquo;I see that Paraguay has offered to take all of them and the Pope is on our side now.&equo; 
 no ufend 
 Barlow Clowes investors win &pound;150m payout. 
 By Daniel John and Alan Travis 
 THE Government yesterday agreed to pay &pound;150 million in compensation to the investors of the failed Barlow Clowes group after it was castigated for &bquo;substantial maladministration&equo; by the Parliamentary Ombudsman over its handling of the affair. 
 In a decision which surprised MPs and investors, the Trade Secretary, Mr Nicholas Ridley, told the Commons that the bulk of the 18,000 investors are to get nearly 90 per cent of their money back in an unprecedented state payout. 
 However, Mr Ridley said the Government disagreed with the five main findings of Sir Anthony Barrowclough, the Parliamentary Commissioner for Administration, whose 170-page report was released yesterday after a 13-month investigation. 
 Neither was the Government legally liable to pay compensation, he said. 
 But given the &bquo;exceptional circumstances&equo; and &bquo;out of respect&equo; for the Ombudsman, substantial tax-free payments would be made. 
 The decision means those who invested up to &pound;50,000 will get 90 per cent of their money, those who put in between &pound;50,000 and &pound;100,000 will receive 80 per cent, and those over &pound;100,000 will get 60 per cent. 
 No distinction will be made between the two funds involved even though one of them was not the responsibility of the Department of Trade and Industry. 
 Only 255 investors put in more than &pound;50,000, while 70 invested more than &pound;100,000. 
 The department will now take charge of the legal battle to recover the Barlow Clowes funds and that money will offset the payouts. 
 Mr Ridley said the action would be pursued with the utmost vigour. 
 Mr John Dyer, chairman of the Barlow Clowes Investors' Group, which was set up to fight for compensation, said: &bquo;I really think investors ought to be deeply grateful. 
 It could have been so much worse.&equo; 
 But he said the Government bore some responsibility for what had happened. 
 Labour's trade and industry spokesman, Mr Gordon Brown, asked how the Government could pay &pound;150 million in compensation and yet not even apologise for its mistakes. 
 He said it was not the small investor but the &bquo;fecklessness, gullibility, and incompetence of the Government, which for months and for years, ignored all the warnings. 
 Who in the Government intends to take responsibility for this negligence on a vast scale, that is now costing vast sums of public money?&equo; 
 Barlow Clowes collapsed in June 1988 putting at risk &pound;190 million of investors' money. 
 Since then, liquidators have recovered &pound;60 million and paid &pound;34 million to investors in the UK business, Barlow Clowes Gilt Managers. 
 But 11,000 people who invested in the Gibraltar-based Barlow Clowes International, and who faced losses of up to &pound;100 million, have yet to receive anything. 
 Seven people, including Mr Peter Clowes, former head of Barlow Clowes, face criminal charges as a result of the firm's collapse. 
 The smaller British fund had been licensed to operate by the DTI since 1985 and it had known about the business as far back as 1975. 
 It received a licence despite warnings from the Bank of England, the International Stock Exchange and Nasdim, a City regulatory body. 
 Sir Anthony launched his investigation last November following complaints by MPs and after an independent report into the DTI's role by the former Monopolies Commission chairman, Sir Godfray Le Quesne, which the then Trade Secretary, Lord Young, concluded cleared his department of any responsibility. 
 The Ombudsman found that the DTI committed errors in its advice to Barlow Clowes back in 1976 and if it had applied for a licence then it would not have been granted one. 
 He also ruled that if the DTI 
 Turn to page 20, column 3 
 Barlow Clowes investors to receive &pound;150m compensation continued from page one had properly investigated an obscure Jersey partnership which had been licensed then it would have established a link between it and Barlow Clowes. 
 The Jersey operation turned out to be run by Peter Clowes and operated one of the controversial offshore investment portfolios which later collapsed. 
 If the link had been spotted, Sir Anthony concluded, Barlow Clowes's operations would have been halted in 1984. 
 This would have prevented the loss of nearly three-quarters of the money. 
 Faults were found in the DTI's procedures involving the scrutiny of an auditor's report of Barlow Clowes's funds. 
 Sir Anthony, who recommended full compensation, concluded: &bquo;A regulatory agency ought to my mind, by definition, to adopt a rigorous and enquiring approach as regards material coming into its possession concerning an undertaking about which suspicions have been aroused. 
 &bquo;It was, in my view, the lack of a sufficiently rigorous and enquiring approach which led not only to the failure to appreciate that there was a Jersey partnership but also to some others of the faults I have identified.&equo; 
 Mr Ridley defended the DTI's handling of the case and insisted it was &bquo;within the acceptable range of standards reasonably to be expected of a regulator&equo;. 
 Details, page 11; City Notebook, page 10; Leader comment, page 18 
 Critics tone down attacks on legal reform plans. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 LEGAL peers renewed their attack on the Government's plans to shake up the legal profession yesterday, when the Courts and Legal Services Bill had its second reading in the Lords. 
 But criticism of the package, which will end the barristers' monopoly right to appear in the higher courts and transfer a huge chunk of the High Court's caseload to the county courts, was considerably less strident than when the original green paper proposals were debated last April. 
 Opening the debate yesterday, Lord Mackay said the bill's key aims were to ensure a voice for the users of legal services, and to make sure that decision-takers on legal services were answerable and took their decisions with the benefit of full and considered advice. 
 The proposals included a vital role for the judiciary in framing rules for advocates and preserved the independence of the legal profession, he said. 
 The bill gives four senior judges and the Lord Chancellor a veto over rules for solicitor advocates. 
 The judges must take account of advice from a lay-dominated advisory committee and the Director-General of Fair Trading. 
 Any judge refusing to approve the rules will have to give written reasons and can be challenged. 
 Lord Donaldson, Master of the Rolls, and Lord Lane, Lord Chief Justice, two of the four senior judges with a veto, criticised the role given to them by the bill. 
 Lord Donaldson described the measure as &bquo;fatally flawed&equo; and attacked the framework for consultation and approval of the rules as a &bquo;choreographed quadrille&equo;. 
 Lord Lane called for centralised control of advocates' conduct, enforced by the judges. 
 The bill proposes enforcement by barristers' and solicitors' separate professional bodies. 
 Lord Lane also launched a strong attack on the crisis in the crown and county courts. 
 In many cases morale had collapsed through underfunding. 
 &bquo;It is a misleading fantasy to suggest that part I of the bill can be implemented when the infrastructure of the courts is crumbling,&equo; he said. 
 Lord Mishcon, Labour spokesman on legal affairs, described the situation in the county courts as &bquo;ludicrous&equo;. 
 The Lord Chancellor's Department had twice the rate of resignations of any other government department, he said. 
 Lord Hailsham, a former Lord Chancellor, said it was paradoxical that a Government dedicated to privatisation should produce a bill whose object was to nationalise the judiciary and the legal profession. 
 Former Attorney General Lord Rawlinson said the reforms would lead to the destruction of the independent bar. 
 Artists record anthem to aid boat people. 
 By Seumas Milne. 
 ARECORD in the Band Aid tradition of charity singles is being recorded this week to raise money for the Vietnamese boat refugees facing repatriation from Hong Kong. 
 The Bob Geldof of the &bquo;Rock Against Repatriation&equo; project is Steve Hackett, former Genesis guitarist, who has assembled a group that includes Brian May of Queen, Mike Rutherford of Genesis, members of Tears for Fears and Marillion, Howard Jones and Bonnie Tyler to record Rod Stewart's 1970s hit, Sailing. 
 Recording begins today in Peter Gabriel's studio in Bath, and release is scheduled for mid-January. 
 The money is going to the British Refugee Council and the Save the Children Fund, but Hackett rules out giving any to projects in Vietnam, where the refugee problem originates. 
 He also insists it will not be just another showbiz charity record, but a protest record and a &bquo;symbol of hope&equo;. 
 &bquo;Repatriation is evil, it smacks of the final solution. 
 Britain should find countries willing to take them,&equo; he said. 
 Prince scorns new Bible and service in attack on &bquo;dismal&equo; use of English. 
 By Joanna Coles 
 THE Prince of Wales renewed his criticism of English teaching in schools yesterday and declared the English language had declined into a &bquo;dismal wasteland of banality, cliche and casual obscenity&equo;. 
 He said he deplored &bquo;the abandonment of learning the rules of grammar by rote&equo; and stressed that higher standards of literacy were needed if Britain was to compete in an increasingly competitive world. 
 Teachers needed to give pupils &bquo;a vision of greatness&equo;, he added. 
 &bquo;If we encourage the use of mean, trite, ordinary language we encourage a mean, trite, ordinary world.&equo; 
 The prince aroused anger among teachers last June when he attacked the teaching of English, claiming that many of his own staff could not write properly. 
 But yesterday he acknowledged the role of teachers. 
 &bquo;I do not envy the task that teachers have, particularly in inner-city schools. 
 They need our sympathy in an exhausting task.&equo; 
 However, it was the New English Bible and the Church of England's Alternative Service which took the brunt of the prince's speech as he presented the Thomas Cranmer Schools prize, sponsored jointly by the Spectator and the Prayer Book Society, at St James's Church, Garlickhythe, in the City. 
 The former was written in the style of an internal memo while the latter was crass and patronising, he said. 
 How can we expect to be lifted by the language of prayer &bquo;if the sentence itself needs to be lifted &mdash; by a stretcher?&equo; he asked. 
 The editors of the NEB patronised congregations by assuming that God was over their heads. 
 But God is supposed to be over our heads &mdash; that is the whole point, he said. 
 Stressing the need for the rich cadences and rhythms of the Book of Common Prayer, he said people loved them because they could remember them in times of crisis. 
 The prince compared the King James version of &bquo;Harken to my words&equo; with its modern equivalent &bquo;Give me a hearing&equo;. 
 &bquo;It might be accessible for all, but so is a desert,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We have rejected quality in expression, just as we have rejected quality in the buildings in which we work and educate.&equo; 
 The prince stressed that Britain had produced the world's most successful language but, as its use in the media and theatres showed, it had become impoverished, sloppy and limited. 
 He proffered a modern translation of Hamlet's &bquo;To be, or not to be&equo;. 
 It ran: &bquo;Well, frankly, the problem as I see it at this moment in time is whether I should just lie down under all this hassle&hellip; 
 I mean, let's face it&hellip; know what I mean?&equo; 
 Mr Doug McAvoy, general secretary of the National Union of Teachers, welcomed the prince's apparent support. 
 &bquo;Teachers alone cannot tackle the problems of society including the standards of literacy,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They have to deal with what comes through the school gates. 
 &bquo;Unlike architects, teachers don't choose the material and resources they have to work with. 
 I urge the prince to lead a partnership between teachers and parents.&equo; 
 Mr David Hebblethwaite, secretary of the Liturgical Commission which helped produce the Alternative Service, said that if one translated the service back into the language of even 50 years ago, it would be &bquo;pretty incomprehensible&equo;. 
 &bquo;Certainly no one sets out to be patronising. 
 It depends on who's hearing it, but no one intended that,&equo; he said. 
 The Bishop of St Albans, the Rt Rev John Taylor, said he agreed with the prince about the beauty of Cranmer's language. 
 &bquo;But that is a quite separate issue from the Alternative Services book which is an alternative way of enabling congregations who have not been well versed in Cranmerian language nevertheless to use a language which does reflect their longings and their prayers and can speak to them of God.&equo; 
 Schools &bquo;need &pound;1.1 billion for repairs&equo; next year. 
 By Celia Weston 
 LOCAL education authorities want to spend more than &pound;1 billion on school repairs next year, three times the amount allocated for this year, the Labour Party said yesterday. 
 Mr John MacGregor, the Education Secretary, intends to announce the capital allocation to LEAs this week. 
 Mr Jack Straw, the shadow education secretary, said a Commons written answer from Mr MacGregor disclosed that England's 96 LEAs want permission to spend about &pound;1.1 billion next year on state schools and &pound;150 million on voluntary-aided schools. 
 Last year capital spending was &pound;313 million, &pound;220 million below its 1979 level, Mr Straw said. 
 Labour claims that central government capital spending on schools has been cut by 29 per cent in real terms since 1979, while LEA spending has been squeezed mercilessly. 
 The Department of Education and Science has estimated that state schools have a &pound;3 billion backlog of repairs. 
 LEAs had asked for &pound;34 million for this year but were allocated &pound;13.6 million. 
 Labour has pledged to cancel the City Technology College programme to release &pound;100 million immediately for repair and decoration of dilapidated schools. 
 It wants a commitment from Mr MacGregor to show no favouritism in distributing the &pound;118 million earmarked in the autumn statement for building grants to voluntary-aided and opted-out schools. 
 MPs question &pound;11m dons' pay waste. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 UNIVERSITY administrators who wasted &pound;11.3 million of taxpayers' money by re-employing more than 200 redundant academics given &bquo;golden goodbyes&equo; averaging &pound;80,000 each are to be summoned by the Commons public accounts committee to explain their mistakes. 
 The decision follows the disclosure in the Guardian on Monday of payments to 231 lecturers and professors which were in breach of Treasury regulations in a routine audit of the Department of Education's accounts. 
 MPs have decided to call Sir Peter Swinnerton-Dyer, chief executive of the Universities Funding Council, and Mr John Caines, permanent secretary at the DoE, to a hearing on February 28. 
 A report from Mr John Bourn, the Comptroller and Auditor General, to the committee recommended the hearing. 
 The mistakes follow a check by the National Audit Office, Parliament's financial watchdog. 
 This revealed that the University Grants Committee, the UFC's predecessor, had breached Treasury rules in allowing 20 universities to re-employ the lecturers and professors who had benefited from a &pound;130 million early retirement programme. 
 The programme was part of a restructuring of university staff to prepare for a new market environment. 
 A total of 1,500 academics teaching subjects no longer in demand were offered generous compensation to retire early, while 1,000 new staff in more popular subjects were to be appointed. 
 The 231 staff were re-employed indefinitely &mdash; at cost of &pound;50,000 each &mdash; some doing less work for the same money. 
 MPs are also to summon Sir Clive Whitmore, Permanent Secretary at the Home Office, to explain repeated failures by his ministry to curb TV licence evasion. 
 The hearing, on January 31, comes after a critical analysis by the NAO of the Home Office's record in combatting evasion. 
 Last year the ministry claimed it had made progress, only to find it had to revise its figures to reveal no progress had been made for five years. 
 Fresh investigations by the NAO to be published early next year include comparisons between private hospitals and the NHS; the privatisation of British Steel; the sale of the National Bus Company and the effectiveness of invalidity benefits. 
 Special investigations have also been carried out into British aid for India and the payment of pensions in Gibraltar. 
 Russia warns on German unity hopes. 
 By John Palmer in Brussels 
 THE Soviet Foreign Minister, Mr Eduard Shevardnadze, yesterday warned that demands for a rapid unification of Germany and the rise of rightwing German nationalism could threaten the peace and stability of Europe. 
 He implied that a united Germany might have to wait on an end to the division of Europe. 
 Mr Shevardnadze told members of the European Parliament that while the German people had the right to self-determination there would have to be &bquo;political, legal and material guarantees that German unity would not eventually create a threat to the national security of other states and to peace in Europe&equo;. 
 In what was seen as an important statement of Soviet foreign policy in the face of growing demands for German reunification, Mr Shevardnadze posed seven questions which would have to be answered before it was &bquo;possible realistically to raise the issue&hellip; of re-establishing German unity&equo;. 
 He suggested that a start to answering these questions should be made at a 35-nation European summit, under the auspices of the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe, which the Soviet Union has suggested be brought forward towards the end of next year. 
 The seven questions were: What guarantees would there be that a united Germany would not threaten security and peace in Europe?; 
 Would &bquo;such a hypothetical Germany&equo; accept its existing borders?; 
 What would be the place of a united Germany in relation to the cold war alliances?; 
 Would a united Germany accept demilitarisation and &bquo;adopt a neutral status?&equo;; 
 Would allied soldiers remain on German soil?; 
 How would a united Germany fit in with the attempt through the Helsinki process to end the division of Europe?; and, would the new Germany take into account the interests of others in concluding a European peace settlement? 
 The Soviet Foreign Minister left no doubt about his concern that some West German politicians might compromise the right of the GDR to self-determination by &bquo;offering prescriptions as to how and when to change the GDR system&equo;. 
 He said this campaign raised &bquo;doubts about the authenticity of the eventual allegedly free choice&equo;. 
 Speaking at a press conference later about the Bonn government's attitude to accepting existing borders and renouncing any territorial claims, he pointed an accusing figure at Chancellor Helmut Kohl for his recent plan for reunification. 
 This he unfavourably contrasted to recent statements by the West German Foreign Minister, Mr Hans-Dietrich Genscher, accepting the inviolability of Germany's borders, notably the Oder-Neisse frontier with Poland. 
 Mr Shevardnadze deplored the fact that Germany's pre-1937 borders had not yet been &bquo;legally disbanded&equo;. 
 In an apparent reference to recent demands by German nationalists and neo-fascists for one state with Germany's pre-1937 borders, he warned against &bquo;certain signs of political extremism, one that would ignore political realities and the historic memory of hundreds of millions of people&equo;. 
 Anticipating his discussions in London later yesterday with Mrs Thatcher, the Soviet Foreign Minister said that the four Berlin powers had a continuing responsibility to preserve peace in Europe. 
 &bquo;Surely the peoples of the Soviet Union are entitled to know what any changes in central Europe would mean for their future and their security. 
 We paid the price of 20 million lives for the existing European stability.&equo; 
 Aware of the concern felt by many in his audience of European parliamentarians about the potential power of a united Germany, Mr Shevardnadze went out of his way to express agreement with President Franois Mitterrand that &bquo;no European country can act without due regard for the European balance, without taking into account the interests of others and the existing historical situation that resulted from the second world war&equo;. 
 Before addressing the European Parliament, Mr Shevardnadze paid an unprecented visit to Nato headquarters in Brussels. 
 Text of the statement, page 8 
 Government faces compensation claims over EC deal Fishing quotas &bquo;may halve Scottish fleet&equo;. 
 By Alan Hope in Brussels 
 AN AGREEMENT on fishing quotas reached by EC ministers yesterday could push half of Scotland's fleet to bankruptcy, Scottish Fishermen's Federation chief executive, Mr Bob Allan, said. 
 The Agriculture Minister, Mr John Gummer, and the Scottish Secretary, Mr Malcolm Rifkind, celebrated the small gains they had been able to negotiate, but admitted that the industry in Britain faced a tough time in the coming year. 
 The agreement, reached after 26 hours of talks in Brussels, will reduce British quotas for haddock and cod in the North Sea. 
 The result will be drastic cutbacks for East Coast fishermen, most of them in Scotland. 
 The industry would seek compensation from the Government for the effects of the quota cuts, Mr Allan said. 
 In Scotland about half of the 600 boats currently operating could be severely affected. 
 &bquo;The figures don't constitute more than about six months of real and viable fishing for our fleet,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;What has happened is that we have been clawed back from the disastrous level of whitefish we started at to a position in line with the top end of scientific advice.&equo; 
 The haddock quota for 1990 was set at 36,280 tonnes compared with 54,400 tonnes this year. 
 The final result is better than the 32,000 tonnes originally proposed by the Commission and is the maximum catch recommended by scientists to stop fish stocks disappearing. 
 Mr Gummer's determination to win the highest figures advised by the scientists failed for the North Sea cod quota. 
 Britain will have 46,180 tonnes in 1990, compared to 55,600 this year. 
 Scientists had recommended a maximum of 47,400 tonnes. 
 Mr Gummer claimed he had won the best deal possible. 
 &bquo;There was no way we could come back to fishermen without the maximum available.&equo; 
 He denied suggestions that the quotas would mean an immediate rise in fish prices: &bquo;There is no automatic relationship between this agreement and the price of fish.&equo; 
 The junior fisheries minister, Mr David Curry said: &bquo;What we have agreed today is designed to ensure that there still are some fish left in 10 years time.&equo; 
 The Government rejected attempts by the Fisheries Commissioner in Brussels, Mr Manuel Marin, to take control of parts of national quota management. 
 One measure would have forced British haddock fishing boats to lie idle for 10 days every month. 
 Another would have forced fishing for whiting and saithe to stop in the North Sea when the haddock and cod quotas were exhausted. 
 The Government and the British industry saw these proposals as an intrusion into national decision making. 
 While the Government supported the ideas behind the proposals, Mr Gummer said Britain preferred to take its own management decisions in co-operation with the industry. 
 Britain won a concession over mackerel fishing in western waters. 
 Because of the migration of mackerel over the notional dividing line between eastern and western zones, British fishermen had been faced with dwindling numbers of a healthy species. 
 British boats will now be able to take 28,000 tonnes of mackerel to the west of their own zone. 
 But Mr Rifkind appeared to rule out the scheme to pay fishermen to leave the industry. 
 A previous scheme had not worked, he said, and had been the subject of a scathing report from the Commons Public Accounts Committee. 
 &bquo;We would be very reluctant to go down that road again,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That is tremendously bad news,&equo; said Mr Allan. 
 &bquo;Market forces will never take care of an industry as special as fishing.&equo; 
 Tory MP found dead in car. 
 By Paul Hoyland, Michael White and Alan Travis 
 MR JOHN Heddle, the Conservative MP for Mid Staffordshire, was found dead in his car yesterday at a chalk pit near Canterbury, Kent. 
 A hose pipe was connected to the exhaust. 
 police said there were no suspicious circumstances. 
 The Conservative chairman, Mr Kenneth Baker, said last night: &bquo;He was a loyal and hard-working member of the party and a loyal and good friend.&equo; 
 At Westminster MPs were astonished at the apparent suicide of a seemingly outgoing colleague with no problems. 
 Speculation about his death centred most persistently on financial worries. 
 Mr Heddle was a former surveyor and an underwriting member of Lloyds. 
 He had several directorships and property interests. 
 Mr John Brown, the Conservative agent for the West Midlands, said he had heard rumours about financial difficulties yesterday: &bquo;I do not know if there is any truth in them, and I cannot react.&equo; 
 Mr Heddle, aged 48, was due to appear in court in Spain over a parking dispute while in Benidorm in May. 
 Police said he acted like a lager lout and hit an officer. 
 The MP vigorously denied assault and said he had been struck by the officer. 
 He said he would return to answer all charges. 
 The prosecution had sought a one-year prison sentence, to be suspended. 
 Mr Philip Jones, his constituency chairman, said yesterday that he did not believe the case worried him. 
 Mr Heddle had been MP for Mid Staffordshire since 1983, with a majority of 14,654 in 1987. 
 He was chairman of the Tory backbench environment committee. 
 He and his first wife, Judith, who died last year, had four children. 
 The marriage was dissolved in 1985, and in 1986 Mr Heddle married his second wife, Janet. 
 Mr Heddle lived at Hawkhurst, Kent, and had a constituency home in Lichfield. 
 Mr Jones said that his party and constituents would miss a &bquo;hard working and deeply caring Member of Parliament&equo;. 
 The present constituency, redrawn in 1983 from the former Labour seat of Lichfield and Tamworth which Mr Heddle won in 1979, showed a strong swing toward Labour in the May council elections. 
 John Heddle&hellip; faced court appearance in Spain 
 Parking ban mars solstice tradition. 
 By Owen Bowcott 
 TOMORROW'S dawn celebration of the winter solstice at Stonehenge may attract up to 1,000 travellers. 
 Traditionally it is a peaceful event, without confrontation between police and what they describe as the hippy convoy. 
 This year the Wiltshire County Council has closed Larkhill Track, an old drove road near the stones where many travellers park their vans. 
 English Heritage has agreed to open Stonehenge from about 6am for the sunrise, but is closing the car park. 
 Both bodies fear that the travellers, once established near the stones, may not move on. 
 &bquo;The solstice is the natural rhythm of the planet,&equo; said Mr Alex Rosenburger, editor of Festival Eye and a member of Travellers Aid Trust, yesterday. 
 He believed that many legitimate visitors would be forced to park on the main road because the council had closed the track. 
 &bquo;They fear loads of hippies going with cans of Special Brew, but that's not true,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Rosenburger was recently acquitted on a charge of breaching the peace, having read out extracts from the Universal Declaration of Human Rights outside Salisbury Cathedral in the summer. 
 His protest was directed at the midsummer's day four-mile &bquo;exclusion zone&equo; at Stonehenge, imposed by Salisbury District Council and confirmed by the Home Secretary. 
 The trust, a charity which helps those who describe themselves as &bquo;New Age Travellers&equo;, plans to appeal against the convictions and average fines of &pound;50 plus costs imposed on 65 of the 130 would-be visitors who were arrested and charged with public order offences. 
 The trust aims to challenge the legality of the exclusion order, made under the 1986 Public Order Act, deeming two or more people walking towards the stones to be a criminal procession. 
 Mr Don Aitken, a trust member, said it hoped to bring a test case. 
 Arts, ReviewsWS27. 
 CartoonsWS29. 
 Classified AdvertisingWS22-25. 
 CrosswordsWS20, 29. 
 Financial NewsWS10-12. 
 Guardian SocietyWS21, 23. 
 Guardian WomenWS28. 
 Home NewsWS2-4, 20. 
 International NewsWS8, 9. 
 Law ReportWS29. 
 LettersWS18. 
 ListingsWS26. 
 ObituaryWS29. 
 PoliticsWS6. 
 Sports NewsWS14-16. 
 Young GuardianWS17. 
 TV, Radio and WeatherWS30 
 Mother's body kept in kitchen for three years. 
 AWOMAN kept her mother's body hidden among rubbish in her kitchen for almost three years, an inquest heard yesterday. 
 Miss Norma Scott, aged 23, failed to report her mother's death because she did not want the council to discover the squalid conditions at her home in Bilsmoor Avenue, Newcastle upon Tyne. 
 She did not even tell her father, John, aged 76, of his wife's death. 
 He never found her body as the kitchen was barricaded and he was afraid of dogs his daughter kept. 
 The death of Mrs Norma Scott, aged 54, in October 1986, came to light on September 7, when Newcastle council called in workmen to clear the rubbish as part of a scheme to upgrade houses in the area. 
 Her skeletal remains were found then. 
 Details of the police inquiry into the death were given by acting inspector David Hall at the resumed inquest in Newcastle. 
 He said that after 1983, Mrs Scott and her daughter decided to live in the kitchen with the dogs &mdash; which were never let out of the house &mdash; to stop them fighting. 
 Daughter Norma slept on the floor and her mother, virtually housebound because of varicose veins, in a bed. 
 The mother's health deteriorated and she died in the bed. 
 The next morning, her daughter covered the body with bedclothes and made a barrier, with fencing from the garden, to stop the dogs &bquo;interfering&equo; with it. 
 She then carried on &bquo;as normal&equo;, even buying dressings for her mother's legs so her father would not know she had died, Mr Hall said. 
 When her father, a retired civil servant, asked her about his wife's condition, she would reply: &bquo;The same as usual.&equo; 
 He eventually stopped inquiring. 
 Mr Hall said Norma had become &bquo;rather a recluse&equo;, hiding the death from everyone. 
 &bquo;She began to pile up empty tins and rubbish against the fencing until her mother's body was completely covered.&equo; 
 During 1986, Mr Scott did once enter the kitchen, and when he did not see his wife assumed she was visiting relatives. 
 Mr Hall said Miss Scott had explained she did not give notification of her mother's death because she was afraid the authorities would discover the conditions in which they had been living. 
 The inquest heard she had spent time in council care as a child and feared something similar might happen again. 
 She knew she ought to report the death, but felt she could not because of the passage of time. 
 Mr Hall stressed there was nothing to suggest anything sinister about Mrs Scott's death. 
 The Crown Prosecution Service planned no action. 
 Before the death there were up to 15 dogs in the house, as the family's bitch produced two litters which were both kept &mdash; one set in the kitchen, and the other in a bedroom. 
 At the time of the discovery, five were left. 
 They were destroyed by the RSPCA. 
 Miss Scott and her father are now being cared for by Newcastle social services in a home for vulnerable people. 
 However, she attended the hearing and told the coroner she agreed with the police report. 
 A pathologist told the inquest it was impossible to say what caused Mrs Scott's death. 
 Summing up, the coroner praised the police for their investigation of what he described as &bquo;a most unhappy and distressing case&equo;. 
 As there was no medical evidence on the cause of death, he recorded an open verdict. 
 Prince tilts at new Bible and service in attack on &bquo;dismal&equo; use of English. 
 By Joanna Coles 
 THE Prince of Wales renewed his condemnation of English teaching in schools yesterday and declared the English language had declined into a &bquo;dismal wasteland of banality, cliche and casual obscenity&equo;. 
 He said he deplored &bquo;the abandonment of learning the rules of grammar by rote&equo; and stressed that higher standards of literacy were needed if Britain was to compete in an increasingly competitive world. 
 Teachers needed to give pupils &bquo;a vision of greatness&equo;, he added. 
 &bquo;If we encourage the use of mean, trite, ordinary language we encourage a mean, trite, ordinary world.&equo; 
 The prince aroused anger among teachers last June when he attacked the teaching of English, claiming that many of his own staff could not write properly. 
 But yesterday he acknowledged the role of teachers. 
 &bquo;I do not envy the task that teachers have, particularly in inner-city schools. 
 They need our sympathy in an exhausting task.&equo; 
 However, it was the New English Bible and the Church of England's Alternative Service which took the brunt of the prince's speech as he presented the Thomas Cranmer Schools prize, sponsored jointly by the Spectator and the Prayer Book Society, at St James's Church, Garlickhythe, in the City. 
 The former was written in the style of an internal memo while the latter was crass and patronising, he said. 
 How can we expect to be lifted by the language of prayer &bquo;if the sentence itself needs to be lifted &mdash; by a stretcher?&equo; he asked. 
 The editors of the NEB patronised congregations by assuming that God was over their heads. 
 But God is supposed to be over our heads &mdash; that is the whole point, he said. 
 Stressing the need for the rich cadences and rhythms of the Book of Common Prayer, he said people loved them because they could remember them in times of crisis. 
 The prince compared the King James version of &bquo;Harken to my words&equo; with its modern equivalent &bquo;Give me a hearing&equo;. 
 &bquo;It might be accessible for all, but so is a desert,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We have rejected quality in expression, just as we have rejected quality in the buildings in which we work and educate.&equo; 
 The prince stressed that Britain had produced the world's most successful language but as its use in the media and theatres showed, it had become impoverished, sloppy and limited. 
 He proffered a modern translation of Hamlet's &bquo;To be, or not to be&equo;. 
 It ran: &bquo;Well, frankly, the problem as I see it at this moment in time is whether I should just lie down under all this hassle&hellip; 
 I mean, let's face it&hellip; 
 You know what I mean?&equo; 
 Mr Doug McAvoy, general secretary of the National Union of Teachers, welcomed the prince's apparent support. 
 &bquo;Teachers alone cannot tackle the problems of society including the standards of literacy,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They have to deal with what comes through the school gates. 
 &bquo;Unlike architects, teachers don't choose the material and resources they have to work with. 
 I urge the prince to lead a partnership between teachers and parents.&equo; 
 Mr David Hebblethwaite, secretary of the Liturgical Commission which helped produce the Alternative Service, said that if one translated the service back into the language of even 50 years ago, it would be &bquo;pretty incomprehensible&equo;. 
 &bquo;Certainly no one sets out to be patronising. 
 It depends on who's hearing it, but no one intended that. 
 Cranmer's England was far more structured,&equo; he said. 
 Demo police win ban on prosecution. 
 SEVEN police officers charged after a demonstration at Mr Rupert Murdoch's News International headquarters in Wapping, east London, won their attempt yesterday to halt criminal proceedings against them. 
 The Director of Public Prosecutions, Mr Allan Green, QC, failed to overturn a magistrate's decision not to prosecute six of the officers, charged with conspiring to pervert the course of justice. 
 Lord Justice Watkins and Mr Justice Garland, sitting in the High Court, dismissed Mr Green's application to quash the ruling, made in May by Mr Ronald Bartle, a Bow Street stipendiary magistrate. 
 Mr Bartle had ruled the delay in notifying Sergeant Robert Goodger and Constables Ian Storrar, Nigel Pratt, Gavin Steff, Terence Chitty and Ivan Szubin of the allegation, and delay in bringing the prosecution was prejudicial and an abuse of the court process. 
 Lord Justice Watkins said Mr Bartle applied his mind to the correct principles of law and applied them in a manner which could not be faulted. 
 The judges also allowed an application by PC Russell Cherry, charged with wounding a man he arrested during the dispute, for an order quashing a decision by another Bow Street magistrate, Mr Geoffrey Wicks, to proceed with his committal. 
 They said Mr Wicks's decision was based on the flawed findings that the delay was justifiable and there was no prejudice. 
 The demonstration, in January 1987, followed the sacking of print workers by Mr Murdoch's newspaper group in its move from Fleet Street. 
 More than 15,000 protesters and 1,000 police were involved. 
 Mr Mike Bennett, chairman of the Metropolitan branch of the Police Federation, said last night: &bquo;I just hope that the honourable thing is done in relation to the 18 other officers who are still to come before the magistrate on January 25.&equo; 
 Lord Justice Watkins said that in the case of the six officers, where two years &mdash; less 12 days &mdash; elapsed before the officers were summonsed, Mr Bartle exercised his discretion &bquo;without any flaw&equo;. 
 He was acquainted with the facts, had the benefit of much of the argument later addressed to the High Court, and preferred the submissions made to him by counsel for the officers. 
 &bquo;Those submissions have been amplified impressively before us. 
 We have found them compelling,&equo; the judge said. 
 In relation to PC Cherry, who had to wait the same period before being summonsed, Lord Justice Watkins said the delay after April 1987, when there was ample evidence to sustain a prima facie case against him, was &bquo;undoubtedly extreme&equo;. 
 He was not persuaded by the argument that the only way the inquiry could be properly conducted was to see the whole picture before making any final decision on an individual case. 
 &bquo;The mere fact that more than a thousand police officers know that their conduct is under investigation can, it seems to us, in no sense diminish the prejudice suffered by a particular officer against whom there was a prima facie case of the commission of a criminal offence at a very early stage of that investigation.&equo; 
 Ms Brenda Dean, general secretary of Sogat (Society of Graphical and Alled Trades) said: &bquo;The decision will give the green light to a small minority of cynical police officers, encouraging them to build in unnecessary delays when they are investigating their own.&equo; 
 Brandenburg to reopen before Christmas. 
 By Anna Tomforde and Michael Farr in Dresden 
 IN A gesture symbolic of the new relationship cemented in Dresden yesterday between East and West Germany, the leaders of the two countries announced that the Brandenburg Gate in Berlin would be opened before Christmas, probably on Saturday. 
 Chancellor Helmut Kohl and the East German Prime Minister, Mr Hans Modrow, said that, from Christmas Eve, West Germans would be able to cross without visas. 
 The two leaders will meet at the gate on Saturday. 
 Chancellor Kohl, on his first official visit to East Germany, was mobbed in the centre of Dresden by a crowd of several thousand shouting: &bquo;Germany, Germany&equo;, &bquo;Helmut, Helmut,&equo; and &bquo;Germany united Fatherland&equo;. 
 Minutes before Dr Kohl arrived at the Palace of Culture, the brass band on the Christmas market opposite played to the waiting crowd: &bquo;See the conquering hero comes,&equo; from Handel's Judas Maccabaeus. 
 But both Dr Kohl and Mr Modrow, aware that the hopes of many for reunification are growing by the day, and more quickly than the politicians can accommodate, tried to cool expectations. 
 A joint statement released after the first day of the summit stressed that both Germanys had to act responsibly, and take into account the concerns and interests of their neighbours and allies in East and West. 
 &bquo;We should show understanding for the fear of our neighbours; we should take them seriously,&equo; Dr Kohl told the West German flag-waving crowd outside the Church of Our Lady, left in ruins by the Anglo-American air raids of February, 1945. 
 &bquo;Self-determination is the right of all people in the world, including Germans, but it only makes sense when one does not lose sight of the concerns of others&hellip; we are coming to the end of a century which has seen the special responsibility of Germans for some terrible things.&equo; 
 But he added: &bquo;My goal remains &mdash; when the historic moment comes &mdash; the unity of the nation.&equo; 
 The joint statement underlined the importance of good neighbourly relations between the two German states for the stability of Europe and their contribution to a &bquo;new European architecture&equo;. 
 But Mr Modrow, who emphasised the need for East Germany to exist as a separate state, said he and Dr Kohl agreed that a stable East Germany was an important precondition for peace and co-operation in Europe. 
 But the cautious words of the politicians were taken further by an impatient crowd, demanding: &bquo;Helmut and Hans, make Germany one again.&equo; 
 There were also some aggressive shouts of &bquo;Down with the Communist Party&equo;, &bquo;Reds out&equo; and occasionally, &bquo;Russians out&equo; from mostly young supporters of the Right, a number of whom had travelled to Dresden for the occasion. 
 But on the whole, the several thousand, out of Dresden's total population of 520,000, who came to cheer Dr Kohl, represented a cross section of East German society, young and old. 
 The numbers swelled later as people streamed to the Neumarkt square after work to hear the Chancellor speaking in front of the church ruins. 
 Many brought with them East German flags from which they had cut out the hammer and compass, the Communist symbol. 
 Mr Modrow said he and Dr Kohl would be present at the opening of a pedestrian crossing through the Brandenburg Gate before Christmas. 
 More than any other landmark, the Brandenburg Gate, erected in 1794 as a triumphal arch, has come to symbolise the division between East and West. 
 The two leaders also agreed that visa and currency exchange-free travel to East Germany for West Germans and West Berliners, planned to come into force next January, would be brought forward to December 24. 
 Mr Modrow added that political prisoners held in East Germany would be released before Christmas in a further gesture of goodwill. 
 The two leaders will meet again at the end of January, and later to sign a treaty on co-operation and good neighbourly relations by next spring which is to cement what is being described as a &bquo;Treaty-based relationship.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, a joint economic commission would look into ways of economic and industrial co-operation. 
 PM quells Hong Kong row over passport quotas. 
 By Michael White and David Hencke 
 MRS Thatcher yesterday marshalled the Cabinet behind a Foreign Office plan to give full British passports to at least 50,000 of Hong Kong's leading figures and their families, despite the misgivings of the Home Secretary, Mr David Waddington, and other colleagues. 
 The bill is expected to sweep aside restrictions under the 1981 British Nationality Act which require six months prior residence before the granting of citizenship. 
 But confusion and uncertainty surrounding the Government's efforts to restore confidence in the colony are likely to continue after the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, makes his long-awaited statement to the Commons this afternoon. 
 Details of the legislation &mdash; including the points system whereby passports are allocated to senior Hong Kong government officials and businessmen &mdash; may not emerge until Easter. 
 Businessmen will get most passports, perhaps as much as two-thirds. 
 But no prospective beneficiary will be free to arrive until 1991 or later, raising private fears among some MPs that continued flight will mean a de facto Chinese takeover long before 1997. 
 Mr Waddington, a former immigration minister and rightwinger, seems to have gritted his teeth at yesterday's meeting and stood by the compromise hammered out at Mrs Thatcher's insistence in a cabinet committee. 
 Although she backed the plan to &bquo;keep Hong Kong prosperous&equo; until 1997 in the Commons yesterday, she let the Cabinet know she was displeased by the row. 
 But Mr Waddington's tone left colleagues in little doubt about his lack of enthusiasm about having to solve another minister's problems with legislation which will be attacked from all sides, including Tory rightwingers. 
 When MPs last night debated the related issue of compulsory repatriation of Vietnamese refugees from Hong Kong, they divided largely on party lines. 
 Some ministers, notably Mr Nicholas Ridley, registered scepticism about the wisdom of the scheme during the meeting and doubted their ability to sell it to MPs and voters. 
 It is intended to reassure key figures in Hong Kong that they have a &bquo;safety net&equo; and need not emigrate elsewhere if relations with China do not improve as the 1997 handover approaches. 
 But the changes to the immigration package made yesterday were minor. 
 One senior minister said: &bquo;There was nothing in it for the Right.&equo; 
 Discrepancies remained last night between the Foreign Office's emphasis on 50,000 heads of families involved and what looked like a Home Office attempt to put a ceiling of 200,000-225,000 on the total number. 
 Estimates of the family multiplier have ranged from 3.5 dependants per head of household to five, adding to uncertainty and the widespread backbench Tory hostility to the reopening of what one called &bquo;a hideous wave&equo; of immigration. 
 Ministers believe that with several months leeway, they can overcome public fears and backbench resentments sufficiently to reduce the potential Tory rebellion from 50-70 votes &mdash; which could spell defeat &mdash; to a manageable 20-30. 
 The package is expected to allow all Hong Kong residents who qualify &mdash; officials, security staff and leading businessmen &mdash; to be given automatic British residence status, although Whitehall is keen to avoid loopholes which other Commonwealth citizens might exploit. 
 Although some Tory rebels claim their constituents fear intolerable pressure on homes and social services, others agree with Labour that the scheme is elitist, unfair and unworkable. 
 However, one Tory loyalist said: &bquo;If Gerald Kaufman wants to form an alliance with Tim Janman (a rightwinger), good luck to him. 
 We will defeat the extremists.&equo; 
 The Liberal Democrats want twice as many admitted. 
 Their leader, Mr Paddy Ashdown, yesterday challenged Mrs Thatcher to ignore her own bigots and Labour's &bquo;moral bankruptcy.&equo; 
 But in last night's debate on the boat people, Labour's junior foreign affairs spokesman, Mr George Foulkes, denounced compulsory repatriation as despicable and heartless. 
 He called for international reconstruction of Vietnam's economy. 
 Politics, page 6; Lost passports, page 9 
 Aldington gets &pound;30,000 over Tolstoy book. 
 FORMER deputy Tory party chairman Lord Aldington yesterday accepted &pound;30,000 agreed High Court damages and a public apology over war crimes allegations from the publishers of historian Count Nikolai Tolstoy's book, The Minister and the Massacres. 
 The full details of the settlement, agreed in June, were kept secret until after the hearing of Lord Aldington's libel action against Count Tolstoy and property developer Nigel Watts over a pamphlet repeating the allegations. 
 Last month, after a nine-week trial, the peer was awarded &pound;1.5 million by a jury in that action. 
 However, yesterday's award is the first money the peer has received. 
 The &pound;1.5 million has been stayed pending a possible appeal. 
 It was said yesterday that the book's publishers, Century Hutchinson, accepted that the &bquo;very grave charges&equo; were &bquo;entirely untrue&equo;. 
 It had been alleged that the 75-year-old peer had in May 1945 defied orders, deceived superiors and conspired to bring about the tragedy which befell thousands of Cossacks and Yugoslavs, forcibly repatriated by British forces from Southern Austria to Soviet and Titoist forces. 
 Most of them were massacred or tortured on their return. 
 The peer's counsel, Mr Charles Gray QC, told Mr Justice Michael Davies in a statement in open court that the publishers had agreed to pay legal costs and not to repeat the allegations. 
 They accepted that there was no conspiracy. 
 Mr Gray said Century Hutchinson accepted that Lord Aldington was &bquo;a brave and dedicated officer with a deservedly distinguished war record and that at all times he was conscientiously seeking to implement the orders of higher commands without suspicion that atrocities would be committed by the Soviets and Titoists&equo;. 
 After the statement was read, Mr Justice Davies &mdash; also the trial judge in the pamphlet action &mdash; said it would have been unfair to Count Tolstoy and Mr Watts if the jury in the action against them had been told that &bquo;responsible publishers&equo; had already paid money into court and agreed to apologise and withdraw a book containing similar charges as those made in the pamphlet. 
 The judge went on: &bquo;The fact that there is a difference in the figures between the settlement in the book action and the jury in the pamphlet action will not surprise anyone familiar with all the circumstances. 
 &bquo;In so saying I express no view whatsover as to the correctness or otherwise of the jury's award&equo;. 
 Biologists iron out gene theory. 
 By Nigel Williams Science Correspondent 
 MODERN molecular biology has finally answered one of the most important questions thrown up by experiments in the last century on the nature of genetic inheritance. 
 A team led by Dr Cathie Martin at the John Innes Institute in Norwich, has isolated the gene which determines the &bquo;wrinkliness&equo; of peas. 
 The pattern of inheritance of this simple characteristic led the Moravian monk, Gregor Mendel, to one of the greatest insights in biology &mdash; character traits were not blended during passage from one generation to another but inherited as separate factors, later called genes. 
 Mendel had no idea how the genes made the peas become wrinkled. 
 But now, more than a century later, the Norwich team has found the answer. 
 Round peas contain much more starch than the wrinkled variety which contain more sugar. 
 The developing round peas produce a vital molecule, called starch-branching enzyme, which builds up complex starch molecules from sugar. 
 Dr Martin's team have shown that the wrinkled peas contain a defective gene for this enzyme and fail to make it. 
 They accumulate abnormal amounts of sugar which causes them to swell during development. 
 When they mature and dry out, however, they shrink and become wrinkled. 
 Dr Martin says that the team hoped the work would round off one of Mendel's experiments but the results have turned up a surprise. 
 The defective gene in the wrinkled variety contains an extra piece of DNA &mdash; the stuff genes are made of &mdash; which prevents it working properly. 
 But this piece looks like a member of a family of rogue &bquo;roaming&equo; elements called transposons that can move in and out of genes and may provide fundamental insights into gene functions. 
 &bquo;The behaviour of transposons in other plants is a key feature of our research, but this result was completely unexpected,&equo; said Dr Martin. 
 PM quells Hong Kong row over passport quotas. 
 By Michael White and David Hencke 
 MRS Thatcher yesterday marshalled the Cabinet behind a Foreign Office plan to give full British passports to at least 50,000 of Hong Kong's leading figures and their immediate families, despite the misgivings of the Home Secretary, Mr David Waddington, and other colleagues. 
 The bill is expected to sweep aside restrictions under the 1981 British Nationality Act which require six months prior residence before the granting of citizenship. 
 But confusion and uncertainty surrounding the Government's efforts to restore confidence in the colony are likely to continue after the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, makes his long-awaited statement to the Commons this afternoon. 
 Details of the legislation &mdash; including the points system whereby passports are allocated to senior Hong Kong government officials and businessmen &mdash; may not emerge until Easter. 
 Businessmen will get most passports, perhaps as much as two-thirds. 
 But no prospective beneficiary will be free to arrive until 1991 or later, raising private fears among some MPs that continued flight will mean a de facto Chinese takeover long before 1997. 
 Mr Waddington, a former immigration minister and rightwinger, seems to have gritted his teeth at yesterday's meeting and stood by the compromise hammered out at Mrs Thatcher's insistence in a cabinet committee. 
 Although she backed the plan to &bquo;keep Hong Kong prosperous&equo; until 1997 in the Commons yesterday, she let the Cabinet know she was displeased by the row. 
 But Mr Waddington's tone left colleagues in little doubt about his lack of enthusiasm about having to solve another minister's problems with legislation which will be attacked from all sides, including Tory rightwingers. 
 When MPs last night debated the related issue of compulsory repatriation of Vietnamese refugees from Hong Kong, they divided largely on party lines. 
 Some ministers registered scepticism about the wisdom of the scheme during the meeting and doubted their ability to sell it to MPs and voters. 
 It is intended to reassure key figures in Hong Kong that they have a &bquo;safety net&equo; and need not emigrate elsewhere if relations with China do not improve as the 1997 handover approaches. 
 But the changes to the immigration package made yesterday were minor. 
 One senior minister said: &bquo;There was nothing in it for the Right.&equo; 
 Discrepancies remained last night between the Foreign Office's emphasis on 50,000 heads of families involved and what looked like a Home Office attempt to put a ceiling of 200,000-225,000 on the total number. 
 Estimates of the family multiplier have ranged from 3.5 dependants per head of household to five, adding to uncertainty and the widespread backbench Tory hostility to the reopening of what one called &bquo;a hideous wave&equo; of immigration. 
 Ministers believe that with several months leeway, they can overcome public fears and backbench resentments sufficiently to reduce the potential Tory rebellion from 50-70 votes &mdash; which in tandem with Labour could spell defeat &mdash; to a manageable 20-30. 
 The package is expected to allow all Hong Kong residents who qualify &mdash; officials, security staff and leading businessmen &mdash; to be given automatic British residence status, although Whitehall is keen to avoid loopholes other Commonwealth citizens might exploit. 
 Although some Tory rebels claim their constituents fear intolerable pressure on homes and social services, others agree with Labour that the scheme is elitist, unfair and unworkable. 
 However, one Tory loyalist said: &bquo;If Gerald Kaufman wants to form an alliance with Tim Janman (a rightwinger), good luck to him. 
 We will defeat the extremists.&equo; 
 The Liberal Democrats want twice as many admitted. 
 Their leader, Mr Paddy Ashdown, yesterday challenged Mrs Thatcher to ignore her own bigots and Labour's &bquo;moral bankruptcy&equo;. 
 But in last night's debate on the boat people, Labour's junior foreign affairs spokesman, Mr George Foulkes, denounced compulsory repatriation as despicable and heartless. 
 He called for international reconstruction of Vietnam's economy. 
 Politics, page 6; Lost passports, page 9 
 US satellites to go to China. 
 President Bush has approved the sale of three civilian satellites to China and lifted a trading ban. 
 The action removes a large part of economic sanctions imposed after the Tiananmen Square massacre. 
 The White House is under pressure from Congress to show results from recent secret contacts with Beijing. 
 Page 9. 
 German unity warning. 
 Mr Eduard Shevardnadze, the Soviet foreign minister, has warned that demands for a rapid reunification of Germany could threaten European stability. 
 Page 20. 
 Pilots' hours cut. 
 The Civil Aviation Authority has ordered cuts in pilots' hours after the discovery that flight crews have been falling asleep in the cockpit. 
 Page 4. 
 &bquo;Threat&equo; to Scots fleet. 
 An agreement by European Community ministers on fishing quotas could push half of Scotland's fleet to bankruptcy, the Scottish Fishermen's Federation has said. 
 Page 2. 
 War book damages. 
 The former Tory party deputy chairman, Lord Aldington, has accepted &pound;30,000 agreed damages and a public apology over war crimes allegations from the publishers of the historian Nikolai Tolstoy's book, The Minister and the Massacres. 
 Page 4. 
 Stella Gibbons dies. 
 The novelist Stella Gibbons, author of Cold Comfort Farm, died yesterday at her north London home, aged 87. 
 Obituary, page 29 
 Hamlet before and after. 
 Prince Charles yesterday parodied Hamlet to illustrate how literature could be destroyed by bad use of language. 
 Hamlet, Prince of Denmark: Act III, Scene I. 
 HAMLET: To be, or not to be: that is the question: Whether &bquo;tis nobler in the mind to suffer The slings and arrows of outrageous fortune, Or to take arms against a sea of troubles, And by opposing end them? 
 To die: to sleep; No more; and, by a sleep to say we end The heartache and the thousand natural shocks That flesh is heir to, &bquo;tis a consummation Devoutly to be wish'd. 
 To die, to sleep; To sleep: perchance to dream: aye, there's the rub; For in that sleep of death what dreams may come When we have shuffled off this mortal coil, Must give us pause. 
 Charles, Prince of Wales: Act 1, Scene 1. 
 CHARLES: Well, frankly, the problem as I see it At this moment in time is whether I Should just lie down under all this hassle And let them walk all over me, Or, whether I should just say: &bquo;OK, I get the message&equo;, and do myself in. 
 I mean, let's face it, I'm in a no-win Situation, and quite honestly, I'm so stuffed up to here with the whole Stupid mess that, I can tell you, I've just Got a good mind to take the quick way out. 
 That's the bottom line. 
 The only problem is: What happens if I find that when I've bumped Myself off, there's some kind of a, you know, All that mystical stuff about when you die, You might find you're still &mdash; know what I mean? 
 Palumbo demolition victory &bquo;exception to planning rules&equo;. 
 By Madeleine Bunting 
 ACONSERVATION group has lost its High Court fight to save eight listed buildings in the City of London which are to be demolished by the property developer, Mr Peter Palumbo. 
 The grade two listed buildings on the Mappin and Webb site opposite the Mansion House are to be replaced by a single new building comprising offices, shops, a restaurant and a pub. 
 The proposed complex, designed by the architect James Stirling, has been described by the Prince of Wales as resembling &bquo;a 1930s wireless set&equo;. 
 However, in the High Court yesterday, Mr Justice Simon Brown rejected claims by the group, Save Britain's Heritage, that the decision in June of the then Environment Secretary, Mr Nicholas Ridley, to grant planning permission was contrary to stated government policy, and should be quashed. 
 But he said he wished Mr Ridley had made clear that the strong argument for conservation was only over-ridden because of &bquo;a combination of wholly exceptionable circumstances&equo;, and that the case was &bquo;unique&equo; because of the high standard of the proposed scheme. 
 The judge said the case did not mark a sharp change in government policy, and emphasised it was not to be regarded of general application by planning authorities around the country. 
 The conservation group claimed the judgment vindicated their challenge, by narrowing the potentially damaging effects of Mr Ridley's decision. 
 &bquo;The judge has set our fears at rest that Ridley's decision would be used as a precedent for demolishing thousands of other listed buildings,&equo; said Mr Marcus Binney, the group's president. 
 Mr Palumbo said he was delighted with the decision, and that the cost of delays has been &pound;1million per day. 
 In his lengthy judgment, Mr Justice Simon Brown also acknowledged the &bquo;enormous controversy&equo; over the scheme. 
 But he said that his only concern was to establish whether Mr Ridley's decision had been in accordance with the law. 
 He concluded that it was. 
 &bquo;Everybody accepted that the existing buildings were of both individual and group value, and not to be demolished save in favour of an outstanding replacement,&equo; he commented. 
 Following a public inquiry, the inspector had concluded a new building on the site provided a &bquo;vital opportunity&equo; for &bquo;a considered mature work by a British architect of international stature, of whose achievements the nation can be justly proud.&equo; 
 It &bquo;might just be a masterpiece&equo;, he said in his report. 
 In recognition of it being a charity which had acted in the public interest, the judge awarded only three-quarters of the costs, estimated at &pound;50,000, against the conservation group, which is considering an appeal. 
 Video evidence plan for children. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 CHILD witnesses in trials for sexual or violent offences, cruelty or neglect will be able to give evidence by pre-recorded video rather than appearing in court if the Government accepts a Home Office advisory group's recommendations. 
 In its report, published yesterday, the advisory group on video-recorded evidence says no child witness in such cases should be required to appear in open court. 
 The Home Office yesterday broadly welcomed the report, but said it would consult interested parties before deciding on implementation. 
 The group, chaired by Judge Thomas Pigot, QC, a senior Old Bailey judge, recommends that the rule that children under seven or eight should not give evidence, laid down in a string of cases, should be abolished. 
 The rule, combined with the rule against hearsay which prevents criminal courts admitting evidence of a child's interviews with social workers or psychiatrists, has made it impossible to prosecute many alleged child abusers. 
 The group, which includes a barrister, a law professor and representatives of the police and social services, also suggests that in rape and other sexual assault cases, judges should no longer be required to direct the jury about the danger of convicting the accused on the uncorroborated evidence of the alleged victim. 
 Video-recorded interviews with police, social workers or others concerned with child welfare or criminal investigation should be admissible in court if the child is under 14, the group recommends. 
 For sexual offences, the upper age limit should be 17. 
 Where the case is to be tried by a jury in the crown court, the judge should decide at a pre-trial hearing whether to admit the video as evidence. 
 Videotaped interviews should only be excluded if admitting them would be contrary to the interests of justice. 
 Interviews should comply with a statutory code of practice and the judge should be required to take account of the code in deciding whether to admit the video. 
 Cross-examination by defence lawyers should also be videotaped at an informal hearing before trial, with the press and public excluded. 
 Defendants should be prohibited from cross-examining the child. 
 Most of the group suggests the court should be able to order, in the case of very young or disturbed children, that questions be relayed through a psychiatrist or someone who enjoys the child's confidence. 
 The barrister member, Miss Anne Rafferty, dissented. 
 Report of the Advisory Group on Video-Recorded Evidence, Home Office, 50 Queen Anne's Gate, London SW1H 9AT, &pound;2 Leader comment, page 18 
 Ashdown claims &bquo;moral voice&equo; for the 1990s. 
 By Paul Nettleton 
 MR PADDY Ashdown yesterday staked the Liberal Democrats' claim to offer British politics a &bquo;moral voice&equo; for the 1990s, building on its stance over Hong Kong and the Vietnamese refugees. 
 He admitted the strategy posed risks to his party, but said: &bquo;I've got to be prepared, to continue to be prepared, to take risky positions to keep in the game.&equo; 
 He went on: &bquo;Looking back, the fact that we were the first to say Thatcher should go over the Lawson affair meant that we were in the game. 
 The same is true of Hong Kong. 
 There is no benefit to my party, no benefit whatsoever, in simply taking safe positions. 
 &bquo;If we're going to break through, we've got to be prepared to be quick on the button and to say quite risky things.&equo; 
 In an end-of-year assessment at Westminster, Mr Ashdown admitted that when he became leader, his job had been to stabilise a party &bquo;in a fast downward spiral of disintegration&equo;. 
 The party's September conference in Brighton &bquo;was the point at which we said &bquo;right, this is a political entity that's going to continue&equo;. 
 I don't mind sharing the view, there were moments when I wondered whether it could actually be done.&equo; 
 Mr Ashdown said progress for the party would be incremental. 
 &bquo;I am determined that we build solidly rather than build fast.&equo; 
 He said Labour's proposed end to support for the closed shop, rather than evidence of a changed attitude to Europe, was a piece of clever opportunism to get the party where it wanted to be. 
 He saw little sign &bquo;of the commitment to deepening European unity which is going to be the main thrust of European, if not domestic politics, in the next five or 10 years.&equo; 
 On Mrs Thatcher and Europe, he felt she had been &bquo;locked in the bunker surrounded by sycophants so long that she's lost touch with reality. 
 &bquo;I do think that this is a very important issue for us in politics. 
 We own this agenda. 
 I can feel the British people moving very fast towards a position we've held with some electoral drag for a number of years. 
 &bquo;At the end of the day, what we're really looking for is the right byelection.&equo; 
 A PRIVATE member's bill to introduce payments for Crown servants who were exposed to radiation during nuclear weapons tests and have since contracted leukaemia and other cancers, and to the dependants of those who have died, was presented to the Commons by Mr Bob Clay (Lab. 
 Sunderland N). 
 Mr Clay drew eighth in the ballot for private member's bills, but with only seven Fridays available for second readings has limited chances of seeing his bill made law. 
 THE Social Fund budget is to be increased by &pound;3 million to increase allocations to 100 offices where applications have been higher than expected, Mr Tony Newton, Social Security Secretary, announced in a written answer. 
 Mr Newton also announced that the amount of savings elderly people may have before cold weather payments are reduced will be increased to &pound;1,000. 
 SUBSIDIES totalling &pound;11.6 million will be paid next year towards essential ferry and coastal shipping in the Northern and Western Isles of Scotland, Mr Malcolm Rifkind, Scottish Secretary, told Sir Hector Monro (C. Dumfries &amp; Galloway) in a written answer. 
 FINAL allocations of water shares were 46.875 per cent to the public; 39.25 per cent to institutions and 13.875 per cent to overseas investors, Mr Michael Howard, water minister, told Mr Graham Allen (Lab. 
 Nottingham N) in a written answer. 
 TODAY'S BUSINESS House of Commons: Scottish questions; Christmas adjournment debate; Consolidated Fund Bill &mdash; all night session of short backbench debates. 
 House of Lords: Debate on international action to protect the environment. 
 Exploding myth of Thatcher folklore Points of Order. 
 By Ian Aitken 
 THE round of applause which the Prime Minister attracted at the European summit in Strasbourg earlier this month has already entered the folklore of Thatcherism. 
 It is presented as proof of the success of her softer approach to all those Frogs, Krauts and Wops who live on the other side the English Channel. 
 The story is that President Mitterrand and Chancellor Kohl led the clapping as a tribute to Mrs Thatcher's transformed behaviour. 
 Alas, like so many things which get into the history books, it wasn't quite like that. 
 According to very senior sources who were present at the final session of the summit, what actually happened was subtly different from the PR people's version. 
 They say that as the meeting was drawing to its conclusion, everyone was waiting for a certain person to utter a few graceful words by way of a thank-you to the summit host, Mr Mitterrand. 
 The designated person, it was thought, was the Irish Prime Minister, Charlie Haughey. 
 But time passed and, to everyone's embarrassment, Mr Haughey showed no sign of doing his bit. 
 So Mrs Thatcher, demonstrating hitherto unsuspected social graces, decided to step into the breach herself. 
 Declaring that she believed she was speaking for everyone, she expressed gratitude for the splendour of the hospitality provided by La Belle France, thanked the president personally, and added a few more words of the sort which well-brought-up people employ on such occasions. 
 When she finished, the rest of Mr Mitterrand's guests clapped politely, and they were joined by Monsieur le President. 
 It is anyone's guess why Mr Mitterrand applauded, though he is said to get on better with Mrs T than Euro-legend has it. 
 But the others were plainly endorsing her vote of thanks to their host rather than paying tribute to the newly-discovered &bquo;communautaire&equo; qualities of the Iron Lady. 
 THE sickening events in Romania over the past few days now leave Albania as the last resort of old-style Stalinism. 
 It is, in a memorable phrase from the 1930s, a faraway country of which we know little. 
 But thanks to its urgent need for &bquo;hard&equo; (ie. capitalist) currency, even Albania was forced to open its borders to tourism some time ago. 
 One of the first tourists to venture into the former realm of King Zog was John Biffen, who soon discovered his fairly orthodox demeanor was regarded as offensively trendy by Albania's time-warped Bolshevists. 
 It wasn't just that copies of knitting patterns in a popular British magazine were regarded as subersive, or even that the border guards had strict rules about the permitted length of visitors' hair. 
 There was also the problem of Mr Biffen's shorts. 
 These were a survival from his army days and, therefore, some way from being sexually provocative. 
 But the pure Marxism-Leninism of Albania's then president, the late Enver Hoxha, decreed that shorts could only be worn on the beach. 
 Regrettably, Mr Biffen wore his on the brief journey from his seaside hotel to the beach. 
 This act of gross indecency provoked stern disapproval from the tour guide. 
 Mr Biffen, who was later to become Leader of the Commons and Lord President of the Council, and was eventually to be sacked by You-Know-Who for wholly ideological reasons, was marched back to the hotel to cover himself. 
 The event suggests the Albanian Communist regime might most easily be toppled by dropping tons of trendy magazines on Tirana. 
 MEANWHILE, admirers of Joseph Vissarionovich Dzhugashvili (Stalin to you) are scarce outside Albania nowadays. 
 Even the old-style British Communist Party has renounced him, along with pretty well all his works. 
 So colleagues were intrigued when posters appeared near the Guardian office recently, announcing a meeting to celebrate Uncle Joe's 110th birthday in a hall close to King's Cross station. 
 The celebrant was to be something calling itself the Revolutionary Communist Party of Britain (Marxist-Leninist). 
 Sadly, the reporter despatched to attend and describe this promising event was quite unable to find it. 
 Had it been April, one could have understood. 
 But December? 
 Perhaps it was the flu. 
 Tunnel travellers to stay in cars. 
 By Andrew Cornelius Business Editor 
 AFRESH row over Channel Tunnel safety is likely to follow yesterday's confirmation that passengers will not have to leave their cars and coaches when they travel through the tunnel. 
 It came as a relief for Eurotunnel, which otherwise would have needed to redesign the tunnel trains, causing delays in delivery. 
 The Anglo-French Intergovernmental Commission, which sets safety and security standards for the project, announced the decision after receiving advice from the Tunnel Safety Authority. 
 &bquo;The current studies are sufficiently convincing for Eurotunnel to continue the development of its transport system on the principle of non-segregation of passengers for diesel and petrol cars and coaches,&equo; the authority said. 
 Passengers will have to be separated from light commercial vehicles, light vehicles with caravans or trailers and mixed-use vehicles like campers and mobile homes. 
 The company had already decided to separate drivers and passengers of heavy goods vehicles and motorcycles from their vehicles. 
 A further outcry from consumer groups and fire brigade unions is expected over the dangers from fire. 
 They have lobbied hard for complete segregation on tunnel trains, similar to the operation of cross-Channel ferries. 
 Eurotunnel welcomed the decision. 
 &bquo;It enables us to continue to develop the project as conceived from the start,&equo; said a statement by Eurotunnel's co-chairmen, Mr Alastair Morton and Mr Andre Benard. 
 &bquo;In the past four years, a great deal of research and design has gone into the safety of the project. 
 In the coming months we will begin a series of presentations to help the public fully understand our system.&equo; 
 Muslims fight Rushdie threat. 
 By Sarah Boseley and Tom Sharratt 
 AGROUP of moderate Muslims yesterday launched a campaign to silence those calling for the death of the novelist, Mr Salman Rushdie. 
 The call came as two Iranian students were deported after being questioned in connection with threats to firebomb bookshops. 
 Mr Allama Abul Fateh Chisti, an Islamic scholar who is managing director of the Muslim Unity Study Centre in Southall, west London, and a prominent businessman, Mr Riaz Khalid, are the prime movers behind the British Muslim Alliance. 
 They hope to unite Muslim organisations in a peaceful campaign against Mr Rushdie's novel, the Satanic Verses, which they consider blasphemous. 
 But they want an end to all death threats against the novelist. 
 Mr Chisti said calls for the killing of Mr Rushdie had backfired. 
 &bquo;We achieved nothing because the prime purpose of the movement was only to ban the book or withdraw the book from the shelves or have Rushdie brought before a court of law. 
 Instead of that, Rushdie became very famous and the book became a bestseller.&equo; 
 He appealed for all Muslim organisations to join the Alliance. 
 &bquo;If not, then I fear that this paperback edition will come and it will be sold on a very large scale and will be smuggled to other countries where it is banned and will be read in translation,&equo; Mr Chisti said. 
 The organisers hope their movement, which they say is supported by many Muslim organisations, will persuade the Government to order an inquiry into the Rushdie affair. 
 The organisers are planning a rally in February. 
 Mr Khalid said the Government could repair damage by agreeing to an inquiry. 
 He said: &bquo;The stance that the British government has taken has damaged its trade with Islamic countries.&equo; 
 The leading moderate Muslim, Dr Hesham El-Essawy, chairman of the Islamic Society for the Promotion of Religious Tolerance, welcomed the organisation's launch and said it reflected the feelings of most British Muslims. 
 He said many were shamed by the outbursts from Muslims like Mr Kalim Saddiqui, the most prominent supporter of the Rushdie death sentence pronounced by Iran's Ayatollah Khomeini. 
 Mr Saddiqui was not impressed by the launch of the organisation although he wished it well. 
 The Home Office announced last night that two Iranians arrested on Friday under the Prevention of Terrorism Act are to be deported. 
 Two other Iranians arrested at the same time by Greater Manchester police were released without charge yesterday. 
 Mr Zahid Dar, a spokesman for their solicitors, said the other two may seek compensation for wrongful detention. 
 The two who are to be expelled are Mr Karen Abrinia, aged 32, and Mr Mehrdad Kokabi, aged 33, engineering students at the University of Manchester Institute of Science and Technology. 
 It is understood that they were questioned in connection with threats to firebomb bookshops. 
 Fare rises, job losses and substitution to buses in rural areas forecast for 90s BR grant to be slashed by a third. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 DIRECT government grants for the railways are to be slashed by 33 per cent to &pound;345million, after adjustment for inflation, in the next three years. 
 The cuts, which emerged in the new British Rail corporate plan for the early 1990s, will mean substantial real increases in passenger fares for the foreseeable future, more one-off sales of railway property, fewer jobs and substitution of rail services with buses insome rural areas. 
 In the wake of the Clapham Junction crash, the plan also earmarks &pound;250million of capital investment on safety measures, but admits the true cost of improving railway safety will be significantly higher. 
 Despite the reductions in grant, Mr Cecil Parkinson, the Transport Secretary, is steering BR towards a record &pound;5billion investment programme of modernisation for the 1990s, and is welcoming private sector involvement. 
 The latest cuts in public sector support follow a steady reduction in government aid from more than &pound;1billion a year during the 1980s. 
 The main grant, the Public Sector Obligation, was sliced by 25 per cent between 1983 and 1986/87, and BR faces a further 29 per cent cut by the end of the current financial year in March 1990. 
 Details of the corporate plan are: 
 Grants to commuter services in the South are to be abolished by 1992/93, having run at over &pound;300million a year as recently as 1985/86. 
 Grants of &pound;94 million are forecast this year, and the new plan asks BR to produce, by December 1990, proposals for Network SouthEast to achieve significant progress towards a commercial rate of return by 1995/96. 
 BR forecasts continuing increases in demand in the congested South-east, and half the planned investment of &pound;2billion up to 1994/95 will go on new rolling stock. 
 But the document warns: &bquo;Real pricing is assumed in every year of the plan, averaging approximately 2 &frac12; per cent per annum, consistent with the quality improvements which will be brought about by investment.&equo; 
 Receipts per train mile are forecast to rise by 11 per cent up to March 1994. 
 The threat of more rises is apparent in a promise by BR to review by 1991 whether changes in quality targets can be justified, &bquo;taking account of passengers&equo; willingness to pay for them.&equo; 
 BR says strenuous efforts are being made to improve punctuality, but admits overcrowding and cancellations on some services has reached unsatisfactory levels. 
 It says it is not possible to predict when loading standards can be met. 
 Public sector support for provincial services is being reduced by &pound;77million to &pound;345 million by 1992/93, from almost &pound;550 million in 1985/86. 
 The corporate plan assumes a 6 per cent reduction in costs, a 14 per cent jump in receipts and a 15 per cent rise in the number of passenger-miles by March 1994. 
 However, it also assumes a reduction of 2,400 vehicles on the provincial network by 1993/94. 
 The plan notes &bquo;some lines may be the subject of bus substitution proposals to provide local transport at lower cost&equo;. 
 Investment in the provincial sector is set to exceed &pound;500 million over the coming five years, with half in new rolling stock. 
 The InterCity service, which received grants of more than &pound;120million in 1985/86, is projected to make profits of &pound;20 million in the current year, rising to &pound;95million by 1992/93. 
 Business is scheduled to grow by 7 &frac12; per cent by March 1994, and BR admits prices &bquo;will relate to what the market will bear.&equo; 
 Increases above inflation will be concentrated on long-distance commuter services, which BR says are &bquo;well below standard rates&equo; in the south. 
 InterCity is forecast to continue reducing costs and invest &pound;750million within five years. 
 The freight operation, which received over &pound;50million of support in the mid-1980s, is set to make profits of &pound;22million in the current year and &pound;50 million by 1992/93. 
 Investment within five years is put at &pound;670million. 
 The parcels operation, which lost &pound;18million in 1987/88, is set to earn profits of &pound;9million by 1992/93, and investment is put at &pound;35million. 
 BR is projecting to shed 1,000 jobs a year for the next five years, cutting the total workforce to 130,000 by 1992/93 &mdash; from around 200,000 in the early 1980s. 
 BR investment is forecast at &pound;5 billion in the five years to March 1994, about double the rate of the past five years. 
 Some &pound;1.49million is scheduled for infrastructure, &pound;2.5billion for rolling stock and &pound;836million for stations and terminals. 
 However, BR is concerned that the key assumption of the report &mdash; a UK annual growth rate of 1.7 per cent &mdash; will not be achieved. 
 It warns that because of the recent downturn, there is a significant risk growth will not be so high. 
 &bquo;Clearly, this is worrying for the board as it prepares to address the new objectives for 1992/93.&equo; 
 Rail fares to soar as grants are cut. 
 By Michael Smith and Patrick Wintour 
 RAIL fares are scheduled to soar in the next few years and at least 5,000 railway jobs will be lost following the Government's decision to slash grants for British Rail in the early 1990s. 
 The Transport Secretary, Mr Cecil Parkinson, announced yesterday that BR grants would be cut by a third from &pound;516 million to &pound;345 million by 1992/93 and that BR plans to shed 1,000 jobs a year up to March 1994. 
 Mr Parkinson told the Commons there was no need for &bquo;large fare increases&equo; but BR's corporate plan, also published yesterday, revealed a steady upward climb in the cost of travel. 
 BR warned that fares on Network SouthEast, where grants will be withdrawn altogether by 1992/93, would rise in real terms by 2 &frac12; per cent over inflation for the next five years. 
 Fares on provincial operations, where grants will be cut by 18 per cent, would face &bquo;selective real pricing&equo;. 
 Network SouthEast will be the only European commuter rail operation not supported by public money, and Mr Parkinson has ordered it to earn a commercial rate of return by 1995/96, a move which implies further fare increases. 
 Fares on InterCity will relate to &bquo;what the market can bear,&equo; with real increases focused on long distance commuters. 
 Rail fares have been rising at around 1 &frac12; per cent over inflation in recent years and the new corporate plan also warns that BR has 12 months to assess whether passengers would pay even more for a better service. 
 While Mr Parkinson faced severe criticism from opposition MPs, rail unions and transport groups, he counter-attacked by promising &pound;5 billion of capital investment and telling MPs: &bquo;To subsidise a service for which there is excessive demand is a very silly way of using national income.&equo; 
 Mr Parkinson will face continued criticism of government policy to spend more on building roads while reducing support for public transport. 
 The former prime minister, Mr Edward Heath, signalled some Tory backbench unease by saying the Government had to realise there was a difference between subsidy and expenditure to help the environment. 
 Mr John Prescott, the Labour transport spokesman, said BR would lose &pound;3.5 billion of public support by 1993, which would leave it at the bottom of the international league for support and top for fares. 
 He warned that the overall effect would be to drive the public back on to overcrowded roads. 
 The rail unions rejected Mr Parkinson's plans. 
 Mr Jimmy Knapp, general secretary of the National Union of Railwaymen, said the proposals would threaten essential measures like new signalling. 
 Mr Stephen Joseph, of the pressure group Transport 2000, said the plans would force people back on to the roads. 
 &bquo;The Government is asking the railways to do more with less.&equo; 
 Details, page 3 
 Adverse conditions disrupt service on Commons line Sketch. 
 By Andrew Rawnsley 
 CECIL Parkinson, the Transport Secretary, was due at the despatch box to make his statement about the future of British Rail. 
 But, in the finest traditions of BR, the service was inevitably subject to a series of unavoidable delays. 
 Mr Parkinson was delayed by a dense bank of fog ahead of him on the line &mdash; Nicholas Ridley, the Trade and Industry Secretary, making his statement about the Barlow Clowes affair. 
 The arrival of the Transport Secretary was further postponed by a slow-moving statement over frigate orders. 
 And first, there was a long interruption to normal service at Prime Minister's Question Time when two Tory backbenchers threw themselves in front of the House and got mown down by the Opposition roaring with ridicule. 
 Afterwards, everybody asked themselves: Was it a cry for help? 
 In the case of one of them, Andy Stewart, the Conservative MP for Sherwood, it almost certainly was. 
 Ever since he entered the House, the more brutish Labour members have harried Mr Stewart with heckles of &bquo;Give us a jig!&equo;, and &bquo;Where's your kilt?&equo;. 
 Anxious to prove that he is a serious figure, yesterday he presented Mrs Thatcher with the latest dire threat to the British way of life from the European Commission. 
 He asked for her help in resisting attempts to ban the sale of fresh turkeys at Christmas. 
 &bquo;Will you,&equo; he asked her, &bquo;defy this gobbledygook?&equo; 
 Oh dear. 
 This got Mr Stewart harried with new heckles of &bquo;Get stuffed!&equo; 
 Still, it's an improvement on &bquo;Bring on Moira Anderson&equo;. 
 The other Tory backbencher, Sir Michael Shaw, MP for Scarborough, prefaced his question to the Prime Minister with the words: &bquo;On this, her last Question Time of the 1980s&hellip; 
 &equo; He, too, was drowned out by some Labour jeering. 
 Composing himself, Sir Michael pressed on: &bquo;Would my Right Honourable Friend reflect on the great progress that has been made during the last 10 years in the well-being of our country and the competitiveness of our industries and&hellip; 
 &equo; On and on he swirled. 
 &bquo;Furthermore&hellip; 
 &equo; Even his own side were groaning. 
 &bquo;Briefly, please,&equo; implored the Speaker, to no avail. 
 Like the Yorkshire resort he represents, Sir Michael is famous for blustering high winds. 
 &bquo;And would she look forward&hellip; &bquo; 
 Mercifully, another cacophony of groans drowned out whatever it was Sir Michael was looking forward to. 
 Anyway, Mrs Thatcher liked it. 
 &bquo;In the last 10 years we've created more jobs than ever before, higher living standards than ever before, better social services than ever before, higher living&hellip; 
 &equo; Had that one already, Prime Minister. 
 With Prime Minister's Question Time at last over, those of us waiting to catch the Parkinson statement now found it had been further held up while one of the defence ministers made a laborious job of unwrapping the Ministry of Defence's Christmas present for the navy &mdash; three new frigates. 
 Then, Mr Ridley turned up to make his statement about the Barlow Clowes affair. 
 As far as you could understand him, this was to the effect that since the Government was rejecting any suggestion that it was to blame for this scandal, since most of the alleged swindlers were difficult to bring to book, and since the investors who lost the money nearly all live in Tory marginals, then the one innocent party &mdash; the taxpayer &mdash; would foot the &pound;150 million bill. 
 By this time, those hoping to catch the Parkinson statement had, in the finest traditions of BR, given up and walked. 
 East and West denounce suppression of protests &bquo;Massacre&equo; on streets of Romania. 
 By Ian Traynor in Budapest 
 TROOPS were reported to be patrolling the streets of the Romanian capital, Bucharest, yesterday as evidence mounted of a massacre in the town of Timisoara at the weekend and East and West moved to denounce the brutal clampdown by the regime's security forces. 
 The Yugoslav news agency Tanjug said there were unconfirmed reports that up to 2,000 people had been killed since the weekend. 
 In Timisoara, there were reports of more gunfire being heard yesterday morning. 
 Further unrest was expected in the town last night, as evenings have been the peak periods for the protests over the past five days. 
 As the country's political isolation reached unprecedented levels, the authorities appeared to have deepened its isolation by sealing the borders with the Soviet Union and Bulgaria, in addition to the earlier closure of the frontiers with Yugoslavia and Hungary. 
 The isolation made it virtually impossible to gain any conclusive information on the scale of the weekend violence, but a growing volume of eyewitness accounts spoke of hundreds being killed in a bloodbath at the hands of the army and secret police. 
 &bquo;Tiananmen is nothing compared to Timisoara,&equo; said a Western student who entered Yugoslavia yesterday from the centre of the weekend carnage. 
 Tanjung said: &bquo;Witnesses claim that police are taking the arrested demonstrators to the central Timisoara square, where they beat them up and stab them with bayonets, before shoving them into lorries and driving them away no one knows where.&equo; 
 Austrian television quoted a witness in Timisoara as saying he had seen lorries carrying away &bquo;cubic metres of bodies&equo;. 
 The report said Romanian troops were hunting down and apparently executing anti-government demonstrators who escaped the killings in Timisoara. 
 A Hungarian with relatives employed at a Timisoara hospital told Budapest radio that at least 250 bodies had been admitted to one hospital and that the death figure was bound to be higher. 
 A doctor in Timisoara, contacted by the Catholic news agency Kathpress, said that the death toll could run to several hundred and that many hundreds more had been injured. 
 The Austrian news agency, APA, giving further details of the weekend clash which began after crowds tried to stop police evicting a popular priest and human rights campaigner, Pastor Laszlo Tokes, said tanks had driven into the crowds and soldiers opened fire without warning. 
 It quoted an Austrian-based Romanian doctor who had been visiting relatives as saying: &bquo;The first three rows of protesters collapsed dead or injured. 
 People stopped private cars and put the dead and injured in their boots. 
 Blood and torn clothing lay everywhere.&equo; 
 Armed soldiers were reported to be patrolling the streets of Bucharest and the capital's students were said to be voicing solidarity with the protesters in the north of the country, in what appeared to be a menacing escalation of the crisis. 
 President Nicolae Ceausescu, however, remained unperturbed by the news and continued his official visit to Iran. 
 He assured Iranian leaders in Tehran in a banquet speech on Monday night that his country's economic and social position was &bquo;good, stable and balanced&equo;, according to the official Agerpres news agency. 
 The superpowers deplored the violence and the rest of Eastern Europe issued protests. 
 The Soviet Foreign Minister, Mr Eduard Shevardnadze, said in Brussels that he had no specific details of the unrest but that any intervention by the security forces was highly regrettable. 
 Czechoslovakia, East Germany and Poland joined Hungary in condemning the clampdown by the Warsaw Pact's last hardline regime. 
 Leading world church organisations joined in the chorus of condemnation. 
 Britain protested to Romania over the violent crackdown on dissent and urged Romanian state employees to overthrow the Communist government for their own safety. 
 The Foreign Office Minister, Mr William Waldegrave, said: &bquo;The message we must get across is that those in the security services, those working for the state, should recognise that a day of reckoning will come for them as it has come for the East Germans and others.&equo; 
 The leading Romanian playwright Mr Eugene Ionescu appealed to President Mikhail Gorbachev to help secure the removal of Mr Ceausescu. 
 A Western resident of Timisoara said that the scale of the violence in the town on Sunday was horrifying, while a Yugoslav lorry driver who came out of the region yesterday reported seeing fires. 
 But what now clearly looks to be the gravest threat to Mr Ceausescu's 24-year period of iron rule remained unreported by the Romanian media. 
 Popular revolt, page 8; Leader comment, page 18; State of fear, page 19 
 MacGregor admits Baker aim of 20 CTCs &bquo;overambitious&equo;. 
 By Martin Linton 
 THE Education Secretary Mr John MacGregor conceded at question time yesterday that his predecessor Mr Kenneth Baker's target of establishing 20 City Technology Colleges by the end of this year had been &bquo;overambitious&equo;. 
 He blamed the delays on &bquo;the realities of getting practical things off the ground&equo;, but insisted that the Government was sticking to the original target figure and they were making &bquo;excellent progress&equo;. 
 But Labour's shadow education secretary Mr Jack Straw said since only three of the 20 were in operation on the target date &bquo;why doesn't he recognise the CTC programme as an immoral and wasteful failure?&equo; 
 Since the Government's own inspectors had said that half of secondary school children were being educated in substandard buildings why did he not cancel the CTC programme and use the money to repair Britain's crumbling schools? 
 Mr MacGregor said that to describe the programme as immoral was absolutely ludicrous. 
 &bquo;There are always practical problems in getting planning permission and finding sites, and linking sponsors to sites. 
 &bquo;But it is quite clear from the responses to the colleges that it was an excellent innovation.&equo; 
 PM challenged to allow ambulance arbitration. 
 By Martin Linton 
 THE LABOUR leader, Mr Neil Kinnock, challenged the Prime Minister yesterday to allow the pay of 22,000 ambulance staff to be referred to a pay review body, as is done for 600,000 health service workers. 
 He urged her to acknowledge that she could quickly end the dispute by allowing it go to arbitration. 
 &bquo;Or is it the case, as millions now believe, that she does not want a resolution to this dispute?&equo; 
 Mrs Thatcher said that pay review bodies were only &bquo;given to those who do not go on strike, like the nurses&equo;, and that some &bquo;militant&equo; ambulancemen wanted to withdraw the emergency service across the country to force through their pay claim. 
 She challenged the opposition leader to join her in urging them to accept the &bquo;generous&equo; pay offer ranging from 9 to 16.3 per cent over 18 months &bquo;or at least to have a truce over Christmas&equo;. 
 The offer was backdated to April, and there were now arrears waiting to be picked up varying from &pound;653 to &pound;12,090; she hoped they would consider that it was a reasonable offer. 
 Mr Kinnock reminded her that the non-TUC Association of Professional Ambulance Personnel, &bquo;the kind of organisation she likes&equo;, had by five to one turned down her pay offer. 
 &bquo;Doesn't she get the message from that? 
 Because if she doesn't, I do; millions in this country do; and members of her own party do: that urging from the Prime Minister won't resolve the dispute &mdash; arbitration will.&equo; 
 Attack over repatriation, is repulsed Boat people debate. 
 Martin Linton. 
 THE Government successfully defended the forced repatriation of Vietnam boat people last night when the Commons approved a supplementary estimate by 309 votes to 219, a majority of 90, with two Tory backbenchers rebelling. 
 The Foreign Office minister, Mr Francis Maude dismissed the Opposition's bitter criticism of last week's deportations, saying it came from those who could stand on the sidelines wringing their hands and decrying what was done. 
 But the Government had to face the realities and accept responsibilities, he said. 
 In the aftermath of the Vietnam war it had agreed to take in those fleeing from the persecution of a vindictive regime and agreed to resettle those who fled by boat. 
 But soon the nature of the exodus from Vietnam had changed and the majority were people seeking a more prosperous life. 
 By 1987 the numbers were so huge that the ability of the West to take in all comers was strained No force had been used in last week's operation, he insisted. 
 &bquo;These were people who were being sent back against their will to a country they had sought to leave and it is inevitable that they should not be joyful, but there was no resistance.&equo; 
 He also dismissed suggestions that the operation had been conducted under a blanket of secrecy when live television pictures were being screened worldwide as it was carried out. 
 Labour's spokesman, Mr George Foulkes, said that only a programme of assistance to Vietnam would improve the lives of the people there and encourage those who have already left to return. 
 &bquo;Those who return will go back to an increasingly tolerable life and they will send messages back to those who are still in the camps and that will reinforce the voluntary return.&equo; 
 Mr Foulkes agreed that if Britain resettled all the boat people and did nothing else, the flow would continue unabated and this will be increasingly difficult for Hong Kong and damaging for Vietnam. 
 But Labour believe Britain needed to tackle the root cause of the problem with a viable, long-term, humane solution. 
 &bquo;We disagree totally with forced deportation as heartless and inhumane,&equo; he said. 
 Mr David Howell (C. Guildford), the chairman of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, who opened the debate, said it had been a choice between the lesser evil of repatriation and the greater evil of doing nothing, which might inflict more cruelty, suffering and inhumane conditions on the people in the camps. 
 &bquo;If we do not act then thousands more will come floating in on the early spring tides, maybe tens of thousands, even hundreds, and they will bring chaos and suffering on a scale far larger than anything we have seen so far,&equo; he warned. 
 &bquo;There is no choice but to take an ugly and difficult decision to avert an even greater injustice, and those who cry halt and say there must be some other way, even though every conceivable way has been sought, would carry the responsibility for the even more catastrophic consequences of inaction,&equo; he added. 
 He regretted the Opposition had not agreed a bipartisan policy and it had to be asked why they had no similar feelings about the forced repatriation of people from Hong Kong to China &bquo;which goes on on every bitas big a scale as anything we are contemplating now&equo;. 
 &bquo;Those who argue that maybe we should just once more try to delay it must face up to the responsibility that they may, by their good intentions, create much more suffering than anything we have seen so far. 
 Washington's policy was &bquo;pure humbug&equo; on this issue, he said. 
 Most of the boat people wanted to go, not to Hong Kong, but to the United States. 
 But the United States was refusing to accept them. 
 The Liberal Democrat leader, Mr Paddy Ashdown, called last week's repatriation operation a &bquo;three o&equo; clock knock&equo;, and warned that it set an &bquo;appalling example&equo; to China, which would be responsible for the safekeeping of British subjects in the colony from 1997. 
 He criticised the system of screening and the appeals tribunal for refugees due to be sent back, saying they were forbidden to be present, allowed no legal representation, and were not told the reasons for decisions. 
 He called for action to tackle the difficulties without &bquo;shaming the reputation of this country and infringing the civil liberties of a few helpless people whose only sin has been to seek freedom and our protection&equo;. 
 Mr Maude dismissed the alternative policies offered. 
 Increased aid was not going to discourage people immediately and it was inconceivable that increased voluntary repatriation could suffice on its own, he said. 
 Senior Tory Mr Julian Amery (Brighton Pavilion) joined those urging ministers not to be hasty. 
 &bquo;There is no need to take the decision yet. 
 This is a problem which may be solved in Government time,&equo; he said. 
 Mrs Maureen Hicks (C. Wolverhampton NE) accused President Bush, the Pope, and the Archbishop of Canterbury of criticism without offering any positive action. 
 She told Mr Ashdown he did not represent an inner-city constituency such as hers, which would bear the brunt of any immigration. 
 &bquo;I'm not a racist, I'm a realist,&equo; she said. 
 The two Tory rebels were Miss Ann Widdecombe (Maidstone) and Sir Philip Goodhart (Beckenham). 
 Frigates order keeps Tyne yard in work. 
 By David Fairhall Defence Correspondent 
 THREE Type 23 anti-submarine frigates have been ordered from Swan Hunter on Tyneside, the Ministry of Defence announced yesterday. 
 Without new orders, the shipyard would have run out of work by the end of next year. 
 The MoD is believed to have struck a hard bargain &mdash; at somewhere between &pound;120 million and &pound;130 million a ship &mdash; with Swan Hunter winning the work against &bquo;keen and commercial&equo; competition from Yarrows on Clydeside and Cammell Laird on Merseyside. 
 The order, announced in the House of Commons by the junior defence minister, Mr Michael Neubert, will be greeted with some relief in the Navy. 
 It may find it increasingly difficult to hold the Government to its promise of a 50-frigate Navy when the Warsaw Pact military threat is perceived to be diminishing. 
 HMS Norfolk, the first of the &bquo;Duke&equo; class Type 23 frigates, was built by Yarrow and accepted into the Royal Navy last month. 
 A further nine are now on order, essentially to replace the ageing Leander class ships. 
 The Controller of the Navy, Vice Admiral Kent Eaton, said yesterday that tenders for up to four more vessels would probably be invited next year. 
 Although Mr Neubert would not say how much the three Swan Hunter Type 23s will cost, it is thought to be about three-quarters the price of recently built Type 22 frigates, which have a crew of 240 as against 170 for the Duke class. 
 Students attack 5pc grant rise. 
 STUDENT grants will rise by 7.4 per cent in London and 5 per cent elsewhere in England and Wales in 1990 when loans of up to &pound;460 a year are due to be introduced, the Government announced yesterday. 
 The new levels of grant &mdash; &pound;2,845 in London halls or lodgings, &pound;2,265 out of London and &pound;1,795 for students living at their parental home &mdash; should remain frozen from next autumn as the loan scheme is phased in. 
 Current full grants are &pound;2,650, &pound;2,155 and &pound;1,710 respectively. 
 The new grants were attacked by the National Union of Students as another cut in living standards when inflation was running at 7.7 per cent and housing costs, according to estimates from the committee of vice-chancellors and principals, had increased by 8.6 per cent. 
 Mr John MacGregor, the Education Secretary, said in a Commons written reply that the 1990 main grant and full year loan would amount to about 25 per cent more than the 1989 grant for most students. 
 But Ms Maeve Sherlock, NUS president, said students could lose far more in welfare benefits than they would be able to borrow &mdash; around &pound;523 per term for every claimant in London and up to &pound;900 a term for mature students in the capital. 
 The right to claim benefits will be withdrawn when loans are introduced. 
 The Government also disclosed that the present method of assessing parental contributions according to parents' residual income, after tax and mortgage payments, is to be retained for the time being. 
 The November 1988 white paper on the loan scheme proposed a move to gross income. 
 Mr MacGregor said further work was needed to resolve practical difficulties. 
 Next year parents whose residual income is below &pound;11,500 will not be assessed for a contribution. 
 Most parents will pay &pound;1 in &pound;9.33 on residual income between &pound;11,500 and &pound;14,700, &pound;1 in &pound;6.66 on income up to &pound;21,600 and &pound;1 in &pound;5.33 above that level. 
 The Government did not yesterday rule out including part-time students in its loans scheme, although it opposed excluding students in Scotland from the new legislation. 
 Main rates of Scottish student allowances will rise by 5 per cent, the Scottish Office minister, Mr Ian Lang, said in a Commons written reply. 
 The new grants (with current grant in brackets) will be: halls or lodgings in London: &pound;2,780 (&pound;2,585); elsewhere: &pound;2,200; (&pound;2,090); parental home: &pound;1,660 (&pound;1,575) Mr Mike Watson, MP for Glasgow Central, told the committee examining the Education (Student Loans) Bill, that Scottish students would suffer financial hardship because most Scottish degree courses were four years instead of the usual three in England and Wales. 
 Their debts at the end of a course would be even greater. 
 David Ward writes: 
 The Association of University Teachers decided yesterday to urge its 30,000 members to switch their accounts from banks which take part in the Government scheme for student loans. 
 The AUT's governing council, meeting in York, agreed to support a National Union of Students proposal for a one-day shut-down of universities in protest at the scheme with teach-ins on campuses. 
 The AUT plans to warn its own bankers, NatWest, that it may withdraw its own account in protest at the bank's support for the Government scheme. 
 Council members condemned plans to make universities bid for public money based on the number of students they expected to teach. 
 Mr Bill Trythall, the AUT president, said: &bquo;The pressure is on us to regard universities less as centres of academic excellence and more as productive enterprises, the analogues of manufacturing industry.&equo; 
 Minister angers crews. 
 By Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 AROW between health minister, Mrs Virginia Bottomley and Surrey ambulance workers has led to crews voting to step up their action on New Year's Eve, one of the busiest nights of the year. 
 It is the first time crews outside London have decided to cut themselves off from controllers and to accept only those calls put through by the police, the fire service, GPs, hospitals and the public. 
 The move, a reflection of the growing anger being felt by ambulance workers around the country, was announced as Health Secretary Kenneth Clarke acknowledged the dispute, now entering its fifteenth week, was unlikely to be settled before Christmas. 
 Mr Clarke was responding to calls from leaders of all the main Churches for the dispute to be brought to an end swiftly. 
 The six Church leaders warned: &bquo;Unless the dispute is resolved and a proper service is resumed as soon as possible, we believe that people's lives will increasingly be put at risk.&equo; 
 The decision to escalate the action in Surrey for 24 hours from 7am on New Year's Eve was taken at a meeting in Redhill. 
 Crews belonging to all five TUC-affiliated unions, as well as members of the breakaway Association of Professional Ambulance Personnel, voted 99 to 10 to threaten escalation unless Mrs Bottomley recognised ambulance workers as part of the emergency services. 
 The vote followed a row which blew up during a meeting between five ambulance workers and Mrs Bottomley in her constituency, South West Surrey, on Friday. 
 Yesterday, she again said that 9 out of 10 of the journeys carried out by ambulance workers were concerned with non-emergency work. 
 There was &bquo;no real validity&equo; in the argument that they should be paid the same as fire-fighters and the police. 
 A Country Diary: OXFORDSHIRE: On the first morning of this month, whilst watching the usual passage of gulls to the local refuse-dump, I spotted a flock of waders, estimated at between 300 and 400, much higher up and heading due south, and, a matter of seconds later, a similar party followed them on the same course, and I was able to identify them as Golden Plover. 
 Since this line of flight would take them straight to the pioneer party of 200-300 already assembled on the traditional Witney site, I wondered whether this was their destination. 
 A few days later, immediately alongside the busy M40, a pause at traffic-lights enabled me to glance at a dense assembly of birds, as closely-packed as starlings, extending for almost a quarter of a mile along the edge of the arable field, and I was able to identify them as a mixture of Lapwing and &bquo;goldies,&equo; all immobile, and many of the latter with their heads tucked in as if fast asleep. 
 An estimate of numbers was impossible in the few seconds available at the pause, but on the return journey, about an hour later, something had awakened them and a most spectacular aerial display was in progress &mdash; the two species had reacted differently to whatever had disturbed their siesta &mdash; the lapwing wheeling erratically just above ground level, but the &bquo;goldies&equo; in ever-changing smoke-like clouds high above, performing quick-change evolutions reminiscent of starlings going to roost. 
 Again, an estimate of numbers was difficult, but I am confident that there were well over 1,000 of the &bquo;goldies&equo;, and almost as many lapwing. 
 W. D. CAMPBELL. 
 Dear Santa, I'd like a piana or some leggo Old Red Cheeks gets snowed under every year with letters from children. 
 Sometimes the spelling isn't so hot but belief, as Melanie McFadyean found, still seems to burn bright. 
 SANTA CLAUS probably got more letters than the Queen or Margaret Thatcher this year. 
 But then he's cuddlier. 
 The Post Office, who handle his mail, say there were 600,000 letters for the plump, red-cheeked old fellow. 
 Naturally he couldn't answer them all himself, so Post Office staff lent a hand and every kid who wrote to him got a reply, postmarked Reindeerland or Santaland. 
 Whether they get the computer software, dolls and musical instruments they asked him for remains to be seen. 
 It depends how much the adults collude and what their bank balances are looking like. 
 If 600,000 write to Santa, it follows that a great many children believe in him. 
 But one child I know caught his parents prowling around with stockings at the dead of night and is now impressing upon his little pals that the whole thing is a con. 
 But his parents continue to leave sherry and mince pies out for Old Red Cheeks &mdash; perhaps they believe in him. 
 Lots of parents, and the odd nanny or two, provide back-up references for Santa explaining that little so-and-so is really a very good child. 
 These good children who wrote to Santa this year, and their parents and nannies, don't seem keen to continue the tradition of leaving sherry out. 
 They're OK about the mince pies, but Santa is likely to drown in milk this year. 
 Perhaps it's part of the drink/driving campaign reaching people who ride the sky in a sleigh drawn by reindeer. 
 (As for the reindeer, one thoughtful child added a PS, saying she would make sure there were carrots and water for them.) 
 After stuffing himself on mince pies and quaffing all that milk, and getting even tubbier, it's surprising that Santa can carry all the things the 600,000 ask him for. 
 And even more amazing that he can still squeeze through chimneys and central heating air vents in tower blocks. 
 Most kids have a pretty long list: &bquo;Please may I have a Barbie doll with her van and a oops a daisy doll hands down games bensing babys teddy bears leggo my dolley suprise hungry hippoes.&equo; 
 Some of these kids start young. 
 One three-month-old baby managed to talk its parents into sending Santa a letter asking for some clothes and a few bits for the cot. 
 One nine-year-old got most of the Christmas myth and the consumer dream into her letter as well as showing some concern: &bquo;Dear Santa, how are you doing? 
 I can not wait until Christmas come up and we have fun. 
 On Christmas Eve I said Christ was born many years ago tonight. 
 I'd like a piana from you for Christmas or if you can not get me that I would like a bike. 
 How is your wife? 
 I will leave you some Christmas cake sweets and beer.&equo; 
 The beer should cheer Santa up after all that milk. 
 But let's hope the piana is only an upright: it would be a shame if the child who wants an organ has to go without and it's hard to see how Santa would manage with a Steinway grand. 
 In New York, letters to Santa reflect the need more than the greed in that city of cities. 
 A 10-year-old asks for shoes: &bquo;Right now my mother doesn't work.&equo; 
 Her mother has two other little kids and is on welfare &mdash; &dollar;231 (about &pound;l44) a month. 
 A 50-year-old grandmother wrote to Santa: &bquo;I'm a sick lady with cancer. 
 I'm always with pain in the body. 
 I like a Quilt so I could be warm at night.&equo; 
 The letters are pinned up in a big main post office and generous people send the presents. 
 Last year the Post Office in Britain answered one such request, giving a wheelchair to seven-year-old Trudy Heenan's grandfather. 
 A quick straw poll of parents revealed that the little children are thrilled to get their letters marked Santaland or Reindeerland, and believe that Santa really does come down the chimney while they're asleep. 
 They believe it even though the evidence is suspect, such is the charmed life of the child. 
 But what about the uneaten mince pies? 
 Oh we just take a bite or two out of them, say the parents. 
 Presumably they pick up the pinta and down the sherry and beer as well, not to mention making it look as if the reindeers have had a go at the carrots. 
 (Next year some clever dick will take a patent out on sets of replica reindeer teeth to clamp around the carrots.) 
 The prize goes to a child, age unspecified but a couple of years off joined-up writing, who says: &bquo;Dear Father Chismas can I have some of these things?&equo; 
 The letter consists mostly of a complicated table of page and reference numbers with prices. 
 These refer to the Argos catalogue, a big hit with the under-5s I'm reliably informed. 
 The total cost of the numbered items from the catalogue is &pound;156.63. 
 Let's hope Santa isn't too strapped for cash as a result of the interest rate because he also has to get Silvanian fire places, sewing machines, Sindy (sic) dolls, guns, kitchen sets, guitars, books, a baby changing unit, felt tip pens, videos, electric cars, electric trains, micro machines, computers, personal stereos, mighty metro racing sets, radio controlled aeroplanes, slippers and a camra. 
 Another day. 
 December 20, 1969: Frost and snow. 
 Ted and I nearly lost our fingers pulling snow-frozen ivy off the trees to decorate the cottage. 
 The car broke down, we had great difficulty in collecting the Christmas trees from Jackson's farm and Ted got into a quite a suicidal mood. 
 But I said that it is always a good sign when things go wrong before the night. 
 (Barbara Castle: The Castle Diaries. 
 Weidenfeld &amp; Nicolson). 
 Badminton. 
 By Richard Jago 
 DARREN HALL, seemingly able to run forever, won the Oracle English National Championship for the fourth time in five years at Crawley last night. 
 Combining powerful smashes with deft drop-shots, Hall, from Chingford, Essex, beat Steve Baddeley, the left-handed Sussex player, 15-18, 15-4, 15-4 in a 66-minute final. 
 Hall's speed was matched against the slightly greater power of Baddeley. 
 But the deciding factor was the latter's growing fatigue in the final stages. 
 Baddeley is now 28, four years older than his rival. 
 Hall kept him moving and gradually drew the sting from his opponent's game. 
 Hall, in fact, might well have won in straight games, as he led 9-6 in the opening game and then missed four successive smashes to allow Baddeley to go ahead for the first time at 10-9. 
 Baddeley, champion three times in the past, fought grimly and finally took the marathon first game after 24 minutes. 
 But Hall began to dominate, leading 6-0 and then 9-4 before taking the second game to level the match. 
 From 2-3 down in the third Baddeley was outplayed by his fleet-footed opponent. 
 The Sussex man noticeably slowed as Hall continued to switch the play. 
 Then, leading 12-4, Hall took three points running for a convincing victory. 
 Hall, annoyed at being seeded No.2 to Baddeley even though he is the present No.1, refused to labour the point: &bquo;I wanted to prove to everyone that I could play good badminton, not to show the seeding committee to be at fault,&equo; he said. 
 Rugby Union Predatory Cardiff prompt fears of transfer war. 
 By David Plummer 
 WHEN delegates of the Whitbread Merit Table clubs took time off from their deliberations over leagues last week to enjoy a day out at the University Match, they took the opportunity to complain to Cardiff about the legions of players who have made the journey to the Arms Park in recent months. 
 Two members of this summer's Lions squad, Mike Griffiths and Mike Hall, decided to leave Bridgend for Cardiff last week, while the Wales hooker Ian Watkins joined them from Ebbw Vale in August to be followed by Newport's Wales B wing Damien Griffiths and the Abertillery lock Stuart Nunnerley. 
 This week Newbridge's Wales B lock Andy Sutton trained with Cardiff and he too seems likely to join their squad. 
 They could now field a team featuring only two players, Nunnerley and the captain Tim Crothers, who have not been recognised by Wales. 
 Cardiff have always attracted players, but what has fuelled the apprehension of the other Merit Table clubs is that they, along with Newport, are now competing eagerly in the transfer market. 
 The Llanelli and Wales lock Phil May believes that in a couple of years Cardiff will become pre-eminent in Welsh club rugby both because of their magnetic appeal and because of Wales's economic geography. 
 May points to Wales's declining staple industries, such as steel and coal, remarking that new jobs are being created along the M4 basin close to both Cardiff and Newport. 
 With the wealth of connections in the two clubs, and the end of their squeamishness over protocol, May fears that even the two ascendant clubs in Wales &mdash; Llanelli and Neath &mdash; will be hard pressed to compete. 
 Cardiff have certainly adopted an efficient recruitment policy. 
 But they deny that car-park money or the like is finding its way into the pockets of players. 
 With both Cardiff and Newport dormant in recent years, other clubs have benefited from the movement of players; talent has been spread over a wider area. 
 But even then the only player of note Cardiff themselves lost was Mark Ring, and he returned from Pontypool after just a year. 
 The fear of Cardiff's rivals is that, without the same resources, they can only lose in a transfer war, and some are looking to the Welsh Rugby Union for legislative salvation. 
 The WRU yesterday turned down a request by the Merit Table clubs for a meeting tomorrow to discuss the proposed national leagues. 
 The clubs countered by saying they would boycott a scheduled meeting between the WRU's competition sub-committee and the leagues working party. 
 Racing: Little Polvier poised for his third National victory. 
 By Chris Hawkins 
 ARTHUR Stephenson, asked yesterday whether he will run The Thinker in Saturday's Coral Welsh National at Chepstow, replied that he is, &bquo;still thinking on it.&equo; 
 For the bluff, reticent Arthur such wit suggests the Christmas spirit has already got to him but he added realistically that his decision depends on the state of the ground: &bquo;If it's bottomless he won't run.&equo; 
 Chepstow is renowned for its soft ground and even two weeks ago after a prolonged drought the going was on the soft side. 
 The deluge since then must make heavy ground a distinct possibility and with The Thinker doubtful the sponsors current odds of 12-l Little Polveir look outstanding value. 
 Little Polveir is going for the National treble, having already won the Scottish version in 1987 and the Seagram Grand National last season. 
 The common denominator each time was heavy ground. 
 At Aintree he beat The Thinker just over seven lengths and is due to meet him on the same terms, although Jimmy Frost, his rider, may put up a pound or two more than the minimum 10st. 
 Bonanza Boy finished a remote eighth in the race and is 10lb worse off with Little Polveir but it is unwise to judge him on that performance which came at the end of a long season after some punishing contests. 
 It is better to judge him on his reappearance run at Chepstow when, despite being 11 kilos overweight, according to trainer Martin Pipe, he easily disposed of Run And Skip, with Little Polveir beaten out of sight. 
 Take that form literally and there is only one winner on Saturday as Bonanza Boy is bound to have come on for the outing. 
 An extra threequarters of a mile and heavy going puts the race in a different light, however. 
 Little Polveir does not get warmed up until he has gone three miles and Toby Balding has been training him specifically with Saturday in mind. 
 The Hennessy winner, Ghofar, looks nicely treated off bottom weight, including a 4lb penalty, although technically he is still 5lb out of the handicap. 
 Although I have a soft spot for him after his super-game Hennessy win, he does not appeal greatly as 7-2 favourite. 
 He had a hard race at Newbury, following one the previous week behind Man O Magic at Ascot, but as a six-year-old he looks too young for something as gruelling as the Welsh National &mdash; the last six-year-old to win was Miss Gaynus in 1932. 
 Cool Ground is an improving seven-year-old who will love the ground. 
 He won the Kim Muir at the Cheltenham Festival, having previously finished seven lengths second to Roll-A-Joint at Chepstow, with Little Polveir behind, over three and threequarter miles. 
 Roll-A-Joint has been disappointing this season and if he runs will be meeting Cool Ground on a stone worse terms, while Little Polveir is a stone better off with Cool Ground, who, at 10-1, is the other each-way bet. 
 He finished fourth to Baies and The Thinker at Haydock last week, running well for a long way. 
 At Folkestone this afternoon Fit For Firing (1.45) should give us some ammunition. 
 He looked unlucky when a close third to Going Gets Tough at Newbury on his chasing debut and has less to do here. 
 Weights for The Ladbroke Hurdle to be run at Leopardstown on January 13 were announced yesterday. 
 Beech Road has top weight of 12st and is set to give 10lb to his aspiring young stable-companion Morley Street, whom the sponsors make 10-1 joint favourite with Mick O'Toole's Lough Gale. 
 The latter on 9st 2lb needs a rise in the weights. 
 Welsh dairy farmer Sirrell Griffiths is hoping enough rain will fall at Kempton Park before Boxing Day to allow his former point-to-pointer Norton's Coin to take on Desert Orchid in the King George VI Rank Chase. 
 Griffiths trains just three horses at Nantgaredig, Carmarthen, and Norton's Coin is easily the best of them, supplying the permit holder with all his three wins last season. 
 The trainer's wife, Joyce, yesterday said: &bquo;We'd love to run Norton's Coin against &bquo;Dessie&equo; and will do so provided the ground is soft.&equo; 
 &bquo;People think we are mad to take on Desert Orchid, especially as Norton's Coin will probably need the run, but we have nothing to lose. 
 Besides, after winning such a good race as he did at Cheltenham last season when beating Beau Ranger, it is very difficult to find suitable opportunities.&equo; 
 The ten entries are: Ballyhane, Barnbrook Again, Bishops Yarn, Bob Tisdall, Bonanza Boy, Desert Orchid, Norton's Coin, Pegwell Bay, Vodkatini and Yahoo. 
 The Jockey Club has announced it is to look again at the appeals procedure available to parties involved in disciplinary hearings. 
 It follows the controversial case of the &bquo;Beverley 11,&equo; when 11 jockeys were fined for allegedly refusing to obey the starter, which led to considerable debate on the courses of appeal open to the riders. 
 The subject was discussed at a meeting of members of the Jockey Club last week and spokesman David Pipe said today: &bquo;The Stewards have asked the Disciplinary Committee to review the well rehearsed arguments and produce a report in due course.&equo; 
 Cycling Grey Guard goes west. 
 OLYMPIC and world champions from East Germany are poised to join leading Dutch professional teams in 1990, writes William Fotheringham. 
 Potential employers are lining up leading members of the &bquo;Grey Guard&equo;, who have dominated amateur cycling in the 1980s. 
 Uwe Ampler, the 1986 world champion, looks set to ride with Ireland's Sean Kelly in the PDM team. 
 Ampler took gold in the 100km team time-trial in the Seoul Olympics and this year scored his third successive win in the Peace Race, the amateur equivalent of the Tour de France. 
 Jan Schur, a member of the GDR's gold medal-winning 100km team at the world championships in France this year, has also joined PDM. 
 PDM outbid a rival Dutch team, Buckler, who were confident of signing the pair to join their top West German, Rolf Golz. 
 A similar battle is taking place over the Seoul Olympic champion Olaf Ludwig, with the all-West German Stuttgart team fighting Panasonic, who recently paid &pound;400,000 for the Soviet Olympic track champion Vyatcheslav Ekimov. 
 Rowing Henley closes loopholes to block the pot-hunters. 
 By Christopher Dodd 
 HENLEY Royal Regatta has changed qualification rules in an attempt to curb the tendency for &bquo;trophy hunting&equo;. 
 Peter Coni, chairman of the Stewards, announcing the new rules yesterday, criticised a growing number of top crews for entering lesser events at Henley &bquo;rather than showing the ambition and confidence to try to win at a higher level&equo;. 
 Coni said the trend was having a &bquo;seriously adverse effect upon domestic club rowing as a whole&equo;. 
 Some clubs exploited loopholes by entering &bquo;cooked&equo; crews. 
 &bquo;I think we have closed the loopholes now,&equo; he said. 
 One change intended to improve standards at Henley is the exclusion of Olympic and international oarsmen from certain events intended for club crews. 
 The Stewards yesterday reshaped the qualification requirements for the Ladies' Plate, Thames Cup and the corresponding challenge cups for four-oared crews. 
 The Stewards also introduced a new event for eights, the Henley Prize. 
 While the Grand Challenge Cup remains the blue riband open event, the Ladies' Plate reverts to its 1984 qualification, being open to student clubs, with composite crews only admitted from colleges of a single university or two or more schools, and entries being cut from 32 to 16. 
 A new rule for the Thames Cup states that no one &mdash; except coxes &mdash; may compete if they have rowed in an Olympic or heavyweight world championship event. 
 The Thames Cup also reverts to its pre-1984 qualification, being open to any club below Grand level, including student clubs, with no composites but retaining the present 48 starting places. 
 Then comes the Henley Prize for 16 crews from single colleges or schools. 
 The Princess Elizabeth for 32 school crews is unchanged, but the Special Race for Schools, started over a shorter course for those involved in exams, will not be held. 
 Entries for the Diamond Sculls have been reduced from 24 to 16. 
 Rugby League Regal return for King Ellery. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 ELLERY HANLEY will play his first game of the season for Wigan in their Regal Trophy quarter-final replay with Leeds at Central Park tomorrow, and a game already generating considerable interest could now draw a crowd of 20,000. 
 The club have kept this one very quiet as it was not expected that Hanley, who returned from a summer in Australia with a bad pelvic strain, would come back before the New Year. 
 To Leeds the news must have come like a blow from a steam hammer. 
 Wigan had intended to spring the former Great Britain captain on an unsuspecting St Helens, their arch-rivals, on Boxing Day. 
 However in the past few days Hanley has come through a series of rigorous tests, and his return was hastened by the absence of Andy Goodway, who broke a finger at Headingley last Saturday. 
 Hanley has been the most illustrious victim so far of the worrying modern phenomenon known as back-to-back football, which sees players performing practically non-stop here and in Australia. 
 For the game's big money-earners it is a difficult cycle to break, for all its obvious dangers. 
 Hanley's fitness, strength and dedication to the sport compel admiration even among his fellow professionals. 
 But the punishment to his body started to show itself during his summer contract with Western Suburbs, where reputedly he was earning &pound;4,000 a match. 
 For the last month of his contract, Hanley played but did not train. 
 Wigan were dismayed at his condition when he came back, and there was a half-hearted threat from Central Park to demand financial compensation from the Sydney club. 
 He had a successful hernia operation but was a regular visitor to Harley Street as additional deep-seated groin trouble failed to respond to treatment. 
 By November, Wigan were promising to scour the world for a cure, while Hanley in his enforced idleness was reported to be depressed and frustrated. 
 Wigan have not done at all badly without him but his return, to loose forward, could not be more timely. 
 Goodway has been playing with consistent brilliance there this season, scoring 18 tries, but he will now be out for a month, and Hanley is no stranger to the position after spending earlier periods of his career mostly at centre or stand-off. 
 But it matters little where he plays; he is a prolific try scorer from any position, as a career total of 247 touchdowns testifies. 
 He is, indeed, entitled to be described as a great player, Britain's nonpareil of the 1980s, who was eventually recognised as such by even the hardened doubters in Australia after his summer with Balmain in 1988. 
 Leeds, who could not beat Wigan's 12 men on Saturday, cannot have dreamed that Hanley would figure in their pre-match planning. 
 But they have their own good news with the return to fitness of the GB forward Hugh Waddell, out with a broken jaw since November, and David Creasser, who has played only once this season. 
 Golf Faldo forced to take a back seat to Walker Cup team. 
 By David Davies 
 NICK FALDO, undoubtedly the most successful golfer in the world in 1989, collected yet another award in London yesterday when he was made the Ritz Club Golfer of the Year. 
 This goes alongside his BBC Sports Personality of the Year nomination on Sunday and his winning of the polls conducted by, among others, the British Sportswriters, Panasonic-LWT and even the American magazine Golf Digest. 
 Faldo won the US Masters in April by holing a 25ft putt on the second extra hole to beat Scott Hoch, who had missed from inside two feet on the first. 
 Faldo also won the Volvo PGA Championship and the Dunhill British Masters in May and June and, four weeks later, the French Open. 
 He failed to win the Volvo Masters, finishing second to Ronan Rafferty, but nevertheless it was a season of stunning success for the British golfer. 
 But he failed to achieve a clean sweep of the end-of-season awards. 
 The one that eluded him was that of the Association of Golf Writers which, asked to nominate who had done most for European golf, decided on the Walker Cup team that went to the United States and won the trophy there for the first time. 
 Faldo, who has a feud-ridden history with some members of the AGW, could be forgiven for thinking that this is yet another example of a lack of sympathy with his cause. 
 But the fact is that the golf writers have, in the recent past, been thoroughly spoiled for choice. 
 In 1985, when Sandy Lyle won the Open Championship and Bernhard Langer won the US Masters, the writers' choice was the Ryder Cup team and when Faldo himself won the Open in 1987 it was again the Ryder Cup team, who won in America, who were selected. 
 As Diane Bailey's Curtis Cup team were chosen in 1986 that means that in four of the past five years a team have come top of the poll. 
 It was always likely that this would happen again this year, given that the Walker Cup team were making history whereas Faldo, for all his brilliance, was the second Briton and the fourth European in the Eighties to win at Augusta. 
 Sailing Britain wait for protest news. 
 BRITAIN closed on the two teams ahead of them in the NorTel Southern Cross Cup series when Juno IV finished fourth, Heaven Can Wait seventh and Canon Express tenth in the fourth race yesterday &mdash; and there is a protest to be heard against two of the New South Wales team who lead the series, 11.5 points ahead of Australia and 21.5 ahead of Britain, writes Bob Fisher. 
 The protest is by Hong Kong's Foo2 against Cyclone and Great News, second and third yesterday behind the 83ft Drumbeat which claimed her third handicap win of the series by 3 &frac12;min. 
 Tennis &pound;4 million cup goes ahead. 
 THE Grand Slam Cup will go ahead next December despite the opposition of the Association of Tennis Professionals and the West German federation. 
 The International Tennis Federation yesterday reaffirmed its commitment to the new &pound;4 million event but said it was still discussing objections with the ATP. 
 But an ITF spokesman, Ian Barnes, added that there was little chance of merging the &pound;4 million event with the ATP finals three weeks earlier. 
 Barnes said Munich, Dortmund, Berlin and Stuttgart were interested in staging the new cup tournament. 
 Badminton: Hall runs Baddeley to ground. 
 By Richard Jago 
 DARREN HALL, seemingly able to run for ever, won the Oracle English National Championship for the fourth time in five years at Crawley last night. 
 Combining powerful smashes with deft drop-shots, Hall beat Steve Baddeley 15-18, 15-4, 15-4 in a 66-minute final. 
 Hall's speed was matched against the slightly greater power of Baddeley. 
 But the deciding factor was the latter's growing fatigue in the final stages. 
 Baddeley is now 28, four years older than his rival, and Hall kept him moving until he drew the sting from his opponent's game. 
 Hall, in fact, might well have won in straight games, as he led 9-6 in the opening game and then missed four successive smashes to allow Baddeley to go ahead for the first time at 10-9. 
 Baddeley, champion three times in the past, fought grimly and finally took the marathon first game after 24 minutes. 
 But Hall began to dominate, leading 6-0 and then 9-4 before taking the second game. 
 From 2-3 down in the third Baddeley was outplayed as Hall continued to switch the play. 
 Eventually, leading 12-4, Hall took three points running for a convincing victory. 
 But, despite his annoyance at being seeded No.2 to Baddeley even though he is the present No.1, he declined to labour the point afterwards. 
 Later Fiona Smith, who had beaten her greatest rival Helen Troke in the Commonwealth Cup at Bath last month, did so again in the women's singles final. 
 Smith, the England No.1, beat Troke 11-1, 11-7 in 27 minutes to take the title for the fifth time in seven years. 
 Outlook brighter for Grima. 
 THERE were compensations yesterday for Joe Grima, the New Zealand forward deeply upset on Monday after being struck off Widnes's register, writes Paul Fitzpatrick. 
 Not the least was his obvious popularity. 
 Swinton, who sold him to Widnes for only &pound;7,500 in January last year, would like him back. 
 Salford are in the bidding, Oldham are keeping a keen eye on him and St Helens are reportedly interested. 
 It could also be that Widnes's match with Barrow last Sunday will be deducted from his current eight-match suspension. 
 He will not, though, be able to work off the remaining seven games until he joins a new club. 
 The League, who will discuss Grima's case today, has confirmed that Widnes are within their rights to demand a fee even though they have cancelled his registration with two years of his contract left. 
 Widnes's coach, Doug Laughton, says that the asking price will be &bquo;realistic&equo; so as to enable Grima to move quickly to a new club. 
 Also under discussion today will be the inclusion of Boblyn Tuavao &mdash; the Tongan forward who has replaced Grima as the club's third overseas player &mdash; in the Widnes side which beat Barrow at Craven Park last Sunday. 
 His registration was received at headquarters after Friday's 5 pm deadline and strictly the Tongan was ineligible. 
 But Laughton says the situation is ridiculous, claiming that the League was aware of Tuavao five weeks ago when Widnes attempted to have their hooker, the Australian Phil McKenzie, reclassed as a non-overseas player. 
 The disciplinary &bquo;purge&equo; took a curious turn yesterday with the one-match suspension of a referee and two touch judges for &bquo;failing to meet necessary standards&equo;. 
 Warrington's Silk Cut Challenge Cup first-round match with Featherstone Rovers on Saturday, January 27 will be televised by the BBC. 
 Brazil exiles can tax Dutch. 
 BRAZIL can strike a psychological blow for South America's World Cup hopes tonight when they play a weakened Holland, the European champions in name if not substance, in Rotterdam in the Dutch FA centenary fixture that England abandoned because of fears of hooliganism, writes David Lacey. 
 The Brazilians, who beat Italy 1-0 in Bologna in October, have available their European exiles plus Bebeto, the exciting Vasco da Gama striker, and Ricardo Rocha, the Sao Paulo defender. 
 With the Brazilian championship decided, both have been released by their clubs. 
 Sebastiao Lazaroni, Brazil's team manager, may even put Romario, who has scored 50 goals in 51 games for PSV Eindhoven, on the bench in order to pair Bebeto with Careca of Napoli. 
 This would raise a wry smile from the Dutch manager, Thijs Libregts, who is finding it hard to discover a matching pair. 
 Ruud Gullit is injured and Ronnie Koeman, the Barcelona libero, has been ordered to rest for a week, and Milan, having won the World Club Championship in Tokyo, have advised Rijkaard and Van Basten not to play in Rotterdam. 
 In addition, Holland's four Mechelen players &mdash; Bosman, Erwin Koeman, Rutjes and Hofkens &mdash; are needed by the Belgian club. 
 To give his team some credibility without upsetting Milan, Libregts may give Rijkaard and Van Basten half a game, but much will depend on Wouters, Van Tiggelen, Kieft and Ellerman. 
 Brazil are unbeaten in 14 internationals since losing to Sweden, Denmark and Switzerland last June. 
 During this run they won the South American Championship for the first time in 40 years and qualified for the World Cup. 
 England meet them at Wembley on March 28, the date left vacant by the cancellation of the friendly against the Republic of Ireland. 
 Fifa set to stamp on pro foul. 
 THE FA's attempt to outlaw the professional foul, vetoed by Fifa seven years ago, may now receive official backing from the world body, writes David Lacey. 
 Graham Kelly, the FA's chief executive, hopes the idea will be adopted by the International Board when it meets in Rome next June. 
 Kelly has been asked to prepare a discussion document by the FA's referees committee. 
 &bquo;I was encouraged by the way the idea was received by Sepp Blatter, Fifa's general secretary, when I met him last month,&equo; Kelly said yesterday, &bquo;and I've also been encouraged by his comments since then.&equo; 
 The FA tried to stamp out the professional foul, a euphemism for cheating, at the start of the 1982-83 season. 
 Referees were encouraged to send off offenders for &bquo;serious foul play&equo; through a stricter interpretation of the laws. 
 Particular note was made of defenders and goalkeepers who brought down attackers breaking through and likely to score. 
 But Fifa objected, with the president, Joao Havelange, demanding &bquo;the abolition of the system introduced in the English League of sending off players who commit deliberate fouls to prevent a goal&equo;. 
 This, remember, was said only a few months after Battiston of France suffered a serious neck injury when Schumacher, the West German goalkeeper, brutally bodychecked him in a World Cup semi-final. 
 Clamping down on the professional foul does not need a change of law, simply a change of emphasis by referees. 
 However the FA is to put a proposal in Rome to modify the offside law so that &bquo;interfering with play&equo; becomes &bquo;seeking to interfere with play&equo; in the hope of reducing the number of involuntary offsides. 
 The suggestion will be coupled with the proposal by the Scottish FA that a player no longer be offside if he is in line with the last defender when the ball is played. 
 Edwards hangs on to shares and control of United. 
 MARTIN EDWARDS, chairman and chief executive of Manchester United, insisted after a four-hour board meeting at Old Trafford yesterday that he would still not be rushed into selling his majority shareholding, writes Stephen Bierley. 
 In a brief statement Edwards said: &bquo;I have told my board colleagues that I will not be rushed and will come to a decision towards the end of the season.&equo; 
 Amer Midani, United's second largest shareholder, had apparently annoyed Edwards last weekend by with his call for the public flotation of the shares. 
 Midani and his fellow director Nigel Burrows had hoped to buy out Edwards once Michael Knighton's takeover had fallen through. 
 But Edwards is believed to have increased his price from &pound;10 million to nearer &pound;30 million. 
 Despite considerable pressure, much of it from outside the club, there was little chance of a decision being taken yesterday. 
 Edwards has emphasised, ever since the annual meeting two weeks ago when he used his majority shareholding to secure Knighton a place on the United board that he would make his decision at the end of this season. 
 However, with attendances falling and United facing a potentially damaging FA Cup third-round draw away to Nottingham Forest, Edwards's hand may yet be forced. 
 By Stephen Bierley 
 MARTIN EDWARDS, chairman and chief executive of Manchester United, insisted after a four-hour board meeting at Old Trafford yesterday that he would still not be rushed into selling his majority shareholding. 
 In a brief statement Edwards said: &bquo;I have told my board colleagues that I will not be rushed and will come to a decision towards the end of the season.&equo; 
 Amer Midani, United's second largest shareholder, had apparently annoyed Edwards last weekend by calling for the public flotation of the shares. 
 Midani and his fellow director Nigel Burrows had hoped to buy out Edwards once Michael Knighton's takeover had fallen through. 
 But Edwards, who was prepared to accept &pound;10 million from Knighton, is believed to want nearer &pound;30 million now. 
 Despite considerable pressure, much of it from outside the club, there was little chance of any crucial decision being taken yesterday. 
 Edwards has emphasised, ever since the annual meeting two weeks ago when he used his majority shareholding to secure Knighton a place on the board, that he would make his decision at the end of this season. 
 However, with attendances falling and United facing a potentially damaging FA Cup third-round draw away to Nottingham Forest, Edwards's hand may yet be forced. 
 Liverpool call for British Cup. 
 LIVERPOOL yesterday revived the idea of a British Cup to increase revenue and capture the imagination of English fans starved of top-class midweek football by the European ban. 
 Peter Robinson, Liverpool's chief executive, said the plan for top English, Scottish and Irish clubs to play a knock-out competition had been the basis for the agreement to reduce the First Division. 
 Liverpool and other members of the Big Five have rejected the Zenith Data Cup. 
 Robinson says: &bquo;We are playing on average 10 games less than when in Europe, and the fans aren't happy.&equo; 
 Steve Bull is taking a two-day break from training. 
 The Wolves manager Graham Turner said the striker's first full England game last week had tired him so soon after a three-match ban. 
 The FA, with Football Trust assistance, must find &pound;100,000 to cover the cost of sending English police the World Cup. 
 The Government are not contributing. 
 Oldham have signed the 20-year-old Manchester United reserve left-back Wayne Heseltine for &pound;40,000. 
 North 30, Soviet Union XV 14 Heslop undoes Soviets. 
 By Our Correspondent 
 AN ICY reception awaited the Soviet Union touring side at Aspatria last night, but they did their reputation no harm by providing a stern test. 
 It was a good contest that will have given the England team manager Geoff Cooke at least one hint about filling the vacant places in his training squad for Lanzarote in the new year. 
 The Orrell wing Nigel Heslop scored two blistering tries to push his claim, opening the scoring with a scintillating try which Strett converted. 
 But Dzagnidze then followed his own kick for a try in the corner, and Mironov swept through for a try that Dzagnidze converted. 
 Strett had already restored the North's lead when Bryan Barley intercepted a Soviet move on his own 22 and Stuart Holmes released Heslop who galloped 50 metres for a superb try that Strett converted. 
 Strett soon afterwards worked a scissors with Hunter who raced clear of the cover for a try. 
 Strett again converted. 
 In the dying minutes Alexander Tikhonov scored a try; but almost immediately Bob Kimmins forced his way over for the final try, with Strett, almost inevitably, converting. 
 NORTH: I Hunter (Northampton); S Burnhill (Sale), B Barley (Wakefield), G Childs (Northern), N Heslop; M Strett (both Orrell), N Summers (Headingley); M Whitcombe (Sale), N Hitchen, S Southern (capt), R Kimmins, D Cusani (all Orrell), S Hodgson (Sale), S Gallagher (Waterloo), S Holmes (Cambridge University; D Cleary, Orrell, 68 min). 
 SOVIET UNION: N Dzagnidze; E Zvev, I Necheaev, M Parshin, I Mironov (capt); I Kuperman, I Frantzuzov; Z Bakiradze, R Malikov, S Molchanov, A Sokolov, S Sergeev, V Negodin (B Koroliov, 40), A Tikhonov, I Khairulin. 
 Referee: M Bayliss (Gloucester). 
 Zenith Data Systems Challenge Cup: Rangers 1, Arsenal 2 Davis leads way towards a minor satisfaction. 
 By Our Correspondent 
 EVEN Arsenal, who carried the distinction back to London, would not claim that they played well enough in Glasgow last night to be the undisputed champions of anywhere, no matter the vainglorious subtitle given to this friendly. 
 They were, though, marginally the more inventive in a game that showed signs of decline from the early stages. 
 The so-called unofficial championship of Great Britain was in trouble from the outset. 
 The kick-off had to be delayed because of a motorway accident, which left a decimated attendance of 31,000 in spite of a delayed start to facilitate the inconvenienced. 
 Worse was to follow for Rangers as Graham Souness's side, without the prolific McCoist, went a goal behind after 27 minutes of adisappointing game. 
 Arsenal's scorer was Paul Davis, playing his first game since April because of injury. 
 He looked as if he had been conserving all his energy since then for the moment when he took advantage of an error by Butcher to shoot strongly past Woods. 
 A long kick-out by Lukic was mistimed by the England defender and Davis seized on the ball to score from 20 yards without breaking stride. 
 Butcher was not the only one to look less than dazzling in front of the watching England manager Bobby Robson. 
 Tony Adams was uncertain at the heart of Arsenal's defence and those on the periphery of Robson's thoughts prior to the World Cup, such as Rangers' Steven and Walters, did themselves no favours. 
 It could have been worse for Rangers. 
 Merson had the opportunity to extend Arsenal's lead when Gough and Butcher misread one another's intentions but, in keeping with the general tone, he was well off the mark. 
 The loss of Gough after the interval was another setback for Souness. 
 It is only two weeks since Gough came back from a multiple fracture of the cheekbone. 
 He was injured again when Quinn's boot made accidental contact with his face. 
 The idea of the night being irrevocably jinxed for Rangers seemed in doubt when Ferguson's cross was chested over the line by Johnston for the equaliser in the 50th minute. 
 But Quinn restored Arsenal's lead six minutes later, touching home a pass by Merson across the face of Rangers' goal. 
 Rangers: Woods; Stevens, Munro, Gough, Spackman, Butcher, Steven, Ferguson, Walters, Johnston, Brown. 
 Arsenal: Lukic; Dixon, Winterburn, Davis, O'Leary, Adams, Rocastle, Richardson, Merson, Quinn, Marwood. 
 Referee: D Syme (Rutherglen). 
 Ernie Walker, the retiring secretary of the SFA, said yesterday that Scottish football could have a two-month winter shut-down scheduled for as early as next season. 
 He said that all Premier Division clubs had indicated their approval. 
 PAGE 
 Zenith Data Systems Challenge Cup: Rangers 1, Arsenal 2 Davis leads way towards a minor satisfaction. 
 By Our Correspondent 
 EVEN Arsenal, who carried the distinction back to London, would not claim that they played well enough in Glasgow last night to be the undisputed champions of anywhere, no matter the vainglorious subtitle given to this friendly. 
 They were, though, marginally the more inventive in a game that showed signs of decline from the early stages. 
 The so-called unofficial championship of Great Britain was in trouble from the outset. 
 The kick-off had to be delayed because of a motorway accident, which left a decimated attendance of 31,000 in spite of a delayed start to facilitate the inconvenienced. 
 Worse was to follow for Rangers as Graham Souness's side, without the prolific McCoist, went a goal behind after 27 minutes of adisappointing game. 
 Arsenal's scorer was Paul Davis, playing his first game since April because of injury. 
 He looked as if he had been conserving all his energy since then for the moment when he took advantage of an error by Butcher to shoot strongly past Woods. 
 A long kick-out by Lukic was mistimed by the England defender and Davis seized on the ball to score from 20 yards without breaking stride. 
 Butcher was not the only one to look less than dazzling in front of the watching England manager Bobby Robson. 
 Tony Adams was uncertain at the heart of Arsenal's defence and those on the periphery of Robson's thoughts prior to the World Cup, such as Rangers' Steven and Walters, did themselves no favours. 
 It could have been worse for Rangers. 
 Merson had the opportunity to extend Arsenal's lead when Gough and Butcher misread one another's intentions but, in keeping with the general tone, he was well off the mark. 
 The loss of Gough after the interval was another setback for Souness. 
 It is only two weeks since Gough came back from a multiple fracture of the cheekbone. 
 He was injured again when Quinn's boot made accidental contact with his face. 
 The idea of the night being irrevocably jinxed for Rangers seemed in doubt when Ferguson's cross was chested over the line by Johnston for the equaliser in the 50th minute. 
 But Quinn restored Arsenal's lead six minutes later, touching home a pass by Merson across the face of Rangers' goal. 
 Rangers: Woods; Stevens, Munro, Gough, Spackman, Butcher, Steven, Ferguson, Walters, Johnston, Brown. 
 Arsenal: Lukic; Dixon, Winterburn, Davis, O'Leary, Adams, Rocastle, Richardson, Merson, Quinn, Marwood. 
 Referee: D Syme (Rutherglen). 
 Ernie Walker, the retiring secretary of the SFA, said yesterday that Scottish football could have a two-month winter shut-down scheduled for as early as next season. 
 He said that all Premier Division clubs had indicated their approval. 
 FA Cup second round, second replay Reading 0, Welling 0 (aet) Senior discovers angels on the side of the Wings. 
 By Ian Ridley 
 NIGHTS such as these are forgotten when FA Cup final day comes around, the sun shines and two of the game's more illustrious names are competing. 
 Last night at Elm Park the rain lashed down, the wind howled and the quest was for memories and money &mdash; and a goal. 
 It would not come despite chances galore, especially for Reading and Trevor Senior &mdash; although in a heart-stopping moment for the home side Neil Clemmence headed against the bar with 10 seconds of normal time left &mdash; and the tie will resume at Welling tomorrow. 
 Welling have stuck to Reading like chewing gum to the sole of a shoe. 
 Each time Reading threatened to overwhelm, back came Welling &mdash; in last week's first replay with an equalising goal inside two minutes. 
 So it proved last night. 
 After an early fright, when Hone half-volleyed a good chance high for Welling, Senior had a header saved well by Barron, Payne sent another over and Gilkes, Reading's most dangerous player, was just too high with a powerful shot. 
 Senior did once turn the ball into the net but David Elleray was more alert than the referee of England's 1986 World Cup tie against Argentina and had noticed the hand of a mere mortal. 
 When Tait miskicked in front of a gaping goal, it seemed as though somebody up there was working for Welling. 
 But then Booker miscued the rebound from Clemmence's late header against the bar after White's good cross as Welling, remarkably, finished normal time the stronger. 
 Senior, twice, Whitlock and Wood, once each, headed at the Welling goal in extra-time but the Wings did not deserve to be clipped. 
 Sunderland will have to wait a little longer before knowing whether to turn left or right on to the M25. 
 Reading: Burns; Jones, Richardson, Beavon, Hicks, Whitlock, Wood, Tait (Leworthy, 66min), Senior, Gilkes, Payne. 
 Welling: Barron; Hone, Horton, Glover, Ransom, Clemmence, White (Burgess, 112), Handford, Booker, Robbins, Reynolds. 
 Referee: D Elleray (Harrow). 
 Boxing Board may stop Benn v Duran. 
 By John Rodda 
 NIGEL BENN's arrival on the world championship stage may have to be delayed or diverted to another country. 
 The British Boxing Board of Control, in a commendable exercise to shore up the credibility of the sport yesterday, questioned the plan for Benn to challenge one of boxing's legends, Roberto Duran, for his middleweight title. 
 It does so on two grounds: that Duran is no longer a champion and that he may not be fit. 
 John Morris, the board's secretary, has already suggested to the World Boxing Council that, since Duran was inside the middleweight limit when he lost to Sugar Ray Leonard, he should have lost that title, even though the pair were fighting for the world super-middleweight championship. 
 Dr Adrian Whiteson, the board's chief medical officer, said that, if Duran came to fight in Britain, he would want assurances about his weight. 
 Clearly Whiteson is suspicious that Duran may not have shed 30lb to get down to the middleweight limit for Leonard by wholly natural methods. 
 &bquo;Duran does boxing no service by allowing himself to become so unfit,&equo; Whiteson said. 
 &bquo;He was a shadow of his former self and a boxer cannot go into the ring semi-fit. 
 &bquo;He should have an intensive medical examination and a complete psychological assessment before he could be considered to box Benn for that title. 
 &bquo;We must protect the name of boxing. 
 I don't want any more Alis in the world in the shape of Duran or any other boxer. 
 It is difficult enough to defend boxing.&equo; 
 In another move which shows that the board intends to live up to the word &bquo;control&equo; in its title, it sent a message to the Dominion Theatre in Tottenham Court Road, where Frank Bruno is playing in Aladdin, to the effect that Bruno will not be able to rub his genie's lamp and in a puff of smoke reappear in a world title fight. 
 &bquo;We would expect to see him in a couple of warm-up fights, certainly someone in the top 10, before he fights Mike Tyson again, if that is to happen,&equo; said Morris. 
 Since there are plans for Tyson to come to Britain in July, Bruno could have a busy spring in the ring after he finishes on the boards in February. 
 He has not fought since he lost to Tyson in February and he indicated only last week that he would be prepared to fight again. 
 The board reports that the sport is in a healthy state. 
 It has 709 active professional fighters, with 280 tournaments promoted this year, both figures the highest since 1954. 
 Britain has more professional boxers than the rest of Europe put together. 
 BOOKS FOR CHRISTMAS. 
 Running away with himself 
 John Rodda enjoys a detailed study of Sydney Wooderson 
 SYDNEY WOODERSON and Zola Budd did not have much in common but they knew a special achievement and a peculiar failure. 
 They also shared the deep satisfaction which running brings, often more in preparation than in the race itself. 
 Their achievement was in pushing back the frontiers of distance running with world records. 
 Their failure was that, because of man's inhumanity to his fellow beings, they did not fulfil their potential. 
 Hitler's war deprived Wooderson of going into the Olympic arena in Helsinki in 1940 as a hot favourite for the 1500 metres; Budd's natural progression was hindered by her country's policy of apartheid. 
 This year there have been publications about both. 
 David Thurlow's Sydney Wooderson, Forgotten Champion, to celebrate the runner's 75th year, is a simple record of the man's achievements on the track; it is riveting. 
 Budd's tome Zola, written for her, pours out the turmoil and blame for the five years she spent trying to run with a foot in two worlds. 
 Too many people, pulling in various directions, mostly clinging to a percentage of her value, made her into the rag doll she often appeared on the track. 
 In the unpolluted air of the Thirties there were no such problems for Wooderson. 
 Running was his hobby, centred on the loyalty which a club like Blackheath Harriers generated. 
 If Wooderson was any different from his fellows it was that he tried harder; he had the old equivalent of tunnel vision, enhanced by a coach, Albert Hill, who had won the 800 and 1500 metres at a single Olympics. 
 What astonished everyone, from the time he started winning schools races to the glorious battles at the White City after the war, was that such a weedy looking person could perform such feats. 
 How did a man of 5ft 6in produce such an enormous stride in his sprint finish? 
 His rivals must have wondered too. 
 Thurlow concentrates on vividly detailed description of his races, mostly in the style of the time. 
 How did Wooderson get to Motspur Park? 
 On the train? 
 And were there ever family squabbles which ruined a race? 
 Probably not but, if there were, they are not part of this story. 
 Such things are left to Budd. 
 Thurlow's story is strictly that of a man pursuing his hobby and getting more and more embarrassed as the public eye focused upon him. 
 The first pinnacle of his athletic achievement should have been at the Berlin Olympics in 1936. 
 He had beaten the New Zealander Jack Lovelock in the AAA mile &mdash; one of five consecutive championship victories &mdash; but Lovelock, the more experienced runner, was using the race chiefly to see how and when this little man used that devastating sprint. 
 But they did not meet in Berlin. 
 Apart from one session a day, Wooderson's training included long walks with his brother Stanley. 
 On one of these he stubbed his foot in a rabbit hole and twisted his ankle. 
 He ran in his Olympic heat with the injury strapped but the pain was excruciating and he failed to reach the final. 
 He had broken a bone. 
 Would Wooderson have beaten Lovelock? 
 The runner himself thinks not. 
 &bquo;I think the ordeal of the big occasion would have affected me and my nerves would have got the better of me. 
 He &lsqb;Lovelock&rsqb; was more experienced at running in major races. 
 He had been running in international events since the Olympics of 1932.&equo; 
 Of course Wooderson could get things wrong &mdash; like the time he went for the British mile record and broke the world time. 
 But 1940 would surely have been a different tale, if 1937 and 1938 were anything to go by. 
 The last Briton to hold the world mile record, WG George in 1886 with a time of 4min 12 &frac34;sec, was at Motspur Park on August 28 to watch Wooderson's attempt. 
 Pacemaking then was more predictable than now; in a well-organised handicap someone like Wooderson always had a target just ahead. 
 The event had all the highs and lows of a record attempt. 
 The first quarter was in 58.6sec, and this 17 years before the first four-minute mile. 
 But by the end of the third lap the pace had slouched to 3min 7.2sec. 
 In that final quarter, though, Wooderson had a lot of people to pass &mdash; on the inside, of course, for this was a gentlemen's race &mdash; and he zipped smoothly from one to the next to the finish line. 
 The watches were stopped and everyone held breath as the timekeepers turned for consultation with the track referee. 
 That clearly meant a record &mdash; a world record of 4min 6.4sec. 
 &bquo;I was only aiming for the British record,&equo; Wooderson declared in a state of shock which caused him sleepless nights for a week. 
 The following year he was back to Motspur Park to attack the half-mile record, a distance he did not often run. 
 He had never done faster than 1min 54sec before 1938 and he was attacking 1min 49.8sec. 
 Yet again he eked out his resources across the two laps to set a new best of 1min 48.4sec. 
 That was virtually the end of his two-lap running but his miling exploits continued, stubbed by the war and an attack of glandular fever. 
 Yet he was to run faster, 4min 4.2sec, and run arguably his most significant mile race at the White City in the first post-war match. 
 Britain was a long time recovering after 1945. 
 Though Wooderson failed to beat the two healthy Swedes Gundar Hagg and Arne Andersson before 54,000 people, his effort lifted the spirits at a time when, without the tension of war, there was still the dreariness of rationing and shortage. 
 It was the sort of contribution to British life which might have brought him an honour. 
 Perhaps he declined it. 
 But that performance and the world record before the war inspired one young spectator at the White City, Roger Bannister, who was to run the first four-minute mile nine years later, and set off a string of British world record breakers, Derek Ibbotson, Sebastian Coe, Steve Ovett and Steve Cram. 
 Wooderson continued running for a few years, winning the European 5,000 metres and stretching his span of achievement from world record breaker at half-mile to national cross-country champion over nine miles in 1949. 
 As Thurlow sums him up, &bquo;in everyday life he was a small insignificant man in an ordinary suit&hellip; but take off the uniform of the city solicitor and put on the running singlet and the track shoes and the transformation was amazing&equo;. 
 Within the sport his contribution was always acknowledged; outside, it never properly was. 
 Sydney Wooderson &mdash; Forgotten Champion by David Thurlow; British Sports Association for the Disabled, 34 Osnaburgh St, London NW1, &pound;4.95 plus 50p pandp. 
 Zola by Zola Budd and Hugh Eley; Partridge Press, &pound;12.95. 
 Sports Politics Call for cash facts on Games. 
 LIBERAL Democrats on Sheffield City Council are asking to be told about the financial state of GB Universiade, the company organising the World Student Games in 1991, writes John Rodda. 
 The council this week announced that the company has cash-flow problems. 
 Further meetings examining the situation went on yesterday and the council plans to make an announcement today. 
 &bquo;Hopefully we will have some good news about the television contract,&equo; said Cllr Peter Price, the council's deputy leader and the man behind the project to bring the Games to Sheffield. 
 However, David Chadwick, a member of the Liberal Democrats group on the council, said: &bquo;All my requests to the chief executive of the council for financial details about this company have been turned down. 
 We must know whether this company is insolvent and therefore whether it should continue trading.&equo; 
 The council is providing the Games infrastructure at a cost of over &pound;100 million, and has three leading members among the directors of GB Universiade. 
 At the next council meeting on January 3 the Liberal Democrats intend to call for the resignation of the three &mdash; Price, the council leader Clive Betts, and Mrs J C Barton, chairman of the education committee, all Labour members &mdash; on the grounds of conflict of interest. 
 Ashes used in ratings ploy. 
 THE loss-making Sky Television is hoping to boost its poor ratings with live ball-by-ball coverage of England's 1990-91 Ashes tour of Australia. 
 Pictures produced by Australia's Channel 9 will be screened at 10.0 or 11.0 pm through to the next morning. 
 Sky is also showing the World Series Cup, comprising 16 one-day internationals between Australia, England and New Zealand. 
 The station is already showing live coverage of England's tour of the West Indies next year. 
 Soccer London fighters are let off lightly. 
 By David Lacey 
 THE Football Association revealed a velvet hand in an iron glove last night when they fined Wimbledon and West Ham United a mere &pound;20,000 each after finding the clubs guilty of bringing the game into disrepute following a 17-man fracas during the Littlewoods Cup tie at Upton Park on November 22. 
 Much heavier punishments had been expected. 
 Each club have been fined the same amount as Arsenal, who were found to be the less culpable party in the mass scuffle with Norwich City on November 4. 
 Norwich, who in spite of an outstandingly good record of behaviour were fined &pound;50,000, must be wondering if this is the same Football Association who dealt with them so severely only last month. 
 Fines of at least &pound;50,000 were being widely predicted yesterday and there was speculation that Wimbledon's punishment might even top the &pound;75,000 Chelsea had to pay last year after crowd trouble at Stamford Bridge. 
 Wimbledon had been expected to bear the brunt of the FA's displeasure because of their past record. 
 They had already been hauled up eight times, the first during the summer of 1981, and had been fined a total of &pound;23,200. 
 &bquo;The commission took into consideration their record over the past five years,&equo; said Graham Kelly, the FA's chief executive, &bquo;but they also noted that they had taken steps to improve it over the last 18 months.&equo; 
 Another pointer in favour of Wimbledon and West Ham was that the clubs had already taken action or announced their intention to take action against certain players involved in the incident. 
 When Norwich and Arsenal appeared at Lancaster Gate the FA was concerned not only that neither club had condemned the incident immediately but that Norwich had not given any indication that they were going to punish some of their players, apart from fining them for making comments to newspapers. 
 &bquo;The commission took into consideration the fact that the Wimbledon manager, Bobby Gould, was recommending to his board of directors that action should be taken against one particular player for his part at Upton Park,&equo; said Kelly. 
 The incident occurred a minute before half-time after a tackle from Dennis Wise, Wimbledon's England B winger. 
 &bquo;They had regard for the previous exemplary record of West Ham and the fact that they have already taken action against their players concerned,&equo; Kelly added. 
 Julian Dicks, the West Ham captain, was sent off in the 61st minute for a late tackle on Wise and the referee, Alf Buksh, needed a police escort at the end of the tie, which West Ham won 1-0. 
 Lou Macari, the West Ham manager, was reported to have said it was impossible to control players once they had taken the field. 
 Gould's post-match view was: &bquo;I don't think anybody is pleased to see that on a football field.&equo; 
 Buksh booked five people including the Wimbledon physiotherapist, Steve Allen, and in his report to the FA mentioned &bquo;an unruly disturbance&equo;. 
 It was this, plus echoes of the Arsenal-Norwich affair, that prompted the FA to follow its own precedent by bringing further disrepute charges against clubs rather than individual players. 
 Kelly implied that each case had been judged on its merits, but the previous fines were criticised by politicians and police as being too lenient and the FA can expect more of the same after its latest decision. 
 Kelly and the FA are determined to press ahead with plans to harden up the rules for next season in order to deduct League points from clubs who offend. 
 In the meantime all those due to appear in the FA Cup third round in the New Year have received a letter from Lancaster Gate reminding them that the FA has the power to throw them out of the competition if their players become involved in mass brawls. 
 Times change but the victims don't Television. 
 By Hugh Hebert 
 WITH the continent the way it is, the end of Made in Latin America (BBC-2) was inevitable. 
 It was the shooting dead in August of Colombia's poll-topping Liberal presidential candidate, Senator Luis Carlos Galan. 
 He arrived at the crowded town square near Bogota and was born shoulder high to climb up onto the back of a truck to make his campaign speech. 
 The shots sounded like no more than a bad cough. 
 True, there was the other mass gathering-a packed hall in Medellin, Drug City, listening as poets challenged the deadly fluence of the Mafia through writing that has the characteristics of war work: defiant, angry, and sad. 
 But what you carry away in the back of your eye is the image of two very still figures, in foetal folds, on the platform of that truck as everyone else dived for cover. 
 Mike Dibb's series has been sometimes confusing, lacking in structure. 
 But it has made us aware of the crusted, jewel-bright variety of Latin America behind things that more often lump its nations together. 
 Drugs, debt, dictators, destitution, maracas, machismo, priests, peasants, tangos&hellip; 
 The Venezuelan poet Juan Liscano sits by the sea and tells us that Europeans &bquo;tend to classify us as exotic birds-parrots, or toucans&hellip;&equo; 
 But the truest expression of Latin America, he says, is its culture. 
 You shake a sheaf of poems in the face of killers; you do paintings with Uncle Sam as an anaconda; and writers talk of five centuries of resistance to oppressors who may change-colonists, missionaries, generals, coke bosses-but whose victims remain the same. 
 That is one kind of identity. 
 Bandung File (C4) also ended last night-really ended, the last programme of its fourth and last series, for reasons still not clear-with a profile of the only Arab ever to win the Nobel Prize for literature, the Egyptian novelist and poet Naguib Mahfouz. 
 He took the cameras round the back alleys of Gamalliyya, the district of Old Cairo where most of his books are set. 
 A district that in this film still looks like a Bible story invaded by the internal combustion engine. 
 The street names, he tells us, have stayed the same since the 10th century. 
 Traditionally there was no distinction in Arabic between the language used in conversation, in correspondence, or in literature. 
 That distinction is recent, stemming partly from Mahfouz's determination to make language match his theme. 
 His use of Arabic, we're told, is as different from the traditional forms as Dickens is from Chaucer. 
 It sounds like a man who has squashed five centuries of a nation's literature in his palm. 
 His early work about the alleys of Gamalliyya was fundamentally on the side of the revolution-the one that failed to dislodge the British in 1919, and that finally threw out Farouk and brought Neguib and later Nasser to rule Egypt. 
 After Nasser, he says, his themes seemed to refer to a vanished society and for five years Mahfouz wrote no books. 
 When he began writing again, he had given up realism for allegory about the conflict between, among other things, science and religion. 
 And the traditional religious leaders did not like it. 
 Mahfouz was applying the spirit of scientific inquiry to spiritual matters. 
 The row erupted again when he won the Nobel last year, and the citation named the offending work. 
 But this time the religious extremists' anger took a more dangerous form. 
 The death threats began. 
 The threats are threats, not official sentences. 
 Unlike Salman Rushdie, he can still take his walks through the back streets of his chosen city. 
 Now, he says, he has a great desire to write. 
 But the themes elude him. 
 And you can't really be surprised. 
 Diary. 
 By Andrew Moncur 
 SEASON'S greetings to Sir Gordon Manzie, chief executive of the Property Services Agency. 
 He has been traipsing about, explaining to staff the joys of privatisation which await them. 
 No fewer than 23,000 copies of a glossy PSA calendar have been given to the troops. 
 These feature such triumphs of design in the Government service as Richmond House, workplace of K.Clarke, the ambulance crews' friend. 
 That building was valued by a private firm &mdash; well, it's that sort of Government &mdash; at a cost of &pound;40,000. 
 It eventually emerged, after dogged questioning in parliament, that the PSA would have done the same job for &pound;1,500. 
 Anyway, off goes Sir Gordon to Ashdown House, Hastings, home of about 1,000 agency staff. 
 A rostrum is prepared. 
 In front of it, lumme, a pile of 650-odd PSA calendars. 
 Unwanted gifts. 
 &bquo;Dear Sir Gordon,&equo; says a note, &bquo;&hellip; 
 We should be helping to conserve the environment and discouraging the unnecessary destruction of trees.&equo; 
 And what happened after he visited his Scottish HQ in Edinburgh? 
 Signs appeared on the hot-air hand-driers in the ladies' and gents': &bquo;If you missed Sir Gordon's speech to staff and wish to hear a recorded version, press this button&hellip; &bquo; 
 DEAR Doctor. 
 So, we're feeling a bit peaky are we? 
 Please tick: Yes, we are; or No, we're not. 
 The Liberal Democrats have, very ambitiously, been conducting a national survey among GPs about the likely impact of the Government's proposals for the health service. 
 This is reckoned to be the largest exercise of its type since the reforms were put forward, blood pressure started to rise, nostrils began to flare and so on. 
 Now comes the business of sorting out the returned forms. 
 Most of the questions may be answered with a tick. 
 But some spaces are left for the doctors&equo; comments. 
 Oh, good grief. 
 Their handwriting. 
 &bquo;We can't read what most of them say,&equo; muttered a party spokeswoman. 
 &bquo;Most of these forms are like prescriptions.&equo; 
 GREAT Corrections Of Our Time (No.198). 
 Construction News: &bquo;We would like to point out that the name of Balfour Beatty's project manager &lsqb;at a site in Edinburgh&rsqb; is Mike Izzy.&equo; 
 Turn back to the original feature about that very development. 
 And who do we have here? 
 The builder's project manager, Alex Fishface. 
 Yes, that's Fishface. 
 AND THERE goes Terence Heiser, Knight Commander of the Most Honourable Order of the Bath (KCB), Permanent Secretary at the Environment Department, appearing before the Public Accounts Committee. 
 This event is billed in the House of Commons information bulletin as an outing by Sir Terence Heiser KGB. 
 THANKS a lot, whoever delivered to homes in Roehampton yesterday, on behalf of the Metropolitan Police, folders of helpful Christmas crime prevention hints. 
 Like this: &bquo;Try and make the house look occupied when it's left unattended&hellip; 
 &equo; What a good idea. 
 But not so terribly easy when a folder of crime-fighting guidance is left propped against every front door. 
 MEANWHILE, if you're not actually strangling a turkey at the moment then you might like to do the next worse thing and plunge into the unsavoury giblets of the 1990 calendar of the National Association of Conservative Graduates. 
 They seem proud that it's offended just about everyone; it enjoys the billing &bquo;Tasteless &mdash; the Sun&equo; in the association's latest mailing. 
 This calendar marks special dates, thus. 
 The sinking of the Rainbow Warrior; the death of Blair Peach; and so on. 
 WHO, BY the way, is getting the biggest postbag at Westminster at this joyful time? 
 K.Clarke, of course. 
 It's an infallible indicator of unpopularity, according to experts in the mail room. 
 TIME for another selection of winning entries for the Vicar's Competition: captions for the nineties. 
 &bquo;President Mandela of Azania welcoming Premier Sillars of the Republic of Scotland to his 80th birthday celebrations.&equo; 
 (Elspeth Loades); &bquo;Lord James Goldsmith (right) announcing his plans to demerge the USSR.&equo; 
 (Anon.); 
 &bquo;Frank Naylor being presented with the memorial award for making most contributions to Guardian diary competitions without having any printed.&equo; 
 (Frank Naylor). 
 JUST a word now about Santa Claus. 
 The one who carried out a hold-up in Philadelphia &mdash; and, while waiting, sang &bquo;We wish you a merry Christmas&hellip; 
 &bquo;No, don't tell me the police are looking for a getaway sleigh. 
 AND J.Danforth Quayle's secret servicemen have been off, at taxpayers&equo; expense, for three weeks' skiing tuition. 
 In order to guard the V-P on his hols, you see. 
 Last year one got a little out of control &mdash; and ran over Marilyn, Mrs Quayle. 
 18COMMENT THE GUARDIANWednesday December 20 1989 Killing behind a closed border. 
 HORROR at what is happening in Romania is every bit as justified &mdash; even if the details of the killings in Timisoara are ob scure &mdash; as the global protest at the events six months ago in Tiananmen Square. 
 There are enough case his tories now to begin to establish a typology of last-ditch tyrannical L action. 
 The State regards itself as threatened by Counter-revolution; its apparatus of power is theoreti cally entitled to employ all means at its disposal; the great leader person ally authorises the use of force (and who dares contradict him?); the army and security forces lumber in with a grotesque over-use of fire power &mdash; in this case including heli copters &mdash; and within minutes there are bodies in the streets. 
 Just how many bodies is still an open ques tion. 
 As the June events in China showed, eyewitness accounts are necessarily very fallible. 
 Not every one who stumbles is a casualty; not every casualty is fatal, and the grim sight of a few corpses can easily overwhelm statistical accuracy. 
 But no matter what the final total may be, the Ceausescu regime has L crossed a line which sooner or later should prove fatal for it. 
 At first sight, the location of protest sub stantially among Romania's alien ated Hungarian minority suggests that it may be more easily confined by the leadership in Bucharest. 
 But the wholly unpredicted speed-up of events elsewhere in Eastern Europe should make us wary of assuming that the Romanians must be so much further behind. 
 The two official Party newspapers in Bucharest  admitted a threat to &bquo;the whole socio-economic construction of Romania&equo; &mdash; implying a threat to the regime itself. 
 Mr Ceausescu's Stalinist rule is such an easy target for condemna tion that there is a danger of over- reaction. 
 Wild talk of intervention &mdash; whether by Hungary, or by a War saw Pact which has somehow redis covered its lost unity, or even in a joint operation with Nato &mdash; is merely post-cold war romancing. 
 Short of a situation of mass genocide (Kampuchea or Idi Amin's Uganda) individual peoples have to be left to fight their own battles, if they are to generate genuine and lasting solu tions for their own futures. 
 Nor should the West be excessively high-minded now in condemning a L regime which once served its anti- Soviet purposes so well. 
 Mr L Ceausescu may have become some what more dictatorial in the past de cade, but it is not a qualitative change. 
 He was already a very un pleasant person when he was enter tained in Buckingham Palace by the Queen in 1978. 
 He was equally sinis ter two years later when the Foreign Secretary Carrington visited him with a strange request for help in promoting the neutralisation of Af ghanistan. 
 The Hungarian minority was already complaining bitterly then of persecution &mdash; their plight widely regarded as the unfortunate flip-side of Ceausescu's ultra-nation alism, which at least kept the Rus sians at bay. 
 Ms Nadia Comaneci was still performing on the long bar for Romania, but her gymnastic trainers had already defected to the US. 
 None of this stopped President Carter from sending a senior envoy to Bucharest in December 1978 to express his praise for &bquo;Romania's independence and US-Romanian L friendship.&equo; 
 This year's special mis sion of appeasement was paid (twice as we now discover) by President Bush's special envoy Mr Brent Scowcroft to Beijing. 
 Outrage apart, grand diplomacy still has its own special rules. 
 The terms at Trade. 
 YESTERDAY's statement from Mr Nicholas Ridley on the Bar low Clowes affair marks an extraor dinary about-turn for a Government which has always denied any legal responsibility for the losses suffered by 18,000 investors. 
 A year ago, remember, Mr Ridley's predecessor as Trade Secretary, Lord Young brushed aside all legal, moral or hu manitarian reasons for rescuing investors. 
 Today the Government, of course, still denies legal responsibility &mdash; presumably to frighten off any other claimants &mdash; but will dispense &pound;150 million of taxpayers' money to com pensate investors of both the Barlow Clowes UK fund and the Gibraltar based international fund (which isn't covered by the Department of Trade's writ and which offered rates of interest on allegedly gilt-edged stock which were not possible with out tax avoidance). 
 That &pound;150 million will be reduced after the liquidators have handed over the money they expect to recover (at least &pound;60 mil lion) and possibly more if other claims are pursued by the DTI. 
 But it is still a very large sum indeed, which may be viewed with some in credulity by the millions of lower paid people who have been hit by the Government's attitudes on, for example, child benefits. 
 Mr Ridley, who was not involved in any of the original decisions, is no supporter of the nanny state either. 
 He is coughing up because the Om budsman has found five separate cases of maladministration which, the minister admits, amount to a moral if not a legal responsibility. 
 The counter argument is that investors ought to have known that there was a risk involved, particularly those who put their funds in the Gibraltar fund at suspiciously high rates of interest in order to avoid UK taxation. 
 However, the Ombudsman found that the UK and Gibraltar funds were closely linked and that, if the Department had moved swiftly enough to revoke the UK licence, the Gibraltar fund could not have continued to exist. 
 Three of the instances of maladministration related to the licensing of the Chesh ire-based savings group in 1984/85, where the Ombudsman felt that there was enough evidence to have ordered Barlow Clowes to cease op erations. 
 The DTI was found not to have heeded a number of warnings from authoritative sources about the dubious status of the Clowes em pire: witness the Bank of England, the Stock Exchange and the regula tory bodies. 
 He was not impressed either by the Department's argu ment that to have revoked the licence would have triggered a dis orderly collapse, allowing the smart money to get out and leaving pen sioners high and dry. 
 Yesterday's report was welcomed by both sides of the House and, hopefully, will prove the last case of its kind now that the savings indus try has set up its own investor com pensation scheme. 
 It is important for the Government to pursue other involved parties &mdash; including the company itself, but also the finan cial advisers who put savers into the Gibraltar fund without inquiring too much about how it was able to offer such high rates of interest, not to mention the auditors who looked at the books. 
 Meanwhile, though, the savers can count themselves very fortu nate, particularly those in the off shore fund who now stand to get nearly all of their money back. 
 This Government is rarely so generous with the taxpayers' money, espe cially to people who seek out an in vestment opportunity which doesn't involve paying UK tax. 
 A little thank you to the Ombudsman would not go amiss. 
 Video justice. 
 PERHAPS the biggest distortion to the scales of justice in Eng land and Wales is about to be removed. 
 Inconceivable though it may seem, some of the most abused victims in the country have the greatest difficulty in having their voices heard. 
 Many, despite the seri ous injuries they have suffered, are completely barred from the courts. 
 Others are allowed to testify, but then the judge is required to warn the juries about the dangers of ac cepting that testimony. 
 Yesterday, though, the independent committee set up by the Government to look at the admissibility of pre-trial video interviews of abused children called for radical changes. 
 Undoubtedly the narrow legal conservatives &mdash; both on and off the bench &mdash; who run the criminal justice system will continue to resist the move; but HMG will not be able to ignore the arguments set out in the report. 
 Child victims of physical and sexual abuse have suffered too long. 
 It is time their voices were heard. 
 Most attention will concentrate on the pre-trial video recording recom mendations. 
 Since the London L borough of Bexley experiment L proved successful, many areas are now using joint teams of social workers and police officers to inter view children who have been L abused. 
 There are numerous advan tages. 
 It allows an early and full account to be recorded before the child's memory fades; reduces the chance of parents or other interested adults influencing what the child says; removes the need for a succession of professional people to probe at length and in detail the traumatic experiences of the child; exposes any leading questions made  the interviewers; and allows people to observe the non-verbal as well as the verbal messages the child wants to make. 
 But, true to its timid traditions, the English crimi nal justice system still excludes these videos from court hearings be cause of the hearsay rule; a rule which has never been definitively formulated but which crudely pre vents statements made out of court by a witness to someone else being admissible. 
 The committee, how ever, sensibly note the long list of exceptions to this rule and insist that pre-recorded videos should be added. 
 One of the many benefits of this proposal will be the readiness of more defendants to plead guilty, thus reducing the length of the trau matic process. 
 The committee's proposed proce dural changes, however, though less &bquo;dramatic&equo;, will be even more im portant. 
 All children under 14 will be presumed to be competent wit nesses. 
 All should give unsworn evi dence. 
 The recommendations will over-rule &mdash; and not before time &mdash; the 1958 Court of Criminal Appeal ruling in the Wallwork case. 
 This ruling has effectively meant that children under eight are almost never called and no child under five is ever called. 
 Yet, just over the bor der in Scotland, children as young as four frequently testify in abuse trials. 
 The most perverse element of the English system is that if a child is not called, the hearsay rule pre vents anyone else &mdash; a parent, doctor or policeman &mdash; from repeating in court what the child said out of court. 
 Many abusers have escaped through this loophole. 
 The committee sensibly want to remove the child from crown court trials, but their solution of prelimi nary hearings is questionable. 
 These are meant to be informal, but will be conducted in front of judges with legal teams on either side. 
 Informal ity in the eyes of English lawyers will be far from informal to the child. 
 Direct video links, already in troduced, look a much better bet. 
 Letters to the Editor PAGE 
 Nikki Foster on the real curse of single motherhood Sole writes Fear and loathing.. 
 THERE seem to be two distinct periods in a heterosexual woman's life when being single is acceptable. 
 As a young adult, mate-hunting with the pack, you are regarded with tolerant amusement; elderly and/or widowed, you are usually afforded a kind of uncommitted sympathy and concern. 
 The middle-aged mother, however, who has dependants, a job, a mortgage and a car &mdash; all the trappings of the standard nuclear family, but without the visible support of the person normally responsible for such things &mdash; is generally treated like a rabid dog, something acknowledged as being in the neighbourhood but to be avoided at all costs. 
 This is nowhere more apparent than in the leafy avenues of middle-class suburbia, among the 2CV owners and Guardian readers, the teachers and social workers, where family life is pictured tumbling happily among Early Learning Centre climbing frames, glowing cosily out from safely bohemian pine-scrubbed kitchens. 
 I have recently moved, with two children, two cats and an apparently treacherous abyss where a husband ought to be. 
 I obviously made some fundamental mistakes within the first few days of my move. 
 I failed to place a cardboard cut-out of a male person lying, in a posture of total exhaustion, in one of the darker recesses of the living room. 
 His silence and inertia would have only made him more lifelike and I would, at once, have been treated as &bquo;one of the girls&equo;. 
 I failed to play a tape throughout the weekend of a drill relentlessly droning away in some shelfless room out of sight. 
 I failed to arrange any stereotypical symbol of masculinity in the porch where all visitors would see it instantly: a pair of size ten wellingtons, a cricket fixture list, a rifle perhaps. 
 The result of this ineptitude was that I was rumbled as a single parent within days, if not hours, and subsequently approached as if I were a fatal poison masquerading as a person. 
 This may sound extreme, but it isn't. 
 Single mothers are seen as totally destabilising, a threat to life as couples know it. 
 Because there are children and therefore the woman has obviously been part of a couple at some point, there is an assumption that in her single state she is critical, cynical and undermining of couples around her. 
 Women seem fearful of becoming too friendly with a single mother; fearful that if they spend too much time with her, they might just get a taste for something that is denied them. 
 What a single mother represents may seem touchingly attractive: not having to cook another adult's meals, or wash his clothes; being able to go to bed when you want; being able to go to sleep when you want. 
 These are tiny freedoms, and if a woman enjoys being part of a couple, they should count for nothing. 
 But then this leads to the idea that perhaps a number of women do not enjoy being part of a couple and that a single woman in their midst acts like a demented lighthouse: enticing hapless travellers, by its safe and steady beam, on to the rocks below. 
 Men, of course, would not make friends with a single mother for the reason that men do not make friends. 
 They make &bquo;drinking companions&equo; and &bquo;football teams&equo; and &bquo;colleagues&equo;. 
 They have sex with women or they dislike them, sometimes both. 
 There are, however, some men who assume that a single mother must be looking for a husband. 
 They are husbands, ergo, she is looking for them. 
 Working on this delusion, they then feel either excited and act like silly children or confused and act like silly children. 
 To be fair, the assumption that a single woman must be seeking the refuge of coupledom again is common to men and women. 
 Yet it's a theory without logic: if you'd just had an Austin Utterly Dependable break down and fall to bits, would you really want another one? 
 That argument has to rest on the principle that it makes other owners of Utterly Dependables feel better if everyone has one! 
 I have attended &bquo;social events&equo; at my children's school at which only the staff have spoken to me. 
 I have joined classes where I've leapt about to Michael Jackson or thrown my pot and been surprised at the sound of my own voice when I've paid the babysitter. 
 Divorced people, and therefore single parents, have had a bad press lately. 
 They are, according to recent research, bringing up the next generation of offenders, truants, divorcees and generally inadequate people. 
 Maybe this is why I am treated as if I've polluted the town's water. 
 Frankly I don't believe that households in which one parent spends all his waking moments either out of the house or refitting the patio doors or under the bonnet of a car are doing a better job than I am, where the kids are concerned, but I haven't got any statistics to prove it. 
 It seems ironic that I pose such a threat to the natural order: an innocuous, above-averagely exhausted woman, mainly preoccupied with children's needs, work, letters from the bank and Sainsbury's, but sometimes longing for a chat, a good laugh, an exchange of views. 
 Most coupled people's preoccupations and needs are very similar but they nurture the hope that their partner will support and fulfil them. 
 Maybe the single parent is seen as somehow highlighting the cracks that couples think they've covered over. 
 Meanwhile, single mothers will sit and watch the TV and watch the advertisements which all show either happy couples or one single person doing something for an unseen other: ironing his shirts, organising their mortgage, driving his Audi to visit her. 
 The only thing single women do on the ads is eat chocolate or feed the cat, so I've stopped watching: it's too depressing. 
 I'm too busy trying to make a tape of someone mowing the lawn who is also trying to watch the Cup Final, who is trying to get the rest of the family to shut up. 
 I'm sure if I play that next Saturday, it'll be the instant passport to any social scene. 
 PAGE wom 
 ALICE PERKINS works four days a week as a high-level administrator at the Department of Social Security. 
 She works intensively from nine to six, skipping lunch and often taking work home to do after her two children, William, 9, and Charlotte, 7, have gone to bed. 
 However, on Fridays she has a day at home. 
 That one day, Perkins says, makes a fantastic difference. 
 &bquo;It means being able to count on time each week to deal with whatever the home priority is. 
 Instead of having to come home from work and worry about wrapping up the Christmas presents, or writing letters to friends, or having a long conversation with someone in the family who needs a bit of support, and fitting all that in after the children have gone to bed and the supper's been washed up and you really ought to be reading papers for tomorrow's meeting, I know I have a chunk of time when I can get on with doing all that. 
 Nobody's got any expectations of what I do on that day. 
 &bquo;I had worked as an Assistant Secretary (senior manager) full time for three years in a very heavy job and I was beginning to feel I was permanently breathless. 
 So I asked whether, at the end of that job, I could work four days a week, and I was favourably surprised at the reaction I received. 
 People could see why I wanted to work in that way and did what they could to make it possible. 
 &bquo;It was partly wanting to say to my children that on one day a week I could always take them to school. 
 I'm now available, if it's during their holidays, to do something with them myself. 
 I felt it was very important at this point in their childhood because I think they are such good company at this age. 
 At the moment they think being with their parents is absolutely wonderful and that's not going to last for ever. 
 I felt that this was a very brief phase and if I didn't cash in on it now, I wasn't going to get the chance again. 
 &bquo;Since I've worked part time I've also become a parent governor at the children's school and most Fridays during term time I go in and listen to children reading. 
 I can also get my hair cut, do some gardening, go to an art exhibition &mdash; things that just got squeezed out altogether beforehand. 
 &bquo;I decided on four days because I reckoned that that's as near to being a full-timer as you can be, while still gaining something significant for yourself. 
 It meant that I could still do what I regard as a worthwhile job. 
 I recognised it could mean marking time but I don't think in practice that has happened. 
 &bquo;Sometimes there are meetings scheduled on Fridays and I feel reluctant to miss them. 
 However, that does have its positive side &mdash; it gives my staff the opportunity to go to meetings and take responsibility when I'm not there, so it can be used in quite a developmental way. 
 You do also have to be fairly well organised, using your time ruthlessly on the top priorities. 
 &bquo;I've been working this way for 18 months now and I'm really happy with how it's going. 
 It's been a real success.&equo; 
 PAGE wom 
 Quote&hellip;. 
 JUST last week, General Manuel Noriega, already the supreme ruler of Panama, had himself named head of government and &bquo;maximum leader for national liberation&equo; by his personally appointed legislature, which went on to pronounce the country to be in a &bquo;state of war&equo; with the United States. 
 Why would he find it in his interest to ratchet up a challenge to a foreign power that has, after all, an impeccable legal position in Panama and a considerable military position? 
 It seems a case of a dictator generating a sense of hysteria and national besiegement to rally people around, but the weekend's shooting incidents pose an apparently deliberate provocation to an American presence that is firmly rooted in treaties between the Panamanian and American Governments, and they force the question of whether Noriega is bent on invalidating those treaties. 
 Washington Post, December 19 
 Working mothers are faced with two choices: follow the male career route and spend little time with their children or sacrifice their prospects, knowing that working part time means low status and low wages. 
 Maggy Meade-King reports Part exchange SIXTY-SIX PER CENT of British mothers who work are considered to do so part-time; 11 per cent work 40 or more hours per week. 
 Twenty-two per cent of French women work part time and 64 per cent work 40 hours or more per week. 
 Fifty per cent of mothers returning to work part time do so in lower level jobs than those they left at childbirth. 
 Even where both partners work full time, 72 per cent of domestic tasks are done mainly by women. 
 Most British mothers choose to work part time. 
 They spend a short period at home full time while their children are small, then look for a job that will fit in with their family commitments. 
 The majority need the money and many enjoy the social life and stimulation of work outside the home. 
 However, they also want to spend time with their children. 
 In addition, lack of good, affordable pre-school and out-of-school childcare, and responsibility for the care of elderly relatives and household chores means that part-time work often seems the only practical option. 
 A happy compromise between the needs of family and work, you might think, but the end result is a sharp downgrading in the work returning mothers do. 
 A Thomas Coram Research Unit study, New Mothers At Work: Employment And Childcare, found, for example, a woman who moved from being an Executive Officer with the DSS to childminding, and another who moved from bank clerk to cleaner. 
 As many mothers rely on their partners for childcare, they often work out-of-sight, nil-promotion night shifts. 
 When their children go to school, they may take on a morning job in a shop or making school dinners. 
 At any rate, it is the service sector that benefits most from this army of workers who have to sacrifice pay and conditions for convenient hours and proximity to home. 
 Even women in well-paid jobs, who can afford childcare and domestic help, face a stark, all-or-nothing choice. 
 Most career jobs expect people to work more than nine-to-five hours, to travel abroad or move house if necessary, maybe to attend conferences at weekends or socialise in the evenings; in short, to put work before family. 
 Those who are not prepared to do so may find that their promotion's blocked or they're shunted into a backwater &mdash; one experienced insurance broker of my acquaintance, for instance, was offered a job in the stationery department! 
 Part-timers or job-sharers are increasing but still a rarity in the middle or higher levels of management. 
 It seems to be a question of if you can't take the workaholic heat, get back to the kitchen. 
 Women must either follow the male career route and spend little time with their children, or drop out for the vital middle years that filter out the top managers. 
 Part-time solicitors, accountants or doctors will rarely become partners in their firms; they are at best marking time, at worst barring themselves for ever from the higher reaches of their professions. 
 Even women who do work traditionally seen as compatible with motherhood may be disadvantaged. 
 Part-time teachers, for instance, will not be promoted and even those who work full time will often not apply for positions with extra responsibility because of their commitments at home. 
 Generally, part-timers work in low-status, low-wage occupations because that's all that's on offer at the hours they can work. 
 The West Yorkshire Low Pay Unit found recently that, while part-time work was increasing in their area, women were actually being paid a lower percentage of local full-time wages than they had received a decade ago. 
 Those who work less than 16 hours per week (or eight hours after five years with one employer) also lose employment rights such as maternity leave, unfair dismissal protection and redundancy payments. 
 All those working less than full-time hours (generally 35 or more per week) may find themselves barred from pension, profit-sharing and preferential company loan schemes. 
 Britain and Eire are alone in the EC in treating part-timers differently. 
 In France, for instance, where there are no incentives for employers to take on part-timers (in the form of our lower National Insurance contributions and lack of rights and benefits for part-timers) and far more extensive subsidised childcare facilities and parental leave, far fewer mothers work part time and more are in higher status occupations, according to the Department of Employment's French And British Women's Employment Comparisons. 
 Indeed, many British employers may be illegally discriminating against their part-time workers. 
 If they are predominantly female, and 83 per cent of part-timers are, the equal pay legislation may entitle them to the same benefits and conditions as their full-time colleagues. 
 The Manufacturing, Science and Finance union negotiated an agreement last year, for instance, that entitled part-time women working for Norwich Union to benefit from a mortgage subsidy scheme. 
 We are likely to see more agreements offering better deals to part-timers, to entice mothers back to work, as the demographic changes begin to bite. 
 However, none of them is likely to affect those workers who fall outside of collective agreements; the contract workers and the many women who work for small manufacturing or service sector employers. 
 For them, especially, it's time we caught up with the rest of the European Community and extended to all workers employment protection, pro rata benefits and pay, as well as parental leave and childcare. 
 The good news is that the need to retain skilled and experienced workers is encouraging the more enlightened employers to offer better terms to people who want to work reduced hours. 
 Most Civil Service departments, for instance, now allow their staff to work part-time at their current grades, with pro rata pay and benefits, such as pensions. 
 There are currently over 28,000 part-time staff in Government Service and, while the great majority of these are in the junior grades, ten per cent of women at Principal level and above (senior staff) now work part time. 
 While this may mean working only one day less per week, that one day may provide a vital breathing space for women like Alice Perkins, working in demanding, pressurised jobs, and it may just allow them to remain on a career path that will take them into positions of power. 
 A male colleague of Perkins', working at the same grade, is also taking a day off a week to spend more time with his children and perhaps this is the most heartening news of all. 
 It offers a vision of a future in which the importance of both parents spending time with their children is recognised, as is the right of both sexes to use their skills in the workplace to the extent of their abilities, for the benefit of us all. 
 New Mothers At Work: Employment And Childcare and the forthcoming Motherhood, Employment And Childcare: The Early Years, by Julia Brannen and Peter Moss, are both published by Unwin Hyman. 
 French And British Women's Employment Comparisons was compiled by SDex, PWalters and DAlden for the Department of Employment. 
 PAGE wom 
 The lost spirits of Christmas present Living alone after being in care can be too much. 
 Helen Brown reports on the ones who can't cope. 
 &bquo;C. 
 HRISTMAS IS very hard to deal with,&equo; says 22-year-old Mark. 
 &bquo;If you've been in care most of your life, there's nowhere you can go. 
 A lot of my downfalls have been over Christmas. 
 I end up crawling inside bottles of drink.&equo; 
 And Mark is one of the lucky ones &mdash; he at least has somewhere to sleep. 
 Thousands of young people will be spending this Christmas on the streets because they have no home to go to, and over a third of them will have spent most of their childhood in care. 
 Fewer than one child in every hundred is taken into care, yet, in London alone, at least one in every three young homeless people has a background in care. 
 And often it's not that they never had anywhere to live, it's just that they couldn't cope with the responsibilities and the isolation of living on their own. 
 It's difficult enough to manage for yourself when you first leave home, but if you've spent your childhood in an institution, you probably don't even know how to change a light bulb, let alone keep a rent book. 
 On their 18th birthday, and sometimes even before, anyone in care is considered to be an adult and able to fend for themselves. 
 They are suddenly faced with finding a place to rent and budgeting the cost of living. 
 Housing authorities have a general duty to house &bquo;vulnerable&equo; people but a recent survey by the National Children's Home found that only 50 per cent of authorities would classify as vulnerable a young homeless person with no parents and no support. 
 A young care-leaver's chances of being made a housing priority vary from one in three in Scotland to one in four in a London borough or metropolitan authority, to only one in eight in the South of England. 
 Even if a place is found there's the bills. 
 Years of moving from one home to another, having meals cooked for you, never having to think twice about leaving lights on or taps dripping is hardly the best preparation for surviving in a bedsit on a YTS wage of &pound;29.50 a week (trainees don't qualify for income support). 
 One unforeseen bill and the debts start piling up, one long delay in receiving housing benefit and the landlord may throw you out. 
 Many people find themselves homeless within a year of leaving care. 
 Fred, from Newcastle, still finds things hard, even after spending time in a &bquo;halfway house&equo; which let him get used to paying his own way. 
 &bquo;It was such a shock to me,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;When nobody was there, I just didn't know what to do. 
 At 18 I was saying &bquo;I'm a man and ready to tackle this&equo;. 
 But I'm 20 now and I still haven't grasped it yet.&equo; 
 Perhaps more difficult even than the financial juggling is the isolation and loneliness. 
 One boy, a friend of Mark's called Kenny, who was living in a hostel in Croydon, was housed on the 13th floor of a frequently vandalised tower block in Camberwell. 
 He was only a few miles away but for him it might as well have been a million miles. 
 Cut off from the only social contact and emotional support he had known, he went downhill and ended up being arrested for stealing. 
 Mark himself has had two attempts at living independently. 
 He is intelligent and articulate, and bitter at the way the years he spent in care have handicapped his chances: &bquo;I went into care when my family broke up. 
 I was moved from home to home. 
 There was one time when I moved 14 times in seven months &mdash; that really disrupts your education. 
 It also means you have real problems building relationships because you just expect to lose friends all the time. 
 Most of the people who have been close to me over the years have been paid to be. 
 &bquo;And then at 18, or in my case at 17, they take you away from everything you know and stick you in some broom cupboard of a bedsit. 
 I had no preparation for that at all. 
 Everything fell down around me. 
 &bquo;I started drinking very heavily, using aerosols, dope, pills. 
 It got rid of problems until the next morning. 
 And then the rent demand would come, and things would get worse and worse.&equo; 
 Mark was &bquo;rescued&equo; by a Barnardo's project, based at the Cleevedon Hostel in south London, which helps young people to work gradually towards total independence. 
 He now shares a house near the hostel with four other care-leavers and has stabilised a great deal. 
 But there are too few projects like Cleevedon, and too little money to help more than a handful of youngsters every year. 
 Mark is visibly angry with &bquo;them&equo;, the faceless bureaucrats who made the rules that nearly lead to his ruin. 
 &bquo;They take you away from your family because they say the state can be a better parent. 
 But in the end it's not &mdash; because at 18 you're just dropped. 
 I'm not asking for more than any other 22-year-old &mdash; just the same.&equo; 
 Angela McRobbie investigates the long-term effects of living in care Home from home?. 
 &bquo;I. 
 KNEW nothing about sex. 
 They never tell you anything. 
 When I came on with my period, I didn't know who to tell. 
 I was petrified. 
 I didn't even know what pregnancy was. 
 The doctor said to me, &bquo;Haven't you been told about these things?&equo; then sat and explained it all to me. 
 And I cried because I didn't know what had happened. 
 They persuaded me to have a termination.&equo; 
 Donna, 22, interviewed in Women, Crime and Poverty by Pat Carlen (OUP, 1988). 
 Whatever the conditions are that force a young person to run away from home, there is no doubt that institutionalised care exacerbates them. 
 A recent study by Professor Pat Carlen shows that of 39 female adult criminals, 22 spent a substantial period of their childhood and adolescence in care. 
 The young people who come into care are drawn almost exclusively from the ranks of the poor and disadvantaged and though many reasons are given for the move, frequently it is the inability of the family to cope with illness, bereavement, divorce or remarriage. 
 (Recent attention to cases of child sex abuse has resulted in children rather than young people being taken into care; teenagers are more likely to act out their distress by running away and only reveal why much later.) 
 The single most startling fact for girls, however, is that they tend to be taken into care for &bquo;status offences&equo; rather than for breaking the law. 
 While for boys the &bquo;justice&equo; rather than the &bquo;welfare&equo; model prevails, between 70 and 80 per cent of girls in care in this country are there as a result of parents or step-parents calling in the social services because they feel their daughters to be &bquo;beyond parental control&equo; or &bquo;morally at risk&equo;. 
 Initially the girls welcome a private space away from the family. 
 As one young woman I spoke to put it: &bquo;I thought at least I'll be going to a place where these people are not my parents so they won't be able to put a hand on me.&equo; 
 But once the bleak regime of institutionalised care hits young people, the relief of being away from an unhappy family situation sours into feelings of failure and rejection. 
 Another girl, placed in a children's home at 13 after her mother had a nervous breakdown and her father left for another woman, described her shock at finding it was also a place of &bquo;correction&equo; for young offenders. 
 &bquo;I had been rowing with my dad since I was little, so I didn't want to go to his new family with my brother. 
 The social workers told me I would like the home and that I could stay on at my old school and still have the same friends. 
 But when I got there I found I was in with kids who'd been nicked for stealing or who'd been on drugs or alcohol or glue, and girls who had been on the streets at 13. 
 That made me feel I must have done something to deserve this. 
 It was my fault Mum got ill and Dad went off with someone else.&equo; 
 Many girls do manage to survive and come out able to build up a life for themselves, but the odds are stacked against them. 
 Two depressing scenarios emerge from Carlen's research into the long-term effects of care on young women. 
 First there is an increase in misdemeanours &mdash; the type of behaviour a girl might be ticked off for at home but which in care results in her finding herself further up the custodial ladder in a Community Home with Education. 
 Minor misdemeanours can place her in a position of great vulnerability, subject to the whim of whoever happens to be on duty, and institutional life, by definition, is less flexible, less forgiving, than the &bquo;normal family&equo; home. 
 Siblings will, for example, invariably fight and argue their way through childhood. 
 For Cecilia, however &mdash; a young black girl placed in care at 13 because her mother couldn't cope &mdash; the fact that she could express anger and upset with her sister, whom she dearly loved, resulted in social workers suggesting a move, &bquo;for her own good&equo;, to a smaller family-style establishment in the country, miles from the inner city community in which she had grown up. 
 She stayed there for three years and lost track of her sister during that time. 
 Sometimes anger is the only resource left in a situation like this. 
 Cecilia eventually hit out against the home's petty rules and forced the social workers to come up with an alternative. 
 Within a week she was living with a black foster parent, in the area in which she had grown up, and was able to resume contact with her sister. 
 The second social consequence of care that emerges from Carlen's work is that not only is the education of the young person seriously neglected, but so, too, is the emotional development. 
 Cecilia has done well &mdash; she is now on a polytechnic degree course &mdash; but nothing in her years in care prepared her for independent living. 
 And for other girls in Carlen's study, the scars of having been in care are more vivid. 
 Many have been psychologically damaged, like Yasmin, whose continuous self-injury meant that she was moved into a more punitive environment. 
 Fortunately, over the past few years there have been attempts by social services and local authorities to review the value of care for young people. 
 (And the Children's Bill currently going through Parliament will seek to give them more rights and protection.) 
 Voluntary organisations like the Rainer Foundation are at last being listened to and boroughs that ten years ago might have had a dozen children's homes now have only a couple. 
 Such successes have pushed social workers and government agencies to consider preventative interventionist work, with the girl in question and with her family. 
 The CARLI (Care Alternatives Resources Liaison Information) project in Basildon brought together Rainer workers with social workers in an attempt to reduce the move into care of over 100 young girls. 
 Day care, counselling, group activities and continuous support reversed this trend and, in recognition of the difficulties that often emerge between teenage girls and step-parents, a support group was set up to arbitrate and seek solutions. 
 Other initiatives have also developed. 
 Where a period of &bquo;cooling&equo; care seems inevitable, a &bquo;planned care experience&equo;, with set deadlines and clear outcomes, is recommended. 
 Where abuse is disclosed, a teenage girl will be counselled and provided with &bquo;safe, defensible space&equo; in the form of a foster home or place in a hostel. 
 The value of early intervention is stressed. 
 It is vital, however, that agencies involved in alternatives to care continue to listen to those who have been through the system. 
 None of Cecilia's &bquo;placements&equo;, for example, managed to create anything vaguely resembling the warmth and informality of a real home. 
 She was forced time and again to face the fact that, for so many of those into whose care she was put, it was just a job. 
 &bquo;What I would like to see,&equo; she says, &bquo;is more regular checks done on those who work in care or offer homes to young people, because once they get through the vetting, if anything goes wrong, then it's always you who's to blame. 
 Nobody ever points the finger at them.&equo; 
 See Young Guardian on page 17 for more on coping with life after care. 
 Guardian Women is edited by Louise Chunn PAGE wom 
 A big shove-off for the boat people News round-up. 
 By us75Melanie McFadyean 
 IT WAS 3am when prison officers in riot gear ran into Phoenix House holding centre in Hong Kong. 
 Francis Maude, the Foreign Office minister responsible for Hong Kong, called them &bquo;counsellors&equo;. 
 Hong Kong's chief secretary, Sir David Ford, said: &bquo;Our first concern was the safety and dignity of the people concerned.&equo; 
 The people, who accused the authorities of assault, were 26 children, 17 women and eight men, herded on to an aeroplane and sent, against their will, back to Vietnam, a country from which they had fled. 
 America disapproved of the repatriation but did not offer to take any refugees. 
 Vietnam's acute poverty, which the boat people are trying to escape from, is a legacy of the war the Vietnamese won against the US. 
 The world was outraged. 
 But nobody made a fuss about another repatriated group, the 55 people sent back last week to mainland China by the Hong Kong authorities. 
 This year 13,000 illegal Chinese emigrants have been repatriated from Hong Kong. 
 They return to the government which massacred the students demonstrating peacefully for democracy in Tiananmen Square in June. 
 APSYCHOLOGIST whose research suggests that almost a fifth of pupils are being bullied has called for government action to tackle the problem. 
 An official campaign almost halved bullying in Norway and similar action should be taken in Britain, said Dr Peter Smith of Sheffield University. 
 His survey of 1,000 children found that 18.3 per cent of secondary and 17.1 per cent of middle school pupils claimed to have been bullied. 
 Many said they were regularly bullied &mdash; 8 per cent of secondary pupils at least once a week and 5.5 per cent of middle school pupils several times a week. 
 GOODBYE to the lager lout? 
 A survey has found that people under 24 are cutting down on alcohol. 
 Five years ago 440,000 young people went to a pub once a day; the number is down by 150,000. 
 There are three million more teetotallers than 10 years ago, with an increasing trend away from liquor, especially among young women. 
 More than 80 per cent of 18 to 24-year-olds agreed with random breath testing and ID cards, as did more than half of the 15-17 age group. 
 Bad news for publicans and wine merchants, good news for livers. 
 TUT TUT. 
 Cards depicting Santa in horribly compromising positions are selling like hot cakes. 
 A spokesman from the firm responsible said: &bquo;Some of the designs might be a bit near the knuckle, but the bonking snowmen have been so sucessful that we've commissioned even more variations for next year.&equo; 
 Mary Whitehouse said they are &bquo;contrary to the spirit of Christmas. 
 Decent people should refuse to buy anything from shops that sell these cards.&equo; 
 NO MISTLETOE this year in Minnesota's State University. 
 A psychology instructor complained it &bquo;sanctified uninvited endearments&equo; and encouraged sexual harassment. 
 Law Report. 
 Abuse of justice may follow delay in investigation:. 
 Queen's Bench Divisional Court Regina v Bow Street Magistrate, ex parte Director of Public Prosecutions Regina v Bow Street Stipendiary Magistrate, ex parte Cherry Before Lord Justice Watkins and Mr Justice Garland December 19 1989 
 MERE delay which gives rise to prejudice and unfairness may by itself amount to an abuse of the process of the court. 
 In such a case the court has power to stop the prosecution in its tracks. 
 The Divisional Court held that the delay in investigating and bringing proceedings against police officers involved in incidents arising out of an industrial dispute at Wapping in East London, amounted to an abuse of the process of the courts and the prosecutions were stopped. 
 The facts. 
 On January 24 1987 a demonstration with 12,000 to 15,000 demonstrators took place at the premises of newspaper proprietors in Wapping and there were many arrests. 
 It was alleged that police officers over- reacted or committed breaches of discipline and even criminal offences. 
 The next day the Metropolitan Police Commissioner referred the complaints to the Police Complaints Authority. 
 The authority decided to wait until all the evidence was in before interviewing any officer involved in the incident. 
 Nobody was interviewed until a year later. 
 On December 17 1987 a notice under regulation 7 of the Police (Discipline) Regulations 1985 was served in general on the officers under investigation. 
 On February 17 1988 a formal specific regulation 7 notice was served on PC Cherry telling him of the allegations. 
 On May 3 1989 committal proceedings began in respect of six officers who were charged with conspiracy to pervert the course of justice. 
 Mr Bartle, the stipendiary magistrate, declined jurisdiction to hear the charges on the ground that the delay in the investigation and prosecution of the case constituted an abuse of the process of the court. 
 The DPP sought judicial review of that decision. 
 At the end of May 1989 committal proceedings began in respect of PC Cherry who was charged with unlawful wounding. 
 Another stipendiary magistrate, heard argument about abuse of the process and came to the opposite conclusion from Mr Bartle, namely that delay in Mr Cherry's case did not constitute an abuse of the process. 
 Mr Cherry sought judicial review. 
 The decision. 
 For the DPP Miss Goddard said that mere delay is not capable of being an abuse of the process unless the delay is so great that what is sought by the Crown is no longer the vindication of justice but amounts to oppression or harassment of a defendant. 
 In long and complex cases delay was inevitable and had to be accepted, so why then, she asked, should that not be so in a simple case. 
 Mr Lawson asserted that the right to a trial without delay had long been established: see Magna Carta Chapter 40: and such a fundamental principle was valueless unless a court had power to enforce it by not tolerating abuse of its process. 
 Lord Justice Watkins said the Divisional Court could review an order of the magistrates' court made for the purpose of preventing an abuse of its process and had done so on a number of occasions. 
 Delay was nowadays, perhaps too often, a feature in both civil and criminal cases and had been considered by courts countless times. 
 There was no warrant for not following the ample precedent for the proposition that mere delay which gave rise to prejudice and unfairness could by itself amount to an abuse of the process. 
 What had to be demonstrated to the court was that the delay complained of had produced genuine prejudice and unfairness. 
 All the relevant facts were before the two magistrates who were weighing them up to decide whether it was more likely than not that there was prejudice and unfairness that led to an abuse of the process. 
 The Divisional Court concluded that Mr Bartle exercised his discretion without flaw. 
 In Mr Cherry's case Mr Lawson submitted that the decision to postpone service of a specific regulation 7 notice was mistaken and contrary to Home Office guidance, particularly when a criminal offence was involved. 
 Miss Goddard urged that the decision not to serve the notice was correct in view of the complexity of the whole investigation. 
 In Cherry's case the magistrate's conclusion was that the delay was extreme but justifiable and there was no prejudice. 
 His Lordship said the power to stop a prosecution in its tracks must only be used in a clear case. 
 But their Lordships had concluded that in Cherry's case the magistrate's finding that the delay was justified was wholly untenable. 
 It was perfectly proper to infer prejudice from the mere passage of time: in Cherry's case the magistrate's decision was based on two flawed findings of justification and no prejudice. 
 The DPP's application was dismissed and Mr Cherry's application was granted. 
 Appearances: Tudor Owen for the officers in the first case, Edmund Lawson QC and Michael Egan for Mr Cherry, all instructed by Russell Jones &amp; Walker; Ann Goddard QC with Nicholas Ainley in the first case, and with Oliver Sells in the Cherry case, all instructed by the DPP; James Holdsworth instructed by the Treasury Solicitor for both magistrates. 
 Shiranikha Herbert barrister 
 Letters: WLW writes: The Czech reformers in their moment of victory were particularly shaken by the death of Andrei Sakharov, the pre-eminent champion of civil rights not only in the Soviet Union but in its sphere of influence as well. 
 His intelligent and uncompromising struggle was always an inspiration to them in theirs. 
 Only the other day a leader of the student movement in Prague said that the first letter of support they had received from abroad after baptising the revolution in their blood on November 17 was from him, with the signatures of four other Soviet Academicians. 
 When the news was broken to Vaclav Havel in the middle of Jon Snow's television interview he stopped the cameras, appalled, much too moved to be able to make an appropriate instant response. 
 Nicolas Walter adds: Andrei Sakharov was a convinced humanist and a prominent figure in the world humanist movement. 
 In 1983 he was one of the original members of the international Academy of Humanism, and in 1988 he received the International Humanist Award &bquo;in recognition of his long-standing contributions to the cause of human rights, the scientific outlook, and the ideals of humanism.&equo; 
 For twenty years, in fact, he was the most active and admired humanist in the world. 
 Textbook case of growing Soviet honesty Commentary. 
 By Jonathan Steele 
 SPARE a thought, as the Eighties come to an end, for the new-wave re-writers of Soviet history. 
 Over the past three years they have turned one of the most dishonourable Soviet professions into something worthy of admiration. 
 The lies, omissions, and distortions which used to characterise historical research and teaching have come to an end and, with every day, honesty about the past is capturing more territory. 
 It is not just a question of new ground being broken in the academic journals and literary magazines. 
 An astonishingly frank, and therefore pessimistic, view of Soviet history is now the basis of instruction in Soviet schools. 
 Take the latest &bquo;History of the Soviet Union&equo; for children in the final two years of school, which my son, Benjamin, brought home the other day. 
 In some areas it goes further in its handling of Stalinism than the conventional wisdom in the Soviet media, and certainly than official party spokespeople have done. 
 Children used to be told of one triumph after another. 
 In the previous textbook printed in 1981 the chapter on Stalin's campaign against the kulaks was headed: &bquo;The victory of collective structures in the countryside&equo;. 
 The Stalin constitution of 1936 was called &bquo;The Constitution of Victorious Socialism&equo;. 
 Now everything is upside down. 
 The new book talks of the 1936 constitution as &bquo;a contradiction between word and deed&equo;. 
 On paper, it says, the constitution was a step towards genuine democracy by providing for direct and secret elections, and widening citizens' rights. 
 &bquo;In fact it contradicted the practice of Stalinism, and actually made it illegal. 
 The constitution and daily life were in sharp divergence. 
 This was obvious to anyone who could think,&equo; it says. 
 In an almost throw-away sentence the book gives one of the highest figures for the number of those whom Stalin killed or imprisoned during collectivisation and the purges: &bquo;According to preliminary estimates, the total number of victims of the repressions was around 40 million.&equo; 
 The textbook discusses the Nazi-Soviet pacts, and in particular condemns the Treaty of Friendship, &bquo;which caused consternation among Soviet people and Communists abroad.&equo; 
 It points out that Stalin wiped out the entire leadership of the Polish Communist Party in 1937. 
 It attacks Soviet policy in the winter war with Finland, and says the recognition of a puppet Communist government set up by emigre Finnish Communists was a serious mistake. 
 All these points were approved for printing some months before they became official policy. 
 The textbook is vague on the sensitive issue of annexation of the Baltic states. 
 But it does state that &bquo;immediately after Soviet power had been restored there as a result of complicated processes in international and internal life&equo; abuses of power and human rights violations were committed. 
 It is not surprising that the total reversal of the ideology of the past is having its effect on Soviet pupils. 
 Benjamin reports that his classmates openly say things which were never said a year ago. 
 &bquo;Lenin is to blame&equo; and &bquo;If we hadn't had the revolution we would at least be living like people&equo; are two typical sentiments. 
 Nowadays the term &bquo;comrade&equo; with which pupils addressed each other in class debates is only mentioned derogatively. 
 The new textbook is the second one to have emerged since the crisis of early 1988 when the authorities announced that school graduation exams in history were being abolished. 
 The gap between what history teachers were telling their classes and what people instinctively knew to be true had become unbearably wide. 
 Teachers ran the risk of looking like idiots or liars. 
 A re-written textbook was rushed out last autumn, but it was little better than its predecessors. 
 Stalin was praised as a great theorist and organiser, and for crushing Bukharin's &bquo;rightist deviations&equo;. 
 The latest textbook is an enormous improvement. 
 Two of its three authors are among the leading radical historians. 
 Yuri Korablev, deputy chairman of the Scientific Council on Complex Problems of the History of the Great October Socialist Revolution was one of the first to publish an article recognising that Trotsky was the driving force behind the creation of the Red Army. 
 Yuri Borisov is a section head at the Academy of Science's Institute of History. 
 Both men have been prominent in the academic debates which have helped to make the current revolution in historical studies one of the most significant of the many upheavals Gorbachev has sanctioned. 
 A parcel from London recently landed on my desk with what turns out to be the best analysis of it, Soviet History in the Gorbachev Revolution by Professor R W Davies of Birmingham University's Centre for Russian and East European Studies (Macmillan, hardback &pound;29.50, paperback &pound;7.99). 
 Davies points out that Gorbachev took a conservative attitude to Soviet history for the first 18 months of his time in power. 
 Even his magnum opus, Perestroika, written in the summer of 1987, contained the amazing notion in its first edition that &bquo;if it had not been for collectivisation, we could have died from hunger in the war&equo;. 
 The main impetus for change came from Gorbachev's close colleague, Alexander Yakovlev, who was the first Politburo member to ask publicly whether there had been alternatives to the command-administrative system. 
 He has also been the main advocate of pluralism, and of not assuming there is only one correct interpretation of the past. 
 He was probably responsible for the corrective Gorbachev gave in January last year to his own speech on the 70th anniversary of the revolution in 1987. 
 That speech disappointed many analysts with its cautious assessment of the l920s and 1930s and its justification of rapid industrialisation. 
 Two months later Gorbachev was saying his comments were not the Tablets of Moses. 
 &bquo;The understanding of our history we achieved in preparing for the 70th anniversary of October is not something frozen and given once and for all. 
 It will be deepened and developed in further research,&equo; he declared. 
 The new openness expressed in the academic debates, and the latest school textbook, still leaves many issues unanswered. 
 The acquisition of the Baltics, and post-war policy in Eastern Europe are areas crying out for more honesty. 
 There are even bigger issues: the role which Lenin played in preparing the ground for Stalin, an objective assessment of Trotsky's contribution, and the feasibility of alternatives to industrialisation at the end of the 1920s. 
 In many ways literature has run ahead of history. 
 Professional researchers are still some way behind. 
 Solzhenitsyn's Gulag Archipelago is published. 
 August 1914 and its sequels will come out shortly. 
 If Soviet historians have not had time to enter party and state archives, why not publish authoritative foreigners &mdash; Isaac Deutscher, E H Carr and Davies himself? 
 With luck it may be only a matter of time. 
 Already we can safely say goodbye to that old Soviet joke about the Stalinist re-writing of history &mdash; &bquo;The future is certain: the past is unpredictable&equo;. 
 Factory life in focus Critics' choice Visual art.. 
 By Mary Clarke 
 CHRIS KILLIP is one of the best of contemporary descriptive photographers, and this morning he opens a rather special exhibition at the Victoria and Albert Museum, an account of the way that Pirelli tyres are made, from Malayan rubber, at the factory in Burton-on-Trent. 
 He spent a month there, and his photographs show that the production of tyres, which are things that we take for granted, depend on individuals, their skills, and a surprising amount of physical effort. 
 Factory life in the age of automation has never recently been so closely or sensitively examined. 
 The New Contemporaries exhibition at the ICA has been chosen from London art colleges. 
 The painting is not nearly as good as the recent Young Contemporaries show in Manchester, where the sculpture was non-existent. 
 And at the ICA sculpture is lively. 
 What can this mean? 
 Has three-dimensional art become the natural expression of the capital? 
 Or has the show been dominated by a faction from Goldsmith's College? 
 This has been Eric Gill's year, and 140 of his engravings are at Sally Hunter. 
 Go before the end of the week. 
 Also closing is Agnew's Salute To Turner, which ends on Friday evening. 
 Bids are invited (in aid of the National Trust) for paintings by 50 contemporary artists including Bert Irvin, William Tillyer, Patrick Procktor, David Gentleman and Bernard Dunstan. 
 The old fogies tend to be the best. 
 There's an interesting mixed show of American masters at Fabian Carlsson, and the National Gallery puts some trecento painters under the restorers eye in the latest exhibition of the series Art In The Making. 
 The most interesting show out of London is Miro: Sculpture, which has opened at the Southampton City Art Gallery; 37 bronzes are on show, each one of them made by a Catalan, anarchist, sex-mad Santa Claus 
 Dance. 
 By Mary Clarke 
 CHRISTMAS is upon us. 
 The Royal Ballet embarks on a run of Ashton's Cinderella on Friday. 
 Two performances on Boxing Day; assorted casts, full details of ballet casting from 01-240 9815. 
 Sadler's Wells Royal Ballet at the Wells dance the MacMillan triple bill of Danses Concertantes, Las Hermanas and Solitaire tonight, and from tomorrow until December 28 give David Bintley's character-comedy ballet Hobson's Choice (no performance on Boxing Day). 
 English National Ballet start their Christmas season at Royal Festival Hall next Tuesday and give The Nutcracker in the Peter Schaufuss staging until January 20. 
 Twice daily from December 27 to January 6. 
 Thereafter Saturday matinees on January 13 and 20. 
 Box office 01-928 8800. 
 Channel 4 has a variety of dance programmes, namely Maguy Marin's bizarre version of Cinderella on Christmas Eve; An Evening for Armenia, the Covent Garden gala of earlier this year, on Christmas Day; the ubiquitous movie Red Shoes and English National Ballet in Swan Lake (Evelyn Hart and Schaufuss in the leads) on Boxing Day. 
 Check times with TV Times, see listings for other details In My Generation by Nick Cass of Manchester; New Contem- poraries, ICA Gallery: see Critics' choice Maria Almeida in the title role and Jonathan Cope as the Prince in the Royal Ballet's production of Ashton's Cinderella PHOTOGRAPH: LESLIE E. SPATT A detail from Carel Weight's Turner Goes To Heaven; Agnew's: see Critics' choice. 
 Moira Shearer and Robert Helpman in Red Shoes, one of Channel 4's Christmas dance offerings: see Critics' choice 
 Appreciation: Laurie Pavitt. 
 This was not a matter of political convenience. 
 I was drawn to Laurie at first meeting, when the local Co-operative Party nominated him as candidate for the 1959 general election. 
 From the bottom of the list of nominees he climbed to the top. 
 Laurie had a warmth of personality in all his doings with people and politics. 
 For me his was pluralist socialism at its best &mdash; in the service of the community. 
 A pacifist, co-operator, Third World volunteer, borough councillor, heartfelt socialist, he served the people of Brent warmly and well for 28 years. 
 In the Commons he was an independently minded, but loyal member of the Parliamentary Labour Party. 
 His concern for and knowledge of the NHS was widely recognised &mdash; and respected, though he never achieved the sort of ministerial office for which he was well qualified. 
 We marched together to and from Aldermaston, we worked together for co-operative socialism, we campaigned together for health, welfare, employment, education and housing in our &bquo;inner city&equo; constituencies. 
 We worked for a wider Europe, international peace, development and disarmament. 
 Always he was an inspiration. 
 Laurie had a passion and a warmth for people rather than the state. 
 He represented the British Labour Movement at its best. 
 He stayed in Parliament despite ill health to ensure the good health of the the Labour party he believed in. 
 I am so pleased to think that his kind of socialism &bquo;without the state&equo; is now coming to the fore again in Labour politics. 
 We have much to bless and indeed warmly remember him for. 
 John Heddle. 
 MP toed the line:. 
 THE record of John Heddle showed the Conservative MP for Mid-Staffordshire as accident-prone, impulsive and self-promotional rather than self-destructive. 
 If the archetypal Tory of the 1979 intake was a rent-a-quote property dealer who backed Mrs Thatcher to the death and the death penalty to the hilt, Mr Heddle can be called a sad loss to the Two Nations Tendency. 
 A chartered surveyor, he talked himself into the chairmanship of the Conservative backbench environment committee and in 1987 he tried to curb gazumping by a system of forfeits. 
 His most obvious weakness, like his death, was localised in cars. 
 As a new-boy, he had already been labelled as the MP who found himself driving seven miles the wrong way on the M6 until he was stopped by a patrol and banned for six months. 
 In April this year, he was arrested in Altea, near Benidorm, during a dispute with a policeman about a parking ticket. 
 Only three weeks ago, Benidorm's public prosecutor demanded a year's imprisonment and a fine if the MP were to be convicted on a charge of obstructing the police. 
 Perhaps he remembered all too clearly his 1986 suggestion that &bquo;Britons guilty of drunken and disreputable behaviour should have their passports endorsed, with automatic confiscation after three endorsements&equo;. 
 His parliamentary interventions were not confined to property, housing and environmental questions. 
 He shuddered, for instance, at the prospect of school textbooks containing anything of a &bquo;salacious, blasphemous or subliminal political nature&equo;. 
 His vestigial liberalism or compassion persuaded him to resist the introduction of the poll tax for nurses and other deserving persons &mdash; but the Whips knew him as a man who would always toe the lobby line with a specious ministerial assurance, such as Nicolas Ridley's promised poll tax rebate of &pound;130 millions. 
 After all, he had always attacked the rating system, and especially Labour councils which had &bquo;hoarded and boarded&equo; inner city land and buildings for years. 
 And he was young enough to hope for something better than a pat on the head from the Leaderene. 
 C.P.D. (Bentley) John Heddle, born September 15, 1941; died December 19, 1989. 
 Knocking in vain on Labour's door If you're not in a union, attempting to join a local branch of the Labour party can be a maddening experience, says Jane Furnival. 
 FOR SEVERAL years, my husband has been trying to join the Labour Party. 
 What's the problem? 
 Is he a Trotskyite or a right-wing mole? 
 No. 
 He has no excessive tendencies, apart from a fascination with Eastern European motorbikes. 
 An advertising writer, he's energetic, articulate and presumably just the sort of person Labour say they want to recruit. 
 But he's not allowed into the Labour Party because he's not a union member. 
 He was once in the party while a student at Cambridge. 
 But he drifted away, disenchanted, when he came to London. 
 Then &bquo;sheer revulsion&equo; at the Government, combined with Neil Kinnock's TV campaign for more members, pricked his conscience. 
 When a canvasser called during the election run-up, he decided to rejoin. 
 The man took away the application form and the &pound;12 fee. 
 A few weeks later, the Streatham area organiser phoned. 
 &bquo;You haven't filled in the bit about union membership,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;That's because I don't belong to a union: they don't have them in advertising,&equo; he explained. 
 &bquo;Anyway, shouldn't union membership be a separate decision from joining a political party?&equo; 
 The area organiser responded: &bquo;It's a local rule, and I can tell you now that the committee will reject your application unless you're in a union.&equo; 
 To prove her point, she offered the phone number of a solicitor who had joined a union just to get in. 
 Astonished, he asked her to put in his application anyway, to see what would happen. 
 We pondered our next move. 
 Kinnock's TV commercial hadn't mentioned union membership. 
 Should we complain to the Advertising Standards Authority? 
 Unfortunately, they have no power over political parties, who aren't expected to be legal, decent, honest or truthful. 
 Instead, I phoned Labour Party headquarters and spoke to Mr Whitty, the person in charge of national membership. 
 He explained that union membership was an outdated rule. 
 The idea was to encourage people to join a union &mdash; not ban them if they couldn't. 
 He would sort it out, he said. 
 Then a rejection letter arrived from Streatham branch &mdash; because he wasn't a union member. 
 However, they graciously added, could they keep his &pound;12 joining fee &bquo;as a donation to party funds?&equo; 
 He wrote to Mr Kinnock. 
 &bquo;I got an indignant reply from a Ms Norris, saying in effect how dare I trouble Mr Kinnock with this low-level stuff,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;They passed it downwards.&equo; 
 When he heard nothing, he wrote to headquarters again. 
 Still no response. 
 By this time, we got the impression that the gulf between Walworth Road and Streatham was so great, it was like trying to control unruly hill tribes beyond Hadrian's Wall. 
 At the same time, our cleaning lady, an ex-bus conductress and union member, tried to join the same Streatham branch and was turned away because they were &bquo;too busy&equo;. 
 Now we have moved to Dulwich, my husband has had another go at joining. 
 He filled out the form. 
 Three weeks ago came the ominous phone call. 
 &bquo;Are you a union member?&equo; 
 Patiently, he explained that he now ran his own fledgling advertising agency. 
 &bquo;Oh, a company director? 
 Let's put you down as self-employed and get round it that way.&equo; 
 He was assured that he would hear in a few days. 
 Then &mdash; silence. 
 It looks like the shop door has once more closed in his face. 
 The hell that is Easterhouse Dominic and his family live in one of Glasgow's worst housing estates. 
 This-in his words-is his story. 
 After five years on the dole in Easterhouse, Dr Bob Holman (the estate's campaigning community worker) gave me a job working with him as a neighbourhood worker. 
 I enjoyed the job and did pretty well. 
 But my housing conditions were constantly weighing on us. 
 Our flat is one of the two occupied in the block. 
 The empty upstairs became the haunt of druggies and our small children would sometimes carry in their needles. 
 Here is what has happened to me. 
 April 27, 1989. 
 Bob sends a letter to Housing Dept supporting my request for a transfer. 
 June 28. 
 Door kicked in and rented video stolen. 
 I have to pay for this. 
 August 12. 
 Came home from a week's camp with local youngsters to find that the whole house had been ransacked, windows smashed, kids toys broken, the water boiler ripped out and everything wet. 
 Schools clothing grant giro, my medical card, fishing rods, my son's snooker cue all stolen. 
 Books, letters, clothes, scattered everywhere. 
 Living room and bedrooms totally vandalised. 
 August 15. 
 Submitted another letter from Bob to Housing Dept in which he expresses concern about the effects on the children and asking for us to be re-housed in a safer area. 
 Had interview with housing official who stated that I had to transfer the tenancy from my wife's name to mine and then something would be done within a week. 
 My wife has left with the two girls saying &bquo;I canny take any more&equo;. 
 They are in a flat for the homeless. 
 August 17. 
 Housing official signed transfer forms and I was told I would receive notification of anew house within a week. 
 August 19. 
 Water boiler in flat above stolen, water pours on to us. 
 Still no hot water in our flat as council not replaced our boiler. 
 Kids had bath at Bob's. 
 September 3. 
 Door kicked in again. 
 They stole my two guitars and hi-fi. 
 September 4. 
 Door kicked in yet again. 
 The replacement water tank and copper piping (which the council had brought) stolen along with more of our stuff. 
 September 5. 
 Broken into again. 
 Amplification stolen. 
 Informed police once more. 
 September 6. 
 This was the day when I decided that I'd had enough. 
 I totally cracked up and got steaming drunk. 
 Phoned Bob to tell him. 
 He came. 
 Suicidal, admitted to hospital. 
 September 7. 
 Released from hospital. 
 Saw psychiatrist and was assured that a bed would be made available at Parkhead hospital as soon as possible. 
 On sedation. 
 September 8. 
 Saw a social worker who listened but was of no real practical help. 
 By this time I was a nervous wreck and The house in Govan was a shambles. 
 There was no way I could bring up children there. 
 the kids were terrified to stay in the house. 
 I tried to explain about the break-ins, the gangs, the violence but he was adamant. 
 He went on to say that if I did not return I would be making myself voluntarily homeless and would never be re-housed. 
 September 11. 
 Saw police detective sergeant who was very understanding. 
 Told me that one youth was in custody and another due to appear in court for the break-ins. 
 But other gang members warned my kids that I was to get slashed for grassing. 
 Saw another social worker who got on to housing. 
 The official referred to me to the Homeless Unit. 
 I made the long trip with my boys but the unit told me I should not be there. 
 Back to square one. 
 After a long debate, they finally agreed to put us up for the night. 
 By this time the kids were as confused as I was. 
 September 12. 
 The Homeless Unit took us to the Housing Department. 
 Waited 2 &frac12; hours to see the same official. 
 I now handed in a form explaining that my dad lived alone, is blind and disabled, and would benefit from me moving to his part of Glasgow. 
 I was told this would take time to go through. 
 September 13. 
 The Housing again. 
 The official told me that the form was not enough and that I needed a letter from my dad saying he lived alone. 
 He then said that he now had confirmation from the police and that I qualified for a transfer and would receive an offer for Govan (where my dad is) within a week. 
 September 14. 
 Got offer for house in Govan. 
 It was a shambles, gangs openly using drugs in the street, every second house boarded up. 
 There was no way I could bring up young children there. 
 The place should be closed down by the Environmental Health Department. 
 Back to housing, handed in a letter from my doctor which states that the root of my illness is my current housing situation. 
 September 15. 
 Housing official too busy to see me. 
 Handed in letter from my father stating that he had no other relatives in the area and because of his blindness and disability he would benefit from them moving into the area. 
 Now I've been informed that I have &pound;200 rent arrears. 
 Filled in a new rent rebate form. 
 SINCE the start of this saga I've lost my wife, who is currently staying in a homeless flat with two of the children. 
 My mental health has deteriorated to such an extent that I had to be admitted to hospital and am currently on sedation. 
 I've resigned from my job because I can't cope. 
 My three boys are terrified to sleep in their own beds. 
 I started drinking heavily although the medication has stopped this. 
 If I could get a home where my kids could grow up with daily fear and where I could also help my father, I could push this hell out of my mind and start afresh with my family. 
 Is this too much to ask? 
 Memory loss by the state Erlend Clouston reports on the difficulty people like Debbie Finni have in obtaining treatment for brain disorders like the amnesia she suffered four years ago. 
 WHOSE job is it to look after people whose bodies are incapacitated, for one reason or another? 
 Most people assume the government will lay on something. 
 A few may flourish the 14 pages of the Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons Act, 1970; seven inches of section 2 specifies a local authority's obligation to lay on just about everything short of a course in elephant skinning: meals, education, holidays, telephones, and recreation are all there in paragraphs (a) to (h). 
 It looks moderately cast iron. 
 But it is not. 
 Nearly two years ago, this page highlighted the condition of Debbie Finni, a 21-year-old Manchester amnesiac trapped by official indifference in a twilight world of video tapes and puzzle books. 
 BBC television's Brass Tacks subsequently featured Debbie in a programme exposing the inadequacy of the rehabilitation facilities available to Britons with brain injury. 
 Yet now, three and a half years after Debbie was discharged from hospital, her mother has written a letter to the authorities, bitterly criticising them for &bquo;bad planning, no comprehension and dismissive attitudes&equo;. 
 In January 1986, Debbie suffered a brain haemorrhage. 
 This left her with a severe form of amnesia that reduced her memory span to 20 minutes or less. 
 She was incapable of work, bewildered by the sudden inexplicability of situations she found herself in. 
 She could not walk to the shops as there was no guarantee she would arrive there, let alone walk back. 
 She became informally imprisoned in the family maisonette, unable to cope with cooking, visitors, or any kind of isolation. 
 Her mother, Freda, separated from her husband, had to keep a 24-hour vigil. 
 A personable and pretty girl was locked into a lifestyle (the videos, the soap operas, the Jumbo Colouring Pads, mum's ancient friends) that would have bored a tortoise. 
 Yet, until very recently, the local health authority made no attempt to provide any kind of rehabilitation for their former patient. 
 The only official compensation is a weekly &pound;76-worth of invalidity and daytime attendance allowance. 
 &bquo;If Debbie had lost a leg she would have been given a customised artificial limb and provided with physiotherapy at the hospital and at home,&equo; says Mrs Finni. 
 &bquo;I don't see why it should be any different if a person loses a brain function.&equo; 
 Debbie is not alone in her predicament. 
 It is estimated &bquo;If I die, they will have to do something for her. 
 So why can't they do it now?&equo;. that there are close to 200,000 victims of brain injury in the country. 
 They wander in an administrative mist, abandoned by the neurologists and orthopaedic surgeons who first treated them, ignored by occupational therapists and social workers to whom brain disorder is juju territory. 
 &bquo;The crux of the matter,&equo; says Deborah Wearing of the Amnesia Association, &bquo;is that the system recognises physical disability, mental handicap and mental injury; those three categories have budgets and departments and care units. 
 But the system does not, so far, recognise brain injury, despite the enormous advances over the past ten years in the study of cognitive, behavioural and memory problems.&equo; 
 Debbie and Freda Finni know this to their cost. 
 Debbie has been referred to a Young Disabled Unit and a psychiatric unit (&bquo;On the second day they found her playing cards in the alcoholics&equo; ward&equo;). 
 Six months after the Guardian article appeared, two and a half years after she was waved out of their hospital, South Manchester health authority finally agreed to supply a psychologist for two hours a week. 
 Ms Barbara Speke helps Debbie develop &bquo;strategies for coping.&equo; 
 Mrs Finni is grateful for Ms Speke's &bquo;wonderful&equo; work. 
 &bquo;But how much, realistically, can you achieve in two hours?&equo; 
 Mrs Finni's parental patience finally snapped this summer. 
 First, Ms Speke was off ill for three months. 
 Then an attempted entry to a local authority hairdressing course went embarrassingly wrong; it finished with Mrs Finni having to spell out her daughter's handicap to students and a flustered teacher who eventually refused to accept responsibility for a girl who could never be left alone in the classroom. 
 &bquo;I was absolutely devastated. 
 It was back to square one: telly 24 hours a day. 
 What put the top hat on it was, when we came back, Debbie sat on the sofa and cried &bquo;Mum, I'm so fed up of being amnesic&equo;. 
 Compared with four years ago, Debbie is improving. 
 Her memory can sometimes stretch back one hour or more. 
 She writes letters; propped up on her dresser is a postcard from Greece, sent by an amnesic pen pal who began to correspond after spying Debbie on the Brass Tacks programme. 
 Supervision need not be so intense. 
 &bquo;Debbie could certainly be capable of working for a hairdresser in some capacity,&equo; says Fergus Stewart, a lecturer at the Central Manchester College of Technology where Mrs Finni had Debbie briefly enrolled this spring after her local branch of the Amnesia Association suggested a visit. 
 The frustration is almost unbearable for the mother. 
 &bquo;If I die, they will have to do something for her,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;So why can't they do it now?&equo; 
 Her letter &mdash; her distress call &mdash; begged that someone do something quickly. 
 &bquo;Both Deborah and I are at our wits&equo; end.&equo; 
 Three weeks after posting copies to Manchester's social services and education departments, the North-west regional health authority and South Manchester health district, Mrs Finni had had no replies. 
 So the Guardian made some inquiries. 
 Social Services: &bquo;Haven't got any letter; maybe it's at the Wythenshawe office?&equo; 
 It wasn't. 
 Education: &bquo;Obviously there is something extraordinary here. 
 We are arranging a case conference. 
 We have a lot of sympathy for the family.&equo; 
 Regional health authority: &bquo;We are preparing a response. 
 The person who is writing it is at a meeting so you can't speak to him.&equo; 
 South Manchester health district: &bquo;We have put everything we possibly can into this case. 
 The psychologist really is the tops. 
 What Mrs Finni may feel is the answer may not actually be the answer. 
 If there was any extra request for assistance we would look on it favourably.&equo; 
 And the impressive promises contained in the Chronically Sick and Disabled Persons Act, 1970? 
 At the Department of Health they said it was Department of Social Security matter. 
 At Social Security they said nonsense, it must be Health. 
 Finally, 24 hours later, Health admitted responsibility. 
 &bquo;Amnesiacs could be covered by the Act. 
 It doesn't specify conditions. 
 Everything depends on the degree of the condition, as determined by social services following medical advice.&equo; 
 Mrs Finni will apply, without much optimism. 
 &bquo;They're crafty; very hard to get anything out of.&equo; 
 Debbie's application for attendance allowance has already been squashed on the grounds that she knows the names of her mother, her sister and the Prime Minister. 
 The Amnesia Association (01 969 0796) is at St Charles Hospital, Exmoor St., London W10 6DZ. 
 Debbie Finni&hellip; trapped by indifferencePHOTOGRAPH: DON McPHEE 
 At a time of radical change in Hungary, Nick Dallman relives his experiences at the hands of the secret and often brutal state now being dismantled State of fear. 
 ARAP on the door. 
 Nerves tighten. 
 Nowadays in Hungary, when the dismantling of red stars &mdash; from public buildings, from railway engines, and perhaps even from the gravestones of party members &mdash; has become a minor industry, nobody worries about ominous knocks on the door. 
 Ten years ago, however, when memories of nocturnal visitors &mdash; coming in twos, but more often in fours, hardly bothering to produce a warrant &mdash; were still fresh, the noise made hearts miss a beat. 
 &bquo;We are expecting nobody,&equo; I hear someone say, but the silhouette at the door, like an exclamation mark at the end of a command, demands attention. 
 The silhouette materialises into a colonel in uniform, standing at ease, his face breaking into a tentative smile. 
 &bquo;Hello, old man, you haven't changed a bit in 35 years,&equo; says the colonel. 
 That is a lie for a start, I think, as I submit to the customary kiss on both cheeks. 
 After an absence of so many years, this kissing among men seems an odd thing, but one ought to be thankful for small mercies: at least it is only two kisses and not three, as is the Russian custom. 
 I am much less worried by the kisses than by the question of the identity of the officer in front of me. 
 Who is he, I wonder, as I struggle to superimpose a young face on his middle-aged features. 
 As his hand reaches out for mine, I recollect that at one point in those early post-war years I had a positive dread of men in uniform, and my terror grew in direct proportion with each extra pip. 
 My aversion to officers, especially those dressed in the dull green of the Wehrmacht, was already well established when, the war over, I ran into an old schoolmate of mine who was well versed in the ways of the then flourishing black market. 
 Sensing, or knowing, that my days in my native land were numbered, he asked me if I needed foreign currency. 
 Undeterred by an evasive reply, he told me he could even provide a reliable guide who would conduct me across the border. 
 The temption was too great to resist. 
 I turned up at his apartment at the appointed hour. 
 A maid &mdash; a rarity in those puritan and egalitarian days &mdash; opened the door. 
 &bquo;Can I take your coat?&equo; she asked sweetly. 
 Suddenly my eyes opened wide: I saw that my faded garment was being hung in the closet next to four well-tailored officers' overcoats, gold stars shining on pale blue epaulets, the insignia of the AVO, the state security police. 
 A trap had been set, but they had forgotten to camouflage it. 
 Before she could announce me, I retrieved the coat, muttered a few feeble excuses, and ran. 
 Barely six months earlier, however, another trap had been laid and I had fallen into it with a resounding thud. 
 I was doing my third week as a young crime reporter and had just about finished my second and last story of the day when the phone rang. 
 The police press officer's secretary was on the line: &bquo;I'm glad your are still there. 
 We have a story for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine,&equo; said I cheerily, &bquo;I shall be round in a jiffy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't bother,&equo; came the reply. 
 &bquo;The inspector in charge is going your way, just wait for him.&equo; 
 A few minutes later a car drew up, its brakes screeching in the best SS fashion. 
 Four men burst into the room. 
 After the clatter and the slamming of the door&hellip; silence. 
 IWAS looking at them uncomprehendingly; they were eyeing me like a cat watches a captured mouse that might yet try to make a dash for freedom. 
 Then one barked at me: &bquo;Hand over your revolver!&equo; 
 &bquo;My what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Stop wasting time,&equo; he said. 
 I would have smiled at the Kafkaesqueness of the situation, had I not broken out in a cold sweat and had I at that stage not been ignorant of Kafka's existence. 
 The journey to the State Security offices was short; the stay there much longer. 
 By way of welcome, I was told to stand facing the wall. 
 This order was not countermanded until the early hours of the morning. 
 By that time the room had acquired an axis and was gently girating around it. 
 I was hungry and dizzy. 
 &bquo;Sit down,&equo; said the night worker. 
 &bquo;I need your signature.&equo; 
 He shone his desk lamp in my face. 
 I delved into my rather limited reservoir of defiance. 
 &bquo;You wanted to confuse me. 
 You have succeeded. 
 Now I can't even remember my name.&equo; 
 At this point his heavy hand came into harsh contact with my face. 
 Later I saw in the mirror that the shape of his palm and fingers was etched in dark red on my skin. 
 If I had been able to see a copy of the local Communist party paper, I would have learned that I &mdash; with many others &mdash; had been unmasked as a conspirator and an enemy of the state. 
 I was in good company. 
 The then prime minister &mdash; another, now forgotten, Nagy &mdash; was also accused of conspiracy. 
 It was never explained how was it possible to conspire against yourself. 
 Our official unmasking was yet to come. 
 One afternoon I was bundled on to an open lorry where about 40 others were already shivering in the late autumn frost. 
 Destination&hellip; 
 Budapest, Andrassy ut 60, taken over without any qualms by the AVO from its fascist secret police predecessors. 
 By way of diversion we stopped off at the army's counter-intelligence headquarters. 
 Forty bunks to a barrack room. 
 Still shivering, we were made to lie down, men and women in adjoining beds. 
 Four soldiers with submachine guns patrolled the room, and an officer made his rounds at frequent intervals. 
 Loo time twice a day. 
 The loos had no doors. 
 We were taken out one by one and always a soldier stood behind, the barrel of his gun shoved between the prisoner's shoulder blades. 
 We could hear the women beg: &bquo;Can't you please move away?&equo; 
 This plea was always followed by laughter. 
 Nobody questioned us, and the soldiers never replied if someone dared to speak to them. 
 In a desperate attempt at humour someone in a neighbouring bed muttered half out loud: &bquo;The suspense is killing me.&equo; 
 A gale of laughter. 
 &bquo;Shut up, you bloody lot,&equo; shouted a soldier, and and he and his companions started rushing up and down the room. 
 The commotion brought in the new duty officer, a tall and muscular young lieutenant with a sad, world-weary face. 
 &bquo;John!&equo; 
 I cried out in relief and happiness: I thought I recognised him as a former schoolmate, a boy with whom I used to exchange groans about the maths problems whose solutions so frequently eluded us. 
 He had left our school in our final year, when his parents moved to another town. 
 But &bquo;John&equo; did not respond. 
 He looked in my direction briefly, but without a flicker of recognition. 
 I am hallucinating, I said to myself at first: the strain has affected my mind. 
 During the next two days, before the dungeons of Andrassy ut 60 finally swallowed us, &bquo;John&equo; continued to make his rounds. 
 My eyes followed his every move. 
 The question of whether he was or was not John became the most important thing in my constricted universe. 
 I had to convince myself that my grasp of reality was not slipping away. 
 If it were, the day would come when the man behind the shining table lamp would toss a fountain pen in my direction and tell me to sign a piece of paper, and I would say, what the hell, why not? 
 But &bquo;John&equo; was no help. 
 He just looked through me. 
 I was a non-person in the making. 
 THIRTY-FIVE years later, as these thoughts of my encounters with men in uniform flashed through my mind, the colonel, who by this time I had succeeded in recognising as another former classmate, said to me: &bquo;Come and have a coffee!&equo; 
 He grabbed my arm and guided me towards the road. 
 The coffee came with Unicum, a bitter spirit so much beloved by Hungarians that it is only available in expensive restaurants and hard-currency shops. 
 Another coffee and two more Unicums later the colonel asked: &bquo;Do you remember John, who was in the army with me?&equo; 
 &bquo;Funny you should mention him&hellip; 
 &equo; I replied. 
 He cut me short. 
 &bquo;John died of leukaemia five years ago. 
 I saw him in hospital a few days before the end. 
 He told me there was one thing which had deeply troubled him throughout his life, and that was refusing to acknowledge you when you were in trouble. 
 He asked me to find you and to offer you his apologies and regrets. 
 So I have made a point of looking you up.&equo; 
 This called for another Unicum, without coffee this time, and a bottle of sparkling wine as a chaser. 
 The colonel and I parted the best of friends. 
 Don't worry, John, all is forgiven&hellip; and almost forgotten. 
 Just tell me one last thing: as everyone is so busy wiping out the memory of the last 40 odd years, do you still want to keep your military headstone with its red star? 
 Nick Dallman, now an assistant foreign editor at the Guardian, escaped from Hungary to Austria in 1948. 
 In a bid to get to France, he joined the Foreign Legion, escaping from that two days later. 
 A tram driver hid him under a seat in return for two packets of cigarettes and he escaped from the Austrian Soviet zone. 
 He then came to Britain, where he worked on a farm and in a Blackburn cotton mill. 
 After taking a degree in economics he joined the Sheffield Telegraph, moving to the Manchester Guardian in 1960. 
 David Brindle finds a cure for many of the ills dogging the NHS's new contract culture The Welsh way to good national health. 
 AS ARGUMENT over the Government's health reforms shifts to Parliament, and with line-by-line combat over the National Health Service and Community Care Bill, so attention is focusing on the quality of care we should expect and receive. 
 Labour will use the bill's committee stage, which began yesterday, to argue that the legislation is silent on how care standards will be measured in the NHS's new contract culture and how the views of patients will be taken into account. 
 The bill is, in this respect, a cart without a horse. 
 Because it lacks any tangible goals for the delivery and outcome of health care, it remains vulnerable to accusations of crude cost-curbing. 
 It needs, as a minimum, some complementary statement of aims of what the NHS should achieve as it moves into the next century. 
 As it happens, there is one. 
 Published last month, it sets out a strategic intent and direction for the health service, priorities for progress and practical steps to be taken &mdash; in Wales. 
 Not for the first time, the NHS in Wales seems streets ahead of its big brother in England. 
 In policy areas ranging from mental illness to community nursing to staff development, the Welsh health service has been taking the plaudits. 
 It came as no surprise in July when the Commons Public Accounts Committee contrasted a shambles over heart disease prevention in England with a &bquo;vigorous and businesslike&equo; Welsh approach. 
 Now, the NHS in Wales shows every sign of making a half-decent fist of the Government's shake-up, whatever its merits, while England stumbles on blindly and hastily. 
 The changes &mdash; opted-out hospitals, GP budgets, the so-called internal market &mdash; apply equally throughout Britain. 
 But while England and, for that matter, Scotland, are being stampeded into adopting them before the ink on the bill is even dry, there is a definite lack of urgency west of Offa's Dyke. 
 Thus the Welsh Office says: &bquo;Hospitals have the option to seek self-governing status, but we are not expecting many applications.&equo; 
 There are, in fact, no applications; nor are there Welsh GPs queuing up to run their own budgets. 
 As for England's painfully tight April 1991 deadline for the changes, the Welsh prefer to think in terms of the &bquo;early 1990s&equo;. 
 &bquo;It's a question of horses for courses, finding the best route forward and adopting the practices to fit that rather than bulldozing your way through without perhaps realising the wider environment in which this needs to work,&equo; says John Catford, director of the Health Promotion Authority for Wales and professor of health promotion at the University of Wales. 
 It is Wales which has produced a health planning strategy. 
 Ian Grist, the junior Welsh minister responsible for health, says he and Peter Walker, the Welsh Secretary, &bquo;fully recognise the need for the NHS in Wales to be given a clear steer as to its future direction&equo;. 
 This steer, in brief, sets out 10 key areas of &bquo;health gain&equo;, ranging from emotional health to cancers, and determines how these should be addressed by &bquo;people-centred&equo; planning and effective use of resources. 
 While much of it may seem blindingly obvious, one non-NHS member of the team behind the strategy points out: &bquo;Irrespective of the fact that the approach is well recognised in industry, it's totally innovative in NHS terms. 
 Wales has stolen a march on England.&equo; 
 To rub salt into England's wounds, Wales has produced an information technology policy to underpin the budgeting, pricing and payment demands of the coming health market. 
 A computer strategy for England is promised. 
 But critics charge that the NHS shake-up has already been damaged by the existing technology free-for-all. 
 As the Welsh policy says, the internal market can only work on the basis of a high level of integration of technology. 
 Or as Dr Dani Bevan, general manager of Powys health authority puts it: &bquo;If we don't get the communications right, we can't talk to each other.&equo; 
 The reasons for Wales's clarity of thinking are not difficult to see: ministers more interested in practical achievement than ideology; an NHS management team together now for five years; and, above all, a district structure and population the size of just one of England's 14 regions. 
 Is not the answer, then, to devolve responsibility from Whitehall and, in effect, turn England into 14 Waleses? 
 While the Government claims its plans are all about decentralisation, the new powers the NHS bill gives the Health Secretary suggest otherwise. 
 Telling tales Television. 
 By Nancy Banks-Smith 
 LONG ago, said Signals (Channel 4) in a nice, pouring-cream sort of voice-over &bquo;in an almost forgotten time, even before Morecambe and Wise and the James Bond movie on TV, for many people Christmas entertainment meant an evening of storytelling by the light of a log fire.&equo; 
 Goodness, yes. 
 I remember it well. 
 Chestnuts roasting on an open fire, Jack Frost nipping at your nose, Cousin Lizzie Ann, a stalwart of the Band of Hope, incapable as usual on sherry trifle and the seasonal sound of feet running upstairs and passionate sobbing from the bedroom. 
 What a treat it all was. 
 As Signals explained, television ruined all this homespun entertainment but personally I found it quite a relief when we got a set and could all sit around watching King George's funeral. 
 To reintroduce us to the joys of story telling round the log fire, Signals rounded up a slightly disconcerting group of five contemporary writers, all strange to me. 
 Some stranger than others. 
 Kathy Acker's off-the-shoulder dress displayed to advantage her collection of off-the-shoulder tattoos; Sara Maitland wore a pale pink pyjama suit and Jean Binta Breeze seemed to be smoking a pipe. 
 Having told her story with some brio, Miss Breeze burst into tears and was comforted by the motherly Miss Maitland. 
 There were gruff mutterings of &bquo;excellent story&equo; or &bquo;very good&equo; from the two men, who were never in the same league and knew it. 
 The stories were of an dullness to bring a water buffalo to its knees. 
 When John Logie Baird was born I do not doubt that a star stood over the little saviour's cradle. 
 AND now stand by for our Christmas competition. 
 I offer a flask of Featherwheel's famous body lotion (&bquo;Wave goodnight to cellulite&equo;) as seen in Blackeyes (BBC 2) to anyone who can describe, without breaking into a light sweat, what was going on. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; as Blackeyes herself said in this last episode &bquo;What? 
 What? 
 What?&equo; 
 Being in effect a doll, Blackeyes was as dumb as she was beautiful but I couldn't have put it better myself. 
 Blackeyes was a disorientating experience like being caught up in someone else's feverish dream. 
 Her very name, like Snow White or Red Riding Hood, is not real at all, but out of a fairy story. 
 It suggests at once beauty and brutality for some are born with black eyes and some are given them. 
 There was a beautiful girl, a prince and a wicked uncle. 
 A wolf, perhaps. 
 It was a child's story about child abuse. 
 The whole thing seethed, illusion and allusion swinging from branch to branch like gibbons in the treetops. 
 It was painful, beautiful and obscure, a not uncommon state of affairs when the creator also directs, gives a running commentary on the action and writes himself into the story at the end. 
 If God had not kept everything in his own hands, life might be a bit clearer. 
 Long ago when Dennis Potter was a television critic too, he was reviewing Miss World. 
 He said he had been to a beauty contest where the audience were mostly farmers. 
 As the girls paraded, the men shouted out bids. 
 &bquo;WE HAVE decapitated him from the dictatorship,&equo; said General Powell, briefing the press in the Pentagon on Sky, which comes into its own on stories like this. 
 There was a picture of Noriega, coincidentally a head shot, looking like Ronald Kray with a serious skin condition. 
 At first General Powell called him General Noriega then, after some consideration, changed it to Mr Noriega. 
 These rolling stories, coming in live, prickle the skin in a way that is almost primitive. 
 You seem to smell danger and taste excitement and, as television has no smell or taste, that is powerful evocation. 
 PAGE 
 It's easy to criticise. 
 But is it so easy when you're on someone else's patch? 
 We invited our critics to trade places for a day. 
 So how does an art buff see radio, and what does an architecture expert make of TV? 
 Not always the obvious &mdash; there's Dennis Potter's debt to Neighbours, for instance Anything you can do&hellip;. 
 Television Martin Pawley (Architecture Critic) on Blackeyes 
 IT IS amazing how few critics seem to have been able to recognise Dennis Potter's Blackeyes for what it is, just another Anglo-Australian copy of Neighbours. 
 Potter's earlier production The Singing Detective shared the same provenance. 
 Then the hero's ghastly disease was loosely based on the Ramsey Street saga of Bev's car crash and coma. 
 This time the original is more closely followed. 
 At one point in episode three Blackeyes actually says; &bquo;Funny isn't it, I never used to like tea.&equo; 
 Almost too close to Madge Ramsey's famous; &bquo;Say what you like, there's nothing like a nice cup of tea.&equo; 
 Then there is the use of repeated sequences in Blackeyes, many of them differentiated only by the actors' wardrobe. 
 This too is a technique pioneered by Neighbours, where it works best at the beginning and end of each episode, and in the poignant identification of the tragedy of Paul and Gail, who do and say the same things day after day, but wear different clothes. 
 This leads me to my only criticism of Potter's version, its extravagance. 
 In the original not one second of dialogue is ever wasted and Potter could learn a lot from this. 
 When Mrs Broadly is stretchered out of the Coffee Shop in an oxygen mask, for example, we all know Dr Beverley Marshal is going to be sued for malpractice &mdash; such is the power of consummate technique. 
 But Potter's version is profligate with clues, for instance, in the rape scene. 
 If anywhere, it is here that Potter's inexperience shows. 
 Not many viewers can have realised that this was a deft parody of the catastrophic visit of Mike's &bquo;uni-mates&equo; a week or so ago that ended in Bron cruelly dumping him just before his psychology exam. 
 Horses. 
 Mary Clarke (Dance Critic) 
 IF I WAS not writing about dancers, I would love to write about horses. 
 Not to encroach upon this paper's wonderful racing pages but rather to hymn the beauty of the noble steeds. 
 If not at yet another matinee of Swan Lake during the flat season, I am usually in front of a television set fascinated by the fine-boned, immaculately-trained and groomed creatures and then by their sheer grace in motion once they begin to race. 
 Grace in motion is the quality that is shared by professional dancers and thoroughbred horses, for dancers can also be described as thoroughbred &mdash; the classical ballet technique, especially, brings beautiful refinement to dancers' bodies. 
 Ballet traces its origins to the great court spectacles of the Renaissance and horses participated in the &bquo;horse ballets&equo; &mdash; both horses and royal riders gorgeously caparisoned by artists such as Henri Gissey. 
 Horses have been favourite subjects for artists from time immemorial-how lovingly is the horse depicted in Rembrandt's The Polish Rider-but the artist who paid equal attention to dancers and horses was Degas; he understood the special elegance of the way in which they both moved. 
 A number of race horses have been named after dancers. 
 Most famous perhaps has been Nijinsky. 
 In April 1970 Romola Nijinsky, widow of great Vaslav, saw the horse win the Two Thousand Guineas. 
 A very special example of classic horsemanship in performance is provided by the Lipizzaner, the grey-white stallions of Vienna. 
 Beneath the chandeliers of the Spanish Riding School, they display their virtuosity to the music of Mozart. 
 &bquo;It's like Balanchine,&equo; cried an American dancer when she first discovered them. 
 Radio 3. 
 Tim Hilton (Art Critic) 
 THIS last year my wife was ill, hospitalised, went abroad to convalesce. 
 I mooned about the house, not getting on well with writing, nor for that matter with reading. 
 But I had a friend in Radio 3: so thanks, ghostly and absent companion. 
 I listened all day, from the bright, undemanding getting-up-time music to the midnight news, at that terrible hour, owl-season, when newspapers have been put to bed and cold skin grows over the country's cocoa. 
 The music seemed unreal, especially because of my tranny. 
 Sounds come from an apparatus imperfectly tuned to the ether. 
 You find a parallel world that knows great beauty but can speak only through a tiny box of plastic and tin. 
 Orchestras don't work for me, but chamber music becomes cavern music, and I loved the swell of Brahms cello breaking over the piano, and pieces like the Schubert Arpeggioni Sonata (not really Schubertian, says my colleague Ted Greenfield, whose Saturday morning talks are a delight), in which the cello and piano talk together like Piccasso and Braque. 
 Theatre in the world at large is unimaginable without an audience: I wouldn't dream of listening to radio drama with anyone else in the room. 
 Simon Gray's The Holy Terror was good, but Beckett is incomparable, and Barry McGovern's reading of Stirrings Still is an owl in the belfry of my memory. 
 By the way, Beckett critics haven't noticed that his music sometimes comes from Lord Dunsany, the Irish cricketer, fantasist and pioneer of radio theatre. 
 Could we have a Dunsany night some time? 
 Architecture. 
 Tom Sutcliffe (Opera Critic) on the Meyerson 
 LIVING in England, I never expect to get an architectural thrill when I go to a concert or the theatre. 
 There are good theatres in London, all of them built before 1920, and I can take pleasure in the design of the Wigmore Hall and Covent Garden. 
 But of places like the Barbican and the National Theatre, &bquo;nuff said. 
 Theatres and concert halls can be beautiful and stirring places, quite apart from what goes on in them. 
 The frigid elegance of the new Opera Bastille, and the immanence of that whole mixed quartier of Paris viewed from the foyers, makes a memorable experience. 
 But the building does not reveal the hand of a master the way that the Dallas Symphony Orchestra's new Morton H. Meyerson Symphony Center does. 
 My visit to the Meyerson, IM Pei's beautiful construction on the unimpressive edge of downtown Dallas, was a real architectural experience. 
 The concert hall itself reminds one playfully of reproduction art deco and is also acoustically first-class and adaptable. 
 Rhetoric may be a dirty word in modern architecture, because it implies waste and irrelevance. 
 Pei's generosity with space, the fact that one never feels oppressed by ceilings (as I always do at Lasdun's National Theatre), reveals him as a distinctive architectural sculptor. 
 The angles of approach to the main foyer area are scrupulously calculated. 
 In this vast hall, which is partly encased in stone and partly in glass, the eye is invited by the plain and effective lines of the upper level as much as by the round-the-corner restaurant space with its oriental-seeming garden outside. 
 Pei's openness uses the outside so that it seems as inviting as the interior. 
 What is architecture but the memorable and effective use of space? 
 Paris has its Pei pyramid. 
 I wish London had Pei in its skyline. 
 Opera. 
 Michael Billington (Theatre Critic) on various productions 
 IMANAGE to do it about eight times a year. 
 Miriam Stoppard, who has more stamina, says she likes to do it two or three times a week. 
 I refer to opera-going: something that has become not merely trendy but deep-rootedly popular. 
 Why? 
 Several reasons. 
 Ever-improving standards of production and design (hear Arnold Bennett in 1921 complaining that &bquo;operatic mismanagers are obsessed with the music and they leave everything else to people who are either dead and have forgotten to get themselves buried or who don't know the elements of their job&equo;). 
 Increased accessibility: sur-titles, says Rodney Milnes, are the invention of the devil but I find they enhance my intellectual and emotional enjoyment. 
 Also audiences clearly find in opera a spiritual intensity and cathartic richness they are not always getting from the straight theatre. 
 Personal highlights of my own l989 operatic diary? 
 The moving, unearthly off-stage sound of Christopher Robson's counter-tenor in Aribert Reimann's Lear signifying his transformation from Edgar to Poor Tom. 
 The triumphant audacity of David Alden's Coliseum production of A Masked Ball (will one ever forget that last-act image of death on a pale horse smashing time?). 
 The fragrant sadness of Janis Kelly in Street Scene counterpointed by the ebullient jitterbugging of Catherine Zeta Jones and Philip Gould as the young lovers risking careless rupture. 
 The satisfying completeness of the Gotz Friedrich Die Walkure at Covent Garden with its famous Time Tunnel set: visually outre (how rarely does one encounter gods in the Washington subway), it was vocally superb and beautifully conducted by Haitink. 
 I was so purified and uplifted that when I came out and discovered my car had been towed away and I'd have to fork out 70 quid, I was completely unruffled. 
 That wouldn't have happened after The Baker's Wife. 
 Heritage. 
 Edward Greenfield (Music Critic) on Spitalfields 
 LIVING in Spitalfields is something which takes you over. 
 How else to account for what at the time seemed wildly erratic behaviour, when in 1977 a group of distinguished architects and others, members of the newly formed Spitalfields Trust, squatted in two derelict early Georgian houses in Elder Street, thwarting the property developer's bulldozers by sheer persistence. 
 That is only a part of the story, now told in a book published by the Trust, The Saving of Spitalfields. 
 It was the closest of calls, and what the book enthrallingly brings out is how much it all depended on this handful of enthusiasts to preserve an enclave unique in London. 
 For a generation and more it had been an area totally neglected. 
 Dozens of early Georgian houses built in the 1720s in Queen Anne style (surprisingly rare in central London) had been allowed to fall into decay &mdash; to be turned into sweatshops for the clothing industry, to be converted into offices for the fruit-market or simply to become slums. 
 Douglas Blain, secretary of the Trust, describes his own first contact with the area, by chance coming across it in 1961. 
 Single-handed he did his best to prevent the wholesale destruction of the big houses in Spital Square. 
 He failed &mdash; and photographs in the book confirm what a tragedy that was, particularly when the resulting space is still used only as a car-park. 
 Much later he joined forces with the fledgling Spitalfields Trust, and their efforts have ensured that since 1961 only two more Georgian houses have been destroyed, and those in flagrant defiance of the law. 
 Blain's very personal History of the Spitalfields Trust is as gripping as an adventure yarn. 
 The other big piece in the book by one of the area's longtime residents, Raphael Samuel, is both a social history of one of the most fascinatingly mixed areas of London and a passionate polemic against the fruit-market being forced to leave. 
 He may well be right that what he calls &bquo;the Holbornisation&equo; of the area will suck the life out of Spitalfields after all. 
 But both the Trust and those of us lucky enough to live there will do our damnedest to prevent it. 
 Ballet. 
 Adam Sweeting (Rock Critic) on The Prince Of The Pagodas 
 TAKE a chunk of Sleeping Beauty, stir in a bit of King Lear, and season with flavours from the mysterious East. 
 That would give you the bare bones of The Prince of the Pagodas, but not much idea of the richness of Benjamin Britten's score which, paradoxically, has proved a stumbling block in the work's history. 
 It's as if it's too powerful for choreographers to cope with. 
 Does Kenneth MacMillan's new version work? 
 The night I went the original leads, Darcey Bussell (Princess Rose) and Jonathon Cope (her Prince), had already been rotated out of the cast in favour of Viviana Durante and Stuart Cassidy. 
 Cassidy, I thought, was rather more interesting in his nightmarish salamander-prince incarnation, where he writhed around the stage in scaly green tights. 
 Ms Durante was suitably serene of line and firm of resolve, as she underwent an hallucinogenic rite de passage featuring dancing castles and badly-behaved kings. 
 I was particularly amused by Anthony Dowell's cameo as the doddering Emperor, complete with gilded wheelchair. 
 The music remains dependable. 
 There were edgy, mocking passages of woodwind, impressionistic sections led by flute and harp, clattery percussive interpolations, and concluding all's-well-that-ends-well music which must be as close to a waltz as Britten ever came. 
 . correction for main arts page piece 
 Comedy Theatre.. 
 By David Adams Buffalo, Lil and the Indians. 
 FIRST seen at the King's Head six years ago, Sheridan Morley's elegant and civilised entertainment Noel and Gertie now turns up at the Comedy in much revised form. 
 Gone is Mr Morley as presiding anchorman and the device of splitting the evening between actors and singers: instead we have Simon Cadell and Patricia Hodge evoking the platonic passion of Noel Coward and Gertrude Lawrence and giving us generous helpings of songs and scenes from the shows. 
 Considering that Coward and Lawrence only ever appeared together twice in adult life, in Private Lives and Tonight at 8.30, Mr Morley manages to make a little go a long way. 
 But he convinces one that, from their early days of teenage touring in Hauptmann's Hannele, they shared a mutual devotion to each other, an indefinable star quality and a passion for the strange, hermetic world of theatre. 
 Today we expect our stars to have social consciences and wide-ranging opinions. 
 Coward and Lawrence (though he was obviously the brighter, better-read and more inquisitive of the two) belong to an all-but vanished world in which celebrity, success and acclaim were seen as a means of validating one's existence. 
 Bringing past legends to life is not that easy but Simon Cadell is astonishingly successful as Coward. 
 He offers not so much an impersonation as an impression of the man. 
 But he offers a brilliant rendering of Don't Put Your Daughter On The Stage, Mrs Worthington rising to heights of boiling, brick-red rage on &bquo;She's a vile girl and uglier than mortal sin.&equo; 
 He is mercurially skittish as the bell-bottomed tar in Red Peppers executing jaunty scissor-like leaps. 
 And in a scene from Blithe Spirit he adopts a look of frozen outrage that renders a simple line like &bquo;A woman in Cynthia Cheviot's position would hardly wear false pearls&equo; inexplicably funny. 
 Yet underneath it all he suggests there was in Coward a gregarious solitude (&bquo;I am no good at love,&equo; he poignantly records) that slightly undercuts the show's thesis that he carried a lifelong torch for Ms Lawrence. 
 Gertrude Lawrence's magic is harder to resurrect. 
 Contemporary records suggest she possessed neither classic beauty nor a great voice: simply the built-in spotlight of the incandescent star. 
 She must also have been quite a handful judging by Coward's ironic telegram to a Broadway manager requesting 58 per cent of the gross for the task of restraining her from being &bquo;Grock, Beatrice Lillie, Theda Bara, Mary Pickford and Bert Lahr all at once.&equo; 
 Patricia Hodge does not quite evoke the mixture of clown and vamp that list suggests. 
 Her forte is a cool restraint and ladylike sexiness. 
 But she is excellent in the play-extracts, lending Amanda in Private Lives just the right touch of acid mockery and hinting at a whole world of repressed longing as the suburban wife in Still Life (the embryonic version of Brief Encounter). 
 I doubt that she is much like the real Gertrude Lawrence but she is decidedly a class act. 
 Alan Strachan as director knits the whole show together neatly and Jonathan Cohen on piano is a suitably reticent accompanist. 
 It makes for a pleasant evening that reminds us once again of the slimline precision of Coward's comic dialogue and his habit of rendering heterosexual love in terms of recriminatory bickering. 
 Abergavenny. 
 Buffalo, Lil and the Indians. 
 By David Adams 
 MASQUERADE Theatre is a Christmas institution in Wales: a company that works in both English and Welsh, it specialises in an area of theatre that appeals directly to young people. 
 This must be remembered when watching a show like Buffalo, Lil and the Indians which, for all its manifest weaknesses, utterly engaged the audience at Pen-y-Pound Drama Centre in Abergavenny. 
 The rather tacky set, the lucklustre performances, the script from David Straun and Heather Williams that lurches from trite audience participation to over-the-head jokes (would any primary-school child get the one about water privatisation?), all didn't seem to matter as the company of four scampered around with their well-intentioned tale of how the white man destroyed the American Indians. 
 The kids loved the chants and the masks and puppets-usually Masquerade's strength, although here even these lacked the usual imagination-but really it could all have been so much better in almost every respect. 
 It stretched neither the company nor the audience. 
 That small-scale community touring doesn't have to look cheap or lack high-energy skills is evidenced by Theatr West Glamorgan, whose Vanessa is a marvellous display of ensemble performance, sparkling entertainment, political sophistication, sharp direction and smart comedy-even to a non-Welsh speaker. 
 Llanover Hall in Cardiff was as packed as most venues the company play and the enthusiastic applause must become almost tedious to the team. 
 Vanessa looks at the familiar mucky mix of local political wheeler-dealing and multinational corruption with a Welsh village finding that embracing the entente cordiale fools them into having their lake turned into a French chemical waste dump. 
 Their handling of socially relevant themes, with easy solutions shunned, is a lesson to others. 
 The Christmas show exclusively for adults is Cardiff Comedy Explosion's nightly cabaret in the Sherman Arena. 
 Again the fab four take on audience suggestions for a totally impromptu couple of hours. 
 A feature of their new show is a hilarious This Is Your Life, where they ad-lib a potted biography of a victim in the audience to a few hints given by the subject's so-called friends, and the Christmas Story enacted in a series of styles chosen by those there on the night-Joseph and Mary as a double glazing sales force, for example, sounds tasteless but it's all surprisingly inoffensive and very funny. 
 The band that felt it was time to go Rock/Pop. 
 By Robin Denselow FELT: Me And A Monkey On The Moon (EL Acme24). 
 MATHILDE SANTING: Breast And Brown (Megadisc MDC7890). 
 THE ROCHES: Speak (MCA MCG6071). 
 THE HOOTERS: Zigzag (CBS 465084). 
 KAOMA AND OTHERS: Lambada (CBS 466055). 
 MARGARETH MENEZES AND OTHERS: Lambada Brazil (Polydor 841580). 
 O SAMBA: Brazil Classics II, compiled by David Byrne (WEA 926019). 
 LITTLE RICHARD: The Speciality Sessions (Ace AboxCD1). 
 IT SEEMS appropriate to end the Eighties with the band that decided that this decade was quite enough. 
 Felt started out 10 years ago and recorded 10 albums before breaking up this week after a final show in their home town, Birmingham, thus concluding the curious master-plan that was apparently drawn up early in their career by the band's singer and song-writer, who is known simply as Lawrence. 
 Before departing, they recorded a final album that, in their typically quirky style, proves to be their best since the early days of Crumbling The Antiseptic Beauty, even if there are moments when Lawrence comes close to outclassing Morrissey in the annals of wimp rock. 
 He specialises in songs of self-pity and gloom, with stories of betrayal or parting enlivened a little by an autobiographical track like Mobile Shack, with its story of escape from Birmingham thanks to the arrival of New Wave. 
 What makes them interesting is the interplay between depressed singer and band that is capable of creating subtle guitar and synth textures, providing languid settings for a piece like Free, then pushing into country, or a blues riff (on Get Out Of My Mirror), and proves that it can really stretch out when given a chance, as at the end of New Day Dawning. 
 It is exactly the same tension that made The Smiths a success, and in their low-key way I suspect that Felt will keep some of the same cult appeal now they are gone. 
 A band like that survived because of the existence of indie labels that kept going in the Eighties even though many of their major acts like The Smiths, and now The Fall and Blue Aeroplanes, deserted them for the majors. 
 The indies also have a role in picking up those that once recorded for a major label, like the Dutch singer, Mathilde Santing. 
 She is the missing link between the European ballad and torch-song tradition and Anglo-American white soul, and she chooses her material bravely. 
 This selection covers everything from John Cale, Todd Rundgren and Roddy Frame to echoes of Brecht/Weill and Richard Rodgers, with a Philip Larkin poem added in along the way, and it works because of the versatility of her gentle but dramatic singing, and the elegant but sparse settings by the producer and pianist, Mimi Izumi Koyabashi. 
 She uses a touch of eastern exotica and a string quartet for the breathy, sensual, and intimate treatment of Frame's We Could Send Letters, and what sounds like an oriental aquatic effect on Harry Nilsson's witty Think About Your Troubles, but most songs rely solely and triumphantly on piano and voice. 
 From the majors, and the American market, there is more classy female minimalism from The Roches, the trio of New York sisters who started out in the folk scene and evolved a style that veers between thinking woman's pop and close-harmony experimentation. 
 Their new songs range from the rhythmic and tuneful Big Nuthin', with its gently cynical catalogue of the anticlimaxes of life, to an unaccompanied half-spoken, half-sung piece, The Anti-sex Backlash Of The Eighties, dealing wittily and angrily with sexual politics. 
 These ladies deserve careful listening, but there are patches, as on Nocturne, where the music is far less interesting than the well-written and atmospheric lyrics. 
 From the good-time side of the folky American market there is another solid set from The Hooters, one of those bands that would sound ideal in any bar-room, can be guaranteed work on any night of the year, but find it hard getting into the best-sellers. 
 They play the standard all-American folk-rock-country fusion, with the guitars dressed up with a dash of accordion, harmonica and brass, and they write good, solid songs that are tuneful, stirring, but never wildly original. 
 They are at their best when they take chances, throwing a dash of reggae and a muted heavy-metal riff into Don't Knock Till You Try It, and when they re-work an old folk standard, 500 Miles, which is now dressed up with a reggae beat, lap-steel guitar, and harmonica, new lyrics about Tiananmen Square, and the dreaded Peter, Paul And Mary still joining in. 
 Over in the dance and the world-music scenes, the fashion is for all things Brazilian. 
 Great local artists like Gilberto Gil have been trying for years to promote their country's music, but (as with the African-music boom) it has taken the combination of an enthusiastic American super-star and cosmopolitan French audiences to really make the change. 
 Brazil has been boosted both by David Byrne, whose new Latin big band made such an impression here last week, and the dance hit, Lambada, by Kaoma, which sold over a million and a half copies in France and became the best-selling European single of the year. 
 Between them, these two events introduced a vast new audience to the wildly sensual new Brazilian dance called the lambada, and the songs that go with it. 
 Brazilian music can usually be found only on specialist world-music labels, but suddenly there are three compilation albums released by the majors. 
 The best, Polydor's Lambada Brazil, consists almost exclusively of Brazilian, not French, lambada stars and includes a couple of tracks by the wonderful Margareth Menezes, who has been making such an impact performing with Byrne. 
 Her Alegria Da Cidade is light, urgent, funky, and brassy, while other tracks show how Caribbean styles have been mixed into the Brazilian melting pot. 
 This shows in the songs of exuberant performers like Luiz Caldez and Elba Ramelho, and there is a hint of reggae in the track by the now veteran Caetano Veloso. 
 The CBS compilation, which includes the massive Kaoma hit, includes more French lambada, with its throw-away echoes of European disco. 
 David Byrne's new compilation, O Samba, on WEA, is concerned with the earlier dance style, the samba, and comes complete with excellent sleeve-notes, glossary, and translation of the songs, which start with the late Clara Nunes's gently rousing, elegant treatment of a Yoruba legend from West Africa. 
 Byrne is a fan who has done his homework. 
 Finally, for rich veteran rockers who want a late Christmas present, there is a massive six-CD boxed set of Little Richard recordings from the mid-Fifties and concerts from the mid-Sixties. 
 Glorious stuff, of course, but one for those whose devotion verges on fanaticism, and are really ready for four studio takes of Ready Teddy and six versions of Good Golly Miss Molly. 
 Betty Caplan on the blossoming of an experimental theatre group Magdalena takes root. 
 THE MAGDALENA International Women's Experimental Theatre Project has just turned three. 
 Its birthday &mdash; its very existence &mdash; is being celebrated in a new book by Susan Basnett. 
 As is the way with most infants, its future is fraught with possibility and uncertainty. 
 Born in 1986 in Cardiff, it has spread across Europe and to North and South America and, as the author says in her introduction, &bquo;has also shifted focus from experimental theatre in the first instance to all forms of theatre in which women are involved&equo;. 
 The original Cardiff festival in 1986 combined experimental improvisational work with an attempt to &bquo;show&equo; the kind of work being done &mdash; something criticised by some as irrelevant and impossible to achieve in just two weeks. 
 Even more important, perhaps, were the discussions about the notion of a women's aesthetic: again and again, the attempt to articulate the new and unspoken came up against the absence of an appropriate language. 
 In her manifesto, prime mover Jill Greenhalgh wrote: &bquo;There's something new and vital and female that is lying latent and untapped, trapped under thousands of years of patriarchal art, and you just can't quite grasp it.&equo; 
 Fortunately this did not stop the women from trying, and Basnett, senior lecturer in Comparative Literature at the University of Warwick, describes in some detail the individual practitioners who set about the task. 
 Fifteen countries were represented by 30 women, each of whom had been invited on the basis of her contribution to theatre in her own country. 
 Their areas of expertise encompassed a wide range: Sandra Salmaso and Cinzia Mascherin from Italy devised a piece called No Man's Land, described by Mascherin as &bquo;an empty space, without border, beyond quiet&equo;, based on work done with objects. 
 Recreating women and voice work were other options, addressing questions of women's voicelessness and silence. 
 The issue of woman as victim as opposed to woman as survivor was tackled head on by Polish director Zofia Kalinska whose work showing women as bearers of demonic energy culminated in the formation of the Magic Circle, which went on in 1988 to tour a collectively devised piece called Nominate Filiae. 
 The second part of the festival, which resulted in the final performance, raised vital questions about the way women relate to one another when they are free to make real choices. 
 The kind of arguments that have challenged the women's movement over 20 years had to be confronted in a practical manner: were the existing hierarchies justifiable? 
 Should women technicians once again be relegated to a lower rung of the ladder? 
 Why were women of colour excluded? 
 What was the proper role of the director in a truly egalitarian company of women? 
 Many of these problems were taken up again in September 1987 when Magna was established on a permanent basis in Cardiff during a three-day conference on A Women's Language in Theatre? 
 A follow-up meeting in December of that year acted upon suggestions made at the earlier gathering, and aimed to &bquo;set up opportunities for women to explore new approaches to theatre-making that more profoundly reflect their own experience rather than that of men&equo;. 
 Since then, the work has continued to proliferate. 
 Basnett looks forward optimistically to the future which includes a meeting in Colombia planned for 1992. 
 And if some of the material in the book seems occasionally to verge on the utopian, it is worth reminding ourselves that, as Jan Montefiore says in Feminism and Poetry, &bquo;the value of utopias is that they enable us to imagine possibilities of difference for the brute contingent world&equo;. 
 Magdalena, compiled and introduced by Susan Basnett, is published by Berg at &pound;12.95. 
 PAGE wom 
 Lights, action, read &bquo;em! 
 Critic's choice Cinema.. 
 By Derek Malcolm 
 THOSE SEARCHING around feebly to find things to give film buffs for Christmas ought to consider a few of the classic books on directors, stars, studios and the movies themselves. 
 These are not necessarily new, but they are among the best published in recent years. 
 An interest in the early days &mdash; the silent cinema, in fact &mdash; would be well served by Kevin Brownlow's The Parade's Gone By&hellip; 
 It is now out in paperback (WHAllen) and deserves the accolade of being both the easiest to read and the most informative book about the Hollywood of the 1920s, written by a real enthusiast. 
 Another enthusiast &mdash; sometimes rather more controversial in his opinions &mdash; is David Shipman, whose two volumes on The Great Movie Stars, divided into The Golden Years and The International Years, are also now out in paperback from Macdonald. 
 There is endless browsing to be had here and you don't have to agree with everything Shipman says to enjoy the experience. 
 Shipman's two-volume Story of the Cinema (Hodder and Stoughton) is also a very good read &mdash; the first volume goes up to Gone With The Wind and the second starts with Citizen Kane and reaches more or less the present day. 
 But here I find the opinions often less easy to take, though the wide scholarship and enthusiasm involved in the books is not in question. 
 Unfortunately, a good many books about the cinema published today are pretty inaccurate and fairly useless, but two which are not are The British Film Institute's Companion to the Western, edited by Ed Buscombe (Andre Deutsch) and Alain Silver; and Elizabeth Ward's Film Noir (Bloomsbury). 
 The Western book would be a magnificent present for anyone who likes the genre because it is not only a comprehensive guide to the films and film-makers, but also to the cultural background. 
 The Film Noir book is equally encyclopaedic as a reference work, and its opinions are sensitive, sensible and totally without those daft claims which even films as good as White Heat and The Woman in the Window can't really sustain. 
 Finally, there's Joel Finler's remarkable The Hollywood Story (Pyramid) which purports to tell you &bquo;everything you always wanted to know about the American movie business but didn't know where to look&equo;. 
 The work involved in writing this summation must have been back-breaking, and certainly took years of research. 
 And the result is endlessly fascinating for dippers, with the kind of information included you simply can't find anywhere else. 
 Best films around London include Greenaway's The Cook the Thief His Wife and Her Lover, Soderburgh's sex, lies and videotape, Kieslowski's Short Film About a Killing, Branagh's Henry V, Lehmann's Heathers, Tavernier's Life and Nothing But and Peter Weir's Dead Poets Society. 
 Robin Williams, Dead Poets Society: see Critic's choice Virginia Mayo and James Cagney in Raoul Walsh's classic 1949 production of White Heat&hellip; even movies as good as this can't live up to the praise lavished on them by some film reference books: see Critic's choice Hear no equal, see no equal&hellip; 
 Kenneth Branagh, Paul Scofield and Emma Thompson in a scene from Branagh's production of Henry V: see Critic's choice Face at the window&hellip; 
 Sabine Azema in Bertrand Tavernier's Life and Nothing But: see Critic's choice 
 Birdies, butchers and fools They called Forman a Zionist and Menzel a pornographer &mdash; Moscow's stooges had no time for the Czech New Wave. 
 Now the banned films are back on the screens and the film-makers are on the streets. 
 Can they pick up the pieces? 
 Derek Malcolm reports from Czechoslovakia. 
 WE WERE in Prague and then Bratislava for British Film Week, organised months ago by the British Council, but now thrust inadvertently into the middle of a political, social and cultural revolution. 
 The first film was, appropriately enough, Cry Freedom. 
 And Sir Richard Attenborough was there to tell his audience that he felt as if he had come not just to the centre of Europe but of the world. 
 It was scarcely an ideal time for such an event, except that this revolution has been led by an artist and by students, and the Czechs, unlike the British, treat their writers, playwrights, film-makers and students with high seriousness. 
 If they didn't interfere in politics, they would be thought craven. 
 Besides, Sir Richard had made Gandhi, the film about a non-violent revolutionary not totally unlike their own Vaclev Havel. 
 This was the bond which gave him a warm and interested reception. 
 What he and we were curious about in turn was the present and future fate of the Czech rather than the British cinema. 
 No one who went to foreign language movies in the late Sixties will easily forget the extraordinary films that seemed to pour out of the state-owned studios of Czechoslavakia. 
 The Czech New Wave, exemplified by such popular classics as Jiri Menzel's Closely Observed Trains and Milos Forman's Firemen's Ball, and by other directors like Jan Nemec, Evald Schorm, Ivan Passer, Vera Chytilova, Jan Kadar and Jaromil Jires, conquered hearts as well as minds. 
 The movement was called &bquo;liberal bourgeois&equo; by some Marxist film-makers of non-Communist Europe (including Bertolucci), and accused of Titoism, cosmopolitanism, formalism and even &bquo;influencialism&equo; by the shocked bureaucrats of its own country. 
 It was told that it consistently ridiculed ordinary people. 
 But it was its political and artistic daring, enhanced by the most attractively human of values, that the rest of us so admired &mdash; &bquo;those little films&equo;, someone very accurately said, &bquo;which are, as if by accident, important.&equo; 
 And it was all financed by the very regime it surreptitiously criticised. 
 The movement ended abruptly when the Russian tanks rolled in and Dubcek fell. 
 In the spring of 1970, eight finished films were banned and 12 that were being shot were stopped. 
 Menzel was called a pornographer, Forman a Zionist and, later, to celebrate the first anniversary of the invasion, a book was published by a Stalinist hack called They Did Not Pass. 
 In it was a photograph of long-haired youths, some with cameras, giving the V-sign to the Russian tanks trying to disperse them with water cannon. 
 The caption read: &bquo;The sign the young provocateurs agreed upon &mdash; in two minutes we shall start the attack.&equo; 
 The history of the Czech cinema since then reads like a frequently funny if terrible farce, mirroring that of the country as a whole. 
 SHORTLY after the Russians invaded, the famous Barrandov Studios, in which so many world-class directors had worked, were to be used for the making of a film called Factory Of Illusions, in which a young and idealistic graduate of the Film Academy arrives to find well-known film-makers of the New Wave drinking and whoring instead of making films, and almost succumbs to counter-revolution himself. 
 Meanwhile, a famous singer, much loved in the film world, who had kissed Dubcek, found a paste-up photograph of her and the former leader circulating around Prague. 
 The couple were naked and making love. 
 She started a court action which virtually proved what everybody knew already &mdash; that the picture was faked and distributed by &bquo;state authorities&equo;, whereupon the case was adjourned indefinitely. 
 Such palpable absurdities have continued for some 20 years, despite the partial and cautious liberalisation of the past three or four. 
 In the late Seventies I interviewed Jiri Menzel, finally allowed out of the country of his birth after years of neglect, at the National Film Theatre. 
 I asked him through his interpreter whether he could now make the films he wanted again. 
 The answer was a warning kick under the table. 
 The interpreter, as I should have known, was his police minder. 
 Early this year, the Jakes government collected together the eight films banned outright in 1970, including Menzel's Skylarks On A String. 
 They had them sub-titled in order to be sold abroad for possible profit. 
 But they were not deemed fit for home consumption. 
 Now, as abruptly as the New Wave was blotted out, even from the official histories of the Czech cinema, everything has changed again. 
 The Berlin Festival in February will show Skylarks On A String and other once proscribed films, and Gilles Jacob of the Cannes Festival has asked Juraj Jakubisko, the best-known Slovak director, to put a newly shot ending on to his banned Birdies, Orphans And Fools. 
 But the question is &mdash; can the charm, humanity and audacity of the former New Wave be recreated in Czechoslovakia? 
 No, says Dusan Trancik, the Slovakian maker of seven features who has frequently got into trouble with the authorities. 
 That experiment cannot be repeated. 
 But there is still enough talent available, including that of Menzel and Forman (who is apparently returning from Hollywood to make another film at the Barrandov Studios) to push the Czech cinema into the limelight again. 
 THE first 10 years after Dubcek's fall were terrible for everyone,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;But once the authorities had clamped down, it was not a case of political Stalinism so much as bureaucratic perfidy and complete lack of imagination. 
 &bquo;For instance, the man who, up to a short time ago, was chosen to select films from the West for showing in Slovakia, and to attend festivals like Cannes and Venice, was a butcher by trade. 
 He knew nothing, and he cared very little about film. 
 &bquo;Yes, I know Antonin Dvorak was also a butcher. 
 But this one was different. 
 He was just a fool. 
 And if you have an industry run by cautious fools, it is almost worse than more obvious political censorship. 
 &bquo;Those in charge of distribution here used to get hold of prints of movies like Rambo and Ghostbusters and invite their friends round to see them. 
 After which they would inveigh against them as decadent while ordering more of the same for their next well-attended private screenings. 
 It was total hypocrisy, and everyone was affected by it. 
 &bquo;When you get louts like this advising you on your scripts and your films, you live in a state of complete frustration rather than actual fear. 
 &bquo;For instance, when you asked the official you met to find you some film-makers to talk to, he rung me up and spoke to me for the first time for years. 
 He knows now his job is on the line and he's very nervous.&equo; 
 Milan Tomsa, the student strike leader at the Prague Film School, is not at the moment much concerned about the future prospects of the Czech cinema. 
 &bquo;We can't think about the future now,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;We're too concerned about the present. 
 We have to be out on the streets documenting the revolution and helping to forge our new democracy. 
 You have seen the difference in Czech television in just two weeks. 
 We have to keep that difference going. 
 &bquo;Twenty years ago, when the crackdown came, our film-makers got much verbal encouragement from the West but no real support at all. 
 They felt very alone &mdash; my father tells me that. 
 Now we want real help. 
 We haven't got enough equipment to do what we should. 
 &bquo;That's how the West can do something for us. 
 We need the base material &mdash; cameras, video equipment, everything. 
 If you really want to aid us this time round, tell everyone that. 
 Send the equipment to your embassy in Prague and they will get in touch with us. 
 We don't want to be left to fight alone again.&equo; 
 WATCHING the crowds in Wenceslaus Square avidly reading the notices in every shop window about the progress of the revolution, it seemed inconceivable that the hard-liners could ever return. 
 But some of the film-makers we met are not so sure. 
 One of them said: &bquo;When the Communists took over after the war, some of the Fascists became the best Stalinists of all. 
 It will be the same now &mdash; everyone says they were either forced to join the Party, or were never members. 
 There are thousands of informers proclaiming a new devotion to Vaclev Havel. 
 We're in for a very difficult time and we must be prepared for it. 
 &bquo;What we have to admit is that the system we are now overthrowing did give us something. 
 The socialist state nationalised film and gave film-makers much better potential opportunities. 
 As employees of the studios, we had a permanent salary and nobody was as concerned about box-office potential as in the West. 
 Graduates of the Film Academy had a direct route towards a career. 
 &bquo;What the State expected in return was some sort of obedience and a loyalty which often ran directly counter to the truth. 
 If you offended, you could work your way back, as Jiri Menzel had to. 
 Yet in the end there was this awful conformity, of style as well as content. 
 In the world of socialist realism, surrealism is almost as terrible as espionage. 
 &bquo;That's what we hated and in the end we found it intolerable. 
 We're fed up with telling lies on the screen. 
 We would rather have no help at all than continue to do that.&equo; 
 Financed by the regime it surreptitiously criticised&hellip; 
 Jiri Menzel's Closely Observed Trains conquered hearts as well as headsPHOTOGRAPHS: JOHN CARTWRIGHT 
 Obituary: Rene Tavernier. 
 Human rights for writers:. 
 RENE Tavernier was a poet, writer, critic, resistance fighter, and father of the film maker Bertrand. 
 But my recollection of him will be as a friend and food expert. 
 He introduced me to good restaurants in Paris, good food in Lugano, and good wines in New York. 
 Most of all, he was a campaigner for human rights for writers all over the world. 
 His capacity to persuade people to pay attention to the plight of the less fortunate was constant. 
 At times it drove his audience to anger and boredom, but he got what he wanted. 
 Tavernier, born in Paris and schooled in Lyon, was introduced to literary interests early in his school life. 
 He published his first volume of poetry, De vous la merveille &mdash; the title borrowed from Malherbe &mdash; in 1937. 
 A second volume, Sens de la Solitude, followed a year later. 
 During the second world war he played an active role in the opposition to the German occupation, eventually joining the Resistance, and creating the magazine Confluence, which was rapidly banned, and became an early edition of French samizdat. 
 It was wound up in 1950, as Europe moved on to other things. 
 His Questions au soleil levant received the Grand Prix de Poesie de l'Academie Francaise, but although it awarded him medals, the Academy never granted him the membership that was his life's ambition. 
 Rene Tavernier's life was peppered with great occasions not just in PEN or in his election as international President. 
 He was elected president of French PEN in 1979 and immediately set about organising the world congress in Lyon. 
 Such names as Ba Jin, Susan Sonntag, Mario Vargas Llosa and many others were in Lyon in 1981. 
 And Rene was there to organise everything, including my joint press conference with John Peet, the Reuters man who &bquo;defected&equo; to East Berlin in 1950. 
 In Lyon, Rene celebrated the return to his city, and the victory of the Resistance with a grand PEN congress and an expert's appreciation of the restaurants. 
 It is that memory of him that will stay with many English and Scottish writers, and for which my wife and I will always be grateful. 
 He never did make it to the Academie, but being made international president of PEN, following Francis King, mattered a lot to him. 
 (By then he was already very ill: he called it ulcers, but it was cancer.) 
 He had narrowly beaten the Nigerian novelist, Chinua Achebe in May 1989 at the historic congress in Maastrich when the Soviet Union rejoined the writers' international organization after opposing PEN for nearly seventy years, and the way was opened for the Czechs and Slovaks to rejoin. 
 A great time, enjoyed in spite of his illness. 
 Andrew Graham-Yooll Rene Tavernier, born Paris, April 21, 1915; died November 30, 1989. 
 Barnum in the big top Critics' choice Theatre.. 
 By Robin Thornber in Manchester 
 ONLY ONE show opens in London immediately after Christmas &mdash; the American musical, Barnum, begins a three-week season in a big top on Shepherd's Bush Green on December 27. 
 Former Blue Peter presenter, Peter Duncan, treads the high wire. 
 Let me offer a few seasonal recommendations. 
 For the whole family: A Midsummer Night's Dream (Barbican). 
 The most festive show in town. 
 Down in the forest everything stirs, especially Richard McCabe's sinister Puck and David Troughton's outsize Bottom. 
 Whale (Lyttelton). 
 David Holman's ecological thriller with Emil Wolk as an airborne, interventionist raven. 
 The Shaughran (Olivier). 
 Welcome return of Boucicault's romantic melodrama. 
 Cinderella (Theatre Royal, Stratford East). 
 With pantomime a dwindling art-form (dominated by superannuated sportsmen and holidaying soap-stars), David Cregan and Philip Hedley usually nod towards traditional story-telling. 
 A Christmas Carol (Young Vic). 
 David Holman strikes again with a faithful Dickens adaptation; recommended by our own Richard Bates. 
 For mid-teens and upwards: Buddy (Victoria Palace). 
 Exhilarating tribute to the great Buddy Holly. 
 Highlight is Gareth Marks as the Big Bopper singing Chantilly Lace. 
 Mainly for adults: The Liar (Old Vic). 
 Jonathan Miller's delightful production of rare Corneille comedy. 
 Alex Jennings as the compulsive fantasist. 
 Jeffrey Bernard is Unwell (Apollo). 
 Peter O'Toole's happiest hour as the Soho scribe looking back on a mis-spent life. 
 Miss Saigon (Drury Lane). 
 A good musical about a serious subject &mdash; the emotional consequences of the chaotic American exodus from Vietnam. 
 Strong production by Nicholas Hytner. 
 The Cherry Orchard (Aldwych). 
 Unusually buoyant rendering of Chekhov by Sam Mendes. 
 Judi Dench a memorably flirty Ranevskaya. 
 Ma Rainey's Black Bottom (Cottesloe). 
 August Wilson's gutsy play on exploitation and oppression. 
 Fine work by Hugh Quarshie and Clarke Peters. 
 By Robin Thornber in Manchester 
 THE LAST production in Leeds Playhouse's &bquo;temporary&equo; home &mdash; a converted sports hall for the last 19 years &mdash; opens tonight. 
 John Harrison directs Twelfth Night, his 24th Shakespeare in 18 years at the theatre. 
 In March, the company moves to West Yorkshire Playhouse, where Harrison will direct two more shows before handing over to administrator Will Weston and director Jude Kelly. 
 Alexandra Mathie plays Viola and Saskia Downes is Olivia. 
 Simon Higlett designs. 
 Manchester Royal Exchange has Una Stubbs in Oliver Goldsmith's She Stoops to Conquer, directed by James Maxwell, also opening tonight. 
 Sheffield Crucible has Kenneth Grahame's The Wind in the Willows, directed by Paul Whitworth, in the studio from tomorrow and York Theatre Royal opens Aladdin and Liverpool Empire, Cinderella. 
 Recommended as best of the classy kids' shows: The Red Balloon, Albert Lamorisse's Fifties French fable of a small boy and his big red friend, adapted and stylishly staged by Anthony Clark at Contact Theatre in Manchester for primary school age. 
 Best riot for teenagers: John Doyle's Sixties nostalgia version of The Sleeping Beauty, with arm-waving singalong and fast-forward time-travelling, at the Liverpool Everyman. 
 Agnew's Salute to Turner exhibition ends on Thursday evening and not Friday as stated in yesterday's Guardian. 
 Bids are invited in aid of The National Trust for paintings by 50 contemporary artists. 
 Paul Hipp, David Howarth, David Bardsley in Buddy: Choice Things that go bump in the night&hellip; 
 Colin Farrell in A Christmas Carol: see Critics' choice Things that go bang&hellip; 
 Stephen Rea and Michael O'Connor in The Shaughraun: see choice 
 Lust and irony in the alien corn Randy extraterrestrials and delinquent Australians feature as Derek Malcolm reviews the pick of the week's new releases. 
 JULIEN Temple, maker and some say perpetrator of Absolute Beginners, possibly the last ambitious British musical we'll see on the screen, has taken things easier with Earth Girls Are Easy (Prince Charles etc, PG). 
 This is a kind of ironic musical send-up of the life and times of the inhabitants of San Fernando Valley, on the other side of the Santa Monica mountains from Hollywood, and kitsch is quite deliberately its middle name. 
 Tony Garnett produces for Temple in California, and it has to be as far as he has ever got from the Ken Loach films with which he was associated before going to America. 
 The whole operation does not so much aspire to style as do what it pleases with it. 
 It's like a B-movie from a past of happier memories, turned against itself by the one British director who truly understands the mode. 
 Temple has made some of the best music videos that exist. 
 Here, he brings that short-breathed talent to as effective account as he sometimes did in The Great Rock &bquo;n Role Swindle, his first film. 
 The story is simple, not to say simple-minded. 
 A group of aliens from outer space crashland in a private swimming pool. 
 What they find on earth is more unearthly than they are. 
 And Jeff Goldblum, the spaceship driver, falls in love with Geena Davis, whose pool it is. 
 Thus are the stars of Cronenberg's The Fly reunited in dramatically different circumstances. 
 The film's musical score and song and dance numbers are surprisingly its weakest ingredient, though the shooting and editing of Earth Girls Are Easy is often highly original-especially the black and white dream sequence that's a model of its kind and almost a music video in itself. 
 Slaphappy and occasionally slapdash as the film sometimes seems at its more louche moments, as a dramatic entity its energy, irony and visual wit make one forgive almost all. 
 Contrary to persistent rumour, Kylie Minogue's first film, The Delinquents (Warner West End, 12, from Boxing Day) is not the flaccid cods-up we might have expected. 
 It's too long, too slow and in no way original. 
 But it is carefully made by Chris Thomson, and doesn't destroy the Fifties charm of Criena Rohan's book. 
 She is, incidentally, the aunt of Pat Cash and can write like he can rally. 
 What is more, Kylie herself profits rather than suffers from her not specially glamorous girl-next-door looks and produces an unstudied and effective portrait of a young, underage provincial girl who falls for Charlie Schlatter's equally youthful sailor and gets dubbed a deliquent. 
 Thomson recreates the Australian Fifties with more than a cursory skill and catches the censorious, more petit bourgeois than the English tone of the times well enough to convince. 
 He is aided in this by good actors like Angela Punch McGregor as the girl's mother and Bruno Lawrence (so good in New Zealand's in Smash Palace) as the boy's sea-faring mentor. 
 As for the two principals, they play well if not brilliantly together as the star-crossed lovers. 
 And the fact that the film is not frightened of its sexual aspects but treats them with some taste is another point in its favour. 
 I hope the rather hard 12 certificate won't annoy the teenies too much. 
 No one in his right mind would call the Delinquents a memorable piece of work. 
 It is not, however, in any way discreditable, whatever it lacks in flair and narrative drive. 
 &bquo;Where did you come from?,&equo; asks someone to the Swamp Thing in The Return Of The Swamp Thing (Cannons, Oxford Street and Panton Street, 12). 
 Quick as a flash, the Thing replies: &bquo;The bog.&equo; 
 One would sincerely wish, this being the Yuletide season, that Mr Jim Wynorski's film is equipped with a sense of humour. 
 But by the end of 90 minutes one is a little doubtful. 
 There are, however, clear attempts to make us giggle, like when the Swamp Thing (Dick Durock) conceives a passion for Heather Locklear's leading lady but tells her that he can't give her the love she wants because he's a plant. 
 &bquo;That's okay,&equo; she says, &bquo;I'm a vegetarian.&equo; 
 Well, it just about passes. 
 It is a bit of a labour seeing this daft C movie last thing before Christmas, especially since it is based on the DC Comic series, which was beautifully drawn and imaginatively based on the Beauty and the Beast story. 
 Unwisely, as it turns out, the credits display the real thing, which is at least a dozen times better than this carelessly silly concoction. 
 In it is Louis Jourdan, once fabulous-looking but now not just a shadow of his former self. 
 He looks as if he has had one facelift too many. 
 He plays the evil Dr Arcane, whose daughter loves the Thing, and it is painful to watch so many bad lines falling on untilled soil. 
 Greetings if they are still with us to Len Wein and Berni Wrightson, originators of the comic strip. 
 They were better than this lot will ever know how to be. 
 Kylie Minogue: an effective performance in her film debut 
 Sarah Gristwood finds Julien Temple still in musical mode Why Earth Girls wasn't so easy. 
 THE gap between Absolute Beginners and Earth Girls Are Easy seems to have been rather a long one. 
 Industry shake-ups cursed Earth Girls with a protracted delay between the cutting room and the screen. 
 But much, in any case, must be allowed to a man who is single-handedly fighting against the times. 
 Julien Temple takes musicals seriously &mdash; &bquo;a unique and total form of cinema&equo;. 
 His first feature was The Great Rock And Roll Swindle, the story of the Sex Pistols. 
 Some of his more notable work has been done on music videos, a form he is far from despising. 
 (You shoot for three weeks, he points out, and three weeks later your work is being distributed to an audience larger than any cinema film short of Batman could hope to reach.) 
 He admires the old classic musicals for their spectacle if not their storyline, and says that Vincente Minelli &bquo;had a camera like a hawk after a mouse&equo;. 
 And while he says that he is prepared to go on doing musicals until he has one that really works, he would probably not agree with that picture of himself as fighting against the tide. 
 As he sees it, the crest of the wave is coming right his way. 
 &bquo;The energy and excitement that music videos have caused in a young audience has to be consumated into musical film.&equo; 
 In Absolute Beginners he tried to explore the energy of London in the Fifties. 
 In Earth Girls, it's California in the Eighties. 
 &bquo;Earth Girls,&equo; says Temple, &bquo;is about a culture in which the make-over is a tribal ritual, one which boasts tanning booths you can dance in.&equo; 
 He describes the San Fernando Valley, where the film &bquo;These kids may be forgetting how to read, but visually they are very sophisticated&equo;. 
 is set, as &bquo;a strange Utopia of people who can vote but can't think.&equo; 
 One of the more memorable song titles from his film is I Like Them Big and Stupid. 
 (&bquo;What kind of man does a lot for me? /Superman with a lobotomy.&equo;) 
 But that doesn't mean he's entirely dismissive. 
 &bquo;These kids may be forgetting how to read, but visually they are very sophisticated, which makes a playground for film-makers,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;It is a culture of our times &mdash; and I don't feel happy ignoring it.&equo; 
 His next film is a &bquo;character mystery&equo; &mdash; not a musical &mdash; about Weegee, the famous news photographer of the Depression years, named for his ability to arrive at the scene of a crime with a speed which suggested the use of an ouija board. 
 Casting is still uncertain &mdash; Mickey Rourke has been &bquo;on and off &mdash; and off.&equo; 
 But shooting should begin during the spring in New York. 
 In one way Weegee is the film Temple has wanted to do for years. 
 &bquo;I first saw his pictures during the punk period and they seemed to have a similar punch, a thriller realism.&equo; 
 In another, it's a temporary aberration, the straight film he needs to do just to prove he can. 
 He is currently finishing the script for Big Bad Apple, to be set in New York during the late 1990s. 
 Oh yes &mdash; it's a musical. 
 Temple is not deterred by the fact that Earth Girls did what he describes as &bquo;not terribly&equo; at the box office in the States. 
 &bquo;The secret to making musicals,&equo; he says, &bquo;is to keep the costs down.&equo; 
 Presumably, it is a truth he came to realise with the experience of Absolute Beginners behind him. 
 &bquo;If you can make a film that makes its money back, you can justify making another.&equo; 
 The toons are taking over the show Bob Swain on animation after the Roger Rabbit revolution. 
 IF YOU thought Max Headroom was just some crazy dream, think again. 
 There are people out there who really do see him as the pioneer of a computer-generated escape from reality. 
 By the end of the nineties, we could be set for the first Oscars awarded to synthetic actors. 
 Although Mr Headroom was actually flesh and blood posing as the unreal thing, there are plenty of computer animation specialists who think he had the right idea. 
 The trick now is to remove the human element altogether and let artificial intelligence take care of the rest. 
 Pioneering work a few years ago by Keith Waters at Middlesex Polytechnic experimented with a computer-generated version of Spitting Image. 
 The advances in synthesising realistic facial expressions were highly impressive. 
 At about the same time, Nadia Thalmann began work on a new project at the University of Geneva, animating synthetic actors using artificial intelligence and robotics. 
 A short film called Galaxy Sweetheart, starring a synthesised Marilyn Monroe, demonstrates that the theory is well on its way to being proved. 
 The possibilities opened up by such work are unlimited. 
 But whether artificial intelligence turns out to be good enough for the movie makers is likely to be another matter. 
 The history of computer graphics in film production has not been the smoothest. 
 Over-confidence in the early days has led to a surfeit of caution ever since. 
 The first major attempt to use computer animation in a feature film was largely down to the novelty of the medium itself. 
 Tron was released in 1982, using computer animation to rescue a poor script. 
 As the setting was inside a series of computer games, there was no real requirement to go beyond the &bquo;computer look.&equo; 
 Realism wasn't really on the agenda for the time being. 
 At about the same time, the computer graphics lab at the New York Institute of Technology was working on what it ambitiously claimed would ultimately be the first full-length computer-generated feature, The Works. 
 The new three-dimensional worlds and creatures were truly mind-shattering. 
 But like Tron, it could go no further than creating a transparently synthetic world. 
 Appetites were whetted among those working on the Tron project and a host of computer animation specialists sprang up in California looking for a piece of the Hollywood action. 
 The most ambitious of tham was Digital Productions, installing a mighty Cray XMP supercomputer to take care of the number crunching. 
 About 20 minutes' worth of space-age special effects were created for the 1984 movie The Last Starfighter. 
 Whereas the Star Wars films had already hit the mark with computer-controlled model shots of space ships, DP took things a stage further by building the entire star fleet in the Cray's memory. 
 Scenes using the ships were then animated and shot at high resolution on to 35mm film. 
 Although the film was finished, the cost finally pulled Digital Productions under &mdash; together with other Hollywood hopefuls &mdash; in the big US computer animation crash of 1986. 
 The approach has generally been both more realistic and more viable since those days. 
 The current crop of releases includes two movies that demonstrate the reality today of computer graphics in film, making significant but very different uses of the technology. 
 The Abyss builds on the heritage of computer special effects, while Oliver and Company offers a showcase for the latest technical additions to the classic Disney school of animation. 
 Industrial Light and Magic's construction of a realistic creature made of water in The Abyss is the kind of job the &bquo;synthetic reality&equo; wing of the computer animation business has been waiting for. 
 Unlike all those old spaceships, there is no way you could have done this without using advanced computer graphics. 
 Not only is the creature convincingly modelled and animated, but ray tracing and lighting effects are used to give accurate refraction and reflection so that it really does look as if it is made of water. 
 Computer graphics should now make the same kind of inroads into feature film production that they already have in television. 
 With its lower resolution, television proved an easier first target for electronic special effects. 
 Cheap high-resolution input and output devices will soon ensure the same kind of revolution in the cinema. 
 You might have thought that the last bastion of resistance to computers would come from the classic craft environment of hand animation. 
 In fact, computers play a leading role in a great deal of cartoon production these days. 
 Some 11 minutes of the latest Disney feature, Oliver and Company, use computer-generated elements. 
 This does not include the characters themselves, but that wouldn't now be such a giant leap to take. 
 Scenes are also still hand-coloured in order to give them the classic Disney feel, but developments in automatic colouring systems could well change this before too long. 
 Of course it was Roger Rabbit who, last year, brought animated feature films back from the dead. 
 The secret of that film's success was the realistic merging of the cartoon world and live action &mdash; an achievement that was once again down to clever computer effects at Industrial Light and Magic. 
 But why go to all that trouble to make a 2D character appear solid when you could generate it on a computer in 3D in the first place? 
 It shouldn't be too long before we get an answer in the shape of the first computer animation feature films. 
 All the smart money for the first to finally come up with the goods is on John Lasseter of Pixar, the perennial star of animation festivals and the winner of the 1989 animation Oscar for the short film Tin Toy. 
 Having cut his teeth at Disney Studios, Lasseter has developed a reputation with a series of shorts over the past five years which have brought together the very best aspects of hand and computer animation, creating something quite special in the process. 
 His latest film is a knockabout tribute to the cartoon greats called Knick Knack. 
 It's likely to be his last film made purely on a research budget. 
 A production company has been set up at Pixar producing commercials and Lasseter is now predicting a fully computer-generated movie within the next three or four years. 
 It's time for the synthetic actors to start learning their lines. 
 Computer graphics in feature film production will be discussed at the Imagina conference on new images in Monte Carlo, February 6-8. 
 Contact: INA, 4 Avenue de l'Europe, 94366, Bry Sur Marne, France. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE mc1 
 Adam Sweeting on why Prince's dancing sensation is aiming for stardom-without him Cat goes for the cream. 
 IS THERE life after Prince? 
 Cathy Glover, the Chicago-born dancer who shot to prominence on Prince's Sign O The Times tour, is in the process of finding out. 
 It hasn't been easy. 
 &bquo;It was pretty difficult to break away from Prince,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;It seemed like it was the hardest decision I ever had to make in my life. 
 I used to see him every day, basically, every night, just working with him in the studio and stuff, and I think it will always be there, thinking of him and everything. 
 &bquo;But it was just a decision I had to make under the circumstances I was given. 
 I couldn't work in those circumstances, so I decided this was the right time if I really wanted to do something with my solo career, just break loose completely.&equo; 
 But she doesn't really look as though she's broken loose. 
 Dressed in vivid orange, with black lettering down her legs and wearing one of Prince's big heart-shaped mirrors on her sleeve, she could be the same girl who blew into town with the spectacular Lovesexy roadshow last year. 
 She's even wearing a Batman ring on her left hand. 
 The Minneapolis Marvel has left an indelible imprint on her. 
 When Prince and his band played their after-hours show at the Camden Palace on Cat's birthday, Prince gave her a cake with 26 candles on, with the message &bquo;Happy Birthday Darling&equo; in chocolate icing. 
 He even sang Happy Birthday. 
 The speculation, inevitably, was that Cat was Prince's new girlfriend, but she insists that their relationship was strictly professional. 
 She was chief dancer and choreographer, he was bandleader and strategy-maker. 
 Prince, she suggests, never leaves the recording studio long enough to have time for anything romantic like a candelit dinner or taking lady-friends to the movies. 
 Which still doesn't quite explain why, on the Lovesexy sleeve, Cat is represented by the shape of a heart. 
 Somewhere along the line, Cat and Prince's Paisley Park organisation couldn't see eye to eye. 
 The original plan was for her to make a solo album on the label, produced by Prince and featuring songs written by Prince. 
 But Cat wanted more input of her own, which led to her departure from his Minneapolis HQ. 
 &bquo;We had a disagreement about it, we didn't actually fall out,&equo; she backtracks. 
 &bquo;Of course I wanted him to produce me, I love his work, but I only wanted him to produce half the album and I wanted to work with other producers. 
 I felt I had music inside me that I wanted people to hear. 
 I didn't just wanna be put in a chair, given some lyrics to read and say &bquo;that's it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Put it like this. 
 If I did it and it didn't come out as good as I thought, or if I failed, then I'll deal with that, but until I take that chance I'll never know. 
 I'm really confident and positive about my music, it's really energetic and it's fun music, and I think a lotta people need that these days.&equo; 
 The first evidence of Cat's &bquo;I felt I had music inside me that I wanted people to hear. 
 I didn't just wannabe put in a chair, given some lyrics to read and say &bquo;that's it.&equo;. 
 own sound is the new single Catwoman. 
 It's a reasonable enough slice of hyperactive club-pop, featuring roaring guitars, a tense, busy beat, and Cat's imprecations to &bquo;dance all night long.&equo; 
 The snag is it could be almost anyone, and if I were Neneh Cherry or Stock, Aitken or Waterman, I don't think I'd be losing sleep over it. 
 But there's an entire album to follow in the New Year, called I Am Energy, produced by Tim Simenon of Bomb The Bass. 
 When she came to London with Prince, Cat was impressed by the local music-types and by their willingness to find new sounds and try anything. 
 In the States, the emphasis is on sticking to the tried and true. 
 But despite a guest appearance by Jack Nicholson, and the assistance of the ingenious Simenon (a man so uninfatuated by Prince and all his works that he fell asleep during the Sign O The Times movie), does Cat have the creative wherewithal to make it as a solo act? 
 There's no doubting her dance credentials. 
 She remembers being in a kids' dance troupe called the Wee Winkies when she was a seven-year-old in Chicago, she enjoyed a run of successes on the TV talent show Star Search, and she was eventually spotted by Prince dancing in a Los Angeles nightclub. 
 As a writer and singer, though, she has ground to make up. 
 Being one of Prince's chosen women has its drawbacks. 
 Jill Jones, for instance, recorded an album for Paisley Park with Prince as co-producer and guest songwriter. 
 It sounded like Purple Rain Falls Again. 
 This was the kind of thing Cat was worried about. 
 &bquo;Jill Jones's album had been on the shelf for so long that when it did come out, it sounded old,&equo; she reveals. 
 &bquo;It was recorded during the 1999/Purple Rain days. 
 But Jill is very talented, she's going to be really big once she gets her music together.&equo; 
 Obviously. 
 Consider, then, Wendy &amp; Lisa. 
 As Prince's sidepersons, they featured prominently in the Purple Rain movie, and evidently contributed substantially to the Little &bquo;Un's sound of the period. 
 Their subsequent career has met with approval from punters and critics, yet there's that lingering feeling that they're just chips off the Master's block. 
 There's no getting round the fact that Prince's powerful mythology can create starlets in its own image. 
 Sheena Easton has been shrewd enough to ride Prince's coat-tails just so far and no further, without letting her identity be submerged. 
 Sheila E, Prince's drummer, had already established her musician's credentials before she joined him, though it remains to be seen where she goes from here. 
 Cat has high hopes, though. 
 &bquo;At first everyone thought I was gonna sound like Prince. 
 I go &bquo;no no no, this is what I wanna do, this is Cat.&equo; 
 I'm not perfect, I know. 
 I'm working on it, but I'm not perfect.&equo; 
 Well, it's a start. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Trivial treats from a playful Puccini Classical. 
 By Edward Greenfield The Unknown Puccini-Domingo/Rudel. 
 CBS MK 44981. 
 Joan Sutherland Prima Donna Assoluta, recordings 1959-1972. 
 Decca 425 605-2. 
 Faure: La Chanson d'Eve and 18 other songs-Baker/ Parsons. 
 Hyperion CDA 66320. 
 Favourite Encores for String Quartet-Delme Quartet. 
 Helios CDH 88038. 
 The Carol Album, Seven Centuries of Christmas Music-Parrott/Taverner Consort, Choir and Players. 
 EMI CDC 749 809-2. 
 Taverner: Western Wynde Mass, Tallis: Missa Salve Intemerata Virgo-Guest/St John's College Choir. 
 EMI Eminence CD-EMX 2155. 
 Bach: Violin Concertos in E and A minor, Double Violin Concerto, Violin and Oboe Concerto-King/Mackintosh/ Wallfisch/Goodwin/ King's Consort. 
 Hyperion CDA 66380. 
 Saint-Saens: Carnival of the Animals, Bizet's Children's Games, Ravel: Mother Goose -Wordsworth/LSO. 
 IMP PCD 932. 
 Tchaikovsky: Romeo and Juliet, Francesca da Rimini, 1812, Marche Slave-Edwards/ RLPO. 
 EMI Eminence CD-EMX 2152. 
 Horowitz At Home. 
 DG 427 772-2. 
 HERE for Christmas are some lighter offerings, only one of them seasonal but all of them in their different ways highly recommendable. 
 The Unknown Puccini has Placido Domingo in disguise on the front cover. 
 Sitting nonchalantly in straw boater and white suit and sporting a moustache, he sits in the Galleria at Milan, masquerading as the composer himself. 
 This is a celebration of Puccini in trivial mood, a collection of songs written for odd occasions at odd moments through his career. 
 Most of them are early, including two conventional religious pieces and a charming salon song written for a magazine. 
 In it, tongue in cheek, the composer signs off with his name on the final cadence. 
 It later became the Act 3 finale of La Boheme. 
 Another song celebrates the launching of a friend's motor yacht, and a tiny fragment, Casa mia, was written for a house agent to use, when Puccini wanted to sell his house. 
 Domingo gives them all, however trivial, golden treatment. 
 Joan Sutherland, Prima Donna Assoluta, is one of the most cherishable CD collections yet of La Stupenda's great recordings, though it comes on Decca's bargain label. 
 The item to covet most is the earliest and the most extended, the whole of the Lucia di Lammermoor mad scene in the recording Sutherland made in 1959 soon after her first Covent Garden triumph when her voice was at its freshest. 
 Other items include a ravishing account of &bquo;Qui la voce&equo; from Bellini's Puritani done in 1960, the end of Act 1 of Verdi's La Traviata, the Bell Song from Delibes' Lakme and a rare Donizetti aria once used as a substitute item in Lucia. 
 Dame Janet Baker may have announced her retirement from public performance, but she still plans to make one or two recordings. 
 This representative, beautifully chosen collection of Faure songs is the first issue to appear since her announcement, and it whets the appetite for many more. 
 The centre-piece of her collection of 28 songs is the cycle, La chanson d'Eve, late settings of symbolist poems with Faure at his subtlest and most refined. 
 Before that the chronological sequence of songs starts with a charming Gounod-like salon piece, and follows the composer's development, after which the collection is crowned by the best-loved Verlaine settings. 
 Favourite Encores for String Quartet brings together 15 lollipop items to defy any idea that this is an austere medium, with the Delme Quartet making persuasive advocates. 
 The obvious piece, Schubert's Quartetsatz is missing, but that is very well covered on record already, and most of these little charmers are neglected on disc, even Hugo Wolf's deliciously sparkling Italian Serenade. 
 Other items range from the Haydn-Hofstetter Serenade once used as the Music in Miniature signature tune and Tchaikovsky's Andante cantabile to Puccini's Crisantemi and two delightful folk-song settings by Frank Bridge. 
 Helios is the mid-price label published by Hyperion. 
 The Carol Album is a carol record with a difference. 
 Puccini: A celebration Andrew Parrott with his Taverner Consort, Choir and Players has gone back to medieval sources, and devised a sequence not just of carols in more robust settings than is common but of instrumental pieces like the March of the Kings. 
 That uses a theme which Bizet much later cribbed for his L'Arlesienne music. 
 There is an abrasiveness about the Parrott approach, anything but charming in a conventionally cooing way, which is most refreshing. 
 Strong, virile performances of two of the finest of all Tudor settings of the Mass come from the choir of St John's College Cambridge on a label not normally associated with early music, mid-price EMI Eminence. 
 The Western Wynde Mass of Taverner was one of the pieces which first alerted non-specialist listeners to the glories of Tudor church music. 
 What was always striking was the emotional undertow to Taverner's polyphonic writing, more obviously involving than the ethereal Palestrina. 
 That involvement is well caught by the St John's Choir, bringing out the ingeniously woven repetitions of the Western Wynde theme, used as a ground through the whole Mass. 
 It helps that the song itself is sung as a prelude to the performance. 
 Tallis's Missa Salve Intemerata Virgo from a generation later, is a so-called &bquo;parody mass&equo; based on one of the composer's own most extended motets. 
 Though the tenor part was originally missing, it has been faithfully restored by analogy with the motet to make a glorious addition to the recorded repertory of Tallis's music. 
 Bach's violin concertos have been well-treated on record, but this new version from Hyperion using period instruments is exceptional. 
 Until now period performances have tended to be abrasive and to whizz through the slow movements, making even the sublime Largo of the Double Concerto into a trivial siciliana. 
 Catherine Mackintosh and Elizabeth Wallfisch with Robert King and the King's Consort without sentimentality allow themselves a more relaxed view. 
 Though purists may object, the performances of all four concertos on the disc spring to life, fast movements as well as slow, and will equally delight those who would normally choose an account on modern instruments. 
 Besides the Double Concerto and the two solo Concertos in E major and A minor the disc includes the delightful Concerto for Violin and Oboe reconstructed from the Double Keyboard Concerto in C minor, with the oboist Paul Goodwin joining Catherine Mackintosh. 
 It makes an ideal coupling for children of all ages to have three French masterpieces on a single disc-not just Saint-Saens' Carnival of the Animals, but Bizet's Children's Games and Ravel's Mother Goose, all in fresh, well-sprung performances from the LSO under the ballet conductor, Barry Wordsworth. 
 The Saint-Saens comes in the chamber version using single strings, with its wit well caught and the Swan done with stylish restraint. 
 The Bizet is given a sparkling performance too, while generously the Ravel comes in the complete ballet version, even more hauntingly atmopheric than the usual suite. 
 Excellent sound on the mid-price IMP label. 
 EMI Eminence is also promoting completely new orchestral recordings for its mid-price label, and Sian Edwards in her first major recording draws brilliant performances from the Royal Liverpool Philharmonic Orchestra of the three most popular Tchaikovsky overtures, Romeo and Juliet, Francesca da Rimini and 1812 plus Marche Slave. 
 The vivid recording helps to bring out the degree of refinement that Miss Edwards finds even in 1812, without losing anything in dramatic bite. 
 These are performances to make you forget these are pieces usually treated as potboilers. 
 Horowitz At Home is the master's very last recording, capturing him at his most relaxed, when here he is playing in his drawing-room on his own favourite Steinway. 
 Unexpectedly three of the seven items are of Mozart-an early little sonata which he magicks into the status of masterpiece, as well as the late B minor Adagio and Rondo in D. The best-known of Schubert's Moments Musicaux, the little F minor, is given a chirpily personal reading, before he tackles three Liszt pieces, the Fantasy based on Schubert's Serenade as well as the Valses-Caprices nos 6 and 7. 
 On the cover Horowitz himself beams at us like a naughty gnome, and that is just the way his irrepressible musical personality comes over in the performances. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Last exit to Frith Street. 
 By Norman Shrapnel Hazlitt: A Life, by Stanley Jones (Oxford, &pound;35) &bquo;W. 
 ELL, I've had a happy life&equo; &mdash; as Hazlitt may not have said after all, in which case bang goes the cheeriest of all the Famous Last Words. 
 At least, Stanley Jones mentions in his deeply interesting new biography that doubts have been cast on the authenticity of the celebrated exit line, though without actually vouching for it he considers it just what Hazlitt would have said. 
 Would he? 
 Not, surely, on the evidence of an angst-racked life as painstakingly marshalled here. 
 A man of his far from sanguine temperament would hardly want to go through all that again. 
 As for last words, there are some fully-authenticated late ones addressed to an editor which sound more convincing: &bquo;I wish to God you could let me have &pound;5 more on account.&equo; 
 Worrying his head off, scratching about for the rent, weathering one disappointment after another &mdash; it seems to have been like that all the way. 
 Hazlitt has not been short of biographers, but before reading Jones I never felt I had begun to know the man, or formed any satisfying conception of his obviously contradictory nature. 
 After reading Jones I still don't know him but at least begin to recognise the sort of person he was. 
 Self-contradiction is natural in the human make-up; inconsistencies are not worrying in themselves, so long as they aren't planted by memoir-writers or biographers putting down other biographers. 
 The personality contradictions have in no way been ironed out; if anything they emerge more starkly. 
 Hazlitt remains a baffling man. 
 The appeal of this closely-worked new study is that it presents him as a comprehensive human being. 
 The contradictions fall into something like a natural order of things, in a flamboyant era when the natural was notalways easy to come by. 
 Hazlitt, as he nervously emerges here, is the ordinary mixed-up man confronting the hero-figure of the romantic revival, diffident amid the posturing. 
 Though not sure whether he wanted to be a painter or a writer he knew he was no Haydon, the fashionable golden boy of the day, the &bquo;angry young man of romantic art.&equo; 
 There was a gulf between the truculence of his views and the introversion of his behaviour. 
 While others were being lionised he conducted himself like a lamb or even a mouse. 
 He was as little at home in the country as in town; he believed ardently in social freedom but its ambiguities made him equally ill at ease with all classes. 
 Anyone setting out to keep tracks on Hazlitt must indeed find it a cat-and-mouse exercise. 
 The elusive creature may be successfully trailed for a time, then disappear for months and even years. 
 He seems to have had the strongest instinct for cover. 
 And always he was scratching for crumbs. 
 His grander friends had to eat too but set their claims higher. 
 Not for him the elevation and security of Wordsworth's appointment as His Majesty's Distributor of Stamps for the County of Westmorland. 
 Hazlitt found the humbler job of reporting parliament for the Morning Chronicle; we find him describing how one MP rose to a parliamentary occasion by &bquo;soaring into mediocrity,&equo; a joke any modern sketchwriter would be proud to use and probably has. 
 Often he seems out of his period and the more attractive for it. 
 He professed to be unnerved by Wordsworth's towering self-esteem, which he judged a form of dementia because Wordsworth himself considered that nobody else was elevated enough to measure it. 
 This sounds like a satirical whim ahead of its time, and certainly well beneath its victim's cloud-capped head. 
 He could be Proustian: &bquo;It is better to desire than to enjoy &mdash; to love than be loved.&equo; 
 Yet although Haydon mocked his &bquo;passionate timidity&equo; there was plenty of action in the amatory field &mdash; no ambiguity there, even if his style fell short ofByronic. 
 Hazlitt confesses a preference for &bquo;humble beauties, servant-maids and shepherd-girls, with their red elbows, hard hands, black stockings and mob caps.&equo; 
 This sounds uncharacteristically bold but he knew when to take time off from his introversion. 
 And although followed diligently by Mr Jones along many a fascinating track he seems to have won out in the end and disappeared from view. 
 &bquo;The obscurity which enshrouds many earlier moments of his life becomes well-nigh impenetrable in his last years,&equo; Mr Jones finds. 
 He went on writing busily in the journals which employed him, the Edinburgh Review and others. 
 There were the words, as large as life and often twice as sane. 
 But of the man, scarcely a trace. 
 Even so, the story ends on a note of macabre paradox. 
 He died in Frith Street, at one of various lodgings after his second wife had left him. 
 For several days his body was &bquo;thrust aside, hidden under a piece of furniture by his landlady, so that she might not lose the chance of showing the room to a prospective new lodger.&equo; 
 Hazlitt: large as life, twice as saneENGRAVING: THOMAS BEWICK 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Paperbacks. 
 By David Bodanis Kowtow! by William Shawcross (Chatto Counter Blasts, &pound;2.99). 
 Dirty Water, by Judith Cook (Unwin, &pound;4.99). 
 Manufacturing Consent: The Political Economy of the Mass Media, by Edward S. Herman and Noam Chomsky (Pantheon New York, &dollar;14.95) How to Shit in the Woods: An Environmentally Sound Approach to a Lost Art, by Kathleen Meyer (Ten Speed Press, UK distributor: Airlift Book Company, &pound;4.95) 
 TWO psychiatrists are in a lift. 
 One is relaxed, the other dishevelled. 
 The dishevelled one says: &bquo;How can you look so comfortable, after all the grief our patients give us?&equo; 
 And the first one answers, surprised: &bquo;Who listens?&equo; 
 Polemicists do not like this joke. 
 William Shawcross says clearly, with simple words in only 57 pages of fairly large print, why Britain should take Hong Kong refugees after the Chinese takeover if needed. 
 It would be good for the Hong Kong citizens, and it would be inconsistent for Thatcher not to do this, since she has said, for the Falklands, that a people should be able to choose their own government, and we shouldn't give in to dictatorships. 
 Although I'm persuaded, Thatcher's government is probably not going to listen; nor will most Britons. 
 Where is it written that Thatcher has to be consistent? 
 She used big general terms about the Falklands, but all she really meant was: Argies aren't going to mess white Britons about. 
 The problem is one that most pamphleteers face. 
 They want to appeal to people's better nature, but to do that they can't point out what shmucks most of us are, most of the time. 
 The complacent citizen looks up and sees a distant jet's contrails, whooshing along in impressive white streams. 
 He might even say: &bquo;My, how crisp and impressive is Shawcross's argument up there.&equo; 
 But it's not touching what that citizen really feels, and so is unlikely to change him. 
 None of this means Shawcross should stop &mdash; the cause is too important &mdash; but it can make for a frustrating life. 
 Judith Cook should have had an easier job in her pamphlet against water privatisation, for it's British people themselves, in the near future, who will suffer. 
 What they already owned will be taken from them, and they will pay higher bills to feed cash to shareholders who've done nothing. 
 Once again this is wrong, clearly so: &bquo;It is a &bquo;scam&equo; on such a scale it takes the breath away.&equo; 
 But why must I worry about those future citizens, today's citizen-slob might reason, even if they are likely to include me? 
 The me of 1989 exists and can gain money from the shares. 
 The me of 1999 doesn't yet exist. 
 I would feel bad if I knew for certain that someone was going to cosh me with a lead pipe on January 15 of that year. 
 I might even give money to The Campaign for Heavier Helmets today. 
 But otherwise, without this exact knowledge, that future me is just someone vague, no more worth acting for&hellip; than the poor Hong Kong Chinese today. 
 The question is one of how to extend human empathy. 
 Television is excellent for this, and Chomsky for long has had that great domain in which to show how governments and the big businesses linked to most television powers are very, very careful to be sure that few views are presented which violate the currently useful consensus. 
 Working with Edward Herman, a business school professor, he's especially good on showing how the companies create acceptable experts when ordinary ones &mdash; simple academics who've spent lifetimes studying some area &mdash; can't be trusted not to point out inconvenient facts. 
 For Latin America it's very difficult, as you need someone who won't bring up any of the bad guys the US has supported and still does support there when the topic is those dreaded Sandinistas again. 
 But corporate America is a can-do world, and the US networks usually succeed. 
 The best solution is for a pamphleteer to show people how much fun it is to do good. 
 Working with what might appear an impossible topic, Kathleen Meyer shows what a master can achieve. 
 First she disarms us: &bquo;Several seasons of guiding city folks down white water rivers both sharpened my squatting skills and assured me I wasn't alone in the klutz department.&equo; 
 Then she shows how much fun the proper outdoor technique is for her &mdash; &bquo;The ideal occasion for communing with nature&hellip; is while you're peacefully sitting still.&equo; 
 There are even special joys for women: the pride in learning a guaranteed way to keep the boots dry which, if performed behind waist-high bush, means &bquo;you can casually and with dignity intact carry on a conversation with the rest of the camp&equo;; no more of the old &bquo;search for a place to hide (God forbid anyone should know we have to pee in the first place).&equo; 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Flight from enchanters. 
 By Desmond Christy The Torch in My Ear, by Elias Canetti, translated by Joachim Neugroschel (Andre Deutsch, &pound;13.95) 
 BERLIN in 1928 really was no place for a puritan like Elias Canetti. 
 Back in Vienna he had been bewitched by the viciously witty judgments of the satirist, Karl Kraus. 
 If Kraus judged Vienna so harshly, what words could be severe enough for Berlin? 
 Canetti, for example, couldn't imagine writing for money. 
 When he met Brecht he even railed against the advertisements &bquo;contaminating Berlin.&equo; 
 Brecht, whose poetry Canetti admired enormously, wasn't the least bit bothered. 
 &bquo;On the contrary, he said advertisements had their good points; he had written a poem about Steyr automobiles and been given a car for it. 
 For me, these were words from the devil's own mouth.&equo; 
 Much worse was to follow. 
 Karl Kraus had come to town. 
 Karl Kraus &bquo;whom I venerated more than anyone else in the world, without whose wrath and zeal I wouldn't have cared to live, whom I had never dared to approach.&equo; 
 Kraus is the man whose magazine, The Torch, provides a title for this, the second volume of Canetti's autobiography. 
 Kraus, who once defined journalists as people &bquo;with no ideas and the ability to express them,&equo; had come to Berlin without his thunderbolts. 
 He was quiet, polite, and concerned about everyone he met. 
 And who was Kraus's great friend in Berlin, who did he regard almost as a son? 
 Why, Brecht, the car salesman! 
 Here was the beginning of Canetti's slow escape from the thrall of Karl Kraus. 
 But his whole autobiography &mdash; this volume covers the years 1921-1931 during which Canetti lived in Frankfurt, Vienna and Berlin &mdash; is largely about his flight from enchanters. 
 Much of his childhood, after the death of his father, and early manhood was spent wresting himself away from the embrace of his mother. 
 He even ended up inventing women &mdash; he is a very good story teller &mdash; to distract his mother's jealousy from Veza, the amazing woman under whose spell he fell (and who, in part three of the autobiography, he marries). 
 Veza was even better read than Canetti (and she could remember it all). 
 But although she was also one of Kraus's greatest admirers she had dared to read Heine, of whom Kraus had once said: &bquo;Heinrich Heine so loosened the corsets of the German language that today even little salesman can fondle her breasts.&equo; 
 But though certain extremely powerful individuals &mdash; like Kraus and his mother &mdash; enslave him, it is people, &bquo;ordinary&equo; folk who are to him completely extraordinary, who free him from the greatest enchanter of them all &mdash; books. 
 Canetti had read more by the time he was 16 than most of us manage by the time we are 40. 
 He had read them in more languages, too. 
 On a polyglot diet of great classics the bookworm might have gorged himself into a mere know-all, not into a writer capable of winning, and deserving, numerous prizes, including a Nobel. 
 But people, especially when they ganged together into that mysterious thing called a crowd, were his liberation. 
 Crowds were to provide him with the project that kept him busy for decades, the writing of Crowds And Power. 
 On July 15, 1927 he saw a kind of Peterloo massacre in Vienna. 
 The Palace of Justice (a terrible misnomer) was set on fire by the workers. 
 The police, only doing their job, opened fire and 90 people were killed. 
 &bquo;In a side street, not far from the burning Palace of Justice, yet out of the way, stood a man, sharply distinguished from the crowd, flailing his hands in the air and moaning over and over again: &bquo;The files are burning! 
 All the files!&equo; 
 &bquo;Better files than people, I told him, but that did not interest him: all he could think of was the files.&equo; 
 The behaviour of the crowd found its way into Crowds And Power, the behaviour of the man moaning about the files into Canetti's novel, Auto da Fe, and Karl Kraus's behaviour was what, in the nightmare recollections of the massacre, seemed to provide some &bquo;legitimate connection to literature.&equo; 
 All over Vienna posters appeared demanding the resignation of the police chief who had given the orders to shoot. 
 Kraus had put them there, the only public figure with the &bquo;courage of his indignation.&equo; 
 Canetti is not, I think, earnestly recording his life; his passion is really for the others he writes about, be they as famous as Brecht or as obscure as his landlady. 
 He can devote a few paragraphs to Brecht but pages to the crippled young would-be philosopher who spends his life in a barrow flicking through Spinoza and Kant with his tongue. 
 Just as Canetti didn't like the advertising hoardings in Berlin, so he dislikes self-advertisement. 
 He very rarely gives an interview, he hates the prose of feature writers (and, I fear, of book reviewers). 
 But sometimes he relents. 
 The German critic, Bernd Witte, recalls that in 1980, Cannetti gave an interview in which he explained why he embarked on this autobiography in which other people are so important. 
 In August 1971, the same year in which he married for the second time, Canetti's brother, Georg, was dying. 
 The two brothers were very close and no writer I can think of has such a hatred of death as Canetti. 
 When he was a child and his mother was ill, he thought he could make her better by writing a play. 
 So he wrote one. 
 In 1971 he thought he could help his brother in his illness by writing about their childhood. 
 His brother did not live to read about it. 
 Canetti's great foe is death and his belief in the power of words to fight it is some kind of myth that motivates his pen. 
 In 1936 he gave a speech in honour of Hermann Broch's 50th birthday. 
 He felt as if his address was saying to Broch: &bquo;Don't be afraid, you have been afraid enough for us. 
 We all have to die; but it is still not certain whether you too have to die. 
 Perhaps your very words are what must represent us to posterity. 
 You have served us with loyalty and honesty. 
 The age will not release you.&equo; 
 This has been well translated, apart from some American sounding idioms for which Karl Kraus would probably have shot his translator. 
 Canetti has learned to be more human. 
 Kraus taught him to listen and about the limitations of judging. 
 In Berlin Issac Babel taught him how to see. 
 On any page you can see how well he has learned these lessons and like any great novelist he leaves you wondering if you've ever really used your eyes and ears. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Good dirty fun New Fiction. 
 By Robert Nye Myself and Marco Polo, by Paul Griffiths (Chatto &amp; Windus, &pound;12.95) Goatsong, by Tom Holt (Macmillan, &pound;12.95) The Fly in the Ointment, by Alice Thomas Ellis (Duckworth, &pound;10.95) Sex and the City, edited by Marsha Rowe (Serpent's Tail, &pound;5.95 paperback) 
 MYSELF and Marco Polo is a working model of a novel, a clever toy, a verbal tournament, a facetious blueprint for a possible future seriousness: it could only be called a success if its author's aim was merely to intrigue, and I do not feel that Paul Griffiths can be that crude. 
 Mr Griffiths is the music critic of the Times and has written several books on music, including a study of Olivier Messiaen. 
 The present text, his first novel, strikes me as amusing, irritating, and impressive in about equal degrees, and for all I know it might well have been composed rather than written; certainly it seems to have been constructed in 64 chapters based on the hexagrams of the I Ching &mdash; it is subtitled A Novel of Changes, in case anyone should miss this &mdash; with frequent references to Marco Polo's own writings, in Ronald Latham's Penguin translation. 
 None of this would be worth remark if the narrative carried us along by virtue of its own strength, but it hardly does. 
 All the time the reader is reminded that he is reading, confronted with his own reactions, reminded to keep his distance, forced into sceptical attitudes by an author determined that nothing shall appear easy or comfortable. 
 Healthy for us perhaps; but Mr Griffiths himself has the disease of any performer: he needs his audience. 
 Myself and Parco Polo seeks meaning in what it does to us, and it left me thinking that the late Italo Calvino has a lot to answer for. 
 Still, as a post-Calvino performance, this novel has the merit of being fairly convincingly dissatisfied with its own absurdity. 
 Marco Polo tells his tales in a Genoan prison cell, and a scribe called Rustichello writes some of them down, alters and embellishes others, or treats us to his own tourism of the spirit. 
 Between disquisitions on Chinese opera and Venetian architecture, the story of Marco Polo's voyage from Venice to Peking is more or less retold, though the narrative is continually being brought to a halt in moments when it half-realises that it does not mean enough. 
 At best, Mr Griffiths has a useful sense of humour, and he does not spare Rustichello a single revelation of his own insignificance. 
 It is when he tries to make the reader an accomplice in the fiction, over-ambitiously, that the book degenerates into experiment. 
 I suggest that Mr Paul will feel better for having tried this on, and failed, and that his second book will be the one this could have been. 
 Goatsong is also quite good fun as literary games go. 
 Its author Tom Holt began, if I remember right, by publishing his collected poems at the age of 12. 
 Since then he has graduated to writing sequels to E.F.Benson's Lucia novels, a book with the good title of Expecting Someone Taller (which I must read sometime) and another with the awful title of Who's Afraid of Beowulf? (which I recently read for amusement, without success). 
 The hero of his latest effort &mdash; volume one in a series &mdash; is Eupolis of Pallene, gentleman farmer, goatherd, and writer of comedies. 
 Athens is in the middle of her golden age; Pericles is building the Parthenon; the Gods are on Olympus, and all's right with the world&hellip; 
 Except that Eupolis, our narrator and celebrator of these blisses, is himself a cynic. 
 He has lived on, you see, through the time when Athens embarked on the Peloponnesian War, and Cleon and Alcibiades buggered up the world's first and best democracy. 
 Mr Holt's theme is sex as a source of confusion. 
 His secondary theme is Athens, which on the whole he seems to prefer. 
 He treats both subjects with a wit which is lucid and ambiguous at one and the same time, so that I recalled Charles Lamb's remark about the possibility of obscurity through too much meaning. 
 The artful honesty of this novel's conclusion &mdash; with Eupolis impelled towards a moment of self-knowledge which he is not quite permitted to understand &mdash; certainly makes the book stand out. 
 The rest of the series may justify some of the thickness of material introduced here. 
 Meanwhile, this one can be enjoyed for what it does in its own right. 
 The Fly in the Ointment brings to a conclusion the trilogy of novels by Alice Thomas Ellis which began with The Clothes in the Wardrobe and The Skeleton in the Cupboard. 
 Miss Ellis writes cleverly and without wasting words, and her tale of Lili whose father is Egyptian and whose mother English, and whose own nature allows her to assume either nationality as the whim takes her, can be said to be compact and readable. 
 Lili, needless to remark, is unhappy: when she is in the heat of the Nile she longs for the mists of England, and vice versa. 
 Success in love only bores her. 
 I suspect that as with the not dissimilar talents of Anita Brookner, the reader needs to share the author's attitudes to enjoy all this. 
 No such problem rears its pretty head with Sex and the City, a compilation edited by Marsha Rowe in which a number of writers contribute stories about love and lust in an urban &mdash; not to say cosmoplitan &mdash; context. 
 Rosalind Belben's &bquo;My sole feeling of happiness lies in the fact that no one knows where I am&equo; stands out as a brilliant piece of writing, but the stories by Alison Fell, Tom Wakefield, Ian Breakwell, and Elizabeth Cook are also noteworthy, particularly the last about two women who send each other erotic messages by leaving little bite-marks on their mutual man's body. 
 The whole book comes into the category of good dirty fun, and is not the worse for that. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Quisling: bigamist, hypocrite, puritan, racist A labour of loathing. 
 By Dan van der Vat Quisling: a study in treason, by Oddvar K. Hoidal (Oxford, &pound;48) 
 ONE OF THE few quotable quotes attributed to Vidkun Abraham Lauritz Jonssoen Quisling, uttered with contempt on one of the many occasions when his Norwegian countrymen rejected him, is: &bquo;Ibsen knew his people.&equo; 
 What he meant was that his reluctant compatriots were so inward-looking that they could not perceive his genius. 
 One suspects that Ibsen, faced with a character like Quisling, would immediately have applied to join the Norwegian Resistance. 
 Quisling stands supreme as the synonym for traitor. 
 With its onomatopoeic qualities, redolent of a snake in the grass, the name could have been invented by Dickens. 
 None of the collaborators mobilised by Hitler's conquests, not even Petain, evokes quite so much disgust. 
 The reasons are simple: Quisling, a former army officer, diplomat, and minister of defence was the first of his kind; and his bid for power, though his own idea, by coinciding with the German takeover was assumed to be part of it. 
 Readers will soon discern, on page 42 if not earlier, that in the personality of Quisling they are faced with a thundering, breathtaking, unsurpassable bore: &bquo;He lacked a sense of humour to give him balance.&equo; 
 At that point they will still have 735 pages of text to go. 
 The biographer is absolutely right to say at the very beginning that Quisling is not at all difficult to understand. 
 This should not be seen as a deterrent. 
 The psychological black hole which is Quisling's superabundance of gravity is more than counterbalanced by the light thrown on the society which spawned him: a small country struggling in the economic and political tempests of the years between the wars. 
 Among the unconcealed shallows of his character were a vast and voracious ego and many unmistakable traits of the authoritarian personality. 
 His ability to rationalise verged on the psychopathic. 
 He was notably indecisive, especially in a crisis. 
 One of the 20 to 2,000 facts you and I didn't know about Quisling which are in this book is that he was a lifelong bigamist. 
 He was also a hypocrite, a puritan, and a racist. 
 But the central irony about him is that it was not only the Norwegian people that rejected him: even the majority of Norwegian fascists didn't want him. 
 Nor was it only Norway that shunned him: the invading Germans couldn't stand him either. 
 Even the Fuehrer, not a man to rush to admit error, changed his mind about the Foerer, as Quisling styled himself, and had him sacked within a week. 
 It is a measure of Quisling's obstinacy that he was back as &bquo;premier&equo; &mdash; albeit the puppet of Reichskommissar Josef Terboven &mdash; within two years, thus ensuring that he shared the guilt for the occupation war-crimes for which he was duly shot in 1945. 
 Even the most committed opponents of capital punishment will find it hard not to see the Norwegians' point of view. 
 One of the most deeply satisfying moments in the bleak record of Hitler's lightning conquests in 1940 is the sinking of the heavy cruiser Bluecher. 
 This ship was the floating HQ of a generally brilliant invasion operation; it was also carrying one complete, portable occupation government. 
 As the brand-new warship entered the narrows outside Oslo, the ancient but sturdy cannon of the coastal artillery, ironically of the finest Krupp workmanship, disgorged their projectiles at optimum range. 
 So did shore-based torpedo-tubes. 
 Down went the Bluecher. 
 The seizure of Oslo was delayed by only a few hours, just long enough for the king, his ministers and most of parliament &mdash; the collective personification of constitutional legitimacy &mdash; to evade capture. 
 The author reveals that this almighty blunder was down to Quisling who had told German intelligence that the battery would not fire without direct cabinet orders. 
 As for this book, it is regrettably much too long and expensive for all but the most dedicated explorers of the byways of the second world war to buy. 
 It is exhaustive, impeccably organised, and generally well written (apart from a few Germanicisms like telephoning &bquo;over&equo; instead of &bquo;via&equo; Sweden, and Norway's defence being &bquo;overmanned&equo; instead of &bquo;overwhelmed&equo;). 
 What one misses most is jokes. 
 Even though he exhibited less humour than Ibsen on a bad night, the frantic phone calls just mentioned &mdash; by the conquering Germans from Oslo to Berlin trying to get the importunate Foerer off their backs &mdash; offer clear elements of farce. 
 Yet Quisling was anything but a joke to the people he fought so hard to betray. 
 One is left hoping that this painstaking and honourable labour of loathing helps to exorcise the most evil spirit in Norwegian history. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 &bquo;Arrest warrant out for Clowes&equo; partner years before collapse'. 
 By Daniel John 
 AWARRANT for the arrest of the former partner of Mr Peter Clowes was issued seven years before his Barlow Clowes investment empire collapsed, according to evidence submitted to the Parliamentary Ombudsman. 
 Sir Anthony Barrowclough was told that police had wanted to interview Mrs Elizabeth Barlow in 1981 over the collapse of a stockbroking firm which had links with another investment company, Farrington Stead, a similar operation to Barlow Clowes. 
 According to the liquidator of the stockbroking firm which crashed as a result of the Farrington Stead failure, the summons for her arrest was issued late that year. 
 However, Mrs Barlow, who quit her partnership with Peter Clowes in 1978, was said to have left Britain. 
 In his report published two days ago in which he accused the Department of Trade and Industry of &bquo;substantial maladministration&equo; over the Barlow Clowes affair, Sir Anthony wrote: &bquo;He (the liquidator) believed that the warrant for her arrest still remained outstanding.&equo; 
 Mrs Barlow is now thought to be living in the United States. 
 Part of the evidence about Farrington Stead was supplied to the Ombudsman by Manchester solicitors Alexander Tatham, the legal advisers to the Barlow Clowes investors group. 
 Tatham also represented investors who were caught up in the Farrington Stead collapse. 
 Farrington Stead dealt in gilt-edged securities, investments also offered by Barlow Clowes which went into liquidation in June 1988 owing &pound;190million. 
 It is understood that Farrington Stead was set up by former employees of Barlow Clowes. 
 Farrington Stead failed in the early part of 1981 owing substantial debts to Hedderwick Stirling Grumbar, a London stockbroker. 
 As a result, Hedderwick collapsed and was &bquo;hammered&equo; by the Stock Exchange on April 10 &mdash; a move which forced it out of broking. 
 Barlow Clowes' indirect links with the case were raised with the DTI by the Stock Exchange when Hedderwick's liquidator contacted the head of its licensing unit. 
 The Ombudsman's report notes the liquidator expressed surprise then that Barlow Clowes was operating without a licence. 
 Ex-Bond man held over phone tapping. 
 By Jan Mayman in Perth 
 ABOND Corporation director confirmed in Perth last night that a man helping the Australian Federal Police with inquiries about alleged bugging on Mr Robert Holmes a Court's phones was a former Bond employee. 
 Mr Peter Lucas, a director of Bond Corporation, named the man as Mr David Michael, who, he said, had been responsible for top-level corporation security until his dismissal last October. 
 Mr Michael, 49, is believed to be a former British Army officer and is now in hiding along with his wife Jane, in a safe house near Perth under the protection of the Australian Federal Police. 
 The couple disappeared from their Perth suburban house about two weeks ago after telling friends they were seriously worried about their personal security. 
 Mr Lucas said Michael worked for Bond Corporation for around five years and was trusted so greatly he was given responsibility for the security of international VIPs who visited Western Australia during Bond's America's Cup defence three years ago. 
 This year Michael had received a special briefing from the Bond Corporation to check the source of leaks of some highly confidential commercial information. 
 There were suggestions that Bond Corporation executives had been under regular surveillance and that there had been interference with telephone communications, Mr Lucas said. 
 Mr Michael had been asked to arrange electronic sweeps of all office communication equipment in the interests of personal security. 
 Earlier another Bond director Mr Tony Oates said the corporation vigorously denied it had any knowledge of the alleged phone-bugging operation. 
 The Australian Federal Police are saying little about the affair, which has become a national scandal, but they have admitted the discovery of illegal bugs on the phones of Mr Robert Holmes a Court, Sydney stockbroker Mr Peter Burrows and a leading Australian financial journalist, Mr Terry McCran of the Melbourne Herald, a trenchant critic of the Bond Corporation. 
 Junk bond setback. 
 The US junk bond market suffered its latest setback yesterday after buyout firm Kohlberg Kravis Roberts said one of its companies was on the verge of bankruptcy, writes Mary Brasier in New York. 
 KKR said that if Hillsborough could not refinance the debt it took on when it launched a &dollar;2.4billion leveraged takeover in the building industry, it might have to file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy. 
 Seasonal relief. 
 The US Federal Reserve prompted a fall in market interest rates to 8 &frac14; per cent yesterday when it injected &dollar;2billion into the banking system. 
 It was seen as a temporary move to improve liquidity over Christmas, rather than an indication of a new trend in interest rates. 
 Bumper pay rises. 
 More large pay rises for directors have been revealed. 
 Trafalgar House raised chief executive Eric Parker's salary by 62.7 per cent to &pound;480,000 and chairman Sir Nigel Broackes' by 37.6 per cent to &pound;300,000. 
 Kwik Save, the supermarket group, gave retiring chairman Ian Howe a 43 per cent rise to &pound;187,000. 
 Magnet restructure. 
 Magnet, the troubled kitchen and DIY retailer, is expected to announce a financial restructuring today including extended interest and capital repayments on &pound;562million of debt incurred by the &pound;630million management buy-out. 
 Charge dismissed. 
 The Stock Exchange has dismissed a disciplinary charge against market makers Smith New Court which arose when it carried out an &pound;80million &bquo;programme trade&equo; for fund managers Ivory&amp;Sime a year ago. 
 Unit trust boost. 
 Net new investment in unit trusts last month was &pound;339.4million, some 30 per cent higher than the monthly average so far this year. 
 Gross sales were the third highest at &pound;960.2million, while repurchases fell by &pound;300 million to &pound;560.8million. 
 Wall St lower. 
 The Dow Jones stock index closed down 7.68 at 2,687.93. 
 Outlook held over. 
 Outlook has been held over because of lack of space. 
 It will return tomorrow with the first in the annual series of company performance league tables. 
 British Land drops &pound;1.8bn break-up plan. 
 By James Morrow 
 JOHN Ritblat's controversial plans for the break-up of British Land's &pound;1.8billion of assets have been withdrawn after strong institutional pressure. 
 Several leading City investors had opposed the proposals to dismantle British Land by selling off the larger properties and putting the smaller ones into a newly formed group, New British Land. 
 Shareholders were to get shares in the new company and a series of cash pay-outs as the various properties were sold off. 
 John Ritblat, chairman of British Land, said: &bquo;The proposals, now withdrawn, represented a major innovation by the board and its advisers. 
 Having had the benefit of extensive discussions with many of our large shareholders it became clear that the proposals in their entirety did not have support although many features won warm approval.&equo; 
 Major institutional investors felt the deal gave too much to Mr Ritblat, his family and British Land management &mdash; New British Land was to be paid &pound;15million a year in management charges for the first three years, coming down to &pound;10million as properties were sold. 
 One City analyst said he thought Mr Ritblat would not be deterred by &bquo;a little setback&equo; and that the original offer was not too bad being a tax-efficient distribution of British Land assets to shareholders. 
 It is thought that merchant bank Warburg, adviser to British Land, will work on a new scheme to distribute more to shareholders. 
 Panama thrusts Third World back on to centre stage Notebook. 
 By Edited by Alex Brummer 
 THE United States invasion of Panama has instantly diverted global attention from Eastern Europe to Latin America. 
 Last week it was the Deutschmark which was everybody's darling, now it is the dollar and oil prices. 
 What is most interesting, however, is that after a long famine, Latin America and its political and economic uncertainties have been thrust back on to centre stage. 
 Despite the US decision to lift economic sanctions in the hope of giving the newly installed government of President Guillermo Endara a chance, Panama, like much of Latin American and Africa, remains deeply in debt. 
 As the focus of the Bretton Woods institutions has moved across the Atlantic to central Europe deep-seated fears have arisen that time, resources and energy will be diverted from the economies of the southern hemisphere. 
 Although the Brady debt initiative has gone some way to potentially alleviating the debt problems of Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, Mexico and Uruguay &mdash; those countries which have made serious adjustments &mdash; two of the biggest debtors, Brazil and Argentina, remain outside the ring. 
 As the World Bank noted in its debt tables released this week: &bquo;The large foreign debt burden, in conjunction with domestic fiscal crises, continues to feed uncertainties regarding long-term investment and represents a drain on resources.&equo; 
 Despite debt relief in almost every category, Latin American and Caribbean overdrafts climbed in 1989 to an overall &dollar;434billion, according to World Bank projections. 
 It is not just the Latin American economies which are hurting. 
 A plaintive cry from the Organisation of Africa Unity will largely go unheard in the world's chanceries. 
 The OAU stated publicly what has been the worry among many developing countries: it welcomed rapprochement between East and West but warned that funds which might have helped alleviate poverty in Africa may be diverted to central Europe. 
 Africa emerges from the eighties worse off in living standards, education and health services, agriculture, mining, industry, inflation and balance of payments. 
 Debt has jumped fivefold. 
 Such figures underline how important it is not to forget the North-South divide amid the dust thrown up by the Eastern Europe upheaval. 
 Shabby treatment. 
 THE Department of Trade may have been slow to acknowledge financial &mdash; though not supervisory &mdash; responsibility for the victims of Barlow Clowes. 
 But spare a thought for the Isle of Man Government's treatment of depositors in the Savings and Investment Bank. 
 Next summer will be the eighth anniversary of the &pound;42 million collapse, but the Manx Government has fought claims for compensation every step of the way. 
 Two key reports have remained secret. 
 The first, by a Bank of England official, must be presumed to have been highly critical because it led to drastic reform of the island's supervisory procedures. 
 The second report by a banking inspector has also been kept under wraps. 
 But the Manx courts have now agreed that copies may be made available to defendants in a criminal case to be heard next year against eight people involved in the Savings&amp;Investment collapse. 
 This has led to cracks in the wall of secrecy surrounding the government's role in the events leading up to the bank's collapse in 1982. 
 Documents from the report have begun to circulate on the island. 
 Those seen so far by the Guardian are highly unflattering. 
 There is even a suggestion of official encouragement to depositors to use the Manx bank shortly before it went bust. 
 The appointment yesterday of a new Manx Treasury minister, Mr Donald Gelling, at least gives the island the opportunity to make amends for its shabby treatment of the Saving&amp;Investment Bank's victims. 
 The money should be paid back with interest. 
 Conflict of interest. 
 IT IS sometimes difficult to remember that company directors are merely the custodians of their shareholders' money, rather than the owners of the business free to do with it what they will. 
 While the latter is the practical reality in many cases it is certainly not the legal position. 
 And the Companies Acts stand to remind directors of their responsibilities. 
 Grey areas still remain, however, and the Takeover Panel has now attempted to clear one of those concerned with the current fashion for buy-outs. 
 The trouble is that directors involved in buying the company from existing shareholders clearly face a conflict between their own interests (as buyers) and their shareholders' interests (as sellers). 
 The Panel, and the Institutional Shareholders Committee which has been worried about this conflict, say there is no problem with traditional buy-outs of subsidiary companies. 
 That may be too optimistic, since directors facing competing offers might well be influenced by the fact that one offer comes from their mates. 
 Their main concern is with buy-outs of complete listed companies &mdash; such as Magnet, Virgin and International Leisure. 
 The Panel has introduced new rules trying to make sure that shareholders do not sell out too cheaply due to lack of independent advice and information. 
 That is not easy, since the directors engaged in buying the company clearly have more information than anybody else. 
 But the new rules require any directors not involved in the buy-out to obtain independent advice. 
 And to provide the same information to shareholders and competitive bidders as they provide to the banks which are coming up with the funding. 
 Of course, as the ISC says, if there are no independent directors it is rather more difficult for shareholders to get an independent view of the directors' offer. 
 But even in those circumstances the new rules hopefully should make sure that it is more difficult for managements to buy companies on the cheap from under the noses of their shareholders. 
 Freeing credit: the sting in the tail? 
 Economics. 
 By Christopher Huhne 
 LIBERALISATION has been one of the key concepts of eighties' economics, a word which has acquired such power in Anglo-Saxon officialdom that there is virtually no argument about its virtues. 
 A consequence of this unquestioning enthusiasm is that the implications of change have not been thought through, and may yet have a sting or two in the tail. 
 Much of the nineties will be about clearing up the fall-out of the liberal eighties. 
 This is not a reference to problems such as the environment, about which there is a consensus. 
 It strikes deeper than that. 
 Although deregulation in the markets for products, services and labour has brought benefits in the form of more choice and lower prices, the liberalisation of financial markets may leave a less happy legacy. 
 Governments have already decided that they cannot accept a free currency market. 
 A question for the nineties will be whether credit markets are any different. 
 One problem is whether companies will be able to bear the debt burdens heaped on them by leveraged buy-outs, particularly in the United States. 
 But an equally significant problem may well be the behaviour of the personal sector &mdash; people. 
 Most people's savings are contractual, through pension funds and life assurers. 
 They vary the actual level of their net savings through their borrowing. 
 Because borrowing has become easier, and because confidence has been high, personal savings have been falling around the developed world. 
 This phenomenon has been particularly acute in the three Anglo-Saxon countries where liberalisation has moved fastest: Britain, Australia and the United States. 
 It has landed all of them with serious stabilisation problems. 
 Their balance of payments deficits have been alarmingly large, and their currencies have dropped sharply, aggravating their inflationary problems. 
 Indeed, it is arguable that the different speeds of financial liberalisation are a prime cause of world trade and savings imbalances. 
 Take Britain. 
 The extraordinary 19 per cent rise in real consumers' spending between 1985 and 1988 was mainly due to the real wage rise of 14.1 per cent. 
 But it was the rise over and above the increase in real incomes which caused most grief for inflation and the payments balance. 
 We borrowed and spent far more. 
 The biggest influence on this behaviour has probably been the large increase in wealth, which in turn boils down to the sharp rise in house prices. 
 The average house price, according to the Halifax sample, was &pound;30,952 in 1984 and is now &pound;60,837. 
 It is not surprising that many people, some of whom may have seen the equity in their homes rise tenfold, should decide to spend more. 
 This is what the graph shows. 
 One line shows what has happened to personal wealth divided by personal income: if wealth merely rose in line with incomes (which would be represented by a flat wealth line on the graph), the theory would suggest that it would not have any independent influence on savings. 
 The rise means that wealth has been increasing faster than incomes. 
 The second line shows the fall in the savings ratio. 
 In order to highlight the way in which the rise in wealth and the fall in savings have moved together, the axis showing the savings ratio is inverted: a lower savings rate is represented by a rise in the line on the graph. 
 So far, so good. 
 Clearly, wealth has recently moved in tandem with the savings ratio. 
 But does financial liberalisation cause the wealth increase? 
 Some analysts argue that the rise in wealth and the fall in savings are both caused by a third factor: people's belief that their incomes will grow more rapidly in future. 
 Understandably, people want to borrow more today in order to spend on houses (thus boosting prices) and on other goods. 
 This may be part of the explanation in Britain, where there has been some improvement in the potential of the economy. 
 It seems less plausible in the United States, where productivity growth has slowed down and foreigners' have built up large claims on US output. 
 Yet almost exactly the same phenomenon of rising wealth matched by falling savings has been occurring in the US, as the second graph shows. 
 It is, of course, possible that factors specific to both economies account for the same movement. 
 But it seems more plausible to highlight the financial market liberalisation which has taken place in both economies. 
 The key point is that the old, regulated financial systems stopped people from borrowing as much as they wanted at a given level of interest rates. 
 When the constraints eased under the pressure of fresh competition, people were able to borrow what they were previously prevented from borrowing. 
 Some bought more houses, pushing up prices. 
 Those who did not want to buy a bigger or better house were able to borrow more to extract equity from their fast-appreciating assets. 
 The liberalisation thus boosted both house prices and consumption. 
 In Britain, the key change was the removal of the &bquo;corset&equo; on banks in 1980. 
 After 1982, the Third World debt crisis also turned banks towards the home market in the search for creditworthy borrowers. 
 The result was a sharp rise in mortgage lending by banks, competition which scared the building societies into relaxing their traditional rules of thumb. 
 The institutions are now prepared to lend larger multiples of income, and higher proportions of the purchase price. 
 How much was the liberalisation worth on house prices? 
 In other words, how many people were constrained by credit rationing? 
 The question is important because it gives some clue as to the likely rise in the long-run house price to income ratio (because demand for housing has shifted upwards, while supply remains relatively constant). 
 This in turn gives us a clue as to whether the &bquo;feelgood&equo; aura from rising house prices is likely to be reversed quickly. 
 There are, as yet, no estimates based on hard research but some back-of-the-envelope guesses have been made by David Miles, a former Bank of England economist now at Birkbeck (1). 
 The essential point is that real interest rates effectively determine the cost of housing to the homebuyer. 
 The lower the interest rate when credit is liberalised, the higher the rise in demand for (and price of) housing. 
 Mr Miles reckons that the house price rise needed to clear the market &mdash; to balance demand and supply &mdash; could be 45 per cent if real mortgage rates are a low 3 per cent. 
 By contrast, the removal of credit rationing would boost prices by only some 4.5 per cent if real mortgage rates were as high as 10 per cent. 
 The real mortgage rate is currently a relatively high 7 per cent, implying prices 10.5 per cent higher than under rationing. 
 With real mortgage rates on extra borrowing normally between 4 and 5 per cent, it is quite plausible that about a quarter to a third of the value of housing equity &mdash; estimated at &pound;830billion at end-1987 &mdash; could be due to deregulation. 
 Clearly, liberalisation is a crucial factor explaining both the rise in house prices and in wealth, and the increase in consumers' spending, inflation and the balance of payments deficit. 
 In the United States, a similar shift from credit-rationing to price-rationing also took place between the seventies and eighties. 
 A recent OECD study (2) shows that households also benefited from innovations such as the securitisation of mortgage debt &mdash; making mortgages tradeable between lenders, so that the institution which originally lent the money might sell its mortgage claim to another bank or thrift when it needed cash. 
 This in turn attracted more lenders into the market, and made borrowing more attractive. 
 Liberalisation also gave US consumers a new deal by cutting the cost of car credit. 
 The spread &mdash; the banks' profit margin over its cost of funds &mdash; charged on auto loans dropped by 4 percentage points and consumers had longer to pay. 
 Monthly car payments declined by about 40 per cent, the OECD notes. 
 It is by no means clear that the process of financial innovation has run its course. 
 High interest rates, themselves necessary to hold spending within non-inflationary bounds because of the liberalisation, may put the process into reverse for a while. 
 But what will happen to the housing market and consumers' spending when, for example, the lenders increasingly introduce shared equity loans, widening the housing market to a new range of low income buyers? 
 Either the more prudential economies like West Germany and Japan will have to de-regulate &mdash; at the cost of still higher real interest rates &mdash; or the liberals will have to re-regulate in order to avoid macro-economic retribution. 
 But it is a fair bet that, during the nineties, something will have to give. 
 (1) David Miles &bquo;Financial liberalisation, the housing market and the current account&equo;, Birkbeck, mimeo, September 1989. (2) &bquo;United States: OECD economic survey 1987-8&equo; Paris, 1988. 
 Beecham sells UHU for &pound;97m. 
 SmithKline Beecham is selling its German-based UHU adhesive business to HSG-Vermogensverwaltungs GmbH of Frankfurt for &pound;97.5million, of which &pound;91million will be paid in cash. 
 Beecham bought UHU &mdash; which sells its products in 50 countries &mdash; in 1970. 
 SmithKline Beecham is to continue the manufacture of Badedas and Duschdas shower gel at the same West German plant at which UHU is made. 
 The move completes SmithKline Beecham's withdrawal from the home improvement business, begun by Beecham with a series of disposals in 1986 and 1987. 
 Since the merger of Beecham with SmithKline Beckman last summer, the group has emphasised its health care business. 
 It is keen to cut its gearing from over 200 per cent. 
 Boost for Batleys' hopes. 
 Batleys, the Huddersfield-based cash and carry wholesaler, whose controlling family shareholders are considering whether to buy out minority holders after about 17 years on the stock market, has reported a good interim profit. 
 Stock gains and the absence of new opening costs are behind the rebound, which spurred the shares to a new peak. 
 Discussions about the chairman's bid approach, announced on November 3, are continuing. 
 Sales jumped by &pound;26million to &pound;181million largely as a result of inflationary price rises by suppliers. 
 There were no new openings in Scotland or the north of England, where the main urban areas are supplied and interest charges were almost steady at &pound;528,000. 
 Pre-tax profit, therefore, jumped back to &pound;2million, from &pound;521,000. 
 The interim dividend stays at 0.5p, though earnings leapt to almost 10p. 
 The shares soared l2p to 143p on hopes of a generous buy-out price. 
 Switched-on Yorkshire. 
 Yorkshire Radio raised pre-tax profits by 76 per cent to &pound;1.4million in the year to September on turnover up 56per cent at &pound;6.8million. 
 Yorkshire was floated on the Unlisted Securities Market in August and the chairman, Michael Mallett, says the recent &bquo;heady growth&equo; in revenue is slackening as the squeeze on retail sales tightens. 
 But unlike other UK radio companies, Yorkshire has engineering interests and a South East Asian cable broadcasting company based in Singapore, where Mr Mallet says opportunities are &bquo;virtually unlimited&equo; to cushion the impact of the slump in UK consumer spending. 
 In the Yorkshire Radio area, where the company's broadcasts are aimed at the under-35s, listening figures rose 32 per cent to 13.85 hours a week over the year. 
 In short&hellip; 
 ROSEHAUGH shares jumped 5per cent to 494p yesterday on news that BPC Associates, a partnership affiliated with JMB Realty of Chicago, had bought a near 5 per cent stake. 
 It is not expected that a bid will follow. 
 BLUEBIRD TOYS saw brokers downgrade profit forecasts for the group from &pound;3million to &pound;2million against &pound;2.3million a year ago after &pound;1million of orders failed to come through. 
 The shares dropped 17 per cent to 150p. 
 AMI HEALTHCARE, the private hospitals group, raised pre-tax profits by 15 per cent to &pound;6.6million in the three months to the end of November. 
 Turnover was 12 per cent higher at &pound;36.3million, showing profit margins at almost 19 per cent. 
 The group maintains that average in-patient charges have risen by only 8 per cent. 
 Out-patient visits were 8 per cent higher than the previous year. 
 The markets. 
 Gilts rose half a point as the prospect for interest rates continued to brighten, while a broadly-based advance in equities took the FTSE 100 index up 18.6 points to 2,360.7. 
 Insurances, both lifes and composites, led the way on renewed takeover talk. 
 Textiles had a late flat spot in Tootal, 12p down at 99p, as the company ended its bid talks with Coats Viyella, 4p lower at 136p. 
 Some stores were bright on reports of an eleventh-hour Christmas buying spree. 
 Hong Kong: Steady in moderate trading. 
 Hang Seng Index: 2,868.49 (2,879.42). 
 Tokyo: Closed mixed. 
 Nikkei Index: 38,512.00 (38,439.10). 
 Frankfurt: Shares extended rally. 
 FAZ Index: 700.70 (688.47). 
 Paris: Stocks closed higher in moderate trading. 
 CAC Index: 538.7 (538.7). 
 Agreement on pan-European code delayed. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 AGREEMENT on a long-awaited pan-European takeover and mergers code is being held up by West Germany, consumer affairs minister, John Redwood, claimed yesterday. 
 He claimed that Britain and other leading European powers are at odds with the Germans over crucial aspects of the European Commission code on community take-overs. 
 &bquo;The other member states regard Germany as quite isolated.&equo; 
 With no immediate compromise in sight, Mr Redwood refused to speculate on when the directive will come into force. 
 Merger policy is on the agenda of today's Brussels meeting of the Internal Market Council. 
 Discussions are being held up by Germany's insistance on the involvement of a national body to help decide on any major takeover. 
 Britain and other EC partners argue that this policy defeats the point of a unified EC take-over code. 
 Mr Redwood described the German move as setting up a &bquo;two stop merger policy&equo;. 
 Other stumbling blocks include differences in the regulations of individual stock exchanges on voting rights of shares in take-over targets. 
 Germany has also resisted the setting up of a unified life assurance market. 
 &bquo;They are very reluctant to see brokers included in the remit. 
 We'll have to decide what compromise we can agree on. 
 We are desperate to see some progress,&equo; he said. 
 East German industrial output dips. 
 By Reuter in East Berlin 
 EAST Germany's industrial production dropped last month and the number of unfulfilled output targets has more than doubled, worsening consumer shortages and hurting export commitments. 
 The Communist Party daily Neues Deutschland gave a dismal report on the economy yesterday, against the backdrop of a visit by West German Chancellor Helmut Kohl for talks focusing on emergency aid for East Germany. 
 Industrial output dropped 2.5 per cent last month from the corresponding period last year, Neues Deutschland said. 
 It linked the poor performance with the exodus to the West of more than 330,000 East Germans disgruntled with Communism. 
 This had reduced the workforce by 53,800, or 2 per cent, from last year, strapping many key industries. 
 Of the 383 state production plans, 148 had been unable to meet their target &mdash; more than double the previous figure of 65. 
 This increased consumer good shortages and hampered fulfillment of export commitments, the paper said. 
 Consumer goods worst affected by production and supply bottlenecks included car tyres, high-tension electrical switches, spare parts for agricultural machinery and telecommunications equipment. 
 East Germany also fell far short of targets for residential construction despite stepped-up efforts to rectify a longtime housing shortage. 
 Builders were 7,921 units behind the 1989 plan as of the end of November. 
 PAGE 
 Ferranti trustees threaten legal action. 
 By Mark Milner 
 FERRANTI International, the troubled defence electronics combine, could face a legal challenge from the trustees of the estate of its founder over a report into frauds totalling &pound;215million. 
 At the annual general meeting of the company yesterday, Mr Ian Mackeson-Sandbach, a trustee and executive of the estate of the late Sir Basil de Ferranti, called on the board to publish the investigation findings of accountants Coopers &amp; Lybrand into the frauds at ISC Technologies, part of Ferranti's US subsidiary. 
 When his call was refused by Sir Derek Alun-Jones, the chairman, on the grounds that it was likely to form the basis of future litigation, Mr Mackeson-Sandbach said the trustees would be seeking &bquo;legal advice on the means open to them to examine this report&equo;. 
 Mr Mackeson-Sandbach also called for the board to be strengthened, a demand subsequently reinforced by one of Sir Basil's sons, Mr Adrian de Ferranti. 
 The trustee was later one of a handful of shareholders to vote against the re-election of Sir John Hoskyns to the board. 
 The meeting comes after months of turmoil at Ferranti, from the discovery of a series of bogus contracts at the International Signal subsidiary, most of which were committed before it was bought by Ferranti in 1987. 
 As a result Ferranti had to write off &pound;215million, reissue its annual report and negotiate financial support from its bankers. 
 It is also planning a &pound;187million cash call on shareholders early next year, unless a bid for the company emerges in the meantime, though that now looks unlikely. 
 The group has issued a series of writs against several former ISC employees, including Mr James Guerin, the head of the company at the time of the merger with Ferranti. 
 He became deputy chairman of the merged business. 
 Yesterday's meeting, which saw the group change its name from Ferranti International Signal to Ferranti International, also approved changes in its articles designed to prevent it breaching borrowing powers as a result of the decimation of its equity base by the &pound;215million write-off. 
 Sir Derek came under fire from several shareholders. 
 One asked why directors responsible for the ISC acquisition were still on the board. 
 In reply, Sir Derek said that though he could not speak for other directors, &bquo;my resignation has been available to the board from the day all this started. 
 It will remain available and can be used at any time the board thinks appropriate.&equo; 
 DTI sinks Sealink, P&amp;O cartel plan. 
 By Daniel John 
 APLAN by cross-Channel ferry rivals Sealink and P&amp;O to operate a joint service to combat the threat of the fixed tunnel link was blocked by the Monopolies and Mergers Commission yesterday on anti-competition grounds. 
 The companies had sought to merge their fleets on the currently lucrative Dover, Folkestone and Ramsgate routes to France which would have fixed prices at one level and allowed them to operate a single timetable. 
 The proposal, unveiled in April, was initially investigated by the Office of Fair Trading and then referred to the MMC three months later for a more detailed probe. 
 In its report, the MMC ruled that the price-fixing cartel may be expected to operate against the public interest and should be blocked. 
 Its recommendation was accepted by Nicholas Ridley, the Trade and Industry Secretary, who said his prime concern was to ensure &bquo;effective competition&equo;. 
 Mr Ridley said: &bquo;It is clear from the MMC's report that this proposal would have reduced competition in the period before the tunnel is operational (in 1993). 
 I also accept the Commission's view that any joint service intended as more effective competition would not need to be introduced so far in advance of the tunnel's opening.&equo; 
 The decision was particularly sensitive for the Government as P&amp;O's chairman, Sir Jeffrey Sterling, is a special adviser to the DTI &mdash; a post he has held since 1983. 
 A favourable decision would have almost certainly provoked parliamentary uproar given Sir Jeffrey's position and the time lag between the formation of the joint service and the tunnel's opening. 
 P&amp;O European Ferries described the DTI's decision as surprising. 
 &bquo;However, it does not alter our stated objective to provide a first rate competitive alternative service to the tunnel,&equo; said a spokeswoman. 
 Disappointment was also the reaction of Sealink British Ferries, whose parent company Sea Containers is currently fighting a &dollar;1.036 billion bid from Temple Holdings which would involve the UK ferry business ending up in Swedish hands if it succeeds. 
 Sealink disagreed with the MMC's findings that reduced choice, higher fares and a poorer quality service would result in the pooled operation before the tunnel's opening. 
 &bquo;The ferry operators undertook not to reduce services or increase fares by more than inflation during this period.&equo; 
 The company said the MMC's view that ferry prices may rise post-tunnel appeared to take into account the higher cost of building the link, now set at more than &pound;7 billion. 
 &bquo;Sealink shares the view that scope for higher fares may now be greater but the economies of pooling would enable the ferries to offer a superior, uniform product and have a better chance of survival if the tunnel competition proves to be severe.&equo; 
 The two companies had sought to have withdrawn undertakings given to the MMC 15 years ago when it last investigated their grip on cross-Channel routes. 
 Sealink and P&amp;O are estimated to have 80 per cent of the market and the undertakings barred them from pooling their services. 
 Mr Ridley said it would be open to the companies to approach th OFT again closer to the opening of the tunnel. 
 &bquo;I will have regard to how vigorous competition with the tunnel can be best assured as well as with how well the current competitive arrangments have operated,&equo; he said. 
 However, Sealink considered that the effect of the MMC's decision could result in a pooling service operating anyway following the link's opening, though it would have to comply with UK and European Commission competition law. 
 Warning over inflation battle. 
 By Larry Elliott Economics Correspondent 
 THE GOVERNMENT was warned yesterday that a heavy-handed approach to curbing inflation could jeopardise Britain's chances of exploiting the opportunities provided by the creation of a barrier-free Europe in 1992. 
 The message from the influential backbench Treasury and Civil Service Committee came as the latest official figures provided further evidence of the economy grinding to a halt. 
 According to the Central Statistical Office, gross domestic product rose by 0.5 per cent in the third quarter of this year, but almost all the increase resulted from the recovery in North Sea oil production after the series of pipeline accidents in 1988 and early 1989. 
 Essentially, the economy was flat over the past six months, with the annual growth rate in the year to the third quarter 1.9 per cent, compared with 2.7 per cent in the year to the second quarter and 4.1 per cent at this time last year. 
 Meanwhile, money supply figures from the Bank of England showed that borrowing increased by &pound;4.9 billion in November, the smallest monthly rise since February 1988. 
 In September, bank lending rose by more than &pound;10 billion, but this fell to &pound;5.2 billion in October. 
 Mr John Shepperd, analyst with Warburg Securities said firms may have started to destock rather than continue borrowing at high rates of interest. 
 That would cause a sharp slowdown in the economy next year, but could also herald an improvement in the UK's record trade deficit. 
 &bquo;The feeling in the market is that there could be a good trade figure in store,&equo; Mr Shepperd said. 
 The considerable scope for destocking &mdash; the main cause of the recession of the early 1980s &mdash; was highlighted by the CSO, which said industry had been building up inventories of unsold goods for two years. 
 Officials estimate that supply has exceeded demand by &pound;7.5 billion since the beginning of 1988. 
 Although the economy grew by 2 per cent over the year to September, the drain caused by the deterioration in the current account meant national wealth increased by only &frac12;per cent. 
 After increasing by 9 per cent in 1989, manufacturing investment is expected to rise by just 1 per cent next year as firms lower their growth expectations in the light of high interest rates and muted consumer demand, according to the CSO's investment intentions survey. 
 The Government's main fear for the coming year is that the economy will enter a period of stagflation, with minimal growth combined with stubborn inflationary pressures. 
 In its report on Nigel Lawson's last Budget earlier this year, the TCSC said the Chancellor was walking a tightrope, with inflation on one side and recession on the other. 
 It said yesterday that Mr Major remained in the same predicament as his predecessor. 
 One important element of inflationary pressure &mdash; the level of wage settlements &mdash; has shown no signs of abating in recent months, according to the Confederation of British Industry's pay databank. 
 Deals in manufacturing industry struck in the third quarter averaged 8.3 per cent, up from 7.6 per cent in the second quarter. 
 The TCSC was sceptical about the Treasury's forecast of inflation dropping to 3 per cent by 1992 given that official predictions have been wrong so often in the past. 
 &bquo;Repetition in the face of failure has not added credibility to this forecast,&equo; the report noted drily. 
 It added that control of inflation was necessary, but it was important that &bquo;a reduction of a few percentage points in the headline inflation rate should not be achieved at a disproportionate cost in terms of income creation and employment&equo;. 
 NatWest rap for DTI investigators. 
 By Peter Rodgers City Editor 
 DEPARTMENT of Trade inspectors should not pass judgments on individuals, NatWest chairman Lord Alexander yesterday told a Commons trade and industry committee hearing. 
 Instead their reports should stick to investigating and reporting the facts, he told the MPs' inquiry into the methods of company investigations. 
 Conclusions about criminal or other responsibility should be left to the police or regulatory bodies such as the Bank of England to decide. 
 Speaking from NatWest's experience of the DTI report on its role in Blue Arrow's rights issue, Lord Alexander said: &bquo;I find it a simply awful process that people of 40 years&equo; experience should have to resign on the basis of judgments in the report without having the opportunity of going through the regulatory process that you in Parliament provided.&equo; 
 It was, he said, &bquo;more Draconian than any deselection committee&equo;, affecting people's future in what he saw as a &bquo;most sad process&equo;. 
 Careers could be destroyed without any adequate appeal. 
 Technically, judicial review was available, but it was rarely used. 
 Three NatWest executive directors resigned after being criticised in the inspectors' report. 
 Since then, six NatWest executives including two explicitly cleared by the inspectors have been charged with fraud. 
 But the three directors who resigned have not been charged. 
 NatWest's evidence to the committee, signed by Lord Alexander and his chief executive Tom Frost, says inspectors should &bquo;complete their inquiries independently, indicating what are their findings of fact, but not pass judgment by drawing conclusions&equo;. 
 Lord Alexander told MPs that inspectors should record where facts are in dispute, whatever their own views. 
 They should also give everybody named in the report an opportunity to respond, rather than the current practice of approaching only those criticised. 
 People criticised should be given drafts of all references to them, including the evidence cited. 
 He also urged speed and independence and said there should only be administrative contact between inspectors and DTI officials during an investigation. 
 Any other questions should be dealt with at ministerial level. 
 There may have been press briefings by regulatory bodies during and after the Blue Arrow inquiry which he said called into question their impartiality. 
 Endara's belated rise to power comes as mixed blessing. 
 By Simon Tisdall in Washington 
 THE man who took office as President of Panama early yesterday morning was popularly elected last spring but had to wait more than six months before being thrust into power by the United States. 
 Although most Panamanians will welcome the departure of General Noriega, the fact that their new President was sworn in by a US army general at a US army base is likely to colour perceptions of the new government. 
 Mr Guillermo Endara, leader of the Civic Democratic Opposition Alliance, (Adoc), won the May 7 presidential elections by a margin of three-to-one over Mr Carlos Duque, the head of the Noriega-approved National Liberation Coalition (Colina), according to US and independent observers. 
 Mr Endara, aged 53, is a labour lawyer who served as an aide to the former President, Mr Arnulfo Arias Madrid. 
 Three days after the poll, Gen Noriega annulled the elections. 
 A post-election attack on an opposition motorcade protesting against election fraud by paramilitaries and Panama Defence Forces (PDF) troops put Mr Endara in hospital, after he was clubbed with an iron bar. 
 Mr Guillermo &bquo;Billy&equo; Ford, a vice-presidential Adoc candidate, was also severely bloodied and beaten even as the other Adoc leader, Mr Ricardo Arias Calderon, condemned the cancellation of the poll as &bquo;an unbearable mockery of the will of the Panamanian people&equo;. 
 The fraudulent conduct of the poll, and the subsequent annullment, was deplored by the former President, Mr Jimmy Carter. 
 But the US appeared powerless to intervene as Gen Noriega persisted in the harassment and arrest of his opponents and the continued muzzling of the media. 
 Mr Ford and Mr Arias Calderon subsequently left Panama and last summer, Mr Ford visited Mrs Thatcher at Downing Street. 
 In an interview last October, conducted in the Adoc offices in Panama City as armed pro-Noriega thugs paraded outside, Mr Endara said: &bquo;I will be arrested again. 
 They can arrest me, they can do anything they want&hellip; but what does this man (Noriega) want? 
 He cannot arrest everybody.&equo; 
 Shortly after the interview, paramilitaries raided the Adoc offices and Mr Endara was forced to flee by taxi, taking refuge at the Vatican embassy. 
 Mr Endara and Adoc campaigned in the May elections on a straightforward anti-Noriega platform, pledging to renew democratic institutions, purge the armed forces of corrupt elements (a reference to the involvement of the PDF in drug trafficking) and restore Panama's economic fortunes through a free market system. 
 Central to this last promise was a US agreement to end the economic sanctions imposed on the Noriega regime, should the opposition win. 
 But US support for Adoc was a mixed blessing, given the history of US intervention in Panama and the passionate determination of Panamanians to achieve soberania total &mdash; complete sovereignty &mdash; over the Panama Canal by 2000, as agreed with the US in 1977. 
 Mr Endara was moved to distance himself from proposals in Washington to support anti-Noriega parties with CIA funds, describing the scheme as &bquo;insulting&equo;. 
 The opposition also denied US news reports that Washington had contributed &dollar;10 million to his election campaign. 
 Mr Endara also rejected the use of force by the US as a means of resolving the situation, urging that solutions be sought through the Organisation of American States and the United Nations. 
 President Endara's first task will be to appoint a cabinet and dissolve the absurd, rubber-stamp National Assembly which last week issued the fateful declaration of war against the US. 
 He will be assisted by the lifting of US sanctions and the unfreezing of Panamanian assets held in the US. 
 But obvious problems will centre on the security situation, and the reconstruction of the defence forces and the economy. 
 Mr Endara, like it or not, is likely to be leaning fairly heavily on the US for some time to come. 
 Grenada PM sworn in. 
 By Greg Chamberlain 
 BEN Jones, an elderly lawyer and nutmeg farmer, has been sworn in as Grenada's prime minister after the death of Herbert Blaize, who had ruled the southern Caribbean spice island since the withdrawal of US invasion troops five years ago. 
 Mr Jones, long Blaize's self-effacing righthand man, is expected to call a general election, which is constitutionally due within three months. 
 The conservative Blaize, who died of prostate cancer and had been confined to a wheelchair for the past year, lost his parliamentary majority five months ago but had clung to office despite opposition protests. 
 The Governor-General, Sir Paul Scoon, broadcast an appeal for calm to the country's 103,000 people. 
 He appointed Mr Jones because the opposition, which has a three-seat majority in the 15-member parliament, is divided. 
 Blaize had been deposed as leader of the New National Party which he led to a landslide electoral victory under US auspices in 1984 and had defiantly formed a new grouping. 
 A lawyer and former oilfield worker, he was head of government for nine years in the 1950s and 1960s under British colonial rule before being beaten at the polls by a charismatic rival, Mr Eric Gairy. 
 He was brought out of retirement after US troops invaded Grenada in 1983 and overthrew the island's Marxist government. 
 The US and other Caribbean leaders persuaded squabbling Grenadian politicians to accept him as a compromise to prevent an electoral comeback by Mr Gairy. 
 But his government coalition soon fell apart. 
 Most leading ministers resigned, complaining of his dictatorial behaviour, and now form the parliamentary opposition. 
 The National Democratic Congress party, which has six seats and is headed by Mr Nicholas Brathwaite, is tipped to win the general election. 
 Behind Mr Brathwaite, an elderly teacher who chaired the interim government installed by the invasion forces, are two of the island's most influential politicians, Mr Francis Alexis and Mr George Brizan, whose disagreement led to the original choice of Blaize in 1984. 
 Two weeks ago, the island was paralysed by a strike of government workers, who accused Blaize of breaking his promise to hand over more than &pound;2 million in back pay. 
 Obituary, page 33 
 Lurking threat of the jean-clad Dignity battalions. 
 By Simon Tisdall in Washington 
 ONE of the many weapons of control &mdash; and one of the most intimidating &mdash; employed by the General Noriega was the civil militia known as the Dignity Battalions. 
 Composed of sympathisers, spies and informers of the regime, the Battalions are made up of men, mostly in their late teens and 20s, who cruised the streets of Panama City in trucks and open Jeeps, armed with clubs, rubber truncheons (akin to South African sjamboks), knives and hand-guns. 
 Members wear no uniform other than the paramilitary garb &mdash; a mixture of jeans, leather jackets, and army fatigues &mdash; familiar throughout Central America. 
 Contacted by telephone early yesterday when fighting was still under way, a young American couple told of how they crouched on the floor of their appartment, armed with their own guns, terrified that reports of the Battalions roaming suburban areas would mean the thugs appearing at their door. 
 Luckily for the couple, the Battalions did not come their way. 
 Seemingly other foreigners &mdash; principally Americans &mdash; were less fortunate, as local news media reported kidnappings and hostage-taking. 
 While pro-Noriega units of the Panamanian Defence Forces might indulge in such abuses, the most likely culprits were the Battalions. 
 And the Battalions, as they drop from sight, may pose one of the most serious threats to the new government of Guillermo Endara. 
 David Fairhall adds: The regular Panamanian forces, not all of whom opposed the American intervention according to the Pentagon, were vastly outnumbered by US troops. 
 Excluding the para-military National Guard, they number only 4,400, whereas the normal US garrison of about 10,000 men had already been augmented to 13,000 before airborne units parachuted in to secure the international airport and clear the way for further reinforcements. 
 The Americans finally assembled a combined total of 24,000 men. 
 If the immediate military objectives were to seize Noriega and paralyse potential opposition before it could organise, both seem to have failed. 
 But the use of overwhelming numbers, if not of overwhelming force, was clearly a good way to start. 
 The Panamanian army can only muster 3,500 volunteers, lightly equipped with armoured vehicles, mortars and rocket launchers. 
 It has a couple of fully formed battalions, the rest organised in indiviudal companies, two of which are devoted to maintaining public order. 
 The Panamanian air force was in no position to oppose the intervention, whatever its political leanings. 
 It has only four combat aircraft &mdash; armed maritime reconnaissance aircraft &mdash; and no armed helicopters.The navy's main force consists of half a dozen inshore patrol craft. 
 The problem for the US troops, as in the bombing attacks aimed at Colonel Gadafy's Libyan regime, is that there is no such thing as a surgical military strike against targets surrounded by civilians, many of them in this case US citizens. 
 Monroe doctrine lives on as Bush wields big stick. 
 By Mark Tran in Washington 
 PRESIDENT Bush's decision to throw US combat troops against General Noriega shows that the Monroe doctrine is alive and well despite talk of new standards of behaviour from the superpowers. 
 It is a fair bet that the Panama episode will not be the last time that the US will intervene militarily in the region, given the pattern of repeated American meddling in its &bquo;backyard&equo;. 
 The assault on Panama marks the second time in six years that the US has employed its military forces against a country in the hemisphere. 
 In October 1983, President Reagan dispatched an invasion force to Grenada after radical forces overthrew and killed the Prime Minister, Maurice Bishop. 
 The official reason for the invasion was to protect some 600 medical students supposedly endangered by the coup. 
 More likely, the episode was considered an opportunity to rid the island of Cuban influence and a chance to demonstrate US firepower just after 241 troops had been killed in Lebanon. 
 US forces made heavy weather of overcoming 700 Cuban engineers, and the operation exposed glaring shortcomings. 
 Troops had to use 1977 tourist maps that had such points of interest as nutmeg factories instead of the grid coordinates needed in battle. 
 The US finally conquered the island after increasing the invasion force from 1,900 to 6,000. 
 The other manifestation of the Monroe doctrine under the Reagan administration was the US proxy war against the Sandinista government in Nicaragua. 
 President Reagan spent an inordinate time in trying to destabilise the Sandinistas by arming the contra rebels. 
 His venom against a country of 3 million people not only reinforced the Latin American image of the US as a bully, it also led directly to the Iran-contra scandal, the most serious political crisis of his administration. 
 The CIA-backed contra war was an inconsequential affair in world terms, although it brought much destruction and suffering to the Nicaraguans themselves. 
 That could not be said of the Cuban missile crisis which could be seen as President Kennedy's determination to uphold the Monroe doctrine. 
 Kennedy's insistence on keeping Soviet influence out of the Western Hemisphere and miscalculations by both superpowers brought the world to the brink of nuclear conflict in 1962. 
 Following Fidel Castro's seizure of power, Kennedy failed to keep a gung-ho CIA in check, which proceeded with its ill-conceived invasion plans of Cuba. 
 The episode ended in the Bay of Pigs disaster, with Cuban exiles pinned on the beaches cursing the US for failing to provide air cover. 
 In order to reassure Castro of Soviet support Khrushchev began sending nuclear missiles to Cuba, triggering the October crisis. 
 In the Nixon-Kissinger years, while there was no direct military intervention against the democratically-elected Marxist government of Salvador Allende, there was certainly a concerted destabilisation programme which contributed to his fall from power. 
 Set forth in 1823 by President James Monroe, the doctrine's original thrust was designed to keep the Western Hemisphere free from European interference. 
 It evolved, however, into a more robust policy of US intervention under President Teddy Roosevelt. 
 Under the big stick policy, the US sent armed forces into Honduras in 1905, Cuba in 1906, Panama &mdash; the first of four invasions in a decade &mdash; in 1908, Nicaragua in 1912, Haiti in 1914, and the Dominican Republic in 1916. 
 The Dominican Republic got a further dose of American bayonets in 1965, when President Johnson sent the marines to thwart a rebel coup. 
 British passport offer fails to restore Hong Kong confidence on future. 
 By Steve Vines in Hong Kong 
 THE Hong Kong Government yesterday endorsed the British offer to grant 25,000 passports to residents of the colony. 
 A cautious welcome was also given by the colony's business establishment, but it was not shared by many of those who have campaigned for more generous measures to help restore confidence after China's bloody suppression of its democracy movement in June. 
 The Governor, Sir David Wilson, set the tone for the establishment's response, saying the offer &bquo;will be a psychological boost. 
 It will mean that a very substantial number of people who might have left Hong Kong will stay.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;Of course, in an ideal world we should have preferred to have passports for all British nationals in Hong Kong.&equo; 
 Mr Simon Murray, managing director of Hutchison Whampoa, one of the colony's largest companies, and chairman of the Honour Hong Kong campaign which represents leading firms, said: &bquo;Our reaction is one of welcome, we see this as a good way to restore confidence in Hong Kong. 
 &bquo;I'm not saying we're over the moon, but it's a good move.&equo; 
 He did not explain why the campaign had suddenly reversed its recently declared position that passports would be needed for more than 300,000 key wage-earners in the colony as well as their families. 
 That is six times the number to be offered the right of abode in the government's package. 
 A diametrically different view came from a trades-union leader, Mr Lee Chuk-Yan, who said: &bquo;This whole thing of right of abode gives one more choice to people who already have lots of choices. 
 It gives nothing to those who have no choice.&equo; 
 A similar view was expressed by Mr Lee Wing-Tat, the radical local council leader, who made history by heckling the former Foreign Secretary, Sir Geoffrey Howe, at a lunch last July. 
 &bquo; 
 The Hong Kong Chinese are very pragmatic. 
 They won't like this but I don't think they will make a violent reaction,&equo; he said. 
 Most people would think that &bquo;the United Kingdom Government is not taking enough responsibility to protect the people of Hong Kong,&equo; he argued. 
 But would they do anything about it? 
 Mr Lee had his doubts: &bquo;That's life,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Ordinary people don't have a chance to leave.&equo; 
 Mr Lee Chuk-Yan reflected a similar weary resignation: &bquo;We won't bother campaigning, it's a hopeless case,&equo; he said. 
 He believed the offer of passports would &bquo;split the community into those who have passports and those who believe that the British have betrayed them. 
 That's not good for confidence.&equo; 
 This fear was shared by Ms Gladys Li, a lawyer who dazzled the parliamentary foreign-affairs committee with her presentation of the case advanced by the Lobby Group, representing liberal-minded professionals in the territory. 
 She said: &bquo;The message is that the UK government couldn't care less, they are just applying a Band-Aid to a mortal wound.&equo; 
 According to Ms Li: &bquo;Most people are fairly cynical and fairly resigned about the UK Government's attitude to Hong Kong. 
 People don't have much confidence, this is just one more nail in the coffin.&equo; 
 Mr James Tien, a member of the legislative council and a textile manufacturer, said that as an employer he was already experiencing acute shortages of skilled staff. 
 &bquo;We have a confidence problem. 
 In all conscience, I can't tell my staff that everything's all right.&equo; 
 Mr Tien saw the package as damaging the colony's business prospects. 
 &bquo;As an investor, I have to say that this environment does not allow me to put more money into Hong Kong. 
 I don't want to invest in anything where every day I have to worry whether my managers are going to leave me.&equo; 
 What impact the British offer would have on the brain drain, which is expected to push over 10 per cent of the population out of the colony before China's 1997 takeover, was not clear. 
 Ms Li said: &bquo;I don't know if it's possible to have less confidence in the future than people already have, but I'm certain it will decrease confidence in the British Government.&equo; 
 Transylvania clergy take the lead Calvinist pastors are an increasing threat to Ceausescu's domination of the Romanian churches, Ian Traynor writes. 
 THE role of the church in helping to topple the Communist order in Poland and East Germany, compounded by the fact that it was the fate of a Protestant clergyman in Timisoara that triggered the unrest in Romania, has raised the prospect of Romanian churches becoming a focus of political resistance. 
 Observers are quick to point out that the main church, the Romanian Orthodox, is well under the control of the secret service and constitutes no threat to President Nicolae Ceausescu. 
 In the north-west, the seat of the current crisis, the situation is different. 
 In Transylvania, the two million strong Hungarian minority is served by the Catholic and Hungarian Reformed Churches. 
 The pastor, Laszlo Tokes &mdash; reported by Human Rights workers to be in a remote village in the Romanian district of Salaj &mdash; belongs to the latter, Calvinist denomination. 
 He appears to be the standard bearer of a young, more radical generation of clergymen in deep conflict with their elders and increasingly assertive in their defence of religious, cultural and ethnic rights. 
 The Hungarian Reformed Church in Transylvania has about 800,000 members, slightly fewer than the Catholic community. 
 The 680 pastors that serve the region are said to preach to well-attended churches on Sundays. 
 Mr Gyula Keszthelyi, the former editor of a Hungarian-language daily newspaper in the main Transylvanian town of Cluj, who fled to Hungary last year but remains in close contact with the region, says that there is now a serious row raging between the local pastors and the church hierarchy. 
 &bquo;There is a grave conflict between the bishops and the local clergy because the pastors are getting rebellious, particularly those of the Tokes generation.&equo; 
 The two elderly Reformed Church bishops in Transylvania, Laszlo Papp in Oradea and Gyula Nagy in Cluj, are widely viewed as being beholden to the regime, giving them little authority with their congrega-tions. 
 &bquo;The bishops do what the Securitate Party tells them to do. 
 The pastors are trying to defend the Hungarian identity,&equo; says Mr Keszthelyi. 
 Pastor Istvan Szalatnay, a member of the Hungarian Reform Church General Synod in Budapest, responsible for links with the Church's communities outside Hungary, describes Bishop Papp as &bquo;the hand of the Ceausescu regime and the secret police.&equo; 
 In contrast, most local clergymen seek to serve their local communities and defend them against Bucharest's policies of assimilation. 
 &bquo;The great majority of the pastors try to live in their congregations,&equo; he says. 
 But the scope for resistance is limited and the all pervasive security network is said to extend to Sunday services where sermons are monitored for hints of dissent. 
 &bquo;The pastors try to survive. 
 They see no possibilities of widening the issues beyond their congregations.&equo; 
 His General Synod colleague, Pastor Tamas Bertolan, goes further. 
 &bquo;The church leadership implements the policies of the regime, while the pastors are persecuted.&equo; 
 But the grass roots is fighting back. 
 This month the clergy forced the hierarchy to issue a letter requesting ethnic Hungarians to stay in Transylvania and work for change rather than seeking to flee to Hungary. 
 It was the first time the church authorities had discussed the issue of the refugees, some 25,000 of whom have entered Hungary from the south over the past year. 
 The grass roots also tabled a demand for 30 new pastors to be appointed each year to take over vacant parishes. 
 At the moment half a dozen vacant posts are filled a year. 
 Pastor Szalatnay was in Transylvania last month and says that the atmosphere among local Hungarian intellectuals is one of expectation. 
 The events in East Germany and Czechoslovakia have made a strong impact, he says. 
 &bquo;The mood now is that there is a chance for change.&equo; 
 Germanys agree on spy swap in sign of improving relations. 
 By Anna Tomforde in Dresden 
 EAST and West Germany have set in motion a big spy swap, as a sign of rapidly improving relations, it was announced yesterday. 
 The exchange involves the handing over of 24 convicted West German agents for four high calibre Communist spies held in West Germany. 
 They include two top secretaries formerly employed in Bonn ministries and the Chancellory. 
 Mrs Margarete Hoeke, sentenced in August, 1987 to eight years in jail for spying for the KGB, and Mrs Elke Falk, a ministerial secretary sentenced to 6 &frac12; years last May, both said they were forced into spying after love affairs. 
 In advance of their exchange, they were pardoned yesterday by President Richard von Weizsaecker. 
 Meanwhile, Chancellor Helmut Kohl yesterday described German longing for unity as an historic fact and said those trying to ignore it were making a &bquo;serious mistake&equo;. 
 Dr Kohl was speaking at the end of a two-day visit to Dresden &mdash; his first official trip to East Germany &mdash; which left him clearly pleased with his reception and warm response to his striving for German unity. 
 But the enthusiasm of the 10,000 East Germans who cheered Dr Kohl and pinned their hopes on him to bring the two Germanys together was in stark contrast to official statements on the future from East Germany's reform-minded leaders. 
 Mr Wolfgang Berghofer, the mayor of Dresden and deputy Communist Party chairman, insisted after meeting Dr Kohl that East Germany would continue as a sovereign state. 
 But he also said that, after the Chancellor's Dresden meeting with the East German Prime Minister, Mr Hans Modrow, &bquo;relations between the two German states will never be the same again&equo;. 
 A day after Britain and the Soviet Union cautioned against &bquo;hasty steps&equo; towards German reunification, Dr Kohl yesterday made a point of citing US support for the desire for German unity. 
 He maintained President Bush totally agreed with his own viewpoint on unification. 
 &bquo;President Bush understands the position of his friend Helmut Kohl very well,&equo; the Chancellor said. 
 Asked whether the same applied to Mrs Thatcher, Dr Kohl replied: &bquo;She is a democrat, she supports self-determination, but her ideas about a time frame for German unity are different.&equo; 
 Dr Kohl said he understood fears over unification arising from Germany's past. 
 But no one needed to be afraid of a future where 17 million &bquo;dynamic&equo; East Germans were united with 62 million West Germans. 
 Europe was a &bquo;vocation&equo; for Germans, and within a European framework reunification would be acceptable. 
 &bquo;It is absurd to talk about a fourth Reich, because it is us Germans who are today leading the way in ceding national sovereignty to European institutions&equo;, he said. 
 East Germany's leaders will have the opportunity of discussing the future of the two Germanys over the next two days with President Franois Mitterrand of France, the first head of state of the Western wartime Allies to pay an official visit to East Germany. 
 The French President, who arrived in East Berlin last night, will have talks with Mr Modrow, the Communist Party chairman, Dr Gregor Gysi, and Mr Manfred Gerlach, the acting head of state. 
 Mr Mitterrand, who will visit the southern city of Leipzig today, said on television he was looking forward to his talks with East Germany's new leaders after the extraordinary changes that had taken place in the country. 
 &bquo;I hope for a rapprochement between our two countries, which know very little about each other,&equo; he said. 
 Rogue regimes show up the shortcomings of law Experts agree the US breached international conventions. 
 But, John Cunningham argues, it is not quite as simple as that. 
 PANAMA is the latest in a series of rogue regimes, the menacing state of whose internal affairs has led to armed intervention by other countries &mdash; and to an unresolved international tangle about the legality of such action. 
 The chain has stretched from Uganda to Grenada and Nicaragua, since the 1970s. 
 Experts cite Romania as a possible future instance where human rights violations could lead to a call for action from outside national boundaries. 
 This strengthens the case for powers to be granted to the United Nations to deal with such conflicts. 
 Gen Noreiga said last Friday that Panama considered itself at war with the US so long as American aggression against Panamanians continued. 
 The reaction of a Pentagon spokesman to the remark was first an incredulous &bquo;What?&equo; then laughter. 
 The implication was that Gen Noreiga's bravado could in no legal sense be taken as a declaration of hostilities. 
 The mechanisms for registering and resolving a conflict via the United Nations, which would apply in this situation, had not been gone through by the general. 
 The thrust of the Bush justification for US action was the very real danger to US personnel. 
 &bquo;I have no higher obligation than to safeguard the lives of American citizens,&equo; he said on television. 
 The President gave lower ranking to ancillary reasons: safeguarding democracy, combatting drug trafficking and protecting the integrity of the Panama Canal Treaty. 
 To experts in international law and relations, the US action demonstrates a breach by a major power of international conventions. 
 It also shows the shortcomings of international law in not providing a mechanism for dealing with such situations. 
 Panama, as a sovereign state, can claim that any interference in its domestic affairs by another country contravenes the UN charter, says Paul Wilkinson, Professor of International Relations at St Andrew's University. 
 He points out that such a provision bans any invasion of sovereign territory, air space and maritime zones, even where there might seem to be good grounds. 
 &bquo;That's why human rights violations, even those by Idi Amin in Uganda, have been such embarrassments, because you can't legally do anything about them in international law,&equo; Prof Wilkinson says. 
 The public, at least, generally reconciles its conscience if such interventions end cleanly, effectively and quickly, says another academic, Professor William Gutteridge, executive director of research at the Institute for Conflict. 
 It's a cynical view, he admits, but if there are few casualties, people will tolerate such action, without condoning it, even though &bquo;Americans have a habit of being very clumsy, as in Grenada&equo;. 
 The thornier aspects continue to intrigue international legal experts. 
 Prof Wilkinson points out that the international community might not decry unilateralist intervention provided that it approves of the outcome. 
 While intervention on the basis of protecting American lives might win approval because it could be classified as a humanitarian act, President Bush has apparently widened this to take in replacing one leader with another. 
 &bquo;I don't think what is happening in Panama can be compared to a raid to rescue hostages,&equo; says Prof Gutteridge. 
 Nor does the drugs menace pose a sufficient threat to US security to justify the US action, says Professor Wilkinson. 
 However, he feels that there are instances where regimes violating human rights might justifiably be subjected to external action. 
 He sees it as a weakness of international law that no such machinery exists, and argues that an internationally authorised force should be set up by the UN Security Council to intervene in rogue states on various continents. 
 PAGE 
 Delegates fear a split as minority hardline grouping displays bitterness Lithuanian Communists vote to be independent. 
 By John Rettie in Vilnius, Lithuania 
 IN an historic decision to break with Moscow, the Lithuanian Communist Party voted yesterday to declare itself an independent party by more than 5 to 1, well above the two-thirds majority needed. 
 After the vote at the 20th party congress, delegates leapt to their feet in rapturous applause and sang the Lithuanian national anthem. 
 A beaming party leader, Mr Algirdas Brazauskas, went to the podium to declare the party &bquo;rejuvenated and ready for new battles&equo;. 
 In the name of the Congress, Mr Algimantas Cekuolis, an influential member of both the party and the nationalist movement, Sajudis, issued a clarion call to young people to join the party now. 
 &bquo;We are a great force,&equo; he declared. 
 &bquo;There are over 200,000 of us but we need more. 
 Let us not leave it to others to fight for our goals.&equo; 
 The decision is seen in Vilnius as the biggest step yet on the road to the complete independence of Lithuania, although Mr Brazauskas was careful to draw a distinction between party and state relations. 
 Only a fortnight ago, the Lithuanian parliament abandoned the constitutional guarantee of the party's leading role in society, in favour of a multi-party system. 
 In the new year, Lithuania, together with the other two Baltic republics of Latvia and Estonia, will become economically autonomous within the Soviet Union. 
 But there is a real possibility of a split within the Lithuanian party. 
 The minority which voted for a &bquo;sovereign party within a renewed Soviet Communist party&equo; arranged to meet last night to consider its position. 
 The vote for independence came after two days of acrimonious debate between the Lithuanian majority and the Russian Polish minority, who were joined by a handful of old-guard Lithuanian Communists. 
 The minority, which could muster only 160 votes against the majority's 855, displayed considerable bitterness towards what they said was pressure on them to accept independence, and threats that they would lose their jobs or worse. 
 A woman tractor driver, Ms G. Serzhantovich, said: &bquo;I consider that the formation of an independent Lithuanian Communist Party will lead to its annihilation. 
 But there is no opportunity to express an opinion other than that of Sajudis.&equo; 
 They expressed fears of leaving the embrace of what they regarded as the mother party. 
 &bquo;The proposed new independent status would mean a split in the party,&equo; said the Vilnius district secretary, Mr Vladislav Shved, speaking in Russian. 
 &bquo;Is it democratic to declare the Lithuanian party independent without a referendum of party members?&equo; 
 Delegates rejected proposals for a referendum. 
 But there was even greater bitterness among many Lithuanian nationalists, who felt the Russians had never wanted to understand why the Lithuanians felt resentment against years of oppression. 
 &bquo;I can well understand the feelings of the minority, but I cannot understand why they're offended,&equo; said Mr Sliudikas, another district secretary in the capital. 
 &bquo;People had begun to look on the Lithuanian party as the servile agent, even the secret agent, of the Soviet Communist Party.&equo; 
 American soldiers killed Bush pledges swift withdrawal of 12,000 troops Protracted resistance by guerrillas feared Elite paratroopers spearhead US attack. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 IN the biggest American paratroop operation since the Allied attempt to seize the Rhine bridges in 1944, the US Army dropped two battalions of elite Rangers into Panama in an operation involving 24,000 troops, tanks, warplanes and gunships. 
 Claiming a military success in toppling the regime, even while General Manuel Antonio Noriega remained at large, the chairman of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Colin Powell, said: &bquo;Noriega has been decapitated from the dictatorship of this nation.&equo; 
 More reinforcements flew in yesterday morning from the 7th Infantry Division in Fort Ord, California, to back up the earlier contingents from the 82nd Airborne and the 5th Mechanised Infantry, who launched the initial assaults. 
 The highlights of the operation were two night-time parachute assaults by the Rangers, one on the International Airport, the other on the Rio Jara base of the 7th company of the Panamanian Defence Forces. 
 The first casualty reports from the Pentagon said 11 US troops had been killed in action, 39 had been wounded and one man was missing. 
 Briefing reporters at the Pentagon yesterday morning, Gen Powell said he had &bquo;no reliable information&equo; on Panamanian military or civilian casualties. 
 Facing powerful political pressure in Washington for reductions in the defence budget, the Pentagon was also keen to overcome the embarrassing memories of the chaotic invasion of Grenada in 1983. 
 President Bush and Gen Powell insisted that the 12,000 extra troops deployed in Panama over the past 48 hours would be withdrawn &bquo;as soon as possible&equo;. 
 But as the shooting and the mopping-up continued yesterday, the prospect of a protracted guerrilla operation began to loom over what the Pentagon had hoped would be a splendid Christmas victory. 
 Four separate military task forces were deployed in the first major military deployment of the Bush presidency, with the Pentagon keen to show that if the traditional threat in central Europe was declining, it was ready to project US power elsewhere in the globe. 
 But the clear intelligence failure which let Gen Noriega escape, to organise what could prove to be a prolonged guerrilla resistance, threatens to turn this latest military adventure into a political embarrassment. 
 After weeks of planning, the first phase of the military operation went well. 
 The troops were delivered to their start lines with the traditional logistical efficiency of the US armed forces. 
 They launched their assaults with the equally traditional use of overwhelming firepower. 
 As convoys of military cargo planes flew into Howard Air Force base all day on Tuesday, bringing the advance elements of the 82nd Airborne, there was little real surprise. 
 The combat operations began just after 1am local time, shortly after the new government was sworn in. 
 The first military operations were launched by Task Force Atlantic, charged with securing the canal itself. 
 Special Forces seized control of the main dams on the canal, and prepared landing grounds for the helicopter-borne troops who came in to block the roads and defend the canal against guerrilla attacks from the pro-Noriega armed militia, the Dignity Battalions. 
 Simultaneously, Task Force Semper Fidelis, composed of US marines and military police, seized the main road across the canal, the Bridge of the Americas, and secured the approaches to Howard Air Force Base, which was always under US military control. 
 Almost immediately afterwards, Task Force Bayonet, the armoured force, headed into the centre of Panama City. 
 A mechanised battalion from the 5th Division based at Fort Polk, Louisiana, they had been deployed in Panama since Gen Noriega's suppression of the elections in May. 
 Task Force Bayonet launched its platoon of light tanks and its companies of armoured personnel carriers against the HQ of the Panamanian Defence Forces (PDF). 
 Some of the heaviest fighting took place here, and witnesses reported severe damage to some of the civilian areas in the tight-packed streets around the headquarters. 
 Most of the civilian casualties were incurred here. 
 Defended by well-armed troops, the US assault forces had to use heavy weapons, including anti-tank rockets and mortars, to blast their way into the building, which was largely destroyed in the fighting and the fires. 
 TF Bayonet was also charged with protection of US bases and sent two assault companies of helicopter-borne troops from the 87th Infantry to block the PDF base at Fort Amador. 
 The 5th company of the PDF, apparently surprised by the American move, slowly organised a counter-attack and gunfire was still being heard from this area yesterday morning. 
 The paratroops, known as Task Force Red, dropped in two waves from C-141 cargo planes. 
 The first wave landed at about 1.55am and the second some four hours later, at about 5.15am. 
 They were dropped around the Rio Jara base, where two Panamanian companies were &bquo;neutralised&equo; by a parachute battalion of 600 US Rangers. 
 Some of the Panamanians managed to escape with their weapons and spasmodic fighting continued in the area yesterday. 
 A second battalion, dropped onto the International Airport, was also charged with neutralising the elite Battalion 2000, the most formidable of the Panamanian forces. 
 These first three strikes were launched in Panama City and its immediate surrounds on the Pacific Ocean end of the canal. 
 The wider operations were the responsibility of Task Force Atlantic, which included naval forces and troops which had been sent to reinforce Southern Command earlier in the year. 
 Their main objective was to seize and hold the canal itself against the demolition attacks which had long been threatened by Gen Noriega. 
 A battalion of the 7th Light Infantry Division and a battalion of the 82nd Airborne, being used as ground troops, were deployed to seize the Atlantic Ocean end of the canal at Colon. 
 They also took command of the crucial Madden Dam, which regulates the amount of water flowing into the canal, and maintained helicopter and motorised patrols along the 51-mile length of the canal. 
 Task Force Atlantic also attacked and seized the main military prison, freeing some 48 prisoners who had been arrested by Gen Noriega after the abortive coup against him on October 3. 
 Other operations were directed against the small Panamanian Navy of coastal gunships, and against the airports used by the small air force. 
 Not seen as a serious military problem, these naval and air assets were seized mainly to cut off possible escape routes for Gen Noriega and his supporters. 
 Rent-a-colonel outlives value to old friends. 
 By Mark Tran in Washington 
 AN AMERICAN visitor to Panama who had the rare chance of meeting General Manuel Antonio Noriega said the dictator bore &bquo;that look of doom on his face&equo;. 
 Plucked from obscurity by US intelligence and groomed into a CIA asset over three decades, the general took no chances. 
 He never slept in the same place, and his meals were prepared mostly by women he trusted &mdash; his partner, Vicky Amado and her mother. 
 But the strain took its toll. 
 &bquo;Noriega looked like a man who hadn't slept for 20 days,&equo; said Mr Larry Birns of the Council on Hemispheric Affairs. 
 There could be further strain for Gen Noriega. 
 Wanted on drug charges, he may end up at the centre of an extraordinary trial in Miami. 
 US authorities allege that Gen Noriega made millions in illegal profits by allowing drug trafficking to go on freely in Panama. 
 They also accuse the general of permitting banks in Panama to launder billions of drug money made by the Colombian drug cartels. 
 Such a trial, however, could well prove to be a double-edged sword for the administration, since the general once boasted that he possessed information that would prove highly embarrassing to President Bush. 
 That claim may have been sheer bravado, but given his long association with US intelligence, the general undoubtedly has enough mud to splatter many of his erstwhile US friends. 
 Of all the dictators the US has befriended and turned against, Gen Noriega has proven the most resilient and ruthless &mdash; partly out of necessity. 
 One Colombian drug boss, upon hearing in 1987 that Gen Noriega was negotiating with the US to abandon his command for a comfortable exile, sent him a hand-sized mahogany coffin engraved with his name. 
 The US knew the kind of man it was dealing with. 
 In 1960, when Gen Noriega was both a cadet at an elite military academy in Peru and a spy-in-training for the US Defence Intelligence Agency, he was detained for allegedly raping and savagely beating a prostitute. 
 He became a formal CIA asset in 1966 or 1967. 
 He rose to chief of intelligence in Panama's G-2 in 1970 after providing the populist dictator, General Omar Torrijos, the support to defeat a coup. 
 Gen Noriega, however, soon started freelancing for Cuban, Israeli, and Taiwanese intelligence services. 
 &bquo;Early on in the State Department, we took to calling him the rent-a-colonel, in tribute to his ability to simultaneously milk the antagonistic intelligence services of Cuba and the US,&equo; said Mr Francis McNeill, a former deputy assistant secretary of state for Inter-American Affairs. 
 In 1976, US intelligence discovered that the rent-a-colonel was buying recordings of taped conversations from Military Intelligence. 
 He was taken off the CIA payroll. 
 But all was forgiven when the Reagan Administration came to power. 
 Gen Noriega ingratiated himself by offering his services to a White House bent on making the Sandinistas &bquo;cry uncle&equo;, although his help for the contra cause was limited. 
 The downfall of Gen Noriega can be traced to the brutal killing of the opposition leader, Hugo Spadafora, found beheaded in 1985. 
 Public opinion in Panama turned against him. 
 While in the past, US officials blocked investigations into Gen Noriega's drug links; this time they let justice take its course. 
 In February last year, lawyers in Miami indicted him on drug charges. 
 If Gen Noriega goes to trial, it could well be dubbed &bquo;trial of the century&equo;. 
 Oil prices surge ahead. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 OIL prices surged yesterday amid market fears that the Panamanian crisis could hit US crude supplies. 
 North Sea oil on the London spot market rocketed 30 cents a barrel before settling back to &dollar;19.45 in late trading. 
 In New York, the spot price of West Texas Intermediate, the main crude traded on Wall Street, rose 35 cents to nearly &dollar;22 a barrel. 
 About one quarter of production from the giant Alaskan oilfields is pumped through the 81-mile TransPanama pipeline for shipment to the US Eastern seaboard. 
 The oil mostly comes from British Petroleum and Exxon's Alaskan fields together with a small quanity of Latin-American and Asian crudes. 
 Only small quantities of oil are transported through the actual canal because the shallow water depth bars the passage of large tankers. 
 The pipeline operators, US Northville Industries, claimed yesterday that production is being held at normal levels of around 300,000 barrels day. 
 Offloading from a tanker on the Pacific seaboard into the pipeline system was last night suspended. 
 A Northfield spokesman said: &bquo;We have held one ship which was scheduled to unload until we are sure that everything is quiet.&equo; 
 But oil traders said there would be no immediate impact as there were storage facilities with at least eight days supply at both ends of the pipeline system. 
 Brokers at Nomura Research, the Japanese financial giant, said a halt of supplies for one day would be of &bquo;minor consequence&equo;. 
 A longterm shutdown, however, could force BP to ship its oil around Cape Horn. 
 A BP spokesman said that the company was taking no action to seek alternative methods of transport until events in Panama became clearer. 
 Analysts said the Panamanian Government would make every effort to ensure that supplies are continued because of the country's reliance on oil revenues. 
 Proceeds from both pipeline and the canal amount to around &dollar;100 million, about 25 per cent of Panama's GDP. 
 Night of terror turns to sorrow. 
 By Candice Hughes in Panama City 
 THE fighting had just broken out in Panama City when a group of men dressed in civilian clothes and armed with rifles surrounded the Marriott Hotel and began rounding up guests. 
 For the next 4 &frac12; hours the men held us hostage, told us about their comrades who had already fallen in battle, and threatened to kill us. 
 &bquo;A lot of Panamanians have died and we can kill you,&equo; one of them told New York Times correspondent, Mr Lindsey Gruson. 
 &bquo;Don't think we won't.&equo; 
 I had just checked into the hotel and come down to the sunken terrace when I saw armed men running in a crouched position by the swimming pool. 
 About the same time I heard gunfire. 
 It was about midnight (5am GMT) and the US assault had started. 
 I made for the hotel's main building with several other reporters when a man with an assault rifle appeared and said: &bquo;Hit the floor.&equo; 
 He herded us into the lobby, which was full of people. 
 The gunmen took people's passports and they searched my bag. 
 About a dozen men took charge of me and 11 other foreigners.I never saw more than 20 armed men in the hotel. 
 They told us they had surrounded the building. 
 &bquo;We're being invaded, so we're taking hostages,&equo; said one, who appeared to be their leader. 
 They did not threaten me personally, but they made it clear that they could kill us all. 
 There were about eight US citizens in our group. 
 The armed men eventually let me retrieve my bag and notebook &mdash; my money had been taken &mdash; and remain in the lobby. 
 Mr Gruson went upstairs where he said he was threatened by one of the gunmen. 
 At one point, the gunman put the muzzle of his weapon against Gruson's mouth, he told me later. 
 About 1.45am a few other hostages and I were herded into a red van at gunpoint and driven to a private home in the wealthy neighbourhood where General Noriega lives. 
 We were ordered into the service area off the kitchen and made to sit on the floor. 
 Our captors let us have water and smoke cigarettes. 
 We were there until 4am. 
 I kept hearing aircraft passing low overhead and sporadic gunfire from automatic weapons. 
 Things were tapering off. 
 Then a man who seemed to be in charge said, &bquo;We're going to let you go. 
 We don't want to kill you. 
 Tell the truth about Panama. 
 We're not killers. 
 There are hundreds of dead in the Central Barracks.&equo; 
 The men seemed very sad. 
 One was crying. 
 They put us back into a van and let us out in the street. 
 I raced to a private home and called the Associated Press office. 
 &mdash; AP 
 Nemeth quits his party role in Hungarian budget row. 
 By Ian Traynor in Budapest 
 THE Hungarian Prime Minister, Mr Miklos Nemeth, quit the leadership of the ruling Socialist Party yesterday amid bitter disagreement over his economic policies and the pace of the country's transition to a market economy. 
 Mr Nemeth, a strong adherent of neo-monetarist measures to resolve the country's fiscal crisis, accused his party colleagues of failing to support him as head of government and claimed his resignation was guided by national rather than party interest. 
 In his letter of resignation to the party leader, Mr Rezsoe Nyers, with whom he has been waging a long-running feud, Mr Nemeth stated he had no option but to resign. 
 But there was no indication that his tenure of the premiership would be threatened by the decision. 
 &bquo;The praesidium decided not to support the 1990 budget and the party is against the (government's) housing programme. 
 This could be a clever pre-election manoeuvre. 
 But since I represent the country, I cannot agree with this,&equo; he stated. 
 Despite the party leadership's opposition to aspects of Mr Nemeth's austerity measures, the budget is expected to be approved today, after parliament successfully watered down the controversial changes in housing policy which entailed steep rent rises and a sharp increase in mortgage payments. 
 The budget is critical to Hungary's hopes for economic recovery, as the International Monetary Fund (IMF) will not authorise the release of western credits until the tight fiscal regime is applied. 
 Introducing the budget yesterday, Finance Minister Mr Laszlo Bekesi said that only such a regime could prevent economic collapse. &bquo; 
 In order to meet the IMF's requirements and thus ensure &dollar;350 million in stand-by credits and another billion dollars in European Community funds, Mr Nemeth intends to slash the huge budget deficit from around 50 billion forints (&pound;500 million) to 10 billion. 
 An emergency congress of the Czechoslovak Communist Party yesterday elected the former prime minister, Mr Ladislav Adamec, as chairman to guide it through free elections due within six months. 
 Mr Adamec replaces Mr Karel Urbanek, who took over less than four weeks ago after the ousting of hardliner Milos Jakes. 
 East and West leaders join in condemning killings... 
 By Foreign Staff OUTRAGE and concern at the violence in Romania during the weekend came from all parts of the world yesterday, with the Soviet Union and the US in the lead. 
 The White House said the repression was &bquo;totally unjustified&equo; and that the US would consult its allies on a co-ordinated response. 
 European foreign ministers, meeting in Brussels, condemned &bquo;in the strongest possible terms&equo; the measures taken by the Romanian security forces. 
 The Soviet Foreign Minister, Mr Eduard Shevardnadze, was foremost among those who deplored the violence. 
 Questioned as he left Nato headquarters in Brussels, he said &bquo;if indeed some loss of life has occurred, I can only express my very profound regret&equo;. 
 The Soviet Union was categorically opposed to the use of force, he added. 
 The Soviet news agency, Tass, was also explicit about developments in Romania, stating that &bquo;tension was high&equo; inside Timisoara. 
 It reported that Romanian state institutions and factories were under intensified guard, and that the frontiers were closed to tourists. 
 There was no official comment from China which has had close relations with Romania's President Ceausescu. 
 Solidarity's leader, Mr Lech Walesa, said: &bquo;We demand respect for the human and civil rights of Pastor Tokes and all Romanians persecuted by the inhuman regime of Nicolae Ceausescu.&equo; 
 He appealed to Nobel Peace laureates (of which he is one) to take common action to defend Pastor Tokes and to exert pressure on the Romanian authorities. 
 The Polish Parliament stood for a minute's silence after approving unanimously a resolution which accused the Romanian authorities of &bquo;exceptional brutality&equo; leading to children being shot at and expressed solidarity with the &bquo;victims of terror.&equo; 
 The World Council of Churches, the World Alliance of Reformed Churches, the Lutheran World Federation and the Conference of European Churches said in a joint telegram they were &bquo;deeply disturbed by the disquieting intervention of the army against civilian people in Timisoara.&equo; 
 They added: &bquo;We urge you to take all necessary measures to guarantee the safety of people and a lawful solution of the problems involved.&equo; 
 The Romanian ambassador in London, Mr Stan Soare, was summoned to the Foreign Office where Mr William Waldegrave, the Junior Minister responsible for Eastern Europe, said &bquo;the right thing&equo; for Romanian state employees, including those working for the security services, to do was to represent &bquo;the true will of the Romanian people&equo; and overthrow the Ceausescu Government. 
 Some 1,000 Bulgarians attended a requiem Mass outside the Romanian embassy in Sofia for those killed. 
 Reporters said demonstrators carried banners decorated with swastikas and calling President Ceausescu a fascist. 
 The crisis that could not be contained. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 THE latest phase in Panama's crisis began last Friday, when General Noriega had himself declared formal head of government by his self-appointed National Assembly, and simultaneously announced that a &bquo;state of war&equo; now existed with the US. 
 Gen Noriega's apparently gratuitous escalation of the crisis played into American hands, allowing President Bush to claim a strong degree of bipartisan support from Congress. 
 The &bquo;state of war&equo; declaration clouded what might otherwise have been a clear-cut case of American aggression and gave the White House the makings of a case under international law. 
 But it is not clear whether the military operation which unfolded yesterday could have been organised in only four days. 
 Gen Noriega's provocations may simply have accelerated a plan that had been ready to be unleashed at any time. 
 The day after the declaration, which did not seem at first to be being taken seriously in Washington, Gen Noriega's troops escalated the crisis into a confrontation. 
 The shooting dead of a US marine and the wounding of another at a Panamanian roadblock on Saturday forced the US to take the situation more seriously. 
 Colombian-born Lieutenant Roberto Paz, was unarmed when he and other marines in civilian clothes were stopped at a roadblock. 
 The Panamanians claim the car was trying to escape. 
 The Pentagon claims that the marines had shown their papers and been passed through the roadblock, when the Panamanians opened fire. 
 Later, an American naval officer and his wife were arrested at a roadblock. 
 According to the Pentagon, in four hours of brutal interrogation, the officer was beaten and repeatedly kicked in the head and the testicles while loaded pistols were aimed at him. 
 His wife was slammed against a wall, sexually threatened and ordered to stand with her arms raised over her head until she collapsed. 
 On Sunday, a Panamanian soldier loaded his assault rifle and aimed it directly at patrolling US troops. 
 Tensions between the US and Panamanian forces were running high on Monday, when a US Army lieutenant in civilian clothes, who was not authorised to carry arms, shot and wounded a Panamanian traffic policeman. 
 On Monday, the White House declared the violence to be &bquo;part of a pattern of harassment&equo; and claimed that this &bquo;co-ordinated campaign&equo; was linked to the state of war declaration. 
 That evening, the US charge d'affaires in Panama, Mr John Bushnell, made discreet contact with Mr Guillermo Endara, the leader of the Civic Democratic Opposition Alliance, which most independent observers reckoned the clear winner of the elections last May. 
 Mr Endara was told of the planned attack, and asked for his support, which he apparently granted, saying that he was ready to become the new leader if the US could topple the Noriega regime. 
 Mr Endara was sworn in as President shortly after midnight last night, on a US military base, in the presence of a US Major-General, with members of Panamanian human rights groups as witnesses. 
 Videotapes of the ceremony were made &bquo;as proof of the legitimacy of the occasion&equo;, US officials claimed. 
 Yesterday, US diplomats formally told the UN that they intended to file an explanation of their actions under Article 51 of the UN Charter, which grants states the right to self-defence. 
 Tamil Tigers give up war to enter political arena. 
 By Chris Nuttall in Colombo 
 SRI LANKA'S Tamil Tiger guerrillas announced yesterday that they had renounced violence and registered as a political party. 
 The Tigers, who are fighting for military supremacy in the Tamil-dominated north and east of the island, told a news conference their political wing would be known as the People's Front of the Liberation Tigers. 
 The Tigers have had a political wing since 1976 but never registered it as a legal party. 
 The move is the culmination of more than six months of peace talks with the government during which the Tigers declared an end to their 17-year guerrilla war. 
 The Tigers boycotted elections in November last year for the North-Eastern Provincial Council, the new body set up as a compromise to demands for self-rule, saying that it did not fulfil the aspirations of the Tamil people. 
 But the guerrilla leadership now says the council will serve as an interim administration. 
 Once elected, they would negotiate for greater devolution. 
 While the Tigers are finally embracing democracy, violence seems certain to continue in the north and east. 
 The guerrillas are embroiled in a civil war against an alliance of rival Tamil groups, the Tamil National Army, in areas from which the Indian Peace-keeping Force has withdrawn. 
 The Tigers say they will not contest elections until there is peace. 
 The Indians, who they fought for nearly two years, must also complete their pullout. 
 As well, the Tigers' chief political adviser, Mr Anton Balasingham, said the guerrillas would not contest elections until the government drops a constitutional amendment requiring election candidates to swear an oath of allegiance to a unitary state. 
 This is bound to create suspicions among the majority Sinhalese community that the Tigers still harbour ambitions of their own Tamil state. 
 The new party is also dedicated to &bquo;fighting for the right of self-determination of the Tamils and Muslims&equo; and &bquo;protecting and preserving the geographical identity and integrity of the traditional homelands of the Tamils and Muslims&equo;. 
 But Mr Balasingham stressed that &bquo;self-determination&equo; was different from separatism. 
 &bquo;It is like a husband and wife,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If they can live harmoniously and happily together, they will remain united. 
 If the relationship becomes intolerable, the parties will have the right to divorce. 
 By self-determination we mean the right for us to associate and integrate with the unitary state, or, as a nation, to secede.&equo; 
 The constitution should not constrain us from articulating these political ideas, therefore we will request the Sri Lankan government to bring about an annulment of the amendment.&equo; 
 This could be difficult. 
 The ruling United National Party does not have the two-thirds majority in parliament required to change the constitution. 
 The Tigers' political leadership is attempting a difficult balancing act. 
 It is entering the mainstream to satisfy the demands of the people of the north and east, whose high turnout in last November's election was seen as a cry for peace. 
 It has had to soften its stance on separatism to try to convince the Sri Lankan Government and the Sinhalese people that it sincerely wants a negotiated settlement. 
 At the same time, however, the Tigers cannot antagonise their own supporters by abandoning the concept of a homeland called Tamil Eelam. 
 Ousting Noriega will help US to fulfil treaty terms. 
 By Mark Tran in Washington 
 THE ousting of General Noriega is likely to make it easier for the US to live up to its commitments under the Panama Canal treaties agreed by President Carter and then Panamanian strongman, Omar Torrijos. 
 Signed in 1977, the treaties ended unilateral US control in 1979. 
 All US operational rights over the canal will terminate by the year 2000. 
 But rightwing members of Congress have never reconciled themselves to the return of the canal to the Panamanians. 
 Figures such as the Florida senator, Connie Mack, saw the Noriega affair as a golden opportunity to make the 1977 canal treaties void. 
 By toppling Gen Noriega, President Bush has deprived rightwing resentment of a focus. 
 &bquo;I am fully committed to implement the Panama Canal treaties and turn over the canal to Panama in the year 2000&hellip; 
 As soon as the new government recommends a qualified candidate, Panamanian, to be administrator of the canal, as called for in the treaties, I will submit this nominee to the senate for expedited consideration,&equo; Mr Bush said yesterday. 
 Now that Gen Noriega is gone, senate approval of the administrator is likely to be much less of a problem. 
 The history of US policy towards Panama is inextricably tied to its canal. 
 President Roosevelt first contacted Colombia to get rights to build a canal through the isthmus of Panama, which was then within its boundaries. 
 When the democratically-elected Colombian senate rejected Mr Roosevelt's proposal because the money offered was too low, he sponsored an invasion instead. 
 Thus Panama gained its independence from Colombia and the Canal Zone was born. 
 Since then, with the exception of the period beginning with Torrijos coming to power in 1969 and the Noriega years, the US controlled not only the Canal Zone itself, but Panamanian politics as well. 
 A 1903 treaty between the US and Panama gave the US the right to build and open a waterway. 
 The US also received the right to govern an area of land called the Panama Canal Zone on both sides of the canal. 
 The arrangement eventually became a sore point in relations between the US and Panama, which regarded the original treaty as an affront to its sovereignty. 
 As a result of the 1977 treaty, most of the zone reverted to Panamanian control in 1979. 
 The canal itself will be handed back to Panama on December 31, 1999. 
 A second and less well-known treaty gives the US the right to defend the canal's neutrality. 
 Once considered a vital and strategic waterway &mdash; huge quantities of war material passed through the canal during the Vietnam war &mdash; the Panama Canal has lost some of its importance because of air freight. 
 The Panama Canal Commission said in Washington yesterday that it planned to reopen the waterway for daylight transit today. 
 Revaluation will push business rates higher than expected. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 THE outcome of the first commercial rating revaluation in England and Wales for 16 years has produced increases higher than the Government predicted, it was disclosed yesterday. 
 Business leaders believe that the new &pound;8.5 billion national business rate will create political and inflationary problems for the Government when it is introduced next April. 
 Mr Chris Patten, the Environment Secretary, yesterday moved to mitigate the effects of the Inland Revenue revaluation by announcing that the poundage will be set at 34.8 pence in the pound instead of the provisional figure of 36 pence in the pound announced last month. 
 Draft rating valuation lists showing the new rateable values for 1.5 million businesses will be available from town halls from January 2. 
 The Government had predicted that rateable values would rise by about seven times, but the revaluation has produced an eightfold increase. 
 An early Inland Revenue analysis of the revaluation suggest that 240,000 businesses in England face increases of 100 per cent or more in their annual bills; about 230,000 rises between 50 and 100 per cent and a further 390,000 increases of between five and 50 per cent. 
 Those businesses facing rises are mainly shops and offices in the South. 
 Ballot winners choose their bills. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 HOME Office and planning issues dominate the concerns of MPs who won places in the private members' ballot for legislative time in the coming session. 
 All 20 who won places declared their chosen subjects yesterday. 
 Labour's Mr Martyn Jones, MP for Clwyd South West, heads the list with a bill to give consumers a statutory guarantee of the quality of the goods they buy. 
 The top seven, all Tories apart from Mr Jones, have the most chance of success, since business managers have set aside seven Fridays for private members' bills. 
 Mr Michael Mates, MP for Hampshire East, after considering a bill to improve the position of war widows, has opted to make provision &bquo;for certain debts to carry interest&equo;. 
 Mr Michael Colvin, MP for Romsey and Waterside, is to bring in an anti-computer hacking bill. 
 Sir William Shelton, Streatham, aims to tighten the law against kerb crawling and soliciting, and has taken on board a Home Office proposal to abolish the presumption that a boy aged under 14 is incapable of sexual intercourse. 
 Mr Edward Leigh, Gainsborough and Horncastle, and Mr John Wilkinson, Ruislip-Northwood, have opted for planning changes. 
 Mr Leigh wants more protection for footpaths and bridleways. 
 Mr Wilkinson requires developers to get planning permission before demolishing a single house. 
 The seventh MP, Mr Graham Bright, Luton South, wants more penalties available to the courts against organisers of unlicensed entertainments such as acid house parties. 
 Among the remaining 13 private members' bills, whose chances are far more dependent on the amount of controversy they attract, are measures to compensate British nuclear test victims, abolish poll tax warrant sales in Scotland, and lay down car telephones standards. 
 Job tally queried. 
 By Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 THE Government was challenged yesterday to overhaul its employment statistics as Labour's front bench employment team accused ministers of &bquo;statistical sleight of hand&equo; in claiming a huge expansion of jobs in the eighties. 
 In a briefing document presented by the employment spokesman, Mr Henry McLeish, at Westminster, Labour challenges Government claims that nearly a million jobs were created in 1979-89. 
 Discounting 440,000 people with two jobs and 470,000 on training courses such as Employment Training and the Youth Training Scheme, the document puts the net figure for employment growth at only 68,000. 
 The paper, the Jobs Miracle That Never Was, attacks as barely credible Government claims that the economy has seen a &bquo;jobs miracle&equo; since 1983, with a net increase of 2.75 million people in employment. 
 The paper points out that, apart from the 470,000 trainees included in the statistics, a further 500,000 jobs should be discounted if the European Commission's formula of full-time equivalence is applied to the one million new part-time jobs. 
 It says that 340,000 people with two jobs are being double counted, and there is a discrepancy of one million between the numbers claimed to be in self-employment and those self-employed people paying national insurance. 
 Labour also pointed to a significant north-south divide on new jobs, with the north having lost 330,000 jobs since 1979, and the south having gained 1.1 million. 
 Banks abandon student loans. 
 Plans to introduce top up loans for students faced collapse last night after all the major banks told the Government they were pulling out. 
 Page 20. 
 Greener green bill. 
 The Environment secretary, Mr Christopher Patten, has presented an Environmental Protection Bill making sweeping changes in the way industrial pollution is controlled. 
 Page 4. &pound;20m contract row. 
 A &pound;20 million contract for running a new social security computer centre has been awarded to a non-union, American-based company without any other bids being invited. 
 Page 3. 
 Lithuania breaks free. 
 In an historic decision to break with Moscow, the Lithuanian Communist Party has voted by more than 5-1 to declare itself an independent party. 
 Page 8. 
 Ethnic recruitment. 
 The Metropolitan Police are to adopt MPs' proposals for a big recruitment drive among black and Asian communities in 1990. 
 Page 2. 
 Ferry deal blocked. 
 Plans by Sealink and P&amp;O to operate a joint cross-Channel service to combat the threat of the tunnel link have been blocked by the Monopolies and Mergers Commission. 
 Page 12. 
 Spies swap. 
 East and West Germany have set in motion a big spy swap, involving 28 agents, as a sign of rapidly improving relations. 
 Page 8. 
 Inflation warning. 
 Heavy-handed government attempts to curb inflation could jeopardise Britain's chances of exploiting a barrier-free Europe after 1992, MPs warn, amid further evidence of the economy grinding to a halt. 
 Page 12 
 US firm wins &pound;20m dole office deal. 
 By David Brindle, Social Services Correspondent 
 ACONTRACT worth up to &pound;20 million for running a new social security computer centre was yesterday awarded to a non-union, American-based company without any other bids being invited. 
 Mr Tony Newton, the Social Security Secretary, was accused of misleading Parliament when he announced in a written reply that Electronic Data Systems had been given the five-year contract for running the centre at Norcross, Lancashire, &bquo;following consideration of a tender&equo;. 
 His department later confirmed that there had been no competitive tendering and that no companies apart from EDS, nor the department itself, had been invited to bid. 
 The National Union of Civil and Public Servants claimed that Mr Newton had given the impression of a tendering exercise having taken place. 
 Ms Rosie Eagleson, the union's senior official for social security, said: &bquo;It's totally misleading. 
 Although he didn't actually say there had been competition, the implication was very strong.&equo; 
 Earlier this year EDS, an autonomous subsidiary of General Motors, was awarded a five-year contract worth between &pound;10 million and &pound;15 million to run a social security computer centre at Livingston in Scotland. 
 Leaked Government documents later appeared to suggest civil servants could have run the centre for &pound;2.5 million less. 
 One of the documents, an apparent memorandum from Mr John Moore, Mr Newton's predecessor, said the choice of EDS was designed to make the computerised benefits network less vulnerable to industrial action. 
 Livingston and Norcross are two of four area computer centres which will run the social security and pensions systems. 
 A third, at Washington, Tyne and Wear, is being run by civil servants and a fourth, at Swindon, will be subject to competitive tendering next year. 
 The department said it had been decided not to invite competing tenders for Norcross because the contract award, worth between &pound;17 million and &pound;20 million over five years, followed so quickly the tendering exercise for Livingston that competition would have been &bquo;unlikely to yield any improvement in value for money&equo;. 
 The Civil Service unions are convinced that EDS will win the Swindon contract. 
 They said they were warned yesterday that the Washington area centre would also be privatised if there were any problems in its running. 
 Banks drop student loan scheme. 
 By Education Staff 
 PLANS to introduce top up loans for students faced collapse last night after all the leading banks told the Government they were pulling out. 
 Ministers are now isolated as virtually the only supporters of the scheme which has been condemned by Conservative backbenchers, Opposition MPs and students. 
 The Royal Bank of Scotland said it had pulled out because it saw no continuing need for its participation. 
 &bquo;We don't wish to be associated with what is a political act &lsqb;the scheme&rsqb;.&equo; 
 The proposal is likely to emerge radically altered when details are set out in regulations after the loans legislation is passed. 
 Labour and student leaders welcomed the banks' decision as a victory for common sense. 
 The decision leaves in tatters the Government's original plans for a scheme administered by the private sector, and in effect hands control of higher education funding to the Treasury, a blow to the morale of the Department of Education and Science which wants to expand student numbers. 
 The Government will now take over the Student Loans Company, the Glasgow-based firm set up to lend and collect repayments on the Treasury-financed loans. 
 It has only two options for collecting repayments of loans worth up to &pound;460 a year &mdash; an income tax surcharge, or increased national insurance contributions &mdash; unless it sets up an even more costly mechanism. 
 Mr John MacGregor, the Education Secretary, said the decision would not alter the principles, objectives or framework of the scheme as outlined in the Education (Student Loans) Bill currently going through Parliament. 
 He insisted the scheme was not in tatters and the main effect of the banks' decision would be to make applying for a loan less convenient for students. 
 He left open the possibility that Girobank, recently privatised, could be made responsible for collecting repayments and chasing defaulters, the number of whom could rise significantly above the Government's current estimates. 
 &bquo;I am informed that the Girobank is not in a position to take a decision about full ownership of the company.&equo; 
 Dr Keith Hampson, a leading Conservative backbench critic of the scheme, said last night: &bquo;The possibility of getting a workable scheme that is not in a shambles by September must be in severe doubt.&equo; 
 He added that the decision marked the first nationalisation under a Thatcher government. 
 Mr John Quinton, chairman of the Committee of London and Scottish Clearing Banks and of Barclays, told Mr MacGregor yesterday that all clearing banks had decided to withdraw from the scheme. 
 The banks have been hostile to the plans from the beginning but had been waiting for the right moment to withdraw on commercial rather than political grounds. 
 It is understood that Lloyds was chosen to withhold its co-operation when 10 banks agreed in November to participate in preparations for the scheme's introduction next autumn. 
 The move was intended to prove that co-operation could damage business. 
 Students have launched a protest campaign against the 10, by withdrawing, or threatening to withdraw, individual and student union accounts. 
 Lloyds, the Bank of Scotland and Clydesdale have benefited as students transferred to them. 
 This enabled the banks to pull out on the grounds that involvement was not commercially justifiable. 
 Mr Jack Straw, the shadow Education Secretary, called on the Government to abandon the scheme and withdraw the bill. 
 &bquo;The scheme is now bankrupt&hellip; 
 To claim, as Mr MacGregor has done, that this changes nothing is obvious nonsense.&equo; 
 Ms Maeve Sherlock, president of the National Union of Students, said: &bquo;The Government must now take on running a scheme which the best financial experts in the country want nothing to do with.&equo; 
 It would have to spend large amounts of public money to save face. 
 However, Conservative students said the banks had failed them. 
 &bquo;The top up loans scheme is the only way forward for the finance of student maintenance and ultimately students will recognise the logic and necessity of the scheme.&equo; 
 War breaks tropical dawn. 
 By Suzanne Dempsey in Panama City 
 WHEN war breaks out, you don't get much warning. 
 We were woken a few minutes before one o'clock in the morning by a phone call from a friend who told us that the insistent thudding we could hear was American artillery fire. 
 Even though life has been tense in recent months, it's still a strange feeling when the city you live in is transformed into a battlefield. 
 After a normal day at the Panama Canal Commission's public affairs office in Balboa Heights, I had returned to my home in La Boca, formerly part of the canal zone and now on Panamanian territory. 
 My husband &mdash; an American who also works for the commission &mdash; and I went to bed after an uneventful evening. 
 At 12.49am the telephone rang. 
 Although there was a loud banging noise, it had been so regular that both of us had incorporated it into our dreams. 
 Now we knew it was artillery, it sounded terribly close. 
 Looking out of our window we saw US tanks coming over the Bridge of the Americas, which links the west bank of Panama &mdash; where some US bases are located &mdash; with the east side, on which the rest of the bases, most commission installations, the Panama Defence Forces (PDF) headquarters and Panama City itself, are situated. 
 From our patio we saw three streaks of red shoot towards Los Rios &mdash; a US civilian area. 
 As we stood there, watching smoke rising from Panama City, nearby machinegun fire sent us running indoors. 
 We grabbed the baby from her cot and crouched down in the hall of our house, thankful that it is made of concrete rather than wood. 
 By this time I was shaking and each new thud seemed louder and more terrifying than the last. 
 My husband kept vigil by a window, because of spasmodic machinegun fire very close by. 
 We didn't see a single soldier or vehicle and assumed that the US army was blocking off La Boca from the Panama Defence Force, whose local headquarters is only about 300 yards from our house. 
 At one point, a flare lit up the night sky. 
 Planes flew overhead constantly. 
 The artillery petered out somewhat from 3am to 4am and then started again. 
 At around 6am we heard heavy machinegun fire from the direction of the Deni, the investigative branch of the PDF, about half a mile from the commission headquarters and dangerously close to US and Panamanian civilian housing. 
 Several rounds from a sub-machinegun indicated that a lone member of the PDF may have got into the neighbourhood. 
 It is quite light now, but the delicate pinks and yellows of a tropical sunrise are obscured by a thick, black cloud of smoke. 
 Every now and then, we hear staccato bursts of gunfire, with the occasional thump of artillery. 
 For me, the daybreak brings new terrors. 
 Panama is a small place where everyone knows everyone else, and today I must find out which of my friends &mdash; US and Panamanian &mdash; are dead, wounded or bereaved. 
 Ceausescu defiant after massacre. 
 By Ian Traynor in Budapest 
 PRESIDENT Nicolae Ceausescu of Romania last night defied international condemnation of the massacre of demonstrators by his security forces at the weekend as reports indicated tens of thousands had again taken to the streets of in Timisoara, escalating the crisis. 
 A state of emergency was last night declared in the district where the killings took place. 
 Meetings of more than five people were banned and a night curfew was imposed on the western area of Timis near the Yugoslav and Hungarian borders. 
 Earlier, about 50,000 protesters were reported to have been chanting anti-government slogans in Timisoara and demanding that the bodies of victims be returned to their families. 
 Hungarian radio said the bodies were being dumped in mass graves. 
 The East German news agency ADN reported that up to 4,000 people had been killed. 
 It quoted Romanians living in East Germany who been in contact with relatives. 
 The Yugoslav Consul General in Timisoara, Mr Mirko Atamnarkovic, was quoted by the Yugoslav news agency Tanjug as saying tens of thousands were demonstrating in the town. 
 He said security forces were out in strength but did not intervene. 
 Tanjug also claimed 36 children were among those killed at the weekend and police fired into the bodies of the wounded. 
 The Hungarian report said many members of the security forces joined the insurgents, who were acquiring weapons, probably from the army and police. 
 As the Kremlin issued strong signals to the dictatorship, and the Hungarian Socialist and Yugoslav Communist parties broke links with the Romanian party, President Ceausescu went on national television to blame the violence on &bquo;hooligans, terrorists and spies&equo; organised from abroad. 
 Within hours of his return from a three-day visit to Iran, he said &bquo;imperialist and revanchist circles and foreign espionage centres&equo; were behind the actions. 
 The remarks appeared to be directed principally at Hungary. 
 Both countries have long been embroiled in a row over the Hungarian minority in northern and western Romania. 
 As more reports emerged, putting the death toll in Timisoara between several hundred and several thousand, Mr Ceausescu said the security forces had displayed great patience and had fulfilled their duty towards &bquo;the homeland, people and socialist achievements&equo;. 
 His address, delivered with the entire government and his wife Elena lined up behind him, did nothing to tackle the problems that have sparked discontent. 
 The Hungarian Foreign Minister, Mr Gyula Horn, broke his country's silence on the crisis to say that several hundred people had been killed or wounded at the weekend. 
 He accused the Romanian authorities of behaving brutally and demanded the immediate release of Pastor Laszlo Tokes, the ethnic Hungarian clergyman whose harassment by the authorities 
 Turn to page 20, col 3. 
 continued from page one sparked the wave of unrest. 
 Hungarian radio reported that people arriving from Bucharest said the army had been mobilised and that reservists were called in on Tuesday night. 
 The Defence Minister, Mr Ferenc Karpati, told the Hungarian parliament that the troops used were not from the regular army but from the Securitate secret police, whose uniforms are similar and who are equipped with tanks and sophisticated weapons. 
 Mr Zoltan Kiraly, a Hungarian MP, demanded an emergency Warsaw Pact meeting on the crisis. 
 Meanwhile, Mr Lhea Munteanu, a Soviet MP from Moldavia, reported further demonstrations yesterday in the towns of Iasi and Arad, and elsewhere in the country. 
 &bquo;These events are occurring now because human rights have been violated for a long time,&equo; he said. 
 The strongest signal of Moscow's fury with the intransigent Romanian regime came when Pravda, the Communist Party daily newspaper, reported favourably on the demonstrators in Timisoara, saying that they were looking for rapid reforms in the country. 
 The whereabouts of Pastor Tokes remained unclear, amid unconfirmed reports that he had been murdered. 
 A Hungarian source told the Guardian the pastor's family believed he had been taken to a village in north-eastern Transylvania, near the Hungarian border. 
 A Romanian national table tennis player, Mr Simion Crisan, is reported to have appealed to West Germany for political asylum, according to sports officials. 
 Clergy take the lead, page 8 
 Police drive to recruit more blacks. 
 By John Carvel and David Rose 
 THE Metropolitan Police are launching a recruitment campaign among blacks and Asians next year following criticism by MPs yesterday of low recruitment figures and a disturbingly high wastage rate among the ethnic minorities. 
 So far this year 26 black or Asian officers have left while only 35 have been recruited. 
 London police chiefs are understood, however, already to have been planning an initiative early next year which would lower height requirements. 
 These are seen as a barrier to many Asians. 
 The package will also include &bquo;special access courses&equo; so that aspiring black recruits without the required educational qualifications can satisfy admissions board standards. 
 There will be an intensive campaign of advertisements, local authority initiatives, and seminars. 
 Black personalities are being approached to become &bquo;father figures&equo; who would encourage suspicious youths to regard the police service as an acceptable career. 
 There may also be bursaries and scholarships for black undergraduates &mdash; an ethnic version of schemes run in the universities by the armed services. 
 The report by the all-party Commons home affairs committee yesterday on racial attacks and harassment finds that serious reported offences have declined but that the total of less serious incidents has increased. 
 &bquo;Most disturbingly&hellip; the vulnerability of the Asian community worsened between 1981 and 1987. 
 &bquo;At present, only about one per cent of police officers in England and Wales and about 1.5 per cent of Metropolitan Police officers are from racial minorities.&equo; 
 The impetus of ethnic recruitment drives in 1986 and 1987 had been lost. 
 The committee proposes relaxation of height requirements and an equal opportunities policy &bquo;based on a genuine commitment to increase the proportion of police officers from the ethnic minorities to match the proportion in the local population.&equo; 
 Ethnic minority groups account for 3.9 per cent of the economically-active working age population in Britain and about 10 per cent in London. 
 There are no black or Asian officers in the ranks of chief superintendent or above and only one superintendent, recently appointed in Leicestershire. 
 There is also very low ethnic recruitment to police civilian jobs. 
 The MPs also call on the Home Office to investigate the frequency of racial attacks. 
 Mr Keith Vaz, a Labour member of the committee said: &bquo;There is still a lack of confidence in the police force among black and Asian people. 
 The statistics we have on the number of racial incidents are not accurate because there is gross under-reporting.&equo; 
 The committee concludes: &bquo;Despite the progress made racism and its most ugly manifestations, racial attacks and harassment, are still frightening realities for many British citizens.&equo; 
 Mr David Waddington, the Home Secretary, deplored &bquo;this obnoxious and criminal behaviour.&equo; 
 Racial attacks and harassment; Home Affairs Committee; HMSO &pound;7.40 
 Ford faces strike over pay deal. 
 By Keith Harper Labour Editor 
 THE Ford Motor Company faces an all-out strike next month following the 4-1 ballot rejection yesterday of a two-year pay deal by its 32,000 hourly paid workers. 
 They will be pressing for a settlement of more than 10 per cent in what will be the most severe test of the Government's inflation policy. 
 The two-year deal amounted to 9.5 per cent for the first year and inflation plus 2.5 per cent for the second. 
 Improvements in certain allowances were made, described as divisive by the unions, but the company has refused to compromise on a reduction in the shorter working week. 
 Ford dismissed an immediate meeting with the unions but did not rule out talks after Christmas. 
 It said that a strike would be damaging to the company and to its staff. 
 Production closed down at Ford last night for the Christmas period. 
 Plants will open again on January 2. 
 Staff voted 20,343 in favour of action, with 4,727 against. 
 The electricians are holding a postal ballot with the results announced after Christmas. 
 The unions said that they were looking for the second week in January to begin an all-out stoppage. 
 Mr Jimmy Airlie, secretary of the Ford union side, said: &bquo;We expected to get a favourable majority. 
 This exceeded even our expectations.&equo; 
 Mr Jack Adams, chairman of the union side, said that action would have to take place within a 28-day period from yesterday's anouncement or it would be ruled out of order. 
 He thought the big strike vote was partly due to Ford's record profits last year of &pound;673 millions. 
 The company is likely to be affected by a series of unofficial stoppages before any official action begins, as it was in the lead up to negotiations when Ford's final offer was rejected last month. 
 Patten preserves Foxley Wood. 
 THE ENVIRONMENT Secretary, Mr Chris Patten, yesterday finally rejected plans to build a new town of 4,800 homes at Foxley Wood, Hampshire, saying the county council should come up with fresh county-wide plans. 
 Dismissing an apppeal against a planning decision, the minister said he did not believe it was possible to solve Hampshire's housing problems by allowing pockets of development. 
 But the planning authorities could not resist all new development. 
 Nor could they turn their backs on the housing needs of the people already living in the county. 
 &bquo;That is why I want Hampshire county council to come forward quickly with fresh proposals on a county-wide basis which have regard to the current regional guidance housing provision figures.&equo; 
 It is estimated Hampshire will need 66,500 new homes between 1991 and 2001. 
 Mr Patten said that his Foxley Wood decision did not imply rejection of the concept of new settlements. 
 Mr Patten also rejected plans for 2,500 homes at Eversley and 2,000 at Hook, both in Hampshire. 
 &bquo;Polluter pays&equo; philosophy underpins bill. 
 By Paul Brown. 
 THE central plank of the bill is the curb on the country's biggest industrial polluters by making them use the best available technology to cut discharges. 
 They will pay for licences to release substances they cannot economically recycle or recover. 
 More sweeping changes to deal with the threat of global warming will have to wait for the Government's environment white paper under discussion in cabinet committee. 
 The bill brings a host of new controls and regulations which, if fully implemented, would make polluting the environment an expensive option both for industry and individuals. 
 The big question mark over it is whether there is the political will in Whitehall to keep Mr Patten's pledge to provide the resources to police the environment. 
 One of its key provisions is the creation of registers, open to the public, which show details of licences and who pollutes the environment. 
 The original promise was to allow enough information to be placed on record for the public to know who was breaking the law, and when, so prosecutions could be brought if necessary. 
 If the Government backs off from this promise and retreats into &bquo;average&equo; discharges, avoiding mention of breaches of licences, public confidence in the bill will be undermined. 
 Pollution Control: A comprehensive plan is introduced for modernising pollution control by looking at discharges from big factories to air, water and land as one big package, requiring one licence. 
 It obliges industrialists to employ &bquo;the best available technology not entailing excessive costs&equo;, a European Community concept. 
 Operators will have a &bquo;residual duty&equo; to minimise the impact of their discharges on the environment. 
 This will apply to around 3,000 of Britain's worst polluting processes, including those that produce the so-called red list substances &mdash; heavy metals and chemicals most dangerous to man and the environment. 
 These will have to be rendered harmless. 
 The whole scheme will be policed by Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution, currently seriously understaffed with suitable recruits hard to find. 
 Industry preparing for the Government legislation is luring inspectors away faster than they can be recruited to enforce it. 
 Mr Patten has promised enough resources for the inspectorate to solve this problem but it may be years before it is strong enough to effectively enforce its new duties. 
 Waste: Local authorities already have a key role in waste disposal but the bill creates new duties and involves a form of back-door privatisation. 
 Existing waste disposal operations will have to be put out to private or arms-length companies so the local authority's policing role cannot be mixed with its disposal role. 
 Local authorities will be responsible for controlling discharges from smaller factories and license provisions for waste disposal contractors. 
 New powers to refuse wastes and revoke licences are potentially powerful weapons in controlling the movement and safe disposal of wastes. 
 Producers of wastes will have a &bquo;duty of care&equo; to make sure they are disposed of properly. 
 This makes them liable to prosecution long after the wastes have left their premises. 
 Trans-frontier shipments of hazardous wastes also comes under new controls. 
 There will be moves to tighten up this part of the bill in the Commons to try to stop some of the waste imports from countries which can dispose of them but find it politically expedient to export them. 
 At the moment, local authorities, which are supposed to police many of the new controls, do not have either the expertise or the money to make them work. 
 Conservation bodies: Proposals for dismembering the Nature Conservancy Council and the Countryside Commission in favour of three bodies for England, Scotland and Wales, have diverted attention from other parts of the bill. 
 Threats of a Lords revolt remain, with Mr Patten's attempts to defuse the row having failed. 
 Conservation groups believe the original decision was a political move to cut the clout of the council which was stopping development, particularly forestry in Scotland. 
 The resignation of the organisation's chief scientist last week after four months in the post has fuelled these fears. 
 Genetic Engineering: This is a first attempt to legislate in this area, currently dealt with by voluntary codes of practice, because science has been moving quicker than the law makers. 
 It involves moral and practical problems which cross political and ethical boundaries. 
 For example, legally enforceable rules need to be applied to crops such as genetically altered, frost-resistant potatoes. 
 The change makes the potato a potential weed. 
 Possibly more troublesome and dangerous are micro-organisms which can be used in agricultural and medical applications but once released cannot be recaptured. 
 Genetically-engineered organisms mutate and develop their own new lifestyles. 
 One of the best natural examples of this is the ability of the flu virus to keep cropping up in new forms. 
 Litter and Recycling: Industry will have to prepare to take recycled waste rather than use raw materials and the legislation may need the boost of tax incentives. 
 Changing the habits of people used to throwing away litter will need a few highly publicised prosecutions. 
 Friends of the Earth award &bquo;Green Con&equo; to BNF advert. 
 By James Erlichman, Consumer Affairs Corrrespondent 
 BRITISH Nuclear Fuels, yesterday won the first &bquo;Green Con Award,&equo; conceived last September by Friends of the Earth. 
 Runner-up was Higgs Furs, of Westcliff-on-Sea, Essex, for its claim that real furs are more environmentally friendly than fake furs made from polluting synthetic fibres. 
 The winners were chosen from more than 280 nominations and judges included Mr Ian Hislop, editor of Private Eye, and Julia Hailes, environmental author. 
 The BNF full-page newspaper advertisement claimed nuclear power stations do not produce carbon dioxide but neglected to address the problem of nuclear discharges and radioactive waste. 
 Mr Jonathon Porritt, director of FOE, said that a typical nuclear plant created 230,000 tonnes of carbon dioxide each year once construction of the plant and mining and enriching of uranium were taken into account. 
 A spokesman for BNFL said: &bquo;We were not playing on fears, just presenting the facts, although we could not address all the issues in one advertisment.&equo; 
 Mr John Higgs Wilson, a partner in the 101-year-old furs firm said: &bquo;We don't withdraw one word. 
 Synthetic furs are made from chemicals which create toxic waste.&equo; 
 Other winners included: Aerosol makers, for making ozone friendly claims while using methyl chloroform, which damages the ozone layer, as a propellant; Monsanto, for claiming its conventional weedkiller was a &bquo;green&equo; product; and Procter &amp; Gamble, for claiming that its Bold liquid detergent in a conventional plastic bottle enjoyed &bquo;disposable packaging.&equo; 
 Ignore this: Councils to get wider powers. 
 By Andrew Culf 
 THE 120-clause Environmental Protection Bill, which was published yesterday, sets out a series of reforms to key areas of pollution control. 
 Its main provisions include: 
 Pollution control: A system of integrated control will be introduced. 
 It is described as a new approach to the regulation of emissions to air, land and sea from most polluting processes, and will apply the concept of &bquo;best available techniques not entailing excessive cost&equo;. 
 Factories will be required to obtain prior authorisation from Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution to carry out industrial processes. 
 The conditions are designed to prevent or minimise the release of the most dangerous polluting substances. 
 Local authorities will be given new powers over a second tier of less heavily polluting processes, which will only be allowed to take place after councils have imposed stringent operating conditions. 
 Waste: Tighter controls on dealing with waste are proposed with regulation carefully separated from those involved in waste disposal. 
 Responsibility for waste will rest on the person who produces it, and everyone who handles it through to the process of disposal or reclamation. 
 Only &bquo;fit and proper&equo; people will be allowed to run waste sites and operators will have to care for their sites until all risks of gas or pollution have passed. 
 The Government will be able to control international shipments of waste. 
 Local authorities' waste disposal operations will be set up as &bquo;competitive arm's length&equo; companies to be separate from councils' responsibilities for policing environmental standards. 
 Waste regulation authorities will be more closely scrutinised by the inspectorate and councils will have to plan for recycling, for which they will also be given wider powers. 
 Nuisances: A streamlining of local authority procedures to make the tackling of noise nuisances simpler is proposed. 
 Regulations over smoke, grit, dust and fume emissions will also be tightened. 
 Litter: Stiffer penalities will be introduced for the dropping of litter. 
 Councils will be given the power to operate fixed penalty schemes like that operated by Westminster city council. 
 The maximum fine in magistrates' courts will be increased from &pound;400 to &pound;1,000. 
 Local authorities, educational establishments and other landowners will have to keep their public land clear of litter, and citizens will be able to apply to the courts for a &bquo;litter abatement order&equo; to ensure they do so. 
 District and borough councils will become wholly responsible for cleaning all roads except motorways. 
 Radioactive waste: Exemptions enjoyed by the UK Atomic Energy Authority and Crown premises over the storage and disposal of radioactive waste will end. 
 Local authorities will be required to hold public registers of information. 
 Additional powers will be introduced for the issue of immediate enforcement and prohibition notices where the rules are being broken, or where there is a risk of environmental harm. 
 Genetically modified organisms: The bill provides for additional safeguards against the import, containment and release of Genetically Modified Organisms. 
 Those using GMOs will face a new general &bquo;duty of care&equo; to prevent significant harm to the environment. 
 A unified system of administrative control, involving the Department of Environment, the Health and Safety Executive, and other interested parties, will be developed for those proposing to use GMOs. 
 Nature Conservancy Council: The organisation will be split into three agencies to cover England, Scotland and Wales. 
 In Wales the responsibilities of the NCC will be combined with those of the Countryside Commission. 
 A joint committee of the three new agencies will be established to provide scientific standards and advice on wider nature conservation issues affecting the whole of Britain or European commitments. 
 Mr Chris Patten, the Environment Secretary, said that an independent chairman will be appointed to the new joint committee, and will be named during the bill's parliamentary passage in January. 
 Hazardous chemicals: New powers over the storage and disposal of hazardous chemicals will be introduced. 
 Existing powers over importation, use and supply of hazardous chemicals will be extended. 
 Dumping at sea: New powers governing dumping at sea will give Britain the widest controls in Europe. 
 Any vessel dumping at sea without a British licence within Britain's waters will face a maximum fine of &pound;50,000, which has been increased from &pound;2,000. 
 Chemicals: The Government plans further controls later over chemicals to form a legal framework for the systematic evaluation of potentially harmful effects of industrial chemicals on health and the environment. 
 The information will be used to support British contributions to international programmes on the assessment of hazardous chemicals, including a proposed European Community regulation. 
 Stubble burning: Straw and stubble burning will be banned from 1992. 
 150,000 will be tested anonymously for HIV virus. 
 By Nigel Williams Science Correspondent 
 ABOUT 120,000 pregnant women and 30,000 people attending sexually-transmitted disease clinics will be tested anonymously for HIV next year, the Department of Health said yesterday. 
 Mrs Virginia Bottomley, the Health Minister of State, said the tests would help assess the prevalence of the virus in the population for the purpose of planning health education and the provision of services. 
 She went on: &bquo;Information at the moment comes from people who come forward voluntarily for testing, which inevitably is a biased sample.&equo; 
 The programme, which starts on January 15, will involve 10 ante-natal clinics and five sexually-transmitted disease clinics in several cities in England and Wales. 
 The names will not be announced until next month. 
 Later next year patients in general hospitals will be also be tested. 
 Explanatory leaflets and posters in several languages offer people the option of not allowing their blood to be tested. 
 Where blood is taken from a patient for another purpose, a small sample of blood may be tested for HIV. 
 The sample would be stored on a culture plate showing only the patient's age and the location of the laboratory. 
 At intervals these plates would be sent to central laboratories to be tested. 
 Mrs Bottomley said that the United States was the only other country carrying out anonymous HIV tests. 
 &bquo;These have been extremely helpful in determining the shape of the epidemic and not subject to any criticism,&equo; she said. 
 Lawyers want more protection for people with stake in homes. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 PEOPLE who help buy the homes they live in but whose names are not on the title deeds should be able to stop the legal owner selling over their heads, the Law Commission for England and Wales recommended yesterday. 
 At present, they are entitled to a share in the sale proceeds but cannot forestall a sale by staying in the house. 
 The recommendation would help married or unmarried partners whose homes are held in the other partner's name. 
 It would cover parents living in a &bquo;granny flat,&equo; grown-up children sharing a home with their parents, and families in a business partnership. 
 The commission suggests that anyone over 18 who has contributed to the cost of the property he or she occupies should have to agree to its sale. 
 The court would have power to dispense with the non-owner's consent if justified. 
 The commission referred to a recent case decided by the Law Lords. 
 A young couple and the wife's parents bought a house together but only the younger couple were registered as owners. 
 They took out a mortgage without telling the older couple. 
 When they got into arrears, all four had to go. 
 The proposed change would have prevented the older couple from being evicted unless they had consented either to the mortgage or the later sale. 
 Mother wins on L-instructors. 
 The junior transport minister, Mr Robert Atkins, proposed yesterday that drivers supervising a learner must be at least 21 and have had a full licence for at least three years. 
 This follows a campaign by Mrs Victoria Stone, of Kingswinford, West Midlands, whose daughter, Kate, aged 17, died in a crash as the L-driver was being supervised by a 17-year-old. 
 Lecturers claim 27pc. 
 The council of the Association of University Teachers backed a claim drawn up by the union's executive for a 27 per cent pay rise from next April. 
 Woman's car found. 
 The car of shop assistant Miss Ruth Stevens, aged 33, who disappeared eight days ago in Warminster, Wiltshire, was found in Islington, north London. 
 Speeding fine for MP. 
 Mr Jack Cunningham, shadow Leader of the House, was fined &pound;150 after admitting driving at 103 mph. 
 Life for woman's killer. 
 Donald Mackay, aged 41, was jailed for life at the Old Bailey &mdash; and recommended to serve at least 40 years &mdash; for the murder of a prostitute, Ann Petherick, and for assaulting another prostitute, Rosemary Saunders. 
 Wapping claim settled. 
 The Metropolitan Police settled in the High Court the damages claim of cameraman Mr Anthony Walsh, whose spine was injured during the Wapping dispute. 
 Terms were not disclosed. 
 McCarthy advert banned. 
 The Independent Broadcasting Authority banned a radio advert of the Friends of John McCarthy to mark his fourth Christmas as a hostage because it broke political rules. 
 Bush invasion of Panama courageous, says PM. 
 By Hella Pick and Alan Travis 
 THE Soviet Union yesterday strongly condemned the US invasion of Panama. 
 But Mrs Thatcher endorsed the US action, saying it was necessary &bquo;to bring an end to this rule of terror&equo;. 
 After Mr Bush had told her of the US military action by telephone at 7am, an hour after his troops moved in, Mrs Thatcher told reporters: &bquo;I believe he was right to do so. 
 I believe this is what friends are for, to give support at this time. 
 It was a courageous decision.&equo; 
 She said the support of other world leaders &bquo;would give a great morale boost to those soldiers who are fighting &mdash; they have to bear the brunt of the battle to uphold democracy.&equo; 
 But the Soviet Union warned that the invasion had dealt a blow to growing co-operation in US-Soviet relations. 
 By extension, Mrs Thatcher's quick endorsement is likely to backfire on Britain's standing in Moscow. 
 The rest of Nato was divided, with Spain &bquo;deeply lamenting&equo; the US action, the Netherlands supportive, and France reserving judgment. 
 None of the allies, however, wants to be directly involved. 
 On the contrary, the US decision, which was taken without consultation or advance notice, will act as a strong deterrent to accepting a US proposal last week that the Alliance should involve itself in regional issues outside Europe. 
 In Latin America, the Group of Eight leading countries in Central and South America called an emergency meeting. 
 Colombia, which is president of the UN Security Council, called an informal session. 
 Countries across Latin America attacked the US action. 
 Venezuela, a fierce critic of Gen Noriega, said the invasion should be condemned and rejected. 
 Brazil called it a step backward in international relations and Mexico called for an immediate cessation of hostilities. 
 Chile called for an end to the fighting and refused to recognise the new Panamanian leader, Mr Guillermo Endara. 
 Nicaragua said its army had been placed on &bquo;a maximum state of alert&equo; because of the &bquo;brutal aggression&equo; by the US. 
 President Alan Gacia of Peru called for a planned summit on February 15 with President Bush to discuss drugs to be &bquo;deferred&equo; because of the invasion. 
 He described the US action as &bquo;an outrage to Latin America&equo;. 
 It &bquo;reproduces the most grotesque practices of imperialism&equo;, he said. 
 Peru recalled its ambassador to Washington. 
 Cuba issued a call to arms in support of the people of Panama against &bquo;imperialist aggression&equo;. 
 Iran and Libya predictably were vehemently against the action, which Colonel Muammar Gadafy described as &bquo;state terrorism that made Hitler look like an angel&equo;. 
 The Soviet Union was ready with its condemnation, almost as fast as Mrs Thatcher was with her welcome. 
 Mr Vadim Perfilyev, a Soviet Foreign Ministry spokesman, said it was &bquo;a violation of the UN Charter. 
 The US should stop its armed intervention in Panama immediately.&equo; 
 Tass carried a statement accusing the US of applying &bquo;the laws of the jungle and gunboat diplomacy&equo;. 
 US and British officials saw Soviet expressions of displeasure as ritualistic, and the least that Moscow could do for its allies in Nicaragua and Cuba. 
 But there were indications that Mr Gorbachev feels compromised and personally let down by President Bush after their talks in Malta earlier this month, when both leaders undertook to consult on actions that could undermine international stability. 
 President Bush and Mrs Thatcher denied yesterday that there was any comparison between Panama and Eastern Europe, and argued that the US action was in defence of democracy. 
 Labour condemned General Noriega as a corrupt dictator, but Mr Gerald Kaufman, the shadow Foreign Secretary, demanded to know what rationale in international law there was for the invasion. 
 The author Graham Greene, a passionate defender of Panamanian sovereignty, said Gen Noriega was not &bquo;half as bad&equo; as Washington's record in Central America. 
 Condemning the US action, he said: &bquo;The US has no business interfering in Panama.&equo; 
 Battle for Panama, pages 10 and 11; Leader comment, page 18; Still trapped in the jungle, page 19 
 High Court grants permission for full trial of solicitor accused of negligence over &pound;4m will after six-year wrangle that has tied legal profession in knots Milestone in brother's &bquo;crusade for justice&equo;. 
 By Joanna Coles 
 AFTER six years of tortuous legal battles, Mr Thomas Mathew was yesterday granted permission in the High Court for a full trial in his action against the solicitor who held his brother's will for &pound;4 million. 
 In the past six years he has represented himself before 34 High Court judges, 25 Masters, 14 Registrars, four stipendary magistrates, two Justices of the Peace, and four Scottish sheriffs Yesterday was his 239th court appearance. 
 He is suing Jocelyn Timothy Thomas, a solicitor who held his late brother's will at the time of his death, for negligence to the tune of &pound;4 million. 
 If the High Court decides in his favour he will be a rich man. 
 If he loses, he says he will begin all over again. 
 Plump, scarlet-faced through high blood pressure and wheezing with crusading zeal, Mr Mathew is the sort of character Dickens liked to create. 
 Married to Princess Olga Romanoff, a great niece of the last Czar, he claims to have survived three attempts on his life. 
 The combined talents of Kafka and Jackie Collins could not have produced his story. 
 It is a tale of one man's obsession, against his family and against an apparent injustice which has deprived him of more than &pound;1 million. 
 To prove his point he has taken on the legal profession and, with no legal training whatsoever, tied judges in such knots they have overruled each other. 
 Mr Mathew's story begins with a death, that of his elder brother, Theobald, in July 1983, who left a will stating that his &pound;1 million estate should be split among his four younger brothers. 
 That part at least is uncontested, but for various complex legal reasons it took Thomas, an executor of the will, nine months to get probate. 
 During that time three solicitors were, he alleges, unlawfully granted powers to administer the estate. 
 The estate turned out to be worth &pound;5 million and among them, Mr Mathew also alleges, the three solicitors disposed of &pound;3.8 million. 
 The case has pitched brother against brother and mother against son. 
 In November 1983, a registrar ordered the grant of letters of administration to the three solicitors to be rendered null and void and Thomas thought the case was over. 
 It was just beginning. 
 A month later the decision was appealed against and in March 1984, the appeal was allowed although the registrar's order was amended to make the granting of the letters temporary. 
 The unprecedented judgment was then published in the All England Law Reports but two months later the grant of letters was ruled void by another judge. 
 Numerous court hearings brought by a combination of the four brothers and their solicitors followed. 
 In January 1987, yet another judge stated that the March ruling was, in fact, in breach of statute but as it had not been appealed against it had to stand. 
 In another hearing, the Vice Chancellor, Sir Nicolas Browne-Wilkinson, declared the history of the management of the estate to be &bquo;disastrous&equo;. 
 After three years, during which he had to cope with the death of his youngest son, Mr Mathew was denied leave to appeal against the March 1984 judgment. 
 The judge said he had left it too late, although he agreed the appeal would have been successful. 
 So the March judgment still stands, in breach of statute, giving temporary administrative powers to parties unnamed by a will. 
 In order to expose what appears to be a series of monstrous, incomprehensible legal blunders, Mr Mathew gave up work in 1983. 
 He has not seen his wife or their three children since July since he cannot afford to travel home to Banchory, near Aberdeen. 
 Unavailable for work, he relies on friends for food, lodgings and money. 
 His main expense is photocopying thousands of legal documents and he spends his days preparing the next part of his case. 
 Even his opponents acknowledge his tenacity. 
 Jocelyn Thomas, the subject of next week's appeal, says &bquo;his crusade is more moral than financial. 
 I liked him when I met him and I still like him now. 
 It's terribly sad, but what the justice or reality is, well, I have lost any contact with that.&equo; 
 Mr Mathew claims that as long as the temporary grant is allowed to remain &mdash; in breach of statute &mdash; anyone who makes a will is similarly vulnerable. 
 &bquo;All I want to do is claim what is rightfully mine and ensure the wishes of my brother are carried out. 
 That's all I have ever wanted to do.&equo; 
 And so next February, when the full trial is due to begin, the High Court will be mistily engaged in one of the 10,000 stages of another endless cause. 
 Just as in Jarndyce vs Jarndyce in Bleak House, Thomas Mathew will watch them &bquo;tripping one another up on slippery precedents, warding heads against walls of words, until they deliver a verdict&equo;. 
 Thomas Mathew&hellip; 239th court appearance yesterday 
 Hong Kong passports plan divides Commons. 
 By Michael White and Mark Milner 
 AFTER months of ministerial indecision, the Government's formula for restoring confidence in Hong Kong emerged last night to a mixed response from a bitterly divided House of Commons &mdash; and no more than a guarded welcome from the colony itself. 
 There were fears that the compromise announced by Mr Douglas Hurd, the Foreign Secretary, which will give full British passports to 50,000 key personnel and their families &mdash; 225,000 people &mdash; could prove the worst of all worlds. 
 This falls well short of the target set by Honour Hong Kong, a pressure group drawn from the colony's business community. 
 A report commissioned by the group identified a total of 315,000 staff which the colony needed to keep. 
 As the figure does not cover families, yesterday's decision to grant rights of entry to 50,000 households is likely to cover less than 20 per cent of those it targeted. 
 Mr Simon Murray, leader of Honour Hong Kong, said: &bquo;I am not saying we are over the moon, but it is progress.&equo; 
 The Hong Kong Government welcomed the move, saying the package would &bquo;help to re-establish confidence&equo;. 
 But in the Commons, the most striking feature of MPs' reaction was a chaotic cross-party divide. 
 Mr Hurd urged them not to make &bquo;the last main chapter in the story of this country's Empire&equo; a shadowy one. 
 The split saw Mr Norman Tebbit align the Tory Right with the Labour front bench, while Ulster Unionists, the Scottish Nationalists, the SDP, a few Labour leftwingers and the Liberal Democrats signalled grudging support for the Cabinet, which needs every vote it can get to pass the promised bill next spring. 
 Conservative loyalists rallied, but the rebels were bitter. 
 &bquo;Now it all depends which way public opinion goes,&equo; said one. 
 Ministers believe the public will respond decently. 
 They were adamant that their scheme, a compromise between the Foreign Office and the harder line sought by Mr David Waddington, the Home Secretary, is the best way to prevent a mass refugee crisis if Hong Kong collapses before 1997. 
 The Government still has to work out a points system whereby a cross-section of Hong Kong residents, whose skills are needed, will be given full British citizenship rights between 1992 and 1997. 
 Labour believes a points system will rally its party to oppose the bill. 
 Unlike existing immigration criteria, wealth will not be a factor, though seniority, British ties and usefulness to Hong Kong will. 
 Mr Hurd stressed that no citizens of other Commonwealth countries will be allowed in as a result of the bill. 
 It was designed to persuade people not to come to Britain. 
 That was the hope &mdash; and paradox &mdash; of yesterday's strategy. 
 In his statement, broadcast live to the colony, the Foreign Secretary struggled to balance his &bquo;desire to be as effective as possible in restoring confidence&equo; with what he politely called &bquo;our ability to accept the individuals concerned for settlement in this country &mdash; should that ever be necessary&equo;. 
 It amounted to a coded acknowledgement of the barely-supressed rage of Conservative MPs, mostly on the right, whose concern over a fresh wave of &bquo;large-scale immigration&equo; hitting overcrowded facilities in Britain was clothed yesterday in language close to that of Mr Gerald Kaufman, the shadow Foreign Secretary, who called the plan &bquo;inherently unworkable, invidious and divisive&equo;, and demanded details on how it would work. 
 Mr Tebbit, a former Tory chairman, told Mr Hurd he disagreed with almost everything he said and agreed with almost everything Mr Kaufman said. 
 Conservative loyalists said Mr Tebbit had made a blunder, but he showed no sign of backing off from &bquo;one of the things that brought me into politics &mdash; the belief that immigration should be reduced&equo;. 
 Mr Paddy Ashdown, for the Liberal-Democrats said the numbers &bquo;fell far short of the necessary minimum&equo;. 
 Politics, page 5; Offer fails to restore confidence, page 8; Leader comment, page 18 
 US puts &dollar;1m price on Panama strongman's head &bquo;40 American hostages taken&equo; Bush overthrows Noriega. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 GENERAL Manuel Noriega remained at large and skirmishing continued around Panama last night, as an ugly and protracted guerrilla war and a potential hostage crisis threatened President Bush's hopes of a brisk Christmas victory in America's back yard. 
 The US announced it will pay a &dollar;1 million reward for information leading to the general's capture. 
 The White House said it would also pay &dollar;150 for each Panamanian gun turned in. 
 Mr Bush said yesterday that &bquo;key military objectives have been achieved&equo; by the 24,000 US troops, whose Operation Just Cause invasion replaced the dictatorship of Gen Noriega with a constitutionally-elected civilian government. 
 Sixteen hours after the first assault, the Pentagon said the invasion force had ended &bquo;all organised resistance&equo; by the Panamamian Defence Force, although scattered soldiers were still fighting. 
 Strongholds of the so-called Dignity Battalions civil militia in Panama City had yet to be reduced, and some tough street fighting lay ahead, Pentagon officials said. 
 The Pentagon said 250 prisoners had been taken and the forces of two other organised battalions had been scattered. 
 Four US helicopters had been put out of action. 
 Noriega loyalists were holding out last night in a key barracks, despite overwhelming US firepower. 
 US forces used loudhailers to urge them to surrender amid intermittent explosions of gun and cannon fire. 
 The operation could be &bquo;mopped up&equo; in three days, but troops may stay in place to perform a policing function, General Tom Kelly, a Pentagon official, said. 
 Last night, Gen Noriega's armed militia were still setting up roadblocks in the city's main financial district, while the new civilian government, headed by Mr Guillermo Endara, was kept under guard by the US military, which said it was too risky for it to appear in public. 
 Mr Endara was elected in the spring, but Gen Noriega annulled the poll. 
 The Soviet Union swiftly condemned the invasion, saying it was a blow to growing warmth in US-Soviet relations. 
 But Mrs Thatcher backed the &bquo;courageous&equo; US action. 
 Mr Bush sent a private cable to Mr Gorbachev explaining the reasons for the US military intervention just after the operation began, the Secretary of State, Mr James Baker, said. 
 But he added there was some evidence suggesting it did not arrive before Moscow issued its condemnation of the US action. 
 While Democrats in Congress gave support to the President's decision to launch the biggest US military operation since the Vietnam War, Russia expressed &bquo;deep concern&equo; for what it dubbed gunboat diplomacy which violated the UN Charter. 
 Eleven US troops died and 59 were injured in the operation. 
 Sixty civilians were reported dead and up to 1,000 wounded. 
 Panamanian military casualties were not known. 
 The fighting began with US parachute assaults at 1am, and a tank-led assault on the headquarters of the Panama Defence Forces caused widespread damage in the heart of the city. 
 The headquarters was burnt to the ground. 
 While all Panamanian military posts were reported secured yesterday, and US electronic warfare teams jammed most Panamanian-controlled TV and radio broadcasts, at least one central radio station remained in the hands of Noriega supporters, rallying the militia to resist the US invasion, and claiming to hold 40 American hostages. 
 There was no confirmation of the claim, although there was no contact with the CBS and ABC TV correspondents, who were said to be among them. 
 Twelve hostages, including journalists from Reuters and the New York Times, were seized in the early hours yesterday, before being released by pro-Noriega armed civilians, who urged them to &bquo;tell the story of the American invasion&equo;. 
 General Colin Powell, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, said: &bquo;The operation is not over yet. 
 Mr Noriega is in hiding. 
 We will chase him and we will find him. 
 We have decapitated him from the leadership of his country. 
 He is not running anything. 
 We own all the bases. 
 We have cut off the head of that government.&equo; 
 He acknowledged that &bquo;having him loose does raise the potential that he might make more mischief, take to the hills and be very hard to find&equo;. 
 Mr Bush, in a dawn TV address yesterday, said his objectives were to protect American lives, to restore democracy and an elected government to Panama, to bring &bquo;the indicted drug trafficker&equo;, Gen Noriega to American justice, and &bquo;to ensure the integrity of the Panama Canal treaties&equo;. 
 &bquo;I will continue to seek solutions to the problems of this region through dialogue and multilateral diplomacy.&equo; 
 The President decided upon military intervention on Sunday, after a weekend of harassment of US citizens, and a year of humiliation at Noriega's hands. 
 The accusations of incompetence after the botched attempt to support the anti-Noriega coup in October had stung the Bush Administration. 
 According to the Tass news agency, which was in contact with Noriega supporters, the US strike failed to arrest any of his leaders. 
 The fighting, which had died down during the night, flared again as dawn came, and US Cobra gunships began to fly over Panama City. 
 Shooting, explosions and mortar bombs were heard intermittently throughout the day, from scattered locations including the inner city, Fort Amador and San Miguelito. 
 The canal, closed for the first time in its 75-year history, will reopen for daytime operations today. 
 &bquo;Manuel Noriega, who was yesterday's Panama's maximum leader, is today a hunted fugitive,&equo; Mr Baker said. 
 He stressed that the US would abide by the Canal Treaty timetable to hand over the canal to Panamanian rule. 
 &bquo;Give it a chance. 
 Democracy will take over in Panama,&equo; Mr Baker insisted. 
 Battle for Panama, pages 10 and 11; City Notebook, page 12; Leader comment, page 18; Still trapped in the jungle, page 19; War shatters sunrise, page 20 
 Fowler falls in line on charter. 
 By Michael White, Chief Political Correspondent 
 THE Government will today fall into line with the European Community's proposed Social Charter when the right of workers to belong &mdash; as well as not to belong &mdash; to a trade union is enshrined in its Employment Bill. 
 It will mean trade union members refused work by anti-union firms or blacklisted by groups such as the Economic League on grounds of union membership, will be able to get industrial tribunals to direct employers to hire them &mdash; or pay compensation of up to &pound;8,900. 
 National security grounds will still enable ministers to deny union rights to staff at GCHQ in Cheltenham. 
 Automatic negotiating rights are not guaranteed, but employers are likely to be angry. 
 The move is part of the Employment Secretary, Mr Norman Fowler's, package designed to outlaw secondary strike action and abolish the pre-entry closed shop. 
 The bill had been intended to highlight Labour's continued adherence to the closed shop, until Mr Fowler's shadow, Mr Tony Blair, last weekend announced the Opposition's support for the full Social Charter agenda. 
 Patten speaks of a milestone on the road toward a cleaner Britain and makes key concession on Nature Conservancy Council Green legislation faces bumpy ride. 
 By Paul Brown Environment Correspondent 
 THE Environment Secretary, Mr Christopher Patten, yesterday presented his Environment Protection Bill, which makes sweeping changes in the way industrial pollution is controlled, as a milestone on the road to a greener Britain. 
 At a press conference he committed himself to a big recruitment drive for Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution, and, if necessary, to putting more resources into local authorities in order to make the bill work. 
 One surprise in the bill was a U-turn in the battle over the future of the Nature Conservancy Council. 
 Mr Patten has conceded that the council should have an independent chairman who can represent the United Kingdom at home and abroad. 
 This will go some way to draw the fire of the Government's critics, but he can still expect a rough ride for the bill on the House of Lords. 
 The central part of the bill is the creation of integrated pollution control. 
 Around 3,500 of Britain's industrial processes will have to be justified to the inspectorate for the pollution they put into the environment on land, into the air and into water. 
 Industry will have to pay for the licences they are granted and will have a duty to reduce pollution and render their discharges harmless. 
 Mr Patten said this would put Britain in front of Europe but acknowledged that it may be some time before it can be implemented. 
 He disclosed that the crisis in the inspectorate had led to 32 vacancies in a professional staff of 135 in October. 
 The complement had now been raised to 145 and salaries increased by 28 per cent. 
 There were 175 applicants for the newly advertised posts and interviews would begin next year. 
 When this round of appointments was made the situation would be reviewed to see if the inspectorate needed further strengthening. 
 &bquo;The immediate task is to make sure the HMIP is able to discharge the substantial range of functions in this bill. 
 I accept that the sophisticated application of integrated pollution control depends crucially on a good and effective inspectorate.&equo; 
 Another area vital to the success of the bill was public confidence and access to information. 
 The details to be included in the public registers to be established under the bill had yet to be decided but he personally favoured &bquo;more information rather than less.&equo; 
 Details of the registers would be available before the bill reached the committee stage but he wanted them to contain enough detail to be wholly credible in the eyes of the public. 
 New powers in the bill give Mr Patten vetoes over the import of both toxic and other wastes. 
 He said he wanted to establish that countries deal with their own waste but he felt it was too early to impose a complete ban on imports. 
 Some countries did not have the facilities to deal with the wastes themselves and a ban might encourage indiscriminate dumping. 
 These new powers would sound a warning to a number of companies which run, or are planning to build, new incinerators in Britain, some of which rely on imports to maintain profitability. 
 Apart from industry paying for pollution controls, he said, reorganisation of waste disposal would extend the polluter pays principle to ordinary waste disposal. 
 Local authorities will now have to divorce their regulatory arms from the disposal organisation by forming separate companies which would normally be in private hands. 
 This would encourage realistic pricing for landfill operations. 
 There would be a specific duty on local authorities to make plans for the recycling of waste which must be high on the list of priorities when formulating policy. 
 He was entering a study with local authorities on the cost of implementing the measures and was prepared to make appropriate increases in the rate support grant. 
 Increased fines for dropping litter, and regulations requiring local authorities and landowners keep their premises free from litter would be brought forward. 
 Mr Patten said the 120-clause bill was only part of the Government's strategy for the environment. 
 A strategic overview on the issue would be published in an autumn white paper. 
 Sir William Wilkinson, chairman of the NCC, welcomed the Mr Patten's decision to allow an independent chairman for the organisation after the Government's refusal to do so only three weeks ago. 
 Mr Chrisopher Patten&hellip; 
 Sounding a warning 
 PC Peacock and PC Renton: An apology. 
 ON May 13, 1986, we published an article entitled &bquo;A force to be reckoned with&equo; which mentioned factors likely to deter potential black recruits from joining the police force at that time and cited as one example &bquo;the beating to death of a black Hell's Angel by policemen&equo;. 
 On March 26, 1986, a jury had returned a verdict of manslaughter by neglect following the inquest into the death of a Hell's Angel, Mr John Mikkelson, while in police custody. 
 That verdict did not implicate individual police officers. 
 In our report of the verdict and in other press articles, PC Peacock and PC Renton of Hounslow police station were named as the officers who arrested and detained Mr Mikkelson. 
 Some readers may therefore have identified them as the police officers referred to in our article of May 13, 1986. 
 The first inquest verdict was later quashed by the Court of Appeal. 
 A second inquest in February 1987, returned a verdict of death by misadventure. 
 Our article of May 13, 1986 was not intended to apportion blame for Mr Mikkelson's death. 
 We accept that the statement that he was &bquo;beaten to death&equo; whilst in police custody was incorrect and went beyond the original inquest verdict of manslaughter. 
 We apologise unreservedly to PC Peacock and PC Renton for this error and for any misunderstanding which this may have caused. 
 Home Secretary plans to allow in 250,000 from colony. 
 Labour says proposal is &bquo;unworkable and divisive&equo; Tebbit leads Tory attack on Hurd Hong Kong. 
 Paul Nettleton. 
 THE former Cabinet Minister, Mr Norman Tebbit, yesterday led an angry response from the Tory backbenches to Mr Douglas Hurd's announcement in the Commons that up to 250,000 Hong Kong people will be offered full British citizenship in the hope of staunching the &bquo;haemorrhage of talent&equo; from the colony. 
 Mr Tebbit, the ex-party chairman and MP for Chingford, asked Mr Hurd &bquo;whether the pledge that we have given for the last four general elections, that there would be no further large-scale immigration, still stands or not?&equo; 
 The Foreign Secretary said: &bquo;My right honourable friend knows that I have spent quite a lot of time in the last four years as Home Secretary, with his full support, trying to plug loopholes, trying to keep our immigration control strict and fair. 
 Mr Tebbit repeatedly shouted &bquo;answer the question&equo;. 
 Mr Hurd replied: &bquo;I don't need any education on the importance of a strict immigration control for entry into this country.&equo; 
 Supposing Mr Tebbit was right in his fears and considerable numbers did come to Britain, what would be the nature of the penalty? 
 &bquo;We would be paying the penalty of a sizeable but limited number of professional people, selected for their talent and experience, coming from one of the most successful societies which has been created in the 20th century.&equo; 
 He told Mr Tebbit: &bquo;You have been chairman of our party &mdash; and a very successful one &mdash; and you know the traditions of our party. 
 This is the last main chapter in the story of this country's empire. 
 I am rather keen, and I'm sure you are rather keen, that it should not end in a shabby way.&equo; 
 The Foreign Secretary had told the Commons that 42,000 people left the colony this year, and 55,000 are expected to leave next year. 
 A growing number were people Hong Kong could least afford to lose. 
 &bquo;We aim to give such people the confidence to remain in Hong Kong so that they can continue to make their contribution to the success and prosperity of the territory.&equo; 
 To give right of abode to all British Dependent Territories passport holders in Hong Kong &bquo;could, if that right was exercised, create unacceptable strains here&equo;. 
 But, &bquo;if, on the other hand, we kept the scheme too narrow, it would fail in its purpose and&hellip; we might be faced with a much more severe problem.&equo; 
 A points scheme would enable a maxium of 50,000 heads of households, plus their dependants, to be awarded full British citizenship without having to leave Hong Kong. 
 The decisive criteria &bquo;will be the value of the individuals&equo; service to Hong Kong&equo;. 
 Mr Gerald Kaufman, the shadow foreign secretary, reiterated Labour's opposition to any commitment to offer the right of abode to favoured categories based on status or affluence. 
 What Mr Hurd had done &bquo;is not to work out what he believes are essential categories and decide to legislate on those categories. 
 Instead he has thought of a number. 
 He has haggled on that number with the Home Secretary and been beaten down&hellip; 
 I believe such a system to be inherently unworkable, invidious and divisive,&equo; said Mr Kaufman. 
 An incoming Labour government would examine how the system was working but &bquo;will not be bound to continue it&equo;. 
 Mr Hurd replied: &bquo;We have worked out what we believe to be the most sensible balance between our desire for good race relations and harmony in our cities&hellip; and our very strong feeling that we have a continuing&hellip; duty of responsibility to people in Hong Kong.&equo; 
 Sir Peter Blaker (C. Blackpool S) said Mr Hurd's &bquo;responsible and sensible decision&equo; would help the prosperity and stability of Hong Kong. 
 For the Liberal Democrats, Mr David Steel said the scheme would fail to provide the assurances that would enable people to stay in Hong Kong and would &bquo;involve so many arbitrary choices, where X will be chosen instead of Y&equo; which would be &bquo;very unacceptable&equo;. 
 He predicted &bquo;deep dismay in Hong Kong, deepened only by the statement of the official Opposition.&equo; 
 But Mr Tebbit told Mr Hurd: &bquo;I regret having to say that I disagreed with almost everything he (Mr Hurd) said and agreed with almost everything the Right Hon gentleman said from the Opposition front bench.&equo; 
 Replying to questioners, Mr Hurd disclosed that Hong Kong Indians and others, thought to total about 1,500 families, would also be included in the scheme. 
 Mr David Howell, Tory chairman of the Foreign Affairs Select Committee, said the scheme must &bquo;anchor&equo; people in the colony because any loss of confidence could lead to an immigration flood exceeding &bquo;the worst fears&equo; of many of his backbench colleagues. 
 Mr George Gardiner (C. Reigate) asked how was Mr Hurd going to explain to ethnic minorities already in this country the strict entry controls on their relatives &bquo;while at the same time amending the law so as to create a preferential class of treatment for the Hong Kong Chinese&equo;? 
 The SDP leader, Dr David Owen, supporting Mr Hurd said &bquo;the answer to Mr Tebbit is, after what happened in Tiananmen Square, honour demands that this House needs to do more to sustain the prosperity and security of Hong Kong&equo;. 
 Labour leader returns from Berlin meetings sensing need for forward options to which he says Thatcher's policies are opposed. 
 Kinnock seeking strategy to speed reform in East Patrick Wintour sounds out Opposition views on the two Germanys question and Britain's proper response to it.. 
 WHEN Mr Neil Kinnock addressed the German Social Democrats' (SPD) conference in Berlin this week, he did so against a vast photographic backdrop of Europe seen from space, without a cloud in the sky. 
 Beneath it was a quote from Willy Brandt, elder statesman of European democratic socialism: &bquo;Now grows together what belongs together.&equo; 
 Fired with enthusiasm for the new Europe on his return flight over the North Sea, Fuhrer Kinnock, as he is known in the German press, seemed more frustrated than ever at being out of office at such a momentous time. 
 In an interview with the Guardian, he attacked the Prime Minister for failing to have an urgent strategy to help the reform movements in the East. 
 Her defence, economic and political policies were out of tune with the spirit of the coming European decade. 
 A new political convergence was occuring between East and West, from which Mrs Thatcher was excluded by her market liberalism. 
 If the politics of the eighties has been characterised by Mrs Thatcher's confrontational style, Mr Kinnock believes the politics of the nineties must be about international negotiation and co-operation. 
 At the same time, he said, it was clear the European Community &mdash; another institution from which Mrs Thatcher had &bquo;absented&equo; herself &mdash; would have to be the chief forum by which the West would help the East. 
 It was sensible, as Mrs Thatcher had, &bquo;to counsel caution in the maelstrom, but it all depends on whether you're saying that in order to guide events in a steady fashion or whether you're using it as an alibi to do nothing. 
 She's wrong because she falls into the latter category. 
 &bquo;It's partly because she has got herself cornered economically, and partly because deep down she thinks there is a nationalist string she can pluck to her electoral advantage. 
 I think she's wrong, because there's been a readjustment in British attitudes to Europe. 
 &bquo;While people are cautious about a lot of developments in Europe, rightly so, and while they are looking for British advantage, rightly so, they realise it cannot be done from the back of the class. 
 &bquo;On one bank there is the remnant of Stalinism in the form of President Ceausescu, and on the other, at least in terms of ultra-liberal rhetoric, is Mrs Thatcher. 
 Yet at the same time the broad mainstream is flowing by. 
 Of course, there is a left and right side to that stream, but I think it is the left side of the stream which is broadening.&equo; 
 Mr Kinnock, who met opposition fugures in East Berlin last week over a working breakfast, claims the reform movement in Eastern Europe represents a triumph for European social democracy, not Thatcherism. 
 &bquo;This idea that the flame of freedom in the East was ignited in Conservative Central Office is just poppycock. 
 &bquo;Obviously, anyone who has been oppressed for 40 years will have among their number people who want to make the complete lunge towards a so-called free market utopia. 
 But the mainstream know freedom and the free market are not co-terminous. 
 They know there is another path, which is democratic socialism. 
 &bquo;What I have been interested to witness over the last year to 18 months is a newly confident Left in the Socialist International saying we have a common formulation about the best way to proceed. 
 &bquo;Coincidentally, we are now seeing coming out of Eastern Europe that same broad attitude being adopted, not only by the democratic socialists and social democratic parties which are emerging in the East, but also amongst the reform wings of the old Communist parties led by a new generation who realise the command economy Stalinist game is completely up. 
 &bquo;So there is a new convergence of political thinking between East and West and within the West.&equo; 
 He sums this up as &bquo;a general realisation that you need the combination of the market and the socially responsible community, and that the two are not mutually incompatible.&equo; 
 But he warned that unless the West, meaning primarily the European Community, offered economic aid quickly, &bquo;there will be disillusionment which will be very destabilising. 
 We have had stability for 40 years. 
 It was not a nice stability, but it was there. 
 Now it's gone. 
 We have to move very quickly find a new stability.&equo; 
 In the search for that stability, Britain's role should be to ensure that the European Community becomes the vehicle with which to channel aid into the East in terms of commitment to training, new technology, transport improvements and preferential commercial arrangements. 
 The East would prefer such a comprehensive approach from the community, rather than a series of bilateral arrangements. 
 He also echoed Willy Brandt in warning that unless the West was seen to act quickly and in concert, demand for German reunification could become overpowering in both East and West. 
 In the West, a populist right, linked to neo-fascim, was &bquo;willing to use racism, as it does already in the northern industrial towns, and the overcrowding which will occur if there is a large influx from East Germany. 
 They will argue that the only way to deal with this invasion is by reunification.&equo; 
 In the East, &bquo;there could be such a lust for reunification for economic reasons, to get access to the prosperity of West Germany, that it will pressurise all the existing political parties into embracing reunification.&equo; 
 During his visit, Mr Kinnock became the first British political leader to meet Gregor Gysi, the new East German Communist Party leader. 
 The Communist Party, he told Mr Gysi, would be making a serious error if he went ahead and fought the planned May elections on a manifesto which simply warned reunification would be a victory for the right. 
 If the issue was not taken head on, he said, and the movement towards unification became precipitate or unorganised, it would not merely be a blot on the landscape, it would &bquo;rock the continent.&equo; 
 But &bquo;I don't think there is anyone at a serious level on either side who wants that.&equo; 
 Mr Kinnock called on Mrs Thatcher to show her commitment to change in Eastern Europe by launching a public review of Britain's defence policies. 
 &bquo;The Pentagon is advising the president about troop reductions. 
 The Germans patently are not going to allow modernisation of short-range weapons. 
 Nato is discussing the mutual withdrawl of short range weapons in Germany. 
 &bquo;Again there is a consensus with one exception, Mrs Thatcher. 
 November 9 &lsqb;the day that the Wall was opened&rsqb; provides us with the chance to look for defence savings. 
 Let's have a defence review so both the military and the industries are prepared for change when it comes.&equo; 
 Brother of princess alleges tabloid press harassment. 
 THE Princess of Wales's brother and his wife have accused tabloid newspapers of harassing them and making up stories in the run-up to their wedding in September this year. 
 They claim a private surveillance team was engaged by one newspaper to follow them, events and quotes attributed to them in stories were made up, and their family and friends were harassed and their privacy invaded. 
 In an interview on Channel 4's Hard News programme, to be shown tonight, Viscountess Althorp said of her experiences of tabloid journalists: &bquo;I think they're really totally insensitive, evil people.&equo; 
 Viscount Althorp said of reporters covering his engagement: &bquo;They wanted to get back, bring me down, and make Victoria's &lsqb;his wife's&rsqb; life a misery.&equo; 
 &bquo;Everyday people are bruised by the press and they haven't got any recourse. 
 I am doing this because I think I ought to and am in the position to do so.&equo; 
 Viscount Althorp claims a national newspaper hired a firm of private detectives to follow them round-the-clock. 
 His wife criticises a story in the Sunday Mirror which claimed she spent her &bquo;hen night&equo; in &bquo;smooching the night away&equo; with a former boyfriend. 
 Her husband says he found a photographer hiding in some bushes by his house. 
 The Sunday Mirror refused to comment. 
 Environment bill &bquo;lacks adequate back-up resources&equo;. 
 By Paul Brown and Andrew Culf 
 STRONG reservations about whether the Government would provide enough resources to make the Environmental Protection Bill work tempered enthusiasm for its contents yesterday. 
 Some dubbed it a cosmetic exercise which did not go far enough and said too many concessions had already been made to industry. 
 Ms Diane Brown, of the Chemical Industries Association, said her members fully supported its intention but were anxious the &bquo;hotch potch&equo; of measures should be made to work. 
 The association's 170 members will have to bear the brunt of new fees for proposed discharge licences and are demanding a strong inspectorate to enforce the legislation. 
 &bquo;Integrated pollution control is a totally new concept, but there is a difference between a good philosophy and a workable system. 
 We need a much larger and better resourced inspectorate to enforce it so it is fair and seen to be.&equo; 
 The association also welcomed the duty of care placed on people who produce waste to make sure it is properly disposed of. 
 This would cut out the &bquo;cowboy&equo; operators who will lose their licences if caught dumping illegally. 
 During the next three years the industry has committed &pound;1 billion to cleaning up its discharges and recycling wastes which would otherwise be dumped. 
 This is 15 per cent of all capital investment and double the figure five years ago. 
 Labour's environment spokesman, Mr Bryan Gould, said the bill was a &bquo;ragbag&equo; of measures resulting from various government commitments to vested interests and voluntary groups. 
 The new system of Integrated Pollution Control designed to curb harmful emissions from factories would be undermined by staff shortages and poor morale. 
 Proposals to curb litter and waste did not go far enough and would land local authorities with extra bills but no additional resources. 
 &bquo;I think it is a little premature at this stage to be dreaming of a green Christmas,&equo; Mr Gould added. 
 The Green Party said plans to clean up the environment were doomed unless the Government gave an immediate cash injection to the departments responsible for enforcement and introduced a crash training programme for new staff. 
 Moves to clean up Britain's heavily polluted cities and countryside were welcome, but without resources the proposed measures were merely wishful thinking and would prove a cosmetic exercise. 
 Mr David Icke, a Green spokesman, said the Government appeared embarrassed that the bill would fail to impress as a careful response to environmental problems. 
 &bquo;We can see no other reason why the Government should introduce this bill less than 24 hours before the house rises for Christmas and that they are fundamentally ashamed of it.&equo; 
 Mr Roger Lankester, the party's pollution specialist, said: &bquo;My biggest criticism is that each part of the bill appears to have a loophole or get-out clause which will render much of it unenforceable.&equo; 
 He did not believe that &bquo;this piece of tinkering by the Government will stop Britain becoming the dump of Europe in the 1990s.&equo; 
 Mr David Gee, director designate of Friends of the Earth, said the bill had already been weakened by giving big concessions to industry, especially over freedom of information to the public and scope and timetable of the new controls over pollution. 
 &bquo;None of the Government's proposed reforms will be effective without a threefold increase in the number of HMIP pollution inspectors, extra resources for local authority environmental health officers and far more effective monitoring.&equo; 
 Mr Ian Prestt, director-general of the Royal Society for the Protection of Birds, said the most contentious part of the bill was the proposal to break up the Nature Conservancy Council. 
 Sacking threat to ambulance staff. 
 By Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 THE 15-week ambulance dispute moved into a new area of confrontation yesterday as non-emergency workers in Surrey were threatened with the sack unless they returned to normal working in the new year. 
 At the same time the non-TUC Association of Professional Ambulance Personnel voted by two to one against acceptance of a revised 9 per cent pay offer over 18 months. 
 The vote robs Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, of the chance to impose the offer, also rejected by the five TUC unions. 
 Managers in Surrey sent letters to all their ambulance workers threatening to use outside contractors to carry out non-emergency work and refused to guarantee that they would be withdrawn once deployed. 
 The letters were in response to a decision by ambulance workers to refuse all calls from controllers for 24 hours on New Year's Eve. 
 The action was called after a row between ambulance staff and Mrs Virginia Bottomley, the Health Minister of State, at her South-west Surrey constituency last Friday over her refusal to recognise ambulance workers as the third arm of the emergency services giving them a pay formula automatically tied to the police and fire fighters. 
 Sources at Surrey Ambulance Service confirmed last night that staff, of which about 80 are non-emergency workers, had been told &bquo;quite bluntly&equo; of the consequences of the action. 
 The threat to employ outside contractors is in line with plans for hiving off parts of the ambulance service sketched out by Mr Clarke during the dispute. 
 Surrey managers said that many elderly day patients who would normally be carried by non-emergency crews have had to be readmitted to hospital in the past three months. 
 The two sides are due to meet tomorrow. 
 Ugly Sisters play to packed House Sketch. 
 By Andrew Rawnsley 
 ANYBODY casting a pantomime this Christmas might not instantly consider Margaret Thatcher for the role of Cinderella or Douglas Hurd in the part of Buttons. 
 And Hong Kong is not the sort of story likely to have the traditional happy ending. 
 But anybody still short of two Ugly Sisters should get in touch at once with Gerald Kaufman and Norman Tebbit and ask them to repeat yesterday's performance in the Commons. 
 The Foreign Secretary began by outlining, rather well, his package to give British citizenship to up to 50,000 Hong Kong families. 
 Mr Kaufman, Labour's chief foreign affairs spokesman, sat at his bench shaking his head. 
 Over the way sat Mr Tebbit, the Tory party's chief foreign affairs spokesman for the rabid Right, shaking his head. 
 Mr Kaufman spoke first. 
 &bquo;The Opposition are against the creation of specially-favoured categories based on status or affluence,&equo; he said, and would vote against Mr Hurd's proposals. 
 The Hurd scheme was &bquo;elitist and discriminatory&equo;, not to say &bquo;unreasonable, unworkable, invidious and divisive&equo;, for Mr Kaufman never uses one adjective where one hundred will do. 
 &bquo;The system will arouse doubt and uncertainty since no-one will be sure whether he or she can qualify.&equo; 
 Mr Kaufman did not outline his preferred plan for maintaining confidence and honouring obligations to Hong Kong. 
 But there is certainly no doubt or uncertainty, elitism or discrimination about Labour's own scheme. 
 Under the compassionate, egalitarian, principled Kaufman scheme, no one in Hong Kong will be given the right of abode in Britain. 
 &bquo;How will the 50,001st person in the queue feel?&equo;, 
 Mr Kaufman demanded of Mr Hurd. 
 To which the best answer is: a lot better than the first person in any queue organised by Mr Kaufman. 
 On the other side of the House, Norman Tebbit and the rest of the rabid Right had been nodding along to Mr Kaufman. 
 The Essex Men had mobilised on the Tory backbenches in strength. 
 When the Speaker called for questioners, a forest of bodies shot up wanting to speak. 
 There was Tim Janman, the MP for Thurrock. 
 When he last spoke, Mr Janman said Britain would take one refugee from Hong Kong &bquo;over my dead body&equo;. 
 The Speaker &mdash; squeamishly &mdash; did not call him, leaving Mr Janman pawing the ground like a rabid ferret. 
 It was, anyway, Norman Tebbit that everybody was waiting for. 
 When he spoke, it was from the first Tory bench below the gangway, the place he used as a backbencher before his ministerial days, in his youth as the Chingford Skinhead. 
 It was almost immediately clear that, though a rather greying skinhead now, Mr Tebbit had returned to his roots. 
 After attacking the Foreign Secretary, he began shouting at Mr Hurd again and again as Mr Hurd attempted to reply. 
 &bquo;Would my Right Honourable Friend accept how much I regret,&equo; Mr Tebbit had begun his snarl at the Foreign Secretary, &bquo;having to say how much I disagree with nearly everything he said and agree with nearly everything said by the Right Honourable Gentleman for the Opposition.&equo; 
 &bquo;You must be wrong, Gerald,&equo; cried a Labour voice. 
 Well, no doubt Mr Kaufman would argue that there are important differences between him and Mr Tebbit. 
 But to any of the Hong Kong Chinese watching yesterday, Mr Kaufman and Mr Tebbit must look terribly alike. 
 PanAm suspect snubs detectives. 
 By David Sharrock in Uppsala 
 SCOTTISH police investigating the Lockerbie bombing have been forced to return empty-handed from Sweden after the terrorist suspect Mohammed Abu Talb refused to be interviewed. 
 A Swedish court is today expected to convict Mr Talb and three others of involvement in terrorist attacks on Israeli and American targets in Copenhagen, Amsterdam, and Stockholm in 1985 and 1986. 
 Three weeks ago Mr Talb was described in Uppsala District Court as being &bquo;suspected in Scotland of murder or as an accessory to murder&equo;. 
 A year to the day since PanAm 103 exploded over Lockerbie, Mr Talb remains the only suspect officially identified. 
 Two Scottish detectives met Mr Talb on Tuesday, but his lawyer, Mr Sven Eric Sjogren, said Mr Talb refused to talk in front of them. 
 A Swedish newspaper yesterday added to the mass of circumstantial evidence linking Mr Talb with the Lockerbie bombing. 
 Kvallposten, an evening newspaper in Malmo, reported that a diary belonging to Mr Talb which was seized during police searches shows December 21 1988 &mdash; the day on which PanAm 103 blew up &mdash; with a circle around it. 
 The report, quoting Swedish security sources, claimed it was confirmed that a man using an Egyptian passport in the name of Mohamed Abu Taleb was in Malta at the end of November last year. 
 Fifteen bags of clothing were taken from Mr Talb's home in Uppsala by Swedish and Scottish police three weeks ago. 
 Kvallposten claimed that immediately after the search Mr Talb's ex-wife telephoned a Palestinian family in Uppsala and ordered them to &bquo;get rid of the clothing&equo;. 
 Police intercepted the call and raided the address. 
 The seized clothing has been shown to a Maltese shopkeeper who identified items found in the suitcase containing the Pan Am bomb as bought from him. 
 Killing with racial undertones halts town's minicab service. 
 By Martin Wainwright pic Joan Russell &bquo;S. 
 ORRY love, no taxis today,&equo; said Mr Mohammed Siddique repeatedly, as the phone at Huddersfield Taxis jangled every couple of minutes. 
 &bquo;Top Town Cars? 
 No, they're shut too. 
 And GT. 
 And Three Star. 
 No, I don't think anyone's open today, love.&equo; 
 The shutdown yesterday by Huddersfield's eight main minicab firms, all Asian-owned and with only a handful of non-Asian staff, followed a fatal stabbing in the most serious incident in an outbreak of violence involving drivers and their customers. 
 Racial abuse forms a regular part of this, although drivers, as well as police, see the issue as more complex than simple &bquo;Paki-bashing&equo;. 
 Taxi proprietors were discussing the problem with senior Huddersfield police early on Tuesday evening when news came through of the stabbing of Mr Andrew Brown, aged 24, of Birds Edge, near Penistone, South Yorkshire, at Three Star Taxis' office in Beast Market. 
 West Yorkshire police emphasised yesterday that no evidence had emerged to link the killing to any vendetta or previous trouble. 
 But drivers, meeting behind Three Star's shattered office windows yesterday, said that violence &mdash; with a frequent racial element &mdash; was a rapidly growing problem. 
 &bquo;We've been used to fares running off without paying in the past,&equo; said one. 
 &bquo;But in the last couple of months we've seen things suddenly boil up &mdash; violent attacks, cars damaged, that sort of thing, along with loads of abuse.&equo; 
 A four-hour protest strike by drivers in August was the first organised reaction. 
 Last week the eight taxi firms declared a boycott of Golcar, a Pennine village on Hudderfield's fringe. 
 The move followed stone-throwing by dozens of people after two youths disputed the fare when they were dropped off at a pub. 
 Four people were arrested. 
 &bquo;Rushdie? 
 No, it's nothing to do with that,&equo; said one of the drivers at the Three Star meeting. 
 &bquo;Copycats more like it. 
 The trouble usually comes after the pubs have opened. 
 I'd say you could put a lot of the abuse down to drink, though anyone with a black face was in trouble in Golcar that Saturday night.&equo; 
 With almost all the minicab drivers Asian (as in Bradford, Dewsbury, Batley and Keighley, which have similar problems), any general anti-taxi complaint can seem a racial one. 
 Police were unwilling to comment in detail on the problem yesterday, with inquiries continuing into the Three Star killing and a man being held for questioning. 
 No-go area&hellip; 
 Violence involving Huddersfield's eight Asian-owned minicab firms and customers has led to drivers boycotting one area of the townPHOTOGRAPH: JOAN RUSSELL 
 Thatcher, Archer and Stallone lined up for BBC's Wogan shows. 
 THE Prime Minister, Jeffrey Archer, Sylvester Stallone and Rod Stewart are among those lined up to appear on the Wogan chat show as part of BBC TV's &pound;82 million line-up of programmes for the new year. 
 Dave Allen heads the comedy bill, which includesBen Elton, French and Saunders and The Comic Strip. 
 Stars of Hi de Hi and It Ain't Half Hot Mum team up for a new series set below stairs, You Rang M'Lord. 
 US comedienne Ruby Wax will present her first series for the BBC, Stephen Fry and Hugh Laurie are back with A Bit of Fry and Laurie, and Mel Smith returns as a reluctant rail man in Colin's Sandwich. 
 On the drama front Shoestring star Trevor Eve appears in A Sense of Guilt, by Andrea Newman. 
 The BBC will go on patrol in Liverpool with the Waterfront Beat, while detectives Bergerac and Campion return. 
 Lou Grant actor Edward Asner stars in a dramatisation of Jeffrey Archer's novel Not a Penny More, Not a Penny Less. 
 Screen Two will feature Stephen Fry and Simon Callow in a new Simon Gray comedy, Old Flames. 
 Edward Fox and Jane Lapotaire star in Nina Bawden's Circles of Deceit, while Jonathan Pryce, Susannah York, and Anna Massey appear in the thriller The Man from the Pru. 
 Thursday People. 
 Dennis Barker:. 
 Well bred in tooth and claw. 
 &bquo;D. 
 RESSES like a pin-striped banker but talks like a countryman conservationist,&equo; was a typical verdict yesterday on the most vociferous fighter against the Government's plans to fragment the power of the Nature Conservancy Council. 
 He is its chairman, Sir William Wilkinson, who has campaigned courageously despite personal difficulties that would have stopped many more bullish men. 
 Now 57, Sir William said yesterday that his background was &bquo;academic through and through.&equo; 
 His father was a housemaster at Eton, his mother a lecturer in classics at London University. 
 But the guts he has shown in resisting government plans for the body he has chaired from 1983 are far from academic. 
 Sir William, who claims that fragmentation will damage Britain's world influence in conservation, is a merchant banker who for two years after joining the NCC combined banking with conservation. 
 Eventually he took a hefty drop in income by abandoning the lucrative corridors of merchant bank Kleinwort Benson. 
 A year ago he had a heart by-pass which had to be re-done and for a while totally lost his sight because of a clot in the blood supply to the eyes. 
 He struggled on and, with less than 50 per cent of his sight restored, took this year's annual meeting of the NCC without betraying his difficulties except when he said when taking questions: &bquo;I will ask my deputy to point you out for obvious reasons.&equo; 
 His sight is improving but he has to be helped to cross roads. 
 &bquo;He makes light of his handicap,&equo; said an admirer who attended the meeting. 
 It has been particularly difficult for him because the Government have two of their placemen on the council, but he has managed to keep fighting though the council has this deadweight of government lackeys.&equo; 
 Sir William said yesterday: &bquo;My father was a good amateur ornithologist and my mother was a little bit of a botanist. 
 I felt nature conservancy was something that really mattered.&equo; 
 Was one of his hobbies, shooting, consistent with that? 
 &bquo;Yes it is, provided the shooting is carried out in a responsible manner. 
 I think the huge scale massacre of pheasants is revolting. 
 It must be a proper sport and conducted as such. 
 &bquo;It doesn't worry me morally but I have a lot of sympathy with those who don't think it is very attractive. 
 This is a question of people's personal decisions. 
 My wife is mildly agaist shooting.&equo; 
 The self-confidence inspired by his Eton and Trinity background may have helped him in the several differences of opinion he has encountered in his life. 
 He was one of the eight directors of Lonrho who parted company from it after trying to oust Tiny Rowland in 1973. 
 Asked whether he is now used to confrontations, he said: &bquo;I hate them but they seem to come my way. 
 I find them extremely depressing but I shall go on slogging away until my term as chairman ends in the early summer.&equo; 
 Sir William: schooled in confrontation PAGE 
 Sharp rises likely in Tube fares. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 LONDON Tube and bus fares are likely to rise sharply in the coming years as London Regional Transport seeks to price passengers off overcrowded public transport. 
 It is clear that LRT is planning regular increases above the rate of inflation for at least the next five years. 
 Fares go up by 10 per cent in February. 
 LRT said in its corporate plan published yesterday: &bquo;The level of congestion on the Underground is such that unconstrained further growth in demand cannot safely be accommodated, and real increases in fares would help restrain excessive growth.&equo; 
 It said further annual real increases were envisaged. 
 The decision will bring more criticism of the public transport policies being adopted by Mr Cecil Parkinson, the Transport Secretary, who was under fire this week for forcing substantial increases in British Rail fares into the 1990s. 
 Mrs Joan Ruddock, Labour spokeswoman on London transport, said the Tube fare rises were &bquo;a cynical attempt to restrain further growth in demand&equo;. 
 LRT's chairman, Mr Wilfrid Newton, said: &bquo;Creating successful change in busy, heavily developed greater London will be neither easy nor quick, and it will be very costly.&equo; 
 The corporate plan says the above-inflation increases and rising productivity on the Underground would allow it to become financially self-sufficient, apart from funding major capital spending programmes. 
 London buses will also be expected to achieve commercial viability, except for some outlying services. 
 LRT has warned that passengers cannot be expected to finance the group's entire five-year &pound;3 billion capital spending programme. 
 &bquo;LRT should be able to fund about one third of this investment from internal resources, leaving the remainder to be funded from grant,&equo; the corporate plan says. 
 &bquo;By the end of the five years, however, passengers should be paying for all operating costs and providing about half the investment expenditure.&equo; 
 The decision to allow passengers to remain in their cars while transporter trains pass through the Channel Tunnel has come under attack. 
 Mr John Prescott, the shadow transport secretary, will today seek to raise the issue in the Commons, while the Fire Brigades Union and the privately funded British Safety Council have appealed to Mrs Thatcher to overturn the decision by the Anglo-French tunnel safety commission. 
 Mr Richard Warburton, director general of the Royal Society for the Prevention of Accidents, said: &bquo;If you were looking for the highest standards of safety, then you would be separating people from their vehicles in the tunnel.&equo; 
 He also criticised the commission for taking the decision in private. 
 Mr Dave Matthews, the FBU's safety officer, said the tunnel could become the &bquo;longest crematorium in the world&equo;. 
 In a joint message to Mrs Thatcher, the FBU and the council said: &bquo;The vast majority of serving fire and safety experts in the United Kingdom believes that unless passengers are segregated from vehicles in trains, there is a very serious fire risk.&equo; 
 The high price of Ridley's thoughts. 
 By David Hencke Westminster Correspondent 
 WHITEHALL'S most expensive confidential memoranda are written by Mr Nicholas Ridley, the Trade Secretary, and cost &pound;4.86 a time, an official investigation revealed yesterday. 
 He is followed by Mr John MacGregor, the Education Secretary, whose thoughts cost the taxpayer &pound;4.19 a document. 
 Details of the costs of Whitehall's bureaucracy are revealed in a National Audit Office investigation. 
 It found that more than &pound;300million a year is spent on employing staff to type for 600,000 civil servants and 22 cabinet ministers. 
 This means jobs for 23,400 typists and supervisers whose varying rates of productivity come under fire. 
 Best value for money are the Ministry of Defence's 22 out-of-town typing pools, which cost 77p a memo, with an output of 110 per typist per day. 
 Among the worst is the Department of Education's headquarters secretariat &mdash; serving ministers and top civil servants &mdash; which costs &pound;4.19 a time, but can produce only 29 memos per typist per day. 
 At least two departments have introduced internal charges to encourage civil servants and ministers to think twice before putting their thoughts on paper. 
 The Department of Trade and Industry has three levels of charges: &pound;2.16 a memo for routine work outside London; &pound;3.24 for routine work in London; and &pound;4.86 for priority work at headquarters. 
 Customs and Excise have two charges: &pound;3.60 for routine memos, rising to &pound;5 for urgent memos and letters. 
 The auditors also found Whitehall slow to adapt to new technology, and that millions was spent on correcting letters by hand instead of on word processors. 
 Text Processing in the Civil Service. 
 Report by the Comptroller and Auditor General. 
 HMSO &pound;5.50 
 A Country Diary: EGGLESTON BURN, Teesdale: Small burns that feed the main rivers of the Pennine Dales create some of the wildest features of the landscape. 
 Sit on the bank of one of these fast-flowing rocky streams and close your eyes. 
 The smell of the peat, gurgle of water racing over boulders and chuckle of flocks of fieldfares searching for mountain ash berries are as characteristic as the scenery itself. 
 This was the first time we had returned to Eggleston Burn since a summer visit in search of the Grass of Parnassus and butterwort that grow in its boggy flushes. 
 Today we approached from the most picturesque direction, through a stile set in the wall of the narrow stone bridge whose elegant arches span the burn's deep-cut ravine. 
 The muddy track skirted the precipitous drop to the water one hundred feet below, then descended to the stream edge and meandered through ancient alders with red-tinted catkins, through poor pastures, passed blackthorn covered in deep purple sloes withering on spiny twigs and wound upstream into open moorland. 
 It's here that this particular burn springs a surprise, cutting a deep and narrow, zig-zag ravine through rock, beckoning you to explore around the next corner. 
 When we entered the chasm the steep rock sides, fringed on the skyline with twisted birches, had a vaguely threatening air. 
 Jagged boulders from rockfalls triggered by ice and rushing water made progress difficult. 
 Concentrating on maintaining a foothold on rocks worn smooth by winter torrents, I put up a startled grouse that exploded into flight. 
 The sudden shock and noise of whirring wings broke the stillness and left our pulses racing. 
 From around the next bend in the stream its &bquo;go-back, go-back, go-back&equo; call echoed off the rock walls. 
 In fading winter light that seemed wise advice and we retraced our steps to the gentler landscape of Teesdale itself. 
 PHIL GATES 
 Pocketing a new generation of little big games. 
 Jez San finds that games consoles are shrinking in size but expanding in range and addictiveness potential.. 
 COMPUTER games consoles are getting better, cheaper and smaller than ever before. 
 And the latest clash of pocket-sized titans is Nintendo's GameBoy versus Atari's Lynx. 
 Both have dinky LCD (liquid crystal display) screens, tiny flat joystick pads, and plug-in games on equally dinky cartridges. 
 Both are built in Japan, though the Lynx was designed in California by Epyx, a software house which ran out of development funds and sold the product to Atari. 
 Nintendo's is a pocket version of its Entertainment System currently gracing over 15 million American TV sets, though it is actually incompatible with it. 
 The Walkman-sized GameBoy fits comfortably in one hand, and has a two-inch yellow monochrome screen on which it is often hard to get the viewing angle right. 
 It comes with Tetris, a simple but addictive Russian game, for &dollar;89 in the US, or &pound;99 here as an overpriced import from Toys R Us. 
 It's an expensive Christmas present, but worth it to keep the kids quiet on long plane, train and car journeys. 
 Only a few simple cartridges are available, including Tennis, Baseball and Super Mario Land. 
 Most remind me of the Sinclair Spectrum games of a few years ago, but that last one is a typical Japanese &bquo;happy jumpy scrolly&equo; game &mdash; weird, but compulsive. 
 If you have five minutes to spare, plug in Super Mario and spend half an hour trying to rescue the princess! 
 Atari is now Nintendo's arch-rival, but 10 years ago, it owned the video games market. 
 Its VCS (Video Computer System) was the first colour home game system, and sold over 20 million. 
 But the market saturated, the bubble burst, and everyone thought the console business was finished. 
 However, strange to say, the Atari VCS never penetrated Japan, and this allowed Nintendo &mdash; previously known mainly for board games and packs of cards &mdash; to dominate the market there. 
 A few years later, with Atari in deep financial trouble, Nintendo was able to take over the US market too. 
 Nintendo exerts strict control over the market by not allowing anyone else to put games on its machine (which Atari Games claims violates US anti-trust laws) and by its powerful marketing. 
 Now over 20 per cent of American households have a Nintendo, and the Atari VCS is just a fond memory. 
 Atari needs a VCS-successor, and the Lynx may be it. 
 It has a full-colour 3.5-inch backlit screen, which compares favourably with the GameBoy's small, blurry black and white LCD. 
 Atari is sure that people are used to colour, and will not go back to black and white, even if the machine is pocket-sized. 
 The Lynx is larger than the GameBoy and you need two hands to hold it. 
 You need a big pocket, too: it is video-cassette sized, and nearly twice the price (&dollar;170 US, probably &pound;130 here in a few months) with one cartridge, California Games. 
 As well as an excellent display, the Lynx has a much louder speaker and &mdash; in the tradition of the Atari 8-bits and Commodore Amiga &mdash; a powerful set of chips to help it with the animation needed for superior three-dimensional games. 
 With 64K, it also has four times the memory of the Nintendo. 
 Lynx games will appeal to kids of slightly older ages. 
 The first batch includes California Games (a set of four sports games), Electro Cop (a Robocop-style adventure), Gates of Zendocon (a scrolling shoot-'em-up) and Blue Lightning (an Afterburner-style game). 
 They are fast-moving, colourful, noisy, and as good if not better than anything you can buy for home computers. 
 Where many GameBoy cartridges are puzzle-orientated, due in part to the blurry display not being ideal for fast movement, the Lynx's offer arcade excitement. 
 The images are fast and sharp, so it's much easier to see what's going on. 
 The Lynx has some other novel features, including a &bquo;flip&equo; button that turns the display upside down. 
 You can then turn the machine around to play left- or right-handed. 
 If your fingers get tired, you can even swap round in the middle of a game. 
 It turns itself off if you leave it untouched for five minutes, a feature sadly lacking on the GameBoy. 
 Both machines have a pause button for interruptions. 
 Battery life on the Lynx is about four hours with six AA batteries, but a mains adapter is included in the package (the GameBoy adapter is extra). 
 The GameBoy runs for about 15 hours on four AA cells. 
 The hottest new concept in pocket gaming is multi-player games. 
 If you and a friend own the same game, you can often plug them together (with the supplied cable) and play against each other. 
 Adding a human opponent gives a game an extra, unpredictable excitement that a computer opponent lacks. 
 The Lynx goes further and allows up to eight players to link together. 
 And multi-player games are good for business: groups of friends will have to buy more than one copy of each game, rather than sharing a set of different games. 
 Which one do you buy this Christmas? 
 That's easy. 
 Only the GameBoy is available. 
 Tracking down a Lynx is hard enough in New York, but impossible in the UK. 
 In a few months, however, the Lynx should be on sale here, and the tables will turn. 
 The Lynx is the superior machine. 
 I have owned a GameBoy for a few months now, and still use it. 
 The games are addictive, and I carry it whenever I'm likely to be bored somewhere. 
 I've just got a Lynx, and it's going to be much harder to smuggle it around. 
 But I'll try. 
 Jez San is managing director of Argonaut Software, which specialises in games (eg StarGlider) and flight simulators. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE mc1 
 Basketball Leicester put the Cat out. 
 By Robert Pryce 
 GARY &bquo;CAT&equo; JOHNSON, the coach of the season in 1987-88, has been dismissed by the Leicester Riders. 
 Leicester have won just one of their 11 Carlsberg League games this season, but the club suggested that the reason for the dismissal was Johnson's unwillingness to involve himself in the club's junior programme. 
 &bquo;I don't believe that,&equo; Johnson said yesterday. 
 He suggested that the club expected him to score more points. 
 &bquo;I've always been an unselfish player. 
 Some people appreciate that. 
 Some people don't.&equo; 
 He also suggested that their had been a clash of opinions. 
 &bquo;They've always had a yes man. 
 I have very strong views.&equo; 
 A 5ft 9in point guard out of Oral Roberts University in Tulsa, Johnson played for the Lancaster Lightnings in the Continental Basketball Association before moving to this country to join Newcastle. 
 He was player, coach and director at Calderdale before joining Leicester last season. 
 Tennis Golden deal for the golden girl from Florida. 
 Russell Thomas on the riches awaiting the 13-year-old Jennifer Capriati 
 JENNIFER CAPRIATI, the 13-year-old American prodigy, is joining the professional ranks on a contract almost certain to make her the youngest millionairess in the sport. 
 The girl from Tampa, Florida, has signed a long-term deal with Mark McCormack's International Management Group even though she is still three months away from making her senior debut. 
 Capriati has been courted for months by IMG, whose promotion, coupled with success on court, will bring their teenage client millions of dollars. 
 The girl who this year became the youngest Wightman Cup player in history is technically not allowed to join the professional tour until she is 14, in March. 
 But she has been given special dispensation to play in two events in her home state before that birthday. 
 She will make her senior debut in the Boca Raton Grand Prix, starting March 5, and then appear in the prestigious Liptons International at Key Biscayne. 
 Capriati, who won the junior French and US Open titles this year, admits she is &bquo;excited but anxious&equo; about playing on the tour. 
 She will be accompanied by her father, who will continue as coach, with her mother looking after her studies. 
 Education appears to be the main priority for Sarah Loosemore, the 18-year-old who is Britain's best women's prospect. 
 The South Wales player, who yesterday reached the final of the BWTA tournament at Queen's Club, has won a place at Oxford and starts a degree course in psychology and sociology at St Hilda's College in September, 1991. 
 Pat Cash, out for eight months with an Achilles tendon injury, could make his comeback in the doubles at the Australian Open in Melbourne next month. 
 Ian Barclay, coach to the 1987 Wimbledon champion, said it was extremely unlikely Cash would play singles then, but he was aiming to be fit for the Davis Cup tie with France in February. 
 The rival powers of men's tennis &mdash; the International Tennis Federation and the Association of Tennis Professionals &mdash; have come to an agreement over umpiring at the Australian Open. 
 The ATP will provide seven umpires for the event, which comes under the ITF's aegis. 
 The organisers had feared the ATP would withhold its officials, the most experienced in the men's game. 
 Snooker World series back on the calendar. 
 By Clive Everton 
 BARRY HEARN and Ian Doyle, who between them manage 13 of the world's top 20 players, have jointly announced the relaunching of a world series. 
 The initial 1987-8 venture was abandoned after three events in the face of a rival promotion in Beijing, but Hearn, unabashed, said: &bquo;This is a different time and a different set-up.&equo; 
 There will be six world-series events in 1990, starting with the new French Masters at Toulouse in June. 
 The other events will be in Belgium, New Zealand, India, and two more in the Far East. 
 The fields will comprise the leading eight in the world rankings at the end of this season and eight more players supplied by the host association or invited by the sponsors. 
 Inevitably most of the players will be from the Hearn and Doyle camps, which are headed by Steve Davis and Stephen Hendry respectively, but Doug Mountjoy, who is unmanaged, and Dean Reynolds, who is managed by Mark McCormack's International Management Group, are also provisionally in the top eight. 
 It is hoped that clashes of dates with the World Professional Billiards and Snooker Association's world-ranking events, which the Hearn and Doyle camps still intend to support, will be avoided. 
 According to Hearn the WPBSA intends to take only 16 players for a week to its overseas events instead of 32 for nearly a fortnight. 
 If so, these clashes of dates may not occur. 
 Clashes with the WPBSA on other fronts, however, appear inevitable. 
 Doyle said that he had been &bquo;totally frustrated&equo; by his two years on the board. 
 Hearn and Doyle are certain to be vocal at the WPBSA's annual general meeting at Bristol on December 29. 
 &bquo;I have no intention of wiping out the WPBSA or of setting up an alternative governing body,&equo; Hearn said. 
 &bquo;But the game has gone down the wrong road and we are not sitting back and just letting it happen.&equo; 
 Cricket Riot stops Pakistanis. 
 THE one-day international between Pakistan and India was abandoned yesterday after a demonstration in Karachi's National Stadium turned riotous. 
 Indian fielders were pelted with stones and oranges and police retaliated with tear-gas. 
 Several shots were fired but no casualties were reported. 
 Many of the 25,000 crowd fled at the sound of the shots. 
 A student with a revolver was caught trying to climb a wall into the ground. 
 Police used steel-tipped batons on the crowd outside the stadium. 
 Mohammed Azharuddin was slightly hurt when struck on the elbow by a stone while fielding, prompting the visiting team to run off the field through a hail of rocks and oranges. 
 The second game in the three-match one-day series, reduced from four after the first was downgraded to a friendly, was suspended after little more than an hour's play. 
 Pakistan had reached 28 for three after 14.2 of their allotted 40 overs. 
 Imran Khan was not out nine with Shoaib Mohammad on 13. 
 The umpires tried to restart the game after about 35 minutes but the Indian team again left the ground when Ravi Shastri complained the crowd was hurling stones. 
 Pakistan's Javed Miandad then appealed for calm, but he failed to quieten the protesters. 
 Although organisers still hoped the match could resume, the Indians refused to make another attempt to enter the field. 
 &bquo;We played under tension for 45 days on this tour,&equo; said Chandu Borde, the Indian team manager. 
 &bquo;How can you expect me to risk my boys?&equo; 
 The trouble began after spectators carrying flags of the opposition Mohajir National Movement gathered near a high steel fence outside the general enclosure and shouted slogans expressing their opposition to a visit to Pakistan planned by Indian film stars. 
 Fundamentalist groups in Pakistan are hostile to the Bombay film industry, believing that shows featuring women desecrate Islam. 
 Violence between Muslims and Hindus in India is reported to have claimed some 300 lives in the past few months. 
 Azharuddin, the one Indian player hurt in yesterday's demonstration, is a Muslim. 
 The final game of the series is due to be played tomorrow in Lahore. 
 South African Cricket Union officials, responding to an allegedly inaccurate itinerary published in a national newspaper yesterday, said they do not intend to reveal the schedule for the unofficial English team's six-week tour any earlier than mid-January. 
 But David Graveney, the team's player-manager, expressed some disquiet yesterday at the Sacu's reluctance to reveal details of the tour. 
 &bquo;This is not an undercover operation,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The players don't want to be leaving this country in disguise. 
 All this secrecy creates more fuss than is necessary.&equo; 
 The tour dates cannot be changed too much. 
 Travel agents in England have already sold package deals for holidays that include tickets for the international matches &mdash; five-day games in Cape Town (February 8-13) and Johannesburg (February 16-21) and a six-game series of one-day matches (February 23 to March 7). 
 Graveney said that the venues for the three three-day warm-up games were subject to alteration but that the international matches &bquo;are as first planned&equo;. 
 The first game is provisionally scheduled to begin on January 26. 
 Red League faces. 
 ITV's controversial screening of Liverpool's match with Manchester United on Saturday has caused the Football League more embarrassment. 
 Already almost &pound;200,000 poorer because of ITV's decision to delay screening of the match rather than show it live, the League has now admitted that its own company, Worldwide Soccer, will provide the network with the pictures. 
 Worldwide, through its Chrysalis subsidiary, has a contract with Granada TV to provide the coverage of all matches in the region, which includes Liverpool and Manchester. 
 Lee Walker, of the League's commercial department, confirmed the &bquo;long-standing&equo; arrangement, adding: &bquo;We will receive a fee, which I can't divulge, for the service.&equo; 
 ITV, paying &pound;25,000 compared with &pound;200,000 for a live broadcast, was accused earlier this week of acting outside the spirit of its &pound;44 million contract with the League. 
 Meanwhile, ITV announced yesterday that it will televise live Norwich's game with United on January 21. 
 Liverpool's call for a British Cup has been given a frosty reception by the Scottish League president, Jack Steedman. 
 The Anfield club want a tournament featuring top English and Scottish clubs plus two from Ireland. 
 But Steedman said: &bquo;The risk to our European status would be considerable with fans coming from the south to see games.&equo; 
 Stoke's manager Alan Ball has criticised agents after finally signing Preston's striker Tony Ellis for &pound;250,000. 
 A deal collapsed last week over personal terms. 
 After new talks succeeded, Ball said: &bquo;Sometimes agents&equo; demands exceed what the players want but, because they are in their stable, they have to take advice from these gentlemen. 
 Sometimes they price the players out of the buying or selling.&equo; 
 Steve Foley has become Colchester's caretaker-manager for a second time, Jock Wallace having been appointed a director last week &mdash; &bquo;I will do all in my power to help the club,&equo; he said. 
 Foley, a former Colchester player, was caretaker for three months before Wallace's arrival last January. 
 Foley does not want the permanent job, saying: &bquo;I again regard it as a short-term business.&equo; 
 Sailing Prime Factor in Britain's climb. 
 By Bob Fisher 
 APENALTY of nine places against the Australian yacht Prime Factor has dropped her team to third overall in the NorTel Southern Cross Cup series and lifted Britain to second. 
 Prime Factor was protested by Britain's Canon Express for an infraction of the basic right-of-way rule on the first leg of the fourth race. 
 The jury found that Canon Express, on starboard tack, was forced to give way to Prime Factor on port. 
 Britain trail New South Wales by 21.5 points but there is a protest outstanding against one of the NSW boats, Cyclone, which finished second in the race but is alleged to have fouled the Hong Kong yacht Foo2, the former Jamarella. 
 If the protest, to be heard before today's 25-mile inshore race, goes against Cyclone it will put Britain in the lead. 
 The wind gusted to 30 knots in the fourth race, and Heaven Can Wait, the British team's 50-footer skippered by Harold Cudmore, was among the damaged boats. 
 The mainsheet traveller tore off the deck and began a chain reaction: next to go was the boom vang, and this caused the boom to fracture at the gooseneck, overloading the mast check-stay which parted. 
 A temporary vang, taken to a pad-eye on the deck, then ripped the eye and a part of the deck away. 
 Surprisingly Cudmore and his crew finished seventh and kept their lead in the individual standings. 
 The Australian yacht Southern Cross inverted her mast &mdash; made it S-shaped &mdash; when some rigging gave way. 
 She will sail gently round the course in today's race to score what points she can, while a replacement spar is completed in time for the climax of the series, the 630-mile Sydney to Hobart race which starts on Boxing Day. 
 Racing: Morley Street looks tempting Ladbroke wager. 
 By Richard Baerlein 
 IN the &pound;40,000 Victor Chandler Handicap Chase, to be run at Ascot on January 13, Barnbrook Again is handicapped 14lb below Desert Orchid. 
 Yet William Hill, in the betting on the King George VI at Kempton on Boxing Day, only offer 3-1 against Barnbrook Again beating Desert Orchid, who stands at 15-8 on at level weights. 
 Admittedly, handicap weights have meant little of late in the top chasing events, with Long Engagement successful when carrying 15lb overweight and Solidasarock winning with 11lb overweight. 
 Although the Victor Chandler is a very well endowed race judged by English standards, there were only 23 entries and all but six are out of the handicap proper. 
 That does not say much for the top chasers of the day, which are very thin on the ground. 
 There may well be only six runners in the King George, but as long as Desert Orchid runs the faithful will be there. 
 If the English handicapper appears to have been lenient with Barnbrook Again, the Irish handicapper has been the same with Morley Street. 
 When the champion hurdler, Beech Road, and Morley Street won at Cheltenham ten days ago it was hard to say which put up the better performance and which would be the stable's first choice for the Champion Hurdle should both be trained for the race. 
 The general opinion, never a good guide, suggested there would not be much between them, but the Irish handicapper has decided that Morley Street is 12lb below his stable companion when framing the weights for the Ladbroke Hurdle. 
 Now that Toby Balding has decided to send Morley Street to Ireland for the race the 10-1 on offer from the sponsors is a most attractive price. 
 He must be well handicapped and is an improving horse. 
 Jonjo O'Neill cannot be dissatisfied with a 10st 2lb awarded to Vicario di Bray, whose rise to the top was somewhat dented in the middle of last season. 
 He looked such a handicap certainty for the Tote Gold Trophy that he quite ruined the betting on the race when starting 7-4 on in a field of 10, the smallest of the series. 
 He was well beaten and in a later race broke a blood vessel. 
 He is at his best on soft ground and would be a danger to all off his present mark if he could find his best form. 
 Even then I doubt if he would be a threat to Morley Street. 
 There will be no shortage of runners at Towcester or Kelso this afternoon. 
 The directors of Kelso, however, are disappointed at the continual absence of southern trained horses at their meetings, though half the prizes are at around &pound;1,500 to the winner and few above the &pound;2,500 mark. 
 The horse box charge from the south would be a minimum of &pound;500 and more for those coming from the West Country, so there would be little change from a &pound;2,000 race when all the expenses, including the deductions for trainer, jockey and stable lads have been completed. 
 A year ago we won a race at Carlisle, nearer to the south than Kelso, where the first prize was &pound;503 and the horse box alone was &pound;500. 
 The answer might be to reintroduce transport allowances, but only on Tuesday the Racehorse Owners' Association voted against that. 
 Furthermore, David McHarg, clerk of the course at Kelso and other Scottish tracks, said that when the transport allowances from the Levy Board were cut off it made no difference whatsoever to the number of runners. 
 When a clerk of the course comes out with a statement like this it seriously weakens the case of those, like myself, who would like to see transport allowances reintroduced. 
 The ROA would prefer to see the money used to increase prize money in the lower races, but when money is reallocated in that manner it has a way of disappearing. 
 At Kelso this afternoon Jonjo O'Neill can win the Birgham Hurdle with Stay Awake. 
 Northern Brave, the probable favourite, was rather disappointing last time out, and Valiant Boy may not have won such a good race as Stay Awake. 
 Dancing River, from the local stable of Arthur Stephenson, is a tip, but Stay Awake could be on the upgrade. 
 Gordon Richards, whose horses are bang in form, can win the Elibank Handicap Chase with Tartan Trademark. 
 Highfrith can be another winner for Richards in the Racing Post Novice Chase. 
 The horse was quite impressive when winning at Haydock and could record his fourth consecutive victory of the season, during which he has been unbeaten. 
 Miss Timber Topper looks best in the opener and after Richards has had another winner with Pyjamas in the St. Boswell's Handicap Chase I expect Stephenson's Jupiter's Glory to complete a great day for punters. 
 At Towcester Nicky Henderson can score a double with Mr Gossip, who will be making his seasonal debut, and Master Bob. 
 The stable is just finding its form now that the ground has changed and his horses can be followed with some confidence. 
 Jenny Pitman is another who has been waiting for the rain before releasing a very strong team. 
 There is a big tip for Egypt Mill, her runner in the final event, and he should not be opposed, though Father Time will be backed to beat him. 
 PAGE 
 Cool head with Italian passion on his hands Patrick Agnew in Cagliari watches Italy's manager Azeglio Vicini take a long view of today's match against Argentina. 
 AZEGLIO VICINI is not exactly a typical Italian, even less is he a typical Italian national team manager. 
 Born in the North at Cesena 56 years ago, he fits the stereotype of rational northern European much more comfortably than that of fiery Latin. 
 He fielded question after question from television crew after television crew in the unseasonably warm Sardinian sun yesterday, causing onlookers to wonder at his calmness, patience and diplomacy. 
 In the next six months, as Italy faces the responsibility of hosting next summer's World Cup finals, Vicini is likely to need all his inner calm if he is to keep his head while all about him people are becoming a little agitated. 
 As he prepares for this afternoon's prestige friendly against the World Cup holders, Argentina, in Cagliari, Vicini is characteristically playing the match down. 
 &bquo;Today's game is only of relative importance, not just because it is a friendly but for the good reason that today's Argentina bears little resemblance to the one that will play in next summer's finals. 
 The Argentines base their whole preparation on the last month of pre-World Cup training. 
 Next summer they will be much more prepared.&equo; 
 Win or lose, the important thing for Vicini is to set an example of calmness to his side, to remove some of the pressure of the nation's extravagant expectations. 
 For, as he never tires of repeating, Italians will judge anything less than a semi-final place next summer as a total failure. 
 In the meantime, however, Vicini has to consider how best to protect his players from Diego Maradona. 
 In his phlegmatic way, the Italian manager declined to say which defender will be assigned to mark the enfant terrible. 
 &bquo;Until I see the entire Argentine line-up,&equo; he said, &bquo;how can I possibly know how I shall mark him?&equo; 
 Under his apparent calm, however, the desire for victory is apparent. 
 A win against the reigning world champions is always good for morale, but in the wake of less than convincing performances against Brazil (1-0 defeat), Algeria (1-0 win) and England (0-0 draw), a resounding victory would keep the huge weight of the Italian sports press off Vicini's back. 
 Significantly, the Italian manager will not use today's game to experiment. 
 Leaving aside the injured Roberto Baggio, Andrea Carnevale and Ricardo Ferri, today's side is the strongest available. 
 It is significant, too, that Vicini has asked the Milan trio &mdash; Roberto Donadoni, Paolo Maldini and Franco Baresi &mdash; to play. 
 Since all three have been to Tokyo and back last weekend to help Milan win the World Club Championship, they might have expected to be rested. 
 As Italy have only two full-scale friendlies between now and the start of their World Cup training camp (against Holland in February and against Switzerland in March), Vicini wants to try out his strongest side. 
 Argentine preparation for today's game has been disrupted by the ever-controversial Maradona. 
 The world's most famous footballer declined to turn up at the Argentine team camp until late on Tuesday night, 48 hours later than most of his team-mates. 
 Furthermore, as soon as he did turn up, Maradona unwisely told the expectant press corps that he thought the World Cup draw had been fixed so that Italy would find itself in an easy group. 
 &bquo;I think the draw had already been done &lsqb;before being&rsqb; shown publicly for the benefit of television,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'm convinced of it. 
 I swear it.&equo; 
 The Italian Football Federation has taken note of Maradona's remarks and will pass them on to Fifa. 
 A heavy punishment could be on the way. 
 Carlos Bilardo fields a mixture of old and new. 
 The World Cup finalists Ruggeri, Batista, Pumpido, Olarticochea, Giusti and Burruchaga are joined by two newcomers, Dezotti in attack and Simon at libero. 
 These days, Bilardo is constrained to do his team coaching down the transatlantic telephone line, since half his squad play in Italy, France or Spain. 
 Given the difficulties of keeping tabs on faraway players, it comes as no surprise to learn that Bilardo has appealed to one of the key figures of his 1986 World Cup team, the 34-year-old Jorge Valdano, to end his two-year retirement. 
 Valdano, who gave up playing after struggling to throw off a viral-hepatitis problem, has agreed to attempt the unlikely come-back. 
 In the meantime Dezotti, who has scored eight goals for lowly Cremonese in the Italian First Division, has a chance to stake his claim to Valdano's old position. 
 Italy: Zenga; Bergomi, Maldini, Baresi, Ferrara, Berti, Donadoni, de Napoli, Giannini, Serena, Vialli. 
 Argentina: Pumpido; Ruggeri, Simon, Monzon, Batista, Olarticochea, Giusti, Bermaldo, Burruchaga, Mandolone, Dezotti. 
 PAGE 
 Cool head with Italian passion on his hands Patrick Agnew in Cagliari watches Italy's manager Azeglio Vicini take a long view of today's match against Argentina. 
 AZEGLIO VICINI is not exactly a typical Italian, even less is he a typical Italian national team manager. 
 Born in the North at Cesena 56 years ago, he fits the stereotype of rational northern European much more comfortably than that of fiery Latin. 
 He fielded question after question from television crew after television crew in the unseasonably warm Sardinian sun yesterday, causing onlookers to wonder at his calmness, patience and diplomacy. 
 In the next six months, as Italy faces the responsibility of hosting next summer's World Cup finals, Vicini is likely to need all his inner calm if he is to keep his head while all about him people are becoming a little agitated. 
 As he prepares for this afternoon's prestige friendly against the World Cup-holders, Argentina, in Cagliari, Vicini is characteristically playing the match down. 
 &bquo;Today's game is only of relative importance, not just because it is a friendly but for the good reason that today's Argentina bears little resemblance to the one that will play in next summer's finals. 
 The Argentines base their whole preparation on the last month of pre-World Cup training. 
 Next summer they will be much more prepared.&equo; 
 Win or lose, the important thing for Vicini is to set an example of calmness to his side, to remove some of the pressure of the nation's extravagant expectations. 
 For, as he never tires of repeating, Italians will judge anything less than a semi-final place next summer as a total failure. 
 In the meantime, however, Vicini has to consider how best to protect his players from Diego Maradona. 
 In his phlegmatic way, the Italian manager declined to say which defender will be assigned to mark the enfant terrible. 
 &bquo;Until I see the entire Argentine line-up,&equo; he said, &bquo;how can I possibly know how I shall mark him?&equo; 
 Under his apparent calm, however, the desire for victory is clearly visible. 
 A win against the reigning world champions is always good for morale, but on this occasion it would be especially welcome. 
 In the wake of less than convincing performances against Brazil (1-0 defeat), Algeria (1-0 win) and England (0-0 draw), a resounding victory would keep the huge weight of the Italian sports press off Vicini's back. 
 Significantly, the Italian manager will not use today's game to experiment. 
 Leaving aside the injured Roberto Baggio, Andrea Carnevale and Ricardo Ferri, today's side is the strongest available. 
 It is significant, too, that Vicini has asked the Milan trio &mdash; Roberto Donadoni, Paolo Maldini and Franco Baresi &mdash; to play. 
 Since all three have been to Tokyo and back last weekend to help Milan win the World Club Championship, they might have expected to be rested. 
 As Italy have only two full-scale friendlies between now and the start of their World Cup training camp (against Holland in February and against Switzerland in March), Vicini wants to try out his strongest side &mdash; which, of course, means playing both Baresi and Donadoni, arguably the two most influential players in the squad. 
 Argentine preparation for today's game has been disrupted by the ever-controversial Maradona. 
 The world's most famous footballer declined to turn up at the Argentine team camp until late on Tuesday night, 48 hours later than most of his team-mates. 
 Furthermore, as soon as he did turn up, Maradona unwisely told the expectant press corps that he thought the World Cup draw had been fixed so that Argentina would be in a difficult group and Italy in an easy group. 
 Carlos Bilardo, the Argentine coach, fields a mixture of old and new. 
 The World Cup finalists &mdash; Ruggeri, Batista, Pumpido, Olarticochea, Giusti and Burruchaga &mdash; are joined by two newcomers, Dezotti in attack and Simon at libero. 
 These days, Bilardo is constrained to do his team coaching down the transatlantic telephone line, since half his squad play in Italy, France or Spain. 
 Given the difficulties of keeping tabs on such faraway players, it comes as no surprise to learn that Bilardo has appealed to one of the key figures of his 1986 World Cup team, the 34-year-old Jorge Valdano, to come out of his two-year retirement. 
 Valdano, who gave up playing after struggling to throw off a viral-hepatitis problem, has agreed to attempt the unlikely come-back. 
 In the meantime Dezotti, who has scored eight goals for lowly Cremonese in the Italian First Division, has a chance to stake his claim to Valdano's old position. 
 Italy: Zenga; Bergomi, Maldini, Baresi, Ferrara, Berti, Donadoni, de Napoli, Giannini, Serena, Vialli. 
 Argentina: Pumpido; Ruggeri, Simon, Monzon, Batista, Olarticochea, Giusti, Bermaldo, Burruchaga, Mandolone, Dezotti. 
 Badminton Smith scents gold. 
 By Richard Jago 
 FIONA SMITH's brisk late-night win over Helen Troke in the final of the English National Championships at Crawley on Tuesday established her beyond question as the country's best woman player. 
 She is also an obvious favourite for the gold medal in the Commonwealth Games. 
 Smith was both the holder and top seed and, despite suffering from a heavy cold, she won 11-1, 11-7 with something to spare. 
 But she still laboured under the apprehension that she had to prove herself better than a famous opponent who has been more successful than any other English singles player of the decade. 
 &bquo;I just got used to being in her shadow and I still thought there were people who didn't reckon I was better,&equo; said Smith. 
 &bquo;But I have beaten her three times in a row, which proves the point. 
 It is probably the second most important win of my career.&equo; 
 The most important, Smith believes, was her success against South Korea's Hwang Hye-Young in the Wimbledon Open final in October and she has now improved her speed and self-confidence enough to seek regular victories over foreign opponents abroad. 
 She also has a genuine chance of succeeding Troke as a Commonwealth Games gold medallist, and may also make a challenge in Moscow in April for the European title, which Troke has won twice. 
 But first she must think about Auckland. 
 PAGE 
 Skiing The grass was greener in 1750. 
 John Samuel talks snow-famine with the FIS secretary 
 IN A normal year Franco Kasper, the International Ski Federation's secretary, would be at Saalbach in the Austrian mountain heartland today, running a critical eye over the brand new downhill course being tested in World Cup before next season's World Championships. 
 This, though, is not a normal year, or what many once thought of as normal. 
 Saalbach has been cancelled because the artificial snow at the bottom of the course has melted. 
 Schladming, just to the east, which tried to take on the World Cup commitment, has suffered similarly. 
 In either case Kasper could only have got there, like many of the top racers, on crutches. 
 In the autumn he broke a leg while attending the World Grass Ski Championships. 
 Where the new season's races have taken place, all have been on strips of man-made snow set into dun-coloured grass. 
 If they sound like Vimy Ridge then so, according to some, are the casualty lists, verbal exchanges of fire, post mortems and cries of ruination. 
 In recent years the FIS has known nothing like it. 
 Six hundred races were cancelled or rescheduled in 1987-88 and 800 last year, the worst on record. 
 Kasper was just back from an hour-long agonising on Swiss television about the disaster in store for the winter sports industry. 
 &bquo;It's true this is the first time all but one of the World Cup downhills have been called off before Christmas and, with the Madonna slalom cancelled, that's unique.&equo; 
 Already the FIS is discussing whether it should start the European season in Scandinavia, these days more reliably enjoying early snow, then move down to Central Europe to artificial-snow centres. 
 Critics, though, say man-made snow is dangerous. 
 Top racers already sidelined with injury include the World Cup champions Marc Girardelli, Vreni Schneider and Tamara McKinney; the former world champion Peter Mueller; the Olympic gold medallists Alberto Tomba and Martin Hangl; and the silver medallist Helmut Mayer. 
 &bquo;Yes, the injuries are worrying, but you can't lump them all together and blame artificial snow,&equo; said Kasper. 
 &bquo;Without man-made snow we would not have had the 1980 Lake Placid Olympics. 
 We would not have had World Cup races this season in Australia and the USA, or any at all in Europe. 
 &bquo;Yes, there are problems. 
 When you have fohn &lsqb;warm wind&rsqb; and temperatures go from minus 20 to plus 10 you get a kind of surface soap which can be a problem. 
 It is a little more difficult to ski at high speed. 
 &bquo;Man-made snow is harder to fall on. 
 Some of the runs are too narrow. 
 Falling on grass or hard ground can be dangerous. 
 Organisers set up safety netting well beforehand, then find course setters have changed the lines, so the nets are in the wrong places. 
 Mueller fell in practice on the Camel bumps where the man-made snow was perhaps too thin. 
 Those are things we are urgently addressing.&equo; 
 The postponed Val d'Isere and Saalbach downhills will be staged as early as possible in the New Year: low-level Garmisch will be the first notional beneficiary, but people are already talking in terms of Are, Sweden, in March. 
 &bquo;The winter only began in spring of last year,&equo; said Kasper, &bquo;but I'm cautious about changing our whole programme, even if we could. 
 &bquo;We've discussed the idea of continental championships in each of the disciplines and bringing the best skiers together for a Masters final late in the season. 
 &bquo;But how can you have Kitzbuhel and Wengen as qualifiers? 
 Would anyone want Wimbledon as a qualifying competition? 
 January is high season for ski racing. 
 There's a declining interest wherever we stage World Cup afterwards.&equo; 
 Kasper recalls the 1750 St Moritz snow record, culled by his father from church records. 
 &bquo;This year we had our first snow&hellip; on February 28.&equo; 
 A pity they did not have TV to show us Christmas cattle grazing the Alpine pastures. 
 Soccer Holland 0, Brazil 1 Brazil win a phoney war. 
 By David Lacey in Rotterdam 
 BRAZIL gently teased Holland's irregulars in the rains of Rotterdam last night without feeling the need to reveal the full range of their attacking talents for the benefit of prying eyes from Scotland and England. 
 Andy Roxburgh, who knows he will face the Brazilians in the World Cup next summer, and Bobby Robson, who suspects that he might, were reminded of Brazil's flair but had to take their finishing on trust until Careca won the game with a 54th minute header. 
 Brazil, undefeated in 15 matches since their disastrous European tour last June, when they were beaten by Sweden, Denmark and Switzerland, have now won in Italy and Holland as part of their warm-up programme for the World Cup. 
 Although these games are only part of the phoney war the results are still important to a country's prestige and confidence and Brazil would love to add England to their victims when they visit Wembley at the end of March. 
 This is the date England had originally set aside for a friendly against the Republic of Ireland in Dublin but which both Robson and Jack Charlton agreed to abandon when they found themselves paired in the same World Cup group. 
 England, who could meet Brazil in the second phase, may find the exercise more worthwhile than an hysterical afternoon at Lansdowne Road. 
 For their part the Brazilians want to play British oppositon to remind themselves of what it feels like to be searching for the ball in the air for much of the game. 
 Every time they looked up last night all they experienced was rain, rain and more rain. 
 It was Holland's first home defeat since they lost a friendly 2-1 to Bulgaria in the same stadium in May 1988 shortly before embarking on their triumphant course towards the European Championship. 
 The truth is that Holland were not Holland last night, just a raw collection drafted in to complement the remnants of their regular side. 
 None of their Milan players made an appearance. 
 Gullit, of course, is injured and there are still fears for his playing career, never mind his appearing in Italy. 
 Rijkaard and Van Basten had travelled to Holland but Milan did not want them to play and both pulled out of the squad, Rijkaard with flu, Van Basten claiming he was tired after his trip to Tokyo for the World Club Championship. 
 Ronnie Koeman captained the Dutch team for half the game after Johan Cruyff, the expatriate but hardly patriotic Dutchman who manages Barcelona, had ordered him to rest for a week. 
 Barcelona only released Koeman after the Dutch Football Federation had threatened both the club and the Spanish FA with legal action over a clause which stipulates the number of matches for which their foreign-based players have to be released during the season. 
 Koeman gave Holland 45 minutes of limited credibility and might have inspired a Dutch goal in the second minute when his early through-pass beat Brazil's offside trap and sent Kieft clear on the right. 
 On a dry pitch Kieft might have gone for goal instead of squaring the ball to Berghuis, one of four new Dutch caps to appear during the game, whose shot sailed high over the bar. 
 Holland gained few glimpses of goal after that, although Taffarel failed to hold a hard low centre from Berghuis eight minutes before half-time and was fortunate that no Dutchman was around to pounce on the loose ball. 
 Brazil, marking tightly and tackling hard, looked as well organised in defence as they had done against Italy in Bologna two months earlier. 
 Again, however, their finishing was hardly commensurate with the skill and imagination of their approach work. 
 Valdo, Alemao and others often showed a remarkable lightness of touch in the soggy conditions but several times promising movements failed for want of a penetrative final pass or someone reading the right space at the crucial moment. 
 For the best part of an hour Brazil produced a dainty dish to set before the Queen of the Netherlands, who may have felt that she had something better to do than sit out a sparring match in driving rain. 
 But the match needed an attacking spark from Romario or Careca to bring it fully to life and the goal saved the evening a damp, dismal denouement. 
 The moment was worth waiting for. 
 Jorghino, suddenly spring-heeled and full of running on the right wing, outflanked the Dutch defence before producing an inspired centre. 
 Careca rose to head the ball firmly down past Van Breukelen. 
 Brazil will fill Wembley next March and if they show just a fraction more ambition near goal it will be a night to remember. 
 Last night was one to bear in mind. 
 Not a bad game in the circumstances but just a preliminary skirmish in World Cup terms. 
 HOLLAND: Van Breukelen (PSV Eindhoven); Sturing (Vitesse), Reekers (Bochum), R Koeman (Barcelona, Laamers, h-t), Van Tiggelen (Anderlecht), Wouters (Ajax, Blind, 68min), Latuheru (Vitesse), Van Aerle (PSV), Kieft (PSV, Van Loen, 79), Ellerman (PSV, Winter, 20), Berghuis (Volendam, Van't Schip, 58). 
 BRAZIL: Taffarel (Porto Alegre); Jorginho (Leverkusen), Aldair (Benfica, Julio Cesar, h-t), Mozer (Marseille), Branco (Porto), Ricardo Rocha (Sao Paulo), Alemao (Napoli), Dunga (Fiorentina, Silas, 73), Careca (Napoli, Muller, 73), Valdo (Benfica), Romario (PSV, Bebeto, 58). 
 Referee: W Fockler (West Germany). 
 Soccer. 
 Holland 0, Brazil 1 
 Soccer Holland 0, Brazil 1 Careca rules the waves. 
 By David Lacey in Rotterdam 
 BRAZIL teased and tantalised Holland's irregulars in Rotterdam last night without feeling the need to reveal the full range of their talents for the benefit of prying eyes from Scotland and England. 
 Andy Roxburgh, who knows he has to face the Brazilians in next summer's World Cup, and Bobby Robson, who knows he might, were reminded of Brazilian flair but were left to take Brazilian finishing on trust until Careca, the Napoli striker, headed them in front early in the second half. 
 With all the rain emptying itself over the Feyenoord Stadium it was hard to put last night's match in the context of a World Cup which is more likely to present problems of heat than waterproofing. 
 The Queen of Holland probably felt she had something better to do. 
 At least the night held more relevance for the manager of England who, though watching a Dutch side deprived of most of its foreign-based players, now had a chance to run the rule over a Brazil team finally set to play at Wembley on March 28. 
 The Brazilians want to remind themselves of the British style before they meet Scotland in Italy. 
 The earliest they can play England or Holland is in the second phase. 
 Not that Sebastiao Lazaroni, the Brazilian manager, was ever going to learn much about the Dutch last night that he did not already know. 
 Gullit is still injured, with his playing career in doubt, and the other two Milan players in the Dutch World Cup squad, Rijkaard and Van Basten, both pulled out yesterday at short notice. 
 Rijkaard had flu and Van Basten said he was still tired after the trip to Tokyo at the weekend for the World Club Championship. 
 Milan had asked both not to play. 
 However, Ronnie Koeman was in the Holland team as captain in spite of Johan Cruyff, his manager at Barcelona, ordering him to have a week's rest. 
 Koeman's presence almost brought Holland a goal in the second minute. 
 His early through pass caught Brazil moving up too late for offside and Kieft broke clear before squaring the ball to Berghuis, one of three new caps in the Dutch team, who lifted his shot high over the bar. 
 Unlike Holland, Brazil played the team which will probably appear in Italy. 
 Valdo and Romario soon defied the squelching conditions with a double exchange of passes that took them through the middle of the Dutch defence before the ball rolled across a gaping goalmouth with no one to apply a finishing touch. 
 Holland lost Ellerman, victim of a brusque tackle from Mozer, midway through the first half and, although his replacement was the experienced Winter, the change did nothing to help the Dutch search for a blend. 
 After their early opportunity Holland did not glimpse another scoring chance until eight minutes before half-time, when Kieft and Koeman combined to set up Berghuis for a hard, low cross which Taffarel could not hold. 
 Winter was just too far away to take advantage. 
 A few minutes later Branco sent a typically fiendish Brazilian free-kick dipping and swerving past the wall and Van Breukelen, who rarely encountered anything like this in his Nottingham Forest days, punched the ball clear without knowing much about it. 
 After half-time Holland allowed Koeman to resume his week's rest and Laamers, a fourth new cap, replaced him. 
 Brazil replaced Aldair in their back four with Julio Cesar. 
 The rain returned in earnest and, for all the skill and craft of Valdo, Alemao and the rest, the evening desperately needed an explosion from Careca or Romario near goal to bring it to life. 
 Right on cue a Brazilian goal arrived in the 54th minute and was largely the result of a surging run on the right and inspired cross from Jorginho, Careca rising to meet it with a firm header down past Van Breukelen. 
 Given their weakened state, the Dutch had done well to hold out for so long. 
 HOLLAND: Van Breukelen (PSV Eindhoven); Sturing (Vitesse), Reekers (Bochum), R Koeman (Barcelona), Van Tiggelen (Anderlecht), Wouters (Ajax), Latuheru (Vitesse), Van Aerle (PSV), Kieft (PSV), Ellerman (PSV), Berghuis (Volendam). 
 BRAZIL: Taffarel (Porto Alegre), Jorginho (Leverkusen), Aldair (Benfica), Mozer (Marseille), Branco (Porto), Ricardo Rocha (Sao Paulo), Alemao (Napoli), Dunga (Fiorentina), Careca (Napoli), Valdo (Benfica), Romario (PSV). 
 Referee: W Fockler (West Germany). 
 PAGE 
 Italian League may ban Maradona over allegations. 
 DIEGO MARADONA could be fined or banned from playing in the Italian League because of his reported remarks that the World Cup draw was fixed, a spokesman for the Italian Federation said yesterday. 
 The disciplinary commission of the Italian League will consider disciplinary action against the Argentinian, who plays for Napoli. 
 Maradona, who captains the defending World Cup champions, was quoted in several Italian newspapers yesterday as saying that &bquo;World Cup groups had been predetermined and the draw was made just for the fun of the television audience&equo;. 
 A federation spokesman said that Fifa had been informed. 
 Maradona allegedly made his remarks after he arrived by private aeroplane to join the Argentinian team in Cagliari for today's exhibition match against Italy. 
 Scudamore lands treble and equals his record century. 
 PETER Scudamore landed a 71-1 treble at Bangor yesterday on Miss Chalk, Redgrave Devil and Abbotts View. 
 His second victory &mdash; on Redgrave Devil in the Barkin Developments Novice Chase &mdash; brought up the 100 on the same date he achieved the fastest ton last season. 
 Scudamore, who went on to ride a record 221 last term, said: &bquo;To ride 100 winners is always a thrill. 
 Everything else is a bonus, but it's also a bit like hunting round the first circuit safely in the Grand National &mdash; you know it's the next circuit that matters.&equo; 
 Both Miss Chalk and Redgrave Devil are trained by Martin Pipe. 
 Miss Chalk, who joined Pipe a couple of months ago, started 5-2 for the first division of the Yellow Collar Selling Hurdle and made all the running to beat Dreaming Star by 10 lengths. 
 Pipe watched the race in a Wellington betting shop then returned to his car to hear the racecourse auction relayed on a phone from his son David. 
 After Miss Chalk had been retained for 5,000 guineas David said: &bquo;I think my father is pleased. 
 She cost only 3,000 guineas.&equo; 
 At Folkestone the stewards asked trainer Roger Hoad to explain how Carfax came to be declared a &bquo;non-runner&equo; by the Press Association, who supply riding plans to the newspapers, after running second to Yanbu in the Sellindge Selling Handicap Hurdle. 
 He told them he was unable to account for the error. 
 None of his staff had given the information to the news agency and the explanation was accepted. 
 Judges declare Jockey Club is above the law. 
 TWO judges yesterday dismissed the case brought by a racehorse owner and trainer in the High Court and upheld the Jockey Club's argument that its decisions were not open to judicial review by the courts. 
 But Lord Justice Neill, sitting with Mr Justice Roch, said that Adrian Massingberd-Mundy had been treated with a &bquo;surprising lack of courtesy&equo; by the Jockey Club. 
 Massingberd-Mundy, a 62-year-old former Royal Navy submarine commander of South Ormsby Hall, Louth, was attempting to quash a decision by the Club to strike him off the list of potential chairmen of the stewards' panel at Doncaster racecourse. 
 This followed an argument seven months previously about a stewards' inquiry into a televised race. 
 The inquiry was ordered into the Glasgow Paddock Selling Hurdle on December 12, 1987 after allegations of interference by the riders of the first and second horses. 
 Massingberd-Mundy, then chairman of the panel and a local steward since 1970, claimed the stewards' secretary, Major Peter Steveney, threatened to report him to the Jockey Club if he stuck to his personal view that both horses should be disqualified. 
 Massingberd-Mundy complained to Lord Vestey, then chairman of the Club's disciplinary committee, about Steveney's remark. 
 In July 1988 he received a letter from Lord Vestey saying his name was withdrawn from the rotating list of those qualified to act as chairman. 
 He claimed in court that he had been treated unfairly. 
 Lord Justice Neill said an examination of the Royal Charter under which the Jockey Club was set up and of the powers conferred on it suggested that in some aspects of its work it operated in the public domain. 
 (The judicial review procedure is available to complainants only in public-law matters, not in private contractual disputes). 
 But in an earlier case, he said, it had been held that the authority of the stewards of the National Greyhound Racing Club to suspend a trainer's licence was derived solely from a contract between him and the club and that the stewards were purely a domestic tribunal. 
 The judges in that case recognised that decisions of the stewards might affect the public but concluded they were not decisions in the sphere of public law. 
 &bquo;It is important,&equo; Lord Justice Neill said, &bquo;that the courts should act with restraint before interfering with the decisions of sporting bodies, however wide-ranging their powers may be.&equo; 
 Costs were awarded against Massingberd-Mundy. 
 Paul Fitzpatrick finds the gem of rugby league literature Semi-detached Moorhouse. 
 SINCE Raymond Fletcher and David Howes joined forces nine volumes ago the game has been well served statistically by the Rothmans Rugby League Yearbook, and the standard remains impressively high. 
 Complementing it is the British Coal Yearbook which offers a written record of the season and which has expanded this time to embrace the seasons in France, Australia and New Zealand. 
 It is doubtful, in these expensive times, if there is a sports book anywhere that offers better value for money. 
 No question, though, about the pick of probably the largest and choicest crop of books in the game's history. 
 Geoffrey Moorhouse's At the George is, to my knowledge, the first collection of essays on the sport. 
 It could well remain the best. 
 It was only to be expected that a man who has written with such insight and style about Calcutta and New York, cricket and the crossing of deserts would do justice to a life-long passion. 
 But, while working from the premise that rugby league &bquo;is incomparably superior to any other winter game&equo;, this is no emotional treatise but an intelligent, dispassionate examination of the game in relation to its environment, to art and to other sports. 
 There is a sense of hero-worship for the Wigan side of the immediate post-war period especially and for Wally Lewis. 
 But detachment is one of Moorhouse's qualities, and he is blind neither to the failings of individuals nor to those of the game as a whole. 
 Ray French does not possess Moorhouse's gifts as a writer, but he has never been short of constructive opinion, good ideas or a sense of humour, qualities readily apparent in More Kinds of Rugby. 
 This takes a look at where the game has been in the Eighties and where it might be going in future. 
 French has had a busy year. 
 He has also compiled 100 Great Rugby League Players. 
 It is expensive but has a host of fine illustrations to support the 500-word pen-portraits. 
 Robert Gate has gone up in the world, and no one deserves it more. 
 There was a time when he was forced to publish his own works, but now Arthur Barker has done him proud with Rugby League: An Illustrated History. 
 Gate, now the game's official historian, has written a typically well researched text to go with an excellent collection of illustrations and cartoons. 
 Rothmans Rugby League Yearbook by Raymond Fletcher and David Howes; Queen Anne Press, &pound;11.95. 
 British Coal Yearbook; Kingswood Press, &pound;6.99. 
 At the George by Geoffrey Moorhouse; Hodder and Stoughton, &pound;10.95. 
 More Kinds of Rugby by Ray French; Kingswood Press, &pound;7.99. 
 100 Great Rugby League Players by Ray French; Macdonald, &pound;15.95. 
 Rugby League: An Illustrated History by Robert Gate; Arthur Barker, &pound;9.95. 
 Sports Politics Burns dismissed as World Student Games organiser. 
 By John Rodda 
 PETER BURNS, head of the Sheffield World Student Games organisation, has been dismissed by the company which is organising the event, Universiade GB Ltd. 
 He goes because of &bquo;an irretrievable breakdown&equo; between the board of the company and himself, according to the official announcement issued by Irwin Mitchell, the company's solicitors. 
 At a long meeting of board members on Monday, Burns was asked to resign and refused. 
 There was a further meeting yesterday &mdash; at the solicitors' offices &mdash; at which he was not present. 
 Forecasting his impending departure, Burns, who was appointed as a consultant in April of last year, said on Radio Sheffield that if he was dismissed he would be seeing his solicitor. 
 The Universiade GB board also announced that the immediate cash-flow problems, revealed a week ago, had now been resolved by an injection of funds by Sheffield City Council and that further offers of financial support are to be followed up immediately. 
 Members of the board then went to the organisation headquarters to reassure the staff &mdash; there are now 35 working on the project &mdash; that the Games would go ahead. 
 Norman Adsetts, chairman of the Regional Council of the CBI and a leading Sheffield businessman, has been appointed to oversee the running of the day-to-day business of the company. 
 Last night he pledged &bquo;determination, effort and energy&equo; to make the games a success. 
 The key to the problems facing Sheffield has been a lack of sponsorship by commercial companies. 
 Announcements have been promised but have not materialised. 
 Two months ago the company was confident that sponsorships would be in place by Christmas. 
 Yesterday, however, Peter Price, deputy chairman of the council and a member of the board, said that they would not now be likely to be available before Easter. 
 There should, however, be a timely upswing in Sheffield's fortunes with an announcement that a television contract has been agreed. 
 It is likely that Sky and Eurosport will be taking the role of host broadcaster, which will guarantee sponsors some form of exposure of their products during the Games, from July 14-25, 1991. 
 Sheffield City Council, which is handling the infrastructure for the Games, has also met problems over one of the showpiece arenas, the Pond's Forge swimming complex. 
 The project is three months behind schedule and will not be completed until December 1990, with a cost over-run of 14 per cent, or &pound;6 million. 
 Davies speaks volumes Robert Armstrong on the biography destined to be a rugby union classic. 
 BOOKS FOR CHRISTMAS 
 TO BE sure of getting value for money in rugby books it is usually good policy to lash out on a yearbook or an expensive work of reference. 
 Autobiographies, ghosted or not, and &bquo;humorous&equo; essays tend to lurk in the literary equivalent of shark-infested waters. 
 One notable exception to the bland, sanitised image-building that marks many a sporting biography is Jonathan, the story of perhaps the most gifted Welsh fly-half the Lions never had. 
 Written by Peter Corrigan, with first-person inserts from JDavies, this handsome book is about as close as one can get to a warts-and-all picture of an ambitious international player. 
 The loss of Davies to Widnes last January has cast a long shadow over British rugby. 
 What a difference he could have made to the Barbarians in their recent clash with the All Blacks. 
 Jonathan charts the painful break with union which it seems remains his first love &mdash; while Corrigan delves into the psychology of a man who temporarily split up with his wife, Karen, as a result of the grinding pressures of the modern game. 
 Strangely Davies has never been fully appreciated in Wales, possibly because his genius could often only flicker in a context of national decline. 
 In a real sense league has been the making of him, supplying the hard gloss finish he might never have acquired in union. 
 Davies may number John McEnroe and Alex Higgins among his heroes yet mundane security has now replaced his self-destruct button. 
 A quick sidestep from the sublime to the ridiculous carries one into Ripley's Very Rough Guide To Rugby. 
 The tactical value of Velcro, jock straps scented with Chanel No.5, the pitfalls of mixed rugby, the Exiles' disease chronicus Taffyitis &mdash; there is information here for the most esoteric taste, not to mention pictures so surreal that Magritte (a minor Belgian prop) would be proud to own them. 
 Andy Ripley is mad, mad, mad, but he made me laugh. 
 It is less disconcerting to tackle the Rugby Union Yearbook, a glossy new annual edited by Mick Cleary who sets out to offer more words and less statistics than the respected Rothmans Rugby Union Yearbook. 
 Cleary wanted to include the imprimatur &bquo;Official&equo; in his title but somehow the Rugby Football Union, despite weighing in with pieces by the President and the Secretary, never got around to giving its official blessing. 
 Never mind: the action pictures by Russell Cheyne are worth the price on their own. 
 For a good lively read it is worth dipping into The Whitbread Rugby World &bquo;90. 
 The former Wallabies coach Alan Jones examines the umbilical links between commerce, international rugby and player demands for financial security and much of the Whitbread, edited by the broadcasters Nigel Starmer-Smith and Ian Robertson, is devoted to the Lions&equo; tour of Australia which gives a sharp retrospective edge to interviews with David Campese and Ian McGeechan. 
 However, one could have done without the editors' patriotic digs at Australian journalists who are certainly no more chauvinist than British fans with typewriters (or indeed television cameras). 
 The rise and rise of league rugby makes the Official Rugby Union Club Directory an indispensable guide to the intricacies of England's premier domestic competition. 
 If you never knew the club colours of Bakewell Mannerians or the membership fees for Old Patesians, here is the ideal means of finding out. 
 The Rugby Clubs of Wales hit the bookstalls in good time for the All Blacks' tour. 
 Anyone who wishes to hone up on the likes of Cross Keys or Maesteg, not to mention aristocrats like Llanelli, will find a great deal to intrigue and amuse. 
 Finally, the autobiography of Colin Deans, You're A Hooker Then, has been reissued in paperback. 
 His wife Val contributes a postscript in which she reveals, rather wanly, that she is still looking forward to her honeymoon, postponed because of a rugby match. 
 &bquo;Prepare to sacrifice a lot of your own life,&equo; is Val's advice to would-be rugby wives. 
 Jonathan, by Peter Corrigan (Stanley Paul, &pound;12.95). 
 Ripley's Very Rough Guide To Rugby, by Andy Ripley (Stanley Paul, &pound;9.95). 
 Rugby Union Yearbook, edited by Mick Cleary (Virgin, &pound;12.95). 
 Rothmans Rugby Union Yearbook, edited by Stephen Jones (Queen Anne Press, &pound;11.95). 
 The Whitbread Rugby World &bquo;90, edited by Nigel Starmer-Smith and Ian Robertson (Lennard Publishing, &pound;9.95). 
 Official Rugby Union Club Directory 1989-90 (Daily Mail, &pound;9.95). 
 The Rugby Clubs of Wales, by David Parry-Jones (Stanley Paul, &pound;12.95). 
 You're A Hooker Then, by Colin Deans (Pan, &pound;3.99). 
 Hockey England skip cup. 
 By Janet Ruff 
 ENGLAND and Holland have declined to enter the sixth European Women's Indoor Cup early next month because it has been sprung on them by the European federation. 
 The event has been brought forward a year from 1991 and moved also from France to West Germany. 
 The switch and consequences leave the Germans with the gold medal practically on a plate. 
 They have won all previous championships. 
 The Dutch were silver medallists last time and England have taken the bronze in the last two events. 
 They are reluctant absentees but with the difficulty of revising an overcrowded fixture list, and no financial provision for the event or the extra training at &pound;1,200 a weekend, they have taken the line of least resistance. 
 &bquo;It was a decision taken without any joy,&equo; said Joyce Clarke, chairman of the England indoor committee. 
 &bquo;We are all disappointed, particularly the players.&equo; 
 England's World Cup preparation outdoors could clearly not be ignored but, even with a weakened squad, a medal might have been in reach. 
 Last weekend they won the HDM tournament in The Hague for the first time while Karen Brown, Mary Nevill, Sandy Lister and Tracy Fry were engaged on outdoor commitments. 
 Scotland at their best and Ireland should now reach the semi-finals and Wales, competing for the first time, could join them. 
 EUROPEAN WOMEN'S INDOOR CUP (Jan 6-7): Pool A: Scotland, Poland, W Germany, Italy or Switzerland. 
 Pool B: Ireland, Wales, Spain, France. 
 The Hockey Association has acknowledged its error in planning to stage the eighth-finals of the Nationwide Anglia English Cup on January 6, writes Pat Rowley. 
 It has agreed that, because of international players' commitments, only three of the eight ties will be played on that date, with the others in the following four weeks. 
 Rugby Union Banned for year. 
 By David Plummer 
 RICHARD ANTHONY, the Cross Keys lock forward, has been banned for 33 playing weeks for verbally abusing a referee. 
 He was reported for remarks made to the Taffs Well official Gwyn Bowden after Cross Keys' local derby against Newbridge three weeks ago. 
 The Welsh Rugby Union disciplinary committee handed out such a stiff sentence &mdash; Anthony will be out of the game until December 1990 &mdash; because this was his fourth offence. 
 He received a 16-week suspension for a third sending-off when he was playing his rugby with Cwmbran. 
 &bquo;Similar offences in the past have received a fortnight's suspension, but because of the player's disciplinary record he has been given this long ban,&equo; said the committee chairman David Johnson. 
 &bquo;He has been told that if there is another occasion he will attract an indefinite period of time out of the game. 
 &bquo;He was suspended for two weeks for the abuse offence, one week for a previous sin-bin and then the rest came from his past cases.&equo; 
 The WRU and its leading 18 clubs are deadlocked over the issue of leagues, with no sign of a thaw in the cold war between the two bodies which has gone on for two years. 
 The Merit Table clubs are refusing to take part in the WRU's national league structure unless they are allowed to run the competition. 
 The Union says that that will not happen, and the clubs have refused to enter into any more negotiations with the WRU. 
 The WRU now has to decide whether to take its ultimate sanction and expel the 18 from membership. 
 The governing body insists leagues will start next September, but it wants to delay as long as possible any decision about what to do with the Merit teams. 
 &bquo;We hope they will resume talks, but we cannot waste much more time. 
 That is not fair to all the other clubs. 
 I just hope that the Merit Table representatives fully realise the implications of the stand they are taking,&equo; said a WRU spokesman. 
 Steve Bates, the Wasps scrum-half, has recovered from an ankle injury in time to take his place in the England B team for Saturday's match against the Soviet Union at Northampton. 
 Earlier in the week Rupert Moon, the Neath scrum-half, was drafted into the squad as possible cover for Bates but primarily to fill the gap left by Dewi Morris on the replacements' bench. 
 Morris was concussed playing for the North at the weekend. 
 The London play-off between Middlesex and Hampshire to decide the division's county championship semi-finalists, postponed last night because the Staines pitch was water-logged, will be played on January 31 at a venue to be decided. 
 Jon Webb, the Bristol full-back, has told the England manager Geoff Cooke that he still wants to play international rugby. 
 There had been speculation over his future after he was dropped by the South-West. 
 Triple Cross sinks Derby. 
 STEVE CROSS, a tireless Derby midfielder, settled the Zenith Cup tie at Newcastle last night with his third goal of the game in the 114th minute. 
 Unfortunately, it was into his own net. 
 Cross equalised Liam O'Brien's 25th-minute goal with a superb chip over John Burridge, then put Derby into the lead in the fourth minute of extra-time. 
 Peter Shilton, who had performed impeccably, then conceded the decisive goals to a deflected shot from Gallacher and Cross's own-goal. 
 Bernie Slaven brought his goals for the season to 19 &mdash; one behind Mick Quinn and Darran Rowbotham among the League's top scorers &mdash; with three for Middlesbrough in their 4-1 win over Sheffield Wednesday. 
 Alan Kernaghan scored the fourth when Kevin Pressman was unable to hold another shot from Slaven. 
 Chris Lightfoot scored two in three minutes to overcome a seventh-minute deficit at Rochdale and put Chester City into the first round of the Leyland Daf Trophy. 
 The match of the day, though, took place at Darley Abbey in Derbyshire. 
 Nigel Clough, the 23-year-old Nottingham Forest and England striker, married Margaret Sharp. 
 Table Tennis Douglas takes on the Preans. 
 DESMOND DOUGLAS has accused the English Table Tennis Association of giving preferential treatment to Carl Prean, the son of the ETTA chairman. 
 The 34-year-old left-hander, 10 times the England champion, wants a meeting between players and officials at the end of the season. 
 &bquo;We want one rule for everyone and no favouritism.&equo; 
 Douglas referred particularly to Carl Prean's recent decisions to withdraw from the national rankings and forgo the English Top 12 tournament at the end of the year. 
 &bquo;Carl's decision not to go on the ranking devalues the No.1 position of Alan Cooke,&equo; Douglas said. 
 &bquo;And Carl has decided not to play in the Top 12 because of a commitment with his German League team. 
 But when I missed it last year because of the Euro-Asia match I was severely criticised by the chairman.&equo; 
 Douglas and Prean will face each other tonight in the Macartney and Dowie Classic at the Peneil Academy in Brentwood. 
 They have been drawn in the same group, along with Steve Dorking, the England No.9. 
 Cooke, the winner of the inaugural tournament last year, faces Nicky Mason and Matthew Syed in the other group. 
 Australia v Sri Lanka: second Test, fifth day Border's year ends on a high note. 
 MERV HUGHES took the final wicket with just half an hour remaining as Australia beat Sri Lanka by 173 runs to win the second Test in Hobart yesterday. 
 It was Australia's sixth victory in 11 Tests during 1989. 
 With the other five games drawn, the unbeaten run is Australia's best for 15 years. 
 Australia, who had set Sri Lanka 522 to win after declaring their second innings at 513 for five, appeared to be coasting home when they took three wickets before lunch to reduce the touring side to 208 for six. 
 But Ravi Ratnayeke and Asoka de Silva took Sri Lanka to within 70 minutes of their second draw of the two-match series. 
 The resistance was broken when a tiring Ratnayeke was superbly caught by the wicketkeeper Ian Healy, one-handed down the leg side, for 75 after flicking once too often at Greg Campbell. 
 Ratnayeke hit 13 boundaries in adding 124 for the seventh wicket with de Silva, whose 50 was his maiden half-century in first-class cricket. 
 The remaining three wickets fell cheaply, with Aravinda de Silva named man of the match after his innings of 72. 
 Arjuna Ranatunga, the Sri Lankan captain, accused the Australian team of making racist taunts during the game. 
 He said: &bquo;When we played last time we didn't have any problem, but here they tried to unsettle us because they were really frustrated. 
 We were not disappointed but we were a little hurt.&equo; 
 Australia's captain Allan Border said: &bquo;I wasn't aware of any problems. 
 There certainly weren't any racial taunts, so there's obviously been a misunderstanding there.&equo; 
 The leg spinner Peter Sleep, the all-rounder Tom Moody and Carl Rackemann have been left out of next week's squad for the one-day tournament against Sri Lanka and Pakistan. 
 Rugby League Hull try to catch Webbe. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 HULL officials are travelling to South Wales this weekend &bquo;to talk, not to watch&equo; and are confident that they will sign two players, one believed to be the 26-year-old Bridgend wing Glen Webbe. 
 Nigel Davies, the Llanelli centre, has been touted as the possible second man, but he has recently recovered his place in the Welsh squad. 
 Hull, who had Webbe watched in Bridgend's game with Neath a week last Saturday, say that the two players involved were &bquo;very keen&equo; to turn professional. 
 But Hull also say that if the pair decide to change codes it will be for realistic sums of money. 
 Webbe is reported to want a four-year, six-figure contract. 
 Webbe's appearances for Bridgend have been limited this season and he has only five tries so far. 
 But he is regarded as one of the quickest men in Welsh rugby and has 198 career tries to support the claim. 
 He has played 10 times for Wales. 
 The success of Gerald Cordle at Bradford Northern could persuade Webbe that a move to the Boulevard would be in his interests. 
 The former Cardiff winger has his faults but so far he has adapted well to his new code and in a Bradford side playing more expansively these days is seeing plenty of the ball. 
 He is joint fifth top scorer in the First Division with 16 tries. 
 Gary Lord has replaced Gary Spencer at full-back in the Leeds side to meet Wigan in tonight's Regal Trophy quarterfinal replay at Central Park. 
 Hugh Waddell, the Great Britain forward, absent since November 19 with a broken jaw, and David Creasser, who has played only once this season, are the Leeds substitutes. 
 Ruthless cuts are being made to Canada's railway system and the last whistle is soon to blow for the country's most famous train, The Canadian. 
 Matthew Engel climbed aboard in Montreal Last train to Medicine Hat. 
 TRAIN No. 1, The Canadian, leaves Central Station, Montreal every morning at 9.55. 
 It arrives, theoretically, in Vancouver three days, three hours and five minutes later, having crossed 2,887 miles of pine-wilderness, prairie and mountain. 
 The official guidebook calls it &bquo;the world's most spectacular rail journey.&equo; 
 In my childhood encyclopaedia it was listed among the marvels of the world, along with the Taj Mahal and Everest. 
 The distinctive dome-cars were almost as potent a symbol of Canada as the moose and the Mounties. 
 Three weeks hence, The Canadian will head west for the last time. 
 Then it will be abolished, along with more than half the country's other trains. 
 Brian Mulroney's Conservative government in Ottawa has imposed, through an order-in-council subject to no legislative scrutiny whatever, what is probably the greatest single cutback in public transport attempted anywhere. 
 January 14 will see the Last Train to Medicine Hat, to Moose Jaw, Locust Hill, Swift Current and Indian River; to Antigonish, Merigomish and Hectanooga; and &mdash; because Canadian placenames reflect a variety of influences &mdash; to Weymouth, Berwick, Peterborough and Pontypool. 
 Government funding is to be pruned over three years from &pound;350 million to &pound;200 million. 
 In one daring Beechingesque stroke, VIA Rail, the national passenger service, will cut its 405 trains a week to 191, and its workforce of 7,000 to 4,000. 
 From seven million passengers this year, the system will carry an estimated four million next. 
 This sort of thing is known here, in a touchingly post-colonial manner, as &bquo;Thatcherism.&equo; 
 It will still be possible to cross Canada by train, just. 
 But there will be three trains a week instead of 14, all going by the less attractive and evocative northern route and not over the historic line of the Canadian Pacific Railway. 
 No one expects this rump of a service to be viable. 
 It is possible that by the mid-1990s &mdash; barring a few suburban services &mdash; Canada will become the first industrialised country to abolish passenger trains completely. 
 Yet this was the nation created by railways. 
 The completion of the Canadian Pacific was the condition of the west joining the confederation. 
 The related arguments and scandals dominated Canadian politics throughout the 1870s and 80s. 
 Its construction, by 30,000 men over vast tracts of unexplored Canadian trains are among the last refuges from the characterless hell of modern travel. 
 country with an outrageous climate, was probably the greatest of all navvying adventures. 
 The cities of the west only exist because the railway came through there. 
 And there is something about rail travel that is essentially Canadian: the US, deep down, was always a stagecoach society, wayward and unpredictable; trains seem right for Canada, exciting but disciplined. 
 The Canadian West was never that wild: the Mounties and a strong puritanical streak saw to that. 
 &bquo;Every country has a great national epic,&equo; said Pierre Berton, Canada's best-known journalist. 
 &bquo;Most of them are bloody wars. 
 Ours was the building of a railway. 
 It is our seminal story.&equo; 
 Berton wrote two popular history books on the subject &mdash; The National Dream and The Last Spike. 
 Both phrases have been much invoked in recent weeks as in: &bquo;Mulroney has driven the Last Spike into our National Dream.&equo; 
 The decision was announced by the Transport Minister Benoit Bouchard (&bquo;Benny the Butcher&equo;) in October. 
 It was greeted with some fury: &bquo;It's the beginning of a war,&equo; said Fernand Daoust of the Quebec Federation of Labour. 
 &bquo;No one will rest.&equo; 
 But this is Canada and wars happen elsewhere. 
 In the small city of Sydney, Nova Scotia, a thousand did turn out to protest at the loss of the local train. 
 There have been complaints in all the affected towns: about the lost jobs, the hardship to students and the old, the economic and environmental effects. 
 But when a national day of action was organised in Ottawa earlier this month just 200 stood in the cold outside Parliament. 
 It takes a lot to arouse nationwide indignation in Canada. 
 It is a country of strong, clean, wholesome, enviable communities, leading American lives without quite being part of America. 
 But it hardly exists as a nation in a recognisable sense. 
 St John's, Newfoundland is nearer to Liverpool than to Winnipeg. 
 Vancouver is another world. 
 Traditionally, Canada was said to be bound by the Canadian Pacific's ribbon of steel. 
 And what else is there? 
 The monarchy? 
 Excuse me. 
 A shared culture? 
 A third of the country speaks French. 
 Ice hockey? 
 Maybe. 
 A shared distrust of the United States? 
 Most likely. 
 Canadians do not even travel across the country that much. 
 There is none of the restless westwardness of the US. 
 When a Quebequois or a Torontonian gets fed up with life 30 degrees below freezing, he heads south to the Caribbean not west. 
 Hardly anyone ever travels the full 3,727 miles from sea to frigid sea &mdash; Halifax, Nova Scotia to Vancouver, British Columbia &mdash; except the odd, crazed British journalist. 
 And yet it is such a magnificent journey. 
 It is not the scenery &mdash; after the first million pine trees there are a billion more. 
 It is the trip itself. 
 Canadian trains are among the last refuges from the pre-packaged, plastic, characterless hell of modern travel. 
 No wonder they are being abolished. 
 Trains called The Atlantic and The Ocean make the 21-hour trip from Halifax to connect with The Canadian at Montreal. 
 This, however, turns out to be a polite fiction. 
 The Canadian's carriages actually start from Toronto. 
 The train that leaves Montreal comprises only a couple of day coaches, linking up with the main service 10 hours later at the junction town of Sudbury, Ontario. 
 No one, however, dare tell the Quebecois that their train is not No.1. 
 A roomette on The Canadian, when you eventually join it, is slightly under seven foot by three (which includes a private lav) with a bed that slides out from the wall; it thus manages to combine the characteristics of both the womb and the mortuary. 
 It is totally private, there is no need ever to leave it and I swear the Japanese woman opposite never did. 
 Define heaven. 
 A jug of wine, a loaf of bread and thou? 
 Pate de foie gras to the sound of trumpets? 
 Or miles to go, a good book, a comfy seat and no decisions to make except first sitting or second, beef or sole (both freshly-cooked), red or white? 
 Yet no one can ever be lonely on The Canadian. 
 Within five minutes of ordering lunch or a drink, someone will tell you his life story. 
 Ordinary bland rich Canadians go by plane, which is quicker; ordinary bland poor Canadians go by bus, which is cheaper. 
 This leaves the train free for the unbland minority. 
 There was Gerry who made a fortune in the Californian avocado boom and now just wanders the world. 
 There was Ian, Canada's leading advocate of childhood suffrage. 
 There was Libby, a middle-class city girl who lives in a log cabin in the sub-arctic woods. 
 There was Joshua, whose arms were covered in tattoos. 
 On his left bicep was the grim reaper with battleaxe; on his right wrist was the motto &bquo;Live Free or Fuck Off&equo;; Where, I asked coversationally, did you get that done? 
 &bquo;Oh, in prison,&equo; he said casually. 
 We sat, a strange but contented group, in the dome-car bar as the train swayed through Western Ontario. 
 When the line came through here, it was built inch by inch through solid rock. 
 Its progress now was often no quicker. 
 The temperature outside dropped: 20, 30 degrees below freezing. 
 Icicles the size of stalactites hung from the eaves of wayside stations. 
 The track itself is often obliterated and a large part of a rail man's job is hacking ice and snow away from the points or the platforms between carriages. 
 Inside, everything The bar was like a cruise ship passing through the tropics &mdash; but without quite the same sexual charge. 
 was cosy. 
 Except for the new diesel engines, the trains date back to 1954. 
 They were built, in steel and chrome, to last &mdash; but not quite this long. 
 As the railways run down and maintenance gets neglected, they keep going wrong: the steam-heating in particular. 
 Happily, it usually becomes over-cosy rather than frozen solid. 
 The bar was like a cruise ship passing through the tropics without, I thought at the time, quite the same sexual charge. 
 But after almost everyone had tiptoed tipsily to bed, one couple &mdash; or so I was told over breakfast next day &mdash; stayed behind in the darkened dome-car and made love softly, to the rhythm of the rails. 
 It is too good to last, of course. 
 Only three per cent of Canada's inter-city journeys are made by train. 
 Professor Julius Lukasiewicz, professor of aerospace engineering at Carleton University, Ottawa, has advocated the abolition of the passenger service for years. 
 &bquo;It will be scrapped, of course,&equo; he told me. 
 &bquo;It is not that I am in favour of it, it is what is happening. 
 We are subsidising users of The Canadian 300 per cent and there is no justification for it.&equo; 
 What about the environment, I said. 
 &bquo;The diesel engines are much more of a pollutant than buses,&equo; he said dismissively. 
 &bquo;I know it's a nice way to travel. 
 I would love to have a chauffeured Cadillac but I can't afford it.&equo; 
 The pressure group Transport 2000 (Transport 1800, as Professor Lukasiewicz calls it), loosely linked to its British namesake, is fighting a rearguard action, which is less of a defence of the railways than an attack on their management. 
 &bquo;It is not that the Canadians have deserted the railways,&equo; says Roy Jamieson, their policy officer, &bquo;the railways have deserted Canada.&equo; 
 VIA Rail was set up in 1977 after the competing giants, Canadian Pacific, now grown into a huge conglomerate, and its nationalised rival Canadian National had found passenger travel a distraction from the main business of moving freight. 
 VIA was given no clear brief, no money for investment, an absurdly top-heavy management structure and a board described by Roy Jamieson as &bquo;a dumping ground for political hacks.&equo; 
 VIA also has to pay heavily to use the tracks and it is almost universally agreed that CP in particular has spent the last 12 years over-charging and trying to find ways of clearing the passenger trains from the path of its lucrative freights. 
 CP is certainly not protesting about Benny the Butcher. 
 The original payoff for building the railway was a swathe of the adjoining land. 
 Cities naturally grew up next to the tracks and railway land thus became Canada's prime real estate. 
 The mere business of shifting passengers has long been a dreary distraction. 
 The railways are also a sink of ancient union restrictive practices. 
 The Canadian has an operating crew of five (excluding the dozen or so service staff) and no one is entirely clear what they all do: fill out forms mostly, so far as I could see. 
 The employees are accepting their fate with the usual mix of bitterness and resignation. 
 &bquo;Twenty-two years,&equo; sighed Mike Wolfe, the service director on The Canadian. 
 &bquo;I grew up on this train, eh? 
 It's not very nice, is it?&equo; 
 Mr Wolfe had just been doing his customary job of explaining to the passengers why we were late: &bquo;We have an emergency situation which is not a real alarm situation.&equo; 
 The train had been forced to brake hard at a level crossing to miss a taxi and one of the wheels had been damaged. 
 We waited an hour, two hours, three hours. 
 Outside, it grew ever colder. 
 The snow started again, gently. 
 Inside, the water in one of the bathrooms froze. 
 No one worried much; people in a hurry have long since found another way to travel. 
 Four hours late, the train limped into Winnipeg at midnight. 
 They released the valves on the heaters and vapour poured from every orifice, turning the station into something like Monet's Gare St Lazare. 
 Dawn on Day Three and we were crossing the prairies. 
 There was only a scattering of snow across the wheatlands, the area which needs it most to moisten the soil for the growing season. 
 Whenever there was a stretch of double track, we would usually stop to let through a freight train. 
 The towns here &mdash; Portage-la-Prairie, Brandon, Regina, Medicine Hat &mdash; were created by and for the Canadian Pacific. 
 It is supposed to be the boring part of the journey and if the train were on time would be crossed at night. 
 I was enthralled by the emptiness. 
 We had some excitement too. 
 A couple got off the train, were met by the police and put up a ferocious but unsuccessful fight: suspicion of a bank robbery the previous day, apparently, back down the line in Thunder Bay. 
 After Calgary (population: 400,000; rail service after January: one train a week, summer only) we were in the mountains, and people crowded into the dome car for the high spot of the trip. 
 But we were so late it was growing dark. 
 I decided to stop in Banff, a ski resort created by the railway, for 24 hours. 
 It was 26 hours, actually; the next day's train was even later. 
 And the mood on this one was far grimmer. 
 The passengers had spent six hours stuck without explanation in Winnipeg. 
 The conductor, who has overall charge of the train, was less friendly than most. 
 The cast of characters was less interesting: mostly Japanese honeymoon couples, travelling en masse, and train buffs. 
 But the lateness meant that the thrilling descent towards Vancouver, down the Fraser River Canyon, took place in daylight. 
 I would have done it all again. 
 I am not so sure about the Japanese honeymoon couples. 
 It will still be possible to make this part of the journey next year. 
 The Rocky Mountaineer will continue to make one round trip a week in summer from Vancouver to Calgary. 
 But that is tourism not travel, and the fares are about to double. 
 A private firm is also trying to start a luxury train &mdash; the Occident Express, I suppose &mdash; but if it happens the fare will be over 1500 pounds. 
 Ian and Libby and Joshua will be travelling by bus or car; it might suit Avocado Gerry, though. 
 And the bank robbers. 
 Maybe we could all find space aboard one of CP's freight trains. 
 Hobby hoboism has become quite fashionable among bored yups in California. 
 But it is perhaps a little too wild for a Canadian weekend. 
 Rather cold up here, too. 
 For most, this does seem like the last ride over the Canadian Pacific. 
 Pierre Berton, who wrote the books, has just got back from Vancouver. 
 How was it? 
 &bquo;A good flight, thank you.&equo; 
 Flight? 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; he said, &bquo;I went across Canada 12 times during the war on trains with slatted seats. 
 They smelt of oranges and babies. 
 I hate railways.&equo; 
 Richard Sarson considers the task facing Steve Shirley, the admired new president of the BCS Aiming high. 
 GERMANS are not often polite about British managers. 
 But Ralf Dahrendorf, when he left the post of director of the London School of Economics, answered the question &bquo;Has Britain got a future?&equo; by singling out Steve Shirley. 
 He saw F International, her company of home-working software writers and consultants, as a model of successful innovation. 
 Ms Shirley is now faced with a tougher challenge for her revolutionary management skills. 
 She has just taken office as president of the British Computer Society, and needs to make it jump from the seventies, where some believe it is still stuck, into the nineties. 
 She says she &bquo;wants to bring it centre-stage&equo;. 
 It is far from centre stage at present. 
 None of its suggestions to the DTI Select Committee last year on training, infrastructure, and government procurement policy were accepted by the Government. 
 But another forum for part of the computer industry, the Computer Services Association (CSA), got what it wanted &mdash; a promise from the Government to buy in from software houses at least one-third of the applications software needed to run the ministries. 
 This reflects a Thatcherite judgment that the CSA, an employers' association representing over 300 companies, has more clout than a chartered professional institute with 30,000 registered members. 
 That figure sounds a lot, but does not rate very high against the estimate of 300,000 professionals &mdash; programmers, systems analysts, project managers, networking specialists and support staff &mdash; in the industry. 
 This one-to-10 ratio makes the computer profession unlike law, architecture, medicine and even engineering, where you need to be registered and qualified before you start practising at all. 
 The letters MBCS after your name cut little ice with personnel managers and head-hunters, except in academia and in software houses whose chairmen are pillars of the BCS. 
 The others tend to say &bquo;experience is more important than qualifications,&equo; and &bquo;in a fast-moving industry like ours, paper qualifications are obsolete before they are printed.&equo; 
 They say the same about computer science degrees. 
 So, why bother to spend years jumping over the BCS hurdles? 
 There are other grumbles about the society, very often coming from members themselves and sometimes published in the society's own organ, the Computer Bulletin. 
 One recent letter deplored the excessive influence of academia, pointing out that 10 out of 12 of the Bulletin's editorial board are from universities. 
 David Mann, managing director of Logica, wrote in an editorial that the BCS &bquo;is regarded as more of an enthusiast's club than a professional institution and is considered to have an academic bias with insufficient relevance to the problems of implementing real-life industrial and commercial systems.&equo; 
 Away from London, however, BCS branches are places where computer people, both academic and business, can huddle together for warmth in a hostile world. 
 The Belfast branch, for instance, with 700 members, draws its officers from the civil service, the Electricity Board, local software houses and the University of Ulster. 
 It has a young professionals group and the bootstrappers club for teenagers. 
 This branch's annual programme covers every aspect of computing from Transputers and Women in Computing, through Document Image Processing to 4GLs (fourth generation languages). 
 It holds joint meetings with the British Institute of Management, the Institute of Electrical Engineers, the NCC, and the Irish Computer Society across the border. 
 Des Vincent, this year's branch president, says that the BCS &bquo;pulls things together. 
 It's the communication vehicle which we desperately need over here.&equo; 
 The BCS does lots of other good things, like sitting on 31 standards committees, working with 15 European computer societies to harmonise professional qualifications for the single market, accrediting computer science courses to make them less theoretical and more oriented towards projects, maintaining a register of expert witnesses, setting up ad hoc specialist groups very quickly on new areas like expert systems, natural language translation and parallel processing, and helping the disabled. 
 It even has a strategic review panel to act as a think-tank. 
 So, while it can seem churlish to knock the BCS, what has so far been lacking is someone to harness these scattered initiatives and local enthusiasms into a national force. 
 The main block is that the London-based mandarins of the BCS still appear to see the world from the seventies standpoint of the large data processing installation or university department, full of Cobol or Fortran programmers, churning out hand-crafted systems for mainframes. 
 The nineties are not going to be like that. 
 The micro-revolution of the eighties gave the world not only cheap machines &mdash; which are now more powerful than the mainframes of the seventies &mdash; but tools like spreadsheets, 4GLs, Case (computer-aided software engineering) tools and data management languages. 
 These systems are going to become more and more simple, to accomplish more and more complex tasks. 
 The BCS has got to decide whether it is just for computer people who produce systems, or also for those &mdash; accountants, engineers, project managers, architects, writers, artists, musicians and designers of arcade games &mdash; who apply them. 
 If it is the latter, then the BCS must revamp its qualifications, to attract the new membership. 
 This need not reduce the rigour of the professional disciplines demanded, but it would make the qualifications less technical and inward-looking. 
 One BCS initiative has started to produce a &bquo;hybrid&equo; &mdash; a computer-person who understands the outside world, or conversely an outsider who understands computers. 
 It might even bring British computer people up to the level of their more professional continental opposite numbers. 
 If membership of the BCS becomes more relevant to the nineties then government departments, personnel managers, and recruitment consultants will start demanding the letters MBCS after the candidate's name, as in other professions. 
 The 30,000 should swell to 100,000 in five years, and the BCS would move centre-stage. 
 PAGE mc1 
 In Real Women Don't Take It Lying Down (December 14), Tony Parsons accused women of giving up the fight against sexism. 
 The response &mdash; from tacit agreement to outrage &mdash; was enormous&hellip;. 
 Real women &mdash; and men &mdash; answer back 
 IN RESPONSE to Tony Parsons, there are several reasons for so-called post-feminism. 
 One is the influence of the media (which created the mythical bra-burners). 
 The &bquo;new angle&equo; must be sought to retain reader interest, and this goes beyond the cynical. 
 What's in will be out and vice versa. 
 And movements follow the finite. 
 Secondly, the second generation, by its nature, must reject its elders, taking their hard-won social victories for granted. 
 And with the cold-eyed realism that not a lot has been achieved by feminism, many younger women have sought to take on men on their own ground, accepting extant values and the handicaps of modern commerce and industry. 
 Hatred and fear of women is not new and is overt in religions, so much so that the evolvement of codes of courtesy to the female has been felicitous. 
 Male and female roles were separate and complementary, and based on the primitive, that the male was the stronger and not exposed to the constant and deathly risks of the childbed. 
 But that began to give way in the Industrial Revolution. 
 An increasingly complex society began to need new skills &mdash; quick-wittedness, dexterity, verbal skills, all traditionally associated with the female. 
 So women's labour was needed in the market, and men became reactive on three counts. 
 Their jobs were threatened; their cradle to grave support system was threatened; and, most dangerously, their view of themselves, of their maleness, their dominance, their bravery, was threatened. 
 It is this, I think, that causes such venom, such reaction. 
 Tony Parsons says get tough. 
 There are those of us who don't want to be tough, who think that tough leads to murder. 
 Who wants a society that reduces men to predatory thugs, when there is so much to be done? 
 Perhaps with society more dominated by the old, there will be more respect for wisdom, sagacity. 
 For men to model themselves on Ulysses rather than Hercules. 
 And women? 
 Perhaps they can be let off the hook, be allowed their complexity. 
 Pam Gems London W2 
 THERE'S no shit from Tony Parsons, he knows he's a sack of scum. 
 So are all the lads. 
 Trouble is, you can't expect a man to change himself. 
 No, ma'am. 
 You women are neglecting your duty. 
 You must take our hands and show us the way, like Mum did. 
 And if you don't? 
 Well, Tony and the boys will be forced to remain scumbags. 
 Peter Francis-Mullins London SE22 
 THANK you so much for Tony Parsons' brilliant article. 
 I agree with every word. 
 Thank God someone's said it. 
 We really need more help from you good men to stand up and be counted! 
 Kate O'Connor London NW1 
 PARSONS' piece was well meant, but very revealing about the attitude of a supposedly enlightened male. 
 He spoke of men's &bquo;sexist&equo; behaviour, but laid the responsibility for providing a remedy with women, who must exercise a &bquo;civilising influence&equo; on these infantile people. 
 No, thanks. 
 This is patronising to men and idolises women. 
 Parsons wrote that he &bquo;hates post-feminists&equo;. 
 A touch of misogyny there perhaps? 
 These women he decries are simply weary with having to be constantly on guard against abuse, and why should they have to justify their position when the men are at fault? 
 When women do confront sexism, the glib reply is often that it is a joke. 
 Parsons concludes with a purposely provocative comment about an actress: &bquo;Great pair of tits&hellip;&equo; 
 Oh, I see, it was only a joke. 
 You're not really ridiculing the anger I experience at your flippant pseudo-feminist attitude. 
 With friends like you&hellip; 
 Catherine Jeffrey London N8 
 IT MAY surprise Tony Parsons to know that real feminists have more important things to do than comment on the way he holds a teapot. 
 They are too busy campaigning on issues like equal pay, childcare, child benefit, violence against women, homelessness, carers, the representation of women in Parliament and public life, rights for part-time workers and the myriad other urgent issues with which they are confronted each and every day. 
 Amongst those concerns, the issue of the portrayal of women in the media features prominently. 
 Serious feminist magazines like Spare Rib and Everywoman, and both specialist and generalist groups, such as the Campaign Against Pornography and the Townswomen's Guilds, all tackle these issues in an informed, responsible way. 
 For Tony Parsons to imply that he has a monopoly of concern on these matters or that so-called &bquo;post-feminists&equo; have copped out of the struggle is an insulting travesty of the truth. 
 Jane Grant Director, National Alliance of Women's Organisations London E1 
 BY SUGGESTING that women have a monopoly on being civilised, does Tony Parsons not open the door for double standards of judgment to be applied to the behaviour of women and men? 
 Is this not the worst and most pernicious kind of sexism? 
 Jonathan Chalstrey Woodstock, Oxfordshire 
 TONY Parsons' article was a mixture of self-indulgent bullshit and pure shit-stirring. 
 I am, I am told, a post-feminist merely because I prefer a constructive approach to the achievement of equality rather than one that is essentially negative. 
 &bquo;Making a fuss&equo; has always been counterproductive and superficial. 
 To achieve profound change, women must necessarily work within the existing structure. 
 An attempt to revolutionise social attitudes is no less revolutionary merely because it is subtle. 
 I like the Fat Slags because they scare the shit out of men. 
 Millie Tant, who also graces the pages of Viz, is viewed with contempt. 
 The question has to be: who is the more liberated? 
 I plump (!) for the Fat Slags every time. 
 HSMorris Bristol PS I did find the article amusing and am no less a woman because I did. 
 Men do not have the sole franchise on a sense of humour. 
 HAVING just read Tony Parsons' article, I feel like exploding. 
 I'm so angry that he would be proud of me! 
 Can women ever win in this male world? 
 When women march and protest, they are howled down. 
 When they try sweet reason they are ignored. 
 When they stoop to the level of men and try to be &bquo;good sports&equo;, they're accused of being wimps. 
 I would like to ask Tony Parsons if he &bquo;liked&equo; the &bquo;old&equo; style feminist? 
 Did he stand up to be counted in the old days? 
 I think not! 
 Let me tell you, Tony Parsons, what I as a woman hate. 
 I hate men like you who proclaim that they are supportive of women and their efforts for equality. 
 Where are these men when, as you say, there are men literally getting away with murder? 
 Why don't you protest loud and long when women are depicted in the media and the arts as sexual stereotypes? 
 If men &bquo;need &mdash; crave, cry out for &mdash; the civilising influence of women&equo;, my advice is to shout a little louder because women can't hear you. 
 MERule Ormskirk, Lancs 
 SORRY, pal. 
 If you are waiting for post-feminists to hasten to your rescue, girding their loins and hairy-leggedly taking on the Viz comics and Dennis Potters of this world on your behalf, I would suggest that you don't hold your breath. 
 Here is one post-feminist who has better ways of occupying her time. 
 Lesley Maltman Tonbridge, Kent 
 WHAT WE &bquo;post&equo; feminists need are more men like Tony who are prepared to stand up in their men's self-help groups &mdash; instead of wasting space on the semen-stained women's page &mdash; and acknowledge together that they are basically &bquo;sacks of scum&equo;. 
 Men have been getting away with murder for years. 
 Go and cut your own mustard, Tony. 
 We're too busy trying to avoid the bullets. 
 Karen Stowe, Michelle Rogers London N5 Guardian Women is edited by Louise Chunn PAGE wom 
 Audrey Segal. 
 Caring career woman:. 
 AUDREY Segal was a remarkable woman who overcame her disabilities &mdash; she was confined to a wheelchair for 23 years after contracting a virus in Morocco &mdash; to invent and develop careers education in this country, and to remain its foremost exponent for more than 20 years. 
 Her extraordinary enthusiasm for her work (including regular contributions to the Guardian and Observer), was registered in guffaws of delight at new discoveries and scoops. 
 She could virtually match the data bases of bodies like UCCA for up-to-the-minute information, and she saw earlier than most the new opportunities opening up in Europe for higher education students. 
 For many years she had worked as a librarian before switching to journalism, training &bquo;on-the-job&equo; under an American industrial and securities correspondent and as personal assistant to Dan Rather, now CBS's news anchorman, then becoming a freelance writer. 
 Audrey was famous for her accuracy, and her appetite for information was voracious. 
 She compiled a 1300-page Careers Encyclopedia for school-leavers, graduates, parents, teachers and advisers (She was working on its thirteenth edition when she died. 
 She also edited Which Degree? and Which University? from 1966-80, as well as Graduate Studies, and the Directory of Graduates. 
 Her disability never stopped her attending meetings, briefings and conferences, often aided by her twin sons, Paul and Mark, and she would ask uncommonly fierce questions from her wheelchair. 
 But, above all, she will be remembered for her passionate caring for young people and their prospects, dedicating her career to enhancing theirs. 
 David Gow Audrey Segal, born April 9, 1932; died December 12, 1989 
 Closed minds on the closed shop Commentary. 
 By Hugo Young 
 THE MOST interesting reaction to the Labour Party's abandonment of the closed shop is not that of the Left or the unions but of the Conservatives. 
 They are deeply shocked. 
 Their response encompasses indignation yet also disbelief. 
 They cannot accept that one of their most cherished foxes has been shot. 
 So they choose to contend that it has not really happened: and in so choosing raise a timely question about the nature of political belief. 
 For this is not the first such episode. 
 Every shift towards plausibility which Mr Kinnock has led the Labour Party into making has received a version of the same response. 
 Because Labour was once against Europe, it cannot now be for Europe. 
 Because it was once the party of nationalisation, it cannot now be the party of the small shareholder. 
 Because it used not to understand markets, it cannot conceivably have rectified this gap in its political intelligence. 
 Furthermore, although it may sincerely believe it is a new party, the very fact that it has often changed its mind should debar it from being taken seriously. 
 These changes, the argument runs, are not real and will not stick. 
 By deserting its past, Labour has misled us about its future. 
 Without a shred of embarrassment, the sentimental Tory takes out his hanky and invites us to watch him dripping crocodile tears of fond reminiscence for the days of that most honourable of men, so lauded by the Conservatives of his era, Mr Tony Benn. 
 Coming from Thatcherites, this is a puzzling charge. 
 They are, after all, the arch exponents of a political style in which denouncing the past was the most satisfying of activities. 
 From 1975 to 1979, Mrs Thatcher was engaged in a process not dissimilar from that which Mr Kinnock now presides over. 
 She tore up the inheritance of Edward Heath, as if she had had no part in it. 
 She began to re-write Tory policy on tax, on public spending, on welfare, on corporatism. 
 She eventually articulated a philosophy which depended in large and explicit measure on repudiating what Conservatism had said about the role of the State for the past 30 years. 
 For a party with that record now to deride as unreal, and even denounce as illegitimate, opponents who are also re-examining their past suggests the presence of a certain myopia. 
 Nor is that all. 
 For is this not also the party which is led by a woman who has devoted much effort to preaching the virtues of abolishing precisely what Labour is trying at least to re-define: socialism itself. 
 When Dr Owen left Labour to form the SDP, Mrs Thatcher's outrage was genuine. 
 She always said he should have stayed to fight his corner. 
 Now that Mr Kinnock is achieving the same effect, ought this not to attract the modest admiration of an opponent whose vision of British politics has, in any case, always seen Republicans and Democrats &mdash; capitalist parties both &mdash; as the model which a well-ordered, post-Thatcherite country should emulate? 
 One part of this myopia can doubtless be attributed to simple electoral panic. 
 If Labour looks like becoming credible, Conservatives must find any stick with which to mutilate the appearance of a smooth conversion. 
 But lying behind this is a rather higher claim which deserves not altogether sceptical consideration. 
 What does distinguish the Thatcherite from the Kinnockite conversion is the connection it originally made with party roots. 
 Although Thatcherism denounced past policies, it affected to return to past philosophy. 
 It was radical, but also reactionary. 
 It proclaimed the rebirth of right-wing ideology, a term which readily entitled its new exponents to talk about their pure &bquo;convictions&equo;. 
 Possessed of such, and revelling in the distance set between them and miserable &bquo;pragmatism&equo;, Mrs Thatcher's Conservative Party can still persuade itself to see the last decade as a period when undeviating conviction wrought a miracle in the land. 
 The Kinnock conversion has gone in the opposite direction: away from ideology, towards &bquo;realism&equo;. 
 And realism, it is argued, is a poor basis for belief. 
 Lacking such belief, will not Labour be wrested from its pragmatic and up-to-date policies at the first whiff of hot breath on Prime Minister Kinnock's neck? 
 For firmness of purpose, surely, can only be associated with the missionary attachment to first principles which he has been energetically abandoning. 
 This seems to me to be mostly self-regarding poppycock. 
 The record of this government, conviction-inspired though it thinks of itself as being, is replete with pragmatic compromise of every kind. 
 It has deviated from passionately enunciated principles on monetarism, on public spending's rightful portion of GNP, on Ireland, on state control of education, on (soon) immigration, and much else. 
 Shouting about convictions is no guarantee that they will survive a period in government. 
 Still more tendentious is the Tory claim as it relates to a potential Labour Government. 
 For the implication it carries is that Kinnock is in truth a ravening left-wing wolf but briefly clad in the sheepish woolies of a moderate man. 
 Thus, his new commitment against the closed shop, through the acceptable voice of Mr Tony Blair, awaits only the sniff of power to be countermanded. 
 Europe, on this reading, will swiftly go the same way. 
 All in all, the entire Labour package is a massive con-trick, which a sinister shadow cabinet, behind its smiling mask of reassurance, is even now preparing to abandon under the narcotic influence of power. 
 There are certainly some Labour MPs who would like that to happen. 
 But to suppose that this picture bears the faintest resemblance to what the Labour leadership wants betrays something like paranoia cubed. 
 The truth is almost exactly the opposite. 
 One does not need to scrutinise Labour's policy positions for their mystical inner sincerity in order to evaluate the leadership commitment to them. 
 The fact is that Mr Kinnock and his friends understand well enough not only that they could not be elected but that Britain could not be governed without some serious accommodations of the kind they now stand for. 
 The leadership wants the old baggage left behind; wants to avoid legislating against public opinion, as with the closed shop; wants to stick with a hard-headed economic programme. 
 The leadership also has a new control, which makes it less likely to be unhorsed by its own interest-groups than the Callaghan Government was in the late 1970s. 
 So it is fanciful to suppose that Labour's conversion somehow cannot last and is not real. 
 On the other hand, it does badly need shoring up. 
 Labour may not be in the business of re-connecting with the past, but its attachment to the future is still confused. 
 What this debate about conviction highlights is the continuing absence in the new Labour Party not of sensible policies but of an enveloping conviction that can be easily summarised, passionately preached, readily understood. 
 It has legitimately changed its mind. 
 Its leaders have policies they want to stick to. 
 What they still lack is what the Tories would fear rather than scorn: three easy sentences to ring the bell. 
 Quote&hellip;. 
 BECAUSE the United States is to reduce its military spending, it is inevitable it will withdraw some of the US military forces now based in Japan and reduce forces deployed for emergencies. 
 The United States would request its allies to fill in the &bquo;vacuum&equo; created by such cutbacks &mdash; this would increase the so-called burden sharing. 
 Japan, especially, is likely to be pressured to take on more of the burden sharing. 
 It is likely that Japan's defence spending will continue to grow on the theory that circumstances in Asia are different from those in the West, and that burden sharing is a matter of course under the US-Japan security treaty. 
 We must be prepared for an ironic result &mdash; that the reduction of US military spending will lead to an increase in Japan's defence spending. 
 Ashai News Service, 
 December 18 
 Herbert Blaize. 
 Their man in Grenada:. 
 HERBERT Blaize, a courtly politician of a bygone Caribbean era, believed God had chosen him to restore democracy to Grenada after 7,000 US troops invaded his island in 1983 to overthrow its marxist rulers. 
 In the eyes of many, especially Washington, he succeeded, with a free press, elections and liberal economics. 
 But to others, he was a stubborn old man, in constant physical pain, who harassed his opponents, drove his ministers to resign and clung ignominiously to power after losing his once-crushing parliamentary majority. 
 One of his last acts, two days before his death from prostate cancer, was to accept formal leadership of a new political party after his own had sacked him. 
 He tried to speak from his wheelchair, but his voice was gone and he gave up. 
 Such indignity had better beginnings. 
 The son of a labourer from Grenada's sister island of Carriacou, which he represented in parliament for nearly 30 years, he cut his political teeth, like many other Caribbean leaders, working at the giant Lago oil refinery on Dutch-ruled Aruba in the 1940s. 
 But he returned to Grenada to throw his lot in with the mostly light-skinned urban middle class to which he only half belonged. 
 By 1957, he was in parliament, leader of the Grenada National Party and head of government. 
 His lifelong political rival, the charismatic, unlettered Eric Gairy, mocked Blaize's kindly manner as weakness. 
 But except for a brief interval, Blaize ruled for 10 unmemorable years until Gairy decisively beat him at the polls a few months after Britain granted the island wide autonomy in 1967. 
 His political career was apparently finished. 
 He returned to Carriacou and qualified as a solicitor through a London University correspondence course. 
 No-one saw him as an alternative to the increasingly-authoritarian left-wing regime of Maurice Bishop in the early 1980s. 
 Yet after 7,000 invading American troops had swept away the revolutionaries, Blaize was imposed by the US and its Caribbean allies as the harmless head of a reluctant coalition of squabbling younger politicians, a half-respected figure from the past who might block the eccentric Gairy's return to power at the polls. 
 A heavily US-financed campaign did the trick and Blaize, with a 14-1 majority, took over and thanked God for sending the Americans to save Grenada. 
 Washington declined his invitation to keep its troops on the island and disappointed Blaize by failing to come up with promised investment to reduce huge unemployment. 
 Although the economy improved in recent years, Blaize was soon politically stranded. 
 His leading ministers walked out on him because of his heavy-handed behaviour. 
 He was also obsessed by an imagined threat from the few remaining ex-revolutionaries. 
 He banned books, seized passports, expelled foreigners, legalised detention without trial though he did not use it and dismissed international protests about torture of the still-gaoled leftist ex-leaders. 
 An enthusiastic member of the US-sponsored Caribbean Democratic Union of right-wing regional leaders, he did not hesitate to call in soldiers from neighbouring islands to guard against imagined plots. 
 At the end, between lengthy visits to Walter Reed Hospital in Washington and crippled with arthritis as a result of a youthful bicycle accident, he turned a deaf ear to opposition calls to resign after losing his majority. 
 &bquo;I'm staying,&equo; he told me when I visited him last July. 
 His wife Venetia had wheeled him, perspiring with illness, to his desk at Mount Royal, his official residence overlooking the capital. 
 &bquo;Water will find its level,&equo; he said softly of his divided opponents' noisy threats, never carried out, to vote him from office. 
 Greg Chamberlain Herbert Augustus Blaize, born February 26, 1918; died December 19, 1989. 
 Deaths: General Albert Wedemeyer who died on Sunday aged 92 was described by John Keegan as one of the most intellectual and farsighted military minds America produced. 
 The son of an army bandmaster, he was a brilliant student at the United States Military Academy and at staff college, studying Chinese during a posting to Tientsin and in 1936 attending the Kriegsakademie in Berlin. 
 His report on the German military brought him to the attention of General George Marshal, on whose staff he later served. 
 In 1943, he became deputy chief of staff to Lord Mountbatten in South East Asia and in the following year chief of staff to Chiang Kai-shek and commander of the American forces in China. 
 After the war he favoured stronger support for the South Koreans and a more interventionist policy with regard to China than President Truman would entertain, retiring in 1951 and going into business and right wing Republican politics. 
 Olive Booth, lieutenant Colonel in the Salvation Army and a grand-daughter of its founder, has died at the age of 98. 
 Before retiring in 1951, she had been director of the Army's European relief project, arranging the return to Germany of refugees from Russia and elsewhere after the huge migrations at the end of the war in Europe, and was later secretary of the war graves' department. 
 She was one of three long-lived sisters who rose to senior posts in the Army. 
 Her older sister Catherine died in 1986 at the age of 104 and Dora, her younger sister last February, aged 95. 
 Diary. 
 By Andrew Moncur 
 IT'S TIME to name some winners in the diary's annual Squishy Satsuma Awards for Christmas card initiative. 
 A commendation in the category for slightly bewildering greetings goes to Romola Christopherson, director of information at the Department of Health. 
 Her card features a caricature of her boss Kenneth Clarke, the ambulance crews' friend, looking like a cross between Tigger, a scalded cat standing on its tail and a whirling dervish. 
 This creature is set against a background recalling the Somme 1916 (shell craters, explosions, etc). 
 Question: does this suggest that (a) his nine lives are up; or (b) this is some sort of vision for the future of the health service? 
 A special mention for the Office of Population Censuses and Surveys, whose very exciting card shows a view of the Smedley Hydropathic Establishment, Southport, 1890. 
 The North West Thames health authority's greeting depicts a large apple core. 
 I won't pretend to understand this. 
 Congratulations to the Department of Social Security for its choice: Boticelli's Virgin And Child With Singing Angels (obviously scroungers). 
 A small prize to the Treasury which has, remarkably, picked a picture of a Liberal and &mdash; worse &mdash; one-time Chancellor of Oxford University, George Goschen (1831-1907). 
 The Luncheon Voucher trophy goes to Mrs Cynthia Payne for the card she has sent to, among others, Jean Rook, the First Lady of Fleet Street. 
 This shows a scene at one of her famous parties, with the greeting: &bquo;Hope you can come in more ways than one.&equo; 
 What can this mean? 
 DERANGED woman held in Downing Street. 
 Police swoop. 
 Read all about it. 
 There was a small disturbance early yesterday, it emerges, at the famous entrance which is soon to be closed by Mrs Thatcher's ornamental security gates. 
 A woman appeared, brandishing a knife and uttering threats against the person of Her Majesty the Queen. 
 She was clearly confused, not least about matters of geography &mdash; or something. 
 PLUCKY little Minister for Sport Colin Moynihan has wisdom teeth, shock. 
 Who would have thought it? 
 And who could have guessed that, with said gnashers playing him up, he would have to hand over one of his duties &mdash; and that a Labour MP would be called in from the subs' bench. 
 Step forward Tom Pendry, who chairs the Labour Party sports committee. 
 He was whisked in to open officially the new offices of the British Paralympic Association. 
 YOU MAY recall the departure of Andrew Ellis, known among jobbing politicians as a sort of one-man byelection-winning machine, from his top job with the Liberal Democrats (as they have since become). 
 His post as chief executive more or less folded up under him in a wholesale shake-up of staff. 
 Now he pops up at Rupert Murdoch's Sky TV, as a pundit. 
 Or, more precisely, as a consultant (election coverage a speciality). 
 NOW FOR some more winning entries in the Vicar's Competition: captions for the Nineties. 
 &bquo;A jubilant Mrs Thatcher (waving stick) outside No.10 prior to starting her sixth term.&equo; 
 (Tim Gunn); &bquo;British justice again proved best in world, claimed Ivor Stanbrook MP (right) seen here congratulating the Birmingham Six on their release after admission by Home Secretary of wrongful conviction 20 years ago.&equo; 
 (Geoff Neil); &bquo;In Oslo, workmen install Britain's annual gift to the city of a Christmas tree unaffected by acid rain.&equo; 
 (Ted Gunby). 
 WELL, IF you want to go on strike, the place to do it is obviously the London borough of Barnet. 
 Witness this letter sent by the Director of Educational Services to college lecturers who took action on October 17. 
 &bquo;You will probably have realised that, due to an administrative error in our payroll section, you have been given an extra day's pay&hellip; instead of having a day's pay deducted.&equo; 
 The bad news is that they're snatching it back. 
 DEFINITE sightings are now being recorded of Uncle Joe Stalin's 110th birthday party. 
 This event, billed to take place in London this week under the auspices of the Revolutionary Communist Party of Britain (Marxist-Leninist), was previously thought to be some sort of mirage. 
 Eye-witnesses insist that it did happen and, further, that 80-odd (or even very odd) people showed up. 
 So there. 
 LOST for gift ideas? 
 All the rage in California: a fax machine for your car. 
 A snip at &dollar;1,400. 
 Why Bush finally came to shove. 
 ON TUESDAY evening in the White House, while the camouflaged C-141s carried the paratroops of the 82nd Airborne through the Caribbean night towards Panama, President Bush held hands with his wife, smiled at his guests and sang Silent Night under the White House Christmas tree. 
 No scene could have been more peaceful. 
 But it was all a bluff. 
 This may be the season of goodwill, but the Imperial Presidency is back with a vengeance. 
 Nobody kicks sand into George Bush's face and gets away with it. 
 We can dust off the Rambo movies, and Mikhail Gorbachev can sit back amid the ruins of the Soviet empire and watch how a superpower really behaves. 
 It has seemed this month as if Ronald Reagan never left town, as President Bush decisively buried his lingering image as a White House wimp with a series of interventions that stamped his own authority on US foreign policy, and America's will upon the world. 
 This month of Super-Bush began with the decision to defeat the coup against President Cory Aquino of the Philippines. 
 That first presidential order to send American troops into possible combat was taken on the run, as Bush was preparing for his first superpower summit with Mikhail Gorbachev at Malta. 
 Bush was affable and even supportive of Gorbachev's reforms, keen to make the meeting a success. 
 But this readiness to intervene in the Philippines was a useful message to send to a Soviet leader still exploring the thinking and the reactions of the new US President. 
 Mr Bush's clear determination to continue with America's global role added force to his blunt rejection of Gorbachev's call for naval nuclear disarmament. 
 The message to Moscow was clear, that George Bush was no wimp. 
 It has now been conveyed to the rest of us, and we should not too quickly dismiss the thought that this message might resonate usefully in Nicaragua, in Iran and the Lebanon, and perhaps even in the two Germanys. 
 &bquo;The 1979 Canal Treaties were not in jeopardy, there was no sign of danger to the Canal, and the war declaration by Noriega was more rhetoric than reality,&equo; commented Mr Larry Birns, director of the respected regional think-tank, the Council for Hemispheric Affairs. 
 &bquo;The military action has more to do with White House fears of &bquo;wimpdom&equo; than any realistic threat to US national security.&equo; 
 In between came the almost arrogant announcement that President Bush had decided unilaterally to end the diplomatic isolation China had suffered since the massacre of Tiananmen Square. 
 His decision to send National Security Advisor Brent Scowcroft and Deputy Secretary of State Lawrence Eagleburger to Beijing not only flouted international opinion, it suggested a commitment to Realpolitik. 
 As a former director of the CIA, Bush was familiar with the secret world, and comfortable with its tradition of covert operations. 
 And as the first US Ambassador to the Communist regime in Beijing, he believed that secret emissaries to his old Chinese contacts was the way to launch his personal brand of presidential diplomacy. 
 &bquo;Operation Just Cause,&equo; yesterday's surprise invasion of Panama, will certainly wipe any lingering concern about the White House's Chinese Realpolitik from the front pages. 
 In his TV statement as dawn broke over Washington, the President maintained that the invasion had been prompted by the weekend of harassment of US soldiers in Panama City. 
 Doubtless that was the trigger, but an operation of 24,000 men is not thrown together in a few days. 
 &bquo;Just Cause&equo; was a carefully planned invasion just waiting to happen, poised at the starting gate for the kind of justification that the macho thug in Panama City was bound to provide sooner or later. 
 Bush had every reason to expect an easy victory, the ultimate Christmas gift to an adoring American public, who have granted him a record approval rating in the opinion polls. 
 The Panamanian Defence Forces are hardly a formidable foe. 
 They contain some 6,000 troops organised into three infantry battalions, and backed up by a small Air Force with a squadron of A-37 attack planes and six Huey helicopters. 
 Their officers still demoralised by the Noriega purges which followed the abortive coup in October, the PDF are massively outgunned by the US forces, although the armed militia of the &bquo;Dignity Battalions&equo; will help redress the balance. 
 But this kind of assertive coup de main carries a huge risk. 
 It has to work. 
 A sudden reminder to the world that while the Russian Bear may be slinking back into its cave, the American Eagle can still scream through the skies, is one thing. 
 A protracted guerrilla war in Panama, with back-street snipings on Christmas Eve and exploding Canal locks on Christmas Day, is something else altogether. 
 The Democratic Congressmen and Senators, who yesterday scurried to give bi-partisan support to what looked like a patriotic pre-Christmas success, may be forced to think again if this drags on into a stand-off with American hostages in Noriega's hands. 
 President Bush took a considerable gamble with this invasion, and it has not yet paid off. 
 The price in Panamanian civilian casualties has yet to be counted, and world opinion has yet to give its verdict. 
 As the Christmas Carol services recommend Peace on Earth to Washington's Merry Gentlemen, George Bush waits to learn whether Panama will be his Grenada, or his Iran. 
 As US troops occupy Panama, Richard Gott surveys the country's multi-layered society and the origins of the conflict, and below Martin Walker explains how the White House wimp became a warrior Still trapped in the jungle. 
 FOUR different countries are hidden away in the damp jungles of Panama. 
 The first is usually ignored and forgotten: it consists of farmers and peasants who live miles from anywhere in the largely inaccessible tangle of mountain and forest that make up much of the land area of the eastern end of the Central American isthmus. 
 I travelled there once with Omar Torrijos, friend of Fidel and Graham Greene, and charismatic leader of all the Panamanians &mdash; except for the rich and privileged class that used to live more in Miami than Panama. 
 We landed at overgrown grass airstrips (Torrijos at the controls) and were soon surrounded by ragged children and earnest villagers. 
 Torrijos loved these expeditions, and the peasants loved him. 
 Their huts were 12 hours' journey from the nearest main road, and the occasional and always unexpected arrival of the maximo lider was a cause for rejoicing and an indication that somebody, somewhere actually cared for them and took an interest in their otherwise isolated and neglected lives. 
 This particular pattern of political life is a familiar one in Latin America: the caudillo who rides in on horseback (nowadays a Cessna or a helicopter) and gives personal attention to the grievances of his supporters. 
 It is a technique used both on the Left and on the Right, by General Pinochet as well as by General Castro. 
 Torrijos played the role better than most. 
 It is a familiar theme in Latin American fiction, and something of the flavour of this part of Panama can be gleaned from Garcia Marquez's One Hundred Years Of Solitude, set in the forgotten swamps of Colombia (of which Panama once formed part). 
 The difficulty with this direct form of government is that it rarely survives the death of the caudillo. 
 When Torrijos's plane fell out of the sky one stormy day in 1981, his political project died with him. 
 His successor was General Manuel Noriega, his intelligence chief. 
 Noriega did his best to continue the 
 Torrijos tradition, and his political skills were considerable. 
 He was never a typical military dictator, nor was his Panama to be compared with Pinochet's Chile. 
 But he lacked the charisma and charm of Torrijos. 
 He had little vision of what Panama could become. 
 The peasants were abandoned, and even the urban poor (long a bastion of support for the regime) lost their early enthusiasm. 
 These are the inhabitants of the second country contained within Panama: the poor slum dwellers of Colon and Panama City, many of them black (and many still English-speaking), descendants of the Caribbean workers brought in to build the inter-oceanic means of communication, first the railway, then the canal. 
 The damp and leaky shacks they inhabit have not changed much since the famous sepia photographs that sometimes decorate contemporary colour magazines were taken nearly a hundred years ago. 
 The Americans think they constructed the canal &mdash; and the lasting folk memory of that achievement in the United States provides much of the emotional underpinning that sustains the American anti-Noriega hysteria &mdash; but it was actually built by black workers from the Caribbean. 
 SOME residual sense of pride from that era infuses the strong brew of nationalism that has characterised Panama's independent history, a nationalism more potent and anti-American than that of any other country in Latin America (except for Cuba and Nicaragua), and fuelled (like theirs) by years of military occupation. 
 There is rich irony in President Bush's complaint yesterday of sexual harassment against the wife of an American soldier. 
 For were not the brothels and whorehouses of Panama City and pre-revolutionary Havana developed for the most part for the benefit of American troops? 
 Other people's nationalism is never easy to fathom, but Panama's is more than usually overlaid with issues of race (white and black) and class (rich and poor). 
 In the poorer neighbourhoods, the atmosphere of suppressed rage is sometimes palpable. 
 The Americans used to be so arrogant that they refused even to allow the Panamanian flag to fly. 
 (The national currency today is still the US dollar.) 
 An event a quarter of a century ago sparked off the nationalist project that has now been brought so violently to an end. 
 Panamanian students were shot in January 1964 for daring to demonstrate in favour of their flag. 
 Torrijos seized power four years later, vowing to put an end to what was perceived as a long era of national humiliation. 
 The Canal Treaties he signed with Jimmy Carter were the fruit of his long labours. 
 The urban poor were the backbone of Torrijos's support, and they continued initially to cheer for Noriega. 
 But over the years enthusiasm gave way to mere tolerance. 
 People abandoned hope that things would get better, fearing simply that change at the top would mean change at the bottom &mdash; for the worse. 
 Earlier this year, in May, they voted for change, but when Noriega disavowed the election result the mass of the people shrugged their shoulders and went back to work. 
 When the Catholic archbishop came out against Noriega, and fatwahs against him were read out in church, the church services in the middle class suburbs turned into political demonstrations against the regime. 
 But when I toured the poorer areas of Panama City, the church congregations there were silent, sad and confused. 
 They were not prepared to demonstrate against Noriega, but neither would they come out in his support. 
 They had little interest in the apparent winners of the elections; and they seemed no longer to care much what would happen next. 
 It was clear then that Noriega only held on to power by two threads &mdash; popular apathy and the loyalty of the Panama Defence Force. 
 But the hostility of the United States, and its rather too blatant financial involvement in the election campaign, may well have prolonged his regime &mdash; wrapped in the armour of outraged nationalism. 
 The third country in Panama still belongs all too obviously to the United States. 
 It is not just the canal and its still extraordinary miracle of turn-of-the- century engineering. 
 Nor is it just the lawns and bungalows and supermarkets of what was once the Canal Zone that make up the fabric of a colonialism with which several European countries have been historically familiar. 
 Nor is it just the exported population of thousands of American suburbanites, the wives and families with their attendant schools and hospitals and tennis courts. 
 It is more the fact that this is still a vast military entrepot, an extension of America's armed might projected down towards South America. 
 Although the training grounds of US 
 Southern Command have been whittled down by the Carter- 
 Torrijos treaties, this part of Panama remains a formidable military affair. 
 Even the canal is owned by the Pentagon, still a state-run company in an era of privatisation. 
 Paradoxically, the Pentagon has never been as preoccupied as the State Department with the vagaries of General Noriega. 
 Better a tough general in charge, was their argument, to ensure the stability of the US-Panama relationship, than a weak civilian regime unable to control nationalist hotheads. 
 THERE is, finally, a fourth country in Panama. 
 Never quite perceived as such, it is one of the more important countries in the world. 
 It has a history that goes back to Morgan and Drake, a history of piracy and corruption that reaches down to the present day. 
 Much of the West's money is laundered through its huge concentration of banks; its registered shipping clogs the sea-lanes of half the globe; its duty-free stores (once the repository of Peruvian silver) now hold immense quantities of electronic goods from the East; and its beaches and airports bear daily witness to the transfer of cocaine from the impoverished producers of South America to the insatiable markets of the North. 
 Panama gets its cut. 
 It is a country largely hidden from view (apart from the skyscraper banks that clutter the skyline of Panama City). 
 It is a land almost entirely owned and run by foreigners, though there must be few of Panama's oligarchs &mdash; soldiers and landowners and bankers &mdash; who do not have an honorary passport or draw a regular remittance. 
 Until the last two years, when the United States imposed economic sanctions, this &bquo;Panama&equo; did pretty well in the Noriega era. 
 And Noriega did pretty well too. 
 These are the four countries that make up contemporary Panama. 
 They, and the delicate balancing relationship between them, will all have been dramatically upset by the decision of the American commander-in-chief, George Bush, to initiate military action yesterday to overthrow General Noriega. 
 In theory, it is a simple matter to overthrow a wilting strongman and replace him with a civilian president conveniently waiting in the wings. 
 But will the money launderers and the drug-runners suddenly find they have no friends? 
 Unlikely. 
 Will Panamanian nationalism, and the threat it poses to America's commercial and strategic interests, suddenly disappear? 
 Improbable. 
 Will the urban poor benefit from the change of regime? 
 Not a chance. 
 Will the forgotten peasants suddenly find that someone has remembered them? 
 Faint hope. 
 And there's the rub. 
 For when the military regime goes and the era of democracy dawns, the problems tackled by Torrijos (with some success) and by Noriega (with little or none) will still remain. 
 Military action may solve a little domestic difficulty in the United States, with sections of American opinion hyped up for the kill. 
 But for Panama &mdash; the many Panamas &mdash; it will only make life more difficult. 
 The face of nationalism&hellip; 
 Panamanians on the Canal Zone border celebrate the coming into effect of the Canal Treaties in 1979 by tearing up the American flag 
 Another day Our camps and theirs. 
 By Christopher Driver 
 CHRISTMAS Day in the Workhouse used to be an Edwardian party-piece. 
 Concentration camp Christmases are too painful for memories. 
 Christmas in the Scrubs ought to crop up in some colour magazine, Home Office permitting. 
 But there are two internment Christmases, half-forgotten episodes separated by 35 years in wars between the same countries, that deserve a retrospective. 
 Internment &mdash; as opposed to prisoners-of-war camps &mdash; has a unique sociological flavour. 
 There, two national cultures were on trial, both uncertain how to proceed in both situations. 
 One of the chief differences between 1914 and 1939 was the blue-sky outbreak of war in August 1914, and the gathering storm in 1938-39. 
 This too affected the social and political complexion of the internees, both British and German. 
 From November, 1914, Ruhleben (racecourse stables outside Berlin) housed for up to four years about 4000 Britons, who ranged from several honeymoon couples just arrived in Germany for their August holidays to dons and students on walking or reading parties, musicians and sportsmen snatched from festivals, and even a journalist with an ear supposedly close to the ground, Israel Cohen, a German correspondent for the London press who had cheerfully left on July 29 for his vacation near Dresden. 
 (He ended up writing one of the best books on Ruhleben.) 
 Some internees were resident German-speakers, British only by background; others were a large squad of Merchant Navy officers and seamen, British to their tough cores. 
 All were unheated, congested, and meagrely fed, and the miracle was that a disease-free, self-governing, microcosmic version of male England emerged and survived &mdash; not without tensions and tragedies and an element of anti-Semitism &mdash; till the end of the war. 
 For a German observer who had been interned in Britain 1914-18, &bquo;the great secret of masculine psychology is that all men of all ages act and behave like schoolboys as soon as their individualities are merged in a crowd.&equo; 
 Lower-deck language infiltrated the upper-lip middle classes at Ruhleben and a diarist had to remind himself, against his ultimate repatriation, &bquo;Don't stick your spoon in your button-hole and go to the kitchen with your plate at a restaurant with a lady&equo;. 
 Laughter helped. 
 In Cohen's Ruhleben description in March 1915: &bquo;It was an ideal morning for an official inspection from the Berlin Kommandatur. 
 The rain had fallen throughout the night, and the largest pond, as usual, had formed around the Stores. 
 A prisoner fixed a pole into the muddy soil, bearing the cardboard inscription: &bquo;Good Fishing Here.&equo; 
 The military visitors saw a prisoner in top boots, oilskin and sou'wester angling and pulling out a dripping clog. 
 One of them remarked: &bquo;Die Englander haben Humor.&equo; 
 As at Auschwitz, even, music flourished. 
 A young aspirant conductor, F.Charles Adler, and instrumentalists of the calibre of Carl Fuchs of the Manchester College of Music, rehearsed for Christmas Eve an orchestra of 25 and a chorus of 100 the Messiah (&bquo;realised&equo; by feverish copyists, unable to arrange the score for male voices. 
 As the camp magazine critic noted: &bquo;The effect of soprano and alto parts an octave lower than written by Handel was peculiar but&hellip; the aged Commandant, Graf Schwerin, thanked the men for the music with trembling voice and tears on his cheeks.&equo;) 
 A few months later, along with adult education, commerce, cobbling, tailoring and printing, arts both heavy and light were flourishing. 
 While Benjamin Dale, the composer, or Leigh Henry, the critic, lectured on Stravinsky and Schoenberg (in 1915!), two companies of music-hall artists competed with Legs and the Woman (the title after Shaw&hellip;) and with the camp's first ragtime chorus in drag: Down in Ruhleben, there I want to be, Four thousand boys would be enough for me! 
 For we're the girls, girls, girls, And we would charm you With our curls, curls, curls &mdash; We wouldn't harm you To quote Davidson Ketchum &mdash; who with the magazines &bquo;In Ruhleben Camp&equo; is the principal source of this account &mdash; &bquo;Few small towns since the Middle Ages can have had so productive a group of artists.&equo; 
 In both wars and both countries, internment was an abomination and an absurdity. 
 In Germany in 1939, a British Gentile, let alone a Jew, knew what to expect of the Nazi authorities and got out if they could. 
 In Britain, although no one except Beaverbrook Newspapers were under any illusions that war was imminent, there was still surprise among German and Italian nationals by then resident in Britain that Conservative ministers (led by Sir John Anderson, Home Secretary) interned all aliens without distinction of friend, refugee and enemy, shamelessly abetted by the press of the Fascist-sympathiser, Rothermere. 
 Hence the community of subsequently famous musicians (the Amadeus Quartet, Egon Wellesz, Peter Stadlen), architects (Bruno Ahrends, Schwitters), scholars (Richard Friedenthal, Stefan Zweig's literary executor), and above all, perhaps, Eugen Spier, who was one of the moving political and industrial spirits behind British anti-Nazism throughout the 1930s, and was imprisoned for two years in spite of very high level representations (another Official Secret never explained). 
 Refugees from Nazi persecution were interned with their former tormentors. 
 Even they could consider themselves lucky compared with the shackled Italians torpedoed on the Arandora Star on their way to Canada, or other internees beaten and robbed on their way to Australia by British officers and NCOs on the Dunera who gave a pretty good imitation of Hitler's Stormtroopers. 
 (Little of all this would have reached the public but for two courageous soldier-MPs, Col. Josiah Wedgwood and Maj. Victor Cazalet). 
 Perhaps the strangest &bquo;Christmas&equo; internee festival of either country or war took place fifty years ago today. 
 Like Ruhleben, one British internee camp was another racecourse, Lingfield. 
 It was Winter Solstice, 1939. 
 For the pagan celebration, &bquo;huge baulks of timber were piled high and set ablaze. 
 Putzi Hanfstaengel, Hitler's former friend who had fled his own country, presided and read passages of the nordic Edda. 
 Runes were cast, followed by chanting of the Horst Wessel. 
 British officers watched what Spier called &bquo;a mockery of christianity&equo;, while the rest of the internees looked on with disgust from the members' box on the grandstand.&equo; 
 Stille Nacht und Nebel? 
 J.Davidson Ketchum, Ruhleben (University of Toronto, 1965). 
 Ronald Stent, A Bespattered Page? &mdash; The Internment of &bquo;His Majesty's most Loyal Enemy Aliens&equo; (Andre Deutsch, 1980) 
 Microfile. 
 By Jack Schofield Computer editor 
 XEROX filed a &dollar;150 million lawsuit against Apple Computer in the US District Court, San Francisco, last Thursday. 
 The suit claims Apple pirated key elements of Xerox software for its Lisa and Macintosh user interfaces. 
 Xerox developed the first graphical user interface for its Star computer in the seventies. 
 Apple staff saw it when visiting Xerox Parc and at a trade show in 1981. 
 Apple also hired several Xerox employees, including Star software developers. 
 Xerox further claims that Apple copied substantial portions of its Lisa and Macintosh Finder programs, including the design and appearance of the main application windows, dialogue boxes and menu, and some of the icons used. 
 Apple spokesmen commented that Xerox's software concepts were not protected by copyright any more than depictions of birds and trees are protected by the copyright on a painting. 
 &bquo;The complaint confuses the difference between ideas and expression; the copyright protects expresssion, not ideas.&equo; 
 Whatever the rights and wrongs of the case, some software developers regard the suit with glee. 
 Apple has made itself unpopular by suing Digital Research, MicroSoft and Hewlett-Packard to protect the &bquo;look and feel&equo; of the Apple Macintosh graphical user interface. 
 Now it's the biter bit. 
 Dead Zebra. 
 ZEBRA Parallel, a start-up company based on Alvey research at the Polytechnic of Central London, is to be closed down with the loss of eight jobs. 
 The firm had developed novel parallel processing software which worked like a &bquo;worm&equo;, spawning segments which moved from processor to processor. 
 It received backing from venture capital firm 3i. 
 Zebra lost around &pound;240,000 in its year of existence. 
 It did not make any sales. 
 Live Owl. 
 MATSUSHITA has taken over Office Workstations Ltd, OWL, a &pound;2 million British software house and a world leader in hypertext systems. 
 OWL, which has 89 staff, has developed Guide hypertext software, based on work done by Professor Peter Brown at the University of Kent. 
 Matsushita is one of the world's major manufacturers, well known for its Panasonic, Technics and National brand names. 
 Konosuke Matsushita, who founded the company in his front room with 100 yen capital in 1917, died earlier this year leaving a record 245 billion yen (over &dollar;1 billion). 
 Dial Plus. 
 FROM January 31, British Telecom will offer PSS Dialplus, a much-improved version of its dial-up packet switched data communications service. 
 Dialplus doubles the sqeed of communications to 2400 bits per second and introduces V42 standard error correction (MNP Class 2 and LAP-M). 
 In fact the Microcom Networking Protocol is supported up to MNP Class 5, which provides data compression to double the throughput of data. 
 With Dialplus, users need call only one PSS number, instead of there being a separate number for each modem speed. 
 Also, subscribers can use any Dialplus node instead of having to register their password on each one separately. 
 And whereas ordinary PSS is famous for being user-hostile, Dialplus has a menu-driven front end which is far easier to use. 
 Best of all, Dialplus usage is charged on time only, not the volume of data transmitted. 
 This offers high-speed modem users the chance to cut costs. 
 Cheap modems. 
 WITH the arrival of 2400 bps access to services such as Telecom Gold electronic mail and data services, there should be a large market for cheap high-speed modems. 
 Many firms are interested. 
 3Net has launched the Net 45 Smart Quad at &pound;350 plus VAT. 
 It has speeds up to V22bis (2400bps) and MNP Classes 4 and 5 (tel.: 0256 840429). 
 Hi-Tec has just received BABT approval for its EC-2400 modem quad modem, which also offers V22bis and MNP up to Class 5. 
 The price has been cut from &pound;699 to &pound;399 plus VAT. 
 (Tel.: 0733 897333) Frontier Software is also close to shipping a full V42 quad speed modem with MNP up to Class 5. 
 The Supra 2400 Plus will be a development of the established Supra 2400, and the target price is &pound;230 plus VAT. 
 (Tel.: 0423 67140) Today the &pound;299 Amstrad SM2400 seems to dominate the low end V22bis market. 
 This lacks both error correction and data compression &mdash; though PC users can use Micropack Ltd's Odyssey (&pound;70 plus VAT) to provide MNP Classes 4 and 5 in software (tel.: 0224 631100). 
 Keyline. 
 KEYLINE, the forthcoming home shopping service based on a new portable terminal (Computer, July 7, 1988 and September 7, 1989) has finally announced the names of some of the firms who will use it. 
 These include Freemans, Kays, Littlewoods, Gateway Foodmarkets, W H Smith, Philips, Thorn EMI, Commercial Union, General Accident, Sun Alliance, the Bank of Scotland, the Nat-West, Ladbrokes, Coral and British Telecom Directory Enquiries. 
 Le mail. 
 BEFORE language students at Exeter University send letters to their European pen-pals by electronic mail, they can get help with their grammatical errors from an expert system. 
 The human pen-pal can then correct any semantic errors. 
 The Pen-Pal project is part of a teaching experiment in which the School of Modern Languages and the Department of Computer Science are taking part. 
 It is also a feasibility study of Le-Mail, a multilingual comms network, and has won financial backing from both the Societa Italiana per l'Esercizino della Telecomunicazioni and the Deutsches Bundespost. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE mc1 
 Is organic sheep farming a natural career move for an ageing Playmate? 
 For Arabella Melville &mdash; BSc, PhD and sexual libertarian &mdash; it is A wolf in sheep's clothing. 
 By Carmel Fitzsimons THE cut-price wellingtons (blue, &pound;4.99, Harrow Road) were at my feet. 
 The sun was shining over the Gower Peninsula and the train was sending me all how-green-was-my-valley. 
 Idly I turned to a 1975 profile of Dr Arabella Melville. 
 The description by Jill Tweedie of the organic sheep farmer I was travelling to meet bounced from the page: &bquo;This once respectable female stripped off and began sitting around in front of cameras with her legs apart and her hands in unmentionable places.&equo; 
 What? 
 &bquo;Dr Arabella, 26 year old, BSc, PhD, and fallen woman. 
 Unclothed, clothed, gartered, suspendered, unknickered, arranging her front and hind quarters in revealing positions. 
 &bquo;She also dashes about London trying to redress the sexual balance by finding out where a woman goes for paid sex, trying it and telling you how it was and how much.&equo; 
 Trying it. 
 Telling you how it was. 
 Paying. 
 I've spared you the bit about sleeping with a famous broadcaster and writing in her magazine, The Libertine, that he was as &bquo;good&equo; as he boasted. 
 Honestly, it's not prudery. 
 It's just that there are some things the mind-set is not adjusted to and I was tuned in for bracing winds, long place names and snatches of Tom Jones. 
 I expected ecological debate, the odd clash over vegetarianism and a hint of hippiness. 
 Sex, I was not expecting. 
 At Carmarthen I and my now derisory wellingtons were feeling flustered. 
 Dr Arabella had written to the Guardian from her innocent sounding Old Vicarage Farm, in Cenarth, Dyfed, about the agonies suffered by sheep under normal farming methods. 
 &bquo;As one of a growing band of organic sheep farmers, I know that sheep can be reared without cruelty. 
 My flock is extremely healthy, charming and friendly.&equo; 
 We'd all loved the charming flock. 
 Porcelain shepherdess and fleeces white as snow. 
 But when her letter said how tasty these little organic chaps can be when placed close to carrots, peas and gravy, I should have seen that she was open to contradictions. 
 Arabella Melville was waiting at Carmarthen station in a tartan dress. 
 Not a hippy. 
 And not an ageing Playmate. 
 She seemed a very candid person. 
 &bquo;Isn't it a lovely article? 
 It was 1975 and I was being charged under the Obscene Publications Act and it was like the Oz trial, so I was interviewed. 
 I only did the nude modelling because my sister did it. 
 It didn't grow into The Libertine magazine and become an anti-censorship campaign until after I met Colin.&equo; 
 Colin Johnson is driving the van and has been Bella's lover for 15 years. 
 He is one of the world's stirrers and shakers, and even more than Bella he seems to wolf life down in big mouthfuls. 
 &bquo;We don't mind what the locals know about our &bquo;I thought it was fun. 
 I was over-qualified and signing on and I realised there was more money to be made taking my clothes off&equo;. 
 past. 
 This is a country stuffed full of homes out of the Daily Mail Book of Bungalows. 
 Let's face it, Wales is a huge monoculture, all inward looking and local. 
 They always feel beleaguered. 
 It's inevitable that they don't accept us.&equo; 
 He cheerily negotiates a hairpin country road. 
 It's still pretty difficult to understand why someone with lots of other opportunities (that BSc in psychology, the PhD in psychopharmacy and the lectures given at Iowa and McGill University) should be a porno model. 
 Melville is fearless: &bquo;I thought it was fun. 
 I was over-qualified and signing on and I realised there was more money to be made taking my clothes off. 
 It didn't hurt me.&equo; 
 &bquo;We were anti wank magazines, too,&equo; says Johnson robustly. 
 &bquo;That's why we started The Libertine. 
 We wanted to break the dreadful sex magazine mafia, allow people to buy what they wanted and maybe get them to understand the plumbing of sex. 
 That it can be great fun.&equo; 
 Johnson is 50, Melville is 41 and sometimes as you hear this playground talk about sex you hear echoes of a world ignorant of Aids. 
 Sex-plumbing and sex-fun seems far, far removed from the complex business we now all say it is. 
 Melville explains, &bquo;The downside got overlooked because of the crusading side, but eventually I got the sex mag blues. 
 It made me anxious, focusing on my physical self, keeping a certain shape.&equo; 
 But you did sleep with people just to report back on it. 
 As did Johnson? 
 &bquo;We were very open. 
 I've never had difficulties about Colin sleeping with other people. 
 I'm just as likely to start feeling insecure about someone in his past as someone now.&equo; 
 We are in the Old Vicarage Farm now, which Johnson describes as a pretentious heap of shit built to impress the local peasants. 
 It is large and grey and chilly but surrounded by beautiful land. 
 They have a mobile cordless phone and post-it yellow reminder stickers above the old hearth saying No Smoking. 
 The place is full of the aroma of Spot-Knee, the ram lamb who recently copped it after a blissful organic life. 
 On the wall is the Soil Association certificate showing that no nasty pesticides have been used on the farm for two years. 
 You can't be Green without one. 
 Talking about the old days is fun. 
 They laugh about the time when Colin was making love with a girlfriend and Bella, in the room next door, heard her moan that her feet were cold. 
 So she ran in and whipped a pair of socks on to the girl's feet. 
 I am beginning to wonder if I inhabit the same planet. 
 Johnson and Melville are used to this. 
 My children, Johnson says, are in their twenties and they can't handle all this swinging talk. 
 It's a question of morphology, he says, cultural movements. 
 You can predict that the romantic will be followed by the realistic. 
 Punks hate hippies. 
 The Yuppies presage the New Age. 
 The Green movement is partly due to the flower people reaching a crest of economic power. 
 So how did sex magazine entrepreneurs become organic sheep farmers of the late Eighties? 
 They tell it in a way that makes it make sense. 
 They won their obscenity trial but poverty drove them to a caravan beside a Methodist chapel where they lived off skips, meeting other swinging exiles and learning how much people waste. 
 By chance, and on the basis of her scientific qualifications, Melville got a job at Swansea University researching doctors' prescribing habits. 
 With Johnson, &bquo;a denim capitalist&equo;, she wrote Cured To Death about the chronic effects of prescription drugs. 
 She realised people needed drugs because they were sick from stress and poor food. 
 &bquo;The book made us think about the nature of health. 
 We could see that the health of the person is directly tied in with the health of the planet.&equo; 
 With the profits from their books they made enough finally to buy Old Vicarage Farm, with four others, as an organic co-operative, in 1987. 
 But now the duo are selling up. 
 &bquo;It's not been a failure of the organic principle, it's been a failure of people,&equo; says Melville unhappily. 
 Johnson is about to explain with lots of big words but it's agreed he should shut up. 
 Melville continues: &bquo;The young people had no idea of how hard it would be. 
 We became like their parents. 
 It was weird. 
 From the first day they completely opted out, wandering around saying how beautiful it was while we dug the vegetable garden. 
 &bquo;I fell in love with this place the first time I saw it. 
 Colin loved the land but he wouldn't even get out of the van to look at the house.&equo; 
 Johnson says, &bquo;It's too big. 
 It was the wrong people. 
 We brought tools, they brought gonks.&equo; 
 The evening is drawing in early but it's sad how the shadows lenghthen around Melville's words. 
 &bquo;I tried to hang on. 
 But it's emotionally draining living here with someone who does not want to be here.&equo; 
 The young people have left. 
 Says Melville, &bquo;We learned that it's very difficult to live and work together.&equo; 
 Johnson adds that the definition excludes them because they are in love. 
 Melville says she would prefer it if he said that they loved each other, and that subtle point is not lost on anyone. 
 It's not the sex mag blues nor the poverty in the caravan nor the midnight tending of newborn lambs that saps us. 
 It's someone stealing your dream away. 
 We visit the charming sheep and I get a chance to wear my wellingtons after all. 
 In their generosity, or relief of getting out of the kitchen, they ply me with bag loads of organic vegetables. 
 They say I must come and see them on their new organic farm &mdash; more land, less house, says Johnson. 
 And, like the movers and bustlers they are, when we miss the train at Carmarthen because we are talking too much, they summon a cab to race the train to Swansea. 
 Propelled by their energy I arrive, naturally, 20 minutes ahead of the commuters. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE wom 
 Search for a safe passage. 
 OVER the last 10 days, tens of thousands of PC users have received a floppy disc from the PC Cyborg Corporation offering information about Aids &mdash; but, like the Trojan horse, it is more than it seems. 
 Its other function is to take over your hard disc and encrypt all the file directories, rendering the disc unusable. 
 If you have received such a disc, don't run it. 
 If you have already run it, then you need a copy of a program called Clearaid. 
 Exe, written by Jim Bates. 
 Essentially the &bquo;Trojan&equo; demands money with menaces &mdash; exactly as predicted on this page by Rupert Goodwins many months ago (Computer April 7, 1988). 
 Virus-expert Alan Solomon of the IBM PC User Group explains how it does it. 
 If you run the Install program, it creates two subdirectories with &bquo;impossible&equo; names. 
 One of these consists of one invisible character, &lsqb;Alt-255&rsqb;. 
 It then copies your Autoexec.Bat to a file called Auto.Bat and creates a new Autoexec.Bat file which is both hidden and read-only. 
 This runs the other hidden file whenever you start up your PC. 
 After the computer has been started up a number of times &mdash; possibly 90 &mdash; the damage starts. 
 The program tells you to turn off your PC, and it encrypts your directory, hiding all the files on your hard disc except one, called Cyborg.Doc. 
 If you start the PC from the hard disc, it tells you your software licence has expired and demands money (&dollar;378) to renew it. 
 This must be sent to a PO Box in Panama City. 
 Before that stage, the program may also have provided instructions to encourage you to copy files on to a blank disc in drive A:, to &bquo;please insert this in another machine&equo; and type A:Share. 
 (Obviously you shouldn't do this!) 
 Experienced PC users can deal with the Trojan by using software tools to make the new Autoexec.Bat file visible and read/write, before deleting and replacing it with a correct version. 
 However, it is not certain that this completely solves the problem. 
 Users should also start their machines from a virus-free floppy disc and do a file copy to back up all their files onto clean discs. 
 (Do two copies!) 
 Protected applications software should be de-installed. 
 The hard disc can then be formatted before all the files are restored. 
 Jim Bates has written two programs to deal with the Trojan. 
 The first, Aidsout.Com, can be used before the damage routine has been triggered. 
 The latest version, Clearaid.Exe, works both before and after. 
 Bates's efforts have been sponsored by Personal Computer Business World magazine, which innocently provided the mailing list used to distribute 7,000 Trojans to readers with PC/XT computers. 
 Editor Mike Magee is keen to supply afflicted users with copies of Clearaid. 
 It can also be downloaded from Power Tower, Jim Bates's bulletin board, and may be available from other magazines such as PC Magazine. 
 Although the Trojan has been described, sensationally, as &bquo;the biggest computer crime in the world,&equo; what law does it break? 
 A disc has been sent out with a software licence asking for &dollar;189: don't users install this at their own risk? 
 Some commerical software suppliers take pains to protect their programs, and the Trojan could be considered as such, albeit in a dangerously extreme form. 
 But those who wish to make a formal complaint can contact Detective Sergeant Donovan of the computer crime unit, tel.: 01-725 2434. 
 There's also Data Integrity's Systems Perils Policy, available from any Lloyds broker, for bolting the stable door after the horse has bolted. 
 Further information: Alan Jay, IBM PC User Group, 01-863 1191. 
 Clearaid: Personal Computer Business World, 01-831 9252. 
 PC Magazine, 01-661 3662. 
 Power Tower bulletin board, 0533 880114 (8 data bits, one stop bit, no parity, baud rate self sensing). 
 Data Integrity Ltd: Graham Hore, 01-636 1971. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE mc1 
 Out for the count. 
 By Walter Gratzer Innumeracy, by John Allen Paulos (Viking, &pound;12.95) Ideas and Information: Managing in a High-Tech World, by Arno Penzias (W.W. Norton, &pound;12.95) 
 THERE is, as James Thurber sagely noted, no safety in numbers or in anything else. 
 Consider for example the proposition that the average human possesses one breast and one testicle, a grievous misapplication of statistics no doubt, but less of an affront to logic than the argument of the weather forecaster, seized on by John Allen Paulos: with a 50 per cent chance of rain on Saturday and a 50 per cent chance on Sunday, he declared, &bquo;it looks like a 100 per cent chance of rain this weekend&equo;. 
 No wonder, Paulos argues, that in a society in which such lapses are common, and indeed go unremarked, the citizenry should be prey to every form of delusion and chicanery, political or mercenary. 
 Paulos is a professor of mathematics; his book, he owns, was born of indignation and he writes with passion, tempered however by good humour. 
 It is, I suspect, a sad inevitability that he will be read mainly by those least in need of the lessons he teaches. 
 Certainly their substance should be accessible to anyone not so far gone in the contemplation of astrology &mdash; a science, so it is widely held, on the cogent grounds that its practitioners use computers &mdash; homeopathy, aromatherapy, or telekinesis as to be beyond the reach of reason. 
 Paulos is admirable on the nature of coincidence &mdash; the inevitability of improbable events &mdash; on the logic of gambling in its various forms from coin-tossing to the Stock Exchange; the Gambler's Fallacy (the belief that when a coin has landed heads several times over, there is an increased probability that tails will turn up on the next throw); Pascal's wager; Condorcet's paradox; the prisoner's dilemma. 
 They are all here. 
 I wish I could remember the name of the functionary who pronounced on the news that a union vote had gone 70/30, at least three to one in favour: I would gladly lend him my copy. 
 It is a sound maxim that you do not ask the barber whether you need a haircut, and if Prof Paulos is not a wholly disinterested party in matters of numeracy, you will certainly not expect Arno Penzias, a distinguished physicist and vice-president for research at the Bell Telephone Laboratories of AT&amp;T, to be less than sanguine about the remorseless advance of information technology. 
 Ideas and Information is a guide for the perplexed. 
 The subtitle contains, as I take it, a deliberate ambiguity, for most of the book is concerned with managing in the sense of coping, but in the last chapter Penzias dilates on how technologically based organisations should be run. 
 He has no time for inefficiency, and he reserves a particular scorn for the manner in which the medical profession organises itself. 
 Penzias conveys a vivid sense of the pace of technological evolution in our time. 
 He recalls his days as a graduate student when the famous IBM 650 was the last word in computing wizardry. 
 It occupied an entire building and was similar in capacity to the programmable pocket calculator that one now buys at the stationers. 
 Printed circuits containing 10 million transistors are already available and will fit on a penny coin. 
 Penzias foresees that the number will have risen to a billion by the end of the century, with an untold gain in computing power. 
 Compact-disc technology for encoding sound and other information has gained ground rapidly and, Penzias believes, optical fibres will soon supplant communications satellites. 
 Open access to all this vast capacity for generation of information creates its own demands: in the US alone 18 million filing cabinets are manufactured each year to hold the paper output. 
 Perhaps the most alluring prospects lie in artificial intelligence and computers that learn. 
 Research in neutral networks has become a growth industry. 
 Penzias does not, though, embrace the philosophical heresy that computers can be said to reason, even if public credulity, reinforced by science fiction, often imputes sentient powers to them. 
 Psychotherapy by a programme (Eliza) consisting of a small repertoire of reassuring questions and answers, was pronounced a success by the patients on the couch. 
 Such applications were prefigured by Michael Frayn some 20 years ago in his novel The Tin Men which features a computer programmed to pray, so that its orisons might bring down divine favour in accordance with Christian teaching: the computer having no selfish motives, its disinterested sincerity cannot be doubted. 
 &bquo;Benefit&equo; is a word on which the reader may frequently stub his toe in Penzias's pages. 
 The optimism is unremitting. 
 For a gentle corrective one could do worse than go back to H.L. Mencken who opined that Alexander Graham Bell &mdash; the progenitor of the institution in which Penzias holds sway &mdash; and Thomas Alva Edison had done more than any of their contemporaries to add to the sum of life's damned nuisances. 
 And yet Penzias makes a good case for the new golden age, and his urbane discourse is both enlivening and instructive. 
 His book undoubtedly fills a need; it may, besides, make you wonder whether we have most of us come all that far since the days of Babbage, the true father of the computer, who recorded in his memoirs that he often used to be asked by the mandarins of the English establishment, when they came to view his difference engine: &bquo;Pray, Mr Babbage, if you put into the machine wrong figures, will the right answers come out?&equo; 
 Babbage adds: &bquo;I am not able rightly to apprehend the kind of confusion of ideas that could provoke such a question.&equo; 
 Today the answer could be encapsulated in one word, the programmer's acronym, gigo: or garbage in, garbage out. 
 But, oh, how the garbage is sanitised and transmuted by the alchemy of the machine! 
 You can tell from the way it gets lapped up. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 A 50-year odyssey through the dark. 
 By George Campbell Edna Manley: The Diaries, edited by Rachel Manley (Andre Deutsch, &pound;14.95) 
 WHEN the artist Edna Manley died in 1987, she left her stamp on history as an inspired visionary, creative seeker, and chronicler. 
 With her passing, the nation of Jamaica appeared stunned. 
 She was unique. 
 She was the widow of Norman Manley, first Premier of Jamaica and the mother also of a then twice elected Prime Minister, Michael Manley. 
 There were also many other significant aspects of a remarkable life. 
 Edna Manley was born in Cornwall, England, on Leap Year's day, 1900; the fifth of nine children of an English Methodist Missionary and his Jamaican wife. 
 While studying at St Martin's School of Art, she married her first cousin, Norman Manley, a decorated first world war veteran and Rhodes scholar at Oxford. 
 After his graduation as a barrister, they returned to his Jamaican homeland. 
 And thus this odyssey began, encompassing almost 50 years in the strange new culture of her adopted country. 
 It was a land with no nascent art, save the reflected mirror of its colonial masters. 
 There she faced the challenge of developing a new form based on the realities around her and through her caring spirit and love in serving others, encouraged around her a vibrant movement, ensuring her the title of Mother of Jamaican Art. 
 She edited the first authentic magazine, Focus, whose contributors were accorded free access for their vibrant breakaway from Victorian (Wordsworthian) poetry. 
 Many of these artists and writers have become internationally known. 
 These diaries do not always follow conventional order, in that chronology is often ignored; but then she elaborates later on questions of importance. 
 A thematic key to the diaries was a haunting experience she had as a child in Cornwall. 
 As she expressed it: &bquo;I see two paths inextricably bound to each other, and yet in some curious way almost irrelevant to one another&hellip; 
 &bquo;These two paths travel through country. 
 One country is full of people, people seen objectively and people seen subjectively, people in relation to myself, where the image is vivid, where the music is loud, sometimes overwhelmingly loud, and where the vision is nearly always distorted like a face in the back of a spoon&hellip; 
 Those are people who have made you, carved you, produced you. 
 &bquo;But the other path passes through country that is without sound or sight or contact. 
 It is a world of twilight and in it something grows&hellip; that creature which is the inner you&hellip; 
 &bquo;One is a world of natural phenomena, or light and rain and people passing down the roads, or things happening, or excitement and peace and of music ending. 
 The other is nothing, yet everything. 
 Nothing happens, nothing comes, only a growing in the dark, a state of being.&equo; 
 These diaries &mdash; edited by her granddaughter, Rachel &mdash; reveal a remarkable literary talent. 
 In these pages she produces an almost rounded figure of her famous husband Norman, who abandoned a successful law practice to lead the masses. 
 She recalls him once campaigning in mountainous terrain: &bquo;When&hellip; 
 Norman was called upon, he was standing on the rock just behind Issaacs, swaying on his hips in that way he has, with his face turned up to the night. 
 Lit faintly by the moonlight and with the mighty peaks behind him, he looked a quiet, impressive figure. 
 &bquo;When he stepped up, the storm lantern threw its uneven yellow light up under this face, making the hollows in his cheeks look carved and his eyes enormous.&equo; 
 At times she is whimsical as on a visit by Princess Margaret to Jamaica in 1955: &bquo;May I go on record once and for all &mdash; I hate to bend the knee, except to God, and even then not too often.&equo; 
 On talking with her son Michael &mdash; &bquo;Talking with Michael is like going down a water chute and finding yourself in the same swimming pool, very much at the deep end.&equo; 
 She writes about her country home: &bquo;The old toad is rolling his drum down at the foot of the hill, and the crunch, crunch of the cows is near to my window over the barbecue. 
 The dark and the light have lain down in each other's arms to sleep in a bed of silver moonlight and a little shifting wind brings the scents from the nearby woodland on the other hill.&equo; 
 She took her art seriously and in the agony of creative inspiration often turned to poetry and music for assurance. 
 As in the entry: &bquo;Tonight, this night of March 25, with the Andante of Schubert's A Major Sonata stealing out into the night, I swear all I have of passion, all I have of love, I will pour into a message of faith as I carve.&equo; 
 And, at the advent of carving a crucifix for a church, she records: &bquo;I started work at around 9 am. 
 I knelt and prayed, not only for guidance and inspiration in the carving, but that a new era of peace and honesty should invade my life whilst I worked&hellip;&equo; 
 A later entry reveals an undesirable recognition of her own skill as a wood carver: &bquo;I know I am a minor artist, but no one, but on one is a better woodcarver. 
 No one can bully, cajole, coax, batter, trick or beguile wood like I can!&equo; 
 Plagued with illness after working with glass fibre, she gave up carving to work with other media for casting into bronze. 
 Finally, she turned to painting very successfully. 
 She died with an unfinished &bquo;Lazarus&equo; on canvas. 
 George Campbell's book of poetry Earth Testament was illustrated by Edna Manley. 
 His First Poems has been reprinted by Yale University, New York. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 To the green and pleasant?. 
 Tim Radford reports on the prospects and options for farmers in the next year.. 
 THE British farmer is about to wander into fresh woods and pastures new. 
 In the course of doing so he could change the face of Britain. 
 He could grow &bquo;biomass&equo; for biotechnology. 
 He could &mdash; in theory &mdash; farm for the pharmaceutical companies. 
 He could diversify into new crops like meadowfoam, lupins, borage, linseed and flax. 
 In some areas he could plant his land with windmills. 
 If the climate changes a bit more, he could grow sweet corn in the south and wheat in the north. 
 He could farm alpaca, deer and wild boar. 
 He could take up organic farming and selling nurture as nature intended to a consumer market now seriously worried about E numbers and Alar. 
 He could take up agroforestry; he could convert to timber; he could take up government agency schemes and grow winter grass mixtures for wild geese to graze upon, or engineer his fields to be a home for the stone curlew. 
 He could grow hedges and wildflowers instead of sugar beet; he could turn his fields into areas of &bquo;quiet countryside enjoyment&equo;; he could restore ancient coppices and chalk grassland. 
 He could also go broke &mdash; last year, farm incomes fell by 25 per cent. 
 His land could tumble down to scrub and nettles and eventually untidy woodland. 
 Or he could sell most of his land to Mr Big and his house and a few acres could fall into the hands of a merchant banker who wants somewhere quiet with a paddock for the daughter's ponies. 
 Then Mr Big could try diversifying. 
 But he too would run into the same problems. 
 Britain is over-producing: there will have to be some way of reducing output. 
 There is a Ministry proposal called &bquo;extensification.&equo; 
 It means that the whole farm has to produce 20 per cent less. 
 One scheme is already in place. 
 It is called &bquo;set aside.&equo; 
 A proportion of the farm &mdash; or for that matter all of it &mdash; is set aside, left fallow, mown once a year while the farmer draws a set fee per acre and manages on the rest or gets another job. 
 Either way, the countryside changes. 
 There are various calculations about how much land is potentially redundant: it could be as many as three million acres. 
 For the first time in decades, the nation has a chance to decide what to do with it. 
 Conservationists, farmers and government agencies all agree that there is an opportunity right now for debate and then decision. 
 But there is no debate, and any decisions are likely to be taken, piecemeal and by default. 
 On the horizon is a field of view overgrown with nettles, which no one seems to want to grasp. 
 One of them is the geography of decline. 
 Miss Melinda Appleby is environmental policy adviser to the National Farmers' Union. 
 She says one fear is that land in the hills will become redundant. 
 &bquo;These are areas where you could say farming was marginal. 
 As profitablilty declines, they would go out of farming. 
 There is a big fear in the hills that in order to maintain businesses in the lowlands, people will diversify into sheep, and the profitability of sheep in the lowlands will be greater.&equo; 
 In fact, the Countryside Commission has just announced an imaginative scheme for 12 &bquo;community forests&equo; on marginal urban fringe farmland. 
 But the community forests &mdash; plus the Commission's other plan for 100,000 acres of new forest in the Midlands, which will also soak up redundant land &mdash; together with new land released for development, will barely scratch the surface of the problem. 
 The National Farmers' Union doesn't like the idea of set aside. 
 In the first place, the scheme only operates for five years, with no guarantee of continuation. 
 There are also emotional objections. 
 &bquo;We wish to see as many farmers as possible occupying the countryside,&equo; said Melinda Appleby. 
 &bquo;We want to see a working countryside and we don't want to see it fossilised so it's almost like a theme park.&equo; 
 Farmers have higher hopes of the &bquo;extensification&equo; programme in the wings. 
 Under this, farms would have to reduce output by 20 per cent. 
 Some farmers are likely to achieve this by converting to organic farming. 
 To a farmer it's anathema not to produce on land. 
 Unfortunately, even this won't be enough: the output figures from well-run organic farms are only between 6 and 12 per cent below those from intensive estates. 
 So &bquo;extended&equo; farms will have to leave a wide strip of unsown soil in each field, and let the hedges grow. 
 But only a few will make the change. 
 Most will still be farming what they always farmed. 
 And they still won't feel enthusiastic about extensification. 
 &bquo;To a farmer it's an anathema not to produce on his land and therefore it's not that he is not being responsible in meeting the challenges.&equo; 
 Many farmers, it turns out, wouldn't in the least object to making the countryside &mdash; their countryside &mdash; more attractive. 
 It depends on what is defined as attractive. 
 It would also depend on incentives and on some serious stimulus from the conservation lobby. 
 &bquo;People were extremely disappointed that conservationists could not come up with exciting positive solutions for potential land that might come out of agriculture,&equo; says Miss Appleby. 
 Another problem is that the wildlife lobby is divided even over simple things like the future of old farm woodlands. 
 Most of these were &bquo;coppiced&equo; &mdash; cut to the ground every 20 years or so and then allowed to regenerate. 
 Should these go back to coppice? 
 Or be allowed to go on growing? 
 She goes on: &bquo;The problem with taking a management decision out of a farmer's hands as an economic decision and putting it into conservationists hands is that the conservationists don't always agree. 
 &bquo;In the future, it seems, we are going to be taking arbitrary decisions about what we want from the countryside: the large blue here, a certain bird there, and we are going to manage for those species, which will mean that everything else will go.&equo; 
 The countryside may be changing. 
 It will go on changing. 
 The Agriculture and Food Research Council reckon cereal yields could be increased by another 25 per cent this century, freeing even more land. 
 In a bid to meet the problem halfway, the AFRC has also invested &pound;730,000 in a five-year study of the relationship between wildlife and farming &mdash; and what will happen as land use goes on changing. 
 The point is, that for the first time in decades, the environmentalists have a powerful voice &mdash; and a Government which claims to listen. 
 Three million acres or more of Britain's countryside can't be left to tumble down to nettles, bracken, Oxford ragwort and rosebay willow herb, punctuated by leisure centres and car parks. 
 Or if it can &mdash; there is a case for that too &mdash; it might as well be thought about first. 
 Both the farmers and the conservationists agree that there ought to be a debate. 
 They also agree that a debate doesn't seem to be taking place. 
 There is a nettle for a somebody &mdash; it might as well be the new Environment Secretary &mdash; to grasp. 
 Stephen Young on the animals that excel in fuel economy Camels do it better. 
 THREE wise men can't be wrong. 
 The camel is without doubt one of the natural world's most remarkable forms of transport. 
 Consider the specification of the average dromedary: a top speed of 650 kilometres in four days under Saharan conditions, a regular luggage capacity of 200 kilograms and a maximum recorded burden of 865 kilograms. 
 Also fitted as standard: a handy fuel store in the hump and an attitude to water conservation which, if widely adopted, would halve the price of water shares overnight. 
 Underpinning all these accomplishments is the camel's efficient use of metabolic fuel &mdash; a skill put to good use by Mohammed's camel, which allegedly covered the distance between Mecca and Jerusalem in four bounds. 
 Modern observations are more conservative but no less intriguing. 
 With such thoughts in mind, three zoologists led by M. K. Yousef of the University of Nevada gathered recently in Australia to investigate the camel's fuel economy. 
 The focus of their studies was a group of six half-tamed dromedaries, originally part of the feral camel population of central Australia. 
 The researchers' aim was simply to measure the amount of oxygen consumed by the camels under various conditions. 
 As each beast ambled at its own pace along a farm track, the team collected its breath with the help of a gas-tight mask and a weather balloon. 
 Analysis of the gas in the balloon told the team how much oxygen the camels were using as they walked. 
 This figure is directly related to the rate of consumption of metabolic fuel &mdash; the camel's equivalent of mpg. 
 For comparative purposes, the team also took a similar set of readings on human walkers. 
 Once the zoologists had taken account of the difference in weight, the camels emerged as clear winners. 
 Over the same distance, people use two and a half times more energy (per kilogram of their bulk) than the average camel. 
 Although large animals are generally more efficient at walking than small ones &mdash; just as trains outperform cars &mdash; the camel is in an altogether different league. 
 It uses less than three-quarters of the energy expected of a mammal of its size. 
 The camel's metabolic response to heavy loads is no less dramatic. 
 Most animals increase their fuel consumption in proportion to the extra baggage they are carrying, but not the camel. 
 With a burden of about 150 kilograms &mdash; equal to more than a quarter of its body weight &mdash; a camel burns only around 15 per cent more fuel than it burns unladen. 
 The findings throw fresh light on the camel's former popularity both as pack animal and military mount. 
 When Alexander the Great looted Persepolis in 330BC, he wisely enlisted 500 camels to carry the booty. 
 Equally perceptively, Napoleon Bonaparte founded his own crack camel corps after studying the progress of a desert caravan. 
 As the Christmas story demonstrates, more peace-loving potentates also appreciate the camel's skills. 
 Zoologists have yet to establish the precise mechanisms behind the camel's fuel economy. 
 One candidate is the leg musculature, which may turn out to be constructed from slower, more efficient fibres than those employed elsewhere. 
 Another candidate is the unique stepping gait. 
 Camels operate each foreleg and its associated hindleg in unison, more like a pantomime horse than a regular quadruped. 
 This method of progression is unsettling enough to make some riders seasick, but it may hold the key to the beast's endurance. 
 (Physiological Zoology, vol. 62, p. 1080.) 
 Forelegs good-and hind legs too&hellip; secret of the dromedary's success OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sci 
 The greenhouse effect means the world is in hot water. 
 But how fast and far is it rising? 
 Jeremy Leggett reports on some cold-comfort clues from the Ice Age, while David Pugh considers the particular dangers facing cities like Venice as sea levels rise The big melt-down to a flood of fears. 
 THE RISE of sea level predicted as a consequence of global warming has been the subject of some spectacular doom-mongering since the greenhouse effect leapt to prominence. 
 But as in all aspects of forecasting the greenhouse world, the task of prediction is clouded by uncertainty. 
 We know with some confidence that if greenhouse gases continue to be emitted in their present quantities, we will experience unprecedented rates of sea-level rise. 
 But how fast? 
 Recent issues of the journal Nature have featured new research on the sea-level rise which is likely to give us the biggest clues: the rise at the end of the last Ice Age. 
 Global sea level was 120 metres below the present level during the Ice Age. 
 Together with woolly mammoths and sabre-toothed tigers, our ancestors roamed what are now submarine continental shelves. 
 A phase of global warming which began about 17,000 years ago took us from a glacial world, up to 5C colder on average than the present one, into the equable post-glacial world of the last 10,000 years. 
 As the world warmed, the global sea level rose at rates which certainly were without parallel in the last 100,000 years, but until this month no continuous record of this sea-level change had been available to scientists. 
 Now, Richard Fairbanks of New York's Lamont-Doherty Geological Observatory has uncovered a detailed record which shows how fast global sea level rose at different times during the transformation from the glacial to the post-glacial world. 
 Like many advances in scientific knowledge, Fairbanks's is rooted in a simple technique. 
 He drilled through submerged coral reefs off the island of Barbados, looking for the coral Acropora palmata, which can only live within five metres of sea level. 
 By measuring the trace amounts of radioactive carbon in coral skeletons, which decays at a known rate, he could work out the ages of the corals at different depths in his boreholes. 
 By subtracting the slow rate at which the planet's surface is rising in the Barbados area, known from previous geological work onshore, he could work out where sea level stood at different times in the past. 
 Fairbanks found that when sea level first began to rise as the ice sheets melted, 17,000 years ago, it did so at a rate of about 4mm per year. 
 This is some four times faster than the 1mm per year or so at which global sea level has been rising this century. 
 It is about the same as we can anticipate in the next century, on the basis of currently predicted rates of greenhouse warming, according to scientists like Tom Wigley, Director of the Climate Research Unit at the University of East Anglia. 
 If governments do nothing about greenhouse gas emissions, Wigley's best guess for the resulting warming is around 1.5 to 3C by 2050, which would cause a global sea-level rise of 4 to 6mm per year. 
 Fairbanks's corals showed him that in the de-glaciating world around 13,000 years ago, a rapid acceleration occurred. 
 Sea level went up by 24 metres in less than 1,000 years, a rate of more than 24mm per year. 
 After a period of slower rise until 10,500 years ago, corresponding to a time known as the Younger Dryas &mdash; when ice sheets temporarily advanced again in the Northern hemisphere &mdash; a second burst of accelerated sea-level risk took place, at rates similar to the previous acceleration. 
 Where did the extra water in Fairbanks's pulses of sea-level rise come from? 
 The oxygen isotope chemistry of the corals reflects the composition and origin of the water in which they lived. 
 On this basis, geologists can be confident that the two phases of accelerated sea-level rise were due to dramatic additions of meltwater to the oceans from melting northern hemisphere ice sheets. 
 Why should the North American glaciers have melted so irregularly? 
 One possibility is that the complex wobbles of the Earth's axis as it orbits the sun contrived to produce a peak of solar insolation &mdash; stronger than usual phases of heating by the sun &mdash; during the two times of accelerated meltwater runoff. 
 Astronomers can calculate when such maxima of solar insolation took place, and Fairbanks found that his two phases of accelerated run-off do not correlate with the maxima. 
 He was forced to conclude that there is currently no obvious explanation for why his phases of meltwater runoff and accelerated sea-level rise took place when they did. 
 Other possibilities arise as a result of further research on sea levels published recently. 
 John Shaw, a geographer from Queen's University, Ontario, argued in a recent issue of the US journal Geology, that enormous volumes of glacial meltwater must have burst forth from the Canadian ice sheets in cataclysmic floods as they broke up at the end of the Ice Age. 
 If Shaw is right one such flood must have contained around 84,000 cubic kilometres of water. 
 Such a volume, Shaw calculated, would have given a rise in global sea level of 230mm within a matter of weeks. 
 He believes that such vast and unexpected escapes of sub-global meltwater might have occurred a number of times as the ice sheets broke up at the end the Ice Age. 
 Indeed, he proposes that the myths about ancient floods, common to many cultures, owe their origins to this process. 
 Would the same principle of sudden and catastrophic meltwater releases to the Greenland and Antarctic ice sheets in the greenhouse world to come? 
 Dr Mike Tooley, a University of Durham geographer, commenting on Shaw's paper in Nature, drew attention to measured rates of end-of-Ice-Age sea-level rise well in excess of those uncovered by Fairbanks, though sustained over shorter periods. 
 Researchers in eastern China recorded one peak of 75mm per year. 
 &bquo;Is there a potential on the Earth now,&equo; Tooley asked, &bquo;for catastrophic, subglacial floods raising sea level by 23cm in a few weeks or several metres in a few years?&equo; 
 Probably not. 
 But only probably. 
 And even if not, the lessons from the end of the Ice Age suggest that we are going to need much more than Thames Barriers in the absence of an effective international policy response to the greenhouse effect. 
 Dr Jeremy Leggett is director of science at Greenpeace UK. 
 Depth in Venice&hellip; rising problems for a city on water OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sci 
 John Illman on The Lancet's humorous side Hitting the funny bone. 
 The Lancet is known to the public as one of the world's leading medical journals. 
 It has become synonymous with sober science, if not pompous solemnity. 
 To its regular readers it is also renowned for its humorous In England Now column, introduced 50 years ago and now the subject of a new anthology. 
 The thing that is really appealing about In England Now is that self-important, overbearing medical people are still aghast at the idea of a major journal of international repute devoting space to humour. 
 In fact, the column has provided an invaluable reflection of grassroots medicine, while encouraging successive generations of doctors not to take themselves too seriously. 
 These are edited excerpts from the book: EXTRACT from medical report form for one of the Big Five banks: &bquo;For colour vision, ability to distinguish between red and black is the only requirement.&equo; 
 ONE IS always a bit bashful about asking for blood tests on onself &mdash; no one likes to be thought of as a hypochondriac. 
 However, the margarine adverts having got to me, and the latest atherosclerosis story beginning to look as though it might be true, I succumbed to the temptation of having my lipids (blood fats, including cholesterol) done. 
 Diffidently, I filled in the form: 40,000 mile service, please. 
 Alas, like my father before me, my cholesterol is high. 
 The biochemist's comment was curt: suggest oil change. 
 AFTER THE end of the last act our host began to sweat and look pale&hellip; 
 A man approached stating that he was a doctor and offering help. 
 Much relieved I handed over without a word. 
 Then I began to foresee our mutual embarrassment if events should develop in such a way which would force me to reveal my professional identity. 
 Very humbly I said how grateful I was, since I was only a surgeon. 
 &bquo;So am I,&equo; he said, and departed. 
 THE OPENING ceremony had been a great success. 
 The royal personage was gracious; the weather was fine; my speech had been well received; the dinner had been brilliant. 
 As we went to bed that night, my wife said: &bquo;I was very proud of you today.&equo; 
 When I got up next morning, I said to her, &bquo;Are you still proud of me?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; she replied, &bquo;I'm all right now.&equo; 
 HOW FEW of my medical patients behave sensibly when they have their coronaries. 
 One doctor was being driven home when he suddenly said: &bquo;Stop the car and let me out&equo;, at which he leapt out and ran off down the road into the dark. 
 A few minutes later he breathlessly approached the car from the opposite direction, fell into his seat, and said: &bquo;Well, that's all right. 
 I had an awful pain in my chest and did not know whether it was a coronary or indigestion. 
 I thought that if I ran and it was a coronary, it should have got worse, but I &bquo;ve run round the block and it hasn't, so it must be indigestion.&equo; 
 PATHOLOGIST, seeking improvement to his department, at staff committee: &bquo;We must think of our public image. 
 Of course the mortuary is the shop window of the hospital.&equo; 
 I HAD to spend some time comforting a distraught mother whose child was thought to have a behavioural problem. 
 She had just taken him to a psychiatrist who among many searching questions had asked the five-year-old: &bquo;If your sister is a girl, what is your brother?&equo; 
 No answer was forthcoming, and no doubt the appropriate score went down on the questionnaire. 
 The mother came came away somewhat bewildered. 
 To test my own four-year-old daughter's reaction, I asked her, &bquo;If your sister is a girl, what is your brother?&equo; 
 A long pause followed, and then she said tartly: &bquo;A mouse&equo;. 
 I said rather disappointedly, &bquo;Why did you say that?&equo; 
 The prompt reply was, &bquo;Ask a silly question and you get a silly answer.&equo; 
 In England Now. 
 Fifty Years of Peripatetic Correspondence In The Lancet. 
 Published by The Lancet/ Hodder and Stoughton. 
 Available from bookshops or from Publication Dept., The Lancet, 46 Bedford Square, London WC1. 
 Overseas orders: add &pound;1.50 for post and packing by airmail. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 Check-Up.. 
 ACONSUMER'S guide of alarm clocks and baby alarm clocks for hearing-impaired people is now available from the Health Department. 
 It is based on a study of flashing light and vibrating pad alarms at the Radcliffe Hospital and Infirmary, Oxford. 
 Copies available from Health Publications, No.2 Site, Heywood Stores, Manchester Road, Heywood Lancs OL10 2PZ. 
 ANEW type of health guide has been produced in the West Country. 
 Avon Health 89-90 is believed to be the only local guide in the country to both orthodox and complementary health. 
 Covering the four health authorities in Avon, it incorporates NHS hospitals, social services, individual orthodox and alternative practitioners, charities and self-help groups. 
 It also answers questions ranging from how do I get my eyes tested, to what is the Alexander Technique? 
 PEOPLE with epilepsy are being urged to alert hospital staff to their condition if they undergo hospital tests. 
 The warning follows a case involving a member of the British Epilepsy Association who had a seizure during hospital tests involving a two day fast. 
 Further advice available from the Association, Anstey House, 40 Hanover Square, Leeds LS3 IBE. 
 The association runs a helpline, manned Monday to Thursday between 9am and 4.40pm and on Friday between 9am and 4pm. 
 Tel: 0345-089599. 
 Self-Help. 
 (An alphabetical directory of self-help groups) British Sports Association for the Disabled, Mary Glen Haigh House, 34 Osnaburgh Street, London NW1 3ND. 
 Tel: 01-383 7277. 
 Aims: to help both the physically and mentally handicapped, by both providing and contributing towards sporting facilities. 
 British Tinnitus Association, Royal National Institute for the Deaf, 105 Gower Street, London WC1 6AN. 
 Tel: 01-387 8033. 
 Aims: to assist in the setting up of local self help groups and to provide information and counselling. 
 Brittle Bone Society, Unit Four, Block 20, Carlunie Road, Dunsinane Industrial Estate, Dundee DD2 3QT. 
 Tel: 0382 817771. 
 Aims: to provide practical support, advice and encouragement for patients and relatives. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE 
 The Centre for Alternative Technology soon goes public, reports Trevor Blackwell Shares and share alike. 
 ON January 1 the National Centre for Alternative Technology, one of the focal points in Britain's emerging green network, is going public and eight weeks later will be launching a &pound;1.25 million share issue. 
 Although there won't be the saturation advertising that usually attends popular capitalism, there will be a prospectus containing a supportive letter from the Prince of Wales, and offers of preferential access to the centre's facilities. 
 Coming from a group whose aim is the simpler life, such an entry into the market place raises some intriguing questions. 
 Are we witnessing the next step in the greening of the market, or is it just the latest move in the marketing of the greens? 
 Five miles outside Machynlleth in central Wales the centre occupies a disused quarry which has been surrounded with windmills and filled with gleaming solarpanels. 
 Dedicated to demonstrating and popularising alternative, sustainable ways of using energy &mdash; sun, wind and water power &mdash; it is now the second most popular tourist attraction in Wales, drawing 1,000 visitors a day in the summer. 
 It also runs practical residential courses on the environment for schools and is constantly consulted for advice and information by industry and individuals. 
 What makes it so special is the people who live and work there, who don't just talk about the need for alternative technologies, or even just demonstrate workable alternatives but actually live by them. 
 For the families and individuals this means that they depend for their electricity on what they can generate for themselves, grow much of their own food and recycle their own wastes. 
 They build and insulate their own houses, draw minimal wages and cook for each other. 
 So why do they now need &pound;1.25 million? 
 Roger Kelly, who coordinates its work explains: &bquo;For 15 years this place has been going through a slow, organic evolution. 
 What we're experiencing now is a huge upsurge in demand for everything we do. 
 Reviewing our resources, we've decided to try and influence the relatively large number of people who need something beyond simply factual material about green issues. 
 We aim to offer our visitors in the nineties a &bquo;total experience&equo; that involves all their senses and emotions.&equo; 
 What this popular environmental education might look like &mdash; beyond the existing displays &mdash; is elaborated by the centre workers. 
 The new exhibition of organic gardening, for example, would take visitors first through an electronic display which would simulate a magnified section of the sub-soil with its organisms and cycles. 
 People would emerge into a sunken greenhouse where organifarming methods would be displayed, and information given on its local practicalities and its world-wide implications. 
 Up to 20,000 visitors a year will be transported to the site by a new water-powered railway. 
 Roger Kelly is convinced that there are enough people to invest in the centre: &bquo;Five years ago this would have been a pipe-dream, but with the rise of the ethical investment movement it's become a real possibility. 
 Look at Tradecraft, for example, who recently raised &pound;300,000 on its first share issue, and then &pound;1,000,000 on its second.&equo; 
 The centre becomes a plc on January 1, and launches its share issue on March 1. 
 The shares will be non-voting ones which means that the workers will keep control. 
 Kelly concludes: &bquo;Obviously there are still choices about whose money you'll accept. 
 We wouldn't go begging to British Nuclear Fuels, for example. 
 We have to face the fact that there is virtually no money which has a 100 per cent pure source.&equo; 
 There are some misgivings about the effects the envisaged doubling of visitors will have and the enormous expansion of residential courses. 
 &bquo;It's always been difficult to let people see what the collective living is about&equo;, says one member of the site community. 
 &bquo;The truth is that simple things, like eating together, probably contribute more to energy saving than all the machines we use. 
 But people like seeing new machines and gadgets. 
 You can't put the community on the displays.&equo; 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE en2 
 It'll be all right, make no mistake Daedalus. 
 By David Jones 
 JUST AS the calculator has produced its own brand of innumeracy, so the word-processor is generating its own style of illiteracy. 
 Its speed and ease, says Daedalus, are filling books, papers, journals and commercial literature with increasingly careless and muddled English. 
 Spelling-checkers, and even the more recent grammar-sensitive &bquo;style-checkers,&equo; only give the muddle a little extra polish. 
 Easy writing is still damned hard reading. 
 So Daedalus is developing a new word-processing program. 
 It tries to deduce what, if anything, the author has to say, and then nags him into saying it clearly. 
 The Dreadco &bquo;Literary Critic&equo; seeks clarification of every sentence typed. 
 &bquo;I thought he died in Chapter 8?&equo; it might remark; or &bquo;You said the opposite in line 154,&equo; &bquo;Is &bquo;boxing&equo; the day, the sport, or the packaging?&equo; and for real puzzles, &bquo;Do you really mean that?&equo; or even &bquo;Who he?&equo; or &bquo;Shome mishtake shurely?&equo; 
 These seemingly intelligent interjections are, of course, nothing of the sort. 
 The Literary Critic doesn't understand English; still less does it have any feel for the aesthetics of the language. 
 What it has is a big dictionary of words and synonyms classified by type (people, locations, actions, etc) and connected by their most likely relationships. 
 Like other conversational programs, it uses this big database to fit some sort of &bquo;logical tree&equo; to the growing narrative, and respond to it from a programmed strategy. 
 Once it has decided what the text is &bquo;about&equo;, it queries each apparently new or discordant topic or action, and amends its database from the writer's response. 
 It marks occurrences with their stated sequence in time, keeps tabs on the &bquo;cast&equo; of characters or concepts being discussed, and asks further questions when ambiguities or inconsistencies seem to occur. 
 Where logically necessary, it generates new linking text, and tries to rearrange the whole assembly of statements into their neatest logical tree. 
 This relentless nagging and tidying will have an effect out of all proportion to its actual cogency. 
 For as Socrates knew, a sequence of silly questions is a wonderful way of forcing someone to think out just what he believes and wants to say. 
 Under the prodding of the Literary Critic, the most shambolic writer should soon sort out his slipshod ramblings into a coherent story, with no unstated assumptions, contradictions, or logical gaps. 
 It won't be deathless prose, but it should be a grammatical and effective piece of writing. 
 Self-conscious stylists will hate the Literary Critic. 
 But the children and students of the electronic age will simply accept it as an effortless and automatic guide to self-expression. 
 &bquo;How do I know what I think till I've heard what I've got to say?&equo; they will ask; and, sitting down at the keyboard, will type in a few hasty half-baked assertions, and let the program nag them into developing a coherent and well-expressed thesis. 
 But the Literary Critic may have its finest effects outside the educational and professional establishments. 
 Many humbler folk, with fascinating ideas and personal stories to tell if they only dared to sit down and write them out, will be grateful for its tireless and patient tuition. 
 It will help policemen and insurance assessors to extract sensible evidence from befuddled witnesses, tease effective instructions out of skilled but inarticulate craftsmen, and trick unwary criminals into much completer confessions than they had intended. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sci 
 for 3rd arts south Celebrating the first steps of a maestro. 
 By Mary Clarke at Sadler's Wells 
 SADLER'S Wells Royal Ballet opened their Christmas season at the Wells with a programme which paid tribute to the 60th birthday of Kenneth MacMillan, whose early ballets were staged in that theatre. 
 It was a curious evening, a backward look to pieces in which could be seen the seeds of the choreographic gift that was to develop, sometimes into epic stagings, in the years ahead. 
 The programme began with Danses Concertantes of 1955, with which MacMillan made his debut as a professional choreographer. 
 It was the first work on which he collaborated-and collaborated happily-with Nicholas Georgiadis but it is now given in the heavy scarlet, black and gold designs which Georgiadis substituted in 1980. 
 They tend to overpower the spiky, inventive choreography. 
 On the other hand Solitaire, which closed the evening, has had its original 1956 designs by Desmond Heeley restored, to the delight of those who admire this &bquo;kind of game for one&equo;. 
 It needs a stronger, warmer personality for the solitary girl than Bonnie Moore can provide but the dancing was sprightly. 
 If these two ballets were evidence of MacMillan's gift for using the classical technique in a fresh and personal way, La Hermanas (based on Lorca's The House of Bernarda Alba), which came between, showed those themes of dark sexuality which would find their full development in Mayerling. 
 Made for the Stuttgart Ballet in 1956, the ballet has stayed the course because of its tight construction and the meaty roles it offers. 
 On Tuesday Marion Tait was superbly tragic as the older sister, Karen Donovan full of spite as the jealous one, and Anita Landa fiercely repressive as the mother, while Joseph Cipolla gave due emphasis to the pelvic thrusts of which his role chiefly consists. 
 MacMillan has come a long way since 1963 but Hermanas can still grip when done as well as this. 
 SWRB at Sadler's Wells until January 6; this programme repeats on January 2 and 3. 
 Hit and miss from Frank. 
 By M Grosvenor-Myer 3 Pantomimes. 
 THERE is a first time for everything: Aladdin was the first panto I'd been to and the first Frank Bruno has performed in. 
 I hope he had as good a time as I did. 
 But he did not look very relaxed in his supporting role of the Genie. 
 He should not be nervous: by the time he arrives on stage just before the end of the first act the youngsters in the audience had been thoroughly warmed up by all the silliness created by Michael Barrymore and the Roly Polys; the bruisers from Essex who turned up to see their hero had been thoroughly oiled with lager and were ready to send their love across the footlights. 
 Bruno is turned out in a set of white-sequined boxing trunks with blue stripes and a matching set of Masters of the Universe shoulder pads, his incredibly muscled midriff exposed between. 
 For most of the time he shifted about from one foot to the other, more like a naughty schoolboy who has been hauled up in front of the head master than a genie rubbed out of a bottle. 
 He was difficult to hear &mdash; either a touch of flu or a dose of technical problems. 
 Still, Bruno has charm and stage presence. 
 I was surprised, although not as surprised as Mike Tyson when Frank got up and hit him back. 
 Two acting notes for Frank: Less is more &mdash; do not shift your eyes at the audience so much, stare them down once every scene; when in doubt about what to say next do not keep ad-libbing about Harry. 
 Use his name once a performance: keep 'em waiting for it. 
 The rest of the production hums along. 
 Barrymore's Wishee Washee carries the evening on his narrow shoulders. 
 He arrives on stage going faster than an Olympic sprinter. 
 He could not possibly be on steroids: he is too damn skinny. 
 The evening is a holiday stew with something for everyone: multi-ethnic chorus lines, poll-tax jokes, Kylie and Jason jokes, and Second World War jokes for those old enough to remember. 
 There are the usual look-behind-you routines.There are no mother-in-law jokes, although inevitably a few ethnic ones slipped in. 
 The great thing for a first-timer like me was the crowd: noisy and well behaved. 
 People who will not like Aladdin are doctrinaire anti-vulgarians or those who were traumatised as children at other pantos. 
 Among the others in my party, four-year-old Caitlin liked the Princess best. 
 Her sister, 10-year-old Claire, was amazed that people could make rude jokes and not get into trouble for it. 
 Taunton Allen Saddler. 
 Irma La Douce. 
 TAUNTON'S Brewhouse Theatre continues its Christmas tradition of shows that have nothing to do with Christmas with the opening of the Century's tour of Irma La Douce. 
 Touring reduces a full-scale dancing and singing show to a chamber musical and is an ambitious venture. 
 Century engage actors who are also musicians. 
 It is entertaining to see a group of loushe Parisian types forming a street band or filling in for cabaret. 
 Bob Eaton has many bright ideas for direction, but the show lacks a really winning song. 
 There are lots of bright and witty numbers but The Language of Love is the nearest to a heart-schmaltzy ballad and it isn't very convincing. 
 Irma La Douce is a musical based on the farce mechanism, with a cast of Damon Runyon characters, transferred from Brooklyn to the Pagally. 
 Irma, a prostitute and a really nice girl, falls for Nestor, a young law student, who is jealous of her clients. 
 Nestor invents an elderly admirer, who can pay enough for Irma to dispense with other clients. 
 The elderly admirer is Nestor himself in a false beard and Irma, who is clearly short sighted as well as dim and really nice, hardly notices the difference. 
 Nestor gets jealous of his other self and stages a killing of his rival, for which he is arrested and convicted. 
 Well, a law student might have spotted that a man cannot be convicted without the dead body being around. 
 Elementary. 
 But this ruse gives a chance for Nestor and the gallery of small time crooks and pimps to be transported to Devil's Island, an escape on a raft in a storm and end up at the North Pole for a sequence with a dancing penguin and a polar bear, to give the show a Christmas gloss. 
 Shelley Willetts plays Irma like a grubby angel. 
 She gives a wistful version of the title song, but her Irma is more EastEnders than Montmatre. 
 Wayne Morris is very active as Nestor and surely has a career in regular farce. 
 Irma La Douce is lightweight entertainment, held down by the off hand commentary of Liz Spenz as the owner of the back street cafe where the plot keeps boiling over. 
 Birmingham Gerald Larner. 
 CBSO/Rattle. 
 NEXT time Simon Rattle and the City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra perform Messiaen's Et Exspecto Resurrectionem Mortuorum they should do it in a great cathedral. 
 Not a modest one like St Asaph, where the gong and tam-tam crescendos of the third movement would be damagingly deafening, but in some vast Gothic building where the acoustic reverberations would be as effective as the spiritual associations in enhancing the effect of the piece. 
 In a place with an acoustic as dry and an atmosphere as worldly as Birmingham Town Hall it doesn't work. 
 Indeed, without the ecclesiastical aura, the passages of massively slow-moving melody, unadorned and sometimes unharmonised, can sound too plain and even too thin in texture. 
 The birdsong episodes in the third and fourth movements, projected in brilliant colours and vital rhythms on this occasion, can only benefit from concert-hall clarity, it is true. 
 But most of the score-for 40 wind and percussion players without strings-is about immensity rather than detail, above all in the last movement. 
 The culminating voice of the multitude cannot be heard without a congregational blurring of the line in long-accumulated reverberations, however heroic the efforts to magnify the dynamics at the end. 
 The consolation was in a wonderfully spontaneous performance of Rachmaninov's Second Symphony. 
 If the CBSO strings failed to assert themselves strongly enough in the overall balance at certain crucial points in the first movement, they certainly approached the textural problems of the adagio with great sensitivity and, when it came to them, phrased the main theme as eloquently as the clarinet had done on its first appearance. 
 We didn't really need a Christmas present after that but the encore, the intermezzo from Delius's Fennimore and Gerda, was very welcome all the same. 
 Newcastle-under-Lyme. 
 Barber Of Seville. 
 By Robin Thornber 
 BEAUMARCHAIS's comedies are less well known in this country (though still popular with the Comedie Francais) than the operas derived from them, Rossini's The Barber Of Seville and Mozart's The Marriage of Figaro. 
 But it seems he's suddenly being rediscovered here. 
 Henry Livings faced formidable problems in tackling this new translation of the original Barber. 
 An elderly gent wandering the streets talking to himself about his secret wedding to his ward tomorrow (because the plot requires him to be overheard so she'll find out) is the sort of thing you can only get away with in opera. 
 But he has, on the whole, pulled it off. 
 He succeeds brilliantly in finding a style of speech which is neither archaic nor too modern (apart from the odd anachronism like cash-flow) but belongs to a timeless tradition of broad, popular comedy, like Ayckbourn with clogs on. 
 Beaumarchais/Livings is funnier, faster and subtler than, say, the average Whitehall farce and could be just as accessible. 
 But Peter Cheeseman's production at the North Staffordshire New Victoria seems to strive too hard for lightness of touch; it feels too scholarly and reverential. 
 There is much to enjoy in an unbuckled way in this basically commedia dell'arte wheeze of young lovers enlisting the wily servant's help to outwit the old guardian-in this it springs from the same dramatic roots as much of pantomime. 
 Two of the company seemed to have clocked that slightly outrageous, out-front performances were called for-Graham Fellows, as a nudging, naive Count Almaviva, and Victoria Scarborough as a gloriously posing heroine, Rosina. 
 If only the rest had been encouraged to play it big and brassy like this. 
 But on the first night at least Richard Hague's careful Figaro seemed only part way there, tentative and restrained in his guile. 
 (Think what Bob Hoskins would have made of it.) 
 As did Edward York's Basilio-he had it, but wouldn't let go of it. 
 There was some very insecure playing, too. 
 The whole company appeared nervous. 
 Maybe, now that they know it works and if they are embold-Clare Shearer as Rosina ened, it will grow during the run into the big, bold bellylaugh it ought to be, forgetting operatic pretensions to high art and closer to situation comedy. 
 North Staffordshire New Victoria (0782 717962), in repertory until January 27. 
 Leicester. 
 Chicken Tango. 
 By Pat Ashworth 
 THIS is such a delicious offering, of the kind that makes you chuckle in recollection on the way home, that I do not really want to give the game away by saying too much about what goes on. 
 The Phoenix Arts Centre in Leicester is trying to shake off its persistent image of being just too highbrow for words and it is striving to show the general public that they might actually enjoy some of the things that go on there. 
 So they have put on a Christmas show that runs until the end of January, which while still being very different from anything else in the Midlands this Christmas, should entice a new audience into the theatre. 
 It is described as a comic love story for clumsy people, and it is just that: endearing, touching, and very, very funny. 
 Fiona Gordon and Dominique Abel, who both studied at the Paris School of Mime, Movement and Theatre, play Rosie Tickletoe and Charles, two remarkably unremarkable people, who meet, fall in love, and get married. 
 She is strikingly unattractive in a bright-green stretchy dress, jumble-sale hat, thick spectacles and slightly protruding teeth; he is a wonderfully bashful, not very good magician in an oversized jacket. 
 In quite outrageously comic and very skilful sequences of movement, mime and clowning, they attempt courtship, and in a shower of champagne that misses more often than it hits the glass, approach the great unknown of the wedding night. 
 How they actually manage it is not revealed and so it is highly suitable for family viewing. 
 Supported with some powerful sound effects and swelling music, this rare treat it has toured Europe and north America, and after the Phoenix it is off to Africa, so catch it while you can. 
 At Phoenix Arts (0533 554854) until January 30. 
 Cambridge. 
 3 Pantomimes. 
 By M Grosvenor-Myer 
 BACK to a festive original; or, if not quite Garrick or Grimaldi, at least H. J. Byron. 
 His Aladdin or The Wonderful Scamp, first performed at the Cambridge ADC Theatre in 1862, was brought back to its original home by the enterprising Hamlyn's Music Hall company, complete with appalling Victorian puns and outrageous Victorian rhymes. 
 Lovely. 
 Elsewhere in these parts, it's been the more traditional (i.e. more modern) panto. 
 TV stars, tights and drag, eclectic music. 
 In the Cambridge Arts Dick Whittington, La Donn' E Mobile was pressed into service for a song about cooking by Graham James as Sarah the Cook, a delightful dame smack in the Dan Leno tradition. 
 Of the big names, Esther Rangzen's two present front men, my eye and ear were most taken by the gifted and versatile Grant Baynham. 
 Joanne Robley-Dixon was an expressive and acrobatic cat. 
 Amanda Bairstow's principal boy was attractive, but, whatever the provincial accent she adopted as the fortune-seeking Dick was meant to be, it was nowhere near the Gloucester that the script (and history) specified. 
 There was much for the eye, especially a lovely sinking ship effect followed by a charming underwater ballet. 
 The woodland ballet and the black-light sequence were high points of Red Riding Hood at the Theatre Royal, Bury St. 
 Edmunds, a colourful confection well danced, agreeably sung, and with a good lot of laughs from Alan Wells's Dame and Neil James's Simple Simon. 
 Blow for freedom. 
 By John Fordham at the ICA 
 JAZZ Against Apartheid (an organisation launched early this year to raise cash for black South Africa) ended 1989 in positive shape. 
 It assembled a variety of skilled sympathisers on the stage of the ICA that both set the audience hopping up and down and delivered music of such a strong African flavour as to make the issue and the entertainment inseperable. 
 Appropriately for the cause, the music on Tuesday night was emphatically collaborative -much of it a jam involving trumpeters Dave DeFries and Claud Deppa, saxophonist Dudu Pukwana, guitarist Lucky Ranku and others. 
 The two trumpet players made a particularly attractive contrast, Deppa brittle and fiery, DeFries (on flugelhorn) rounded and measured, his phrasing full of potential new tunes. 
 Toward the close of the show, following enthusiastically received representations from the South African trade union movement, a steadily intensifying free-blow ensued, showcasing Deppa and DeFries before the great Port Elizabeth altoist Dudu Pukwana came on stage and the dynamic Tony Marsh to the drum. 
 Probably anticipating the enhancing of the already considerable temperature that might ensue from a stretch of proven hell-raising, Pukwana called for a blues, and set about declaring his intent with that impassioned alto cry (the instrument in his hands displaying the weight of the tenor as well as the wild, wayward quality of the higher horn) that has been thrilling British audiences since the Sixties. 
 Pinise Saul's vocals added a spine-tingling force to a mid-tempo theme, Dave DeFries's flugalhorn complementing her with brisk fluttering phrases. 
 Tall tales and mortal quirks Radio. 
 By Val Arnold-Forster 
 I CAN'T think of anything more likely to get us through the pre-Christmas traumas than a new play by Don Hayworth. 
 He is one of the jewels of radio, a playwright who understands the medium, but who doesn't use radio merely as a way of playing tricks that wouldn't work on stage or television. 
 He can combine tenderness and humour without becoming mawkish. 
 His latest is called Fairy Story (Radio 4, Monday, to be repeated on Saturday). 
 Cindy is a farm maid, at the beck and call of her wicked, snobbish guardians, with a travelling shoe salesman Ginger as her Prince Charming and the local lady of the manor as the Fairy Godmother. 
 Actually, Hayworth isn't intent on following the classic Cinderalla theme, but in telling us a pleasantly absurd tale of country life in the Thirties. 
 Her wicked guardians try to marry Cindy off to a local nob; a disastrous fire frustrates their plans and, as we are fully expecting, love triumphants. 
 Not a wildly exciting play, though with the production in the safe hands of Alfred Bradley and charming performances all round, it was always easy to listen to. 
 Hayworth's ear for the quirks and sayings of ordinary people never fails. 
 It's not satire exactly, since Hayworth has too kindly an eye for the human condition. 
 Even the wicked guardians prosper, and end up taking tea with the gentry. 
 A spot of folklore in Turpin Hero (Radio 4, Wednesday) in which David Ashford investigates the reality of that famous highwayman's legend. 
 He was, we were told, a butcher from Thaxted who joined a gang of baddies and eventually landed up in York jail, where he was hanged for horse stealing. 
 Turpin, it seems, wasn't an especially heroic character &mdash; but the half-hour programme was full of minor insights into social history. 
 The gang of baddies were originally deer stealers; and it was The Food programme, discussing the increasing availablity of game in High Street supermarkets, who had pointed out that at one time British prisons held more poachers than all the prisoners in France put together. 
 The most memorable detail, though, was the achievement of Turpin's ex-school master. 
 He recognised his ex-pupil's handwriting on a letter and thereby identified the highwayman &mdash; even though Turpin had only been his pupil for three quarters of a year. 
 Harry Thompson's Carry On Up The 55s (Radio 4, Wednesdays) finished this week with a look at the Fifties and sex. 
 Cheery stuff, with Thompson wide-eyed at those fuddy duddy old attitudes. 
 Mind you, its easy enough to giggle if your main sources for Fifties's sexual attitudes are the Ron and Eth dialogues. 
 But it's been an entertaining series, even though there must be quite a few Radio 4 listeners somewhat startled to hear the Fifties treated as risable history. 
 Once more, I found myself sympathising with a Punters lady. 
 Not the one who wanted, for goodness sake, to have a different matching shopping trolly for her different outfits But how much I agree with the lady who wanted the cost of High Street Christmas lights spent on something more practical. 
 Christmas makes grumpies of us all. 
 PAGE 
 Appreciation: Lynn Bari. 
 Always the other woman:. 
 THERE are some movie stars in the minor league who are held in almost as great affection by film fans as the major ones. 
 One of these was Lynn Bari, who has typically had to wait a few weeks after her death before receiving an obituary due her. 
 With over 65 pictures to her credit (and debit), Lynn Bari has probably been seen on television in more homes on weekend afternoons than many more famous names. 
 Twentieth Century-Fox musicals of the '40s were expertly wrapped lighthearted packages &mdash; just the thing to send the troops at the front &mdash; and Lynn Bari was invariably one of the prettiest ingredients. 
 In 1945, she was selected second only to Betty Grable as the most popular pin up amongst servicemen. 
 But then she was used to playing &bquo;the other woman&equo;. 
 Most memorably, in Hello Frisco Hello, (1943), she was the upper crust lady who temporarily takes social-climber John Payne away from the saloon-singer Alice Faye. 
 In fact, she had started pinching other women's men in Always Goodbye (1938), in which Herbert Marshall strayed from Barbara Stanwyck into Bari's arms. 
 However, her favourite roles came in two Glenn Miller movies Sun Valley Serenade (1941), as the band's vocalist (Pat Friday dubbing her singing &bquo;I Know Why&equo;), and as one of the Orchestra Wives the following year. 
 But by 1946, after playing the small role of Jeanne Crain's rival in Margie, she left Fox because she felt the studio hadn't given her enough big parts over the past decade. 
 At Universal, she found herself painfully opposite the eponymous talking mule in Francis Joins The Wacs (1954) and as the female lead in Abbott and Costello Meet the Keystone Cops, (1955) but had delightful moments in Has Anybody Seen My Gal? (1952) singing &bquo;The Red Red Robin&equo; while bobbing around doing the housework. 
 Lynn Bari, who was born Marjorie Schuyler Fisher on December 18th 1913 in Roanoke, Virginia, concocted her screen name from that of the actress Lynn Fontane and author James Barrie. 
 She broke into films in 1933, when MGM advertised for &bquo;tall girls in bathing suits&equo;, and made her movie debut in the chorus in Dancing Lady, which also happened to be Fred Astaire's first film. 
 Unfortunately apart from some of the movies mentioned above, she found herself stuck in the '40s with the unwelcome label of Queen of the B's, because of her frequent roles in Charlie Chan, Mr Moto and Falcon Quickies. 
 An outstanding exception was in The Bridge of San Luis Rey in 1944, as the singer who becomes the favourite of the Viceroy of Peru. 
 Bari's three marriages were to agent Walter Kane, Producer Sid Luft (who later married Judy Garland) and Dr Nathan Rickles, for whom she worked as a nurse for a while in 1956. 
 Her last movie was as Patty McCormack's mother in The Young Runaways in 1968, but she toured with stock company stage productions in the &bquo;70s. 
 A lengthy illness prevented her from appearing on Alice Faye's &bquo;This Is Your Life&equo; tribute a couple of years ago. 
 Ronald Bergan Lynn Bari, born December 18 1913; died Goleta, California, November 20, 1989. 
 Letters: 
 Ruth Hill-Williams writes: J.P.M.Millar had a long life (obituary, December 7), and his death signals the end of an era. 
 My own father (1897-1940) was one of those who, although he had a brilliant mind, came from a large, poor, working-class family. 
 He was sent at the age of 14 to work as an office boy at the city railway station. 
 Passionate with indignation at the poverty and injustices which he daily met around him in the industrial north of Bradford, he sought, and was able to gain from, J.P.M.'s National Council of Labour Colleges, that knowledge which served him so well throughout his short working life, as a weapon with which to fight and change the capitalist system which tolerated and perpetuated such inhumane living conditions. 
 As a child of the Thirties I heard much talk of J.P.M. and Fred Shaw (the NCLC Organiser), Plebs and the Railway Service Journal &mdash; and the Manchester Guardian &mdash; were as much a part of my youthful literary life as Mickey Mouse and Film Fun. 
 As Allen Saddler's notice so rightly says, many of the Labour MPs who swept to power in 1945 had come through J.P.M.'s schools and were thus well armed to fight for the legislation which so transformed society after the second world war. 
 That society became a more egalitarian, caring and humane society, and the present generation would do well to reflect on this. 
 Expect the unexplainable Top of the chat 
 By Rick Glanvill 
 ASK Vic Reeves to describe his sense of humour and you get an answer which sums up his offbeat, skewed vision of the world. 
 &bquo;It's like a shopfront with a little bit of dust in the corner.&equo; 
 His view of contemporary comedy as a whole is equally oblique: &bquo;I see it as a very, very long trench with a worm and a piece of hot bacon nearby.&equo; 
 Perhaps it's not the kind of humour that transfers well to paper &mdash; try explaining Reeves's hero, Tommy Cooper, in print. 
 Reeves stumbled into performance five years ago when, as manager of a club, he had to stand-in for a guest who failed to turn up. 
 Imagine a post-modern, post-punk Morecambe and Wise and you are getting close to Reeves and his foil, Bob Mortimer. 
 Reeves puts their humour down to their upbringing in Darlington and Middlesbrough respectively. 
 Their sell-out shows invariably consist of a series of increasingly strange guests (usually played by Bob Mortimer) constantly interrupted by Reeves's tangential monologues and a catalogue of references to pop music and trash television. 
 In spite of this anarchy, Reeves engenders a kind of instinctive conspiracy between himself and the audience, encouraging a call and response, particularly appropriate tomorrow night when there will be a seasonal pantomime. 
 This is as well as &bquo;an attempt at mind regression&equo; and Vic and Bob's appearance as alter-egos, Donald and Davey Stott, who this weekend will be trying out some magic. 
 &bquo;They are going to cut someone's leg off and then pour some hot oil on a bird.&equo; 
 His current activities point to a bigger future. 
 He now shares an agent with comic icons Rowan Atkinson and Harry Enfield. 
 Having worked his way up via his own live spoof chat show Vic's Big Night Out, he has latterly been guesting on television's One Hour With Jonathan Ross, a show whose format bears a strong resemblance to Reeves's own showcase. 
 You can usually spot Reeves on the programme by his larded-on northern accent. 
 Future projects include a series on Channel 4 in April, to be followed by a sitcom for Granada, hopefully in the summer. 
 &bquo;The working title is The Weekenders. 
 It's about two men who go away every weekend doing different things. 
 In the pilot we go off mine-detecting on the Isle of Wight and discover some lizards.&equo; 
 There is also a Radio One show in the pipeline, so tomorrow's event may well prove to be one of Reeves's last nights out in his adopted home of Deptford. 
 Vic Reeves's Christmas Big Night Out is at the Albany Empire tomorrow night. 
 Three more shows there are provisionally planned for January 
 Bondi's best 
 By Rick Glanvill 
 THIS year has seen a procession of visiting Senegalese acts. 
 Their West African near-neighbours redress the balance somewhat when Gambia's top dance band Ifang Bondi visit the Africa Centre today. 
 For a band that has been performing for around a decade, their output is remarkably small, but perfectly formed. 
 Like the more accessible Senegalese acts like Xalam or Super Diamono, Ifang Bondi combine the strength of their own culture with the best of the rest, interpreted by a stunningly androgynous dancer. 
 Funk, jazz and reggae influence their sound, but the result never dips into a Western dirge. 
 Their social concern is subtly voiced, occasionally in English, and the new Sanjo set continues their maturation. 
 See Rock listings for full details. 
 Steve Harley; Hammersmith Odeon: see Rock/Folk Talk show-off&hellip; 
 Vic Reeves presents his Christmas Big Night Out at the Albany Empire: see Top of the Chat Big Audio Dynamite; Raw-knuckled rock &bquo;n&equo; roll at the Subterania: see Rock/Folk Thomas Mapfumo: chart topping with the album Corruption 
 Daisy-cutter: Snowella pantomime at Sutton and Peckham. 
 V&amp;A's Spirit of Christmas. 
 Miniature winter wonderland: the Playboard Puppets' Spoon family and Egbert Ugly sister's secrets Holiday what's on.. 
 By Betty Jerman 
 LIVE theatre, as we have come to call it since the advent of television, is a feature of Christmas, never forgotten. 
 Theatres specialise for children, ready to tell us tales, ancient and modern, in spectacular fashion. 
 Of course there is also pantomime and now in a museum! 
 London's Theatre Museum could rout its critics by putting on its very first, entitled Cinderella And Her Very Ugly Sisters, as well as a Panto Fun Week of workshops where families can find out how Daisy the Cow negotiates the stage or how a handsome actor is turned into an Ugly Sister, or personally seem to be a Dame or a Principal Boy by being photographed with face beaming through a cut-out stylised figure. 
 In some museums, like the Museum of London, and those in Bradford and Birmingham, you can put on your own show; in Chester you can put on theatre make-up. 
 These are among the enticing participatory events organised by museums and art galleries for the holidays. 
 Liverpool opts for Bulgarian traditions, Maidstone for fossils, Manchester for funny faces. 
 If you seek something completely different, what about a Tudor sing-along in a Royal Palace? 
 That is a rarity indeed. 
 It is a pleasure to see that so many museums still have free admission and free events but if you are dropping in on a favourite, remember that many close at Christmas and New Year and booking is advisable. 
 Quote&hellip;. 
 CONTRARY to Broadway gospel, Dustin Hoffman does not have star billing in the new &bquo;Merchant of Venice.&equo; 
 That honour is reserved instead for the Peter Hall Company &mdash; or, to put a finer point on it, for Peter Hall. 
 Once you've seen the production, in many ways an unexpected one, you'll understand that Mr Hall isn't being pretentious and that Mr Hoffman hasn't suddenly been struck by false modesty. 
 This really is the director's &bquo;Merchant&equo; &mdash; at times Shakespeare's, too &mdash; and Mr Hoffmann plays a supporting role. 
 It's the modern practice that Shylock dominate any version of &bquo;Merchant,&equo; whatever the interpretation, despite the fact that he appears in only five of 20 scenes. 
 Mr Hoffman's Shylock &mdash; meticulous, restlessly intelligent, emotionally and physically lightweight &mdash; does not. 
 His performance is a character actor's polished gem rather than a tragedian's stab at the jugular. 
 This Merchant is likely to prove a big target for American people who routinely deplore British Shakespearean acting and staging. 
 Though the production has gained some Amercian actors since its inception, its classical look and blander, if well-spoken, performances are ripe for Anglophobic attack. 
 But to criticize Mr Hall's production as an exercise in fuddy-duddy Shakespeare is beside the point. 
 The results may look conservative, but in this century it is almost a novel idea &mdash; even if born of necessity &mdash; to restore romance and comedy to &bquo;The Merchant of Venice.&equo; 
 Which isn't to say that Mr Hall's novel idea is necessarily the whole idea. 
 His solid, highly watchable production, like Mr Hoffman's performance, leaves one thinking about this endlessly debated play without for a second being challenged or moved by it. 
 Frank Rich, New York Times 
 December 20 
 It was a film-maker's dream &mdash; total artistic control and a healthy budget. 
 So why did it end with dwindling audiences and a critical drubbing? 
 Hugh Hebert investigates the troubled history of Dennis Potter's &bquo;one-man show&equo; Blackeyes and red faces. 
 BLACKEYES ended, trailing an ever thinner line of puzzled viewers, exasperated critics, and the nagging question, what went wrong? 
 In a sense, the hype answered that question even before we saw the programme. 
 Here was Dennis Potter, by critical consent the best pure television writer we have, directing his first ever film: as near as dammit, total artistic control under conditions of time and budget that were extraordinarily generous; the film-maker's dream. 
 The irony is that, despite the hype, that was not the way it was planned, and there were snags from early on. 
 It was known that Potter wanted to direct some of his own work at some stage. 
 But the assumption was always that his first attempt at direction should be on a modest scale. 
 The initial production planning on Blackeyes was done by Kenith Trodd, who has produced most of Potter's major work, including Pennies From Heaven and The Singing Detective. 
 The idea was that it should be directed by Jon Amiel, who directed Singing Detective and never got much credit for its success, but he didn't want to do it. 
 Nicholas Roeg was approached but didn't like it. 
 With production dates looming, Potter decided he would direct it himself. 
 Trodd says that he supported that decision at the time. 
 But differences began to emerge, with Trodd uneasy about the casting of Gina Bellman as Blackeyes. 
 That unease had already been there over their previous BBC project, Christabel. 
 And Trodd's later analysis of that feeling has a direct bearing on one of the central criticisms made of Blackeyes: its dangerously ambivalent attitude to its central character. 
 There was never much chance that Potter, of all writers, would escape the accusation that his exposure of the exploitation of a model was itself exploitative. 
 It was one of the reasons that earlier discussions with Thames Television fell through &mdash; though Blackeyes was always designed as a movie or a BBC series. 
 It was inherent in the project that Blackeyes should be played by a relatively unknown, inexperienced actress. 
 Despite the doubts, Gina Bellman does have the naive, vulnerable quality Potter clearly wanted &mdash; to that extent, she was right. 
 Trodd now believes that the problem with Christabel and Blackeyes was that &bquo;in the conception, the writing and the casting of women in key roles, Dennis's judgment is flawed.&equo; 
 Just over a year ago, Trodd left the Blackeyes project, and Rick McCallum became the sole producer. 
 There is no doubt that Trodd would have done some things differently, or at least struggled hard to get them changed. 
 But there is no guarantee that he would have succeeded. 
 His presence on Christabel did not prevent it being, to my mind, a critical failure though a modest popular success. 
 Potter's strength is creation not adaptation. 
 What is clear is that once Trodd, a strong and familiar collaborator had gone, dangers crowded in. 
 For one thing, too much was now riding on the project. 
 Pennies and Singing Detective raised interest and expectation, but not on anything like the same scale. 
 The BBC, quite rightly, had given Potter unprecedented freedom, a large budget, and lots of time. 
 But two of the mediating factors that had been present in his triumphant Pennies From Heaven and Singing Detective had gone: no independent director or challenging producer. 
 Everything was in Potter's hands. 
 Potter then began rewriting, as he usually does, adding more and more layers, which is another of the dismaying aspects of the series. 
 He added his own voice as yet another narrator. 
 And as director, he adopted a slow, fluid style that compounded the problem. 
 The fact that it looks so good is a credit at least as much to the man behind the camera, Andrew Dunn, as to Potter's fledgling talent as director. 
 As narrative, it ends in an even more labyrinthine post-modernist muddle than it began. 
 There's a lesson here for the BBC or for any television organisation &mdash; and it's important that everyone should get that lesson right. 
 All credit to any television organisation that backs one of its best talents with money, time, and freedom. 
 But there's also some danger in drifting into a situation where all of that, and the power to get exactly what he wants, is in the hands of one person struggling with a new job, isolated among unfamiliar collaborators. 
 Directors love that power. 
 But it's not only Trodd and other producers who believe that what makes good work in a collaborative art is the challenge of having to justify decisions to your colleagues, and having colleagues who are not afraid to make those challenges. 
 Trodd, the original producer (left), Potter, and Bellman (centre), the star they fell out over 
 Albert Fisher food group seeks &pound;180m for expansion plans. 
 By Tony May 
 THE Albert Fisher fresh food distributor is to raise &pound;180million to fund expansion and has found itself a strong shareholder in the process. 
 Its chairman, Mr Tony Millar, has done a deal with the US Corporate Partners group which invests some &pound;1billion of funds on behalf of US and foreign institutions like pension funds. 
 He is placing about 29million shares at 110p with the company to raise &pound;32million. 
 Shareholders are offered a one-for-three rights issue at 110p to raise &pound;152million, but Corporate Partners will take up any shares not subscribed to. 
 He also proposes a one-for-10 bonus issue of warrants to subscribe for shares at 185p. 
 If no one took up the rights issue, Corporate could end up with nearly 29 per cent of the shares, but a 20 per cent stake is more likely. 
 Mr Millar is forecasting dividends for the year to next August of 3.35p net per share, a jump of 22 per cent. 
 Pro-forma net assets will be &pound;328million. 
 Trading so far this year is up and the board expects &bquo;another year of good growth.&equo; 
 Corporate Partners is keen to talk to other UK companies with a strong balance sheet and a proven management ability to execute a business plan. 
 Its stategy is to make substantial investments, primarily through direct private placements. 
 Bell seeks to cut Bond Corp link. 
 By Reuter 
 BELL Resources, 58 per cent owned by Alan Bond's Bond Corporation, is running out of time to obtain money or assets from Bond that would save it from collapse, its chairman, Geoff Hill, said yesterday. 
 &bquo;Time is a luxury that Bell Resources may well not have,&equo; he told shareholders at the annual meeting in Perth. 
 Mr Hill, appointed chairman this week, said one of his first moves would be to separate management of the company from Bond Corp, which is struggling under huge debts. 
 He described his company's fortunes as inextricably tied to Bond and the fate of the group's brewing arm, Bond Brewing. 
 &bquo;Even now, Bond Brewing bankers are meeting to assess their position in respect of Bond Brewing. 
 &bquo;The consequences of a receiver being appointed to Bond Brewing are, as you can imagine, potentially calamitous for Bell Resources, which has a A&dollar;1.2billion (&pound;591million) deposit partially secured against the capital of Bond Brewing.&equo; 
 He was appointed chairman in a deal negotiated between Bond Corp, 19.9 per cent shareholder Adelaide Steamship and Australia's corporate watchdog, the National Companies and Securities Commission. 
 Several shareholders sharply criticised the behaviour of Bond Corp, which posted a net loss, the largest in Australian history, of A&dollar;814million in the year to June 30. 
 But a move to vote the Bond Corp chairman, Alan Bond, off the Bell Resources board failed. 
 Mr Hill said Bond's board term was not over so the meeting could not vote on removing him. 
 At the annual meeting on Thursday of Bell Group, another Bond subsidiary, the chairman, Tony Oates, said his firm would weather a collapse of Bond Corp because it was a separate company. 
 &bquo;It has its own assets, it has its own financing. 
 It's not interdependent,&equo; he said, in response to a shareholder question. 
 Bell Group is about 75 per cent owned by Bond Corp. 
 Whitbread clinches sale of spirits arm. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 WHITBREAD will today announce the sale of its wines and spirits business to rival brewer Allied-Lyons for between &pound;530 and &pound;550 million. 
 The business was put up for auction two months ago when Whitbread decided that its spirits operation, including brands such as Long John Scotch, Laphroaig malt whisky, Burrough's mixed doubles and Beefeater gin, was too small to compete with the giants of the industry like Grand Metropolitan's IDV, Guinness' United Distillers and Allied-Lyons' Hiram Walker Allied Vintners. 
 The stock market has been expecting an announcement all week. 
 But details of the sale were finalised only last night. 
 There had been speculation Allied-Lyons would clinch the purchase of the Whitbread operation by teaming with its existing partners Suntory of Japan &mdash; whose liqueurs and spirits Allied already markets in the US. 
 But sources yesterday indicated that Suntory would not be involved. 
 Seagram of Canada and France's Pernod-Ricard are understood to have put in bids for the Whitbread business. 
 Included in the sale is James Burrough, best known for its Beefeater gin, which was bought by Whitbread little more than two years ago; the Buckingham Wile Company, which distributes Beefeater, Cutty Sark Scotch, and Benedictine in the US; and the Atlas Peak vinyards in California. 
 Allied-Lyons already sells Ballantine's, Canadian Club, Glendronach malt, Teacher's Scotch, Tia Maria, Canadian Club, Courvoisier, Babycham, Harveys Bristol Cream and Cockburn's port. 
 The company is currently auctioning its Embassy Hotels and is likely to sell the J. Lyons catering operation which provides food at events like Wimbledon. 
 Allied-Lyons' &dollar;325million takeover of American fast-food operation Dunkin' Donuts has just become unconditional. 
 Whitbread says it will spend the money from selling the wines and spirits business on expanding its Pizza Hut, Beefeater Steak Houses, Country Club Hotels and TGI Friday's chains in the UK and Europe and on the company's Keg chain of restaurants in the US. 
 Only this week, Whitbread announced that it had won the franchise to operate TGI Friday's restaurants in Canada, Washington State and Oregon. 
 Societies hit by water shares. 
 The popularity of the water privatisation reduced the net receipts of building societies to &pound;177million in November &mdash; the second lowest this year &mdash; the Building Societies Association says today. 
 However, the success of societies in winning back a bigger market share of mortgage business from the banks was highlighted by the increase in gross home loan advances to &pound;4,157million, a figure topped only once during 1989. 
 Pressure on UAL. 
 United Airlines is under new pressure to agree to a buyout proposal from its employees, writes Mary Brasier in New York. 
 Coniston Partners, the New York investment group which holds nearly 12 per cent of UAL, has given the board until January 8 to come up with an alternative to the &dollar;6.75billion buyout which failed to take off in October. 
 If the pilots, flight attendants and management cannot agree a new buyout, Coniston said it would force a restructuring of UAL which could include selling off the company's planes and its air routes. 
 It has also threatened to oust most of the UAL board by a shareholder vote. 
 &pound;55m damages. 
 Broker Maclaine Watson must pay two Shearson Lehman Hutton companies more than &pound;55million in damages for breach of contract after the collapse of tin prices in October 1985, a court ruled yesterday. 
 Tin had been sold by Shearson to Maclaine for more than &pound;9,000 a tonne but prices nosedived after the International Tin Council market support pact collapsed. 
 Maclaine subsequently refused to accept delivery from Shearson. 
 Boots sale. 
 Boots is selling Fine Art Wallcoverings to its management for an undisclosed sum. 
 Fine Art was acquired as part of Boots' &pound;900million takeover of Ward White in August this year. 
 Fine Art had a turnover of &pound;17.2million in the year to January 31, 1989.. 
 Wall Street higher. 
 On Wall Street, bargain-hunting lifted stocks to a moderately higher close but concern about credit dampened any year-end cheer. 
 The Dow Jones Industrial Average ended the day up 3.20 points at 2,691.13. 
 Cable's talks on &pound;750m China deal boost shares. 
 By Mark Milner 
 SHARES in Cable &amp; Wireless received a sharp boost yesterday after the company disclosed it was discussing the sale of up to &pound;750million worth of shares in its Hong Kong telecomunications subsidiary to the Chinese Government. 
 The company, headed by Lord Sharp, said the talks centred on China International Investment and Trust (CITIC) acquiring a &bquo;significant minority interest&equo; as a long term investment. 
 Cable &amp; Wireless finance director, Mr Rod Olsen, said the size of the stake being discussed was &bquo;not less than 10 per cent and not more than 20 per cent&equo; which would cost CITIC between &pound;375million and &pound;750 million. 
 Cable &amp; Wireless said the transaction was only at a preliminary stage but the talks were taking place on the basis of Hong Kong Telecom's average price last month. 
 If it does go through it will provide a double benefit for the UK-based telecommunications group and is also likely to be seen as a significant plus for Hong Kong's stock market. 
 Hong Kong Telecom, which operates the colony's domestic and international telephone system, accounts for almost 13 per cent of the Hong Kong stock market's Hang Seng index. 
 The market has been in the doldrums in the wake of the suppression of the pro-democracy movement in China this summer and a decision by an arm of the Chinese Government to make an investment of the size being planned by CITIC is likely to have a considerable impact. 
 For Cable &amp; Wireless, the CITIC investment would remove what analysts describe as the &bquo;political factor&equo; which has been hanging over Hong Kong Telecom. 
 The company accounts for around two-thirds of group profits. 
 As one London analyst said yesterday: &bquo;Psychologically, having the Chinese Government take a stake like this is going to be seen as very positive.&equo; 
 The proceeds of any sale would also remove another concern which has influenced attitudes towards Cable &amp; Wireless. 
 The group has invested heavily in building up its Mercury business in the UK and is also committed to the expansion of its PCN business but the disposal of between 10 per cent and 20 per cent of Hong Kong Telecom will allay concerns about the group's funding requirements. 
 News of the negotiations pushed Cable &amp; Wireless shares up 29p to 548p on the stock market in London. 
 Yesterday Mr Olsen said the company had been approached by CITIC about the possible purchase of a holding back in November and the talks had reached a point at which they had had to be made public. 
 Cable &amp; Wireless holds around three-quarters of the shares, the Hong Kong Government another 7 per cent and the remainder are held by outside shareholders. 
 Though both Cable &amp; Wireless and the Hong Kong Government sold shares when the company was floated on the stock market, the government is not thought likely to join in the sale of the stake to CITIC, though it is aware of the negotiations. 
 The UK group has a long standing commitment, made to the Hong Kong Government, to broaden the shareholder base of Hong Kong Telecom and a deal with CITIC would be consistent with that. 
 However Mr Olsen made it clear that the company had no intention of allowing its stake to fall below 50 per cent. 
 &bquo;We will maintain majority equity control and management control.&equo; 
 Hong Kong Telecom was created by the merger of the colony's domestic telephone operator, the Hong Telephone Company, with its international carrier, Cable &amp; Wireless Hong Kong, in January last year. 
 Cable &amp; Wireless held around 80 per cent of both companies. 
 When the merger plans were announced, an offer for sale of shares to the public was planned for early 1988 but it was scrapped in the wake of the 1987 stock market collapse. 
 Brussels to examine large cross-border EC mergers. 
 By John Palmer in Brussels. 
 THE European Community yesterday agreed regulations for vetting large cross-border mergers, after years of complex and tough negotiations. 
 Ministers from the 12 EC countries unveiled a new system which may involve around 40 multi-million pound takeovers being subject to the approval of the European Commission in Brussels each year. 
 Under the scheme, which will operate for four years, the Commission will have the sole authority to investigate and &mdash; where it deems fit &mdash; veto mergers involving transnational companies with a combined turnover of more than &pound;3.5billion a year. 
 This will apply where at least two of the firms earn &pound;170million or more of that turnover in the EC but do not earn more than two-thirds of their total turnover in a single EC country. 
 Hailing the agreement as &bquo;important&equo; yesterday, the British consumer affairs minister, Mr John Redwood, said it might catch about 12 major mergers involving British companies annually. 
 Had the system been in place before, mergers such as GEC-Plessey and Nestle-Rowntrees would probably have come under Brussels' scrutiny, he said. 
 Proposed mergers involving companies with a turnover of less than &pound;1.4billion may be examined by the Commission at the request of an affected member state. 
 Any decision on whether to change the criteria so that smaller mergers would be automatically referred to the Commission will be taken by a qualified majority of the Council of Ministers. 
 The mergers agreement, and progress on a range of other single market issues such as rules for public procurement, the harmonisation for testing and market veterinary medicines and the labelling of irradiated food, were seen as a triumph for the French presidency of the EC Council of Ministers which has ensured that the legislative timetable for the 1992 single market remains on course. 
 &bquo;The Community can be proud of reaching agreement on an issue of such complexity and importance after so many years of negotiations,&equo; the British Commissioner, Sir Leon Brittan, said last night. 
 &bquo;Following this decision, the Community will have for the first time a single framework within which takeovers and mergers of a Community dimension can be dealt with, recognising the importance of maintaining fair competition throughout the single market.&equo; 
 The final compromise over how the system would operate was only reached after concessions by the British and West German Governments. 
 But although Mr Redwood agreed to allow the West German competition authorities special rights to look at sensitive mergers, he obtained a commitment from the Council of Ministers that this could only be used &bquo;in exceptional circumstances&equo;. 
 Mr Redwood said that, in effect, the agreement installed a &bquo;one-stop shop&equo; for vetting mergers, so companies concerned would always know clearly where they stood. 
 ICI in &dollar;193m explosives deal. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 ICI, the chemicals giant, is paying &dollar;193million (&pound;120million) to buy an American explosives manufacturer. 
 The company is buying Atlas Powder Co from its parent, Tyler Corporation, and will pay for the deal by taking on about &dollar;58million of debts and issuing new ICI shares to cover the balance. 
 ICI has explosives businesses in Canada, Europe, Australasia, Asia, Latin America, the Indian sub-continent and South Africa. 
 Last year, their sales totalled &pound;364million and showed a trading profit of &pound;47million. 
 Atlas Powder's 1,500 employees will join the 8,000 who work for ICI's worldwide explosives operation. 
 The principal uses of explosives are in mining, quarrying, the building industry and seismic exploration. 
 The deal is the latest step in a steady series of disposals and acquisitions under ICI chairman, Sir Denys Henderson. 
 Within the last 18 months, the company has sold: its European silicones business to Rhone-Poulenc for &pound;30million; four businesses from its Canadian offshoot CIL; a computer software company to managers; a West German printing inks business; its over-the-counter drugs business in the US and Savlon in Britain; a Canadian building products business to Trafalgar House; and its Coopers Animal Health, which it owned with Wellcome, to Chicago-based Pitman-Moore; During the period it has bought: Cambridge research Biochemicals; a privatelyowned US acrylics company, K-S-H; Rayca Chemical Corporation, which makes chemicals for the US textiles industry. 
 It has also taken full control of its Spanish pharmaceuticals business, ICI-Farma, announced a &pound;150million investment in a Taiwanese chemicals plant making the raw material for polyester fibre and trimmed its UK fertiliser business. 
 The business league proves more interesting than sport Outlook. 
 By Roger Cowe 
 IF BUSINESS were as simple as sport it would now be possible to present a league table for the 1989 season, showing games played and points won and leaving one company out on top. 
 Thankfully business is more interesting than that. 
 So for the next few days this column will present several different ways of assessing corporate performance for 1989. 
 As with all the best competitions the rules are entirely arbitrary and drawn up by an impartial judging commmittee consisting of the proprietor of this column and nobody else. 
 Different criteria are used for each table, but a common minimum market value of &pound;100million is used to exclude the smallest companies where small changes can produce disporportionate results. 
 Where employees are concerned, a minimum of 2,000 has been used for the same reason. 
 The facts are drawn from the Datastream database, and are thus subject to the vagaries of any such enterprise. 
 Still, it is the best information available, so with those caveats, the show goes on. 
 Today the tables focus on growth, or lack of it. 
 Three criteria have been chosen, attempting to measure the most important attributes of company performance over the year. 
 Growth in earnings per share is the key short-term measure so far as the City is concerned. 
 Return on capital attempts to measure the efficiency or otherwise with which directors use the funds entrusted to them: while employment is a rather important measure of companies' progress which tends to be overlooked in conventional financial circles. 
 Even with individual measures such as these, however, it is not easy to decide who has won. 
 Take earnings per share. 
 If the percentage increase in eps is taken as the key measure, companies which begin with very low earnings have an unfair advantage. 
 But if the absolute rise in eps is used, companies which begin with high eps have an unfair advantage. 
 In the true spirit of liberal compromise, the eps league combines both these measures, leaving LLoyds Abbey Life the winner even though it did not top either individual table. 
 Most of the companies in the top 10 are small and fast-growing, which is only to be expected &mdash; after all, it would be extraordinary for ICI to double its earnings. 
 The exceptions are WPP, the new giant of the advertising industry, and insurance company Sun Alliance. 
 Interestingly, though, the bottom 10 includes many household names fallen on hard times. 
 De La Rue, still struggling despite the sale of Crosfield printers, props up the table, with a fall of 28p virtually wiping out earnings. 
 Poor old Westland has plunged into loss, leaving it second from the bottom below the likes of Storehouse and Amstrad. 
 Amstrad is the only company also to appear in the return on capital bottom 10. 
 At the bottom end of the ROC table it is no surprise to see companies like Dixons, Saatchi and Saatchi, United Newspapers and Amstrad. 
 But BodyShop's appearance is more a reflection of accounting curiosities which gave it such a huge return on capital last year: likewise fire extinguisher company Nu-Swift, whose remarkable figures last year put it at the top of the ROC table. 
 WPP's appearance in the top 10 by employment growth as well as the other two tables suggests there is some sense in the measures used. 
 That does not mean that those which have lost most employees during the year are struggling &mdash; Grand Met and Guinness appear due to the clear-out of peripheral businesses, and Reed International because of its transformation from manufacturing to publishing. 
 The employee top 10 features those companies which are expanding fastest, and it says something for the performance of WPP that it has managed to perform well in eps and return on capital terms at the same time as it has achieved that expansion. 
 The composite league table at the end of next week will combine these and other factors to produce the overall winners and losers of 1989. 
 Meanwhile, since Christmas fast approaches, tomorrow will identify the Scrooge of 1989. 
 The threat behind the Eastern promise Frontiers of work. 
 Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent. 
 WHEN Lech Walesa made the keynote speech of his recent five-day visit to Britain most people in his audience of trade unionists, politicians and church and business leaders wore Solidarnosc badges &mdash; some old, some spanking new. 
 The welcome for the man who is recognised as a significant player in unleashing the democratic tides sweeping Eastern Europe was genuine and widespread. 
 Even Norman Fowler, Employment Secretary, who was representing the Government, was persuaded to wear one of the distinctive red and white labels. 
 Yet Mr Walesa's message &mdash; particularly his calls for massive investment to rebuild the Polish economy &mdash; has sparked a wave of largely half-muttered fears in the British union movement about the way the economic rebuilding of East European economies will unfold. 
 He came calling for Europe to work towards economic integration to ensure that the democratic hopes of people in the East did not give way to an opposite undertow of disillusion. 
 He appeared to give carte blanche to investors, predicting that by spring there would be significant business between Britain and Poland. 
 His meetings with the CBI and the Prime Minister were clearly the main focus of his mission. 
 But he also included some explosive thoughts about the future political makeup of Poland. 
 Notably, he refused to say whether it would be a socialist or capitalist state, insisting that these words no longer meant anything in Poland. 
 But it was the call for investment that aroused the most plain fears, and these have been compounded in recent days by a clutch of investments in Eastern Europe by big western manufacturers. 
 Not least was the announcement that Fiat will build a car plant in the Soviet Union, a move described candidly by one Fiat official in the Guardian: &bquo;Fiat believes that Eastern Europe will become the new Korea of the motor industry, except this time cheap production will be available on our doorstep,&equo; he said. 
 Simultaneously, the US group Combustion Engineering announced a &dollar;2billion deal to build a petrochemical plant in Siberia. 
 Since then General Electric has paid &dollar;150million for a half stake in the Hungarian light bulb manufacturer Tunsgram and General Motors has decided to build an engine plant there. 
 These investments are seen by some as the start of an inevitable flood establishing a low-cost source of supply for the West. 
 Mr Roger Lyons, the assistant general secretary of the MSF technical union, sees the need for a massive programme of training to equip trade unionists in the East with skills to handle multi-nationals. 
 But he also sees the need for guarantees on employment conditions there. 
 &bquo;We are very worried that multi-nationals with a captive audience in the East will impose conditions there that would not be acceptable in the European Community. 
 We don't want to deny them opportunities, but those opportunities musn't be unrestrained,&equo; he says. 
 He sees the Fiat plant as a signifiant threat to motor manufacture in Western Europe, and the potential for GE and Tungsram (which has 8 per cent of the world market in light bulbs) to flood the western European market. 
 Governments and the EC, he argues, have not realised the inherent threats to manufacturing in the West. 
 They would need to insist on Eastern states meeting minimum labour standards as a pre-cursor to trading with the West. 
 This is an issue which Western Governments and unions are only really beginning to grapple with in the context of the Single European market, and for many that is where the debate will stay for some time. 
 Mr Bill Jordan, president of the AEU engineering union and the leading figure on the right of the TUC general council, dismisses the prospect of a sudden flood of western investment in Eastern states. 
 Extending the debate over minimum standards to new trading partners in the East is a long way off. 
 Multinationals are by nature conservative, seeking out investment areas which are politically stable. 
 &bquo;These countries are going to go through a period of not only political but also economic instability for some time to come,&equo; he says. 
 Many on the right of the labour movement expect that the biggest problems will occur among unions on the left who have fostered close ties with East European unions which are now being discredited. 
 For TUC bureaucrats the emphasis in the short term is to concentrate on helping to develop real trade union structures in Eastern European states. 
 The need is to move unions on from being state-controlled agencies for controlling industrial production to collective bargaining organisations. 
 There is a clear realisation that attempting to export western trade unionism to the East would be futile. 
 The need to prepare the economies for unemployment and social security provision for the first time will be the important issues. 
 So far the TUC has begun a series of training seminars with Solidarity aimed at pushing it away from being a political and highly regionalised organisation into being an industrial and truly national one. 
 Heads of department from the Soviet trade union centre, the AUCCTU, are expected to visit Congress House in the New Year on a fact-finding mission, and there have been requests for training links to be built between the TUC and the Hungarian trade union body, SZOT, which has been attempting to restructure itself over the last two years. 
 The threat from investment in the East is also being played down by TUC officials who say the biggest business to be done by investors will be in filling East European markets with much-craved products. 
 The clearest message from Mr Walesa's visit, however, was that in Eastern Europe now nothing is particularly clear politically or socially. 
 Until crippled economies are rebuilt everything will be very brittle. 
 OECD says rate rise may be needed to defend pound. 
 By Larry Elliott Economics Correspondent 
 THE UK economy faces a period of considerable uncertainty, with the risk that the government will have to raise base rates again to defend the pound, according to an international report today. 
 A survey by the Paris-based Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD) predicts that the UK will be one of the worst performing nations next year, and warns that a recession will be a real risk if interest rates rise again. 
 It adds that inflation is likely to be higher and domestic demand slower than it predicted in its last report six months ago. 
 Then the OECD forecast that UK interest rates would be 13 per cent by the end of 1989, which would allow the economy to grow by just over 2 per cent next year and inflation to rise by 5 &frac34; per cent. 
 It now believes consumer prices will rise by 6.5 per cent in 1990 but growth will be 1.3 per cent, and could be less than 1 per cent excluding North Sea oil. 
 There was &bquo;no strong case&equo; on domestic grounds for the last base rate increase to 15 per cent. 
 Growth in Germany and Japan next year is expected to be 3.2 per cent and 4.5 per cent respectively. 
 The average for the 24-nation OECD is 2.9 per cent. 
 The OECD says it is concerned by the increase in inflation among members, but the average of 4.5 per cent is still well below the forecast for the UK. 
 The cost of living in Germany is expected to rise by 3 per cent in 1990, with Japan's inflation rate even lower at 2.6 per cent. 
 While its overall assessment paints a picture of relative stability over the next two years, the assessment of the UK's economic prospects is downbeat. 
 It includes the UK in the category of countries where trade deficits are worryingly large, adding that if market confidence in the pound is not restored, &bquo;exchange rate stability might require a further increase in interest rates. 
 &bquo;Further tightening of credit conditions could tip the already slowing economy into recession,&equo; the report says. 
 However, it adds, an even greater risk is that higher mortgage rates will add to wage pressures. 
 It predicts a brighter outlook for the balance of payments, with the lower pound helping export growth and flat domestic demand curbing import growth. 
 However, improvement in the current account deficit will be slow and gains in market share are likely to be limited because Britain's inflation rate is higher than its competitors. 
 Investment is expected to remain subdued and a period of destocking is possible as firms respond to lower demand. 
 Cash is back&hellip; or why dearer credit is on the cards Notebook. 
 By Edited by Alex Brummer 
 IN ALMOST every area of commercial activity the phrase cash discount carries special resonance. 
 It is part of the daily truck in street markets; it the kind of thing which turns on the average car dealer; it is part and parcel of many of the transactions carried out in the building trade and cash or at least early settlement means a better price for the retailer when negotiating with a manufacturer. 
 In the United States even those most staid of institutions, the public utilities, offer a cash discount to those customers who pay for their water, electricity or gas on time. 
 The current regime governing credit card transactions in the UK runs counter to such basic trading practices and principles. 
 Far from receiving a discount the purchaser arriving at the average high street store which a bunch of fivers in most cases pays more for his new washing machine or bicycle because the retailer has factored into the pricing structure the credit card company's fee (which can range from one to four per cent). 
 Thus, the decision by the Trade Secretary, Mr Nicholas Ridley, to abolish the credit card companies &bquo;no discrimination&equo; rule must be sensible. 
 It allows retailers to set prices as they see fit. 
 They can either follow customary practice and offer cash buyers a discount or charge the credit card buyer a surcharge. 
 This is not revolutionary. 
 Anyone crossing the Atlantic (on a cash only bucket shop fare) will quickly find filling stations only too happy to offer a substantial cash discount at the pump. 
 Moreover, the average service station in the US seems to have no trouble operating a third tier of pricing which offers an even more generous discount for self-service. 
 So much for the idea that two-tier pricing will somehow be too complicated. 
 Other criticisms of the Ridley ruling appear to show scant regard for the integrity of the retailer or its competitiveness. 
 It is argued that there will be no discounts only surcharges, on original prices, and this will be inflationary. 
 This seems highly unlikely at a time when high street stores are holding sales before Christmas. 
 Admittedly, it's a nuisance in going into crowded banks to obtain cash. 
 That could be resolved if financial insitutions were willing to invest a little more in cash dispensers in shopping centres. 
 There may also be collateral benefits. 
 In effect the Government is imposing a surcharge on an important source of credit: the direct controls it abhors. 
 If this were to inhibit credit expansion it could lead to lower interest rates. 
 Trivial detail. 
 WHEN Kingfisher's Geoff Mulcahy launched his &pound;560million bid for Dixons, he insisted that a takeover &mdash; merging Kingfisher's Comet with Stanley Kalms' chain &mdash; would give the combined company 22 per cent of the UK retail electrical market. 
 This was the first piece of silliness: Comet already has 8.8 per cent and Dixons has almost 18 per cent &mdash; quite enough when merged to breach the 25 per cent ceiling which triggers a Monopolies Commission inquiry. 
 Mr Mulcahy's 22 per cent figure could be justified only by including rentals of new TVs, video recorders and other hired electrical equipment. 
 The second piece of silliness came from Dixons' Mr Kalms. 
 After the Guardian pointed out on December 8 that Kingfisher did indeed face a prima facie competition problem, he told another newspaper that during his 1986 bid for the then Woolworths, he had been obliged by the OFT to pre-sell Comet to Granada to avoid a monopolies investigation. 
 Yes, Dixons had lined up Granada as a buyer of Comet were the bid to succeed. 
 And yes, the OFT did take this into account when clearing the bid. 
 But the sale was not a precondition of clearance. 
 Then when Dixons admitted that Mr Kalms had perhaps overstated his case when talking about the &bquo;86 bid, Kingfisher smugly declared that it was &bquo;pleased to note&equo; Dixons' clarification. 
 The important point is this: whether or not Kingfisher-plus-Dixons would have a market share of 26 per cent or 22 per cent, a successful takeover would give a single company a large and powerful share of electrical retailing. 
 This would not necessarily be a bad thing. 
 In the past, Kingfisher has argued cogently that tipping the bargaining balance towards the electrical retailer and away from the manufacturers would benefit consumers. 
 This may well be true. 
 If it is not, the bid should be be blocked. 
 If it is true, then Kingfisher should not be afraid of arguing its case in front of the Monopolies Commission. 
 Kingfisher's bid for Dixons should be investigated. 
 At the very least, it would mean that the real issues are debated rather than the trivial detail of statistics and history. 
 Shop soiled. 
 THE final act of the bloody TSB reorganisation was played out yesterday when banking chief Don McCrickard moved into the group chief executive slot, until now occupied by Philip Charlton, who is to become one of three deputy chairmen. 
 Mr McCrickard has two years to get the TSB into shape before the protection against takeover bids expires. 
 The results of the inaugural year of new chairman Sir Nicholas Goodison will be published on January 11. 
 It will be odd if he does not exercise the incoming chairman's prerogative of dumping as much rubbish as possible into the accounts. 
 Analysts are forecasting &pound;340-&pound;350million before tax. 
 There are also likely to be provisions against losses on swap deals with local councils, which may be over &pound;50million. 
 Most of the reorganisation charges incurred in the efficiency drive announced last month, which will prune 3,000 jobs, are also likely to appear in the next accounts. 
 That could be nearly as much again. 
 The result will be a shop-soiled look for the TSB. 
 If Mr McCrickard gets it right, the benefits of cost savings will begin to come through in 1991. 
 If he does not, analysts are already talking about recommending the shares on bid hopes. 
 Warsaw wrestles with tricky task of selling share ownership to the workers. 
 By Daniel John 
 AS THE argument over economic solutions to solve Poland's ills grows, the debate has turned to ways of maintaining worker interest and participation in industries which will be subject to a tougher managerial and financial climate. 
 With the new Polish Government actively considering large-scale privatisation, much attention is beginning to focus on a proposal favoured by both sides of the political fence in Britain. 
 It is a solution which fits in neatly with Mr Lech Walesa's suggestion that the future political make-up of Poland may be neither capitalist nor socialist. 
 Hence why, six weeks before Mr Walesa arrived in Britain for his historic visit last month, a group of merchant bankers, accountants and lawyers, led by rightwing theorists from the Adam Smith Institute (the doyen of advisers to Mrs Thatcher's government), went to Warsaw to discuss the different aspects of privatisation, including the idea of influential worker share ownership. 
 Given what has happened in Britain, certain enterprises could lend themselves to being sold to the Polish public who, surprisingly, might have few difficulties putting up hard cash to buy shares. 
 Evidence suggests that there is a sizeable amount of foreign currency held in Poland &mdash; it is thought between one and two billion US dollars is currently banked with the financial institutions, but the undeclared amount almost certainly swells that figure many times over. 
 But considerable problems lie ahead. 
 Dr Kristof Lis, Poland's minister in charge of the Plenipotentiary for Changes in Ownership, is currently having to wrestle with the fact of real worker power &mdash; from the concept of actual ownership to the committees which have a large say in the running of industry. 
 He has to come up with a strategy which will instill new financial disciplines in Polish industry and satisfy the demands of the workers/public en masse. 
 And the first sell-off has to be success. 
 If it is not, then British privatisation experts are certain that the programme will be still-born. 
 Selling industries, lock, stock and barrel, to their workforces is not an option in the Polish case. 
 Going straight from state ownership to worker ownership is unlikely to change the company's culture or management style, believes Mr Laurie Brennan, chief executive of New Bridge Consultants, an arm of the law firm, Clifford Chance, set up to promote employee share ownership, and who has just returned from Poland. 
 He bases his argument on inefficient and corrupt managers who will be unable and unwilling to adopt the necessary business-like ethics needed to turn their companies round. 
 And some of the painful medicine required &mdash; like plant closures and unemployment &mdash; will not appeal to the workers either. 
 But there is also another reason why management and/or employee buyouts are unlikely to succeed. 
 Part of the point of selling state businesses is to raise hard cash, and taking on more debt to fund worker buyouts in return for low or non-earning equity stakes (which may prove to be worthless in the long run) is not a real option for the government. 
 Western banks are even more reluctant to part with cash, seeing the possibility that East European borrowing could become the Third World debt problem of the 1990s. 
 And even if this could be got round, extra sums would be needed for redundancy payments, investment and modernisation. 
 However, this does not rule out worker participation in Dr Lis' plans. 
 The workers will have to be part of the success of the sell-offs, which is why advisers like Mr Brennan are proposing that they be given sizeable stakes in companies for nothing &mdash; up to 5 per cent or more &mdash; with the possibility of them buying more shares at big discounts. 
 This would allow them to have some influence in the company (unlike in Britain, where there has been no sizeable reservations of shares on a collective basis in the shape of employee trusts) as shareholders as well as having worker-directors. 
 The theory sounds fine but there remains the problem of the deep cultural clash which the new government itself represents. 
 Solidarity, quite rightly, sees the recent changes as its victory. 
 Overnight, government ownership has become the peoples' ownership but soon that will change a third time to shareholder ownership. 
 Little wonder then that the prospect of a Solidarity-led government clashing with Solidarity-led trade unions is a real fear to those involved. 
 Frontiers is edited by Peter Large 
 PO says pay deal will hit profits. 
 By Andrew Cornelius Business Editor 
 THE Post Office warned yesterday that this year's profits will be affected by higher than usual cost increases, including the latest pay deal for Royal Mail staff this year. 
 This followed the announcement that the corporation made pre-tax profits of &pound;58million in the first half of the year, from April to September, against &pound;4million in the first half of 1988. 
 The second-half results will also be affected by higher than usual increases in costs in the second half. 
 The Post Office said that the pay deal for 160,000 Royal Mail Letters staff which came into effect last month would affect the full year results. 
 In previous years, their pay increases operated from April. 
 The financial figures exclude the contribution from Girobank, the banking subsidiary, which is to be sold to the Alliance and Leicester Building Society. 
 Girobank's post-tax profit &mdash; calculated on a basis that does not take inflation into account &mdash; was &pound;9million, unchanged on the first half of 1988. 
 Full-year results for the bank are expected to be higher than last year. 
 Post Office Counters, the business which includes all sub-post offices in the country, made pre-tax profits of &pound;16million in the first half of the year. 
 Last year's results were lower because of the national postal strike and because of the pay increases, the Post Office said. 
 This year's profits will be used to help fund a record &pound;1.5billion programme of investment over the next five years to cope with what is described as &bquo;a phenomenal&equo; growth in mail. 
 The money will be invested on upgrading sorting offices and expanding the Post Office vehicle fleet. 
 The Post Office is the last state-owned business still controlled by the Department of Industry. 
 Surcharge put on flexible friends. 
 By Teresa Hunter 
 SHOPS will soon be able to charge higher prices for goods bought by credit card, the Trade and Industry Secretary, Mr Nicholas Ridley, announced yesterday in a written reply to a parliamentary question. 
 Retailers will be able to choose whether to surcharge credit card customers or to offer a discount for cash, giving them greater price control. 
 But the Consumers Association and banks are concerned it could lead to excessive surcharging. 
 Mr Simon Hinde, Consumers Association spokesman, predicted: &bquo;There is potential for profiteering. 
 We would have preferred a six-month trial period and controls to prevent abuses.&equo; 
 The Retail Consortium, which lobbied the government hard for the abolition of what is known as the &bquo;no discrimination&equo; clause in agreements between banks and shopkeepers, was delighted. 
 The Petrol Retailers Association also welcomed the scope to slap a surcharge on credit card bills. 
 But most banks reacted with dismay, predicting that the measure would be inflationary, and lead to a rise in crime as people were encouraged to carry more cash. 
 A Monopolies and Mergers Commission inquiry into credit cards recommended the abolition of the &bquo;no discrimination&equo; clause in agreements between banks and their retailers when it reported in the summer. 
 Retailers have to pay between 1 and 4 per cent of all credit card transactions to their bank. 
 It averages 1.8 per cent. 
 The government squashed a previous recommendation to abolish the &bquo;no discrimination&equo; clause, made by an earlier inquiry in 1980. 
 But this time Mr Ridley has concluded that the &bquo;no-discrimination&equo; rule is anti-competitive. 
 &bquo;It restricts the freedom of retailers to set their own prices. 
 The effect of ending the rule will be to give retailers freedom to choose whether or not to charge the same, whether payment is made by credit card or cash.&equo; 
 Large stores are unlikely to dual-price. 
 Marks&amp;Spencer and Storehouse, representing BhS, Habitat, Richard Shops and MotherCare, have already confirmed that they will not be introducing dual pricing. 
 But smaller shops, restaurants, jewellers and petrol stations are likely to be attracted by the prospect. 
 Shops will have to clearly display signs warning customers that those paying by credit cards may have to pay more. 
 However, it is not yet clear whether the new regulations, will call for the individual dual pricing of all goods in the shop, or whether a simple surcharge could be added to the bill. 
 Mr Ridley has called on the banks to publish greater details of their various charges to retailers, to encourage competition. 
 Baker names research chief. 
 MR Kenneth Baker, the Conservative Party chairman, yesterday named Mr Andrew Lansley as the new director of the party's research department, writes Alan Travis. 
 The post has been vacant for months and the lack of suitable candidates puzzled officials as the job proved the starting point for such politicians as Mr Chris Patten, Mr Iain Macleod and Mr Reginald Maudling. 
 Mr Lansley, who is at present policy director of the Assocication of British Chambers of Commerce, was Mr Norman Tebbit's private secretary when he was party chairman. 
 Mr Baker also said three MPs would act as campaign co-ordinators in London, Birmingham and Leeds for next May's council elections. 
 Hungarian budget clears the way for Western aid. 
 By Ian Traynor in Budapest 
 THE Hungarian Parliament yesterday endorsed Prime Minister Miklos Nemeth's austerity budget aimed at hastening the transition from a centrally planned to a market economy and clearing the way for economic aid from the West. 
 The budget had been the topic of fierce argument, but in the end it was passed by a huge majority, satisfying the Prime Minister, who proclaimed himself a happy man after having threatened to resign if he did not get his way. 
 The package of fiscal policies aimed to cut the budget deficit from its current level of about 50 billion forints (&pound;500 million) to 10 billion forints. 
 &bquo;The measures are very, very tough,&equo; said the Finance Minister, Mr Laszlo Bekesi. 
 But he insisted that there was no alternative if Hungary was to gain the confidence of the international credit institutions and seek to heal the economic crisis. 
 In order to release &dollar;350 million in stand-by credits and clear the way for the injection of &dollar;1 billion in European Community funds, the International Monetary Fund originally demanded that the budget deficit be wiped out altogether and that public spending be subjected to even more stringent cuts than are planned. 
 The result was the compromise accepted yesterday. 
 Mr Bekesi said that unless the government moved swiftly on economic reform, the outcome would be a flourishing black market, widespread shortages, inflation much higher than its current level of about 20 per cent, and high unemployment. 
 &bquo;There is no alternative to our programme. 
 What is at stake is the complete collapse of the economy.&equo; 
 But the public remains ambivalent about the Prime Minister's free-market policies and there are rumblings of union discontent and sporadic strikes. 
 As the country seeks to manage the transition from Communist state to parliamentary democracy, complaints are growing that the &bquo;proletarian dictatorship&equo; is being replaced by the &bquo;neo-monetarist dictatorship&equo;. 
 Parliament yesterday confounded widespread predictions that it would wind itself up ahead of the Warsaw Pact's first free elections scheduled for the spring. 
 The favourite date for the poll is March 25, but a note of confusion was sown when parliament decided it would continue sitting until March 16. 
 The timing of the elections is entirely at the discretion of interim president, Mr Matyas Szueros. 
 He is expected to announce a March poll soon, but the elections could be delayed until June. 
 Under the current electoral law, parliament could have dissolved itself immediately and carried on until the election in a caretaker role. 
 However, Mr Jeno Horvath, a member of parliament and legal expert, said parliament had a lot of unfinished business and had decided the public might be confused to see it dissolved but continuing to function. 
 It will be the first completely free election in East Europe in more than 40 years. 
 Adamec becomes head of demoralised Czech party. 
 By Michael Simmons 
 CZECHOSLOVAKIA'S Communist Party, in its latest round of musical chairs, has appointed Mr Ladislav Adamec, the man who so angrily relinquished the prime ministership two weeks ago, as its new leader. 
 He replaces Mr Karel Urbanek, the former railway worker, appointed last month and discredited almost before he had started. 
 Mr Urbanek said the party was &bquo;in a deep crisis&equo; and that he himself was partly responsible. 
 Mr Vasil Mohorita, still in his 30s and the youngest member of the reshuffled politburo, becomes first secretary of the party. 
 He will have the onerous task of reviving low morale. 
 Mr Adamec failed to form a consensus government after the November revolution, and conceded after being elected that he did not have an easy task. 
 &bquo;I cannot be suspected by anyone of seeking prestige,&equo; he said. 
 The party appointments came after the leadership had authorised a statement formally apologising to the Czechoslovak people for leading the country into its latest crisis, before they were hustled out of the building because the cleaners wanted to go home. 
 Television workers refused to broadcast conference proceedings live. 
 &bquo;The party apologises to the working people, artists, the intelligentsia and young people for its past policies,&equo; said a statement read on television. 
 It expressed regret for the violence, presumably approved by the leadership of Mr Milos Jakes, with which riot police suppressed the student demonstrations on November 17. 
 &bquo;The party wishes to become the joint guarantor of our rights to a free and dignified life and for the fulfilment of your hopes,&equo; the statement added. 
 As a signal of its goodwill &mdash; reluctantly agreed to by some members, but a signal nevertheless &mdash; the party acceded to popular pressure to disband its own private army, the People's Militia. 
 The decision takes immediate effect and will remove for many workers the threat of reprisal from aggrieved party officials. 
 The militia was much in evidence last January during a week of demonstrations in the centre of Prague in memory of Jan Palach, the student who had burned himself to death in public protest 20 years before. 
 The militia also threatened factory workers not to become involved in last month's decisive general strike against Communist rule. 
 Meanwhile, the new Prime Minister, Mr Marian Calfa, has secured agreement from President Gorbachev to start bilateral talks as soon as possible for the withdrawal of Soviet troops from Czechoslovak soil. 
 Bush comes under pressure to talk terms with Noriega. 
 By Our Correspondent in Washington 
 STUNNED by the loyalty General Noriega has been able to inspire among his troops and fearful for the fate of US hostages, the Bush Administration is under growing pressure to reach a deal with the former dictator of Panama. 
 Although President Bush has been opposed to any such deal, Miami lawyers acting for Gen Noriega and leading US senators have been exploring the possibility of an agreement that could lead to a ceasefire and freedom for the American hostages. 
 The million-dollar bounty placed on Gen Noriega's head testifies to the growing American frustration at his ability to evade the US's clutches. 
 Gen Noriega was able to broadcast to the people and organise resistance over the main national radio network, until a special US assault team blew up the transmitters late on Wednesday. 
 US Intelligence was surprised by the readiness of some Panamanians to fight and die for their leader, forcing the US troops besieging barracks at Fort Amador to bring in 105mm howitzers to blast away pockets of mortar and sniper fire. 
 There are now fears that unless he is persuaded to surrender with guarantees of safe conduct, Gen Noriega could organise a prolonged resistance, and seek assistance from Nicaragua and Cuba. 
 Up to 400 Cuban military advisers are reported to be at fortified bases in northern Panama, where they have been training the the militia of the Dignity Battalions, the Washington Times said yesterday. 
 &bquo;If Noriega gets into the northern redoubts, there are caches of arms and ammunition and he will have access to his bank accounts. 
 If the Cubans and Nicaraguans become his primary support groups, it will be a very bad situation,&equo; Mr Andy Messing, a former US Special Forces officer who trained in Panama, said yesterday. 
 Despite declarations that there would be no deal, officials yesterday grudgingly confirmed a Washington Post account of negotiations between Gen Noriega's lawyers and the State Department, begun before and continued after the abortive coup in October. 
 Mr Frank Rubino, a Miami lawyer, negotiated with Mr Michael Kozak, the Deputy Assistant Secretary of State for Inter-American Affairs, and with Mr Robert Muller, described as a senior staff adviser in the office of the Attorney-General After demanding that Gen Noriega simply step down, the US officials then relaxed their terms and suggested he relinquish positions of power in return for a US promise not to proceed with attempts to extradite him. 
 &bquo;They just wanted him out,&equo; Mr Rubino said yesterday. 
 &bquo;I told Noriega they were hot for an agreement.&equo; 
 Another of Gen Noriega's legal team, Mr Raymond Takiff, said that US reports about Gen Noriega's habits and personal life were &bquo;deeply flawed&equo;. 
 Senior White House aides and CIA officials have been telling members of the Congressional Intelligence Committees this week that Gen Noriega is drinking heavily, taking drugs, and is so nervous that he moves addresses four and five times a night. 
 &bquo;I have been 30 hours and more with him this year so far, and I have never seen him take a drink. 
 Not once. 
 Noriega does not drink. 
 He does not take drugs. 
 The most he ever offered me was an aspirin,&equo; Mr Takiff said. 
 The prospect of Gen Noriega being brought to the US to face trial on drugs charges, one purported object of the US invasion, was causing some alarm among US Intelligence officials yesterday, who feared that Gen Noriega's former links with the CIA could prove embarrassing in open court. 
 &bquo;Do we really want him on trial and talking about his past secret relationships?&equo; 
 Admiral Stansfield Turner, the former CIA director, asked yesterday. 
 The charges include accepting bribes from the Colombian cocaine cartel &mdash; the legal basis for attempts to freeze Gen Noriega's bank accounts. 
 But Admiral Turner pointed out that any mention in court of money would enable the dictator to cite in his defence secret payments from the CIA and the Drug Enforcement Agency. 
 But Gen Noriega's capacity to inspire personal loyalty, as well as the power of his purse, is well known to US Intelligence. 
 According to the CIA report on the October 3 coup bid, when the dictator was imprisoned in his bedroom, he phoned his mistress, who passed on to loyal troops his message that the uprising could be thwarted. 
 Food is short but surveillance ample in the frozen domain of Zero One Erlend Clouston explores the nightmare world of Ceausescu's Romania, where even the ashtrays are thought to have ears. 
 TO ENTER Romania is to sink into a bad dream. 
 At Brasov the vast potato fields are protected by the binoculars and semi-automatic machine-guns of soldiers perched in 15ft watchtowers. 
 In Bucharest, gangs of crawling labourers comb weeds from the cobbled forecourts of Socialist ministries. 
 In Sapinta, three miles south of the Russian border, a chambermaid begs for a packet of ground coffee to meet a doctor's bill; when the doctor arrives, he complains wearily that there is no anaesthetic in the hospitals. 
 Such indiscretions are rare; Decree 23 stipulates that it is an offence to communicate with foreigners without reporting the conversation to the police. 
 Romanians queue for hours, sometimes days, for their monthly allowance of 30 litres of petrol. 
 At the state-run Peco garages, blue-jeaned secret policemen saunter along the lines of Dacias, checking who is playing truant from work. 
 Motorists are only permitted two Sunday outings a month. 
 It is not easy to cheat; liberty is licensed by the last figure (odd or even) of your number plate. 
 The engineers at Dacia, cossetted perhaps by a 99 per cent share of the local market, offer no relief. 
 Fifteen years ago the Renault 12 lookalike needed just over six litres to cover 60 miles the current model drinks seven. 
 Crude energy controls cut deep everywhere. 
 Urban Romanians are burdened with freezing flats and murky streets. 
 The state does not spare even essential services; it is disconcerting for the Western traveller disembarking at Otopeni international airport to see technicians servicing a Tupolev by torchlight. 
 The cities are desperately short of food. 
 Policemen marshall grumbling queues whenever a load of bread or chickens jolts in from the country. 
 The people vaguely understand that the bulk of their country's agricultural output goes abroad to pay Romania's external bills. 
 They do not see the antiquated Gloria combine harvesters or the Transylvanian wheat fields bloodshot with poppies: charming to the eye, but evidence of faltering investment in machinery and decent fertilisers. 
 Agriculture is crippled, too, by the miserable conditions on the collective farms. 
 A herdsman from Sibiu, just north of the great Carpathian sickle, estimated that he earned half the urban worker's monthly wage of 1,500 lei. 
 &bquo;So when we can, we go to the factories.&equo; 
 The factories, in turn, are obliged to dispatch a resentful proletariat to help (clumsily) with the harvest. 
 Neither group will ever be well-off in Western terms: a video recorder costs 40,000 lei, a Dacia banger 70,000 lei. 
 Troublemakers higher up the salary structure are brought to heel with an invitation to contribute 500 lei to the national debt. 
 No receipt from the national debt office, no salary. 
 Failure to turn out for major party festivals (May 1, August 23) can bring harsher sanctions. 
 Many Romanians are subsidised by Western currencies brought into the country by relatives on holiday from jobs abroad. 
 On a back street, just off Bucharest's Bulevardul General Magheru, a spiral stone staircase winds up to the cramped first floor offices of Comturist. 
 Here, in an aquarium light, men and women crouch in rows of wooden tip-up seats, peering at half a dozen shuttered doorways. 
 One of these is labelled &bquo;Iran (Irak)&equo;. 
 Every ten minutes an austere blouse steps into the gloom and calls a croucher forward to the cashier's hatch. 
 Credit notes bought with francs, marks and dollars win relatives access to government caches of whisky, butter, chocolate and ground coffee. 
 Otherwise, rationing restricts Romanians to one kilo of meat a month and half a loaf of bread a day. 
 Protest is countered abroad by the Departamentul de Informatii Externe, smothered at home by the Securitate. 
 Ion Pacepa, the defecting boss of Securitate, has claimed (vaingloriously?) that 10 million state microphones are embedded in Romanian walls, television sets and ashtrays, enabling the Great Conductor, alias President Nicholae Ceausescu, to eavesdrop on most of his 21 million subjects. 
 Surveillance is not entirely electronic. 
 Pre-printed Romanian envelopes break the citizen's whereabouts down into ten components: Strada, Nr., Blocul, Scara, Etajul, Apart., Sectorul, Judetul, Codul and Localitatea. 
 The cult of precision reaches its apotheosis in the presidential code name: Zero One. 
 Up to now Romanians have rationalised their predicament in different ways. 
 Some have turned to religion, some to aesthetics. 
 In his comfortable living room a Transylvanian poet scoffed at the idea of protest: &bquo;On a barricade you burn like a flame in seconds. 
 It is more important to preserve the culture.&equo; 
 Some have preferred to close their eyes. 
 &bquo;Well, you know, the secret police have to hear what is going on,&equo; shrugged a Bucharest physicist. 
 &bquo;Maybe some people with political ideas have problems. 
 Not me.&equo; 
 But if an informer heard him denouncing the President as an idiot, what then? 
 &bquo;It would just go on my record that maybe I talked too much. 
 No prison, no shooting.&equo; 
 He laughed. 
 He had just been given permission to take a post in West Germany. 
 The physicist is lucky. 
 Few of Zero One's subjects have access to independent information on Western Europe, let alone a passport. 
 Tanker fire extinguished. 
 Salvage experts extinguished a fire on an Iranian oil tanker early yesterday and stemmed a leak that had caused a 30-mile oil slick 100 miles off Morocco, a maritime official said. 
 Mr Fernando Cano of the Spanish Merchant Marine said if the wind changed the oil could reachsouthern Portugal and Spain. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Muslim march. 
 Up to 300,000 Muslims marched on the Algiers Parliament yesterday to demonstrate against &bquo;threats to Islam&equo;. 
 Separate columns of men and women converged on the National Assembly at noon. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Marcos deal mooted. 
 US prosecutors and lawyers for Imelda Marcos, widow of the late Philippines president, have discussed a possible deal for her to plead guilty and make a full disclosure in a racketeering case in exchange for a suspended sentence, Manila's chief government lawyer said yesterday. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Condoms to Russia. 
 Two Japanese companies will build a condom factory for the Soviet Union, which has an acute shortage. 
 Japan's Mitsui and Company said yesterday that it would join Okamoto Industries to build the plant for the Soviet Ministry of Chemical and Oil Refinery Industries at Serpukhov. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Hillary remarries. 
 Sir Edmund Hillary, the first man to climb Mount Everest, has married his longtime companion June Mulgrew, in Auckland, New Zealand. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Pakistan death toll. 
 Three bullet-ridden bodies were found in Karachi yesterday, bringing the death toll to seven since the latest outbreak of ethnic violence in Pakistan began on Wednesday. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Mandela phone link. 
 South African authorities have for the first time permitted Mr Nelson Mandela to talk by telephone with exiled leaders of the African National Congress from the prison where he is held near Cape Town. 
 Mr Alfred Nzo, general secretary of the ANC, said yesterday that he spoke to Mr Mandela for the first time in 26 years. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Free meals offer. 
 About 850 &bquo;restaurants of the heart&equo; opened their doors in French cities yesterday to serve free meals to the poor over Christmas and the winter. 
 The entertainers behind the charity, Les Restaurants du Coeur, expect to serve 25 million meals before spring. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Aids &bquo;cure&equo; failure. 
 An unpublished US government study of 16 Aids patients shows that bone marrow transplantation has so far failed as a treatment. 
 Researchers claimed that transplant, combined with the drug, AZT, might have eliminated the virus in one patient. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Bus crash kills 32. 
 At least 32 people died in Australia's worst bus accident when two coaches collided head-on on the Pacific Highway on the New South Wales coast early today, police said. 
 The front of the buses appeared welded together and people were still trapped inside. 
 Police feared the death toll could rise to 35. &mdash; Reuter. 
 Obituary: Herbert Hartwell. 
 Peace from Prussia:. 
 HERBERT Hartwell was appointed a judge of the Berlin Kammergericht, the Prussian Supreme Court, at the age of 33, in spite of interrupted legal studies during war service in 1914-18 (including the Iron Cross). 
 A different kind of courage, coupled with staunch Christianity, marked his opposition to the Nazi regime during the 1930s. 
 In 1934 he joined the Confessing Church, the wing of the national (Lutheran) Church which refused to compromise with the Hitler government. 
 The next year he was dismissed under the Nuremberg Regulations. 
 A friend of Probst, H. Gruber and Pastor Martin Niemoller, Hartwell worked to aid the escape of Jews from Germany. 
 This brought him into touch with George Bell, then Bishop of Chichester, and with John Marsh, the Congregational theologian, who invited him to Oxford. 
 In August 1939 he escaped with his family on the last but one ship to leave Hamburg. 
 He took up the invitation, only to be interned on the outbreak of war. 
 George Bell secured his early release. 
 Within months he determined to be ordained, believing that the Congregationalists most closely represented the standpoint and theology of the Confessing Church. 
 Dr Nathaniel Micklem, who himself had been deeply involved with the Christian opposition in Germany, accepted him for training at Mansfield College, Oxford, for the ministry. 
 He and his children were always grateful to &bquo;Nat&equo; (whose successor as Principal was Dr Marsh) for many kindnesses over the years. 
 At Oxford he took a D.Phil. on Barth, to set alongside his Erlangen law doctorate. 
 After ordination he worked as a chaplain with German prisoners of war for the YMCA and from 1948 as secretary for German affairs with the British Council of Churches Inter Church Aid and Refugee Service, the forerunner of Christian Aid. 
 The West German Government honoured him for his notable work in promoting friendship between the two countries. 
 Robert Courtney Edwin Robertson writes: Whenever I answered the telephone in the fifties and sixties and heard the anxious voice at the other end saying &bquo;Here is Hartvell&equo; (he never quite managed that English &bquo;W&equo;), I knew that either my deadline for an article was passed or he had some exciting new book for me to review. 
 Hartwell devoted his brilliant mind and untiring energy in those years after the second world war to forging links between Christians in his adopted country and that of his birth. 
 He did this at an intellectual level, and one of his chief instruments was the German-British Fellowship. 
 Herbert Hartwell born April 20, 1894; died December 11, 1989. above is p23 international PAGE 
 Legal experts give mixed opinions on Washington's justification of action. 
 By David Savage in Washington 
 THE Bush Administration stressed four legal justifications on Wednesday for its invasion of Panama: the protection of American lives, the defence of the Panama Canal, the backing of the country's &bquo;democratically elected&equo; officials, and the pursuit of an indicted US drug criminal &mdash; namely, General Noriega. 
 International law experts say the first reason is the strongest and the last the weakest. 
 &bquo;I think they can make a much more plausible case for this than the invasion of Grenada &lsqb;in 1983&rsqb; or the Dominican Republic in the Sixties,&equo; said an American university law professor, Mr Robert Goldman. 
 President Bush had reason to use military force to protect Americans because thousands were scattered around Panama and Gen Noriega's troops had shown a willingness to harass and even kill them, Mr Goldman said. 
 By contrast, the Reagan Administration justified its invasion of Grenada by pointing to the danger faced by a small group of American medical students, a rationale that was rebutted by international law bodies. 
 Critics noted that the students could have been evacuated without US troops overthrowing Grenada's government. 
 Under the norms of international law, countries are justified in using military force abroad to defend their citizens from hostile military action. 
 But the response must be limited to the amount of force necessary to protect them. 
 The classic example of such a military move, law experts said, was the 1976 Israel raid on Entebbe. 
 Israeli commandos landed at the Ugandan air base, rescued the hostages and left, without attacking the Ugandan dictator, Idi Amin. 
 Several law experts, while agreeing on the need to defend American lives in Panama, questioned whether a full-scale invasion was justified under international law. 
 &bquo;When you have the killing of a Marine and the beating of the navy man, some response was certainly called for,&equo; said Mr Edwin Smith, a University of Southern California law professor. 
 &bquo;Whether it rises to the level of a threat to US sovereign interests is another question.&equo; 
 A Columbia University professor, Mr Oscar Schachter, said US officials must show that the attacks on Americans were more than isolated incidents. 
 &bquo;I think they need to make a much stronger factual case than they have made so far,&equo; Professor Schachter said. 
 &bquo;If you have one man killed, you are not justified in bombing cities or killing lots of others. 
 But if you can show a pattern of attacks, then you have a much stronger case. 
 I don't think we know enough at this point to make a judgment.&equo; 
 Gen Noriega and his few remaining allies would be hard-pressed to argue against the US invasion in an international legal body such as the UN, the experts said, because he declared last weekend that his forces were in &bquo;a state of war&equo; with the US. 
 &bquo;That was his biggest blunder,&equo; Mr Goldman said. 
 &bquo;He badly overplayed his hand.&equo; 
 Department of Justice officials made it clear that they still see the pursuit of Gen Noriega as a criminal case. 
 Last month, Department of Justice lawyers said that US military personnel could track down and apprehend drug traffickers abroad. 
 In the past, US law was understood to restrict the military from engaging in criminal law enforcement. 
 But administration lawyers said that limitation now applied only within the US and not beyond its borders. 
 International law experts scoffed at that justification for the invasion. 
 In a February 1988 indictment, Gen Noriega and 16 of his associates were charged with violating the Racketeering Influenced and Corrupt Organisations Act and laws barring the manufacture, importation and distribution of cocaine, along with interstate and foreign travel in aid of racketeering activities and conspiracy. 
 &mdash; Los Angeles Times 
 Mitterrand warns of rapid change. 
 By Anna Tomforde and Michael Farr 
 PRESIDENT Franois Mitterrand, the first head of state of the wartime Allies to visit East Germany, said yesterday that the existence of two sovereign German states could not be &bquo;abolished at a stroke&equo;. 
 Reflecting French anxiety over German reunification, Mr Mitterrand said the two Germanys were jointly responsible for stability in Europe. 
 &bquo;German unity depends first of all on the German people&hellip; and France will not be against it. 
 But Germany must be aware that it has to keep the balance in Europe,&equo; Mr Mitterrand said following talks with Mr Hans Modrow, the East German Prime Minister. 
 Earlier, he said on East German television that it would be &bquo;far from good, even dangerous&equo; if European borders were put into question. 
 After meeting Mr Modrow, Mr Mitterrand travelled to Leipzig in recognition of its leading role in East Germany's peaceful revolution. 
 At the Karl-Marx University, the oldest in East Germany, he held an animated and good-humoured discussion with 450 students. 
 They were interested in learning about the opportunities for French involvement in rebuilding the East German economy, but asked how Mr Mitterrand felt about Germans, as a former prisoner of war. 
 Mr Mitterrand praised the people of Leipzig for &bquo;having written the history of Europe and Germany in the last few weeks&equo;. 
 The speed of change was such that it had become difficult to keep up with developments of which perhaps &bquo;we have not yet seen the end&equo;. 
 But he appealed to the students to contain their passion and to show a measure of reason. 
 &bquo;If you want peace it is important to stay cool.&equo; 
 Later, he visited the church of St Nicolas, the starting point every Monday evening for the demonstrations which have gripped Leipzig and forced the pace of change. 
 Mr Mitterrand also had talks with one of the key figures in the reform movement, the conductor, Kurt Masur, who has urged East Germans to pause and reflect before pursuing their revolution further. 
 In Berlin last night, Mr Mitterrand had what were described as wide ranging talks with Dr Gregor Gysi, the new chairman of East Germany's Communist Party. 
 Meanwhile, preparations were under way for the opening of two pedestrian passages through the Wall, on either side of the Brandenburg Gate. 
 The bulldozers were to start work overnight, according to East German police. 
 The neo-classical Triumphal Arch, erected in 1794, has been sealed off since the Berlin Wall was built in August, 1961. 
 The formal reopening will be attended today by Chancellor Helmut Kohl and Mr Modrow as well as by the mayors of East and West Berlin. 
 The two German leaders agreed on the Christmas re-opening in Dresden earlier this week. 
 US condemns &bquo;barbaric oppression&equo;. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 ROMANIAN security troops opened fire on an unarmed crowd with machine guns just down the street from the US embassy in Bucharest, an appalled State Department spokesman announced yesterday, expressing official condemnation of Romania's &bquo;barbaric oppression&equo;. 
 &bquo;A just arrived report from the US embassy, Bucharest, states that 13 young people were killed by automatic weapons fire from government security forces during a major anti-regime demonstration, which continues now in the centre of Bucharest, about two blocks from the embassy. 
 Other fatalities may have occurred as well,&equo; Mr Richard Boucher, a State Department spokesman, anounced at yesterday's regular briefing. 
 The British Foreign Office said events in Bucharest mirrored those in Timisoara at the weekend and called on all countries to condemn &bquo;in the strongest possible terms&equo; the actions of Romania's Communist leadership. 
 Namibia close to constitution. 
 By Billy Paddock in Windhoek 
 NAMIBIA'S seven political parties in the Constituent Assembly surprised the country by announcing their agreement on a constitution with &bquo;only technical and minor amendments&equo; outstanding. 
 The Assembly's standing committee has managed to iron out all the main points of contention in less than a month, dispelling the predictions by foreign and local pundits of drawn-out negotiations. 
 This means Namibia could have a constitution by the end of January, and its independence soon after. 
 Swapo holds 41 of the Assembly's 72 seats, but observers expected its main opponent, the Democratic Turnhalle Alliance (DTA) which has 21 seats, to block a Swapo-drafted constitution. 
 The speed of reaching agreement and the lack of conflict in the standing committee indicates the lack of material dispute among the parties &mdash; all accepted Swapo's draft as a working document &mdash; and some fine footwork by Swapo behind closed doors. 
 The main areas of dispute had been an executive president, a second house of parliament, and proportional representation. 
 Swapo's wish for an executive president was opposed by all except the Namibian National Front, which holds one seat. 
 Swapo was alone in its opposition to proportional representation and a bi-cameral system. 
 A Swapo representative, Mr Harmut Ruppel, announced on Wednesday that it had agreed to this, but acknowledged that this was in exchange for an executive president. 
 The deal makes it almost certain that Mr Sam Nujoma, president of Swapo, will become the country's first president. 
 The standing committee's choice of legal experts to draw up the constitution, adopted unanimously by the assembly, was surprising. 
 All three are from South Africa: Mr Arthur Chaskalson, head of the Legal Resources Centre and chairman of the Johannesburg Bar Council; Professor Gerhard Erasmus, professor of international law at Stellenbosch University; and Professor Marius Wiechers, professor of constitutional law at the University of South Africa. 
 Professor Wiechers was the architect of the controversial Turnhalle constitution a decade ago when South Africa tried to undermine UN Resolution 435. 
 His appointment is seen as a concession to the DTA. 
 Mr Chaskalson has long been known as a human-rights lawyer defending people charged under South Africa's apartheid and terrorism laws. 
 Mr Nujoma proposed a cabinet late yesterday composed of a president and 17 cabinet ministers, including a prime minister. 
 It would be dominated by Swapo, and two minor deputy cabinet minister posts would be given to small opposition parties. 
 US hopes for speedy troop withdrawal When the shooting dies down in Panama, the Bush Administration still faces a minefield of perils in Latin America, Tom Redburn reports. 
 NOW that US forces are firmly established in Panama, what do they do next? 
 The danger facing American troops, military analysts say, is that the new civilian government headed by President Guillermo Endara may not be strong enough to rule on its own. 
 That could push the United States, with a pre-invasion force of about 13,000 troops in Panama responsible solely for protecting the canal, into the unwanted role of a long-term army of occupation. 
 &bquo;The future risks are tremendous,&equo; said Mr John Roberts, a Panama expert who served as general counsel on the Senate Armed Services Committee when the Panama Canal treaties were ratified in 1978. 
 &bquo;The worst possible scenario would be for the civilian government to remain in a weak and powerless state, forcing us to maintain a military occupation in the city,&equo; said Mr Roberts, who is dean of the law school at DePaul University in Chicago. 
 &bquo;That would be a disaster.&equo; 
 Although US officials refuse to be pinned down on how long occupying troops will be needed in Panama, they talk in terms of sooner rather than later. 
 Marine Lieutenant-General Thomas Kelly told reporters that the mopping-up operation is likely to be completed within three days. 
 Politicians agreed with that prognosis. 
 &bquo;There've been some fears expressed that we might have an occupation force in Panama,&equo; said Senate minority leader Mr Bob Dole. 
 &bquo;I don't foresee that.&equo; 
 Mr Dole's views were seconded by Senator John W. Warner, of Virginia, the top-ranking Republican on the Armed Services Committee. 
 Others, however, were less optimistic. 
 &bquo;The PDF (Panamanian Defence Forces) as an institution is rotten to the core,&equo; argued Mr Alan Sabrosky, professor of international studies at Rhodes College in Memphis, who taught for more than five years at the Army War College. 
 &bquo;For the government to survive, we may have to rebuild &lsqb;the military&rsqb; from the ground up.&equo; 
 Mr Les Aspin, the chairman of the House Armed Services Committee, warned that US military police units might be forced to stay in Panama for at least a year to help keep the peace. 
 He noted that the last MPs did not leave Grenada until 18 months after the 1983 invasion. 
 Despite fears that the continuing American presence could undermine Panamanian support for the new government, they &bquo;are going to need a police force&equo;, Mr Aspin said. 
 &bquo;The whole public safety forces of the country are being decimated. 
 Who's going to arrest and interrogate the PDF?&equo; 
 Mr Jeffrey Record, a military analyst at the Hudson Institute and a former aide to the Senate Armed Services Committee chairman, Mr Sam Nunn, said it was likely to take months to rebuild the PDF into a military institution capable of supporting rather than threatening the new civilian government. 
 &bquo;You're going to have to have a fairly visible presence there for quite a while to put the authoritarian opponents on notice that we mean business.&equo; 
 Some analysts said President Endara faces a struggle in establishing the legitimacy of his new government. 
 He carries the burden of having been sworn in just before the US operations began, and he remains in hiding under the protection of the United States. 
 &bquo;It's not a good sign that the new government doesn't have enough confidence to emerge from protective custody,&equo; Mr Roberts said. 
 Several analysts said that it would be far easier to overcome any remaining resistance if Gen Noriega were found. 
 &bquo;Obviously if Noriega is captured or killed, that would take the stuffing out of his remaining support,&equo; Mr Record said. 
 US officials say that Gen Noriega is no longer a threat. 
 He &bquo;may take to the hills and be very hard to find&equo;, said Mr John Bushnell, the US charge d'affairs at Fort Clayton outside Panama City. 
 &bquo;But he wouldn't have a significant force to actually do anything. 
 The faster US troops can turn over responsibility for keeping the peace to Panamanian forces, officials said, the better the US invasion would look to Latin Americans. 
 Sources said top administration officials told politicians in a closed briefing on Wednesday that one of their greatest worries was that a long-term American occupation would turn opinion both in Panama and throughout the region against the new government. 
 &mdash; Los Angeles Times. 
 Diplomats concerned invasion sets precedent for further intervention Latin America fears grow as troops dig in. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 LATIN American reaction to the new Bush Administration assertiveness remained unclear yesterday as troops were deployed around the US embassy in Nicaragua, and diplomats warned that the invasion of Panama was a dangerous precedent which could be used to justify further US intervention in the region. 
 Angry anti-US demonstrations in Cuba and Nicaragua intensified after reports that US troops had surrounded the Panama City embassies of the two leftwing countries. 
 US conservatives have begun arguing openly that if the Sandinista Government tries to remain in power after the scheduled election in February, the invasion of Panama could be used to justify a new wave of military intervention. 
 Latin American diplomats have been saying privately in Washington that they are appalled at the jingoistic reaction of Americans. 
 A Brazilian said it reminded him of London during the Falklands war. 
 Colombian and other diplomats at the Organisation of American States were furious at the legalistic wranglings the US delegation has been using to buy time at the OAS meetings in Washington. 
 Trying to fight off calls for a ceasefire or resolutions that could be interpreted as critical, the US used its clout with Caribbean nations to block consideration of Nicaragua's proposal on the grounds that all resolutions should be tabled with 24 hours notice. 
 This would not normally apply to emergency resolutions. 
 The Nicaraguan proposal is not inflammatory. 
 It calls for an end to the fighting, and re-asserts the OAS principles of non-interference in the internal afairs of other states and no military action against a fellow OAS member except in the case of aggression. 
 The wide US support for the invasion, extending to the liberal media, including the New York Times and the Washington Post, has startled Latin Americans. 
 But they feel torn between their loathing for General Noriega's drug-based regime, and their alarm at the cavalier flouting of the OAS principle of non-intervention. 
 The legal cloak given to the US action by the formal request for US assistance by the new government of President Guillerm Endara is not convincing, since the government was sworn in on a US military base with a US general standing by. 
 Peru angrily cancelled its participation in February's scheduled US-Colombian anti-drugs summit, after denouncing the invasion. 
 After an initially cautious response, provoked by Gen Noriega's unsavoury reputation, opinion seems to be hardening against the US invasion. 
 Costa Rica and Venezuela issued cautious statements criticising the use of force, and despite phone calls from Mr Bush and the Secretary of State, Mr James Baker, there were signs Brazil and Argentina were preparing critical statements. 
 The US maintains that it supports the OAS charter, that it is acting to protect the integrity of the Panama Canal treaties, and that Latin America has no cause to fear that the invasion of Panama will be used as a precedent. 
 The Noriega government was a special case, and even then the Bush and Reagan administrations showed restraint for years before moving in to protect US lives. 
 But there is clearly a newly assertive policy being followed in the White House, and the early exuberance of US politicians when the invasion seemed to be going well has provoked fears that President Bush might be tempted to apply military solutions to Nicaragua and to the war on drugs. 
 US State Department experts on Latin America fear that the longer the military resistance against the US troops continues in Panama, the more the Latin Americans are likely to be driven by their own domestic public opinion to voice protests at the US action. 
 Britain stands alone in EC for defending invasion. 
 By John Palmer in Brussels 
 TWO days after the US invasion of Panama, Britain is still the only member of the European Community to have given public support to the action. 
 Yesterday, the European Commission and the political secretariat of the EC Council of Ministers continued to refuse to comment officially on President Bush's decision to send forces into Panama to overthrow the Noriega regime. 
 Not a single other EC government had yesterday come out in support of the American President's decision. 
 Apart from Mrs Thatcher's unqualified declaration of support, the only other comment on the events in Panama has come from the Spanish Prime Minister, Mr Felipe Gonzalez, who told the Cortes in Madrid that his government &bquo;condemned outright all foreign intervention&equo;. 
 None of the other EC members have any sympathy for General Noriega or seriously doubt that the results of last year's general election were in favour of the Panamanian opposition. 
 But in most EC capitals yesterday there was barely disguised embarrassment at the timing of the American military action, which is seen as diverting attention from the repression by the Ceaucescu regime in Romania. 
 &bquo;The Commission has nothing to say on this subject; it is something which will have first to be discussed by the member states of the Community in political co-operation,&equo; a Commission spokesman said yesterday. 
 However, officials working on EC foreign policy co-operation discouraged any suggestion that either a statement or a special meeting to consider Panama was likely in the near future. 
 Quite apart from their own reservations about the wisdom of the American action in Panama, most EC governments believe it would be impossible to find the form of words which could be agreed by the British Government and by Spain and other critics of the US intervention. 
 Privately, however, some European diplomats conceded that a failure to issue any public statement on Panama would weaken the credibility of EC efforts to develop a united foreign policy. 
 &bquo;Most of us just hope this will be over as quickly as possible and that the Americans go home,&equo; a diplomat said. 
 &bquo;The longer they remain, the greater the chances of disaster. 
 &bquo;What is most worrying about this kind of action is that it could complicate matters if someone else were to decide to intervene, say in Romania. 
 What could we say then?&equo; 
 In contrast to its silence over Panama, the Commission confirmed yesterday that it would be ending all contact with Romania, following the bloody repression of protests throughout the country. 
 It also said that it would cancel a planned meeting with the Bucharest Government to discuss the future of the EC's co-operation agreement with Romania. 
 But the Community will provide emergency economic aid to refugees from the Ceaucescu regime, notably those who have gone to Hungary. 
 West Germany seeks UN security council meeting. 
 By Agencies 
 WEST Germany has asked the UN Security Council to meet to discuss the situation in Romania. 
 A Foreign Ministry statement said yesterday that Bonn made the request after the Foreign Minister, Mr Hans-Dietrich Genscher, telephoned his opposite numbers in the US, Britain, Italy and Hungary. 
 &bquo;The Federal Government has requested in New York that the United Nations Security Council discuss the worrying developments in Romania,&equo; the statement said. 
 European governments yesterday formed a united front to condemn the continued repression, and President Franois Mitterrand said President Nicolae Ceausescu's &bquo;days are numbered&equo;. 
 At the end of the current round of the East-West conventional arms talks in Vienna, a diplomat expressed concern that the unrest in Romania might jeopardise negotiations. 
 &bquo;It is feared that Hungary and Romania will no longer sit on the same side of the negotiation table in Vienna,&equo; he said. 
 The Soviet Union officially reacted with caution. 
 &bquo;If we do receive information on victims among people we will of course be extremely sorry for them,&equo; said the Soviet Foreign Ministry spokesman, Mr Vadim Perfiliev. 
 &bquo;We should emphasise that we do have opinions on what is happening, but in my place as an official representative of the Ministry of Foreign Affairs I cannot go into comments without having all-inclusive information and orders in that regard.&equo; 
 In East Berlin, President Mitterrand was more blunt. 
 &bquo;It is a regime of personal, family power that has no honest reason to remain,&equo; he told reporters. 
 &bquo;I think that the days of this regime, in a Europe in full movement, are numbered. 
 But at what price?&equo; 
 In Bonn, Chancellor Helmut Kohl was said to be &bquo;deeply shocked over the brutal repression of the justified and peaceful protests&equo;. 
 In London, the Foreign Office said that Common Market countries were considering a withdrawal of ambassadors from Romania. 
 But he stressed that this was only one of a number of options. 
 Italy announced it had recalled its ambassador to Romania for consultations, as did East Germany, condemning the &bquo;brutal action of the Romanian state power against peaceful citizens demonstrating to assert their elementary human rights&equo;. 
 Thousands of East German troops urged their comrades in the Romanian forces not to fire on their fellow citizens peacefully demanding their human rights. 
 Demonstrators picketing the Romanian embassy in East Berlin urged the people of other East European capitals to hold simultaneous rallies on Saturday afternoon &bquo;against the bloody terror of the corrupt Romanian dictator&equo;. 
 Czechoslovakia summoned a senior Romanian diplomat to receive a protest from the Foreign Ministry in Prague. 
 Street protests demonstrate strength of feeling against the President Romanians launch first opposition body in 25 years. 
 By Michael Simmons 
 THE Committee for Socialist Democracy, which has just been formed in riot-torn Timisoara, is the first sign of organised and coherent opposition in Romania since President Ceausescu became Communist Party leader almost 25 years ago. 
 According to the Yugoslav news agency, Tanjug, which still has one of the few non-Romanian journalists operating out of the country, the committee consists of lawyers, artists, and workers, but there is still no sign of a leader or a programme. 
 The thousands of Romanians demonstrating in the streets show how widespread is the opposition to the personality and policies of President Ceausescu. 
 Until now they have represented a mass of public opinion which is noisy rather than articulate, and more remarkable for its courage than its ability to coalesce as an organised force. 
 There is no national group comparable to East Germany's New Forum waiting in the wings or person, with or without charisma, who seems likely to emerge as a de facto leader in the way that Lech Walesa emerged in Poland or Vaclav Havel did in Czechoslovakia. 
 Partly because the machinery of repression has been so all-embracing for so long, stifling any messages of opposition before they reached a platform, and partly because Romania has for so long been cut off from the mainstream of European thinking and political change, constructive ideas have been hard to come by. 
 Strict censorship, and a security service which keeps a register of all privately owned typewriters in the country, means that the source of locally produced printed material can quickly be identified and there is precious little chance of such material being widely circulated. 
 Any printed material discovered which might be construed as dissent, or likely to encourage dissent, has routinely been seized and those in possession imprisoned. 
 Vocal opposition, such as it is, has come from people who are retired from public life, who have been purged or pushed to one side by the Ceausescu leadership, or who have been forced to make do with a moral posture on key issues, registering their dissent, but no more. 
 Most notable in the first category have been six veterans of the Romanian Communist Party who at the beginning of the year addressed an open letter of defiance to President Ceausescu, telling him that &bquo;the very idea of socialism for which we have fought is discredited by your policies&equo;. 
 The most distinguished of the signatories was Mr Corneliu Manescu, former Romanian foreign minister and president of the UN General Assembly. 
 Another was Professor Silviu Brucan, Romanian envoy at the UN and chief editor of the party newspaper, Scinteia. 
 Two others, Mr Constantin Pirvulescu and Mr Gheorghe Apostol, both held senior positions in the party during the Ceausescu era, which dates from the mid-Sixties. 
 While their challenge was clearly the most serious to have been presented to President Ceausescu, and was made with the full knowledge of important facts, it was also made by people who have long since left the political scene, mainly having retired, or been retired &mdash; prematurely &mdash; by Mr Ceausescu. 
 An individual of note is Mr Ion Iliescu who fell out of favour with the leadership in the early Eighties. 
 He is seen as a reforming Communist and was, for a while, in charge of the youth section of the party and a provincial Communist Party leader. 
 His opposition while in office was such that he was ousted &mdash; to run a technical publishing house &mdash; but he is still in his early fifties and may yet have a political future. 
 There are dozens of ministers, some highly qualified, who have been purged from the leadership by Mr Ceausescu, usually because they disagreed with him on particular issues or because their superior intelligence made him insecure. 
 Outside the country one of the most distinguished Romanians is Mr Mihai Botez, professor of mathematics at Stanford University, California. 
 If ever emigres were to be welcomed back, as is suddenly the case in Czechoslovakia, he could have an important role in economic planning. 
 Others who have had the courage to stand up and be counted include Miss Doina Cornea, a former professor of French, now on hunger strike in the ethnic Hungarian city of Cluj; Mr Gabriel Andreescu, a geophysicist in Bucharest; and Mr Mirca Dinescu, a poet, also in Bucharest. 
 Punjab worries ease as Sikh drops plea for homeland Singh's National Front endorsed by acclaim. 
 By Derek Brown in New Delhi 
 INDIA'S twenty-day-old minority government easily passed its first big political test yesterday, securing a parliamentary confidence vote by acclaim. 
 The ruling National Front coalition, with only just over a quarter of the seats in the lower house of parliament, the Lok Sabha, was supported by the rightwing Bharatiya Janata Party and the Communist-led Left Front. 
 When the National Front leader, Mr Vishwanath Pratap Singh, was invited to form a government on December 1, he was told by President Ramaswamy Venkataraman to secure a vote of confidence within 30 days. 
 Some observers then thought he might not even survive that long. 
 But in the event, the government's early performance has delighted even its own supporters. 
 The Congress Party, the biggest single group in the house, but now in opposition for only the second time since independence in 1947, had no option but to sit in silence when the voice-vote was called. 
 A single, unidentified, MP called out a no vote. 
 The effortless victory followed an occasionally rowdy five-hour debate in which Congress speakers taunted the new government for its dependence on other parties, and for alleged inability to spell out its policies. 
 Mr A.R. 
 Antulay, a senior Congress member, described the administration of the Prime Minister, Mr Vishwanath Pratap Singh, as &bquo;two headed and three legged&equo;. 
 It had not been able to clarify its position on vital issues such as Punjab violence and communalism. 
 The unity of India was imperilled, he said, by a government which was &bquo;at the mercy of the rightists and the charity of the leftists&equo; and which held power only by the magnanimity of the Congress leader, Mr Rajiv Gandhi, who did not try to form a government. 
 He told the Prime Minister: &bquo;We have handed over to you a united country. 
 I hope you are not presiding over its liquidation.&equo; 
 However, the majority mood of the house yesterday was running strongly for Mr V.P. Singh. 
 In an encouraging sign for his hopes of achieving an early solution to the tangled and bloody problems of Punjab state, even the small group of Akali Dal members supported the confidence motion. 
 The Akali Dal, or rather the faction of the much splintered Sikh movement which swept the November poll in Punjab, was formerly in the forefront of the campaign for a separate homeland. 
 But yesterday one of the group's leading members, Mrs Rajender Kaur, stated firmly that Sikhs did not want Khalistan, their own state. 
 Rather, they wanted justice and honour. 
 She accused the Congress government of treating the whole Sikh community as extremists, and authorising untold atrocities. 
 Mr V.P. Singh said his immediate priority was to deal with separatist and secessionist violence in the Punjab, Jammu and Kashmir. 
 Soviet deputies moderate pace of economic change Ryzhkov takes safe route to reforms. 
 By Jonathan Steele in Moscow 
 BORIS Yeltsin chose the best word to describe the economic recovery plan which the Congress of People's Deputies passed this week. 
 Is this &bquo;hybrid&equo; viable? he asked. 
 The question was well put because the Prime Minister, Mr Nikolai Ryzhkov, is proposing an extraordinary six-year programme, which aims to switch the giant Soviet economy towards market principles only after further tightening of administrative methods. 
 It is like a leap into the past in order to emerge into the future. 
 Had this apparently contradictory programme been worked out over a long period, it might have seemed more logical. 
 But it contains the hallmarks of a last-minute compromise with conservative critics of the market system. 
 The signs of retreat in the Ryzhkov formula are only too apparent compared with the plan put forward by his deputy, Mr Leonid Abalkin, only a month ago. 
 The &bquo;hybrid&equo; looks less like a controlled experiment than a hasty effort to balance political opposites. 
 Parliament is united on what is wrong with the Soviet economy. 
 Growth has been slowing; inflation is up. 
 The government has been spending beyond its means, with a budget deficit last year of 120 billion roubles (&pound;120 billion at the official rate), or 10 per cent of GNP. 
 Some form of short-term stabilisation programme is needed to eliminate shortages of goods, and soak up people's cash. 
 There is also agreement that a switch to market incentives is necessary after that. 
 The argument centres on what kind of stabilisation plan to introduce, the pace of reforms, and whether the two programmes can be combined. 
 Can you deal with inflation while bringing in the market, or should you deal with the first problem first? 
 The government's solution relies on a sharp switch from long-term capital investment and the defence sector towards food and consumer goods production and improving social services. 
 Many construction projects are already being stopped. 
 Over the next two to three years, between 89 and 90 per cent of national income will be allocated for current consumption to cut the budget deficit to 92 billion roubles this year, and 60 billion roubles in 1990. 
 The government has also drafted a set of measures to restrain the growth of individual cash incomes so as to reduce demand for goods. 
 It also intends to tax enterprises which increase wages by more than 3 per cent. 
 The Prime Minister told parliament that he was against freezing savings accounts or monetary reform which would devalue the internal rouble and cut the value of individuals' savings. 
 Mr Yeltsin has supported such reforms while trade unions have suggested that all savings accounts above a certain level should be wiped out. 
 Mr Ryzhkov also ruled out rationing of food and basic goods with other products available on the free market, saying rationing was a return to centralised administration, and contradicted the notion of reform. 
 &bquo;It would be difficult to introduce a rationing system but even more difficult to get rid of it. 
 It would be a major step backwards with great adverse effects,&equo; Mr Ryzhkov said. 
 However, his own plans rely on strengthening the central system. 
 Mr Abalkin, outlined three possible reform variants. 
 The first, &bquo;conservative&equo; option proposes a gradual switch to market principles over an unspecified number of years. 
 There would be prize freezes, limits on co-operatives, and controls to prevent producers from cutting back on low-priced goods in favour of more profitable lines to control inflation. 
 The consumer market would be saturated with goods. 
 Enterprise managers would be free to make their own deals with suppliers, but there would be no change in the basic concept of state ownership of industry. 
 Mr Abalkin rejected this as too slow; instead of giving the old system time to adjust, it would allow &bquo;opposing forces time to consolidate&equo;. 
 His second &bquo;radical&equo; option called for far-reaching cuts in state investment and price subsidies, transformation of state-run enterprises into joint-stock companies, co-operatives and private companies. 
 Mr Abalkin rejected this also, saying that the distortions in the economy are too great to allow it to work properly. 
 Many companies would go bankrupt and others would prosper unfairly by raising prices rather than output. 
 Social tension would reach explosion point, making it easier for conservatives to restore administrative methods. 
 The third and favoured &bquo;radical-moderate&equo; option is an eight-point plan calling for a consistent denationalisation of property; reliance on new tax and credit levers to curb excess profits, encourage resource conservation, and direct investment for consumer goods production; a system of fixed, floating, and free prices; and creation of a financial market. 
 Mr Ryzhkov's plan, which the conservative-dominated parliament has accepted, is striking in its moderation. 
 Sixty-five per cent of the economy will remain in state hands in six years' time and workers will no longer elect managers. 
 While the Abalkin plan had tight deadlines for closing down or leasing unprofitable state enterprises, (industry by the beginning of 1991, state and collective farms by 1992), Mr Ryzhkov gave no cut-off date. 
 Instead, he protected less profitable state farms by writing off their debts and delaying the implementation of a new procurement pricing system. 
 The Ryzhkov plan is also cautious on foreign loans and investment. 
 While Mr Abalkin spoke eagerly of bringing the Soviet economy more in line with the international market, Mr Ryzhkov warned that increasing loans could increase economic and political dependence. 
 Instead, he promised a halving of imports of rolled steel products, chemicals, pipes and paper, which the Soviet Union could produce itself. 
 It is no surprise that parliament should have approved a conservative plan. 
 Most of its members represent the old party and management apparatus. 
 Even if they were willing to see their own power reduced, radical reform is a jump into the unknown. 
 However bad the situation, the majority is unwilling to risk change. 
 Investigation hampered by lack of conclusive evidence Airport security criticised Town's muted anger on anniversary Bomb suspect convicted of terrorism. 
 By David Sharrock in Uppsala 
 TWELVE months after PanAm 103 crashed into Lockerbie killing 270 people, the first suspect to be officially identified was yesterday convicted of terrorism. 
 Mohamed Abu Talb will serve his sentence in a Swedish jail with three accomplices for a terrorism campaign carried out in 1985 and 1986 against American and Israeli targets in Copenhagen, Amsterdam and Stockholm. 
 One person died and 26 were injured in the attacks. 
 The four men &mdash; Talb, aged 35, Marten Imandi, and two brothers, Mustafa and Mahmoud Mougrabi &mdash; were known to the intelligence services, who linked them with a Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine &mdash; General Command (PFLP-GC) cell working in Frankfurt and Neuss. 
 Talb's record stands out for attention, even if evidence of direct involvement in the PanAm bombing for the moment appears to be largely circumstantial. 
 He received military training in the Soviet Union and Egypt in the 1970s, fought the Israelis in Lebanon in 1982 and first entered Sweden the following year after obtaining a visa through its Damascus embassy. 
 Dogged police work by the Lockerbie investigation team, allied with the forensic skill of the Royal Armaments Research and Development Establishment at Fort Halstead, Kent, established that the bomb had most likely been loaded in a suitcase at Malta before being transferred to PanAm 103 at Frankfurt. 
 While the Lockerbie investigation proceeded, Talb was in a Swedish prison awaiting trial for the 1985/6 bombings. 
 On May 18 of this year, Talb's former wife, Jamila Mougrabi, revealed during interrogation by Swedish police that her husband was in Malta in October 1988. 
 In a police statement she said: &bquo;On Malta he visited a friend who owns a bakery and a brother whose name is Abdes Salam. 
 He owns a clothing company where Abu Talb bought clothes.&equo; 
 Three weeks ago Swedish and Scottish police searched Talb's flat in Uppsala, removing 15 bags of clothing. 
 It is believed that the Maltese shop owner, who recalled selling a bundle of assorted clothing which was in the bomb-carrying suitcase, has inspected the bags. 
 Two months before PanAm 103 was blown up, West German federal police raided the PFLP-GC cell in Neuss and Frankfurt. 
 Operation Autumn Leaves uncovered a large quantity of guns, ammunition, Semtex explosive and a bomb-making factory. 
 Sixteen arrests were made, but only two men were detained. 
 One of those was Hafez Dalkammoni, believed to be the cell's leader, who is now awaiting trial on arms offences. 
 Scottish police believe the men to be heavily implicated in the Lockerbie bombing. 
 Talb and Dalkammoni visited Malta together in October 1988 and met members of a PFLP-GC cell on the island. 
 Another of Dalkammoni's associates who was arrested during Operation Autumn Leaves was Marwan Khreesat, known to be an expert bomb-maker. 
 Khreesat was freed within days of his arrest for lack of evidence. 
 Police discovered a radio-cassette converted into a bomb hidden in one of the group's cars. 
 The bomb had a barometric trigger of the kind that had been used to bomb aircraft before. 
 The intelligence source which had originally tipped off West German police about the group's activities claimed that five bombs had been made. 
 Two were recovered in the raids. 
 Another two were found in the shop of a man called Hasham Abassi, Dalkammoni's brother-in-law, two months after the PanAm bombing. 
 Circumstantial evidence suggested that the fifth bomb was loaded at Malta and transferred onto PanAm 103 at Frankfurt. 
 The evidence gathered by Scottish, Swedish and West German police still refuses to cohere. 
 The West Germans believe that the PFLP-GC was not involved in the bombing, even though Talb's links with it appear to be a matter of record. 
 Ahmed Jibril, PFLP-GC's leader, also denies itsinvolvement. 
 Talb is believed to be a member of the Palestinian Popular Salvation Front, a PLO group. 
 The Lockerbie team hope of speaking directly with Talb was dashed earlier this week when he refused to co-operate. 
 Scotland's senior law officer, Lord Fraser has said he does not intend &bquo;at present&equo; to seek the extradition of Abu Talb from Sweden. 
 Mohamed Abu Talb&hellip; refused to co-operate 
 Judge rules out ad inserts. 
 MAIL Newspapers yesterday won a High Court ruling to prevent unauthorised advertising material being inserted between the pages of its two national newspapers and Sunday colour magazine. 
 Mr Justice Mummery ruled in favour of the publisher and owner of the Daily Mail, the Mail on Sunday and You magazine in an action against Mr Christopher Arnold, a businessman. 
 He said Mail Newspapers would probably &bquo;suffer damage to their goodwill and reputation in consequence of Mr Arnold's proposed activities&equo;. 
 The judge said an &bquo;insert boom&equo; was spreading to Britain from the United States and Europe. 
 He ruled that placing advertising inserts in Mail Newspapers's publications without the company's authority or consent &bquo;constitutes or involves the making of a misrepresentation&equo;. 
 &bquo;Mail Newspapers and other newspaper proprietors clearly attach a great deal of importance to maintaining their goodwill and reputation with their readers by exercising careful control over who can advertise in their newspapers and what kinds of advertisements appear there,&equo; the judge said. 
 If Mr Arnold was allowed to go ahead, Mail Newspapers would have &bquo;no control whatsoever on who advertises or on the type of advertisement inserted&equo;. 
 Council rents will span wider band. 
 By Alan Travis Political Correspondent 
 RENTS for council housing in 66 local authority areas will rise by &pound;4.50 a week or at least 20 per cent next April, according to figures released by the Department of Environment yesterday. 
 These sharp increases will contrast with below-inflation rent rises of 95 pence a week in about 156 local authority areas, as the Government for the first time moves away from a single national rents policy for the 4.5 million council tenants in England. 
 Mr Michael Howard, the Housing Minister, said that the rent guidelines, published yesterday, assumed there would be a national increase of 10 per cent in gross rent income. 
 &bquo;That produces an average guideline increase of &pound;2.08 a week, compared with &pound;1.95 last year. 
 &bquo;However, unlike previous years, the determinations this year provide for different guideline rent increases in different authorities.&equo; 
 It would move councils towards a &bquo;sensible pattern of rents&equo;, in which they would generally be lower in parts of the country where the value of houses and flats was lower, and higher where the values were relatively high. 
 The highest rise of 27 per cent will be in Salisbury, where a &pound;4.50 increase will bring rents up to &pound;20.50 a week. 
 But weekly rents will now vary widely, from &pound;43.24 a week in Kensington and Chelsea to &pound;14.70 a week in Ellesmere Port. 
 Under the 1988 Housing Act, local authorities will have to increase their rents further if they allow arrears and fail to achieve 100 per cent rent collection. 
 Along with other changes to the &pound;3 billion a year housing subsidy system, the Government yesterday also published the annual housing investment programme allocations for local authorities. 
 For the first time, the level of proceeds from council house sales accrued by each local authority has been taken into account in deciding the distribution of this year's &pound;1,784 million of borrowing permissions and capital grants. 
 The Government says it will use the new system to allocate resources to those councils with the worst housing problems. 
 The Department of Environment also announced yesterday that it had abandoned the system it has used for most of the past 10 years to channel extra housing cash into the 57 worst affected inner-city areas. 
 Mr Howard said that the system was not only obscure but also ineffective. 
 Instead, the Housing Minister announced a &pound;100 million allocation specifically for the target areas. 
 Tebbit tosses grenade on immigration. 
 Alan Travis cautions against parallels with Powell's &bquo;river of blood&equo; campaign. 
 &bquo;ENOCH Powell once advised me: &bquo;Never go into the Chamber of the House of Commons without a verbal grenade in your pocket&equo;,&equo; Mr Norman Tebbit wrote in his biography Upwardly Mobile. 
 The former Conservative party chairman certainly ignited a powerful piece of ordnance in the Chamber on Thursday during the statement on Hong Kong. 
 In the process his demand that there be no further large scale immigration infuriated the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, who retorted: &bquo;I do not need any education on the importance of strict immigration control for entry into this country.&equo; 
 Mr Tebbit's attempt to build a backbench revolt over the question of passports for the Hong Kong Chinese has inevitably drawn comparisons with the role of Mr Enoch Powell in the 1960s. 
 As Mr Jim Lester, the MP for Broxtowe, on the left of the party, said yesterday: &bquo;I am quite sure he will get quite a lot of support. 
 It brings out the old policies of Enoch Powell way back and there are still a few Powellites in the Tory party. 
 But I don't think it is right.&equo; 
 There is an important difference between Mr Tebbit and Mr Powell. 
 The latter was essentially isolated within the Conservative parliamentary party. 
 When Mr Heath sacked him from the Shadow Cabinet in 1968 after he had paraphrased Virgil's Aeneid and with foreboding claimed to see &bquo;the River Tiber foaming with much blood&equo; he began a journey into the wilderness. 
 London dockers and the Smithfield porters were alone in marching on Westminster demanding: &bquo;Don't Knock Enoch.&equo; 
 Only periodically does Mr Tebbit seem to have looked to Powell as a politician who could express some of his gnawing doubts about the Heath government. 
 The doubts most clearly arose over the question of Idi Amin's expulsion of the Ugandan Asians in the summer of 1972. 
 Even then, the terms of the protests put forward by officials of his Chingford Conservative Association proved too strong for Norman Tebbit. 
 He told them both content and tone were unacceptable. 
 He does not reveal which way he voted in the subsequent secret ballot on the issue at the 1972 Conservative Party conference when Mr Powell's amendment was defeated by 1,721 to 736 votes. 
 But he does note that Heath's claim that it was a clear victory was based on just over half the representatives supporting the Government. 
 Mr Powell was never to regain any sizeable base among Conservative MPs but Mr Tebbit, after leaving the Cabinet, has proved again and again that when combining with Mr Michael Heseltine or other factions within the party he can rally a significant number of MPs. 
 Immigration, however, may prove to be a banner around which only the rightwing can rally. 
 Mr Tebbit has consistently made clear his opposition to large scale immigration but he has said he is in favour of &bquo;attracting immigrants who are well educated and highly skilled&hellip; regardless of race&equo;. 
 One Tory MP on the right summed up the difference: &bquo;Enoch was infinitely more interesting and distinguished than Tebbit. 
 There is a crude mateyness about Tebbit. 
 He reflects the social changes in the constituencies and the parliamentary party and because of that is much more effective.&equo; 
 Mr Powell's lofty academic style made it difficult for him to approach MPs. 
 He would ask potential supporters: &bquo;Would you like a copy of my speech of the third of August. 
 I will leave a copy on the message board for you.&equo; 
 Mr Tebbit was keen yesterday to distance himself from any comparison with Mr Powell. 
 He also said that he had never talked in terms of prospective violence nor had he suggested that &bquo;any of these people&equo; were in any way inferior to anybody else. 
 Whether he has any greater success in mounting a rebellion against Mr Heath's former political secretary, Mr Hurd, than Mr Powell had against the former Prime Minister 17 years ago remains to be seen. 
 Parkinson attacked over baggage screening delay. 
 By Michael Smith Transport Editor 
 THE TRANSPORT Secretary was attacked yesterday for failing to bring in screening of passenger baggage to be stored in aircraft holds, and for putting commercial interests ahead of tighter security. 
 Mr John Prescott, the shadow Transport Secretary, said the Department of Transport &bquo;seems as complacent as ever about its security responsibilities&equo;. 
 Mr Cecil Parkinson rejected a demand from MPs on the transport select committee for immediate screening of passenger baggage on international flights, and instead promised &bquo;a progressive extension&equo; of screening. 
 He has accepted 21 of the 28 recommendations made by the committee, but turned down demands for baggage hold examination and the introduction of a levy on fares to pay for better security. 
 Mr Parkinson promised extra security inspectors at airports, some posing as terrorists to test security. 
 Mr Prescott, who plans to table amendments to the airport security bill, said Mr Parkinson was paying lip service to screening and giving no indication when this would be achieved. 
 &bquo;The major obstacle to achieving that goal is money,&equo; Mr Prescott said. 
 &bquo;Space is always available at airports for commercial operations such as shops and bars, but the authorities are not prepared to give up some space for security.&equo; 
 He also expressed concern at private evidence submitted to the committee by American airlines that the US Federal Aviation Administration was waiving its requirement that all hold baggage should be examined because British airport owners would not provide the extra space. 
 The charge of putting profits before passenger protection was also made by the Transport and General Workers' Union, the aviation industry's biggest trade union, in a booklet launching its Aviation Security Charter. 
 The charter calls for a government-funded airport security system protected from the commercial pressures of privatisation and from the contracting-out of essential services. 
 It says private contractors should be banned from airports. 
 Mr George Ryde, TGWU national secretary for civil aviation, said: &bquo;Our members are involved in almost every aspect of airport work, and they tell a different story to the public relations myth that nothing is spared in providing passengers with maximum security. 
 &bquo;Their experience is that commercial pressure is threatening proper security throughout the industry.&equo; 
 The booklet, including the charter, is based on concerns expressed by transport union members in aviation at a conference organised by the TGWU in September. 
 The British Airports Authority and the Department of Transport said they could not comment until they had studied the union's findings. 
 Judge orders confiscation of smuggler's &pound;1.5m assets Drugs baron faces 15 years in solitary. 
 DRUGS baron Rene Black was jailed for 15 years yesterday for organising a &pound;15.5 million conspiracy to flood Britain with drugs from Europe's first cocaine factory. 
 His partner in the conspiracy, James Laming, who claimed during the trial to have invented a racehorse nobbling stun gun, was jailed for 14 years. 
 At Southwark crown court, Judge Gerald Butler, QC, ordered confiscation of all Black's assets, worth nearly &pound;1.5 million, with the threat of 10 more years in prison if he defaulted. 
 He also ordered that Black, said to be in fear of his life after alleged death threats by former drug associates, be deported at the end of his sentence. 
 Black, a 35-year-old Peruvian, of Cranleigh, Surrey, faces the prospect of spending his entire sentence in solitary confinement for his own safety. 
 Like Black, Laming, aged 49, a car dealer, of Peckham, south London, was expressionless as sentence was passed. 
 Judge Butler ordered that assets worth &pound;23,950 be confiscated under the 1986 Drugs Trafficking Offences Act with the threat that Laming serve a further 18 months in default. 
 A third defendant, Patrick Fraser, aged 38, of Catford, south London, was jailed for eight years for possessing 501 grams of cocaine with intent to supply. 
 The judge ordered seizure of his assets totalling &pound;36,200 or Fraser would serve a further 18 months in jail. 
 Black's father-in-law, Ronald Fisher, aged 52, was jailed for 30 months. 
 He had admitted suspecting that money he helped Black to launder at banks was the proceeds of drugs trafficking. 
 Laming, who was convicted during his trial of conspiring with Black to supply cocaine, was also sentenced to nine years to run concurrently for possessing 501 grams of cocaine. 
 Black had admitted conspiring to import, produce, and supply cocaine, and to possessing 30 kilogrammes of the drug with a street value of &pound;5 million. 
 Judge Butler said he had reduced Black's sentence &bquo;substantially&equo; because the Peruvian had co-operated with police. 
 The judge, who took just 45 minutes to decide on the sentences, said he accepted Fraser was a drug addict who had admitted what he had done. 
 But this in no way excused his crime. 
 Fraser had a previous criminal record that included convictions involving drugs. 
 He said Fisher's plea of guilty had been a mitigating factor. 
 The court had heard that Black and his brother Rudolpho, aged 32, used their fruit importing business as a front to smuggle raw cocaine from Peru to Britain. 
 The drug was refined at their laboratory in Cranleigh, with Laming acting as distributor. 
 Rudolpho is believed to be hiding in Peru. 
 Laming's defence hinged on his claims that Black was the backer for his plan to undermine racecourse betting and bookmaking in Britain with the stun gun device. 
 Laming claimed he knew nothing about the drugs ring and said Black put up &pound;10,000 towards development of the stun gun. 
 Jockey Greville Starkey was allegedly unseated by an ultrasonic stun gun as he neared the winning post on Ile de Chypre at Royal Ascot last year. 
 The court heard that the converted binoculars could fire a beam of sound over 50ft, audible only to horses. 
 The effect on a racehorse would have been like &bquo;a firework exploding in its ear&equo;. 
 Black's fortune from drug trafficking was put by the prosecution at &pound;3.55 million. 
 He and his &bquo;playboy&equo; brother, Rudolpho enjoyed a luxurious lifestyle on the profits. 
 The brothers owned two penthouses in Florida worth &dollar;250,000 and paid &pound;87,000 for a Porsche car. 
 In addition, Rene, a keen showjumper ranked fifth in Peru, spent &pound;500,000 on the sport after arriving in Britain in 1982. 
 200 children may sue over tainted blood. 
 By Clare Dyer Legal Correspondent 
 UP TO 200 haemophiliac children infected with HIV, the Aids virus, through tainted blood products, are expected to join in the compensation claim against the Government under changes to the legal aid rules which come into force next April. 
 At a private hearing at the High Court in London next month, Mr Justice Ognall is expected to extend the original February 2 deadline for joining in the legal action for children under 16. 
 Children will become eligible for legal aid in their own right in April under changes announced last month by Lord Mackay, the Lord Chancellor. 
 Under the present rules, which require parents' means to be taken into account, most infected children are unable to sue because their parents earn too much. 
 Around 1,200 haemophiliacs, including children as young as six, have become infected through contaminated blood products, mainly imported from the US, in the early 1980s. 
 The judge has also decided not to go ahead with a preliminary trial on two key issues in the case, scheduled to begin on January 15, which would have broken new legal ground. 
 Without considering the individual cases, he was to have decided whether the Government can be sued over its policy on allocation of resources. 
 Lawyers for the haemophiliacs, 600 of whom have issued writs, argue that the Government was negligent in not becoming self-sufficient in blood products sooner and in not heat-treating earlier to kill the virus. 
 The second question was whether the licensing authority, which licenses medicinal products, owes a duty of care to individuals. 
 The judge's decision means that the case will not come to court before early 1991, when the issues will be decided in the context of the individual cases. 
 Mr David Watters, secretary of the Haemophilia Society, yesterday described the decision as &bquo;a bit of a blow. 
 It could have helped clarify a number of issues at an early stage and possibly saved people a lot of money and anguish.&equo; 
 In the Court of Session in Edinburgh yesterday, Lord Morrison refused to order the Scottish National Blood Transfusion Service to hand over the name of a donor whose blood allegedly infected a 26-year-old man with HIV. 
 The man, referred to as AB, suffers from Aids-related complex (ARC), a condition stopping short of full-blown Aids. 
 He received two blood transfusions after a bone marrow transplant and wanted the name so he could sue the donor. 
 Lawyers said the action for disclosure of the name was believed to be the first of its kind in Britain. 
 AB alleges he discovered, through records obtained before he launched a &pound;200,000 legal action against the transfusion service, that the donor knew he was in a high-risk group for HIV infection. 
 Lord Morrison accepted arguments by Mr Malcolm Rifkind, the Scottish Secretary, that disclosure would endanger blood transfusion supplies because future donors would be reluctant to give blood. 
 He ruled that the public interest in ensuring enough blood outweighed the public interest in allowing AB to seek justice through the courts. 
 AB's solicitor, Mr Brian Donald, said he was considering an appeal. 
 Tebbit &bquo;aims to be leader&equo;. 
 Mr Norman Tebbit attacked Cabinet policy for Hong Kong yesterday, convincing some MPs that he was manoeuvring to succeed Mrs Thatcher when she retires. 
 Page 24. 
 Brandenburg work. 
 East German border workers with a crane and a pneumatic drill last night began demolishing the top of the Berlin Wall at the Brandenburg Gate, which opens as a new crossing point between East and West Berlin today. 
 Page 10. 
 Pollution concern. 
 Discussion of the Environmental Protection Bill will be dominated by the breaking-up of the Nature Conservancy Council and not enough attention will be given to pollution and genetically-manipulated organisms. 
 Environment, page 25. 
 Drugs baron jailed. 
 A man who planned to flood Britain with cocaine was jailed for 15 years yesterday and his assets of &pound;1.5 million were confiscated. 
 Page 5. 
 Children's claim. 
 Up to 200 children infected with HIV, the Aids virus, by tainted blood products are expected to claim compensation from the Government. 
 Page 8. 
 PanAm suspect jailed. 
 A man believed involved in the Lockerbie PanAm bombing was jailed in Sweden yesterday. 
 Report, page 24; Lockerbie one year on, page 3. &pound;50m hope. 
 The European Community is expected to authorise a &pound;50 million grant to help regenerate parts of Manchester, Salford and Trafford. 
 Page 15. 
 Indian victory. 
 India's new minority government has passed its first parliamentary test. 
 Page 13 
 Glenys Kinnock heads Third World trust in honour of victim. 
 ANEW charity backed by a host of public figures was launched yesterday in memory of Bernt Carlsson, a Swedish diplomat and United Nations Commissioner for Namibia, who was killed in the Lockerbie disaster. 
 The Bernt Carlsson Trust, which is chaired by Mrs Glenys Kinnock, wife of the Labour leader, pledges to &bquo;aid the poor and distressed in the third world&equo;. 
 Mr Carlsson was on his way to New York to sign a Namibian peace settlement when the disaster happened. 
 The trust's first action will be to launch an appeal for Namibia, which is trying to rebuild after years of war. 
 Among the charity's trustees are actor Anthony Sher, comedian Ben Elton, rock star Peter Townshend and the news presenter Anna Ford. 
 The trust aims to relieve poverty and distress in the third world, educate the public about the third world, and promote research into finding solutions to third world problems. 
 A minute's silence was held in memory of the Lockerbie victims when the charity was launched yesterday at Transport House in London, headquarters of the Transport and General Workers' Union. 
 Mrs Kinnock spoke of the &bquo;idealism and courage&equo; of Mr Carlsson, whose career was dedicated to &bquo;peace, freedom and humanity&equo;. 
 His brother, Tore, was at the launch. 
 BBC wins right to control satellite viewing fees. 
 BBC Enterprises, the corporation's commercial arm, yesterday won a crucial right to authorise and control the reception of its satellite television transmissions to Europe. 
 The BBC, which cannot collect statutory licence fees from European viewers, has been transmitting &bquo;scrambled&equo; programmes on the basis that it has a monopoly on the right to authorise the making and selling of the necessary &bquo;unscrambling&equo; decoders. 
 Yesterday's Court of Appeal ruling overturned a High Court judge's decision last month in favour of Hi-Tech Xtravision, of Camberley, Surrey, which makes and sells rival decoders and which challenged the right of BBC Enterprises to grant an exclusive decoder distributorship to Northampton-based Space Communications (Sat Tel) Ltd. 
 Allowing the BBC's appeal, the Vice-Chancellor, Sir Nicolas Browne-Wilkinson, sitting with Lords Justices Staughton and Beldam, said the 1988 Copyright Act created rights and remedies for broadcasters not against those who received the programmes, but against those who enabled viewers to receive the transmissions and thereby avoid the viewing fee. 
 The ruling means that BBC Enterprises can go ahead with its court action seeking a permanent ban on sales of decoders by Hi-Tech. 
 A further hearing of the case, to decide the viability of defences raised by Hi-Tech under European free trade laws, was adjourned until the new legal term which starts on January 11. 
 Mr Richard Aiken, counsel for BBC Enterprises, had told the court that a decision on whether to continue the BBC Europe service should have been made at the end of November but had been deferred until a meeting of the directors on December 29. 
 &bquo;They are anxious that they should not go on running a system which may in the long term be at a loss,&equo; he said. 
 Hi-Tech, which has told the court it is willing to collect the &pound;100-per-decoder viewing fee because it does not wish to &bquo;kill the goose that lays the golden egg&equo; is now restricted to fulfilling its existing orders for decoders pending the further hearing in the New Year. 
 A lawyer said Hi-Tech will seek to appeal to the Lords. 
 Troops kill US teenager in the silent suburbs *. 
 By Suzanne Dempsey in Panama 
 THE American soldiers at the roadblock in La Boca were exhausted and perplexed. 
 Their part in the campaign to liberate Panama had consisted of 34 hours in one place and had culminated in them killing an American teenager. 
 La Boca, a middle class suburb of the city, was yesterday preternaturally quiet. 
 There were no children playing, no neighbours talking, and the whole place had the deserted air of an American neighbourhood on Thanksgiving Day. 
 Close by the canal were two armoured personnel carriers and about eight US military policemen. 
 They were all tired; two were sleeping. 
 They told us they had been there since the outbreak of the war &mdash; approximately 34 hours previously. 
 Wire across the road forced drivers to slow down. 
 Very few cars passed &mdash; some with white handkerchiefs draped around their radio aerials. 
 The MPs said the only firing they had done was on two US teenagers &mdash; children of Panama Canal Commission employees. 
 The teenagers had been on their way home from a party just after the outbreak of hostilities and, according to one military policeman, had tried to crash the road block, almost running down one of the MPs. 
 We walked across to the teenagers' car, which had veered across the lawn of a local church. 
 One had been shot in the head and had later died, another had been wounded in the knee. 
 There were two bullet holes in the windscreen. 
 A shoe lay on the ground, next to the driver's side of the car. 
 There was a pool of blood in the passenger seat. 
 Further down the street, at the former Panama Defence Force police station, five Panamanian prisoners of war sat on the steep steps, bordered by hibiscus bushes. 
 They all had their hands tied behind their backs and one prisoner was in his underwear. 
 I asked the soldiers if I could take a photograph and was told: &bquo;Only if you keep moving.&equo; 
 I crossed the road to the gutted police station. 
 A cardboard nativity scene on the gravelled forecourt was all that remained standing. 
 Some US troops were examining the rubble. 
 One shouted &bquo;No photos.&equo; 
 Further into town, there were more people, many carrying white plastic bags, clearly filled with booty from looting expeditions. 
 Most of them looked dazed, but in a happy sort of way. 
 More prisoners of war sat in a car park under guard, their legs crossed and their hands tied behind their backs. 
 They looked dejected and as puzzled as some of their captors. 
 A few supermarkets and food shops were open, most with long queues of customers waiting in the intense heat, hoping to stock up on food and other necessities in case the paralysis of the city's life continues. 
 Near Albrook air base, a Panamanian passenger bus lay in a ditch. 
 Nobody seemed to know what had happened to the passengers. 
 Diary. 
 By Andrew Moncur 
 MEDICAL textbooks probably define the condition of Nicolae Ceausescu as barking. 
 The same could be said, but for different reasons, of one member of his retinue &mdash; small, big appetite, wears a black furry coat &mdash; who, rather uncomfortably, bears witness to the days of Anglo-Romanian entente. 
 I'm speaking of Gladstone. 
 He was handed over to the terribly liberal (sorry, I think that should be liberally terrible) dictator by Mr David Steel, hard-line leader of a British political grouping engaged in the notorious Lib-Lab pact, at a time when Ceausescu was still wildly popular. 
 Particularly with the Liberals, who struck up a sort of Bucharest-Ettrick Bridge accord. 
 The Queen, of course, installed Our Nicolae as a Knight of the Bath. 
 Mr Steel merely gave him a black labrador puppy. 
 The little chap is presumed alive and well &mdash; although anything's possible. 
 You know. 
 Sit! 
 Look, I won't tell you again. 
 Bang! 
 There were mutterings among Lib Dem MPs yesterday. 
 There's feeling that the Queen should withdraw the knighthood. 
 In which case, surely Mr Steel should ask for his dog back. 
 EVER stopped to think where Old Pineapple Face has stashed his ill-gotten fortune? 
 He's reckoned to have a minimum of &dollar;50 million put aside for an incredibly rainy day. 
 And the feeling in Washington is that a great pile of it is lying around (under the name of Noriega M.) at banks in London. 
 Further, there are signs that another call will be made on Mrs Thatcher, fresh from her latest triumph in her celebrated role as the Instant Megaphone, performing God Bless America. 
 Members of the Senate Intelligence Committee have been told that a formal request will be made to Britain to seize the general's dosh. 
 Can we? 
 Well, yes, theoretically, says the Home Office. 
 Under the 1986 Drug Trafficking Offences Act. 
 RATHER less will be seen in the public prints of the wit, wisdom (hold on) and waffle of Norman Tebbit. 
 He's been writing a column for the Sunday Express, occupying the space most famously enjoyed by John Junor, the laird of Auchtermuchty. 
 But, no more. 
 Out goes the Chingford Skinhead &mdash; who has a tiresome tendency to bang on about politics &mdash; and in comes a writer who takes a broader swipe, Tom Utley. 
 RIDING on horseback, with only your hairdo to conceal your parts, must have been hard enough in 11th Century Coventry. 
 At Congress House, headquarters of the 20th Century TUC, it simply isn't on at all. 
 The management has, very decently, been slapping up borrowed works of art. 
 A highly-coloured tapestry is hung. 
 Passers-by glance up and, well, pass-by. 
 Then the truth begins to dawn. 
 It's Lady Godiva and &mdash; good grief &mdash; those are naked bosoms. 
 A word to the staff office committee. 
 &bquo;There is obviously a consensus that, generally speaking, it is useful not to work in an environment with pictures of naked women,&equo; said a committee spokeswoman yesterday. 
 Oh, dear. 
 A complaint goes off to the powers. 
 Yes, it's coming down. 
 Footnote: Lady G. rode out, starkers, on behalf of the long-suffering taxpayer. 
 YOU MIGHT also like to know that the University of Minnesota has banned the use of mistletoe this year. 
 It leads to sexual harassment, you see. 
 Honestly, no man is safe at this time of year. 
 YOU HAVE to spare a thought, too, for the University of Sussex. 
 A slight misfortune in the Christmas card department. 
 The one that bears a picture of an honorary graduate. 
 Dr Andrei Sakharov. 
 UNLESS I'm mistaken, it's time for the Vicar's Competition: captions for the nineties. 
 &bquo;Nicholas Ridley (far right) hails opening of first Lada plant in Britain as beginning of renaissance of British industry.&equo; 
 (Nigel Stanley); &bquo;Sunseekers sprinting through Gatwick in attempt to catch their flight to Spain.&equo; 
 (Gloria Crick); &bquo;Prince William with fiancee Sharon at their comprehensive's disco.&equo; 
 (Colin Smith). 
 LAST word from the Foreign Office (courtesy of Westminster's House Magazine) on the fate of the boat people. 
 A spokesman: &bquo;I have nothing new to say, except to say that when I do have something to say I will say it.&equo; 
 Thank you. 
 EVIL empires may crumble, invasions might occur. 
 But through it all comes Douglas Hurd of the F.O. Finding time to write a seasonal short story for yesterday's London Evening Standard. 
 Happy Christmas. 
 River's farewell to a grand old man. 
 By Christopher Dodd 
 PUTNEY buried one of its favourite sons yesterday and bore testament to a passing era. 
 Dick Phelps, aged 92 &mdash; waterman to the Queen, the Thames Rowing Club, and British Olympic crews, was borne along the Embankment at Putney, accompanied by a phalanx of Doggett's Coat and Badge men in scarlet tunics and knee breeches. 
 The cortege started at from Dick's home near the river, paused at the rowing club, then progressed along the river front past the clubs which he and his father and his uncles, cousins, and brothers had served &mdash; Vesta, Lensbury, Westminster School, Barclays and NatWest and Midland banks, and the London Rowing Club. 
 Each club flew its flag at halfmast; each waterman stood sentinel at his boathouse door before joining the entourage, which was led by Bobby Prentice, Bargemaster to the Waterman's Company, to St Mary's parish church by the bridge. 
 There has been a Phelps working this reach at least since &bquo;Honest John&equo; Phelps was the finishing judge of the Boat Race, a duty from which he was forcefully retired after a controversial dead heat in 1859. 
 Phelpses built boats, maintained boats, became champion scullers, taught the gentlemen how to scull, and bowed and doffed their caps &bquo;below stairs&equo; at the clubs before the war when watermen were not allowed to drink at the bar. 
 Some Phelpses became English and world champions. 
 Doggett's race, which 10 of the Phelpses won, is the most visible link with the watermen's proud past. 
 The annual contest from London Bridge to Chelsea was founded in 1716 by the actor Thomas Doggett to commemorate the accession of the Hanovers to the throne. 
 Until recently, competitors only had one chance to win because it was only open to men in their first year after indenture to the Company of Watermen and Lightermen &mdash; so winning the buckled shoes, white stockings, silver badge and scull cap which complete the scarlet raiment is no mean feat. 
 Dick was indentured to the Company in 1917, &bquo;admitted, allowed, and registered&equo; to the Freemen in 1933, became waterman to Thames RC in 1931 after starting out as a boatbuilder, became a Waterman to Her Majesty in 1953, and an Extra Waterman to Her Majesty in 1967. 
 He retired from Thames in 1966, but not from the river. 
 He could tell of earning half a crown a week and leading the horse pulling the Putney clubs' boats home from Henley, and of the visit of Harvard to race Cambridge at Putney in 1906. 
 There are still professional watermen in the Tideway and still Phelpses on the river, but the former are a dying breed and the latter are amateur competitors. 
 Yesterday, the watermen acknowledged Dick as &bquo;one of the best&equo;. 
 Picture, page 4 
 Rethink call from Tory peers follows banks' pull-out Minister in corner over student loans. 
 By David Gow and Martin Linton 
 MR JOHN MacGregor, the Education Secretary, yesterday came under pressure from MPs, peers and vice-chancellors to rethink completely the Government's scheme for student loans, following the major banks' decision to pull out. 
 Lord Boyd-Carpenter, chairman of backbench Tory peers, said it would be wise to use the Christmas recess to give further thought to the scheme. 
 Conservative peers are expected to criticise the scheme sharply when the Lords begin debates on the Education (Student Loans) Bill in mid-February. 
 Ministers are known to be bracing themselves for a series of defeats. 
 Lord Boyd-Carpenter said that criticism was unhappily &bquo;not confined to the other side&equo; and it would be many years before the scheme would bear fruit. 
 His colleague, Lord Beloff, asked why the Government had brought forward a bill without support in either House for a scheme the vice-chancellors had repeatedly told them was impossible. 
 Professor John Ashworth, vice-chairman of the committee of vice-chancellors and principals (CVCP), also urged Mr MacGregor to use &bquo;a heaven-sent opportunity to go back to the drawing board and look at the entire issue of how students are supported &mdash; grants, loans and fees.&equo; 
 Professor Ashworth, Salford University vice-chancellor, said repayments of loans, worth up to &pound;460 a year, should be made through the Inland Revenue &mdash; an option consistently ruled out by ministers and officials. 
 &bquo;The university or polytechnic should administer the grant and loan and collect the full-cost fee. 
 The money would be provided by government. 
 We would administer it and the access and hardship funds connected to the scheme and inform the Government of the money to be repaid. 
 They would doubtless inform the Inland Revenue and the effect would be simple and administratively cheap.&equo; 
 But, under the system now envisaged by Mr MacGregor's officials, higher education students would get a certificate proving they were on a recognised course and apply by post to the Glasgow-based Student Loans Company for a loan. 
 They would then automatically get one without their credit rating being investigated. 
 Repayments, according to officials, would be made by direct debit through the student's personal account with a bank or building society. 
 Mr MacGregor rejected Opposition charges that the Government's plans had been torpedoed by the banks' withdrawal when he made a statement to the Commons yesterday. 
 The principles and framework of the scheme were &bquo;completely unchanged.&equo; 
 Opposition MPs mocked the Government's decision to take over the Student Loans Company as its first act of nationalisation. 
 Mr Jack Straw, Labour's spokesman, said the company would now be a nationalised corporation. 
 Mr Simon Hughes, Liberal Democrat spokesman, challenged the Government to say how it could reconcile a state-run loan system with its privatisation programme. 
 Other Opposition MPs called for the Ombudsman to investigate the issue and for Mr Robert Jackson, higher education minister and the scheme's author, to resign. 
 Mr Straw insisted that the banks' participation was absolutely central to the bill. 
 But Mr MacGregor, despite previous ministerial statements to the contrary, retorted that private sector involvement was not crucial to the bill. 
 Sir Peter Emery, a former Conservative minister, accused the banks of &bquo;highly irresponsible&equo; action and urged ministers to consider making student grants encashable only at co-operating banks. 
 Jailed men cleared by court. 
 AMAN jailed for 12 years for robbery after he was picked out on an identity parade because of his &bquo;frightening, evil, and sadistic eyes&equo;, was cleared by the Court of Appeal in London yesterday. 
 Anthony John Allen, aged 23, of Huyton, Liverpool, was cleared by the appeal judges, along with William Willis, aged 23, who had been given an 11-year sentence for his alleged part in the attack three years ago on a Southampton publican, his wife, and a barmaid. 
 Lord Justice McCowan, sitting with Mr Justice Roch and Mr Justice Alliott, ruled that the robbery convictions were unsafe. 
 They said that there had been &bquo;serious and fundamental&equo; errors by Judge Lewis McCreery in his summing-up to the jury at Winchester crown court in February last year. 
 Criticising the trial judge's directions to the jury, they cited poor identification evidence against Allen, and held that accomplice evidence given in Willis's case had caused them great anxiety. 
 The court was driven to conclude that the jury would not necessarily have convicted had it been correctly directed. 
 Friday People. 
 Dennis Barker:. 
 Day of the Three Wise Ladies 
 BRITISH motorists must be grateful this festive time to three ladies who will not see a Christmas day lunch. 
 The Automobile Association skeleton staff trio will be huddled in front of their personal computer screens relaying road conditions to drivers. 
 Nick Simmons, manager of the AA Roadwatch nerve centre at Stanmore, Middlesex, hastily pointed out yesterday that those who drew the short straw for Christmas duty could just as easily have been men. 
 This year he has a perfect excuse &mdash; his wife is expecting their first baby during the time the Three Wise Ladies are picking up from police, local authorities, and others information about weather, congestion, and danger points, and relaying it to the media. 
 Most of the exchange of information goes on before the Christmas holiday &mdash; like yesterday and today when 12 people were at their computers. 
 &bquo;The prospects at the moment look pretty good,&equo; said Simmons, a bright and optimistic 28-year-old who has been with the AA seven years. 
 &bquo;At the moment it looks as if all major roadworks are suspended.&equo; 
 The weather forecast was not too bad, either, except that the heavy recent downpours might lead to the cracking of some water, or even gas, mains. 
 The immediacy of the job is obviously an attraction to Simmons, born in Merton, south London, and a pupil at Dulwich college who never visualised a career with the AA. 
 He went to the National Broadcasting School on a programming foundation course, then worked for P&amp;O liners for a year, presenting radio programmes on cruises. 
 &bquo;I went to the AA &mdash; for six months or so, as I thought &mdash; at 22, because it was a job. 
 And I have stayed ever since because when I joined Roadwatch it was at a time when they were developing from just 15 information stations throughout the country &mdash; there are now almost 100. 
 Nick Simmons&hellip; taking off with the AA 
 US fungicide ban prompts safety review. 
 By James Erlichman, Consumer Affairs Correspondent 
 APROPOSED US ban on the most widely used fungicides has plunged the Ministry of Agriculture into another safety review. 
 The review was triggered when the US Environmental Protection Agency confirmed its intention to ban further use of maneb, mancozeb and zineb on most foods because the fungicides, used widely for 40 years, have been strongly linked with cancer. 
 The Guardian disclosed in July that the Ministry of Agriculture secretly agreed to an investigation as soon as the US findings were known. 
 The ministry said yesterday that an urgent review of the fungicides&equo; safety was in progress and ministers were expected to announce their decision early in the new year. 
 The review may lead to another clash of scientific opinion. 
 Last week, the Government declared the apple spray, Alar, safe but failed to study the evidence which led the US authorities to ban it. 
 Manufacturers of the three fungicides voluntarily instructed US farmers in October to stop using them on 70 out of 83 approved crops. 
 British farmers received no warnings and use of the fungicides has not been cut in Britain. 
 Mr George Bochanski, a spokesman for Rohm &amp; Haas, the manufacturer, said: &bquo;We continue to believe these products are safe and it is not our job to pre-empt the regulatory bodies in the UK.&equo; 
 But the US Environmental Protection Agency has decided that the voluntary withdrawal does not go far enough. 
 It said it would also seek to ban the fungicides' use on tomatoes, potatoes and bananas. 
 The ban is expected to come into force within 18 months. 
 Mr William K. Reilly, the agency's administrator, said the immediate cancer risk to children from fungicide residues was negligible. 
 But daily consumption of ETU, a component of the fungicides, posed a considerable long-term risk. 
 The agency believes at least 125,000 Americans will develop cancer from the current level of ETU residues being consumed. 
 British experts are likely to dispute these calculations which are based on mathematical models that attempt to extrapolate likely human cancers from laboratory studies. 
 The review will increase pressure on scientists at the ministry's Pesticides Safety Divison who say they are too understaffed to handle the backlog on older, more hazardous chemicals. 
 Fowler rounds off his industrial relations programme Bill allows choice on union membership. 
 By Keith Harper Labour Editor 
 MR NORMAN Fowler, the Employment Secretary, indicated that the Employment Bill published yesterday, which ends the closed shop, would be the last piece of trade union legislation in the present Parliament. 
 Apart from abolishing the closed shop, in a move which has TUC and Labour Party support, the legislation deals with unofficial strikes and outlaws secondary action. 
 The closed shop: Mr Fowler said the legislation would guarantee people the freedom to decide whether or not to join a union. 
 The law would make it unlawful to deny people a job either because they were union members, or because they did not want to belong to a union. 
 Mr Fowler said it was an historic step, because the closed shop had existed for more than 100 years. 
 Since 1980, the protection of the law against the closed shop had been progressively extended so that it now covered everyone in employment. 
 Mr Fowler said that while the existing law provided that it was automatically unfair to dismiss anyone for not being a union member, the bill completed the outlawing of the closed shop by extending the same protection to people applying for jobs. 
 Taking up the points made in recent days by Mr Tony Blair, Labour's employment spokesman, and the TUC, Mr Fowler said the dismantling of the closed shop need not wait for the passage of the bill. 
 Union leaders should take immediate steps to ensure that no one was ever denied a job because they did not have a union card. 
 He hoped that anyone over the coming weeks who failed to get a job because of not being a union member would write to the Government and explain the facts. 
 Secondary action: Mr Fowler said the law would no longer protect the sort of &bquo;industrial blackmail&equo; which last year prevented the Ford Motor Company building a new plant at Dundee. 
 The plan was strongly opposed by the unions, including the Transport and General Workers', which threatened to organise action to prevent the factory opening. 
 Mr Fowler said there was no reason why businesses and jobs should be put at risk by workers called upon to strike when they had no dispute with their employer. 
 Unofficial action: According to Mr Fowler, this is a &bquo;deep-rooted and long-standing problem&equo;. 
 He claimed that last year nearly 1 &frac12;million working days were lost through unofficial strikes, and that 75 per cent of strikes were unofficial. 
 He said the bill would end the situation where an employer had to dismiss either all the strikers or none at all. 
 If a union decided to repudiate a strike, it had to write to all its members taking part in the strike to tell them that the union would give no support, and that they risked dismissal without compensation if the strike continued. 
 Mr Fowler added that in the Government's even-handed approach to employment, people would have the right to belong to a union and could not be excluded from a job on the grounds that they were trade unionists. 
 This had nothing to do with the European Social Charter, which proposes to enshrine similar rights, he said. 
 Another measure in the bill will allow the Government to amend a code of practice without consulting the Advisory, Conciliation and Arbitration Service. 
 Also under the bill, all secondary school pupils will in future be eligible to participate in work experience schemes from the beginning of the summer term. 
 Industrial muscle&hellip; workers at Ford's Halewood plant on Merseyside show union solidarity in a vote at a 1984 mass meetingPHOTOGRAPH: DENIS THORPE 
 News in brief: Banker loses document fight. 
 Lorrain Osman, Britain's longest-serving unconvicted prisoner, failed at the High Court in London yesterday to have 30 bags of documents returned to him. 
 They were seized in a police raid on his home. 
 Mr Osman, 58, a banker, has spent four years in Pentonville Prison, fighting extradition to Hong Kong on fraud charges. 
 Acid apologies. 
 Three organisers of an Acid House party who were jailed for three months for breaching an injunction banning an event in Warwickshire were freed in the High Court in London yesterday after apologising. 
 Fire deaths rise. 
 The number of people killed in fires rose to 732 in 1986 from 710 in the previous year while the number injured reached a record 10,178, the Home Office said yesterday. 
 Pregnancy award. 
 Mandy Winston who claimed she was sacked by Oldham Crompton Batteries because she was pregnant has been awarded &pound;5,798 by a tribunal. 
 Waite attack. 
 A 16-year-old girl from Bermondsey, south London, was sent to a young persons' institution for four months yesterday after being found guilty at Seymour Place juvenile court of causing grievous bodily harm to Francis Ruth Waite, 24, daughter of Terry Waite, held hostage in Lebanon. 
 Bolton fans charged. 
 Thirty-two Bolton Wanderers football fans appeared in Manchester crown court yesterday charged with a series of offences, including riot. 
 Justice trial. 
 PC Kevin Williams, aged 28, of Paddington Green and Sergeant Colin Moore, of West End Central, accused of perverting the course of justice, were sent on bail to stand trial at the Old Bailey by Bow Street magistrates yesterday. 
 Airliners in near miss. 
 An Aer Lingus BAe 1-11 airliner was involved in a near miss with a Trans World Airlines TriStar over Hertfordshire yesterday. 
 The pilots were alerted and passed a mile apart. 
 The Civil Aviation Authority is investigating. 
 Mr Tim Janman MP: a clarification. 
 IN YESTERDAY'S parliamentary sketch (page 5), Mr Tim Janman MP (Conservative, Thurrock) was reported as saying that Britain would take even one refugee from Hong Kong &bquo;over my dead body.&equo; 
 Mr Janman has asked us to make it clear that, as he wrote in last Saturday's Sun, he recognises that both crown servants and substantial investors in Britain have an existing right to come here and that though at present he advocates the strict exclusion of all others, he would cease to do so if the Chinese were to attempt &bquo;a Tiananmen-style crackdown&equo; in Hong Kong in 1997. 
 Kent Opera goes into liquidation after Arts Council grant withdrawn. 
 KENT Opera went into liquidation yesterday, unable to continue after the Arts Council withdrew its &pound;750,000 grant. 
 The touring company, founded 20 years ago, was to present King Priam at the Royal Opera House in London in February and March. 
 A statement from the company's offices at Dartford said that because of the Arts Council cut it had to go into voluntary liquidation. 
 Mr Alec Jessel, the marketing officer, said: &bquo;It is very sad that such an established company has to take such a step, but there was nothing more we could do. 
 The losers are the singers and orchestras we employed. 
 They will have their contracts honoured in full.&equo; 
 The Duke of Kent, the opera's patron, and Sir Michael Tippett, composer and president of Kent Opera, both fought to save the company, the first in regional professional opera to tour the country. 
 As the company grew it began to tour abroad. 
 Jonathon Miller directed performances of Eugene Onegin and Rigoletto which were highly praised by critics and public. 
 Uncertainty over performances at the South Bank Centre in London ended yesterday when management and unions agreed a pay deal. 
 Striking absence of vital statistics. 
 By Keith Harper Labour Editor 
 THE Government admitted last night that it kept no statistics of unofficial strikes although Mr Norman Fowler, Employment Secretary, said yesterday that 75 per cent of all strikes were unofficial. 
 His department said that it only kept records of strikes lasting more than three days and involving more than 100 people. 
 It said that strikes usually lasted five days but it could not differentiate between official and unofficial disputes. 
 Mr Fowler said that the main plank of the Government's sixth piece of trade union legislation was an &bquo;even-handed approach&equo; to industrial relations. 
 For instance, it prevented people from being excluded from trade union membership and he denied that this clause was in because of the European Social Charter. 
 But the most controversial part of the bill relates to unofficial strikes, a legacy of the one-day summer stoppages on the London Underground. 
 A union would have to issue written warnings to all those members it had learned were threatening an unofficial stoppage telling them that they risked dismissal without compensation if the strike continued. 
 Mr Fowler conceded that a union might not always be able to do this but it would have to show that it had used its best endeavours. 
 The proposal would not prevent unofficial action taken on the day without any notice. 
 But the company would be able to dismiss workers selectively. 
 Later, officials at the department admitted that a legal ban would not be completely effective. 
 This part of the bill has already been criticised by wide sections of management. 
 London Transport said it would not have dismissed strike leaders even if it knew their identity, for fear of bringing the Underground system to a halt. 
 Mr Tony Blair, Labour's employment spokesman, said the bill had no genuine support in industry. 
 Its object in rerunning the debates of the 70s was to provoke bad industrial relations for the sake of the Tory party. 
 Granting employers the ability to sack union leaders selectively over unofficial action was &bquo;utterly offensive and would be opposed by most sensible managers. 
 &bquo;It is surely wrong to make unions police unofficial action which they have not endorsed.&equo; 
 Cold wind that stirs up bitter memories Peter Hetherington reports on ambivalent feelings created by a memorial service in the town scarred by last year's crash. 
 THEY stood in the chill wind in Dryfesdale cemetery &mdash; Lockerbie people, relatives of the victims of PanAm flight 103, and a scattering of dignitaries &mdash; to dedicate a garden of remembrance for the 270 victims of Britain's worst air disaster. 
 Where they stood, barely a mile from the aircraft's final resting place, there was no escaping a muted collective anger &mdash; directed as much at seemingly complacent airport authorities and governments as at the perpetrators of mass murder a year ago. 
 Small red posters, beside the many wreaths, told part of the story: &bquo;Remember PanAm 103 &mdash; demand airline security&equo;. 
 Lapel badges told the rest: &bquo;The truth must be known&equo; and &bquo;Terrorism and apathy &mdash; a deadly combination&equo;. 
 One year on, many still ask why the authorities did not issue a warning, based on intelligence reports, about a Christmas terrorist threat. 
 But as around 1,000 mourners shivered through a ceremony made all the more moving by its simplicity and brevity, there was little bitterness evident &mdash; only bewilderment. 
 &bquo;To me, nothing helps&equo;, said Ms Marina De Larracoechea, from New York, who lost her sister, Nieves, a stewardess, in the disaster. 
 &bquo;I guess these things &lsqb;memorial services&rsqb; have to happen, but the reality is she's no longer around&equo;. 
 The town's three clergymen, who played such an important part in counselling the victims after last December 22 &mdash; James Annand, Church of Scotland; Alan Neal, Scottish Episcopal; and Father Patrick Keegans, Roman Catholic &mdash; conducted the short dedication beside an impressive memorial, hewn from four tons of Finnish granite, bearing the names of the 270 victims, including 11 from Lockerbie itself. 
 It lies against a stone wall, shielded by birch and fur, overlooking a garden of remembrance, containing more memorials. 
 Local scouts and guides lined the route through the cemetery to the memorial, where Scotland's chief law officer, the Lord Advocate, Lord Fraser, stood alongside the US ambassador, Mr Henry Catto. 
 Mr Stevan Flannigan, who lost his parents and sister in the disaster, was comforted by the Princess of Wales' mother, Mrs Frances Shand-Kydd, who lives in Argyll. 
 Sir Hector Monro, the local MP, who lives nearby, welcomed relatives with the hope that the garden would prove a loving place full of compassion and warmth. 
 Father Keegans, whose own house was damaged as the remains of the plane exploded only yards away, said the 270 were deeply loved, sadly missed, &bquo;and will always be remembered.&equo; 
 Then Mr Neal read from Romans 12: &bquo;Avenge not yourselves, but rather give place unto wrath&hellip; vengeance is mine: I will repay saith the Lord&equo;. 
 Last night, before an ecunemical service attended by several thousand people outside Lockerbie town hall, some relatives gathered in the small church at Tundergarth, four miles away. 
 It is here that the nose section of the 747 landed, 150 yards from the church, and 120 bodies were found on the surrounding hills. 
 Mr Cameron Gibson, the local minister, comforted a steady stream of relatives all day. 
 &bquo;I felt very inadequate but at least I was able to provide a shoulder to cry on.&equo; 
 Just outside the church, a small building is being converted into a room of remembrance dedicated to the memory of the PanAm victims. 
 Beside it, a small wreath of red carnations read: &bquo;In loving memory of Raymond Wagner &lsqb;co-pilot&rsqb; from his wife Norma, and children Carol, Ray junior and Jenny.&equo; 
 As Americans, and relatives from many other countries filed through the town, and walked over the surrounding countryside yesterday &mdash; over 20 nationalities were represented on the flight &mdash; Mr Joe Horgan, a spokesman for the American victims of Flight 103, spoke of a bond between the US and Lockerbie. 
 &bquo;At times, we lost faith in our fellow man, and we just had to come here. 
 The town which was devastated itself reached out, held our hand, and guided us&equo;. 
 At last night's service, which ended with a piper playing the lament Flowers on the Forest, Father Keegans said: &bquo;Quite simply, life cannot be the same again&hellip; 
 But to say that there is no recovery&hellip; is to say to the terrorists: &bquo;Here, you can have our lives as well&equo;. 
 And that I refuse to give them.&equo; 
 Minister &bquo;ashamed&equo; of tabloid journalists. 
 MR DAVID Mellor, the Home Office Minister of State, said yesterday that he was &bquo;almost ashamed and embarrassed to live in the same society&equo; as journalists working for tabloid newspapers. 
 He told Channel 4's Hard News programme that the popular press was &bquo;drinking in last-chance saloon&equo;. 
 He said he was looking forward to the results of the inquiry chaired by Mr David Calcutt, QC, into press behaviour. 
 Mr Mellor said: &bquo;I think British journalism contains some of the best and worst journalism in the world. 
 I open some of the popular newspapers covering some people's private lives or great national tragedies and I feel almost ashamed and embarrassed to live in the same society as people who can produce that sort of stuff.&equo; 
 He cited photographic coverage of the Hillsborough tragedy as an example of intrusive and morbid reporting. 
 He said the Government was reluctant to interfere, but it had become aware of &bquo;widespread detestation in Parliament&equo; of some trends in the popular press. 
 Fears for Mersey birdlife eased. 
 By Alan Dunn 
 FEARS that a power-generating barrage across the Mersey could seriously damage the estuary's international status as a wintering home for wildfowl and waders have been partly eased by preliminary studies of bird habits. 
 These show that the birds make little use of the lower mudflats, which would be permanently flooded when the barrage is built, preferring the higher levels, which would still be exposed. 
 But the studies, carried out by the British Trust for Ornithology for the Department of Energy and the Mersey Barrage Company, have still to indicate whether or how the bird population might be changed by a barrage. 
 &bquo;At present the turbid estuary is continually re-depositing mud on the flats,&equo; says Mr Nigel Clark, of the trust. 
 &bquo;If, post-barrage, water flows slow down, we may find that less mud is pulled in and the situation may stabilise. 
 Some birds may do better in that situation and some worse. 
 It could change the community of bird species. 
 But initial studies show there are higher concentrations of birds on the higher areas of the mudflats.&equo; 
 The preliminary judgment is another hopeful sign that the barrage will receive government approval and could within the decade be feeding electricity into the national grid. 
 A decision is expected before March on the barrage company's application for a place in the non-fossil fuel obligation under the new Electricy Act, which gives the right to sell electricity to the privatised grid. 
 There have been 270 bids. 
 It is the biggest single concept, many others being devoted to using methane gas at waste product dumps. 
 In the meantime the company is seeking to win hearts and minds among communities on both sides of the Mersey and to attract national and international investment for the &pound;880 million project. 
 Liverpool city council recently gave backing to the scheme, and on January 3 the company will present its plans to a special meeting of Wirral council. 
 The message they will receive from Mr Desmond Pitcher, chairman of the company, is that the 700 megawatts of pollution-free energy released by harnessing the 10-metre tidal rise and fall will be commercially attractive over the project's 120-year life. 
 The scheme would create up to 5,000 jobs during the five years of construction, beginning in 1994. 
 If the Government approves the company's bid, an application will be made in 1991 for a parliamentary bill. 
 Intruder gets to airbus controls. 
 ASWISS student was able to enter the cockpit of an empty airbus at Gatwick and tamper with the controls, a court heard yesterday. 
 After the case, the airport authorities issued a statement saying they were not even aware there had been a breach of security and that the matter was the responsibility of the airline, Wardair. 
 Wardair yesterday accepted responsibilty and disclosed plans to tighten security. 
 In future its aircraft will not be connected to passenger jetties during maintenance and the airline may employ full-time security teams to guard planes before boarding. 
 Prosecuting counsel Anne Toynbee told magistrates at Crawley, west Sussex, that the aircraft had been parked at a stand at Gatwick on Wednesday while engineers worked on an electronic fault. 
 &bquo;Suddenly a sharp blast of high pressure air rushed downward from the engine,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;They went to the cockpit and saw Mark Schmit sitting in the captain's seat and noticed that certain instruments had been tampered with.&equo; 
 When asked what he was doing Schmit told the engineers: &bquo;Leave me alone. 
 Can't you see I'm trying to fix the plane?&equo; 
 Schmit, 19, of Liestal, told the police that he pushed the buttons in the cockpit because he was trying to start the aircraft but had no intention of flying it. 
 Ms Toynbee said Schmit had flown in from Zurich earlier that morning and was waiting to travel on another Wardair flight to Vancouver. 
 The incident delayed the Wardair Airbus on its flight to Toronto by three hours 11 minutes and she asked for compensation of more than &pound;1,500. 
 Defence counsel Simon Scammell, blaming lax security by both airport and airline, said his client should not be expected to pay all the compensation. 
 &bquo;It is horrifying that anyone in transit can find their way on to an aircraft undetected. 
 No- one was aware of his presence on board the aircraft until engineers saw the rush of air. 
 &bquo;If someone can go on board an aircraft like this there must be something wrong. 
 One can only be fearful of what could have been the situation.&equo; 
 He said Schmit had a considerable interest in aircraft but did not intend to cause damage. 
 If he had been spotted he would have returned, he said. 
 Schmit was fined &pound;700 plus &pound;30 costs. 
 The magistrates said the issue of compensation could be sorted out in the civil courts. 
 In their statement the Gatwick airport authorities said: &bquo;We are not aware that there has been a breach of BAA (British Airports Authority) security at Gatwick. 
 &bquo;The man's presence in the aircraft is a matter for the airline which has sole responsibility under the Government's national aviation security programme.&equo; 
 Mr Hugo Summerson, Conservative MP for Walthamstow, called on the Transport Secretary, Mr Cecil Parkinson, to carry out another review of security at Gatwick following &bquo;this grave breach.&equo; 
 PAGE 
 Court upholds adoption veto. 
 AMOTHER'S objections to her two children being put up for adoption were upheld in the Court of Appeal yesterday. 
 But the ruling by two judges in favour of the mother, who in the interest of the children cannot be identified, was described as &bquo;cruel kindness&equo; by the third, dissenting judge. 
 Lords Justices Balcombe and Beldam ruled that the mother, aged 25, was at this stage entitled to block local authority plans to put her daughter, aged 5 &frac12;, and her three-year-old son up for adoption. 
 They decided that her objections to adoption were not unreasonable and dismissed an appeal by the local authority against a county court judge's rejection of its adoption proposal on the grounds that it was premature. 
 The children were taken into care in mid-1987 because of their parents' inability to look after them properly and following suspicions of sexual abuse against the girl. 
 Lord Justice Balcombe said it was unlikely that a pending court application by the mother, who is divorced from the children's father, for access to her children would succeed. 
 He also warned that a future application by the council for the children's adoption against their mother's wishes might succeed. 
 Lord Justice Dillon, dissenting, said he would have allowed the local authority appeal. 
 It would be a &bquo;cruel kindness&equo; to uphold the county court order. 
 He viewed the chances of the children being successfully reintroduced to their mother as nil, and in these circumstances the mother &mdash; who was backed in yesterday's court action by the children's father &mdash; had unreasonably withheld consent for adoption. 
 The local authority was refused leave to appeal to the House of Lords. 
 Protest spreads throughout Romania &bquo;We are the people&equo; the demonstrators chant Czechoslovak Communists cut links Ceausescu unleashes carnage. 
 By Ian Traynor in Budapest 
 MASS brutality by the Romanian regime on the streets of Bucharest and cities and towns across the country cast a chilling shadow over Eastern Europe's momentous year of democratic change yesterday. 
 As reports emerged of unrest and violence which claimed scores of lives throughout Romania, the dramatic escalation of the uprising fuelled speculation about the future of President Nicolae Ceausescu. 
 But, while his security forces turned the streets of Bucharest into a killing field, it seemed that Mr Ceausescu was ready to stop at nothing. 
 Tens of thousands demonstrated last night in the Romanian capital after reports of at least 20 deaths there earlier in the day, and students at the heart of the protest movement have called for a general strike today. 
 The Czechoslovak Communist Party voted yesterday to cut links with the Romanian Communist Party immediately over the violent suppression of anti-government protests. 
 The US said it was considering sanctions. 
 A teacher in the Transylvanian city of Cluj told the Guardian that she saw corpses lying in the streets after troops opened fire on demonstrators. 
 Contacted by telephone, she said students and workers gathered in the city centre last night to protest and that the security forces used automatic weapons against them. 
 Gunfire could be heard in the city all day, she said, but the violence escalated late in the evening. 
 Late last night, the Hungarian news agency MTI said it had received telephone calls reporting more than 30 killings in clashes in Cluj, while another source reported clashes in Arad, 60 miles north of Timisoara, where demonstrators were massacred last week. 
 Timisoara and Arad were reported to be on a general strike. 
 Hungarian television also carried witness accounts of killings in Arad. 
 It quoted a Polish couple who arrived in Hungary yesterday as saying that they were in a large shop on the main square when two or three thousand people began chanting anti-Ceausescu slogans outside. 
 &bquo;Suddenly, armed soldiers broke the shop windows and opened fire on those inside, at everyone, indiscriminately. 
 Those who could not escape met their horrific, futile deaths there,&equo; they said. 
 The television report said the couple fled from the shooting. 
 When they looked back &bquo;they saw that tanks were rolling into the demonstrating crowd&equo;. 
 It added: &bquo;They also saw students from a college being ordered out in front of the building, made to stand against the wall, and shot dead. 
 Few people managed to escape.&equo; 
 Budapest Radio said several people were killed at a demonstration in the Transylvanian town of Tirgu Mures yesterday. 
 It gave no figures but said Romanians and ethnic Hungarians took part in the protest which followed a strike in the area. 
 &bquo;Shootings were heard and there were fatalities,&equo; the radio said. 
 A Romanian traveller arriving in Yugoslavia said he also heard of protests yesterday in the cities of Craiova and Suceava. 
 The strongest evidence yet emerged yesterday about the massacre in the north western town of Timisoara at the weekend. 
 The Hungarian Foreign Minister, Mr Gyula Horn, he had &bquo;reliable and authenticated&equo; information that more than 1,000 and possibly more than 2,000 people died in the attack. 
 He also said that as the unrest continued throughout Romania, there were clashes between the army and the huge internal security apparatus, the Securitate. 
 This dovetailed with reports that the Securitate shot soldiers who refused to kill demonstrators and that many servicemen joined the side of the protesters in Timisoara. 
 The security forces are said not to have intervened when up to 100,000 people demonstrated in Timisoara on Wednesday evening. 
 Some joined the insurgence and armoured vehicles left the scene of the protest draped in white flags. 
 The reports of the fratricidal strife among the security forces indicated a threatening polarisation in the country as the regime dug in, while a burgeoning opposition gained in confidence. 
 Tens of thousands were reported back on the streets in Timisoara yesterday, defying a state of emergency, a curfew, and a ban on assembly of more than five persons imposed on the region. 
 Factories were occupied and a strike was announced for tomorrow unless the security forces pulled out of the town, reports said. 
 The demonstrators threatened to blow up factories. 
 Budapest was abuzz with rumours that the embattled Romanian leader might be planning to seek refuge in China. 
 According to reports from the Romanian capital, the violence yesterday started when President Ceausescu sought to address a staged rally of support that rapidly turned into a huge protest. 
 Demonstrators ripped up the national flag amid shouts of &bquo;Yesterday Timisoara, today Bucharest.&equo; 
 Mr Gyorgy Kellti, a Hungarian Defence Ministry spokesman, said that the crowd of 150,000 in Bucharest shouted anti-regime slogans, and an angry throng surrounded Mr Ceausescu, who was saved only by his ring of Securitate bodyguards. 
 As the protest grew, the troops came in with automatic weapons, armoured vehicles and teargas. 
 Mr Ceausescu remained intransigent in a speech to the rally, repeating his claims that the unrest was being fanned from abroad. 
 Romanians launch first opposition, page 10; Leader comment, page 22; Defending the indefensible, Commentary, page 23 
 Drug smuggler gets 16 years. 
 A Turkish lorry driver was jailed for 16 years yesterday for smuggling heroin worth &pound;1.2 million in his vehicle. 
 Customs officers arrested Ahmet Ataban in September at Dover, Kent, when they found 13 kilos of the drug after removing the tyres from the wheels of his lorry. 
 Woman loses baby. 
 A pregnant woman lost her baby after she fainted as she waited for a bus and fell into the path of a lorry driven by her uncle. 
 Faye Herbert, aged 24, who was four months pregnant, was in a stable condition last night in hospital following the accident at Timsbury, near Bath. 
 Court clears soccer club. 
 Nottingham Forest Football Club was yesterday cleared of racial discrimination after an Afro-Caribbean group had alleged an application to hold a pop concert at the club's stadium was rejected on race grounds. 
 Nottingham county court accepted the club's explanation that the decision was made on commercial grounds. 
 Action on bus safety. 
 Measures to make automatic bus doors safer were introduced by the Government yesterday. 
 Doors will now have to be fitted with special safety devices to prevent people or objects getting trapped in them. 
 Poll tax protester fined. 
 Mr Mark Gale, who was fined &pound;50 after completing his poll tax registration form in Arabic, said yesterday he will appeal against the penalty. 
 Legionnaires' death. 
 A pensioner, Mr Kenneth Sanders, aged 66, of Derby, has died in hospital after contracting legionnaires' disease while on holiday in Majorca. 
 Soldier fined &pound;600. 
 A soldier who feared flying was fined &pound;600 yesterday for endangering a civil aircraft and disobeying the captain's orders. 
 Rifleman Ian Richardson, aged 19, admitted his part in the incident on Wednesday. 
 Nuclear costs hit the CEGB. 
 By Patrick Donovan Industrial Correspondent 
 FRESH controversy gripped Britain's discredited nuclear power programme yesterday after the Central Electricity Generating Board admitted that the overall cost of decommissioning redundant power stations and dealing with spent fuel has nearly doubled to &pound;13.3 billion. 
 The full extent of the taxpayer's liability over atomic energy has been flushed into the open because of accounting changes demanded by City analysts in the run-up to next year's electricity privatisation. 
 Disclosure of the massive &bquo;hidden&equo; costs followed an internal &bquo;reassessment&equo; by the CEGB and an internal review by the Atomic Energy Authority. 
 The Energy Secretary, Mr John Wakeham, was obliged last month to remove nuclear power from the privatisationand announce a moratorium on the building of new power stations. 
 Casting a shadow over the CEGB's last set of accounts in the state sector, the company announced yesterday that decommissioning costs have doubled to at least &pound;600 million a station. 
 This doubles to around &pound;8 billion the total cost ofdismantling and making safe nuclear installations at the end of their commercial life. 
 In addition, the CEGB has more than doubled, from &pound;3.1 billion to &pound;6.4 billion, the extra provisions needed &bquo;for work still to be carried out on nuclear fuel and wastes from past years&equo;. 
 A portion of this, however, is included in the decommissioning costs. 
 After the separate nuclear liabilities incurred by Scottish nuclear power stations are taken into account the overall sum for nuclear waste disposal amounts to around &pound;13.3 billion, the CEGB said yesterday. 
 The CEGB disclosed the escalation in nuclear costs as it announced that operating profits are &pound;603 million lower than expected at &pound;355 million. 
 The return on assets works out at 1.8 per cent compared with a 3.75 per cent target set by the Government. 
 Most of the nuclear increases result from cost increases by British Nuclear Fuels, the reprocessing body which supplies both the civil and military atomic programme. 
 After revising its own nuclear liability, BNFL has passed these on to the electricity industry in the form of new fixed price contracts. 
 The findings again call into question the Government's attempt to privatise nuclear power despite constant warnings over the costs The shadow Energy Secretary, Mr Frank Dobson, claimed yesterday that the CEGB's accounts had been &bquo;massaged and adjusted to suit the Government's privatisation policies&equo;. 
 They owed a lot more to artistic interpretation than to technical merit, he said. 
 Analysts at Smith New Court, the City stockbroking firm, said yesterday: &bquo;The costs are much higher than we thought. 
 They are a result of the auditors saying that the accounts must be prudent. 
 This is purely a reflection of the fact that we didn't clearly understand the cost of nuclear electricity&equo;. 
 Lord Marshall, the CEGB's former chairman who has resigned with a &pound;250,000 payoff, said the lower return would be especially disappointing to staff who had &bquo;devoted their customary high level of professional commitment to preparations for privatisation&equo;. 
 Pointing out that the CEGB had achieved its highest ever nuclear power output at 18.7 per cent of all power generated, Lord Marshall said: &bquo;The plant is in good shape and our staff can take pride in a job well done. 
 Manpower productivity has continued to rise and we have brought down the price of electricity in real terms since 1958 when the CEGB was established.&equo; 
 Bucharest protesters defy brutal clampdown. 
 By Foreign staff 
 SECURITY forces launched a fresh assault on tens of thousands of demonstrators in the centre of Bucharest late last night at the end of a day in which violent repression was reported to have cost at least 20 lives in the Romanian capital. 
 Reports from East European news agencies and diplomats gave graphic witness accounts of earlier violence in which armoured vehicles crushed demonstrators to death and police shot at anything that moved. 
 Western correspondents have been refused entry to the country. 
 The violence began after an attempt by President Nicolae Ceausescu to rally support for his regime turned into a massive protest against the Romanian dictator. 
 Late last night, Tass reported that bursts of automatic fire were heard all around the city as &bquo;several tens of thousands of people&equo; gathered on Bucharest's University Square. 
 The demonstrators were &bquo;surrounded by Romanian army soldiers, special troops armed with truncheons and plastic shields and security forces,&equo; the report added. 
 Two Tass reporters said tear-gas shells were fired over the heads of the demonstrators at around 11pm after an army officer had appealed in vain through a megaphone for them to disperse. 
 &bquo;The whole square was filled with thick, suffocating gas,&equo; the Soviet journalists said. 
 &bquo;Some of the demonstrators withdrew into narrow side-streets, but the square promptly filled again with people as soon as the gas began to disperse. 
 &bquo;In response, the demonstrators began to chant &bquo;We won't leave&equo;. 
 Two passenger cars were set on fire outside the Intercontinental Hotel. 
 &bquo;Tanks and firehose trucks moved into the square several times in an apparent attempt to intimidate the demonstrators. 
 But the people on the square shouted at the security forces &bquo;We are the people&equo;, &bquo;We are not terrorists&equo;, &bquo;You eat the people's bread.&equo; 
 As we write, fire-engines are trying to douse some burning lorries and huge volleys of tear-gas shells are continuing. 
 &bquo;Choppers are patrolling over the city,&equo; Tass added. 
 &bquo;Tanks are standing by in clouds of smoke with their motors running. 
 Groups of young people are crowding round in front of the soldiers chanting &bquo;The army is with us&equo; and &bquo;No violence&equo;.&equo; 
 The Yugoslav news agency, Tanjug, reported that about 5,000 students were building barricades of garbage cans in front of the Intercontinental Hotel. 
 &bquo;There are indications&hellip; that police will intervene. 
 Weeping women are lighting candles throughout Bucharest,&equo; it added. 
 &bquo;There is light in all the windows of buildings in the areas where the demonstrations are under way. 
 People have come out on to balconies and some of them are shouting slogans supporting the protests.&equo; 
 In another report, Tass correspondent Nikolai Morozov said University Square in Bucharest had become a centre of the protests, with mainly young speakers taking turns to denounce the government. 
 &bquo;Now and again, tanks and armoured cars move into the crowds but they cannot disperse them. 
 As dark fell, street lights went on in the square and many demonstrators lit paper torches.&equo; 
 Mr Morozov, said when he sought comment from a security forces' official at University Square he was taken through four police cordons and lines of tanks to &bquo;a short, thick-set man in civilian clothes with a hard voice and authoritarian air.&equo; 
 The man said: &bquo;What you see here is a generation brought up on videos. 
 What you've got happening back in Moscow you can see happening here now.&equo; 
 The Tass reporter said the following conversation ensued. 
 Morozov: &bquo;I heard shots. 
 Who was firing? 
 Were there any casualties?&equo; 
 Man: &bquo;There are no casualties, not one.&equo; 
 Morozov: &bquo;But I saw wounded being taken away and ambulances.&equo; 
 Man: &bquo;Those were people who didn't have enough for dinner, got excited and fainted.&equo; 
 Morozov: &bquo;Who are you?&equo; 
 Man: &bquo;I am an ordinary representative of the workers and I'm helping to keep order here.&equo; 
 Earlier, Tanjug's correspondent reported from Bucharest that armoured vehicles ran over students, while police turned automatic gunfire on crowds chanting &bquo;Down with Ceausescu&equo; and &bquo;Down with the killers&equo; during demonstrations that erupted at the government-organised rally in support of President Ceausescu. 
 Tanjug said police fired rockets from helicopters into the crowd and police sprayed automatic weapons fire into the demonstrators &bquo;shooting at everything that moved&equo;. 
 Twenty youths were killed running to help two people who had been crushed by armoured vehicles on Student Square, said the agency. 
 &bquo;The command rang out: &bquo;Aim! 
 Fire!&equo; 
 Shots rang out and at least 20 demonstrators fell dead,&equo; Tanjug said. 
 Other witnesses spoke of the killings. 
 &bquo;My colleagues have seen eight or nine bodies, mostly apparently students, visibly dead, bleeding from head wounds in the streets&hellip;,&equo; a British diplomat told BBC television news. 
 Tass confirmed the report of armoured vehicles running over students, saying demonstrators were killed by the personnel carriers. 
 &bquo;When the group of witnesses rushed to pull those injured from under the wheels of the armoured personnel carrier, they were fired on by automatic weapons.&equo; 
 Tanjug said demonstrators outside the Intercontinental Hotel tore up pictures of President Ceausescu and sang an old nationalist song, Wake up Romania. 
 &bquo;Several thousand people, mostly pupils and students, found themselves surrounded by police and tanks,&equo; the agency added. 
 &bquo;Police began firing on the trapped mass of people. 
 Eyewitnesses said many were wounded and probably dead.&equo; 
 Nature council celebrates new species of fly. 
 By Nigel Williams Science Correspondent 
 TWO new species of fly have been discovered in Wales by scientists from the Nature Conservancy Council. 
 One was found on decayed plant material in peatland at Llyn Eiddwen, in Dyfed, and the other on the droppings in burrows of small mammals such as moles and voles in Merioneth. 
 The team of three, led by Dr Peter Holmes, have just finished the last field work of a three-year study of the effect on invertebrates of different peatland management strategies across Wales. 
 &bquo;British insects have been so well recorded that the discovery of new species is the icing on the cake of the study,&equo; said Dr Holmes. 
 About one or two new species of insect are found in Britain each year but Wales includes some of the least-studied habitats. 
 The new species may be unique to Wales. 
 They will not be named until publication of details in an academic journal, but the second one belongs with the lesser dung flies in the Sphaeroceridae family: &bquo;a lovely little group,&equo; he added. 
 The team have also discovered six species of fly never previously recorded in Britain and more than 100 other species of invertebrates including beetles, plant bugs and spiders never before found in Wales from the study of 120 peatland sites. 
 &bquo;The conservation of invertebrates is important because they are good indicators of the quality of the habitat&equo;, said Dr Holmes. 
 Three die in salmonella outbreak at hospital. 
 By Tom Sharratt and James Erlichman 
 THREE elderly women patients have died after contracting salmonella at an Oldham hospital, it was disclosed yesterday. 
 Another five were said to be &bquo;very poorly&equo; after being transferred to a hospital specialising in infectious diseases. 
 Ten women patients and a nurse in the geriatric ward of the Royal Oldham Hospital in Greater Manchester have been infected by the disease since the first case was diagnosed last Thursday. 
 Admissions to the 17-bed ward have been halted and nurses have been ordered to wear special disposable gowns in the hope of preventing the infection spreading throughout the 1,000-bed hospital. 
 Investigations have so far failed to identify the cause. 
 Mr Peter Shrigley, general manager of Oldham health authority, said: &bquo;There is nothing to suggest any connection between hospital catering and this outbreak. 
 Inquiries are being pursued to try to identify possible sources.&equo; 
 Hospital sources said that the Royal Oldham was not using the controversial &bquo;cook-chill&equo; method under which pre-cooked food is re-heated by microwave on the ward. 
 Mr Shrigley said two of the women had died from the serious illnesses for which they had been admitted to the hospital. 
 The death of the third, however, might have been hastened by the salmonella complication. 
 US invasion bogged down by Noriega's resistance. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington and Simon Tisdall in Miami 
 HEAVY fighting broke out in at least three districts of Panama City yesterday, as General Noriega and his supporters continued to defy the bogged-down 24,000 US invasion force with bitter resistance. 
 Heavily-armed US combat troops, supported by artillery and helicopter gunships, were deployed through the streets of the capital yesterday, after a night marked by sporadic gunfire, looting and continuing reports of hostage-taking. 
 Last night, the new civilian government declared a curfew at the end of a day in which helicopters firing rockets and machineguns were deployed against the pro-Noriega militia based in the sprawling poor districts of San Miguelito. 
 The invasion, additionally justified by the US as necessary to defend the Panama Canal, was showing signs of turning into an occupation &mdash; and, what was more, an occupation facing potential guerrilla resistance. 
 In Nicaragua, the US embassy in Managua was surrounded by troops in retaliation for American troops ringing the Nicaraguan embassy in Panama City. 
 Spain called for the fighting to be stopped after Juan Moreno, a photographer for the newspaper El Pais, was killed in crossfire. 
 A representative of the newly installed Panamanian government said yesterday that if Panamanian forces found General Noriega they would not extradite him to the US to stand trial. 
 Asked about Noriega's extradition, Mr Eduardo Vallarino told reporters: &bquo;The Panamanian constitution prohibits extradition, so if Noriega is apprehended he'll have to be duly charged and tried in Panama.&equo; 
 In Washington, President Bush appeared in the White House press room to tell reporters &bquo;Yes, it has been worth it.&equo; 
 At the same time, the first US bodies were flown home. 
 Journalists reported that forces loyal to General Noriega were holding the northern border regions of Panama. 
 US intelligence reports of &bquo;northern redoubts&equo; where Cuban advisers have been training the militia and storing arms and ammunition could also mean a far longer military operation than the Pentagon had originally envisaged. 
 The failure to capture General Noriega threatened to complicate and prolong the US intervention. 
 The White House spokesman, Mr Marlin Fitzwater, said yesterday that the troops would stay for &bquo;as long as it takes,&equo; while a subdued Defence Secretary, Mr Dick Cheney, added: &bquo;Within the next few weeks we'll be able to meet the objectives.&equo; 
 There was growing concern yesterday for the fate of 11 US scientists from the Tropical Research Institute who were taken from their island laboratories on Wednesday. 
 At least two of the journalists seized at the Marriott hotel on Wednesday were still feared to be in pro-Noriega hands yesterday. 
 On the second day of &bquo;Operation Just Cause&equo; the US still had no idea of the whereabouts of General Noriega, according to General Colin Powell, the chairman of the joint chiefs of staff. 
 Late on Wednesday night, a man purporting to be General Noriega spoke on the pro-regime National Radio, urging all Panamanians &bquo;to keep up the resistance&equo; and appealing for support from the outside world. 
 US troops later blew up the radio transmitter to prevent further broadcasts. 
 The official US casualty toll stood yesterday at 19 killed in action, 151 wounded, and one missing. 
 Panamanian casualties, military and civilian, were thought to top 1,000. 
 The Pentagon said it knew of 59 dead and 66 wounded, and of 1,500 prisoners from the 6,000-strong Panamanian Defence Force. 
 But US reporters at the military hospitals in Texas to which the US casualties are being flown said at midday yesterday they had counted 190 US wounded being flown in, with more planes on the way. 
 The casualties were expected to climb further. 
 Bickering began on the US side yesterday, with State Department officials angrily protesting to the White House that the Pentagon failed to provide any security for the US embassy in Panama. 
 The US ambassador to Panama, Mr Arthur Davis, who returned to the country with the 12,000 invading US troops, 
 Turn to page 24, col 7 
 Noriega forces still resisting. 
 continued from page one warned of retaliation by the Dignity Battalions (civilian militia) and advised all American civilians in Panama to take extreme care. 
 Describing the deployment of troops in Panama City as the start of a &bquo;mopping up&equo; operation, General Powell said the US forces would now attempt &bquo;to assist President (Guillermo) Endara's government to start functioning.&equo; 
 He added that the freeing of Americans and others who were held hostage by Dignity Battalion gunmen would be &bquo;a priority for us today&equo;. 
 The combat troops were drawn from the Seventh Infantry Division, part of an 8,000-strong party of reinforcements dispatched to Panama on Wednesday night. 
 The US now has an estimated 32,000 military in the country, including the 12,000 personnel permanently stationed in the Panama Canal bases. 
 Panama remained physically cut off from the rest of the world yesterday, with the national airport closed and under US control, and the northern border with Costa Rica sealed. 
 While the US claimed to have overrun all principal military installations, North American control of this tiny country of 2.4 million people was clearly not complete. 
 The Bush Administration has put a bounty of &dollar;1 million on General Noriega's head and offered &dollar;150 for every PDF weapon handed over to the authorities. 
 The US has also attempted to appease national opinion by lifting the trade embargo, unfreezing Panamanian assets in the US, and pledging to reopen the canal today. 
 But the slaughter and the destruction in central Panama City, especially in the Chorrillo area close to the Noriega Command HQ, appeared to have shocked and alienated many inhabitants. 
 Many families lost their homes in the fighting and the fires which followed. 
 The battle for Panama, page 14 
 Ambulance stalemate as breakaway talks rejected. 
 By Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 HEALTH service managers last night ruled out further talks with the Association of Professional Ambulance Personnel after its members rejected a revised 9 per cent pay offer over 18 months. 
 In a statement released by the Department of Health last night, management said: &bquo;There is little point in meeting Apap in the near future because such a meeting would be bound to raise false expectations of an improved offer.&equo; 
 The statement followed calls from the leadership of Apap &mdash; which is not affiliated to the Trades Union Congress &mdash; for fresh negotiations, after members on Wednesday voted by two-to-one against accepting the 9 per cent proposal. 
 The offer, already rejected by the five TUC-affiliated ambulance unions in the 15-week-old dispute, had been recommended for acceptance by Apap's leadership, after pay talks earlier this month. 
 Before the talks, the union had not been recognised by the Government for national pay bargaining, leading to the belief that recognition had been granted to give managers the opportunity to impose the offer on all ambulance staff if it was accepted by Apap. 
 The rejection of further talks means Apap now is bound officially to press ahead with industrial action, even though many of the union's members already have supported the action being taken by others. 
 The Society of Telecom Executives, representing 29,000 managerial and professional staff in British Telecom, yesterday instructed its staff not to cut off phone lines to ambulance stations if called to do so by BT. 
 The warning followed incidents in London and the West Midlands where lines to ambulance stations were disconnected. 
 A spokesman for BT yesterday refused to comment on whether the company had received instructions to cut lines. 
 But London Ambulance Service categorically denied that it had plans to cut off phone lines, saying that it had only authorised one disconnection at Park Royal Ambulance Station, West London, because crews had locked themselves in. 
 Baggage handlers at Manchester Airport voted last night to end their three-week strike after management and unions agreed on a peace settlement. 
 Some of the 490 handlers, members of the Transport and General Workers Union, were to return to work at 7pm last night. 
 The main night shift was due to start at 10pm. 
 They have accepted a compromise deal which will give them a special allowance for working an extra hour in the morning and late at night under a new roster system. 
 The airport was closed for six days last week when fire crews refused to cross picket lines by baggage handlers protesting against having the new system imposed on them. 
 Scotland sends in the poll tax bailiffs For councils that have to pioneer community charge collection, the nightmare is just beginning. 
 Peter Hetherington reports. 
 IN SMALL, anonymous offices around Scotland, well away from the public eye, computer printers are now busy churning out tens of thousands of warning letters to rebellious voters. 
 They represent the first legal moves against an estimated 400,000 people who, by accident or design, have made no contribution towards the poll tax, introduced last April north of the border. 
 After sending out up to four earlier warnings, Scotland's nine large regional councils have now reached the critical phase in collecting the community charge from 3.7 million Scots, including an additional 1.7 million new taxpayers drawn into the net. 
 It is proving the nightmare many anticipated. 
 Authorities, borrowing heavily to meet budget shortfalls caused by non-payment, concede that the system is creaking, with collection and rebate allocation well behind schedule after countless Government amendments. 
 Labour councils, desperate to avoid the final sanction &mdash; a sale of goods in a debtor's home &mdash; are now agonising at the prospect of taking legal action against their own supporters. 
 One controlling Labour group, Lothian, is literally falling apart. 
 Financial and legal pressures have forced councils to hand over debt recovery to private agents known as sheriffs' officers &mdash; Scottish bailiffs &mdash; in a surprisingly clinical fashion. 
 Computer discs, containing the names of defaulters, are being despatched to the men in the small offices so that final legal warnings can be printed and distributed. 
 For a few, the poll tax is proving lucrative. 
 Kenneth Simpson, the Perth-based spokesman for the Society of Sheriffs' Officers, says they are already getting results. 
 &bquo;A woman might say &bquo;Sorry we haven't paid because my husband has lost his job and I'm unemployed&equo; so I say &bquo;OK, let's come to an arrangement, work it out.&equo; 
 They usually agree.&equo; 
 In the highest-taxed district, Edinburgh, some defaulters now owe over &pound;400, which means that thousands of couples are almost &pound;1,000 in arrears. 
 This week the local regional council, Lothian, revealed that over &pound;25 million was outstanding. 
 It is now asking sheriffs' officers to take action against over 76,000 people &mdash; 12 per cent of its poll tax payers &mdash; who have paid no community charge. 
 The leader of the Tory group on the council admits anxiously that services will have to be cut if the defaulters are not vigorously pursued. 
 The picture in the biggest region, Strathclyde, is even worse. 
 An estimated 250,000 refuseniks &mdash; 14 per cent of voters &mdash; now owe an estimated &pound;60 million. 
 With only 180 sheriffs' officers throughout Scotland, Simpson acknowledges that the collection process would be thrown into chaos if the non-payers persisted with their rebellion. 
 He admits that the final sanction, the warrant sale, provides the only alternative. 
 But for the moment he's not too disheartened. 
 Simpson's own practice recently received a computer disc from an unnamed council containing the names of over 5,000 defaulters. 
 They duly processed the information and despatched warning letters stating that offenders had five days to make a payment arrangement &mdash; with a 10 per cent surcharge &mdash; before a court order, a summary warrant, was activated. 
 &bquo;As a result, we've had an awful lot of letters from people saying there'd been an oversight on their part,&equo; says an outwardly cheerful Simpson. 
 &bquo;We've only had a couple of abusive ones, and a couple of nasty telephone calls.&equo; 
 But for councils, who have already spent &pound;40 million implementing a tax they profoundly dislike, the collection process is proving as difficult as most anticipated. 
 Roy McIver, secretary general of the Convention of Scottish Local Authorities (COSLA) says the level of non-payment is giving &bquo;cause for concern,&equo; with cash flows less favourable than under the old rating system. 
 Supporters of civil disobedience, notably a loose, unholy alliance of Scottish Nationalists and the Militant Tendency -both out to embarrass law-abiding Labour councils as much as the Government &mdash; are adamant that a mass non-payment resistance is being mobilised, particularly on Scotland's huge, outer-city housing estates. 
 They point to hundreds of disaffected Labour voters being attracted to protest meetings. 
 The Government is equally adamant that councils' financial problems are being exaggerated and that the civil disobedience campaign is flopping. 
 The true picture lies somewhere between these extremes. 
 Authorities originally budgeted for a non-payment level of six per cent &mdash; about 250,000 Scots. 
 They are probably about 150,000 short of this figure. 
 Legal action, as Mr Simpson indicated, should bring the non-payment level substantially down. 
 The hard-core of defaulters will then face wages arrestments &mdash; either directly at work or, more likely, at a bank where sheriffs' officers will attempt to freeze accounts. 
 This will cause problems. 
 Scottish banks have warned council chief executives that they will be unable to cope with even a modest level of account arrestment. 
 This claim, while strengthening the hand of non-payment groups who say the system cannot cope with mass civil disobedience, will alarm the big Labour councils. 
 They are counting on bank arrestments to avoid politically damaging warrant sales in the run-up to regional elections next May. 
 In truth, the full non-payment picture will not emerge for several months yet &mdash; but those who argue that Scotland is now experiencing the calm before the political storm could well be proved right. 
 And with harassed English treasurers now seeking help from the Scots on how to implement the tax next April, one senior council official said he could offer only two words of advice &mdash; &bquo;Expect chaos.&equo; 
 Tebbit stirs row &bquo;in bid to be leader&equo;. 
 By Michael White, Chief Political Correspondent 
 MR NORMAN Tebbit's decision to raise the stakes in the Conservatives' Hong Kong immigration row with a brutal attack on the Cabinet's policy last night convinced some MPs that he is preparing a bid for the party leadership when Mrs Thatcher retires. 
 The former Cabinet minister refused to rule out the possibility in the wake of his scornful accusation that the Prime Minister's shrewd political instincts had been led astray by the &bquo;Irish logic&equo; of the Foreign Office, though he did say it was &bquo;very unlikely&equo;. 
 In the absence of a clear candidate of the right next time, some MPs suspect that Mr Tebbit may be manoeuvring to become a serious outside runner rather than a king-maker. 
 Coming on top of Wednesday's Commons confrontation with Mr Doulgas Hurd, the Foreign Secretary &mdash; in front of Mrs Thatcher &mdash; Mr Tebbit's column in yesterday's London Evening Standard dramatically departed from normally discreet Tory methods of party in-fighting. 
 He described the Cabinet as split between &bquo;bitterly opposed factions&equo; led by Mr Hurd on one side and his successor as Home Secretary, Mr David Waddington, on the other. 
 He even named the Government Chief Whip, Mr Tim Renton, and the party chairman, Mr Kenneth Baker, as Waddington allies who &bquo;saw the danger (but) failed to prevent such a folly&equo; which, Mr Tebbit argued, was in danger of handing back to an opportunist Labour Party the very &bquo;key group of voters whose support is vital for a fourth election victory&equo; &mdash; by implication Tory populists sensitive to what he called &bquo;being swamped by people of different culture, history and religion&equo;. 
 In another passage evocative of past attempts to play the race card, Mr Tebbit wrote that &bquo;most people in Britain did not want to live in a multicultural, multiracial society, but it has been foisted on them&equo;. 
 Few Conservative MPs doubt the sincerity of Mr Tebbit's gut hostility to the plan to give British passports to up to 225,000 Hong Kongers as an insurance policy designed to &bquo;anchor&equo; them in the troubled colony. 
 But even some admirers were puzzled by the aggressively public way he has pursued it, the more so since he has been careful to acknowledge that there may not be enough rebels to defeat the Government's legislation with &mdash; &bquo;a sad day for me&equo; &mdash; Labour's help. 
 Critics were appalled at the split. 
 &bquo;It's his bid for the leadership,&equo; one prominent ex-minister on the right of the party said. 
 &bquo;It's the one thing he can outflank both Baker and Heseltine on.&equo; 
 A party official said: &bquo;It's the Powellite coalition, anti-immigrant, anti-Europe.&equo; 
 A Tory wet added: &bquo;He feels that the right has not got a standard-bearer or a contender. 
 He may begin as a standard-bearer and allow himself to be persuaded to go forward as a contender.&equo; 
 Against such calculations were those MPs who believe the hard-right strategy would not work and that Mr Tebbit is too flawed, too shrewd and too devoted to his wife, Margaret &mdash; crippled in the IRA's Brighton bombing of 1984 &mdash; to make a serious bid. 
 To run as a spoiler, simply to block Michael Heseltine's ambition to become leader, is another option he has voiced. 
 Immigration grenade, page 6 
 Remote TV controls blamed for &pound;12m waste of electricity. 
 By James Erlichman, Consumer Affairs Correspondent 
 ENOUGH electricity to light Basingstoke is being wasted every night by people too lazy to switch off their remote control televisions at the mains. 
 A television turned off by remote control continues to use a quarter of normal power because it needs to be electrically awake to receive the next remote signal to switch back on. 
 There are 14 million remote control televisions in Britain. 
 At least half are believed to be switched off by remote control every night. 
 The total energy consumed overnight is 70 megawatts, the amount needed daily to supply electricity to a town of around 70,000 like Basingstoke, St Albans or Methyr Tydfil, according to research published yesterday by Friends of the Earth. 
 The environmental pressure group calculates that the wasted energy costs &pound;12 million a year and generates nearly 200,000 tonnes a year of extra carbon dioxide (the primary greenhouse-effect gas) from power stations. 
 &bquo;People who can must start over Christmas by getting out of their seats and using the switch when they turn off the TV,&equo; said FoE energy campaigner, Mr Simon Roberts. 
 &bquo;That way we stop this damaging and unnecessary pollution.&equo; 
 Stripped, tied up and left to freeze It sounds like torture &mdash; and it is for some young workers forced to endure outdated initiation rites. 
 Stephen Cook reports. 
 IN AN alley-way outside a small London print works last week, a new employee was stripped by his workmates, tied to a chair, daubed with ink, flour and discarded food, and left out in the cold for two hours. 
 Even seasoned print workers felt that things went a little too far. 
 Such initiation ceremonies remain common in many jobs in Britain, despite growing disapproval by managers and trade unions. 
 The evidence that they can go tragically wrong came in Liverpool crown court this week when two teenagers were jailed for manslaughter. 
 They had doused a colleague's trousers with paint thinners, a regular initiation ceremony in their Skelmersdale factory. 
 But they had also struck matches to frighten him. 
 He caught fire and suffered fatal 80 per cent burns. 
 In other cases which have attracted recent headlines, trainee firemen in London were hosed with cold water and left in the street in baby doll nightdresses, a young policewoman in Manchester was handcuffed to railings through a freezing night, and army recruits in Colchester were forced to call out musical notes as a sergeant hit them on their naked buttocks with a baseball bat. 
 Although there has been some success in attempts to halt such ceremonies, or at least to make them less dangerous or humiliating, there is evidence that they are a perennial aspect of group behaviour unlikely to be eradicated. 
 Mr Allen Abramson, a London University anthropologist who has studied initiation rituals, said that most societies used them to mark important developments in a person's life, and that they often involved pain or privation. 
 &bquo;Wherever you find a group within society which feels that what it's doing is seriously different from everyone else, then you're likely to find initiation rites,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That's why they're common in the fire service and the army, where people are doing something out of the ordinary and taking greater risks than others. 
 &bquo;It also happens in public schools, where new arrivals are considered ordinary weaklings until they've been pushed out to survive some sort of ordeal so they can re-enter the group with a new identity.&equo; 
 Early last year the Ministry of Defence announced new measures to discourage bullying after young recruits revealed that they had been pushed into rivers, pelted with stones, and gassed with CS gas. 
 Commanding officers were asked to clamp down on harmful initiation ceremonies, and &bquo;agony aunts&equo; from the Women's Royal Voluntary Service were installed to provide a sympathetic hearing for bullied soldiers. 
 An MoD spokeswoman said yesterday that 92 &bquo;agony aunt&equo; posts had been established in Britain and Germany, and 24 filled. 
 &bquo;Ill-treatment and bullying is being tackled with a range of measures including better training for junior officers,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Harmful initiation rights are definitely out, but non-harmful ones would be okay. 
 It would be up to officers to decide what was dangerous and whether to discourage it. 
 But it might just take the form of going to the bar to buy drinks for everyone.&equo; 
 The fire service clamped down on initiation rituals after a young firewoman in London revealed that colleagues had tied her to a ladder, hosed her down, poured urine over her, used foul language and exposed themselves to her. 
 Four officers had pay stopped, and London's chief fire officer said it should be possible to create group spirit without &bquo;the denigration and ridicule of individuals.&equo; 
 Mr Dave Higgs, a spokesman for the Fire Brigades Union, said yesterday that initiation rites were &bquo;not widespread at all. 
 We don't condone them in any way, especially if they have racist or sexist aspects. 
 &bquo;I would like to think that any sort of physical abuse doesn't go on any more, but this does not mean that people might not get a bucket of water over them sometimes.&equo; 
 Printers, traditionally an exclusive &bquo;closed shop&equo; of workers, say that initiation ceremonies for apprentices are less common now than 20 or 30 years ago. 
 Rituals often involved the daubing of men's private parts with indelible inks or waste paper and glue. 
 A spokeswoman for the print union, Sogat, said such practices were on the way out. 
 &bquo;Some could be quite nasty, with people being tied up with ink chucked at them. 
 We wouldn't encourage anything which was risky, and some were a bit near the mark.&equo; 
 Mr Abramson said he thought that if management or officers tried to suppress or control initiation rites, the rank and file would usually devise new ones. 
 &bquo;There'd be the official ceremony, then the men would take the new person off and say, now we're going to really initiate you.&equo; 
 One print worker who was daubed and paraded on a trolley around Croydon in Surrey as an apprentice 25 years ago said: &bquo;The worst thing was if they didn't do anything to you at all &mdash; it showed you weren't wanted.&equo; 
 Baker names research chief. 
 Mr Kenneth Baker, the Conservative Party chairman, yesterday named Mr Andrew Lansley as the new director of the party's research department, writes Alan Travis. 
 The post has been vacant for months and the lack of suitable candidates puzzled officials as the job proved the starting point for such politicians as Mr Chris Patten, Mr Iain Macleod and Mr Reginald Maudling. 
 Mr Lansley, who is currently policy director of the Assocication of British Chambers of Commerce and was Mr Norman Tebbit's private secretary when he was party chairman. 
 Mr Baker also said three MPs would act as campaign co-ordinators in London, Birmingham and Leeds for next May's council elections. 
 BR to test computerised safety system. 
 PILOT projects for a safety system aimed at preventing disasters like that at Clapham last December have been approved by British Rail. 
 BR will award multi-million pound contracts for the introduction of a computer-guided Automatic Train Protection system in the next few weeks. 
 The system will automatically prevent a train passing through signals in dangerous situations, and will also govern speeds in restricted areas, an advance on the present automatic warning system, which sends warning signals to the driver. 
 Installation for the ATP equipment is to be completed by 1991, and a standard system suitable for the national network will be introduced in 1992. 
 News of the pilot projects was given yesterday in Western News, the staff magazine for 16,000 BR employees in the South-west and South Wales. 
 The system was being given the highest priority by the BR board, it said. 
 Investigation work on ATP started before the Clapham disaster, in which 35 people died and 113 were injured. 
 A later inquiry blamed BR for &bquo;unacceptable and dangerous&equo; work practices, and revealed that faulty wiring in trackside signalling equipment had led to the crash. 
 BR has selected the high-speed mainline service from Paddington to Bristol, and the suburban Chiltern line out of Marylebone, to pioneer the project in Western Region. 
 Mr Knowles Mitchell, corporate affairs manager for BR's Western Region, said yesterday: &bquo;The introduction of the ATP system and other measures are intended to remove any likelihood of a recurrence of a Clapham-type disaster.&equo; 
 He said trackside monitoring equipment would feed information to a receiver on the train. 
 A processor on the train would match that information with the train's performance, and the brakes could be applied if the driver did not take the required action. 
 BR has investigated similar ATP systems abroad. 
 Michael Smith adds: London Regional Transport is planning to extend the East London line north-eastwards from Bishopsgate in the City to Dalston, and from New Cross south-westwards to East Dulwich, in a &pound;100 million extension of the Underground network. 
 The development will add seven new stations to the East London line and take the Underground deeper into south London, where the network is limited. 
 If the Transport Secretary, Mr Cecil Parkinson, approves the extension the line could be operating by 1994. 
 PanAm suspect jailed in Sweden. 
 By David Sharrock in Uppsala 
 ABU Talb, named in connection with the blowing up of PanAm flight 103 over Lockerbie a year ago, was jailed for life yesterday after being found guilty by a Swedish court of attempted murder during terrorist-related incidents in 1985. 
 Talb planted a bomb at a Jewish synagogue in Copenhagen on July 22, 1985. 
 He was also found guilty of attempted murder in a bombing in Amsterdam on September 30, 1985. 
 An accomplice, Marten Imandi, was found guilty of murdering a person at the North-West Orient Airlines office in Copenhagen on July 22, 1985, and was given a life sentence. 
 Brothers Mustafa and Mahmoud Mougrabi received one year and six years respectively for conspiracy to murder. 
 All four were acquitted of involvement in a bomb attack in Stockholm on April 7, 1986. 
 One person died and 26 were injured in the 1985 bombings. 
 Talb's lawyer, Mr Sven Eric Sjogren, said he would be appealing against the convictions. 
 He confirmed that Scottish police visited Talb on Tuesday but said his client refused to speak to them. 
 The Lockerbie investigating team is seeking further information about why Talb visited Malta before the PanAm bombing. 
 The detectives are concentrating on the theory that the bomb was loaded at Malta before being transferred to PanAm 103 at Frankfurt. 
 Three weeks ago Talb was described in Uppsala Central Court as being &bquo;suspected in Scotland of murder or as an accessory to murder&equo;. 
 Swedish and Scottish police searched his flat, removing 15 bags of clothing. 
 It is believed that these clothes have been taken to Malta for comparison with items purchased there which were found in the suitcase containing the bomb. 
 Mr Sjogren said that Talb had agreed in principle to answer questions about the Lockerbie bombing. 
 &bquo;The ball is now in Scotland, we wait for them to come back,&equo; he said.Mr Sjogren repeated that his client insisted he had nothing to do with the explosion that brought down PanAm 103. 
 Talb's visit to Malta in October 1988 had been a business trip. 
 In Lockerbie yesterday the 270 victims of the bombing of flight 103 a year ago were remembered. 
 Last night 2,000 people filled the town's main square for a simple memorial service. 
 Earlier, 270 candles were lit after a ceremony attended by 1,000 local people in Dryfesdale cemetery to dedicate a garden of remembrance. 
 Lockerbie one year on, page 3 
 Japanese economic recipe &bquo;could improve British health&equo;. 
 JAPAN'S economic miracle has contributed to its population having the longest life expectancy in the world and Britain's social and health policy makers could learn from it, two researchers claimed yesterday. 
 Between 1965 and 1986, life expectancy in Japan rose by 7 &frac12; years for men and eight years for women, said Professor Michael Marmot, of University College and Middlesex School of Medicine, and Dr George Davey Smith, of the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine. 
 A Japanese boy could now expect to live 75 years, three years longer than a boy born in England or Wales. 
 Japanese girls could expect to live to 81, compared to 78 in England and Wales. 
 Writing in the British Medical Journal, the researchers said: &bquo;The success of the Japanese economy must be considered a factor in the rapid improvement in life expectancy. 
 &bquo;If prosperity is related to health or, more importantly, if relative poverty is related to poor health, this may be one way in which Britain could act to improve life expectancy,&equo; they said. 
 The researchers said the Japanese growth in wealth seemed to have been accompanied by a narrowing in the difference in incomes between the richest and poorest, whereas in Britain the gap had widened. 
 Another factor contributing to Japan's good health was the country's low-fat diet, the researchers said. 
 Auctioneers cleared over Stubbs works. 
 AFIRM of auctioneers which sold two oil paintings for &pound;840 five months before the works fetched &pound;88,000 at Sotheby's after being attributed to the 18th century master, George Stubbs, won its appeal yesterday against a judge's ruling that it had been negligent. 
 The Court of Appeal set aside a High Court decision that Messenger May Baverstock, of Guildford, Surrey, should pay &pound;112,000 damages to Mrs Penelope Luxmoore-May, of Dunsfold, Surrey. 
 Mrs Luxmoore-May, aged 66, and her husband, Paul &mdash; a former senior partner in the firm &mdash; sent the oils for auction to Messenger May Baverstock in October 1985. 
 The &bquo;rather dirty&equo; old paintings had been a wedding present at the time of Mrs Luxmoore-May's first marriage in 1948. 
 In March 1986, the oils were sold to an American art collector, Mr Paul Mellon, for &pound;88,000. 
 Yesterday, Lord Justice Slade, sitting with Lord Justice Mann and Sir David Croom-Johnson, said Mrs Luxmoore-May deserved sympathy, as did anyone who had unwittingly parted with a &bquo;sleeper&equo; &mdash; an item of hitherto unrecognised value. 
 But, while the opinion of Messenger May Baverstock might have been erroneous, negligence in law on the part of the auctioneer's had not been established. 
 Mr Justice Simon Brown, the High Court judge, had expected too high a standard of care and expertise in the firm's performance of its duties towards the Luxmoore-Mays. 
 The firm did not seek a costs order against Mrs Luxmoore-May, but she will have to pay her own costs for the original hearing and appeal. 
 Lord Justice Slade said that, in the case of &bquo;sleepers&equo;, it was all too easy to be wise after the event. 
 The valuation of pictures, where the artist was unknown, involved an exercise of opinion and judgment and was not an exact science. 
 Providing the valuer had been honest and diligent, the court should be cautious before convicting him of professional negligence merely because he had failed to be the first to spot a &bquo;sleeper&equo;. 
 The evidence did not justify the judge's conclusion that no competent valuer could have failed to spot the potential of the two oils. 
 Payment of the damages, which represented the difference between the two sale prices, plus interest, had been frozen pending appeal. 
 Immigration at four-year peak but below pre-Thatcher level. 
 By John Carvel Home Affairs Editor 
 IMMIGRATION into the UK is at its highest for four years, but remains below levels recorded before Mrs Thatcher introduced additional curbs in her first administration. 
 Home Office figures published yesterday show that 49,200 people were accepted for settlement in the 12 months to the end of September. 
 This was about 2,000 more than in the previous 12 months and the highest figure since 1985. 
 The number would have been higher if temporary recording changes had not been introduced. 
 The numbers accepted for settlement fell from 81,000 in 1976 to 70,000 in 1980 and 55,000 in 1985. 
 Since then immigration has been fairly stable. 
 The latest increases are mainly from the Indian sub-continent, but also from the Middle East, Australasia, Eastern Europe and Africa. 
 Fewer settled in Britain from the European Community and the Americas. 
 The figures include about 700 Vietnamese refugees. 
 The Home Office does not give a detailed breakdown of immigration from Hong Kong, but there was no significant increase in the &bquo;remainder of Asia&equo; category which includes the colony. 
 Inspection for puppy farms. 
 THE Government has promised random inspection of &bquo;puppy farms&equo; &mdash; where dogs are bred for sale &mdash; after allegations in a Commons debate yesterday of &bquo;horrific&equo; treatment by a small minority of breeders, writes Martin Linton. 
 Mr Alan Wynne Williams, Labour MP for Carmarthen, said the pet shop window was sometimes the end of a &bquo;callous, cruel, and dishonest trail&equo;. 
 Bitches were often crammed several to a cage, and dogs kept in old cars. 
 Mr Peter Lloyd, the Home Office junior minister, agreed that more powers for local authority inspectors were necessary, but to compel licensing of all breeders would place unnecessary restrictions on pet owners wanting to sell a litter. 
 Newspapers pay libel damages to footballer and two actors. 
 THE Manchester United footballer Viv Anderson was given a public apology and undisclosed libel damages in the High Court yesterday over a story in the Daily Star concerning a post-match clash between Anderson and the Wimbledon player John Fashanu. 
 His counsel, Mr Thomas Shields, told Mr Justice Popplewell that the article, headed: &bquo;Fash: I'd have knocked him through the wall. 
 Come clean, Anderson!&equo;, could have been understood to imply that Anderson was lying over his version of the incident. 
 The film star Arnold Schwarzenegger accepted substantial undisclosed libel damages and apologies in the High Court for allegations in the News of the World in February 1988 that he held &bquo;fervent Nazi and anti-semitic views&equo; and was a &bquo;secret admirer of Hitler&equo;. 
 The article also alleged that the star's father had been directly involved in rounding-up Jews and homosexuals who were tortured and murdered in Nazi concentration camps, the court was told. 
 The actor John Thaw accepted a public apology and undisclosed libel damages in the High Court over allegations in the People in December 1988 about his behaviour while filming the TV series Inspector Morse. 
 The article had suggested that, because of the actor's separation from his wife of 15 years, actress Sheila Hancock, he had behaved in an unprofessional and undignified manner, the court heard. 
 &pound;200,000 EC aid for victims of flooding. 
 THE Government is to receive &pound;200,000 in emergency European Community aid to help victims of flooding in south-west England, which has been battered by torrential rain and high winds since last weekend. 
 Worst hit were the Devon seaside towns of Sidmouth and Exmouth, which were cut off for several hours on Wednesday. 
 Some outlying villages were still under several feet of water yesterday and weathermen warned of more to come in the holiday weekend. 
 A warning was issued by the National Rivers Authority in Shrewsbury that the swollen River Severn was expected to burst its banks overnight for the second time in a week. 
 Emergency services were put on alert. 
 In the South-west, many roads were impassable after being swamped under five feet of water as an inch of rain fell in an hour. 
 Cars were abandoned in Plymouth as rain flooded main routes, and a landslide on the M5 near Exeter led to further disruption. 
 A woman who fell 50 feet down a cliff was rescued by a Royal Navy helicopter after she was trapped on Burgh Island in Bigbury Bay, near Plymouth. 
 The EC aim is to meet the priority needs of families hit by the consequences of the storms. 
 The money comes from the EC disaster fund. 
 The London Weather Centre said that people travelling for the holiday weekend will face more rain tomorrow and Sunday. 
 Bookmakers William Hill are offering 8/11 on a rainy Christmas and 11/10 on a dry one. 
 But the heavy rain has been welcomed by the British Waterways, as a much needed boost for its canals and reservoirs which have been kept low during this year's long, hot summer. 
 A spokesman said: &bquo;Our water engineer's prayers have been answered. 
 But he says we need a lot more heavy rain before he can roll up and put away his prayer mat.&equo; 
 Under water&hellip; aftermath of the River Severn overflowing near Tewkesbury, GloucestershirePHOTOGRAPH: MICHAEL CHARITY 
 Minister's staff set to test rules. 
 By Simon Beavis Labour Correspondent 
 APROJECTED surge in strikes at the Department of Employment could lead to the Employment Secretary's own backyard becoming the testing ground for his Employment Bill. 
 Mr Fowler's decision to close nearly half the country's 2,000 JobCentres and unemployment benefit offices, to integrate the remainder, and to bring the much-reduced network under the control of a semi-autonomous agency has far-reaching implications. 
 Yesterday, sources in the employment services division of the department warned that industrial relations were deteriorating. 
 One claimed that a manager in the West Midlands had offered a Christmas bonus to employees who had worked through strikes in Coventry and Wolverhampton. 
 With the employment services division set to be transformed into a &bquo;next step agency&equo; in April, there are question marks over terms and conditions of employment. 
 There are fears that the restructuring of the division presages wider use of performance-related pay deals and special supplements, determined by local managers with greater autonomy. 
 This would threaten existing collective bargaining. 
 In recent months, after the computerisation of employment records, the service has been the focus of a wide range of stoppages over staffing. 
 Unions have argued for staff increases, claiming new legislation requiring claimants to prove they are &bquo;actively seeking&equo; rather than just &bquo;available for&equo; work is labour-intensive. 
 Managers have agreed to 860 posts being created to cover computerisation but they have not acceded to further staffing demands. 
 The integration of JobCentres and unemployment benefit offices is expected to lead to redundancies. 
 Mr Fowler has conceded that about 100 higher executive officer posts are threatened, but staff fear more jobs could be lost. 
 MP &bquo;had history of depression&equo;. 
 MR JOHN Heddle, the MP for Mid-Staffordshire who was found dead in his fume-filled Jaguar on Tuesday, had a history of depression, a Canterbury inquest was told yesterday. 
 PC John Burden, coroner's officer for Canterbury, Kent, said: &bquo;He had a history of depression dating back to the early 1970s and he had been depressed since September this year.&equo; 
 He told Mr Richard Sturt, the Canterbury and Dover coroner, that Mr Heddle's daughter, Caroline, a 23-year-old veterinary nurse, had identified her 48-year-old father's body after it was found in the car in a chalkpit at Chartham, near Canterbury. 
 A post-mortem examination by Dr Alexander Gibson, a Home Office pathologist, gave the cause of death as carbon monoxide poisoning. 
 PC Burden said a note was found, written by Mr Heddle, but no details were given during yesterday's hearing, which was adjourned until February 15. 
 PC Burden said Mr Heddle lived at Lowndes Close, Belgravia, London, with his second wife. 
 He had two sons and two daughters from a previous marriage. 
 A coalman, Mr Martin Phipps, had been driving his lorry along the downs at Chartham at 7.25am on Tuesday when he noticed a Jaguar XJS parked in a chalkpit, said PC Burden. 
 &bquo;He noticed a hosepipe attached to the exhaust of the vehicle, leading inside the vehicle. 
 Mr Phipps approached the car and switched the engine off. 
 The deceased, at that time, was sitting in the front passenger seat.&equo; 
 Police were called and a police surgeon later certified Mr Heddle dead. 
 The coroner granted a request from the family, none of whom were in court, for a cremation certificate. 
 A Country Diary: NORTHUMBERLAND: When we saw our first immigrant golden-eye bobbing on the waters of Bolam Lake in the early months of each year, we always took it as the first sign of spring. 
 Black and white in appearance, the male golden-eye can be distinguished from the less strikingly marked male tufted duck by its lack of drooping crest and an ostentatious white patch behind the bill. 
 &bquo;Bucephala clangula&equo; sounds noisy but, in fact, the golden-eye is a silent duck compared with the mallard and wigeon. 
 Bolam Lake has now been designated a Country Park and has a warden to protect it. 
 I often see foxes, roe deer and red squirrels in the conifer plantation there. 
 Surely a tribute to sensitive management. 
 David Noble-Rollin, of the Natural History Society of Northumbria led a party to Bolam last week. 
 Mist hung over the water and the huge concourse of duck swam and ducked and preened. 
 I picked out two golden-eye amongst teal and wigeon. 
 David told us that swan pattern of movement was currently being monitored in the north-east, so he was trying to read the leg bands through his glass. 
 All on the same alder tree we saw coal tits, gold crests, marsh willow tits and long-tailed tits and I learnt to distinguish the whip-like whistling note of the marsh tit. 
 A first sighting of a nuthatch was recorded. 
 A group of yellow bar-winged siskins caused a flurry of excitement; the first time such a large flock had been sighted at Bolam Lake. 
 Whooper swans are molested by irresponsible trigger-happy parties but here, at Bolam, they visit in peace. 
 The wild whooper swan is a bird of great beauty and, I think, on the increase in the Border region. 
 The swan was once a highly regarded delicacy on the Christmas table. 
 Ornithologists gave the bird a Christian foundation and believed that the first mute swans were brought to Great Britain by the Crusaders from Cyprus in 1192. 
 This theory was contradicted following the discovery of swan bones in Cambridgeshire, Norfolk, Suffolk and Essex. 
 VERONICA HEATH 
 Presents of mind Gifts say an awful lot about the giver &mdash; and can be hazardous: a timely warning from John Illman. 
 YOU CAN blame the three wise men. 
 They started it all. 
 Not for nothing, however, are they called wise. 
 We know absolutely nothing about them. 
 They gave away very little about themselves in their choice of the first Christmas presents. 
 They would not get away so lightly today. 
 The psychologists would be in the manger with the TV crews, evaluating them on the basis of their offerings &mdash; gold, frankincense and myrrh. 
 The psychology of present giving is a great giveaway, revealing more about the giver than the recipient. 
 Gifts are expressions of taste, emotions, wealth, power, social awareness, aspirations, imagination, fashion &mdash; oh yes, and love and affection &mdash; well, sometimes. 
 If you're lucky. 
 What kind of present-giver are you? 
 And how should you regard relatives bearing gifts? 
 We've classified 12 types of present-giver &mdash; one for each of the 12 days of Christmas, plus health hazard rankings, with top scores of 10. 
 THE ROMANTIC: They may please Barbara Cartland, but the true romantic scorns heart shaped chocolates, Chanel No. 5, sexy underwear and other fashionable cliches of romance. 
 He spares nothing in pursuit of surprise and mystery. 
 But being romantic can be a health hazard &mdash; threatening both your life and your wallet. 
 Witness the mystery buyer of the world's most expensive teddy bear: a &pound;55,000 present for his wife. 
 The message here is that romantic cliches may safeguard you from a heart attack and prevent you making a fool of yourself. 
 Health hazard ranking: six. 
 THE JOKER: He may also decide to give sexy underwear that doesn't actually fit, or, if he is feeling malicious, spicy chewing gum for the loud mouthed &mdash; gum that cements the lips together. 
 A typical present might be a bomb, or rather a hand-grenade alarm clock. 
 When it goes off you throw it against the wall to stop the noise. 
 The joker, however, gives the present knowing that in the confusion as it goes off, it may be thrown the wrong way &mdash; into the face of the recipient's partner. 
 So beware the joker. 
 HHR: seven. 
 THE BLACKMAILER: The biggest health hazard of them all &mdash; there is at least one in every family. 
 He gives an expensive present to a dying aunt, hoping to be remembered in her will. 
 Always hovering like a vulture around the vulnerable, pressing on them the drinks and fattening foods to make all his dreams come true. 
 HHR: eight. 
 THE MACHO MAN: His present is his presence: his life story, a feel of his biceps, a drunken kiss to any woman who is silly enough to stray within reach of his groping; and, if he is feeling generous, the promise of a night out at his local. 
 Another health hazard. 
 Fill him up with food and booze, direct him to a warm room and then pray hard. 
 HHR: eight. 
 THE DIY BORE: He likes nothing more than to celebrate his talent, big or small. 
 A picture from the artist; a plant from the gardener; a book from the author, obtained at discount (or even free) from the publisher. 
 HHR: four. 
 THE NEW MAN: The term may now be unfashionable, but the man himself is still in evidence. 
 He presents his wife with a food processor or the latest wisdom on toilet training or breast feeding. 
 She spends Christmas wondering if Macho Man really is the pig he is made out to be. 
 HHR: 10. 
 THE PEACEMAKER: He sees gifts as an excellent way of atoning for sins, but can put himself at risk by overstating himself &mdash; giving an exquisite set of English porcelain when a book token would do. 
 His genuine desire to make up may be interpreted as an attempt to embarrass or be-little. 
 His present may trigger the inevitable family festive fall-out usually breaking out somewhere between the Queen's speech at three and the Christmas cake at five. 
 HHR: nine. 
 THE ENTHUSIAST: The biggest bore of them all, and, again, every family has one. 
 His mission in life is to expand the horizons of those around him. 
 The Christmas present gives him one more chance to convert the family to the alleged delights of fly fishing or English cathedrals or war games &mdash; or whatever his confounded passion is (Oxfam shops, however, are very grateful to him). 
 HHR: four. 
 THE IMPROVER: The kids want a bicycle or the Beano annual or the latest computer game. 
 But the improver is into intellectual nourishment on a lavish scale. 
 The kids, aged, typically, eight and nine, are baffled to receive the complete works of Shakespeare, especially when he starts reciting Hamlet over the Christmas pud. 
 HHR: one. 
 THE IMAGE MAKER: Christmas is another opportunity to cultivate perfection &mdash; the right dress, perfectly matched with bewitching accessories. 
 She wants to walk out, but is afraid of &bquo;spoiling&equo; Christmas for the rest of the family. 
 HHR: nine. 
 THE DUTY MAN: Pants, socks et al, with big Christmas bonuses for M&amp;S. 
 The functional never gives away to the festive. 
 Invariably the butt of the family joker, he leaves his wife clamouring for an image maker for a husband. 
 HHR: six. 
 THE REFORMER: Cosmetics for people with skin trouble, watches for bad time keepers, personal organisers for the chaotic &mdash; the reformer is convinced that all the answers are in his hands. 
 HHR: four. 
 Macho Man and The Joker&hellip; the Sylvester Stallone and Jack Nicholson characters would offer gifts likely to endanger health OVERNIGHT FILE 
 If we're not careful we can kiss this goodbye Mistletoe-that old Christmas staple-is dying out. 
 Malcolm Smith explains why. 
 WORSHIPPED by the Druids and used for generations to guarantee a Christmas kiss, mistletoe &mdash; long a traditional part of the festive season &mdash; is dying out. 
 This year, the white-berried twigs with their narrow, leathery leaves are harder to come by and more expensive than ever. 
 And if you do buy a couple of tiny sprigs for &pound;1 it's likely to be French mistletoe. 
 The decline in home-grown mistletoe is the direct result of the continuing loss of yet another typical feature of the English countryside, the apple orchard. 
 Mistletoe grows on old tree branches, preferring the rugged bark of apple trees but also poplars, limes and, occasionally, hedgerow hawthorns. 
 Conifers it detests. 
 Apple trees are its bread and butter in Britain but mistletoe clearly has no meal ticket. 
 In 1957, England had 26,000 hectares of dessert apple orchards. 
 Now, fewer than 14,000 hectares remain. 
 Many of these survivors are not traditional tree orchards at all, but bush varieties on which mistletoe is incapable of gaining a foothold. 
 Cider and culinary apple orchards have gone the same way, all helped along until a few years ago by government grants to grub up the old trees and replace them with easy to spray, prune and pick bush types. 
 A partial parasite, mistletoe relies on birds such as thrushes eating its oily berries and dropping the seeds out at the other end on to the branches of trees where they perch. 
 If it ends up in a bark crevice, the seed may germinate and penetrate the tree. 
 The growing plant partly relies on the host tree for nutrients but it also makes its own by the usual photosynthesis. 
 Evergreen mistletoe stems can be a metre or so long. 
 Mistletoe was once quite common &mdash; as were apple tree orchards &mdash; in eastern and southern England, the south-west and parts of the Midlands. 
 It has always been absent from Scotland and Ireland. 
 Its decline explains why the wholesale price of mistletoe has gone up this year by as much as &pound;15 a hundredweight at England's largest market &mdash; Tenbury Wells in Herefordshire. 
 Nick Champion of Russell, Baldwin and Bright Markets, who run it on the four Tuesdays prior to Christmas and sell several tons a year, says dealers are having to travel far afield to collect mistletoe to sell at Tenbury. 
 Once, they could gather all they needed from orchards in Shropshire, Herefordshire and Worcestershire. 
 Scouring the countryside is bound to deplete it even further. 
 From Tenbury Wells market, mistletoe is sold on to other markets all over Britain. 
 French mistletoe is making big inroads. 
 Covent Garden deals in it, as do many provincial wholesale markets. 
 But nurseryman Peter Summers of Teme Valley Nursery at Tenbury reckons that the English variety is far superior. 
 &bquo;The French mistletoe (exactly the same species) is cut earlier and dries out more because of the distance it comes,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;That is why the berries drop off sooner.&equo; 
 The French, though, have retained far more of their apple orchards. 
 And Napoleon started a useful trend in planting poplars along French roadsides to shade his soldiers from the midday heat. 
 Unless, that is, his motive was to supply the infantry with sprigs of mistletoe to give to their sweethearts at Christmas. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sci 
 Loosemore's Oxford place strains Britain's meagre resources. 
 By Mike Dickson 
 SARAH LOOSEMORE's award of a place at Oxford University means that the British game may again have to contend with the loss of one of its major assets. 
 The 18-year-old from Dinas Powys, currently Britain's best young player, learned this week that she has won a place at St Hilda's College for September 1991 to study physiology and psychology. 
 The award comes after she sacrificed much of her tennis year, including Wimbledon, to take her A levels. 
 After sucessfully completing the exams, she suffered a wrist injury which has virtually written off 1989, with her world ranking slipping to 298. 
 &bquo;I don't regret anything I've done,&equo; she said yesterday after beating Julie Salmon 6-3, 6-3 to win the final of the BWTA Christmas tournament at Queen's club. 
 &bquo;This news has justified the exams and I was thrilled when I heard. 
 I don't want to say much about making any decision. 
 It means I can now play solidly for the next 18 months knowing that tennis is not the be-all and end-all.&equo; 
 There is a considerable drop-out rate in professional women's tennis around the age of 20. 
 Another reasonable prospect in world terms, Annabel Croft, dropped out in 1988 to present television game shows. 
 More recent and less celebrated examples include Teresa Catlin, Lisa Gould and Valda Lake. 
 Those who run the game in Britain will hope fervently that the Cardiff solicitor's daughter does not go the same way. 
 She has the ability and attitude that have raised expectations that British tennis may get the player of star quality it so desperately needs. 
 She had plenty of time to ponder things last night after flying off to Perth where she and Jeremy Bates are the stand-bys for next week's Hopman Cup. 
 Her progress next year should determine whether tennis's loss will be Oxford's gain or vice-versa. 
 Soviet team too costly. 
 THE Soviet team Stroitel Kiev, who were to play in this year's World International Club Championships at Crystal Palace next week, will not now do so after the organisers refused their demand for &pound;1,900-a-game appearance money. 
 A spokeswoman for the competition said: &bquo;We never pay appearance money and that is always made clear in the contracts. 
 So to ask for it is really naughty.&equo; 
 Stroitel will be replaced by Kingston, the current Carlsberg League leaders, who join the New York Lakers, Leverkusen, Solna, Maccabi, Brixton, Bracknell and Oslo. 
 The Chiefs' tank guns for Miami Mark Tran on a new &bquo;humble superstar&equo;. 
 WITH so many teams vying for the play-offs, NLF officials and coaches are going dizzy trying to calculate the permutations. 
 &bquo;In the seven years I've been doing this, there's never been anything like it. 
 It's driving me positively ga-ga,&equo; said Peter Abitante of the AFC, where 11 out of 14 teams still harbour play-off hopes, including all four teams in the AFC Central Division. 
 This is the former NFL commissioner Pete Rozelle's much-cherished parity run amok. 
 Heading into the last weekend of the regular season, a record 17 out of 28 teams remain in play-off contention. 
 When the dust or the snow settles, the play-offs will comprise 10 teams &mdash; six division winners and two wild-card teams (the best of the rest) from each conference. 
 So far, only San Francisco, Denver and the New York Giants have made sure of play-off slots. 
 One of the long shots for a wild card are the Kansas City Chiefs, who have to beat Miami on Christmas Eve while others lose. 
 However, even if they do not make the play-offs, the Chiefs have achieved a degree of respectability that has eluded them in past seasons. 
 A large reason for their success lies in their 28-year-old running-back Christian Okoye, the surprise rusher of the season. 
 Originally from Enugu, Nigeria, Okoye's combination of bulk (almost 19 stone) and speed (4.48sec for 40yards) make him a human tank. 
 &bquo;To feel the force he runs with is amazing,&equo; says the Kansas tackle Irv Eatman. 
 &bquo;He has slammed into my back on running plays a few times, and the only way I can describe what it feels like is to imagine standing on the street and getting hit by a car going 50 miles an hour. 
 And he's just getting a head of steam. 
 Imagine what's it's like to tackle him.&equo; 
 The Seattle Seahawks know what it is like following their game in October. 
 Starting on the Seahawk 13, Okoye shrugged off an arm tackle from one linebacker and flipped another on to his back at the 11. 
 Two other defenders made a grab for Okoye but missed. 
 Two more made a futile dive for Okoye's legs at the five and he evaded a final defender at the goal-line. 
 He had just ploughed through seven Seahawks. 
 Of course, having a good offensive line helps and the coach Marty Schottenheimer has inherited one of the NLF's most underrated offensive units, averaging 6ft 5in and over 20 stone. 
 They prefer to block aggressively, opening the way for the run, instead of playing on their heels, containing pass rushers. 
 With Schottenheimer favouring the ground game, in contrast to his predecessors who leaned towards the pass, Okoye's career has flourished. 
 In only his third season, Okoye is still learning. 
 He runs too upright, relies too much on sheer strength instead of evading defenders, and so takes too many hits. 
 Most tacklers bounce off him, but the bumps take their toll. 
 &bquo;I am very sore on Monday,&equo; he says. 
 Okoye also tends to fumble, because he does not protect the ball enough. 
 Okoye has endeared himself to team-mates and fans not only through his play on the field but through his incredibly modest behaviour off it. 
 Described by his colleagues as a humble superstar, Okoye earns a relatively modest &dollar;215,000 (&pound;145,000) a year. 
 But his attitude is downright un-American. 
 &bquo;Being too rich can be a problem. 
 Man does not live by money alone,&equo; he says. 
 His opposition to premarital sex &mdash; he and his university sweetheart stay in separate rooms &mdash; adds to the eccentric image. 
 But the way he is playing football, no one is complaining. 
 Sunshine break for Harris. 
 TIM HARRIS, the national professional road-race champion who has been left out in the cold by British team sponsors, will be basking in Spanish sunshine next year, writes Graham Snowdon. 
 Harris, who last season captained the Raleigh-Banana team which has now been disbanded, announced yesterday that he had been offered a contract by the Spanish Lotus-Festina squad. 
 &bquo;I have got a very good deal, and it came virtually out of the blue,&equo; said the Doncaster-based rider, who until last week thought his future lay with a new team being planned in Belgium. 
 The luck of Lyle's caddie in picking the right year David Davies does a round of golf's library and rejoices in one man's rub of the green. 
 ON the golf course, 1989 was a vintage to declare and may well be the source of good things to come in the publishing world. 
 But, although the game continues to produce books by the yard, only one this year made any impact on a library already overstocked with histories and instruction tomes, and even that was published back in April. 
 Life With Lyle by Sandy Lyle's caddie, Dave Musgrove, breaks the mould, being a record, kept by Musgrove, of their times together during a period when Lyle won three events in America, including the US Masters, and three events in Europe, including the World Match Play Championship. 
 Such books are a good idea usually frustrated by circumstances. 
 A 1987 book on the four major championships, done for the British market, had as its winners Larry Mize, Scott Simpson, Nick Faldo and Larry Nelson &mdash; three bores out of four. 
 The following year would have yielded Lyle, Curtis Strange, Severiano Ballesteros and Jeff Sluman &mdash; only one bore out of four. 
 Where Musgrove and John Hopkins, who put it all together, got lucky was that they chronicled a period of success that may never have been equalled, let alone exceeded, by any British golfer. 
 All those wins, plus being top of the US Money List for 133 days &mdash; it was a fabulous run and it is all faithfully recorded, providing on second reading a clue as to why Lyle is now having trouble hitting his hat. 
 In addition to the wins, Lyle was in contention almost permanently and the pressure, for close on 18 months, was immense. 
 He is now undergoing a re-couping, re-generating process. 
 He will surely be back. 
 Some browsing books for the enthusiast have arrived on the market, and a couple for the fanatic. 
 Into the latter category comes John Ball of Hoylake by John Behrend. 
 Ball was the first amateur and the first Englishman to win the Open, at Prestwick in 1890, but the kind of loving research that has to go into books of this type invariably makes fascinating reading. 
 There is also a re-issue of The Encyclopaedia of Golf Collectibles, revealing that a matched set of irons, &bquo;Harmonised Irons&equo;, could be obtained from MacGregor way back in 1926, and that golf balls coloured oriole orange and canary yellow were available from Wilson in 1928. 
 There are lots more facts like that. 
 For the browsers there is Golf: The Golden Years, a pictorial anthology by Sarah Baddiel celebrating the last few years of the 19th century and the first 40 or so of the 20th. 
 This is probably the best value of the Christmas publications. 
 Another in the same mould is Golf's Lighter Side, a selection of articles from Golf Illustrated from the last 100 years. 
 In The Best of Golf Peter Alliss and Bob Ferrier deal with the great players and the great deeds, plus some lesser and more interesting ones. 
 I particularly enjoyed the chapter on Cyril James Hastings Tolley. 
 He was good enough to be in six Walker Cup teams, sufficiently well heeled to be of independent means and later a Captain of the Royal and Ancient. 
 The authors have recorded an interview with him, reproduced verbatim. 
 The Official History of the Ryder Cup by Michael Williams is well researched and therefore surprisingly interesting while Ryder Cup &bquo;89 conveys the atmosphere of the event rather better than most instant histories. 
 There is the usual wodge of instructional stuff which, in general, is a waste of paper. 
 No book can do in two hours what any club's teaching professional can do in two minutes, and that, perhaps surprisingly, goes for the video too. 
 Golfers who know go to their pro. 
 Life With Lyle by David Musgrove; Heinemann Kingswood, &pound;12.95. 
 John Ball of Hoylake by John Behrend; Grant Books, Droitwich, &pound;18. 
 The Encyclopaedia of Golf Collectibles; Gazelle Book Services, Lancaster, &pound;11.50. 
 Golf: The Golden Years by Sarah Baddiel; Bracken Books, &pound;7.95. 
 Golf's Lighter Side; Lennard Books, &pound;10.95. 
 The Best of Golf by Peter Alliss and Bob Ferrier; Partridge Press, &pound;17.95. 
 The Official History of the Ryder Cup by Michael Williams; Stanley Paul, &pound;14.95. 
 Ryder Cup &bquo;89; Virgin, &pound;9.95. 
 Protests put Britain in lead. 
 By Bob Fisher 
 WITH only the Sydney-Hobart race to come, Britain leads the NorTel Southern Cross Cup series. 
 The lead changed hands after an excellent result by the three-boat team in the fifth race and some protest decisions from earlier racing. 
 It was certainly Britain's day yesterday in the 25-mile race around an Olympic course outside Sydney Heads. 
 Mike Peacock's 45ft Juno IV, skippered by Mike McIntyre, revelled in the choppy seas and 14-17 knot south-easterly breeze. 
 The Tony Castro-designed Juno IV was comfortably ahead of the other boats of her size and won on handicap by over a minute. 
 It was an all-round performance by Juno IV. 
 McIntyre was able to drive her almost as fast to windward as the 50-footers and lost nothing on the downwind legs. 
 At the finish, after nearly four hours of racing, Juno IV had lost only nine minutes to the leading 50-footer and was three minutes ahead of her close rival, Peter Kurts's Madeline's Daughter from New South Wales. 
 Alan Bond's Drumbeat led the fleet home, finishing almost 45 minutes ahead of Juno IV but was placed fifth on corrected time. 
 Heaven Can Wait, skippered by Harold Cudmore, led her group, finishing third overall on corrected time. 
 With Eddie Warden Owen 11th in Canon Express, Britain took second place. 
 But after the protest of the Hong Kong yacht Foo 2 against Cyclone for an infringement in the fourth race was heard, Cyclone was penalised nine places. 
 That put Britain into the lead and leaves the battle for the cup between Britain and the New South Wales team, as the Australian national side suffered several disasters. 
 First, the 40ft Southern Cross had to pull out of the race with rigging problems; Prime Factor was recalled at the start; and the third boat, Sagacious V, faces another protest which is likely to see her heavily penalised. 
 Already the Australian team are 64 points, or 13 places in the long final race, behind Britain, the 1985 winners. 
 The 630-mile NorTel Sydney to Hobart starts on Boxing Day. 
 TEAM POINTS (provisional after five races): 1, UK 469.5; 2, NSW 463; 3, Australia 405.5; 4, Hong Kong 394.5; 5, West Australia 363; 6. 
 Victoria 312; 7, USSR 91.5. 
 Lord Lichfield will not be racing aboard Rothmans when the third leg of the Whitbread race starts from Fremantle tomorrow. 
 The skipper Lawrie Smith has decided that the 3,450-mile leg is too crucial to drop one of the regular crew of 16 in favour of his sponsor's official photographer. 
 McLean may act as Scotland's spy. 
 By Patrick Glenn 
 DUNDEE UNITED have been invited to Central America to face Costa Rica, the dark horses in Scotland's group in the World Cup finals. 
 If the match takes place &mdash; some time next month has been suggested &mdash; it will provide ideal circumstances under which Andy Roxburgh, the national coach, may watch Costa Rica for the first time. 
 United, led by Scotland's former assistant manager, Jim McLean, will decide at a board meeting this morning whether or not to accept the role of fifth columnists for the Scots in the build-up to Italy. 
 Ernie Walker, the SFA secretary, confirmed yesterday that there would be no objections from the authorities if United decide to go. 
 McLean said: &bquo;It really would be great if we could fit in such a match. 
 It is a great compliment and a chance for us to find out about Costa Rica.&equo; 
 United could also do England a favour by accepting another offer, this time from Egypt, for a match at Tannadice later in the season. 
 The Egyptians are in England's World Cup section. 
 They plan a tour of Britain to familiarise themselves with the British style and the first place they wish to stop is Dundee for the game with United. 
 That will be decided later, when the Egyptians reveal their itinerary. 
 The Scottish League management committee yesterday came out officially against the idea of a winter shut-down, but promised to canvass all 38 member clubs for their views. 
 &bquo;There is no groundswell of opinion in favour of a break,&equo; said the secretary Jim Farry, &bquo;so we will continue with the present principle of playing when we can, and at the same time continue to exhort clubs to improve the fans&equo; comfort. 
 It was recognised that the vagaries of the weather make pre-selection of a period for a close-down impossible.&equo; 
 Racing: Scudamore and punters are keen on Bonanza Boy. 
 By Chris Hawkins 
 YAHOO, a length and a half runner-up to Desert Orchid in last season's Cheltenham Gold Cup, is being heavily backed to take his revenge in Boxing Day's King George VI Chase at Kempton, and Coral's yesterday cut him to 6-1 from 10-1 after laying him to lose &pound;40,000. 
 Soft ground is essential for Yahoo and conditions should be to his liking, although if he could not beat Desert Orchid in the Cheltenham bog it is difficult to visualise him doing it at Kempton. 
 Pegwell Bay, who will be ridden by Carl Llewellyn, has also attracted support and is 6-1 from 7-1, while in the face of this Desert Orchid has eased from 8-15 to 8-13. 
 There seems to be plenty of confidence between topweight Bonanza Boy in tomorrow's Coral Welsh National and last year's winner is now 3-1 joint favourite with Ghofar following two bets of &pound;7,000 to &pound;2,000 with the sponsors. 
 That confidence was echoed by Peter Scudamore when I spoke to him at Towcester yesterday. 
 He poohed-poohed the suggestion that Bonanza Boy had too much weight, commenting: &bquo;The distance is the key, he'll love it. 
 Three miles is too short for him.&equo; 
 There are no problems at Chepstow at the moment but if itfalls foul of the weather, Bonanza Boy will be re-routed to the King George at Kempton. 
 Incidentally, there will be an 8.30am inspection today to determine prospects for tomorrow's meeting at Hereford. 
 Following heavy rain the meeting is in danger. 
 Clerk of the Course Bob Davies said: &bquo;We could not have raced today.&equo; 
 Jenny Pitman's Do Be Brief stepped onto a racecourse for the first time in the first division of the Christmas Pudding Novice Hurdle and made quite an impression in beating Sailor's Luck, but not half as big as his stable-companion Egypt Mill, who looked something special in landing the second division by 10 lengths. 
 Egypt Mill is a lovely, big horse by Deep Run and looks worth every penny of the 30,000gns he cost at the Ballsbridge Sales last year. 
 Established stable star, Golden Freeze, who misses the King George after grazing a knee in a fall on the road, has responded well to antibiotics and is expected to be sidelined for only two weeks, but this injury and all the firm ground have made a mess of Mrs Pitman's plans. 
 Golden Freeze is not well handicapped and has gone up 4lb since finishing second to Joint Sovereignty in the Mackeson. 
 This means handicaps are out for him in the immediate future and conditions races will have to be the order of the day on the run-up to Cheltenham. 
 &bquo;Its still either the Gold Cup or National for him. 
 We'll have to see,&equo; said assistant David Stait. 
 &bquo;But on a point of handicapping, why has he been raised 4lb after finishing second in the Mackeson, while Desert Orchid has been dropped 2lb for finishing second to Long Engagement?&equo; 
 The answer to that is probably that Long Engagement was 15lb out of the handicap at Sandown and Desert Orchid therefore achieved relatively less. 
 Nicky Henderson's Mr Gossip justified favouritism and made a winning debut over fences in the second division of the Misletoe Novice Chase but it was only by a head that he got home from Bit Of A Clown, with Bronze Final a head away third. 
 Mr Gossip jumped left at his fences which mystified Henderson, who said he has not done it before. 
 The answer is probably to run him on a left hand track where such antics would not cost him so much ground. 
 Henderson is genuinely optimisitc about his triple Champion Hurdler, See You Then, who will be ten at the turn of the year, making a comeback next month. 
 The gelding's career seemed to be over when he broke down badly in the spring of 1988. 
 He was promptly retired but has made a remarkable recovery. 
 &bquo;He needs at least two or three races if he's to have a go at the Champion again. 
 But it is either the Champion or nothing. 
 If he's not up to it there's no question of him running in anything else,&equo; said Henderson. 
 A cricket landmark vanishes with the final over for Gover Matthew Engel pays tribute to the academy which kept a straight bat for 61 years 
 TOMORROW afternoon, on the last shopping day before Christmas &mdash; perhaps the least cricketing day of the entire calendar &mdash; one of London's sporting institutions will close its doors forever. 
 Alf Gover has decided to retire and the Gover Cricket School in Wandsworth is to be demolished. 
 Gover prefers it that way: he could not imagine anyone else running the place. 
 Wisden says he is nearly 82; he still looks nothing of the kind, but lately he has started to feel it a little more. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry,&equo; he says, &bquo;but you can't kick against the breeze. 
 Three years ago, I was fine. 
 You start to think you're immortal. 
 But there have been one or two things this year.&equo; 
 His wife Marjorie puts it more graphically: &bquo;It's not &bquo;Come on, let's get upstairs&equo; any more. 
 It's &bquo;Ooh, we've got to get up those stairs&equo;.&equo; 
 It is the end of a very long era. 
 The school was opened in 1928 by two other Surrey eminences, Andy Sandham and Herbert Strudwick. 
 Gover took over from Strudwick in 1938 and has run it himself since 1954. 
 Since then it has become a complete family business. 
 Marjorie does the books; their son John runs the shop and helps with the coaching; his wife Janie does the typing, and when I was in the office the lad who brought in the post said &bquo;There you are, Grandad&equo; and turned out to be John's son, James. 
 But Alf Gover has become a sort of universal grandad. 
 No one has ever worn an England sweater longer. 
 He only played in four Tests but the sweater (and his knotted silk scarf) became his uniform. 
 He has got through a dozen of them over the years and generations of cricketers have passed by. 
 It is not entirely true to say everyone who is anyone has been coached there, but a heck of a lot have &mdash; Frank Tyson, Fred Titmus, Ted Dexter, Viv Richards and the teenage Ken Barrington, who hung around day after day asking questions. 
 Fewer of the modern English pros have come by, partly because most counties now have their indoor nets, partly because fashions change. 
 But foreign players have remained keen: the West Indians Phil Simmons and Ian Bishop are among recent customers. 
 But the Gover School has never depended on major names. 
 The speciality has always been genuinely private tuition, one-to-one coaching for anyone willing to pay (&pound;16 an hour at the end) whether brilliant or hopeless. 
 Most cricket schools prefer group therapy. 
 For their money, they got traditional advice &mdash; Gover would always try to get batsmen to live up to the technical ideal of Jack Hobbs &mdash; put in an unstuffy and flexible way: &bquo;We would fit the mould to the customers, not the other way round.&equo; 
 Gover is now planning to write his memoirs, which will cover quite a range of cricketing experience. 
 He reported three tours of Australia for the Sunday Pictorial and was the radio summariser with Alston, Arlott and Swanton for the Tests in the early Fifties. 
 His book will not just be the usual lament for the good old days, either: Gover first advocated one-day cricket in 1938. 
 Meanwhile, the old building will come down. 
 It has always looked a bit ramshackle, with its claustrophobic nets, which were gas-lit until the 1960s. 
 It will be replaced, most probably, by a modern sports centre which will have no room for cricket. 
 Gover is matter-of-fact about it, but 61 years is a long time. 
 Above the roar of the South Circular Road traffic I swear it will always be possible to hear the thwack of bat on ball and the occasional rasp of &bquo;One to drive&equo;. 
 Hampson is given ten-week ban after third sending off. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 STEVE HAMPSON, the Wigan and Great Britain full-back, was suspended for 10 matches by the disciplinary committee yesterday after being sent off for a head tackle in Saturday's Regal Trophy quarter-final with at Leeds. 
 He had a good idea of what was coming. 
 After the match he was asked what punishment he thought he might receive. 
 &bquo;Let's say that I'm booking my holidays for January,&equo; he replied. 
 Hampson, who had not been sent off prior to this season, has had a wretched past seven weeks. 
 He was dismissed in the opening minutes of Great Britain's third Test with New Zealand for head-butting and sent off the following day for tripping Castleford's Steve Larder. 
 Those offences cost him four matches. 
 Since then the League have been punishing heavily anyone guilty of illegal high tackles, with eight-match suspensions being the normal currency. 
 And when Hampson brought the Leeds hooker, Colin Maskill, to the ground with just such a tackle he must have known that the rest of his season would be cut short. 
 Widnes meantime, according to their coach, Doug Laughton, have accused the League of treating them &bquo;shabbily&equo; over the Joe Grima affair, perhaps the most two-faced quote of the Eighties. 
 The League ruled that the striking off of Grima from the Widnes register and an attempt to replace him with the Tongan forward, Boblyn Tuavao, was &bquo;unacceptable&equo;. 
 To which Widnes have countered with three pages of questions to League headquarters, demanding answers. 
 Grima says that he is simply grateful that he has started to work off his eight-match suspension. 
 More disciplinary problems loom with the news that Alan Burke, the referee, has reported a brawl in Sunday's match between Batley and Trafford Borough &mdash; a game in which five players were sent off. 
 England may well save a place for in-form goalkeeper Clark. 
 By Pat Rowley 
 AN England cap may be the prompt reward for John Clark, who kept goal so well for East Grinstead in the Birmingham Midshires International Indoor tournament last weekend. 
 The national selectors indicated before England's unexpected success in the HDM international tournament at The Hague that they wanted to test other members of their squad before the team is announced for the first official internationals of the season, the Four Nation tournament at Crystal Palace in a month's time. 
 Neither Andy Forshaw nor Martin Langston stood out in the HDM event, so Clark, for so long on the fringe of national selection, could get his chance for England in the Buttermen Indoor tournament at Crystal Palace on December 29-30. 
 The other two goalkeepers in the England squad, David Luckes and Craig Winter, are sure to be on view at the Buttermen tournament, playing for England juniors and Bromley respectively. 
 In Pool A for the Buttermen tournament will be Roses (England), Harborne, Hounslow and Teddington, while Pool B will comprise England Juniors, Bromley, Fareham and Swansea. 
 The selectors have the opportunity to strengthen the England side with three World Cup reserves &mdash; Rob Thompson, Rupert Welch and Don Williams &mdash; who were unavailable previously because of World Cup training. 
 The draw for the new European Cup Winners' Cup is to be made today. 
 England's qualifiers, Hounslow, learned yesterday that their qualifier at Easter will be in either Barcelona or Stuttgart. 
 The venue for the second qualifier is yet to be decided, but the winners of the two qualifiers will meet in the final during the European Cup for Club (League) Champions at Frankfurt in June. 
 St Albans wait to hear the draw for the first official European Club Indoor Championship at Amiens in March, when their rivals will include Amsterdam, Holywood &bquo;87 (Ireland), MIM (Scotland), Swansea and Rot-Weiss Cologne. 
 By Patrick Agnew in Cagliari 
 DESPITE the encouragement of 65 degrees of bright Sardinian sunshine, Italy and Argentina contrived a predictable bout of pre-World Cup shadow boxing here yesterday and played out a dull if meaningful draw in a match dominated by the defences. 
 Neither team deserved to win. 
 The Argentinian goalkeeper, Pumpido, had a much busier afternoon than his Italian counterparts, Zenga and Tacconi. 
 Pumpido had to make two saves while neither of the Italians need have been there at all. 
 Although Argentina started ominously well, finding a lot of space down the Italian right, neither of the two front players, Dezotti and Maradona, looked likely to score before Christmas 1990. 
 What little excitement there was for the colourful Cagliari crowd of 30,000 came from the Italian midfielder Giannini. 
 On the half-hour he got on the end of a short pass from Vialli on the edge of the penalty area and hit a fine shot that brought an equally fine save from Pumpido. 
 In the second half Giannini again created the best moment, first intercepting a pass, then setting up Serena for the clearest chance of the match. 
 But Pumpido was again alert, coming quickly off his line to close down Serena. 
 In terms of penalty-area action that was about it. 
 The rest of the match, however, was not wholly uneventful. 
 Tough marking by the Argentinian defenders Batista, Monzon and Simon meant that the Soviet referee A Spirin, and the Italian magic sponge were kept busy. 
 Commenting afterwards on this unfriendly aspect to a so-called friendly, the Argentinian coach Carlos Bilardo explained: &bquo;Games like this are friendly in name only. 
 I had guys like Simon, Monzon, Dezotti and others all desperately trying to play their way into my World Cup team. 
 The same applies to some of the Italians. 
 In circumstances like that no one wants to make a mistake and no one is going to take things casually.&equo; 
 He seemed happier than his opposite number Azeglio Vicini. 
 Though the match might have been short of entertainment, it was full of information from a technical viewpoint. 
 The sharp running and creative midfield work of Giusti and Burruchaga was a sweet sight for Bilardo. 
 Two of his 1986 World Cup winning heroes are back, as good as ever. 
 Another two, the defenders Batista and Ruggeri, have never been away. 
 They gave Vialli, Donadoni and Mancini a combative afternoon. 
 There was further satisfaction for Bilardo in the performance of less experienced players. 
 On his international debut the sweeper Simon looked the genuine article, while the central defender Monzon showed he can compensate for a lack of height with good positioning and excellent timing. 
 With all this reassurance Bilardo could afford the luxury of being relatively unconcerned about Maradona's performance. 
 According to the match programme Maradona was on the pitch, wearing the No.10 shirt. 
 The rumour cannot, however, be confirmed. 
 He can never have been more anonymous. 
 This was partly due to the excellent marking job by his Napoli team-mate Ferrara but possibly also due to off-field distractions. 
 His mind seems currently more on organising Hollywood-type weddings, extended holidays and wondering about the legality of the World Cup draw. 
 The worrying thing for other World Cup teams next summer is that, if and when Maradona recovers his best form &mdash; and he will most likely do so in June &mdash; then the rest of the Argentina side looks ready to set him up for another stupendous tournament. 
 It is hard to see what comfort Vicini will have derived. 
 He said he was happy that his side had done most of the attacking. 
 On the day, though, that was a small achievement. 
 He also admitted that on the balance of their performances against Brazil, England and Argentina this autumn, his side clearly lacked that extra something. 
 He must be hoping that the stimulus of playing the World Cup at home will provide the extra sparkle. 
 And so say 55 million Italians. 
 ITALY: Zenga; Bergomi, Maldini (De Agostini, 46min), Baresi, Ferrara, Berti, Donadoni (M Mancini, 46), De Napoli, Vialli (Fusi, 77), Giannini, Serena. 
 ARGENTINA: Pumpido; Ruggeri, Simon, Monzon, Olarticochea, Giusti, Batista, Basualdo (Troglio, 39), Burruchaga, Maradona, Dezotti (Caniggia, 81). 
 Referee: A Spirin (USSR). 
 Prean still the man to beat. 
 By Richard Jago 
 CARL PREAN, the man whose name does not appear in the English rankings, again showed that he is the country's current outstanding player by beating Desmond Douglas to win the Macartney and Dowie Classic in Brentwood yesterday. 
 Prean, who objects to the way the rankings are calculated, saw Douglas overcome the titleholder and England No.1, Alan Cooke, in the semi-finals, and then beat the 10-times former national champion 21-19, 19-21, 21-10 with a forceful forehand attack. 
 But Prean had been fortunate to survive from 10-15 down in the final game in the semi-final against the England No.3, Nicky Mason, who had beaten him last year, while Douglas, weakened by a stomach upset, survived a hard three games with Prean at the round-robin stage. 
 The 34-year-old still managed to win 21-17, 21-9 against Cooke, who has been struggling to find his best form all season. 
 David Lacey on the anti-climactic run-out at Rotterdam No samba in Brazil's new step. 
 BRAZIL's 1-0 victory over what amounted to a Holland B team in Rotterdam on Wednesday night continued the process of pragmatic regeneration they have undergone since the desultory performances in Europe last summer which left some observers wondering whether they would qualify for the World Cup at all. 
 Happily for their manager Sebastiao Lazaroni, the Brazilians are now unbeaten in 15 games and embarked on a run which they hope will carry them to Turin next summer on a wave of confidence and efficiency. 
 Sweden and Costa Rica must already be bracing themselves for a high tide. 
 Scotland, too, although the state of their sea defences will depend on the course the opening phase has taken by the time the countries meet on June 20. 
 Bobby Robson will be more immediately concerned with the mood and strength of the Brazilians when they come to Wembley on March 28. 
 While the match is only another World Cup warm-up, it is likely to be more of a searching test of England's potential than last month's goalless draw with Italy. 
 Of course that goes even more for the game against Holland in Cagliari on June 16, but on Wednesday the Dutch, deprived of most of their foreign-based players, were in no position to provide fresh portents. 
 Robson, who saw Brazil beat the Italians 1-0 in Bologna in October, flew on to Cagliari disappointed at the spectacle in the Feyenoord Stadium but impressed with Brazil's organisation. 
 &bquo;They're going to be very difficult to break down,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They beat Holland the same way they beat Italy, by defending tightly with a sweeper and breaking away cleverly to score. 
 I don't think they'll concede the sort of easy goals they have allowed in past World Cups.&equo; 
 While agreeing broadly with the England manager's summing-up of the present Brazilian team, the thought did occur that in another footballing era he could have been describing an Italian side &mdash; brilliant in breakaways but giving nothing away at the back. 
 When Brazil beat Italy 4-1 in the final of the 1970 World Cup the style of their triumph was a cry of defiance against the organisation men, the managers and coaches who insisted on getting things right in defence before even thinking about the imaginative attacking play which should be the game's apotheosis at this level. 
 An impudent, illogical backheel by Clodoaldo inside his own half, for instance, allowed Boninsegna to steal an Italian equaliser before Gerson's wonderful goal restored Brazil's lead and Pele and Carlos Alberto completed a triumph which said everything about the samba approach to football. 
 Only the other day Robson was criticising Paul Gascoigne for attempting a similar back-heeled flick during England's B match against Yugoslavia&hellip; could be costly, might give the other side a goal, must cut out that sort of thing, and so on. 
 In strategic terms the England manager, who does not have a Gerson or Pele to bail his team out of the trouble caused by such indiscretions, was right, but if you drive the idiosyncrasies out of football altogether what is left can be grey indeed, which is what one finds a little disconcerting about the present Brazilian side. 
 They pass the ball sweetly, create space effortlessly, and in Alemao, Branco, Valdo, Dunga, Mozer and Jorginho possess players who should give them a formidable momentum next summer. 
 But after watching Brazil for a total of three hours, few gems of individualism stayed in the memory. 
 The free-kick from Cruz that beat Italy was one, and the run and cross from Jorginho which led to Careca heading the winner in Rotterdam another, but in these games Brazil have impressed as a team without making you want to leap out of your seat as Pele once did. 
 Still, Lazaroni has to be given credit for absorbing the pan-Europeanism of his squad into something the Europeans will need to be aware of in Italy. 
 This Brazilian team can mark and tackle with a cool realism that their 1974 World Cup side never achieved in West Germany, when toughness became confused with thuggery. 
 Wednesday's match marked the Dutch football federation's centenary, although considering the side Holland were forced to field, Queen Beatrix might just as well have stayed at home and sent the centenarians a congratulatory telegram. 
 It was a bit like going to the Rijksmuseum to see the original Rembrandts and being shown postcards instead. 
 Boxing. 
 Tony Wilson, whose previous fight ended in farce when his mother climbed into the ring and attacked his opponent, made an orthodox return to the ring last night. 
 The former former British light-heavyweight champion from Wolverhampton stopped Dave Lawrence in six rounds at Birmingham in a warm-up for his final eliminator with Southampton's Steve McCarthy for the right to challenge Tom Collins. 
 Athletics. 
 Carl Lewis, the American 100 metres and long jump Olympic champion, has filed a &pound;120 million libel suit against the West German magazine Stern and a former team-mate, Darrell Robinson, a 400 metres runner, for a story which alleged Lewis used steroids to improve his performances. 
 He finished second in the 100 metres to Canada's Ben Johnson, later disqualified after failing a drug test. 
 Table Tennis. 
 Simion Crisan, a Romanian international, has defected and asked for political asylum in West Germany. 
 The West German club TTC Juelich said that Crisan, 27, had fled from his homeland and joined them. 
 Tennis. 
 Boris Becker has been confirmed as a definite starter at next month's New South Wales Open in Sydney. 
 Ivan Lendl, Mats Wilander and Yannick Noah will also be playing in the event. 
 Cycling. 
 The Belgian team ADR are to sue Greg Lemond after the American left them for their French rivals Z. Lemond, the Tour de France winner and world champion, was lured to Z in September for a record &pound;3.5million fee, having served only half of his two-year contract with the Belgian team. 
 Olympic Games. 
 The East German Sports Federation is supporting an Olympic bid by Berlin for the Games of either 2000 or 2004. 
 Manfred von Richthofen, president of the West Berlin Federation, said a committee will be set up to examine the possibility of a bid from the city. 
 Fifa brands Maradona &bquo;stupid&equo;. 
 DIEGO MARADONA's claim that the World Cup draw was rigged was yesterday dismissed as &bquo;stupid&equo; by Fifa. 
 &bquo;What Maradona said is the most stupid declaration of the Eighties by a football player,&equo; said the Fifa spokesman Guido Tognoni, who added that no disciplinary action would be taken against the player. 
 The Argentina captain said yesterday he was unrepentant, but added: &bquo;If I have to say sorry I will,&equo; for his remarks on Tuesday that he believed the draw was decided in advance, putting Argentina in the hardest group. 
 Prost's racing glove conceals an iron fist Alan Henry finds that the three-times world champion does not pull many punches in his candid tale of life on the grand prix circuit. 
 IT is probably all for the good that Alain Prost left McLaren to join Ferrari at the end of the season because I doubt his autobiography, Life in the Fast Lane, will be nestling in the McLaren chief Ron Dennis's Christmas stocking. 
 The three-times world champion has a good tale to tell and, while the format could have done with more meat on the bones, this volume certainly does not pull any punches. 
 Yet throughout the narrative, Prost's awareness of the dividing line between professional respect and personal friendship is firmly evident. 
 Among other things he chastises Renault for their failure to respond to BMW's challenge which led to him losing the 1983 world championship, chides Dennis for his lack of punctuality and disinterest in anything that is not his own idea and expresses his admiration and respect for Niki Lauda, with whom he was partnered in 1984. 
 These are but a handful of key motor racing personalities round whom Prost weaves an absorbing range of anecdotes and gossip. 
 My favourite is one tale Prost tells against himself. 
 Beaten into second place by his team-mate Rene Arnoux in the 1982 French Grand Prix, he pulled into a service station on his way home only for the attendant to mistake him for his rival. 
 &bquo;Well done Monsieur Arnoux,&equo; says the man, &bquo;that Prost is a proper little prick &mdash; he had it coming.&equo; 
 Thinking on his feet, Prost whipped out a fistful of cash, sparing both of them the embarrassment had he paid by credit card. 
 His lukewarm relationship with Ayrton Senna comes across firmly, particularly bearing in mind that this book closes with the end of the 1988 season. 
 At least Senna and Honda can be grateful for that&hellip; 
 Their troubled relationship with Prost notwithstanding, Honda's successful assault on the bastions of Formula One is admirably chronicled by Christopher Hilton in Conquest of Formula One, although his somewhat hectoring style makes the first few pages something of a battle. 
 Yet Hilton has approached the story from a refreshingly energetic and revealing standpoint, his exhaustive researches producing hitherto unrevealed nuggets about the pioneering years of the Honda's Formula One involvement. 
 The photographic content, and captioning, left something to be desired, though. 
 I bet he wishes he could re-write the one which reads: &bquo;They liked and respected each other,&equo; referring to a photograph of Prost and Senna. 
 For those tiring of today's political grand prix scene, Gerald Donaldson's Gilles Villeneuve &mdash; The Life of the Legendary Racing Driver represents a long-overdue memorial to the heroic Canadian driver who was killed seven years ago practising in his Ferrari for the Belgian Grand Prix. 
 Donaldson, whose previous works have included a biography of the Canadian skier, Steve Podborski, has quizzed just about every available friend, colleague and observer of Villeneuve's. 
 The result is a sympathetic and charmingly balanced profile of this charismatic driver whose uninhibited spirit at the wheel made him so compelling to watch. 
 As Lauda remarked: &bquo;He was someone I took a great liking to, the craziest devil I ever came across in F1.&equo; 
 Lauda crops up again in Maurice Hamilton's informative tome The British Grand Prix, an absorbing record of this country's most important fixture on the international racing calendar. 
 At first glance, you may wonder how the history of a single event could possibly be spun out to fill a 255-page epic, but this is far from a specialist lap-by-lap potted report of each race. 
 Although the official world championship did not start until 1950, Hamilton has wisely used a broader brush with excellent effect to put the race in an accurate historical perspective. 
 He starts with the pioneering days at Brooklands and has taken care not to omit the Donington grands prix in 1937-38 where Germany's Auto Unions and Mercedes were so dominant. 
 If you prefer some lighter reading to re-awaken forgotten memories, Nigel Roebuck's Inside Formula One is to be highly recommended. 
 Its title is rather misleading, for it amounts to an anthology of Roebuck's weekly columns which have appeared over the years in the motor racing magazine, Autosport. 
 Informative, sensitive, irascible and perceptive, Roebuck has distilled the flavour of grand prix racing in the Eighties. 
 Life in the Fast Lane, by Alain Prost (Stanley Paul, 12.95). 
 Conquest of Formula One, by Christopher Hilton (Patrick Stephens, 16.95). 
 Gilles Villeneuve &mdash; The Life of the Legendary Racing Driver, by Gerald Donaldson (McLelland &amp; Stewart, &pound;14.95). 
 The British Grand Prix, by Maurice Hamilton (The Crowood Press 17.95). 
 Inside Formula One, by Nigel Roebuck (Patrick Stephens, 14.95). 
 Sport in brief Table Tennis. 
 Simion Crisan, a Romanian international, has defected and asked for political asylum in West Germany. 
 The West German club TTC Juelich said that Crisan, 27, had fled from his homeland and joined them. 
 Tennis. 
 Boris Becker has been confirmed as a definite starter at next month's New South Wales Open in Sydney. 
 Ivan Lendl, Mats Wilander and Yannick Noah will also be playing in the event.. 
 Cycling. 
 The Belgian team ADR are to sue Greg Lemond after the American left them for their French rivals Z. Lemond, the Tour de France winner and world champion, was lured to Z in September for a record &pound;3.5million fee, having served only half of his two-year contract with the Belgian team. 
 Olympic Games. 
 The East German Sports Federation is supporting an Olympic bid by Berlin for the Games of either 2000 or 2004. 
 Manfred von Richthofen, president of the West Berlin Federation, said a committee will be set up to examine the possibility of a bid from the city. 
 PAGE 
 Green with envy for Norway. 
 By Stephen Lee 
 IT SEEMS the last Christmas of the decade will be more green than white. 
 The best area in Switzerland is the Grisons. 
 In the Engadin, Diavolezza is mostly open with new snow, Celerina has 15cm lower and 50cm upper slopes, Corvatsch (15-70cm with skiing to the valley). 
 Upper slopes at Flims-Laax are reasonable (0-90cm). 
 The Bernese Oberland and Valais have few reports of snow. 
 Verbier (0-40cm) and Zermatt (0-45cm) are skiable on upper slopes. 
 Andermatt has spring-like conditions, skiing on the glacier only. 
 Norway is well ahead with new snow everywhere, holding up in full winter conditions. 
 With 150cm Oppdal is set for the winter. 
 Voss and Geilo have 50cm new snow. 
 The United States has good skiing. 
 Killington has 50cm of fresh snow, 700 skiable acres and 105 trails open, while Jackson Hole, Steamboat, Sunlight, Vail, Cooper, and Beaver Creek are 95 per cent open. 
 Italian Courmayeur survives on artificial snow. 
 In France, Tignes has fair skiing on the glacier, but off piste is feeble. 
 Chamonix is closed, snow above 2600m, lower later. 
 Austria has 10 resorts with skiing down to valley level. 
 Skiable resorts are Bad Gastein (20-50cm), Bad Mittendorf (30-40cm), Flachau (30-30cm), St Anton (20-60), Obergurgl (10-70cm), Obertauern (20-40cm). 
 In West Germany, only the Zugspitze (Garmisch Partenkirchen) has snow, 100cm (10cm new) and four lifts open. 
 In Scotland only the Lecht is skiable (two runs). 
 Operators report varying attitudes from snow-hungry skiers. 
 The past two seasons have discouraged many from booking early, or from booking at all. 
 Other more experienced skiers are earmarking March or April as the best candidates for reliable cover. 
 A third group have packed their bags and are ready to travel immediately as the snow falls. 
 But there is a real danger that lucky resorts will be fully booked within hours of a good dump. 
 There is still a good case for booking ahead now, but look for high resorts, preferably with a glacier as well as access to some non-skiing activities. 
 Skiing weather is fickle. 
 The Swiss forecast last Monday (&bquo;no snow until Saturday&equo;) missed Wednesday's flurry. 
 France has been expecting heavy snow all week to 1200m&hellip; and still waits. 
 Chamonix locals are sticking to their prediction of a heavy winter. 
 If it does come, say the Swiss, it may not be until the second week in January. 
 For the moment Christmas on the slopes holds little promise. 
 The Alpine forecast from the Manchester Weather Centre is to become colder on the weekend with a good chance of substantial snowfalls. 
 The Ski Service resumes on Wednesday December 27. 
 Vale angry at the bill. 
 THE Port Vale chairman Bill Bell has called police costs at Vale Park &bquo;outrageous&equo; after recent figures revealed a 500 per cent increase in the last year. 
 The leap from &pound;11,000 to &pound;55,202 put Vale into the Football League's top ten with a policing cost of 35 pence per spectator. 
 Bell said: &bquo;Clubs cannot cope with these increases. 
 They are absolutely crippling and some clubs could even go out of business. 
 As far as I am concerned games are over-policed. 
 I can understand the caution in the light of the Hillsborough disaster, but the charges per officer are outrageous.&equo; 
 Superintendent Gordon Thompson of Staffordshire police said: &bquo;Our prices are fixed by the council's police committee and agreed with Port Vale.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, another change to the offside law is being proposed &mdash; this time by the Football Association of Wales &mdash; and it could be introduced at non-League level next season. 
 The new rule is &bquo;no player will be offside if he receives the ball directly from his own half of the field&equo;. 
 Fifa has given approval via its technical committee and if the international board agree next June, the new experimental rule will be used in the Abacus League next season. 
 Fifa is also considering a rule change whereby an attacker level with the last defender would not be offside. 
 The use of Cardiff Arms Park for all future Wales games will be discussed by the FA of Wales and the Welsh Rugby Union next month. 
 The postponed Littlewoods Cup fourth-round replay between Southampton and Swindon will now be at The Dell on January 16, kick-off 7.30. 
 Ipswich staged a dramatic recovery to knock Wimbledon out of the Zenith Data Systems Cup at Portman Road last night. 
 First they equalised in injury time, when Joseph tripped Johnson to concede a penalty, then they scored twice in two minutes in the first period of extra-time to win 3-1. 
 Banbridge's Ascot form is first class. 
 DAVID Nicholson's Banbridge put up a fair performance when running Clever Folly to four lengths at Ascot last month and must be fancied for the Tanners Claret Handicap Chase at Ludlow this afternoon, writes Chris Hawkins. 
 Banbridge was receiving 13lb from Clever Folly but as the winner subsequently went on to triumph in the A F Budge Gold Cup at Cheltenham, breaking the track record in the process, there is little wrong with the form. 
 The improving Nearly Medina should make a market and although there are only five runners BANBRIDGE (1.0) should not be too short a price and merits the nap selection. 
 At Hexham George Moore introduces Afton Express, once thought to be champion hurdle material, to fences in the Portman Bloodstock Novice Chase. 
 With the stable now returning to form after a lean spell, Afton Express should go close but I slightly prefer the more experienced RIVER HOUSE (1.15), who jumped well when scoring over the course recently. 
 Oliver Sherwood's MIDNIGHT STORM (12.45) should be hard to beat in the Concord Business Park Novice Chase at Uttoxeter. 
 Midnight Storm made every yard of the running and jumped well when winning unchallenged at Nottingham recently. 
 With the Jenny Pitman horses in such tremendous form at the moment, MOSSGARA (2.15) must be greatly respected in the second division of the Knight Park Novices Hurdle. 
 Mossgara was hampered at halfway but stayed on well when second to Wizzard Artist at Plumpton on his debut and is bound to have derived considerable benefit from that experience. 
 She can complete a course double with BAGGRAVE LAD (3.15) in the Orbital Centre NH Flat race and earlier at Ludlow she may have initiated a treble by winning with her dual bumper winner RUN TO FORM (12.30). 
 Fellow Lambourn trainer Charlie Brooks also has excellent prospects of landing a double with BLACK HUMOUR (12.15) and WOLFHANGAR (1.45). 
 European Tour prize money climbs to record &pound;16 million. 
 By David Davies 
 THE PGA European Tour, which started in Tenerife last year, will be moving north to Portugal for its first tournament of the Nineties. 
 Organisers of the Tenerife Open failed to make the requisite telephone call by 10am yesterday morning to tell tour officials that they could raise the money, so it has been replaced by the Atlantic Open at Estela, near Oporto, from February 15-18. 
 The second event is the Dubai Classic and the third the Mediterranean Open at Las Brisas. 
 The tour may have lost an offshore event but financially it is far from being at sea. 
 Prize money will rise by a further 18 per cent during the forthcoming year, which takes the total to &pound;16 million, considerably more than the &pound;1.3 million on offer in 1980. 
 The Atlantic and Mediterranean Opens are new events, the latter being sponsored by American Express, and there are four new tournaments in all. 
 The Murphy's Cup, a small-scale affair this season at St Pierre, Chepstow, next year becomes a full European Tour event at Fulford, York, while it is likely that the fourth event will have as one of its entrants no less a player than Jack Nicklaus. 
 It is the Austrian Open, to be played on a course at Gut Altentann, near Saltzburg, which is a Nicklaus creation. 
 He has a habit of playing in at least the inaugural event held on one of his lay-outs and in December 1988 fully intended to play in the Austrian Open of 1989. 
 He was disappointed to learn that there was no such event on last season's European Tour calendar, but seems sure to get his wish next year. 
 Two days ago the organisers of the NM English Open, to be played from August 16-19 at The Belfry, announced that their prize money would be increased from &pound;250,000 to &pound;400,000. 
 That kind of rise has helped to push the average purse available on the tour next year up to &pound;340,000, whereas 10 years ago the prize fund for the Open Championship was only &pound;200,000. 
 Golf continues to boom as never before. 
 FOREIGN FIELDS: Deborah Pugh follows a session of the Cairo climate conference with David Trippier, British Environment Minister The can't pay, won't pay approach to the problem. 
 POLLUTION in Cairo is on a level with Los Angeles and even more crowded, dirty and chaotic than London. 
 Mr. Ibrahim Sadek, an Egyptian engineering consultant, lays the blame on the lack of unleaded fuel and to state production of outdated car engines: &bquo;We are producing Fiats with engines designed back in the Forties&equo;, he told the World Conference on Preparing for Climatic Change which ended in Cairo yesterday. 
 This did not go down well. 
 Egypt, it seems, is not preparing, or more realistically, does not have the resources to change the environment. 
 Mr. Sadik shared the panel on Energy, Industry and Transportation with the Egyptian Minister of Oil, Mr. Abdel Hadi Kandil, who confirmed that Egypt had &bquo;no plans to introduce unleaded fuel&equo; and showed no interest in iniating any. 
 Sitting beside him, Mr. Maher Abaza, the Minister for Power and Electricity, dismissed solar energy and renewables with a sweep of his hand. 
 Egypt's nuclear power industry is still in the design phase, but according to Mr. Kandil, nuclear power was the only clean energy alternative for Egypt: &bquo;If developed countries want to enjoy a good climate, they should give us these plants at lower cost. 
 Then everybody would be accepting them gladly&equo;. 
 In the hot debate that followed, the benefits of fuel efficiency and alternative renewable energies sources were argued persuasively by one of the acknowledged international experts in the field, but neither minister appeared to be actually listening to Amory Lovins of the American Rocky Mountain Institute. 
 Lovins dismissed the development of nuclear power as the primary source of energy for industrial growth in the developing world, by estimating that in order to generate the level of energy pro-nuclear scientists were calling for, a new plant would have to come on stream every eleven hours throughout 54 years of actual construction, a financial impossibility. 
 In the case of Egypt, with a staggering debt burden of &dollar;50 billion, a predicament similar to many other countries in the developing world, access to such capital is very limited. 
 The Americans and Germans have provided aid for the modernisation of electrical plant but the question of who will pay the multi-million dollar bill for Egyspt to produce cleaner cars is unananswered. 
 According to David Trippier, the British Enviroment Minister, if developing countries increased their per capita use of ozone depleting chemicals to just one tenth of the 1986 consumption rate in industrialised economies, and used them indefinitely: &bquo;Then we would never return to the levels needed for us to get rid of ozone holes, even if the rest of the world stopped using them althogether.&equo; 
 Mr Trippier was one of a number of European government ministers who attended the conference and spoke of their committment to compensate developing countries for the expense they would have to entail in order to avoid adding to an ecological disaster that has been created by industrialised states. 
 However, the only individual who appears to have a plan that will appeal to the developing world is Dr. Mustapha Tolba, head of the United Nations Enviroment Plan who proposed a users' tax paid by the consumers of ozone depleting chemicals, to be collected by governments and used by developing countries both to modernise their production systems and to compensate the multi-nationals for the transfer of their most advanced energy effective technology. 
 Dr. Tolba, widely respected for the critical role played by UNIP in achieving the Montreal Protocol on ozone depletion, is looking forward to the London Conference on Climate next June aimed at toughening up the Montreal guidelines. 
 He ended by warning that if there was no indication of how the world was going to handle the issue of transfer of technology and financial resources needed by the developing countries, there would be no strengthening of the convention and even the ones already in might opt out. 
 &bquo;I don't want that disaster to happen&equo;. 
 PAGE 
 Pollution and the break-up of the NCC will dominate the debate around the green bill. 
 Environment Guardian analyses this week's proposals All muck but little money POLLUTION: The plans read well, says Julie Hill, but there is little evidence that the Government can make them work. 
 IT IS a shame that discussion of the Environmental Protection Bill will be dominated by the ill-judged decision to dismember the Nature Conservancy Council. 
 The clauses on pollution and on genetically manipulated organisms deserve more attention than they are now likely to get. 
 Although overdue, two elements of the bill can properly claim to be breaking new ground. 
 The first is what is known as &bquo;Integrated Pollution Control&equo; (IPC). 
 This was first proposed in 1974 but when the Environmental Protection Bill becomes law, the UK will be the first European country to put in place a national system of integrated control The importance of IPC is that it aims to treat the environment as it is: an inter-related system where pollutants can be exchanged between air, water and land. 
 Traditional pollution control in the UK has been fragmented with air, water and wastes regulated by diffrent agencies operating different pollution control approaches. 
 This can mean that factories prevented by one inspector from discharging pollutants into the air are allowed to divert them to, say, water. 
 Now, for the most polluting substances, control over their impact on the environment as a whole will be consolidated in the hands of one agency, Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution (HMIP). 
 IPC is a good principle. 
 The argument is likely to be less over the substance of the legislation than over whether the system can be implemented. 
 The problems faced by HMIP are considerable. 
 Inspectors previously specialised in particular areas of pollution control will be expected to regulate industrial processes presently outside their experience. 
 They will also have to decide what IPC means in practice for the 3500-odd industrial processes under their control and as yet have set no timetable for doing so. 
 The division of responsibilities between HMIP and other polution agencies, particularly the National Rivers Authority is still in dispute. 
 Low pay has made it difficult for HMIP to recruit and keep adequately qualified staff. 
 They need far more people and morale has been low. 
 Chris Patten acknowledged on Wednesday that HMIP needs more staff but there is, as yet, no firm commitment to extra cash. 
 The Government reckons it will cost about &pound;4 million to implement, 75 per cent of which it is hoped will be clawed back from industry. 
 But the costs could be greatly under-estimated and considerable extra resources may well be required to solve HMIP's problems. 
 The bill contains a host of other pollution measures including long-awaited improvements to waste regulation, increased powers for local authorities to control air pollution, updating of radioactive waste regulatuions, new measures on recycling, litter and dog mess. 
 But of all of these, Integrated Pollution Control is the only significant measure aimed at preventing pollution at source rather than dealing with it once it has reached the environment. 
 Unfortunately, IPC as proposed is applicable to only a relatively small number of pollutants. 
 The other measure of the bill that deserves extensive scrutiny is the part dealing with genetically modified organisms (GMOs) Genetic modification, or engineering, is the precise manipulation of the genetic code that governs the characteristics of any organism. 
 It enables adaptation of plants and animals to human purposes that would be beyond the reach of traditional breeding techniques; an example is the insertion of toxin genes from bacteria into plants to give them an in-built system for poisoning pests. 
 The next decade is likely to see a new industrial revolution based on the new biotechnologies. 
 Genetic modification will bring benefits, but no technology is risk-free. 
 The provisions on GMOs in the bill are to take account of the possible impacts of altered organisms on the environment &mdash; potential impacts on human health are deemed to be covered under existing health and safety regulations. 
 The clauses in the bill and the Government's proposals for the regualtions that will follow from them, raise some fundamental issues. 
 It is not clear that producers of genetically modified organisms will be fully liable for any damage they may cause. 
 It may not be possible to adequately define &bquo;damage&equo; to the environment, or even to detect it, when the environmental impact of a genetically engineered bacterium may be as undramatic as replacing a naturally occurring species of bacterium. 
 Most important, given that a rogue GMO in the environment might continue to reproduce and spread, it cannot be assumed that any system of regulation can adequately guard against an environmental catastrophe. 
 This legislation on GMOs has come forward in advance of public debate on the environmental risks of genetic engineering, and indeed before widespread debate on on the broader social, economic and ethical implications of the new biotechnologies. 
 It is essential that there is some form of public participation in the regulatory mechanism. 
 There should also be a Public Biotechnology Commission with representation from a broad range of public interest groups. 
 Such a body would have to consider all the implications of bio-technologies. 
 IPC and GMOs have an important element in common &mdash; both sets of measures in the bill contain provisions for public access to information. 
 The arguments will be over how much inmformation, and in what form, will become available. 
 A reversal of the current presumption for secrecy in many areas of environmental control is essential for restoring battered public confidence in the regulatory system. 
 If the Government argues against full disclosure of information, it will be undermining the credibility of its environment policy almost as much as by splitting up the NCC. 
 Julie Hill is Parliamentary Officer for the Green Alliance. 
 THE Government is not backing down on re-organisation of the Nature Conservancy Council and Countryside Commissions, despite the drubbing that its proposals have received from virtually every conversation organisation in Britain. 
 Wednedsay's announcement still implies that the crucial science base of the NCC is to be split between Scotland, Wales and England, and the Chief Scientist's post abolished. 
 The Joint Co-ordinating Committee to be set up to maintain standards countrywide is now to have an independent chairman. 
 This is only a marginal improvement, for even if a government stooge is avoided, the separate agency chairmen and members may still win control on important issues. 
 In any case, standards in conservation science cannot be managed by a committee which will become a bureaucratic talking shop, needing endless feeding with papers and briefings, and will doubtless spawn sub-committees. 
 There needs above all to be a consistency in the whole chain linking nature conservation policy with action on the ground. 
 Practice needs to be as strong as possible, not levelled down to a lowest common denominator. 
 Moreover, any watchdog needs teeth. 
 Despite the mauling that Chris Patten and Co. are going to receive, they can force through this ill-considered legislation. 
 With this government any issues soon take second place to being seen to win. 
 The monumentally crass decision to include this item in the Environment Bill reflects badly on the judgement of ministers and the competence of their advisers. 
 The Government has failed to add any convincing arguments to its feeble justifications for the changes, and dares not come clean about the real reasons. 
 When the full story is eventually told, it will be one of treachery, careerism, power, privilege and political ambition. 
 For example, the battle over Duich Moss on Islay was not really about conservation versus jobs &mdash; as subsequent events have proved &mdash; but about saving embarrassment in high places. 
 Why, otherwise would the EC investigating lawyer be bombarded with phone calls all trying to dissuade him from a site visit? 
 The anger over the Flow Country is not so much about employment as about the ending of a scandalous rip-off of public funds which fuelled private forestry and the associated inflation of land values. 
 The carve-up of the NCC is the price of challenging the control of those who run rural Scotland. 
 Nature conservation action stands to become seriously weakened in all three countries, but especially in Scotland, which has one of the worst records of any westernised country in nature conservation. 
 It is one of two European countries without a single national park. 
 These have been kept at bay for 40 years by the power and special pleading of the vested interests who are right now busily working out how to control the new Heritage Agency. 
 We shall, indeed, know the score when we see the names appointed to run all three new agencies. 
 For the concerned public to have any confidence that they can succeed, these bodies will need both governing councils and senior management who know what they are talking about, and show genuine commitment to conservation goals. 
 The danger is that there will be a careful selection both of members with primary allegiance to different and even hostile interests, and of officials preoccupied with their careers. 
 All will swear devotion to conservation, but some will be temporisers and compromisers, if not actual fifth columnists. 
 Ministers will urge upon them the favourite concept of &bquo;balance,&equo; and good marks will be earned by not playing the game too hard. 
 Any tinkering with conservation measures will be a bad sign, and backsliding on established gains a cause for real alarm. 
 Nature conservation runs against the grain of current political doctrine. 
 In a new age of philistinism, when everything has to wear a price tag, the beauty and wonder of the world of nature have low value in the market place. 
 The State is allowed to continue subsidising unprofitable farming and forestry, because that keeps old pals and supporters happy; but too many conservationists have an unfortunate leaning towards the radical. 
 Free enterprise has been the curse of conservation, feeding the feckless exploitation of the world's natural resources in a rat-race pursuit of material wealth. 
 The arguments used to justify destruction of the tropical rain forests and the flow country are, at bottom, the same. 
 It therefore seems that the way will be eased to the continuing destruction of what is left of wild nature in Britain, to serve the open-ended demands of development and growth. 
 This will happen, although a tithe of the funds poured into farm surpluses and defence white elephants would solve most problems of both conservation and rural society. 
 Conservation will fail if it does not embrace a view of social justice, but both need careful planning &mdash; and that is a dirty word nowadays. 
 Derek Ratcliffe was Chief Scientist of the NCC until July. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE 
 CORRECTED VERSION Eco Soundings. 
 By John Vidal 
 IT'S killer bee time in the States and smart federal scientists have spent &dollar;100,000 working on the problem of how to track the swarms that ravage farming and kill anything in their way. 
 They've come up with a solar-powered, infrared-pulsating, microchip bee backpack. 
 Cripes. 
 Just catch some unsuspecting psychopathic bee, strap it on and watch it go. 
 Hang on&hellip; the transmitter weighs 65 milligrams and even a sherpa bee can only lift 50 milligrams. 
 &bquo;But I think we've proved the concept&equo;, says the inventor. 
 ON January 13 the Turks will stop the flow of the mighty Euphrates river for a month to build up the water level in their new Ataturk dam; fine, except that the Euphrates flows into Iraq which needs the water for irrigation and electricity. 
 So Iraq has now formally asked the Turks to shorten the cut-off period but the Turks reply that they have been releasing more water down the river and the Iraquis should have been able to build up stocks. 
 A compromise will be reached but the implications are clear; international eco politics are with us. 
 Pearce, goodwill. 
 THE Economist next week runs, as an advertisement, a 1500 word piece &mdash; &bquo;The Profit in Survival&equo; &mdash; by Professor David Pearce, economics adviser to Christopher Patten. 
 Nothing new in it, but an interesting departure for the professor because it was commissioned &mdash; at enormous cost &mdash; by Ermenegildo Zegna. 
 Who's he? 
 Oh, yes, the Milan-based menswear group which charges about &pound;700 for a regular suit and wants to be seen as a deeply serious friend of the earth. 
 Boughing out. 
 THE Forestry Commission this week began felling 120 fine old beech trees in the Crown-owned Savernake Forest in Wiltshire, saying they had to protect the public from dangerous boughs. 
 Savernake is famed for its lichens and the Forestry Commission is noted for its love of lichens on old trees. 
 In June they published a handbook about how valuable they were. 
 Quote: &bquo;Conservation of lichens oftens means site preservation, identification of old trees and saving them from felling&equo;. 
 PAGE en2 
 Another day. 
 December 22, 1845: People used to say to me, &bquo;You expect too much &mdash; you are too romantic&equo;. 
 And my answer always was that I could not expect too much when I expected nothing at all for I never thought that anyone whom I could love, would stoop to love ME. 
 And now when it comes in a miracle, you wonder at me for looking twice, thrice, four times, to see if it comes through ivory or horn. 
 You wonder that it should seem to me at first all illusion But how natural &mdash; It is true of me&hellip; very true&hellip; that I have not a high appreciation of what passes in the world under the name of love; &amp; that a distrust of the thing had grown to be a habit of mind with me when I knew you first. 
 It has appeared to me, through all the seclusion of my life &amp; the narrow experience it admitted of, that in nothing, men &mdash; &amp; women too! &mdash; were so apt to mistake their own feelings, as in this one thing. 
 Putting falseness quite on one side, an honest mistaking of feeling appears wonderfully common &mdash; &amp; no mistake has such frightful results &mdash; none can. 
 Robert Browning and Elizabeth Barrett, The Courtship Correspondence 1845-1846, edited by Daniel Karlin, Clarendon Press, &pound;17.50) 
 33. 
 Obituary:Rev Dr Herbert Hartwell. 
 From Prussia with peace:. 
 HERBERT Hartwell was appointed a judge of the Berlin Kammergericht, the Prussian Supreme Court, at the age of 33, in spite of interrupted legal studies during war service in 1914-18 (including the Iron Cross). 
 A different kind of courage, coupled with staunch Christianity, marked his opposition to the Nazi regime during the 1930s. 
 In 1934 he joined the Confessing Church, the wing of the national (Lutheran) Church which disowned the &bquo;German Christians&equo; and refused to compromise with the Hitler government. 
 The next year he was dismissed under the Nuremberg Regulations. 
 A friend of Probst, H. Gruber and Pastor Martin Niemoller, Hartwell worked with the Confessing Church to aid the escape of Jews from Germany. 
 This brought him into touch with George Bell, then Bishop of Chichester, and with John Marsh, the Congregational theologian, who invited him to Oxford. 
 In August 1939 he escaped with his family on the last but one ship to leave Hamburg. 
 He took up the invitation, only to be promptly interned on the outbreak of war. 
 George Bell secured his early release. 
 Within months he determined to be ordained, believing that the Congregationalists most closely represented the standpoint and theology of the Confessing Church. 
 Dr Nathaniel Micklem, who himself had been deeply involved with the Christian opposition in Germany, accepted him for training at Mansfield College, Oxford, for the ministry. 
 He and his children were always grateful to &bquo;Nat&equo; (whose successor as Principal was Dr Marsh) for many kindnesses over the years. 
 At Oxford he took a D.Phil. on Barth, to set alongside his Erlangen law doctorate. 
 After ordination he worked as a chaplain with German prisoners of war for the YMCA and from 1948 as secretary for German affairs with the British Council of Churches Inter Church Aid and Refugee Service, the forerunner of Christian Aid. 
 In the next years he translated Weiss on the Psalms, published an introduction to Barth's Church Dogmatics and continued to write. 
 The West German Government honoured him for his notable work in promoting friendship between the two countries. 
 Robert Courtney Edwin Robertson writes: Whenever I answered the telephone in the fifties and sixties and heard the anxious voice at the other end saying &bquo;Here is Hartvell&equo; (he never quite managed that English &bquo;W&equo;), I knew that either my deadline for an article was passed or he had some exciting new book for me to review. 
 Hartwell devoted his brilliant mind and untiring energy in those years after the second world war to forging links between Christians in his adopted country and that of his birth. 
 He did this at an intellectual level, and one of his chief instruments was the German-British Christian Fellowship. 
 The Fellowship had George Bell as president and I was its chairman, but the work was done by Hartwell as honorary secretary and joint editor for the movement's journal, The Bridge. 
 There I had him as a charming, affectionate colleague of mature judgment. 
 I saw, too, his gentle persuasion to make British Christians take modern German theology seriously. 
 It was he who introduced me to Dietrich Bonhoeffer. 
 When Eberhard Bethge produced Bonhoeffer's volumes of papers, lectures and letters in a series of Collected Works in German, Hartwell saw to it that I reviewed each volume in The Bridge as soon as it arrived. 
 Long before John Robinson's Honest to God made Bonhoeffer known to a mass public, Hartwell persistently made us see that this theologian-martyr really mattered for post-war theology. 
 The development of such a good relationship between Christian leaders and theologians in the two countries owed everything to Hartwell's knowledge of both communities and his sensitivity to the changing climate of opinion and thought. 
 Herbert Hartwell born April 20, 1894; died December 11, 1989. 
 Assessment: Gerry Healy. 
 Entryism and exits:. 
 ONE had assumed that Gerry Healy (Obituary, December 18) would be always with us. 
 Now that he is not, we can say, with luck we shall not see his like again. 
 This year was the fiftieth anniversary of his joining the British Trotskyist movement. 
 According to Jock Haston, his mode of entry was eccentric. 
 Haston was selling papers at Hyde Park Corner when he was accosted by Healy, then a member of the Communist Party. 
 Harsh words led to action, and Haston despatched him down the public lavatory stairs. 
 Whether it was the power of Haston's argument or of his boot, the result was that Healy joined the Workers' International League. 
 He was a good public speaker and organiser and endowed with extraordinary energy. 
 In an organisation with such talented people as Heaton Lee, Jock Haston and Ted Grant, however, he occupied inevitably a secondary role in the leadership &mdash; not to his taste. 
 In 1944, under the impetus of a wave of strikes in the mines, the British Trotskyist movement was united for the first time as the Revolutionary Communist Party, anticipating the imminent collapse of capitalism in the West and Stalinism in Russia. 
 From four hundred members they expected to rise to hundreds of thousands in the coming &bquo;death agony of capitalism&equo;. 
 History records that it did not happen; the RCP was marginalised by the post-war economic revival. 
 It was in the decline of the movement that Healy came into his own. 
 Flying in the face of the facts, he prophesied that the economic crisis was so close that there was no time to build the party: the RCP must join the Labour Party, whose working class members, given Trotskyist leadership, would become revolutionary under the pressure of events. 
 In 1947 he was given permission by the Fourth International to form an independent Labour Party entry group. 
 His cadre was small &mdash; some fifty people &mdash; but they were his. 
 He had arrived at last. 
 When the RCP was founded in 1949, he received a &bquo;bonus&equo; increase in membership of &bquo;The Club&equo;, as his group was known. 
 The internal structure was draconian, dissent of the mildest form was crushed with all possible force. 
 He got rid of oppositionists by proposing some impossible task, and when they failed or refused would move their expulsion, anyone who voted against automatically expelling themselves. 
 In this way, Ted Grant and his comrades were got rid of, likewise Tony Cliff and his comrades. 
 After the crisis in the Communist Party following Khrushchev's speech to the Twentieth Party Congress, CPGB was in turmoil. 
 Some seven thousand members left, among them Brian Behan, Peter Fryer and John Daniels. 
 Healy was ideally placed to take advantage of this. 
 He had a printing press and, through his connection with the American Socialist Workers' Party, the plates for a number of Trotsky's books and pamphlets. 
 For disillusioned communists reared on Stalin's grim prose, Trotsky was a revelation. 
 The Club recruited some of the most talented militants. 
 British Trotskyism's new lease of life did not last for long. 
 In 1959, the imminent collapse of the system once more predicted, the Socialist Labour League was formed to draw in industrial workers, and immediately proscribed by the Labour Party. 
 The sharpness of the turn led to a bitter faction fight, at the end of which most of the recent recruits had either left or been ejected on the toe of Healy's boot. 
 This process of finding a likely area of recruitment (by turns the Young Socialists, the unemployed, mods and rockers and blacks), building up the group and then destroying the gains in a destructive faction fight was to be repeated ad nauseam. 
 As soon as the group became too large to be controlled by a hyper-active Healy rushing around the country to quell the first signs of dissidence it had to be smashed. 
 Gerry Healy made more ex-Trotskyists than anyone else except Stalin. 
 Fortunately he did not have the GPU at his beck and call. 
 He was powerfully addicted to conspiracy theory, according to which the group was continually under surveillance by the Special Branch and MI5, while concentration camps were being prepared to incarcerate the militants as the capitalist crisis deepend. 
 (At one conference delegates were told to talk at the floor because Special Branch had hi-tech microphones trained on the windows to catch the sound-waves.) 
 Healy's last years were blighted by the humiliation of expulsion from the WRP for using his position to seduce young female members. 
 This occasioned some surprise. 
 Healy was over 70, short, fat and neckless, his massive head growing straight out of his shoulders. 
 As someone said at the time, &bquo;I could believe him guilty of grievous bodily harm, but not grievous bodily charm.&equo; 
 In his 50 years of Trotskyism he made not one small dent in the capitalist system, but he mortally wounded the movement he claimed to lead. 
 Jim Higgins. 
 ATrotskyist &bquo;dur&equo; of the old school, Healy's finest hour was the Socialist Labour League, into which he recruited some of the best British communists disillusioned with the Soviet Union after Hungary. 
 It was a significant influence in the wave of strikes of the late Fifties, until Healy's authoritarian methods drove away the best people. 
 In 1969, he achieved his lifelong ambition of a daily Trotskyist newspaper, The Workers Press, and transformed his group into the Workers Revolutionary Party. 
 Although publicly scathing about the student left and the anti-Vietnam movement, Healy none the less cultivated a discussion circle of London writers, actors and television producers, it is said with some charm and intellectual force, which was to presage his fixation with Equity, the actors' Union which increasingly provided personnel and finance for the ERP. 
 This salon is encapsulated in Trevor Griffith's play The Party, in which a Glaswegian version of Healy is seen overawing a motley of trendies, including an inebriated David Mercer-like figure. 
 Olivier's performance in this role is generally regarded as somewhat flattering. 
 David Widgery. 
 Defending the indefensible As the crisis in Romania deepens the role of the armed forces is crucial. 
 Because one of President Nicolae Ceausescu's many titles is that of chairman of the National Defence Council, and his brother, General Ilie Ceausescu, is head of political administration for the forces, the loyalty of the high command may not be in doubt, but morale in the ranks is low. 
 Henry Dodds assesses the situation. 
 SOVIET military influence in Romania is non-existent. 
 The last Soviet troops left the country in 1958 and Romania has not taken part in any Warsaw Pact exercises since 1968. 
 This has left the armed forces short of modern equipment. 
 Romania has the worst equipped army in the Warsaw Pact. 
 A third of its 1,800 main battle tanks are of Second World War vintage, and most of the remainder date from the 1950s. 
 The 1989 defence budget called for 1.7 per cent growth in spending to 11.75 billion lei (approximately &pound;500 million &mdash; Britain's defence budget in the same period was &pound;19.2 billion), but this is insufficient for the armed forces' perceived needs. 
 Many mechanised units which should be riding around in armoured personnel carriers are still mounted in trucks &mdash; some are even reduced to walking. 
 Because of Ceausescu's insistence that the entire population is responsible for national defence, there is seen to be no need to maintain professional and well-trained armed soldiers. 
 Instead, the armed forces (especially the army, which could pose a potential threat to his rule) is regularly employed as a massive source of cheap labour. 
 Many conscripts &mdash; they make up 65 per cent of the armed forces &mdash; receive only the most basic training. 
 When this is over, they are sent straight to work building roads and bridges, digging canals or collecting the harvest. 
 &bquo;Working battalions&equo; have their own command structure and run incentive competitions. 
 The lucky winner has the privilege of sending their leader the first congratulatory telegram, announcing the success of the latest project. 
 Morale in the army is generally low. 
 The air force and the diminutive navy do not usually participate in these acts of manual labour, but are severely hampered by financial constraints. 
 Half of all aircraft are said to be inoperable and two thirds of all vessels are in port at any given time. 
 This is usually due to fuel shortages brought about by excessive exports of Romania's home-produced oil. 
 Despite the lack of anything other than basic equipment for its armed forces, according to Nato estimates Romania topped the league of non-Soviet Warsaw Pact arms exporters to the Third World by the mid 1980s. 
 In the last year, Romania is believed to have made offers to sell arms to Nigeria, Iran, Iraq, Ethiopia, Mozambique and Egypt. 
 Ceausescu's visit this week to Iran may well have been in connection with a possible sale of arms. 
 This determination to sell arms on the international market has a more sinister note, since Romania's large chemical industry is in close contact with a number of Arab states, whose positions on chemical weapons Ceausescu supports. 
 In January, the day before a conference on chemical weapons opened in Paris, the Romanian leader announced publicly that he would not accept a ban on chemical weapons unless a universal ban on nuclear weapons was agreed at the same time. 
 This is consistent with the position of Arab states such as Iraq and Libya. 
 Soviet chemical weapon stocks still exist in Romania and West German intelligence sources have suggested in the past that there are also production and testing facilities. 
 The Soviet Army newspaper, Krasnaya Zvezda, has also recently mentioned special Romanian chemical troops. 
 The thought of a beleaguered Ceausescu in possession of chemical weapons is a chilling one. 
 Romania has had disputes with both the Soviet Union and Hungary. 
 In the east, the ethnic Romanian area of Bessarbia, which forms part of the Soviet Socialist Republic of Moldavia, has been a source of tension since its &bquo;misappropriation&equo; by the Soviet Union in May 1940. 
 Today, as then, it forms part of the vital defence barrier guarding the southern strategic approaches to the USSR. 
 It also affords the Soviet Army swift access into central and southern Europe. 
 The dispute with Hungary is more serious and centres around the region of Transylvania. 
 The area is predominantly ethnic Hungarian and Hungary has therefore always maintained a close interest in the treatment of Hungarians there. 
 Tension existed even before Ceausescu came to power in 1965, but relations between the two states have degenerated in a flurry of mutual recrimination, slander and public protest. 
 Hungary received support in its argument against Romania in 1987 and 1988, in the form of an influx of Romanian refugees. 
 In one case in 1988 a Romanian border guard pursued a Romanian citizen into Hungarian territory and shot him. 
 A significant factor in the dispute is the close interest which Ceausescu and several members of his family have taken in directing the Romanian case. 
 The Romanian leader's brother, Lieutenant General Ilie Ceausescu, a deputy defence minister and head of political administration for the armed forces, has been closely concerned with the presentation of the historical case and has unhesitatingly attacked the Hungarians in several articles published in the Romanian press. 
 In the summer, the two sides took the unprecedented step in the Warsaw Pact of recalling their two ambassadors. 
 At a meeting between the Hungarian and Romanian leaders in August 1988, ostensibly called to ease tension between the two countries, Ceausescu is reputed to have threated Karoly Grosz with the words: &bquo;We do not, and do not wish, to manufacture nuclear weapons; however, we do possess the capability to do so.&equo; 
 The alarmed Hungarians initially kept this threat to themselves, but have since raised the issue in private both within the Warsaw Pact and with certain Western governments. 
 That Romania could build a nuclear weapon at the moment is unlikely. 
 In the late 1970s a contract was signed with Canada for the creation of three nuclear power stations. 
 The first, a 660MW reactor of the Candu type has yet to enter service, but is being built with no outside supervision and under military control. 
 Ceausescu's aim in issuing such a threat was probably to frighten Hungary, but Romania already has the delivery system in the form of Soviet built Scud missiles and is believed to be developing its own missile with the help of Egypt and Iraq. 
 The picture emerging from Romania this week is of a country barely under control. 
 In his television broadcasts since returning from Iran, Ceausescu has looked under severe pressure. 
 When he visited Moscow in October 1988, Gorbachev asssured him that &bquo;the Romanian people can be confident that it will always find in the Soviet people a reliable ally, a useful partner, and a true friend.&equo; 
 Whether that offer of friendship extends to Ceausescu and his family remains to be seen. 
 In a country where one in four is said to be an informer or member of the secret police, if the present order breaks down there will be a lot of old scores to be settled. 
 Whether the Soviet Union and Hungary will be able to resist intervention in such circumstances is open to question. 
 Henry Dodds is editor of Jane's Soviet Intelligence Review. 
 Off-duty members of the Romanian armed forces at last month's Party CongressPHOTOGRAPH: MARTIN ARGLES. 
 World washes its hands of the horror Commentary. 
 By Hella Pick 
 WHEN President Ceausescu of Romania ordains his forces to shoot on his own people after they call for democracy and bread, and causes mass deaths whose numbers can only be guessed, Nato and Warsaw Pact countries cry shame and horror. 
 But they also throw up their arms, and say there is nothing they can do except hope that people power will prevail and the self-styled &bquo;great redeemer&equo; self-destruct. 
 How different when dictators in Panama misbehave. 
 President Bush explained on Wednesday that he decided to send in thousands of marines to capture General Noriega and restore democracy in Panama, after forces under Noriega's command killed one unarmed US serviceman, wounded another, arrested and assaulted a third and brutally interrogated his wife, threatening her with sexual abuse. 
 It is certainly not a very edifying tale, but it is small fry compared with the massacre in Romania last weekend at Timisoara, and the further shootings reported to have taken place in Bucharest yesterday. 
 Is it really beyond the realms of the possible for the international community to put any tangible pressure on Ceausescu? 
 Do thousands more have to be massacred before he is toppled? 
 In the days when Romanians were still in a mood to tell jokes, they used to ask a rhetorical question: how long would it take for a Soviet expeditionary force to reach Bucharest from the Soviet border? 
 The answer was 24 hours or 48 hours, depending on whether the Russians met opposition. 
 If they were opposed, it would take only 24 hours, but if there was no opposition it would take twice that time, because the cheering Romanian population would hold them up with their welcome. 
 This story did the rounds some years ago, when Romanians already had the measure of their leader, but while the West was still honouring President Ceausescu for what was considered to be his independent stand on foreign policy issues. 
 Today, it is easy to imagine that Romanians would indeed welcome Soviet forces with open arms as liberators. 
 But is it also realistic to assume that the West might tolerate it if Mr Gorbachev decided that the Romanian people, not unlike the people of Panama, deserve to enjoy democracy, and that the Soviet Union should send some of its military across the border to dispose of the Ceausescu family and their killer Securitas forces? 
 Or would the West cry foul, and declare that Mr Gorbachev cannot, after all, be trusted to keep his word that the Brezhnev doctrine is dead, and that he will not interfere in the Warsaw Pact countries? 
 During their pre-Christmas cocktail rounds, Western diplomats have bantered to their Soviet colleagues that Romania was the one country where the Soviet Union deserved to have a free hand. 
 They would be doing everybody a favour. 
 Or perhaps Romania could be the testing ground for co-operation between Nato and the Warsaw Pact and they should mount a joint expeditionary force. 
 Even if any of this were serious, there is no evidence that Mr Gorbachev has felt any pressing need, at least until now, to intervene militarily in Romania. 
 Even if the West were to applaud, the Soviet Union had nothing to gain from such a move. 
 Mr Ceausescu is certainly detested in Moscow as much as in London or Washington. 
 And as a Warsaw Pact leader they know him more intimately in the Kremlin than in the West. 
 But since Mr Brezhnev's death the Romanian leader has lost his ability to act as an irritant. 
 Mr Gorbachev could not care less whether Romania endorses perestroika and glasnost or the Soviet Union's foreign policies. 
 He might even allow himself a wry laugh when he considers how the West has come to excoriate Ceausescu today, after all those years when they applauded his &bquo;daring&equo; dissent from Warsaw Pact orthodoxy, and acting as a thorn in the Kremlin's body politic. 
 Mr Brezhnev was infuriated when Ceausescu used to call for lower Warsaw Pact defence budgets, or established diplomatic relations with Israel, or restored party-to-party relations with China's Communist party. 
 When Ceausescu in 1968 refused to become involved in the Warsaw Pact intervention against Czechoslovakia, and publicly condemned it, the Kremlin was furious, and briefly threatened Romania that a similar fate awaited them. 
 Mr Gorbachev has not bothered to hide his disapproval of the way Mr Ceausescu and his family have ruled Romania. 
 But he has also discovered that the Gorbachev magic has not worked in Romania as it has elsewhere in Eastern Europe. 
 He only had to visit Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, even East Germany, and political earthquakes followed. 
 In Romania, however, there was not even a ripple when Mr Gorbachev went to Bucharest to preside over a Warsaw Pact summit in July. 
 Mr Ceausescu had encased himself in such an impeneterable fortress that Gorbachev spared the Romanian leader from the warning he was to deliver later to Erich Honecker, that ageing leaders who failed to reform in time would pay dearly. 
 The Soviet Union has no great security interests in Romania. 
 Mr Ceausescu has not allowed any Soviet forces to be stationed there, and long ago ordered all Soviet military advisers to leave. 
 This means that there are no Soviet officers to prevent excesses by the Romanian army or to help the demonstrators. 
 In the economy Mr Ceausescu has also created a fortress. 
 His foreign debt has been repaid and he has even amassed enough hard currency reserves to buy, if necessary, oil from Iran and Libya. 
 The Soviet Union is reluctant to cut back on its oil supplies to Romania, since it still needs Romanian meat and consumer goods more than Ceausescu needs Soviet imports. 
 He has stashed up reserves of arms, and can probably get more. 
 Romania's other neighbours, Yugoslavia, Bulgaria and Hungary, also detest the Ceausescu regime. 
 But Bulgaria and Yugoslavia are more than preoccupied with their internal affairs, and certainly cannot contemplate military expeditions to rescue the Romanians. 
 Hungary, of course, is much more directly involved in Romania's agony. 
 But between political reform and economic crisis, even Hungary will think hard before giving way to emotion and sending its forces in to help the beleaguered Hungarian Romanians. 
 Pulling together against the tide. 
 VENICE, Dacca, Leningrad, Osaka&hellip; cities of history and romance, but perhaps also cities in danger. 
 Last week Venice hosted an international meeting of Cities On Water, to consider the impacts of possible sea-level rise. 
 While the Conference met, high spring tides were oozing through the paving of the Piazza San Marco. 
 In November, the island republic of Maldives held a similar conference of small states on sea-level rise. 
 Neither the Maldives nor Venice have land higher than two metres above today's mean sea level. 
 In the past 50 years, relative sea levels in Venice have increased by 23cm, largely because of sub-surface layer compaction and sinking as a result of groundwater pumping. 
 World-wide sea levels have increased only by about 15cm over the past century. 
 Melting of glaciers and the thermal expansion of the oceans have contributed, but the link with greenhouse warming is not yet clear. 
 Nor is it possible to say with confidence how much of the increase is due to melting glaciers and how much to thermal expansion. 
 Small wonder that the estimates of global sea-level rise for the next 100 years are very tentative. 
 Politicians are not impressed by scientific caution. 
 Mr Ruffolo, the Italian Environment Minister, told the Venice Conference that too much is at risk. 
 Scientific certainty is not an affordable luxury. 
 The citizens of Venice and the Maldives want action now. 
 Agreement on the actions needed is beginning to emerge from these recent meetings of politicians, administrators and scientists. 
 For many &bquo;Cities on Water&equo;, pumping of groundwater for local supply must stop. 
 Venice has already engineered a water supply from more distant sources. 
 Some cities, including Venice, can also build defences across critical connections to the sea. 
 But artificial defences have a finite life. 
 Natural defences can adjust to gradual sea-level rise. 
 For example, coral islands such as the Maldives may keep ahead of a rise of 50-70m a century. 
 Coral growth and the accretion of sediments in coastal mangroves will compensate. 
 But the mining of coastal coral for building must stop or the protection which it gives against waves and flooding will be lost. 
 Planners need reliable measurements of sea-level change. 
 All impacts of future rises will be felt locally but the problem is one of global change which demands global monitoring systems. 
 Measurements at a single site cannot be used to calculate global changes. 
 There may be local vertical land movement as in Venice, added to the sea-level change. 
 Scandinavia is still rising, in places by one metre a century, after the removal of the ice at the end of the last glaciation some 10,000 years ago. 
 Most of Scotland is still rising but the south-east of England is sinking by 15cm a century. 
 Using recent developments in survey technology, it is possible to fix anywhere on Earth in geocentric coordinates to within one or two centimetres. 
 A selected set of sea-level gauges will be located at intervals, using this new satellite technology so that vertical land movements over decades can be identified. 
 Early identification of accelerated rise will be possible if the year-to-year variability can be understood and removed from the records. 
 There is a close parallel here with changes to atmospheric pressure; high and low sea-level systems exist in the oceans. 
 The ocean currents flow around these in the same way that winds blow around high and low centres of atmospheric pressure. 
 To understand the year-to-year changes of sea level, we need to understand the ocean circulation and how it is driven by winds and by the balance of tropical warming and polar cooling. 
 The World Ocean Circulation Experiment begins next year and extends to 1995. 
 During this period, scientists from many countries will be systematically surveying ocean temperatures, salinities and currents. 
 At the same time, scientists are building computer models of ocean circulation but full three-dimensional models must wait for the next generation of powerful computers. 
 Early warning of accelerating sea-level rise will allow effective planning. 
 Meanwhile many studies of potential local effects of rising sea level are under way. 
 If new coastal engineering works can be enhanced at small extra cost, to anticipate sea-level rise, the investment will be a worthwhile insurance. 
 If sea level rises, one response will be a gradual relocating to higher ground. 
 For Venice and the Maldives this is not an option: there is nowhere to go. 
 Instead, a careful balance of engineered defences and the protection of natural defences will be necessary. 
 Concern about sea-level rise must not be allowed to divert attention from other problems caused by the increase of coastal populations. 
 Male, the capital of the Maldives, has a serious shortage of fresh water; Venice reports problems of coastal pollution. 
 However, sea level rise is a global problem which captures global imagination. 
 Our immediate response must be the development of a global monitoring system, including coastal gauges and satellites; support for global ocean and atmosphere studies; and initial analyses of local vulnerability. 
 Whether these rational and progressive responses to the problem of sea-level rise will satisfy the coastal dwellers who are at risk is an open question. 
 The small boy at the Green demonstration in the Maldives has no doubt: his home-made banner read &bquo;Down with Sea Level Rise&equo;. 
 The problem cannot be left for his generation to solve. 
 OVERNIGHT FILE PAGE sci 
 Melanie Phillips celebrates in carols the hopes and fears of a year which saw environmental issues high on the agenda. 
 WE THREE GREENS We three Greens of Politics are Patten and Porritt and Pearce, we'll go far Two of us preaching, One of us teaching, how to avoid the car. 
 Oh: car of menace, car of blight Cars the atmosphere ignite Greenhouse warming, Havoc forming Parkinson must see us right We're au fait with entropy Gaia, Ecosphere, synergy Words for greening But their meaning's A linguistic mystery Oh: politicians must invent Worship of environment Genuflecting by reflecting Words of verdant bafflement Now our water's unfit to drink Too much aluminium and zinc No solution To pollution No-one can stand the stink Oh: public filth and pestilence Highlights private opulence Does the glitter, clear the litter All it needs is pounds and pence GOD REST YE MERRY God rest ye merry, gentle Greens Let nothing you dismay The much foretold apocalypse Is now well under way Not even Mr Gorbachev Can stop the world's decay Oh, tidings of comfort and joy, Oh, tidings of comfort and joy We can't eat meat or hens or fish The farming is too cruel The only food we now permit Is foul organic gruel Irradiated food and veg Now double up as fuel Oh tidings of comfort and joy, Oh tidings of comfort and joy Now everybody wants a car Though noise and fumes are vile The Iron Curtain fractures and The jams stretch back for miles Mobility and liberty Cannot be reconciled Oh tidings of comfort and joy, Oh tidings of comfort and joy We think that greenhouse warming will Bring on the world's demise If forests burn it's not just trees but mankind too that fries But all this may be garbage Because scientists tell lies Oh tidings of comfort and joy, Oh tidings of comfort and joy Consumers must buy less to reach Sustainability For galloping consumption is More lethal than TB So much for Third World dreams of fleeing Grinding poverty Oh tidings of comfort and joy, Oh tidings of comfort and joy Unless we stop producing kids The planet will not cope No hope for birth controllers short of Kidnapping the Pope But since the Greens recycle people they May turn us into soap Oh tidings of comfort and joy, Oh tidings of comfort and joy In searching for clean energy The choice is pretty stark The floods that come when coal is burnt will keep us in the Ark But had Lord Marshall got his way We'd all glow in the dark Oh tidings of comfort and joy, Oh tidings of comfort and joy Dumb animals are much preferrred To flawed humanity Ill-treatment of old people may Provoke insanity But culling seals and whales is judged The worst profanity Oh tidings of comfort and joy, Oh tidings of comfort and joy Now Mrs Thatcher goes bright green A highly suspect hue Her policies have after all Kept filth and squalor blue It's just another way she's found To tell us what to do Oh, tidings of comfort and joy, Oh tidings of comfort and joy With greenhouse gases, PCBs Sulphuric acid rain This fragile globe's environment Is going down the drain It is a cosmic punishment That we can't start again Oh, tidings of comfort and joy, Oh tidings of comfort and joy Melanie Phillips OVERNIGHT FILE 
 PAGE en2 
 North K 7 3 A 2 A 9 7 6 A K 9 6 West Q 9 8 6 Q J 8 7 K Q J 4 3 East J K 6 Q J 8 4 2 10 8 7 5 2 South A 10 5 4 2 10 9 5 4 3 10 5 3 &mdash; WestNorthEastSouth No1DNo1S No2NTNo4H No4SNoNo No 
 Even if you do not agree with the bidding, you will certainly admire the play. 
 West led the queen of clubs, and declarer won in dummy, discarding a diamond from the closed hand, and immediately led the ace and another heart. 
 East won with the king and returned a second club to dummy's king, with South discarding a second diamond from hand. 
 Now came the key play of the king of spades. 
 When the jack appeared from East, declarer ruffed a club and ruffed a heart in dummy. 
 She was now in complete control. 
 The ace of diamonds and another club ruff were followed by a second heart ruff in dummy, leaving the following position: 
 North &mdash; &mdash; 9 7 6 &mdash; West Q 9 8 &mdash; &mdash; &mdash; East &mdash; &mdash; Q J 8 &mdash; South A 10 10 &mdash; &mdash; 
 Declarer now had a complete count of West's hand. 
 She led a losing diamond from dummy, on which she discarded the winning heart from the closed hand, and West was forced to ruff and concede the last two tricks. 
 South's well-timed play had produced an overtrick on a hand on which a number of declarers actually went down in four spades, and, not surprisingly, the Israeli pair collected a complete &bquo;top&equo;. 
 PAGE 
 Havel, the young playwright in the late 1960s A writer still?. 
 IS CZECHOSLOVAKIA likely to gain a president in Vaclav Havel and lose a dramatist? 
 It seems unlikely. 
 One of the striking things about Havel is his commitment to drama over the past quarter-century and his insistence, in the period immediately before the Czech revolution, that he was first and foremost a writer. 
 I had occasion in late October to present a brief profile of Havel as a preface to a Radio 4 presentation of his latest play, Redevelopment. 
 In the course of it Edward Lucas, a BBC Prague correspondent, asked Havel directly if he wanted to be president. 
 He said that he could not imagine conditions arising that would make it possible, stressed the collective nature of the democratic movement and said &bquo;I cannot forever play this dual role of amateur politician and writer.&equo; 
 Earlier this summer he similarly told the Observer's Mark Frankland &bquo;The more I am forced to be active in politics, the more I enjoy doing theatre.&equo; 
 History moves fast these days. 
 But what persuades me that we have not heard the last of Havel the writer is that he combines a total commitment to social freedom and individual responsibility with an extraordinary ironic detachment. 
 In both his plays and essays &mdash; recently issued in paperback by Faber under the title Living In Truth &mdash; he shows a remarkable gift for analysing the dilemmas of the dissident in a repressive society. 
 He is both participant and observer: &bquo;a sceptical, sober, anti-Utopian, understated mind&equo; (in his own words) confronting the business of opposing state power with rueful self-awareness. 
 Havel is now in the seat of power; but I cannot imagine he has lost his central European gift for irony. 
 At first, I suspect, we got Havel wrong in this country: on the strength of an early play like The Memorandum (1965) we pigeonholed him as an Absurdist along with Beckett and Ionesco. 
 In that early work, memorably presented on TV and radio, we see a monolithic state organisation attempting to replace the existing vernacular with a synthetic language, Ptydepe, that will iron out the ambiguities and imprecisions of everyday speech. 
 But where true Absurdism, as Vera Blackwell pointed out, posited a meaningless universe, Havel's aim was &bquo;the improvement of man's lot through the improvement of man's institutions.&equo; 
 Havel has written constantly about the oppressive nature of Communist bureaucracy. 
 But in recent years his plays have been more about the paradoxical nature of dissidence itself: the emotional turbulence of the authority given the individual as a public spokesman, and about the fact that one of the worst features of any totalitarian system is the need to conform to other people's expectations. 
 Havel explored the dilemmas of the dissident with wry comedy in The Vanek Plays (Audience, Protest and Private View) written in the mid-70s. 
 In the best of them, Audience, Havel capitalises on his own experience of working in a brewery at Trutnov stacking empty beer barrels. 
 In the play we see Vanek (a lightly disguised version of Havel) summoned for an interview by the brewery's lager-swilling Head Maltster. 
 He finds that he is being offered a simple trade-off: a comfortable job as a stock-checker if he will provide incriminating information about himself which the Maltster can then pass on to the Party. 
 The sting lies in the tail when Vanek bends his principles to accommodate his desperate interrogator. 
 What Havel wittily shows is the kind of Catch-22 situation faced by a dissident in a despotism: whether to cling fiercely to your own moral integrity (thereby landing others in the shit) or whether to conform and perpetuate a corrupt system. 
 EVEN after nearly four years in prison (where, characteristically, he turned the permitted weekly letter to his wife into philosophical essays) Havel was able to dramatise the dissident's dilemma with a mixture of recollected pain and resilient humour. 
 Largo Desolato, written in the early 80s is about the difficulty of being a moral hero in an immoral society. 
 Havel's protagonist is a philosopher caught in a double bind. 
 He has offended the state with a work called The Ontology of the Human Self and an openly provocative paper (much as Havel himself did with his Open Letter to President Husak of 1975). 
 But his simple desire for seclusion is imperilled by a succession of visitors. 
 On the one hand, two fans from a papermill implore him to become a dissident figurehead: on the other hand, two state policmen want him to sign a document denying authorship of the original article. 
 One sympathises with Havel's predicament. 
 At the same time the play leaves a key question tantalisingly unresolved: whether, in a repressive state, one can seek freedom for oneself without seeking it for others. 
 And this raises the question of whether Havel's talent had begun to be affected by the nervous strain of writing under surveillance and of not having seen any of his work performed since 1969. 
 Any fears, however, that Havel's talent might be going off were for me resolved by the broadcast version of Redevelopment, given a dramatised reading by the RSC in February under the title Slum Clearance. 
 This is a major work: a dense, multi-layered allegory with its roots firmly in reality. 
 It is set in a medieval castle in a historic town in Eastern Europe. 
 Supervised by a state functionary (with a sqeaking shoe) and led by an emotionally-chaotic project director, a group of architects struggle to come up with a high-rise building scheme that will destroy the ancient town's character and, incidentally, clear away its slums. 
 On the realistic level, the play is about a universal architectural dilemma: how to achieve a balance between conservation and civic improvement. 
 But it also works as a political metaphor about the whimsical arbitrariness of autocracy with the architects first working under strict supervision and then being granted an illusory whiff of freedom. 
 This is vintage Havel: creating a work that is both specific and universal, tragic and comic. 
 It leaves me speculating that Havel the artist is unlikely to be displaced by Havel the politican. 
 For the moment, he obviously has more urgent tasks than writing plays. 
 But he is unlikely to be satisfied forever with the illusion of power. 
 Michael Billington t 
 Where all the nuts are Trumps Gumpets. 
 By Beverly Pagram GUMNUTLAND &mdash; twinned with Willesden Junction, says the sign over the platform. 
 The station master is wearing a hat shaped like a cucumber. 
 There's a small green dog asleep in the ticket office. 
 Gumnutland is on a branch line at Wanneroo, near Perth in Western Australia. 
 None of its inhabitants is more than three inches high. 
 Made of eucalyptus gumnuts, banksia nuts, dried wildflower petals and seedpods, these homuncules would have confounded Gulliver. 
 They throng the streets and mini-timbered buildings of Gumnutland in their hundreds. 
 Beside the chuffing narrow gauge train, travel-weary &bquo;Gumpets&equo; wait with their titchy acorn prams and seed-case luggage. 
 There are swarms of Gumpets going to school, to the office, to the bank, waiting outside the grocers' for cut-price Cadbury's Fruit &amp; Nut. 
 This remarkable scene is the showpiece of a workshop-museum and export business called The Gumnut Factory. 
 It has become such an attraction that local tour operators are beating a path to its door. 
 Perth is proud of its image as a breeding ground for don't-take-no-for-an-answer entrepreneurs. 
 It's not surprising, therefore, that a 33-year-old former London motor mechanic has turned a A&dollar;200 garden shed operation into an expanding enterprise with a A&dollar;250,000 per year turnover. 
 What is extraordinary is that Chris Trump is raking it in with nature table whimsy, rather than oil, beer, or newspapers. 
 In Perth souvenir shops, Gumpets are elbowing their way on to the shelves alongside the stock-in-trade plywood boomer angs, mallee-root ornamental clocks and kangaroo-skin sporrans. 
 Recently Trump has sold three Gumnut Factory shop franchises &mdash; two to New South Wales tourist outlets and one to a Californian company. 
 Consignments of his nutty bushwackers are on their way to UK gift shops to compete with fir-cones in frocks and teasel mice. 
 This Trumping of the souvenir market goes back to a boyhood in Portsmouth and a hobby of collecting shells and making creatures out of them. 
 &bquo;When I came here with my parents in 1974 and saw that most of the &bquo;Australian&equo; souvenirs were imported from Hong Kong and the Philippines, I decided to try and break into the market,&equo; he recalled. 
 Retail outlets and distributors alike told him where to stick his gumnuts. 
 The Small Business Advice Bureau said there was not much call for banksia-blossom owls. 
 But by 1979 he was selling enough stock from his Mum's garden shed to move into the Wanneroo premises. 
 Also in the pipeline is an Australian children's TV series based on Gumnut Factory Folk Tales (written, illustrated and published by Chris Trump, A&dollar;7.95). 
 Cynics might observe that Trump is exploiting his relationship with wee George and Gertie Gumnut et al. 
 In fact he takes his role as guardian of these fey fellahin so seriously that perhaps one should regard him as the Brobdingnagian Mayor of Gumnutland. 
 The Gumnut Factory is at 30 Prindiville Drive, Wangara Centre, WA 6065. 
 Feature Tours, Australian Pacific and Bus Australia all make regular visits. 
 Where brass makes music Critic's choice Music.. 
 By Gerald Larner FOLLOWERS of the BBC Philharmonic &mdash; that small but discriminating section of the concert audience in the North-west &mdash; will have noticed a peculiarly high proportion of works featuring solo trumpet in the orchestra's current programmes. 
 Earlier this month Elgar Howarth conducted the BBC PO in Christopher Sansom's Invisible Cities for trumpet and trombone and orchestra, with Hakan Hardenberger and Christian Lindberg. 
 In the RNCM on Friday they are playing Sir Peter Maxwell Davies's Trumpet Concerto, with Hakan Hardenberger as soloist. 
 In Studio 7 on January 11 they are playing Michael Blake Watkins's Trumpet Concerto, again with Hakan Hardenberger. 
 The reason behind this concentrated specialist activity is that Hardenberger, Howarth, and the BBC PO are making a record of the Maxwell Davies and Blake Watkins concertos together with Harrison Birtwistle's Endless Parade, which last they performed so well and so memorably at York University last season. 
 For Hardenberger &mdash; the brilliant young Swedish trumpeter for whom the Birtwistle and the Blake Watkins pieces were written and who would have commissioned the Maxwell Davies if John Wallace hadn't go there first &mdash; it is an exciting project. 
 &bquo;To me these three pieces are possibly better than anything written for my instrument.&equo; 
 What anything?, 
 I asked, desperately trying to think of great composers who have written great trumpet concertos. 
 &bquo;Yes, although the Haydn can possibly compete.&equo; 
 The point is that it has taken players like Wallace and Hardenberger to contradict the cliches about the limitations of the instrument and to prove how flexible it really is. 
 Indeed, with what he callls its &bquo;huge range of expression&equo; as well as its power to fill even the largest concert hall, Hardenberger feels that the trumpet is a particularly valuable instrument for the contemporary composer. 
 He points to the three British works in the recording project to demonstrate what variety it has to offer &mdash; the &bquo;hard black-and-white&equo; sound of the Birtwistle, the comparitively florid &bquo;flute or clarinet-like writing&equo; in the Maxwell Davies Concerto, the &bquo;very expansive&equo; trumpet part in the Blake Watkins, which is a &bquo;wonderfully lyrical work without being sweet or silly in any way.&equo; 
 Hardenberger is particularly happy that his partners in the concerts and in the recording are Elgar Howarth and the BBC Philharmonic. 
 Howarth, a fellow student of Birtwistle and Maxwell Davies (who wrote the Trumpet Sonata, Op.1, for him) in Manchester in the 1950s, is himself a trumpet player as well as a specialist conductor of contemporary music. 
 Hardenberger also recalls that the BBC PO's York performance of Endless Parade &mdash; a work so difficult in its string scoring that two or three other orchestras have actually refused to play it with him &mdash; is the best he has taken part in so far. 
 I get the impression that, of the three, Hardenberger's favourite is the Blake Watkins Concerto, which he considers &bquo;very English, more traditional perhaps but without being in any way limited. 
 The orchestration is wonderful and there is an absolutely beautiful trumpet part.&equo; 
 On the other hand, he says, &bquo;I feel such an enormous amount of emotion in all three pieces. 
 It's not really up to me to judge that they are the best ever. 
 But we shall see in 200 years if I am right.&equo; 
 Trumpeter as soloist&hellip; 
 Hakam Hardenbergher: see Critic's choice THIS CAPTION FOR N-WEST TABLOID 
 Robert Hands and Tracey Childs in a musical treatment of Great Expectations; Liverpool Playhouse: see Theatre PAGE 
 No comfort from yachting win. 
 By Mike Seccombe in Canberra 
 AUSTRALIA's best-known businessman and yachtsman, Alan Bond, had little time to savour his victory in Australia's premier yacht race, the Sydney to Hobart. 
 The first Mr Bond knew of the successful move by the National Australia Bank to put his brewery businesses into receivership, was through a radio news bulletin aboard his A&dollar;3.5million maxi-yacht, Drumbeat. 
 On his arrival in Hobart, Mr Bond told journalists he was not finished yet. 
 &bquo;I have just got it confirmed, but these things take time, and there's a long way to go yet.&equo; 
 But Mr Bond was vague on details, because the rules of the race are that once a boat has started, it may not make contact except with officials until the event is over. 
 So while his empire teetered, Mr Bond sailed on for more than three days incom-municado. 
 Last night an executive director of Bond Corp, Peter Lucas, attacked the NAB move: &bquo;If that's the way business can expect bankers to behave, God help Australia.&equo; 
 But Mr Bond has been through it all before. 
 In 1974 his property and investment group also faced problems brought on by a credit squeeze and downturn in the building market. 
 Luck was on Mr Bond's side that time, reaping more than &dollar;5 million from a decision by the Western Australian Government to pay out &dollar;13million to cover land purchases in 1975. 
 The Federal Government in turn bailed out Western Australia. 
 Ironically Federal Cabinet approved the payment on September 26, 1983, the day Mr Bond won the America's Cup. 
 No such intervention is in the offing now. 
 Downhill Down Under. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 IT HAS been downhill for the past 13 months at Bond Corporation ever since the Lonrho chief, Tiny Rowland, unleashed his first poisoned arrow. 
 In mid-November last year after Alan Bond had the temerity to build a stake in Lonrho &mdash; later increased beyond 20 per cent &mdash; Mr Rowland declared the Australian group nothing more than &bquo;a A&dollar;10 billion bubble of debt.&equo; 
 Just two weeks later Mr Rowland declared it &bquo;technically insolvent.&equo; 
 It is a charge never withdrawn and it is one which stuck. 
 An Australian Broadcasting Tribunal investigation into Mr Bond's eligibility to own television stations declared him &bquo;not fit and proper&equo; and growing stock market unease was accentuated by the disclosure that Mr Bond was trying to sell Van Gogh's Irises, for which he had paid a record &dollar;54million but which had been partially funded by the auctioneer. 
 Mr Bond's business tactics became an increasing focal point and the autumn increased certainty that Mr Bond's corporate days were numbered. 
 A stock market probe was launched in September and the group's media business, including the prestigious Channel Nine, had slumped into the red. 
 Deadlines were repeatedly missed for the sale of the brewing businesses. 
 In October, Mr Bond revealed the much-delayed results from his corporation showing losses of A&dollar;1 billion &mdash; the largest in Australian corporate history. 
 Mr Bond has been threatened with receiverships, the loss of boardroom control at his key Bell Resources company, failure to secure sale of the breweries, share suspensions, disclosure that a former employee may have been involved in telephone bugging and the final indignity of a derisory A&dollar;53 million bid from rival Kerry Packer for his TV interests. 
 Home help for first-timers. 
 IF YOUR New Year resolution is to become a home owner, the Yorkshire Building Society is offering first-time buyers mortgages at two per cent below its standard interest rate of 14.75 per cent for the first six months of the loan. 
 The society will lend up to 95 per cent of the purchase price or valuation, whichever is lower. 
 And the Sussex County Building Society will peg the interest rate for first-time buyers at 13.65 per cent for a year. 
 Meanwhile housebuilder Cala Homes is wooing first-timers by paying the 5 per cent deposit, stamp duty and &pound;500 towards the legal costs. 
 The builder still has a number of unsold houses at Petersfield, Hampshire, and Billinghurst, Sussex. 
 Prices start at &pound;62,500. 
 When the compass is thrown out, then financiers beware Eighties notebook. 
 By Alex Brummer 
 WITH the exquisite sense of timing of the champion yachtsman Alan Bond brought the last trading session of a tumultuous decade to a halt. 
 The shift in winds as the international economy moved from the extravagant eighties to the uncharted nineties has been evident for sometime but only the master helmsman could have kept afloat until now. 
 In many ways Alan Bond's demise is a parable of the last 10 years. 
 Mr Bond's business rise would not have been possible without the return of laissez-faire; the emergence of deregulation; the ascent of the mega-merger and the credit boom centred on the Anglo economies of Australia, the United States and Britain. 
 Conspicuous consumption epitomised by Mr Bond's &dollar;53.9million purchase of Van Gogh's Irises was as much a totem of the gilded era as insider trader Ivan Boesky's exaltation to greed. 
 The political powerhouses behind the era of easy debt and spending were Ronald Reagan and Margaret Thatcher. 
 Their revolutions based on the 18th century economics of Jean-Baptiste Say and Adam Smith, paved the way for the most profligate age since the 1920s. 
 Once the constraints of monetarism and dirigisism were swept away everything seemed possible. 
 In the US the historic walls which had been built between the banking system and the savings and loans were breached without attention to the integrity of the financial system. 
 In the UK, financial deregulation from freeing of the building societies to Big Bang in the City were handled more sensibly. 
 But the effects were the same: an untrammelled credit explosion. 
 A sure-footed City scribbler Tim Congdon of Gerrard &amp; National writes: &bquo;The 1980s will be remembered as a decade of remarkable growth in all forms of credit.&equo; 
 In 1980 new bank and building society lending was &pound;15.7billion and by 1988 it had reached &pound;82billion. 
 In the US the picture was similar. 
 There was an enormous expansion of credit to finance cumulative budget deficits of &dollar;1,400billion. 
 What was worrying about this phenomenon was its accompaniment by financial hooliganism. 
 As John Kenneth Galbraith writes in the January 1990 issue of The New York Review of Books: &bquo;Not before in our history have so many strong influences united to produce so large a disaster as in the the current case of the savings and loan disaster: bureaucratic inadequacy and incompetence, perverse ideology, money in large amounts for political protection.&equo; 
 Another important consequence of deregulation was the availability of finance for mega-mergers. 
 The funds unlocked by Michael Milken's junk bonds, a form of finance which uses the tax benefits which accrue to corporate debt, meant that the unthinkable takeovers of the past became possible. 
 Moreover, the insatiable desire of Wall Street, the City and the commercial banks for a share of the action meant that finance was rarely a bar. 
 In the early 1980s Lord Hanson's &pound;3.5billion successful bid for Consolidated Goldfields would have seemed unlikely and Sir James Goldsmith's audacious &pound;13billion offer for BATs impossible. 
 But in the eighties the compass was thrown away. 
 Oil giants such as Getty were stalked by takeover wildcatter T Boone Pickens and swallowed whole by others. 
 Airlines attracted the attention of corporate buccaneers like Carl Icahn who was to turn his attention to that icon of American might USX (the former United Steel). 
 The most illustrious names in retailing from the House of Fraser to Macy's and Bloomingdale's were caught up in leveraged and management buyouts. 
 RJR-Nabisco was consumed by Kohlberg Kravis and there was even a scheme, at one stage, to mount a &dollar;40billion plus takeover for General Motors. 
 The mega-merger brought with it its own lexicon and culture. 
 Terms like junk bonds and LBOs tripped off the tongue. 
 Corporate raiders like Mr Bond, Ronald Perelman, Sir James Goldsmith et al bestrode continents like the explorer knights of the 16th century. 
 There were white knights and poison pills, Pac-Man defences and unbundling. 
 And all of this was wrapped up culturally by Tom Wolfe in the Bonfire of the Vanities and Oliver Stone in Wall Street. 
 They were to the 1980s what F Scott Fitzgerald was to the roaring twenties. 
 The money sloshing around allowed new wave companies to agglomerate, service the raiders and beneficiaries of Big Bang and create demands which people didn't even know they had. 
 Saatchi &amp; Saatchi was among the hidden persuaders and such niche retailers as Next and the Body Shop made looking and feeling good availiable to all. 
 The double breasted suit moved from Savile Row to the high street and console jockeys of the financial markets, celebrated in the Thames series Capital City. 
 This unfortunately is a series caught in a time warp. 
 The Saatchis are yesterday's men; Next has shed George Davis and its allure and this has been an end of year without bonuses for the City as it seeks to operate within the constraints of a tight credit policy and high interest rates. 
 While the credit- driven Anglo economies draw in their horns the savings and investment driven economies of Japan and West Germany are reaping their rewards. 
 Japan's status as an economic superpower will shortly be marked at the International Monetary Fund and its surpluses, built on the voracious consumer, speak for themselves. 
 Sony's &dollar;3.4billion acquisition of Columbia Pictures is a vivid illustration of how even national symbols can fall prey. 
 Nothing, however, quite prepared us for the momentous last months of this decade. 
 As the Eastern European economies submitted to the attractions of the market system all the excesses of the eighties somehow look slighter. 
 The roar of the SuperMark becomes louder by the hour as freedom translates to trading and economic opportunities to the Western economy plumb in the centre of the new Central Europe. 
 On our own Stock Exchange the shares of Deutsche Bank, with its tentacles in every corner of Euro-business, have doubled this year and climbed more than 10 per cent in one trading day this week. 
 There could be no more potent proxy for a new economic order in the nineties. 
 Bond in last-ditch move to save empire. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 ALAN BOND, the Australian entrepreneur, part of whose business empire was yesterday put into receivership, will today begin last-ditch legal action to keep his organisation afloat. 
 The 11th-hour courtroom drama follows a year of struggle by the tycoon &mdash; owner of Castlemaine XXXX lager &mdash; to keep his brewing, property, media and resources corporation alive despite debts of more than A&dollar;8billion. 
 This is not the first time in his career that Mr Bond, condemned for unconventional and perhaps sometimes dubious business tactics, has teetered on the brink of bankruptcy. 
 But if his empire fails this time it will join the record books as the largest business collapse in the world. 
 A &bquo;sunset raid&equo; yesterday in the Victorian Supreme Court by the National Australian Bank appointed receivers to six of the Bond Corporation's brewery businesses and threatens to topple the entire organisation. 
 The breweries, which include Tooheys and Swan lager, are the powerhouse of the Corporation, providing by far the majority of cash flow with which to meet mounting debt payments, running at A&dollar;4million a day. 
 A spokesman for Bond Corporation admitted the action could wipe out the entire group. 
 Its auditors warned recently that difficulties over just one debt could have a domino effect throughout the organisation. 
 &bquo;In theory, it could trigger the repayment of every other facility we have. 
 It could bring Bond down,&equo; he said. 
 Receivership at the breweries, for instance, could immediately trigger the repayment of most of the group's A&dollar;1.65billion convertible loan notes. 
 Shares in Bond group companies were suspended on the Stock Exchange after the receivership decision but the group said other lenders had said they would not take immediate action. 
 Describing NAB's decision as &bquo;outrageous&equo;, Bond Corporation is today applying for a restraining order to prevent the receivers taking any action until a full court hearing on Tuesday. 
 The corporation, which yesterday announced a A&dollar;2billion deal to sell the breweries and some other assets to its 58 per cent owned subsidiary, Bell Resources, said NAB &mdash; whose syndicate is owed A&dollar;880million &mdash; was acting in a &bquo;quite extraordinary&equo; way. 
 The company argued that it was given a stay of execution by other bankers even though it had defaulted on loans connected with its American Heileman brewing operations. 
 But one banking source involved in the NAB syndicate said: &bquo;It has been a long-running saga and banks were worried about yet another swing of assets from one part of the Bond organisation to another.&equo; 
 The Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation, a major lender to Bond but one which cut its exposure to about A&dollar;1billion earlier this year, said it would study the implications of the NAB action over the weekend. 
 Standard Chartered in London, understood to have around &pound;300million on loan to Mr Bond, declined to comment, although it is understood executives are confident of the asset backing for most of the exposure. 
 News of the receivership proceedings came as Mr Bond won the Sydney to Hobart yacht race and witnesses said he was visibly shaken and &bquo;distraught&equo; at the news. 
 He immediately flew to Perth in an attempt to begin his defence and boost the morale of his remarkably loyal employees, who were yesterday attempting to portray the receivership move as a battle between &bquo;old money&equo;, represented by the Melbourne banking community, and &bquo;new money&equo;, in the form of Mr Bond. 
 Analysts predicted that if the appointment of receivers was followed by the collapse of the whole Bond Corporation the Australian stock markets would suffer a setback. 
 But it is understood that most of the banks who have lent money to Bond have secured their loans against assets or have made provisions against ultimate default. 
 &bquo;Bond has been one of the walking wounded for so long that most people have seen this coming and should have provided against it,&equo; a banking executive said. 
 &bquo;The major bankers have also been very close to goings on in the Bond Corporation for some time.&equo; 
 Bond Corporation will seek in court hearings today and on Tuesday to defend its viability. 
 In a letter to the Australian Stock Exchange, the company said it would &bquo;vigorously oppose the appointment that has been made and will do everything in its power to have the receivership rescinded.&equo; 
 It will question NAB's assertion that the value of the brewery operations has fallen to such a level that asset-backed loans are in jeopardy. 
 The company claims not to have defaulted on the NAB loan and criticised the bank for failing to take account of the &bquo;extraordinary financial difficulties&equo; being faced throughout the country's business community because of high interest rates. 
 The stock market sees out 1989 in fine style. 
 By Mark Milner 
 THE stock market rang out 1989 in fine style yesterday but for the pound it was the familiar story of a struggling recovery from a previous hefty fall. 
 The contrasting fortunes of share prices and sterling were illustrated by the Financial Times Stock Exchange 100 share index closing within a whisker of its best for the year whilst sterling could manage only a marginal improvement from Thursday's all-time low against the German mark. 
 Better-than-expected trade figures and increasing optimism that UK interest rates may start to fall from their current 15 per cent level, perhaps as early as next spring, helped fuel a 23.9 point rise in the index to 2,422.7 &mdash; within four points of the year's high of 2,426 established just before the mini-crash in October and within hailing distance of the all-time high of 2,443.4, established on July 16, 1987. 
 Though the London market was slow to recover from the great crash in October 1987, it has enjoyed a bumper run in 1989. 
 Yesterday's close compared with the 1,793.1 at which the FTSE index ended 1988. 
 The pound's fall from grace has not been quite as marked as the stock market's recovery but, for all the Government's protestations about the need for a firm exchange rate, its decline has been very sharp. 
 At the end of 1988 the pound stood at &dollar;1.79 and DM3.20, putting the effective exchange rate at around 97 per cent of its 1985 value. 
 But despite the climb in bank base lending rates to 15 per cent and frequent support from the Bank of England sterling's effective index is ending the year a full 11 per cent lower at 86.0. 
 Against the DM the pound managed to rally a pfennig yesterday to close at DM2.7336 whilst it was little changed against the dollar, at &dollar;1.6130. 
 This year's strong performance by UK share prices closes a decade which, according to the financial information group, Datastream, has seen the UK stock market climb 266 per cent. 
 But even that performance is only sufficient to put it in the middle ranking of the world's stock markets. 
 Top position over the decade goes to Japan where the Nikkei Dow average rocketed by 875 per cent in dollar terms, more than double that of its closest rival, Italy. 
 But the UK market is still a long way ahead of the worst performers in Datastream's league table, Hong Kong and Switzerland. 
 But even they could show a better return for investors than gold. 
 Datastream's end of decade calculations show that a &pound;100 investment in the shiny yellow metal made at the beginning of January 1980 would be worth just &pound;78. 
 Putting the cash in the building society would have yielded just over &pound;300. 
 The world markets yesterday: 
 New York: The Dow Jones added 20.91 points to close the year at 2,753.20, just 1 per cent below its all-time high set in October. 
 Hong Kong: Prices nosedived. 
 Hang Seng index: 2,836.57 (2,895.43). 
 Tokyo: Slightly firmer. 
 Nikkei index: 38,915.87 (38,876.94). 
 Paris: A late rally helped shares recover. 
 CAC index: 553.8 (552.0). 
 . 
 By Nick Pandya 
 ONE of the most remarkable features of the Thatcher decade is the continuing rise of consumer credit. 
 The average home loan is now almost triple the &pound;13,000 at the beginning of the Eighties. 
 And the outstanding debt which excludes mortgages has seen a three-fold increase to &pound;40 billion. 
 The most tangible signs of this tendency to borrow more are highlighted in the Central Statistical Office's Social Trends 1989, which showed that household expenditure exceeded income in 1986 and 1987 for the first time since compilation of the information began. 
 This phenomenal growth in consumer debt is partly explained by the proliferation of credit and charge cards, which the marketing men sell as &bquo;take the waiting out of wanting. 
 The number of plastic cards in circulation has risen from less than 10 million 10 years ago to 27 million today, while the total bank lending on cards &mdash; which in January 1980 stood at &pound;934 million &mdash; currently stands at a massive &pound;6.6 billion. 
 Another major feature of the past decade has been the advent of in-house credit cards offered by large department stores, which remain popular despite the punitive rates of interest. 
 Consumers are frequently lured into debt by careful manipulation of the English language. 
 Retailers have effectively redefined &bquo;debt&equo; as &bquo;credit&equo; &mdash; a move which has been dubbed the greatest marketing coup of all time by the National Association of Citzens Advice Bureaux (NACAB). 
 But, for the over extended borrowers, the chickens have come home to roost. 
 The NACAB has recorded a rise of 120 per cent in the number of debt related inquiries in the last 10 years. 
 NACAB increasingly deals with clients who have run up large bills on their credit cards only to find that the repayments crippling. 
 For such clients raising a second mortgage to pay off the credit card debt often seems the only answer. 
 A personal triumph for the pension revolution. 
 By Mihir Bose 
 PENSIONS underwent an unexpected revolution in the Eighties &mdash; sparked by a report in 1982 from the Occupational Pensions Board on the plight of those who move jobs. 
 A company pension system which rewarded those who stayed with one firm all their working life with a pension equivalent to two thirds of final salary, &bquo;froze&equo; the pensions of those who moved jobs. 
 The debate generated by the report acquired extra bite when a document calling for Portable Pensions was issued by the Centre for Policy Studies. 
 The document was shrewdly timed. 
 Within a few months of its publication the government had launched a huge inquiry into pensions which was to produce a series of changes &mdash; including the right of employees changing jobs to either take a pension with them, or leave it with the previous employer and have it uprated in line with the retail price index up to a maximum of 5 per cent. 
 The crowning piece of this legislation was the introduction of personal pensions in 1988, which allowed individuals to opt out of their company plans and start a personal pension. 
 As Chancellor of the Exchequer, Nigel Lawson considerably modified the tax framework in which life assurance and pensions schemes operated, removing for instance the tax relief on life insurance premiums. 
 And in his last Budget, in 1989, he capped the salary that can be used to contribute to a pension scheme at &pound;60,000. 
 The Eighties ended with Mrs Thatcher being forced to concede increased pensions of &pound;40 a week for widows of servicemen killed in the second world war. 
 Their pensions were substantially lower than the ones enjoyed by widows of servicemen killed in subsequent wars. 
 Kalms unveils Dixons defence. 
 Mr Stanley Kalms, chairman of electrical retailer Dixons, yesterday unveiled his company's defence document aimed at beating off a &pound;550million bid from Kingfisher. 
 The document is full of information about Dixons' market share &mdash; reckoned to be around 16 per cent &mdash; and efforts to smarten up Dixons and Currys outlets. 
 But Mr Kalms refuses to give any information about current trading or likely profits. 
 That will come later, he says. 
 RI raise Invicta stake. 
 Radio Investments has taken its stake in Kent-based radio station Invicta Sound to 10.47 per cent through the purchase of another 1.39 per cent. 
 Panfida sells in US. 
 Panfida is to sell its US retailing and trading interests to concentrate on its British business, the Martin Retail Group. 
 MMC deadline extended. 
 The Trade Secretary, Nicholas Ridley, has extended the January 12, 1990 deadline set for the Monopolies Commission's report on the proposed merger of the Colne Valley, Lee Valley, and Rickmansworth water companies to February 12. 
 Attwoods expands. 
 Attwoods, the waste disposal group where Denis Thatcher is a director, is to buy London-based Taskmasters Cleansing Services for &pound;3.7million. 
 Opec departure. 
 Opec President Rilwanu Lukman is likely to step down after being switched from the Nigerian oil minister's job in a cabinet reshuffle. 
 Lukman, now foreign minister, was re-elected OPEC president in November. 
 Grenfell unconditional. 
 Deutsche Bank's agreed bid for Morgan Grenfell has gone unconditional after acceptances were received from holders of 59.5 per cent of its shares. 
 New bid for Carron?. 
 Carron Phoenix, the Glasgow sink manufacturer which has withdrawn its recommendation for French company Bene's bid, could receive an offer from 6.4 per cent shareholder Franke of Germany. 
 Cadbury on panel. 
 Sir Adrian Cadbury, who has just stepped down as chairman of Cadbury Schweppes, has been appointed a member of the Takeover and Mergers Panel. 
 . 
 By Jill Papworth 
 THERE'S little doubt that over the past decade the British public has been moving towards the Tory party's ideal of a nation of home owners. 
 But the price of home ownership has been an increasing mortgage burden. 
 Just over 65 per cent of homes are now owned by their occupiers, compared with 55.5 per cent in 1979. 
 But, in order to buy rather than rent their own homes, Britain's nine million home buyers now have to borrow an average of &pound;37,000 &mdash; more than twice the average income &mdash; whereas 10 years ago the average loan of &pound;11,800 worked out at 1.7 times income. 
 This is mainly because salaries have not kept pace with the rise in house prices which, until this year's slump, had more than tripled from an average &pound;19,925 in 1979 to &pound;61,965 by August this year, according to the Building Societies Association's latest figures. 
 And as the decade comes to a close that mortgage burden is weighing particularly heavy. 
 After no less than four mortgage rate rises in the past 18 months &mdash; which have brought the average home loan rate close to an all-time high of 15 per cent &mdash; home buyers have seen their monthly payments go up by more than 50 per cent. 
 Many first time buyers are seeing more than half their take home pay eaten up by their mortgage payments. 
 Some can no longer make ends meet. 
 And although home ownership has proved a profitable investment during most of the decade, with house prices rising by an average of around 12 per cent, it looks far less so now. 
 Home buyers approach the end of the decade seeing the value of their homes fall by an average of three to four per cent over this year and the prospect of an average fall of 10 per cent next year. 
 A major change in the 1980s has been the huge increase in both the choice of lenders and the range of products. 
 In the mid-70s building societies were virtually the only source of house purchase loans. 
 In 1978 they provided 95.7 per cent of all mortgages. 
 Two changes since those halcyon days for the societies has put an end to their safe monopoly. 
 First, the abolition of government restrictions on bank lending in 1980 paved the way for the banks to move forcefully into the mortgage market. 
 By 1982, they had grabbed 40 per cent. 
 A second competitive threat has come from insurance companies and specialist mortgage companies such as The Mortgage Corporation and National Home Loans. 
 The societies' worst point came in 1987 when their market share was reduced to just under 50 per cent; the banks had 34.5 per cent and other finance companies 16.3 per cent. 
 The societies woke up to the threat and realised that the public was no longer naturally coming to them for mortgages. 
 The new lenders were offering borrowers more flexible loan arrangements than the traditional 25-year endowment and repayment mortgages on offer from the societies. 
 Their interest rates also tended to be more attractive. 
 Both the introduction of new rules on how societies could raise funds for mortgage loans and the 1987 stock market crash &mdash; which prompted small investors to get out of equities and put their money into building society saving accounts &mdash; made it possible for the societies to get their act together and fight back. 
 More active marketing, an increasing range of special mortgage products and interest rates currently undercutting those of the banks and new lenders, have allowed the societies to start clawing back their share of the market. 
 By the first quarter of 1989, the societies had reclaimed a 67.6 per cent share. 
 Of course, while the wider range of lenders and mortgage products mean that borrowers can end up with a better deal than in the past, it also means spending more time and effort choosing the best mortgage for your particular circumstances. 
 It has become increasingly important to carefully compare interest rates and terms offered by the various lenders on their myriad of products, particularly while base rates are high and lenders are in fierce competition to attract the relatively few people willing to brave the stagnant property market. 
 Events of 1989 have done little for Australian image. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 WITH admirable understatement, the chief economist of one of Australia's big four banks admitted yesterday that events of 1989 have done little to help his country's international business image. 
 Australia, said Mr Bob Graham of Westpac, &bquo;is gaining a bad reputation overseas as a result of the failures.&equo; 
 The collapse of Mr Bond's empire is particularly spectacular simply because of its size. 
 But it is not the first case where an Australasian entrepreneur, hailed as a hero when things are going well, has found himself brought to earth with an ignominious bump when the going gets tough. 
 It is only two months since the American arm of Quintex, the media group put together by Australian Christopher Skase, had to file for protection from its creditors under bankruptcy laws. 
 And last January saw the collapse of New Zealander Allen Hawkins' Equiticorp after it had bought Britain's GPG, parent of venerable institutions including Guinness Peat and Guinness Mahon. 
 Other antipodeans have shown greater caution &mdash; and greater resilience. 
 Sir Ron Brierley, who had a tilt at Britain's Ocean Transport &amp; Trading has survived and prospered by sticking to investments with the safe and reassuring backing of secure assets. 
 Kerry Packer sold most of his stock market investments &mdash; some of them to Bond &mdash; at the height of the stock market's bull run in 1987. 
 Robert Holmes a Court, one-time head of the same Bell Group now convulsed in the death-throes of the Bond empire, was happy to take Mr Bond's money and stand back. 
 Pat Goodman, head of New Zealand's Goodman Fielder Wattie food group, has withdrawn from the fray in Britain after buying a stake in Ranks Hovis McDougall, mounting a bid which was stalled by the Office of Fair Trading then pocketing a profit by selling his shares to Sir James Goldsmith and partners. 
 And John Spalvins, head of Adelaide Steamship sits astride an apparently financially robust company. 
 These are the survivors. 
 But between the caution of a Brierley or a Spalvins and the reckless aggression of Bond, there is a middle group of antipodean entrepreneurs who have borrowed heavily to expand but for whom the expansion has so far paid off. 
 Most notable are Rupert Murdoch &mdash; whose News Corporation has made hugely expensive forays into satellite TV in Britain and virtually every conceivable medium in the US &mdash; and Mr John Elliott whose Elders IXL is now controlled by a private company controlled by Mr Elliott and fellow executives. 
 Both Elders and News Corporation are controlled by private companies. 
 Both have expanded by borrowing. 
 No one is yet saying that either company will follow Bond, Hawkins or Skase. 
 As Mr Graham of Westpac acknowledges, Australia's overseas business image could do with a less exciting 1990. 
 Now wives and Woopies can look forward to a happy New Year. 
 By Margaret Hughes 
 THE past decade has proved just how foolhardy it would be to gaze into the crystal ball and confidently predict what lies ahead in the next 10 years. 
 But it is possible to make a few predictions for 1990. 
 Next year will certainly be a time for married women although their husbands will also be able to benefit from the personal tax changes which come into force on April 6. 
 This is the date which will see the taxman treat a married woman as a person in her own right. 
 She will be taxed independently of her husband, allowed to complete her own tax return and pay her own tax. 
 She will also have her own tax allowance, be entitled to her own standard rate band and have her own capital gains tax exemption. 
 Apart from bestowing long overdue financial independence on married women, the changes also offer couples the chance of substantial tax savings. 
 Non-working wives with incomes from savings or investment will be among the main beneficiaries as they will be able to receive tax free income or interest equivalent to their personal allowance. 
 But to get the full benefit of the new tax regime these married women will need to look for investments that pay interest gross. 
 That will tend to be offshore as banks and building societies in this country have to deduct tax at source. 
 But as the deadline approaches look out for new products, such as cash unit trusts paying interest gross, as the banks and building societies battle to hang on to those deposits. 
 This will also be the year when Woopies &mdash; well off older people &mdash; get a tax break. 
 For April 6 is also the day when the over 60s will be eligible for tax relief on the premiums they pay for private medical insurance. 
 Although primarily part of the government's plans for reducing dependence on the National Health Service, the main beneficiaries will be the Woopies since it is they who can afford private health insurance in the first place. 
 At the other end of the age range employees who have not taken advantage of the incentives to contract out of the State Earnings Related Pension Scheme (SERPS) should do so before they dwindle away altogether. 
 If you're not one of the 3.5 million who have already contracted out you will have lost out on the chance to back date for up to two years the National Insurance Contributions rebate plus the extra 2 per cent &bquo;bribe&equo;. 
 Meanwhile, 1990 will again be a year when we will have to live with high interest rates. 
 And that will mean resisting those tempting offers from lenders designed to encourage us to take on more debt by making the initial costs appear cheaper, but which store up trouble for the future. 
 It will also pay to weed out credit cards which either charge high interest rates or an annual fee, unless combined with an especially low rate of interest. 
 And if retailers do indeed start charging less for cash purchases than for those bought on credit cards, ensure that this is precisely what they are doing and not merely surcharging credit card users. 
 On the other hand there will be a greater onus to shop around for the best home for whatever spare cash you may have. 
 Despite the government's bail-out of investors, the Barlow Clowes scandal should have shown the value of placing funds in safe hands. 
 Then it will be a matter of finding the best returns, taking advantage of the already fierce competition between banks and building societies. 
 And as this competition intensifies we should become more demanding so that we actually get the kind of services and products we want. 
 We should park a little of our funds in those societies either tipped to convert to a public company or ripe for takeover to benefit from any freebies that may be on offer. 
 The stock market is unlikely to have much allure for the small investor although the start of the electricity privatisation may provide a temporary fillip. 
 What equity investment there is will be best placed in the regular savings schemes offered by unit trust and investment trust schemes with higher rate tax payers using the tax shelter of PEPs. 
 And Europe, rather than green, is likely to be the flavour of 1990. 
 Money Guardian is edited by Personal Finance Editor Margaret Hughes 
 Daniel John Did you refuse to say yes? 
 Or perhaps you didn't get the habit? 
 Maybe you2 didn't even consider being 2late for water?. 
 If the affirmative was the case in all three, don't feel ashamed. 
 Contrary to popular myth and the Government's public relations machine, you were among around 30 million people in Britain who have failed to join the crusade of popular capitalism which swept through the 1980s. 
 Whether in its truest sense &mdash; the sale of state-owned assets &mdash; or the conversion of ownership from an institution's members to a new breed of shareholders, privatisation has made profiteering a respectable way of life. 
 Maybe so, though it is still nice to see that principles still count for something, particularly when it comes to refusing to buy something you already own or turning that hand-out of shares over to a deserving charity at the expense of an easy-come, easy-go profit. 
 That apart, the figures from the 15 largest privatisations since 1981 and the two public sale-like floats &mdash; TSB and Abbey National &mdash; also tell a different story from the image which the proponents of the programme would like us to believe. 
 On one level, there is no faulting their conviction that popular capitalism has caught the public's imagination as well as our money. 
 When the Conservatives swept to power in 1979, just seven per cent of people owned shares. 
 Now, as we are frequently told, there are more shareholders than trade unionists. 
 A closer examination of the numbers shows that the most recent development of the concept &mdash; widening and deepening share ownership &mdash; has yet to catch on. 
 Just over half of all private investors hold shares in privatisation issues and of these, 56 per cent have stakes in just one of company. 
 The percentages drop greatly in terms of wider ownership: one in five hold shares in two companies; one in 12 in three and one in six in four. 
 Figures from the Treasury and the International Stock Exchange also show just how important large issues have been share ownership. 
 Abbey National's arrival on the stock market handed shares to 5.5 million people, for instance, of which 3.5 million were completely new entrants in the popular capitalism field says the Abbey. 
 The same could be said of the TSB while if you sell shares at such low prices that they guarantee the buyers an instant and spectatular profit then a lot of people are going to say: &bquo;Thank you very much indeed&equo;. 
 The 1990s then will provide the proof of just exactly how long term the effects of privatisation will be. 
 Certainly, the market crash of &bquo;87 put the whole matter into perspective and help to propel to prominence the small print in the Government advertisments that investments can go down as well as up. 
 To be fair, there is no doubt that with luck, commonsense and sensible advice many people have done very well out of privatisation shares. 
 Witness the 460 per cent rise in the shares of Associated British Ports or the 250 per cent increase in those of Enterprise Oil as just two examples. 
 But just like the City institutions, there comes the time of the irresistible profit. 
 The new breed of shareholders has yet to show its skills of actually trading shares for long term appreciation and has tended to sell out at the most lucrative time. 
 And while such mundane things as fluctating interest rates and ever-increasing gas, electricity, water bills remain on the scene, it's a strong possibility that &bquo;wider and deeper ownership&equo; will be hampered by thevery economic policies that spawned it. 
 * Price Waterhouse: Privatisation The Facts &mdash; price &pound;10. 
 PAGE 
 Bonus scheme for TVS executives. 
 By Daniel John 
 TWENTY key executives at TVS Entertainment have been offered a package of financial incentives aimed at securing their services for the station's battle to retain its lucrative ITV franchise in the South-east. 
 Details of the bonus scheme for the station's senior management emerged yesterday at a special meeting of shareholders called to approve the departure of Mr Arthur Price, former head of MTM, TVS's loss-making US production arm which it bought 18 months ago for &pound;190million. 
 So far 17 executives have signed the new terms and the agreement of the other three is just a &bquo;matter of paperwork&equo; said Mr James Gatward, TVS's chief executive who was given an 110 per cent annual pay rise only in July. 
 He now earns &pound;250,000 a year. 
 The deal does not involve them getting options on TVS shares or any large stake in the company like the package offered to executives at London Weekend Television who stand to become millionaires through a 15 per cent holding. 
 It is believed the TVS proposals involve straight forward bonus payments, the size of which will depend on whether the contractor retains its franchise, lasting 10 years, in 1992. 
 Mr Gatward refused to say whether it would involve them receiving a percentage of TVS's future profits but indicated the amount of cash involved was not large enough to require shareholder approval. 
 Other ITV stations will closely scrutinise the small print when further details are released in a few weeks. 
 However, the approaches to its main executives only came out under aggressive press questioning of Mr Gatward after yesterday's meeting which a handful of shareholders attended. 
 Lasting only seven minutes, the meeting approved without any questions the deal which sees MTM president Mr Price, who received &pound;63million for his MTM shares when TVS bought the company, leave without compensation. 
 Mr Price has also handed back 6.1million shares worth around &pound;10million which TVS is now looking to place with a potential broadcasting partner. 
 As for MTM (which took its name from US actress Mary Tyler Moore, its founder, and is best known in Britain for Hill Street Blues and Lou Grant) Mr Gatward said it would take between 18 months to two years before the company was turned around. 
 Having bought it under expectations of strong profits, TVS has since discovered MTM is making losses of &pound;20million. 
 Mr Gatward said TVS has narrowed down the candidates for the MTM job to two. 
 He is also in the process of looking for a joint venture production partner who would be interested in taking a 49 per cent stake in MTM. 
 Bonus scheme for TVS executives. 
 By Daniel John 
 TWENTY key executives at TVS Entertainment have been offered a package of financial incentives aimed at securing their services for the station's battle to retain its lucrative ITV franchise in the South-east. 
 Details of the bonus scheme for the station's senior management emerged yesterday at a special meeting of shareholders called to approve the departure of Mr Arthur Price, former head of MTM, TVS's loss-making US production arm which it bought 18 months ago for &pound;190million. 
 So far 17 executives have signed the new terms and the agreement of the other three is just a &bquo;matter of paperwork&equo; said Mr James Gatward, TVS's chief executive who was given an 110 per cent annual pay rise only in July. 
 He now earns &pound;250,000 a year. 
 The deal does not involve them getting options on TVS shares or any large stake in the company like the package offered to executives at London Weekend Television who stand to become millionaires through a 15 per cent holding. 
 It is believed the TVS proposals involve straight forward bonus payments, the size of which will depend on whether the contractor retains its franchise, lasting 10 years, in 1992. 
 Mr Gatward refused to say whether it would involve them receiving a percentage of TVS's future profits but indicated the amount of cash involved was not large enough to require shareholder approval. 
 Other ITV stations will closely scrutinise the small print when further details are released in a few weeks. 
 However, the approaches to its main executives only came out under aggressive press questioning of Mr Gatward after yesterday's meeting which a handful of shareholders attended. 
 Lasting only seven minutes, the meeting approved without any questions the deal which sees MTM president Mr Price, who received &pound;63million for his MTM shares when TVS bought the company, leave without compensation. 
 Mr Price has also handed back 6.1million shares worth around &pound;10million which TVS is now looking to place with a potential broadcasting partner. 
 As for MTM (which took its name from US actress Mary Tyler Moore, its founder, and is best known in Britain for Hill Street Blues and Lou Grant) Mr Gatward said it would take between 18 months to two years before the company was turned around. 
 Having bought it under expectations of strong profits, TVS has since discovered MTM is making losses of &pound;20million. 
 Mr Gatward said TVS has narrowed down the candidates for the MTM job to two. 
 He is also in the process of looking for a joint venture production partner who would be interested in taking a 49 per cent stake in MTM. 
 PAGE 
 Sweetener takes sugar chief's pay to &pound;534,000. 
 By Daniel John 
 THE chairman of Tate &amp; Lyle, Neil Shaw, received a massive sweetener to his annual salary this year with a 53 per cent increase, taking the amount to &pound;534,000. 
 According to the company's 1989 report, Mr Shaw's salary, paid in Canadian dollars and equivalent to C&dollar;993,000, rose from &pound;348,000 in 1988. 
 Tate &amp; Lyle's 1989 profits rose by 67 per cent to &pound;200 million and earnings per share by nearly a third to 31.6p. 
 The rise is one of the largest percentage rises to be awarded to directors of UK companies in the new round of boardroom wage negotiations. 
 The salaries of senior directors have been rising by between 20 per cent and 30 per cent over the last year and the trend shows little sign of slowing. 
 . 
 By Teresa Hunter 
 THE 1980s was the decade when the sleeping giants of the High Street banks tried to wake up to customers' needs before competitors stole accounts from under their noses. 
 At the beginning of the decade, opening a bank account was a privilege rather than a right, and customers organised their financial lives round the inflexible routine of their local branch. 
 The manager himself seemed like a distant god to be both wondered at and feared. 
 Barclays director of UK Retail Services Seymour Fortescue predicts that history will mark the late 1980s as the watershed of personal banking. 
 &bquo;A time of swift, sometimes brutal change when the old established order is all but over,&equo; he says. 
 Undeniably there has been change &mdash; much of it brought on by technology &mdash; and, generally the customer has benefited. 
 But despite the grand words from Barclays, change in local branches has frequently been slow to take effect. 
 Branch managers and staff have changed surprisingly little as a breed, for all the brighter uniforms and open plan offices. 
 Customers still get landed with unexpected bills for bank charges, despite the arrival of the age of free banking. 
 And the explosion in complaints about new technology, such as direct debits &mdash; which transfer money automatically from your account to pay bills &mdash; and cash dispensers indicate that the new method of banking could leave the customer less protected than under the old-fashioned paper-based system. 
 Competition was the driving force which lead banks to develop a more sophisticated range of services. 
 Never before were they faced with the threat of losing substantial numbers of accounts. 
 This new competition arose out of a battle between banks and building societies which arose when the banks made their first major inroad into the mortgage market. 
 New legislation freed the building societies from the constraints of selling only two products, mortgages and savings accounts, and they began to offer current accounts. 
 The writing was on the wall and the banks began to fight back. 
 Winning customers became a priority and in the early 1980s banks began tailoring accounts to meet the needs of certain sections of the population. 
 In 1982, for example, the first children's account was set up. 
 Looking at banking hours became a priority, as Saturday opening was helping building societies to woo bank customers. 
 In 1982 Barclays became the first bank to re-open its doors on Saturday mornings, and the other high street banks soon followed suit. 
 More recently, banks have extended opening hours in certain branches, to either 5pm or to coincide with late night shopping. 
 However this has not been an across the board extension. 
 In 1985 free in-credit banking was reintroduced, but to off-set these costs the programme for electronic banking was speeded up. 
 Although direct debits and cash dispenser machines had been around since the late 1960s, promotion campaigns made them farmore popular during the mid-1980s. 
 However complaints involving new technology have abunded. 
 There is general dissatisfaction with direct debits being charged at the wrong time or from the wrong account and so-called &bquo;phantom withdrawals&equo; from ATMs. 
 But the real watershed for banks came in 1987 when the Nationwide Anglia building society launched an interest-bearing current account called FlexAccount, which was soon followed by a similar one from the Abbey National. 
 It took the banks nearly two years to retaliate with interest bearing accounts of their own in an attempt to stem the flood of accounts deserting to building societies. 
 One and a half million new accounts were opened in the first year. 
 Home banking is being taken to its ultimate with the launch of Midland's Firstdirect &mdash; the bank without branches. 
 But the new decade also promises to revolutionise high street bank branches yet again. 
 Banks wish paper-based administration to be completely electronic releasing back-office staff to become front office &bquo;sales people.&equo; 
 General branches offering all services over the one counter will be replaced by cluster branches, containing specialists in different fields. 
 PAGE 
 Sock Shop shuts down in the US. 
 By Ben Laurance 
 SOCK Shop, the niche retailer created by Sophie Mirman which made its stock market debut in a blaze of publicity two years ago, has closed its 17 loss-making American outlets. 
 The shops were shut without warning two days ago. 
 All are in New York. 
 Sock Shop admitted earlier this year that all was not well with its American outlets. 
 Shoplifting and robberies forced the company to spend heavily on expensive security measures. 
 And the outlets had to be revamped to attract more customers. 
 The company has huge debts relative to its size &mdash; the most recent available figures show Sock Shop's gearing was 200 per cent. 
 Losses from the American business were &pound;670,000 in the 17 months to the end of last February. 
 It is understood that Sock Shop directors were in the US yesterday trying to find someone who might be prepared to take over the American end of the operation and continue to run it under the Sock Shop name. 
 Until now, Sock Shop has tried to avoid franchising new outlets, preferring instead to borrow to finance expansion under its own steam. 
 Any deal to keep the US shops running is likely to involve their being run on a licence or franchise basis. 
 Sock Shop shares, having hit 325p last year, now stand at a record low of 62p. 
 In Britain, the company said it was hit by this year's hot summer which meant more women were prepared to go without stockings or tights. 
 The rail strikes also had an impact: several Sock Shops are on stations and rely for their custom on rail travellers. 
 Besides the ill-fated expansion into the US, Sock Shop has also opened outlets in France. 
 There are doing well, the company says. 
 Analysts believe that at best, Sock Shop will show profits of &pound;1million in the 12 months to next February &mdash; less than half the level seen in the previous two years. 
 Bonus scheme for TVS executives CORRECTION FOR 
 By Daniel John 
 DID you refuse to say yes? 
 Or perhaps you didn't get the habit? 
 Maybe you2 didn't even consider being 2late for water? 
 If the affirmative was the case in all three, don't feel ashamed. 
 Contrary to popular myth and the government's public relations machine, you were among around 30 million people in Britain who have failed to join the crusade of popular capitalism which swept through the 1980s. 
 The figures from the 15 largest privatisations since 1981 and the two public sale-like floats &mdash; TSB and Abbey National &mdash; tell a different story from the one which the proponents of the programme would like us to believe. 
 Trade gap narrows despite cut in invisible earnings. 
 By Mark Milner 
 LAST month's improvement in Britain's huge current account deficit was achieved despite a reduction in projections about the size of the country's invisible earnings. 
 The Central Statistical Office has reduced its guesstimate of the expected monthly surplus from &pound;300million to &pound;100million, though it stresses the figures are subject to &bquo;substantial&equo; revision. 
 Britain's invisible earnings, which are made up of a surplus on things like insurance and banking offset by government contributions to the European Community and overseas aid, are now projected to be about &pound;2,670million in 1989, less than half the &pound;6,100million total earned in 1988. 
 Part of the fall is accounted for by the pattern of transactions between Britain and the EC, but part must also reflect the cost of British borrowing from overseas investors. 
 Though the invisible trade surplus has been marked down, there was encouraging news for the Government yesterday on the visible trade deficit. 
 The figures for the three months to the end of November indicate that the policy of high interest rates is beginning to have an impact in slowing down the across-the-board demand for imports which has set Britain on course for a worst ever annual trade deficit. 
 Imports of passenger cars over the three months rose only two per cent by volume, whilst imports of capital goods were down six per cent. 
 Imports of other consumer and intermediate goods both fell marginally. 
 However, imports in all four categories are still running well ahead of the same three-month period in 1988. 
 In November overall imports actually fell to &pound;9.6billion &mdash; 2.5 per cent down on October. 
 Over the last three months they rose only 0.5 per cent by value on the previous three months, but still some 12 per cent more than the same period in 1988. 
 On the export side the volume of cars shot up 27 per cent in the three months to November, compared with the previous three months though other consumer, intermediate and capital goods showed much more modest increases of 5.5 per cent, 4 per cent and 9 per cent, respectively. 
 The overall exports total showed a modest 0.5 per cent increase by value to &pound;8.1billion in November. 
 However, in volume terms, exports were up seven per cent in the last three months compared with the previous three months and was up 13 per cent on a year ago. 
 The CSO cautioned it regarded comparisons of the volume figures as distorted by the impact of the dock strike on August and September returns. 
 By taking a four-month period to flatten out the effect of the usually low total in August and the correspondingly high one for September it calculates the increase on the previous four months was four per cent and the year on year growth at 11 per cent. 
 However, the full year current account deficit is still likely to be nearer &pound;21billion than the &pound;20billion predicted by Chancellor John Major in his Autumn statement. 
 Though the trend is one of improvement few City economists are prepared to be more optimistic than Mr Major's own forecast for next year of &pound;15billion. 
 The nomal revision to which the trade figures are subject has meant that July this year has replaced October 1988 as the month in which Britain ran up its worst ever current account deficit. 
 Yesterday's CSO figures showed that the July total had been revised up to &pound;2,487million from the previous &pound;2,225 million figure. 
 . 
 By Nick Pandya 
 ONE of the most remarkable features of the Thatcher decade is the continuing rise of consumer credit. 
 The average home loan is now almost triple the &pound;13,000 at the beginning of the Eighties. 
 And the outstanding debt which excludes mortgages has seen a three-fold increase to &pound;40 billion. 
 The most tangible signs of this tendency to borrow more are highlighted in the Central Statistical Office's Social Trends 1989, which showed that household expenditure exceeded income in 1986 and 1987 for the first time since compilation of the information began. 
 This phenomenal growth in consumer debt is partly explained by the proliferation of credit and charge cards, which the marketing men sell as &bquo;take the waiting out of wanting. 
 The number of plastic cards in circulation has risen from less than 10 million 10 years ago to 27 million today, while the total bank lending on cards &mdash; which in January 1980 stood at &pound;934 million &mdash; currently stands at a massive &pound;6.6 billion. 
 Another major feature of the past decade has been the advent of in-house credit cards offered by large department stores, which remain popular despite the punitive rates of interest. 
 Consumers are frequently lured into debt by careful manipulation of the English language. 
 Retailers have effectively redefined &bquo;debt&equo; as &bquo;credit&equo; &mdash; a move which has been dubbed the greatest marketing coup of all time by the National Association of Citzens Advice Bureaux (NACAB). 
 But, for the over extended borrowers, the chickens have come home to roost. 
 The NACAB has recorded a rise of 120 per cent in the number of debt related inquiries in the last 10 years. 
 NACAB increasingly deals with clients who have run up large bills on their credit cards only to find that the repayments crippling. 
 For such clients raising a second mortgage to pay off the credit card debt often seems the only answer. 
 Twenty things you didn't know about business in 1989&hellip; 
 1. 
 In June, Alan Bond said his company &bquo;had the capacity to do something major&equo;. 
 In October he unveiled the biggest loss in Australian corporate history and he ended the year with debts of A&dollar;8billion. 
 Yesterday receivers were appointed to the breweries. 
 2. 
 DM3.20 to the pound was a critical level to defend. 
 3. 
 The American Brooks Brothers chain, bought by Marks &amp; Spencer, is likely to have sales of around &pound;183million &mdash; some &pound;50million less than M&amp;S's single largest British store at Marble Arch. 
 4. 
 Mitsubishi bought Trex oils and Princes canned foods from Nestle. 
 5. 
 &bquo;Every facet of the business improved&equo;, according to Lowndes Queensway. 
 6. 
 Church Times was bought by the Canterbury Press. 
 And the divide between the Catholic and Anglican churches was bridged &mdash; at least for investment purposes when the insurance arms of the two churches set up a joint venture, Ecclesiastical Underwriting Management, headed by the aptly named Kevin Cannon. 
 7. 
 Samuel Courtauld, the last part of the group trading with the original founder's name, was sold &mdash; to the Japanese company Toray Industries 8. 
 The Pru lost nearly &pound;1million a week on its estate agency business, and parted company with the chain's managing director. 
 Legal and General paid &pound;12million for a 103-branch chain. 
 9. 
 TV Times joined Woman, Womans Own, Farmers Weekly, Family Circle and Country Life when Reed International bought it from the ITV companies. 
 10. 
 MK Trafford Holdings failed in a takeover bid for Manchester United, which failed to float on the stock market as well as the pitch. 
 11. 
 Phillips' Polygram record company bought the Island label, then floated off as an island of its own. 
 12. 
 Ellen Schneider-Lenne became the first woman on the board of Morgan Grenfell in its 151-year history, thanks to its takeover by Deutsche Bank. 
 13. 
 Walt Disney bought the Muppets for a rumoured &dollar;100million. 
 14. 
 Andrew Brownswood of the eponymous greetings card maker was paid &pound;3.6million, modest in absolute terms by some standards but a staggering 31 per cent of the company's sales. 
 If BP boss Sir Peter Walters had been paid the same proportion of sales he would have received a salary of &pound;8.1billion. 
 As it was he had to be satisfied with a rise of 48 per cent to &pound;514,558, well below the highest-paid public company boss, Lord Hanson, who received &pound;1.5million for his efforts. 
 15. 
 American Airlines became the world's largest airline (not counting Aeroflot) when it overtook (without taking over) United Airlines. 
 16. 
 Robert Maxwell reassured shareholders and the world at large that he had turned his giant mind to the greenhouse effect. 
 He said he was negotiating to publish Eastern Bloc research on the subject and had the world's climate &bquo;well in mind&equo;. 
 17. 
 Braniff Airlines went bust for the third time. 
 18. 
 Japan's biggest bank, Dai-ichi Kangyo, just stayed ahead of Sumitomo with revenues of Y3.3billion &mdash; roughly &pound;14billion for the year or &pound;60million per working day, equal to the UK's big four banks put together. 
 19. 
 Apart from water privatisation, Harry Ramsden's fish and chip restaurant was the most oversubscribed new issue of the year at 2.6 times. 
 Hay's, which came to the market around Grey Monday, managed to sell just 8 per cent of the shares on issue. 
 20. 
 Bass, Britain's biggest brewer, became the world's largest hotelier with the &dollar;2billion purchase of America's Holiday Inn. 
 ROGER COWE 
 Body of French charity worker explodes at Khartoum airport. 
 By Peter Biles in Nairobi 
 THE body of a French charity worker killed in the shooting down of a Medicins sans Frontieres (MSF) plane in southern Sudan nine days ago exploded at Khartoum airport in what is thought to have been a booby-trap. 
 The body was being transported to Paris when the incident occurred. 
 The bodies of the four victims of last week's crash near the government-controlled town of Awiel, 560 miles south-west of Khartoum, arrived in the capital on a plane chartered by the United Nations Children's Fund (Unicef). 
 They were loaded on to two trucks at the airport, and were being moved across the tarmac when one of the bodies exploded. 
 Sources said the explosion seemed to have been caused by an incendiary device. 
 But Dr Roger Vavirie, an MSF programme director in Paris, said it was only &bquo;a small explosion,&equo; and could have been the result of decomposition. 
 It is understood that, because the victims of the Awiel plane crash were badly mutilated, doctors who had packed the bodies before shipment to France had taken extra precautions, and an explosion from decomposition was therefore said to have been unlikely. 
 There has been speculation that the body was booby-trapped before it left Awiel, and may have been timed to explode in mid-air. 
 Moldavian election campaign launched. 
 By John Rettie in Kishinyov, Moldavia 
 THE crucial elections campaign, in which Moldavian nationalists will challenge the Communist Party for control of the Soviet republic's government in February, is being launched today. 
 While senior members of the party and government hold a series of meetings around the city, the Stefan the Great Movement for National Revival is holding what it calls a &bquo;great gathering&equo; in the main stadium. 
 The rally has been officially authorised and no violence is expected. 
 But the movement will make a strong appeal to passionate feelings of renewed nationhood in Moldavia, which have been fanned by events in neighbouring Romania. 
 The Communist Party cannot match this. 
 But it has other weapons which it deploys with some skill. 
 The republic's new party leader, appointed after violent clashes last month between nationalist demonstrators and the security forces, is a good conciliator who has created a favourable impression among many Moldavians. 
 A native-born Moldavian despite his Russian name, Mr Pyotr Luchinsky, the new first secretary has been going the rounds, talking to people in soothing terms all over the republic. 
 It seems to have been working &mdash; up to a point at least &mdash; and even members of the opposition Popular Front agree that he has been accepted by many Moldavians. 
 He went down extremely well last Sunday, for example, when many people gathered outside the party's central committee building in an unauthorised meeting and called on him to come out and talk to them. 
 He did so and, according to students who were present, spoke in amiable and conciliatory terms. 
 But the students, members of the Popular Front through their own organisation, the Students' League, said they were less happy with his performance at a meeting with them last Wednesday. 
 They said he answered some of their questions sarcastically and spoke in Russian, even though he is bilingual and the questions had been put to him in Moldavian. 
 However, as yesterday's Moldavian press reported, he spoke encouragingly about abandoning Article Six of the constitution, which guarantees the party's leading role in society &mdash; although not just yet. 
 But, not surprisingly, Mr Luchinsky flatly rejected any suggestion of changing Moldavia's frontiers &mdash; an allusion to unity with Romania. 
 &bquo;Anyone who starts talking about reviewing territorial frontiers is consciously moving towards confrontation, and incidentally, not only with local significance,&equo; he warned. 
 Although the students accepted this, and demanded only an open frontier with Romania, across which relatives could easily visit each other, some nationalists are certainly going to raise the issue. 
 Among the slogans of the Stefan the Great Movement are not only &bquo;Liberty&equo;, but also &bquo;Unity&equo;, which means unity with Romania. 
 The appeal which this call makes to Moldavians cannot be matched by Mr Luchinsky or his party. 
 No one at this stage is prepared to hazard a guess at the outcome of the poll on February 25. 
 The Stefan the Great Movement is not part of the Popular Front, which is the main umbrella group co-ordinating the opposition campaign, although many people are members of both. 
 But if it is not calling for immediate independence, or for unity with Romania, the Popular Front is certainly demanding sovereign autonomy for Moldavia and a renewal of national culture and identity. 
 While also talking of national renewal, the Communist Party emphasises its ability to concentrate resources on reviving the economy in a way that a Popular Front government could hardly expect to. 
 However, its record on the economy, housing and social services inspires little respect. 
 With Romania seething next door, Mr Luchinsky will have his work cut out to capture the spirit of Stefan the Great from those who present themselves as his heirs. 
 Hungary is hopeful but stays sceptical of better relations. 
 By Jonathan Eyal in Budapest 
 THE arrival in Romania of Mr Gyula Horn, the Hungarian Foreign Minister, is a sign of Hungarian hopes for better relations with their neighbour after the popular revolution which overthrew the Ceausescu regime. 
 But they are also fearful and sceptical about the future of democracy in that country. 
 At the heart of the dispute is the fate of Romania's roughly two million-strong Hungarian minority, who mostly live in Transylvania &mdash; a Hungarian territory until 1918. 
 Ceausescu singled out this minority for especially severe treatment in order to emphasise his nationalist credentials. 
 Janos Kadar &mdash; Hungary's now detested former Communist leader &mdash; preferred to counter this with quiet persuasion which, needless to say, left Ceausescu unmoved. 
 A treaty between the two states, signed in 1977, guaranteeing special cultural rights to the Hungarian minority was ignored and subsequently practically abrogated by Romania. 
 The political changes in both states have, if anything, exacerbated the conflict. 
 For the Hungarian political parties, facing a general election in March, the issue is of great importance, while for the provisional government now in control in Bucharest the question of Romania's sovereignty remains extremely sensitive. 
 The Hungarian authorities privately point to some recent developments which they find disturbing. 
 The Romanian revolution started in Timisoara, a racially mixed south-western town, and was initially concerned with defending the rights of the ethnic Hungarian priest, Father Laszlo Tokes. 
 Yet in the last few days the Romanians have started underplaying the role of Timisoara in sparking off open opposition to Ceausescu, highlighting instead the undoubtedly fearless role of the citizens of Bucharest. 
 Hungarians understand perfectly well that this may be due to internal Romanian reasons &mdash; the Romanian army had played some part in the initial repression in Timisoara, but since it joined the rebellion this fact has been conveniently forgotten. 
 However, Timisoara remains crucial in Hungarian calculations as it was the best example of co-operation between all ethnic groups and a good omen for the future. 
 Budapest also remain apprehensive about the nature of Romania's future political parties, and particularly those of the National Christian Peasant Party, which was recently formed with the help of Mrs Doina Cornea, one of Romania's leading former dissidents. 
 Her party's platform is imbued with religious themes and ethnic Hungarians &mdash; different from the majority of the Romanians in religion, language and traditions &mdash; have nothing to expect from this religious revival. 
 Finally, Budapest is closely watching the personalities currently running Romania's affairs. 
 In its eyes, the appointment of Mr Sergiu Celac as Romania's new foreign minister is hardly crucial. 
 Much more important is the fact that Mr Constantin Oancea, the man who dealt with Hungarian relations at the Romanian foreign ministry in Ceausescu's time, has not only remained in post but appears to have been promoted. 
 The recent declaration of the Romanian Front for National Salvation in favour of &bquo;minority rights&equo; is, at best, imprecise. 
 The problem is, therefore, one of lack of confidence between the governments of the two states. 
 The arrival of Mr Horn in Bucharest was intended to dispel some of these suspicions. 
 Hungary has been effusive in its help to the Romanians &mdash; in the first four days after the revolution no fewer than 550 trucks of aid were sent to Romania. 
 And, while the Nagylak border crossing point continues to be jammed by convoys of aid from all states, the Hungarian armed forces are preparing to airlift food supplies into Romania. 
 Mr Horn will seek to capitalise on the ensuing good will to convince Bucharest that his country has no hostile designs. 
 But he wants firmer guarantees on the status of the Hungarian minority, in particular, group rights rather than individual rights for all Romanians. 
 He hopes the Hungarian minority will be allowed to run its own schools and re-establish its university in Transylvania; that it will be allowed to run its own affairs at municipal level and that it will have &bquo;economic autonomy&equo;. 
 Mr Horn may also be able to obtain some assistance in the repatriation of 30,000 Romanian citizens who sought refuge in Hungary during Ceausescu's dictatorship. 
 However, Romanians remain prisoners of their own history: they continue to fear that Hungary's real intentions are not ethnic minority protection but a revision of frontiers. 
 As long as these fears persist, Mr Horn could only obtain the diminution, rather than a solution, to the problem of the Hungarian minority in Romania. 
 US to blockade drug barons. 
 An air and sea blockade of Colombia is part of a plan approved by President George Bush for possible use in the fight against international drug trafficking, American officials said yesterday. 
 The officials said the plan, approved by the President last week, has as a central element the use of the US military to intercept drug transactions abroad. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Drugs haul. 
 Swazi police said yesterday they had seized illegal drugs worth more than &dollar;4.3 million, the biggest haul ever made in this tiny southern African kingdom. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 18 die in clash. 
 Pro-Indian Tamil guerrillas ambushed and killed 18 members of the rival Tamil Tigers militia in northern Sri Lanka, residents said yesterday. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Kuwaitis warned. 
 The Kuwaiti Government, in an bid to contain growing agitation for the revival of a democratic parliament has warned Kuwaitis against holding unauthorised meetings. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Saudi beheadings. 
 Saudi Arabia yesterday publicly beheaded four people &mdash; two Saudis and two Indians &mdash; convicted of murder, taking the total number of people beheaded this year to 99. &mdash; Reuter. 
 86 held in raid. 
 The Pakistani army has arrested 86 people, bulldozed 20 houses and seized numerous heavy weapons in a sweep of the frontier arms-trading town of Darra. 
 The District Magistrate's office said the booty included anti-aircraft guns, artillery, rocket launchers, drugs and counterfeit money. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Bofors under review. 
 The Indian Prime Minister, Mr V.P. Singh yesterday said the government was reviewing the 1986 sale of Swedish artillery to the army amid allegations of kickbacks and bribes. 
 His statement followed a decison on Tuesday to halt future contracts with Bofors. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Turkish relief. 
 Bulgaria's new Communist authorities yesterday ended key aspects of the official assimilation policy which has forced thousands of ethnic Turks to flee the country. 
 Muslims will no longer have to assume Bulgarian names. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Toll put at 10. 
 Australian rescue workers in Newcastle yesterday recovered another body in the wreckage of a workers' club, bringing to 10 the official death toll in Thursday's earthquake. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Swedish theft. 
 Twenty-four works by Miro and worth up to three billion crowns (&pound;323,000) have been stolen from a Stockholm art gallery. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 Rangoon ban. 
 Myanma's (formerly Burma) military rulers yesterday barred one of the country's main dissident groups headed by a former prime minister, U Nu, from contesting elections set for next May. 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 SA violence. 
 At least five black men were killed and seven seriously injured in street fighting between rival groups, including the United Democratic Front, near the southern town of Uitenhage, police reported yesterday. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Counting the cost. 
 Israel will have to trim its army because of a &pound;320-million deficit stemming from the Palestinian uprising, a military source said yesterday in Jerusalem. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Israel silent as US seizes Noriega aide. 
 By Ian Black in Jerusalem and Martin Walker in Washington 
 ISRAEL yesterday maintained an embarrassed official silence on the capture by US troops in Panama of Mike Harari, a former Mossad officer and close aide to the deposed Panamanian leader, General Manuel Noriega. 
 Harari was in charge of Israel's intelligence networks in Mexico, Central America and the Caribbean until his retirement in 1979, after a 25 year career, when he became Panama's commercial attache and honorary consul in Tel Aviv before rejoining Gen Noriega in Panama City two years ago. 
 He is credited with forcing Gen Noriega to remove a portrait of Adolf Hitler from the wall of his secret bunker, training the dictator's personal bodyguard, setting up his computer networks and complex personal banking system, and establishing a small and private intelligence team to watch over the Panamanian secret police and military intelligence. 
 The US repeatedly asked Israel to ensure that Harari, aged 62, to leave Panama, but Israel insisted that he was a private citizen, a claim which was treated with considerable scepticism by Washington. 
 US officials claim the Israeli has been involved not only in security matters in Panama but also in the drug traffic for which Gen Noriega, now hiding in the Vatican embassy, is wanted by Washington. 
 For all his international notoriety, Harari is barely known in his native country, and the one photograph known to exist of him was reprinted on the front pages of newspapers yesterday accompanying the news of his arrest. 
 It was taken in 1985 when, as Panama's honorary consul in Israel, he accompanied Gen Noriega on an official visit. 
 It shows him, impassive in dark glasses, standing behind the saluting general. 
 Harari spent much of his adult life in Israel's secret world. 
 Born in Tel Aviv in 1927, he worked as a radio operator in Italy for the pre-state Haganah militia during the campaign to smuggle Jewish Holocaust survivors past the British naval blockade of Palestine. 
 In the 1950s he joined the Shin Bet internal security service and by the early 1960s was operating secretly in Europe, running agents into Arab countries for Mossad. 
 Known as a field man par excellence, he led the Israeli assassination teams that hunted down and killed Palestinians involved in the Black September terrorist organisation in the early 1970s. 
 The Mossad squads were set up after the massacre of 11 Israeli athletes at the Munich Olympic games in September, 1972. 
 But in July, 1973, Harari led a group which accidentally killed an innocent Moroccan waiter in the Norwegian town of Lillehammer. 
 Harari left Mossad in 1978, and shortly afterwards became a private businessman. 
 By 1980 he was working in Central America, where he befriended Gen Noriega's predecessor, Omar Torrijos. 
 He supplied Israeli security personnel to guard the Panamanian leaders and train their own forces, and later became involved in official Israel arms sales to the central American country. 
 He remains the most notorious of a large group of retired Israeli intelligence and security men whose dubious activities in support of unsavoury regimes have embarrassed their own government. 
 Former Mossad colleagues have insisted hotly that Harari could not have been involved in the drugs trade, but he is clearly a hard man to defend. 
 &bquo;The greatest damage to Israel,&equo; says Meir Amit, a former head of the intelligence agency, &bquo;is that rather than being known as producers in agriculture, in genetics, or in medicine, our trademark is the security business.&equo; 
 A second Israeli who acted as a civilian chief of Gen Noriega's personal security team, Eliezer Ben Gaitan, took refuge in the papal mission in Panama City with the deposed dictator, and was detained by US troops on Tuesday. 
 Well-paid for his services to Gen Noriega, Harari was known in Panama as &bquo;Mr Sixty Percent,&equo; according to Panama's former Ambassador to Tel Aviv, Mr Eduadro Herero Hassan, who was flown back to Panama this week by the US to help rebuild a new Panamanian security force. 
 Tributes greet President Havel. 
 By Michael Simmons 
 TO trumpeted fanfares, standing ovations and cheers from the people, and a 20-gun salute, Vaclav Havel, playwright extraordinary and leader of the year's most peaceful revolution against Stalinism, was acclaimed in Prague Castle yesterday as Czechoslovakia's new President. 
 The ceremony was in the hands of Mr Alexander Dubcek, who came in from the political cold less than 24 hours before, to be elected head of the new-style Federal Assembly. 
 He it was who ushered in the new head of state to the dais in Prague Castle where the oath was sworn. 
 Every member of Mr Dubcek's Assembly had voted that Mr Havel should be the country's first non-Communist leader since 1948. 
 It is a post that Mr Havel did not seek but for which he was the only serious candidate. 
 Three out of every four of the population, according to a recent poll, supported him. 
 Now, he says he will keep the post until free elections are held, probably in the first half of the coming year. 
 As a Central European intellectual, his credentials are impeccable. 
 Only a few months ago, he was in prison for &bquo;subversion&equo; and &bquo;anti-state activities&equo;; but yesterday, before the day was out, he was being congratulated as a worthy successor to the country's first leader, Tomas Garrigue Masaryk. 
 Nominating him, the Prime Minister, Mr Marian Calfa, declared: &bquo;Although he has been forced to live on the fringe of society, he has retained his moral integrity.&equo; 
 It was a tribute which will mean as much to Mr Havel as any formal honour. 
 After the vote, which had been taken in the Vladislav Chamber, where the Kings of Bohemia were once crowned, Mr Havel was sworn in. 
 &bquo;I swear on my honour and conscience, my loyalty to the Czechoslovak Socialist Republic,&equo; he said. 
 The word &bquo;Socialist&equo; in this context could also become an anachronism very soon. 
 Civic Forum wants just the &bquo;Czechoslovak Republic&equo; to be enshrined in the new Constitution; the promise &bquo;to serve the cause of socialism&equo; was deleted from the presidential oath on Thursday of this week. 
 On leaving the castle, the dapper-suited President Havel, more at home in sweater and jeans, stood with everyone else for a rendering of the national anthem. 
 This was the theme tune at last month's revolutionary rallies, where the crowds sang it with great gusto and clapped to the jaunty rhythm of its concluding lines. 
 Then, having announced to his prime minister that he hoped to be &bquo;a president of national understanding&equo;, he was called upon to review a military parade, before proceeding to attend a commemorative mass in the great Gothic Cathedral of St Vitus. 
 After these heavy formalities came the public acclaim. 
 Tens of thousands of people, many waving the national flag, were gathered in the castle courtyard, chanting &bquo;Truth will Prevail&equo; (which is the presidential slogan) and &bquo;Long Live the President&equo; as the protagonist stood with his wife, Olga, on the famous balcony. 
 &bquo;I promise,&equo; he told them, &bquo;that I shall not fail your trust and that I shall lead the country to free elections. 
 These elections must take place in a clean and decent way so that our revolution is not tarnished.&equo; 
 The new President's first state visits next week will be to East and West Germany to meet acting President Manfred Gerlach in East Berlin and President Richard von Weizsacker &mdash; and Chancellor Helmut Kohl &mdash; in Munich. 
 Mr Miroslav Stepan, the politburo member who has been accused of setting the riot police on the demonstrators, has been charged. 
 He could face up to 10 years in prison. 
 The reluctant president, page 19 
 &bquo;Semitic hieroglyphs&equo; found in Peruvian jungle city Orthodox archaeologists are sceptical about a claim that sounds like a Hollywood dream. 
 Martin Walker reports from Washington. 
 ONE of the great controversies of archaeology, the possibilty of transatlantic cultural links in ancient times, has been re-opened by an American expedition which claims to have found three large stone tablets inscribed with ancient Semitic hieroglyphs in a 9,000ft high lost city deep in the Peruvian jungle. 
 To the polite scepticism of orthodox American archaeologists, the expedition's leaders are interpreting some of the hieroglyphs as containing ancient Hebrew letters and symbols which refer to Ophir, or Beth-Horon, the gold source of ancient Palestine in the times of King Solomon. 
 This combination of lost Peruvian cities and King Solomon's Mines sounds like something dreamed up by Hollywood. 
 But the expedition's leader and the discoverer of the tablets, Mr Gene Savoy, is a respected figure in the world of archaeology who is credited with the location of 43 previously unknown Inca cities in Peru. 
 Mr Savoy was decorated by the Peruvian Government last month for his services to archaeology, which include finding the lost Inca city of Vilcabamba in 1964. 
 &bquo;We invite criticism and discussion by the archaeological professsion to see what this really means. 
 At this stage I cannot give an explanation for their presence in that Peruvian cave, beyond saying that we have found something that indicates contact with the Old World. 
 We need the glyphs properly interpreted,&equo; Mr Savoy told the Guardian yesterday. 
 Mr Savoy came across the stone tablets in a remote cave as his expedition of 40 men and 70 horses trudged back from discovering Gran Vilaya, his 43rd lost city in Peru this year. 
 Widely hailed as a major and historic find, this is the largest pre-Columbian metropolis in the Americas and possibly the lost capital of the pre-Inca Chachapoyas civilisation. 
 &bquo;In a cliff on the edge of the city, about 2,500ft up from the valley floor, we came on an old tomb, full of bones and ceramic pieces. 
 The bones are carbon-dated to about AD960. 
 And on the walls, cemented into place, are these three stone tablets, 5ft by 10ft, each a little different, and each in the same style &mdash; the first writing found in the ancient civilisations of the Andes,&equo; Mr Savoy said. 
 &bquo;We have found something that is going to revolutionise the archaeological interpretations of Peru's ancient civilisations. 
 This writing is unique to Peru. 
 &bquo;The elements are Sinaitic and proto-Sinaitic. 
 That would bring you into Egyptian, old Hebraic and Phoenician. 
 These people had their own form of writing that encompassed serifs and descending and connecting lines that are common to the Sinai. 
 How can we explain this?&equo; he went on. 
 Mr Savoy, who is based at the Andean Explorers and Ocean Sailing Club in Reno, Nevada, has long suspected that ancient man had far more trans-oceanic contacts than most orthodox historians accept. 
 He believes that King Solomon's sailors could have made the passage across the Atlantic, up the Amazon and its tributaries, to the Peruvian Andes, where the glyphs were found. 
 &bquo;The New World may not be the New World at all, it may be the Old World. 
 We are not sure where civilisation evolved. 
 &bquo;But I think that people were in contact all over the world, and that that there are hints of contact with Easter Island and with the Indus Valley,&equo; Mr Savoy continued, warming to his controversial theme in a way which unsettles his academic admirers. 
 &bquo;Savoy is not an archaeologist but an explorer. 
 He uses his explorations for business, videos, pictures and stories. 
 I think it is sophisticated, inspirational &mdash; but it is not archaeological research,&equo; comments the Peruvian expert, Dr Ramiro Matos, of Dumbaton Oaks. 
 Many passengers switch flight after bomb threat. 
 By Paul Webster in Paris 
 MANY passengers on a Northwest Airlines flight from Paris to Detroit, due to leave soon after noon today, cancelled their reservations yesterday after the American airline took the unprecedented step of revealing a bomb threat. 
 By late afternoon at least 50 passengers had called off their trips on Flight 51, while French airport police stepped up security that had already been tightened a week ago because of a feared terrorist attack. 
 Northwest's Paris sales manager, Mr Frederic Wuatelet, said a steady stream of passengers had accepted the offer of an alternative flight after the airline's head office in St Paul, Minnesota, revealed that a man with a Middle Eastern accent had telephoned the company and threatened Flight 51. 
 Normally, airlines and governments keep quiet about terrorist threats, a silence that has been criticised since the Lockerbie disaster a year ago, when secret service information on suspected sabotage was kept back. 
 A Northwest spokesman in St Paul, Mr Douglas Miller, said that the latest threat was unusual as a specific flight and day had been mentioned by the caller, who warned of reprisals for the jailing of two Palestinians for a series of bombings. 
 Abu Mohammed Talb, a suspect in the Lockerbie bombing, and Marten Imandi were given life sentences in Sweden. 
 Among the bombings was an attack on Northwest's Danish office in Copenhagen which killed one person and injured 20 others. 
 Mr Miller said security around all Northwest's flights had been increased but there was no intention of cancelling Flight 51, a DC-1O due to arrive at Roissy airport from Detroit at 6.40am today. 
 &bquo;We feel we have all the security measures and precautions in place,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If we did not feel 100 per cent positive about our ability to fly the plane safely, we would not put it in the air.&equo; 
 The American Federal Aviation Authority in Washington was alerted and it co-ordinated security with both Northwest and the French authorities. 
 The deputy chief of France's air and border police, Mr Pierre Quilici, said the warning had been passed on by the Americans several days ago. 
 &bquo;The plane will be guarded from its arrival in Paris,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We will reinforce the controls on passengers, hand baggage and hold baggage.&equo; 
 The measures will be even tighter than those instituted for all flights from French airports a week ago &mdash; which include the X-raying of all hold baggage, new controls on hand baggage, and body searches &mdash; that have added up to an hour to flight checks-ins. 
 Earlier in the month, security was stepped up at border crossings, department stores, railway stations and airports after reports that a terrorist commando was planning raids from a base in Spain. 
 Wave of strikes upsets Yugoslav authorities' austerity drive. 
 By Barney Petrovic in Belgrade 
 WORRIED Yugoslav Communist authorities yesterday attempted through the officially-controlled trade unions to halt the wave of mass strikes sweeping across the country. 
 With an eye on recent developments in neighbouring Romania, trade union leaders appealed to strikers not to stage demonstrations, apparently fearful of a spread of unrest. 
 Earlier this week police struggled with thousands of workers who attempted to enter the parliament to shouts of &bquo;give us bread&equo;. 
 Similar protests were held in other towns, where the party and regional authority's headquarters were besieged by angry demonstrators. 
 Miners, dockers, industrial workers, teachers and civil servants struck in at least 30 towns, demanding pay rises of between 100 and 200 per cent. 
 Many calculated their wages not in the national currency, the dinar, but in deutschemarks at the rate of between 400 and 600 marks a month, three times the present average. 
 At the car plant in Kragujevac, 3,000 workers raised a loaf of bread halfmast on the pole where the national flag is usually flown. 
 At the military industries factory at Trstenik, 13,000 workers demanded a doubling of their wages and sacked all the management. 
 The pay rises will jeopardise the new tough austerity programme of the Prime Minister, Mr Ante Markovic, which is due to come into effect on January 1. 
 It freezes salaries and wages while allowing most prices to rise. 
 Prices of industrial products doubled this week and rising prices of bread, milk and meat will worsen the already fast-declining living standards of the population, two thirds of whom live on the poverty line or below. 
 Inflation in December was 59.6 per cent, bringing the annual rate to over 2,500 per cent. 
 PAGE 
 Poland sweeps away 40 years. 
 By Wieslaw Horabik and agencies in Warsaw 
 THE Polish parliament yesterday approved a set of new rules placing the country firmly on the road towards a free market economy, cancelled the Communist Party's leading political role and dropped constitutional clauses defining the country as a socialist state. 
 In a series of constitutional amendments sweeping away the formal vestiges of Stalinism, the Sejm (lower house) also restored the pre-war name Republic of Poland and returned the traditional crown to the official Polish emblem, the white eagle. 
 Deputies stood and sang the national anthem after Communist and Solidarity members united to approve the changes by a vote of 374-1 with 11 abstentions. 
 The economic reforms came after an eight-day debate, the most heated in the short history of the half democratically-elected Sejm. 
 Deputies sanctioned 11 decrees which will thoroughly reshape Poland's economy. 
 The new economic deal, worked out by the Deputy Prime Minister, Mr Leszek Balcerowicz, aims to expand the private sector in trade and industry, reform banking and financial systems and introduce the internal convertibility of the Polish currency, the zloty. 
 The government plans to beat hyper-inflation by temporarily freezing wages and changing the structure of prices. 
 Subsidies will be halved and the balancing of the budget is supposed to be achieved by limiting central investments and cutting expenditure on the security forces and the army. 
 The harsh measures of the transitory period are expected to lower the standard of living for about 20 per cent of the population. 
 The government wants to set the new system to work from January 1. 
 Agreements with the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank, upon which Poland's credit depends, also envisage this starting date. 
 &bquo;After the autumn of shock caused by tremendous price rises, we are now facing a winter of discontent,&equo; said one deputy. 
 Despite the hardships the population has been warned of, the popularity of the Prime Minister, Mr Tadeusz Mazowiecki, stands as firm as ever, with recent polls showing that 95 per cent of the population support his political goals. 
 Mark Tran in Washington adds: Industrial nations have agreed to provide a &dollar;500million bridging loan for Poland as it embarks on its austerity programme, the US Treasury announced yesterday. 
 Of this, &dollar;200million will come from the US, as previously announced by President Bush, to tide Poland over until it receives &dollar;710million from the IMF as part of a long-term programme to restructure its economy. 
 If the Polish Government adheres to the IMF programme, further loans of up to &dollar;1.67 billion over the next 18 months will be available from the World Bank. 
 Vietnam holds firm against tide of reform with new press law. 
 By Nicholas Cumming-Bruce in Bangkok 
 VIETNAM'S National Assembly, despite the Socialist bloc move towards glasnost and multi-party government, has passed a press law that local journalists fear will bind newspapers more tightly to the dictates of the Communist Party. 
 Frightened by events in Eastern Europe, Vietnam's ageing leaders appear to be trying to shore up the authority of the party by cutting down the independence of an already tightly-regulated press. 
 The law was passed in the face of strong objections from southern deputies, echoing the view of one senior journalist earlier this month, that &bquo;the law created more difficulties for editors, their rights will be limited and that means journalism in general will be limited.&equo; 
 Official news reports of the Assembly debate failed to reveal details of the controversial content of the law, especially its much-criticised Article 5. 
 Party leaders inserted this clause after an August Central Committee meeting at which the General Secretary, Mr Nguyen Van Linh, exposed the leadership's anxiety at developments in China and Eastern Europe with a fierce denunciation of political pluralism and subversive imperialist powers. 
 The law provides for central government approval in the hiring and firing of editors and says journalists should reveal the source of their information on request to court authorities. 
 Article 5 of the draft made it an offence to &bquo;propagandise against the rule and policy of the party, the law of the state or against socialism.&equo; 
 Letters or articles advocating a switch to political pluralism &bquo;would be an act against socialism,&equo; according to Mr Tran Cong Man, Deputy Secretary General of the Journalists' Association. 
 It would also be an offence to cause suspicion or undermine the confidence of the people. 
 Catholic church and Brazilian police row over murdered priest. 
 By Jan Rocha in Sao Paulo 
 THE body of a 53-year-old French Catholic priest who was murdered in Brazil on Christmas Eve has been flown back to France, amid a row between the church and police over the investigation of his death. 
 The police say Father Gabriel Maire was the victim of a robbery attempt, but the Archbishop of Vitoria, the south-eastern Brazilian city where he worked in a slum parish, said he was killed because of his pastoral work. 
 Archbishop Silvestre Scandian said: &bquo;The state police should be taken off the case, because Father Gabriel made a statement to the Justice and Peace Commission mentioning a police officer as one of those who had made death threats against him.&equo; 
 The church and the French diplomatic authorities have asked the federal police to take over the investigations, but the state police have already arrested two men and accused them of the crime. 
 The priest was shot dead as he drove back to his parish after conducting a wedding ceremony, but nothing was stolen. 
 Father Maire was said to have received death threats because of his work in organising the poor. 
 Vitoria, capital of Espirito Santo state on Brazil's Atlantic coast, has recently become notorious as the home of a crime syndicate allegedly run by several state policemen, involving drug trafficking and stolen cars. 
 Emigres return home doubting. 
 By Nick Dallman in Bucharest 
 ATRICKLE of returning Romanian dissidents, wearing arm bands and rallying behind the National Salvation Front, have arrived in the capital. 
 Many of them are acting as interpreters and trying to put a semblance of order into the chaos as the world's press converges on ministries with fresh tenants and uncertain programmes. 
 But they do not like everything they see. 
 Bilici Constantin, a cheery film man in his early 40s, hurried back from France after an absence of 10 years and arrived just as Ceausescu fell. 
 He and a few of his colleagues were inspired by the early struggles of Solidarity in Poland a decade ago. 
 In Ceausescu's Romania there was no chance of pressing their claim too far. 
 They just wanted to redress some glaring injustices in their terms of employment. 
 One of their main demands was compulsory insurance for crewmen who received no compensation if they were injured during filming. 
 Even such an embryonic independent union met with fierce rejection and as one of Mr Constantin's fellow organisers, named Grlisefski was driving home one day his car was rammed by a military vehicle, killing him. 
 Mr Constantin believed it was no accident and escaped to France. 
 Now back in Bucharest he finds the people who stifled his union at birth are still holding important positions in the film industry under the umbrella of the National Salvation Front. 
 The front is certainly a broad church and those who have rallied to its support, the entire political spectrum. 
 Perhaps only because Green is the opposite of Red many people said Green when asked what party they would support in the forthcoming elections. 
 It is too early to test the political waters, nobody even knows for certain if the Communist Party has been dissolved or not. 
 Among the parties that are soon to come to life the Socialists, National Democrats and the Christian Democrats will figure strongly. 
 However, there appears little support at this stage for the former king's return from his Swiss exile. 
 For the moment there are more immediate concerns. 
 The returning emigres hope for a clean sweep but this has not happened anywhere in Eastern Europe where the price of reconciliation has always been a measure of compromise. 
 What worries many here is the claim that in the initial stages the surge for the Securitate men has not been pursued with real vigour. 
 One guest at the Hotel Bucharest, which saw fierce fighting in the initial stages and now stands deserted, has complained that nobody believed him when he pointed out the leader of the Securitate fighters. 
 The man managed to disappear in the cellar beneath the kitchen. 
 He was captured days later however, in another action. 
 Now the snipers keep up the pressure while the new Romania's foundations are being laid. 
 Many fear the longer the fighting goes on the less the chance of a tolerant democratic system emerging. 
 Romania's Interior Minister said yesterday there had been a counter-revolutionary plot by pro-Ceausescu forces but the situation was now stable despite sporadic shooting in the capital and other towns. 
 &bquo;The situation is under control by the population and the army.. 
 The situation is stable,&equo; Mr Mihai Chitac said on television. 
 &bquo;There are still isolated shootings in Bucharest.. 
 But these are isolated groups which do not make up a force.&equo; 
 &mdash; Reuter. 
 No reprieve for the boat people. 
 By Hella Pick Diplomatic Editor 
 MANDATORY repatriation of Hong Kong's Vietnamese boat people will resume during the first half of next month, despite the protest action in detention centres and international pressure on Britain and the Hong Kong Government to allow more time for voluntary repatriation. 
 Britain and Hong Kong have apparently decided against waiting for the Steering Committee of the UN Conference on Indo-Chinese refugees to meet on January 18 before reviewing the situation. 
 It is likely that a group of fewer than 100 boat people will be sent back just before the arrival in Hong Kong of the Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, planned for mid-January. 
 Fifty-one Vietnamese deported from Hong Kong earlier this month were the first of 3,600 deemed to be illegal economic migrants, after they had failed screening tests by the UN High Commission for Refugees. 
 A further 40,000 boat people still waiting to be screened will almost certainly be ruled illegal as well. 
 The Foreign Secretary, Mr Douglas Hurd, has adopted the same position as his predecessors, Sir Geoffrey Howe and Mr John Major, insisting that the deportations are an essential deterrent against a fresh influx of Vietnamese next year. 
 The US, the most vociferous of Britain's critics, refuses to take any of the boat people, because almost all come from north Vietnam, still considered enemy territory by the US. 
 Britain points out that the Bush Administration is still using its political weight in the IMF to block financial relief for Vietnam, even though it is widely recognised that the exodus from Vietnam will only stop when living standards improve. 
 Britain has apparently undertaken to review its own aid to Vietnam once it becomes clear that forced repatriation is working smoothly, and that Hanoi keeps to its side of the bargain, not to punish boat people who are deported from Hong Kong. 
 Because of this amnesty requirement, Hanoi is insisting that each separate name has to be cleared, to ensure that individuals are not wanted for ordinary offences. 
 This administrative process is very slow and limits the rate at which people can be sent back from Hong Kong. 
 Officials say that unless this can be speeded up, it will take up to three years before the detention centres can be emptied of their present populations. 
 Britain and Hong Kong claim they are eager for international agencies to monitor the resettlement of the illegal migrants, just as is already being done for those boat people who have returned voluntarily. 
 But the UN High Commission for Refugees and other qualified international bodies have all refused to become involved. 
 Christmas tree goes to mulch. 
 By Mark Tran in Washington 
 THE Christmas tree lying on the side of the pavement and shorn of its decorations is not only a forlorn sight but also symbolic of a gigantic disposal problem as America's landfills rapidly run out of space. 
 During the coming days Americans will be throwing away some 35 million Christmas trees, creating an urban disposal nightmare. 
 But an alternative now exists to the crowded landfill &mdash; tree cycling. 
 As a result of grass roots pressure, city halls and private groups are encouraging people to take their 1989 Christmas trees in for recycling into mulch, fuel or erosion barriers. 
 Many cities run the trees through chippers, paying for the operation by selling the mulch or using it in public parks. 
 Some, including Portland, Oregon, charge &dollar;1 or so to recycle a tree. 
 The guru behind the Christmas tree cycling movement is Mr John Giedraitis, the city forester in Austin, Texas. 
 &bquo;You get three clear benefits out of this,&equo; he explained. 
 &bquo;You save the cost of picking up old trees and moving them, and you save space in landfills, which is precious now. 
 Then you get all the mulch for free that your park departments would have to pay for. 
 And, finally you spread the idea of recycling.&equo; 
 The 35 million Christmas trees bought this year would have to rot for 30 years before decomposing in dumps that are already overflowing. 
 One way around this problem is tree-cyling. 
 A tree that goes in a chipper as a 7ft, 20lb pine comes out as a pile of fragrant mulch that can be carried away in a small box to be used in parks or gardens. 
 Some cities have found other uses for old Christmas trees. 
 Several communities in Texas use piles of trees as the base for dunes to fight beach erosion. 
 In Chicago, an annual chipping ceremony is held to the strains of &bquo;O Christmas Tree, O Christmas Tree.&equo; 
 Creditors' move may preface collapse of Bond empire. 
 By Lisa Buckingham 
 RECEIVERS were yesterday appointed to the brewing businesses of the Australian yachting tycoon, Mr Alan Bond, in what may prove to be the first step towards the world's largest corporate collapse. 
 The action, brought by Australia's third largest bank, comes at the end of a year during which Mr Bond &mdash; best known for brewing Castlemaine XXXX lager and his 1985 triumph in the America's Cup yacht challenge &mdash; has fought a desperate battle to keep his creditors at bay. 
 The news was relayed to British-born Mr Bond as his &pound;1.5 million vessel crossed the finishing line to win the three-day Hobart-to-Sydney yachting race. 
 Clearly upset, the 51-year-old entrepreneur said that his group would not give up the fight. 
 But a spokesman for Bond Corporation admitted that the receivership could trigger Mr Bond's mountain of debt, making financial collapse almost inevitable. 
 It is estimated that his corporate empire, whose interests also include Swan lager, a stake in British Satellite Broadcasting and one of Australia's largest television groups, has more than &pound;4 billion worth of debts. 
 Once one of the most successful corporate raiders in the world, Mr Bond's troubles began just over a year ago when he crossed swords with Mr Tiny Rowland, the head of Britain's Lonrho group. 
 A loss of confidence by his bankers coupled with some damning judgments on his corporation's business conduct culminated in the action by the National Australian Bank, which heads a syndicate of lenders owed A&dollar;880 million by the Bond organisation. 
 Bankruptcy for Bond Corporation, which employs 21,000 people worldwide, would represent the largest company failure in world business records. 
 Last-ditch bid, page 7 
 Schools bank on parents to maintain books stock. 
 By David Ward, Northern Education Correspondent 
 PRIMARY schools are increasingly relying on money from parents for a decent stock of books, according to government inspectors. 
 The finding follows a study by Her Majesty's Inspectorate of reading among children aged five to 14 made just before the introduction of the national curriculum last September. 
 Inspectors visited 17 schools and in some of the seven primaries found that parental contributions could double the capitation allowance given by a local education authority. 
 Schools in &bquo;advantaged&equo; catchment areas with affluent families did well; inner city schools generally fared badly. 
 &bquo;In some schools teachers brought their own books from home to augment classroom stocks.&equo; 
 Top-up funds from parents had little impact, however, in secondary schools where capitation levels ranged from &pound;1.30 to &pound;2.73 a pupil &mdash; money which usually had also to cover stationery and printing costs. 
 &bquo;These sums compared unconfortably with the current average book price of &pound;5.42 for textbooks, children's books and fiction.&equo; 
 Shortage of funds was often matched by literary poverty. 
 Book stocks in secondaries were &bquo;moderate&equo; in quality and the range limited &bquo;with a heavy emphasis on contemporary novels written for young people.&equo; 
 Few classes had access to an extensive range of poetry or play texts and little use was made of pre-20th century literature. 
 &bquo;Much of the poetry studied was contemporary or near-contemporary, although many classes had encountered at least one poem by a first world war poet.&equo; 
 The range in primary schools was similarly limited. 
 The inspectors conclude that reading policies in schools are not underpinned by clear, coherent, and comprehensive policies linked to practice in the classroom. 
 &bquo;The implementation of the national curriculum will require the drafting of much clearer objectives.&equo; 
 Large class sizes were also a problem. 
 The inspectors add that initial reading has been generally well taught and that primary teachers often read aloud to pupils &mdash; &bquo;frequently very well.&equo; 
 But fluent readers were sometimes under-challenged and support for poor readers not always adequate. 
 Progress needed to be more closely monitored. 
 New links with schools in the Soviet Union and eastern Europe will be forged as a result of an increase in the 1990/1991 government grant to the Central Bureau for Educational Visits and Exchanges to &pound;1.18 million from the current &pound;657,000. 
 The money will be used for international teacher schemes, cooperation on educational projects, and inter-school visits. 
 Last year the bureau set up 69 teacher exchanges in Europe and 129 in the US, and established 127 new school links with foreign countries. 
 Youths held after fracas. 
 Eight people were arrested yesterday after police with riot shields were attacked by about 30 teenagers as they moved a family to safety from a council house at Southmead, Bristol. 
 Firemen needed police support as they tackled a car in the driveway which had been set on fire. 
 They were later called away to deal with a house which was ablaze. 
 Animal rights attack. 
 The Animal Liberation Front yesterday claimed to have planted an incendiary device which was removed by police from the Duke Street, London, office of Sears plc &mdash; Selfridges' parent company. 
 Gasmen's warning. 
 British Gas North-Western workers are sticking the skull and crossbones symbol on appliances fitted by unqualified workmen in non-English speaking homes after three people in the area died in accidents caused by fumes last winter. 
 Woman prisoner dies. 
 An internal police inquiry was started yesterday after Ms Marie Priestman, aged 48, was found dead in a cell in Cleethorpes, Humberside. 
 Patient missing. 
 Police were yesterday searching for Mr Eric Cooke, aged 44, who walked out of Bradford Royal Infirmary, West Yorkshire, on December 23 in pyjamas and a black leather jacket after brain surgery. 
 Dog fetches grenade. 
 A dog caused the evacuation of six houses in Birkenhead, Merseyside, late on Thursday after bringing home an old unexploded grenade. 
 A bomb disposal team made the grenade safe. 
 Ulster bomb alert. 
 Several families were evacuated from their homes in Ulster last night after a bomb alert. 
 Police said a number of suspect devices were found inside a vehicle at a checkpoint in Coalisland, Co Tyrone, and a number of arrests were made. 
 Spa town taps the public's taste for spies Maev Kennedy on a cloak and dagger plot to boost tourism in downtown Cheltenham. 
 PETER ROLLINS sent off polite letters to GCHQ, MI5, and the CIA, saying he was very interested in spying. 
 He provoked only slightly more suspicion with phone calls in his broad Belfast accent, asking for any old intelligence information, codes, ciphers, bugs, they might happen to have lying around. 
 MI5 never replied, GCHQ expressed polite and emphatically arm's length interest, and the CIA offered help, exhibits and the information that the only other museum of spying they know of is in Havana. 
 They have not contributed artefacts, though they figure in many. 
 Cheltenham has tea shops, terraces, pump rooms, a nice floral clock, and the racecourse, all a bit lost on children. 
 The tourism people felt they needed a &bquo;family visitor attraction.&equo; 
 Mr Rollins, the assistant tourism director, asked everyone he met what they associated with Cheltenham: horses and educated ladies came second by a length to spies. 
 He then went to look at some property left to the council by a benefactor, an old grain warehouse. 
 Behind the stripey brick facade, on a run-down street behind the market, there was an interesting building, one room wide but 100 yards deep, deserted except for the odd work of art. 
 Mr Rollins loved it immediately, cobbled yard, rusty milling machinery and all. 
 It had served as a community arts centre which ended in a dreadful financial muddle, with an unsavoury reputation among the town's staider citizens, and a very popular bar which managed to lose money. 
 As he squeezed past the giant black lobster blocking the third floor corridor, inspiration struck Peter Rollins. 
 The Chandleresque tones on the promotional tape take up the tale: &bquo;&hellip; downtown Cheltenham, gee, what a place.&equo; 
 Turning up its coat collar in a hard-boiled way, the voice is briefed on its mission &mdash; &bquo;leather couches, portraits of the Queen&hellip; this must be MI6&equo; &mdash; passes a dingy border checkpoint getting its forged passport stamped, studies a spy plane view of Cheltenham, cracks a cipher or two, and spots a glamorous female spy from the window of the Orient Express to Istanbul. 
 And so on to the shop &mdash; &bquo;hey&hellip; they're selling stuff here!&equo; &mdash; and the cafe, the Casablanca Club, where a second voice murmurs, as it may well have done in arts centre days but certainly won't when the family visitor attraction becomes reality, &bquo;a cup of coffee?&hellip; pastry?&hellip; hashish?&equo; 
 The council isn't building the nuclear submarine or the underground cavern itself. 
 It has leased the building to Living Images, a Middlesex firm specialising in talking heads, which made the floating Lawrence Olivier head for the musical Time, and also the Crusades Experience at Winchester. 
 The basement of Living Image's boathouse studio on the Thames is full of magic. 
 A two-foot high figure of Isambard Kingdom Brunel talks and smiles in his glass case. 
 Sir Christopher Wren sits behind his desk, large as life and at least as natural, until a cloth is draped over the leather bound book concealing the projector, and his head is revealed as a white splodge which takes 80 hours of modelling. 
 Checkpoint Cheltenham is only one of a mound of proposals on marketing director Brian Larcher's desk, of which perhaps one in eight will get built. 
 There's the Coventry Blitz, which was to have been the Ramsgate Blitz until problems with planning permission. 
 There's a proposal for The Thames Story, with tourists on Tudor barges sailing down a river in a rebuilt railway station at the gates of Hampton Court Palace. 
 There's a proposal for the Bounty to land at a vast shopping centre planned at Thurrock. 
 And there's one which perhaps gives Mr Larcher the most quiet pleasure, for another shopping centre in Hull. 
 This will have Vikings, and a long boat, and visitors met by a floating Nordic goddess. 
 The pleasure comes from the fact that, as Mr Larcher pointed out sweetly, Hull is where the Vikings landed before going on to found Jorvik &lsqb;York&rsqb;. 
 Checkpoint Cheltenham is still a demilitarised zone, but if Mr Yves d'Ans wants his white masks from the first floor galleries back he should move quickly before the Iron Curtain descends. 
 The Orient Express is due to pull in in May. 
 Mr Rollins will be offering half price entry to GCHQ staff, the most cunningly cheap special offer in the history of marketing: staff at the Government's intelligence gathering centre are not permitted to identify themselves. 
 Mean streets&hellip; 
 Peter Rollins outside the warehouse earmarked for Checkpoint CheltenhamPHOTOGRAPH: DAVID SILLITOE 
 Riot police storm boat people camp. 
 By Stephen Vines in Hong Kong 
 FOUR hundred riot police firing tear-gas stormed into one of Hong Kong's detention centres holding Vietnamese boat people after meeting resistance to what was officially described as a routine weapons search. 
 Dozens of people were injured during the police operation, including three Vietnamese who were taken to hospital. 
 Twenty-seven people were arrested when the police finally got the camp back under control in the early evening. 
 The confrontation took place at the Chi Ma Wan island detention centre, which houses those believed to be next in line for deportation. 
 The first group was sent home in a widely criticised night operation two weeks ago. 
 Fears about the threat of more deportations in the near future are believed to be behind the resistance to the police action. 
 A police spokesman said that people in the camp were in a &bquo;very emotional&equo; state. 
 Chi Ma Wan inmates have been threatening violent resistance should moves be made to deport them. 
 At 8am police officers, accompanying prison staff, tried to enter the centre but were met by a hail of stones. 
 The officers withdrew and an attempt was made to resolve the problem with the mediation of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees and aid workers in the camp. 
 The mediation attempt failed and at 3.30pm 400 riot police forced their way into one half of the camp and seized more than 700 weapons such as iron bars and home-made knives. 
 An hour later they used the same tactics to gain entry to the other half of the camp. 
 Mr Geoffrey Barnes, Hong Kong's secretary for security, said the action had been taken only after &bquo;repeated efforts to obtain the co-operation of boat people and warnings that the search would have to be carried out regardless of their objections&equo;. 
 He said: &bquo;The boat people, in order to make the operation more difficult, pushed their women and children to the front.&equo; 
 Tear-gas was used &bquo;to reduce the possibility of serious injuries&equo;. 
 Reporters have not been allowed access to Chi Ma Wan or any of the other detention centres. 
 All information on the incident has come from government sources. 
 A further group of 111 Vietnamese has left the colony, bringing the number of those who have returned under the voluntary repatriation programme this year to 874. 
 This month, for the first time during the year, more boat people left than arrived in Hong Kong. 
 Reports circulating in Hong Kong suggest that Britain will authorise the next group deportation under the mandatory programme before the next meeting of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees' Indo-China committee on January 18. 
 Britain and Hong Kong want to show they are determined to press on with this way of dealing with those not considered genuine refugees. 
 Tension remains high in the other detention centres. 
 On Thursday night, Mr To Quan Dat, a 25-year-old Vietnamese, was killed in a dispute at the centre on the Sek Kong military airfield. 
 Many other inmates were injured during the fighting, which involved about 200 people. 
 The trouble apparently followed disagreements over food distribution. 
 No reprieve, page 6 
 Whitehall denies common curbs aimed at protesters Ministry threatens Greenham rights. 
 By David Fairhall Defence Correspondent 
 THE Ministry of Defence is threatening to abolish all commoners' centuries-old grazing rights on the Greenham Common nuclear cruise missile base, unless restrictions on the rights are agreed within the next few days. 
 The ministry says it will take this action under the 1854 Defence Act if the commoners &mdash; local residents &mdash; cannot agree to relinquish rights which affect military installations. 
 Three of the 64 Berkshire commoners are refusing to accept a deal under which they would be paid about &pound;750 each to forfeit rights over the built-up part of the US Air Force base and agree not to exercise them in other areas. 
 Their decision could also be crucial to the outcome of a long legal battle between the ministry and women peace protesters who have been at Greenham for eight years. 
 The women claim that the existence of commoners' rights invalidates the defence bylaws under which thousands have been fined or imprisoned for trespassing inside the base. 
 This view was upheld in a lower court, was rejected on appeal, and will shortly be tested in the House of Lords. 
 If the Lords rule in favour of the two women who have brought the test case, hundreds of other cases that are pending in Newbury magistrates' court will have to be dropped and thousands of earlier prosecutions might become subject to compensation claims. 
 The Ministry of Defence's legal department therefore has a powerful incentive to abolish commoners' rights at Greenham as quickly and comprehensively as possible. 
 But officials deny that this is their aim. 
 They say they are prepared to extinguish only those rights of common &mdash; attached to local property and covering things like grazing cattle and collecting firewood &mdash; which apply to land on which hangars, missile shelters, nuclear bomb stores and other military installations have already been built. 
 They would leave rights over the base's grassland in existence, provided they were not exercised. 
 If agreement cannot be reached on this compromise before next week's deadline, the ministry will use the Defence Act of 1854 to abolish all rights of common. 
 Under the act, they claim, they cannot extinguish just some of the rights. 
 The commoners' representative, Dr Roy Swayne, believes it would be advantageous to accept the compromise deal, with its cash offer, because if the ministry ever were to sell the airfield when the Americans had gone, the 64 households concerned would still have some say in what happened. 
 The alternative, if three of the commoners continued to hold out, would be for them all to claim compensation for lost rights from the Lands Tribunal. 
 The cause of recovering Greenham Common for the people has been taken up by the author of Watership Down, Mr Richard Adams, who knew the area before it was requisitioned during the second world war. 
 &bquo;I don't see why this splendid open space should not be restored just because it's 50 years since it was taken in a national emergency,&equo; he said. 
 Mr Tony Benn, the Labour MP for Chesterfield, is concerned with the effect abolishing rights of common would have on the Greenham women's protest. 
 He has put down a Commons motion condemning the Defence Secretary for &bquo;the arbitrary action which he is taking to extinguish the ancient rights of common &lsqb;&hellip;&rsqb; for political reasons to prevent the women's peace camp from continuing their peaceful demonstrations&equo;. 
 He said: &bquo;If you have any rights in Britain they abolish them. 
 Why shouldn't the women of Greenham be treated like the heroines fighting for freedom in Romania?&equo; 
 Jobless total may exclude &bquo;dossers&equo;. 
 By Keith Harper Labour Editor 
 DRUG addicts and &bquo;dossers&equo; are being considered by the Government among groups who should no longer be counted as unemployed. 
 A confidential review of long-term unemployment is being carried out as part of the Department of Employment's examination of the Government's &pound;1.3billion Employment Training programme. 
 The review's suggestion that drug addicts, &bquo;dossers&equo; and some people with mental health problems should not be counted as unemployed is partly based on the department's evidence that a &bquo;significant and relatively high proportion&equo; of mental patients have been returned to society as part of the Government's &bquo;care in the community&equo; policy. 
 Mr Simon Montgomery, administrator of the Brighton Unemployment Centre, which obtained a copy of the review, said yesterday: &bquo;We are establishing a new category of people who may have to be outside the welfare net &mdash; people with mental health problems who form part of the new underclass.&equo; 
 The Government forecasts that the number of people out of work for more than two years will fall from 550,000 in April 1989 to 325,000 by April 1991. 
 The &bquo;major constraints&equo; of the housing market means there is no viable case for encouraging people to move home to find work, the review says. 
 But the long-term unemployed could be given travel assistance, particularly as 40 per cent live in heavily populated areas. 
 The report suggests that free bus passes could also be offered to &bquo;certain disadvantaged groups&equo; in their first weeks of employment. 
 The review proposes a national insurance contribution &bquo;holiday&equo; to employers who recruit the long-term unemployed, although it admits that the Treasury would probably veto the plan. 
 A more simple option would be a cash subsidy to employers who hired the long-term unemployed. 
 Companies could receive up to &pound;4,000 if they offered a one-year job contract. 
 The review argues that Restart courses, under which the long-term unemployed are interviewed about their efforts to find a job, should be subject to benefit sanctions to widen take-up, &bquo;especially among those too demotivated to volunteer&equo;. 
 Maxwell editor offered buy-out. 
 By Ben Laurance * 
 MR Richard Stott, editor of the Daily Mirror, is to take charge of the People and will be given the opportunity to lead a management buy-out of the Sunday paper, its publisher, Mr Robert Maxwell said yesterday. 
 Mr Stott replaces Ms Wendy Henry, who was sacked last month after publishing photographs of Prince William urinating in a London park. 
 Mr Stott would restore the People &bquo;to its role as an entertaining, investigative, and informative newspaper,&equo; Mr Maxwell said yesterday. 
 It is hoped that within two years Mr Stott will lead a management buy-out of the People, making it independent of the other Mirror titles. 
 &bquo;I am giving him the chance to be his own publisher,&equo; said Mr Maxwell. 
 &bquo;I do not think any publisher has given any journalist that chance before in the United Kingdom.&equo; 
 After the planned buy-out, Mirror Group will keep a minority stake in the People. 
 When the printing operation of Mr Maxwell's quoted company Maxwell Communications was taken over by its management this year, 24 per cent was retained by the former parent. 
 The proportion of the People retained by Mirror Group is likely to be similar &mdash; and the paper will continue to be printed on Mirror presses. 
 The Mirror Group &mdash; controlled by Mr Maxwell's private companies &mdash; was to have been floated on the Stock Exchange next year. 
 But that has now been put back to 1991. 
 The company makes profits of about &pound;1 million a week. 
 Mr Maxwell said that the postponement was agreed in the last few weeks, following a decision to spend heavily next year on unspecified initiatives to increase Mirror Group's market share. 
 Mr Stott has been editor of the Daily Mirror since 1985. 
 He will be replaced by Mr Roy Greenslade, aged 42, associate editor of the Sunday Times. 
 Revellers urged to avoid square. 
 By Susan Tirbutt 
 HEALTH unions yesterday urged people to stay away from London's Trafalgar Square celebrations on New Year's Eve because of fears for their safety during the ambulance dispute. 
 Scotland Yard announced that people obviously drunk or carrying alcohol or aerosol sprays would be turned away and that this policy would also apply to Parliament Square. 
 Mr Chris Humphreys, of the National Union of Public Employees, said that Trafalgar Square, where often 60,000 congregate, could be a dangerous place. 
 &bquo;If the celebrations are not cancelled the public will be well advised to stay away,&equo; he said. 
 New Year's Eve is the busiest period of the year for emergency services, with up to 300 calls an hour. 
 The London Ambulance Service usually deploys 110 vehicles. 
 Because of the dispute only 54 army ambulances will be available to cover London, in addition to police and St John's Ambulance. 
 In Scotland 100,000 have applied for free tickets to a Hogmanay party in George Square, Glasgow, which will also celebrate the city's year as Cultural Capital of Europe. 
 But only 15,000 will be admitted. 
 Organisers of an Essex acid house party say they will go ahead, despite warnings from police that they will close it down. 
 Up to 10,000 are expected at the 12-hour party scheduled to begin at 8pm tomorrow on a private estate. 
 Promoters World Wide Productions said it was likely to be the last party of its kind before new legislation comes into effect. 
 The company has sent an invitation to Mr Graham Bright, the Tory MP for Luton South, whose bill seeks to ban all-night parties. 
 &bquo;We want him to see what the reality is, compared with the tabloid myth,&equo; said a party organiser. 
 British Rail will be running Sunday services on New Year Day. 
 Alliance formed to fight NHS plans. 
 By Paul Keel 
 PATIENTS, consultants, and family doctors yesterday formed a united front, called the NHS Support Federation, to fight proposed changes in the National Health Service. 
 Patients' groups, including Hospital Alert and the Birmingham Committee for the Rescue of the NHS, joined with the NHS Consultants' Association and the NHS Support Party, which intends to field GPs as parliamentary candidates in Tory marginals. 
 Professor Harry Kean, of Guy's Hospital, a co-ordinator of yesterday's meeting in London, was elected chairman of the federation. 
 He said the white paper on which the National Health Service and Community Care Bill is based had been devised without consultation with professional people or the public. 
 &bquo;I think there is a real prospect of getting major changes to this bill,&equo; he added. 
 The new alliance of pressure groups would aim to &bquo;secure democracy in the NHS, exclude commercialisation of health care from the service and achieve a real health service review in which the people who work in the NHS are consulted.&equo; 
 The NHS needed reform but not the government changes. 
 On the issue of hospitals taking more control over their affairs, Professor Kean said: &bquo;Hospitals to a very large extent can have that without turning the health service into a sort of supermarket.&equo; 
 He added: &bquo;I qualified in 1948 and came in with the health service. 
 I am not prepared to let it die.&equo; 
 Professor Kean, a specialist in diabetes, is also spearheading a move in the High Court on January 31. 
 He and five senior consultants will seek through judicial review a declaration that Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, used taxpayers' money unlawfully in implementing white paper directives. 
 Road-block salvo shatters Bucharest's fragile silence. 
 By Ed Vulliamy in Bucharest 
 IT IS the early hours of Friday morning. 
 I am walking back to my hotel after dinner with a Bucharest novelist and his family and being graciously escorted by him and his wife through the still evidently dangerous, silent streets. 
 The deadline for the surrender of the Securitate secret police was only a few hours ago. 
 On the Bulevard Republicii there are a number of road- blocks, formerly manned by militias and now by troops. 
 Our company is exchanging greetings with the young soldiers when suddenly a white car refuses to stop at the next checkpoint up the street &mdash; braking only slightly and seeking to swerve past the two soldiers. 
 In the darkness there is an almighty salvo of machine gun fire, like a cacophony of cracking whips. 
 Instinctively everyone falls flat in the dirty slush. 
 The car reels and swerves up on to the pavement, crashing into a shopfront and shattering itself and the window panes. 
 Silence. 
 Then two isolated shots. 
 Then another. 
 Then a speedy convergence of vehicles from nowhere, one of them a taxi converted into an ambulance. 
 Soldiers quickly reinforce the road-blocks to stop the emerging onlookers from reviewing the scene. 
 People are ushered into the supposed safety of an archway. 
 Men huddle round the car, removing what look like dark, limp sacks of potatoes from within it. 
 Everything is now relaxed. 
 People get back to their feet. 
 The novelist and his wife cross themselves and apologise incongruously for the &bquo;terrorists in our country&equo;. 
 Eventually the by now substantial crowds are ushered along the walls towards the square by the barely adolescent soldiers, some of whom ask for cigarettes as they do so. 
 Young lads gather round the car which looks as if it had been dead for days or weeks. 
 An armoured car obligingly shines its headlamps to facilitate a brief inspection by 20 people or so, soon cut short on the instructions of an officer. 
 The car has been raked with bullets leaving silvery steel pockmarks that shine through the paintwork. 
 Apart from that it could have been any accident on an urban road. 
 The soldiers announce: three Securitate agents shot dead and two badly injured. 
 Some say the men were armed, others not. 
 A debate even begins about whether the army is not getting a little trigger-happy in its nervous and no doubt terrified tension. 
 Reports earlier in the evening said over 2,000 Securitate are still at large across the country. 
 &bquo;If you do not stop at the road-block, you are dead,&equo; says a soldier with a grimace. 
 The crowd is told to go back home, and does so with some relief. 
 There is a much appreciated personal escort for the 100 yards to the hotel, for the price of a handful of Marlboro. 
 The novelist and his wife cross themselves again and turn back into the night. 
 Within an hour, Bucharest is buried under a blanket of virgin snow. 
 Food critic quits advisory post. 
 By James Erlichman, Consumer Affairs Correspondent 
 THE Government's most outspoken food safety critic, Professor Richard Lacey, has resigned from his only Whitehall post claiming it is being &bquo;neutered&equo; to protect the food and drug industry. 
 The Veterinary Products Committee, where he served for four years, gives advice on food and animal drug issues to the Minister of Agriculture. 
 It was Dr Lacey, professor of microbiology at Leeds University, who explained the transmission of salmonella in eggs and defended assertions by Mrs Edwina Currie, the sacked junior health minister, that the infection had spread throughout the British laying flock. 
 He was first to find frequent listeria contamination of cook-chill foods and demonstrated the failure of microwaves always to kill the bacteria which can be fatal to foetuses, newborns, and the elderly. 
 News of the professor's departure was a single sentence at the bottom of a footnote in a holiday-period ministry press release. 
 Professor Lacey said yesterday: &bquo;I have seen the membership of the committee refined over the years to suit the interests of the large food and pharmaceutical companies. 
 &bquo;There has also been a deliberate policy to exclude the committee from important decisions to license new veterinary drugs.&equo; 
 The ministry said: &bquo;We cannot support any of these allegations. 
 Professor Lacey left of his own accord and was thanked for his valuable contribution. 
 The committee continues to have ample microbiological expertise.&equo; 
 Much of its work will be transferred after 1992 to a European Commission panel. 
 The EC has already imposed a two-year ban on BST, the genetically-engineered milk yield booster which the Government supports. 
 Professor Lacey expressed his concerns about BST last October. 
 Haughey flaunts Europe mantle. 
 By David Hearst in Belfast. 
 AS the Irish Prime Minister, Mr Charles Haughey, prepares to take over the presidency of the European Economic Community on Monday, promoting his country is high on the agenda. 
 A &pound;500,000 budget has been set aside to create a press office to represent him in Brussels, in addition to Dublin's existing one. 
 Dublin Castle, the venue for the main event, the European Council of Ministers meeting on June 25 and 26, has been refurbished at a cost of &pound;22 million and equipped with a new conference centre. 
 Even the carpet in the state rooms &mdash; a fault in whose weave is said to depict a wounded leader of the 1916 uprising, James Connolly who was later executed &mdash; has been lifted. 
 No effort is being spared to ensure that the 1,400 journalists and hundreds of European officials who are expected to invade the capital for the June summit depart with a good impression of Irish hospitality. 
 Ireland, in its fourth EC presidency, is espousing the European ideal as a model for Irish unity. 
 The advent of the single market in 1992 has been used by Mr Haughey as a pretext for renewing his offer of direct talks with Northern Ireland Unionists. 
 He offered to talk to the three Ulster MEPs, one of whom was Mr Ian Paisley, the Democratic Unionists' leader. 
 The offer was rejected but behind it lay the assumption that a new relationship will have to develop between north and the south in a wider European context. 
 Since 1973, Ireland has received around &pound;9 billion in EC funds &mdash; five times more than it has contributed to the community. 
 The &pound;6 billion received in farm subsidies has put Ireland very much on the side of the French and West Germans when it comes to defending the Common Agricultural Policy. 
 Travelling less than hopefully puts blight on holidays abroad. 
 By Angella Johnson 
 TRAVELLING to holidays abroad is becoming more stressful, according to a survey by Gallup yesterday. 
 More than three in four of the 828 adults interviewed were upset by dirty toilets at departure points while 74 per cent complained about lack of information when travel delays occurred. 
 Having nowhere to sit while waiting also came high on the list. 
 More than three in five complained about noisy and drunk passengers and just over half were upset by having to travel with smokers. 
 &bquo;A lesson to airlines is that when delays occur, communicating is the best way to avoid passenger distress,&equo; said Mr Tony Farrell of North Sea Ferries UK, which commissioned the survey. 
 Sue Keane, a consumer psychologist, who designed the survey, said: &bquo;People have to work harder, often for longer hours, in the entrepreneurial 1980s and deserve a restful journey.&equo; 
 The top 10 complaints were: dirty and untidy toilets; insufficient information about delays; cramped conditions; nowhere to sit while waiting; long delays at departure points; uncomfortable seating on board; noisy or drunk fellow passengers; long queues at check-ins; overheated travelling environment; and rude staff at departure points. 
 Police to bridge ambulance gap. 
 By Michael Morris 
 POLICE were last night standing by to answer emergency calls as ambulance crews in Greater Manchester planned to ban the use of radios while on the road. 
 Greater Manchester Police said that if a local health authority asked the police for assistance the force would respond. 
 The chief ambulance officer, Mr Jim Barkley, said he had asked for police help on behalf of the 12 district health authorities because it was &bquo;a very serious escalation &mdash; the worst that has hit us&equo;. 
 He said that the police had a statutory obligation for public safety. 
 It would be up to control officers to decide at what stage to ask for police help, which would include the use of police vans, stretchers, and blankets. 
 A meeting of shop stewards from the National Union of Public Employees approved the intensification of action in the four-month-old dispute. 
 It voted to cease all transfers of patients between hospitals from midnight. 
 Mr David Owen, Nupe's area officer, said the decision not to use ambulance radios meant that crews would only answer emergency calls at stations. 
 The action, he said, was being stepped up as a result of Thursday's suspensions of ambulance staff in London, threatened disciplinary action against ambulance staff in the Midlands, and Bury health authority's use of private ambulances. 
 The shop stewards also decided that all accident and emergency cases would be taken to the nearest accident and emergency department. 
 North Manchester health authority was making emergency plans last night to use voluntary agencies to transfer patients between hospitals. 
 Twenty-eight ambulance control officers in the London area were suspended without pay yesterday for refusing to cover for colleagues taking industrial action. 
 They were suspended for not complying with an instruction to be transferred from their normal centres to handle emergency calls at the Waterloo control centre, said the London Ambulance Service. 
 A spokesman said staff at two divisional centres, New Malden and Bromley, agreed to the instruction but seven at Ilford and 21 at Kenton were suspended. 
 He went on: &bquo;They are normally engaged in planning non-emergency journeys but since there have not been any it was felt that they have just been sitting around socialising when others are working long hours. 
 This was considered unfair and they were stood down.&equo; 
 Five weeks ago, 35 control staff based at Waterloo were suspended for refusing to put calls through to Scotland Yard. 
 Sir John Hunt, the Tory MP for Ravensbourne, has written to Mr Kenneth Clarke, the Health Secretary, calling for a &bquo;positive proposal&equo; to break the impasse. 
 Brussels brings cold comfort to sheep farmers. 
 By Michael Morris 
 THE European Commission is a greater threat to the Lake District's native hill sheep, the Herdwick, than a cruel winter on the high fells ever could be, according to farmers in the area. 
 A new directive to reduce EC support to Herdwick farmers by 10 per cent could end centuries of resilience. 
 The farmers are already on narrow profit margins. 
 One of the biggest producers, Mr Tyson Hartley, whose flock winters on 3,000-ft fells in the Duddon Valley, said: &bquo;No other breed will survive there. 
 That is the problem.&equo; 
 Herdwicks start lambing a year after other breeds because they need to grow enough to stand the harsh climate. 
 Normally, ewes have to be pregnant, or have a lamb, to qualify for payments under the European Community sheep meat regime. 
 In 1986, the Government won a concession for Herdwicks to receive 70 per cent of the premium before lambing. 
 But it is now to be cut. 
 Making a living is hard at any time for Herdwick farmers. 
 But the move has come after a series of blows, including poor livestock sales and lower wool prices. 
 Mr Hartley fears cutting the concession could be the last straw for some 80 farmers who keep 75,000 Herdwicks in the Lake District. 
 He has about 3,000 sheep at Seathwaite, where shepherd's pie, rather than ploughman's, is served at the pub and Herdwick sheep postcards are sold, captioned, &bquo;there you go, posing again&equo;. 
 While his dog, Nell, rounded up 300 sheep, he said: &bquo;They go back up there, on Dow Crag and Coniston Old Man, for the winter because that is their home. 
 They are the only sheep that can stand it. 
 They are bred for the purpose.&equo; 
 There is enough grass on the high hills for the white-faced, hairy-legged sheep to last the winter. 
 Mr Hartley and his two sons, Christopher and Andrew, only feed them in very severe weather. 
 &bquo;Those people in warm offices in Brussels just don't understand what the climate is like here. 
 It can blow and snow for six weeks,&equo; he said. 
 Sometimes, the Hartleys have to rely on their 10 dogs to find sheep covered over by snow blown off sheltering walls and rocks. 
 &bquo;The 10 per cent reduction in subsidy on the shearling (two-year-old) and the ewe takes 10 per cent off our living. 
 It is a big slice in one go. 
 They think we should breed lambs off them and we don't do that because they are too young to stand the environment,&equo; Mr Hartley said. 
 The National Trust is supporting MEPs, MPs, and the National Farmers' Union in fighting the directive. 
 The trust owns about one third of the total Herdwick flock. 
 Mr Nigel Sale, a trust spokesman, is worried about over-grazing if farmers increased flocks to overcome EC cuts. 
 Mr Rodney Bacon, NFU policy adviser, sees the directive as a heavy blow for traditional Lake District sheep farming. 
 &bquo;There has been a whole series of events in the last year going against the hill sheep farmer, and this could be one of the final straws.&equo; 
 Herded into oblivion&hellip; 
 The Lake District's Herdwick sheep are threatened by the reduction of an EC subsidy concession allowing for late lambing in the cold climatePHOTOGRAPHS: DON McPHEE Tyson Hartley&hellip; 
 &bquo;People in warm offices in Brussels don't understand that it can blow and snow for six weeks here&equo; 
 Last hours of murdered lovers' lane couple could yield clue. 
 By Angella Johnson 
 POLICE were reconstructing yesterday the movements of the couple murdered in a &bquo;lovers&equo; lane&equo; in Epping Forest, Essex, in the hope of jogging the memory of someone who could help find the killer. 
 Mr Terry Gooderham, aged 39, an accountant, and his girlfriend Mrs Maxine Arnold, were shot in the back of the head while sitting in their F-registered dark grey Mercedes. 
 A small quantity of substances in the car was sent for analysis but Scotland Yard said there was &bquo;no evidence whatsoever&equo; of drugs dealing. 
 It has been claimed that Mr Gooderham may have had financial problems. 
 A close friend, who said he was too frightened to reveal his name, has told the drinks trade newspaper, the Morning Advertiser: &bquo;My life could be in danger if I say too much but I have my own idea what the murder is all about. 
 It is nothing to do with his love life or his own business but a lot of money is involved.&equo; 
 The reconstruction retraced the couple's movements from 7pm when they are thought to have set off from Mrs Arnold's flat in Shernhall Road, Walthamstow, east London. 
 Mrs Vi MacNamara, mother of Mrs Arnold, said the couple seemed to have left in a hurry. 
 When she arrived for a pre-arranged drink the lights were on. 
 Earlier, their telephone had been engaged. 
 Sport and culture lead New Year's Honours list. 
 By Michael White, Chief Political Correspondent 
 STARS from both sporting and artistic worlds &mdash; including golfer Tony Jacklin, actress Maggie Smith, and Frank Bruno, the heavyweight boxer &mdash; rub shoulders with 22 heroes of the Lockerbie disaster in the first New Year's Honours of the 1990s, published this morning. 
 A superior brand of knighthood, the KBE, goes to the former Liberal leader, Mr David Steel, while Sir John Fieldhouse, ex-chief of the Defence Staff and First Sea Lord during the Falklands War, becomes one of three new life peers. 
 The sole new Companion of Honour is Mr David Lange, the former Prime Minister of New Zealand. 
 Sport and culture pack a bigger punch than politics this time &mdash; as does industry &mdash; although Sebastian Coe's OBE represents a foot in both camps. 
 The runner is now a Tory candidate. 
 Bryan Robson, captain of Manchester United and England, gets a CBE alongside Finlay Calder, the captain of the British Lions' rugby team. 
 The sprinter Linford Christie joins Frank Bruno in the ranks of MBEs. 
 The novelist, V.S. Naipaul, becomes one of 30 new knights, and Maggie Smith emerges as the theatre's latest Dame. 
 There are CBEs for A.S. 
 Byatt, the writer, Professor Brian Cox of educational &bquo;black paper&equo; fame and Michael Gambon, the actor. 
 John Drummond, head of Radio 3, gets a CBE, as does the conductor, John Eliot Gardiner. 
 Anthony Thwaite, the poet, becomes an OBE. 
 Tony Jacklin gets his OBE upgraded to a CBE &bquo;for services to golf&equo;. 
 The knighthood for Colonel David Stirling, founder of the SAS, who helped to try and set up a strike-breaking organisation called GB75 in the 1970s, may prove controversial. 
 The most conspicuous group to emerge from the 947 names on the Prime Minister's list &mdash; about 30 more than usual &mdash; are key figures in the traumatic aftermath to the terrorist bombing of Pan-Am's Flight 103 over Lockerbie last December. 
 They include CBEs for Mr John Boyd and Mr Neil McIntosh, who headed the local police and regional council during the tragedy, a sprinkling of MBEs to voluntary workers like Dr Alastair Cameron, director of Dumfriesshire's Red Cross, and a British Empire Medal for Mr George Johnstone, the keeper at Lockerbie town hall where the dead were taken. 
 Today's peers include Miss Daphne Park, retired principal of Somerville College, Oxford &mdash; Mrs Thatcher's alma mater &mdash; and Sir Frank Tombs, chairman of Rolls-Royce and Turner &amp; Newall, a pillar of the industrial wing of the British Establishment. 
 Mr Michael Angus, chairman of Unilever, Mr Harold de Ville, chairman of Meyer International, Mr Derek Hornby of Rank Xerox UK (&bquo;for services to exports&equo;), Mr George Turnbull, chief executive of Inchcape plc, and Mr Frank Lampl of Bovis Construction, are among industry's new knights in the year of a record trade gap. 
 They are joined by Mr John Quinton, chairman of Barclays Bank, while a CBE goes to the monetarist pundit, Mr Gordon Pepper of Midland Montague. 
 In the academic world, new knights include Professor Eric Ash, rector of Imperial College, London, and Professor James Holt, the distinguished medieval historian and authority on the Magna Carta. 
 The three new Privy Counsellors are Sir Nicholas Lyell, the Solicitor-General, and two high-flyers of the class of &bquo;79 who are still stuck as ministers of state: Mr William Waldegrave of the Foreign Office and the Home Office's John Patten. 
 Only the Conservatives and the Liberal Democrats made nominations for political services and, apart from Sir David Steel, there are just three backbench knighthoods. 
 They are Mr Charles Irving (Cheltenham); Mr John Wheeler (Paddington) and Dr Alan Glyn, the 71-year-old MP for Windsor. 
 It is a tacit acknowledgement that neither office nor a peerage awaits them. 
 But Mr Christopher Prout, MEP, leader of the Tories&equo; Euro-group, which took the brunt of Mrs Thatcher's Gaullism in the European elections, becomes a knight. 
 Sir David Steel, as he is now, last night spoke for them all when he promised: &bquo;I don't think it's going to alter me or Judy greatly.&equo; 
 Full list, page 4 
 Tear gas used on boat people. 
 Riot police used tear gas at a Hong Kong detention centre for Vietnamese boat people after meeting resistance during a &bquo;routine weapons search&equo;. 
 Page 20. 
 Police &bquo;racism&equo; claim. 
 The Commission for Racial Equality is pressing the Police Complaints Authority to investigate allegations of racial discrimination by members of the now-disbanded West Midlands serious crimes squad. 
 Page 3. 
 Ambulance escalation. 
 Police were last night standing by to answer emergency calls as ambulance crews in Greater Manchester planned to ban the use of radios while on the road. 
 Page 3. 
 Greenham threat. 
 The Ministry of Defence is threatening to abolish commoners' centuries-old grazing rights on the Greenham Common cruise missile base. 
 Page 2. 
 Food critic resigns. 
 Outspoken food safety critic, Professor Richard Lacey, has resigned from his only Whitehall post. 
 Page 2. 
 Parents pay. 
 Schools are increasingly relying on money from parents to provide decent stocks of books, government inspectors report today. 
 Page 2. 
 People power. 
 Mr Richard Stott, editor of the Daily Mirror, is to take charge of the People and will be given the opportunity to lead a management buy-out of the Sunday paper. 
 Page 3 
 Romania sweeps away socialist system. 
 By Ed Vulliamy and Ian Traynor in Bucharest 
 THE provisonal government of Romania made itself very much less provisional yesterday by decreeing significant constitutional changes, including the fact that the country is no longer a socialist republic. 
 Copies of what amounts to a new constitution were seized eagerly by people on the streets. 
 The document proclaims the obliteration of the old Ceausescu order and of the entrenched position of the Communist Party. 
 It promises sweeping freedoms, a new economic order, a commitment to a united Europe and the separation of the executive and judiciary. 
 Romania is to stay a republic, suggesting the country's new rulers see little future for the former King Michael. 
 A military member of the National Salvation Front also disclosed yesterday that ex-President Ceaucescu was captured at a roadblock north of Bucharest while trying to flee. 
 He was handed over to local army units and then driven around in an armoured car for three days to prevent Securitate units discovering his whereabouts. 
 Mr Silviu Brucan, a leading member of the front, was reported as saying yesterday that the Communist Party was now finished and had played no part in the revolution &mdash; despite increasing complaints, particularly from students at the centre of the uprising, that most of those moving into power were party members. 
 &bquo;All communist parties are politically discredited for elevating criminals and psychopaths to highest office, such as Ceausescu, Pol Pot, Mao and Stalin,&equo; said Mr Brucan. 
 But despite its claims to instigate a pluralist society, the new constitution places substantial powers in the hands of the Council of National Salvation and is accompanied by the appointment of military personnel to key political positions. 
 Published simultaneously were lists of military promotions, creating a top-heavy army that enjoys the apparently unqualified goodwill of the political authorities. 
 Although for the moment the army is the darling of the people, its closeness to the now constitutionally-entrenched council will afford the military great authority. 
 Among yesterday's appointments were General Atanasie Stanculescu, a former deputy defence minister, as Minister of Economics, and General Mihai Ghitac as Interior Minister. 
 The Defence Minister, General Nicolae Militaru, issued a final appeal for the surrender of &bquo;terrorist forces&equo; still loyal to Ceausescu. 
 One of the country's vice-presidents, Mr Casimir Ionescu, said thousands of Securitate members waging a guerrilla campaign had given up, while hundreds remained at large. 
 Sporadic shooting continued yesterday in Bucharest and other cities.There were repeated television appeals that acts of revenge should cease. 
 The new constitution said the ruling council represented &bquo;the joining of all of us &mdash; the army and the patriotic forces for the democracy of our country&equo;. 
 The principles of the constitution are: 1. 
 The end of the one-party system. 
 2. 
 The promise of free elections in April 1990. 
 3. 
 The &bquo;restructuring of the economic system and the national economy having as its aim efficiency and free enterprise and the elimination of bureaucratic methods of planning&equo;. 
 4. 
 The restructuring of agriculture and the &bquo;supporting of the small holdings of the peasants and their produce and the end of the destruction of rural communities and villages&equo;. 
 5. 
 The complete restructuring of the ministry of education. 
 6. 
 To proceed towards a humanist and democratic ideology and government in the name of human values. 
 7. 
 The respect of &bquo;the rights and liberty of our national minorities&equo;. 
 8. 
 Full freedom of worship. 
 9. 
 The reorganisation of the &bquo;whole system of commerce, starting with the demand of the people and its satisfaction&equo;. 
 10. 
 &bquo;The reorganisation of ecological balances which will eliminate subsidies to any goods or process bad for the earth and the environment.&equo; 
 11. 
 Foreign policy based on &bquo;peace, good relations with our neighbours and integrating into the process of a whole united Europe&equo;. 
 Romania will recognise both the Warsaw Pact and the Helsinki Agreement. 
 The Bank of England is understood to have told the Romanian authorities they will have to apply to the British courts to have bank accounts belonging to the former dictator Nicolae Ceausescu frozen, writes Mark Milner. 
 Last week the new Romanian authorities asked the Bank of England and other major central banks to freeze assets said to belong to the Ceausescu family. 
 But the bank is believed to have replied that it did not have the power to do so. 
 Intellectual revolution, page 5 
 Police inquiry urged to look into racism. 
 By David Rose Crime Correspondent 
 THE Commission for Racial Equality is pressing the Police Complaints Authority to investigate allegations of systematic racial discrimination by members of the now-disbanded West Midlands serious crimes squad. 
 The authority is presently supervising an inquiry by West Yorkshire Police into the squad's activities. 
 It is understood there is prima facie evidence of racial bias in several cases which the inquiry, under Mr Donald Shaw, the assistant chief constable, and a team of more than 30 detectives, is looking into. 
 It is the biggest investigation in the history of the complaints authority, and into policing since the Operation Countryman inquiry into the Metropolitan Police in the 1970s. 
 Many of the 55 defendants arrested or convicted by the squad since 1986 who have made formal complaints to the inquiry team are black. 
 It is understood there may also be evidence of discrimination against Irish suspects. 
 At least four of the 55 members of the squad suspended pending the investigation, took part in the inquiry which led to the conviction of the Birmingham Six. 
 If allegations of discrimination against Irish suspects were sustained, the pressure on the Government to re-open the Birmingham Six case would be intensified. 
 The question of racial discri mination was first raised in correspondence between Mr Michael Day, the chairman of the commission, and Mr Francis Petre, his counterpart at the complaints authority. 
 The commission believes that the possibility of racial discrimination in the West Midlands' affair must be investigated as a matter of priority, and that the authority should, in any event, consider possible racial overtones in all cases. 
 But Mr Day's approaches have so far, according to sources within the authority, been stonewalled. 
 It is thought that members of the authority are divided on the issue. 
 A meeting between Mr Petre and Mr Day is likely early next month. 
 But if no progress is made towards full ethnic monitoring of the West Midlands case, the commission is understood to be prepared to raise the matter with Mr David Waddington, the Home Secretary, who is responsible for both the commission and the authority. 
 According to commission sources, investigating the possible racial aspects of the serious crime squad scandal would be in the interests of both the police force and the authority, which has been criticised since its formation under the 1984 Police and Criminal Evidence Act as being ineffective and slow to act, particularly in cases of alleged assault or ill-treatment of black suspects. 
 Sir Peter Imbert, the Metropolitan Police Commissioner, said in an interview in the Police Review this month that the complaints procedures had become almost unworkable, and failed to command public confidence &mdash; and particularly of ethnic minorities. 
 He found it hard to believe that the 3 per cent of allegations of racial discrimination sustained by the authority could reflect the true picture, and he supported an independent investigatory agency to handle all aspects of complaints against the police. 
 It is understood that the commission has also raised the issue of discrimination with Mr Geoffrey Dear, the West Midlands Chief Constable. 
 UN deplores invasion as &bquo;violation of international law&equo; US defied by Vatican on Noriega.. 
 By Martin Walker in Washington 
 THE discovery of two kidnapped and executed American civilians sharply increased the tension of the siege of the Papal mission in Panama yesterday, as the Vatican refused to hand over General Manuel Noriega to &bquo;the occupying power&equo; of the US. 
 The UN General Assembly last night adopted a resolution deploring the US military intervention in Panama as a flagrant violation of international law. 
 By 75 votes to 20, with 40 abstentions, the assembly endorsed a document similar to the one vetoed by the US, Britain and France in the Security Council on Saturday. 
 The Soviet Ambassador to the UN, Mr Alexander Belonogov called the intervention &bquo;international terror against a small and in essence defenceless state&equo;. 
 While not seeking to whitewash General Noriega, he asked: &bquo;Where is the guarantee that under some trumped up pretext&hellip; the US would not send &lsqb;forces elsewhere&rsqb; to justify their arguments are right?&equo; 
 The bodies of Richard Paul, aged 20, and his uncle Raymond Dragseth, aged 47, a professor of computer science at Panama Canal College, were found shot through the back of the head in a building near the Vatican Embassy in Panama yesterday. 
 Mr Dragseth had been taken from his home at gunpoint by pro-Noriega supporters on the day after the invasion. 
 General Noriega had been asked to leave the Papal mission but would not be forced to leave, Vatican spokesmen insisted. 
 The US countered that the discovery of the civilian bodies was &bquo;tragic new evidence&equo; that General Noriega was &bquo;a criminal fugitive from justice who does not deserve diplomatic sanctuary&equo;. 
 The US continued to soften its previously aggressive tone towards the Vatican. 
 The White House spokesman, Mr Marlin Fitzwater, said the talks with the Papal diplomats would &bquo;continue in a positive vein,&equo; and there was no deadline on the talks. 
 Clearly rattled at the prospect of a confrontation with the spiritual father of 52 million US voters, the White House said yesterday that the Church &bquo;is playing a very serious and constructive role&equo;. 
 The Vatican spokesman, Mr Joacquin Novarro-Vallas, in Rome yesterday denounced the US siege tactics, and said &bquo;an occupying power cannot interfere with the work of a diplomatic mission or demand that a person who is seeking asylum there be handed over to it&equo;. 
 &bquo;I think the Vatican is doing a fine job,&equo; Mr Fitzwater told reporters in Texas, where President Bush is taking a quail-hunting holiday. 
 But Mr Fitzwater refused to go into details on the various compromises being suggested to winkle Noriega from his refuge. 
 &bquo;We just don't think it is helpful to talk about a lot of these things while we are in this process,&equo; he said. 
 There has been intense speculation that a third country might take Noriega, with Cuba and India being mentioned. 
 But the US has said that the prospect of General Noriega at large with access to secret funds and free to organise revenge or counter-coups or de-stabilisation in Panama was simply unacceptable. 
 The alternatives would seem to be handing General Noriega to the US forces to face trial on drug-trafficking charges, which the Vatican has said it will not do, or giving him up to the new Panamanian Government, which has already declared it &bquo;has enough on him to put Noriega away for life&equo;. 
 In a heart-rending telephone call to a US television station, Mrs Dragseth said the US embassy was of no help, and it seemed incompetent even to register the fact of his abduction. 
 &bquo;I feel the efforts of the US embassy have been very inadequate,&equo; his daughter Caroline said by telephone from Panama yesterday. 
 The discovery of the two bodies yesterday has started a new check on the 30,000 US civilians in Panama. 
 US military sweeps through the countryside found no resistance, and rounded up hundreds more former members of the Panamanian Defence Forces, as life returned to normal in the capital. 
 But as the military confrontations evaporated, the diplomatic stand-off at the Papal mission escalated yesterday, with new Vatican protests at the searching of priests and the frisking of the Papal Nunciate. 
 The decibel-diplomacy outside the Papal embassy continued yesterday with more top-volume rock music in spite of Vatican protests. 
 The most-played tunes so far are Beat It by Michael Jackson, You're No Good by Linda Ronstadt, and I Fought the Law and the Law Won by the Bobby Fuller Four. 
 The US army spokesman in Panama insisted that the rock music assault was simply &bquo;a way of introducing ambient sound to ensure the security of military communications&equo;. 
 Meanwhile, the White House announced that the Deputy Secretary of State, Mr Lawrence Eagleburger, would lead an economic reconstruction team to Panama next week. 
 Ex-Mossad man seized, page 6 
 Trade deficit at eight-month low. 
 By Mark Milner 
 BRITAIN remains on course for its biggest annual balance of payments deficit despite a better-than-expected trading performance last month. 
 Figures released by the Central Statistical Office yesterday showed that the current account was &pound;1.4billion in the red in November, some &pound;300million less than the revised deficit for October and the lowest since March. 
 It takes the shortfall for the year to date to &pound;19.3billion and the annual total will easily top the &pound;20billion forecast by the Chancellor, Mr John Major, in his autumn expenditure statement. 
 But there was some comfort in the figures for the Government and for an already hard-pressed pound, which could have faced another battering if the deficit had been worse than the expected &pound;1.5billion. 
 Yesterday's figures showed the value of imports falling by 2.5 per cent to &pound;9.6billion in November while exports rose by 0.5 per cent to &pound;8.1billion, giving the lowest visible trade deficit since September last year. 
 Invisible earnings for the month are projected to have been &pound;100million, while their contribution in October has been revised down from &pound;300million to the same level. 
 Overall the statistics provided some evidence to support the view of Mr Major and his predecessor, Mr Nigel Lawson, that high interest rates would slow the economy, helping to choke off the boom in imports and putting pressure on industry to boost exports. 
 The volume of exports in the four months to November was up 4 per cent on the previous four months, while imports rose 1 per cent. 
 The Central Statistical Office said the figures showed &bquo;the underlying level of non-oil import volume may now be flat whilst non-oil export growth still seems to be rising strongly&equo;. 
 Yesterday's trade figures were well received in the City. 
 The stock market climbed 23.9 points to 2,422.7, within a fraction of its highest level this year. 
 On the foreign exchanges the pound managed a modest recovery from Thursday's slump when it hit an all-time low against the German mark. 
 Sterling's effective index ended up 0.5 at 86 per cent of its 1985 value. 
 However, City economists expect Britain's trade deficit to improve, but with few expecting next year's trade gap to be better than the &pound;15 billion figure forecast by Mr Major in his autumn statement. 
 &bquo;The figures should help sterling in the short term, but given the size of the deficit, the pound remains vulnerable,&equo; said one economist. 
 Mr Gordon Brown, the shadow Trade and Industry Secretary, said the figures meant &bquo;Britain enters the 1990s with the highest interest rates, the worst inflation and the biggest trade gap of all our European competitors&equo;. 
 Trade gap narrows, page 9 
 DPP appeals in Wapping police case. 
 By Owen Bowcott 
 THE Director of Public Prosecutions is to appeal against the High Court's decision to halt criminal proceedings against seven police officers charged following clashes outside Mr Rupert Murdoch's News International plant at Wapping in 1987. 
 Just before Christmas the DPP, Mr Allan Green, QC, failed in his attempt to have the cases against the seven officers reinstated. 
 They had been quashed by Bow Street magistrates court earlier this year on the grounds of delay. 
 The DPP must now seek leave from the Divisional Court to take the appeal to the House of Lords. 
 Six officers were originally charged with conspiracy to pervert the course of justice and the seventh with unlawful wounding. 
 The clashes in January 1987 followed the sacking of print workers by Mr Murdoch's newspaper group when it moved to its new print plant at Wapping, east London. 
 What kind of holiday can you get in 1990 for &pound;1,000 &mdash; the average amount spent by any one family? 
 The market place can be confusing but Trader Horn picks his way through the mire Going for the grand tour. 
 Discounting a discount war 
 First steps in the making of a Good Agency Guide 
 Agencies. 
 A GRAND is the average amount that a British family pays out when booking its annual holiday package. 
 This at least is the figure assumed by the market leaders, Thomson Holidays, and the other majors do not differ greatly. 
 There is a statistical rider which puts even greater emphasis on that sum: it does not matter whether the family unit is made up of two, three or four people &mdash; the &pound;1,000 booking is near enough a constant &mdash; though what people spend when they get there is harder to establish. 
 In a confused and confusing holiday price structure, it may be useful to translate these figures into pictures, do a Jack Horner on the holiday pie and pluck out some typical plums, pinpoint what the 1990 market offers for &pound;250 per head. 
 Vigorous thumb work produces these nearly perfect (arithmetically speaking) examples: A fortnight with B&amp;B accommodation in Alanya in Turkey is offered by Intasun (0274 736403) at &pound;251pp, though they can also do Alanya self catering at &pound;199. 
 A week in a one-star hotel in Madrid can be set up by Time Off (01-235 8070) for &pound;227pp, with an optional day tour to Toledo for &pound;26 or to Avila and Segovia for &pound;33. 
 For four people sharing, Global Villas (01-466 4625) have a 2-bedroom villa with pool a kilometre from the beach at Carvoeira in Portugal, at &pound;252pp for a week. 
 (The price includes flights). 
 Grecian (01-444 3333) offer B&amp;B in a &bquo;traditional style A-class&equo; hotel in Thassos Town from &pound;249pp for 14 nights. 
 In the south of France, Euroexpress (01-748 2607) can arrange six nights in a 2-star hotel in Juan Les Pins for &pound;251pp &mdash; extra nights &pound;24. 
 Italian Escapades (01-748 2661), with Pilgrim Air have a design-your-own-holiday programme which for &pound;204 charter flight (or &pound;264 scheduled service) allows you 5 nights in Rome at a 4-star hotel near the Trevi and Spanish Steps. 
 Among the cheaper European destinations is Bulgaria, where Balkan Holidays (01-493 8612) offer a 7-night fly/drive with set itinerary and B&amp;B at hotels from &pound;239, the route to include Golden Sands, the Borgas area, Plovdiv, Sofia and Veliko Turnovo in the Yantra Gorge. 
 A new destination in the Greek islands for Manos (01-630 1161) is Samos, where 14 nights in a self-catering apartment with flights sells at &pound;912 for four people. 
 Thomson themselves (01 435 8431) offer 14 nights half-board at a 4-T hotel (Thomson's own classification) in Palma Nova in Mallorca for two adults and two children at &pound;842, or a self-catering deal in Santa Ponsa at a similar class apartment for &pound;508. 
 To embroider the sampler, we turned to some multiple agencies and asked them for their recommendations of good value on a &pound;1,000 booking for four people. 
 Their choices follow: Lunn Poly's marketing director Peter Rothwell observed that as a rule the staff in their 505 shops base their selling on the answers given by the customer in a questionnaire, to prevent mismatches between customers and the holidays they took, but he nevertheless felt safe in saying that two young couples, a bit adventurous, would do well if they invested in an ILG Drive Europe holiday along the west coast of France to Biarritz, good countryside and a nice old town, accommodation at the Mer et Golf apartments, two weeks in all with ferry and accommodation included for &pound;255 each. 
 Pickfords marketing man Andrew Jones drew attention to the company's discounting policy, operating until the end of February, and put forward three options. 
 Two adults and two children staying 10 nights at the Hotel Cavanna in La Manga in Spain in June would work out, with the discount, at &pound;907. 
 A Crystal premier villa-with-pool and ferry 14-night package to the south of France, insurance in and discount applied would add up to &pound;1032. 
 Or, for half the time but twice the luxury, they could go in June with Airtours for seven nights to the Hotel Magaluf near Palma in Mallorca, via Stansted, for &pound;976. 
 Spain evidently filled the screen for Hogg Robinson's Holborn manager Phil Feak. 
 He'd have liked to plump for the Algarve but, he said wistfully, you do go over the &pound;1,000. 
 So he would go instead for Mallorca in June, 14 nights half board for &pound;239 in Alcudia, or the Hotel America in Calas de Mallorca. 
 Sales talk. 
 IN THE AFTERMATH of Christmas such multiple agencies as Thomas Cook, Pickfords and Lunn Poly have been holding sales, knocking off &pound;50, &pound;70 and &pound;100 off many holidays. 
 Everyone knows that 1990 will be a tough year, with bookings something like 40 per cent down, the public playing a lament in J. Major, the tour operators bent on improving profit margins instead of competing by price for market share, with heavily reduced capacity particularly at the cheaper end of the range. 
 As an earnest of their firm intentions they have been consolidating flights in December, which is unprecedented. 
 With this in view the consensus among the agencies is that there will be some discounting, because nobody can ever get it exactly right, but nothing like what has been available in recent years. 
 If the attempt to entice custom from people who only take a foreign holiday when it is ultra-cheap has been abandoned, they will be glad. 
 But if the operators are set against discounting it will not prevent the agencies from doing some on their own account. 
 In fact this shift has been visible for some time and seems at present to be increasing. 
 This is only one of several tactics which has the incidental effect of squeezing the &bquo;Mum and Dad&equo; agencies. 
 The start-up costs of a travel agency have been relatively small. 
 While business was buoyant there was a living in it for many small shops that are liable to succumb in a climate where 40 per cent of the country are wanting independent deals, and the remainder are demanding much improved advice and service. 
 Thomas Cook, investing &pound;18m to redesign their 300 retail outlets in four-section specialist subdivisions, predict that the 6,500 Abta-bonded agencies will decrease by 1,000 in 1990. 
 Nobody can know the world, not even the parts of it on offer to tourists, but they can know how to look them up, and the training for too long has been exiguous. 
 There is no use in telling a customer wanting to go to San Marino (as I have been in three central London agencies) that it doesn't exist, that he really means San Remo. 
 But this is what happens when agencies are staffed by school leavers on pathetic salaries like &pound;5,000 a year. 
 But the scene is changing. 
 It is not necessary to go to the lengths of the British Airways new Four Corners shops, where the travel element can hardly be distinguished through an Ali Baba's cave of irrelevant merchandise, but only to set up efficient systems run by people who know what they're talking about and who can make time to understand what their travellers want, like Trailfinders with their honest bucket-shop approach, or the STA chain with its expertise in student travel. 
 David Radcliffe, marketing director for Hogg Robinson's 206 shops, for which they produced this week the latest edition of a four-volume in-house resort hotel guide to 1750 establishments, points out that his chain is already &bquo;segmented on tailor-made, seat-only and bed-only markets&equo;. 
 He felt that Cook's were right in the direction they were taking and correct in their prediction of 1,000 failures among agencies. 
 The image of counter staff did need some polishing, in fact they had just put all their 1,300 people through a course teaching them &bquo;how not to behave like Sharons and Traceys.&equo; 
 IT WAS difficult for small independents to offer services like their Holiday Care system, which offered immediate help to holidaymakers, whatever the problem, like lost baggage or loans to cope with legal problems over cars in Spain, for which customers were given access to a phone numnber until 15 days after coming home. 
 Bruce Shepherd, marketing director of the Scottish-based A.T.Mays chain (nearly 300 shops, 60 per cent in England) thinks I am too severe in my view of agency service. 
 Ninety per cent of their demand is for &bquo;pretty ordinary&equo; packages, and his staff know how to pick their way through the brochures. 
 But the A.T. 
 in A.T.Mays stands for &bquo;All Travel&equo; 
 It was true that the chains' capacity for negotiating good deals made it hard for the family-run business to keep going, and they had many letters offering businesses for sale, and the price of shops was coming down all the time. 
 On the other hand specialists could thrive. 
 Although it would be a tough year for sure, revenue was not dropping anything like as much as the bookings percentage. 
 There were marvellous areas of growth, like Caribbean cruising with the fantastic prices and quality incidental to the impact of all the extra tonnage, and the ferries were doing so well that it would be a good idea to discourage people from turning up in hordes at Dover unticketed. 
 Agency guide. 
 AS A PIONEERING venture towards the making of a Good Agency Guide, we've assembled a dossier across the country with whom we would not hesitate to deal. 
 It is not meant to be an exclusive list, and nothing would please us more than to hear from readers about others &mdash; or their shortcomings, if the case deserved it. 
 ABERDEEN Bell Travel, 127, Rosemount Place, AB2 4YH; tel 0224 633038. 
 The ability to seek out travel services for the customer even when they do not appear on brochure racks has brought the company a strong following in the town but also, according to manager Sandra Chisholm, from as far as Glasgow. 
 &bquo;Knowing the local community is important. 
 If a customer wants to spend time deciding on a holiday we are prepared to spend that time. 
 However, we can work fast when people are in a rush.&equo; 
 BELFAST Menary Travel, 30 Howard Street, BT1 6PF; tel 0232 320881. 
 The agency has been in business for 20 years. 
 Proprietor Geoffrey Menary says that more than three quarters of its clientele are repeat customers. 
 BIRMINGHAM Courier Travel, 131 High Street, Harbourne B17 9NP; tel 021 4275181. 
 This company specialises in upmarket holidays. 
 &bquo;People spend a lot of their hard-earned money on holidays,&equo; observes sales director Ray Wilkins, &bquo;and they need professional service and advice. 
 As a small independent we try to appreciate the client's requirements.&equo; 
 BOLTON W.H.Smith Travel, 14 Newport Street BL1 1NB; tel 0204 392226. 
 &bquo;Buying travel is a bit like going to the hairdresser,&equo; says manager Christine Power. 
 &bquo;People have their favourite person. 
 Travel is a very personal matter and our staff build up their own clientele.&equo; 
 The agency is part of a nationwide chain, but &bquo;We do not have counters. 
 We find customers prefer to sit down at individual desks and discuss their requirements.&equo; 
 BRISTOL Bakers Dolphin, 16 Clifton Down Road, BS8 4AD, tel 0272 7433221. 
 The company specialises in long haul holidays with off-the-beaten-track itineraries. 
 Most of our local people do not want to be tied into packages,&equo; says assistant manager Tracey Johnson. 
 &bquo;We try to offer extra services, such as providing free transport to the airport.&equo; 
 Customers are also invited to travel evenings where films, lectures or perhaps foreign cookery lessons are staged. 
 &bquo;Our staff are experienced travellers &mdash; we all regularly go on long haul trips.&equo; 
 CARDIFF Gwalia Travel, 98 Cowbridge Road East, Canton Cardiff CF5 1DX; tel 0222 238888. 
 A family-run company that puts a strong emphasis on product knowledge. 
 Managing director Vincent Rey says, &bquo;I have been in the tour operating business since 1965, so my knowledge of both sides of the business is greater than that of many people running retail outlets.&equo; 
 DUNDEE A.T.Mays, 22 Chrichton Street, DD1 3AR; tel 0382 26222. 
 In the view of general manager Alan Sinclair, most agents in Britain lean too heavily towards the mass marketing of packages rather than providing a proper travel service. 
 &bquo;We try to provide a full range. 
 Customers can buy insurance, foreign exchange, a coach or rail ticket along with package holidays, hotel or flight bookings.&equo; 
 EDINBURGH Sibbalds Travel, 10 Queensferry Street, EH2 4QX; tel 031 2251402. 
 Founded 1947 by the late Robert Sibbald. 
 The company is firmly opposed to discounting on the grounds that it undermines standards. 
 &bquo;We have shied away from the rigours of the discount war,&equo; says director Dennis Hart. 
 &bquo;As a rule of thumb, we have not found it necessary. 
 There are people prepared to pay for quality.&equo; 
 The company preferred to invest in well trained staff rather than cut overheads to the bone, and many have been 20 years in the trade. 
 &bquo;There is good competition, but also too many cowboys,&equo; he says. 
 LEEDS Keith Prowse Travel, 22 New Market Street, LS1 6DG; tel 0532 431102. 
 Branch manager Kevin Rainey says, &bquo;I used to work in a multiple agency where we averaged one booking every 22 minutes. 
 Here we do not push customers out of the door as soon as we have made a sale.&equo; 
 The company believed trading volume sales got customer loyalty and was good for business. 
 Profits were boosted by selling traditional short breaks to local businesses as sales incentives. 
 LIVERPOOL Wise Travel, 66 Allerton Road, L18 1NA; tel 051 7331476. 
 The agency's own Concorde charters swooping over the Grand National, and personal gifts such as bouquets of flowers for customers have earned it an enthusiastic local following. 
 Clients tend to book long haul holidays and cruises rather than two weeks in the Spanish sun. 
 LONDON (north) Chapter Travel, 102 St Johns Wood Terrace, NW8 6LP; tel 01 5869451. 
 One of the first companies to realise travellers need more than a ticket. 
 It runs a travel book and map shop within its premises. 
 Staff are hired more on the basis of travel experience than button pushing. 
 Founder Edward Marquis despises &bquo;tacky stickers and cheap office rubbish&equo; but goes for plants and table lamps and interesting displays. 
 They handle mostly independent travel, selling farmhouse holidays and the like. 
 LONDON (south) The Travel Business, 94 Dulwich Village, SE21 7AQ; tel 01 693 5224. 
 &bquo;Our customers expect a high level of knowledge. 
 They do not necessarily have a lot of money but they do expect good value and a broad service. 
 It would be no good us offering just tour operator packages. 
 We have our own tour products, such a villa holidays but most people want to be independent.&equo; 
 They also sell guides and maps. 
 LONDON (east) Greenwood Travel, 94a Chingford Mount Road, Chingford E4 9AA; tel 01 5272648. 
 Independent agencies are in a better position to offer personal service than are those tied to big chains, believes managing director Daphne Armstrong. 
 &bquo;Many of our enquiries come through word-of-mouth recommendations.&equo; 
 LONDON (west) Weider Travel, Charing Cross Station Concourse, The Strand, WC2N 4HZ; tel 01 836 6363. 
 The only retail travel agency in Britain specialising in passenger journeys on board cargo ships. 
 The firm represents a large number of cargo shipping lines. 
 But, says ocean voyages manager John Alton, it also sells an extensive range of mainstream travel services. 
 MAIDSTONE Kent Exchange Travel, 4 Gabriels Hill, ME15 6JG, tel 0622 691400. 
 Providing conscientious service sometimes means persuading a customer the holiday of their choice is unsuitable, remarks branch manager Barbara Muir. 
 &bquo;It is vital you offer correct information to ensure this year's customer returns the next. 
 We sell a great many long haul holidays, often breaking apart the packages then putting them together again at lower cost.&equo; 
 NEWCASTLE Callers Pegasus Travel Service, 11 Saville Row, NE1 8TA; tel 091 2610381. 
 &bquo;It doesn't matter whether the customer wants to buy a bus ticket or round the world cruise,&equo; says managing director William Shaw, &bquo;we offer a complete service to all and don't just concentrate on packages.&equo; 
 The company was originally part of a furnishing business and applied general retailing techniques when it entered the travel trade in 1963. 
 If a complaint arises, it declines to pass the buck to tour operators, hotels or airlines. 
 &bquo;We take the matter up on the client's behalf.&equo; 
 NOTTINGHAM Neilson Travel, 11 Ashfield Precinct, Kirkby-in-Ashfield, NG17 7BQ; tel 0603 755441. 
 One of the few agencies in the survey to use discount schemes that include the acceptance of low deposits and the offer of free travel insurance. 
 It reports a noticeable growth in the sale of long haul holidays, especially to the USA, and in demand for unpackaged travel. 
 SOUTHEND Lipscombe Travel, 22 Queens Road, SS1 1LX; tel 0702 351111. 
 The agency's move into local tour operating has brought in new bookings at a time when agents generally are feeling the pinch of high mortage rates. 
 Ot has introduced short breaks to Paris using scheduled flights from nearby Southend Airport. 
 The company notices strong growth in the sale of short breaks, at the expense of longer package holidays. 
 Briefcase. 
 Dan-Air has an easy direct flight Gatwick-Lourdes, 20 minutes by car from Pau. 
 It leaves every Saturday at 14.15, eta 16.55, returning Saturday 17.50, eta Gatwick 18.30. 
 Scheduled Apex return fare &pound;127, 14 days advance booking, maximum stay three months, full economy fare &pound;163. 
 Danair reservations, tel: 0345-100200, or write Dan-Air Services, Newman House, 45 Vcitoria Rd, Horley RH6 7QG. 
 An alternative is the consolidated rate of &pound;110, no changes nor refunds once booked, valid for one month, obtainable from Davies Newman, Norway House, 21-24 Cockspur St, London SW1; tel: 01-839 1192. 
 A more leisurely route is by Brittany Ferries (tel: 0705 827701) to Santander &mdash; foot passenger return &pound;58, April/June &pound;62, then &pound;66 &mdash; and a drive through the mountains. 
 When DIY comes under the psychologist's scrutiny The good, bad and the mucky Do It Yourself. 
 By Gareth Parry AS THIS column is just over a year old, I thought I'd give you all a bit of a break, and write about the psychology of DIY. 
 It's a previously unexplored area, but W.H.Smith/Do It All commissioned a media psychologist, Jane Firbank, to investigate what it is that motivates a phenomenally, perhaps weirdly, growing pastime. 
 The study, using data supplied by a nationwide survey of 1,000 people, shows that more and more people are tackling increasingly advanced jobs as the area becomes demystified. 
 It identified women, the supposedly better-off Southerners, and AB social groupings as becoming the most enthusiastic practitioners, and that regionally the keenest DIYers come from the South-west and the least keen from Lancashire. 
 It found that women often felt fairly unsure of their ability in DIY matters, but once they had breached the confidence barrier many regularly tackled demanding jobs and felt that their results were as good or better than those achieved by the professional. 
 More and more women are tackling advanced jobs like rewiring and installing heating. 
 The report says that part of the reason for this, apparently, is the instruction sheets provided in Do It All and other stores. 
 I'm sure that's true, but many of the letters I receive indicate that women are doing things because they, generally, have to live with leaking taps, bubbling pipes, cold radiators and all the other annoyances. 
 One of the great attractions of DIY for many householders is that it avoids the notoriously difficult relationship between householder and the professional builder or decorator. 
 All this makes doing it yourself liberating and morale boosting. 
 It extends the householder's feeling of control over his or her domain, and gives a direct outlet for the natural desire to improve it. 
 Because of this, even those who could afford professional labour will often prefer to do it themselves. 
 The richer ABs spend more time shopping for DIY products, and buy more, than members of any other social group. 
 So which of the six major types of DIYers are you? 
 Just over one in ten (11 per cent) fall into the elite &bquo;Captain&equo; category; nearly threequarters (72 per cent) are male and often Southerners. 
 Captains regularly tackle the most difficult jobs with calm confidence. 
 They think they can produce a better result than the professionals and they are right. 
 They are not into bodging or compromise. 
 They must be hell to live with; they demand discipline and achievement from their co-workers and family and may lack emotional understanding and sensitivity. 
 These decisive, goal-oriented, often authoritarian, intolerant people find DIY satisfying and challenging, something of an end in itself, says Ms Firbank. 
 Having finished a job, they don't sit around enjoying the results &mdash; it's on to the next. 
 And when one house is improved to the limit, it's on to the next there too. 
 A fifth of all DIYers fall into the &bquo;Hobbyist&equo; category. 
 Forty per cent of them are women, and many are Northerners. 
 They enjoy DIY for its own sake &mdash; not just the product, but the process of creating it. 
 They generally have a (half-completed) job on the go, but don't rush it. 
 Sometimes they risk being over-conscientious, or over-involved in particular aspects of the project and losing sight of the overall goal. 
 A recent divorce petition cited the fact that just about every wall, fitment and piece of furniture in the home was in a half-dismantled or half-done state and had been for years. 
 The husband was continually starting projects, and leaving them unfinished. 
 About a fifth of us fall into the &bquo;Get It Over With&equo; category. 
 They're mostly Northerners, and they don't want to muck about. 
 If they could afford to pay someone else, they would. 
 They'll often put up with dripping taps and wobbly shelves for quite some time before being motivated to fix them. 
 He or she is not house-proud or much concerned with appearances. 
 Their houses are described as &bquo;patchy&equo; &mdash; areas of chaos, or purely functional &bquo;make-do&equo; items, amid cared-for bits representing special interests. 
 Not much in the way of frills and colour co-ordination either. 
 They've not much time for things that aren't either pleasurable or functional. 
 But it's probably the sort of house where visitors feel sufficiently at ease to put their feet up on the sofa. 
 Get It Over Withs prefer watching TV. 
 Fifty six per cent of the &bquo;Look At Me&equo; category are women. 
 They tend to be inspired by many of the ideas for home projects they see, but they lack confidence. 
 They avoid the more complicated jobs, but within their limitations they are more able than they think and usually can be sure of being pleasantly surprised by the result of their efforts. 
 They're proud of their DIY achievements, which they often find better &mdash; and a lot more satisfying &mdash; than if a professional had done it for them. 
 Their exploratory &bquo;have-a-go&equo; mentality makes them fun to be with. 
 They may need a little time to think about it, but they'll try most things once. 
 All Thumbs will do only essential mending, and even that tends to be unpleasant, since the poor results just confirm their feeling that the whole area is a minefield. 
 Drill-holes never end up in the right place, screws don't go in straight, and no matter how carefully they measure, nothing ever quite fits. 
 Practice might improve things, but with this weight of negative experience, practice is the last thing they want. 
 The Procrastinators hate DIY. 
 Often they really are too busy: prominent in this group are Midlands housewives in car-less D-E families. 
 They'd rather live for ages with sagging shelves and peeling paint. 
 For one thing they've got better things to do with their time. 
 They are sure they are no good at such things, and they're right. 
 They never even daydream about undertaking projects. 
 Some are almost proud of their practical incompetence. 
 This group is probably responsible for most of the DIY nagging. 
 Women in this category nag their partners to get on with it; men in this category get nagged. 
 Both are more likely to escape than do anything. 
 They will have areas of life where they feel competent, happy and in control. 
 His allotment, her sewing; the pub or a Mills &amp; Boon. 
 Nagged to fix a shelf, the male Procrastinator is more likely to go and polish his prize onions than fetch a hammer. 
 However, Ms Firbank points to an American study which showed an inverse correlation between house-proudness and sexiness. 
 These women may not be house-proud, but they should be responsive lovers. 
 If they are not too tired. 
 Finding myself at wit's end of an era Bad Housekeeping. 
 By Dulcie Domum MUMMY, says Harriet anxiously, was Mrs Thatcher real? 
 Much speculation recently about the existential status of Santa Claus, Jesus, etc. 
 Reply yes, though retain private doubts as to whether Mrs T is fully biodegradable. 
 Harriet turns pale at the news that the PM is not just another terrifying old witch from a fairy tale. 
 Cannot bear to think about festivities. 
 Still, Spouse is taking the children to Kirkwhinnie for Hogmanay where they can wallow in Aunt Elspeth's Home Made everything whilst I&hellip; but do not permit myself to imagine naughty idyll at Porritt Gardens. 
 Must check present list first. 
 At least confident that Spouse will enjoy, and probably pick up a few tips from, biography of Hitler. 
 Admire the Liberty shawl for Aunt Elspeth, and wonder if she might be delighted enough to leave it to me in her will. 
 Though Spouse says Elspeth defies the idea that You Can't Take It With You and will join her ancestors wearing her best tweed and Celtic silver and clutching the two cut-glass decanters he has always coveted. 
 The Nefertiti of Kirkwhinnie. 
 Am gloomy about presents for the children. 
 Not sure that tasteful ceramic nativity set will console Harriet for non-appearance of Sindy Doll. 
 As for Henry, nothing short of Middle Eastern arms shipment would satisfy him and unlikely that Acid Rain Testing Kit will divert him for more than five seconds. 
 Still, at least Santa can soak up the blame. 
 Haunted by a fear that I have forgotten to stock up on one of the essentials of life but cannot think what it is. 
 The thought of shops shut for days brings on deep depression. 
 SPOUSE to London for some dinner or other. 
 Take kids for last shopping trip but still cannot remember which essential of life we have run out of. 
 Arrive home, carry first boxful in, go out again to car where Henry and Harriet are engaged in the first barney of Xmas, and to my horror hear front door slam behind me. 
 Keys are on kitchen table. 
 Remember that I had always intended to leave spare key with the Twills next door but never got round to it. 
 Thoughts fly to Tom &mdash; he could probably break in through plumbing outlet or shin gracefully up drainpipe. 
 But cannot phone him from Twills as Mr Twill would insist on shinning up drainpipe himself and break femur. 
 Children excited by crisis and run round the back whilst I vacillate on the pavement. 
 Decide to ring doorbell of house opposite into which rather smart-looking couple, Marc and Elaine, have recently moved. 
 Elaine, wearing kimono and looking wan, answers door. 
 Ask to use phone but Tom is out. 
 Explain situation to Elaine, who though clearly suffering from flu, offers hospitality, tea, TV for kids, etc. 
 Marc is apparently in Madrid or he would be up my drainpipe like a shot. 
 Feel that Mr Twill may be called upon to lay down his femur after all. 
 Back in street, behold Henry and Harriet waving at me from our upstairs window. 
 &bquo;The back door was wide open, Mummee!&equo; they cry. 
 Hope Elaine did not hear this, and carry more boxes of shopping up path. 
 Half an hour before the shops close forever, realise it is bog paper that we need. 
 Race to Green Light wholefood shop and buy several rolls of recycled. 
 Wonder if it was newspaper before and wonder which. 
 Christmas falls upon us. 
 Harriet quite likes Nativity set but informs me it is not Baby Jesus but Princess Lucinda. 
 Feel I may be witnessing end of Christian and dawn of Lucindian era. 
 Henry contrives guided missiles from acid rain test kit and launches attack on manger. 
 Two shepherds badly chipped. 
 Security Council resolution passed declaring stable a No-Go Area. 
 Wonder if Henry was Herod in previous existence. 
 Have nasty moment in bathroom before I realise that recycled bog paper is full of eccentric imperfections. 
 Essential I survive intact until New Year. 
 Though in my case, intact is Emeritus. 
 One way to get around America is through the multitude of car delivery companies. 
 David James Smith reports Auto motive 
 Fly-drive. 
 WE WERE broke, flying into Miami. 
 Seattle was 3,500 miles away, and we couldn't afford the air fare. 
 The train was booked solid for weeks, and there was the Greyhound&hellip; &bquo;that's your cheapest option,&equo; said our friends in Seattle, &bquo;but you might be sitting with child molesters.&equo; 
 They knew nothing about the drive-away alternative, neither did we but it wasn't hard to find out. 
 We sat on a phone at Miami airport with a pile of quarters and a copy of the local Yellow Pages: &bquo;Automobiles &mdash; Delivery and Drive-Away,&equo; a couple of sheets of box ads and a user-friendly voice on the line. 
 &bquo;Hi, I'm Karen, how can I help you?&equo; 
 There was a saloon going to Chicago but there was a sports car to Los Angeles. 
 &bquo;A 1988 Corvette, just come in. 
 It's a repossession.&equo; 
 What's a Corvette? 
 &bquo;Why don't you come down to our office and have a look?&equo; 
 It was quite a car and who hasn't dreamed of being a repo man? 
 A-1 Auto Movers have an office in Miami Beach and branches in every major US city. 
 They deliver cars. 
 Whether Americans have more money than sense or are just plain lazy is hard to tell, but they pay A-1 and others like them up to &dollar;1,000 a time to take their automobiles from A to B. 
 It's big business, and the drive-away companies use up tankfuls of drivers on a casual basis. 
 Anyone can do it so long as they are not criminals or kids, and promise to play by the rules. 
 There is no fee for the driver, and unless the owner offers a fuel allowance, the driver pays for gas. 
 But there's no hire charge of course. 
 And no child molesters. 
 A-1 put the fear of God into us about the Corvette. 
 It was brand, spanking new, not a dent nor scratch on its sleek body. 
 We had to pay a &dollar;300 cash deposit, refundable on delivery, or entirely lost if there was so much as a cigarette burn in the carpet. 
 The form left nothing out. 
 Diagrams, charts, lists, detailing every damageable inch of the car. 
 The rules: don't pick up hitchers, don't drink in the car, don't exceed the speed limit, don't drive after 10 at night, and don't miss the delivery date unless you want to go to jail. 
 This car must be in LA in seven days, now sign here please, and go. 
 It was 2,700 miles. 
 We asked for an extra day, and that was fine. 
 We had no map: &bquo;Don't worry about it, just pick up Interstate 10 and it's straight all the way.&equo; 
 THE Corvette could practically drive itself. 
 It was a &dollar;35,000 car &mdash; no wonder the owners hadn't made the repayments &mdash; with computerised dash, booming hi-fi, and cruise control which meant the car would keep a fixed speed without a foot on the accelerator. 
 It was fun, and we were getting cocky by New Orleans. 
 People stared at the car, and we tried hard to look like the owners, not just the delivery team. 
 The elevated highways over the Louisiana swamplands were needle straight, and we started to snap the speed limit, just a little. 
 By Texas we were out of control, doing 96 mph on the flat when the flashing light in the rear mirror pulled us over. 
 He wore a big hat and reflector shades, and was not best pleased. 
 &bquo;I've been chasing you for eight miles. 
 I could whip you straight into jail.&equo; 
 We were very English and terribly sorry, and he let us go without a ticket. 
 An hour later a rear tyre blew. 
 We were keeping within the limit, and it was OK. 
 At 96 we would have lost our deposit. 
 The Interstate speed limit in the States is a strictly enforced 65 mph. 
 There are few tearaways. 
 We left Miami on a Tuesday afternoon and were in A-1's Los Angeles' office by midday on Saturday. 
 We were in a hurry, and didn't even stop at a motel on the Friday night, driving 1,400 miles at a stretch. 
 The LA office was laid back to horizontal. 
 They did not care about the burst tyre &mdash; all 14 inches and &dollar;400 of it &mdash; and could hardly be bothered to check the rest of the car. 
 They had another waiting to go to Seattle. 
 Nothing fancy now, only an Old Plymouth with Alaska plates, heading back to the Yukon. 
 We signed another form, paid another, smaller deposit, and checked right into a motel in Santa Barbara for a long rest. 
 In the end we virtually circumnavigated America, taking a third car &mdash; a tiny Chevette &mdash; across from Seattle to Washington DC, to fly home. 
 It was that simple, and at a more leisurely pace would have been less of a caper and more a proper holiday. 
 Whatever else there is to say about the States, it exists to be driven in; a road runner's playground littered with the seductive comforts of the drive-in-drive-out lifestyle. 
 Motels were never hard to find. 
 We paid &dollar;35-&dollar;40 a night for a double room. 
 When was the last time you actually wanted to have friends round? 
 There is a conspiracy of silence about what is happening, says Christina Hardyment That's entertainment. 
 Home Front. 
 AT THE risk of being shouted down by millions of mulled-wine swilling, mince-pie munching merrymakers, I'd like to raise the issue of hospitality &mdash; or rather, its decline. 
 Christmas time, when party-giving is on the whole overdone, may make the social aridity of the rest of the year seem almost attractive, but this exhausting seasonal overswill also points up the ordinary isolation that obtains for most of us nowadays. 
 There is a conspiracy of silence about what is happening. 
 Nobody likes to admit that they entertain very little, or that they rarely enjoy it when they do. 
 I tried declaring my own sense of dissatisfaction to a few friends and found I'd caught a tiger by the tail. 
 &bquo;I thought it was only us,&equo; was the most common reaction. 
 &bquo;All that work beforehand &mdash; I'm exhausted by the time we sit down to eat. 
 Then there's clearing up after they've gone.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's absurd &mdash; I look on Margaret as my best friend, but I've only seen her once in the last six months &mdash; I do feel guilty about it.&equo; 
 And again and again: &bquo;We'd rather sit down in front of the TV, or get a video.&equo; 
 The casualness which governs who we see and when is unnerving. 
 The rigid rules for turn and turn about social calls are no longer observed. 
 An uneasy feeling that we should wait to be asked back before we repeat an invitation, coupled with the rarity with which we have the energy to entertain, can reduce social intercourse to an annual gesture rather than a matter of maturing friendships. 
 Today's crowded world militates against a sense of community. 
 We lead more private lives today than ever before, a defence perhaps against the masses who press against us in the tubes, in the office, at school. 
 Professional agencies look to our problems, be they medical, psychological, or moral. 
 None of us needs any particular other any more, so acquaintance is a whim, flowering or dying with the moment. 
 Chance now rules social intercourse, not the old realities of good neighbours. 
 In The last Country Houses, a book which documents the death of the old tradition of hospitality, Clive Aslett records the response of a nouveau riche lady when told that some pleasant people lived near the rural seat her husband had just acquired. 
 &bquo;Pleasant or not, it matters little to us,&equo; she retorted. 
 &bquo;We shall get our friends down from London with the fish.&equo; 
 Traditional entertainment was rooted in local interdependence &mdash; it was a form of community cement. 
 At its best, it extended the family circle and brought in new blood; it relayed vital personal information (too often dismissed as gossip) and offered an informal moot for exchanging opinions and information. 
 In different forms it could provide marriage market (21st birthday party or coming-out-ball), gynaecological information service (women withdrew from male company at some point during the evening), a seasonal celebration of community spirit (harvest home, yuletide) or a mark of respect to a human life (funeral, wake). 
 COMMUNITY cooperation always ended in a party, be it a barn-raising, as in Seven Brides for Seven Brothers, or the annual distribution of porcine largesse at pigkilling time described by Flora Thomson in Lark Rise to Candleford. 
 Above all, it was continuum, a regular habit. 
 Even when industrialisation took most men out of the home, women ensured that the old neighbourly traditions lived on. 
 Meetings were necessary for social contact, apart from anything else. 
 Sewing and apple-paring bees, and quilt-making sessions were ways of combining hospitality with practical usefulness. 
 What has affected the recent decline of entertaining more than anything else, of course, has been the change in the position of women. 
 Hospitality was one of the first duties of any bride; at certain social levels it was a woman's raison d'etre. 
 But now we are all individuals with our own self-fulfilment to worry about. 
 Wedding bells are merely an incidental punctuation in a life which will already be committed to career, aerobic class and the occasional night with the lasses. 
 With pregnancy things change. 
 Being at home with small babies is an instant culture shock to the young woman of the world. 
 There will be a flurry of cordon bleu cookbooks, a splurge of flowers and pools of candlelight to drown the everyday realities of bottles and babygrows. 
 What then? 
 The cast is assembled, but more often than not it has nothing to say. 
 The men are too tired, the women too remote from the issues of the day, to offer more than a commentary on the quiche or a flirtatious skirmish. 
 The whole pointless exercise, the sense of being marginalised, can be what sends a mother back to work, although the declared reason will be the need to boost the family income. 
 Then the real juggling act begins &mdash; job, children, house and husband. 
 As the children get older, evenings become valuable family time; as we get older, early nights become increasingly attractive. 
 The TV provides everything we could ask for and more. 
 Entertaining, in this context, seems an unnecessary luxury. 
 Does it matter? 
 We don't on the whole mind the isolation until something happens to rock the applecart &mdash; a death, a loss, a crisis. 
 When a marriage breaks down, there will be an urgent need for support, both intimate, and social. 
 At this point the failure, the essential selfishness, of our social network becomes extraordinarily evident. 
 Depending on our social class we will turn to tranquillisers, professional counsellors or gin. 
 But there is also a more insidious danger to our deeply private modern lives. 
 The psychological, physical and sexual abuse of weaker members of the family by the stronger is more possible when there are no casual droppers-in, no family friends to turn to, no habit of exchanging confidences. 
 We may scoff at the sort of community action that was represented by ducking-stools and pillories, by &bquo;sending to Coventry&equo; and by, in its extremest form, lynch law. 
 But in a world where observing the social decencies passes unnoticed, how much incentive is there to be ordinarily good? 
 THERE are signs that we are beginning to acknowledge our need for community support, encouraged, ironically, by a welfare state that can no longer pretend to provide a substitute for friendship. 
 There are neighbourhood watch schemes and informal baby-minding groups. 
 A surge of participation in evening classes and sports is as much about a search for companionship as mental and physical fitness. 
 Franker discussion about the nature and value of conventional entertaining could improve matters even more. 
 Four-course meals that last four hours are marathons for everyone concerned. 
 It would be easier all round to suggest coming to eat and just to eat &mdash; leaving as pudding is cleared away (or better, after you've helped to wash it up). 
 As for that video, what could be more relaxing and companionable than sitting down with Marks&amp;Spencer meals on our knees and watching it in company? 
 In the context of hospitality and friendship, little and often is worth more than the grandest of annual social jamborees. 
 The wrong policy could cost you more than a pocketful of dreams. 
 Jill Papworth reports Travel light with a cover. 
 Insurance. 
 OF THE estimated 12 million holidaymakers who took out travel insurance policies last year, one in 15 made a claim. 
 Half were for cancellation, a quarter for medical expenses and most of the remainder for loss or theft of belongings. 
 Given the high expenses you could suffer should disaster strike just before or while on holiday, and the relatively low cost of buying adequate cover, only a fool would book travel arrangements without taking insurance. 
 It is worth shopping around before choosing as the scope of cover, sums insured and premium costs vary considerably. 
 Most good travel agents require you be insured if booking a package holiday, but will nowadays be able to offer you the choice of the tour operator's policy or their own. 
 Ask for a specimen policy and read the small print to be sure you will not be affected by exclusions and that the cover is appropriate for your particular travel arangements. 
 The Association of British Insurers points out an increasing trend among major insurers to offer selective cover for people who already have some elements of cover under existing household and life policies, or free with their credit and charge cards (NatWest's Gold card offers the only truly standalone, comprehensive travel cover). 
 In any policy, medical and repatriation cover should be up to &pound;250,000 when holidaying in Europe, unlimited for the USA and &pound;500,000 for the rest of the world. 
 The Barclays Bank policy, one of the cheapest, is rare in offering unlimited medical cover worldwide. 
 Cover should include all reasonable medical treatment, extra hotel and travel expenses related to sickness or injury, and daily hospital benefit averaging &pound;10 to &pound;15. 
 Few policies cover pre-existing conditions, self-inflicted injury or pregnancy-related claims. 
 Many insurers have a link with an emergency assistance organisation such as Mondial, GESA or Europ Assistance and will give you a local 24-hour phone number to call should you need sudden medical or repatriation help. 
 Cover for cancellation of your arrangements due to an accident or illness affecting you or your family should be &pound;1,000 to &pound;3,000. 
 Some policies will also include eventualities like job loss or having to stay home to care for a sick relative. 
 Curtailment cover should be included to compensate for days lost if you have to cut short your holiday and return early because of illness or death in the family. 
 PERSONAL liability of &pound;250,000 to &pound;1 million is advisable to cover you for the legal liability of injuring someone or damaging their property, particularly as insurers report an increase in such claims. 
 Some insurers, such as Perrysurance and Pickfords, have also introduced cover for legal expenses if you want to pursue a third party. 
 Cover of around &pound;1,000 is normally given for loss, damage or theft of belongings, with a limit of &pound;150 &mdash; &pound;250 for any one item and &pound;200-&pound;300 for lost money. 
 There should also be some cover for buying basics like toothbrush and undies if your luggage is delayed. 
 You will need to take out extra cover or extend your house contents policy if you take valuables such as a video camera or precious jewellery. 
 To discourage petty claims, most insurers make you liable for the first &pound;25. 
 Most policies pay out a measly amount for expenses on delayed departures. 
 On average you get a maximum of &pound;60 &mdash; &pound;100, paid in instalments after the first 12 hours' delay. 
 Extrasure is this year one of the first insurers to reduce the qualifying period to eight hours. 
 Anyone with special needs should beware. 
 Those aged 70 and over are often charged double or three times the standard premium, though providing you are fit and healthy, Barclays, Thomas Cook and Pickfords charge the standard rate. 
 If you plan to take part in a risky sport like skin-diving or hang-gliding, don't expect automatic cover. 
 Contact the related UK sports organisation. 
 Comparing adult premiums for two weeks in Europe and worldwide on a selection of major policies and some smaller insurers, recommended for their low rates in last year's Which? magazine survey, produces the following examples. 
 ABTA's Travelguard, offered mainly by independent and smaller travel agents, charges &pound;12.70 and &pound;31.50 respectively; Thomas Cook &pound;19.45 (&pound;39.95); Barclays &pound;14.55 (&pound;39.55); United Friendly &pound;17 (&pound;34); Extrasure &pound;17 (&pound;41); Perrysurance &pound;13.20 (&pound;26.20/US &pound;33.30); Pickfords &pound;18 (&pound;38). 
 MOST give free cover to children under two; United Friendly, Perrysurance, Pickfords give substantial discounts for older children. 
 Families get a good deal with Extrasure which offers every insured person free cover for a child aged 11 or under, and with ABTA's special policy rates of &pound;33.50 (&pound;79) for a couple and all dependent children under 16. 
 For further information, contact local branches for Thomas Cook, Barclays and Pickfords; United Friendly (branch or tel: 01-928 5644); Extrasure (01-480 6871); Perrysurance (01-879 1255). 
 Reflections on The Decade Letters. 
 By YOU MAY feel that Julie Burchill's advocacy of the drug culture (December 16 issue), replete with &bquo;Thatcherite values&equo;, amusing. 
 I found it a rather disgusting product of a self-admitted drug damaged brain. 
 I'm surprised that such hedonistic, empty headed opinions should find a place in what I have always regarded as a serious, intelligent newspaper. 
 Further on, Richard Gordon reviewed disease in the Eighties &mdash; such as Aids and M.E. 
 As for his opinions on M.E., I must assume that he would also condemn the support groups for MS, cancer and heart disease as &bquo;self-commiserative&equo; societies. 
 &bquo;Yuppie Flu&equo; is a term invented by the gutter press &mdash; the same people who dismiss Aids as a &bquo;Gay Plague&equo;. 
 P. Edisbury Solihull. 
 POOR old Jeffrey Bernard, so terrified of women, shaking in his frail, alcoholically reinforced misogynists shoes &mdash; cynical and brittle, propping up the bar and amusing his (male) audience by spilling his wit and intelligence in bar-room bons mots. 
 From that dissolute, pleasurable and wasted place, no wonder he's threatened by people who decide to use their intelligence differently, and especially by women who don't fit a stereotype that bolsters the ludicrous notion that He is a Superior Being. 
 Sad really, but I'd rather the impotent ramblings appeared in the Spectator and left the Guardian to those of us who enjoy reading it. 
 A. Tunnicliffe Llangadod, Dyfed. 
 YET MORE articles attack the softest of soft targets, the heritage industry. 
 But never mind the trash shops and the coach lamps. 
 Why is the past such big business nowadays? 
 Vintage pop, vintage Hollywood, vintage beer bottles &mdash; you name it, somebody's collecting it, researching it, producing a surprisingly expensive book about it. 
 There is a profound streak of anti-modernism running through the Thatcherite Kingdom of the Bland: no one seems to want the future any more, apart from Martin Pawley. 
 This trend did not start in the Eighties either: the old puffer and old motor movement were well under way when Prince Charles was a lad. 
 So, come on you literary types; stop fretting about Orwell and start getting under our skins. 
 There is a massive sub-culture there, looking backwards and it's getting more insidious all the time. 
 A. Townley Manchester, 25. 
 CAN YOU tell me why you found it necessary to print such an offensive cartoon (Lagerland, page 40)? 
 Do you assume you have no Christian believers among your readers or are you deliberately seeking to insult and estrange them? 
 John Tester Edinburgh YOUR Decade supplement was most entertaining, but you missed The Guardian off the &bquo;Born Again' list. 
 Patrick Thorne Kiltarlity, Inverness-shire. 
 I WAS shocked and disturbed by the full-page advertisment for The Sport and Sunday Sport. 
 The rest of the edition was completely spoilt for me. 
 Please try harder. 
 Rowena Dawson Kegworth, nr Derby I READ The Empress Without Clothes (page 6) with interest. 
 The text was interrupted successively by some text running sideways, a graph depicting escalating mineral water sales, the number &bquo;6&equo; and a table of five useless gadgets. 
 The article was terminated by a line of words beginning with B. The empty reproduction of information (a contagion of the Eighties) does not contribute to rational knowledge and reasoned thought. 
 Antony Knight Waltham Abbey, Essex. 
 Looking for tourist highlights in Montepulciano can prove difficult. 
 But when, says Juliet Clough, you do find them, the sights can prove both beautiful and satisfying The icing on the cake 
 Tuscany. 
 IN Montepulciano's Museo Civico, a painted St Agnes proffers a model of her city with the proprietorial air of a waitress with a tea tray. 
 Such an ambitious Tuscan confection surely deserves a cakestand, assembled as it is on a noble pedestal of rock, its buildings (mixed plain and fancy) composed of that porous tufa which looks much like sponge cake and which comes in all the golds, pinks, browns and mauves of the best Battenberg. 
 It is fruitless as well as greedy, however, to try and pick Montepulciano over for cherries. 
 This is a city very much all of a piece, its chief delight for visitors lying in its completeness, in the hands-off self containment of its torpid, shuttered streets. 
 Looking for tourist highlights in Montepulciano is, to change a crumbling analogy, rather like looking for elephants in the African bush. 
 It is only when you stop scanning the horizon for monumental shapes that you realise they have been looming unnoticed in the foreground all along. 
 Wandering with pleasure along the Corso, the knobbly spine of the town, we eventually open the guide book, to find we have failed to focus on seven modest palaces. 
 These, however, do not include that of the 18th-century antiquarian Pietro Bucelli, who decorated the base of his mansion with unmissable eclat, using bits of Etruscan cinerary urns. 
 The montage of winged heads, flowers and cryptic inscriptions shares, in effect, something of the ephemerality of Oggi, Bella and Donna Moderna, lined up outside the next-door newsagency. 
 Much more entertaining than any guide is the dyspeptic company of Maurice Hewlett's, The Road In Tuscany (1906) which finds in Montepulciano &bquo;much to make the judicious grieve&hellip; the Piazza a barrack square, the belfry a maimed stump&equo; and so on. 
 While unable to sympathise with Hewlett's aesthetic sufferings, I find it impossible not to admire the iron nerve with which he chronicles them. 
 This is a person who sees nothing to recommend the Duomo at Siena (&bquo;it seems to have been got by outlining&equo;), nor Sienese painting in general: &bquo;evidence of love; but not of art&hellip; 
 Mercifully for us they had gold leaf in plenty&equo;. 
 Perhaps he was looking for a drink by the time he had climbed as far as the Piazza where three renaissance palaces, a town hall and cathedral confront each other across an open space of such lively dignity and harmony as to make the lack of tourist cafes completely forgivable. 
 Certainly you would have to be in pretty desperate case to dismiss the eloquent Michelozzo figures on the cenotaph frieze in the Duomo as &bquo;wriggling in lines like leeches in a bottle&equo;. 
 The best places for bottles in Montepulciano are the cool brick cantine like that of the Contucci Palace, cellars furred with black fungus where Vino Nobile has been produced for a thousand years. 
 Domestic vines and orchards, in patches of garden overgrown with poppies and clover, straggle as far up as the fortress. 
 Beyond the grey-blotched roofs and television ariels of the outer town lie more vineyards and cornfields, olive groves and forests; beyond them again Lake Trasimene. 
 Stuck with posters advertising the return of a group called Sttonehenge (sic), &bquo;Il Coraggio di Essere Giovani&equo;, apricot coloured walls give off a lazy warmth. 
 It might indeed take courage to be young in Montepulciano. 
 What could anyone under 50 do in a place so prosperously becalmed in its tangible past and agricultural present? 
 We go in search of the Editori del Grifo, a young team of publishers said to have moved from Rome back home to Montepulciano as a vote of confidence in the old place; they have moved again, however, and we have run out of the steam needed to look for their new office. 
 THE faint pall of dust hanging over Montepulciano's precipitous lanes presumably heralds the approaching festival of the arts, directed every July by the composer Hans Werner Henze. 
 Cobbles are being relaid, the Jesuit church facelifted; S Agostino smells of varnish as well as incense. 
 Fronting the tiers of frivolously gilded boxes, just discernible in the gloom of the Teatro Poliziano, the stage appears to be brilliantly lit, set with an all-purpose lyric opera backdrop. 
 Montepulciano not only looks but behaves like a stage set, patronising barbers' shops and swirly baroque cafe; its hours are numbered by a forbidding clock-tower Pulcinella; it goes to church, outside the walls, in the most theatrical building of all. 
 &bquo;A sepulchre of windy shams&equo; says Hewlett, squaring up in excellent form to the classical urbanity of San Biagio. 
 The church, a copybook model of renaissance perfection, imposes most beautifully, if rather donnishly upon the pastoral scene. 
 Hewlett, predictably, has &bquo;never seen a worse church&equo;. 
 The road between San Biagio and Montepulciano is the one down which the Montepulcianesi came to welcome Iris Origo and the troupe of refugee children whom she walked to safety across a battlefield in June 1944, caught between the German army of occupation and the advancing Allies. 
 &bquo;War in Val d'Orcia&equo; is her dispassionate account of attempts to keep life on a local estate balanced between bellicose German troops, jumpy partisans, exhausted refugees, escaping British prisoners and the local Fascisti, during the appalling interlude following the fall of Mussolini. 
 Recently read, the Marchesa's diary, however unembittered, makes the sound of German tourist voices reverberate uneasily in these streets. 
 It has taken more than 40 years, we are told, as well as improved autostradas, for the first &bquo;Zimmern&equo; signs to appear in Montepulciano. 
 A cake plate so temptingly situated is bound to be fought over. 
 That the lion's share fell to Florence rather than Siena, after a century and a half of medieval snatch and grab between the two republics is proclaimed by the splendid lions on the well and on the Marzocco column. 
 Briefcase: Juliet Clough went to Italy fly/drive, London to Pisa, with an Alitalia scheduled flight and hiring an Avis car. 
 The journey was arranged with the help of Italiatour!, 21 Fleet Street, London EC4 1AA; tel 01-353 9686. 
 Prices starts at &pound;216pp (based on two people staying 7 nights and hired a Grade A car). 
 Among several tour operagors with accommodation in Tuscany, Italiatour! offer, for example, a self-catering apartment in a castle about 25km from Montepulciano at &pound;260pp for four people staying seven days, (including flight, car hire and apartment). 
 Alternatively, staying in 4-star country style hotel in the Chinati region would cost &pound;384pp for seven days, including flight, car hire and B&amp;B. 
 For self-tailored holidays, Italiatour! organise Alitalia bookings and accommodation in almost any Italian town. 
 Further information from Ufficio Turistico Comunale, Via Ricci 9, 53045 Montepulciano (Siena); tel: 0578-757442. 
 In Britain: Italian State Tourist Office, 1 Princes Street, London W1; tel: 01-408 1254. 
 Alastair Ayres chooses some hardy annuals All-weather favourites. 
 Gardening. 
 WHAT will the weather have in store for us in 1990? 
 Another mild spring and long, hot summer? 
 Or late frosts, and drizzle throughout August? 
 Although British summers are likely to become hotter and drier as a result of the greenhouse effect, scientists don't foresee major changes taking place for about 40 years. 
 The Met Office regards last summer as one of those exceptions from the norm which go to make up the typical British weather rather than some trend for the future. 
 Predicting the weather is a risky business, but you can take out insurance by choosing seeds and plants to cope with both drought and downpour. 
 Among the flowers that did really well in last year's hot summer were alyssum, geraniums and petunias. 
 Alyssum flourishes, whatever the weather, and breeding advances in recent years have made this plant a lot more versatile. 
 The new varieties Snow Crystals and Creamery have a compact habit and much larger flowers than the traditional varieties. 
 They would be ideal for edging mixed borders or bedding schemes. 
 There are also now a lot of good coloured alyssum mixtures. 
 Three that have done particularly well in Gardening from Which? trials are Magic Circle, Magic Carpet and Morning Mist. 
 All three are quite similar with a pastel range of pink and purple flowers as well as white and cream. 
 The heights of the plants vary from about eight to 20cm, so they won't make as neat an edging as the single-coloured varieties &mdash; but they are attractive gap fillers or ground cover. 
 Oriental Night is a rich plum-coloured alyssum with a fairly even habit and would make a good, easy-to-grow substitute for lobelias. 
 Geraniums are one of the best flowers for containers. 
 They will survive without water for up to two weeks (providing you don't forget to water too often) and love hot weather. 
 However, if you choose the right varieties, they will also brighten up your garden in a cool, dull summer. 
 Buy the F1 varieties like the Century, Gala, and Pulsar series, which all come in a range of colours. 
 The F1 hybrids produce twice as many flowers and have a much bushier habit than the older varieties. 
 Avoid geraniums with double or semi-double flowers as, unlike the single varieties they don't drop their petals as they fade, and the blooms are prone to rot in wet weather. 
 You'll find lots of geraniums in the seed catalogues. 
 But, when you consider that seeds of F1 geraniums cost 20-30p each and they need to be sown in a heated greenhouse in January or early February, plants are a better buy. 
 If you look for strips of young geraniums at the garden centre, you should be able to get F1 hybrids for around 60p or so a plant. 
 Virtually all petunias did well last summer, but this is not always the case. 
 In poorer summers, the taller varieties and the grandiflora types (with larger flowers) are often ruined by wind and rain. 
 Double-flowered petunias are also prone to rotting in wet summers. 
 The safest bets are the F1 multi flora varieties with single flowers. 
 Although they may get flattened by a rainstorm, they quickly recover once the sun comes out. 
 In Gardening From Which? trials in 1985, which was a fairly wet summer, petunia Resisto Mixed did particularly well and provided a colourful display until late September. 
 In trials last summer, two newer varieties &mdash; Carpet Mixed and Joy Mixed &mdash; formed more even plants with a good mixture of colours. 
 They look well worth trying. 
 In the vegetable garden, both sweetcorn and outdoor tomatoes were an amazing success in many parts of the country last year due to the hot summer. 
 If you are planning to try them again this year, take the precaution of choosing quick-maturing varieties in case this summer doesn't turn out to be as sunny. 
 Good sweetcorn varieties are Candle (one of the new super-sweet types), Kelvedon Sweetheart and Sunrise. 
 The tomatoes Red Alert and Tornado should give reasonable crops outdoors in a dull summer &mdash; at least in the southern half of the country. 
 IF THE summer turns out to be hot, it will be a lot less work if you plant outdoor tomatoes in the ground rather than in growing bags. 
 Where you are short of garden space, try the dwarf varieties Pixie (large fruit) or Tiny Tim (small fruit) in tubs. 
 Most traditional vegetables do best in a cool, wet summer, so incorporate as much organic matter as possible and consider using strips of black polythene between rows to reduce the need for watering in a good summer. 
 If you can't water your vegetable plot, beetroot, leeks, onions, root crops, and maincrop potatoes should all give reasonable yields, even in a hot, dry summer. 
 Extremes in the weather are nothing new for the British garden and one fairly safe prediction for 1990 is that the weather will be as unpredictable as ever. 
 Shopping list for seeds: Alyssum: Creamery (Mr Fother gill); Magic Carpet (Carters); Magic Circle (Dobies, Suttons); Morning Mist (Suttons); Oriental Night (Browns, Suttons, Thompson &amp; Morgan); Snow Crystals (Browns, Dobies, Mr Fothergill's, Unwins). 
 Petunias: Carpet Series Mixed (Browns, Mr Fothergill's); Joy Mixed (Marshalls); Resisto Mixed (widely available). 
 Tomatoes: Pixie (Johnsons); Red Alert (widely available); Tornado (Marshalls, Mr Fothergill's, Suttons); Tiny Tim (Mr Fothergill's, Suttons). 
 Sweetcorn: Candle (Suttons); Kelvedon Sweetheart (Hursts, Marshalls); Sunrise (Carters, Dobies, Marshalls, Thompson &amp; Morgan). 
 Seedsmen: Browns: Station Road, Poulton-le-Fylde, Blackpool, Lancs FY6 7HX. 
 Mail order only. 
 Carters: Shops and garden centres only. 
 Dobies: Broomhill Way, Torquay, Devon, TQ2 7QW. 
 Mail order only. 
 Johnsons: London Road, Boston, Lincs, PE21 8AD. 
 Shops and garden centres only. 
 Marshalls: Wisbech, Cambs, PE13 2RF. 
 Mail order only. 
 Mr Fothergill's: Gazeley Road, Kentford, Newmarket, Suffolk, CB8 7QB. 
 Mail order, shops and garden centres. 
 Suttons: Hele Road, Torquay, Devon TQ2 7QJ. 
 Mail order, shops and garden centres. 
 Thompson &amp; Morgan: London Road, Ipswich, Suffolk IP2 0BA. 
 Mail order, shops and garden centres. 
 Unwins: Histon, Cambs, CB4 4LE. 
 Mail order, shops and garden centres. 
 Alastair Ayres is the new editor of Gardening From Which? published by the Consumers' Association, 2 Marylebone Road, London NW1. 
 Peter Black relishes the solid comfort of a French town steeped in history In a class all of its own. 
 Pau. 
 AS OFTEN happens near mountains in spring, the temperature fell 10 degrees overnight. 
 I awoke back in winter. 
 It was really too cold for the clothes I had brought, so I fell back on a recommended resource. 
 I put my pyjamas on underneath my clothes and thus protected went for a walk round Pau. 
 It was Sunday and the streets were empty. 
 The gentle recorded feminine voice that admonished pedestrians &mdash; &bquo;Attendez, pietons!&equo; and then, in encouraging tone, &bquo;Pietons! 
 Traversez!&equo; echoed rather sadly off the walls. 
 It grew colder and began to rain, as the iron bells of churches rolled of a French Sunday over the town. 
 In the morning, spring had returned. 
 The magnificent view to the south, from the Boulevard des Pyrenees, built along the bluff above the fast-running Gave de Pau, displayed an inspiring panorama, thousands of miles of rich valley climbing towards the snowcapped Pyrenees. 
 This was the view that Wellington's army saw when they broke into France in 1814, so beginning an extraordinary chapter in the town's history. 
 After the Peninsular campaigns unravaged southern France must have seemed like Arcady. 
 The living was cheap and easy, the Bearnais were grateful, there was hunting all year round. 
 With peace, some returned to Pau, to build the villas in the big gardens that give the town its green and spacious air. 
 By 1840 there were enough to start the Pau hunt. 
 Some of its relics are scrupulously cared for in the English Circle headquarters; they showed me a pair of jockey scales, caricatures of riders clambering redfaced out of ditches, group paintings of the hunt moving off. 
 It used to release captured foxes, give them up to nine minutes start, and chase them through areas designed Old England, Leicestershire, Hill District, Home Circuit. 
 Except for a few extremely rich Americans (Gordon Bennett was one) and a sprig of French nobility they were British and Irish aristos, and landed gentry and army officers. 
 They were extremely dashing riders, if we may believe the Vicomte de Vaufreland. 
 He reckoned to be airborne for 15 minutes in every 50 of the average run. 
 In 1856 three Scots army officers and an archdeacon founded Pau Golf Club on land running along the river. 
 I approached it as a pilgrim, though today of course it looks like any other golf club; the members are indigenous and they are Japanese. 
 (The club's brochure includes advice on etiquette which as always sounds surrealistic in French. 
 &bquo;Ne vous lamentez pas a haute voix sur vos mauvais coups.&equo;) 
 In the clubhouse, though, are relics as evocative as cave drawings. 
 A photograph of the Duke of Hamilton and Brandon, Major Pontifex and Archdeacon Sapte, faces frozen stiff by the camera. 
 Tauchnitz English editions of Victorian novels; volumes of The Queen &mdash; &bquo;The Lady's Newspaper&equo;; leather-gripped hickory shafted clubs of strange shapes, fashioned like painters' brushes for special purposes. 
 (One was for hitting a ball out of a cart rut; its head was no bigger than a soup spoon.) 
 By 1892 there were 340 members and not a foreigner among them (Americans didn't count). 
 A group painting by Alan Sealey in 1893 shows members watching a player drive off. 
 The men wear wide moustaches, deerstalkers, and caps, with red jackets and loose tweeds, breeches and gaiters. 
 The women stand on one side, in straw hats, skirts and parasols. 
 Sealey has caught the player in a fine action pose. 
 He is clearly a very good golfer, though his flying right elbow looks odd now. 
 Nobody is identified, but I would bet he is Horace Hutchinson, son of the Colonel Hutchinson who was among the founders. 
 Despite that elbow, Horace was the finest amateur of his day. 
 He also created a profession; he was the first outstanding golfer to write about the game. 
 Looking into those calm, assured faces in this odd setting I felt a stab of the futile longing to communicate that Alan Moorehead described on meeting a family of gorillas. 
 Everybody had money, not distastefully earned. 
 Like called confidently to like. 
 There were picnics, parties, theatricals &mdash; &bquo;a perfect storm of unending pleasure&equo; wrote Count Henry Russell. 
 So the years rolled by until the day the Archduke Ferdinand's carriage was accidentally halted in a street in Serajevo. 
 Then they went home to the battlefields of the Great War. 
 AFTERWARDS the typical expatriate had less money, and liked Pau because it went further; and the servants still came when you pressed the bell. 
 The best known of them was Dornford Yates, author of the now unreadable but once hugely read Berry and Co stories. 
 He lived in Pau for 17 years, as a fugitive from a Britain given over, as he saw it, to socialist malcontents. 
 Pau retains a circle of Anglophiles who cherish the British connection and speak of it with affectionate admiration &mdash; not the most widespread of French responses to us. 
 I think the dashing strain in these emigres appealed to the countrymen of Henri IV, Bernadotte, Foch (and our own Fieldmarshal Alanbrooke), and Dumas's d'Artagnan. 
 And Pau is not in the mass tourist market. 
 Its British visitors are discriminating people who relish the solid comfort of a prosperous southern French town, where regional bourgeois cooking exists as a living celebration going back into antiquity. 
 I am not such a fathead as to attempt to describe the pleasure of eating, but I would draw your attention to the vegetable soup cooked with a hambone (le garbure), to the river trout braised in Henri IV's favourite Juranon wine, the grilled breast of duck. 
 Observe too the presentation of the vegetables. 
 The French beans are wrapped in a strip of bacon. 
 Simon Rae Counting out the Eighties. 
 Oh God, another 10 years down the drain; More damage for the mirror to explain: Those whisps of grey, new veins across the nose, The growing paunch that half obscures the toes&hellip; 
 Outside the bathroom door the long dead news Is served again in dozens of reviews; The colour sups dementedly parade Pictorial pickings from the past decade: A cast of horribly familiar faces, The winners of a hundred one-horse races, The media icons of a 10 year binge When loads of money was society's hinge &mdash; Money for an image or a slogan; Money &mdash; lots and lots &mdash; for Terry Wogan, And other stars who live the live of Riley: Madonna, Joan (and Jackie) Collins, Kylie&hellip; 
 Beyond the tabloid visions wars galore, Catastrophies disasters by the score, Plagues and famines &mdash; countless thousands died. 
 The Third World's poor stayed poor, and multiplied. 
 But Berlin has outlived its shameful war And last week saw the vile Ceausescus' fall As long as Gorbachev still gets his way, The Stalinists at last have had their day. 
 While here at home the Liederene ploughs on, Though many punters think the magic's gone. 
 The Eighties, clearly, were the Thatcher years, But Nanny's reign looks set to end in tears. 
 Pyrgic Puzzles. 
 By Christopher Maslanka 
 1. 
 According to a shamefaced Treasurer of the India Club: &bquo;One night last week I attended three parties one after the other. 
 The attendances of these three parties, leaving me out of the reckoning altogether, summed to 49. 
 Furthermore, at each of the three parties an identical cake was served: same size and same shape. 
 On each occasion the cake was divided exactly and equally among all those present (this time including me) and there was none left over. 
 When I arrived home very late that night (What a dog I felt!) 
 I realised, to my embarrassment, that I had eaten the equivalent of exactly half a cake. 
 &bquo;Given that there were many at the first party, fewer at the second and fewest at the last, how many people were there at each of the three parties, not including me?&equo; 
 ILLUSTRATION: IAN ANDERSON 
 2. 
 To direct questions such as &bquo;How old are you?&equo; 
 Lady Belladonna answers truthfully, though often indirectly. 
 Thus it was that a caddish cub reporter from the Cricklewood Cricket drew the following response: &bquo;A quarter of my age in years multiplied by a fifth of my age in years multiplied by a forty-fifth of my age in years gives my age in years.&equo; 
 The reporter was ungentlemanly enough not only to do the calculation and obtain the correct answer but also to print it in the society column. 
 How old is the lady? 
 Nameless Lives. 
 By Aubrey Anon HE WAS a friend of Byron at Harrow, and later a better friend of the Met, of working people in need of &bquo;abundant and untaxed food&equo; and of Roman Catholics, whom he had governed in Ireland under the longest Conservative administration anyone hopes to see. 
 A braver man than most of his successors, he challenged the Gerry Adams of the day to a duel and crossed to Ostend to meet his enemy, but the project fell through with the arrest of his opponent. 
 As a backbencher, his mind changed: &bquo;Do you not think that the tone of England is more liberal than the policy of the government? 
 Public opinion is growing too large for the channels that it has been accustomed to run through.&equo; 
 He even managed to reform the British judiciary. 
 Solutions. 
 1. 
 Had the attendance of the third party been only two, the Treasurer would have eaten his half-cake at that party alone. 
 Assume the fewest possible, namely three. 
 Then he ate one-third of a cake, leaving one-sixth unaccounted for. 
 Arguing in a similar way, there could have been seven at the second party, leaving one-forty second of a cake unaccounted for, and hence an attendance of 42 at the last party. 
 Not counting the Treasurer, then, this gives attendances of 41, six and two, which do indeed sum to 49. 
 These attendances not only fit the facts but are the only set which does. 
 2. 
 Lady Belladonna's utterance is tantamount to saying her age multiplied by her age multiplied by her age is the same as multiplying her age by four and then by five and finally by 45. 
 This in turn means that multiplying her age by her age equals 900. 
 So her age in years is 30. 
 Nameless Lives: Sir Robert Peel (1788-1850), who became Chief Secretary for Ireland in 1812 after Spencer Perceval was assassinated and Lord Liverpool became Prime Minister for what must have felt for ever. 
 The creator of the Metropolitan police force (Peelers), he changed sides over Catholic emancipation and the repeal of the corn laws, and carried his (Tory) party on both reforms by his eloquence and stature. 
 His duel opponent was Daniel O'Connell. 
 That queasy feeling behind Christmas Diary. 
 By Claire Rayner 
 A QUEASY week. 
 It's not excess of turkey and plum pudding that has been indigestible; it's the surfeit of news. 
 I've been reared on Christmasses and New Years that deserve the label &bquo;silly season&equo;, when news editors scrabble among the Christmas morning swimmers and the New Year's Eve drink statistics to cobble up a headline, but this sudden toppling of Evil Empires and establishment of Free Democracies (poor souls! 
 They think this will make tham a lot better off; a little perhaps, but a lot?) is enough to give anyone a sick headache. 
 Perhaps my problem is the way I perceived the first news of the crumbling of the old Europe; sitting in hospital and festooned in drip feeds and stoned out of my mind on pethidine as I came round from an anaesthetic, I muzzily watched the news on the TV in the corner of my room and truly believed I was hallucinating as I saw kitchen choppers taking down the Berlin Wall; after such a beginning to the thaw, how can I believe that as well as East Germany's arrival in the West, Czechoslovakia is almost herself again. 
 Ceausescu is dead, Lithuania stirs and Bulgaria stretches ready for its own emergence. 
 Let alone the news from Panama &mdash; I'm entitled to be queasy. 
 All this and &bquo;Donald, Where's yer troosers?&equo; 
 It's more than mortal woman can stand. 
 THIS SEASON of violent contrasts started for me on TV-am where, as part of the Christmassy Victorianisation of After Nine, I sat on the sofa in bustle and bare bosom (well, upper bosom anyway) and suitably black-lace-becapped to be a Fin de Siecle (nineteenth variety) agony aunt. 
 I started reading out some of the advertisements from a magazine of 1890 or so: &bquo;Ladies&equo; Safe Remedy: Apioline. 
 A safe and Personal Remedy for Functional Troubles, Delay, Pain and Irregularities&hellip;&equo;; 
 &bquo;Appiol and Steel Pills: A French Remedy for all irregularities&equo;; &bquo;Ottey's Strong Female Pills. 
 Quickly and certainly Remove all Obstructions arising from any Cause Whatever where Steel and Pennyroyal fails.&equo; 
 If the anti-abortion campaigners have their way advertisements like these, and for similar dangerous products, will no doubt reappear. 
 If the choice facing us were legal, clean, decently performed abortion or none at all, no doubt many of us would be hard put to it to vote for the former; but in fact the choice is between the legal, clean sort and backstreet self-induced efforts of the Ottey's Pills variety. 
 And if the anti-abortionists succeed in 1990, I and others of my ilk will once again be begged, somehow, to help the unwillingly pregnant. 
 Well that's what Christmas is all about, isn't it? 
 Keeping up the good old traditions. 
 BOXING Day and we launch ourselves on our own family tradition &mdash; a visit to the theatre. 
 We've done it since the oldest was five, so why stop it now, a mere 20 odd years later? 
 Now we have to accommodate the tastes of partners of immediate family as well as our own offspring, so choice is careful indeed. 
 We opt for The Baker's Wife at the Phoenix and all vote it a definite winner, and I wonder again at the jaundiced palate of critics who gave it a fair old drubbing when it first trotted out. 
 A mind stretcher it wasn't but an agreeable evening in the theatre it undoubtedly was, and harmed us not at all. 
 Which is more than can be said, perhaps, for some of the offerings labelled Panto that are currently mopping up a lot of customers. 
 The year's resurgence of interest in travesties of middle-aged women, all ugly, strident and terminally randy, boucing around alongside girls in doublets and hose or whatever, intent on making respectful love to sugary heroines in lacy crinolines, has always seemed to me extraordinary. 
 How can a country which is so deeply intolerant of sexual differences in real life offer so raucous a welcome to such creatures? 
 God help the feller who turns up at the factory to work in silk knickers under his overalls, but at Christmas, of course, on a stage, of course, it's all perfectly all right. 
 Of course. 
 Mind you, I feared the worst for this year's crop of pantomimes. 
 One management even offered me the role of Fairy Godmother in Cinderella. 
 Even my highly regrettable tendency to react positively whenever the fridge door is opened was proof against that. 
 Can you imagine it? 
 No, don't. 
 It'll strain you badly. 
 Not that I wasn't able to do a bit of Godmother, Fairy, problems-for-the-solving-of act this year. 
 It became urgently necessary on Christmas Eve afternoon to get a comforting present sent from London to a sad lady in Wordsley near Wolverhampton. 
 Interflora on Christmas Eve? 
 Forget it. 
 This was a Sunday. 
 Any shops open anywhere in Birmingham who could help? 
 Who knows? 
 In our North London fastness we are as ignorant as snowflakes of such matters. 
 Enter stage right disc jockey Jimmy Franks of BRMB, local independent radio in Birmingham, the only chap who happens to be around when I phone to see if anyone there could help me out. 
 He arranged within an hour for the delivery of a bottle of something bubbly, by taxi, to sad friend in Wordsley who is, we fondly imagine, instantly magicked into happy lady. 
 Jimmy Franks is one hell of a Christmas Fairy. 
 He not only transforms sad friend, but maintains my reputation for being a resourceful problem solver. 
 Phew. 
 That was a close one. 
 FOR ME, reared in a tough Puritan tradition, a traditional Christmas ends the day after Boxing Day with a return to stern work. 
 So, I write, as well as this diary, some of my new novel (a killer, this one, dealing as it does with post-Holocaust survivors' guilt; why do I set myself these agonies?) and start pinch-hitting for Gloria Hunniford on Radio Two. 
 My first interview is with Barbara Cartland. 
 As I say, life is full of contrasts. 
 Especially this Christmas. 
 Claire Rayner is a novelist, broadcaster and agony aunt. 
 Miles better in 1990 Weekend attractions.. 
 By Chris Riley G. 
 GLASGOW hardly needs the encouragement, but on Sunday night it follows in the civic steps of Athens, Florence, Amsterdam, West Berlin and Paris as Cultural Capital of Europe &mdash; Glasgow 1990. 
 While Paris's tenure saw events swallowed up by the huge bicentenary celebrations, West Berlin's year stimulated an extraordinary range of artistic events, concentrated in the summer months. 
 Glasgow, already the host for many of the UK's most innovative arts events, hopes to go one better in 1990, combining commercial and publicly-funded activity in a year-long cultural feast. 
 Appropriately it kicks off on the stroke of midnight tomorrow with a pyrotechnic extravaganza likely to distract even the most serious Hogmanay party-goers. 
 Six fireworks displays will simultaneously usher in the New Year. 
 In the city centre there's a massive Hogmanay Party at George Square for those lucky enough to hold tickets. 
 Starting at 10pm, it features the River Detectives, Urban Sax, Tommy Smith, Hue and Cry, Robbie Coltrane, Runrig, Aly Bain, Lulu and many others. 
 Although a number of the year's major events are still being finalised, much of the menu for 1990 has been announced. 
 It is full of theatre, dance, opera and other performing and visual arts, showcasing some of Scotland's finest talents together with artists and companies from around the world. 
 Two of the opera world's leading stars give concerts &mdash; Luciano Pavarotti in May, Jessye Norman in November &mdash; while the Bolshoi Opera visit the Scottish Exhibition and Conference Centre in July and August with productions of Boris Godunov, Prince Igor and The Maid Of Orleans. 
 Choral and early music are strongly represented with festivals in June and August respectively, while Scotland's orchestras, including the SNO and SCO, have full programmes throughout the year. 
 The SNO's new home, the Glasgow International Concert Hall, opens in October, and a number of visiting orchestras, including the Berlin Philharmonic, help celebrate with concerts there. 
 Among the next few months' highlights are Borderline's production of Dario Fo's Mistero Buffo at the King's Theatre with that man Robbie Coltrane again (Feb); The Art of Print, a survey of European Print Masters at the Hunterian Art Gallery (Jan-Apr); a new production of Pirandello's Enrico Four at the Citizens Theatre (Feb); Steven Campbell's first one-man show in Glasgow at the Third Eye Centre (Mar) and Freaks by the Companie Genevieve de Kermabon at Tramway (Mar). 
 Brochures available from Glasgow 1990, PO Box 88, Glasgow. 
 Luciano Pavarotti is one of the stars visiting Glasgow during 1990, as it celebrates its year as cultural capital of Europe CAPTION FOR TABLOID PAGE34 The Dinosaur Roadshow is on display at Newcastle: see Events 
 Defector in a safe hostel On a wet weekend, Michael Woods keeps his assignment with the mole-hunting major. 
 Theme Breaks. 
 I NEVER did find Mr Wright although, following the instructions I received at my briefing, I spent some time looking for him. 
 I did, however, locate Mr Wrong &mdash; for that is how our small team of spycatchers finally code-named him. 
 We had staked out the war memorial where the secret meeting was destined to occur. 
 One of us read a newspaper on a nearby bench, another casually admired the view while the third, myself, studied with infinite curiosity a nearby noticeboard. 
 I know every word of it by heart. 
 At precisely the right moment, a heavily-built fellow with a black beard arrived and paced about, staring this way and that as if waiting impatiently for another to arrive. 
 A girl from one of the other teams &mdash; for all of us had assembled by now &mdash; asked him for the time and briefly discussed the weather with him and when, after about 15 minutes, he struck off purposefully around a nearby playing field, he had a tail of 14 people &mdash; the entire membership of all four spy teams &mdash; determined not to lose their quarry. 
 After a considerable amount of doubling back, hiding in bushes and around buildings and mingling with crowds, the poor fellow finally gave us the slip and disappeared. 
 Only next day did we discover that he had no part whatever in the plot &mdash; to Mr Wrong of Colchester, our apologies! 
 I suppose it is an inevitable reaction of those who look at the world with questioning eyes, to regard everyone with suspicion and, after a whole day tracking spies on this spycatcher weekend, our senses were certainly finely tuned. 
 When the &bquo;real&equo; spies did turn up (one carried the Guardian as a signal) they acted with such obvious shadiness that they were instantly recognisable. 
 The clue we recovered from their dead letterbox, however, only served to confuse us further. 
 Oh, where was George Smiley now? 
 The weekend had begun with a briefing from the Major and from a purported Russian spy seeking to defect to the west and who, meanwhile, was staying in a safe house. 
 All fairly straightforward though the coded letter we recovered from his baggage took a long time to crack, while his shaving kit will never be the same again after each piece was stripped to its component parts by one participant. 
 The following morning our team of John, a theology student from a Jesuit College who talked like Derek Nimmo in All Gas and Gaiters, James, a British Telecom engineer (useful) and I, set off to follow a long and complicated trail across Colchester. 
 For one group the trail went cold. 
 They had to retrace their steps to pick it up again, while a second team discovered that neither a policeman nor the Council knew where the Local Authority parcels office was. 
 We returned to the safe house for dinner with most of our theories shattered. 
 Only interviews with the prime suspects could enlighten us now but, instead, they served to confuse still further. 
 In the nature of spying, none of their stories agreed and, indeed, some were completely contradictory. 
 The result was that, although all four teams put their heads together in the pub, there were almost as many theories as there were people. 
 To find out who was correct, we had to wait until the following morning and our debriefing with the major. 
 Team A &mdash; a group of students and a civil servant &mdash; probably came closest although, as in all things, there appears to be no correct answer, just a selection of possibilities. 
 My own suggestion that we were dealing with a whole nest of Mata Haris was declared plausible but incorrect while Team C, consisting of two middle-aged couples, produced two theories, the second of which named me as a potential mole! 
 If this has blown my cover, you may not hear from me again. 
 (Apart from Colchester, the names of people and the locations of the events mentioned in this article have been changed in order to protect the integrity of the Service.) 
 Spycatcher Weekends are run by the Youth Hostels Association at their Colchester Hostel and the next three such weekends are scheduled to take place on the weekends of January 26, February 9, and February 23, 1990. 
 They last from Friday evening to Sunday lunchtime and cost less than &pound;60 (fully inclusive, with overnight passes for the hostel). 
 You need not be a member, nor be a youth: Youth Hostels are open to anyone and provide a countrywide network of cheap accommodation which is warm and comfortable. 
 How to survive the sun war John Illman on the slip, slop, slap method of enjoying sunshine while avoiding the killer rays. 
 Health. 
 WE WERE sailing from the Queensland port of Cairns to go diving on the Great Barrier Reef. 
 I was sitting on the deck, my back exposed to the sun. 
 I hadn't been there for more than a minute when the skipper bellowed: &bquo;This is melanoma country, mate. 
 Get inside.&equo; 
 Melanoma is a sun-linked form of skin cancer. 
 Queensland is where it occurs most. 
 But melanoma country is any hot spot. 
 In the heat of last summer it was even possible to run up &bquo;minus points&equo; on the melanoma scale. 
 In a tragic testimony to the commercial success of the package holiday business over the last 30 years, melanoma now ranks as Britain's fastest growing cancer. 
 Within two decades the number of cases reported each year has more than doubled to at least 3,000. 
 Small wonder that doctors are calling for the return of the parasol and pith helmet. 
 The disease is nearly twice as common among women than men. 
 There is increasing evidence that the age range 10 to 19 may be the crucial age for exposure, though younger children may also be at increased risk. 
 The key message is that kids cook quick &mdash; which is not to say that they immediately contract the disease. 
 There may be a latent period of 30 years before it actually erupts. 
 Specialists are worried by a recent survey showing that most Britons are still totally unaware of the disease, never mind its life-threatening potential. 
 Of 1,250 people quizzed, three quarters had not even heard of it. 
 Of those who had, only six per cent knew that it was dangerous. 
 Characteristically, Australia has been fighting the sun war with a slogan, Slip, Slop, Slap: slip on a shirt, slop on some cream and slap on a hat. 
 Even so the disease is still striking 3,300 Australians a year and killing a thousand of them. 
 The emphasis there is not on staying indoors, but on learning how to enjoy a sunny, beautiful country and survive. 
 This involves avoiding the midday sun. 
 Staying out of the sun between 11am and 3pm can reduce exposure by 60 per cent. 
 As another Australian slogan advises: slip under a tree between eleven and three. 
 Exactly what is melanoma? 
 It is linked with melanin, the dark brown pigment of the hair, skin and eyes which is present in varying amounts in people of all races. 
 Melanin producing cells in our bodies are activated by ultraviolet light from the sun and can have a protective effect. 
 The disease, however, may be triggered in moles containing unusually high concentrations of melanin. 
 Consult a doctor immediately if a mole causes irritation, itching, soreness, inflammation, or bleeding or changes in size or colour. 
 A new mole around an existing one can also mean trouble. 
 WRITING in the Lancet this year, a Glasgow team led by Professor Rona MacKie, identified four key &bquo;risk factors&equo;: 
 Having more than 20 moles; 
 A tendency to freckle; 
 Having three or more moles greater than five millimetres in diameter (ones you cannot cover with the blunt end of a pencil); 
 Three or more exposures to severe sunburn. 
 There is a lot of controversy over which SPF (sun protection factor) creams are best for particular countries. 
 Caution is the key word. 
 With that in mind stick with 15. 
 And remember too, despite what we've been brought up to believe, a suntan is not a symbol of health and fitness. 
 It's the body's response to a threat. 
 Michael Levy hot on the trail of the finest plastic junk in the world from Niagara to Bangkok The attack of the tack culture. 
 Ephemera. 
 TRAVELLING these days, especially on a low budget, is supposedly aided by the plethora of guidebooks, travel companions and survival kits. 
 They give us information on the medieval pottery museum, birthplace of local legends and the address of the youth-hostel-cum-doss-house. 
 Once the experience of local life and culture has been assimilated, the traveller moves on, a more complete person. 
 This approach ignores the delights of &bquo;tack travelling.&equo; 
 Time spent in the tack emporiums of any town or city gives a greater insight into the ways and customs of a place, then trudging around dolls museums and marine parks, or even witnessing displays of traditional, tourist-orientated dancing. 
 What is tack? 
 It can't be defined, it just exists. 
 It jumps out of the shop window, attacks your aesthetic sense and begs to be admired. 
 Mass-produced ephemera is a regular feature of the times. 
 Each place has its own particular style of tack. 
 China's &bquo;four modernisations&equo; ignores a fifth one &mdash; mass development of silly objects. 
 Pictures of cats made out of synthetic material and stuck on to plastic plates are available in virtually every store. 
 Why visit the gardens or the pagodas of Suzhou, when much more can be gained by attempting to buy a 1950s style mannequin. 
 A day spent finding China's Number One sea shell carving factory, brought forth the awesome sight of the Great Wall made entirely of shells. 
 Every visitor to Toronto is told to visit the CN tower. 
 A fatal mistake. 
 One then may miss the Ukrainian religious tack store &mdash; Pope plates. 
 3-D Jesus key rings. 
 Then there is Honest Ed's a five-storey Aladdin's cave of the cheap and gaudy. 
 The beauties of the Buddhist temples of Thailand are no match for the plastic clocks, surrounded by the Thai royal family, readily available. 
 Forget the Berlin Wall itself, there are some lovely kiosks selling cold war kitsch. 
 Perhaps the most wonderful place on earth (though I am told on good authority that the souvenir shop at Graceland takes some beating) has to be Niagara falls. 
 Shop after shop filled full of plastic &bquo;snow and shakes&equo; of the falls, cushions proclaiming one's love for the falls, key rings, tea sets, T-shirts ad infinitum. 
 The true tack traveller would spend his/her honeymoon in a motel, on a heart-shaped water bed. 
 (The true story of Niagara is that when the European settlers first arrived they were so impressed by the tack stores, that they decided to build the falls). 
 What are the parameters of the tacky way? 
 It is essentially a non-authoritarian mode of travel. 
 There is no point booking a package holiday &mdash; this contains the essentially free spirit of the tack traveller. 
 However, &bquo;macho travelling&equo; is to be avoided &mdash; one need not travel eight days in the toilet of a train to sample &bquo;real life.&equo; 
 Find a fairly comfortable base, a place to spread out the newly-acquired tack. 
 An early rise is not necessary, as tack is always there. 
 NB: When in Socialist countries, if something exquisite comes up, snap it up immediately, as centrally-planned economies can play havoc with the supply of tack. 
 Avoid &bquo;healthy&equo; outdoor pursuits which involve the use of your own legs. 
 Waiting around markets is the correct function of a tack traveller's legs, not clambering through the foothills of the Himalayas (where there is a distinct lack of plastic ephemera). 
 The tack traveller must be bold, prepared to go where no tourist dares to step with the tack antennae on constant alert. 
 A medical supplies shop in the back streets of Shanghai is not the average travellers idea of an attraction, but for the tack traveller it contains hidden treasures. 
 Here is a test: if you were in Warsaw, faced with an hour to fill before catching a train, would you go up the tallest building in the city to experience a panoramic view, or rush to the bookstore/poster shop in order to buy a massive Telly Savalas poster? 
 A true tack traveller doesn't even have to think. 
 Judy Rumbold on the tell-tale trim and trappings of the tourist. 
 Montage by Graham Rawle Button up a package deal THE SEASONED traveller can be identified at check-in by a conspicuous absence of specially designed leisure clothes festooned with pockets, zips and velcro. 
 There is no superfluous gadgetry or foldaway, stowaway gimmickry. 
 The rest, and this is what (snobbishly) differentiates intrepid wanderers from tourists, travel considerably less lightly. 
 Unfamiliar locations invite panicky packing that will cover all eventualities, and casualwear manufacturers encourage normally chaotic tourists to be minutely organised. 
 Everything must perform a specific function &mdash; from myriad pouches on a holdall to passport holders and water bottles to sling around the neck. 
 Ludicrously over-equipped tourists might recognise themselves from this checklist: 
 Track or leisure suit. 
 Must be bulky, ill-fitting and very obviously new looking. 
 Sickly pastel colours are the most popular &mdash; pale lemon, pink, green or blue &mdash; punctuated by unattractive logos and go-faster stripes in tones that jar hideously with the original colour scheme. 
 Leisure suits effectively soften the line of the body and look like adult-size romper-suits. 
 They lend to an airport lounge the look of a grotesque, sprawling creche peopled by monster babies. 
 A tracksuit's unfamiliarity forces compromise; its wearers are often loath to forgo elaborate hairdos, makeup, heels, jewellery and medallions just because the sportiness of the outfit implies reckless, leisurely abandon. 
 Holdalls. 
 Usually the fifth, runtish item in a five-piece Samsonite luggage set. 
 Probably won as fifth prize in a quiz show. 
 Made from nasty leatherette with myriad pockets and a different strap for carrying it every way humanly possible. 
 Redundant handles scrape along the ground like entrails and get tangled up in pushchair wheels and unsuspecting dogs' legs. 
 There are pockets within pockets ad infinitum &mdash; a Russian doll of a bag &mdash; so compartmentalised do tourists' possessions become that they completely lose track of where everything is. 
 Otherwise, the bag is a big, nylon pastel effort that expands to the size of a small marquee and then folds away to postage stamp size (except that, like a map, once unfurled it's hellish folding it back again). 
 Pockets. 
 No tourist should be without at least 10 times as many pockets as they'll ever find use for. 
 They should be all over the place &mdash; especially where least expected &mdash; halfway down a leg, on a collar, cuff or elbow for instance. 
 Particularly ridiculous are see-through plastic map-pouches on the outsides of sleeves. 
 It is important that pockets render completely unaerodynamic any garment they come into contact with. 
 Leisure wear manufacturers embraced the superfluous pocket with great enthusiasm; here was a way of disguising less than pristine workmanship with countless compartments in the shape of long pointed things and small squat ones &mdash; nothing sensible enough to accommodate anything that people really own. 
 They are also fond of pushing the idea that the more pockets there are, the more covetable the garment. 
 Pockets, they think, make people feel important &mdash; like explorers, war reporters or Anneka Rice. 
 Jackets. 
 Should be lightweight and preferably reversible. 
 A popular aberration has a light yellow exterior with towelling striped innards. 
 The important thing to remember is that it doesn't matter in the slightest what this garment looks like, as long as it boasts practicality and water-resistant qualitites. 
 Worn by four-strong cereal-packet families who once favoured kagools or train-spotterish anoraks. 
 Zipup compartment behind collar for redundant hood. 
 Also popular for travelling are quilted, overblown pseudo-ski jackets in pink or blue that look like duvets rampant. 
 Safari jackets are still favourites with more mature male travellers. 
 Often worn with pale, open-necked sports shirts and dodgy cravats. 
 Very Alan Whicker. 
 Velcro. 
 The leisurewear industry would come apart at the seams, literally, without this indispensable fastening. 
 Aeroplanes resound to the deafening rasp of anorak pen-pockets when passengers are told to fill in their landing cards. 
 Velcro also in evidence all over training shoes, holdalls and generally where it is least needed. 
 Disadvantages of the stuff are that it attracts fluff, hair and biscuit crumbs. 
 Loses its powers of adhesion. 
 Sensible shoes. 
 Broadcast their newness around airport lounges by squeaking and creaking but never, ever slipping (God forbid that those hi-grip soles should fail you) around the polished floor. 
 Popular styles include pristine trainers bought especially for the trip, squashy leather K shoes with side zips, and the trusty Jesus sandal. 
 Foldaway slippers for the flight are tucked away in a holdall with disposable nappies and sick tablets. 
 Shoes always turn out to be wrong for the climate. 
 Tourists inevitably end up having to buy either wellies or flip-flops when the weather does something perverse. 
 Trousers. 
 Quilted or ostentatiously functional &mdash; the Swiss army penknife of the trouser kingdom &mdash; with a thousand pockets, clips, keyrings and a thing for getting stuff out of horses hooves all attached to the waistband. 
 Usually worn by those smug bastards who fidget relentlessly on planes and insist on getting up and walking round the whole time, demonstratively taking photos out of windows and asking for guided tours of the cockpit. 
 Pretend to know a lot about everything and are patronising to air hostesses. 
 Women tourists are fond of white cotton trousers with dark knickers underneath. 
 Money belts. 
 Circumnavigate the area approximating the waist. 
 Usually screamingly conspicuous because they're such a new, unfamiliar concept for most tourists. 
 They might as well have a badge on them saying Steal Me in big black letters. 
 Denim. 
 Not such a great idea on long flights as it tends to cut off circulation in several different places. 
 But lots of people travel in the snow-washed variety &mdash; especially cocky skiers who say they wear denim on the slopes because they never fall over. 
 These are usually the people you see on the return flight with both legs in plaster. 
 Accessories. 
 It's important for the foreign traveller to accumulate lots of useless gadgetry and ephemera that they'd never dream of buying normally, and which makes the whole process of travelling so much more cumbersome and awkward for others. 
 Blow up kidney-shaped cushion for the neck; clip-on sunshades, tubular money holders to hang around the neck, haircuts as pristine and new as thatched cottages; too many magazines, trashy paperbacks, a whole arsenal of cameras, video equipment and binoculars. 
 Watches that tell the time in 18 different languages, make toast and have so many knobs and dials that the clock face is completely obscured. 
 PAGE 
 To hell and back via Bank Breakdowns, queues, filth, cancellations &mdash; even the escalators don't work. 
 Why is London's Underground so dreadful?. 
 Tom Hibbert reports from the innards of the capital Photographs by David Modell. 
 Wednesday, 8.05 pm, District Line. 
 IN THE tunnel between Gloucester Road and Earls Court, the train-supposedly bound for Richmond-has come to a halt: 25 minutes pass, a hot, cross silence broken only by the coughs and tuts and groans and rattling Evening Standards of disgruntled passengers (sorry, &bquo;customers&equo;; London Underground now wishes to refer to the sad user of the subterranean network as a &bquo;customer,&equo; dictionary definition: n. one who buys). 
 The lucky ones are sitting in relative comfort and mute fury beneath cardboard advertisements for Wardour pickles, Stolichnaya Vodka, the National Army Museum and the Corby Trouser Press. 
 The less fortunate have to stand on aching pins as the carriage, unventilated (it is impossible to fit air conditioning to tube trains as the tunnels are too small to acccommodate such devices), grows hot and foetid; even the lines of Shirley Lim's Modern Secrets up there amongst the ads- &bquo;Last night I dreamt in Chinese/Eating Yankee Shredded Wheat&equo; -brought to us by &bquo;Poems On The Underground,&equo; a ruse to make tube travel a little less stressful, cannot alleviate the strap-hangers' gloom and frustration. 
 &bquo;Bloody, bloody typical,&equo; mutters a smart, young City-type, rolling back his eyes and snapping shut his briefcase in wrath. 
 Why are we waiting? 
 We are not allowed to know just yet, for the London Underground rule book tells drivers to wait for 30 minutes before making an announcement, unless they've received a message to the contrary from their controllers or there is some &bquo;immediate threat to safety.&equo; 
 But, finally, the answer to our unspoken query comes crackling over the train's less than clear public address system. 
 &bquo;I am sorry about this,&equo; begins the driver's voice. 
 &bquo;There's a train stopped in front of us. 
 The driver's left it and no one knows where he's gone. 
 And we can't move till someone finds him.&equo; 
 This excuse is met by a low moan crawling through the carriages. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry!&equo; goes the disembodied voice; &bquo;I'm as pissed off about this as you are. 
 I want to get home too.&equo; 
 The driver sounds so genuinely distressed, it seems churlish to complain (not that that would do much good). 
 Thursday, 8.45 am, Parsons Green, Eastbound platform. 
 A cheery bing-bong-a new addition, the kind of chime you hear in airports-peals out over the PA system. 
 Followed by the voice of &bquo;your District Line information service at Earls Court.&equo; 
 The message the voice has to impart is well-known to the users of this service: &bquo;Good morning, ladies and gentlemen inaudible earlier defective train leading to inaudible cancellations inaudible delays to all destinations.&equo; 
 Thursday, 9.20 am, Earls Court. 
 A woman pulls a boy child by his little hand toward the escalator leading down to the Piccadilly Line. 
 &bquo;I bet the moving staircase doesn't work, Mummy,&equo; pipes the lad, evidently a seasoned tube traveller. 
 &bquo;Don't be silly!&equo; snaps the woman, tugging her offspring through the throng. 
 More haste, less speed, Madam! 
 The child is right, this escalator, like so many on the London Underground network, has not been in operation for months. 
 40 escalators out of service over the 270 stations, but fret not; it's estimated that all will have been repaired by 1996. 
 The woman steps aboard the unfunctioning device and, taken by surprise by its lack of motion, trips and tumbles. 
 The boy bursts into tears. 
 The commotion is ignored by all others bustling down into the Earls Court bowels. 
 IF ONLY the woman had paused for a moment to inspect the hastily scrawled felt tip notice at the top of the stairs: &bquo;I am sorry for any inconvenience caused to all our customers during the period that the down escalator has been out of service. 
 This fault is due to a shortage of an electrical part. 
 I cannot give any estimate of its arrival. 
 Please accept my apologies, Peter J. Saunders, Group Station Manager.&equo; 
 Thursday, 9.45 am, Piccadilly Line. 
 With no explanation or apology the Piccadilly line train shoots through Leicester Square station without stopping and dumps a grumpy load at Covent Garden. 
 Only one of the brand-new lifts is working, or so a smudged note scrawled in chalk on a blackboard attempts to tell us: &bquo;Due to a defect, certain lift operations suspended.&equo; 
 There's nothing for it but to clamber, wheezing and bursting of heart, up the steep steps (300 and more) of one of the deepest shafts of the Underground to air and freedom. 
 Friday, 7.50 am, Edgware Road, Bakerloo line. 
 I have little to report here for the station is closed. 
 Due to staff shortages. 
 And entirely in the interest of the travelling public, you understand. 
 Since the King's Cross fire of 1987, London Underground has been forced to adopt certain stringent safety measures. 
 These include calling in the fire brigade at the first sign of what they quaintly call &bquo;smouldering in senile machinery&equo; and ejecting all the customers forthwith, and not opening stations if the required number of staff (two on the smaller stations) have failed to turn up. 
 Thus at least six stations are shut every morning. 
 &bquo;Our levels of absenteeism are not untypical of the London area,&equo; says Dennis Tunnicliffe, the managing director of London Underground; &bquo;And that's enough to cause some noise in the system.&equo; 
 The only noise one hears at Edgware Road this morning is that of embittered commuters stomping away from locked gates and cursing as they plan alternative routes. 
 Friday, 3.20 pm, Central Line. 
 THE EASTBOUND train, for once uncrowded, stops at Marble Arch. 
 Aboard steps a busker in a perky kiss-me-quick hat with lucky heather stuck in the band, accompanied by a face-painted consort. 
 They are less welcome than a troop of ticket inspectors. 
 The man with the acoustic guitar and stupid headgear launches into an awful rendition of Dire Straits' Sultan Of Swing, out-of-key hummings taking the place of the Knopfler guitar solo, while his florid chum scampers down the aisle embarrassing travellers to such an extent that they all toss loose change into the jumbo jamjar. 
 This is mugging, with discomfiture, rather than fists or knives, as the threatening weapon. 
 The unwanted jongleurs even proffer tourist information: apparently if we disembark at Oxford Street we'll be in one of the finest shopping centres in the world, so why don't we &bquo;all fuck off there and buy yer wives a mink? 
 We'd like to say it's been a pleasure serving you, but we'd be lying, you miserable tight-arses!&equo; 
 They alight at Bond Street to hold another innocent train to ransom with abuse and ghastly tunes. 
 Friday, 4.00 pm, Tottenham Court Road Station. 
 There's a gruesome ringing in my ears-an unpleasant melody, Feelings perhaps, possibly played by hectic dervishes on microwave mouth organs and paraffin stoves. 
 The sound is very horrible indeed. 
 This is the sound of Muzak brought to you courtesy, and for absolutely free, by London Underground. 
 This music, something like they serve up in supermarkets and American elevators, is an &bquo;experiment,&equo; and Tottenham Court Road is the first station to feel the &bquo;benefits&equo; of a new system that &bquo;customers&equo; can actually hear and, according to London Underground, the racket is intended to &bquo;calm people awaiting their train. 
 It might even deter muggers from mugging people.&equo; 
 But-when you're stuck halfway down the steps to the Central Line platform, unable to proceed as the platform is so packed, unable to retreat as there's a crush of bodies behind you-the bizarre rendition of Tie A Yellow Ribbon Round The Old Oak Tree adds to your dread as it echoes around the halls. 
 &bquo;We think that music is a good thing,&equo; says Tunnicliffe; &bquo;If you look at our everyday lives, many of us live in a music-filled environment so there is a reasonable chance that it will be a positive thing. 
 Tottenham Court Road was the trial station of upgrading our public address system and so we thought, well, just plug the music in and see what happens.&equo; 
 MUZAK also helps to deter buskers. 
 &bquo;We have the dilemma of buskers. 
 Our public are, when we polled them, down the middle, half liking them and half hating them, so on balance we'd rather not have the buskers. 
 It is essentially illegal.&equo; 
 Indeed, London Underground's own byelaw 22 states that &bquo;No person while upon the railway shall to the annoyance of any other person sing, perform on any musical instrument or use any gramophone record player or tape recorder or portable wireless apparatus.&equo; 
 260 troubadours, tap-dancers and persons with flutes, sheet music and accompanying ghetto-blasters fall foul of this law every year-though no one has as yet been prosecuted for playing an irksome Walkman-zzzsssss zzzsssss-on a train, and, evidently, the ruling does not apply to the operators of the Underground themselves. 
 Friday, 8.30pm, Waterloo, Northern Line. 
 The &bquo;misery line&equo; as it is called-stations from Kennington to Morden dim and cheerless dungeons, trains cancelled with appalling regularity (there's a shortage of drivers on the Northern Line, because it is the last to embrace OPO-one person operation-and so the pay is lower than on other lines). 
 In 1988, customers, so cheesed off with the Line's service, staged the famous so-called &bquo;battle of Finchley Central,&equo; occupying a train after an all-too-common announcement that it was to be diverted to Mill Hill East instead of &bquo;speeding&equo; to its original destination of High Barnet. 
 &bquo;I've had enough!&equo; cried the ringleader, the Spartacus of the Northern Line, &bquo;I'm staying put! 
 If we all do it they'll have to take the train on!&equo; and 60 fellow travellers rebelled in agreement, using seat cushions to prevent the doors from being closed. 
 &bquo;Selfish and irresponsible,&equo; London Underground called the action. 
 &bquo;The Tube is not a personal taxi service.&equo; 
 Indeed it is not. 
 One could never accuse it of that. 
 I am puzzling over the dot matrix display board that's trying to tell me what trains are coming my way. 
 1: Edgware 5 minutes, 2: High Barnet 8 minutes, 3: Edgware 15 minutes. 
 (And &bquo;No smoking on the Underground,&equo; says the display at every available opportunity.) 
 Eighteen minutes pass and having failed to meet their appointments, the promised trains disappear from the board. 
 A young man of shaven pate, E-X-P-L-O-I-T-E-D tattooed on his forehead, approaches me brandishing a splashing can of Carlsberg Special Brew and asking me the time. 
 It is ten to nine, I inform him, but and my uncontroversial and accurate reply seems to enrage him. 
 &bquo;Fucking Prince Charles!&equo; he snarls, swaying dangerously and lowering his head towards me. 
 &bquo;Who do you fucking think you are? 
 Got any pound coins for me?&equo; 
 ISWALLOW hard, suspecting that I am about to become another statistic in the rising tide of Tube violence, 380 reported assaults a year and mounting, 16,000 other crimes. 
 But, no, my &bquo;assailant&equo; proves incapable of doing any GBH unto me. 
 The worse for drink, he lurches away, staggering to a litter bin where he is sick. 
 Sadly, however, his delicate tidiness is wasted-the bin is a bottomless shell and the liquid vomit showers over the wall, on to his trousers. 
 All alone in the big city&hellip; there are 380 reported assaults a year on the Tube, and 16,000 other crimes Saturday, 12.10 pm, Piccadilly Circus. 
 Here is the very subway corridor in which, in 1980, Lord Home, Sir Alec as was, became the most celebrated personage ever to be mugged on the Underground system. 
 And here is a platform littered with persons waiting anxiously for that last train home. 
 Tourist backpackers chattering in high tones; theatre-/supper-goers gazing nervously at the cluster of dishevelled, ruby-faced lads who wave their cans and bawl out the rallying cry of &bquo;'Ere we go, &bquo;ere we go!&equo; at alarming volume; a comatose figure lying on the bucket seats and crying out an important but indecipherable message about some quite obvious connection betwixt Jesus and Aids; in the corner a girl with dishevelled hair and a soiled James Dean T-shirt sprawled on the concrete and a man with bloodied chin mouthing profanities as he urinates against the wall. 
 There's a scuffle taking place on the adjacent platform: you hear the yells and the fists. 
 To think that during the Blitz, families, stout-hearted folk, were down in these caverns holding hands beneath blankets and whistling the stirring refrains of Dame Vera Lynn. 
 &bquo;Get a ticket, not a criminal record,&equo; the ads urge you; but this is easier said than done. 
 The booking office is closed (staff shortages). 
 I stand in the queue for one of the new-fangled ticket machines clutching my one pound coin, but when it's my turn, the dot matrix display has changed suddenly from CHANGE GIVEN to EXACT MONEY ONLY. 
 Insert your ticket, if you are fortunate enough to have one, into one of the newly-installed electronic barriers designed to reduce fraud (handy tip for cheapskates: exit barriers are happy to accept a cheap children's ticket regardless of age). 
 Also presumably designed to confuse tourists. 
 Y OU will, more likely than not, find your entry barred and spy a sign flashing SEEK ASSISTANCE. 
 From whom, pray? 
 Many consider these new gates something of a menace. 
 Last year one Christopher Sutton found himself stuck in a mass of bodies at Oxford Circus because all but two of the barriers were not working. 
 Result: human club sandwich wall-to-gate. 
 &bquo;You'll have another King's Cross disaster on your hands!&equo; shouted Sutton-who was immediately taken aside by station manager Henry Feathers and arrested by the police for being a nuisance. 
 Once on the platform, if you are lucky enough to get there, you will be met, eventually, with logic-free announcements to explain why you are going to be ridiculously late for work or that important appointment. 
 &bquo;Ladies and gentlemen, this is your inaudible because of problems, your journey may take longer than usual.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ladies and gentlemen, London Underground apologies for the late running of trains, which is due to an earlier signal failure in the Wimbledon area.&equo; 
 &bquo;There will be no further Eastbound trains until a defective train is removed from the stretch between Victoria and Sloane Square.&equo; 
 &bquo;London Underground wishes to apologise for intervals between trains, this is due to earlier intervals.&equo; 
 &bquo;There are no trains Eastbound on the Central Line until further notice, this is due to inaudible inaudible London Underground would like to apologise for any inconvenience. 
 Further to this notice inaudible.&equo; 
 And then, of course, there is the ever-handy standby &bquo;person under train&equo; -person under train guaranteed to shut your route right down. 
 One hundred persons per year under train. 
 The figure growing. 
 &bquo;Person under train.&equo; 
 A not-so-good euphemism for someone who has tried to do him/herself in by hurling him/herself beneath a moving tube train, or someone who has been jostled from a congested platform on to the track, or some kicky kid indulging in Tube surfing-travelling outside the train and hanging on, and falling off, like John Koporo, age 11, who in 1987 at Kilburn became the sport's first victim. 
 London Underground is spending &pound;100,000 on research to find out why so many of us like to toss ourselves on the rails. 
 Perhaps the torment of Tube travel itself has something to do with it. 
 The old and needed services for customers are becoming non-existent on the Tube. 
 Once upon a time, if you were caught short, there would be a convenience at your disposal. 
 No more. 
 The toilets at Piccadilly Circus closed down years ago. 
 They've gone at Finchley and almost everywhere else. 
 &bquo;Rather sadly it is a comment on modern society that keeping public loos clean and not vandalised is an uphill battle,&equo; says Dennis Tunnicliffe. 
 &bquo;We are looking at what you might loosely call superloos. 
 We're going to experiment with one or two of those to see if they survive better. 
 And then we may retro-fit to places like Finchley.&equo; 
 No loos, and Ellie's Sandwich Bar on Piccadilly Circus is long gone too, and, if you fancy a refreshing beverage while you're waiting (endlessly) at Sloane Square, tough luck-that platform pub has gone too, a victim of No Smoking restrictions. 
 Never fear, you can still buy an attractive neck-tie at King's Cross's Tie Rack emporium. 
 No services, no decipherable announcements, nothing one actually wants or needs. 
 Station refurbishment seems a mere insult when the trains don't run on time. 
 At Baker Street, tiles showing a profile with a deerstalker hat and a curvaceous pipe: Sherlock Holmes, who lived in Baker Street. 
 At Leicester Square, reels of film-there are many cinemas showing films on the streets above us. 
 At Finsbury Park a great big hot air balloon: er, a bit of a poser, this one, unless you know that Finsbury Park was the site of the first hot air balloon flight. 
 Tottenham Court Road, dots and squiggles. 
 Designed by Eduardo Paolozzi. 
 A mystery. 
 But supposed, to evoke the inner workings of the electrical goods sold by so many shops in the road up there. 
 No refurbishment at all at Oval on the grim, dank Northern Line. 
 Not a tiled cricket bat or a profile of Surrey's fast-bowling demon of yesteryear, Geoff Arnold, to be seen. 
 Stuck on a Northern Line train between Tooting Beck and Balham, a gaggle of lads running amok and jeering with lighted fags. 
 Do you tell them that smoking is banned on the Underground? 
 Do you remind them of Angela Williams, the first person to be prosecuted for smoking on the tube or of Paul Deiring, the first person to be jailed for smoking on the tube (he couldn't pay his &pound;25 fine) or do you make like Eric Butler, the Bernard Goetz of the Victoria Line, who, in 1987, mocked and taunted by drunken youths, retaliated with a sword-stick and was punished in the courts for his efforts. 
 No, of course you don't. 
 You keep your peace. 
 A ND you resist all eye contact, remembering the words of barrister Caradog Morgan who earlier this year, in defending one Victoria Carrington, freelance insurance consultant accused of assaulting two fellow passengers because they had joggled her newspaper and dared to look at her right in the face, said, &bquo;There is a convention on the Underground that people do not look each other in the eye.&equo; 
 Jammed down here between Tooting Bec and Balham on a train that's going nowhere, with no reason given why, one can dread all sorts of things. 
 One thinks of the Moorgate crash in 1975 which killed 42 people and seriously injured 75; one thinks of the Goodge Street fire of 1981 and, inevitably, King's Cross. 
 One thinks of the stories of child muggers bearing sharp knives, driven below by a greater police presence upstairs, of the Underground &bquo;acid fiend&equo; who squirts hydrochloric acid on people's legs before making his escape, of steamers, hip-hop-styled persons perpetrating economy-sized thefts. 
 Whatever happened to the Guardian Angels? 
 One thinks of the religious maniac who gripped one's hand too firmly, hours earlier, on the Metropolitan Line and asked one, sincerely, to &bquo;repent,&equo; of the strange fellow who took umbrage at the book one was reading-The Boss; J. Edgar Hoover And The Great American Inquisition-and accused one, for some unaccountable reason, of being no better than Norman Tebbit. 
 One looks up at the cheery advertisement that reads &bquo;Lonely? 
 Afraid? 
 Need Hope? 
 Call The Helpline (0442 69123/4/5)&equo; and rather wishes they had telephones aboard these rumbling cars. 
 One thinks, oh, God, I might die down here. 
 A victim of the &bquo;smouldering&equo; that closes stations daily (between October 1 and November 12 this year, &bquo;smouldering&equo; -a fire or smoke alert on the Underground- caused the closure of King's Cross on no less than 14 occasions. 
 Oh, God, I might die down here. 
 Please let me be remembered by something more adequate, less apologetic than the plaque, brown, one foot by two, up there on the wall by the Euston Road exit at King's Cross: &bquo;In Memory Of/The Thirty One People/Who Lost Their Lives/In The King's Cross/Underground Fire Of/18th November 1987.&equo; 
 Alongside is a garish sticker saying KEEP THESE PREMISES TIDY. 
 It is old, this Underground. 
 Engineer Peter William Barlow sank the first hole in the ground on Tower Hill in 1869. 130 years on we've got creaking trains that have been in service for 30 years and more. 
 The tunnels, given to us by Victorians and Edwardians, are slim, with no twin-tracking-that's why we can't have an all-night service like New York's; the tracks have to be walked for maintenance and defluffing nightly. 
 It has long been mismanaged, this Underground, and lacking in public subsidies. 
 No subway system in the world (save Hong Kong's) makes a profit; in Rome, 82 per cent of public transport operating costs are met by public subsidy, in Paris, 52 per cent. 
 In London it's 30 per cent and falling. 
 In London they are determined to break even without outside assistance-even if this means raising fares to ease congestion. 
 &bquo;What we would like to do,&equo; says Dennis Tunnicliffe, &bquo;is slow down the rate of growth because my system is full. 
 We actually close it every morning at up to six stations and deny people entry. 
 To be safe it has to be rationed. 
 It is either going to be physically rationed or price rationed&hellip; prices are too low anyway, since we still have to have an operating subsidy, and that is not in line with the long-term political trend&hellip;&equo; 
 So, a yearly 10 per cent rise in fares for the next five years. 
 A CRUMBLING network the size of Belgium; 2.7 million passengers a day; the average Londoner's travelling time to work 52 minutes and rising by several seconds each week. 
 Margaret Thatcher advises us to walk to our offices. 
 Margaret Thatcher might possibly be right. 
 But then we might miss out on Dennis Carthy, the fellow who used to take to the Tube dressed in a bra, a blouse and fishnet stockings and entertain customers on the Bakerloo Line with tricks that involved a teddy bear, a pistol and a six-foot python. 
 The busker who plays Chariots Of Fire on a Casio organ at Bank would leave it in a trice if only he could think of some other way of turning a penny. 
 It's not the police-who move him on regularly, arrest him occasionally- that he loathes so much: it is the public. 
 Last night his hourly wage, about &pound;8 in loose change was nicked from under his nose by scavenging ragamuffins. 
 The night before, a well-dressed elderly woman reeled towards him clutching a half-eaten burger and threw up all over his instrument. 
 Took him hours to clean it up and, since then, the pitch and tone have been all askew. 
 &bquo;Some of them are okay,&equo; he says of his audience. 
 &bquo;Most of them stink.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have you ever taken part in a fire drill,&equo; I ask a ticket collector at a station on the Jubilee Line (which was supposed to be called the Fleet Line until the GLC's Horace Cutler decided to change it in deference to the Queen at a cost of &pound;50,000). 
 &bquo;Why? 
 Are you on fire? 
 Ha ha!&equo; he replies; &bquo;I'll spit on you, if you like! 
 &bquo;I hate the public because they're so rude. 
 I hate the management. 
 I'd like to be on the lovely buses. 
 By the way, the fare from West Kensington is 90p, not 60p. 
 You owe me 30p.&equo; 
 I cough up and march towards the escalator. 
 A sign: &bquo;We're sorry that this escalator has been out of use for so long&hellip;&equo; 
 The average Tube-goer's travelling time to work is 52 minutes and rising by several seconds every week. 
 Margaret Thatcher advises us to walk to our offices. 
 Margaret Thatcher might possibly be right. 
 PAGE t2 
 Rugby Union No rest for Bath. 
 By Robert Armstrong 
 SWANSEA and Bath have chosen their strongest available sides for today's Anglo-Welsh clash at St Helen's even though key players from both clubs are involved in national squad sessions in Portugal and Lanzarote next week. 
 But Harlequins, who have seven players in the England squad, will put out a much weakened side against Cardiff, who are also weakened, at the Stoop Memorial Ground. 
 Mike Teague will miss Gloucester's match against Bridgend at the Brewery Field, but the Lions and England forward will turn out in the home game against Moseley on New Year's Day. 
 Teague, who joins England's 28-man squad for the trip to Lanzarote next Wednesday, is eager to gain as much competitive action as possible after a three-month lay-off with a shoulder injury. 
 Swansea include an 18-year-old full-back, Geraint Davies, from the Welsh junior club Bryncoch, in place of the injured Mark Wyatt. 
 Robin Jones keeps his place at open-side flanker where he has played in Swansea's last three matches in the absence of another injury victim Alan Reynolds. 
 Bath have selected Tim Reeman, a local schoolmaster, at fly-half in place of their captain Stuart Barnes who has a persistent calf injury. 
 Nick Maslen replaces the blind-side flanker John Hall who is unavailable, while the United lock Martin Haag wins his place on merit in preference to John Morrison. 
 Cardiff, who play host to Bath next Saturday, today face an improvised Harlequins team that lacks nine first-choice players, including six of the pack. 
 Paul Ackford, a police inspector, will be on duty at Clapham, Winterbottom is nursing a shoulder injury and Edwards, Olver, Mullins and Skinner are all taking a rest. 
 The half-backs Luxton (shoulder injury) and Pears are also missing. 
 &bquo;We have important league and cup games coming up next month in addition to national squad weekends, so it's understandable that some of our players don't wish to take their chances in a club fixture,&equo; said the Quins' press officer Alex Saward yesterday. 
 Cardiff will be without their international hooker Ian Watkins, who was sent off in the game with Pontypridd on Boxing Day, and also the Lions three-quarter Mike Hall whose former club Bridgend have not yet granted him a transfer. 
 Hall put in his request last week, but the Bridgend secretary is away on holiday, and the club committee has yet to meet to discuss the issue. 
 However, the loose-head prop Mike Griffiths, another Lions and Wales player who has left Bridgend to join Cardiff, will play against Harlequins. 
 Coventry entertain Pontypridd in one of their last fixtures before the All Blacks' coach Alex Wyllie takes over the Midlands Second Division team for six weeks from Tony Hunt. 
 Wyllie will arrive early in the New Year. 
 Blunt instrument hits Oslo. 
 By Robert Pryce 
 MICAH BLUNT put in an early claim for the Player of the Tournament award at the World Invitation Club Championships last night. 
 The 6ft 9in American centre scored 31 points, gathered several fistfuls of rebounds, hit two one-handed slams and threw in a three-pointer to lead Kingston into the semi-finals of the men's competition with a 112-62 win over an underpowered team from Oslo. 
 Blunt established his playing qualifications with the Green Wave &mdash; the nickname of a university team in New Orleans rather than a synonym for nausea. 
 There is some kind of epidemic of withdrawals going around Crystal Palace this year, and the Norwegians are not the only side to have suffered. 
 The late non-appearance of Stroitel Kiev, the Soviet champions, from the men's tournament and BCN Sao Paulo, the holders and Brazilian champions, from the women's has left the line-up looking sicklier than ever. 
 Kingston are not immune either. 
 Martin Clark looked a little green, though he forced down 20 points, and they missed Joel Moore, whose ligament injury will take at least two more weeks to heal. 
 Last night, when the 5ft 9in Alton Byrd took a rest the 6ft 8in Alan Cunningham took over as their playmaking guard. 
 &bquo;I mean,&equo; said Kevin Cadle, the Kingston coach, &bquo;we are in trouble.&equo; 
 Richard Rellford, a monomaniac dunker with Maccabi Rishon, promises them more trouble in this evening's semi-final. 
 The 6ft 7in American slammed in 46 points as the Israelis beat Brixton Topcats in last night's other quarter-final 99-89. 
 Solent Stars, last in the Carlsberg League but unhappy with its organisation, have decided to withdraw at the end of the season. 
 Table Tennis Douglas aims to fizz past a flat champion. 
 DESMOND DOUGLAS, at the age of 34, is unofficial favourite to win back the National Top 12 title at Clacton-on-Sea today from Alan Cooke. 
 This reflects his enduring excellence as well as the titleholder's puzzling lack of recent form, having established himself top of the domestic pack last season, writes Richard Jago. 
 Cooke needs a return of the effervescence that earlier in the year made him England number one, English national champion and Commonwealth champion all in a short space of time. 
 Only nine days ago he lost the Macartney and Dowie Classic when Douglas defeated him in the semi-final, and the loss of another title today could be extremely damaging to morale. 
 Carl Prean, another former holder of the Top 12 who beat Douglas in the final of the Classic, is absent in Germany, which should give Cooke a better chance to revive his fortunes, although he does have two talented teenagers Matthew Syed and Michael O'Driscoll in his group. 
 Sailing Bond gets his reward for 20 years of trying. 
 By Bob Fisher 
 ALAN BOND has steered his 83ft maxi-rater Drumbeat to line honours in the Sydney-Hobart Race. 
 The huge yacht sailed up the Derwent accompanied by hundreds of spectator craft to take the winner's gun early yesterday evening. 
 It was evidently a popular win for the troubled businessman. 
 The crowds at Constitution Dock cheered the owner who has been trying for 20 years to score a major success in this race. 
 Bond was smiling, presumably at the thought that he had beaten his long-time rival Syd Fischer whose 79ft Ragamuffin finished next. 
 The outcome of the race, on handicap &mdash; and the NorTel Southern Cross Cup &mdash; was far from settled, although it is acknowledged that the New South Wales team will win after Britain's Juno IV retired with a broken boom. 
 The front-runners on corrected time change with every position report. 
 Harold Cudmore, skippering the chartered 50-footer Heaven Can Wait, is poised to claim a race win for Britain as some consolation for the team. 
 He is being pressed by the Hong Kong yacht Foo 2, the former Jamarella of Britain's winning Admiral's Cup team, and Cyclone from the New South Wales team. 
 The increasing wind was expected to help the smaller boats, and the leaders for most of the race may be deposed when the handicaps are computed. 
 True Blue (Western Australia) and Sagacious (Australia) were best placed among the one-tonners along with Eddie Warden Owen and Canon Express. 
 Cricket The Whale spouts some fighting talk as West Indies loom on the horizon. 
 Frank Keating finds Eddie Hemmings in optimistic mood 
 THE HONEST old hired hand who has seen it all looks you unwaveringly in the eye. 
 He is bushy-tailed and defiantly optimistic for the new decade &mdash; which in his case starts early when the still battered England cricket team leave for the West Indies in less than three weeks. 
 Eddie Hemmings, suddenly England's senior spin bowler, will celebrate his 41st birthday on the tour. 
 So you expect him at least to be coyly cagey about strong predictions. 
 Not a bit of it. 
 &bquo;Our preparations have gone so well that none of us can wait to get there and begin in earnest. 
 We are determined to come back in the spring showing the country that we have some really talented and fighting cricketers in England. 
 Win or lose, I guarantee we will not return with our tails between our legs, but with a hell of a lot of dignity and applause from you blokes. 
 You see.&equo; 
 In what seems a courageously wild effort to match fire with fire, England have packed their side with fast bowlers of unproven calibre, so Hemmings's wise-owl control and skill, patience, duty and courage promises to be crucially tested. 
 The sharp-fingered Cockney apprentice, Keith Medlycott, is the only other spinner in the party. 
 Caribbean cemeteries are littered, you might say, with tweaker's tombstones. 
 The place is a particular graveyard for off-spinners. 
 Just before a tyro Pat Pocock played his first Test there, over 21 years ago, Tom Graveney cruelly pointed to the Bridgetown sightscreen and said to the tremulous off-spinner: &bquo;Oh, look lad, it's still peppered with those little red dots from that time Clyde Walcott got after Jim Laker ten years ago. 
 Oh yes, boy, they really dine on off-spin over here.&equo; 
 And after two painfully brave campaigns for the cause, John Emburey's decision this time to cash in the krugerrands is fairly understandable. 
 So step forward, Edward Ernest Hemmings. 
 He is thrilled to. 
 Hemmings has, in fact, played a first-class game in the West Indies. 
 And, incredibly, remains the only bowler in history to have taken all ten wickets in an innings in the Caribbean. 
 So he is already a celebrity in island cricket. 
 September 26-27, 1982: West Indies X1 v Rest of the World at Kingston, Jamaica: West Indies 419, EE Hemmings 49.3-14-175-10. 
 Who was in that side you bowled out? 
 &bquo;Oh heck, I can't for the life of me remember.&equo; 
 His first five wickets, for starters, were Greenidge, Haynes, Rowe, Lloyd and Dujon. 
 &bquo;Oh, really,&equo; says Eddie, matter of fact, even slightly embarrassed. 
 &bquo;Just one of those days. 
 I had one end, the seamers swapped around at the other. 
 The bats just decided to smash me around the island, and for every bag of boundaries they hit they then made a mistake. 
 All history now, and I'd swap those ten any day for five in an innings in a couple of proper Tests this winter.&equo; 
 That feat, and just two single deliveries, one as a bowler, one as a bat, have already put Hemmings in the all-time, gold-leafed parchment scrolls. 
 Since he began first-class cricket way back in the mists of 1966 he has bowled some 80,000 balls and taken well over 1,200 wickets. 
 The world knows about just one, when, with nerveless panache, he cut down Viv Richards in most merciless swagger to win England the quarter-final of the last World Cup in India &mdash; with the daring of, it looked at the time, a schoolboy's lob. 
 &bquo;He can be impossible to bowl against. 
 He'd just hit me for two huge sixes, then slapped me savagely through the covers. 
 The game could be lost inside five minutes with him like this. 
 I go back to my mark. 
 I've got to contain him somehow. 
 Just got to fire it in, haven't I? 
 Stands to reason. 
 So I give it even more air than my usual slower one. 
 And, blimey, it turns and bounces too and that was that.&equo; 
 Richards b Hemmings 51. 
 England won by 34 runs. 
 As an improvising batsman, of course, his immortal shot was the joyous, off-carved, square, slaphappy thing by which Notts beat Essex in the Benson and Hedges final at Lord's last July. 
 Last ball, John Lever to bowl. 
 Two ageing champions, born within four days of each other in February 1949. 
 &bquo;He knew and I knew, the obvious thing for him was a yorker. 
 But, because it was so obvious, would it be a yorker? 
 It was like a goalie guessing at a penalty. 
 I had to make up my mind before his arm came over. 
 I did. 
 Before he bowls it, my back leg moves away to get ready for the carve. 
 So I guessed right; sheer luck. 
 If it hadn't been a yorker I'd have looked an absolute idiot, I wouldn't have been in the same street, let alone cricket ground. 
 &bquo;I looked for JK after. 
 I think he just slid off. 
 Obviously I felt for him, I wouldn't have been too delighted if our positions had been reversed; and they could so easily have been. 
 There's a hell of a lot of luck in cricket, you know.&equo; 
 Like when Hemmings embarked on a second career. 
 He played, with increasing unhappiness, for Warwickshire until 1978. 
 &bquo;I packed it in. 
 No drive, no ambition; the team was just turning up to go through the motions; and behind the scenes, lots of devious insider stuff.&equo; 
 He prepared to work for his father in the building trade, or even go back to college. 
 &bquo;Then out of the blue, Nottingham came for me. 
 It was a revelation. 
 Clive Rice threw me the ball and just said: &bquo;Right, get on with it&equo;. 
 He basically just told me to be myself. 
 He does his 110 per cent utmost to win, but then enjoys a half of beer and a non-stop cricketing chinwag after the game. 
 Clive was a stupendous captain.&equo; 
 Within three years, his 90 wickets helped bring Trent Bridge its first championship in over half a century. 
 It led to the first of his nine England caps, mostly on tour, where his tubby enthusiasm and &mdash; from behind the ropes anyway &mdash; his seemingly unathletic, but jauntily optimistic matelot's gait have endeared him to crowds. 
 His 5ft 10in and 13 stone are rather baggily proportioned and he has answered to &bquo;The Whale&equo;. 
 In Australia six years ago they released a squealingly plump piglet onto the field, with the legend &bquo;Eddie&equo; daubed on its side. 
 At Edgbaston, in his early days, it is hard to recall him as the skinny lad in wire spectacles who tried too hard to bowl at medium pace, and when he became depressed at his form, came out in eczema rashes and asthma wheezes. 
 (The Sun, the other day, tried a typical scary smear: England Pick Asthmatic. 
 Eddie laughed: &bquo;The one place I won't remotely get asthma is in the Caribbean sun.&equo;) 
 For the last month he has relished driving through the cold and the foggy damp from his Nottingham home to the Headingley indoor nets a few days a week for practice with the rest of the England team. 
 &bquo;It's been absolutely fascinating, a revelation, to hear Geoff Boycott coaching the batsmen. 
 He's still very intense about the art, still loves his cricket with a passion. 
 Oh yes, just like him, we're going out there to win, to accept the challenge with a will. 
 I promise you, you just wait and see. 
 And remember, old Eddie told you first&hellip;.&equo; 
 Robert Pryce on soccer's quotes of the year Meat, Melchester and mistresses. 
 January 1989. 
 If we think they are easy meat we will end up with egg on our faces. 
 Bradford's manager Terry Dolan on Bristol C. 
 I don't get involved with team matters now that we've got a manager who can manage. 
 Ken Bates confesses. 
 Football is a harsh mistress. 
 Sutton's manager Barrie Williams after their 8-0 FA Cup fourth-round defeat at Norwich. 
 Looks like I won't be on Wogan on Monday. 
 Sutton's Lenny Dennis. 
 February He turns the six-yard box into a cartoon strip. 
 Malcolm Macdonald on West Ham's goalkeeper Allan McKnight. 
 He had such class he unsettled my stomach. 
 Torquay's manager Cyril Knowles on Manchester United's winger Lee Sharpe. 
 March. 
 We're now expecting an offer from Melchester Rovers. 
 Mo Johnston's agent Bill McMurdo after his client scored both goals in Scotland's 2-0 win over France. 
 I was grateful to be called anything at all. 
 &bquo;Meatloaf&equo; would have been okay. 
 Vinny &bquo;Psycho&equo; Jones on his nickname. 
 April In footballing terms, two of them are not even on solids. 
 Wigan's manager Ray Mathias on his back four (average age 19). 
 May We tried to keep things tranquillo, as they say in Sheffield. 
 Wednesday's manager Ron Atkinson. 
 July. 
 Football is a capricious mistress. 
 Barrie Williams on retiring. 
 August I will not accept a team of gangsters directed by a mental retard. 
 Jose Eduardo Guinle, manager of the Copacabana Palace hotel, turning away the Chilean national team. 
 September. 
 They weren't just head and shoulders better but chest and waist too. 
 Palace's Ian Wright on losing 9-0 at Liverpool. 
 The last time we got a penalty away from home, Christ was a carpenter. 
 Lennie Lawrence. 
 November We have not attacked better all season. 
 In the first half it was a case of premature ejaculation. 
 Leeds' manager Howard Wilkinson after 2-1 win over Plymouth. 
 There is no crisis here. 
 Just panic. 
 Millwall's manager John Docherty after seven games without a win. 
 He was of the impression that his findings could overturn the Act. 
 Eminent and learned the judge may be, but he cannot set himself up as God over all football. 
 John Carlisle MP on Lord Justice Taylor, leading the Hillsborough inquiry. 
 December I want to be the longest-serving manager under Peter Swales. 
 Howard Kendall's ambition as the new manager of Manchester City. 
 Juventus? 
 The way Bully played on Wednesday night you must mean Fray Bentos. 
 Aston Villa's manager Graham Taylor on being told that a foreign club was interested in signing Steve Bull. 
 WEEKEND HIGHLIGHTS. 
 Aston Villa v Arsenal With Liverpool back at the top of the First Division a draw will do neither of their immediate pursuers much good. 
 Bould, out with a groin injury all season, is in their squad and, with Marwood doubtful, Davis may continue his resurgence. 
 Villa, who have won nine of their last 12 League games, hope to have Price fit after Achilles trouble. 
 Crystal Palace v Norwich City Palace continue to flirt with danger and Norwich, who remain one of the best footballing sides in the League, have Fleck in their squad after knee and back injuries. 
 Derby County v Coventry City Coventry have Regis back in their squad after &bquo;flu but are still missing Kilcline, Peake and the suspended Billing. 
 After their little November surge Derby are slipping again. 
 Even a point would be welcome now. 
 Liverpool v Charlton Athletic It would be typical of the way Charlton's luck is going at the moment were Barnes and Hansen to return to the Liverpool side after injury. 
 Charlton have Pates back in their defence but after seven League matches without a win cannot hold out much hope of getting off the bottom this afternoon. 
 Luton v Chelsea With Elstrup out of action following a cartilage operation, Harford is set to make his first appearance in Luton's attack for seven months. 
 Beasant's goalkeeping spared Chelsea another drubbing at Crystal Palace on Boxing Day and so long as their strikers remain on target they could get a decent result today. 
 Erland Johnsen, the Norwegian signed from Bayern Munich, is expected to help take the strain in Chelsea's defence. 
 Manchester City v Millwall There is quite a bustle at Maine Road in the wake of Howard Kendall's arrival as manager. 
 Ward, newly signed from West Ham, joins Allen in the City attack this afternoon, the pair replacing Morley and Bishop, who have gone to Upton Park. 
 Millwall did not sign Goddard in time to put him straight into their side. 
 So, with Sheringham still unfit, Cascarino will have to soldier on with inexperienced support. 
 QPR v Everton After a couple of wins QPR have found a familiar rut and Everton, who arrested their decline with a win at Derby, will be hoping for something similar at Shepherds Bush. 
 Then again, Everton's goal at the Baseball Ground was scored against the run of play and Falco can punish any lapses today. 
 Southampton v Sheff Wed Arsenal and Liverpool have lost at The Dell this season, so what price lowly Wednesday? 
 In fact Ron Atkinson's team are playing well and, with Ray Wallace out of the Southampton defence, will be confident of improving a wretched away record, especially if the other Atkinson starts hitting the target. 
 Tottenham v Nottm Forest Brian Clough's 1,000th League game as a manager and a fixture he will expect to win, seeing that Forest have beaten Spurs on three of their last four visits to White Hart Lane. 
 Tottenham have Van Den Hauwe back in defence. 
 Hodge, a former Spur, could be Forest's match winner, or match saver, this afternoon. 
 Wimbledon v Manchester U That hard-won point at Liverpool a week ago must seem awfully distant now as Alex Ferguson approaches the most critical period of his managerial career at Old Trafford. 
 Bryan Robson is still out with a groin strain and doubtful for Monday's game against QPR. 
 Danny Wallace is missing with a hamstring injury. 
 No doubt Ferguson wants his team to make a fight of it, though presumably on more civilised lines than the tunnel punch-up which followed their last match here. 
 David Lacey 
 THE EIGHTIES IN PERSPECTIVE. 
 David Davies treasures some memories from a decade when a Spanish genius inspired British and continental players to a period of unparalleled success 
 Europe's dynasty reigns in a golden age of golf 
 FROM time to time all games go through a golden era; a time when great players perform great deeds on the great stages of sport. 
 The trick is to recognise it while it is still happening &mdash; to relish it, embrace it and know that, in the nature of things, it cannot last. 
 The seaside photographer who promises &bquo;Memories to treasure&equo; with every happy snap might have been present at every major golfing occasion in the Eighties as the players of the age showed their capacity for repeating and exceeding the highwater marks of the very recent past. 
 Through the decade the glories of the game have been gloriously demonstrated. 
 They are not yet over, of course, these gilded moments. 
 The players who have strolled through our consciousness these past 10 years are mostly with us yet, but whatever they do in the Nineties will not resound in the way that their achievements of the Eighties did. 
 We cannot win the Ryder Cup, the Curtis Cup, the Walker Cup in the United States for the first time again. 
 We cannot have a Briton winning the US Masters for the first time again, nor a Briton putting the green jacket on yet another Briton for the first time again. 
 These are firsts, as was the winning of the US Women's Open in successive years by first a British professional, then a European. 
 Everywhere one looked there were unaccustomed trophies on display and, when the visiting Ryder Cup team arrived at The Belfry in the last few moments of the decade, they were greeted by the sight of the Ryder, Curtis and Walker Cups, knowing that the last name on them was not that of the United States of America. 
 There could have been a fourth cup there, for Great Britain and Ireland had also won the Eisenhower Trophy for the World Amateur Team Championships, providing also the winner of the individual section. 
 Golf, from nothing, has become in the Eighties the most successful sport, internationally, practised in these islands. 
 In that decade European men won almost a quarter of the 40 major championships played and for most of it dominated the top ten in the world rankings. 
 It would be too simple to suggest that all this was brought about by one man. 
 But the almost mesmeric brilliance of Severiano Ballesteros first of all broke down what had appeared to be insurmountable barriers and then allowed him to charge through the gaps, devastating anything in his path. 
 Ballesteros took world golf by the scruff of the neck and shook it until it reformed into patterns more nearly to his liking. 
 It was often not an attractive process but, in succeeding, he cleared the way for other Europeans to become the world-class players they are now. 
 Ballesteros is an extraordinary character. 
 At base there is an enormous arrogance and an overweening ambition. 
 The dates of the World Cup do not suit? 
 Change them. 
 The Ryder Cup will not come to Spain in 1993? 
 &bquo;I won't play.&equo; 
 The American Tour changed the qualification rule to one dictated by Ballesteros himself and then refused to change it again when Ballesteros realised he had got it wrong. 
 &bquo;Stupido,&equo; said Ballesteros darkly, &bquo;they will pay.&equo; 
 It is possible to harden the heart against a Ballesteros in these moods but then he goes and does something sublime on the course, hits a shot that no one else would conceive, let alone execute, and one realises here is genius in sport. 
 He has been European golf's generalissimo and it is appropriate that the decade opened to the sound of a Ballesteros devastation. 
 In April 1980, at Augusta, Georgia, he led the US Masters by 10 shots with nine holes to play. 
 He won, as do thoroughbreds, easing up. 
 American golf knew then that things would never be the same again. 
 Ballesteros was 23. 
 He was the first European to win a Masters title and the difference between him doing that and Tony Jacklin winning the US Open in 1970 is that by the Eighties there were other talents ready to be inspired by the Ballesteros achievement. 
 Sandy Lyle, Nick Faldo, Bernhard Langer, all looked up and took note. 
 Ballesteros won the Masters again in &bquo;83, the Open Championship in &bquo;84 and, while all this was hugely satisfactory, there was a longing for a winner from closer to home. 
 He appeared in July &bquo;85, ambling down the 18th fairway at Royal St George's. 
 He arrived at his drive, discussed the second shot, decided on a club and then, before taking it out of the bag, held out his hands in front of his caddie and said: &bquo;Look, not a tremor.&equo; 
 Sandy Lyle was slightly unlucky that that second shot ran off the green into a depression called Duncan's Hollow, and definitely unlucky that his third shot, which he attempted to finesse, failed by a fraction and ran back to the edge of the green. 
 He fell to his knees, buried his head in the grass, feeling that he had lost his chance in that moment. 
 But he got down in two more, for a bogey five, and then the chasers, Langer and David Graham, found they had run out of puff. 
 Lyle's Open was the first by a Briton since Jacklin in 1969. 
 Lyle issued orders that a marquee be erected in his back garden and on Monday night there was a party, the food being funnelled in as on a conveyor belt from a nearby Chinese restaurant. 
 Faldo gritted his teeth and attended. 
 He was happy enough for Lyle to win; desperately disappointed that he had not yet won a major himself. 
 He was to have to wait until 1987 when, amid great grey curtains of mist and murk, he played one of the greatest of championship courses, Muirfield, by parring every hole in the last round. 
 He hit one of the great five irons, too, at the last hole, a shot that still gives him one of those lovely shivers of success whenever he thinks about it. 
 One each in one of the decade's continuing stories, the rivalry between Lyle and Faldo, but it was only a matter of months before Lyle made it 2-1. 
 The 1988 US Masters had looked, for most of its duration, to be Lyle's. 
 But to the sounds of utter silence from the European section of the Augusta press room, he hit his tee shot at the short 12th into the water, took five and by the 15th had given up his lead. 
 He arrived on the 18th tee needing a par to get into a play-off and, with an extraordinary demonstration of the tension involved, jumped up and down half a dozen times as his tee shot headed inexorably for the bunker on the left. 
 It landed in the sand, hopping on to the upslope and, when Lyle got there, he knew he could hit it the required 140 yards to the pin. 
 In fact he hit it 150 yards, the ball pitched, began to spin back and rolled towards the hole, finishing 10 feet away. 
 The American golf historian Herb Warren Wind has called it the greatest bunker shot in all championship play. 
 The putt for the win was, of course, holed. 
 By now Ballesteros had not won a major since St Andrews &bquo;84, but the &bquo;88 Open was at Royal Lytham St Annes, where he had won in &bquo;79. 
 He won again, with one of the most sustainedly brilliant final rounds in the history of the championship. 
 Nick Price, incredibly, started two shots ahead, went round in 69 and lost by two shots to a superb 65. 
 The drama of it was unmatched in the Open in the Eighties, although maybe second to the 1977 Turnberry confrontation between Jack Nicklaus and Tom Watson in the all-time list. 
 Europeans had now won two majors in &bquo;88 and Faldo had nearly won the US Open in between. 
 Only a magnificent sand shot at the 72nd got Curtis Strange into a play-off for his country's national title, although once in it he dominated. 
 Faldo had to wait until the &bquo;89 Masters before he could catch up with Lyle and maybe the picture of him on the 11th green, the second hole of a sudden-death play-off with Scott Hoch, encapsulates Europe's men in the majors in the Eighties. 
 Faldo, who had holed a motorway of putts in the final round, holed yet another on that green, up went his arms in a triumphant &bquo;V&equo; and an Augustan decade had ended as it had begun, with a European as Master. 
 Lyle, as defending champion, had to be-jacket Faldo, and coincidentally it signalled the end of perhaps the finest stretch of golf played by a British golfer. 
 For 133 days in 1988 Lyle had led the US Money List, he had won the Phoenix, Greensboro and Masters titles and in the first months of 1989 he twice came second. 
 It was an unsustainable pace and Lyle spent the rest of &bquo;89 in seclusion. 
 The decade saw the emergence of three European women professionals capable of playing with the world's best and, better yet, two of them proving it. 
 Laura Davies won the US Women's Open in 1987 and such is the power that she generates that any time she plays really well she wins. 
 But whether she plays well appears to be a matter of chance. 
 She is totally untaught, will not listen and makes so many basic errors in her set-up alone that consistency is obviously impossible. 
 She was succeeded as US champion by Liselotte Neumann, the Swede from a club in Finspang where people put their green fee into a milk churn and just go out and play. 
 The third woman of world class is Marie Laure de Lorenzi, who wins everything in Europe but has yet to be persuaded that America is worth a detour. 
 She will need to go if she is to take what would seem to be a deserved place in the record books. 
 Golf, the most individual of sports, is never more demanding than when played in its team format and, when Sam Torrance holed the winning birdie putt at The Belfry in &bquo;85, and very soon afterwards burst into tears, he began a sequence that would be rejected out of hand by any self-respecting editor of the Boys&equo; Own Paper. 
 Of the eight contests against America from then to the end of 1989, the United States won only two. 
 Two Ryder Cup matches were won outright, another halved; the Curtis Cup team went to Hutchinson, Kansas in 1986 and won, and defended successfully at Royal St George's, while in August of this year the Walker Cup team, quite improbably, went to Atlanta and won the Walker Cup. 
 The excitement in all of them was close to unbearable. 
 If Ballesteros was partially responsible for the all those individual successes, then Jacklin may deserve the credit not just for the Ryder Cup but for demonstrating that inspirational leadership, combined with an infinite capacity for detail, can produce a team better than the sum of its parts. 
 Diane Bailey, the Curtis Cup captain, seized on the Jacklin example and so did Geoff Marks and all around him at the Walker Cup in &bquo;89, and their teams responded magnificently. 
 In Kansas in &bquo;86 the American women were outplayed, the win no less thrilling for that. 
 But the following year the Ryder Cup men had to go to Muirfield Village &mdash; Jack's patch &mdash; the course and club he created, to play a team captained by the Golden Bear himself. 
 For British golf fanatics, there has perhaps never been a more nerve-wracking day than when, with only four points to get in the final singles, there was never a moment when it appeared likely that we could get them. 
 But let us glory in a statistic for once. 
 Of the 12 games that went to the 18th hole during the course of the match overall, only one was won by an American and, as matters got tighter and tighter, the home team got worse and worse. 
 Dan Pohl, Larry Mize and even Ben Crenshaw all made hopeless hashes of the last hole, Eamonn Darcy holed the putt of his life, Ballesteros was obsessively snuffing out Strange and shortly after that something nice took place in the woodshed. 
 It was, more accurately, a wood-built open-air refreshment centre and it was taken over by Europe's supporters. 
 They sang, they danced on the tables, they called for their heroes and their heroes went to them. 
 It was a wonderful hour or more and later Ian Woosnam called for a knighthood for Jacklin. 
 It was not, however, Sir Tony Jacklin who produced the halved match, and the retained Ryder Cup, at The Belfry this year, although two of his players were Sandy Lyle MBE and Nick Faldo MBE. 
 Nor, despite the merit of the achievement, did the Ryder Cup team get the vote when the Golf Writers&equo; Association announce their selection for their annual trophy this year. 
 That went to the Walker Cup team. 
 Given the strength of American college golf, with its state subsidies in the form of golf scholarships, the Walker Cup has always looked the least likely of the three team competitions to be won by Great Britain and Ireland. 
 But by the end of the decade they had absorbed the lessons learned by the other teams, and had accepted that, if they played as well as they could, they could win. 
 They picked a proper team, not having done so two years previously when they incomprehensibly left out their two best players, Peter McEvoy and Garth McGimpsey. 
 But even with a lead requiring only 1 &frac12; points from the final singles the match nearly got away. 
 The necessary points came in the shape of three halved games, with Andrew Hare recovering from two down with two to play and Jim Milligan, playing Jay Sigel in the anchor match, was two down and three to play. 
 Sports Editors fretted and printers fumed as the match went on and on into the British night, with Milligan winning the 17th by chipping in, to go to all square. 
 The 18th saw Sigel, who in his time has won 15 United States titles, miss the green, miss a little chip and miss a putt, allowing Milligan to halve the hole with a bogey five. 
 The GB and Ireland team went wild, rushing across the green to swamp their Scottish saviour and the celebrations went on long into the night, and the morning too. 
 Their win, in so many ways, epitomised the Eighties on this side of the Atlantic. 
 They had won, as they will always have to, against the odds, but they did it by capitalising on their best players, by utilising every ounce of available experience and by trying as hard as they knew how. 
 Those are good, sound formulas for success, and they worked, to the greater glory of golf, throughout the Eighties. 
 A Year to Remember When in doubt sonolidate: gems from our electronic waste-paper basket. 
 LET us make it clear from the outset, writes Jack Massarik, that the correspondents, copytakers and editorial staff who contribute to your sports pages are all doing an absolutely splendid job. 
 It is a complete mystery to everyone how the following gems came to light in 1989. 
 But at least none of them saw the light of print &mdash; until today's souvenir edition. 
 GLORIOUS FOR SOME High achievement Northamptonshire's all-rounder Richard Williams will launch his benefit year on Sunday by jumping out of an aeroplane over Bedfordshire. 
 Useful pedigree CHICAGO (AP) &mdash; The Queen of England will race a horse in the United States for the first time in 35 years at Arlington International Racecourse. 
 Cool customer This he will do from the scrum-half position in the now customary French fashion while the nominal scrum-half, Berbizier, froze the ball in from touch. 
 Branching out Jo Durie, the British No.2, gave a pleasantly fluent performance near to the rhododendron bushes on an outside court. 
 &hellip; DISAPPOINTING FOR OTHERS Drummed out Probyn was automatically ruled out when he was diagnosed by the Irish team doctor, Mick Molloy, as suffering from percussion. 
 Precious McKenzie? 
 A short lifter had accounted for Hardie on Saturday. 
 Patience rewarded Nowhere are Yorkshire's technical shortcomings more recognisable than with Sharp, recalled after three centuries in the second team. 
 Had a good innings It looks as though Ian Butcher may be forced to retire because of injury at the age of 226. 
 Rubbish Fadeev clung to the world championship lead despite falling on a tripe loop in yesterday's original programme. 
 Got a nasty kick &bquo;The concentration of the man is unbelievable. 
 If he was a bit deadlier in the balls he'd have been world champion.&equo; 
 Galley slave During the Admiral's Cup he (Lawrie Smith) was released to be starving helmsman and tactician aboard the top-scoring Jamarella. 
 Beyond the fringe Nicky Mason, who has been on the fringes of England's best men's team for 30 years, showed during England's outstanding 5-1 victory that he can still&hellip; 
 DEEP THINKERS Forward planning O'Donovan also offers the simple but profound thought that it is women who will be giving birth to the next generation of Rugby League players. 
 I dunk, therefore I am The Chicago Bulls fired coach Doug Collins on Thursday, citing philosophical differences during the three years he headed the National Basketball Association club. 
 Pull the other one Chelsea captain Graham Roberts has a sceptic foot and is very doubtful. 
 What's up, doc? 
 The doctor also told of a four-hour meeting with a group of Irish throwers, who asked his advice on how to improve the efficiency of their drug programme. 
 Sure thing It seems that the only certain thing about the race is that it will be run at Doncaster. 
 (Harry Heymer on the St Leger). 
 UNSUITABLE FOR A FAMILY NEWSPAPER Veil of secrecy &bquo;You could see right through his trousers,&equo; said the British judge Vanessa Riley. 
 &bquo;Fadeev was not a sight I would want my eight-year-old to see. 
 It does the sport no good.&equo; 
 Orgy of violence AP &mdash; Rome police intervened and arrested three Lazio rooters. 
 Blazing Saddles Extel Pro cycling &mdash; RAYNER CATCHES AUSSIE BY BEHIND. 
 On the piste 1. 
 He looked up towards the Jungfrau, its golden breasts framed against cerulean blue, and blew it a kiss. 
 &bquo;Beautiful,&equo; he said. 
 2. 
 The Rear entry is convenient and comfortable. 
 But it does not provide the immediate edge control a performer in the highest class demands. 
 Vastly experienced Judges decided in favour of Ritschel in recognition of her strong uchi-mata (inner thigh) attacks, and a couple of dangerous pick-ups made by the West German. 
 QUOTES OF &bquo;89 Yes, Minister &bquo;Mr Moynihan, I know, will join me in congratulating Frank Bruno on his gallant attempt to win the world heavyweight title. 
 The Sports Minister, more than most, knows what it's like to be in with a dangerous hooker.&equo; 
 &mdash; Frankie Taylor to the guest of honour at the British Boxing Writers' Club annual dinner. 
 Cheep shot Of Parrott, Doyle said: &bquo;John's a great home bird.&equo; 
 That shooting The London boxing promoter Mickey Duff said: &bquo;The only thing that worries me at the moment is his speedy recovery.&equo; 
 Boomer Maclean's recovery stemmed from two thunderous winners late in the third game. 
 &bquo;I thought I was out, but played to two shots from out of my backside, and then found that I was in,&equo; he said. 
 SONOLIDATING ON THE ORIGINAL Hard to improve upon In both of yesterday's games England displayed excellent control and built up 6-0 leads before sonolidating. 
 Jag at bay Sweden's Per Eklund ran out of time yesterday after gearbox and electrical problems in his Landseer. 
 Have it your own way 1. 
 As the fastest growing sport in the UK with some 450,000 active participants, it is important that the sport is called by its official title &mdash; &bquo;WINDSUFRING&equo; &mdash; RYA press release. 
 2. 
 Change nationality of Fram Knattspryrnufelagio and give its full name. 
 &mdash; AP. 
 Heavy going at Wigan The start was delayed for 25 minutes to enable the now inevitable lakecomers to find a vacant place. 
 Wing and leg it The security, with its metal detectors and baggage searches, would not have disgraced an El Al chicken counter. 
 Hockey England score 35 goals and win their group with ease. 
 By Pat Rowley 
 ENGLAND'S indoor team, even with Ian Jennings, their recognised goalscorer, being rested, amassed 35 goals in their three group games in the Buttermen indoor tournament held at Maidenhead yesterday. 
 England beat two Buttermen Indoor League Premier Division clubs, Hounslow (14-2) and Teddington (9-7), then won their group by routing Harborne, last season's national quarter-finalists, 12-3 in their last group match. 
 In Jennings's absence Neil Barker, one of this season's England newcomers, took on the chief goalscoring role, ably supported by his captain Andy Halliday. 
 Each scored eight goals, Barker getting five against Hounslow and Halliday four at Teddington's expense. 
 The opposition in England's group was nothing like as strong as they faced in winning the HDM tournament in Holland before Christmas. 
 Only Swansea looked likely to offer them a serious test. 
 Hounslow and Harborne were weakened by calls from Wales. 
 In fact Hounslow could find only eight players for the first match of the tournament and conceded 12 goals against England before the hard-working Hacker opened their account. 
 Teddington had to give up Laslett and Barker to England but put up a spirited performance against the national side. 
 Better finishing enabled England to lead 8-2 by early in the second half. 
 Teddington rallied well but too late to save the game. 
 The bustling Billson, Szwinto and Benzies each had the consolation of scoring twice against England. 
 England's junior team had much more of a struggle in the other group. 
 They were behind throughout the second half against Bromley, but the lethal shooting of Kulbir Takher saved them. 
 He scored his fourth high-quality goal to get them a 6-6 draw with just two seconds remaining. 
 Against Fareham the juniors trailed 2-1 at half-time, but a change of tactics brought them a 6-2 win. 
 The juniors' teamwork suffered from their lack of a genuine middleman. 
 Machin arrives at Barnsley full of promotion promise. 
 By David Hopps and Russell Thomas 
 MEL MACHIN, sacked as Manchester City manager five weeks ago amid accusations that he lacked rapport with the fans, chose his appointment at Barnsley yesterday to parade a new upbeat persona. 
 The man regarded by Peter Swales, at Manchester City, as a little dull, introduced himself at Oakwell by saying: &bquo;It may take a little time, but I can assure you that we will get promotion within three years.&equo; 
 Machin's faith arises from promotion seasons with Norwich (1985-6) and City (1988-9). 
 Two visits to Oakwell, incognito, also persuaded him that a more immediate priority, to move away from the lower reaches of the Second Division, is realisable. 
 Barnsley have won only six League matches all season. 
 Machin has signed a 3 &frac12;-year contract. 
 He intends to expand the coaching staff, although Eric Winstanley, caretaker since Allan Clarke's removal, will be retained. 
 Another South Yorkshire manager signing until the end of the 1992-3 season is Sheffield United's Dave Bassett. 
 He has accepted improved terms for himself and his training and physiotherapy staff. 
 But money remains scarce for team strengthening. 
 Reg Brealey, the club chairman, told shareholders at yesterday's annual meeting that the club still owes &pound;2.3million. 
 Newcastle's attempts to bolster their midfield foundered yesterday when their manager, Jim Smith, failed to reach agreement with Chelsea's Micky Hazard. 
 Paul Goddard will make his Millwall debut &mdash; against his old club, Derby &mdash; on New Year's Day after completing his &pound;800,000 move yesterday following a medical. 
 As Derby bade farewell to one striker, they missed out on another when an ambitious move to bring a Colombian World Cup winger to the Baseball Ground fell through. 
 Leonel Alvarez, rated at about &pound;1 million and expected to play a major part in his country's World Cup campaign, had been lined up initially on loan, but Derby's manager Arthur Cox said: &bquo;We explored the situation, but it wasn't possible.&equo; 
 Trevor Francis is still &bquo;thinking over&equo; an offer to join Luton and is set to make a decision on New Year's Day. 
 Sheffield Wednesday are among those pursuing the former QPR player-manager. 
 Bristol City are offering about &pound;100,000 for Charlton's Welsh international striker Andy Jones. 
 Bristol Rovers are likely to abandon their interest in their former striker Steve White. 
 &bquo;Swindon want to keep White and I'm in no real position to offer the kind of money to make them change their mind,&equo; says Rovers' Gerry Francis. 
 Steve Stoutt, Grimsby's defender, has joined Lincoln for &pound;10,000 and plays today. 
 Hull moved out of the Second Division relegation zone for the first time since mid-September with a 2-1 win over Plymouth last night &mdash; their fourth win in their last six games and their third successive victory under the new manager Stan Ternant. 
 Swan put Hull ahead with a close-range shot, but Plymouth, who dropped their captain, Tommy Tynan, for only the second time in seven years, equalised throughCampbell before Terry hit Hull's winner. 
 Stockport's second victory in four days at Edgeley Park moved them into second position in the Fourth Division. 
 Two goals in eight minutes from their record signing, Keith Edwards, secured a 3-1 win. 
 Romania will go ahead with preparations for next summer's World Cup. 
 Their squad assembles on January 22 to prepare for a series of warm-up matches, including games in France on January 25 and 28. 
 Opponents due to be played in Bucharest include the United States on March 25, Holland on April 25, Brazil on May 12 and Egypt on May 20. 
 Oldham square up to Round. 
 OLDHAM have placed Paul Round, their second-row forward, on the transfer list for &pound;95,000, claiming he is in breach of contract for refusing to train or play for the club, writes Paul Fitzpatrick. 
 Round was signed from St Helens for a club record of &pound;65,000 in the summer of 1987 but he damaged a knee in his only game this season &mdash; at Carlisle in October &mdash; and needed a cartilage operation. 
 Jim Knox, an Oldham director, says that the club have fulfilled their financial obligations to Round and do not know why he is behaving in this way. 
 Oldham have also cut the transfer fees on three players. 
 Terry Flanagan's price has been reduced from &pound;60,000 to &pound;25,000, Kevin Meadows is now on offer at &pound;8,000 and Ian Sanderson at &pound;20,000. 
 The Leeds stand-off or loose forward, David Heron, has received the now customary eight-match ban after being sent off for a high tackle in the Regal Trophy quarter-final replay with Wigan. 
 Widnes, meanwhile, have decided not to appeal against the eight-match suspension imposed on Mike O'Neill. 
 Leeds will play the Australian forward, Cavill Heugh, signed from Barrow, in Monday's match with Hull. 
 To accommodate him on their overseas register Leeds have had to part with Craig Izzard. 
 Paul Loughlin seems likely to play for St Helens against Widnes on Monday, but he will then have an injection for a groin strain and could be out for two weeks. 
 Jonathan Griffiths, also suffering from groin trouble, sees a specialist on January 8. 
 Racing: Richard Baerlein summarises the best of today's betting prospects Smart Tar on course for Mandarin THE MANDARIN Handicap Chase, now sponsored by Save and Prosper, has many happy memories for some and not so happy for others. 
 Fulke Walwyn, who kept on winning it, has by far the best record but he does not have a runner this year. 
 For me, his victory last season with Ten Plus when there were only four runners, convinced me his chaser would win him another Gold Cup, a race he must have won had he not fallen at that fatal third fence from home. 
 This time, Reg Akehurst, who was taken by surprise when Solidasarock won the SGB Chase at Ascot, will be expecting his seven-year-old to improve on that performance in today's event at Newbury and there is no reason why this promising young chaser should not continue to progress. 
 In the Ascot race Brown Windsor was giving him a stone and finished 5 &frac34; lengths behind. 
 The second, Panto Prince, has already enhanced the form, while Brown Windsor meets Solidasarock on 3lb better. 
 Brown Windsor was rated the top novice chaser of last season and began this season in handicap company in great style. 
 He was only just caught by Ghofar in the Hennessy, though the form in that race is not working out too well. 
 Smart Tar in his seasonal debut was sixth in the SGB and will improve on that performance. 
 There were many shrewd operators who backed him for last season's Grand National and they will be doing so again. 
 He has a 5lb advantage with Solidasarock. 
 The top weight, Golden Friend, made a promising seasonal debut when beating The Thinker at Haydock in November but was pulled up on a return visit to the course when Baies beat The Thinker narrowly. 
 Door Latch is unlikely to be ready yet in spite of the good form of his stable-companions. 
 The bottom weight, Polyfemus, has done well since joining Michael Robinson's stable during the summer and he made all the running when beating Charter Hardware 1 &frac12; lengths over three miles, three furlongs at Chepstow earlier in the month. 
 Charter Hardware was far from disgraced when running third to Bonanza Boy in the Coral Welsh National, only losing second place close home to Cool Enough. 
 However, Bonanza Boy won so easily that there really was no second. 
 Smart Tar has a 2lb advantage over Brown Windsor on the running in the SGB but as that was his first outing against three from Brown Windsor and four from Solidasarock, I prefer Smart Tar. 
 Likewise, there were only five runners in last season's L'Oreal Handicap Hurdle won by Afaristoun. 
 This has now gone up to 16 making it the hardest handicap hurdle of the season to date for any punter to try and solve. 
 Let's hope there is not a single dropout to preserve the quarter odds a place, one, two, three and four. 
 David Elsworth's Imperial Brush must be on the short list. 
 He won two handicap hurdles last season over this course and has had two races to tune him up again and he is not badly handicapped. 
 Toby Balding's Directly ran third to Imperial Brush last season and is 7lb better off but he was beaten over 14 lengths into fourth place behind Rusty Roc at Ludlow last time out. 
 He would have to make the same improvement as his stable-companion Forest Sun did from Chepstow to Ascot to be given a sporting chance here. 
 Nigel Tinkler sends down Bank View to carry top weight and this Yorkshire trainer has a good record with his southern. 
 In this very difficult handicap I shall stay with Imperial Brush. 
 In the Wantage Novice Chase Richard Green's smart hurdler, Decided, makes his first appearance over fences. 
 Last season he was trained by Oliver Sherwood, who turned him into one of the best novice hurdlers and now Henrietta Knight will be attempting to do the same over fences. 
 His introduction will be no walk-over but if he is half as good over fences as he was over hurdles, he should win. 
 In the Philip Cornes Novice Hurdle Minnehoma and Qannaas stand out. 
 Both have given every indication that they will stay this trip, so I must go for Martin Pipe's runner Minnehoma. 
 Clara Mountain, already a three times course winner, is most consistent and should score again in the Hungerford Handicap Chase, while Brabazon, who declined an earlier engagement in the Philip Cornes can make fitness tell against the seasonal debutante Young Pokey in the Ramsbury Hurdle. 
 Young Pokey won his only two races last season and will not be long in scoring again. 
 At Folkestone, Allen's Rock looks best in the opener, while John Edwards would not be sending Western Legend all the way from Hereford without a chance. 
 Favourites look as if they will have a good run at Catterick with Royal Greek, Black Spur, James Joy and Pyjamas in particular. 
 Rugby League Monie is on Wigan. 
 By Paul Fitzpatrick 
 SO impressive has been Wigan's play of late that it seems reasonable to conclude that the transitional period from the control of Graham Lowe to that of John Monie is complete. 
 The club have, inevitably, hit a few patches of turbulence along the way but, apart from their defeat at Oldham in the Lancashire Cup, nothing too damaging. 
 Even when they have not played particularly well they have still managed to win, and that has preserved confidence. 
 Now confidence has burgeoned, and they are looking the most complete side in the First Division, secure in defence and incisive in attack; and, with a squad gradually returning to strength, they could dominate the second half of the season. 
 Ellery Hanley is back at loose forward for the Regal Trophy semi-final with Castleford at Headingley today, while the New Zealand centre Kevin Iro also returns after recovering from an operation for cartilage trouble. 
 So, even with players of the class of Steve Hampson and Andy Goodway missing, Wigan look formidably strong, and Castleford will do well to repeat the victory they achieved in October at Central Park &mdash; the last time Wigan lost. 
 Castleford always were capable of springing surprises. 
 Their problem was to control the wild fluctuations of form to which they were prone. 
 Their Australian coach Darryl Van De Velde seemed to have found that elusive consistency last season, but such an assumption was shattered by Castleford's spectacular collapse over the final weeks. 
 The rebuilding is still taking place, but while they perhaps lack Wigan's all-round capability, some of the assurance that carried them so successfully through two-thirds of last season has looked to be returning, and they could possess the forward strength to disrupt Wigan's composure. 
 The winners meet Halifax, of the Second Division, on the same ground in two weeks. 
 Honours A new title for Bruno, Jacklin and Coe. 
 By John Rodda 
 BRITAIN's most popular loser, Frank Bruno, joins some distinguished sporting winners in the New Year's Honours list. 
 Bruno, twice beaten in world heavyweight title fights, against Tim Witherspoon in 1986, and this year by Mike Tyson, receives the MBE for his services to boxing. 
 A year ago he was in Arizona showing the strain of preparing to face Tyson in Las Vegas; yesterday he registered two more performances as the genie in Aladdin at The Dominion, Tottenham Court Road. 
 There is one sporting knight in today's list, John Smith, the chairman of Liverpool Football Club, whose is rewarded for his service as chairman of the Sports Council. 
 His vice-chairman, now also retired from the job, Sebastian Coe, receives the OBE for his work with the council. 
 Coe is now in Melbourne, preparing for his final track race, the 1500 metres in the Commonwealth Games. 
 As an Olympic gold medal winner he already holds the MBE. 
 Tony Jacklin, four times captain of the Ryder Cup team, who retired after this year's drawn contest with the United States, receives the CBE. 
 So too does Micky Steele-Bodger, who played for the England rugby team at flank forward in the 1947-48 season, and has since contributed enormously as an adminstrator, particularly in raising a team each season for the past 42 years to play Cambridge in their preparation fo the University match. 
 He has helped in revitalising the Oxford-Cambridge match which this year drew a capacity crowd to Twickenham. 
 Finlay Calder, the Scottish player who led the Lions to victory in Australia, and is now in his final season at the age of 32, receives the OBE. 
 Three other captains are recognised for their services. 
 Bryan Robson, who steered England's soccer team to the World Cup Finals, receives the OBE, Linford Christie, the Olympic silver medal winner and spearhead of the British team which won the European Cup and placed third in the World Cup, is awarded the MBE, as does Ellery Hanley, leader of the Great Britain rugby league side. 
 The women's world squash champion, Martine Le Moignan, and Jack Simmons, who has just retired from playing cricket for Lancashire at the age of 48, receive the MBE. 
 Among the overseas sporting awards is an OBE for Ewen Chatfield, the veteran New Zealand bowler, who was saved by the prompt action of Bernard Thomas, the MCC physiotherapist, when a ball from England's Peter Lever knocked him unconscious in his maiden Test match at Auckland in 1975. 
 Green light has resurgent North on red alert for deciding match. 
 By Janet Ruff 
 THE North, with two victories over the Midlands and West, remain the front runners in the Women's Territorial Championship at the Silksworth Leisure Complex, Sunderland, with maximum points from three games. 
 This is a complete reversal of fortunes. 
 In last year's championship they managed a single draw and finished last. 
 The destiny of the NatWest Cup now rests on today's match between North and South. 
 Having drawn their first game, against West on Thursday, South need a victory to win overall. 
 They took the honours yesterday for the most attractive play despite the loss of their captain Katie Dodd with the recurrence of a long-standing muscle injury. 
 A 2-1 win over a disappointing Midlands side was surpassed in the final game, when they defeated East, the holders, 3-1. 
 Anne Green, the Ealing striker, gained four of the South's five goals, bringing her total to five in three games. 
 The North opened with a hard-won 2-1 defeat of the East, scoring at two penalty corners in the last 25 minutes through Cate Cook and Kirsten Spencer. 
 Margaret Allan replied. 
 North overcame the West 2-0 rather more easily, West hardly mounting a worthwhile attack. 
 Mandy Sowerby and Spencer were the scorers. 
 Midlands have little form and against the South showed a defensive bias and no discernible pattern. 
 South, on the other hand, played with imagination and good teamwork, although the game deteriorated into a dull affair. 
 Green scored from a penalty stroke and a fine open-play goal before Yvonne Ayshford got Midlands' consolation goal almost on time. 
 The South game against the East was, in contrast, a lively battle, swung South's way by Green's two opportunist goals and one from Kathy White in a red-blooded second half. 
 Lynn Bollington replied for the East. 
 NZ rivals battle for home cheers. 
 THE leaders on the third leg of the Whitbread Round the World Race have cleared the southern tip of Tasmania and the outlying islands and begun their passage across the Tasman Sea to Cape Reinga at the north end of the North Island of New Zealand, writes Bob Fisher. 
 As they rounded Tasmania, there was a pause in their rapid progress, speeds of some of the boats dropping to four knots for a while. 
 Yesterday afternoon, however, saw them all back up to speed with Grant Dalton's Fisher &amp; Paykel out in front by three miles from Steinlager 2, skippered by his fellow New Zealander Peter Blake. 
 There is a keen battle between these two to be first into their home port of Auckland. 
 Lawrie Smith in the 80ft sloop Rothmans was 12 miles behind the leader but still 10 miles clear of Markku Wiikeri's Martela OF. 
 Sport in brief Tennis. 
 Boris Becker has withdrawn from the Australian hard-court tournament in Adelaide, the first event on the new ATP tour, but is still expected to play in the New South Wales Open starting in Sydney on January 8. 
 The West German is hoping to replace Ivan Lendl as world No.1 by winning the Australian Open which starts on January 15. 
 Spain's brother-and-sister team of Emilio and Arantxa Sanchez beat Austria 2-1 in the quarter-finals of the Hopman Cup in Perth, while Yannick Noah lost to Petr Korda during Czechoslovakia's 3-0 defeat of France. 
 Ice Hockey. 
 Britain secured their second victory in two nights over Belgium yesterday with a lopsided 10-0 win in Durham, although the Belgians, ranked 25th in the world, did not use their full international side. 
 Stephen Johnson, Tony Hand and Paul Hand got two goals apiece and Iain Robertson scored on his senior debut. 
 Chess. 
 Michael Adams, at 18 Britain's youngest national champion, shares the lead with a win and a draw after two rounds of the Foreign and Colonial International at Hastings, writes Leonard Barden. 
 Adams, from Truro, beat Murray Chandler of London in 56 moves to stand level with Sergei Dolmatov of the USSR and Predrag Nikolic of Yugoslavia. 
 Bowls. 
 The world indoor champion, Richard Corsie from Edinburgh, dropped two counts of four and trailed 16-15 before recovering to beat David Lockhart of Cheshire 21-19 in the Mackeson Fylde Classic at Blackpool. 
 His Commonwealth Games team-mate Willie Wood scrambled to a 20-19 victory over David Holt while three of England's Auckland team, David Bryant, Tony Allcock and John Ottaway, all won their opening matches. 
 Darts. 
 Eric Bristow was knocked out of the British Darts Open in London last night by Charlie Holdaway, a 28-year-old furniture assembler from Isleworth, Middlesex. 
 Bristow, who has just regained the world No.1 ranking and was chasing a fifth title, lost 3-1. 
 The holder, Brian Cairns of Wales, and the England international Dave Whitcombe were other fourth-round casualties. 
 Ian Ridley. 
 ATTENDANCES on Boxing Day totalled some 556,000, an increase of about 82,000 on last year, and ITV also announced this week that viewing figures for live matches were up. 
 So everyone is basking in the increased popularity of the game. 
 Or are they? 
 ITV also announced this week that, with the agreement of the Football League, they had taken out the Arsenal v Liverpool match from the fixtures for February 24 and it would be played at a later date, invoking a clause in their contract with the League that allows them to use three matches a season in this way. 
 The League, therefore, had to agree. 
 Publicly they say that ITV have acted within their contract, which was agreed by all 92 clubs. 
 Privately, they are disturbed by the move, which follows the controversy last week when ITV delayed transmission of the Liverpool v Manchester United match. 
 Stung, the League said yesterday that they expect ITV to come up with a new date within the next fortnight and they will not tolerate one beyond the scheduled season's end of May 5. 
 The rest of us were as thrilled as ITV at last season's denouement between the two clubs. 
 It is also conceded that many viewers will want to see the match and that ITV were in a tricky position because on that weekend in February they are planning to screen a Littlewoods Cup semi-final. 
 But besides the inconvenience to the long-suffering paying customer &mdash; and Liverpool's have suffered more than any from TV whim &mdash; it begs the question of whether the tail is wagging the dog. 
 It does appear that ITV is indulging in some manipulation of the finale, instead of reflecting it as they should. 
 MILLWALL's efforts to get themselves on television succeeded earlier this season when their game against Liverpool made The Match. 
 In the coming week they will be featured twice. 
 The first they could probably do without, the second will probably fill the Lions with pride. 
 On Wednesday at 9.25pm BBC2 will show the play Arrivederci Millwall, which follows a &bquo;gang of hooligans&equo; (Radio Times) fuelled by hatred after the invasion of the Falkland Islands on a trip to the World Cup in Spain in 1982. 
 Two nights later at 8pm Channel 4 presents a documentary entitled &bquo;No One Likes Us, We Don't Care&equo;, taken from that defiant, whining chant of Millwall supporters (&bquo;articulate, concerned&equo; &mdash; TV Times). 
 It is said to show how the club has changed along with the community of South-east London. 
 You pays yer licence money&hellip; 
 THE first prediction for the new decade to fall before the new decade has begun comes from World Soccer's January edition. 
 The magazine, unfortunately with a deadline of well before Christmas, has this to say of Romania in its summary of how changes in Eastern Europe might affect the game there: &bquo;No visible signs of change and with the recent party congress having given the despotic president Nicolae Ceausescu another five years in office and dissident opposition ruthlessly crushed by the secret police, Romania will remain in the Dark Ages for the foreseeable future.&equo;. 
 READERS with longer memories will recall that Crystal Palace were dubbed The Team Of The Eighties by some people who should have known better and promptly began the decade with a 0-0 draw against Norwich. 
 Today the two teams end the Eighties in opposition again and, to mark the occasion, fans of both teams have got together in a spirit of goodwill and charity. 
 The fanzines, Never Mind the Danger, of Norwich, and Eagle Eye, of Palace, will meet this morning in a light-hearted match at the National Sports Centre and later hold a collection at Selhurst Park, the proceeds of which will go towards children's charities in Norfolk and London. 
 NIGERIA seems likely to follow the English game in embracing the long-ball philosophy of Wing Commander Charles Reep and his Position Of Maximum Opportunity. 
 Their new General Secretary is a Mr Okpomo. 
 ENTRIES for footballer-artists have dribbled in, Bernie Winston of Waterloo, Liverpool citing the Reds' management team of Monet Moran and Kenny Degaslish, for example. 
 Dave Russell of Halifax invokes Rembrandt Moses, Franz Carravaggio, Salvador Daley and Mick Millais. 
 Interestingly, he adds: &bquo;We should also consider art from other cultures. 
 Recently dug up by archaeologists on Merseyside were a group of statues named the Terry Darracotta Army.&equo; 
 Tennis Sanchez lives dangerously. 
 By Mike Dickson in Perth 
 ARANTXA SANCHEZ nearly saw her decision to enter the Hopman Cup backfire yesterday. 
 She had to save two match points before beating Austria's Barbara Paulus, and put Spain on their way to the semi-finals. 
 In the deciding set, her tall and athletic opponent had spectacularly converted a set and 4-0 deficit into a 5-3 and 40-15 lead. 
 The ensuing pressure had contrasting effects on the players. 
 Paulus proceeded to turn to jelly, while Sanchez, the French Open champion, steeled herself and emerged a 6-4, 6-7, 7-5 winner. 
 She then joined her brother, Emilio, in the mixed doubles, and they beat Paulus and Thomas Muster 7-6, 6-4 to put Spain into a semi-final against Czechoslovakia. 
 Today sees the first appearance of the American team, comprising John McEnroe and Pam Shriver, who face Australia. 
 This pits McEnroe against his doubles partner Mark Woodforde, while Shriver plays Hana Mandlikova. 
 Soccer Western agents rub hands over the prospect of an eastern defection Talking Point. 
 By David Lacey 
 THE monolithic facade which Eastern Europe once presented to the world never seemed the same after West Bromwich Albion visited Bucharest in 1968 to play a Cup Winners' Cup match against Dinamo in the August 23 Stadium, where it was rarely the 23rd and seldom felt like August. 
 After a bad-tempered encounter the soldiers who made up most of the small crowd threw stones at the West Bromwich players. 
 To deter them, the Dinamo side linked arms with their opponents as they left the pitch. 
 The soldiers then turned their attention to the police and a free fight broke out. 
 The most likely outcome of the upheavals in Romania, Poland, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, East Germany and Bulgaria will be to drive their better footballers into the arms of the West in ever-increasing numbers. 
 The outlook for their national teams is, to say the least, uncertain. 
 Yet a revolution in the way football is run in a number of these countries was already under way before the democratisation set in. 
 The old assumption that the best club sides were organised by the army and the secret police, who in turn provided the foundations of the national squads, had been overtaken by more commercial considerations. 
 The great Hungarian team of the early Fifties was based on Honved, the army side. 
 Ferenc Puskas was Major Puskas and during the 1956 uprising there were reports he had been killed. 
 Then he turned up playing for Real Madrid. 
 Hungarian football has since fallen victim to the corruption and match-fixing scandals. 
 Bulgaria has been similarly affected and four years ago wound up their two leading clubs, Levski Spartak and CSKA Sofia, the army side, after the players reduced the Cup final to a brawl. 
 CSKA have re-emerged as CFKA Sredets and continue to win the League regularly, but for several seasons the Bulgarians have allowed footballers to be paid for playing. 
 Professionalism and sponsorship have penetrated a number of countries in Eastern Europe, most notably the Soviet Union. 
 The immediate problem is that while soccer in these countries may acquire the trappings of the West, they are not in the same league for cash. 
 Their economies are failing and even if their players become wealthy by staying at home, there is not a lot for them to buy. 
 The situation is not dissimilar to that in England during the years of austerity in the Forties, when a number of First Division players were tempted to play in Bogota. 
 Restrictions on footballers in Eastern Europe playing abroad have gradually been eased as Poles, Soviets and others have come to regard the export of players as a useful means of acquiring hard currency. 
 Only last summer Sergei Aleinikov moved from Dynamo Minsk to join Alexander Zavarov at Juventus for &pound;1.75 million. 
 Some countries have tried to slow down the exodus by insisting that players cannot leave before a certain age, usually 28, or until they have completed their national service. 
 But once all the barriers have been removed, Western Europe can expect a flood of footballers from the East which will make the present procession of Yugoslavs seem a mere trickle. 
 Talented East Germans will head for West Germany, inspired by the success of a defector, Norbert Nachtweih, Bayern Munich's central defender. 
 The Czechs, whose repressive system drove Lubos Kubik and Ivo Knoflicek into hiding in a remote fishing village in Spain, could also look to the Bundesliga, France is a natural destination for the Romanians and every footballer of true world class will end up in Italy. 
 This surely applies to the best Romanian talent, Gheorge Hagi, who has been the target of several Italian clubs. 
 Hagi plays for Steaua Bucharest, the army club who have recently won a sponsorship from Ford. 
 This appears to put him on the right side of the new rulers, even if Steaua were answerable to one of Ceausescu's brothers. 
 Had Hagi played for Dinamo Bucharest, whose future is now in doubt because of its links with the notorious security police, Securitate, it might have been a different matter. 
 According to a Yugoslav newspaper report yesterday, which quoted Uefa's vice-president Freddy Rumo, Dinamo are about to be disbanded. 
 In that case, their opponents in the Cup Winners' Cup quarter-finals, Partizan Belgrade, would receive a bye into the last four. 
 As it is, Hagi will go to the World Cup with a price on his head, always assuming he is not snapped up beforehand. 
 Romanians, Czechs and Soviets may still be playing for national honour next summer but they will also be in the shop window and the busiest men in Italy during June will be the agents. 
 From the Atlantic to the Urals, European football is about to become the biggest common market of all. 
 Elena Ceausescu At the end of my work, there is nothing but dust. 
 Samuel Beckett We want him in a nice jail where we can keep an eye on him. 
 White House spokesman Marlin Fitzwater on General Noriega That's what friends are for. 
 Mrs T on why she supported Bush Death from Above. 
 Motto of 82 US Airborne Divison 
 In the backwoods of southwest Virginia there's a little noticed struggle going on-complete with camouflage, weaponry and mercenaries-between the mine owners and the local communities. 
 Billy Bragg reports from Camp Solidarity Big rock union mountain. 
 GERRY JOHNSON is driving me along the winding roads of south-western Virginia. 
 &bquo;When I was a boy in Harlan County we were real poor and every morning I used to wake up and look out of my bedroom window at this mountain called Gray's Knob. 
 I once saw a painted picture of something like it in the Rockefeller Centre &mdash; must have been worth a million dollars or more &mdash; but we never had anything like that, so that mountain was my art, something beautiful and eternal. 
 &bquo;Then I went up to Chicago and Detroit to work and, when I came home again years later, my mountain was gone. 
 They'd strip-mined it! 
 But I went back there just the other day and I noticed the ground is starting to hump up again.&equo; 
 The Appalachian Mountains pass through this far corner of the Commonwealth of Virginia on their long journey from Maine down to Alabama. 
 In the 18th century, these densely wooded peaks were the original border of the United States. 
 These are The Backwoods, one of the most beautiful and inaccessible regions of the US. 
 This is also coal-mining country. 
 Since April, the United Mine Workers of America have been on strike here against the Pittston Company: 1,700 miners have been out for seven months and, despite intimidation, no one has gone back to work. 
 Pittston has drafted in &bquo;scab&equo; labour to get the coal out, but the roads in these mountains are narrow and winding so the strikers drive their vehicles ahead of the coal trucks as slowly as possible. 
 Hundreds of people have been arrested on contempt charges and Virginia Hills have been declared a &bquo;federally secured area&equo;. 
 The genesis of this strike was Pittston's decision to leave the Bituminous Coal Operators of America with whom the UMWA had signed an industry-wide contract. 
 Once it had withdrawn from the BCOA, Pittston rejected the union contract and cut off health benefits to 1,500 widows, disabled miners, and pensioners. 
 The UMWA members worked in good faith within a contract for 14 months while negotiations went on. 
 Pittston finally provoked a strike by demanding mandatory overtime and Sunday working, the right to contract non-union labour at union operations, and 24 hours' advance notice before the union brings safety experts or union officials to the mines for inspections. 
 Pittston also demanded an end to the full health-care plan, and sought cuts in health and pension benefits for retired miners. 
 To all Americans, the fear of facing illness and expensive hospital bills is a constant nightmare; in these tightly-knit mining communities, Pittston's decision reaches into every family. 
 Taking a day off between shows in Chapel Hill and Charlotte, North Carolina, we head towards the UMWA District 28 office &bquo;just behind the Pizza Hut&equo; in Castlewood, Virginia. 
 We cross the Blue Ridge Parkway and, just beyond the town of Abingdon, find ourselves travelling on the Trail of the Lonesome Pine itself, which was named not after a Laurel and Hardy song but after the &bquo;underground railway&equo; route which helped escaping slaves escape before and during the Civil War. 
 Such is the radical tradition of the area. 
 The UMWA itself sprang out of these hills to found the Congress of Industrial Organisations, an industrial rival to the craft-based and racist American Federation of Labour. 
 The two eventually merged to form the AFL-CIO, the American TUC. 
 Just over the mountain in Kentucky is Harlan County, where in 1973 the miners fought a long and bitter strike. 
 They lost, but during the struggle the rank-and-file movement gained control of the UMWA. 
 These workers have traditionally been the toughest and most radical, and employers all over America are aware that if Pittston can break the &bquo;mother union&equo;, then the attempts to gain the ground lost in the Reagan years will be stillborn. 
 At Castlewood we meet Gene Carroll, a UMWA spokesman. 
 We follow his car as it winds through the hollows and around the hills until we reach the Moss No.3 Preparation Plant where the Pittston Company cleans and grades its coal before moving it out to power stations or abroad. 
 This summer it was the scene of the first mass occupation of a plant by strikers in the USA since the 1930s, and has been the focus of much of the non-violent direct action during the seven-month strike. 
 THE gates of Moss No.3 were the scene of mass demonstrations during the summer as strikers attempted to stop the coal trucks getting into the plant. 
 They sat down in the road and, when the state police dragged them away, they threw jackrocks under the wheels of the &bquo;scab&equo; trucks (a jackrock is a couple of sharpened nails welded together so that no matter which way they land, they always have a point sticking up in the air). 
 For these acts and for occasional bouts of stone-throwing, the UMWA has been fined more than &dollar;30 million by the courts. 
 &bquo;When seven miners were killed in an accident at their McClure No.1 mine in 1983, Pittston was fined &dollar;47,500,&equo; Gene tells us, &bquo;and they fine us &dollar;30 million for demonstrating peacefully in defence of our communities.&equo; 
 UMWA president Richard Trumka says the company and the courts are mistaken if they think the union is dependent on money. 
 The union, he says, &bquo;is an idea that lives on in the minds of our workers and their children&equo;. 
 Things are quiet on the picket line on this Sunday afternoon. 
 Three union members sit outside their hut, whittling redwood and drinking coffee while their comrades attend a local rally for Doug Wilder, the Democratic Party candidate in Virginia's forthcoming gubernatorial elections. 
 I ask one of the pickets if he supports the Democrats. 
 &bquo;Most of the time,&equo; he replies drily. 
 Does he think the Democrats support the strike? 
 &bquo;Most of the time,&equo; is his reply. 
 Has the strike shaken his faith in the American Way? 
 &bquo;Well, it's shocked me that President Bush has gone out and ballyhooed the unions in Poland and yet he's turned his back on us.&equo; 
 A car passes and sounds its horn in solidarity. 
 Across the road in a secure compound are the buildings that house the mostly out-of-state blacklegs. 
 From behind the wire fencing, a uniformed guard eyes us with binoculars. 
 This area is physically remote from the rest of the USA and, without sympathetic media support, it's hard to get the news out. 
 Things happen in these hills that don't make it on to the evening bulletins. 
 &bquo;I saw state policemen drag strikers across the road and make them kneel in the ditch there while they held shotguns in their backs. 
 You just know the camera crews won't turn up until we respond to their provocations,&equo; says Gene. 
 &bquo;This strike is not about higher wages or shorter hours,&equo; Gene explains. 
 &bquo; 
 It's not as if Pittston is heading for bankruptcy. 
 The mining division makes huge profits and it also owns the Brinks security firm and Burlington Northern Air Freight.&equo; 
 Estimates put the cost of hiring private security men during the strike at about &dollar;20 million. 
 Vance International, the firm hired to protect the drafted-in new workers is owned by the son-in-law of former President Gerald Ford. 
 The company is reported to have hired former mercenaries from Rhodesia, Central America and the Middle East who are equipped with assault rifles or shotguns, gasmasks, tear-gas munitions, counter-sniper equipment, intrusion detection devices, armoured vehicles, and K-9 teams. 
 IT'S not surprising that the miners have chosen camouflage as their symbol of solidarity. 
 Everybody is wearing it. 
 Not just the miners themselves, but their families, wives and teenage children, babies, and grandmothers wear camouflage hats, T-shirts, trousers. 
 Besuited union officials wear camouflage ties. 
 They have been criticised for the choice of colours associated with warfare, but up here in these hills surrounded by an army of uniformed police, US marshalls and private security guards all bristling with weapons, it is war: UMWA vice-president Cecil Roberts has said as much. 
 &bquo;Welcome to class warfare in south-western Virginia,&equo; he told a rally this summer. 
 UMWA women recently held a birthday party for Roberts and presented him with a plaque engraved with his now famous quote. 
 As in the NUM strike of 1984, the women have been the backbone of this struggle: dressed in camouflage and calling themselves the Daughters of Mother Jones, after the legendary union organiser from the turn of the century, they have walked the picket lines, sat in front of coal trucks, and been arrested. 
 There are women miners here who were among the first to be laid off when Pittston sacked 4,000 of its 6,000 unionised miners in the early Eighties. 
 They sing the songs of Florence Reece, who wrote Which Side Are You On, and of Sarah Ogen Gunning, author of such great songs as I Hate the Capitalist System. 
 Some of them wear solidarity earrings in the shape of a miniature jackrock. 
 We drive over to Russell County past Carbo Power Station, its cooling towers belching out steam in the valley like a giant fog generator. 
 We are looking for a couple of acres owned by the UMWA member which has become the focus of the strike: Camp Solidarity. 
 Since the spring, 40,000 people have visited this spot, pitching tents and sleeping rough, bringing money and food and leaving their banners and messages of solidarity. 
 We sit and chat with the miners in their newly-finished bunkhouse, drinking coffee beneath a sign inscribed by, among others, our own National Union of Railwaymen and Amalgamated Engineering Union. 
 AS THE talk develops, the strikers reveal their belief that there is more at stake than just their rights. 
 &bquo;These big international companies recognise borders only when they want to use them to set one workforce against another,&equo; says one. 
 Multinational unions are the only way to deal with multinational corporations, it is suggested. 
 I ask if they have heard that in Bolivia the government, spurred on by the IMF, made thousands of miners redundant to make their economy &bquo;viable&equo;. 
 Bolivian miners marched on La Paz to protest and, when the government refused to meet them, 29 miners had themselves &bquo;crucified&equo; for 24 hours at the university. 
 The pressure in Latin America to keep wages low, in the name of &bquo;sound finance&equo;, is particularly strong in Mexico, where starvation wages undercut labour costs in the non-unionised southern and western states of the USA. 
 This in turn puts pressure on the wages of organised labour in the north. 
 If the workforce doesn't keep in line, their jobs begin to move south. 
 You can look across the Rio Grande river in Texas and see American-owned factories, deregulated and non-unionised, on the Mexican side. 
 When the working people in this country &mdash; whose only national newspaper, USA Today, reduces all its non-cold war international news to an eighth-of-a-page column called &bquo;Elsewhere in the world&equo; &mdash; begin to discuss the issues of international capitalist exploitation, it's not surprising that the media portray the strike as some petty industrial dispute in the backwoods of the Appalachians. 
 Slowly, though, word is seeping out. 
 There have been mass demonstrations in some American cities with striking Eastern Airlines employees and telephone workers joining the UMWA to express their solidarity. 
 A friend of mine who took part in such a march in Greenwich, Connecticut, headquarters of the Pittston Group, said that first came the airline pilots in their dark blue uniforms and gold braided hats; then the telephone workers all dressed in red shirts; and then the miners covered from head to toe in camouflage. 
 The fact that everyone was waving tiny American flags made this spectacle of labour all the more bizarre. 
 It seems that union members have learned their lesson after they allowed Ronald Reagan to break the air traffic controllers in the early Eighties. 
 Not only are they marching in common cause with other unions, but the UMWA is also forging links with groups fighting against conservative forces in American society. 
 Environmentalists have supported the miners against Pittston strip-mining and long-wall techniques, and I was given a badge which proclaimed &bquo;I'm Pro-Union and Pro-Choice&equo;, linking the strike with the most inflammable issue in US politics today, abortion rights. 
 With all this, and the union vice-president talking in terms unheard of since the heyday of the Industrial Workers of the World, you begin to understand why it is imperative for capitalism that Pittston succeeds in its attempt to break the UMWA. 
 THE days following our visit to Camp Solidarity bring encouraging news. 
 Doug Wilder is elected governor of Virginia with the media noting that &bquo;South-western coal counties helped to fuel his victory.&equo; 
 Wilder will be the first black governor in American history and the union endorsed him believing that he will ensure fairer treatment at the hands of state officials. 
 In the coal counties themselves, Jack Stump, the president of the local District 28 of UMWA, overwhelmingly defeated the incumbent Democrat to win a seat in the Virginia House of Delegates. 
 This is unprecedented for a &bquo;write-in&equo; candidate not supported by any party machine. 
 And the victory is even sweeter as his opponent, Don McGloghlin Snr, is father of the judge responsible for the bulk of the &dollar;30 million fines levied against the union. 
 The next day we sit amazed watching people dancing on top of the Berlin Wall. 
 The world is changing fast before our eyes, while the Bush Administration stands transfixed, unable or unwilling to respond to Gorbachev's reforms. 
 This is not the much-touted &bquo;end of history&equo; that we are witnessing; it is merely the end of the American ability to control events around the world. 
 It must now face the imperial impotence that Britain has found it so difficult to adapt to. 
 American capitalism has always relied on international rivalry and the occasional war to create an artificial community of interest between the rich and the poor. 
 If the Soviet Union refuses to play that game any more, how long will it be before the poor of this great country realise that the genuine community of interest exists among themselves? 
 Already they have stopped voting along purely racial lines. 
 I eventually saw a report about striking miners on American TV. 
 It was the third story in an evening bulletin, and the tone of the commentary implied the legitimacy of their struggle. 
 The report came from the Soviet Union where miners within the Arctic Circle are seeking better conditions. 
 I hope they don't ask me to come and do a benefit concert up there. 
 At least not until the spring. 
 Cafe. 
 Europe in turmoil. 
 MUCH of the breeding ground for Czechoslovakia's revolution lay in the baroque atmosphere of Prague's elegant cafes. 
 These imposing buildings from another era were the meeting point for elements that the establishment wanted to keep apart. 
 Through the country's long years of repression, artists, intellectuals and students met each other in the cafes, to swap ideas and information and to give each other solidarity. 
 To Western eyes, this may not seem extraordinary. 
 But Jaroslav Rona, a member of a group of prominent artists, says: &bquo;If intellectual groups had not met in the cafes, nothing would have happened. 
 If the authorities had had any sense, they would have closed the cafes.&equo; 
 Prague's cafes have been the centre of cultural activity since the days of the Austro-Hungarian empire. 
 So potent is the tradition of Czech cafe society, that most cafes were shut down after the Communist takeover in 1948. 
 To prevent opposition forces coalescing, the authorities went to great length to separate the various strands of artistic and intellectual thought. 
 Separate organisations were created for, among others, officially approved painters, writers and architects, with each group being allocated an official meeting place. 
 Contact between the different groups was actively discouraged. 
 Students were not even given their own campus cafe or union bar to meet in. 
 The only place where artists, intellectuals and the students could meet regularly were the cafes. 
 But whenever the system was threatened, even the cafes became no-go areas. 
 After 1968, no new artistic movements were permitted, and groups of artists or intellectuals meeting in cafes became the subject of suspicion. 
 After Charter 77 was launched, even the cafes had too many secret police sipping tea. 
 People began to meet in their homes. 
 BUT when the system loosened up slightly under pressure from Gorbachev's reforms, some groups started to return to the cafes. 
 One was The Tvrdohlavi, loosely translated as hard or tough heads, a group of leading Czech artists who formed their original group in the cafe Obecni Dum, the building where Thomas Masayrek proclaimed the formation of Czechoslovakia in 1918. 
 The Tvdohlavi took their name from the Tvrdosijni (strong backbone), a group of painters from 1920s cafe society who had met to explore the new artistic style of Cubism. 
 The Tvrdohlavi, just eight strong, wanted to be free to explore artistic avenues and to meet other creative people away from state influence. 
 &bquo;By forming groups such as ours,&equo; says Rona, &bquo;it became possible for people who would never otherwise have met, to compare ideas.&equo; 
 Gradually, what began as isolated pockets of thought, became a vibrant movement. 
 Students were the final element to join the new cafe society. 
 The most important cafe was The Slavia. 
 Built in the 1860s as the last privately built palace in Prague, and later partially converted to a cafe, The Slavia's significance came from its location. 
 On the floor above was the faculty of film making. 
 In the same road was the school of journalism. 
 Directly opposite, lay the National Theatre. 
 THERE is no name on the door of The Slavia. 
 Some of its grand design was lost in a Sixties refit. 
 But its pull remains powerful. 
 Throughout the dark years, some of the artists and intellectuals, who were given manual jobs for producing unacceptable works of art, met in The Slavia. 
 In the months leading up to the Prague autumn, The Slavia played elegant host to a more accurate cross-section of Czech society &mdash; punks, housewives, artists, students, writers, weary shoppers &mdash; than probably existed anywhere in the country until the rallies in Wenceslas Square. 
 When the distinguished writer Pavel Kohout recently returned from exile he went directly to The Slavia. 
 When the revolution came, artists and students continued their association, with artists designing many of the posters that students plastered across the city. 
 Little wonder then that when the students launched a magazine to spread information between their disparate groups, they called it Kavane, meaning Cafe. 
 society USE THIS ONE PATCH FOR PAGE ELEVEN TAB. 
 Blue Ridge base&hellip; on a small patch of land owned by a member of the miners' union, 40,000 people have called to offer their solidarity since last spring. 
 PAGE 
 Fresh hope for the homeless Property. 
 By David Lawson THE ESTATE agent was gut-wrenchingly honest about putting cash before humanity. 
 &bquo;There is no reason why I couldn't unlock 45 flats for homeless people for nine or 10 months. 
 &lsqb;But&rsqb; I don't want an agreement where I have to apply to court to get them out. 
 It costs &pound;1,500 minimum to stage a court case.&equo; 
 Scattered among the hundreds of central London houses he manages are at least 100 empty properties. 
 Some have been unoccupied for more than four years, and most for at least six months. 
 Meanwhile more than 30,000 people will see in the new year squeezed into bed-and-breakfast accommodation. 
 And as the charity shelters close, many more will be put back in their cardboard boxes. 
 The agent has an answer, but not the one buried in a torrent of new laws introduced this year. 
 Short- hold and assured tenancies aimed at enticing owners to let empty homes are looked on with suspicion and disdain. 
 Freedom to charge higher rents will reopen some doors but the court orders still necessary to remove tenants could block real advances. 
 Owners don't want property to stay empty, says the agent. 
 But they want to be sure it is empty at the time they might need to sell or redevelop. 
 He promised to release the empty flats in his row of Chelsea houses tomorrow if guaranteed repossession within 48 hours by some sort of contract. 
 In fact all his empties could be let at low rents for perhaps three years. 
 It was a startling promise, stimulated perhaps by the fact that he did not have to reveal his name and live up to his words. 
 Anonymity was guaranteed by investigators from Social and Community Planning Research who were looking into reasons why landlords refuse to let empty property. 
 But landlords are desperate to offload homes, particularly in the South-east where the depression is deepest. 
 They are queueing up to offer properties to local authorities, according to Hal Pawson of the London Research Centre. 
 Not a single borough in the capital was having difficulty finding enough flats and houses. 
 This is creating a vital staging post between expensive hotels and permanent rehousing for the homeless. 
 &bquo;The use of bed and breakfast is still hovering close to record levels,&equo; says Pawson, &bquo;It is only through the boom in short-term leasing that boroughs have been able to avoid further increases in hotel placements.&equo; 
 Around 40,000 people could be housed this way by next April, more than double the number last spring. 
 Private Sector Leasing in London is available from the London Research Centre, 81 Black Prince Road, London SE1. 
 Price &pound;15. 
 Empty Dwellings, by Helen Finch, Alice Lovell and Kit Ward from any HMSO. 
 Price &pound;14. 
 The rule of truth Yesterday Vaclav Havel became president of Czechoslovakia. 
 WL Webb and Michael Billington profile the president and playwright, chosen above all for his reputation as a man whose word is to be trusted. 
 Europe in turmoil. 
 CULTURE, or art, said a young playwright in an interview in Prague in Spring, 1968, &bquo;is concerned with truth, it tries to show reality as it is. 
 Politics wishes to change reality, it requires power, and thus it is primarily in the service of power&hellip; 
 It is an open question whether intellectuals can ever play an active role in political life without becoming unfaithful to their main goal, which is truth.&equo; 
 In 21 maturing years since then, Vaclav Havel has learned much more about power and how a citizen-intellectual may have to deal with it, or even assume it. 
 Some of these lessons were very practical. 
 In 1975 he wrote his open letter to President Husak about the price that would have to be paid for delivering their country into the hands of an &bquo;entropic&equo; regime which depended &bquo;solely on the ruling minority's instinct of self-preservation and on the fear of the ruled majority&equo;, a regime which positively required the suppression of truth and history for its surival. 
 After that he learned first to carry with him everywhere his own survival kit of razor, toothpaste and cigarettes against the likelihood of arrest, and then to survive years in prison surrounded by gaolers like characters out of his own plays, who lived by the laws of the regime's own absurdist, reality-denying logic. 
 You can read about how he survived in the letters he wrote to his wife, published here by Faber as Letters To Olga. 
 The years of his longest sentence, from 1979 to 1983 (incurred for setting up, in admiring imitation of the Polish KOR, a Czech Committee to Defend the Unjustly Prosecuted) were punctuated by other, sometimes painfully absurd episodes: for example the day the Interior Ministry's men relented sufficiently to allow him to attend his father's funeral, and then inadvertently let him be surrounded by a tight scrum of friends who brought him up to date with all the latest political news. 
 The other half of his proposition about culture and politics was onlydeepened by the experiences of the last two decades. 
 When the philosopher and historian Thomas Garrigue Masaryk became the first President of the new republic of Czechoslovakia between the wars, there flew above his residence in Prague Castle a flag bearing the words Truth Prevails, and it's hardly a coincidence that the central theme of Havel's political writings has been &bquo;To live in truth&equo;. 
 The worst thing the old politburocracy did to the Czechs and Slovaks was to require them to &bquo;live lies&equo; because the truth didn't fit the pseudo-history which was supposed to legitimize Brezhnev's satraps. 
 It was this more than anything that impelled Havel into active opposition, and there's little doubt that it's his reputation as a truth-teller, a man whose word is to be trusted, that most commends him to a nation recovering from constitutional mendacity. 
 That may be his paramount qualification for &bquo;going to the Castle&equo;, but some of the others seem hardly less important. 
 Again and again, people told me in Prague earlier this month how the Forum had been held together at difficult moments by his irrestistible decency and gentle authority. 
 The deep Kissinger-bass issuing from that mild and amiable countenance seems somehow to incarnate that balance. 
 He really is a good man. 
 &bquo;The only man I know&equo;, wrote Karel Kyncl earlier this year, &bquo;who blushes when confronted with something deplorable.&equo; 
 Then, by birth and by upbringing, he offers in his own person a connection between the Czechoslovakia now beginning to resume its history after 20 years in the deep freeze and both the pre-war Republic and the experiment in state socialism that followed liberation from the Nazis. 
 His grand-father was a diplomat, briefly a cabinet minister and &bquo;a bit of a writer&equo;. 
 In the 1920s, an uncle founded the Barrandov film studios that were to have their finest hour with the Czech New Wave of the Sixties, and his father was responsible for and owned, among other buildings, the Lucerna block in the heart of the city which has been part of the life of most Pragers, with its remarkable collection of art-deco restaurants, bars, cinemas and concert hall. 
 Havel's friend and co-resister Ludvik Vaculik describes a birthday party for &bquo;our own particular Wenceslas&equo; (Vaclav is the Czech version) in one of its restaurants a few years ago, on one of those occasions when they were wrily living &bquo;as if&equo; in freedom; all those present remember some high or low point of their lives happening somewhere in the Lucerna Palace. 
 He remembers the onset of class guilt and embarrassment during the war when as a small, spoiled, fat model child, he was taken to school by a governess in the Moravian village where they were evacuated. 
 After February 1947, when he was 12, he and his family became &bquo;the objects of class war&equo;. 
 As a scion of the haute bourgeoisie, he wasn't allowed to have higher education. 
 He wanted to read philosophy but the university refused him; so did the cinema school and the drama faculty (though to the amused admiration of his friends in the theatre, he did eventually attend, as a student, after the successful opening of The Garden Party, and when he had already completed his best play, The Memorandum (which remains probaby his most effective play). 
 So he experienced society from the bottom up, before talent and determination made room at the top for him: &bquo;That was a most valuable bit of education for which I shall always be grateful both to my bourgeois ancestry as well as to the regime,&equo; he was to say later. 
 &bquo;I didn't have the slightest desire to see the restitution of my father's property,&equo; he added in that 1968 interview, and &bquo;I was always in favour of socialism in the sense of nationalisation of major means of production.&equo; 
 His other great asset has been his sense of the way minds changed in the generations of the late Sixties and after. 
 Reflecting in 1968 on the difference between him and Communists of the older generation, he said: &bquo;They seem to approach reality by way of certain abstract categories, which seem to them to have a lot of meaning and to reflect concrete experience&hellip;; &lsqb;whereas&rsqb; members of my generation tend to use as a starting point reality as it exists at the moment, they form general concepts on the basis of this reality and they disregard categories which seem to have lost their relevance and to function more as incantations than as concepts.&equo; 
 People younger than him, he noted, &bquo;not only reject all a priori ideological filters, just as I do, but&hellip; refuse to have anything to do with people who use such filters. 
 Their attraction to concrete reality is very much more radical.&equo; 
 Havel's recent writings and statements show how he has gone forward into the politics implicit in such a view of society. 
 Like the new politics all over Europe, they are passionately ecological, inevitably in a region where the dragon's breath of unchecked industrialisation has scorched great tracts of lately rural land, sickening trees and children indiscriminately. 
 Havel's later prison letters are intense meditations on the alienation from Being revealed in man's destructive, monkey-clever exploitation of the natural world and his fellow men. 
 With that goes a rejection of the corrupted language and thought of the old politics. 
 In his country, he wrote a year ago, formally accepting a West German peace prize, &bquo;socialism&hellip; was transformed long ago into just an ordinary truncheon used by certain cynical, parvenu bureaucrats to bludgeon their liberal-minded fellow-citizens from morning till night, labelling them &bquo;enemies of socialism&equo; and &bquo;anti-socialist forces&equo; '. 
 The efforts &mdash; and prison sentences &mdash; of the unofficial peace movement had redeemed the similarly contaminated word peace, but &bquo;in my country, for ages now, socialism has been no more than an incantation that should be avoided if one does not wish to appear suspect.&equo; 
 Shortly after reading that I was fascinated to come across Hugh Seton-Watson's account, in a book written 44 years ago, of how in Eastern Europe between the wars the word &bquo;Communist&equo; had become popular with the poor subjects of largely dictatorial regimes because their rulers used it as a term of abuse against &bquo;ordinary men and women who have asked for reforms, protested against bureaucratic abuse, or resisted the gendarmerie in the execution of some wanton brutality.&equo; 
 I'm not sure whether 40 years later, the same mechanism made the word &bquo;capitalism&equo; popular among the people; the Leipzig demonstrations suggest that in Saxony, at least, it may have done. 
 WHAT I do know is that people like Havel have been getting a little impatient with those relishing pieces appearing lately in the American press that say, roughly: &bquo;Right, you guys over there have had your romantic Ruritanian fun and games with revolution and dancing in the streets. 
 Now get down to the business of making a country fit for business to operate in, with plenty of unemployment and real inequality.&equo; 
 Exchanging one kind of social and economic brutalism for another is not what Havel and his kind have in mind, nor do such prescriptions fit the democratic habit of the Czech temperament, formed long before communism's arrival to power. 
 Most of the Habsburg successor states, as the Czech historian Zbynek Zeman reminded us in his vivid modern history of the region (Pursued By A Bear: Chatto), were invented to serve the interests of the Western allies after the first world war, as a hedge against German expansion eastwards and a firebreak against the spread of revolution west from Russia. 
 Left to their own devices, with intractable economic and ethnic problems, most of them, though not Czechoslovakia, were military or royal dictatorships by the mid-Thirties. 
 What a fine piece of historical irony it would be if from the heart of this wounded part of Europe there were to emerge a politics that would begin to show us how to be at home in the world, decently balancing the requirements of social justice and economic sufficiency, of finite nature and what we call human nature. 
 W. L. Webb t Eating words 
 Food. 
 Britain's food was, is, and will continue to be among the best and safest in the world. 
 John MacGregor, Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food I have no doubt that there is indeed a serious public health problem associated with salmonella enteridis phase 4 in eggs in this country. 
 Sir Donald Acheson, Chief Medical officer Production at Dairy Crest's creamery in Cambourne, Cornwall, has been suspended until the completion of a company investigation into how mercury got into a tub of Sainsbury's butter. 
 Daily Telegraph The supermarkets adopt bully-boy tactics. 
 They are aggressively self-interested. 
 They get away with murder because of their buying power. 
 Gerry Harding, Chairman of the Organic Growers, West Wales Germs&hellip; a damn sight less dangerous than politicians. 
 Ms T. Gorman, MP Two Archers actors to sue the BBC over party illness. 
 Daily Telegraph Dog food is subject to stricter controls than human food. 
 Professor Richard Lacey More choice for your doggies &amp; moggies. 
 Marks &amp; Spencer press release Eat your own pet ad criticised. 
 Daily Telegraph We've moved beyond grazing into gulping Al Rosenfeld, publisher of Frozen Food Age A Czech store manager has been jailed for 12 years for stealing-and eating-nearly &pound;60,000 worth of food. 
 A Prague newspaper said yesterday that he weighed 36 stone. 
 Reuters Between chimes of Jingle Bells, the Holly and the Ivy and other festive tunes, we Brits nibble our way through the equivalent of nearly half a billion 50g packets of nuts from October until the New Year. 
 KP press release Micro-organisms in general are pretty clever beasts. 
 Dr Paul Gibbs, Leatherhead Food Research Association We are giving sensible and balanced advice to consumers based on the best available advice of the Chief Medical Officer. 
 John MacGregor, Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food I am advised that hard cheese processes suppress and kill off pathogens. 
 It may be more difficult with soft cheeses and we will be examining this very carefully. 
 John MacGregor, Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food There is no proposal to ban unpasteurised soft cheese. 
 John MacGregor, Minister of Food, Fisheries and Agriculture What John (MacGregor) has said is he's thinking about the possibility of banning cheese (made) from non-pasteurised milk, but it hasn't got beyond that. 
 Kenneth Clarke, Minister of Health This is a decidedly unfriendly act. 
 A French spokesman. 
 The reason the Government seems to be directing its big guns at unpasteurised milk producers has more to do with the big dairy industry's concerns at the erosion of their share of the market. 
 Humphrey Errington, milk &amp; cheese producer The squabbling between the Department of Health and the Ministry of Agriculture shows that, far from getting their act together, they are in a total shambles. 
 Professor Richard Lacey (It) would probably find its way into the press and make a stink. 
 Dr Anne Dawson, senior official in the Department of Health and Social Security on the possible consequences if the Department warned the NHS about the dangers of salmonella We have known that there was salmonella in 60 percent of chickens' guts for many years. 
 Senior Public Health Officer There has been no cover-up, no conspiracy with the industry, and no complacency&hellip; but regular and prompt action based on a wide range of scientific advice. 
 John MacGregor, Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food Here is a guy going to prosecute me. 
 He said &bquo;I would like to bring my wife for lunch or dinner.&equo; 
 I told him lunch was &pound;19.50 and it was a good bargain. 
 Would he do that if my kitchen was filthy? 
 It was a tranquilliser to my heart. 
 Albert Roux, chef/proprietor of Le Gavroche restaurant The flies and the pigeons do not belong to me. 
 They are not on my payroll. 
 Albert Roux In the Jewish religion&hellip; a fly in one's soup is grounds for divorce. 
 Dr Nicholas Burridge Cooking isn't an art, it's chemistry. 
 To be a good cook you have to do a lot of things precisely, but it requires no understanding. 
 Albert Raymond These men are alchemists, but I'm still a humble cook. 
 Marco-Pierre White, chef/proprietor of Harveys I think the time is fast approaching when the lady must be given no choice. 
 She must be told to appear before the Committee or be forced to take the consequences. 
 Paul Marchand MP on Edwina Currie No one has bought my silence; no one ever could. 
 Mrs Edwina Currie MP Tuna have feelings. 
 Linda McCartney If people swallowed tomato seeds (of a genetically engineered wrinkle-free tomato) the plants could end up growing in a sewage farm somewhere, and this would be an unauthorised release of a genetically engineered organism. 
 Simon Best, Business Development Manager of ICI Seeds There is nothing unusual about ministries being responsible for both industry and the consumer. 
 John MacGregor, Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food. 
 It is increasingly felt by members of the public that large-scale soil erosion, the destruction of wildlife habitat and the excessive use of chemicals and unnatural substances are unacceptable, and cannot continue unabated without ruining the countryside for future generations and probably causing long term health hazards. 
 HRH Prince Charles in a message to the sixth National Conference of Organic Food Production What is worrying farmers most is that nature has a nasty habit of having a sting in the tail. 
 Mr Bob Wright, National Farmers Union Midland and Northwest spokesman commenting on the good weather We don't want to turn our cows into drug addicts. 
 Barnaby Hannam, farmer Bacon and pork will be the next infected-food scandal. 
 Sir Richard Body, MP Hirohito, shy god who liked bacon &amp; eggs. 
 Daily Telegraph If you did not put aluminium in you would have water that was cloudy. 
 Spokesman for Department of Environment Speaking personally, it has long been my view that these matters of food safety should be in the hands of a Minister of Consumer Affairs. 
 Mrs Sally Oppenheim-Barnes, Chair of the National Consumer Council We also hope to discover how important gravity is to mushrooms. 
 We hope to see what happens when you try to grow mushrooms without gravity but with light. 
 Dr David Moore of Manchester University on the decision to allow the British astronaut to take 24 quails' eggs and 24 mushrooms on the Soviet Juno space mission People are standing in front of the toaster saying &bquo;Faster, faster&equo;. 
 Joel Weiner, marketing executive of Kraft General Foods It is precisely because we are not complacent about this issue that the Government have been preparing a major Food Bill since October 1987. 
 Richard Ryder, Parliamentary Under-Secretary at the Ministry of Food, Fisheries and Agriculture Shopping in a place called a health food shop doesn't mean you can assume everything it sells is safe or healthy. 
 Which? 
 Can it really be in the consumer interest that the Government stops this work (food research and development) being carried out, particularly when we face an epidemic of food poisoning and growing public concern abou the quality and wholesomeness of food? 
 Dr David Clark, Labour Agriculture spokesman I am convinced one reason you used a cucumber was for self-preservation. 
 If you were caught you could point to the cucumber and deny responsibility. 
 Mr Justice Jowitt commenting at the trial of Ernest Coveley, accused of carrying out a series of robberies with a cucumber The escargot laying season is between June and September. 
 Escargots lay an average of one hundred eggs a year, giving a total weight of about 3.5 grammes. 
 By comparison the sturgeon produces between 8,000 and 20,000 grammes, depending on the species, at one time: in other words, 4,000 times more! 
 But as everyone knows, Lady Nature only provides the exceptional with parsimony. 
 An advertisement for Brut d'Escargot snails' eggs I will take a tough line on food safety in terms of banning things that are dangerous. 
 John Selwyn Gummer, Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food There is no point in producing a list of microwave ovens without giving the detailed instructions so that those using them can improve their performance. 
 John Selwyn Gummer, Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food When Mr Gummer took over the Ministry of Agriculture, he promised he would put the consumer first. 
 His chance to do this has come with the microwave report, but he has decided to put the interests of microwave manufacturers first. 
 John Beishon, director of the Consumers' Association You could argue that food difficulties proceed and contribute to the development of sexual problems&hellip; 
 The final irony and, to me, the bitter one, is that women, the sex that eats in an irregular, disordered and joyless fashion, have a greater capacity to enjoy food than men. 
 Again, an analogy with women's potential for more intense and prolonged sexual pleasures suggests itself. 
 For both capacities-though feared by men-are largely unrealised. 
 Dr Germaine Greer I'm no puritan. 
 John Selwyn Gummer, Minister of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food The results suggest that the addition of a moderate amount of MSG to new foods can facilitate the acquisition of a preference for the foods and, over time, stimulate intake of those foods. 
 Monosodium and the acquisition of food preference in a European context, by France Bellisle, Alain Tournier and Jeanine Louis-Sylvestre Food today is more of a maintenance function than a pleasurable experience. 
 Richard Nelson, Director of Market Research Services at Campbell Soups All consumers want is to be told what is happening to their food, how safe it is and what is its quality&hellip; 
 After all, we're not asking much. 
 Just to be told what's going on, what's in the packet, what the future holds for us in the food game. 
 Derek Cooper, presenter of The Food Programme Drink. 
 Beaujolais should not be a civilized society lady; it is the one-night-stand of wines. 
 Kermit Lynch, Adventures on the Wine Route How can a rare bottle of wine fetch the price of the great work of art? 
 Can it, however perfect, smell more beautiful than a rose? 
 No must surely be the honest answer. 
 But what if, deep in the flushing velvet of its petals, the rose contained the power to banish care? 
 Hugh Johnson, The Story of Wine When Jesus Christ turned water into wine, he didn't hand out a warning label. 
 Brother Timothy of Christian Brothers on new American legislation requiring wine to carry health warnings The liquids appear in wine bottles. 
 They have labels like wine bottles. 
 And they look like wine. 
 The one thing they don't do is taste like wine. 
 And if something doesn't taste like wine, I for one don't want to waste my time trying to pretend it does. 
 Oz Clarke on low alcohol wines The effect that the Group Areas Act, the Population Registration Act and the Separate Amenities Act have on black vineyard workers is deplorable and, in my opinion, morally indefensible. 
 Tim Hamilton-Russell, South African wine producer and founder signatory of The Winelands Commitment I'm sick of people asking if organic wine is made from rhubarb. 
 Charlotte Mitchell, author of The Organic Wine Guide Marques de Alella Seco: made with the varieties of Macabeo, Pansa Blanca and Chenin Blanc. 
 Of fruty (sic) flavour, a fresh wine-sort, clear and shining. 
 The Chenin Blanc conferes (sic) this wine a touch of sofistication (sic), combining a sour taste and fruty (sic again) flavour. 
 Manglish Award for the handout of 1989. 
 Any pub is a good pub if you have enough to drink. 
 A Dublin drinker As two Gulf newspapers were banned for 24 hours for advertising a Beaujolais wine festival, the United Arab Emirates used bulldozers to crush 9,000 bottles of confiscated whisky and 1,500 cans of beer into the desert sands. 
 Reuters Our request was an act of humility. 
 We must lay off the booze even during Holy Communion. 
 A priest in Friuli, commenting on the Vatican's decision to allow non-alcoholic wine at Mass to help priests with an alcohol problem  
 PAGE 110 
 ADKIN ESTABLISHED 1793 Moving in Oxfordshire 
 ADKIN SELLING 
 HOW ADKIN WILL SELL YOUR PROPERTY IN 3 EASY STAGES 
 STAGE 1. 
 THE FREE VALUATION 
 Our advice is based on nearly 200 years' experience in the Oxfordshire property market. 
 Through our experience and knowledge derived from sales in the area we are able to ensure that you have the greatest chance of selling at the highest figure. 
 The valuation is important: if you put too high a price on the property the market will reject it and you will not sell. 
 Price it too low and you will lose money. 
 We are constantly watching the property market and are alert to every factor which affects it, so you can be confident of getting the soundest marketing advice available. 
 So if you want results that count simply call your local Adkin office  and  we'll make an appointment to suit you. 
 STAGE 2. 
 THE INSTRUCTION 
 Once you are happy that a marketing price has been reached then you simply instruct us to sell. 
 At this stage no money is required  &mdash;  everything is free. 
 We work on a &bquo;no sale no fee&equo; basis. 
 (Expenses are sometimes charged for auctions etc. but these will always be agreed in writing beforehand.) 
 Once the instruction is given, you will be impressed by the speed and enthusiasm shown by our sales staff who are so vital to the success of Adkin. 
 We are very prominent estate agents in Oxfordshire and the efficiency of our network of offices, our massive mailing registers, our eye catching &bquo;For Sale&equo; boards and our unrivalled advertising exposure, all combine to get you fast results. 
 STAGE 3. 
 THE SALE 
 You are kept constantly informed of progress and as soon as a purchaser has been introduced we will negotiate to obtain the best price. 
 Their purchasing position will be clarified and the solicitors notified. 
 Naturally the final decision is yours but we will keep a close check on the progress of the sale. 
 Vital at this stage are the mortgage arrangements and our Mortgage Department is there to advise you or your purchaser on the most effective sources of finance. 
 Our expertise will help guide the sale through smoothly. 
 We are only too aware of the frustrations and annoyance of a sale which collapses and we will do everything in our power to ensure that your sale is completed to your total satisfaction and with a minimum of fuss. 
 SELLING THROUGH ADKIN GIVES YOU DISTINCT ADVANTAGES 
 We have nearly 200 years experience of selling in the area. 
 We have over 15 offices in Oxfordshire, all prominently located. 
 Most offices are open seven days a week &mdash; until 6 p.m. weekdays &mdash; to see more buyers. 
 We advertise extensively, so your property is seen by more people. 
 Our &bquo;For Sale&equo; boards could not be more catching and are promoting your property 24 hours a day. 
 ADKIN SURVEYS 
 What do Adkin Chartered Surveyors offer the House Buyer? 
 It is extraordinary that many more people have an inspection when buying a second-hand car than they do when purchasing a house. 
 A home is the single largest capital investment  to  make in our entire life, and yet only some ten to fifteen percent of purchasers will commission a detailed report. 
 Of course, if you are financing the purchase through a Bank or Building Society, a valuation report will be commissioned and you receive a courtesy copy in most instances. 
 The purchaser who relies solely on this mortgage report takes on the risk of unexpected building defects. 
 A mortgage valuation may be considered sufficient for a lending institution able to spread the risk across many loans, and which also has the benefit of the security of each borrower's income as well as the property. 
 However, that property could have defects which could only be identified and reported by a more detailed survey. 
 The Chartered Surveyor is specially trained to identify building defects and to evaluate their significance and how therefore the property's value is affected. 
 You may only have seen the property once, and for all sorts of  emotive  reasons, may have fallen in love with the place. 
 You will find your Surveyor will not have such emotive issues on his mind when he inspects! 
 Yes &mdash; he will obviously see and know of the good points, but it is his job to find the faults and problems. 
 If few or no defects are found, then at least you have the peace of mind in knowing your new home has been expertly checked. 
 Beyond the mortgage report, there are two options: 
 (a) 
 A Structural Survey. 
 (b) 
 An RICS House or Flat Buyers Report and Valuation. 
 THE STRUCTURAL SURVEY 
 A full inspection is conducted, detailing all visible AND potential faults. 
 The services are not tested but a visual inspection is made and advice is offered if further specialists' tests are needed. 
 Following the on-site inspection, the findings are analysed and the Surveyor prepares his written report, giving the purchaser a clear picture of the property's condition and information  of  the important defects which will need immediate attention and those which may be required in the medium to long term. 
 For the purchaser moving into a new area, invaluable comments can be made on the property's location and any unfavourable matters which may adversely affect the value now or in the future. 
 THE RICS HOUSE OR FLAT BUYERS REPORTS AND VALUATION 
 A few years ago, the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors introduced and published this report particularly to assist those buyers who felt they could not afford the fees of a full Structural Survey. 
 The inspection is similar to that carried out for the Structural Survey, however because the report is in a standard format, the information conveyed is more concise and limited in order to identify the more important defects, bearing in mind the property's type and age. 
 The report is more suited to houses of less than 200ft 2 , and built after 1900. 
 Whatever you do, before you are committed to purchase, safeguard yourself by talking to the professionals. 
 Don't leave your decision to the last moment &mdash; you should not expect your surveyor to hurry a report which can potentially save you thousands of pounds &mdash; talk to him as soon as you have chosen your purchase. 
 Can you afford the risk? &mdash; NO.   
 ADKIN BUYING YOUR NEW HOME 
 IF YOU ARE BUYING&hellip; 
 BUY THROUGH ADKIN 
 Our friendly efficient staff will take care to understand your every need. 
 When you register with Adkin you will be assured that&hellip; 
 You will have access to what is probably the largest choice of homes available. 
 You will be telephoned, if you are agreeable, with details of properties just received onto the market. 
 Most offices are open 7 days a week &mdash; until 6 p.m. on weekdays for your convenience with caring conscientious staff. 
 We offer free and expert guidance on all the finance aspects of home purchase. 
 We have the independence to approach a variety of mortgage companies, and we have &bquo;lowest rate&equo; mortgage funds available. 
 We will give you written quotations. 
 We carry out consistent weekly mailings, and we have modern technology to assist in the matching process. 
 We have the experience and knowledge to provide an  unrivalled  service. 
 WHY NOT CALL IN OR TELEPHONE NOW. 
 STEP BY STEP GUIDE TO BUYING YOUR NEW HOME 
 Q. It's quite an involved business, buying a property, isn't it? 
 YES, but with the right professional help to smooth your path it need not present you with any problems. 
 At Adkin we pride ourselves on giving you that help every step of the way. 
 Q. Where do I start? 
 A. Call into any Adkin office. 
 Our sales staff are friendly, experienced people who are there to give you helpful advice. 
 They will listen to your ideas, find out how much you can comfortably afford to spend and point you in the right direction of the right properties, in the right location, at the right prices. 
 Q. What about a mortgage? 
 How much will it cost? 
 A. Our own independent Mortgage Consultants are on hand to give you free and impartial advice. 
 Building Societies, Banks and other lenders all vary in what they charge and why. 
 Our people are there to make an arrangement which suits you. 
 They will be able to tell you whether you will be able to get a mortgage and exactly how much your repayments are going to be. 
 Q. That sounds good. 
 But won't I need a Solicitor? 
 A. YES. 
 There are complex legal matters involved which need the experienced guiding hand of a good solicitor who will do a thorough job and we are able to recommend excellent local ones experienced in the area. 
 Q. Will I need a survey? 
 A. We recommend it, and our surveyors are on hand to help. 
 If we are selling the property we are able to recommend other surveyors to you. 
 Fees vary according to the price of your property and the type of survey involved &mdash; we'll give you plenty of advice. 
 See feature on page 10 
 Q. Will anything else cost me money? 
 A. Stamp duty is payable (currently at 1%) on any property purchased at over &pound;30,000. 
 Our sales negotiators will tell you exactly what costs are involved. 
 Q. Fine. 
 Now I want to look at some properties. 
 This is the part I'm looking forward to! 
 A. We like this part too. 
 You will get clear, concise particulars of properties in your range &mdash; choose the ones which interest you most and we'll make arrangements for you to see them. 
 Q. What do I have to do when I find a house I like? 
 A. Just let Adkin know as soon as possible. 
 If you like the house the chances are that other people will like it too, so speed is of the essence. 
 Our negotiator will take the necessary details from you, forward your intention to purchase to the vendor and tie up all the details. 
 Q. Surely there are all sorts of problems that can happen? 
 A. There are, but we've been in this business for nearly 200 years and pride ourselves  in  the fact that we have probably dealt with every known problem that has ever arisen. 
 But remember, if you have any query, no matter how trivial, please ask us &mdash; we're here to help you.  
 HAPPY HOUSE HUNTING 
 CONVEYANCING 
 With the introduction of the new conveyancing scheme the legal process of acquiring a home should be made  a lot  easier. 
 It was the solicitor's function to investigate the draft contract and to examine very closely the issues which may be raised by it which were often incomprehensible to the layman. 
 Now homemoving legalities have hopefully been completely revolutionised by the new scheme. 
 On 21st March 1990 a new conveyancing scheme was launched, which aims to make buying and selling homes straightforward and comprehensible. 
 It is called TransAction . 
 TransAction  clients will be provided with an organisational file and a guide to home-moving to inform them of what exactly is being done on their behalf at every stage. 
 All TransAction  documentation has been approved by Clarity (The lawyers' campaign for the use of plain English) and words like &bquo;vendor&equo; and &bquo;purchaser&equo; are replaced by &bquo;seller&equo; and &bquo;buyer&equo;. 
 TransAction  introduces important procedural changes for the home-moving consumer. 
 Firstly, the local authority search and all standard information about the property will now be obtained by the seller's solicitor at the beginning of the process, so that when it comes to buying a property all the initial legal information will be available and in place. 
 TransAction  should, therefore, reduce delays and make it easier for the consumer to understand the process in partnership with their solicitors. 
 Secondly, TransAction  introduces a clearer approach to fixtures and fittings in order that both parties know exactly what is to be bought and sold. 
 TransAction  has been enthusiastically received by the Consumers' Association, the Lord Chancellors and the Land Registry. 
 Their comments were as follows: 
 The Consumers' Association gives three cheers for the new house buying and selling system &mdash; TransAction . 
 This will bring in reforms of the kind which the Consumers' Association have been campaigning for over many a long year. 
 We think it is going to achieve two key improvements in the house transfer process: It will speed things up and will improve the standards of service to the customer. 
 The Lord Chancellor said that the new conveyancing scheme, &bquo;seems to me to show what the Law Society can do by way of setting appropriate standards of service to the public. 
 I hope that solicitors will be quick to adopt the new system in the interests of their existing and potential clients&equo;. 
 Mr. E.J. Pryer, The Chief Land  Register  at the Land Registry commented: &bquo; TransAction &equo; together with the steady improvements being effected by the Registry, should produce a speedier conveyancing service for the public.&equo;  
 DAMP PROOFING YOUR HOME 
 THE WHY &amp; HOW OF DAMP PROOFING YOUR HOME 
 If you are buying a house more than thirty years old, you would be well advised to instruct a specialist company to inspect the property for timber defects and/or rising damp. 
 Nowadays, there are many such service companies to choose from but it is essential that you s elect a company that is a member of the British Wood Preserving Association (B.W.P.A.) and British Chemical Dampcourse Association (B.C.D.A.). 
 These bodies insist that their members work to the highest standards set out in the relevant Codes of Practice and strongly recommend that their surveyors are qualified by becoming a Certified Timber Infestation Surveyor (CTIS) and Certificated Remedial Damp-proofing Surveyor (CRDS). 
 PASS &amp; Co.  carry out without cost or obligation a detailed survey for TIMBER INFESTATION and RISING DAMP; a comprehensive report coupled together with estimated cost of eradication will be sent, in most cases, within 24 hours of notification. 
 On completion of timber treatment or chemical damp coursing the contractor will normally issue a long-term guarantee, but the number of unqualified contractors offering these guarantees for timber treatment and dampcoursing has increased rapidly and this section of the building industry is high on the list of Company failures. 
 PASS &amp; CO.  have over thirty years experience in prevention and preservation work in houses and are a member of the Professional Associations that control and regulate this work. 
 Our professional surveyors reports are accepted by Building Societies and Banks as is our remedial work, and this work is covered by a 30 year PASS &amp; CO. 
 Guarantee. 
 This guarantee is further supported by a 30 year Guarantee from Remtox Chemicals Ltd. 
 ADKIN PROPERTY AUCTIONS 
 Adkin have sold properties by auction since the firm was established in 1793 and today our Property Auction Department is able to offer the specialist skills and advice required to value, market and dispose of assets by auction. 
 We presently organise regular collective auctions comprising of a wide variety of properties located throughout Oxfordshire and recent sales have included: 
 RESIDENTIAL PROPERTIES FOR REDEVELOPMENT 
 BUILDING PLOT 
 DEVELOPMENT LAND 
 BARNS FOR CONVERSION 
 FARMS AND FARM LAND 
 COUNTRY HOUSES 
 PROPERTIES FOR CONVERSION TO FLATS 
 PROPERTIES SOLD ON BEHALF OF TRUSTEES &amp; EXECUTORS 
 Our services include the preparation of detailed particulars, plans and photographs, site surveys, liaison with our clients solicitors, comprehensive advertising, viewings and provision of auction room facilities. 
 Sales of individual properties can always be arranged if required. 
 For further information please contact the head of our Property Auction Department Mr. J.A. 
 Sayers ARICS, FAAV on (0235) 26080.    
 ADKIN PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 
 Sometime in the future you may wish to let your home whilst you are away for six months or more. 
 We appreciate your concern in allowing &bquo;strangers&equo; to live in your home but it is better to have your home cared for rather than leaving it empty. 
 We are able to offer you a comprehensive letting and management service which was created to suit all needs. 
 ADKIN RESIDENTIAL PROPERTY MANAGEMENT 
 Adkin Residential Property Management is a specialist department dealing with the Letting and Management of a large number of properties throughout Oxfordshire. 
 It is a comprehensive professional service based at our computer-linked offices in Oxford, Abingdon and Harwell. 
 WHY PROFESSIONAL MANAGEMENT? 
 Your home is probably your most valuable possession and, as such, should be entrusted to the care and supervision of a reputable Company who will, at all times, be responsible directly to you &mdash; the owner. 
 We are happy to visit you to discuss individual requirements and advise on all aspects of letting, including: 
 The rental value of the property 
 Preparing the property for letting 
 The correct form of Tenancy Agreement to protect your interests 
 Details of our comprehensive and caring Management services 
 Like all other departments we have been established a very long time and therefore have the experience and the knowledge in dealing with lettings. 
 You will no doubt appreciate that letting property today is very complex and governed by so much legislation that it is essential you enjoy a competent Managing Agent. 
 As part of our service we attend to all the legalities therefore ensuring the return of your property to you. 
 Our management services have one common factor and that is CARE . 
 We take care in our selection of tenants and we take care of your home in every respect. 
 CARE  in the selection of tenants 
 CARE  in the preparation of the Inventory 
 CARE  in the drawing up the Agreements and Rent Act Notices 
 CARE  in all aspects of our administration and management. 
 THE FIRST STEP 
 Whether you are moving to another part of the country or going abroad let us know as soon as possible so that we can publicise details of your property to maximum effect. 
 Once ADKIN has been instructed our full Management Services will apply and we would 
 Add details of your property to our property and mailing lists. 
 We also advertise in the leading Oxon newspapers and the lists can be obtained at all ADKIN offices 
 Introduce and carefully screen suitable tenants 
 Collect rents, deal with arrears, maintain and render quarterly or monthly accounts 
 Deal with your routine property expenses such as Rates, Insurance Premiums etc. 
 Arrange repairs if and when necessary 
 Carry out regular inspections 
 Adkin Residential Property Management is a specialist department dealing with the Letting and Management of a large number of properties throughout Oxfordshire. 
 It is a comprehensive professional service based at our computer-linked offices in Oxford, Abingdon and Harwell. 
 WHAT WILL IT COST? 
 Professional fees for our Management Services are moderate &mdash; taking into account the peace of mind and sense of security engendered. 
 We are pleased to offer a choice of four Services to match the varying personal requirements of Landlords. 
 Letting Service &mdash; aimed at Landlords who wish to manage the properties themselves Equivalent to 4 weeks' rent 
 One Star Management 12.5% commission of the gross rent charged 
 Two Star Management 15% commission of the gross rent charged 
 Three Star Management 17.5% commission of the gross rent charged 
 Our staff are fully experienced in all aspects of letting and they will be more than pleased to answer any queries which you may have. 
 In the event of you wishing to let your property please do not hesitate to contact us by telephone for further details of our services, at any of the undermentioned offices:   
 We never stop caring! 
 Kitchens in their true colours 
 Formed in September 1987 by Harvey Wilson, Martin Glick and Alan Sheldon &mdash; three of the most knowledgeable people in the kitchen manufacturing industry with 50 years experience between them &mdash; Wilson &amp; Glick Kitchens promise to be one of the most striking success stories of the 1990's. 
 Higher quality at lower prices&equo; is the reassuring promise made in their advertisements and a ten year guarantee &mdash; as opposed to the normal one year  guarantee &mdash; is what Wilson &amp; Glick are committed to. 
 As Harvey Wilson, says, &bquo;Nobody puts their name to a business they're not proud of and, by the same token, it gives the customer confidence to know that somebody is accountable at the end of the day&hellip; that they are dealing with a company that is owned and run by the people whose names appear on the top of letterhead.&equo; 
 By identifying these two fundamental factors and offering a realistic proposition (higher quality at lower prices), rather than a &bquo;free&equo; this or a &bquo;free&equo; that, Wilson &amp; Glick have already gained the confidence of hundreds of satisfied customers for whom value for money and quality at an affordable price are the main criteria. 
 There are thirteen ranges, each manufactured to the highest standard, available. 
 Deliberately setting out to offer higher quality at lower prices, Wilson &amp; Glick kitchens include many features normally found only in the most expensive European kitchens. 
 Solid beech lined drawers that run on easy glide telescopic roller slides, thick (18mm) easy-to-maintain side panels and base shelves, 40mm thick work surfaces, spring loaded hinges which close at a touch, and cabinets that stand on their own (individually adjustable) four feet to ensure absolute stability on even the most uneven floors, are just some of the standard features that make Wilson &amp; Glick Kitchens one of the most successful companies in the UK since its formation in 1987.  
 PIONEERS OF A NEW PROCESS 
 Hand dragged furniture had been around since the 18th century. 
 It demands considerable skills to achieve the delicate balance required between the painted finish and the natural grain of the timber. 
 And as a consequence, it has always been prohibitively expensive. 
 But this situation is about to change, thanks to a pioneering new process, now made available to you by Wilson &amp; Glick. 
 The wood used goes through eight different stages, before it's hand-finished and sealed. 
  The  result has all the colourful character of other hand dragged kitchens, but with a very real and visible bonus. 
 Instead of being largely obscured, as it is in the conventional process, the beautiful grain of the timber is highlighted to stunning effect. 
 Each one  is  custom built and fitted by our own appointed craftsmen. 
 Beneath their beautiful, colourful finish, the high standards applied in selecting the timber are immediately apparent. 
 And as in all their kitchens, they're made from extra thick, heavy-weight materials. 
 Features like these are characteristic of their commitment to higher quality, at lower prices. 
 WILSON &amp; GLICK AND BRITISH GAS 
 Even Better &bquo;The Second Time Around&equo; 
 Following the tremendous success of Wilson &amp; Glick kitchens on the British Gas stand at the 1989 Ideal Home Exhibition, Wilson &amp; Glick once again played a major role on the British Gash stand at this year's exhibition. 
 With two brand new kitchens on view; &bquo;Westminster&equo;, which is available in three colourways &mdash; nearly-black anthracite, pearlised white and rich cream with a metallic lustre &mdash; as well as &bquo;Chippenham&equo;, providing limed oak luxury, Wilson &amp; Glick now have 13 kitchens in their range, 7 of which were on show to the public. 
 By adhering to their policy of providing &bquo;higher quality at lower prices&equo;, coupled with a total design and installation service with delivery within a week to ten days, Wilson &amp; Glick have maintained a continuous growth in sales since the company was formed in 1987, despite the current down turn in the market generally. 
 Many features distinguish Wilson &amp; Glick kitchens from others in a similar price bracket, making them exceptionally good value for money, as could be seen at the Ideal Home Exhibition which was even more successful &bquo;the second time around&equo;. 
 WILSON &amp; GLICK FACTS 
 SIDE PANELS and base shelves are constructed from 18mm (&frac34;&ins;) thick high density particle board. 
 WORK SURFACES are 40mm thick. 
 CABINETS are all available in either white or woodgrain finish to co-ordinate with the front door finish. 
 EDGES, including rear and underneath, are protected with matching melamine, ensuring protection against moisture  absorption . 
 BACK PANELS are in matching melamine faced hardboard. 
 PLINTHS, manufactured in melamine faced particle board, are edged all round, and supplied in continuous lengths of up to 3000mm. 
 DRAWERS are manufactured from solid beech hardwood and are mounted on easy glide telescopic roller slides 
 BASE CABINETS AND TALL UNITS have adjustable legs, which ensure absolute stability on even the most uneven of floors 
 SPRING LOADED HINGES made from solid metal open the doors to any angle (up to 90 degrees) and will close automatically at a touch 
 WALL UNITS have 2 fully adjustable internal shelves, extra deep carcases of 320mm deep and a fully adjustable wall hanging bracket which ensures perfect alignment of cupboard and ease of installation. 
 DRAWER packs have 3 drawers plus 1 extra deep pan drawer. 
 A FULL 10 YEAR GUARANTEE is automatically provided. 
 SERVICES: planning (including home visits) and installation 
 DELIVERY: 1 week&ndash;10 days 
 PURPOSE GROWN TIMBERS from North America, Scandinavia and Italy are used for the wooden kitchen ranges 
 THE WOODLAND TRUST is actively supported by Wilson &amp; Glick 
 The latest range from Wilson &amp; Glick with the looks and quality of its European counterpart. 
 Called &bquo;Westminster&equo;, it is available in three finishes including anthracite &mdash; a very-nearly black silky grey, as shown, with sleek easy-to-hold silver handles. 
 Chrome accessories include fashionable bar rails, 2-tier vegetable baskets on roller runners, a bottle rack, a cup rack and a 3-tier spice rack. 
 And &bquo;kiddie&equo; catches&equo; which lock base unit doors as if by magic (but with a magnet) can also be fitted. 
 Wilson and Glick have now added this most luxurious of timbers to their range of kitchens. 
 And the glamorous good looks of the &bquo;Chippenham&equo; kitchen ensure that it will be equally at home in the town as in the country. 
 One of two new ranges to be introduced this summer, both &bquo;Chippenham&equo; and &bquo;Melrose&equo; (dark and handsome in solid oak) carry the Wilson &amp; Glick ten year guarantee. 
 Giving added sophistication to a range of kitchens where the emphasis is on quality, the turned wood spindles, galleried shelves, a dresser with bevelled glass doors, and the intricate touch of fretwork that can be seen in the photograph, are all features that make these two ranges very special indeed. 
 The glamour of limed oak &mdash; creating an atmosphere that seems to belong entirely in the country. 
 The very best in kitchen technology &mdash; details showing the Westminster range fashioned with finest ash-grained laminated. 
 ADKIN AGRICULTURAL 
 Adkin have been involved in handling all aspects of agricultural property and chattels since the firm was established in 1793. 
 As the  agricultural  industry has changed so have we. 
 With our specialist team based at Abingdon we offer a full range of services including: 
 SALES &amp; VALUATION OF LAND, FARM &amp; OTHER RURAL PROPERTY. 
 VALUATIONS FOR PROBATE &amp; TAXATION PURPOSES. 
 ADVICE, PLANS AND APPRAISALS FOR LEISURE SCHEMES. 
 PLANNING FOR BUILDING CONVERSION &amp; ALTERNATIVE USES. 
 SCHEMES FOR POLLUTION CONTROL AND FARM IMPROVEMENTS. 
 COMPENSATION CLAIMS FOR ROAD IMPROVEMENTS &amp; PIPELINE SCHEMES. 
 SALES AND APPORTIONMENT OF MILK QUOTA. 
 RENT REVIEW NEGOTIATIONS. 
 SALES OF HAY, STRAW &amp; GRASS KEEP. 
 LAND, BUILDING &amp; SITE SURVEYS. 
 INSOLVENCY SALES. 
 ADKIN FINANCIAL SERVICES 
 Adkin Financial Services offers comprehensive financial advice and support to clients of Adkin based on the extensive experience and know-how of its professional staff. 
 Each of our advisors is registered with Fimbra, the Financial Intermediaries Managers and Brokers Regulatory Association and as such has to meet high standards of knowledge, experience and professional competence. 
 In short, our status as Independent Financial Advisors means we must always give you the best possible advice regarding your options in the financial marketplace. 
 If you are looking for a mortgage we can recommend the cheapest, the largest or the most flexible without you needing to take up valuable time researching the market yourself. 
 If you are looking for a pension or other financial advice we can similarly give you information and guidance to make the right decision. 
 The whole service is designed to save you both time and money in arriving at the correct long term decision. 
 What do we charge for this service? &mdash; generally nothing, as our costs are normally covered by commissions payable on business that we introduce but we provide you with a full statement of our Terms of Business before any transaction takes place. 
 HOME SECURITY 
 BY THAMES VALLEY POLICE 
 Don't wait until you are burgled before you do something to make your home more secure. 
 You've  bought  your new home, and no doubt that has meant new carpets or new curtains or maybe a new fitted kitchen because you want your home to be comfortable. 
 So imagine how you would feel if someone breaks into your new home and destroys or steals the very things you are proud of, the things you have worked hard to buy. 
 The chances are you've not yet considered the security of your home, not a lot of people do &mdash;  it's  at the bottom of a long list of priorities. 
 Basic security need not cost a fortune but will be effective against opportunist burglars. 
 DOOR LOCKS 
 A cheap lock is  child's  play for a thief. 
 Invest in a good deadlock (up to British Standard &mdash; look for the Kitemark!) for your front door. 
 Good locks aren't cheap&hellip; unless you compare them with the sort of loss and distress even a minor burglary can cause. 
 Now the front door is secure &mdash; don't let them in at the back! 
 Put strong bolts at the top and bottom of all outside doors, the Mortice Security bolt is one of the best type available and can not be opened from the outside of the door. 
 Don't forget patio doors either. 
 The fitting of additional security locks top and bottom is essential for all round protection. 
 Finally when moving into a new house it pays to replace door locks &mdash; you don't know who has previously had a key!! 
 WINDOWS 
 Fasten your windows when you leave the house? 
 Of course you do. 
 But simple latches are no problems to a thief &mdash; if you lock yourself out you will soon see why. 
 Window locks are an essential deterrent to the opportunist, while they will be prepared to break a small area of glass and reach in to open the catch, they will think twice about smashing a whole pane &mdash; as  it's  very noisy and dangerous. 
 There's a lock for every kind of window, not forgetting upstairs, bathroom windows for instance, are often near drain pipes. 
 BEWARE OF STRANGE CALLERS 
 Everyone should have a chain fixed to the front door. 
 You should fasten it before opening the door to check the identity of callers. 
 Most officials  carry   an  ID card, so ask to see it, genuine callers will understand. 
 A door viewer is useful as well, you can see who's outside without opening the door. 
 If you see a stranger acting suspiciously outside your home or your neighbours (especially if they are  away  on holiday) call the police. 
 They won't mind if  it's  a false alarm, and you could prevent a burglary. 
 DON'T HELP THE THIEF 
 Keep garages and sheds locked. 
 A thief would find a ladder and tools very useful to break into your house. 
 If you can't keep your ladder in a shed or garage, padlock it to something secure and never leave a key &bquo;hidden&equo; outside. 
 The thief knows where to find it. 
 If you want free advice on how to make your home secure, contact the Crime Prevention Officer at your local Police Station. 
 CHECK LIST 
 1. 
 Are you careful not to leave spare cash in the house? 
 (It's safest in the bank, post office or building society.) 
 2. 
 Could you describe your property if it was stolen? 
 (Keep note of serial numbers on TVs etc. 
 Photograph valuable jewellery or antiques.) 
 3. 
 Have you marked all your property with your postcode and house number? 
 (Use a security marker pen containing invisible ink and detectable only under ultra-violet light. 
 Available from most good stationers.) 
 4. 
 When you go out in the evening do you always draw the curtains and leave a light on? 
 (In a room, not the hall.) 
 5. 
 Do you remember to cancel all deliveries when you go on holiday? 
 (A build-up of milk or papers is a real give-away.) 
 6. 
 Does a neighbour keep an  eye  on your house while you are away? 
 (Try to leave an address and telephone number.) 
 7. 
 Are you a good neighbour? 
 Would you ring the police if you saw something suspicious? 
 (The police prefer false alarms to thefts.) 
 ADKIN NEW HOMES 
 Adkin New Homes Department has been established for twenty years, servicing a wide selection of large and small developments throughout Oxfordshire on behalf of our builder clients. 
 The Head Office is based at Abingdon with a further three branches operating from Didcot, Wallingford and Witney. 
 Adkin New Homes is able to offer a comprehensive service to Developers in conjunction with its allied Land, Planning and Financial Services departments. 
 In the current market, availability of funds presents no problem for house purchase; many fixed rate mortgages are on offer from a wide range of lending institutions enabling prospective purchasers to stabilise their out-goings for the next one to two years. 
 Large developments by Beazer, Wimpey, Berkeley, Crest, Durkan, Prowting, Trencherwood, Salthorp and Penta have been successfully sold or are currently being marketed by Adkin New Homes branches spread over Oxfordshire. 
 There are also many smaller select developments currently under construction by a wide range of local builder clients. 
 The recently completed and award winning St Mary's Field development in Wallingford by Salthorp attracted a great amount of attention during its construction. 
 An imaginative mix of 1, 2 and 4 bedroomed units incorporating great flair in their design proved to be a winning formula for everyone involved. 
 This year saw the completion of 45 quality 2 and 3 bedroomed homes in picturesque Bampton on the fringe of the Cotswolds by Stanley Hugh Leach. 
 A steady demand was maintained during the building programme with prospective purchasers queuing on occasions to avoid disappointment. 
 Prestige developments, particularly Abingdon Marina, which is now well advanced into its 5th phase offers a comprehensive choice of quality waterside homes set in idyllic tranquil surroundings. 
 Ranging from 2 bedroomed apartments at around &pound;130,000 to &pound;145,000 to varying styles of 3, 4 and 5 bedroomed detached houses most residents will have direct water frontage or moorings in the Marina. 
 Six spacious executive homes by Berkeley at Brightwell near Wallingford have also been well received by early visitors to the site. 
 Similarly Crest Homes Colegrove Down development of 21 luxury 4 and 5 bedroomed residences on Cumnor Hill Oxford has recently commenced and is also impressing the public with its exceptional elevated location and high standard of finish. 
 We are pleased to be the appointed agents for several interesting sites countywide currently on offer by Trencherwood. 
 Ranging from 1 bedroomed starter units through to 4 bedroomed family homes there is always a wide choice available to suit most purchasers. 
 The sales of several prestigious sheltered housing and retirement schemes have recently featured prominently through Adkin New Homes. 
 The highly acclaimed Herringcote development at  Dorchester-on-Thames by Beechcroft, together with a similar select retirement scheme which is now under construction at Woodstock by the same company. 
 The picturesque Sweetbriar development by Manordock comprising 27 cottages and flats with resident Manager in the sought after village of Marcham is also well advanced. 
 We have recently completed the sale of 54 cottages, bungalows and flats in central Didcot, built by Secure Retirement, the development being the first of its kind in the Town. 
 Several new interesting development projects are scheduled for the forthcoming year notably sixty-nine 1, 2 and 3 bedroomed houses and flats by Salthorp at Milton Heights near Abingdon, Forty-four 1&ndash;4 bedroomed units by Ideal Homes at Crowmarsh, Gifford and several further phases of larger sites currently under construction. 
 Eight 1 bedroomed flats close to the town centre at Wallingford by J Smallbone and Sons together with many other individual and small prestige developments for local client developers throughout the County of Oxfordshire are also planned for the near future.  
 About Oxfordshire 
 WOODSTOCK, WITNEY, KIDLINGTON &amp; BICESTER 
 Lying just North and East of the city of Oxford is the fertile agricultural country of the Cherwell and Windrush river valleys. 
 This area is rich in historic houses, such as the magnificent Blenheim Palace, and honey-coloured stone cottages clustered in scenic Cotswold villages. 
 Situated between the Oxford canal, a 90 mile waterway (built in the 1780's) that links the Midlands to Oxford, and the River Cherwell lies the town of Kidlington. 
 Only 5 miles north of Oxford, Kidlington belies its modern appearance for it once was an ancient settlement, and in some quiet corners, it still retains vestiges of a village past. 
 Ancient landmarks, that remind the inhabitants of its past are the church, which is part thirteenth century and which is primarily noted for its soaring spire. 
 Also, both the vicarage and Rectory farm can trace their origins back to the 1500's. 
 Although there is some commercial and industrial development, modern Kidlington is now primarily more a residential area and serves Oxford as a dormitory with its own shopping and leisure centres. 
 Bisecting Oxford and Bicester is the M40, due to be completed in Spring 1991, and though only about thirteen miles away Bicester has obviously evolved into its own entity. 
 From sixth century beginnings Bicester gradually grew into a focus for an area separate from Oxford, and during the Middle Ages it was granted various licenses for markets and fairs. 
 By the 1700s, there were no less than seven annual fairs which mainly reflected the specialized industries that had developed. 
 There are a number of surviving features from that Old Bicester, mostly found near the Market Place, including half-timbered sixteenth and seventeenth century houses, two coaching inns &mdash; The Kings Arms and the Swan &mdash; and, above all, St. Edburg's church with its proud pinnacled tower. 
 Although dating from the 1400s, it incorporates elements from earlier times; mainly a Saxon arch. 
 Bicester is also a well known hunting centre with a hunt dating back to the late 1700s. 
 The Army established its ordnance depot in Bicester in 1941, and as a result the town is the second largest population centre in the Cherwell district, yet, despite that expansion the town essentially remains a market town serving its rich agricultural hinterland. 
 Sited ten miles west of Oxford is the small market town of Witney. 
 Its heritage goes back to when &bquo;The Witan&equo;, or the council of the Saxon kings, established the significance of Witney when they chose the then village as a meeting place in the  10th.  and  11th.  centuries. 
 Later, in the Middle Ages, the main London to Gloucester road passed through Witney, which was a further contribution to its economic prosperity. 
 The town has been producing wool, cloth, and blankets since the  13th.  century and much of its prosperity today is still founded on those industries. 
 The town centre, west of the Windrush river, was first laid out by the Bishop of Winchester in the early  13th.  century, and is considered to be a fine example of medieval town planning. 
 The Market Square, which lies at the junction of the two main streets, contains the Butter Cross, a medieval meeting place which has a steeply gabled roof surmounted by a clock turret from 1683. 
 Opposite from the Butter Cross, the  18th.  century Town Hall is built above a piazza. 
 Market Square widens into Church Green, which is dominated by the tower and spire of the  13th.  century Church of St. Mary. 
 Pollarded lime trees and Georgian houses surround the green. 
 In the High Street is the  18th.  century Blanket hall, which was built by the Witney Blanket Weavers Company for weighing and measuring the locally made blankets. 
 On the road to Woodstock and Bicester lies Woodgreen, an  18th.  century residential suburb. 
 This area contains some of the best designed and well-kept Georgian houses in the town, as well as a  19th.  century blanket warehouse which has been converted into flats, all grouped round a small green. 
 Eight miles North-west from Oxford on the southern edge of the  Cotswolds is Woodstock. 
 It is a charming and prosperous town renowned for its unspoilt,  18th.  century buildings. 
 The town was believed to have been founded in 1163 though most of the surviving old buildings date from the  16th.  and  17th.  centuries. 
 Its present appearance today owes a great deal to the Duke of Marlborough who in 1704 remodelled the town. 
 The main streets offer dignified Georgian facades whilst the narrow lanes behind abound with charming old cottages. 
 These cottages were once the abodes of the workers in the famous glove-making industry on which the town first prospered, yet it is probably tourism that is the town's major attraction now. 
 In Woodstock town centre is situated the famous Oxfordshire County Museum, which vividly displays the Oxfordshire landscape and how the lives of its inhabitants have changed over the centuries. 
 It is an intriguing picture of how local industries have developed, and how that has affected the people who worked within it. 
 A similar type of museum is Cogges Manor Farm Museum near Witney which provides a working window on the landscape, buildings and people of Oxfordshire. 
 Cogges was recorded as a flourishing hamlet in the Domesday Book. 
 The Manor House itself dates from the  13th.  century but it has now been restored to portray how this ancient building was the centre of a thriving farm at the turn of the century. 
 The area abounds in historical reminders, perhaps none more   important  than  Islip, where the rivers Ray and Cherwell meet. 
 It is a site of a Roman villa and a Saxon palace; it is the birthplace of Edward the Confessor, and was the site of a Royalist garrison during the Civil War. 
 There have been two battles at Islip during the English Civil War, in 1644 and 1645, which both resulted in Royalist defeats. 
 Ot Moor just a couple of miles east of Islip is a low-lying wilderness area of 6 square miles, mainly of wet marshlands, which proves to be a great attraction to naturalists. 
 Though, the jewel in the crown for the whole of the area must be Blenheim Palace. 
 It was built for John Churchill, the First Duke of Marlborough in recognition of his great victory over the French at the battle of Blenheim in 1704. 
 The Palace was designed by Sir John Vanbrugh, took 18 years to build and covers an area of 7 acres. 
 The Long Library, almost 200 ft. long is considered to be the room of the most outstanding beauty for it contains over 10,000 books plus various paintings by Van Dyck and Reynolds. 
 The grounds, 2000 acres of parkland,  was  designed by the famous Capability Brown which contains a large man-made lake crossed by the Grand Bridge designed by Vanbrugh and is reputed to be the finest bridge in Europe. 
 Oxford itself, the &bquo;city of dreaming spires&equo; as  John Betjeman  eulogised  it  is only a few miles away with all its many and varied attractions. 
 This area is rich indeed.  
 The GRAND BRIDGE (BLENHEIM PALACE) &mdash; Photograph supplied courtesy of Wolf Lithographs on behalf of Blenheim Palace. 
 BLENHEIM PALACE &mdash; photographs supplied courtesy of Blenheim Palace. 
 IMPROVING YOUR NEW HOME 
 Investing in quality home improvements is not difficult, but there are guidelines which you should take care to follow. 
 Hopefully the new home which you are now considering as a prospective purchase will be suitable for your needs in every way, but it may well be that a need for some renovation or refurbishment is indicated from the surveyor's report or that you will wish to make improvements or alterations of your own. 
 Unless you have a fair experience of building handicrafts and a lot of time on your hands, you will probably need to hire a builder, and you should take as much care over this as possible since the quality of building work varies very substantially indeed, and two different firms of builders, next to each other in the &bquo;Yellow Pages&equo; may reflect totally different standards and attitudes. 
 The most important thing to obtain is a recommendation. 
 If a friend has had work done by a particular building firm and found them reliable, honest and efficient it is likely that you will too. 
 If you are new in the area your estate agent will be pleased to recommend a firm whom they know to be reputable. 
 All the suppliers of building services represented in this brochure have been selected from amongst those recommended by established local opinion as being reliable and reasonable. 
 When you have decided exactly what work needs to be done, you should obtain several quotations for the job. 
 Remember that quotations and estimates are not the same thing, and that a low estimate can very easily turn into a high bill. 
 It is worth your while to obtain detailed quotations at the outset and to insist upon a further quotation for any work which may be added to the schedule as you go along. 
 Don't necessarily accept the lowest quotation: you are likely to pay more for professionalism and thoroughness. 
 There is no need to pay in advance for the work even if you are asked to do so; you may be in an awkward position if the firm ceases to trade without having completed the job. 
 If the company you have hired cannot obtain materials from a builder's merchant without any advance payment there is something wrong. 
 If it is a very large contract then it may be reasonable for the builder to ask for interim payments as the work progresses, and you can discuss this with him at the outset. 
 You are, of course, protected by law. 
 Builders must finish the job in a proper and workmanlike fashion and must use suitable materials &mdash; you have a claim if these principles are not adhered to, and if you can establish shoddy or negligent work it is possible that the courts will award damages for inconvenience caused in addition to the cost of rectifying the initial problem. 
 This should be a last resort however, as legal action may be costly and, more importantly, time-consuming, particularly if the case is contested. 
 If you follow the principles laid down at the beginning of this feature then you should have no problem. 
 Remember that if you hire a builder with a large stetson hat and a six shooter you might very easily reach a situation where, &bquo;The house ain't big enough for both of you.&equo;  
 CALL IN THE EXPERTS 
 Most who drive cars would agree that does not make us expert mechanics. 
  People's  view of building is often somewhat different, and many feel savings can be made by not expending money on  architect's  fees. 
 Architects may in fact save you money. 
 The case of the two-storey extension, that as a result of an Architects advice, became a single storey extension with internal rearrangements at 60% of the budgeted cost illustrating the point. 
 Imagination saved money and easily covered the fee. 
 The point you want to arrive at, is getting what you want at the price you can afford. 
 To get there via the complexity of legislation, contractual pitfalls, constructional problems and costing complexities let aside evaluating design possibilities needs skill, knowledge and commitment, certainly it can take a considerable amount of time. 
 The role of the Architect is to provide such a service. 
 The title Architect is protected by law and can only be used by those appropriately qualified and registered. 
 It implies a duty to provide expert advice. 
 Those who provide architectural services are however often not Architects. 
 Architects will provide partial services to advise you on the condition of a property you are interested in. 
 The service provided, and fee are matters to discuss initially with an Architect, ranging in cost from a few pounds upwards. 
 Purchase of property is a major expenditure for everyone. 
 Even with an Architect, problems may arise and it is then many people have found out how pleased they were to have an Architect at hand to turn to.  
 Living Space 
 DUVETS &amp; FURNISHINGS 
 A co-ordinated lifestyle that enhances &amp; enriches your living space, providing that individual stamp of luxury. 
 Since the introduction of the duvet to this country in the early 1970's, the duvet has become the most popular form of bedwear. 
 Perhaps, the most appealing factor of a duvet is its apparent lightness which also retains a great deal of warmth. 
 Long gone are those piles of suffocating heavy blankets needed to keep warm in bed at the height of winter coldness and the arduous task of bedmaking. 
 Lightweight and snug, simple yet practical, the duvet epitomises the continental style of sleeping. 
 Duvet warmth is measured in &bquo;togs&equo; ranging in scale from 4.5 tog to 13.5 tog. 
 The higher the tog value of your duvet the warmer it will be. 
 You can purchase two kinds of  duvet, polyester filled or natural. 
 Most polyester duvets contain the most technically advanced non-allergenic filling which have the advantage of being machine washable. 
 Natural filled duvets are more expensive and those filled with duck down, are considered the ultimate in luxury duvets. 
 All duvets need covers to keep them clean and as a result designers have had virtual carte blanche in producing happy and aesthetic designs for the covers. 
 They are produced in a multiple of shades which allow the greatest scope for individual expression. 
 There are the traditional floral designs of an English classical style that evoke associations with days of yore. 
 Or, in great contrast, there are the more modern abstract designs that might not look out of place displayed on a wall. 
 Dorma is one of the leading home furnishing companies that produce duvet covers. 
 Their &bquo;Croscill&equo; and &bquo;Jenny Wren&equo; ranges epitomise the traditional style; pink roses gaily festooned in abundance, and Victorian memories to the fore. 
 The &bquo;Directions&equo; range is a bold step towards the future; stripes and motifs providing dramatic effects. 
 The &bquo;Jay Yang&equo; range takes its inspiration from the Far East with traditional floral designs with striking background colours creating the drama of the Eastern world. 
 The &bquo;Fine Arts&equo; range are more subdued designs; more feminine in their appeal, the colours muted. 
 From the independent design house of Munro &amp; Tutty come the designs, with their primary colours, that attempt to recreate the effects of  lazy hot summers, and an adjunct, &bquo;Country Diary&equo; wish to echo those long hot days and bountiful harvests. 
 And, as a matter of course, all duvet covers are matched with similarly designed pillowcases. 
 You can give the bedroom its total co-ordinated look by flat, fitted and valance sheets, cushions and bolsters, choosing from the wide range of bed dressings available, the superb selection of window dressings, wall-coverings and light fittings. 
 With such a wide range of bed dressings available today it is possible to choose a sleeping system most suitable for your personal requirements and allows you to experiment with new looks and styles in the bedroom. 
 Embellished duvets have become popular recently. 
 These are lightweight, throw-over designs with permanent covers. 
 They are quilted in different patterns and trimmed with frills. 
 They can be used in summer on their own over a top sheet and in winter over a quilt or blanket. 
 Dorma have carefully endeavoured to provide a discriminating range of duvet covers and bedwear that will reflect every mood and enhance every possible bedroom style. 
 But, Dorma have taken a very important step in helping you, the customer, to design your own unique bedroom environment. 
 You can now buy matching coordinates in most of the ranges that can give the room a total individual look. 
 These products span from the wallpaper itself, through to curtains, pelmets, friezes, blinds, windows and a new range of lighting styles.  
 Fabric in &bquo;Harriet&equo; and &bquo;Victoria&equo; from the Jenny Wren Collection by Dorma 
 &bquo;Wallace&equo; from the Munro &amp; Tutty Collections by Dorma. 
 Frilled quilt covers are priced from &pound;36.99; frilled pillowcases at &pound;10.99 each; fitted valance sheets from &pound;28.99; curtains from &pound;35.99 a pair (54&ins; drop); and a wallborder frieze at &pound;4.99 a roll. 
 &bquo;Harriet&equo; from the Jenny Wren Collection by Dorma, available as a lace-frilled decot duvet from &pound;99.99, lace-frilled pillow shams at &pound;24.99 each, a lace frilled flat sheet from &pound;29.99, a fitted sheet from &pound;19.99 and a valance from &pound;27.99. 
 At the window are luxurious Satin Finesse curtains from &pound;43.99 a pair, tie-backs at &pound;15.99 a pair, and a festoon pelmet at &pound;29.99. 
 These are complemented by a festoon blind available from Swish. 
 &bquo;Harriet&equo; also comes as wall-covering at &pound;6.99 a roll, a 10-inch deep wallpaper frieze at &pound;6.50 a roll, square, round and bolster lace-frilled cushion covers at &pound;11.99, and a mushroom pleated lampshade (not shown) at &pound;16.99. 
 &bquo;Isadora&equo; from the Munro &amp; Tutty Collection by Dorma. 
 Embellished quilt covers are priced from &pound;29.99; embellished pillowcases at &pound;7.99 each, fitted valance sheets from &pound;28.99; and curtains from &pound;35.99 (54 &ins; drop). 
 Polyester-filled duvet by Dorma. 
 Available in three weights, lightweight 6 tog priced from &pound;23.99, 13.5 tog priced from &pound;33.99 and 12.0 tog priced from &pound;29.99. 
 Pillows at &pound;6.99 each. 
 Bedwear in &bquo;Tabriz&equo; (pastel), &bquo;Isadora&equo; (deep), and &bquo;Wallace&equo; (deep) from the Munro &amp; Tutty Collection by Dorma. 
 The Right School? 
 To find the right school in your area The &bquo;Education Year Book&equo; stocked by your nearest reference library lists every local education authority (LEA) in the country. 
 It gives head office phone numbers. 
 Phone the LEA office and ask them to send you school prospectuses by post. 
 A detailed prospectus is one of the signs of a good school. 
 Try to visit some of the primary schools in your area around morning or afternoon break of going-home time. 
 You can find out a lot by seeing if there is bedlam in the playground or if there are lots of crisp packets and chocolate papers scattered about &mdash; this will give you clues to how the school is managed. 
 Try to talk to parents with children at the proposed school, or to the local newsagent. 
 Find out as much as you can about the school. 
 THE PRE-SCHOOL CHILD 
 If you've just moved to a new area a good way to break the ice for you and your child is a parent and toddler group. 
 These are usually for the under 3's, and are found in Church Halls or private houses. 
 The next stage is a pre-school playgroup at 3 or 3&frac12;. 
 They generally stimulate and acclimatise your child to playing with other children. 
 You could start your own playgroup so if you want any help or advice contact the Pre-School Playgroup Association (address opposite). 
 PRIMARY SCHOOLS 
 When you have shortlisted the primary school for your child remember to visit the school first. 
 Ask questions: listen, too, not only to the answers but the Head's tone of voice &mdash;is he courteous and do you get the impression that he will be approachable in the future if your child has a problem which need to be discussed? 
 Your child's pre-school days and infant and junior school years are vital in his future development. 
 Be careful how you choose &mdash; your child won't learn to his maximum potential in an environment where he or she is not happy. 
 Primary education covers infant schooling from the ages of 5&ndash;7 or 8, then junior schooling concluding at the ages of 10 or 11. 
 Moreover, you may live in area where children go to middle schools from the ages of 8 or 9 until 12 or 14. 
 SECONDARY EDUCATION 
 Choosing a secondary school for your child will be much the same procedure as when you were choosing your child's primary school. 
 Spotting a good school will depend on using information and common sense. 
 However, parents have one big advantage and that is that they now have access to the GCSE and A-level exam results of all pupils &mdash; that is the biggest giveaway! 
 All state secondary schools are required by law to publish their results once a year and so now you can write or phone individual school secretaries or the LEA and ask for a copy of the exam results, ideally asking for the previous 2 or 3 years. 
 This can be so useful to anyone looking for a secondary school, especially for the young couple with a growing child who are looking for a new area to move into. 
 LIFE AFTER GCSE 
 After GCSE the next step for many young people is to take A-levels. 
 Traditional sixth form education may still exist in some comprehensive schools &mdash; the 11&ndash;18 range &mdash; but you may have to find a place for your child in a FE (Further Education) establishment. 
 The FE colleges have developed mainly for providing vocational opportunities to young people beyond the age of 16. 
 Sixth form colleges offer a half-way house providing a link between school and higher education or work. 
 INDEPENDENT SCHOOLS 
 More and more parents every year are opting for independent schooling for their children: it is no longer seen as exclusively the preserve of a privileged class. 
 ISIS (The Independent Schools Information Service) may be of most use if you wish to explore this option, and they will send you detailed lists of schools in your area with contact names and addresses. 
 Again, send off for the school prospectus and find out the school's aims and objectives. 
 Make sure you're clear about what you are paying for, as there may be hidden extras. 
 A booklet which is issued by ISIS, called &bquo;Questions to Ask When You Visit a School&equo;, may be of immense value to you. 
 Whatever type of school you are looking for, it is worth taking time to find the right one &mdash; where your children's education is concerned, no compromise is acceptable.   
 an A&ndash;Z of useful addresses 
 This instant reference guide includes useful addresses and phone numbers you may need.  
 b 
 BRITISH RAIL London&mdash;Reading&mdash;Didcot-Bristol or South Wales: 
 Generally hourly Inter-City express service; about 45 minutes Didcot to London. 
 There are also local services along the above routes and also from Oxford to Charlbury, Evesham, Worcester, Malvern and Hereford; from Banbury to Bicester, High Wycombe and London (Marylebone); from Henley to Twyford (for Paddington) and a recently restored service from Oxford to Bicester. 
 c 
 COACHES AND BUSES 
 South Midland operate a network of local services in and around Didcot, Wantage, Abingdon, Witney, Carterton, Bicester and Chipping Norton. 
 Telephone numbers for enquiries: South Midland Tel: Witney 76679  
 e 
 ELECTRICITY 
 The County is mostly served by the Southern Electricity Board.  
 f 
 FIRE 
 In emergency, dial 999. 
 For advice on fire prevention and protection, and other matters, Tel: Banbury 62852  for Bampton, Banbury, Bicester, Burford, Charlbury, Chipping Norton, Deddington, Eynsham, Hook Norton, Kidlington, Witney and Woodstock areas. 
 g 
 GAS 
 The county is in the Southern Gas Board area, who have showrooms at:  
 h 
 HEALTH 
 Hospitals 
 Addresses and numbers are listed in the telephone directory.  
 l 
 LEISURE 
 Whether your idea of leisure is fishing in the Thames, hitting a ball or watching a film you will be able to do it in Oxfordshire. 
 LOCAL GOVERNMENT 
 County Council 
 Oxfordshire County Council's headquarters are at County Hall, New Road. 
 m 
 MISCELLANY 
 Births, Deaths and Marriages 
 Opening times of the offices vary widely and a check should be made before a visit.  
 w 
 WATER 
 Almost all the area is served by Thames Water. 
 For telephone numbers for emergencies and general enquiries in respect of water supply, land drainage, pollution control, navigation and boat registration, sewerage and sewage treatment, see telephone directory under &bquo;WATER&equo;.  
 The Carpet Guide 
 A short guide to the bewildering choice of carpets. 
 Here are some ground rules on how to choose your carpet, and its upkeep. 
 Carpets are perhaps one of the biggest and most important furnishing investments in any home. 
 Because of this expense a carpet is not an item one changes every year as the fancy takes you. 
 As a result, you will spend many years with your new carpet, and so it is worth taking a little while making the right choice of carpet. 
 Ideally your carpets should be the first major purchase in your new home, for it is around this essential item of furnishing that the rest of your interiors should be planned. 
 The right  choice  of carpet can transform any room, for it can make a small room appear more spacious, a large room seem cosier, and a cool room warmer. 
 Another consideration that should be taken into account when choosing a carpet is to select the correct quality of carpet for the area concerned. 
 For example, when choosing a carpet for the bedroom which is obviously a light wearing area, bright colours or pastel shades are idea. 
 In areas of the home where there is heavy wear, such as the stairs or the kitchen, rich colours and patterns will help hide soiling and staining. 
 Again, if your living space if restricted, then a light-coloured or a plain carpet will make the room appear roomier. 
 In small modern homes or flats a single colour scheme in different types of carpets can create a sense of space and continuity through the home. 
 More neutral tones are advised in the more modern home as that will allow the widest choice of complementary furnishings and decoration. 
 Something else to take into consideration when choosing a carpet is which way does the room face. 
 North facing rooms receive less light so a carpet with rich colours will make the room feel warmer. 
 South facing rooms which already appear to be warmer due to the extra light can more easily  accommodate  cooler shades such as pale blue. 
 Because of that initial expense you will want your carpet to keep its good looks for many years to come. 
 Although it is rare to see a carpet  that's  been worn right down to its backing they can often look worn. 
 This is when there has been such heavy use that the pile eventually flattens or there is excessive &bquo;tracking&equo; in a doorway. 
 Such an obvious change in appearance of one section of a carpet can cause dissatisfaction with the whole thing. 
 The actual construction of a carpet goes a long way to determining how long it will keep its original appearance. 
 Woven carpets, such as Axminster and Wilton, are still second to none in design and quality, and these are still produced by having the backing and the pile both woven at the same time. 
 Tufted carpets are much more economic to produce in that the pile is needled into a pre-woven backing. 
 What the carpet is made of is also an important consideration when buying a new carpet. 
 Wool is a well tried and tested material in that its natural crimp enables the fibres to resist pressure from heavy furniture. 
 It also has a good reputation for retaining its good appearance over along period of time. 
 Man-made fibres are also hard wearing, have an improved resilience to hard wear and are now anti-static. 
 A good quality under-felt is essential to prolong the life of your carpet and make it more comfortable to walk on. 
 Some carpets have an integral foam backing as part of the underlay. 
 If you choose one of these kinds of carpets they should be laid on the paper to stop them sticking to the floor. 
 MISERABLISM MORRISSEY 
 I think I've met them all now. 
 For me, there are no more heroes left. 
 And no new ones coming along, by the look of it. 
 It could be that this is a time marked by a dearth of characters, or that the smart people in rock aren't interested in self-projection but in obliterating themselves in noise. 
 But really, I think, it's the case that, in this job, you don't have time to develop obsessions, what with the insane turnover, and all the incentives to pluralism. 
 The heroes you have kind of linger on from a prior period when only a few records passed through your life, when you had the time to get fixated, spend weeks living inside a record. 
 It's a real effort to click back to that frame of mind, which is bad because fanaticism is the true experience of pop, not discrimination and broad-mindedness &mdash; I think of the splendid devotion of all those boys and girls, who as soon as they've got hold of the new Cure or New Order or Bunnymen record, immediately set to learning the lyrics by heart, then spend days exhaustively interpreting the Tablets From on High, struggling to establish some fit between their experience and what is actually some drunken doggerel cobbled together in a studio off-moment. 
 Seriously, I approve. 
 I approve the deadly seriousness, the piety, the need for something sacred in your life. 
 However &bquo;deluded&equo;. 
 It's become a reflex for critics to castigate the readers for being partisan, for being sluggish and single-minded in their choices. 
 We exhort you to disconnect, discard and move on, acquire a certain agility as consumers. 
 But maybe this ideal state of inconstancy we advocate only makes for fitter participants in capitalism. 
 For the one thing that makes rock more than simply an industry, the one thing that transcends the commodity relation, is fidelity, the idea of a relationship. 
  There are voices you turn to as a friend, and you don't just turn your back on your friends if they go off the rails. 
 You hang around. 
 You give them the time of day. 
 So &mdash; in the year in which we've forced the text-centred discipline that is rock writing to incorporate everything that it has excluded for so long (the relationship between the star's body and the fan's, the voice, the materiality of music) &mdash; maybe it's time to make criticism grapple with what undoes it, &bquo;the uncritical&equo; itself. 
 When I meet Morrissey, at the Hyde park Hotel, he's dressed from head to foot in black. 
 So am I. The whole tableau is idol meets fan to an embarrassing tee. 
 Happily, my finally getting to meet him coincides with the release of one of Morrissey's great records (they seem to alternate quite evenly with duff ones), so there's no awkward rub between the fan's loyalty and the critic's &bquo;responsibility&equo; to the &bquo;truth&equo;. 
 Viva Hate ! feels implausibly fresh: the music's breathing again, free of a certain stuffiness and laboriousness that had set in seemingly irreversibly in The Smiths' twilight period. 
 All due respect to Johnny Marr (though the haircuts never get better&hellip;) but, like most people &bquo;blessed&equo; with skill, there was a tendency to be used by one's versatility rather than use it. 
 Songs were getting written to accommodate guitar conceits, pointless feats and smotheringly unnecessary elaboration. 
 And I never much cared for the bumptious, muscular side of The Smiths, so I welcome the spaciness Vini Reilly brings as new guitarist, whether it's the lurid wig-out of &bquo;Alsatian Cousin' or the dew-and-moonbeam iridescence of &bquo;Late Night, Maudlin Street&equo;. 
 In American teen slang, Vini is a &bquo;space&equo; &mdash; a dreamer, someone not all there. 
 Hailed by Paul Oldfield as &bquo;the missing boy of pop&equo;, someone whose resistance takes the form of an absenteeism from life, it strikes me that Reilly's mystical anorexia is unusually suited to Morrissey's neurasthenia, his supine delinquency. 
 Viva Hate !, unsurprisingly, returns again and again to the Englishness which obsesses Morrissey. 
 For instance, &bquo;Everyday Is Like Sunday&equo; pores over the drab details of some benighted seaside resort: &bquo;Hide on the promenade/How I dearly wish I was not here&hellip; trudging slowly over wet sand&hellip; win yourself a cheap tray&hellip; share some greased tea with me&hellip; 
 &equo; Typically, Morrissey seems to cherish the very constraints and despondency of a now disappearing England, fetishize the lost limits. 
 What is this love/hate relationship you have with Englishness? 
 &bquo;There are very few aspects of Englishness I actually hate. 
 I can see the narrowness, and love to sing about it. 
 But I don't hate Englishness in any way. 
 All aspects of England, whether it be underclass, or extreme affluence, I find very  interesting and entertaining. 
 And it's still, I feel, clich&eacute; as it may seem, the sanest country in the world.&equo; 
 But there is the echo of Betjeman-on-Slough in the line &bquo;come! come! come! &mdash; nuclear bomb!&equo; 
 I mean, if it was such a rotten holiday, why hark back to it? 
 &bquo;That never really occurred to me. 
 The pleasure is getting it out of your system, saying &bquo;never again' instead of &bquo;same again next year&equo;. 
 And the British holiday resort is just like a symbol of Britain's absurdity, really. 
 The idea of a resort in Britain doesn't seem natural.&equo; 
 Again, on &bquo;Late Night, Maudlin Street&equo;, you say: &bquo;I never stole a happy hour around here&equo; &mdash; but the whole effect of the song, the way your murmured reveries drift in and out of Vini's entranced playing, just makes the whole time and place seem magical, otherworldly, and incredibly precious&hellip; 
 &bquo;It is a trick of memory, looking back and thinking maybe things weren't that bad, but of course, if you concentrate, you realize they were. 
 But I don't want to sing about football results or importune people to dance. 
 There are too many other people doing that, and I feel sad there aren't people making serious statements. 
 I feel slightly let down. 
 I feel I should look about and see streams of groups being angry and hateful &mdash; but it's just not happening at all.&equo; 
 For me, this song is the centrepiece of the album. 
 But you seem not so much angry, as succumbing to memories, drowning in them, leaving this world behind&hellip; 
 &bquo;But, I think, finally exorcising the ghost of that past and those small times.&equo; 
 It reminded me of the comparison the Stud Brothers made between you and 
 Sinead O'Connor: the &bquo;rigorous autobiography&equo;, the way both of you seem to have stopped living in order to document more completely your adolescence. 
 &bquo;But my life never really started at any stage &mdash; which I know you won't believe, but it's true &mdash; so it never really got stopped at any point. 
 But obviously the past is what makes any person. 
 It's because of your past that you're sitting there now, with your list on your knee. 
 I can't help thinking about the past.&equo; 
 The line &bquo;women only like me for my mind&equo; is clever&hellip; 
 &bquo;It's the final complaint, I suppose, in the long list of complaints about the past.&equo; 
 It's still not widely appreciated that men can want to be objects, as much as agents, of desire. 
 &bquo;But I think men are seen like that, actually &mdash; now. 
 Men are aware of their sexuality in a way they previously weren't, or weren't supposed to be. 
 I think women have become very open about their needs and desires, and this was entirely due to feminism. 
 By women being open about sex, it made life much  easier for men. 
 And this is why feminism helps everybody, to be slightly more relaxed about life.&equo; 
 Mindful of Morrissey's Jean-Genet-like interest in ruffians, as evinced by &bquo;Suedehead&equo;, I ask: have you always been drawn to people who are tough and streetwise and unlike yourself? 
 &bquo;I'm enormously attracted to people who can look after themselves. 
 I'm obsessed by the physical, in the sense that it always works . 
 It's a great power to be very physical, to be able to storm through life with swaying shoulders, instead of creeping and just relying on your thesaurus. 
 That doesn't work! 
 I've had so many conversations with people trying to convince them of a particular point, and although I find words central to my life&hellip; &bquo; 
 You'd like to be capable of violence&hellip; 
 &bquo;Nothing shifts or stirs people like a slight underhand threat. 
 They jump. 
 But most of the friends I have are very very and cross-legged individuals and not very demonstrative in any way. 
 So I've never belonged to any physical set. 
 The song &bquo;Break up the Family&equo; is strongly linked with &bquo;Suedehead'&equo; and &bquo;Maudlin Street'&equo;, that whole period In 1972, when I was twelve, thirteen. 
 &bquo;Break up&hellip; &bquo;' is about a string of friends I had who were very intense people and at that age, when your friends talk about the slim separation between life and death &mdash; and you set that against the fact that this period of your youth is supposed to be the most playful and reckless &mdash; well, if you utilized that period in a very intense way, that feeling never really leaves you.&equo; 
 Did you all consider the family a bad institution? 
 &bquo;No, we didn't feel that at all. 
 The family in the song is the circle of friends, where it almost seemed, because we were so identical, that for anybody to make any progress in life, we'd have to split up. 
 Because there was no strength in our unity. 
 And that's what happened, we did all go our separate ways, and quite naturally came to no good&equo;. 
 And your gang, were you outcasts, victimized by &bquo;The Ordinary Boys&equo;? 
 &bquo;Yes, but half of it, I have to confess, was the effect of deliberate choosing. 
 We chose to reject the normality of life, and be intense and individual.&equo; 
 Do you think in ten or twenty years, your life will still be structured around these playground antagonisms? 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 People don't really change, do they? 
 They don't change. 
 And the playground antagonisms are replaced by other&hellip; more adult antagonisms., 
 Office antagonisms. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Canteen antagonisms&hellip; getting heavily antagonized while you're  queuing up to purchase a doughnut. 
 But surely you have a happy question?&equo; 
 The last track on Viva Hate ! is a rueful little ballad with the self-explanatory title &bquo;Margaret on the Guillotine&equo;, which describes &bquo;the wonderful dream&equo; (i.e. the gory and spectacular public execution of our PM) that all &bquo;the kind people&equo; harbour. 
 The chorus, repeated five times, is the plaintive, rhetorical question: &bquo;when will you die?&equo; 
 You realize all this will cause you no end of trouble? 
 &bquo;Anything that's very clearcut and very strong causes difficulty, doesn't it? 
 But why should it? 
 I'm not looking for attention. 
 In this case, attention is the last thing I really need. 
 I don't want to be in the Daily Mirror . 
 There is something in this above controversy and outrage and all these over-familiar words. 
 It's too easy to be controversial., 
 So you mean it? 
 You'd like to see her dead? 
 In a cruel, bloody sort of way? 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Would you carry out the execution? 
 &bquo;I have got the uniform, ready.&equo; 
 One line in the song seems to me to be very revealing: when you say you want to see her killed &bquo;because people like you/make me feel so tired&hellip; so old inside.&equo; 
 If you compare The Smiths with the previous Great White Hopes of preceding eras, it's clear that the rebellion of the Stones, Who, Pistols, jam, was based in some kind of activism or at least action, an optimism about the potential of collective or individual agency. 
 But The Smiths' rebellion was always more like resistance through withdrawal, through subsiding into enervation. 
 The fantasy in &bquo;Margaret on the Guillotine&equo; is more like wishful thinking, than the resolve to do violence, or even personify violence theatrically. 
 Isn't the effect of &bquo;Margaret&hellip;&equo; just to encourage wistful resignation? 
 &bquo;Maybe, but I do also firmly believe in action. 
 But also there's a great sense of doorstep rebellion, and stamping of feet. 
 I think, above all, that dealing with people's manipulations is  very tiring. 
 You grow old very quickly when every day of your life you're trying to win arguments. 
 Politically, I do feel exhausted. 
 I do feel there are no more demonstrations, no more petitions to be signed. 
 I think those things, and group meetings and cr&ecirc;ches, are completely boring and a waste of time. 
 I do feel a sense of apathy.&equo; 
 I'm interested you talk about &bquo;stamping of feet&equo;, because this fantasy of offing Mrs Thatcher, as though this would somehow solve everything, as if the &bquo;evil&equo; in  this country weren't a lot more structural and entrenched &mdash; well, there's something a bit childish and petulant about it. 
 &bquo;Believe me, I'm totally aware of that. 
 But there's also something important about it. 
 The song is silly, it's also very heavy, and it's also very brave. 
 And I sit back and smile. 
 Surely you can see that the very serious element in it puts the straightforward demonstration &bquo;Maggie Maggie Maggie Out Out Out'&equo; protest song, in its place and makes it seem trite and a little bit cosy?&equo; 
 The thing with protest songs is that pop's always been about the immediate, spontaneous and puerile, it hasn't the patience to slog through sub-committees and lobbying and making orderly demands through the proper channels. 
 Pop isn't programmatic, it won't negotiate, it wants the world and it wants it now, and it's much more satisfying to hear about your enemy being slaughtered. 
 Even if it's just a fantasy&hellip; 
 &bquo;Is it? 
 You obviously haven't listened. 
 I think it's possible. 
 The times are quite ropy. 
 Things are touch-and-go. 
 You don't believe me? 
 There's a lot of organized suffering in England right now.&equo; 
 Petulancy is Morrissey's forte: petulancy and POIGNANCY. 
 They're the reason why he's been vilified as regressive, maudlin, self-martyring. 
 Underneath the scorn, the subtext is that Morrissey's art lacks a vital virility. 
 Female artists are allowed to be vulnerable, frail, because this corresponds with the idea of woman as lack. 
 But in a man, such qualities merely indicate a repugnant limpness of being. 
 Poignancy spells NANCY. 
 Not that the accusations are inaccurate. 
 Morrissey is regressive. 
 He can't grow, as an artist or a person, because he's addicted to his own neurosis, addicted to poignancy &mdash; Which is, after all, the sublime taste of your own defeat, your own incompleteness. 
 Poignancy (and this is why its domain is the minor key) is the exquisite meshing of two contradictory feelings. 
 It's a piercing beauty, or a sweet sorrow. 
 Anyone who's ever treasured their pain, tried to prolong it, toyed with exacerbating it or been driven to dwell on inside it long after recovery was an option, preferring the company of ghosts to the dreamlessness of everyday sociability &mdash; that person understands poignancy. 
 Morrissey has always lived and breathed poignancy, always secretly treasured the gulf between himself and the loved one, the difference that makes love possible but makes possession illusory, a delusion, so that, in the end, we are all  unrequited lovers. 
 And poignancy is why he obsessively prizes and keeps open ancient wounds. 
 But poignancy isn't just retrospective, it's also the rapture that's the same as grief, a radiant apprehension of death. 
 In its own, gentle way, poignancy is as profound an intimation of the contradictions of being, as any of the mindfuck experiences or headlong plunges into the horror-of-it-all that the anti-Morrissey brutalists advocate. 
 A lot of people &mdash; including the singer himself &mdash; see the point and appeal of Morrissey as &bquo;authenticity&equo;, There's a simplistic notion that his fans identify straightforwardly with the scenarios in the songs. 
 But how do they connect with such a statistically-remote calamity as &bquo;Girlfriend in a Coma?&equo; 
 Isn't there something almost aspirational about their identification with such irregular forms of martyrdom? 
 A craving for the hardest hit of self-pity? 
 &bquo;I don't feel they're extreme. 
 If anything, I feel they're understated. 
 I think people live very urgent lives. 
 I don't feel I'm in any sense vaudevillian or melodramatic.&equo; 
 On &bquo;Rubber Ring&equo; you seemed aware that, for many of your fans, the relationship is going to be a temporary if intense, even lifesaving one. 
 Do you think that maybe most of your fans are going through a phase, and that most of them will emerge the other end and leave you behind? 
 &bquo;Well, it probably is a phase. 
 But if people move on, it's understandable, in the event that everyone moves on, and I'm left dangling in the recording studio &mdash; then it would seem to confirm everything I've ever thought about the cruelties of life.&equo; 
 It seems to me the only people who do persist in that phase and make something tenable out of an unsatisfied, unsettled life, are rock musicians, and rock critics. 
 But has satisfaction ever threatened to descend on your life? 
 &bquo;It's never been something I've been immediately faced by. 
 It's definitely a possession of other people, I have a very long list of things I want to do.&equo; 
 Artistic or personal? 
 &bquo;Artistic. 
 Nothing else counts.&equo; 
 Does a notion of &bquo;artistic growth&equo; have any place in your scheme? 
 &bquo;Not really. 
 Can you give me an example of where that's happened?&equo; 
 You're right &mdash; in rock and pop, it seems that people just have their thing. 
 &bquo;And they hone it. 
 Or they start bad and merely get better. 
 Artistic growth? 
 I  don't really have any ambitions to change in any drastic ways. 
 I'm quite satisfied with how I am.&equo; 
 You're satisfied with your dissatisfaction? 
 &bquo;Totally. 
 I couldn't be happier. 
 I don't want anything to interfere with this state of dissatisfaction.&equo; 
 And there'll be an endless-renewed harvest of dissatisfied young souls filling up this phase which is your constituency, a.k.a. adolescence. 
 &bquo;But I don't consider it to be adolescent. 
 I am not adolescent. 
 I'm twenty-eight. 
 It's something quite beyond and more complicated than &bquo;adolescence&equo;, something that hasn't been thought out yet, but shouldn't be dismissed as &bquo;adolescent'&equo;.' 
 I'm just using &bquo;adolescent&equo; as a handy signifier for a life of restlessness, impatience and insatiability. 
 But would you prefer &bquo;a questioning life&equo;, maybe&hellip;? 
 &bquo;Yes, something like that&hellip; and that's something that can only aid and assist.&equo; 
 And you'll grow old (but not up) gracefully&hellip; 
 &bquo;Disgracefully. 
 I grow old disgracefully!&equo; 
 Why were The Smiths &bquo;important&equo;? 
 Because of their misery. 
 Never forget it. 
 Around Meat is Murder  the critics suddenly discovered Morrissey's humour &mdash; George Formby was trundled out as a reference point. 
 If you ask me, The Smiths could have afforded to be more  humorless . 
 The Smiths' finest moments &mdash; &bquo;Hand in Glove&equo;, &bquo;How Soon is Now?&equo;, 
 &bquo;Still Ill&equo;, &bquo;I Know It's Over&equo; &mdash; were moments of reproachful, avenging misery, naked desperation, unbearable reverence &mdash; free of the &bquo;saving grace&equo; of quips and camp self-consciousness. 
 If there was laughter it was black, scornful, scathing. 
 If the Smiths had only produced sunny, cuddly stuff like &bquo;Heaven Knows&equo;, &bquo;Ask&equo;, &bquo;Vicar in a Tutu&equo;, they would have merely presaged the perky negligibility of The Housemartins, the sound that grins itself to death. 
 The Smiths were heroic party-poopers at the Top of the Pops  office do, glowering at the forced jollity; they were like those gauche youths Who turn up to house parties only to cling to the dark comers in chaste disdain, driven by the na&iuml;ve, vaguely inhuman conviction that all merriment is a lie. 
 And The Smiths were important because of their extremism, their unbalanced view of the world, their partiality. 
 Morrissey is a character in a pop era of nonentities, and characters are always lopsided, contrary, incomplete, the sum of wounds and bigotries. 
 Morrissey is &bquo;half a person&equo;, his very being constituted around lack, maladjustment &mdash; this is the vantage point from which he launches his impossible demands on life, his denial of the reality principle. 
 Satisfaction  and adjustment could never enter The Smiths' picture, for this would breach their identity. 
 This is why Morrissey can't &bquo;develop&equo; as an artist. 
 How could he grow when his very being is constructed around the petulant refusal &mdash; &bquo;I won't grow up&equo;? 
 The refusal to be responsible and motivated, to get a job, to take on the brutalization and disenchantment entailed in &bquo;gainful&equo; employment. 
 The refusal to collude in the state of dreamlessness that is adulthood, even to the Pyrrhic point of clinging stubbornly to the state of being unsatisfied, forever. 
 Having perfected this petulant stance, all he can do is reiterate it &mdash; with a self-deprecating acknowledgement of the onset of self-parody: &bquo;Stop Me if You Think You've Heard This One Before&equo;, &bquo;Sweet and Tender Hooligan&equo;, where the chorus is simply &bquo;et cetera, et cetera&equo;&hellip; 
 Not that Morrissey's misery is something we simply identify with. 
 What The Smiths were about was narcissism, damaged, exploding back with a defiant fantasy of martyrdom. 
 The Smiths seduce us into aspiring to the same heroic pitch of failure and exile. 
 The tragedy of The Smiths is that Morrissey could only become the victim of the perfection of his style. 
 Like Jagger, like Rotten, he is condemned to live out its pantomime forever. 
 When The Smiths first appeared they seemed to be a reaction against the opulence/corpulence of nouveau riche new pop. 
 Really, they were a return to a different vision of &bquo;new pop&equo;, the Postcard ideal. 
 The Smiths were the second coming of Postcard &mdash; the whiter-than-white &bquo;pure pop&equo;: the sexual ambiguity; the Luddite insistence on guitars: Edwyn Collins's avowed rating of romance over sex; the swoon instead of the earthy R&amp;B rasp; the flustered undanceability. 
 What The Smiths returned to the charts was something that pop had seemingly left behind &mdash; adolescence. 
 New pop had rapidly lost its mischief and settled down into a post-rock, post-teenage maturity, peddling naff fantasies of sophistication to a new generation of moneyed teeny-boppers whose only desire was to grow up as soon as possible. 
 The Smiths, on the other hand, provided fantasies of innocence to those in the process of leaving behind their adolescence. 
 Their constituency was the silent majority of music paper readers that critics love to sneer at: students, ex-students, and those destined to be students (sixth formers and fifth formers). 
 The pale skinny boys identify with Morrissey because he lives out their quandaries. 
 Morrissey is a paradigm of a certain kind of ethereal, inhibited masculinity that would rather live in dreams than risk being disappointed by reality. 
 (Morrissey invests his emotion in pristine  idols, preferably dead, like James Dean, rather than deal with the mess and awkwardness of any real close encounter.) 
 Situated in the space between the constraints of childhood and having a career, these are people who dream for a while of wanting a vague something more from life, yet are saddened by these dreams because they know deep down they'll probably relinquish them, buckle down to a life of mediocrity. 
 When this happens, the records get harder to listen to, the music gets to be like a reproach, stirring up the taunting ghosts of prematurely foregone dreams. 
 Nagging &bquo;but&hellip; you've got everything now&equo;, &bquo;please save your life/because you've only got one&equo;&hellip; which is why people give up pop music, in the end. 
 New pop, far from being a bright new beginning, turned out to be merely the inauguration of global designer-soul, the soundtrack to the new yuppie culture of health and efficiency. 
 In the face of the benign totalitarianism of leisure capitalism and its off-the-peg self improvement, The Smiths glamourized debility and illness, advocated absenteeism, withdrawal, the failure to meet quotas of enjoyment. 
 The profound embarrassment of Morrissey's dancing turned the lack of oneness with your body into glamour. 
 All the self-squandering and deficiency of lifeskills that animated The Birthday Party and The Fall, The Smiths turned into brilliant, glamorous, consumable pop, two minute bursts of otherness in the heart of the charts. 
 They were meant to be The Rolling Stones of their time. 
 If The Stones' camp appropriation of black R&amp;B sexuality was the supremely relevant response to straitlaced, petit bourgeois English suburbia, then The Smiths' refusal of the travesty of healthy sexuality that black pop degenerated into, was the appropriate response to eighties &bquo;liberated&equo; suburbia. 
 The Smiths deployed the imagery of provincial northern life, the residues of a lost Englishness, as a weapon against the cheap hedonism of an Americanized southern England. 
 The very parochial stuffiness that the Stones reacted against had somehow become an alluring and reproachful memory. 
 &bquo;As grey and repressive as this lost world was, the inchoate colourific eighties is worse. 
 At least then you stood out, if only to be beaten up&hellip; 
 Morrissey is needed, not as an ombudsman, or a figure of the eighties, but as a horrified figure against  the eighties, who has turned his back on the march of pop time as the last keeper of the sanctuary of self-pity, apartness, exile&equo; (David Stubbs). 
 For the Stones, desire was obviously the enemy of materialism, work and a planned life. 
 But today desire has become incorporated as one element in a life's work. 
 Getting in touch with your body, getting in touch with your soul, has  become a humanist work-out. 
 &bquo;Satisfaction&equo; has become feasible, something you can plan for. 
 The Smiths, hooked on the glamour of the misfit, could only occupy an IMPOSSIBLE position, attempt to create a rock music where aggression was replaced by vulnerability, hedonism by asceticism. 
 From the private pain, the furtive &bquo;minor language&equo; of unrequited obsession, that they began with, The Smiths went public, became the rock band, the pollwinners, ombudsmen for wider grievance. 
 Whether speaking out for the silent rock majority against the soulboy mediacrats, or representing The Smiths as media martyrs. 
 Morrissey ascended a paranoiac spiral of statesmanship (paranoia is inverted narcissism) &mdash; check the progression from &bquo;Panic&equo; through The World Won't Listen and Louder Than Bombs , to Strangeways Here We Come . 
 &bquo;Did that swift eclipse torture you? /A star at eighteen and then &mdash; suddenly gone/ down to a few lines in the back page of a teenage annual/oh but I remember you/I looked up to you&equo; &mdash; &bquo;Little Man, What Now?&equo;. 
 &bquo;Fame, Fame, fatal Fame/It can play hideous tricks on the brain' &mdash; &bquo;Frankly Mr Shankly&equo;. 
 One of the best tracks on Viva Hate ! is &bquo;Little Man, What Now?&equo;, an eerie, enchanted, rather chilling song, in which Morrissey ponders the fate of a young TV actor (&bquo;a real person &mdash; but I don't want to name names&equo;) he remembers from &bquo;Friday nights 1969&equo;, briefly elevated to the level of minor celebrity before being abruptly dispatched back into obscurity, never to return &mdash; except for an afternoon TV nostalgia show, where the panel &bquo;couldn't name you&equo;. 
 It's another example of Morrissey's unusual awareness of the trajectories of fame, and the ways in which fans use and are used by stars. 
 &bquo;Fame is the most fascinating subject in the world and I'm keenly interested in speaking to certain people who've had fame and then lost it.&equo; 
 Did you always crave fame? 
 &bquo;I always had a religious obsession with fame. 
 I always thought being famous was the only thing worth doing in human life, and anything else was just perfunctory. 
 I thought anonymity was easy: it was easy to be a simple, nodding individual who got on the bus. 
 I wasn't terribly impressed with obscurity.&equo; 
 Did you have a rich sense of destiny and difference? 
 &bquo;I always knew something, shall we say, peculiar  was going to happen. 
 I think real, true artists do have that instinct.&equo; 
 From the age of what &mdash; nine, ten? 
 &bquo;Much earlier. 
 In some form. 
 I saw a multitude of options and the dilemma was  just which one to concentrate on. 
 Obviously, I wrote. 
 At the age of six I compiled a personal magazine every week. 
 I was intensely interested in journalism, and all the things around it, whether it was performing or actually playing records. 
 I intensely envied DJs. 
 To simply sit on this cushion at the BBC day after day and flip on anything they thought was moving &mdash; well, I thought that was the most sacred and powerful position in the universe. 
 To me, it was more important than politics.&equo; 
 You wanted to be a DJ? 
 &bquo;At a tender age, I craved that power &mdash; to impose one's record collection on people in launderettes and on scaffolding. 
 But now I think it's such a terrible job that DJs deserve to be the highest paid people in the country. 
 To have to sit in an office all day playing the same records &mdash; all of which are awful &mdash; over and over and over again &mdash; well, it's not funny, is it? 
 We shouldn't pick on these people. 
 We should send them parcels!&equo; 
 About this early magazine&hellip; 
 &bquo;I was only six, so the art direction let it down a bit, really. 
 It was simply the Top Ten, then certain pin-ups of artists of my person choice&hellip; sketched, in fact, by the editor himself.&equo; 
 What kind of circulation did it have? 
 &bquo;There was just the one copy, which limited readership somewhat.&equo; 
 You quickly became an avid reader and writer? 
 &bquo;I very quickly became obsessed by music papers and pop journalism, and collected them ravenously.&equo; 
 Did you turn to music as an avenue for writing, or were you driven by musical instincts? 
 &bquo;By staunch instincts of very brittle criticism. 
 Developed through having had this magazine of my own since the age of six, and listening to the Top 30 every Tuesday only to run off instantly to the typewriter in order to compile my own personal Top 30 which totally conflicted with how the world really was. 
 But in my sense, my Top 30 was how the world should have been. 
 It was a Top 30 of contemporary records, but the new entries were very unlikely, and obviously I favoured certain musicians, like T. Rex. 
 &bquo;I can remember writing an extravagant critique of &bquo;Cinderella Rockefeller'&equo;. 
 I was always a totally dissatisfied consumer, aflood with complaints. 
 It seemed to me that the world of pop music, which I worshipped, was there to be altered and corrected.&equo; 
  this other people's stuff &mdash; has been an abiding acrimony on the rock &bquo;left&equo; for some fifteen years or more. 
 (Punk had very little impact on the charts, on what sold.) 
 So Morrissey's infantile gainsaying of pop reality was the chrysalis for indiepop's current wistful, wishful fantasy of a &bquo;perfect pop&equo; returning to oust the impostors in the hit parade. 
 &bquo;I think we have now reached an unthinkable state, where things are orchestrated entirely by unsympathetic and unmusical hands and ears. 
 The people in key positions are people who don't consider pop culture to have any serious importance whatsoever.&equo; 
 You believe pop is or can be art, but that belief is sustained by only very rare instances. 
 You seem to have very specific ideas about what those are. 
 The other day it occurred to me that there are maybe two kinds of intelligence in the world: one that's very open, that tries to take on everything, and accordingly gets paralysed by choice: another kind that's narrow, that finds strength focusing on some things and excluding most everything else&hellip; 
 &bquo;If I liked everything, I'd be very hard to understand. 
 I always found the idea of people who were very hard to please, including journalists who were very critical &mdash; I always found they were almost always right when they found something praiseworthy. 
 I find people who are unbudgeably fair quite time-consuming. 
 I find agreeable people immensely disagreeable.&equo; 
 Is that the idea of Viva Hate ! that we need bigotries in order to make sense of the world, in order to act? 
 (The hankering for a punk-style commotion is precisely for such an illiberalism, a taking of sides, a new order.) 
 &bquo;Sadly, a lot of people need to be told, rather than asked. 
 Also, I often feel I gain from venomously critical views of me as an artist, more than from dithery, sloppily fawning, supportive views.&equo; 
 Going back to fame, to your intimate knowledge of the processes of identification and obsession&hellip; having been through various manic fixations, you have progressed to being a star, the subject of fixation yourself. 
 Most of your fans though, will remain condemned in a lonely monologue with their distant idol&hellip; 
 &bquo;Condemned sounds a bit rough&hellip; 
 But, nonetheless, I can't help but agree.&equo; 
 You encourage the obsessiveness, though, don't you? 
 I remember you once saying you were delighted people sent you underwear, or demands for underwear&hellip; 
 &bquo;Yes, both! 
 I do gets lots of very fascinating and fascinated letters, and lots of fascinating gifts. 
 I can very clearly understand obsessiveness, and the people who write to me see that I understand obsession and preciousness. 
 And I  respond in the same way. 
 I still get very nervous when I meet people who I admire&hellip; &bquo; 
 What does it feel like to see your image about, on hoardings, in magazines, to hear your voice on the radio? 
 &bquo;It's very odd. 
 I was in a shop once, buying scented candles, and on the radio came Steve Wright with a collage of Smiths&equo; songs, and I got a distinct chill, almost as though the hand of death was tapping me on the shoulder, saying: &bquo;put yer candles down, it's time to go!&equo;&equo; 
 The Smiths were prime movers in what you could call the depoliticization of personal life, after punk's initial demystification. 
 Remember 1980: &bquo;personal politics&equo; was the phrase that tripped off every lip, groups like Gang of Four (&bquo;Love like Anthrax&equo;), Delta Five, and Au Pairs worked towards their notion of the equal relationship, liberated from the veils of romantic false consciousness. 
 A &bquo;radicalism&equo; that was barely distinguishable from the pragmatism and &bquo;common sense&equo; of therapists' and counsellors' discourse, with their notion of love as contract. 
 Men 1982: attention shifted to the public language of love, to pop's sexual iconography &mdash; the buzzwords were the &bquo;language of love&equo;, &bquo;the lexicon of love&equo;, &bquo;the lover's discourse&equo;; demystification was superseded by deconstruction and ambiguity. 
 Finally, with Nick Cave's misogynist agonies, the Jesus and Mary Chain's candyskin classicism, and The Smiths' eternally unrequited gaze, came the return of romanticism in all its purity and privacy. 
 Pop had returned to what it had always been about: the personal as the realm in which the meaning of your life is resolved. 
 Romanticism &mdash; the dream of the redemptive love that will bring heaven-on-earth, resolve all difference, end alienation &mdash; has in the twentieth century replaced religion as the opium of the people. 
 But it's the dream that continues to speak most deeply to us. 
 Maybe the superstition of love is our last reservoir of spirituality in the face of those &bquo;specialists of the soul&equo; who would seek to reform relationships in accordance with their ghastly notions of &bquo;negotiation&equo;, &bquo;support&equo;, &bquo;partnership&equo;. 
 I always come back to the Stones when I think of The Smiths, because of the camp, but mainly because of the way each band illuminates their era for us. 
 For the Stones, satisfaction was the goal: everything would be all ALL RIGHT if we shed the inhibitions that held us back and down. 
 Revolution meant good sex on the &bquo;morrow.  
 But the Stones were the product of expansive times. 
 The Smiths the product of contracted and beleaguered times. 
 With The Smiths it was a question not of desire but of longing &mdash; the yearning to belong to or with someone, to belong somewhere. 
 The dream that two &bquo;half-a-persons&equo; can make a whole, fit &bquo;hand in glove&equo;. 
 The Stones and their time were all about leaving home; The Smiths and our time are about pining for a home. 
 Morrissey is the first major teen icon whose aesthetic is based around the conviction that rock'n'roll's best years are (in the) past, that the premises of youth culture have been outflanked (&bquo;I Know It's Over&equo;). 
 The first major teen icon whose work is grounded not in anticipation and impatience, but vacillation, resignation and looking back. 
 These feelings &mdash; homesickness for a place you couldn't wait to leave (Manchester), nostalgia for a time that was never any good in the first place (adolescence) &mdash; were why the music of the Smiths refracted the quandaries of the eighties like no other. 
 It's a sign of the times that pop-as-reinvention-of-the-self is something that resonates for fewer and fewer people in the world that is the music press readership. 
 That the pollwinner, the figure most identified with is Morrissey: victim of his past, chained to his memories, only able to imagine being eternally unrequited by life. 
 And as he says, artists don't really &bquo;develop&equo;, they have their act, gift, whatever, and stick with it. 
 That peal of exile first heard in Hand in Glove  still rings true in moments on Viva Hate ! and no doubt always will, no matter what follows, in the same way that traces of wantonness persist in Jagger's voice, beneath all the mannered overlay of time. 
 As I neurotically double-check if the tape is running, I mutter by way of apology, &bquo;I've had some bad experiences with tape recorders.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I've had some bad experiences with people actually&hellip; you're very lucky.&equo; 
 (1988)  
 throwing muses 
 The last thing I want to do is break the spell. 
 The last thing I want is to impale this dancing, living creature upon the stake of meaning. 
 Is it possible to write about Throwing Muses without confining their strange and terrible beauty, taming it, making it easier to live with? 
 The music of Throwing Muses has inhabited my flesh like a cold flame these past six months. 
 A kind of traumatized folk-punk, shifting fitfully between grace and frenzy, extremes of heat and cold, their debut album is the choreography of a body possessed and scattered by dread: as The Stud Brothers put it, music like &bquo;a punch, accentuating and projecting every hiss, mutter and scream&hellip; so exact and punctual it's simply sublime.&equo; 
 This is an exceptional band &mdash; David Narcizo on drums, Leslie Langston on bass, Tanya Donelly a talented singer-songwriter in her own right &mdash; but the star here is Kristin Hersh. 
 She writes the words: arresting images (lives that go in circles &bquo;like a pigeon on a tyre&equo;), moments of disturbing lucidity amid inscrutable dream-imagery (&bquo;give me what I want/ And all I can think about is losing it&equo;; &bquo;why can't you do to my insights/What you do to my insides?&equo;; 
 &bquo;I'm in a deep hole I dug by being deep&equo;). 
 But what pierces and transfixes is the rendition; the rending of the text, by Kristin's voice, its violence and daring. 
 A voice that moves somewhere midway between Stevie Nicks and Diamanda Galas, that goes places there aren't words for. 
 On &bquo;Finish&equo;, mid-syllable, a hiccup of desolation that'll turn you inside out. 
 Kristin's voice is gratuitous &mdash; so much more happens than is needed to get across the &bquo;meaning&equo;: an endless haemorrhage of semiotic material, released in sobs, moans, sudden gales of rage, a luxury of grief. 
 What is conjured is the  apparition of someone falling apart before your eyes. 
 But more than anything she &bquo;does&equo; with her voice, it's something clotted, intractable, something inconsolable within its fabric, that holds and entrances. 
 Kristin is blessed or cursed with the voice of a body congested with tears, tom inside. 
 Shivers down the spine? 
 Glaciers. 
 &bquo;The first time I heard my own voice? 
 We were recording in a mobile unit in this street, because I'd broken my leg. 
 The song was pretty and harsh. 
 Then they played it over these big speakers, and the doors of the van were open, so my song was booming out into the neighbourhood. 
 And I realized that when you record a song it's not yours anymore, it has a life of its own. 
 And suddenly hearing something that is part of your body, out there, beyond your control, entering other people's lives &mdash; it was too much for me, I just collapsed, crying, everyone had to hold me up&hellip; &bquo; 
 Strange talking to Kristin Hersh, trying to connect this sweet, funny girl and her rich, throaty laugh, with the haunted and haunting vinyl presence. 
 Drinking blackcurrant juice from a plastic beaker, her hair in a bob that looks as though she did it herself with kitchen scissors, she looks like a child. 
 At other times, she looks spinsterish, in cinder-coloured skid, tatty shoes and (most mindblowing), a kind of denim tanktop. 
 Actually, she's twenty, and a mother. 
 &bquo;When I discovered I was pregnant, it was at a time when I was very manic about the group, I felt it was my mission. 
 And I also felt about twelve years old. 
 But I came to feel it would be a step backwards for me to abort the pregnancy, that it wouldn't be moving my life forward. 
 And, anyway, doing the band had become less of a time thing, more a psychological matter of getting down to writing. 
 Having a child is an enriching thing as regards that. 
 It's given me an incredible new perspective on what life is, and what it's worth. 
 I had been very anti-body before. 
 I couldn't figure out why our spirits were supposed to have bodies and exist in the physical world of cars and houses. 
 And then Dylan came along, and he didn't have to do anything, he just was. 
 &bquo;And all the incredible holes he puts in me, all the fear he creates in me, has given me such an awesome respect for life. 
 He's just a raw nerve. 
 If something happened to him, my whole life would be crushed.&equo; 
 Wandering around the Muses' hometown, Newport, Rhode Island, I begin to believe this could be heaven &mdash; beautiful colonial architecture, quaint, toytown  paint-schemes, big gardens, porches, wide, empty streets. 
 So how has this suburban paradise spawned something like Throwing Muses? 
 The mystery deepens when I learn that the band's background isn't even affluent-but-screwed-up middle class, but liberal and permissive and caring. 
 Their parents are philosophy professors and learning-disabilities therapists and guidance counsellors and physical therapists. 
 Tanya and Kristin spent their early childhood in communes. 
 &bquo;But there's also been a lot of divorces, remarriages&hellip; there's certainly been turmoil. 
 and remember &mdash; when you're adolescent you can make a lot of trouble for yourself.&equo; 
 Adolescence. 
 Adolescence is what pop has forgotten or betrayed. 
 Throwing Muses are one of a handful of groups who write about adolescence as a period of maladjustment and withdrawal, who resist the now-pop version of youth as healthy, extrovert, unproblematic hedonism. 
 Compare The Smiths with Throwing Muses. 
 Both Morrissey and Kristin Hersh work with and within the flux of adolescence &mdash; the vacillation between agoraphobia and claustrophobia, possibility and constraint; the feeling that one's body, and the cultural meanings attributed to it, are a cage. 
 Morrissey represents that flux, turns it into couplets, quips, aphorisms, insights, a wisdom we can draw comfort from. 
 Hersh reproduces that flux, her voice is  flux. 
 The Smiths are a synopsis of pain, a resolution &mdash; awkwardness and alienation ennobled, given poise. 
 Hersh is the presence of pain; her voice, the intolerable stress it inflicts on the words, is the sound of the inconsolable wrestling with the insoluble. 
 The difference is between commentary and embodying. 
 It's the reason why The Smiths are more powerful as a pop as art. 
 &bquo;The songs on the first album stem from a period a year and a half ago that was the emotional and physical hole of my life. 
 It was as dark as the record suggests. 
 I was very unhappy, physically and psychologically ill. 
 If I was to describe the symptoms that would limit the songs too specifically for the listener.&equo; 
 I tell Kristin about how, a while back, somebody invented the term &bquo;miserabilism&equo;. 
 The people who used this vile slander seemed to believe that any kind of troubled, troubling music, anything introspective or tragic, was self-indulgent wallowing. 
 Pop music, it was argued ought to address itself to the &bquo;real&equo; problems &mdash; unemployment, racism, etc etc. 
 &bquo;That's strange, because I think of our music as very political. 
 Politics has to start from the insides. 
 If you just deal with politics at a surface, organizational level,  you never understand how things have got to be this way. 
 I tend to see people as walking garbage cans, fill of all this mess they don't know how to deal with.&equo; 
 Or, as she said in an interview with Paul Oldfield: &bquo;Throwing Muses go so far into people's inner dreams, their family lives, that you find what appear as outside problems.&equo; 
 Kristin continues: &bquo;A lot of the songs deal with the agoraphobia versus claustrophobia dilemma: the problem of what a home is, when do you leave it, how are you going to make yourself a home. 
 The problem is that where there's security, there's also entrapment.&equo; 
 Whereas adolescents' problem is that they're between homes, they don't have that shell, so they're free but also vulnerable. 
 &bquo;Teenagers are very open to the world. 
 They're trying to figure out what's going on, what they're going to grow into. 
 They take on the whole world, but they've got no patterns with which to deal with all that experience., 
 Because growing up involves making your mind up, making up an identity for yourself. 
 And identity really means limits, a refusal of choices and possibilities, a kind of protective blindness. 
 &bquo;Exactly. 
 Adolescents have no defence like that to cut off experience, they have wide-open eyes, and they take it all on. 
 It's obvious from the record that I was weighted down by an incredible burden I didn't know was mine or not., 
 But, as you say, a fixed identity, a shell, is also a trap, is no solution. 
 I'm reminded here of the ideas of Julia Kristeva. 
 She believes the mistake psychoanalysis has made hitherto is aiming to shore up a kind of finished and defined ego. 
 Instead, she imagines a kind of lifelong therapy, a continuous flow of repressed material, liberated through art and fantasy, pushing back the borders of the self. 
 &bquo;That sounds wonderful. 
 That's my whole argument with the self-actualization movement, this idea of a fixed and tidy self. 
 It's like when I finished those songs, I felt an incredible sense of boredom, &bquo;Oh, now I'm done.'&equo; 
 I actually wanted to be upset again.&equo; 
 One of the things I feel about Throwing Muses music is that it's visceral, sexual, but not sexy. 
 The sexuality in the record is troubled, mind and body are not at one with each other. 
 &bquo;It's the same with 90 per cent of adolescents, I guess. 
 But especially right now. 
 They're not sure what they're supposed to want or be. 
 David (Narcizo) always says that we trust this music more than we trust our own bodies. 
 The thing is that, when you're not in touch with your body, you're not in touch with the earth, with  our reasons for being here. 
 A lot of that album is about feeling that your body is a cage, that your physicality boxes you in, could betray you.&equo; 
 Why women especially? 
 &bquo;Women today are presented with too many choices, not enough choices. 
 We're still limited by sexism, but at the same time we're bombarded with images telling us that we have to achieve a lot. 
 Women are still judged so much by their appearances, so we feel we have to get that perfect first, before achieving anything.&equo; 
 I think we're talking about anorexia here, aren't we? 
 Something you've been through? 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 &bquo;America (She Can't Say No) '&equo; was from that period. 
 It's about how America is a land of excess. 
 Obesity is a huge problem here, but so is anorexia. 
 People don't appreciate the material belongings that surround them, they just buy things and then chuck them away, they consume and consume and get more and more lost. 
 And when I was fifteen I had to take all this craziness on my shoulders, there was so much imbalance out there, so much excess. 
 I had to go to 
 Another thought &mdash; love in Throwing Muses is not the vision of mutual support, of exchange and negotiation, that pervades yuppie consciousness, but love as being devoured and possessed and controlled&hellip; 
 The mood of the music is sometimes murderous, homicidal: its subtext could almost be &bquo;men! can't live with'em, can't live without'em!&equo;. 
 &bquo;Well, that's because love and fear are really inseparable. 
 Being in love leaves this huge hole in your self, and if you're adolescent, and don't have a clear concept of yourself, then you are just a hole, an outline. 
 And if anything happens to the person you depend on, your whole being is just this lack. 
 That's real scary when you're struggling to create yourself.&equo; 
 I've read that you feel that the music comes from outside of you. 
 &bquo;What happens is that maybe I'll just see the shape of some chords, or where my fingers should be on the frets. 
 Or songs will come about because of the sound of the words. 
 It really does sometimes feel like someone's playing a trick on my head. 
 For instance, I was writing a new song and it was making sense and suddenly these words came into my head: Once there was two Mexican women/ran over the hill/ripped off their skin/and ate it up. 
 And I was going: &bquo;C'mon! 
 Don't make me say that! 
 They're going to hate me!'&equo; 
 But&hellip; when I sat in the middle of the song, it worked.&equo;  
 Women in rock are forced to speak as women. 
 Men are allowed to assume a neutrality, to wield truth on behalf of everybody. 
 But maybe Kristin Hersh will be one of the first female artists whose alienation transcends gender. 
 She'd hate to be thought of as a seer, but maybe she is destined to be a figure like Morrissey or Ian Curtis, someone whose vision of adolescence comes to represent all our experience. 
 And with this would come a second liberation for women, the freedom to transcend the roles set up by figures like Annie Lennox and Janet Jackson, and to recover the right not to be strong, independent, immaculately in control. 
 The right to be as fucked up as men. 
 &bquo;Or even not to be fucked up, just to be regular. 
 That would be an incredible relief.&equo; 
 But what if motherhood, fulfilment, her committed relationship, turned out to be an abrupt end to the productive misery of adolescence? 
 &bquo;I've been worrying about this. 
 When I didn't have any way out, I felt like songs were a tunnel and if there was any mess I could just funnel it out and it would become a beautiful picture at the end of the tunnel. 
 But now I'm more together, I've a whole lot of other areas in which I can express my feelings, I just hope the songs won't lose anything. 
 What I've found is that there's a lot more complexity and problems in happiness, many more layers, than I'd imagined. 
 I doubt I'll ever be fulfilled, but I'm less manic. 
 The darkness hasn't necessarily gone, but now I can live with it, instead of inside it.&equo; 
 (1987)  
 p 36: blank 
 LESS&hellip; 
 LESS regressive rock 
 At the end of 1986, John Peel described that year's Festive 50 &mdash; his audience's annual poll of favourite records &mdash; as the most staid and conservative since 1975, the nadir of progressive rock. 
 For more than a decade, the spectre of the return of the hippy, of progressive rock, has haunted music-making. 
 But it's clear that it's hardly plausible to account for the current indie mire in those terms, as a problem of indulgence, pretentiousness, over-inflated ambition and gross-out. 
 Fact is, it's precisely the too-thorough internalization of punk's dread of the hippy and the resulting strategy of self-limitation that has led to a wholly different kind of dire stasis. 
 REGRESSIVE ROCK: the enemy is not a new breed of post-punk dinosaurs, but of post-punk mice, or voles. 
 1967 
 And what better time to consider this dead end than the twentieth anniversary of 1967, that pivotal point at which sixties beat music leapt into the beyond, and the very notion of &bquo;the progressive&equo; was born. 
 1967; minds were blown; dance was left behind as beats stretched out into timelessness; rock acquired a whole new chromatic and spatial vocabulary, as new kinds of instrumentation were added and the studio itself became an instrument; the first dabblings with stage effects and multi-media experience were made. 
 Current indie music refuses this leap into the beyond. 
 Burdened by hindsight, by a chronic fear of becoming bloated and self-indulgent, this indie generation tries to freeze-flame development at the point just before &bquo;it all went wrong&equo;, and so turns its back on the few things that went right. 
 Time and time again, indie music chooses The Byrds of &bquo;All I Really Want to Do&equo; over &bquo;Eight Miles High&equo; or  &bquo;Younger Than Yesterday&equo;, chooses the Velvet Underground of &bquo;There She Goes Again, over Venus in Furs&equo;, the Pink Floyd of &bquo;See Emily Play&equo; over &bquo;Interstellar Overdrive&equo;. 
 1979 
 To 1967, I'd add another year, an equivalent point of take-off &mdash; 1979 (punk energy making its first altercations with black dance production, dub and funk, its first trysts with electronics, its first stabs at multi-media performance). 
 Current indie pop refuses the dizzying possibilities of 1967 and 1979, attempts a deliberate retardation of development. 
 1966 and 1978, Byrds and Buzzcocks, are merged into a &bquo;pure pop&equo; limbo. 
 The desire to be sixteen forever has caused the sound of being sixteen &mdash; noisy guitar primitivism with no added knobs or frills &mdash; to become fetishized, petrified. 
 But this &bquo;perfect pop&equo; is regressive rock because it is a rock idea of pop, a fantasy dreamed up within music paper discourse. 
 The real &bquo;perfect pop&equo; of 1987 is most likely Mel and Kim, Jam and Lewis productions like Janet Jackson, Stock Aitken Waterman, etc. 
 Paralysed by fear of &bquo;the progressive&equo;, this stunted generation have chosen to take as their inspiration the sprightly, cramped insistence of The Monochrome Set, The Undertones, Girls at Our Best, rather than the stealth and reach of Can, Tim Buckley, Hendrix, Talking Head's Remain in Light , PIL's Metal Box , chosen to explore an emotional climate of suave nonchalance or at best pensive mawkishness, rather than denser and more elusive feelings; chosen to prefer the banal clarity of &bquo;communication&equo; over the glare of revelation and the clouded vision of horror. 
 INVERSIONS 
 Regressive rock is an exact inversion of progressive rock: both started with a commotion (punk, psychedelia) and slavishly followed through its principles and logic, ending up a remote travesty of the original. 
 Look at the parallels-in-negative. 
 Progressive rock followed through psychedelia's cosmic ambitions and became BLOATED and meandering. 
 Regressive rock is ANOREXIC, reduced and confined by its anxious deference to punk's creed of minimalism and under-production. 
 Progressive rock was GLOBAL, selling hugely, gawped at in stadia (the &bquo;ant-like figures onstage&equo;), disseminated so broadly as to be rootless and meaningless. 
 Regressive rock's meaning is diminished because hardly anyone at all is into it;  the scene is claustrophobically LOCAL a parochial huddle &mdash; its problem is not one of dehumanized distance but of an overdose of intimacy. 
 That's because psychedelia privileged the &bquo;far out&equo;, punk privileged the grass roots. 
 Progressive rock believed in FUSION, the grafting on of new musics. 
 Regressive rock is obsessed with PURISM: there's a steadily more depleted and over-stretched gene pool of approved &bquo;pure pop&equo; traces, resulting in ever more grotesque and gormless breeds. 
 (Like pedigree dogs.) 
 Can you imagine what the offspring of the BMX Bandits will be like?! 
 Progressive rock fetishized the VIRTUOSO. 
 Regressive rock fears accomplishment, privileges INCOMPETENCE, or at least demands the active concealment of skill. 
 Progressive rock was OVER-CONCEPTUAL made risible attempts to sum up all the riddles of existence on a single (or triple) LP, extended these pompous didactic ambitions on to the stage with all manner of theatrical set pieces. 
 Regressive rock's sin is its lack of conceit, its cultivation of EMPTYHEADEDNESS and na&iuml;vet&eacute;, its refusal to stretch beyond a shallow delving into the slight pangs of mundane love and small sadness. 
 Progressive rock was over-dressed, the music of a leisured rock aristocracy, who possessed the money to lavishly construct a LUXURIOUS palace of sound, and the time to squander in excessively fastidious attention to detail. 
 Regressive rock groups, on the other hand, are stingy with sound; their music is governed by a PURITAN aesthetic of austerity. 
 Records get knocked out in the studio hastily, emerge knock-kneed, spindly, pallid and monochrome. 
 STUNTED REMNANT 
 Regressive rock is the attenuated remnant of punk, the substance of punk shorn of its spirit (ambition, anger, artifice). 
 Punk reduced, through shortsighted, dogged adherence, to an anti-hippy tradition: instead of long tracks, pseudo-virtuosity, mystique, complex instrumentation &mdash; a self-conscious absence of these things. 
 These are the anti-hippy hippies&hellip; 
 Close Lobsters, Wedding Present, Miaou, Pooh Sticks, Railway Children, Soup Dragons, Flatmates, Shop Assistants, Mighty Mighty, The Chesterfields, Primal Scream, The Housemartins&hellip; the list is endless. 
 and if you define &bquo;regressive rock&equo; as deliberately induced arrested development, then you can add the whole Grebo Rock boom to the list (Crazyhead, Zodiac Mindwarp, Gaye Bykers, Batfish, The Cult, Bomb Party etc). 
 You can include a lot of the trad-rock bands in America (Camper Van Beethoven, anything produced by Don Dixon or Mitch Easter, anything influenced by Big  Star, The Feelies or The dB's). 
 Even the cults of Real Soul, Third World Music and Go Go are forms of regressive rock, in so far as they're fantasies generated within rock press discourse, and represent a retreat from the studio and technology in search of roots and &bquo;raw truth&equo;. 
 Of course, limits can channel brilliance productively, make it blaze all the more fiercely. 
 But instances like the Primitives get rarer and already one feels ashamed for indulging such backward passions. 
 Exactly a year ago, I celebrated the &bquo;new innocence&equo; of &bquo;anorak&equo; groups like The Pastels, James, and The Bodines. 
 But the problem with these groups is not that they're wimps, but that they're runts; not that they're vulnerable or soppy, but that they're flimsy, What's happened is that the perfectly valiant and appropriate refusal to grow up has become a refusal to grow, musically &mdash; to take on space, drift, experiment. 
 This petrification of the sound of adolescence has meant a loss of the essential dynamism, fluidity and reach of adolescence, its true pretentiousness. 
 TRAD JAZZ 
 Clearly the enemy in 1987 is not some new generation of rock dinosaurs (Banshees, Cure, Cocteaus, Bunnymen) but the puny underachievement and Luddite anorexia of REGRESSIVE ROCK. 
 The choices ahead are as drastic and clearcut as the choice between trad jazz and new jazz. 
 I suggest a total overhaul of values. 
 Instead of sparseness or spareness, a corsetted sound, look for opulence, sprawl, vulgarity even &mdash; the ruinous vanity of Prince, the indecently sumptuous Act. 
 Abandon the obsessive search for grassroots, and value music for its distance from them, its floating free and outlandishness. 
 Look for music that takes the plunge into the infinities of outer or inner space, rather than music which paddles through the shallows of everyday feeling. 
 Reject the exhausted creed of naturalism and prize the far-fetched, the super- or un-natural. 
 Rescue the word &bquo;pretentious&equo; (all it means, after all, is aspiring to something) and turn &bquo;unpretentious&equo; into a pejorative. 
 Rehabilitate the notion of &bquo;art-rock&equo;, and raze the self-limiting horizons of &bquo;power pop&equo;. 
 THE MOON 
 The spaces of pop (the disco, venue, pub, party) are social spaces &mdash; packed, hustling, sweaty, normative. 
 The only escape is to be found in the anti-social (the alien within, the heart of darkness) or the extra-terrestrial (the alien expanse without). 
 It seems to me that there are a number of satellites (labels like 4AD, Mute, Factory, Play it Again Sam, Product Inc, Blast First, plus various hip hop,  house and electro producers whose work has very little to do with the human), satellites bound to Planet Pop by some kind of gravitational attraction, yet estranged by the nature of their practices (the lost spirit of &bquo;67 and &bquo;79). 
 From time to time they shed meteorites and the odd one will make a small, exotic dent on the surface of pop. 
 For the most part, it's up to us to follow David Stubbs's advice: leave and let loose this place, ad drift to the moon. 
 (1987)  
 indecency (written with David Stubbs) 
 There's a consoling belief, one that has always held dull sway over critical and receptive minds, that both rock and pop are fundamentally about Good Songs. 
 &bquo;He may be ugly, but at least he writes good songs.&equo; 
 &bquo;They may not be the future, but they do craft good songs.&equo; 
 It's an easy platitude, a constant appeal: &bquo;excellent grasp of the song structure&equo;, &bquo;well-crafted&equo;, &bquo;wry&equo;, &bquo;observant lyrics&equo;. 
 Amazingly, 1986 has seen a reappearance of the singer-songwriter, with Peter Case, Stan Ridgway and Andy White receiving more than a smattering of applause. 
 That this should be the case is as much a curiosity as the pop success of Chris de Burgh. 
 Evidently, there are some very decent people out there. 
 Moreover, a hip consensus of veneration has settled around a canon of lost rock visionaries: Tim Buckley, Alex Chilton, Scott Walker, Dylan, Patti Smith, Nick Drake, Lou Reed, Gram Parsons, the luminaries and seers who shaped truths and made sense. 
 The current mood of retrospection, coupled with reissues and reassessments (another Dylan biography!) all indicate that a sense of lineage and legacy has been established. 
 This is rendered quite conscious not just in the touching veneration of Andy White (&bquo;it's in my blood!&equo;) but even in the work of Sonic Youth, who apply a sense of legacy to their history of rock extremity. 
 They make references to the Stooges' &bquo;1969&equo;, to Manson, to Presley's &bquo;Mystery Train' (also the title of Greil Marcus's famous book on the mythology of rock). 
 Far from slaughtering their ancestors (&bquo;Kill  Yr  Idols&equo;) Sonic Youth reaffirm their heroic, historic significance. 
 This inordinate attention to the past arises from both shame and pride. 
 The dust has settled on rock, there are no cloud bursts of white blindness as such, nor  any prospects of any. 
 So, a sort of ignominious continuation &mdash; Elvis Costello's thirty-third album! 
 There isn't much of a future, but one hell of a past. 
 In this more temperate climate, we can see that rock's estate is a grand one, and it's tempting to tramp its grounds &mdash; necessary, perhaps, if only so as to have somewhere to &bquo;go&equo;. 
 It's been a quiet sort of year. 
 A steady year. 
 Not unlike last year. 
 Or the year before that. 
 Legacy, estate &mdash; today's principal activities are alchemy and archaeology. 
 The idea is that, if you pick out the best bits from the past, combine them, mix and match them, dust them down and restore them fondly, then the result will be something better. 
 Take a little Can, pluck out the eyes of Grace Jones, warmed-up Kraftwerk, siphon off the froth of Aretha Franklin's &bquo;passion&equo;, snatch a little Glitter leather and smear off a fingerful of Bowie mascara, ignite with the spark of a torch song, and you've got &mdash; Eurythmics! 
 Take the Bunnymen, overlay every cartoon watchword in pop over the past twenty years, and you've got &mdash; The Mighty Lemon Drops! 
 Scrape the residual platinum off every major jazz, soul and classical efflorescence knowable to pop, melt it down and redisperse it in silver phials and you've got &mdash; ZTT! 
 These people construct their own hierarchies of taste, quite often in the hope of intoxicating us or invading our sensibilities with a violent shock of colour. 
 But the indecency is borrowed &mdash; at heart they're workers, tinkers. 
 This is &bquo;perfect pop&equo;, pop perfected, finished off. 
 If it's not Perfect, then it is LEARNED pop, necessarily referential, secretly wistful. 
 Weller, of course, with his stem blackboard of Philly, Stax, Motown and Mod. 
 Of course, pop learnedness can be genuinely clever, helpfully perverse. 
 Nick Cave finds a sort of superfatted theatre of tragedy in the later  Dylan, the later  Presley, makes sense of Gene Pitney and the New Seekers, reinvests the Singer and the Blues with a novel, unbearably ironic significance. 
 Or Psychic TV's &bquo;Godstar&equo;, their knowingly morbid celebration of the Stones in their most colourful, outlawed years of lurid decay, the angel Brian Jones about to snuff out. 
 Behind Psychic TV exists an occult, disparate breed of hipsters heavily into Gary Glitter, early Sabbath, Arthur Brown, Grateful Dead just because they know it would scandalize the prevailing arbiters of taste. 
 If we must have a past, then let's be sure it's molested with this kind of amusement! 
 Alas, the more orthodox cherish a notion of pop as historical progress. 
 Pete Astor of The Weather Prophets defines his project as &bquo;reactivating and redefining  old musical forms&equo;, claiming that this was what T. Rex was all about: &bquo;revitalizing Chuck Berry and Howlin' Wolf,&equo; reapplying these ancients in a pop context and embalming their legacy. 
 Revitalizing! 
 T. Rex! 
 The rash combustion, the pyrotechnic spree of the Electric Warrior reduced by the fond stroke of a pen to mere running-boy torch bearer in pop's endlessly unfurling tapestry! 
 The whole Creation aesthetic seems based in the sad conviction that rock is over, it's been and gone, and all that's left is to uphold the legacy through the Dark Ages of Plastic Pop. 
 The result is bands like Primal Scream: a living, breathing archive of rock gesture. 
 A mere footnote. 
 As one settles down, then, to a quieter pop life, grows a little older, the more it seems that the &bquo;correct&equo;, the &bquo;valid&equo; response to music is the appreciative, the considered and discerning response, the thinking cap doffed to the craftsman. 
 It is hard to think of any British rock, for instance, that's sufficiently ignorant to consist of nothing but screamworthiness alone. 
 An influence here may well be English Literature, with bands and critics adopting the tools of the stuffier sort of literary criticism, the kind that sees the priority of art as being the reaffirmation of human values, art as the search for a stable base, art as something that orders the confusion of experience. 
 Hence, a music that demands to be considered at the level of what the words mean, the coherence of the narrative, the intentions of the artist, biographical input. 
 Hence Costello, The Triffids, The Go-Betweens&hellip; well, we're thoroughly partial to all of them, but strongly suspect that they have nothing to do with the rupture, the indecency of pop. 
 At the moment when conscientiousness sets in, when a conscience is acquired, when you start casting conspicuous glances over your shoulder, this is the moment at which POP becomes ROCK. 
 The difference has nothing to do with the presence or absence of powerchords. 
 Rock is evocative; pop provocative. 
 Pop provokes a restless, alluring, mass response: compulsion as opposed to appreciation. 
 The difference is analogous to that between breakaway Protestantism and Catholicism, as rock was a breakaway from pop. 
 Protestantism concerned itself with the inscription of dogma, attention to the text, was more emphatically scriptural. 
 Catholicism, however gripped the masses by virtue of its incense, its ritual, all quite arbitrary, compulsion without purpose. 
 In the same way, it's the heathen elements of Pop that trouble the sober-minded rock fan, keen to see through the superficial, engage with the depth of an artist,  
 STARLUST 
 Pop attracts an abnormal fixation of the gaze, fetishism, voyeurism. 
 Pop, in a word, is fascination versus meaning. 
 The power of pop is situated in so many other places than the good song, or good intention &mdash; in the strange, the intolerable, the unattainable, the curiously sexual. 
 While the beaverish construction of good songs continues apace, you'll find the pop kid skiving off, caressing the cornerstone, transfixed by its coarseness. 
 Rock is about Essences and Ideas. 
 Pop is about the thing-in-itself. 
 Take the voice. 
 Good songwriters often have unremarkable voices: a weather-beaten bleat that denotes experience, maybe, or a finished shine in which meaning can glisten. 
 More often than not, they're no more than a glass through which the all-important text is transmitted. 
 Diction is paramount. 
 With pop, the voice becomes material, in itself, with a voluptuous quality above and beyond its expressive function. 
 Michael Jackson singing about anything &mdash; fish, or socks&hellip; 
 Need either he, or we, &bquo;say&equo; more? 
 One didn't measure Bolan by his doggerel, but by his pucker. 
 Moreover, Morrissey's falsetto wail soars above and beyond the bad music criticism languishing in his lyrics. 
 Then there was the strangeness of Siouxsie, leading us in circles, nowhere in particular. 
 This composition of pop suggests occasional rupture and random fun-quake, rather than a benign process of amelioration, or accumulating body of good work. 
 There is a history to be written of the VOICE in pop, the voice that makes present the physicality of the body. 
 Which has its own story: Jagger's lips, Hendrix's cock, Bolan's gin, Prince's tongue, Morrissey's nipple (one of the few options of indecency left, to revel, to splay oneself-as-object, play thing). 
 Even the pop consumer's body has a history. 
 In Starlust , Fred and Judy Vermoral suggest a life of pop as a flood of tears, semen, saliva, love-juice, breath, sweat, fantasies of licking whipped cream out of Clem Burke of Blondie's bum. 
 There's a &bquo;truth&equo; of pop music to be found in the wet seats at Beatles or Stones concerts &mdash; as much as in the pantheon of Lennon's songwriting, or the vicissitudes of the counter culture. 
 And do many fans, we wonder, fantasize about being given an enema by Van Morrison? 
 This lascivious hankering for the impossible, this lusty speculation and mystification, what the Vermorels call &bquo;consumer mysticism&equo;, all of this was written off by Punk, which left us with a shame about worship, made it a pad of its task to negotiate equal terms between audience and artist.  
 Finally, pop consists in its own surfaces, as sound-in-itself, rather than instrument of discourse. 
 That's what (once) made The Jesus and Mary Chain pop and Nik Kershaw rock. 
 On &bquo;Never Understand&equo; the song is lost in an aggravated, black hole of noise. 
 Bolan, too, was a buzz and a blur, not a series of compositions. 
 What this ideal and proven pop amounts to is spectacle, a near-touchable presence from afar. 
 The rock artisans, the good songwriters, are mere messengers, with a modest and inadequate sense of their selves. 
 Poor old Peter Case in his suit! 
 It's as if his actual presence were some kind of inconvenience, like going to the toilet, as if his body were a mere nuisance. 
 In good songs, the thinking is: &bquo;you reap as you sow!&equo; 
 There's an ecological balance at work. 
 You draw from life and you give back to live. 
 Wisdom! 
 As with folk, it's a natural process, simply reflective. 
 But pop sets itself against nature and abandons wisdom for folly, moments of dissipation. 
 Pop is un-natural, larger than life and insistent enough to make of itself an inevitable pad of the landscape, like a motorway, or pollution. 
 (Fantasy has its own reality-effect on behaviour and appetite.) 
 Pop can be sufficient intoxication to induce a different state of being, other than the one in which you exist. 
 is this extensive egotism preferable to the scheme of collective improvement drawn up by good songs? 
 Pop is not about schemes but about SELF! 
 SELF! 
 SELF as cartoon, heightened sense of self, self as superman. 
 This striding, Nietzschean self, &bquo;bigger&equo; as opposed to &bquo;better&equo;, couldn't be accommodated in any kind of social order, would never really be happy. 
 Morrissey's wounded narcissism is both intolerable and intolerant: driven by an instinctive disgust, he makes a meal out of himself in protest against the mealy-mouthed, constructs a grandeur out of swollen self-pity. 
 &bquo;I'm HERE!&equo; 
 Compare this to the strenuously managed, balanced sense of self arrived at by the likes of The Eurythmics and Howard Jones. 
 Take note, when we say &bquo;pop&equo; it's to the exclusion of such rock-minded types who happen to occupy prominent positions in the pop charts. 
 This pegged and tapered generation have learned from punk, will never repeat the glaring abuses of an earlier rock aristocracy. 
 They will succumb to neither self-abuse or abuse at the hands of others. 
 Unlike earlier pop stars, they have been careful not to be ripped off &mdash; they have a hand in the business side, share production, invest their earnings wisely. 
 They aren't puppets. 
 They know when to just say &bquo;No&equo;. 
 These artists aspire to self-sufficiency, complete control, self-exploitation. 
 Perhaps it was better in the days when the stars were ripped off, fucked about,  had no grip on their affairs. 
 They were exploited, for sure, but their exploits were myth incarnate. 
 These foolish spendthrifts hurtled, flashed and exploded on a clear black sky, crashed their limos into trees, were sensationally na&iuml;ve. 
 They made martyrs of themselves occasionally &mdash; a sorely missed commodity. 
 Not for them, the index-linked pension. 
 Not for them, the twilight appearance on Pebble Mill  
 The pop hero is uneconomical. 
 He spends his money and himself too quickly, runs up massive bills, gives, gives, gives, takes, takes, takes, fast forwards himself to extremes of bliss, extremes of abjection, invests unwisely in the single love-object, the addiction or the fetish. 
 The results are often catastrophic. 
 Pop creates more problems than it solves. 
 In love, the sensitive, reflective songwriter will treat the issue as a matter for negotiation, a question of exchange, the construction of a partnership. 
 This vision of love as healing or therapeutic, scours desire of its irrational elements, ravenous appetite, inequality, worship, degradation and devouring. 
 To essences and opposites: decency-rock is conscience, consideration, assessment, education. 
 Pop is vandalism, hysteria, oblivion, truancy&hellip; 
 LOVE JUICE TOPSOIL? 
 The demand for good songs occurs when people who have grown up with pop are forced to accommodate their love of pop within their new sense of themselves as responsible adults. 
 Since the sixties, rock and pop have been considered a stamping and breeding ground for burgeoning leftist/liberal sensibilities, a place where dissent is felt and upsurges occur. 
 Rock is pop energy commandeered for protest&hellip; but pop is protest-in-itself . 
 Morrissey's dissatisfaction may not arise from political constrictions, but from a more profound restlessness at the limits of life. 
 If Bolan is in heaven, he's probably miserable. 
 If he'd been in Eden, he would have probably left apple cores strewn all around the garden. 
 For sure, The Beastie Boys would have! 
 What's startling about 1986 is the manner in which the pop obsessions of self, want, luxury and aggression, have found their way to the surface of hip hop, with all the softer elements not germane to this violent push ruthlessly edited out. 
 The rupture of hip hop is a quite logical, unsettling upshot. 
 Unsettling, because it cannot be tamed. 
 Run DMC loathe &bquo;fuckin' faggots&equo;, The Beastie Boys say all girls are fit for is menial work and occasional abuse. 
 Schoolly D reckons it's funny the way people squirm when they lie dying of gunshot wounds. 
 This is what happens when the  bedrock of decency, the liberal sensibilities and assumptions which we all share, are all that's left to be scandalized. 
 They're out for us &mdash; we sucker-ass liberals are the target. 
 And yet, awkwardly, schizophrenically, these twisted sickos are taken up by the right-on, their cause espoused in the same breath as calls for a better world the assumption being that the better things in life &mdash; hip hop imports, clothes, socialism &mdash; would undoubtedly cohabit in utopia. 
 Well, to embrace both decency and pop in this context, to be a socialist by day and a hip hopper by night after a hard day's campaigning, are quite feasible options, but only in a rotten, free-market society such as our own. 
 It's a privilege, not a proof that a better world would be enriched, or its advent hastened, by pop. 
 Oh sure, it can be a tonic, and it's useful as glucose if you just want to kick things over, but, come the advent of a newer and more just social order, the one for which we all cry out, there would be no place for the scandal and achievement of pop, for Prince and any foul Beasties. 
 Plato wrote that the potentially subversive qualities of music were such that it would not be permitted in the perfect state. 
 And so our pop, with its incitement to insatiability, its spiralling creation of new appetites, would have to be, regretfully, abolished. 
 Rap, with its frequent assertions of power, would have to be put down, like some troublesome insurrection, or would no longer be necessary, in the new, egalitarian, ego-supportive state of play. 
 The truth is that pop is of much greater danger to social democracy than it is to capitalism. 
 Ecologically, too, pop is highly unsuitable. 
 Its courting of chaos, its materialism, its abuse of, and disrespect for, its resources, its spendthrift gluttony would be intolerable in any delicately-balanced and naturally-harmonious social order, the kind of world we need to seek out! 
 (Acid rain is ruining our forests! 
 Our layer of topsoil is diminishing dangerously! 
 Mother Earth is not being respected but raped!) 
 Pop's power, its danger and its crime, consist in its over-stimulation of desires for pleasure and for self-aggrandizement: desires constructed by capitalism. 
 Pop is hysteria, a neurotic symptom of what may well be the last days of Western capitalism. 
 For each of us, as the apocalypse looms, there's a power struggle within the self, between decency and dissipation. 
 Pop's role in this struggle is to lure us into truancy from our better selves. 
 Pop or a better world. 
 The choice is yours! (1986)  
 prince 
 Prince wants to be everything to everyone. 
 He wants to be all you could ever need. 
 Musically, he's a pop polymath, flitting between funkadelia, acid rock, deep soul, schmaltz &mdash; often within the same song. 
 And his love songs return over and over to the fervent wish to satisfy each and every need, live out all the fantasies of his beloved. 
 But if Prince pleases, in music, in bed, it's because nothing is ever done just to please. 
 Prince never caters, never serv(ic)es; he's always pleasuring himself first and foremost, following his own wayward impulses. 
 Even the pinnacle of his success to date was free of any taint of pandering: compare &bquo;Purple Rain' with Michael Jackson's &bquo;Beat It&equo;, where Eddie Van Halen was dropped plum in the middle as a calculated bid for MTV exposure and the Middle American AOR heartland. 
 But when Prince rocks out it's because that's as much a part of him as the funk strut. 
 He contains within himself all the pop factions (and the racial and social divisions that lie behind them) that record companies try to straddle with strategies of hybridization as maximum market penetration. 
 As Barney Hoskyns put it in his Prince: Imp of the Perverse  &mdash; &bquo;he is where all the desires of pop meet and tangle &mdash; their camp cupidon, their locus of signification.&equo; 
 The undeniable &bquo;something for everyone&equo; crossover effect of Purple Rain  won a huge, variegated audience. 
 But subsequent albums, especially Sign of the Times  have seen Prince's cultural schizophrenia implode within individual songs. 
 And so sales and profile have dwindled to a fraction of their enormity circa Purple Rain . 
 Prince is now demanding listeners as mixed up and variegated inside as himself, and is finding that there aren't that many around. 
 Prince has a near-pathological desire to escape the confining fixity of an  identity. 
 &bquo;Prince&equo; is not so much a person as a persona, a space, in which he can become anything he or we want him to be. 
 His being, his desire, is stretched and broken over sexual/racial divides. 
 So Prince's impulse is always to dissolve differences and borders. 
 The desire to be everything for somebody, the yearning for ultimate closeness, reached its lunatic peak in the sublime schizophrenia of &bquo;If I Was Your Girlfriend&equo;; &bquo;if I was your one and only friend would U run to me if somebody hurt U even if that somebody was me?&equo; 
 The song's agony is that of the spirit chafing against the straitjacket of sexual identity. 
 Sex for Prince isn't &bquo;communication&equo; or &bquo;exchange&equo; but something altogether more mystical: the dissolution of the very differences and identities that make communication and sex possible. 
 Like Morrissey, Prince feels trapped by his sex, or rather by the cultural assumptions/expectations vested in it. 
 Prince confounds all this. 
 He will pursue like a panther and be coy prey, present himself as rapacious subject of desire and  fey object of bliss (&bquo;Anna Stesia&equo; pleads &bquo;praise me, ravish me&equo;). 
 With &bquo;If I Was Your Girlfriend&equo; he created another identity for himself (&bquo;Camille&equo;) by subjecting his vocal to studio wizardry that tweaked it up to an androgynous 55 rpm. 
 But maybe that isn't such a departure when you consider that falsetto has always been &bquo;a sexual mask&hellip; the sound of a woman coming from a man&hellip; a way to demonstrate to his intended lover that he understands her fears and desires as if he were female himself (Michael Freedburg). 
 But there's at least one fantasy Prince can't or won't live out, one role he can't slip into with ease: the black pop statesman. 
 Throughout his career there have been calls on Prince by both the US and UK critical establishment to be a better role model, to make himself accountable to some kind of community, to address himself explicitly to the problems of the day. 
 Even now, there are those churlish souls who mourn the fact that Lovesexy  is not a There's a Riot Goin' On  for the eighties. 
 But Prince is either too frivolous or too religious for his flighty fancies to be pinned down to this discourse of responsibility and constructive intervention. 
 His responses to the troubled present are either retreat ever deeper into the infantile security of reclusive hedonism, or especially on Lovesexy , a wishy-washy, semi-mystical affirmation of the power of &bquo;positivity&equo;. 
 Sign of the Times  was like &bquo;What's Goin' On&equo;, in that it's a pandemonium of anguish and compassion in the face of the impending apocalypse, devoid of any real critique let alone programmatic approach to change. 
 Protest as a groan of anguish, as the sound of something buckling under pressure, rather than protest as a policy document. 
 Fantastic records both, but like There's a Riot Goin' On , they don't fit the erroneous model of &bquo;political soul&equo; that's been constructed by white &bquo;soulcialists&equo;. 
  It's the songs' incoherence &mdash; for who can keep themselves together in a world that's falling apart &mdash; that gives them their power: to hurt, if not to motivate. 
 Along with the bleatings about &bquo;responsibility&equo; and &bquo;growing up&equo; come other carping reservations. 
 A certain schoolmasterly tone enters the prose: &bquo;there is an&hellip; undeniable talent here, I grant you&hellip; but it's frittered away in self indulgence and conceit. 
 If only Prince would acquire a bit of self-discipline, he could channel that talent and produce consistently first-rate soul records.&equo; 
 Pah! 
 As if a steady stream of uncut, top-notch, straightforward soul is what Prince should be striving for! 
 Prince overflows and perforates the category of R&amp;B at so many points, it's barely relevant. 
 Miles Davis has already described Prince's music as jazz; his use of electronics can be a as minimal and futurist as Front 242 or DAF; at other times his intentions are patently psychedelic. 
 Prince doesn't so much build bridges between categories as create music that exceeds each category simultaneously. 
 But perhaps the best tag for him is &bquo;hippy&equo;, in so far as that term has become, for post-punk critic and consumer alike, a cipher for pretension, over-inflation and over-reach. 
 Prince is a hippy! 
 This covers both his penchant for fusion, and his dippy mystic positivism and cosmology of love. 
 Indeed, in his formative years he was influenced as much by Santana, Joni Mitchell, Todd Rundgren and Hendrix, as he was by Sly Stone, George Clinton or Earth, Wind and Fire. 
 (And these black musicians were themselves all shaped by the counter culture and acid rock.) 
 You can hear it in the jazz metal fills in &bquo;Glam Slam&equo; and &bquo;U Got the Look&equo;, in the way the West Coast power pop of &bquo;I Could Never Take the Place of Your Man&equo; subsides brilliantly into a brooding meander of acid guitar, in the raga anthem &bquo;The Cross,&hellip; 
 Most pop is created in factory conditions, as product made to satisfy specific consumer needs. 
 Prince has been elevated by success to a level beyond that of a musician working for a living. 
 He's often slammed for being a &bquo;spoilt child&equo;, which seems to stem from a distrust of the fact that his music is play rather than (good) work. 
 Post-punk criticism is still uneasy about music that isn't tied to a good intention or specific function, that isn't answerable to a community. 
 But Prince has floated free of grassroots or use value, and ascended to an aristocratic, aerial domain of licence and luxury &mdash; where he's instigated a promiscuous chaos of stylistic miscegenation. 
 While his superstar peers make records with one ear cocked in anxious deference to pop currency, Prince alone behaves like an aristocrat, squandering the success he's earned rather than consolidating the estate with cautious  measures. 
 (In early 1989 it was revealed that the aristocrat was close to bankruptcy, the Purple Rain  fortune dissipated in over-lavish stageshows and in supporting the stillborn careers of a seemingly endless series of prot&eacute;g&eacute;s.) 
 And he demands an aristocratic listener, one prepared to laze and gorge. 
 Prince's adolescence was spent, by his own account, in daydreams (of sex, of fame) in the basement lair where he also learned his multi-instrumental virtuoso skills. 
 This little bubble of unreality has since expanded until it enfolds the entire Paisley Park complex in Minneapolis, with all the technology and all his minions at Prince's beck and call. 
 This reminds me of two things. 
 The Jesus and Mary Chain's perpetual twilight adolescence, cooped in their bedrooms, steeping themselves in pop and producing, years later, pop of their own, veined (like Prince's) with references and allusions. 
 And Des Esseintes, the aristocrat recluse in Huysmans Against Nature , who dedicates himself to the diligent pursuit of ever more rarefied and unnatural means of stimulating the senses. 
 Prince's music makes me think of Des Esseintes's symphony of perfumes: exquisite, heady, overpowering, slightly nauseous. 
 Prince does to black music what the Butthole Surfers do to rock &mdash; survey its whole length and breadth, take whatever seems like a good idea, regardless of its proper place in the narrative of pop, gather then let loose with a supreme incontinence and disregard for modesty. 
 And of course Prince also casts his eye over rock too. 
 What a spree! 
 Prince and the Buttholes both play with sound in the most wanton fashion, disfigure, aggravate and dismember it. 
 There's a gratuitousness of form over content: so much more is done than is &bquo;required&equo; for the purposes of communication, so much flaunting and adornment. 
 It's not the getting from A to B of the song, that counts, but the swagger, the way of walking. 
 Unlike the singer-songwriter creed, attention is always drawn away from the song to the figure of the person working at it: there's a flagrant exhibitionism that forces us into the role of voyeur. 
 Sometimes, with Prince, it's like watching someone else watching himself masturbate in a mirror. 
 The two criticisms commonly levelled at Prince are that a particular song is &bquo;overdone&equo; or that it's &bquo;unrealized&equo;. 
 These privileged pejoratives show how firmly entrenched most rockcrit is within the tradition of Anglo-American literary criticism, with its values of proportion, symmetry, restraint, economy. 
 What's all important is the narrative, the sequence of utterances, rather than the voluptuousness of utterance itself. 
 For me, &bquo;overdone&equo; and &bquo;unrealized&equo; are just the opposite poles of a hyperactive musical intelligence. 
 I like it when a Prince  song is overwrought, has been worked at neurotically (Prince's music teeters on the brink of being addled by perfectionism, but never is stifled by attention, because every superfluous squiggle or quiver in the sound is a carnal appendage of the man's polyrhythmic perversity). 
 And I like his doodles, follies and ideas toyed with and abandoned in impatience, the debris of a restless desire. 
 It's all part of the generous gush of expenditure without return. 
 There's another set of poles around which Prince's music is organized, and these are tied to two figures of supreme influence. 
 On the one hand, James Brown, whose shows made such a profound impression on the young Prince and after whose fashion Prince drills his musicians with dictatorial discipline. 
 On the other, Hendrix, the noble savage in dandy's finery, the freeranging kaleidoscopic improviser. 
 For all its Hendrix-derived elements of bravura free expression, dextrous embellishment and luxury, Prince's music rarely loses touch with James Brown's locked groove of desire, mesmerizing monotony and crude assertion of repetition. 
 Discipline and dilettantism coexist. 
 Another angle to this contradiction is the way Prince is torn between the urge to be naked and the desire to dress up, between porn explicitness and the veils of flamboyance. 
 Both James Brown (sex machine with a bouffant hairdo) and Hendrix (the wild man swathed in foppish elegance) were prototypes for this collision of primitivism and decadence. 
 If Lovesexy  is Prince's strongest record to date, it's because its strength lies in coherence. 
 There's none of the dazzling leaps or appalling lapses that gave previous albums a dynamic range. 
 There's nothing on Lovesexy  as supersaturated as &bquo;Adore&equo;, as out of kilter as &bquo;Ballad of Dorothy Parker&equo; or as vacant and cretinizingly compulsive as &bquo;Hot Thing&equo;. 
 The songs on Lovesexy  are fullbodied, throbbing, for sure, but the unnatural excitation of tissue, the swelling and the morbid flush that characterize Prince's peaks, are nowhere to be seen. 
 The dominant tone is of jubilation, not the hysteria that makes me swoon in Prince. 
 Compared with anyone else in the world of the pop that sells, Prince's Lovesexy  is choc-a-bloc with risk and dare. 
 But by his own lights, the album has definitely been shaped by a measure of temperance. 
 It seems likely that Prince, chastened by the relative fall-off in his popularity after the caprices and wilful erraticism that followed Purple Rain  has opted for consolidation. 
 Nearly half the songs on Lovesexy  explicitly expound Prince's nebulous ideas about salvation, and the rest of the album is limned with references to a &bquo;new power&equo;, a positivism that is our answer to the problems of a world that's going to hell in a handbasket. 
 In the glow of this new power, erotic love and spiritual love  are somehow conflated (in a way that seems finally to overcome for Prince the apparent mutual antagonism between sensuality and righteousness that has hitherto perplexed him). 
 But it's not really surprising that this accommodation should come to pass. 
 Prince has always sacramentalized erotic love, and eroticized religion; made God munchy, made raunch his God. 
 The two were always interdependent for Prince anyway: pleasure only exists where there's a taboo, a limit to be crossed &mdash; as &bquo;It&equo; goes, &bquo;feels so good/it must be a crime&equo;. 
 I was thinking hard about why Prince pleasured me. 
 It wasn't just the vertiginous span between his moments of exquisite taste and subtlety, and his lapses into the crassest vulgarity and corn. 
 It wasn't just the sumptuous disproportion of form over content, or the ultra-vivid hypersexual bliss induced by his refinement and exaggeration of the mannerisms of passion. 
 There was something else. 
 Then I remembered what Ian Penman said, a long time ago, in reference to Prince and Michael Jackson: &bquo;the greatest singers die into their music.&equo; 
 There's something in Prince's voice, an itch that gets right into my pants, a dead centre, a Numan drone. 
 It's there all of the time, but it comes out the clearest when all the &bquo;dramatic inflections, subtle stresses and sympathetic accents&equo; (Barthes), all the art of the singer, are abandoned, fall away, when Prince swoons, sounds like he's on the brink of insensibility. 
 You can hear it on &bquo;It&equo;, particularly in the final, protracted, delirious &bquo;doin' it's&equo;. 
 Then there's nothing but the implacable, soul-less beat, and a subdued babble of shudders and metallic gasps. 
 Prince sounds stricken, evacuated, annulled. 
 Or &bquo;Hot Thing&equo;, where his descending drone-chant of the title makes him sound like a machine, subjugated to the moronic sex-beat. 
 Again the track trails off into languishing shivers and cadaverous moans. 
 If, as Bataille argued, eroticism is about destroying &bquo;the self-contained character of the participants as they are in their normal lives&equo;, then this loss of separateness is a kind of momentary death. 
 This violently-wrenched escape from &bquo;me&equo; shakes our &bquo;ordered, parsimonious and shuttered reality&equo; to the core. 
 I think it's the loss of this sense of the singer (and listener) expiring, in the music, that me about Lovesexy , for all its many splendours. 
 This scream from a shattered soul is what really links Prince with Little Richard and James Brown, and why we link Prince to a lost golden era of pop when that pandemonium and hysteria was the norm, not a freak occurrence. 
 When Prince is the master of all he sees, when everything he touches turns to  gold when he's the supreme seducer &mdash; that's when my admiration knows no bounds, that cool is why he TOWERS in our imagination way, way above those meagre souls who statistically and fiscally dwarf him. 
 But what sends me, ends me, is not when Prince is captivating, but when he's captured, enslaved by desire, a thing, even. 
 That, paradoxically, is when Prince is truly God. 
 (1988)  
 p 56: blank 
 THE POWERS OF HORROR 
 noise 
 Noise is the casual currency of eighties rock, practically all there's left to believe in. 
 Such a satisfying idea &mdash; noise annoys &mdash; at once simple-to-grasp kernel and yet capable of inflation into the most grandiose theories of subversion. 
 But&hellip; who is there to be annoyed, and in what ways? 
 What is noise anyway? 
 NOISE/HORROR 
 If music is like a language, if it communicates some kind of emotional or spiritual message, then noise is best defined as interference, something which blocks transmission, jams the code, prevents sense being made. 
 The subliminal message of most music is that the universe is essentially benign, that if there is sadness or tragedy, this is resolved at the level of some higher harmony. 
 Noise troubles this worldview. 
 This is why noise groups invariably deal with subject matter that is anti-humanist &mdash; extremes of abjection, obsession, trauma, atrocity, possession &mdash; all of which undermine humanism's confidence that through individual consciousness and will, we can become the subjects of our lives, and work together for the general progress of the commonwealth. 
 This dark, unmanageable matter of horror and sickness is a kind of cultural noise, causing a blockage and destabilization of the codes by which we make sense of the world, make life habitable. 
 Noise then, occurs when language breaks down. 
 Noise is a wordless state in which the very constitution of our selves is in jeopardy. 
 The pleasure of noise lies in the fact that the obliteration of meaning and identity is ecstasy (literally, being out-of-oneself).  
 Historically, what has happened is that the rock vanguard has shifted its focus from eroticism to the psychedelic powers of horror. 
 When sex was a scarce, invisible, unattainable quantity, to sing about it was publicly transgressive and personally mindblowing (because unthinkable). 
 But after the permission of the seventies, when sex was banalized by becoming available, it could no longer be the instigator of desperation (it's that state of mind that is indispensable to rock, not physical fin). 
 The site, the cue, for jouissance, shifted to the unspeakable. 
 STOP MAKING SENSE 
 The problem is that, to speak of noise, to give it attributes, to claim things for it, is immediately to shackle it with meaning again, to make it part of culture. 
 If noise is where language ceases, then to describe it is to imprison it again with adjectives. 
 To confer the status of value upon excess and extremism is to bring these things back within the pale of decency. 
 So the rhetoricians of noise actually destroy the power they strive to celebrate; they are the very start of the process by which subversion is turned into contribution, which is absorbed as a renewal for the system. 
 As rhetoric enfolds a group or initiative, so fibres of meaning interpenetrate every strand of sound, ensuring that the experience reaches us already placed in a general scheme of significance, validated and rendered ripe for the ICA We are constantly made conscious. 
 However sick, vile and depraved the material may be, nothing can prevent an aura of moral and spiritual superiority from entwining the latest noise/horror collision, like a halo. 
 Here are some examples of noise overdetermined by meaning. 
 Noise as reality effect: 
 There is a widely held view that beauty and harmony are a lie, presenting a bourgeois vision of nature and society as fundamentally balanced and ordered. 
 And that we have an obligation to listen to noise because it shows us the grim truth of reality. 
 In this vein, Swans are astonishing, the ruthlessly dehumanized mechanism of their rock functioning as a perfect analogue of their argument &mdash; that social life is enslavement. 
 Theirs is a sado-masochistic vision of the universe to rival Samuel Beckett's or Schoolly D's. 
 But any vertiginous feelings are stabilized almost immediately by the rhetoric that enfolds the band (which they severely resent), which recruits their private obsessions into a grand scheme of subterranean resistance. 
 Noise as anti-pop gesture: 
 With the death of the parochial, the media now constitutes our new environment. 
 Pop looms as the largest thing in our lives, but as something we've  lost control of. 
 Rock'n'roll was originally a revolt against straitlaced stuffy mores (encountered in the family, at school, in the small town), but now it's &bquo;brainwashing media images and fantasies&equo;, the very institution of pop itself, that we define ourselves against, Indiepop is fast becoming nothing but commentary on pop &mdash; The Membranes' &bquo;Death To Trad Rock&equo;, Sonic/Ciccone Youth's obsession with Madonna, Age of Chance's &bquo;Kiss&equo;, Oblivion is forestalled because we are constantly made conscious that this is a reaction against . 
 Age of Chance are the most sophisticated development of this process. 
 &bquo;Kiss&equo; is anti-anti-pop, a gesture against indie stasis. 
 AOC's noise is practically inaudible beneath the din of intertextual meanings. 
 Still, they have a good point. 
 Anti-pop doesn't challenge its listeners, as it purports to, it flatters them. 
 THE SUBVERSIVE FALLACY 
 Both the above viewpoints represent noise as subversive. 
 There seems to be a need to maintain the belief that &bquo;straights&equo;, grown-ups would be shocked, damaged, altered, if they were around to hear the music. 
 But the blindingly obvious fad is that no one is around to be disturbed. 
 The fiction that &bquo;the enemy&equo; occupies the same space as our noisemaking seems integral to the pleasure people derive from noise, the significance they confer. 
 Noise, in Britain, is always being read , furiously. 
 But the whole discourse of noise-as-threat is bankrupt, positively inimical to the remnants of power that still cling to noise. 
 Forget subversion. 
 The point is self-subversion, overthrowing the power structure in your own head. 
 The enemy is the mind's tendency to systematize, sew up experience, place a distance between itself and immediacy. 
 The American bands understand this, instinctively. 
 The goal is OBLIVION (a.k.a. jouissance, the sublime, the ineffable). 
 What could be more UN-NOISE than the slickly-planned career move, and tailored  manifestos  of the Age of Chance? 
 For them I reserve my highest pejorative &mdash; journalist. 
 They are the inbred offspring of ten years of music press ingestion. 
 Theories do not make for liberating music. 
 Give us poetry. 
 OUT-OF-YOUR-HEADS-IS-THE-PLACE-TO-BE 
 You can see a widespread hunger for oblivion, and a refusal to talk, throughout pop. 
 The indie shamblers, the Goths, the B-boys, the noise bands, the new psychedelics, all are reluctant or unable to justify their thirst for noise. 
 Opposed to this discrete tendency, steadily more redundant and isolated, we have two contingents &mdash; the soulboy soul-cialists and the decent singer-songwriters. 
 Both  are still committed to meaning, both want to promote pride and dignity, give us clear vision, a sense of sanity, encourage people to take control of their lives. 
 The others want to lose control, lose their selves, in noise. 
 Noise is about fascination, the antithesis of meaning. 
 If music is a language, communicating moods and feelings, then noise is like an eruption within the material out of which language is shaped. 
 We are arrested, fascinated, by a convulsion of sound to which we are unable to assign a meaning. 
 We are mesmerized by the materiality of music. 
 This is why noise and horror go hand in hand &mdash; because madness and violence are senseless and arbitrary (violence is the refusal to argue), and the only response is wordless &mdash; to scream. 
 A DEAD END 
 The problem is that, as with any drug or intoxicant, tolerance builds up rapidly. 
 The result is an exponential curve of increased dosages of noise/horror, an upward spiral that will one day, sooner than later, culminate in SEIZURE. 
 As the barriers in the head get broken down, the noise buff becomes a kind of hip vegetable, by a process that paradoxically combines both brutalization and weakening. 
 To be shocked (i.e. get your hit) requires that the individual be immersed to some degree in a culture or value system. 
 But noise hipsters have uprooted themselves so successfully from their parent culture, they can cope with absurd levels of outrage/dissonance, and therefore require extreme after extreme in order to feel stimulated/mindblown, Burnout approaches. 
 The noise/horror aesthetic has driven itself into a dead(ening) end. 
 A sublime, monumental dead end, that has produced some brilliant sado-masochist poetry from band and critic alike. 
 But a dead end nonetheless. 
 Here are some clues to THE WAY OUT. 
 INCONSISTENCY 
 Too often, noise has meant a level plane of abraded texture, which can merely add up to a different kind of blandness, a sense-dulling consistency. 
 There needs to be more dips, swerves, lapses, use of space and architecture. 
 Hip hop is something the noise bands can learn from. 
 The current hip hop aesthetic, as displayed by the music of Salt-N-Pepa. 
 Frick and Frapp, Beastie Boys, is based around the forcing-into-friction of antagonistic ambiences and idioms, sampled from random points in pop history. 
 The effect is psychedelic, dispersing consciousness as effectively as any pure din.  
 TEXTURAL LUXURY 
 The guitar is still privileged as the source of noise. 
 There needs to be renewed awareness of the capacity of the synthesizer and sampling to produce filthy, noxious tones. 
 There needs to be a realization of how far rock noise trails behind the avant garde and new jazz. 
 People have to attend to the possibilities for the human voice opened up by Diamanda Galas and Tim Buckley; listen again to Faust, Can, Hendrix, Sun Ra, Cabaret Voltaire, Suicide&hellip; 
 THE VOICE 
 All this depends still on the assumption that noise is a state with defined boundaries. 
 But if noise is the point at which language buckles and culture fails, then you could argue that noise occurs in moments, tiny breakages and stresses dispersed all over the surface of music, all kinds of music. 
 Maybe we should listen out for the noise in the voices of Kristin Hersh, Tim Buckley, Prince, Michael Jackson &mdash; the way they chew and twist language not for any decipherable, expressive reason, (that's to say, not to accentuate more deeply the conventional mannerisms of &bquo;passion&equo;), but for the gratuitous voluptuousness of utterance itself. 
 In their voices, you can hear a surplus of form over content, of genotext over phenotext, semiotic over symbolic, Barthes's &bquo;grain' (the resistance of the body to the voice) over technique. 
 Of &bquo;telling&equo; over &bquo;story&equo;,. 
 DIRTDISH V. UNEARTH 
 There seem to be two choices in noise right now, two routes to oblivion. 
 One is the noise/horror interface, in which violent imagery and musical dissonance are applied concussively, inducing a shell-shocked state of catatonia. 
 Big Black and Swans take this aesthetic about as far as is conceivable or desirable. 
 The alternative? 
 The Blue Orchids' creed: &bquo;the only way out is LJP&equo;. 
 Here consciousness is not mangled but dissipated, the borders of the self expanded to the point of dissolution. 
 Noise/horror undoes the self by confronting it with the other that dwells within it, the monstrous potential latent in us all, waiting to be catalysed by an extreme predicament; what I've called the new psychedelia undoes the self by letting it drift off and disappear into the otherwordly. 
 Noise/horror strikes me as a limited form of self-destruction, that can only yield diminishing returns. 
 Compare its claustrophobic confines and concealed machismo with the open spaces and fragility of the new psychedelia, as signposted by A.R. 
 Kane's &bquo;When You're Sad&equo;, Husker Du's &bquo;Up in the Air&equo;, Meat Puppets' &bquo;Two Rivers&equo;, Saqqara Dogs' &bquo;Greenwich Mean Time&equo;&hellip;  
 FROST IN MUSIC 
 Both &bquo;strategies&equo; are alike in one thing &mdash; they demand from the listener an immobility &mdash; one stunned, the other spellbound. 
 Unlike the soulboys or decent songwriters, resistance does not take the form of becoming a subject, but through becoming an object. 
 Refusing (at least in the domain of leisure) to deploy power over the self; to escape, for a few blissful moments, the network of meaning and concern. 
 (1987)  
 wasted youth 
 As punk faded into distant memory, the grip of its vetoes and taboos began to weaken. 
 By the late eighties, it was not just permissible but de rigueur for bands to grow their hair long, drop acid, use wah wah and other quaint effects, play solos&hellip; 
 Led Zeppelin, Grateful Dead, Hendrix, Iron Butterfly, Blue Oyster Cult, Quicksilver Messenger Service etc etc, all became legitimate reference points For new bands. 
 Above all, the goal was to GET WASTED. 
 Sixties acid rock's quest for the mindblowing was given a ruinous, apocalyptic, eighties inflection: psychedelia's pristine bliss-out was polluted by hardcore punk nihilism. 
 Out of this strange interface between post-punk and post-hippy (what punk once aimed to bury), the key groups to emerge were Dinosaur Jr and Butthole Surfers, in the USA; Spacemen 3 and Loop, in the UK. 
 Of these, Butthole Surfers were the most exemplary. 
 This was a band inspired into existence by The Sex Pistols, but who had more in common with Sabbath, Hawkwind, Hendrix, Pink Floyd&hellip; 
 The Buttholes brought back to rock the expanded WAISTLINE, a conspicuously WASTEFUL attitude to sound. 
 The Butthole Surfers burst the girdle of punk ideology, and let huge spare tyres of sound flop free. 
 What they resurrected was the idea of orgiastic music, a feast of sound &mdash; something that contravened both punk's parsimonious and anorexic tenets of economy and tightness, and pop soul's belief that The Song is best served by understated, deferential &bquo;backing&equo;. 
 Butthole Surfers led the way in erecting a new charter of values: overload, disproportion, over-emphasis, surfeit, gross out, turgidity&hellip; 
 1987's Locust Abortion Technician  saw them dredging for the very dregs of sound. 
 Using samplers, slowed-down tapes, echo-box, fuzz, wah wah, bullhorns,  saws, car doors (from which they got slowed-down squeaking sounds), and tapes of cattle lowing, they plumbed new depths of the bass-spectrum, new limits in the degradation and deterioration of sound. 
 Locust Abortion Technician  was a glorious mire, a glistening palace of ordure, a cataract of dysentery. 
 Hardcore groups like Big Black and Butthole Surfers have two zones of impact. 
 Total white-out in the HEAD &mdash; a rush of interference blanching the screen of consciousness. 
 And seismic intervention in the ANUS. 
 The importance of the rectum in pop is something rarely acknowledged, although it's been a constant; from George Clinton to the Beastie Boys (with their crapped-in-pants waddledance), a record's crucial when it has a lot of bottom . 
 Butthole Surfers take their cue from Black Sabbath's dis-inhibitive combination of bowel-quaking &bquo;low end&equo; bass frequencies and booze'n'barbiturates. 
 But the scatomanic orgy of Locust Abortion Technician  remains a work of real accomplishment. 
 Guitarist Paul Leary Walthall is a virtuoso of abjection just as Hendrix was of free flight, his domain the sewer rather than the firmament which Jimi traversed like a comet. 
 Where Hendrix transformed R&amp;B into abstract, dragonfly arabesques, the Butthole Surfers reduce R&amp;B to an invertebrate, protoblues agony, an infantile squall. 
 After Locust&hellip; came 1988's Hairway to Steven . 
 The Buttholes were hailed, by the farsighted, as the most masturbatory musicians around and the opening track &bquo;Jimmy&equo; was a delirious frottage of surfaces and inflammation of tissue, a paradigm of ruination. 
 But having got that out of their systems, on &bquo;X-Ray of a Girl&equo; and &bquo;Johnny Smoke&equo; they went into interstellar overdrive, in search of cosmic WASTE. 
 Going nowhere, vast&hellip; 
 For 1988 was a year in which the goal was to get TOTALLY WASTED. 
 The Butthole Surfers and Sonic Youth's version of the acid experience is not a transcendental access to the benign spiritual principles that underlie and order the universe, but more like schizophrenia: succumbing to the chaos of both your own drives and of external reality. 
 In particular the chaos of the media; where Front 242's use of TV images of terrorism and catastrophe was as a backdrop to their own survivalist strength, with Butthole Surfers it's more the case, as David Stubbs said, that they've fallen foul of the media overload, are carried by a momentum that is not their own. 
 What Butthole Surfers have done, what made and makes them so crucial, is that they've taken on the sonic possibilities bequeathed still unexplored and underdeveloped by acid rock but have jettisoned many of the disabling attitudes that originally trammelled that music &mdash; sophistication, expertise, the counter-  cultural impulse to edify. 
 They reclaim the access to VASTNESS those musics offer but redirect it towards primitive and puerile ends. 
 They expand the consciousness to the point of bursting, but feel no obligation to raise the consciousness, elevate it to lofty concerns. 
 Few bands sink so low, few soar this high. 
 Nobody else can do both within the same song. 
 WASTE your life, lay WASTE to yourself. 
 US hardcore has always been about self-squandering and auto-mutilation. 
 There's a link here with hip hop's &bquo;radical Politics of the slob&equo;. 
 Both share a policy of ostentatious self-neglect, that's an unarticulated, instinctive reaction against contemporary yuppie culture's ideals of health and self-realization. 
 There's a stubborn clinging to bad habits that benign social planners and therapists would like to &bquo;liberate&equo; us from, an obstinate refusal to &bquo;move on up&equo; and make something of oneself. 
 Naff plebeian drugs, junk food, hoary sexism, a love of trash culture&hellip; hip hop and hardcore share all these, but where hip hop still has a guiding notion of cool (both music and style are minimal) neo-hardcore is prepared to LET IT ALL HANG OUT horribly; the corset of cool has been ruptured and all manner of banished and forbidden rock memories have sprawled free&hellip; grotesquerie embraced as a defiant gesture against the sound track of yuppie culture &mdash; sleek, chic, designer pop-soul. 
 The conflict between yuppie designer pop-soul and hardcore is between two very different kinds of politics: the politics of self-realization versus the politics of dissipation, of debility. 
 For those excluded from status and opportunity (blacks, women, gays etc) being strong, becoming the subject of your life, these are crucial goals. 
 For white middleclass males, however, pride and dignity has little resonance, when all your life you've been trained to be aspirational and competitive. 
 &bquo;Pride and dignity&equo; appears to be barely different from conventional ambition/self-presentation/self-nurture, ultimately amounting to little more than the uncritical desire to participate in society on its own terms. 
 What does resonate is the fantasy of being unemployable, of being an unmotivated object rather than a purposeful subject. 
 Where designer pop-soul seeks to bolster narcissism (&bquo;learning to love yourself/is the greatest love of all,&equo; as Whitney Houston puts it) and amplify one's sense of human capability to manage life, hardcore finds perverse pleasure in damaging narcissism, destabilizing one's sense of human mastery, by a morbid preoccupation with&hellip; psychic breakdown, arbitrary violence, random calamity, irrational impulses, the Whole gamut of &bquo;unemployable negativity&equo; (Bataille). 
 What is the fascination of horror? 
 Is it psychedelic, a fall of the self, crushed by a  &bquo;weight of meaninglessness&equo;? 
 Or is it that When the vile or appalling &bquo;lies quite close, but cannot be assimilated&hellip; at the border of my condition as a living being&equo; (Julia Kristeva), what is produced is a momentarily heightened sense of one's own aliveness, teetering on the brink of extinction? 
 Or is it, as Leslie Dick suggests, that contemplating one's own self-destruction or mutilation is actually a way of perceiving and relishing one's wholeness &mdash; self-destructive fantasies as a kind of warped feast of narcissism? 
 Or is it that the sudden perception of one's own constant vulnerability provides, in its black, clouded way, a dazzling, near-religious feeling of revelation &mdash; this is how things really are; that to be born is, by definition, to be a victim? 
 To be prey&hellip; 
 Butthole Surfers are perhaps the ultimate expression of hardcore's predilections. 
 They remind me a little of Georges Bataille's pre-war secret cult, Acephale, whose goal was to get rid of the head &mdash; starting with the moral guardian in one's own head, the super-ego, then moving on to all the other &bquo;heads&equo; (the father, the State, the Law, God). 
 This was to be achieved through fascination with base material (excrement, big toes, freaks, anything that highminded principles and good taste decreed lowly); through an obsessional interest in ritual and religiosity, a pagan celebration of the moment rather than investment in a scheme of forward planning and providence, a pagan worship of the icon-in-all-its-materiality rather than of the Essence. 
 (A worship of signifier rather than signified: the definition of fetishism?) 
 Bataille's key notion was that of expenditure without return, an orgiastic squandering of time and self. 
 Either in the profane &mdash; polymorphous perversity that threatens the law and order of the Phallus/Father/adult genital sex; a decentred sexuality without goals (neither reproductive nor relationship-bonding). 
 Or in the sacred &mdash; ritual and sacrifice. 
 &bquo;Plunging in at the anus and tunnelling a giant point of exit at the sockets&hellip; one part giant surge of flesh, one part holy revelation.&equo; 
 David Stubbs's metaphor for the Butthole sound pleases me immensely, for he has unwittingly and uncannily arrived at the image that haunts Bataille's writing. 
 From the fetid depths of his mind, Bataille dredged up a fantasy of human evolution one part pseudo-science, one part myth; as the apeman became homo erectus, all the erotic energy vested and mind. 
 The point of this myth is that the base and the elevated, the profane and the sacred are intimately related, depend on excluding each other for their self-definition. 
 For Bataille, the ultimate destination of rational thought is the revelation that we know and can know nothing, beyond the realization that all the  towering projections of the human spirit are based on a primary denial of the abyss out of which we were formed. 
 The realization that &bquo;elevation is the fall; humanity is animality; insight is blindness; health is terminal pathology; God, when he knows, is a pig&equo; (Allan Stoekl). 
 It's this fall, this unseating of our lofty conception of ourselves (as conscious, self-determining spirits) that Butthole Surfers love to induce: hence the fascination with surgery (exposing the meat and muck out of which we're made), with lapses into the unreason of psychosis or perversion. 
 Against the US mainstream culture of rose-tinted kitsch (which Milan Kundera defines as &bquo;the refusal to accept that shit exists&equo;), bands like Big Black, Flipper and the Buttholes react by devising a near-catastrophic conception of &bquo;authenticity&equo;. 
 It's as though only the worst in human beings is what's real, the hard core of reality. 
 This is anti-kitsch &mdash; the idea that only  shit exists. 
 Hardcore is obsessed with WASTE &mdash; both physiological and psychological. 
 On I Crush Bozo  and My Skin Covers My Body , Happy Flowers take hardcore back to its primal matrix of unrequited desire and disproportionate rage: infancy's uncontrolled appetites for oral and anal gratification, its delusions of omnipotence, its terror of the breakdown of the borderline between identity and the primal abjection out of which it's formed. 
 The Buttholes are driven by an almost mystical nihilism. 
 They're obsessed by the shit out of which we're shaped (surgery), the shit that could befall us (horrible accidents), the shit in our souls (the drives and impulses we suppress and expel in order to constitute ourselves as normal, but which sometimes break free in perversion or psychosis). 
 &bquo;X-Ray Of A Girl (Passing Gas)&equo;, is a love song of sorts, an excremental vision worthy of Swift (recalling his &bquo;O! 
 Caelia, Caelia, Caelia&hellip; shits &equo; ode). 
 The strength of Butthole Surfers is their heterogeneity; they don't turn &bquo;filth&equo;, &bquo;the dark side&equo; into a religion-in-negative like so much hardcore, heavy metal etc. 
 Their nihilism is jumbled up with a mystical affirmation of experience (horror for the Buttholes is awe-full) but also with humour (they've advanced through parodying successive rock idioms, exaggeration improving each one by making it more extreme). 
 As their fascination for the appalling, arbitrary and marred has got more religious, so their sound has begun its ascent into the cosmos. 
 - 1987/88, then: the reign of WASTED YOUTH &mdash; of devastated vastness, sublime vacancy, vertigo, virulence and &bquo;the gift of the void. 
 (1988)  
 Nick cave 
 DISCIPLINE AND PUNISH 
 Nick Cave looks the part. 
 Deep gashes of black under the eyes, skin the colour of ashes, a slight wobbliness to his movements, His speech is fastidious, precise in a way that would seem pompous if he were at all ebullient; but with his small, gave voice &mdash; sometimes withering, always withered &mdash; the impression is of a wary distrust of words and the ways they can be misconstrued. 
 But he's much more forthcoming than in an earlier, abortive encounter. 
 Almost affable. 
 Pardon the ignorance, but what exactly is &bquo;The Mercy Seat&equo;? 
 &bquo;It's the throne of God, in the Bible, where he sits and throws his lightning bolts and so forth. 
 But it's also about this guy sitting on Death Row, waiting to be electrocuted or whatever. 
 It's juxtaposing those two things. 
 A person in his final days, thinking about good and evil and all the usual fare.&equo; 
 So the fallibility and the arrogance of human justice is something that obsesses you? 
 &bquo;It's something that interests me a lot. 
 My social conscience is fairly limited in a lot of ways, there's not much I'm angry about that doesn't affect me quite directly. 
 But the prison system &mdash; not particularly capital punishment &mdash; but the penal system as it is, and the whole apparatus of judgement, people deciding on other people's fates&hellip; that does irritate, and upset me quite a lot.&equo; 
 Is that why you got involved in the film about prison life, Ghosts of the Civil Dead ? 
 &bquo;It's a two-way thing: I had those feelings long before I wrote drafts for the script, but the process of writing and research inflamed them. 
 It should be clear to anybody that the basic idea behind the prison system is corrupt and unjust, but  the more I worked on the film, the more I understood how extreme the injustice was. 
 This particular film has quite a strong political statement to make, which is something that I'm not really known for. 
 I was involved in writing the first two drafts of the film, but by the sixth draft there weren't that many of my ideas left. 
 I also have a small part: I play a kind of known provocateur, who is brought into the prison &mdash; one of the new hi-tech ones &mdash; in order to disrupt the equilibrium. 
 He's a psychotic with some kind of death wish&hellip; spends his entire time screaming abuse. 
 &bquo;What angers me about the system goes beyond the unreliability of &bquo;proof&equo;&hellip; it's that the way criminals are dealt with has nothing to do with rehabilitation and readjusting people who've stepped outside society's norms. 
 The same goes for mental institutions and so forth. 
 But it's also the very idea of someone being judged &bquo;criminal'&equo; or &bquo;insane'&equo; because they're unable to fit into what a basically corrupt society considers &bquo;social'&equo; or &bquo;&bquo;sociable'&equo;.' 
 So you take issue both with the very idea of &bquo;the normal&equo; and &bquo;normalization&equo;, and with the fact that the authorities don't even bother to fulfil their professed 
 &bquo;Yeah, something like that. 
 I did a lot of homework when I started working on the script. 
 The initial plan was to use the prison world to create a certain kind of readymade atmosphere. 
 But over the eight drafts, what emerged was a particular vision of the whole penal system as almost a plot by the higher powers to perpetuate the whole system of crime, keep it rolling, keep criminals on the streets&hellip; &bquo; 
 In order to terrify the population into accepting the existence of the police. 
 All this reminds me of the ideas of Michel Foucault. 
 He looked back to the era (pre-industrialism) before the things we consider &bquo;natural&equo; &mdash; prisons, asylums, hospitals &mdash; had been devised, in order to trace the &bquo;genealogy&equo; of pseudosciences like penology, criminology, psychiatry and sexology. 
 What he discovered is that these &bquo;disciplines&equo; were not really about uncovering truth for its own sake; the &bquo;knowledge&equo; they generated was inseparable from and instrumental in &bquo;techniques of domination&equo;. 
 Later, he shifted his focus from social hygiene (segregation/surveillance/normalization) to study mental hygiene; the ways in which each individual is involved in self-policing. 
 We define ourselves as &bquo;normal&equo; by repressing our own capacity for violence or the visionary &mdash; just as we suppress and marginalize those people in the body politic who've gone over limits. 
 Looking back, it's clear that Cave has always been obsessed with this latent  other within each individual, that can be catalysed by an extreme predicament. 
 See how he describes his novel And the Ass Saw the Angel : 
 &bquo;It's set in a small valley in a remote region somewhere in the world. 
 A sugarcane-growing valley. 
 It's the story of the people who live there. 
 The fascination of these closed communities and hemmed-in lives, that recur in my work, is that they breed a certain ignorance, can be the breeding ground for very extreme, absurd emotional releases.&equo; 
 In Cave's work, most of the characters are in a sense prisoners &mdash; of an obsession, or a claustrophobic environment. 
 But maybe this sounds glib when set against the specific and extreme misery of imprisonment. 
 &bquo;I've been writing songs about prison ever since I started writing songs. 
 But I have a less romantic conception than when I started. 
 The film is in two sections &mdash; the population section and the maximum security section. 
 When the film-makers were in America, going from penitentiary to penitentiary, looking in libraries, interviewing people, they stumbled on this amazing story about Marin. 
 Over six months, the inmates were subjected to these totally unfair changes of routine, from small things like not getting coffee one day, to next day having their cells raided and all their possessions confiscated. 
 The whole balance between guards and inmates was totally disrupted. 
 The convicts became more and more upset, the guards were afraid, but they kept getting orders from above telling them to maintain these random violations of the equilibrium. 
 Until eventually it broke &mdash; and a prisoner stabbed two guards to death. 
 This was leaked to the media, who began to clamour for stricter control. 
 Marin was put onto immediate lockdown &mdash; which is where no one is allowed out of his cell and all privileges are removed. 
 Twenty-one months later it was still in lockdown. 
 The point is that two guards were sacrificed by the authorities in order to achieve this control situation. 
 That's the kind of system you're dealing with. 
 &bquo; The Mercy Seat  is about this person in solitary confinement, becoming more sensitive to inanimate objects, and as he sits thinking about human and Divine Justice, finding himself judging these things as Good or Evil.&equo; 
 Some say that The Mercy Seat  is the best thing Cave has done for five years, since Mutiny in Heaven . 
 I wouldn't go so far (that would be to devalue all the peaks in the interim) &mdash; but the single is stupendous. 
 It's a gigantic, near-illegible swirl-surge, a horizontal, disciplined avalanche. 
 With its maddened strings, echo-chamber vocal and the odd filigree of lonesome country whistling, it is vaguely suggestive of the sixties pop-melodrama of &bquo;Wichita Lineman&equo; or &bquo;Something's  Gotten Hold of My Heart&equo;. 
 But a sense of the epic driven to such histrionic pitch that it verges on Velvet's White noise and viola hysteria. 
 &bquo;Dignity&equo; is not a word that figures in my lexicon of praise (too redolent of the prattle of soulboys) but with Cave's work since Kicking Against the Pricks , it's appropriate and unavoidable. 
 A ruined dignity, the courage of someone staring into the abyss with &bquo;nothing left to lose&equo;. 
 Here it's the condemned man waiting to &bquo;go shuffling out of life/just to hide in death a while&equo;. 
 Eventually, the song becomes a real-time simulation of a locked groove, an out-of-control roller-coaster of dread but also of resilience: &bquo;And the Mercy Seat is waiting/And I think my head is burning/And in a way I'm yearning/To be done with all this measuring of proof/An eye for an eye/And a tooth for a tooth/And anyway I told the truth/And I'm not afraid to die.&equo; 
 Over and over and over, 'til you think your cranium is set to bust. 
 MADNESS AND CIVILIZATION 
 Nick Cave is afflicted and empowered by a certain, crucial deficiency of humanity. 
 Or rather, more accurately, he's estranged, wilfully, from the confining notion of &bquo;full&equo; humanity that's been installed by the positive Aid popular culture &mdash; extroversion, civic engagement, the benign totalitarianism of caring/sharing/ opening up, the cult of health and efficiency. 
 Morbidly inward, unforgiving, Cave goes against the grain of the times by being sick but refusing to be healed and integrated. 
 His obsessions are wounds he deliberately keeps open. 
 Looking back over his oeuvre, you see not development, but fixation. 
 &bquo;Lyrically, thematically, my work is still changed to the same bowl of vomit.&equo; 
 In fact, Cave and his ilk (Michael Gira of the Swans, Blixa Bargeld of Binsturzende Neubauten) are &bquo;agitating&equo; for a broader definition of &bquo;the human&equo;, one that incorporates lapses into the inhuman, incompleteness, a dilapidation and destitution of the soul. 
 They hark back to an older, more religious notion, where it's not a question of wholeness of being, but of holes. 
 Would you agree that your sense of the world isn't secular and humanist, but religious? 
 &bquo;I have no cut and dry philosophy, but I can't believe that we just die and become dust. 
 It just doesn't seem particularly logical or rational to me, that you live and strive for a while, then die. 
 Without sounding too clich&eacute;d about it, there should be more to it than that. 
 But what, I don't know.&equo; 
 Do you think these vague presentiments of a beyond or after could ever draw you into organized religion?  
 &bquo;That has a lot to do with my state of mind at the time. 
 I almost became a born-again Christian on the flight over from Australia. 
 Two days sitting in the plane and fifty bourbons later I had this young born-again advocate holding my hand and praying for me at the top of his voice. 
 He was actually asking God to show me some sign. 
 In fact later on during the flight, when I'd unravelled myself from this guy and was playing poker with some French people, I asked God to give me the sign then, in the hand I was about to get. 
 And I had three kings and two queens, which sobered me a little bit. 
 But I guess it was just a lucky hand.&equo; 
 Was this Christian especially voracious or were you just unusually vulnerable? 
 &bquo;Well, whereas the rest of the passengers were basically gearing up to tear my girlfriend and me to bits if we continued to go the way we were going &mdash; you get a kind of cabin fever on these flights between Australia and England &mdash; this Christian and his wife decided to adopt us, I guess as a kind of test for themselves. 
 There's something about that flight&hellip; every time you do it, you just get off the plane shaking your head and thinking how incredibly tolerant the staff are. 
 They must be trained in channelling animal behaviour.&equo; 
 Were you brought up religiously? 
 Did this missionary have anything to work on? 
 &bquo;As it turned out, I knew the Bible better than he did. 
 He started quoting things from his Modern translation, which I find really irritating. 
 I find the King James version in its original translation to be incredibly inspiring. 
 To find it so utterly demystified by these modern religions keen to allow people of today to understand&hellip; it really appals me. 
 And the translations are so incredibly liberal, there may as well be no original text at all. 
 &bquo;It was basically the novel that made it necessary for me to look into the Bible. 
 I started by looking up quotes for characters to say, and found myself reading four or five pages, until I found myself reading the Bible and only the Bible for quite a long time. 
 And then the Bible and Christianity became more and more central to the novel., 
 Another sense in which you're anti-humanist is that you have no truck with ideas of personal (or social) progress &mdash; people achieving self-sufficiency and fullness of being by becoming more &bquo;conscious&equo;. 
 &bquo;No, I don't have that view of the world. 
 i see everyone as very much alone. 
 To see yourself as part of some greater humanist scheme&hellip; 
 I can't really abide by that myself. 
 I'm someone who has very little concern with any kind of social problems, someone who's very much concerned with their own particular plight. 
 .. I don't know what this is founded in, but I believe that there must be some kind  of basic system of balance, where everything's weighed up and when all the pain we've created in the world gets salved because we live again. 
 I have some kind of feelings towards that idea.&equo; 
 FROM HER TO ETERNITY 
 Nick Cave surfaced at a time when post-punk's handle on the workings of desire was diagrammatic and programmatic. 
 Punk had bequeathed the idea that demystification was the route to enlightenment. 
 &bquo;Personal politics&equo; was the buzzword: the acknowledgement  of the &bquo;dark side&equo; was always grounded in progressive humanism, the belief that what was twisted could be straightened out, that the shadows could be banished by the spotlight of analysis. 
 The idea was that through deconditioning, unblocking, a ventilation of the soul (&bquo;airing your problems&equo;), it was possible to achieve some kind of frank and freeflowing exchange. 
 Against this view of love as contract, Cave, in The Birthday Party, was almost alone in reinvoking love as malady, monologue, abject dependence, whose ultimate expression could only be violence: the recurrent theme of girl-murder, or at the opposite pole the paroxysm of desire in &bquo;Zoo Music Girl&equo;, &bquo;Oh! 
 God! please let me die beneath her fists!&equo; 
 Cave was the first writer, in a post-punk climate of positivism, to start using Biblical imagery (sin, retribution, curses, bad seed, revenge)&hellip; 
 &bquo;Perhaps I'm kind of emotionally retarded&hellip; but basically I've just written about things how I've felt about them, myself, emotionally. 
 Things like revenge, which you talk about as almost an Old Testament feeling, I see as completely now. 
 It's just one of those things this society has suppressed, along with any other strong or extreme outburst of emotion. 
 I think there's a certain numbness in the world today&hellip; that accepts certain kinds of violence, but is against other kinds of violence., 
 So you have a kind of ethics of violence? 
 Certain kinds of violence &mdash; the crime of passion &mdash; have a kind of aesthetic integrity? 
 &bquo;That's one way of putting it&hellip; 
 There's something more noble in revenge, than in&hellip; sadism, or violence through greed. 
 Maybe there's something more aesthetically pleasing about it, I don't know&hellip; 
 I just find those subject the easiest to deal with: on the one hand, they're the most tangible feelings I have to pull out of myself; on the other, they make me want to make a stronger statement when I ultimately do that. 
 I don't deny feelings of happiness just because I don't write about them. 
 For me, there's just something more powerful in Man's ultimate punishments &mdash; whether they're on a humanist level or a more mystical level &mdash;  than in his ultimate rewards. 
 The rewards of happiness and contentment and security, I see as mostly drawn out of a routine of things. 
 And they have no aesthetic interest for me, or much lasting value. 
 &bquo;But then again, my favourite song in the world is &bquo;Wonderful World'&equo; by Louis Armstrong. 
 If any song really chokes me up, it's that one. 
 If there's any song that I would like to do, but would never attempt because I wouldn't know how to begin, that's the one. 
 If I could produce the same effect on other people as Louis Armstrong does with that song, then I'd be really happy. 
 But there's something so unintentionally tragic about that song. 
 Although I'm sure that has a lot to do with the way I listen, Louis Armstrong being this all-time winner and happy guy.&equo; 
 Do you resent the arbitrary power that beautiful people have? 
 Something shallow, unearned, but capable of putting you in thrall. 
 Revenge would seem to originate in this feeling of powerlessness. 
 &bquo;You're asking me if I'm some sort of embittered, wounded animal, who only wants to reach out and break things because he can't be happy or possess them?&equo; 
 No, more generally than that: the idea of beauty as terrorism. 
 Of possession as the delusion we all run aground on. 
 It seems like there's a negativity at the heart of romantic love, because love is nothing if not the always already doomed fantasy of possession. 
 Doomed because of the flux (growth or decay) that is the loved one. 
 You were talking about life's punishments just now, and maybe the fact that love is doomed from the off is one of them. 
 &bquo;There's lots of different angles you can look at things from. 
 I accept all that. 
 Although I don't think it's impossible that it can't be the other way, that two people can't grow toward each other. 
 I don't particularly believe all love is doomed. 
 But I guess, one is usually kinda suffering from some aborted love affair or association, rather than being at the peak of one. 
 I think it's fairly obvious that a lot more suffering goes on in the name of love than the little happiness you can squeeze out of it. 
 But I wouldn't like to dwell on it. 
 Perhaps you could lighten up a little bit.&equo; 
 Condescendingly, like an agony aunt or something, he adds: &bquo;There are plenty more fish in the sea.&equo; 
 THE SINGER 
 Since the death of the Birthday Party, Nick Cave has steadily made a transition from exhibitionist, incendiary live performer to something more stately and, yes, dignified. 
 The fireball has become an ember. 
 Kicking Against the Pricks , an album of cover versions, marked the key shift from poet visionary of sex-and-death to interpretive balladeer, from torched singer to a croon the colour of  cinders, from Dionysiac excess to a ruined classicism. 
 And on Your Funeral &hellip; 
 My Trial , Cave and the Bad Seeds were staging their own dilapidated equivalents to &bquo;By the Time I Get to Phoenix&equo; and &bquo;Something's Gotten Hold of My Heart&equo;, in the gently obliterating, slowly gathering, morose grandeur of &bquo;Sad Waters&equo; and &bquo;Stranger Than Kindness&equo;. 
 Cave has influenced other kindred spirits to leave behind self-immolation in favour of The Song. 
 When did he start getting into what he calls &bquo;entertainment music, although some might call it corn&equo;? 
 &bquo;I've just found myself usually more affected by the clich&eacute;s in pop, in art, in life, than I have by the&hellip; &bquo; 
 Wilful difference? 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 I find that wilfulness in itself is enough to make me turn away from something. 
 When people are attempting to be different for the sake of it, I find it incredibly irritating.&equo; 
 Do you have different influences now than when you started? 
 &bquo;I think I've been through being influenced by people. 
 I don't think that could happen to me now, in the way that it did in my formative years. 
 My ideas are self-generating now, they spring from what I've done before. 
 It's all very inwardlooking, and a lot of the time I find myself &mdash; it may sound unforgivable &mdash; ignorant of what's going on outside me and the influences that are going around. 
 I don't think I'm fully formed or ever will be, but my basic creative journey is now self-perpetuating.&equo; 
 But musically at least, you've moved from Stooges-meets-Beefheart conflagration to something more classically structured: the songs are like the charred and gutted husks of magnificent pop architecture. 
 And figures like Dylan and Leonard Cohen and Tim Rose have become important to you&hellip; 
 &bquo;But not as a matter of influence as such. 
 I only look towards someone like Dylan because I see the things that have happened in his career and the conclusions he's come to and the way he's responded to outside forces, the audience, the press&hellip; and I recognize a similarity to how I feel in my career. 
 I have a vague inkling of why Dylan has progressed the way he has, which I don't have about other people. 
 The particular songs of his which affect me have helped me to understand what I ultimately want to make of my music, and what I'm failing to make of my music. 
 What I've found to be the most inspiring of his work have been the songs which are ultimately almost meaningless in their simplicity. 
 &bquo;Take Nashville Skyline . 
 I found the fact that he made that record much more affecting than, say, Highway 67 Revisited . 
 Nashville Skyline  was one of the albums he put out after his motorcycle accident, from which the critics concluded that he  must have somehow injured his brain&hellip; 
 All the complexities of his lyrics were ironed out&hellip; 
 He made some very basic country records. 
 It's these songs, or albums like Slow Train Coming , Which affect me more than Blonde On Blonde . 
 The simplicity of the statement, and the bravery&hellip; in a way, it requires more courage than making something more &bquo;experimental&equo;.&equo; 
 So you feel the same enlightenment that happened to Dylan has also befallen you? 
 You no longer want to be marginal or difficult? 
 &bquo;I am still waiting for what happened to Dylan to happen to me. 
 I'd be a lot happier if I could disentangle myself from What I've already done and create songs from a completely fresh perspective.&equo; 
 THE BAD SEED 
 When did you first feel different or destined? 
 At school? 
 Later? 
 &bquo;I assumed everybody felt they were different from everybody else&hellip; it would be a pretty sad individual who didn't feel that they were unique.&equo; 
 But such an individual usually defines him or herself against a body of people who are meant to be homogeneous and standard-issue. 
 &bquo;I didn't have any great coming out. 
 Perhaps my basic thoughts were externalized by reading Crime and Punishment  by Dostoievsky, and realizing that I had a basic Napoleonic complex. 
 That was quite a revelation in those years of juvenilia. 
 That book is all about the idea that the world is divided into the ordinary and the extraordinary, and that the extraordinary shouldn't have to live by the dictates of the mediocre majority. 
 As an adolescent, this made sense to me.&equo; 
 Do you think every body has the potential to be extraordinary, if pushed over a limit? 
 &bquo;No, I don't, actually. 
 I think everybody probably does feel they do. 
 But I think they're probably deluded. 
 I don't believe that we're all born equal, as lumps of dough that are later shaped by our peers and parents and so forth&hellip; 
 I believe in innate inequality.&equo; 
 Did you have an unusual childhood? 
 Was there something to colour your worldview with its tragic perspective? 
 &bquo;I'm sure there was&hellip; but I'm not about to start psychoanalysing myself&hellip; &bquo; 
 You see it as a bogus science? 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 Anyway, rather than attributing it to my childhood, I prefer to believe that I was born into the world with greater or lesser faculties than other people and that I can take full responsibility for them. 
 I wouldn't put it down to the way I was manipulated as a child.&equo;  
 Doesn't that mean you have even less responsibility? 
 Wouldn't that make you even angrier with the world? 
 &bquo;I think people get even angrier if they think about this precise thing that was done in their so-called formative years that made them the way they are. 
 I just feel that I can take credit, or blame, for what I do and have done. 
 That it came from within me, not from without. 
 I'd rather see what makes me different as something almost congenital. 
 And I have these inklings that what you commit or endure in this world, relates to some kind of system of justice or balance. 
 Maybe if you get a bad deal in this world, it is because of something you did, or were, in a previous life. 
 Which is why I don't feel sorry for the poor.&equo; 
 Cave's departure from progressive humanism, with Its belief in individual and social transformation, is so extreme that his worldview verges on the Mediaeval: the language of curses, bad seed, the worm in the bud. 
 The world is a vale of tears, a giant ball of dung. 
 Even more than Morrissey and his bad memories, Cave's vision is the antithesis of the idea of pop as a remaking of yourself. 
 For Cave, the sole possibility for heroism is in fatalism, a stoic dignity in the face of your plight, the blight that is your negative birthright. 
 (1988)  
 p 78: blank 
 THE DEATH OF SOUL all souled out (written with David Stubbs) 
 THE QUEEN IS DEAD AND HER NAME WAS ARETHA FRANKLIN 
 What is strangling pop? 
 What has turned its face that grey colour? 
 Passion. 
 Passion is blushing furiously across pop, rapidly turning it to ashes in its shame. 
 The blight of &bquo;87 is not media cowardice, record companies asleep at the wheel, callous insipidness, the return of rock, incoherence, a lack of great songs, but rather, a surfeit of PASSION. 
 In 1987, the consensus is that everything must be stamped with soul and franked with passion. 
 We're thinking Terence Trent d'Arby, but also U2; Tina Turner, but also Chuck Brown; Mick Hucknall, and all soul music. 
 But Passion is spent! 
 Soul is dead, like God is dead. 
 The battles are over. 
 The hour is late, but the likes of View From a Hill and Hothouse Flowers won't admit it. 
 In the age of sampling, they're still using a Hammond organ. 
 What is the thinking behind this small insistence? 
 Our culture is clearly a riotous heap of fragments and Erasure are asking us why we can't live together. 
 Who are they trying to kid? 
 We could tolerate these sentimental Luddites but then hot-foot comes the final straw on the broken back of a donkey: a ferry sinks, claims the lives of dozens, questions are raised about profits gained at the expense of passenger safety, and a bunch of pop stars gather together, whimper, implore, shed buckets for us to throw money in, unite in the passionate cry &bquo;Let IT BE!&equo; 
 Sorry, we believe that should read: &bquo;Pursue the Matter to the Highest Court&equo;! 
 Is this what Womack has come to? 
 A stick to beat us with? 
 Cajole, shame, bully, push away? 
 For too long, we have stared from the moon in reproachful silence at this spectacle. 
 Better that Aretha Franklin had not been born than that we should  endure a drop more of this acid rain of spittle! 
 Soul? 
 My arse &mdash; the Queen is dead and her name was Aretha Franklin! 
 VINTAGE STUFF 
 In 1987, soul is no more than a packed vehicle beating a hasty retreat from what are perceived as the excesses of white modernism. 
 This reaction owes its first impulse to the early days of punk, when groups like Marine, The Pop Group and A Certain Ratio first dabbled, intrigued, in funk. 
 What began as an exotic flirtation with the Other, a pop foray into a perceived Heart of Darkness, soon turned into a full-blown dance initiative in those irony-clad years of 1980&ndash;81, with everyone from Japan to ABC to Cabaret Voltaire to Spandau Ballet to Heaven 17 conspiring to venture a white funk whose snappiness was a jeer at the indies, a white funk that would saunter easily into the charts and every other public place and, with their  manifestos , make them better places to be. 
 While that particular strain of thinking was busy degenerating into New Pop, scholars, as they will, peeled back this pop cartoon to find the real thing feeding it from beneath&hellip; torch singers. 
 Lost Soul. 
 Billie Holiday. 
 Aretha. 
 There swiftly followed a post-modern embarrassment of Charly re-issues, soulboy standards, and a wave of remorse swept over Face  readers the world over (well, London over). 
 &bquo;My God. 
 We can never be this good again.&equo; 
 Thousands took the pledge and joined the anti-rock wagon. 
 There are people now in the Wag Club whose musical digestive systems would probably collapse if they were to be inadvertently fed a powerchord. 
 New pop was born, concurrently, with Yazoo. 
 Alison Moyet's voice was a wholesome barrage of body, a humanist apology for the perceived thin-ness of Depeche Mode (her partner Vince Clarke's first group), a fiery torch brought to bear on a cold, metallic sound (synthpop, modernism at its coolest). 
 The upshot, you know &mdash; death, as it were, warmed up. 
 Today's pop, be it Moyet, Curiosity, even Phil Collins or Tina turner, reads as a continued act of contrition for past pop mischief &mdash; how could Clare Grogan eat ice cream when, as we all know, Billie Holiday spent nine months in a state asylum? 
 It's a music that boasts some kind of spiritual superiority to the allegedly ubiquitous synthetic rubbish' that is elsewhere smothering our lives like nylon. 
 But where is this &bquo;white trash&equo;? 
 It's been marginalized, become a myth. 
 The truth is that today's pop &mdash; Whitney, Simply Red, Tina turner, George Michael, Anita Baker, Fine Young Cannibals, Percy Sledge, Ben E. King, The  Communards, Gabriel, Erasure, The Christians &mdash; are about shame about pop. 
 They're right to be ashamed, but of themselves, not of pop. 
 There is a tedious pounding at the heart of this music, a sincerity that allows for only one angle of delivery, a passion that has created a pop atmosphere in which it's impossible to be clever, cool or cynical, a soul whose impulse is NOT to embrace the avant-garde, like Faustus, and be cut into a thousand pieces by a sampling machine. 
 This pop will never trivialize itself, and so can never be lauded as cheap tack. 
 Nor, conversely, does it aspire to art-pop status, because its aim is to be truthful to its mediocre soul. 
 It is therefore neither fascinating, nor &bquo;literate&equo; &mdash; just warm. 
 If you want to know why the charts are no good these days, therefore, don't blame Radio One: blame Billie Holiday, Stax, Sam Cooke, Blind Lemon Jefferson even. 
 Or rather, the people who decided that they were &bquo;relevant&equo;. 
 THE PUTRID EMOTION 
 In what ways are &bquo;passion&equo; or &bquo;soul&equo; appropriate signifiers for these times? 
 Is Mick Hucknall really how emotion sounds? 
 A regular, freeflowing effusion of passion? 
 This soulful thrust, this loud inundation? 
 What information does it really carry, apart from telling you about the therapeutic inclinations of the caterwauler himself? 
 For us, there is more emotion in the undemonstrative numbness, the ironically incomplete account given of self by New Order or the Mekons, than in the silky signals emanating from your Anita Bakers. 
 Can you find dejection, prostration, the sticking in the craw of the intolerable, in the passionate grit of a Terence Trent D'Arby? 
 Sometimes, the dis-passionate vocal can express more grief &mdash; the wounded, bloodlet voice of a Kristin Hersh, or the muezzin prayer wail of a John Lydon or a David Thomas &mdash; an upwardly spiralling peal that emanates from exile, a gaping chasm where SOUL once plumply resided. 
 In the drowsy drawl of Arthur Russell or A.R. 
 Kane, the emotional content hangs as beautifully as bromide, approaches oblivion, unconsciousness or drifting consciousness, as opposed to the rigid wide-awake club that comprises the Totalitarians of Passion. 
 THE EXAMPLE THAT HOWLINGLY TOPS THEM ALL: The Fine Young Cannibals' cover of The Buzzcocks' &bquo;Ever Fallen In Love&equo;. 
 THE ORIGINAL: a sullen, inexpressive wail, a fallible voice as small and sorely limited as a back bedroom, a fey, frustrated frailty. 
 THE COVER: Roland Gift's overdressed, over-stressed surfeit of overtures  glows with an odious, and utterly irrelevant magnificence! 
 Gift's bombast is quite at odds with the gnawing sense of LACK at the heart of the lyric. 
 The problem here is, of course, one of stylization. 
 The Totalitarians of Passion have reduced their technique to the state of James Brown's knees &mdash; a splintered mess, tattered through over-use. 
 Although the passion-merchant, the soul man, is in pursuit of some sort of authenticity, a confirmation of his depth of feeling, his is not his own voice, is rather the convention, a tear-jerk reaction. 
 When someone uses the conventional cues and triggers of emotion in this way, all they end up communicating is the desire to cue an acquired reflex. 
 Insofar as soul is about sex, one result can be a musical hypersexuality, where the signs of passion are learnt, exaggerated, Inflated and unmoored from the &bquo;real thing&equo;. 
 With Prince or Zapp, this is most fine, as they achieve the other, an ultra-vivid (Prince), more super-human sound (Zapp's vocoder). 
 Prince is the Hendrix, in terms of achieving this emotional swell: Mick Hucknall the Gary Moore. 
 THE FETID BLIGHT OF HUMANISM 
 SOUL was once &mdash; a very long time ago &mdash; the sound of a psyche breaking up, shattered by desire or loss &mdash; a wracked catharsis, an ailing, dejected, broken sound, essentially tragic. 
 Today, soul has become a token of strength of feeling, strength of being. 
 Beige popsters take a vicarious pride in the slow baptism of fire that their chosen genre and its protagonists underwent. 
 They imagine that they can bask in the reflected glory of their martyr, Sam Cooke, of legions of underpaid, socially alienated, forgotten black vocalists. 
 Beige vocalists admire and envy the &bquo;blacks&equo; for being more in touch with their emotions, their bodies, the unfettered ignorance of their self-expression. 
 Faintly irked by the &bquo;crisis&equo; of white music &mdash; that its body has been &bquo;forgotten&equo;, its attention allowed to meander across the debris of a vast information explosion, away from the folk fire, to be easily bored, jaded, distracted &mdash; beige vocalists attempt to construct an ersatz black body to signify&hellip; what? 
 Health! 
 The vocal dexterity, vigour and power of the soul man amount to&hellip; passion as workout! 
 In our culture, which sets such a high premium on self-enrichment (in every sense), the robust, emotive and expressive aspects of soul act as a sort of therapy, helping us to &bquo;liberate&equo; ourselves by getting back in touch with ourselves, opening up, unblocking, becoming more functional and therefore (it runs) more &bquo;free&equo;. 
 The musclebound exhibition of soul works as a boast &mdash; see the depth of my feeling, hear the wealth of my emotion! see how I am moved!  
 Yes, it is quite as sinister as it seems. 
 &bquo;Totalitarianism&equo; is not too strong a word. 
 This humanistic vision of vigour and common purpose quite simply writes out deviancy, strange pain, breakdown of communication, the incapacity to be &bquo;moved&equo;. 
 Even when the soul man is &bquo;hurt&equo;, it is only a celebration of his ability to be &bquo;touched&equo;. 
 Today, every voice in pop must be a Voice, must measure up, because today, anything less than a raucous tear-blob sounds simply feeble on Planet Pop, must die like the runt. 
 We all heard about the Consensus Terrorism at work in Band/Live/Ferry Aid. 
 It could not have found a more appropriate, more common voice than the soulful. 
 The sub-text of &bquo;Feed the World&equo; was anxious self-congratulation, an insidious demonstration of feeling. 
 &bquo;Look at the strength of our concern!&equo; 
 The bluster of the tear-stained pop stars simply buffeted, pushed away the possibility that the lyric ought to have contained certain small truths such as &bquo;WE ARE THE SICK ONES, WE IN THE WEST&equo;. 
 The all-prevailing, extended blubber of Passion has become incapable of expressing sickness. 
 What we got was the jelly-like wobbling of Western pop's fulsome, milky tit in the face of the starving. 
 More recent, more passionate, more obscene still: The Ferry Aid single. 
 To say nothing of the fact that &bquo;charity&equo; should not have been invoked in this issue, the fact was that the excruciating passion levels broke all records on this outing, bust all guts. 
 And, once again, the incontinent hysteria of the massed popsters was an utterly inappropriate treatment for the hushed resignation of &bquo;Let It Be&equo; (itself an inappropriate song!!). 
 It's quite clear that the influence of soul music in pop has become poisonous, repressive, grey and total. 
 It's time to haul away from the centre of pop, the humanist body (Terence Trent, U2, Simply Red) and leave in its place a ghostly un-body (Public Enemy, Throwing Muses, A.R. 
 Kane). 
 To move from the FULFILMENT, SELF-ASSURANCE, STRENGTH, and SELF-POSSESSION implied in passion to a pale sense of LACK, VULNERABILITY, of being POSSESSED. 
 To snuff out the FIRE OF PASSION and shiver again to the CHILL OF AWE, of magic, trance, falling, yearning. 
 It's time to put a bullet through the head of SOUL HUMANISM and find liberation in the inhumanity of the mechanical, bestial, angelic, demonic, ghostly. 
 To leave the crowded, tear-stained, blackened spaces of Planet Pop and drift to the MOON. 
 To share there the cold, quietly admonishing gaze of He Said, The Stars of Heaven, Happy Mondays, Meat Puppets. 
 To go UNDERWATER and SWIM with Arthur Russell and A.R. 
 Kane. 
 Or UNDERGROUND, to join Big BLACK, BUTTHOLE Surfers, World Domination, Skinny Puppy&hellip; 
 Blast Passion, which has blasted all doubt, mischief and intrigue onto the peripheries, drowned pop in shame.  
 A CONCERNED SOULBOY DOUBTS OUR WORD 
 CONCERNED SOULBOY: &bquo;Very provocative, I'm sure, but none of this seems all that radical to me. 
 When it comes down to it, all you're saying is that the likes of Tina Turner and Mick Hucknall have created a bloated travesty of soul. 
 Well, I'd go along with that &mdash; but you seem to forget that Tina turner is fake soul, not real soul at all.&equo; 
 Ah, but it's this very desire for a &bquo;real soul&equo; that is the malaise. 
 A yearning for a &bquo;new Marvin Gaye&equo; to throb miraculously at the centre of pop to resolve its own, fabulous identity crisis. 
 Do you imagine that any single figure in pop can tell us precisely What's Goin' On? 
 And would such a figure &mdash; an auteur with a carrying voice to bring us all within earshot &mdash; be helpful, or even possible? 
 (Terence Trent D'Arby, ha ha ha!) 
 Why do we need more and better soul &mdash; why should it not swiftly become a fat, sweaty, obscenity, like the last lot did? 
 Ultimately, the Campaign for Real Soul amounts only to an ostrich-head-in-sand retreat from the future: a future pop based in soul-less, ground-less dis-corporation. 
 CS: &bquo;You can say all you like, but it's clear that soul music is more popular than it has ever been, worldwide.&equo; 
 You do not seem to appreciate that the point at which Soul is stretched the furthest, globally, is the point at which it is weakest. 
 Spread thin, ubiquitous, where once it was rare, exotic, precious, a sob in private. 
 A little too much of anything suffocates pop. 
 CS: &bquo;And I suppose you think there's been a bit too much soul. 
 So, after all this, what do you foresee as the consequences for hip hop, Chuck Brown, Tashan, Alexander O'Neal? 
 I know you like them all.&equo; 
 Black people are quite as capable of evading the totalitarianism of passion as whites are of perpetrating it. 
 This is not an issue of race, but of creed. 
 Take hip hop and house. 
 Twelve-inch culture kills soul! 
 Hip hop is anti-soul, disperses consciousness, quite literally CUTS UP ITS BODY. 
 From here on, the likes of Tashan must be discussed not in terms of &bquo;spirit&equo;, passion, emotional commitment, but ether, wire, the ocean, the paintings of Chirico, peculiar grace. 
 We have no quarrel with the delicious plastic that Tony Blackburn plays on his daytime show. 
 CS: &bquo;You bastards! 
 There's more of worth, more that uplifts in a single chorus of &bquo;We Need Money'&equo; than in a dozen of your picky, pedantic articles!&equo; 
 A dozen or more examples of the soulboy's discourse have made it impossible for us to listen to virtually any &bquo;black&equo; record with any real pleasure, without  ghastly phrases like &bquo;pride and dignity&equo; popping into our heads. 
 This is nothing personal, you understand &mdash; your voice is not your own, you are the product of a discourse. 
 CS: &bquo;You bandy about the word &bquo;totalitarian'&equo; &mdash; you're scarcely immune from that yourself! 
 No soulboy would propose a five-year boycott of Velvet Underground LPs &mdash; yet that is precisely what you propose for Marvin Gaye, Aretha and Billie Holiday!&equo; 
 We realize that it is hard. 
 To you, it doubtless seems as &bquo;unnatural&equo; as ripping out your own heart with a mechanical claw. 
 But there is no longer a &bquo;natural&equo; role for soul. 
 With the death of God and the death of the Ground, all that is left is &mdash; the Air. 
 Try to understand that Pop should be up in the air, supernatural, alive to all angles and shades of emotion, plastic and twice-cooked. 
 Bless Marvin Gaye &mdash; but we don't need him at the moment! 
 This is the age of the Aerial! (1987)  
 from &bquo;young soul rebels&equo; to designer soul-cialism 
 Dexy's Midnight Runners were perhaps the prototype for the new soul militancy of the eighties. 
 Soul for them was a form of exertion; performance that Barney Hoskyns called (in reference to The Jam, as it happens) &bquo;a gymnasium of exhortation&equo;. 
 Tenderness and languor did not fit into the &bquo;Young Soul Rebels&equo; scheme. 
 Dexy's songs were a series of  manifestos  and clarion calls for a new, pure music, always about  to be born. 
 This was meta-music, its subject an alleged degeneration of pop culture, its mission to bring back a sense of a mission to music. 
 All Kevin Rowland seemed to be saying was that he had something to say. 
 He was a zealot for zeal in itself. 
 Dexy's used to workout together, they abstained from alcohol and drugs. 
 Developing your body and your soul, exercise and suffering, were both facets of a supremely masculine fortification of the spirit. 
 Lamming  on Dexy's-clones Big Sound Authority: &bquo;wait till you see this man sweat&equo; &mdash; sweat as the tangible proof of authenticity, commitment.) 
 Kevin Rowland's first group &mdash; a punk band &mdash; were called The Killjoys. 
 Rowland &mdash; with his paranoiac hatred of the music press, his fervent work ethic, his privileging of &bquo;projected passion&equo; over intellect &mdash; turned soul into a kind of micro-fascism. 
 All that was needed was for someone to take Rowland's ascetic vision/version of soul fanaticism and commandeer it for political ends. 
 SOCIALIST REALIST POP 
 The Redskins are &bquo;Young Soul Rebels&equo; with  a cause. 
 An ultimate agit pop group, sat painfully pat at the confluence of three socialist realist orthodoxies: that there is a necessary and simple fit between pop culture and radical politics: that youth culture is a working-class phenomenon; that black music alone is the only  unembarrassing and legitimate basis for protest. 
 They take the intensity of soul and clench it into a fist rather than using it as a form of release. 
 The euphoria of R&amp;B is made the vehicle for constructive ends. 
 Scrape past the Soul Man postures and you find&hellip; 
 The Clash, or worse, The Tom Robinson Band. 
 The Redskins' link-up with the Socialist Workers' Party is the most stringent and emphatic attempt to thrust pop into some sort of relation to the &bquo;real&equo; world. 
 This is the most deluded fantasy of all &mdash; the idea that, by buying certain pieces of vinyl and by going to certain gigs, instead of consuming a commodity, you are participating and making a contribution to &bquo;the struggle&equo;. 
 In the agit-pop scheme of things, pleasure-in-itself has no value. 
 Expenditure without return, the sheer waste of energy, is forbidden. 
 The guilt of consumption, of being consumed, has to be expunged, validated by a second, ulterior use (drinking Nicaraguan coffee annoys Reagan, going to a rock benefit is fun with a purpose). 
 Agit-poppers constantly castigate pop for its dereliction of duty and its straying from being aligned. 
 For instance, witness Steven Wells fulminating in the NME : &bquo;Pop can be treated as the vile pus that drips from sores of a cancerous body politic.&equo; 
 Its only value is as &bquo;a platform for propaganda&equo;. 
 Of course, the left has traditionally had a purely instrumental attitude to culture, leisure, fin. 
 Art for art's sake has been dismissed as &bquo;apolitical&equo;, &bquo;solipsistic&equo;, &bquo;bourgeois&equo;. 
 (But isn't the terror of expenditure without return the very epitome of bourgeois economic continence?) 
 In the fifties, socialists railed against the decadence of youth consumption, youth's hankering for Americana, like zoot suits, comic books, quiffs and the &bquo;meaningless gibberish&equo; of rock'n'roll. 
 What was detested was an excess of form over content, the gratuitous flamboyance of tail-fins on cars, extravagant use of cloth in clothing. 
 Paul Weller's Style Council and Red Wedge are the latest incarnations of this tendency. 
 Weller is trying to make political idealism glamorous by linking it with being a stylist, and validate being a stylist by aligning it with political ideals. 
 There's an idea here of consumption with integrity, the notion that certain consumer choices have a natural fit with certain political choices &mdash; hence the cover of Our Favourite Shop . 
 What is fantasized here is a perfect life &mdash; a smoothly running, perfectly functional, utilitarian consumer aesthetic that has a natural congruence with socialist politics. 
 Weller's shopping list of socialist good taste includes Bass Weejuns, Burberry raincoats, Motown and Stax 45s, Italian design, Blue Note LPs, etc. 
 But what is included is less revealing than what is excluded: all the excessive elements of working-class consumption that refuse to fit neatly into this socialist continence &mdash; Stanley knives, lurid cocktails, Blind Date , trash videos, tabloids, bingo, heavy metal, Club 18&ndash;30&hellip;  
 DESIGNER SOUL-CIALISM 
 You can find a similar idea of consumption with integrity in The Face , where the Disinformation column snuggles next to photographs of exorbitant clothes and furniture, the implication being that avant-garde design is part of some grand progressive thrust that also includes socialism. 
 This is designer socialism: the belief that buying tassled loafers rather than winklepickers, is somehow as much a PR of the struggle as being on the picket line at Wapping. 
 The semiotic approach to subcultural style pioneered by Dick Hebdige and his cohorts at Birmingham's Centre for Contemporary Cultural Studies &mdash; reading into working-class consumption for evidence of myriad micro-resistances to the status quo &mdash; has been turned arse about tit. 
 &bquo;Pride and dignity&equo; is the soulboy soul-cialist's supreme tenet. 
 This too has its origins in subcultural theory: Hebdige's hypothesis that the &bquo;classy&equo; look of Mod style was a challenge to the class structure in sixties Britain, an expression of resilient self-belief. 
 But this begs the question: does &bquo;pride and dignity&equo; amount to anything more than the aspiration to participate in society on its own terms? 
 What use is the Staples Singers' exhortation &bquo;respect yourself&equo;, if the notion of self-respect is still bound to conventional notions of respectability? 
 ROOTS RHYTHM RADICALISM 
 In the early eighties there was a massive defection of Social Realist Pop to the cause of black music. 
 Weller led the way, dropping The WHO as his model for political protest in favour of funk and early seventies disco. 
 Agit-poppers convinced themselves that rock was archaic and debased, no longer capable of functioning as a medium for radical comment. 
 The energy of punk, of the whole Rock Against Racism initiative, had faded. 
 At similar moments of entropy, black music has functioned as an alluring outside for white youth &mdash; the old notion of the Black as other, incarnation of sexuality and the forbidden. 
 But whereas previously identification with geographically-proximate black subcultures was the influence (punk felt an affinity with Rastafarian dub, for instance), this time round there was a dissemination of certain ideas of blackness through the media, a borrowing from the files of history. 
 ROOTS RHYTHM RADICALISM &mdash; this cluster's perceived identity was what lay behind the drive for an infusion of blackness. 
 The assumption behind this shift was that an ideal black music would naturally link up with socialist politics. 
 And so a sanitized canon of soul and funk was drawn up: James Brown's &bquo;Say it Loud, I'm Black and I'm Proud&equo;, Curtis Mayfield's &bquo;Move On Up&equo; and &bquo;We've got to Have Peace&equo;, Timmy Thomas's &bquo;Why Can't We Live  Together&equo;, Gil Scott Heron's &bquo;The Bottle&equo;, Grandmaster Flash's &bquo;The Message&equo;, Brother D and the Collective Effort's &bquo;How We Gonna Make the Black Nation Rise&equo;, James Brown and Afrika Bambatta's &bquo;Unity&equo;. 
 What's brought to the fore is the political content of the music, but what's written out is the &bquo;unsoundness&equo; &mdash; the anti-social, anti-egalitarian narcissism of black pop, the brutality of hip hop, the show excess and upward aspirations of mainstream soul. 
 In its insistence on the Message and on street-cred, the new soul is very much cramped and shadowed by the dowdy spirit of new wave, with its emphasis on lyrical &bquo;relevance&equo;. 
 New soul carries on the side of punk that was least interesting (slogans, youth rhetoric, documentary realism) rather than the more artistically provocative element (punk's theatre of rage and disgust). 
 If The Redskins are the Clash of the new soul, what we need is soul's Sex Pistols, a group that can work from soul's unrealism, its dangerous ecstasy, to make unreasonable demands. 
 All that's happened is that, in switching from rock to soul, agit-pop has shifted emphasis from denunciation to affirmation, or what has been called offensive optimism. 
 &bquo;Shout it to the Top&equo;, as The Style Council have it. 
 THE COST OF LOVING 
 It's a strange journey Paul Weller's made, but stranger still is that he's managed to take the greater part of his audience along with him. 
 Somehow he's managed to lead one of the most entrenched examples of playsafe rock consensus &bquo;forward&equo; into apparently digging music that sounds just like Con Funk Shun, Rah Band, Loose Ends. 
 The problem is that Weller, ever earnest, has internalized too thoroughly the edict Rock is Dead. 
 For every past powerchord and epic gesture he now endeavours to atone, publicly, by the slavish imitation of the most slick and redundant aspects of contemporary black music. 
 Once he believed The Jam was the true sound of When you're young'; now he's wised up, got hip to the fact that where the &bquo;real kids&equo; are at is&hellip; 
 Robbie Vincent, LWR, all the loathsome details of fake sophistication (&bquo;light those candles&hellip; open the freezer door&equo;). 
 Embarrassed by the rash declamatory urgency of his past with The Jam, Weller wants to leave behind adolescence, and &bquo;progress&equo; from gauche to smooth. 
 The Style Council sound is a condensation of the whole gamut of naff provincial fantasies of sophistication &mdash; vibes, Hammond organ, strings, jazzfunk, drummers who use a brush; easy listening that appeals to spivs of either political denomination. 
 No longer a rock band, where a certain stiffness in the limbs is a virtue, but not yet virtuoso jazzers, The Style Council are stuck at that most useless of levels &mdash; semi-fluency. 
 Who needs spineless pastiche of &bquo;My Guy&equo; perkiness  and Modem Jazz Quartet cool jazz? 
 Five years on, anti-rockism is the new hippiedom. 
 Weller has simply transposed one &bquo;reality&equo; of English suburbia for another, the smalltown smallness of &bquo;English Rose&equo;, &bquo;That's Entertainment&equo;, &bquo;Smithers-Jones&equo; (derived from mod) updated to a world of winebars and nightclubs. 
 But is deference to &bquo;reality&equo; such a good thing anyway? 
 What exactly is of value in this nouveau-riche southern heartland of Thatcherism? 
 The Cost of Loving  sees Weller severing, finally, from the sixties. 
 The music is a surprisingly accurate imitation of that most toothless, spineless idiom, Britfunk.. 
 Philly pastiches, jazz-funk ballads, Streetsounds  stuff&hellip; none of which approaches the real mind-lessening ecstasy of disco. 
 It's irretrievable naffness can be conveyed in only two words &mdash; Junior Giscombe. 
 Songcraft, good intentions, an anxiety to avoid love clich&eacute;s &mdash; all these are the very death of disco. 
 Worse still is when Weller attempts to remotivate the sound of Saturday Nite, make it bear the burden of his meaning well. 
 I liked them more when The Style Council played with pop history, assembled their own fantasy of &bquo;perfect pop&equo; out of Philly, Blue Note, Left Bank, Holland-Dozier-Holland. 
 Dear old Paul Weller. 
 We're all on the same side. 
 No doubt I'll be voting Labour with exactly the same mixture of dutiful resignation and frustration there's no more incandescent alternative, as he will. 
 I even have a sneaking affection for the man. 
 But the sad fact is that even if it is possible to achieve a co-incidence between desire and responsibility, ecstasy and concern, Weller is incapable of such a balance. 
 The problem is the fundamental modesty of his aspiration, of his person &mdash; those unvoluptuous good looks. 
 Within The Redskins' drastically curtailed emotional range, they worked, because there's a potential for romance in streetfighting and revolution. 
 But&hellip; how can you make the Labour Party seem exciting? 
 That's the flaw in Red Wedge &mdash; their chiding logic of pragmatism (&bquo;as good as we'll get&hellip; let's face facts&equo;) is in fundamental antagonism to pop's intolerant utopianism. 
 On The Cost of Loving  there's a track called &bquo;Right To Go&equo;, recorded with &bquo;homegrown&equo; rappers The Dynamic Three. 
 It's dated flailing and useless, hardly crucial or fresh, but the real problem is: how can you conceivably make trudging through the wet leaves and puddles to your local primary school, in order to tick a piece of paper in a polling booth, seem like a glamorous and dynamic act of self-realization, or even solidarity? 
 THE CHRISTIANS 
 Nothing makes me more downcast than the &bquo;uplifting&equo;, nothing elevates me more than the de-jected. 
 Only music that stems from spiritual impoverishment  enriches my life, Oh, like everybody else I had my summer of soul, like a lot of white boys, thought I'd found my truest voice. 
 But what was once a breakthrough, a crucial realignment of taste among white rock fans, has subsequently congealed into orthodoxy. 
 In the process, soul has been installed as something that bolsters your life, rather than knocks the ground from under your feet. 
 The extremism I once heard in soul has been evened out. 
 Britpop always lags far behind black American pop. 
 In the sixties and seventies the blues boom and heavy metal were vulgarizing the blues years after the fact. 
 Now it's early seventies black pop that's being bastardized, the exquisite anguish of your Timmy Thomases reduced to a blunt compassion. 
 What groups like The Christians do to soul is both coarsen and mute it, at the same time. 
 But that's as maybe &mdash; even if The Chieftains were this decade's Temptations, Mayfield or Gaye, they still wouldn't be needed. 
 Speaking purely politically, in the current climate, cultural representations of failure have more resonance than fortitude-in-adversity. 
 Pop's prime mover is narcissism, always will be, and so self-pity is more crucial a pop response than altruism. 
 Pop was never meant to be this vicarish. 
 &bquo;How Long Can This Go On&equo;, &bquo;Save A Soul In Every Town&equo;, &bquo;Ideal World&equo;, &mdash; even the CRASSEST agit-pop militancy is preferable to this cooing and billowing Radox bath of sententious platitudes. 
 Give me rage and hate anyday. 
 Sure the world needs more love in it; sure, the brutal and uncaring hold the reins; sure, some people have no choice about having their lives wasted &mdash; but I celebrate the brutal and wasteful in music because I know what fascinates me, and it's not this ghastly New Wave soul with-the-one-saxophone-tacked-on. 
 I also know that nothing &bquo;political&equo; happens at Christians gigs, not with words this literal, emotions this plain and simplistic. 
 People may be moved, but no one is moving . 
 (1985&ndash;7)  
 smooth operators 
 What is it with today's teenyboppers? 
 Why is it that they bestow their ardour upon the well-adjusted, wholesome architects of pop's fatal new maturity? 
 In the old days, there used to be crazes, Adam and the Ants, Gary Numan, absurd figures who nonetheless possessed a certain mesmeric force, managed to induct us into ludicrousness, like the Pied Piper. 
 Maladjusted, inadequate characters with a grudge against the world and a lot to prove (both Adam and Numan had mammoth chips on the shoulder about the music press). 
 These fanatics used fame as a chance to impose their own loopy private fantasy world on pop kids' imagination. 
 Today, the level-headed hold sway, pop planners with sufficient self confidence to want to use pop to do more than celebrate themselves. 
 Unlike the damaged narcissists, with their compensations of spurious glory or morbidly melodramatized misery, the new pop workers want attention not for themselves, not for their make-believe world, but for what they have to say about the outside world. 
 I allude, of course, to the wave of middlebrow mature pop for whom the Song is more important than the Star &mdash; Wet Wet Wet, Deacon Blue, Hue and Cry, Blow Monkeys, Danny Wilson, Microdisney, etc. 
 Fame is not the spur, it's a liability, or a &bquo;necessary part of the process, y'know&equo;&hellip; 
 This decade has seen the old bogey of progressive rock gradually replaced by progressive pop: the site for left-liberal well-meaning and pensiveness has shifted from concept albums and pomp rock, to the three-minute song and pop soul. 
 Prog pop (like prog rock before it) is an embarrassed attempt to leave behind adolescence &mdash; that unsettled interim state so fruitfully prey to traumas, visionary  states, loosemindedness, impossible aspirations. 
 To move &bquo;forward&equo; from self-absorbed narcissism/doubt to adult altruism/commitment. 
 And so the sound of pop is no longer adolescent &mdash; urgent, frustrated, awkward, rampant &mdash; it's &bquo;assured&equo; and &bquo;classy&equo;. 
 Ricky Ross from Deacon Blue talks about not wanting to seduce the audience: &bquo;I don't like the idea of people throwing themselves over to our music&hellip; abandonment is a great idea but it worries me because it's all so power-orientated.&equo; 
 All that's left is &bquo;communication&equo;, pop as vehicle. 
 The desire to ingratiate a way into the listener's consciousness and thus inveigle an all-important content is the reason all these groups draw inspiration from Sinatra, Bacharach and David, Sondheim, Steely Dan, early seventies' soul, to produce slick, crafted, sophisticated pop. 
 Unfortunately, the decision to opt for smoothness rather than scruffiness, composure rather than gaucheness, is not an innocent choice. 
 Sounds have political resonance. 
 The lyrics may be concerned and caring, but the music sounds nouveau riche, ostentatiously flashy, costly. 
 The invariably suave vocals bring to mind the phrase &bquo;smooth operator&equo;, and the only people who want to be smoothies are Thatcherite southern spivs. 
 To aggravate all this further, the records all sound as though they were designed to be played on compact disc. 
 For these groups, &bquo;classy&equo; and &bquo;classic&equo; have become elided, identical. 
 They've scoured their record collections for their favourite chic embellishments so as to enhance the luxury commodity aura of their product. 
 Danny Wilson use Lester Bowie's Brass Fantasia. 
 Hue and Cry jet off to Sigma Sound, NYC, to work with Jimmy Biondolillo (Sinatra's strings arranger) and the horn section James Brown used for Living in America . 
 Wet Wet Wet mosey down to Memphis to work with Willie Mitchell in the studio he used to record Al Green; Dr Robert duets with Curtis Mayfield. 
 With the entire wealth of pop history on hand, the temptation is to indulge in the kind of free-for-all pick'n'mix that has been called retro-nuevo. 
 The result is that any notion of musical futurism has fallen into abeyance. 
 The idea of the New has always been a crucial part of pop's rhetoric: the idea that the future is going to be a improvement on the past (that sixties' feeling of being on the brink of a whole new order, the beginning of an endless breaking down of barriers and limits). 
 In the eighties, though, everything from pop to advertising is telling us that all the golden ages are located in the past. 
 And on the other side of the Atlantic too. 
 All the mature pop groups come from Scotland or the northernmost parts of England, but all their musical reference points seem bound up with American ideas of sophistication and glamour. 
 It's curious how someone like Pat Kane  mixes being staunch SNP and singing in an American croon. 
 It's also curious how most of these groups have written at least one song about the meretricious lure of the capital. 
 Wet Wet Wet's &bquo;Wishing I Was Lucky&equo; is about going to London, then returning disillusioned to Clydebank; Danny Wilson's &bquo;Davey&equo; is another anti-metropolis warning; Hue and Cry's &bquo;Goodbye to Me&equo; is about the disorientation and displacement of the jetset life, while Deacon Blue's &bquo;Town to Blame&equo; and &bquo;Dignity&equo; and Kane Gang's &bquo;Looking for Gold&equo; are about escaping smalltown constraints. 
 There seems to be a common thread here &mdash; a desire to rise above northern grim limits into a world of sleek, cosmopolitan opportunity, and at the same time an anxiety to retain one's roots. 
 The result &mdash; a strange (but not particularly compelling) mismatch between form and content &mdash; American finery meets northern realism. 
 These groups have made strenuous efforts to get it right &mdash; to get the sound they always wanted, with none of the cheapskate shoddiness that British soul/jazz groups often settle for: to counterbalance that lush, affluent sound with concerned lyrics, nods to their roots and tons of soul-blaring compassion. 
 And they're dead keen to suppress any burgeoning, ego-trip tendencies. 
 You can almost hear them thinking, &bquo;Who could hold anything against us? 
 What have we done wrong?&equo; 
 But I can think of several reasons to resent their existence. 
 Because they strive, but can never counterfeit the ease or inevitability of great soul; are smart but never opulent, well-turned but never flamboyant. 
 Because they choose their words too carefully, jealously control their meanings, and if they're sussed enough to believe in ambiguities and contradictions you can be sure each one is carefully mounted in position for you, the listener. 
 Because they're almost there  &mdash; unlike previous white soul or funk aspirants like Kevin Rowland or A Certain Ratio who fell so far shod of their ambitions they inadvertently created something different, these groups have, through graft and expense, come close, and so clog the second division of pop-soul. 
 In the process, they participate in the global installation of a kind of universal grade of emotive competence, a standardization of the voice which is marginalizing deficient or regional voices. 
 Because they denigrate the guitar. 
 And &mdash; despite the cosmopolitan sheen of the music &mdash; precisely because their feet are  still firmly on the ground. 
 SEDUCED BUT NOT ABANDONED 
 Hue and Cry are the most interesting of the new pop sophisticates, not so much because of the music, but because singer and lyricist Patrick Kane is an  intellectual firebrand who's more sussed than most about the contradictions and complexities of trying to infiltrate intelligence into the world of teenpop. 
 Recently he penned probably the most abrasively intelligent letter ever to appear in Melody Maker , in which he laid out with admirable succinctness the differences between his pop aesthetic (making sense of the world, pop as motivator) and what he identified as the MM  aesthetic of pop as dissipation. 
 Why the obsession with American culture? 
 &bquo;I don't think I need to tell us how saturated we as a people are by American culture. 
 You cannot evade the fact that we are cultural Americans, dreaming American dreams.&equo; 
 But there are so many different Americas that fascinate and shape us. 
 In Scotland there are two in particular &mdash; there's the pop scene that draws its inspiration from American bohemians like Lou Reed, Arthur Lee, Tom Verlaine, and there's your scene, which takes its cue from Bowie's Young Americans , Average White Band, Steely Dan, Chic&hellip; 
 &bquo;People have attributed that vision of America to an upwardly mobile Glasgow scene of bands addicted to dancefloor culture. 
 Glasgow 1982&ndash;83 was a lot like New Romantic era London. 
 A lot of the pop soul, nouveau muso thing came about as a reaction to Postcard, or the post-Postcard janglepop. 
 The wilful amateurism and na&iuml;vet&eacute; started to grate on everybody's nerves. 
 The Postcard vision of America is a late sixties&equo; America&hellip; &bquo; 
 A kind of anti-American America&hellip; 
 &bquo;It's an anti-lush America. 
 Which is the America I love &mdash; the America of classic showbiz, a wee utopia of lovely surfaces and lush expensiveness&hellip; &bquo; 
 But I thought you were political&hellip; 
 &bquo;Political in the sense that if I threw this glass of water over you in an interview, that would be a political act. 
 C'mon, life is political. 
 Rick Astley is political&hellip;&equo; 
 But whereas Astley, like anything else in the world, is full of inadvertent political resonance, Hue and Cry are trying to control their political meanings. 
 Smuggle &bquo;improper&equo; ones in. 
 Isn't the danger with using an expensive sound the probability that people will take it straight, as un-ironic luxury? 
 &bquo;Yeah, but a song like &bquo;Strength to Strength'&equo; is a joke we're playing on the English working class after the election. 
 If they want a kitsch little anthem they can sing while aspiring to the next set of double glazing or automated garden gnomes, that's okay by me, because that song is a BOMB delivered from Scotland.&equo; 
 It occurs to me that Kane is overly optimistic here on three counts. 
 He over-estimates the importance of the text in pop. 
 He assumes that &bquo;ordinary&equo; pop  fans are attuned to reading off &bquo;subversion&equo; or &bquo;importance&equo; in the same way music press readers are &mdash; it's an approach in which you have to be initiated. 
 Most people may not be primed to be &bquo;subverted&equo; because they think of pop as light entertainment. 
 Finally, he underestimates the ability of pop fans to live with hidden or even oven meanings in pop that ought to affront them. 
 I've encountered Arena  -reading Young Conservatives who get off on The Smiths and Sex Pistols: I knew a girl whose favourite group is The Jam but who claims to be apolitical and whose one great desire in life is a Mercedes. 
 There's no accounting for how people (mis) use pop. 
 Being aware of the mechanics of fan idolatory, do you feel a responsibility? 
 &bquo;Aye, but you respond in a funny way. 
 I'd rather be seen as a big brother than a juicy sex symbol. 
 Someone who gives you advice that you don't want to hear, but it sinks in anyway. 
 A sententious older brother. 
 But a lot of people are looking for pseudo-satisfaction through lusting after this complete stranger, and you have to accept that, fight on that terrain., 
 So you're confident that intelligence can withstand the spotlights unwithered, untrivialized? 
 &bquo;Course it can. 
 Everybody's intelligent, everyone's trying to make sense of the world, even if they're not plugged into larger systems of thought like some of us. 
 Everyone's making choices everyday.&equo; 
 Having taken on all these images and elements of pop mythology, do you want people to be aware there's an element of irony involved? 
 &bquo;It's got to be a sugared pill, always. 
 On the subject of using the past, making references, it's just that it's impossible to evade the past, it's here, it's being thrown at you, and you have to deal with it. 
 Sure, it gets to be like a supermarket of history, pick'n'mix, and yeah, I don't know what happened to labour history, working class dignity&hellip; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Springsteen bought it all,&equo; pipes up Greg, Pat's engagingly sullen brother. 
 Pat: &bquo;Well, there you are &mdash; Springsteen's authenticity is as much constructed out of signs as anyone.&equo; 
 Discussing how Hue and Cry have left behind notions like &bquo;modernism&equo;, &bquo;rock&equo; and &bquo;youth&equo;, we somehow get round to what is the point of pop. 
 Pat &mdash; an avid reader of the music press and an ex- NME  crit himself &mdash; explains my approach&hellip; 
 &bquo;His theory, Greg, is&hellip; how long you got?&hellip; his theory is that the best music is the stuff which makes you go doolally, lose yourself. 
 I love the consistency of the theory, but I hate the actual theory.&equo; 
 Because it doesn't equip people to do anything with their lives?  
 &bquo;Because it doesn't look at the object of music. 
 If everybody was just gonna get off on weird sounds, there'd be no words. 
 And there are  lyrics and it makes sense, and that's what pop music is &mdash; popular poetry. 
 Even the most banal song makes sense. 
 People like thinking, like making sense of things.&equo; 
 But there's no single, proper use of music, no correct hit that we should all be getting. 
 I certainly wouldn't claim that the loss-of-self aesthetic was valid outside of a probably quite limited, class- and gender-specific group of people who need their over-orderly thought patterns disrupted good'n'proper. 
 But Kane was right when he identified in his letter a broad-and-loose Melody Maker  aesthetic that prefers transports to truths, rapture to appreciation, magic to meaning, the letting loose of ecstasy to the clench of commitment. 
 So if you hate the theory so much, how come you're so boned up on it? 
 What's this huge stack of post-modern journals you've got here? 
 (One of them, Seduced and Abandoned , a collection of Baudrillard-influenced essays, supplies the title of the Hue and Cry debut LP). 
 &bquo;Because it's the only thing that's happening, intellectually. 
 I read it to know the enemy. 
 I think all that stuff is just lying down in the face of the mass media. 
 Certainly, people are seduced and abandoned by the media, by its lush images &mdash; but you have to deal with that, infiltrate ideas in, give people back their vertebrae.&equo; 
 Baudrillard would argue that radical initiatives only end in re-energizing the pop machine, are more grist to commerce's mill. 
 &bquo;But that guy's a pessimist, a fuckin' nihilist.&equo; 
 THE COLLABORATORS 
 What Kane proposes is the strategy of ENTRYISM &mdash; which in its original connotation was a strategy of entering mainstream political parties undertaken by revolutionary groups so as to subvert from within. 
 The idea (rather than the term) first had rock currency in the punk aftermath. 
 After the initial night to the margins, there was speculation on how to build on the energy of punk. 
 It was around then the following formulation took hold: radical meanings required radical forms of musical expression. 
 After some time, when people began to chafe against the impotence, isolationism and &eacute;litism of the post-punk avant-garde, this notion, indeed the very idea of the &bquo;alternative,&equo; was gradually dismantled. 
 Entryism &mdash; the idea of concealing radical meanings within a conventional pop format &mdash; was born. 
 A syndrome &mdash; which was to recur again and again, from ABC to Age of Chance &mdash; of indie bands lashing other indie bands for their defeatism in not taking on the mainstream, was inaugurated. 
 ABC extolled irony,  detachment, and doffed tuxedos as a gesture against post-punk stasis. 
 As Martin Fry said later: &bquo;I am a punk. 
 I always will be,&equo; claiming that taking on the pop funk sound of the moment was a perfect fulfilment of punk's evangelist logic. 
 Scritti Politti also moved out of the shadowy margins and proposed a schizoid project &mdash; the making of perfect pop that contains its own internal deconstruction. 
 Pop that seduces as it unravels the very iconography/mythology (absolute love, the perfect girl) which drives it. 
 Between the two of them, ABC and Scritti, with their widely disseminated interviews and much-parroted rhetoric, made rock an embarrassing relic, pensioned off the guitar, discredited the indie ethos, and made soul and funk de rigueur. 
 1987 and the influence of ABC and Scritti is everywhere, still, albeit filtered and degraded by intermediaries like the Kitchenware stable (Kane Gang, Friends Again, Prefab Sprout, Bourgie Bourgie) and The Style Council. 
 ABC are everywhere suits and irony hold sway (Pet Shop Boys) while Wet Wet Wet took their name from a lyric in Scritti's &bquo;Gettin', Havin' and Holdin'. 
 Generally ABC and Scritti's ideas &mdash; that rock music is finished, and only black music is a viable vehicle for intelligence; that if you believe in what you do you owe it to yourself to dive headfirst into the mainstream &mdash; still exert something verging on hegemony. 
 Me, I find myself steadily drifting back to the unfashionable conviction that radical meanings are betrayed by conventional forms; that if melodies, key changes, and vocal cadences follow expected paths they can only reinforce commonsense perceptions. 
 I am drawn more and more to a resurrected belief in the marginal and its value-in-itself, beyond any consideration of its power to infect pop's arterial thoroughfares. 
 A belief in the &bquo;alternative&equo; &mdash; not so much in terms of an independent business infrastructure &mdash; but in the sense of otherness: music that explores the otherwordly, or the other within yourself. 
 Instead of &bquo;subversion&equo;, the cunning interpolation of irregular meanings into pop's circuitry, I'm interested in a more literal up-turning &mdash; topsy-turviness, the vaporization of meaning itself. 
 It's the difference between putting across a point of view, and sharing a vision. 
 Between Hue and Cry and The Sugarcubes. 
 Groups like Microdisney and Danny Wilson, who try to use MOR in order to get their messages over to as many people as possible, are doubly misguided. 
 How can words stir anyone to action or even reflection if the accompanying music fails to quicken the pulse? 
 And isn't it the case that real MOR &mdash; the stuff that sells, boys &mdash; has words that are anodyne too, that reinforce commonsense views of normality and (human) nature?  
 More than any other group I can think of, Microdisney are victims of rock's over-privileging of the text. 
 The words, and the need to get those words within earshot of the maximum number of people, have subordinated the music to the level of glossy paper &mdash; designed to interfere with clear transmission and reception of the message as little as possible. 
 Maybe they genuinely like their kind of aural semolina. 
 Give me un-easy listening. 
 All that wasted intellect. 
 Four years ago, we would have said of blokes like Cathal Coughlan and Patrick Kane: pop needs more figures like them, spiky, striving, sussed. 
 Now I just think their struggles sustain the fiction that intelligence can work within pop, can avoid being misread, misappropriated, or plain ignored. 
 The only hope we have for intervention in pop is as a visitation, a bolt of strangeness, something whose point is to be undecodable. 
 Like M.A.R.R.S. or The Sugarcubes. 
 Music that could never be taken as light entertainment. 
 But why bother anyway? 
 Let pop die. 
 And let those who contribute to extending its life's breath be called &mdash; COLLABORATOR. 
 (1987)  
 p 100: blank 
 SCHEMERS VERSUS DREAMERS schemers versus dreamers (written with David Stubbs) 
 In &bquo;Smooth Operators&equo; I took to task the brace of pop collaborators &mdash; Hue and Cry, Wet Wet Wet and so forth &mdash; whose reading of white funk has implicated them as collaborators in pop's current fixation with sincerity, soulfulness, positivism. 
 Groups who have drifted from our ranks in a misguided attempt to make decent pop's terrain, render it a worthy environment for Ben E. King. 
 These bands are juniors in a hegemony established by Live Aid, that unprecedented feat of anxiety, in which the likes of Quo, Dire Straits, U2, Phil Collins, even Boy George, closed ranks, created, as well as a spectacle of pop unity, an unbeatable mediocracy. 
 Since the failure of ZTT and Sputnik particularly, it has never really seemed likely that our own spiky tarts could share the limelight with the outright MOR. 
 Today, pop is a closed circuit, a self-sufficiency. 
 A chasm has reopened between a galvanized, airborne rock, the rock celebrated in the pages of Melody Maker , and the sealed, well-rounded, well-grounded entity that is pop. 
 Once more, it's Us and Them. 
 So what happened to the infiltrators, the double agents, the 
 POP STRATEGISTS 
 Pop strategy began and ended with ABC, Heaven 17, Scritti Politti and Malcolm McLaren. 
 These were the days when rock was being shooed out in disgrace, a lumpen confusion of scratched armpits and muddled motives. 
 New pop was a shiny parody of efficiency, of &bquo;wanting in&equo;. 
 Heaven 17 appropriated the jargon and paraphernalia of industry, presented themselves as a well-heeled corporation,  offering &bquo;Music Of Quality and Distinction&equo; which suavely played pop at its own game. 
 Scritti Politti appropriated the labels of luxury commodities on their record sleeves, a gesture against their early DN sleeves (photos of squats, photocopies of litter). 
 Both were provoking a spectacular confusion of signs &mdash; &bquo;quality&equo;, the &bquo;finer things in life&equo; restored to the avant-garde hipsters who, like ABC, &bquo;know what trash is&equo;. 
 Malcolm McLaren disseminated Situationist ideas through Bow Wow Wow, naked and primal jumbles of desire &mdash; &bquo;I Want Candy&equo;. 
 Later came Sputnik, with their third-generation pastiche of ambition, masterplan, world domination; their relentless colourquest for the ultimate pleasure product, for hyperstimulus. 
 There was ZTT's Frankie Goes To Hollywood, and Propaganda; Paul Morley promoted them on the assumption that pop was run by flabby-faced cowards who didn't even know how to do their own job &mdash; in other words, it took an aesthete to know and score a hit. 
 But he fell victim of the dawning disenchantment when he declared in an interview: &bquo;TWO Tribes'&equo; can be number one for nine weeks and then it's toppled by George Michael's &bquo;&bquo;Careless Whisper'&equo;. 
 You see, nothing happens.&equo; 
 Of course, &bquo;something happened&equo;. 
 It's possible to trace George Michael back to the colourmotion, the white funk irony that more or less began with ABC and spawned a straight, bleached-out generation of Howard Jones and (eventually) the Hues, Wets, Styles and Curiositys ad nauseam. 
 Nothing else though. 
 Yet there are still a smattering of pop ironists trickling sporadically, lip-first into the fray. 
 There's Win, still carrying the cheeky pennants and slogans of &bquo;81, boasting of chewing gum for the ears, expressing admiration for advertising jingles. 
 Or Age of Chance, grunting urgently about &bquo;go for it&equo; assertiveness training, positive power, hi-impact multi-sensory overload, cartoon Ballard litanies of &bquo;crush collision&equo;. 
 And there's Transvision Vamp, a chink in that chimera &bquo;the new glam&equo;, who offer us the usual tenth-hand situationism, trash reappropriation of spectacular signs (guns, stars and stripes, peroxide, Warhol), proposing &bquo;cinepop&equo; (that old &bquo;81 line about multi-media infiltration) and posturing as corporate buccaneers. 
 And there's Act with their amoral fascination for the artifice and decadence of showbiz. 
 All of these bands explicitly lambast indie parochialism and neurotic fear of major label compromise; all peddle an obsolete notion that the brash and the colourful represent a victory over the hegemony of a vague grey, with the na&iuml;ve optimism of nineteenth-century dandies. 
 But modern bourgeois suburbia is  colourful, tacky, vulgar, and these groups only mimic this different kind of  banality. 
 All talk of plunder, piracy and plagiarism in a shopworn discourse of &bquo;irreverence&equo; and boisterousness, as if Westworld kick up some kind of a rumpus on pop's trash-heap of efflorescences, as if there are still grandmothers to be shocked and purists to be cheeked. 
 What these bands have most in common, however, is that they FAIL ABJECTLY. 
 Win lost! 
 The Age of Chance's number never came up. 
 As. 
 for Transvision Vamp &mdash; well, what about them? 
 You'll find them next year all commingling ignominiously in the bargain bins with the indie &bquo;underachievers&equo;, the Motorcycle Boys and Shrubs, all malingering in the same space. 
 The Pop Tarts are the apotheosis of this disparity between rhetoric and achievement. 
 They talked a good interview. 
 They had &bquo;attitude&equo; &mdash; boy, they had attitude. 
 With a cleverly effete waft they dismissed &bquo;anti-pop&equo; (The Smiths, REM), were &bquo;pro-product, anti-celebrity&equo;, namechecked Hermes, Giorgia, Ralph Lauren, wanted to proliferate in every medium from cinema to truffles. 
 They didn't even get a record deal. 
 Even Stockport indie gerbils A Witness could boast more than that, 
 Even when the music's good, (Act's first single was superb, the Age of Chance LP was surprisingly listenable) the problem is that the pop schemers have made MASS POPULAR SUCCESS such an integral part of the product. 
 As with Frankie, so much of the pleasure is bound up with the sense of something breaking out all over the surfaces of everyday life, and you being in on it from the start. 
 Without that sense of reverberation or sensation, the brash colours and sharp slogans flail in ignominious and redundant isolation. 
 Exhibitionism ignored is a pitiful sight. 
 So why is pop impervious to these bright entryists, these studied simulators? 
 You'd have thought anybody with two brain cells to rub together and a spark of wit could find a way past Mike Read and Phil Collins. 
 There are several reasons: 
 1) 
 &bquo;Simulation pop&equo; is generally couched in brazen, nakedly aggressive terms, conceives of pop as openly cut-throat, ruthless, plastic, self-adoring, cynical (as Age of Chance put it, &bquo;Don't Get Mad, Get Even&equo;). 
 In fact this vision of pop is as fictional and irrelevant today as the indie notion of &bquo;perfect pop&equo; (an airy idyll of sixties' byrdsong), Today's pop is soulful, concerned with banishing inhuman traces, yearning for a lost passion and integrity. 
 Which is why a &bquo;real&equo; popster like Mark Knopfler would shake his head in genuine dismay at Jamie Reid's manifesto for Transvision Vamp, why your Climie Fishers make it and your Sputniks burn up in orbit. 
 2) 
 Pop as Pure Pleasure Product, pop as blipvert, does actually enjoy a routine, marginal existence &mdash; house, Hi-NRG, Stock Aiken Waterman &mdash; functioning  blankly, without recourse to discourse, with no need of a statement of intent, UNMEDIATED. 
 3) 
 Everything is sewn up. 
 The biz is no longer in the state of confusion of seven years ago, when Altered Images could giggle and tumble their way onto TOTP. 
 Today, the industry has no need to feed off the margins, needs no lessons from Sigue Sigue Sputnik about the Global Leisure Industry, movie tie-ins or the killings to be made in the future collusion of pop and advertising to create new needs. 
 With pie diagrams indicating that the major pop consumers are the staid, over-25s, the development in the ad industry of &bquo;psychogeographics&equo; (the science of using pop to home in on specific taste publics &mdash; i.e. Springsteen fans are likely to desire different products from Whitney Houston fans), and the construction of bands in the studio, pop has never required less urgently a rush of theory from the &bquo;left&equo;. 
 4 
 By exposing the workings of pop (the way myth is stagemanaged, the way glamour is constructed) the new pop entryists actually deny the listener the chance to lose themselves in the &bquo;commodity fetishism&equo; they purport to celebrate. 
 They force the listener to be aware it's not for real. 
 Their foregrounding of this unreality, their knowing winks, are actually an abstention from immersing themselves fully in the &bquo;pop process&equo; in all its madness, carnality and glamour. 
 A cowardly vacillation, this hesitation to commit themselves to being myth. 
 In fact, at this point it's worth taking a pitchfork to that grossly over-rated entity &mdash; CAMP. 
 It's a terrible mistake to believe that you can consciously create camp, at this late hour, Camp is an aesthetic of consumption, not production. 
 Camp is a response to pop performances that are artificial, ludicrously stylized (Liberace, Tom Jones, Shirley Bassey), but whose stars enter into it all with a seriousness, a passion that affects with its holy, innocent imbecility. 
 (Precisely the immersion-in-myth, the plunge, that our knowing pop double agents refuse to make.) 
 Camp is a schizoid pleasure; you're amused by the absurdity and touched by the sincerity, at the same time. 
 Manifest inauthenticity on the suffice, inner authenticity soul-deep. 
 All this means we can forget about The Communards' cover version of &bquo;Never Can Say Goodbye&equo;, and we can forget about the wretched Pet Shop Boys, the only successful contemporary pop ironists. 
 This group's only sin is their wry self-consciousness which falls smugly short of arrant narcissism; the fey, running commentary implicit in their song-titles (&bquo;Rent&equo;, &bquo;Shopping&equo;, &bquo;Suburbia&equo;, &bquo;Opportunities &lsqb;Let's Make Lots of Money&rsqb;&equo;) signifies detachment, and finally alienation From the allure, the lush materiality of pop. 
 This isn't even pop about pop, this is  fop about pop. 
 It shows that camp is a defensive attitude, a flight from real involvement. 
 Rather than simply consuming pop (which makes clever little references to its commodity status) we should look to music that consumes US. 
 That exceeds the commodity relation and its in-built alienation, and allows us to worship. 
 DEMYSTIFICATION 
 The &bquo;Simulation Pop&equo; of the Pet Shop Boys, Pop Tarts, et al, is the end product of a discourse of demystification that began with punk, its DIY ethos, its &bquo;anyone can do it&equo; clarion call. 
 The original notion was to demystify the means of production, in order to liberate creativity, marginal voices. 
 But the logic of punk's evangelistic drive to change things led to a attempt to take demystification to the people: the pop deconstruction of ABC (exposing pop's stage managing, as on the sleeve of The Lexicon of Love ) and Scritti Politti (affirming and unravelling, simultaneously, the lover's non-sensical discourse). 
 DMs original idea was that anyone could find something brilliant to create within the limits of their (in) competence. 
 But the false legacy of demystification is the belief that anyone can be pop stars &mdash; a flagrant falsehood! 
 Aided by cheap drum machines and synthesizers, these canny aspirants endeavour to construct a spectacular pop by distilling the pop essence from all past efflorescences, using the hindsight sophistication of the present day. 
 But all the ambition, striving, graft, pop-learning in the world can't earn you pop divinity. 
 Attitude is never going to count for as much as the Gift &mdash; the untranscribable charisma, the arbitrary aura, the unequally-bestowed vocal magic that no amount of homework or calculation can procure. 
 It makes sense that the ineffable languor of Prince is infinitely more fruitious than a thousand sinewy Age of Chance slogans. 
 Pop should be a scarce resource, rather than something &bquo;deserved&equo; (like free milk). 
 The pop entryists &mdash; whose creed is that anyone with attitude, a masterplan, a nice line in self-salesmanship, can break on through &mdash; disqualify themselves From becoming objects of worship. 
 Pop that unravels its own workings, undoes itself. 
 Pop, by definition, must mystify. 
 Marc Bolan, who knew about these things, said it best: &bquo;pop should be a spell.&equo; 
 Now of course it hasn't needed a lambast from the likes of us to prompt the breakdown of pop entry. 
 It has pretty much happened, we're chasing its last desperate apologists down a hole of their own making. 
 A chasm has undoubtedly developed, but the sporadic re-emergency of the blasted simulators &mdash; they keep  crawling up time and time again with bedraggled, sanguine hollers of intent - and the beady eyes cast by all manner of unlikely contenders on pop's centre stage (&bquo;We see no reason why this band shouldn't be huge&equo;) &mdash; suggests that our new proposition of an overground and underground sticks in the craw. 
 What it means for &bquo;us&equo; is not so much the resurrection of &bquo;anti-pop&equo;, but a culture of margins; a disdainful gaze upon the terrain we once occupied, a satellite relationship to a pop centre now barred to us. 
 It means UNKNOWINGNESS as opposed to IRONY &mdash; the afflicted voice (Pixies, Throwing Muses, et al), the white blindness of the new guitar air (Dinosaur Jr, Husker Du), or the unblinking fervour of The Young Gods. 
 The music of the ever-receding margins, the music over which we have a claim, should be not just anti-soul (against intimations of health, the centrality of the body, straighttalking, wholesomeness) but anti-irony (the raised eyebrow, the quotation marks). 
 Our music should be set in an outward discovery of difference and space. 
 Detachment, self-consciousness must be flooded out by the stream of consciousness &mdash; music caught in its own flux, a white water of dream language (REM, Muses). 
 To hell with the GOOD TALKERS, those pugnacious interviewees all set to give &bquo;sleepy&equo; pop the kick in the pants it deserves &mdash; pop beauty should be the subject of dumbfoundedness, the breakdown of schematics. 
 As for the New Boisterous, the cheery spree of custard colours and polemical beiges that are the persistently &bquo;new&equo; colourmotion, let's get it straight &mdash; the State of Pop is not Grey, but over-determined by a stifling, cloning rainbow  coalition of mediocrity. 
 RE-MYSTIFICATION 
 The return to rock means the supercession of demystification by re-mystification, giving people back their sense of worship, rather than forcibly opening their eyes to the nuts and bolts of how &bquo;myth&equo; is constructed. 
 Entryist pop implied the filling of every space, a tight, breathless glut of good ideas, an endless process of signification. 
 The return to rock means a re-awakening of dub, remoteness, loss of self in a recession of space, a search for unlit rather than overlit regions. 
 A.R. 
 Kane and Arthur Russell skid the peripheries, imply a distance from the centred subject of pop that is hauntingly suggested by their Plutonic, echoing surfaces of sounds. 
 Their beauty is arbitrary, beyond grasp, gazing and gazed upon. 
 MY LITTLE UNDERGROUND 
 New pop is extrovert, forever shaping up to splash down in supposedly &bquo;unstirred&equo; regions, forever dramatizing itself against a torpid and shockable  opposition &mdash; the grown-ups, straights, squares, &bquo;the dullards&equo;. 
 The return to rock represents an abstention or introversion, a retreat (the Jesus and Many Chain's &bquo;My Little Underground&equo;), a local culture rather than any doomed attempt at a global overhauling. 
 Rebellion has imploded; the enemy is the finger-wagging parent inside your head &mdash; your own inhibitions, regular thought patterns, inflexible mental grids and perceptual blinkers. 
 The rebirth of an underground implies induction, being drawn into shared exile, being both insider and outsider; rather than trying to break down the doors to edify the unconverted. 
 To &bquo;forget&equo; pop is to renege fundamentally upon the (over-determining) intentions of punk. 
 No more &bquo;resistance through rituals&equo; (revolt into style, sartorial bricolage that confounds expectations, all of which are read, interpreted, mediatized and accommodated in a trice, these days). 
 No more implanting the virus from within, no more attempting to gatecrash a terrain that no longer really belongs to us (whatever it may once have been, simple demographic change has turned pop into global light entertainment). 
 No more agoraphobia (mistrust of anything longer than the classic three minutes, the squitBrit aversion to the cumulus wail). 
 No more going public and imagining that by the gesture alone you'll be &bquo;improving&equo; matters. 
 With the music we like, it doesn't matter if it doesn't &bquo;breakthrough&equo;, if it doesn't &bquo;happen&equo; &mdash; because, by being created, it's happening. 
 It's there as a choice, a reproach, and its remoteness from the secular pop world is a sign of its success. 
 The further out, the more FAR OUT. 
 The return of rock means not so much a crashdown as a return towards rock, a departure from planet pop to a self-sufficiency that matches pop. 
 A parallel universe, mutually incompatible, like matter and anti-matter. 
 No more Tube , no more of your favourite bands on the telly, another dark age as regards the media. 
 No more breaking in but breaking away, leaving and letting loose into the impending night. 
 Goodbye, The Style Council. 
 Goodbye, bleached pop-funk. 
 Goodbye, the classic three-minute single. 
 Goodbye, Janice Long. 
 Goodbye &bquo;wanting in&equo; &mdash; hello THE WAY OUT. 
 Let the fatuous sun shine by itself and let's head for the moon. 
 Let's snuff out the shod people and welcome the long shadows. 
 (1987) 
 INTRODUCTION 
 This book is meant to be a layman's guide to the evolution of the smaller English house. 
 I have chosen as perfect an example as I could muster of each stage of that evolution, but it is inevitably a personal choice rather than a textbook one. 
 The smaller English house does not steer a straight and obvious course of architectural style, but veers off into strange and pleasurable directions like that of &bquo;Strawberry Hill&equo; Gothic or Victorian &bquo;Queen Anne&equo;. 
 The thread I have chosen to follow is that of houses I consider to be perfect period pieces or exceptional architectural masterpieces, and hence they are not always conventionally representative of their particular period. 
 I may also have dwelt too long on the years between 1690 and 1730, but this was simply because it seems to be most people's favourite period. 
 I asked innumerable friends and acquaintances which was their favourite house in England; almost invariably their choice was built between these dates. 
 Three different people chose Mothecombe in Devon (1710), not least for its idyllic situation. 
 This is not the book of a scholar, as you will soon realize, but that of a genuine enthusiast. 
 I derive untold pleasure from looking at buildings, but not just as objects which please the eye, nor just as works of art, as you would look at pictures in a gallery; I also like imagining who commissioned them, who built them, what sort of person first lingered on their balcony or opened their casement window. 
 This book is an effort to pass that pleasure on. 
 The size of house chosen is meant to kindle a perfectly plausible dream. 
 It should be possible to live in any one of them without staff, though some might need a large and willing family to maintain them. 
 Over the doorway of a fine Georgian house called Knockhill in Scotland, there is the following line carved in stone: &bquo;Too Small for Envy, for Contempt too Great&equo;. 
 This aptly describes the houses in this book, which were built on the whole by country gentry, tradesmen and clergymen, on a moderate scale, rather than by the aristocracy, who liked to flaunt their aesthetic views and show how cultivated they were on a much larger one. 
 Finding the perfect English house was easier said than done. 
 At the outset, my criterion was that each house should be unadulterated and purely of its time. 
 It was easy enough to find Victorian and Edwardian houses which had not been changed a jot, but with houses of earlier periods it became increasingly difficult. 
 Frequently a Georgian house which I had always seen from the road and considered to be all of one date, was revealed, when I came to knock on its door, to be purely a fa&ccedil;ade built on to a much earlier building. 
 Hence it is sometimes only the face in the photograph which represents the demonstrable and technical perfection, as at Netherhampton in Wiltshire, for instance. 
 But despite the varying dates behind Netherhampton's front, the latter still ranks as a &bquo;perfect&equo; house to me. 
 Early houses which remain completely  untouched are few and far between, but a general rule emerged during my research for the book: the less important the house and the more remote its situation, the more old-fashioned it remained, like Hareston in Devon, which had no fashion-conscious owners wanting to show-off their taste and wealth to passers-by. 
 Also, demotion from primary residence to tenanted farmhouse for a century or two, saved many a small grand house from a buffeting by the winds of changing style, as at Croan in Cornwall, Beckley in Oxfordshire or Mothecombe in Devon. 
 The pattern of change of many of the houses built before 1700, and the fluctuating fortunes of their owners provide a pretty good history lesson. 
 When Henry VIII severed his relationship with the Church of Rome, many of the Italian craftsmen who were in England went home or to Ireland. 
 Our classical development was hence later than in some other European countries. 
 Old land-owning families prospered and built under Queen Elizabeth I's reign, but many of them became badly unstuck during the Civil War. 
 Nearly every house in the book built before 1650 was owned by an active Cavalier, whose fortunes dwindled in consequence, and only one by a Roundhead, the builder of Lodge Park in Gloucestershire. 
 After Cromwell, new squires, successful tradesmen, farmers and impoverished Cavaliers who had made good marriages then began to build new houses. 
 If you look through a family history and hit upon an advantageous marriage, the chances are that you will find a new house or a completely restored one at around the same date. 
 The eighteenth century was a fairly settled time for the small English house, and saw the birth of the professional architect and the introduction of pattern books. 
 The early 1800s produced a wealth of eccentric houses and cottages orn&eacute;es  by the seaside, built by the frustrated rich who were unable to go abroad during the Napoleonic Wars. 
 By the time of the Industrial Revolution, the look of England was in the hands of the speculative builders and the architects. 
 The new rich who were building new houses were only too happy to have their aesthetic decisions made for them by the &bquo;professionals&equo;. 
 Man's basic need has not changed over the five centuries that this book covers. 
 Apart from the obvious business of living, a house is, as Reginald Turnor describes in The Smaller English House , &bquo;a place in which a man can think his thoughts and please his vision&equo;. 
 Every man I have written about in this book, when he had made or married his fortune, built a new house or radically re-modelled an old one in the fashion of the moment. 
 These men were pioneers of new architecture. 
 Since the Second World War, however, nearly every rich man, on making his fortune, has bought an old house and refurbished it in its period style. 
 Why?  
 page 8 blank 
 TUDOR TO EARLY RENAISSANCE 
 Some houses of this time still have a fortified and military feeling, but most are Gothic in spirit. 
 They were built from the materials closest to hand and so have an utterly distinct regional character. 
 These materials, like wood or stone or brick, also determined the architectural style. 
 During Elizabeth I's prosperous reign, houses and brick kilns doubled in number, fashions travelled and, despite the anti-papist atmosphere, classical decoration from Italy and elsewhere began to creep into the English house, first on porches, then over windows, until by the end of the Jacobean era, the slow transition of the English house from Gothic to classical had begun.  
 1350 and 1500 HARESTON FARM Brixton DEVONSHIRE 
 THE Most forgotten manor farm in England, untouched for three or four hundred years, sits safely impossible to find down miles of private sunken lanes which in the spring brim with campion, bluebells, early purple orchids, primroses, violets, speedwell and stichwort. 
 Wooded hills rise behind this, the quintessence of an ancient English manor house. 
 It has rubble-stone walls and its steeply pitched roofs make the granite-capped chimneys seem all the higher. 
 The projecting porch with its embattled parapet is rendered with local marl and is a late sixteenth-century addition. 
 The house has evolved in a haphazard manner around a simple &bquo;hall&equo; type dwelling of the early Tudor period. 
 Outbuildings, including a fourteenth-century chapel, now a garden shed, appear to huddle round the medieval manor as though for warmth, giving the whole an informal and completely unselfconscious appearance. 
 The name &bquo;Hareston&equo; may derive from the great granite boulder, now hidden by brambles in a field near the house. 
 These stones were called &bquo;hoar&equo; stones and were frequently used to mark parish boundaries. 
 Hareston is still on the extreme edge of the parish of Brixton. 
 It is recorded in the Domesday Book as a manor, and belonged to one Fratmund until 1064. 
 It then passed to Robert of Mortain, followed by Reginald de Valletort and Edric. 
 In the thirteenth century Walter de Colaford, alias Hugh de Hareston, owned it in conjunction with Ralph de Lyneham. 
 Peter Silverlock, whose father had been a Member of Parliament, acquired it in 1367. 
 (One member of the Silverlock family married Matilda de Langford, whose first husband had been William de Mohun &mdash; see page 28.) 
 Hareston then passed through the female line for three generations to Alice de Hareston, who married John Wood. 
 The Wood family lived here for three hundred years until the death of the last male heir in 1743. 
 Soon afterwards there was a disastrous fire during the harvest season, and much of the south wing was destroyed and never rebuilt. 
 Hitherto the house had enclosed a three-sided courtyard. 
 The Hareston estate was still retained by a Miss Audrian Wood who married a Mr Winter. 
 They called themselves the Wood-Winters. 
 Then, three generations later, the Winter-Woods. 
 In 1824 they removed to a more commodious place at Lower Hareston and let Hareston Manor to a succession of tenant farmers. 
 It was in 1863, when a Mr and Mrs Parsons lived here with their nine children, ranging in age from one to nineteen years, that a terrible thing happened. 
 Within a period of six weeks all nine children died from either cholera or diptheria contracted from contaminated water from the well in the house. 
 Neither Mr nor Mrs Parsons was affected. 
 prompted by a local superstition that sheep's breath would discourage further contamination, Mr Parsons drove a flock of sheep into the house, where the animals were allowed to roam the ground floor rooms for several days.  
 pages 11 and 12: photographs 
 circa 1470 PATTENDEN MANOR Goudhurst KENT 
 PATTENDEN MANOR, which stands beside a tributary of the River Teise, was built by the rich yeoman farming family of Pattyndenne and later reputedly became the trysting place for Catherine Howard (Henry VIII's fifth wife) and her cousin and lover Thomas Culpepper. 
 The Culpeppers owned the vast and neighbouring estate of Bedgebury and are likely to have bought Pattenden to extend their property. 
 During Catherine's brief marriage to Henry, Culpepper and another former lover, Richard Dereham, were arrested and tortured into admitting having lain with Catherine before she wed the King. 
 Dereham had in fact considered that he and Catherine were engaged to be married, and this, if revealed at the time, would have invalidated the royal marriage. 
 It was concealed, with disastrous results, for Culpepper and Dereham were executed on 1 December 1540. 
 The house is built on the site of a Saxon prison, which was still used in the twelfth century to incarcerate cattle rustlers. 
 The Pattyndennes were of the newly emerging class of yeomanry, who with the gradual acquisition of land in the fertile valleys of the Weald were one step ahead of the rest of agricultural England during the mid-fifteenth century. 
 The &bquo;Wonderful Weald&equo; of Kent and Sussex is a bed of clay, which determines the character of what lies on top. 
 Oak trees thrive in this soil, and Pattenden Manor, the archetypal Wealden house of south-east England, was the architectural result. 
 It displays a method of building which was so logical and so satisfactory that it was used from the end of the fourteenth century until well into the eighteenth. 
 The basic Wealden house structure is rectangular and joins together the central hall, which is open through its two storeys, and the cross wings, whose upper floors are &bquo;jettied&equo; (meaning that they oversail the floor below). 
 Pattenden is an especially fine example of this Kentish style because its upper floors are jettied at the back as well, a rare refinement. 
 There was usually a passage which went from one wing to the other and crossed the open hall at first floor level. 
 In many cases the roofs were thatched, but are now mostly tiled. 
 The whole effect is distinctive and familiar. 
 There are thousands of Wealden houses which survive, though few as early as Pattenden. 
 They tend to be out on their own, away from towns or villages, for they were built to stand in the midst of their acres.  
 circa 1535 THE MANOR HOUSE Sandford Orcas DORSET 
 IT FEELS almost like Somerset here, where the fields and hills are small, and this intimate and beautiful valley enfolds one of the best manors in the West Country. 
 The village, where three streams rise, is of honey-coloured hamstone and thatch, and the church of St Nicholas with its fifteenth-century tower nestles beside the manor gatehouse, to form a perfect grouping. 
 This is England at its most picturesque, at its most idyllically pastoral. 
 One of the chief glories of this house is that it has been little altered since it was built around the middle of the sixteenth century. 
 A feeling of peace and calm pervades the place, and the silence in and around the house somehow seems more complete than if one was standing, say, in the middle of an open field. 
 Although the building is of more or less one period, it is still nonetheless a higgledy-piggledy place to find one's way about in, as though the builders had not planned it as a whole but acted on whims and perhaps the need to accommodate an expanding family. 
 There is a narrow entrance passage leading into a hall, which has a carved wooden screen and chimney-piece and is lit by mullioned bay windows facing east and south, with heraldic designs on painted glass in the upper lights. 
 A newel staircase leads up from either end. 
 The south stair winds past the old buttery to the first floor, where levels change in and out of the - bedrooms and chambers. 
 A step up here, a step down there until perhaps you reach the door of the room from which, although it is locked and empty, you can hear shuffling footsteps. 
 Edward Knoyle inherited the manor in 1533, and probably set about building this mullioned and gabled beauty about ten years later around a humble medieval hall. 
 (Nobody knows the exact date, which is probably just as well: to categorize a house like this can take away some of its romance.) 
 There are stone monkeys on the gable tops of the east fa&ccedil;ade which faces gentle lawns, clipped yews and sloping pasture. 
 At the left end is the two-storeyed, canted bay of the hall. 
 The Knoyle family were Roman Catholic, and strong supporters of first the Cavalier and then the Jacobite causes. 
 Over the two hundred years that they owned the house their fortunes dwindled until the house was sold to the Hutchings family in 1736. 
 They let it to tenant farmers until the 1870s, when the Hubert Hutchings returned. 
 The consequence of the Knoyles' poverty and the Hutchings' absenteeism over the previous two centuries was that the Manor House had a miraculous escape from Georgian owners wanting to keep up with the times. 
 It remains in the Medlycott family, relations of the Hutchings.  
 page 15 and 16: photographs 
 1540 BECKLEY PARK Beckley OXFORDSHIRE 
 ONE SUMMER in 1920, while staying with the Morells at Garsington, the late Percy  Feilding  went for a drive around Oxfordshire, and miles up a cart track, purely by chance, he found Beckley. 
 Once you have seen Beckley you are captivated. 
 It is a magic place and always has been. 
 Percy  Feilding  fell for it hook, line and sinker and ended by buying this, the most perfect small Tudor house in Oxfordshire. 
 Beckley stands like a beautiful beached ship on the ancient fen of Otmoor. 
 It was built by Lord Williams of Thame in 1540 as a hunting lodge beside the once busy Roman road from Dorchester to Bicester. 
 In the ninth century King Alfred had built a castle here surrounded by three rectangular moats, from which to guard the road. 
 After the Norman Conquest Beckley was acquired by a big Oxfordshire land-owner called Robert d'Oilly, and then, in 1227, Richard, Earl of Cornwall built a hunting lodge within the outer moat, which lies unexcavated in the garden. 
 Thus the place was already steeped in history when Lord Williams decided to build his modest but very modern hunting lodge, between the inner and middle moat. 
 It was built in the beautiful plum-coloured brick he had used at his main residence of Rycote. 
 Owing to the narrow slope of the site, the house is only one room thick, as compact as can be. 
 Lord Williams was up to the minute in his domestic arrangements. 
 The main rooms are unusually high and light and the sanitary arrangements are most elaborate, with three lavatory flues. 
 Under the three perfect gables are three towers, one containing the stairs which Amanda  Feilding , who grew up here, describes as &bquo;pivoting around a central column, all of oak. 
 Though it is the only staircase in the house, so hard is the wood that 450 years of treading have worn no hollows in the steps&hellip; 
 I remember the fear of going up the spiral stairs to bed, the tapestry billowing along the passage with some hidden killer, creaking of wood. 
 As a teenager I moved out of the nursery into the attic. 
 A long dark room, it has a turret growing out of it with a view of untold magic, looking over the yew garden and the rose garden, on to Otmoor.&equo; 
 Within the moats Amanda  Feilding's  grandfather, Percy, grew, and her father, Basil  Feilding , shaped, one of the best topiary gardens in England, which somehow completes Beckley as a perfect work of art. 
 &bquo;I had always thought that its grip on me was purely personal,&equo; wrote Amanda, &bquo; &mdash; I loved it simply because it was my home &mdash; but then I found that it caught other people in its web too.&equo;  
 1570 TRERICE Newquay CORNWALL 
 THE ARUNDELLS of Cornwall must have been a very sophisticated family, for it is peculiar to find such a fancy fa&ccedil;ade of this date in such a distant corner of the land. 
 Sir John Arundell, who built it, inherited a fortune from his father, also Sir John, who had lived during five reigns and served under four monarchs. 
 He was a favourite with Henry VIII and his Esquire of the Body. 
 By Edward VI he was made &bquo;Vice Admiral of the King's ships in the West Seas&equo;, and his remains lie in the nearby church of Stratton, where a brass plate depicts the knight, his wife and their twelve children. 
 His son, Sir John the builder, married his neighbour the heiress Katherine Coswarth, whose land marched with that of Trerice. 
 He had four daughters with her, one of whom, Juliana, married Richard Carew of Antony, author of the Survey of Cornwall  (1602). 
 He painted this picture of his father-in-law: &bquo;Over his kindred he held a wary and chary care, which bountifully was expressed when occasion so required, reputing himself not only principal of the family but a general father to them all&hellip; as for frank, well ordered and continual hospitality he outwent all show of competence; spare but discreet of speech: better conceiving than delivering; equally stout and kind, not upon lightness of humour, but upon soundness of judgement: inclined to commiseration, ready to relieve.&equo; 
 His house faces east, crowned by extravagantly scrolly gables with carved mask corbels at their bases. 
 It is built of Pentewan stone, a type of Cornish Elvan, the name given to the local quartz-porphyry. 
 Pentewan was quarried on the cliff top near Mevagissey and is harder to cut than granite, it does not have that same sparkly effect caused by the mica flakes. 
 The bay to the left of the projecting porch contains the full length mullioned and transomed hall window, which is thirty-six feet high and twenty-four feet wide, with twenty-four lights. 
 There are 576 panes of glass in this one window, much of it original! 
 Inside, the room is richly decorated with a fine scrolled plaster overmantel, dated 1572, and a little musicians' gallery which looks down into the hall through a row of arches set high up in the cornice. 
 Like most true Cornishmen, the Arundells were staunchly Royalist during the troubles, and the sixth Sir John was killed at Plymouth while charging at the head of his troop in 1643. 
 (Everyone in Cornwall who supported King Charles planted a Scots pine outside his house as a sign of welcoming like-minded passers-by who might be in need of protection. 
 Many are still growing today.) 
 In the eighteenth century the Wentworths of Hembury in Dorset inherited Trerice, and it was let to tenants. 
 It subsequently passed, in 1802, through fairly obscure cousinly connections to Sir Thomas Dyke-Acland, a phenomenally rich gentleman who owned tracts of Devon and Somerset and built the model village of Selworthy. 
 In 1943 Sir Richard Acland gave Trerice, and his two other estates of Holnicote and Killerton, to the National Trust.  
 page 19: photograph 
 circa 1582 WOOD DALLING HALL Saxthorpe NORFOLK 
 AT THE first bend in the narrow lane from Guestwick to Corpusty there are the vestiges of an old carriageway turning off into a field in a south-westerly direction. 
 Twenty years ago I walked along it, half hoping to find a lost domain, and when I had crossed the small brick bridge over a stream I suddenly saw Wood Dalling Hall sailing like some proud ship above hawthorn hedges and ancient meadows, as beautiful and as Norfolk as could be. 
 When I got closer I found it to be empty and forgotten; cattle grazed up to its outer walls, its projecting porch was thick with ivy, its gardens with nettles. 
 Wood Dalling Hall epitomises the perfect Elizabethan manor house. 
 It is built in a style which England had made her own. 
 Although those terrifying Latin countries were building in a classical style by then, England preferred her own flights of fancy. 
 The Hall is of rose-red brick built in English bond, it boasts a host of gables on every fa&ccedil;ade, some straight, some crow-stepped, and some topped by pinnacles. 
 The mullioned and transomed windows are large and light, but its fine, tall, clustered chimneys are its crowning glory. 
 This gentle stretch of Norfolk is Bulwer country. 
 The church, a mile to the east of the Hall, contains myriad ancient brasses and memorials to the Bulwer family, from Matilda Bulwer in 1463 to Elizabeth in 1742. 
 It was Richard Bulwer who built the present Wood Dalling Hall in 1582, at about the same time as his neighbour Henry Dynne was building the much larger Heydon Hall. 
 They bear a strong resemblance. 
 Wood Dalling remained the home of the Bulwer family until 1780, when William Wiggett Bulwer married the rather pasty-faced Mary Earle, heiress to Heydon Hall. 
 They chose to live in the grander of the two houses, and Wood Dalling was demoted to a farmhouse and remained thus until comparatively recently. 
 This is how it has retained its gloriously untouched state both outside and in. 
 &bquo;There are five attic bedrooms,&equo; reads an accounts book of 1890, &bquo;a box room, four principal bedrooms and dressing room. 
 A nursery approached by separate staircase, and a groom's room over the wash house. 
 Downstairs there is a panelled hall and fine oak stair, dining and drawing rooms, study, store room and large kitchen.&equo; 
 Over the last few years the house has changed hands many times. 
 Someone tried to make a golf course in the water meadows; another tried to run it as a pub, and put close-fitting carpets over the flags. 
 It is sadder now than it ever was, and the magic has gone.  
 page 21 and 22: photographs 
 1586 WILDERTHORPE MANOR Runhbury SHROPSHIRE 
 THE MANY-GABLED limestone manor stands tucked into an open fold between Wenlock Edge and Aymestry in the remote and unspoiled Shropshire valley of Hope Dale. 
 It was built by Francis Smallman, whose initials and those of his wife Ellen appear all over the plasterwork ceilings. 
 He came from an ancient Corvedale family, branches of which were in the forefront of Shropshire life during the seventeenth century &mdash; Francis's nephew was a Member for Wenlock in Charles I's parliament. 
 The Smallmans lived at Wilderhope until 1742. 
 The house, set on a south-east facing slope, was probably built by the local mason who also built the nearby Shipton Hall, for they have exactly the same broad gables and the same asymmetrical front. 
 Inside there is the most beautiful and elaborate plasterwork ceiling in the parlour, where huge intersecting stars contain smaller designs. 
 It was executed by a travelling craftsman whose stock pattern can be recognized at other local houses. 
 There are shields in several places bearing the motto &bquo;Droi Deu est mal meu&equo;, roughly translated from the Old French as &bquo;Lawful right is ill moved&equo;. 
 This was certainly the case when some of Cromwell's troops, returning from the Battle of Worcester, called in at Wilderhope because they knew that Thomas Smallman, a major in the Royalist army, would still be away. 
 They carried away what they could on their horses in the form of silver and pewter. 
 When the Major returned and discovered what they had done, he galloped off and, knowing the country, was able to overtake the thieves on the road to Ludlow, where he killed most of them and retrieved his property. 
 Later on during the Civil War the Major was carrying dispatches from Bridgnorth to Shrewsbury when he was captured by Cromwell's troops. 
 They took him back to his own house and shut him upstairs while they sat below and deliberated what to do with him. 
 He managed to escape (probably through the garderobe flue which is accessible on the attic and first floors), and rode off. 
 The soldiers heard the clattering hooves and sped after him. 
 They caught up with him a mile or so away at the Plough Inn. 
 In order to escape, the Major turned off the road and kicked his horse on over Wenlock Edge. 
 A crab-apple tree broke his fall, and he was able to hang on to it, but his horse fell below and was killed. 
 He eventually escaped and delivered the dispatches to Shrewsbury. 
 To this day the spot is known as &bquo;The Major's Leap&equo;.  
 1589 THE LEY Weobly HEREFORDSHIRE 
 HEREFORDSHIRE is little spoiled. 
 Its hedged fields are sprinkled with oak trees, and apple orchards and half-timbered houses abound. 
 Weobly, lying among gentle hills, its church spire visible from miles away, boasts more and finer black and white medieval houses than anywhere in the county. 
 Three-quarters of a mile south of the church, down a bumpy farm track which was once a well used road, is the greatest beauty of all, a silvery oak-timbered house called The Ley. 
 Since 1589, this house has hardly changed at all. 
 It is built on the &bquo;H&equo; plan with the cross wings at the east and west ends of this north-facing front. 
 Its box frame construction is a method still used in house building today. 
 There is a moulded beam between the two main storeys and extremely pretty carved barge boards on all its seven gables. 
 Above the front door there are two carved panels showing the date and impaled shield of The Ley's builder, James Brydges. 
 The Brydges family had owned the property since 1428, when their ancestor Symon de Brugge bought it from the two daughters and co-heiresses of Richard de Ley. 
 During the sixteenth century the Brydges bought up the neighbouring estate belonging to the Garways (now called Garnstone), and at the height of their affluence James Brydges married Jane Blount and built The Ley exactly as you see it today. 
 James and Joan had three sons, one of whom became a major in Charles II's army and drowned in the river at Pershore. 
 Thomas, his elder brother, was fined as a recusant in 1646, and little by little the Brydges' fortune dwindled. 
 In 1707 the last heir died. 
 A letter from Charles Carne dated 27 February 1707 to his sister who had married &bquo;William of the Ley&equo; reads, &bquo;My poor sister, the last Brydges of the Ley is  ded .&equo; 
 The Ley eventually reverted to the Garnstone estate and has long been a farmhouse, which it remains to this day.  
 pages 25 and 26: photographs 
 circa 1570 RESTROP MANOR Purton WILTSHIRE 
 IF THE Ley is the quintessence of Herefordshire Elizabethan, then Restrop is the quintessence of north Wiltshire Elizabethan. 
 It is built of glowing limestone, known as Coral Rag, a stone made of the fossilized remains of coral and other shells. 
 Restrop was built at the very height of the great Elizabethan age, when the craft of building began to turn into an art. 
 It was no longer necessary, when building a moderate sized house, to be completely practical and simply to provide shelter &mdash; people had more money and thus concentrated more on pleasing their eye. 
 Restrop is of as perfect and pure a style as Elizabethan houses of this size ever reached. 
 It is built on the shape of the letter &bquo;E&equo;, not necessarily as a compliment to Queen Elizabeth but for the satisfactory symmetry it afforded to the most important east-facing front which the world and his wife could view as they passed by. 
 It was built around 1590 for a younger son of the Earl of Shaftesbury, whose family had owned the manor of Restrop for three hundred years, The coat of arms of the Ashley-Coopers (the Shaftesbury family name) is over the door, and it is very unlikely that such a very fine house, with its particularly beautiful roofs over the projecting bays, would have been built for a tenant farmer. 
 There is a local story that Queen Elizabeth spent a night here; what is certain is that she passed on this road on her way from Burderop to Cirencester. 
 No records remain as to who lived here through the seventeenth century, when during the Civil War a bloody battle took place on the Manor's doorstep. 
 Human skeletons and a cannon-ball weighing twelve pounds have been unearthed in the garden, and the names &bquo;Battle Well&equo; and &bquo;Battle Cottages&equo;, both found close by, are unlikely to have been called this without good reason. 
 Perhaps Lord Ashley-Cooper was so horrified that he moved to another property, for there is evidence that the Manor reverted to being a tenanted farmhouse and remained thus until it was sold by the Shaftesburys in 1912 to Colonel Canning. 
 The latter set about restoring its decrepit but largely unaltered state, uncovering the great stone fireplace in the hall. 
 He commanded a batallion in Gallipoli during the famous evacuation of the Arabian desert, and was awarded the CMG. 
 Restrop has since changed hands. 
 The Manor was an important landmark during the annual and ancient custom called the &bquo;perambulation of Purton&equo;, during Rogation Tide in May, when a large procession, headed by the clergyman, would beat the bounds over a period of two days. 
 This was a way of defining the parish boundary, and every half mile or so gospels would be read and a cross erected. 
 Trees like Greenhill Oak and Charnham Oak became landmarks, as did the triangle of grass in front of the Manor.  
 circa 1600 MANOR FARM HAMMOON Sturminster Newton DORSET 
 LOST AMONG apple orchards and water meadows beside the River Stour not far from Shaftesbury lies the well settled hamlet of Hammoon. 
 As you turn the corner towards the church of St Mary, which was enthusiastically restored in the picturesque style during the nineteenth century, you are bowled over by the beauty of this grandest of farms. 
 Peaceful, mellow and noble, in the shade of a great sycamore, it is the sort of house that feels as though it has been there from time immemorial. 
 Once, in a former guise, it was the manor of William de Moion, a mighty man of mettle. 
 &bquo;He came to England with the conqueror,&equo; says Hutchins in his History of Dorset , &bquo;with a retinue of forty seven knights of note. 
 For this great service he obtained eleven manors in this county; also the castle of Dunster in Somerset, and fifty-five other manors&equo;. 
 Thus the name Hammoon derives from &bquo;ham&equo;, or dwelling place, of the Moion family (subsequently Mohun and eventually Moon. 
 There are still Moons in Dorset). 
 Out of his manors, William chose to reside at Hammoon, and his descendants certainly lived here until the seventeenth century. 
 Romance and mystery were added to the place when Meade Falkner wrote Moonfleet , the classic children's adventure story which was loosely based on this family and hamlet, though set nearer to the sea. 
 The house is built on an &bquo;L&equo; shape, and though it evolved gradually over the fifteenth, sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, the whole gives a uniquely harmonious appearance, which must stem from the use all those years ago of essentially local materials which cannot but blend. 
 The bulk of the building is in Marnhull stone, quarried locally and much used in local villages such as Buckthorn Weston, Todber and West Orchard. 
 However, it was obviously not deemed grand enough by the Moon of the manor at the beginning of the seventeenth century who built on the exquisite Renaissance porch in Purbeck limestone. 
 It is rare for a house of this size and date to remain thatched, for so often the roof pitch would be changed to accommodate the more convenient slates or tiles. 
 A house of this size could take two men six months to thatch, and it might - need to be re-ridged every five years or so and re-thatched every twenty to thirty years.  
 page 29: photograph 
 circa 1600 WATERSTON MANOR Charminster DORSET 
 &bquo;BY DAYLIGHT, the bower of Oak's newfound mistress Bathsheba Everdene presented itself as a hoary building of the Jacobean stage of Classical Renaissance as regards its architecture, and of a proportion which tells at a glance that, as is frequently the case, it has once been the manorial hall on a small estate&hellip; 
 &equo; So wrote Thomas Hardy about Waterston, the model for Bathsheba's house in his famous novel Far from the Madding Crowd . 
 He describes its every blind arched chimney and fluted pilaster. 
 There is much argument over the exact dates of Waterston. 
 I can't see that it matters, for the fact remains that it exemplifies the very finest and most elegant architecture which displays the first burgeoning of the English Renaissance. 
 This was the time when the old style of gabled manor was feeling the first breath of classical ideas. 
 The mixture of the two styles is magically uncontrived at Waterston, set now in its cosy Edwardian garden laid out with great vision by Morley Horder, the architect who was helping to remodel the interior in 1911. 
 Waterston's history is perhaps more chequered than that of the average English manor house. 
 It was kicked around like a football from family to family, none of whom seemed to have loved it or to have been able to hold on to it for long. 
 In 1863 it was all but gutted by a disastrous fire, but mercifully the ashlar-faced east fa&ccedil;ade remained entirely intact with its projected balustraded bay, its shell-headed niches, its eccentric demonstration of Doric, Ionic and Corinthian columns in three tiers &mdash; all in Purbeck stone. 
 In ancient times the manor had belonged to the Martyns before they left for Athelhampton. 
 From 1377, through various marriages and generations, Waterston passed from the Newburghs to the Marneys to Lord Howard of Bindon, who married the East Lulworth heiress. 
 It was the Howards who were responsible for the daring architectural refinements of the late sixteenth and very early seventeenth century. 
 Elizabethan builders were learning new things from the Netherlands, and Thomas Howard was eager to display his knowledge of architectural fashion. 
 In 1605 Waterston passed to Thomas's kinsman the Earl of Suffolk, who never lived there. 
 He sold it to Sir John Strangways, a member of the Illchester family, in 1641; four years later, however, the manor passed on yet again to another Illchester in part payment for fines imposed on poor Strangways for malignancy, a crime for which he was put in the Tower. 
 From then onwards Waterston stayed in Illchester ownership for two and a half centuries but, since they preferred the grandeur of Melbury, it soon degenerated into the farm that it was in Bathsheba Everdene's time. 
 It was Captain Carter who bought the house at the beginning of this century, and lovingly restored whit is here today.  
 pages 31 and 32: photographs 
 1608 ALLERTHORPE HALL Gatenby YORKSHIRE 
 ALLERTHORPE HALL has always stood apart and important on the flat plain beside the Roman road that runs straight as a die from Borough Bridge to Catterick, and on the bendiest of bends in the River Swale. 
 There is no village now, but for a thousand years there has been a manor. 
 Before the Norman conquest Allerthorpe (which once was Erlevestrop or Herlevestorp, then Arlathorp) was owned by Count Alan, and his tenant was called Ribald. 
 The place then passed to the Middlehams, and in 1270 was left by Ranulf Middleham to his daughter Joan, through whom it came to the Nevills of neighbouring Swainby. 
 During all this time the Lascelles family, beginning with William, were the tenants. 
 They stayed at Allerthorpe for three hundred years, after which, in 1590, Sir Thomas Lascelles conveyed the manor to William Robinson. 
 It was Robinson, an alderman of the city of York, who built the present Hall, as a home and, more importantly, as a place to entertain his fellow aldermen in style. 
 The Mayors of York would often stay and hunt here, but the glory was short-lived, for William died eight years after he had built the house. 
 Robinson's rusticated gate piers are as grand as anything in York, from where he obviously employed his stonemason. 
 The house is also exceptional. 
 It is built of the typical pale Yorkshire brick with local stone dressings. 
 The two circular towers still have the original casement windows with leaded panes. 
 There is also one of the original mullioned windows in the main block of the house, but the others were converted into sash windows in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. 
 Inside, two of the main rooms contain the original panelling, and above one of the fireplaces there is a fine overmantel with Ionic pilasters flanking carved arches and supporting a frieze with anthemion and acanthus patterns. 
 The ten diagonal chimneys rising from the steep pantiled roof are the finishing touch, making Allerthorpe as grand a farmhouse as you could find in all Yorkshire.  
 1630 HAGGE FARM Nether Handley, Staveley DERBYSHIRE 
 MORE THAN any other county, Derbyshire seems to have the sharpest contrasts between urban and rural surroundings. 
 Within seconds black streets give way to walled farmland. 
 Heading north from Chesterfield on the road to Dronfield, with urban sprawl spreading its way along the valley of the River Drone, you would hardly guess that high on Barrow Hill a mile away stands Hagge Farm, as lost and as completely rural as anything in the country. 
 It looks down imperiously towards Staveley, where the vast ironworks used to employ upwards of four thousand men. 
 Hagge Hall, as it was called, was built as a dower house and shooting box for Sir Peter Freschville, whose main residence at Staveley Hall did not afford such huge views. 
 The ladies would stand on the leaded roof of the projecting porch and watch the hunt run from Nether Handley to Apperknowle, or from Butchersick Farm to Moortop Farm. 
 The house is North Country Jacobean, as solid and safe as could be. 
 The windows of early houses get smaller as you travel north and the weather gets colder. 
 Here they are half-way to becoming like the tiny windows of farms in Cumberland where fierce winds blow. 
 &bquo;The Hagge&equo;, as it is referred to locally, is built of Millstone Grit, so called because being hard and tough it was used to crush the corn in Pennine village mills. 
 Its common name is Darley Dale sandstone, of which there were over a dozen local quarries, some of Roman origin. 
 Alec Clifton-Taylor describes this stone as being &bquo;absolutely dependable&equo;, which is how I would also describe &bquo;The Hagge&equo;. 
 Inside, the forty-two solid oak steps which lead to the top of the house are all original, as is much of the panelling. 
 The ghost of Hagge Hall is a typical &bquo;white lady haunting&equo;. 
 Her spectre is reputed to be that of Frances Culpepper, daughter of Lord John Freschville. 
 She has been seen several times over the years. 
 On one occasion an Irish visitor asked a late tenant, Mr Crawshaw, if the lady in white who had passed him on the stairs would be coming down to breakfast soon. 
 Mr Crawshaw replied that there was no lady staying in the house. 
 The estate was sold a long time ago to the Dukes of Devonshire and was tenanted at one time by the Reverend Thomas Fosbroke, the celebrated antiquary.  
 pages 35 and 36: photographs 
 circa 1640 PARHAM OLD HALL Parham SUFFOLK 
 &bquo;I HAVE received vague but disquieting information about the inaccessibility of the Willoughbys&equo; old home,&equo; wrote William Dutt in 1914, who was keen to see Parham Old Hall (or the Moat Hall as it is sometimes called), before nightfall. 
 &bquo;It has been described to me as an isolated house in the midst of fields, through which are only rough and rutty waggon tracks, and I have been told too, that it is hidden from passers along the road by a dark grove of trees. 
 &hellip; Crossing a wooden foot bridge to the right of the village street, passing the village church and climbing a rather steep hill, on the crest of which the road curves to the right, I soon see the cart-track which leads to the hall. 
 I have heard that the house is inhabited, and that it is now a farmhouse; but not a human being in sight anywhere near it; the ploughmen have left the fields, the farm buildings are deserted. 
 Although the trees are still leafless, I do not get a glimpse of the hall until it is within a stone's throw, so hidden is it by a dense screen of boughs and underwood; but I know it is near at hand, for an ancient archway spans the path leading to the farmyard, and just beyond the Tudor gateway bearing several clear-cut coats of arms. 
 Through the arch too, I see the dark water of a deep wide moat; so dark, indeed, is the water that it might well have remained unstirred since the days of the &bquo;brave Lord Willoughby'&equo;.' 
 Little has changed. 
 There is still an air of past glory, of semi-decay. 
 The Tudor chimney-stacks and beautiful brickwork are the vestiges of a much larger house &mdash; the ancient seat of the Willoughbys. 
 This remaining wing was built in about 1640, a time when local builders were more than ever turning their craft into a conscious art. 
 A hundred years before, Katharine, whose father was lord of Parham, married first the Earl of Suffolk, who died, and then Richard Bertie, who was a victim of Queen Mary's persecution of the protestants. 
 They fled to the low countries, fell among thieves, and Katharine was reduced to giving birth to her son on the steps of a church at Wesel, even the sexton refusing to give them shelter. 
 On the accession of Queen Elizabeth they returned to England and lived happily ever after. 
 Their son Peregrine became a popular hero owing to his skill and courage as general of the English forces campaigning in the United Provinces. 
 The fifteenth day of July 
 With glistening spear and shield, 
 A famous fight in Flanders 
 Was foughten on the field: 
 The most courageous officers 
 Were English captains three: 
 But the bravest man in battle 
 Was brave Lord Willoughby. 
 page 38: blank 
 RENAISSANCE TO BAROQUE 
 Although remote rural areas remained unaffected, by the middle of the seventeenth century the rebirth of classicism had begun to transform the face of England. 
 Inigo Jones had started to build the Queen's house, Greenwich, in 1616, and Sir Christopher Wren was building the Sheldonian, Oxford, in 1664. 
 Court architects set the fashion, and what used to be an essentially English style took on a strong foreign influence. 
 Sir John Summerson, the architectural historian, said that Gothic architects were masons who thought in terms of their materials and construction, whereas Renaissance architects were sketchers who thought in terms of paper and ink. 
 Once the transition had occurred, some builders expanded on the square and rectangular theme and added wild, exuberant and curvaceous forms &mdash; this is sometimes called Baroque.  
 circa 1640 BARNHAM HALL Chichester SUSSEX 
 BARNHAM HALL was built at one of the most confusing periods of domestic architecture in England. 
 In the first half of the seventeenth century the traditional Elizabethan style carried on, unabashed by fashion; then again there was the purely classical Queen's House at Greenwich, built by Inigo Jones, as radically different to the former as chalk is to cheese. 
 Then, somewhere in between, there was this strange Flemish style, which Kew Palace exemplifies, and to which Barnham Hall must be closely related. 
 Some people call it the &bquo;Artisan Mannerism&equo; style. 
 It was the eastern side of England which was most strongly affected, particularly East Anglia where many manors display crow stepped gables. 
 Barnham was built at the height of the period's fairly short ascendancy, when these swooping gables were laid on top of the English traditional style, bringing a strong flavour of Amsterdam to the village. 
 The Hall stands serene and proud with its pale red brick beside the bronze-coloured Pulborough stone of the church of St Mary. 
 It is set apart a little from Barnham Junction, where the trains for Bognor Regis leave the main line and around which has grown an early suburbia on the flat lands near the sea. 
 There was probably a nunnery here originally, and certainly a manor since the 1300s, for there are the remains of a fish-pond in the garden. 
 Over the centuries Barnham has belonged to the families of St John, Poynings, Fitzwilliam, Howard, Morley and Acland. 
 Then the Shelleys of Michelgrove, rich yeoman farmers, arrived and built this stylish house in the early 1640s. 
 The most amazing thing about it is the brickwork, which after three hundred and fifty years has hardly softened or worn at all despite its exposure to south-westerly winds and salty sea air. 
 It is a very hard brick which is finely worked in various decorative details such as the Doric and Ionic pilasters which frame the windows on both the main floors and the elaborate dentil pediment and rusticated pilasters around the door. 
 The brick is laid in &bquo;English bond&equo;, as opposed to that of Kew Palace which is in &bquo;Flemish bond&equo;. 
 The sash windows were put in at a later date but the glazing bars still follow the lines of the mullions and transoms and look particularly well.  
 pages 41 and 42: photographs 
 circa 1650 LODGE PARK Sherborne GLOUCESTERSHIRE 
 A HUNCHBACK, John Dutton of Sherborne, known as &bquo;crump&equo;, built beautiful Lodge Park. 
 The Duttons had come a hundred years before to the long straggling village of Sherborne in the archaically beautiful Borne Valley, where Thomas Dutton had built the original house of Sherborne Park in 1551. 
 (This was added to over the centuries and culminated as a gigantic mansion of the early 1830s). 
 Up the long slow hill from Sherborne, over the main Oxford to Bath road, there are bleak, windswept wolds, flat as a pancake, crossed at this point by a narrow and perfectly straight road. 
 Here the last thing you expect to see is one of the most exquisite small houses in the land; yet here, glimpsed down a short straight avenue of completely inappropriate young cherry trees, is Lodge Park. 
 For a long time the building was attributed to Inigo Jones, something people much enjoy doing. 
 Recently the experts have deemed this unlikely. 
 Apparently it is too old-fashioned and cluttered for the great master to have had anything to do with it &mdash; despite the fact that Lord Burlington, the aristocratic architect, was convinced of his having designed it. 
 It was not designed as a dwelling place in the first instance. 
 John Dutton, a great friend of Oliver Cromwell, was a &bquo;learned and prudent man,, according to his contemporary Anthony &agrave; Wood, &bquo;and as one of the richest, so one of the meekest men in England&equo;. 
 From 1624 to 1640 Dutton bought up the land round Sherborne Park in order to create a deer park, to be enclosed by a high wall. 
 Once done, he set about building this lodge to serve as a grandstand, from whose balcony he could be with family and friends and watch his hounds coursing deer across the bare miles. 
 The thin beech spinney from where the dogs were slipped still stands near the Oxford road. 
 The lodge contained a large hall below and a banqueting room above, connected by a grand wooden stair. 
 In 1898 Emma, Lady Sherborne, converted the Lodge into her dower house, built two little lodges to herald its and her own grandeur and to house her staff, destroyed the staircase and made the two long rooms into four apartments. 
 &bquo;&hellip; there is another park,&equo; wrote Mr Hutton in By Thames and Cotswold  at the beginning of this century, &bquo;it is isolated and wild with a Jacobean hunting lodge worth all the great houses near it thrown together.&equo; 
 The sculptor mason now thought to have built it, Valentine Strong, whose building family owned stone quarries at nearby Little Barrington, will long be remembered for his witty epitaph in Fairford churchyard: 
 Here's one that was an able workman long 
 Who divers houses built, both fair and Strong; 
 Though Strong he was, a Stronger came than he 
 And robb'd him of his life and fame, we see: 
 Moving an old house a new one for to rear, 
 Death met him by the way, and laid him here. 
 circa 1670 KELLAWAYS Chippenham WILTSHIRE 
 KELLAWAYS is a perfect miniature manor house, set in flat fields beside the wide River Avon, which floods the farmland around with the utmost regularity. 
 It is a typical &bquo;hanger on&equo; to the traditional Elizabethan style. 
 Many builders of smaller houses in the Cotswolds clung on to this much-loved style which they had so perfected. 
 The manor is built of &bquo;Kelloway's Rock&equo;, a peculiar oolitic limestone containing masses of fossils, which was quarried nearby. 
 Beside the gateposts to the manor's short straight drive, is the famous &bquo;Maud Heath's Causeway&equo;, the only way to cross the Avon in flood. 
 Maud Heath was a pedlar woman who lived on Wick Hill and walked four and a half miles, past Kellaways, to Chippenham each morning. 
 When she died in 1474, she left enough money to build, and maintain in perpetuity, the pavement and causeway with its sixty-four arches. 
 The charity still maintains it. 
 The Kellaway family gave their name to this house and the now tiny hamlet, when they were the lords of the manor in the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries. 
 The next owner was Robert Russell, a merchant from Bristol who is buried at Bremhill, beyond Wick Hill, and then came John Bagot. 
 In 1500 Sir Thomas Long bought Kellaways, and it remained in his family until 1844. 
 If families like this one were on the wrong side in the Civil War, their property was sequestered by Parliament, but it appears that John Long petitioned to have it restored as his inheritance in 1650, and it was probably he who built the present house. 
 Though they remained lords of the manor, the Longs sold off the house and farm of 122 acres, and in 1834 it belonged to William Stancombe, whose tenant was coincidentally also called John Long. 
 In 1878 The Royal Agricultural Society reported in their journal: &bquo;This farm, in fact, has all the requisites of a prize farm, and we had  therefore  very great pleasure in awarding First Prize (in all England) to Mr Long who will, we feel certain, consider it a recognition of the untiring industry shown by himself and his wife in the management of this pretty little farm&hellip; the arable land is cultivated like a garden, being wonderfully free from weeds. 
 Two cart horses and one nag are kept on the farm; Mr Long employs three labourers, at wages of 15s a week, and 3 pints of cider per day. 
 The cattle on the farm are 38 dairy cows and 1 bull.&equo;  
 pages 45 and 46: photographs 
 circa 1670 SOUTH LUFFENHAM HALL Oakham RUTLAND 
 HERE is the perfect Carolean house, gleaming in golden limestone and sailing above one of Rutland's fifty villages and some of the best hunting country in England. 
 But for the glass in its windows, which originally would have been in small leaded panes, it remains unaltered on the outside. 
 Sir Christopher Wren had already built the Sheldonian, and being the court architect had enormous stylistic influence. 
 The radical change from the romantic picturesqueness of the Elizabethan manor house to the measured symmetry of South Luffenham Hall must have upset many of the more traditional locals, for this house would have looked daringly modern when it was built. 
 The fundamental difference between this new style and the old, was that in order to achieve it you needed the assistance of an architect. 
 The builder could no longer rely on eye alone; the Renaissance was a time for an order based on detailed knowledge. 
 Nobody knows exactly who built South Luffenham, but it is almost certain that an architect called John Sturges supplied the drawings. 
 He was involved in the building of nearby Lyndon Hall, which is exactly like South Luffenham in every detail except that the latter has five bays on each side and Lyndon has seven. 
 Architecture taken out of Palladio  had been translated into English and published in England in 1663, as had Gerbier's Counsel and Advice to Builders . 
 Cultivated gentlemen could, with the help of a very good builder, sometimes get by with a minimum of help from the architect, for these books provided inspiration, theory and practical guidance. 
 Gerbier, for instance, says on window design that they &bquo;must be as high again as wyde&hellip;&equo; and that their mouldings needed &bquo;the broad brim of a good hat to a travaileur on a rainy day&equo;. 
 The result of this scholarly study often produced tall houses such as this, with a semi-basement to rise above the damp and a stairway up to the main floor to add importance. 
 Inside, the Hall retains most of its original panelling. 
 (A surviving bill at Lyndon gives the price for 200 yards of wainscot at &pound;28 in 1676.) 
 &bquo;It will be handsome when uniforme,&equo; said Palladio about his houses, &bquo;because a building should be like an entier and perfect body where each member agrees with the other.,  
 circa 1680 THE MANOR HOUSE Poulton GLOUCESTERSHIRE 
 LIKE SOUTH Luffenham Hall, Poulton Manor is built of limestone, a belt of which runs up from the Cotswolds to Grantham. 
 It is England's finest stone and retains a clear-cut crispness three centuries later. 
 Still in the Wrenish mood, the roof is slightly more hipped than at South Luffenham, and the swans&equo; necks over the door have become a purely classical pediment. 
 It has a quiet rural grace about it and, particularly in this area where gabled houses went on being built well into the eighteenth century, it displays a certain amount of daring. 
 This has always been one of my favourite houses. 
 On journeys to the Cotswolds, when I was small, we would often pass through the winding village of Poulton. 
 The Manor was one of the first houses my father ever pointed out to me in an effort to get me to appreciate architecture. 
 &bquo;Look what a beautiful house!&equo; he said. 
 On subsequent journeys I would always try to be the first to see it and shout, &bquo;There it is, I saw it first!&equo; 
 Even today I still look forward to my first glimpse of it, after a huge bend in the road, through the gate in its enclosing wall. 
 The village of Poulton consisted of only seven cottages at the time of the Domesday survey. 
 There was a Gilbertine priory here (the only purely English monastic order), traces of which survive at the south end of the village. 
 At the Dissolution of the Monasteries, the manor of Poulton was granted to the Pagets. 
 Some people think that a Paget built the manor, but to judge by the monuments in the church (rebuilt by William Butterfield in 1873) it would seem likely that the builder was a &bquo;Thomas Bedwell, Gent.&equo;, 
 who died in 1691. 
 Inside, the house is virtually untouched since that date. 
 There are two rooms at the front and two at the back on each floor, and although you could not tell from the outside, the first floor rooms are a foot higher than those below. 
 Hence the first floor is a sort of piano nobile , a recent and foreign innovation which did not catch on for very long in smaller English country houses. 
 I suppose that, Holland being so flat, all Dutch houses needed a piano nobile  from which to get a better view, and that the fashion came here with the new King William. 
 The drawing-room is fully panelled, with a pair of Doric pilasters flanking the chimney-breast. 
 There are wide oak or elm floorboards in every room excepting the hall, which is stone flagged and from which rises a thick oak staircase with fat bannisters. 
 The manor orchard has a reputation in the village for being haunted. 
 When the house was empty at the beginning of the century following the owner's death, some village children crept into the orchard and began to collect apples. 
 They were terrified out of their wits when the supposedly dead owner appeared through the gate in the wall and shouted at them to go away. 
 In fact it was his identical twin, whom nobody knew about, and who had come back to tidy up his brother's affairs.  
 pages 49 and 50: photographs 
 circa 1690 OSWALDKIRK HALL Ampleforth YORKSHIRE 
 &bquo;OSWALDKIRK HAG&equo;, a fine belt of hanging woodland which covers the steep side of this beautiful stretch of the Hambledon Hills, shelters the Hall from cold northerly winds. 
 The house sits snugly, 275 feet above sea level, with a view southwards out over a wide expanse of undulating country to hills beyond. 
 It is rare to find such a fine and architecturally distinguished house, built in the reign of William and Mary, in a remote corner of the North Riding. 
 The last forty years of the seventeenth century were a boom period for country house building, and although many of them were replaced in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, Oswaldkirk is a beautiful reminder of the high quality of those houses. 
 It was built to impress, and this it still does, rising from the village which huddles around it. 
 Fifty years later saw the high fashion of segregating house from village. 
 Lords of the manor would either flatten the encroaching village and build a new one some distance away, or build their new house on a different site in pastoral isolation. 
 This is why many Georgian and Victorian houses are out on their own, whereas William and Mary and Queen Anne houses are often in the middle of villages, where the original manor had always stood. 
 The history of Oswaldkirk Hall follows the pattern of so many of the smaller manor houses of England. 
 At the time of the Domesday survey, it was held by Count de Mortain, whose tenants were the de Surdevals. 
 In the thirteenth century Emma de Surdeval married William de Barton, and their son then lived here. 
 From him it passed to the Pickerings in 1316. 
 Sir William Pickering was Knight Marshal to Henry VIII, and when he died in 1542 he left Oswaldkirk to his 24-year-old son, an extremely handsome and distinguished courtier and diplomat, brave and wise as well, and considered at one time as a suitor for Queen Elizabeth. 
 He died in 1574, leaving the property to his illegitimate daughter Hester, who married Lord Wooton. 
 Their hot-headed Jacobite descendant, Edward Hales, sold Oswaldkirk to William Moore in 1674. 
 It was Moore's son, also William, who probably built the present house, to match his desired image of the new country squire that he was. 
 The old Hall at Horningham, across the valley, had recently been demolished and rebuilt in this classical style in the early 1680s, and William Moore most probably employed the same builder. 
 His new house, built of hammer dressed limestone, with Westmorland slates for the roof, abutted on to the remains of the original house which he made into a service wing, and on the south side he made the grand entrance. 
 He used the best available craftsmen to make beautiful rusticated quoin stones, decorated iron rainwater heads, bolection moulded panelling and door surrounds with broken pediments over, a plaster ceiling on the landing with swags and scrolled foliage, and a grand segmental pediment over the front door.  
 1694 BETTISCOMBE Bridport DORSET 
 ALMOST IN Devon, Bettiscombe is a hidden house tucked beautifully into a bowl of hills which culminate in Pilsden Pen, the highest in Dorset. 
 At the end of a quarter of a mile of rough track it seems on first sight to be a typically humble and remote farmhouse, with its low and unobtrusive policies almost growing around it. 
 Then you notice that there are cobbles in the yard, there is lichen on the golden hamstone dressings, the iron railings keeping the cows from the garden are refined and elegant, and the carved and hooded doorway does not seem to herald the entrance to an ordinary farmhouse. 
 You look again. 
 It is only the size that is deceptive. 
 This house was indeed built for a gentleman &mdash; it just happens to be on an almost miniature scale. 
 Inside, a more civilized and settled atmosphere would be hard to find. 
 You walk into a flagstone-floored hall with a triple arched screen. 
 The quality of workmanship is unsurpassed and everything, from the sumptuous oak staircase with fluted bannisters and fat, swooping bannister rail to the door handles and keyhole covers, is delicately and perfectly made. 
 There are three ground floor sitting-rooms, panelled and with Purbeck marble or carved fireplaces. 
 Each of the six bedrooms has a small panelled closet. 
 It is rare to see a house so little altered. 
 Perhaps its remoteness has been its saving grace, coupled with the fact that by the nineteenth century the Pinney family who had built it deemed it too small and dim to live in and moved to their other house of Racedown, a mile up the road. 
 (William and Dorothy Wordsworth rented Racedown in the last years of the eighteenth century.) 
 The Pinneys had lived at Bettiscombe since the sixteenth century, but the first Pinney of note was John, a puritan divine and lace manufacturer. 
 In 1672 he obtained permission from Charles II to hold Presbyterian meetings in the house. 
 John's youngest son, Azariah, backed Monmouth in the rebellion and was banished to the West Indies, where he became a sugar planter. 
 Meanwhile his older brother, Nathaniel, married Naomi Gay (a cousin or an aunt of the author of The Beggar's Opera) , and in 1694 they built Bettiscombe in its present form around the vestiges of an earlier house. 
 Meanwhile, Azariah had made good in the West Indies, and his grandson, John Frederick, returned to England and Bettiscombe towards the middle of the eighteenth century and became MP for Bridport. 
 Despite his wonderfully unattractive and humourless appearance, his exotic origins nonetheless gave rise to an extraordinary rumour. 
 The Bettiscombe skull, preserved in the house at that time, was said to be that of a negro slave, so devoted to John Frederick that it emitted the most ghastly screams if it were ever parted from him. 
 The story then went that if the skull was ever taken died. 
 The skull has recently been identified as the fossilized cranium of a white woman, at least 1,500 years old, which probably came from the burial ground on Pilsden Pen.  
 pages 53 and 54: photographs 
 circa 1695 WADDON MANOR Weymouth DORSET 
 WADDON MANOR is more perfectly proportioned than almost any house I have ever seen. 
 There is an inexplicable rightness about it which makes me want to look at it for ages. 
 This has little to do with a conditioned eye, influenced by architectural orders, and more to do with a basic and instinctive feeling that lifts the spirit and brings about a sense of harmony between the scale of the house and the human frame. 
 You approach it along the narrowest road which creeps warily on the side of a steep chalk plateau, one step up from the flat farm land which, after a mile or so, tumbles to West Fleet and over Chesil Beach into the sea. 
 There, as though hanging from the green hillside, is Waddon Manor, with its air of vanished glory and its sad seaward gaze. 
 This east wing is all that remains of a house that was once in the shape of an &bquo;E&equo; without the middle. 
 It is easy to picture how it looked, for the steps and ball-topped garden gate piers to the left of it would have led up to the front door, and there would have been an exact replica of this wing to the far left. 
 Colonel Bullen Reynes, who fought for the king during the Civil War, built the house in the 1690s. 
 During the Restoration he had regained the lands he had lost when the king was defeated, and ended up as a Vice-Admiral of the Fleet. 
 He decided to live in Dorset and chose this site (where an earlier house had been), because it looked for all the world as though, when the house was built, it could sail straight out to sea. 
 Reynes was an acquaintance of the diarist Samuel Pepys, who referred to him as &bquo;a willing man, ready to co-operate in plans for the Navy&equo;, and &bquo;one who understands and loves a play as well as I, and I love him for it&equo;. 
 Being a cultivated man, he built his house in the style of the day. 
 The end of the seventeenth and the beginning of the eighteenth century was a tip-top time for English domestic architecture on this small scale. 
 There was a perfect grace which architects had been working towards through the seventeenth century and which seemed to peak in its purest form at about this time, not without a little Royal influence from Holland! 
 Before this time, vestiges of England's Tudor past were still evident, and some time afterwards the style grew tired, and the proportions lost their perfection. 
 Inside, the rooms are light and panelled with elegant pedimented overdoors, and it is sad to think that the full splendour of Bullen Reynes's house was only enjoyed by his son and his family for a few short years; the bulk of it burned down in 1704. 
 No one attempted to rebuild it, and the house soon reverted to being a farmhouse, as which it appeared in the film of Thomas Hardy's Far from the Madding Crowd . 
 The fine pair of dogs on top of the gateposts of the present-day front door were taken away after the fire and put on the gateposts of a house near Mere, belonging to Bullen's daughter-in-law's second husband, Mr Chaffin. 
 They were recently bought and reinstated by the present owners of Waddon.  
 1696 CROAN Wadebridge CORNWALL 
 EDWARD HOBLYN realized a dream in 1696 by building this beautiful house. 
 He was an attorney at law who, when he first began his practice, bragged, according to Gilbert's Parochial History of Cornwall , &bquo;that he would get an estate by the law one way or the other. 
 viz., right or wrong, and common fame saith he was as good as his word, in the worst sense. 
 Whereupon since his death by an unknown but arch hand, was fixed upon his grave in this parish this taunting epithet: 
 Here lies Ned 
 I'm glad he's dead, 
 If 'twere another 
 I wish t'were his brother, 
 And for good of the nation 
 His whole relation.&equo; 
 It is hardly surprising that no trace of this epitaph remains on a lichen-covered gravestone in the churchyard at Egloshayle. 
 Croan is lost deep in old woodland which feels strange and haunted and is always dark. 
 Up the winding lane from Wadebridge which was once the main road, a large light clearing reveals the house, down its straight grassy approach, as calm and gentle and Cornish as could be. 
 It is built of freestone rubble which was quarried in the grounds. 
 From this same quarry the longest bridge in Cornwall was built across the Camel at Wadebridge in 1485, and it is still going strong. 
 The greeny brown surface of the stone is dappled with grey and yellow lichens, and wisteria and ceanothus thrive on this south fa&ccedil;ade. 
 Edward Hoblyn's son, another Edward, married Barbara Hawkins. 
 They had one daughter called Damaris, who married a Mr Kirkham. 
 Damaris lived to a very great age and outlived not only her husband but all her five children. 
 She left Croan and its estate to her cousin, Henry Hawkins Tremayne, son of her Aunt Grace (n&eacute;e Hawkins). 
 The Tremaynes preferred their original country seat of Heligan, near Mevagissey, and during the nineteenth century they made a lot of money, which they lavished on the latter, leaving Croan untouched by architectural fashions. 
 It was let to a series of tenant farmers for over two centuries, until the Tremaynes returned in 1914. 
 The only inconvenience of the original interior was that the bedrooms all led into one another (just as they had always done in houses past: passages were only deemed essential when the segregation of servants became the norm in the eighteenth century); but this was overcome by making a gallery and rearranging the staircase.  
 pages 57 and 58: photographs 
 1698 FORSTON MANOR Charminster DORSET 
 FORSTON IS a tiny hamlet on the River Cerne, which winds down the valley from Cerne Abbas to join the River Frome at Dorchester. 
 Over in the next valley to the west lies the great park and lost house of Frampton Court, the home of the beneficent Browne family who were responsible for the building of Forston Manor. 
 Robert Browne had architectural aspirations. 
 In 1695 he built the west tower on his local church at Frampton, in a mixture of classical and traditional taste, then he built Forston in 1698, before rebuilding his own house, Frampton Court, in 1704. 
 Although it was embellished in 1750 by John Browne, Forston Manor was already extremely sophisticated for a house of its size at the time, for it has some details that are &bquo;Baroque&equo;, a style that often moved rectangles into curves. 
 The use of the term &bquo;Baroque&equo; for an English house is really quite recent, and it simply means the breaking of rules and the taking of liberties with the pure classical style. 
 In Italy, Austria and south Germany the baroque style went wild, but in England it was short-lived and remained terrifically reserved and in character with the nobility and gentry who were to live with it. 
 The way the parapet wall, which screens the attics, sweeps down in a bold curve is exceptionally pretty, and it really makes you want to stop and stare at the house as you glimpse it through trees and across the river meadow from the Dorchester to Godmanstone road. 
 Forston stayed in Browne ownership until 1827, when the philanthropic Francis John Browne of Frampton Court, who had no direct heirs, offered the manor to the county authorities, together with seven acres of land, as an &bquo;asylum for the benefit of pauper lunatics&equo;. 
 He also left &pound;4,000 for its endowment. 
 Hitherto there had been no provision for the mentally afflicted poor; only licensed &bquo;mad houses,, run on a private basis, which could only be used by those whose relations could afford them. 
 By 1832 an enormous wing was attached to Forston's north side which stretched for five hundred feet and accommodated 65 patients and half as many staff. 
 Forston Asylum was one of the most advanced in the country and set a new example. 
 In 1863 another county asylum was built a mile away at Herrison, and Forston gradually became redundant. 
 It was not until 1960 that the gargantuan task of demolishing the attached asylum was undertaken and Forston Manor returned to its original self as though nothing had happened.  
 page 60: photograph 
 1700&ndash;2 REDDISH HOUSE Broad Chalke WILTSHIRE 
 &bquo;IT IS aesthetically always a matter of satisfaction when a notable house finds an occupant worthy of its quality,&equo; wrote Christopher Hussey of &bquo;this outstanding example of rustic baroque&equo; and its owner, Cecil Beaton. 
 Visiting Reddish in the late 1950s was like visiting heaven. 
 I had never seen anything like it; it felt slightly illegal. 
 The drawing-room walls were covered in blackberry-coloured velvet secured by gold filigree, the library walls were green and gold, and there was leopard skin covering the chairs in the hall. 
 There was a conservatory designed by Felix Harboard, lined in split bamboo and with a lotus-shaped lily pool in the middle of its black and white paved floor. 
 The rambler roses in the garden beyond grew along chains which dipped up and down and swung in the wind between six foot high posts, and a row of strangely shaped lumps of yew, grown hugely out of proportion, ran from the north corner of the house. 
 The yew had been grown by John Combes in the early 1700s when this house was built, and there had been an altercation about it; there had also been an altercation about the building. 
 Reddish stands in Broad Chalke, a large and disparate village which lies along the meadows of the Chalke stream. 
 In the seventeenth century, John Aubrey, Wiltshire's first archaeologist, lived in the manor farm, and his name is inscribed on one of the church bells whose ringing he loved so. 
 &bquo;The river running near the churchyard ameliorates the sound,&equo; he wrote. 
 Originally called Littlecotes Farm, Reddish House acquired its name when it was bought by a Christopher Reddishe of Maiden Bradley in 1599. 
 He and his family let it until Jeremiah Cray, a clothier of Ibsey in Hampshire, acquired it in 1702. 
 It was his tenant John Combes who revolutionized Reddish, on the assumption that Cray would pay for most of it. 
 Some haggling ensued, but Combes, who was originally from Broad Chalke and had made good in London as a mercer, wanted to show his village just how well he had done. 
 He ended up by paying for most of the house himself and what had once been a modest little farmhouse jumped up several rungs of the architectural and social ladder. 
 John Combes was obviously friends with a fine stonemason who would have done work at Wilton House and perhaps lived in Broad Chalke. 
 The end result was definitely a cut above the average village manor, with its pediment thrusting forward, its roof line to match, and the strong outline of the window casing, all echoing baroque. 
 Behind the oval window in the pediment there is a cock loft, and originally there were two pairs of square rooms on each floor, some of which have subsequently been knocked into one. 
 The decorations would have been very simple and little of the panelling survives. 
 John Combes and his wife lived out their lives in their dream house, and their children stayed here until the 1760s. 
 In the 1770s a wing was added at the back, and once again the house rose up the social scale.  
 circa 1703 SWANGROVE, BADMINTON Chipping Sodbury GLOUCESTERSHIRE 
 SWANGROVE IS a star of a house; romantic and apart. 
 No roads lead to it. 
 It lies happily stranded across arable fields, beside deep woods on the edge of Badminton Park. 
 It was built in 1703 as a maison de plaisance  by the widowed Marchioness of Worcester for her son, the second Duke of Beaufort. 
 He did not in fact inherit the title until 1705, but a love of hunting he certainly did. 
 It was for this reason that Swangrove came about. 
 Here in the great saloon, light and airy with its tall mullioned windows facing north and south, its smart bolection moulding around the panelling and its groaning tables of food, the men would congregate and feast after a long morning's deer hunting in the park. 
 They could wash their hands in one of the most glamorous marble basins in England, set in a marble niche with a scallop-shaped roof and with water gushing from the mouth of a mandarin mask. 
 In the afternoon, women would arrive in carriages from the great house a mile or so distant. 
 The second Duke was handsome, his friends raucous. 
 The scene, without the players, is the same today as you enter the low walled garden with its four pleasing square summer-houses at the corners and its grand sweeping steps leading up Swangrove is its exotic and inimitable rendering of the local Cotswold style. 
 Queen Anne's reign was a sophisticated time to be building. 
 Most of the nobility were dreaming of classical temples in their parks, or other architectural fantasies from foreign climes, which through the eighteenth century grew ever more complicated. 
 But Swangrove has retained all the details of a local Cotswold house and then exaggerated them. 
 The gables are more pointed than normal, the mullioned and transomed windows more elongated, while the dripstone, such a familiar Cotswold feature, has been turned into a frill which still directs the rain away from the windows. 
 Mr Thomas Sumison, the master mason from Colerne who almost certainly built it, was a genius, for Swangrove belongs to the place. 
 When, in 1750, Worcester Lodge was built, in a sumptuous style, by William Kent at the end of an axial avenue, the fashionable set preferred it. 
 They had grown tired of giving parties and picnics in Swangrove. 
 It became an occasional residence. 
 The third duke, whose wife had left him, set up a lady friend here; and what more perfect house could exist for romantic visitations?  
 pages 63 and 64: photographs 
 circa 1703 THE OLD PARSONAGE Buscot, Faringdon BERKSHIRE 
 HERE SITS, in the sublimest of settings, one of the most perfect houses. 
 It was built at the time when local builders possessed that magic formula for rightness of scale. 
 Above Lechlade, nearer Inglesham, the River Thames becomes too narrow and shallow for a rowing boat to navigate. 
 Here at Buscot it has widened out again, the fair Isis, and the walled garden of the Old Parsonage stretches down to meet it, full of box hedged paths, damask and china roses, with clematis climbing everywhere and Kiftsgate roses in the apple trees. 
 Adjacent is the small, thirteenth-century church of St Mary, which has a stained glass window by Sir Edward Burne-Jones. 
 He was Part of that great brotherhood of the nineteenth century whose influence around here was considerable, for William Morris lived just downstream on the Oxfordshire banks of the Thames in beautiful seventeenth-century Kelmscott. 
 There was obviously a larger village of Buscot here, around the church and parsonage, for the present village lies some way off across the fields. 
 In the 1850s the four thousand acre estate of Buscot Park, with its classical house and its village and lands, were in a derelict state. 
 The whole was then bought up rich Australian gold trader named Campbell, who proceeded to pull things together. 
 He grew sugar beet everywhere and built, on an island in the Thames still known as &bquo;Brandy Island&equo;, a large distillery to make spirit with the sugar beet. 
 He also built a narrow gauge railway which ran round the whole estate. 
 After his death the Henderson family bought the estate and built model cottages designed by Ernest George and Peto in the village. 
 The church and parsonage became even more forgotten. 
 So the Old Parsonage remained until the American Mr Stucley bought it from the church in the 1930s, thereafter leaving it to the National Trust. 
 This was the house which leapt into my mind when The Perfect English House  was first mooted. 
 It is a lot of people's favourite house and, happily, there is absolutely no defining why. 
 Neither the National Trust, who own it, nor the County Listing Department, nor Nikolaus Pevsner can furnish one with anything more than technical descriptions. 
 John Julius Norwich, in his book, The Architecture of Southern England , sums up quite simply: &bquo;The Old Parsonage is a ravishing stone house of about 1700 with two storeys of five bays beneath a hipped roof; unpretentious, but in its way, perfect.&equo;  
 circa 1705 NETHERHAMPTON HOUSE Wilton WILTSHIRE 
 FROM 1907 to 1934 Sir Henry Newbolt, our great patriotic, nautical and sometimes contemplative poet, lived here in this lovely manor house on the village street of Netherhampton, backed by watermeadows and sheltered by the great chalk downs. 
 &bquo;We went to Netherhampton for a year&equo;, he wrote: &bquo;the experiment lasted for seven and here we are still at Netherhampton after a quarter of a century.&equo; 
 To the church, local charities and various far-sighted attempts to preserve the beauty of England's scenery Newbolt gave much of his time. 
 But in the ghosts of the house &bquo;we have little interest&hellip; &bquo;, he wrote. 
 &bquo;One has long made a habit of beheading his wife at intervals in what is now my study: the other, a lady named Madam Sharpe, drops rings and other small objects into a china basin in my dressing room&hellip;. 
 I have never  succeeded  in catching a glimpse of her.&equo; 
 For four and a half centuries the village and manor have belonged to the Earls of Pembroke. 
 There was a humble house here in the 1600s, rented by the rising Gauntlett family who made their money in clay pipes when tobacco was all the rage. 
 In 1670 William Gauntlett took out a patent of arms at the Herald's College and in 1687 made the manor a little larger. 
 Not large enough, though, for William's son John, who became the Member of Parliament for Wilton in 1701 and subsequently built on this exquisite face to his childhood home. 
 At this stage the property comprised &bquo;three ground floor rooms, and three upper rooms lofted. 
 A hay house, a barn of three rooms, a cowhouse, a backside, garden and orchard.&equo; 
 From John it passed to a cousin, then to his niece, Susannah Sharpe (the ghost). 
 Mrs Phillipa Grove took up the lease in 1782 and on her death her daughter, Miss Phillipa Grove renewed the tenancy and payed &pound;44. 10s a year rent to Lord Pembroke. 
 This was put up to &pound;50 in 1813 &mdash; peanuts to Miss Grove, a formidable spinster who had inherited &pound;10,000 from her father when she was twelve. 
 The Groves were an old West Country family, among whom Miss Phillipa was referred to as &bquo;Aunt Grove&equo;. 
 Her favourite niece was pale, blue-eyed Harriet, cousin, collaborator and first love of Percy Bysshe Shelley. 
 Harriet often came to stay at Netherhampton to catch up on all the &bquo;gossip of Salisbury&equo; and to take her mind off her romance with Shelley, thwarted at every step by her brother Charles. 
 When Aunt Grove died in 1840, she left money to fund the school for poor children which she had founded in the village. 
 The Gauntletts left a house, the Groves a school and, attacked by a critic for writing patriotic verse when he was neither a soldier nor sailor himself, Sir Henry Newbolt left these lines: 
 &hellip; 
 Perchance some looked beyond him, and 
 then first 
 Beheld the glory, and what shrine it filled, 
 And to what spirit sacred: or perchance 
 Some heard him chanting, though but to 
 himself, 
 The old heroic names: and went their way: 
 And hummed his music on the march to death. 
 pages 67 and 68: photographs 
 circa 1707 BRIZLINCOTE HALL Bretby DERBYSHIRE 
 THERE IS an avenue of old oak trees marking the drive which two hundred years ago led through twenty feet high brick gate piers to this beautiful Baroque house. 
 Now the gate piers lean at terrifying angles, overgrown with hawthorns, and cattle graze beneath the oaks and right up to the cellar windows of the south side of the house; ivy smothers the old garden walls, and Burton on Trent in the valley below creeps nearer and nearer, an enormous and inevitable incoming tide, towards the steep little hill where Brizlincote Hall still stands high and proud. 
 All the country round about was owned by the Earls of Chesterfield, who resided at neighbouring Bretby House. 
 The third earl, who built Brizlincote, had the reputation of being something of a rake. 
 He didn't talk to his wife, who died at the age of thirty-three, having borne him nine sons. 
 (His second son, Philip Dormer Stanhope, who became the fourth earl, was the famous politician, wit, gambler and letter writer.) 
 The third earl designed this house himself with a view to it being lived in by his eldest son and subsequent heirs. 
 There had been a house here before, built by the Pagets on land they had bought from Burton Abbey. 
 In 1706 Lord Chesterfield acquired the property and demolished the original house. 
 What he built instead was extraordinary and unique. 
 Before the surrounding land was built over in the last century and subsequently, you could have seen it from miles away in every direction. 
 It forms a perfect square, with five bays on every side with the huge segmental pediments above. 
 The tall chimneys perfect its proportions. 
 It is built of small wire-cut bricks from the local kiln, and the quoins and dressings are all of stone from Burton. 
 The Chesterfield heirs never lived here; they spurned Brizlincote, and its radial oak avenues and the formal gardens grew up to see no Stanhope carriages bowling down the drive. 
 In 1793, Lord Chesterfield's chief steward deemed it &bquo;an old whimsical house, but fit for a gentleman's occupation&equo;. 
 William Barnes, a distant Stanhope cousin, lived here for a time, but for most of its life it has been a farmhouse, which it remains.  
 circa 1708 IFORD MANOR Bradford on Avon WILTSHIRE 
 IT WOULD be hard to find a more idyllic setting than that of Iford Manor in its secret valley beside the River Frome, with one bank in Wiltshire and the other in Somerset. 
 The south-facing classical fa&ccedil;ade was built on in about 1708, just after the house had been bought by an affluent salter from Bradford on Avon called William Chandler. 
 Desiring to flaunt his new found riches he did not want to be seen owning the house which lies behind &mdash; a rambling hotchpotch of roof lines and gables which evolved over centuries. 
 He employed a builder from his home town who was well used to the sophisticated style in which the many rich cloth merchants were building their houses. 
 Bristol and Bath were not far away, and this particular corner of England, which was enormously rich in the eighteenth century, was sometimes ahead of London in its architectural fashions. 
 The Romans were always good at finding a sheltered and beautiful site and it was they who first settled here. 
 The Hungerfords of Farleigh Hungerford, the all-powerful local family in medieval times, bought Iford, which was then a mill, in 1369 and held on to it for four centuries. 
 They leased the mill and its house to a reputable family of clothiers named Horton. 
 The Hortons added on to the mill house, and during Elizabeth's reign they made extensive gabled additions which can be seen best on the east fa&ccedil;ade. 
 The house was used for the making of cloth until well into the seventeenth century. 
 Iford Manor was bought in 1773 by the Gaisford family, who owned it until 1853. 
 Thomas Gaisford, who later became Dean of Christchurch, Oxford, was only four years old in 1770 when the great cedar tree was planted which still stands on the hillside walk behind the house. 
 Later he planted the drifts of snowdrops and martagon lilies in the wild garden and the woods. 
 Men of the cloth are nearly always good gardeners. 
 In 1899, when the house had become dilapidated, it was bought by Harold A. Peto, the architect who formed the famous partnership with Sir Ernest George. 
 Lutyens joined their practice as a young man and was much influenced by Peto, who was brilliant, eccentric, energetic and funny and during the later part of his life became increasingly keen on garden design. 
 He created several gardens on the Continent, including Villa Maryland and Villa Rosemary in the south of France; but his crowning glory must be at Iford, where he has brought Italy to Wiltshire and set it tumbling down the hanger, in a series of steep paths, steps, and terraces where colonnades, cloisters, fountains and well-heads abound. 
 On the fourteenth-century bridge in front of the house sits a spectacularly placed statue of Britannia. 
 Inside the Manor, Mr Peto displayed his eclectic tastes and imported great oaken figures to support the ceiling in the garden hall, one of whom is the figure of St Barba, the patron saint of soldiers but also, appropriately, of architects.  
 pages 71 and 72: photographs 
 circa 1701 MOTHECOMBE HOUSE Holberton DEVONSHIRE 
 FROM WHICHEVER direction you approach Mothecombe, whether along the winding wooded valley beside the ever widening River Erme, or down the road from Battisborough Cross and through the clumps of hydrangeas, or by sea around Butcher's Cove to its sandy bay and up the secret combe strewn with bluebells and daffodils, the first sight of it takes your breath away. 
 The house and village of Mothecombe (more anciently Mouthecombe) are as settled, simple and beautiful as any in the land. 
 A row of thatched cottages is strung along the lane coming up from the sea and opens into a forecourt in the front and at the eastern side of the house. 
 Before it is the white eighteenth-century railing erected to add dignity and distance to the smart new house which John Pollexton built in the early 1700s. 
 Now a great sycamore shades his granite portal. 
 From the early 1200s William de Mouthecombe was lord of the manor, and his descendants continued to live here until the fifteenth century, when Margerie Mouthecombe, the last of the line, married Richard Sacheville, a very nasty man who in 1431 caused his neighbours, including Foretescues, Combes, Prideaux and Treebys, to attack Mothecombe with &bquo;swerdis and bokelers, bowesy-bente, arrewes and daggers&hellip; 
 &equo; They kidnapped Richard &bquo;and smytinge the said Margerie so being with childe that she fell downe as a dead woman there they let her lye, the which was the cause of the saide childe's deth.&equo; 
 Nonetheless a William Sacheville, presumably Richard's son, then lived at Mothecombe and his daughter Elizabeth married Andrew Stretchley. 
 Joan, their great-granddaughter, married John Pollexton of Kitley. 
 Three generations later, the third John Pollexton inherited Mothecombe in 1700 and proceeded to build what he referred to in his will as &bquo;the new house by me erected&equo;. 
 A local builder, probably the same man who had just built the beautiful house of Newton Ferrers, created this simple masterpiece in the local sea-grey basaltic stone, mixed with silvery granite from the moor up over the hill to the north. 
 If ever there was a perfect Queen Anne house, here it is, and perhaps a reason for its extra glow is its delicate restoration by the Mildmay family who came to live here in the 1870s. 
 The Pollexton dynasty had finished by 1747, and from then on various relations spurned Mothecome until eventually they sold it at the end of the eighteenth century to a Mildmay forbear. 
 In 1872 Mr and Mrs Henry Bingham Mildmay Found an old coastguard caretaking the house, and its untouched and forgotten quality appealed to their fashionable sense of the romantic. 
 They moved in, and invited William Morris to stay so that he might advise them on decorating and restoring the place. 
 Morris's effect on a whole section of society in encouraging the preservation of old houses was far greater than he is given credit for. 
 The later restoration of Mothecombe was carried out by Sir Edwin Lutyens who made no material alterations to the original house but added a dining room at the back.  
 circa 1710 CROW WOOD Stokesley YORKSHIRE 
 &bquo;THE ENVIRONS of Stokesley are fertile,&equo; wrote John Bigland in The Beauties of England and Wales  in 1812, &bquo;being chiefly in grass and not affording enough employment for the inhabitants, a general langour, as Mr Graves very justly observes, appears to prevail. 
 Stokesley, indeed, possessing neither trade nor manufacturers, has no appearance of bustle or business, and is a place well adapted to retirement.&equo; 
 There is still a feeling of langour about Crow Wood, lying in those fertile surroundings where cattle thrived on the rich pastureland. 
 It was built to house the younger son of the Emmersons of Easby Hall and to display the style and flourish of a small gentleman's residence. 
 The palest pink Yorkshire brick was used, with smart keystones over the windows and elegant corner quoin stones. 
 It is now a grand little farmhouse forming part of a courtyard together with its outbuildings and set against the prevailing wind from the northwest. 
 Pantiles are the typical roofing material of this eastern side of England. 
 (There was an Act of Parliament in the reign of George I, just when this house was being built, which decreed that their measurements should not be less than 13&frac12;in by 9&frac12;in by &frac12;in;, and these dimensions are still more or less adhered to today.) 
 Crow Wood is set below the north-western flanks of the Cleveland Hills, with a clear view to Roseberry Topping, a strangely menacing peak rising straight out of meadows and woodland. 
 By the clouds which hang around it the locals can foretell a storm: 
 &bquo;When Roseberry Topping wears a cap 
 Let Cleveland then beware of a clap.' 
 Looking eastward, the tall column to the memory of Captain Cook, a local lad, stands like a lighthouse on the purplish blue heights of Easby Moor. 
 Crow Wood was empty for most of this century, remote and forgotten between the roads to Easby and Ingleby. 
 Only a rutted bridle track, where orchids still grow, led to it by way of a dilapidated wooden bridge over a stream; the oak avenue which once lined the way gradually fell. 
 The house earned the reputation of being haunted, and was eventually sold when the estate of the Emmersons of Easby Hall was broken up.  
 page 75: photograph 
 circa 1710 COMPTON BEAUCHAMP Shrivenham BERKSHIRE 
 &bquo;COMPTON BEAUCHAMP house is a gem privily set in a bosky lap of the bare chalk downs where they meet the fertile flats of the White Horse Vale. 
 It is a pearl of price combining in high degree amenity of position and charm of layout.&equo; 
 So wrote Mr Avray Tipping in 1918, persuading the traveller to take the winding road from Shrivenham (pronounced &bquo;Shrinam&equo; by the locals) and to glimpse down its fine avenue of limes heralding what for all the world could be the Petit Trianon plucked from Versailles and set down here in Berkshire. 
 At the beginning of the eighteenth century Edward Richards set about remodelling his modest moated manor in the very latest Palladian style. 
 In 1710, while the building was still going on, Edward married Rachel Warneford, of Sevenhampton, near Swindon, and their initials are intertwined on the wrought-iron entrance gates. 
 The new north front was built rising directly from the moat. 
 Once through its portals you find yourself in a courtyard surrounded on three sides by the relatively undisturbed medieval manor, whose mullioned windows have sometimes been exchanged for sash. 
 Look through the south door to the garden and there, across the moat, the formal garden of yews and all&eacute;es  stretches towards the downs just as it did when it was first laid out. 
 Inside, the Richards lined many of the rooms with wainscots and the big bolection moulded panels of the time, mostly in the fashionable white wood, save for an oak room on the first floor. 
 The Richards had an only daughter, Ann, who inherited the house. 
 She became one of the greatest sportswomen of the century and was stunningly beautiful to boot. 
 Men courted her constantly, taking off their riding wigs just short of the lime avenue and putting on their grand ceremonial perukes which their servants carried in bandboxes on the pommel of their saddles, &bquo;duly prepared for an attack on the heart of the young heiress&equo;. 
 She resisted all advances, for her love of coursing far outweighed her interest in any suitor. 
 Every day of the season she would travel in her carriage and six to Ashdown Park on top of the downs, where she would course for hares with her magnificent greyhounds and walk for twenty-five miles. 
 When interviewing cooks (her table was famous), she would ask them first if they liked dogs. 
 &bquo;Remember,&equo; she would say, &bquo;their place in my house is wherever they think fit to go.&equo; 
 She wrote her own epitaph: 
 Reader, if sport to thee was dear, 
 Drop on Ann Richard's tomb a tear; 
 Who when alive with piercing eye, 
 Did many a timid hare decry. 
 At books she laughed, at Pope and Clarke, 
 And all her joy was Ashdown Park&hellip; 
 The Craven family of Ashdown Park eventually bought Compton Beauchamp in the middle of the nineteenth century, but never lived there. 
 The house has changed hands many times over the last fifty years.  
 pages 77 and 78: photographs 
 1710&ndash;11 BIDDESDEN HOUSE Ludgershall WILTSHIRE 
 BIDDESDEN HOUSE, the last word in rural baroque, was built in 1710 for John Richmond Webb, one of Marlborough's finest generals and closest friends, perhaps most famous for his victory at Wynedaele in 1708. 
 I He was very good-looking and fast became a popular idol &mdash; &bquo;As Paris handsome and as Hector brave&equo;, according to a contemporary poetaster. 
 During the summer of 1710, while Biddesden was being built, he contemplated standing for parliament against the Whig, General Stanhope. 
 However, he decided instead to take up the post he had been offered of Captain and Governor of the Isle of Wight. 
 Webb's house was a reflection of his self-esteem. 
 Grand but not too grand, and wearing all its medals and trophies to the fore. 
 It is built in two colours of brick, pinkish red and slate blue, and is richly embellished with urns and quoin stones. 
 The general obviously ordered all the new-tangled things that were on offer: &bquo;Oh yes, I'll have some round windows, and some arched ones, and perhaps some half-arched ones&hellip; 
 &equo; On the north-east corner he asked for a castellated bell tower in which to house the bell he had brought back from Lille. 
 In the great high hall there is an enormous and glamorous portrait of Webb on a black charger, by Wooton. 
 (When this portrait is removed, apparently, which it was once, early in this century, the ghost of Webb gallops noisily up and down the stairs.) 
 The whole effect of Biddesden is ravishing, and it matters not that no one knows who the architect was. 
 Nikolaus Pevsner gives it a whole page in his Buildings of England  series, which is praise indeed. 
 &bquo;It is a very remarkable house,&equo; he says, &bquo;from the point of view of English, not only of Wiltshire architecture. 
 It belongs to the Vanbrugh-Hawksmoor-Archer group and can hold its own.&equo; 
 Biddesden was bought by the Everetts in 1795, and subsequently by the Grahams. 
 In 1931 Brian Guinness (later Lord Moyne), the author and poet, who had lived in Ireland and had been spoiled with beautiful architecture, bought Biddesden, recognizing it as one of the most exceptional small houses in England. 
 It fast became a glorious gathering place for the artistic intelligentsia of the day, who helped to enhance Biddesden further. 
 The artist Roland Pym painted trompe-l'oeils  of Regency figures in two of the blank windows, and Dora Carrington painted another. 
 In his book, Pot Pourri from the Thirties , Lord Moyne writes, &bquo;To me a home in the country was a gateway to happiness&hellip; 
 My roots and my family's have gone deeply into the fields and woods which the General must have owned in the 18th Century.&equo;  
 page 80: blank 
 GEORGIAN 
 The symmetrical and classical looking house was new reaching every corner of England and by the end of the eighteenth century our traditional, organic and unselfconscious architecture was fast disappearing. 
 Andrea Palladio (1518&ndash;1580) the Italian architect, was revered and studied by English architects, who built adaptations of Italian palaces in England, but by the end of the century it was the Adam brothers who were having the greatest influence. 
 They rebelled against the Palladian sense of order and then led a classical revival which heralded the architecture of the beginning of the next century. 
 On a minor, but parallel line, from the 1740s onwards the aesthetic rich began building rustic, Gothick and Chinese garden houses and this picturesque style slowly crept into small house architecture.  
 1718 EBBERSTON HALL Ripon YORKSHIRE 
 EBBERSTON HALL is Palladian to the hilt and also much bigger than it looks. 
 There is an entrance hall of perfect proportions, which is twice as long as it is square, and leading off it are three reception rooms of great height and elegance. 
 One of these, the former bedroom, is the most important room, for Ebberston was built as a romantic love-nest for the mistress of William Thompson, the MP for Scarborough and Warden of the Mint. 
 They say she never even visited it, but there is no proof of this. 
 The enamoured Mr Thompson made the most elaborate water gardens to complement the house, with an aqueduct, canals, fountains and cascades. 
 The architect was Colin Campbell, a Scotsman who, having worked as the agent of William Benson, was then patronized by Lord Burlington, whom he converted to Palladianism. 
 He had just built a house at Beverly for Sir Charles Hotham the year before, and Ebberston was a convenient following job. 
 Campbell was totally influenced by the great Italian architect Palladio and in 1715 published the first volume of Vitruvius Britannicus . 
 For Campbell, the designing of Ebberston was really a chance to perfect his Palladian dream in miniature, for it would have fitted into the hall at either of his famous houses, Houghton in Norfolk or Mereworth in Kent. 
 Mr Thompson was a bachelor, on whose death the Hothams bought Ebberston. 
 In 1807 Yorkshire's famous Squire Osbaldeston moved here. 
 A sportsman legendary both during and after his lifetime he was an unsurpassed master of hounds and once, for a bet, he rode two hundred miles in nine hours, on fifty horses (each going four miles). 
 He killed a hundred pheasants with a hundred shots at his friend Sir Richard Sutton's estate of Lyndford, and in Scotland 97 grouse with 97 shots. 
 With Richard Hill of Thornton he killed 20 brace of partridges with 40 shots. 
 He was, according to a contemporary, &bquo;a compact little figure, often dressed like a jockey, but almost invariably combining the benign aspect of a great sportsman with the countenance and expression of a rural dean&equo;. 
 &bquo;It was a mere chateau in the Italian style of architecture,&equo; wrote Osbaldeston of Ebberston, &bquo;and not large enough for us; but we took it. 
 At a later date I bought the place and built on wings to make the necessary accommodation. 
 I might have saved myself the trouble, as the family remained together for only a short time afterwards; my sisters married, leaving only my mother and myself at home&hellip; 
 &equo; The Squire had a stud here and built more stables; he fished for trout in the ornamental lakes, grew circular coverts to encourage rabbits, which he loved to shoot, kept harriers and a pack of beagles and of course his favourite hunters &bquo;Assheton&equo;, &bquo;Starlight&equo;, &bquo;Elmhurst&equo;, and &bquo;Shamrock&equo;. 
 He had to sell Ebberston in 1848, thanks to keeping too many racehorses and losing too many bets on them, and he died in London in 1866, cared for in his last years by a kind and well-endowed lady friend called Elizabeth William.  
 pages 83 and 84: photographs 
 1621&ndash;3 BIDDICK Lambton park COUNTY DURHAM 
 SET IN the dipping wooded hills of Lambton Park, through which the wide and tidal Wear cuts a deep valley, this grandest of early Georgian houses looks south down a long wide avenue, smothered solid with daffodils in the spring. 
 Although, in the evening, the orange glow of Newcastle-upon-Tyne hangs in the middle distance and the moan of motorways is blown to the outskirts of its beautiful formal gardens, it remains a peaceful oasis of eighteenth-century civilization, unchanged in its verdant park, beneath which lurk a hundred disused coal pits. 
 Coal had been the making of the Lambton fortunes, and this house, built by a younger son, is part or the lavish evidence. 
 It has little to do with local regional architecture. 
 Even the bricks are Dutch, having been brought back as ballast from Holland after the Lambton coal had been disgorged from their boats. 
 In the summer of 1721, Freville Lambton spent much time at Seaton Delaval, the grandest house in Britain, which Vanbrugh was building. 
 It is possible that the latter drew some plans for Biddick; if he did not, then he had a powerful influence. 
 Where else, in a house of this small size, would you see such an extravagantly bold style and brave proportions? 
 Inside, the bedrooms are nearly fourteen feet high! 
 Here stood an ancient pele tower with a half-timbered Tudor house attached, owned from King Stephen's reign onwards by de Biddics, Daldens, Colleys and Bowes. 
 George Bowes sold it in 1610 to Sir William Lambton, who had two wives and twenty-nine children. 
 He fought for King Charles in the Civil War and was killed at Marston Moor in 1644. 
 By the early 1720s the Lambtons were living in Lambton Castle, a mile westwards, and Freville, a younger son of Sir Thomas Lambton set about building a thoroughly modern house on to the pele tower. 
 (Its walls are so thick that the present Lord and Lady Lambton were able to install two bathrooms in their width.) 
 He brought in Italian plasterers, who were working at Lumley Castle, to decorate his ceilings, and built a wide shallow staircase with elaborate Vanbrughian railings. 
 After the Battle of Culloden, James Drummond, heir to the Duke of Perth, was believed to have drowned while escaping to France. 
 In fact, they say, he hid in the labyrinth of coal pits beside the river in the park. 
 Incognito, he worked as a ferryman and lived in Biddick boat-house for over twenty years, when a terrible flood robbed him of his possessions and his proof of identification. 
 It was his grandson who, in 1831, enlisted the help of a Lambton, who had just been made Earl of Durham, to prove his claim to the Earldom of Perth. 
 It failed. 
 Despite the aggrandizements to Biddick, the house was seldom used by subsequent Lambtons, who were forever increasing their fortunes, their titles and their castle. 
 It was only in 1948 that the family returned.  
 1725 THE OLD RECTORY Holt NORFOLK 
 THE SMALL market town of Holt near the north Norfolk coast was nearly all burned to the ground in just three hours in a terrible fire during the summer of 1706. 
 Over the next two decades it was rebuilt to include many fine Georgian houses and in 1725 the then humble parsonage was given this handsome new front by an unknown architect. 
 Although Georgian architecture is now so popular and so familiar, its introduction must have shocked some people at the time. 
 &bquo;It represents nothing more nor less than the imposition of the temple architecture of an extinct Mediterranean civilization upon the house design of a northern people&equo;, remarks Olive Cook in her English House Through Seven Centuries . 
 &bquo;Not only the members of the small governing class but every squire, tradesman and farmer who could afford to modernize or rebuild his house, even the parson, deputy of Christ, lived behind a fa&ccedil;ade which was conceived in the terms of a Classical Order, entered his home through a doorway deriving from the portico of a pagan shrine and sat at a hearth which resembled a miniature triumphal arch or an altar to the Lares.&equo; 
 The priest's home was usually near the church, it was not until the eighteenth century when services became more infrequent that it was thought proper for the priest to become established in a big house, perhaps on a distant part of the glebe, and live with much of the dignity of a squire. 
 Certainly this rectory with its five bays, its golden stucco and elegant elliptical pediment and fan light has all the grandeur of a small manor, set as it is a little out of the town under a small hanger of beech trees. 
 It is not typically East Anglian but for its black glazed pantiles on the roof which are peculiar to Norfolk. 
 Ordinary pantiles abounded in eastern England where commerce with Holland was strong and they began to be manufactured in Norfolk around the turn of seventeenth century. 
 Glazed tiles, however, were extremely rare, a fact which the great connoisseur of England's fabric, Alec Clifton-Taylor, deemed &bquo;aesthetically lucky&equo;. 
 Glazing was done, in fact, to prevent cracking by frost and when the sky is blue the black tiles turn a deep aquamarine. 
 The exceptionally beautiful garden which surrounds the Rectory was laid out by an enlightened early Victorian encumbent who lined the streams with tufa and planted rare snowdrops and ferns along the banks. 
 Perhaps the only unhappy owner of the Rectory was the Reverend Banks who had an extremely unfortunate affliction of the nose which no doctor could alleviate. 
 A quote from a parishioner in the local newspaper of July 1891 reads, &bquo;All the folks was at church of a Sunday morning and Parson he didn't come. 
 Why for? 
 He had drowned himself in the Rectory pond.&equo; 
 The pond is in the foreground.  
 pages 87 and 88: photographs 
 1725 MANOR FARM West Challow, Stanford in the Vale BERKSHIRE 
 THERE USED to be elms along the lanes around Challow. 
 The old thatched tythe barn which stood end on to Silver Lane just below Manor Farm has now made way for a clutch of modern houses. 
 A second barn, cowsheds and stable were also thatched, together with thirteen cottages with bulging bread ovens visible from the outside, when the Raines family, who still live here, came to the farm from Somerset in 1930. 
 This south fa&ccedil;ade of Manor Farm was built on to an earlier house in 1725. 
 Its segment-headed windows, keystones, parapet and raised centre bay look particularly dramatic beside mud-spattered straggling farm buildings; a large herd of Friesian cows amble along its eastern wall each day at milking times. 
 The house appears mildly surprised but always dignified. 
 A fine oak staircase with barley sugar bannisters leads out of the stone flagged hall and the south-east facing sitting-room is panelled. 
 Over the fireplace is a piece of older panelling, probably rescued from the earlier frontage. 
 It bears the initials R.P. 1604, which stand for Ralph Piggot, whose family arrived in the parish at about this time. 
 Stuart Piggot, the celebrated archaeologist, was a direct descendant and lived in West Challow. 
 In the early eighteenth century the Piggot family decided to modernize their humble and rambling seventeenth-century manor and called in the best local builder, perhaps from Stanford in the Vale, a rather grand village displaying much architectural refinement. 
 Within a radius of ten miles of West Challow there are at least half a dozen houses that look so similar to this that they must surely have been built by the same hand. 
 These include West Hanney Manor, Kingston House at Kingston Bagpuize, Coxe's Hall at Stanford in the Vale and the side elevation of Ardington House. 
 They were all built around the 1720s and all have bold keystones and this dramatic and sometimes swooping raised centre: as though a countrified Vanbrugh or Thomas Archer had been at work. 
 In 1802 the Reverend John Piggot sold the manor, and it passed through Hattons, Agaces, Ferards and Schoolcroft Burtons; from 1901 until 1920 it was the dower house to the widowed Lady Wantage. 
 Across the fields towards the downs is the disused Wilts and Berks Canal. 
 In 1947, when the canal froze, you could skate from here to Abingdon &mdash; nearly ten miles. 
 At Kingston Lisle to the west of Challow is the famous blowing stone used to call men to battle. 
 The poet Francis Rose wrote in 1855 of how King Alfred 
 &hellip; his blow-stone blew. 
 It rent the air, it shook the ground, 
 The well known signal flew. 
 In village, hamlet, house and farm, 
 It summoned every liege to arm, 
 Through Kingston, Lambourn, Sparsholt dale, 
 And all along the hollow vale, 
 It well was heard in Challow. 
 circa 1727 WIDCOMBE MANOR Bath SOMERSET 
 WIDCOMBE IS still a village. 
 Though only a mile from the centre of Bath, it has retained a cohesive feeling, clustered deep into the hills between the wooded slopes of Claverton Down and Combe Down. 
 Up a steep and winding lane, on a small brow beside the church, is Widcombe Manor, which must be one of the very finest small houses in the country. 
 It is a mysterious house, even a little foreign-looking, and certainly resembles nothing in all the long streets and crescents of Bath. 
 It makes the work of the Woods, who designed much of that Georgian city, look quite plain. 
 Many people have written about it. 
 Kerry Downes, in his book English Baroque Architecture , calls this &bquo;an elevation of great distinction&equo;, while Pevsner refers to it as being of &bquo;an elegant design and by an unknown architect,. 
 In fact, this house takes most people's breath away. 
 A Saxon and a Norman chapel stood on the site of the present church, which was built by Prior Cantlow in the last ten years of the fifteenth century. 
 His monks had a grange at Widcombe, and at the Dissolution of the Monasteries the lands were divided, the Prior's Park being sold separately to Humphrey Colles while the Manor House and its estate went to the rich clothier, Richard Chapman, who was mayor and MP for Bath. 
 In 1702 a Miss Chapman, the last in this Chapman line and heiress to Widcombe, married Philip Bennet, and they lived and died at his family home of Maperton, near Wincanton. 
 Their only son, also Philip, decided to come back to his mother's home to live. 
 The rebuilding of the old manor took place over a period of about five years and was probably finished in about 1727. 
 Philip brought his young bride Ann Escourt to his &bquo;new mansion&equo;, as a neighbour described it, but she died within three years at the age of twenty-four and is buried here in the churchyard. 
 He then married Mary Hallam, the heiress of Tollesbury in Essex. 
 She too died young, but left him a son. 
 Philip Bennet the second was a great friend of Ralph Allen, who, having made a fortune beyond realms with his stone quarries, began to build the gigantic Palladian palace in the adjoining Prior's Park. 
 Here he entertained the celebrities of the day, Pope, Warburton, Richardson, Quin and Garrick, who would all have spent time with the local squire of Widcombe. 
 Henry Fielding, whose sister lived at a cottage now called Widcombe Lodge, knew the Bennets well. 
 Squire Western is said to be modelled on Philip Bennet, and the heroine of Tom Jones  on his daughter Ann. 
 Mr Allen was the undoubted original of Mr Allsworthy. 
 Widcombe Manor, with all its crisp carving on pilasters, columns, quoins, swags and urns, is as fresh today as when it was built &mdash; perhaps by the Bath mason Thomas Greenaway as it is a fine display of all the decorative details he could do best.  
 pages 91 and 92: photographs 
 1728 THE OLD RECTORY Whittington LANCASHSHIRE 
 ABOVE THE front door of the old rectory is a plaque carved with a shield of arms inscribed: &bquo;George Hornby Clerk A.M. Rector of Whittington erected this House 1728.&equo; 
 Edmund Hornby of Dalton Hall had bought the living for his second son, and George, being a man of means, decided to upgrade the mean existing rectory to suit his status. 
 The Reverend Thomas Horton came to the Rectory in 1781, put forward by his friend Mr Charteris of Hornby Castle. 
 Among his young parishioners was Whittington's famous son, William Sturgeon, the physicist who lived in the cottage next to the Rectory and befriended the Horton family. 
 Sturgeon's father John was a ne'er-do-well shoemaker, who spent most of his days poaching fish and rearing gamecocks. 
 He married Betsy Adcock, the daughter of a Whittington shopkeeper, and their young William became an apprentice shoemaker in 1796. 
 By the 1830s he was a revered scientist and had invented an electromagnetic coil machine. 
 The upper part of the village of Whittington lies on the south-east slope of a steep hillside. 
 Into the slope a valley has been cut by a little brook called the Selletbeck, which runs past the churchyard and on down to the River Lune. 
 The church of St Michael, with its beautiful early sixteenth-century tower, is built within the bailey of a court castle on this strange hillock which rises from the combe. 
 The Rectory, stands a little below the church on the site of an earlier house, some of which remains under the long lean-to at the back. 
 It has a very local feel with its sandstone dressings, and is rendered in rough cast, a common practice in areas like this where the Silurian stone was weak. 
 The sash windows would have been an extremely new-fangled device in such a remote corner of England. 
 The provinces were reluctant to accept the change from casements, but once they did, the whole look of England's houses changed and the Georgian period of architecture became easily definable. 
 The earliest glazing bars were quite thick, as they were hand cut from solid wood. 
 During the eighteenth century they became thinner and thinner, until in the Regency period they were often only half an inch thick. 
 Measuring its glazing bars is a very good way of dating a house.  
 circa 1730 SEDGEBROOK MANOR Grantham LINCONSHIRE 
 IN THE Domesday Book Sedgebrook is valued at &pound;8, having with it three mills, sixty acres of meadow, and land for nine plough teams. 
 Its owners were then called Malet, subsequently Lords of Eye in Suffolk. 
 From then until the fifteenth century it belonged to de Burghs, de Clares, the Earls of Lincoln, de Lacys, Lestranges, and by the 1300s, when Sir John Talbot lived there, it was already quite an important property. 
 Sir John's daughter married Simon Leake and one of their four daughters married Sir John Markham, Sedgebrook's famous son. 
 Sedgebrook is a pleasant village in the flat, once marshy area a few miles west of Grantham, near the confluence of two rivulets. 
 There is a chalybeate spring just outside the village. 
 &bquo;At Sedgebrook,&equo; wrote Willingham Franklin Rawnsley, &bquo;is a farmhouse which was built as a manor house by Sir John Markham when he was Lord Chief Justice of the King's Bench. 
 He it was who received the soubriquet of &bquo;The Upright Judge'&equo;, on the occasion of his being turned out of office by Edward IV, because of his scrupulous fairness at the trial of Sir Thomas Coke, Lord Mayor of London.&equo; 
 He had in fact saved the lands and life of Sir Thomas, who was charged with supplying money to Margaret of Anjou during the Wars of the Roses and had thus infuriated the king. 
 After his unfair sacking he retired here to Sedgebrook and &bquo;lived a quiet and private life&equo;. 
 This eighteenth-century stone front to the manor tells of another chapter in the house's history. 
 Its formal approach to the north-west of the church, between wide grass borders with their April drifts of daffodils, is the result of the Thorold family's ostentatious display of modern taste. 
 Having properties in Marston and Syston, they bought the manor in 1716, when Sir George Markham decided that he wanted to move and bought an estate in Essex. 
 As soon as John Thorold of Marston had moved into the house he died, leaving no children. 
 A cousin, William Thorold, inherited Sedgebrook, but he died within four years and his son Anthony also died soon afterwards. 
 In 1721 Sir William's half-brother John became baronet, and Sedgebrook's face-lift began. 
 A master builder from Grantham was called in and created this beautiful and extremely unusual combination of local style and Italian Pallazzo architecture, with its forthright piano nobile  and its placement of vases and finials. 
 It is more like a palace than a village manor house. 
 The Thorolds, who still live at Marston, kept Sedgebrook until 1928, after which it reverted to its early life as a farmhouse.  
 page 95: photograph 
 circa 1740 ALDERLY GRANGE Wotton Under Edge GLOUCESTERSHIRE 
 HERE IS the perfect mid-Georgian house. 
 A Bristol merchant, of Quaker origin, called William Springett bought Alderly in the early 1740s and determined to turn what was then a small and jumbled Tudor manor into an up-to-date gentleman's seat. 
 Being a rather mean and frugal man, he employed a local stonemason who was well versed in the designs of the great architects of the day such as James Gibbs. 
 This was probably a man called Michael Sidnell, from Bristol, who had carved a memorial tablet in Alderly Church in 1732, and had later gone on to make designs for the court-house at Westbury on Severn. 
 This west front was thus transformed in the 1740s, with its handsome ashlar face and its dormer windows tucked behind the wide panelled parapet. 
 Inside, a grand and generous staircase rose from a pale stone flagged hall patterned with black stone diamonds. 
 William Springett also built a coach-house for two carriages and loose boxes under a crowning pediment. 
 Whether this was all done in preparation for his wedding is not certain, but in 1744 he married a daughter of Richard Osborne from neighbouring Wortley House. 
 Mr Osborne was the proprietor of the largest of the fifteen woollen mills which wound their wheels in Ozleworth Brook in the valley below. 
 The front porch was added in 1751 after the Springetts had had enough of the south-westerly winds. 
 From the only letter which survives written by William Springett, one can only conclude that he was a rather unpleasant man. 
 It was addressed to the retired rector of Alderly, admonishing him for past ingratitudes &mdash; for not returning a book, for not calling at the Grange when he knew the Springetts to be there. 
 &bquo;So it is,&equo; he ends, &bquo;that when men from low estate are once exalted, they generally are most forgetful of past favours&hellip; which is now become too fashionable, especially with such who cover their guilt with the mask of religion&hellip; 
 I have been and still am (tho' I don't want any of your assistance) Your very humble servant.&equo; 
 (The sad thing is that the rector wrote an apologetic reply.) 
 William Springett died soon after he wrote this letter in 1772, leaving an only daughter, Anne. 
 Alderly has had owners far more distinguished than its Georgian creator. 
 One of Gloucestershire's most famous sons, Sir Mathew Hale, was born in the original house in 1609 &mdash; the much esteemed Lord Chief Justice of Charles II. 
 From 1867 to 1894 Brian Houghton Hodgson, the Indian civil servant, botanist and orientalist, owned Alderly. 
 More recently, the great architectural writer James Lees-Milne lived here with his wife, the well-known garden designer, during the 1950s and 60s.  
 pages 97 and 98: photographs 
 1749 THE OLD RECTORY Farnborough WANTAGE, BERKSHIRE 
 IN THE early 1920s, one of the daughters of the Reverend Puxley who resided at the rectory at that time, was playing on the lawn, then separated from the road by a thick laurel hedge. 
 She heard the almost imperceptible hum of a Rolls-Royce drawing up, then saw the tip of a huge Havana cigar appearing over the hedge, followed by a red face nestling in an astrakhan collar. 
 &bquo;Tell me, who lives in this house?&equo; asked the gentleman. 
 &bquo;Why, my father,&equo; replied Miss Puxley. 
 &bquo;He is the rector, and this is the rectory., 
 &bquo;Good God, I must take holy orders immediately.&equo; 
 Built in 1749 of blue glazed and red bricks in the local &bquo;Wantage&equo; style, it exemplifies the comfortably satisfactory feeling of mid-Georgian domestic architecture. 
 It is also much enhanced by the middle projection of columned porch and bell tower, probably added in about 1840. 
 The chain for ringing the bell runs down the house, through the first floor landing, where it can be pulled if desired, to the hall below. 
 Originally it was used to summon Farnborough children to school, when the latter was housed in the earliest part of the house during the nineteenth century: the low bit on the west side which is now the kitchen. 
 In the 1950s it was rung by my mother to summon my brother and me to meals. 
 Farnborough is the highest village in Berkshire, 720 feet up in the downs, and straddles the most beautiful road in that county which leads &mdash; without a wire or cable to be seen &mdash; through open downland to West Ilsley. 
 From my attic bedroom I thought I surveyed the world. 
 The water for washing had to be Pumped up from a well in the scullery every morning for half an hour before breakfast and the drinking water fetched daily in a bucket from a communal tap in the tiny village street. 
 There was no electricity at the rectory, and every evening my father performed the only domestic task he ever did in his life &mdash; apart from lighting the fires &mdash; when he cleaned the wicks and lit the paraffin lamps. 
 &bquo;In the late afternoon,&equo; wrote Evelyn Waugh in his diaries, &bquo;I went to stay with the Betjemans in a lightless, stuffy, cold poky rectory among beechwoods overlooking Wantage.&equo; 
 &bquo;How very Evelyn,&equo; said my father years later, &bquo;to write so readably and inaccurately.&equo; 
 The present owner of the rectory told me that one thing people notice when they go round the garden is that there are now no garage doors. 
 He removed them when he first came since they would not shut because, as old Mr Abbott the gardener explained, &bquo;not once but twice Mr Betjeman reversed out of the garage without opening the doors, and when charged with stupidity, made the excuse that on both occasions he was wearing a sou'wester.&equo; 
 In the small church across the way there is the most beautiful stained glass window that John Piper ever designed, celebrating his friend the Poet Laureate who worshipped here and lived in this well-loved rectory.  
 circa 1750 THE LAKE HOUSE Frampton Court FRAMPTON ON SEVERN, GLOUCESTERSHIRE 
 THE APPROACH to Frampton on Severn, near to the estuary of that great river, is one of the loveliest and lordliest in England. 
 You bowl along a wide, long and beautiful village green, with great stretches of park and garden wall, overhanging trees, duckponds and scattered houses on either side. 
 It is called Rosamund's Green. 
 The houses and cottages are of brick or half-timbered, and it has more of a feel of the Midlands than of what we imagine as Gloucestershire. 
 The Lake House is not Gloucestershire either! 
 At the time of its building, no one in the district had seen anything like it before. 
 There is an entrance to Frampton Court in the long wall along Rosamund's Green (so called after Fair Rosamund Clifford, who was born at the half-timbered farm across the green and whose co-lateral descendants still live at the court). 
 Richard Clutterbuck, who was an official of the Bristol Customs House, built the beautiful Vanbrughian mansion in the early 1730s and soon afterwards set about glamorizing the garden and grounds. 
 Clutterbuck was obviously very cultivated and very ahead of his time, for this was an early move towards romantic landscaping. 
 The Lake House (sometimes called the Orangery) which stands in the grounds of Frampton Court, was almost certainly designed by William Halfpenny or his son John, who lived near Bristol in the 1740s. 
 Clutterbuck was an architect manqu&eacute; himself and would obviously have seen their pattern books, including the one from which this design derives: Chinese and Gothick Architecture Properly Ornamented . 
 Their contemporary, Batty Langley, advertised in the City and County Builder's Treasury  as being able to &bquo;design and build Grottos, Cascades, Caves, Temples, Pavilions, and other Rural Buildings of Pleasure&hellip; in the Grand Taste&equo;, and this is what the Halfpennys did for Clutterbuck. 
 The Lake House is certainly a rural building of pleasure. 
 It is built at the end of a canal and consists of two perfect octagons connected by a passage hall, behind which is a staircase let into another half octagon at the back. 
 Inside there are waving Gothick-y fireplaces, doors and door surrounds. 
 It is built of stone, and there is a little cupola with Gothic trimmings on the top. 
 The &bquo;ogee&equo; line, which captured the romance of that waving &bquo;line of Beauty&equo; defined by Hogarth, is everywhere. 
 The whole effect is original and has more to do with whim and fantasy, rather than the philosophy and scholarship of the later periods of the Gothic Revival. 
 Mr Clutterbuck died in 1755, leaving no heirs, and the ancient Clifford family have owned the Court and this Orangery ever since. 
 Five unmarried Clifford daughters lingered in this garden under these trees and painted the most exquisite water-colours during the mid-nineteenth century. 
 Their collection of paintings of local flowers was produced as a book called the Frampton Flora .  
 pages 101 and 102: photographs 
 1754 CAME HOUSE Dorchester DORSET 
 CAME'S BEAUTY stems from being built in the palest of pale Portland stone, arguably the finest building stone in Britain, quarried over the down a few miles towards the sea. 
 It is also the obvious masterpiece of its Dorset architect, Francis Cartwright, on whose monument in Blandford St Mary Church are carved a T-square, dividers, a rule and a scroll on which is incised an elevation of Came House. 
 Just out of sight and sound of Dorchester lies a quiet park on whose rising ground the Palladian house stands, built all of a piece in 1754, though not to the mansion proportions its creator could have well afforded. 
 It is still lived in by the direct descendant of Sir John Damer, who was perhaps so appalled by the building programme of his brother, Viscount Milton, first Earl of Dorchester, at Milton Abbas, that he vowed to build a small house for himself. 
 (Viscount Milton caused a considerable rumpus when he razed a small market town to the ground and rebuilt the now much admired model village of Milton Abbas. 
 Though Came, with its moderate, manor house proportions, may seem on the small side to be set so grandly in a park, Sir John Damer certainly didn't skimp on employing the very best craftsmen in all London. 
 The present drawing-room, which runs the length of the three central ground floor windows and used to be the entrance hall (until the 1840 addition on the west side was made), must have stunned the neighbours with its sumptuousness. 
 First impressions were all-important to the cultivated Georgian gentleman &mdash; the long meandering drive to display the land, the rich pedimented pillars to display the learning and quality of the owner, and then the entrance hall. 
 A fine gold garland of flowers winds wildly in plasterwork around geometric patterns on the ceiling, gold and white Corinthian columns flank the grand double doors, and paintings of Greek friezes by Cipriani surmount the overdoors. 
 This house is aristocratic Georgian to the hilt, and its ostentatious splendour makes the same impact now as then. 
 The eighteenth century may dominate this grassy rise, but just to the east, under the trees, there is the simple thirteenth-century village church where Came's famous son, the Reverend William Barnes, was rector. 
 He is buried in the churchyard, and Thomas Hardy and Mr Gosse visited the Dorset poet on his deathbed in the rectory in 1886. 
 &bquo;It is curious that he is dying as picturesquely as he lived,&equo; wrote Mr Gosse. 
 &bquo;We found him in bed in his study, his face turned to the window, where the sun came streaming in through flowering plants&hellip; 
 He had a scarlet bedgown on, a kind of soft biretta of dark red wool on his head, from which his long white hair escaped on to the pillow; his grey beard, grown very long upon his breast&hellip; 
 &equo; On walking home it is doubtful that the companions gave a second glance at Came house, described ten years later by Sir Frederick Treves in Highways and Byways of Dorset  as &bquo;an unattractive mansion in what is called the' &bquo;classic'&equo; taste'.  
 circa 1760 CHURCH FARM Stanton Lacy SHROPSHIRE 
 WINDING DOWN the road from Culmington to Bromfield, in the valley of the River Corve you see Church Farm rising above the river in its rich red brick with rooks wheeling above and the steep Stanton Lacy Wood behind. 
 When the river is in flood and the &bquo;Mill Meadow&equo; in front of the house is under water, the only way to reach the village from here is to use the flood path, which crosses right next to the farm on flood boards, spanning the gap between the churchyard and farmyard wall. 
 Much of the village, the church, farm and the surrounding land of Stanton Lacy has long belonged to the Oakly Park estate, whose mansion lies two miles south on the River Teme. 
 An earlier farm stood here beside the Norman church until the new owner of Oakly built a smart new farm around a small Tudor building. 
 It was Lord Clive of India who bought the estate in 1760 from Lord Herbert (he had already acquired the Walcot estate to add to his patrimony of Styche), and directed his agent to improve the whole property. 
 Church Farm has been tenanted ever since, and from Clives, through marriages to the Earls of Powis, it came and still belongs to the Earls of Plymouth. 
 The John family were tenants for two generations around the turn of this century and ran a hauliers business from the farm, where they stabled thirty or more shire horses. 
 There are three staircases in the house, including a great one of oak which leads right up to the second floor, where the rooms are spacious &mdash; not designed for servants &mdash; and the views stretch to the Long Mynd. 
 The house is tall, like so many Georgian Shropshire houses, and was probably built by a man from Ludlow. 
 Its garden appears to have taken in some of the once circular churchyard, now famous for its snowdrops. 
 Perhaps the most famous incumbent of Stanton Lacy is poor Robert Foulkes, who was one of the very few clergymen ever to have been executed for murder. 
 After eighteen years of respected service in the parish he caused a scandal by having an affair with a young woman who was placed under his roof. 
 After murdering the resulting child he was hanged in London in January 1679.  
 page 105: photograph 
 1764 DORMINGTON HOUSE Dormington HEREFORDSHIRE 
 UNTIL 1963, when it was sold by the Church, Dormington House was always the rectory. 
 Its tallness, reminiscent of a town house, tells more of Shropshire and Wales than of Herefordshire. 
 Built of brick in 1764, the rectory was whitewashed at the time, in order to match the small church of St Peter standing beside, also white-washed to enliven its poor-looking rubble walls. 
 The picking out in black paint of the window surrounds and pediment was also instigated by the Georgian rector, and is very much in the Welsh tradition. 
 Nonetheless it fits in beautifully with the black and white timber-framed houses and cottages which are so much part of the county. 
 The sloping wings were originally squared off and must have made the house look even taller. 
 In 1763 the Reverend Thomas Whickens wrote to Bishop James in Hereford informing him that his rectory at Dormington was in a ruinous condition and asking his permission to build a new one. 
 On 17 April 1764, he finally got the go-ahead, providing of course that the new building was erected as economically as possible. 
 Some of the older building was retained at the back and several of the better quality timbers were re-used in the new house. 
 The Reverend Whickens ended up with a smart little house whose roof was as high as that of St Peter's and which comprised a hall, a small parlour and a large parlour, a study, kitchen, dairy and brewhouse, four bedchambers and two small rooms in the garret. 
 After the Reverend Whickens came the Reverends Gwillam, Price and Jenning, and in 1840, when the Reverend Lee was in charge, the village is recorded as having 148 inhabitants, and &bquo;The living&hellip; endowed with the rectorial tithes, with the perpetual curacy of Bartestree united, and valued in the King's books at &pound;4. 6s. 8d.; present net income, &pound;284.&equo; 
 Then came the Reverends Brown and Cope, and it was the latter who in 1877 witnessed the radical and excessive restoration of the ancient whitewashed church to produce what from a distance looks almost totally Victorian with its new little lead-covered spire and shingled bell turret. 
 However, when you get closer, the place feels as ancient as it must be, for the village is of Saxon origin, and has an Iron Age fort. 
 The church door has a beautiful Norman doorknocker in the form of the head of a feline animal, and there is an interesting American organ, installed in 1924, which can be taken to bits and transported with ease. 
 In the garden of the former rectory are the graves of the Reverend Cope's dogs, with headstones inscribed with the names of &bquo;Black Puffin' and &bquo;Toby.&equo;  
 pages 107 and 108: photographs 
 circa 1775 MIDFORD CASTLE Bath SOMERSET 
 MIDFORD CASTLE epitomizes the Romantic Movement in architecture. 
 This was our very own English movement, which many classical purists abhor and consider mere frippery. 
 It did not look abroad for its inspirations. 
 Instead it looked to our medieval buildings, our castles and churches, and to the wilds of Westmorland. 
 There is no referring back to Vitruvius here. 
 Henry Woolhouse Disney Roebuck was a notorious gambler who lived in Bath. 
 The accounts of his card games are sensational, but the most legendary was when, during a game of vingt-et-un , his life depended on the turn of a single card. 
 That card was the ace of clubs and Mr Roebuck won a fortune. 
 Midford Castle is a celebration of that card, for it is built to the same shape, with two rounded leaves of the trefoil facing out across the valley over Cane Brook and Midford Brook, and the third out to the back. 
 The site is suitably romantic, on its precipitous hillside above the small village of Midford, with a bold projecting terrace around it from which the views down the vale to distant hills are still as picturesque as they always were. 
 Mr Roebuck employed the antiquarian draughtsman and architect John Carter to design the castle, probably after he had seen a design for &bquo;a Gothic Mansion&equo; by the latter, published in the Builder's Magazine . 
 Carter had worked under James Wyatt, one of the first professional architects to recognize the Gothic style in the eighteenth century. 
 Whether or not he supervised the building is unknown, but in 1775, when it was begun, the city of Bath must have provided the best builders and craftsmen in the country. 
 They produced a castellated Gothic castle which is unmatched. 
 There are peep-hole quatrefoils in the parapet, ogee mouldings over the windows, and the most wonderful plasterwork imaginable inside. 
 The main stone stair climbs spirally between two towers, and on each floor there are three half rounded rooms, leaving a squarish hall in the centre with landings above. 
 Thomas Stocking produced the rococo plasterwork in all the main rooms, and in the eastern bedroom on the first floor there are plaster birds flying overhead. 
 The effect inside Midford Castle is light, airy, elegant and essentially Georgian. 
 Tastes change, however, and the Reverend Richard Warner, writing about Midford in his Excursions from Bath  in 1801, describes it as &bquo;an anomaly in building equally at war with taste and comfort&equo;!  
 1778 THE CASTLE Sledmere YORKSHIRE 
 SLEDMERE IS the most beautiful and the most important agricultural estate in northeast England. 
 In the 1770s Sir Christopher Sykes literally &bquo;clothed the wolds&equo;, a bleak stretch of land 500 feet above sea level, and set an example of how to plant trees and how to create farmland which has never been surpassed. 
 At twenty-one he had married Elizabeth Egerton of Tatton and become the tenant of Sledmere for life. 
 Having planted avenues and pleasure grounds around the house, he then set about the building of farms and the planting of woods. 
 He employed &bquo;the Great Brown &lsqb;better known as &bquo;Capability&equo;, who&rsqb;&hellip; came to Sledmere early in the morning,&equo; as the meticulously efficient Sir Christopher recorded on Thursday 18 September 1777. 
 The two rode about the parish together, and after a second visit Mr Brown produced a planting plan and a bill for &pound;73.10s. 
 In fact Sir Christopher only used the plan for guidance and much of the one thousand acres of trees that he planted was the result of his own great vision. 
 The new farmsteads were being built at the same time, set snugly into shelter belts of oak, beech and elm, nursed up by Scots pines. 
 Sir Christopher designed most of the buildings himself, but left the design of &bquo;The Castle, to the terrifically fashionable architect John Carr of York, who had been taken up by the Yorkshire gentry after his triumph with the design for the grandstand on the racecourse at Knavesmire. 
 The Castle was built as an &bquo;eye catcher&equo;, to be glimpsed from the library window of Sledmere, as though some forgotten castle had been crumbling in its wood for centuries. 
 This was a typically fashionable thing to do at this the height of the &bquo;Picturesque Movement&equo;, when romantic thoughts could be conjured in an instant by the sight of a castle, but the reality was of course a different matter. 
 Although castellated and towered at the front, the Castle is in fact a perfectly ordinary farmhouse behind the fa&ccedil;ade, and its rear elevation is plain and workmanlike. 
 When Sir Christopher's farms were first built on the high and, in those days, bleak land, with as yet little protection from the wind, the farm buildings were arranged, as here at the Castle, around a courtyard at the back of the house. 
 Another essential element of all the farms was the digging of a dew-pond, for there was no natural source of water. 
 Sir Christopher saw that the &bquo;very important art&equo; of pond-making was well carried out. 
 The castle pond is extremely large, and still never runs dry.  
 pages 111 and 112: photographs 
 1785 SHOTESHAM Norwich NORFOLK 
 SHOTESHAM IS unaltered; it is as though it were built yesterday. 
 &bquo;The House is fronted with white bricks of the best quality,&equo; wrote Sir John Soane, its architect, in 1788, &bquo;the steps, window dressings, cornices etc are chiefly of Portland Stone, and the capitals to the pilasters are of Coade's manufactury. 
 The principal floor is raised about two and a half feet. 
 By four steps you ascend the vestibule, on the right of which is the eating-room, and on the left the withdrawing-room; a small cabinet communicates with the withdrawing-room to the library; beyond the library is a justice-room; the best stair-case is placed in the centre of the house, and lighted with a large Venetian window; the common staircase adjoins the offices.&equo; 
 Sir John Soane was miles ahead of his time. 
 While other architects were falling under the Greek or Gothic spell, he steered his clear uncluttered course amid shallow domes and slow arches. 
 Soane was born in Goring on Thames, where his father was a bricklayer and he began his career as an errand-boy. 
 He finished up as one of Britain's greatest and most original architects. 
 Robert Fellowes commissioned Soane, who was building several houses in East Anglia at that time, to design his family seat in willowy country just south of Norwich near Shotesham All Saints, a village with a winding stream and Dutch gabled cottages. 
 It took three years to build, starting in 1785. 
 The Fellowes family continued to live here until 1979. 
 Soane's houses were always amazingly practical for their time. 
 His own notes on the plans for Shotesham indicate his great attention to detail: &bquo;Particular care must be taken in finishing the floor of the Nursery etc to prevent any Noise being heard on the Principal Floor.&equo; 
 In his introduction to the published plans of this and some of his other early houses he writes, &bquo;Ornaments are to be cautiously introduced; those ought only to be used that are simple, applicable and characteristic of their situations: they must be designed with regularity and be perfectly distinct in their outlines&hellip; 
 &equo; At Shotesham there are delicate plaster ceilings and a frieze of wheat-ears and hops in the entrance hall, which told of Robert Fellowes' surrounding acres. 
 Soane concludes, &bquo;I have been more anxious to produce utility in the plans than to display expensive architecture in the elevations; the leading objects were to unite convenience and comfort in the interior distributions, and simplicity and uniformity in the exterior.,  
 1801 LECK HALL Kirby Lonsdale LANCASHIRE 
 HERE IN the most eastern tip of Lancashire, wedged between Westmorland and Yorkshire, where Leck Fell rises two thousand feet into the Pennine chain and no roads cross, the small village of Leck sits snugly amongst lush trees, as remote and beautiful as anywhere in England. 
 Through the park, landscaped in the eighteenth century, the River Lune winds along its spectacular valley &mdash; a valley that played such an important role in the Romantic Movement. 
 In the 1760s the Lake District with its rugged and dramatic scenery began to be all the rage with artists of all sorts, and in their wake, as usual, the dilettanti rich followed limply behind, thinking there must be something in this search for the sublime through unadulterated nature. 
 Below the Lakes, the Lune valley too afforded all that was truly picturesque. 
 Gray and Mason wrote about it, Mrs Radcliffe raved about it, Turner painted it. 
 Robert Welch, a merchant from Liverpool, decided to buy a bit of it. 
 He had made a fortune out of the slave trade and wanted to spend it on land. 
 Leck was then an area of bare moorland with the occasional huddled hill farm, and in the true eighteenth-century manner of fashionable landscapers like Brown, Welch planted trees in clumps and woods to create the most beautiful park. 
 He had no interest in the architecture of what was then merely a rather dull manor house, but kept on improving the estate, which was to give pleasure to the Welch family until the Second World War. 
 It was Robert Welch's son George who decided to improve the house. 
 In 1801 he wrapped the plain and pleasing ashlar face around what little he decided to retain of the earlier house. 
 He employed the Staffordshire architect John Webb, a landscape gardener at heart, who had done a lot of work locally and came highly recommended. 
 His landscaping at Quernmore Park near Lancaster had been a great success, as was his probable design for Casterton Hall near Kirkby Lonsdale, which looks uncommonly like Leck. 
 Many of the specimen trees which are still in the park were almost certainly planted by Webb at the time, and the elegant arched orangery in the garden must have been built to his designs. 
 Inside Leck Hall, Webb took full advantage of the very high quality mahogany joinery which was available at that time in Lancaster. 
 There are still exquisite doors and bookcases all over the house &mdash; probably from the firm of Gillows, who were the leading mahogany importers in the north-west of England. 
 Leck Hall displays the perfect late Georgian style, plain, simple and pleasing. 
 There is nothing bored or heavy about it, unlike many houses of this period. 
 It marks the end of an era, and although neo-classicism was re-interpreted by the Regency architects, it was never again so unassuming and unselfconscious. 
 Inside, Webb's work was altered a little in the 1830s by George's son, Robert Henry, who chose to replace the staircase.  
 pages 115 and 116: photograph and blank 
 REGENCY 
 By the beginning of the nineteenth century houses had reached their greatest simplicity and were often stuccoed and painted. 
 There was a strong and pure Greek revival which happened as a result of contemporary scholars studying Greek antiquities, and which produced severe and masculine architecture. 
 Alongside this there was a great crescendo of the Picturesque Movement with its cottages orn&eacute;es  and feminine forays into fancy Gothic and even Oriental forms.  
 1805 SANDRIDGE Stoke Gabriel DEVONSHIRE 
 SANDRIDGE PARK commands the most spectacular views imaginable. 
 It sits amid wide lawns and giant cedar trees high above the eastern banks of the wide and winding River Dart. 
 To the south you look down the steeply falling park to where the river slowly bends around Dittisham on the western bank, and to the west a view cut through the trees shows the river almost encircling the Sandridge promontory, its last wide stretch before it narrows upstream to Totnes. 
 By 1805, when Lord Ashburton's widow commissioned John Nash to design her country retreat, he was a highly fashionable architect. 
 Though his first beginnings in London as a speculative builder had ended in bankruptcy, he removed to Wales and began afresh. 
 It was through his shortlived partner, Humphrey Repton, that Nash made his reputation in society. 
 In the 1790s he was commissioned to build a conservatory for the Prince of Wales, which marked the beginning of a renowned Royal patronage culminating in the building of Regent's Park and the Brighton Pavilion. 
 Twenty years earlier, the word &bquo;picturesque&equo; had been formally introduced into the vocabulary of society by one of the movement's staunchest supporters, William Gilpin. 
 Gilpin was a schoolmaster and the vicar of Boldre in Hampshire, who spent his holidays sketching romantic countryside all over Britain. 
 &bquo;The rules of picturesque beauty,&equo; he wrote, &bquo;are drawn from nature&hellip; all the formalities of hedge-row trees, and square divisions of property, are disgusting to a high degree.&equo; 
 He suggested that cattle grazing in the ideal landscape should be any other colour than black and white, &bquo;which make together the most inharmonious of all mixtures&equo;. 
 Gilpin's theories on the return to pastoralism had a profound effect on his contemporaries, and from them, together with much sentimental theory from Sir Uvedale Price and Richard Payne Knight, a distinctly picturesque architecture evolved. 
 Nash was a forerunner. 
 He was witty and imaginative beyond all other architects of his day. 
 Many tried to imitate him, but none had his quirky genius. 
 His cottages at Blaize Hamlet blazed a trail for a hundred years. 
 At Sandridge an extensive orangery took up most of the southern fa&ccedil;ade ingeniously masking the servants' wing. 
 It had fourteen fat Egyptian columns supporting the flat roof, and floor-length windows between. 
 It has now been replaced by a new colonnade. 
 Inside, the drawing-room and dining-room are of different shapes, with long windows angled deliberately to catch the two main views of the estuary. 
 The main bedroom has balconies over the west-facing stone loggia and the bay window of the drawing-room. 
 The decorative details inside are restrained and classical compared with the jolly and jumbled exterior. 
 The plain staircase is lit by a lantern in the Soane style.  
 1808&ndash;9 LETHERINGSETT Holt NORFOLK 
 HERE IS an example of the most masculine Regency taste. 
 During the Napoleonic Wars, when people couldn't go abroad, they became more preoccupied with architectural styles. 
 The interest in Greece had started in the 1750s but reached a great climax in 1820. 
 It had to do with romance and adventure, with Lord Byron and Lord Elgin, with archaeology and theory. 
 The Society of Dilettanti, a dining club for Grand Tourists, looked beyond Italy to the fresh challenge of Greece. 
 William Hardy, a Methodist maltster, was swept up on the Greek Revival wave. 
 He bought the eighteenth-century Letheringsett Hall from the Breretons, and in 1808 engulfed it in Greece, adding this south front of giant Doric columns, which were an exact copy of the temple of Delos on Isis. 
 &bquo;Uncle&equo; Hardy had no direct heir, but left Letheringsett to his sister's son, who was called William Hardy Cozens. 
 The latter studied law, became Master of the Rolls and was made Lord Cozens-Hardy, 
 &hellip; 
 And even in the summer, 
 On a bright East Anglia day 
 When round your doric portico 
 Your children's children play 
 There's a something in the stillness 
 And your waiting eyes are drawn 
 From the butler and the footman 
 Bringing tea out on the lawn, 
 From the little silver spirit lamp 
 That burns so blue and still, 
 To the half seen mausoleum 
 In the oak trees on the hill. 
 But when, Lord Cozens Hardy, 
 November stars are bright, 
 And the Kings Head Inn at Letheringsett 
 Is shutting for the night, 
 The villagers have told me 
 That they do not like to pass 
 Near your curious mausoleum 
 Moon-shadowed on the grass 
 For fear of seeing walking 
 In the season of All Souls, 
 That first Lord Cozens Hardy, 
 The Master of the Rolls. 
 John Betjeman 
 pages 121 and 122 photographs 
 circa 1810 FOREST HOUSE Chigwell ESSEX 
 The Times  of 8 June 1838 ran the following advertisement: &bquo;To be let, furnished or unfurnished, Forest House, Chigwell, twelve miles from the City. 
 The house is beautifully situate, in its own grounds, on the verge of the Hainault Forest, commanding unrivalled views over the counties of Essex and Kent and possesses all the requisite accommodation for a family of respectability. 
 Attached are flower, fruit and kitchen gardens, extensive lawn, conservatory etc.: detached double coach house, stabling for eight horses with loose boxes, brew house, entrance lodge, farm buildings and gardener's cottage with about 15 acres of land, and extensive forest rights whereby the tenant is enabled to rear stock free of expense. 
 To a gentleman fond of sporting, or a family desirous of a truly elegant abode within a moderate distance of town an opportunity such as the present rarely occurs&hellip;, 
 Forest House is ever &bquo;truly elegant&equo;, high on its windy hill. 
 You can see over Epping Forest to High Beach church, over Shooter's Hill to the South Downs, and on a clear day, down the shining ribbon of the Thames you can see St Paul's cathedral. 
 Here in the verdant environs of Forest House is unchanged rural Essex. 
 The elms down Vicarage Lane which once hid the tiny entrance lodge may have long since gone, and the distant kitchen garden contain only Bermudan style bungalows within its walls, but the high Regency atmosphere still remains. 
 The house was almost certainly designed by the popular Regency architect John Papworth, who did much work in Chigwell, for several different clients. 
 Papworth was both a prolific and multifarious designer. 
 He was a prot&eacute;g&eacute; of Sir William Chambers, who saw to it that he worked in every artistic department, including that of interior decoration, before he designed his first house at the age of eighteen. 
 He went on to write many books, such as Architectural Hints  and Hints on Ornamental Gardening , which were invaluable to aspiring &bquo;men of taste&equo;, and on being acclaimed as a second Michelangelo by his friends because he drew so well, he made &bquo;Buonarroti&equo; his middle name. 
 Forest House, with its perfect wrought-iron double-decker verandah, its octagonal dairy and pretty pedimented stables and coach-house close by, was commissioned by an undoubted &bquo;man of Taste&equo;, possibly Sir David Wedderburn, who is recorded as building his house at Chigwell between 1807 and 1810. 
 Benjamin Cotton replied to the Times  advertisement and undertook to &bquo;preserve the mahogany doors (still in fine fettle), to turn the pantry and store room into a servants&equo; hall, and the brew house and cart stable into loose boxes.&equo; 
 Cotton's nephew William or &bquo;son&equo; as he called him (for he had no children), was a close friend of Doctor Livingstone, who was brought to stay at Forest House in the 1860s. 
 By this time the tiny west wing of the villa had been removed to make way for a gigantic conservatory, which has since disappeared.  
 circa 1810 POMFRET LODGE Hulcote NORTHAMPTONSHIRE 
 JUST BEYOND the flower and orchard filled walled gardens of Easton Neston (one of England's greatest and most noble houses) stands Pomfret Lodge, which was originally built as a dower house for the widowed Countesses of Pomfret. 
 It looks out across wide lawns to mild uneventful Northamptonshire countryside, and the private road which runs in front of it winds down into Hulcote, a beauti &mdash; ful horseshoe-shaped model village built around a generous green. 
 It is known locally as &bquo;Chapel Village&equo;, because the Gothic windows of the cottages have a mildly methodist look. 
 If Letheringsett is masculine, then Pomfret Lodge epitomizes the feminine branch of the Regency Gothic taste. 
 Very much in the spirit of the age, the hall, dining-room and drawingroom all open into each other with great double doors, so that you could entertain on a grand scale. 
 There is a lightness of touch in the Gothic tracery in the windows (although it is made of cast iron!) and the barge boarding in the central gable is almost like lace compared with the later and heavier Victorian sort. 
 Henrietta Louisa, Countess of Pomfret, after whom the house is named, was so utterly besotted with the Gothic taste that she even thought of encasing Hawksmoor's classical Easton Neston in the style. 
 Although only the vestiges of her original Pomfret Lodge lie behind this Regency update, it was her obsession with the Gothic that lingered on and produced this pale pink confection. 
 Lady Pomfret had been an excellent wife and mother and an efficient Lady of the Bedchamber, but she exposed herself to constant ridicule in society because she was so desperate to be thought of as a learned woman. 
 Horace Walpole described her as having a &bquo;paltry air of significant learning and absurdity&equo;, and added that she was so totally lacking in humour that &bquo;she repined when she should laugh and reasoned when she should be diverted&equo;. 
 This was particularly sad, considering that it must have been Walpole whom she idolized and wanted to imitate, for it was he who built Strawberry Hill. 
 Later in the nineteenth century the Lodge became the rectory for St Mary's Church of Easton Neston, which it remained until the 1880s. 
 During the last war it was requisitioned by the Navy. 
 Now it has reverted to being the Dower House.  
 pages 125 and 126: photographs 
 1815 SHERINGHAM HALL Sheringham NORFOLK 
 SHERINGHAM IS middle-of-the-road Regency. 
 In 1811 Abbot and Charlotte Upcher, while staying at Yarmouth, saw and fell for a farm which was being sold by Cook Flower. 
 The attorney they instructed to draw up a sales contract was William Repton of Aylsham, the third son of Humphry Repton, the famous landscape architect. 
 The obvious introductions were made, and what ensued was to bring more pleasure to Repton than any job he had ever done &mdash; &bquo;such a specimen of my art,&equo; he wrote of his work at Sheringham, &bquo;as I never before had the opportunity of displaying&equo;. 
 Repton was born at Sustead, five miles away, and had long known and loved Mr Flower's beautiful property at Sheringham which so enchanted the Upchers. 
 &bquo;What infinite variety presents itself in this enchanting spot,&equo; wrote Abbot in his diary on first seeing it. 
 &bquo;What walks with my dear wife and little ones! 
 What a spot to educate them and teach them, to the best of my humble and weak abilities, their duty towards God and fellow creatures.&equo; 
 On 10 July 1811, Abbot Upcher signed the contract and handed over &pound;52,000. 
 In June 1812, Humphry Repton made a five-day visit to Upper Sheringham and discussed plans and ideas with the delightful Upchers &bquo;such a hopeful and enthusiastic young couple, motivated by high ideals and deep religious conviction&equo;. 
 (Charlotte was the daughter of the Reverend Henry Wilson of Kirby Kane.) 
 A month later Repton produced one of his famous Red Books, heavily laced with pastoral philosophy to appeal to the Upchers. 
 Abbot was knocked sideways with delight, and wrote to Repton, &bquo;I am like the possessor of some gem of inestimable value and beauty, concealed in a casket&hellip;. 
 You have presented me with the key, and I now perceive all of its hitherto latent beauties.&equo; 
 The site chosen for the house was in a wooded grove, sheltered from northerly gales and half a mile from the sea. 
 They chose bricks of a pale biscuit-coloured variety which were brought by sea from Lincolnshire. 
 The Upchers did not want anything elaborate, and although Repton had been famous for castellated picturesqueness, here was the perfect chance to create simple neo-classicism, which was all he secretly cared for and the conventional essence of those first twenty years of the nineteenth century. 
 He told the Upchers he wanted to &bquo;unite comfort and convenience with elegance but without extravagance&equo;. 
 They had requested of him a single large living room, an ample eating room and &bquo;no useless drawingroom&equo;. 
 The interior is as Repton had promised, simple and elegant with a brilliantly convenient tripartite bedroom for Charlotte, &bquo;the lady's own room or boudoir, connected with the wardrobe&hellip; and having a d&eacute;gagement  or private stairs&equo;. 
 Walls were painted lime green and lilac. 
 Years later Emma Upcher wrote of her parents, &bquo;They found a spot they thought a paradise and there they began to build their &bquo;bower'&equo;.' 
 Sadly, Abbot died of a brain haemorrhage, before the house was completed.  
 1821 SUTTON ON THE HILL HALL Derby DERBYSHIRE 
 YOU CAN see the ninety feet high Victorian church spire of St Michael (extreme right) a mile away on a small hill, below which lies the unassuming village of Sutton. 
 The hall, settled in the lee of two gentle slopes on a narrow road leading westward out of the main street is not in the least unassuming! 
 Here is an example of the Regency Gothic style taken to the limit. 
 You might expect to find a house like this in some refined seaside resort such as Budleigh Salterton or Sidmouth, where, owing to the wars and consequent lack of foreign travel, the nobility and even a Royal or two were building elaborate holiday houses. 
 The Reverend Richard Rowland Ward, who built the hall in 1821, must have been a desperately romantic character. 
 There was always a modest manor at Sutton, held at the time of the Domesday survey by Henry de Ferrers, then by the Boschervilles, who gave it to the Priory of Trentham. 
 In 1291 a rectory stood here, valued in that year at &pound;10 13s 4d. 
 After the Dissolution of the Monasteries the estate and rectory came to the Sleigh family in the early seventeenth century, and among other Sleigh family memorials in the chancel of St Michael's is a remarkable Jacobean monument of a black coffin, instead of an effigy, in memory of Judith, first wife of Sir Samuel Sleigh. 
 Sir Samuel married three times, but sadly all his three sons died within his lifetime. 
 The Sutton estate with its rectory then fell to his two daughters, Margaret by his second wife and Mary by his third (born posthumously to Sir Samuel who was eighty-two years old when he died!). 
 Margaret was married to James Chetham and Mary to Rowland Cotton. 
 The Chethams ran out of heirs and in 1819 so did the Cottons, with the death of William Cotton. 
 So the property passed to his eldest sister's son the Reverend Richard Rowland Ward and it was he and Mrs Ward who lived out their architectural fantasies. 
 Apart from spending a lot of money on the church, they built this house, where once stood a meagre rectory, and called it &bquo;Sutton on the Hill Hall&equo;. 
 Built of brick and stone, it was once plastered all over, but now only partly so. 
 From the birth of this form of Gothic in the 1740s to its final swan-song in the 1830s, the feeling of romance was ever strong &mdash; here castellations, quatrefoil windows, octagonal turrets, even castellated chimneys and, inside, a wonderful vaulted dining-room all added to the charm. 
 What distinguishes Regency houses perhaps most of all is the elaborate use of ironwork, which architects were just beginning to think of using as a matter of course. 
 It had become easier to fashion and cheaper to use. 
 The Wards' only daughter became heiress of Sutton on the Hill Hall, and married a Reverend German Buxton. 
 (Their descendants, who still live here, changed the spelling to Buckston.) 
 On 19 June 1841 the spire of St Michael's was struck by lightning so severely that it had to be taken down and rebuilt at a cost of &pound;84, paid for by the Buxtons.  
 pages 129 and 130: photographs 
 1827 SIBTON PARK Yoxford SUFFOLK 
 THERE IS a haunted road which curls round Sibton Park to Sibton Green. 
 On the bank are the grass graves of two gypsies who are supposed to have fought together till both were killed. 
 This parish has a strange park-like quality, where a ruined abbey, founded in 1150, lies tantalizingly buried in ivy beside the River Minsmere, which further downstream meanders through the gentle wooded park of Sibton. 
 Before the house it widens into a mere where hundreds of Canada geese gather. 
 You dip down the drive from the Yoxford to Peasenhall road across an ornamental bridge and on towards this plain and golden Greek Revival house. 
 The porch is a semicircle of giant Ionic columns running the full height of the house. 
 They are very surprising and daring. 
 Sibton was built in 1827 atthe tail end of this pure and severe period of architecture of which William Wilkins, who built Grange Park, and the Northumbrian architect John Dobson were past masters. 
 The style was a perfect foil to the fripperies of the cottage orn&eacute;  and displayed the serious character of its commissioner, Robert Sayer, who had just bought this large property and wanted to live in a modern house rather than the older one by the abbey ruins. 
 By the end of the Regency period, England had produced and patented many different types of external rendering, which today is generally referred to as stucco. 
 Building materials were scarce and expensive in the first decades of the nineteenth century, and stucco could cover a multitude of sins, including poor stone or brickwork. 
 Sibton displays Parker's Roman cement, which was patented in 1796 and which Nash used on most of his buildings. 
 The process involved the burning of nodules of calciferous clay to form a cement which was strong and durable and could withstand damp. 
 Mr J.W. Brooke bought Sibton in the 1850s. 
 His family woollen business was founded in 1541 and is believed to be the oldest family business of its kind in the world.  
 circa 1830 BRIDEHEAD Little Bredy DORSET 
 DAVID INSHAW'S painting of &bquo;The Cricket Game&equo; in the lazy valley of the River Bride might make the fat green chalk hills around look too good to be true. 
 His paintbrush does not lie &mdash; this countryside is idyllic. 
 Just out of the sound of the sea, it is as verdant and gently rolling as Mr Inshaw's image. 
 Bridehead lives for cricket. 
 No summer Sunday goes by without a game. 
 Elizabeth Lady Williams, mother of the present baronet, used to field her own XI. 
 In the 1850s a wing was added to the house (which has since been neatly demolished), with twenty-two bedrooms. 
 This was to enable a whole cricket team to stay here with their valets. 
 The Williams family have been here since 1797, when Robert Williams bought the manor of Littlebredy, which had long since degenerated into a farmhouse. 
 Robert's father came from the Williams family of Herringstone, near Dorchester, and was disinherited for marrying beneath him. 
 Robert was sent as an apprentice to an upholsterer in Covent Garden at the age of fourteen, progressed up the ladder, bought the business, and became a big wheel in the East India Company, a founder of Williams &amp; Glyn Bank and the local MP. 
 It was Robert's son, also a banker and MP, who in the early 1830s set about dressing up the newly named Bridehead, making a lake beside it and a complete &bquo;model village&equo; at Little Bredy. 
 His widowed mother Jane had a strong hand in all this and, being a pious Christian until the end (she died aged 102 in 1841), was the perfect benevolent matriarch. 
 Nikolaus Pevsner did not much like Bridehead's rather whacky Tudor style, referring to it in his Buildings of England  as &bquo;excruciatingly awkward&equo;. 
 It is predominantly the work of P.F. Robinson, a popular architect of the time who specialized in the &bquo;Picturesque&equo; and could translate your dream with ease. 
 After more than a century of classical architecture, the mainstream of which became plainer and duller towards the end of the Georges, it is no wonder that the second Sir Robert wanted to go &bquo;Tudor&equo;. 
 That was what he chose from Robinson's wide repertoire, which included &bquo;Swiss Chalet&equo; style and even &bquo;Norman&equo;. 
 Robinson still treated Sir Uvedale Price's Essay on the Picturesque , written in 1798, as his yardstick of propriety. 
 &bquo;It is written with the truest feeling for the subject upon which he treats, as compared with the sublime and beautiful, and with an earnest recommendation to those who are about to improve real landscapes to study the paintings of old masters,&equo; he wrote. 
 &bquo;The Old English Style&equo; he favoured most was seldom so well displayed as here and in the Bride Valley.  
 pages 133 and 134: photograph and blank 
 VICTORIAN 
 By now roads, canals and railways enabled the spread of uniform building materials to all parts of the country. 
 The regional materials of each area, once so varied, began their slow demise as bricks, for instance, became cheaper to import from the Midlands than to bake in the village kiln. 
 A ubiquitous look began, particularly in town and city suburbs. 
 This era was packed with architectural revivals including Italianate and baronial. 
 Most chose the Gothic route, whether it was Ruskin's preferred Italian medieval Gothic or William Morris's and Philip Webb's return to English rural traditionalism. 
 Architects inspired by Augustus Welby Northmore Pugin thought of their architecture in terms of &bquo;morality and truthfulness&equo;, which often Produced a stalwart solidity in their houses. 
 By the end of the century Richard Norman Shaw had produced a free romantic style.  
 1835 ST MARIE'S GRANGE Alderbury SALISBURY, WILTSHIRE 
 &bquo;THERE ARE only two things worth living for,&equo; said Augustus Welby Northmore Pugin, &bquo;Christian architecture and a boat.&equo; 
 St Marie s Grange provided a little of both. 
 It was a home that the great prophet of Gothic designed for himself and his family, and today it is still as strange and startling as it was when he built it around 1835. 
 Pugin (who designed the Houses of Parliament with Sir Charles Barry), was fifty years ahead of his time. 
 When pale imitations of Greece and left-overs of Strawberry Hill Gothic were the norm, suddenly, on a site just south of Salisbury, with &bquo;a magnificent view of the cathedral and city with the River Avon winding through&hellip; as advantageous a situation as any in England&equo;, there sprang up this towered, monastic, miniature Gothic ch&acirc;teau. 
 Pugin was not trying to be different for the sake of it; his medieval revival was born from a genuine moral and religious fervour. 
 He believed that good architecture could only be created by good people and that you could only be good by being an unreformed Christian. 
 Hence everything he built sprang from the fifteenth century and before. 
 Pugin's strict rules and principles were upheld in part to counteract the inordinate sadness he had suffered at the age of twenty-two, when his first wife died giving birth to their only daughter. 
 At twenty-three he married again, became a Roman Catholic and decided to buckle down to work as best he could and prove by his buildings that &bquo;everything grand, edifying and noble in art is the result of feelings produced by the catholic religion on the human mind.&equo; 
 (He found it difficult to come to terms with the fact - that the Roman Catholics were responsible for the Italian classical revival in the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries.) 
 St Marie's is built on a small plateau above the wide Avon, and on alder-strewn, willowy meadow land, but in a somewhat awkward position. 
 For technical reasons the house had to be set back under a steep bank, and so feels slightly cramped. 
 Although the large Gothic window of the chapel was replaced by a smaller one, and bay windows were added a few years later, it is still, in Pugin's own words, &bquo;the only modern building that is complete in every part in the ancient style&equo;. 
 Within, the atmosphere is heavily ecclesiastical and Pugin's soul still hangs in the air, despite some alterations to the internal layout. 
 A stained glass window lights the stairs, his initials in Gothic lettering appear in much of the decoration, and dark woodwork pervades all. 
 Six months after the house was finished and the specially commissioned green leather furniture from Hull of Wardour Street had been arranged, Mrs Pugin's health proved unsuited to watery Wiltshire. 
 The house had cost upwards of &pound;2,000 to build, and Pugin had great difficulty in selling it. 
 Nobody wanted such a queer house. 
 He ended up by selling it for &pound;500 to Mr Staples, from whom he originally bought the site for the same sum.  
 pages 137 and 138: photographs 
 1843 WINSTON GRANGE Debenham SUFFOLK 
 IN 1843 the parishioners of Winston were worried about the dilapidated state of their vicarage, which stood next to the church of St Andrew. 
 The patron of the living asked the architect Samuel Saunders Teulon to make a report on it. 
 He suggested that it had gone too far and should be pulled down. 
 In its stead he built Winston Grange on a piece of glebeland across the fields from the ancient and unassuming little church. 
 It was a bold and expensive move, for the parish of Winston was small and, in consequence, so was the stipend. 
 The building of Winston Grange, containing the first flush lavatory in Suffolk, proved a triumph, for in 1860 the third incumbent, a Reverend Mundiford Allen, became one of the best and most loved vicars in East Anglia, and although he died and was buried here in 1910, stories of his virtue and kindness are still rife. 
 Mundiford supplemented his stipend by farming the glebeland, and grew two orchards. 
 Among the apple trees, one hot summer in the 1880s, he dug and puddled a large pond with the help of his two sons, which was used as the family swimming pool for years afterwards. 
 On the top floor of the house there were three tiny rooms, one for boxes, one for the Allen boys, and one for the five Allen daughters. 
 When their mother died in 1890, the eldest daughter, who was by then thirty years old, was allowed to move to the first floor bedroom, and from then on she ruled the roost. 
 The maid of all work also died at about this time and was not replaced. 
 When their father died in 1910, the five Allen girls, who never married, moved to Clacton-on-Sea, where they ran a high-class boarding house. 
 Each of the five is buried at Winston. 
 The Grange has always been a happy house and still has a faint atmosphere of piety, fully intended by Mr Teulon. 
 This was a restrained and early work from an architect renowned for his roguish style, who went on to shock and irritate many of his contemporaries but also to amaze and satisfy his clients. 
 His specialities were country houses, churches and vicarages, and he had a great love for bricks, which he used brilliantly and ingeniously. 
 He did not gain many public commissions, because he did not care for architectural competitions. 
 He looked like the archetypal respectable Victorian, with mutton chop whiskers, a top hat, a good wife, four sons, four daughters, and strong evangelical convictions. 
 It was the latter fact that got him so many commissions from the Church of England, who abhorred the Catholic leanings of Pugin and his stable. 
 The later wildness and eccentricity of his style were completely out of character with his conventional, moral and industrious way of life; his obituary reported that he had died from overwork. 
 The Reverend Allen's successor dealt in motor bikes to supplement his pay, but by the 1930s the parish had become so small that a vicarage seemed unnecessary, and it was sold.  
 1845 TOFT MANOR Comberton CAMBRIDGESHIRE 
 THE ARCHITECTS of Victorian England were now born &mdash; Barry, Pugin, Scott, Cockerell, Paxton, Street, Butterfield, Waterhouse and Shaw, and the new age reflected every sort of change from social to technological. 
 The architect who could now travel to sites on a steam train and use technical terms and modern scaffolding had a different relationship with the client, who was more informed about what he wanted in the way of a new house in the country. 
 Whereas architectural changes in the small country house had been slowly transitional in the last four hundred years, so that you hardly noticed the slipping of one style into another over, say, a period of fifty years, now the changes were radical and sometimes startling. 
 If you wanted to rise in your profession as an architect, you would probably choose the Gothic route. 
 Toft Manor was built as a parsonage for St Andrew's church, which the Shell Guide to Cambridgeshire  describes as &bquo;gloomy and largely rebuilt, (with) alabaster figures and dreadful Victorian stained glass&equo;. 
 One of the editors of the Ecclesiologist , writing in 1845, declared that this house, the former parsonage, &bquo;exhibits a great advance upon the usual style. 
 We think he &lsqb;the architect&rsqb; has adopted perhaps too late a period for his model: and there is a little exaggeration in the design which we have no doubt will be amended in the future.&equo; 
 Did the architect get eight out of ten from the powers that be? 
 Samuel Whitfield Daukes was his name, and what a very fine job he made of this rambling Gothic house of flint with its stone dressings, its &bquo;Tudor&equo; windows with their mullions and transomes, and its jolly carved bargeboards. 
 It is typical of a certain sort of domestic architecture which exudes an air of virtue and solidity. 
 Although it may be easier to like the look of a classical house, few imagine how pleasant it might be to live in a Tudor Revival one which combines quaint picturesqueness with modern practicalities. 
 Daukes was a great admirer of Pugan's architecture, including St Marie's Grange, though not of his high-minded religious ideas,; he was very low church himself. 
 He was also a man of means and in 1839, as a young architect, he bought up an estate in Cheltenham known as the Park and set about making fourteen acres of formal gardens and building six of speculative housing. 
 He went on to become famous in the Cheltenham and Gloucester area, where he built many churches and railway stations, as well as Witley Court in Worcestershire, for the Earl of Dudley, and Cirencester Agricultural College.  
 pages 141 and 142: photographs 
 1849&ndash;50 THE OLD RECTORY St Colomb Major CORNWALL 
 NEAR NINE Maidens, the only ancient stone avenue in Cornwall, the little town of St Colomb Major straggles over a steep hill. 
 It has a fine high street at its summit, &bquo;country grand&equo; Victorian buildings, classical Town Hall, Temperance Hall and non-conformist chapels, and a formidable trio of Bank House, Penmellyn House and Old Rectory, by the curious Victorian architect William White. 
 The Rectory is designed in a simple medieval Gothic Revival style. 
 The random roof lines and the use of local materials enable it to fit into the hillside as organically as White had planned. 
 It is a far cry from the Regency Gothic of twenty years earlier, when parsonages sported wrought-iron verandahs looking on to wide lawns and cedar trees. 
 The new clergy houses were of a quite different, selfless and holy Gothic architecture. 
 The great nephew of the naturalist Gilbert White of Selborne, William White, was odds on to be a follower of Pugin and one of the &bquo;Ecclesiological set&equo;. 
 He was the son of a clergyman, the brother of the Archdeacon of Grahamstown and the brother-in-law of the Bishop of Madagascar. 
 He carried a prayerbook and hymnal in his &bquo;Patent Alpine Porte-Knapsack&equo; (his own invention, &bquo;said to create no pressure on the back or arm&equo;) when mountaineering. 
 He disapproved of shaving, sported a beard to his navel and was a great advocate of Swedish gymnastics. 
 Mark Girouard, in The Victorian Country House , describes his appearance in the Alps: &bquo;He wore a flannel suit, brown canvas gaiters and boots with porpoise-hide laces. 
 A puggaree of Indian cotton hung from the back of his hat, to protect his neck from the sun; a brown veil shielded his eyes from the snow; a whistle hung from his button-hole.&equo; 
 He would sometimes sing a song of his own composition called &bquo;Alpine Queen&equo; or &bquo;Mountaineer's Song&equo;. 
 William White had worked in the office of the architect Sir George Gilbert Scott, during which time he had met the famous church architects G.F. Bodley and G.E. 
 Street. 
 In 1847 he set up his own practice in Truro and designed the Old Rectory when he was only twenty-four years old. 
 Of granite, which he has used in dressings around the doors and windows, he wrote: &bquo;Especial care is required to make the mouldings of a broad, bold and massive, rather than a small or delicately undercut character, and to avoid as far as possible anything like minuteness and pettiness in the finish.&equo; 
 The interior banister at the Old Rectory is of granite and is certainly bold and massive, with ceiling-high columns half enclosing the staircase. 
 &bquo;White spent much of his life balanced on the boundary between crankiness and brilliance,&equo; continues Girouard; &bquo;in the end he fell off on the wrong side, and a large proportion of his last years were wasted in trying to prove that Shakespeare was Bacon. 
 The crankiness should not obscure the brilliance. 
 As an architect he is one of the most interesting and least known of the Victorian Gothic Revivalists.&equo;  
 page 144: photograph 
 1856 HINDERTON HALL Neston CHESHIRE 
 CHRISTOPHER BUSHNELL was a Liverpool wine merchant who decided to move from the city and build an honest, solid house in the beautiful Wirral. 
 The civic grandeur of Liverpool, which in the middle of the nineteenth century was ever expanding on the most monumental scale, must have influenced Mr Bushnell's taste, for he had strong views on what he wanted. 
 He chose Alfred Waterhouse as his architect, perhaps because he was a local boy from Liverpool. 
 He could have had no idea that Mr Waterhouse was to become one of the greatest civic architects of the north, for in 1856, when Hinderton Hall was built, he was still at the brink of his career. 
 Alfred Waterhouse was born in 1830, the first of eight children. 
 His parents were Quakers, and Alfred's contacts were only among &bquo;friends&equo; until he was eighteen. 
 After a five-year apprenticeship to Richard Lane of Manchester, he travelled abroad for a year and sketched the most extraordinary number of buildings and architectural details. 
 Greek remains in Paestum, mosques in Istanbul, palaces in Rome and churches in Rouen. 
 Two years later he built Hinderton, which faintly resembles a French ch&acirc;teau mixed very weakly with a Scottish manse. 
 Victorian Gothic it certainly is, and looks wonderfully strong and solid and right for its hard-working and worthy owner, who was not averse to a little picturesque grouping of steep roofs and gables and the addition of a narrow corner tower. 
 The house is built of rock-faced sandstone which is of the deepest pink, peculiar to this area, and its roofs are of patterned slate. 
 There is a two-storeyed entrance hall, twenty-five feet square, around which are the main reception rooms, grouped informally. 
 The surrounding garden is thick with evergreens. 
 Tall firs form a copse at the back of the house and great clumps of rhododendrons and laurels surround the lawns to the south, conserving the safe, dark Victorian atmosphere of the place. 
 Chestnuts line the edge of the small park and afford the house a dignified protection from the lorries that now hurtle by on the main road.  
 1859 THE RED HOUSE Bexley Heath KENT 
 THE RED House is a celebrated Victorian house &mdash; built for William Morris, writer, socialist, artist, craftsman and manufacturer, by his friend, the great architect Philip Webb. 
 The young Morris, born in Walthamstow and educated at Marlborough, had wanted something &bquo;very medieval in spirit&equo;, and the bit of north Kent which was then deep in the fruitgrowing countryside seemed the perfect place to build. 
 In the summer of 1858, Morris, Webb and Charles Faulkner had gone on a rowing trip down the River Seine, to look at medieval cathedrals. 
 It was then the plan to build the Red House was formed. 
 Early in the April of 1859 the contract on the land was signed, and on the 26th of that month, at the age of twenty-five, William Morris married Jane Burden, an Oxford girl. 
 The newly-weds moved into the Red House in 1860, and began to furnish and decorate it to Morris's own designs. 
 (This was the origin of Morris and Co.) 
 In 1861 Jane Morris was born, and a year later May Morris. 
 Everything was rosy at the Red House, which Dante Gabriel Rossetti, Morris's close friend and mentor described as &bquo;more a poem than a house&hellip; but an admirable place to live in too,. 
 It is a house which has given rise to much aesthetic conjecture, and for a long time it was deemed to be the first seed of the modern movement in England, for it did not appear to be built in any revival style, but in a fresh new one. 
 William Morris thought of it as being &bquo;in the style of the thirteenth century&equo;, but then it is also in the style of Philip Webb's master, G.E. 
 Street, in whose office he had worked. 
 He had hardly left the office when he built this, his first house as an independent architect, but later was embarrassed by it, and said at one point that he never wanted to see it or hear about it again, and that no architect should be allowed to build a house before he was forty. 
 It is called the Red House because it is built of deep red brick, an unusual medium for a man of means, who was normally expected to build in something nobler. 
 It rather resembles a Victorian village school in outline (or perhaps Victorian village schools resemble it!), with its steep roof and dormer windows looking like belfries; you fully expect to see a vicarage and church in the same style hovering nearby. 
 It is the work of two young and future geniuses of their generation, who together worked out the principles of architectural truthfulness that would guide the Arts and Crafts Movement in the future. 
 There is a magical quality of invention about the Red House, and perhaps one's excitement is heightened by imagining Morris's friends arriving at Abbey Wood Station and driving the three miles into the country to come and stay here. 
 Edward Burne-Jones, who had been at Oxford with Morris and then shared a London house with him, was a regular visitor. 
 He painted scenes in an amateurish fashion from the medieval romance of Sir Degrevaunt on the lower walls of the drawing room, some of which have survived.  
 pages 147 and 148: photographs 
 circa 1880 BRIDGE LODGE Eythrope, Stone BUCKINGHAMSHIRE 
 BRIDGE LODGE was built as an estate &bquo;cottage&equo;, by Alice, sister to Ferdinand von Rothschild, members of the Vienna branch of this phenomenal and awe-inspiring family. 
 By the 1880s the Rothschilds had taken the Vale of Aylesbury by storm. 
 The Victorian worship of money was on the wax, and houses were an outward expression of what you were worth and how fashionable was your taste. 
 Mayer Amschel Rothschild built Mentmore, Alfred Rothschild built Halton House, Lionel Rothschild rebuilt Tring, and Ferdinand built Waddesdon, all on the most spectacular scale and in the wildest styles they could muster. 
 They employed literally thousands of Buckinghamshire men for years and years. 
 Ferdinand, desperate to be accepted by the cognoscenti  and to build up political influence, flaunted his lavishness by building a gigantic French ch&acirc;teau of bright yellow Bath stone With 222 rooms, and by planting hundreds of fully grown trees on the high bare hill on which it stood. 
 His sister Alice followed suit in a slightly less glittery way on the adjoining estate she had bought at Eythrope. 
 Alice's estate was beautiful already with the wide shallow River Thames running through it. 
 The old Eythrope house which had stood near to Bridge Lodge had belonged to the Earls of Chesterfield, who had pulled it down in 1810 and made the most of the high price of building materials then prevailing owing to the Napoleonic wars. 
 Consequently, vestiges of a great house remained in the form of mature avenues and a feeling of settled peace. 
 This is where the solitary and delicate Alice, whose health was her predominant worry, decided to create her little demesne. 
 She employed the architect George Devey to build her &bquo;Pavilion&equo;, where she would spend her days, but for fear of being made ill by the river's damp fumes she always dined and spent the night with her brother at Waddesdon. 
 George Devey also built this sumptuously romantic Lodge for Alice, right beside a waterfall. 
 Devey has created a masterpiece of the Victorian Picturesque. 
 As so many of his contemporaries did, he had a penchant for traditional cottage architecture and was particularly fond of the Kentish styles and materials, having worked for Lord de l'Isle at Penshurst. 
 He was artistic, gentle and country loving, and though be was based in London, with an office in Great Marlborough Street, country commissions were his favourite. 
 If your client was called Rothschild there was no such word as &bquo;restraint&equo;. 
 Mr Devey went to town.  
 page 150: blank 
 EDWARDIAN TO THIRTIES 
 A more stylish and dramatic return to English tradition came about through the Arts and Crafts Movement, which stood for integrity and truthfulness and believed whole-heartedly in the use of local craftsmen and materials. 
 From those early Tudor days the English house had come full circle, but these Edwardian houses were warm, practical and comfortable; they epitomized countrified romanticism. 
 Meanwhile, on the Continent, the modern movement was on its way to creating houses that abandoned period styles and traditional materials and forged ahead into a scientific age. 
 They left the English house behind.  
 1896&ndash;7 MUNSTEAD WOOD Godalming SURREY 
 THE SOPHISTICATED Miss Gertrude Jekyll, gardening heroine of the Edwardians, commissioned Edwin Lutyens to design her Surrey homestead, and this he did so beautifully that their relationship was cemented and many future joint commissions ensued. 
 The house was built by Thomas Underwood of Dunsfold, and the stonemason was William Herbert of Whitley. 
 The garden front, of Bargate stone, brick and tile, shows how Lutyens has exaggerated the local Surrey style to perfectly fitting proportions. 
 The roof lines swoop, the chimneys soar, and the beams of local oak in the hall look silver with age. 
 (This effect was achieved by spreading the timbers with hot lime for fifteen minutes and then scraping it off.) 
 Miss Jekyll's desire (with a little help) for all that was &bquo;thorough and honest of spirit of the good work of old days&equo;, the creed of the Arts and Crafts Movement, was fulfilled. 
 Munstead Wood, with its half-timbered north-west side, its kitchen courtyard, its ingle-nooks and its superb craftsmanship, became a show-piece of its time. 
 Lutyens was brought up at Thursley in Surrey and developed a great love for that county's local styles and materials, although he also built in the grandest of manners. 
 One of the reasons for his having such innovative ideas was that he was almost untrained, some would say untrainable, and laughed (extremely annoyingly at the time) at his elders and betters and their obsessions with sketching and learning the orders. 
 After spending two years at the South Kensington School of Art, he went for a year to the office of the architect Sir Ernest George when he was still only eighteen. 
 Towards the end of his life he told Osbert Sitwell; &bquo;Any talent I may have was due to a long illness as a boy, which afforded me time to think, and subsequent ill-health, because I was not allowed to play games, and so had to teach myself, for my enjoyment, to use my eyes instead of my feet.&equo; 
 The greatest Scottish architect of his time, Sir Robert Lorimer, was enchanted when he visited Munstead Wood in 1897. 
 He wrote to his friend R.S. Dods in Australia, &bquo;&hellip; it looks so reasonable, so kindly, so perfectly beautiful, that you feel that people might have been making love, and living and dying there and dear little children running about for &mdash; the last - I was going to say 1,000 years &mdash; anyway, 600. 
 They've used old tiles which of course helps &mdash; but the proportion, the way the thing's built&hellip; &bquo;by the old people of the old materials in the old unhurrying way'&equo; but at the same time &bquo;&bquo;sweet to all modern uses'&equo;&hellip; and who do you think did this for her? &mdash; a young chap called Lutyens, 27 he is &mdash; and I've always heard him derided by the Schultz school as a &bquo;&bquo;society,, architect. 
 Miss J. has pretty well run him and now he's doing a roaring trade and has just married a daughter of Lord Lytton, he's evidently right in with the right lot of people&hellip; and what a God's mercy that for once in a way these people have got hold of the right man and what a thing for England.&equo;  
 pages 153 and 154: photographs 
 1898 BROADLEYS Windermere WESTMORLAND 
 &bquo;OWING To its natural beauty, protected situation and other attractive features, Windermere is popular not only as a holiday resort, but as a permanent summer and winter residence. 
 It is entirely modern and in its environs are many residential villas embowered in trees and shrubs and surrounded by beautiful gardens,&equo; reads a guide to the Lakes of the 1900s. 
 Travelling south along the lake-side road, through the village of Bowness (rightly pronounced Bowness by the locals, and Boness by nearly everybody else), the scenery becomes more dramatic, the villas more sparsely spaced and hidden among the maturity of their Edwardian planting. 
 At Gill Head, where Cartmel Fell looms huge to the south and the road is dark with overhanging trees, a hidden drive turns sharply towards the lake and suddenly one of the crown jewels of the Arts and Crafts Movement is before you. 
 Wordsworth had lived in and loved the Lakes for sixty years, and later Ruskin, the great architectural influence of the nineteenth century, built a house on Lake Coniston. 
 As has often been the case, it is the artists who are the forerunners of fashion, and fifty years later the world and his wife craved for Windermere. 
 In 1897 Mr and Mrs Currer Briggs bought the most idyllic site they could lay their hands on and wrote to Mr Voysey the architect. 
 By this time a new aesthetic movement was evolving. 
 Mr and Mrs Currer Briggs longed for that combination of romance and practicality which the Arts and Crafts Movement promised. 
 Mr Charles Annesley Voysey did not disappoint them. 
 The main block of Broadleys faces west towards the lake above terraced gardens designed by Mr Mawson. 
 The service block comes off at a right angle at the back and forms a sort of court where you arrive. 
 Here on this east side are the exaggerated sweeping gables, the cottagey front door with its hinges forged with heart-shaped ends (a trade mark of Mr Voysey), the elaborate gutters, the pebble-dash over the two-feet-thick stone walls, and the cosy, comforting scale of the whole, so nice to come home to on a wet and windy evening. 
 On the west side the great grey Westmorland slated roof dominates the three two-storey bay windows. 
 The hall takes up the central bay through the two storeys; the dining- and drawing-rooms are on either side. 
 Above these are the two main bedrooms with their spectacular views up and down the lake. 
 It is an extremely practical house, having seven bedrooms, two bathrooms, a playroom, a kitchen and the usual domestic offices. 
 Voysey stood for a drastic and stylized return to English country tradition and, along with Charles Rennie Mackintosh, relied on simplicity of composition for greatest effect. 
 Their influence was revolutionary. 
 Voysey's interiors were almost puritanically plain and, like his hero Morris, he designed his own furniture.  
 1902 FOURACRE West Green HAMPSHIRE 
 &bquo;THE PLANNING is without doubt the most important thing in the designing of a house. 
 &bquo;To be happy at home is the ultimate result of all ambition.'&equo; 
 No one can be quite I happy in an ill-planned house any more than in ill-fitting clothes, and although the &bquo;cut'&equo; and &bquo;&bquo;style,&equo; are much, they count for nothing in a garment which pinches and annoys the wearer in a hundred ways&hellip; 
 , So wrote the architect of Fouracre, Ernest Newton. 
 Tucked into cosy woodland near the silver birchy Surrey border, Fouracre (which was never a four-acre site, but started as fifty) is a supremely satisfactory house. 
 It was built for Doctor Wills and his family, whose initials are let into the circles of brickwork in the gables. 
 It sports twenty-two chimneys and wonderful criss-cross brick-work known as &bquo;diaperwork&equo;. 
 If Doctor Wills couldn't decide whether he liked sash or casement windows, then he had a choice: sash in the reception rooms and casement everywhere else. 
 Ernest Newton was a quiet and restrained product of the artistic circle within which he worked. 
 He had started in Norman Shaw's office and was much encouraged by him. 
 In the early 1880s Newton opened his Hart Street I rooms in London for meetings of the St George's Art Society, which he founded and which was designed &bquo;for the discussion of Art and Architecture&equo;. 
 By 1884 it had become the Art Workers' Guild, the hub of the Arts and Crafts Movement, which aimed to bring back all the fine and craft arts and to follow the writings of Ruskin and William Morris. 
 The nineteenth century had brought mass production in the wake of its industrial revolution, and this reversion to the home-made and hand hewn was a natural reaction. 
 Ernest Newton, like his name, was a modest and serious architect who believed in moderation. 
 &bquo;Building must fall into some sort of style,&equo; he wrote &bquo;memory &mdash; inherited forms and ideas. 
 But this must be accepted not sought. 
 Pass all through the mill of your mind and don't use forms unmeaningly, like buttons on the back of a coat&hellip; although house building is very much a practical art the practical elements may be met gracefully and pleasantly, there is scope for dignity, humour and even romance. 
 Our house building ought to develop naturally&hellip; a natural architecture is a rational healthy builder's art expressing itself soberly through the medium of masonry and carpentry.&equo;  
 pages 157 and 158: photographs 
 circa 1910 LINKENHOLT MANOR Andover HAMPSHIRE 
 LINKENHOLT MANOR exemplifies the best sort of modest solid Edwardian country house. 
 Comfortable and friendly, it is a broader, homelier version of the &bquo;Queen Anne&equo; style, which had been conceived over thirty years earlier by the great Richard Norman Shaw, and which eventually became so settled and familiar in suburban streets throughout England. 
 It had little to do with the real Queen Anne architecture of the early eighteenth century, but merely borrowed some of its features, such as, here at Linkenholt: the thick glazing bars on the dormer windows, the shell-shaped pediment over the central dormer, and the gently hipped roof lines. 
 These features were then mixed up with features from the local cottages of Surrey and Sussex &mdash; the tiled roof, the tile-hung wall and the gable. 
 The interior tells the same story, incorporating high quality panelling to Queen Anne proportions, and cottagey casement windows. 
 The previous fifty years had provided so many alternative and revolutionary styles, that architects and clients alike often found themselves in a quandry as to which to go for. 
 Whereas the great architectural theorists of the day and leaders of style spun their philosophy and bossed their clients about, they built few private houses between them. 
 Men like Pugin, Ruskin and William Morris turned a distasteful and then a blind eye to the fast growing urban sprawl and preferred to live in genuine or fake medieval houses by rivers or lakes. 
 Their influence, however, was incalculable, and the most famous of its exponents was the prolific Richard Norman Shaw. 
 His was a free style of architecture which embraced bits of everything, and it was he, together with his friend and partner Nesfield, who invented the &bquo;Queen Anne&equo; style. 
 For a thousand years there has been a manor on this site, which belonged to Hesdins, Wriothosleys, Badds and Worgans until the nineteenth century. 
 Then the Colsons bought the estate and, with typical Victorian model behaviour, began to smarten up the ramshackle village of Linkenholt. 
 They commissioned William White to build the church in 1871, built a school and new cottages, pulled down the old manor and the cottages surrounding it and erected a large Victorian house. 
 In 1886 they ran out of money and the bank foreclosed. 
 In 1902 the house burned down while in the ownership of Mr Charles Julius Knowles. 
 His sons received the news by telegram and were apparently unperturbed. 
 A few years later this latest manor house was built, and in 1928 almost the first double glazing ever seen in England was installed to combat the bitterly cold winds. 
 Linkenholt is the highest village in Hampshire, 700 feet up, with its estate rising to 900 feet. 
 The first combine harvester ever used in England was in service here and, in 1935, agricultural history was made when bread was eaten from wheat harvested, dried, milled and baked in the same day.  
 1912 KELLING HALL Holt NORFOLK 
 SIR EDWARD Maufe, the architect of Kelling Hall, died on his ninety-first birthday in 1974. 
 He was a tall, handsome and courteous man who lived in a Surrey farmhouse with off-white walls, limed oak furniture, Eric Gill sculptures and giant-leaved zimmer lindens. 
 His most famous building was Guildford Cathedral, which he built in 1932. 
 Maufe's obituary read, &bquo;His work is not likely to appeal to the present generation of architects because it was essentially traditional and restrained.&equo; 
 If this was true, then what a lot they missed! 
 Kelling Hall was Maufe's first country house, built on the daring &bquo;Butterfly&equo; plan, so called on account of its shape. 
 Sometimes called &bquo;Sun Trap&equo; houses, the idea behind them was to catch the sun at every angle. 
 Whereas the Victorians had an aversion to the sun, and sometimes faced new houses to the north, the well-off Edwardians worshipped it. 
 They ventured under its rays for breakfast and tea and lolled about in it during the afternoons. 
 The other side of Kelling has the same outward-slanting wings, shielding a terrace from which the garden slopes gently away to the wide Norfolk view. 
 It was Richard Norman Shaw who first conceived the idea when he was remodelling a Northumbrian house called &bquo;Chesters&equo;. 
 His pupil E.S. 
 Prior then refined and glamorized the idea and became the most celebrated and earliest &bquo;Butterfly&equo; specialist. 
 He built a thatched &bquo;Butterfly&equo; at Exmouth for a fellow old Harrovian called Major Weatherby, and the wildly eccentric &bquo;Home Place&equo; just outside Holt. 
 It was the latter which so struck Henry Detterding, the Director General of the Royal Dutch Petroleum Company, who resolved to build himself a &bquo;Butterfly&equo; house and commissioned Maufe. 
 Norfolk is a county poor in stone, particularly in the north, where flint is widely used as a building material, with brick dressings. 
 Maufe imported Dutch brick under instruction from the Dutch Mr Detterding and set it round the flints, which were &bquo;knapped&equo;, that is, cut to make a smooth face rather than left whole. 
 Roderick Gradidge, a scholar of the &bquo;Butterfly&equo; plan period, explains the appeal in his book Dream Houses : &bquo;Firstly it seems logical, for from a central core of the hall and staircase, the wings pushed out catching the sun and view. 
 But also, and for architects of this period more importantly, the silhouette created by the plan had the advantage of being symmetrical and romantically complex at the same time.&equo;  
 pages 161 and 162: photographs 
 1915 INGLEWOOD Ledsham CHESHIRE 
 INGLEWOOD, BUILT for a self-made millionaire by an unknown Arts and Crafts architect in the highly desirable Wirral, epitomizes the lavish taste of the Edwardian era. 
 By the 1900s, British Arts and Crafts houses were admired all over the world. 
 They were a step in a different direction from the exotic and theatrical Victorian house, and they were built for a more architecturally educated and independent type of client. 
 Wives were given a say for the first time, and what they wanted was romantic practicality. 
 Many took the Studio  magazine, which showed the very latest domestic designs. 
 It was not only the cottages of Surrey, Sussex and Kent that inspired the Arts and Crafts architects; there was also a strong movement in Cheshire, where a wealth of clients wanted new homes not too far from the great cities of Liverpool and Manchester. 
 Most of these new rich were only one step removed from village life, and to have a brand new &bquo;cottage style&equo; house, and on an enormous scale, was for them extremely appealing. 
 Seasoned wood, and fires that drew, and casement windows that opened and shut perfectly and admitted no draughts were all hallmarks of the Arts and Crafts architects, who liked to use local craftsmen, local materials and effect complete harmony with the surroundings. 
 Mr Fox had become a millionaire through his marine insurance company in Liverpool. 
 He did not want a classical house, but something cosy and as English as could be. 
 Whereas the Victorians had gone a bit &bquo;foreign&equo; with some of their house designs, Inglewood was as English as you could get, and looked like a clean, clear-cut, practical version of Cheshire's most famous half-timbered house, Little Moreton Hall. 
 Half-timbering is Cheshire's speciality, after all &mdash; what better examples in the country are there than Handforth, Henbury and the spectacularly lavish Hill Bark, built in 1894 (at a cost of &pound;150,000) and moved lock, stock and barrel in 1929 to a site five miles away in order to avoid the view of encroaching development! 
 &bquo;No style of building,&equo; wrote Mr Ould, Hill Bark's architect, of half-timbering, &bquo;will harmonize so quickly and completely with its surroundings&hellip; and none continues to live on such terms of good fellowship with other materials, whether rosy brickwork, grey lichen covered masonry, or pearly flag-slates.&equo; 
 Inglewood must have been a perfect foil for the grand civic buildings of Liverpool, with its open timber balcony on the south side overlooking terraced and formal gardens laid out in the &bquo;Old English&equo; style.  
 1924 THE GATE HOUSE Limpsfield SURREY 
 THE OLD village of Limpsfield rises southwards with views to the chalk downs in the blue half-distance. 
 A little out of it is the Gate House, built in the local Surrey style by Hugh Baillie Scott, for a refined and progressive family who were among the new wave of Surrey homesteaders brought here by suburban railways, and hence having the possibility of commuting. 
 These were the new country people who, like their architects, wanted to experience &bquo;the simple life&equo;. 
 No hunting, shooting or fishing for them, but walking and gardening and breathing in the clear air. 
 Baillie Scott was the progenitor of the American open plan and the most innovative interior decorator the first few decades of the twentieth century ever saw. 
 He came from a family of fourteen and was brought up in Ramsgate. 
 He started his own practice in the Isle of Man and built his first house, half-timbered and tile-hung, in the town of Douglas in 1892. 
 His schemes for interiors and furniture were stylized, exquisitely coloured in pale greens and mauves, but often too far-fetched for clients to dare to execute them. 
 He had a large following in Germany and was a great admirer of the American &bquo;Shingle School&equo; of architects, notably the work of White, Mead and McKim. 
 His beautiful watercolours of rooms were constantly given huge spreads in the Studio  magazine, the most important Arts and Crafts periodical. 
 On writing about his perfect country house, Baillie Scott is adamantly opposed to the vulgar and proposes what he considers to be the simple open plan way of life: &bquo;Having arrived at the central idea of a hall or living room as the keynote of a home it follows naturally that one must group round this the various other rooms&hellip; first the &bquo;ladies&equo; bower'', the &bquo;&bquo;drawing-room'&equo; as we now call it. 
 This is a recess in the hall which is set apart for tea and music and is characterized by a certain daintiness of treatment which bears a feminine relation to the masculine ruggedness of the hall&hellip; at the opposite end is the &bquo;refectory'&equo;&hellip;. 
 Here one catches a glimpse of a table bright with silver, glass, and flowers against the dark background of the seating which runs round three sides of the table&hellip; one must not omit to mention the obvious adaptability of the hall to festive occasions. 
 The underlying idea of the central focus with its grouped dependencies here exactly meets the requirements of the case, and one need not hesitate as to whether the drawing-room or the dining-room carpet should be taken up for dancing&hellip;.&equo;  
 pages 165 and 166: photographs 
 circa 1928 UNDERTOWN Trebetherick CORNWALL 
 UNDERTOWN REEKS of quality; with its great organic chimney and its sumptuous flaunting of local materials, it is a last blast of true Arts and Crafts architecture. 
 The &bquo;village&equo; of Trebetherick has a rarefied air; it keeps apart and does not like to mix with its brash neighbour Polzeath, whose villas are shoulder to shoulder, nor with the heartier village of Rock, where strong men sail small boats. 
 At Trebetherick you paddle on Daymer Bay, or shrimp off Gully, or collect cowries on Greenaway. 
 The pervading atmosphere is one of the 1910s and 1920s, and the tone is set by the holiday houses hiding, like Undertown, among macracarpa trees, or braving it on the cliff with their faces looking to the Atlantic. 
 The summer visitors to Trebetherick were generally the families of retired headmasters of minor public schools, of ex Indian Civil servants or of Harley Street doctors. 
 They felt comfortable in sand shoes and bungalows. 
 Ernest Betjemann, however, who built Undertown, was in trade; he was the son of a cabinetmaker and managed a prosperous business manufacturing inlaid cigar boxes and elaborate cocktail cabinets for Maharajas. 
 He was rather looked down on by the Trebetherick set. 
 At first he and his family hired a house called &bquo;Linkside&equo;. 
 However, little by little, as Aspreys sold more and more of his artefacts, so Ernest bought up more and more land along the cliff and through the village. 
 He ended by building his dream house in the cosy lee of a gentle hill and away from the roar of the sea. 
 Ernest had an eye for detail, and Undertown displays this to the hilt. 
 Every wooden door latch still lifts and drops perfectly, every moulded stone in the ingle-nook is smooth as silk. 
 The architect was Robert Atkinson, a shrewd-looking man with sharp features and reddish hair. 
 He had designed the first &bquo;luxury&equo; cinemas in the land, the most famous of which was the Regent in Brighton, showing that you could be lavish without being vulgar. 
 Ernest and he had met on the golf links and both shared a love of collecting antiques. 
 Although Atkinson was a modernist in principle, he was also capable of building in the true Arts and Crafts tradition. 
 Undertown was designed as a summer holiday house, facing south towards the dunes and up the Camel Estuary, with a view across the golf links to the church of St Enodoc and Brae Hill beyond. 
 There is a spacious loggia, and several nooks well out of the wind. 
 In the shallow sloping terraced garden, with drystone retaining walls, there is a sunken circular garden with a seat all round it and a slate floor which was used for having tea in the shade on boiling afternoons. 
 When Ernest's widow sold Undertown and all her land there, she left a proviso to future builders which contained a strict building code. 
 This code, which is still adhered to, specifies that roofs must be made of slate, all woodwork must be white, and walls must be built in local stone or rendered white; it also specifies that houses must be a certain distance apart.  
 page 168: photograph 
 1929 ASHLEY CHASE Abbotsbury DORSET 
 &bquo;AT THE top of Wears Hill we could just make out a signpost, pointing inland to Ashley Chase. 
 We followed it, passed a massive Iron Age earthwork called Abbotsbury Castle, and gradually entered an isolated valley shielded from the sea by the massive bulk of Wears Hill. 
 As we slowly descended, the mist cleared a little, and we found ourselves amid sheep pastures&hellip;&equo; wrote the late Louis Littman, a successful businessman, when he and his wife first saw Ashley Chase with a view to buying it. 
 &bquo;The particulars we had been given referred to an estate of 680 acres having four cottages and a stone house&hellip; 
 This was no shabby, run-down Victorian house as we had expected, but a splendid stone-clad manor house with golden hamstone mullions, and a greenish roof of Cornish Delabole slate. 
 It presented a varied fa&ccedil;ade, full of gables, stone chimneys, projecting wings, and even a round tower capped with a bronze weather-vane in the form of a galleon. 
 &bquo;We were shown over the house. 
 There were six bedrooms on the first floor and a further two in a small staff flat above, and from every window a different view of the adjacent hills and woods. 
 The architect had sited the house on the slope of a hill commanding a great variety of scenery and had given each bedroom its own special view. 
 The dining-room, drawing-room, parlour and kitchen were all of good but reasonable size., 
 Sir Guy Dawber, a former president of the RIBA, built Ashley Chase, hidden in this most secret of Dorset valleys. 
 He had worked along with Lutyens in the office of Sir Ernest George and set up a practice in Bourton on the Hill, Gloucestershire, where he was kept in constant commission by the smart hunting crowd. 
 Sir Guy was a great and unsung country house architect, a staunch traditionalist and one who loved the Cotswold style the best. 
 His clients were private people who did not want publicity. 
 (Lutyens&equo; fame had grown not least because he was a great friend of the editor of Country Life , and likewise Voysey knew the editor of The Studio.) 
 Sir Guy had little or no Publicity; he wrote books about Cotswold architecture and mixed with the arty-crafty Sapperton Set &mdash; the Gimsons, Barnsley and Norman Jewson. 
 Ashley Chase epitomized his style. 
 &bquo;It was a masterpiece of harmony,&equo; wrote Littman, &bquo;which can be attained when men see to it that their handiwork blends with their natural surroundings. 
 The whole valley seemed to be under a spell, in a timeless past unaffected by wars, the scars of industrial development and the trauma of social upheaval.&equo; 
 Louis Littman did  buy Ashley Chase, after that first visit in 1966, and realized his childhood dream of owning and running the ideal estate. 
 His son continues to do so.  
 1935 CHERRY HILL Wentworth SUNNINGDALE, BERKSHIRE 
 HERE ENDETH the English house in the country. 
 Cherry Hill is in the &bquo;International Modern&equo; style and could equally well be on the outskirts of Stuttgart or San Francisco as Sunningdale. 
 It was a style which heralded the beginning of the end of England's architectural identity. 
 The new buildings in our towns and cities began to look like any other new buildings in the rest of Europe. 
 Sometimes called the &bquo;Jazz Modern&equo; style, International Modern was a term coined in the United States to refer to the new architectural style of the twentieth century, which architects like Frank Lloyd Wright and Walter Gropius were creating before the First World War. 
 Cherry Hill admirably demonstrates all the style's characteristic features &mdash; white rendering, asymmetrical cubic shapes, large windows and a complete absence of mouldings. 
 (The recessed verandah to the right of centre, with its sliding picture windows, was added at a later date.) 
 At the time it appalled the traditionalists; now it is winning them round with its logical elegance, nostalgic glamour and atmosphere of cocktails on a Cunard liner. 
 Oliver Hill, its architect, was a chameleon who could perform miracles and build in whatever style was asked of him by his upper-class clients, some of whom were startlingly &bquo;progressive&equo;. 
 Whether it be in &bquo;International - Modern&equo;, Organic Arts and Crafts, Neo-Elizabethan, Neo-Jacobean, or Neo-Georgian, Hill r could accommodate his client. 
 In 1948 he moved to the ancient house of Daneway, near Sapperton, where he ground his own flour, baked his own bread and made his own paper on which to print his poems on his own press. 
 What a far cry from the &bquo;machine for living in&equo; which Cherry Hill was meant to be. 
 The Architect and Building News  of 10 January 1936 reported: Mr Oliver Hill's romantic modernism has rarely found a happier destination than this charmingly picturesque house in the woods near Virginia Water. 
 The site, on the crest of a hill, is sheltered by a group of scotch firs and to the south an open view extends over Cobham Common&hellip;. 
 All the living and bedrooms are placed on the south side, facilitating the effective area of plain wall on the north. 
 The dining-room and sitting-room which both open into each other display rectangular wall sections of selected birch, slightly pink toned and white waxed&hellip;. 
 The sitting-room has glazed sliding-front china cases, electrically lit on either side&hellip; the staircase window, or rather glass wall, has fringed curtains in green and white, illuminated from below at night time.&equo;  
 page 171: photograph 
 INTRO 
 In Other Words &mdash; David Bowie, is the story of David Bowie, documented in a diverse range of perspectives from actors, musicians, producers, directors and friends, connected with his life and work. 
 The object of the book is not to analyse but to report, which is why it is predominantly the words of others taken from the radio series that I produced, In Other Words &mdash; David Bowie, a series that was narrated by Angie, David's former wife. 
 The project began back in 1976 when I was working for Capital Radio, London's independent local radio station. 
 It was at that time that I interviewed David's mother, Margaret Jones , who recalled a three-year-old David discovering a bag of make-up in an upstairs room and plastering himself with it, and how at one point she thought he would become a ballet dancer. 
 For various reasons I am unable to publish a transcript of everything that was said, although some salient points are to be found in the book. 
 David was sacked from his very first job at Vic Furlongs  Music Shop in Bromley; he was working there whilst still at school but, as Vic describes, &bquo;He was a day-dreamer and had to be gotten rid of.&equo; 
 The early years are documented by Ronnie Ross , his saxaphone tutor, Brian Lane , his music teacher and George Underwood , who first met David in Bromley Cubs when both were nine years old. 
 He recalls that when other boys of David's age listened to Radio Luxemburg, David was tuned in to American football on the American Forces Network, and was fascinated not only by American music, but by the whole culture of America. 
 His first record was released in June 1964 when he was managed by Les Conn , who remembers how David and Marc Bohan would redecorate his office between gigs, and David's first television appearance when he refused to cut his hair. 
 Back in the early 60's, David and a group called The Lower Third would travel to gigs in an old ambulance, and Dana Gillespie  recalls the story she heard of them &bquo;scoring&equo; one night when the van was parked in Piccadilly Circus. 
 Ken Pitt , David's third manager, recalls his first flirtation with Buddhism and David's involvement with Lindsay Kemp , a relationship that Lindsay recalls himself. 
 Not only was David having an affair with Kemp, but also with Natasha Kornilof  at the same time. 
 At the time &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; was written, David had moved in with Mary Finnigan  and they launched the Beckenham Folk Club (in order to raise some money) which later became an Arts Lab. 
 Mary recalls how they were flat broke and almost living hand to mouth. 
 She describes how drugs were used, and how they organised a free open-air festival in Beckenham Park. 
 It was at this time that &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; was released, a period in David's life that brought both triumph and tragedy. 
 Tony Visconti  explains why, although he was making an album with David at the time, he refused to produce the &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; single as he thought it was pass&egrave; because the moon shot was about to take place, and the lyrics &bquo;sounded like a nick from Simon and Garfunkel&equo;. 
 Gus Dudgeon , who produced &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; in the end, picks up the story. 
 With the Arts Lab in full swing and the free festival about to take place, David flew to Italy to take part in a song contest, the story of which is related by Angie Bowie  and Ken Pitt . 
 On his return from the song contest his father died, and David's mother remembers how David rushed back in time to show his father the trophy he had won. 
 Angie recalls how she moved in with David's mother to comfort her and how they eventually found Haddon Hall, a large Victorian folly in Beckenham, where ultimately she and David lived along with Tony Visconti and his girlfriend Liz. 
 When David revealed to the Melody Maker that he was gay, Mick Ronson  remembers his parents' house being daubed with paint and his car being damaged &mdash; the reaction was not all good. 
 He also tells the story of the preparations for the launch of Ziggy Stardust, with Angie describing how David's new manager, Tony DeFries , took over organising the business side of things. 
 For Pitt, it was a sad parting of the ways, and he describes his final meeting with David and Tony DeFries. 
 Tony Zanetta , former President of MainMan, the company set up by Tony DeFries to handle David's career, takes us behind the scenes and describes the setting up of MainMan. 
 &bquo;Tony wanted an empire, he wanted an international entertainment conglomerate which was MainMan. 
 He was very taken with organization in the corporate world, and MainMan was fashioned after a large corporation although, at least in its beginning, it was anything but that.&equo; 
 The rise of MainMan is also documented by  Leee  Black Childers  who describes his horrendous journey with David across Russia on the Trans-Siberian Express. 
 In later years both Tony DeFries and Ken Pitt ended up in litigation with Bowie. 
 As Dana Gillespie recalls, &bquo;I'm sure everyone's got a different version of it, and I really didn't witness any rows, but I would often hear from my assistant who would tell me he'd just come back from MainMan offices and the door was closed into DeFries's inner sanctum, and there were raised voices between David and him in there. 
 I think he did say to me once that he was very disturbed at how much coke David was doing, and it got to the point where he didn't hide it in front of DeFries, whereas he did, for quite a while, at first. 
 Angie recalls how, in the high-flying days of MainMan, David turned to using drugs and how their marriage started to crumble. 
 Sadly they were to part with Angie attempting suicide and David snatching their son Zowie back from Angie while she was away from home in Switzerland. 
 Tony Visconti tells the story of how he testified against Angie in the struggle for custody of Zowie, and how David was frequenting transvestite clubs of Berlin while making an album with Iggy Pop and Brian Eno. 
 Eno describes David's first adventure into the world of cybernetics and the making of their trilogy of albums. 
 The story takes us through his films, shows, tours, from The Man Who Fell To Earth  (about which Nicholas Roeg recalls, &bquo;I was asked by the company &mdash; can he act? &mdash; to which I replied &mdash; what do you mean can he act? 
 Anyone who holds 60,000 people on their own in a hall, is an act; they don't do that at home. 
 Their act is acting&equo;), to Absolute Beginners  and Labyrinth . 
 In order to make the radio series, over 30 interviews were recorded exclusively, although only 5% could be used in the finished production, which is why I decided to produce this book, which will prove to be an excellent documentation on the life of David Bowie &mdash; an insight into this enigma of the rock world &mdash; told by those who really know. 
 Kerry Juby, 1986.  
 Just a Gigolo, Berlin 1978 
 About to board the Isle of Wight ferry, Davie Jones 1965 
 Elvis pout '78 
 On stage at Live Aid, Wembley 1985 
 Bowie's portrayal of the Elephant Man in 1980 
 CONTENTS 
 INTRO 
 ONE 
 HIGH SCHOOL HIGHS 
 TWO 
 THE ARTS ODDITY 
 THREE 
 THE AMERICAN DREAM 
 FOUR 
 THE ACTOR'S TALE 
 FIVE 
 A NEW CAREER IN A NEW TOWN 
 SIX 
 THE BEAT GOES ON 
 HIGH SCHOOL HIGHS 
 In 1946 Howard Stenton Jones set up home with Margaret Burns in Stanstead Road, Brixton, along with Terry, Margaret's son from her previous marriage. 
 &bquo;We had a tough time in those days,&equo; recalled Mrs Jones, &bquo;the post war years were no party for anyone, and we were no exception. 
 David was born on 8th January (1947). 
 The midwife said to me, &bquo;This child has been on this earth before&equo;  and I thought that was rather an odd thing to say, but the midwife seemed quite adamant. 
 When he was about 3 years old, he put on make-up for the first time. 
 We had tenants in the house and one day he went missing upstairs and found a bag of lipstick, eye-liner and face powder, and decided it would be a good idea to plaster his face with it. 
 When I finally found him he looked for all the world like a clown. 
 I told him that he shouldn't use make-up, but he said, &bquo;You do, Mummy&equo;. 
 I agreed, but pointed out that it wasn't for little boys.&equo; 
 David was 4&frac12; when he first went to school and not unlike most mothers Mrs Jones was upset at not having him around the house. 
 He proved to be independent, even at this early age. 
 When his mother took him to school on the first day, he decided from then onwards he could make his own way to school and didn't hesitate in telling his mother just that. 
 At his first school, Stockwell Junior School, David dressed up for the first time in a school nativity play. 
 Mrs Jones recalls, &bquo;I made him a robe and head-dress and his father made him a crook. 
 He was mad about it &mdash; he absolutely loved it &mdash; it was then that we began to realise there was something in David.&equo; 
 In those days there was no television, but David, according to his mother, made the most of radio. 
 &bquo;If there was anything that caught his ear, he would tell everyone to be quiet and listen, and then fling himself about to the music. 
 In those days we thought he might be a ballet dancer&equo;. 
 From Stockwell Junior School, Davis attended Burnt Ash Primary School. 
 By now the Jones' had moved to Plaistow Grove, Sundridge Park, Bromley, a small leafy dormitory area on the outskirts of London. 
 It was around this time that he met George Underwood who was to become a lifelong friend. 
 George Underwood: &bquo;I don't know what year it was &mdash; I think it was the year when Tom Hark was No.1 (1958 Ed.) &mdash; but we went to the Isle of Wight with the 18th Bromley Scouts (we were in the Cubs then). 
 It was a skiffle group basically. 
 We had a double bass, tea chest/broom handle/gut and a ukelele, and we did &bquo;Gambling Man&equo; and &bquo;Cumberland Gao&equo; and a few of the old Lonnie Donegan things, and that was David's first public appearance, on the Isle of Wight. 
 From what I remember, we went down quite well and it was the beginning of quite an interesting career for the young Mr Jones.&equo; 
 In those days most kids listened to Buddy Holly and followed football or cricket, but David was different, even then. 
 He used to listen to American Football on the American Forces Network and was so enthused with it that he wrote to the American Embassy, who invited him to visit them for the day. 
 George Underwood: &bquo;It was all instigated by David really, because he had been listening to the World Service on the radio and suddenly got the bug to get involved in American Football, and he wrote to the American Embassy asking for more information. 
 They got the impression that he was well into it but, in fact, it was only about a week before that he'd started to get interested. 
 I think it was the glamour or the aesthetics of the American football player. 
 They made our football players look a bit weak because of all the big shoulder pads and everything. 
 Anyway, the Embassy wrote back to him asking whether he'd like to visit &mdash; I went along with him. 
 At the end of the day, they presented David with a complete baseball outfit, padded shoulders, football helmet, which he proudly brought to school the following day. 
 It was quite amazing really because we'd never seen any of these things before. 
 You can just imagine this little boy in the playground, when everyone else is kicking a soccer ball, dressed with big padded shoulders and a helmet and an American football &mdash; it was quite bizarre really. 
 I think he was very much into the magic of America. 
 The certain mystique it had was much more than just Cowboys and Indians on television. 
 He had a period that he went through just reading books on America. 
 Even at that age, he was listening to Charlie Mingus and people like that. 
 Not that I thought he understood the music that much, but it was the image of he people behind the music, because people like Charlie Mingus are quite characters. 
 It's quite well known that Little Richard was one of David's idols, but there's a lot of other American people who interested David, as much from the image point of view as the music.&equo; 
 David's step-brother, Terry, was also a great influence on David in the early years. 
 When David was 8, Terry was 16, frequenting jazz cellars and introducing David to writers like Jack Kerouac and Allen Ginsberg. 
 At the age of 11, David tansferred to Bromley Technical High School. 
 Although he passed his 11-plus he chose to go to a technical school as it would be more art orientated. 
 George Underwood: &bquo;I remember when we were at Bromley Tech, we would experiment with telepathy. 
 We would arrange to be something at a particular time in the evening and then the following day we would compare our thoughts. 
 It was uncanny how, on so many occasions, our thoughts were similar.&equo; 
 Brian Lane (schoolteacher): &bquo;One thing I remember about David was something that he didn't take part in, which was a concert held at the school in aid of a pavilion that was being put up by the parents and teachers, and being paid for by them. 
 So popular was this concert that there was no admission charge, only a collection, as it went on for two evenings, but strangely enough, David didn't offer to take part, although George Underwood did and he had a very popular group called George and the Dragons at the time. 
 However, later David did come and see me to ask if his group could play on the school steps at the PTA f&ecirc;te which was to be held in the summer, so I suppose that was one of his first public engagements with his group. 
 He was delighted to have the opportunity to do it. 
 I also recall that at least on one or two occasions, he'd dyed his hair which was almost unheard of in the early 60's. 
 However, some way or other, it was always washed out the next day and back to normal.&equo; 
 In common with most teenagers, David took a couple of part-time jobs, one riding around on a pushbike with a basket on the front for a butcher, and another working for a record shop owned by Vic Furlong. 
 George Underwood: &bquo;I remember how we used to hang around on Saturday listening to records. 
 We'd never buy anything. 
 In fact it was from Vic Furlong's shop that David bought his first saxaphone. 
 He couldn't play it at the time, but it made some really great noises. 
 When he saw the saxaphone he told his father about it and his father said that if he could save half the money, he would make up the other half.&equo; 
 Vic Furlong: &bquo;He was always a bit of a dreamer in that I'd give him a job to do, come back in about an hour and he was still chatting, the job unfinished, so he had to go. 
 He was a nice enough lad. 
 In fact, at the time I was involved with Bromley Theatre, and as some of his interest lay in this field, he wanted me to arrange an introduction. 
 But he was a bit of a dreamer &mdash; so he had to go.&equo; 
 Having acquired his first saxaphone, David got in touch with jazz saxophonist, Ronnie Ross , after finding his telephone number in the &bquo;phone book. 
 Ronnie Ross: &bquo;At the time he came to see me for lessons, groups like The Rolling Stones were just beginning to come into vogue although he was more interested in jazz, and we'd sit and talk about jazz and jazz musicians quite often. 
 He didn't talk about groups he was involved with but I did know that he was playing with a group. 
 He was quite an average sort of pupil, nothing out of the ordinary, and I certainly didn't expect him to become what he is today.&equo; 
 George Underwood: &bquo;We had periods when we would bring a guitar into school, particularly when it was raining. 
 It was what you called a &bquo;wet break&equo; and you weren't allowed to go outside. 
 There was a stairway leading from our form room which had good acoustics and we'd sit there on the steps, and I'd be playing guitar and David would be singing. 
 We did Buddy Holly stuff and Everly Brothers. 
 He was a good harmonizer and still is. 
 He was studying to be a commercial artist and when he was in Mr Frampton's art class (this was Peter Frampton's father) in his later tears at Bromley tech, Frampton lectured the form on how he would not tolerate tapered trousers.&equo; 
 Margaret Jones: &bquo;I remember David asked me to get my dressmaker to taper his trousers and before long other members of his form were also getting me to taper their trousers, so I suppose in a way I was almost helping them to rebel against Mr Frampton.&equo; 
 George Underwood: &bquo;When you leave school, you have to queue up and see a career's officer and I remember I was standing right behind David in the queue and asked him what sort of job he was going to say he was looking for. 
 &bquo;A saxophonist in a modern jazz quartet&equo; came the reply. 
 The careers officer offered him a job in a harp factory in Bromley!&equo; 
 David left school with 2 GCE &bquo;O&equo; level passes, in Art and Woodwork, and the school found him a job as a junior with a commercial art company, The Design Group Ltd., and although some early press releases said that David was expelled from school, the record shows that he left two or three days early to start the job. 
 Margaret Jones: &bquo;He only took the job for his father's sake because his father thought that all this business with groups and music could well be a passing fad and that at least if he spent a year or two at work, it would give him some stable grounding to fall back on. 
 So David did go to work there, though not without protest. 
 I can remember him coming home and moaning about his &bquo;blooming job&equo; and travelling up and down on the train.&equo; 
 It was 1963 and as David started his new job, &bquo;Mersey Mania&equo; was taking its stranglehold on the charts with The Beatles, Gerry and the Pacemakers, Freddie and The Dreamers; everything with a Liverpudlian accent tasted success. 
 Soon David left his job and, along with George Underwood, formed a band called The King Bees . 
 George Underwood: David was always a bit over the top and he decided to write to John Bloom, a millionaire business, saying something to the effect &bquo;Brian Epstein has got The Beatles but you can have us&equo;, but Bloom wasn't that interested and passed his letter to Les Conn, an agent.&equo; 
 Les Conn: The problem was John (Bloom) didn't know anybody in the music business except myself because I was quite well-known at that time in Tin Pan Alley. 
 Bloom got on to me and said he had received a letter from this young. 
 cheeky so-and-so and to give him an audition and see what he was like &mdash; which I did &mdash; and was quite impressed. 
 I got in touch with Bloom and said that I thought the guy had talent and Bloom told me that he was having a wedding anniversary party in Soho, which is in the centre of London, and to give the group &pound;20 and see what he was like. 
 &bquo;You cheap-skate,&equo; I said, what sort of millionaire are you? 
 You could at least give them about &pound;100 to pay for their expense. 
 Anyway, at the party, there was the aristocracy of the land and quite a lot of celebrities and of course, David and his group turned up in scruffy jeans.&equo; 
 George Underwood: &bquo;When we arrived, everyone was rather dressed up and we wore jeans, we were rather shabby looking and got some funny looks. 
 The first number we did was &bquo;I've Got My Mojo Working&equo; and the people in there weren't quite sure what was going on. 
 We didn't exactly get the bird but they just couldn't handle it &mdash; they didn't know what sort of music we were playing. 
 We were pretty much trying to emulate a lot of the early black blues sound. 
 With my guitar, I was trying to sound like Lightning Hopkins and John Lee Hooker and people like this, and we just thought&hellip; &bquo;this sounds OK&equo;, and it didn't sound too bad at the time. 
 So we were doing this music which was away from the pop stuff that was around. 
 Now &bquo;I've Got My Mojo Working&equo; doesn't go down with everyone, but at that time there were a few people around who did like that kind of stuff, and we were hopefully appealing to them.&equo; 
 Les Conn: &bquo;Well, of course, the people weren't prepared for that kind of entertainment and they all put their hands over their ears, and Bloom started screaming, &bquo;Get them off, they're ruining my wedding party&equo;. 
 So, when they'd finished performing I've Got My Mojo Working, I pointed out to David that these people didn't really appreciate their music and David, being the sensitive soul that he is, burst into tears. 
 I told him not to worry and that I was quite impressed and would be interested in managing the band. 
 That's how it began. 
 I used to get them various gigs at the Marquee Club in Wardour Street and the Roundhouse, and some dates at universities throughout the country, but there wasn't an awful lot coming in although I did succeed in getting him a TV appearance and the producer, who was a good friend of mine, said, &bquo;I'll not have this guy on my programme with long hair&equo;.&equo; 
 Dana Gillespie: &bquo;This was about the time The Beatles were just starting and they were considered to have long hair, but if you look at the pictures of them in those days, they had almost crew-cuts compared to David's which was honestly long, bright yellow, bleached blonde from a bottle. 
 He was an extraordinary sight. 
 In fact, I remember when I first introduced him to my father and before he'd said a word, I said, &bquo;This is my father&equo; who told me afterwards that he hadn't realized that it was a boy because I mean&hellip; long hair &mdash; his hair was really long. 
 Les Conn: &bquo;So anyway&equo;, I said to David, &bquo;I think you'll have to have your hair cut, otherwise you won't get this programme on television&equo;, to which he replied that he wouldn't cut his hair for the Prime Minister. 
 It was then that I conceived the idea of getting a few fans that he had in those days to walk around the television company with placards saying Lets Be Fair To The Long Hairs, which did get press publicity, and in the end, the producer relented and he did his first TV show.&equo; 
 Daily Mirror: &bquo;Davie, who comes from Bromley in Kent, said, &bquo;I have no intention of having my hair cut. 
 Mr Langford has left the matter open until Friday in case I change my mind, but I won't. 
 Mr Langford, 39, said, &bquo;Kids today just don't want this long hair business any more.&equo; 
 Les Conn: &bquo;By this time, I had arranged a recording test with Decca and David had his first single released called Liza Jane which was on Vocalion.&equo; 
 Dana Gillespie: &bquo;Actually, before the first single came out, he was doing a support act at The Marquee. 
 I can't remember who he was supporting, but I was a regular visitor because being a big blues fan, it meant I could go and see Sonny Boy Williamson, and all the people who would be at the Richmond Jazz/American Blues Folk Festival that came every year. 
 So I was down there watching The Yardbirds and the English bands that were starting, and one time there was this band &mdash; for some reason I was there early and watching the sound check &mdash; with this blond guy who had very long blond hair, and knee-length sort of sued, fringed, Sherwood Forest, Robin Hood-looking boots, playing a bit of sax on stage. 
 In the break before he actually started, I was standing at the mirror brushing my hair and he came up, took the brush out of my hand &mdash; I had very long, waist-length, peroxide blonde hair in those days &mdash; and he said, &bquo;What are you doing after the show?' 
 He just chatted me up. 
 In fact, I used to see him quite regularly as a boy friend. 
 He'd walk me home from school and it's often said that he carried my ballet shoes, which sounds kind of romantic, but he actually did sometimes, if I was carrying a whole load of things. 
 He'd meet me from school &mdash; I was at drama school then. 
 In those days I used to hang out at the Giaconda Cafe in Denmark Street where all broke musicians hang out, and I remember his first single came out and he dragged me into the record store next door, Francis Day &amp; Hunter, and he said, &bquo;Have a listen to this&equo;. 
 And then we bought a copy of the New Musical Express and saw a little ad that went with it. 
 They were quite good days because I knew absolutely nothing about the music business, being at school, and he was my first boy friend who wasn't upper class. 
 I had no idea there was a class distinction, having lived in a sort of world of my own, and when I went to meet his parents in his house in Bromley, I'd never been to such a small, little house where all the chairs had those things on the back where you catch the Brylcreem and you sat down and had high tea. 
 It was a kind of lifestyle I knew nothing about, having always lived in South Kensington. 
 People that I have known through the years in the music business always knew where to find me and I never moved address. 
 My parents lived in the big house and I built a studio and had a whole little place where I could live in the basement and it was very convenient, so David would come round there.&equo; 
 Les Conn: Anyway. 
 at the time, I thought, &bquo;This is ridiculous, I'm holding these boys back&equo; because I was also managing a singer called Marc Bolan, and in the quieter moments, he and David would decorate my office to fill in the time, but I said to them that I had just run out of money and couldn't afford to carry on &mdash; I'd taken no commission from either of them at the time &mdash; so I went off to Spain to think about my next move and released them both from their contracts.&equo; 
 By this time, The King Bees had released a second single but this time without David Jones, although George Underwood was still with the band. 
 David had moved from The King Bees to The Manish Boys  and released a single, &bquo;I Pity The Fool&equo;, and having supported Gerry and the Pacemakers, The Kinks and Gene Pitney on tour, joined up with a group called The Lower Third, consisting of Graham Rivens, Phil Lancaster and Denis Taylor.  
 Denis Taylor: &bquo;We decided we were going to have a new singer and hold auditions, the idea being that we would go to the old club we used to play in called La Discoth&eacute;que, which was in Wardour Street, not far from the Whiskey-a-GoGo. 
 The manager let us have it because he knew us. 
 Anyway, Davy came along and Steve Marriot also came along on that day, because quite a few people heard about it, as we put the word out at the Giaconda Cafe in Denmark Street. 
 Anyway, David was terrific, and we all made our decision in the Giaconda, and that's how it all really started. 
 We liked the stuff he was doing and he really started to develop an image for us as well. 
 We were quite long-haired &mdash; sort of early Rolling Stones type. 
 I think he was coming to the end of his management with Les Conn at the time. 
 He was a nice person and I think he was genuinely interested in how David was getting on, although he couldn't get him any bookings. 
 David was ambitious for all of us &mdash; he was honestly ambitious for all of us and we loved it. 
 He became a driving force. 
 He'd come to us with numbers he wanted to get off and I'd just play a chord on the guitar and he'd write a number round it. 
 He was the one that did all the pushing because he knew the business. 
 He wrote this little publicity thing under the name Truth Shows  and sent it to various places. 
 One of the places he sent it to was Happy Towers in Edgbaston in Birmingham, which was a Mecca ballroom, and that was the first gig we did, complete with a revolving stage and everything. 
 We barely knew any numbers at all at that time, but we got away with noise and after that we fast became the second loudest group in London playing gigs at Brighton, Hastings, Birmingham, Newcastle Tadcaster. 
 In fact, it was coming back from the Tadcaster job that the old Atlas van that we had, blew up &mdash; the big ends just blew out of it and we had to dump it there and go. 
 &bquo;Liza Jane&equo; and &bquo;Pity the Fool&equo; were released at the time we joined him because he brought this record along and said, &bquo;What do you think of this?&equo; 
 We were obviously impressed because he'd got a record released. 
 Anyway, it didn't get anywhere and the first record we released with David was &bquo;You've Got a Habit of Leaving&equo;, which we did at IBM Studios in Portland Street. 
 Just as the record was going to be released, Dave came round and told us he'd got another manager for us and it turned out to be Ralph Horton  who we'd auditioned for at The Roebuck Pub in Tottenham Court Road. 
 We were up on the top floor and Ralph Horton came up to listen to us and was impressed, although I think he was more impressed with David than us. 
 He was a queen, incidentally. 
 He had a boyfriend called Neil Andersen, who was German, I think, really blonde hair. 
 He was quite tall and very handsome, and I guess he was his assistant. 
 Anyway, he took a liking to David definitely, and from that point it was no longer a singer and a group, it had become a singer with a group, which is a different thing altogether. 
 When we went to gigs David used to travel in Ralph Horton's car and we used to have to go in the old ambulance which replaced the old Atlas van. 
 It was Graham who bought the old ambulance, not David. 
 Graham's father actually gave him the money to buy it from Brixton, after we'd been there to see it. 
 Anyway, David used to travel in Ralph's Mark 10 Jag to any gigs and never used to put any of the gear away when we'd done our work, whereas before he used to. 
 It was becoming obvious to us that Ralph was looking after David and we got hardly any money from the gigs. 
 Poor Graham and myself were really starving and not paying the rent, and David really started looking after himself. 
 I think he thought he was going to get somewhere with Ralph. 
 Mind you, Ralph did go the whole hog with it: he got Gaby Sturmer as PR doing photographs and write-ups and turned out some lovely leaflets. 
 I remember one particular night, the ambulance was parked in Warwick Square where Ralph lived &mdash; it was only about 50 yards from his flat and I was really cold. 
 It was horrible. 
 I was trying to get myself comfortable on these padded seat things and had a blanket over me. 
 I thought, &bquo;What the hell am I doing here when Ralph's flat is over there? 
 I'll go and sleep on his sofa in the lounge.&equo; 
 So I went over to knock on the door. 
 There was another fellow living at Ralph's at the time called Kenny Bell, who said, &bquo;I'm sorry, you can't come in&equo;. 
 I was amazes. 
 I then realizes what David was doing. 
 To me he was battering his career, because, before that we all worked as a team. 
 At every gig we went to, there was a woman there &mdash; that's what we wanted, we liked to see women hanging around the star attraction of the group because he was good-looking and he did stand out and look good on stage. 
 That's the quickest way to get a name, isn't it? 
 Have groupies around. 
 Davie always seemed to have the best girls, and none of them seemed to complain. 
 By this time my whole opinion of him changed. 
 Instead of him being a mate, I loathed him after that until I got used to the idea. 
 You do, eventually, get used to the idea. 
 I know Graham wasn't too happy. 
 I remember I went back to the ambulance feeling quite horrified. 
 I thought &bquo;Good God &mdash; it's the end of the group&equo; &mdash; which it wasn't until a few months later. 
 All this publicity we were getting was not getting us work. 
 It only got us the &pound;15 at The Marquee for doing a show for Radio London, the old pirate radio station. 
 We used to do the live show that was never broadcast &mdash; it was just the bit after all the other stars have been on stage and mimed to their records for the audience. 
 Anyway, that particular gig we did every Saturday morning. 
 It was for &pound;15 between four of us. 
 Of course, Ralph would want his bit out of that as well, so obviously we weren't getting enough to pay for the rent and food, which Graham and myself desperately needed. 
 We had three gigs on the trot, including The Marquee. 
 We had Stevenage Town Hall on the Friday, The Marquee on the Saturday morning and Saturday evening we had the Brummel Club in Bromley which was David's home town at that time &mdash; we'd received a hell of a lot of publicity for that one. 
 Anyway, at Stevenage Town Hall we told Ralph that we expected some money for these. 
 He said &bquo;No way &mdash; it's got to go into publicity&equo;. 
 I told him that we weren't eating and that we weren't paying the rent &mdash; almost destitute. 
 He said &bquo;No, sorry&equo;, to which we replied that we couldn't continue to play or back David if we weren't going to get any money. 
 He just said, &bquo;It's up to you&equo;. 
 We went down to The Marquee the following morning and I think Ralph came up to us and said that we could have the money for all the gigs, including the Brummel Club, but after that we were finished. 
 At the Marquee, Phil's father said that Ralph was using us &mdash; he just wanted us to play tonight and then it was all over, we're finished, so why didn't we finish now? 
 At the Brummel Club that evening, Ralph hadn't changed his mind &mdash; he said exactly the same thing &mdash; after tonight's gig you're finished. 
 So we told him that we weren't interested in tonight's gig and that we'd take the money and go now. 
 So we took the money for the two gigs and left them there. 
 I remember David started crying but Ralph would not back down and say we deserved the money, or to have some of it, so we just left them at the Brummel Club before doing their thing. 
 I don't know what happened at this particular gig, but I know it was his home town &mdash; it was the most important gig to David because it was in front of a home crowd. 
 But during the whole thing David never stuck up for us &mdash; that's what really got me. 
 The last I heard of Ralph Horton was when Dave chucked him and went with Ken Pitt.&equo; 
 Ken Pitt: I have a very clear memory of first meeting David. 
 It was in 1966 at The Marquee. 
 I went down there one Sunday afternoon to see him working. 
 He had a series of Sunday shows down there called the Bowie Show Boat and this was the second one. 
 I remember standing at the back of the club and just leaning against the wall and watching him. 
 It's very difficult to put a finger on what it was that attracted me about him. 
 I think, first of all, it was his amazing confidence and great personality. 
 He had a tight hold on the audience, totally in command of his band. 
 I liked the material he was doing &mdash; not all of it was his own, incidentally &mdash; but particularly. 
 I liked the way he used his entire body. 
 There was an eloquence about his hand movements and I realized also that he could be a dancer if he wanted to be. 
 I think these things were not common in those days and I was looking for someone who had great potential, and decided I'd found it in David Bowie. 
 He'd been making some records but they weren't successful and for the first few weeks after I'd met him and decided to work with him, I was listening to songs that he'd written, and was in the process of writing, and came to the conclusion that he was not essentially a singles artist. 
 The sort of material he was writing and playing, to me, was album stuff. 
 Now in those days you never got an album deal from a record company unless you had a hit single, but I made up my mind that the sort of stuff he had would make a very good album, so I went to Decca with that view in mind, trying to get an album deal, and did get a deal for him. 
 That's how we did our first album which was on the Decca label called &bquo;David Bowie' . 
 One of my old friends at Decca was Hugh Mendl and he was in charge of the singles department. 
 I played a couple of tracks to Hugh and he liked them very much and wanted to hear some more, so I took some more up to him. 
 It so happened that Hugh was the man who had been producing Tony Newley and he said to me after listening to those tracks that this was the most exciting thing to come into his room since Tony Newley which I thought was quite amazing since, some time later, David was quite infatuated with the work of Newley. 
 I think if you saw what David did afterwards, he was obviously attracted to the one-man show that Tony Newley was doing at the time like, &bquo;Stop The World&equo; and things like that, and the lyrics appealed to him. 
 he was so carried away with Newley that I believe quite unconsciously, Newley crept into Bowie's voice and, as you know, he's been accused of copying Tony Newley, but I don't think he was really aware of what he was doing at that time. 
 The album was produced by Mike Vernon and the engineer was Gus Dudgeon.&equo; 
 Gus Dudgeon: I hadn't heard of the guy before. 
 The thing I remember about him as an engineer was that we used to get these forms that told you each week who you were going to be working on, what the line-up was, and I saw this thing and it said David Bowie, Studio Two. 
 producer Mike Vernon, Gus Dudgeon, blah, blah, and this weird list of instruments like bass flute, contra bassoon, bass drum, etc and I thought this was very peculiar, but it was the early days of the Deram label and we used to do some pretty odd sessions. 
 So this guy came in, and he was just extraordinary. 
 He was obviously way ahead of his time. 
 he had a completely different way of doing anything from anybody else. 
 Whatever the rules were, they were not necessarily made to be broken, but they weren't necessarily there to be obeyed either. 
 he had a great attitude about him. 
 he was right at the height of his Anthony Newley hang-up, so one problem was constantly reminding him that he sounded like Anthony Newley and trying to &bquo;de-Newleyfy&equo; him if you could. 
 I remember people coming in from funny countries &mdash; you know, Turkish people and Indian people, and Americans coming in to play oboe. 
 I don't know where he got them all from but it was always very interesting, and we worked our way through an album that was subsequently released. 
 I must admit I really enjoyed working with him, and we did tracks like &bquo;The Laughing Gnome&equo; and I have to say, I am one of the gnomes on that record and am responsible for some of the terrible jokes on it as well. 
 So we &bquo;gnomed&equo; it for a while. 
 Then we did things like &bquo;Love You Till Tuesday&equo; which we did with a huge orchestra, as I recall, which was done in another studio. 
 After the album, we did two or three scattered tracks and various things, but as none of it really sold, we suddenly didn't see him around any more. 
 That was my first experience with him, basically.&equo; 
 Ken Pitt: &bquo;But the big value of that album was that it brought David's work to the attention of a lot of important people. 
 I remember I bought about 100 copies of it and sent it to various agents, bookers, and media. 
 One of them, in actual fact, got into the hands of Lindsay Kemp  and Lindsay used to use the album as background for his mime work at his concerts. 
 David heard about that, went along to see it one day, and that's how the partnership with Lindsay started.&equo; 
 Lindsay Kemp: &bquo;It had been arranged through NEMS&equo; office that we should meet. 
 I'd heard the voice of an angel &mdash; and when a meeting was eventually arranged between David and myself, through NEMS' who were handling both of us at the time, I expected a very pimply youth to be standing there. 
 However, when I opened the blue painted door at Bateman's building, there in fact was an angel. 
 Love at first sight. 
 It had already been love at first hearing. 
 Bowie and I immediately, from that moment standing in the doorway, hit it off. 
 We began work immediately. 
 He chose me as his master, which appealed to me enormously, as it's one of my functions in life to be a teacher, so I was very happy at being this kind of pedagogue. 
 We began to prepare a show which became Pierrot In Turquoise &mdash; turquoise because it's the British symbol of everlastingness and David claims that I saved him &mdash; not from Buddhism, not from everlastingness, but from becoming a Tibetan monk. 
 I do remember saying, &bquo;Look, you can give yourself to God but to me as well, and the public. 
 You don't have to leave any of us out. 
 You can be a marvellous entertainer. 
 You know the entertainer first gives himself to God and then the public.&equo; 
 I just gave him something on the side. 
 I didn't really teach him to be a mime artiste but to be more of himself, physically, on the outside. 
 My endeavour as a teacher really is to make people more of what I believe they are inside. 
 I enabled him to free the angel and the demon that he is on the inside. 
 It helped him to dance, but for me, to dance is a way of allowing and encouraging ourselves to escape through our fingertips, eyelids, lungs and tips of our tongues. 
 He already did it with his tongue, but up till that period his fingers were a bit stiff. 
 Mine had been a decade earlier when Marcel Marceau removed my hands from behind my back; hands, which at that period didn't resemble hands at all, but strawberry coloured boxing gloves. 
 Marcel gave me my hands and a generation later, I gave David Bowie his wings. 
 When we first met, there was a great deal of affection &mdash; there was a great deal of love and a great deal of admiration and respect as well you know. 
 I think that when love, and emotion, and passion, and sexual passion are mixed with respect, then that's the most ideal kind of relationship for me. 
 We weren't lovers from the beginning &mdash; it took about 30 seconds. 
 As a pupil he was marvellous, immediately responsive, especially when he was there. 
 Of course he wasn't always there because frequently there were notes from his mother to say that he had earache or something, but later on I realized, of course, that those notes had been faked, the same as the notes that I had sent to school from my mother several generations before that. 
 But I was fooled, like we always are when we're in love &mdash; blinded you know. 
 Then, of course, he'd send his friends similar notes &mdash; can't stay tonight, got terrible earache, or my mother's not very well &mdash; because for something like a year or more, he was having a double affair with, &mdash; dare I mention her name &mdash; Natasha Kornilof , who was a great friend of mine. 
 Of course, she had no idea.&equo; 
 Natasha Kornilof: &bquo;I have to say David never gave me any notes. 
 I don't question people very hard about where they've been. 
 I always take at face value what they say to me. 
 I'm fairly na&iuml;ve about it. 
 I never had any notes. 
 If Lindsay had notes &mdash; well tough &mdash; it's because he doesn't believe as readily as I do what people say to me. 
 If they don't over-elaborate the story I don't question it. 
 It's when they tell you more and more of a story &mdash; that's when you disbelieve. 
 Yes, this now celebrated affair, which I've not spoken about before, did actually happen. 
 He did give everybody the run-around, but was wonderfully attractive and, indeed, still is. 
 It's not surprising, is it? 
 He's very beautiful and very loving and a very great pleasure to be with. 
 What more can one say? 
 Lindsay always gave him hell. 
 Said he was as stiff as a ramrod and would get nowhere, but he's pretty hard on people anyway. 
 But, Lindsay is also a very good teacher. 
 He's taught an awful lot of people, including myself, an awful lot of things. 
 Before Lindsay, I made costumes &mdash; after Lindsay, I made magic. 
 That's what I owe to him. 
 I benefitted amazingly from the experience and I think almost anybody who has ever worked with Lindsay has benefitted from the experience. 
 It really is something, though he is hard on you and he is difficult. 
 David had a couple of records out at the time and he sang all his songs in the show that we did. 
 We toured the show &mdash; I was designer/driver. 
 We got a dreadful van from a man called Nick the Maltese, down the East End. 
 I'd never driven a van in my life but I managed to drive it from the East End to the West End, which I found a feat, and then I finally drove it up to Cumberland in the snow which was even more of a feat. 
 We were like a terrible gypsy encampment. 
 We arrived and stayed at a farm house with these people in Cumberland. 
 It was all extraordinarily unreal. 
 this tour we did. 
 Lindsay was Pierrot, basically, and the show revolved around him as Pierrot. 
 He did his various pieces of mime which were set pieces. 
 Some he'd learnt off the Frenchman &mdash; whose name is such a household name it escapes me &mdash; Marcel Marceau &mdash; and Jack Birkett (now known as The Great Orlando) was Harlequin, who could also be Columbine. 
 It was quite wonderful. 
 I made Jack shave his head &mdash; because he had the remnants of his hair hanging on &mdash; wonderful shape of ahead &mdash; shaved that off. 
 I put him in drag with a bare head. 
 It was quite amazing. 
 David was a character known as Cloud I think. 
 I dressed him in this huge pink shirt with maroon spots on, with a big maroon and pink ruff and little knee britches in grey with red velvet stripes on them. 
 Wonderful! 
 Absolutely beautiful! 
 He sang the songs that related quite indirectly to the next mime that took place and there was a slight story linking the whole thing &mdash; very slight harlequinade story &mdash; but it hardly mattered at all. 
 Basically it was the songs and a sort of mime play with Jack, Lindsay and David leading into a set piece with Lindsay as the old woman feeding the birds, which is a wonderful one, where the bird grows and grows to a monstrous size and finally devours the old lady. 
 I can't remember which of David's songs led into that &mdash; I shudder to think &mdash; but there was another lovely one about a little coat &mdash; sell me a coat because I feel cold. 
 There was Lindsay like this little tremulous Pierrot (because Lindsay was very little at the time &mdash; much thinner) in these little white tights, and the coat which was like a little 18th century golden coat came down from the flies, if we were lucky enough to have any up there. 
 Some of the places were extraordinary that we played. 
 Then he put this on and he instantly transformed into another character who did a mime to a piece of Baroque music. 
 He was doing a little minuet and he starts finding out things about his body. 
 He ends up doing surgery on himself and takes his heart out, listens to it like a clock and throws it to the audience. 
 It was a wonderful piece. 
 Very bizarre. 
 It was amazingly successful. 
 Everybody said it was magic. 
 I even did the scenery for that one. 
 I painted this wonderful front cloth for it &mdash; God knows where it's gone to since &mdash; I painted it on my sitting room floor with David's help. 
 He came and helped me lay it all in which was very nice. 
 The show went into penury, I think. 
 There were more and more debtors calling at Lindsay's door. 
 It was like something from a restoration comedy as he crouched in his flat in Bateman Street and they began beating down the door. 
 All these bills and demands. 
 I can remember sitting there one whole afternoon with him while he had flu or something, and these people beating down the door. 
 I was trying to make a list of what he owed and how we might get out of this state, which I don't think he ever got out of. 
 I think he got out of the flat first and not out of debt. 
 He was hard on David but David certainly was talented. 
 It was not until a few years later that I think his talent really started to manifest itself because you couldn't quite think where it was going. 
 They were very fey little songs and they were very pleasant, but they were not earth-shaking. 
 It was only when he began having fantasies about space men that he was really in there with the hit. 
 At that time, nobody wanted o sing about space men, did they? 
 But, as we can now see, it was like being a science fiction writer really. 
 That's been his main stock in trade I suppose &mdash; he's always just ahead with what he says.&equo; 
 Lindsay Kemp: &bquo;David Bowie struck me from the very beginning as being very versatile and very &bquo;up-front&equo; and not in the least bit na&icirc;ve. 
 He already seemed to know a hell of a lot and taught me a lot about living, philosophy and music. 
 It was an exchange &mdash; for me it has to be. 
 There's no such thing as a love affair unless there is an exchange. 
 When I talk about love affairs, I also include platonic love affairs. 
 I also include the love affair I have with the public each and every night. 
 For me, as a lover, as a person, as a man, it's not enough for me only to give &mdash; I want it back as well. 
 In other words, I want to be loved. 
 It's this marvellous giving and taking and sharing which provides these marvellous explosions which we call inspired moments which sometimes result in a work of art. 
 Pierrot In Turquoise &mdash; our first child &mdash; came. 
 Whilst David was continuing his studies with me, I was teaching at the Dance Centre in Covent Garden, which is an agency. 
 Every day, I always used to stick my head around the office door and say, &bquo;Anything for me today?&equo; &mdash; and one day they said, &bquo;Well, we're looking for dancers for the BBC's production of Pistol Shot (which was a play by Chekhov) &mdash; maybe you'd like to do it and choreograph it and use some of your students?&equo; 
 I took David Bowie and one or two of the other students to the BBC and we did it. 
 Hermione Farthingale  was one of the girls who had already been chosen and foolishly, I realized later, or maybe wisely, I partnered David and Hermione together because Hermione was extremely beautiful. 
 That wasn't the reason I gave her to David, but because she was a trained dancer and I thought she could help David get the simple steps of the minuet together, because he had difficulty in putting two steps together. 
 Anyway, afterwards they chatted over tea in the BBC canteen, and then he escorted her towards Shepherd Bush tube station, just turning his head over his shoulder towards me. 
 I was, of course, trailing behind about 10 paces, sulking. 
 &bquo;I'll give you a ring later&equo;, he said, and with Hermione Farthingale, David Bowie just walked out of my life. 
 She was an English rose and extremely beautiful. 
 I liked her immensely. 
 She was tall, and pale with ravishingly red hair. 
 I couldn't believe that anyone could love me and a lady equally, although I've had a lot of experiences since and I've known a lot of men and a lot of women since who have loved both sexes. 
 I only wish I could do that. 
 It would probably add to the complications in my life but it would probably lessen the hours that I have on my own, though God knows, I don't do too badly. 
 She and I were always friends, and David and I remain friends. 
 He'd already stabbed me in the heart several times before that with other ladies, but at least this time, there was a lady that I liked immensely. 
 I mean, if he'd gone off with a humped-back, three legged dwarf I would have felt pretty unattractive. 
 I tried to interest both David and Hermione in coming up to Scotland where I lived and to play, would you believe, in &bquo;Puss in Boots&equo;. 
 It was terribly na&iuml;ve of me. 
 By the time I'd asked him to come and play, he was already becoming a name in the pop music field. 
 &bquo;I can't&equo;, he said, &bquo;but how much are you offering?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's gone up since last time,&equo; I replied. 
 When we performed at The Intimate in Palmers Green, he was paid &pound;7.10 and at the Mercury Theatre in Notting Hill Gate, I think he was paid about &pound;4. 
 But anyway, I said we could pay something like &pound;25 a week, but by then Ken Pitt was finally getting him things. 
 I remember the periods that he went through, dish washing and doing house work and those kind of things. 
 But anyway, he and Hermione turned it down.&equo; 
 Having met Hermione Farthingale, David lived with her for a year. 
 It was during this period that he formed a mixed media trio called Feathers  comprising himself, Hermione and John Hutchinson  who came from Hull. 
 The mixed media trio did not prove successful but during that period of David's life he found work as an extra on the film The Virgin Soldiers  and appeared in a pilot television commercial for Lyons Maid, advertising their new ice-cream. 
 It wasn't long before Hermione left Feathers, leaving just David and John Hutchinson. 
 Angie Bowie: I actually met David for the first time when he was with feathers at the Roundhouse and I was with the European head of Mercury Records, a gentleman called Lou Reisner. 
 I met Hermione and David and John Hutchinson, who was the guitarist, at a show which was with the Scaffold and The Who. 
 During that period, I spent a lot of time with Calvin Mark Lee, basically because he was Lou Reisner's assistant, and he and I got on really well. 
 We used to like to go to clubs and I didn't like going by myself and Calvin was a great escort. 
 He was great fun and loved Chinese food, which I adored, so we knew all the Chinatown speciality restaurants. 
 It was him that arranged for David and I to meet. 
 This was after David had split up with Hermione and was nursing a broken heart. 
 Anyway, we went out to dinner and then went to a speakeasy. 
 King Crimson was being partied by a signing label and they got up and played with Donovan. 
 It was fabulous because King Crimson had such a tremendous sound and such a tremendous image that for them to suddenly stand up and do a lot of Buddy Holly hits with Donovan singing vocals was really cute. 
 It was a fabulous night. 
 David asked if I could jive and at this particular time I always dressed as a man, which was probably another reason Calvin and I got along very well because Calvin wore velvet suits and I wore velvet suits &mdash; so that was one area we got on very well. 
 But anyway, we jumped to it and started to jive and I decided that we were quite sympathetic and we got along quite well &mdash; a similar sense of humour, and  lewd  attitude towards women &mdash; we just basically got along well. 
 At the time I couldn't work legally in England and I had about two or three months to deliver my thesis for my degree. 
 I was going out with this guy called John Colley whose relations were sort of minor gangsters in London and I went to work for them because they didn't mind my not being English. 
 David and I went to the travel agency where I was working a couple of times and kept saying, &bquo;What are you doing here?&equo; 
 There was a travel agency in the foyer as you came in and a girl called Dinxie and I ran this travel agency that was open during licensing hours. 
 So, of course, what happened was that you had all these wonderful posters about you as you walked in the foyer and as the punters came out drunk, you sold them weekends in Ibiza. 
 It was all quite sensible but a little nefarious. 
 It was quite rough at times &mdash; and on one occasion, I found a body outside. 
 I called the police and was then told I was not required to work there any longer. 
 By this time David had started up the Arts Lab and asked me if I would teach street theatre and improvisation there, so I was destined to go to Beckenham.&equo;  
 Recording for &bquo;Ready Steady Go&equo;, David Bowie and the Buzz 
 The Ace Face in &bquo;66 
 David on the consumer trail, London &bquo;66 
 The famous Lower Third ambulance. 
 David's mime teacher, Lindsay Kemp 
 Mime shot by David's old manager, Kenneth Pitt 
 Plaistow Grove, Bromley (with white wall) 
 On the Isle of Wight ferry, 1965 
 On stage at The Marquee for &bquo;Inecto&equo; radio shows 
 Phil Lancaster, Davie Jones and friends, 1966 
 The original &bquo;Lower Third Mobile&equo;, 1965 
 Davie Jones, 1965 
 The Kon-Rads rock it up in South London 
 George Underwood, David's school friend 
 Bromley Tech, David's secondary school 
 No. 40 Stansfield Road, Brixton. 
 David's birthplace 
 Stockwell Junior School &mdash; David's Brixton Junior School as it is today 
 THE ARTS ODDITY 
 It was 1968. 
 David was now with his third manager, Ken Pitt. 
 Nine singles and one album had been released, but success still eluded him. 
 He had been involved with Buddhism to the point of almost becoming a monk, and had formed the mixed media troupe called Feathers, after studying mime under Lindsay Kemp. 
 But Feathers was to split when Hermione Farthingale decided she did not wish to continue with the group. 
 It was at this point that David met Mary Finnigan, a journalist living in Beckenham, for the first time. 
 Mary Finnigan: &bquo;I first met David in the summer of 1968 when I was living with my two children in a ground floor flat in an old house in Beckenham. 
 My top-floor neighbours were a couple called Christina and Barry Jackson, and Barry had been to school with David and George Underwood in Bromley, and being a neighbour, I was quite friendly with these two. 
 We used to socialize together and they used my garden as their flat didn't have one. 
 It was a generally free sort of relationship. 
 It was a warm, spring morning and I was lying in the garden, reflecting on life in general and taking it easy, when I heard this music coming from the top-floor flat where the windows were all open &mdash; and there was somebody singing. 
 The thing that attracted me was that it wasn't your average plonk, plonk, three cord amateur musician. 
 It sounded extremely good, so I, lying on my back in the sunshine, shouted up to the open windows, &bquo;Hello, who's playing that?&equo; 
 At this point a rather anaemic looking face with a halo of rather greasy looking blonde curls, poked his head out of the window, looking down at me lying flat on my back and said, &bquo;It's me, who are you?&equo; 
 I said, &bquo;I'm Mary, come down and have a cup of coffee.&equo; 
 So, Barry, Christina and David came down and we had coffee in the sunshine, and that was the start of it basically. 
 It was a couple of days later that I was alone in my flat in the evening and there was a knock on the door, I went to the door and opened it and there were about 10 people with an assortment of musical instruments &mdash; quite merry on this and that. 
 They asked to come in, announcing themselves as an instant party. 
 David was amongst them, and George Underwood as well. 
 At that stage, I think David was just crashing around. 
 He would spend an odd night here and an odd night there, ostensibly living with his parents. 
 He had recently split up with Hermione and was suffering from bruised emotions and in a way, was very much alone in the world, not to mention totally penniless &mdash; he didn't have two beans to rub together. 
 He was doing a bit of odd work here and there on an ad hoc basis, not musical work. 
 He was working in Legastat which was a photocopying office in London and when he needed the money, he'd go and do odd bits and pieces for them, but was not very happy with his circumstances. 
 Anyway, they all came in and we had this instant party which was very pleasant. 
 A couple of days later on, he came to visit me again, this time by himself. 
 He sat on a stool in my kitchen while I was cooking lunch and said, &bquo;Do you like this song? and proceeded to play &bquo;Space Oddity&equo;. 
 He had this little stylophone with him and played both parts, because &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; was originally written as a duet for him and Hutch who was his partner in Feathers, the mixed media group, and when David split with Hermione, he and Hutch were working as a duet. 
 &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; was written as a two-part song, and I recall he played this song in my tiny little kitchen in Beckenham and it sounded absolutely wonderful to me.&equo; 
 Ken Pitt: &bquo;It was 1968 and David and I were going across to Germany quite often to do television shows and on one occasion, the producer whose name was Gunther Schneider, asked us if David would be interested in doing a half-hour programme with him. 
 Of course, it was a very nice idea, but I had seen what the Germans were doing with colour television. 
 It was in its infancy in those days and I noticed that whenever David did a show for them, they dressed the set with every conceivable brightly coloured object, with the result you could hardly see him. 
 I thought no way were we going to have half an hour of this and thought why not make our own? 
 I suggested it to Gunther and he agreed, wanting to have first viewing. 
 We went home and made a half-hour colour television programme which was marvellous. 
 It played a very, very important part in David's career, because it was for that film that he wrote &bquo;Space Oddity'/ Most of the stuff on the film came from the Deram label but I thought we ought to have a very special piece of material &mdash; some new material &mdash; and something that would show how very fine and inventive a writer David was. 
 So, off he went and came back one day saying that he thought he had the song I'd been looking for. 
 He sat down and strummed it &mdash; it was &bquo;Space Oddity&equo;. 
 It was obviously a very clever song but it wasn't until we were recording it and filming it down at Greenwich Studios, that we realised its potential because. 
 during the break, after we had done this segment of the film and had gone into the canteen for lunch, all the people who had been working on the film were whistling the song. 
 As David walked into the canteen one of them said, &bquo;Here comes Major Tom&equo;. 
 At that point we knew we probably had the makings of a hit. 
 David had originally made a demo with John Hutchinson, a demo which had been taken to Philips who were releasing in this country for Mercury Records in America, and they all agreed that this would be the first single under that contract.&equo; 
 Mary Finnigan: &bquo;It emerged that David was looking for somewhere to live. 
 I had a spare bedroom and eventually, we agreed that he would come and live in my flat as a lodger &mdash; which is what happened. 
 I thought I was getting David and maybe a few personal possessions, but when he actually turned up, he was with a friend in a very large van, and this rather ethereal, thin, slightly spotty figure that was David in those days, dressed in extremely scruffy clothes, emerged from this van carrying a twelve string guitar, which it transpired was a present from Pete Townshend. 
 To my amazement, piece by piece, huge speakers, enormous amplifiers, old tape recorders and bits and pieces of audio equipment, along with mike stands and miles of wiring, was towed out of the back of this van. 
 As I looked at this mounting pile of equipment I thought that there was no way this was going to fit into the spare bedroom. 
 Of course, it never did. 
 As soon as David moved into my flat, what used to be the dining room was no longer the dining room &mdash; it was now full of audio equipment, stylophones, keyboards, amplifiers and huge speakers. 
 The whole flat, and the garden, within a very short space of time, was wired for sound and you would come in, perhaps in the middle of the night, and fall flat on your face over and leads and God knows what. 
 There would be blue sparks flying. 
 It was really what one would describe as almost a complete takeover. 
 After David had been there a couple of weeks, I used to go off doing odd bits of work in London, working as a journalist, although I wasn't very keen on that side of my life at the time &mdash; there were other things that interested me more. 
 It was a time when the whole underground culture was at its height and I was very much involved in that and had been since early &bquo;67. 
 I was going through what could only be described a &bquo;drop-out&equo; period. 
 There were quite a lot of drugs around at the time and somehow or other, I didn't quite know how, I managed to scrape enough together to feed my children and keep my flat going and just keep my life ticking over. 
 Being a divorced lady and living on your own with two children, poverty can be a real problem when you lead that sort of life style. 
 It was also a problem for David as well because he wasn't getting any gigs and he wasn't doing any recording work. 
 One evening, David, Barry, Christina and John Hutchinson were all sitting in my front room and talking about what we could actually do to earn some money It was suggested that we might go down to one of the local pubs which held regular jazz nights, to see if they had an evening free and perhaps we could run a folk club just one evening a week and maybe charge people to come in and make a few pennies for ourselves. 
 Having agreed that this was a good idea, David and I went down to a pub called The Three Tuns, which is in Beckenham High Street. 
 The landlord said that we could have the hall on Sunday evenings to run the club, and we could have it for nothing as he would make his money on increased bar sales. 
 Events having turned out better than we expected, we returned to make our plans for the following Sunday when we intended to open. 
 David designed the first poster for our first Sunday evening and stuck it up outside the pub. 
 I had a friend who had one of those ancient slide machines which was used to give light shows, and you could make the slides out of coloured oils and inks and put them together between two sheets of glass and when they're heated up inside the machine, they went, splat, splat, and made these rather beautiful moving colours. 
 The only problem was that by the time you had finished the slide show at the end of the evening you were covered from fingertips to armpits in coloured ink and oil and all the gunge associated with it. 
 It may have been revolting but the effect was wonderful. 
 But anyway we had this one projector which I had winkled out of this friend of mine, and we stuck it up on a couple of stools and hung some sheets up behind the corner of the room which served as a stage, and with some incense burning in the corner an atmosphere was created. 
 The idea was that Davis would be the anchor man, the resident musician, and every week we would have one paid performer who would be highlighted as performer of the week, a tradition that was kept up throughout the history of the folk club and the Arts Lab. 
 On the opening night, David did the major part of the entertainment himself, singing and playing tapes when he wasn't performing live. 
 We used his PA system which was a bit ramshackle, but it worked &mdash; that was the main thing &mdash; and about 25 people turned up in the little mock Tudor, oak panelled dining room that was part of The Three Tuns pub in Beckenham. 
 But, it was a start. 
 By the second week, it looked as if it was going to catch on. 
 George Underwood designed the poster and 50 people turned up. 
 We had doubled our audience. 
 It appeared that we had fulfilled a need among people. 
 We just hit at the right moment and from that week onwards, at least 90 people turned up every week. 
 In fact, we were beginning to pack the place to the point where the landlord was extremely worried because there were far more people in than should have been. 
 The club, by now had spilled out into a sort of annexe conservatory at the back of the room and by the time the summer arrived, people were spilling out into the garden and, in fact, used to come into the club by this route illegally. 
 It wasn't long before we realised there were many other talents around who wanted to be part of it. 
 It was becoming something more than just a folk club. 
 People came to read their poetry, they distributed their art work, they hung paintings and pictures on the walls, and they came along with things they had made, joke jewellery and candles and posters, selling them in the conservatory. 
 All sorts of little sub-businesses grew after the first month or two and it was at this point that we thought it would be nice to turn it into something more than just a folk club. 
 So, one night, it was decided to ask the audience if they wanted an Arts Lab, and during one of his talks to the audience, as David also acted as comp&egrave;re, he asked whether they would like an Arts Lab in Beckenham, with the folk club being the start of it. 
 The response was tremendous; the reaction incredibly enthusiastic, and so from that point, it became a little more than a folk club. 
 It became the local community creative scene encompassing not only music, but mime, drama, poetry reading and in fact, an outlet for local cottage industry. 
 And that's how it all happened. 
 All sorts of people since then have speculated on how the Arts Lab started, and various different books and publications about Bowie's career have put it in all sorts of different context, but that is how it happened. 
 It was a thing that was created by popular demand. 
 People wanted it and it seemed to be the right thing to do &mdash; and we did it. 
 I remember on opening night, a group of musicians arrived led by Roger Wooton, calling themselves Comus. 
 They were to become, more or less, the Arts Lab resident band.&equo; 
 Roger Wooton: &bquo;David Bowie was the resident singer/ song writer &mdash; a sort of folk-pop singer/ song writer and we were a sort of rock/acoustic band &mdash; flute, violin, acoustic guitars and female vocalist, doing sets each week at the club which was the start of our career. 
 David Bowie used to play material like &bquo;Space Oddity&equo;, &bquo;Janine&equo;, &bquo;Port of Amsterdam&equo; &mdash; in fact, the early material which appears on the &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; album which, at that time, hadn't been recorded. 
 He used to just sit there with a 12 string guitar and often used a tape recorder with backing tracks, and then put on a harmony live or used a stylophone. 
 He was a rather fey, quiet, intelligent, but not particularly giving of himself. 
 To me, he seemed like an average folk/pop singer/ song writer. 
 No more, no less. 
 He wasn't particularly impressive live and in fact, the audience weren't particularly impressed with him. 
 The only reason he was there every week was because it was his gig and he had arranged the Beckenham Arts Lab. 
 He was sort of evasive and fey and appeared relatively shy and my impression of him at the time was that he had little charisma, no star quality and not a lot of talent, and it came as a big surprise when he became as successful as he was. 
 The club itself was mainly hippies &mdash; art students and hippies &mdash; there were a lot of drugs around and the Three Tuns used to stink of dope every week. 
 There were lots of dealers there and lots of dope going around and David, to some extent anyway, seemed slightly an outsider, being very quiet and just arranging the gigs, but he was never really a part of what was going on. 
 When I first met him he was just an averagely quiet spoken, fairly intelligent hippie and gradually, the perversity and debauchery crept in. 
 He started wearing women's clothes, he started putting on make-up and on the last couple of times that I saw him he was pretty strange. 
 By this time Angie had entered his life and she was going off with the ladies and he was going off with the boys &mdash; and that's the way it was.&equo; 
 Mary Finnigan: &bquo;Angie was very young and very wild in those days &mdash; real madcap. 
 I got the impression very quickly that she was going through a period where she was experimenting a lot with what she could get away with as an individual. 
 She used to engineer situations by throwing freak-outs and being very of-the-wall on more than one occasion. 
 It was a time before I began to understand her a little better and realise that a lot of this was actually a sort of &bquo;attention-getting&equo; &mdash; a bit of theatre just to see how people would react &mdash; to manipulate situations a little. 
 It wasn't that serious. 
 She was very young, 18 or 19, and relatively immature although much more worldly wise than I was because she had lived a much more international sort of life, and having been around the music scene a lot more than I had, she was streetwise at her age to a greater degree than I &mdash; there was no question of that. 
 It was quite interesting how she first materialized. 
 I had been away for the weekend and David Bowie is not the most domesticated person in the world. 
 In fact, I would go as far as to say he's a slob. 
 He always expected other people to clean up after him. 
 He was totally oblivious of mess and basically needed an army of servants keeping things organised around him. 
 If I had gone away for a couple of days, I returned expecting almost to have to push the door open but to my amazement, the place was immaculate. 
 I walked through one room after another. 
 There was no dirt, no dust, no dirty dishes &mdash; it was tidy, neat as a pin, clean. 
 sparkling and looked like it hadn't been touched, and I couldn't believe it. 
 So, being a nosey bugger, which I am, I went into David's room and looked around for some evidence of what actually might have happened that weekend because I was completely stunned. 
 Eventually, I found a song on a scrap of paper by his bed. 
 It was a song or a poem &mdash; I don't know which but to my knowledge it has never been published &mdash; which was called &bquo;Beautiful Angie&equo;, and I clicked immediately and realised there had been another woman about the house. 
 Gradually, it became apparent that this lady was definitely part of David's life. 
 Now my relationship with David did actually include sex, but it was never initiated on that basis as he'd come to my flat only as a lodger and during the course of the time he was there, we slept together. 
 At the time, the idea of a strong exclusive relationship was something that I did not actually want and I don't think that even consciously at that time, I would have sought to have had that kind of relationship with David who was considerably younger than me and also, even though I was deeply into the whole scene and everything it represented, I don't think I actually wanted to settle down with somebody who was a musician and was leading that sort of life style. 
 But even so, when Angie first materialised I suppose I was a bit put out for two or three days. 
 I was quite open to her presence and accepted her as part of the household and she charmed me very nicely &mdash; she was good at that. 
 She was a very nice person; I liked her very much. 
 She made a very positive effort to be the right kind of person to be around &mdash; in other words, she was not a liability, she was an asset, an extremely good cook and a very good organiser, and having discovered that we both went to the same school in Switzerland where French was the main language taught, we would enjoy talking to each other in French, much to the annoyance of David who couldn't understand the language.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;Mary an I got on really well &mdash; we had a hoot and always enjoyed each other's company, and although the Arts Lab was still running, it was beginning to get out of hand. 
 It was changing into an enormous project with tentacle-like bureaucratic things. 
 It was now called Growth and to get a decision on anything, you had to have a committee meeting, and as I pointed out, if it was going to continue this way, David would lose interest totally. 
 I could feel that the problem with David was very much a tremendous lack of application. 
 A tremendous talent, but unless things were made very easy for him to get on and do things that he wanted to do, he would lose interest very quickly. 
 Mary was aware of this too and tried very hard to explain this to all those other people who were involved. 
 There were so many people that had become involved in this now enormous creature that resided in Beckenham called Growth. 
 It got to the point where you could have one musical act, then you'd have a puppeteering act, all on a Sunday night under the guise of the Beckenham folk club. 
 It was the psychedelic 60s and drugs were beginning to their part in the Arts Lab, and I recall at one point David lecturing the audience on the dangers of taking drugs.&equo; 
 Mary Finnigan: &bquo;We were extremely righteous about our drugs in those days. 
 Alcohol was considered bad news. 
 Few people drank amongst our circle of friends. 
 We smoked dope and people who wanted to would take sillacybin, mescalin or LSD, and that was literally it. 
 There was nothing else considered to be OK. 
 They were the drugs of awareness. 
 They were not anaesthetics. 
 They were things that you took to blot out your life. 
 They were things that you took to enhance your experience and to make it more intense &mdash; to make your personal development became part of your life, It was a very high-minded approach and when one looks at what has happened to the drug scene today and one looks back to the prevailing attitudes at the time, one can see the absolute, total abhorrence among drug takers that I knew in those days of amphetamines, heroin, barbiturates, mandrax &mdash; all those things that had an adverse physical effect which were considered to by highly dangerous to one's personal development and to one's daily living. 
 David used to get drunk and on many occasions I had to pick him up and carry him home from London, absolutely pissed out of his brain. 
 He drank barley wine which is quite strong stuff and he'd smoke a few joints as well, but to the best of my knowledge, he wouldn't touch any hard drugs at all. 
 During the time I knew him, he never took acid as he was very much afraid of it, and counselled other people against it in the sense that he felt it might disturb them psychologically, and felt that's what might happen to him 
 He didn't want to exacerbate what he saw as an existing weakness of his own in that respect, and although he was not censorious of other people, I think he was genuinely quite frightened of it, and at one point in the Arts Lab, when there was quite a lot of speed pills, amphetamines, going around amongst the young people there, he did speak out very strongly one evening against it, saying that he personally did not want anything like that around anything he was closely involved with because he felt that it was not a good thing for people to be speeding and it created the sort of vibes that might end up causing problems. 
 He was absolutely right in that respect and I remember him delivering this homily at The Three Tuns and the people receiving it in a rather stony silence because they were not used to being lectured. 
 In fact, I think quite a lot of them took it to heart. 
 He did see himself very much as a responsible figure as far as other people's well being was concerned when it came to this, and this was probably based on the fact that his step-brother, Terry, by his mother's previous marriage, was classified as schizophrenic, a problem which David felt could be hereditary.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;With the Arts Lab in full swing, Ken Pitt was ironing out the finer points of a new record deal with Mercury Records and in his own way was very lucid about David because he never actually saw him rooted in England or rooted only in rock and roll. 
 He had arranged for him to fly to an Italian song festival which wasn't just Italian, it was an international song festival, of the lesser variety, but one which paid money. 
 The first half was in Malta and the second half in Monsummano-Terme and arrangements had been made for David to fly out there with Ken Pitt and perform &bquo;When I Live My Dream&equo;, one of the songs on David's first album. 
 The plan was that I was to remain in England and organise the Arts Lab with Mary Finnigan and see it didn't fall apart.&equo; 
 Mary Finnigan: It was at this time, when David flew out to Malta, then not only were we organising the Arts Lab but a free open air festival in Beckenham, David, having flown out to the Maltese song festival had sent Angie a postcard saying something to the effect that he was going to be in Italy and why didn't Angie come and join him, which she did, leaving me to sort out both the folk club and the free festival organised for Beckenham Park the following Sunday.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;Anyway, I went out there and it was very romantic. 
 It was not as I had expected at all because living in the kind of commune that Mary Finnigan's house was, there wasn't a lot of time for romance. 
 It was a lot of sort of hippies pulling together to pull something off &mdash; hardly your Daily Mirror love nest, if you get my drift. 
 Being quite intuitive, I did notice there was a funny tension between Ken Pitt and David and I thought that probably what had happened was that David had not been satisfied performing &bquo;When I Live My Dream&equo; with the old backing tracks, as he had been working with Tony Visconti and had all these new tunes and productions and ways of doing things in his head. 
 I don't actually know &mdash; I'm surmising &mdash; but one tends to be fairly observant and that is what I felt. 
 There had obviously been a couple of heated arguments, probably to do with the artistic&hellip; you know, you get bored with something that you've done before and you're working on a new project, and I think he thought that having to wear a suit as opposed to his choice of stage gear can be very nerve-racking. 
 The suit he wore was fabulous &mdash; a sort of electric blue braiding, a nice little cabaret job. 
 I don't mean to sound unkind, because it isn't. 
 He looked very nice in it and he did win the contest, so Ken did know what he was doing. 
 The problem was that I think David was moving so much away and into this trip of actually doing music with a message &mdash; of actually delivering something on stage which meant something to other people of his age. 
 By now he had become aware that he had powers to lead people because of the Beckenham Arts Lab and Growth. 
 He realized that he was somebody who could control people. 
 If he actually put his foot down and said, &bquo;No, I think that's ridiculous&equo;, everyone shut up and listened, and I feel that this was the first time that he realised that he did have the powers of leadership, not only on stage but also off stage.&equo; 
 Mary Finnigan: &bquo;While David and Angie were away with Ken Pitt at the song contest I received a telephone call from David's father asking when David would be back. 
 I said I didn't know, and thought no more of it and it wasn't until David returned and was performing at the Arts Lab on the Sunday night that I remembered and said to David, &bquo;Oh, by the way, while you were away I had a message &mdash; your father is not very well&equo;. 
 He went ashen and screamed at me, &bquo;Why didn't you tell me earlier?&equo; 
 He finished his set and was gone.&equo; 
 Mrs Margaret Jones: &bquo;David arrived home carrying the statuette that he'd won at the song contest that he'd been to with Ken Pitt and dashed straight upstairs to see his father who hadn't been well for a number of days. 
 David handed the statuette to his father telling him he'd won the contest and his father told him he knew he would succeed in the end. 
 He died not long afterwards.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;I was still in Cyprus when David called me. 
 It was the most horrific thing. 
 His father had died of pneumonia. 
 My dad said he'd buy me a ticket to fly back to England and David said that he'd pay him back because he'd be very happy if I could come back and help him as he didn't really know how to deal with his mother's grief. 
 I arrived to a house stricken with grief in Plaistow Grove, Bromley, and it wasn't easy. 
 There were only two bedrooms and I had to share a bedroom with David's mother, a living arrangement that I just wasn't used to. 
 I felt David's mother didn't really like me, and having to share a bed with her really drove me nuts. 
 I tried to be as patient as I could and I think David's mother has realised for quite a long time that I was quite a good daughter-in-law to her (although I wasn't a daughter-in-law at that time) but as a girl friend, I could understand her finding it obnoxious that her son brought some strange person into the house. 
 She wasn't mean about it, she was very grateful to have someone to talk to and I used to try to spend a lot of time with her just to cheer her up &mdash; you know, walk the dog with her and go shopping &mdash; just do all the things that would help. 
 But it was very trying and I don't know if it was like a part of me that was being grabbing or trying to weasel my way into David's affections. 
 I don't think so because I'm not really like that and people who know me know that I'm not like that. 
 I think I just put up with it because he behaved in such extraordinary ways to me in the time I had known him, of showing affection at all? 
 Which he didn't show anyone else, and I felt privileged. 
 I really thought I was not only his girlfriend but someone that he really trusted because he knew I was energetic and dynamic and could get things done.&equo; 
 Tony Visconti: &bquo;I remember when David's father died he was very solemn, as anybody would be when their father dies, and he took the responsibility of looking after his mother very seriously. 
 I think his mother was a very low-key housewife who depended very heavily on her husband to do everything &mdash; to write the bills and all that &mdash; a very dependent housewife, and David automatically assumed the role of his father in matters of domestic finance. 
 He appeared to grow up instantly and became very serious. 
 I think his father's death had a very profound effect on him because his Dad was the only one who was level-headed. 
 Even David could be flippant and bizarre and go off and do his own thing, and Dad was the one person in the family who was the anchor.&equo; 
 Mary Finnigan: &bquo;A few days after the death of David's father, the free festival went ahead as planned and the day was fabulous; the sun shone and everybody but everybody had a wonderful time. 
 There was music, puppet shows, street theatre, side shows, stalls. 
 Angie was running the hamburger stall &mdash; I don't think she has ever cooked so many hamburgers in her life. 
 The day was fabulous and David performed extremely well although he was in the blackest of moods. 
 He was extremely rude to a lot of people, some of whom vowed they would never speak to him again. 
 Calvin Mark Lee, from his new record company, donated posters for us to sell at the festival and he was extremely rude to Calvin, which is very strange when you think of the lyrics to &bquo;Memory Of A Free Festival&equo; which he wrote after the event: &bquo;I kissed a lot of people that day&equo;. 
 He certainly captured the feeling of that gorgeous sunny day in Beckenham Park, but it was not his own feeling. 
 I think that he'd reached a stage in his life where he was to become less community minded and more geared toward the fulfilment of his own career.&equo; 
 Tony Visconti: &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; had been recorded and released at this time although it was not selling. 
 In fact, I remember first hearing the song. 
 We were putting an album together based on his light rock/folk style that he was developing &mdash; songs like &bquo;Janine&equo;, &bquo;Unwashed And Slightly Dazed&equo; &mdash; all that country rock flavour that he was developing and then, out of the blue, he wrote &bquo;Space Oddity&equo;. 
 Now I know David &mdash; he is very original. 
 All his chord changes are very original and his melodies are. 
 And here came &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; which was coinciding with men landing on the moon, which is what I think inspired him to write it, there is no question about it. 
 David had come up with something that was extremely unoriginal. 
 What I'm saying is, &bquo;Here am I sitting in a tin can&equo; sounded exactly like a Simon and Garfunkel record, and the rest of the song was lifts from everything else. 
 Nowadays, I would probably have a complete reverse opinion and say, &bquo;Well done, David&equo;, but in those days I honestly didn't care. 
 I wasn't going for his agreement or anyone else's agreement &mdash; I was going for what I felt was right at the time, and as he'd set me up as this person in his life, I advised him not to do it. 
 However, everyone else advised him to do it and it was probably the most catalystic thing he could have done at that period, although I had the feeling even if he did get a hit, it was something he couldn't follow up because I knew the style of his writing. 
 He wasn't writing anything remotely like it and he didn't afterwards. 
 He just continued writing more of the same stuff that was going on his album. 
 &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; was just 0ne-off and it wasn't until &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo; that he did anything even remotely like it. 
 Having told me that everyone was advising him to record it, I told him to go ahead and do it, but not with me. 
 Gus Dudgeon, who I used on some earlier Deram sessions, said he'd like to work with David, so here was his chance and I put the two of them together.&equo; 
 Gus Dudgeon: &bquo;I was sitting back in my office and the internal phone rang and it was Tony Visconti, whose office was literally just down the hall. 
 &bquo;I've got an old pal of yours in here &mdash; David Bowie&equo;, he said, &bquo;we're talking about making an album but he's got this song which I don't like at all, but you might care for it. 
 Do you want to have a quick listen?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure&equo;, I said. 
 So, he popped down to my office, stuck this demo on the turntable and it just blew my socks off. 
 I couldn't believe it. 
 I rang Tony and said, &bquo;You really can't be serious about not wanting to record this song.&equo; 
 &bquo;I just don't like it&equo;, he replied. 
 I think he had a thing about it particularly because he knew the record company really was going for that song because the first American space shot was coming up. 
 But actually, I don't think the record company realized just how good the song was. 
 It was just that their minds went &mdash; &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; &mdash; guys are going into space &mdash; sounds like a commercial idea &mdash; go for it. 
 So, the underlying part of the contract, as I understand it with Bowie, was that he was going to make an album with Tony Visconti and that song had to be done as a single. 
 But, of course, Tony didn't like the song, so he asked whether I'd do it, and that's how I came to do the record.&equo; 
 I can remember the session very well. 
 The players were Tony Cox on drums, Rick Wakeman on mellotron and Herbie Flowers on bass, who I learned recently, was paid &pound;7.10 for that session, which was his first professional session. 
 I recall I think we possibly planned to use strings right from the word go and David, without my knowledge, went to Paul Buckmaster and asked whether he was interested in writing the string parts. 
 When Paul called me back to ask whether he was serious about this, I replied, yes, although I must admit I didn't hear strings and flutes on &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; at the beginning but once the track was done, it was obvious that it was going to work really well. 
 The other thing that I remember was that this session was very quick. 
 As we were mixing the B side, this guy called Calvin Mark Lee, who worked for the record company, was actually off at Philips cutting the A side. 
 Literally as we were mixing the B side he was over here cutting the A side. 
 It was really high pressure sort of stuff followed by this terrible waiting period, because no sooner did the record come out, and the space shot take off, the BBC banned every record that had anything to do with the moon. 
 They even banned an instrumental called &bquo;Footsteps on the Moon&equo; by Johnnie Harris. 
 I think they were so nervous to play anything that would imply for the space shot or against the space shot &mdash; whether the guys were going to come back or not. 
 It was pathetic really. 
 So, no sooner did the record go into the charts and we were going &bquo;yeah, this is it &mdash; hooray &mdash; we're taking off&equo;, they dropped the record and we had to wait for the guys to come back to earth. 
 Luckily they came back without any harm and the record was then re-released, re-promoted and interestingly enough, as far as I can recall, it's one of the very early stereo singles. 
 I seem to remember they put it in mono and did a limited edition in stereo which, for those days, was a fairly advanced piece of thinking. 
 As a producer &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; was very important to me as it was only my second or third record and I was looking forward to seeing David play it live. 
 The gig was at the Purcell Rooms and he was playing with a band called Junior's Eyes. 
 Obviously he built up to &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; being somewhere in the middle of the set and about half way through the set, he dismissed the band. 
 I thought he was just going to do a couple of acoustic numbers. 
 He went on and played &bquo;Space Oddity&equo;. 
 Just an acoustic guitar and a backdrop of the sun shining. 
 I couldn't believe it &mdash; what a weird thing to do. 
 Like, here was his first big song and everybody had come to see it, and he's not going to do it with a rhythm section &mdash; just acoustic guitar. 
 The whole audience was astounded and it didn't go down very well. 
 It would have been far better if he'd done it the other way around &mdash; the rest of the set acoustic and then brought them on to play. 
 It was just so bizarre. 
 Another amusing incident to come out of &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; was when I got a phone call from David one day, who said he had to record an Italian version of the song because two kids in Italy had apparently done a cover version of it and as it looked as if it was going to do quite well, the Italian record company wanted a version by the original artist and said they would send someone along to teach Bowie phonetically how to sing the song. 
 Anyway, we went down to Morgan Studios in Willesden High Road and this Italian guy showed up at the studio. 
 He was basically directing the session because I didn't know Italian, neither did David. 
 He wrote out all the lyrics phonetically, so when he had to sing an Italian word, it was written down exactly as it should be pronounced. 
 It was an hilarious session. 
 At the end of it when the whole vocal had been recorded, David said to this guy, &bquo;Just out of interest, is this my original lyric&equo; The guy said, &bquo;Oh no, it's a beautiful ballad about a boy and girl and they go out in the mist on the mountain&equo;. 
 &bquo;Good God&equo;, we said, &bquo;are you serious? 
 This is about people in space.&equo; 
 &bquo;No&equo;, he said, &bquo;it's about a love story.'&equo; 
 Tony Visconti: &bquo;I heard the finished version of &bquo;Space Oddity that David had recorded with Gus Dudgeon a few days later and it was great. 
 I figured out that if this is what David wants and I'm not going to give it to him. 
 then I'm perfectly happy to let Gus take over the responsibility since he did such a great job. 
 But David surprised me by saying, &bquo;OK, now we've got that out of the way, let's go and do the rest of the album&equo;. 
 He didn't believe in it himself. 
 He said that he did it because everybody wanted him to do it, and he even agreed with me that bits were like Simon and Garfunkel and it sounded like a hundred songs written before, and admitted that he was cashing in on the moon landing but thought he could make some money doing it. 
 Looking back, I said it would hurt his career. 
 It didn't hurt it, but it didn't exactly help it. 
 It was about two and a half years before he wrote anything like it again. 
 But anyway, we finished the &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; album and promoted it a bit. 
 I do remember we did a few gigs. 
 I was on bass, David was on acoustic guitar and we got this guy called Tex, he was a black conga player and came around with us doing a few gigs, although nothing really happened. 
 I remember we did a live version of &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; with acoustic guitar, bass and congas and it didn't go down so well.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;During this period we were still living with David's mother which certainly moved my rear end out into finding somewhere to sleep because having to sleep with someone really freaked me out. 
 So I was looking around the Beckenham and Bromley area when I found this place called Haddon Hall which was an amazing property. 
 It was the three main reception rooms of an old Victorian folly built for the Crystal Palace Exhibition, backing on to Beckenham golf course which, I suppose became a very desirable place to be out of London in Victorian times. 
 They built these houses onto the back of the park which became the golf course. 
 It was an enormous red folly with balconies all around the back and to the gardens at the sides, and had been divided into apartments. 
 There were seven flats in the building but the three main reception rooms and the hallway and gallery which went round and then, of course, up to the upstairs room, had been blocked off. 
 The hall and the gallery and the enormous stained glass windows which faced the door as you came in, and the three reception rooms were ours, and as I suffer from terrible claustrophobia, I thought it was a wonderful place to live although David, who I am sure doesn't suffer from claustrophobia as badly as I do, being British and like most British people, would be content to live in smaller environments. 
 He thought it was fabulous because I guess he just wasn't used to living in all that space and the idea of living in this enormous rambling series of rooms appealed to him very much. 
 Unfortunately, prior to our moving in, 27 cats had lived there with a professor of history and his wife who were a little eccentric. 
 There were a lot of plants and the cats felt they were in a jungle of their own in the hall. 
 You can imagine the smell! 
 But at 20 years of age I had no scruples about rubber gloves and bleach, and dealt with the problem straight away. 
 It was rather grubby so we just painted it all white and, as I suspected, David's imagination, after it was painted, came into heavy play. 
 It took six months for us to talk the owner into agreeing to let us rent the place. 
 I think this was due to the fact that we didn't have 9-to-5 jobs and we were entertainers and couldn't possibly manage the &pound;7 a week rent. 
 In the end I remember I said to him that I was just a spoilt Yank and my father sent me money so he needn't worry about a thing. 
 Anyway, we moved in. 
 It was the coldest time of the year and the first thing I insisted on was having a telephone. 
 David didn't think it was a good idea but I said we couldn't keep going out and using the phone box down the road. 
 &bquo;I'm telling you&equo;, he said, &bquo;it's not a good idea&equo;. 
 Little did I know how right he was because the first thing that happened when David's mother had a bad day, she would call me everything under the sun. 
 Basically that David had moved out of Plaistow Grove to leave her on her own to die, to live with the fancy whore from America, and yet on other days, of course, I was perfectly lovely and would come and shop with her and do everything. 
 Being as it was David's mother, an older person, it never occurred to me to get mad or upset. 
 I would get mad when I put the phone down and cry a lot, but certainly I wouldn't get mad with her.&equo; 
 Tony Visconti: &bquo;When David and Angela found the enormous Victorian house, Haddon Hall, in Beckenham, my girlfriend and I went along to see it and we loved it. 
 It was the most incredible place we had ever seen. 
 It was like a mansion. 
 We decided to share the place together and pool our resources. 
 It was very strange. 
 I thought we could get on with him but I think within a week of moving in there we became entangled in David and Angela's personal lives. 
 It was a very bizarre one &mdash; always turbulent and very strange. 
 My girlfriend and I were a conventional hand-holding couple and David and Angela were going to gay clubs at midnight and bringing home people at four in the morning which made things very tense, I would say.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;As Christmas drew near, &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; became a hit single in England, going on to win an Ivor Novello Award. 
 Strangely enough, Ken Pitt wouldn't let me go with him, or his mother for that matter, to receive the award. 
 Ken wanted to rake David to this thing on his own and David, being very, very cold &mdash; he hates demonstrations of emotion &mdash; and me being very Mediterranean, I told him that as far as I was concerned, I didn't give a fuck about his award or seeing him receive it, but I thought it was a bit much that his mother couldn't be there because it was a public occasion and it was a time when, without having to speak to her, he could be nice to her, as every mother loves to be there for that kind of thing. 
 David wasn't very happy about me being so blunt, but I think in a way it made him realise that I was really straightforward and that I really did care. 
 It wasn't long after the conversation about the Ivor Novello Award that he became much more resolved that he didn't need Ken Pitt as manager, so I said to him that the only thing he could do in that case was to get an attorney who would break the contract. 
 He replied that he had tried to get an attorney to break the contract and that he had spoken to this lawyer and that lawyer. 
 At the time I was involved in various things at Philips Records and I asked someone if they knew of anyone who could get David out of his contract, and was told that he knew a man called Tony DeFries who was actually not allowed to practise at the bar &mdash; he was a consultant, a trouble-shooter, divorce cases. 
 He suggested we go and talk to him, so I said to David, &bquo;Well, here's this guy &mdash; I don't know what he's going to do, but let's go and see him.&equo; 
 Which we did. 
 DeFries was interested. 
 He wanted to look at the contract and check it out and really, with no trouble at all &mdash; I think he wrote a couple of letters and said that Pitt was not acting in the capacity as manager that David required and that was that.&equo; 
 Ken Pitt: &bquo;I think the great problem was David was always very insecure and because he wasn't achieving the renown he wanted, like most artists he began to worry, bearing in mind that David was now living at Haddon Hall with a few of his friends, all of whom were unaware of what was going on in the office and how we were planning David's career, what progress we were really making. 
 I think they just sucked up to David, and began to put the boot in really, quite unnecessarily and unfairly. 
 As far as I understand it, it was Angela who pursued the interest in Tony DeFries. 
 In fact, I didn't know until recent years that it was a person at Philips Records who in fact mentioned DeFries to David, and when he did meet DeFries, Angela was very much in favour of David moving from me to him. 
 I think events proved that she had come to know me a little better, and talked to me, and tried to find out what I was planning and what I was doing, and how David's career was going, and co-operated with me to assist David, I think he would have had a much happier period ahead of him.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;I never realized and had never been involved in who did what, but I suppose that amounts to, if one wants to look at it from Ken's point of view, being the fly in the ointment, or of one wants to look at it from a real point of view as, in terms of property settlement and management, that I was being David's manager at that particular time, because it was possible for me to advise him to do something about the things that really troubled him artistically. 
 I never really thought of it like that. 
 I thought of it as just being a friend. 
 I thought when someone gets miserable you just sort them out.&equo; 
 Ken Pitt: &bquo;However, I finished with him in April 1970. 
 There was no animosity. 
 It was a very friendly thing. 
 We had a meting in my flat. 
 David said absolutely nothing &mdash; not a word. 
 He said &bquo;Hell&equo; to me when he walked in and &bquo;Thank you&equo; when it was all over and he walked out. 
 He just sat on the chaise-longue. 
 Tony DeFries was rather diffident &mdash; a little restrained I thought. 
 He wasn't the Tony DeFries that he became. 
 We discussed the whole thing and i said there was absolutely no point at all. 
 I think he was rather taken aback because my understanding is that he told David that he could get him out of the contract. 
 From this point of view David asked DeFries if he would become his manager. 
 Well, of course, DeFries didn't get him out of the contract. 
 He just came to me and said that he was unhappy and I said OK. 
 That's really all there was to it and Tony DeFries became his manager. 
 David and I were very close friends and if he wasn't happy with what we were doing and wanted to change, I wasn't going to argue. 
 A number of myths have grown up about David's relationship with me &mdash; one of them being that I wanted him to be another Tommy Steele or another cabaret star, but this was not true. 
 At the time David was going through, what I suppose you could call an apprenticeship and he really didn't know what he wanted to do. 
 We were trying to find out where his particular niches lay and the constant worry at that time was lack of money. 
 His father would now and again telephone me saying that David was down to his last few pounds and that he worried about money. 
 Not that it mattered very much because he was living in my flat and wasn't going to starve, but I said to him, there is only one way that you can make quick, ready money and that is going out in cabaret. 
 I didn't recommend it because I had seen what it had done to sensitive artists like Scott Walker. 
 I said we could select the venues, he could write his own cabaret show; he could go out and do 20 minutes and pull &pound;100 a week, which was a lot of money in the 60's. 
 I don't blame him &mdash; he didn't like the idea at all. 
 So he continued trying to make a living the way he wanted to. 
 Of course, he wasn't making a living at all and there was no way he possibly could. 
 However, it got so bad one day &mdash; I think he had been discussing this with his father because he used to go home sometimes at the weekends and come back to the flat on Monday &mdash; and he came in one day and said, &bquo;OK, it's going to be cabaret&equo;. 
 I thought that was a decision he and his father had come to over the weekend. 
 I remember we set about putting together a cabaret show. 
 It was a very progressive performance, far too uncommercial. 
 However, it was a very good one. 
 He wanted to do a Beatle medley and for that we made four cut-out caricatures of The Beatles in hardboard and painted them and then fitted them on frames and easels so that they could be stood up and moved around. 
 We decided eventually that the time had come to rehearse this seriously and he was very happy about it. 
 We decided to show it to a booking agent who books cabaret, so I spoke to Harry Dawson who did a lot of, cabaret work and we auditioned it for him. 
 David was absolutely marvellous, a tremendous show, and when it was over Dawson said to me, &bquo;Ken, it's a marvellous act but it's too good &mdash; when can I book it?&equo;. 
 Of course, he was absolutely right. 
 It was the end of cabaret as far as we were concerned. 
 The message got round and it got round Haddon Hall like wildfire that I wanted David Bowie to be a cabaret star. 
 No way.&equo; 
 Tony Visconti: &bquo;The fact is that David Bowie was becoming more and more disenchanted with Pitt. 
 He was only getting him little gigs here and there and you wouldn't call him a dynamic person. 
 David has always, for a time, hitched his rocket on somebody who is powerful &mdash; no question about it &mdash; he's powerful himself, but he needed an injection of ruthlessness which Ken Pitt, being a very sweet, nice man, wasn't giving him at the time. 
 And then Tony DeFries just materialised. 
 There is always a guy that says, &bquo;I can get you out of this contract&equo;. 
 David was in a state at that time saying that he had signed these things years ago and wanted to get out. 
 DeFries said he could get him out of anything. 
 So that's how it happened, quite honestly. 
 The way Tony DeFries went at it made me very suspicious. 
 He said, &bquo;What can I do for you?&equo; and I said &bquo;I didn't really want to get out of anything; I'm OK.&equo; 
 So his angle with me was that he'd get me work and get the money owed to me. 
 He wrote a few letters on my behalf and I just didn't think he was for me because of what I saw at the time. 
 So, David went with DeFries and I didn't. 
 I wasn't by any means in love with the man. 
 I thought he was all right, but I didn't think he was all that powerful, although I do believe in chemistry and obviously the chemistry between him and Bowie was magic &mdash; undeniably magic. 
 At the time my feeling was that David was making a conscious decision to become big.. 
 He always did it for a while and then just let it ride to see what happened, but all of a sudden (it's amazing &mdash; I've seen it happen several times) he gets out of bed one morning and says, &bquo;Right, I'm going to do something about it &mdash; it's not moving fast enough for me&equo;. 
 Usually, David at the time would surround himself with friends who did things for him, thinking he would get things done out of loyalty. 
 Then he would change people quite often when it didn't suit him to be with them any more.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;The Christmas before recording &bquo;The Man Who Sold The World&equo;, I had flown back home to see my parents. 
 At the time there was a postal strike and I didn't hear from David for about 3 or 4 weeks. 
 Then eventually, the strike was over, and the phone rang &mdash; it was David. 
 He said that there had been a postal strike and that he had been trying to write to me and as the mail was getting through, I should get the letters. 
 He wanted me to come back as, obviously, it was very helpful for him to have someone who would control things when he had to go out and work. 
 When the mail eventually did arrive, I received this very strange Christmas card which said, &bquo;This year we will marry&equo;. 
 I nearly had a heart attack. 
 With my father agreeing to give me &pound;2,000, and adding, &bquo;This is the third plane ticket I've bought for that man&equo;, I flew back to England and finished painting the house white, thanking God that I liked the art nouveau and Edwardian furniture David had been buying, because otherwise it could have been tricky, having received the letter and realising that it might actually be love, it might actually be something serious going on. 
 My father sent me the cheque, needless to say, so David and I thought we'd better get married because that was the reason he sent the cheque. 
 So, off we went to Kensington market. 
 It was so neat and we had a good time. 
 David said, &bquo;Let's go do it &mdash; let's get wedding duds&equo; and I said, &bquo;Absolutely.&equo; 
 So off we went. 
 Now it sounds like my father paid for it, but that's not true because David took care of all the stuff for the wedding. 
 It was very cute. 
 We got outrageous clothes &mdash; total outfits. 
 David said, I hope nobody's going to be there&equo; and I agreed, particularly the way we were going to look. 
 On that evening, the day before the wedding, we went to visit our friend Clare Shenstone and her brother, friends of ours that we had met through Calvin Mark Lee. 
 We went to her house and had dinner and stayed there all night. 
 In the morning, we suddenly woke up and said, &bquo;Oh no, &mdash; we're supposed to be getting married at 11 o'clock. 
 We raced down to Bromley and got to the registry office and there was David's Mum saying, &bquo;You'll be late for your own wedding. 
 There you are. 
 I told you so.&equo; 
 I couldn't help laughing &mdash; it was so true. 
 We were together. 
 It's hardly as if one of us turned up and the other didn't. 
 It was just one of those comedy of errors. 
 &bquo;It's all right. 
 Don't worry&equo;, she said, &bquo;I've called the press.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo;, said David, dressed in black satin, looking absolutely outrageous, like a Lithuanian Dracula rock and roller about to get married and me in this sort of Victorian gown. 
 It was too much. 
 It was wonderful purple and pink, and very bright. 
 All this and David's Mum having saved the day saying, &bquo;Don't worry, I've called the press.&equo; 
 I thought, &bquo;Oh no.&equo; 
 Needless to say, the press showed up. 
 Little known rock and roller and American decide to get married. 
 It was preserved for posterity with David's Mum smiling away &mdash; bless her heart. 
 I don't know how David's Mum got there because he decided not to tell her, even though I said he could call her because it's not really fair to get married without letting her know.&equo; 
 Tony Visconti: &bquo;At that time, we had gone into the studio to record &bquo;The Man Who Sold The World&equo;, and the horrible thing that was happening to me as a producer, the nightmare of my life, was that David and Angela were becoming totally entwined and enraptured with each other. 
 If they were in a good mood things would go well, but if they were in a bad mood, David wouldn't show up. 
 Sometimes when they were in a needy mood, which was most of the time, David would be out in the lobby at Advision Studios where we were recording, and they would be cuddling and cooing and wooing &mdash; it was disgusting. 
 I've got to tell you it was disgusting. 
 I suppose if you were either one of them it would be nice but I'd go out and say to them, &bquo;David, it's time for us to do a vocal now&equo; and Angie would say, &bquo;Oh, Davey Wavey, do you have to leave me now?&equo;, to which he'd reply, &bquo;Oh, Angie Pangie, I suppose I do &mdash; old Uncle Tony wants me in the studio.&equo; 
 It was absolutely nauseating to be involved with. 
 The album didn't go smoothly at all. 
 Mick Ronson, Woody Woodmansey  and myself would be making backing tracks, having got the brief from David &mdash; it was E chord for 16 bars then an A chord for 4 bars and a B chord for 2 bars &mdash; and we were just banging out these backing tracks, and David would come into the studio, if we could tear him away from Angela for long enough and say whether he liked it or not. 
 He wasn't asleep; it was just a very difficult time for him. 
 He was juggling two different worlds. 
 The musicians on one side and the great love of his life on the other and I could see his conflict, but it was my nightmare. 
 It was my problem. 
 We had about six or seven weeks to finish the album and by the last week, I didn't have a vocal on two of the tracks and this is where it actually began &mdash; David writing on microphone. 
 He'd start singing spontaneously. 
 It was great. 
 It was really wonderful. 
 When he was hot, he was hot, but for me the whole thing was not so good. 
 My two realities were getting this thing done technically to technical excellence, which I was struggling with as I didn't know my stuff so well then, and also, managing to get a good performance out of David. 
 I had two big conflicts and would end the day a bag of nerves, not knowing whether I'd come home with anything. 
 I had a record company screaming for final mixes, not even sure that they wanted this album because &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; didn't do too well and as far as they were concerned this was going to be the last they had to do with David Bowie, and I wasn't delivering the goods. 
 A few thousand quid over budget. 
 It was a nightmare, a really horrible period.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;By this time, David had left Ken Pitt and was with Tony DeFries. 
 I think the death of David's father was probably what took him a while to make the decision about leaving Ken, because to lose his father, who he really adored, who had always been a pillar of strength to him, changed his life, and I think David carried a bitterness about him dying for a long time. 
 I didn't want to get into soap opera conversation about it with him, but on the occasions that we did talk about it, both of us felt that someone, with perhaps a little more eye on reality, would have realised that he should have been in hospital and not at home unable to reach oxygen. 
 For him to die of pneumonia was really a terrible waste and I think David harboured a little&hellip; you can't blame someone for something like a person dying tragically with pneumonia, but I think he felt his mother should have watched over him more carefully, but I suppose that's like saying the cat got drowned, why was the puddle there? 
 It's a stupid thing, I used to try really hard not to get involved in those conversations. 
 His father was a public relations man for Dr Barnardo's Homes and would chat away and do all that kind of thing, whereas David was very much like his mother in terms of showing affection. 
 It was like every time I got a letter or an insinuation from him that he cared, or that he really loved me or wanted me to be with him, it shocked me because he wasn't good at showing that. 
 It was for this reason that I had Zowie because I could see how he was with children. 
 Certainly children drew him out. 
 He could get involved with children and be affectionate and spend time with them. 
 I get very bored with reading how difficult he is and how cold he is. 
 He's not like that. 
 He's a fabulous guy and very funny, but it took a long time, and I don't take credit for it, but it took a long time to put him in a situation where I felt that he was at maximum &bquo;comfortableness&equo;, so that his shyness &mdash; and he was very shy &mdash; was overcome. 
 It was like all that ego-building which eventually turns into a monster. 
 It was very necessary because he was so unsure. 
 Not of his talent &mdash; he always knew he was good and he always knew what a great songwriter and performer he was &mdash; but for instance, he was nervous of audiences. 
 The idea of touching people in the crowd or letting people in the crowd touch him was something that had not occurred to him, but to be beautiful and that remote &mdash; you've got to get a crowd to touch him because that was what really got them wild. 
 That was what caused the hysteria and enthusiasm and so, I felt that if the band on stage was at least so close to his sense of humour that he felt comfortable with them, if the crew and all the support system was so strong that he could relax enough to enjoy the crowd, only then would it get magnetic and spontaneous. 
 He relied on me a great deal because he knew I always knew what to do. 
 It was only when we were very close that he would say he was shy.&equo; 
 David had almost completed the album, &bquo;The Man Who Sold The World&equo;, and it wasn't long afterwards that Tony Visconti moved out of Haddon Hall. 
 Tony Visconti: &bquo;When it was finished, on the last day of the last mix, I remember telling David, &bquo;I've had it. 
 I can't work like this anymore &mdash; I'm through. 
 I've got Marc Bolan who wants to record day and night and is keen to go, and I might as well put my energies into him because you really don't want to work very hard.&equo; 
 David was very disappointed. 
 I remember the final time I saw him. 
 It was outside Tony DeFries's office on the corner of Regent Street and Great Castle Street. 
 I just said &bquo;Goodbye&equo; to him right there and then. 
 He looked at me very quizzically. 
 He was in pain. 
 &bquo;But why?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I told you, I can't deal with this anymore&equo;, I replied, &bquo;and I don't like Tony DeFries.&equo; 
 It's funny, I never really did like him and Ken Pitt thought I always wanted them to be together. 
 It was clearly David's choice and that was it. 
 That was the last time I saw David for about four years.&equo;  
 David in his bedroom at Kenneth Pitt's Manchester Street home. 
 The night before his haircut for &bquo;The Virgin Soldiers&equo; 
 Lower Third Days 
 Mary Finnigan 
 A Space Oddity &mdash; 1969 
 State of the Art, David advertises &bquo;Stylophone&equo;, originally given to him by Marc Bolan 
 The Three Tuns pub in Beckenham High Street. 
 The home of the Arts Lab which was later to be re-named &bquo;Growth&equo; 
 Angie and puppeteer Brian Moore, an Arts Lab regular, with some of his creations (Bowie is under the table 
 Angie Bowie pictured by Ray Stevenson 
 Mrs Jones, David's mother 
 Ziggy beams down to earth 
 Haddon Hall, rare shot of the house where David wrote &bquo;The Man Who Sold The World&equo;, &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo; and &bquo;Hunky Dory&equo; 
 David performing on his first American visit, late January 1971 
 Tony Visconti, David's friend and producer 
 Over page, the mod at work on Clapham Common 
 In New York in 1971 
 David at work in Haddon Hall on the design of Ziggy Stardust's next image 
 David on tour in America and Japan in1973 
 Kenneth Pitt, David's manager &bquo;66 to &bquo;70 
 Stage costume idea, later to be discarded, circa 1971 
 Wedding Day, 1970. 
 David and Mary Angela Barnet 
 Rocking with Mick Ronson 
 The first of many. 
 David interviewed in New York for his first promotional visit of 1971 
 Over page, travelling &bquo;Soft&equo; on the Trans Siberian Express, David still in dressing gown 
 David jams with Marc Bolan on his last TV show 
 Posing with Freddi Burretti, aka Rudi Valentino of Arnold Corns (one of Bowie's experimental bands 
 In happier days. 
 A rare shot with Tony DeFries and Angie Bowie, Chicago, October 1972. 
 Photo: Mick Rock 
 THE AMERICAN DREAM 
 The Arts Lab faded into the distance, &bquo;Space Oddity&equo; was a successful single but the album aroused little interest. 
 David, having parted from Ken Pitt, was now managed by Tony DeFries. 
 The follow-up album, &bquo;The Man Who Sold The World&equo; which caused a parting of the ways between Tony Visconti and David, was also released. 
 David called Mick Ronson and Woody Woodmansey (after making &bquo;The Man Who Sold The World&equo;, they had returned to Hull where they lived) and invited them back to prepare for the next album, &bquo;Hunky Dory&equo;. 
 He informed them of Visconti's departure and the need for a replacement bass guitarist, and they returned with a friend who played bass called Trevor Bolder. 
 Collectively, they moved into Haddon Hall with David and Angie. 
 Meanwhile Tony DeFries was negotiating a new record deal with RCA. 
 Peter Noone, formerly Herman of Herman's Hermits, recorded &bquo;Oh, You Pretty Things&equo;, a song written by David, which entered the British charts and oiled the gears of the DeFries negotiating machine. 
 On May 28, 1971, Angie gave birth to Duncan Zowie Haywood Bowie , an event that David documented by writing &bquo;Kooks&equo; for the &bquo;Hunky Dory&equo; LP. 
 In August Andy Warhol's  production of Pork  opened at The Roundhouse in London. 
 The cast of this production would play a major role in the MainMan organization set up by Tony DeFries to handle David's career: Cherry Vanilla  would become Press Agent, Jamie Andrews  an Administrator, Tony Zanetta  David's Personal Assistant and  Leee  Black Childers  the MainMan Staff Photographer. 
  Leee  Childers: &bquo;The production was made from Andy Warhol's personal tapes. 
 He used to tape everything &mdash; every conversation, every telephone call, everything &mdash; and we put it together into a play. 
 We first performed it in New York where a crazy art dealer decided to bring it to London, so to London we came. 
 None of us had ever been here before and we were all living together in one flat, which we called Pig Mansions, in Earls Court. 
 Cherry Vanilla and I used to take care of our time when we weren't rehearsing by pretending we were rock and roll journalists &mdash; which we weren't. 
 I pretended I was the photographer and she pretended she was the writer. 
 We called up all the record companies to see shows and they let us go and see all the shows because we had American accents and we were crazy. 
 Every week we got the New Musical Express and looked to see who was playing, and one week I saw a tiny ad for David Bowie at a place called The Country Club on Haverstock Hill which, as it turned out, was like a garage behind a row of shops. 
 I'd read an article by Jon Mendlesohn in Rolling Stone , which emanated from a trip he took to Los Angeles the year before, which must have been about 1970, that said that there was this guy who did weird songs and dressed up in dresses. 
 We thought anyone who dresses up in dresses we want to go and see. 
 So we called round but couldn't find a record company, although by this time he was with RCA. 
 He was just doing the &bquo;Hunky Dory&equo; album but we didn't know that, Anyway, we got in touch with The Country Club and they put us on the guest list and Cherry Vanilla, Wayne County and I, posing as journalists, went along to see him. 
 When we arrived there were only about 20 people in the audience and he wasn't dressed in a dress. 
 He was in yellow trousers and big hat. 
 Mick Ronson  was with him and Rick Wakeman on piano. 
 Angie was there, too and Dana Gillespie . 
 Angie was very loud at the time and being really crazy, so we all got on famously. 
 We were a little disappointed &mdash; or at least I was &mdash; with David because he wasn't in a dress and he wasn't nearly as crazy as we thought he would be, but nevertheless, we liked his music a lot and he introduced us from the audience and Cherry Vanilla stood up and popped out a tit for the other 20 people, and David said that we were doing Pork . 
 David and Angie came to the opening night of Pork  and to nearly every night thereafter and we became really good friends. 
 We went out with them to Yours and Mine and The Sombrero, and we danced and found them all very crazy. 
 Then the show ended and we had to return to America and I thought that was that &mdash; good friends, really talented, I'd grown to really like David's music. 
 It was at that time, in fact, that he met Andy Warhol. 
 Actually, I think it was at the opening of Pork  because Andy came to the opening and David had that song on the &bquo;Hunky Dory&equo; album called &bquo;Andy Warhol&equo;, so we made sure they met.&equo; 
 Dana Gillespie: &bquo;I'd just come back from the States and was hanging around with a band called Ashton Gardner and Dyke. 
 In fact, it was about the time that David and I both auditioned for Hair  and we were both turned down which I thought was quite funny because it seemed that just about everyone else in London got the part, but we were very much the kind of solo singers and perhaps the wrong type. 
 Anyway, I was doing Catch My Soul , which was a rock Othello, starring Jack Good who was playing Othello himself. 
 P J Proby and P P Arnold. 
 David and Angela came along to see it and David said, &bquo;I must introduce you to this guy Tony DeFries who is going to be my manager, and I think you should meet him too.&equo; 
 So I went with him to meet DeFries. 
 They were in offices in Regent Street with Lawrence Myers and a lot of song writers like Tony McCauley and Mike Leanders pottering about. 
 I walked in with David and there was this guy with a mass of curly hair siting behind a desk, looking very Jewish, not like the Jewish businessman, though he is a wonderful businessman. 
 We got on very well and from there came the start of MainMan. 
 MainMan wasn't started right at that point but then DeFries had the idea that he could keep a better eye on David, myself and eventually Mick Ronson, as he was being treated as a solo artist. 
 One of Mick's first jobs concerning David was to organize the arrangements for my album which later became &bquo;Weren't Born A Man&equo;. 
 We first did about five tracks which was pressed on a private white album, with me on one side and David on the other. 
 I can't actually recall all the numbers, but I remember I was in the States at one point and I took the album over and tried to sell it to a record company. 
 In fact, I went to a couple of record companies and said, &bquo;This is me and David Bowie&equo;. 
 They said &bquo;Thanks, but no thanks.&equo; 
 Then came the period when I used to hang out a lot just with DeFries and we'd drive down to David and Angie's place in Beckenham, Haddon Hall, on Sundays, and Angie would cook and we'd sit around. 
 I remember David would always watch television if the Alwin Nicholson Dance Company was performing, or there was a programme on Kobuki Theatre or something. 
 He never watched boring Coronation Street type programmes. 
 David had always been a great fashion person as well. 
 He was the first guy I ever saw in military clothes before the main craze for the mods dressing up in military uniforms went on. 
 I remember on one occasion the four of us went down to Glastonbury Fair where he sang, but due to a balls-up over the sound and the electricity, they didn't put him on until the next day and that was at about 5.00 in the morning when the sun came through. 
 He was standing on this big silver pyramid where the stage was. 
 People had been very cold and were sloshing about in the mud from the day before. 
 They were in their plastic bags on the outdoor grounds, and as the sun came up, it came up over the top of the hill and hit the silver pyramid and there was David on stage singing. 
 I think he was singing &bquo;The Sun Machine Is Coming Down&equo; or one of those. 
 It was a great number and they took notice of him even though he was just on his own. 
 His hands were so cold he could hardly play the guitar. 
 I was standing on the side of the stage watching him. 
 It wasn't long after that MainMan was completely formed.&equo; 
  Leee  Childers: &bquo;After playing in Pork , I'd been back in America for about a year when the phone rang &mdash; it was Tony DeFries, David's manager, who I had apparently met before but didn't remember. 
 He said that David was getting ready to tour America, but he didn't want normal rock and roll people &mdash; he wanted weird, crazy people to be his staff and he asked whether we'd do it. 
 Would we become MainMan America? 
 Cherry Vanilla was doing nothing &mdash; she was eating fruit and breaking out all the time as a result, Jane was doing nothing too &mdash; she'd started a group called Queen Elizabeth which played little, low-life funky bars on the Lower Eastside, Tony Zanetta was working coding, which is a very ignominious job that out-of-work actors do in New York, and I was working at 16 Magazine  as a tea boy. 
 None of us had anything to lose, so we said, &bquo;Sure, of course we will&equo;. 
 Little did we know that it would result in one of the most amazing periods of any of our lives &mdash; including David's I'm sure. 
 It was quite bizarre. 
 So that's how I got involved. 
 &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo; had just been released in England and David was doing well with it, or so I'm told, but no-one had heard of him at all in America, so Tony DeFries gave us each a box of 25 albums to just give to whoever we thought was cool, which actually turned out to be a pretty good idea. 
 We took them down to Max's Kansas City and gave one to Micky Ruskin the owner, we gave one to the DJ; and we gave one to Lisa Robinson, the reporter. 
 We just passed them out to crazy people and artistes and people who were always on the scene in New York. 
 Then Tony asked us to find him office facilities. 
 Money, apparently was no object, although there was no money. 
 He kept saying, &bquo;money is no object &mdash; find me what I need.&equo; 
 And we kept saying, &bquo;You have to pay for these things&equo;. 
 He'd say, &bquo;Don't worry, don't worry about that. 
 I'll deal with it. 
 There'll be money&hellip; sometime.&equo; 
 All of us were working on no salary, just expenses, but we found nice facilities on 58th Street and were taught to charge everything. 
 We got charge accounts at Max's Kansas City, we got a charge account with a limousine service &mdash; we rode limousines instead of taxis because we didn't have to pay for limousines and we'd have to pay the taxis &mdash; so we were always in limousines. 
 We got charge accounts at Bloomingdales and stores like that, so we were always dressed fabulously and we were always sitting around in fabulous restaurants, charging for fabulous meals with all manner of people, which was all Tony's plan to make it look like the most successful rock and roll company going. 
 And it worked.&equo; 
 Dana Gillespie: &bquo;DeFries always thought that in order for us to absorb musical culture as it should be from America, we should actually go and live in America, and it took quite a few months for it all to be organized. 
 I was at that time in Jesus Christ, Superstar . 
 It was 1973 and already we were preparing for the move to the States. 
 I'd started my album &bquo;Weren't Born A Man&equo; and Mick Ronson was the arranger and producer for a couple of tracks, and David produced a couple of tracks too, but during the making of the album, David became even bigger and bigger in America and the move to America was absolutely imminent so I had to finish my own album without the help of him because he wasn't around &mdash; which I did. 
 His interest in what was going on in America was always strong. 
 I remember when the Andy Warhol lot came with Pork  to The Roundhouse &mdash; we all went off specially to see them and meet them afterwards.&equo; 
  Leee  Childers: &bquo;In America, we'd go to the record companies and make outrageous demands at RCA because we didn't know any better. 
 We didn't know that we were asking for impossible things, because we had never worked in the record business before &mdash; and we'd get them. 
 We'd get our demands because anything was done to shut us up and get us out of their offices. 
 We just prowled around the halls at RCA at the time, going in any doors that were open and asking for things and demanding things. 
 We'll never know whether it was Tony's plan or David's plan. 
 We had this debate all the time amongst us &mdash; who was the actual person behind the grand design? 
 Was it Tony DeFries or was it David Bowie? 
 I guess we'll never know looking back on it, various things can be traced to David and other things to Tony. 
 We think, but we don't really know what they were saying to each other behind closed doors. 
 But anyway, we created that whole idea that no-one could photograph him, no-one could do do a story on him unless it was going to be a cover story, which was outrageous because he was virtually unknown in America. 
 To ask for things like that was totally beyond what an experienced person would ask for. 
 An experienced publicist would go for a colour piece somewhere instead of the cover, but we were instructed to only go for cover pieces, so we ended up getting them of course, and we ended up creating this whole myth around him which was fabulous. 
 I was the advance man. 
 I was the person who was supposed to go to every city before David got there to make sure that everything was in order, that the hall that was going to be performed in had all the facilities that were required &mdash; and the hotels &mdash; I had to check all of that. 
 I'd never done any of that before either. 
 I was given a list of 12 absolutes that if the promoter could not provide, I was to cancel the gig on the spot. 
 I remember the first gig I went to in Cleveland, the grand piano was two feet too short. 
 I was terrified so I called New York. 
 I told them that the grand piano was two feet too short and DeFries said, &bquo;Cancel the gig &mdash; no gig.&equo; 
 Cleveland was the big David Bowie stronghold &mdash; he'd broken in Cleveland whereas he hadn't in New York and places like that. 
 I said, &bquo;The show's sold out &mdash; the place is really nice&equo;. 
 Tony said, &bquo;Cancel the gig&equo;. 
 So I cancelled the gig and they got the piano that was the right size and the gig was back on. 
 That's the way it went for the whole tour. 
 If one little thing wasn't on, the show was off. 
 By the same token, Tony DeFries had a clause in the contract that if the promoter lost money he would pay it to him, so it was impossible for a promoter to actually risk anything. 
 They would definitely, at least, break even, and it did come to bear a few times. 
 In St Louis, we were booked in a 11,000 seater hall and I think 180 or so people came. 
 From a financial point of view it was a disaster and I saw Tony DeFries actually pay the difference to the promoter. 
 That way, of course, the promoter would re-book. 
 You don't lose. 
 There's no risk. 
 From an artistic point of view, it was one of the best shows and the kids were scattered about this huge place based upon what price ticket they had bought. 
 David was absolutely unbothered. 
 He came out on stage and called them all down to the orchestra pit right in front of him. 
 All 180 kids gathered right at his feet and he did a completely different show from any show that he'd done in the sell-out places for five or six thousand. 
 He did a really intimate show where he sat on the edge of the stage with his ankles crossed and talked to them and sang them songs. 
 It was a whole different show. 
 Occasionally, he'd bounce back on stage and do the whole thing with the strobe lights and everything which sent one poor little girl who had epilepsy into a fit. 
 But apart from that incident, it was a great show and he did the same kind of thing in Seattle, Kansas City and the sort of cities in the Mid West where they hadn't heard of him &mdash; it was too early &mdash; but Tony DeFries was as good as his word. 
 He always paid the promoters if they lost money. 
 The tour was originally booked, I think, for about eight cities starting in Cleveland, then Memphis, then New York. 
 He wanted to do a bit before New York and it worked because before the tour started, there was very little interest in New York, but it sold out in Cleveland which we knew it would, and both shows were great, by which time word got back to New York instantly, as it does, and by the time the show at Carnegie Hall happened, it was sold out. 
 They audience was ready for a great star because they'd heard that he was. 
 It worked beautifully it was a fabulous sensation. 
 Then it was meant to be Detroit, Chicago, St Louis and work its way west and end in Los Angeles but word of mouth, the cover story in Rolling Stone  which Tony coerced out of them, and various other things created such a sensation that they lengthened it. 
 That's why we went on to Seattle and Phoenix and worked our way back east again through the south, through Texas, Florida and Tennessee and it ended up going more than twice its length because of the success of the show. 
 I left before the tour was over because it was time for Mott The Hoople to come and tour and I'd been designated as the person to take care of them, so I went off before it was over. 
 But he did do three fabulous nights in Philadelphia and Boston again. 
 It went on and on and that was what solidified him in America. 
 He still hadn't had any chart hits at the time and in fact didn't until &bquo;Fame&equo;. 
 David had always liked Mott The Hoople and admired them, and I think it was one of the few really unselfish acts he did when, when they were on the verge of breaking up, he wrote them a song &mdash; &bquo;All The Young Dudes&equo;. 
 As far as I could ever determine, he really did do that &mdash; he actually sat down and wrote a song for them because he liked them and didn't want them to go away. 
 Having written the song, he gave it to them. 
 He was not a big star at the time and it was just a good song. 
 He wasn't trading on his name; he didn't think that that would have any particular influence. 
 He wrote it purely because it was a song that was right for them. 
 And it was. 
 Having given them the song, it was a hit and that's when Tony DeFries picked up the management. 
 They were a difficult band to manage because they were always on the brink of breaking up. 
 They were all very highly strung and eventually, they did break up. 
 But David really liked them. 
 He used to go to their shows and just show up out of nowhere.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;Prior to the American Tour, the &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo; album had been released and David had already completed a tour of England. 
 I think it was a great relief for him to think that Tony DeFries would deal with things and all he had to do was deal with his artistry. 
 I don't think he conceived &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo; as a concept album, but the songs slotted together in a way that it became a concept, and the way he presented it on stage, how he wanted to look, how the boy's costumes looked (facsimiles of his &mdash; though his were patterned and theirs were simple) meant that he'd breathe life into a concept hero. 
 I think he got confident. 
 I think he got confident of knowing what he could do. 
 I think Tony gave him confidence because Tony looked after the day-to-day worries of how one paid for what one was going to do. 
 Going into the studio &mdash; you have a record deal that says the record company pays for that &mdash; but has that contract been examined? 
 It took a lot of worry away from him. 
 The band were very supportive and they knew they didn't have to do anything untoward. 
 They just had to be there and play well and perform well. 
 And they enjoyed it. 
 They loved the fact that Tony and everyone was dedicated to making it happen. 
 It was an ideal situation for someone in that vernacular. 
 I think that it was probably the moment that his insecurity was surmounted. 
 He really became able to deal with whatever insecurities he had as an artiste or I hope that's what it was.&equo; 
 Mick Ronson: &bquo;It was a really exciting period then because Tony DeFries got involved, which was about maybe a year and a half after I first played with David. 
 It seemed to be like, &bquo;Don't worry about the money and if you need the equipment, you get the equipment, if you need clothes, get clothes made&equo;. 
 Everything seemed to be taken care of and everybody was on a real high because it left you free to do what you wanted to do without worrying about paying this week's rent or buying a pair of shoes, or whether a valve in the amplifier had gone and you had to replace it. 
 All those sort of things. 
 So all those things went out of the window which makes life easier. 
 It was really exciting just to carry on and get involved in making an album &mdash; get on the road. 
 I think it started before &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo; &mdash; it started around the &bquo;Hunky Dory&equo; period with the clothes and I think we started off playing as a duo in the &bquo;Hunky Dory&equo; period. 
 We'd get Rick Wakeman to play piano on a date and then we'd add someone just playing bongos. 
 I think Woody played bongos on a couple of gigs or something, but it was a very acoustic thing and that's why &bquo;Hunky Dory&equo; sounded like it did. 
 But then it seemed to snowball from &bquo;Hunky Dory&equo; into &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo; because after playing one or two gigs as an acoustic outfit, it seemed to be natural to take it that step further &mdash; to add the bass and add the drums and make it bigger and better &mdash; more of a show of it &mdash; and so it evolved into &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo;. 
 I think David had one or two of the songs off &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo; way before and so it became a natural progression to do that. 
 It all seemed to snowball very quickly.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;I think basically &bquo;Ziggy Stardust&equo; was a good album and they played the parts really well. 
 I insisted they look great all the time. 
 I told them they couldn't expect people to get excited by four scruffy ragamuffins that came in the stage door and then go put on their party clothes, which were fantastic, and then again put on their horrible Levis and leave again. 
 I said, &bquo;You're going to get mobbed coming in and you're going to get mobbed going out, so you'd better look good coming in and going out&equo;. 
 The street clothes had to look as good as the stage clothes. 
 Added to which, David had been interviewed by Melody Maker  and said he was gay which gained a lot of publicity.&equo; 
 Mick Ronson: &bquo;At the time when that story came out, my family in Hull took a lot of flak about it because they'd never even heard about it up there. 
 It came like throwing paint over the car and paint up the front door and stuff like that, which really annoyed me. 
 It's pretty sad. 
 Some people thought I was gay. 
 I wasn't gay, and when somebody asked me I'd say, &bquo;No, I'm not&equo;, which was the truth. 
 That's what I had to say about it. 
 If somebody doesn't like the truth then it's too bad. 
 It was a bit of a pain for a couple of weeks. 
 It was very short-lived but at the time it was a bit of a shock. 
 It wasn't a shock amongst ourselves &mdash; it was more of a shock from other people's reactions. 
 For instance, throwing paint over the car and my mother going through it. 
 People were really annoyed up North. 
 That was something at the time that I felt I didn't really need myself. 
 I think the other thing was that I wanted to be known as a musician rather than some other phenomenon other than a musician and I think that also had an effect on me too. 
 Maybe people were seeing me as something other than what I wanted to be naturally. 
 Audiences like to see a bit of theatrics here and there. 
 They like to be able to go to a show and to be able to see something that they don't see in their everyday lives &mdash; you know, catching the bus to go work or coming home on the bus. 
 When people go out for the night they like to come away with being entertained. 
 Or if it's not being entertaining, coming away absolutely hating or loving it &mdash; as long as it's some sort of reaction. 
 I think people like that because people's lives are pretty dull on the whole. 
 Angie was great because she was always very enthusiastic. 
 Much more than I've ever seen anybody. 
 With me coming from the North of England, everybody is pretty reserved up there at the best of times, so coming down to London and meeting Angie with an American accent and flitting around the room and speaking in a loud voice all the time, it was amazing. 
 She actually did a lot of good things &mdash; she pulled a lot of things together and did a lot of things for David. 
 Just her enthusiasm alone. 
 If you had any doubts about doing anything, she would be the first to say, &bquo;Don't be silly, you can do it.&equo; 
 It was very good to have someone like that &mdash; someone who keeps pushing you and telling you that you can do it and not to be shy.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;That first American tour was interesting. 
 The boys were good. 
 The American audiences were kind of small at first and it was a major promotional coup to have survived it all because a lot of dates were pulled at the last minute &mdash; promoters couldn't get any interest. 
 We'd go and be about to play a town and that town pulled out. 
 Then we'd be sat for two or three days until another show was put in. 
 But David was fabulous &mdash; he was just great &mdash; and the boys were great. 
 Everything about it worked. 
 The only thing that didn't work was the understanding that we had to be big time very quickly. 
 The boys were big time, but we had to have the sound system, the lighting, the stage &mdash; everything had to move at the pace of David's imagination. 
 The shows in New York were incredible. 
 In fact, all the shows that played there were amazing although we did two or three shows in America where there weren't a lot of people. 
 They had large capacity halls &mdash; maybe three or four thousand people there, which was funny for the boys because they weren't used to that. 
 They were already getting used to the fact that they were very popular. 
 Even though they might be cult, they were very popular cult. 
 That first tour did a lot to make the rest of the tours tremendously successful because, with all things like that, if you do play to a small group of people and you still do a great show, then by word of mouth the word spreads how wonderful you were, even though it wasn't packed. 
 It stays with them &mdash; very omnipresent in their minds. 
 They remember that and they love you for it even more, so when you go back, you have this staunch hard core group of fans that really bring things like that to a head, that really make it happen for you. 
 They're the ones that call radio stations and demand more airtime, scream when the station is not playing the new album, and eventually cause it to happen for you.&equo; 
 Tony Zanetta: &bquo;Prior to his tour of the States, David started doing dates in England and within three months he was becoming what seemed like the biggest thing in England. 
 Within another month or two he did The Rainbow which got enormous coverage, and within another month he was here getting ready for the first American tour. 
 It all happened really quickly. 
 The first tour in America was not really a tour. 
 It was random dates &mdash; it wasn't properly organised, it was just eight dates &mdash; and to bring thirty people over was kind of lunatic. 
 But it worked. 
 He came with his random dates and began touring. 
 We all learned very quickly and we learned how to do it fairly quickly. 
 Within a month or two we were getting pretty good at it. 
 There was a lot of waiting around &mdash; waiting for more dates. 
 There was no money. 
 That was the main thing, there was very little money, so we charged everything. 
 DeFries had an idea that to be a star you had to act like a star so everything was first class. 
 Everyone stayed at the Plaza Hotel. 
 There were limousines and flowers and champagne. 
 There was money for silly things. 
 DeFries gave everyone money to get winter coats when he decided it gets cold in the United States. 
 The money would pay for everything anybody needed, but no-one had more than five or ten dollars in their pockets. 
 We were all forced to stay in hotels and eat in hotels and sign for it. 
 RCA had agreed to certain kinds of support that got out of hand. 
 They were willing to charge the hotels against royalties. 
 The room service kind of crept in and since we didn't have any cash, we charged meals. 
 We charged everything. 
 We sat in the Beverley Hills hotel for two weeks and ran up about &dollar;20,000 worth of room service. 
 People didn't have money for taxis so we took limousines. 
 We could get a limousine at the Beverley Hills hotel but you couldn't get a taxi, so everyone learned how to call down from the front desk and order whatever they needed out of necessity. 
 It created this mushroom kind of thing that people stared at. 
 It was total insanity. 
 It looked like there were just fortunes being spent, which there were, but no-one could quite figure out where the money was coming from, or why this money was being spent in this way. 
 It was all a little &bquo;circussy&equo; &mdash; a little P T Barnham. 
 I'm not saying it had such a positive effect on his career but it caused a lot of attention which he didn't buckle under, and I do feel a lot of people couldn't have lived through that experience, but he did. 
 He got a lot of attention. 
 By the end of that first tour he was on the cover of Rolling Stone . 
 He had started out in Cleveland, Ohio playing 3,000 people &mdash; he went back to Cleveland within two months and played to 20,000 people. 
 In Philadelphia, it was like The Beatles had arrived. 
 There were fans everywhere and people chasing after him in the streets. 
 It was all very exciting and again, because none of us had gone through it before, it was really wonderful to watch this happen and to be a part of it. 
 It also began to get weird. 
 Maybe not the first tour but by the second tour, I think it began to get decadent. 
 But first it wasn't. 
 It was very innocent and na&iuml;ve, but it was corrupted. 
 You know, staying at the Plaza and ordering champagne whenever you wanted &mdash; it does something to you. 
 Also, you think you deserve it or you think you've earned it or you think you can afford it, and everyone began to act like that. 
 The arrogance began to creep in. 
 I think in a way we were all Ziggy Stardust and we were all living out this myth of Ziggy Stardust and treated him as if he was Ziggy Stardust. 
 We began to treat him like a strange alien person who need to be over-protected, who needed to be shielded from outsiders and the press. 
 Then we would read about it in the press and it was all self-perpetuating. 
 An incredible arrogance and corruption and decadence set in. 
 It didn't really happen overnight, I guess, but through the MainMan News, MainMan kind of mushroomed into this enormous spending machine that really got out of control and I think was a very destructive influence on everyone that was involved.&equo; 
 Dana Gillespie: &bquo;In the high flourishing finance days of MainMan I had a secretary, a wonderful car, limousines everywhere, and bills paid for everything at places like Bloomingdales. 
 MainMan really looked after their artistes extremely well. 
 I would be flying over and staying with Angie for a couple of weeks at The Sherry Netherland, and Angie and I would go with Zowie in the daytime and then we'd stay up all night with David because he functioned at night. 
 Or Jagger would come over from the next hotel and we'd have late night &bquo;looning&equo; sessions, and then Angie and I would go off again with Zowie. 
 We actually got really tired. 
 In 1974 I was at the National Theatre doing Shakespeare with Sir John Gielgud and whenever there was a play it was in repertory form, so another play came on and I had five days off, so I'd fly to Toronto, have a three day &bquo;loon&equo; in Canada and then come back. 
 Or I'd go to LA where David did his week's show at the Universal Amphitheatre, which was the &bquo;Diamond Dogs&equo; show. 
 That was great and started a whole year of being in America for me, which was seeing David as a major star and also for myself, experiencing life as it should be as a major star, with your cars and people looking after you and the record company being polite to you rather than treating you like shit and not working. 
 DeFries gave me a fur coat. 
 He said, &bquo;If you're a singer, you've got to keep yourself warm.&equo; 
 I was really comfortably looked after &mdash; it was great. 
 I always knew it probably couldn't last because nothing goes on forever, but in that time, I had a great time in New York, and it seemed at one point that everyone was there when David was doing the week at the Universal Amphitheatre. 
 I remember we were all in the Beverley Hills Wiltshire Hotel. 
 DeFries was in the Christian Dior suite, Marc Bolan was in the Marc Bolan suite, David was in the next one, Jagger was there and all the Stones, and every night was party night. 
 All of the MainMan people. 
 Most of the guys who worked for the company were gay &mdash; and Cherry Vanilla was the female press officer &mdash; she was outrageous. 
 We had a great image. 
 You only had to say MainMan or Bowie and all the doors opened. 
 I was the first woman ever into one of the famous gay bars. 
 I went in dressed as a man. 
 We had a very outrageous life-style &mdash; it was wonderful.&equo; 
  Leee  Childers: &bquo;The rest of the world was handled by Tony DeFries pretty much the way America had been handled. 
 He just decided it was time before the country had decided it was time. 
 He certainly did that with Japan. 
 He knew that there was a big market in Japan and that you could tour there fairly economically because it was such a small cluster of islands, and he just decided he would. 
 I think Japan was taken by surprise &mdash; they didn't expect a tour at the time &mdash; but he just decided to do it. 
 And it paid off magnificently. 
 David had no hits of any description in Japan when Tony decided to tour. 
 He was very adventurous in that way. 
 It didn't bother him that David hadn't had any hits &mdash; so what? 
 Japan is there. 
 And, of course, he always got someone else to pay for everything anyway, so it wasn't any financial problem. 
 RCA records paid for transport, so off we went. 
 And it worked. 
 At the beginning of the tour it was very lukewarm. 
 By the end of the tour kids were throwing themselves at the stage like little &bquo;kamikazis&equo;. 
 Sure it started out lukewarm, but once people saw him they went crazy, and by the end of the given tour, he had a totally devoted following because he's a brilliant performer. 
 That's what made all the craziness of Tony's orchestrations work. 
 It wouldn't have worked otherwise. 
 The other argument is, of course, would anyone ever have heard of David if it wasn't for Tony? 
 Who knows? 
 A that time David was going through a period when he wouldn't fly, which was a pretty smart ploy because it gained you a lot of time between gigs, as you have to travel by some sort of surface transportation. 
 That awful thing that so many groups get themselves involved in, when they're on a plane and they do a gig and they don't even know what city they're in, he'd manage to avoid. 
 Now, the next gig was weeks ahead at Earls Court in London and there was a choice of sailing round the Cape of Good Hope, going over the Khyber Pass or going on the Trans-Siberian Express. 
 The quickest and least expensive was the Trans-Siberian Express, although it was a bit of a hassle for me being an American, because Americans are not easily granted visas for Russia. 
 It's a little easier now but in 1973&hellip; 
 Anyway, I was told to accompany David on the Express if I could get a visa and off I went to Washington DC to apply for one and they told me absolutely not &mdash; I couldn't have one &mdash; go away. 
 Everyone else had gone to Japan and I was still in New York trying desperately to get a visa for Russia but I couldn't get one, so I convince Tony deFries that if I went to Japan and went to the Russian Embassy in Tokyo, they'd be so confused by an American applying for a visa in Tokyo's Embassy that i could fake it and get one, and he said I was welcome to try. 
 So, off I went to Tokyo and spent days in the Russian Embassy with the RCA Tokyo man, Mr Yamamoto, but still they wouldn't give me one. 
 The tour in Japan was over and David left &mdash; he sailed for Vladivostok &mdash; and finally, just to get rid of me as usual (if you keep making enough noise they'll get rid of you for a little peace and quiet) they gave me a visa. 
 At this point I had to fly and catch him up, so I flew to Khabarovsk in far east Siberia where I had to spend a night. 
 That's where I was first introduced to the Russian system of having a &bquo;guide&equo; who would take care of you. 
 She was a very nice girl named Eugena, I think, and there were guards at the end of the hotel corridors, I remember giving them the slip and wandering around Khabarovsk on my own in a snowstorm, only to be told the next day that there was quite a bit of excitement in the city during the night because a Siberian tiger had come into the city and was wandering the streets at the same time I was! 
 Anyway, I eventually caught up with him in Irkutsk which is central Siberia. 
 Now the Siberian Express is very strange. 
 It has two classes &mdash; hard class and soft class. 
 We were in soft class which meant you had a bed to sleep on &mdash; a sort of cot. 
 Hard class was for the poor people, they were just on benches, but we weren't allowed in there. 
 Much as I tried to break in several times, they always caught me and wouldn't let me in to see the poor people travelling. 
 It's a ten day journey with 92 stops across Siberia. 
 David had this little compartment and used to spend his whole time in a Japanese kimono with his guitar and a bottle of this horrible Reisling wine that was full of alkaline and gave you splitting headaches, but it was all there was. 
 So there was always a bottle of Reisling and a guitar, his Japanese kimono and him staying in bed, looking out of the window at the wolves chasing the train as we went through Siberia in the snow, whereas Geoffrey McCormack (or Warren Peace as he was known professionally) and I would get off at nearly every stop if we were awake, and run around on the platform. 
 David didn't get off. 
 He'd just look at us and wave and smile until we got to Khabarovsk which used to be named Katerinberg and was the city where, supposedly, the Czar and his family were murdered. 
 I told David that he had to get off and at least stand on the platform because it was the city where the Czar was murdered. 
 He agreed and got dressed and we got off. 
 Now on our car, as in every soft class car, we had two little girls who vacuumed the corridors and who made you tea and took care of you. 
 Well, they weren't little at all. 
 In fact, they were huge Russian girls. 
 David had made great friends with them because they would come into his apartment at night and he would sing them songs and things. 
 He'd take 60's songs like, &bquo;Donna, Donna The Prima Donna&equo; and substitute their names. 
 They couldn't understand it in English, but they'd hear their names to these kind of bouncy 60's tunes and loved David. 
 He can be very charming in that way. 
 So anyway, at Khabarovsk we were eating ice-cream &mdash; there were always ice-cream sellers on the platform &mdash; and I was taking pictures of David and sneaking pictures of the soldiers who were on the platform with us but, unfortunately, they caught us at it. 
 The soldiers came and tried to get my camera but I was fighting back and wouldn't give it to them. 
 David, who had a movie camera which he had bought in Japan, began to film it all. 
 Then they got really crazy and they were trying to get David's movie camera and to arrest us all. 
 At this point the two girls just marched off the train, one of them picked up David, the other one picked me up, screamed Russian things at the soldiers &mdash; I haven't a clue what they were saying &mdash; and marched us back on the train and barred the door, while the Russian soldiers were standing on the platform screaming horrible things at them. 
 The girls were screaming back as the train pulled out and we got away from Khabarovsk without being arrested. 
 Eventually we arrived in Moscow the day before the May Day Parade. 
 David and Geoffrey were perfectly welcome because they were English, but I was not welcome because I was American, so while they were staying on to see the May Day Parade, I was meant to leave and fly to Berlin where I would wait for David and Geoffrey who were going on by train through Poland. 
 I decided to give the authorities the slip and went through the bathroom window of the hotel and got myself lost in Moscow. 
 When they finally found me it was too late to get me out, because everything stops at 5.00pm the day before the Parade. 
 They were furious. 
 David was totally horrified. 
 He was sure I was going to be sent to Siberia but I'd given him all my film and all the pictures that I'd taken already. 
 He was sure he would never see me again. 
 The guards and police took me completely outside the town and put me into some weird hotel that looked like a Holiday Inn, but it was in the middle of the woods. 
 They told me to stay there until they came and got me the following day &mdash; which I didn't. 
 I got out at 5am and left. 
 I had with me only the name of David's hotel which was the Intourist, which was right in the middle of town, and my Russian phrase book, which was full of phrases like, &bquo;I think my leg is broken, can you stop the bleeding?&equo; which did not prove very helpful. 
 I began walking towards what I thought was the town. 
 I was in the middle of the wood, so I didn't know which way I was walking. 
 Dawn was just breaking and I began to see a little more civilisation and it looked sort of right. 
 Then I began to run into the guards, and every guard I saw, I didn't say anything, I just showed them the piece of paper which had written on it Hotel Intourist in Russian, and the phrase book. 
 I'd point to phrases like, &bquo;I can't see anything&equo; or &bquo;Has the sun come up?&equo; and they'd look bewildered at me and point and on I'd go. 
 I made my way through all the guard checkpoints and got to the Hotel Intourist in the middle of town at about 11 o'clock when David and Geoffrey were just siting down to lunch. 
 I walked into the cafeteria and sat down with them. 
 David was horrified and was sure that I'd be arrested and sent back to Siberia. 
 He screamed at me and I screamed back. 
 I wasn't about to miss the parade, and went on to see the whole event, and photographed it &mdash; all the red flags, the guns, the cannons, the missiles, everything, including Black September Group marching. 
 After it was over, we went into the bar for a drink and the authorities came along. 
 Once again, I'd given my film to David. 
 The authorities grabbed me and took me away. 
 I thought that this was it&hellip; 
 Siberia for me, but all they did was put me on a plane heading for Berlin. 
 Deported. 
 Sickening. 
 I'm sure I'll never be allowed back into Russia &mdash; not that I'd ever want to go back. 
 David got out with all the film, so I have all the pictures of the whole thing.&equo; 
 Mick Ronson: &bquo;We toured the States followed by Japan, and by the time we came back to England, it was beginning to really snowball. 
 I think the final Ziggy Stardust tour was in England &mdash; that was the big tour &mdash; and by the time we returned, everyone was talking about it because Ziggy Stardust was a really good show. 
 It wasn't any deeper than that &mdash; I'm not really sure what it was &mdash; but David was very creative. 
 When he was younger he'd write songs about a laughing gnome, or a song about a laughing policeman, and I think it was a great outlet for David because he could almost blow his character out of all proportion and be able to pretend whatever he wanted to pretend, which is what actors and pop stars do. 
 You know, it's a funny thing, when you get on stage in front of an audience &mdash; you become a different person and I think everybody experiences that. 
 You get somebody who is very outrageous on stage but who is maybe very shy off stage, and I think being on stage in front of an audience enables you to step outside of your own body and be somebody else totally different for that period of time. 
 Some people carry on and live it 24 hours a day because they have to be that person all the time and at that time, it wasn't like you played a gig, finished the gig and then had a very private life until the next gig. 
 David would always be seen in public, would always have to do interviews, do a video or go into a recording studio &mdash; so I think the whole time was taken up by feeling involved in the whole Ziggy period or Ziggy way of thinking. 
 You can't go into the recording studio and be Joe Bloggs. 
 You go in there and you do what you want to do. 
 It's an extension of what you do on stage and it became a full=time thing really, until after it stopped and he could change and get into the Diamond Dogs period and the other albums that he made.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;There was a lot of garbage said about him feeling schizoid and it was all so crazy and easy to say that he felt schizoid because of Ziggy Stardust. 
 At the time he was perfectly rational &mdash; he didn't feel schizoid &mdash; he was playing a part. 
 A lot of actors have problems playing parts. 
 It's easy to feel like Ziggy &mdash; of course it is &mdash; you play it on stage half the time and then you come home and have to be David Jones and I don't have too much patience for that talk. 
 The band, for instance, they played &bquo;The Spiders From Mars&equo;. 
 Did they feel like &bquo;The Spiders From Mars?&equo; 
 I'm sure Mick Ronson lay awake at night and worried about being like a Spider from Mars. 
 It's ridiculous. 
 It was just a good album and they played the parts really well. 
 I suppose if one were to wonder about schizophrenia or playing the part too much, it's like an actor who does a film and the film is very successful and he plays Gatsby in the film, and then they never stop wearing 30's tennis whites. 
 Do you know what I mean? 
 Basically, it's all part of promotion for the period that you're filming and promoting. 
 You may well be wearing 30's clothes and I suppose you could start wandering around feeling like Gatsby, but for a man who is a very fine actor and mime artiste, and who learned from Lindsay Kemp way before I met him everything about it being a show off stage and on, I don't really think there's too much relevance.&equo; 
 David Bowie: &bquo;I ran into a very strange type of paranoid person when I was doing &bquo;Aladdin Sane&equo; very mixed up people, and I got very upset. 
 This resulted in &bquo;Aladdin&equo; and I knew I didn't have much more to say about rock and roll. 
 I mean, Ziggy really said as much as I meant to say all along. 
 &bquo;Aladdin&equo; was really Ziggy in America. 
 Again, it was just looking round, seeing what was in my head.&equo; 
 After the successful tour of Japan and the trip on the Trans Siberian Express across Russia, stopping off in Moscow to see the May Day Parade, Bowie travelled overland to Paris and met up with Angie. 
 By this time &bquo;Aladdin Sane&equo; had been released to advance orders in the UK of 100,000, a figure comparable only to albums by The Beatles. 
 David arrived in London with Angie, having travelled more that 8,000 miles overland. 
 The following day they gave a home-coming party at Haddon Hall and invited many of their friends: Tony Visconti, Mary Hopkin, Lindsay Kemp, Mick Ronson, George Underwood, Freddie Barretti, Ken Scott and Mary Finnigan whom he kissed on the cheek and said, &bquo;I love you, Mary.&equo; 
 That was the last time she was ever to see him. 
 A matter of days after his home-coming party, David was back on tour, this time in the UK. 
 The tour, opening in inglorious circumstances at London's Earls Court, marked the debut of David's new character, Aladdin Sane. 
 It would become known as the Aladdin Sane Retirement Tour of Great Britain, comprising over 40 appearances and culminating at Hammersmith Odeon for the famous final concert of June 3, 1973, when David announced his &bquo;retirement&equo; and that he wouldn't perform live concerts again for a long time &mdash; not for two or three years at least. 
 At the Cafe Royal the following night, David held a swish retirement party with guests like Mick and Bianca Jagger, Ringo Starr, Paul McCartney, Keith Moon, Britt Eckland, Tony Curtis, Cat Stevens, Lou Reed, Jeff Beck, Eliot Gould, Ryan O'Neal, Barbra Streisand, Sonny Bono, Peter Cook and Dudley Moore, with music supplied by Dr John. 
 By this time, nearly every newspaper had run &bquo;I quit&equo; stories emerging from the announcement at the Hammersmith show. 
 Mick Ronson: &bquo;After the tour, we recorded the album, &bquo;Pin-Ups&equo;, an album which was just a collection of songs that David really liked from the 60's period, and shortly afterwards, we went to Italy for a holiday. 
 David wanted to write a play &mdash; that's what he fancied doing &mdash; although it never came about. 
 That's when he actually got into the &bquo;Diamond Dogs&equo; period and when the show extended a bit more into the theatrical &mdash; more props with street scenes, a huge lift chair that went over the audience, and things like that. 
 I think it was a cross between writing this play and doing another rock and roll show. 
 He really wanted to do a play on maybe Broadway at the time &mdash; something different.&equo; 
 Tony Zanetta: &bquo;By this time, I'd become the President of MainMan and for a time was Ton's right hand man running errands for him. 
 MainMan was more about Tony than it was about David although David and Tony worked extremely well together as a team, but I think they each had individual goals they wanted to accomplish. 
 Tony wanted an empire. 
 He wanted to have an international entertainment conglomerate, which was MainMan. 
 He was very taken with organisation in the corporate world and MainMan was being fashioned after a large corporation although in its beginning, it was anything but that. 
 It was basically a group of people who happened to be around but very soon we all had titles and were constantly organising and re-organising the creating divisions and systems and methods. 
 Tony was always preparing for the future with David and with MainMan, so he was always two or three steps ahead of himself. 
 David had come to the United States as a headliner. 
 Tony didn't have time to waste booking him as a support act or doing a club circuit or anything like that. 
 What happened was that we began to do all kinds of things that are normally done to support a tour that you farm out, but we used to do it in-house, so we had our own publicity department, our own travel department &mdash; we booked our own flights and our own hotels, we didn't use a travel agency. 
 We had our own accountants in-house. 
 We had everything. 
 We even made our own television commercials and our own radio commercials. 
 We also had our own publishing department. 
 It was all fashioned after a record company. 
 I don't know what good it did David in the long run because what it did was cost a lot of money. 
 It was wonderful if you were going to service five or ten artists, but one artist didn't need all this. 
 What it did for David was have the same mushrooming effect, creating this balloon image of star power &mdash; all that staying at The Plaza and The Beverley Hills Hotel did. 
 It looked important. 
 Anyone who had this kind of machine behind them must be important, so it had the effect of presenting him to the public as this bigger than life pop star which, if you look at his record sales at the time, he wasn't, but he was becoming a media myth, some of this due to his own talent and some of it due to the MainMan hype machine. 
 He was talented enough and resourceful enough to survive it, although I think it almost devastated and destroyed him at a certain point. 
 I think we all became victims of it. 
 We acted as if we owned RCA, that we were RCA, that we had this corporation. 
 We were very grandiose. 
 It was really believing our own notices and becoming very arrogant. 
 Drugs and alcohol began to creep in. 
 There were none of this in the beginning, in the first two years, but at the time of &bquo;Diamond Dogs&equo;, a lot of drugs began to come in, a lot of alcohol came in with different individuals, which helped fuel things. 
 It certainly didn't help. 
 It just added fuel to the fire. 
 The &bquo;Diamond Dogs&equo; tour that followed was an enormous amount of work for everybody involved and in some ways, it began to break down. 
 I really began to sense it when David did a Midnight Special  show in 1973. 
 What happened was that he started doing his English Ziggy Stardust dates in early &bquo;72 and he worked without stopping until the summer of &bquo;73 when he did his Hammersmith Odeon concert and retired from the stage. 
 When he finally did stop working, it was the first time in a year and a half that everyone involved stopped and got a chance to take a break, and once everyone took a break, things began to change. 
 First of all, DeFries, by this time, had set up his headquarters in New York although David was still headquartered in London. 
 They began to spend less time together. 
 DeFries began to build his MainMan empire in New York and it became obvious it wasn't always in support of what David was doing. 
 They were not in fact the same thing &mdash; they were two separate things &mdash; and up until this point, it seemed like it was all one thing &mdash; that MainMan and David were the same &mdash; but it began to become apparent that they weren't. 
 We had a staff of 10 or 15 people in New York and there was a staff of three in London. 
 The staff of three had to service Bowie, Mick Ronson and Dana Gilespie. 
 All the artistes were in England, but the staff were in New York, and to get money and to get certain things that we needed to do took a long time. 
 This was the first experience where it was obvious that the machine was working against itself &mdash; something wasn't quite right. 
 It didn't really become apparent until the Spring of &bquo;74 when David returned to New York to do the &bquo;Diamond Dogs&equo; tour. 
 By that time DeFries had an office in Park Avenue which was very much like the old Gem offices in London. 
 He'd made major strides in establishing the kind of company he wanted, which wasn't the kind of company David wanted, and I think David saw that when he got to New York. 
 Also, it had become much more formal and much more structured in organization. 
 DeFries wouldn't drop anything any time of the day for David any more. 
 It wasn't exactly like he had to have an appointment, but it was that he didn't fit into the structure. 
 In the meantime, I think David had come to realize that he was responsible for an enormous amount of business at RCA in the United Kingdom &mdash; something like 4% of their total gross was David Bowie products &mdash; and he was making an enormous amount of money but he didn't have anything. 
 He didn't have any money because all the money was controlled by MainMan. 
 Any money that he wanted he had to ask for, or if he wanted to buy anything he had to ask for it. 
 Up to this point it had been fine because there had been no money. 
 The money was all in a pot. 
 It was petty cash. 
 MainMan was always in debt and Tony had always gone out and found money to do projects, so it was fine. 
 I was as much a part of this as anybody. 
 I'm not trying to be a saint in any of this at all. 
 I still believed implicitly in Tony DeFries and I'm not trying to put Tony down by this at all. 
 The only thing I saw wrong at the time was that David and Tony began not to communicate. 
 Money was being spent, but money could be accounted for. 
 It wasn't that money was being stolen or sneaked &mdash; everything was down on paper. 
 David and I did have conversations about it and I told David that I thought he should get an accountant, or that he should ask for an account from Tony if he had questions about where money was going. 
 I feel that David didn't want to face it and I don't think Tony wanted to face it. 
 They had really tired of each other and it had become a struggle between them that was slow to surface until the Diamond Dogs tour because a lot of things happened on that tour that they were both very unhappy about. 
 It started with the way the tour was organised. 
 It was farmed out to Broadway people to put together, and cost an enormous amount of money. 
 It was a wonderful show, &bquo;Diamond Dogs&equo;, but it wasn't practical for a tour so we all thought that if we got the Broadway experts to put it together, it would be the best thing possible &mdash; but it wasn't. 
 They weren't used to doing this kind of thing &mdash; they weren't used to rock and roll or putting something up and taking it down every day, so really it was a white elephant from the beginning. 
 The whole thing created a lot of stress and tension, moving this humongous thing around the country. 
 Problems came up with the musicians. 
 DeFries was not on the road, I was not on the road and I think David began to feel very abandoned by this company MainMan. 
 He had no money and he was working very hard every day and there were lots of problems and nobody there to take care of them. 
 In the meantime, he'd discovered cocaine with a vengeance. 
 It was like his year to play drug addict. 
 He wasn't using his best judgement. 
 He was staying up for four or five days at a time and then crashing for four or five days. 
 He was really living the rock star legend to the ninth degree. 
 DeFries was very upset at this because DeFries hated drugs. 
 They more than pulled at this point &mdash; they just stopped communicating. 
 The real turning point was in the middle of the tour &mdash; the natural break in it &mdash; July and August. 
 First of all, David did some recording in July &mdash; he recorded most of the &bquo;Young Americans&equo; album &mdash; and then there was a break in California and we were going to restart the tour in Los Angeles. 
 By that time, David and I had some serious talks and I went on the road for the second part of the tour to try to salvage the relationship, which didn't really work. 
 In Los Angeles David decided that he didn't want to use the set any more, that he wanted to change the whole concept of the show, and that, I think, was the last straw for DeFries because, as difficult as it was as a set, it was an incredible show, quite wonderful to look at. 
 No-one had ever done anything like it in rock and roll and it was getting incredible press. 
 The thing about all this was that sales were beginning to meet his star image. 
 For the first time, he was beginning to sell records in the United States, but the relationship between DeFries and Bowie had disintegrated by this time.&equo; 
  Leee  Childers: &bquo;It all grew too fast all of a sudden. 
 All of us had been promoted out of any efficiency that we might have had. 
 I had a huge office on Park Avenue with a tiger skin rug, mahogany walls, a personal assistant, two secretaries and nothing to do. 
 I used to pull the blinds, turn out the lights and sit in the dark in terror, thinking, &bquo;What am I going to do here? 
 There's nothing for me to do. 
 They're going to find out eventually that I'm doing nothing.&equo; 
 I didn't have enough experience in the music industry to be able to create further usefulness. 
 I could do now, with the knowledge I have, but I couldn't do it then. 
 My personal assistant was my high school sweetheart, Mrs Simpson, who was a complete nutcase. 
 She'd taken it upon herself to be in charge of merchandising, so she was working and creating little David Bowie dolls and placemats and keychains and all that shit, but she was doing that all by herself. 
 Cherry Vanilla was the first to leave. 
 To her full credit, she left of her own accord saying, &bquo;I'm not doing anything, it's time I move on.&equo; 
 And she went. 
 I didn't. 
 I just hung grimly on because the salary was magnificent. 
 I couldn't dream of what I was going to do because you become so dependent on money. 
 I talked to Tony Zanetta and he said, &bquo;You're not doing anything, are you?&equo; 
 I said, &bquo;No, I think I'll go.&equo; 
 And so I went. 
 I told Tony that he would be next and he was. 
 It was just six months later that he left. 
 Anyway, having left MainMan, I came back to England and lived in Oakley Street in David's house with Angela. 
 David wasn't there, so I was living with Angela and that's when I first got the inkling that all was not well between David and Tony. 
 During the time that I was at MainMan, David had become more and more removed from us, but I figured that that was because he was so busy and that was the way it was when you had become a big star. 
 It turns out, I think, that he was being purposely more and more removed from us in order to retain whatever Tony DeFries's idea was of keeping business separate from pleasure. 
 We weren't supposed to be friends with people with whom we were doing business, which was probably a good idea, but just the same, I didn't know that until I began to live on Oakley Street and found out that David was very distressed. 
 He though that we had grown apart from him and he became upset that none of us were around him any more, talking to him any more. 
 This is according to Angela, who was still married to him then, and still close to him. 
 About that time, Tony Zanetta came to London and visited us. 
 He was very restless so I knew it was a matter of moments before he was going to leave MainMan. 
 In fact, he left not long after, leaving all the secretaries and personal assistants in charge, except for my personal assistant &mdash; she got fired. 
 She told me that Tony spent a lot of time making passes at her, but she was horrible flirtatious and very beautiful. 
 But anyway, in the end she was fired and her last act was to send a memo to Tony DeFries, the contents of which I would rather not go into. 
 To finish off the story she married a millionaire in Tennessee, so she's OK.&equo; 
 Tony Zanetta: &bquo;We did the last part of the tour which we called Tour Five. 
 Some people call it The Young Americans Tour, others call it the Black Show because it was David as an R &dollar;B singer. 
 At this point we began to work with Carlos Alomar . 
 In fact, Carlos&equo; wife, Robyn Clarke, was one of the back-up singers with Ava Cherry  and Luther Vandross . 
 Most of the musicians were black and the music had changed and really had an R &dollar;B flavour. 
 The new stuff was very R &dollar;B. 
 The opening act was the back-up singers doing a kind of almost traditional Apollo show which didn't go over. 
 It wasn't English. 
 It wasn't Ziggy Stardust and the reviews became very mixed. 
 The tension increased on the road because David and DeFries had a very important relationship that was crumbling and one of the things about the relationship was the direction that DeFries did supply for him. 
 You could never tell whose idea was what, because they talked everything to death, but if nothing else, DeFries was a wonderful sounding board as he would talk for hours and hours and hours about every little detail of the show, the order of the set, the music, the albums. 
 But David didn't have that any more. 
 Angela wasn't around very much at this point either. 
 This whole experience had been so fast and furious for me I didn't know what I was doing any more. 
 My drinking picked up incredibly. 
 I was dabbling with drugs and doing plenty of drugs and also I'd become very arrogant. 
 I thought I had all the answers although I didn't know what was going on. 
 I was trying to communicate between David and Tony, trying to get them to talk to each other, and as a result was going back and forth between the two of them which was a very frustrating experience, added to which I was tired from being on the road and I was very unhappy. 
 I suppose in a way, I was living out my own part of the Ziggy decadence and the Ziggy demise. 
 We had three arrests on the tour, the third was mine. 
 The last show of the tour was in Atlanta and I decided to give a little party for the singers and musicians and the crew and I tried to rent a banquet room at the hotel, but because it was Thanksgiving Weekend, they said they could only give me a suite. 
 Anyway, the party was busted by the Vice Squad. 
 It was a joke, really, because the night detective of the hotel, this guy in his mid 20s with long blond hair who looked like a hippy with beads on, turned out to be a member of the Vice Squad. 
 They had this entire set-up. 
 It was incredible. 
 They had undercover agents everywhere in the hotel. 
 The party was the quietest you could imagine and they kept complaining that we were making too much noise. 
 There was very little noise as no-one had arrived &mdash; between twenty and thirty people were in the room &mdash; and we had this teeny stereo system about as big as a transistor radio for music. 
 It wasn't exactly an exciting party, but the vice squad knocked on the door. 
 Of course, David's bodyguards were guarding the door and I went to see what they wanted and this guy, who said he was the night detective, announced that unless we emptied the room in five minutes, he was going to close the party down. 
 He and I got into a bit of a squabble. 
 There didn't seem to be anything to do but to close the door, which I did. 
 Unfortunately his foot was in it at the time and I slammed it, at which point he pulled out a badge and said he was a cop. 
 Suddenly there were policemen everywhere who ran into the suite and made everyone get up against the wall with their hands above their heads. 
 It was hilarious. 
 Anyone who had drugs on them dropped them to the floor. 
 Now the suite was in my name, so I was charged with possession of all these drugs, and with assault, and with a lot of other charges like operating a dive, running a disorderly house and all silly charges which were dropped the following day. 
 But it was a fitting end to this tour. 
 It was symbolic of the whole thing. 
 When we returned to New York after the tour, David and DeFries had a couple of meetings and they were rather funny, too, because I would ask each of them what happened. 
 &bquo;Did you resolve it? 
 Did you settle it? 
 Did you talk?&equo; 
 They each had totally different stories, totally different perceptions of what had gone on in the meetings. 
 They each said everything was fine. 
 By &bquo;fine&equo; DeFries meant everything was fine and David meant that he'd left. 
 They were just not talking to each other at all.&equo; 
 Dana Gillespie: &bquo;I've got to say, I think in a way cocaine can really freeze your emotions, and David took an awful lot. 
 I mean, everybody took loads of everything in those days but if you have an incredible tour schedule and you can find a way of having extra energy, which you can get with cocaine, you overdo it if you haven't ever had it before in such huge quantities, and you're that big, and girls come to the dressing room afterwards, and everybody gives you free packets, and suddenly you're everybody's pal. 
 Well David didn't sleep a lot and got thinner and thinner. 
 And it makes you very hard as a person. 
 I know because I've tried it as well, and I would say it was a large contributing factor to a breakdown of understanding, because at this point I was watching the deterioration of the relationship between Tony DeFries and David. 
 By this time David's show was taking on mammoth proportions &mdash; about 50 people as a road crew. 
 The lighting guy was Jules Fisher who was the top guy in New York and then doing straight Broadway musicals, and the crew was fantastic. 
 I remember there was a period when no-one was speaking to anyone and I recall going to the island of Mustique and being there a few weeks just before the final split. 
 There was Defries and his girlfriend and the guy I was and David called a couple of times. 
 It's terribly difficult to make a call to those sort of islands as they don't have many telephones. 
 It takes about three days to get a call out and I remember DeFries didn't answer any of David's calls because I think he knew what was going on. 
 I was blissfully ignorant of the whole collapse. 
 I used to go as little as possible to the MainMan offices. 
 I was aware of the fact that there had been what seemed like 20 people working in the office and then it was suddenly dwindling down to a skeleton staff. 
 I just assumed they were trying to cut back as they had been a bit too lavish. 
 Not that I complained because I was having a great time with it, but I noticed that there were a few changes and when I went back to England from Mustique, that was probably the last time MainMan existed. 
 That was in 1976. 
 I'm sure everybody's got a different version of it and I really didn't witness any rows. 
 I would often hear from my assistant who now looks after Cher, but at that time was delegated to looking after me, and she would say that she'd just come back from the MainMan offices and the main office door was closed into DeFries's inner sanctum and there were raised voices between him and David in there. 
 I think he once did say to me that he was very disturbed at how much &bquo;coke&equo; David was doing and that it had got to the point where he didn't hide it from deFries, whereas he did for quite a while at first. 
 deFries, being a straight guy, wouldn't have known what was going on. 
 Even when he saw it being done he still wouldn't have known what was going on but unless you try it yourself, you don't know what physical effect, or mental effect, it has on you and how speedy and intolerant it makes you of other people. 
 It's really a sort of personality freezer. 
 It's terrible if you take a lot of it because it's just bad for your personality &mdash; not for your health, except for the fact that you get thin. 
 I saw David shovelling more and more, he was getting more tired, more irritable, more run-down and less able to control the madness that was going on around him. 
 It was no longer just go out and do a gig with your equipment &mdash; there were lighting men, dancers, singers, &mdash; there was so much that I think no-one could handle it and he was wanting more and more to make the show very good. 
 At one point he said he wanted something and DeFries said &bquo;No, you can't have it&mdash; you don't have the money.&equo; 
 I remember David had a look of amazement on his face because at this point he had quite a few gold albums, but he still didn't have the money because the rate that they made money went straight back into making the show even bigger and better, and everybody travelled in style. 
 When you went out on a tour with MainMan, you didn't eat in a Wimpey level of place, or stay in the Holiday Inn. 
 Everybody had personal assistants whether they needed them or not. 
 It was great. 
 I had a friend, she now manages the Eurythmics with her husband, but at that time, none of us needed to be in such luxury but none of us said no if it was offered and DeFries always observed the Noel Coward code and said, &bquo;You should travel through life first class.&equo; 
 That was more or less his way of doing things and it cost a lot. 
 So suddenly, David had wanted something &mdash; I don't know what it was &mdash; it might have been something like a synthesizer or some extraordinary thing for the show, but the money wasn't there. 
 I think it was just the final end of a long line of demands that he'd been making. 
 He wanted more of DeFries' time as well and the more DeFries saw things going on that he didn't like, the less time he wanted to put in to both of them. 
 It was a complete breakdown of a friendship in a way. 
 I really can't answer for David because in all the years that I've known him, I always actually found him a rather cold person, even when I was 14 and he was 16, even as boy and girlfriend. 
 DeFries made a lot of career decisions for David that worked, but suddenly decisions, desires to do things, were coming between the two of them, so there was a clash on whose decision was going to win and whose idea was going to win. 
 I think David thought he was the artist and he knew what he wanted to do &mdash; which I think is actually true &mdash; the artist basically does know what he wants to do &mdash; but I think the manager should just be there to sort out the finance and try to keep you on a the straight and narrow. 
 But it was such an unusual rise to fame, a situation that, apart from Elvis and The Beatles, there really wasn't anyone else to make any reference to and say this is how they got through it all, because there had been nobody else of that size who had done it, and it's hard to say how much of the rise to fame was attributed to DeFries. 
 It certainly wouldn't have happened if David hadn't done the music, but it's not just as simple as that. 
 It wouldn't have happened if Angie hadn't been around as well, to keep his morale high and encourage him. 
 The great thing about Angie was that she was always for him. 
 always helping him. 
 She bought his clothes. 
 They had the same size shoes and they wore the same clothes quite often. 
 She was always there trying to be what he wanted and she wanted to make things great for him. 
 At the end, he wanted to be on his own, so he'd encourage her to go out on her own and go loony with me. 
 She became, for a short while, my personal manager &mdash; we did a radio promotion tour around England on the &bquo;Andy Warhol&equo; single &mdash; but I often had the feeling that they were things that were given to Angie to keep her out of David's way, to occupy her so that he could sort himself out. 
 But all it did was to create a bigger gap that just got bigger and bigger. 
 Who the rise was due to I don't know except that I think David probably wouldn't have had the idea to have opened such wonderful offices and created such a great mystique about it which MainMan had. 
 Everything looked great from the writing paper to the T-shirts and the stickers &mdash; just everything was done well. 
 Everyone had what they wanted. 
 It was so great to have your personal limousine. 
 It cost a fortune. 
 Angie and I would ride around in a scarlet limo with a television in the back and a bar and a huge 20 stone black guy as our bodyguard in the front. 
 It was outrageous. 
 We dressed accordingly. 
 Angie would continuously go and buy things for David and Zowie, but also for me. 
 All the things were designed by Natasha Kornilof or another woman called Anne Proctor, and maybe she'd make the introduction and David would meet them, but then she would follow it through and make sure the arrangements were done and the house was kept great when they lived in Oakley Street. 
 But already in Oakley Street he was beginning to discover&hellip; 
 The first time he ever asked me if I knew where he could get &bquo;coke&equo;. 
 He said he'd just come back from Amsterdam and he had tried some and said it was great and did I know where he could get some. 
 I think it was around 1974.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;It was all so depressing. 
 In fact I find it hard to talk about. 
 It was really horrific. 
 I don't know what started it because I wasn't with him. 
 I really didn't know. 
 I didn't understand it or share it and wasn't part of it. 
 I just had to tend to him when it got too much for someone who is not that involved in drugs. 
 Don't misunderstand me &mdash; this isn't the story about me, so it's not a whitewashing job. 
 I got very involved in drugs later because I was nursing a broken head and a broken heart, but at this particular time, 1974, I was not sophisticated about drugs. 
 I'd smoked a joint and taken tincture of cannabis, which is something I had done because I didn't smoke cigarettes and the hippies around me would say, &bquo;Give her a spoonful of tincture of cannabis so that she'll get stoned&equo; but I didn't know if cocaine was like that. 
 I didn't understand the paranoia it induced. 
 I was so concerned that I also really didn't trust other people or stupid books to explain to me whereas usually, in most things I do, if I don't understand them I'll go to the library and get books and read about it and find out. 
 With things like art nouveau and Edwardian furniture, when David started buying them, I went and got books to get my act together in order that I knew what he was into, but with drugs, I didn't know, added to which David was very secretive and for a long time I wasn't aware that he was having a problem, not necessarily from cocaine addiction, which everybody loves to tell you is not addictive, but it is in terms of the fact that you rely on feeling up to cope &mdash; you just become more and more paranoid. 
 Anyway, it was a lawyer named Michael Lipman who engineered David getting away from Tony DeFries.&equo; 
 Tony Zanetta: &bquo;David had moved into a little house in Chelsea in New York and called Michael Lipman. 
 Lipman was a lawyer and an agent at CMA who were our booking agents, and we were all quite friendly. 
 He wasn't as well known as John Eastman or Alan Klein but he was a nice guy.&equo; 
 Angie Bowie: &bquo;The Michael Lipman brought a management contract &mdash; this was when we were in L A and David was doing so much cocaine. 
 I'm so stupid that I started doing cocaine to try to understand him &mdash; to get close to him and understand where he was coming from. 
 Can you believe anyone can be that dumb? 
 But that's how much I loved him. 
 I really thought I couldn't bear not to at least understand what he was going through, but by that time my opinion was totally irrelevant &mdash; not wanted &mdash; added to which, I'm not easy to get along with anyway because I'm not a &bquo;yes-man&equo;. 
 When David did things that I thought were stupid, or when he didn't turn up, or he'd turn up &bquo;high&equo;, I told him I thought he was stupid. 
 But I thought I was on my way out of the door anyway. 
 It didn't take him long to realize that one less headache was getting rid of me. 
 Times change. 
 People don't always stay together. 
 You can't expect him to be grateful for things we did together when we were in love &mdash; when we were working happily together. 
 You can't expect a man to walk around thinking he's got to be grateful to them for the rest of his life &mdash; it's ludicrous. 
 I wasn't there trying to tell him that he was doing something wrong or that he shouldn't be doing it. 
 That wasn't the point. 
 The point was that it basically has to come from yourself and if you feel funny about yourself, then maybe you should go to the root of what's making you feel funny as opposed to just taking downers and then taking uppers. 
 At any time you can take too much or too little of something and die. 
 Then no-one would have been satisfied, let alone the person who is the victim in all this. 
 It only became a moot point because David was a meal ticket for so many people. 
 There was an industry built around David Bowie. 
 I do hope it's not the bitterness of someone who isn't logical, but sometimes it makes me emotional. 
 I really feel for him. 
 I feel how much he was at people's mercy, being manipulated, and it does upset me. 
 I hate talking about it because I hate making it sound as if someone is to blame but I just can't stand people who manipulate other people. 
 It really makes me angry.&equo; 
 Tony Visconti: &bquo;Prior to the split with Tony deFries, our friendship developed once again. 
 I was involved with the show that was recorded at The Marquee and I think a few months after that he called me and said he was doing an album called &bquo;Diamond Dogs&equo; and didn't know where to get it mixed. 
 He'd been all over town and had a few vocals left, a few guitar bits, and was rather disenchanted with the studio he was using. 
 I had just finished building a 16-track studio in my house and asked him to come and have a go on that equipment that even the very big studios didn't have.So he brought his tapes with him that night and he loved it. 
 It was like a little home studio but with all the big gear in it. 
 It was everyone's dream to mix their album in their front room and that's the kind of studio it was at the time. 
 We sat that first evening on two carpenter's benches &mdash; we didn't even have proper tables and chairs &mdash; and started mixing the album. 
 We did a few vocals and overdubs and eventually the album was mixed bar one track, which he did somewhere else. 
 We had all sorts of disasters that night. 
 I did his tape copy on the machine I was using for echo and it was switched to vari-speed, so the copy was played at almost half the speed and when he got it home and wanted to play it to his friends, it sounded rather strange. 
 But in spite of the bumps in the beginning he kept coming back to my little home studio and that's how the second half of our lives together began. 
 I then got a phone call in the middle of the night &mdash; I always get phone calls in the middle of the night from David. 
 He said, &bquo;I want you to mix my live album &mdash; &bquo;David Live'&equo;, so off I went to New York and we did very few overdubs, basically just the backing vocals, because the backing vocals were done by Warren Peace  which is Geoffrey McCormack  in disguise, and some other bloke, whose mane I can't remember, and as they were dancing all the time the backing vocals were rather breathless, so we had to dub them again in the recording studio. 
 But the rest of the album, unlike other live albums, was truly live. 
 All David's vocals were live. 
 I remember he had Earl Slick  in the band then &mdash; it was a very large band, about 14 pieces on that tour.&equo; 
 Tony Zanetta: &bquo;I think DeFries finally realized that it was it. 
 DeFries and David were very much alike, especially in their emotional complexion, both very cold &mdash; or maybe that's the wrong word &mdash; but neither was very expressive emotionally. 
 What DeFries said to David or what he felt I don't know, but what he said was, &bquo;Well, if that's what he wants, then he should leave&equo;. 
 DeFries was never one to tell people what to do or badger anyone. 
 He always expected them to leave: he expected everyone to leave. 
 As far as he was concerned, that was where people are. 
 He didn't think this world would last for ever and if he wanted to leave he should leave. 
 But what it meant to both of them was that all the money was frozen because there was a dispute over whose money was what and how much money had been spent &mdash; that was a problem for David and for Tony. 
 I think it's hard to be honest with yourself about certain things and I wanted to think that I had no part in the grandiosity of MainMan and a lot of the bad things about MainMan. 
 There were a lot of wonderful things about the organisation and about Tony DeFries &mdash; he really is a wonderful man and gave a lot of people a lot of opportunities, but we all took it so much for granted. 
 It made David Bowie a star. 
 I'm not saying he wouldn't have become one without MainMan, but when you talk about MainMan, you have to be so definite &mdash; which part of MainMan and when. 
 The good part, the early part, the middle part, the later part. 
 I think it was Angie and Tony, going back to that incredible support that I told you about when I first met them, that they were also dreamers and had such faith and believed in David's future and his destiny. 
 That was contagious, you see. 
 We were all people that were looking for something to believe in. 
 We were all looking for some direction in our lives and they gave us that direction. 
 I think it came from David, but Angie and Tony certainly drummed it up and sold it to us and then went on and sold it to others. 
 It was an ever increasing thing that blew up because it got a little too big, but it did make David a star and he has dealt with it really well, and is a man who does wonderful work. 
 He can choose his own projects and lives a very private life. 
 When he wants to work he does, and his work is terrific, and that's a nice way to live one's life.&equo;  
 Candy Clarke with the man who fell to earth. 
 Punch drunk and on tour 
 Performing a rare version of &bquo;You Need Hands&equo; for the Midnight Special at The Marquee club, London. 
 Under surveillance, three security police wonder whether to ask for autographs 
 Wayne County and Bowie in discussion 
 Arriving at the Cafe Royal for his farewell party 
 Final touches for a midnight special performance by make-up lady Barbara Daley &mdash; the lady who later went on to do the make-up for Lady Diana on her wedding day. 
 In Amsterdam in 1974 
 David and Geoffrey McCormack always travel &bquo;soft&equo; class, Siberia, 1973 
 On the Trans-Siberian Express &bquo;73 
 The smile of success &bquo;72 style 
 David filming the May Day Parade in Moscow, 1973. 
 Inset with Catherine Deneuve at Heaven night club in the film &bquo;The Hunger&equo; 
 David photographed at the Grammy Awards of 1975 with John Lennon, Yoko Ono and Roberta Flack 
 Diamond Dogs and Soul tour shots from &bquo;74/ &bquo;75 
  Leee  Black Childers &mdash; MainMan 1 
 Cherry Vanilla &mdash; MainMan 2 
 The Thin White Duke, 1976 
 Dana Gillespie 
 Mick Ronson 
 David on the Rona Barrett Show in 1976 
 Climate change and agriculture: and a Soviet dissent 
 Russia's history can be read as a long battle with geography and climate. 
 General Winter may have repelled invaders from Napoleon to Hitler, but he is a domestic tyrant from whom successive regimes have sought to escape by pushing south to more friendly climes and warm-water ports. 
 Summer has never been a sufficient compensation for his excesses. 
 It is a fickle, too-short season and for much of this century the Soviet Union's granaries have never been quite full enough for domestic and political comfort. 
 This is despite the fact that its acreage of farmland is about the same as that of the United States, a nation that has become the world's greatest grain exporter. 
 Tsarist Russia before the First World War held that position, earning a third of its foreign exchange from grain sales. 
 Famine at home did not deter the Tsars from exporting grain; Stalin took a similarly hard-nosed approach, rationed consumption at home and sold abroad for the sake of political influence and foreign exchange. 
 The Soviet Union managed to remain a net exporter until the beginning of the 1970s. 
 From then on the contrast with the United States becomes stark. 
 American production soared, largely to meet overseas demand, and the Soviet Union, despite some impressive gains in production, became for the first time a large importer. 
 Lack of incentives, bureaucratic mismanagement and other well-publicized ills of the Soviet economy may bear much of the responsibility for the disparity between the superpowers, but Robert Paarlberg's Food Trade and Foreign Policy  confirms that climate has been the chief factor: 
 More than half the arable land in the United States receives annually at least 700 mm of precipitation; only 1 per cent of the arable land in the Soviet Union receives as much moisture. 
 In those regions where rainfall is adequate, the soil tends to be poor, or the weather too cold. 
 Plentiful moisture in the extreme northern latitudes, for example, is rendered useless by severe winter frost and an abbreviated growing season. 
 The warmer regions south and east of the Ukraine are unfortunately the driest. 
 Light and irregular rainfall during the summer growing season here is often accompanied by high temperature, scorching wind, and devastating dust storms. 
 Because the inadequate moisture levels are also highly changeable, year-to-year variation in Soviet farm output is typically three times greater than in the United States. 
 Grain has always been important as an indicator of national well-being and prosperity, with bulging granaries more important to security in the long term than the missile silos which often share the same farmlands. 
 The 1988 drought &mdash; the third of the decade &mdash; was arguably more of a blow to the American sense of security than the discovery of an alleged missile gap in the 1950s. 
 Domestic consumption of grain overtook production for the first time. 
 There are no recurrent natural events so mindlessly implacable and dispiriting as droughts and, regardless of the argument about the true cause of 1988s, the televised scenes of dying maize and despairing farmers became the hinge of a turn in the Western world's chief preoccupation, from the threat of nuclear annihilation to climate change. 
 A new era had announced itself. 
 By contrast, the Soviet Union had, of course, always co-existed with a climate which could never be taken for granted. 
 In the post-war period Moscow directed much effort towards overcoming its agricultural inferiority vis-&agrave;-vis  the West, especially the United States. 
 Stalin's successor Khruschev, in the mid-1950s, made overtaking US meat production (which entailed rapid increases in the production of feed-grains) the measure of success or failure of his attempt to improve the Soviet diet. 
 He envisaged a Soviet return to the position of leading exporter of grain as something that would make &bquo;Messrs Imperialists&equo; sit up and take notice. 
 In fact, Soviet production did rise until 1978, after which a run of six bad harvests and the inconsistencies of the Soviet economy produced stagnation. 
 Given the poor publicity generated by the Soviet Union's agricultural failings, it comes as something of a surprise to look at the statistics and see that the Soviet Union is still the world's largest wheat producer, greater than the European Community (which also made agricultural self-sufficiency a goal in its early years) by about 10 million tons in 1989, outstripping the United States and Canada, the world's &bquo;breadbasket&equo;, by almost the same amount. 
 Where the Soviet Union falls down is in the production of what are called coarse grains &mdash; maize (corn) principally, but including barley, oats, rye, sorghum and other grains apart from rice. 
 It was the maize crop which was the chief victim of the 1988 American drought. 
 But even in a bad year like that one, US production was nearly eight times greater than the Soviet Union's. 
 In a reasonably good year like 1989 it was between 12 and 13 times greater, fortunately, perhaps, since the Soviet Union was obliged to purchase 40 million tonnes of grain from abroad. 
 During the early 1970s, when the sort of thinking exemplified by Limits to Growth  permeated official forecasts of imminent shortages of strategic commodities, the CIA toyed with the idea that &bquo;The United States&equo; near-monopoly position as a food exporter&hellip; could give &lsqb;it&rsqb; a measure of power it never had before.&equo; 
 Food would become the weapon with which the United States would counter the Arab world's use of an oil embargo in its fight against Israel. 
 It was an idea that persisted. 
 Food had become power, a &bquo;valuable instrument of foreign policy&equo;, as Alexander Haig, Secretary of State under President Reagan, noted in 1981. 
 President Carter had applied it in the form of an embargo on grain sales to the Soviet Union after the Christmas 1979 invasion of Afghanistan; and it was to prove as ineffective as the Arab oil embargo. 
 The grain trade was &mdash; and is &mdash; of immense importance to the United States, and to its relation with the Soviet Union. 
 It has entered into long-term bilateral grain agreements (LBGAs) with only two countries, the Soviet Union (three times) and China (once). 
 During five years of the second LBGA (1983&ndash;8) with the Soviet Union, the United States sold its rival grain worth &dollar;7 billion and during two of those years &mdash; 1986 and 1987 &mdash; subsidized the sales to the tune of &dollar;450 million. 
 In the peak years of 1979&ndash;80 the United States' share of the world trade was 51 per cent of wheat and 73 per cent of coarse grains. 
 It was a trade worth, in 1980, &dollar;27.1 billion. 
 By contrast, the Soviet Union had become the world's biggest importer, taking almost a quarter of all internationally traded grain, a third of it from the United States. 
 The Soviet Union is making strenuous efforts to reduce its dependence on imports, boosting its use of fertilizers to levels above those anywhere else, but its enlistment of poor, fragile land in the battle for self-sufficiency in the early 1970s has meant a loss of land through abandonment in the 1980s, perhaps as much as 13 per cent of the peak grain area. 
 Food may not have become a weapon, but the failure of Soviet agriculture to meet its peoples' demands was a wound that contributed to the collapse of Soviet power in the second half of the 1980s. 
 Climate change could put both superpowers in the same boat. 
 There are those who see the drying out of the continental interiors as a more significant consequence of climate change than sea-level rises. 
 Environmental politics on the global scale will be dominated increasingly by the need to feed people, so any climate shift adversely affecting the American grain-belt will be a serious matter. 
 Other areas may, of course, be able to produce more. 
 Agricultural adaptation is possible, too. 
 The Israelis have grown fruit and nuts successfully in temperatures of 46 &deg; C and new strains of drought and heat-resistant crops will no doubt be developed. 
 How quickly, though, and whether there will be sufficient incentive to produce in bulk for countries which are unable to pay are different matters. 
 Countries like Ethiopia have been fed out of surpluses at little cost, but even there thousands have died before the food reached them. 
 In much of the West where productivity has been high and population increases relatively small &mdash; in some countries zero &mdash; the problem confronting agriculture has been how to control expensive surpluses. 
 Butter mountains loom above lakes of olive oil. 
 Milk quotas have been introduced to limit the output of over-productive herds. 
 Set-aside schemes have taken land out of production in the United States as well as in the European Community. 
 The United States, for instance, idled 15 per cent of its total crop acreage in 1987 and 1988 in line with the Administration's policy of reducing stocks, raising prices and conserving land at risk from erosion. 
 One of the consequences of the 1988 drought was a sharp reduction in the set-aside programme. 
 Lester Brown, the head of the Worldwatch Institute in Washington, DC, calls the food mountains of the 1980s a &bquo;temporary aberration&equo; which will soon run out. 
 The 1980s, he notes, were the first decade in history in which there was no increase in the area of land farmed and &mdash; also for the first time &mdash; a fall in the amount of fresh water used per capita. 
 Shortages and rising prices could mean the world was heading for &bquo;the grain shock of 1992&equo;, a crisis for which it was unprepared. 
 Towards a brave new modified climate 
 Mikhail Budyko, the most revered figure of Soviet climatology, has never been noted as a cold war warrior, but he has always been aware of the limitations imposed on the Soviet Union by its climate. 
 He is not a sceptic about the reality of global warming &mdash; he can claim to have been the first man to notice it &mdash; but he does not believe it is necessarily harmful. 
 He accepts the evidence that there has been a drying-out in the continental interiors affecting both the United States and the Soviet Union and then qualifies his acceptance by suggesting that it will be remedied in the next century by greater precipitation. 
 He uses a study of past periods of warming stretching back over several millions of years to confirm his view that more carbon dioxide to nourish plants, more warmth, more rainfall, more arable land as the frontiers of ice are pushed back will mean bigger harvests. 
 His thinking, with its faith in science and brave new worlds, is very old-style &bquo;Soviet&equo;, at its core a belief that climate can be modified beneficially on the grand scale. 
 He recommends more research, with &bquo;the aim of creating a global system of biospheric regulation in the interest of human society&equo;. 
 In Climate and Life  he recalls the work of his collaborator O.A. Drozdov on &bquo;Changing the Climate in Connection with the Plan for Transforming Nature in the Drought Regions of the USSR&equo;; and studies by others on the feasibility of melting the polar ice with nuclear energy and by damming the Behring Straits and pumping water from the Behring Sea into the Arctic. 
 It is by no means evident, he admits, that the results would be beneficial; more study is required. 
 He is more convinced by a scheme prepared by another collaborator, M.I. Iudin, for changing the intensity of low-level cyclones by employing a system of vertical air jets in the area where they form. 
 Laying down broad belts of asphalt might, by developing thermal convention, lead to increased precipitation. 
 He writes in the last paragraph, &bquo;It should be borne in mind that for the creation of a climatic regime managed by man, further progress of science and engineering is necessary which would permit a considerable increase in the present production of energy. 
 It is beyond doubt that with peaceful development of human society, such progress will be realised in the near future.&equo; 
 &bquo;Budyko thinks climate change is the best thing since sliced bread,&equo; said a US scientist at the World Meteorological Organization in Geneva in 1989 in a conversation with the author. 
 &bquo;He is greatly respected, but I don't think the Soviet-led &bquo;impacts&equo; group (of the IPCC) will reflect his views.&equo; 
 Others echoed his opinion, with differing degrees of confidence. 
 The belief in a scientifically-controlled world runs deep in Soviet society. 
 If you can't escape your climate, change it. 
 If you don't think your rivers are running in the right place, divert them. 
 The ecological disaster created by the diversion of water from the Aral Sea for the sake of a better cotton crop has given that sort of thinking a severe knock. 
 The Aral has lost 40 per cent of its surface as well as its fish and the fishing fleets that netted them. 
 Salt-laden winds howl round its desiccated and still shrinking perimeter. 
 But in a world where nature left to its own devices is as grim as it is in much of the Soviet Union, the belief that you can bend it on the heroic scale is unlikely to go away. 
 Climate change through the man-made modification of greenhouse gases might be disastrous, but it might equally be deliverance. 
 There might even be, one day, warm water ports in the Arctic. 
 Soviet hesitations were evident when Budyko told a climate change conference in Hamburg in November 1988 that it might be better to increase carbon dioxide emissions to encourage warming. 
 The cost of restricting emissions in a country struggling with inefficient smokestack industries may not have been in Budyko's mind, but it is an obvious factor in the Soviet attitude, as it is elsewhere. 
 Obviously, there is always a temptation to think nationally rather than globally. 
 If India's government is persuaded that warming will produce better and more reliable monsoons, then it might decide that the interests of its burgeoning population would be better served by global warming than by attempts to hold it in check. 
 Even Canada, a leader in environmental matters, must have interest in a situation which could extend its growing season and allow it to push its arable lands further north. 
 But the trouble with climate modification of the sort imposed by the greenhouse effect is that it does not move naturally to a new, warmer status quo which will remain undisturbed for the next thousand years or so. 
 It continues to change, and probably very rapidly, so any gains might well prove to be short-lived. 
 In large nations and groupings of nations, such as Western Europe, advantage in one area might be accompanied by misfortune in another, as, for example, if Northern Europe experienced a more favourable climate while the Mediterranean dried out. 
 The decade of the 1980s had its upturns as well as downturns in food production, but the overall pattern was disquieting. 
 The three drought years sapped North American output. 
 From the middle of the decade onwards the two largest Third World countries, China and India, failed to increase their grain production. 
 It was clear from the records of yields per hectare that the era of &bquo;miracle&equo; grains was over. 
 India, which prided itself on the self-sufficiency achieved by its green revolution, was obliged to buy wheat in 1988&ndash;9; China's imports of wheat reached record levels in the last years of the decade, a reflection, no doubt, not just of two years of drought but of a situation where peasants received certificates instead of cash for their crops. 
 Poland, a developed country, joined the ranks of supplicants for food aid, a category usually limited, under the Food Aid Convention, to developing nations. 
 Despite a 6 per cent increase in the global cereal harvest in 1989, the year was the third in succession in which production failed to meet demand. 
 Food stocks fell to their lowest level since the food crisis of the early 1970s. 
 How accurate such figures are is always open to question, though. 
 Local farmers and regional government often hold large emergency stocks which are not counted, but it is nevertheless accepted that they represent a trend. 
 The figures for food sent by the 22 Food Aid Convention countries reveal once again the importance of the US grain belt. 
 It provides more than half the aid, 75 per cent of which is wheat. 
 So a cut of 30 per cent in the US contribution of wheat is immediately reflected in a similar cut in the total amount available. 
 The effect of that in 1988&ndash;9 was not starvation in developing countries but higher food bills. 
 Whereas in 1987&ndash;8 some 14 per cent of their wheat imports came as aid, in 1988&ndash;9 the percentage was down to 11 per cent. 
 1989&ndash;90 looked like being much worse, with the percentage falling to 8 per cent. 
 As the International Wheat Council noted in its October 1989 market report, the implications for countries struggling with foreign debts, higher commercial grain prices and tougher credit terms were &bquo;especially serious&equo;. 
 On the other hand &mdash; and there is invariably an &bquo;other hand&equo; in these environmental and quasi-environmental matters &mdash; aid tends to depress local markets and discourage farmers from producing more. 
 Reduce aid and they will grow more, goes the argument. 
 That may apply to some African countries, but it is hard to imagine the two biggest aid recipients, Egypt and Bangladesh, doing a great deal more to feed themselves. 
 No more &bquo;miracles&equo; 
 Abundance often lies less than half a day's jet flight from starvation. 
 Distribution problems have probably caused more deaths from starvation in recent years than an actual shortage of food. 
 The West could certainly produce more than it does, but equally certainly not enough to deal with the huge population increases projected for the developing world in the coming century. 
 At the June 1988 Toronto conference three members of the Indian Agricultural Research Centre, in New Delhi, provided some figures which demonstrated the size of the problem. 
 In 1986, 1942 million tonnes of food grains were produced to feed a world population of nearly 5 billion. 
 To maintain the same level of per capita consumption in 2025, with an expected population of 8.2 billion, grain production would have to increase to 3050 million tonnes. 
 To take a few regional examples, Africa would have to increase grain production by almost fivefold and Latin America by almost threefold. 
 Apart from Africa, there is not a great deal of potential arable land left, so, using an across-the-board figure, it would be necessary to devote approximately 66 per cent of all farmed lands to cereals. 
 Even so, the bulk of the increase would have to come from improved yields, as it has in the past three decades. 
 At that point, two factors slide into the picture. 
 The first is the energy, most of it from fossil fuels, required by modern agriculture and the system which delivers its produce to the customers; the other, the peaking of the &bquo;miracle grain&equo; revolution. 
 New and more productive cereal cultivars have contributed their share to improved yields, but the biggest share in developed countries like the United States has come from increased use of fertilizers &mdash; 55 per cent between 1965 and 1976, according to the New Delhi paper quoting an FAO estimate. 
 Modern agriculture requires not only more fertilizer but more mechanization, too: 
 This in effect led to a situation where the commercial energy input became about equal to the equivalent energy output of edible grains. 
 If the energy input to the whole agricultural system was estimated, from land preparation to canned provisions in supermarkets, then the commercial energy expended was greater than the solar energy harvested by the crops. 
 Thus it would be virtually true to say that ultimately fossil fuels serve as food in developed countries. 
 The State of the World  1989 put the same case in a different form: 
 In per capita terms, world fertilizer use quintupled between 1950 and 1984, going from 5 kilograms to 26 and offsetting a one-third decline in grain area per person. 
 As land becomes scarce, farmers rely more on additional fertilizer to expand output, in effect substituting energy in the form of fertilizer for land in the production process. 
 Farmers in developing countries use fertilizers on their lands, too, of course, but more of the routine work is done manually. 
 The New Delhi paper estimated that 0.038 of a ton of oil was burnt to produce a ton of grain in India; in the United States the figure was 0.110. 
 More fertilizer might mean more grain (and more carbon dioxide and nitrous oxide to add to the greenhouse effect), but there obviously comes a point where more fertilizer does not mean a bigger yield or perhaps is not justified on cost grounds, particularly when grain prices are low, as they were for part of the 1980s. 
 The miracle grains introduced in the 1960s have played their part in the agricultural revolution but there is no sign that new strains are on their way. 
 According to the New Delhi paper's authors, the peak yields in both wheat and rice were obtained during experimental trials in the 1960s and have not been repeated since. 
 So any increase in output will have to come from better farming methods, particularly in countries like India, whose rice farmers lag well behind Japan's in productivity. 
 The growth of the deserts 
 Human ingenuity has often confounded the pessimists. 
 Malthus was wrong about the effects of unchecked population growth, as the optimists constantly remind those who look too bleakly into the future. 
 The law of diminishing returns has not applied to food production in the countries which have undergone the industrial revolution, although there have been periodic crises, such as the Irish famine of 1845&ndash;6, to remind us that Malthus was not completely wrong. 
 About one-third of the Irish population emigrated to wrest a living from new lands in North America and Australia. 
 Mass emigration of that sort is not an option these days. 
 Leaving out the debatable new lands opened up by clearing tropical forests, the amount of land available for agriculture, even of the most limited, nomadic sort, seems to be diminishing. 
 According to UNEP's figures, desertification is taking as much land out of agricultural use as exploiters of one kind or another are clearing in the rainforests: 
 UNEP and others have estimated that it would cost approximately &dollar;4,500 million a year over the next 20 years to slow and stop desertification, and to begin to reclaim the land that we have already lost. 
 That money and other needed support just hasn't been forthcoming, and because of that the deserts continue to advance. 
 Pilot projects don't get catalyzed; know-how isn't spread among the very poorest countries; outside development assistance continues to be poorly co-ordinated &mdash; sometimes even pulling in opposite directions. 
 Desertification comes in several guises: as encroaching sand, degrading croplands and grazing, waterlogging and salinization of irrigated land, destruction of trees and shrubs, erosion and deterioration in water supplies. 
 It is above all largely caused by people, with nature in the accomplice role. 
 Under threat are the world's drylands, which are said to constitute about 35 per cent of the world's land area and support some 850 million people. 
 Tolba accuses the international community of neglecting problems which will grow worse with time: &bquo;The real obstacle is the lack of political will.&equo; 
 There are others, though, who say that UNEP's Plan of Action is largely irrelevant to the attempts to stabilize the drylands. 
 Most aid is being given in the form of bilateral projects. 
 And by what method of assessment (ask the critics) did it arrive at its figure of &dollar;90 billion for a twenty-year programme? 
 The truth is that such huge figures have a hypnotizing effect on the victims and arouse a defensive incredulity among those supposed to provide the money. 
 The victims are unlikely to believe that they can do much from their own resources if action is dependent on billions of dollars, and the developed nations can hardly man every environmental barricade from Ethiopia to the Amazonian rainforest. 
 There may be, too, a sotto voce  challenge to the received wisdom that it is people who cause desertification. 
 Deserts are the result of a lack of water and if there is a prolonged, fluctuating drought (like the one that began on the northern fringe of sub-Saharan Africa at the end of the 1960s) vast sums of money are not going to stop desertification. 
 Where desertification poses its greatest threat to the lives and livelihoods of people is in the Sahel and the Horn of Africa. 
 It is not a region where costly Plans of Action are going to work. 
 &bquo;There isn't much point in trying to grow a belt of trees across the desert,&equo; Camilla Toulmin, the head of IIED's Drylands Programme, told the author. 
 &bquo;I would make two points: the first is that a lot of very small-scale activity does achieve results. 
 And the second is the need to get people involved locally. 
 I wouldn't say the desert is being contained, but there are diagnoses and solutions.&equo; 
 The solutions in the end come down to not over-grazing, managing the water supplies and choosing appropriate crops. 
 But sustainability in such arid circumstances depends on sustainable populations which do not exceed the resources. 
 And in Africa that must mean people moving from the rural areas into the overcrowded towns, which at least offer subsistence. 
 They also offer political instability. 
 As is frequently pointed out, every government in the Sahel fell after the droughts of the early 1970s. 
 Poor, vulnerable government makes every problem worse, particularly in a continent where so many factors contributed to increasing poverty and very few to wealth. 
 As a World Bank report noted grimly, &bquo;Never in human history has population grown so fast.&equo; 
 The half-billion people in sub-Saharan Africa will become one billion by 2010, a growth rate which, now or later, has disaster as its terminus. 
 Political will in such situations is a low explosive, blasting along the lines of least resistance. 
 Alas, there is no profitable course of least resistance in Africa. 
 If one takes everything into account &mdash; the shifts in climate which might well remove the United States from its place as the leading &bquo;food power&equo; and affect the Soviet Union as well, the limited prospects for increased yields, desertification and the steady increase in the global population &mdash; it is clear that in the next century large sections of the world's population will have a very narrow margin between them and starvation. 
 In an increasing number of cases, no margin at all, as has been the case in the past and is so today in parts of Africa. 
 There are cushions like the World Food Programme and the stocks held by the major grain producers, but emergencies and poor harvests could run them down very quickly. 
 But there are no easy solutions; it is hard, for example, to imagine the EC countries deciding overnight to forget their searing battles over agricultural policy and return to the old days of costly subsidies and surpluses in order to build up buffer stocks to higher levels. 
 It is equally hard to imagine countries capable of producing surpluses stonily refusing to do so in the face of an evident need. 
 At the moment, though, understanding of the regional impacts of climate change really is not good enough to persuade countries to rush into costly agreements on strengthening food stocks. 
 Countries can think about widespread famine and the international organization needed to deal with it, but it is not easy to make detailed plans years in advance of the crisis. 
 The 1992 UN conference on the environment could be the right place for an analytical look at what the world needs to do to ensure that it can feed its vulnerable populations in the next country. 
 Eco-politics: The greening of the greys 
 The Cit&eacute; des Sciences et de l'Industrie near the Porte de la Villette in Paris is one of those technological markers the French like to put down to show that architecture in their capital is not all ormulu and Belle Epoque . 
 There is also concrete, steel tubing and glass to think about, materials judged more suited to framing the aspirations of modern man. 
 As the venue for the fifth international conference of the European Greens, the Cit&eacute;, with its predications on a science-led industrialized society, seemed about as sympathetic a choice as the Chicago stockyards for a vegetarian convention. 
 The Greens had planned to hold their 1989 rally in the Sorbonne, but at the last minute they were told they would have to go elsewhere and the only venue available at short notice was the Cit&eacute;. 
 The hand of President Fran&ccedil;ois Mitterrand was detected. 
 Euro-elections were pending and, it was rumoured, he was doing his best to make life miserable for an organization which challenged his claim to the green constituency. 
 &bquo;Give the meek a good deal &mdash; join the Greens,&equo; announced a poster on a publicity stand in the foyer of the conference hall. 
 The 1000 or so members of the meek class who presented themselves at the conference, were, suitably enough, unruffled by having been shunted from the Sorbonne to the techno-chic sidings at Porte de la Villette. 
 Inheriting the earth, or what's left of it by the time the non-meek have realized the folly of their ways, is a process which takes much fortitude and patience. 
 It is, in fact, the absence of pushiness which makes the Greens a surprising lot, essentially more religious (in the very broadest sense) than political; more activist Quaker than Marxist. 
 The British Greens, for example, allow time for &bquo;attunement&equo; before their meetings start, reminiscent in its way of the reflective silence that can prevail at meetings of the Society of Friends. 
 The representatives from seventeen national parties at the Paris conference were quite plainly non-attenders in the established church of politics. 
 No priests, merely a shifting scene of spokespeople and co-chairs, and no franchise held by anyone on the pulpit. 
 The Greens are officially leaderless. 
 When the light descends on the individual and the voice within speaks it has an equal right to be heard. 
 It is the individual and the change of heart which prompts him to participate which matters. 
 Only the Germans, with their endless internal quarrels (and who are perhaps more faction-ridden Buddhist than Quaker in their attitudes), challenge the rules of green decorum. 
 They come from the alternative left originally, a sector which at its extremes is tinged with violence. 
 But one can go on almost endlessly tinker-tailoring the sources of greenness: Nordic nature-loving fascist, Quaker, Zen Buddhist, Taoist, Social Creditist, Marxist, socialist, pacifist, quietist, 1930s Green Shirt. 
 John Hargrave, the Quaker founder of the Kibbo Kift Kin, came nearest to bringing it all together when he began his book on the Kin with a quotation from the Taoist Lao-Tzu: &bquo;production without possession, action without self-assertion, development without domination.&equo; 
 The fact that no one is given command in the green movements does not mean that no one stands out among the ruck. 
 There are spokespeople (or speakers) and individuals whose characters and strong views shape the movement: Sara Parkin, who lives in Lyons and is co-secretary of the co-ordinating body which links the European parties; the Swiss Daniel Br&eacute;laz who, in 1979, became the first Green to be elected to a national parliament; Petra Kelly, the uncompromising driving force in the Fundi (fundamentalist) faction of Die Gr&uuml;nen, whose pragmatic factions, the Realos (realistic reformers) and Superrealos, seek to establish working relationships with the mainstream Left; and a number, not very large number, of others. 
 The Greens are, of course, tributary left, at times in spate, at other times the merest trickle, all according to the refreshments offered by fickle public opinion. 
 Their course is so far short: the first national Green Party founded in New Zealand as the Value Party in 1972, the next in the United Kingdom in the following year and then a long gap until Ecolo in Belgium in 1980 heralded a rush either to set up or amalgamate existing groups into parties in the early and mid-1980s. 
 Seen and heard en masse  those at the Paris conference were recognizable as the middle class's awkward squad: idealistic non-makers of money, profoundly suspicious of governments and the works of capitalism, individualistic and a touch anarchistic, decent in a stubborn, purposeful way and kindly. 
 They are the sort of people (and very often the same people) that in Britain you meet in CND and in scores of cluttered offices dedicated to under-regarded and under-rewarded causes. 
 A look later at a partial list of the Green Party's candidates for the 1989 British Euro-elections confirmed the general impression: it was full of teachers, lecturers, organic small-holders, social workers and adult students, with here and there the stray doctor, engineer and journalist. 
 A husband and wife duo of lawyers-turned-smallholders may have founded the British Green Party, but there were no lawyers on the list, or surgeons, or stockbrokers; or, for that matter, plumbers or shop stewards. 
 They are not a noticeably intellectual lot, the Greens, and anyone who goes to one of their conferences expecting deeply researched papers on the carbon tax issue or the structure of the future Green confederation of Europe will come away disappointed. 
 It is feelings, the heart not the mind, which are at the core of the Green polity. 
 As so often with essentially good people who act from feelings, they are broadly right. 
 What is wrong with the Greens is that they do not acknowledge the profound economic difficulties, and all their attendant national and international jealousies and suspicions, which obstruct the path to an environmentally safer world. 
 They suffer, in short, from that most unforgivable of political sins, unworldliness. 
 The Euro-elections were something of a test for the Greens. 
 They were fighting for seats in a body &mdash; the Strasbourg parliament &mdash; which is the assembly of the European Community, of which they strongly disapprove. 1992 and the European Single Market would be &bquo;disastrous, catastrophic&equo;, an &bquo;ideological bluff&equo; devised by deceitful politicians, declared a German MEP at the Paris conference. 
 &bquo;The new material culture will mean McDonalds from Sicily to Scotland.&equo; 
 On the same theme, the UK party made plain in a pre-European election statement why it did not like the Community. 
 The European Community consists of nation-states united by their desire to create greater economic wealth for themselves. 
 This is incompatible with the constraints of a finite world and we are therefore opposed to the EC as presently constituted. 
 The reference to a finite world carried echoes from Blueprint for Survival , the founding document of the British party in the early 1970s. 
 The party's formal manifesto (with a foreword by Petra Kelly) was no less dismissive, predicting failure for the &bquo;European superstore&equo;. 
 It is not just the EC's free market consumerism which the Greens detest; they are opposed, too, to its political structure based on capitalist nation-states. 
 The Greens believe (said the British manifesto) in a decentralized &bquo;Europe of the Regions&equo; which would develop into a Agalevn all-embracing confederation &bquo;from Lappland to Armenia&equo;. 
 How that would work out in practice is unclear. 
 In Britain, there are Scottish Greens and Welsh Greens, but no English Greens. 
 All managed somehow to merge their identities to produce a Euro-election manifesto in the name of the Green Party, which is the generic name under which the party appears on the voting slips. 
 Diminutive Belgium is more precise: its Greens are divided between Flemish-spe and French-speaking Ecolo. 
 Greens are against multinationals, naturally, and even against the ending of monetary barriers within the EC because &bquo;wealth will migrate even more quickly to those areas which are already wealthy, while the &bquo;peripheral areas&equo; will continue to be fed grudgingly with money for inappropriate projects like wall-to-wall holiday apartments and nuclear waste dumps.&equo; 
 (The leisure industry was denounced during the Paris conference as &bquo;prostitution&equo;.) 
 The Greens want regional self-reliance, in agriculture as well as in other things; a land tax applied so that &bquo;in general terms, the nearer the land is to its natural state, the lower the land tax would be&equo;; energy efficiency; population reduction through encouragement and education (with 15&ndash;20 million the target for Britain); and a sharing of &bquo;the abundance which nature can provide for us all if the greedy do not take more than their fair share&equo;. 
 It was easy to make fun of, and it was no wonder that Conservative Central Office had a field day, distributing a compilation of green policy statements, including the unrealistic ones on replacing the EC with a &bquo;loose federation of ecological countries&equo; and disengaging Britain from the international money market. 
 The Conservatives handed out the Greens' fairly innocuous version of the 1989 Queen's Speech gratis, too, in the belief that it was time the public had their eyes opened to what the party was really about. 
 The conflict between abhorrence of the institution and the political expediency which obliges Greens to seek seats in it leads to a rather antiphonal quality in much of what the Greens have to say on Europe and the devolution of power to the regions. 
 Their belief in &bquo;maximum self-reliance&equo; with regional parliaments retaining &bquo;most legislative powers&equo; did not prevent the British manifesto from declaring that a Green government would use the European courts to speed up UK compliance with EC environmental directives. 
 Equally, there would be a &bquo;coherent, integrated, efficient European transport system based primarily on waterways and railways&equo;, but no Channel Tunnel. 
 That presumably would remain the English &bquo;region's&equo; position on environmental grounds even though the French &bquo;region&equo; on the other side of the Channel might favour the tunnel in the interests of an integrated railway system. 
 Even presented in outline like that, it is reasonably clear that under green regimes Europeans would, by any conventional standards, become a great deal poorer than they are at the moment. 
 The Greens admitted that implicitly in the 1984 Joint Declaration of the European Green Parties in which they rejected an &bquo;economy based primarily on productivity (and)&hellip; on the creation of artificial needs&equo;. 
 A better way of life need not depend on a higher standard of living and they were out to stop those whose pursuit of continued economic and industrial growth undermined the basis of life itself. 
 &bquo;We wish to break totally from the liberal capitalism of the West and the state capitalism of the East, and want a third path which is compatible with an ecological society.&equo; 
 Deep within such essentially non-economic thinking is an image of a bucolic arcadia where demands and ambitions are simple and limited, the Amish of Pennsylvania on an international scale, but with railways and EC directives on pollution. 
 The unfortunate reality is that Europe is heavily urbanized and densely populated and there is no prospect, short of disaster, of changing that in the foreseeable future. 
 The Greens may be the wise visionaries of Europe, but in a &bquo;serious&equo; election dealing with economic issues their manifestos would be quickly torn to shreds. 
 No one votes for poverty &mdash; at least, not yet. 
 So why did the British Greens (to take the national party which won the highest percentage of the vote) do so well in the 1989 Euro-elections? 
 First, because Euro-elections do not have the blood-letting ferocity of a general election. 
 What happens in Strasbourg is not going to have much effect on the mortgage rate or inflation. 
 The election coincided with a precipitous slide in the popularity of a Conservative government struggling with a severe balance of payments deficit. 
 It was a great opportunity for registering resentment. 
 Taking a gamble, the British Greens contested all 78 mainland seats and took nearly 15 per cent of the vote (but no seats because of the first-past-the-post rule of British elections; i.e. there was not a single constituency in which the Greens had a majority). 
 In the 1984 Euro-election, when they contested only seventeen seats, they took 0.2 per cent. 
 So it was a remarkable jump into the headlines and popular acceptance, even if it was of a rather limited nature. 
 It was true that the turnout was a meagre 37 per cent of the electorate, by far the lowest in Europe, where the average was 59 per cent, but it was still two million people. 
 The heaviest green voting was in the Tory south, lending weight to the belief that many voters were disenchanted Tories casting a vote against an unpopular government. 
 It was a view supported later by the fading away of Green support to between 3 and 5 per cent in polls held at the end of the year. 
 The voters were by then more hostile to Mrs Thatcher and her government, but they were switching their support to Labour, not to the third parties. 
 The hard core of support seemed to have risen slightly during the year, but voting Green in the Euro-elections had not for most of the voters signified a new allegiance. 
 Relatively few had bothered to examine Green Party policy in detail, and most were unaware that the party was hostile to the EC and proposed reducing consumption in the interests of conservation. 
 The protest vote theory, though valid, was not sufficient to explain why 2 million adults took the trouble to vote for organic smallholders and kindred green souls who had hitherto made little impression on the political scene. 
 The vote was overwhelmingly urban, as it must be in a densely populated country like Britain, and almost certainly middle-class. 
 In similar circumstances in previous elections the dissatisfied Tories would have given the Liberals and the Social Democrats the benefit of their protest. 
 So their switch to the Greens indicated something more positive in their choice than mere protest. 
 Put at its simplest, they were voting for the countryside. 
 The fact that the Greens' &bquo;Europe of the Regions&equo; is little more than a nostalgic fantasy and their economic policies might rapidly place even organic small-holders in the same income bracket as Third World peasants was not important. 
 The Green voters were supporting clean air, unpolluted rivers, a peaceful countryside unblemished by motorways and new estates, in short for &bquo;quality of life&equo;. 
 They voted for a restoration of a betrayed heritage of wild flowers and healthy trees. 
 It might be as much a shimmering dream as &bquo;Europe of the Regions&equo; but that does not diminish its power. 
 A Gallup poll conducted for the Daily Telegraph  two months after the Euro-elections found that an &bquo;overwhelming&equo; majority of the electorate, including three-quarters of those who voted Tory in the 1987 general election, believed the government was not doing enough to protect the countryside. 
 More people than ever wanted to live there rather than in towns and 79 per cent took the view that the countryside was in danger. 
 Reviewing the situation at the end of the year, Lindsay Cooke, one of the Greens' 1989 spokespeople, thought despondently that the movement's share of the poll had shrunk because of a lack of publicity. 
 There were no MPs in Strasbourg or in Westminster for the media to focus on. 
 &bquo;The media have decided that there has been a return to two-party politics and everyone else has been marginalized,&equo; she told the author. 
 &bquo;Our views are not sought and when we do make our views known, they are not interested in reporting them.&equo; 
 The number of local Green parties had risen to nearly 270 by the end of the year and the membership had almost doubled from 9000 at the beginning of the year to 17,000 by the end. 
 Support for the Greens may have shrunk but it was still at the same level as the Liberal Democrats&equo;, the third party in Parliament, so perhaps Ms Cooke was unduly downcast. 
 But despite those substantial gains, bold statements about fighting every seat in the next general election were no longer heard. 
 The party was short of funds; and it was still being run from a tiny office with just four paid staff. 
 A third of the Membership claimed to be unemployed and their reduced subscriptions of &pound;6 did not cover even mailing costs. 
 The press officer, Barbara Bloomfield, complained at a meeting of the Greens' council in January 1990 that if she wanted to step out of the office she had to get a volunteer to take her place, possibly an overseas student who knew next to nothing about the press or the party. 
 Friends of the Earth, by comparison, had ninety paid staff. 
 &bquo;We cannot continue to run a serious party like this.&equo; 
 Chain-stores and industries may take full-page advertisements in newspapers to proclaim their greenness, but no millionaire had come forward to offer a share of his eco-sound profits. 
 If a potential philanthropist did exist, he might have found it a deterrent that there was no established leadership to whom he could talk. 
 The Greens were still arguing over whether the time had come to loosen principle a little and elect a leader, a public face, perhaps Sara Parkin, the International Liaison Secretary of the UK Greens as well as the European Greens' co-ordination co-secretary. 
 &bquo;We believe in leadership with , not leadership over  the party,&equo; said Lindsay Cooke. 
 &bquo;As a problem, it's a media invention, and, as it happened, the media chose a leader for us &mdash; Sara Parkin. 
 I am not decrying Sara in any way when I say it might have been more sensible for us  to choose the leader.&equo; 
 Two million votes and no seats. 
 The British electoral system presents practically insuperable obstacles for small parties to overcome. 
 Under proportional representation &mdash; the rule of all other EC member states &mdash; the British Greens would have been the largest national group in the Strasbourg Green firmament, where the number of those who regarded themselves as in some way Green had risen from 11 to 43. 
 That position was occupied by the French (whose vote had also risen steeply) with nine seats, followed by the West Germans with eight and the Italians with seven. 
 There were in the parliament at the end of 1989 twenty-nine European Greens and fourteen members (including two defectors from the Greens) of their old partnership, the Rainbow Group, a &bquo;technical&equo; gathering of green-tinged communists, nationalists and anti-EC Danes. 
 Even after this hiving-off the European Greens were not exactly monolithic, since, apart from the ideological differences within Die Gr&uuml;nen, they had taken under their wing an Italian who wanted the legalization of drugs and several small, otherwise homeless parties. 
 The most dynamic Green party in Europe is undoubtedly Die Gr&uuml;nen, which took 8.3 per cent of the vote in the 1987 West German federal elections and won 42 seats, only four fewer than the ruling Christian Democrats' coalition partners, the Free Democrats. 
 Here, if anywhere, one would imagine, was the making of the Red-Green coalition with the mainstream left-centre that the Realos seek. 
 Such coalitions exist at the municipal level in West Berlin and Frankfurt. 
 Informal talks were held with the Social Democrats in June 1989 with the 1990 elections in mind, a recognition in itself that the Green pragmatists were in the ascendant and the Marxist regionalists on the wane. 
 And then the Greens' past caught up with them &mdash; or, more accurately, was put on display by the government parties &mdash; and the Social Democrats retreated rapidly in case the electorate took fright at the thought of a pact with such a dubious, anarchic bunch. 
 Die Gr&uuml;nen has been described by Petra Kelly as an &bquo;anti-party party&equo;, and getting into bed with them might be a guarantee of ending up on the floor. 
 They are the &bquo;watermelon party&equo;, green on the outside and red on the inside, part of the &bquo;alternative&equo; subculture, the libertarian siblings of a rich society, not unlike at their extreme end the American drop-out society of the 1960s and 1970s. 
 The communist Greens insist that Die Gr&uuml;nen's posture in the Bundestag must be one of &bquo;irreconcilable opposition to and critique of existing conditions&equo;. 
 And there was more than a smack of sympathy for terrorism in a call by a leading Fundi for a &bquo;broad show of unity&equo; with a group which shot dead two policemen during a demonstration at Frankfurt airport. 
 Given the extremes within the party it is not surprising that there is a continuing feud between those willing to make political deals and those so utterly opposed to the system that they will make no concessions. 
 Die Gr&uuml;nen is generally regarded as the most turbulent and self-destructive of the Green parties, but its internal quarrels are, says Sara Parkin in her guide to the European Greens, &bquo;only a more flagrant example&equo; of what goes on in all the parties. 
 The Greens may have acted as catalysts in the green revolution, and their success in the Euro-election undoubtedly awoke the mainstream parties to the extent of the stirrings in the electoral loam, but they no more held a patent on green ideas than feminists did on equal rights for women. 
 Their ideas could be expropriated as freely and easily as blackberries from a hedge in summer. 
 For Labour, accommodation to the changing mood meant adopting the essentially green idea of assessing the environmental costs of growth and working them into the balance sheets (which the Tories are also adopting), but it did not mean following the Greens in calling for a halt to growth. 
 To do that in the way the Greens proposed would require a &bquo;virtually totalitarian state&equo;, Bryan Gould (at the time Shadow Trade Secretary) told the shadow cabinet in July 1989. 
 He admitted, though, that Labour was seen as too producer-oriented: &bquo;We should be able to give a value to unpolluted air, clean water, a safe environment, as the end-products of economic activity.&equo; 
 A great many green ideas were produced by Labour that summer; a &bquo;green bill&equo; to show up the deficiencies in Tory legislation; making the quality of life the central theme in the 1990 local elections; the mobilization of public opinion through the development of a network of environmental, countryside and energy organizations. 
 The Trades Union Congress weighed in with a Green Charter, which included the right to hold &bquo;green strikes&equo; over issues like the importation of toxic wastes. 
 But by the end of the year the &bquo;green bill&equo; had been quietly dropped and the environmental &bquo;network&equo; had vanished into a general belief in the need for good, informal relations with Friends of the Earth and other environmental organizations. 
 It was no longer necessary to upstage the Green Party; and it was becoming harder, too, to find a straightforward, easily defined green issue on which to challenge the Tories. 
 Mrs Thatcher had established her environmentalist credentials in several speeches and had replaced the true-blue but ungreen Nicholas Ridley with the practically viridescent Chris Patten as Environment Secretary. 
 Labour was obliged to match Patten with Bryan Gould: &bquo;I would agree that Thatcher and Patten understand global warming,&equo; said Gould's environmental researcher and adviser, Nigel Stanley. 
 &bquo;Thatcher's speech to the UN (8 November 1989) was very effective. 
 But I wouldn't agree that there is very little difference between the parties on green issues. 
 The Tories may talk green but they act dirty.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dirty&equo; in this context means trying to apply free market ideas to the prevention of pollution, to continuing to dump sewage in the sea, to not doing enough to curb road traffic and improve public transport. 
 Under the heading &bquo;A better quality of life&equo;, Labour's policy review for the 1990s declared that the future of the planet depended on keeping it at the top of the agenda: 
 People want tougher environmental regulation &mdash; nationally and internationally. 
 Industry, agriculture, local authorities and commercial developers must all have a clear framework within which to plan and invest. 
 It is hard to define precisely what constitutes quality of life. 
 You know it when you experience it, but it is not the same thing as standards of living or GNP; it is not quantifiable and not necessarily &bquo;environmental&equo;. 
 For some it is cows in flowering meadows, for others, cars and cheap central heating; and for the great majority, both. 
 The quality of life issues around which so much of the green argument revolves are not trivial, but they are secondary. 
 It is always possible to be kinder to the earth, but it is not saving clumps of trees from the bulldozers which will matter in the next century. 
 The primary issues are industrial rather than country matters and concerned with survival rather than the quality of life. 
 But if you strip away the embroidery from the Labour statement, there is agreement that the issue is survival. 
 That at least seemed to be bipartisan. 
 &bquo;It is life itself we must battle to preserve,&equo; said Mrs Thatcher in her speech to the United Nations in New York. 
 &bquo;The evidence is there. 
 The damage is being done.&equo; 
 The head of government of any industrialized state, of whatever persuasion, could have echoed that fervently in 1989. 
 The campaigners 
 Margaret Thatcher is a rarity among national leaders in that she has a science background. 
 While the greening of the electorate was rapidly taken aboard and she was impressed by the fact that acid rain could damage international relations as surely as it did stonework and trees, what caught her imagination were the profound implications of what was happening to the chemistry of the deeper atmosphere. 
 Between the glimpses of the apocalypse when she spoke to the UN General Assembly in November 1989 on the unprecedented dangers of its own making which faced mankind was an appeal: 
 it is no good squabbling over who is responsible or who should pay. 
 Whole areas of our planet could be subject to drought and starvation if the pattern of rains and monsoons were to change as a result of the destruction of forests and the accumulation of greenhouse gases. 
 We have to look forward, not backward. 
 We shall only succeed in dealing with the problems through a vast international cooperative effort. 
 The challenge for the negotiators was as great as for any disarmament treaty. 
 Time was too short to allow diversion into fruitless and divisive argument. 
 There was a general acceptance within the green community that the speech was a good one, although it was grudging in some cases: &bquo;Full of poetry and passion but&hellip; short on policy,&equo; wrote Tom Burke, Director of the Green Alliance. 
 What was needed was a lead not a lecture. 
 By the end of the year, Mrs Thatcher was in the chair of a new cabinet committee, Misc. 141, which had been given the task of preparing for the fast-approaching day when limits would be set on greenhouse gas emissions. 
 The new policies which would emerge for discussion in an autumn 1990 white paper would take matter well beyond the December 1989 Green Bill, which does not include carbon dioxide among the gases for which standards are to be set. 
 Cutting its emissions would go to the quick of industry, affecting road transport and energy output and involving potentially huge expenditures which the Treasury had, simultaneously with Misc. 141, set up its own committee to study. 
 Both committees were the result of Chris Patten's desire to see more forward-thinking and more co-operation between departments. 
 It was a measure of how much the green political arena had changed that in December 1989 Jonathan Porritt, then Director of Friends of the Earth, was invited for talks at 10 Downing Street. 
 Environmentalists were no longer &bquo;the enemy within&equo;, as Mrs Thatcher had described them only three years earlier. 
 The former eco-terrorists, feared for their readiness to ambush government whenever it marched into the green province, had suddenly become people worth informing and consulting at the highest level. 
 They were almost &mdash; but not quite &mdash; on the same side. 
 It could be argued, too, that they were beneficiaries of the heightened public awareness created by the increasing emphasis by government on the perils facing the environment. 
 Many waverers must have reached for their chequebooks and signed on with a green campaign organization after hearing the latest pronouncement assuring them that there really was something to worry about. 
 There are dangers in becoming officially accepted. 
 Complacency and a tendency to mute criticism of governments are among them. 
 Becoming fashionable is another. 
 The cutting-edge can become blunted. 
 The campaign groups should ideally be voices calling from the wilderness on behalf of the wilderness. 
 But then, of course, the wilderness grows less, or is saved (or perhaps tamed). 
 The romantic days which have seen the bold David McTaggart striding the Pacific main in the Greenpeace ketch Vega  to challenge the French bomb testers at Moruroa atoll may be passing simply because, in that particular case, the military reasons for testing are passing. 
 The mood and issues of the 1990s are bound to be different from those of the 1980s. 
 Climate change is already more important than acid rain, genetic engineering a more topical issue than saving whales. 
 Changed issues do not necessarily throw organizations into an anxious state of transition; if they are any good, they are always in transition. 
 That certainly applies to the three biggest international green campaign organizations: Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth and the World Wide Fund for Nature. 
 They continue to grow in size and influence and they appear to be still some way from peaking. 
 As they grow larger, they grow richer, they spend more on research and become more authoritative. 
 Greenpeace was accused of scientific sloppiness, so it appointed a director of science and two people to work with him, a recognition in its way that zipping over the waves in pursuit of whalers was not enough to keep it in the forefront in these intellectually demanding days of climate change. 
 But if you begin to get more solid and reliable &mdash; and perhaps institutional &mdash; do you also begin to get &bquo;soft&equo;? 
 The authors of Greenpeace's official history, The Greenpeace Story , go out of their way to refute the slur in their introduction: 
 Direct action remains the central theme of Greenpeace operations. 
 This needs to be stated clearly because there is a current media clich&eacute; that Greenpeace is turning its back on such tactics and is becoming a more bureaucratic, softer version of its earlier radical self. 
 This is demonstrably untrue; the number of direct actions continues in an upwards spiral. 
 What is true is that, in recent years, such actions have been backed up by sophisticated political lobbying and scientific enquiry that have added strength to the organization's dramatic calls for change. 
 Greenpeace's continued insistence on non-violent tactics, even when faced with violence, reflects both its cultural origins and its links with the other great movements for social change in the twentieth century. 
 Peter Melchett, Greenpeace's Executive Director in London, looked at the &bquo;softness&equo; issue from the aspect of whether being tough reduced influence. 
 &bquo;People come to us and say, &bquo;Tone down the message and we'll talk to you&equo;, but we don't accept that. 
 I don't think our direct actions are a problem reducing our effectiveness. 
 Politicians may not talk to us publicly, but they do privately.&equo; 
 The choice of heads for the campaigning organizations says a great deal about their memberships: solidly white middle-class. 
 Lord Melchett, educated at Eton, former Labour Minister of State for Northern Ireland, became head of Greenpeace at the beginning of 1989, near the beginning of the membership boom. 
 At Friends of the Earth there is (or was until mid-1990, when David Gee took over) his friend, the Hon. 
 Jonathan Porritt, Old Etonian, son of Lord Porritt, former Governor of New Zealand. 
 WWF's International President is the Duke of Edinburgh and its UK President is Princess Alexandra. 
 The Duke has an old-fashioned huntin', shootin' and fishin' greenness which is a bit at odds with the panda-loving, badger-saving attitudes of most WWF members, but he is outspoken in his condemnation of &bquo;the ruthless pursuit of economic development&equo;. 
 It is very English, of course, to fight for good causes under the cover of titled office-holders. 
 Neither Melchett nor Porritt fits the usual patterns of lordship, but their presence is reassuring to members who like to see guarantees of moderation and respectability flown at the masthead. 
 A &bquo;moral initiative&equo; for nature 
 As the guardians and voice of nature the green pressure groups are more effective than any political party. 
 The largest of them, Greenpeace, has, in the space of two decades, enlisted 3.5 million members worldwide and become rich enough to maintain a small fleet of boats and a research station in Antarctica. 
 Its activities have led to one boat being badly damaged by a French warship, another rammed by the US Navy while trying to interrupt a missile test, and one sunk in harbour by French agents. 
 In contrast to the other big pressure groups, Greenpeace does not accept funding from governments or firms. 
 It has had, since its inception, an adversarial relationship with governments and its activists are not the sort of people with whom Conservative governments easily make friends, particularly when they block the outflow pipe of nuclear processing plants such as the one at Sellafield in Cumbria. 
 Greenpeace's cultural origins are Quaker. 
 It was founded in 1970 by two American Quaker couples in Vancouver, British Colombia, who fell out with the Sierra Club, the long-established American conservationist organization, over its cautious stand on nuclear power and its refusal to become involved in big international issues. 
 They recalled that in 1958 Quakers had made an unsuccessful attempt to interrupt atmospheric testing of H-bombs at Bikini atoll in the Pacific. 
 The approaching US nuclear test at Amchitka in the Aleutians offered the chance of making a similar sea-borne protest. 
 Confrontation with the United States was followed by the more dramatic confrontations with the French at Moruroa atoll where the goaded French beat up Greenpeace's skipper, McTaggart, rammed a protest boat and eventually murdered a photographer who went down with the sabotaged Rainbow Warrior  in Auckland harbour in July 1985. 
 The Pacific &mdash; and the oceans generally &mdash; became the main theatre of the movement's direct actions, although it has challenged French airfield builders in Antarctica and climbed towering chimney-stacks to plant banners condemning acid rain. 
 Scenes of activists risking their lives to challenge lumbering factory ships generate publicity &mdash; and money &mdash; for causes of which the majority of people in Western countries approve. 
 In a sense Greenpeace volunteers are doing a lot of dirty work for the rest of us. 
 How else would we have known about the slaughter of whales or seal cubs? 
 How else could we have appreciated the dangers of ocean pollution, the extraordinary risks that are being taken with nuclear waste? 
 The politicians will not tell us of what is happening to the environment. 
 The vested interests of large corporations will not come clean unless we force them. 
 That is why Greenpeace have had to take the moral initiative&hellip; 
 &bquo;Moral initiative&hellip; a great movement for social change&equo; (to quote The Greenpeace Story  again)? 
 One does not really think of saving dolphins as connected with social change, but essentially Greenpeace's claim is not exaggerated. 
 In the West at least people have identified with a threatened world and the pressure groups have been the first instruments of that identification. 
 Whales have been saved, so have seals, and nuclear power has had the question-mark over it enlarged. 
 Greenpeace's international HQ produces an amazing amount of campaign literature: sea turtle fact sheets, Everyone's Guide to Toxics in the Home , five major arguments against kangaroo farming, ocean incineration of toxic waste, driftnets, the destruction of red coral, campaign to end nuclear weapon testing, save Antarctica, let's save the Mediterranean, and a great deal more. 
 Friends of the Earth comes from the same womb as Greenpeace, the Sierra Club. 
 The period in which both were founded &mdash; 1969 in the case of the Friends, and 1970 in Greenpeace's &mdash; marked a transition from old-fashioned conservationism to a much more political and active defence of nature. 
 The founder-president of FoE, David Brower, had resigned as executive director of the Sierra Club in 1969 after seventeen years in the post. 
 His parting was a traumatic event which borough conservative lovers of scenic beauty and wide-open spaces into direct conflict with the new breed of activists, internationalist in their outlook. 
 The Club had to decide, said Brower, whether to continue as a society of companions on the trail or take the position that &bquo;the entire environment is the proper province of conservationists&equo;. 
 In a ballot, the Club membership decided to stay with the trails and Brower's suspension by the Board for &bquo;dictatorial methods, disobedience and fiscal irresponsibility&equo; was upheld. 
 In 1989, the membership of FoE in the United Kingdom leapt from 60,000 to 150,000, its income from &pound;1,012,000 to &pound;2,144,000 and its expenditures from &pound;914,000 to &pound;1,996,000. 
 Its advice was sought by all the parliamentary select committees involved in any way with the environment and it had a place on several of the government's consultative bodies. 
 Internationally, it had observer status with the Food and Agriculture Organization, the International Maritime Organization, the London Dumping Convention, the International Whaling Commission, the Ramsar Convention on Wetlands and the International Tropical Timber Organization. 
 There were branches in thirty-three countries. 
 Despite its international image, FoE International's secretariat &mdash; currently in London &mdash; consists of one person. 
 The work is done by the national branches. 
 The British branch employs a fund raising team of eleven and an information staff of the same size. 
 There are nineteen more employed on running campaigns ranging from tropical rainforests to air pollution and London's roads. 
 It is difficult to imagine the World Wide Fund for Nature encouraging activists to clamber up chimneystacks or challenge French warships. 
 It raises funds for conservation and its concerns are with earth-bound pandas (it has helped set up ten panda reserves in China) rather than ocean-going whales. 
 There is a note of disapproval in the response of an official to a question about relations with the other big campaigners: &bquo;We work quite often with Friends of the Earth, less often with Greenpeace.&equo; 
 Royalty is in the van and the British headquarters are in Panda House, Weyside Park, Godalming, Surrey. 
 The late Sir Peter Scott was the founder, in 1961 (WWF is the only one of the Big Three which has British origins), and international headquarters are in Gland, Switzerland, in the same building as the International Union for Conservation of Nature and Natural Resources (IUCN), with which it has close relations (and which, in turn, is close to UNEP). 
 It bills itself as &bquo;the largest private conservation organization in the world&equo;, with offices in twenty-three countries and more than one million members. 
 In addition to the giant panda (its logo) it has &bquo;reprieved&equo; (WWF's word) the Indian tiger and the polar bear, the latter by persuading the five Arctic nations to restrict hunting. 
 The African elephant was a notable beneficiary of WWF's activities in 1989, with two British lawyers working on its behalf during the negotiations on the Cites agreement on ivory. 
 A change of priorities 
 The world's great mammals have, however, been edged away from centre-stage recently. 
 Since WWF's change to its present name from World Wildlife Fund it has, to quote a staffer in a rival pressure group, &bquo;been trying to get away from its cuddly animal image&equo;. 
 WWF says the change was made &bquo;to reflect more accurately the conservation work it does&equo;. 
 Nowadays, less than 10 per cent of its worldwide expenditure on conservation is directed solely on species protection. 
 The priority has become saving habitats and solving environmental problems. 
 One of the projects by which it sets most store is the Plants Conservation Programme, run jointly with the IUCN. 
 WWF found that finding a cuddly plant equivalent of the panda was difficult, so instead it focused on the value of plants to mankind, particularly medicinal plants. 
 And at that point, of course, it swings into the issue of bio-diversity and the threat that destruction of the tropical rainforests, with their genetic richness, will mean more and more plants being lost for good. 
 In Britain, too, there have been changes of emphasis. 
 Until 1985 the bulk of its allocations to projects went on purchases of land for reserves. 
 By 1989 reserves had slipped well down the list and education and public awareness had risen. 
 The most significant change, though, was the appointment of a greenhouse gases and transport campaigner. 
 Like the other campaign organizations, WWF had realized that the natural world can no longer be divided into isolated sectors of activity. 
 All are united by the threat of climate change. 
 Saving elephants, tigers and terms in the twentieth century will be a small gain if their habitats are ruined or destroyed along with man's in the twenty-first. 
 1989 was a marvellous year for the pressure groups. 
 Even at its end the members were still rolling-in in their thousands &mdash; 4000&ndash;5000 a week in Greenpeace's case. 
 Given the cycles in enthusiasm for green issues, maintaining the momentum may be a problem, but the example of West Germany is encouraging. 
 Its population is approximately the same as Britain's but its Greenpeace has 600,000 members, double the British membership. 
 Looked at collectively, the green movements in Britain are already numerically impressive. 
 To coincide with World Environment Day on 5 June 1989, The Times  published a survey which showed that the membership of fifteen green organizations was climbing towards parity with the membership of unions affiliated to the TUC. 
 If the current growth rates continued, it would be close to 6 million by 1992, with the TUC at 8.8 million and declining. 
 It was an unfair comparison, of course. 
 Most of the 2 million who belong to the National Trust (one of the fifteen) do so for the sake of visiting the houses it preserves, not because it is green. 
 All the same, the growth rate of this group, all broadly linked by an interest in the countryside and the environment, was evidence of the power building up behind the green movement in the 1980s and 1990s. 
 There is an obvious danger of excessive duplication when broadly similar organizations conduct broadly similar campaigns. 
 The rainforests are an obvious example. 
 As fund-raisers they are unparalleled. 
 The urban middle-class heart goes out to jaguars, exotic Indians and magnificent trees with a generosity that is not evident in the cases of kangaroos and red coral. 
 FoE is heavily involved in the rainforests; WWF considers them its &bquo;major international priority&equo;; Greenpeace started its rainforest campaign in 1989 and pondered the possibility of seaborne harassment of ships carrying timber exports. 
 &bquo;We are in competition, and I think that is good, but there is a lot of information-sharing,&equo; said Peter Melchett. 
 &bquo;There are informal networks through which we let one another know what we are doing and we meet and talk. 
 For instance, Greenpeace and Friends of the Earth had ten people each at a meeting recently (towards the end of 1989) to talk about the Green Bill and other issues.&equo; 
 Ad hoc  alliances of green organizations take place from time to time, and at the end of 1988 Greenpeace, Friends of the Earth and the World Wide Fund for Nature jointly threw down a &bquo;green gauntlet&equo; to the government, urging it to turn propaganda about the environment into action. 
 A list of thirty measures ranging from recycling resources to doubling overseas aid were proposed. 
 It made very little impact. 
 They appeared to be of one mind again when they appeared jointly to give evidence before the Commons' Energy Committee on the greenhouse effect's implications for energy policy. 
 This time, though, there was an interesting addition to their ranks, the Association for the Conservation of Energy, a combination of think-tank and pressure group mainly financed by manufacturers of equipment for conserving heat and energy. 
 &bquo;We will have to tackle the major issues,&equo; Peter Melchett had said, a shade regretfully, when asked how Greenpeace, with its policy of high-profile direct actions, would deal with the nebulous elements of climate warming. 
 They sent along their air pollution campaigner to the energy committee hearing. 
 But here was the future. 
 The grey enigmatic god carbon dioxide was taking over from Pan. 
 The uncertain politics of carbon dioxide 
 There is indeed something godlike about carbon, its omni-presence in all things living and dead, the grand cycles of time that move it in its vehicular form carbon dioxide between land, sea and air, the fertility it provides and its release by fire. 
 It manifests itself in diamonds as well as in coal, and it has more compounds than any other element. 
 A branch of science, organic chemistry, is witness to their complexity. 
 In combination with oxygen it forms the gas carbon dioxide. 
 A colourless gas with a faint tang, it can produce narcosis and even (after a lengthy exposure at a concentration of 5 per cent or more) unconsciousness and death, but it is as a greenhouse gas emitted in the course of producing man-made energy that it has become central to our end-of-century concerns. 
 That sort of centrality does not automatically make it an easy issue for national politicians, though. 
 All profess greenness nowadays, of course, but climate change has not yet become part of their instinctual combat kit with its codes telling them instantly what to do when action is joined over, for example, trade union legislation and welfare payments. 
 The first Commons debate on world climate change came only two days after the prime minister's theme-setting UN speech on the environment in November 1989, yet at no stage in its five-hour course was it attended by more than fourteen MPs. 
 The debate was opened by David Trippier, Minister of State for the Environment, who said the House could debate no issue of more immediate importance&hellip; and then announced that he would have to leave early to present the Young Environmentalist of the Year award at a lunch. 
 Attitudes on an issue which hardly ever figures in the popular press and does not fit into a ready-made political rut are bound to change slowly. 
 The warning signs were, in any case, hoisted slowly and cautiously by the scientists. 
 Early in 1980, Whitehall's newly-created Interdepartmental Group on Climate Change published a report on the implications of its subject for the United Kingdom. 
 The Thatcher administration was still new to the power it was to hold for the rest of the decade and a reader might reasonably expect to find something seminal in the report. 
 But its reluctant, even remote, tone is that of bureaucrats anxious to distance themselves from what might prove to be no more than fashionable scientific nonsense. 
 &bquo;Some people&equo; had argued that increasing atmospheric carbon dioxide had serious implications for the climate, but the committee had not come to any conclusions on that. 
 Recent extremes of weather had given &bquo;speculations&equo; credibility with the public, but the Meteorological Office scientists took the view that the variations in weather were compatible with established climate patterns. 
 The scientists were being cautious and so were the civil servants; this meant that British politicians could happily continue to struggle over familiar issues until 1988 when a devastating drought enabled scientists in the USA to get the ear of the Senate and pour into it a story sufficiently sensational to alarm the rest of the Western world. 
 The scientists who man the climatological observation posts are less cautious than they used to be now that the general theory of climate change has become common property; government servants are more confident and outspoken; and, while scepticism remains, no cabinet minister is likely to denounce the theory and the accompanying evidence as hysterical. 
 In 1978&ndash;9 the British government spent a modest &pound;250,000 on research, including the development of climate models. 
 By 1989&ndash;90 the budget was &pound;15.54 million (0.53 per cent of the total government expenditure on civil science and technology research and development), with an additional &pound;760,000 over two years for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change and &pound;5 million pledged to fund the new centre for the prediction of climate change announced by Mrs Thatcher in her UN speech on the environment. 
 The valedictory thoughts of Sir Ian 
 The moving spirit behind the November 1989 Commons debate was Sir Ian Lloyd, who delivered a grand and gloomy swan song as chairman of the Commons' Energy Committee. 
 He was, he said, one of that small group of political eccentrics who browsed around the dustbins of policy hoping occasionally to come across the word &bquo;science&equo;: 
 I make a more general criticism. 
 It is not so much a failure of one or other particular party, it is a failure of our culture to recognize the significance and importance of science and to elevate it within the nation more continuously and more substantially than governments of either party have chosen to do during the past 25 years. 
 Sir Ian is a former president of the Cambridge Union, whose career has been woven out of a mixture of Conservative politics, economics and technology. 
 He has tried unsuccessfully to persuade government that it should devote a fixed proportion of either GDP or the defence budget (which has some logic as an idea, since the Meteorological Office is funded through the Ministry of Defence) to research into global warming; and failure in that respect has reinforced his view that governments across the world find inexpensive words preferable to expensive actions. 
 He continued: 
 Although the political will has been expressed in vigorous, interesting and dramatic terms at international conferences, in my judgement the political will to follow through that policy right across the globe to a degree that will be effective does not exist. 
 That political will does not exist because public opinion has not yet begun to be aware of the scale of possible changes that governments will ask their publics to accept. 
 (And even if the political will did exist, he doubted whether the institutions which would have to translate it into collective action were strong enough to do so.) 
 Our international institutions are frail, fragile and tend to be powerless. 
 We are moving into an era when frailty, fragility and powerlessness are simply not enough. 
 The proper institutions must be created. 
 What sort of &bquo;proper institutions&equo; did he mean? 
 &bquo;I was thinking of a general problem,&equo; he said later, 
 which is how far parliaments should surrender part or the whole of their responsibilities. 
 It is my belief that the nature and scale of the change needed is unprecedented. 
 I just don't believe that a conglomeration of nation-states will be able to deal with it. 
 We are facing a situation where the human race will have to govern itself. 
 No existing institution has the power to encapsulate and carry out policies, so we will need new ones. 
 At the moment the world is too fragmented to deal with the crises that will emerge. 
 International conventions were all very well, but they were far too easy to breach. 
 War as the ultimate sanction was not a credible solution. 
 Every instinct and all the forces in political democracy were against the surrender of sovereignty, but we had to move down the road towards accepting it. 
 Governments would face the prospect of catastrophic events and massive expenditures. 
 They would have to make political judgements on how far to reduce standards of living. 
 Sir Ian thinks further ahead than most governments care to go. 
 Surrendering sovereignty to a UN body or its equivalent is not on even the sketchiest draft agenda for the future. 
 &bquo;Ian Lloyd is terribly pessimistic,&equo; a lobbyist in the energy field told the author. 
 &bquo;He doesn't think the world will be able to agree on what should be done on global warming. 
 He may be right. 
 There are too many vested interests.&equo; 
 Vested interests in sovereignty, in industry, in national wealth, in political power. 
 Whichever way you turn in trying to halt the elements of global warming, the costs mount; and as they mount, so do taxes and the perils of inflation. 
 The Conservative government in Britain in 1990 still gave priority to fighting inflation, which was rising more steeply than in its commercial competitors. 
 The promises to cut taxes had been brushed to one side, but it was unlikely that the government would wish to fight the next election against a background of undertakings that would entail their actually being increased. 
 The government's position is that the major decisions on countering global warming will have to wait on international agreement at the 1992 UN conference on the environment, which would project them beyond the present government. 
 Unilateral action is out, since its cost would reduce industry's competitiveness in international markets. 
 So no gestures. 
 It remains, too, the official conviction of the government that market forces rather than regulation will create the necessary responses to global warming. 
 Limiting carbon dioxide emissions depended not on regulation but on the aggregate decisions of millions of individuals remote from government, John Wakeham, the British Energy Secretary, told the World Energy Conference in Montreal in September 1989. 
 There were major drawbacks in concentrating solely on a &bquo;regulatory route&equo;. 
 By contrast, there were clear advantages if people were motivated by their own self-interest to restrain greenhouse emissions. 
 A tax or taxes on energy generally were possible approaches. 
 Moreover, countries should price fuels to reflect their full costs, including environmental costs. 
 They needed to develop market mechanisms which would take account of the cost of environmental effects, and to develop the principle of the &bquo;polluter pays&equo;. 
 &bquo;Market forces&equo; is regarded by some as a doctrinal slogan as nebulous as carbon dioxide itself. 
 &bquo;The cost of polluting the environment is not recognized by the market mechanism,&equo; the Institution of Electrical Engineers remarked drily in its written evidence to the House Energy Committee hearings on the greenhouse effect and its implications for energy policy. 
 There was no way at present of costing one environmental &bquo;pollutant&equo; against another. 
 &bquo;How many times worse than 200 unsightly windmills is the radioactive product of a nuclear power or the CO 2  emissions of one coal-fired station? &bquo;ask Energy Committee in its report of the hearings. 
 Counting the cost of carbon 
 It is estimated that every year more than 200 billion tonnes of carbon are exchanged between the atmosphere, living things and the ocean in a natural cycle. 
 To that, humanity adds about 5.6 billion tonnes from burning fossil fuels, of which the developed nations are responsible for 70&ndash;75 per cent, with power stations the worst offenders. 
 In the last two decades world production of electricity has roughly doubled, with the developing nations pulling towards overtaking the developed. 
 The best guess prediction is that by 2030 the concentration of greenhouse gases of all kinds will be equivalent to a doubling of carbon dioxide (if CO 2  was the only gas, the doubling would not take place until 2080). 
 The consensus is that stabilizing the climate (i.e. halting the warming) will require a 50 per cent cut in carbon dioxide emissions. 
 The Brundtland Commission sketched two scenarios of energy consumption in Our Common Future , one high, the other low. 
 It took as a starting point a figure of about 10 Terrawatts (one Terrawatt equals one billion kilowatts) for global energy consumption in 1980. 
 If per capita consumption remained static, an increased world population would still need 40 per cent more energy by 2025. 
 But if energy consumption became uniform, with people in the developing world using as much per capita as those in the industrial world, global consumption would rise to 55 Terrawatts (TW). 
 Even if that were scaled down to 35 TW, the world in 2030 would still require 1.6 times as much oil as in 1980, 3.4 times as much natural gas and nearly 6 times as much coal, and nuclear capacity would have to be 30 times greater than in 1980. 
 The low 11.2 TW scenario would require the industrialized nations to halve their energy consumption by 2020, while the developing world would more than double theirs. 
 One can, of course, go on writing scenarios and juggling the figures almost indefinitely; the only sure thing that emerges is that stabilizing the climate by halving CO 2  emissions is going to demand a very great &mdash; and expensive &mdash; effort by the industrialized nations. 
 It may well prove to be an impossible task. 
 Costings of domestic expenditures in industrial countries on reducing emissions tend to brush away the minor irrelevancies of the millions and concentrate on refining estimates to the nearest billion. 
 The Electricity Council told the Energy Committee that it would be possible to meet the Toronto Conference target of a 20 per cent reduction in carbon dioxide emissions by 2005. 
 The biggest item would be thermal insulation &mdash; &pound;5 billion. 
 Other measures would involve more combined heat and power (CHP) stations, which, instead of discharging into the atmosphere the 60&ndash;70 per cent of the primary energy input which ends up as waste heat, would use it to provide hot water and heating in homes and commercial and industrial buildings; and, of course, a switch from coal &mdash; which produces more carbon dioxide per ton than any other fuel &mdash; to nuclear, gas, oil and &bquo;renewables&equo; such as  windfalls  and tidal barrages. 
 The council was doubtful whether the public would want to pay for the changes. 
 The Central Electricity Generating Board estimated that achieving a 20 per cent cut through switching from coal to nuclear, gas and oil would require an additional capital expenditure of &pound;12 billion. 
 The effect on electricity prices would be &bquo;very severe&equo;. 
 Dr Ken Currie, the head of the government's Energy Technology Support Unit, had similar reservations when he told the Cabinet at a seminar on climate change in April 1989 that technically it was possible to halve carbon dioxide emissions (the longer-term Toronto objective). 
 On the other hand, there were &bquo;practical obstacles and controversial issues&equo; to be overcome. 
 &bquo;To put the economic aspect into perspective, it would need at least a doubling of the price of energy to make some of the supply options attractive to investors.&equo; 
 There are broadly three ways of reducing mankind's output of carbon dioxide. 
 Power stations can be made cleaner and more efficient, so that they use less fossil fuel, particularly high carbon coal; energy can be used more economically by the consumer; and there is nuclear energy (the subject of the following chapter), which whatever else it is capable of doing, does not produce carbon dioxide. 
 To take more efficient power stations first; there are advanced technologies using fossil fuels (gas turbines, in particular; natural gas produces less carbon dioxide than coal and oil) which are considerably more efficient and produce less carbon dioxide. 
 Under the heading of &bquo;renewables&equo; are windmills, tidal barrages, wave power, solar energy and the &bquo;hot dry rocks&equo; of geothermal power. 
 Windmills and tidal barrages (and perhaps wave power) are regarded as having promise even if the former do spoil landscapes and the latter ruin the mudflats on which ducks and wading birds feed. 
 However, estimates of the space needed for a battery of windmills capable of producing the same amount of electricity as a normal power station, fossil fuel or nuclear, range from 100 to 200 square miles. 
 Sunlight converted into useable energy by photovoltaic cells is of economic value only in countries with a lot of sunshine. 
 Geothermal &bquo;hot dry rocks&equo; are not strictly &bquo;renewable&equo; since the rocks, deep within the earth's crust, lose their heat when it is tapped. 
 Their potential is considerable, though, and the Department of Energy estimated that they could provide 10 per cent of Britain's annual energy requirements over 100 years. 
 Methane gas from rubbish tips is another potentially valuable source of energy. 
 Just as you can remove sulphur from power station emissions so you can do the same with carbon dioxide. 
 Theoretically that is. 
 Studies carried out by the Brookhaven National Laboratory in the United States suggested that 88 per cent of the carbon dioxide could be removed by an absorption-stripping system. 
 However, carbon produces more then 3.5 times its own weight in carbon dioxide so there is a problem in disposing of it. 
 The most feasible means is to pump it as a gas or liquid through a pipeline to the ocean, where at 500 metres, most of it would stay out of contact with the atmosphere for many years, since liquid carbon dioxide has a density greater than seawater. 
 Even safer &mdash; but more costly &mdash; is to pump it to a depth of 3000 metres. 
 However, nothing is known about the long-term environmental consequences &mdash; or even effectiveness &mdash; of using the ocean beds as dumps. 
 Other possible places for disposal are abandoned oil and gas reservoirs and aquifers. 
 Equipping a plant to cope with carbon dioxide is likely to double its cost. 
 Add to that the 17&ndash;20 per cent of the power output consumed in stripping the carbon dioxide and the outcome is probably a doubling in the cost of the electricity produced. 
 It is a sign of the times that despite the cost research is continuing. 
 Leaving out nuclear power and the renewables, the most favoured low carbon dioxide fuel is natural gas (which is largely methane, another greenhouse gas). 
 Emissions from a gas-fired plant are about half those from a coal-fired one. 
 However, there is a snag. 
 Natural gas supplies will begin running down in the twenty-first century. 
 The United Kingdom's reserves are likely to be empty in forty years even at the current rate of consumption. 
 Worldwide gas, and oil, prices are expected to start rising early in the next century. 
 Moreover, the use of gas is not likely to have much impact globally. 
 The Energy Committee's own calculation was that it would require a 90 per cent increase in gas consumption worldwide to reduce carbon dioxide emissions by 10 per cent. 
 The double-glazed future 
 One comes back to what most people are agreed on: in the short term the simplest, cheapest, quickest and most effective means of reducing carbon dioxide emissions is to use energy more efficiently, in both homes and factories. 
 Most developed countries are doing so already &mdash; and in fact have been doing so for the past sixty years. 
 Energy saving does not date from the first oil crisis. 
 Britain is not in the first rank of energy-efficient nations, but, taking 1975 as 100, the energy requirements backing each unit of GDP fell from 115 in 1970 to 81 in 1987. 
 That was better than the OECD (Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development) European average of 106 falling to 89 over the same period. 
 Britain's annual energy needs were almost unchanged between the beginning and end of that period, but real GDP rose by 42 per cent. 
 It was Japan, the most energy-intensive country in the world, though, that showed what can be done. 
 Between 1973 and 1985 GDP there rose by 46 per cent while energy use fell by 6 per cent, and that, according to the Association for the Conservation of Energy, put the United States &bquo;at a &dollar;200 billion disadvantage to Japan as a result of a poorer energy efficiency performance&equo;. 
 Look at the figures for electricity generated (and that is where most of the carbon dioxide comes from), however, and a rather different picture emerges. 
 While the direct use of fuels for purposes other than electricity generation has gone down, the output of electricity has gone up. 
 In fact, it almost doubled in the OECD between 1970 and 1987 and the trend remains upward. 
 Coal-fired power stations were responsible for more than 41 per cent of the electricity in 1987, with nuclear power second with 22 per cent and gas third at 9 per cent. 
 So it is possible to have more efficient use of energy but an increase in output from the sector which produces the most carbon dioxide. 
 The Department of Energy sprang a surprise in the autumn of 1989 when the paper it produced for the &bquo;responses&equo; group of the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change suggested that, with more efficient use of energy, Britain could cut its consumption (and hence carbon dioxide) by 60 per cent by 2005 or 2020. 
 A more realistic figure, it admitted, was 20 per cent. 
 The government acknowledged the need for a target in May 1990 by undertaking to stabilize carbon dioxide emissions at the 1990 level by 2005. 
 Coincidentally with the DoE report, Friends of the Earth produced a non-nuclear package of measures which, it claimed, would produce a 46.5 per cent reduction in emissions in all sectors other than transport, which it excluded. 
 What is striking in any analysis of this sort is how much carbon dioxide is attributable to consumption of energy by the domestic sector: 29.1 per cent in 1987 as a result of all those central heating systems, television sets and cooking stoves. 
 Industry was only slightly ahead at 29.5 per cent, and the transport sector &mdash; the fastest growing source of carbon dioxide &mdash; was third with 23.5 per cent. 
 FoE made a number of recommendations on taxes, incentives and greater spending on research (including the government's Energy Efficiency Office, which, remarkably, given the nature of the times, saw its budget restricted to &pound;15 million a year for two years in succession &mdash; a loss in real terms). 
 The emphasis generally is on the carrot of incentive rather than the stick of taxes and sharply raised prices. 
 The latter were &bquo;a blunt instrument&equo;, said Stewart Boyle, of the Association for the Conservation of Energy, in his address December 1989 to Chatham House's Fourth International Energy Conference. 
 &bquo;Very high increases could lead to a recession as happened in the late 1970s and early 80s due to the oil price hikes. 
 This would tend to slow down capital turnover of old, inefficient equipment, exactly the opposite effect that is required.&equo; 
 He quoted a study of all fuels by the Henley Forecasting Centre which concluded that doubling the fuel costs over five years would simply keep energy consumption level through the 1990s. 
 As for cars, a study of twenty-five countries concluded that a 10 per cent fuel price increase produced only a 3 per cent improvement in fuel economy. 
 Price rises were ineffective unless they were so swingeing as to be ruinous. 
 A rule of thumb is that investment in energy efficiency is expected to pay for itself in two years. 
 If investments have already been made in recent years, the average investor will not bother to make further improvements until energy prices begin to hurt. 
 A visitor to ACE's premises noticed that the windows in the director's office were not double-glazed. 
 The director, Andrew Warren, admitted that even in that citadel of energy conservation he had come to the conclusion that the savings would not justify the cost. 
 Mr Warren's equivalent in Japan would almost certainly have had his windows double-glazed. 
 Japan has few energy resources of its own and it has learnt to be frugal: energy prices are approximately twice those in Britain. 
 It is also the world's most dynamic and successful economy. 
 Measured on the carbon dioxide scale, it emitted 2.109 metric tons per capita in 1986 from fossil fuels and cement production; Britain in the same year emitted 2.938 metric tons per capita from the same resources; the United States 5.005; France (which relies on nuclear power for 70 per cent of its electricity generation) 1.794, and India 0.187. 
 &bquo;Energy demand is shifting, from production to pleasure,&equo; declared Lee Schipper and Andrea Ketoff, at the December 1989 Chatham House conference. 
 They were talking of the developed countries, of course, perhaps with North America mainly in mind. 
 Consumers had always wanted bigger cars, holidays in places that were further away from home, bigger refrigerators, larger homes and well-lit amusement parks. 
 They could realize those ambitions because: &bquo;Low fuel and electricity prices make these goals that much easier for consumers, who are not worrying about the energy implications of their choices: the colour of the refrigerator becomes more important than its energy use.&equo; 
 Since 1972 (the run-up to the Middle East oil crisis), the amount of heated space per capita in homes in most OECD countries had grown by 25 per cent. 
 The number of cars and total miles driven was at least 25 per cent higher in most large countries. 
 Air travel was growing rapidly, while the role of mass transit on the ground was shrinking almost everywhere. 
 A combination of cars and aircraft provided over 80 per cent of passenger transport in Western Europe and over 95 per cent in the United States. 
 Between 1972 and 1985 there had been significant energy savings in OECD countries. 
 The extent to which the momentum towards more efficient use of energy for heat had slackened since 1985 had surprised them. 
 Much the same applied to new refrigerators and electrical appliances. 
 Consumers were not choosing efficiency and manufacturers were not improving efficiency as much as they had in the past. 
 The results suggested a plateau of energy efficiency had been reached. 
 Manufacturers of energy-using equipment for aircraft engines to cars were aware of consumer indifference. 
 Low energy prices were a problem. 
 &bquo;Since most experts seem to preclude a major upturn in energy prices before the end of the century, we may have to develop a combination of policies and taxes to stimulate the market for improvements in efficiency now  as insurance against disruptions from climate change later .&equo; 
 The developed North worries about how to make luxury more responsible with better light bulbs, the impoverished South struggles to put light bulbs into its shanty towns. 
 Efficiency plateaux are still a long way from becoming a feature of Southern energy economics. 
 The scale of the divide between North and South was sketched in a paper read at the December 1989 Chatham House conference by Rajendra Pachauri, Director of the Tata Energy Research Institute in New Delhi. 
 The North's share of the world's energy consumption was expected to decrease from around 70 per cent to 60 per cent by 2020, but in that time the proportion of the global population living in the South would have grown from 75 per cent to 80 per cent. 
 Even with an allowance for higher economic growth rates in the South than in the North, the gap in per capita consumption levels was likely to grow. 
 Improved standards of living in the South would depend on increases in consumption of energy, but there was small prospect of its being consumed as efficiently as in the North. 
 At best, efficiency improvements in the near future would shave off two or three percentage points in the rate of growth in energy demand. 
 It was unlikely that countries like Brazil, China and India, which would be the largest consumers of energy in the future, would succumb to international treaties or conventions limiting energy use at the cost of economic development. 
 The question needs to be asked, whether such limitations would be valid on moral, ethical or social grounds given the disparities that exist in living standards&hellip; 
 The cost of limiting emissions of greenhouse gases has to be borne by those societies which are responsible for the cumulative increase in their concentration levels. 
 The North can argue, of course, that in a world of finite fossil fuel resources inefficiency in itself is immoral. 
 Carbon dioxide emissions per head of population may be low in the developing countries, but they are high when measured against units of GDP. 
 But the paraphernalia of better light bulbs, lean-burn engines and cavity-wall insulation with which the North supports its arguments are likely to be dismissed as irrelevant in parts of the world which for the most part have no need for cavity walls. 
 The South's case is that for the sake of the ever-improving standards of life which the North's electorates demand, it squanders resources, poisons the atmosphere and then, to stem the environmental degradation it has caused, demands that the impoverished South forgo equality with the North in the name of salvation! 
 Shares in the greenhouse 
 By the end of the 1980s all the major governments in the West were carrying out reviews and costing of environmental policies. 
 It is a virtual certainty that the developed world will have to set standards for itself, probably through commitments within the ECE or OECD framework, before attempting the infinitely difficult problem of persuading the South to join it in global agreements. 
 One means of persuasion which has been suggested is the creation of &bquo;greenhouse gas shares&equo;, a virtual currency consisting of marketable carbon emission permits. 
 Something similar in principle has been tried in the United States, with the issue of tradable acid pollution permits. 
 It sounds at first a morally dubious proposition, but Michael Grubb argues in The Greenhouse Effect  that it is more promising, and fairer, that any other scheme for international control. 
 The principle which would have to be established first of all is that each person in the world (all those aged 21 or over, suggests Dr Grubb) would have an equal share in man-made carbon dioxide emissions, regardless of whether he lived in a rich developed country or a poor one which produced hardly any carbon dioxide at all. 
 The next step would be the international negotiation of a target for worldwide emissions over a set period, perhaps a decade or two. 
 The permits would then be allocated by an international agency to governments. 
 Countries whose emissions exceeded their allocations would be obliged to buy (or perhaps lease) permits from countries whose output of carbon dioxide fell below their allowance. 
 The permits could be traded for what the seller wanted &mdash; technology, energy-efficiency equipment, development programmes, and so on. 
 In that way, the rich polluters would be obliged to pay for their excesses through a transfer of technology and wealth to the poor, who in time would come under pressure themselves not to allow their emissions to reach levels which would force them to buy permits. 
 A market-based scheme of that sort has its attractions; and it has its problems, too. 
 What would be the value of the &bquo;currency&equo;? 
 If the value was fixed by bidding, would it mean that the richest nations cornered what they needed and left the not-so-rich scrabbling for the left-overs? 
 Would big but impoverished polluters like the Soviet Union and the East European countries accept it? 
 How would it be monitored and regulated to ensure that those who cheated were penalized? 
 But even if it is not exactly this scheme, it is certain that any global agreement will have to be supported by a mechanism which allows the developing countries to pollute more while they catch up with developed countries which are simultaneously reducing their emissions. 
 Rich countries are not going to accept proposals from India and the Group of 77 countries for an environmental aid fund which would be administered by the developing nations, but transfers of technology and financial aid will be part of the eventual package. 
 Rajiv Gandhi's call when still India's prime minister at the September 1989 Non-Aligned summit for an &dollar;18 million fund based on contributions equivalent to 0.1 per cent of GDP by UN members has the support in principle of the influential Mrs Gro Brundtland of Norway. 
 The argument will be harsh, and if the threat of disaster is vivid enough to bring about agreement, it may be that nations will find that, in the interest of common purpose, they are little by little surrendering the sovereignty of which Sir Ian Lloyd spoke. 
 Nuclear power: carbon-free but costly and feared 
 It was mid-January 1990 and the members of the Commons' Energy Committee were plodding towards the ever-receding horizons that contained the answer to their question: was it worth continuing to fund the fast breeder reactor (FBR)? 
 The representatives of the UK Atomic Energy Authority who had been summoned to attend the session were zealously optimistic about the reactor's prospects, but defending the future of the nuclear industry at the beginning of the 1990s was no easy task. 
 Uranium prices had slumped. 
 New reactor orders were virtually non-existent. 
 Only resource-starved, energy efficient Japan, the first and so far only victim of nuclear warfare, carried the torch of nuclear power with undiminished enthusiasm. 
 In Britain, two months earlier, the government had decided in a last-minute about-turn that its nuclear power stations, once the shining lamps that would light the way to the sustainably developed future, were unsaleable and so would be withdrawn from privatization of the electricity industry. 
 Was it the death knell of the nuclear industry or merely curfew time? 
 Whichever bell was tolling, the question-and-answer on the specific issue of the FBR revealed that the committee was dealing with a legendary creature indifferent to the usual processes of judgement, time and fate. 
 Never before has a machine been allowed such a long and cosseted lead-time. 
 Untold billions have been poured into research and building working reactors in return for a relative few penn'orths of electricity. 
 Research on the fast breeder reactor started in the United States in 1945 and the answers extracted by the committee indicated that the product was unlikely to be needed until practically the middle of the twenty-first century, by which time uranium resources would be running low and prices accordingly high. 
 Or so it was speculated. 
 A grand dismissal of the niggling demands of penny-pinchers who wanted results tomorrow came from the chief witness, John Collier, Chairman of the UKAEA and head of the newly-formed Nuclear Electric utility. 
 When pondering the future of the FBR one needed time-frames of 100&ndash;200 years, he declared. 
 No, it was not possible to say when a commercially viable FBR would be built. 
 The expensive (and dangerous) charm of the FBR derives from its ability to breed fissile plutonium 239 for use as its fuel from uranium's most common isotope, non-fissionable U238. 
 This is over 100 times more abundant than the fissile U235 which fuels conventional thermal reactors like the pressurized water reactor (PWR). 
 However, some breeding takes place in thermal reactors, so the actual gain is that a fast reactor can generate about sixty times as much electricity as a thermal reactor from each tonne of uranium. 
 Since fast reactors can breed from the depleted uranium in the spent fuel from thermal reactors, it can be calculated that in FBR terms British stocks of depleted uranium are comparable to the country's coal reserves. 
 On a global scale, the same calculation doubles world fuel resources. 
 No one loves plutonium, but equally a tamed carbon-free and virtually inexhaustible fuel has its attractions in a world in which increasing demands are made on finite energy resources. 
 Electricity generation would no longer be the major contributor to the greenhouse effect and its fuel would be &bquo;sustainable&equo;. 
 In the late 1940s and 1950s the fast reactor was held in such esteem that other forms of nuclear power generation were seen as filling in time until the FBRs were ready to go on stream. 
 The experimental model at Dounreay, in Scotland, was the first in the world, in 1959, to become operational. 
 In the same year it was considered likely that a commercial FBR would be ready in 1965. 
 That forecast later slipped back to 1970. 
 In 1967, Sir William Penney, then chairman of UKAEA, thought the first commercial reactor would be in operation in 1979. 
 In 1975 Dr (later Lord) William Marshall, the country's leading champion of nuclear power, lamented before a House of Lords' committee that at the current rate of progress there might be only two fast reactors on line by 2000. 
 And so it has gone on, although by the end of the 1980s it was evident that the patience of even a government as dedicated to the eventual triumph of nuclear power as Mrs Thatcher's was showing signs of severe strain. 
 After a review of the state of research, the government decided, in 1988, that it could not justify continued expenditure of &pound;100 million a year on a project with such an elusive prospect of commercial return. 
 The prototype fast reactor at Dounreay would be funded until 1994 and its reprocessing plant for a further three years to allow it to deal with spent fuel. 
 From 1990 there would be a core research and development programme costing &pound;10 million a year, just enough, in the government's view, to allow continued collaboration with the French and Germans on the European Fast Reactor (EFR). 
 The agreements on EFR had been signed in early 1989 and in October of the same year outline permission was given for the building of a &pound;300 million &bquo;demonstration&equo; reprocessing plant at Dounreay to recycle EFR's spent plutonium fuel. 
 The money was as shadowily outlined as the permission, but, like the EFR agreement itself, it revealed the government's unwillingness to relinquish once and for all its place in the search for inexhaustible energy. 
 But what is enough in the voracious world of nuclear finances? 
 Not what the government was offering, said the UKAEA in its written testimony to the Commons' Energy Committee. 
 The British commitment to EFR was being undermined and Britain placed in a &bquo;weak position&equo; relative to its partners. 
 &bquo;Outstanding progress&equo; had been made with EFR's design and it was planned to start construction in 1997 and have it ready for operation in 2005. 
 After a minimum five years' operating experience it would be time to think about taking a few orders for commercial stations, the first of which should come on stream about 2020 &mdash; always provided, of course, that the cost and dwindling resources of uranium made it commercially worthwhile: 
 The strategic need for diversity and ultimately for the replacement of fossil fuels has been the driving force for the development of nuclear power in the U.K. In turn &mdash; since uranium reserves are finite &mdash; the efficient exploitation of nuclear power itself ultimately depends on the fast reactor. 
 Since the 1950s this has been the nub of the strategic and commercial argument for developing fast reactors, and it has not changed. 
 Recently, however, it has been given added emphasis and urgency by the growing appreciation that the damage being done to the environment by the use of fossil fuels may require drastic restrictions on their use. 
 We therefore believe that greater reliance on the fast reactor is a necessary consequence of such restrictions and that the timescale for the large scale introduction of fast reactors may need to be brought forward. 
 That is the classic case for the FBR. 
 The EC Commission said much the same in its submission to the Energy Committee: &bquo;At the present time the FBR is the only reactor type which could, if introduced early enough, extend the lifetime of our uranium resources to the end of the next century &mdash; and beyond.&equo; 
 Strategic needs do not, however, dominate human (or even commercial) reactions. 
 No branch of nuclear technology is more detested and feared by the anti-nuclear and green lobbies than fast breeders. 
 Opposition to fast breeders in Europe has been vigorous. 
 One man died in the 1977 protest at the Creys-Malville FBR site in France: the Kalkar fast reactor in West Germany is mothballed (at a reputed cost of &pound;30 million a year) largely as a result of green agitation. 
 In a memorandum written for the Commons' Energy Committee, Andrew Holmes, the editor of Power in Europe , wrote, &bquo;In the course of my work as a journalist, I have met a few environmentalists who can envisage some kind of long-term accommodation with the nuclear power industry, If waste disposal and other problems are satisfactorily solved; I have never met an environmentalist who was not wholly and implacably opposed to the FBR.&equo; 
 FBRs mean plutonium and plutonium means warheads and, potentially, nuclear holocausts. 
 If fast breeders proliferate how can the spread of plutonium to countries which would have no scruples about making their own nuclear weapons be checked? 
 One measure of how the dangers of plutonium are assessed is the Japanese plan to build an &pound;88 million coastguard vessel to escort shipments of plutonium oxide from the Sellafield reprocessing plant in Cumbria for use in its prototype fast reactor at Monju. 
 Air transport was ruled out because of the danger of crashes on land, which in this case, because of the route, might turn out to be US soil in Alaska. 
 Sending it by sea, on the other hand, would run the risk of hijackings by terrorists or even governments. 
 A ship would have to be guarded by a warship, the Americans, who supplied the original plutonium, insisted. 
 As for commercial reactions, they can be judged by the fact that the capital cost of a first FBR is estimated by the British nuclear industry at between 20 and 30 per cent greater than that of a PWR, and generating costs 20 per cent more. 
 Even the cost of generating electricity from the technically successful French Superph&eacute;nix is twice that of a PWR. 
 Unloved and out in the cold 
 If uranium prices are going to swing in favour of fast reactors, they have a long way to go. 
 At the beginning of the 1990s the spot price for uranium stood at under &dollar;10/lb, the lowest real price since it became a commodity and &dollar;20 below the official floor price for contract sales. 
 The uranium industry in South Africa, the world's biggest exporter, was reported to be on the &bquo;brink of collapse&equo; as electricity generating companies ran down stocks and cut purchases. 
 It was not surprising that the amount spent on exploration sank from &dollar;760 million in the still relatively fat year of 1979 to between &dollar;120 and &dollar;150 million at the end of the 1980s and the size of known reserves remained static over a period of at least four years. 
 In the United States it remained the case that no new nuclear generators had been ordered since 1978. 
 The situation was slightly better than in the first half of the 1980s, when more power stations were cancelled than entered service, but those under construction all dated from orders placed at the beginning of the 1970s. 
 In Britain, three of four planned PWRs were cancelled at the end of 1989. 
 In the rest of Europe the story was much the same, in some ways worse, as a glance within the hopefully green cover of the 1989 status report of the Forum Atomique Europ&eacute;en (Foratom) confirmed: 
 Austria : operations at the country's first nuclear power plant, at Zwentendorf, cancelled following a national referendum. 
 Belgium : the government rejected as &bquo;inappropriate at present&equo; proposals for a new power station. 
 West Germany : &bquo;the nuclear construction programme of the German utilities has practically come to an end for the time being.&equo; 
 Finland : decisions deferred post-Chernobyl. 
 France : new orders dried up as the long run of 63 reactors either built or under construction came to an end and the country grappled with the problem of an over-supply of electricity. 
 Italy : no nuclear plants operating following a November 1987 referendum. 
 Netherlands : no nuclear power stations under construction or planned. 
 Spain : five uncompleted nuclear power stations under a moratorium. 
 Sweden : (where nuclear power provides 46 per cent of the electricity): parliament decides to begin phasing out nuclear power in 1995&ndash;6 (but parliament's restrictions on new hydro-electric power stations and the imposition of a ceiling on carbon dioxide emissions have led to a retreat from the goal of becoming, in 2010, the first country to terminate nuclear power generation). 
 Switzerland : parliament endorsed the cancellation of the planned Kaiseraugst power station near Basel. 
 The nuclear industry's current predicament is usually placed in the context of the near melt-down at Three Mile Island in 1979 and the fatal disaster at Chernobyl, the radioactive fall-out from which was still affecting places as far away as the uplands of Wales and Scotland four years later. 
 The opposition of the activists to all forms of nuclear power, civil as well as military, had, in the view of many, been vindicated. 
 Nuclear explosives might not have killed anyone since Nagasaki in 1945, but the use of nuclear fuel in a civil reactor had. 
 Newspapers were full of stories of leukaemia clusters near nuclear establishments and of the long-term victims of Chernobyl and minor releases, people picked off at random within the pattern of statistical formulations. 
 For most people in Britain, the Medical Research Council's study, published in February 1990, revealing the strong possibility that fathers who worked in the Sellafield reprocessing plant in Cumbria had passed leukaemia to their children in their sperm, moved speculation out of the realms of the circumstantial into that of the confirmed. 
 It was a curious irony that the insidious dangers of civil nuclear power should achieve such prominence just as the superpowers were moving towards agreement on cutting their armouries and reducing the threat of nuclear war caused by suspicion or accident. 
 If Three Mile Island and, above all, Chernobyl, had not happened, the image of civil nuclear power would (or should) have assumed a more friendly warmth as the superpowers' diminishing stocks of warheads dwindled towards a largely symbolic status. 
 It would no longer be damaged by the two-facedness of its fuel. 
 Supposing we had grown to know and love nuclear power (as the French seem to), would we now be seeing it expanding rapidly from what the International Atomic Energy Agency claims is its present provision of 16 per cent of the world's electricity to 25 per cent or more? 
 It's doubtful. 
 The expansion of the early 1970s was largely the result of the oil crisis, a strategic decision made in the face of economic blackmail by the Arab members of OPEC (Organization of Petroleum Exporting Countries) during the Yom Kippur War. 
 Given the long lead-time between ordering a nuclear plant and its commercial operation, the high cost of construction, the equally awful cost of eventually decommissioning it, the margin for safety, the time-consuming process of obtaining approval (the enquiry into all aspects of the British PWR Sizewell B took two-and-a-quarter years and cost &pound;20 million) the commitment has to be strong and &bquo;strategic&equo; enough &mdash; as in France &mdash; to counter the lack of resolve as the bills mount. 
 By the second half of the 1980s oil was cheap once again, thanks to the spur the crises had given to non-OPEC developments like the Alaska North Slope and North Sea oil fields. 
 Strategic reasons declined. 
 The humiliating &bquo;commercial&equo; figures the British industry &mdash; the pioneer of civil nuclear energy &mdash; was obliged to produce in advance of privatization in 1989 practically trebled the previously estimated cost per kilowatt hour. 
 Electricity generated by the one remaining PWR was expected to cost 8p (possibly 10p, according to one report) a kilowatt hour against 3p for power from a modern coal-fired power station and about 2.5p from one of the advanced gas turbine power stations. 
 But these estimates were, of course, based on the short-term, very non-strategic demands of investors who wanted to be assured of a good return on their money if they bought shares in the industry. 
 It was impossible for the nuclear power stations to match those demands. 
 Only the French seemed able to meet challenges of that kind, and how they did it was a mystery to most outside experts. 
 Greater commitment, no doubt; better technology and a higher level of efficiency in construction, perhaps; and quite certainly the use of a combination of secrecy and &bquo;creative&equo; accountancy to maintain the image of technological triumph. 
 In fact, Electricit&eacute; de France, had a deficit of &pound;400 million in 1989 thanks to a mixture of reactor problems and drought. 
 The latter reduced hydro-electric power and caused the shutting down of several nuclear power stations when river levels dropped and the water in any case became too warm for effective cooling. 
 The industry's image was further dented by the leaking of a secret report which criticized overcapacity and questioned whether its export prices would be economic if all costs were included. 
 An added embarrassment was a report (also leaked) by the chief inspector for nuclear safety who warned against complacency and came up with an estimate that there was a &bquo;several per cent&equo; chance of a serious accident in the next twenty years. 
 An accident in France would no have to be as serious as Chernobyl to imperil life and health over a wide area in France and its heavily populated neighbours. 
 In Britain, commercial realpolitik  had won the day. 
 A government committed to the disciplines of the market had had a salutary lesson: the market did not care a damn for the long term, or strategic thinking into the middle of the next century, or, quite possibly, sustainable development. 
 The latter, in fact, was somewhere in all this a casualty. 
 Plutonium and enriched weapons-grade uranium aside (and admittedly it is a big aside), nuclear power in its advanced manifestations is as close to the pure spirit of sustainable development as anyone is likely to get, short of covering the landscape with batteries of windmills. 
 The fact that it is costly merely underlines the fact that sustainable development is  costly. 
 But in the space of less than eighteen months the government had curtailed the nuclear programme and sent the FBR into a dormancy hard to distinguish from a death coma. 
 Anyone who wanders into the fissured terrain of energy economics will before long encounter Keepin and Kats, from the Rocky Mountain Institute in Colorado. 
 They are names which, mentioned favourably, are guaranteed to cause narrowed eyes and a suspicion of froth at the mouth corners in senior members of the nuclear establishment. 
 Keepin and Kats were responsible for a calculation which has been taken up and treated with biblical reverence by the anti-nuclear lobby: for nuclear power to displace coal from the energy mix in a high energy scenario 8000 large reactors would have to be brought on line worldwide at the rate of one every one-and-a-half days. 
 Even then, carbon dioxide emissions could still increase 65 per cent by 2030. 
 The scenario for medium energy growth was little better: a reactor every three days. 
 Not only was nuclear power slower and considerably more expensive than energy efficiency as a means of cutting carbon dioxide emissions, but its overall potential was much smaller. 
 &bquo;A ridiculous cockshy to put up and then knock down,&equo; was Collier's reaction to the Keepin and Kats paper. 
 No one had suggested nuclear power could make the dominant contribution. 
 It had to be balanced with other sources of energy, perhaps gas. 
 An entanglement of questions 
 There is never any one answer to any major problem and Keepin and Kats' calculations are to that extent a cockshy. 
 It would, after all, be a lunatic commander-in-chief who relied solely on nuclear missiles for his country's defence and dispensed with infantry, tanks, aircraft and submarines. 
 Energy efficiency may be the quickest way to abate emissions of carbon dioxide but it is hard to imagine it being applied effectively in Third World countries, whose output of the gas is likely to overtake the developed world's in the second or third decade of the next century. 
 It may not be quite as easy as some assume in the developed world, either. 
 Natural gas as a replacement for coal is important, too, but coal is cheap and plentiful and likely to remain the principal fuel of China, potentially the world's biggest producer of carbon dioxide (and other pollutants, too). 
 John Wakeham, the British Energy Secretary, had put a new twist on the need for nuclear power at the September 1989 World Energy Conference in Montreal by suggesting that the developed countries might have to turn increasingly to nuclear power to &bquo;make room&equo; for more use of fossil fuels by developing countries. 
 Nuclear power is undoubtedly a big &bquo;saver&equo; of carbon dioxide. 
 The South of Scotland Electricity Board generated 30 per cent of its electricity from nuclear reactors in 1980&ndash;1 and 64 per cent in 1990&ndash;1. 
 It estimates that in that time it cut its carbon dioxide emissions by more than 20 per cent. 
 The only other countries in Western Europe which were able to achieve reductions of the same magnitude were those where the nuclear share of electricity were 50 per cent or more. 
 A comparison of Britain and West Germany on the one hand, and France on the other, makes the point clearly. 
 Coal is the main fuel used for electricity generation in Britain and Germany. 
 In 1986 Britain's power stations were estimated to have produced 166.3 million tonnes of carbon dioxide, Germany 187.2 million tonnes. 
 France, which generated 70 per cent of its power from nuclear reactors and 18 per cent from hydro-electric and geothermal sources, produced 30.2 million tonnes of carbon dioxide. 
 Since electricity generation is the world's largest source of man-made carbon dioxide, it is quite clear that nuclear power can and does make a very significant contribution to its reduction. 
 In the end one plunges out of a thicket of statistics into an entanglement of questions. 
 Which is rated as most dangerous, carbon dioxide or nuclear power? 
 Can energy efficiency and a greater dependence on natural gas cut carbon emissions sufficiently on their own? 
 Will low-cost uranium reserves be so depleted early in the next century that prices will begin to rise sharply? 
 What emerges from an attempt to answer the last question is that the known low-cost reserves will have been significantly run down by 2025, but total reserves are large, sufficient to last for more than 400 years at present rates of consumption, according to one estimate. 
 (Other estimates put the span at 75&ndash;175 years.) 
 Because of the exhaustion of the low-cost reserves, uranium prices seem bound to rise in the course of the first half of the next century (assuming the uranium mining industry is to remain in business), but by how much is anyone's guess. 
 Until there is a substantial increase &mdash; indicating scarcity and demand &mdash; the fast reactor seems set to remain in one of the more exclusive suburbs of El Dorado. 
 The British study for the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change indicates that regardless of how fuel prices, whether uranium or fossil, change, nuclear power has a declining role in British energy production up to at least 2020. 
 Gas could be the winner if prices are low, ousting coal. 
 However, if one turns to the report's tables, based on a growth in energy demand of between 1 and 2 per cent a year, it makes little difference whether gas or coal is the main fuel used to produce electricity. 
 The difference in the context of carbon dioxide emissions from all sources in the economy is estimated at between 234 million tonnes if gas is the main fuel and 250 if it is coal. 
 As for energy saving, the study points out that the oil shocks of 1973 and 1979 cut consumption by only 12 per cent. 
 The &bquo;realistic scope&equo; for saving in 2005 and 2020 is put at &bquo;20 per cent of the energy bill of the day for investments with short payback periods&equo;. 
 But that, the report emphasizes, is not a forecast of what will happen. 
 The net result is that, however one mixes the energy cake, carbon dioxide emissions go on increasing. 
 Putting the government's abandonment of the PWRs in the context of the study, the conclusion must be that it decided that, under market force rules, carbon dioxide had to be allowed to win the day over nuclear power. 
 Nuclear power may be in eclipse, but it is hard to believe that it &mdash; and the fast reactor &mdash; will not return to favour as carbon dioxide increases and the greenhouse effect's regime becomes more severe. 
 Market forces will not rule in those circumstances. 
 The health and safety hazards associated with nuclear energy will have to be overcome. 
 Officials concerned with environmental policy predict that a day of reckoning will come when the issue has to be faced again. 
 A combination of the ideology of the market-place, public hostility to nuclear power and fears of high energy prices adding to the problems of an uncompetitive manufacturing industry may have resulted in a setback for nuclear power in Britain, but fossil fuels would no longer seem such overwhelmingly good value, according to Chris Patten, if their wider environmental costs were allocated and more fully reflected in prices. 
 These would have to be raised to pay for the damage they caused in acid rain and global warming. 
 As that happened, nuclear power would become more economically attractive despite the environmental costs of decommissioning redundant reactors and disposing of radioactive wastes. 
 The trouble with nuclear power is that its &bquo;costs&equo; always have the potential to go well beyond the point where they can be factored into an environmental bill. 
 Enriched uranium or plutonium in the wrong hands could be infinitely more dangerous than an oil-rig fire or a coal mine disaster. 
 Acid rain seems a minor hazard compared with the fall-out from a reactor fire. 
 The danger of contamination from radioactive wastes persisting into ages which exist only as figures beyond the range of human imaginations belongs to an order different from that of oil spills and coal slurries. 
 But if you accept that carbon dioxide is a much More insidious threat and nuclear power is the one major supplier of energy that does not produce it, the issue begins to turn not so much on the dangerous unacceptibility of reactors but on how you regulate and make them safe and ensure that their fuel is not diverted for military purposes. 
 Chernobyl had one good result. 
 It led to the creation in Moscow in May 1989 of the World Association of Nuclear Operators. 
 The signing of its charter by representatives of 144 electric utilities with working nuclear power stations was a recognition that the time had come to take the secrecy out of nuclear power and prove that there was a worldwide interest in co-operation and information exchange. 
 Only by ensuring that safety and reliability were maintained could public confidence be restored. 
 WANO has regional offices in Atlanta, Moscow, Paris and Tokyo and a co-ordinating centre in London. 
 Its chairman is Lord Marshall, who resigned as chairman of the Central Electricity Generating Board at the end of 1989 in protest against the government's decision to abandon the British PWR programme. 
 The IAEA and safeguards 
 Before a combination of Chernobyl, glasnost and the easing of East-West military tensions lifted the blanket of secrecy covering civil reactors in the Soviet Union WANO would not have been possible. 
 It complements in a modest way the safety programmes and the &bquo;safeguards&equo; monitoring carried out by the International Atomic Energy Agency from its headquarters in Vienna. 
 The IAEA's role in policing the 1970 Non-Proliferation of Nuclear Weapons treaty through its safeguards provisions is unique among UN agencies. 
 Its international inspectorate patrols the borderline between the civil use of nuclear establishments and fuels and the threat of their diversion to make nuclear weapons. 
 With on-site inspections, seals, analysis of materials, electronic surveillance and satellite links they cover some 95 per cent of the world's nuclear installations outside the five nuclear weapon states &mdash; Britain, France, the Soviet Union and the United States, which all allow safeguards monitoring in a few of their civil installations, and China, which has signed a safeguards agreement but has not yet had a single inspection. 
 The non-proliferation treaty has not prevented countries like Israel, India and South Africa from secretly developing nuclear weapons, but at least they have not gone public with them and no country has officially added itself to the nuclear weapons states. 
 Iraq, a signatory to the non-proliferation treaty, appears to have managed to divert nuclear materials to bomb-making despite regular safeguard inspections, but the treaty has been a success on the whole &mdash; as indeed has been the complex structure of hot-line, surveillance and negotiation which has ensured that the East-West &bquo;balance of terror&equo; never tipped over into nuclear war: 
 It is clear that the present system, perhaps indeed any system that could be devised, is not foolproof, says the IAEA. 
 It is equally clear, however, that it is a remarkable phenomenon and that the chances of its leading to the detection of a diversion that has already taken place, or is in the course of taking place, are reasonably good and are improving as the Agency's technology in this area develops&hellip; 
 A top-level decision to embark on a nuclear weapons programme&hellip; might well involve falsification of records and a good deal of covering up. 
 It would then be necessary for the government concerned to face the consequences of violating its Treaty obligations in such a flagrant manner &mdash; consequences which could be serious indeed. 
 Probably no system can ever be foolproof, particularly when developing technologies continually present new problems for the monitors. 
 Even with the ending of East-West confrontations and the prospect of nuclear armouries being run down rapidly, it is hard to imagine a world in which civil reactors are widely regarded as safe and the problems of acceptable disposal of nuclear wastes are overcome. 
 But internationally agreed carbon taxes, permits and rising global temperatures may push the world along the road towards accepting the unacceptable. 
 Energy efficiency, natural gas and the limited contribution to electricity supplies from renewable resources will not be enough to contain increases in carbon dioxide and provide for the needs of a fast-expanding world population. 
 Even if nuclear power does not become the &bquo;sustainable&equo; energy source of the future, the IAEA and its administration of the Non-Proliferation Treaty's safeguards regime remains of great relevance to the monitoring and application of atmospheric agreements. 
 There will be a need at some stage for an international agency large, influential and well staffed enough to oversee and monitor measures to reduce green-house gases and perhaps administer aid funds. 
 The IAEA, in its offices on the far side of the Danube beyond the Prater's great Ferris wheel, provides a prototype. 
 The pioneering Netherlands: Cows, cars and the Western World's age of mobility 
 The bald facts about the Netherlands suggest an environmental disaster, the country a combination of sink and sewer for the air- and river-borne poisons and wastes of Europe, including its own. 
 The densities per square kilometre of its human and livestock populations are greater than anywhere else in the continent. 
 Its 12 million pigs and 5 million cows (considerably more, when added together, than the human population) burden the land, and the water supply, with some 100 million tonnes of dung every year. 
 It has more cars per square kilometre than anywhere else in the world. 
 More than 80 per cent of the country would revert to lagoons and salt marsh if the sea defeated the country's vigilant engineers. 
 The sea is remorseless and patient. 
 Nature is on its side. 
 Its level rises slowly and the land behind the dykes sinks, but even more slowly. 
 No wonder that Queen Beatrix's 1988 Christmas message to her subjects was notable for an unfestive concentration on doom. 
 The earth is slowly dying. 
 We human beings ourselves have become a threat to our planet. 
 Those who no longer wish to disregard the insidious pollution and degradation of the environment are driven to despair. 
 Strong words which no one would contradict with confidence, even if despair was regarded as an emotion which should never be admitted. 
 But the visitor travelling through the Dutch landscape is struck by the contrast between the royal gloom and the pleasant world all around. 
 A heron makes a measured flight across the setting sun towards a heronry, no doubt protected by the nation's countless defenders of the natural world. 
 The fields are a fresh dark green, the occasional unyarded cattle as majestic as any painted by Cuyp long before the greenhouse era. 
 The cities with their canals and punctual trams are among the most pleasant and orderly in the world. 
 The Dutch have fought hard for their environment and more than any other nation they are aware of how unremitting the battle is. 
 Weaken, turn your back for a moment and it could be lost for good. 
 Which helps to explain why the Netherlands' National Environmental Policy Plan is a pioneering work, a model which other nations study. 
 It is entitled To Choose or to Lose  and it proclaims a strategy &bquo;developed against the background of the desire to solve or gain control of environmental problems within the duration of one generation&equo;. 
 The plan is not a blueprint for the future, it stresses, merely the starting signal for a process in which dialogue and choices made by individuals, private industry and government will shape the environmental programmes: &bquo;What we want to do, in the realization that we do not understand all the relationships, is to indicate the conditions under which an environmental quality can be attained that will provide future generations with as many options as possible.&equo; 
 Reading the plan it is hard to see it as the centrepiece of what was billed as the world's first green election, in September 1989. 
 Controlling ammonia emissions and ending tax-breaks for commuters who drive their cars to work are not usually the kind of issues which sends voters raging into the polling booths. 
 Yet, it was an argument over how to pay for cleaning up pollution which in May 1989 collapsed the Christian Democrat-Liberal coalition. 
 Liberal pique over what they felt was inadequate consultation and personal rivalry between the leaders of the parties were seen by some as the most potent causes of the rift, but the official reason which the Liberals, the junior partners in the coalition, gave was their objection to the ending of tax deductions for car commuters and the raising of taxes on petrol and diesel fuel. 
 They supported the plan, but insisted that the money for implementing it must come from economic growth and cuts in spending on welfare and education. 
 The voters decided otherwise and Ruud Lubbers was returned in the September 1989 election with more seats for his Christian Democrats and new coalition partners, the Labour Party. 
 By that time the state of the economy had eclipsed the environment as the main issue. 
 &bquo;Ecology remains subordinate to the evolution of the economy,&equo; commented Aad van den Biggelaar, of the environmental group Nature and Environment . 
 The plan estimates the costs of implementation in some detail &mdash; about 3 per cent of national income up to 1994, settling down to about 2 per cent by 2010. 
 By that year, energy consumption should be down 30 per cent and emissions of pollutants by 70 per cent. 
 Total investment would be about &pound;45 billion. 
 The biggest shares of the cost would go to cleaning up and limiting acidification (to which Dutch soils are among the most vulnerable in Europe) and disposing of wastes. 
 Industry and agriculture would pay about half the bill, the government the other half. 
 The farmers see a danger that their products will become uncompetitive; the road freight carriers have similar fears about what will happen if 1992 and the advent of the European single market exposes them to competition from foreign firms unfettered by the restrictions and burdens imposed on the Dutch. 
 The food and drink industry and trade generally also see problems. 
 Fears expressed by these sectors of the economy led to the plan's drafters and the Central Planning Bureau carrying out two impact studies: one based on unilateral action, the other assessing what would happen if other EC countries adopted similar measures. 
 The figures are relative to a middle-of-the-road estimate of the course of the economy during the next twenty years. 
 Without similar action abroad, there is a modest decline in employment and production. 
 Agriculture would be the biggest loser, with the volume of production cut by 10.7 per cent and employment reduced because of a drop in the number of livestock. 
 The energy sector is the next biggest loser, hit by the decreased demand brought about by improvements in energy efficiency. 
 Transport does well because of investment in public transport as the plan's measures to persuade people to leave their cars at home take effect. 
 Other consequences would be worsening of the already large budget deficit and a fall in tax revenues. 
 Most people would be worse off financially but not by a great deal. 
 If, however, other countries take similar measures to cut pollution, the situation obviously improves. 
 Tax revenues increase and the impact on personal spending power is less. 
 Generally speaking, the impact seems small either way. 
 The plan claims that the reduction in expected economic growth would be between 0.25 and 0.50 per cent a year if no other countries followed the Dutch route. 
 That would mean the growth rate in employment would be down by between 1000 and 5000 jobs a year. 
 On the other hand, if other countries adopted the same measures, the effect on the economy would be mildly beneficial. 
 But trying to measure what will happen over a span of two decades is a hazardous task and the Central Planning Bureau admits to uncertainty. 
 Dutch policies applied generally might have a damaging influence on the world economy, it says, &bquo;How great such influence might be and to what extent it might be worse that that resulting from the worldwide deterioration in the quality of the environment is not known.&equo; 
 And that, in the age of sustainable development, is a fairly big caveat. 
 Cross-currents in the age of mobility 
 A bold plan of this sort directs its followers into unknown country where the statistical projections may be profoundly untrustworthy. 
 An economic recession could throw it right off course. 
 The loss of competitive edge might open up demands for protective measures against countries which have imposed no limitations on their own industries. 
 But there was no sign of backing down, rather the reverse. 
 By early 1990 an &bquo;NEPP-plus&equo; containing additional measures was being prepared by the Cabinet for submission to the Second Chamber. 
 Paul de Jongh, the plan's project leader, tends to dismiss industry's worries about uncompetitiveness: &bquo;These are partly ritual dances,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It is the first round. 
 Private industry recognizes the virtue of the Plan because they know where they stand. 
 I think the big businesses are prepared to adopt the policies.&equo; 
 He had found that even in Britain, where officials tended to be dismissive of the idea of a plan, people from private industry were receptive when he explained the Netherlands' plan at a meeting: &bquo;They said, &bquo;Yes, we should like such a plan because it reduces our uncertainty. 
 We like the idea of stability of policy and time to work on the reduction of pollution at our own pace&equo;.&equo; 
 There are not as many cars as pigs in the Netherlands, but the country nevertheless has the greatest density of cars anywhere in the world &mdash; 128/km; Britain, by contrast has 59, Japan 47 and France a mere 28. 
 The Dutch may hate the congestion, the fumes and the wasted time brought by cars, but ownership is nevertheless as essential to their perception of what constitutes the quality of life as a bathroom and central heating. 
 The ownership and use of cars in the Netherlands has doubled in the past fifteen years. 
 Only 11 per cent of commuters used public transport in 1985 and the trend is downwards. 
 Bicycles are popular, but they have their limitations on a wet and windy day. 
 As matters stand, the number of vehicles is expected to grow from five million in 1985 to almost 8 million in 2010. 
 The number of kilometres they cover collectively will, it is predicted, increase by 65 per cent. 
 Goods traffic on the roads will show a similar upward trend. 
 Roads are already crammed with traffic despite an intensive road-building programme, so presumably more of the precious Dutch countryside will be concreted over. 
 Although passenger cars are expected to be 80&ndash;90 per cent &bquo;cleaner&equo; (and lorries 75 &mdash; per cent) under the plan, there obviously comes a point where, unless there is an endless expansion of the road system, so many vehicles will defeat their purpose, mobility, and still be, however &bquo;clean&equo;, a pollution problem. 
 De Jongh admitted the dilemmas. 
 There is a consensus among the public that cars should not be used to go to work. 
 But they still want them for pleasure and social purposes. 
 There has been such an enormous increase in mobility in work and recreation. 
 The trains are full and the roads are full. 
 There are so many interconnections between industries and businesses and government departments. 
 For instance, there were 400 people who were consulted in the drafting of the Plan. 
 How did one consult them? 
 One went to see them. 
 (By taxi, usually, in de Jongh's case.) 
 The Dutch are innovators. 
 Given their historic contest with the sea, perhaps they have to be. 
 But what strikes one about their situation and the way they are tackling it is how vary narrowly they are ahead. 
 Every industrialized country faces similar problems and is either considering similar solutions or has already implemented some of them. 
 In a way national plans in Western Europe are an anomaly. 
 They can succeed only if they fit in with similar international plans; in the Netherlands' case, with the standards agreed by the European Community to which it belongs, and that applies particularly to vehicles. 
 Wherever one goes, whatever statistical projection is used in an attempt to bring the future into focus, one is aware of a rising sea of people and their vehicles which defeats frontiers. 
 It is the mark of the age, the constant fretful cross-currents and surge of tidal movements between offices and homes and shops and conferences and holidays. 
 Little more than a century ago most people, even in industrialized countries, rarely travelled more than a few miles from their birthplace. 
 Only wars and emigration shifted them. 
 Vagrants were returned under the Poor Laws to where they were deemed to belong. 
 Today's vagrants, squatting under railway arches and in shop doorways, are not regarded as having strayed from anywhere. 
 They are the only fixed residents in the shifting scene. 
 Once academics and scientists kept in touch by letter and &bquo;corresponding members&equo; of learned societies were for the most part never seen. 
 Today they spend much of their time flying to conferences, of which there are an unending supply, particularly those associated with the environment. 
 In business and government there are countless committees and consultations and yet more conferences. 
 Even drawing up proposals for recycling waste materials in Britain requires ten sub-committees. 
 Faxes and telephones add to the flow of communication but do little to reduce the flow of people. 
 Transport is cheap. 
 Commuters regularly spend three hours travelling to and from work. 
 Those who live close enough to walk to work make a point of mentioning it, rather as if they were keeping alive a forgotten folkway. 
 &bquo;We want to say &bquo;no&equo; to all development which causes more mobility,&equo; said de Jongh. 
 &bquo;It will mean very strict planning &mdash; no more supermarkets and hypermarkets, no new industrial development sites.&equo; 
 One idea which is to be given a test run in 1993 is road pricing. 
 Cars will be fitted with equipment which will register them when they pass through electronic gates. 
 It will be possible to bill the owners for their mileage. 
 De Jongh sounded doubtful about the prospects for the idea's success. 
 &bquo;To be honest, I think it's a lot of fun for the engineers.&equo; 
 Every planning projection of vehicle numbers and mileage has, in Britain at least and no doubt in many other countries, too, been proved wrong. 
 The figures have soared above the modest estimates of the planners. 
 People want cars above all else. 
 They will wince at the idea of paying for their children's school books or having their gallstones removed, but think nothing of spending half a year's income on a car. 
 Companies throw them in as enticing make-weights in their employees' pay packets. 
 People may not like what cars do to their environment, but they are reluctant to give them up. 
 If your household has two cars and you get rid of one of them you may be helping the environment, but are certainly worse off. 
 Only the elderly make that sort of sacrifice as incapacity or reduced income takes its toll. 
 And as the individual thinks, so, in more general terms, does the larger community: the decline of Britain's automobile industry to the point where imports exceeded exports became the measure of the country's fall from a place in the industrial front rank. 
 Yet even in its present state it accounted in 1987, directly or indirectly, for 600,000 jobs and 2 per cent of gross domestic product. 
 An almost unstoppable momentum 
 Transport generally, and cars in particular, is such a huge business that it is hard to see its growth being checked without serious economic consequences. 
 Since the Second World War the motor industry has gone on and on growing, undeterred even by two oil shocks which sent the price of petrol soaring. 
 In 1950 there were an estimated 50 million cars in the world; in 1986, 386 million. 
 Even if there were a willingness to reduce production, it would be hard, in the European Community, to resist the sheer momentum created by opening the frontiers of the new internal market after 1992. 
 It is estimated that its completion alone will increase lorry traffic across frontiers by between 30 and 50 per cent. 
 To growth of that nature can be added the prospect of a fall in car prices, making them even more affordable than they are already. 
 The Task Force on &bquo;the environmental dimension&equo; of the internal market described itself as &bquo;much concerned&equo; with the transport sector, which it thought would have a greater impact on the environment than any other sector. 
 The growth in road transport presents government with dilemmas and almost irresistible temptations. 
 They could be seen very clearly in Britain in 1989. 
 In the first place, everyone travels by car and therefore everyone has first-hand knowledge of how awful the roads are. 
 The great majority would like to see better and wider roads which would be less congested and safer. 
 An Observer/Harris poll in 1989 revealed the strength of the British voters attachment to their cars: &bquo;Voters overwhelmingly backed the continued, untrammelled use of private cars, with 62 per cent disagreeing with further restrictions on their use and a similar number (63 per cent) in favour of a heavy programme of road building.&equo; 
 A government which allowed itself to be perceived as anti-car would clearly be running a risk. 
 The moral to be drawn from polls of that sort is that spending money on roads is going to win votes. 
 The ministers concerned must have congratulated themselves that politically at least they had done the right thing by ignoring the environmental bodies and promising eight-lane motorways and an expenditure of &pound;12.4 billion to ensure that 1992 does not leave Britain stuck in a permanent traffic jam. 
 The government's white paper on the subject was entitled Roads to Prosperity  and the then Transport Secretary, Paul Channon, proclaimed, &bquo;I will not allow Britain's first-rate businesses to be disadvantaged by a second-rate road network. 
 Far from being the enemy of the environment, the expanded road programme will improve the quality of life for thousands of people.&equo; 
 Roads to Ruin , responded the Green Alliance, which estimates that parking alone for all the new cars expected to be on the road in 2025 would require an area larger than Berkshire. 
 The Confederation of British Industry stepped forward with a plan that practically doubled the sum to be spent by the government: &pound;21 billion to rewrite the nation's economic geography and save it from catastrophe. 
 Britain's transport network pointed towards the colonial past, the CBI declared: it had to be redirected to face the European future. 
 Anyone who has driven down the Dover Road to catch a ferry might agree. 
 With Japanese car manufacturers investing heavily in Britain to ensure they are inside the walls if the internal market turns into Fortress Europe, there is a possibility that Britain will become a net car exporter once again, a development which, more than any other, would help put the manufacturing balance of payments back in the black. 
 No government is likely to say at this juncture that it regards cars as an environmental menace and intends to reduce their numbers by so many per cent a year. 
 It is the governments of countries which do not manufacture them &mdash; The Netherlands and Denmark, for instance &mdash; which press hardest for action. 
 The Dutch went ahead on their own in 1989 by approving tax incentives favouring cars fitted with catalytic converters (emission filters costing between &pound;300 and &pound;600). 
 The European Commission's protest that they were distorting competition by acting unilaterally was successfully beaten in the European Court. 
 Moves of that sort, though, are marginal to the general trend towards strict emission controls which will make catalytic converters compulsory in the EC. 
 The Americans have had rigorous standards since 1983, and Australia, Japan, Norway, Sweden and Switzerland have applied similar measures. 
 The EC reached agreement on large cars in 1987 and, after a hard-fought battle, it was agreed in June 1989 that emission standards would be applied to all new small cars from 1992. 
 Agreement on medium-sized cars was expected in 1990. 
 The British front in this battle has not been one of the easiest. 
 Motor manufacturers have been sceptical about the efficiency of catalysts. 
 They need high temperatures to be effective; stop-start driving of the sort prevailing in European cities does not suit them; the planned three-way catalysts are &bquo;poisoned&equo; if leaded petrol is used; they add 10 per cent to fuel consumption. 
 It is an attitude which may go part of the way to explaining why the House of Commons Environment Committee was &bquo;appalled&equo; by the standard of evidence offered by the car manufacturing companies at its hearings on air pollution. 
 They showed &bquo;an almost total lack of awareness&equo; of the roles of nitrogen oxides and hydrocarbons in producing ground-level ozone. 
 The Society of Motor Manufacturers and Traders made no mention of ozone at all and two of the manufacturers largely ignored it. 
 Vehicles are the main source of man-made nitrogen oxides, one of which, nitrous oxide, is a greenhouse gas. 
 They are an important ingredient of acid rain and combine with hydrocarbons to form smog. 
 Vehicle exhausts are also probably the biggest producers of man-made carbon monoxide, which destroys hydroxyl, an atmospheric &bquo;cleansing agent&equo; which gets rid of methane, another greenhouse gas. 
 Catalysts are expected to cut nitrogen oxide emissions from cars to about 10 per cent by 1989 levels by the year 2006. 
 Carbon monoxide and hydrocarbons will be less dramatically reduced, possibly by considerably less than half, while carbon dioxide emissions will increase because catalysts lead to heavier fuel consumption (only lean-burn engines which use less fuel would cut CO 2  emissions, but progress on them is slow). 
 For all vehicles, including heavy goods lorries, the types of emissions covered by catalysts are expected to fall by 2006 to a minimum of about 70 per cent of 1989's output. 
 To what extent is that really good news? 
 A report commissioned by the World Wide Fund for Nature from Earth Resources Research points to a lack of progress in cleaning up nitrogen oxide emissions from heavy lorries as the weak spot in the programme. 
 As the increasing number of cars will mean that, collectively, their emissions will remain substantial, it seems unlikely that a dramatic reduction in nitrogen oxide emissions can be expected. 
 &bquo;On the contrary, with high levels of transport growth the emissions of nitrogen oxides from road vehicles may be higher in 2020 than at present.&equo; 
 As for carbon dioxide emissions, they could more than double by 2020. 
 Even assuming a 1 per cent a year improvement in fuel efficiency from the early 1990s on and combining it with the government's lowest traffic forecast, carbon dioxide emissions could increase by 20 per cent by 2020. 
 If energy saving is applied rigorously in homes and industry and the power stations clean up their act by switching from coal to other fuels or otherwise cutting their carbon emissions, transport seems set to take over as the biggest emitter of carbon dioxide in Western industrialized countries. 
 The environmental issue of the decade 
 Logic would seem to point to car numbers never reaching the astronomic figures produced by the analysts. 
 The predicted 140 per cent increase in traffic in Britain by the end of the first quarter of the next century was an &bquo;unacceptable option&equo;, said Chris Patten. 
 &bquo;I think it's a moral issue as well as an issue of economics. 
 It's about the future of our planet and that's something worth fighting for&hellip; the real challenge for politicians is to convince people that being keen on the environment is not a cost-free option.&equo; 
 Fitting catalysts is expected to cost British motorists &pound;800 million a year. 
 During the 1980s, the British tended to buy bigger, high fuel-consumption cars, so increased taxes on petrol (favoured by Patten) would be an obvious way of driving them towards smaller, more economical cars with fewer noxious emissions. 
 The Transport (formerly Energy) Secretary Cecil Parkinson took the view that cars were not going to go away and discouraging ownership would be &bquo;very, very unpopular&equo;. 
 Doubling rail traffic would cut carbon dioxide emissions by only about 3 per cent. 
 The same cut could be achieved with a 100 cc reduction in the size of engines. 
 We have looked at the attachment of motorists for their cars, the increasing use of heavy lorries, and the reasons why governments are reluctant to impose taxes which push up inflation and weaken an important manufacturing industry. 
 But, despite the attractions of mobility, attitudes can be changed, or at least modified. 
 The EC's environmental taskforce &bquo;1992&equo; report contains the result of a poll comparing national attitudes within the Community on the importance of environmental protection. 
 The poll is not analysed, but it is striking that countries where pollution from cars has become a major problem have the highest percentages of people who believe that the state of the environment requires urgent action: 85 per cent in Italy (at the top of the list), where Milan, one of the world's smoggiest cities, now has car-free days and the capital Rome also suffers severely from vehicle congestion and pollution; 84 per cent in Greece, where restrictions on cars in Athens are imposed to save the citizens' lungs and their ancient monuments; 80 per cent in the most vehicle emission-conscious country in Europe, West Germany, whose dead trees have become the symbol of pollution. 
 In the United States, the strict new Clean Air Bill passed by the senate in April 1990 would cut carbon monoxide emissions by 70 per cent and a number of other gases by 22 per cent. 
 Apart from catalysts, more efficient engines and reduction in mileage, the only other way of tackling emissions is to change the fuel. 
 Southern California is moving towards replacing petrol with methanol, and &mdash; an important first &mdash; limiting the number of cars a family may own; even insisting on radial tyres because they produce less dust. 
 Hydrogen is another fuel receiving international attention. 
 Manufacturing it requires a prohibitive amount of electricity, unless the electricity comes from cheap renewable sources, like photo-voltaic cells in the Sahara, where the sunlight is guaranteed even if the water to make the hydrogen is not. 
 Fuels made from biomass, like ethanol, from sugar cane, are used in Brazil and a few other countries, but are subject to shortages, sometimes because of drought. 
 And then, of course, there is the alternative of public transport, provided it is ground transport (aircraft are major polluters). 
 The popularity of road transport has meant that railways have either had short shrift, as in Britain, where investment per kilometre is about one-third that in France, or have had to be heavily subsidized, as in France and Germany. 
 How you view public transport depends very much on where you live. 
 In contrast to the nationwide Observer/Harris poll of voters referred to earlier, 75 per cent of the Londoners questioned by Gallup on behalf of five London boroughs preferred curbs on cars and better public transport to more city roads. 
 Restraining the use of private cars would carry no disadvantages, in the view of 53 per cent, and only 4 per cent thought that discouraging people from using cars represented a loss of liberty. 
 Basically, there is no alternative to better public transport if big cities like London are to survive. 
 Better trains, improved underground systems, even the large trams used in some continental cities will play their part in the future. 
 High-speed trains in France already compete successfully with the airlines (and cars) over relatively short distances, as, for example, Paris-Lyons. 
 In Britain, the InterCity trains have syphoned off people who would otherwise use cars, and British Rail expects to double passenger mileage between 1988 and 2020. 
 What makes one pause when considering the role of public transport is the dispersed nature of modern society around the big cities. 
 The car has made it that way and it would be almost impossible for public transport to knit it together in the way that the railways did in the nineteenth century. 
 And given the general increase in mobility, would even a massive increase in investment in railways make much difference to road traffic? 
 Chris Patten is among the sceptics: &bquo;Even if it (investment) were to be successful and encourage a 40 or 50 per cent increase in the use of rail, it would make damn-all difference to the growth in road traffic &mdash; it would just take a few percentage points off the top.&equo; 
 The Dutch plan envisages people living closer to their workplace and without that happening it is hard to see how they will be persuaded to leave their cars at home. 
 But how do you get them to live within walking, cycling or tram-ride distance of work? 
 Does the work move to them, or are cars made so expensive that people are obliged to live close to their work, as they were for much of this century? 
 Democratic rights of use and ownership, a way of life and a key industry are involved. 
 It is a highly political issue with international ramifications which we are only just beginning to tackle and which will increasingly burden the agendas of the European Community's new environmental agency. 
 Cleaning up Eastern Europe 
 Is there in Eastern Europe a hideous environmental prototype of what is about to happen in the developing world? 
 There are so many similarities: poverty and governments more concerned (until very recently) with the statistics of production than with the producers; a lack of accountability among governments and officials; an absence of standards maintained through efficient inspectorates; a lack of that motivated middle class which in the West has made its strength felt in politics; a lack of effective protest by the victims, for the most part people who have come to accept pollution and filth as part of their everyday condition. 
 Of course, the Third World has already had &mdash; and has &mdash; some considerable environmental disasters. 
 There is Bhopal, for example, with 2500 dead from an escape of poisonous chemicals from a Union Carbide plant, and the appalling smogs and pollution of Mexico City. 
 And in the West, too, there is a roll-call of man-made horrors, among them the explosion at the Flixborough chemical works on Humberside and the dioxin release at Seveso (Italy), which caused the poisoning of thousands of acres of farmland and the deaths of many more thousands of cattle. 
 But Eastern Europe is different in the sustained and omnipresent nature of its pollution. 
 It is as if governments, having been given the gifts of technology, set them loose without an idea of how or even a wish to restrain them. 
 Production was a good in itself and therefore not to be held accountable for industry's wastes or the ill-health of workers and their families. 
 Assuming any records were kept, pollution was as much a state secret as the artillery's ammunition stocks. 
 Protest was silenced and it was only the new mood of glasnost in the second half of the 1980s which revealed the full extent of what had happened. 
 East Germany, where the lingering Protestant work ethic marched shoulder to shoulder with Leninist concepts of electrification as the vitalizing force that would change society, has the world's highest per capita emissions of sulphur dioxide and carbon dioxide. 
 If ever there was a place waiting for the missionary preachings of the energy efficiency industry it must be there. 
 Somehow the country has managed to consume more energy per capita than anywhere else other than rich (and notoriously thriftless) Canada and the United States and at the same time plunge into a state close to bankruptcy. 
 The Social Democrat parties on both sides of the inner-German border agreed in early January 1990 that &pound;72 billion would be needed to replace the brown coal generators which provide 70 per cent of East Germany's energy and clean up the water and sewage systems. 
 A figure of that sort, roughly twice the value of East Germany's 1986 exports and imports combined, is bound to cause incredulity, but even if the figure were halved, it would still be a remarkable indication of what has happened to a country which in the first half of the 1980s claimed to have established itself among the top ten industrial nations. 
 The coal-fired power stations may be unhealthy, but the nuclear ones are potentially lethal, as Klaus T&ouml;pfer, the West German environment minister, heard when he visited some of them. 
 There have been scores of potentially dangerous incidents, some of them in a generator little more than a mile from the border with West Germany. 
 One incident, in the reactor at Greifswald, nearly caused a meltdown in 1976, an accident that, occurring close to densely populated parts of Western and Central Europe, would have been a disaster of much greater magnitude than Chernobyl. 
 One can go on and on listing East Germany's morbid shortcomings. 
 It requires little research to do so, largely because West German specialists and journalists rushed across the frontier and came back gasping out tales of air pollution four times worse than West Germany's, of mercury levels in the Elbe that were 250 times EC limits, of forests where 40 per cent of the trees are sick. 
 East Germany was the first country in which fears over the state of the environment played a leading part in the overthrow of a system of government. 
 West Germans who had not been to the East had no difficulty in believing them. 
 They had seen the clouds of exhaust fumes spewed by the Trabants and Wartburgs which had brought escaping East Germans to the West. 
 And it was well known, too &mdash; and there was an element of guilt here &mdash; that East Germany was West Germany's dustbin for toxic and other wastes and plain rubbish. 
 Of the 6.6 million tonnes shipped from West Germany and West Berlin in 1989 some 700,000 tonnes were poisonous. 
 There is another way in which Eastern Europe can be seen as the prototype of things to come &mdash; the flow of refugees from East Germany and the German minorities in other countries to their rich brother. 
 In January 1990 alone there were 63,000 from East Germany and 38,000 from other East European countries; 100,000 in 1989 from the Soviet Union's 2 million-strong ethnic German population. 
 Most were economic refugees, but there were many who claimed to be environmental refugees leaving for the sake of their health. 
 The domestic political stress caused in West Germany by such an influx (which also of course, further undermined the East German economy, since many were skilled and professional people) was one very good reason why Bonn was prepared to pour aid into its neighbour. 
 Only by propping it up, and cleaning it up (and in the process uniting with it), was there any chance of stability. 
 West Germany has a constitutional obligation to accept East Germans, so the parallel with Third World economic and environmental refugees is not exact. 
 But under the general principle of rich nations having to pay poor ones to build their economies and stem their pollution it fits well enough. 
 The debit side of &bquo;progress&equo; 
 East Germany's environmental plight may have had more publicity than that of any other East European country, but its neighbours Poland and Czechoslovakia are almost equally high in the pollution league. 
 The flame-belching fires and smoke of the great Nova Huta steelworks at Krakow in Poland have become a stock shot of television coverage of Eastern Europe's environmental crisis, a begrimed image of what was once an icon of progress. 
 Pollution in such places is claimed to be ten times worse than in the West and the tonnage of sulphur dioxide said to fall every year on the average square kilometre sounds like the equivalent of a heavy snowfall. 
 Ten per cent of Krakow's children suffer from chronic bronchitis. 
 Nevertheless, Krakow is not as polluted as Katowice. 
 There, the chance of dying in one's forties is twice that of an inhabitant of relatively salubrious Krakow. 
 To all that can be added the fact that Poland's economic crisis and its indebtedness (at &dollar;39 billion) is worse than East Germany's. 
 Poland, too, is going to require tens of billions of dollars to rebuild its economy. 
 Czechoslovakia is better off than the other East European nations and has committed 2 per cent of its investment to environmental projects, but there once again are to be found the same dreary environmental statistics of rivers poisoned, sewage untreated, sulphur dioxide deposited and trees dying, even if the figures are not quite so bad as elsewhere. 
 Basically any report on Eastern Europe's problems comes down to much the same things: a heavy reliance on smokestack industries burning brown coal (also known as lignite) and pouring out uncontrolled noxious fumes, factories tipping their chemical wastes straight into rivers, and untreated sewage. 
 Only the dimensions of the statistics vary; in the case of the Soviet Union, fairly dramatically. 
 The Soviet Union is said to contain more than 1000 towns where its own permissible levels of atmospheric pollution are exceeded five-fold or more and 20 per cent of the population live in what the head of the Academy of Sciences' biology institute calls &bquo;ecological disaster zones&equo;. 
 One city of a million people, Ufa, 700 miles east of Moscow, was described in Pravda  in 1987 as having become unfit for human habitation. 
 It is doubtful if its situation has improved since then. 
 The heavy use of pesticides and chemicals in agriculture in Azerbaijan and the Central Asian republics is blamed for the high incidence of leukaemia, some of the worst infant mortality rates in the world, and liver disorders and cancer of the oesophagus. 
 Nearly one-third of the citizens of Leningrad are said to suffer from diseases the upper respiratory tract as a result of atmospheric pollution. 
 On the credit side, it should be said that there is now an acute awareness in the Soviet Union and the East European countries that pollution is a social and political issue and not just something that can be categorized vaguely as an environmental problem and shoved to the debit side of &bquo;progress&equo;. 
 Miners have struck in the Soviet Union over pollution (in combination with other matters) and scores of green organizations have sprung up. 
 The largest in the Soviet Union, the Social-Ecological Union, has 200 branches and is avowedly political in its approach. 
 Poverty rather than indifference is the reason for Moscow's inaction, it seems: it was Mikhail Gorbachev who in his autumn 1988 UN speech in New York proposed that the UN should set up an emergency centre for the environment. 
 His foreign minister, Edouard Shevardnadze, by coincidence chose the day Mrs Thatcher's greening was declared in a speech to the Royal Society (27 September 1988) to call for more co-operation in &bquo;ecological security&equo;. 
 One British reaction at the time to the greening of the Kremlin shows quite starkly how much political perceptions have changed in the short space since the autumn of 1988. 
 Michael Heseltine, the former British Defence Secretary, warned the Royal Institute of International Affairs on 23 November that the Soviet Union had identified environmental anxieties in Western Europe and the United States as offering an opportunity for mischief-making. 
 They were attempting to use the green movement to undermine NATO's efforts to modernize short-range nuclear weapons in Europe. 
 &bquo;What we are seeing here is a well thought-out, carefully crafted attempt to hijack the environmental agenda for ulterior purposes,&equo; he declared. 
 By the winter of 1989&ndash;90 the talk was all of troop cuts and disarmament and democratization, and the rapid moves towards German reunification had made talk of modernizing short-range nuclear weapons to be fired from West Germany at targets mainly in East Germany more plainly than ever the nonsense it had always been. 
 President Gorbachev's green fifth column could be returned to the fantasy-land it came from. 
 At this point it is worth taking a step back from the scene and recalling that the Soviet Union and all the East European states are signatories to the Convention on Long-Range Transboundary Air Pollution. 
 With the exception of Poland and Romania, they are pledged under the 1985 Protocol on Sulphur Emissions to reduce their sulphur emissions by 30 per cent by 1993. 
 It is unlikely that when they signed they could ever have had the slightest hope of achieving such a reduction. 
 There have been improvements here and there in the East European countries, but generally speaking they distribute sulphur dioxide to their own fields and cities and to the countries downwind of them as liberally as they ever did. 
 An injured party can complain against its neighbour under the convention, but it has no teeth. 
 What can have teeth, of course, even if it is concealed by a friendly smile, is aid. 
 By early 1990 the European Commission was co-ordinating aid to Poland and Hungary, the two East European countries regarded as having satisfactory democratic credentials. 
 The packages were worth &pound;600 million each. 
 The Japanese were quick to promise similar sums. 
 Under consideration was extension of the EC aid programmes to Czechoslovakia, East Germany, Romania and Bulgaria. 
 The Soviet Union was too big a problem even to begin thinking about seriously at that stage; a military superpower still, even if its economy was falling apart and its politics were in uncertain flux from one-party dictatorship towards a multi-party democracy. 
 The proposal by the President of the Commission, Jacques Delors, in Strasbourg on 17 January 1990 that the EC should treat the six East European countries as if they were backward regions of the Community and extend structural support to them brought gasps of disbelief from every government except West Germany's. 
 What Delors had in mind was aid worth &pound;10 billion a year for ten years. 
 Only two years earlier the Twelve had battled at epic length over increasing the EC budget for the years to 1992 from 0.7 per cent of each member state's gross national product to nearly 1.2 per cent, with the ceiling fixed at over &pound;30 billion. 
 Delors' proposals were clearly out of all proportion to that figure, and he was soon obliged to retreat with a lame explanation that he had been &bquo;arguing from the absurd to show what it would cost to achieve such a goal&equo;. 
 Nevertheless, it is clear that very large sums of money will have to be spent to put Eastern Europe on its feet and ensure that it stays democratic. 
 In the course of doing so money will have to be spent on cleaning up the Six (and, no doubt, eventually, the Soviet Union, too) to ensure that they make respectable cohabitants of the new Europe which various leaders from Gorbachev to Delors to Fran&ccedil;ois Mitterrand have envisaged. 
 Two EC countries (The Netherlands and Denmark) already examine the possible environmental impact of aid to Eastern Europe before approving projects. 
 Britain's Overseas Development Administration has its Manual of Environmental Appraisal  which will presumably apply as much to East Europe as it does to the Third World. 
 The EC itself has not attached environmental conditions in the cases of Poland and Hungary, but Carlo Ripa di Meana, the EC Environment Commissioner, has insisted that a sum (still to be agreed) must be set aside to bring the East's environment up to scratch and there are proposals for training environmental managers. 
 The new Bank of European Reconstruction and Development will obviously have an important role in deciding policy when its opens its doors for business. 
 Aid: East Europe vs. the South? 
 While the EC was debating its approach to the problems of Eastern Europe the president-elect of another distressed part of the world was nearing the end of a pre-inaugural tour which took him to all the major capitals. 
 The message Fernando Collor de Mello brought with him was that Brazil, where he would take over from President Sarney in mid-March, no longer wanted to be tagged as a Third World nation. 
 It wanted to be seen as an honorary member of the developed world experiencing the sort of hard times you might expect in a country with the world's biggest foreign debt, &dollar;115 billion. 
 Under Collor's guidance, it would modernize itself. 
 As host of the 1992 UN Conference on the Environment and Development, he hoped to see the &bquo;depoliticization&equo; of what he called (in London, in February 1990) the unfolding &bquo;ecological drama&equo;: 
 I will endeavour to combat the political, ideological and even electoral exploitation of the issue. 
 This is a serious issue which must be dealt with on a rational basis. 
 Hence the need to avoid mutual recriminations, facile accusations and scapegoats. 
 Let us not be simplistic about things that concern the survival of mankind. 
 Even allowing for a desire to please his audience, sentiments of that sort sound better news than warnings of confrontation. 
 An aspirant to membership of the developed club is likely to be accommodating about rainforests, the welfare of Amazonian Indians, the ozone layer and a climate convention. 
 Collor has spoken favourably of the idea of an international carbon tax. 
 But assuming Collor's Brazil makes it into the ranks of the developed world, it will do so at the lowest level of eligibility, on a par with the East European countries. 
 The country's population is over 140 million; the total population of the East European Six is rather more than 110 million. 
 Brazil had 83 cars and 84 telephones for every 1000 people in 1985; East Germany had 238 and 218 and Poland 119 and 113, respectively. 
 The ratios may have changed, but probably not by all that much, and there are no doubt more sophisticated and precise ways of measuring relative wealth. 
 But it is reasonable to assume that Eastern Europe is still considerably better off than Brazil, which in early 1990 was reported to be &dollar;6 billion in arrears on its &dollar;115 billion debt and facing the prospect of 2200 per cent inflation during the year. 
 In 1989 Brazil repaid nearly &dollar;800 million more to the World Bank than it received from it. 
 So it was not really surprising that despite his upwardly mobile outlook, Collor attended the paupers' summit in June 1990 at which fifteen debtor nations from the underdeveloped South discussed their predicament. 
 That predicament has undoubtedly been accentuated by events in Eastern Europe. 
 The attention of all the principal aid donors is concentrated there. 
 If Eastern Europe gets massive assistance it is logical to assume that the South will get less. 
 Poland's gain may turn out to be India's loss. 
 It may be essentially racist, but rich Europeans are likely to put the needs of poor Europeans ahead of those of poor Asians. 
 The West has a great political interest in seeing democratic systems based on market economies develop in Eastern Europe, since a collapse into worse poverty and anarchy would be a disaster, a tragic first chapter to the new peace between East and West. 
 Apart from that, the prospect of investment and increased trade with countries with long traditions of industry and commerce is a stimulating one. 
 The return on money spent or lent in Eastern Europe can be expected to be better, politically and commercially, than those from similar outflows into the gurgling sink of Latin America and other parts of the South. 
 It was no wonder that some politicians promoted the idea of a &bquo;Marshall Plan&equo; for Eastern Europe. 
 Senator Robert Dole, the Republican leader in the US Senate, went further than most by calling for aid to be diverted to East Europe at the expense of long-standing recipients such as Egypt. 
 As expenditures on arms decline with the ending of the cold war, there may be more money available for aid, but democratic politics being what they are, few would care to bet on it; certainly not on any percentage saved being set aside for the developing nations. 
 Even if it were, its benefits would be quickly swallowed by the rapid increase in the South's requirements as its populations grow; and the experiences of the 1970s and 1980s in which aid and loans failed to reverse economic decline are not encouraging. 
 Disillusionment and the heavy losses sustained by Western banks are reflected in the fact that the total net resource flows from the European Community and the eighteen member states of the OECD's Development Assistance Committee (the world's richest countries) dropped from &dollar;128 billion in 1980 to &dollar;103 billion in 1988. 
 Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union could be equally disillusioning, of course, and when the Governor of the Bank of England, Robin Leigh Pemberton, spoke to the Overseas Bankers' Club in February 1990 on lending to East Europe, he put his call for caution in the context of the losses sustained in the South. 
 Don't get stung again, was his basic message. 
 &bquo;Green conditionality&equo; 
 The bankers will take the risk of getting stung again, of course, because that is the way of the banking world. 
 They will be under political pressure to lend and there will be inducements to do so. 
 So it is fairly safe to assume that assistance from Western sources, official and private, will flow to the East in a crusade against the poverty and pollution caused by seventy years of ideological perversity. 
 The parts of the world &mdash; the Third World &mdash; which may suffer a loss, real or relative, as a result are generally estimated to have a debt of &dollar;1300 billion. 
 Loans and aid of all kinds to the Third World actually dropped slightly in real terms in 1988, from &dollar;96.9 billion in 1987 to &dollar;96 billion adjusted to 1987 prices and exchange rates. 
 Among the seventeen heavily indebted nations (mostly Latin American and including Brazil) per capita income in 1988 dropped by 0.6 per cent. 
 Sub-Saharan Africa continued its decline in per capita income, too, for the same reason as the heavily indebted countries &mdash; population increases continued to outstrip modest rates of economic growth. 
 In fact, the World Bank believes that aid to black Africa (now running at about &pound;10 billion a year, the same figure as that which caused Community jaws to drop when suggested by Jacques Delors for Eastern Europe) needs to increase by nearly 50 per cent by the end of the century. 
 The horror stories of Eastern Europe can be more than matched from the Third World. 
 One in three Peruvian children is stunted by malnutrition, said the Worldwatch Institute of Washington in a 1989 report, Poverty and the Environment:  Reversing the Downward Spiral. 
 Infant mortality doubled in Zambia during the first half of the 1980s. 
 Life expectancy fell in nine African countries. 
 Almost a quarter of the world's population &mdash; 1.2 billion people &mdash; were reckoned to be too poor to meet their most basic needs for food, clothing and shelter. 
 It is not a uniform picture. 
 The two biggest Third World countries, China and India, were, by contrast with Brazil, doing well so far as growth rates are concerned. 
 They are low-income countries and India has more desperately poor people than anywhere else in the world, but in 1988 China's growth rate was 11 per cent and India's 8 per cent, well ahead of their population increases. 
 China's growth is fuelled largely by coal and so is India's, some of it in the latter case thanks to World Bank funding. 
 And burning coal, of course, produces, carbon dioxide as well as sulphur dioxide. 
 The World Bank was last year reported to be in the throes of an anguished debate between its environmental unit and its energy department over the best way of enlisting Third World support for curbing greenhouse gases. 
 Can you really tell countries like India and China that they should switch from coal to some other, more expensive fuel or spend heavily on cleaning up emissions? 
 The Bank stuck to a policy of recommending that subsidies should be ended, which would have the effect of increasing electricity prices and encouraging energy efficiency. 
 Proposals for a worldwide carbon tax and the phasing out of coal-burning generators appear to have been ruled out. 
 The subtraction from &bquo;traditional&equo; aid flows implied by Western Europe's impassioned concern for East Europe has worried the Third World, as its diplomats make clear every time they find a receptive ear. 
 Even before the upheavals in Europe they were warning against attempts to subtract environmental aid from development aid. 
 Western politicians like Lynda Chalker, the British aid minister, have tried to reassure them: &bquo;Britain will continue to respond to the needs of the developing world,&equo; she said in mid-January 1990. 
 &bquo;The very substantial funds which we are making available for Eastern Europe&hellip; are separate from and additional to our regular aid programme.&equo; 
 But statements are unlikely to prevent a heightening of suspicions which are always fairly strong even at the best of times, and that could make it harder for the North to get the global climate convention it is seeking. 
 The South does not, for a start, like the idea of &bquo;green conditionality&equo; being attached to aid agreements. 
 Such conditions were a ruse by the North to make the South pay an unfair share of the cost of protecting the environment, said Bernard Chidzero, the Zimbabwe finance minister, at the September 1989 Commonwealth finance ministers' meeting in Jamaica. 
 The final communiqu&eacute; recorded the ministers' view that aid totals would have to include &bquo;any additional burden on developing countries arising from action to protect the environment&equo;. 
 That general attitude of the South's is said to have been the most striking impression retained by Ripa di Meana, the EC environment commissioner, from talks during his first year in office (1989) with Third World ministers and officials. 
 The agreements on protecting the ozone layer are often pushed forward as pioneering achievements which will ease the way to an atmospheric convention and protocols dealing with carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases. 
 They are indeed considerable achievements, but what they show most clearly is how hard it will be to get the major Third World countries to agree on any protocol which could slow down or affect industrial growth. 
 Aid and technology transfers are their price. 
 Poverty is a more pressing problem for them than the greenhouse effect. 
 That came across very strongly at a UNEP conference in Nairobi in 1989 on phasing out CFCs. 
 Buying out CFCs in the Third World is within the West's means, but buying out carbon dioxide in China, India, Brazil and the lesser parts of the Third World is certain to prove beyond anyone's means. 
 If persuasion does not work, &bquo;green conditionality&equo; might be the answer in some cases, unpopular though it would be; and for the really hard cases, sanctions, provided there is sufficient of a consensus to back them and the industrial world has not sunk into a mood of profound fatalism about the impossibility of stemming the greenhouse gases. 
 Eastern Europe and the Soviet Union are object lessons about the dangers of letting industry befoul the environment in the name of economic growth. 
 There is still time for much of the Third World to be held back from taking the same course. 
 1992 and beyond 
 When it comes to handling the environmental crisis there is undoubted strength but also a flaw in the Western democratic system which has triumphed so dramatically, both ideologically and materially, at the end of the twentieth century: its political and economic well-being depends on growth and the prospect of ever-increasing wealth and improved standards of living. 
 Governments which wish to survive have to maintain growth. 
 Since governments with a death wish are rare, growth which enriches the individual is sacred. 
 Nothing is allowed to impede it. 
 The health of democracy depends on it. 
 Depressions are death. 
 It is a way of thinking which means that in great emergencies such as war, sacrifices are usually made late and reluctantly. 
 There is no reason to believe that the environmental crisis will be treated any differently. 
 Raising the sums which will be required in the name of global environmental security during the next 50&ndash;60 years (which is about as far as anyone can reasonably try to foresee) will create severe political and economic stresses. 
 What they will add up to is anyone's guess at the moment; inflation, uncertainty about the pace and impact of climate change, and the political factors which govern priorities make any attempt at assessment a futile exercise. 
 It is enough to say they will be counted in trillions (millions of millions) of dollars. 
 Some recent estimates of the cost nationally in the United States give an idea of the probable scale: curbing carbon dioxide emissions at 1990 levels could absorb between 1 and 2 per cent of GNP, with the sums rising into the trillions in the next century. 
 There is not a US coastal state which is not considering measures to preserve its coastal regions and the Environmental Protection Agency has put the cost of protecting cities against a one metre sea-level rise at between &dollar;73 and &dollar;111 trillion. 
 Other vulnerable countries face heavy expenditures, cancelling out any savings made in defence budgets &mdash; around one trillion dollars a year globally &mdash; following the end of the cold war and perhaps rising to the levels of expenditures experienced in a war. 
 The temptation for the rich nations will be to avoid or limit them by deferring expenditures on pre-emptive measures which will add up at home to taxes, higher energy costs and technology transfers to poor countries striving to compete with the donors. 
 There is a taste of the difficulties ahead in the ordering of priorities in the advanced industrial countries: first place goes to economic growth and second place to environmental security. 
 Unless there is growth, it is argued, the rich will not be able to provide the money and technological resources needed to counter climate change globally. 
 Thus, the ozone layer can be saved only if there are substitutes for CFCs which enable manufacturers to continue making refrigerators. 
 The fashionable creed of sustainable development panders to that sort of thinking. 
 It tells electorates that there can be continual growth and no one need worry that the cost of environmental security will hit spending power or reduce standards of living. 
 Governments point to just how wrong the environmentalists were in the 1970s when they claimed that the &bquo;squandering&equo; of resources would impose limits on growth. 
 The 1970s and 1980s have been decades of unparalleled growth. 
 But that is an increasingly irrelevant justification for present attitudes. 
 The argument in the 1990s is not about resource depletion but about changes in climate which will concern life and health as well as, ultimately, wealth. 
 Every qualified projection of climate change and population growth indicates a crisis which will grow in seriousness through the first half of the twenty-first century. 
 Concern with growth is not a Western/developed world monopoly. 
 Growth is a desperate necessity for China and India, which between them account for a third of the global population, and other developing nations. 
 The idea of diverting even one per cent of GNP to curtailing carbon dioxide emissions would seem to most of them too frivolous to be seriously entertained, unless, of course, someone else was willing to pay. 
 And which countries, one wonders, would be willing to finance the replacement of China's abundant coal as the fuel for its power stations with less polluting natural gas, or underwrite double-glazing in Chinese homes as a major contribution to energy efficiency? 
 Perhaps they will one day, but at the moment it seems some way off. 
 Taxing the air 
 There is no doubt in the mind of Mostafa Tolba, UNEP's executive director, that &bquo;financing solutions to the global environment crisis will be the major issue of this decade&equo;. 
 Tolba belongs to a political species that will become more common as the decade rolls on towards the next century. 
 He is an environmental statesman. 
 When he speaks he is listened to with well-earned respect, particularly in these preparatory years before the 1992 UN conference on the environment which will mark the culmination of his career. 
 The environmental crisis will, he says, require an increase in the flow of resources to the Third World, debt relief, fair pricing of commodities, land reform and help for Third World food producers in the form of a phasing-out of subsidies to agriculture in the developed nations. 
 A genuine global partnership must be struck between rich and poor in which all contribute and all have an equal say in the allocation of resources. 
 &bquo;The worst mistake that could be made is for the rich to apply conditionality to new aid and loans.&equo; 
 Saving the world will not be cheap, but, then, security never has been cheap. 
 The alternative to North-South co-operation based on aid will be conflict and the prospect of &bquo;21st century eco-wars&equo;. 
 Could Egypt, he asks, allow nations sharing the watershed of the Nile to disrupt the river's flow, the lifeblood of its economy? 
 How would Niger and Nigeria react to the plans of upstream nations for barrages and irrigation schemes which might dry up the Niger? 
 These are not isolated issues. 
 Some 40 per cent of the world's population depends for drinking water, irrigation and hydro-electric power on 214 river systems shared by two or more countries. 
 &bquo;The threat from a nuclear war forced us in the post-war period to think in terms of war destroying the whole planet. 
 Human economic activity forces us to think of the environment in the same terms.&equo; 
 The message is a forceful one, strengthened by the fact that resource wars are not exactly new. 
 The search for better grazing prompted many of the great nomadic outpourings from Central Asia, and as recently as the early 1960s a civil war was fought in what is now Zaire over the control of Katanga's copper mines. 
 However, one can accept the message and still wonder how Tolba proposes raising the money to buy peace. 
 He agrees that &bquo;practical and innovative thinking&equo; is required, and he clearly likes an idea inspired by the sustainable developer's manual, users' fees. 
 This, he says, is an &bquo;attractive option&equo;. 
 It would mean pricing and paying for air and other environmental resources. 
 Fees would be collected by national governments and a proportion of them paid into an &bquo;international fund to save the earth&equo;. 
 The idea of taxing what most people regard as their birthright, fresh air, is startling, but perhaps Tolba is right: we should not take it for granted. 
 After all, we pay for piped, chlorinated water, why not for cleaned-up air? 
 However, acceptance of the idea would still leave open the question of how air is to be priced. 
 If, for lack of a formula, British ministries (and no doubt ministries elsewhere) are unable to price the amenity value of landscapes threatened by development, how on earth would any government &mdash; or, more probably a conference of governments &mdash; be able to arrive at a system for pricing the air? 
 How much more would the rich Swiss pay than the impoverished Vietnamese? 
 Or would it be like the British poll tax, with rich and poor paying the same subject to a complicated system of rebates? 
 If payments were partly based on per capita emissions of greenhouse gases, would methane from paddy fields be given the same price as carbon dioxide from power stations, cars and burning tropical forests? 
 Suppose, though, that Western countries agreed to the idea of users' fees based on notional valuations of the atmosphere and other resources. 
 Suppose, too, that they managed to sell the idea to their tax-payers, who, after all, would have to find the money. 
 They would then be required to hand over the proceeds, without any strings attached, to a fund in which, under the Tolba plan, &bquo;all countries would have an equal say in resource allocation.&equo; 
 Listening to Tolba produces an uneasy feeling that perhaps Nairobi, where UNEP has its headquarters, is a bit isolated, too far away from the &bquo;real world&equo; of money and carbon dioxide and hard-nosed political deals. 
 The case for placing UNEP in the Third World is plain enough &mdash; influence, providing a sense of shaping the decisions &mdash; but where can the pay-off be seen in Africa, a hapless continent which does nothing to strengthen UNEP's authority? 
 If UNEP is to play the key role in shaping and managing the new environmental conventions Brazil would be a better centre (and Geneva an even better one). 
 Realistically, though, there is no chance of extracting UNEP from Nairobi. 
 The politics of the United Nations will ensure that it stays there. 
 Tolba's ideas carry echoes of the argument in the 1970s over the New International Economic Order in which the Third World lined up to demand compensation in the form of aid and technology transfers for the &bquo;looting&equo; of their resources by Western imperialism. 
 The huge Third World debt incurred as the Arab oil producers' profits from the oil boom were recycled by Western banks was the outcome. 
 This time, the Third World has a lever of sorts in its willingness, or unwillingness, to co-operate, but one of limited value since co-operation in drawing up a climate convention is ultimately as much in the interests of the poor nations as it is in those of the rich. 
 It is certainly not strong enough to extract unconditional aid from the developed nations, habitually suspicious of what happens to their money once it reaches Third World administrations. 
 Donors will obviously need to be sure that environmental aid is administered efficiently and spent according to agreed priorities. 
 An end-of-century shibboleth 
 The 1992 UN Conference on Environment and Development will be a test of the world's commitment to take action to protect itself. 
 A climate convention (with or without protocols) should be ready by then to form the agenda's centrepiece, and possibly there will be a convention on bio-diversity which would cover the protection of the rainforests and the multiplicity of species which they harbour. 
 Carbon dioxide will be the supreme test of commitment and anti-pollution technology, but, as has been noted before, it is so omnipresent, its natural cycle so great and its sources and sinks so difficult to determine accurately (one assessment in early 1990 downgraded the amount mopped up by the oceans by 50 per cent but came to no firm conclusion about where the unaccounted for remainder went), so closely linked with economic growth and its man-made sources so hard and expensive to restrain that it is difficult to imagine a protocol which will be globally effective. 
 Methane, which contributes 18 per cent of the greenhouse effect, presents even greater problems. 
 Curbs on ownership of water buffaloes and other ruminant emitters do not seem likely, nor would it be possible to cover up rice paddies and melting permafrost in the tundra. 
 But even if by some miracle effective protocols are agreed, the momentum of climate change means that whatever action is taken to reduce greenhouse gases will be of more value to generations beyond the mid-century than to those which come before it. 
 Mitigating the causes of the crisis has to continue, of course, but the dominant issue may turn out to be crisis management within the triple-P of problems caused by poverty, pollution and population. 
 The philosophy or, perhaps more accurately, the frame of thinking which will guide governments and international institutions in the 1990s and beyond is still in its formative stages. 
 The Brundtland Commission may have made sustainable development the end-of-century watchword, defining it as &bquo;development that meets the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs&equo;, but even Tolba has wondered aloud whether it amounts to much more than a shibboleth. 
 Richard Saunher of the Organization of American States' Department of Regional Development informed the April 1987 Sustainable Development Conference, in London, that &bquo;a concern for sustainable development certainly does not consciously guide our work. 
 Indeed, we make an effort not to use the phrase for a number of reasons, one of which is that we have been unable to figure out what it means&equo;. 
 More importantly, it was regarded as a distraction from the real issues of environment and development. 
 Timothy O'Riordan, of the University of East Anglia, thinks sustainability might be accepted as the &bquo;mediating term&equo; between developers and environmentalists, although he leans to the view that it will eventually languish as a &bquo;good idea&equo; which cannot sensibly be put into practice. 
 The arch-priest of the British sustainable developers, Professor David Pearce of the London Environmental Economics Centre, connects it with the &bquo;quality of life&equo; and people's expectations. 
 &bquo;Sustainable development involves devising a social and economic system which ensures that these goals are sustained, i.e. that real incomes rise, that educational standards increase, that the health of the nation improves, that the general quality of life is advanced.&equo; 
 In both the Brundtland and Pearce reports the principle is established that present development must not jeopardize the future. 
 Pearce encapsulates it as each generation ensuring that it passes on to the next an undiminished stock of assets, including environmental as well as man-made capital. 
 That might just be possible in countries with zero-growth populations, but in the fecund Third World the result would be the equivalent of the ancient Saxon custom of gavelkind, in which the inheritance was divided equally among all the sons. 
 Everyone tended to get poorer as the lots grew smaller and smaller. 
 Without being too sophisticated about its finer points, sustainable development has an obvious, sensible meaning when expressed in terms of a traditional farmer recycling dung and compost to maintain the fertility of his land. 
 Like the farmer, humanity should try to live within its means. 
 If energy can be obtained from tides, waves and windmills that is better than energy obtained from fossil fuels, which are non-renewable. 
 However, the world's preponderance of very poor people want to get richer as quickly as they can and are probably not too concerned if they do so at the expense of the environment. 
 Not only that, but the number of people in that category is rising very rapidly. 
 Between 1985 and 2025 the population of the developing world is expected to increase from 3.7 billion to 6.8 billion, of whom well over half will live in those hotbeds of aspiration and discontent, the cities. 
 Sustainability in those circumstances would seem virtually impossible. 
 One of Pearce's main points is that we need to be able to apply monetary values to environmental gains and losses. 
 An improvement in environmental quality is also an economic improvement if it increases social satisfaction or welfare. 
 We must learn to recognize that environmental capital is just as much capital as man-made capital. 
 Environmental capital includes not just the stock of oil and gas, coal and minerals. 
 It also includes the ozone layer, the protective functions of forests and wetlands, the waste-assimilating functions of rivers and oceans, and the store of biological diversity. 
 To ensure sustainable development, we must &bquo;maintain the capital stock&equo;. 
 Dr Pearce is the special adviser on environmental economics to Chris Patten. 
 Patten believes that people have to recognize that environmental quality is not a cost-free option and that the way in which energy and transport policies will have to be modified to take account of environmental factors will become an important subject of public debate. 
 So let us look at an English case which exemplifies some of the practical problems confronting the theorists of sustainable development: Twyford Down (near Winchester) and the route of the M3 motorway in March 1990. 
 Twyford Down is a much-loved, fiercely defended &bquo;environment&equo; close to a city which values its green spaces. 
 It is designated as an area of outstanding natural beauty, the exquisite chalk-hill blue butterfly has made its home there and there are Celtic fields and an Iron Age fort. 
 Here, clearly, was a marvellous opportunity to give Pearce's principles free rein and see what costings they produced. 
 What had to be decided was whether 2.63 miles of the extended six-lane M3 would be tunnelled through the downland chalk or just cut straight through in a deep, wide trench which would obviously make an irreparable mess of the down. 
 Tunnelling was estimated to cost &pound;128 million; cutting a trench &pound;36 million. 
 The &pound;92 million difference between the was plain enough, but how much was the unspoiled beauty of Twyford Down worth, not just to present-day citizens of Winchester but to future generations? 
 The authors of Blueprint for a Green Economy  express the belief that it is possible to put a money value on the benefit of preserving the rare Californian condor, so why not on chalk-hill blue butterflies? 
 On harebells, primroses, rabbits and just the sheer pleasure people get from walking on such familiar, ancient places, too. 
 &pound;10, &pound;20, &pound;50 million? 
 It is sad to report that neither the Transport Department nor the Environment Department (they made a joint decision in favour of the trench on the grounds of cost) made any attempt to value Twyford Down, its inhabitants and the enjoyment gained now and in the future from them. 
 &bquo;At the moment there are no formulae for costing environmental matters of that sort,&equo; a spokesman for the Department of Transport informed the author. 
 It would, of course, be very difficult to create a formula. 
 A lepidopterist might be able to quote a going price for a preserved chalk-hill blue in good condition, wild rabbits have a price when shot and skinned, but the market price of Twyford Down itself would be low if sold with legal constraints which kept it as an open, public space and high if sold with planning permission for houses or industry (or even a road). 
 If it is so difficult to value a small piece of the environment like Twyford Down, how will it ever be possible to cost the ozone layer? 
 The answer must be that trying to give values to the environment is an irrelevance. 
 Perhaps one can produce figures for the amount knocked off property prices by aircraft noise and excessive pollution (as Blueprint  suggests, with the backing of figures from American cities), but even here there is room for doubt. 
 Some of the highest property prices anywhere are in fume-ridden Manhattan and in cleaner but nevertheless congested central Tokyo. 
 Airports attract hotels and businesses; they employ large numbers of well-paid staff who like to live near their work. 
 House and land prices tend on the whole to go up rather than down. 
 There is another problem when it comes to applying market prices to environmental capital: the pieces of green environment that are most treasured by most people are their gardens. 
 Thousands of millions of dollars, marks, francs, pounds and every other currency of substance must be spent every year on plants and equipment for them. 
 But they are man-made capital rather than environmental capital. 
 In the end environmental issues come down to political decisions on what people want. 
 The Green Belt around London has been preserved not because someone put a price on it but because voters in the Home Counties wanted to stop the city sprawling outwards seemingly for ever. 
 They wanted planning and an attempt at a balance between the traditional English landscape and the demands of housing (and gardens) and roads, quite simple concepts, really. 
 There was another way of tackling the issue of Twyford Down. 
 The Departments of Environment and Transport could have agreed that in principle it was better not to encourage more cars onto the roads by building better motorways. 
 What was needed was a much improved rail link to Southampton, backed by a tax policy that would penalize motor vehicles and favour the railways. 
 But, again, no one seems to have considered that as an option; and if they had, it would have been highly unpopular and, if implemented, its effects slow and perhaps ultimately unsatisfactory. 
 &bquo;We are not going to do without a great car economy,&equo; declared Margaret Thatcher in March 1990 in the course of dismissing &bquo;airy-fairy&equo; green ideas about a return to village life. 
 &bquo;Much of our economy would collapse if we did without that.&equo; 
 What sustainable development really represents, one suspects, is a dilemma. 
 Essentially it comes down to the age-old question which has tormented the rich as much as the fate of their souls: how do you have your cake and eat it? 
 Growth at almost any cost has always been the answer. 
 Industrial society has managed to bake bigger and richer cakes for most of the past two centuries, suffering the occasional bouts of indigestion, but getting fatter most of the time. 
 In the West we have bigger, warmer homes, more amusement, more communications; we travel more and further for work and pleasure than every before. 
 Compared with our ancestors plodding six days a week between plough furrow and hearth and, taking mileage as a measurement of space, we must occupy a thousand, perhaps several thousand times as much space. 
 Sustainable development consoles us with the idea that we can go on having more provided we are more hygienic and respect nature. 
 We have to be vaguely provident, but no real sacrifices are demanded. 
 Common sense may tell us something different: that there are limits to growth (or more accurately, perhaps, to real disposable income), imposed not so much by the depletion of fossil fuels and mineral which worried the Club of Rome, but by numbers of people and the cost of a worldwide defence of the environment. 
 Technology and resource transfers to help and persuade Third World countries to combat the effects of global climate change potentially could impose enormous charges on the developed nations in addition to what they have to spend nationally and regionally. 
 If, for example, lean-burn engines are developed by Western manufacturers as the best way of cutting carbon dioxide emissions by the world's rapidly increasing stock of vehicles, is the technology passed on free of charge to developing countries beginning a build-up to mass production from their own motor industries? 
 Patents and the rights of private industry are not matters which can be brushed aside cheaply in order to enlist Third World support, as the difficult negotiations on the technology for manufacturing CFC substitutes have shown. 
 If the developed world wants to save the destruction of tropical forests by fuel-wood gatherers does it help the countries concerned to provide alternative energy from power stations using shrinking supplies of relatively clean natural gas while it switches to nuclear power, despite its expense and dangers? 
 Building the security regime 
 Sustainable development will have value if it provides politicians with a non-threatening idea to hang on to while they sort out their approach to the problems created by climate change. 
 They know what they have to avoid , another Law of the Sea marathon. 
 What they have to do  initially is agree a climate convention. 
 If it is to be more than a symbolic marker of the moment when North and South decided in principle to work together for mutual survival, a number of decisions on how to administer it will have to be made. 
 Some of the grander ideas have envisaged an all-embracing law of the environment, an entirely new international environmental protection agency and even a special environmental security council. 
 Those who argue that creating such a structure would take years and waste valuable time are probably right. 
 The UN Charter would have to be amended to provide for a special security council which would not, presumably, include the rights of veto held by the five permanent members of the existing security council. 
 What is best in this case is undoubtedly what will be quickest and simplest. 
 The Inter-governmental Panel on Climate Change, which links the World Meteorological Organization and UNEP and has its secretariat in UNEP's offices in the UN's second city, Geneva, could be institutionalized and strengthened under the aegis of UNEP to provide the focal point for investigation, the monitoring of the impact of climate change, and ideas. 
 UNEP, it is worth recalling, was born out of the 1972 Stockholm conference; the 1992 anniversary conference will be the time to consider turning it into a full-blown UN agency with more funds at its disposal. 
 Conversion into an agency would introduce a need for detailed thought about its functions and its future role. 
 Monitoring the climate convention and the impact of climate change would require a mandate and an establishment at least equivalent to that of the Vienna-based International Atomic Energy Agency, which polices the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty. 
 The Nairobi headquarters could stay where they are, but the climate side of its activities would need to remain in Geneva, close to the WMO and in an international hub-city. 
 The environment is already a hazy area which overlaps into a great many administrative realms. 
 It will become even less distinct as environmental issues become more and more merged with problems caused by rapidly expanding populations, poverty and the visibly harsh strictures of climate change. 
 If one had to make a guess, it is that within another ten years or so &bquo;environment&equo; will have become a somewhat pass&eacute;  term, rather as &bquo;ecological&equo; has, simply because of its insufficiency as a generic description; a term which links the preservation of rural landscapes in Europe to the fate of millions in Bangladesh obviously has problems of definition. 
 Under the cover-all of climate change, the issues will tend to become more sectorized, too big to be handled monolithically. 
 International organizations like the World Bank, the Food and Agriculture Organization and the UN High Commissioner for Refugees are already involved in issues and situations which are either directly or indirectly &bquo;environmental&equo; and their workload will increase. 
 It would be virtually impossible to bring them under the control of one super-agency. 
 The World Bank has already put forward proposals for a global environment fund with which UNEP and the UN Development Programme would be associated. 
 Its mandate would include technology transfers and the encouragement of investment in projects which would enhance or safeguard the environment. 
 Rather than establish a separate organization to administer the fund, it would probably be better to leave aid of that nature to the World Bank and bilateral and regional agreements, the more so since an issue like controlling carbon dioxide emissions may come to depend not so much on targets and dates agreed under a protocol to the climate convention as on the speed with which programmes to introduce cleaner forms of energy (possibly including internationally supervised nuclear energy) can be funded and implemented. 
 Even if no super-agency is established to deal with the environmental crisis, it will still be necessary to create a regime which can monitor and police compliance with agreements. 
 It should be possible to take breaches of agreements before the International Court of Justice or, when they amount to a threat to peace, before the Security Council. 
 Obtaining compliance will be as difficult as it always has been, but an international community which has used sanctions to encourage change in southern Africa should be able to tackle the much more serious issues of enforcement associated with climate change and international security. 
 Warnings of eco-wars and the flight of hundreds of millions of refugees cannot be dismissed as fantasies: they are probabilities in situations which become more and more apparent as the century nears its end. 
 Man is a god in ruins, thought Emerson, and perhaps at the end of the twentieth century much the same could be said of his world, a still beautiful but ravaged paradise which, regardless of the tenets of sustainable development will not be passed on to the next century in better or even the same condition, in fact, almost certainly in worse condition as a result of meeting the needs of another billion or so people. 
 But in this pivotal period when cold war recedes and environmental crisis takes its place there are several hopeful factors. 
 The first is that there is in the developed world a new culture of environmental awareness. 
 The electorates are being greened. 
 They may not be unduly apprehensive about climate change, but they know about the greenhouse effect and how the state of the world and their own localities impinges on their lives. 
 The other factors are the ending of the cold war and the building of a largely successful international security apparatus in the post-war era. 
 The common instinct for survival has shown itself more powerful than the urge to take risks on behalf of national interest. 
 It has proved possible to reach agreements that eventually ended atmospheric pollution caused by nuclear tests, that prohibited environmental modification and kept Antarctica free of nuclear weapons and military establishments. 
 Governments have not been as irrational and totally careless of life as the experience of the Second World War led many to believe. 
 These are factors which provide the basis on which the new environmental security regime can be built, although, sadly, it will probably take more than one catastrophe to shake the world into acceptance of the sacrifices of sovereignty and treasure which will be needed to make it effective. 
 For the post-war generations in the developed nations reared on the statistics of economic and social improvement, it will not be easy to accept that the twenty-first century threatens humanity with hard times and lowered standards of living. 
 Acknowledgement of humanity's common predicament should shape the moral stance, since the goal will be mutual survival. 
 Explanatory Notes 
 This book is not primarily about climatology or science (although, obviously, both are very much involved) and it does not attempt detailed scientific explanations of the greenhouse effect and the problems of the ozone layer. 
 Many readers will be familiar with both, but I have included the following for those for whom brief easy-to-find summaries will be useful. 
 The Greenhouse Effect 
 The greenhouse gases are not (apart from man-made CFCs and halons) newcomers to the atmospheric scene. 
 They are essential atmospheric cladding which prevents the earth from becoming a frozen planet. 
 The current problems are the result of the cladding becoming too dense and warm, largely (it is generally assumed) because of human activities. 
 The image of cladding, although apt, exaggerates the volume of the gases. 
 They are a very small part of the atmosphere, of which nitrogen and oxygen constitute 99 per cent by volume. 
 Neither has much effect on the earth's heat balance. 
 The greenhouse gases allow the sun's short-wave radiation to pass through them, but absorb much of the long-wave radiation which the earth throws back towards space (which is what a greenhouse does). 
 Until the beginning of the industrial revolution, there was a rough balance which kept the earth's temperature more or less the same from one year to the next. 
 The Gases 
 A &bquo;natural&equo; greenhouse effect raises surface temperature to an average of 15 &deg; C. Without it, the world would be 35 &deg; C colder than it is. 
 The two most important greenhouse gases are water vapour, which constitutes less than 4 per cent of the atmosphere's volume, and carbon dioxide. 
 Water vapour  is a key gas since it forms in clouds, and clouds are the most effective barrier to the escape of heat. 
 However, the role of clouds is one of the big conundrums of climatology. 
 They also bounce back, absorb and scatter incoming sunlight to an unknown extent. 
 No one is quite sure whether there will be more or less of them in a warmer global climate. 
 Carbon dioxide  is thought to have contributed 50 per cent of the greenhouse effect in the 1980s. 
 Annual emissions from man-made sources have increased by between three and four times since 1950. 
 Because of its close connection with the fossil fuels (particularly coal) used in electricity generation, controlling its emission globally presents acute problems. 
 Man-made carbon dioxide from burning fossil fuels, about 5.6 billion tonnes a year, should be seen in the context of the natural carbon cycle of 200 billion tonnes exchanged every year between the atmosphere, the land and living things and the oceans. 
 It is not yet clear how constant that cycle is. 
 However, the rise in carbon dioxide does parallel the growth of industry. 
 Its atmospheric concentration was between 270 and 280 parts per million in 1850. 
 The Mauna Loa observatory in Hawaii measured it in 1958 at 315 ppm. 
 By the end of the 1980s it was about 350 ppm. 
 Annual increase in concentrations is 0.5 per cent. 
 A doubling of the 1850s concentration would, at that rate of increase, take place around 2080. 
 However, if increases in the other greenhouse gases are taken into account, the equivalent of that doubling will take place in or about 2030. 
 The other greenhouse gases are: Methane  It contributes 18 per cent of the current greenhouse effect. 
 Belching cows, paddy fields, melting permafrost, leaking natural gas pipelines &mdash; all can contribute to methane as greenhouse gas. 
 Its presence in the atmosphere has more than doubled since pre-industrial (mid-eighteenth century) times. 
 The annual growth in concentration in the 1980s was 0.5 per cent. 
 CFCs and halons  CFCs are the well-known ozone destroying coolant gases in aerosols and refrigerators. 
 Halons are used in fire extinguishers. 
 They contribute 14 per cent of the greenhouse effect and are increasing at the rate of 6 per cent a year. 
 They can last for up to 110 years (some CFCs for 20,000 years) and are the most pernicious greenhouse gases. 
 Molecule for molecule, they are 10,000 times more potent than carbon dioxide and it has been estimated that if production is not checked they will rival carbon dioxide as the main greenhouse gas in the twenty-first century. 
 Nitrous oxide  Six per cent of the current greenhouse effect. 
 From fertilizers, vehicle emissions and the burning of fossil fuels and vegetable matter. 
 Annual rate of increase in the 1980s: 0.25 per cent. 
 Tropospheric (surface) ozone  Short-lived but increasing at about 2 per cent a year; 12 per cent of the current greenhouse effect. 
 Caused by the photochemical reaction of sunlight with carbon monoxide (much of it from cars) and nitrogen oxides, most of them man-made. 
 Its annual increase in the 1980s was 1 per cent. 
 Temperatures and Sea Levels 
 Temperatures  The generally accepted estimate is that the world warmed by 0.3&ndash;0.6 &deg; C during the last 100 years. 
 The IPCC scientific assessment group predicts that without any measures to check greenhouse gas emissions the increase in the mean global temperature will be about 0.3 &deg; C per decade &mdash; greater than anything seen in the 10,000 years of the interglacial. 
 This would mean the world being 1 &deg; C warmer than it is today by 2025 and 3 &deg; C warmer by the end of the century. 
 Under other scenarios in which controls of varying severity are introduced the increases would be from 0.1 &deg; C to 0.2 &deg; C each decade. 
 By comparison, the mean global temperature during the last ice age is estimated to have been 4 &deg; C colder than it is today. 
 Sea-Level Rises  The subject is extremely complicated and the increases to be expected undergo constant revision. 
 The top 2.5 metres of the oceans have been described as being the equivalent in terms of heat capacity of the entire atmosphere. 
 Different currents move at different depths and with great variations in temperature. 
 So it is difficult to estimate thermal expansion as a result of surface warming. 
 It is equally difficult to work out what will happen to the ice sheets at the poles. 
 A simultaneous thinning and shrinking of the sea ice lessens its albedo, or reflectivity, thereby allowing the oceans to absorb more heat from the sun. 
 On the other hand, global warming is likely to produce more precipitation over the icecaps, notably Antarctica's, which would mean that water was being taken out of the oceans and stored as ice. 
 Latest estimates are that sea levels could rise by about 20 cm by 2030 and by 65 cm by the end of the 21st century. 
 There will be significant regional variations. 
 (Sources : Association for the Conservation of Energy; report of Commonwealth group of experts on climate change; paper by Dr F. Kenneth Hare at 1988 Toronto conference on climate change; report of IPCC Scientific Assessment Group; paper by Dr J.T. Houghton of the Meteorological Office; and Dr Pier Vellinga, Director of the National Climate Change Programme, The Hague.) 
 The Ozone Layer 
 The ozone layer is in the stratosphere, the upper atmosphere, between 9 and 30 miles above the earth's surface. 
 It is formed when the sun's ultraviolet radiation breaks up the two atoms of oxygen molecules into single atoms. 
 These then combine with other oxygen molecules to form three-atom ozone molecules, resistant to ultraviolet radiation and able to absorb it. 
 Ultraviolet can cause skin cancers and cataracts (and probably other ailments) in humans and it is damaging to plants and marine life. 
 In &bquo;natural&equo; circumstances (before the introduction of CFCs and halons) the ozone layer was kept in balance through natural processes, including destructive gases released at ground level. 
 The production of harmful man-made gases tipped the balance against ozone. 
 Most ozone is generated above the equator, where the sun's radiation is strongest, and then carried by stratospheric winds around the earth towards the poles. 
 The depletion of the ozone layer was first noted over the Antarctic, and, more recently, over the Arctic. 
 Every year the world's industries have been producing more than one million tonnes of chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) and halons for use as refrigerator coolants, in the manufacture of foams, aerosol can propellants, solvents and fire extinguishers. 
 CFCs &mdash; the main problem &mdash; have been with us since the 1930s, a valued invention because they are non-toxic, non-flammable and cheaper to make than any known substitute. 
 Released, they rise very slowly (they can remain in the troposphere, or lower atmosphere, for 100 years) and intact to the stratosphere. 
 Once there, they are broken up by ultraviolet radiation, releasing chlorine atoms which destroy ozone, CFCs are also an important greenhouse gas (see above). 
 CFCs and Halons  
 The main CFC gases are: CFC-12 . 
 This is responsible for nearly half the ozone depletion. 
 It is used in refrigeration, air conditioning, aerosols and foams. 
 CFC-11 . 
 Foams, aerosols and refrigeration. 
 CFC-113 . 
 Solvents. 
 International co-operation on protecting the ozone layer has been good. 
 The Vienna Convention on its protection was negotiated in 1985 and followed in 1987 by the Montreal Protocol, which provides for the control of CFCs and halons. 
 The London conference in June 1990 agreed to tighten up the protocol and phase out production and consumption of CFCs by not later than the year 2000. 
 (Source : Introduction to the ozone layer issue, Saving the Ozone Layer Conference, London, March 1989.) 
 Detective Chief Inspector John McLeish gazed doubtfully at the plate before him. 
 Having thought he was hungry, he now realized that actually he needed anything rather than the overflowing plate of cholesterol the canteen at New Scotland Yard had provided with such admirable promptness. 
 Sleep would perhaps make more sense after thirty-six hours straight on duty, much of it spent with a sullen Jamaican who had killed his landlady and her three children in the crowded kitchen of a house behind the Westway. 
 He took an experimental mouthful of fried egg and waited to see if it was going to suit him, then progressed to the baked beans, cautiously. 
 He finished the egg, all the baked beans and one of the sausages, but decided the fried bread was tempting fate and pushed the plate aside, reaching for his cup of tea, resting both elbows on the table. 
 He lifted a hand off his cup in weary salute to one of his sergeants. a very dark Scot in a crumpled grey suit who was walking over from the counter, and the man altered course to sit opposite him. 
 &bquo;How goes it, Bruce?&equo; 
 Bruce Davidson had accompanied McLeish from his last posting to C1, that division of New Scotland Yard concerned exclusively with murder, and they had now worked together for four years in the CID. 
 &bquo;Got that Tottenham case weighed off, nae bother. 
 I hear you've finished the Westway job. 
 Ye need to get your head down, John, you're looking rough.&equo; 
 McLeish nodded. 
 He had glanced in the washroom  mirror and it had not been a reassuring sight. 
 A big man, six foot four inches in his socks and a good fourteen stone, he always looked mildly untidy, and this morning, having worn the same clothes for a day and a half he looked like a football supporter after a night in the cells. 
 At thirty-two, he was young enough not to look completely haggard, even after thirty-six hours with only the odd hour's sleep, but his dark hair was plastered to his head and the brown eyes were sunk back in his head and reddened with smoke and exhaustion. 
 &bquo;I'm going off. 
 You too?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm waiting for Catherine &mdash; Sergeant Crane.&equo; 
 Even falling asleep as he was, McLeish was amused at Bruce Davidson's hopeful, proprietorial air. 
 Catherine Crane had joined the division three months ago, creating a major upheaval. 
 She was a slight young woman of twenty-seven, whose dazzling, delicate, blond looks concealed a ferocious intelligence and attack. 
 Every man in her vicinity had found himself putting his best foot forward, and she had done wonders for the sartorial standards of the notoriously uncaring C1 division. 
 McLeish himself, though admiring, had been unaffected; he had been in love for over a year with a young woman only a little older, and even cleverer, than Sergeant Crane. 
 His Francesca was a rising star in the Department of Trade and Industry, and they planned to celebrate her thirtieth birthday with a skiing holiday, due to start in two weeks' time. 
 He smiled on Davidson, cheered immeasurably by the thought of getting on a plane with Francesca. 
 After chatting to Davidson for a few minutes longer, he went back to his office. 
 looking for his secretary, a plumpish, infinitely competent, middle-aged mother of three. 
 She was on the phone and he stood silently, filling the doorway, raising an eyebrow at her. 
 She motioned him to stay. 
 &bquo;It's Francesca, John.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thanks, Jenny. 
 I'll take it back there,&equo; he said, brightening, and she watched, with a little jealousy. 
 as he hurried back to his desk.  
 &bquo;Darling. 
 I've got a horrendous problem. 
 Can you possibly duck out and have coffee in the caff in ten minutes?&equo; 
 The voice at the other end was slightly husky but very clear. 
 &bquo;It's Tristram. 
 He's been arrested in New York. 
 Better not talk on the phone, had we?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Christ. 
 No. 
 I'll meet you.&equo; 
 He put down the phone, rattled. 
 With his much-loved Francesca came her four younger brothers for whom, as the eldest child of a widow, she had always considered herself responsible. 
 All four were talented musicians and difficult people, in varying degrees; Tristram. 
 one of the twenty-four-year-old twins, had proved the most difficult, perhaps because he was not the most talented. 
 McLeish gritted his teeth, and, trying not to consider the implications of what he had been told. 
 made one quick phone call, then took the lift down and walked across the road from New Scotland Yard to the little caf&eacute; which was, as usual, full of workmen engaged in rebuilding the offices in the area. 
 Stopping to buy a paper, he caught sight of Francesca through the window, perched on one of the bar stools, totally unconscious of the table full of men next to her all eyeing her long legs. 
 He stood and watched her, putting off the moment when. 
 as he half knew, he would be asked to acquiesce in some lunatic scheme for pulling Tristram out of trouble, and saw her for a moment from a position of detachment: a tall young woman looking younger than her twenty-nine years. 
 dark, with a long straight nose and arched eyebrows. 
 She was looking particularly uncompromising today, tired and pale, her dark, short hair spiking up at the back. 
 She had been crying, McLeish observed resignedly, as he pushed through the door. 
 &bquo;All right, tell me,&equo; he said, as he sat down heavily beside her, and got a careful, measuring. 
 sidelong look. 
 &bquo;I have to go to New York in a hurry and bail Tristram out. 
 He was arrested last night, with one of the backing group and three of the band. 
 They're all in the nick. 
 charged with possession. 
 Cocaine, as I understand it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Jesus.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know, I know, just when he was beginning to be a  success like Perry. 
 It simply went to his head &mdash; you know what he was like when he left.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thought he could walk on water,&equo; McLeish said, in irritated memory. 
 &bquo;Frannie, why do you  have to go? 
 He has a manager and a studio, doesn't he? 
 What can you do that they can't?&equo; 
 She sighed so heavily that her whole ribcage moved. 
 &bquo;I am to some extent on home ground there,&equo; she said, reluctantly and not looking at him. 
 &bquo;Mike &mdash; Michael O'Brien &mdash; will help, but I need to be on the spot.&equo; 
 McLeish held on to his temper, reminding himself that he was very tired. 
 Francesca's much publicized affair with Senator Michael O'Brien was the reason that she had been sent home rather early from a tour of duty in the Embassy in Washington, over a year previously, just before he had met her in London. 
 As one of Francesca's DTI colleagues had maliciously observed, it had been felt that fraternization with the American colleagues could be carried too far. 
 Francesca herself had characteristically taken the line that the Foreign Office ought to have been glad that someone on the staff was that closely involved with the American political Establishment. 
 &bquo;What are you going to do with O'Brien?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I'm hardly going to get back into bed with him after more than a whole year. 
 There'll certainly be another incumbent by now. 
 But he is the senior Senator. 
 we were close when I was in Washington, and whichever way you slice it he won't want my brother being buggered or beaten up in a New York jail.&equo; 
 Her classically good diction always became even clearer under stress, so that this statement emerged with the slightly metallic clarity of a dubbed film, and the client&egrave;le of the small caf&eacute; was obviously appreciating every moment. 
 McLeish decided that since she was unaware of her audience it did not become him to be selfconscious, and asked what she expected even a Senator to achieve in these circumstances? 
 &bquo;Oh. 
 darling. 
 The American legal system is so odd that I've been told I could get Tristram deported in my custody. 
 It's a disaster, of course it &bquo;s a disaster, he'll be banned from  the US for ever presumably; but at least he won't be being interfered with in some unspeakable foreign nick.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought he was off drugs?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well we all hoped, didn't we? 
 But evidently he isn't, and I must get him back.&equo; 
 McLeish found himself on the verge of suggesting that a thoroughly unpleasant time in a New York jail might succeed in curing Tristram where all other methods, including exhortation, loving family support and a spell in a comfortable private hospital in Devon, had failed. 
 He looked at his love's shuttered, miserable face and realized he would get nowhere along those lines. 
 &bquo;Why can't your Mum or one of the boys go?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mum is in bed with bronchitis, as you would know if you had managed to get out of that place since last Friday.&equo; 
 Francesca, a true eldest child, knew how to score her points. 
 &bquo;Charlie's baby is due tomorrow, Perry is in Japan on tour, just like all the papers say. 
 Jeremy is coming with me but he is too young to do this alone, and in any case I'm the only one who can deploy O'Brien.&equo; 
 &bquo;How is the DTI receiving all this? 
 You've got four rescue cases.&equo; 
 Francesca sighed. 
 &bquo;They are as fed up with me as you are, but they won't stop me taking leave.&equo; 
 She stopped sharply, and blushed scarlet. 
 &bquo;Wait a minute.&equo; 
 John McLeish felt his blood-pressure going up. 
 &bquo;What about skiing, if you're using leave?&equo; 
 She looked at him, wretchedly. 
 &bquo;I have  to go. 
 I really expect to get back in three or four days and I will try and hang on to the holiday. 
 I know we need it, it seems ages since we went to bed.&equo; 
 McLeish scowled round the fascinated audience, returning the customers to their egg and chips. 
 &bquo;Anyway, it's been you who have been too busy for months.&equo; 
 McLeish was too honest not to acknowledge the point. 
 &bquo;The more important, then, for us to have a holiday together.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know. 
 Darling, I am sorry, I really expect to be back inside the week, and I wouldn't go if anyone else could. 
 I am trying &mdash; I mean I know I let the boys lean too much.&equo;  
 He looked at her, defeated, and she saw that she had carried the point, but at a heavy cost. 
 &bquo;Do you still love me?&equo; she asked anxiously. 
 &bquo;Not at the moment.&equo; 
 An indrawn breath from the spectators unsettled both of them for a moment. 
 Francesca nearly laughed, but McLeish's expression sobered her. 
 &bquo;Let's get out of here.&equo; 
 She slid obediently off the bar stool, bidding a civil good-morning to the caf&eacute; owner who looked, McLeish observed, as if he would willingly have swept her into his plump Italian embrace, and they walked together to the gates of New Scotland Yard. 
 &bquo;I'll ring you when I get to New York.&equo; 
 She looked, worried, at his profile. 
 &bquo;You're furious with me. 
 I'm sorry. 
 I love you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't think we can go on like this.&equo; 
 McLeish surprised himself as well as her. 
 &bquo;John.&equo; 
 It was an appeal and he was not proof against it. 
 He bent and kissed her. 
 &bquo;I am furious, and I want you back quickly. 
 But good luck with it &mdash; ring me if you need help.&equo; 
 The look she flicked him reminded him that this was one area where she would not appeal for his help; she had been more than careful to protect him from any involvement with a drug-taking brother. 
 It was one of her many advantages that as a professional civil servant herself she understood the constraints of his career. 
 She turned to go, head down. 
 McLeish saw that she was crying again, but decided coldly there was nothing he was going to do and trudged wearily back to the lift, the morning's cheerfulness totally evaporated. 
 &bquo;I'm so sorry, Miss Morgan isn't in today. 
 Would you like to speak to her assistant?&equo; 
 The receptionist, like everything else in the glass-walled hall, was immaculately clean, glossy, highly fashionable and faintly reminiscent of an Italian restaurant. 
 The young woman in the plain suit was not intimidated by it, nor by  the hand-carved plate that proclaimed her to be in the offices of Yeo, Davis and Partners. 
 &bquo;But I'm having lunch with her,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;It was arranged some time ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you'll just wait a minute, I'll ask someone to come and talk to you.&equo; 
 The immaculate receptionist's manner was fraying a little, discomfort with the situation showing like the edge of a petticoat. 
 She looked across the hall and visibly relaxed as she saw a man moving swiftly down the staircase. 
 &bquo;Peter!&equo; 
 The man altered course impatiently to deal with the interruption; just under six foot, he looked smaller because of the width of the powerful sloping shoulders which even good tailoring could do little to minimize. 
 He looked sharply at the receptionist in enquiry, suppressed energy in his every movement. 
 &bquo;This is Miss Huntley who was supposed to be having lunch with Angela today.&equo; 
 The tall young woman blinked as the man turned the full power of his attention on her. 
 &bquo;Have you talked to Angela this week?&equo; 
 She stared at him. 
 &bquo;Well, no,&equo; she said, &bquo;but there was no need &mdash; I mean we had fixed up lunch last week. 
 Is she not here?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 No she isn't, I'm afraid. 
 I'm very sorry she didn't let you know.&equo; 
 He was clearly preoccupied but Miss Huntley was not willing to let him go. 
 &bquo;You're her boss?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm the senior partner, yes. 
 Peter Yeo.&equo; 
 She had his attention back, and noticed how good-looking he was with those bright blue eyes and brown skin against the black hair. 
 Rather heavy in the neck, but an attractive man. 
 He looked back thoughtfully at her, taking in the brown eyes, the long, none-too-clean hair, and the patchy make-up through which broken veins in the cheeks were showing. 
 Late twenties perhaps, but didn't make much of an effort. 
 &bquo;So how do I get hold of her?&equo; the woman enquired, fretfully, voice rising out of control.  
 &bquo;Perhaps we should talk somewhere less public?&equo; he suggested, and showed her hastily into his office. 
 &bquo;What has happened to Angela, then?&equo; 
 Miss Huntley asked anxiously, and he decided to make the best of a bad job. 
 &bquo;She hasn't been in at all this week.&equo; 
 &bquo;And it is now Thursday. 
 But she's very high up here, isn't she?&equo; 
 He blinked. 
 &bquo;She's a partner, yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;You must have talked to her family?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I waited a couple of days. 
 Then I talked to everyone. 
 Her fianc&eacute; has now reported her as a missing person, I believe.&equo; 
 &bquo;Giles Hawick? 
 The Minister?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Sorry&hellip; but were you&hellip; are you close to her?&equo; 
 &bquo;My uncle used to employ her. 
 William Coombes. 
 I do know her quite well.&equo; 
 She sounded indignant and resentful, and he slowed up deliberately. 
 &bquo;Ah. 
 I have heard her speak of him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 He died two years ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;I had remembered.&equo; 
 He was pouring coffee and she watched his thick, well-manicured hands. 
 &bquo;I need to see her.&equo; 
 Both of them were taken aback by the force with which she said it and she blushed red. 
 &bquo;I don't know where she is!&equo; he admitted, reluctantly. 
 &bquo;I was disappointed when I found you didn't either. 
 Oh, darling, hello, do come in.&equo; 
 Since he now sounded flustered, Penelope Huntley looked with interest at the intruder: a good-looking, slightly overweight woman probably in her early forties, carefully dressed but uncertain. 
 &bquo;Darling, this is Miss Huntley, who was expecting to lunch with Angela today. 
 Miss Huntley, my wife, Claudia Yeo. 
 I've just been explaining that Angela seems to have gone missing.&equo; 
 &bquo;I think everyone is probably making far too much fuss, and Angela has just taken off for a few days' holiday.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo looked momentarily furiously exasperated. 
 &bquo;Giles Hawick is taking it seriously enough to have reported her as a missing person,&equo; he said tightly.  
 His wife gave him a long level look with no liking in it at all, and Penelope Huntley watched, fascinated. 
 &bquo;Are we lunching, Peter?&equo; 
 Peter Yeo jerked into action. 
 &bquo;Of course. 
 Look, Miss Huntley, I'm afraid we are rather preoccupied. 
 If you ring us tomorrow we may know more. 
 I'm so sorry she isn't here.&equo; 
 Penelope Huntley, who would very much have liked to have gone on with the discussion, found herself swept out of the office, and walked slowly down the road, flushed with a mixture of disappointment and excitement. 
 In New Scotland Yard John McLeish was trying, increasingly irritably, to clear his desk so he could go home. 
 Bruce Davidson was making a meal of explaining a straightforward case essentially because he was trying to impress Catherine Crane. 
 Not that he was succeeding; Sergeant Crane was sitting, legs crossed, only just not fidgeting, as Bruce Davidson wore on through a lot of unnecessary detail. 
 It was unprecedented for any woman to have that effect on Davidson, whose success in this field was legendary. 
 She was, of course, very desirable, McLeish conceded: reddish-blond hair above blue eyes, and a perfect, pale skin, lightly freckled. 
 Her apple-green light wool suit reminded them all that spring would one day come. 
 Indeed, she was a true beauty: straight, fine features, a long neck, a gently curved, slim figure. 
 He found himself smiling gently as he sat and watched her, and pulled himself up sharply, realizing that the girl was annoyed by what was obviously a familiar reaction. 
 He had looked at her papers three months ago, when the posting had been announced, and had noted how well educated she was. 
 She had joined the Met with three A levels and a huge number of O levels as an eighteen-year-old, then worked her way over into the CID, and was now a Detective Sergeant and ready to move up, having passed the exams for Inspector. 
 His phone rang and he picked it up, reluctantly.  
 &bquo;John, sorry to interrupt. 
 Commander Stevenson wants you, now.&equo; 
 I'll come. 
 Excuse me, both of you.&equo; 
 Catherine and Davidson were left in his office to carry on the conversation, and while Davidson was finding her some more coffee, Catherine turned the photograph on John McLeish's desk to look at it. 
 &bquo;Is she his wife?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no, that's Francesca. 
 They're not married.&equo; 
 &bquo;His fianc&eacute;e?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 No, I don't think you could say they were engaged. 
 They've been together, oh, for over a year.&equo; 
 Davidson reviewed this explanation. 
 &bquo;They don't live together &mdash; I mean not in the same place,&equo; he added conscientiously. 
 &bquo;She was married before.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about him? 
 McLeish?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, he's not been married.&equo; 
 He gazed at her, earnestly. 
 &bquo;Fancy some lunch?&equo; 
 Catherine Crane smiled back. 
 &bquo;Bit early for me.&equo; 
 Davidson, taken aback, glanced at his watch. 
 Twenty past eleven. 
 &bquo;Bit early for me too, sorry.&equo; 
 He stopped, uncharacteristically gravelled, got a quick entirely comradely look of amusement, and laughed. 
 &bquo;Come on, let's get out of John's office, he'll likely be a while yet.&equo; 
 John McLeish, seated at the other side of a table from Commander Stevenson, would have agreed with this judgement. 
 Despite the urgency of the summons, he had been kept waiting in Stevenson's outer office long enough to read the early edition of the Evening Standard . 
 On page four, as he had feared, was a bad picture of Tristram under the headline &bquo;Singing star on US Drugs Charge&equo;. 
 He skimmed the accompanying text, which added little to what Francesca had already told him, filling up the two columns with a recital of Tristram's career beginning with his legendary recording of &bquo;Panis Angelicus&equo; as a thirteen-year-old treble at St Joe's. 
 As usual, much was made of the fact that he was younger brother to the wildly successful  Peregrine, now in Japan on tour with his group. 
 Indeed McLeish reflected, that encapsulated the trouble with Tristram &mdash; everything that he could do, Perry, two years his senior, could apparently do just that bit better. 
 &bquo;Come in John. 
 Sit down.&equo; 
 Stevenson, a quick-moving, stocky northerner with a distinguished record in every possible branch of the Met, was rumoured to be going up to Assistant Commissioner just as soon as the present incumbent retired. 
 &bquo;I take it that's one of your connections in bother,&equo; he observed, seeing the paper in McLeish's hand. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid so. 
 Francesca is on her way to New York.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what I asked her.&equo; 
 McLeish hoped he was not sounding as defeated as he felt. 
 &bquo;You'll need to be very careful, personally, in dealing with an addict.&equo; 
 McLeish sighed. 
 &bquo;They know that. 
 Francesca wouldn't have him in the house when she knew he was on something. 
 They hoped they'd got him detoxed. 
 She's got him booked in again at Cocaine Hall when she gets him back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Will she manage to get him out of the USA?&equo; 
 Stevenson sounded startled and McLeish said, wearily, that Francesca had good contacts. 
 Everywhere, he added sourly, thinking about it. 
 Stevenson considered him thoughtfully but decided there was little profit in going on. 
 &bquo;Not why I called you in. 
 We've got another one to look at. 
 Not necessarily for us yet, but we've been asked by Special Branch to take it on board. 
 Missing Person.&equo; 
 McLeish gazed at his superior. 
 Most missing person reports do not end in a murder. 
 Typically they are husbands or wives walking out to live somewhere else, or teenagers leaving home. 
 He kept what he hoped was a bright and intelligent expression on his face and waited for enlightenment. 
 &bquo;That's how I felt,&equo; Stevenson agreed. 
 &bquo;The problem is that the missing person was going to marry a junior Treasury Minister.&equo;  
 &bquo;It's a girl, then.&equo; 
 McLeish blinked and looked apologetically at his superior. 
 &bquo;How long have you been on duty, John?&equo; 
 &bquo;Thirty-six hours, sir. 
 Sorry, I'll wake up.&equo; 
 Stevenson considered him. 
 &bquo;You'll have to, you're all I've got at your rank. 
 Go home, get a couple of hours' sleep, clean up and get back here. 
 You're seeing Mr Hawick &mdash; who is Financial Secretary to the Treasury and has reported his fianc&eacute;e, a Miss Angela Morgan, as missing. 
 You're due at four-thirty at his office at the House of Commons after Treasury Questions, whatever they are. 
 I'll send a driver for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sir.&equo; 
 McLeish knew what Treasury Questions were, thanks to Francesca. 
 Every afternoon in the House of Commons MPs could raise questions with Ministers about their Departments. 
 These had to be answered, and answered well &mdash; or at least the first ten or so did &mdash; because the original questioner and other MPs were allowed to ask supplementary questions. 
 Once you got down to Question 11, the questioner would get a deeply unhelpful written response which would, if the civil servants knew their business, leave no one any the wiser. 
 Endearingly, Francesca herself was not good at drafting that sort of answer and usually had to enlist a more senior colleague to achieve the correct polished hand-off. 
 And he knew that the Financial Secretary was the junior of three Treasury Ministers and did not sit in the Cabinet. 
 &bquo;Do you want me to talk to Special Branch, sir?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've done that. 
 Take a sergeant with you, assuming there is such a thing left in the building.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, we got a replacement for Jameson&hellip; what?&hellip; three months ago. 
 I've not yet worked with her personally, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ms Crane? 
 I've seen her.&equo; 
 Stevenson's clean-shaven, tight-mouthed face relaxed in a ferocious grin. 
 &bquo;Wouldn't mind working with her personally, myself. 
 Yes, take her &mdash; I'll check with Hawick's office that it's all right if you come mob-handed, but I've a feeling in my water about this one. 
 I'd like to have a proper team together right from the start.&equo; 
 &bquo;I &bquo;ll tell her, sir.&equo;  
 &bquo;Then get home for a couple of hours. 
 Best suit to go and see Mr Hawick.&equo; 
 John McLeish rose to go but was recalled as he reached the door. 
 &bquo;Anything we can do to help with young Wilson? 
 I could ring up a colleague in New York.&equo; 
 &bquo;She'd rather fix it herself if she can, sir, I do know that. 
 But thank you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Better for us to be involved than you personally, John.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know that, sir. 
 Thank you.&equo; 
 He walked into the corridor, tiredness suddenly overcoming him with the prospect of a few hours off, and very nearly knocked Catherine Crane over in his preoccupation. 
 He caught her elbow to steady her. 
 &bquo;Sorry, not looking where I'm going. 
 I'm off home for the morning, but you're wanted to come with me to see a VIP about a missing person. 
 Walk along and I'll tell you about it.&equo; 
 He told her everything he knew, and made sure she understood where to be and at what time, talking with the speed of true exhaustion and repeating himself. 
 He stopped, realizing what he was doing, and looked at her carefully to see if she had taken it in. 
 She looked back at him and smiled gently, and he saw that she had been writing in a workman-like leather-bound notebook. 
 &bquo;Yes, sir. 
 Got it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don &bquo;t call me sir,&equo; he said sharply. 
 &bquo;Everyone calls me John,&equo; he added mendaciously. 
 Her smile widened, and she nodded, pleased but unsurprised. 
 He rested his eyes on her, very conscious of the smooth skin and her flowery perfume. 
 Gathering himself, he dismissed her and went down to the waiting car. 
 Four miles away, Francesca had already reached her own small Victorian house and was moving clothes from the dryer straight into a battered suitcase. 
 &bquo;Six pairs of knickers must be enough, mustn't it, Charlie?&equo; she enquired of a tall dark-blond young man, unmistakably her brother, who was piling plates into a dishwasher and making two cups of coffee.  
 &bquo;Heap good laundries in New York, darling. 
 How was John?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh God. 
 Furious. 
 And miserable. 
 I felt awful.&equo; 
 Charlie emerged from the kitchen and handed her a cup. 
 &bquo;I really am sorry. 
 I would go instead of you but I can't, can I, with Mum sick and the baby due any day?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, Charlie, of course you can &bquo;t, we've been through that. 
 And Jeremy can't manage on his own, he's just too young. 
 It does have to be me.&equo; 
 Her brother watched her, with love and anxiety, as she checked the contents of her handbag. 
 &bquo;Weren't you and John going skiing soon?&equo; 
 &bquo;We were. 
 We are. 
 We have to get a week together. 
 He's been so busy catching murderers we've hardly seen each other for three weeks. 
 He never stops working.&equo; 
 &bquo;You need to marry him. 
 He loves you, he's a good bloke, you've been together for over a year. 
 He's going up the ladder like a rocket, isn't he? 
 He doesn't have time for all this.&equo; 
 Charlie watched Francesca's vivid face go wooden as she counted currency. 
 &bquo;He does still want to marry you, I take it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes.&equo; 
 She spoke with dismissive confidence. 
 &bquo;It's always been me who said no.&equo; 
 Her brother, closing her suitcase for her, regarded her with exasperation. 
 &bquo;You're nearly thirty. 
 It &bquo;s time you settled down and had children.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've been reading Jane's magazines again.&equo; 
 Francesca silenced him, as she had meant to; his wife Jane, unlike his academically gifted sister, had done the domestic science course at her school. 
 He jerked her case upright, tight-lipped, and put it by the door for her, but relaxed in exasperated pity as he watched her start to check her handbag for the third time. 
 &bquo;I suppose we are right to send you and Jeremy out to get Tristram rather than leave him to take the full consequences?&equo; he said reflectively, as he loaded her and her possessions into his car and took the wheel. 
 &bquo;I couldn't possibly not go,&equo; Francesca said, pushing a cassette-tape into the car recorder. 
 &bquo;It's Tris's demo-tape,&equo; she said in explanation, and both listened, cut off in  concentration, as a pure high tenor, singing &bquo;Plaisirs d'Amour&equo; filled the car. 
 &bquo;Listen to that top A. Better range than Perry, you know,&equo; Francesca said, softly. 
 &bquo;Doesn't project like Perry does.&equo; 
 Charlie started quietly to sing with the tape, and his sister joined him, both stretching for the top notes. 
 They looked at each other and laughed as they went for the top A and each found that no noise came out at all. 
 &bquo;I always think it's very nice of you not to mind being a baritone rather than a tenor, Charlie. 
 I would give my eyeteeth to be a soprano, and to be able to get that high.&equo; 
 &bquo;Or even higher. 
 Tris has a reliable top C, which is more than Perry does.&equo; 
 They fell silent, listening as the tape finished. 
 &bquo;He spits his final consonants out as if he were still at St Joe's,&equo; Francesca observed with love and Charlie sighed. 
 &bquo;All right. 
 You go and get Tristram out of durance vile, helped or handicapped by Jeremy &mdash; for the sake of his talent, if nothing else. 
 And let's just hope your life is where you left it when you come back.&equo; 
 McLeish and Catherine Crane were expected and escorted quickly to the Minister's Private Office. 
 McLeish knew roughly what it would be like from Francesca's description of her own Department, but he was still interested in the controlled bustle in the big untidy room. 
 The Private Secretary, a dark, stocky man a couple of years McLeish's junior, greeted him, observing cautiously that they had surely met at Francesca Wilson's house? 
 He then did a double-take at the sight of Catherine Crane, who had been the object of the most careful attention from everyone else in the room from the minute she had arrived. 
 &bquo;The Minister is just finishing a phone call, then I must tell him one thing before he sees you,&equo; he said, briskly, glancing at the miniature switchboard beside him which  sat incongruously in the draughty, high-ceilinged, dingy room. 
 A light flicked off, and he knocked and disappeared into his master's office, leaving McLeish and Catherine by his desk. 
 A dazzled junior seized the opportunity to press tea on them both, his eyes never leaving Catherine, and McLeish, amused, accepted a cup. 
 &bquo; The Treasury exists to stand in front of the safe, shouting &bquo;Go away!&equo; and making threatening gestures at any Department who comes near it or them ,&equo; he remembered Francesca's clear, amused voice explaining the system. 
 &bquo; But in the end they get pushed over; they just manage to delay the bigger-spending Departments a bit, And they pop up again, good as new, the next time, like a row of skittles .&equo; 
 The Private Secretary &mdash; Michael Marsden, he remembered with an effort &mdash; signalled them from the door and McLeish moved forward, keen to see what the kingpin of this row of skittles looked like. 
 His first thought, as he shook the hand of the distinctive dark man almost as tall as himself, was that Francesca must have got it wrong this time. 
 Giles Hawick was not the sort of man you could flatten easily, and if you managed it, he would not pop up, bright, smiling and bearing no grudge, to face you the next ti me. 
 If you injured this one, it would be as well to kill him before he killed you. 
 McLeish stepped back, surprised at the force of his reaction, and introduced Catherine Crane, watching Giles Hawick carefully. 
 The high, arched eyebrows in the long bony face rose slightly in surprise, but no more. 
 The immediate impression of directed dominance did not come from the man's physique, impressive though that was, McLeish decided as he accepted the offered chair and placed Catherine at the side of the room. 
 Giles Hawick was a beautifully put together man, something over six foot without a spare ounce of flesh anywhere, the long lines in the face being particularly strong. 
 Nor were the very deep-set dark brown eyes particularly hypnotic, as journalists occasionally suggested. 
 It was the controlled, economical force that emanated from the man that was impressive, and the speed with which he absorbed information. 
 In about two minutes he had established precisely which members of C1 he was dealing with and why.  
 John McLeish, himself a forceful character, felt as if he had been put through a wringer. 
 He waited, out of long experience with dominant characters, until a natural break occurred and used it to ask for some background, starting with how long the Minister had known Miss Morgan. 
 Giles Hawick, looking surprised, sat more easily in his chair and started to marshal his thoughts. 
 &bquo;I've known her a couple of years. 
 We met when she came with the chairman of one of the big contractors to lobby me about increasing the road-building programme, when I was a spokesman for Transport. 
 She was working for Yeo Davis, where she is a partner now. 
 A case of gamekeeper turned poacher, given that she had been a fast-stream entrant to the Treasury, much of whose function it is to resist that sort of demand.&equo; 
 Francesca might have it right after all, McLeish thought, enjoying the turn of phrase. 
 &bquo;I liked the look of Angela, and organized an introduction through a mutual acquaintance.&equo; 
 Not being prepared to be beholden to those who were lobbying you, McLeish observed, considering the formidable professional across the table. 
 &bquo;My first wife died some years ago, as you may know. 
 At the time I met her, Angela told me that she was involved with someone else. 
 Women make their own minds up about what they want to do, I find, so I left it; but about a year ago she invited me to a party and indicated that whoever it had been was no longer around. 
 I was very pleased, and we, well, we wasted no time. 
 We intend to marry in April, immediately after the House rises.&equo; 
 He stopped and stared out of the window, across Horse Guards', looking suddenly weary. 
 &bquo;Have you talked to her family?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not yet, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;They are very distressed. 
 There are only two children, both daughters. 
 Angela is the younger.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is there much difference in age?&equo; 
 &bquo;Four years. 
 Jennifer has not married yet. 
 She's a very attractive girl. 
 In fact I took her out a couple of times myself when I found that Angela was occupied with someone  else. 
 I get on well with them all, actually. 
 I think Francis Morgan feels I'm a bit old for Angela &mdash; I'm forty-three and she is twenty-nine &mdash; but he's never brought himself to say so. 
 And Sarah Morgan likes the idea of Angela marrying someone in the government.&equo; 
 McLeish considered this cold and rational assessment. 
 &bquo;When did you last see her? 
 Miss Angela Morgan, I mean.&equo; 
 &bquo;Early on Saturday morning &mdash; about eight-thirty. 
 I didn't expect to see her again until late on Monday &mdash; I went off to do some walking for the weekend and was taking an extra day. 
 I rang her on Monday night and got no answer, but that didn't worry me. 
 I was having lunch with her on Tuesday. 
 She didn't turn up, so of course I then telephoned her office and found she hadn't been there that week. 
 I rang her parents yesterday &mdash; Wednesday. 
 I hadn't wanted to worry them before. 
 Today I felt I could leave things no longer, so I had a word with a colleague in the Home Office. 
 Perhaps I should have done it before, but I suppose one's always afraid of making a fool of oneself.&equo; 
 McLeish decided it was unlikely that that sort of consideration very much exercised this cool customer. 
 &bquo;You had no idea where she might be?&equo; 
 &bquo;I would not have called you in if I had, would I? 
 Sorry, but I cannot imagine what has happened. 
 What has usually happened when people vanish?&equo; 
 McLeish took a minute to formulate his reply, and Giles Hawick got it at once. 
 &bquo;They've gone off with someone.&equo; 
 &bquo;They've mostly gone voluntarily, yes, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo; That's  what your boss was trying to indicate.&equo; 
 Giles Hawick looked down at his blotter, lips tight with tension. 
 &bquo;Angela is a very attractive woman and also very forthright. 
 If she'd wanted to go off with someone else, she would just have said so. 
 Please, Chief Inspector, put that out of your mind. 
 I want the police to look for her, not humour me. 
 Where do you start?&equo; 
 &bquo;With the hospitals and any reports of unidentified persons found dead.&equo; 
 McLeish decided there was no point tempering the wind to this competent and well-clad lamb. 
 &bquo;We'll also circulate her description, and if you have a good, recent photograph that would be very helpful.&equo;  
 &bquo;We'd just had some done for our engagement. 
 My Private Secretary will find them.&equo; 
 Giles Hawick suddenly looked tired and McLeish felt for him, as he promised to keep him in touch with their investigations. 
 Not much danger of his Commander letting him slip up on that, he thought drily. 
 They rose to go, Giles Hawick with the politician's automatic competence escorting them to the lift and warmly asking Catherine Crane where she had trained and how she liked her job. 
 He showed them into the lift, shaking hands with them both, and as Catherine turned away from him to press the lift button, he suddenly raised his eyebrows at McLeish in amusement at his own response to her. 
 &bquo;In what circumstances would an attractive woman of twenty-nine walk out on a fianc&eacute; without telling him or anyone else where she was going?&equo; 
 McLeish asked Catherine as they walked back through St James's Park. 
 &bquo;If she was frightened of him?&equo; 
 She sounded doubtful, but McLeish decided it would be possible to be frightened of Giles Hawick. 
 He had the look of a man with a nasty temper if you got on his wrong side. 
 &bquo;But presumably the Commander doesn't think she ran away? 
 I mean Special Branch has asked us to come in. 
 They all think something's happened to her, don't they?&equo; 
 She might sound diffident, McLeish thought, amused, but she wasn't, just more careful than his blunt Francesca about how she made her points. 
 &bquo;I agree. 
 I don't like the sound of it at all. 
 The best we could hope for is that she's had a brainstorm, and I don't know how often that happens outside of books. 
 Anyway, we need to get back and get the procedures into place.&equo; 
 All that took some five hours for very little result. 
 By ten p.m. 
 McLeish was reasonably satisfied that Angela Morgan was not lying unidentified in any morgue, nor in any hospital, unconscious or suffering from loss of memory. 
 Tomorrow he would have to talk to her family and last  known associates. 
 Remembering that he had sent Catherine Crane to see Angela Morgan's employers, he decided to find out how she had got on; late as it was he did not think she would have gone off duty without reporting to him. 
 He got half-way down the corridor and realized in irritation that he had no idea where she had been given an office. 
 That small problem solved itself readily: one door stood open with Bruce Davidson leaning on the side in a careful presentation of a man who had just happened to be passing. 
 He stood aside for McLeish, then took himself off, observing unnecessarily that he just had a wee bit paperwork to finish up. 
 Catherine Crane, installed behind her desk, gave him a slightly weary smile. 
 She looked, McLeish observed, as immaculate as she had in the morning, but she was pale and her eyes looked huge. 
 &bquo;I've got some useful stuff from Yeo Davis &mdash; that's Miss Morgan's employers, sir, I mean, John. 
 Her diary for last week and the week before. 
 She had a lot of appointments, particularly at lunch. 
 I've listed them.&equo; 
 He peered at the long list. 
 &bquo;What does she do?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeo Davis advise on government and parliamentary affairs.&equo; 
 &bquo;What does that mean they do?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mr Yeo did explain it, but I'm not quite sure I see it, even so. 
 He says they help companies to influence government decisions and legislation.&equo; 
 McLeish decided he didn't understand it either but he wasn't about to discourage Sergeant Crane. 
 &bquo;OK, let's have a look at the list. 
 Last Monday, appointment at the Ministry of Defence, lunch with Hugo Brett MP, afternoon date with Charles Council, drinks at the Reform. 
 Tuesday, more of the same, except she seems to have met Mr Hawick at the House of Commons after work. 
 Wednesday, she sees a chap who is one of the PM's advisers, or that's what it says &mdash; and what does she do for lunch? 
 Blow me, I don't believe it!&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;That Wednesday she had lunch with one F. Wilson, DTI. 
 That's one person I know where to find.&equo;  
 &bquo;Who is it?&equo; 
 &bquo;A girl called Francesca Wilson, who is doing work that involves rescuing dud companies which employ a lot of people in difficult areas.&equo; 
 He hesitated, not sure why he was being cautious. 
 &bquo;In fact, she's my girlfriend.&equo; 
 Catherine Crane smiled at him gently. 
 &bquo;Well, that is easy enough for you, isn't it? 
 Are you seeing her tonight?&equo; 
 McLeish scowled, reminded. 
 &bquo;No, she's in New York.&equo; 
 He glanced sideways at Catherine Crane's unchanged expression which showed merely courteous interest, and decided to sit down and talk. 
 &bquo;Francesca's got four brothers, see, two of them professional singers, two of them by the grace of God ordinary working stiffs in respectable offices.&equo; 
 He paused, trying to decide how to go on, noticing how dirty the walls of the small, dark office looked against Catherine Crane's neat, pale suit and bright blond hair. 
 &bquo;Is one of them Perry Wilson?&equo; she enquired, visibly impressed. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 He's OK. 
 Well, he's not, but he's not causing any difficulty just at the moment. 
 There are twins at the bottom of the family and it's Tristram who's in trouble. 
 Done for possession of Class A drugs in New York.&equo; 
 &bquo;That is difficult.&equo; 
 &bquo;And Francesca's there to try and get him out on bail.&equo; 
 &bquo;Doesn't he have a lawyer?&equo; 
 &bquo;Good question. 
 Fran's gone to make sure no one lays a finger on a brother, that's what it is. 
 They're like that.&equo; 
 He brooded for a moment, sighed, and reached for the list again. 
 &bquo;I'll be able to talk to her sooner or later, and it sounds as if she might actually be useful. 
 She'll at least be able to explain Yeo Davis to us. 
 Anything else on Miss Morgan?&equo; 
 Catherine Crane moved one tidy package of paper, neatly tabulated, in search of an equally tidy pile, and McLeish watched with pleasure. 
 Keeping the paperwork straight might not be glamorous but it was eighty per cent of the battle as he well knew, and he made certain his staff did too. 
 It didn't look as if that particular conversation was going to be necessary in this case. 
 &bquo;Sorry, here we are. 
 Mr Yeo sent us her CV &mdash; the one they send out to prospective  clients. 
 Only the basic facts, but useful. 
 And some spare copies of the photographs that came out from the DTI this afternoon &mdash; we ran off dozens to send out to the regional forces, but I snaffled six.&equo; 
 McLeish took the photographs and considered them. 
 A lively, arrogant face, rather square, eyes wide-set, and a full, curving mouth. 
 Dark brown hair, dark brown eyes, and slightly sallow skin which the photographer had not bothered to disguise or retouch, having understood that this was part of her charm. 
 Not a true beauty, but the girl beckoned you off the paper; confident, sexy, that face invited you to join in if you could stand the pace. 
 A handful, McLeish thought, but a lot of fun. 
 He reached for the CV while Catherine Crane busied herself systematically with her papers. 
 Same age as Francesca, and had attended the same good North London all-girls' grammar school, for entry to which aspiring parents would have been prepared to pay blood-money had there been anyone in the austere intellectual governing body and teaching staff who would have taken it. 
 They must have been the same year, for their birthdays were only two months apart. 
 Even among perhaps a hundred girls in their year, they must have known each other quite well. 
 Their ways had diverged at university &mdash; Angela Morgan had gone on to Oxford to read English, the fatherless Francesca, under more pressure to make a living, had gone to Cambridge to read law. 
 A clever girl, though, Miss Morgan, an Exhibitioner like Francesca and a respectable second-class degree. 
 He considered the arrogant, attractive, knowing face again and put the photo down, shifting his attention to Catherine's pale, classic beauty. 
 He was about to divide up responsibility for checking Angela Morgan's last recorded movements when Bruce Davidson knocked and put his head in. 
 &bquo;John. 
 It's Francesca, on the phone from New York, says will you hurry.&equo; 
 McLeish jogged down the passage, overcoming irritation. 
 Of course he had the sense to hurry when she was hanging on a line from New York. 
 &bquo;Talk more slowly,&equo; he said, in exasperation, after the  first few seconds. 
 She was sounding strained, and as always when she was over-extended she was being unnecessarily bossy. 
 Her sigh of exasperation reached him from 3,000 miles away. 
 &bquo;Sorry, but I've been at it all day.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, calm down. 
 I need to talk to you, too.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about?&equo; 
 Francesca sounded rattled and hostile, and McLeish gazed at the wall, wondering if he had really been in love with her for over a year. 
 &bquo;About someone called Angela Morgan whom you or another F. Wilson at the DTI had lunch with a couple of weeks ago. 
 She's been reported missing and we're checking her movements for the two weeks before she vanished.&equo; 
 A dead silence ensued and he shook the phone. 
 &bquo;Francesca?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorry, yes. 
 It was  me. 
 But why are you  doing this, John? 
 Do you think she's dead?&equo; 
 Well, at least Francesca's mind appeared to be functioning on a subject unconnected with her damned brothers, McLeish thought grimly. 
 &bquo;Not necessarily. 
 She was reported missing by her fianc&eacute;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Giles Hawick. 
 Does he  think she's dead?&equo; 
 &bquo;He hopes she is lying in hospital somewhere, having lost her memory.&equo; 
 &bquo;And she isn't?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not as of an hour ago, no.&equo; 
 &bquo;She's gone off with another bloke, bet you anything.&equo; 
 McLeish grinned at the telephone. 
 &bquo;I didn't think she was one of your mates. 
 But you were at school with her?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes I was, but we were never that close. 
 Different subjects for a start.&equo; 
 There was a pause while she gathered her thoughts and McLeish waited patiently. 
 &bquo;What do you know about her, John?&equo; 
 &bquo;Bugger all, at the moment. 
 I've got a photograph.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then you know quite a lot, if it is a good one. 
 Of all the women I know, she is by far the most successful with men, even though she isn't the best-looking. 
 She is the  original man-trap.&equo; 
 John McLeish blinked at the telephone. 
 Francesca's judgement was typically over-judicial and conscientiously unemotional, but this had real force behind it. 
 He had  never heard Francesca giving vent to feminine jealousy and on the whole he found the experience refreshing. 
 &bquo;You'd better explain to me what it is she does as a job. 
 Hang on &mdash; I'll ring you back, the Yard can pay this bill.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's all right, I'm in a mate's office.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I hope the Senator can afford it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sure he can.&equo; 
 A real advantage of his girl, McLeish thought grimly, was that she never lied if asked directly. 
 She might not volunteer the truth all the time, but ask her and you got a straight answer. 
 &bquo;Angela is a lobbyist.&equo; 
 Francesca made it sound like someone who came to clean the telephone. 
 &bquo;That's not what Yeo Davis call themselves &mdash; I think they use some phrase like &bquo;government and parliamentary relations&equo;. 
 They help clients to push the right buttons in government in the UK &mdash; and increasingly, of course, in the EEC. 
 It's a perfectly respectable trade,&equo; she added conscientiously. 
 &bquo;I don't mind  lobbyists, I'd just rather they called themselves by their proper name as they do in Washington, rather than wittering on for hours about relationships with opinion-formers. 
 Angela got up my nose as usual on this point over lunch, banging on about the importance of seeing that Ministers were properly informed and by the right people. 
 As if the Civil Service spent all its time obfuscating issues and introducing Ministers to the wrong people.&equo; 
 McLeish decided that it was probably not the moment to suggest to her that the real reason any civil servant disliked lobbyists must be that the chaps were paid to make sure Ministers got a view other than the Departmental one. 
 &bquo;Can you give me an example of what they do? 
 I mean, why was Miss Morgan having lunch with you, or was that just for old time's sake?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no, I now rank as an important contact, a senior opinion-former, or so she flatteringly told me. 
 It was quite a good example of lobbying, in fact. 
 It's widely known &mdash; because the unions have publicized it &mdash; that the Department is looking at bailing out Huerter Textiles. 
 Henry and I are doing it, as the resident textile rescue-squad. 
 You just haven't heard about it because you've been too busy.&equo;  
 Trust Francesca to get her points in while she could, McLeish thought irritably. 
 &bquo;And her firm is working for Huerter?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no, quite the contrary. 
 Her  firm, Yeo Davis, is working for Barton Mills, which is the other really big surviving textile company in the north-west. 
 Their chief executive, Andy Barton, feels, with some reason one would have to say, that it isn't right that the government should bail out a competitor. 
 The point is , darling, that in order to make sure Huerter has a future, we would have to put a lot of money in to restore a bombed-out balance sheet. 
 Barton has heavy borrowings too, and to put it crudely, if they're paying interest and Huerter isn't, Huerter ought to be able to undercut them in the market.&equo; 
 &bquo;So Miss Morgan was making sure you'd understood all that? 
 I see where it annoyed you.&equo; 
 Francesca was not amused. 
 &bquo;Yes, well, it is an offensively elementary consideration and one to which Ministers' attention had been drawn. 
 Yeo Davis seem to have felt, nonetheless, that it was worth a lunch.&equo; 
 She paused. 
 &bquo;I'd have to say that given the change of government they ought to have a very good chance of preventing us assisting Huerter. 
 I mean, this lot did come in, only six months ago, announcing that everyone would have to stand on their own feet and not be rescued, and face up to competition, and all that. 
 But whatever they said, as you know they haven't actually done any of it yet &mdash; they did rescue Fryers and  Towyn Metals, using tax-payers' money, just like they said they wouldn't. 
 Yeo Davis could have credibly warned Barton that, whatever the public statements, there was a real risk that Huerter would be bailed out.&equo; 
 McLeish considered this, &bquo;Are lobbyists well paid?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Not that Angela needed the money.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rich girl, is she?&equo; 
 &bquo;Very. 
 She didn't earn it in any conventional sense: her last employer left one third of his substantial fortune to her outright, and another third for life. 
 His family &mdash; a sister and niece as I remember &mdash; was awfully cross. 
 This was about two years ago.&equo; 
 McLeish told Francesca to hang on while he got this  down as a note, and stared at the result. 
 It made a good reason for those excluded to dislike Miss Morgan, but it had been true any time these past two years. 
 &bquo;When you had lunch, how was she? 
 I mean, it didn't sound as if she had plans to go off with someone else.&equo; 
 In the silence at the other end of the line he heard Francesca think. 
 &bquo;No, she didn't come over like that, not at all. 
 In fact, she was excited in an innocent way about the wedding plans. 
 Reception at the House, all very grand and smart. 
 And awfully good for her business, too.&equo; 
 McLeish smiled to himself at the swift fall from grace in the postscript. 
 Prodding gently, he got Francesca to run through the substance of the lunch-time conversation. 
 It was clear that Miss Morgan's brain had been fully engaged on what she was doing, which was pushing a client's interest, and that such attention as she could spare from that had been centred on her forthcoming marriage. 
 Nothing at all there, five days before her disappearance, to suggest she was planning to vanish. 
 Francesca's attention would have been undivided as well, as that lunch had taken place before Tristram had managed to get himself so comprehensively into trouble. 
 McLeish remembered abruptly Francesca's chief preoccupation. 
 &bquo;How are you getting on over there?&equo; he asked, cautiously. 
 &bquo;Much fixing is going on. 
 I'm basically just biting my fingernails and holding Tristram together. 
 He has been bailed on several sureties and appears in court tomorrow.&equo; 
 She was sounding terse and McLeish decided not to ask her any more details over the transatlantic phone. 
 &bquo;I've told them here I don't need the week after next off,&equo; he said, as levelly as he could. 
 &bquo;Oh, John.&equo; 
 She sounded appalled. 
 &bquo;I'd managed to hang on to it. 
 Why ever  did you do that?&equo; 
 &bquo;How was I supposed to know?&equo; he said, instantly aware that he had acted too hastily because he had been so angry with her. 
 &bquo;Well, I said I'd call you. 
 I ought to be home in three days and I've made a deal with Henry. 
 That was just plain bloody-minded of you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Coming from you, that's ridiculous!&equo; 
 A combination of  justified annoyance, guilt and weeks of overwork blew John McLeish's temper to shreds instantly, and Francesca, seriously over-stressed and not one to duck a quarrel at the best of times, responded in kind. 
 She banged the phone down a second before he did, leaving him raging. 
 Ten minutes later he had calmed down sufficiently to make himself a cup of coffee and write himself a note to check Angela Morgan's financial status. 
 He bethought himself guiltily of Sergeant Crane, who might be assumed to be waiting to continue the conversation that Francesca's call had interrupted, and padded down the corridor. 
 Her office was now marked by a frieze of officers, two lounging half in and half out of her door, a third a little behind, the attention of all three directed entirely towards her desk. 
 Two of the three moved off as he arrived, with unconvincing references to waiting papers, but Bruce Davidson stood his ground, enquiring heartily how Francesca was and had she been helpful? 
 McLeish considered him with something between amusement and irritation. 
 Bruce was pale with the deep pallor that overworked CID tend to acquire in London in the dead of winter, seriously overtired and overweight. 
 But he was alert and sparkling, his motor well and truly turned on by the presence of Catherine Crane, and he probably wasn't going to go home till he, or Catherine, dropped in their tracks. 
 &bquo;She was fine, and yes she was,&equo; he said, dealing with Bruce's formal question. 
 &bquo;And it'll all wait till the morning. 
 Go home, Bruce, or back to whatever your case is, and I'll have a word with Sergeant Crane.&equo; 
 He nodded decisively, and equally firmly walked into her office and closed the door on Davidson's hopeful face. 
 &bquo;Sorry, but that phone call was useful.&equo; 
 He ran, as dispassionately as he could, through Francesca's account of her lunch with Angela Morgan. 
 &bquo;So she probably didn't vanish voluntarily,&equo; Catherine Crane said, in summary. 
 &bquo;It doesn't sound like it.&equo; 
 He looked unseeingly at the beautiful face across the table, hearing the echo of his quarrel with Francesca, feeling his mind still chuntering on in justification of the anger that had led him to cut off all  possibility of their holiday next week. 
 Well, he had  been fed up, and why shouldn't he be? 
 He was fed up with the whole situation, and all Francesca's family. 
 &bquo;Sir &mdash; John, is there anything more tonight?&equo; 
 He came back smartly to the office and the desk on which he was leaning. 
 &bquo;No, sorry. 
 Have you eaten since lunch?&equo; 
 &bquo;A sandwich and lots of coffee which Sergeant Davidson brought. 
 I'm fine.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not. 
 I'm going to get something at the pub on my way home. 
 Come with me?&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you, I'd like to.&equo; 
 She smiled at him and he smiled back, cheered by the thought of a drink and something to eat in her company. 
 He collected her as soon as they had both tidied their offices, McLeish maliciously enjoying Davidson's obvious chagrin as they said good-night to him on the way out. 
 &bquo;A good man, that,&equo; he said, guiltily, to Catherine as they went down in the lift. 
 &bquo;One of the best. 
 I want to get him up to Inspector as soon as possible.&equo; 
 &bquo;He has been very helpful.&equo; 
 McLeish repressed a grin and bustled into the big noisy pub on the corner, receiving an instant acknowledgement from one of the bartenders, who all knew any member of the C1 hierarchy. 
 McLeish carried over a loaded tray, and ate ravenously, noting with interest that Catherine Crane had an equally good appetite, though it was not obvious where she was putting it on that slim frame. 
 She caught his eye and laughed. 
 &bquo;I have to eat about five times a day, or I just stop in my tracks.&equo; 
 She licked her fingers and applied herself to her beer. 
 Like Francesca, McLeish thought, and irritably suppressed the reflection. 
 &bquo;Tell me about you. 
 Did you do all your time in the Met, or did you start up north?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I came straight to the Met from school at eighteen.&equo; 
 Left home as soon as she could, McLeish observed, instead of starting where she could work from home. 
 &bquo;Do you still have family in wherever it is &mdash; Stoke on Trent?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, they're still there.&equo; 
 She was looking wooden, and McLeish decided to move off this point, but she forestalled  him. 
 &bquo;It's my stepfather and mother and four half-brothers and sisters. 
 My dad was killed at work when I was three.&equo; 
 Doesn't get on with stepfather, McLeish noted mentally, listening to the colour in her voice. 
 &bquo;Where are you living now?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've just bought a flat.&equo; 
 McLeish asked whereabouts and discovered it was three roads away from his own flat, so they complained enjoyably to each other about the local council. 
 &bquo;You were a graduate entry, weren't you?&equo; she asked as this conversation ran out, &bquo;and in the Flying Squad?&equo; 
 McLeish, warmed by the fact that she had taken the trouble to find out a bit about him, confirmed he had been at Reading University and had worked as a young sergeant in the Flying Squad. 
 &bquo;I always heard graduates weren't welcome there?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right. 
 The guv'nor there, when he was offered me, wanted quite seriously to know what use I would be. 
 It's changing now. 
 But they took me in then because one of my mates in the London Scottish was in the Squad. 
 They gave me a bad time &mdash; they'd all been in since they were seventeen and they were hard men. 
 But I got by on brute force and ignorance till I learnt a bit.&equo; 
 She gave him a quick amused glance, her head leaning back against the faded red of the alcove seat. 
 &bquo;The man who brought you in to the Squad must have been Alan Jones. 
 He was my guv'nor in Tottenham and he said you were all right.&equo; 
 McLeish beamed at her, more than pleased with this recommendation. 
 &bquo;How is old Alan?&equo; 
 She settled down to tell him how old Alan was while he leant forward, listening with pleasure to the slightly nasal accent of Stoke on Trent. 
 Her judgement of Alan Jones was both admiring and shrewd, and he asked about her own education, becoming aware that at least four other men were listening with great interest and that Catherine Crane was so used to this that she was unconscious of it. 
 &bquo;I came in with three A levels,&equo; she said, matter of factly. 
 &bquo;I was at Queen Eleanor's and they urged me to go to  university, but I wanted to be independent, so I came into the Met.&equo; 
 McLeish nodded, his impression of family difficulty confirmed. 
 &bquo;What were your grades?&equo; 
 &bquo;Three As. 
 English, history and economics.&equo; 
 &bquo;Better grades than mine,&equo; McLeish said, impressed. 
 &bquo;Do the lads get at you, too?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, a bit.&equo; 
 She laughed at him, the pretty mouth opening to reveal small, even teeth. 
 &bquo;But I don't have a posh set of in-laws like you do.&equo; 
 McLeish, more sharply than he had meant, pointed out that he had a girlfriend but not a wife. 
 &bquo;This is a good pub,&equo; she said, hastily, obviously aware of having trespassed, her gaze passing over the heavy plush seating and lighting on one of the barmen who was openly resting his eyes on her as he polished glasses. 
 &bquo;We use it a lot.&equo; 
 He followed her gaze and the barman lifted his right hand in a drink-pouring gesture, nodding at the same time towards the clock which showed five minutes to eleven. 
 McLeish indicated equally economically that no more drinks would be required. 
 &bquo;I've got my car in. 
 Would you like a ride home?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;If it's not out of your way,&equo; she said, serenely, knowing that it wasn't, and McLeish got to his feet, savouring self-consciously the sensation of being whole-heartedly envied by the surrounding male drinkers. 
 He drove her sedately home. 
 Getting out to open the passenger door for her, he noticed that, in contrast to Francesca, she expected this and accepted the courtesy gratefully. 
 &bquo;I'll wait while you let yourself in,&equo; he said, in an attempt at sounding policeman-like, and she smiled at him. 
 &bquo;Thanks. 
 And thanks for the ride.&equo; 
 She had her key ready and he looked down at her for a minute. 
 She looked back, her eyes wide, and he found himself holding his breath. 
 &bquo;Good-night, John,&equo; she said, demurely, and walked up her front steps, turning to wave to him from inside the house.  
 The boy and the dog skirted round opposite sides of the puddle, the boy, a light, tall fourteen-year-old, labouring in wellington boots too large for him, and the dog, a three-year-old Labrador bitch, picking her way reluctantly, with frequent pauses, as if her paws hurt. 
 The boy, unlike the dog, knew that the mud did not go on for ever; beyond the bridge, the disused railway embankment along which they were walking became built up, so that water ran off it. 
 He pulled the dog close to him to let a mixed string of horses and Ponies go past, waving shyly to the lead rider, a pretty, capable girl an unbridgeable two years older than him. 
 He watched her as she went past at a walk, the black Labrador and he both gazing wistfully, their breath steaming in the cold February morning. 
 He waited till the horses were well away and looked round the wide, flat landscape carefully before unclipping the lead. 
 &bquo;Way you go, Patty,&equo; he said softly, and the dog was off, hurling herself along the embankment, all paws and flying ears, after a rabbit who had been sitting in a patch of sun but disappeared with contemptuous ease as she came close. 
 The boy had been told unequivocally not to let her off the lead &mdash; the riding-school only used the land by grace of its owner and it was a shooting estate &mdash; but he hated keeping the dog straining at the lead and knew that she would always come to his call. 
 He stood for a moment laughing at her as she cast furiously for the vanished rabbit, and walked on, to catch her up, along the raised embankment. 
 The trees had grown up beside it in the twenty-five years since the railway had closed, and the boy stopped every now and then to watch small birds hopping around the top branches. 
 He particularly liked this stretch; nothing but the odd tractor and the horses ever came down this embankment, and the birds were unworried by his presence.  
 After half a mile he decided to turn off the embankment and walk up the side of the next field and along the path at the top of it, following the horses whom he could still see in the distance. 
 He called Patty to him. 
 She didn't come, which was surprising; she was a docile creature and particularly devoted to him because he always took her for a walk when he was at the stables. 
 He could hear her barking and looked down over the steep side of the embankment to the bottom of the trees. 
 He called her again and again, but she would not stop barking at something he could not see. 
 Probably a squirrel, he decided, and slithered down the side of the embankment to join her, scolding as he went. 
 Straightening up beside the dog, he looked where she was looking, and blinked. 
 He saw a leg, uncomfortably wedged between sapling trees, swollen grotesquely, and gazed at it, stupidly, wondering if it was plastic. 
 As his eyes focused he realized he was looking at a hideously swollen human body, and just then, as the light breeze shifted, he caught the stomach-turning odour of decay. 
 He was a sensible and capable boy, an eldest child, so he moved closer, trying not to breathe, and stood steadfastly looking until he was confident of what he had seen: a body, must be a girl because it was wearing a skirt, lying face down, head towards the bottom of the embankment as if she had dived off the top. 
 He clipped the lead on to the dog with cold hands which would hardly function, and let her pull him up the slope as fast as he could make his legs move. 
 He stopped on the embankment, shaking with cold and shock, to note the spot, then fled along the tractor paths, the dog running with him, to the stables where the ten o'clock children's ride was in its closing stages. 
 &bquo;Miss Williams!&equo; 
 &bquo;Jamie, I'm teaching.&equo; 
 The thin, capable woman who was taking the riding-class looked at him in amazement as he leaned panting on the gate to the ring, the dog whining beside him. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry. 
 Please, I've found something, I must tell you.  
 She had known him since he was a very small five-year-old, perched like a mosquito on one of the placid beginners' ponies, so she told the class to carry on walking their ponies while she came to him. 
 &bquo;There's someone dead. 
 Below the railway embankment.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you sure?&equo; 
 The boy looked at her and uncontrollable tears suddenly filled his eyes. 
 He was very nearly as tall as her, but she put an arm under his shoulders and supported him to the untidy room which served as the stable office, calling to one of the stable girls to take over the class. 
 &bquo;Patty found her. 
 She's just lying there, but she is dead.&equo; 
 He scrubbed at his face with the handkerchief she offered and gulped for air. 
 &bquo;I'll ring the police.&equo; 
 She did so, casting an experienced eye over him. 
 &bquo;Sit down here, Jamie, and I'll make some tea. 
 Mummy will come back in a few minutes, won't she, for Susie?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not Mummy. 
 Aunt Margaret is coming at ten.&equo; 
 The boy thought longingly of his mother, but managed to help Miss Williams describe the location of the body to a startled local station sergeant and to drink a cup of sweet milky tea without being sick. 
 By the time his aunt arrived Jamie was so far recovered as to be able to refuse to go home and to point out, severely, that he would be needed, either to assist the police or to be lead rider in the eleven-thirty class, or possibly both. 
 He watched his aunt and Miss Williams wordlessly consult each other, but knew his aunt would do as she was told; successful solicitor though she was, she was ten years younger than Miss Williams and, as she complained, totally intimidated by her as she had not been by anyone since her late headmistress. 
 He was unsurprised to find her packed off firmly to take his sister home, leaving him as a person of major importance in what he instantly assumed to be a real murder. 
 Miss Williams took him to meet the police Land Rover at the stable gate, a bone-thin, wiry woman in her late fifties, her expression sufficiently forbidding to prevent the parents, edging cars through the gate to collect children  from the ten o'clock ride, from asking any questions. 
 Jamie, through a renewed queasiness, just observed that the police driver was instantly reduced to half his age by Miss Williams's greeting. 
 &bquo;He was one of my boys,&equo; she said in explanation to the CID sergeant who was leading the party as they bumped over the rough road, through the thick mud and on to the dry embankment. 
 &bquo;Like Jamie here.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you recognize the person you found, young man?&equo; the sergeant asked, carefully. 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Tears started into Jamie's eyes. 
 &bquo;She was all swollen.&equo; 
 The sergeant's eyes widened, and he slid out of the Land Rover and stood back to let Jamie out. 
 &bquo;Very competent boy. 
 Almost a professional singer, handles himself very well.&equo; 
 Miss Williams's natural pitch, well suited to reaching across a hunting-field, was discreetly reduced. 
 The CID sergeant thanked her gravely and went to stand beside Jamie who was peering down the embankment, looking pinched. 
 &bquo;We'll go down together, lad.&equo; 
 &bquo;There isn't room. 
 I'll lead.&equo; 
 He took a deep breath and headed down, the sergeant, two constables and Miss Williams in his wake. 
 Soon they all stood side by side, one of the younger policemen coughing involuntarily. 
 &bquo;Oh dear, oh dear,&equo; Miss Williams said on an indrawn breath. 
 &bquo;Sorry. 
 Come along, Jamie, let's get you back.&equo; 
 She took out a handkerchief and mopped her eyes. 
 The police driver shot Jamie a look of enquiry which he missed, occupied as he was with guiding Miss Williams back up the hill. 
 He had seen her weep before but only for a sick horse, and he was awe-struck. 
 &bquo;Jamie, did you let Patty off the lead?&equo; 
 The boy blushed to his ears and owned to it. 
 &bquo;You must not do it, Jamie, we'll be in trouble with Colonel James, I've told all you boys a thousand times.&equo; 
 &bquo;He'll perhaps not do it again,&equo; the sergeant murmured, and received the look that Miss Williams habitually bent on a child who was riding carelessly. 
 &bquo;How long had she been there?&equo; 
 Jamie asked, anxiously.  
 &bquo;A few days,&equo; the sergeant said, grimly. 
 &bquo;How many?&equo; 
 &bquo;Doctor'll tell us.&equo; 
 He considered the boy thoughtfully, and decided to take him back quickly. 
 These teenagers were in his experience a lot less tough than they looked. 
 &bquo;Any idea who it could be?&equo; he asked Miss Williams casually. 
 &bquo;No. 
 But only a local would know to put a body there. 
 If Jamie hadn't let the dog off the lead she could have been there much longer.&equo; 
 The sergeant nodded, deciding it could do no harm to concede a point he had already taken. 
 &bquo;No one could tell who she was, surely?&equo; 
 Miss Williams said quietly to him, sounding shaky. 
 &bquo;She didn't even look human .&equo; 
 The sergeant confirmed that that happened with bodies after a few days. 
 &bquo;We'll identify her, though,&equo; he said, reassuringly. 
 &bquo;Somebody will likely have reported her missing.&equo; 
 He stopped, abruptly, as he remembered a conversation earlier that week, and lit a cigarette, thinking furiously. 
 This could be the girl whom the Yard were looking for, and he had better do everything very quickly indeed, including finding his Chief, who would then want to find his  Chief Constable and notify Scotland Yard. 
 Presumably it would be the Yard who investigated this one, rather than the regional crime squad. 
 He chewed his thumbnail as he walked, out of long experience keeping in mind the highest priorities: Ensure Body Not Moved and Ensure Next of Kin Notified before the Press got the story. 
 He posted the detective constable he had with him back down the path to join his colleague, armed with instructions to repel all attempts by anyone, however senior or armed with whatever authority, to go anywhere near the body unless he, Sergeant Black, personally accompanied them. 
 Then he climbed into the Land Rover beside his two passengers and drove off fast, with the aim of abandoning Jamie to the custody of his aunt as quickly as possible. 
 He could see with half an eye that the kid's aunt was going to be one of the confident, bossy, well-connected women with  whom that part of Cambridgeshire was substantially over-provided. 
 John McLeish was in his office, Saturday or no Saturday, telling himself he needed to catch up on the paperwork. 
 The phone rang and he picked it up, frowning. 
 One of the pleasures of Saturday working was that the phone did not ring all the time. 
 The voice at the other end was plainly over-excited and it took him a minute to disentangle what he was being told. 
 &bquo;Oh congratulations, Charlie. 
 Sorry, what did you say it was again?&equo; 
 &bquo;A little girl. 
 Actually a very big girl as these things go, nine pounds. 
 It's fantastic, John, there she is, a new person, lying on her face, sound asleep. 
 I've just left them and I'm going back.&equo; 
 McLeish repressed the malicious thought that this event might put Francesca's nose just a little bit out of joint. 
 She had been utterly secure in her position as the only girl in the Wilson family and now there was another one. 
 &bquo;I've got another bit of good news. 
 Frannie's going to be able to bring Tristram home pretty soon, apparently.&equo; 
 McLeish expressed qualified enthusiasm and Charlie assured him he felt exactly the same about his younger brother. 
 &bquo;The difficulty is that Perry does everything that bit better than Tristram. 
 Not that this is any excuse, John, I do  know.&equo; 
 He paused, reminding McLeish irresistibly of a Labrador wondering how best to approach an acquaintance. 
 &bquo;I wanted to say, you see, that I know you thought Frannie shouldn't have gone, and that it's ruined your holiday plans, and, on behalf of us all, I'm sorry. 
 I know the little boys lean on her too much and I  would have gone if I could.&equo; 
 He coughed, embarrassed and a little pompous, very much conscious of his new status as a father, while McLeish remembered that he was a scant four years older than the delinquent Tristram. 
 &bquo;Anyway she should be back soon,&equo; Charlie concluded. 
 McLeish thanked him gravely, feeling, as he often did with the Wilsons, that he was being enveloped in a large  feather eiderdown, and, made restless by the call, went down the corridor to where he knew Catherine Crane was also in, getting her office in order. 
 He stopped at the door and smiled at her. 
 Wearing jeans and a blue shirt, she was tugging at a filing cabinet which was too large for her to embrace and which was threatening to over-balance on her. 
 She looked about sixteen and beautiful. 
 She let go of the cabinet, coughing in the dust of ages that appeared to be lurking behind it, and smiled back at him as the February sun shone through the small window behind her, throwing into sharp relief the patches on the wall where her predecessor had hung posters, and the ingrained dirt on the flaking paintwork round the mean, narrow, metal window. 
 &bquo;Where do you want that put?&equo; 
 McLeish advanced on the cabinet and shifted it authoritatively, ignoring the clip on the ankle dealt him by an unsecured bottom drawer apparently full of bricks. 
 &bquo;I should have unloaded it first,&equo; Catherine Crane said, apologetically, &bquo;but I just couldn't move in any direction with it where it was.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm here, just tell me if you want anything else shifted.&equo; 
 He hesitated. 
 &bquo;I'm going to do another hour, then have some lunch, if you want to come?&equo; 
 He was aware that he was not managing to sound exactly like a senior officer making a recent arrival feel at home, but decided not to add any further riders to his invitation. 
 &bquo;That would be very nice. 
 Are we going to the canteen?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not if I can help it. 
 What about the pub? 
 &bquo;If I'm allowed to buy my own.&equo; 
 McLeish considered. 
 &bquo;That's fine on the food &mdash; I'll buy the drinks, I'm too old to get used to women buying my drinks.&equo; 
 She laughed at him and said gravely that she would be happy to indulge him, and he went away, grinning. 
 Peter Yeo was also in his office, having told his wife he was lunching with a client. 
 It was, he felt, just too difficult to be at home at all, with Claudia in a permanently bitchy mood and both his teenage children taking their cue from her and  behaving intolerably. 
 He wandered restlessly about, and decided that the lie might as well become the truth. 
 Without Angela Morgan, at least two major clients were in danger of not getting the assiduous service they were paying for, and it would be well worth trying to see if one of them, whom he knew to be a fellow refugee from family life at the weekends, could be found. 
 He was in luck, and fixed to meet Andy Barton at Brazzo's where Yeo Davis had a table permanently booked. 
 He had to admit that this particular client hardly added to the general decorative smartness of the place. 
 Andy Barton, founder and chief executive of Barton Textiles, was almost as broad as he was long, virtually neckless, with incongruously long brown hair curling over his collar. 
 His enormous hands dwarfed the elegant menu which he was studying in apparent disbelief, and Peter Yeo noticed again, as Barton without rising extended one massive paw, that though the fingers were an ordinary length it was the width of the palms that made the hands so large. 
 &bquo;I never see how they get the sales per square foot in these places,&equo; Barton observed, without further greeting. 
 &bquo;I mean, they're not open twelve hours like my shops, and they aren't using the space.&equo; 
 His small bright blue eyes swept disparagingly over the minimalized black and white flooring, stainless steel chairs and black wooden bar. 
 &bquo;They make a huge margin on a smaller turnover, Andy, out of punters like us.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo was amused by, and respectful of, a man with an obsession. 
 &bquo;Angela not working today?&equo; 
 Barton worked a sixteen-hour day, which began with careful, detailed consideration of the trading figures and key ratios for every one of his forty-three major shops and the output of both factories, and continued, usually by helicopter, with a detailed aerial survey of a particular area as the quick way of identifying new sites, interspersed with unheralded descents on the manager of any shop he took a fancy to visit. 
 Peter Yeo, who had known this particular juggernaut since he had his first small factory and two stores and dirt  under his fingernails from shifting packing-cases personally, was not fazed by the question. 
 &bquo;Angela's taking a few days off &mdash; she hasn't been well,&equo; he said, easily. 
 &bquo;I know she's been working very hard for you. 
 I'm up to speed with Huerter, of course, but is your planning application in Leicester all right?&equo; 
 Barton assured him warmly that Angela had done a great job and he was now confident of getting planning permission on the vast site he had wanted. 
 Peter Yeo, who knew him in this over-candid, over-emphatic mood, decided to prod gently. 
 &bquo;Angela said the council wanted it for housing?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, some of them did. 
 Silly buggers, it's jobs they want there first. 
 Plenty of housing if those stupid farts at the council got round to repairing it and stopped their tenants tearing apart what they have got. 
 My Mum brought up five of us in a flat far worse than what these immigrants complain about.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo, who had personally persuaded Barton of the presentational disadvantage of using words like &bquo;darkies&equo;, &bquo;niggers&equo; or &bquo;wogs&equo;, decided that &bquo;immigrants&equo; even though used in the manner of one invoking a curse, was as good as he was going to get with this particular client. 
 &bquo;She's doing a good job on sorting this Huerter thing, too. 
 Bloody ridiculous them blokes at the DTI pushing assistance for Huerter. 
 I voted for this government because they said they weren't going to go in for that sort of rubbish. 
 No one ever gave me anything and my business works. 
 Still, Angie can fix the Treasury on this one, given her boyfriend, can't she? 
 That's the reason I wanted you on this.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo winced inwardly, but he was not going to tell Andy Barton that Angela was missing, or express any of his reservations about how much influence Angela could bring to bear. 
 He smoothly changed the subject to the looks of the blond model, three tables away, and Barton agreed he wouldn't mind a bit of that; on the thin side, mind you, but tasty. 
 The rest of lunch passed in similar diversion, interspersed with details of last week's turnover which  were never far from Barton's mind, whatever other distractions offered. 
 Mrs Huntley was having lunch with her daughter. 
 She ate placidly, acknowledging to herself with her customary good sense that at the moment, as at any time since her brother William had died, she and Penelope were getting no pleasure at all from each other's company. 
 Penelope was looking particularly discontented and disaffected, picking at her food. 
 Her red suit was smart, but too bright a colour for her pale English pink and white skin, her brown hair could have done with a wash and her nails were ragged and bitten. 
 She was frowning, deep lines appearing between her eyebrows, mouth drawn down at the edges so that instead of a classically good-looking slim English Rose in her late twenties, she looked faded, years older than her real age, and shrewish. 
 Mrs Huntley sighed; her brother whom she had loved, but knew to be self-indulgent to a fault, had done his niece real harm by leaving so much of his money away from the girl who had confidently believed herself to be his favourite thing on earth. 
 Penelope, however, it had to be acknowledged, had made no attempt to rise above the blow she had been dealt by finding a dazzling girl of her own age favoured over herself in her uncle's will. 
 At least, Mrs Huntley thought hopefully, she had stopped wondering, unbecomingly and stridently, how her uncle could have been fooled by Angela Morgan. 
 It was Grizel Huntley's own view that her brother had not been fooled at all but had been charmed and diverted by a dashing girl thirty years his junior, and had seen no reason at all why she should not have a share of his considerable estate when that left a very decent down-setting for his niece as well. 
 Indeed, she had respected Angela Morgan for the straightforwardness with which she had tackled the issue when they had met at the lawyer's office. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry you're disappointed,&equo; she had said to Penelope, &bquo;but after all there's a lot of money, quite enough for both of us.&equo; 
 So there was, Grizel Huntley acknowledged, and it would be  a great deal better if Penny could manage to think a bit more positively. 
 &bquo;If she has vanished, I'm going to see that solicitor about whether I can get her presumed dead.&equo; 
 Penny, sounding childishly, sullenly determined, broke into her mother's thoughts. 
 Grizel Huntley looked across at her, shocked. 
 &bquo;I would wait a little if I were you.&equo; 
 Penelope glared at her, turning an ungraceful scarlet, but Mrs Huntley held her ground. 
 &bquo;You are being silly about this, Penny. 
 You are letting this disappointment &mdash; and that's all it is, you're still a very well-off young woman &mdash; get in the way of everything.&equo; 
 Penelope choked on her pudding and started to cry, angry, uncontrollable tears. 
 Grizel Huntley reached out to comfort her but she forced back her chair and fled, clutching her handbag and napkin, leaving her mother with the ruins of lunch. 
 Fifty miles north, Sarah Morgan had just finished serving a lunch that no one had done more than pick at. 
 Her husband Francis had made a slightly better showing than her daughter Jennifer, who was looking particularly ragged. 
 Mother and daughter were very like each other, tall, dark, slim, pleasant-looking women with mid-brown curly hair and slightly snub noses. 
 Francis Morgan, by contrast, was dark, almost black-haired, sallow-skinned, with bright brown eyes. 
 Of medium height and packed with energy, even distressed as he was, he was bursting round the kitchen, hair still damp at the back from his swim. 
 &bquo;Let's go to the flicks. 
 No point at all sitting round looking at each other. 
 Come on Jennifer &mdash; or are you going out with Michael?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's gone back to Australia, Dad. 
 Last week.&equo; 
 Jennifer sounded defeated, and he looked at her sideways with familiar love and exasperation. 
 She just didn't seem to be able to hang on to men, he thought impatiently, not like his Angie, wherever she was. 
 &bquo;Giles rang up,&equo; his daughter volunteered, and he was uncomfortably reminded by something in her voice that  Giles Hawick was one of the men Jennifer hadn't been able to hang on to &mdash; or not once he had seen Angela. 
 &bquo;How was he?&equo; his wife Sarah asked, rather too quickly. 
 &bquo;Well, very worried. 
 He said the police were talking to everyone Angie had seen in the two weeks before she&hellip; well&hellip; vanished, and so far had come up with nothing. 
 I mean no one noticed anything unusual about her and she seemed to be full of plans for the wedding.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I told them that,&equo; Francis Morgan said irritably and his wife and daughter caught each other's eye in silent agreement that he hadn't told them that Angela was refusing point-black to be married from home and was insisting on the full London set-out, reception at the House of Commons, replying unanswerably when he had objected on grounds of expense that she could well afford to pay for it herself. 
 A row of epic proportions had ensued, which he and Angela had evidently enjoyed but which had left Sarah and Jennifer sick with distress. 
 &bquo;I don't want to go out, Frank. 
 Someone might ring.&equo; 
 Sarah Morgan was sounding diffident but resolute, and as Morgan opened his mouth to protest in exasperation the doorbell rang. 
 Both women looked at him in joint appeal and he marched to the door, pulling it open with unnecessary force. 
 He stood, door in hand, checked by something in the way his visitors, a man and a woman, were standing. 
 The man, a stocky, greying fifty-year-old in a navy raincoat over a suit, his hair cut short, was attended by a uniformed policewoman, hair smartly set under the cap, her eyes watchful in the wide, flat, placid face, and both of them were standing square and stolid. 
 Francis Morgan stood and stared at them, and even before the man stepped forward steadily, hand extended, mouth opening to speak, he understood who they were and what they had come to tell him.  
 &bquo;Catherine.&equo; 
 John McLeish, looking even bigger than usual, appeared in her office. 
 &bquo;The Cambridgeshire police think they have found Angela Morgan. 
 They've got a body of about the right description and they've gone to see Miss Morgan's parents. 
 We need to hurry but it'll take an hour or so and I don't want the papers on to it before the next of kin know. 
 You got your kit?&equo; 
 Catherine Crane wordlessly pointed to the back of the door of her office on which hung a neat suit. 
 He looked round, and realized she had cleaned the whole office in the hour and a half since he had seen her. 
 &bquo;Looks a lot better. 
 And only just in time. 
 Meet you in ten minutes. 
 I've got to change, then we're on our way. 
 Sorry about lunch, we'll get a sandwich.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Mr Morgan, but we can't move the body yet. 
 There is a senior officer from Scotland Yard on his way, and our people, photographers and so on.&equo; 
 &bquo;If it's my daughter I want to see her now, I don't want to wait.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, sir.&equo; 
 Francis Morgan subsided abruptly on one of the uncomfortable chesterfields in the sunny, cramped, living-room and Detective Inspector Teversham shifted uncomfortably, wishing the phone call would come. 
 The phone rang. 
 He sprang to it, and collected instructions in a room silent except for the sound of Mrs Morgan weeping drearily into her handkerchief. 
 With one part of his mind he logged the fact that Mum had understood the worst immediately and must in some way have been expecting it. 
 The deceased had been Daddy's girl, then &mdash; although it was usually the dads, where a daughter was in question, who fought against the realization of the truth. 
 His WPC was  looking at him anxiously for guidance, but he shook his head at her slightly and waited, standing squarely on both feet as he had done in many trying circumstances before. 
 &bquo;I'll come with you. 
 Sarah and Jennifer, you stay here.&equo; 
 Mrs Morgan made a movement of protest but Francis Morgan looked to Teversham for support. 
 &bquo;I think that would be better, yes, sir,&equo; he agreed. 
 &bquo;I must see her.&equo; 
 Sarah Morgan emerged from her handkerchief. 
 &bquo;Don't be silly Sarah, it might not be Angela,&equo; Francis Morgan said, desperately. 
 &bquo;Sergeant Jennings here will make some tea, then she'll stay with you while Mr Morgan and I go over to the stables. 
 We'll be back inside the hour. 
 Perhaps we could have a cup now?&equo; 
 He watched, stolidly, as Mrs Morgan disappeared to the kitchen to show the sergeant what was what and considered, without watching her, the other Miss Morgan. 
 She wasn't crying her eyes out. 
 She was pale, but not as shocked as she might have been. 
 Well, that was all right &mdash; she could look after Mum in the hour that was to follow while the identity of the body was established, and in all the grim hours after that, if the body was her sister. 
 He gently insisted that Francis Morgan got a cup of tea, with sugar, down him before he escorted him out to the waiting car. 
 He sat in the back with him, for company, and chatted soothingly of nothing as the driver did the eight miles or so to Kirton, and swept into the riding-school yard. 
 Evidently a class had just finished and the place was boiling with ponies, small children, pink-faced with exertion in oversized helmets covered with bright silks, parents urging them to hurry up and get in cars, and teenage girls bulging out of light jodhpurs organizing the whole. 
 A still point in this maelstrom was Sergeant Black, who had tucked himself between two of the sheltering twelve-foot evergreens planted to cut off the east wind from the ring. 
 The man moved efficiently past a child who had succeeded in entangling her pony's reins with her feet and who was being blasted for it by a girl who couldn't have been more than sixteen, but was sounding like a woman three times her age. 
 Precisely who it was she was using for  a role model became clear as a middle-aged lady, admirably slim in well-cut jodhpurs, erupted from some inner fortress to enquire, in tones that carried effortlessly across the yard, precisely why Caroline had failed to run up her stirrups, how  long had she been riding? 
 The tone was uncompromising but somehow neutral, and the child addressed hastened to make the adjustment, rebuked but not embarrassed or crushed. 
 Teversham stopped where he was, saw Miss Williams notice him, and waited patiently while she dispatched four of the assorted teenagers to a distant meadow with eight ponies, and while the yard cleared of small children and their parents. 
 &bquo;Miss Williams? 
 Detective Inspector Teversham. 
 Mr Morgan is in my car over there.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll just have a word with him, Chief Inspector. 
 I used to know him well.&equo; 
 She was white-faced but determined and the policemen stood back as she walked over towards the car. 
 &bquo;Decent of her,&equo; Teversham observed, without moving his lips. 
 &bquo;Hang on a minute, who's this?&equo; 
 A grey car, immaculately clean, was just pulling up at the gate and a big man in a plain grey suit was getting out to open it. 
 &bquo;Must be the Yard,&equo; his sergeant observed. 
 &bquo;The bloke might be. 
 But who is the popsy with him?&equo; 
 Teversham's terms for pretty women had been taken wholesale from his father who had been a young airman in World War II. 
 The car drew up alongside them, McLeish having known them as policemen by the same process as they had recognized him. 
 &bquo;Chief Inspector John McLeish.&equo; 
 He flapped his warrant card in automatic greeting and waved a hand at Catherine who had also got out of the car. 
 &bquo;Detective Sergeant Crane.&equo; 
 He watched amused as both the Cambridge detectives shook hands gingerly, obviously taken aback. 
 &bquo;Father of the missing girl over there, talking to the good lady who runs this establishment and who has already seen the body. 
 There's a man of mine on the spot. 
 We  think it's probably your girl &mdash; the ring on the finger fits the description and her parents are local.&equo; 
 John McLeish considered this admirably succinct report and decided the competent bloke was bound to resent Scotland Yard intrusion. 
 &bquo;If this turns out to be the lady we're looking for, she was engaged to a Treasury Minister, who called in my guv'nor.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, rather you than me, if that's who she is. 
 And much better you have it from the start. 
 My Super's already got his knickers in a twist.&equo; 
 The reply was prompt and ungrudging and McLeish breathed easier. 
 It was no fun at all working with an uncooperative and resentful local force. 
 &bquo;I've got a scene-of-crime squad coming, if that's all right. 
 I've worked with them before, you see,&equo; he added, in explanation and Teversham had just time to assure him he well understood and wouldn't himself like to work with anyone else's squad, before Miss Williams, tears in her eyes, and Francis Morgan, white with distress, bore down on them. 
 John McLeish introduced himself and Catherine in suitably subdued tones. 
 Even through his distress, Francis Morgan was obviously struck by Catherine Crane's looks and as the party distributed itself into the big Land Rover he managed to sit next to her. 
 McLeish, sitting on the other side of her, huddled on the uncomfortable bench-seating, could smell the faint perfume she wore and thought, with what detachment he could bring to bear, that one of the minor complications of this case was going to be the reactions of every man involved as suspect, colleague or witness, to this beauty he had managed to import on to his staff. 
 The Land Rover bumped along the track to where the young detective constable, looking chilled and ti red, was waiting for them. 
 As they decanted themselves McLeish managed to agree quickly with Teversham that, assuming the identification was confirmed, he would take Francis Morgan and Miss Williams back, leaving Catherine and himself at the site. 
 He waited tactfully with Catherine and  the young constable on the embankment, liking the sweep of the country as it spread out in the raw, cold day. 
 &bquo;Must be the only hill between here and Russia,&equo; he observed to Catherine who pointed out it wasn't much of a hill, more a fifty-foot ridge, it just looked high in this dead flat plain. 
 &bquo;You must know Cambridge, though, John. 
 Your girlfriend studied here, didn't she?&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't know her then,&equo; he said, repressively, uneasily conscious that he had given Francesca no thought at all that day and didn't much want to think about her now. 
 Catherine Crane fell silent, and he fished out the one-page note Teversham had handed him and read it, scowling. 
 &bquo;Good God,&equo; he said, involuntarily, and Catherine looked at him enquiringly. 
 &bquo;I know the boy who found the body &mdash; I mean it must be him. 
 He lives round here. 
 Jamie Brett-Smith. 
 He's a child star &mdash; a singer. 
 Did the theme song for that TV thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a hymn tune. 
 My Mum has it &mdash; I don't think she's ever bought a cassette before. 
 How do you know him?&equo; 
 McLeish hesitated, then said stiffly that he was Francesca's godson, and also something like her third cousin, or his mother was. 
 He glanced down the slope and realized the party was returning. 
 Francis Morgan white-faced and dazed, Miss Williams supporting his elbow, equally white and trying not to cry. 
 Teversham, at Morgan's other side, nodded to McLeish in confirmation, pro forma. 
 The small group struggled up the last piece of the embankment, Teversham necessarily in the rear and Francis Morgan stumbled almost on to McLeish's feet. 
 McLeish reached out to steady him and the man looked up at him, unseeingly. 
 &bquo;Christ. 
 Thirty years, and it's all gone. 
 That's my Angie. 
 It's her ring and I bought her that scarf.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm very sorry.&equo; 
 Francis Morgan looked at him wildly as Teversham came up at his elbow, solid as a rock. 
 &bquo;It's your job now, is it?&equo; he asked, earnestly. 
 &bquo;You'll catch the bastard who did it.&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll try, sir.&equo; 
 Francis Morgan looked from him to Catherine Crane,  obviously hardly knowing what he was doing, in an agony of loss. 
 &bquo;How old are you, Sergeant?&equo; he asked, abruptly. 
 &bquo;Twenty-seven, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Almost the same age as her &mdash; Angie, I mean.&equo; 
 The bright brown eyes rested on her and you could see written all over his face the jealousy that this girl, daughter to some man, was still alive while his child was gone. 
 Teversham and his sergeant closed round Morgan, shepherding him to the waiting Land Rover with meaningless gentle instructions to watch the step, up you go now. 
 McLeish glanced up the track to see, in the distance, another Land Rover swaying over the rough bits, and touched Teversham's elbow. 
 &bquo;That's my lot, I think.&equo; 
 Teversham nodded in acknowledgement. 
 &bquo;Miss Williams, we'll find the road again if we go straight and turn left by the hedge, won't we?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't do that,&equo; McLeish said urgently. 
 &bquo;Sorry, but if there was a vehicle involved it probably came from there. 
 No tracks on this side, except ours.&equo; 
 &bquo;Damn.&equo; 
 Teversham was unnerved by the nearness of the following Land Rover and irritated with himself for missing an elementary point. 
 In the end it took ten minutes to get the Cambridgeshire police Land Rover turned past McLeish's squad and their vans, and away back up to the stable. 
 Teversham had agreed to call the AC at the yard and report that the identification had been confirmed, so that he could go and see Giles Hawick. 
 Francis Morgan would no doubt ring him too, but he was naturally so shaken that McLeish thought that small piece of insurance worthwhile. 
 He watched them out of sight, then turned to his squad. 
 &bquo;Right, down we go. 
 The corpse is at the bottom of the slope. 
 Young woman, aged twenty-nine, dead about a week the local bloke reckons.&equo; 
 He glanced down the slope wishing he had brought boots; his shoes were already letting in mud. 
 He looked at Catherine Crane's feet and saw she was in a similar situation. 
 The sergeant from the scene of crime squad pushed past him, and advanced on Catherine Crane, holding out a pair of battered wellingtons with the air of the prince hopefully extending a glass  slipper. 
 &bquo;They'll be too big, Sergeant, but maybe better than your shoes? 
 We have some spare socks, too.&equo; 
 McLeish watched her melting smile, as did every man in the group. 
 &bquo;Got anything there to fit me?&equo; he asked pointedly, and a young constable reluctantly transferred his attention. 
 Kitted up some five minutes later with a pair a good size too small and with a hole in the right toe, McLeish led his troops into action. 
 The smell hit them as they slithered to the bottom of the slope and McLeish resolutely took a breath before walking over to where the swollen body lay. 
 It was, as usual, not the person who lay dead but the shell in which the person had lived. 
 The girl that was Angela Morgan had looked out of the photograph, whereas what lay on the ground, arms outstretched, could have been any young woman with dark hair. 
 The well-defined features of the photograph had vanished, the face had swollen in death as had the exposed arms. 
 Thank God it wasn't high summer, McLeish thought, stepping back almost on to Catherine's toes and reaching for his handkerchief; the cold, particularly at night, would have retarded decay. 
 The girl had been missing for what &mdash; a week? &mdash; and off-hand he agreed with the local man's judgement that she had been here for most of it. 
 The sapling trees had grown tall in the twenty-five years since the Beeching axe had fallen on the single railway track, and, even leafless as they were, they effectively screened the view from the top. 
 A thick hedge shielded her from the field which swept down towards the foot of the embankment. 
 Whoever had brought her here must have known the place; you couldn't have picked it out in a hurry. 
 The country is not as deserted as all that, as McLeish, brought up in a village in Leicestershire, well knew. 
 There are always people about, in tractors, walking or riding; there is always an inquisitive dog. 
 He stopped at this thought, wondering if dogs came along here frequently. 
 &bquo;Careful round the body,&equo; he said unnecessarily to the sergeant in charge of the squad, who was matter-of-factly  distributing heavy-duty surgical masks. 
 He looked round for Catherine and found she had vanished. 
 &bquo;Back that way, sir,&equo; one of the squad volunteered, barely intelligible through his mask, and McLeish saw her, twenty yards away, walking back slowly towards them, head bowed. 
 &bquo;All right?&equo; he asked as she came up beside him and she replied that she was, thank you. 
 She was very white, the freckles standing out brown on her skin, and she was blowing her nose. 
 &bquo;We'll go up and see if we can see how she got here. 
 Carry on, Sergeant.&equo; 
 He plunged up the embankment, taking a grateful breath of fresh air, then turned and extended a large imperative hand to Catherine Crane and pulled her up beside him. 
 &bquo;Were you sick?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sorry.&equo; 
 &bquo;Come on, let's get you up top.&equo; 
 She stood on the embankment breathing in gulps of air as he stood awkwardly by her, then fumbled for a handkerchief and he saw that she was crying. 
 &bquo;Sorry,&equo; she said, feeling him watching her and he fought back a violent physical impulse to give her a cuddle and take her away from all this. 
 &bquo;Happens,&equo; he said gruffly, patting her gingerly on the shoulder, and striding down the track ahead of her. 
 Behind them he saw a pair of horses, obviously having been warned off, turning to ride through a field, the colours of the riders' helmets very bright against the pale, cold, February sky. 
 He tried to remember what the weather had been like in the last week and realized he had no idea; like many city-dwellers he had moved from flat to car to office without registering any variation. 
 &bquo;It's obviously rained a lot,&equo; Catherine Crane volunteered, edging cautiously down the side of the track. 
 &bquo;That's a tractor, isn't it? 
 I suppose they could have come that way.&equo; 
 McLeish was walking the track, also keeping well to one edge, watching carefully. 
 &bquo;Still the same tractor. 
 Hang on&hellip; here's car tracks. 
 Faint, but there.&equo; 
 McLeish squatted unselfconsciously in the mud. 
 &bquo;No point me being clever.&equo; 
 He walked back along the side of the track and edged  down to join the scene-of-crime squad. 
 &bquo;I want the whole track photographed and samples taken. 
 Some car tracks, lots of tractor tracks, very deep.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sticky stuff, this clay. 
 Likely any car would have traces of it for a long time. 
 Dyes clothes yellow, too,&equo; the sergeant in charge volunteered. 
 &bquo;Is it murder, then, sir?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, have you noticed the head? 
 It's out of shape. 
 She's been missing for a week, was going to marry a rising Minister, successful career, everything coming up roses. 
 Doesn't look like an accident. 
 I'll get the doc to think on, when he arrives.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's the Land Rover back now. 
 I can hear it. 
 Likely that'll be him.&equo; 
 It was and McLeish greeted him with relief. 
 This was a senior man whom he had worked with before, a fellow Scot, grey-haired now, slight, quick-moving and thorough. 
 He went back down the embankment with him, telling Catherine to stay where she was and help with photographing the track. 
 Dr Scott, from long experience, did no more than wrinkle his nose at the odour of decay, and spent twenty minutes there, mostly occupied with a careful consideration of the head. 
 &bquo;How long do you think she's been dead?&equo; 
 &bquo;Rigor completely gone.&equo; 
 Scott lifted gently one bloodless arm, which fell limply. 
 &bquo;Subcutaneous swelling, decay. 
 Six or seven days, I would say &mdash; I'll not be able to be more precise until the autopsy.&equo; 
 &bquo;What was it, Doc?&equo; 
 &bquo;Very nasty bang on the head for one thing. 
 You noticed the skull is bulging &mdash; there, look. 
 Done with something sharp-edged, and a lot of force.&equo; 
 &bquo;That killed her?&equo; 
 John McLeish asked. 
 &bquo;Probably. 
 I'll start as soon as you can get the body back. 
 I'll ring you tomorrow or later tonight.&equo; 
 McLeish thanked him, scrambled up the embankment, drawing in deep breaths, and walked carefully down the side of the track in the sizeable footsteps of his squad, explaining to them that they were looking for a sharp-edged weapon. 
 He found Catherine Crane competently and tactfully assisting with operations, and as he came to  stand beside her realized she was so cold that she was almost shuddering. 
 He bustled her back to the Land Rover and raided the squad's provision box which he knew from experience would contain thick sandwiches and hot nourishing drinks. 
 He pressed both on her. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry,&equo; she said, when the shuddering had become only a shiver. 
 &bquo;I didn't realize I'd got so cold.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, you lost your breakfast and you never got lunch. 
 We'll get a square meal, then we'll see the family. 
 I don't want to spend too long &mdash; there's a lot else to do in London and  I'd rather have the autopsy before I ask too many questions. 
 Come on, we'll walk back to the car.&equo; 
 Even in the twenty minutes it had taken to get some nourishment, the light had faded and the dull day was darkening into a cold night; the beginnings of a frost crackled under their feet as they walked briskly along the embankment. 
 The long ridge to their left looked particularly bleak and lifeless, the heavy clay sitting solidly in the ridges where the plough had left it months before, no trace of last year's crop, nothing to indicate that this was good cereal country. 
 The tops of the sapling trees, waist-high at the edge of the embankment, were leafless and still. 
 A bad, cold night to lie out in. 
 McLeish had to remind himself that the dead girl behind them would have felt none of this dank chill. 
 It was almost totally dark when they arrived in the stable yard and Catherine jumped involuntarily as something moved and rattled against the boards. 
 &bquo;The hunters will be in &mdash; only the rough ponies will be turned out,&equo; McLeish observed out of childhood knowledge as he led her towards his car, looking very forlorn in the big parking area. 
 As he unlocked it, a light came on almost above his head. 
 &bquo;Who is it?&equo; 
 It was a clear, carrying command with no anxiety in it at all, and McLeish identified himself promptly. 
 &bquo;Ah. 
 Will you come in for a cup of tea? 
 I have James Brett-Smith, who found Angela this morning. 
 He says he knows you and came back in case you wanted to see him.&equo; 
 McLeish sighed inwardly. 
 &bquo;Of course, Miss Williams. 
  Sergeant Crane and I would be glad of tea. 
 Hello, sunshine.&equo; 
 This last was addressed to Jamie, who was peering round Miss Williams and was openly pleased to see him. 
 Not every day you saw that poised, competent kid distressed, McLeish thought, resting a hand on his shoulder. 
 It took a lot to faze a talented one like that, who had been a successful soloist for two years, managing with having a sick father and about one tenth of his mother's attention. 
 He realized the boy had grown in the two months since he had last seen him and looked at him carefully, noticing the way his wrists poked out of the shirt and the slight roughness of the clear skin. 
 &bquo;Is Francesca still in New York?&equo; the brat was asking anxiously, and McLeish, who had not wanted to discuss her in this company, found he had to reassure Jamie about her whereabouts and probable date of return. 
 &bquo;She's chaperoning for me on Monday next week,&equo; the boy explained. 
 &bquo;I'd forgotten, but she won't have&hellip; 
 Come and tell me about this morning,&equo; He looked round for Catherine to discover that with admirable good sense she had asked for the facilities of the house, and was being issued with soap and hand-towels by Miss Williams. 
 He took Jamie quickly through his story, finding him healthily excited by his part in it, but with an obvious undercurrent of anxiety. 
 &bquo;John,&equo; Jamie asked when he had told his story, &bquo;you won't leave her there, will you?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no, Jamie, that's the ambulance I can hear now, come to pick her up.&equo; 
 The boy's colour came back and he looked shame-faced at McLeish. 
 &bquo;I know it's silly, I mean she's dead, but it's so cold and I couldn't bear the idea of her just lying there.&equo; 
 Curious how the same thought had struck him, McLeish reflected, as he looked properly round the warm, untidy comfort of Miss Williams &bquo;s sitting-room, which smelled cheerfully of woodsmoke and wet dog. 
 A big black Labrador, catching his eye, thumped her tail and rolled on her side, looking up at him hopefully. 
 She closed her eyes in ecstasy as Jamie flung himself on her, accusing her of being a flirt. 
 McLeish looked past the boy to see Catherine Crane,  colour returned, seated on an upright chair, drinking tea. 
 He grinned at her. 
 &bquo;We'd best get on, Miss Williams, but could I use a cloakroom too? 
 Is Jamie being collected, or does he want a ride home?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no, his aunt is coming for him. 
 He's just polishing some tack for me.&equo; 
 So he was, McLeish observed, the devil plainly being given no opportunity to find work for idle hands. 
 He extracted Catherine a short while later and turned the car back on the darkened road which would lead them towards the A1. 
 &bquo;There were three dog leads and a packet of dog biscuits in the cloakroom,&equo; he told her, grinning in the darkness. 
 &bquo;The hairbrush in Miss Williams's bathroom had Labrador hairs in it. 
 Or it was the Labrador's hairbrush,&equo; Catherine Crane offered demurely, and McLeish burst out laughing, glancing admiringly sideways at her. 
 He felt extremely comfortable with her already, he thought happily. 
 They followed Miss Williams's directions to the Morgan family, and knocked on the door, being let in promptly by the stocky WPC who had stayed in the house with the women of the Morgan family. 
 Jennifer Morgan came into the hall; she had been crying and was looking white, but had herself in hand. 
 &bquo;Dad is lying down. 
 He wanted to be called when you arrived. 
 I don't know if you would like to talk to Mum and me first?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sorry to trouble you now, but if you can bear it it would help us to get some more information from you all. 
 I had spoken to your father before on the telephone, when your sister was first reported missing, but we didn't cover all that much ground.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I'd rather talk about it now,&equo; Jennifer Morgan said drearily. 
 &bquo;You've talked to Giles, of course?&equo; 
 &bquo;When he reported your sister missing &bquo;&equo; McLeish confirmed, leaping at the opening. 
 &bquo;I understand that you have known him longest of all the family?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo;  
 &bquo;Do you know him well?&equo; 
 She gave him a level look, understanding that he must be working, as they say, on information received. 
 Quick, as her dead sister must have been. 
 &bquo;We did go out together a few times, yes, Chief Inspector. 
 I liked him, but he and Angela are &mdash; were &mdash; better suited to each other.&equo; 
 It must have been painful to have a man you liked appropriated by a younger sister, McLeish thought, but this self-contained creature was not going to tell him &mdash; or possibly anyone else &mdash; how it had felt. 
 He considered her, as he went through the routine questions about when she had last seen her sister. 
 &bquo;We didn't meet very often in London unless it was a party. 
 I work in the British Museum, and my flat is quite close to it. 
 I &bquo;m an Assistant Curator in the Middle Eastern section.&equo; 
 McLeish blinked involuntarily, and she smiled faintly. 
 &bquo;I read Middle Eastern Languages, and spent a year in Turkey after Oxford, then came back to the Museum. 
 I specialize in fourteenth-century ceramics.&equo; 
 It was a less lively face than her sister's because it was more turned in, more contemplative, less concerned with the things of this world. 
 Well, fourteenth-century Turkey must be pretty safely removed from the things of this world. 
 He considered her good but unremarkable clothes, and wondered what she did for laughs. 
 Or was fourteenth-century Turkey laughs enough, what did he know? 
 He fell back on routine and asked Jennifer to confirm exactly when she had last seen Angela. 
 &bquo;I last saw her here, the weekend before she disappeared. 
 She came up here for a night to see Mummy, to sort out some details about the wedding.&equo; 
 &bquo;That must be a lot of work for your mother,&equo; McLeish said, hopefully, and got another level, distantly amused look. 
 &bquo;You would have to ask her  that. 
 My impression was that since it was to be held in London, Angela was doing the work, with a good deal of help from colleagues at Yeo Davis. 
 They have a lot of experience of large parties.&equo;  
 Ouch, McLeish thought, not such a gentle, distant academic, are you? 
 A very sardonic eye there indeed. 
 &bquo;We talked to Mr Yeo when your sister was reported missing. 
 He obviously considered your sister a very valuable colleague.&equo; 
 &bquo;She is &mdash; was &mdash; extremely competent, as well as very good at getting on with people, which is of course critical to jobs like that. 
 I imagine she will be very much missed.&equo; 
 She looked sharply out of the window and produced a handkerchief which she held clenched in her hand but did not use. 
 &bquo;Miss Morgan, would you like to stop for a minute? 
 Can we get you some more coffee?&equo; 
 McLeish glanced at Catherine who was already on her feet, and Jennifer Morgan nodded in acquiescence. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry. 
 I'll just go and tidy up.&equo; 
 She got up stiffly and went upstairs, holding blindly on to the banisters. 
 McLeish joined Catherine in the comfortable modern kitchen where they foraged companionably for coffee and milk, waiting until they heard Jennifer Morgan come down again. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry,&equo; she said, wearily. 
 &bquo;Where were we? 
 My mother is coming in a minute.&equo; 
 &bquo;We were asking about your sister's position at Yeo Davis. 
 I think you had made it clear that Mr Yeo very much valued her. 
 Would she have wanted to continue working there after she was married?&equo; 
 Jennifer Morgan looked at him quickly and he realized he must have stumbled on something. 
 But she knew her hesitation had given him a lead. 
 &bquo;She would have wanted to continue, yes. 
 There might have been some difficulty there because of Giles &bquo;s position, because of the conflict of interest. 
 Yeo Davis exists to lobby government and Giles is a Minister.&equo; 
 She sounded like Francesca when she talked about Yeo Davis, McLeish reflected. 
 &bquo;Did he want her to give it up?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, he did. 
 He found it awkward, but Angela was &mdash; naturally &mdash; reluctant.&equo; 
 Some colour had come back into Jennifer's face. 
 So he talked to you about it, McLeish thought, and saw  Catherine register the same point. 
 He decided to leave this one for the moment but logged the fact that Jennifer Morgan had still been interested in, and comfortable with, the man who had become her sister's fianc&eacute;. 
 A tap on the door made them all start. 
 Catherine Crane went across to open it and held a murmured conversation with someone. 
 Sarah Morgan came in to the room like a ghost, and McLeish drew breath as he saw her. 
 She was deathly pale, the mid-brown hair flattened to her head, the lined skin without make-up except for a brave but mistaken line of smudged lipstick. 
 She looked at him dumbly, and even McLeish's hardened investigator's nerve failed him. 
 He glanced involuntarily at Jennifer Morgan who said she would make tea, which was what her mother preferred, and bore her off to the kitchen. 
 They returned with the tea accompanied by a bottle of pills &mdash; Valium, McLeish noticed automatically &mdash; and with Mrs Morgan looking more gathered. 
 The buttons of her cardigan were correctly done up and the collar flattened neatly, the zip of the skirt was in its proper place at the side and her tattered bedroom slippers had been replaced with a tidy pair of court shoes, the wrong colour for the skirt. 
 It was better, but not a lot, and McLeish who knew her to be in her late fifties decided any casual observer would put her at nearer seventy. 
 Jennifer Morgan looked at him doubtfully, but he shook his head to her implied question; he preferred to conduct his interviews without members of the family present. 
 &bquo;Won't be long,&equo; he said, reassuringly, just managing not to pat Jennifer Morgan on her beige cashmere shoulder. 
 He was extremely gentle with Sarah Morgan, as he had implicitly promised her daughter, but it was a desperately painful experience, and, he began to fear, not a useful one. 
 She had not seen Angela since the weekend before the one on which she had disappeared, but had spoken to her twice on the telephone. 
 Well yes, Angie had been very busy and preoccupied with the wedding preparations, naturally, but she had been happy. 
 And no, they had not been expecting to see her that weekend, though with Giles  away she had said she might come on the Sunday. 
 But she would have telephoned first. 
 She seemed to be eased by talking of her daughter, and by the time she stopped, apologetically, and drank some tea poured for her by Catherine, she looked exhausted but less like a wraith. 
 She pushed the Valium aside, observing that she did prefer not  to take drugs, a reaction so typical of her age and class that McLeish decided he might after all be able to conduct a useful interview. 
 &bquo;I understand it was your older daughter who met Mr Hawick first?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, she did, and I think she hoped something would come of it &mdash; well, so did I. But when he met Angela he was just bowled over by her. 
 I was sorry for Jennifer but they had only been going out for a month or so, and not terribly seriously. 
 And in any case, you can't do anything about these attractions, can you?&equo; 
 McLeish agreed with her promptly and she raised half a smile for him. 
 He waited, remembering Jennifer Morgan's obvious pain and wondering what her mother's views about it were. 
 He watched her thoughtfully as she ate a biscuit. 
 &bquo;Angela must have been a very attractive girl,&equo; he suggested, cautiously. 
 &bquo;Oh, she was,&equo; Sarah Morgan agreed. 
 &bquo;But I used to wonder whether she was ever going to get married. 
 She never seemed to fall for anyone her own age, they were always older.&equo; 
 She was talking with the ease of total emotional exhaustion. 
 &bquo;Was there anyone else who was important to her &mdash; I mean before she met Mr Hawick, of course?&equo; he asked, vaguely. 
 Mrs Morgan took another biscuit and accepted another cup of tea. 
 &bquo;I did think that there was something between her and Peter Yeo &mdash; her partner &mdash; but nothing came of it. 
 He has a wife and children and most men don't usually leave their wives, do they?&equo; 
 The question was rhetorical and McLeish waited. 
 &bquo;Anyway, Giles was perfect for her; fourteen years older and with his own very distinguished career. 
 I was  sure she was going to be happily settled.&equo; 
 She stopped, staring out of the window, her hands clenched together. 
 &bquo;And then this terrible thing happens. 
 Who could have wanted to kill her?&equo; 
 Francis Morgan did not bother with knocking at the door but walked in without apology. 
 He was deathly pale and obviously still in the first shock of grief but it had taken him differently. 
 He was wound up like a spring, furiously angry, unable to keep still or to prevent himself from fidgeting. 
 &bquo;Where's Sarah?&equo; he demanded, and took in the scene in front of him. 
 &bquo;Why didn't you wake me?&equo; 
 &bquo;I understand the doctor wanted you to have a sleep if you could, Mr Morgan &bquo;&equo; Catherine Crane said briskly. 
 &bquo;Would you like some tea? 
 We have only just started talking with Mrs Morgan.&equo; 
 She looked very young and pretty as she held up the teapot and Francis Morgan hesitated, then sat down, heavily, and seized two biscuits. 
 &bquo;Sorry,&equo; he said, awkwardly, through a mouthful of Rich Tea. 
 &bquo;I can't stop thinking about her and wondering what happened.&equo; 
 He slapped both hands palms down on the table, slopping his tea and making them all jump, totally unselfconscious in his misery. 
 What, McLeish wondered acerbically, did he imagine his wife and surviving daughter were thinking about &mdash; or did he assume they had taken the death of a daughter and a sister in their stride? 
 From under his eyelashes he could see Mrs Morgan was watching her husband with a sort of furious compassion, and was careful not to catch her eye. 
 The man was quite literally distracted, unable to concentrate at all. 
 McLeish looked thoughtfully at Jennifer Morgan who had come in and was considering her father with what he was startled to recognize as dislike. 
 This was evidently a family that was not going to be brought closer by grief. 
 She nodded to McLeish and started gently to bustle her mother away. 
 He settled Francis Morgan down as best he could and took him again through the events of the week before his daughter vanished. 
 No, he hadn't seen her for a week before that weekend; he had missed her &mdash; this with a baleful glance towards the door &mdash; and had  indeed got as far as ringing her up on the Saturday morning, hoping she would come up for Sunday, but had got no answer from her flat. 
 &bquo;It wasn't worth going down on the off-chance, or so I thought. 
 But perhaps if I had&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;You were close to your daughter, then?&equo; 
 McLeish asked hopefully. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 We were like each other; she knew what she wanted and she didn't mess around. 
 I can't bear people who don't know what they want and dither.&equo; 
 &bquo;So you were pleased that she was marrying?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not particularly.&equo; 
 McLeish did not manage to conceal surprise and Francis Morgan looked at him wretchedly, the restless brown eyes wide-set, like the dead girl's, and very bright. 
 &bquo;He's all right, I suppose, Giles &mdash; for a politician. 
 But he thinks he's the centre of the world and he was going to make it difficult for Angie to do what she wanted if it would affect his career. 
 He likes all that, the cars and people calling him Minister, but he wanted her to be the good politician's wife, doing his entertaining. 
 He didn't say so, mind, but I told Angie she would have to watch it after she married him. 
 And he wanted her money, of course. 
 These chaps don't have security of tenure.&equo; 
 McLeish reflected that Giles Hawick was the classic example of someone who knew what they wanted and didn't mess around, and that that was what had attracted Francis Morgan's daughter. 
 Perhaps he had not said to himself that in a marriage between two like this, someone was going to have to know a little less clearly what they had wanted. 
 &bquo;Was there someone else around you would rather she had married?&equo; he asked bluntly, deciding it was that sort of conversation. 
 &bquo;No one in particular, but I thought she'd have been better off with a chap of her own age who would have wanted her to carry on where she was. 
 Someone who would have known she was exceptional and have encouraged her.&equo; 
 And been less of a direct rival to her Dad, and all,  McLeish thought, and stuck to his line. 
 &bquo;And there was no one like that in her life?&equo; 
 Francis Morgan, calmer now, visibly bent his mind to the question. 
 &bquo;She had dozens of boyfriends,&equo; he said, wistfully. 
 &bquo;I probably met them all. 
 But they didn't seem to last very long. 
 She didn't want to settle down, you see, and they all wanted her to.&equo; 
 McLeish decided he was not going to get much more out of this and went on to check, gently, what Francis Morgan had done with the weekend. 
 He appeared to have spent it blamelessly playing golf, dining with neighbours and at home doing some work. 
 He would check it, if he needed to, but he could not at the moment see why Morgan would have wanted to kill the daughter to whom he had plainly been so devoted. 
 He managed to have another few words with Mrs Morgan also, who was looking much stronger. 
 She apologized obliquely for her husband, and McLeish murmured that Mr Morgan had obviously been very much attached to Angela. 
 &bquo;So was I, Chief Inspector,&equo; Sarah Morgan said evenly. 
 &bquo;And I was glad she was marrying an older man like Giles Hawick.&equo; 
 The emphasis on the &bquo;I&equo; was faint but definite and McLeish carried the echo away in his head. 
 &bquo;I don't mean to sound ungrateful, but I'm starving,&equo; Catherine said, as they reached the gate. 
 &bquo;Can you wait till London? 
 There's a good place in Ealing &mdash; well it's a chipper really, but he has good steaks at any time you want them. 
 Have a sleep if you want.&equo; 
 She slept deeply while they were on the motorway, but woke as he came into London and had to stop and start in the heavy evening traffic. 
 &bquo;Better,&equo; she said, smiling at him. 
 &bquo;Dinner &bquo;s not far.&equo; 
 Restored by a large steak, he explained to her as they ate  that he liked to work very quickly on a murder case, pushing everyone to get an answer. 
 &bquo;I expect that means you do more cases than most?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've been a bit lucky,&equo; he said, modestly. 
 &bquo;I've ended up most of them with a full confession, once we'd worked it out. 
 That way you know you've got it right.&equo; 
 &bquo;Unless you're in Henley,&equo; she observed with privileged acerbity and he laughed, embarrassed as every policeman had been by the revelations just made of Thames Valley's modus operandi . 
 &bquo;Eight cases withdrawn so far, isn't it?&equo; 
 Catherine asked. 
 &bquo;And more to come.&equo; 
 He smiled at her, thinking what a treat it was to talk shop with someone as beautiful and intelligent as this. 
 She insisted quietly on halving the bill and he let her have her way, not wanting to jeopardize his chance of eating with her in the future. 
 He glanced up as they completed this transaction to find the attention of the nearest two tables, both exclusively male, fixed disbelievingly on them. 
 As three men slowly looked away McLeish received the uncompromising message that if any of them had been so lucky as to have dinner with Catherine Crane, none of them would have let her pay for herself. 
 Indeed he had a strong feeling that only his six foot four inches prevented one of them from saying so. 
 He glanced at Catherine but she had obviously noticed nothing out of the way. 
 Outside the restaurant McLeish hesitated, not wanting the evening to end. 
 &bquo;A drink?&equo; he suggested, hopefully, but Catherine shook her head. 
 &bquo;My flat is in almost as much of a mess as the office. 
 I was in a chain, and I only managed to complete last week. 
 I'd better go and get it straight. 
 I haven't even got the curtains hung, or unpacked the kitchen stuff.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let me come and help?&equo; 
 McLeish offered, cheerfully. 
 &bquo;It is the fault of C1 that you don't have today or tomorrow to get straight. 
 I'll come and put in a couple of hours, so you can get a bit more comfortable.&equo; 
 She hesitated, then said that she would like that rather than a drink, if he really wouldn't mind.  
 The flat was indeed in some disarray: immaculately clean, evidently she had done that first, but with most of its furnishings disposed in boxes on the floor. 
 McLeish, naturally efficient and brought up by a mother with firm views on men's participation in the drearier household chores, took just over an hour to sort her kitchen to her satisfaction while she got the living-room straight, with all the books unpacked. 
 &bquo;That's marvellous. 
 Thank you very much. 
 Can I give you a coffee?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd like that. 
 Then I'll be off so you can catch up with yourself.&equo; 
 They fell comfortably into gossip about various parts of their experience until McLeish noticed she was looking tired. 
 &bquo;I'm off,&equo; he said, briskly. 
 &bquo;I'll be going into the Yard first thing to work out what's to do. 
 I'll not need anyone till about lunch-time so you have your sleep in, but I may ring you up after that. 
 I find if you get the case started off quickly it all goes easily.&equo; 
 She thanked him demurely, and he realized she was laughing at him. 
 He looked down at her, about to kiss her good-night as if she were one of Francesca's friends, and pulled himself up. 
 This was a colleague, a fellow detective. 
 As well take to kissing Bruce Davidson good-night, he told himself, and got himself out of the door on this thought. 
 The telephone was ringing as McLeish walked into his own flat, and he picked it up to find his Commander on the other end of the line. 
 &bquo;So I've arranged you'll take a statement from Hawick tomorrow afternoon, then.&equo; 
 &bquo;We haven't got the autopsy, sir, so I've no idea when the girl died, yet. 
 I'll have to see him again when I do know. 
 Wouldn't he rather wait twenty-four hours?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's a busy man. 
 Also he wants to talk to someone, he wants to make sure we're doing our job. 
 Don't give me a hard time, McLeish, just bloody do it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sir.&equo;  
 &bquo;Don't be like that. 
 Take that gorgeous sergeant of yours, give Hawick something to look at.&equo; 
 &bquo;She's been with me in Cambridge all day &mdash; I told her she could have Sunday off.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then tell her different. 
 She with you?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, sir. 
 I left her at her flat.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your girl's due back when?&equo; 
 McLeish raised his eyebrows, taken aback by the transparency of his superior's line of thought, and primly gave him Francesca's projected timetable. 
 &bquo;Glad to hear it. 
 Good luck with the Minister, and give me a ring afterwards. 
 I like to know where the bullets are coming from. 
 G'night.&equo; 
 McLeish, shaking his head, rang Catherine and broke it to her apologetically that she would be required for the afternoon. 
 &bquo;Doesn't matter. 
 We &mdash; you &mdash; would have had to see him soon anyway. 
 Is the autopsy going to give us much idea when Angela Morgan died &mdash; I mean within a day or so?&equo; 
 &bquo;Probably not,&equo; McLeish conceded. 
 He went to bed to dream uneasily, and woke early as he always did in the early stages of a case before he had got the machine working properly. 
 At tea-ti me the next day he picked up Catherine at her flat, noticing that she was looking rested and pretty even if he was feeling jaded and disaffected. 
 They were received in the Minister's private flat in one of the narrow streets close to the House of Commons. 
 McLeish remembered that this man's constituency was in Derbyshire. 
 They took a tiny, cramped lift to the top floor of the building and were admitted by Hawick, who was wearing an expensive blue-green sweater, and slacks, the clothes sitting easily on his long, slim frame, the dark hair beautifully cut, a little too long, flopping on his forehead. 
 Despite the elegance, it was a completely masculine presence, and he dominated the room as easily as he had his own office. 
 He was grim-faced and looked as if he had not slept, but he offered them freshly made coffee and raised a smile for Catherine. 
 He saw her comfortably established at a table &mdash; &bquo;I know  you'll want to take notes&equo; &mdash; and offered McLeish his choice of three big armchairs. 
 &bquo;I'm not sure some of the upright ones will hold you, Chief Inspector, I sit on them very gingerly myself.&equo; 
 Hawick chose a big chair by the fireplace in which a simulated coal fire burned merrily, emitting real warmth thanks to the gas which powered it. 
 &bquo;I'd prefer a proper fire, of course, but we made them illegal in this part of London some years ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;We&equo;, McLeish remembered from Francesca, did not necessarily mean this administration but must mean one of the same political persuasion. 
 Measures passed by those of a different political hue were described as the work of a &bquo;previous government&equo;. 
 A good room to be in, McLeish thought, with its high ceiling and the Sunday quiet of London, and what was obviously a copy of every Sunday paper published lying tidily on a side table. 
 &bquo;It comes with the job,&equo; Giles Hawick explained, following his eye. 
 &bquo;We read them all. 
 There is nothing yet about Angela in any of them.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, sir. 
 We did not have a definite identification until late yesterday afternoon, in any case.&equo; 
 &bquo;Poor Francis. 
 He rang me last night, very kindly, principally I think to assure me that there could be no doubt. 
 That it was Angela, I mean.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm very sorry.&equo; 
 &bquo;Were you there too? 
 Did you see Francis &mdash; Mr Morgan?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, we were, although it was a Cambridge officer who broke the news because I didn't want any delay in case the Press got it. 
 We were actually with him when he made the identification, though.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've been to that riding-stable &mdash; Angela's sister Jennifer and I went hacking one day when I stayed the weekend there. 
 It's an excellent stable &mdash; they produced a very good hunter for me once Jennifer had assured them I was safe. 
 I can't remember it all, but I think we rode along the old railway line.&equo; 
 He bit his lip and looked into the remorseless, even flames. 
 &bquo;I was just following Jennifer's lead.&equo; 
 &bquo;You only went once?&equo; 
 &bquo;Twice. 
 Angela didn't ride, though she had done as a  child. 
 I told you, I think, that I had met Jennifer first, some time ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;Indeed.&equo; 
 Well, it was interesting, McLeish thought gravely, making an unnecessary note, that Giles Hawick had admitted unprompted to the local knowledge necessary for disposing of Angela Morgan's body in that particular place. 
 But it had been the older sister he had gone there with, and had apparently abandoned in favour of the younger, more exciting girl. 
 He decided he wasn't going to get anywhere along those lines, or not yet, and went over again the details of when Hawick had last seen his fianc&eacute;e. 
 He found his account, as he would have expected, consistent, and considered the man carefully as he did so. 
 For all his ambition, Hawick was obviously a man of strong passions and, for McLeish's money, well capable of murder. 
 There was, however, no apparent motive, McLeish reminded himself, and he must not let his own uneasy conviction that Angela Morgan would have been more than capable of stirring up strong and complex emotions in those around her cloud his judgement. 
 Time to ask the obvious question. 
 &bquo;We're at a very early stage in all this, Minister, but can you think of anyone who would have wanted to harm Miss Morgan?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 McLeish blinked at him, startled. 
 &bquo;Yes, I can think of one or two people who might have wanted to harm her, as you suggest. 
 None who might have carried that wish to the length of killing her. 
 I take it her death cannot have been accidental?&equo; 
 &bquo;Probably not,&equo; McLeish agreed, thinking of the misshapen skull. 
 &bquo;Who had reason to wish her ill, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;She was left a large legacy by an ex-employer. 
 His niece, who is a little unbalanced, took this very badly, despite the fact she herself was a substantial legatee. 
 She certainly made threats against Angela and has bothered her recently. 
 This is a woman called Penelope Huntley. 
 I've never spoken to her myself but I know Angela had found it necessary to get her solicitor to write.&equo; 
 McLeish made a note. 
 &bquo;We haven't been able yet to speak  to Miss Morgan's solicitor,&equo; he observed. 
 &bquo;Do you know if she left a will?&equo; 
 &bquo;Indeed she did. 
 We both made new wills last week, in expectation of marriage. 
 We each left the bulk of our estates to the other, with a couple of minor legacies &mdash; my old college and a couple of godchildren on my side, and her sister on hers.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you know what Miss Morgan's previous will provided?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I don't. 
 But that will, of course, is the only one that's valid. 
 We never married.&equo; 
 The wide mouth twisted. 
 &bquo;So the wills we made last week are irrelevant.&equo; 
 He looked suddenly tired and old, the deep lines in his face intensified. 
 &bquo;There were probably professional jealousies in Angela's life, too,&equo; he said, wearily, rubbing the patch between his eyebrows in a gesture McLeish recognized from his television appearances. 
 &bquo;You mean she could have run into trouble as a result of her professional activities?&equo; he asked, cautiously. 
 &bquo;I hope not. 
 I must say I was not totally happy about her going on at Yeo Davis, with me in the government. 
 But she was very reluctant to give it up and there is a precedent. 
 One of my Ministerial colleagues is married to a partner in a firm specializing in financial public relations where there are similar possibilities for conflict of interest.&equo; 
 But maybe your Ministerial colleague isn't going right for the very top, McLeish thought with unreasonable conviction, and you were going to stop her working at Yeo Davis when you could. 
 He glanced up and found the cool blue eyes on him. 
 &bquo;That being said, anyone will tell you that a Minister of the Crown needs a wife capable of supporting him. 
 It's one of those jobs where the pay doesn't actually cover the cost of the lifestyle, and you can be out on you one day and the next. 
 But I think we would have tried to find her a job rather more removed from mine, over time.&equo; 
 A very fair admission, McLeish thought admiringly, and made his standard speech about the need, if he might, to come back on various points as they occurred to him.  
 &bquo;Of course you must. 
 Just so long as you are not intending to ask me not to leave London. 
 I'm in Newcastle tomorrow and the day after, and next week I have several days in Washington. 
 I have told you where I was already.&equo; 
 He hesitated. 
 &bquo;I'm assuming she was killed on the Saturday, of course, when she first went missing, as we now know. 
 I hope so. 
 I mean it would be worse if she had been &mdash; hurt &mdash; first.&equo; 
 McLeish instantly understood the man's nightmare but realized he could give only qualified reassurance. 
 &bquo;She was probably killed by a blow on the head, Minister. 
 We have not had the autopsy result.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can you let me know?&equo; 
 &bquo;Certainly.&equo; 
 He and Catherine took their leave and crammed themselves again into the rickety lift. 
 It was another windy, sunny day, the brilliant February sun which has no strength in it but still gives the reassurance that summer will come and a sun will shine with real warmth again. 
 Discarded papers blew in the narrow street as they walked back to the car. 
 &bquo;John, excuse me. 
 Are we allowed to tell people involved in the case what the autopsy result is?&equo; 
 &bquo;If that one's a murderer he knows what happened. 
 If he isn't, it doesn't matter what he knows and he can go over my head any day he likes and make the Assistant Commissioner read him the whole report if he wants to. 
 No point me being difficult.&equo; 
 He got a respectful sideways look, which he appreciated, and smiled down at her. 
 &bquo;Did you think he was a murderer, Catherine?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well capable of it, if crossed,&equo; she said, promptly. 
 &bquo;But I can't see the motive.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about if Angela Morgan was involved with another bloke and he found out?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, then. 
 But not if he had time to think what it would do to his career.&equo; 
 McLeish grinned. 
 &bquo;He's too ambitious. 
 He's one of these blokes where he comes number 1, 2 and 3, and anyone else comes nowhere.&equo; 
 There was real feeling in this judgement, McLeish decided, and tried to imagine  what kind of man had decided to relegate Catherine Crane to fourth place in his scheme of things. 
 In a windy, cold field in Cambridgeshire, green with winter wheat, half a mile away from where Angela Morgan's body had been found, a small man with a narrow, turned-down mouth sat smoking his twentieth cigarette of the day at the wheel of a Land Rover. 
 He arrived at a decision, threw the cigarette away, and turned towards a small depressing row of agricultural cottages. 
 He emerged two minutes later with a bulky small man, and the Land Rover turned on to the Cambridge road, making for the headquarters of the regional crime squad. 
 An hour later the phone rang in New Scotland Yard where John McLeish was sitting reading the scene-of-crime report. 
 &bquo;A what? 
 Yes, sorry, of course I've heard of ploughs. 
 My mind wasn't with you. 
 Standing there, was it? 
 Yes, I've got the scene-of-crime report, hang on &mdash; yes, deep tracks, evidently belonging to a tractor, plus other deep tracks, query agricultural machinery. 
 Well, you can't blame them, Sergeant, they're like me, not used to the country, real townees. 
 It was a plough, was it?&equo; 
 He listened as the Cambridgeshire sergeant explained that the keeper on the shooting estate had realized he had seen the old plough there last week and had fetched the farmer in to explain where it had gone. 
 &bquo;He says he never saw a body when he moved it. 
 He was very unhappy at having to come out at all, but I think he &bquo;s just pig-ignorant rather than involved. 
 Do you want me to send someone to look at the plough?&equo; 
 &bquo;Have you seen it?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 I'll go if I must, but we haven't got any forensic people here, it being Sunday. 
 I can get them out, of course.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I'll send a couple of my blokes, as soon as I can. 
 Could you do us a real favour? 
 Make sure the vehicle is under cover so if there is anything on it, prints, whatever, that haven &bquo;t already gone, we get them. 
 I mean, don't let the farmer clean it, or anything dead stupid.&equo; 
 The sergeant at the other end said grimly that the bloke  was quite thick enough to do just that, so due precautions would be taken. 
 &bquo;I'll go myself in fact. 
 No, it's no bother, it's on my way home. 
 Give your blokes this number so they can arrange a visit, but I'll have a quick look while I'm there.&equo; 
 John McLeish was feeling justifiably pleased with himself as he walked into his office at eight o'clock on Monday morning. 
 He had devoted Sunday evening to making a plan of action and knew exactly what he and everyone else he could press into service was going to be doing this morning. 
 His schedule for the day was organized, thanks to some brisk telephoning the night before, and he would have Catherine Crane at his side all day, and all the days until this case finished. 
 He arrived at his desk, squinted at the offering tucked into his blotter and sat down to read it properly: a short, sanctimonious newspaper piece on the temptation and pressures on the successful young, Tristram Wilson being mentioned, with many a crocodile tear, as one of the recent casualties. 
 It was presumably Bruce Davidson, who admired and was annoyed by Francesca in about equal measure, and therefore took an unremitting interest in all her activities, who had favoured him with this. 
 McLeish threw it away and methodically sorted his notes; he was not going near a top firm of solicitors without a very careful list of questions, and his first port of call that morning was to be Huttons, who had been Angela Morgan's solicitors. 
 He and Catherine were ushered into the presence of Mr Timothy Hutton, who was housed in outwardly featureless modern offices in one of the little streets off Ludgate Hill. 
 The view from the window featured a building site and a large collection of assorted earth-moving machinery and cranes, all displayed simultaneously. 
 Even through double glazing there was a dull, continuous background noise,  and the huge modern windows were dusty in the February sun. 
 The furniture and fittings were ruthlessly modern, several steps beyond the conventional Scandinavian. 
 Mr Hutton's desk was a shaped piece of black wood with a single file on it, and the heavily bound books that covered one wall appeared to be held there by the power of faith, no shelves being visible. 
 The owner was also uncompromisingly twentieth-century, a man of much the same height and age as McLeish but built like a string bean, with brown, short-cut hair and fashionable heavy horn-rimmed spectacles. 
 He greeted them briskly and folded himself into a chair. 
 McLeish noted enviously that Mr Hutton was a vision of elegance in one of this year's broadly striped blue and white shirts: he had tried one on himself recently, and had been forced reluctantly to the conclusion that he looked like a bouncer for an East End club. 
 &bquo;Dreadful thing about Miss Morgan,&equo; Timothy Hutton said earnestly. 
 &bquo;We were all very shocked &mdash; I told my partners at prayers this morning. 
 Sorry, that's what we call the Monday morning meeting where we discuss what's going on. 
 How can I help you?&equo; 
 &bquo;You can tell us, please, what Miss Morgan's property was and how her will distributes it. 
 I understand that you are her executor.&equo; 
 &bquo;I am, yes. 
 With her father. 
 I've just looked it up. 
 I didn't, of course, expect to have to &mdash; not quite so soon.&equo; 
 He opened the file and considered it, unhurriedly and unselfconsciously, and McLeish had a sudden vision of an older Mr Hutton in a tail-coat and wing collar behind this modern fa&ccedil;ade. 
 &bquo;We have two wills on file,&equo; Timothy Hutton said, reaching the end of whatever internal debate he had been having, &bquo;but the second, which was made in anticipation of her marriage to Mr Hawick, cannot of course be submitted for Probate since that marriage did not take place. 
 So it's the first will she made &mdash; what? &mdash; eighteen months ago, which is valid.&equo; 
 McLeish said promptly that he would need to know the contents of both wills as well as details of Miss Morgan's estate, and Timothy Hutton considered him carefully.  
 &bquo;Yes, I see you do,&equo; he agreed, &bquo;and I'm not here to make difficulties. 
 Look, I need to explain a bit of background. 
 Angela was very comfortably off. 
 Just over two years ago she benefited very considerably from the will of a chap called William Coombes, who was senior partner in one of the second-rank stockbrokers. 
 They do all right, those chaps, even after taxes. 
 She got about two hundred thousand and a life interest in another two hundred thou. 
 The family wanted to dispute the will, and that's when Angela &mdash; Miss Morgan &mdash; came to us for advice. 
 Well, Coombes was only sixty-two when he died &mdash; it was a heart attack, there was nothing wrong with his brains. 
 The family didn't have a leg to stand on and so I advised. 
 They caved in; I mean it was only a sister and a niece, and they'd both been provided for during his lifetime and  the niece got a couple of hundred thou in his will. 
 But the niece was very bitter about it &mdash; I had to write a letter to her solicitors a year or so later because she'd been bothering Angela long after the estate was settled.&equo; 
 McLeish thought his way through this one, drawing a diagram on the edge of his notes. 
 &bquo;Miss Morgan got some of it just for life? 
 Who gets it now, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;The niece, the one I've been telling you about. 
 Penelope Huntley. 
 I can give you the address of her solicitors &mdash; Kenwards, two-partner firm in Kensington. 
 I'll look for it. 
 Go on asking me things.&equo; 
 &bquo;How old is Miss Huntley?&equo; 
 &bquo;Same age as Angela. 
 I agree, she would not normally have expected the remainder to fall in and be useful to her, but of course if she had had children, it would have been valuable to them.&equo; 
 &bquo;But if you were Penelope Huntley you might not have been consoled by the thought that your children would inherit after Miss Morgan's death.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I wouldn't. 
 Nor was she.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorry?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what she kept writing to Angela about. 
 Her lawyer had advised her that she could, by agreement with Angela, break the trust. 
 They're both &mdash; were both &mdash; well over twenty-one, and they could have made a deal which  essentially bought out Angela's life interest for a capital sum and then Miss Huntley would have got the rest.&equo; 
 McLeish thought that it seemed a reasonably sensible plan. 
 &bquo;Is that very difficult to do?&equo; he asked, cautiously. 
 &bquo;No. 
 It's a routine valuation exercise based on actuarial tables. 
 I don't think it would have done Miss Huntley a lot of good financially though, given that Angela was only twenty-nine and actuarially good for another forty years.&equo; 
 McLeish considered him with pleasure. 
 His last interview with a solicitor had been conducted in a language barely recognizable as English and it had taken over three hours and a reference to the Chief Constable to elicit the fact that the deceased had made a previous will in which the respective positions of his wife and his mistress had been exactly reversed. 
 As McLeish had observed to a colleague at the ti me, he'd have understood the whole performance if the solicitor in question had been going to marry either of them, but there had been no question of that, it was just obfuscation for its own sake. 
 He decided, to make sure he had this clear. 
 &bquo;So Miss Morgan would have got the lion's share of the other two hundred thousand even if she had  agreed to break up the trust? 
 Yes? 
 Then why did she not agree to it? 
 Or was she going to?&equo; 
 Timothy Hutton stopped hunting in the file. 
 He spread both hands on the table in an aid to thought and McLeish noticed how long the fingers were. 
 &bquo;Sorry. 
 She wouldn't do it at the time, because she felt the whole issue ought to be allowed to settle down. 
 It was very difficult, you know &mdash; Miss Huntley was bitter and there was an extremely unpleasant scene in Kenwards's offices. 
 The partner there was terribly embarrassed, rang me up and apologized for hours afterwards, couldn't get him off the phone. 
 So Angela didn't want to get involved &mdash; she didn't need the capital, after all &mdash; and she said to me she might do it in a year or so when Miss Huntley had calmed down.&equo; 
 He gazed at his hands, and visibly played this back to himself, then looked across at McLeish, and put his glasses on. 
 &bquo;Look, I'm not saying Angela actually refused. 
 Sorry, I can  hear how it sounds. 
 She said &mdash; or rather I did, to her solicitors &mdash; that she would consider it again in a year or so when everyone was calmer.&equo; 
 McLeish flipped back through his notes. 
 Catherine was so quiet that she might as well not have been in the room and it occurred to him that he must train her to make some unobtrusive signal to him when she thought he was missing something. 
 &bquo;You said, Mr Hutton, that a letter had been written.&equo; 
 Her cool voice, with the slight nasal edge of Stoke on Trent, came from behind him, and Timothy Hutton looked up sharply. 
 &bquo;Did I? 
 Well, yes, there was one. 
 Not to me, to Angela, but she showed it to me.&equo; 
 His glance towards the file told them precisely where that letter was and McLeish asked for it promptly. 
 Hutton extracted it with every evidence of reluctance. 
 &bquo;Bit hysterical,&equo; he said, apologetically. 
 Yes, indeed, McLeish thought, working his way through the letter. 
 &bquo;Is this a copy?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no, it's the original. 
 That's how it came. 
 Penelope Huntley must have thought about it. 
 Not exactly guaranteed to encourage my client to do anything.&equo; 
 &bquo;What did you do?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wrote a snotty letter to the poor chap at Kenwards &mdash; I rang him up first, of course, he was embarrassed all over again &mdash; asking him to ask his client to leave mine alone. 
 I'll get you a copy.&equo; 
 He reached his hand for a bell, but Catherine's voice checked him. 
 &bquo;So, as matters stand, that &pound;200,000 passes to Miss Huntley? 
 It doesn't matter what Miss Morgan's will says.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, that's right. 
 It is part of William Coombes's estate and passes under his will.&equo; 
 He looked at her carefully to see he had made himself clear, then resumed his search through the file. 
 &bquo;You wanted to know what was in Angela's will &mdash; the one we're going to prove, that is. 
 I'll get you a copy, but it's absolutely straightforward. 
 It's left to her sister, after decent legacies for both parents and small ones to charity, and to her sister's children if the sister predeceases. 
 Sorry, irrelevant now, of course. 
 It's the sort of will young women without husbands or children do make. 
  The second one &mdash; the one she made a couple of weeks ago &mdash; i-s a bit more complicated, but not much. 
 Giles Hawick would have got &pound;100,000 outright, her sister and various charities got small legacies, and the rest was to be in trust for children.&equo; 
 &bquo;What if there weren't any?&equo; 
 &bquo;Her sister Jennifer would have got it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let me see I have it right,&equo; McLeish said, after a pause. 
 &bquo;If she had married before she died, the sister would only have got a small legacy. 
 But Miss Huntley would still inherit &pound;200,000 on Miss Morgan's death, whenever that happened.&equo; 
 Timothy Hutton nodded and took his glasses off, and McLeish realized that he didn't actually need them. 
 &bquo;You haven't asked me what's in the estate, and I've got a list of assets here.&equo; 
 He passed it over the table, and courteously got up to give Catherine a second copy. 
 The problem item appeared right at the bottom of the page, in what McLeish decided was characteristic legal style &mdash; you didn't hide it, you just put it last, after the long respectable list of &pound;20,000 
 ICI loan stock, and 7,000 25p shares in Sainsbury. 
 &bquo;This is a loan of &pound;100,000 to Yeo Davis? 
 Her employers?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, it's the amount she was asked to put up when she became a partner last year.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that usual?&equo; 
 &bquo;Difficult to say.&equo; 
 Timothy Hutton was looking uncomfortable and McLeish said that it just seemed a lot to him. 
 &bquo;I mean, I imagine a lot of people might have difficulty raising that much?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes and no. 
 She drew something like &pound;30,000 from the partnership last year. 
 People can borrow on that. 
 But I did think it was a lot, and I tell you why: I can't really see what a group of professionals charging fees like that needs cash for . 
 When we started here we only put in about &pound;100,000 between four of us, to keep us going till the fees came in, and that was more than enough. 
 And Yeo Davis charge a good deal more than we do, I can tell you. 
 In some sense Angela may have been paying for the assets &mdash; they had assets valued at &pound;600,000 then, most of it in the lease on the building. 
 But you usually deal with that by giving new  partners uneven shares. 
 Say the profits come out at &pound;500,000, then senior partner gets &pound;200,000, second partner &pound;100,000 and so on. 
 It's not usual to make new partners put up a lot of cash.&equo; 
 McLeish contemplated this and decided he would have to find out more about Yeo Davis's financial affairs. 
 &bquo;What happens to that loan now?&equo; 
 It was Catherine again and McLeish was mildly irritated by the way she seemed to be ahead of him. 
 &bquo;I'm looking at the partnership agreement now&hellip; trm, trm, trm, here we are &mdash; death in partnership &mdash; well, it dissolves the partnership, course it does, but what happens to the money? 
 Ah yes, the partnership has a year to give it back. 
 I remember saying this was a bit leisurely, wasn't it, but there was some apparently reasonable explanation, like no one gave any notice that they were going to die and the partnership could be a bit pushed to produce the cash if it was the wrong time of year. 
 And of course none of us were particularly exercised about death as a real possibility. 
 As executor, I'll ask for it back formally, but I won't hold my breath. 
 It's interest-free, so I'd expect to get it in eleven months and twenty-nine days from giving notice.&equo; 
 The phone rang and Hutton picked it up, glancing at his watch. 
 &bquo;Yes, yes I know. 
 I'll be along as soon as I can&hellip; what, five minutes?&equo; 
 He looked enquiringly at McLeish. 
 &bquo;Fine.&equo; 
 He banged the phone down briskly and sat, clearly working out what else he could offer to get them to go. 
 Amused, McLeish said that he would be happy to wait in an outer office for copies of the various documents, or to have them sent on. 
 &bquo;What would happen if anyone just wanted to get out of the partnership &mdash; I mean, without a death being involved?&equo; 
 McLeish asked, as they stood up. 
 &bquo;Six months' notice, both ways, and any loans repaid within that period. 
 Pretty much a standard period. 
 Lots of provisions against stealing clients subsequently, of course.&equo; 
 As Timothy Hutton's attention was openly on whatever his next problem was, McLeish decided to leave, and to  extract anything else he needed from the documents. 
 He did now at least know roughly what was in them. 
 In the event, they went back to Scotland Yard so that McLeish could get to a phone and check with his secretary, and with Bruce Davidson, who was co-ordinating the evidence as it came in. 
 &bquo;Forensic rang,&equo; Bruce reported dourly. 
 &bquo;The autopsy report is on its way, so they say, usual rubbish about typing difficulties. 
 He wanted to speak to you but I said you had a string of interviews, so he coughed up to me, nae bother. 
 Killed by a bang on the head from behind, massive bleeding inside the brain. 
 Small contusion on the right cheek as well. 
 He went on a while about the various tests but where he came out was that she'd been dead for at least five days, and seven was perfectly possible. 
 Nae bloody use at all.&equo; 
 McLeish silently agreed with that judgement. 
 That left at least forty-eight hours from Angela Morgan's disappearance when, as far as the forensic evidence went, she could have been alive. 
 It was in his experience difficult for most people to prove conclusively exactly where they had been for any forty-eight-hour period, members of the Metropolitan police force always excepted, and this was going to make his life very difficult. 
 &bquo;You find anything useful from the scene-of-crime report? 
 I never got beyond page two this morning.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not a thing. 
 No weapon, no footprints, no fingerprints, all the bits of fibre caught on bushes came from the deceased's clothes.&equo; 
 &bquo;A clever one. 
 Car tracks?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean, yes?&equo; 
 &bquo;Lots of them. 
 Traces of at least a dozen different cars up that wee track that leads back to the road, and of two or three heavy vehicles, all very deeply indented. 
 The lads tell me it's a shooting estate &mdash; likely that's where people leave their cars.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh Christ.&equo;  
 &bquo;Well, someone knew that, didn't they, John?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 Yes, of course they did. 
 We have  got a clever one here. 
 I'll be in later, after six. 
 Hang on.&equo; 
 He picked up his phone to find the Cambridgeshire sergeant to whom he had spoken the day before on the line. 
 &bquo;I only didn't ring last night because I couldn't find you, sir. 
 Your blokes are on their way, but there are definitely bits of blood and hair on one of the metal parts of this thing &mdash; the truss, the bloke here says. 
 Could she have fallen on it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Jesus Christ. 
 Well done, Sergeant, thank you very much. 
 You haven't touched it &mdash; no, sorry, course you haven't. 
 I take it it's not something a murderer could pick up? 
 No, I thought not.&equo; 
 The voice at the other end warmed. 
 &bquo;I was surprised too, sir, you know. 
 I only looked for the sake of form. 
 I took a picture last night and put a plastic bag on and told the farmer we weren't going to put him in jail here and now. 
 He can account for his movements, as it happens. 
 He was in Northumberland with the wife's mother for ten days, only got back three days ago. 
 Well, she's been dead longer than that, hasn't she?&equo; 
 &bquo;He still around?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, that's the point. 
 He's a bit upset, and he doesn't need to be. 
 I'll tell him &mdash; I think that's your blokes now, I'll get them to ring you.&equo; 
 McLeish put down the phone, heavily. 
 &bquo;She fell back on it, assuming it's her blood.&equo; 
 &bquo;Accident?&equo; 
 Bruce Davidson said, and McLeish gave it thought. 
 &bquo;No. 
 How did she get there? 
 There must have been someone else around. 
 Unless she crawled to the edge of the embankment &mdash; I suppose it's possible, but she can't have walked to the spot in the first place.&equo; 
 He gazed at his subordinate. 
 &bquo;This is silly. 
 We'll wait for the lads up there to tell us about the blood and we'll read the autopsy report. 
 What else can we do while we &bquo;re waiting?&equo; 
 &bquo;One of the appointments we found in Miss Morgan's diary was with a Miss Huntley. 
 She was due to have lunch with Miss Morgan last week apparently &mdash; she is on the  phone, I looked. 
 Didn't want to talk to me, so I told her she'd have to wait.&equo; 
 Miss Huntley? 
 McLeish thought. 
 Ah yes, the hysterical Penelope, niece of the late William Coombes. 
 &bquo;Now, her I do want to see. 
 Fix a date for tomorrow, Bruce. 
 Anything else?&equo; 
 &bquo;Aye, a wee message from one of Francesca's young men at the Department. 
 She's been delayed &mdash; she doesn't think she'll get back to London until Thursday, now. 
 Sorry to bring you more bad news.&equo; 
 McLeish grunted, feeling meanly triumphant that he had turned out to be right in his view that Francesca would not be able to sweep Tristram out of the hands of the New York police in quite the Napoleonic way she had assumed. 
 And he had been perfectly justified, he assured himself smugly, in cancelling their holiday plans at once &mdash; she had never been going to get back on time. 
 Feeling vindicated and far-seeing, he strode off to collect Catherine and finish his coffee. 
 Over at the Department of Trade and Industry the news that Francesca would not be back before Thursday morning was being received with open dismay. 
 Bill Westland CB, MC, the fifty-five-year-old Deputy Secretary responsible for both personnel matters and regional policy, cursed heartily. 
 He summoned his junior, Rajiv Sengupta, a rising star of thirty-six who had the job of co-ordinating financial assistance to industry in the regions, to worry with him. 
 He derived some comfort from Rajiv's habitual elegance; wearing a suit, shirt and tie that must have cost two months of his salary as an Assistant Under-Secretary of State, he was sitting at the other side of the large, uncompromising desk that the Department provides for its most senior officials, not a hair out of place and his black eyes alive with amusement.  
 &bquo;What are we going to do with Professor Thornton tomorrow?&equo; 
 Bill Westland appealed, hopelessly. 
 &bquo;You and I and Henry will be with the Minister at the Select Committee all afternoon, and we'll have to be on call to brief all morning. 
 I was depending on Francesca to look after Thornton, and give him lunch and introduce him around, since she'll be working with him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why is Francesca delayed?&equo; 
 Rajiv asked. 
 &bquo;Some problem with the New York legal system. 
 Or she's staying to thank O'Brien personally &mdash; I really don't know.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't seem to have much control of your god-daughter.&equo; 
 &bquo;None whatsoever, as well you know, Rajiv. 
 You're no use either, and you taught her for three years at Cambridge. 
 Never mind that: at ten o'clock tomorrow we have Professor Thornton, distinguished economist, Oxford don and friend of the Prime Minister, here for five weeks to do a study on how effective regional assistance is, and we have no one to meet him. 
 Now what do we do?&equo; 
 &bquo;Send him to a regional office?&equo; 
 Rajiv offered. 
 &bquo;Without someone from here to look after him? 
 Heaven forbid.&equo; 
 &bquo;Give him to the Chief Statistician?&equo; 
 &bquo;To Gerhard ? 
 Even if we get him to comb his hair, it'll be too much of a shock for Professor Thornton.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh come now, Bill, Oxford senior common rooms are full of people quite as untidy and generally as odd as Gerhard. 
 Last ti me I dined at Balliol I sat next to the Regius Professor of Chemistry, aged around 193, who told me about his visit to Egypt before the war, probably the Boer War. 
 His teeth didn't fit awfully well, so I couldn't be sure. 
 Gerhard is at least intelligible.&equo; 
 Bill Westland, grinned, sidetracked. 
 &bquo;You know the story about Gerhard, looking as he usually does, standing on the steps of Horseguards after a Cabinet Committee, when a kindly person sidled up to him and gave him a quid to buy himself breakfast?&equo; 
 &bquo;I have always assumed it to be apocryphal.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not at all, dear boy, I was there . 
 Gerhard thought it a charming example of English eccentricity and placed the  quid tenderly in the mince-stained pocket of whatever Oxfam-reject he was wearing. 
 I suppose it's not a bad idea to get him to entertain Thornton.&equo; 
 He seized the telephone, and, ruthlessly disrupting Sir Gerhard's morning, imposed a guest on him for lunch. 
 &bquo;In the afternoon the good Professor Thornton can come and watch us and the Minister defending the assistance given to Willis Engineering,&equo; Rajiv pointed out, eyes bright with malice, and Bill Westland winced. 
 &bquo;It is, of course, precisely what he ought to be seeing,&equo; he agreed, reluctantly. 
 &bquo;As an expos&eacute; of the soft underbelly of our policy on regional assistance, Willis Engineering has no equal. 
 I suppose so, Rajiv, I suppose so, but he is not  to come to the briefing. 
 Then what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, by Wednesday I'm clear of the Committee, and I could take him to a Regional Office. 
 If I must.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, you must, but not Birmingham. 
 After last week's announcement that its development-area status is being removed, the staff are all cowering under their desks while the population throw bricks through the windows. 
 What about Manchester &mdash; virtually everyone there has applied for selective financial assistance? 
 Can you keep him there overnight? 
 Good, then Francesca can do the honours from Thursday and work for him thereafter. 
 She's got the troops and it's right up her street, she can get on with anyone.&equo; 
 &bquo;What age of man is he?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mm, hang on. 
 Fifty-two, married to an American, four children but three are steps, girls; his own boy is only eight. 
 Fellow of Balliol, went to Harvard in his late thirties, came back five years ago. 
 Lots and lots of long, distinguished, incomprehensible books on econometrics.&equo; 
 &bquo;Frannie's maths was never any good,&equo; Rajiv warned. 
 &bquo;This may be beyond her.&equo; 
 &bquo;She'll find a way,&equo; her godfather said, with perfect confidence. 
 &bquo;I just wish she was here now. 
 I've got enough to worry about without Professor Thornton.&equo; 
 Interesting that the offices of Yeo Davis should be very much less at the leading edge of modern design than the  solicitors' which they had just seen, McLeish thought, and murmured as much to Catherine Crane, who laughed. 
 &bquo;It's like all the Italian restaurants used to be, isn't it? 
 Lots of black and white tiles and plants and arches.&equo; 
 McLeish was considering the possible relationship between design and organizational style when Peter Yeo himself came down to fetch them. 
 &bquo;Nice to meet you, Chief Inspector,&equo; he said with automatic politeness, then considered what he had just said, decided it was beyond explanation and led them upstairs to his office. 
 This echoed the prevailing Italian-restaurant theme, except for the large comfortable mahogany desk which featured reassuring and recognizable objects like drawers and blotters. 
 Peter Yeo himself was an old-fashioned and recognizable object, McLeish thought, seeing him against the rapidly fading light from the window. 
 It had been Bruce Davidson who had interviewed Yeo before, when Angela Morgan had still been officially only a Missing Person and Peter Yeo, as her employer, one of the obvious people to talk to about where she might be. 
 He considered him as he caused coffee to be produced and established them at the big table at the other end of his room. 
 Given a choice, you would have taken him rather than Timothy Hutton for a solicitor. 
 With his conventional double-breasted suit, carefully cut to disguise a distinctly stocky figure, and his watchful courtesy he was in sharp contrast to Hutton's hard-edged efficiency. 
 The difference was partly generational; this man must be ten years older than Hutton. 
 The real distinction however, McLeish thought in a flash of revelation, lay in their clients' expectations. 
 Yeo Davis's business was concerned with representing people who did not know the ropes, or even that there were any ropes; Hutton's predominantly with fellow professionals in other fields who just wanted the best and swiftest way through. 
 So Peter Yeo had  to look reassuring and solid and a bit older, while Timothy Hutton could probably have come to work in striped organza without losing a single client. 
 He abandoned this line of observation and looked carefully at the man inside the suit. 
 The impression of suppressed energy which he had received as he arrived was  intensified; Peter Yeo could barely sit still and was discharging tension by moving papers on his desk, then fiddling with the Venetian blinds to prevent the sun from shining in Catherine's eyes. 
 The bright blue eyes looked a bit bloodshot, and there was a flush of colour across the cheekbones. 
 Yeo rubbed the back of his neck irritably, and reached for his coffee, downing two cups while McLeish and Catherine Crane were still passing each other milk and sugar. 
 A thick weekend, McLeish decided, trying to think how best to establish what Yeo's relationship had been with the dead girl. 
 He started, as he had intended, from where the last interview had left off and went quickly over the ground again. 
 &bquo;Last Friday, yes, ten days ago, was the last time I saw her,&equo; Yeo confirmed. 
 &bquo;Around five o'clock &mdash; she left early because she was meeting Giles. 
 Giles Hawick, yes. 
 She was spending the night with him before he went off for a walking weekend in Derbyshire. 
 She didn't want to go with him because she had too much to do, what with the wedding. 
 As I told you, I didn't particularly take in her plans for the weekend, you know how one doesn't, one just asks to be civil and doesn't listen properly to the answer.&equo; 
 He met McLeish's eye and blinked. 
 &bquo;That must sound remarkably silly to a policeman. 
 Sorry, I'm afraid I'm still baffled by all this. 
 What on earth can have happened? 
 I understand she was found not all that far from her parents' house? 
 But she wasn't planning to go to her parents &mdash; I know because I rang them on Tuesday when she still hadn't turned up.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wondered if she might have come into the office on the Saturday?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not while I was here. 
 I was in&hellip; oh, from about ten o'clock to well after lunch, and I wouldn't have thought she would come in late in the afternoon. 
 I mean, it's not a bad idea, Chief Inspector. 
 She often was in on Saturday. 
 We own the building and all the partners have keys, so unless someone else was here she could  have been in and out without anyone noticing.&equo; 
 &bquo;I see. 
 You left at what time?&equo;  
 &bquo;Well, about three. 
 I was going to have lunch with a client but it got cancelled, so I just stayed here. 
 There's a kitchen here, we have a girl who comes in and cooks lunch during the week and there's always cheese and things around. 
 I killed a rather good bottle of Fleurie, as I remember it. 
 I went to the flicks &mdash; I wanted to see Some Like It Hot  for about the tenth time and it was being revived at Baker Street. 
 I knew my wife didn't want to see it at all. 
 Then I came back here to change, before I joined my wife at a dinner party. 
 Angie wasn't here then, either.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about Sunday? 
 Did you go to the office?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I didn't. 
 We spent the day with friends.&equo; 
 That left a large space of time on Saturday where there was little possibility of establishing that Peter Yeo had been where he said he was. 
 But the man himself seemed to be unconcerned about this. 
 &bquo;One or other of my partners is usually in the office on a Saturday. 
 It happened that none of them were, last week. 
 In fact it's so regular that Fiona &mdash; that's the girl who does our weekday lunches &mdash; is under instructions to leave something we can eat for Saturday lunch.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you tell her how many are likely to be here?&equo; 
 Catherine had decided to ask a question. 
 Yeo thought about it. 
 &bquo;Depends &mdash; I mean, if I knew I had a team coming of course I'd tell her. 
 But otherwise I just reckon there will be something around &mdash; or if the locusts have been at the fridge, well, I can always go out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can you remember what you ate?&equo; 
 Peter Yeo considered her, as the reason for her question sank in. 
 &bquo;Actually I can. 
 I had an enormous slice of quiche that was left over from Friday. 
 I felt afterwards it would have been better not to make such an effort to finish it all. 
 Fiona will probably remember.&equo; 
 He sounded mildly offended but not in the slightest bit rattled. 
 &bquo;I think Some Like It Hot  started around three-thirty but I can't quite remember. 
 I walked down &mdash; it's not far, and I was feeling rather full of quiche.&equo; 
 That will check, McLeish thought, of course it will, someone just has to do it all. 
 That means at some stage we  may have to see Mrs Yeo. 
 In fact, he decided, he would be interested to see a wife who accepted with such apparent equanimity her husband's absence on a Saturday. 
 Presumably, however, the senior partner in Yeo Davis was hardly needed to do the odd household chore. 
 Which brought him to consider the Yeo Davis partnership; how did it work? 
 How important to it had Angela Morgan been? 
 He decided to start as softly as possible. 
 &bquo;Groups like yours are a bit outside my experience,&equo; he confided, &bquo;and I need to understand a bit about what Miss Morgan did for a living. 
 Could you tell me, perhaps with an example?&equo; 
 He observed from the way peter Yeo gathered himself and sat up straight that he was on familiar territory, and understood further that the general patter was well rehearsed. 
 It was, for obvious reasons, a great deal less incisive than Francesca's summary, but the same skeleton was recognizable under the attractive padding placed round it by Peter Yeo. 
 Much emphasis was put on the importance of identifying the key decision-takers and making sure that they had the right information &mdash; much was made of the necessity of their getting a balanced picture on which to take their decisions. 
 &bquo;Ours is not unlike the job of a good barrister,&equo; Peter Yeo observed, reaching a peroration. 
 &bquo;We try to make sure the judge has all the facts before arriving at a decision. 
 Mostly we do this by ensuring that our client gets to talk to the decision-takers. 
 There is no point at all in my  talking to those people, except on a preliminary basis; they're not that interested in my views. 
 I do the background briefing but the clients have to do most of the work, and so I always tell them.&equo; 
 McLeish decided this was good stuff from which, but for Francesca, he would have gained no clear idea of what a firm like Yeo's was really for. 
 &bquo;So you would, for instance, have lunch with people in government departments to talk to them about particular policies.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, often that is the best way to start. 
 We've got a lot of friends whom we can talk to about a policy generally,  and where we can put a word in. 
 Let me try and think of an example that isn't confidential. 
 Yes. 
 One of our clients is Andy Barton, who runs the biggest textile group in the north-west. 
 Well, the DTI is at this moment considering giving money to keep Huerter, one of his main rivals, going. 
 A Conservative government, if you believe their manifesto, ought not even to be considering putting money into dying private-sector firms, but Huerter employ a lot of people, many of whom voted for this government. 
 One of the last things Angela did was to have lunch with an old schoolfriend in the DTI who is responsible for the Huerter case, to make sure the DTI understood the impact of such assistance on Barton's operations.&equo; 
 &bquo;And did it?&equo; 
 McLeish asked. 
 &bquo;Oh yes, but Angela was clear that the civil servants were going nonetheless to recommend assisting Huerter. 
 They've been rescuing companies for so long they do it automatically now, I expect. 
 So that told us that we had better get a full-scale defence working immediately.&equo; 
 McLeish, who had understood from Francesca's report of her lunch that she and her seniors were indeed going to push for assistance, was amused to hear that she had not succeeded in disguising her intentions from Miss Morgan. 
 &bquo;Can you tell me what you are going to advise your client now? 
 I mean, what is a full-scale defence?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, well it varies. 
 I've got Andy Barton in to see the Minister responsible at the DTI. 
 I'm keeping the Secretary of State &mdash; that's the top man &mdash; in reserve. 
 And, of course, we are arranging to brief Treasury people, who will automatically be opposed to giving away public money; and we are working with the company on a memorandum on what assistance to Huerter would do to Barton, with a two-page bullet-point summary. 
 Politicians don't have time to read screeds, so you have to give them short, pithy things to look at, We were doing all this anyway, of course, but the chaps at Barton, including Andy, are working on it much more effectively since we were able to say definitely that the DTI civil servants were agin them. 
 These chaps, good blokes who've spent all their lives running businesses, believed the government manifesto and thought that if  they shouted loud enough in the local paper, Whitehall would crumble and right would prevail. 
 It's a bit more difficult than that.&equo; 
 That lunch had, in fact, given a considerable spur to a campaign being waged against the policy Francesca and her colleagues wanted, McLeish observed. 
 The point of Yeo Davis was now clear: they were there to inform, inspire, and orchestrate a client's efforts to get what he wanted, as efficiently as possible. 
 &bquo;I've read about people giving MPs  expensive lunches,&equo; he said, with interest. 
 &bquo;Waste of time,&equo; Peter Yeo said briskly. 
 &bquo;The good ones don't have time for long drunken lunches, and you get better results by getting them to give you and the client a sandwich in a bar at six p.m. 
 The ones you can get for lunch &mdash; there are plenty &mdash; will likely forget every word you tell them, and they certainly don't feel obliged to help.&equo; 
 He caught McLeish's eye. 
 &bquo;Sorry, but the fact is the average backbench MP doesn't know anything, unlike the average civil servant who really does know about his or her particular area. 
 It's only worth using MPs to have a go at the government, and then you spoon-feed it to them.&equo; 
 The man had come to life very considerably in discussing his job and a formidable personality was emerging. 
 McLeish decided he would have to abandon any prejudice taken from Francesca about this trade; Peter Yeo knew his business and was obviously effective. 
 And it was a good thing Yeo Davis existed; McLeish himself had often been quietly riled by the intellectual scorn which Francesca and her colleagues would bring to bear on criticism of some of their more sweeping policies. 
 It might well have been necessary to invent Yeo Davis if they hadn't already existed. 
 He reminded himself that he was talking to the inventor of the firm and decided to prod a bit further. 
 &bquo;How long have you been in this field?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've spent all my life in general PR, but it was about eight years ago I decided that there was room for a specialist agency, not really a PR firm, which was concerned entirely with government relations. 
 Government in the widest sense, including our masters in Brussels. 
 I have  &mdash; &mdash; had &mdash; four partners, and we have another twenty people working for us.&equo; 
 McLeish glanced at the clock on Yeo's desk and saw that he was running behind ti me, as tended to happen at this stage in an investigation when you needed to be in six places at once. 
 He considered his notes; what he needed from this interview was to confirm that Angela Morgan had not been in the office on Saturday, and a statement of Peter Yeo's movements over the period within which Angela Morgan had probably been killed. 
 He also did need to understand the financial side. 
 &bquo;Was Miss Morgan about the same age as the rest of your partners?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no, she was the youngest by a good five years. 
 She is &mdash; was &mdash; outstandingly able, that's why I asked her to join us.&equo; 
 McLeish noted the absence of reference to the other partners. 
 Yeo Davis, evidently, c'est moi  as far as Peter Yeo was concerned. 
 &bquo;I'd like to confirm what the financial arrangements were. 
 I mean how much did she get paid, and how much capital was she asked to put up, that sort of thing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, I suppose you do. 
 Well, you understand about partnerships, do you? 
 None of the partners here is actually entitled to a salary; in theory we split the profits in accordance with a formula that we fix annually and that takes account of age, and experience and what people are contributing in terms of work or clients. 
 As a matter of practice, and because we've all got to live, we all draw about two-thirds of what we would have got last year as we go along, then share out the rest at the end of the year.&equo; 
 McLeish contemplated this system and its possible application to the Metropolitan police force and felt imagination boggle. 
 He himself would have been desperately pushed if he had had to manage on two-thirds of his salary until Christmas every year. 
 A moment's thought told him that this system worked only because two-thirds of the expected total of a Yeo Davis partnership came out at an amount well in excess of his salary, or that of any public servant of his age. 
 He asked what Angela Morgan had been drawing  on every month and found his belief confirmed. 
 Christmas must be worth having at Yeo Davis. 
 &bquo;What about tax?&equo; he asked, still considering the mechanics of the system. 
 &bquo;All partners are technically self-employed but in order to prevent them from getting into a frightful mess we deduct a percentage from their drawings, so there is something put aside for tax. 
 I'd have to say it's a great deal lower percentage than most employed people pay because there are all sorts of expenses a partnership can claim. 
 If we seem to have got it wrong, we sort it out when we divvy up the profit.&equo; 
 McLeish made a conscientious note, feeling that he had got himself sidetracked off the more interesting question of Angela Morgan's capital investment in Yeo Davis. 
 Finding no way other than the direct question, he put it, and watched Yeo, unruffled, confirm that she had indeed put up &pound;100,000. 
 &bquo;The rest of us had put up much the same, given that we had done it earlier,&equo; he assured McLeish. 
 &bquo;It seems a lot, but we have employees, I can tell you, below partner level, who would be prepared to mortgage their children to get a partnership here. 
 And Angela didn't need to borrow &mdash; I imagine you've talked to her solicitors? 
 Well then, you know that she was pretty well placed.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't know that a business like this needed much working capital?&equo; 
 McLeish said, in faithful imitation of Timothy Hutton. 
 &bquo;Oh, you'd be surprised. 
 We live off fees, of course, but they can be slow coming in. 
 And this is a short lease here &mdash; we have to provide for buying something or paying a hell of a lot more rent. 
 No, that sort of money is needed, believe me.&equo; 
 McLeish, who had a built-in prejudice, well supported by experience, against statements incorporating an appeal to belief, noted dourly that he might at some later stage need to get closer to Yeo Davis's accounts. 
 That could wait, and he would possibly talk to Timothy Hutton again first. 
 He wound up the interview and was rising to say goodbye  when Catherine, sounding shy, asked Peter Yeo if she could possibly use their ladies' room. 
 &bquo;Of course, of course.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo was obviously delighted to do any service, however modest, for her and bustled her away, returning belatedly to ask McLeish if he would like a similar facility, which he accepted, obedient to the unwritten CID rule that you looked after your physical needs at any moment that opportunity offered, because you never knew when you were going to get stuck for hours without help. 
 He waited what seemed to him rather an excessive ti me for Catherine, but decided, charitably, that you couldn't look as she did without pretty regular attention to the overall effect. 
 They were in the car, preparing to drive off, before she spoke. 
 &bquo;There's a nice little flatlet on the second floor. 
 Bathroom, bedroom with double bed, kitchen off. 
 I thought there might be.&equo; 
 He looked at her sideways; she sounded both smug and irritated. 
 &bquo;You think it's misused regularly?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd put money on it.&equo; 
 The response was so swift and unhesitating that McLeish was taken aback, and drove much too close to the car in front. 
 &bquo;Sorry. 
 You thought he was that kind of bloke?&equo; 
 She was silent, and pink across the cheekbones &mdash; and McLeish, who like all good policemen depended heavily on intuition, understood suddenly that experience was speaking here. 
 She laughed shortly, obviously annoyed with herself but determined to make her point. 
 &bquo;Well, let's say that I've heard of married blokes who always had to go to the office on Saturdays, and it usually wasn't office work they were doing. 
 It sounds all right, and if the wife gets suspicious and rings up, well he's there, isn't he?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not so good if the wife decides to drop in,&equo; McLeish offered, with interest. 
 &bquo;Well, you have to keep the office door locked on a Saturday, don't you? 
 So you've got warning,&equo; she said dismissively, and McLeish let himself, briefly, wonder who the bloke had been who had introduced Catherine to this  experience. 
 He abandoned speculation firmly and concentrated on the implications for the present case, since he was plainly being offered expert testimony. 
 &bquo;Could be that any of the other partners used it?&equo; he suggested. 
 &bquo;The place isn't run like that. 
 Mr Yeo is the boss, isn't he?&equo; 
 So she too had observed Yeo's imperial command of the partnership. 
 &bquo;No, I agree. 
 So he was maybe with a girl on that Saturday?&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe. 
 I was wondering about him and Miss Morgan. 
 I mean, he likes women, and she operated by sleeping with the boss.&equo; 
 McLeish found himself shocked by this piece of feminine sharpness and must have registered something because his sergeant blushed. 
 &bquo;I don't mean that like it sounds &mdash; she didn't do it to get on, or not like that.&equo; 
 Her hands moved, in frustration as she tried to explain. 
 &bquo;I think she might have done it as a quick way of finding out how the business worked. 
 Because she was obviously both clever and ambitious.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mm.&equo; 
 McLeish found himself receiving this with reluctance and wondered why, since it made sense. 
 He glanced at her, being taken aback to find her looking strained and as near plain as anyone with her looks was going to. 
 Her profile was very sharp against the gathering darkness. 
 &bquo;What is it, love?&equo; he asked, anxiously, falling into a term of his childhood, and she jumped. 
 &bquo;Sorry, I'd drifted off. 
 I was wondering about Peter Yeo. 
 Suppose they had been having an affair, and she'd  dropped him?&equo; 
 McLeish considered this. 
 &bquo;When she met Giles Hawick?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, that's possible, isn't it? 
 If you remember, Hawick said &mdash; and he's not silly &mdash; that there was someone else on the scene when he first asked her out. 
 Perhaps it was Mr Yeo? 
 And she decided Hawick was the better bet, particularly since he wasn't married.&equo; 
 McLeish pondered this, eyes narrowed, driving fast but carefully. 
 &bquo;Perhaps there isn't all that much fun in going around with a married bloke, after all?&equo;  
 &bquo;She could still have wanted him but got tired of waiting &mdash; decided he wasn't going to leave his wife.&equo; 
 Catherine was sounding tough and rational, but something in her voice made him feel this whole discussion was uncomfortable for her. 
 He sneaked a look at her, and found he had an excellent view of the back of her head; she was staring out of the passenger window at the darkening vista of St James's Park. 
 He looked again, cautiously, and saw that she was blindly extracting a crumpled paper handkerchief from her neat navy bag. 
 He waited thirty seconds before glancing sideways again, and found her dabbing at her face, trying hard not to sniff. 
 He flicked up the left-hand indicator and stopped the car. 
 &bquo;I need some tea and I've got a thermos here,&equo; he announced, getting out of the car without looking at her and opening the back door on his side to find the thermos which he had filled before starting off. 
 He got the top off and a cup poured before lowering himself gingerly back into the driving seat and passing it over to Catherine. 
 Then he glanced quickly at her. 
 It was nearly dark outside but the dashboard lights cast a faint greenish glow. 
 She was still sitting with her head partly averted, so her face was hidden. 
 He poured himself a cup of tea and drank it, selfconsciously, very aware of her sitting tensely beside him. 
 &bquo;Thank you, John. 
 That was nice.&equo; 
 Catherine sounded suddenly exhausted, and as she gave him back the cup she turned towards him, letting him see that she had been crying, but without looking him in the face. 
 Looking down at the curve of her cheekbone, still wet with tears, he suddenly wanted her, quite overwhelmingly. 
 He sat frozen in his seat by surprise, so blocked by his own consideration of duty, honour and the right way to behave to junior staff that in the end it was she who moved towards him, and touched his cheek. 
 He slid his cheek against hers and, moving with delicious deliberate slowness, he kissed her on the lips. 
 The sheer pleasure of it swept him up and it was a full minute before he pulled back and looked at her, amazed at how happy he felt.  
 &bquo;Jesus, Catherine. 
 Another minute and I'll be inviting you into the back of the car.&equo; 
 He watched her smile, happy and comfortable with him, secure in the pleasure they shared. 
 &bquo;If you like, or we could go back to my flat?&equo; 
 For McLeish the rest of the journey had the quality of a dream. 
 With one part of his mind he knew he was getting the benefit of the backlash from an experience in Catherine's past, but with another part he didn't care about any of that, there was no reality beyond her. 
 The feeling of dream-like ease persisted when they arrived at Catherine's flat. 
 He opened the car door for her, hugged her as she got out, and they went up to her flat, his arm round her shoulders. 
 He took off her clothes for her, while she undid as many of his buttons as she could, and after that it was pure, undiluted, uncomplicated pleasure until they fell asleep in each other's arms. 
 Either Bruce Davidson always sounded like a Speak Your Weight machine when he was delivering a prepared statement, or the answer-phone stripped all character from People's voices. 
 McLeish had rung his own flat to collect messages; he could see Catherine just waking, and waved to her to indicate that he was on the phone. 
 He realized that he was getting cold, clad as he was exclusively in a rather small towel, but decided to stick it out and pick up all of Davidson's message. 
 There were two key pieces. 
 The first was the news from Cambridge: the samples of blood and hair collected by his long-suffering team were confirmed as a match to the dead girl's. 
 The indentation in her skull also matched. 
 She had either fallen or been pushed on to a spike on the plough; the level of her blood alcohol gave some credence to the idea that she had fallen. 
 The doctor who had done the autopsy, however, had scouted, promptly, any suggestion  that she could have moved thereafter. 
 She had died instantaneously, or pretty nearly so, without first getting up and crawling down the embankment, or for that matter getting up and riding a bicycle. 
 Someone had thus moved the body, and it had to be assumed that it was the same person who had pushed her on to the plough. 
 &bquo;Doc says the best bet, given the mark on her cheek is that someone slapped her one and she fell back. 
 He'll put it in writing tomorrow,&equo; Davidson summarized succinctly. 
 The second key piece of information was that Angela Morgan's car had been found in North Kensington, not far from her flat, and was now cordoned off and being crawled over inch by inch by a forensic team hastily dispatched by Davidson. 
 Did McLeish want to come and see it, in situ , because they would have to move it when Forensic had finished? 
 A detailed inventory of Bruce's day followed, and McLeish understood that having Catherine Crane working on this case had rattled Bruce in several ways. 
 Right at the end, as McLeish's teeth were starting to chatter, Davidson confirmed that Penelope Huntley would meet him at eight next morning and he hoped that that wasn't too early, sorry, but the lass had been difficult to tie down to a time. 
 McLeish glanced again at his watch &mdash; eleven-thirty p.m. 
 Just as well someone had rung Catherine half an hour ago, or they'd both still have been asleep, and he would have had difficult questions to answer in the morning about why he had been, uncharacteristically, out of touch with everyone since leaving Yeo Davis at six. 
 He rang Davidson to confirm that he could make the eight a. m. appointment. 
 &bquo;We have a date at eight o'clock,&equo; he said redundantly to Catherine. 
 &bquo;I heard. 
 I've put the heating on. 
 Why don't you have a bath, you're cold?&equo; 
 &bquo;I &bquo;d like that. 
 They've found her car, too &mdash; I'll have to go and look at it before they take it away.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll come with you.&equo; 
 He hesitated. 
 &bquo;Nothing I'd like better. 
 But they're all  going to wonder why I dragged you along at this time of night. 
 I mean, what have we been doing?&equo; 
 Catherine looked downcast, and McLeish felt uneasy. 
 &bquo;Sweet, it's you I'm trying to protect.&equo; 
 &bquo;And yourself.&equo; 
 McLeish acknowledged the point promptly. 
 &bquo;Both of us need protecting. 
 Old Stevenson would go spare if he knew, and I'm not certain whether he'd try and get me moved as a danger to junior staff, or you moved as a wicked woman. 
 But he'd shift one of us. 
 His staff do not have private lives and certainly not with each other.&equo; 
 She looked at him carefully; wrapped in a sheet, with her blond curly hair ruffled, she looked like an advertisement for almost anything. 
 &bquo;Sorry, you're right,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;It would be me he'd try and shift, too. 
 He's not got much of a reputation as a feminist.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Met's a bit short of those,&equo; McLeish agreed. 
 &bquo;Look, you get some sleep. 
 I'll go and see the car and get back to my flat, and I'll pick you up at seven-thirty tomorrow. 
 All right?&equo; 
 &bquo;You'd like to get home?&equo; 
 She was perfectly secure in her own attractions and amused, and McLeish was disconcerted. 
 &bquo;No, I mean&hellip; no. 
 I just thought you wouldn't want to be woken up again.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't mind being woken up.&equo; 
 He found himself avoiding the street in which Francesca lived as he drove for North Kensington, calling ahead on his car phone to make sure that the forensic team was still there. 
 He arrived to find them just finishing and asked hopefully if any prints had been found. 
 &bquo;No prints on the steering-wheel or any of the doors. 
 Somebody's been over it with a duster. 
 They probably wore gloves, too. 
 We've got some smudges but that's not a lot of use.&equo; 
 McLeish left them to it and walked away to consider exactly where he was. 
 It was a cul-de-sac off Ladbroke Grove, with two restaurants and two large pubs at the top of it. 
 The pub was orthodoxly darkened and shuttered, but  a few diners were still left in the restaurants. 
 It was a road on the way up, this Malplaquet Terrace, as McLeish, a Londoner by adoption, observed. 
 The two large pubs, the little Indian grocer, and the shabby peeling premises which offered dry-cleaning were relics of an earlier era, but both restaurants, on the other hand, were new and forbiddingly smart. 
 One was Italian, one French; both were separated from the street by extensive terraces and were distinctly expensive. 
 He peered at the menu displayed with accompanying admiring press comment outside the Trattoria San Giorgio, and decided you'd be lucky to get out of there under &pound;20 a head. 
 La Bretagne looked even pricier. 
 Next to these was a small antique shop, window lights on even at this hour, displaying elegant white china dogs and small pieces of Victorian furniture, and next to that an estate agent. 
 It would only be a matter of ti me before the pubs, the little grocer and the dry-cleaner's were replaced by some establishment selling something on which an enormous mark-up could be obtained. 
 As he walked back down the cul-de-sac McLeish found a demarcation line, so precise it might have been achieved by running a tape across the road, where the commercial element stopped and flat-fronted, early Victorian terraced houses, took over. 
 Further down yet, the terracing ceased and became pairs of large semi-detached houses set well back from the road with the front gardens mostly paved and dedicated to parking space. 
 It was possible to see the same sort of divide as at the commercial end: every second house had been restored and repainted, with extensions sprouting in the gaps between them. 
 Most of the others seemed to be in the process of renovation. 
 McLeish counted, out of interest, ten separate sets of scaffolding. 
 People would still be living here who had been in residence since before the war and were holding on to controlled tenancies until dislodged by offers of cash or other accommodation, but they would not be there much longer. 
 He had arrived back beside Angela Morgan's car, and stopped to contemplate it. 
 A blue BMW, neat but not gaudy, not souped-up, but a fast, useful car. 
 On her money she could well have afforded something grander, like a  Porsche, but evidently she had decided against ostentation. 
 It was the sort of car that a successful young man bought for himself, not a woman's car in the generally used sense of the phrase, nor a car that a man would choose for a woman. 
 It was neither the sensible shopping-basket that men bought for their wives, nor the flashy jobs rich men bought for their mistresses. 
 He looked at the number plate and realized that he had found the sole piece of ostentation Miss Morgan had allowed herself; she had been Angela Jane Morgan and the car was AJM 563. 
 She must have had to pay a bit for that. 
 The car was parked neatly between two patches of off-street parking, in one of the very few parts of the street that was neither metered nor dedicated to residents' parking. 
 Not put here by chance then; someone had known this street. 
 Assuming the car had gone missing at the same ti me as Angela Morgan, it might have been there for over a week; it had only been found that evening by a uniformed constable who was keeping his eyes open. 
 Evidently, people in this street were used to strange cars being parked and nobody had thought it worth while to ring the police, despite the fact that the doors bristled with Neighbourhood Watch signs. 
 Perhaps the car had not actually been there since Angela Morgan disappeared, but that seemed unlikely. 
 He asked the forensic team leader for his views and the man shook his head. 
 &bquo;I would think it's been here for several days, sir. 
 It's covered with dust and the road's dry underneath, although we've had a lot of rain.&equo; 
 &bquo;Anything useful?&equo; 
 &bquo;We've got some tiny samples from the tyres. 
 It's been in the mud somewhere. 
 We'll compare it with what we took up at the site.&equo; 
 &bquo;Could be the murderer used this car?&equo; 
 &bquo;He cleaned it first, then, before dumping it, sir. 
 Nothing on it, just a few smudges. 
 Probably put it through a car-wash. 
 The inside has been vacuumed recently, too. 
 We're not getting much here, apart from the samples off the tyres, We'll take it apart when we get it away from here, of course.&equo;  
 Both men stood aside to let a big dark-green Jaguar edge carefully round them on to the forecourt of the house immediately to the left of where the BMW was parked. 
 A small bouncy couple in their fifties got out, staring at the lights and the screens round Angela Morgan's car, and came over to them with all the confidence of the middle-class member of a Neighbourhood Watch scheme. 
 &bquo;Can I help? 
 That car's been parked there over a week, and I was just beginning to wonder about ringing the police. 
 Lots of people from the restaurants park down here in the evening, but I only just realized, talking to my wife, that it had actually been there all day as well. 
 Stolen car, is it?&equo; 
 McLeish, tired as he was, fell promptly on this witness and accepted an invitation to coffee. 
 The Masters had been out to dinner and were well mellowed, wide awake and disposed to chat, but sitting in their quarry-tiled kitchen-diner, with thousands of pounds' worth of elegant cabinet work and expensive machinery around him, McLeish managed to extract a coherent story. 
 Mr Masters was quite clear that he had first seen the blue BMW late on the Saturday evening, ten days before, pointing out that, while you couldn't exactly complain, it had made access to his own forecourt space a little difficult, or at least when there was already another car on the forecourt, which there mostly was, that being Mrs Masters's runabout. 
 He was sure it had been there every night since, and Mrs Masters turned out to be equally confident that it had also been there during the day. 
 They had looked at each other, disconcerted at this apparent lack of liaison, but McLeish had been reassuring: very natural that they hadn't compared notes, extremely useful that he now knew how long the car had been there. 
 &bquo;Was it stolen, Chief Inspector? 
 I mean, do chief inspectors look at stolen cars? 
 We've never seen much above a detective sergeant in the road before?&equo; 
 Mr Masters, mellow or not, had gathered his wits. 
 He was a small bright-eyed, balding, active man, interested in everything around him. 
 &bquo;Not necessarily. 
 We've been looking for this car as part  of a murder investigation. 
 It belonged to a Miss Angela Morgan, and you may have seen the death reported.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's the matter with me?&equo; 
 Mr Masters enquired, smiting himself on the forehead. 
 &bquo;I saw it in the papers, I even noticed that the car was missing, and it was a BMW. 
 I just didn't put it together.&equo; 
 &bquo;You would have, sooner or later,&equo; McLeish said, liking the man. 
 &bquo;That's what happens, something ticks away in your mind and you suddenly realize there's a connection. 
 We'll have to send people round all the houses in the street, see if anyone saw the person who left the car here.&equo; 
 &bquo;Could have been the girl herself?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, possibly.&equo; 
 McLeish decided not to expand, and rose to go, conscious that it was one-thirty a.m. 
 And that he had an interview at eight in the morning. 
 He found at the edge of his consciousness the wish that he was just going to his own flat to crash out rather than back to share Catherine's warm bed. 
 At eight a.m. it was pouring with rain, and very cold, as the partners of Yeo Davis straggled in through the neat entrance, their footsteps echoing on the tiles. 
 It was far too early for the immaculate and highly paid receptionist to be in; in fact, no one below the level of partner was present. 
 Peter Yeo, accustomed to leading from the front, had arrived at seven-thirty and personally made the coffee and brought in croissants, so that the reassuring presence of food greeted the other three partners. 
 &bquo;Sorry to get you here so early,&equo; he said, &bquo;but Angela's death means we have to reorganize the entire workload, and I wanted a longer meeting today. 
 There's a lot going on. 
 Tim, I'd like you to report on administrative matters first, to get that out of the way.&equo; 
 Tim Reagan, a gaunt forty-year-old, who was a genius with trade unions as well as being an accountant and Peter Yeo's right hand, moved swiftly through the secretarial problem, which was one of shortage of same, and seemed, as Peter Yeo observed pleasantly, to have been exactly the  same difficulty any time in the last two years, to a discussion of building security, in which no one was much interested either. 
 &bquo;The next problem is fees,&equo; Tim said, noticing sardonically that his partners' level of attention rose sharply. 
 &bquo;As you all know, we billed &pound;400,000 for our success fee to Regina Securities a good eleven months ago &mdash; they were one of Richard's clients.&equo; 
 He paused and the meeting observed a thirty-second silence in honour of Richard Fairley who had left the partnership a year previously for considerably more than a handful of silver, taking with him Regina Securities' main reason for being interested in paying Yeo Davis's bills. 
 &bquo;I've written, Peter's written, the solicitors have written. 
 Absolutely nothing has happened. 
 We need to decide whether to put in a writ or what.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have we tried lunch?&equo; the next most senior partner enquired hopefully, invoking what all felt to be the partnership's most powerful weapon. 
 &bquo;Oh God, yes.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo roused himself. 
 &bquo;Brady and I lunched, and we've talked several times. 
 He's been all sweetness and light, promised nothing and done ditto.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do we have  to sue?&equo; the questioner pressed, unhappily, and Tim Reagan considered him wearily. 
 &bquo;Mike, that &pound;400,000 sits in our last year's accounts as an asset &mdash; a debt someone owes us. 
 It's in this year's draft accounts too, but we have people called auditors who are going to recognize this bill, and ask all sorts of boring questions like why it has not been paid, whether it is likely to be paid, and if so when. 
 And if we can't produce some pretty credible answers then they won't allow that &pound;400,000 to sit in the accounts at the full value. 
 Either we'll have to take a very heavy discount on it, or we'll get our accounts qualified. 
 The other even more pressing reason is that we need the cash; we're running an overdraft and that's not funny with these interest rates.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo, who had been watching his partners, realized that he and Tim were not carrying the other two and decided to make another effort. 
 &bquo;The reason the auditors will give us trouble, Mike, is  that they have to certify that our accounts give a true and fair account of the financial state of the business. 
 And if we have &pound;400,000 in there which isn't really &pound;400,000, then the accounts don't tell you what's going on.&equo; 
 He watched grimly as Mike Laister, easily the best man with any drinks company, grasped the point. 
 &bquo;The business isn't worth what we thought it was, that's what you're saying?&equo; 
 &bquo;Right.&equo; 
 Tim Reagan was obviously relieved. 
 &bquo;Or it may  not be, but we won't know till we sue them.&equo; 
 &bquo;It'll take a long time in the courts, won't it, though?&equo; 
 Mike Laister was still clinging to his point of view. 
 &bquo;What we hope is that a writ will make them settle, Mike, at some level.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo sounded soothing. 
 &bquo;It'd better,&equo; Tim Reagan said. 
 &bquo;The administrators of Angela's estate are going to ask for her &pound;100,000 back. 
 They're not going to get it till the end of the notice period, which is twelve months, but we need the cash. 
 And we are behind with tax.&equo; 
 &bquo;We've got more than enough time to worry about that , Tim, and I'm sure the bank will cover us.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo spoke hastily. 
 &bquo;But do we now all agree that we should issue a writ against Regina? 
 I honestly don't believe there is any alternative.&equo; 
 His partners, brought to the sticking point, agreed, somewhat reproachfully, and passed on firmly to the question of who was going to take over which of Angela's clients. 
 &bquo;I will of course remain responsible for Barton, since I know Andy well,&equo; Peter Yeo said, firmly. 
 &bquo;But I'll need some support if I am to give him the service he wants. 
 Angela was doing a very good job there, taking him round the MPs he had to talk to.&equo; 
 Tim Reagan stirred. 
 &bquo;I did say to her that the man Andy should see was Giles Hawick himself. 
 It will in the end be a Treasury concern, and if the DTI is really going to be allowed to spend millions propping up Huerter, now that it's a different government, it's very much in Hawick's area. 
 Maybe she felt it was too awkward? 
 Or maybe she  felt she could do the briefing personally, as it were? 
 Did she do anything about that?&equo; 
 He observed with interest that his partner Peter Yeo was looking extremely uncomfortable. 
 &bquo;She would have, of course, but I don't know if she did.&equo; 
 He considered, scratching the side of his jaw. 
 &bquo;It's a good point, though, Tim, thank you. 
 I'll see what I can do with it. 
 There's a lot of work to do on that case &mdash; can I have Susy Harvey to assist?&equo; 
 Two of his partners protested promptly that the said Susy was fully deployed on their cases, and Peter Yeo settled down to reorganize the workload, emerging after ten minutes' hard negotiation with more or less the conclusion he had wanted. 
 &bquo;I can't do that thing on Saturday &bquo;&equo; he said apologetically to Tim Reagan, who, having sacrificed one of his staff in the arrangement, was mildly suggesting a reciprocal deal. 
 &bquo;I've promised to take Claudia away for the weekend, and she's not going to let me off it even though we're so shorthanded. 
 Can't blame her, really; there's never any time.&equo; 
 Tim Reagan, who would not have dared to give his French wife as little time as Claudia Yeo got, murmured that this was of course important and good luck to them, indeed. 
 &bquo;Something else I wanted to mention, Peter,&equo; he went on. 
 &bquo;If it turns out that &pound;400,000 really isn't there, then perhaps we charged Angela too much for her partnership share? 
 We were acting in good faith, of course, and I can't imagine that anyone is going to be difficult now she is gone. 
 Just thought I'd mention it &mdash; the auditors may say something like it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let them,&equo; Peter Yeo said, angrily. 
 &bquo;Angie had nothing to complain about &mdash; anyone would have been glad to put up &pound;100,000 to get in here. 
 That Regina fee is just a blip &mdash; we're on to a &pound;500,000 success fee from Barton, and we'll get that.&equo; 
 Tim Reagan raised his hands in mock submission, surprised by his partner's vehemence, and followed him out of the door. 
 In the hall sat Claudia Yeo herself, evidently waiting for  her husband, and Tim stopped to say hello to her. 
 She looked as if she needed that weekend away. 
 She was overweight, overtired, distinctly anxious, her hair was untidy, and both her suit and her shoes were in need of a clean. 
 Not what one expected of the wife of the senior partner, Tim observed, thinking smugly of his own immaculately turned-out Patrice, who would refuse to eat if she put on even an extra pound and who would as soon leave the house naked as without make-up. 
 &bquo;Oh, Peter, there you are.&equo; 
 His senior partner was not at all ravished by this incursion into his working day, Tim observed maliciously, as he faded tactfully away. 
 Peter Yeo bustled his wife into his office calling automatically for coffee. 
 &bquo;Claudia, I've got a meeting in ten minutes, then I'm booked solid through the day. 
 What is it? 
 Can it not wait till tonight?&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean, tonight? 
 Eleven-thirty or later, as usual? 
 Perhaps I ought to ring Dawn and make an appointment if I want to talk to you? 
 You never see the children either.&equo; 
 They glared at each other across the table, two people in early middle age who had had the same quarrel in the same words many times. 
 By mutual consent they desisted, and Peter Yeo took a deep breath. 
 &bquo;Sorry,&equo; he said, grimly. 
 &bquo;What is the problem?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've had the police round, asking about Angela.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo breathed deep in exasperation. 
 &bquo;Type of police? 
 Bobby in a helmet with a notebook, was it?&equo; 
 Claudia considered him with open dislike and lit a cigarette deliberately. 
 &bquo;No, dear, a CID sergeant from Scotland Yard. 
 A Scot. 
 I asked to see his identification. 
 And his assistant's.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll find you an ashtray. 
 Don't  put it in the saucer, Claudia, for God's sake.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo felt a headache starting, and felt the familiar pressure just above the right eye worsen with the realization that in precisely five minutes he would be needed in a meeting. 
 &bquo;What did he want to know?&equo; 
 She didn't answer immediately but looked down at the  table, then up at him. 
 &bquo;When I come to think about it afterwards, I don't know quite what he was after.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo controlled the impulse to shout at her, realizing that his wife was badly rattled. 
 She might exasperate him, but she was fully as intelligent as he was and it would be as well to get to the bottom of this. 
 &bquo;Did he say why he had come to see you?&equo; 
 &bquo;He had a perfectly good reason. 
 They had checked Angela's diary for the two weeks before she had gone missing and were talking to everyone in it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Including the clients?&equo; peter Yeo sat bolt upright, appalled. 
 &bquo;Oh God. 
 Well, I suppose so.&equo; 
 They stared at each other, momentarily united in recognition of the difficulties. 
 &bquo;I'll call them all, personally.&equo; 
 Yeo jabbed a finger on a button on his phone. 
 &bquo;Dawn, please get Angela's diary for the two weeks before she went missing &mdash; and last week &mdash; and list every date she had. 
 Now, please, in the next ten minutes. 
 Sorry, but this is a crisis.&equo; 
 He returned his attention to his wife. 
 &bquo;I didn't realize you had seen Angie quite recently.&equo; 
 &bquo;We had a drink together.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo rose abruptly and went to straighten a picture on the wall opposite him, his wife watching him warily. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; he asked over his shoulder. 
 &bquo;I didn't think you were all that friendly.&equo; 
 Claudia Yeo closed her eyes and forced herself to speak to the empty space behind the desk. 
 &bquo;I suppose I wanted to make sure she was going to marry Giles Hawick.&equo; 
 She dragged on her cigarette, listening for any movement from her husband behind her, and jumped as he walked round to stare out of a window. 
 &bquo;And she said she was?&equo; he asked, into the silence. 
 &bquo;Yes, she did. 
 But she also said Hawick wanted her to give up her partnership here and she didn't think she could bear to.&equo; 
 &bquo;She'd have talked him round, surely?&equo; 
 Peter Yeo was still looking out of the window, and Claudia glanced at his  familiar back, too short and too broad despite the most expensive tailoring, with real anxiety, &bquo;You don't honestly think that, do you, Peter? 
 People like Giles Hawick don't get talked round.&equo; 
 He turned, and they regarded each other steadily across the room. 
 &bquo;She was definitely going to marry him. 
 And I suppose we might have lost her in the long run, but not just yet.&equo; 
 Claudia Yeo nerved herself for a final effort. 
 &bquo;And you'd really accepted that they would marry?&equo; 
 He hesitated, then became angry. 
 &bquo;Of course I had, Claudia, what do you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;I know you two were very close, as the papers say.&equo; 
 Claudia Yeo was feeling sick, but knew she was on secure ground. 
 &bquo;I hoped that she had really decided to go for Giles Hawick instead.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo opened his mouth to speak, and found nothing useful to say. 
 &bquo;I didn't tell the police any of this, of course,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I just said that I was having a drink with her to ask her what she would really like as a wedding present from the firm, because men are no good at that sort of thing.&equo; 
 She paused and looked at him sidelong. 
 &bquo;I thought that was rather clever.&equo; 
 Peter Yeo's mouth quirked involuntarily. 
 He reached for Claudia's hand and held it, looking steadily into her face. 
 &bquo;She was a good mate and a very able, ambitious girl. 
 I'm not sure Hawick was right for her and I'd have been sorry to lose her, but that's beside the point. 
 She was going to marry him.&equo; 
 She tightened her hand on his, and they sat holding hands for half a minute before Peter Yeo caught sight of his watch. 
 &bquo;Darling, I must get on. 
 We are in chaos here until we get all Angela's work redistributed, we're all of us doing five things at once. 
 Thank you for coming to talk to me, and why don't you come with me to this thing this evening? 
 It's not a riot of pleasure, but we'd be there together.&equo; 
 She returned his kiss, but declined firmly to join him at  the Allied Steelmakers' annual dinner (carriages eleven-thirty), saying she would actually rather go to the cinema with a girlfriend, and tripped out of the office looking considerably less harassed than when she had arrived. 
 At New Scotland Yard, John McLeish was spitting feathers, as one of his staff graphically put it. 
 He had arrived, pale and markedly short of sleep, at seven-fifty and at eight-thirty had rung Penelope Huntley's flat to find her barely awake, bad-tempered, vague and professing not to have made an appointment at all. 
 Furious but civil, he had offered to go round to her flat to see her, an offer which she had declined with the first sign of decisiveness she had been heard to display. 
 She had offered to be at New Scotland Yard by nine-thirty and it was now nine forty-five. 
 &bquo;She's playing hard to get, isn't she, John?&equo; 
 Bruce Davidson suggested. 
 &bquo;She agreed eight o'clock when I spoke to her yesterday, after I'd offered her every other hour of the day. 
 She's a nutter, maybe; there's always one in a case.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mm.&equo; 
 McLeish decided to get some work in. 
 &bquo;Tell me about Mrs Yeo. 
 Was her husband playing around?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd say so. 
 She's a good-looking woman, but she's jumpy and she does'na have the confidence. 
 Let herself go a bit &mdash; ye get that with women whose men are giving them a hard time, and who hav'na found a way of getting their retaliation in first.&equo; 
 McLeish considered his local expert on women narrowly. 
 &bquo;It's not evidence.&equo; 
 &bquo;You didna ask me for evidence, John, you sought my best judgement, and you have it. 
 I'd have been glad to give a wee helping hand there myself, and I'm sure one was needed.&equo; 
 Some of it was instinct with Davidson, of course, but most of it was solid experience, starting, as Davidson had once told him, with his being seduced by the school-dinner lady at the age of thirteen in his native Ayrshire. 
 &bquo;Och well, John, there's not a lot else to do up there in winter,&equo; he had  observed, radically changing McLeish's views of the activities available to schoolchildren in country districts. 
 McLeish reflected uncomfortably that he would have to be very circumspect in his dealings with Catherine, with this beady-eyed observer around the place. 
 On this thought, Catherine put her head in, politely excusing herself to Bruce Davidson, and said that Miss Huntley had finally got here. 
 &bquo;She can damn well wait for a minute,&equo; McLeish decided. 
 &bquo;Bruce, why did the good Mrs Yeo want to have a drink with her rival? 
 All girls together, did you think? 
 No hard feelings, darling, so  nice you're getting married?&equo; 
 Bruce Davidson considered his notes. 
 &bquo;She said to me that the partners in the firm couldna decide what to give the lass for her wedding and had asked her, as wife of the senior partner, to have a wee word. 
 It's possible, John.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, it is,&equo; McLeish conceded. 
 He sighed. 
 &bquo;We'll have to see her again, Bruce &mdash; if Yeo was having it off with Angela Morgan, both he and his missis have to be in the frame. 
 And you think that's likely?&equo; 
 &bquo;I told you that I formed the impression that Mrs Yeo was not secure in her husband's affections,&equo; Davidson said, primly. 
 McLeish grinned at him and told Catherine to organize Penelope Huntley, hoping he had struck the right brisk note. 
 He was not reassured by hearing Bruce Davidson in the passage cheerily observing to Catherine that she was looking a bittie pale; was it just the London air, or had she been burning the candle at both ends? 
 He let a dignified minute pass before going out himself, collecting Catherine, and dispatching Bruce to supervise the house-to-house interviews in Malplaquet Terrace, to see if anyone could be found who had seen the blue BMW arrive or caught sight of its driver. 
 McLeish stopped at the door of the interview room and looked in through the spy-hole, wanting to get some feel for the  evidently  hostile and, by all accounts, neurotic Penelope Huntley. 
 His first sight of her was reassuringly  normal: a tall, dark girl dressed in a good grey suit of the type favoured by Francesca, which acted effectively as a uniform without doing much for her. 
 An expensive handbag lay on the table, and she was reading the morning paper in a perfectly ordinary way. 
 But as she lifted her head to greet them, McLeish decided the first impression had been false. 
 Her hair was lank, her skin blotchy and spotty. 
 She was evidently a heavy smoker for the first two fingers of her right hand were stained with nicotine, and, now that he looked, the nails were bitten and the cuticles chewed raw. 
 She looked as if she had just got out of bed, and McLeish had a sudden vision of a dark basement flat with greasy mugs on every surface. 
 She looked both wary and defiant; well, people often did, faced with the police, but it was an unusual combination to find in a girl from the confident middle class. 
 &bquo;Is it not warm enough in here?&equo; he enquired by way of greeting, seeing her clasping her jacket round her. 
 Penelope Huntley let go of it anxiously and said no, that it was perfectly fine, she'd just been cold outside. 
 McLeish took her briskly through the course, making the now familiar speech about Angela Morgan's death being treated as a case of murder, which meant taking statements from everyone who had been associated with her and might be helpful. 
 Penelope Huntley sat silent through this speech, chain-smoking, her eyes downcast. 
 In the end he stopped talking and watched her till she looked at him, sideways and warily. 
 &bquo;In the course of this process we have talked to Miss Morgan's solicitor, who told us that she was the life tenant of a substantial estate, and that you are what they call the remainder-man.&equo; 
 &bquo;That is the correct term, yes. 
 It was my Uncle Bill's money.&equo; 
 Well, that woke her up, McLeish thought, watching the &mdash; restless fingers. 
 The sight of a young woman alternately smoking her head off and chewing her cuticles left a lot to be desired. 
 &bquo;I understand that a substantial part of his estate was left to Miss Morgan?&equo; he enquired, with a strong feeling of throwing petrol on to a fire.  
 &bquo;Yes, it was. 
 We both got legacies, and she got the bulk of the estate for her lifetime. 
 She was his mistress, of course, although she was over thirty years younger than him.&equo; 
 She ground a half-smoked cigarette into the ashtray, and McLeish was left with the feeling that she would willingly have done the same to the live flesh of Angela Morgan, if available. 
 &bquo;How do you feel about that?&equo; 
 Her head came up and she looked him in the eye. 
 &bquo;Well, it was his money, wasn't it, and I was only his niece. 
 I was disappointed of course, but I got over it.&equo; 
 A good prepared speech, McLeish thought, with not a word of truth in it. 
 In fact, he realized, she had simply adopted the words other people must have said to her over and over again. 
 He wondered whether she had always been quite so uncaring of her appearance or whether it had been grief and rage at Uncle Bill's defection that had started this off. 
 Not a very easy question to ask. 
 &bquo;Were you close to your uncle?&equo; 
 &bquo;Till she  came along,&equo; The answer was like a rifle shot, full of pent-up rage, and McLeish sat back. 
 &bquo;You felt she displaced you &mdash; with him, I mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, she had all the advantages, didn't she?&equo; 
 Penelope Huntley was destroying the remaining cuticles on her left hand, a finger pushed savagely against her teeth. 
 &bquo;I mean, she could go to bed with him. 
 He wanted her, and he was getting old and silly.&equo; 
 &bquo;I understand that he was sixty-two when he died,&equo; McLeish said, drily. 
 &bquo;It's not all that old.&equo; 
 &bquo;He was idiotic about her. 
 Completely OTT. 
 She didn't really care about him at all, she just wanted his money.&equo; 
 McLeish decided it would be a waste of time to suggest that it would have hardly been reasonable for Angela Morgan to expect to inherit a quick fortune from a man of sixty-two. 
 &bquo;They had no plans to marry, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course not. 
 Or she  didn't. 
 She was just stringing him along.&equo; 
 &bquo;Even though she would have been a rich woman had she married him?&equo; 
 Penelope Huntley looked momentarily disoriented, but  any recognition that a valid point had been made disappeared and she went back to chewing her cuticles. 
 &bquo;You now, of course, come into possession of a substantial sum, following Miss Morgan's death,&equo; McLeish observed, sounding as accusing as he could, and she stopped chewing and gave him her full attention. 
 &bquo;Yes, I do. 
 Not anything like it would have been if Uncle Bill had left it to me in the first place, because it will pay duty twice.&equo; 
 &bquo;But more than you would have got if Miss Morgan had agreed to your suggestion of splitting the fund up between you. 
 &bquo;How did you know about that? 
 Solicitors, I suppose &mdash; if it was mine I'll find new ones.&equo; 
 She glared at McLeish, who looked deadpan. 
 &bquo;Yes, I wouldn't have got all that much, but she wouldn't even agree to that, greedy cow.&equo; 
 The sudden descent into abuse took McLeish by surprise and he realized he must have shown it, because the girl literally got a grip on herself, folding her arms and hunching over the table. 
 &bquo;Well, you've got it now,&equo; he said crudely, and watched with fascination as the corners of her mouth tucked in smugly. 
 &bquo;I'd like to go over your movements with you for last Saturday, Sunday and Monday week, please,&equo; he went on crisply. 
 Penelope Huntley looked at him in amazement, with dawning understanding. 
 More human than she'd looked all morning, he thought, realizing he had taken against his witness at least partly because she was alive and the amusing, lively, feminine creature that had been Angela Morgan was not. 
 Uncle Bill had been a wise man to leave the money to Angela, who had enjoyed it, rather than to this grudging, bitter, scruffy young woman. 
 &bquo;I didn't kill her, if that's what you mean. 
 I thought of it at one ti me, but I knew I'd make a mess of it.&equo; 
 She bit &mdash; savagely at her cuticles again, and McLeish had to fight back the urge to yell at her to stop, for God's sake. 
 &bquo;Could you tell us where you were and what you were doing on those three days, please?&equo; he said, instead, levelly and she gave him another sideways, calculating look. 
  &bquo;Including, please, names and addresses of anyone you spent time with,&equo; he added pleasantly and saw her understand that he was serious and she had better get her act together. 
 It seemed to take an unreasonably long time and much bad temper, evasion and deliberate obfuscation, together with consultation of a diary that appeared to be alternately blank and covered with scribbled hieroglyphics. 
 And the narrative extracted with such difficulty was not helpful. 
 Miss Huntley claimed to have spent the Saturday by herself in and around her flat, doing a bit of shopping and cleaning before meeting a few friends &mdash; only one of whom appeared to have an address &mdash; and going on to a party around ten o'clock at night. 
 A large party, in and out of which people had evidently flowed like water circulating in a swimming pool. 
 Sunday was not much better; Miss Huntley had not risen from her bed until one p.m. and had not left the flat until five, then only to go to the cinema. 
 On Monday she had gone to her job &mdash; improbably she appeared to be a supervisor for a market research firm &mdash; as usual, and could be vouched for by colleagues there. 
 Well, two colleagues anyway. 
 No, she did not own a car &mdash; could not afford to &mdash; but she did have a driving licence. 
 Uncle Bill had run a car for her on his company while he was alive but of course that had all stopped when he died. 
 McLeish, who remembered that she had been left &pound;200,000 outright, received this as further evidence that the young woman had gone into a massive sulk after her uncle's unexpected death. 
 It was difficult to tell, of course, whether she had always possessed an unattractive, aggressive, sullen personality, or whether rejection by her uncle in favour of Angela Morgan had tipped her over into this behaviour. 
 Perhaps she would brighten up now that she had another substantial amount of cash to spend. 
 He asked her to come back as suited her to sign her statement, and she made all kinds of difficulties about when this would be possible. 
 He finally dealt with that by saying briskly that one of his staff would come to her place of business. 
 She opened her mouth to argue further, being plainly in the mood to announce she was leaving her job  rather than allow any arrangement to succeed, but something about McLeish's expression checked her and she agreed meekly. 
 McLeish saw her off and returned to confer with Catherine. 
 &bquo;You get all that? 
 It'll all have to be checked &mdash; you've got Donalds and Ridley to do that.&equo; 
 He gazed at her bent head as she read through her notes, and she looked up and smiled faintly at him. 
 &bquo;Shall I do it now?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not yet. 
 What did you think of Miss Huntley? 
 What a bitch, eh?&equo; 
 Catherine considered him thoughtfully. 
 &bquo;I was sorry for her. 
 Her dad died, then her uncle went off with someone else. 
 And left his money away from her.&equo; 
 &bquo;I hadn't quite seen it like that,&equo; McLeish acknowledged humbly, remembering that the beautiful woman in front of him, whom you could not suppose ever to have encountered rejection in any form, had lost a father when young, and had been so little attached to her stepfather that she had left home at the earliest opportunity. 
 &bquo;She is in the frame, though?&equo; he suggested. 
 &bquo;Oh yes. 
 What was it she would get on Angela Morgan's death &mdash; about &pound;120,000 after taxes? 
 And I suppose she feels she's won. 
 I mean she's alive, isn't she?&equo; 
 McLeish observed soberly that &pound;120,000 and the death of a hated rival seemed a prize well worth playing for. 
 &bquo;She's got a nasty enough temper &mdash; I just don't myself see her as clever or organized enough to cover her tracks. 
 Well, perhaps you'll find she hasn't &mdash; it's not much of an alibi, is it?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 Gaps all over Saturday and Sunday &mdash; you reckon Angela was killed then, rather than Monday?&equo; 
 &bquo;I reckon Saturday. 
 We've got no sighting of her after first thing Saturday morning.&equo; 
 Catherine Crane looked at &mdash; him carefully, and he grinned at her. 
 &bquo;Come on, I know that look now. 
 What am I missing?&equo; 
 She blushed. 
 &bquo;It's just that the only person who saw her on Saturday was the Minister &mdash; Mr Hawick.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why would he be lying?&equo;  
 &bquo;Only if he was the murderer and had actually killed her earlier.&equo; 
 McLeish sighed. 
 &bquo;I'd not forgotten him, but I just couldn't see why he'd want to kill her. 
 He didn't get any of her money if she died before they were married.&equo; 
 &bquo;It could have been jealousy. 
 Mrs Morgan did think there was, or had been, something with her boss. 
 And Mr Hawick didn't seem to me the kind of chap who'd put up with that.&equo; 
 McLeish nodded, not entirely convinced, but unwilling for a variety of reasons to discourage Catherine. 
 &bquo;We need to check what he was doing those days, anyway &mdash; I didn't try too hard when we were last there, because I hoped the autopsy might give us something. 
 As it did. 
 I'll get Jenny to fix it.&equo; 
 She nodded, and he sat looking at her until she looked back at him. 
 He glanced up at the spy-hole and grinned. 
 &bquo;Let's get some lunch. 
 I can't face the canteen but there's a trattoria round the corner. 
 I never see anyone from this place there.&equo; 
 They ate in the small crowded Italian restaurant which was, as he had promised, free of their New Scotland Yard colleagues. 
 It was also free of DTI civil servants as he had quietly ascertained while they waited for their lunch to arrive. 
 They walked out into a cold, bright day, into one of the labyrinthine streets by the side of Westminster Abbey, straight into a column of knickerbockered children chattering hard and sweeping all before them. 
 As they stood patiently in a doorway waiting for the column to pass, Catherine turned to say something to McLeish and he looked down at her for a long moment. 
 &bquo;Better get back.&equo; 
 Smiling to himself, he looked idly across the road and saw Francesca, who should not have been back till Thursday. 
 She was not looking in their direction, her head was turned to say something to whomever she was with, her short hair blown straight up by the wind as they went into the little newsagent's, leaving McLeish a clear run to get Catherine back to the Yard. 
 He walked heavily beside her,  trying to convince himself that Francesca had not seen them. 
 But she had, of course she had; that was why she had fled. 
 He got back to his own desk and sat, looking at his hands, unable to decide whether to ring her up, or what to say. 
 Great Britain has lost an Empire and has not yet found a role  Dean Acheson, West Point, 1962 
 The Whitehall Market-place and the Military Road to Absurdity 
 Britain's influence in the world depends first and foremost on the health of her internal economy and the success of her export trade. 
 Without these, military power cannot long be supported Duncan Sandys, 1957 Defence White Paper. 
 This book is about Britain's Defence policy in her post-imperial era, and is the sequel to my Withdrawal from Empire , published in 1986, in which I looked through military eyes at the creation, development and eventual transformation of the Empire into the loosely-knit British Commonwealth. 
 I used the analogy of a family that goes from rags to riches and back to rags in three or four generations. 
 The first generation establishes the foundations of the family's wealth; the second and third develop and enjoy it; and the fourth loses it, not necessarily through riotous living or altruism, but because times have changed and the foundations upon which their wealth was built have collapsed. 
 It took Britain four centuries rather than four generations to complete the cycle. 
 We are now back where we were in Elizabeth I's days: a middle power, making our way in a world dominated by two superpowers, and doing so through intuitive manipulation of balances of power, as we have always done over the centuries. 
 In the first Elizabeth's time the superpowers were France and Spain; but, while much has changed, Britain is still an island upon which no other nation has any territorial, ethnic or political claim. 
 We prize our independence as much as ever, although we accept that in the run-up to the twenty-first century independence can only be relative: international interdependence is a Line qua non . 
 My first choice of tide for this book was The Offshore Island  because it reflects a return to our seventeenth-century political and military status, and our true position in the world today. 
 We are Europeans and yet we are separated from Europe both physically and psychologically. 
 We have a closer relationship with North America, but, like Canada, we have no wish to  rejoin our former American colonies as the fifty-first State of the Union, despite our common Anglo-Saxon heritage. 
 We have even closer blood relationships with the more distant Australians and New Zealanders. 
 Our ties with them still matter, though they have been weakened by Australasia's dependence on the United States for security and by our entry into the EEC. 
 And, having freed over a quarter of the world's population from our colonial rule, we have no desire to lose our own independence. 
 The politico-military problem that we face in our post-imperial era is how to maintain the greatest practicable measure of national independence without jeopardizing the security of our islands and of our wider interests in the world at large. 
 But in the light of the collapse of the Berlin Wall, which occurred after this book was completed and sent to my publishers, we have changed its title to Britain's Defence Dilemma: An  
 Inside View. 
 My conclusions, expressed in the last chapter &mdash; &bquo;Venice of the Twenty-First Century?&equo; &mdash; have been reinforced by the events that have been taking place in Eastern Europe since the autumn of 1989. 
 In devising policies to ensure national security with minimal loss of independence in the post-imperial era, successive Secretaries of State for Defence and their principal military advisers, the Chiefs of Staff, have had to grapple with three dominant factors: a growing Soviet military threat; a decline in Britain's ability to create wealth until the very recent Thatcher revolution; and an accelerating rate of technological change. 
 The first needs no elaboration; the second stemmed from socialism and the growing demands of the Welfare State; and the third created rampant inflation in the cost of defence equipment, which has yet to be mastered. 
 There is no generally recognized date marking the end of our imperial era. 
 The grant of independence to India in 1947 removed the keystone from the British imperial archway, but, because India and Pakistan became Dominions in the fashion of Canada, Australia and New Zealand, nothing seemed to change: the Empire went on. 
 Attlee, Churchill, and Eden, as Prime Ministers in the 1950s, could well have repeated Churchill's own words, uttered during a wartime speech at the Mansion House in the City of London in November 1942, &bquo;I have not become the King's First Minister to preside over the liquidation of the British Empire.' 
 In military terms the imperial era came to an end when the last British troops were withdrawn from East of Suez in 1972, but politically it had ended sixteen years earlier at Suez. 
 Before the Suez d&eacute;b&acirc;cle in the autumn of 1956, British governments had felt themselves able to dictate the pace at which the colonial Empire would be transformed into a cohesive Commonwealth of Nations: after Suez the imperial ethos was shattered, and our run down to middle-power status was no longer resisted. 
 Suez was the watershed between our imperial past and our offshore island future: before Suez we sought to restore our declining power; after Suez we shed our self-imposed colonial responsibilities as fast as we could reasonably do so. 
 I have, therefore, taken 1957 as the true starting Point of our post-imperial era.  
 The exact date of the beginning of our post-imperial era is, however, relatively unimportant. 
 The development of Defence policy is slow and essentially evolutionary. 
 The Services themselves are living organisms that, like the human beings of which they are composed, develop slowly, each generation handing on its accumulated wisdom and experience to the next. 
 Their weapons, equipment and tactics take decades rather than years to develop. 
 And Defence policy cannot grow in isolation from the rest of national decision-making in Whitehall. 
 It is rarely, if ever, possible to start with a clean sheet of paper: the starting point has to be the existing force structure and the current consensus of opinion within Whitehall. 
 In this chapter, I will sketch briefly the Defence policy-making machinery; and then, in chapter 2, look equally briefly at the development of our military thinking in the immediate post-war decade, 1946 to 1956, from which our post-imperial policies have flowed. 
 But, first, a distinction should be drawn between national grand strategy, Defence policy and current military strategy. 
 The first is long-term, evolutionary, and the product of centuries of often painful experience &mdash; the pain caused more often than not by repeated failure to pay a realistic Defence insurance premium. 
 The second is the medium-term and politically expedient view, taken by the government of the day, on how Britain's grand strategy should be implemented within its perceived availability of resources &mdash; &mdash; perceived because it is the product of subjective views and intense bargaining within the market-place that is Whitehall. 
 And the third is the current military method of implementing that Defence policy in terms of operational roles and resources allotted to the different elements of our military forces. 
 British grand strategy is, like the Constitution, unwritten. 
 The strategic equivalent of the Constitution are the &bquo;Three Pillars&equo; of British strategy that cohave evolved since Cr&eacute;cy and Agincourt in the Hundred Years War of the fourteenth and fifteenth centuries. 
 They can be stated in a number of different ways, but they are generally accepted to be: 
 1. 
 Ensuring the security of the British Isles. 
 2. 
 Maintaining a favourable balance of power in Western Europe. 
 3. 
 Projecting and protecting British interests overseas. 
 Until 1939, the Three Pillars stood upon a foundation of British sea power. 
 During the short five-year period of the Second World War, a layer of air power was added to that foundation, but since the atomic bombs were dropped on Japan in 1945, and Britain armed herself with nuclear weapons in the 1950s, the Three Pillars have stood just as securely upon the strategic nuclear deterrent. 
 It is worth recalling that even at the height of Britain's imperial power we rarely tried to go it alone. 
 We usually gained our ends by astute and almost instinctive creation of alliances, for which we provided leadership, and small  but professional military forces that were sought by friends and feared by foes for the impact they could make upon contemporary balances of power. 
 In Britain's heyday we provided financial subsidies as well; but though we have retained our fighting abilities, as was demonstrated by the Falklands Campaign, the decline in our resources relative to the superpowers now limits our influence and inhibits our quest for the greatest possible measure of national independence. 
 While the Three Pillars have stood the test of time, there has always been controversy about their relative importance, and hence about the allocation of resources between them. 
 Few strategists would gainsay the primacy of the First Pillar &mdash; the defence of the British Isles &mdash; upon which the sovereignty of the realm depends; though, paradoxically, the United Kingdom has usually been so secure behind its sea walls that Home Defence has been accorded the lowest allocation of resources. 
 On the other hand, arguments have raged since the early eighteenth century about the relative emphasis to be placed upon the Second and Third Pillars. 
 During Queen Anne's reign, the Continental and Maritime schools in British strategic thought clashed over the Second and Third Pillars. 
 The two schools became closely associated with the Whig and Tory Parties, in much the same way that the Labour and Conservative Parties champion non-nuclear and nuclear policies today. 
 The business-inclined Whigs believed that victory in Europe would automatically secure our overseas interests: the land-owning Tories, with their traditional dislike of the high taxation needed to pay for a standing army, sought to achieve the same ends with peripheral maritime operations, carried out by the Navy, which could largely pay for themselves by taking other powers' colonies and trading posts. 
 In practice, however, we have rarely fought any of our major wars with an exclusively Continental or Maritime strategy. 
 We have usually deemed it strategically unwise not to employ a judicious mix of the two. 
 Four examples make the point. 
 Continental strategy was uppermost during Marlborough's campaigns in the war of the Spanish Succession in the eighteenth century and during the First World War, though Britain's maritime effort was far from insignificant. 
 Few would challenge the Maritime school's claim that both these wars resulted in massive haemorrhages of blood and treasure. 
 Nevertheless, in their aftermaths, Britain's voice was undoubtedly strengthened in world affairs. 
 By way of contrast, the British campaigns during the Napoleonic Wars and in the Second World War were fought, perforce, with a Maritime strategy for most of the time; but, as the Continental school rightly points out, final victory was won on the Continent at Waterloo in 1815 and in north-west Europe in 1945. 
 The Maritime school can counter-claim that casualty lists were far shorter in these two wars. 
 In the present nuclear era, the controversy still rages. 
 It is convenient to continue using the shorthand of Continental and Maritime schools of thought, although the issues are more complex than they were in Queen Anne's day. 
 The  extremists among the Continental school argue that all our military resources should be concentrated upon the defence of Western Europe as the best way to ensure the country's continued survival. 
 In their view, only minimal forces should be trained and equipped to protect Britain's residual interests outside the NATO area. 
 The Maritime school acknowledge that the greatest Soviet threat is to Western Europe, but they believe that the most likely threats to British and Western interests lie in the more unstable areas of the world beyond NATO's boundaries. 
 They believe that our forces must be so trained and equipped that they can play both a Continental and Maritime role. 
 Some of the Maritime school go further and ask the question, &bquo;Who are We ?; and answer it by pointing out that We  are not just the people living in the United Kingdom today. 
 We  are the descendants of all those generations that emigrated out of Europe over the last three centuries to populate the emptier quarters of the earth. 
 We , and the other races who took on our way of life during our imperial era, encircle the globe. 
 British Commonwealth links, though gossamer thin for most of the time, can become emotional ties of steel in times of crisis, drawing us into unexpected military commitments, as occurred in the Falklands Campaign. 
 They remember also that the Dominions came voluntarily to our aid in the two world wars: we would be in honour bound to do likewise if any of them came under threat. 
 Nonetheless, the Maritime school accept that our forces should be deployed primarily to support the First and Second Pillars, but argue that they must also be given the strategic mobility, equipment, and training to continue Britain's global role as required by the Third Pillar. 
 British Defence policy, unlike her grand strategy, is written, re-written, written about and debated annually in the Defence White Papers, in which the government of the day makes its case for military expenditure for the coming year. 
 It has far less to do with strategy than with financial bargains struck in the market-place of Whitehall, and with efforts to contain galloping inflation in weapons procurement. 
 Indeed, British Defence policy can be described as the sum of Naval, General and Air Staff special pleading. 
 Each is supported by parliamentary, industrial and media lobbies, and makes the best use of political trends, economic factors, technological change, and the rush of world events to reinforce its case for a larger share of the national cake. 
 Cynical though this description of Defence policy-making may be, the analogy of the Whitehall market-place is apt. 
 The currency of the market is compelling argument: the more convincing a case, the higher its value in the bidding for national resources, and in the creation of a favourable climate of opinion in Whitehall and Westminster. 
 Personalities, presentational skills, prejudices, and political dogmas all play their part, but the working of the market-place helps the coinage of sound argument to drive out the counterfeit of special pleading. 
 Alter most of Britain's major wars there is a rush to demobilize, and to return to the parsimonious levels of peacetime Defence expenditure. 
 In 1945 this did  not happen: indeed, more than a decade was to pass before conscription was phased out. 
 Defence could muster cogent arguments to maintain an unusually high level of expenditure. 
 The hostility of the Soviet Union, generous American aid, and the disinclination of successive governments to abandon Britain's great-power status, all made higher Defence expenditure politically acceptable. 
 The Attlee administration, and Ernest Bevin in particular, believed it was only a matter of time before the British economy would recover. 
 They hoped that the dynamic forces released by socialism would generate new wealth, enabling Britain to stride the world once more in a continuing and -equal partnership with the United States, rather than as the American satellite which she had become in the latter phases of the Second World War. 
 While the remorseless Soviet military build-up continued to give Defence powerful arguments for keeping up Britain's Defence forces, the failure of the British economy to grow in the enervating climate of the Welfare State progressively eroded Britain's military strength. 
 Throughout the 1950s, '60s and '70s, both major political parties pursued Keynesian economic policies, deferred to the trade unions, and allowed overmanning and bureaucracy to strangle initiative. 
 And they both diagnosed high Defence spending as one of the root causes of Britain's economic malaise rather than the policies of the Labour Party, or the neo-socialism of the Conservatives. 
 There is a striking similarity between the preambles written by both political parties to their Defence White Papers, following the three major Defence Reviews that took place between 1957 and 1975. 
 In 1957 Duncan Sandys followed the quote at the head of this chapter with the words: 
 It is therefore in the true interests of defence that the claims of military expenditure should be considered in conjunction with the need to maintain the country's financial and economic strength. 
 In 1966 Denis Healey.: 
 Military strength is of little value if it is achieved at the expense of economic health. 
 In 1975 Roy Mason: 
 &hellip; because the economic situation is now more serious than at any time over the last 25 years, the Government decided that resources must be released for investment and improving the balance of payments&hellip; 
 The defence programme, with its considerable demands on skilled manpower and industry, should play its part in this process&hellip; 
 The credibility of Defence in the Whitehall market-place was further weakened by three other factors: first, the &bquo;bull&equo; market enjoyed by the high-spending, socially-orientated departments &mdash; Health, Education, Labour and Social Services; secondly, the failure of our West European allies to match our level of Defence expenditure, thus providing arguments that Britain was doing more  than her fair share in collective defence; and thirdly, trading rivals, like Germany and Japan, honing their competitive edge with lower military expenditure, likewise adding to the consensus view that Britain was overspending on Defence however potent the Soviet military threat might be. 
 The &bquo;bear&equo; market in Defence shares is well illustrated in figure 1 . 
 It shows the decline in the percentage of the Gross Domestic Product devoted to Defence from 1946 onwards. 
 The steep post-war decline was arrested by the Korean War re-armament programme, which reached a peak of 10 per cent GDP in 1953. 
 The decline began again in 1954: 7.8 per cent at the time of Suez in 1956; 6.3 per cent at the end of National Service in 1962; 5.4 per cent when Denis Healey completed his Defence Reviews in 1968; and 4.9 per cent in 1970, when the withdrawal from East of Suez was nearing completion. 
 Thereafter, it averaged 4.85 per cent until 1979 when the seven years of the NATO 3 per cent annual increases in Defence spending began to take effect. 
 It rose to its highest point of 5.4 per cent in 1984, falling back again to 4.7 per cent in 1988, and with a threat of a further decline to the lowest point since the Second World War of 4.4 per cent in 1989 &mdash; despite all the Conservative Party's claims to be the party that looks after the defence of the realm. 
 The decline in military and civilian manpower employed in the Services, shown in figure 2 , has followed a similar pattern, but with one important difference: whereas military manpower stabilized at 320,000 after Roy Mason's    
 Defence Review in 1974/5, civilian manpower has gone on falling thanks to efforts of successive Permanent Under-Secretaries to reduce overheads and to increase the percentage of the Defence vote that can be devoted to weapon procurement. 
 To continue the analogy of the Whitehall market-place, the Ministry of Defence itself can be looked upon as a specialized commodity market, in which the three Services and the Defence scientists bargain for their share of the resources won by the Secretary of State on the main trading floor during the annual Public Expenditure Reviews. 
 The share quotation list in the Defence commodity market is the Ministry's Long-Term Costing, in which all programmes and projects are costed over a ten-year period. 
 It is a rolling assessment, which is recosted every year in the late summer so that the effects of financial targets set by the Treasury for the coming year can be fully assessed before the Cabinet starts its Public Expenditure Review in the autumn. 
 The figures in the first three years of the Long-Term Costing are detailed and relatively firm because they are fixed by the Public Expenditure Survey Committee each year &mdash; hence they are referred to in Whitehall jargon as the PESC years. 
 Thereafter, they become progressively rounder and broader for each succeeding year as the work of estimating costs becomes more difficult and hence more speculative. 
 The main purpose of the costings for the latter years is  to identify probable peaks and troughs in the overall programme, which can be smoothed out by phasing in major projects so as to avoid clashes. 
 Inclusion of projects in these latter years also provides the programme with its substance, and gives the projects themselves their validity. 
 If a Service fails to argue a project into the costings at an early stage, it will find it much harder to do so subsequently. 
 Other projects, already in the costing, start jostling for more space due to initial underestimates caused by unforeseen increases in development costs; or due to deliberate &bquo;thin end of the wedging&equo; by a department to get an expensive and controversial programme into the Long-Term Costing in the first place. 
 The bargaining processes within the Defence commodity market are often described in the media and in Parliament as vicious inter-Service infighting. 
 There is some truth in this, but it is the price that has to be paid for reaching balanced judgements on the way ahead. 
 It takes a lifetime to master warfare in one element &mdash; sea, land or air &mdash; and, as yet, few officers have achieved the breadth of experience to command total confidence in all three. 
 Without the heat of inter-departmental argument, controversial issues would not be distilled to a point where their essential elements can be clearly identified and sound decisions taken on them. 
 In practice, inter-Service rivalry only becomes unbridled when there is a danger &mdash; real or anticipated &mdash; of the balance between the Services being upset; or of the structure of one of them being changed in a revolutionary rather than an evolutionary way. 
 The occasions that stand out in the three decades of our post-imperial era are: Duncan Sandys' 1957 decision to recommend the end of National Service, which almost halved the Army; the Kennedy/Macmillan Polaris agreement at Nassau in 1962 that led to the RAF losing responsibility to the Royal Navy for the British nuclear deterrent; Denis Healey's scrapping of the TSR2 in 1965, which threatened to &bquo;unhorse&equo; the RAF's knights; his cancellation of the aircraft-carrier replacement programme in 1966, which did much the same thing to the Royal Navy; and John Nott's attempt in 1981 to maintain the strength of the Rhine Army and RAF Germany at the expense of our maritime capability. 
 On these occasions the gloves came off as the Service most adversely affected sought support in Parliament, in the media, from industry, and from the electorate, in what it saw as its fight for survival. 
 In most years the updating of the Long-Term Costing, though always difficult, is a relatively gentlemanly struggle between sensible men, trying to squeeze a pint of requirements into a half-pint financial pot, as happens in the budgetary processes of any large organization or commercial conglomerate. 
 Inter-Service friction has been eased over the years by successive steps taken to concentrate greater power in the hands of the Central staffs as more tri-Service experienced officers have become available; and to bring the Services closer together at every level of command, and in training and operations. 
 Paradoxically, in most years the outcome of the Defence budgetary process is under-rather than overspending, and this is not because the accounting officers  fear the wrath of Parliament, but because of what has become known as the &bquo;Bow-Wave Phenomenon&equo;, illustrated in figure 3 . 
 In the first three years of a Service's Long-Term Costing after the actual estimates year, there seems to be a bow-wave of requirements that cannot be fitted into the programme. 
 Before presenting the Service's estimates to Parliament, the department should, in theory, prune its programmes down to  the financial target line imposed by the Treasury; but, in practice, it has been found that the bow-wave tends to dissipate as the actual financial year goes by because there are always delays in most programmes that lead to underspending on individual projects. 
 Even the most experienced managers cannot tell how, when and in which projects delays are going to occur; the wise accounting officer discounts his programmes by an arbitrary percentage judged from past experience to be sensible for his particular field of responsibility: that is to say he keeps in his programme some ten to twenty per cent more potential expenditure than his financial allocation theoretically allows. 
 As each financial year passes, the bow-wave does, indeed, dissipate as research and development programmes meet snags; as decisions are delayed in the labyrinth of Whitehall committees; as procurement contracts slip behind schedule; and as units expend less than they asked for due to similar delays in their day-to-day training and operations. 
 The best and most experienced accounting officers come out about all square and do not have to suffer the indignity of having to ask their ministers to present supplementary estimates to  Parliament at the end of the financial year. 
 Even so, Defence has constantly underspent its vote, and by substantial margins on those occasions when there have been unforeseen delays in the deliveries of major equipments such as warships and advanced aircraft. 
 There was one exceptional year that proved the rule: in 1980, the economic recession so emptied British industry's order books that firms were able, and keen, to deliver faster than anticipated with embarrassing consequences for the accounting officers in post at the time. 
 There was a gross overspend that year, which led, in part, to the replacement of Francis Pym by John Nott, as will be recounted in chapter 8. 
 Some good, however, came out of this. 
 Hitherto departments had not been allowed to carry forward underspends into the next financial year though the Treasury was allowed to penalize departments by deducting overspends from the next year's targets. 
 In consequence, there was always a scramble to spend in the last half of the financial year when the danger of an underspend was becoming apparent. 
 By then it was usually too late to accelerate existing contracts or to initiate new ones. 
 Hence, the &bquo;Bow-Wave Phenomenon&equo; turned into the &bquo;Barrack Square Syndrome&equo;, in which the only way to mop up money was to spend it on a few quickly and easily let contracts, like refurbishing barrack squares and military roads! 
 Defence is now allowed to carry forward a percentage of its vote into the next financial year. 
 The problems of the Defence budget are generally well known. 
 An average of forty per cent of the vote is spent on pay and pensions, which have to be held at comparable levels with their civilian equivalents if the principle of voluntary recruitment is to be sustained. 
 About twenty per cent goes on the maintenance of the forces in being at the time. 
 Any cheese-paring of the logistic stocks reduces battle efficiency, and failure to look after barracks, married quarters, and installations in the short term piles up trouble and expensive rebuilding for the future. 
 The only flexibility lies in the remaining forty per cent, which is devoted to research, development, and procurement of equipment. 
 But here too, room for manoeuvre is limited: the long-term nature of most major weapon programmes is such that few can be brought to a successful conclusion in much less than a decade, and in some cases even longer. 
 Needless to say, it is on this part of the budget that the debates are fiercest. 
 The majority of potentially battle-winning systems are pursued at or beyond the frontiers of existing technology where the risks of failure are high; where cost estimates are notoriously uncertain; and hence where the judgments of the soundest and most experienced men can turn out to be fallacious. 
 At the beginning of the annual costing exercises there is usually a significant gap between the targets set by the Treasury and the genuine requirements of the Services, which no amount of discounting can bridge. 
 The mismatch is part of the bargaining process of the Public Expenditure Review, and is common to all major spending departments in Whitehall. 
 A laborious internal review of the Long-Term Costing is undertaken to whittle down the gap, and to highlight vulnerable programmes so that the Secretary of State can be given the strongest  possible brief to help him fight for a higher allocation of resources; and conversely to enable him to fend off attacks by other high-spending ministers, who are intent on grabbing a larger share for themselves, often at the expense of Defence. 
 Closing the costings gap is never easy, and is resisted by the Service departments with all the ingenuity that they can muster. 
 One of two methods is generally applied: the &bquo;illustrative cut&equo; of individual projects and commitments, or the percentage cut across the board. 
 In the former, Service departments are asked to list their lowest priority items, and to state the implications of their demise if the books cannot be balanced by other means. 
 In theory, this should produce a list of the least harmful cuts from which the Secretary of State can choose, if he fails in his bid for more resources. 
 It also reinforces his case by demonstrating the implications of not giving him the cash that he needs. 
 On some occasions, however, the gambit can backfire. 
 A Service department may take the risk of including an important project in its list, not because it believes it has a low priority, but because it knows it would be politically awkward for the party in power to consider cutting it. 
 In most years, the blunt instrument of the percentage cut is used to close the final gap when all else has failed. 
 Some programmes are &bquo;stretched&equo; to reduce expenditure in the estimates year. 
 In the case of logistic programmes this entails reducing activity generally and training in particular &mdash; less sea time for the Navy, fewer track-miles for the Army, reduced flying hours for the RAF, and lower allocations of training ammunition for all three; and in equipment procurement, the rate of re-equipment has to be slowed down. 
 Other programmes are &bquo;slipped to the right&equo;, which means delaying them to later years in the Costing; and the rest are pruned in size or cut out all together. 
 &bquo;Stretching&equo;, &bquo;slipping&equo;, and &bquo;pruning&equo;, reduce costs in the short term, but increase them overall because shorter and slower production runs increase overheads. 
 Cancellation is the least favoured option: once a project is cut out of the Long-Term Costing, it is rarely possible to argue it back in again. 
 Each Service department has its own well-known strengths, weaknesses, sensitivities and prejudices in the bargaining on the floor of the Defence commodity market. 
 The Army, being manpower intensive, is on its guard against cuts in the operational commitments that underpin the existence of its named infantry and armoured regiments, whose traditions stretch back to the Restoration. 
 There has to be an operational role or &bquo;peg&equo;, which provides the raison d'&ecirc;tre  for each regiment, if it is to survive in the harsh financial climate of our post-imperial era. 
 For instance, it has, at times, looked desirable to reduce the order of battle of the Rhine Army, in order to build up a larger uncommitted and strategically mobile central reserve in the United Kingdom. 
 Such ideas tend to be anathema to the Army Board, not because they are against the creation of stronger reserves; nor because of the difficulties of finding barrack accommodation and training areas in the cramped and over-populated British Isles; but because the units withdrawn from the Continent would become  vulnerable to pruning in some future retrenchment programme &mdash; reserves are always the first to go when cuts are demanded, since their size is based on subjective rather than objective judgments. 
 The loss of traditional regiments would mean the forfeiture of three centuries of accumulated battle experience. 
 The Royal Navy and RAF, being capital intensive, tend to shield their major re-equipment programmes. 
 The Navy's costings are the most brittle: cancellation of just one warship or submarine punches a yawning hole in a year's programme, and slowing down construction increases overheads and hence costs dramatically. 
 The RAF's aircraft replacement programmes tend to be more expensive than warship construction, but they have greater flexibility since the number of aircraft ordered in any one year can be varied without throwing the Air Department's costings off balance. 
 By way of contrast, the Army's re-equipment has the greatest flexibility in that it consists of many smallish programmes, each involving the production of large numbers of relatively low-cost weapons or equipments. 
 However, herein lies the Army's greatest weakness in the bargaining process. 
 Its programmes are much the most susceptible to &bquo;salami slicing&equo;, since it is difficult to claim that the end of the world will come if the Army receives, say, ninety instead of a hundred tank replacements in a particular year. 
 Whitehall market forces have produced an optimum balance in the allocation of resources between the three Services. 
 Figure  4 shows the costs of the nuclear deterrent, and the General-Purpose Combat Forces of each Service in percentages of the total Defence vote from 1965, the first year in which  functional costings were presented in the annual Defence White Papers, to 1988. 
 They show the consistency that is to be expected from a ten-year rolling programme. 
 The main variations are caused by the phasing in of major re-equipment programmes: Polaris in the latter half of the 1960s; RAF re-equipment in the early 1970s; Army re-equipment in the mid-1970s; the Tornado programme in the mid-1980s, and the start of the Trident programme in the late 1980s. 
 The RAF and the Army vie with each other fairly closely with an average of 18.3 per cent and 17.0 per cent of the vote respectively over the 24-year period. 
 The Navy averages 13.2 per cent, but, if the nuclear deterrent average of 2.7 per cent is added, resources allotted to naval forces comes to 15.9 per cent, which is not far below the allocations to air and land forces. 
 In the broadest terms, these figures can be rounded to: 
 Air 18% Land 17% Sea 16% 
 These cold statistics do not show one important trend that has been taking place since 1945. 
 Equipment-cost inflation has done more than the huge cost of the Welfare State and our poor economic performance to reduce Britain's military independence. 
 At the end of the Second World War, we could go it alone across the whole spectrum of military weapon systems from high-performance aircraft at one end to the simple automatic rifle at the other. 
 In the early post-war years, we were confident that our research and development establishments and armament firms could compete with and, on occasions, surpass in innovative ability the much larger but more cumbersome organizations in the US and USSR. 
 Not only would we be able to provide battle-winning equipments for our own forces, but our balance of payments would benefit from a flourishing export trade in armaments. 
 Had it not been for the Cold War, these expectations might have been realized. 
 The United States would probably have reverted to isolationism as happened after the First World War; Congress would have cut back Defence spending, starving the US defence/industrial base; and American big business would have looked elsewhere for profitable enterprises. 
 This did not happen; instead Soviet-American military rivalry generated the nuclear, conventional, and space arms races on a scale that dwarfed British efforts. 
 With the American Research and Development budget exceeding the whole of the British Defence vote, we had to become progressively more selective, concentrating on those projects in which success would give us the greatest measure of national independence. 
 In past centuries, shortages of military manpower used to force us into alliances with continental powers. 
 In the second half of this century, we have had to seek partners in the US and Western Europe to overcome our technological and industrial limitations. 
 The problems of equipment-cost inflation have become so crucial in Defence planning that it is worth recalling briefly how the British weapon procurement  system works. 
 The initiative comes from the Operational Requirements Staffs of the Naval, General, and Air Staffs (now part of the Central Staff under the latest reorganization of the Ministry, but still carrying out the same function &mdash; see page 175) . 
 It is their responsibility to decide what new equipments are needed, and to specify their performance and other critical parameters. 
 They do not work in isolation. 
 On the one hand, they are experienced officers drawn from operational units with whom they keep in close touch; and, on the other, they are advised by the Defence scientists and by the technologists in British industry. 
 They have also the closest links with the equivalent staffs in the Pentagon, and in Western European and major Commonwealth capitals, particularly Bonn, Paris, Rome, Canberra and Ottawa. 
 It is their job to know where new technological doors are opening, and when to recommend going through them. 
 The OR Staff, as they are called, specify what is needed in two documents: the &bquo;Staff Target&equo;, which is couched in broad enough terms to allow several solutions; and the &bquo;Operational Requirement&equo;, which subsequently narrows down the possibilities, and sets out more detailed specifications for the research and development phases of the project. 
 When prototypes have satisfied the OR Staff, production is carried out by the Procurement Executive of the Ministry of Defence, using commercial contracts of a number of different types such as &bquo;fixed price&equo;, &bquo;single tender&equo;, and the much criticised &bquo;cost-plus&equo;, which is used when the technical risks are too high, the contractors able to tender too few, or the time too short for normal competitive tendering. 
 Staff Targets for new weapon systems are most often written for the replacement of existing equipments that are likely to become obsolescent in a specific time-frame. 
 They are also written in response to technological breakthroughs; to counter Soviet changes in weapons and tactics; and to compete with new systems emerging from other countries' armament industries. 
 They are often written as well to support private ventures by British firms, which are showing promise, but need a Staff Target or Operational Requirement before they can be given official consideration. 
 The Operational Requirement system, while entirely logical and well practised, is also inherently unbalanced in one important respect, which tends to exacerbate equipment-cost inflation. 
 The OR Staff are quite rightly intent on seeking battle-winning performance; the scientists and technologists enjoy and rise to the challenge; and so both the principal groups of participants in equipment development are pushing in the same direction without an effective countervailing force. 
 There is little, apart from general cost-consciousness, to restrain their enthusiasm until the risks and costs of a project can be established with any certainty and the Treasury is in a position to intervene. 
 By then it is often too late and too expensive to turn back. 
 Both sides know that &bquo;the best is the enemy of the good&equo;; that the Services want reliable, cost-effective equipment without &bquo;gold plating&equo; and that asking and striving &bquo;for the moon&equo; leads to cancellation through costs becoming  unmanageable. 
 They are equally aware that achieving the last few percentage points in performance of ten causes a disproportionate increase in costs. 
 But, and it is a very big but, where should the line be drawn? 
 Servicemen must not be asked to fight and risk their lives equipped with inferior weapons; and yet, they will have too few weapons if the costs are too high. 
 Judicious balances between all the multifarious factors are needed, but they are notoriously difficult to strike, and are even more so in international collaborative projects. 
 Throughout the first three decades of our post-imperial era, equipment-cost inflation has outstripped monetary inflation, and there has been insufficient growth in the British economy to make up the difference. 
 We have been riding down what the Americans have called the &bquo;Military Road to Absurdity&equo;. 
 The higher the performance, the greater the cost, and the fewer the weapons the Services can buy; and the shorter the production runs, the larger the overheads and the higher the price, leading to ever smaller orders. 
 &bquo;Absurdity&equo; would be reached when we can only afford a one-ship navy, a one-tank army and a one-bomber air force! 
 The development of Defence policy since the Second World War has been dominated as much by efforts to find ways off the &bquo;Military Road to Absurdity&equo; as by the struggle for resources in the Whitehall market-place. 
 Apart from remorseless administrative efforts by the successive Permanent Under-Secretaries of the Ministry of Defence to reduce overheads so that more resources could be freed for re-equipment programmes, two well-trodden paths off the &bquo;Military Road to Absurdity&equo; have been thoroughly explored: partnership with the US, Canada, Australia and New Zealand (the ABCA countries); and collaboration with our Western European allies. 
 Both paths have proved tortuous and are strewn with awkward boulders. 
 On the ABCA path, it used to be relatively easy to agree common operational requirements, and to collaborate in research and development. 
 The Chiefs of Staff and most senior officers on both sides of the Atlantic and Pacific knew each other, having served together on NATO, CENTO, and SEATO staffs and in exchange appointments in each others' armed forces. 
 They had also shared operational experience of the Second World War, and comparable experiences in the Cold War. 
 Although Britain took no part in the Vietnam War, we faced similar but lesser problems in Malaya, Kenya, Cyprus, Borneo, and Aden. 
 In recent years the advantages of the old Dominion connection in the ABCA grouping have tended to fade as Canadian, Australian and New Zealand attitudes to Defence, their relations with the US, and their view of Britain have changed with their own growing maturity. 
 Nevertheless, reaching understandings with them on operational requirements is still easier than with our European partners. 
 The Anglo-American special relationship, on the other hand, is as alive as ever, and has made it possible for us to buy advanced US weapon systems like Polaris and Trident on very favourable terms. 
 The difficulties arise when joint production with the US is involved, as was the case with the ABCA Mallard trunk communication system, or when outright US purchases of British manufactured weapons, like Rapier, are  contemplated. 
 However co-operative the Pentagon may wish to be, the American industrial lobby in Congress usually intervenes at a late stage to protect its own narrow interests and the projects collapse. 
 The joint Harrier venture with the US Marine Corps has proved an outstanding exception, though it has not been without its problems. 
 The &bquo;not invented here&equo; syndrome is as prevalent in US military thinking as it is in Britain's. 
 The close relationship between the British and American Services, while admirable in most respects, has its dangers. 
 British officers on the Defence Adviser's staff in our Washington Embassy, and in exchange appointments at US military establishments, see the products of the vast US research and development programmes and become wedded to them to the detriment of British-developed equivalents. 
 Moreover, they become mentally attuned to American tactical doctrines, which are often devised to sell US equipments to the Western Alliance. 
 American salesmen thus have a built-in launch pad for their products within the British military establishment that they are not backward in exploiting. 
 Collaboration with Europe presents almost diametrically opposite problems. 
 Agreeing operational requirements is the first and most tiresome obstacle. 
 Apart from the language barrier, which has been eased by the general acceptance of English everywhere except in France, British and Continental military staffs have practically no shared operational experience or traditions. 
 It is perhaps easier to work with the Germans, whom Britain fought so bitterly in the first half of this century, than with the French or the Italians, whose active roles in the Second World War were prematurely curtailed. 
 When it comes to sharing development and production with our European partners, we have the common aims of all middle powers: protecting our own national armament industries; and preserving the greatest practicable measure of military independence. 
 In consequence, European collaboration is fraught and costly: operational requirements are made more complex than they ought to be by the need for compromise; sharing development leads to mismatches of components that have to be corrected late on in programmes; and divided production and assembly increases overheads and puts up costs. 
 On the credit side, collaboration with Europe has three great advantages: development costs, though not halved, are reduced from about a third to a quarter for each country depending on how many countries participate; production runs are longer, leading to lower costs; and, from the cynical military point of view, expensive high-risk collaborative projects are more difficult for governments to cancel. 
 It is often argued that we would all be better off if we followed the Warsaw Pact system of accepting their superpower's equipment, produced mainly in the Soviet Union, but also in satellite countries like Czechoslovakia. 
 We could standardize on US equipment with production under licence of those items that it is practicable and economic to manufacture in Western Europe. 
 But the loss of military independence, industrial capacity, employment and markets that such a policy would involve has always made it unacceptable to Western  European governments and electorates, including our own. 
 Developing convincing arguments that will satisfy the brokers in the Whitehall market-place; squeezing the pint of requirements into the half-pint pot of the Long-Term Costings; and trying to find new paths off the &bquo;Military Road to Absurdity&equo; are the monotonous fare of the Defence policy-makers. 
 When a new government takes office and opens the Defence books, it expects to find ample room for change and improvement. 
 The new ministers soon find that there is remarkably little room for manoeuvre, and that most of the quick and easy panaceas to the intractable problems of Defence have been tried many times before. 
 The long-term nature of the programmes imposes evolutionary rather than revolutionary change. 
 The whole structure which the Ministry controls and administers is as closely integrated as that of modern warships and high-performance aircraft. 
 Evolution rather than revolution is also imposed by the British system of government, which has given the country twenty-one Ministers of Defence since the Second World War. 
 Most Secretaries of State only manage to tap the helm, giving Defence policy little more than a change in emphasis during their time in office. 
 The Defence wheel can only be put over for a major change of course when there is a fortuitous coincidence of national and international events, political trends, and economic pressures at a time when there is also a Secretary of State in office, who has the strength of character and political standing to create a new consensus in Whitehall, Westminster, and the electorate. 
 In the thirty-two years that have passed since Suez, there have only been four such occasions when the wheel has been put over: 
 1957: Duncan Sandys' &bquo;Big Bang&equo; philosophy, that led to the end of National Service; 1965: Denis Healey's rolling Defence reviews, ending in the withdrawal from East of Suez; 1974: Roy Mason's concentration of resources on Western European Defence, taking the withdrawal from empire to its logical conclusion; 1981: John Nott's intended sacrifice of Maritime in favour of Continental capability, that was aborted by the Falklands Campaign. 
 All four changes of course had a Continental bias. 
 On each occasion, however, the currents flowing in world affairs swung Defence policy back to a more balanced Maritime/Continental course. 
 The fact is we remain an island power and cannot ignore the sea however close we may be to the Continent. 
 The military strategy devised to implement successive governments' Defence policies reflects both long-term national grand strategy and the directions given by the government of the day, and is largely the responsibility of the Chiefs of Staff. 
 Their power and influence in the Whitehall market-place has waxed, waned and waxed again since 1945. 
 Under Field Marshal, the Viscount, Alanbrooke's chairmanship during the Second World War they were  the Government's most powerful advisers. 
 Their influence declined only slowly after the war because British military operations continued around the world as Britain at first struggled to retain her empire, and then, after Suez, fought to bring about a prudent and dignified withdrawal from colonial responsibility. 
 By the early 1970s the struggle was over, and the decline in the Chiefs of Staff's activity and influence in national affairs was soon being reflected in the steady drop in the frequency of their meetings. 
 This waning of the Chiefs of Staff's influence was caused by the combination of three factors. 
 The first stemmed from Britain's own decline as a world power. 
 She no longer wished nor was able to gain her own ends by military means, the handling of which is, after all, the Chiefs' raison d'&ecirc;tre . 
 Moreover, although there was a continuing flow of military operations in the post-war years, their scale and frequency also declined steadily, all but fading out entirely by the mid-1970s. 
 The second factor was the change in the Ministry of Defence's decision-making processes brought about by the increasing complexity of Defence issues. 
 The contributions of the Chief Scientific Adviser, the Chief of Defence Procurement and the Permanent Under-Secretary and their staffs increased progressively relative to those of the military Chiefs, creating new and inevitably rival centres of power within the Defence commodity market. 
 And the third factor was the splintering of the collective voice of the Chiefs of Staff as decision-making swung away from operational problems to arguments over the Defence programmes. 
 Each Chief had to pay far more attention to the interests of his own Service in the cut-throat struggle for resources in a declining market. 
 It became extraordinarily difficult for them to speak with one voice on critical issues. 
 In consequence, Secretaries of State tended to look elsewhere within the Ministry and elsewhere for impartial advice. 
 The progressive loss of the Chiefs of Staff Committee's influence in the Defence commodity market led to a failure to formulate a military strategy that was understood and accepted in the main market-place of Whitehall. 
 Reviews of strategy turned into financially-driven Defence reviews, in which pruning hooks were more prominent than spades to plant new strategic ideas for the future. 
 The last time that the Chiefs of Staff managed to formulate a genuine military strategy was in 1961: after Macmillan's &bquo;Wind of Change&equo; speech; Iain McLeod's acceleration of the decolonization programme; and de Gaulle's veto on the British application to join the EEC. 
 The subsequent withdrawal from empire, which flowed from these events, was carried out on a strategy set out in a Chiefs of Staff Paper which remained the military planners' increasingly tattered bible until Roy Mason's 1974 Defence review made British military strategy synonymous with NATO strategy. 
 The Forces were then given four strategic roles: maintaining the British strategic nuclear deterrent; defending the United Kingdom Base; contributing to the landward defence of Western Europe; and helping to secure our seaward defences in the eastern Atlantic. 
 Since the low point in the mid-1970s, the Chiefs' influence has begun to wax  once more. 
 Britain now has a louder voice in world affairs that needs to be backed by a coherent national military strategy. 
 And the Chiefs' voice is no longer fragmented. 
 The Chief of Defence Staff is now the sole military adviser to the Government, drawing his advice from the three single Service Chiefs of Staff, whose responsibility is to give the naval, army and air points of view, unfettered by the need to reach collective decisions. 
 That is now the task of the Chief of Defence Staff and his Central Staff, who are responsible for formulating national military strategy, and for expressing it to the government of the day and within the Whitehall market-place. 
 Suggesting how Britain's future military strategy might be developed into the twenty-first century is the main purpose of this book on post-imperial Defence policy. 
 But first let us look back briefly at the events from 1945 to 1956 that provided the prologue to the post-imperial era which began at Suez.  
 the Coequal Anglo-American Partnership: 1945&ndash;56 
 The British decision to make an atomic bomb had &bquo;emerged&equo; from a body of general assumptions. 
 It had not been a response to an immediate military threat, but rather to something fundamentalist and almost intuitive &mdash; a feeling that Britain must possess so climacteric a weapon in order to deter an atomically armed enemy, a feeling that Britain as a great power must acquire all major new weapons, a feeling that atomic weapons were a manifestation of the scientific and technological superiority on which Britain's strength, so deficient in sheer numbers of men, must depend. 
 Professor Margaret Gowing, Official Historian to the UK Atomic Energy Commission. 
 Suez, in 1956, may have been a buoy in the main stream of British history, marking the end of empire and the beginning of the post-imperial era, but the course taken by Britain when rounding that buoy was based upon her experiences since the end of the Second World War. 
 These will be sketched briefly in this chapter to provide the background to Duncan Sandys' revolutionary Defence White Paper of 1957 &mdash; the first attempt to establish a post-imperial Defence policy. 
 The Empire reached its zenith after the First World War with the acquisition of former German colonies in Africa and with the addition of League of Nations mandates to govern parts of the old Ottoman Empire in the Middle East &mdash; Palestine, Jordan and Iraq. 
 The Second World War added no territory to the Empire, but it left British troops in occupation of the Italian empire in Africa, and the Dutch and French empires in the Far East. 
 But it also left her economically and psychologically exhausted. 
 Britain had once again snatched victory from defeat, but on this occasion the electorate decided charity should begin at home; although without consciously wishing to see any decline in Britain's influence in the world. 
 There seemed to be no incompatibility between building a welfare state at home and discharging the responsibilities of a great power abroad. 
 Indeed, socialism was expected to release the dynamic qualities of the British people that would create the wealth needed to sustain standards of living and world power. 
 While it was generally accepted that the country was economically near bankruptcy and would need time and a continuation of generous American aid to effect recovery, few people doubted the economy could be rebuilt faster than that of devastated Europe and Japan. 
 The majority view was that Britain was and would remain a great power, giving the world leadership based on her experience over the centuries rather than on the depth of her pocket. 
 After the First World War &mdash; the war to end all wars &mdash; hopes of a better world had rested upon the creation of the League of Nations, headed by the United States. 
 The American people opted for a return to isolationism: in consequence, the League lacked the power and cohesion to curb the ambitions of the Axis powers. 
 After the Second World War there was a greater sense of realism in implementing the provisions of the Atlantic Charter through the creation of the United Nations, but the Charter had contained a pledge that amounted to a promise to dismantle colonial empires. 
 Its third principle, which was based upon a draft by the imperialist Churchill rather than the anti-colonialist Roosevelt, read: 
 Third, they &lsqb;the Western Allies&rsqb; respect the right of all peoples to choose the form of Government under which they will live; and they will wish to see sovereign rights and self-government restored to those who have been forcibly deprived of them. 
 Although this principle was intended to apply to the Nazi-occupied territories of Europe, nationalists throughout the colonial world, particularly in India and  Burma, demanded its application to all dependent peoples. 
 They were pushing at a partially open door as far as Britain was concerned. 
 Both major political parties accepted that colonialism would be dismantled at a pace consistent, first, with the speed of political and economic development in each territory; and, second, with the growth in its ability to look after itself militarily. 
 Britain's voluntary, though gradual, conversion of the colonial Empire into the British Commonwealth of Nations would help her recovery as a great power: her military commitments to provide overseas garrisons should diminish, and her influence was expected to be enhanced as she became the central pivot of an association of free and independent states girdling the globe. 
 In the early stages of independence, former colonies were expected to need some military assistance through defence agreements, supplies of military equipment and provision of training teams. 
 Such agreements could only be honoured if Britain retained the power to go to their assistance when called upon to do so. 
 The old imperial line of communication through the Mediterranean, Suez Canal, Red Sea and Indian Ocean to the Far East and the Antipodes would be just as important to the Commonwealth as it had been to the colonial Empire. 
 And so it was envisaged that the former coaling and oiling stations of Gibraltar, Malta, Port Said, Suez, Aden, Bombay, Colombo, Penang, Singapore and Hong Kong would become air staging posts as well in the post-imperial era. 
 Two imponderables worried the British policy-makers: an American return to isolationism, and Soviet emulation of Tsarist imperialism. 
 Neither seemed imminent in 1945. 
 The closeness of the Anglo-American special relationship during the Second World War boded well for a continuing post-war partnership, in which Britain would be able to influence US policy in a mutually beneficial way; and latent Soviet hostility, which became apparent in London sooner than in Washington, was lessened by the assumed technological backwardness of Russia, and by the devastation she had suffered at the hands of the Germans. 
 Such was British confidence in the future that the Attlee government reintroduced Lloyd George's notorious &bquo;No war for ten years&equo; assumption for Defence planning, but for sounder reasons. 
 The military world was on the threshold of far-reaching revolutionary changes in weapon technology, not only in atomic weapons, but also in propulsion systems, missile guidance and electronics generally. 
 Sensibly, priority was to be given to research and development before any major re-equipment programmes were undertaken. 
 Meanwhile, the Services had to live on their very considerable wartime fat until the way ahead could be seen more clearly. 
 Sadly, all these post-war ambitions and assumptions proved fallacious. 
 Socialism could not create the wealth needed for the Welfare State as well as great-power status. 
 Britain lurched from one economic crisis to another under both Labour and Conservative governments. 
 It was not until the political and economic Thatcher revolution of the 1980s, in which the creation of wealth was  given priority over its equitable distribution, that a start could be made in reestablishing British influence in world affairs, although this process has been beset with the economic problems of the late 1980s. 
 The transition from Empire to Commonwealth was remarkably successful, but it did not strengthen Britain as had been hoped. 
 The loose-knit and voluntary grouping of independent states, united by ties of sentiment and not much else, could not match the political, economic and technological power of the homogeneous United States or Soviet Union although the total population and raw material resources of the Commonwealth were not inferior to those of the two superpowers. 
 Moreover, the theory that the pace of colonial development should and could be controlled effectively from Whitehall was soon disproved. 
 Like all withdrawals, the conversion of Empire into Commonwealth went far faster than was prudent or planned, thanks to American impatience, and to the hostility of the Communist and the Third World states. 
 Anglo-American relations, too, proved less harmonious than Britain expected or would have liked. 
 However co-operative US administrations might try to be, Congress was always there to put narrow American interests first. 
 The special relationship was born of a common heritage, but it was nurtured by American and British self-interest as well. 
 Even the most generous US aid was limited by the value placed upon it by Congress in terms of American advantage. 
 Nowhere was this more evident than in the marked differences in the handling of collaboration in the atomic and conventional weapons fields. 
 The United States sought to maintain an atomic energy monopoly &mdash; both military and civilian &mdash; as a God-given right; but for the purposes of conventional warfare they needed the support of allies and were prepared to buy international collaboration with superficially altruistic aid programmes. 
 In the immediate post-war years the special relationship almost collapsed. 
 Americans looked upon Britain not only as a poor relation, ignoring the causes of her poverty, but a dangerous one as well. 
 British socialism, so alien to the American way of life, was to them only a short step away from communism, which they feared would engulf the whole of Europe. 
 In the American view, the British Isles were too exposed to risk production or minimal stockpiling of atomic weapons on British soil. 
 And to make the point even more strongly, Lend-Lease was ended at Congressional insistence in August 1945 before the war with Japan was over; and the Truman Administration was only allowed to grant Britain her first post-war loan on the most ungenerous terms. 
 Congress would brook no potential economic rivals in the post-war world. 
 British, and for that matter American, estimates of Russian intentions and capabilities were equally awry. 
 As late as mid-1947 a reunited Germany was seen by the Foreign Secretary, Ernest Bevin, as a greater danger to world peace than the Soviet Union; and the Chiefs of Staff were assuming that Russia was unlikely to solve the problems of atomic weapon production before 1956 at the earliest. 
 In fact, the first Soviet atomic device was detonated in August 1949! 
 And as if to cap the list of failed British assumptions, the Korean War broke out  in June 1950, forcing the abandonment of the &bquo;no war for ten years&equo; rule and its substitution with an over-hastily generated rearmament programme, the size of which proved beyond Britain's economic capacity. 
 Revolutionary changes in weapon technology had not been the only reason for the reimposition of the Ten-Year Rule. 
 There was the pressing need to concentrate on national reconstruction, which imposed financial stringency in all other fields of government expenditure, including Defence. 
 And there was a deep feeling of uncertainty about the continuing validity of the Three Pillars of Britain's traditional grand strategy &mdash; defence of the British Isles, maintenance of a favourable balance of power in Europe, and projection and protection of British interests overseas. 
 Had the advent of atomic weapons invalidated them; did they need re-definition; and what priority should be accorded to each of them? 
 The most difficult strategic question was whether sea power was any longer the foundation upon which the Three Pillars could continue to stand. 
 Strategic air power had all but won the Second World War. 
 If it had not been for the extraordinary resilience of Hitler's Wehrmacht  and the fortitude of the German people, it would have done so. 
 Would the addition of atomic weapons to the RAF's armoury make it, rather than the Royal Navy, Britain's &bquo;Senior Service' in the atomic era? 
 (The term &bquo;nuclear&equo;, as opposed to &bquo;atomic&equo;, did not emerge in general parlance until the hydrogen bomb was tested by the United States in November 1952.) 
 There were many theories, but the clouded crystal of the future was almost opaque in the immediate post-war years. 
 The Labour Government and the Chiefs of Staff needed time to chart a new course in Defence policy. 
 As far as the First Pillar &mdash; the defence of the British Isles &mdash; was concerned, the country was, paradoxically, more secure and yet more vulnerable than it had ever been. 
 There was no immediate threat to the United Kingdom. 
 Germany was prostrate; France had ceased to be Britain's inveterate enemy; and the Soviet Union had enough on its hands rebuilding Mother Russia. 
 The spread of Communism presented a threat to the Second and Third Pillars, but was making no impact upon the British political system. 
 But our crowded islands were as vulnerable as Japan's had been to atomic attack, and there appeared to be no sure defence against it. 
 The Air Staff were not slow to underline the Second World War's lessons of air warfare: the need to win and to maintain air superiority by offensive air action. 
 In their view, two things were required to give Britain the prospect of security in the atomic era: first, the atomic bomb itself; and second, the means of delivering it at strategic ranges. 
 The Naval and General Staffs did not demur. 
 The principal questions that the Chiefs of Staff Committee addressed were whether long-range missiles would eventually replace the bomber as the delivery system; and if so, whether, in the meantime, the last generations of bombers needed to be supersonic or not. 
 The development of delivery systems &mdash; bombers or missiles &mdash; was well within  Britain's technological and financial resources in the late 1940s and 1950s. 
 Operational Requirements for the V-bombers were issued in 1946 with an in-service date of the mid-1950s, as required by the Government's Ten-Year Rule. 
 In the meantime, the wartime Lancasters would be replaced, as a stopgap measure, by the unpressurized Lincolns, which would be large enough to carry atomic bombs, if the Government decided to manufacture them in spite of US objections. 
 Beyond the V-bombers, which were to be high-altitude, subsonic aircraft with a range of 1,500 nautical miles, the Air Staff envisaged a supersonic successor with greater range and navigational accuracy. 
 They were confident, despite predictions by some eminent scientists, that the manned bomber would prove superior to any cruise or ballistic missile that might be developed from the German wartime V-1 (Flying Bomb) or V-2 (Ballistic Missile). 
 Nevertheless, they accepted the need for research into missile technology to go ahead in parallel with aircraft development. 
 With Australian collaboration, the Woomera Rocket Range was established in 1947 in the South Australian desert west of Adelaide with a telemetered track over the uninhabited heart of the continent to the Indian Ocean 1,250 miles away to the north west. 
 The problems associated with the development of the British atomic bomb for the V-bombers to carry were of a different order of magnitude. 
 The effort involved was likely to overstrain Britain's available scientific, financial and material resources, but the Government, supported by the representations of the Chiefs of Staff, accepted the burden as an essential component of Britain's recovery as a great power. 
 The strain could, however, be eased if renewed American co-operation in atomic development work could be negotiated. 
 In the wartime agreement on pooling brains and resources for the original work on the atomic bomb, which was signed at Quebec in 1943 between the United States and Britain in association with Canada, there were five clauses: the signatories would not use atomic weapons against each other; they would not use them against third parties without the others' consent; no information would be given to third parties without mutual consent; Britain disclaimed any interest in commercial and industrial exploitation, because the heavy burden of production would fall on the United States; and a Combined Policy Committee would be set up to ensure full and effective collaboration. 
 Subsequently a Combined Anglo-American Development Trust was established to handle the procurement and allocation of uranium ore. 
 Most of the then known uranium deposits were in British overseas territories, except for the very high quality ore of the Belgian Congo. 
 Britain had successfully negotiated long-term contracts for the total output from the Congo, and so had a near monopoly of ore supplies, which she had been happy to share with the US in the wartime atomic weapons programme. 
 In addition to the Quebec Agreement, there was a record of a conversation between Roosevelt and Churchill, agreeing that Anglo-American collaboration should continue in both military and commercial atomic development after the  defeat of Japan. 
 This was known as the Hyde Park Aide-Memoir  of September 1944. 
 It was on this document rather than the Quebec Agreement that the British Government pinned its hopes of continuing post-war collaboration and for American help with its own atomic bomb programme. 
 Almost as soon as the Japanese surrendered in August 1945 these British hopes turned to doubts. 
 The Truman Administration had already been forced by Congress to end Lend-Lease; many of the joint boards set up to co-ordinate the Anglo-American war effort were summarily dismantled; and, although the Combined Policy Committee and the Combined Development Trust survived, the flow of technical information, on which Britain was depending to set up her own atomic establishments, began to dry up. 
 Attlee flew to Washington in November 1945 with two purposes in mind: to agree a joint Anglo-American approach in the United Nations on the international control of atomic weapons; and to update the 1943 Quebec Agreement. 
 He was successful in the former, and he thought that he had laid the foundations for the latter. 
 But, as so often happens when dealing with the United States, informal agreements reached with Presidents are not necessarily supported by Congress. 
 Continued atomic collaboration with Britain had many enemies on Capitol Hill, amongst the American scientific community, and within the Government. 
 There were several prominent Anglophobes in Truman's Administration, like James Byrnes, the Secretary of State, but most of the opposition stemmed from the widely held belief within the American electorate that the United States should guard its lead, if not monopoly, in military and civil uses of atomic energy. 
 Very few American politicians and officials were aware of the secret Quebec Agreement, which was not revealed to them until May 1947, and none knew of the Hyde Park Aide-Memoir , which had been filed amongst Roosevelt's papers. 
 The arrest of the British scientist, Alan Nunn May, as a Soviet spy in March 1946, undermined American confidence in British security. 
 The general ground swell of opinion in Washington enabled the &bquo;American Firsters&equo; in Congress to force through the MacMahon Act in August 1946, making it a criminal offence to divulge classified atomic information to any other country, including Britain. 
 For internal political reasons, Truman did not oppose the passage of the bill despite his informal understanding with Attlee. 
 The MacMahon Act strained relations with Britain, but did not close the door entirely to limited atomic collaboration. 
 The Combined Policy Committee and the Development Trust stayed in being to handle unclassified and declassified information, and to adjudicate on the allocation of British controlled supplies of uranium ore, upon which the US programmes were heavily dependent. 
 Personal relations amongst officials on both bodies remained cordial, and as much as possible was done to keep collaboration alive without breaching the letter of Congress's legislation. 
 The MacMahon Act did not, as is often suggested, trigger Attlee's decision in January 1947 to go ahead with the development of the British atomic bomb. 
  Important steps had already been taken that were to lead to the decision. 
 Setting up of the Atomic Energy Research Establishment at Harwell had been agreed in October 1945; approval to build the first British atomic pile for the production of plutonium had been given in December; the Chiefs of Staff had stated their requirement for a British manufactured atomic bomb in January 1946; William Penney (later Sir William) had begun to plan the Atomic Weapons Section of the Armaments Research Establishment, of which he was Director, in mid-1946; the Air Ministry placed its first requisition for an atomic bomb on the Ministry of Supply in August; and Lord Portal, the wartime Chief of Air Staff, who had become Controller of Atomic Energy in the Ministry of Supply, sought a mandate from the Prime Minister to set atomic bomb development in train during the autumn of 1946. 
 Attlee gave the decision to go ahead in January 1947. 
 The MacMahon Act only reinforced his reasons for doing so. 
 It was symptomatic rather than part of the train of thought that led to his decision: Britain, as a great power, could not leave her security in the hands of the Americans, who, however friendly, could veer so unpredictably from generous international collaboration to self-centred isolationism. 
 The view of the Official Historian, Margaret Gowing, on Attlee's decision is quoted at the head of this chapter. 
 She went on to say: 
 The decision was also a symbol of independence. 
 It had not been taken as a result of the breakdown in 1946 of Anglo-American atomic cooperation. 
 The decision to produce fissile material in the United Kingdom had been taken before the breakdown and was regarded as non-negotiable in any circumstances&hellip;. 
 It is conceivable that if an agreement had been signed and if henceforth Anglo-American relations had been bathed in sweetness and light, arrangements might have been made for pooling atomic weapons production. 
 But in view of the actual American mood at this time, such a possibility is not worth even a cursory exploration. 
 As it was American atomic attitudes in this period hardened British resolution not to be bullied out of the business and not to acquiesce in an American monopoly; it encouraged her determination to be a nuclear power for the sake of the influence this was expected to give her in Washington! 
 What the MacMahon Act did do was to make the British programme slower and more expensive; and from the wider standpoint of the Western Alliance, it led to unnecessary duplication of effort. 
 The Government was tempted to seek alternative partners in the Commonwealth and Europe, but did not do so because the Americans had so much more to offer if the MacMahon restrictions could be circumvented or ameliorated. 
 Instead two further attempts were made during Attlee's prime-ministership to negotiate a replacement for the Quebec Agreement. 
 Both came near success, but, in the end, were defeated by those in the US Administration, who believed fervently in the preservation of  the American monopoly, and who considered that sharing with Britain constituted too great a risk to American security. 
 The first attempt was made in the autumn of 1947. 
 Some of the awkwardness in Anglo-American relations had been dispelled by a combination of circumstances; James Byrnes had been replaced as US Secretary of State by the anglophile General George Marshall; Britain, for her part, had supported the launch of the Marshall Plan in Western Europe; and the Americans were beginning to appreciate that they were unlikely to be able to tame the malign hostility of the Soviet Union as Roosevelt had once hoped. 
 British representatives in Washington thought that they detected an American shift towards a more liberal interpretation of the MacMahon Act whereby closer collaboration with Britain could be defended in Congress as being in the United States' best interests. 
 They felt that the time was ripe for a new approach. 
 Unfortunately they had misread the omens. 
 The actual driving force behind American thinking on a renewal of atomic collaborations was anxiety about uranium ore supplies, which were being consumed at an increasing rate as American programmes accelerated. 
 Here too the British misinterpreted American intentions. 
 They thought that Congressional leaders were trying to make Marshall Aid to Britain a quid pro quo  for larger allocations of British controlled ore supplies. 
 The American ploy, however, was even more devious. 
 Their hidden aims, according to the British Official History, were: 
 to abrogate the wartime agreements, to acquire British ore stocks, to get a much greater share of the Congo production and to obtain British and Canadian support for ore negotiations with South Africa. 
 In return the United States would give some information. 
 The meetings of the Combined Policy Committee, which was tasked to draft a replacement for the 1943 Quebec Agreement in the form of a modus vivendi , were constructive and cordial: the Americans had much to gain from making them so. 
 The Quebec clause, giving Britain a veto over an American use of the atomic bomb against third parties, was dropped in exchange for the release of Britain from the clause restricting her commercial exploitation of atomic energy. 
 The allocation of ore was settled for the next two years in America's favour, but the compensating exchange of information was far less liberal than the British negotiators had hoped. 
 The &bquo;some information&equo; turned out to be nine specific subjects in research and development fields, which, though useful, excluded anything to do with weapons. 
 Working on the principle that half a loaf is better than none, the British side accepted the agreement, intending to open negotiations separately on military issues. 
 The modus vivendi  was not signed, but it was promulgated in January 1948 in the minutes of the Combined Policy Committee so as to avoid reference to Congress or to the United Nations, which would have been necessary for a formal international agreement. 
 The proof of the pudding was in the eating: the modus vivendi  turned out to be a  great disappointment. 
 The Americans got their ore, but the British received a pittance of information in return. 
 An attempt by the Minister of Defence, A. V. Alexander, to reach an agreement on the release of weapon information with James Forrestal, the US Secretary for Defence, was equally unsatisfactory. 
 Forrestal was a believer in the theory that it was too dangerous for atomic weapons to be manufactured and stored in the United Kingdom, where they could be overrun in a Soviet invasion of Western Europe. 
 Furthermore, he saw incompatibility in Britain spending large sums on atomic weapons whilst accepting Marshall Aid. 
 There was just no meeting of minds on the weapons issue. 
 The Americans did not want Britain to acquire weapons of her own, and, though they were not prepared to say so publicly, they were determined to make acquisition as difficult and expensive as possible. 
 The British Ambassador, Sir Oliver Franks, wrote at the time. 
 The whole question of our relations with the Americans on atomic energy questions seems to me bound up with the larger issue of the extent to which the Americans are prepared to treat us on more or less equal terms as a first-class power. 
 The year 1948 was a US presidential election year, so further attempts to reopen the issue were deferred until a new Administration had taken office. 
 The delay proved wise, since in the meantime pressure of world events had begun to draw the two sides closer together again. 
 The Communist coup in Czechoslovakia (January 1948), the Berlin Blockade (June 1948), the signing of the North Atlantic Treaty (April 1949), the first Soviet atomic bomb test (August 1949), and Mao Tse Tung's proclamation of the Peoples Republic of China (October 1949), all rekindled a sense of common purpose between Britain and the United States, and created an urge to find a way of harmonizing their atomic energy programmes. 
 The second attempt to replace the Quebec Agreement with something more useful than the modus vivendi  began in September 1949, just after the detonation of the first Soviet atomic bomb was confirmed, and coincidentally with a devaluation of sterling, which threw a spotlight on the shakiness of the British economy. 
 The Americans wanted the greatest possible acceleration of weapon production on behalf of the Atlantic Alliance in order to keep ahead of the Russians, but they insisted on two principles: first, that production and storage facilities should be located with due regard to strategic considerations, and that meant location in North America with minimum holdings in Europe; and second, that there should be co-ordination of the American and British programmes to make best use of available expertise and resources, including exchange of scientists. 
 During the negotiations the British team accepted the force of most of the American arguments. 
 After much soul-searching, British ministers were prepared, if necessary, to concentrate upon industrial uses of atomic energy,  provided there was full technical co-operation and no restriction on exchange of information. 
 They also insisted that a minimum stockpile of atomic bombs (a figure of 20 was mentioned) should be maintained in the United Kingdom under British operational control at all times for use by Bomber Command. 
 The ministerial position went a long way towards meeting the US criteria, but the British side had worries as well. 
 They had been bitten too often by Congress reneging on agreements negotiated in good faith by the White House. 
 They insisted, therefore, that the agreement must have the formal approval of the President and a guarantee that no subsequent action by Congress could invalidate it; after all, the future security of the United Kingdom was at stake in such a far-reaching agreement. 
 All avenues were explored to see whether such a guarantee could be given by the Americans, but no way of doing so could be found without breaching the US Constitution. 
 The only way forward was via a formal international treaty, and there were still enough isolationists, atomic energy monopolists, and anglophobes in Congress to make the passage of the necessary legislation impracticable. 
 The price of integration of the British and American programmes had proved too high for both sides. 
 And so the British Government decided that Britain would remain independent unless there was a genuine change of heart in Washington that would allow the passage of a formal treaty through Congress. 
 Two events occurred that ensured, for the time being at least, no such a change in Congressional attitudes would occur. 
 In January 1950, the Americans decided to develop the hydrogen bomb. 
 They were determined to snatch and hold a lead in nuclear fusion weapons: exchanging information with Britain would, in their view, be far too risky. 
 This was given unfortunate confirmation a month later by the arrest, as a Soviet spy, of the British-naturalized Austrian scientist, Klaus Fuchs, who had worked at Los Alamos. 
 Matters were made worse by the defection of the Harwell scientist Bruno Pontecorvo in September 1950; and later by the escape to Moscow of the British diplomatic defectors Burgess and Maclean in June 1951. 
 It might have been possible for Britain to enforce Anglo-American nuclear collaboration by withholding ore stocks, but to have done so would have reduced American production of fissile material to the Soviets' advantage. 
 Until the RAF was carrying atomic bombs, the First Pillar of British grand strategy &mdash; the defence of the United Kingdom &mdash; depended upon the US Strategic Air Command. 
 It would have been foolhardy to risk weakening it at a time when the Cold War was about to turn hot in Korea. 
 The development of Labour Government policies for the Second Pillar &mdash; the maintenance of a favourable balance of power in Europe &mdash; was a happier story in that British and American interests coincided. 
 This was not so in 1946, but thanks to the blatancy of Soviet hostility, to the efforts of Churchill and Ernest 
 Bevin amongst the politicians, and to Field Marshal Montgomery amongst the military, they were soon aligned. 
 Churchill's Iron Curtain  speech in March 1946  at Fulton, Missouri, and Montgomery's discussions in September with the American Joint Chiefs of Staff, on the Potomac river in the yacht Sequoia , articulated the threat and laid the foundations for Anglo-American cooperation in the defence of Western Europe. 
 The first positive step in the post-war consolidation of Western Europe came about through Ernest Bevin's down-to-earth leadership amongst his Continental colleagues, which helped General Marshall to push his aid programme through Congress, thus pre-empting an economic collapse and a Soviet take-over. 
 Thereafter, events had an almost predetermined ring about them as Soviet action was matched by Western reaction. 
 The Communist coup in Czechoslovakia in February 1948 was followed by the signing of the Brussels Treaty with a 50-year term in March. 
 The Berlin Blockade of June heralded the stationing of the first three US bomber groups in the United Kingdom in July; and was followed by Montgomery's appointment as Chairman of the Western European Chiefs of Staff committee in November, and the signing of the North Atlantic Treaty the following April, coincidently with the passage of the US Mutual Defence Aid Programme through Congress. 
 And the outbreak of the Korean War in June 1950 looked so very like the preliminaries to the Third World War that it led to Eisenhower again becoming the Allied Supreme Commander, Europe, with Montgomery as his deputy in November to prepare resistance to a probable Soviet invasion across the Iron Curtain. 
 This chain of events led to British support of NATO becoming the basis of her Second Pillar of grand strategy, but it was to be another four years, and under Churchill's last Administration, before it was finally set in concrete with the extension of the Brussels Treaty in the October 1954. 
 Britain pledged herself to keep BAOR, comprising four divisions, and RAF (Germany) on the Continent in order to assuage French fears of German rearmament, which the extended Treaty now authorized. 
 For the first time since Mary Tudor lost Calais in 1558, Britain had troops permanently stationed across the Channel in peacetime. 
 Formulation of Labour Government policies to support the Third Pillar &mdash; the projection and protection of British interests overseas &mdash; needed least reorientation of traditional British military thinking that had evolved from three centuries of global geo-political experience. 
 The threat to British interests had changed, with international Communism replacing the political and military intrigues of predator European powers and Tsarist Russia of earlier centuries, but the policies for meeting the new threat remained traditional: the judicious stationing of garrisons to protect overseas territories from external aggression and from internal subversion; the deployment of naval forces to maintain the freedom of the seas in areas of British interest; and the positioning of strategic reserves at key points, like Egypt and Singapore, on the imperial lines of communication through Suez to the Far East. 
 Domination of the Middle East had always been seen as an important element of British strategy since Nelson defeated Napoleon at the Battle of the  Nile in 1798; and it remained so into the 1940s and early 1950s. 
 The Middle East was seen as the sea and, later, the air crossroads of the Eastern Hemisphere; as the land bridge between Europe, Asia and Africa; and as the main source of sterling oil upon which Britain and Western Europe were becoming increasingly dependent. 
 Britain had sunk vast capital sums into the military installations set up in the Suez Canal Zone and at Alexandria to serve the British campaigns in the Mediterranean during the Second World War. 
 Much the same could be said of Singapore. 
 It, too, was at another of the world's maritime crossroads: it was part of the island chain from Asia to Australasia; it was an important source of sterling rubber and tin; and it had major naval, army and air installations to house and support strategic reserves. 
 It is not surprising, therefore, that the continuing use of the Canal Zone and Singapore became axiomatic in post-war military planning. 
 While the Anglo-American partnership was vital but unequal in maintaining the First and Second Pillars of grand strategy, Britain was expected to go it alone in supporting the Third Pillar, which was an essentially British requirement that had little to do with the Americans or the North Atlantic Alliance. 
 Moreover, in the light of the Americans' deep-seated anti-colonialism, neutrality was the most that could be hoped for in the problems that would face Britain in converting her Empire into the Commonwealth at a prudent and realistic pace. 
 The United States was not in the business of helping to prolong British imperial power. 
 Such Anglo-American co-operation as there was outside Europe was directed towards the containment of Soviet and Chinese Communism. 
 And in this endeavour Britain had much to offer: experience in handling Afro-Asian affairs, and bases around the periphery of the Communist Bloc, from which political and military pressure could be exerted. 
 Although old-fashioned spheres of influence were anathema to the United States, there was a tacit acknowledgement of areas of primary leadership in the protection of Western interests from the cancer of Communism. 
 The division of responsibility was based upon past historical connections and more recent wartime involvement with particular areas of concern. 
 The United States took the lead in North East and East Asia due to their occupation of Japan, and to their support of Nationalist China: Britain led in South East Asia, the Indian Ocean and the Middle East. 
 While the Americans were re-educating Japan, the British were waging their long but successful campaign against the Chinese Communist terrorists in the jungles of Malaya, and the French were failing to master the Communist-inspired rebellion in Indo-China. 
 The Anglo-American partnership outside Europe was put to the test when the Korean War started in June 1950. 
 The Attlee Government loyally supported the American-led United Nations war effort, not only with naval, army and air forces, but also with a major rearmament programme of its own. 
 Its loyalty was to contrast favourably with American disloyalty five years later during the Suez crisis. 
 Allied intelligence assessments suggested that the  Communist offensive in Korea was a preliminary skirmish to draw Anglo-American forces eastwards, and to hold them in the Far East while Soviet forces destabilized the politically shaky states of Western Europe. 
 The chances of these Communist tactics leading to the Third World War by 1953 were deemed too high for any complacency in Western capitals. 
 In Washington, the Combined Anglo-American Chiefs of Staff Committee was reactivated, and it proposed massive rearmament programmes for both countries. 
 The British programme was costed at &pound;6,000 million spread over three years, to which the United States would make an undefined contribution. 
 Subsequent Cabinet and Service Department screening in Whitehall reduced the figure to &pound;4,700 million which was the most that the Treasury believed the economy could bear without being put on to a war footing. 
 At the same time National Service was increased from eighteen months to two years. 
 By 1953, Defence expenditure had almost doubled and was running at around 10 per cent of GDP. 
 The British electorate, conscious of the lessons of pre-war appeasement policies, accepted the burden as a reasonable insurance against a Third World War. 
 The Korean War, and more particularly the fear of a major Soviet offensive of some kind in Europe in 1953, which killed the Ten-Year Rule, led to crash production programmes at the expense of the previous policy of giving priority to research and development. 
 Although the first production order for V-bombers (the Valiant) was placed in December 1950, the V Force itself, carrying British-manufactured atomic bombs, could not become operational before the mid-1950s at the earliest. 
 The United States had already agreed under the Mutual Defence Aid Programme to provide 70 B-29 bombers (renamed Washingtons in RAF service) as a stopgap, and these had started to arrive in March 1950 as part of the NATO build-up in Western Europe before the Korean War began. 
 The Washingtons, though welcome, could not fill the gap entirely, so thoughts turned to the production of relatively simple flying bombs. 
 Two flying bomb systems were tried: Bristol Aircraft's plastic Blue Rapier, and Vickers' light alloy Red Rapier. 
 When the intensity of the crisis had died down and fears of an imminent Soviet advance into Western Europe had receded in late 1953, both were cancelled and work was started on a stand-off weapon for the V-bombers. 
 The first was Blue Boar, a glide missile with television guidance and a range of only 25 nautical miles, on which preliminary work had begun in 1951. 
 By 1954, the Air Staff decided that an all-weather system was needed and that the technology for it was available. 
 Blue Boar was dropped and replaced by Blue Steel Mk 1, an inertially guided cruise missile with a range of 100 nautical miles that eventually came into service with the V Force in 1962 as part of Britain's Independent Nuclear Deterrent. 
 The development of the V-bombers' supersonic successor, the AVRO 730, and of Blue Steel MkII with a range of 750 nautical miles, began in the mid-1950s. 
 The story of Britain's fighter development was more complex and was  slowed by one fundamental error of scientific judgment. 
 In 1945, the Miles Aircraft Company was developing a supersonic experimental aircraft, the M 52, but lack of basic data on supersonic conditions led to the decision in 1948 not to risk a pilot's life flying it until more was known about the compressibility of air, or the sound barrier. 
 Instead, it was decided to use remotely-controlled test vehicles. 
 The M 52 development was stopped, but testing without &bquo;a man in the circuit&equo; proved unreliable. 
 Data accumulated subsequently suggests that the M 52 could have been flown safely and might have given the British aircraft industry a commanding lead in supersonic fighter development. 
 Nonetheless, research and development in post-war fighter aircraft went forward at a brisk pace and over a wide range of options. 
 It was not without its setbacks, one of which was the Korean War rearmament programme, that resulted in premature production of two subsonic fighters as short-term stopgaps: the highly successful Hunter and the unsuccessful Swift, both of which entered RAF service in 1954. 
 By that time there were three supersonic contenders for the medium term: the English Electric Company's P-1, which later became the Lightning, the Saunders Roe P-177, which combined jet with rocket propulsion; and the Fairey delta-winged PD-2, in which Peter Twiss wrested the air speed record from the Americans in 1956 with a speed of 1,132 m.p.h. 
 Concurrent with these military developments the British aircraft industry was waging a losing battle with the Americans for a large share of the civilian passenger and freight markets. 
 The health of the industry in the longer term, and hence the degree of independence Britain would attain in military aircraft production, would depend on the outcome. 
 It was not a happy saga. 
 Commercial, political and military misjudgments played significant parts in Britain's defeat. 
 The commercial misjudgment centred upon British Airways' obstinately held belief that turbo jets were more economic than pure jets and were preferred by passengers. 
 Politically, unemployment in Belfast created pressures favourable to the turbojet Britannias, that were built there, to the disadvantage of Vickers' VC-7 with pure jet engines. 
 Unfortunately, the Air Staff, who preferred the military version of the VC-7, the V-1000, could not make a strong enough case to offset the commercial and political arguments favouring the Britannia. 
 The VC-7/V-1000 was scrapped, and the Boeing 707 rode through the gap as pure jets proved both economic and attractive to passengers in spite of the Comet 1 disasters. 
 On the other side of the technological coin, missile development was going ahead concurrently with aircraft design. 
 Both the American and British missile programmes owed much to German wartime work on their V-1s and V-2s, which did so much damage to London, Antwerp and Paris during the closing stages of the Second World War. 
 The Americans forged ahead not only because they could deploy greater resources, but also because they were more ruthless in seeking out key German experts during the chaos of the German surrender, and in persuading them to work for them in the United States. 
 The British  research and development establishments were curiously loth to employ them, and the Germans themselves preferred to rebuild their lives in North America where the scientific opportunities were so much greater. 
 Unlike their failure to collaborate in the atomic field, the two countries did decide to work together on missiles. 
 An agreement to do so was signed in February 1950, just over a month after the breakdown of the second attempt to replace the 1943 Quebec Agreement. 
 In the British programme, the missile rival to the AVRO-730 supersonic bomber was Blue Streak, a liquid-fuelled ballistic missile with a 2,500-nautical mile range and weighing 100 tons. 
 The American equivalents were Atlas and Titan 1. 
 The British air defence missiles were the Royal Navy's Sea Slug, the Army's Thunderbird, and the RAF's Bloodhound. 
 Their American equivalents were the Hawk and Nike families of missiles. 
 During the early 1950s too little was known about rocket propulsion and missile performance for finite decisions to be taken in favour of either aircraft or missiles. 
 It was generally assumed that they would probably prove to be complementary to each other, but what the optimum mix would be was far from clear. 
 There were, of course, the inevitable extremists who foresaw the demise of one or other system for a variety of different and often conflicting reasons. 
 But in the history of warfare new weapon systems rarely achieve immediate dominance: only the passage of time and operational experience decides whether the older, well-tried systems should be superseded or not. 
 The Korean rearmament programme soon proved to be too ambitious for Britain's fragile economy and fatal to Attlee's Labour Government. 
 The balance-of-payments crisis of 1951 was caused by one foreseen and two unexpected factors. 
 The former was the obvious clash between Britain's need for exports to pay her way in the post-war world and the requirement of the rearmament programme, both of which competed for the same scarce skills and resources of the metal-working industries to the detriment of the export trade. 
 The two unforeseen factors were the Iranian nationalization of the Anglo-Persian Oil Company during the Abadan crisis of May 1951 which forced Britain to buy oil for dollars; and the inflation of world raw material prices due to the demands of the American rearmament and strategic stockpiling programmes. 
 British colonies profited by the latter, but spent their newly earned dollars on their own development programmes, causing a major outflow of dollars from the sterling area. 
 The Socialist Government might have survived the crisis had it not been for the internal rift within the Labour Party that was brought about by the Cabinet's decision to impose charges for medical prescriptions to curb excessive waste in the newly established National Health Service. 
 Aneurin Bevan, who led the revolt against the charges, portrayed them as the direct result of the financial strains caused by the rearmament programme. 
 Attlee went to the country over the issue and lost the general election of October 1951. 
 The clash between the demands of the Welfare State and Britain's desire to regain her position as a great power had claimed its first victim!  
 Churchill's return to power had an immediate and dramatic effect upon Anglo-American relations. 
 Doors that had remained firmly shut in Attlee's days began to open. 
 During his visit to Washington in January 1952, he was briefed in depth on the US Strategic Air Plan. 
 The briefing convinced him that the combination of the atomic bomb and air power would give the Western Alliance a favourable balance of power in the world for the foreseeable future. 
 A month later, the NATO Council met in Lisbon and surprisingly ignored US atomic capabilities. 
 They based the Alliance's first &bquo;Force Goals&equo; upon outdated concepts that called for the deployment of very large conventional forces by the Alliance. 
 The target set by NATO for Britain was nine to ten regular and territorial divisions (in 1954 the figure was raised to the even more impracticable level of nine of each by D-day plus 30). 
 The superimposition of massive conventional forces on what should have been an atomic strategy, made no sense to Churchill, who appreciated that financial pressures would reduce rather than increase the number of divisions that Britain could contribute to Western European defence. 
 He instructed the Chiefs of Staff to examine ways of discharging Britain's military commitments more economically, absorbing less manpower and reducing dollar expenditure. 
 The Chiefs of Staff took the unusual step of going down to the Royal Naval College, Greenwich, in the late spring of 1952, where they worked for a fortnight on Churchill's requirement with their principal scientific and technological advisers, free from the day-to-day hubbub of Whitehall. 
 The Global Strategy paper that they produced pleased Churchill, and it became the starting point for the development of British military strategy in the nuclear era. 
 The term &bquo;nuclear&equo; rather than &bquo;atomic&equo; is appropriate from this time onwards because the first American hydrogen bomb was tested in November 1952. 
 Although the first British atomic bomb had only just been tested a month before at Monte Bello Island off the north-west coast of Australia, the British government, under Churchill's leadership, decided remarkably quickly in December to follow the American lead and to build its own hydrogen bomb as soon as possible. 
 The Chiefs of Staff 1952 Global Strategy paper concluded that Soviet and Chinese Communist aggression could best be countered by nuclear deterrence. 
 Although the US Strategic Air Command's nuclear capability was already formidable, Britain should make her own contribution to the Western nuclear deterrent by giving absolute priority to the rapid build-up of the V Force in order to maintain British influence in the Atlantic Alliance, and as a hedge against isolationist tendencies in the United States. 
 They hoped that the number of troops committed to NATO for conventional defence could be reduced when tactical nuclear weapons, then under development in the US, became available within the Alliance. 
 At sea, the Royal Navy should prepare for a long &bquo;broken back&equo; period after a nuclear exchange in Europe, during which resupply across the North Atlantic would  be vital to the United Kingdom's survival, whether the exchange had been decisive or not. 
 In considering policies for the protection of British interests outside Europe, the Chiefs of Staff envisaged a reduction in the very large forces deployed in the Middle East, provided a new Anglo-Egyptian Treaty could be successfully concluded in 1952 as the Foreign Office was confidently expecting. 
 In the Far East, they believed that Chinese Communist subversion would create increasing instability and prevent any reduction of force levels East of Suez. 
 Bearing in mind the continuing need to protect British interests and to support friendly states in the Middle and Far East, they recommended that steps should be taken to build up RAF Transport Command's capacity to provide greater strategic and tactical air mobility. 
 The creation of air-mobile strategic reserves could lead, they thought, to a reduction in static overseas garrisons; and the replacement of troop-ships by trooping-aircraft should also save manpower locked up in the trooping pipeline. 
 The years 1952 and 1953 saw further major changes in the world's political leadership. 
 Eisenhower won the 1952 presidential election, and brought in John Foster Dulles as his Secretary of State. 
 Stalin died in March 1953 and was succeeded by the moderate Malenkov, who was to be ousted by the raucous Khrushchev in February 1955. 
 The Korean armistice was signed in July 1953; the first Soviet hydrogen bomb was tested in August; the RAF received its first British atomic bombs into service with the V Force in November; and at the turn of the year, Foster Dulles announced the United States' twin policies of &bquo;massive nuclear retaliation and the containment of the Soviet Union&equo;. 
 The US Strategic Air Command had the bombers and nuclear weapons to make his &bquo;retaliation&equo; policy credible. 
 His energetic, though convoluted, diplomacy gave reality to &bquo;containment&equo; with the formation of SEATO in May 1954; the extension of the Brussels Treaty in 1954 to include the rearmament of West Germany and the British pledge to keep four divisions on the Continent; and the signing of the Baghdad Pact in February 1955 that led to the formation of CENTO in 1957. 
 One of the conclusions of the Chiefs of Staff was soon disproved by events. 
 The Middle East became more troublesome than the Far East where the British successes in the Malayan jungles contrasted sharply with the French disasters in Indo-China (Dien Bien Phu fell in May 1954); and Anthony Eden's diplomacy led to the Indo-China settlement at Geneva in July 1954. 
 It was the fall of King Farouk of Egypt in July 1952 and the subsequent rise of Colonel Nasser, not only as dictator of Egypt, but also as the leader of Arab Nationalism, that invalidated the Chiefs of Staffs assessment of the Middle East. 
 Nasser drove a much harder bargain than Farouk's negotiators, which seriously delayed the completion of the New Anglo-Egyptian Treaty, preventing any reduction of British troops in Egypt. 
 The negotiations were not helped by American diplomats in Cairo, who covertly supported Nasser, or by the machinations of the US oil companies operating in the Middle East.  
 Anglo-American relations in the Middle East were far from satisfactory in the early 1950s. 
 While Britain had given the United States wholehearted support in Korea, she had also shown her independence by what the Americans saw as over-precipitate recognition of Communist China, and by Attlee's personal efforts to dissuade Truman from extending the war to mainland China and from using atomic bombs to settle the conflict. 
 The boot was now on the other foot in the Middle East where the Americans were the critics and Britain was shouldering the primary responsibility for the stability of the area. 
 The American view of the Middle East situation was that any failure of British colonialism to come to terms with Arab Nationalism would open the door to Communist infiltration and eventual domination of the area. 
 American political pressure on Churchill in London, and diplomatic help to Nasser in Cairo, resulted in the highly unsatisfactory Anglo-Egyptian Agreement of October 1954, whereby the military base installations in the Canal Zone were to be handed over to British civilian contractors, and all uniformed personnel were to leave Egypt by the end of March 1956. 
 The bases could only be reactivated if the Egyptian Government agreed that there was a military threat to international integrity of the Suez Canal. 
 The British Government had every right to expect uninhibited American support in ensuring the success of this impracticable settlement: it was not forthcoming. 
 Anthony Eden took over from Churchill in April 1955 as British troops began their withdrawal from the Canal Zone to new bases in Cyprus and Aden, and back to England to reinforce the Strategic Reserve. 
 (The last troops, in fact, left 
 Egypt on 13 June 1956.) 
 The first V-bombers were entering service equipped with free-fall atomic bombs (Blue Steel stand-off missiles were not available until 1962). 
 The development of the Blue Streak ballistic missile that might replace the V-bomber had started, and was greatly helped by the 1950 Anglo-American agreement to collaborate in missile technology; and the development of the British hydrogen bomb was well under way. 
 In Europe, NATO had accepted the deployment of US tactical nuclear weapons. 
 BAOR was about to be equipped with US Corporal and Honest John missiles with their nuclear warheads held by American custodial teams. 
 The same arrangement was to be extended to nuclear artillery shells when these too became available. 
 No attempt was being made to manufacture British tactical nuclear weapons, but the Army was developing its own surface-to-surface tactical missile, called Blue Water, to replace Corporal. 
 With a new Prime Minister at the helm, the time was opportune for a further review of strategy to take account of these recent advances in weapon systems. 
 Eden took a close personal interest in the 1955 Review of Strategy, writing the guidelines himself: 
 1. 
 The main threat to our position and influence in the world is now political and economic rather than military; and our policies should be adapted to meet the changed situation. 
 Effort must be transferred from  military preparations to maintenance and improvement of our political and economic position. 
 2. 
 The period of foreign aid is ending and we must now cut our coat according to our cloth. 
 There is not much cloth. 
 We have to find means of increasing, by &pound;400 million a year the credit side of our balance of payments. 
 3. 
 In our defence programmes generally we are doing too much to guard against the least likely risk, viz. the risk of a major war; and we are spending too much on forces of types which are no longer of primary importance. 
 The possibility of ending of National Service was not mentioned in these guidelines, but it was the first item on the agenda of subjects to be discussed, and it was seen in the Whitehall market-place to be the political &bquo;Blue Chip' stock of the year. 
 The market discounted the fact that most of the military policy-makers doubted the practicability of reverting to the British tradition of voluntary regular service without taking undue risks with the country's security. 
 The chances of recruiting enough regulars seemed slender in the conditions of overfull employment prevailing in Britain in the 1950s. 
 In his memoirs Eden wrote: 
 I had long wished to bring National Service to an end. 
 A large proportion of our forces had to be ready to travel to distant theatres of war and it was uneconomic that they should be composed of National Servicemen, admirably though those carried out their duties&hellip;. 
 I was not, however, prepared to give an undertaking to bring National Service to an end until I was certain that we had the necessary voluntary enlistment. 
 The 1956 Defence White Paper summarized the outcome of the 1955 Review of Strategy: 
 The increased power of the deterrent, that is, the nuclear weapon and the means of its delivery, has made global war more frightening and less likely. 
 Our first and chief objective must be to prevent war by the maintenance of the Allied deterrent, to which we have begun to make our own substantial contribution. 
 It is our belief that given the deterrent, given the robust faith on the part of the free world in the strength of their institutions, and given continued growth of NATO's defensive power, global war can be prevented. 
 In the deterrent must be included an effective early warning system and the ability of the forces of the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation to hold the line by land, sea and air until the nuclear counter-offensive has broken the back of the enemy assault. 
 In the military strategy devised by the Chiefs of Staff to support the Eden  Government's Defence policy, the Services were to fulfil four roles: contributing to the Allied nuclear deterrent; exerting influence in the Cold War; dealing with outbreaks of limited war; and playing an effective part in global war, if the deterrent were to fail. 
 There was to be a modest reduction in their strength from 800,000 to 700,000 in all ranks. 
 No mention was made in the 1956 Defence White Paper of the possibility of ending National Service, but within the War Office a committee was set up under General Sir Richard Hull (later to become Field Marshal, succeeding Mountbatten in 1965 as Chief of Defence Staff) to examine the size of regular Army that would be needed, and could be recruited, if National Service was abolished. 
 The Navy and Air Force were less dependent on National Servicemen, but were directed to formulate contingency plans for their demise. 
 And so it came about that while the Operational Staffs of the three Service Ministries were grappling with the Suez crisis of 1956, which entailed increasing the Defence effort and calling up reservists to fill gaps in the order of battle for the contingency plan Musketeer , they were answering questions posed by the Hull Committee about the implications of halving Service manpower by April 1960 or 1961 at the very latest! 
 The rights and wrongs of the Suez d&eacute;b&acirc;cle will be debated as long as the history of the mid-twentieth century has any relevance in world affairs. 
 The crisis itself, and the subsequent failure of the Anglo-French efforts to topple Nasser, demonstrated where real power lay. 
 In effect, the two new superpowers came together to crush the great powers of yesteryear; and the growing voice of Afro-Asia in world affairs was heeded for the first time. 
 As far as Britain was concerned, the failure showed the limits not only of British power, but also of the Anglo-American special relationship. 
 It was cold comfort to realize after the event that the drama had been played out by three sick men, whose judgments contributed to this deeply wounding incident in Anglo-American relations: Eisenhower was suffering from ileitis; Dulles had cancer; and Eden had a recurrence of the abdominal obstruction that had laid him low once before in 1953, and was to do so again after he resigned. 
 Eden, who in pre-war days had fought a losing battle in British politics against the appeasement of the dictators, saw Nasser as the reincarnation of Mussolini, if not of Hitler; and in consequence, tried to use a sledge-hammer to crack a nut. 
 Dulles precipitated the crisis by peremptorily withdrawing US financial aid for the Aswan Dam, thereby opening the door to the flow of Eastern Bloc arms and influence into the Middle East &mdash; the very situation that he had feared British colonial obduracy would create. 
 And yet he refused to follow through the consequences of his devious diplomacy. 
 Siding covertly with Nasser, he progressively undermined the Suez Canal Users Association, which he himself had created, and sapped British and French confidence in American good faith with every twist in his tortuous attempts to reach a peaceful solution. 
 Eisenhower, who was in the midst of his re-election campaign and was presenting himself to the American electorate as &bquo;a man of peace&equo;, failed to  make clear to his British and French colleagues in the Atlantic Alliance the depth of his reluctance to countenance the use of force over an issue that was only important and not vital to US interests. 
 During the Korean War, Attlee made Britain's objections to the extension of the conflict to mainland China crystal clear to Truman. 
 Eisenhower and Dulles prevaricated over Suez, and, in the longer term, the United States has paid the price for their misjudgments. 
 America inherited Britain's thankless task of trying to maintain a semblance of stability in the Middle East, and has been singularly unsuccessful in doing so over the three decades that have passed since Suez. 
 The political lessons of Suez could not be disguised. 
 In relative terms, Britain was shown to be a middle-ranking power with her ability to take independent military action strictly limited. 
 In the face of American, Soviet and Afro-Asian opposition to colonialism, it was also clear that Britain no longer had the resources to dictate the speed at which her Empire should be transformed into the Commonwealth of independent nations. 
 Her imperial era was over, though it took another decade and two major anti-terrorist campaigns in Borneo and Aden to complete the transition. 
 The military lessons were equally clear. 
 British military reaction had been too slow and ponderous to command respect in the politico-military environment of the post-war world. 
 The Suez operation smacked too much of a Normandy-style landing, and too little of the quick military reaction needed in the nuclear era, which is also the era of instant communication and mass-media debate on a world scale. 
 The buttress of the Third Pillar of grand strategy &mdash; domination of the Middle East &mdash; had collapsed into a pile of rubble, blocking Britain's sea and air communications to the Far East. 
 Finding ways round the block of Arab Nationalist states, that stretched from Syria in the north to the southern frontier of the Sudan in the south, was to become one of the major tactical problems faced by the Defence operational staffs and the Diplomatic Service throughout the 1960s. 
 While it may be debatable whether Suez marked the end of Britain's imperial era, it undoubtedly blew away the mirage of coequality in the Anglo-American partnership. 
 This might have been the moment for Britain to transfer her loyalties to the European Community, but her ties with the Commonwealth and the special relationship were too strong. 
 Europe might be geographically closer than the United States, but it was psychologically much farther away. 
 Britain's attachment to her colonies, past and present, was far stronger than her recently acquired Brussels Treaty links with her historic rivals across the Channel. 
 Moreover, Europe was still recovering from wartime devastation, and had achieved neither political coherence nor a sound enough military/ industrial base to provide a viable alternative to the North American connection. 
 In the aftermath of Suez, Britain had no other option but to try to repair the damage done to her trans-Atlantic anchor cables and to accept her position as an offshore island of the United States.  
 The Offshore Island of the United States: 1956&ndash;70 
 The British Empire and the United States will have to be somewhat mixed up in some of their affairs for mutual and general advantage.  
 For my part, looking out for the future, I do not view the process with any misgivings.  
 I could not stop it if I wished,; no one can stop it.  
 Like the Mississippi, it just keeps rolling along.  
 Let it roll.  
 Let it roll on full good, inexorable, irresistible, benignant, to the broader lands and better days . 
 Sir Winston Churchill 
 Duncan Sandy's Nuclear Reformation: 1957&ndash;59 
 The forebodings of the Chiefs of Staff were largely justified. 
 He &lsqb;Duncan Sandys&rsqb; treated them with scant consideration, brushed their doubts and fears aside, and scarcely allowed them to make their voices heard. 
 Philip Ziegler, Mountbatten : 
 &bquo;The Sandys Years&equo;. 
 The Suez crisis of November 1956 had demonstrated Britain's economic vulnerability, the decline in her political power, and the cumbersome orthodoxy of her military establishment. 
 But it did not throw a spotlight on the inadequacies or otherwise of British weapons and equipment, apart from obvious shortages of transport aircraft and ageing of her amphibious shipping. 
 There was, however, a growing realization in Whitehall that Britain could no longer &bquo;go it alone&equo; in weapon development, and so she would have to seek some form of closer partnership with the United States, at least, until Europe could provide a viable alternative. 
 And that, in 1957, seemed a very long way off. 
 When Harold Macmillan took over from Anthony Eden in January that year, he had three primary objectives in mind: to place the British economy on a sounder footing; to repair the damage done to Anglo-American relations by Suez; and to restore the fortunes of the Conservative Party. 
 With the next general election not due until May 1960, he had three years in which to establish himself as Prime Minister, provided he could ride through the political fallout from Suez. 
 Radical changes in Defence policy lay at the root of Macmillan's aspirations. 
 Righting the economy demanded major cuts in Defence spending and the release of skilled manpower from the Services to export-orientated industries. 
 Closer collaboration with the United States would reduce costs in weapon  development, and enable Britain to be more selective in the projects she chose to pursue by herself in order to maintain the greatest measure of national independence. 
 And the electorate's view of the Conservative Party would depend upon its success in creating a Defence policy that was perceived to give reasonable security at lower cost. 
 There was, as yet, no significant revulsion amongst the general public towards the use of nuclear weapons to save manpower. 
 Indeed, it was considered a desirable benefit flowing from Britain's advanced technology. 
 Ending National Service, if it proved practicable, would be a political prize of great value. 
 Should the Conservatives fail to bring it about, the Labour Party would certainly incorporate it in their next election manifesto. 
 Macmillan decided on a two-handed approach. 
 With one hand he would try to mend Britain's fences with the United States by using his own close relationship with President Eisenhower and other senior members of the US Administration, which he had formed when he was British political adviser at Eisenhower's Allied Force Headquarters in the Mediterranean during the War. 
 With the other, he would exploit the nuclear defence philosophy sketched out by the Chiefs of Staff in their 1952 Global Strategy paper to get rid of National Service. 
 As a former Minister of Defence, Foreign Secretary, and Chancellor of the Exchequer, he was all too familiar with the Defence arguments in the Whitehall market-place. 
 They had convinced him that no radical change in Defence policy would be negotiable unless the Minister of Defence was given greater powers to override the special pleading of the Admiralty, the War Office, the Air Ministry, and the Ministry of Supply. 
 The vigour with which changes were imposed would help to create public confidence in his administration; and a measure of ruthlessness would be needed to overcome the conservatism of the military establishment. 
 He needed a minister with the strength of character, reforming zeal and awareness of technological opportunities to push through the changes in Defence policy that he had in mind to help in the consolidation of his political power. 
 Duncan Sandys was the obvious choice. 
 He had the drive and determination that Macmillan sought, and his time in the Ministry of Supply had given him experience in, and a fascination for, advanced technology in weapon development. 
 On 18 January 1957, he was invested with the necessary powers. 
 In the immediate post-war years, the Minister of Defence had been little more than the co-ordinator of the three autonomous Service Ministries and the Ministry of Supply. 
 His Chief Staff Officer was not even a full member of the Chiefs of Staff Committee, the chairmanship of which was rotated between the three Service &bquo;Chiefs&equo;. 
 In October 1955, Eden had increased the powers of the Minister marginally, and his Chief Staff Officer was made Chairman of the Chiefs of Staff Committee. 
 Appreciating that the RAF would be playing a dominant role in manning Britain's nuclear deterrent, Eden had appointed Marshal of the Royal Air Force Sir William Dickson to the post. 
 Macmillan now  took the process of integrating the Service Ministers a step further by making Duncan Sandys, his new Minister of Defence, responsible for: 
 the formulation and general application of a unified Defence policy relating to the Armed Forces of the Crown as a whole and their requirements. 
 Duncan Sandys was personally tasked by Macmillan: 
 to work out a new Defence policy in the light of present strategic needs which would secure substantial reduction in expenditure and manpower; at the same time to prepare a plan for reshaping and reorganising the armed forces. 
 Subject to the overriding authority of the Defence Committee and the Cabinet, he would have the power to decide: 
 all questions on the size, shape, organisation and dispositions of the forces, as well as their equipment and supply, and their pay and conditions of service. 
 Sandys went off to Washington at the end of January to update himself on the latest US operational thinking and advances in weapon technology. 
 During his visit the Americans offered to supply Britain with 60 of their Thor intermediate-range ballistic missiles to reinforce the nuclear deterrent while the V Force was being built up with Vulcans and Victors. 
 Manning these missiles would give the RAF experience in handling ballistic systems while Blue Streak was being developed. 
 Thanks to the updating of the 1950 Anglo-US missile agreement in 1953, British development costs and time were being saved by fitting Blue Streak with Atlas rocket engines and inertial guidance systems. 
 The Thors and their nuclear warheads were to be provided at US expense. 
 The launch sites would be constructed by the United Kingdom, and the missile systems would be fully manned by the RAF crews. 
 Control would be by &bquo;Dual Key&equo;. 
 Generous though the offer seemed to be at first sight, it was in American interests to acquire missile sites in Britain to bring the Soviet Union within range of American attack. 
 Turkey and Italy were the only other NATO countries that would provide sites for Thors. 
 Allowing the British to man the 
 Thors was a small price to pay for the risks that Britain would be running by having American missiles deployed in her crowded islands. 
 The possibility of the Soviets being able to counter with similar missiles of their own seemed remote in January 1957. 
 Sandys' friendly reception in Washington, and the Thor offer, confirmed suggestions, gleaned through diplomatic channels, that the Americans were as anxious as the British to start healing the wounds of Suez. 
 At Eisenhower's suggestion, he and Macmillan met at Bermuda in March. 
 The meeting did start the healing process, and it gave the US an insight into the thinking behind  the changes in British Defence policy towards which Macmillan was working. 
 It also formalized British acceptance of the Thor missiles and the agreement that they would only be used with the sanction of both governments. 
 Meanwhile, Duncan Sandys had been imposing his own view of future British Defence policy upon Whitehall with the dogmatic enthusiasm of a religious reformer. 
 On 21 October 1517, Martin Luther had nailed his Ninety-Five Articles of Religion on the door of Wittenberg Cathedral, starting the Protestant Reformation. 
 On 4 April 1957, Duncan Sandys published the 73 paragraphs of his notorious Defence White Paper entitled Defence: Outline of Future Policy, thereby triggering the British Nuclear Reformation. 
 Prior to Sandys the orthodox military priesthood had seen nuclear weapons as being in support of conventional forces. 
 In the Sandys doctrine their roles were reversed: primacy was to be given to the nuclear weapon, and conventional forces were to be reduced to a supporting role. 
 Neither Luther nor Sandys would have achieved much had the political conditions of the day not been extraordinarily favourable. 
 In the sixteenth century, Roman Catholicism was ripe for reform, but Luther's success depended less on religious conviction than on the determination of the north German princes to be rid of the political influence of Rome. 
 In the latter half of the twentieth century, belief in Sandys' nuclear philosophy counted for less than the political opportunity that it provided for ending National Service. 
 The Sandys doctrine was a crystallization of the imponderables of the early years of the nuclear era. 
 It solidified the tentative ideas that had been evolving in Whitehall since the drafting of the 1952 Global Strategy paper; and it was, in many respects, ahead of thinking in Washington, where traditional military orthodoxy still held sway. 
 It rested on two basic assumptions: that Britain's power and influence in the world depended upon a sound economy; and that by making the fullest use of nuclear weapons, missiles, and modern transport aircraft, men and money could be saved for the country's economic benefit. 
 The traditional ways of supporting the Three Pillars of Britain's grand strategy would need radical revision. 
 The embryo British independent nuclear deterrent would, in Sandy's opinion, replace sea power as the foundation upon which the Three Pillars would stand in future. 
 Sandy's view of the First Pillar &mdash; the defence of the British Isles &mdash; was chillingly realistic: 
 It must be frankly recognized that there is at present no means of providing adequate protection for the people of this country against the consequences of an attack with nuclear weapons. 
 Though in the event of war the Royal Air Force would unquestionably be able to take a heavy toll of enemy bombers, a proportion would inevitably get through. 
 Even if it were only a dozen, they could with megaton bombs inflict widespread devastation. 
 The conclusion &bquo;that the overriding consideration must be to prevent war  rather than to prepare for it,&equo; was inescapable. 
 He recognized that, pending a comprehensive international disarmament agreement: 
 the only existing safeguard against major aggression is the power to threaten retaliation with nuclear weapons. 
 Although the defence of the West depended primarily on the American nuclear umbrella, he could justifiably claim that there was a wide measure of agreement in Britain that the country must possess &bquo;an appreciable element of nuclear deterrent power&equo; of its own. 
 British atomic bombs were already in steady production. 
 A British megaton weapon had been developed and would shortly be tested. 
 They would both be delivered by the V Force. 
 The crux of the White Paper lay in para. 42: 
 The revised Defence plan, with its greatly reduced demands on manpower and its emphasis on highly trained mobile forces, now makes it possible to contemplate putting the Services on to an all-regular basis; and the Government will endeavour to bring about this change as soon as practicable. 
 The crunch came in para. 47: 
 The Government have accordingly decided to plan on the basis that there will be no further call-up under the National Service Acts after the end of 1960. 
 Sandys acknowledged that the Army would have the greatest difficulty in making ends meet. 
 It had about 164,000 regulars, of whom only some 80,000 were on more than a three-year engagement. 
 The Government's demographers advised that the largest regular army that could be recruited and sustained, under the conditions of full employment prevailing at that time, would be in the order of 165,000, excluding the 14,600 Gurkhas and other locally recruited forces. 
 Sandys hoped to reduce the risks of failure to reach this figure by making regular military service a more attractive long-term career. 
 In weapon procurement the highest priority was to be given to: 
 The development of British nuclear weapons suitable for delivery by manned bombers and ballistic missiles. 
 Nuclear warheads were also being developed for defensive guided missiles. 
 Close co-operation with the United States was seen as a means of saving time and money with little regard to the risks of losing some national independence. 
 In view of the likely progress in missile development, the supersonic AVRO 730 manned bomber would be cancelled; and no further work would be done on fighter aircraft after the completion of the development of the English Electric Lightning. 
 There would be increased emphasis on nuclear propulsion for maritime purposes. 
 And closer collaboration would be sought with Western Europe and the Commonwealth, particularly with Australia.  
 Sandys set out the ways and means of his reformation in the form of a five-year rolling programme. 
 Before he took office the Defence estimates for 1957-58 were running at &pound;1,700 million. 
 His short-term measures to reduce expenditure brought the figure down to &pound;1,420 million. 
 He had every hope that his longer-term plans would reduce the Defence share of the GDP from 7. 1 per cent down to 5 per cent by the end of his five-year programme. 
 He did, however, warn that savings would not be proportionate to the cut in manpower because regulars were more expensive than National Servicemen, and equipment costs were rising. 
 Sandys concluded his White Paper with a peroration: 
 The Government are confident that this defence plan, while helping to relieve the strain on the economy, will produce compact all-regular forces of the highest quality, armed and organized on the most up-to-date lines. 
 It might have been more honest to have said that the price paid for ending National Service was increased dependence on nuclear weapons. 
 The corollary was just as true: elimination of nuclear weapons would require a return to National Service. 
 It would do so just as surely today, in the 1990s, as it would have done in the late 1950s. 
 The contents of Duncan Sandys' White Paper were judiciously leaked during March; a standard Whitehall ploy based on the well-founded assumption that neither the market nor the media like to be taken by surprise. 
 They need time to digest radical change, otherwise their immediate reaction is negative. 
 Sandys' &bquo;Articles of Religion&equo; were well received by the majority in both major political parties in the House of Commons, and in the country at large. 
 Labour showed some chagrin that the Tories had stolen a march on them by ending conscription, but even Aneurin Bevan, the shadow Foreign Secretary and a unilateralist at heart, accepted the need for the British nuclear deterrent, making his famous remark that to abandon it would &bquo;send a British Foreign Secretary, whoever he may be, naked to the conference table&equo;. 
 At the Labour Party Conference of 1957, it was generally accepted that to give up the independent nuclear deterrent would disable a future Labour government from pursuing a foreign policy not approved by Washington. 
 British vital interests might not necessarily coincide with those of the Americans as Suez had shown all too clearly. 
 Over-dependence upon the United States should be avoided at all costs. 
 Hugh Gaitskell made the Tory Government's case for it when he said in the House of Commons Defence debate: 
 We might have to say to them (the US), &bquo;Will you please threaten to use the ultimate deterrent? 
 We have not got it.&equo; 
 Could we be sure in those circumstances that the American president and Congress would be prepared to risk the wholesale destruction of American cities merely to meet our point of view? 
 George Brown, who later became Foreign Secretary, when asked why in his opinion Britain needed the hydrogen bomb replied: 
 I want us to have our own foreign policy, and that means having the means to carry it out. 
 Attitudes outside Parliament were very similar, and would have reduced Labour's chances of winning the next election if they had advocated non-nuclear defence in 1957. 
 In an opinion poll taken in December of that year on the question &bquo;Which do you think is the more important for Britain to concentrate on: building up strength in atomic weapons and missiles, or in conventional weapons like troops, tanks and bombers?&equo; 52 per cent favoured the former, 8 per cent the latter, 22 per cent neither, wanting disarmament instead, and 18 per cent did not know. 
 Sandys' proposals were not so well received inside Whitehall. 
 Service attitudes &mdash; even in the RAF, which had most to gain from the Sandys Reformation &mdash; were bitterly hostile. 
 Part of the trouble stemmed from a dislike of Sandys' refusal to heed professional advice, and from his propensity for allowing the senior civil servants in the Ministry of Defence to usurp the powers that properly belonged to the Chiefs of Staff. 
 Justifiable comparisons were made with Hitler's OKW, where selected men exercised unbridled power without the responsibility of executive management. 
 Nevertheless, Sandys had some Service supporters. 
 For instance, Lord Mountbatten, who was First Sea Lord at the time, records that he found Sandys a good listener. 
 This was perhaps because he managed to stop Sandys sweeping the aircraft-carriers onto the junk-heap of history as he had intended to do when he first took office. 
 While the Chiefs were largely as one in their dislike of Sandys and his methods, there was little else that united them: each had to do his best to preserve the interests of his own Service in the turbulence that hit the Whitehall market-place in 1957. 
 The Royal Navy's primacy was threatened and, with Mountbatten as First Sea Lord, the Admiralty was soon fighting back. 
 The Army was more ambivalent: while welcoming the end of National Service and the return to &bquo;real soldiering&equo; with a regular army, the Army Council looked askance at the loss of 51 regiments, 17 of which were infantry battalions with battle honours stretching back over the centuries. 
 Once such regiments had been disbanded, their accumulated battle experience would be lost for ever. 
 The CIGS, General (later Field Marshal) Sir Francis Festing, felt the price of Sandys' Reformation was too high and considered resignation, but the other Chiefs would not support him, believing that such gestures would have little impact on a government that had the full support of Parliament and the electorate for its Defence policy. 
 The Air Staff were relatively content since Sandys had confirmed the RAF's ascendancy as the wielders of the independent nuclear deterrent. 
 Nevertheless, even they had qualms about the longer term. 
 The disappearance of manned bombers as well as fighters would reduce  the RAF to a missile and air-transport force &mdash; not an inviting prospect, but one that seemed too far ahead to worry about unduly in 1957. 
 Sandys soon found that the easiest part of his Nuclear Reformation was writing and pinning up his &bquo;Articles of Religion&equo; in Westminster. 
 During the two shorts months that it took to draft the White Paper, opposition could be quelled, using the new powers and wholehearted support given him by the Prime Minister. 
 But starting the Reformation was only half the battle: turning its principles into practicable policies and maintaining momentum in the face of opposition from determined vested interests was much more difficult. 
 Sandys' task was eased to some extent by Macmillan's success in reestablishing the Anglo-American special relationship. 
 In the aftermath of Bermuda, goodwill surged to and fro across the Atlantic. 
 British confidence and American respect for Britain were enhanced by the successful detonation of the British hydrogen bomb at Christmas Island in the Pacific in May 1957, which gave credibility to the independence of the British nuclear deterrent. 
 Even Admiral Hyman Rickover, father and all-powerful master of the US Navy's nuclear programme, who had hitherto blocked all Anglo-American collaboration in nuclear submarine development and had a well-known contempt for all things British, agreed not only to Britain purchasing an American reactor for her first nuclear submarine, Dreadnought , but also for the reactor to be the most recent second-generation version, thus saving Britain valuable time and development costs. 
 British staffs were also made aware of the progress being made in the development of two mobile strategic missiles in the United States: the US Air Force's bomber-launched Skybolt missile; and its rival, the US Navy's submarine-launched Polaris. 
 Sandys, when Minister of Supply, had already been instrumental in deciding to develop Blue Streak as the replacement for the V-bombers, and so in 1957 he saw no requirement for either Skybolt or Polaris. 
 There was, none the less, an element of condescension, if not charity, in the American efforts to undo the Suez damage. 
 Condescension disappeared on 4th October 1957 when the Russians launched their Sputnik 1 into earth orbit, and on 3rd November sent up Sputnik 2 with a dog in it. 
 The world's strategic balance had been upset dramatically. 
 The Western hemisphere would soon be in range of and vulnerable to Soviet intercontinental ballistic missiles, carrying megaton warheads. 
 The American nuclear umbrella over Western Europe would become less certain and the case for the independent British nuclear deterrent was correspondingly strengthened. 
 More immediately the Americans appreciated that the measure of technological superiority over the Soviets, on which their political and military plans were based, had been an illusion. 
 They needed British and West European support more than they had previously been prepared to admit. 
 Self-interest, if nothing else, brought about a genuine change in American attitudes. 
 The shock waves of the unexpected Sputnik launches, which broke on both shores of the Atlantic, brought disarmament into coequal partnership with  deterrence as a primary aim in Western Defence policy. 
 This was clearly demonstrated in Duncan Sandys' second Defence White Paper, published in February 1958, in which disarmament was given pride of place. 
 It was appreciated, even at this early stage in the post-Sputnik era, that nuclear disarmament had to be accompanied by reduction in conventional forces as well, and an effective system of verification had to be devised. 
 Every Defence White Paper to this day has stressed the importance the British Government attaches to the achievement of a comprehensive nuclear and conventional force disarmament package as the only alternative to nuclear deterrence. 
 Soon after the first Sputnik launch, Macmillan crossed the Atlantic to consolidate the refound Anglo-American special relationship. 
 He was very conscious of &bquo;An ominous note of confidence and truculence in recent statements of Russian policy. &bquo; 
 The meetings in Washington recaptured something of the wartime Anglo-American relationship that had done so much to win the Second World War. 
 They ended with the &bquo;Declaration of Common Purpose&equo; at the heart of which lay a commitment by the President to: 
 request the Congress to amend the Atomic Energy Act of 1954 as may be necessary and desirable to permit close and fruitful collaboration of scientists and engineers of Great Britain, the United States, and other friendly countries. 
 Such was the state of American public opinion that Congress did not demur. 
 The MacMahon Act was amended in July 1958, enabling the two countries to sign the Agreement for Co-operation on the Uses of Atomic Energy for Mutual Defence Purposes. 
 Under its terms, exchange of information and materials was permitted solely to those countries that had made &bquo;substantial progress&equo; in the development of nuclear weapons. 
 The Administration's interpretation of this proviso was such that only Britain was able to benefit from it. 
 Thus the costly development of the British hydrogen bomb had paid off handsomely. 
 It had opened the door to closer collaboration in the nuclear field, bringing substantial savings in research and development costs, and enabling Britain to retain and constantly modernize her independent nuclear deterrent in ways that otherwise would have been beyond her economic means. 
 The exchange of nuclear information was not a one-way street. 
 The British thermo-nuclear tests on Christmas Island showed that British scientists were ahead of their American colleagues in several important areas and could contribute significantly in the collaborative exchanges. 
 In operational planning, the Declaration of Common Purpose, which Macmillan would have preferred to have called the Declaration of Interdependence, led to even closer relations between the British and American air forces. 
 The provision of bases in Britain for the US Strategic Air Command bombers and the RAF-manned Thor missiles were repaid in exchanges on nuclear strategy, tactics and  targeting. 
 The RAF's V Force began to play a modest, but significant, role in the Western deterrent. 
 The Royal Navy had been the first Service to react strongly to the Sandys Reformation. 
 Soon after Sandys had been appointed, Mountbatten's immediate predecessor as First Sea Lord, Sir Roderic McGrigor, had written to warn him about Sandys&equo; views. 
 His letter is worth quoting as it shows the depth of feeling and suspicion in the Services at that time. 
 Sandys believed, he said, that: 
 (a) In war very little in the way of a navy is necessary as everything will be finally decided by the H-Bomb (b) In peace foreign stations are unnecessary. 
 We can always warn trouble-makers that if they don't stop it the RAF will deal with them (c) Cruisers are not needed and should be scrapped (d) Aircraft Carriers and naval Aircraft are unnecessary. 
 The RAF can do it all and it is their job (e) Other types of ships should be drastically reduced 
 In fact the Navy is no longer needed and it is a luxury the country cannot afford. 
 On taking office Sandys did, indeed, warn the Board of Admiralty that he believed that carriers cost more than they were worth. 
 He did not believe in the 1952 Global Strategy paper's concept of a period of &bquo;broken-backed war&equo; after an indecisive nuclear exchange in Europe that would give the Navy a worthwhile role in the Atlantic in global war. 
 The Admiralty stood its ground on the principle of always maintaining a balanced fleet, based on a limited number of capital ships, which, in 1957, were generally agreed to be the aircraft-carriers. 
 However, their Lordships shifted the emphasis in Naval policy away from global to limited war scenarios, while, at the same time, stressing the continuing need for anti-submarine forces and carrier-borne nuclear strike aircraft in the NATO area for global war purposes. 
 The naval arguments were persuasive. 
 Sandys accepted the need for carriers in limited war and enshrined the continued existence off our carrier groups, one of which would normally be deployed East of Suez, in his 1957 White Paper. 
 Moreover, he did not cancel the development of the naval strike aircraft, the NA 39, which eventually became the highly successful Buccaneer. 
 The Navy can be said to have won the first round of the long-running carrier battle, which was to bedevil Naval-Air relations for the next decade. 
 The Naval shift of emphasis to limited war capabilities was strongly supported by the General Staff, who doubted whether the degree of strategic mobility, upon which Sandys was banking to reduce overseas garrisons, would be practicable with the transport aircraft likely to be available in the foreseeable future. 
 Quick air-reinforcement with infantry was one thing, but  any serious fighting or prolonged operations would need far heavier loads and greater tonnages of ammunition and supplies than the RAF could lift in the required time scale. 
 The gap would have to be bridged with supply by sea. 
 Moreover, they saw a strong case for the development of amphibious forces, supported by the carrier groups, to seize points of entry for the fly-in of air-transported forces. 
 There were few potential trouble spots, in which British forces were likely to be involved, that were not reasonably close to the sea; and naval forces had the advantage of being able to lie out of sight over the horizon during periods of tension. 
 The Naval and General Staff cases were made for them by Sandys&equo; tour of the Mediterranean, Middle East, and East Africa in July 1957, and of the Far East in August. 
 Perhaps the greatest impact was made on his thinking by the Commonwealth Prime Ministers&equo; Conference of that year, when general dismay was expressed about his proposed reductions in overseas garrisons before adequate air-reinforcement capabilities had been built up. 
 He was made aware that nuclear weapons were no substitute for the presence of frigates on station and infantry battalions on the ground in maintaining stability in Afro-Asia. 
 In developing the future size and shape of the Royal Navy, the Admiralty had two useful and recent precedents: the successful use of carrier-borne aircraft in interdicting the Chinese supply routes during the Korean War; and the much more recent use of carriers to provide the lion's share of tactical air support during the Suez landings, and the ad hoc  use of the carriers Theseus  and Ocean  as Commando-helicopter-carriers in the amphibious assault on Port Said. 
 Realizing that they had a fight for Naval survival on their hands, the Admiralty took the unprecedented step of &bquo;going public&equo; to win support of opinion-makers, politicians, industrialists, and Commonwealth representatives in London. 
 They staged a major presentation of Naval policy, called Exercise &bquo;Fairlead&equo;, at the Royal Naval College, Greenwich, in May 1957. 
 What the general effect of their anti-Sandys offensive was on informed opinion in the country at large and in Whitehall in particular is not easy to judge. 
 In some quarters it was counter-productive, as it was seen as naked lobbying, and in others it was applauded as a justifiable counter-offensive against an ill-founded doctrine. 
 Nevertheless, it seems to have had some effect on Sandys. 
 In July, he authorized the conversion of the carrier Bulwark  into a Commando Ship, and the inclusion in estimates of funds for the subsequent conversion of Albion  as well. 
 In one important area the Navy held its ambitions in check for bargaining reasons within the Whitehall market-place. 
 The Board of Admiralty had been well aware since 1955 that the US Navy's Polaris-armed submarines might become the capital ships of the future, and might prove to be more invulnerable as mobile launch platforms for the nuclear deterrent than the US Air Force's Skybolt, if it too was successfully developed. 
 They watched the progress of  Polaris closely, but made no bid for it because to have done so would have loaded the Naval votes with its costs at the expense of the rest of the Fleet. 
 Taking over responsibility for Britain's nuclear deterrent from the RAF would be attractive only if funds allocated for it were transferred from the Air vote; or 
 Polaris was paid for out of a Central Staff vote. 
 The Admiralty were also well aware that the Air Council would oppose a naval bid for Polaris, and that they would have most of Whitehall on their side. 
 For the British nuclear deterrent to be truly independent, it should be based upon British and not US delivery systems. 
 Blue Steel Mk II and Blue Streak were in full development and their cancellation was unthinkable. 
 Added to which, a serious takeover bid by the Navy at a time when the Services needed to stand together to mitigate the worst excesses of the Sandys Reformation, would have been unforgivable. 
 The Admiralty held its hand. 
 The Air Staff's worries were longer-term. 
 As far as could be foreseen, they were to retain responsibility for the nuclear deterrent after ballistic missiles had taken over from manned bombers. 
 The men being trained on the Thors would provide the cadre for the future RAF Missile Command. 
 In the meantime, the life of the V Force would be extended and its vulnerability reduced by the provision of Blue Steel Mk II with its stand-off range extended from the Mark I's 100 nautical miles to 700, and its speed raised to Mach 3 at 70,000 feet. 
 Skybolt did not figure, as yet, in the Air Staff's calculations. 
 At the heart of the 
 Air Staff's confidence lay the belief that Sandys would be proved wrong by events and that the days of manned aircraft were still far from over. 
 Like the Royal Navy, the RAF sought and found a gap in the Sandys doctrine, and it was the Army's requirements that again provided the case. 
 There was little doubt that tactical support and reconnaissance for the land battle would still need piloted machines. 
 Furthermore, the need to win air superiority over the battlefield was as vital as ever. 
 It was generally accepted that this was best achieved by attacking enemy tactical aircraft on their airfields. 
 There was already an Air Staff Target (GOR 339) in existence for the replacement of the Canberra light bomber with a Tactical Strike and Reconnaissance aircraft capable of carrying nuclear or conventional weapons, which would be ideal for airfield attack. 
 The RAF's case for the Canberra's replacement was also reinforced by the need to preserve the viability of the British aircraft industry, which was threatened with collapse after cancellation of work on the supersonic bomber and ending fighter development. 
 The orders for civil aircraft alone could not sustain the large number of smallish firms that comprised the industry. 
 And so the Air Staff found that they had a vociferous and powerful industrial lobby in both Westminster and Whitehall to back their case for GOR 339. 
 Sandys bowed to the political and industrial pressures generated by the Air Lobby and accepted the validity of the Air Staff requirement for GOR 339, which became the ill-starred TSR 2. 
 He insisted, quite reasonably, that one basic airframe should be used to meet both the Air and Naval Staff  requirements for a strike/reconnaissance aircraft. 
 The development of the Naval version, the NA 39, was ahead of the RAF's and was showing great promise. 
 It was partially funded by the US under the Mutual Defence Aid Programme, and, from the Defence costs point of view, was the obvious choice as the common airframe, if the operational requirements of the two Services could be harmonized. 
 Whether harmonization of requirements would prove feasible or not, there would have to be a major rationalization of the aircraft industry if it was to continue competing in world markets. 
 The prospect of amalgamation led to a bitter battle amongst the aircraft contractors over the TSR 2, in which only the fittest and most ruthless firms survived. 
 Out of it came the British Aircraft Corporation (an amalgamation of Vickers and English Electric) with the design contract, and Bristol-Siddeley with the responsibility for the development of the Olympus engine. 
 Harmonization proved impossible: the two Services were looking for two quite different aircraft. 
 The RAF wanted a new &bquo;capital&equo; aircraft with a broad spectrum of capabilities that would replace the V-bomber in the missile era, and would demonstrate the continuing need for pilots in air warfare. 
 The Navy, on the other hand, looked on the Buccaneer as just another weapon in their armoury with specific and narrowly-defined tasks. 
 In the arguments that followed Sandys' decree that a common airframe should be used, the fundamental weakness of the Whitehall bargaining system in equipment procurement was demonstrated. 
 The Air Staff sought battlbattle-winningormance in an aircraft that would do virtually everything in all weathers from long-range nuclear deterrent strike, through all the phases of reconnaissance, down to close battlefield support for the Army, almost regardless of cost since it was to be their capital aircraft. 
 The Defence scientists accepted the challenge and supported the Air Staff in making the best the enemy of the good. 
 In the end, they priced the TSR 2 out of the market, though this outcome still lay in the clouded mists of the future. 
 In 1957, costs were too uncertain and experience too limited in putting together so complex a weapon system for the Treasury to do more than impress on the Air Staff that the TSR 2 must be accommodated within the Air Ministry's financial ceilings. 
 But when a Service is seeking a capital system upon which its very future may depend, it will always offer to accommodate the cost by slipping lesser-priority programmes to the right or cancelling them altogether. 
 During the propaganda war that was waged between Sandys and the Services, the Air Staff were not to be outdone by the Admiralty. 
 In May 1958, just a year after the Navy's &bquo;Fairlead&equo; presentation at Greenwich, they mounted a larger and more elaborate seminar of their own, called Exercise &bquo;Prospect&equo;, at the Royal Commonwealth Society in Northumberland Avenue, London, to put the RAF case to the opinion-makers. 
 In his summing up at the end of &bquo;Prospect&equo;, the Chief of Air Staff, Sir Dermot Boyle, publicly expressed the RAF's opposition to the Sandys Reformation. 
 He said:  
 We in the Royal Air Force, if you ask for our professional advice, are convinced that we will require manned aircraft as far as we can see to supplement the missile in both the offensive and defensive roles. 
 No man, even such a strong and determined minister as Duncan Sandys, can force Whitehall to accept more change than it collectively sees as reasonable. 
 The Navy had won the first round of the carrier battle: Sandys now conceded the RAF's case for developing the TSR 2 around a new airframe instead of forcing the naval NA 39 upon them. 
 Unfortunately, the TSR 2 was such an advanced and complex weapon system that British industry could not provide a firm with sufficient breadth of technological expertise to act as prime contractor. 
 In consequence, the project became a Whitehall &bquo;camel&equo; (a vehicle designed by a committee) instead of having a chief designer able to impose his personal decisiveness on the final product. 
 The committee system was to become standard practice in aircraft development in Europe for the rest of the century. 
 The TSR 2 did not establish a happy precedent, though the full implications still lay in the future. 
 The Army had no capital ships or aircraft to worry about: manpower was its principal concern. 
 Its size and shape depended on the number of infantry battalions and armoured regiments in its order of battle. 
 Artillery, Engineer, and Signals regiments, and its logistic corps, were tailored to support them. 
 Each infantry battalion and armoured regiment had to have an operational &bquo;peg&equo;, but much of the sting was taken out of the Sandys Reformation, as far as the Army was concerned, by many of its regiments having 2nd and 3rd battalions, which could be amalgamated with 1st battalions as National Servicemen ran out, thus preserving regimental traditions. 
 The Army was also promised that a large proportion of the financial savings, which flowed from ending of National Service, would be ploughed back into major re-equipment and barrack rebuilding programmes to make regular service more attractive. 
 The Army had another reason for quiet confidence. 
 The figure of 165,000 could be taken as the basis for further negotiation, because no one could tell how regular recruiting would go. 
 The level of future military commitments was just as uncertain. 
 In the General Staff's view, instabilities in Britain's overseas territories were likely to grow rather than decline as Sandys hoped. 
 Afro-Asian aspirations for more speedy decolonization than the British Government thought wise, or indeed practicable, were already causing concern in the aftermath of Suez. 
 Moreover, there were four years before the last National Serviceman would leave the Army, in which time world instabilities would, in the General Staff's opinion, make the Army's case for a higher manpower ceiling. 
 They had few doubts that the Army could recruit as many regulars as it really needed, within reason, provided the country was prepared to pay enough for them. 
 From the moment the 1957 White Paper was published, the Army Council maintained discreet but relentless pressure on the Government to increase the ceiling as commitments grew, just as the General Staff had  predicted they would do, and as recruiting figures showed that it was practicable to find enough men to take &bquo;the Queen's Shilling&equo;. 
 In 1958 regular recruiting went far better than the demographers had predicted, and the Army Council was able to substantiate its claim for a higher manpower ceiling. 
 Its pressure paid off, but Whitehall had to find a face-saving formula to cover its miscalculation. 
 The 1959 Defence White Paper announced that the Army would be allowed to recruit up to a ceiling of 180,000 &bquo;to ensure that its strength shall not fall below the planned figure of 165,000&equo; &mdash; a lame excuse since this requirement was just as valid in 1957. 
 The new ceiling enabled the War Office to retain some extra units that would otherwise have been disbanded. 
 The first task that faced the Government after the publication of Sandys' White Paper of 1957 was to convince its European allies, the United States, and the Commonwealth, that nuclear weapons were a valid substitute for manpower, and that the proposed reductions in British forces deployed overseas would not increase world instability. 
 It proved to be an uphill struggle, and was far from successful. 
 The French were the first to object: they still had qualms about German rearmament. 
 The Germans themselves were equally nervous about any reduction in the strength of the Rhine Army. 
 Even when the Bundeswehr  was fully established, NATO's Central Front would still be relatively weak compared to the Soviet deployment in Eastern Europe. 
 Moreover, the Germans had no desire to be saddled with more of BAOR's sector of the front: they had enough on their hands under-pinning the Dutch and Belgian corps, whose military worth they had good reasons to doubt in the late 1950s. 
 And to all Britain's European allies there seemed to be something incongruous about her ending conscription just as they were trying to expand their conscript forces under American pressure, in order to make the forward defence of Western Europe, which they all desired, a practicable strategy. 
 It was also vital to raise the nuclear threshold in Europe by increasing the level of conventional forces, and yet the British, for all too obvious financial reasons, were doing just the opposite! 
 In Washington there was understanding, but just as much disquiet about British Defence policy. 
 The Sputnik demonstration of Soviet technological capabilities had made Foster Dulles&equo; philosophy of massive nuclear retaliation untenable, and in its place had come the theory of imposing a pause with conventional forces to allow time for last-minute negotiations to reduce the chances of mutual nuclear suicide. 
 It took the very considerable diplomatic skills of Macmillan and the British ambassadors in Washington, Brussels, Paris and Bonn to win reluctant acceptance of Duncan Sandys&equo; theory that 45,000 regular troops, supported by tactical nuclear weapons, would be more valuable to the Alliance than 77,000 National Servicemen with only conventional artillery and air support. 
 SACEUR, General Lauris Norstadt, argued for and won some delay in Sandys'  programme and a modest increase in the proposed strength of BAOR. 
 The run-down was to be stretched over a longer period and the agreed strength raised from Sandys&equo; proposed 45,000 to 55,000. 
 The only consolation that Britain's partners could perceive was that she had not reneged on her Brussels Treaty obligations altogether: her commitment to station troops permanently on the Continent was still intact, but many people wondered for how long &mdash; &bquo;perfidious Albion'! 
 The reduction of British troops on the Continent was within the competence of the British Government: cutting back overseas garrisons was not so amenable to arbitrary decisions in Whitehall. 
 In the 1950s, the National Service Army of some 450,000 men with 77,000 in BAOR had just managed to win the anti-terrorist campaigns in Malaya, Kenya and Cyprus. 
 In the 1960s, under the Sandys plan, a regular army of only 165,000 was expected to maintain stability in the colonial Empire as well as keeping BAOR at 55,000 men &mdash; not an inviting prospect. 
 Sandys&equo; proposed deployment of the Army might have been practicable if Afro-Asia had remained quiescent, and if the Army had been given the strategic mobility needed to compensate for its reduction in manpower. 
 Any chance of the former had been negated by Britain's failure to topple Nasser at Suez; and the latter was unlikely for some years because the aircraft did not, as yet, exist; and the RAF had no real enthusiasm for providing the necessary money to buy them out of Air votes, which they quite naturally wanted to use for combat and not transport aircraft. 
 In the event, Afro-Asian Nationalists and Communists were encouraged by the Anglo-French defeat at Suez. 
 The militants were tempted to think that the door to their ambitions was ajar. 
 The 1957 White Paper confirmed in their minds that the decline in British power had reached a point where the concerted pressure of world opinion, particularly in the United Nations, would throw the door wide open for them to walk through into their heritage of immediate rather than prudently timed independence. 
 During his tours of the Middle and Far East Duncan Sandys was made well aware by British Governors, High Commissioners and Commanders-in-Chief of the political and military risks that he was taking; and local political leaders, like the Tunku Abdul Rahman in Malaya and Lee Kuan Yew in Singapore, warned him of the dangers of creating power vacuums that could be exploited by the Communist powers. 
 But there could be no going back on the decision to end National Service, which had been taken over-hastily in the first place, and without adequate consultation in the second. 
 The General Staff was left with unenviable task of deploying a smaller army than was needed in such a way as to reduce the risks of the Sandys Reformation. 
 From the General Staffs&equo; point of view, there were some bright patches in the otherwise sombre overcast of the last years of the 1950s. 
 The US Congress had passed the Eisenhower Doctrine in March 1957, which expressed the US resolve:  
 to block the Soviet Union's march to the Mediterranean, to the Suez Canal, and to the pipelines and to the underground lake of oil which fuels the homes and factories of Western Europe. 
 The United States was, at last, firmly committed to helping in the maintenance of the stability of the Middle East, though British commitments to the Arab sheikhdoms in the Persian Gulf and the Aden Protectorates were undiminished. 
 Political progress was being made in establishing the Federation of South Arabia to give the Arab tribes around Aden enough political cohesion to resist the ambitions of the Imam of the Yemen and his Egyptian backers. 
 The struggle for Cyprus had been eased by British acceptance of the Sovereign Base concept, though the Zurich Agreement between Greece and Turkey, which enabled Britain to grant Cyprus its independence, was not signed until February 1959. 
 And in Malaya the last of the Communist terrorist gangs were being driven to their destruction in the jungles of north Malaya and south Johore by British military pressure and the financially inspired defections of many of their leaders. 
 But these bright spots were dimmed by the assassination of the Western-orientated Hashemite royal family in Baghdad on 14th July 1958 during the Nasser-inspired coup, which ended Britain's treaty relations with Iraq and led to the RAF's withdrawal from the Habbaniyah and Shu'aiba air bases that lay on the air-reinforcement route to the Far East. 
 In developing its plans for the redeployment of the Army, the General Staff were faced with three major difficulties: lack of genuine air mobility; loss of overflying rights over Arab countries and restricted overflying of the Indian subcontinent due to India's &bquo;non-aligned&equo; stance and Pakistan's natural sympathy for Moslem Arab Nationalism; and the justifiable reluctance in Whitehall to build up new overseas bases. 
 The three were closely linked and led to two important conclusions: part of the Strategic Reserve would have to be positioned East of Suez; and there would have to be some stocking of heavy equipment and supplies, and the establishment of essential repair facilities, on the far side of the Arab air/sea barrier. 
 There was also general agreement that logistic stocks and infrastructure on the far side of the barrier should be kept to a minimum &mdash; a principle that was easier to propound than fulfil. 
 On the nearside of the barrier, it was agreed that the existing facilities at Gibraltar, Malta and Cyprus would be adequate for the of British commitments on the southern flank of NATO and to the Baghdad Pact. 
 The problem was where to position reserves East of Suez. 
 The views of the Foreign, Commonwealth Relations, and Colonial Offices were sought on the security of tenure that British forces were likely to enjoy in territories East of Suez; but in the late 1950s there was no consensus on the probable speed with which Britain's dependent territories would advance to independence. 
 The need to ensure that the new all-regular Army lived in conditions that would not deter recruiting became more pressing than consideration of the risks of capital expenditure on accommodation in areas  where reasonable security of tenure was not assured. 
 As the 1960s went by, cynics began to observe that barrack building in an overseas territory was a sure sign that it would soon be granted its independence! 
 Singapore was the obvious place for the main base East of Suez. 
 It had all the facilities needed by the three Services and there were as yet few worries about security of tenure. 
 Moreover, the Commonwealth Strategic Reserve Brigade of British, Australian and New Zealand troops was already stationed at Malacca in support of SEATO, and the 17th Gurkha Division was responsible for security in Hong Kong, Malaya, North Borneo and Singapore. 
 The Gurkhas were a useful bonus because they were not included in the Army manpower ceiling of 165,000 men. 
 Singapore, however, had one military drawback: it was a long way from the Arabian Peninsula and the Persian Gulf. 
 Aden was the right place for forward operating facilities, but its scorching barren rocks and unhealthy climate made it an unattractive place in which to station Army and RAF units of the Strategic Reserve. 
 The General Staff; therefore, pressed for troops to be stationed in Kenya where the climate was more suitable and, in the wake of the Mau Mau campaign, where troops were needed anyway to reassure the White settlers. 
 Such limited logistic installations as were needed west of Singapore were to be built up at Aden, but as few troops as possible would be stationed there. 
 The Quartermaster General's staff were instructed not to allow Aden to become another expensive base and hostage to fortune. 
 Sandys accepted the General Staff view after his visit to Kenya, during which   he came under pressure from the settlers to give confidence by building permanent barracks for the Strategic Reserve units likely to be stationed there. 
 Contracts were let in 1958 for both barrack building and the modernization of the RAF stations at Eastley and Embakasi. 
 The Governor of Kenya, Sir Evelyn Baring, was able to reassure the settlers by saying that &bquo;Kenya can't go independent because it is a fortress colony.' 
 The establishment of a secure air-reinforcement route was a problem that had to be solved by the Air Staff in conjunction with the Foreign Office. 
 Prior to the Iraq coup in mid-1958 the route had skirted hostile Arab air-space to the north by overflying Turkey and Iraq to reach the Persian Gulf and Indian Ocean. 
 Pakistan and India could be avoided, if need be, by using Colombo, but, after the Suez crisis, the Government of Ceylon (now Sri Lanka) had demanded the closure of British bases on the island. 
 They had been handed over amicably in November 1957, as work had already been started on building a staging airfield on the Indian Ocean island of Gan, just south of Ceylon. 
 When Gan was complete, the Britannias, which were just coming into service with the RAF, would be able to reach Singapore without overflying India. 
 With the loss of the Iraqi airfields, the route was shifted further north over Iran, making the principal stops Ankara, Tehran, Bahrein, Gan, Singapore. 
 An alternative southerly route was established from Malta to Kano in Nigeria, and thence across Central Africa south of the unstable Congo to Nairobi in Kenya. 
 Sandys would have liked to have unified the policy direction and command of the three Services as part of his Reformation. 
 He was supported in this view by Mountbatten, who, with his experience as Supreme Commander South-East Asia and Viceroy of India, believed that such a course was desirable for efficiency's sake and was practicable. 
 Macmillan, however, saw that amalgamation of the Service Ministries and the Ministry of Supply concurrently with sweeping changes in Defence policy would be more than the Defence establishment could take. 
 He believed, quite rightly, that there should be evolution and not revolution to achieve Service unification. 
 It took a lifetime of service to master warfare in one element: breeding officers who could handle operations in all three would take time. 
 Nevertheless, Macmillan had no objection to experimental steps being taken in that direction. 
 I he opportunity for doing so arose in the Middle East. 
 After the evacuation of the Canal Zone in 1956, GHQ Middle East had been re-established in Cyprus. 
 By 1957, it had become clear that it was easier to direct affairs on the far side of the Arab sea/air barrier from London rather than from Cyprus, which had little or no contact with Aden and Kenya. 
 In July 1957, Sandys announced that the headquarters in Cyprus would become GHQ Near East. 
 Its responsibilities East of Suez would be taken over by a new tri-Service headquarters established at Aden under an air vice-marshal with the title of HQ British Forces, Middle East. 
 With that decision came the near certainty, strenuously denied at the time, that Aden would grow into a fully fledged  military base. 
 Sandys would have liked to have established a similarly unified headquarters at Singapore, but determined Naval opposition thwarted him. 
 Turning the dogmas of the Sandys Reformation into practicable military policies had not been easy when faced with the real world beyond the confines of Whitehall and Westminster. 
 Before 1957 was out, world events were sowing the seeds of a conventional forces counter-reformation. 
 At the end of July, a rebellion against the rule of the Sultan of Muscat and Oman broke out. 
 The Sultan, who had treaty relations with Britain, asked for help. 
 Aden was at that time an RAF command, in which the operational policy of air control had been successfully applied for some years. 
 Political officers in the Aden Protectorates had been supported by lightly armed local levies, led by RAF officers. 
 Whenever there was trouble beyond their capacity to snuff out, they could call for air support from Khormaksa, the RAF base at Aden. 
 In the past, this had sufficed to keep the peace between the rival warring tribes. 
 In 1957 air control failed in the Oman. 
 There was a hard core of Egyptian-trained Arab Nationalists, loyal to President Nasser, amongst the dissident tribesmen. 
 They were not deterred by air action. 
 Despite a statement by Selwyn Lloyd, the Foreign Secretary, in the House of Commons on 23rd July that there was &bquo;no question of large-scale operations by British troops on the ground&equo;, Army units had to be flown up to the Oman from Kenya to support the Sultan's armed forces in crushing the rebellion. 
 A combination of ground and air action broke the back of the rebellion. 
 The Sultan's writ was re-established throughout the Oman, except in the mountain fastnesses of the Djebel Akhdar, which were eventually cleared by the SAS in 1959, while on their way back from Malaya for probable disbandment under the Sandys cuts! 
 This minor affair underlined the Army's contention that nuclear weapons and air power were no substitute for troops on the ground in the type of fighting in which Britain was likely to be involved as long as she remained a colonial power. 
 Selwyn Lloyd pointed out in the House of Commons, during a debate on the operations in the Oman, that Britain had to honour two types of obligation. 
 He said: 
 the difference between a formal obligation and the obligations of a longstanding relationship of friendship is not readily apparent to the local rulers and people. 
 If we were to fail in one area it would begin to be assumed elsewhere that perhaps the anti-British propaganda of our enemies had some basis to it, and that the Government were no longer willing or able to help their friends. 
 World power, like stock markets, depends largely on confidence. 
 Most of Britain's dependent peoples saw the presence of British troops close by, and not far away in the United Kingdom, as the assurance they needed of continuing British protection. 
 A much more serious crisis of a similar nature arose immediately after the Iraqi coup of July 1957 when the Hashemite dynasty was overthrown, and the  Eisenhower Doctrine for the Middle East was put to its first test. 
 The governments of Christian-dominated Lebanon and the Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan feared that Nasser-inspired coups were about to be sprung in Beirut and Amman. 
 The Lebanese Government appealed to the United States, and King Hussein of Jordan invoked his long-standing friendship with Britain to ask for her help. 
 US Marines from the American Sixth Fleet landed at Beirut on 16th July; and next day the British 16th Parachute Brigade was flown into Amman, but not without difficulties that highlighted two weaknesses in the air mobility assumptions of the Sandys doctrine. 
 First of all, there was an unfortunate delay in obtaining diplomatic clearance to overfly Israel. 
 Although on this occasion the Israeli objections were quickly overcome, this might not always be possible in future emergency operations. 
 And secondly, due to shortage of heavy-lift transport aircraft in the RAF, the US Air Force had to be asked to provide those needed to fly in the heavier military equipments and supplies into Amman until an overland supply route could be established. 
 The carrier Bulwark  had to be sailed hastily north from Mombasa with an infantry battalion embarked to establish a forward base at Aqaba on the Red Sea, through which supplies could be despatched to Amman by road. 
 The case for the Navy's amphibious capability was being made by events. 
 The Iraqi coup seemed to confirm all the Foreign Office's worst fears about Nasser becoming the Hitler of the Middle East. 
 The likelihood of Britain having to meet her obligations in the Persian Gulf and the Arabian Peninsula increased in step with the raucousness of Radio Cairo's &bquo;The Voice of the Arabs&equo;, adjuring all true followers of Islam to oust every vestige of European colonialism from their lands. 
 In the Far East, where Britain had been so successful in defeating Communist terrorism, there was also growing instability. 
 The flimsy Geneva settlement, engineered by Eden in 1954 to enable the French to withdraw from Indo-China, was breaking down as Ho Chi Minh had begun his attempt to take over the South with backing of Communist China. 
 And in Hong Kong Communist subversion was rife, involving British troops in border incidents and in quelling vicious internal rioting that over-stretched the colony's police. 
 The Sandys reductions in Army manpower looked uncomfortably premature. 
 Fortunately, 17th Gurkha Division was still available to underpin the British position in the Far East, which depended more upon trained and acclimatized infantry than on nuclear weapons. 
 Back at home the first positive political opposition to the philosophy of nuclear deterrence, upon which the Sandys Reformation depended, began to crystallize with the formation of the Campaign for Nuclear Disarmament. 
 &bquo;Rather Red than Dead&equo; became its slogan, and protest marches from Aldermaston Atomic Weapons Research Establishment to Westminster became a way of life for many church-goers, left-wing intellectuals, pacifists and liberal moralists. 
 The leaders of the Labour Party only just managed to hold the party to a (common-sense) multilateralist line on disarmament against  increasingly emotional demands that unilateralism, already espoused by the Liberal Party, should become Labour Party policy as well. 
 Morality and pacifist emotion were the driving forces behind much of the uninformed criticism of the Sandys Reformation. 
 There was also a growing body of opinion in Westminster and Whitehall amongst many of those who had initially welcomed Sandys&equo; 1957 Defence White Paper, that his doctrine was not as sensible as they had first thought. 
 The premise of Britain's influence over American policy and her standing as a great power, was being questioned more widely, and with some justification. 
 At the time of the Korean War, when Attlee helped to persuade Truman to drop any idea of using the atomic bomb against the Chinese mainland, Britain had not exploded her first nuclear weapon. 
 Then, at Suez, Britain's possession of the Bomb had not helped her one iota in swaying American Middle East policy. 
 In the opinion of Sandys&equo; opponents, his and Macmillan's emphasis on the independence  of Britain's nuclear deterrent was creating gross misconceptions of her real power and influence in the world. 
 The facts, in their view, should be squarely faced: defence was no longer practicable on a national basis; technologically Britain was becoming ever more dependent upon US Research and Development; and Macmillan's concept of Anglo-American interdependence  was a myth. 
 The amendment to the MacMahon Act might have saved Britain money and time in establishing her nuclear deterrent, but, as each year passed, the deterrent would become less and less independent as Britain's own research establishments were bypassed, and more and more of its sub-equipments and components came from America. 
 Strategically, the only conceivable reasons for using British nuclear weapons would flow from the collapse of NATO. 
 In that case, the electorate might well prefer to be Red and live to fight another day rather than be consigned to a nuclear crematorium. 
 Duplicating the American nuclear deterrent was a waste of national resources, which Britain could ill afford in the straitened circumstances of her post-imperial era. 
 The strength of the critics&equo; arguments was neutralized to some extent by Macmillan's determination to seek both nuclear and conventional disarmament with the twin-track approach, which has remained valid to this day: maintaining the potency of the deterrent while, at the same time, seeking genuine arms limitation, if not disarmament. 
 The general election of 1959 was fought, as usual, on domestic policies. 
 The Conservative Party manifesto set out the issues as: 
 Do you want to go ahead on the lines which have brought prosperity at home? 
 Do you want your present leaders to represent you abroad? 
 Hugh Gaitskell countered by promising that the Labour Party would make improvements in the Welfare State and increase pensions without increasing taxation. 
 Labour's promises were judged by the electorate to be impracticable, and so the Conservatives were returned with a just over one hundred-seat  majority. 
 Macmillan was thus able to pursue his own policies during his second term in office rather than having to concentrate on damage limitation forced upon him by Anthony Eden's Suez disaster. 
 Across the Channel great changes were taking place in Western Europe. 
 Apart from providing the military leadership in the formation of NATO, Britain had felt unable to join the march to a united Western Europe because of her family connections with the Commonwealth and her special relationship with the United States. 
 The Treaty of Rome had been signed without her in March 1957; the EEC had come into being in January 1958; and de Gaulle had been recalled to power in France to solve the Algerian crisis in June that year. 
 Europe would begin to play a more significant part in British affairs in the future. 
 Being a European offshore island was beginning to make a greater impact upon British affairs.  
 The Watkinson Conventional Counter-reformation: 1960&ndash;64 
 The primary purpose of our defence policy is, therefore, that it should protect us, our allies, and our friends against the whole spectrum of possible aggression and military threats, from small local action which might be the beginning of larger and more dangerous adventures through &bquo;nuclear blackmail&equo; to nuclear war. 
 Harold Watkinson's 1961 Defence White Paper. 
 During his first term in office Macmillan had achieved the three objectives that he had set himself when he took over from Eden in 1957. 
 By the end of 1959, the economy had improved so much that his oft quoted quip &bquo;You've never had it so good&equo; had a ring of truth about it. 
 Anglo-American relations had been fully restored. 
 And the one-hundred-seat Tory majority in the new House of Commons showed that he had rebuilt the fortunes of the Conservative Party. 
 But in terms of Defence and Overseas policy there had been a price to pay for these successes. 
 Ending National Service, which helped to right the economy, was also placing a limit on Britain's retention of imperial power. 
 Soon she would not have the troops with which to maintain her responsible policy of granting independence only when a colony was politically, economically, and militarily ready to stand on its own feet. 
 The growing Nationalist pressures, fanned by the United Nations&equo; de-colonization debates, could not be resisted without a return to conscription. 
 And the re-establishment of the Anglo-American special relationship, though welcome, had its disadvantages. 
 The short-cuts provided in weapon development were to lead to a paring of independence, stunting of British research and development capacity, and a strengthening of the anchor cables holding Britain in her position as an offshore island of the United States at a time when closer relations with Europe were becoming more compelling. 
 In narrower military terms, the Sandys&equo; Reformation, without which it would not have been possible to contemplate ending National Service, was already seen in Whitehall as premature, if not wholly mistaken. 
 In retrospect, it is possible to illustrate the fallacies of the Sandys doctrine, using a notional prism to analyse the spectrum of warfare in the nuclear era. 
 The spectrum has six bands, stretching from nuclear war at one end, through conventional war, limited war, guerrilla war, and terrorism, across to internal security or police action at the other end. 
 The intensity of warfare and the weight of weapons used declines across the spectrum; all the bands are blurred at the edges where they overlap; and each has a number of gradations within it.   
 The deterrent effectiveness of military force displayed so far in the nuclear era is represented by Curve A in figure 6 . 
 this curve is at its highest, i.e. most effective, over the nuclear war band, since deterrence has been 100 per cent effective in preventing the use of nuclear weapons. 
 It drops away only slightly over conventional war because fear of escalation into nuclear conflict is an effective, though not total, deterrent in this band of the spectrum, as the Iraq/ Iran war has shown. 
 It then falls away steeply across the limited war band to its low point between the guerrilla war and terrorism bands, where the frequency of such wars in the post-war period has demonstrated the greatest weakness in military deterrence &mdash; &bquo;Davids&equo; have found it all too easy to defy &bquo;Goliaths&equo; in these bands as the French and American defeats in Vietnam have shown so vividly. 
 Deterrence is almost as low over the internal security band, as the rising rate of violent crime in our so-called civilized societies and the current Israeli difficulties with the Palestinians demonstrate. 
 These conclusions are reinforced by Curve B, which represents the frequency and length of conflicts that have occurred since the Second World War. 
 It is at zero in the nuclear war band and rises steeply to its peak over the guerrilla war and terrorist bands. 
 Thus the peaks and troughs of the two curves match, illustrating the obvious conclusion that military policy-makers should be  seeking ways of increasing the deterrent capabilities of their armed forces in the lower-intensity bands at the right-hand half of the spectrum rather than in the higher-intensity bands at the left-hand end. 
 The need is to push up Curve A over the guerrilla and terrorist bands, as shown by the arrow, while maintaining the current effectiveness of the nuclear deterrent, as represented by the pillar. 
 Sandys&equo; Reformation did exactly the opposite: his policies reinforced British military capabilities for nuclear war, while cutting the ships, aircraft and above all infantry needed for the type of fighting in which military forces have been constantly engaged in the latter half of the twentieth century. 
 He went further. 
 While few Whitehall officials disputed the need for nuclear weapons to damp out the possibility of a recurrence of the conventional-weapon slaughter of the two World Wars, Sandys had breached a fundamental principle of British military policy &mdash; the maintenance of balanced military forces able to react to the unforeseen. 
 The unexpected usually occurs in military affairs for the simple reason that what can be foreseen can be deterred and so tends not to happen. 
 The overemphasis on nuclear weapons and missiles at the expense of conventional forces was seen by many observers, both military and civilian, to have gone too far, too fast, and too soon; but the political prize of ending National Service had been seized and that was all that mattered to the Macmillan Government in 1957. 
 The divergence of view between Sandys and the military establishment was illustrated by the Government's over-reaction to a talk given to the Royal United Services Institute by General Sir John Cowley, the Controller of Munitions in the Ministry of Supply, in November 1959. 
 Sir John suggested that if there was a clash in the allocation of resources between a credible level of nuclear deterrence and the necessary level of conventional forces, he, for one, would support giving priority to the latter. 
 He added four lines to Lewis Carroll's verse about the old man on the gate: 
 I also have a plan to spend a thousand million pounds, 
 To buy some guided missiles and to hide them in the ground, 
 And then to clearly paint on each &bquo;these things must not be used&equo;. 
 No wonder that our citizens are getting so confused. 
 And he ended his talk by saying: 
 I believe that in 100 years people will look back on the middle of the twentieth century as a nightmare period when mankind suddenly discovered the means to destroy itself, and was seriously considering using this as a preferable alternative to reconciling differing political views. 
 Macmillan was not unaware of the stresses and strains that Sandys' Reformation had caused in Whitehall; nor of the lack of confidence that had grown up between Sandys and his principal advisers, the Chiefs of Staff. 
 In his post-election Cabinet reshuffle Sandys was sent back to the Ministry of Supply  to use his undoubted energies to create the much needed Ministry of Aviation. 
 He was replaced by the able, but less flamboyant, Harold Watkinson, who was a sound administrator and ideally suited to the task of restoring Britain's military balance. 
 In the same reshuffle Alan Lennox-Boyd was replaced as Colonial Secretary by Iain MacLeod, a far-sighted minister with confidence in his own convictions. 
 Lennox-Boyd had been in the post for five years and had asked to retire for family business reasons. 
 During his time as Colonial Secretary he had established the measured steps towards independence for all Britain's dependent peoples, the speed of which depended on the current state of development in each territory. 
 His programme, however, rested upon the continuing power of the British Government to dictate the rate of advance. 
 Iain MacLeod appreciated that Britain, in the post-Suez era, had neither the political will nor the military resources to slow the tide of colonial emanicipation; and so he was prepared, with Macmillan's whole-hearted support, to accelerate the process, despite opposition from the right wing of the Conservative Party. 
 Defence policy in Macmillan's second term of office was dominated by four streams of events: an acceleration in the rate of change in weapon technology; the &bquo;Winds of Change&equo; in Africa; Britain's first attempt to join the EEC; and the Mountbatten reorganization of the three Service ministries into a unified Ministry of Defence. 
 Each contributed in different ways to the Watkinson counter-reformation that began soon after he took over as Minister of Defence in October 1959. 
 The first task that Watkinson set himself was to re-establish a better working relationship between himself and the Chiefs of Staff. 
 This was not difficult because his own ideas on the way forward matched those of his Chief of Defence Staff, Lord Mountbatten, and his Chief Scientific Adviser, Sir Solly Zuckerman, both of whom had recently taken over their posts. 
 The three Service Chiefs welcomed his preference for evolution rather than continuing and abrasive revolution, but the doubts and suspicions that they had about Mountbatten's impartiality made it difficult for him to rebuild complete confidence between his staff at the Ministry of Defence and the Service ministries. 
 Nevertheless, there was general agreement on all sides that Sandys had overstepped the line between sensible and imprudent change, and that it was time to shift the emphasis away from the nuclear end of the spectrum of War and back to a more balanced, central position. 
 Watkinson records in his memoirs: 
 I was more interested in the need to achieve a reorganisation of Britain's conventional forces under firm businesslike central direction, coupled with a policy which would speed up their reaction time and create a mobile military force with a poised capacity to operate from land or sea bases. 
 This seemed to me a more important priority in 1959 than  overmuch argument about nuclear philosophical heresies of one kind or another. 
 But neither he nor his advisers were entirely free agents: events forced the nuclear band of the spectrum to his attention first. 
 One of the main planks of Sandys&equo; doctrine had been the replacement of the V-bombers by the Blue Streak ballistic missile. 
 By the autumn of 1959, the Chiefs of Staff had begun to doubt its viability as an effective deterrent. 
 It was liquid-fuelled with a relatively slow reaction time (10 to 15 minutes); and it was to be launched, like the Thors, from unprotected platforms; but since the original decision had been taken by Sandys to develop Blue Streak, the range and accuracy of Russian missiles had greatly improved. 
 By early 1960 it was clear that Blue Streak would be much too vulnerable to a pre-emptive First Strike by Soviet missiles to maintain the credibility of the British nuclear deterrent. 
 Continuing deterrent credibility would, in future, depend upon Britain's known ability to retaliate with an invulnerable Second Strike weapon. 
 Blue Streak was unlikely to measure up to this requirement. 
 Furthermore, installing any static system in the overcrowded British Isles was neither militarily nor politically sensible. 
 Unlike the United States, Britain had no large sparsely-populated desert areas in which to deploy strategic missiles. 
 Studies were put in hand to see whether it would be practicable to deploy Blue Streak in hardened underground silos in the Welsh mountains or the Scottish highlands, but the cost was found to be so great that it would have beggared the Defence Vote, making the restoration of more efficient conventional forces impossible. 
 Macmillan and Sandys, as Minister of Aviation, fought hard to prevent cancellation, but Watkinson and the Chiefs of Staff had an unbeatable operational case. 
 In February 1960, the Cabinet agreed to write off the &pound;60 million already spent so far on Blue Streak, and to seek an alternative delivery system for British nuclear warheads. 
 No public announcement was to be made until a replacement had been decided upon. 
 Admiral Mountbatten and Professor Zuckerman had visited the United States in the autumn of 1959 and had been shown the massive underground silos of the Titan intercontinental ballistic missiles, and had concluded, quite rightly, that Britain had neither the resources nor the need to enter the land-based ICBM league. 
 Invulnerability for her nuclear delivery systems must be sought in airborne or submarine mobility. 
 There were three possible air-launched solutions: the US Air Force's Skybolt, which could be modified to fit the V-bombers; a simpler British &bquo;ram jet&equo;, called Pandora, suitable for the TSR 2, whose development was at such an early stage that costs could only be guessed; and further development of the existing Blue Steel stand-off bomb on which work had been stopped after the Sandys Defence Review. 
 The submarine solutions were more limited. 
 The US Navy's Polaris missiles could either be bought with American submarines, or fitted into British-built hulls.  
 The debate on these options in Whitehall was one-sided, because the RAF wanted to maintain its hold on the deterrent and the Navy was still uncertain about what effect a take-over bid would have on the future size and shape of the Fleet. 
 Of the air-delivered systems, Skybolt was technically the most advanced and was seen by the RAF as the best weapon for extending the life of the V Force. 
 It had three advantages over the submarine system: British launching aircraft already existed whereas the submarines did not; the American content of the total system could be reduced by manufacture under licence in the United Kingdom; and the Americans were likely to tie the purchase of Polaris to the mixed-manned Multilateral Nuclear Force that Eisenhower was keen to foist upon NATO. 
 But there were also two major objections to Skybolt: it was the most expensive of the air mobile options; and the Americans pointed out that the technological risks were so high that the project might well fail. 
 They agreed, however, that the British could collaborate in the Skybolt development and buy it on very favourable terms. 
 Skybolt just won the debate in the face of a growing body of opinion that favoured fitting Polaris into British-built nuclear submarines. 
 This option might have to be taken up in the future when the V-bombers reached the end of their operational lives, unless the TSR 2 turned out to be as effective as the RAF hoped, and was able to extend the life of the airborne nuclear deterrent indefinitely. 
 Macmillan flew to Washington in March, primarily to discuss the proposed Nuclear Test Ban Treaty. 
 He came back with an exchange of letters, in which Eisenhower had agreed that Britain could buy Skybolt; and, in return, Macmillan had accepted an American request for base facilities for US nuclear submarines at Holy Loch on the west coast of Scotland. 
 No formal agreement was made on the Polaris alternative, because Eisenhower hoped to persuade NATO to accept the system as part of his Multilateral force idea. 
 Macmillan, however, was confident that the Americans would provide Polaris, at a price, if the British needed it later were the Skybolt project to fail. 
 On 13th April, Macmillan announced in the House of Commons the demise of Blue Streak and its replacement by Skybolt. 
 The decision caused consternation on both sides of the House, because it confirmed what many people feared: that Britain was slipping too far behind the superpowers; and was, indeed, losing a measure of her sovereignty. 
 The cancellation of Blue Streak threw the &bquo;independence&equo; of the British nuclear deterrent into doubt. 
 The Tory back-benchers could take some comfort from the argument that it was operational control rather than manufacture of the weapons that mattered. 
 A nuclear war could only last a matter of days and would be fought with the weapons that were in the hands of the military at the time; there would be no question of re-supply, so British operational independence would not be jeopardized by buying US missiles. 
 Multilateralists on the Labour benches, who had supported the retention of nuclear weapons on the grounds that they gave Britain an independent foreign  policy, were seriously discomfited by the obvious loss of a measure of that independence through acceptance of an American delivery system. 
 Unilateralists felt that their case had been made for them; and they became more determined than ever to get rid of nuclear weapons altogether. 
 It was no coincidence that the largest CND march from Aldermaston to Trafalgar Square took place that Easter. 
 At the September Trades Union Congress, Frank Cousins came out strongly in favour of unilateralism, winning support for a resolution that rejected &bquo;any defence policy based on the threat of the use of strategic nuclear weapons&equo;. 
 At the subsequent Labour Party Conference in October, the TUC resolution was only narrowly defeated after Hugh Gaitskell's famous last ditch speech in which he vowed &bquo;to fight and fight and fight again&hellip;&equo; 
 While the Blue Streak saga was being played out, Macmillan and McLeod had been setting the stage for Britain's final withdrawal from Empire. 
 Macmillan's &bquo;Wind of Change&equo; speech in Cape Town rang bells around the world because it said what needed to be said, and signalled the forthcoming change in Britain's colonial policy. 
 The pace of colonial emancipation would, in future, be governed more by the dependent peoples&equo; view of their readiness for independence than by British administrators&equo; judgement of their fitness to stand on their own feet. 
 British military forces would only be used to ensure the smooth transition of power to properly elected local governments, and to protect the newly independent states from external predators. 
 Greater emphasis would be needed, as Watkinson proposed, on military intervention capability rather than on the existing network of colonial garrisons. 
 It is one of the unhappy paradoxes of the Whitehall market-place that it reacts to the goad of strong, abrasive ministers like Duncan Sandys, whose revolutionary ideas it detests, and yet is slow to implement the more balanced, evolutionary policies of a Harold Watkinson, for which it craves. 
 The Watkinson counter-reformation was slow to develop. 
 Thanks to the forceful leadership of Mountbatten when he was First Sea Lord, the Navy's development of its limited war amphibious capability acquired a momentum of its own. 
 Bulwark  was commissioned in January 1960 and stationed with her Commando embarked at Singapore; Albion  followed as the second Commando Carrier about a year later; construction of six Army-owned Landing Ships Logistic (LSLs) was authorised in August 1960; the Assault Ships Fearless  and Intrepid  were ordered in 1961 and 1962; and design work was started in December 1961 on the next generation of aircraft carriers, the first of which was code-named CVA 01. 
 In stark contrast, the transport aircraft needed for air mobility trickled out: the Britannia inter-theatre aircraft started coming into service in 1959; the Argosy intra-theatre aircraft in 1962; and the Belfast strategic freighter in 1964. 
 The total number of helicopters of all types in RAF service at the beginning of 1961 was only 24, including just three of the larger twin-rotor Belvederes. 
 Nevertheless, RAF attitudes were changing: the disbandment of Fighter  Command and the probable demise of the V Force made pilot seats in transport aircraft more attractive than they used to be. 
 It is events, however, rather than personalities that generate change quickest in Whitehall. 
 Sandys could not have achieved his reformation without Suez. 
 Watkinson was helped with his by the Kuwait crisis of 1961. 
 The military regime in Iraq laid claim to Kuwait on the grounds that it used to be part of the Ottoman province of Basra. 
 Contingency plans were laid in London and Aden to intervene if the ruler of Kuwait invoked Britain's commitment to go to his assistance. 
 The crisis came to a head on 27 June 1961, when the British Embassy in Baghdad reported the movement of Iraqi troops and tanks from the capital to Basra. 
 At the time, there were three British frigates and the Amphibious Squadron in the Persian Gulf. 
 The latter had been redeployed there from Malta in July 1960 in anticipation of just such a crisis. 
 It had half a squadron of tanks embarked and there was another half squadron stockpiled in Kuwait itself. 
 Bulwark , with 42nd Commando on board, happened to be at Karachi doing hot-weather trials, and 45th Commando was at Aden. 
 The aircraft-carrier Centaur  was in the Indian Ocean on passage to the Far East. 
 The 24th Brigade of the Strategic Reserve was in Kenya, and the nearest Parachute units were in Cyprus. 
 The RAF had two squadrons of Hunters and four Shackleton bombers at Aden, and a transport force of twelve Beverleys and six Vallettas split between Aden and Kenya. 
 On 28 June, before any request had been received from the ruler, Centaur  and Bulwark  were sailed for the Gulf; the Amphibious Squadron left Bahrein for Kuwait with instructions to stay out of sight of land; the Hunters and Shackletons were flown north from Aden to Bahrein; a Canberra squadron was sent from Germany to Bahrein as well; and 24th Brigade was alerted in Kenya and preparations were made to fly it to Kuwait in chartered civil aircraft. 
 The request for military assistance came on 30 June. 
 On 1 July, 42nd Commando landed by helicopter from Bulwark;  and the fly-in of troops and aircraft, and the landing of tanks, began under air cover provided by Centaur . 
 By the end of the day, Brigadier Horsfield, the commander of 24th Brigade, had the equivalent of half a brigade with tank and air support with which to reinforce the small Kuwaiti army in defensive positions north of the city on the Mutlah ridge. 
 At the end of the first week, there was a force of five British battalions with tank, artillery, air and naval gun fire support ready to meet any Iraqi invasion. 
 Iraq did not attack. 
 The effectiveness of rapid amphibious and air-transported intervention as a deterrent to predator states had been clearly demonstrated. 
 The operation had not gone without hitches because adequate amphibious shipping and transport aircraft were not yet available. 
 Nevertheless, it provided Harold Watkinson with just the precedent that he needed to swing the pendulum back into the centre of the spectrum of war. 
 In his last Defence White paper, published in February 1962, he was able to say:  
 Our policy of deterring war has been severely tested in the past twelve months&hellip;. 
 So far it has succeeded. 
 We must continue to make it clear to potential aggressors, however, that we should strike back with all the means that we judge appropriate, conventional or nuclear. 
 If we had nothing but nuclear forces, this would not be credible. 
 A balance must be maintained, therefore, between conventional and nuclear strength. 
 Kuwait made a significant impact on opinion in Whitehall. 
 Doubts about the practicability of amphibious and air-transported intervention operations were softened, and projects with an East of Suez flavour became more fashionable. 
 Amongst the projects that benefited immediately were the Vertical Take-Off ground attack fighter, P1127, which eventually became the Harrier, and its supersonic variant the P1154 air defence fighter. 
 The Air Staff, hardly surprisingly, began to laud the TSR 2 as ideal for East of Suez operations, using island bases instead of expensive aircraft carriers like CVA 01. 
 Aden's usefulness was also acknowledged in the 1962 Defence White Paper, which gave it the status of a base. 
 And the naval objections to the establishment of a unified command in the Far East were overcome by the clear example of the success of HQ British Forces, Middle East, during the Kuwait operation. 
 Admiral Sir David Luce was appointed the first tri-Service C-in-C, Far East, in November 1962. 
 The Kuwait intervention, though important to the Defence policy-makers, was of little consequence to the political departments, whose mandarins were immersed during the first half of 1961 in two major debates: how to handle the Anglo-American special relationship after Kennedy had taken over as US President in January; and whether or not to put less emphasis on Anglo-American and Commonwealth links by applying belatedly to join the EEC. 
 Britain's first application was tabled in august, just after the Kuwait crisis, but had little effect on Defence policy at the time, because negotiations were relatively short-lived. 
 In January 1963, de Gaulle vetoed the application on the grounds that Britain's links with the US and the Commonwealth were still too strong for her to become truly European &mdash; which was true! 
 It was also true that the France of de Gaulle was trying to reverse her military defeat in 1940 by winning hegemony in post-war Western Europe by political means; and her partners in the EEC lacked the unity needed to stand up to her. 
 The EEC negotiations were not entirely without impact on British politics. 
 In the sixteen months between Britain's application and its rejection by de Gaulle, a body of opinion was created in Whitehall and amongst the electorate that looked forward to Britain becoming more closely linked to Europe for a variety of reasons; one of which was to reduce America's dominance in the West's military affairs. 
 Although Macmillan was the driving force behind the bid to enter Europe, he had no wish to weaken Britain's links with the States. 
 Other members of his government, however, saw considerable advantages in developing a European nuclear deterrent, based on pooling British and French  nuclear know-how and resources. 
 Throwing mooring ropes out to the Continent to balance Britain's over-strong anchor cables to America made sense to many people. 
 Henceforth, a Defence partnership with Europe became a growing, if theoretical, possibility. 
 This tentative swing towards Europe was spurred by the new Administration in Washington. 
 The personal element in the Anglo-American special relationship, which had been based on war-time partnership, started to crumble with the departure of Eisenhower from the White House, and had to be painstakingly rebuilt with the younger generation of American leaders. 
 Macmillan established a personal relationship almost at once with Kennedy at their first meeting at Key West in March 1961; and Watkinson renewed the agreement on &bquo;interdependence&equo; during his visit to the States in May, during which prospects of future Anglo-American collaborative projects were optimistically discussed. 
 But there could be no disguising the change in American attitudes. 
 The changes stemmed largely from the generation gap. 
 Kennedy was intent upon leading the Western World with an open-handedness that made Britain no more than just one of the Western European states. 
 And Robert McNamara, the new US Secretary of Defence, had even less of a feel for the special relationship than the President. 
 He joined the Kennedy Administration direct from the board of the Ford Motor Company and began sweeping away waste wherever he could find it. 
 In American jargon, he was long on cost-effectiveness and short on political understanding. 
 There was bound to be trouble and it was not long in coming. 
 At the NATO meeting in Athens in the spring of 1962, and more publicly at the University of Michigan at Ann Arbor in June, McNamara spoke of the nuclear forces of powers possessing limited nuclear capability and acting independently as: 
 dangerous, expensive, prone to obsolescence and lacking in credibility as a deterrent. 
 His subsequent disclaimer that he was not referring to the British nuclear deterrent, which was closely integrated in the Strategic Air Command's target planning, but to de Gaulle's Force de Frappe , lacked conviction &mdash; it was too near the truth for British comfort! 
 During 1962 McNamara applied his industrial cost-effectiveness criteria to all US weapons projects. 
 The development of the Minuteman and Polaris missiles was deemed successful; but Skybolt had failed successive tests, and was proving less reliable, less accurate and more costly than its rivals. 
 In November he decided that Skybolt had no place in the US weapon procurement programme and should be scrapped. 
 In doing so, he failed to appreciate the political impact on the British, who had put their faith in Skybolt as a way of maintaining the greatest measure of independence for their nuclear deterrent that was practicable at reasonable cost.  
 British irritation was increased by the suspicion that McNamara was deliberately trying to wean Britain away from her nuclear special relationship with the United States, and from her determination to maintain her own independent nuclear deterrent, which embarrassed American foreign policy towards Europe. 
 De Gaulle was refusing military co-operation within NATO unless the Anglo-American nuclear club was widened into a tri-partite relationship; and Washington feared that the Germans might also start pressing for a finger on the nuclear trigger. 
 The year 1962 had not been a good one for Macmillan: his domestic policies had started to go awry; the application to join the EEC was unpopular; his showing in the opinion polls had slumped to 36 per cent; in July he had sacked one-third of his cabinet, fearing a revolt against his leadership; in October he was seen to play little part in the Cuban missile crisis, in which Kennedy alone took the decisions that could have drawn Britain, whether she liked it or not, into nuclear war between the superpowers; and in December it was becoming clear that de Gaulle was blocking the EEC entry negotiations. 
 It is not surprising that McNamara received a cool reception from Peter Thorneycroft, who had succeeded Harold Watkinson as Minister of Defence in Macmillan's new cabinet, when he arrived in London on 11 December to explain the reasoning behind the decision to cancel Skybolt. 
 When the news of the Skybolt cancellation became public, a wave of anti-Americanism swept Westminster and Whitehall. 
 With anti-Europeanism also rampant over French attitudes to Britain's EEC application, Little Englanderism &mdash; or British isolationism &mdash; became fashionable in all walks of life. 
 Dean Acheson, US Secretary of State, did not help matters by including, in a wide-ranging speech on US foreign policy at West Point, the cutting words: 
 Great Britain has lost an empire and has not yet found a role. 
 The attempt to play a separate role &mdash; that is, a role apart from Europe, a role based on a &bquo;Special Relationship&equo; with the United States, a role based on being head of a &bquo;Commonwealth&equo; which has no political structure, or unity, or strength, and enjoys a fragile and precarious reality by means of the sterling area and preferences in the British market &mdash; this role is about played out. 
 December 1962 was a busy month for Macmillan. 
 He was due to meet de Gaulle on the 15th at Rambouillet in an attempt to soften the General's opposition to Britain's entry into the EEC; and then to fly to Nassau on the 18th to meet President Kennedy for wide-ranging talks, including East-West relations, the backwash of the Cuban missile crisis, improvement of India's defences against China, the Congo Civil War, and, most important of all, the proposed Nuclear Test Ban Treaty. 
 Macmillan made little progress at Rambouillet. 
 Before he left for Nassau the Cabinet agreed that he should reject offers made by McNamara for Britain to continue the Skybolt development on a fifty-fifty cost-sharing basis with no guarantee that the US would buy the  weapon in the end; or to buy the lower-performance US Hound Dog missile for her V Force. 
 Instead he should press Kennedy to honour Eisenhower's unwritten pledge to provide Polaris as an alternative to Skybolt. 
 The Nassau meeting has been described as &bquo;one of the great confrontations in the history of Anglo-American relations.' 
 The agenda for the meeting was virtually swept aside by the Skybolt issue. 
 Macmillan made a long and politically emotional appeal for Skybolt's replacement by Polaris. 
 Kennedy's advisers opposed this solution because it would again single out Britain amongst the European states for special treatment; it would fuel de Gaulle's dislike for NATO; and it would make Britain's entry into Europe, which was part of the State Department's policy, even less likely. 
 Allowing Britain to buy Polaris also ran counter to Eisenhower's plan that was still being worked up in Washington for the creation of a mixed-manned European multilateral nuclear force. 
 The American policy-makers were labouring under the delusion that such a force would be attractive to the Europeans. 
 Britain, for one, was not prepared to join such a militarily unsound project. 
 But she was quite ready to assign her nuclear units to a NATO Multinational Force; indeed, she was, in effect, already doing so through the joint targeting of her V-bombers with the US Strategic Air Command, subject to her right to use them for her own purposes if vital national interests were at stake. 
 Macmillan played on Kennedy's political instincts by suggesting that a failure to honour Eisenhower's Polaris pledge could sink the Macmillan Government and lead to the election of an anti-American alternative, either Conservative or Labour &mdash; anti-Americanism not being confined to one party. 
 If there must be a parting, Britain would continue to honour her side of the Anglo-American nuclear understandings: Holy Loch and the Fylingdales radar station would still be available to the United States; RAF bases would continue to house US bombers; and Britain would carry on accepting the risks that all this entailed. 
 She would not ask for any further exchange of nuclear information, but she must be released from her obligation not to use the knowledge she already possessed in seeking collaboration with other partners. 
 Though some of the President's advisers wished to use the crisis to drive Britain out of the nuclear deterrent business altogether, Kennedy had no intention of doing so, and insisted on a formula being found that would enable Britain to buy Polaris without jeopardizing the US policy of working towards a NATO Multilateral or Multinational nuclear force. 
 The agreement finally reached was over-hastily drafted, and contained many inconsistencies and much imprecision. 
 The upshot, however, was that the British could buy the latest mark of Polaris missile without warheads, which they would provide themselves, and could fit them into five British-built nuclear submarine hulls. 
 They would, in return, assign not only their Polaris submarines, but also their V-bombers and tactical nuclear delivery systems to NATO, subject to the  usual overriding proviso: &bquo;except where Her Majesty's Government may decide that the supreme national interests are at stake. 
 It was possible to argue that, because the Polaris missile was supplied by the United States, the British Nuclear Deterrent was no longer independent. 
 But the counter-argument still held good: that it was the operational control and not the manufacture of a weapon system that made it independent. 
 Moreover, Macmillan managed to ensure that the Americans did not impose a dual key system as they had done with the RAF-manned Thors. 
 He had thus had achieved the greatest practicable measure of independence without squandering resources on strategic missile development. 
 Naval fears of the financial burden of taking over the Nuclear Deterrent and its effect on the size and shape of the Fleet were allayed by the unification of the 
 Ministry of Defence and the centralization of the Defence votes, which were being studied at the same time as the Skybolt/Polaris crisis was coming to a head. 
 After appointing Thorneycroft as Secretary of State for Defence in July 1962, Macmillan decided that the time was ripe to take a further step in the gradual process of integrating the management of the Services. 
 The tri-Service commands in the Middle and Far East were working well, and so he tasked Thorneycroft to apply the same principles to the Service ministries in Whitehall. 
 Mountbatten, as Chief of Defence Staff, welcomed the idea, if he did not actually sow it in the Prime Minister's mind in the first place. 
 He produced a paper of his own straight away, which found favour with his political masters but was opposed by his fellow Chiefs of Staff, mainly because they distrusted his motives. 
 Macmillan astutely side-stepped the opposition by appointing General &bquo;Pug&equo; Ismay, Churchill's wartime Chief Staff Officer, and General Ian Jacob, who had been one of his deputies and then Director-General of the BBC, to use their acknowledged experience of the workings of Whitehall to produce a blueprint of the most practicable way of bringing the three Service ministries together into a single Ministry of Defence. 
 The Ismay Jacob report led to the 1963 reorganization of Defence, which abolished the Admiralty, War Office, Air Ministry, and Ministry of Supply. 
 In their places came a unified Ministry under the Secretary of State for Defence, who was given two Ministers of State with functional responsibilities to assist him. 
 All Operational, Intelligence and Weapon Development policy was made the responsibility of the Central Staff, which encompassed but did not unify the Naval, General, and Air Staffs. 
 The administration of the Services was to be carried out by three co-located but separate Service Departments, each under a junior minister. 
 Financial control was centralized under one accounting officer, the Permanent Under-Secretary for Defence, with subordinate Deputy Under-Secretaries to oversee the individual Service votes, which were still retained for administrative convenience, but could be adjusted to conform to Defence, as opposed to single Service, priorities. 
 The historic Board of Admiralty, Army Council, and Air Council were downgraded to become the Admiralty, Army,  and Air Boards. 
 And the whole of the new organization was co-located in the former Air Ministry/Board of Trade building on the south side of Whitehall, where it is today. 
 Many people felt that the Thorneycroft/Mountbatten reorganization did not go far enough, and that Service Departments should have been abolished and a completely functional organization adopted. 
 This would have been unwise. 
 The Services needed time to grow closer together: it was just not possible to find enough officers with the experience in tri-Service co-ordination to go further in 1963. 
 Co-location of staffs would help to break down barriers between the Services, and the development of tri-Service staffs at lower levels would also build up the necessary expertise. 
 Time and experience were needed to establish new working practices. 
 The changes imposed were just about as much as the Services could take at that time without loss of morale and fighting efficiency. 
 The world outside Whitehall had not been standing still since Thorneycroft took over. 
 The last National Serviceman left the Army in May 1963. 
 By then, warnings were already blowing in the post-imperial winds of change that the all-regular Army might soon be overstretched trying to maintain stability in the final stages of Britain's withdrawal from Empire. 
 The Central African Federation, embracing the Rhodesias and Nyasaland, had broken up under African nationalist pressures at the end of 1960; the West Indies Federation had gone much the same way during 1961; and South Africa had become a republic and left the Commonwealth that year. 
 Iain Macleod's acceleration of the withdrawal timetables was being implemented: the independence of Tanganyika was brought forward from 1970 to December 1961; Uganda's from 1973 to October 1962; Kenya's from 1975 to December 1963. 
 Apart from South Africa, none of the new states were able to look after themselves militarily. 
 Although nationalist ambitions in Africa had been largely assuaged by these demonstrations of British good faith, this was not true of Arab Nationalism in the Middle East, or of Chinese Communism in the Far East. 
 A pro-Nasserite revolution occurred in the Yemen in September 1962, which was to lead to Egyptian-backed rebellions in the Aden Protectorates and later in Aden itself. 
 In the Far East, the Azahari revolt broke out in Brunei in December 1962; and, although it was crushed relatively easily by British and Gurkha troops stationed in Malaya, it led on to the Indonesian &bquo;Confrontation&equo;, which began in a small way in April 1963. 
 Further minor straws in the wind were Archbishop Makarios&equo; request for British help in Cyprus in December 1963, which drew in most of the Strategic Reserve's 3rd Division before a hand-over to the United Nations could be negotiated; and the quelling of the military mutinies in newly independent Tanzania, Kenya and Uganda in January 1964, at their governments&equo; request, by Commandos brought on the aircraft-carrier Centaur  from Aden and by units of the Strategic Reserve in Kenya. 
 A much more significant straw, however, was the direct military involvement in August 1964 of United States military forces in Vietnam, which led to Australian and New Zealand military  contingents being provided and might have attracted British troops as well, if they had not already been committed in Borneo and the Aden Protectorates. 
 The overstretch of the regular army did not become a major political issue during the last of years of the Conservative Government (then under Douglas Home, who succeeded Macmillan in October 1963): it was a legacy left to Labour when they came to power in October 1964. 
 Harold Watkinson had not survived as Secretary of State for Defence long enough to see his counter-reformation completed, but he did have the satisfaction of knowing that, had it not been for his efforts to swing the pendulum of British Defence policy back into the centre of the spectrum of war, Britain's disengagement from empire would not have been so successful. 
 He had provided the foundations for the strategic and tactical mobility that enabled the small regular Army to meet its commitments in the mid-1960s &mdash; but only just. 
 Army overstretch was not the only awkward legacy that would be bequeathed by the Conservatives to their socialist successors. 
 The financial savings made possible by Sandys&equo; Reformation had been gradually whittled away by escalating equipment costs, and by the need to provide the strategic mobility that his policies had assumed, but which had been inadequately provided for in his costings. 
 When Thorneycroft took over in July 1962, the Defence Votes were under pressure again, and pruning was once more the order of the day. 
 In order to help accommodate the costs of the Navy's new carrier, CVA 01, and Polaris, and the RAF's TSR 2, such projects as the Army's Blue Water artillery missile were cancelled in August 1962; and, despite the pressure on Army manpower, it was decided to run down the Gurkhas from 14,600 to 10,000 rather than cut any more British battalions &mdash; a decision that had to be reversed nine months later to meet the needs of the Borneo campaign. 
 Such pruning was only a palliative. 
 There were three expensive aircraft projects in addition to TSR 2, awaiting funding; the subsonic P 1 127 vertical take-off close support aircraft; the supersonic P1154 vertical take-off fighter; and the HS681 short take-off medium-range transport. 
 The Navy also needed a supersonic fighter. 
 Thorneycroft insisted, like Sandys before him over the TSR 2, that economies should be made by the Navy and RAF using the same airframe for their future supersonic fighter, but he was equally unsuccessful: the requirements for the two environments were far too far apart. 
 The P1154 went ahead for the RAF only; and the Navy was allowed to buy the American Phantom. 
 Large additional costs could be seen arising from the Nassau Agreement on British participation in the American-sponsored NATO Multilateral Force as part of the quid pro quo  for Polaris. 
 The US proposal was designed to assuage European, particularly German, ambitions to have more influence in NATO's nuclear forces without jeopardizing American control of the Western nuclear deterrent. 
 There were to be twenty-five surface ships, each armed with eight Polaris missiles. 
 The Ministry of Defence objected on three grounds: the  increase in nuclear missiles available to the West was operationally unnecessary and would only add to the existing nuclear overkill; mixed manning was a formula for military disaster; and the cost of the British share would have to come out of the already overstretched Defence budget. 
 American political pressure for agreement on the formation of the force was so intense that there seemed little chance of it being rejected by NATO on military or financial grounds. 
 Thorneycroft, therefore, proposed an alternative solution at the NATO Council meeting in July 1964. 
 Existing European air and missile forces, equipped with nuclear weapons, should be placed under SACEUR as a NATO interdiction force for use against Warsaw Pact communications. 
 This he believed would meet the political need without incurring the cost of building up a new fleet of surface ships and perpetrating the military nonsense of mixed manning. 
 The &bquo;Thorneycroft Proposals&equo; were not well received by the Americans, but they were prepared to consider them. 
 In the meantime, the British agreed to send thirty officers and men to take part in the experimental mixed-manning of the US destroyer Admiral Claud V. Ricketts . 
 But, in Britain, it was election year, and, in America, President Johnson was only just beginning to grasp the reins of power after Kennedy's assassination, and so little political progress was made. 
 The problem of Multilateral versus Multinational nuclear forces became another legacy bequeathed to the Wilson Government when it came to power. 
 At the end of the thirteen years of Conservative rule, Britain was still an offshore island of the United States, but times were changing. 
 Collaboration with Europe was starting to become a possibility. 
 De Gaulle was not immortal, and so it was only a question of time before further attempts could be made to find a sheltered anchorage off the Western European shore.  
 This and next two divs are really front matter; however, current (920624) CDIF does not allow structure of front matter to be shown 
 A practical and informative book for the keen and adventurous cook and a delightful bedside companion for the culinary insomniac. 
 Delicatessen: A Celebration and Cookbook  explores the irresistible delights of the delicatessen counter. 
 This cook's tour of the shelves takes you round the cold meats, sausages and cheeses, the oils, vinegars, dressings and sauces, the bewildering arrays of herbs and spices, the teas and coffees and much, much more. 
 It tells where the foods come from, how they are processed, how they should be stored and how they might be served. 
 Delicious recipes will tempt you to experiment &mdash; try Smoked Quails' Eggs and Mozzarella salad for an unusual starter; tiny Mushroom Souffl&eacute;s using dried funghi; Lemon and Pistachio Pudding. 
 The true food enthusiast will appreciate the &bquo;cameos&equo; which focus on a variety of subjects such as the new generation of farmhouse-produced cheeses and how they are made, while the delightful drawings and colour photographs will whet the appetite. 
 What should you look for when buying dried fruit? 
 Are capers really pickled nasturtium seeds? 
 Black, white, pink and green peppercorns &mdash; which should be used and when? 
 Rosemary Moon has the answers. 
 Whether your delicatessen is part of a hypermarket or superstore or a tiny shop packed with delights from around the world, this book will help you to explore the potential of the exciting variety of foods available on the shelves.  
 JACKET PHOTOGRAPHY BY JOHN PLIMMER/RPM PHOTOGRAPHIC 
 This book is for Ear'ole, who has been as enthusiastic about my shop as she has been about all the other things that I have tackled, and then begged her to help with. 
 With very special thanks to: 
 John Plimmer and all the staff at RPM Photographic, Havant, Hants. 
 To John, for taking the snaps, and to all the others for keeping us going with cups of tea. 
 William Morris of Arundel, for the loan of the fine china and crystal for the photographs. 
 My husband Nick, for his enthusiasm and endless help. 
 CONTENTS 
 Introduction 
 Cold Meats &amp; Charcuterie 
 A Tavola! 
 Dressing Up 
 Oil Refinery 
 Vinegar Variations 
 Coffee 
 Teas &amp; Tissanes 
 Fingers on the Pulse 
 Ol&eacute; for Olives! 
 An Energetic Caper! 
 Salt &amp; Pepper 
 Far Eastern Promise 
 The Rice Bowl 
 Mustards to Relish 
 Fruits of the Vine 
 Cosmopolitan Cheese 
 The Flavour of France 
 Chocolate &amp; Cocoa 
 Fasta Pasta 
 The Soil Association &amp; Organic Foods 
 The Great British Eight 
 Cheesemaking Then &amp; Now 
 Sheep's &amp; Goats' Milk Cheeses 
 Blue Cheeses 
 The Spice of Life 
 Fiesta Foods 
 Fish Tales 
 Dried Mushrooms Sun-dried Tomatoes 
 Nibbles and Fancy Bits 
 Glossary/Index  
 INTRODUCTION 
 Travel has undoubtedly broadened our culinary horizons and ingredients that were only ever found in markets on holidays abroad are now readily available in specialist shops and large supermarkets. 
 It is wonderful to have this array of foods accessible to us, but it is even more exciting when you know a little about the food, how it is produced, how to prepare it and how it should be served. 
 A good delicatessen or deli counter in a large supermarket should be run by enthusiastic, trained staff who will be willing to share their knowledge and love of food with you. 
 Chatting often produces some very interesting ideas for serving and preparing the food and all of us can learn something from each other in casual conversation. 
 Many delicatessen foods should be eaten and appreciated just as they are, requiring no elaborate preparation or cooking. 
 If you are paying a little more for the food you should enjoy it for what it is &mdash; avoid recipes which suggest such things as stuffing breasts of chicken with Parma ham mousse, then wrapping them in smoked salmon and poaching in wine before serving with a cream sauce. 
 The money spent could pay for a whole dinner party. 
 Delicatessen: A Celebration and Cookbook will delight the enthusiastic cook who is interested in making the most of the very best ingredients. 
 I cannot promise to make you into a world authority on ingredients, but I do hope to share my passion for good food with you, and to inspire you to try a different type of tea or a new way of serving pasta. 
 I have kept to foods which I hope you will be able to find locally &mdash; there is no point in inspiring you with mouthwatering descriptions of cheeses available only in small mountain villages in the Alps! 
 A good retailer will enthuse about his stock and tempt you to try new foods. 
 Take advantage of this knowledge and enjoy trying all that is offered to you in your delicatessen &mdash; it really is an endless delight.  
 COLD MEATS &amp; CHARCUTERIE 
 Why is it that so often we think of pork as suitable only for roasting, for chops or sausages? 
 Remembering bacon and ham, the versatility of the pig can be stretched to pies, sandwiches and ham, egg and chips. 
 Yet a walk into any delicatessen or a continental charcuterie will prove the enormous potential of this vastly underrated animal. 
 Pork was the staple diet of most Europeans for many centuries and it was said that the peasants of Britain lived on bread, bacon and beer. 
 The pigs took care of themselves, scavenging and digging for food and eating virtually anything that they found in the streets of villages and towns alike. 
 For a peasant farmer, the pig was a good investment, being almost totally edible after it had provided very rich fertiliser during its lifetime. 
 Pork is still eaten throughout the world and in the Far East it is a very important ingredient in many stir-fried dishes as it is tender and cooks quickly. 
 In the UK, there has been a revival in the traditional art of sausage-making and strict regulations now dictate the maximum quantity of cereal filler allowed in the not-so-humble British banger. 
 The addition of herbs and spices in many combinations produces a wonderful variety of flavoursome sausages to grace any supper table, but it is really only black pudding, a breakfast sausage made with large pieces of pork back fat and pig's blood, thickened with a cereal (usually oatmeal or barley), that survives as a similar food to the continental salami or saucissons.  
 SALAMI &amp; SAUCISSONS 
 It has been said that it is best not to know too much about salami and other sausages, in the same way that ignorance about haggis aids its enjoyment and easy digestion. 
 Sausage-making is recorded in histories of the Roman Empire and the words sausage, salami and saucissons are all derived from the Latin salsus , meaning &bquo;salted&equo;. 
 These days the word salame is also used to refer to an idiot with less brains than a sack of potatoes! 
 All salami are raw meat, usually pork but sometimes with the addition of a little beef. 
 The flavour of each sausage is mainly determined by the proportion of meat to fat, the meatier sausage usually being the sweetest. 
 The most usual flavouring additions are spices, peppercorns and nuts, especially pistachios. 
 Some salami are wrapped in garlic or herbs which give additional flavour. 
 The white dust often found on the casing of salami is bacterial and usually contributes to the flavour of the sausage. 
 Garlic is seldom put into salami as it would mould and cause the sausage to deteriorate, so the garlic-like flavour is achieved by a combination of other flavouring ingredients. 
 All products grouped collectively under the name charcuterie must be treated in some way to ensure the products' keeping qualities. 
 The most common methods are smoking, drying or curing, or a combination of two of these processes may be used. 
 Salami are usually air-dried at a constant temperature during which time they lose well over a quarter and up to a third of their original weight through evaporation of the water content. 
 The size of the sausage will determine how long the drying process will take, but it is of paramount importance that the meat is perfectly dry if it is to store well.  
 Milano is the variety that I regard as the standard among the enormous range of Italian salami. 
 It is minced fairly finely with a high proportion of fat to meat and has a good spicy flavour which is not too hot, although peppercorns and other spices are often included. 
 Napoli is also a very popular variety, having coarser lumps of flat than the Milano and being made with a mixture of pork and beef. 
 I find that Napoli is slightly chewy but delicious. 
 Italian salami often contain a mixture of pork and beef, whereas the French are more likely to keep to a pure pork sausage. 
 Small metal tags on the string coatings of Italian salami will indicate the meat content &mdash; those stamped &bquo;S&equo; are made with pork only, whereas mixtures of pork and beef are marked &bquo;SB&equo;. 
 I also try to have one very hot salame always in stock &mdash; Ventracini and Murghetto are the usual choice. 
 These are both very peppery, but the full effect is often not realised until you swallow. 
 Although it is most usual to think of salami as an Italian speciality, they are, in fact, made throughout Europe. 
 The most popular German salami that I sell is the square peppery variety, which is very finely minced pork and beef coated on the outside with ground black peppercorns (see p7). 
 German salami are often quite heavily smoked. 
 Hungarian salami, a small sausage approx 5cm/2in in diameter, is very hard and spicy and is an excellent ingredient in quiches and pizzas. 
 The meat used for Danish salami is pre-salted (saltpetre is included) which explains its very vivid pink colouring and its salty flavour. 
 I always feel that Danish salami lack the finesse of many other varieties and their inferior quality is reflected in the price, which is generally considerably lower. 
 The most widely sold of the French salami in the UK are the plump, sweet Jesus de Lyon and the Arles, from the gastronomically famed region of that name. 
 It is impossible to describe any but the most popular of the salami that are found both in delicatessens and supermarkets. 
 It is quite acceptable to ask to sample before you buy, although this is only possible if you are purchasing over the counter. 
 Always ask for a slice cut freshly from the salame and do not expect to get the true flavour from a pre-cut chunk on a plate. 
 HINTS FOR BUYING SALAME 
 Uncut salami keep perfectly at a cool room temperature and may often be found festooning a delicatessen's ceiling. 
 Once cut, however, they should be treated as any other cold meat and kept under refrigeration, usually with the cut end covered &mdash; do not buy from a cut salame which is not refrigerated. 
 A good delicatessen will always remove the casing from a salame before slicing it, unless it is wrapped in garlic or herbs, but only enough should be removed for the immediate customer. 
 Resist being served from a salame where all the casing has already been removed &mdash; the meat may have become dry and tough during storage. 
 If you wish to purchase a chunk of salame to slice yourself in the future, you should ask for the casing to be left on the meat to keep it in prime condition. 
 It is usual for all salami to be sliced very finely. 
 COOKING WITH SALAMI 
 Apart from using the ends of the sausages in sauces, it is generally best not to cook with these meats but just to enjoy them cold. 
 Salami are best served as an antipasto, in sandwiches, with salads or eaten with a little cheese and fresh crusty bread. 
 There was a time when a popular cocktail food was salame (usually Danish) rolled round a cream or cottage cheese filling to form a cornet. 
 Luckily, this fashion seems to have passed as such things were never very easy to eat in a dignified way. 
 Should you arrive at a delicatessen counter when a salame is just being started or finished, you may be lucky enough to collect the end chunk which can be used to give extra flavour to spaghetti sauces or risotto-type dishes. 
 I find that the finer, harder salami are best for adding to recipes, but remember that they contain a high proportion of fat, so adjust oil or butter in the recipe accordingly.  
 SUPPERTIME RISOTTO 
 Serves 2&ndash;3 
 This simple risotto provides a filling supper dish and may be made with an end chunk of salame. 
 Left-over cold meat from a joint may also be added together with any vegetables that are to hand when you add the salame. 
 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 1 onion, finely sliced 1 clove garlic, crushed 225g/8oz/1 cup risotto rice, thoroughly washed in running water 1 &times; 5ml/tsp powdered saffron (optional) 186g/6&frac12;oz can pimentos, drained and chopped 175g/6oz salame, finely chopped 500ml/1pt/2&amp; cups boiling water or vegetable stock 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped parsley salt and freshly ground black pepper 25&ndash;50g/1&ndash;2oz Parmesan cheese, freshly grated 
 1. 
 Heat the oil in a large pan over a moderate heat, add the onion and garlic and cook, covered, until well softened and just starting to brown. 
 2. 
 Add the rice and saffron and saut&eacute; for a few minutes with the onion until opaque. 
 3. 
 Add the pimentos, salame and boiling water or stock to the pan with most, but not all of, the parsley and a little salt and pepper. 
 Return to the boil, stirring once or twice. 
 4. 
 Simmer, covered, for about 20min until all the liquid has been absorbed. 
 5. 
 Remove from the heat and season to taste with salt and pepper, then stir in the Parmesan cheese. 
 Leave for a minute or so, until the cheese has melted, then serve, sprinkled with the remaining parsley. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Risotto rice is generally served slightly wet (see Rice, p57) and is usually in a fairly rib-sticking form! 
 Slivers of butter are often added just before serving (see Risotto Milanese, p58), but I like to add Parmesan to this recipe for extra flavour, especially if the salame is the only meat being used. 
 SMOKED, SCALDED, DRIED OR COOKED &mdash; YET MORE SAUSAGES 
 Many varieties of sausages are not classed as salami at all, these coming mainly from Germany, Poland and other mid-European countries. 
 They are usually smoked or scalded to preserve the meat, but some, such as haslet and liver sausage, are totally cooked. 
 It is simplest to describe them according to how they have been preserved. 
 Smoked Dried Sausages 
 Without doubt the best known and most readily available variety in the UK is Cervelat from Germany (see p7). 
 It is a finely ground mixture of pork and beef with a comparatively bland seasoning. 
 The sausage is smoked until it is golden-brown. 
 The wide availability of Cervelat in supermarkets and delicatessens makes it one of the most popular of charcuterie products and one that will not offend even the most conservative of palates. 
 Teewurst is another German example of this type of sausage and is usually sold in small packs. 
 It is a smooth spreading sausage, similar in texture to a fine liver sausage, with a bright pink colour. 
 Teewurst has a rich and pronounced smoked flavour and is delicious on hot toast or crackers. 
  The best examples are made from pure pork, but cheaper varieties may also contain some beef. 
 Mettwurst is similar to Teewurst but is always made from a mixture of pork and beef, is very smoky and often contains paprika to give it a more spicy flavour. 
 It is available smooth for spreading, or of a coarser texture for slicing when it may be heated before serving. 
 Extrawurst or Fleischwurst is another lightly smoked sausage for eating cold but may also be poached or grilled. 
 These sausages sometimes contain nuts or garlic which give extra texture to an otherwise smooth paste. 
 Scalded or Lightly Cooked Sausages 
 These are generally large sausages that are sold for slicing, mainly to beaten cold, but some are good for cooking. 
 The scalding or light cooking of these products acts to preserve them. 
 Bierwurst is a large German sausage that may be pork or pork and beef, has a fine texture and is usually spiced with peppercorns and white mustard seed. 
 There is no beer in the sausage, but it is a traditional accompaniment to the brew. 
 Bierschinkenwurst is a coarser textured Bierwurst incorporating small pieces of ham. 
 Frankfurters are the most widely known of all the scalded sausages, and many other varieties such as Bockwurst, Knackwurst and Weinerwurst are really the same thing but in different sizes. 
 To my taste, none of these have a particularly distinctive flavour, but the quality in texture is immediately obvious. 
 The best of these sausages are loose or in jars &mdash; I find that the necessary temperatures achieved during canning tend to make the sausages rather fatty and slimy in texture. 
 Garlic sausages are made in many countries, notably France, Germany and Poland. 
 I sell most of the French variety, which is a small sausage with a strong flavour but a coarse and fatty texture. 
 German garlic sausages tend to be milder, while the Polish varieties are hard in texture and small in size. 
 Mortadella is the most popular Italian example of the scalded sausages; it is usually very large and always contains chunks of fat in the smooth meat paste. 
 The best Mortadella also includes pistachio nuts, the texture and flavour of which relieve an otherwise bland but pleasant meat. 
 Within this category of sausages are several harder and spicier varieties which are excellent when added to cassoulet-type dishes or bean stews. 
 These are, namely, chorizos and kabanos. 
 Chirozos are always peppery, flavoured with paprika and although they sound Spanish, are often made in Germany. 
 They are generally quite small, about 225/8oz in weight, but some of the German varieties are large and intended to be sold sliced. 
 They usually need to be cooked and I use them a great deal with beans and in Mexican dishes, slicing them before cooking. 
 Kabanos are much thinner than chorizos but are used in much the same way, although the older, drier varieties are popular as chewing sausages. 
 Many of the branded &bquo;pepper salame sticks&equo; sold in supermarkets are variations on the theme of the kabanos, sold very fresh before they harden. 
 The Polish sausages Wieska and Tuchowska are generally sold in rings for slicing and heating, although they may also be eaten cold. 
 Wieska is my favourite of the two, being leaner and drier. 
 Cooked or Boiled Sausages 
 Many of the meats in this category may not immediately be labelled as sausages in your mind, but this is where they fit in the standard delicatessen classification. 
 They are usually made from pig's offal or blood. 
 Black pudding is the most common of these sausages in the UK. 
 It is made from blood thickened with cereals and contains large pieces of fat. 
 You either love it or hate it. 
 It is usually sliced, fried and eaten for breakfast. 
 If you really want to experiment, try if with bacon, tomatoes and fried bananas. 
 The Germans, French and Poles all make variations on this traditional dish. 
 Brawn is usually square in shape and therefore quite unlike a sausage, although it is classified as one. 
 I have never eaten brawn &mdash; no doubt I should do so &mdash; so cannot comment on it except to say that it is made from the pig's head which is simmered with herbs and spices; the resulting meat is set in the naturally produced aspic. 
 It has always had about the same amount of appeal to me as sheep's eyes. 
 As a confirmed haggis lover, that just proves how irrational we humans can be! 
 Haslet is a pork meat loaf, which is flavoured with a variety of herbs and spices. 
 With the  addition of plenty of hot English mustard, it makes one of my favourite sandwiches. 
 It is peculiarly English and should be bought from a round loaf, covered in strings of fat which give it flavour. 
 Loaf-tin shaped varieties are seldom tasty or worth eating and are often cooked without the flavoursome larding of fat. 
 Haggis is the famed dish of Scotland. 
 It is made from the liver, lungs and heart of a sheep with the addition of oatmeal and spices, all of which is packed into the sheep's stomach. 
 Natural stomachs are not often used now and the casing should be well pricked before the haggis is simmered in a pan of water for 30&ndash;40 min. 
 Haggis also reheats well in the microwave cooker; approximately 10min should be allowed for a 450g/1 lb example on a setting of 70% power. 
 Haggis is traditionally washed down with whisky. 
 I have also sliced a haggis and cooked it as burgers over the barbecue on a piece of foil &mdash; it makes a change from beefburgers. 
 Liver sausage may be firm for slicing or smooth for spreading and most of the continental varieties are of the latter type. 
 The sausage is generally made from pork liver and the price paid dictates the quality received. 
 Very expensive liver sausages may be made from calves' or goose livers, but these are difficult to find and very rich in taste. 
 HINTS FOR BUYING PRESERVED SAUSAGES 
 All these products should be kept under refrigeration unless, like some members of the Frankfurter family, they are preserved in a jar or can. 
 Slicing sausages should be stored in a chiller with the cut end always covered. 
 Don't worry if the slice is slightly discoloured &mdash; the meat is simply oxidising. 
 The retailer should not sell you the first slice and the second cut should be of a bright, usually pink colour. 
 If the sausage is discoloured all the way through, do not buy it. 
 Keep any sliced meat in the refrigerator until it is required.  
 HAMS 
 There is a world of difference between ham that has been sliced from the bone or cut from a joint on a machine and the pre-packaged wet and tasteless substance that so many people believe to be ham. 
 We always have a boiled ham on the bone in our delicatessen counter and it is without doubt the single main item responsible for drawing people into the shop who might otherwise be content to look through the window. 
 A true ham is the whole rear leg of the pig and is cut from the carcase before it is prepared. 
 If the leg is cured while it is still attached, it is technically a gammon &mdash; hence the confusion caused by the term &bquo;gammon ham&equo;. 
 PARMA HAM 
 Parma is perhaps the most famous of all the dried hams and is air-dried in a similar way to many salami. 
 Being an air-dried product, Parma ham is raw and should be referred to as &bquo;prosciutto crudo&equo; &mdash; prosciutto  is the Italian word for ham and may refer to cheaper hams that may look like Parma but are not. 
 True prosciutto crudo has the brand name stamped into its skin and is always from the Parma area of Italy. 
 Tips for Buying Parma Ham 
 First, even if you are in Italy, expect to pay a high price for Parma ham &mdash; anything that seems a real bargain will probably not be true prosciutto crudo. 
 Only but a whole ham if you are really going to use it. 
 You can freeze it, but it will start to go rancid after a comparatively short storage period of three months. 
 You will also need to consider slicing. 
 It is not fair to expect your local delicatessen to do it for you as it takes a long time to slice the whole ham and Parma must be cut thinly. 
 If you attempt to cut it with a knife, remove the thick brown skin from the portion to be sliced, paying great attention to the direction in which you are cutting &mdash; it is very easy for the knife to slip and the blade must travel away from you. 
 Only cut the amount required at one time, otherwise the extra slices will dry out during storage. 
 The ham is always easier to cut when it is well chilled and may be even easier to handle if it is lightly frozen. 
  Parma ham is available ready sliced in small packets, but this is an expensive way to but it, although it does always ensure good, even pieces. 
 Cooking with Parma Ham 
 Most people think of serving this delicacy with slices of ripe melon as a starter, but it also makes an excellent accompaniment to many of the exotic fruits that are widely available in greengrocers and supermarkets. 
 I particularly enjoy Parma ham with slices of ripe mango (see p19) or paw-paw (also called papaya), and it is also delicious with fresh figs. 
 Although the idea of cooking with Parma ham sounds prohibitively expensive, it need not be so. 
 The Smoked Trout &amp; Parma Ham Mousse (see p18) is merely decorated with slices of the ham and the Carbonnade of Beef is enriched by using diced ham instead of bacon. 
 Ask your local delicatessen to keep the end of a new Parma ham for you, or put in a bid for the unsliceable knuckle end. 
 Such pieces are also excellent for adding to spaghetti sauces and for mincing with other meats for meatballs, again to serve with pasta. 
 OTHER CONTINENTAL HAMS 
 Although regional hams are produced throughout Europe, few are particularly well known. 
 Of these, the French Bayonne and the German Westphalian hams are the most popular and the easiest to obtain. 
 The Bayonne is a raw ham cured at Orthez in south-west France. 
 Its particular flavour is achieved by the addition of red wine and rosemary to the brine in which it is cured. 
 The ham is then lightly smoked. 
 It is very similar in appearance to Parma ham. 
 Westphalian ham is darker in colour than Parma and Bayonne; it is more heavily smoked than Bayonne and is aged before selling. 
 CARBONNADE OF BEEF 
 Serves 6&ndash;8 people (see p19) 
 This very rich and delicious dish should be served with plain boiled rice or jacket potatoes and a boiled or steamed green vegetable such as Calabrese or Brussels sprouts. 
 The casserole is topped with a thick-set natural yoghurt which offsets the richness of the meat. 
 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 225g/8oz Parma ham, but into very small dice 1 large onion, thinly sliced 775g/1 &frac34;lb braising steak, cut into large dice 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp flour 375ml/15fl oz/2 cups brown ale or stout 2 bay leaves 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp Dijon mustard salt and freshly ground black pepper set natural or Greek yogurt for serving chopped chives to garnish 
 1. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 3/160&deg;C/325&deg;F. 
 2. 
 Heat the olive oil in a large casserole or pan, add the Parma ham and the onion, cover and cook over a low heat for 10min, stirring once or twice. 
 3. 
 Add the braising steak to the pan and brown on all sides over a higher heat. 
 Remove the meat and onions from the pan using a slotted spoon. 
 4. 
 Stir the flour into the remaining juices and cook slowly until well browned, stirring all the time. 
 This may take several minutes, but do not be impatient otherwise the sauce will be pale and uninteresting instead of a rich dark brown colour. 
 5. 
 Remove the pan from the heat and gradually add the beer, stirring constantly. 
 Bring the sauce to the boil. 
 6. 
 Return the meats and onions to the pan and add the bay leaves, mustard and salt and pepper. 
 If the pan is not suitable for use in the oven, transfer the meat to a casserole dish. 
 Cover and cook in the pre-heated oven for 2&frac12;&ndash;3hr, until the beef is tender. 
 7. 
 Remove the bay leaves and season the casserole to taste. 
 Serve topped with yogurt and garnished with freshly chopped chives. 
 COOK'S TIP: Always break the bay leaves before adding them to the pan otherwise most of their flavour will be trapped and they will be of no benefit to the casserole.  
 SMOKED TROUT &amp; PARMA HAM MOUSSE 
 Serves 8 (see p19) 
 The flavours of the trout and ham combine beautifully in this starter, which can be served either with melon balls mounted in the centre or set into the mixture. 
 The recipe is also delicious if it is made with smoked salmon pieces, but the trout is a little more unusual. 
 Use smoked rainbow trout &mdash; salmon trout is an unnecessary extravagance. 
 250ml/8fl oz/1 cup milk 6 peppercorns 1 blade mace small piece celery small piece carrot small piece onion 25g/1oz butter 25g/1oz flour salt and white pepper to taste 175g/6oz Parma ham slices 450g/1lb smoked trout, flaked 250ml/10fl oz/1&frac14; cups double or thick cream 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp boiling water 1 &times; heaped 15ml/tbsp gelatine (1 sachet) 2 egg whites 1 ripe melon, balled toast fingers or Melba toasts to serve 
 1. 
 Heat the milk with the peppercorns, mace and vegetables until almost boiling, then remove from the heat, cover and leave for 10min. 
 This may be done by heating in a jug in the microwave for 4min, then cover the jug and leave for 10min. 
 2. 
 Prepare a bechamel sauce with the flavoured milk. 
 Melt the butter, add the flour and cook for a few seconds, then gradually add the milk, straining it into the roux mixture. 
 Beat thoroughly while adding the milk, then return the sauce to the heat and bring to the boil, stirring constantly. 
 Season to taste with salt and white pepper, then cover the sauce with greaseproof paper to prevent it from forming a skin and allow it to cool completely. 
 (The sauce may also be prepared in a microwave cooker.) 
 3. 
 Prepare a 23&ndash;25cm/9&ndash;10in ring mould. 
 Lightly oil a plastic mould and line with greaseproof paper or baking parchment. 
 Metal moulds should also be lightly oiled. 
 Lay the slices of Parma ham in the mould to make a covering for the mousse; slightly overlap the slices of ham. 
 4. 
 Place the cooled sauce and the trout in a liquidiser or food processor and blend until smooth. 
 Whip the cream until thick but still soft. 
 Fold the trout mixture into the cream. 
 5. 
 Sprinkle the gelatine onto the boiling water in a small bowl and stir well &mdash; then leave for a minute or so to dissolve. 
 If the powder is not completely dissolved, place the bowl in a saucepan of water and heat gently or heat in the microwave for 20sec &mdash; do not let the gelatine boil. 
 6. 
 Allow the gelatine to cool, then add to the trout cream. 
 7. 
 Whisk the egg whites until stiff, then add to the cream. 
 Place a layer of the mixture in the base of the prepared mould, then arrange the melon balls on top, if they are to be set into the mousse. 
 Carefully spoon the remaining trout mixture into the mould. 
 8. 
 Fold the ends of the Parma ham slices over the filling, then refrigerate for 2&ndash;3hr until set. 
 9. 
 To serve, ease the mousse away from the edges of the mould, then invert it onto a serving plate and shake firmly to release the mousse. 
 Pile the melon balls into the centre of the mousse if they have not been set into the mixture. 
 10. 
 Serve with freshly cooked toast fingers or Melba toasts. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Commercially prepared Melba toasts are available, but they are nothing like the real thing. 
 Use pre-sliced white bread and remove the crusts. 
 Toast on both sides under a grill, then carefully slice through horizontally, using a sharp thin-bladed bread saw. 
 Toast the newly cut surfaces but keep a watchful eye on them as the toast is now very thin and will cook extra quickly.  
 THE TRADITIONAL HAMS OF BRITAIN AND THE USA 
 Many of the most famous hams are British, which makes it all the more shameful that many shops are selling the wet and tasteless ersatz ham that we are all familiar with. 
 York ham is renowned throughout the world, although other hams are less well known. 
 All the hams are dry salted to preserve the meat by extracting the juices which would otherwise cause the meat to perish. 
 While the period of maturing is seldom described as such, the hams are thoroughly air-dried after being treated with a mixture of sugars and spices; they are also often smoked before drying. 
 Oak is the most commonly used wood for smoking meat in the UK but other varieties are also used and all contribute to the final flavour of the ham. 
 After drying, the following hams are soaked in water to remove any excessive saltiness from the curing and then cooked, unlike the continental hams described earlier. 
 A dried, uncooked ham will keep for several months in dry cool conditions. 
 CARVING A HAM ON THE BONE 
 Should you ever possess a whole ham on the bone, you must know how to carve it properly, otherwise you will waste a great deal of meat and subsequently be eating ham soup for ages. 
 Securing the ham (so that it doesn't run away from you) will be the first problem. 
 If you have a ham stand, all well and good, otherwise invert a large plate and stand the ham on that; it will raise the meat sufficiently to allow your carving knife to travel as required during slicing. 
 You will need to turn the ham over twice during carving to remove the maximum amount of meat. 
 I always start at the fillet end and work towards the knuckle. 
 Always aim to be carving at right angles to the bone, otherwise the sliced meat will be stringy in appearance and texture. 
 1. 
 Start from the fillet or thick end of the ham. 
 Remove the first slice, then continue carving until approximately one third of the way down the ham. 
 Cut down to the bone to avoid excessive wastage. 
 2. 
 Turn the ham over and continue slicing the middle third of the ham. 
 3. 
 Turn the ham over again and finish carving the ham to the knuckle end. 
 HAM &amp; LENTIL SOUP 
 Serves 6 
 Many delicatessens will sell their ham bones but you should be prepared to put your name on a waiting list. 
 After trimming most of the meat away, the bones will make marvellous stock or soup. 
 Ensure that any resulting stock is not too salty before you add it to casseroles or other recipes. 
 125g/4oz/&frac34; cup red lentils 1 large onion, sliced 1 large carrot, diced 2 sticks celery, finely sliced 125g/4oz ham, from the bone, cut into small pieces 1 litre/2pt/4&frac12; cups ham stock 2 bay leaves freshly ground black pepper salt to taste 
 1. 
 Rinse the lentils in a sieve under running water, then place them in a large saucepan with all the remaining ingredients except the salt. 
 2. 
 Bring the soup to the boil, stirring from time to time, then simmer slowly for 45&ndash;60min, until the vegetables are soft and the lentils have cooked and thickened the soup. 
 3. 
 Remove the bay leaves. 
 Season the soup to taste with salt and pepper and serve with fresh crusty bread. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Red lentils do not require soaking (see p38). 
 If you have not made stock from the bone, place the whole bone or part of it in the pan with the measured amount of water, not stock. 
 The bone will give plenty of flavour to the soup during cooking and should be removed before the soup is seasoned prior to serving.  
 YORK HAM (see p10) 
 Perhaps the most famous of all, this ham is dry cured when it is rubbed with salt and then matured for 3&ndash;4 months. 
 It is simmered slowly after it has been soaked and is usually coated with breadcrumbs before it is sold. 
 York ham commands a high price and is much sought after, especially at Christmas time. 
 It will be interesting to see whether, in the future, the generation that is now being raised on comparatively low salt diets will consider the York ham to be as special as those who now remember it so fondly. 
 BRADENHAM HAMS (see p11) 
 In its uncooked form, the Bradenham ham is easily distinguishable by its very dark, almost black appearance and the brand mark Bradenham stamped into its skin. 
 These hams are from Chippenham in Wiltshire, where they have been prepared since 1781. 
 They are rubbed with salt to dry cure them and then coated with a mixture of spices, including juniper, and molasses, which is mainly responsible for the black appearance of the ham. 
 After curing, the hams are soaked and then simmered, black treacle usually being added to the water in which they are cooked. 
 As with all hams, the thick skin is removed before sale or serving. 
 Bradenham hams should be presented uncrumbed or coated in white breadcrumbs. 
 SUFFOLK HAM 
 Lesser known than the Bradenham, the Suffolk is also a sweet ham which is lightly smoked. 
 It must also be said that a plain boiled ham presented on or off the bone is a delight to the jaded palate and should not be ignored because it remains undistinguished by any special cure. 
 When bought in large pieces, such hams may be further enhanced by baking for a short time in a hot oven with a glaze of either honey, ginger syrup, marmalade mixed with orange juice or fruit syrups. 
 VIRGINIA &amp; SMITHFIELD 
 The Hams of the USA 
 These hams are dry cured in the same way as many of the English hams, but their distinctive flavours were traditionally achieved by feeding the pigs on special foods. 
 Virginia hams were taken from pigs that were fed on peanuts and peaches while those producing Smithfield hams enjoyed a diet of acorns and other nuts. 
 I wonder whether these diets are still adhered to? 
 OTHER DELICATESSEN MEATS 
 It is quite usual to find large joints of roast beef and pork for slicing on the delicatessen counter, but two of the more interesting meats to reach us in recent years have been smoked turkey and pastrami. 
 Smoked turkey (see p11) is produced in many countries, but my preference is for the Belgian variety. 
 Available on or off the bone, the meat is usually from only the breasts of the birds and is lightly smoked, moist and quite delicious. 
 Smoked turkey may be sliced thickly and eaten hot or served cold, with or in salads (see p27). 
 Smoked chicken is also popular and smoked pheasant makes a treat. 
 Pastrami, made famous outside the United States by the television series Kojak , in which the hero ate this meat on rye bread, is salted and spiced brisket of beef. 
 I prefer it coated in very coarsely grated black pepper and it should always be sliced extremely thinly. 
 Pastrami cut from a very regular block will probably not be made from brisket of beef, so the odder the shape, the better the meat. 
 Bresaola is a similar dried salt beef from Italy, but is often not quite as lean as pastrami. 
 Corned beef is a traditional favourite and should not be totally forgotten in favour of other more refined (and more expensive) meats. 
 Corning was originally a process of preservation achieved by rubbing the meat with corns or grains of salt. 
 The corned beef that we are familiar with is a cured beef which is then boiled and pressed before being canned. 
 Mainly produced in South America, a good quality corned beef is delicious served cold with pickles or hot with potatoes in a hash.  
 ( page 9 ) 1 French ham sausage; 2 German pepper salame; 3 Italian Milano salame; 4 French garlic sausage; 5 French pistachio sausage with beef; 6 German Cervelat 
 ( l to r ) York ham on the bone; home cooked honey-roast ham; p&acirc;t&eacute; de campagne; haslet; smoked turkey; raw Bradenham ham ( hanging in background ) 
 front to back  Parma Ham with Fresh Mango; Smoked Trout &amp; Parma Ham Mousse; Carbonnade of Beef 
 Right hand 
 Left hand 
 A Tavola! 
 There is a great deal more to Italian food than an endless variety of pasta shapes topped with Bolognese sauce, and pizzas. 
 Italy is famed for its salami, sausages and Parma hams (see pp8&ndash;18), its cheeses and olive oils, but there is still much about the cuisine that is relatively unknown. 
 What could you include with mixed salami to make a really interesting dish of antipasto? 
 I suggest Marinated Aubergines and Cannellini Bean &amp; Tuna Fish Salad for a good combination of colours and textures. 
 Homemade pizzas often lack even a vague hint of authenticity. 
 The secret is the dough for the base and the use of Mozzarella for the topping. 
 There are some excellent commercial pesto sauces available, but always be prepared to pay for one made with olive oil and not a lighter, less flavoursome oil. 
 If you are following the recipe opposite for Pesto alla Genovese, do try to get some Pecorino to mix with the Parmesan &mdash; it is a sharp ewes' milk cheese that really adds an extra bite to any pasta dish.  
 Smoked Quails' Eggs &amp; Mozzarella Salad 
 Italian specialities can easily be combined with foods from other countries. 
 Mozzarella cheese adds flavour and an unusual texture to any salad &mdash; combine it with smoked quails' eggs for a very special starter. 
 The salad may be served on a bed of raw spinach. 
 Serves 4 (see p27) 
 2 ripe avocados, peeled and sliced lemon juice 2 &times; 200g/7oz Mozzarella cheese, sliced 4 large flavoursome tomatoes, sliced 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped mixed herbs 12 smoked quails' eggs 4 &times; 15ml/tbsp set natural yogurt salt and freshly ground black pepper 4 &times; 15ml/tbsp virgin olive oil crusty bread for serving 
 1. 
 Sprinkle the avocado slices with lemon juice, then arrange them with Mozzarella and tomato slices. 
 2. 
 Scatter the freshly chopped herbs over the tomatoes and lightly season with salt and black pepper. 
 3. 
 Place 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp natural yogurt in the centre of each plate and top with three quails' eggs. 
 4. 
 Trickle a little oil over each salad. 
 Serve with fresh bread. 
 Pesto alla Genovese 
 This traditional sauce of basil, garlic and cheese should always be made with best quality virgin olive oil. 
 It makes approximately 375ml/15fl oz/2 cups &mdash; sufficient for 8 servings as a starter. 
 125g/4oz/2 cups fresh basil leaves, torn from their stalks and chopped or 75g/3oz/1&frac12; cups parsley and 5 &times; 5ml/tsp dried basil &frac12; &times; 5ml/tsp salt &frac12; &times; 5ml/tsp freshly ground black pepper 3&ndash;4 cloves garlic, chopped 50g/2oz/&frac13; cup pine kernels 250ml/10fl oz/1&frac14; cups virgin olive oil, approx 50g/2oz/1 cup freshly grated Parmesan and Pecorino cheese, mixed pine kernels to garnish 
 1. 
 Chop all the ingredients together in a liquidiser or food processor, then gradually add sufficient olive oil to give a smooth paste. 
 2. 
 If you have no blender pound the dry ingredients in a pestle and mortar, then gradually stir in the oil. 
 3. 
 Stir the sauce into freshly cooked pasta which has been tossed in butter. 
 Sprinkle with pine kernels and serve immediately.  
 Antipasto 
 Here are two ideas to complement your own selection of salami and sausages. 
 Marinated Aubergines 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 
 450g/1 lb aubergines, halved lengthways then thickly sliced 3 &times; 15 ml/tbsp white wine or garlic vinegar 1 clove garlic, crushed 1 &times; 5ml/tsp freshly chopped basil 1 &times; 5ml/tsp freshly chopped oregano salt and freshly ground black pepper 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp virgin olive oil 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp capers (optional) 
 1. 
 Simmer the aubergines in a large pan of water until just cooked, about 10min, or cook, covered, in the microwave for 7&ndash;8min or until just tender. 
 Drain. 
 2. 
 Mix together the vinegar, garlic, herbs, salt and pepper in a large bowl, then add the aubergine slices and toss until coated in the dressing. 
 leave until cold, toss, then cover and chill in the refrigerator for at least 1 hr. 
 3. 
 Add the olive oil and capers just before serving and toss again. 
 Cannellini Bean &amp; Tuna Fish Salad 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 
 2 &times; 400g/14oz can cannellini beans, drained and rinsed 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp virgin olive oil juice of &frac12; lemon 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped spring onions 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped parsley salt and freshly ground black pepper 1 &times; 200g/7oz can tuna fish 
 1. 
 Shake the cannellini beans dry, then place them in a bowl. 
 2. 
 Place the oil, lemon juice, spring onions, parsley and seasonings in a small screw top jar and shake well. 
 Pour the dressing over the beans. 
 Chill in the refrigerator for at least 1 hr. 
 3. 
 Flake the tuna fish; dispose of any brine, but if the fish is packed in olive oil it may be added to the dressing for the beans. 
 4. 
 Serve the salad on a plate with the flaked tuna arranged on top of the beans. 
 COOK'S NOTE: I have also prepared this dish using flageolet beans. 
 This is not so authentic but the green beans give an attractive appearance to the dish.  
 Pizza 
 Serves 2&ndash;4 (see p110) 
 Pizza is one of the most popular Italian dishes to be exported around the world, after the many variations on pasta. 
 Pizza dough is more oily than a standard bread dough. 
 It should be rolled thinly and cooked very quickly. 
 Adding sun-dried tomatoes as a garnish to the pizza gives a strong savoury taste. 
 450g/1 lb/4 cups strong white bread flour 1 &times; 5 ml/tsp salt 125ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cups olive oil or pizza oil 25g/1 oz fresh yeast pinch caster sugar 250ml/10oz/1&frac14; cups, approx, warm water 350ml/15fl oz/2 cups prepared tomato sauce for pasta 125g/4oz sliced pizza sausage, sardines, salame, etc, if required 8 sun-dried tomato halves, chopped 450g/1 lb Mozzarella cheese, grated or finely sliced 4 &times; 15ml/tbsp grated Parmesan cheese 8 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 
 1. 
 Place the flour in a large bowl with the salt and oil. 
 Cream the yeast with the sugar and a little of the warm water. 
 Add to the flour and mix to a manageable dough, adding more water as required. 
 Knead thoroughly on a lightly floured surface until the dough is smooth and elastic. 
 2. 
 Place the dough in a clean bowl and cover with cling film. 
 Leave in a warm place for 1&ndash;1&frac12;hr, until well risen and doubled in size. 
 3. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 8/250&deg;C/450&deg;F. 
 4. 
 Turn the dough out onto a lightly floured surface and knead gently. 
 Divide into four and make each piece of dough into a circle approx 25cm/10in in diameter. 
 Use a combination of rolling with a pin and pressing with the heel of your hand to make the circle. 
 Place the dough on greased baking sheets, raising the edges of each piece slightly to contain the topping. 
 5. 
 Spoon the pizza sauce onto the dough and top with the ingredient of your choice, or leave plain for a tomato pizza. 
 6. 
 Scatter the Mozzarella over the pizzas, then garnish with the chopped sun-dried tomatoes. 
 Top each pizza with grated Parmesan and drizzle 2 x 15ml/tbsp olive oil over each one before baking. 
 7. 
 Bake in the pre-heated oven for 5min, then reduce the setting to gas mark 6/200&amp;C/400&amp;F for a further 5&ndash;10min, until the dough is lightly browned and the filling is bubbling hot. 
 8. 
 Serve immediately. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Pizza oil is an olive oil flavoured with pimentos and spices. 
 Further Topping Ideas: Pizzas allow you to show your creative genius &mdash; and to use up all sorts of bits and pieces lurking in the 'fridge! 
 Try tuna, sardines or anchovies, or chopped spinach with plenty of garlic and black pepper. 
 Any thinly sliced salami works well, also cold roast meat with garlic and chilli sauce. 
 Lemon &amp; Pistachio Pudding 
 Serves 6 
 This pudding combines Ricotta cheese with Mascarpone, a sweet dessert cheese that is very rich. 
 Use a good cream cheese if you cannot find Mascarpone. 
 225g/8oz Ricotta cheese 225/8oz Mascarpone cheese 50g/2oz/&frac14; cup caster sugar 50g/2oz/&amp; cup plain flour 4 eggs, separated 2 lemons, grated rind and juice 125g/4oz/1 cup pistachio kernels cream for serving 
 1. 
 Lightly grease a 20cm/7in souffl&eacute; dish. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 5/190&deg;C/375&deg;F. 
 2. 
 Beat the Ricotta and Mascarpone together until soft, add the caster sugar and beat until fluffy. 
 3. 
 Add the flour and the egg yolks and beat well, then add the lemon juice and rind and mix until evenly incorporated. 
 Fold in the pistachios. 
 4. 
 In a separate bowl whisk the egg whites until stiff. 
 Fold the whites into the cheese mixture, then turn into the prepared souffl&eacute; dish. 
 5. 
 Bake in the pre-heated oven for 40&ndash;45min, until the pudding is browned and set. 
 6. 
 Serve immediately with cream.  
 ( l to r ) Torta Dolcelatte; Parmesan; Penna pasta; Gorgonzola; Torgellini pasta; Mozzarella; Grissini breadsticks; Mortadella; Milano salame ( above ); Ventricini salame ( below ); Pasta with Pesto alla Genovese 
 DRESSING UP 
 A salad of even the simplest ingredients is enlivened by an innovative dressing. 
 If the salad is delicate, then a flavoured vinegar or aromatic oil may be sufficient, as for the Smoked Quails' Eggs and Mozzarella Salad (recipe p23) pictured on previous page and dressed only with virgin olive oil. 
 More adventurous dressings might contain fruits or cheese. 
 Avoid strongly flavoured dressings with delicate salads, but be bold and experiment. 
 RASPBERRY &amp; HAZELNUT VINAIGRETTE 
 Raspberry vinegar makes a wonderful salad dressing but is also used extensively in nouvelle cuisine for sauces and trickled over soft fruits (sometimes with a little black pepper). 
 Hazelnut oil is the secret ingredient of so many sumptuous French salads where its fresh flavour sparkles over the vegetables. 
 Combine the two for a very special dressing. 
 75ml/3fl oz raspberry vinegar 75ml/3fl oz hazelnut oil 
 Place the two ingredients together in a vinaigrette bottle or small screw-top jar and shake vigorously until blended. 
 Pour over a green salad and serve immediately or hand separately. 
 COOK'S NOTE: This vinaigrette is unusual as it has equal quantities of vinegar and oil. 
 This is because they both have such distinct flavours and the resulting dressing is more balanced using these quantities. 
 I find that no additional seasoning is necessary. 
 FROMAGE FRAIS &amp; CRANBERRY DRESSING 
 125g/4oz/1 cup fromage frais 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp cranberry sauce 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp raspberry vinegar 
 1. 
 Place the fromage frais and cranberry sauce in a liquidiser or processor and blend well. 
 Alternatively, whisk together in a bowl. 
 2. 
 Add the raspberry vinegar, which will prevent the dressing from being too sweet. 
 Mix well. 
 COOK'S NOTE: This dressing is especially successful with a salad of crisp vegetables and smoked poultry or game. 
 The salad pictured overleaf to accompany the dressing is of sliced radishes, raw mushrooms, chopped pickled walnuts, orange segments and smoked pheasant. 
 Smoked chicken or turkey could be substituted. 
 GARLIC VINAIGRETTE 
 This is a very simple variation of the basic vinaigrette dressing on p31, using a flavoured vinegar for added interest. 
 75ml/3fl oz/&frac14; cup garlic vinegar 150ml/6fl oz/&frac12; cup grapeseed or peanut oil salt and pepper 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped parsley 
 Place all the ingredients in a vinaigrette bottle or small screw-top jar and shake vigorously until blended. 
 Use immediately. 
 COOK'S NOTE: The garlic vinaigrette is pictured overleaf as a dressing for a mixed nut salad. 
 Combine 125g/4oz salted cashew nuts, 125g/4oz chopped walnuts and 125g/4oz pistachio kernels with two red and two green eating apples, peeled, finely diced and tossed in lemon juice. 
 Pour the garlic vinaigrette over and toss the salad, then serve immediately, scattered with cress. 
 If left to stand, the flavours will combine but the nuts may become slightly soft. 
 STILTON &amp; WALNUT CREAM DRESSING 
 This recipe produces a thick, creamy dressing. 
 Add a little mayonnaise if a thinner consistency is required, or use single cream instead of double. 
 125g/4oz/1 cup Stilton cheese, crumbled salt and freshly ground black pepper 125ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cup double or thick cream 75ml/3fl oz/&frac14; cup walnut oil crumbled Stilton to garnish 
 Place all the ingredients in a liquidiser or food processor and blend to a thick paste. 
 Season to taste and serve with the salad of your choice. 
 COOK'S NOTE: The easiest way to crumble any blue cheese is to stroke it with a fork until crumbled. 
 The dressing is pictured overleaf with a salad of smoked turkey, chopped avocado, lettuce and walnuts.  
 ( l to r ) Smoked Pheasant Salad; Fromage Frais &amp; Cranberry Dressing; Mixed Nut Salad with Garlic Vinaigrette; Smoked Turkey Salad with Stilton &amp; Walnut Cream Dressing; Smoked Quails' Eggs &amp; Mozzarella Salad 
 OIL REFINERY 
 The use of oils in the kitchen has greatly increased in the last few decades, influenced by foreign travel and the subsequent awareness of international cuisine. 
 Conclusive evidence of the links between solid animal fats and heart disease has also encouraged the use of oil, which now frequently replaces traditional favourites such as butter and lard. 
 There are many different types of oil, each having its own place in the kitchen. 
 The best oils are generally the least refined, extracted without heat and left their natural colour. 
 Such oils are described as &bquo;virgin&equo; or cold pressed. 
 Corn, sunflower and grapeseed oils are all for general cooking and are relatively inexpensive. 
 Sunflower and grapeseed varieties are light and therefore particularly good for frying, leaving food crisp and free from grease. 
 Corn oil is slightly heavier and more distinctive in flavour &mdash; I find it too heavy for salads. 
 I use grapeseed oil for mayonnaise, finding that olive oil gives too rich a flavour. 
 Groundnut or peanut oil is similar in character and uses to sunflower and grapeseed oils but is rather more expensive. 
 It is also a useful substitute for sesame seed oil in Chinese cookery. 
 Nut oils, despite their very high cost, are becoming more and more popular for special salad dressings where their flavours are superlative. 
 Nut oil vinaigrettes are especially delicious served as a warm dressing for salads. 
 Walnut, hazelnut and almond oils are the most popular. 
 They are all cold-pressed virgin oils and should be kept in the dark and refrigerated after opening to prevent them from becoming rancid. 
 Hazelnut oil is my favourite, but unfortunately is by far the most expensive. 
 Olive oil is the classic ingredient for so many fine dishes. 
 Produced in many parts of the Mediterranean, the oil has been a major trading commodity throughout history, just as it is today. 
 Olive oil is like a fine wine &mdash; you can buy &bquo;plonk&equo; for everyday cooking or an estate bottled vintage for the connoisseur. 
 There are three common grades of olive oil: extra virgin, which is thick and green, and cold-pressed with an acidity of less than 1%; virgin, which is green and cold-pressed but with up to 4% acidity, and fine olive oil, for general cooking, which is heat treated during the second pressing to extract the maximum oil from the fruit and often blended with other olive oils. 
 France, Italy and Greece are the major producers of olive oil and each oil has slightly different characteristics. 
 Try them all to find the one that suits your palate best. 
 I like them all, but tend to use the Italian oils most. 
 Safflower oil is very light and is used extensively in low-fat and special diet foods. 
 It is rather expensive. 
 Sesame seed oil is used extensively in Eastern cuisine. 
 It is a light oil with a high flash point, making it particularly good for stir-frying as it leaves the food crisp. 
 It is also used to baste raw and cooked foods for extra flavour, having a distinctive pungency and taste. 
 Storage tips All oils keep best in a cool, dark place &mdash; ideally a larder. 
 Do not leave your best virgin oils on display in a bright, sun-filled kitchen as they will quickly go rancid. 
 Keep them in a cupboard, away from any heat source. 
 The more expensive virgin and nut oils are best kept for salad dressings and for adding to foods which require no further cooking.  
 VERSATILE VINEGARS 
 Vinegar is more than just a table condiment to sprinkle over chips. 
 It is a product of fermentation and can be based on any alcoholic liquid such as wine, cider, sherry or beer. 
 Originally used as a preservative, today flavoured vinegars are popular as condiments, especially on salads. 
 A good vinegar is clear and transparent. 
 Avoid non-brewed condiments, which are diluted acetic acid coloured with caramel and without the rounded acidity of a true vinegar.  
 Balsamic vinegar 
 Very popular in the USA, this vinegar is produced by the acetification of grape must (new wine not properly fermented for drinking), which is concentrated and then aged in wooden barrels. 
 It is used on salads and as a general condiment. 
 Cider vinegar 
 Available straight or with honey, this vinegar is for general cooking and dressings for salads, including apples. 
 It is a good substitute for rice vinegar in Oriental cookery. 
 Cider vinegar is also thought to be beneficial to arthritis sufferers. 
 Flavoured vinegars 
 Usually based on wine vinegar, there are many popular variations, such as blackcurrant for marinading and cooking game, garlic and herb for general use, raspberry for sauces and dressings and tarragon for salads, especially on tomatoes. 
 Malt vinegar 
 Based on beer and widely used for preserving and pickling, malt vinegar is also available as a strong, colourless, distilled vinegar which is particularly useful for preserving foods that have to last a long time. 
 Wine vinegars 
 The most versatile of the vinegars, these are used for general cookery and in many of the classic sauces. 
 White wine vinegar should be used for mayonnaise, Hollandaise and Bearnaise sauces. 
 Basic vinaigrette 
 Vinaigrette is a simple salad dressing of oil and vinegar. 
 It can be varied by the addition of freshly chopped herbs, mustard powder, lemon juice or garlic, or indeed by using a nut oil or a flavoured vinegar. 
 The basic recipe uses twice as much oil as vinegar. 
 In a vinaigrette shaker or a small screw-top jar combine 100ml/4fl oz/&frac12; cup oil, 50ml/2fl oz/&frac14; cup wine vinegar, salt, freshly ground pepper and a pinch of dry mustard. 
 Shake until well blended. 
 Use immediately. 
 This will make approximately 150ml/6 fl oz/&frac34; cup. 
 BLACKCURRANT MARINADE FOR GAME PIES 
 Use this marinade for pheasant or venison. 
 After marinading, add 2&ndash;3 x 15ml/tbsp blackcurrant vinegar to the meat during cooking and sweeten to taste with a little blackcurrant jam. 
 Add a few mushrooms to the meat before baking under a pastry crust. 
 2 pheasants, quartered or 675g/1&frac12;lb venison, diced 1 large onion, sliced 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp blackcurrant vinegar 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 2 &times; 5ml/tsp pink peppercorns 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped mixed herbs or 1 &times; 5ml/tsp dried fines herbes 6 juniper berries pinch salt 2 bay leaves 250ml/10fl oz/1&frac14; cups red wine, approx 
 Place the pheasant or venison in a bowl or dish with the onion. 
 Add all the remaining ingredients with sufficient wine to cover the meat. 
 Stir, then cover the bowl and place in a refrigerator. 
 Leave for at least 24hr, stirring once or twice. 
 Drain the meat and cook with fresh vegetables and wine. 
 Allow the meat to cool, then top with pasty and bake.  
 ( l to r ) Garlic vinegar; sherry vinegar; cider vinegar; raspberry vinegar; balsamic vinegar; tarragon vinegar; vinegar with Herbes de Provence; vinaigrette 
 COFFEE 
 A Brief History of Coffee 
 The coffee shrub is a large evergreen tropical bush, originally found in North Africa but now grown in many areas of the world. 
 It is found as far north as Mexico and as far south as southern Brazil. 
 The best crops of arabica beans are grown at altitudes of between 2,500 and 6,000ft. 
 Coffee has been drunk in the Middle East for over a thousand years and its popularity spread rapidly throughout the world as explorers began to travel widely. 
 The most popular legend relating to the discovery of coffee tells of an Ethiopian mullah and a goat herd. 
 The mullah, who was finding it difficult to stay awake throughout his devotions, was led by the Prophet to an encounter with a goat herd who had noticed his flock becoming very frisky after grazing on the berries of a certain shrub. 
 The mullah made a drink from the berries which kept him awake throughout his prayers, and so began the tradition of coffee drinking. 
 Widely available since the 1930s, instant coffee is produced commercially by brewing ground freshly roasted coffee to a strong concentrate. 
 It is then passed through an atomising spray into a stream of hot air to evaporate the water and leave a fine coffee powder. 
 Freeze dried instant coffee is more aromatic than the instant coffee powder and more expensive. 
 The brewed coffee is frozen and then ground. 
 The particles are put into a vacuum with a minimal amount of heat, which turns the ice into steam, leaving the ground particles dry and ready for use. 
 Freeze dried instant coffee is always more granular and chunky than instant coffee powder. 
 Caffeine is found in varying amounts in coffee (and tea), and is a stimulant which acts on the nervous system. 
 A small amount of coffee can be soothing and help relieve tiredness; it also sharpens the concentration. 
 Large amounts of strong coffee can cause insomnia and, in extreme cases, palpitations and irregular heartbeats. 
 Coffee is drunk at the end of a meal to act as a digestive stimulant. 
 Decaffeinated coffee is now widely available as beans or as instant coffee and is suitable for drinking by children and insomniacs and by people with heart conditions and high blood pressure, where caffeine can aggravate the symptoms. 
 Coffee decaffeinated by chemicals is generally thought to be as harmful as the beans containing caffeine, so always look  for the water processed decaffeinated coffee. 
 The price of the product will reflect the process used, water processing producing a better quality, purer coffee at a higher price. 
 The best coffee beans are of the arabica type and are low in caffeine. 
 Arabica beans are grown mainly in Brazil, Central America, Kenya and India and are the beans that are stocked by specialist delicatessens and coffee merchants. 
 Robusta beans have a more neutral flavour, a higher caffeine content and are used in commercially prepared blends and for the catering trade. 
 They are mainly from the West African coffee producing areas and Indonesia. 
 Liberica beans, from Liberia, are prolific but have little quality or flavour. 
 Raw coffee beans are green in colour and have no aroma. 
 Left unprocessed, they have a long storage life if kept dry. 
 To release the aroma and flavour of the coffee beans, they must be roasted, the process which also gives them their brown colouring. 
 The beans almost double in size during roasting. 
 Well roasted coffee beans are always brown &mdash; black beans are over roasted and will have a bitter flavour and insufficiently roasted beans are pale and give a colourless, tasteless drink. 
 As a general rule, the paler the roast the milder the coffee; darkly roasted coffees are more suitable for drinking black. 
 Once roasted, coffee will deteriorate quickly. 
 Coffee contains volatile gases which must not be lost after roasting if the beans are to have a good nose. 
 Many roasters now pack the beans warm from the roasting process in bags with a special filter which allows the beans to cool while preventing the volatile gases from escaping, taking much of the flavour of the beans with them. 
 If you wish to roast your own coffee, you should use the round peaberry beans from Kenya or Tanzania. 
 These round beans, one from each berry, give a more even roast than the usual split beans and may be roasted in a single layer in a heavy frying pan over a moderate heat. 
 They should be stirred constantly until they are the required colour. 
 Crack a cooled bean and check that it is evenly coloured throughout; if so, the beans are ready for immediate use of may be cooled and stored in an airtight jar. 
 Green peaberries are usually available only from specialist coffee merchants. 
 Hints on Making Coffee 
 * Grind the beans to suit your coffee maker, generally fine for filters and medium for cafeti&egrave;res and jugs. 
 If your coffee beans are ground for you in a shop, tell the retailer how you brew your coffee. 
 * Use 4 level 15ml/tbsp of ground coffee for each 500ml/1pt/2&frac12; cups water. 
 * Do not make coffee with boiling water. 
 Leave the boiled water for 10sec before pouring it onto the coffee. 
 * Reheating coffee is not recommended as it can develop a very bitter flavour.  
 The Most Popular Coffees 
 Many types of coffee are grown throughout the world, each with its own characteristics. 
 The following are the most widely available: 
 Brazilian 
 The Santos coffees are the best, gleaning their flavour from the iron-rich soil in which they are grown. 
 Bourbon Santos, the premier coffee, has a smooth flavour. 
 Lesser varieties are good in blends. 
 Brazil is the largest producer of coffee in the world. 
 Colombian 
 Characterful coffees, rich in flavour with high acidity, Colombian coffees blend well. 
 Excelso has a nutty flavour and Medellin is very fragrant. 
 Costa Rican 
 These high-grown coffees with a fine, mild, slightly nutty flavour, are usually drunk with milk. 
 Ethiopian 
 Wild Ethiopian coffee is spicy and blends well with a rich coffee such as Colombian or Javanese. 
 Ethiopian Mocha is the name given to the cultivated Harar coffees, which are gamey and ideal for drinking black after a meal. 
 Guatemalan 
 These mild, mellow coffees have a full flavour and fragrant bouquet. 
 Jamaican 
 The most famous Jamaican coffee, Blue Mountain, is grown high in very small quantities. 
 It is medium roasted to preserve its extremely mellow flavour. 
 A great favourite in the USA and Japan, the demand for this coffee has led to its very high price. 
 Two stamps to confirm the authenticity of the true Blue Mountain coffee have recently been introduced by the Coffee Industry Board of Jamaica to stop inferior coffees being sold as Blue Mountain. 
 Indian Mysore 
 , a full-bodied, smooth, rich coffee, has a distinctive flavour on its own and blends well with Mocha. 
 Javanese 
 The best Javanese coffees are strong with a fine acidity that is hardly noticeable. 
 Javanese blends well with Kenyan, Colombian or Mocha coffees. 
 Kenyan 
 are smooth, rounded coffees that drink well by themselves but are also very good for blending. 
 Mocha 
 Usually produced in the Yemen, Mocha coffee has a winey, gamey flavour. 
 It is a good after-dinner coffee, but is also very good for blending. 
 Coffee is also sold according to its roast &mdash; for example, French Roast is a strong dark roast while Italian Roast is a very dark or double roast. 
 These continental roasts often have chicory added to them.  
 A selection of teas and coffees; the large cafeti&egrave;re on the right contains jasmine tea 
 TEAS &amp; Tisanes 
 Tea is without doubt the world's most popular drink. 
 Whether accompanied by a light meal of sandwiches and cake served in a cosy sitting room in front of a fire, or somewhere as elegant as the Ritz, a cup of tea is part of the English way of life and the tea ceremonies of all the Orient are equally famed. 
 TYPES OF TEA 
 There are basically only two types of tea: green and black. 
 Green tea comes from leaves that have been withered and dried immediately after picking to preserve their fresh green colour and light, scented qualities. 
 These teas are mostly from China or Japan. 
 Black tea is perhaps more familiar to most people; the withered leaves are left to fully oxidise (ferment naturally) to the familiar dark brown colour before they are dried. 
 CHOOSING A TEA 
 This may be to suit you or your mood or the time of day. 
 The great thing about tea drinking is that so many varieties are available that you can always find a brew that is appropriate to the occasion. 
 I like to wake up to a cup of Assam, a very robust tea, or a strong blend of African and Indian teas of the type that makes a good English breakfast blend; in the evening I prefer to drink Keemun or Lapsang Souchong. 
 Teas should be savoured and the following brief descriptions may encourage you to try something deliciously different. 
 Assam 
 Robust is certainly the description of this very big Indian tea. 
 It may be just a little too strong for some people. 
 Ceylon 
 A slightly fragrant tea of good character for all-round drinking. 
 All teas grown in Sri Lanka have retained the name Ceylon. 
 Darjeeling 
 Known as the champagne tea and highly regarded for afternoon drinking. 
 It is grown very high in the foothills of the Himalayas and has a light grapy flavour, although I find it can become slightly acidic if brewed for too long. 
 Earl Grey 
 Legend has it that the mandarin was so grateful to Earl Grey for services rendered that he gave him his secret tea recipe, to keep mind, body and spirit together in perfect harmony. 
 As no tea  was grown in India during Earl Grey's lifetime, it is obvious that this was purely China tea flavoured with oil of bergamot. 
 In the past, many tea companies have included other teas in the blend, but more and more now seem to be reverting to pure China tea for this popular flavoured brew. 
 English Breakfast 
 A strong, refreshing blend of African and Indian teas, although Ceylon may sometimes be included. 
 Formosa Oolong 
 A semi-fermented or oxidised tea with a delicate flavour. 
 It is difficult to find this tea, but it is worth looking for. 
 Gunpowder 
 A green China tea of moderate flavour but with a spectacular visual effect as the leaves &bquo;explode&equo; in the pot to an enormous size. 
 Irish 
 I am often asked for this but it is difficult to obtain. 
 Basically, it is a very strong blend of Assam and Ceylon teas. 
 Jasmine 
 A summer afternoon tea and known as the tea most often served in Chinese restaurants. 
 It may be black or green tea flavoured with jasmine flowers, is very fragrant and is always drunk without milk. 
 Japanese 
 I was recently given some Japanese tea to try. 
 It is a large leaf green tea with a very delicate flavour, sometimes enhanced by the addition of toasted rice grains &mdash; delicious. 
 Keemun 
 A most agreeable China tea for any palate and good with or without milk. 
 It is weak but flavoursome. 
 Kenyan 
 Dark and refreshing, it makes a strong cup of tea with plenty of flavour. 
 African teas are also grown in Uganda, but the Kenyan variety is more often sold unblended. 
 Lapsang Souchong 
 The most common of the smoked teas, it is smoked over burning bamboo roots. 
 It is an acquired taste but very refreshing. 
 Flavoured teas 
 These are becoming more popular and are generally Indian and/or African teas blended with fruit blossoms or oils, or spices. 
 The most popular include apricot, blackcurrant, cinnamon, lemon and orange, passion fruit, peach and spice. 
 They may be drunk with or without milk. 
 Tea in History 
 This and the following div2 actually appear on p. 36 
 Tea is the leaf from the plant Camellia sinensis  which is native to Assam, China and Japan. 
 The bush is now grown in other tropical areas that have a sufficiently warm, wet climate. 
 Like coffee, legend surrounds the beginning of tea drinking and it is also reputed to have kept awake an ancient priest throughout a long vigil, stimulating him with its caffeine. 
 We do, however, know that tea was valued and enjoyed in China and Japan for many centuries, long before it was introduced to India, Ceylon and Africa. 
 It was brought to Europe and England in the seventeenth century, arriving on our shores from Holland via the East India Trading Company. 
 The colonists in North America were encouraged to partake of the new refreshment but were taxed on tea and other imports from 1765 onwards, which led to a trade in tea smuggling from Holland to avoid the taxes. 
 The East India Company later gained a monopoly to deal with the North Americans, but resentment caused the colonists to rebel against the traders and at the Boston Tea Party, the shipment of tea was thrown into the harbour by the rebels. 
 Tea is not grown in the United States and, even today, most Americans prefer coffee. 
 Harvesting &amp; Processing Tea 
 Only the top two leaves of the plant and the bud are harvested for making into tea. 
 This is often referred to as pekoe, meaning the downy part of the shrub that is of the best quality. 
 These have to harvested by hand, like coffee, as mechanised picking would lacerate the plant and produce a much inferior product. 
 The time of harvesting also affects the final quality of the tea, the best teas being collected during the peak season and the more standard teas during the remaining months of the year. 
 All teas are dried before use and are graded when dried &mdash; generally the larger the leaf the better quality the tea. 
 The terms Orange Pekoe and Broken Orange Pekoe refer to the size of the leaf and not to chopped orange peel included in the pack! 
 The Perfect Cuppa 
 * Tea is often dull if the brewing is rushed. 
 * Always warm the pot with hot water before making the tea. 
 * Tea should always be made in a china tea-pot &mdash; metal pots will taint the brew. 
 * Always pour boiling water onto the tea &mdash; freshly boiled water will always make the best drink. 
 * Tea should be allowed to brew for 4&ndash;5min &mdash; frenzied stirring of leaves and bashing of bags forces the flavour and emphasises the tannin. 
 * I always think that it is best to pour the tea onto milk in the cup as this distributes the milk more evenly &mdash; it also seems to produce a better colour. 
 * Sugar is, of course, a matter of taste but it can annihilate the more delicate flavours of green teas. 
 * I always think that it is better to make a fresh pot of tea than to top up the old pot. 
 Loose Tea or Bags? 
 For many years it was considered that tea-bags were filled only with tea dust, the fine residue left after the sorting and packaging of tea, and that the drink obtained by using bags was therefore of very inferior quality. 
 This is no longer true and tea-bags are now available containing teas from selected estates according to the best crop available at the time of packing. 
 These teas are unblended and have strong, distinctive flavours &mdash; one bag will often produce a pot of tea for two people. 
 It is now a matter of personal preference as to whether you use loose tea of speciality tea-bags. 
 Decaffeinated Teas &amp; Tissanes 
 Some teas are now available with the caffeine removed and these appeal to people who find ordinary tea too much of a stimulant, perhaps disturbing their sleep at night or generally upsetting their metabolism. 
 It is not advisable to give tea to very young children because of the caffeine content. 
 Herbal teas or tisanes are also very popular with those who cannot tolerate caffeine. 
 They are produced from flowers and other plants, are brewed with boiling water in the same way as tea and usually drunk without milk. 
 Probably the most popular varieties are camomile and rosehip, but lime, mint, apple mint and mixed fruit are also easily available. 
 Some of the best established tea companies are now entering the herbal tea market, offering blends for evening and morning drinking.  
 FINGERS ON THE PULSE 
 Many people wander into my delicatessen thinking that it is an up-market health-food shop. 
 In may respects, my shop is just the opposite, although I certainly have a health foods section, as do many delicatessens. 
 In addition to dried beans and pulse vegetables, I stock several varieties of canned beans which are always very popular for salads and quick meals, where there is no time (or the customer forgot!) to soak dried pulses. 
 I certainly sell more red lentils than any other dried pulse, probably because they are the only variety that does not require soaking before cooking and are therefore the most convenient. 
 A delicatessen will usually also have a good selection of nuts &mdash; Brazils, pecans, pistachios, walnuts and cashews &mdash; all of which are invaluable in a vegetarian diet. 
 Lentils are either red, green or beige/brown. 
 Red lentils are the easiest and quickest to cook; although the green or brown varieties have more flavour, they do require soaking. 
 Red lentil dhal is a popular side dish for Indian meals, being rather bland and having the effect of cooling the heat of the curry. 
 Split peas are either yellow or green; the green variety is more difficult to find but has a fuller flavour than the yellow and is therefore worth looking out for. 
 Both types are good in soups and for thickening casseroles. 
 Chick peas have a deliciously nutty flavour and are excellent for vegetarian casseroles and salads, as well as being the basis for hummus, a very popular Mediterranean dip. 
 For bean cuisine there are many varieties, differing in shape and colour, but only very slightly in flavour. 
 My favourites tend to be the beans that have a flavour of their own, especially flageolet beans which are a delicate green colour and have a subtle, fresh flavour; they are, however, rather more expensive than any of the other varieties. 
 Mung beans are very small green beans that can easily be sprouted at home for use as a salad vegetable. 
 The slightly larger burnished red aduki beans are nutty and combine well with orange in casseroles or salads. 
 Haricot beans are surely the most popular beans in the world, as it is these that are coated in tomato sauce to make baked beans. 
 Of the remaining varieties, red kidney beans are the most widely known, being a vital ingredient in chilli con carne, which strikes me as being second only to ham, egg and chips on the standard pub menu! 
 This is all wrong, as chilli should really be made with pinto beans, a member of the kidney bean family. 
 Pinto beans are a rather unattractive, dull brown colour, which is why they are generally replaced with the more attractive red beans. 
 Pinto beans have the distinction of being one of the quickest beans to cook. 
 Borlotti beans are similar to pintos, but a little larger and somewhat redder in colour. 
 I have made a selection of my favourite bean cuisine recipes that include dried and canned pulses. 
 Some are main courses and some are salads. 
 All are delicious and are well worth trying, whether you are vegetarian or not.  
 Kidney Bean Tartlets 
 Serves 4 (see p39) 
 The combination of a pulse vegetable and pastry provides a substantial supper dish. 
 Eat these kidney bean tartlets with freshly cooked vegetables or a side salad. 
 175g/6oz/1&frac12; cups wholewheat flour 75g/3oz butter or margarine 4 &times; 15ml/tbsp canned red kidney beans, drained 40g/1&amp;oz Cheddar cheese, finely grated 125ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cup milk 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp creamed sun-dried tomatoes with chilli (optional) 1 egg, beaten salt and pepper 
 1. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 6/200&deg;C/400&deg;F. 
 Lightly oil four individual quiche tins. 
 2. 
 Place the flour in a bowl and rub in the butter or margarine until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs. 
 Add sufficient warm water to mix to a firm dough, then lightly knead and roll out the pastry. 
 Use to line the prepared quiche tins. 
 3. 
 Place a spoonful of beans in the bottom of each tin. 
 Sprinkle the cheese over the beans. 
 4. 
 Beat together the milk, sun-dried tomatoes (if used), egg, salt and pepper. 
 Pour the mixture into the four tins. 
 5. 
 Bake in the pre-heated oven for 10min. 
 Reduce the heat to gas mark 5/190&amp;C/375&amp;F and cook for a further 15&ndash;20min, until the quiches are set. 
 6. 
 Allow to cool slightly, then serve warm, or cool completely and serve cold with salad. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Always mix wholewheat pastry with warm water to help the dough to bind together. 
 Do not use breadmaking flour for pastry as it is far too coarse. 
 Use a fine pastry flour or an &bquo;85%&equo; flour which has the coarsest of the bran removed. 
 Spicy Sausage Beans 
 Serves 4 (see p39) 
 This supper dish may be simmered gently on the hob or baked in the oven &mdash; yes, baked beans! 
 It is surprising how many men enjoy cooking their own baked beans. 
 It was one of the first recipes that my husband attempted in his bachelor days. 
 225g/8oz haricot beans 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp oil 1 onion, chopped 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp molasses 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp tomato pur&eacute;e 2 &times; 5ml/tsp dry mustard powder 1 &times; 5ml/tsp salt 225g/8oz spicy sausage, eg Chorizo, thickly sliced freshly ground black pepper 
 1. 
 Place the beans in a large bowl, cover with plenty of water and leave to soak for at least 8hr. 
 Drain the beans and rinse well. 
 2. 
 Add the beans to a large saucepan of boiling water and boil rapidly for 10min. 
 Remove from the heat and leave until required. 
 3. 
 Heat the oil in a large pan, add the onion and cook covered for 4&ndash;5min over a moderate heat. 
 4. 
 Drain the beans and add them to the onion with the molasses, tomato pur&eacute;e, mustard powder, Worcestershire sauce and salt. 
 Add sufficient water to cover the beans and simmer slowly for 45min, until the beans are just tender. 
 5. 
 Add the sliced sausage to the pan and cook for a further 15min. 
 6. 
 Season the dish to taste and serve immediately with freshly cooked vegetables or a green salad. 
 COOK'S NOTE: If you prefer to cook the beans in the oven, do so at gas mark 3/160&amp;C/325&amp;F for approximately 1hr. 
 Borlotti Bean Salad 
 Serves 6 
 Borlotti beans look like dark-skinned pinto beans. 
 Both types belong to the kidney bean family and have a slightly nutty flavour. 
 I have never seen dried borlotti beans but they are available canned and are very good in salads. 
 This one is a particular favourite with my catering business. 
 1 &times; 400g/14oz can borlotti beans, drained and rinsed 1 &times; 400g/14oz can red kidney beans, drained and rinsed 6&ndash;8 small dill cucumber pickles, diced 175g/6oz cherry tomatoes 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped mixed herbs 6 &times; 15ml/tbsp vinaigrette dressing (see p31)  
 1. 
 Place the borlotti and kidney beans together in a large bowl, then add the dill pickles, tomatoes and herbs. 
 2. 
 Pour the vinaigrette over the salad and toss well. 
 Chill in the refrigerator for at least 1hr, then toss again before serving. 
 Warm Bean &amp; Mushroom Salad 
 Serves 4 (see p39) 
 Warm salads became very fashionable in the days of nouvelle cuisine. 
 They make ideal starters as a warm dish always makes your guests feel that you have made an effort, yet they are very quick and easy to prepare. 
 1 &times; 400g/14oz can flageolet beans, drained 75g/3oz ham, chopped or shredded 125g/4oz cherry tomatoes, halved 50g/2oz butter 1&ndash;2 cloves garlic, crushed salt and freshly ground black pepper 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped parsley 125g/4oz small button mushrooms lettuce, radichio or spinach leaves for serving 
 1. 
 Place the flageolet beans, ham and cherry tomatoes in a bowl and toss together until well mixed. 
 2. 
 Melt the butter in a saucepan or a microwave dish, add the garlic and mushrooms and cook for 2&ndash;3min, until just soft. 
 3. 
 Season with salt and pepper to taste, then add the freshly chopped parsley. 
 4. 
 Pour the mushrooms and garlic butter over the beans and toss gently. 
 Serve immediately on a bed of lettuce, radichio or raw spinach.  
 ( front to back ) Warm Bean &amp; Mushroom Salad; Spicy Sausage Beans; Kidney Bean Tartlets 
 OL&Eacute; FOR OLIVES! 
 Olives are grown in many Mediterranean countries, where they have been cultivated for centuries and have been an important trading crop since ancient times. 
 They are either green or black, the green varieties being the unripened fruits of the same trees that produce the fully ripened black olives. 
 Olive oils are described on p29, so I am concentrating here on olives for eating. 
 Many varieties of olives are available, either plain or stuffed with almonds, anchovies or pimentos. 
 It is also possible to produce delicious cocktail snacks by marinating olives at home in a mixture of herbs and spices. 
 Olives are grown either to eat or to be made into olive oil. 
 Most of the world's production comes from Spain and Italy, although Greece and France also grow large quantities. 
 The Spanish influence in Central America is reflected in the wide use of olives in Mexican food and some crops are grown in Mexico and on the west coast of the USA. 
 Like the vine, olives have recently been cultivated successfully in southern Australia. 
 Preparing Olives For The Table 
 There are very few varieties of olives that would be suitable for eating straight from the trees as the fruits, especially the unripened green olives, are usually very bitter. 
 Green olives have to be treated in a soda solution to soften them before they are ready for pickling in brine. 
 Black olives, being fully ripened, are naturally sweeter and are usually sold preserved in brine or olive oil. 
 I think it is fair to say that the really top quality olives are usually sold in oil rather than in brine. 
 Prepared Olives 
 Olives are sold with or without stones, which are removed commercially by machine. 
 They are most frequently stuffed with bright red pimentos, providing an eye-catching garnish and a good ingredient for adding to stews and casseroles. 
 Also popular are almond-stuffed olives (although I always think the nuts suffer for being in the pickling brine) and those filled with tiny pieces of anchovy, which balance the flavour of the fruits beautifully. 
 Tips for Buying Olives 
 Green olives 
 Mainly from Spain and France, the variety to look for is the Spanish Manzanilla olive which has a fine texture and flavour. 
 Queen olives are larger and tend to be a little darker in colour and stronger in flavour. 
 Black olives 
 These can be black or red, the red varieties coming from Greece where the best are the Kalamata olives. 
 My preference in black olives are those from Provence, France, which are tossed in olive oil and flavoured with the herbs of the region &mdash; rich, strong and flavoursome. 
 Storing Olives 
 If you return from holiday with a large quantity of olives, they will survive longer if they are kept in a dark place, so that the light cannot cause any fermentation in the brine. 
 Mould growth will also be retarded by adding a slice of lemon to the preserving liquid. 
 I prefer to rinse the olives well if they have been bottled in brine and then to toss them in a little olive oil and leave for an hour or two before serving. 
 Plucked straight from the brine, the flavour of the olives can be overpowered by the salt. 
 Marinated Green Olives 
 450g/1lb pitted green olives 2 cloves garlic, crushed 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped dill 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 1 lemon, grated rind and juice 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp coriander seeds, lightly crushed 
 1. 
 If the olives have been stored in brine, rinse them well in running water, then pat them dry on kitchen paper. 
 2. 
 Place the olives in a bowl and add all the remaining ingredients. 
 Leave for at least 4hr, stirring once or twice. 
 3. 
 Serve with drinks or as required. 
 4. 
 Store the olives in a covered container in the refrigerator. 
 They should last at least a week.  
 Pork &amp; Olive Casserole 
 Serves 6 (see p43) 
 25g/1oz butter 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 1 large onion, finely sliced 2 cloves garlic, crushed 1,600g/3&frac12;lb boneless shoulder of pork, cut into 4cm/1&frac12;in dice 185g/6&amp;oz can pimentos 200g/7oz pack pimento stuffed olives, drained (approx 125g/4oz) 400g/14ox can chopped tomatoes 1 &times; 5ml/tsp paprika 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp tomato paste salt and freshly ground black pepper sugar to taste, if required 
 1. 
 Heat the butter and the olive oil together in a large heavy saucepan or casserole dish, until the butter has melted. 
 Add the onion and garlic and cook slowly, covered, for about 10min, until well softened and browned. 
 Stir once or twice. 
 2. 
 Add the diced pork and brown on all sides. 
 3. 
 Remove the pimentos from the can and slice them. 
 Add to the pan with the juice from the can, the drained olives, chopped tomatoes, paprika, tomato paste, salt and pepper. 
 4. 
 Cover the pan and simmer the casserole very slowly for 1&amp;&ndash;2hr, until the meat is tender. 
 5. 
 If the casserole is still quite liquid, remove the lid from the pan and simmer more quickly until the sauce is reduced. 
 6. 
 Season to taste and add the sugar if required.  
 ( l to r ) Black olives with Herbes de Provence; green olives with anchovy; Greek Kalamata olives; Manzanilla olives with almonds; Pork &amp; Olive Casserole; marinated olives 
 AN ENERGETIC  CAPER! 
 It seems to me that few people have anything pleasant to say about capers, but I love them. 
 They have a unique flavour and need only to be used sparingly to enliven the dullest of dishes. 
 It is a commonly held fallacy that the caper is the pickled seed of the nasturtium plant, although it is easy to see how this theory may have developed, as they are very similar in shape and are from a spreading plant of a very similar habit. 
 Nasturtium seeds are edible and are known as &bquo;poor man's capers&equo;. 
 Growth &amp; Harvesting 
 Capers are the unopened flower buds of the plant Capparis spinosa  which has a low, trailing habit and grows abundantly in the wild, although it is cultivated extensively in Mediterranean countries, especially Spain and France, where the export of capers is a lucrative business. 
 In the wild the plant is valued because its roots tend to anchor the otherwise loose soil and the autumnal leaf fall from the plants further helps the soil by fertilising it. 
 Capers tend to be expensive because they must be harvested by hand. 
 The smallest varieties are the most prized, so the plants have to be picked over every two or three days to prevent the buds from becoming either too large or opening into flowers. 
 The capers are usually pickled in a white wine vinegar to preserve them. 
 If the flavour of this solution is too strong, they may be soaked in milk before use. 
 Caper Berries 
 The Spanish are now promoting the use of the caper berry, the fruit that is produced after the plant has flowered, as a garnish for both food and drinks. 
 These are fleshy fruits about the size of a small olive. 
 We will have to wait and see whether caper berries take over when fromage frais and raspberry vinegar are exhausted. 
 Cooking with Capers 
 Capers are often used to garnish cocktail savouries and canap&eacute;s. 
 Added to a simple white sauce, they make a good accompaniment to plain meats such as boiled bacon. 
 They also lend a delicious flavour when added to cheap cuts of stewing lamb with caraway seeds, especially if the sauce is finished by the addition of a little soured cream.  
 Lamp &amp; Caper Pies 
 Makes 4 individual pies 
 This is a very tasty way of using up any left-overs after a meal of roast lamb. 
 Leeks always combine well with lamb and the addition of capers make these pies just that extra bit special. 
 40g/1&frac12;oz butter or margarine 40g/1&amp;oz flour 375ml/15fl oz/2 cups milk salt and pepper 450g/1lb leeks, sliced, cooked and drained 325g/12oz cooked lamb, cut into small pieces 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp capers 225g/8oz/2 cups plain flour 1&ndash;2 &times; 5ml/tsp caraway seeds 125g/4oz butter or margarine water to mix beaten egg to glaze, if required 
 1. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 5/190&deg;C/375&deg;F. 
 2. 
 Prepare a white sauce by melting the butter in a pan, then adding the flour. 
 Cook the roux paste for a few seconds, then gradually add the milk. 
 Bring to the boil, stirring continuously, then remove from the heat and season to taste. 
 (This sauce may be prepared in the microwave cooker.) 
 3. 
 Add the leeks, lamb and capers to the sauce and divide the mixture between four individual pie dishes. 
 4. 
 Mix together the flour and caraway seeds in a large bowl, then rub in the butter or margarine until the mixture resembles fine breadcrumbs. 
 Mix to a firm dough with cold water. 
 5. 
 Knead the pastry lightly on a floured board, then roll out and use to cover the pie dishes. 
 Use any pastry scraps to decorate the pies and glaze with beaten egg if required. 
 6. 
 Bake in the pre-heated oven for 25min, or until the pastry is golden brown. 
 Serve with freshly cooked vegetables or a side salad. 
 Spanish Potato Salad 
 Serves 4 
 450g/1lb cold boiled potatoes 400g/1lb can artichoke hearts, drained and halved 4 tomatoes, seeded and chopped 125g/4oz cooked peas 125ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cup mayonnaise 125ml/5fl oz/&amp; cup natural yogurt 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp capers salt and pepper 
 1. 
 Chop the potatoes into bite-sized pieces and place in a large bowl with the artichoke hearts, tomatoes and peas. 
 2. 
 Mix together the mayonnaise and yogurt and pour over the vegetables. 
 Scatter the capers over and add a little salt and pepper, then toss all the ingredients together. 
 3. 
 Chill, then serve as required. 
 Skate with Black Butter 
 This is the classic way of serving skate. 
 It may be poached in water or stock, but I prefer to cook it in the microwave, then coat it with the black butter. 
 For two wings of skate you will need: 
 50g/2oz butter 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp white wine vinegar 2 &times; 5ml/tsp capers 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped parsley 
 1. 
 Heat the butter in a pan until it is lightly browned. 
 Add the vinegar and capers and cook for a further 2&ndash;3min. 
 2. 
 Pour the butter over the cooked skate and sprinkle with the chopped parsley. 
 Serve immediately. 
 Tartare Sauce 
 Serves 6 
 This is a classic sauce to serve with fish. 
 It is so simple to make that, provided you have all the ingredients, I cannot imagine why anyone ever buys the ready-prepared varieties. 
 125ml/5fl oz/&amp; cup mayonnaise 1 &times; 5ml/tsp freshly chopped tarragon or chives 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp chopped capers 2 &times; 5ml/tsp chopped gherkins 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped parsley 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp lemon juice or tarragon vinegar 
 1. 
 Blend all the ingredients together in a bowl and leave in the refrigerator for at least 1hr to allow the flavours to blend together. 
 2. 
 Serve with any fried or poached fish.  
 front to back  Spanish Potato Salad with Capers; Skate with Black Butter; Lamb &amp; Caper Pies; Tartare Sauce 
 SALT &amp; PEPPER 
 The Essential Seasonings 
 Salt and pepper are the two most common seasonings in cooking and are taken very much for granted. 
 They have been used for thousands of years, one of the earliest references to salt being in the Old Testament when Lot's wife was turned to salt in the desert. 
 SALT FROM THE SEA 
 Salt (sodium chloride) is a flavour enhancer and is used in many recipes, both savoury and sweet. 
 A pinch of salt is taken for granted in many cake recipes and is added simply to bring out the flavour of the other ingredients. 
 Salt is effective by stimulating the taste buds of the tongue and making them aware of the basic tastes of the food being eaten. 
 Although the seasoning of foods is a very personal matter, I believe that it is preferable to add salt during cooking to benefit the developing flavours and not at the table, where the tongue will distinguish the undissolved salt added to the food. 
 Salt has received much bad publicity in recent years as a major contributory factor to heart disease, but the initial hysteria has now given way to the theory that salt in quantity will only be to the detriment of those people prone to heart disease from other causes. 
 Products labelled &bquo;table&equo; or &bquo;cooking&equo; salt usually contain chemicals and anti-caking agents to ensure free-flow from the drum in which they are packed, giving rise to famous advertising slogans such as &bquo;Everyone knows Saxa flows&equo; and &bquo;When it rains, it pours&equo;. 
 The more natural rock, sea and Maldon salts are completely with additives. 
 Maldon salt is a trade name for sea salt from the many inlets on the Essex coast. 
 All sea salts are produced in shallow beds where salt is deposited by the ebbing tide and most of the remaining moisture is evaporated by sun and wind. 
 Each successive tide dissolves the salt and deposits more, forming pools of highly concentrated saline. 
 The saline is eventually filtered and then heated in shallow pans to complete the evaporation process before the salt is left to crystallise. 
 Sea salt is usually available in coarse or fine grades and is best used from a salt mill as a condiment. 
 Unmilled salts dissolve quickly in cooking liquors. 
 Rock salt is the land equivalent of sea salt, having been deposited when the sea covered the area in a previous age. 
 It is mined, then washed, filtered and artificially evaporated before being left to crystallise. 
  Salt has been used for many centuries as a preservative, whereby it is left on food to withdraw the moisture present by the process of osmosis. 
 The salt retains the extracted moisture, thus inhibiting the growth of bacteria which require moisture to flourish in the food. 
 Before refrigeration, salting was about the only process reliable enough to preserve meat. 
 The same principle is still used, to a lesser degree, where vegetables containing bitter juices, such as aubergines and courgettes, are sprinkled with salt and then left until the juices have been drawn from the flesh. 
 Vegetables treated in this way must be washed very thoroughly before use to remove both the extracted juices and the surplus salt. 
 Saltpetre, or potassium nitrate, is a preserving salt usually available only at a chemist's or pharmacy and is most commonly used to preserve the pink colour of pickled or salt beef. 
 It is used in processed ham and bacon; also to preserve the pink colour of the meat. 
 The mineral traces in unrefined salt can sometimes affect the foods with which they are used. 
 The mineral to be most wary of is calcium, which can toughen some grains when used during cooking. 
 It is most commonly known to affect brown rice and sweetcorn during cooking. 
 Stock cubes should always be checked for their salt and calcium content before they are used with brown rice, and sweetcorn should always be cooked without salt. 
 PEPPERCORNS &mdash; VARIETY IN COLOUR AND FLAVOUR 
 Black and white peppercorns are well known to all cooks, but any good delicatessen should also stock green peppercorns, both dried and pickled in brine, and pink pepper berries. 
 Some delicatessens will also stock a mixture of dried corns of varying colours &mdash; not always natural &mdash; which look most attractive in an acrylic peppermill. 
 Peppercorns, which are harvested from a vine-like plant some 3&frac12;m/12ft high, Piper nigrum , were originally grown in India and south-east Asia, although they are now widely cultivated in other tropical areas such as Madagascar and the West Indies. 
 The peppercorn was valued very highly and was frequently used in trade between the East and the West. 
 The term &bquo;peppercorn rent&equo; related to the time when the spice commanded a high price, although such a charge nowadays is generally disregarded. 
 The stage at which the peppercorns are harvested from the vine decides their colour. 
 Black peppercorns 
 are the unripe, green berries which have been allowed to dry and blacken in the sun after picking. 
 My favourite black pepper is the telicherry berry, which is hot and pungent and excellent for general cooking and for use whole in marinades. 
 Green, or unripe, peppercorns 
 are available both commercially dried and pickled in brine. 
 The latter are the hottest, the dried berries having a more subtle flavour. 
 Green peppercorns can be used in place of the more traditional black for Steak au poivre, and also look most attractive when used sparingly with fish. 
 White pepper 
 is milder than black and is best used with fish, white meats and delicate sauces, where both the flavour and appearance of black pepper would be inappropriate. 
 The white berries are obtained by rubbing the reddish-black skin from peppercorns left on the vine until they are ripe. 
 The resulting white peppercorn is then dried. 
 Pink pepperberries 
 are not true peppercorns. 
 They should not be used in any quantity as they can cause stomach upsets, but are extremely useful for the presentation of nouvelle cuisine dishes. 
 They are purchased in brine and are less pungent and slightly sweeter than true peppercorns. 
 I find them useful for flavouring game pies. 
 Mixed peppercorns 
 look attractive and combine a variety of flavours and heats. 
 They are sometimes mixed with other spices, such as allspice or coriander seeds, for a table condiment. 
 Plain mixed peppercorns make an excellent flavouring for venison.  
 Venison with Mixed Peppercorns 
 Serves 6 
 675g/1&amp;lb venison, boned forequarter, diced 
 MARINADE 
 1 large onion, sliced 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp red wine or blackcurrant vinegar 4 juniper berries 4 black peppercorns 4 white peppercorns 4 green peppercorns 1 bay leaf 250ml/10fl oz/1&frac14; cups red wine, approx 
 CASSEROLE 
 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 1 large onion, finely sliced 225g/8oz green bacon, diced 25g/1oz wholewheat flour bay leaf 4 black peppercorns 4 white peppercorns 4 green peppercorns 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp tomato pur&eacute;e 250ml/10fl oz/1&amp; cups red wine 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp redcurrant jelly salt 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp Demerara sugar freshly chopped parsley to garnish 
 1. 
 Place the venison in a large bowl with all the ingredients for the marinade. 
 Stir well and add sufficient red wine to cover the meat. 
 Cover and leave in the refrigerator for at least 24hr, stirring occasionally. 
 Drain the meat from the marinade. 
 2. 
 Heat the oil in a large casserole dish or saucepan, add the onion, cover and cook over a moderate heat until softened and transparent, about 5min. 
 3. 
 Add the bacon and venison and cook quickly for a few minutes, stirring frequently, to seal the meat. 
 4. 
 Sprinkle the flour into the pan and stir thoroughly. 
 Add all the remaining ingredients except the redcurrant jelly and sugar. 
 Add sufficient wine to cover the ingredients. 
 Cover and cook in the pre-heated oven for 3&frac12;&ndash;4hr, until the venison is cooked and tender. 
 5. 
 Add the redcurrant jelly and season to taste with salt and sugar. 
 6. 
 Serve the venison, garnished with freshly chopped parsley. 
 Steak au Poivre 
 Serves 2 
 Steak au poivre is traditionally served in a rich sauce of brandy and cream. 
 This recipe gives the option of choosing the traditional sauce, or one using green peppercorns, red wine and yogurt for a lighter but very hot variation. 
 2 steaks, size and cut to suit your pocket 2&ndash;3 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 3 &times; 5ml/tsp black peppercorns 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp brandy 125ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cup double or thick cream salt 
 1. 
 Brush the steaks with the oil. 
 Crush the peppercorns coarsely, then press into the surface of the steaks. 
 Leave the meat for as long as possible before cooking. 
 2. 
 Heat a large, heavy frying-pan on the hob. 
 Brown the steaks quickly on both sides, then cook to the required state. 
 No extra fat should be required to stop the steaks from sticking to the pan. 
 3. 
 Transfer the meat to warmed plates. 
 Add the brandy to the meat juices and heat for a few seconds before igniting. 
 Allow the flames to die down with the pan off the heat. 
 4. 
 Slowly stir the cream into the pan, then heat gently until warm, but do not allow the cream to boil. 
 Season to taste with salt, then serve over the steaks. 
 To vary, use drained green peppercorns in brine. 
 After cooking these steaks, add 125ml/5fl oz/&amp; cup red wine to the pan, then boil rapidly until the wine is well reduced. 
 Remove the pan from the heat and stir 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp strained Greek yogurt into the sauce. 
 Whisk until the yogurt is incorporated, season with salt, then serve over the steaks.  
 FAR EASTERN PROMISE 
 Supermarket and delicatessen shelves are often stocked with many interesting tins and bottles of sauces that conjure up the promise of the Orient with their exotic names. 
 To attempt to summarise the cookery of the Far East in two or three paragraphs would be impossible, so I will limit myself to a brief description of some of the more readily available Oriental foods, and an Eastern style recipe for the buffet table which is always very popular in my catering business. 
 Bamboo shoots 
 After water chestnuts, I think these are the most successful of the canned vegetables for Oriental cookery. 
 They are flat strips cut from young shoots of the bamboo plant and can be eaten straight from the tin or stir fried. 
 Bean sprouts 
 The canned variety tends to be mushy and should therefore be avoided. 
 This is the one unusual Chinese vegetable that is available fresh almost everywhere. 
 Black beans 
 These are used in many Eastern dishes, either whole or made into a sauce. 
 Black beans are used extensively in Cantonese cookery and are usually served with fish or beef. 
 They are fermented and, consequently, have a strong flavour, being mixed with soya sauce and salt. 
 The sauce is milder than the canned beans. 
 Chinese egg noodles 
 These are used in many Oriental dishes, but are also useful for store-cupboard cookery. 
 The noodles are very thin and simply require boiling water to be poured over them and should then be left to steep for 3&ndash;4min. 
 They can be added to stir-fry vegetables at the end of cooking or served as an accompaniment. 
 Hoisin 
 A Chinese barbecue, sweet and sour sauce. 
 Ketjap manis 
 A sweet soya sauce used in Indonesian cookery. 
 Mie noodles 
 Flat egg noodles, similar to egg pasta, mie noodles cook quickly and have a good flavour and texture. 
 They are particularly favoured for Indonesian and Thai cookery, but are used throughout the Orient.  
 Sambals 
 The Oriental equivalent to chutneys, sambals are strong relishes for serving with Oriental foods, often based on amazingly hot peppers. 
 Soya sauce 
 A thin salty sauce used as the main condiment throughout the Far East, virtually replacing dry salt. 
 It is made from fermented soya beans and the whole process of producing the sauce should take at least a year. 
 Lesser sauces have sugar added to speed the fermentation process, so look for tamari, which is always naturally fermented. 
 Other grains and flakes can be added to the basic sauce during fermentation for extra flavour &mdash; for example, wheat and soya-bean flakes are added to shoyu. 
 All soya sauces provide invaluable seasoning to strict vegetarian diets that are based mainly on relatively bland grains. 
 Teriyaki 
 A marinade based on soya sauce but with the addition of Tabasco sauce, sherry and sugar. 
 It is rounder and more pungent than soya sauce. 
 Tofu 
 Widely used in Eastern cookery and in strict vegetarian diets in other parts of the world, tofu is bean curd and can be eaten cold or cooked in a number of ways. 
 It is a valuable vegetable protein. 
 Tofu is available fresh or in long-life packs; the fresh variety has a firmer texture. 
 Water chestnuts 
 A tuber, similar to Jerusalem artichokes in habit, that is grown in the East Indies, China and Japan. 
 Water chestnuts are very crisp and are used for texture as much as flavour. 
 They are sold canned but, being dense in texture, do not lose their crispness, even when cooked. 
 COOKING WITH A WOK 
 The wok is used for the majority of Eastern cookery. 
 It has sloping sides and a small base to allow maximum heat over the maximum possible surface area, thus encouraging quick and even cooking. 
 Woks are best used over a gas flame. 
 The very best oil to use in a wok is sesame oil which is pungent and flavoursome. 
 The best alternative is peanut oil which is light but fairly full-flavoured. 
 Cook food in the base of the wok, and then pull the food up the sides to keep warm whilst adding more to the base of the pan. 
 Oriental Beef 
 Serves 20 as part of a buffet (opposite) 
 This provides an excellent contrast to the more usual turkey and chicken dishes to be found on cold buffet tables, in much the same way as pastrami enlivens a plate of cold sliced meats. 
 Oriental Beef is very strongly flavoured and your guests will not require very much of it. 
 It is stunning to look at and should be served cold with a rice salad. 
 1,350g/3lb cooked beef, thickly sliced and cut into strips 250ml/10fl oz/1&frac14; cups teriyaki 4 &times; 15ml/tbsp sesame or peanut oil 2 red peppers, seeded and cut into strips 2 green peppers, seeded and cut into strips 1 large bunch spring onions, finely chopped 1 &times; 170g/6oz can black beans 1 &times; 225g/8oz can water chestnuts, drained 1 &times; 225g/8oz can bamboo shoots, drained 1 &times; 400g/14oz can baby corn cobs, drained and halved if necessary lettuce, spring onions and radishes, cut deeply and steeped in cold water to open, to serve 
 1. 
 Toss the beef in the teriyaki in a large bowl and leave to marinade for 1&ndash;2hr. 
 2. 
 Heat the oil in a large pan and cook the pepper strips and spring onions until just cooked but still crisp. 
 Allow to cool. 
 3. 
 Combine all the ingredients in a large bowl the teriyaki will provide a sauce for the dish. 
 4. 
 Serve the Oriental Beef on a bed of lettuce on large platters and garnish with spring onions and radish waterlilies. 
 Chill until required.  
 The Rice Bowl 
 Rice is one of the most important foods in the world, providing the basic diet of many thousands of people in the countries in which it is grown. 
 It is thought that rice was first cultivated in India and Indo-China, but it is now grown extensively throughout the Far East. 
 Smaller quantities are produced elsewhere, such as in the southern states of North America and Italy. 
 The main requirement for growing rice is a lush wetland with extensive irrigation systems. 
 In some areas, such as Bali, the cultivation of rice has been linked to religious ceremony for hundreds of years, to ensure an adequate water supply throughout the growing season. 
 In the Far East it is said that a girl is not eligible for marriage until she can cook a perfect bowl of rice. 
 TYPES OF RICE 
 Eating habits in the West have changed dramatically during the last ten to twenty years. 
 Just as white bread was once eaten in preference to brown, so white rice was always the standard choice. 
 However, with the move towards less processed foods, the brown, unpolished grains of rice are becoming more popular, just as brown or wholemeal flour is favoured over white. 
 Whole rice is protected by an outer husk, which is always removed. 
 The remaining rice in its unprocessed state still contains the bran and this is brown rice. 
 Once the bran has been removed by milling, the rice assumes a polished appearance and is generally white in colour. 
 There are many thousands of varieties of rice, but they are divided into two main groups &mdash; long and short grain. 
 Long grains usually cook up to give a dry, fluffy dish, whereas the shorter grains cook wet or sticky and have a tendency to cling together. 
 Although it is normal to be served long grain rice at a Chinese restaurant, it is much easier to eat the shorter grains with chopsticks. 
 Long grain rice 
 is the name generally applied to rice of varying quality and sold as an all-purpose grain. 
 Always wash this rice thoroughly in a sieve under running water otherwise you will get a scum on the water in the pan, causing the rice to boil over on the hob and resulting in an unpleasant appearance when the grains are cooked.  
 Easy-cook rice 
 is par-boiled to remove the surface starch that causes the problems when cooking other long grain rices. 
 It is certainly easy to prepare, but I always think it lacks the flavour of some other types of rice. 
 Basmati 
 is the everyday luxury rice. 
 It is grown on the slopes of the Himalayas in Pakistan and has very thin grains and a surprising fragrance. 
 It has always been acknowledged as a superior rice and with the move to whole grains, brown Basmati is now much in demand. 
 This rice is not always easy to obtain, although it is now available in larger supermarkets. 
 I use basmati whenever I can, and for dishes such as Chicken Pilaf it is superb. 
 Arborio or risotto rice 
 is sometimes referred to as Italian rice, and is really a short grain rice, although slightly longer than the traditional round grain pudding rice. 
 It does cook up wet and sticky, but has a texture of its own and is full of flavour. 
 Arborio rice is grown in Italy and should always be washed before cooking. 
 Short grain or pudding rice 
 is almost round and slightly sweeter than long grain rices. 
 Brown or polished grains are available, the latter being the most common. 
 I always remember making a particularly unsuccessful pudding with brown rice as a young bride &mdash; we ate chewy rice in slightly reduced buttery milk! 
 Nowadays, I usually use the polished variety. 
 Wild rice 
 is regarded as the most expensive grain in the world, and isn't really a rice at all but a type of grass. 
 It is grown in swamp areas of the USA which are often very remote, and in Canada. 
 The plants grow wild along the banks of the rivers and inlets and the grains are harvested from a boat. 
 This takes a long time and is reflected in the price of the product. 
 Wild rice has a very nutty flavour and takes a long time to cook. 
 I think it has a fragrance reminiscent of Darjeeling tea while it is simmering. 
 Wild rice is far too expensive to serve, like traditional rice, as an accompaniment to other dishes. 
 It can be mixed with basmati rice to give an attractive appearance, but it is generally used for stuffings for game. 
 The recipe for Wild Rice &amp; Mushroom Stuffing complements pheasant particularly well. 
 Chicken Pilaf 
 Serves 10&ndash;12 
 Pilafs and other rice-based dishes are a very good way of entertaining plenty of people without too much fuss and expenditure. 
 I prefer a pilaf to a risotto for parties. 
 Although risotto rice always cooks up wet, your guests might think that something has gone wrong. 
 A pilaf may be prepared in advance and heated through when required in the oven or microwave. 
 Cut all the vegetables finely so that the dish can be eaten easily with just a fork. 
 675g/1&frac12;lb/3 cups basmati rice 3 pinches or sachets powdered saffron 1 litre/3pt/7&amp; cups water or chicken stock 50g/2oz butter or margarine 1 large onion, finely sliced 3 stalks celery, finely sliced 2 green peppers, seeded and cut into strips 325&ndash;450g/12&ndash;16oz cooked chicken, shredded or diced 175g/6oz/1 cup seedless raisins 1 &times; 185g/6&amp;oz can pimentos, drained and chopped salt and pepper 125g/4oz/&frac23; cup pistachio kernels freshly chopped coriander or parsley to garnish 
 1. 
 Wash the rice in a sieve under running cold water. 
 Place in a large bowl with the saffron and measured water or cold stock and leave until required. 
 2. 
 Melt the butter or margarine in a very large pan, add the onion, celery and peppers and cook slowly, covered, until the vegetables are soft &mdash; about 10min. 
 3. 
 Add the rice and water to the pan with the chicken, raisins and pimentos. 
 Season with salt and pepper, stir well and bring to the boil. 
 4. 
 Reduce the heat, cover the pan and simmer for 12&ndash;15min, until all the liquid is absorbed. 
 Remove the pan from the heat and leave, covered, for a further 5min. 
 5. 
 Season the pilaf to taste with extra salt and pepper, then serve, garnished with freshly chopped coriander or parsley. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Soaking the rice before cooking in the measured water helps to produce a fluffier risotto of a richer saffron-yellow colour.  
 Risotto Milanese 
 Serves 6&ndash;8 
 This is a classic Italian risotto and is always served with Osso Bucco. 
 It can also be eaten as a supper dish with a salad. 
 It makes a very good (if expensive) alternative to macaroni cheese. 
 40g/1&frac12;oz unsalted butter 1 medium onion, finely chopped 150ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cup dry wine 450g/1lb/2 cups arborio or risotto rice 1 envelope or &frac12; &times; 5ml/tsp powdered saffron 1 litre/2pt/5 cups chicken stock 40g/1&amp;oz unsalted butter 75g/3oz fresh Parmesan cheese, finely grated salt and freshly ground black pepper, if required 
 TO GARNISH 
 2 lemons, finely grated rinds 4 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped parsley 2 cloves garlic, finely chopped 
 1. 
 Melt the butter in a large saucepan, add the onion and cook slowly, covered, for 5min. 
 Do not allow the onion to brown. 
 If your butcher will let you have a veal bone, scrape the marrow from the bone and cook it with the onion. 
 2. 
 Add the wine to the pan and cook over a high heat, uncovered, until the liquid has reduced by half. 
 3. 
 Add the rice to the pan and cook until it becomes opaque. 
 While the rice is cooking, add the saffron to the stock and allow to stand. 
 4. 
 Add the stock to the pan and return to the boil. 
 Cover the pan and simmer the rice for about 20min, until the stock is absorbed. 
 Allow to stand for 2&ndash;3min. 
 5. 
 Cut the remaining butter into slivers and stir into the rice with the grated Parmesan cheese. 
 Season with salt and pepper if necessary. 
 6. 
 Mix together the lemon rind, parsley and chopped garlic and sprinkle over the rice before serving. 
 COOK'S NOTE: The risotto should be wet and sticky &mdash; don't worry! 
 Osso Bucco 
 Serves 6 
 This is a classic Italian dish that is not too expensive to prepare, using shin of veal rather than an expensive boneless cut. 
 The addition of the sun-dried tomatoes gives extra flavour to the sauce. 
 Osso Bucco should always be served with Risotto Milanese. 
 50g/2oz butter 2 cloves garlic, crushed 6 thick slices of shin of veal, approx 225&ndash;275g/8&ndash;10oz each 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp seasoned flour 1 large onion, chopped 3 large carrots, peeled and diced 3 stalks celery, finely sliced 450g/1lb tomatoes, skinned, seeded and chopped 8 halves sun-dried tomatoes, chopped 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped rosemary 200ml/8oz/1 cup dry white wine 250ml/10fl oz/1&frac14; cups boiling vegetable stock, approx salt and pepper 
 1. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 3/160&deg;C/325&deg;F. 
 2. 
 Melt the butter in a large heavy casserole and add the garlic. 
 Toss the veal in the seasoned flour, then brown quickly on both sides. 
 Remove the veal from the pan. 
 3. 
 Add the onion to the pan, stirring well to mix with any flour left at the bottom of the pan. 
 Cover and cook over a medium heat for 5min, then add the carrots and celery and cook for a further 5min. 
 4. 
 Return the veal to the pan, add the fresh and dried tomatoes, rosemary, wine, stock, salt and pepper. 
 5. 
 Cover the casserole dish and place in the pre-heated oven. 
 Cook for 1&frac12;&ndash;2hr, until the veal is tender. 
 Remove the veal to a heat-proof plate if it is necessary to thicken the sauce, and keep the meat warm in the oven. 
 6. 
 If the sauce requires thickening, boil it quickly in the casserole or a saucepan on the hot-plate until it has reduced sufficiently &mdash; it should be thick but moist. 
 Season to taste with salt and pepper before serving over the veal.  
 Wild Rice &amp; Mushroom Stuffing 
 50g/2oz/&frac14; cup wild rice, cooked 15g/&frac12;oz dried mushrooms 15g/&amp;oz butter 1 small onion, finely chopped 25g/1oz wholewheat breadcrumbs 1 &times; 5ml/tsp freshly chopped sage salt and pepper beaten egg to bind 
 1. 
 Boil the rice in plenty of water until soft, then leave to cook. 
 2. 
 Pour boiling water onto the mushrooms and leave to stand for at least 15min. 
 3. 
 Melt the butter in a small saucepan and cook the onion until soft and transparent. 
 4. 
 Drain the rice. 
 Drain and chop the mushrooms. 
 5. 
 Add the breadcrumbs, rice and mushrooms to the onion with the sage and salt and pepper. 
 Mix well, then bind together with a little beaten egg. 
 Use as required. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Rice-based stuffings do tend to fall apart when they are cut after cooking. 
 This is probably why they are particularly good for stuffing game, when it is quite usual for a whole small bird to be served.  
 Mustards To Relish 
 Everyone has heard that the mustard giants make their money from the amount of the condiment that is left on the sides of our plates. 
 There are numerous varieties of mustards from around the world, although Dijon in France is acknowledged as the mecca of the trade and is still said to produce almost 50 per cent of the world's mustard. 
 All mustards are made from three varieties of seeds: white, brown or black, the latter two being hotter. 
 The word &bquo;mustard&equo; comes from the Latin mustum ardens , meaning burning must, probably because mustard powder used to be mixed with grape must in France. 
 This would imply that the majority of mustards are hot, but it is only the English mustard that is really fierce. 
 (Chinese and Japanese mustards are also said to be strong, but I have not tried them.) 
 Mustard does have a preserving quality; the seeds are often used in pickles and chutneys while the flour is used in piccalilli. 
 Mustard seeds may be used either whole or cracked, or pulverized into flour. 
 The pungency of mustard is only realised when it is mixed with cold water; salt, vinegar and hot water inhibit the flavour, producing a milder condiment. 
 Mustard should be allowed to stand for a few minutes after mixing and before serving to allow the flavour to develop, but mix little and often the flavour will be retained but the pungency will soon be lost. 
 To gain the maximum flavour, always mix mustard powder to a paste before adding it to recipes. 
 As a general rule, mild mustards should be served with spicy foods and hot, fiery varieties to enliven bland food. 
 I wonder who first decided that we shouldn't eat mustard with lamb? 
 It certainly never seems right to do so. 
 VARIETIES 
 English 
 This mustard is made from a mixture of white and black mustard seeds with wheat flour and turmeric. 
 It is sold dry, in powder form, which is generally stronger than the more convenient ready-mixed varieties. 
 English mustard is sometimes sold with horseradish incorporated, but I find that the flavour of the extra ingredient is lost unless it is a very well balanced mixture. 
 French 
 There are many types of French mustard, but the most popular are Dijon and Bordeaux. 
 The less common Florida mustard is made with wine from the Champagne region. 
 Dijon mustards are generally smooth and fairly hot, although mild compared with English. 
 Bordeaux mustards are darker and milder and often contain flavourings such as vinegar or herbs, especially tarragon. 
 Bordeaux mustard is especially good in salad dressings. 
 Whole grain mustards have recently become very popular and the best known French variety is the Moutarde de Meaux. 
 I like to add whole grain mustard to white sauce to pour over cauliflower ( see also  Kidneys with Dijon Mustard Sauce, p76). 
 German 
 These mustards are usually from Dusseldorf and are similar to Bordeaux varieties, often containing herbs and spices. 
 They are particularly good with cold meats. 
 I have many happy memories of eating Frankfurters with lashings of mustard in Cologne. 
 American 
 A mild mustard that goes hand-in-hand with the hot-dog and hamburger trade. 
 These mustards are often sweetened with sugar. 
 I sell a very popular Canadian mustard called Honeycup, which is actually sweetened with sugar and is delicious with any cold meats, but especially with smoked turkey.  
 FRUITS of the vine 
 There has been a great deal of correspondence in the trade press and the media concerning the absence of top quality vine fruits from the shops. 
 This simply is not true. 
 All the fruits are available, but you must ensure that your local shopkeeper realises that you want, and are prepared to pay for, the best. 
 The difference is amazing &mdash; full, plump fruits bursting with flavour. 
 Vine fruits &mdash; that is, currants, sultanas and raisins &mdash; are full of invert sugars which are readily absorbed and assimilated by the body and are therefore a good supply of immediate energy. 
 Many mothers prefer to give children a small packet of raisins as a snack rather than a chocolate bar. 
 These fruits were traditionally sun-dried after fumigation to remove any bugs and insects, but many are not dried by accelerated methods to cut the processing time and, therefore, the costs. 
 Wine is now produced in many areas of the world and the production of vine fruits has also been spread far and wide. 
 The majority of the fruits are from California, Australia and South Africa. 
 Currants 
 were originally grown in Greece and are the dried fruits of the &bquo;Corinth&equo; grape, a small, black, seedless variety. 
 Many currants are now grown in Australia, but I find that the best are the tiny Greek vorzittzas, which are sweet and plump. 
 Cheap currants, especially if they are used in too great a proportion to other fruits, are bitter and can ruin a cake. 
 Sultanas 
 are dried white seedless grapes and have a sweeter flavour than either currants or raisins. 
 Look for the Australian Five Crown Sultanas which are perfectly delicious. 
 If you want to add extra fruit to a cake or pudding, add extra sultanas. 
 Raisins 
 are the most variable of all the vine fruits &mdash; they can be small or large with various grades in between. 
 Red grapes come in many sizes, with seeds or without, hence the many varieties of raisins, which are simply dried red grapes. 
 My favourites are the seedless Thompson raisins for everyday baking and for including in salads and pilafs, and the larger lexia raisins from Australia, which are usually seeded and are ideal for special cakes and puddings. 
 As a dessert or table raisin, the flavour of the muscatel berry cannot be surpassed. 
 OTHER FRUITS TO WATCH FOR 
 Turkish sun-dried apricots 
 are superlative. 
 They have so much more flavour than the fresh fruit and can be eaten on cereals, used for puddings and fruit compotes, cooked with meat (especially lamb) or made into jam. 
 Commercially dried apricots are exposed to sulphur dioxide to preserve their colour, before they are dried in hot air. 
 Prunes 
 are dried plums and the best are the pruneaux d'Agen from France. 
 These are delicious by themselves, but if you use them for Devils on Horseback (see p112) your cocktail party will surely be an enormous success. 
 Candied peel and angelica 
 are coated in a thick sugar syrup, then dried. 
 Both are at their best when bought in large pieces and chopped just before use, either for decoration or in cakes. 
 Always flatten angelica with the blade of a knife before using it for decoration.  
 Panettone 
 Italian fruited yeast cake 
 Panettoni are widely available at Christmas time, often with marzipan paste incorporated into the dough or covered with chocolate. 
 Homemade panettone made with top quality peel and fruit has a wonderful flavour that justly rewards the rather long preparation time. 
 The cake keeps well in a tin or tightly wrapped in foil and should be served sliced, buttered or with jam. 
 Try it for Christmas morning breakfast. 
 40g/1&amp;oz fresh yeast 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp lukewarm water 6 egg yolks 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp vanilla essence grated rind of one lemon &frac12; &times; 5ml/tsp salt 50g/2oz/&frac14; cup caster sugar 225g/8oz/2 cups strong plain flour, approx 125g/4oz softened butter 50g/2oz candied peel, cut into small dice 40g/1&frac12;oz seedless raisins 40g/1&amp;oz sultanas 25g/1oz unsalted butter, melted 
 1. 
 Sprinkle the yeast over the water in a cup and leave to stand for a few minutes in a warm place before stirring to completely dissolve the yeast. 
 Leave the mixture in a warm place until the yeast starts to bubble. 
 2. 
 Scrape the yeast liquid from the cup into a large bowl and add the egg yolks, vanilla, lemon rind, salt and sugar. 
 Add the flour gradually, beating all the time, until the dough is still soft and sticky but can be gathered into a ball. 
 Add a little extra flour if necessary. 
 3. 
 Add the softened butter to the dough in three pieces, mixing it in thoroughly &mdash; the dough will become very heavy and sticky and will be difficult to manage when all the butter is incorporated. 
 4. 
 Add sufficient extra flour to make the dough manageable, then knead it thoroughly for about 10min, until smooth and shiny. 
 Place the dough in a clean bowl, sprinkle lightly with flour, cover and leave in a warm place to double in bulk. 
 This will take about 1hr as the dough is very rich. 
 5. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 6/200&deg;C/400&deg;F. 
 Lightly oil a 450g/1lb loaf tin or a 15cm/6in round cake tin. 
 6. 
 Lightly knead the dough on a floured surface, working in the candied peel, raisins and sultanas. 
 Do not over-knead the dough while adding the fruit or it will discolour. 
 Shape the dough and place in the tin. 
 7. 
 Leave the dough in a warm place to rise for a further 20min, then brush with melted butter and place in the oven. 
 Bake for 10min, then lower the temperature to gas mark 4/180&amp;C/350&amp;F, brush with more butter and cook for a further 30&ndash;40min, until golden brown. 
 Brush with butter once or twice more before cooking. 
 8. 
 Cook slightly before turning out onto a wire rack. 
 9. 
 Serve sliced, with jam and fresh coffee, or with a well-chilled dessert wine.  
 COSMOPOLITAN CHEESE 
 Cheese is an enormous subject. 
 Many books have been written about this topic alone and cheese is indeed as international as food itself. 
 Few of the learned tomes that have been written are for the domestic consumer and contain few, if any, recipes to lighten the technical detail. 
 I cannot devote a whole book to the subject, so my descriptions of the numerous cheeses available will be rather brief. 
 There is no better way of buying cheese than from a specialist cheese shop, where you will be encouraged to taste before buying and the retailer will be knowledgeable, friendly and, above all, enthusiastic about his stock. 
 When talking about individual cheeses, I have tried to mention only those that are available in the UK without too much difficulty &mdash; I see no point in being lyrical about a cheese that you will have to travel to London (or abroad) to purchase.  
 THE CLASSIFICATION OF CHEESES 
 Cheeses may be categorised in great detail according to fat content, milk type and the cheesemaking processes used. 
 For ease of discussion, I will split them into four main categories: fresh; soft; semi-hard and hard. 
 It is usual to add blue cheeses, sheep's and goats' milk cheeses as three extra types, in addition to the four main categories. 
 Fresh cheeses 
 These are eaten very young &mdash; less than one month after the cheese is made &mdash; hence the term &bquo;fresh&equo;. 
 They are often (but not always) relatively low in fat and can be made from skimmed milk or whey. 
 They are soft in texture, usually sold in a pot or tub, and creamy white in colour. 
 Fresh cheeses have become much more popular in recent years and cows' and goats' milk varieties are now available in most good supermarkets. 
 Fresh cheeses are used both as table cheeses and as an invaluable ingredient for cooking. 
 Cottage, cream and curd cheeses are probably the best known of the fresh cheeses of Britain. 
 Cottage cheese is granular as it is skimmed cows' milk curds, drained and washed before being coated in a very thin cream. 
 The fat content varies, so check the nutritional information supplied on the tub. 
 If a recipe calls for Ricotta cheese, sieved cottage cheese is the best alternative. 
 Flavoured varieties are available, but it is far more interesting to make your own additions to the basic curds. 
 Curd cheese is a low or medium fat cheese, very similar to cream cheese but having a more lactic flavour. 
 It is often referred to as baker's cheese and is, as implied, very good for cooking. 
 Cream cheese may be moderate or full fat content and is used extensively as a base for dips, for cocktail fillings and for cooking. 
 I find it rather rich for eating as a table cheese, but a few spoonfuls stirred into hot pasta is delicious. 
 Crowdie is the best known of the Scottish fresh cheeses. 
 It can be laced with herbs or garlic and has a rather sour flavour &mdash; butter or cream are sometimes worked into the cheese to give a more rounded taste. 
 Many continental fresh cheeses have now found their way to the supermarket shelves and to the specialist delicatessen. 
 Among the most popular are fromage blanc and fromage frais from France, and quark from Germany. 
 All have varying fat contents, so check before buying if you are following a low fat diet. 
 The lower fat varieties make interesting alternatives to cream on desserts and are especially good with fruit. 
 Although these cheeses are very popular in Europe (it is said that the average German eats 5kg/11lb of quark a year, accounting for half their cheese intake) they may become a passing fad of the era of nouvelle cuisine in the UK. 
 Of the Italian fresh cheeses, Ricotta and Mascarpone are the most widely available and the most highly publicised. 
 Ricotta was originally a whey cheese and therefore very low in fat, but whole or skimmed milk is sometimes added to give a richer cheese. 
 It is usually made from cows' milk but the whey resulting from the making of Pecorino, a hard sheep's milk cheese, may also be utilised. 
 It is used extensively in Italian cooking for both sweet and savoury dishes. 
 Ricotta has a very short life and should be bought and used daily. 
 This is not always possible outside large Italian communities and &bquo;long-life&equo; Ricotta, which lasts several weeks, is now available, but the flavour does suffer from this treatment. 
 Mascarpone is the fresh cheese that really rebels against being low fat &mdash; it is virtually solidified cream. 
 In Italy it is often found flavoured with crystallised fruits for eating as a dessert cheese, or it can be used plain for cooking, but mainly for desserts. 
 It is also very popular as a speciality cheese; in layers either with Dolcelatte or Gorgonzola, it looks and tastes delicious.  
 Tips for Buying Fresh Cheeses 
 Always check the recommended sell-by date. 
 These cheeses should be eaten as soon as possible after purchase, otherwise the flavour and character deteriorates. 
 Some fromage frais and quark have a longer shelf life and may be kept for a week or ten days after purchase. 
 Listeria Hysteria 
 There has been much adverse publicity concerning food poisoning caused by soft cheeses. 
 Such cases are few and far between and few have been proven. 
 Pregnant ladies and elderly people should be careful when eating soft cheese, as they should be when exercising. 
 Soft Cheese 
 Of all the soft cheeses, Brie and Camembert must surely be the most popular. 
 The citing of these two varieties will illustrate the basic characteristics of the cheeses of this type &mdash; uncut curds treated very gently and never pressed, the whey being allowed to drain naturally. 
 Some soft cheeses are of the washed rind variety. 
 This means that the rinds are dipped or rubbed with salt during their ripening period. 
 It is more usual to wash or dip the cheeses in liquid. 
 It may be brine or alcohol and this turns the cheese into what one of my customers calls &bquo;garage cheese&equo; &mdash; smelly! 
 Don't be put off, though, as the actual rind of these cheeses is seldom eaten and the remaining paste is often surprisingly mild. 
 The French are the undisputed kings of the soft cheese market, but they must fight to keep the unpasteurised, fuller flavour Bries and Camemberts in full and regular production if they are to avoid losing the truly classic cheeses of their country. 
 Brie and Camembert are best bought from a cheese shop. 
 Supermarkets seldom have time to nurture the cheese to full maturity and it is often sold with a large, hard &bquo;chalk&equo; in the centre of the paste, which is flavourless and most unpleasant to eat. 
 Once a Brie has been cut in that state, it will seldom ripen properly. 
 France, Germany and now the UK all produce Bries, although I think that the French varieties remain the best. 
 Many additions are made to the basic cheeses, such as mushrooms peppercorns, garlic and herbs, but the greatest distinguishing factor between one Brie and the next is whether it is made with pasteurised or fresh, untreated milk. 
 Both have a good flavour when fully ripened, but the unpasteurised cheeses are very strong and an absolute delight! 
 I do think that Brie is probably still unknown to you unless you have tried an unpasteurised variety. 
 Certainly the most successful of the &bquo;modern&equo; Bries has been Cambozola, a German cheese referred to as a blue Brie. 
 It is a soft cheese with a Camembert mould on the rind and blue caused by the introduction of the Gorgonzola mould. 
 When ripe, it is almost inclined to run, with a creamy flavour sharpened by the blue mould. 
 Camembert is also made from pasteurised or fresh milk and, like Brie, it is the mass-produced pasteurised cheeses that are the most readily available. 
 It is, however, well worth seeking out an unpasteurised Camembert, handmade in Normandy and originally only available from the end of spring through to the autumn. 
 Camemberts are still packed in the chipwood boxes that were first used for the cheeses in the 1890s. 
 There are many cheeses that are similar to Brie and Camembert but produced in different shapes or sold at differing stages of ripeness. all are referred to as surface-ripened, containing bacteria on their developing white rinds. 
 Coulommiers is a small Brie, eaten very young when the surface mould is only just starting to appear, and Fongeru is similar but ripened in fronds of bracken and very difficult to obtain. 
 Heart-shaped cheeses are also produced which are very attractive on a cheese-board: Coeur de Neufchatel and Coeur de Bray are two of the best known, both from the Pays de Bray in Normandy. 
 Epoisses is a very popular washed rind soft cheese from Burgundy. 
 It is usually dipped in white wine and develops an orange-red bloom on the rind. 
 It is sometimes flavoured with peppercorns. 
 Munster also has a reddish bloom to the rind and has a strong distinctive flavour &mdash; it is delicious on hot baked potatoes. 
 Munster originates from the Vosges mountains of France, but is much imitated throughout the world. 
 I have stopped telling customers that it used to be ripened under piles of manure, as it seemed to stop them from  buying it. 
 Pont l'Eveque is one of the oldest of all the cheeses made in Normandy and is distinguished by its square shape, being packed in small boxes similar to those for Camembert. 
 It has an open textured paste when ripe and is usually washed or brushed with brine. 
 There is one very ancient soft cheese from Scotland that has recently been revived. 
 Caboc is a cows' milk cheese made in small cylindrical shapes and rolled in toasted oatmeal to give it a more distinctive flavour. 
 Of the soft Italian cheeses Bel Paese, Mozzarella and Tallegio are the best known, although they are very different in character. 
 Bel Paese was created in 1906 by Galbani and is sweet and buttery; it is used mainly as a table dessert cheese. 
 It is named after the book by Stoppani, whose portrait is imposed over a map of Italy on the foil packaging. 
 Mozzarella was originally made from buffalos' milk but it is now a cows' milk cheese. 
 It has a distinctive texture which becomes stringy when cooked and is most famous served on top of pizzas or lasagne. 
 Eaten raw in salads, it becomes more interesting if it is topped with herbs and a good quality olive oil. 
 If you purchase Mozzarella at the supermarket, it may be in brine or be ready grated; it is difficult to grate but melts more evenly if you make the effort. 
 Other Mozzarellas must be stored in their wrapping in water, which requires changing every day. 
 Taleggio is a wonderful cheese when ripe; the paste should appear creamy and supple and the rind should be pinkish-grey in colour and not cracked. 
 Eat it in the sunshine with Italian wine. 
 Perhaps the most famous of the remaining soft cheese is the Vacherin Mont d'Or, made in both France and Switzerland on either side of the border. 
 This is a spooning cheese and should be served by removing the top crust and scooping out the paste with a spoon &mdash; from the retailer's point of view it is quite difficult to persuade customers that the cheese is as it should be. 
 If the cheese is cut, the paste must be restrained inside the crust &mdash; thank heavens for film wrap, before which glass or wood had to be used. 
 Semi-hard Cheeses 
 This is probably the largest of all the categories of cheeses and it encompasses many of the traditional British varieties (see The Great British Eight, p86) as well as continental cheeses such as Edam, Chaumes and Pyrenees. 
 The Dutch cheeses Edam, Gouda and Leiden all belong to this group, although they may be sold at varying stages of maturity and the older examples will be harder in texture. 
 Edam and Gouda are both eaten as table cheeses and used for cooking, when they melt readily. 
 Kaasdoop, the Dutch version of fondue, is made with a mixture of these cheeses, although the addition of some mature Gouda will add extra distinction to the flavour. 
 Although the majority of these cheeses are made on a commercial scale, a number of farms still make unpasteurised Gouda which has the word boeren  (farmhouse) stamped on the rind. 
 Leiden is very similar to Gouda and is generally sold in the same yellow paraffin wax coating. 
 I call it curry cheese as it is very heavily flavoured with cumin seeds. 
 Switzerland is famous for six cheeses, four of which belong to the semi-hard family, although they are sometimes referred to as hard cheeses. 
 Emmenthal and Gruy&egrave;re are the most famous, Emmenthal having the distinctive holes, a nutty flavour and drawing threads when heated, whereas Gruy&egrave;re has a very few small holes, if any, and melts readily and evenly. 
 Both cheeses are slightly unusual in as much as they are made with cooked curds that have been heated in the whey for about 30min before being drained. 
 Emmenthal must have Switzerland stamped in red on its rind, whereas the markings on Gruy&egrave;re are in blue. 
 The holes in Emmenthal are the result of the lactic acid in the cheese undergoing a secondary fermentation owing to a slightly higher temperature in the storeroom at the beginning of the cheese's ripening period. 
 Emmenthal and Gruy&egrave;re are mixed together to make a Swiss cheese fondue. 
 Appenzell and Royalp are the remaining Swiss cheeses in this group. 
 Both have washed rinds and a firm texture and tend to have the washed rind garage-cheese smell, as described in the section on soft cheeses (p69). 
 Appenzell is especially good for cooking. 
 All these Swiss cheeses are made in wheels, the retailer buying a wedge-shaped cut of the required  size. 
 A large Emmenthal wheel may weight up to 80kg/200lb. 
 Norwegian Jarlsberg, based on an old recipe but reintroduced in the 1950s, is best described as a cross between Emmenthal and Gouda. 
 It has a nutty flavour and similar holes to Emmenthal. 
 Jarlsberg is very popular in the United States and is becoming very well-known in the UK. 
 Norway also produces Gjetost, a sweet, dark brown, fudge-like cheese that should be pared or sliced very thinly. 
 It can be used to accompany dishes of herrings and other pickled fish, and helps to offset the acidity of these foods. 
 Of the French semi-hard cheeses, Chaumes, Pyrenees, Gaperon and Port Salut are probably the most famous. 
 Chaumes and St Albray are washed rind, garage-type cheeses, having a firm, even-textured paste that oozes when ripe. 
 The flavours of both cheeses are less powerful than the bouquets. 
 When buying, avoid cheese that is discoloured under the rind. 
 Pyrenees is a mild cows' milk cheese, usually in a distinctive thin black rind. 
 It is factory made and the paste has many small holes in it. 
 Pyrenees may also refer to small ewes' milk cheeses that are produced in the same area. 
 Gaperon is rounded in shape and made from skimmed milk or buttermilk and often flavoured with garlic or peppercorns. 
 Produced in the Auvergne and usually ripened for about two months, Gaperon is expensive. 
 In the past it was often hung from farmhouse ceilings to display a person's wealth (the more Gaperons the better) and to indicate the size of the dowry of an eligible daughter. 
 Port Salut is a washed rind cheese of a fairly mild flavour, originally made by Trappist monks when it was referred to as Port du Salut. 
 The modern commercial version is very similar to Saint Paulin. 
 If you are in France, try to find some of the Port Salut that is still made by the monks &mdash; it has a more distinctive flavour than the mass-produced cheese. 
 Esrom, from Denmark, and Tilsit, from Germany are also popular continental semi-hard cheeses. 
 Esrom is based on a Port Salut recipe and has a washed rind and big bouquet. 
 It is usually produced in rectangles and is easy to slice and therefore very useful for sm&oslash;rgasbord. 
 Tilsit was originally made by Dutch cheesemakers living in East Germany, but is now made throughout Germany. 
 It is stronger in flavour than the traditional Dutch cheeses and has a texture punctuated with many small holes. 
 It is sometimes available in supermarkets, pre-packed in slices. 
 Hard Cheeses 
 Of all the hard cheeses produced throughout the world, Parmesan must surely be the most famous. 
 It is the essential ingredient in much of the best Italian cuisine, whether it is cooked in the dish, sprinkled onto the food just before serving, or eaten as a table cheese. 
 The best Parmesan is Parmigiano Reggiano, which has its name stamped on the rind. 
 The cheese is sold at no younger than two years and up to five years old. 
 Parmesan is a scalded curd cheese, meaning that the curds are heated to 58&amp;C (136&amp;F) before they are pressed. 
 It is a &bquo;grana&equo; cheese &mdash; that is, grainy. 
 Owing to its price, it is unlikely that real Italian Parmesan is sprinkled generously over your food in Italian restaurants. 
 Sbrinz, a grana cheese from Switzerland, is a  very good substitute for Parmesan, being only approximately half as expensive. 
 It is slightly softer but has a similar flavour. 
 Sbrinz is sometimes cut from the wheel using a chisel-like cheese knife. 
 Provolone, another hard Italian cheese, was originally made from buffalos' milk (as was Mozzarella), but is now made from cows' milk. 
 It is distinguished by its flavour, the cheese being smoked before it is left to mature. 
 Provolone is always made in unusual barrel shapes and tied in cords, which are then used to hang the cheese while it is maturing. 
 Cheese is always classified into the above four main categories, but individual cheeses may be put into different groups according to the author's opinion. 
 What really matters is the ability to recognise when the cheese has been properly stored by the retailer and when it is being offered for sale in prime condition. 
 TIPS FOR BUYING &amp; STORING CHEESE 
 This material actually appears on p. 72 
 * Avoid soft cheeses with discoloured paste under the rind or with a damp surface; these will probably be over-ripe. 
 Conversely, avoid those with a hard chalk in the centre, as these are not ripe and may never ripen if they have been cut too young. 
 * Do not store various types of cheeses together unless they are individually wrapped. 
 Wrapping cheese in foil is probably the best method of storage. 
 * Avoid any cheeses that look hard or discoloured around the edges and that are cracked or dry. 
 * Cheese should always be eaten at room temperature to allow the flavour to develop. 
 Cheese stored at room temperature will quickly begin to sweat and become very strong. 
 Store your cheese in a cool part of the refrigerator and remove it at least 1hr before eating.  
 (overhead: l to r ) Munster; Farmhouse Brie; Roquefort; Vieux Pan&eacute;; Banon d'Or; Chaumes; Rambol aux Noix; ( in basket ) Vignotte; Pipo Creme 
 ( front to back ) Blau Castello; Gjetost; Gouda, Cambozola; Rougette, Emmenthal; Parmesan; Gruy&egrave;re; Leiden 
 The Flavour of France 
 The cuisine of France has contributed so much to the culinary traditions of the world that to attempt to summarise all that is good about French cooking in the space of a page or two would be impossible. 
 A country that has given us countless cheeses, truffles, classic dishes such as moules marini&egrave;res  and cassoulet, champagne and, for many years, some of the world's finest wines, requires several tomes to do it justice. 
 You have only to look through any cookery book index to realise the extent of the French influence on even the most basic of dishes and the number of French recipe titles is further proof of a lasting international legacy. 
 Many French dishes are basically simple but may take a long time to prepare in the traditional way. 
 Food and its enjoyment are very serious business and are not to be hurried. 
 As with any quality foods, simple traditional French fare may require the minimum of fuss. 
 What could be nicer than a summer picnic (preferably involving a bicycle ride) of fresh baguette, ripe Brie or Camembert and a bottle of vin de table? 
 There are many dishes throughout this book that use French ingredients or that show the country's enormous influence. 
 Illustrated opposite are the classic Salade Ni&ccedil;oise and a delicious dish of lambs' kidneys, saut&eacute;ed in butter and served with a sauce flavoured with Dijon mustard.  
 Kidneys with Dijon Mustard Sauce  (Rognons &agrave; la Moutarde) 
 Serves 2&ndash;3 (see p74) 
 This dish, suitable for a light lunch or supper, needs only freshly cooked vegetables or a salad of endive to accompany it. 
 Serve with creamy potatoes or boiled rice if you require a more substantial dish. 
 75g/3oz unsalted butter 12 lambs' kidneys, skinned and cored 3 small shallots or salad onions, finely chopped 125ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cup dry white wine 50g/2oz softened unsalted butter 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp Dijon mustard salt and freshly ground black pepper 2 &times; 5ml/tsp lemon juice freshly chopped parsley to garnish 
 1. 
 Melt the 75g/oz unsalted butter in a large frying pan over a moderate heat. 
 Add the kidneys when the foam subsides and saut&eacute; them quickly until browned on all sides, in about 5min. 
 2. 
 Remove the kidneys to a warmed plate with a slotted spoon and keep warm. 
 3. 
 Add the shallots or salad onions to the remaining butter in the pan and cook until just soft. 
 Add the wine and bring to the boil, stirring constantly and scraping down any meat particles from the sides of the pan. 
 Boil rapidly until the wine is reduced to about 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp. 
 Remove the pan from the heat. 
 4. 
 Beat the remaining butter until very soft, then add the mustard and a little salt and pepper. 
 Drop small blobs of the butter into the pan, off the heat. 
 5. 
 Slice the kidneys thickly and add to the pan with the lemon juice. 
 Heat gently for 1&ndash;2min, then season to taste and sprinkle with freshly chopped parsley before serving. 
 Salade Ni&ccedil;oise 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 
 This salad may be served as a colourful starter or be made into a more substantial lunch or supper dish with the addition of some potato salad on top of the bed of lettuce. 
 Select the freshest and crispest salad ingredients and serve the salad immediately after it is prepared. 
 1 large lettuce, cabbage or Webbs, washed and dried 4 large tomatoes, ripe but firm, quartered 3 hard-boiled eggs, shelled and quartered 1 &times; 200g/7oz can tuna fish, drained and broken into large pieces 125g/4oz black olives 1 &times; 50g/2oz can anchovy fillets, drained 275g/10oz green beans, blanched and drained 6 &times; 15ml/tbsp vinaigrette (see p31) 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped parsley 
 1. 
 Break the lettuce leaves into small pieces and use to line a large salad bowl or individual salad plates. 
 2. 
 Arrange the tomatoes, eggs, tuna fish, olives and green beans on top of the lettuce and then arrange the anchovy fillets over. 
 3. 
 Spoon the dressing over the salad, then sprinkle with chopped parsley before serving. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Tuna fish in olive oil gives a better flavour to the salad than in brine; when the sun is not shining, the latter is reminiscent of the South of France.  
 OPPOSITE: Salade Ni&ccedil;oise; Kidneys with Dijon Mustard Sauce 
 Chocolate &amp; Cocoa 
 Chocolate is a most romantic food if only because, as a woman, one expects to be showered with delicious boxes of confectionery at every possible moment (husbands and lovers, take note). 
 Chocolate is made from cocoa which was originally grown in Mexico, although the majority of the world's supply now originates from West Africa. 
 Other beans come from Brazil, but the finest cocoa is still from Central America. 
 In its raw state, cocoa is very bitter, and the beans, once removed from the pods, are left to ferment to diminish the bitter flavour before they are processed. 
 The beans are roasted (like coffee beans) to dry the outer skin, which is then removed to leave the cocoa nib &mdash; the important bit. 
 Cocoa butter, the rich fatty substance in the beans, is extracted from the ground nibs and this is the basis of the chocolate industry. 
 It is the percentage content of cocoa butter that dictates the quality of the chocolates that you buy. 
 Cocoa butter is blended with sugar and flavourings and, sometimes, milk powder to produce confectionery, or is further processed to remove the fat, leaving cocoa powder. 
 The extraction process for cocoa powder was invented by a Dutchman, van Houten, in the late 1820s, and his family firm still produces the best cocoa powder (see p79), which has a very rich and rounded flavour. 
 I find it very difficult to obtain a regular supply of van Houten's cocoa; it sells almost immediately, so if you see it, buy it. 
 Cocoa has long been associated with the Temperance societies and other groups who fought against the consumption of alcohol. 
 As cocoa contains caffeine, it would have stimulated the Temperance workers on their way. 
 The village of Gospel Green, home of one of my locally made cheeses (see pp93&ndash;5), was visited by cocoa-drinking Temperance missionaries, although few of the generation who received instruction are still alive. 
 Chocolate bars are available in many flavours, but for cooking I prefer plain dessert chocolate, which is mildly bitter, or the French bitter patisserie bars. 
 I often mix French chocolate with an English dessert variety for chocolate sauces. 
 Bitter chocolate may be added to meat sauces for extra flavour &mdash; it sounds odd but it is very good and originates from a traditional Mexican dish of turkey cooked with very hot peppers, the chocolate being added to slightly sweeten and round the sauce. 
 With regard to powders, as a general rule cocoa should be added to mixtures that are to be cooked and drinking chocolate to foods, such as butter creams and icings, that will not be heated. 
 If you are melting bars of chocolate which will then reset, for example a chocolate biscuit cake, add an egg yolk to prevent the chocolate becoming cloudy and dull in appearance when it resets. 
 Rich Chocolate Cheesecake 
 Serves 6&ndash;8 
 This is a most unusual and very rich dessert. 
 Serve sparingly. 
 1 &times; 20cm/8in pre-cooked pastry shell or biscuit crust 225g/8oz cream cheese 100g/3&frac12;oz ground almonds 125g/4oz plain chocolate, broken into pieces 1 &times; 5ml/tsp coffee essence knob butter 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp honey or golden syrup 50g/2oz glac&eacute; cherries, halved 
 1. 
 Leave the pastry case or biscuit crust in a loose-bottomed tin. 
 2. 
 Beat the cream cheese until smooth, then add the ground almonds and beat well. 
 3. 
 Melt the chocolate, coffee essence, butter and honey together, either in a bowl over a pan of  water or in a microwave cooker. 
 Mix to a smooth paste, then add to the cream cheese and beat well. 
 Stir in the chopped cherries. 
 4. 
 Spoon the filling into the flan case or onto the biscuit base and smooth the top. 
 Chill until set (approximately 2hr), then remove from the tin and serve as required. 
 Italian Chocolate Biscuit Loaf 
 Serves 6&ndash;8 (see p79) 
 All chocolate refrigerator cakes are rich, but this is even more so. 
 Serve in small slices after a fairly plain main course. 
 Pour cream over the dessert if you dare! 
 225g/8oz plain dessert chocolate, broken into pieces 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp rum or liqueur of your choice 225g/8oz unsalted butter 25g/1oz caster sugar 2 eggs, separated 150g/5oz blanched almonds, finely chopped 12 petit beurre biscuits, cut cleanly into halves icing sugar for dredging (optional) cream to serve (optional) 
 1. 
 Line a 675g/1&amp;lb loaf tin with non-stick baking parchment. 
 2. 
 Heat the chocolate until melted, either in a bowl over a pan of water or in a double saucepan, or in the microwave for about 2&ndash;3min on 100% power. 
 Stir thoroughly, then allow to cool to room temperature. 
 3. 
 Beat the butter in a large bowl until light and fluffy. 
 Beat in the sugar and the egg yolks, one at a time, then stir in the almonds and the cooled chocolate. 
 4. 
 Whisk the egg whites until stiff, then fold into the chocolate mixture. 
 When the egg whites are properly combined with the chocolate, carefully add the biscuit halves &mdash; do not add any crumbs. 
 5. 
 Spoon the mixture into the prepared tin and press down with the back of a metal spoon. 
 Be quite firm so that it forms a solid chocolate loaf in the tin, but do try not to break the biscuit. 
 6. 
 Cover and chill for at least 2hr. 
 7. 
 Invert the loaf onto a serving plate and remove all the non-stick parchment. 
 Dredge with sieved icing sugar, if required, and serve in slices. 
 Black Forest G&acirc;teau 
 Serves 10&ndash;12 (see p79) 
 Year after year, this is constantly the favourite dessert when eating out. 
 If you take the time and trouble to make your own, you will discover a truly delicious g&acirc;teau. 
 60g/2&amp;oz unsalted butter 6 eggs 175g/6oz/&frac23; cup caster sugar 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp cocoa powder sieved together with 90g/3&frac12;oz plain flour 6 &times; 15ml/tbsp kirsch 350ml/15fl oz/2 cups double or thick cream, whipped 1 &times; 400g/14oz can pitted black cherries, drained Chocolate caraque to decorate (see Cook's Note, below) 
 1. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 5/190&deg;C/375&deg;F. 
 Lightly grease and line 2 &times; 22cm/8in sandwich tins. 
 2. 
 Heat the butter until melted, then allow to cool slightly. 
 3. 
 Whisk together the eggs and sugar until very thick &mdash; you should be able to write a four-lettered word in the mixture. 
 4. 
 Sieve half the flour onto the eggs and fold in lightly with a metal spoon, then fold in half the butter, the remaining flour, then the remaining butter. 
 Pour into the prepared tins and bake immediately, for 20&ndash;25min or until the cakes are cooked. 
 5. 
 Turn onto a wire cooling rack and leave until cold. 
 6. 
 Place one cake on a serving plate, spike all over with a skewer and lace with half the kirsch. 
 Spread the cake with cream and then top with the drained cherries. 
 Place the remaining cake on top of the cherries, spike and lace with kirsch as before. 
 7. 
 Spread the remaining cream over the cakes and decorate with the chocolate caraque. 
 Leave for at least 2hr before serving to allow the kirsch to soak properly into the cakes. 
 COOK'S NOTE: To make caraque, melt about 175g/6oz plain chocolate, then spread it thickly on some baking parchment and leave to set. 
 Scrape a large sharp knife across the surface, shaving off rolls of very fine chocolate. 
 Scatter these over the cake.  
 Black Forest Gateau; Italian Chocolate Biscuit Loaf 
 FASTA  PASTA 
 Pasta is quick to prepare, and provides a substantial, tasty meal without too much time and effort. 
 Pasta has been eaten in Italy for centuries and there are records of the ancient Etruscans eating laganon, or sheets of pasta that we now call lasagne. 
 Pasta is the ideal mid-week supper dish and the possibilities for tasty accompanying sauces are endless. 
 The following selection of sauces are all quick to prepare. 
 Some are based on classic recipes and some on contemporary flavours and foods; some can be made almost entirely from the store-cupboard. 
 Basic pasta itself is made from a stiff dough of flour and water, although eggs may sometimes be included. 
 The best pasta is made with durum wheat, a very hard, translucent grain. 
 For wholefood enthusiasts, I would recommend buckwheat pasta rather than wholemeal, which I think is rather dull in flavour and texture. 
 Buckwheat pasta has a strong, nutty flavour. 
 If you are making your own pasta, use a strong flour, such as you would have for breadmaking. 
 Homemade pasta requires a very definite skill which I haven't got (the texture of the dough is of paramount importance), so I cheat and use fresh pasta for special occasions. 
 This is widely available in supermarkets and delicatessens. 
 The quality of dried pasta varies enormously &mdash; always check that it is made from durum wheat. 
 A plain flour and water dough will be referred to as &bquo;pasta secca&equo; while an egg pasta will be labelled as &bquo;pasta all'uovo&equo;. 
 Pasta comes in all shapes and sizes, some for specific recipes, such as the large sheets of lasagne, but many of the others can be used as required. 
 Filled pasta shapes, such as ravioli and tortellini, make an instant meal with some prepared tomato sauce. 
 The fillings may be meat based, or a mixture of spinach and Ricotta cheese. 
 I think that spaghetti should be thin and it may often be referred to as spaghettini &mdash; it's much less like eating long worms! 
 Pasta may be flavoured with spinach (verde), tomato or carrot and tri-colour pastas are now widely available, which have a particularly attractive appearance. 
 Of all the shapes my favourite is penne &mdash; medium-sized tubes of pasta that fill up with large amounts of sauce. 
 If you visit the USA, do try to find some of the very large pasta shells that are available there &mdash; one of these per person makes a wonderful starter. 
  The following is a selection of my favourite pasta sauce recipes. 
 They all serve four and are to accompany 500g/1lb dried pasta, cooked as directed on the packet. 
 Vary the amount of pasta to suit your own appetite. 
 Creamed Leek &amp; Chilli Sauce 
 450g/1lb leeks, trimmed, sliced and freshly cooked 1 &times; 113g/4oz can green chillis in brine for Mexican cooking 25g/1oz butter 3 cloves garlic, crushed or finely chopped 225g/8oz cream cheese salt and pepper 1 &times; 5ml/tsp paprika watercress to garnish 
 1. 
 Drain the leeks and place in a liquidiser or food processor with the green chillis and the brine. 
 Process to a smooth pur&eacute;e. 
 2. 
 Heat the butter until melted in a large saucepan, add the garlic and cook for 1min. 
 Stir the leek pur&eacute;e into the butter and cook over a moderate heat until warmed through. 
 3. 
 Stir in the cream cheese and continue to cook until thoroughly blended and piping hot. 
 Add salt, pepper and paprika to taste. 
 4. 
 Drain the pasta and rinse in boiling water. 
 Toss the pasta in the sauce and place in a warmed serving dish. 
 Garnish boldly with watercress and serve. 
 COOK'S NOTE: A milder sauce can be made by pur&eacute;eing the leeks with 250ml/10fl oz/1&frac14; cups milk instead of the canned chillis. 
 Freshly cooked and pur&eacute;ed spinach may also be used. 
 Clam Sauce 
 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp white wine &frac12; &times; 400g/14oz can clam soup or chowder 5 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 2 cloves garlic, finely chopped 2 &times; 290g/10oz can clams, drained 25g/1oz soft butter 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped parsley or 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp dried salt and white pepper 
 1. 
 Boil the wine rapidly in a small saucepan until it has reduced to approx 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp. 
 Stir in the clam soup and set to one side. 
 2. 
 Heat the oil in a large frying pan, add the garlic and cook for a few seconds. 
 Add the wine and clam soup and boil quickly until the sauce has stopped foaming and is well reduced. 
 3. 
 Stir the clams into the sauce and heat for a further 1&ndash;2min until piping hot. 
 4. 
 Drain and rinse the pasta. 
 Add the softened butter and stir well, then place in a serving dish with the sauce and toss them together with the parsley and seasonings until all the ingredients are well mixed. 
 5. 
 Serve immediately. 
 COOK'S NOTE: This clam, or vongole, sauce is traditionally served with spaghetti. 
 Quails' Eggs &amp; Fresh Herb Sauce 
 24 quails' eggs, fresh or smoked or a mixture of both 25g/1oz softened butter 240g/8oz/carton strained Greek-style yogurt 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped chives 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped dill 50g/2oz pine kernels salt and pepper freshly grated Parmesan cheese to serve 
 1. 
 Hard boil the fresh quails' eggs for 3min, cool slightly and shell. 
 2. 
 Stir the butter into the freshly cooked, drained pasta with a fork, then stir in the yogurt. 
 Add the herbs and heat gently for 3&ndash;4min, stirring constantly. 
 3. 
 Add the shelled eggs to the pan, stir well and continue to heat for 2&ndash;3min, until the eggs are piping hot &mdash; do not overcook, otherwise they will become rubbery. 
 4. 
 Stir in the pine kernels and season the pasta to taste with salt and pepper. 
 Transfer to warm plates or a serving dish. 
 5. 
 Serve with freshly grated Parmesan cheese.  
 Ragu Bolognese 
 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 125g/4oz smoked bacon or ham, finely chopped 1 medium carrot, finely chopped 1 carrot, peeled and diced 1 stick celery, finely chopped 325g/12oz braising steak, finely minced 125g/4oz pork leg steak, finely minced 225g/8oz chicken livers, finely chopped 125ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cup dry red or white wine 375g/15fl oz/2 cups beef stock 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp tomato pur&eacute;e pinch ground nutmeg salt freshly ground black pepper 4 &times; 15ml/tbsp double or thick cream (optional) 
 1. 
 Heat the oil in a large heavy pan, add the bacon or ham, onion, carrot and celery and cook over a moderate heat for about 10min, until lightly browned and well softened. 
 2. 
 Add the meats to the pan with the chicken livers and brown on all sides, stirring constantly. 
 3. 
 Add the wine to the pan, increase the heat and boil briskly until almost all the liquid has cooked away. 
 4. 
 Add the stock and tomato pur&eacute;e to the pan with a little nutmeg, salt and pepper. 
 Bring to the boil, then reduce the heat and simmer the sauce, covered, for about 1hr &mdash; the longer and slower the better. 
 5. 
 Adjust the seasoning to taste, then add the cream, if used, and heat through, without boiling, for 2&ndash;3min. 
 6. 
 Serve with the freshly cooked pasta of your choice. 
 COOK'S NOTE: The difference in flavours between a ragu prepared in this way, using beef, pork and chicken livers, and the accepted standard of Spaghetti Bolognese that appears on so many menus is outstanding. 
 This sauce may also be prepared for lasagne, but omit the cream. 
 Garlic &amp; Walnut Sauce 
 125g/4oz shelled walnut pieces 2&ndash;3 cloves garlic, crushed 250ml/10fl oz/1&frac14; cups single cream 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped marjoram or parsley salt freshly ground black pepper 
 1. 
 Blend the walnuts, garlic, cream and marjoram or parsley in a liquidiser or food processor to a smooth, thick cream. 
 Alternatively, chop the nuts very finely, add the garlic and use a pestle and mortar to grind them down. 
 Add the cream a little at a time and finally add the freshly chopped herbs. 
 2. 
 Season the sauce to taste and stir into freshly cooked pasta, tossed in 25g/1oz butter and 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp walnut oil. 
 COOK'S NOTE: This is a marvellous starter, divided between six or eight people and served with very fine bird's-nest or capellini pasta. 
 HINTS FOR COOKING PASTA 
 * Always add the pasta to a very large pan containing plenty of boiling, salted water. 
 * Adding a little oil to the water prevents pasta from sticking together during cooking. 
 (Using enough water is also important.) 
 * Do not overcook the pasta &mdash; it should be &bquo;al dente&equo; &mdash; ie, firm to the bite. 
 Fresh pasta requires only 3&ndash;4min cooking, a much shorter time than dried pasta. 
 * Instead of rinsing your pasta after cooking, drain it and put in a serving dish or back in the saucepan, then add a few knobs of soft butter. 
 Toss this gently into the pasta to prevent it from sticking together. 
 * Except for the top quality, Italian-produced no-cook pasta, such products should be avoided as they tend to taste of cardboard and have a similar texture. 
 There is always an exception to a rule: I sell an excellent Italian no-cook lasagne.  
 ( front to back ) Garlic &amp; Walnut Sauce; Clam Sauce; Ragu Bolognese; Creamed Leek &amp; Chilli Sauce 
 THE SOIL ASSOCIATION &amp; Organic Foods 
 Interest in the production of foods without the use of chemicals has been growing rapidly. 
 Organic foods were originally mainly sought after by people suffering from various food allergies as conclusive evidence of links between many allergies as conclusive evidence of links between many allergies and other problems and the use of pesticides and modern agri-chemicals was produced. 
 Environmental issues now contribute much to an ever-increasing awareness of the overwork of the land and the pollution of the countryside. 
 In an age where the ability of the land to produce more food than is required for many parts of the world is a fact of life, the argument for organic farming methods has never been stronger. 
 Organic farming is like wild gardening &mdash; you cannot just stop all planning and let nature take over. 
 Striking the balance requires a long lead-in period to allow the land to be cleansed of chemicals and to create a fertile environment through natural manuring and crop rotation. 
 It is also important to realise that weeding of crops is manual rather than by mechanically applied chemicals, therefore taking much longer and being less cost-effective. 
 Most supermarkets now have organically produced fruits and vegetables for sale and the increasing choice of varieties available reflects the public's growing interest in these products. 
 They do command a higher price, but the generally improved flavour, combined with an understanding of the increased effort required to produce the food, warrants the extra expenditure. 
 The organic food most commonly found in a delicatessen is cheese. 
 This is invariably from small-scale farmhouse producers, using just the milk of their own herd, be it cattle, sheep or goats, fed on pastures that are organically fertilised with farmyard manure or a natural material such as seaweed. 
 Very often such cheeses are made with a vegetarian rennet and natural sea salt. 
 Any herbs that are added are also organically produced on the farm. 
 The number of organic cheeses available is constantly increasing and the varieties include hard, Cheddar-types, semi-hard and soft, creamy cheeses. 
 It is very interesting to note that many people who have been unable to eat cheese because of headaches, migraines or digestive problems following its consumption are able to eat organically produced cheeses with no side effects. 
 The Soil Association exists as a standards body for much of the organically produced food in the UK. 
 The well-known symbol of the Association is on all packaged foods that it recognises as being truly organic and indicates that the food has been produced on land that meets all the requirements of the Association. 
 The Soil Association's symbol is the consumer's only guarantee that the food being offered for sale is truly organic and worth the premium that is demanded for foods produced in this way. 
 At the time of writing it is possible that the organisation Food From Britain will assume responsibility for marketing and controlling organic foods, which may result in a new logo to certify organic foods.  
 SYMBOL OF ORGANIC QUALITY organically grown  This product is recognised by the Soil Association as coming from a natural and sustainable system of agriculture using environmentally sound practices and avoiding synthetic fertilisers and sprays. 
 THE GREAT BRITISH EIGHT AND THE REST 
 For many years the choice of British cheeses was limited to the Great British Eight: Caerphilly, Cheshire, Double Gloucester, Lancashire, Red Leicester, Sage Derby, Stilton and Wensleydale. 
 These are, of course, in addition to the superb English Cheddar. 
 Other varieties were made on farms in small quantities and were usually for home consumption only, but the resurgence of interest in farmhouse foods coupled with milk quotas that forced farmers to look for ways of using their surplus milk, has brought about a revolution in British cheesemaking, which is all to the good for the cheese eating public. 
 Cheddar 
 is generally thought of as the all-purpose cheese, for cooking and eating. 
 Available in varying maturity, it must be kept for two years before it attains a real &bquo;bite-back&equo; sharpness. 
 Most good delicatessens should carry a one-year-old farmhouse Cheddar on the rind, and, in my opinion, this is really the only way to buy the cheese. 
 Cheddars may be hard or semi-hard; they are pressed lightly for a matter of hours and then more firmly for a short period of days. 
 This causes much of the whey to be lost, resulting in the firm texture of the cheese. 
 Because Cheddar has been the yardstick of the British cheese industry, it has perhaps suffered more than any of our other cheeses, as it has been forced into mediocrity through extensive mechanisation of the various stages of making. 
 It has also been shaped for ease of packaging, rubberised and refined, with the result that it is often quite tasteless. 
 TIPS FOR BUYING CHEDDAR 
 * Try to buy Cheddar on the rind &mdash; it makes a tremendous difference to the flavour (like cooking meat on the bone), and instantly shows that the cheese has been cut from a truckle and not from a block. 
 * Any unpasteurised cheese will have a stronger, fuller flavour than its treated counterpart. 
 Look for unpasteurised Cheddar. 
 * It is false economy to buy a milder, cheaper Cheddar for cooking. 
 You will require much more to attain a good flavour and will therefore be raising your fat consumption for no good reason. 
 A little of a stronger, if more expensive cheese, is much better for health, wealth and flavour. 
 Caerphilly 
 is the traditional cheese of Wales, although it was first made as recently as the 1880s. 
 It has a slightly sharp flavour and is crumbly and moist. 
 Processed  Caerphilly can be rather bland, but a traditional farmhouse variety has a delicious, if subtle flavour. 
 The cheese is only lightly pressed, which explains its slightly open texture. 
 In Wales, Caerphilly was referred to as &bquo;new cheese&equo;, as it could be ready for sale within ten days of making. 
 Caerphilly is now enjoying a revival in Wales after many years of being made only in England. 
 Cheshire 
 is crumbly in texture and pale peach in colour when young, although it darkens as it ages. 
 Most Cheshire is eaten young, but it is quite delicious when matured. 
 In addition to the usual peach-coloured cheese, there is a white Cheshire which is very popular in the North of England. 
 The difference is only n the colour; the cheese tastes the same. 
 Cheshire is the oldest of all the English cheeses and is referred to in the Domesday Book, although it is thought to date back to pre-Roman times. 
 It is actually a scalded curd cheese, the curds being heated in the whey before being drained. 
 Cheshire is actually sold when it is one to two months old, but it can be matured for over a year. 
 Farmhouse cheeses are bandaged in cloth and either dipped in wax or larded. 
 Blue Cheshire is hard to find but worth the search. 
 It is sharp and strong, the blueing being achieved by the introduction of the Roquefort penicillium . 
 Double Gloucester 
 is rich orange in colour and is made from the morning and evening milkings of Guernsey cattle. 
 One or two farms make the cheese with milk from the Old Gloucester cattle, from which it was traditionally made, and the resulting cheese is quite delicious. 
 The cheese is firm in texture and has a strong flavour. 
 This cheese is often shipped when factory made and combined with other cheeses or flavourings, eg &bquo;Cotswold&equo; being Double Gloucester with herbs. 
 Lancashire 
 is the perfect answer for people who do not like grating cheese &mdash; it crumbles very easily for adding to sauces and salads, etc. 
 Factory made Lancashire cheese can be very mild, but the farmhouse varieties are wonderful. 
 The curds of two days' cheesemaking are mixed together before being milled and pressed. 
 Lancashire is the best cheese to use in place of the Greek Feta when you return from holiday but still hanker after the sun. 
 Leicester 
 &mdash; usually called Red Leicester &mdash; melts quickly and evenly. 
 With its strong colour it is an ideal cheese for cooking in a microwave as it will add colour to dishes that would not otherwise brown. 
 Many people ask for farmhouse Leicester in my shop, in preference to the pre-packed factory-produced variety. 
 Sage Derby 
 is the most common way to buy Derby cheese, which is a great pity as a mature, plain Derby is stronger than a one-year-old Cheddar, but very difficult to find. 
 To produce the green veining in Sage Derby, the leaves of this very pungent herb are soaked in chlorophyll and the resulting juice, rather than the chopped leaves themselves, is added to the cheese. 
 A very subtle flavour results.  
 THE NUTRITIVE VALUE OF CHEESE 
 Cheese is a protein of high biological value and a little goes a long way. 
 Although primarily a protein food, cheese has a high fat content and care should be taken when eating if you are following a strict diet for health or cosmetic reasons. 
 As a general rule, the softer cheeses are less fattening. 
 This does not mean that they have a lower percentage fat content but that the fat present is partly mixed with the liquid that is retained in the cheese. 
 Hard cheeses are more fatty, the whey having been pressed out of the cheese to leave only the fatty curds. 
 The worst thing about dieting is giving up cheese. 
 Stilton 
 is the king of English cheeses, but is as variable as English weather. 
 If you like a mild cheese, buy pasteurised Stilton, but for the true flavour of the cheese, do look out for the unpasteurised cheeses. 
 Prime Stilton is available from the autumn onwards, being made with summer milk. 
 These cheeses have a slightly yellower paste than the Stiltons available at other times of the year and are perfect for eating at Christmas. 
 Stilton is blued by using the Roquefort penicillium  and should always be creamy and not crumbly. 
 Left-over Stilton is very good for cooking and is an affordable substitute for Roquefort. 
 White Stilton is a very young, immature Stilton and does not compare to the traditional blue variety, although I like it in salads and for cooking, where its slightly sharp flavour is penetrating. 
 Wensleydale 
 is crumbly, being only lightly pressed, and is the traditional cheese of the North for eating with apple pies, fruit and cake. 
 Like Cheshire, Wensleydale is an ancient cheese, made originally by the monks at Jervaulx Abbey. 
 Many of its contemporaries, such as Coverdale and Swaledale, which never transferred to large-scale factory production, have recently been revived, but Wensleydale is the best known of this group. 
 These traditional cheeses have now been joined by a host of other British cheeses, some based on ancient recipes but others on new ideas, and British cheesemaking is enjoying a glittering renaissance. 
 Farmhouse cheeses are being made throughout the British Isles and many are available all over the country through specialist cheese shops. 
 It is, however, difficult for the cheesemaker to equate maintaining quality and making money. 
 Cheesemaking is very labour-intensive and the producer must be dedicated to his art to maintain his enthusiasm. 
 The cheesemaker has the best control over his cheese if he is able to use the milk from his own flock or herd &mdash; he then knows exactly what he is getting and where the animals have been grazed as the type of grass and subsoil contributes much to the flavour of the milk and then the cheese. 
 The following are some of my favourite farmhouse British cheeses that you should be able to get without too much difficulty:  
 Castle Hill 
 is a Sussex Cheddar-type cheese made on a large scale but only from the milk of a single Friesian herd. 
 As it is unpasteurised, it is strong and rounded. 
 Lanark Blue &amp; Dunsyre Blue 
 are made in Scotland from ewes' milk and cows' milk respectively. 
 Lanark Blue is very similar to Roquefort and nearly as expensive, but the Dunsyre Blue is more affordable and has a creamy yet pungent flavour. 
 Llangloffan 
 is my favourite of the harder Welsh cheeses. 
 It can be sold mild when young, or matured to a greater depth of flavour. 
 It is always creamy, being made from Jersey milk. 
 Milleens 
 is an Irish soft cheese with a washed rind, similar to Port Salut. 
 It is clean and fresh, although well flavoured. 
 Pencarreg 
 is a soft Welsh organic Brie, made from unpasteurised milk, so has a full flavour. 
 Single Gloucester 
 is another traditional cheese that is enjoying a revival. 
 It should be made from just the morning milk taken from Old Gloucester cows. 
 It is softer and milder than Double Gloucester and, although it tastes creamy, is relatively low in fat. 
 Spenwood 
 is a delightful sheep's milk cheese from the same dairy as the Wellington. 
 It is hard, like the Spanish sheep's milk cheese Manchego, and has a flavour that is slightly similar to Gruy&egrave;re. 
 It cooks well and is particularly useful for children who are allergic to cows' milk cheeses, although all sheep's milk cheeses are expensive for everyday use. 
 Swaledale 
 is a traditional cheese of the same era as Wensleydale, which has been revived and is now selling well. 
 It is slightly creamier than Wensleydale, but is also lightly pressed so it always has a soft texture. 
 Swaledale is beautiful when first cut. 
 If your cheesemonger cuts a Swaledale for the person in front of you, make sure that you take a piece as well. 
 Teifi 
 is best described as Welsh Edam, being very similar in texture and flavour. 
 It is sold with various flavourings added, such as garlic, chives, peppers, etc. 
 Like Edam, Teifi is waxed and keeps well. 
 Wellington 
 is made from Guernsey milk from the Duke of Wellington's cattle and processed in vats that were originally used for making Edam. 
 The cheese is most similar to a good Double Gloucester and is very creamy in flavour. 
 The cheeses are matured in cellars at Stratfield Saye, the country home of the Duke. 
 Wheatland &amp; Wheatland Moor 
 are made in Devon in the style of traditional French cheeses, the Wheatland being like the best farmhouse Brie and the Moor following a recipe for Port Salut. 
 Both are made on a farm that uses only calcified seaweed to fertilise the ground.  
 ( l to r ) Burndell goats' milk cheese; Cheddar; Cheshire; Dunsyre Blue; Wheatland; Belstone; Swaledale; Castle Hill; Wheatland Moor ( at front ); Wellington; Teifi; Malthouse Coulommier goats' milk cheeses 
 CHEESEMAKING Then &amp; Now 
 There are many stories concerning man's first attempts at making cheese. 
 Mammals were first domesticated for their milk around 6000BC and cheesemaking was a natural progression from the acid that formed naturally in the milk and curdled it. 
 The most popular legend concerning true cheesemaking is that of a herdsman who put fresh milk into an animal's stomach pouch that had not been cleaned and sterilised and discovered that the action of the remaining rennet reacted with the milk to form a sweet cheese, as opposed to the known acid variety. 
 Cheeses have evolved throughout history and new varieties are still being made today. 
 The early travellers who returned from all parts of the world with new recipes and ideas for incorporating herbs and spices did much to widen the knowledge of cheesemaking techniques. 
 All cheeses are made in basically the same way, by heating milk to separate the curds from the whey and then cutting the curds before pressing to yield the finished cheese. 
 The type of milk used and additives to the natural ingredients will all affect the finished cheese, as will the actual process of making the cheese. 
 Factory-made cheeses are manufactured in huge quantities and each process is mechanised. 
 The stirring is automatic, the cutting is done by machine and the milling is done by a machine working on the principle of a giant food processor. 
 Such mechanisation produces very consistent results throughout the year, but the cheeses often lack the authentic flavour of handmade varieties. 
 CHEESEMAKING NOW The Old-fashioned Way 
 The revival of small-scale farmhouses cheeses and the subsequent interest in these individual products has been brought about partly by the farmers' need to cut the amount of milk that they send to the Milk Marketing Board and partly by the public's demand for &bquo;real&equo; cheeses with traditional texture and flavour. 
 I was lucky enough to join the makers of Gospel Green, a Sussex-made hard cheese, to watch the cheesemaking in process. 
 Here is a true marriage of traditional methods and equipment with modern health and hygiene requirements &mdash; their vat,  tools and press are old equipment that was purchased from an elderly cheesemaker some twenty years ago, together with the recipe for the cheese. 
 I had a relatively easy morning, joining James and Cathy Lane once the 409 litres (90gal) of Friesian milk was in the vat in the dairy at 7.30am (they had risen at 5.30 to do the milking). 
 One cow will yield up to 23 litres (5gal) of milk and 4&frac12; litres (1gal) should make 450g (1lb) of cheese. 
 The Lanes' vat has had to be fitted with a new stainless steel liner. 
 It is held in a double-skinned tank which is filled with hot water to raise the temperature of the milk. 
 An enzyme starter culture is added to the milk at 1.1&deg;C (30&deg;F) and stirred for 5min with a curd fork. 
 This starts to raise the acidity of the milk and thus to curdle it. 
 Unpasteurised milk, such as used for Gospel Green cheese, will curdle naturally through the action of the bacteria that is present when the milk is heated, but the addition of the starter culture, which must always be used when cheese is made from pasteurised milk, hastens the process. 
 After a period of time, the milk appears to skin; this is the cream rising to the surface of the vat. 
 Rennet is added to the vat, then the milk is deep stirred, right to the bottom of the tank, to ensure that the rennet is thoroughly mixed, and the top is stirred to keep the cream properly blended. 
 After a period of some 45min, the vat appeared full of blancmange. 
 The curds could be pulled away from the edge of the vat, in the same way as a cooked Victoria sandwich can be lightly pulled away from the edge of a cake tin, and the curd could be cut in a straight line with a finger. 
 The curds are then cut with a curd knife, from top to bottom and from side to side, and, after a short time, the curd sinks to the bottom of the vat and the whey rises. 
 The temperature in the vat is then raised very slowly to 3.3&amp;C (38&amp;F). 
 This process must not be rushed or the final cheese will be of poor quality and liable to develop faults while it matures. 
 The developing cheese must be stirred throughout this process. 
 I visited the Lanes on a very cold day and the correct temperature was eventually obtained within the vat by flushing hot water through the double skin of the liner. 
 The curds were left to settle to the bottom of the vat, a process known as pitching. 
 The whey, which is ideal for feeding to pigs, is then drained from the vat. 
 Cheesemaking only becomes totally economic if all the products from the process can be used. 
 The curds are lifted onto muslin-covered racks and cut through with a knife before they are left to drain. 
 The cutting and draining is done twice. 
 The curds are now quite hard and at this stage resemble a chunky cottage cheese crossed with the homemade cheese or paneer as used in Indian cookery. 
 The drained curd, now a solid mass, is turned out of the muslin and the really hard work of milling begins. 
 The firm curd is squeezed through the cheesemaker's fingers to break it into small particles &mdash; they must be small or the finished cheese will be of an uneven texture. 
 I imagine that this would be a good finger exercise for resting concert pianists &mdash; after the first few minutes my digits were dead! 
 Salt is then lightly worked into the curds before they are packed into muslin-lined truckles or moulds. 
 The Gospel Green wooden truckle ends have had to be replaced with pvc equivalents to satisfy current health standard requirements. 
 The truckles are lightly pressed for 24hr, then turned and pressed more firmly for a further 24hr period, during which more whey is lost from the cheese. 
 After 48hr the cheeses are trimmed and wrapped in sterilised muslin, which is stuck to the cheese with a flour and water paste. 
 The cheeses are matured in a specially constructed humid cellar for 2&frac12;&ndash;3 months, during which time they lose a further 225&ndash;325g/8&ndash;12oz in weight and develop a mould or rind beneath the muslin. 
 Cheesemaking by hand is a long and tiring process &mdash; it sounds idyllic but is very hard, physical work. 
 Turning a full cellar of Gospel Green cheeses can take up to 2hr and each cheese must be turned every day. 
 When I visited the dairy we left at 2pm, after cleaning the walls, floor and all the cheesemaking equipment. 
 Handmade cheeses are justifiably more expensive than the factory-produced equivalents and are, in my opinion, worth every penny. 
 GOSPEL GREEN 
 is a close-textured cheddar-type cheese with a full and distinctive flavour. 
 It is available by post, except in the summer months when there may be a seasonal shortage. 
 For further details contact James &amp; Cathy Lane, Gospel Green Cottage, nr Haslemere, Surrey.  
 SHEEP'S &amp; GOATS' MILK CHEESES 
 Any animal that can be milked can provide the raw material for making cheese. 
 It is said that yaks' milk is sometimes used and in Italy buffalos' milk is made into cheese. 
 however, cows' milk is the standard, but there is a growing market for cheeses made from the milk of sheep or goats. 
 They tend to have a distinctive, pungent flavour and are quite different from other cheeses. 
 The curds are often whiter and paler. 
 Ewes' milk cheese is generally hard, while goats' milk varieties may be processed in many ways. 
 Of all the ewes' milk cheeses, Roquefort is surely the best known. 
 Roqueforts exported from France are often well salted to improve their keeping qualities, but the variety produced in France has a well-balanced, almost delicate flavour. 
 Production of Roquefort is strictly controlled and the cheeses are stamped in red with a picture of a sheep to show that they are genuine, made with milk from Larzac sheep and matured in caves in Combalou. 
 Roquefort is always foil wrapped as this prevents a rind from forming on the cheese. 
 Pecorino, Feta and Manchego are the best known of the remaining ewes' milk cheeses. 
 The first, from Italy, is a hard grana cheese and is excellent for all Italian cookery. 
 It is sharper than Parmesan and combines well with pasta (see Pesto alla Genovese, p23). 
 Pecorino Romano is the best variety of this cheese and has a white, waxy rind. 
 Feta is a much softer ewes' milk cheese and is made throughout the eastern Mediterranean. 
 It is delicious in salads of onion, tomato and juicy black olives, sprinkled with fresh oregano. 
 Of all the Spanish cheeses, Manchego is the only one to be widely available outside Spain. 
 The pure ewes' milk cheese is of a better flavour than the cheaper mixed milk version and it also has a very dry texture. 
 The French made countless varieties of goats' milk cheeses which are often small and wrapped in a chestnut leaf and then tied with raffia (see p67). 
 Ch&egrave;vre is the best known of all the goats' milk cheeses, possibly because the name is actually a generic term for all goats' milk cheese. 
 It is usually sold in a log and displayed on straw. 
 English goat-keepers are now producing some excellent cheeses &mdash; I stock four that are all made in Sussex. 
 Fresh goats' milk cheese is available in many supermarkets and has a slightly sharper flavour than fromage frais. 
 Some goats' milk cheeses are lightly pressed and then rolled in herbs, while others are soft, unpressed, surface-ripened cheeses made in the Coulommiers style. 
 I keep one pressed goats' milk cheese, Burndell, which has a creamy texture and a mild flavour. 
 It is waxed like an Edam and is quite delicious. 
 Many goats' milk cheeses are produced organically by small-scale farmers and smallholders. 
 Both ewes' and goats' milk cheeses are often sold in olive oil, flavoured with herbs and spices and they are delicious. 
 Usually eaten cold with the flavoured oil spooned over, these cheeses are also excellent when placed under a very hot grill until browned.  
 BLUE CHEESES 
 There are many varieties of blue cheeses, most of which are produced by introducing a controlled penicillium  into the paste during ripening, although a few cheeses do blue naturally. 
 Most blue cheeses are cheeses in their own right, but others are treated versions of existing cheeses, eg Cheshire and Blue Cheshire. 
 The penicillium  is often introduced to the cheeses by syringe and spreads through the tiny gaps between the lightly pressed curds. 
 Nearly all blue cheeses are scalded and lightly pressed and tend to crumble. 
 It is virtually impossible to grate then, so they should be broken up by stroking with a fork if required for cooking. 
 Like Roquefort (see p96), most blue cheeses are wrapped in foil to prevent any skin or crust from forming on the cheese. 
 It is therefore unreasonable to question the fact that the cheese is weighed with the foil on if you normally buy a rinded cheese that is weighed with the outer crust. 
 The British blue cheeses are described on pp86&ndash;92. 
 Of the French cheeses, Bleu d'Auvergne and Forme d'Ambert are my favourites, in addition to Roquefort. 
 Both are creamy and slightly sharp with a close and even blueing. 
 Many other varieties of French blue cheeses are available both in France and in cheese shops throughout the world. 
 Danish Blue is one of the best known of the blue cheeses, but it is very sharp and unrefined. 
 Blau Castello is a relatively new Danish cheese with a very creamy paste and slightly sharp but tempered flavour. 
 The Italians make wonderful blue cheeses of which the best known are Gorgonzola, from Lombardy, and Dolcelatte, which literally means sweet milk. 
 The best Gorgonzolas should be clean and sharp and almost green in appearance rather than blue. 
 Blue cheeses are used quite extensively in Italian cooking and Gorgonzola is much better for this purpose than the slightly sweeter Dolcelatte. 
 Of the remaining blue cheeses, Mycella is probably the best known. 
 It is sometimes called the Danish Gorgonzola, although the veining is greenish in colour and the paste is very yellow. 
 Mycella is relatively mild for a blue cheese.  
 THE SPICE OF LIFE 
 Some foods would be very bland without the judicious use of spices and other seasonings. 
 Many cuisines that are based on grains and pulses make extensive use of a wide range of spices to flavour their foods and this can clearly be seen in Indian and Far Eastern cookery. 
 The following spices are shown on p99 and are some of the most popular  
 Bay leaves 
 Bay trees grow well in almost any country and the dried leaves are added to many stews and casseroles, as well as to countless other dishes. 
 Bay leaves should always be broken to release their flavour which is mainly contained in the stalk. 
 I think that bay is very underrated and should be used more by itself to reveal its flavour. 
 Black peppercorns 
 are an essential spice for any form of cookery (see p57). 
 Cardamoms 
 can be green or black and are a collection of aromatic seeds contained in a pod which must be split to release the full flavour. 
 Cardamoms are used to flavour rice and, after saffron, are the world's most expensive spice. 
 Cassia bark 
 is the Oriental version of cinnamon and can be used as a dried bark or ground into powder form. 
 Chillis 
 are very hot, dried peppers. 
 Do not rub your eyes when preparing them. 
 They are native to South America and are used mainly in Mexican cookery, although some Indian recipes also include them. 
 Cloves 
 are dried flower buds and are usually sold whole. 
 Ground cloves, if available can produce a delicious flavour in Christmas puddings. 
 Cloves are very aromatic and can be used for their scent, as in orange pomanders, as well as for their ability to flavour both sweet and savoury dishes. 
 Cumin Seeds 
 are used in curries and also extensively in Mexican cookery. 
 The seeds are often ground and the resulting powder is a basic ingredient of curry spice mix. 
 Desiccated coconut 
 is not strictly a spice but is a basic ingredient for many curries as well as being used extensively for cakes and desserts. 
 Fenugreek 
 is often sold as dried seeds but is really more useful in powder form, when it is a vital ingredient in many curries. 
 Mace 
 is the outer husk of the nutmeg and has a strong but fragrant flavour. 
 I combine mace with bay, especially for seasoning pork or oily fish, such as herrings.  
 Star anise 
 is a dried pod containing anise seeds. 
 It is used in Chinese cookery. 
 Turmeric 
 is the ground root of a member of the ginger family. 
 It has little flavour and is used mainly to colour foods. 
 If you cannot afford saffron, use turmeric, but you will miss the delicate fragrance of the Spanish spice. 
 White mustard seeds 
 These hot seeds are used for English mustard (see p60). 
 White poppy seeds 
 are less common than blue, and are used mainly in Indian and Jewish cookery. 
 They have a distinctively nutty flavour and texture. 
 Other spices that you may only be able to find in a delicatessen include juniper berries, which are used to flavour gin and are essential when cooking game casseroles; tamarind seed, which is really a dried pulp and is used in curries; and annatto which is a small seed used in latin American cookery. 
 The outer casing is removed from these seeds and used as a food dye; it is used extensively on washed rind cheeses. 
 Pepper sauces 
 are made mainly in South America, where the most famous of all is Tabasco sauce. 
 Tabasco is so well known that it is to pepper sauces what Hoover is to vacuum cleaners. 
 It is named after the Tabasco region of Mexico where the peppers used in its production are grown. 
 They are very hot &mdash; much stronger than any fresh chillis that are available in the UK. 
 The peppers are pulped, then left to mature for three years before being distilled with vinegar. 
 The seeds and skins of the peppers are removed from the sauce which is then bottled. 
 Tabasco can be added to casseroles and rice dishes. 
 I find it rather overpowering in fish recipes, but it is used extensively in Creole cookery and in dishes such as seafood gumbo. 
 As a change from the very fiery nature of Tabasco, I sometimes enjoy the slightly sweeter, thicker opaque chilli sauces from Indo-China. 
 These have a roundness that belies their heat. 
 Sambals are also pepper sauces, although reduced to give a thick relish used as a chutney (see p54). 
 These are used in Indonesian and Thai cookery.  
 Spices: 1&amp;15 Green cardamoms; 2 white mustard seed; 3 bay leaves; 4 cumin seeds; 5 cassia bark; 6 fenugreek seeds; 7&amp;18 brown cardamoms; 8 turmeric; 9 cloves; 10 chillis; 11&amp;12 peppercorns; 13 mace; 14 desiccated coconut; 16 star anise; 17 white poppy seeds 
 FIESTA FOODS 
 Mexican food is becoming more and more popular. 
 Chilli con carne is an established favourite and many shops stock the ingredients for making tacos &mdash; crispy pancake envelopes that contain a deliciously spicy meat or fish filling, all topped with salad and a tangy tomato sauce. 
 Delicatessens often stock a wider range of Mexican ingredients to enable you to produce authentically flavoured dishes. 
 These should include mild and hot peppers (the jalape&ntilde;o pepper is not for the faint hearted), and tomato sauces for tacos which can also be used for many other dishes. 
 It is often advisable to use the commercially prepared seasonings for tacos and chilli as many of the varieties of red and chilli peppers that are abundant in Mexico cannot be obtained easily in other countries. 
 I have chosen the following recipes to show the versatility of Mexican food. 
 They are all relatively quick to prepare and could be combined for a Mexican buffet party. 
 Simple salads of lettuce, tomatoes and olives may accompany most of the main dishes. 
 Avocado Soup 
 Serves 4 
 This vivid green soup is a colourful beginning to any meal. 
 It is usually served well chilled, but may also be eaten warm. 
 Do not boil the soup, especially if you add soured cream or natural yogurt. 
 750ml/1&frac12;pt/3&frac34;cups chicken stock 3 ripe avocados 1 can Mexican green chillis in brine (approx 125g/4oz), drained salt and pepper soured cream or natural yogurt (optional) 
 1. 
 Cool the chicken stock, then place in a blender or food processor with the flesh of the avocados, half the green chillis and a little salt and pepper. 
 Process until smooth. 
 2. 
 Turn into a serving dish and chill in the refrigerator for 1&ndash;2hr. 
 3. 
 Chop the remaining chillis and serve them with the chilled soup, after adding 2&ndash;3 &times; 15ml/tbsp soured cream or natural yogurt, if required. 
 Mexican Tomato Soup 
 Serves 4 
 A spicy variation on a traditional favourite in any country. 
 Tostada shells may be served with this soup; they are flat fried tortilla pancakes which require heating in a moderate oven for a few minutes before serving. 
 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp oil 1 large onion, chopped 1 clove garlic, crushed 1 green pepper, chopped 1 &times; 400g/14oz can chopped tomatoes 1 packet taco seasoning mix 500ml/1pt/2&frac12; cups boiling chicken stock 
 1. 
 Heat the oil in a large saucepan, add the onion, garlic and green pepper and cook until soft. 
 2. 
 Add the chopped tomatoes, the taco seasoning mix and the stock. 
 Cover and simmer for 20min. 
 3. 
 Season to taste if necessary, and serve with cro&ucirc;tons, tortilla chips or heated tostada shells. 
 Tortilla Chip Pie 
 Serves 4&ndash;6 (see p103) 
 This is a very good way of introducing the family to Mexican food. 
 The pastry case contains a spicy beef taco filling and the grated cheese topping browns in the oven to give a tempting appearance. 
 1 &times; 22cm/8in pre-baked pastry case 450g/1lb minced beef 1 packet taco seasoning mix 150ml/6fl oz/&frac34; cup water 1 ripe avocado, peeled and sliced (optional) 4 tomatoes, sliced 50&ndash;75g/2&ndash;3oz Cheddar cheese, grated tortilla chips to serve 
 1. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 5/190&deg;C/375&deg;F. 
 Place the pastry case on a baking sheet. 
 2. 
 Cook the minced beef in a saucepan over a high heat until browned. 
 Drain off any fat. 
 Add the taco seasoning mix and the water, stir well and simmer for 20min. 
 3. 
 Pile the meat into the pastry case and top with the sliced tomatoes and then the grated cheese. 
  Place in the pre-heated oven for 30&ndash;40min, until the cheese is golden brown. 
 4. 
 Before serving, arrange the tortilla chips around the pie on top of the cheese. 
 COOK'S NOTE: A layer of soured cream may be added to the pie for extra flavour. 
 I find it best to spread the cream over the minced beef, and then to top that with the avocado (if used) and the tomato. 
 Four Bean Salad 
 Serves 6 (see p103) 
 There are many variations on this popular and filling salad. 
 Use the beans of your choice, but do include red kidney beans. 
 175g/6oz green beans 175g/6oz broad beans 1 &times; 400g/14oz chick peas 1 &times; 400g/14oz can red kidney beans 100ml/4fl oz vinaigrette dressing good pinch ground chilli salt and pepper to taste 
 1. 
 Cook the green and broad beans in boiling salted water until just tender. 
 Drain and refresh immediately by steeping them in cold water. 
 2. 
 Drain and rinse the chick peas and kidney beans and combine with other beans. 
 3. 
 Add the chilli to the vinaigrette dressing, pour over the salad and toss. 
 Chill well, then toss again before serving. 
 Guacamole 
 Serves 8 (see p102) 
 No Mexican party would be complete without this renowned avocado dip. 
 2 large avocados, peeled and stoned juice of 1 lime 1 jar taco tomato sauce, mild or hot 2 cloves garlic, crushed salt to taste coriander sprigs or chilli powder to garnish tortilla chips to serve 
 1. 
 Place the avocados, lime juice, taco sauce and garlic in a blender or food processor and process until smooth. 
 Season to taste with salt and transfer to a serving bowl. 
 2. 
 Garnish the guacamole with chilli powder or coriander sprigs, then serve in the centre of a plate of tortilla chips. 
 Turkey with Mexican Mole Pepper Sauce 
 Serves 4 
 Turkey with Mexican Mole Pepper Sauce is based on a classic dish, eaten throughout Mexico, of turkey cooked in a fried chilli sauce &mdash; this is to Mexicans what curry is to Indians. 
 The classic dish may require preparation over a period of two days, but this simple variation is much quicker. 
 The big talking point is the addition of grated chocolate to darken and enrich the sauce. 
 Don't worry about the mole &mdash; it's the Mexican word for sauce! 
 This dish equates to a vindaloo curry and should be eaten with respect. 
 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp oil 1 &times; 200g/7oz can jalape&ntilde;o peppers, drained and chopped 1 &times; 113g/4oz Mexican green chillis in brine, drained and chopped 2 cloves garlic, crushed 4 large turkey breasts, skinned and beaten 50g/2oz toasted sesame seeds 450g/1lb tomatoes, chopped 125g/4oz salted roast peanuts &frac12; &times; 5ml/tsp ground aniseed 6 cloves freshly ground black pepper 500ml/1pt/2&amp; cups boiling chicken stock 4 &times; 15ml/tbsp tomato pur&eacute;e 40g/1&amp;oz bitter cooking chocolate salt plain boiled rice and salad to serve 
 1. 
 Heat the oil in a large flameproof casserole dish and cook the jalape&ntilde;os, chillis and garlic until softened. 
 Add the turkey breasts and cook until browned on both sides. 
 2. 
 Add half the sesame seeds to the casserole with the tomatoes, peanuts, aniseed, cloves, pepper and stock. 
 Bring to the boil, then cover and simmer very slowly for 1&ndash;1&amp;hr, until the turkey is tender. 
 3. 
 Remove the turkey from the pan and keep warm on a serving dish. 
  4. 
 Liquidise the sauce. 
 Add the tomato pur&eacute;e, grated chocolate and salt and pepper to taste. 
 5. 
 Heat the sauce gently until all the ingredients are well combined. 
 6. 
 Serve the turkey breasts sprinkled with the remaining sesame seeds and with the sauce handed separately. 
 Beef &amp; Green Chilli Stew 
 Serves 6 (see p102) 
 This is a rich, satisfying casserole with more than a taste of the exotic, but which could be included in nearly any dinner party menu. 
 The green chillis used are the milder of the Mexican peppers. 
 Tostada shells may be served in place of potatoes. 
 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp oil 1 large onion, sliced (use a red onion if possible) 2 cloves garlic, crushed 675g/1&frac12;lb braising steak, trimmed and cubed 1 packet taco seasoning mix 1 &times; 400g/14oz can chopped tomatoes 1 can Mexican green chillis in brine, drained and chopped 1 &times; 400g/14oz can Mexican refried beans salt and pepper parsley to garnish 
 1. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 4/180&deg;C/350&deg;F. 
 2. 
 Heat the oil in a large pan, add the onion and garlic and cook until soft. 
 3. 
 Toss the beef in the taco seasoning mix, then add to the pan and brown the meat on all sides. 
 4. 
 Add the chopped tomatoes, chillis and refried beans to the casserole with a little salt and pepper. 
 5. 
 Bring to the boil, then cover and cook in the pre-heated oven for 2hr or until the beef is tender. 
 6. 
 Season to taste and sprinkle with parsley before serving. 
 Nachos 
 Serves 12 
 This is the basic recipe for nachos &mdash; Mexican canap&eacute;s. 
 You may add other toppings if you wish, but always use refried beans as the base. 
 Nachips are small round tortilla pancakes. 
 A slice of chorizo sausage may be placed on top of the refried beans for variety. 
 Chorizo is used widely in Mexican food, showing the strong Spanish influence. 
 1 packet nachips 1 &times; 400g/14 oz can refried beans 125g/4oz Cheddar cheese, grated 1 can Mexican green chillis in brine, drained and chopped or 1 can jalape&ntilde;o peppers, drained and sliced or black olives for garnish 
 1. 
 Spread the nachips with a thickish layer of refried beans and place them in a grill pan on a rack. 
 2. 
 Scatter a little grated cheese over the nachos and top each one with either chopped green chillis, jalapeno slices or olives. 
 3. 
 Place under a hot grill until the cheese has melted. 
 Serve immediately. 
 Cebiche 
 Serves 4 (see p103) 
 Like the Japanese, the Mexicans eat raw fish. 
 In this variation on a very traditional recipe, the fish is marinaded in lime juice and takes on a white, cooked appearance. 
 Serve as a starter or a lunch or supper dish. 
 450g/1lb fresh white fish fillets, eg cod, haddock, plaice, etc juice of 6 limes, or 4 limes and 2 lemons 1 jar mild taco tomato sauce salt and pepper &frac12; &times; 5ml/tsp dried oregano 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil rice salad or warmed pitta bread for serving 
 1. 
 Skin the fish, remove any bones and cut into bite-sized pieces. 
 Place the fish in a small china dish and add the lime juice, making sure that all the fish is completely covered. 
 2. 
 Cover the dish and place in the refrigerator for at least 5hr, until the fish has turned white and has a cooked appearance. 
 Stir the fish carefully once or twice during marinading. 
 3. 
 Carefully stir the taco sauce, salt and pepper, oregano and olive oil into the fish. 
 Chill for a further 45&ndash;60min. 
 4. 
 Serve with rice salad or warmed pitta bread.  
 ( l to r ) Beef &amp; Chilli Stew; Guacamole; Tortilla Chip Pie; Cebiche; Four Bean Salad 
 Fish Tales 
 Delicatessens stock an interesting selection of canned fish and they will always stock smoked salmon. 
 The best smoked salmon is definitely Scotch; it has a pinker appearance than the inferior Canadian salmon. 
 Pre-sliced salmon should never be chunky or fatty and should be evenly sliced. 
 Trimmings are a good buy for making into p&acirc;t&eacute;s and dips. 
 I have also made a very rich soup from smoked salmon pieces, but be very cautious about your fish stock if it is not to be spoiled by excessive salt. 
 I think that smoked salmon in quiches is rather an extravagance. 
 Gravadlax makes a delicious alternative to smoked salmon and is the raw fish marinated with plenty of herbs, especially dill. 
 It may be used in salads, as on p107, or served with a mustard-based sauce and brown bread and butter as a starter. 
 Gravadlax can be more expensive than the best smoked salmon. 
 The best canned fish is further improved if it is steeped in olive oil rather than a cheaper vegetable oil. 
 Sardines and anchovies are worth extra money if canned in olive oil and their flavour is greatly improved, even if you do not eat the oil. 
 Gaffelbitter are tiny Scandinavian herring fillets and can be purchased in a variety of sauces, of which red wine and sherry are the most popular. 
 They are traditionally served to accompany egg dishes. 
 Use them in egg mayonnaise, omelettes or simply to top scrambled eggs. 
 Of the various smoked shellfish available, smoked mussels and oysters are the most popular, and smoked squid is the sort of thing that browsers pick up, show their friends and put down again. 
 Mussels and oysters are usually canned in cotton seed oil which is very strong, so they should be well rinsed before use and, if necessary, tossed in a little olive oil to restore their flavour. 
 They are best used for cocktail savouries, but the cheaper mussels make a very tasty pasta sauce. 
 SMOKING IS GOOD FOR YOU! 
 Smoking is a very ancient art that has been used for hundreds of years to preserve fish and meat, preferred to salting because it does not destroy the natural flavour of the food to the same extent. 
 Gutted raw fish are smoked slowly over wood chips and it is generally agreed that oak gives the best flavour, although other woods are preferred in some part of the world. 
 Smoking takes place in a smoke house which is linked by a pipe to a firebox. 
 The smoke is directed across the food and out of the smokehouse. 
 It is a very gentle process and the length of time required to complete the smoking depends on the size of the fish or meat to be processed. 
 Home smokeries may be purchased or made in large tins or drums. 
 Quails' Eggs with Gravadlax 
 Serves 4 
 125g/4oz gravadlax, finely sliced and chopped 125g/4oz chunk cucumber, finely diced 240g/approx 8oz tub natural Greek yogurt salt and freshly ground black pepper 12 quails' eggs green or blue food colouring salad garnish 
 1. 
 Combine the gravadlax, cucumber and yogurt in a bowl, add salt and white pepper to taste. 
 Leave in the refrigerator for the flavours to blend for at least 1hr. 
 2. 
 Place the quails' eggs in a pan of boiling water and boil for 3min. 
 Drain and refresh immediately in cold water, cracking the egg shells to allow the eggs to cool more quickly. 
 3. 
 Lightly crush the shells of the eggs, then drop them into a very strong solution of water and food colouring (approx 40ml/1&frac12;fl oz to 125ml/5fl oz water). 
 Leave the eggs to colour for 2&ndash;3hr. 
 Carefully peel the eggs, then leave to dry. 
 4. 
 Make a small bed of salad on each plate, then top with the gravadlax and cucumber salad. 
 Arrange three eggs on each plate and garnish with fresh dill or mint. 
 Serve with warm fingers of pitta bread or Melba toast.  
 Quails' Eggs with Gravadlax 
 DRIED MUSHROOMS 
 One of the more unusual foods to be found in a delicatessen are dried mushrooms. 
 These are grown mainly in France, although Italy and Poland also produce some varieties. 
 The most common are ceps and chanterelles. 
 The flavour of these mushrooms is superb and, although they are expensive, they are worth treating yourself to for a special occasion. 
 Dried mushrooms keep for at least a year and 75g/3oz is equivalent to 450g/1lb of fresh ones. 
 Wherever possible, keep the water that the mushrooms are soaked in for use in the recipe. 
 POT ROASTED BEEF WITH MUSHROOM &amp; CREAM SAUCE 
 Serves 6&ndash;8 
 25g/1oz dried mushrooms, preferably ceps 500ml/1pt/2&frac12; cups boiling water 25g/1oz butter 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 1,800g/4lb joint boned and rolled rib of beef 1 clove garlic, crushed few drops Tabasco sauce salt and freshly ground black pepper 125ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cup double or thick cream 1 egg yolk 
 1. 
 Place the mushrooms in a bowl and cover with the boiling water then leave to soak for at least 20min. 
 2. 
 Heat together the butter and olive oil in a large pan or casserole dish, until the butter has melted. 
 Add the beef and cook quickly on all sides until browned. 
 Remove the meat from the pan. 
 3. 
 Drain the mushrooms with a slotted spoon and add them to the fat and juices in the pan. 
 Cover and sweat over a low heat for 4&ndash;5min, stirring once. 
 Return the meat to the pan and add the juice from the mushrooms with the garlic and Tabasco sauce. 
 Cook, tightly covered with a lid, for 2&frac12;hr, until tender when tested with a fork. 
 4. 
 Remove the meat from the pan and allow to stand for a few minutes before slicing. 
 5. 
 Beat together the cream and egg yolk, then add to the pan. 
 Cook slowly, stirring constantly, until thickened but do not allow the sauce to boil or the cream will curdle and the egg will scramble. 
 Season to taste, then serve over the sliced beef. 
 MUSHROOM SOUFFL&Eacute;S 
 Makes 36 
 These tiny souffl&eacute;s make a delicious pre-dinner nibble and are strongly flavoured by the dried mushrooms. 
 36 pre-cooked pastry cocktail cases 25g/1oz dried mushrooms 25g/1oz butter 1 clove garlic, crushed pinch mace 25g/1oz flour 125ml/5fl oz/&frac23; cup soured cream 2 eggs, separated 
 1. 
 Place the mushrooms in a bowl and cover with boiling water. 
 Leave for 15&ndash;20min, then drain and chop. 
 2. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 5/190&deg;C/375&deg;F. 
 Place the pastry cases on baking sheets. 
 3. 
 Melt the butter in a pan, add the chopped mushrooms, garlic and mace and cook for 2&ndash;3min, until the mushrooms are soft. 
 Add the flour and cook for a few seconds, then remove the pan from the heat and add the soured cream and the egg yolks. 
 Beat well. 
 4. 
 Whisk the egg whites until stiff, then fold them into the mixture. 
 Use to fill the pastry cases and bake immediately in the pre-heated oven for 10&ndash;12min, until set. 
 5. 
 Serve immediately.  
 SUN-DRIED TOMATOES 
 These expensive, shrivelled and unappealing tomatoes possess an incredible flavour that is quite outstanding. 
 Recently introduced to the UK, I hope that sun-dried tomatoes will remain essential for the kitchen store-cupboard for as long as olive oil, salt and pepper are there. 
 Keep the opened jar in the refrigerator; the tomatoes are packed in olive oil which may become cloudy, but this will not affect the flavour. 
 Slightly cheaper sun-dried tomatoes are now available in dry form. 
 Chop and add to casseroles or steep in boiling water for a few minutes before adding to salads. 
 Summer Lamb Ragout 
 Serves 6 (opposite) 
 This casserole uses summer vegetables with the addition of sun-dried tomatoes to give a wonderfully rich flavour. 
 Passata and stock are used in preference to wine for the casserole, to allow the flavour of the young lamb and vegetables to dominate the dish. 
 2kg/4&ndash;4&frac12;lb shoulder of lamb 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 15g/&amp;oz butter 1 large onion, sliced 1 red pepper, seeded and sliced 1 green pepper, seeded and sliced 450g/1lb courgettes, trimmed and thickly sliced 2&ndash;3 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped rosemary and oregano, mixed salt and pepper 900g/2lb fresh tomatoes, skinned, seeded and chopped plus 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp tomato paste or 500ml/1pt/2&amp; cups passata 6 sun-dried tomato halves, chopped freshly chopped parsley, to garnish 
 1. 
 Trim the shoulder of lamb of most of the fat, then remove the meat from the bone and cut into small pieces. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 3/160&deg;C/325&deg;F. 
 2, Heat the oil and butter together in a heavy pan or casserole dish, add the onion and peppers and cook until soft. 
 Add the courgettes, cover, and cook slowly for 4&ndash;5min until all the vegetables are soft. 
 Remove to a plate using a slotted spoon. 
 3. 
 Add the lamb to the pan and cook quickly on all sides until browned. 
 Return the vegetables to the casserole dish, or turn the meat and vegetables from the pan into a casserole suitable for the oven. 
 4. 
 Add the herbs, some salt and pepper and the chopped tomatoes or passata to the casserole with the chopped sun-dried tomatoes. 
 5. 
 Place the casserole into the pre-heated oven and cook for 1&frac12;&ndash;2hr, until the lamb is tender. 
 6. 
 Season the casserole to taste with salt and pepper and garnish with freshly chopped parsley before serving. 
 Tomato, Lime &amp; Basil Soup 
 Serves 4 (opposite) 
 This soup is sharp and fresh &mdash; delicious. 
 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp olive oil 1 onion, sliced 1 small clove garlic, crushed 900g/2lb tomatoes, roughly chopped 2 limes, grated rind and juice 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped basil or 1 &times; 5ml/tsp dried basil 250ml/10fl oz/1&frac14; cups vegetable stock 1 bay leaf salt and pepper 8 halves sun-dried tomatoes cream to serve 
 1. 
 Heat the oil in a large saucepan, add the onion and garlic, cover and cook over a moderate heat until the vegetables are soft, in about 3&ndash;4min. 
 2. 
 Add all the remaining ingredients. 
 Bring to the boil, then cover and simmer for 25&ndash;30min. 
 Cool slightly, then blend until smooth in a liquidiser or processor. 
 3. 
 Season the soup to taste, then reheat, if necessary. 
 4. 
 Swirl a little cream into the soup just before serving.  
 ( front to back ) Summer Lamb Ragout; Pizza; Tomato, Lime &amp; Basil Soup 
 NIBBLES &amp; Fancy Bits  
 The eternal enigma for the cocktail party host or hostess is what to give the guests that is different and can preferably be eaten in one bite. 
 I find that traditional cocktail foods are always very popular and Devils or Angels on Horseback are a guaranteed success. 
 Dips should be fairly thick so that they do not drop off accompanying crudit&eacute;s, and fillings for pastry parcels and buns should be firm if the food is likely to be bitten and not eaten in one mouthful. 
 I usually allow about eight mouthfuls per person for catering. 
 Do not underestimate the time required to prepare a cocktail party &mdash; a four-course dinner often takes less time! 
 Devils on Horseback 
 Makes approx 30 (see p115) 
 A classic dish that benefits from using the very best prunes (pruneaux d'Agen, see p61) and bacon. 
 30 thin rashers back bacon 450g/1lb ready-to-eat prunes, pitted wooden cocktail sticks 30 small cro&ucirc;tons, lightly fried 
 1. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 5/190&deg;C/375&deg;F. 
 2. 
 Stretch the bacon rashers using the back of a knife. 
 Roll one rasher around each prune and secure with a cocktail stick. 
 3. 
 Place one devil on each cro&ucirc;ton, pressing the cocktail stick into the bread and place on a baking sheet. 
 4. 
 Place in the pre-heated oven for approx 10min. 
 5. 
 Serve immediately. 
 I usually leave the cocktail sticks to make it easier for people to pick the devils up when they are hot. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Angels on Horseback are prepared in the same way, using oysters in place of prunes; canned oysters are very good for this purpose. 
 I do find, however, that prunes are generally more popular. 
 Taramasalata 
 Makes approx 225g/8oz (see p114) 
 This is now as internationally popular as holidays on the Greek islands, from whence the recipe hails. 
 A traditional dish of the eastern Mediterranean, there are many different recipes for taramasalata. 
 Tarama is the salted and dried roe of the grey mullet, but is more usual to use cods' roe which is easily available from fishmongers and delicatessens. 
 Commercial taramasalata is often spoiled by the addition of too much bread or too much oil. 
 2 slices of white bread, crusts removed 125g/4oz smoked cods' roe, skinned juice of one large lemon 75&ndash;125ml/4&ndash;5fl oz/&frac23; cup olive oil 1 &times; 15ml/tbsp grated onion, squeezed dry salt and pepper if required  1. 
 Soak the bread in water for about 10min &mdash; this will make it easier to combine with the roe. 
 Squeeze dry. 
 2. 
 Place the roe, lemon juice and squeezed bread in a food processor blender. 
 With the motor running, slowly add the oil until the mixture is the consistency of a thick mayonnaise. 
 3. 
 Stir in the onion, add the salt and pepper or a little more lemon juice if required. 
 Serve with crudit&eacute;s or fingers of pitta bread. 
 COOK'S NOTE: I tend not to use virgin olive oil for this dip as I find the flavour too strong for the roe. 
 Savoury Petits Choux 
 Makes approx 50 (see p115) 
 Tiny puffs of choux pastry may contain a variety of fillings. 
 They always look attractive and make a very welcome change from vol-au-vents at a party. 
 The pastry is easy to make. 
 75g/3oz butter 200ml/8fl oz/1 cup water 12 &times; level 15ml/tbsp flour, sieved 3 eggs, beaten beaten egg to glaze 
 1. 
 Pre-heat the oven to gas mark 7/225&deg;C/425&deg;F. 
 Lightly grease two baking sheets. 
 2. 
 Place the butter and water in a saucepan and heat until the butter is melted. 
 Bring to the boil, then shoot in the sieved flour. 
 Quickly remove the pan from the heat while beating the mixture vigorously, until it leaves the side of the pan and forms a ball. 
 Cool slightly. 
 3. 
 Gradually add the egg, beating well after each inclusion, until the mixture is shiny and of piping consistency. 
 4. 
 Pipe tiny balls of pastry onto the prepared baking sheets, or not more than &frac12; &times; 5ml/tsp mounds if you do not have a piping bag. 
 5. 
 Brush each bun with a little beaten egg, then place in the pre-heated oven. 
 Bake for 15min, then reduce the heat to gas mark 5/190&deg;C/375&deg;F and cook for a further 10min, or until the pastry is browned and crisp. 
 6. 
 Slit each bun with a sharp knife and place on a cooling rack until cold. 
 Suggested fillings 
 As these buns are so small, it is very important that the filling chosen should be smooth enough to pass through a fine pipe into the pastry. 
 Flavoured cream cheese fillings are generally best. 
 Pipe the filling into the buns and decorate the tops with any that is over. 
 Sprinkle the filled buns with chopped herbs or lumpfish caviar as appropriate. 
 Cream cheese and Herbs 
 (see p115). 
 Beat 175g/6oz cream cheese until smooth, add 1&ndash;2 &times; 15ml/tbsp single cream or strained natural yogurt and 2 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped herbs of your choice. 
 Add salt and pepper to taste. 
 Curried cheese 
 Add 1&ndash;2 &times; 5ml/tsp curry paste to 175g/6oz softened cream cheese. 
 A little finely chopped fresh coriander may also be added for colour. 
 Cream cheese with anchovies 
 Add a few drops of anchovy essence to 175g/6oz softened cream cheese, until the required flavour is reached. 
 Add 1&ndash;2 &times; 15ml/tbsp single cream or strained yogurt, if necessary, to give a piping consistency. 
 COOK'S NOTE: The petits choux may be served warm or cold. 
 Do not overheat them or the filling will become soft: 5&ndash;8min in a moderate oven at gas mark 4/180&amp;C/350&amp;F should be sufficient. 
 Tartlets in a Hurry 
 (see p114) 
 For those of you who invite people round for drinks on the spur of the moment, it is a very good idea to visit your local &bquo;deli&equo; and purchase a few packets of ready cooked canap&eacute; cups and miniature tartlet cases. 
 These have a long shelf life and can be served hot or cold, making them a very good standby to have in the cupboard. 
 Suggested fillings 
 Fish or meat p&acirc;t&eacute;s are a useful standby for fillings. 
 Taramasalata may also be used, and any of the cream cheese fillings suggested above for Savoury Petits Choux. 
 Garnish the tartlets with lumpfish roe, slices of olives or capers. 
 If you have time, pipe a little flavoured butter around the tartlets to give them a professional finish.  
 Cheese &amp; Pineapple Dip 
 Serves approx 30&ndash;40 
 If you are laying your cocktail party nibbles out on a table that the guests will see, it is a very good idea to have a centre-piece, to give a focal point to the display and some height as most nibbles are small and therefore low. 
 This dip is served in two scooped-out halves of a pineapple. 
 Cut carefully through the leaves at the top of the pineapple so that some remain attached to each half of the fruit. 
 Incidentally, the pineapple is a sign of hospitality, making this a very appropriate dish to serve at a party. 
 1 large pineapple, carefully cut in half lengthways 225g/8oz cream cheese 675g/1&frac12;lb cottage cheese 3 &times; 15ml/tbsp freshly chopped chives 325g/12oz Shropshire blue cheese, crumbled salt and pepper paprika to garnish crudit&eacute;s to serve 
 1. 
 Scoop out the flesh of the pineapple halves, taking great care not to cut through the skin. 
 Turn the shells upside down on kitchen paper to drain any juice while preparing the dip. 
 2. 
 Pur&eacute;e the pineapple flesh in a liquidiser or food processor. 
 3. 
 Beat the cream cheese until smooth. 
 Sieve the cottage cheese and add it to the cream cheese and beat well. 
 Gradually mix in the pineapple pur&eacute;e with the chives. 
 4. 
 Add the crumbled Shropshire blue cheese to the dip, then season to taste with salt and pepper. 
 5. 
 Spoon the dip into the pineapple shells and arrange them top to toe on a large serving plate. 
 Sprinkle lightly with paprika and serve with the crudit&eacute;s surrounding the fruits. 
 COOK'S NOTE: Do not serve the dip too cold otherwise the flavours will be lost. 
 If preparing this in advance of the party, leave the dip in a bowl in the refrigerator. 
 Remove about an hour before the guests are expected and fill the pineapple shells, then leave to come up to room temperature. 
 Ginger &amp; Coriander Rolls 
 Makes approx 60 pinwheels (see p114) 
 This recipe was given to me by a well-travelled customer on her return from the USA. 
 It will grace any cocktail party where the guests are adventurous. 
 225g/8oz crystallised ginger 4&ndash;6 &times; 15ml/tbsp fresh coriander leaves 10 thin slices bread, crusts removed mayonnaise for spreading 
 1. 
 Chop the ginger very finely. 
 Chop the coriander leaves and mix with the ginger. 
 Alternatively, chop the ginger and coriander together in a food processor &mdash; this will produce a vibrant, bright green filling. 
 2. 
 Flatten the bread with a rolling-pin, then spread each slice thinly with mayonnaise. 
 3. 
 Spread the bread with the ginger and roll each slice up into a roll. 
 Wrap tightly in cling film and refrigerate for 3&ndash;4hr or overnight. 
 4. 
 Cut the rolls into slices approx 1cm/&frac12;in thick. 
 Arrange on a serving plate, cover and refrigerate until ready to serve.  
 ( l to r ) Taramasalata; P&acirc;t&eacute; Tartlets; Ginger &amp; Coriander Rolls; Savoury Petits Choux; Devils on Horseback 
 GLOSSARY/INDEX 
 Angelica p61 Antipasto p24/ Italian starters, often salami and salads  Apricots p61 Aubergines, Marinated p24 Avocado Soup p104 
 Bamboo Shoots p52/ Flat strips cut from the young tips of the bamboo plant  Bean &amp; Mushroom Salad, Warm p40 Beans, Black p52/ Fermented beans used extensively in Eastern cookery  Beef &amp; Green Chilli Stew p106 Bierwurst p14/ A German slicing sausage with a mild flavour  Black Forest Gateau p78 Black Pudding p14/ An English sausage made from pig's blood, thickened with cereals and also containing lumps of fat  Blackcurrant Marinade for Game Pie p31 Borlotti Bean Salad p40 
 Caffeine p32/ A stimulant found in tea, coffee and cocoa  Candied Peel p61 Canned fish, types of p108 Cannellini Bean &amp; Tuna Fish Salad p24 Capers p45/ The pickled, unopened flower buds of the caper plant  Carbonnade of Beef p17 Cebiche p106 Charcuterie/ A general term describing cured meats and other meat products  Cheese &amp; Pineapple Dip p116 Cheese, Fresh p65/ Very young cheeses, eaten less than one month old. 
 Often very soft owing to a high whey content  Cheese, Soft p69/ Cheeses of the Brie and Camembert types, made from uncut curds which are allowed to drain naturally  Cheese, the nutritive value of p88 Cheesecake, Rich Chocolate p77 Cheesemaking p93&ndash;5 Cheeses, Blue p97 Cheese, Goat's milk p96 Cheeses, Hard p72/ A group including some very hard varieties such as Parmesan, but also Cheddar  Cheeses, Semi-hard p70/ Probably the largest group of cheeses, including many traditional British varieties  Cheeses, Sheep's or Ewes' milk p96 Chicken Pilaf p57 Chinese Egg Noodles p52/ Thin dried noodles reconstituted in boiling water, used for Eastern Cookery  Chocolate p77/ The refined product of the cocoa plant  Chocolate Biscuit Loaf, Italian p78 Chocolate Cheesecake p77 Chorizos p14/ Spicy sausages used extensively in Spanish and Mexican cookery  Clam Sauce for pasta p82 Cocktail Tartlets, Tartlets in a Hurry p113 Cocoa p77/ Cocoa butter and cocoa powder are the basis of the chocolate industry, and are extracted from the beans of the cocoa plant  Coffee p32/ A drink prepared from the berries of the tropical coffee plant  Coffee, types of p34 Creamed Leek &amp; Chilli Sauce p82 Currants p61 
 Danish Salame p12/ One of the most widely available salami, very bright pink in colour and often very salty  Devils on Horseback p112 Dip, Cheese &amp; Pineapple p116 Dried Mushrooms p109/ Full flavoured mushrooms dried for culinary use, usually from France or Italy  
 Extrawurst p14/ A smoked German sausage which may be eaten hot or cold  
 Farmhouse English Cheeses p92/ Mainly produced on a small scale, often from the milk of the  cheesemaker's own herd. 
 A wide variety of these individual cheeses is now available. 
 Four Bean Salad p105 Fromage Frais &amp; Cranberry Salad Dressing p28 
 Garlic &amp; Walnut Sauce for pasta p84 Garlic Vinaigrette p28 Ginger &amp; Coriander Rolls p116 Gravadlax p108/ Raw salmon marinated with plenty of dill and often served with mustard sauce  Guacamole p105 
 Haggis p15/ The famed dish of Scotland, made from sheep's intestines and served on many traditional feast days. 
 Ham pp16&ndash;21/ A whole leg of pork, cut from the carcase before curing  Ham, Bayonne p17/ A lightly smoked ham from south-west France  Ham, Parma pp16&ndash;17/ An Italian air-dried ham, served very thinly sliced  Ham, Smithfield p21/ Traditionally made from pigs fed on nuts, mainly acorns  Ham, Virginia p21/ Traditionally made from pigs fed on peaches and peanuts  Ham, Westphalian p17/ A German smoked ham  Ham, York p21/ A dry cured ham, traditionally eaten at Christmas  Ham, Bradenham p21/ English hams, cured in a mixture of juniper and molasses to give a very black appearance to the uncooked hams  Haslet p14/ An English spiced meat loaf made from pork and sold sliced  Hoisin p52/ Chinese barbecue, sweet and sour sauce  
 Kidney Bean Tartlets p41 Kidneys with Dijon Mustard Sauce p76 
 Lamb &amp; Caper Pies p48 Lamb Ragout, Summer p111 Lemon &amp; Pistachio Pudding p25 
 Marinated Green Olives p44 Mettwurst p14/ A smoked German spreading sausage  Mexican foods pp102&ndash;6 Mexican Tomato Soup p104 Mie Noodles p52/ Flat egg noodles, similar to egg pasta, used in Eastern cookery  Mortadella p14/ An Italian slicing sausage often flavoured with pistachio nuts  Mushroom Souffl&eacute;s p109 Mustard p60/ A spicy condiment made from ground mustard seeds and available in various strengths  
 Nachos p106 Nibbles &amp; Fancy Bits p112/ Cocktail party food  
 Oils, cold pressed p29/ Unrefined oils, extracted without heat, having a full flavour and natural colour. 
 Also called virgin or extra virgin, according to acidity  Oils, olive, grapeseed, sesame etc p29/ Culinary oils with characteristic flavours for various culinary uses  Olives p42/ The fruits of the olive tree, eaten when ripe or crushed to make olive oil  Olives, Marinated Green p44 Organic Foods p85/ Foods produced without the use of chemical at any stage, either to fertilise the land or to treat the crops or the food  Oriental Beef p54 Osso Bucco p58 
 Panettone p63 Pasta Sauces pp82&ndash;4 Pasta, types of p81/ Made from a stiff dough of flour and water or egg, rolled into many shapes before drying. 
 Fresh pasta is also available. 
 Cook and serve with a sauce  Pastrami p21/ Brisket of beef, salted and spiced then coated in peppercorns. 
 Served very thinly sliced  Pepper p50/ A common seasoning obtained from the dried berries of the pepper plant. 
 Usually ground into a powder before use  Pepper Sauces p101/ Hot condiments made from a variety of chilli peppers and often matured for several  years. 
 The most well known is Tabasco sauce  Pepper, types of p50 Pesto Alla Genovese p23/ A sauce of basil, garlic, Parmesan, olive oil and pine nuts for pasta  Pilaf, Chicken p57 Pizza p25 Pork &amp; Olive Casserole p45 Pot Roasted Beef with Mushroom &amp; Cream Sauce p109 Prunes p61 Pulse vegetables p38/ Dried peas and beans, used extensively in vegetarian and wholefood cookery  Pulse vegetables, varieties of p38 
 Quails' Eggs Small, mildly flavoured eggs particularly useful for garnishes. 
 Available fresh, smoked or pickled  Quails' Eggs &amp; Fresh Herb Sauce p82 Quails' Eggs with Gravadlax p108 
 Ragu Bolognese p84 Raisins p61 Raspberry &amp; Hazelnut Vinaigrette p28 Rice p56 Rice, Arborio p57/ Italian round grain rice, used for risotto, also called risotto rice  Rice, Basmati p57/ A fine, long-grain rice grown in the Himalayas  Rice, Brown p56/ Unpolished rice still containing bran but with the husk removed  Rice, wild p57/ A brown grain grown in North America and having a nutty flavour  Risotto Milanese p58/ A rich rice dish containing butter and Parmesan cheeses  Risotto, Suppertime p13 
 Salad, Four Bean p105 Salade Ni&ccedil;oise p76 Salami p9/ A group of air-dried sausages made from raw, cured meats and eaten very thinly sliced  Salt, types of p49 Salt p49/ A natural product used as a flavour enhancer to bring out the flavours of other ingredients. 
 The most common seasoning  Saltpetre p50/ A preserving salt, used mainly to preserve the pink colouring in cooked meats  Sambal p54/ Hot relishes used in Eastern cookery  Saucissons p9/ The French name for air-dried sausages. 
 See Salami  Sausages, smoked, scalded, dried etc p13 Savoury Petits Choux p113 Skate with Black Butter p48 Slicing sausages, types of p14 Smoked Quails' Eggs &amp; Mozzarella Salad p23 Smoked Trout &amp; Parma Ham Mousse p18 Smoking, as a method of preservation p108 Soup, Avocado p104 Soup, Mexican Tomato p104 Soup, Tomato, Lime &amp; Basil p111 Soya Sauce p54/ A salty sauce used throughout the Far East as a replacement for salt  Spanish Potato Salad with Capers p48 Spices &amp; Seasonings pp100&ndash;1 Spicy Sausage Beans p40 Steak au Poivre p51 Stilton &amp; Walnut Cream Dressing p28 Sultanas p61 Summer Lamb Ragout p111 Sun-dried Tomatoes p111/ Dried tomato halves, seeded, possessing a strong, rich flavour. 
 Add to stews or casseroles, or chop and use to garnish Italian dishes or salads  Suppertime Risotto p13 
 Taramasalata p112 Tartare Sauce p48 Tea p36/ The most popular drink in the world, made from the dried leaves of the plant Camellia sinensis  Tea, varieties of pp36&ndash;7 Teewurst pp13&ndash;14/ A smooth German sausage for spreading  Teriyaki p54/ A Japanese marinade based on soya sauce  The Great British Eight pp86&ndash;8/ The traditional   selection of British cheeses that have been produced for many years  The Soil Association p85/ The standards body controlling the marketing of officially recognised organically produced foods  Tisanes p37/ Herbal drinks made from the leaves or fruits of plants such as mint, hibiscus etc. 
 Popular with people who cannot take drinks containing caffeine  Tomato, Lime &amp; Basil Soup p111 Tortilla Chip Pie p104 Turkey with Mexican Pepper Sauce p105 Venison with Mixed Peppercorns p51 Vinaigrette p31 Vine Fruits p61/ The generic term for currants, sultanas and raisins  Vinegar p30/ A fermented condiment for table or culinary use, based on alcoholic liquor  
 Water chestnuts p54/ A crisp vegetable used in Eastern cookery  Wild Rice &amp; Mushroom Stuffing p59  
 ROSEMARY MOON had seven years' experience in the domestic appliance industry, both in research and international marketing, before embarking on a freelance career. 
 She taught many microwave cookery schools and was consultant on food, appliance and product developments. 
 She is a Fellow of the Institute of Home Economics and was for two years the Institute's Vice-Chairman. 
 Rosemary now combines her writing with a catering business specialising in small dinner parties called &bquo;Book the Cook&equo; and her successful specialist delicatessen &bquo;The Cook's Counter&equo; in Arundel, West Sussex. 
 Married and living in Chichester, Rosemary's hobbies are gardening, walking, reading and trying to lose weight. 
 Humans have a special affinity for dolphins, which are widely perceived as having a special degree of intelligence. 
 In fact, the sperm whale (one of the toothed whales) boasts the largest brain on the planet, and in many dolphins, the arrangement and complexity of the brain and nervous system show striking similarities to those of humans. 
 The small cetaceans (dolphins, porpoises, and small toothed whales) show a remarkable range of adaptations to life in and under the surface of the ocean. 
 THE HUMAN/DOLPHIN ENCOUNTER 
 Dolphins are very much in vogue these days. 
 They have become a symbol, along with rainbows, of the dawning of a new age of Aquarius, when qualities of love, peace, and harmony have their renaissance on the earth. 
 Our cousins in the sea, as they are sometimes called, seem to us to have created a society far closer to human ideals of Utopia than anything we have managed to achieve on land, and their social behaviour and lifestyle embody many of the virtues and qualities we humans hold so dear. 
 No wonder, then, that we make of them a symbol of our own visionary dreams. 
 Their movement in the oceans speaks to us of freedom, grace and beauty. 
 Their lifestyle contains all the ingredients that for us make up &bquo;the good life&equo; &mdash; plenty of time devoted to playing, socialising, and making love. 
 Their society is co-operative, with many examples of seemingly altruistic behaviour, and dolphins are always ready to come to the assistance of those in distress, both their own species and humans. 
 Apart from a few minor displays, they are free of aggression toward their own kind. 
 &bquo;It is with a feeling of surprise and wonder, even of awe, that humans become aware of a great intelligence living in the sea; of marine mammals with a perception greater than that of other animals, more akin to our own,&equo; says New Zealander Frank Robson, who has spent many years working with dolphins both in captivity and in the wild. 
 &bquo;We see them communicating easily with one another, trying to communicate with us, solving problems, reasoning enjoying a joke.&equo; 
 The ancient Mediterranean cultures believed that the dolphin represented the vital power of the sea. 
 Delphys, the Greek word for dolphin, means womb. 
 Dolphins were closely linked with the gods, and were a complex symbol associated not only with innocent love and friendship, beauty and harmony, and erotic love, but also with darker areas of death and destruction. 
 Popularly considered to be a creature of peaceful virtue and undisguised joy, the dolphin was a guardian of the sea and a guide to other worlds. 
 In these times, killing a dolphin was tantamount to killing a person, and both crimes were punished with the death penalty. 
 Early Greek mythology describes several encounters between a strong god/hero and a snake/dolphin/woman figure. 
 One of the most famous is that of the Sun God Apollo, who fought with Delphyne, the dolphin/womb monster. 
 When he defeated her he founded an oracle in the dolphins' honour at Delphi (dolphin town), building a shrine where he hoped humans might be guided by a sense of otherworldliness. 
 He also instituted a festival called Delphinia to commemorate his victory. 
 A God had the power to turn himself into whoever or whatever he  defeated or ate, so Apollo could now assume the form of a dolphin. 
 Once, while in a giant dolphin body, Apollo commandeered a boat full of merchants and redirected their craft to Delphi. 
 There he revealed himself as god and ordered them to serve him as priests in his new shrine. 
 Dolphins not only guided the god of the sea, Poseidon, to his lover Amphitrite, but also persuaded her to marry him. 
 Poseidon was so grateful that he created a constellation in the dolphins' honour called Delphinus, just west of Pegasus. 
 The son of Poseidon and Amphitrite was called Triton, and was usually represented as half-man, half-dolphin, holding in his left hand an upright dolphin that suggests an erect penis. 
 Triton roamed the shores raping anyone who took his fancy and earned himself the title Sea Satyr. 
 Men used to wear dolphin tails and dance in his honour. 
 Dolphins graced mosaics, ceramics, and painted murals in ancient Greek and Roman societies. 
 Some of the earliest images are of leaping and swimming dolphins that feature on painted frescoes in the Minoan temple of Knossos on Crete, dating back over 3000 years to when the Minoan civilisation ruled much of the Mediterranean. 
 Frequently a symbol of salvation, a dolphin talisman would ensure a safe journey on land or at sea, and its image stamped on a coin or token was used as a good luck charm. 
 Dolphins were often associated with the anchor, another symbol of salvation, and a dolphin twined around an anchor signified arrested speed, or prudence. 
 The dolphin rider is another image that occurs frequently in early Mediterranean mythology. 
 Eros and Aphrodite were the most popular dolphin riders, and their relationship with the dolphins they rode appears sensuous, loving and often erotic. 
 There is also evidence that not only gods and mythical figures were associated with dolphins and mounted their backs, but children apparently rode wild dolphins in just about every bay, harbour, and inlet of the ancient Mediterranean, and dolphins often befriended sailors and rescued people from the sea, carrying them safely to land. 
 A popular legend tells of Arion, a lyric poet and musician, who was returning to Greece from Italy, laden with riches he had won at music competitions. 
 The crew of the boat on which he was travelling attacked and were about to kill him when he asked for a last favour &mdash; to play a tune. 
 The sound of his music attracted a school of dolphins, whereupon Arion leapt overboard and was carried safely to shore on the back of one of the dolphins. 
 In his gratitude, he erected a bronze statue of a dolphin rider on the clifftops, honouring Poseidon, God of the Sea. 
 In the Pacific, just as in ancient Greece and Rome, dolphins have been traditionally regarded as messengers of the gods. 
 Ancestral spirits were believed to take the form of guardian dolphins or sharks, who guided canoes, effected rescues, and assisted in fishing. 
 A tribe of Aborigines known as the Dolphin People, who live on Mornington Island in the Gulf of Carpentaria, in northern Australia, is said to have been in direct communication for thousands of years with the wild bottlenose dolphins who reside just off the coast. 
 The Dolphin People shamans know a complex series of whistles that signal the dolphins to venture close to shore. 
 The whistling then becomes animated, before stopping altogether. 
 The shamans explain that, at that point, they begin to speak to the dolphins mind to mind. 
 In Kiribati in the Pacific Ocean, formerly known as the Gilbert Islands, certain local clans also had the power of dolphin calling. 
 A dolphin caller would go into a dream where his spirit went out of his body and sought the dolphin folk in their home under the western horizon and invited them to a dance, with feasting, in the village. 
 If he spoke the words of the invitation correctly, the dolphins would follow him with cries of joy to the surface. 
 Having led them to the lagoon  entrance, the caller would fly forward to rejoin his body and warn the people of the coming of &bquo;our friends from the west&equo;. 
 This ritual was practised until the last decade or so but has apparently now ceased, which is perhaps in the best interests of the dolphins. 
 They often finished up as the main item on the menu at the feast after their visit. 
 New Zealand's indigenous Maori people also had an active relationship with dolphins and called them with the word &bquo;Tepuhi'&equo;, which emulates the sound a dolphin makes blowing air through its breathing hole. 
 Around the world, many cultures believe that any harm done to a dolphin may cause ill-fortune or sickness. 
 In the Ganges, Amazon, and other major rivers inhabited by freshwater dolphins, similar protective myths have arisen, often coupled with symbiotic fishing practices. 
 Mutual assistance in fishing is a widespread human/dolphin relationship that has now been well documented in both North Africa and Brazil. 
 Fishermen on the south coast of France and from the Solomon Islands are both credited with the power to call dolphins from the sea. 
 Solitary dolphins have been known to spend long periods around human settlements, encounters which attest to their humour, playfulness, curiosity and gentleness, and their readiness to help humans in distress. 
 One of the earliest documented encounters took place in AD 109 when a dolphin befriended a boy swimming offshore at the Roman settlement of Hippo in northern Africa, and thereafter returned day after day to play with other children, who slowly overcame their initial fear. 
 However, the expense of welcoming and entertaining all the visitors who came to see the dolphin began to tax the modest resources of the town, and to destroy its quiet and peaceful character. 
 In the end, according to the classical writer Pliny, it was &bquo;decided to do away secretly with the cause of the invasion.&equo; 
 The first account of a solitary dolphin encounter since classical times seems to be in England in 1814. 
 A 4-metre (13-foot) male bottlenose called Gabriel made his home in the river Dart and befriended children and adults. 
 Some entrepreneurial showmen then decided they would try to make money out of his popularity and they caught him with the hope of transporting him to London to put on display. 
 Gabriel died an agonising death on the back of a cart on his way to London. 
 A happier story is that of Pelorus Jack, a dolphin who escorted a ferry steamer through New Zealand's narrow French Pass for some 24 years from 1888 to 1912. 
 Thought to be a Risso's dolphin, he would meet steamers with faithful regularity, joining and leaving at a particular spot, and then bow riding at speeds up to 15 knots and rubbing his body against the ship's hull. 
 Pelorus Jack became famous throughout the world and attracted thousands of tourists. 
 Eventually public concern for his safety persuaded the New Zealand Government of the day to introduce special protective legislation. 
 The need for such protection for friendly dolphins is evident in the stories of Opo and Nina, who both suffered fates similar to that of the Hippo dolphin. 
 OPO AND NINA 
 In 1955 a solitary bottlenose dolphin came to live in the remote Hokianga Harbour in Northland, New Zealand, and was soon to cause a sensation. 
 Throughout the summer the dolphin, who came to be known as Opo, played with swimmers, performed tricks, escorted boats in the harbour, and for 11 weeks received regular newspaper coverage. 
 Opo developed a special friendship with a 12-year-old girl, who would enter  the water five or six times a day to swim with or stand and talk to her. 
 Opo would ease between her legs and take her for rides. 
 An increasing number of people flocked to visit Opo, with 1500 visitors sometimes crowding the beach. 
 Locals began to fear for her safety. 
 Indeed several attempts were made on her life, until finally one day she was found dead on the rocks, thought to have been killed by gelignite. 
 On the other side of the world on the north-west coast of Spain, a dolphin called Nina created a similar social upheaval in 1972. 
 At first befriending a local diver, Nina then attracted a Cousteau film team and her fame spread until she soon became a Spanish national heroine. 
 She made a fuss of every boat that approached her and mixed with all bathers on the beach, allowing them to pet her, hold her tail, and ride on her back. 
 As many as 2000 people would throng into the water to touch her. 
 For five months tourists flocked to the area, creating traffic jams and increasing resentment from some of the locals. 
 Concern for her safety grew and laws were passed for her protection. 
 But one day, like Opo, her dead body was found washed ashore, and human foul play was suspected. 
 DONALD 
 Donald first made his appearance when he started playing and interacting with divers near a marine laboratory on the Isle of Man in 1972. 
 Encounters with Donald were documented for the next 6 years, during which time he travelled on a southward odyssey along some 480 km (300 miles) of British coastline, from the Isle of Man to Wales and then to Cornwall, stopping off in small harbours, boat havens and coves along the way to socialise. 
 Many anecdotes about this cheeky and colourful personality have been collected and published by Horace Dobbs. 
 Donald loved biting paddles, splashing and capsizing people and pushing boats around. 
 The more excited people became, the more active and outrageous he would get. 
 He would meddle with fishing nets, pull up anchors and tow boats, tease dogs and tow swimmers. 
 He could also be very possessive, especially towards women. 
 Dobb's book, Save the Dolphins, describes a lengthy and tender relationship that developed between Donald and a woman trainer Maura Mitchell, which included croonings and cuddles at each meeting, during which Donald would shut his eyes. 
 THE MONKEY MIA DOLPHINS 
 Monkey Mia, on the remote western coastline of Australia, has for more than two decades been visited by wild dolphins. 
 Dolphins of all ages and humans intermingle daily in knee-deep water in what is the longest human/dolphin encounter on record. 
 Around 10 dolphins are usually in the bay, part of a larger group further off the coast. 
 Their visits break many of the established patterns of human/dolphin encounter: they accept gifts of dead fish (one theory is that the dolphins receive the fish as a signal from humans that they have come to play and interact), and they maintain their own social grouping while at the same time allowing close human contact. 
 They have provided a wonderful opportunity to get to know dolphins in the wild, and several of the females have given birth over the years they have been frequenting Monkey Mia, thus enabling study of their maternal care and child development. 
 As the news of Monkey Mia spread, it became one of Australia's leading tourist attractions and was included on the itinerary of tour buses. 
 People from all over the world began to make pilgrimages to  Monkey Mia and some 200,000 visitors arrived during the 1989 season. 
 Local residents have sought special legislation to protect the dolphins, an information centre has been built, and now full-time custodians are appointed to act as guardians and to teach the public how to treat the dolphins. 
 As always, the mass tourist response carries its own breed of problems and risks. 
 Foreign objects innocently thrown to dolphins may cause their death, as happens with dolphins in captivity. 
 Speed boats and fishing nets also need to be kept out of the area. 
 DOLPHINS COMING TO THE RESCUE 
 Dolphins have often rescued people at sea. 
 Swimmers in distress have been carried to safety on dolphins' backs. 
 Dolphins have suddenly appeared to help fight off a shark attack, and they frequently guide boats through storms or treacherous waters. 
 Yvonne Vladislavich was on a cabin cruiser that was caught by a wave and sank off Mozambique. 
 She swam for 40 km (25 miles) in the shark-infested Indian Ocean, but she had cut her foot and she saw half a dozen sharks trailing her. 
 As the sharks circled closer, two dolphins appeared at her side and protected her until she reached a buoy and could climb up onto it to safety. 
 Another report tells of a Mrs Yvonne Bliss who fell off a boat in the West Indies. 
 She describes how a porpoise appeared and guided her so that she was being carried with the tide, and then helped her to a section of shallow water. 
 As soon as she was safe her rescuer &bquo;took off like a streak on down the channel&equo;. 
 AND BEING RESCUED 
 The echolocation system of dolphins occasionally lets them down, and they become stranded on beaches. 
 Most of the humans who have been involved in rescues of dolphins or small whales such as pilot whales will readily admit that it is an emotional and moving experience. 
 Experiences in recent years in New Zealand and Australia suggest that many stranded animals can be saved if certain simple rules are followed. 
 The biggest danger for any stranded cetacean is overheating. 
 The blubber which keeps them warm in the water acts as an overly-effective insulator on land, and they can literally cook in their own fat if they are not kept cool. 
 The tail flukes radiate heat from the body most effectively, and they should be consistently cooled with water to avoid overheating. 
 The animal should be kept on its belly, with as much of the body as possible covered with damp blankets or sheets to prevent the sun's rays from burning the sensitive skin. 
 Muscle cramps can be relieved, and the animal's sense of balance restored, by rocking a stranded dolphin or whale from side to side as the tide comes in, just before its refloating. 
 Stranded dolphins can sometimes be transported by helicopter from the stranding site to the open sea.When refloating a herd, it is important to hold the rescued animals together until the entire herd is assembled before releasing them to the open sea. 
 PROJECT INTERLOCK 
 New Zealanders Wade and Jan Doak have embarked on a life-long study into the cetacean mind, called &bquo;Project Interlock&equo;. 
 It all began when Wade was swimming with dolphins, imitating their movement in an undulation that began at the head and rippled along his body to his  fins. 
 A dolphin drew alongside, and by counter-opposing its flippers, barrel-rolled right in front of his mask. 
 Doak imitated this corkscrew manoeuvre, albeit rather slowly and clumsily. 
 As Doak describes, &bquo;Then something startling happened.... a formation of six dolphins abreast of me... repeated that trick in unison, reinforcing my newly acquired mimicry patterns.&equo; 
 With his family and friends Doak has pioneered work and communication with dolphins in the wild, interacting with them on their terms, and in their environment. 
 Working from a base in Northland, New Zealand, Doak spends long hours at sea on a small catamaran, inviting close encounters with dolphins. 
 When going out to meet dolphins he plays &bquo;sweet music&equo; through the bows of the boat to create a receptive mood and establish trust. 
 Doak also understands body language to be a key to communicating with cetaceans, and he experimented with special wetsuits that were modelled on the dolphin body, black above and white below, with both legs enclosed in a sheath terminating in a tailfin or jetfins. 
 The dolphin suit enables more complex response to dolphin body language, as mutual mimicry and playfulness are primary means of dolphin communication. 
 The first time Jan Doak wore the dolphin suit in meeting common dolphins, one individual bonded with her for over four hours, a rare response from this shy species. 
 The Doaks have found a number of friendly gestures to be successful in communicating intentions to dolphins and engaging them in gamesplay. 
 These include mimicry of dolphin swimming patterns, showing feelings and spontaneous behaviour, responding to their signature whistles by talking back through snorkels, making eye contact, and responding to their gestures. 
 Some of the many ways in which dolphins make signal gestures to humans are leaping at significant moments, deliberately splashing people on boats after first making close eye contact, vocalising or whistling through the blowhole after people have made communicative calls or whistles, defaecation and touching. 
 Examples of gamesplay are playing with strands of seaweed, bubble gulps, and sexual behaviour. 
 Among a group of dolphins around the bows of a boat, certain individuals will be most attentive and keep returning again and again. 
 Doak is quite sure that dolphins have varied personalities or behavioural traits, despite the uniformity of their bodies. 
 It is important to observe and respond appropriately to these individuals, recognising them by their distinctive fin markings, body scars and other distinguishing features. 
 As part of Project Interlock, Doak began publishing newsletters, in which he would write of his own experiences and invite others with similar interests to record theirs. 
 The response was staggering &mdash; reports of encounters with dolphins now range across species and latitudes. 
 Doak now has over 30 written accounts of dolphins living in close proximity to humans. 
 The most complex and prolonged human/dolphin associations have been with bottlenose dolphins, but Doak thinks that they are by no means limited to this species. 
 He invites everyone on this journey of discovery into the potential for interspecies communication.  
 the Evolutionary Journey of Dolphins 
 Five hundred million years ago there was life in the sea but none on the land. 
 Then some sea creatures developed lungs and the ability to breathe air and they moved out of the ocean on to dry terrain. 
 Land mammals evolved, with a backbone and warm blood, carrying their young in their bodies and suckling them with milk alter birth. 
 As the ages passed, a few land mammals, the distant ancestors of today's whales and dolphins went back to the sea, and gradually changed shape as they adapted to an underwater environment. 
 The earliest cetaceans are thought to have been related to primitive ungulates or hoofed mammals, who returned to the sea some 50 million years ago. 
 Cetaceans today still carry in their bodies some of the physical traits of their land-dwelling ancestors. 
 The structure of a dolphin flipper resembles the bone structure of an arm and hand with lingers, and a dolphin still has pelvic bones and remains of hipbones that once held limbs. 
 First entering shallow equatorial seas, then estuaries and coastal oceans, the prehistoric cetaceans spread through the seas of the world. 
 At each stage of their return to the sea, they became specialised to their particular habitat, some going back into freshwater rivers, others frequenting shallow coastal waters or the deep oceans. 
 Eventually, 25&ndash;30 million years ago, two peat groups of whales and dolphins emerged: the baleen whales (which filter-feed and lack teeth) and the toothed whales. 
 All dolphins and porpoises belong to the latter group. 
 Fossil Records Trace Extinct Species by Ewan Fordyce  
 Dolphin history is revealed by fossils from ancient marine sediments now exposed on land. 
 Most work on fossil dolphins has been done in the Northern Hemisphere, and little is yet known about the South. 
 Fossil dolphins &mdash; small toothed cetaceans &mdash; encompass the ancestors of modern groups and other groups now extinct, and species are identified wholly on bones, most reliably on skulls, jaws, and earbones. 
 Three living dolphin groups have a record that extends back to about the late Miocene period some 11 million years ago. 
 These are the true dolphins (family Delphinidae), porpoises (family Phocoenidae), and narwhals and their relatives (Family Monodontidae). 
 Records show that dolphins have repeatedly colonised fresh waters, and that the living river dolphins, although unified by habit, are not all closely related to one another. 
 The ancestor of most dolphins is not clear (although this is a very active field of research at present), and with further work the records of most groups probably will be extended further back in time. 
 Few fossils from the critical Oligocene epoch (24&ndash;36 million years) are known, and even fewer are described. 
 Back beyond the Oligocene there is evidence only of archaeocetes, the rather large ancestral toothed whales that apparently gave rise to both the Odontoceti and Mysticeti. 
 It seems that fossil dolphins, like living odontocetes, used echolocation to navigate and Find prey. 
 Even the earliest dolphins, such as late Oligocene kentriodontids (about 24 million years ago), have the skull and earbone structures thought to indicate their use of echolocation. 
 There is clear evidence, in fossil skulls, Of bony sinuses identical with those used by living dolphins to produce high frequency sound. 
 The use of high frequency sound should have led to the development of sound-processing pans of the brain, although it is not clear whether any extinct form had as large a brain cavity as seen in some modern delphinids. 
 Dolphins are probably as diverse now in terms of numbers of species, as at any time for which we have a good fossil record. 
 However, today most Of the species belong to one family, Delphinidae, with a modest contribution from Phocoenidae. 
 In contrast, the families which contain the different living river dolphins seem to have been more diverse in the past, and were also more widely dispersed. 
 Why these groups became less diverse, and why other dolphins disappeared completely, is unclear. 
 Examples of extinct families include the shark-toothed dolphins (Squalodontidae), and groups such as the Squalodelphidae, Acrodelphidae, and Albireonidae. 
 These might be seen as representing early &bquo;experiments&equo; in dolphin lifestyles that did not persist, despite the abundance of the species involved. 
 Squalodontids were mostly medium to large animals (perhaps 3&ndash;6 metres or 10&ndash;20 Feet) characterised by shark-like teeth. 
 Different species differed in number and size of teeth and proportions of the jaws. 
 Acrodelphids, uncertainly related to the living Ganges River dolphin, included some species with an exceptionally long, narrow, flattened beak. 
 Judging from skull form, these now-extinct groups were probably reasonably efficient feeders, which poses questions about the causes of their extinction. 
 Climate change was probably important in both extinction and evolution of dolphins. 
 Climate can affect marine organisms directly, through temperature intolerance, and indirectly, through affecting food resources. 
 Climatic changes may be shod term, like El Nino, or long term, like global cooling or warming over millennia. 
 Climatic changes do affect oceanic food resources, so in the past such changes could have provided new evolutionary opportunities or forced extinction through loss of food. 
 For example, the earth cooled with the development in the Oligocene (perhaps 30&ndash;35 million years ago) of the Southern Ocean and Circum-Antarctic Current, and at this time early odontocetes and mysticetes appeared. 
 Conversely, global climates started to cool late in the Miocene, at about which time some formerly common dolphin families disappeared. 
 Competition between different groups of dolphins might have led to extinctions in some groups, but there is no direct evidence. 
 It is plausible that the diverse delphinids of modern oceans are more efficient feeders which merely outcompeted other small dolphins. 
 There is no clear evidence that any group of dolphins became extinct because of competition from animals other than cetaceans. 
 Fossil dolphin bones occasionally carry tooth gouges, traces of attack by sharks and other predators. 
 Ancient dolphins might have competed for resources with seals, giant penguins, and other sea birds. 
 Extinction, like evolution, is a natural process that occurs in response to changing opportunities. 
 Humans should not further tip the balance against living dolphins. 
 The natural world is tough enough without interference.  
 &bquo;If we comb through our stories and one encounters with wild whales and dolphins, we find that they seem to hang together along a shining thread &mdash; that whales and dolphins know what they are doing, that their actions are purposeful, and stunningly specific to the occasion, that they intend us no harm, that they are aware. 
 Joan McIntyre, Canadian conservationist  
 &bquo;The Maori once regarded the dolphin as some kind of God or influence to direct them to things they wanted to know. 
 To me it is a human being in the sea&hellip;. 
 We only call dolphins when we need help in a rough sea, or we are in difficulty or if there is something we would like to know about relatives at a distance over the ocean. 
 If a relative is sick when the dolphin appears it will give a sign whether or not that person will recover or has already recovered. 
 We can tell from the way it leaps.&equo; 
 Warpu Ata, contemporary Maori elder New Zealand  
 An American, Chi-uh Gawain, made many journeys to Monkey Mia and wrote a book about her experiences. 
 &bquo;I have the impression the dolphins don't want us to have any purpose in our relations with them. 
 And especially no tricks or pretence. 
 They want us to be ourselves and they themselves and to meet as friends&hellip; only after some quiet times with a dolphin do we enjoy letting it be in charge of the encounter, and see what it may decide to do next with us.' 
 &bquo;For the next year I devoured every written word I could find on dolphins and whales. 
 knowledge of dolphins I found was based almost entirely on captive animals. 
 How much could be learned about our species from a study of people prison?&equo; 
 Wade Doak, Encounters  with Whales and Dolphins 
 The ying-yang symbol painted on the hull of the Doaks' Wharram catamaran symbolises the between humans and dolphins. 
 Wade Doak 
 AN EQUAL INTELLIGENCE IN THE SEA? 
 Dolphins have an impressive ability to imitate and learn, often apparently for the sheer pleasure of doing so. 
 This, together with their displays of co-operative and seemingly altruistic behaviour, and their large brain size, has inspired many studies into the nature of cetacean intelligence. 
 The fascinating question raised is, are dolphins conscious, aware, and conceptualising creatures, with whom we can communicate and from whom we have much to learn? 
 All the small whales and dolphins have very large brains, roughly equivalent to the size of a human brain, although variation among species is considerable, even among species of similar body weight. 
 However brain size alone is not an absolute indication of intelligence - elephants, for example, have brains four times the size of our own. 
 The ratio of brain weight to spinal cord weight is considered a better measurement of complexity and intelligence. 
 In fishes, the brain weighs less than the spinal cord; in the horse the ratio is about 2.5 to 1; in the cat 5 to 1; in apes about 8 to 1; and in humans about 50 to 1. 
 The bottlenose dolphin has an average ratio of 40 to 1, the dusky dolphin about 35 to 1, and Dall's porpoise about 26 to 1, suggesting that dolphins generally show a degree of intelligence comparable with that of humans.  
 EXPLORING INTERSPECIES COMMUNICATION 
 Scientific study of whales and dolphins began as far back as the fourth century BC, when the Greek philosopher Aristotle observed and experimented with live animals. 
 His account of the common dolphin, written nearly 2500 years ago, is so thorough that little can be added to it even today. 
 The physical difficulty of working with oceanic animals has limited cetacean study in the past, and much of the information available on whales over the last few centuries has, ironically, come from the whaling industry. 
 When in the 1950s attempts to keep dolphins in captivity finally succeeded and the entertainment value of dolphins was suddenly realised, the demand for dolphin shows led to a rapid escalation of the numbers of dolphins captured alive. 
 Dolphin studies then focussed on dolphins in captivity, and trainers and researchers alike were amazed at the speed with which dolphins could learn. 
 Dolphins were often cruelly maimed or killed during such research, but, thankfully, today's studies tend to focus on animals in the wild, and mostly aim to be as non-intrusive as possible. 
 Roger Payne made a breakthrough in studying cetaceans in their natural environment, with aerial photography and new techniques of measuring and recording. 
 He was able to provide information on age, sex, and growth of whales for the first time without killing, touching, marking, or molesting a single animal. 
 What is becoming increasingly evident is how much we have to learn from dolphins &mdash; and how much they may have to teach us. 
 There are numerous accounts from researchers or trainers who start their contact with dolphins thinking they will teach a dolphin how to communicate with humans, and end up wondering it in Fact the dolphin has been trying to teach us a thing or two about communicating with them. 
 Numerous formal studies have been made to determine the intelligence of the bottlenose dolphin, according to its performance in tests on classical learning, discrimination, and problem solving. 
 The results suggest that its intelligence lies somewhere between that of a chimpanzee and a dog. 
 However, as Dr Lyall Watson has pointed out, the conclusions must be suspect because the experiments required the animal to do repetitive and meaningless tasks in isolation &mdash; a far cry from the dolphin's natural condition. 
 &bquo;Humans, under similar conditions, score considerably less well than pigeons.&equo; 
 Traditionally, we have tended to use dolphins' ability to understand and communicate with us on our terms as a measure of their intelligence. 
 But this is more a measure of the limitations of our own mind. 
 Says Joan McIntyre, president of the Project Jonah organisation for many years: &bquo;Try for a moment, if you can, to imagine the imagination of a whale, or the awareness of a dolphin. 
 That we cannot make those leaps of vision so because we are bound to a cultural view which denies their possibility.&equo; 
 We need to stop evaluating intelligence purely within the model of our own. 
 Just because dolphins use language in a different way does not mean that they lack high intelligence or cannot communicate. 
 Their brains are as large and as complex as ours, and in fact evolved to this size and complexity several million years earlier than human brains. 
 Having so long regarded our intelligence as supreme, perhaps we should now consider the possibility that other creatures may be equally intelligent and possess a communication system that is beyond our comprehension. 
 The real significance of these comparisons remains unknown, as do the real workings of the dolphin mind, but it seems that dolphins and porpoises achieved their modern enlarged brains about 15&ndash;20 million years ago, whereas the evolution of the human brain is a phenomenon of the past few million years at the most. 
 Moreover, dolphins and other cetaceans have evolved in a watery environment, a much better medium than air for the transmission of sound. 
 Sound has therefore become the most important sense for cetaceans. 
 While human evolution has oriented around the use of hand and eye, and developed down a highly visual and linear path, the dolphin mind has been on a very different track &mdash; acoustic, non-linear and non-manipulative. 
 The properties of water and behaviour of sound are quite different to those of air and sight, therefore the dolphin mind has developed quite different processes of perception, communication and behaviour. 
 The speed of sound in water is roughly four times as great as it is in air. 
 On the other hand, water is not much different for taste and smell, and much worse for vision. 
 Except at its surface, the sea is dark and shadowy, and underwater creatures are thought to rely mainly on black and white pigmentation for their vision. 
 Off shallow coasts, 90 per cent of white light is absorbed at 10 metres (33 feet) depth, and only one per cent of white light penetrates below 40 metres (130 feet). 
 At depths of greater than 430 metres (1400 feet), the sea is pitch black. 
 Sound behaves quite differently to light. 
 It can bend round corners and pass through objects. 
 While vision depends on the presence of light, sound can be used at any time of day or night and at all depths. 
 A dolphin emits a steady stream of sounds, each lasting only 10&ndash;100 milliseconds. 
 These are short pulses of ultrasonic sound (from 0.25 to 220 KHz), produced in the nasal passages and probably focussed through an organ in the forehead, known as the melon, into a narrow stream of clicks and whistles. 
 The sound waves bounce off objects in their path and are reflected back to the dolphin where they are channelled through oil-filled sinuses in the lower jaw to the inner ear. 
 Through this &bquo;echolocation'&equo; system a dolphin builds up an acoustic picture of its surroundings, and can hunt its prey over a much greater distance than the limits of visibility in the water. 
 In the area at the front of the skull are connecting sacs which enable the dolphin to cut off one or all of the four high-frequency signals which may be in operation. 
 As no vocal chords as we know them are to be found in the larynx, the sounds emitted probably come from the lips of the larynx. 
 A dolphin's vocabulary is varied, with a range of whistles, squeaks, squawks, groans, rattles, clicks, and many other sounds. 
 Most cetaceans have developed two kinds of voices &mdash; pulsed sounds such as clicks and burst pulses, and unpulsed sounds like whistles and squeaks. 
 The unpulsed sounds seem to relate to times of heightened excitement, such as during feeding, when stranded or in a state of distress or alarm, or between mother and newborn calf. 
 Pulsed sounds like clicks are used for echolocation and navigation; yelps can be a feature of courtship; and other pulsed calls are made during distress and aggressive confrontation. 
 The click noises are high frequency and travel only short distances, so tend to be used by groups in close contact with each other. 
 Unpulsed whistles carry over long distances, which may explain their frequent use among spinner and bottlenose dolphins, who often form large groups, and the absence of these sounds among the less social species. 
 The two main types of voices overlap in both quality and function, and can be used simultaneously. 
 Dolphins have a remarkable capacity for vocal mimicry, and they learn to imitate sounds very accurately and quickly. 
 In studies in Hawaii  in 1984, a captive bottlenose dolphin was trained to mimic computer-generated sounds by modifying its whistle. 
 When new computer sounds were made, the dolphin could immediately and with great accuracy copy the previously unheard sounds. 
 Furthermore, the dolphin could relate a sound to an object like a ball or hoop, and thus was able to give vocal labels to these objects. 
 Numerous other experiments have been well documented. 
 Dolphins have been trained to respond to human words, and in Holland a killer whale once spontaneously repeated a human sound. 
 Studies by Louis Herman have established that dolphins are capable of understanding simple auditory and gestural language and can comprehend two- or three-word sentences. 
 One limitation of these studies, however, is that while they demonstrate the capacities of the dolphin to develop a particular kind of human-derived language ability under the influence of humans, we are still pretty ignorant about the existence of any natural language among dolphin species, although their communication with each other is clearly complex and elaborate. 
 One clear difference between human and dolphin perception is that because of the ability of sound waves to penetrate objects, the dolphin can listen and &bquo;see&equo; through things. 
 A dolphin &bquo;listening&equo; to another dolphin can hear inner information with a kind of X-ray vision &mdash; body contours can be heard diffusely, teeth and bone reasonably well, and those parts containing air very distinctly. 
 This has considerable significance for the communication of emotional states and personal interaction. 
 It must be virtually impossible for a dolphin to hide its inner emotional state. 
 John Sutphen suggests that with the three sonar channels available to dolphins, cetaceans can see-read-hear into each others' hearts and brains. 
 Telepathic communication, for us still the domain of science fiction or fringe experimentation, may be part of a dolphin's daily life, and may have been so for centuries.  
 THE MYSTERIOUS SONG OF THE HUMPBACKS 
 There have long been stories of mysterious sounds at sea: haunted eerie calls in the night, mermaids singing, sirens luring sailors on to the rocks. 
 Although nineteenth century whalers discovered that many Of the strange calls at sea were the voices of whales, only recently have the songs Of cetaceans become familiar to the rest of the world. 
 The mysterious and plaintive songs and calls of the humpback whales are now well known, after the efforts of Americans Roger and Katy Payne to record their haunting deep-sea melodies. 
 In these songs, the great variety of cries and moans are repeated over and over in ordered patterns built around a basic unit or syllable that is equivalent to a note in our music. 
 Syllables are grouped in repeating sequences called phrases, and groups of phrases are called themes. 
 About 20 syllables and 6 basic themes have been recognised in the whales' singing, which can continue through day and night with only short pauses for breath. 
 One whale was heard singing nonstop for at least 22 hours. 
 The song of each whale has its own individual signature, but within a season all whales within a region will sing a similar song. 
 These songs are continually changing over the years. 
 Singing is almost entirely confined to breeding grounds, most singers are males, and they mostly sing alone. 
 The songs of the whales carry through the water, over long distances with astonishing clarity, and were heard clearly through the wooden hulls of the old whaling ships in calm weather, giving rise to the belief that the sounds were the songs of mermaids. 
 Humpback whale songs change throughout the breeding season, as males change their songs in a bid to attract females. 
 Unsuccessful suitors copy the songs of the successful ones, and so the songs change steadily through the breeding season. 
 Researchers have discovered that significant changes in the same songs have been copied by humpbacks on opposite sides of the Atlantic Ocean within 6 days, far faster than a whale could swim the 5000 or so km (3250 miles).  
 &bquo;Our best developed areas are those which deal with the elaboration of motor skills made possible by our hands, while cetaceans seem to concentrate on areas of social perception. 
 dolphins show marked development of those parts of the brain responsible for orientation, social skill, emotional self-control and perhaps even humour&hellip;. they seem to have responded to social and sexual pressures rather than to the purely physical. 
 Our dependence on tools&hellip;. means that a large part of the mental capacity of a human culture exists outside the individual, whereas in non-manipulative dolphins it is still embodied in brain and  behavior &hellip;. as social beings&hellip;. we may be inferior to many cetaceans.&equo; 
 Dr Lyall Watson, naturalist  
 Comparative size of human brain (right) and that of a bottle dolphin Tursiops truncatus). 
 Bottlenosed dolphin brains are more deeply folded than human brains, which increases the surface area of the cerebral cortex &mdash; the &bquo;thinking'&equo; part of the brain. 
 This is considered a measure of certain forms of intelligence. 
 &bquo;To enter into the perceptual world of whales and dolphins, you would have to change your primary sense from sight to sound. 
 Your brain would process, synthesise and store sound pictures rather than visual images. 
 Individuals and other creatures would be recognised by the sounds they made, or by the echoes they returned from the sounds you made. 
 Your sense of neighbourhood, or where you are and who you are with, would be sound sense.&equo; 
 Dr Peter Marshall, US environmentalist and naturalist  
 John Lilly, am experimental neurologist, founded the Communication Research Institute in the Virgin Islands to explore the potential of the dolphin's large and complex brain. 
 During the 1960s, he demonstrated that dolphins could produce sounds in air that seemed to be direct and relevant imitations of human speech patterns. 
 In one long experiment a woman and bottlenose dolphin lived together constantly fur several months. 
 Lilly believes that humans and dolphins can communicate with each other despite their physical differences, and he has constructed a complex computer system to send translated messages between human and dolphin. 
 Louis Herman, at the University of Hawaii, has devised a series of new experiments in which dolphins have learned to understand sentences. 
 Using simple tones to represent words, Herman has taught a dolphin called Akeakamai (Lover of Wisdom) to recognise some 40 or 50 verbs and nouns, which can be combined into more than 1000 different sentences. 
 At present, Akeakamai can understand sentences of up to five words, and can understand commands even when hearing them for the first time. 
 Dolphins interact with each other and with their environment primarily through the use of sound, and their manipulation of sound greatly surpasses the control shown by any human musician or that needed to operate any human device. 
 Their sonar system enables them to communicate with each other, to &bquo;see&equo; through echolocation, and they cam possibly even stun fish sonically. 
 Dolphin sounds are unintelligible to humans, and cover a larger range of frequencies than we can hear or differentiate. 
 To us, their noises sound just like buzzes, clicks and high-pitched whistling. 
 The dolphin's melon, a waxy, lens-shaped organ, extends from the blowhole to the beak and contains much fine wax-oil held in suspension by a very fine web-like tissue, which resembles the inside of a pipless, unripe melon. 
 Many bio-acoustic experts agree that the echolocation clicks are created by implosive movements of air in the nasal passages, but the exact process of sound production and projection is unknown &mdash; possibly, the echolocation waves pass through the melon. 
 The manner in which the dolphin receives the returning echoes is also a mystery, but they are thought to be picked up by all parts of the body, to travel through the bones to the head. 
 A significant proportion of the dolphin's brain is thought to be used in processing the information produced by the echolocation system. 
 Upper: Anatomical drawing of a bottlenose dolphin for simplicity the lungs and intestines, which fill much of chest cavity, have been omitted. 
 Lower: Skeleton of the same dolphin, showing the finger-like bones in the flipper 
 &bquo;Dolphins rely on their oil channels for precise echolocation but sound still impinges on all parts of their bodies with the same high energy and turns every inch into a functional sound receptor. 
 It is not just the surface that is involved either, because sound passes easily through the skin and muscle and bounces back only from bone and air-filled cavities. 
 The internal working of all bodies around him are a normal part of any dolphin's external environment&hellip;. 
 When you swim with one he is constantly aware of your health and general well being, of your physiology and the level of your emotional arousal. 
 There is no hiding or lying and no possibility of denial.&equo; 
 Dr Lyall Watson , Gifts of Unknown Things 
 In the new project called Project Delphis, the Hawaiian-based environmental organisation Earthtrust is using computer technology to convert dolphin sounds into electrical impulses, so that dolphins can interact with computers via a standard video screen. 
 Unlike John Lilly, who created a computer-generated pidgin language for communication between dolphin and human, Earthtrust's project is establishing an open-ended tool for exploring and demonstrating dolphin intelligence and creativity. 
 ADAPTATION TO LIFE UNDER WATER 
 Dolphins have developed many adaptations to survive and succeed in a marine and, to a lesser extent, freshwater environment. 
 Their bodies are streamlined for maximum efficiency in moving through water, and they have evolved a highly sophisticated sonar system to communicate and receive information through water and over long distances. 
 Streamlining and swimming 
 The external body features like arms, hands, legs, and genitals of the dolphin's land-based ancestors, have either been eliminated or withdrawn inside the dolphin's body to create the most beautifully proportioned and elegant of forms, perfectly streamlined for movement in the water. 
 The shape and musculature of a dolphin do not alone account for its speed and swimming efficiency, and biologists have long been searching for features of the skin which may explain the mysteries of the dolphin's swimming prowess. 
 It seems that the dolphin has been able to eliminate frictional drag and turbulence when it swims, a feat never achieved by any human-made vessel. 
 A perfectly streamlined form creates no turbulence and only minimal drag, and fluid layers are able to flow smoothly over each other. 
 One of the explanations for the dolphin's superb streamlining seems to be that while they are swimming their skin surface shifts in folds or ripples, caused not by muscular action but as a response to changes in pressure on different parts of the body. 
 This constant changing of shape could be a way of continually inhibiting turbulence. 
 The dolphin's skin is designed to aid maximum swimming efficiency. 
 Unlike most mammals, a dolphin's skin is hairless, smooth, and thick with no glands. 
 Body heat is retained by a layer of blubber under the skin. 
 Skin cells are shed and replaced rapidly, and whole sheets of skin are often found in pools where dolphins are held in captivity. 
 The outermost skin layer of the bottlenose dolphin is replaced every 2 hours, which is nine times the rate of human skin renewal. 
 Another feature of dolphin skin which could offset turbulence and accelerate movement is a system of dermal ridges (similar to those that make up our fingerprints) which are found beneath the skin on the back and flanks of most cetaceans, and seem to correspond to the patterns of water flow. 
 The secretion of lubricating oily substances on the skin may also help the dolphin's speed through the water. 
 Breathing and Diving 
 Like all mammals, dolphins need air to live, and the first act of life of a newly-born dolphin is to find its way to the surface to breathe. 
 The dolphin has undergone some remarkable adaptations in order to survive a life in which it is under water much of the time. 
 Cetaceans breathe through a blowhole at the top of their heads, enabling them to surface to take a breath while still swimming. 
 The blowhole itself is the hinged flap of a watertight valve, and through it the dolphin can empty and refill its lungs in the unbelievably short time  of one-fifth of a second. 
 Directly below the blowhole are twin valves which separate and direct the incoming air into two streams to supply the two lungs. 
 These valves also serve to trap any water which may accidentally pass the blowhole, and thus prevent it from entering the lungs, which would cause choking or drowning. 
 When a dolphin becomes trapped in a net, it drowns because it is unable to get back to the surface to refill its lungs when the supply of air runs out. 
 Net-caught dolphins frequently have lungs filled with water. 
 Dolphins breathe far less frequently than humans, and compensate by taking deeper breaths and extracting more oxygen from the air they do take in. 
 They can also store more oxygen. 
 Their lungs are not particularly large, despite the fact that a dolphin can hold its breath for five minutes or more, and some species of whales can submerge for up to an hour and survive on a single breath. 
 Efficiency, not size, enables this feat. 
 They fill their lungs to capacity, and change up to 90 per cent of the air with each breath, whereas humans only fill one-eighth of lung volume on an average breath. 
 Dolphins are superb divers. 
 Many species can dive to depths of 200 metres (650 feet), and several, such as the Pacific variety of bottlenose, and Fraser's dolphins, have been reported to reach 500 metres (1625 feet), in dives lasting over 8 minutes. 
 Some small whales perform even more impressively &mdash; pilot whales can go to 600 metres (almost 2000 feet) in a dive lasting 18 minutes, and the beluga can reach 650 metres (more than 2000 feet). 
 Moreover, cetaceans can dive to these remarkable depths and return rapidly from great deep-sea pressures without suffering from any of the compressed-air conditions like the &bquo;bends'&equo;, which can so easily kill human SCUBA divers. 
 A dolphin dives with its lungs filled, and copes with the crushing effects of pressure at these depths by collapsing its chest as the water pressure compresses the air in its lungs. 
 The collapse is possible because many of the ribs are not joined to the sternum, and those that do join make contact by long flexible cartilages. 
 The ability to collapse their lung air-sacs with increasing depth is probably the dolphin's major protection against the bends. 
 Like seals and other diving animals, dolphins exhibit bradycardia - the slowing of the rate of heart beat. 
 Bottlenose dolphins have a heart rate of 80&ndash;90 beats per minute just after &bquo;blowing&equo;, slowing within a few seconds to 33&ndash;45 beats per minute and remaining at that rate until the next blow. 
 On surfacing, the rate again speeds up, generally remaining at the higher level until the carbon dioxide content of the exhaled air has returned to normal &mdash; usually in a few seconds. 
 Through the condensation set up by the intake of cooler air into a warm-blooded animal, a dolphin receives a supply of fresh non-salt water when breathing. 
 Despite the old prints which showed whales spouting water, the blow is simply water condensation. 
 Paradoxically, although surrounded by water, dolphins, like other marine mammals, tend to lose water from their bodies to the sea. 
 They compensate for this by gaining water from their food both through the workings of their powerful kidneys, which extract much of the water from the urine, and by the condensation of water during breathing. 
 Feeding 
 When the ancestral cetaceans returned to the sea, they had to adapt to the much colder temperatures of water, which conducts heat 26 times more efficiently than air. 
 A thick layer of blubber beneath the skin helps insulate cetaceans against temperatures that would quickly kill a human. 
 Humans become unconscious after being submerged for 3 hours in water at 15&deg;C (60&deg;F). 
 Dolphins also have a higher metabolic  rate than terrestrial mammals of a similar size. 
 The harbour porpoise, for instance, needs to maintain a rate three times that of an equivalent-sized land mammal to keep itself warm in cold waters. 
 The dolphins' high-protein fish or squid diet, with almost no carbohydrate content, also contributes considerably to a high metabolic rate. 
 Those species studied have large thyroid glands and a high level of circulating thyroid hormones. 
 Much of a dolphin's life revolves around finding and eating food, and it has evolved a highly developed jaw and sonar system to serve its feeding requirements. 
 The toothed whales have a set of teeth which they use to grasp large and quick-moving prey, mainly squid or fish. 
 The number and size of teeth varies greatly among species, and in some of the dolphins and small whales, teeth have become virtually nonfunctional. 
 The common dolphin has a total of 180 teeth, which it uses to hold the captured meal fast while it is turned around to be swallowed head first. 
 Dolphins that feed mainly on squid usually have fewer teeth and have developed other adaptations to hold on to their slippery-bodied meals. 
 Beaked whales generally have only a single pair of teeth protruding from their lower jaw, and instead of teeth they use a ribbed palate to get a firm grasp on their prey. 
 The narwhal also has only two teeth, and in the male (and occasionally the female) one of these grows outwards to form a long, impressive, spiralling tusk. 
 This tooth tusk is thought to be used more for jousting matches than to help in feeding, and narwhal tusks brought back to Europe by early ocean adventurers almost certainly inspired the legends of the one-horned unicorn. 
 The narwhal has developed other techniques to capture its food, such as sucking or blowing. 
 Its highly flexible neck enables it to keep watch over a wide area while it is both searching for and chasing prey. 
 In contrast, the dolphins that are equipped with good sets of teeth, and the porpoises, which have 13&ndash;28 pairs of spade-shaped teeth in each jaw, have a less flexible neck because their neck vertebrae are fused together. 
 River dolphins have highly specialised feeding behaviour. 
 Their small eyes and poor eyesight, combined with their often murky environment, means they have to rely on a short-range echolocation system to find food. 
 Their inability to see or echolocate over longer distances undoubtedly contributes to their frequency of net entanglement. 
 They have numerous conical pointed teeth, with 24&ndash;60 pairs in each jaw. 
 Although unstreamlined and slow swimming, they are highly manoeuvrable, with a flexible neck. 
 Their long slender beak also assists in capturing their prey. 
 They are solitary creatures, usually feeding on their own, searching for prey on the river bed. 
 Dolphins feed mainly on schools of prey. 
 Here, there is always more food than any individual would need, and because searching for food as a group is more efficient than searching individually, most dolphins have developed communal and co-operative hunting practices. 
 They travel in large concentrated groups to search for food, particularly when herding shoaling pelagic (open sea) fish. 
 Not only can they cover a much wider area than they could on their own, but their collective experience assists in finding food. 
 While searching for prey, many dolphin species move in tight schools distributed over a large area, using sound to stay in contact and communicate with each other over significant distances. 
 A dolphin school will often divide up into subgroups while searching for food, which separate and spread out over a wide area of sea, still diving synchronously &mdash; evidence that they are probably in some form of acoustic contact. 
 Echolocation, too, plays an important role in food hunting for dolphins and toothed whales. 
 The sonic pulse systems emitted by toothed whales are directional and most species seem to use them not only to detect food but also to make fine distinctions on the basis of the  echoes. 
 Most dolphins and small whales travel in groups broader than they are long, which allows them to acoustically scan as large an area as possible. 
 The size of the groups is probably determined by the number of individuals that can be sustained by the size of the school of prey. 
 Where the prey is shoaling fish, the schools of common, spinner and spotted dolphins who feed on them can often number in the hundreds, sometimes even thousands. 
 Once dolphins locate a school of fish, they spread out, some individuals diving down to the school of prey to herd it to the surface by swimming around and under the fish in an ever-tightening formation. 
 The water surface then acts as an entrapping wall, although individual fish will often be seen flying through the air trying to avoid capture. 
 The dolphins may also make loud sounds and a series of echo-clicks which help to herd the fish and may even stun them. 
 Herding and criss-crossing behaviour has been observed in spotted and spinner dolphins, common dolphins, dusky, white-beaked and bottlenose dolphins and probably also occurs in other species. 
 We are unsure whether the behaviour is truly co-operative, or is organised by certain individuals in the school, but the whistles and considerable vocal activity which often occur among members of feeding groups are undoubtedly communication signals.  
 social behaviour 
 Earlier this century, studies of the dolphin relied on observations of animals in captivity, and interpretations of social behaviour drawn from these studies are likely to be suspect. 
 In recent years however, scientists have taken a greater interest in the exciting possibilities of observing animals in their natural surroundings. 
 The development of sophisticated photographic techniques and new technologies like DNA-fingerprinting have encouraged an increasing number of cetacean studies in the wild, gathering information not only from a wider range of species, but also in a wider range of contexts and environments. 
 Such information is undoubtedly more valuable than that derived from captivity studies. 
 However, many studies are still done on animals at or just below the surface, where dolphin behaviour is usually affected by the presence of the human observer. 
 Dolphins are essentially social animals. 
 Most species will form groups at some stage of their life, for feeding, defence, or caring for the young, for example. 
 However, some species, such as the beaked whales and the river dolphins, can be almost solitary. 
 This is easy to understand for the river dolphins, which feed on individual prey on the river bottom, but the habits of beaked whales remain almost a total mystery. 
 Large groups of dolphins are mixed in age and sex, but smaller groups generally are of three types: a nuclear group, comprising a single adult male and female; a nursery group, with a number of adult females and young; and a bachelor group, with adult and young males. 
 Many communities of small cetaceans have rigid hierarchies of power. 
 Dolphin groups tend to travel in specific formations, exhibiting refined and developed skills in working and cc-operating as a group. 
 A navigating formation travels in a wedge shape, with dominant animals and perhaps those with developed sonar skills at the front, and the young of the herd protected in the centre. 
 Other groups will form a parade, and travel in single file on long journeys, or sometimes in open square or hollow circle shapes. 
 For hunting, various formations may be adopted. 
 Many field studies suggest that the social structure of both inshore and pelagic dolphin species is generally fluid and loose, with probably a promiscuous mating system for most. 
 A core group of individuals does seem to stay in association with each other over extended periods, although there may be some coming and going within that time. 
 Individuals in one group in the morning may have joined another group some 10 kilometres (7 miles) distant by the afternoon or next day. 
 Mothers and calves may remain together for many years, from 3&ndash;6 or even 8 years. 
 Segregation by sex and age is relatively common. 
 The age of sexual maturity varies, from only 3 years for the common dolphin to 8 or 9 years for the spotted and the striped dolphins. 
 The larger species tend to reach sexual maturity later, and differences between the sexes are greatest in those species thought to be polygamous. 
 In these, males are much larger than females and take much longer to sexually mature - perhaps the result of the increased time spent in competition with other males to take over a group of females. 
 Many marine mammals (for example, sperm whales, sealions, and elephant seals) show a similar difference in size between mature males and females, especially if the dominant male holds a number of mature females, often known as a &bquo;harem.&equo; 
 Behavioural and sound signals seem to be used to communicate sexual interest, and among the toothed whales, with their great acoustic sensitivity, receptivity to sex may be communicated by something which a dolphin can &bquo;see'&equo; or &bquo;&bquo;hear'&equo; with its sonar. 
 Females also indicate their enthusiasm by giving out signals such as changes in the  shape and colour of their genitals, and possibly a discharge of hormones in their faece or urine. 
 Courtship may take various forms including chases, simultaneous surfacing, breaching, and flipper contact, and sound is almost certainly used to communicate identity and emotion. 
 Harbour porpoises and bottlenose dolphins both make pulsed yelps during courtship. 
 Before mating, pairs may join belly to belly either in an upright position, or with the female lying motionless belly-upwards just beneath the surface. 
 In the latter position the female swims beneath the male, but usually the pair swims with the male gliding beneath the female. 
 Such behaviour may be practised by animals of any age, and at different times of year, and sometimes between the same sex, but does not always lead to mating. 
 All species of whale and dolphin usually produce a single young. 
 Although female cetaceans do have paired mammary glands, twins have been recorded only very rarely, and even then one or both have died. 
 Gestation normally lasts 10&ndash;12 months, but is 15 or 16 months in certain species (usually those for which squid are important prey). 
 The young are suckled usually for 18&ndash;20 months, 24 months at most. 
 Some solid food will be taken on average from 6 months of age. 
 The mother's milk is very rich, with a 40 per cent fat content (the fat content in human milk is only 2 per cent). 
 Because of the long gestation and lactation periods, the interval between calving is usually at least two or three years. 
 A dolphin calf is born tail-first with open eyes, alert senses and enough muscular co-ordination to follow its mother immediately. 
 At birth the mother will help her calf to the surface to gain its first breath, taking about 10 seconds to do so. 
 The mother may be assisted by others (usually non-pregnant females) who often help take the calf to the surface for air. 
 These &bquo;aunts&equo; may also help the mother if she is in difficulty, supporting her underneath her body and swimming with her. 
 Young may be carried on the snout of the mother if they are in distress (or stillborn), a behaviour that is also sometimes extended to humans in distress. 
 An attending female has been seen to bite through the umbilical cord of a captive dusky dolphin during the birth of her young, but usually the mother does this herself. 
 Aunts continue to show great interest in the calf after birth, helping to protect it and sometimes &bquo;babysitting&equo; the calf. 
 In most cetacean groups, if mother/calf pairs come together, with or without aunts, to form nursery groups, they are segregated from males, who play no part in parental care. 
 Throughout its early life, the calf stays close to its mother, positioning itself above  the midline and forward of her dorsal fin. 
 During swimming the young may press its flipper against her side and thus be helped to move with her. 
 As the calf grows older the bond with the mother weakens, although it may last 2 or 3 years. 
 Interactions with other young increase, and similar-aged individuals will form into groups, either of the same or of mixed sex. 
 Protection and Aggression 
 Cetaceans have few predators other than man. 
 Sharks, killer whales, and false killer whales are believed to present some threat to dolphins - scar marks thought to have been caused by shark attack have been observed. 
 However dolphins and toothed whales commonly rake each other with their teeth, as dominant animals show aggression towards subordinates (usually younger males) and in competition for females, and this may also be a cause of scarring. 
 The common response to predator attack appears to be for the cetaceans to flee, often silently, having first formed a tight group if they can. 
 Sometimes aggression will be displayed, and the predator is pursued or attacked. 
 Bottlenose and hump-backed dolphins have been seen chasing off shark predators and even killing them, but packs of killer whales can encircle and trap a school of dolphins with a curtain of sound, before selecting a few hapless victims. 
 Despite their fearsome reputation, however, killer whales have never been known to attack humans without the provocation of a bullet or harpoon, although boats have occasionally been attacked and sunk. 
 Play and Friendship 
 Dolphins of all ages are frequently seen playing with each other. 
 Young dolphins repeatedly practise aerial leaps and spins, and fin and head slaps. 
 They will ride the surf or the bows of a vessel, constantly passing back and forth and making boisterous leaps. 
 Young dolphins also play with toys such as feathers and stones in long and involved games. 
 Social and sexual behaviour is common with much tactile contact by young animals, who stroke one another with their penis or flippers, and may swim together belly to belly or touching flippers &mdash; something similar to holding hands. 
 They do this throughout life, not only in courtship, and the penis probably serves as a tactile as well as sexual organ. 
 This friendly, affectionate behaviour is often extended to humans. 
 Much attention has been given to the seemingly altruistic behaviour of dolphins, with various authors citing such examples as the way cetaceans will assist or stand by other ill, injured or stranded animals even to the point of their own death. 
 They are always ready to rescue and support sick or injured animals and help them to the surface to breathe, in the same way that mothers and &bquo;aunts&equo; will help their young to take their first breath. 
 Dolphins will also come to the defence of each other in fighting off an attacker or threat, and they are ready to extend these forms of rescue to humans in distress.  
 Dolphins are incredibly graceful and efficient swimmers. 
 Powering themselves with their tails and using their flippers for steering and balance, they are often seen travelling at speeds greater than 45 k per hour (25 knots), and the fastest species can reach maximum speeds of over 56 k per hour. 
 They'll frequently jump cigar out of the water while swimming fast, enabling them to maintain their speed while coming to the surface to breathe. 
 dolphins are capable of remarkable feats of aquabatics. 
 Walking backwards on their tails and soaring to astonishing heights to nod balls or jump over ropes are common features of public displays. 
 Dolphins and whales can store large reserves of oxygen, not only in their large veins and blood sinuses, but also in their muscles. 
 A diving whale may store more than 40 per cent of its oxygen intake in its muscles, far more than a human is capable of. 
 Cetacean muscle is usually very dark because of the presence of the respiratory pigment myoglobin, which acts as an oxygen reservoir. 
 The condition known as the &bquo;bends&equo; is caused by the absorption of nitrogen into the bloodstream from the air in the lungs. 
 As the pressure increases, so does the amount of nitrogen forced into the bloodstream of a SCUBA diver. 
 Unless the pressure is reduced very gradually, the nitrogen cam be released from solution as small bubbles, which can lodge in joints, causing severe pain, or in vital blood vessels, causing paralysis or death. 
 At 100 metres (325 feet), a dolphin's lungs are probably completely collapsed &mdash; all the air has been forced into the thick-walled windpipe and nasal passages, from where no nitrogen can be absorbed into the blood. 
 As the air in the lungs was at only atmospheric pressure when inhaled, the amount of nitrogen absorbed into the dolphin's bloodstream is insufficient to cause bubbles to form on surfacing. 
 The baleen whales (Mysticetes) are huge creatures who sieve from the sea small crustaceans and fish through a curtain of fibrous baleen material hanging from their upper jaw. 
 The toothed whales (Odontocetes) have teeth and eat larger prey such as fish and squid. 
 The baleen whales include most of the larger species known as the Great Whales, but represent only 11 of the 77 cetacean species currently recognised. 
 The toothed whales range in size from the smallest dolphins, 1.3 metres (4.2 feet) long and 30&ndash;40 kg (6068 lb) in weight, to the mature bull sperm whale, 18 metres (58 feet) and 50 tonnes or more. 
 Over half the species of toothed whales are dolphins or the closely related porpoises. 
 Scientists characterise dolphins by their pointed teeth; porpoises have spade-shaped teeth and a different bone structure in the skull. 
 In common use, however, the terms dolphin and porpoise are often interchangeable. 
 Dolphins need to eat considerable quantities of food. 
 A 120 kg (260 lb) Dall's porpoise, a fast-swimming and deep-diving species, consumed 15 kg (3 lb) of fish daily without increasing its weight while held in captivity in California &mdash; equivalent to a human eating 7&ndash;10 kg (15&ndash;22 lb) of steak in a day. 
 And the dolphins high-protein diet makes them especially vulnerable to environmental contaminants which become increasingly concentrated as they are passed up the food chain. 
 Dolphins have an ingenious adaptation to cope with eating under water. 
 On the upper surface of the tongue of many species are small perforations, whose purpose is to stimulate the mucous glands at the base of the tongue as soon as the fish is taken into the mouth. 
 This mucus floods the area at the base of the tongue and the entrance to the gullet, adhering to the walls. 
 As the fish enters the gullet, the mucus clings closely to the skin of the fish as well as the walls of the gullet and it closes behind the disappearing tail, thus preventing any salt water from entering the stomach. 
 Food-herding by white-beaked dolphins: Upper: Dolphins converge to bunch the fish together. 
 Lower: A group moves in a U-shaped formation in the direction of a smaller number of individuals, napping the herded fish. 
 Group numbers in dolphins may reach into the thousands and oceanic dolphins may gather in numbers exceeding 100,000. 
 Striped dolphins and Dall's porpoise are most often seen in groups of 530 and 2&ndash;20, respectively, but both have also been observed in numbers of around 300. 
 Most species generally congregate in groups of 6&ndash;60 individuals. 
 The size of groups can be difficult to measure, because dolphins apparently travelling separately may in fact be part of a widely spread group in acoustic communication with each other. 
 Dolphins spend a lot of time enjoying sex and foreplay, and unlike most wild animals, their sexual interest is not determined by being &bquo;in season&equo;, or the urge to procreate. 
 They are exponents of free love, and generally seem to be promiscuous and ready to make love with everyone, including mothers, fathers, aunts, uncles, and children. 
 Bulls have been observed to mate with as many as 20 females, after much love play, over one and half hours. 
 According to Lyall Watson, this &bquo;freedom of sexual expression and emancipation of sex from purely seasonal procreative activity usually indicates a high level of behavioural organisation and development&equo;. 
 Courtship of the Ganges dolphins. 
 The lifespan of cetaceans varies among species, the larger species generally living longer. 
 Examples average lifespans are 20 years for the common, bottlenose, and Ganges River dolphins, and 25 years for the narwhal. 
 Maximum lifespans may be much greater, some narwhal and spotted dolphin living to 40&ndash;50 years, and the Baird's beaked whale possibly to the ripe old age of 70 years. 
 &bquo;If a dolphin can out-manoeuvre or outswim a shark it will do so&hellip;. if the dolphins cannot take evasive action for some good reason, such as that a birth is about to take place, they will attack a shark. 
 The females close in on him, led by some old lady dolphin who has obviously had much practice at settling sharks. 
 She will strike a tremendous blow with the end of her beak. 
 Her mouth is tightly shut and the full weight of her body is behind the blow which the shark gets in the liver and can prove fatal. 
 if he survives this and decides to retreat he is allowed to do so, but if he stands his ground he is doomed. 
 The rest of the females will butt him&hellip;. until his liver is pulverised.&equo; 
 Frank Robson, New Zealand whale and dolphin expert  
 page 40: drawing 
 Dolphins and their closely related cousins, the porpoises and small whales, show many of the attributes of Intelligence and social awareness which humans have recognised in the great whales. 
 Yet while there has been a concerted worldwide effort to save the larger cetaceans from agonising death by human hands, the small cetaceans have in recent years been dying in record numbers. 
 THE SAD STORY OF THE RIVER DOLPHINS 
 The dolphins that live in the large, silty, turbid rivers of Asia and South America are strange, almost mythical creatures with long sensitive beaks, small near-blind eyes, and broad short flippers. 
 They show features once considered primitive, but many scientists now consider them to be highly specialised. 
 Their story is one of the saddest, as two species, the Indus River dolphin and the Yangtze River dolphin (baiji), are on the edge of extinction, and their continued survival seems unlikely. 
 The survival of the other species of river dolphin is also precarious and to a certain extent unknown, as accurate figures on population numbers are lacking. 
 No one knows whether river dolphins were once more abundant or whether their numbers have always been low because of their restrictive and specialised habitat. 
 But they are now undoubtedly the most endangered of the dolphin species, largely because their small and isolated populations are particularly vulnerable to the industrialisation which has occurred throughout much of their range in the past few decades. 
 Besides the destruction of their habitat caused by dam building, silt and pollutant discharges into rivers, and the effects of boat traffic, the dolphins have also had to contend with accidental capture in fisheries, directed hunts for food and other uses, and even capture for display in overseas aquaria. 
 INDUS RIVER DOLPHIN 
 The Indus River dolphin is found only in the Indus River and its tributaries in Pakistan, and was once widespread throughout the 3200 kilometre (2000-mile) river system. 
 Only about 500 dolphins remain, however, and the species is verging on extinction. 
 The Indus River dolphin is a small, essentially blind creature, which swims on its side, hunting for fish by echolocation. 
 It has been traditionally hunted for food and as a source of medicinal oil, and has in recent years been accidentally captured in fishing nets. 
 The dolphin is practically extinct in the Punjab, where only 60 to 70 are reported to survive in the thousands of kilometres of river which were until recent times the home of many more animals. 
 The decline in dolphin numbers in the Punjab is probably largely due to the activities of the local dagori , or dolphin catchers. 
 Others die from entanglement in fishing nets. 
 The severest human impact on this rare creature, however, has been  the loss of its habitat. 
 During the 1960s and early 1970s, a series of dams was built along the river as part of a massive irrigation system. 
 Six barrages on the Indus itself, and more in the river's tributaries, have created impassable barriers, preventing seasonal migrations and separating and isolating different populations. 
 The dams also render the animals easy prey for hunters and trap them when the water is drained for irrigation. 
 In 1972 the Government of Sind Province declared the river dolphin protected by law and prohibited its killing and trapping. 
 Several years later, after a recommendation from the World Wildlife Fund, the Government established part of the Indus river in the Sind Province as a dolphin reserve, where 400 of the 500 remaining dolphins are reasonably well protected. 
 The dolphin received further protection in 1975, when the District Magistrate of Sukkur made trapping or killing of dolphins illegal under a Criminal Procedure Code, which was given extensive publicity by drums, through radio and newspapers, and by placing posters in key locations. 
 As a result of these measures, the river dolphin population now appears to be stabilising and even increasing, but the dolphin is still extremely vulnerable and needs continued surveillance at both national and international levels. 
 As often happens with highly endangered species, this dolphin has been much sought after as a rare specimen for overseas aquaria, and has been captured for display in the US and Switzerland. 
 GANGES RIVER DOLPHIN (Ganges susu) 
 The Ganges susu, closely related to the Indus River dolphin, is a more abundant species found in the Ganges, Brahmaputra, and Meghna river  systems, from the estuaries in Bangladesh and Bengal, up to Nepal and the Himalayas. 
 No complete census of dolphins has ever been carried out in India, although the total population is generally assumed to be between 4000 and 5000. 
 The dolphin is under threat from various quarters. 
 In both India and Nepal, Ganges susu are hunted and killed for their oil. 
 Indian fishermen use dolphin oil to lure catfish into their nets, and in Nepal, dolphins are netted by fishermen and marketed for their oil, which is used as a remedy for a wide range of diseases. 
 As with the Indus River dolphin, the construction of dams has seriously affected the Ganges susu, both through draw-down of rivers and loss of habitat. 
 The changes in water flows inevitably associated with dams have enormous impacts on the ecology of any dammed river. 
 The lakes created behind the barriers often become de-oxygenated through rotting submerged vegetation. 
 The populations of invertebrates, plankton, and fish change, and top predators such as dolphins may find their traditional prey disappearing altogether. 
 In Nepal, dolphin habitat has traditionally been in deep clear water with swift currents, but hydro-electric development is occurring in many of the susu's favourite remaining areas. 
 Construction of hydroelectric dams not only removes the opportunity for adjacent populations to interbreed, it also utterly changes the characteristics of the river, with siltation and often stagnation occurring upstream of the barrier. 
 THE YANGTZE RIVER DOLPHIN (baiji) 
 Rivalling the Indus River dolphin for the dubious distinction of most endangered dolphin, is the baiji or Chinese river dolphin, a little-known species found only in the Yangtze River. 
 Once found throughout the Yangtze, as well as the adjacent Futon River, the baiji, 2.5 metres (8 feet) long, is now reduced to a handful of sub-groups. 
 Its total population is thought to be no greater than 200&ndash;300, scattered along about 1400 km (875 miles) of the Yangtze's lower and central sections. 
 About 350 million people live in the Yangtze valley, and its thousands of kilometres of waterways are essential to commerce, industry, and  fishing. 
 The Yangtze River valley supplies 40&ndash;70 per cent of China's annual grain harvests, and is home to nearly three-quarters of the country's heavy industry. 
 The river system serves simultaneously as a commercial waterway, a source of huge volumes of water for industry, and a sink for the wastes and debris of modern society, as well as a source of food for the human population and a livelihood for tens of thousands of fisherfolk. 
 Increasing volumes of boat traffic along the river, pollution, industrial activities along the river bank, siltation, and incidental mortalities from fishing all contribute to the baiji's decline. 
 Like China's famous panda, the baiji is a fully protected species, recognised as part of China's natural heritage, and the Chinese government has taken several steps to improve the prospects for the animal's continued survival into the twenty-first century. 
 Education programmes have been established to inform river-based communities about the plight of the baiji. 
 Laws have been passed to restrict the use of the &bquo;rolling hook'&equo; fishing method, in which groups of large unbaited hooks are placed on the river bed, with the intention of impaling large catfish. 
 Unfortunately, river dolphins and catfish inhabit the same river, and between 1950 and 1980, about half the 100 or so baiji found dead had died from swallowing or being snagged by fish hooks. 
 Even in areas where the use of nylon set-nets and &bquo;rolling hooks&equo; are officially prohibited, these practices are still in use and are responsible for many dolphin deaths each year. 
 Others die from collisions with vessels travelling up and down the river, and from explosions carried out during river bank construction. 
 The baiji, like the Indus River dolphin, is classified as among the most endangered cetacean species by IUCN. 
 Its survival far into the next century is unlikely. 
 AMAZON RIVER DOLPHIN (boto) 
 The boto (also often spelt boutu) is found throughout the Amazon and Orinoco river systems, which flow through Peru, Brazil, Ecuador, Guyana, Venezuela, and Colombia, including tributaries upstream in Bolivia. 
 Pink in colour, the boto may be up to 2.75 metres (9 feet) in length. 
 It feeds on a wide variety of fish &mdash; 43 different species are known to be taken as prey. 
 The boto is protected by law in Bolivia as well as Brazil. 
 Human pressures on the Amazon, however, are intense, and the dolphin's habitat is being rapidly developed and degraded. 
 There are no reliable estimates of the past or present size of its populations, or of the rates of losses, although fishing is clearly a major cause of accidental death. 
 According to two post-graduate researchers who were studying the dolphin in Brazil, Vera da Silva and the late Robin Best, the boto is caught in seine-nets, gill-nets and drift-nets. 
 Apparently, the dolphin has learned to use a partially formed seine-net (which works by encircling a school of fish) to catch fish, while the fishermen wait in the river for the arrival of a large school. 
 In some areas, the dolphins may actually assist the fishermen by herding up the fish. 
 Perhaps for this reason, traditional fishermen generally try to release alive any captured dolphins, but if they are inside the net when it is closed, they may become entangled or trapped and drown. 
 Large-scale use of set-nets in the Amazon is recent, and has come about because of the worldwide availability of cheap monofilament nylon nets. 
 Although the boto is a powerful animal, and can sometimes tear its way out of nets, more often it becomes entangled and drowns. 
 The boto has also reportedly become adept at stealing fish from this type of net, and may cause considerable damage to the fishing gear in the process.  
 According to Best and da Silva, the degree of hostility from commercial fishermen towards the boto is unquestionably growing. 
 In the past this has been countered by the numerous superstitions of the indigenous peoples towards the river dolphins, but as the economic pressures of the commercial fishery become greater, these superstitions are likely to become less respected, especially by the younger fishermen. 
 Development pressures in the Amazon basin, such as the construction of hydro-electric dams, deforestation, and commercial fishing, have brought a flood of new settlers to the area. 
 Many of them are reportedly gun-happy, and have taken to firing shots at the river dolphins. 
 The meat is not eaten and has no market value, but the dried eyes and the sexual organs of the boto are often sold as amulets to increase one's attractiveness to the opposite sex, or to increase the bearer's sexual powers. 
 Eyeballs are sold openly in markets and tourist shops in Rio de Janeiro and other major cities. 
 Other dolphin products are also in demand in Brazil, especially dolphin oil, which is a favourite lure for fish. 
 Although the populations and the status of the boto are not known, probably numbers are declining. 
 Fortunately, a recommendation made by the Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO) of the United Nations in its 1960 Report on the Fisheries of the Amazon Region has not been followed, or the situation would be worse still. 
 The FAO report, written at a time of negligible ecological awareness in fisheries management, suggested that populations of dolphins and fish-eating birds should be reduced to raise the fisheries potential of the region. 
 Like the Indus River dolphin, boto are also sought after by wealthy institutions in developed countries. 
 A steady number of dolphins are captured alive in Venezuela, Colombia, Peru, and Brazil for aquarium display in the US and Japan. 
 Seventy boto have been captured for display in aquaria in the US since 1956. 
 By 1986, only one captured animal remained alive. 
 TUCUXI 
 Also found in the Amazon basin is the tucuxi (it is a member of the hump-backed dolphin family). 
 Although not closely related to other river dolphins, the tucuxi is included here because it shares a similar habitat. 
 The tucuxi is one of the few dolphins to be found in both fresh and salt waters. 
 Its range extends from Colombia, all along the eastern coast of South America in shallow coastal waters, to around Santos in and throughout the Amazon River and the lower parts of its tributaries. 
 There are no population estimates, but the tucuxi is currently listed as highly endangered. 
 The distribution of the boto and tucuxi show considerable overlap, and according to da Silva and Best, both are the victims of accidental death from entanglement in fixed nylon gill-nets. 
 The tucuxi is, however only half the length of the boto, and is thus less able to break out of gill-nets when captured. 
 Although fixed gill-nets may drown more tucuxi, they generally avoid shallow inshore areas, and are therefore rarely caught in the beach seines which are such a hazard for the boto. 
 But drift gill-nets (which are not fixed) present a much greater entanglement hazard for the tucuxi, since they are used in the deep main river channels rarely frequented by the boto. 
 Although the ranges of the two dolphins correspond geographically, the feeding ecology of the two species is more distinct. 
 The tucuxi preys on some 28 fish species, but only 13 of these are also taken by the boto. 
 Analysis of the frequency of occurrence and the biomass of these fish suggests little competition for food between the two species.  
 Incidental catches in gill-nets are widespread, and the tucuxi is also harpooned in many places along the central and northern coasts of Brazil. 
 They are used for shark bait and for human consumption, and the sexual organs are sought as love charms or amulets. 
 LA PLATA RIVER DOLPHIN (franciscana) 
 The franciscana may be the closest living relative of the baiji. 
 It is one of the smallest cetaceans &mdash; adults may be less than 1.3 metres (4.2 feet) long and weigh less than 30 kg (66 lb). 
 It inhabits the Atlantic coast of South America, from the Valdez Peninsula in Argentina to the Tropic of Capricorn in Brazil.  
 The greatest human impact has been in Uruguay, where 600&ndash;2000 franciscanas have been drowning annually in a gill-net fishery for sharks in recent years. 
 Several hundred more are thought to die each year in gill-net fisheries in northern Argentina, and at least 250 were reported incidentally taken in Brazilian fisheries in 1983. 
 There is no reliable estimate of abundance for the franciscana, although the incidental gill-net kill of tens of thousands of dolphins over the last 30 years has undoubtedly significantly reduced the total population. 
 The number of interbreeding populations is unknown, as are chances for long-term survival. 
 WHAT HOPE FOR THE RIVER DOLPHINS? 
 As the terrible inevitability of extinction looms ever closer for the baiji and Indus River dolphin, the international community is belatedly responding to the conservation challenge. 
 The International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) has developed a 5-year (1988&ndash;1992) Action Plan, which features the preservation of the river dolphins as one of its major objectives. 
 The IUCN is seeking funds for several vital programmes aimed at safeguarding these rare and fascinating creatures. 
 Among these programmes are: 
 Baseline studies for a proposed baiji reserve at Shi Shou. 
 The best hope for the beleaguered baiji is the establishment of semi-natural reserve areas where some dolphins can feed and breed without the danger of human interference. 
 Establishment of reserves for the Indus River dolphin in the Punjab, where no more than 80 animals are thought to remain. 
 Establishment of a Ganges River Dolphin Project, similar to the highly successful Tiger Project which brought together various government agencies, international conservation organisations, and universities in a tightly directed campaign to save remaining tiger habitats and arrest the steady population decline of previous decades. 
 A similar plan to save the river dolphins would need to bring together the major universities and management agencies along the Ganges and Brahmaputra Rivers. 
 Surveying the distribution of dolphins and promoting the establishment of dolphin reserves in suitable areas of Bangladesh, India, and Nepal. 
 Establishing a dialogue on river dolphin conservation and management between the governments of Brazil, Peru, Venezuela, Colombia, Ecuador, and Bolivia. 
 Promoting establishment of river dolphin conservation areas in Brazil. 
 Promoting legislation to fully protect river dolphins in Peru, Ecuador, Colombia, and Venezuela, and enforcement of existing laws in other areas of river dolphin habitat. 
 Whether the headlong rush to develop and industrialise the world's last great wild places can be controlled to ensure the survival of the unique river dolphins will depend on how the respective governments accept their responsibilities to care for and conserve the wonders of natural evolution. 
 For developing countries with large populations, the problems contributing to the decline in river dolphin numbers are often closely tied to regional and national economies which support millions of people. 
 Yet the current momentum of industrial development is expected to result in the disappearance of no less than 20,000 species of plants and animals over the next decade. 
 As the species which is most obviously shaping the future of planet Earth, humans need to examine the consequences of many current development strategies and urgently find solutions.  
 Most river dolphins are almost blind. 
 They have an extraordinarily sensitive echolocation system, and their huge foreheads enclose a large brain and sound organ which enable them to navigate and detect prey in conditions of zero visibility. 
 During tropical rainy seasons when rivers flood and spread muddy waters over the land, the Amazon River dolphin ranges miles from the river bed seeking fish. 
 Unlike oceanic dolphins, they have articulated vertebrae similar to those of land mammals, which enable them to manoeuvre through tree trunks and roots in flooded forests. 
 They can travel easily in silty water only a metre or so deep, and as the waters recede they can remember the way back to the river bed along deep channels. 
 Map of the Indus and Ganges River catchments, showing the known distribution of Indus River dolphins and Ganges susu. 
 Distribution of Yangtze River dolphins (baiji), China. 
 In am attempt to rescue the baiji from extinction, a joint US-Chinese research team is establishing reserves. 
 Scientists from Nanjing Normal University are building display tanks and a semi-natural reserve in the form of a 1.5km (1-mile) channel between two islands in the river at Tongling. further upstream, at Shi Shou, the Wuhan institute plans to adapt a 20-k (12-mile) old oxbow in the river to become a reserve. 
 Even with supplementary feeding, only a few dolphins can be kept alive in such small reserves, which may not be enough to maintain an adequate gene pool. 
 Even here, their future remains in the balance. 
 The boto is credited with many natural and supernatural powers. 
 Some stories tell of botos coming up underneath canoes and taking off with the paddles, leaving a lone canoeist adrift on the river, while at other times the dolphin is said to have saved the lives of people from a capsized boat. 
 The boto is certainly credited with keeping away the flesh-eating piranha fish. 
 They are also believed to come ashore during fiestas and dance with village girls, and they are held responsible for many a fatherless child. 
 Distribution of boto, tucxi and franciscana dolphins, south America. 
 &bquo;The human standard of living has become the planet's standard of dying. 
 &bquo;How much is really saved by reducing a species to a handful of survivors and banishing them to glorified captivity? 
 What is the real cost of degrading an entire river system to the point that it is no longer capable of supporting its most highly-evolved species?&equo; 
 Sam La Budde, US environmental activist  
 THE DELIBERATE KILLING OF DOLPHINS 
 Tens of thousands of dolphins and small whales throughout the world are still being deliberately and often brutally massacred every year. 
 The stories of &bquo;directed kills'&equo; are some of the most horrifying of all. 
 Japan, Peru, and the Faroe Islands, Greenland and Arctic regions, and Caribbean countries, are all actively hunting dolphins and small whales for food. 
 Japan shredded a large proportion of the dolphins it hunted and turned them into fertiliser. 
 Turkey greatly reduced dolphin populations in the Black Sea to produce dolphin oil and chicken feed. 
 In Chile, some of the world's most endangered dolphins are being killed for crab bait. 
 Some of the stories that follow are now history, but the damage to dolphins is irreparable. 
 In most cases the slaughter still continues, driving some species close to extinction. 
 And what we tell here may not even be the whole story. 
 Further reports of deliberate dolphin killings keep coming to light and have yet to be substantiated; the true story may be even worse. 
 KILLING DOLPHINS FOR HUMAN FOOD 
 THE JAPANESE 
 Dolphins have been hunted in Japanese coastal waters since at least the seventeenth century, when drive fisheries were first reported. 
 According to Japanese scientist Masaharu Nishiwaki, the consumption  of dolphin was traditionally restricted to poorer people, especially those living in cold coastal and mountainous districts. 
 The blubber was probably considered to be a valuable dietary supplement to help counter the effects of the cold weather. 
 Now, however, the demand for dolphin meat for the human dinner table is rapidly increasing. 
 Whale meat has traditionally been a popular part of the Japanese diet, but since the International Whaling Commission's moratorium on commercial whaling took effect in 1985, the price of whale meat on the Japanese market has risen dramatically. 
 Now, only the wealthiest can afford to eat it, served in high class restaurants as a great delicacy. 
 Hunters are cashing in on this shortage and expense of whale meat, and are providing the Japanese market with a more affordable substitute of dolphin flesh. 
 Where an average minke whale would yield between 1000 and 2000 kg (2200&ndash;4400 lb) of meat, now some 17&ndash;34 dolphins have to die to provide an equivalent amount. 
 Sometimes the dolphin is mixed and sold with whale meat, and called Kurokujira , or black whale meat, on the Tokyo market.  
 separate section 
 THE DRIVE FISHERIES 
 The drive fishery is a barbaric practice that often kills entire schools of dolphins. 
 The dolphin flesh is destined for local meat markets, and although Japanese scientists have often appealed to fishermen to release young animals, they are generally ignored since tender infant dolphin meat fetches the highest prices. 
 The drive fisheries are centred on the Izu and Kii Peninsulas in the southern Honshu region of Japan. 
 The main target is striped dolphin, because it is the easiest to capture. 
 In 1975, a record kill year, approximately 20,000 striped dolphins were killed in the drives. 
 These dolphins are oceanic travellers, with a migration route Of thousands of kilometres which takes them past the southern coastline of Japan on both legs of their annual migration. 
 Fishermen of the Kii and Izu Peninsulas therefore have two seasons for hunting dolphins each year. 
 The city of Ito, on the Izu peninsula, and Taiji, on the Kii peninsula, are the major base ports for the drive fisheries. 
 Dolphin has been a popular food in Ito for many years. 
 The city not only has its own traditional dolphin stew, but also a dish known as iruka kuroshioboshi , dried dolphin meat cured to the consistency of leather. 
 It's a popular snack in bars and restaurants. 
 Members of the Ito Fishermen's Union carry out drives cooperatively. 
 Every time a dolphin school is sighted, the group decides whether to pursue it and attempt the drive. 
 All the fishermen stop fishing to join in the drive. 
 The dolphins have often formed up in groups of up to 3000 when they reach Izu, and they are driven into the narrow inlets of Suruga Bay. 
 Successful drives often capture the entire group. 
 Catches of as many as 4000 dolphins in a single drive have been reported from the last century, and the record number of animals killed in a single day during the 1970s was 2838. 
 The average annual catch, mainly of striped dolphins, in the drive fisheries between 1975 and 1986 was 4734. 
 Other species taken in the drives are bottlenose dolphin (average catch 926), Pacific white-sided dolphin (440), and pilot whale (466). 
 Species such as Risso's dolphin and false killer whales are killed in smaller numbers.  
 THE DESTRUCTION OF DALL'S PORPOISE 
 The last-swimming oceanic Dall's porpoise is a popular food item and has been a favourite target of Japanese harpoons in the province of Iwate (north-eastern Honshu) for many years. 
 The porpoises delight in riding on the bow waves of motor boats, which has frequently proved to be a fatal mistake. 
 By even a conservative estimate, about 10,000 Dall's porpoise were harpooned each year from 1976 to 1987. 
 However, the director of research on small cetaceans at the National Far Seas Fisheries Research Institute, Dr Toshio Kasuya, believes that the number of dolphins caught, as reported through fishing unions, underestimated the catch by at least 40,000. 
 Between 1977 and 1981, the season For hunting Dall's porpoise Increased from 4 months to 10 months, and in 1987 the number of boats hunting the dolphins and porpoises in the area increased from 200 to 350. 
 By 1988, it had almost doubled again to 600, and boats based on Iwate took over 90 per cent of the total reported Japanese dolphin and porpoise catch. 
 Kasuya's fears proved to be well founded, and he dropped a bombshell at the 1989 meeting of the IWC's Scientific Committee, when he revealed to the Small Cetaceans Subcommittee the staggering increase in the number of Dall's porpoise killed in the harpoon fishery based on Iwate Prefecture. 
 In 1988, according to Kasuya, over 39,000 Dall's porpoise were killed in the harpoon fishery, not including porpoises that were struck but escaped, possibly mortally wounded. 
 At the same IWC meeting, Kasuya tabled a paper which estimated the abundance of Dall's porpoise in the harpoon fishery area to be no greater than 105,000. 
 In a single year the unregulated Japanese hunt had killed almost half the local porpoise population. 
 The Scientific Committee had in previous years expressed concern about the Dall's porpoise harpoon fishery, fearing that even the much smaller annual catch may not have been sustainable, since Japanese scientists had calculated a replacement rate of only about 5000 porpoises each year. 
 However, the scientists' attitudes towards the current catch level were clear. 
 At the 1989 meeting, &bquo;the subcommittee concluded that the take was clearly not sustainable and that, depending on the stock composition of the catch, the situation could be even worse than was immediately apparent. 
 For example, the incidental take from squid gill-net fisheries by Taiwan and Korea was unreported and therefore an unknown quantity. 
 The subcommittee said it was a matter of urgency to ensure the catch was reduced to at least the levels of previous years (which themselves had possibly been too high).&equo; 
 Concerned at the rapid expansion of the hunt, and the declining stocks of small cetaceans around the coastline, the Iwate Prefecture in January 1989 instituted a licensing system, so that for the first time ever, the hunt could be regulated. 
 No new applications for dolphin hunting will be accepted, and the number of licensed vessels is to be reduced from 600 to 540. 
 Only boats under 20 tonnes will be permitted, and August and September will be a closed season. 
 Such half-hearted measures, however, are unlikely to significantly reduce porpoise catches before the stocks collapse. 
 Before 1989, dolphin and porpoise hunting in Japan was unregulated, and from 1981 catches rose steadily so that by 1987 over 21,000 animals were reported taken for human consumption, and the following year officially reported numbers had risen again to over 25,000. 
 In 1989, fishermen received double the price of 2 years earlier. 
 A major attraction of dolphin and porpoise hunting is the low operating costs - all that is needed is a harpoon and fuel for the boat. 
 Some boats are reported to take 500&ndash;600 animals during a 3-month season. 
 As coastal fisheries have become less profitable through overfishing, more fishermen have taken to killing small cetaceans to supplement their incomes. 
 Close to a quarter of a million small cetaceans were killed between 1976 and 1987 in Japan. 
 The dolphins and porpoises are hunted either with hand harpoons or in drive fisheries. 
 Around 2 per cent die in set-nets. 
 THE PERUVIANS 
 In 1985 Peruvian fishermen caught around 10,000 dolphins and porpoises, most of them destined for the fish markets of Peru's capital Lima, making Peru second only to Japan in the consumption of dolphin flesh. 
 Fish, sea birds, and small cetaceans have long gathered in large numbers to feed in the deep waters off the Peruvian coast, which are among the richest in the world. 
 The Humboldt Current that sweeps up the western side of South America brings an upwelling of nutrient-rich water from the ocean depths. 
 For many years, the Peruvian catch of anchoveta was the largest volume fishery in the world, peaking in 1970 at 12.28 million tonnes. 
 Overfishing, combined with the effects of the cyclical change in currents known as El Nino  (which can cause widespread collapses in the marine food-web), resulted in the collapse of the anchoveta stocks in 1972, when catches fell to less than one-twentieth of that in the 1970 season. 
 During the 1970s, many fishermen were forced from the anchoveta fishery and the associated use of purse-seine vessels, and began using smaller boats, setting gill-nets to catch coastal fish species. 
 When these nets also started to fish up cetaceans (mainly Burmeister's porpoise) as an incidental catch, the fishermen discovered a ready market for porpoise meat among lower income groups. 
 By 1975, over 100 tonnes of  porpoise meat was being sold in Peruvian fish markets, amounting to at least 2000 animals killed each year. 
 Since then, some Peruvian fishermen have specialised in capturing small cetaceans for human consumption. 
 And as the numbers of porpoises have dwindled, they have fished local dolphin populations, in particular dusky dolphins, most of which are caught with small driftnets. 
 Although the total catch of small cetaceans is only a small proportion of the total landings of fisheries products in Peru, for some ports the landings of dolphins may be very significant. 
 In Cerro Azul in 1984, dolphins comprised almost 19 per cent by weight of the fish and marine products caught for human consumption. 
 Because there are no reliable estimates for the abundance of any of the small cetacean species exploited in Peru, the impact on the dolphin and porpoise populations in the area, or how much longer they can withstand the pressure, cannot be assessed. 
 A multi-national research team led by Andrew Read of the University of Guelph in Ontario, Canada, and Koen van Waerebeek, University of Ghent, Belgium, monitored the landed catch of dolphins in a number of Peruvian ports during 1986 and 1987, primarily at Pucusana and Cerro Azul. 
 Not only did they monitor landings at the wharf, they also sifted through refuse dumps to find the remains of butchered dolphins, to estimate catches in previous seasons. 
 More than 80 per cent of dolphins are caught in a directed drift-net fishery operating from August to October. 
 Nets, 0.6&ndash;1.5 km (0.5&ndash;1 mile) long and 7&ndash;10 metres (23&ndash;33 feet) deep, are usually set at dusk and retrieved in the morning. 
 Catches are better on windy, moonless nights. 
 Dolphins are also harpooned if they approach boats closely enough, and some are also taken incidentally in purse-seines and coastal set-nets. 
 FAROE ISLANDS &mdash; BUTCHERY AMIDST AFFLUENCE 
 Participating in a traditional bloody ritual called the grynd , that dates back over the centuries, Faroe Islanders each year herd large schools of pilot whales into shallow waters and then, with man and whale alike thrashing in red blood-stained water, the animals are gaffed, speared, or knifed to death. 
 The effect on the whales is tragic &mdash; at least 220,000 pilot whales have been killed in these drives since first records were kept in 1709. 
 To the outsider, the way the whales are killed is nothing short of barbaric. 
 When a herd of whales is sighted, two-way radios carry the news from village to village. 
 The villagers turn out en masse , and with motor boats (replacing the row-boats of earlier days) they herd the whales into bays to trap them. 
 The killing can then be a long and slow process, and the animals often have to endure hours trapped in the midst of the bloody massacre of their family, awaiting their own agonising mutilation. 
 The Faroe Islands, halfway between Scotland and Iceland in the stormy North Atlantic Ocean, were colonised some 1000 years ago by the Vikings. 
 For centuries, their descendants led a harsh and precarious existence, relying heavily on the sea to provide food. 
 The occasional beachings of pilot whales must have provided a welcome source of protein. 
 The Faroese soon developed a drive fishery for pilot whales, and the grynd  came to be an important social event, an occasion when the whole community would come together to catch their food. 
 The grynd  continues, but these days the whale meat is no longer needed for food, and islanders are often having to empty last year's whale meat from the freezer to make way for the fresh catch. 
 Large quantities of unused frozen meat and blubber have been found on rubbish dumps after recent drives. 
 Killing has now become more of a sport, or an adherence to an ancient custom. 
 In fact the Faroese are killing more whales than ever. 
 Throughout the 1970s, the average annual catch of  pilot whales was 880, but from 1979 to 1984, the average rose to over 2300. 
 In 1987, 1422 whales were killed, and in 1988, the toll rose to 1690 pilot whales. 
 Other species are also victims of the Faroese kills, and in 1988, over 600 other small cetaceans were killed, including 544 Atlantic white-sided dolphins slaughtered in a single drive. 
 White beaked dolphins and three rare and protected northern bottlenosed whales were also killed in this year. 
 In 1989 the reported kill figures were 735 pilot whales and 2 rare bottlenose whales. 
 However, the Faroese government has just committed US&dollar;300,000 towards the improvement of two of its main whaling bays &mdash; to make whale killing easier. 
 Until the 1980s the killing of 2000 or so pilot whales each year in the Faroe Islands was considered to be of far less significance than the slaughter of tens of thousands of the much rarer great whale species. 
 After the ban on commercial whaling, however, the IWC is now turning its attention to other species, and international concern is focusing on the Faroes. 
 The Faroe Islands are self-governing, but have been for many years a colony of Denmark, and still rely on the government of the old mother country for international representation. 
 And the IWC has found itself powerless to act to regulate the Faroes hunt because Denmark is claiming that the IWC has no authority over small whales, a view conveniently shared by other countries like Japan and Mexico who hunt or &bquo;accidentally'&equo; catch dolphins within their exclusive economic fishing zones. 
 The Danish government also claims that however much it may disagree with the grynd , it is unable to interfere in the domestic matters of the Faroe Islands. 
 While the politicians make their excuses, the pilot whales continue to be cruelly slaughtered, and their populations in the North Atlantic grow increasingly scarce. 
 They were caught in large numbers for many years from the north-eastern seaboard of the US and Canada, and the Scottish islands of Orkney and Shetland. 
 Stocks around Newfoundland collapsed through overhunting after over 30,000 whales were killed between 1953 and 1957. 
 Only the Faroese now still hunt them in large numbers. 
 A resolution of the European Parliament early in 1989 called upon the Faroese to ban the use of the gaff from boats and in water more than a metre deep. 
 This would eliminate the worst cases of cruelty and would substantially reduce the number of whales killed, as only those beached would be gaffed and killed, and the rest could be driven back to sea. 
 Ironically, the best hope for the pilot whales of the North Atlantic is that they are becoming unsafe for humans to eat. 
 High levels of mercury have been reported from Faroese for some years, and the Health Department there has advised islanders to cut down on the amount of whalemeat they eat. 
 More recently, industrial contaminants such as polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs) have accumulated in the liver and kidneys of pilot whales in quantities which make them unfit for human consumption. 
 THE ARCTIC 
 Some of the world's rarest cetaceans, such as the narwhal, beluga, and harbour porpoise, are still being hunted and killed in the high latitudes of the Arctic. 
 As the commercial whaling industry has declined throughout most of the world, Greenland has been left with one of the highest catches of whales and small cetaceans. 
 Accurate figures for the number of animals caught in these remote freezing areas are hard to collect, but those we do know show the situation to be alarming. 
 In Greenland alone, 1000&ndash;3000 harbour porpoises are killed each year, along with 300&ndash;600 belugas (white whales) and 400&ndash;500 narwhals and some pilot whales. 
 The most seriously endangered species is the harbour porpoise, whose total Arctic population may be as perilously low as 15,000. 
  Beluga populations are also in many places suspected to be at dangerous levels after years of overexploitation. 
 In the mid 1960s annual world catches of beluga were estimated to be around 5000 &mdash; 6000, and 20 years ago in the USSR alone, catches were 3000&ndash;4000. 
 Now the USSR catches only a few hundred belugas each year, not only because of enforced catch limits, but because these impressive creatures just are no longer there to be caught in such numbers. 
 In the freezing barren icelands of the Arctic north, whale and dolphin meat has long been a traditional and important part of the diet for coastal settlements. 
 But many of today's hunts are motivated far more by commercial interests than subsistence needs. 
 For example, narwhal were traditionally hunted for food by the Inuit Eskimoes of the eastern Arctic region of Canada, who ate the outer layer of meat and skin ( muktuk ) and some of the red meat, and fed the remainder to their sled dogs. 
 In recent years sled dogs have been replaced by snowmobiles, so now the main incentive for the whale hunt is the narwhal's single ivory tusk. 
 This ivory increased in value 180-fold from 1961 to 1982. 
 As the price increased, so did the size of the kill, until in 1977 the Canadian government imposed a quota of 400 narwhals per year. 
 The recorded catch has been within the quota for many years. 
 But it is unlikely to be an accurate assessment, because shot and mortally wounded whales, unlike harpooned ones, can escape and die without being retrieved and, of course, are not counted against the quota &mdash; in fact as many as 1000 narwhals may die each year at the hands of Canadian hunters. 
 THE CARIBBEAN 
 Dolphins and small whales have also been hunted in the Caribbean for many years, especially around the island of St Vincent. 
 They are regarded as a valuable source of meat, and for many years also supplied a US market for oil from the pilot whale melon. 
 In St Vincent, 2912 pilot whales were landed between 1962 and 1974, and these &bquo;blackfish&equo;, as they are called, were the main quarry of the Vincentian whalers until the introduction of the US Marine Mammals Protection Act in 1972 closed the US market for whale oil. 
 Blackfishing has since gone into decline, but whalers still pursue and kill other small cetaceans, such as killer whales and small spinner dolphins. 
 Between 1972 and 1974 at least 500 dolphins ended up in meat markets in Kingstown, St Vincent. 
 OTHER DELIBERATE KILLING OF DOLPHINS 
 THE GUNNING DOWN OF DOLPHINS IN THE BLACK SEA 
 Dolphins have been hunted in the Black Sea since the late nineteenth century, when Russian fishermen sought them for their meat and oil. 
 By the mid 1930s, up to a quarter of a million dolphins were being killed each year by Turkish, Bulgarian, Romanian, and Russian hunters. 
 In 1964, dolphin populations off the USSR's area of the Black Sea collapsed, and by 1966, the USSR, Bulgaria, and Romania had prohibited all dolphin hunting. 
 Turkey, however, allowed the hunting of dolphins to continue in its waters, and the annual kill continued to increase. 
 In 1969 alone, an estimated 166,000 dolphins were killed by Turkish hunters, most of them shot. 
 No regulations governed the hunt &mdash; anyone with a rifle and a boat could kill dolphins without a licence. 
 Almost a million dolphins have been killed over the past 20 years, and the populations of dolphins and porpoises in the Black Sea have been decimated. 
 As long ago as 1976, the marine resources committee of the FAO  believed that &bquo;populations of all three dolphin and porpoise species were probably being exploited in the Turkish fishery at levels they would not be able to survive for more than a few years.&equo; 
 They urged the closure of the Turkish fishery or a substantial reduction in the catch. 
 The appeal found no favour with the Turkish government, and the hunt continued unchecked. 
 Little scientific data has ever been released to assess the effect of the killing on the dolphin population, and much of what is known about the hunt has been gathered at great personal risk by non-government organisations. 
 In 1979, British researcher Suzi Newborn visited the eastern Black Sea area, and confirmed that dolphin hunting was still a popular activity. 
 In 1982, the People's Trust for Endangered Species, a conservation group based in the UK, sent Allan Thornton and photographer David Higgs to document the hunt, and attempt to determine the number of dolphins being killed. 
 Posing as the authors of a book on fisheries of the world, Thornton and Higgs, accompanied by an interpreter, set off in search of evidence of the continuing carnage. 
 After 3 days, they reached the port of Ordu, where the dolphin hunt was supposedly centred. 
 There they found two boats tied up alongside the wharf, waiting to unload their cargo of dolphin corpses. 
 One vessel was carrying 78 dolphins, the other had 65 aboard &mdash; the catch from a 5 day expedition. 
 Fortunately for the investigators, the fishermen were eager to talk about dolphin hunting. 
 Thornton and Higgs were told that each boat caught about 2000 dolphins each year, travelling up to 180 km (1 12 miles) offshore to find their quarry. 
 Nevertheless, the rewards were poor. 
 The hunters received on average about US&dollar;5 for each dolphin, and the dolphins were all processed at the nearby factory. 
 According to one of the skippers, each hunting trip cost on average over US&dollar;130 more than the crew received for the catch &mdash; the fishermen were simply carrying on a proud and noble tradition, even though it cost them money. 
 The reporters then visited the government-owned processing plant at Trabzon, the only factory in Turkey still handling dolphins. 
 Here the carcasses were skinned, the oil extracted from the bodies, and the meat turned into meal to be used as chicken-feed. 
 The manager proved to be very co-operative, and Thornton and Higgs were shown the machines which processed the dolphin meat into round slabs of meal, and a huge open vat of dolphin oil. 
 At the end of the factory tour they saw in a large room more than a thousand dolphins, some piled four or five high. 
 At the far end were hundreds of skinned carcasses. 
 A man with a long knife cut the dolphins' skins and fat from the bodies, by cutting across the dolphin's head, slicing it down the middle, then peeling off the outer layer. 
 As they watched, he skinned a pregnant female and pulled a perfectly formed foetus from its belly. 
 All these deaths were adding to a stockpile of dolphin oil, which nobody wanted, and meal for poultry food. 
 The hunters were not even breaking even, yet the hunt continued despite the falling catches. 
 Throughout the late 1970s, tens of thousands of dolphins were killed by Turkish hunters each year. 
 In 1980, the catch exceeded 54,000 animals, but in 1981 fell to about 10,000, with harbour porpoises rather than dolphins comprising most of the catch. 
 The populations of dolphins and porpoises were finally on the verge of total collapse when the Turkish Government suspended the hunt in 1983, and commissioned a report on the populations of dolphins and their effects on fish stocks. 
 Although the report was due in 1987, it has not yet been presented. 
 Turkey is a signatory to the Berne Convention, which prohibits indiscriminate killing of cetaceans.  
 JAPANESE IKI ISLANDERS TURN DOLPHINS INTO FERTILISER 
 The small island of Iki, lying off the northern coast of Japan and near to the coast of South Korea, was until very recently the scene of some of the most terrible examples of deliberate dolphin slaughter several times each year. 
 Hundreds of fishing boats drove whole herds of dolphins into bays where they were massacred, most of them destined to become fertiliser. 
 Over 6000 dolphins and small whales were killed on Iki between 1976 and 1982, two thirds of them bottlenose dolphins. 
 Other species that ended up in fertiliser bags included false killer whales (a small whale about 5 metres (16 feet) long and 2 tonnes in weight), Risso's dolphins, and Pacific white-sided dolphins. 
 The local fishermen alleged that the dolphins were a threat to the local fishing industry, and the Japanese Government was only too ready to support the belief. 
 Reports published by the Japanese Fisheries Agency (a government organisation) between 1968 and 1971 blamed dolphins for damaging fishing gear, stealing hooked fish from fishermen's lines, dispersing fish schools and causing fish to stop feeding. 
 The Agency claimed that the yellowtail angling fishery around Iki suffered in particular. 
 The sad fact is that although the ostensible reason for the dolphin kills was that dolphins were stealing and eating the commercial fish species, examination of their stomach contents showed that only the false killer whales were actually feeding on yellowtail. 
 To add to the senseless tragedy, the Japanese didn't really know what to do with all the dolphin carcasses once they had killed them. 
 At first most were buried on land, then disposal at sea was tried, weighting the dolphin corpses with cement blocks, a method abandoned in 1979. 
 Live animals were sometimes sent to aquaria, but the demand was limited. 
 A demand for dolphin meat for human consumption has been only a recent trend, but high transport costs from the remote Iki Island made the export of edible dolphin meat uneconomic. 
 Finally a solution was found &mdash; large numbers of animals were rapidly disposed of by sending them whole or shredded to a plant which turned them into fertiliser. 
 As word of the dolphin slaughter at Iki spread, international conservation groups became increasingly concerned, and sent their own investigators to gather first-hand reports. 
 Conservationist Dexter Cate of Hawaii was jailed for 100 days in 1980 when he released several hundred dolphins from the bay into which they had been driven before slaughter. 
 The subsequent outrage from conservationists worldwide spread the gruesome story of Iki Island around the globe and the drives were curtailed after the international condemnation that followed the widespread publicity of the incident. 
 THE CRAB BAIT SCANDAL IN CHILE 
 Chilean fishermen are killing thousands of some of the world's rarest dolphins so that they can chop them up for bait to catch the southern king crab. 
 The local crab industry is lucrative and expanding, as are the dolphin kills, and an estimated several thousand are being harpooned or shot each year. 
 The southern king crab seems to prefer dolphin meat to other kinds of flesh also used for bait, such as sea lion, penguin, fur seals and cormorant. 
 The fishery operates in a remote area at the tip of South America, where the southern king crab frequents the cold waters of Tierra del Fuego. 
 Commercial crabbing began in 1928, but catches increased from 355 tonnes in 1968 to 2680 tonnes in 1984. 
 This huge expansion was the result of increased fishing technology, better boats, and the free market policy adopted by the Pinochet government in Chile in the 1970s to try to tackle its crippling debts. 
 The industry is geared towards maximum use of the resource, short term profits, and foreign dollars, and  overseas restaurants were keen to provide markets after the collapse of the Alaskan king crab fishery. 
 Almost all Chilean crab is exported, mainly to the US, West Germany, France, Belgium, Holland, Italy, and Japan. 
 Despite the large profits made by the industry, only four of the 26 companies involved will provide bait to the fishermen, and even when they do the amount supplied is grossly inadequate. 
 So the crab fishermen go out and massacre dolphins. 
 Not only are they free, but one dead dolphin can bait over 350 traps. 
 Although the remoteness of the region makes accurate information hard to come by, in 1979, even before the main expansion of the industry, an estimated 4100 dolphins and porpoises were being killed each year for bait. 
 During the late 1970s, Commerson's dolphin was the most heavily hunted, but recently this species has become less abundant and the crab fishermen are now catching Peale's dolphin, dusky dolphin, Chilean black dolphin, and Burmeister's porpoise. 
 A study by US scientist Stephen Leatherwood in 1984 suggested that between 2600 and 3000 black dolphins had been taken for crab bait in only two years. 
 Dusky dolphins and Burmeister's porpoise are considerably more abundant and wide-ranging than the other three species. 
 Chilean national laws do protect dolphins, but weak and ineffective enforcement means that no effort is made to regulate the dolphin kills associated with the crab industry. 
 Despite the fact that crab stocks are declining through overfishing, the government buckled to pressure from the fishing industry and actually eliminated a closed season on crabbing in 1983. 
 Recommendations to the contrary made by the Chilean state agency Instituto de Fomento Pesquero (similar to the US NMFS) were ignored. 
 To use rare and endangered dolphins for crab bait must be one of the most depressing examples anywhere in the world of commerce brutally overriding humanity. 
 In just a few years, Chilean fishermen have inflicted damage on dolphin stocks which will take decades, if not centuries, to repair. 
 If the situation continues unchallenged, not only will local populations of rare dolphins be wiped out, but the threat of extinction looms not far behind. 
 Like so many of the problems threatening dolphins all over the world, the Chilean crab bait scandal is easily addressed. 
 Fishing companies simply need to provide fish bait for their fishermen. 
 Other countries could boycott the import of Chilean crab. 
 Like the tuna fishery in the Pacific, dolphins are dying to increase the profits of the fishing companies. 
 DOLPHINS TORTURED IN TAIWAN 
 In the Taiwan Strait, between Taiwan and mainland China, lies an archipelago of 64 small islands, the largest called Penghu. 
 For over two centuries, local fisherman have driven dolphins ashore to be butchered and eaten. 
 In a typical drive in March 1990, Penghu fishermen rounded up a mixed herd of 50 to 60 bottlenose dolphins and false killer whales ( Pseudorca ), and drove them through the narrow channel into Shakang Harbour. 
 A few animals were sold to a Taiwanese Sea World, but several of the whales were cruelly slaughtered and killed. 
 Beer bottles, stones, and steel rods were used to block blowholes and prise open wounds, and lances were driven into their eyes. 
 One 3OOkg false killer whale, after hours of being teased and tortured, had its throat cut and bled to death on the dock. 
 The remainder of the animals were confined by a net within a section of the dirty harbour, while the fishermen debated what to do with them. 
 Taiwanese residents who were members of the Hawaiian-based group Earthtrust contacted the Honolulu headquarters, and within a  few days, an international team, led by Michael Bailey, arrived at Penghu to negotiate for the release of the remaining animals. 
 They found that the mammals had been separated into three groups. 
 The group remaining in Shakang Harbour were in a sad state, confined in a small space in a filthy harbour, with fishing boats leaking diesel and oil onto the surface of the water and continual dumping of rubbish, particularly plastics, from the shore. 
 Another group of dolphins was kept in cleaner surroundings in a large concrete pool at the &bquo;Hawaiian Paradise&equo; resort in Chikan Harbour. 
 By the time the Earthtrust team arrived, two nursing calves had already died of starvation after being separated from their mothers. 
 The third group of dolphins was in transit in Yeliu Harbour, prior to shipping to the oceanarium on mainland Taiwan. 
 Earthtrust removed the dead bodies and organised regular supplies of fish for the surviving dolphins in Shakang Harbour who were starving to death. 
 The next challenge was how to secure their release. 
 In 1989, a resident of Penghu, disgusted at the continuing slaughter of dolphins, had purchased some victims of a drive and released them. 
 This year, he had been offered the same opportunity, but at twice the price. 
 By the time that the Earthtrust team arrived, the price had climbed higher still. 
 Earthtrust discovered that many other locals were opposed to the capture and slaughter of dolphins, and had tried for several years to halt the practice. 
 During the week after their arrival, meetings were held with the State Senator, the Mayor of Penghu County, teachers, businessmen, students, and Buddhist priests. 
 They managed to convince the authorities that the dolphin kills were bad publicity, and that the release of some dolphins would be seen as partial atonement for the brutal killings which had already taken place. 
 The Mayor of the Hu Xi district offered almost US&dollar;20,000 to the fishermen for the purchase of 17 dolphins, hoping to use them as a tourist attraction. 
 Earthtrust agreed to assist in caring for nine of the dolphins, if agreement could be reached to release three dolphins and the five remaining false killer whales. 
 Although the fishermen were not happy about releasing the dolphins, the Mayor insisted, and to the cheers of bystanders, and the chanting of blessings by Buddhist monks, State Senator Chen Goei Miao untied the net and six fishing vessels escorted the cetaceans back to the open sea. 
 However, the mayoral offer of money for the dolphins' release was not forthcoming, and much of the goodwill between fishermen, villagers and conservationists evaporated. 
 Dolphins continued to die steadily in the pen in Shakang Harbour. 
 One committed suicide by repeatedly smashing its rostrum against the concrete wall of the harbour, and then swimming into the net which held it captive. 
 Many of the dead dolphins were found to have died as a result of ingesting garbage &mdash; one had a 1-litre Pepsi bottle in its throat, another a beer can in its stomach. 
 Nevertheless, Michael Bailey believes that this could be the beginning of the end of Asian drive fisheries, and that by working with people, with an understanding of their culture and needs, cooperation can result. 
 The Earthtrust presence at Penghu has focussed national attention on the dolphin drives, and senior officials in the Taiwanese Fisheries Department are now considering the introduction of legislation to provide some form of protection for marine mammals.  
 Main regions of the world where dolphins are still being deliberately killed 
 Many Japanese families today are sitting down to enjoy a meal of dolphin, perhaps eating it raw, or salted and pickled in miso, or dried with seasonings and made into sausage. 
 Other families may be feeding dolphin meat to their dogs. 
 It's a taste that seems to be catching on in Japan, replacing a traditional fancy for whale meat, which is now priced well out of the range of most Japanese pockets. 
 As the demand grows, so does the dolphin kill. 
 Japanese dolphin hunts are centred on the Izu and Kii Peninsulas in southern Honshu, and the harpoon fishery is centred in the Iwate Prefecture in the northeast. 
 The main target is striped dolphins, whose migration paths (arrowed) take them past the southern and eastern coastlines of Japan every year. 
 When Peru was actively whaling in the 1970s and early 1980s, catching Bryde's whales mainly for the Japanese market, unsuccessful attempts had been made to introduce whale meat to the Peruvian population. 
 Fresh dolphin meat, however, has not met the same opposition, because it has been marketed under the name of chancho marino , or &bquo;sea pig&equo;. 
 Furthermore, the public is told that ail similarities to dolphins are purely coincidental. 
 According to Koen Van Waerebeek, who has spent many years studying the dolphin hunt, hardly anyone in Peru is aware of the true nature of chancho marino . 
 A small proportion of dolphin meat is salted, dried, and sold as long strips known as muchame , which was originally introduced by Italian immigrants. 
 &bquo;With repeated strokes they hack into the blubber and flesh of the thrashing animals with 15cm knives, attempting to cut through the carotid arteries alongside the spine. 
 However finding the artery is very difficult, and often the whales break their own spines by their thrashing. 
 &bquo;Other members of the herd are swimming around in the blood-red sea as this killing continues. 
 It can take several hours to kill an entire whale group which may number several hundred individuals.&equo; 
 Report of the Faroe Islands pilot whale kills, taken from minutes of the European Parliament, 1989  
 One of the most inhumane aspects of the grynd is the use of a stout metal hook which is driven into the whale's neck, often from a boat. 
 A rope attached to this gaff enables a number of men to drag the whale into shallow water and hold the thrashing animal while others kill it with knives. 
 Pilot whales are endearing creatures, as anyone who has been involved in their rescue will testify. 
 A middle-sized species of whale, they grow to an average of 7 metres (23 feet) long, and weigh up to 2 tonnes. 
 They are highly social, congregating in groups as large as 500, and the bonding between members of the herd is so strong that if a pilot or lead whale beaches itself, the rest of the herd will often follow, creating a mass stranding. 
 &bquo;We have hunted the dolphins for many years. 
 My father hunted them before me and his father before him. 
 Our family has caught dolphins since 1919 and we want to preserve the tradition. 
 We have to kill the dolphins because they eat our fish. 
 But there are fewer dolphins each year and they are more difficult to find.&equo; 
 Turkish fisherman  
 &bquo;&hellip; the weak autumn sunlight spreads across the still waters off the Turkish coast&hellip;. 
 The dolphins, engrossed in feeding on an anchovy school, fall to detect the vessels as they make their stealthy approach. 
 &bquo;The first shots shatter the morning stillness and three dolphins are struck. 
 The male half jumps from the water, blood pouring from its mouth, before it sinks below the surface. 
 One female is struck in the back, but still attempts to swim away, accompanied by her young calf. 
 A second female is shot behind the eye and swims erratically in half-circles before floating motionless on the surface. 
 The first female is then shot a second time, and as the confused baby attempts to suckle from its dying mother, it too is despatched with a single bullet.&equo; 
 Allan Thornton, Canadian conservationist  
 &bquo;Dolphins with bellies slit open thrashed about whistling in distress as their entrails flopped on the concrete. 
 They didn't lose consciousness even as blood gushed from their throats. 
 As we stood there, horrified witnesses, a fishermen deftly severed the heart from a still quivering dolphin, tossing it aside. 
 It landed less than a yard from my feet, still beating.&equo; 
 Dexter Cate, Hawaiian environmentalist, arrested for releasing 250 netted dolphins at Iki, 6&ndash;8 November 1980 . 
 Iki fishermen have pursued various quarries over the years. 
 In the 1800s most fishermen were after whales, until their coastal net fishery wiped out local populations. 
 During the early part of this century, the major fishery was for sardines, but local stocks suffered and the industry collapsed in the 1940s. 
 Squid and yellowtail then became the main species fished, but throughout the 1960s and 1970s the pattern was repeated as the yellowtail fishery began to show the familiar signs of overfishing, with catches decreasing despite increasing fishing efforts. 
 Three dolphin species in particular - Commerson's dolphin, the Chilean black dolphin and Peale's dolphin - are endangered by the Chilean king crab fishery. 
 These species are found only in the Southern Hemisphere, have a very restricted range, and occur only in small numbers. 
 Commerson's dolphin is found in Chilean waters and at the sub-Antarctic Kergueien Island in the Indian Ocean; Peale's dolphin is restricted to coastal waters around the southern tip of South America and around the Falkland Islands; and the Chilean black dolphin is found only in Chilean waters. 
 The original and present populations of all three species have never been assessed reliably, but because of their restricted distribution and the uncertainty of their numbers, the extent of their killing by crab fishermen is cause for grave concern. 
 The Chilean educational organisation Committee for the Defense of the Flora and Fauna of Chile (CODEFF) is heading efforts to stop the dolphin hunts. 
 It believes that the government wants a short-term profitable fishery regardless of the consequences for the crab fishery or the dolphins. 
 The dolphin hunts are a violation of Chilean law, several international conventions, and customary international law. 
 But because of the economies of the crab fishery and the dim awareness of conservation within the Chilean government, the Committee believes that the hunting can be stopped only by pressure from governments that buy the crab. 
 SLAUGHTER IN THE TUNA INDUSTRY 
 When US marine biologist and environmentalist Sam LaBudde worked undercover as a cook aboard a Panamanian tuna boat in 1988, he witnessed the full horror of the dolphin slaughter that frequently accompanies modern tuna fishing operations in the eastern Pacific Ocean. 
 LaBudde documented for the first time, on video and in his diaries, the suffering and death of thousands of dolphins in a tuna fishing practice known as &bquo;fishing on porpoise'&equo;, which has over the last 30 years killed between 6 and 12 million dolphins in the eastern Pacific. 
 This senseless slaughter takes place merely to try to catch a few extra tuna, and in fact the tuna caught through this method amounts to only about 5 per cent of the world's total catch. 
 Tuna can be successfully caught without killing any dolphins. 
 Fishing on porpoise is unique to the Eastern Tropical Pacific (ETP), a stretch of ocean extending from southern California to Chile and including about 11 million square kilometres (6 million square miles) of sea. 
 In this area, schools of large yellowfin tuna often swim underneath groups of oceanic dolphins. 
 The reason they swim together is not fully understood, but the tuna are believed to stay close to the dolphins to take advantage of their superior food-finding talents. 
 Fishermen have long known of the association, and have traditionally used the presence of dolphins as a cue to finding schools of tuna. 
 In the days when tuna were caught by the pole and line method, the dolphins were rarely involved or injured, but when the US introduced the purse seine fishing technique in the late 1950s, the slaughter of dolphins began on an unprecedented scale. 
 In purse-seine fishing, dolphin schools are often spotted from the air by the vessel's helicopter. 
 They are then chased by both the helicopter and small high-speed boats which are also carried on board the seiner. 
 The assumption is always made that a school of tuna is swimming underneath the dolphins. 
 Tuna bombs, equivalent to small stun grenades, are frequently thrown from the air or boats, to further disorientate and scare the dolphins. 
 When the dolphin school eventually stops, too confused or exhausted to swim any further, the  purse seiner steams up and sets its net around both dolphins and tuna, and then pulls the bottom closed, just like a drawstring purse. 
 Many dolphins drown as the net is pulled and tightened towards the side of the seiner, and they become trapped in the closing mesh. 
 Those that do escape, or are released by compassionate fishing captains and crew, are often caught again, and the same dolphins may often be chased to exhaustion and encircled with tuna nets many times each fishing season. 
 Pregnant dolphins and mother/calf pairs are understandably the most severely affected by this ordeal. 
 The purse-seine tuna fleet in the Eastern Tropical Pacific is dominated by vessels registered in Mexico, the USA, Venezuela and Panama. 
 In 1972 the US had by far the biggest fleet, with 98 of the largest class of tuna seiners, and was responsible for almost 90 per cent of the dolphin kill. 
 Today US-registered vessels make up only one-third of the fleet, and account for less than 16 per cent of the total number of dolphin deaths. 
 Mexico now has the largest purse-seine fleet, followed by the US and Venezuela. 
 Pressure by environmentalists in the US has meant that that country has exerted some control over the industry by insisting that observers are placed on board US-registered boats. 
 However, the powerful US tuna industry lobby has made sure that it has been given an annual &bquo;dolphin kill'&equo; quota. 
 This bizarre concept makes a mockery of any claim that the dolphin slaughter by the tuna industry is incidental, but at least the quota provides a limited measure of control. 
 The situation with non-US tuna vessels is far worse, as most of them are operating free of any regulations whatsoever. 
 True records of the dolphin kills by this sector of the industry can therefore only be estimated, and are likely to be very conservative. 
 Official figures do not usually include animals that escape or are released from the nets but have nevertheless been mortally wounded. 
 Until very recently, observers were rarely on board to verify officially reported figures, and even if they were, attempts were often made to stop them witnessing the dolphin catch. 
 Nor do the figures take into account the effect of the repeated chase and capture of dolphins during a fishing season. 
 Dolphin kills were suspected from the time the practice of fishing on dolphins began in 1959, but a secretive tuna industry for many years resisted all attempts to have observers placed on their boats, no doubt fearful of the outrage that would result if the truth were made public. 
 Until 1971, dolphin mortality could be estimated only from analyses of vessels' logbooks &mdash; and the figures are probably underestimates. 
 In the worst year, 1961, more than half a million dolphins were killed. 
 This figure gradually declined to a low of about 25,000 in 1979 but has since climbed again, to around 125,000 in 1986. 
 Dolphins captured in nets can be freed if skippers and crew are sufficiently compassionate or are legally obliged to do so. 
 One skipper who sought to reduce the carnage discovered that trapped dolphins could be released from nets by the use of a manoeuvre which came to be known as &bquo;backdown.&equo; 
 The purse seine nets are made of large mesh in which it is easy for a dolphin to get its flipper or snout caught. 
 However if a panel of fine mesh (called a Medina panel after the skipper who invented it) is incorporated into the back of the net, this can help save many dolphins. 
 When the net has been pursed and brought to the side of the boat, the seiner can release the tension on the headrope of the net by the backdown procedure, which enables the back of the net with the finer mesh to sink and makes it easier for dolphins to escape, while the tuna continue to swim around in the net below. 
 The US tuna industry was compelled by law to modify its nets and use the backdown procedure, which has significantly decreased the number of dolphins killed.  
 In many tuna sets most encircled dolphins are successfully released, but sometimes adverse weather conditions or equipment malfunctions can hamper the efforts of even the best-intentioned and most experienced crews. 
 The resulting &bquo;disaster sets'&equo;, when attempts to rescue the dolphins fail, can kill huge numbers. 
 In 1986, 16 disaster sets accounted for 43 per cent of observed dolphin mortality by the US fleet and a single set that season killed 736 dolphins. 
 In a &bquo;sundown set'&equo; dolphins are encircled late in the day, so that all or part of the backdown procedure is carried out during darkness. 
 These dusk sets make it much harder for observers to see what is happening, and also make a successful backdown less likely. 
 The kill rate is four times as high in the dark as during daylight. 
 Not all vessels bother to try to release the trapped dolphins from the tuna nets, especially if there is no observer on board. 
 Non-US vessels frequently make no attempt to save dolphins through the use of backdown. 
 Such slaughter of millions of dolphins is euphemistically classified as an example of &bquo;incidental catch&equo;. 
 This misleading term tends to conceal the fact that dolphins are intentionally located, chased, harassed and encircled with a fishing net, from which attempts may not be made to release them. 
 Public outrage over the deaths of millions of dolphins in the 1960s prompted the introduction of a Marine Mammals Protection Act (MMPA) by the US in 1972, which was intended primarily to address the problem of dolphin kills in the tuna fishery. 
 Although the intention was that the allowable dolphin kill be gradually reduced each year to zero, since the introduction of the Act 800,000 dolphins have been killed by US purse seiners alone. 
 Despite the vehement opposition to the passage of the Act by the tuna industry, steady progress was being made for a while by the US tuna fleet to reduce dolphin kills, until the election of ex-Californian governor Ronald Reagan as US President. 
 Reagan was quick to succumb to pressure from the San Diego based tuna industry, and the MMPA regulations were relaxed. 
 In 1981, an amendment by the US Congress permitted an annual US kill of 20,500 dolphins in tuna nets, completely overturning the original intention of the Act. 
 Once the new dolphin kill quota is reached, US seiners must stop carrying out sets on dolphins until the end of the year. 
 However, there are always loopholes. 
 For example injured and dying animals are not included in the limit the US tuna boats are officially allowed to kill each year. 
 And observers on US-registered tuna boats claim that they are often pressured to falsify information about how many dolphins are &bquo;accidentally'&equo; killed during fishing operations. 
 The prime reason for encircling dolphins to catch yellowfin tuna is that the tuna which associate with dolphins tend to be larger, and command a higher market price. 
 US fishermen in search of higher profit margins have increased the percentage of sets on dolphins every year since 1981. 
 At this time the annual kill per US boat was less than 200, but by 1986, 94 per cent of all US sets were being &bquo;made on dolphins'&equo; and the kill figure had increased to more than 600. 
 Meanwhile, many of the largest US purse-seiners had been re-flagged or sold to foreign investors. 
 Thus fewer US vessels were responsible for killing an increasing number of dolphins between 1983 and 1986, while boats sold abroad were not affected by the imposition of dolphin kill quotas. 
 The Marine Mammals Protection Act does at least go some way in limiting the dolphin kills, but since its introduction the tuna fishing fleet has become dominated by non-US vessels. 
 Non-US vessels are not bound by the MMPA, they are not required to carry any dolphin-saving equipment, and they rarely carry observers. 
 Before 1986, Mexico, now the country with the largest purse-seine fleet, had not allowed any observers aboard its vessels. 
 When, it finally did,  reports showed that the Mexican tuna fleet had killed roughly 100,000 dolphins during that year &mdash; a rate four times greater than for US boats. 
 The 1986 data destroyed the myth that the foreign kill rate was comparable to the US rate, and confirmed that the widely accepted official figure of 6 million dolphins killed by purse seiners over the past 30 years was a gross underestimate. 
 The true number probably lies somewhere between 8 and 12 million animals. 
 There is little effective international regulation of the tuna fishery in the ETP zone. 
 The Inter-American Tropical Tuna Commission (IATTC) is the international agency responsible for carrying out research into the biology of tuna and recommending conservation measures to maintain fish stocks at &bquo;levels which will afford the maximum sustained catches.&equo; 
 Nine countries originally entered the convention under which the IATTC functions, although only five (US, Panama, France, Japan, and Mexico) remained in 1986. 
 Of the 16 countries presently fishing for tuna in the Eastern Pacific, only Panama and the US are currently members of the IATTC. 
 From 1967 to 1979, tuna catch quotas set by the Commission were approved by the IATTC countries. 
 Since 1980, however, the member countries have failed to agree on the quotas recommended by the IATTC. 
 In the absence of biologically sustainable quotas, yellowfin has been overfished. 
 Stocks are now believed to be below the level which would allow the predicted maximum yield of 175,000 tonnes per year. 
 In a declining fishery, extra pressure is thus placed on fishermen to catch the larger and higher value yellowfin which associate with dolphins. 
 Although the IATTC provides observers on purse-seiners, the programme is voluntary, and the tuna industry agreed to it only on the condition that observers are not allowed to report any violations. 
 Furthermore, IATTC data are made available only to the US NMFS in an edited, summary form. 
 The IATTC observer programme is thus a fairly pointless exercise, since the true data are not obtainable and violations are hushed up, proving the power of the tuna industry to silence the truth. 
 No regulations relating to night sets apply to the non-US fleet. 
 An NMFS regulation brought into force in January 1981 to disallow night sets by US boats was dropped after only 8 days because of pressure from the tuna industry. 
 No further controls on the use of night sets were introduced until mid 1986, when US vessels were required to use effective lighting for dusk sets. 
 This resulted in some success in lowering dolphin mortality, but it is still at least twice as high as during daylight hours. 
 Before 1982, less than half the tuna sets carried out by the US fleet were made on dolphins. 
 When 4 years later the US fleet was ordered to stop making sets on dolphins once they had exceeded the annual kill quota, catch rates of tuna were not in fact noticeably affected. 
 Yellowfin became elusive after the El Nino  current change affected the availability of food supplies over the last two decades. 
 This forced the purse-seine fleet to fish outside the eastern Pacific and they successfully caught tuna without encircling dolphins. 
 Some of the same US-registered super seiners operating in the southwest Pacific to catch skipjack tuna were the cause of considerable friction between the US Government and the Solomon Islands and Vanuatu in the South Pacific. 
 These nations were incensed at the arrogant attitudes of unlicensed purse-seiners which plundered the tuna stocks within their 200-mile zones. 
 Corporate concern in the US tuna industry has been far more interested in maintaining profits than in saving dolphins, and they have gone to great lengths to protect their commercial interests. 
 In 1980 alone, the American Tunaboat Association (ATA) spent over one million dollars to attack US fisheries scientists' assessments of dolphin  mortality. 
 They have brought numerous legal challenges to thwart the original intentions of the MMPA. 
 In 1981, the fishing industry lobbied for changes in the Act, asserting that the goal of zero mortality would be satisfied by the &bquo;application of safety techniques and equipment that are economically and technologically feasible.&equo; 
 This substantially overturned the original interpretation of the Act and placed the &bquo;rights&equo; of fishermen to kill dolphins above the rights of marine mammals not to be harassed and destroyed. 
 The same year the ATA moved to keep US observers from being allowed to report violations. 
 They obtained an injunction which prevented compulsory observation from June 1981 to January 1984, when it was finally overturned by the Court of Appeal. 
 Full observer coverage of the US tuna fleet was not achieved until 1989. 
 The NMFS, the US government agency charged with administering the MMPA, has often been accused by environmentalists of being in the pocket of the tuna industry. 
 In 1984, during re-authorisation hearings on the Act, the US Congress directed the NMFS to develop regulations that would require an automatic embargo of tuna from any country which did not comply with the US dolphin-kill quota and requirements for dolphin rescue. 
 It was a full 4 years before the regulations were released. 
 Environmentalists unsuccessfully lobbied the US Congress in 1988 to ban the technique of encircling dolphins, but did succeed in forcing a significant law change. 
 An amendment to the MMPA in November 1988 created the requirement that: &bquo;During the 1989 and subsequent fishing seasons, each certificated vessel shall carry on every fishing trip an official observer.&equo; 
 NMFS caved in to pressure from the tuna industry, and claimed that it was possible to place observers aboard only 50 per cent of tuna seiners for the season beginning 1 January 1989. 
 During a lawsuit brought by environmental groups against NMFS to compel observer coverage of the total US tuna fleet, the legal counsel for Earth Island Institute and the Marine Mammal Fund stated: &bquo;The National Marine Fisheries Service has a long history of ignoring the will of Congress and working closely with the fishing industry. 
 Once again the agency appears to be interpreting the Marine Mammal Protection Act to be the Commercial Tuna Fleet Protection Act.&equo; 
 On 17 January 1989, US District Court Judge Thelton Henderson issued an injunction against NMFS ordering the entire US tuna fleet to carry observers, and ordering all US tuna boats operating in the ETP without observers to &bquo;immediately return to port or otherwise immediately act to carry on board an official certified observer.&equo; 
 The judge's ruling will undoubtedly have a substantial impact on the foreign tuna fleet, numbering more than 100 boats, because they are now required to have dolphin-protection regulations comparable to those of the US if they want to export tuna to the US. 
 Full observer coverage will undoubtedly save the lives of thousands of dolphins caught by US vessels, but a change in corporate marketing strategies and consumer preference will be the most effective way of saving the dolphins of the ETP. 
 The purchase and sale of yellowfin tuna in the US is controlled by two large corporations, H.J.Heinz and Ralston-Purina, which own many of the vessels and canneries, and import most of the tuna caught by Mexican boats. 
 Each of them has the power to decide immediately to stop purchasing tuna caught by fishing on dolphins. 
 Skipjack is the most abundant species of tuna in the area, and, like albacore, can be caught without killing dolphins. 
 Fishermen fish yellowfin rather than skipjack or albacore tuna because it commands a higher price &mdash; its flesh is white, while skipjack and albacore are a darker, red colour. 
 Nutritionally all three species of tuna are equivalent and they taste similar. 
 Yellowfin tuna in fact comprises only a small part of the huge US tuna  market. 
 In 1985, consumption of tuna in the US was 1.5 kg (3.3 lb) per person, of which white meat tuna (yellowfin) made up 0.3 kg (0.7 lb). 
 A consumer boycott organised by environmental groups in the late 1970s slightly reduced demand, but the economic effects were insufficient to force a change in fishing practices. 
 However, since Sam LaBudde's video detailing the horrors of fishing on dolphins was televised worldwide, new consumer boycott initiatives have been launched. 
 The consumer effort has now received Congressional support, in the form of legislation introduced by Representative Barbara Boxer, a Democrat from San Francisco. 
 The Dolphin Protection Consumer Information Act, which would require canned tuna to be labelled as to whether it is &bquo;dolphin-safe'&equo;, received 126 co-sponsors in the House of Representatives, and is to be debated early in 1990. 
 Under the present provisions of the Bill, tuna products resulting from encircling dolphins would be labelled with, &bquo;The tuna in this product has been captured with technologies that are known to kill dolphins.&equo; 
 Conservationists maintain that as much as 80 per cent of the tuna on sale in the US would qualify for the &bquo;dolphin-safe&equo; label, but August Felando, president of the American Tunaboat Association, disagrees: &bquo;It will destroy us,&equo; said Felando in a newspaper interview in November 1989. 
 &bquo;This labelling does not serve a public purpose in terms of nutrition or food safety. 
 This would be an unreasonable interference by Congress in the free marketplace. 
 This is a conspiracy to bring about boycotts and harm the industry.&equo; 
 But as only a small percentage of the US tuna fleet captures dolphins, Boxer argues that her Bill will actually give US tuna processors a competitive advantage in the US market, because foreign fleets are more likely to use methods harmful to dolphins. 
 The European Parliament has also been lobbied to ban the import of all yellowfin tuna, and consumer boycotts are already underway in several European countries. 
 As this book goes to print, it seems that consumer pressure has finally won the day and forced a re-evaluation of corporate policy by the major US tuna canners. 
 In April 1990 Starkist Seafood, the world's largest tuna canner with 35 per cent of the huge US market, announced that they would no longer buy tuna which had been caught by encircling dolphins. 
 The new policy applies not only to purse-seining in the Eastern Tropical Pacific, but also to all tuna caught anywhere with gill-nets, whether drift-nets or set-nets. 
 Starkist President Keith Hauge said that the company would require its suppliers to have observers on their vessels to ensure that drift-nets were not used, and would offer financial assistance to skippers wishing to refit their boats or move their operations to waters where tuna do not swim with dolphins. 
 Under the new policy, Starkist expects tuna prices to rise from 2 cents to 10 cents per can, but hopes that increased costs would be compensated for by increased sales, as environmentally-conscious consumers opt for dolphin-safe tuna. 
 Within hours of Starkist's press conference, their major US competitors, Van Camp and Bumblebee, also announced the introduction of similar policies, and an end to the long and bitter battle between US environmentalists and the tuna industry was at last in sight. 
 According to Anthony O'Reilly, chairman of the multinational H. J. Heinz, which owns Starkist, the internal corporate debate about whether to adopt a dolphin-safe policy was &bquo;epic, almost theological in tone.&equo; 
 One can only ponder at the ethics of an industry which for thirty years slaughtered dolphins in their millions for the sake of saving 2 cents per can, and then requires an &bquo;epic&equo; debate to change its source of supply.  
 Areas where dolphins are killed by purse-seine fishing for tuna. 
 Modern purse-seine boats, the so-called superseiners, fishing for tuna have huge nylon nets over 1.5 k (1 mile) long and 100 metres (325 feet) deep, manipulated by giant power machinery. 
 They are highly sophisticated, crammed with electronics, and often carry their own helicopter. 
 These custom-built vessels have been designed to catch only tuna &mdash; in huge quantities. 
 The biggest are more than 1000 gross tonnes and can carry more than 1200 tonnes of tuna. 
 Unlike the traditional methods of catching tuna by line or by lure, superseiners are able to scoop up entire schools, without a single fish escaping. 
 An American super-seiner with the huge net stacked on its stern, dory alongside and speedboats on the foredeck. 
 &bquo;Crew members are tearing dolphins out of the net and dumping them on the deck with little or no attention to whether they are alive or dead. 
 Many of them just lie there helplessly until somebody manhandles them over the side of the boat. 
 Finally the net is close-hauled and the skiff returns to the port side where the remaining floats in the water are draped over its side, forming a sort of bag between the two boats. 
 It is packed with drowned dolphins. 
 The crew members enter the water to push the dead bodies out of the net. 
 Standing on the corpses they laugh and joke, holding the bodies of the babies over their heads like trophies, pitching them back and forth like footballs.&equo; 
 Sam LaBudde, US environmentalist, 1 January, 1988  
 The main dolphin species that swim in association with tuna are spotted, spinner and common dolphins. 
 By 1979, US fisheries scientists were able to estimate some dolphin numbers in the ETP. 
 Eastern spinner dolphins had been reduced to about 20 per cent of their original numbers, and the Costa Rican spinner dolphin (a subspecies) numbered only 9000. 
 This supposedly protected subspecies continues to die in the tuna nets &mdash; Sam LaBudde witnessed 200 drown in a single net. 
 Northern offshore spotted dolphins were around 40&ndash;50 per cent of their original numbers, and common dolphins about 60 per cent. 
 Since 1979, the spotted dolphin has suffered the highest mortality, more females being killed than males. 
 Of the females, 82.5 per cent have been found to be pregnant or lactating. 
 The effects of the tuna fishery on other species in the ETP, such as the striped and bottlenose dolphin, have also been severe. 
 The US Marine Mammals Protection Act of 1972 stated that: &bquo;&hellip; it shall be the immediate goal that the incidental kill or serious injury of marine mammals permitted in the course of commercial fishing operations be reduced to insignificant levels approaching zero morality.' 
 Although the incidental catch of dolphins in the purse-seine yellowfin tuna fishery in the ETP has indeed been greatly reduced since the 1960s, so also have the numbers of dolphins. 
 Assessments of the permissible level of incidental catch should be based on the desirability of returning dolphin stocks to original levels, not holding them at a depleted level through a continuation of a high level of incidental kill. 
 &bquo;The fishermen resented the presence of a government observer and engaged in every possible form of harassment and coercion to ensure that I did not report the actual number of dolphins killed.&equo; 
 Affidavit filed June 1988 by Kenneth Marten, US fishing observer and research biologist  
 The most tragic and outrageous aspect of the tuna/dolphin story in the ETP is that the practice of encircling dolphins to catch tuna is entirely unnecessary. 
 Yellowfin tuna taken inside the ETP make up about 8 per cent of the world's tuna catch. 
 Even within the zone, good catches of yellowfin can be made without encircling dolphins. 
 In the US, a coalition of animal welfare groups is urging US consumers to stop buying tuna caught on dolphin. 
 One approach developed by the environmental group Earthtrust has been the introduction of the voluntary &bquo;Flipper Seal of Approval&equo;, a sticker attached to cans of tuna signifying that the contents of the can have been caught without harming dolphins. 
 About 830,000 tonnes of tuna is sold annually in the US, and canners have often failed to disclose on their labels where the tuna was caught, let alone under what conditions. 
 DRIFT-NETS &mdash; STRIPMINING THE OCEANS 
 Each night during a 6-month working season, 40,000&ndash;60,000 km (about 30,000&ndash;45,000 miles) of drift-net is set in the North Pacific Ocean - enough to encircle the planet and cross the Pacific for a second time. 
 These &bquo;walls of death'&equo; may be 15 metres (50 feet) deep, and they catch everything that swims into them. 
 Oceanic drift-nets are literally wiping out life over huge tracts of the world's oceans. 
 Dolphins, large and small whales, sea birds and turtles, as well as the fish and squid swimming in the upper surface of the ocean at night, are each year dying in their tens or hundreds of thousands, victims of these enormous and near invisible webs of death. 
 Their widespread use could soon bring about the collapse of entire stocks of oceanic fish and cause lasting damage to marine ecosystems covering vast areas. 
 Since their widespread introduction in the 1960s, drift-nets have already laid waste enormous areas of open ocean, especially in the North Atlantic and North Pacific. 
 Drift-netting is becoming recognised as the most indiscriminate method of fishing ever devised. 
 As most drift-netting operations are carried out in international waters where little or no international agreements are in force, it is extremely difficult to control this destruction of life on the high seas, or even to get an accurate picture of its magnitude. 
 Japan, Taiwan and South Korea are the three countries most responsible for drift-netting, and are operating mainly in the North Pacific. 
 Other nations that use drift-nets include the US, Italy, and Spain, while Denmark in the 1970s had a large drift-net fishery for salmon in the North Atlantic. 
 Drift-nets were first developed by the Japanese, and have been used since 1905. 
 Early drift-nets were made from natural fibres such as cotton and hemp, and were not large. 
 But the large-scale manufacture of plastics after World War 11 encouraged FAO to sponsor the development of cheap, large, plastic nets, which were originally intended to help provide additional sources of protein for developing countries. 
 Instead they have become the favourite fishing method of several highly industrialised fishing nations, and the use of oceanic drift-nets has grown rapidly. 
 The ready availability of cheap, plastic, monofilament (single stranded) net has revolutionised the distant water fishing fleets of Taiwan, South Korea and Japan. 
 Old longline and squid jigging vessels are re-equipped with inexpensive nets instead of being retired, and are sent out to return a few more seasons' profits. 
 Japanese drift-nets in the 1970s were about 15 km (10 miles) in length, but now they may be four times that length. 
 The nets are released at dusk, and drift with the ocean's currents and winds, fishing the rich top 15 metres (50 feet) of the sea, to be retrieved the next day. 
 The lack of international controls in the North Pacific Ocean, and the proliferation of the salmon, tuna, billfish, and squid drift-net fleets over the past two decades, has resulted in the development of a North Pacific fishery so huge that during the 6-month season, the 1000 or so vessels involved deploy 35 million km (1.9&ndash;3.4 million miles) of netting. 
 Japanese authorities have turned a blind eye to the rapid expansion of their drift-net fleet. 
 In 1973, the Japanese Ministry of Agriculture and Fisheries, recognising the possible adverse effect of drift-nets on fish stocks, issued an ordinance which limited the length of all Japanese  drift-nets to 12 km (8.5 miles). 
 At that time, their drift-netters were operating mostly within the Japanese 200-mile Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), and the development of larger vessels and the expansion of fishing grounds to include the high seas had not been expected. 
 In theory, all Japanese drift-netters are still restricted to 12-km nets, with a mesh size of 150 mm (6 inches), but in practice this regulation has been completely ignored, and the high seas drift-net fleets operate with nets of up to 50 or 60 km (about 31 or 40 miles), and with a range of mesh sizes, as small as 80 mm (3.2 inches). 
 The only concession made by these vessels to the ordinance is to break up their massive sets into several lengths of 10&ndash;12 km with a gap of 100&ndash;200 metres between each length of net. 
 Drift-net vessels, like the tuna boats fishing on dolphins, have long been stubbornly refusing to take observers on board. 
 For many years no reliable accounts existed of their effect on oceanic life. 
 But according to a report by an observer from the US National Marine Fisheries Service, during a 6-week period in summer 1986, a single Japanese squid vessel working in Alaskan waters killed 53 dolphins and porpoises and 14 fur seals by entanglement in its nets. 
 If this death rate were typical of the entire squid fleet, more than 125,000 marine mammals would die annually in the drift-nets of the North Pacific squid fishery alone. 
 The fast-swimming Dall's porpoise has been particularly hard hit in the North Pacific and hundreds of thousands of animals over the last 20 years have been entangled in the giant drift-nets of the salmon, squid, and tuna fisheries. 
 It is also deliberately hunted for human consumption in Japan. 
 Estimates of annual deaths range up to 40,000 animals a year on the high seas of the North Pacific. 
 The US Government in 1981 imposed a quota on Japanese drift-netters operating in Alaskan waters of 5500 porpoises a year. 
 Over 20 years ago, Japanese scientists were reporting that over 10,000 porpoises were being killed in the North Pacific each year in the drift-nets of the Japanese salmon fishery, and since then the drift-net fleet has grown considerably. 
 The Japanese drift-net fishery for squid alone accounts for between 7000 and 14,000 Dall's porpoise each year, and there are no reliable estimates for the incidental catch by  Taiwanese and Korean drift-netters in the squid, salmon, and tuna/ billfish fisheries. 
 Japanese scientists, however, have been denying that drift-nets have had any significant effect on Dall's porpoise. 
 In 1975, Dr Seiji Ohsumi, senior biologist at the Far Seas Research Laboratory, wrote that &bquo;many porpoises were incidentally caught by the salmon gill-net fisheries annually,&equo; but he saw &bquo;no evidence to show a decline in their population density.&equo; 
 He concluded that the population size of Dall's porpoise was remarkably large (it was estimated as low as 790,000 in 1983), and that &bquo;the effect of incidental catch was negligible.&equo; 
 In this typical example of scientific doublespeak, the burden of proof is, as usual, thrown on to conservationists to show that a fishing technique has an unacceptable effect, rather than on the fishing nations to show that the method is ecologically sound. 
 The coastal population of Dall's porpoise around northern Japan has also been drastically reduced by the huge growth in commercial harpooning, and this once-abundant species is clearly suffering a steep decline. 
 In 1988, the Hawaiian environmental group Earthtrust took a 13-metre (42-foot) sailboat into the North Pacific Ocean to document effects of the drift-net fishery for flying squid. 
 Expedition biologist Sam LaBudde confirmed environmentalists' worst fears: &bquo;The toll was evidenced in the range of creatures we saw drowned in the nets. 
 Dolphin, albatross, a leatherback sea turtle, numerous sharks, entire schools of tuna, sunfish, marlin, swordfish, salmon and flying squid. 
 It is called a squid fishery, but the truth is that anything that moves near these nets is likely to be caught and killed.&equo; 
 LaBudde noted that the quantity of non-target species taken during their time aboard was greater than the quantity of squid harvested. 
 LaBudde filmed entire schools of tuna trapped in the nets: &bquo;... the collective mass of their bodies temporarily pulling entire sections of net far below the surface. 
 Here, in the seemingly endless expanse of clear blue, hundreds of fish hung strangely suspended in the water, the nets that held them all but invisible.&equo; 
 LaBudde also reported that the two drift-net vessel skippers to whom he had spoken in the North Pacific both admitted to periodically cutting loose large sections of net in which whales had become entangled. 
 Whales enmeshed in a drift-net are condemned to a slow death from starvation or suffocation. 
 LaBudde believes that drift-nets are the prime suspects for the disappearance of dozens of young humpback whales in the North Pacific, who have been failing to return to their Hawaiian breeding grounds in recent years. 
 Their migration route to the Alaskan feeding grounds takes them through an area of ocean which is cluttered with drift-nets. 
 Drift-netting is another example of our inability as humans to establish a sustainable relationship with the planet. 
 In the endless quest for short-term profits, fishing companies use drift-nets in the full knowledge that dolphins, seals, turtles, and sea birds will be killed, often much faster than the target fish species. 
 The environmental consequences of this stripmining of the oceans extend far beyond the inevitable depletion of the commercial resource. 
 The collapse of marine mammal and sea-bird populations may have far-reaching consequences as the complex pattern of interrelationships among creatures in the marine ecosystem changes. 
 Some countries at least are recognising the extreme dangers of drift-net fishing. 
 In 1986&ndash;87, the Canadian Department of Fisheries and Oceans carried out trials with squid drift-nets. 
 During the trials with two vessels, 135 dolphins, porpoises, and small whales were killed, as well as over 700 sea birds. 
 The Canadian Minister of Fisheries terminated the trials, and banned further drift-net fishing in Canadian waters.  
 Australia was also forced to take a stand on drift-netting when the establishment of the Australian Fishing Zone in 1979 brought under Australian jurisdiction a Taiwanese drift fleet that had been operating, since the mid 1970s, in what had previously been international waters in the Timor and Arafura Seas off northern Australia. 
 By 1983, it was clear to the Australian authorities that the drift-nets were killing thousands of cetaceans each year. 
 Australian scientists in 1983 estimated that 4700 dolphins had drowned in the giant nets in 22 months. 
 Experiments with modified nets had no significant effect on the rates of entanglement. 
 Between 1981 and 1985, roughly 10,000 dolphins drowned, mainly bottlenose, spinner, and spotted dolphins. 
 The Australian Government came under strong public pressure to take decisive action to protect the dolphin population from further depletion, and did so in 1986. 
 By restricting the maximum length of pelagic gill-nets in the Australian EEZ to 2.5 km (1.6 miles), they effectively excluded the huge Taiwanese nets. 
 Attempts to introduce drift-nets into neighbouring New Zealand waters were more short lived. 
 In 1981 four Taiwanese drift-netters undertook exploratory fishing for squid in Golden Bay at the northern end of New Zealand's South Island. 
 The trials came to an abrupt end when local fisheries officers found the frozen remains of common dolphins and pilot whales on board the fishing boats. 
 Under New Zealand's Marine Mammals Protection Act, the possession of marine mammals without a permit is a serious offence, and the drift-net trials were promptly terminated. 
 Little more was heard of drift-netting in the South Pacific until 1988, when for the first time, Taiwanese and Japanese vessels moved into the South Pacific and Tasman Sea in large numbers. 
 Although a dozen or more Japanese drift-netters had been operating in the Tasman Sea for the previous 5 years, their presence had practically gone unnoticed. 
 Then in November, 1988, the Japanese drift-net vessel Sankichi Maru no. 18  caught fire in mid-Tasman, with the loss of all the crew. 
 When New Zealand Search and Rescue authorities carried out several extensive air searches for survivors, it became apparent that as many as 50 or more Japanese drift-netters were concentrated in a small area of the Tasman Sea, fishing for albacore tuna. 
 The search for survivors from the Sankichi Maru  was still in progress when the Taiwanese vessel Delima 120  also got into difficulties about 1000 km (700 miles) east of Auckland. 
 Her crew were all rescued, but it was discovered that the Delima  was not, in fact, a water-carrier, as had originally been claimed, but a support ship for a massive fleet of between 60 and 130 Taiwanese drift-net vessels, fishing for albacore tuna along an area of oceanic upwelling known as the Subtropical Convergence Zone, stretching across the South Pacific in a narrow 300-km (200-mile) band from south of the Cook Islands to south of French Polynesia. 
 Horrified fisheries officials in the South Pacific suddenly realized the extent of the drift-net fleet newly arrived in their region. 
 Up to 180 boats were setting as much as 8000 km (5000 miles) of net each night during the 4-month season. 
 Although no reports on incidental killings of small cetaceans in the new Tasman/South Pacific drift-net fishery were provided by the Taiwanese, Japanese, or Korean governments, there could be little doubt of the damage being done. 
 In New Zealand, an unlikely coalition of government scientists, harbour boards, fishermen, and environmental groups pressured the government to take firm action to resist the invasion of the drift-netters. 
 Japanese drift-net vessels, frequent visitors to New Zealand ports during the previous year, now found themselves subjected to lengthy searches by fisheries officers hunting for dolphin and whale remains. 
 Efforts to control the drift-net fleets were boosted by the news that on 8  April 1989 the state legislature of Hawaii, in a bold move, had introduced legislation to ban the use and possession of drift-nets within the state's EEZ. 
 New Zealand rapidly followed suit. 
 On 26 May 1989, the then Deputy Prime Minister, Mr Geoffrey Palmer, announced that not only would the use of drift-nets be banned inside the New Zealand EEZ, but also their possession. 
 Drift-netters wishing to move from fishing grounds in the Tasman to those in the South Pacific would not be allowed to pass through New Zealand waters without risking confiscation of their vessels and a substantial fine. 
 In a strongly worded statement signed by six Cabinet Ministers, Palmer described drift-net fishing as &bquo;abhorrent&equo;, and offered the use of New Zealand aircraft and naval vessels to assist neighbouring Pacific states who might wish to take similar action. 
 The New Zealand stand was swiftly followed by Australia, which also banned the possession and use of drift-nets in their 200-mile EEZ. 
 In June 1989, delegations from Japan, Taiwan, and South Korea attended a meeting of the South Pacific Forum Fisheries Agency (FFA), to discuss the effects of the rapid expansion of the use of drift-nets in the region. 
 Of particular concern to most of the members of the FFA was the effect of the drift-netters on the albacore tuna resource, which plays a major role in many Pacific economies. 
 Despite predictions from the FFA that drift-netting would bring about the collapse of albacore stocks within a few years, the Japanese delegation steadfastly refused to make any concessions. 
 Drift-netting, they declared, was here to stay, and there were no scientific grounds to believe that there was any significant incidental catch of marine mammals, turtles, or sea birds in the South Pacific. 
 Since the Japanese and Taiwanese refused to supply any data on the albacore drift-net fishery, it was hardly surprising that no information on incidental dolphin catches had come to light. 
 Towards the end of the 3-day FFA meeting, the Japanese, &bquo;in a spirit of goodwill and co-operation'&equo;, offered to hold the drift-net fleet for 1989&ndash;90 to the same level as the previous season &mdash; 60 vessels. 
 This represented a four-fold increase on the previous maximum fleet size before 1988&ndash;89. 
 Japanese intransigence, however, served only to harden the resolve of the island nations of the South Pacific. 
 At the July 1989 gathering of Heads of State on the island of Tarawa, in Kiribati, the South Pacific Forum placed the use of drift-nets in the South Pacific as its most important agenda item &mdash; the first time that an environmental issue had topped the agenda at a political gathering in the South Pacific. 
 The Tarawa Declaration, published at the conclusion of the Forum meeting, condemned drift-net fishing as &bquo;indiscriminate, irresponsible and destructive&equo;, and &bquo;&bquo;not consistent with international legal requirements in relation to rights and obligations of high seas fisheries conservation and management and environmental principles&equo;. 
 The Declaration further resolved to call together an urgent meeting of regional diplomatic, legal and fisheries experts to develop a Convention to establish a South Pacific zone free of drift-net fishing, and called upon Japan and Taiwan &bquo;to abandon immediately their damaging drift-net operations.&equo; 
 The South Pacific nations agreed to meet in Wellington, New Zealand, in November 1989, to conclude a convention to ban the use of drift-nets in the entire region. 
 Geoffrey Palmer, Prime Minister of New Zealand, promptly announced his intention to call for a global ban on drift-netting during his address to the United Nations General Assembly in New York in October. 
 In a belated attempt at conciliation, the Japanese Government announced in mid September that the drift-net fleet in the Tasman Sea for the 1989&ndash;90 season would be reduced to 20 vessels, in the hope that the South Pacific nations could be diverted from their diplomatic  assault. 
 Palmer responded that the cut in vessel numbers was a positive move, but fell far short of the ban which remained the objective of the Pacific Island nations. 
 Nevertheless, the Japanese fleet arrived in the Tasman as promised, to be met by the new Greenpeace flagship, Rainbow Warrior II . 
 The Greenpeace ship soon located the Japanese drift-net fleet, monitoring and documenting on film the catches in the drift-nets. 
 Dolphins were frequently observed in the nets, and Greenpeace estimated that even the reduced fleet of 20 vessels probably killed some 4600 dolphins during the season. 
 The prompt action by South Pacific countries to deal with the drift-net plague provided a marked contrast to the situation in the North Pacific high seas, where the US had been dragging its heels as the Asian drift-net fleets continued to pillage the salmon, tuna, and squid resources, and kill tens of thousands of marine mammals and hundreds of thousands of sea birds, many of them in Alaskan fisheries waters. 
 A change in US policy was, however, signalled by the passage through the US Congress of the Drift-net Monitoring, Assessment And Control Act in 1987. 
 The Act requires the Secretary of Commerce to report to Congress on numerous aspects of drift-net fishing in the North Pacific, especially as it relates to the marine resources of the US. 
 Because of their incidental catch of thousands of Dall's porpoise each year, Japanese drift-net vessels fishing for salmon off Alaska are subject to the provisions of the US MMPA. 
 The MMPA generally prohibits the killing of marine mammals in US waters, but contains an important exception &mdash; the Secretary of Commerce can authorise the accidental drowning of marine mammals in commercial fishing operations. 
 The Secretary cannot, however, allow the incidental take of any species in danger of significant depletion or extinction. 
 US scientists in the early 1980s, estimated an &bquo;acceptable level of kill'&equo; for the drift-net fishery of 5500 Dall's porpoise each year in Alaskan waters. 
 Japanese salmon drift-netters fishing off Alaska were therefore allowed this figure as an annual quota as incidental catch. 
 When the permit came up for renewal in 1986, Commerce Secretary Malcolm Baldridge issued a general permit for the drift-netting to continue. 
 He had decided that stocks of Dall's porpoise would not be significantly depleted by such a move, but he was unable to make such a claim for northern fur seals and sea-lions. 
 Environmental groups successfully appealed against the issue of the general permit, and in July 1987, won an injunction which cut short the salmon season for the drift-net fleet. 
 Japanese salmon fishing operations in 1988 were totally blocked by the injunction. 
 Finally, after further lengthy legal battles, the Supreme Court issued a landmark decision in January 1989, and refused to allow the government to permit continued use of drift-nets off the Alaskan coast. 
 In 1989 the global nature of the drift-net plague was for the first time widely recognised. 
 In May, South Africa, concerned at the proliferation of the Japanese drift-net fleet around the edges of its 200-mile EEZ, banned the use and possession of drift-nets in its EEZ. 
 In July, a simmering dispute in Europe became public, when the Greenpeace campaign vessel, Sirius , led a flotilla of 40 Spanish longline fishing boats into the port of Cartagena in south-east Spain. 
 Environmentalists and fishermen were protesting at the devastating effects of the Spanish and Italian drift-net fishery for swordfish. 
 Swordfish is a great delicacy in Europe, and has been traditionally caught on longlines, although catch rates have been declining in recent years. 
 The introduction of large-scale drift-nets into the Mediterranean has greatly boosted the catch of swordfish, according to fishermen. 
 Many Mediterranean fishermen have been subsidised into the use of drift-nets  through the European Community, which has been paying them to convert from bottom trawling &mdash; supposedly because of its detrimental effects on the seabed. 
 In 1988, 30&ndash;40 Spanish vessels were operating out of Algeciras and Almeria, and according to some estimates, as many as 800 Italian and French drift-net vessels, with a total net length exceeding 15,000 km (about 10,000 miles), were fishing in the Mediterranean. 
 The burgeoning European drift-net fleet is thought to have killed as many as 4000 dolphins in 1989, and at least 23 sperm whales during the previous three years. 
 The Milan-based Centre for Cetacean Studies, in association with several other wildlife and research groups, has petitioned the Italian Government for an end to the swordfish drift-net fishery, warning that the cetacean populations of the Italian seas would otherwise be at risk of extinction by the year 2000. 
 As the extent of drift-net fishing around southern Europe became more apparent, public outrage grew. 
 In both Spain and Italy, emergency regulations were introduced to impose a temporary moratorium on drift-net use, pending governmental investigations. 
 In August 1989 Greenpeace drew attention to the swordfish fishery in US waters off the New England coast. 
 Swordfish in the Georges Bank fishing grounds in the north west Atlantic Ocean have traditionally been taken by harpoon, but heavy fishing pressure has driven stocks to an all-time low, and some boats have turned to the use of drift-nets. 
 Although the nets are much shorter than those employed in the North Pacific, and have a much larger mesh, they are devastatingly effective at catching dolphins. 
 The mile-long nets hang in the water to a depth of 30 metres (100 feet), forming a much deeper net curtain than the squid and salmon nets of the open ocean. 
 In September 1989, the South Atlantic Fishery Management Council, one of eight US Regional Fishery Management Councils, voted to prohibit the use of drift-nets for swordfish in southern US Atlantic waters. 
 The Council also urged the New England Fishery Management Council to introduce a similar ban, and called on the US delegation to the International Commission for the Conservation of Atlantic Tunas (ICCAT) to support a resolution to prohibit the use of drift-nets for all tuna and other species under the jurisdiction of ICCAT. 
 By October 1989, therefore, the time was right for a concerted diplomatic initiative against drift-net fishing. 
 New Zealand Prime Minister Geoffrey Palmer's speech to the United Nations General Assembly that month called for a global ban, and spelt out the effect that drift-netters were having on the fragile fishing-based economies of the South Pacific. 
 His address sparked an international campaign, aimed mainly at Japan (South Korea has only observer status at the UN, Taiwan is not represented at all). 
 The first hurdle to be overcome was the development of a joint US/New Zealand resolution which would meet not only the concerns of the South Pacific nations which were at the forefront of the initiative, but also would not alienate the US, whose powerful political muscle would be required to gain the necessary support. 
 For some weeks, it seemed that the joint US/NZ resolution on drift-netting would founder in the mire of State Department compromise, as successive US proposals were rejected as too weak by the New Zealanders. 
 Only after pressure from US Secretary of State James Baker, was a draft resolution agreed with New Zealand, which called for: 
 An immediate ban on drift-netting in the South Pacific. 
 The provision of accurate data by fishing nations. 
 A moratorium on the use of high seas drift-nets from mid 1992 onwards, unless they could be shown to have a negligible effect on marine living resources (diplomatic language for marine mammals and sea birds). 
 The resolution, co-sponsored by Australia, New Zealand, and 14 other states, including several Pacific Island nations, was presented to the Second Committee of the United Nations General Assembly in November 1989. 
 Japan, faced with a diplomatic assault on several fronts, responded with a resolution which shifted the onus of proof - drift-netting could be banned if scientific evidence clearly showed that the effects on fish stocks and cetaceans were &bquo;not sustainable'&equo;. 
 An intensive bout of lobbying by both sides followed during the next month, both in New York and in capital cities all over the world. 
 The opening salvo was fired by Japan, which produced a slick 20-minute video optimistically titled &bquo;The Truth About Drift-netting.&equo; 
 The film flatly denied that there was any problem with dolphin entanglements in drift-nets, saying that the nets were always set in the direction of the prevailing currents, and as marine mammals generally swam with the currents, entanglement was unlikely. 
 The man behind the video and the Japanese public relations offensive in New York was Alan Macnow, long-time lobbyist for the Japan Whaling Association, and a familiar figure at IWC meetings. 
 Even Macnow's legendary skills, however, were unable to persuade any countries to co-sponsor the Japanese resolution. 
 Nevertheless, the Macnow-inspired video did a sufficiently good job of muddying the waters to give the Japanese some hope of diverting the main thrust of the US/New Zealand resolution. 
 After many long hours of negotiations between the key delegations, however, and increasing support among South American and African countries for a total ban on drift-nets, a compromise text was agreed which involved substantial concessions by Japan. 
 The text which was finally agreed on 11 December 1989 provided for: 
 A freeze on further expansion of any drift-netting on the high seas outside the South Pacific. 
 A moratorium on the use of large-scale drift-nets in the South Pacific from mid 1991, at least until the conclusion of a management regime for southern albacore tuna. 
 A global moratorium on drift-net fishing on the high seas, including the North Pacific, from mid 1992, unless scientific evidence can be provided to demonstrate that drift-net use does not pose an unacceptable hazard to marine living resources. 
 The Japanese thus gained a couple of years to phase out their use of drift-nets, and retained the hope that their research scientists might be able to hide the truth about drift-net fishing. 
 By providing Japan with the opportunity to save face and make an orderly withdrawal from drift-net fishing, the UN Second Committee bound them into a commitment to cease drift-net operations in the near future &mdash; an astonishing achievement for a campaign which had only really gathered momentum 10 months earlier, with the sinking of the Sankichi Maru . 
 Perhaps belatedly, many more countries are now coming to understand the damage caused by oceanic drift-nets. 
 Because the nets are usually deployed many hundreds or even thousands of kilometres from shore, few but their crews have ever witnessed the damage inflicted on the marine ecosystem by the drift-net vessels. 
 The true incidental catch of large and small whales, dolphins, and porpoises will never be known, but wherever drift-net fleets go they undoubtedly leave thousands of dead cetaceans in their wake. 
 Although the UN Resolution adopted in December 1989 holds great promise as a major step towards ending the use of large-scale drift-nets, the drift-net nations may still be able to manipulate their own data to &bquo;prove&equo; that drift-nets, if not harmless, at least have no greater effect on marine mammals than other fishing methods, such as purse-seining for tuna. 
 Perhaps we shall see a greater concentration on drift-net fishing for scientific research, as has happened with Japanese &bquo;research  whaling&equo; in Antarctica. 
 But what is required now is not more research, but sustainable alternatives for harvesting the oceans' bountiful resources &mdash; methods such as squid jigging or tuna trolling which have a negligible effect on non-target species.  
 &bquo;Earlier this year, I addressed a meeting of the Western pacific Fisheries Council in Western Samoa. 
 I discussed the evil of drift-netting as but one of a number of kinds of ecological terrorism. 
 Everything I have seen and heard in the ensuing months reinforces my belief that drift-netting is a manifestation of an attitude which, unchecked, will in due course murder the only planet on which we can make our home.&equo; 
 Peter Tali Coleman, Governor, American Samoa Speech to South Pacific Drift-net Conference New Zealand, November 1989  
 Known areas of active drift-net fishing in the Pacific Ocean. 
 dolphins and porpoises fall victim to drift-nets in large numbers because they cannot &bquo;see&equo; them on their sonar. 
 Although a dolphin's echolocation mechanism is remarkably sensitive, it probably cannot detect the thin strands of nylon which make up the mesh of oceanic drift-nets. 
 The plastic floats at the top of the net could easily be detected by sonar, but in drift-nets, they are on the surface, where, even if detected, they would not give the dolphin any cause for alarm. 
 Some observer data on incidental catches on four vessels of the red squid fleet, over a total of 67 days' fishing through the 1980s, showed that 105 marine mammals died in 2870 k (2000 miles) of drift-net - one death for each 27 kind of net. 
 The 105 total included 12 common dolphin, 7 Dall's porpoise, 8 Pacific white-sided dolphin, and 56 northern right whale dolphin. 
 If the annual quantity of net deployed within all North Pacific fisheries in a 6-month season is taken to be 3&ndash;5 million k (about 2&ndash;3 million miles), the total possible deaths of marine mammals would be about 100,000&ndash;181,500. 
 &bquo;We encountered a baby common dolphin trapped only a few feet from the surface, its beak and tall flipper hopelessly wrapped in layer upon layer of nylon mesh. 
 I couldn't help but imagine the scene of panic and desperation that must have taken place a few hours earlier - the young dolphin fighting and dying in a few frantic spasms, its grieving mother well able to defend her child from sharks but helpless against a silent, resisting wall of nylon.&equo; 
 Sam LaBudde  
 Robert Goldblatt, a US marine biologist, spent a month observing on a Japanese drift-net vessel fishing for skipjack tuna in the seas around Yap, in the federated States of Micronesia. 
 During that time, 24 sets killed 97 dolphins, 11 small whales, and 10 turtles. 
 The whales that could be brought on board were filleted and the meat frozen, but the dolphins were thrown away. 
 The catch of skipjack from the month's fishing was a mere 900 fish, weighing on average about 4 kg (9 lb) each. 
 The quantity of whales and dolphins caught far outweighed the tuna. 
 The albacore tuna fishery in the South Pacific was thought by fisheries scientists to be fully exploited by trolling vessels, mainly from the US and New Zealand, and by longliners from Japan, Taiwan, and Korea. 
 The sustainable yield from the fishery by these methods, which have little effect on other fish species, and no significant effect on dolphins, turtles, or sea birds, has been calculated as 45,000 tonnes per year &mdash; 35,000 tonnes of adult fish taken by longlines, and 10,000 juveniles, taken by trolling. 
 The drift-net catch of juvenile in 1988&ndash;89 was estimated at between 29,000 and 49,000 tonnes, which is thought to be unsustainable. 
 GILL-NETS &mdash; THE QUIET MASSACRE 
 separate section 
 THE GILL-NET 
 Modern plastics technology has made possible the mass production of cheap and durable nylon nets, which were initially developed to provide an affordable and effective fishing method to aid developing countries. 
 Gill-nets are almost always constructed of thin nylon monofilament or multifilament line, knotted to form a meshed net. 
 The net has weights along the bottomline, and floats along its topline to hold it vertical in the water. 
 The size of the mesh varies depending on which fish species the net is supposed to catch, as does the length and depth of the net. 
 The strands are so fine that they usually cannot be detected by cetacean sonar, unlike the older type of multifilament cotton nets. 
 Fish encountering the modern nylon nets attempt to swim through the near-invisible mesh and become entangled, usually by the gills &mdash; hence the name gill-net. 
 Depending on the target species, the net is set at the bottom and anchored, or set at the surface and left to drift with the wind and current. 
 Oceanic drift-nets can be enormous, up to 56 km (35 miles) long, and are causing considerable concern because of their effects on marine mammals, sea birds, and fish stocks. 
 Set gill-nets are much shorter, and are used mostly in shallow coastal seas, where they are anchored to the seabed. 
 Gill-net entanglement affects coastal dolphin and porpoise species worldwide, and these animals' low reproductive rates make them ill-suited to cope with this type of threat. 
 Since humans first developed methods of catching fish, the occasional dolphin or porpoise has probably fallen unwitting victim to net, hook, or in more recent times, trawl net. 
 But now these incidental catches have come to present a major danger to cetacean populations. 
 Dr Stephen Leatherwood, of the UN Environment Programme, estimates that between a half to one million small cetaceans each year are caught in set-nets. 
 Many countries do not compel fishermen to report the accidental capture of small cetaceans in their nets, so significant catches may go unnoticed for years. 
 The problem is often the worst in developing countries such as Sri Lanka, where the introduction of cheap nylon nets has often enabled coastal states to rapidly expand their fishing industries. 
 In 1985, a report to the IWC Scientific Committee revealed that more than 40,000 dolphins were being killed each year as a result of incidental catches in set-nets around Sri Lankan coasts. 
 This huge dolphin kill spells a dire warning of the effect of introducing modern plastic gill-nets into developing coastal fisheries, without accompanying controls. 
 There are many fisheries throughout the Indian sub-continent and the Sri Lankan operation is the only one in this area so far to have been carefully studied. 
 It is reasonable to assume that an alarming number of dolphin deaths must be occurring around the coasts of the continent which are as yet unreported.  
 Dr Bill Perrin, who compiled the authoritative International Union for the Conservation of Nature (IUCN) Action Plan for the conservation of dolphins and porpoises, identified the convening of an international workshop on gill-nets and cetaceans as one of the Plan's highest priorities. 
 Participation by developing nations which are expanding the use of gill-nets in their coastal waters will be a key feature of the workshop, scheduled for October 1990. 
 Perrin believes that fishermen in many countries catch dolphins in set-nets, but are not required to report the deaths to fisheries authorities. 
 Among the nations that provide no information on incidental catch in gill-nets are: Pakistan, Bangladesh, Indonesia, the Philippines, Surinam, the Malagasy Republic, Papua New Guinea, Brazil, Argentina, the French Antilles, Venezuela, Mozambique, Tanzania, Kenya, the Somali Republic, Burma, Thailand, Malaysia, Kampuchea, and Vietnam. 
 Even in countries with laws that provide some degree of protection for marine mammals, fishermen are often reluctant to report incidental catches of dolphins or porpoises because they fear having restrictions placed on their use of set-nets. 
 In the Gulf of Maine, commercial mackerel fishermen have kept silent for years about the number of harbour porpoises dying in their nets. 
 The truth was revealed only by chance, when a journalist for the US magazine Sports Illustrated  happened to be aboard a boat when it hauled up seven dead porpoises, caught in a single set. 
 The Sports Illustrated  report confirmed scientists' suspicions that as many as 600 porpoises each year were dying in entanglements in the Gulf, out of a total population for the East Coast of the US and Canada of perhaps only 8000. 
 The annual kill is thought to be far greater than could be replaced by the harbour porpoise's slow rate of reproduction. 
 Because it inhabits coastal waters in heavily populated and fished areas, the harbour porpoise has suffered greatly in recent years. 
 They were once widely distributed throughout the North and Baltic Seas, but populations here have rapidly declined as a result of environmental contaminants such as pesticide residues and toxic industrial wastes. 
 Until recently, they were killed in their thousands by Turkish hunters in the Black Sea and they are still being actively hunted in Greenland, where about 1000 porpoises are harpooned or shot each year. 
 Now harbour porpoises face the additional threat of coastal gill-nets. 
 Tom Polacheck, of the US NMFS, who has been closely involved with the harbour porpoise entanglement problem, believes that the incidental taking of harbour porpoise is an example of the problems that face both the marine scientist and society, in that both marine animals and commercial fisheries are highly valued and represent issues of concern to various segments of society. 
 Canadian Professor David Gaskin's 20-year involvement with harbour porpoise has led him to examine the conflict between gill-net and small cetacean worldwide. 
 He has also been a licensed gill-netter himself. 
 He is convinced that the introduction of lightweight monofilament nylon into coastal gill-net fisheries has been a global disaster for many coastal species of dolphins and porpoise. 
 In a recent letter to an amateur gill-netter in New Zealand, Gaskin said: &bquo;Animals like Hector's dolphin, with a very low reproductive rate, are disappearing steadily all over the world... 
 The New Zealand controversy is not a unique situation. 
 In almost all cases, the sustained incidental catch is caused by gill-nets, either set or drifters, or by lost ghost nets.&equo; 
 In an authoritative report prepared in 1985 for Greenpeace, Simon Northridge of the Marine Resources Assessment Group of Imperial College, London, and Professor Georg Pilleri, a respected dolphin expert, identified a lengthy list of incidental catches of dolphins and porpoises in gill-nets, of which the following are only a selection. 
 The numbers of cetaceans caught in gill-nets through incidental catch need not be large  to severely affect some species, nor are catches confined to developing countries. 
 Many of the species involved are listed internationally as endangered. 
 The Convention of Trade in Endangered Species (CITES) has since 1973 aimed to protect species threatened by international trade, and lists endangered animals in three appendices according to the degree of threat they face. 
 Appendix 1 is the most endangered list, and animals on it may not be traded for commercial purposes. 
 In the Gulf of California, the use of gill-nets may have pushed the vaquita or Gulf of California porpoise to the edge of extinction. 
 Never an abundant species, and very restricted in its distribution, it is probably the most endangered dolphin of all. 
 in the early 1970s a gill-net fishery developed in the Gulf of California for the totoaba fish, and the nets also caught many vaquita (also known as cochito). 
 After less than 5 years of this fishery operating in the Gulf, not only were the totoaba fish stocks in danger of collapse but the vaquita population was also severely depleted. 
 In 1975, the Mexican government banned totoaba fishing, but the damage had already been done. 
 An unknown number of vaquita, probably in the hundreds, had already been lost. 
 An extensive survey of the Gulf in 1986 sighted only 31 animals. 
 Because the porpoise is such a slow breeder, there may not be enough individuals left to guarantee the survival of the species. 
 Despite the international publicity generated by the 1986 research effort, the plight of the vaquita is still not a major concern of the Mexican government. 
 However a grant from the US Center for Marine Conservation enabled Mexico to monitor the Gulf of California fishery in 1988. 
 A sample of the fishermen operating the 816 boats in the area found that 93 per cent used the type of gill-net which entangles vaquitas. 
 Most of them fish legally for sharks, but some still illegally net totoaba, and the 125- and 150-mm (5 and 6-inch) mesh nets they use continue to drown the vaquita. 
 The remaining numbers of vaquita cannot be estimated (even the external appearance of the animal was not fully described until 1985). 
 Nevertheless, the total population is obviously very small, possibly less than 100, and unlikely to be more than 1000. 
 In its action plan to save threatened cetaceans the Cetacean Specialist Group of IUCN has given the highest priority to a study which would monitor the scattered gill-net fisheries in the Gulf of California. 
 The tucuxi is one of the hump-backed dolphins. 
 It is found throughout the Amazon and Orinoco basins, and as far north as the Atlantic coast of Central America. 
 There are at least two separate populations, one coastal and the other freshwater. 
 No reliable population estimates exist. 
 Because of its coastal habitat, incidental catches in gill-nets are widespread but the effects on the population are unknown. 
 The tucuxi is currently listed in Appendix 1 of CITES. 
 The Indo-Pacific hump-backed dolphin, also listed in CITES Appendix 1, is found throughout the Indian Ocean, and as far north as Canton in China and as far east as Sydney, Australia. 
 In Asia, the dolphin is confined mainly to mangroves, where it feeds on shrimps, whereas it is more likely to be found around rocky shores in other parts of its range. 
 It falls victim to gill-nets throughout its range, with the largest mortality thought to be in Pakistan and the Indus delta, although no reliable figures are available. 
 Destruction of the dolphin's mangrove habitat in much of its Asian range may be a particularly grave threat. 
 The exact numbers of animals caught in nets are unknown, but available statistics show incidental captures to be widespread throughout the region, and these mortalities may have a considerable effect on local populations. 
 The Atlantic hump-backed dolphin is found along the West African coast, from Mauritania to Angola. 
 It is rare, and the population size is  unknown. 
 Since the dolphin is caught in shark nets, other unreported deaths probably occur all along the coast. 
 This species is also listed on CITES Appendix 1. 
 Risso's dolphin is widely distributed throughout the world. 
 The most serious incidental catch is in the coastal net fisheries around Sri Lanka, where an unknown number, probably in the thousands, are drowned each year. 
 Spinner dolphins are frequently taken in set-nets around Sri Lanka, where about 17,000 are estimated to be incidentally caught each year. 
 Common dolphins are incidentally taken in fisheries all over the world &mdash; at least 8000 animals each year die in gill-nets and seine-nets. 
 Burmeister's porpoise has been caught incidentally in gill-net fisheries in Peru for many years. 
 As long ago as 1975, 120 tonnes of porpoise meat was sold annually in Peru. 
 The largest interbreeding population of Hector's dolphin around Banks Peninsula in New Zealand, lost 230 of its estimated 760 members through entanglement in set-nets between 1984 and 1988. 
 A close relative of Hector's, the Chilean black dolphin, is caught in surface gill-nets all along the Chilean coast, its only habitat. 
 Annual catches have been estimated at 1500, from a total population believed to number in the low thousands. 
 Estimates of the number of small cetaceans taken deliberately and accidentally around the coastline of France are as high as 3000 animals each year. 
 In addition to the several hundred harbour porpoises which die each year in the set-net fishery in Canada and the north-eastern US, as many as a thousand more are dying in set-nets in the North Sea and Greenland. 
 Local populations of some dolphins have been severely affected by the use of shark nets to protect bathers. 
 In both South Africa and Queensland, shark nets have killed hundreds of dolphins, with the worst affected being hump-backed, common, and bottlenose species. 
 Northridge and Pilleri list many more instances of dolphin entanglement in set-nets. 
 All the data published on the effect of gill-nets on small cetaceans probably represents a conservative estimate of the number of deaths. 
 Dolphins and porpoises are being entangled in monofilament death traps throughout the world, and a great many drownings go unreported. 
 A more concerted action by governments to address this quiet massacre might have been expected, but part of the problem is the lack of a single international forum to deal with the management of small cetaceans. 
 In most countries the fishing industry has a powerful political lobby, with jobs and profits taking priority. 
 International action is now needed to ban the use of gill-nets by amateur fishermen. 
 Even in protein-starved, less-developed countries, the use of monofilament nets ultimately does more harm than good &mdash; their catching efficiency rapidly depletes many fish resources. 
 Ironically, the quest for profits may ultimately come to the dolphins' rescue. 
 In the international seafood trade, freshness and appearance of the product is becoming increasingly important. 
 Fish caught in gill-nets are generally regarded as being of poorer quality, because they are often dead for many hours before coming aboard the fishing vessel. 
 Gill-nets are also generally much less selective than most other fishing methods, and often catch not just marine mammals but many other non-target fish species. 
 There is thus a trend towards phasing out their use in commercial fisheries in favour of other methods like longlining and trolling, which land a better quality product, without the unwelcome incidental catch of non-target species.  
 &bquo;There is hardly a civilised Fisheries Department in the world that would not ban this sloppy, terrible method of fishing if the politicians would show some backbone.&equo; 
 Professor David Gaskin, University of Guelph, Ontario  
 LAST-MINUTE REPRIEVE FOR THE DOWNUNDER DOLPHIN 
 Until recently, little was known about the tiny and endearing Hector's dolphin, found only in the coastal waters of New Zealand. 
 Nobody suspected that a significant proportion of the small population was being caught and killed each year in fishing nets. 
 Now Hector's is in the limelight not only in New Zealand but also internationally, as efforts to save this unique species are making it one of the conservation success stories of the world. 
 The discovery of the plight of Hector's dolphin in 1986 was a fateful coincidence. 
 Virtually no information existed on the biology and distribution of the dolphin, until two Auckland University graduates decided to make the species the subject of their doctoral theses. 
 Their choice may have made the difference between survival and extinction for Hector's dolphin. 
 The story demonstrates the urgent need for similar studies to be undertaken in other parts of the world to determine the status of the many other dolphin species about which we know so little. 
 The two students, Stephen Dawson and Elisabeth Slooten, carried out a 6400-km (4000 mile) survey of the dolphin's known habitat, covering most of New Zealand's South Island and the lower half of the west coast of the North Island. 
 They estimated the total population at 3000&ndash;4000 animals and discovered that almost a quarter lived around Banks Peninsula, near the South Island's largest city, Christchurch. 
 The seas in this area have since the mid 1970s supported many commercial fishermen who set nets around the coast to supply the local fish and chip trade. 
 Dawson and Slooten discovered that these nylon monofilament gill-nets, up to 3000 metres (9750 feet) in length, were responsible for the deaths of far more dolphins than had ever been officially reported, and that the local dolphin population was in fact declining rapidly. 
 Fishermen willingly co-operated with the students, passed on information about dolphin sightings, and even handed over the bodies of dolphins accidentally taken in their fishing nets. 
 Many Hector's dolphins were also falling victim to the nets of recreational fishermen who fish the numerous bays around the peninsula's deeply indented coastline, especially during summer holidays. 
 Slooten and Dawson did a more detailed survey over 1984 to 1988 in the waters of Pegasus Bay, Banks Peninsula, and the Canterbury Bight, which showed incidental catches of between 26 and 90 Hector's dolphin each year. 
 The numbers killed in commercial set-nets declined over the period, but the number caught in amateur nets increased. 
 Because not all catches were reported, the actual numbers caught were probably even higher. 
 Eighty-seven per cent of entanglement deaths occurred within 10 km (5 nautical miles) of the shore, and 60 per cent occurred within 2 km (one nautical mile). 
 Over the period of study, 228 dolphins were reliably reported to have drowned in set-nets, out of a total population estimated in 1984 at 740. 
 Because Hector's dolphins cannot hold their breath for long and dives rarely exceed 2 minutes (compared with up to 8 minutes for a bottlenose dolphin), entanglement in a set-net is usually fatal. 
 Slooten and Dawson found that many of the animals brought in to them were young animals, perhaps inexperienced in the use of their sonar. 
 They discovered that almost all the reported drownings of dolphins occurred  between November and February, when commercial fishermen bring their nets closer to shore, following the breeding dogfish and elephant fish. 
 Although Hector's dolphins do not feed extensively on commercial fish species, they, too, move into the sheltered waters of the peninsula's bays to breed during the summer. 
 In years gone by, the impact of set-nets on the dolphins may have been even more serious. 
 Of the 60 or so gill-net vessels which had worked around the peninsula in the late 1970s, only half a dozen remained by 1986. 
 The introduction of quotas to regulate the commercial fish catch had removed a substantial number of set-netters from the industry. 
 Because so little work had been carried out on Hector's dolphin before Slooten and Dawson began their studies, it is impossible to even guess at the number of dolphins which had been annually killed before 1984. 
 Given the previous level of set-net effort, however, the population was probably originally much larger, and had been on the decrease for many years, at least since the rapid expansion of set-net use in the mid 1970s. 
 Slooten's work showed that female Hector's dolphins begin breeding between 7 and 9 years of age, and rarely live longer than 18 years. 
 They produce a single calf once every 2 or 3 years. 
 Even under the most favourable conditions, therefore, a female is unlikely to produce more than five calves in a lifetime, with three probably being a more realistic average. 
 As the studies continued, it became increasingly obvious that the dolphins could not withstand the high losses they were suffering. 
 This slow breeding pattern is typical of small dolphins and porpoises. 
 Jay Barlow of the US discovered that for the vaquita, new births into the population each year almost exactly balanced the losses through natural mortality. 
 Like Hector's dolphin, the vaquita is incidentally caught in a gill-net fishery, and is unable to replace the losses through increased rates of reproduction. 
 Based on the data on incidental catch provided to Stephen Dawson, Canterbury University experts in population biology and mathematics calculated the likely effect of gill-netting on Hector's dolphin. 
 Because so many of the drowned Banks Peninsula dolphins were young animals, the local dolphin population was predicted to continue to decline for many years, even if all set-net entanglements were stopped, simply because fewer dolphins would reach breeding age. 
 The New Zealand Government's Department of Conservation therefore proposed the introduction of restrictions on the use of set-nets around Banks Peninsula, through the use of an Act of Parliament which most New Zealanders had probably never heard of. 
 The Marine Mammals Protection Act was passed in New Zealand in 1978, and reflected a growing public awareness of the need to provide for the conservation of the country's marine mammals, which had been ruthlessly slaughtered during both the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. 
 Section 22 of the Act provided for the establishment of marine mammal sanctuaries. 
 This power had never been previously used, but became a key element in the plan to save Hector's dolphin through the establishment of a marine mammal sanctuary around Banks Peninsula. 
 The proposed sanctuary area extended 7 km (4 miles) offshore, and covered an area of some 1140 square km (500 square miles). 
 When the Conservation Department proposed the establishment of the sanctuary in its discussion document, the public response was overwhelmingly favourable. 
 An astonishing 6400 replies were received, more than 90 per cent of them supporting the creation of the sanctuary, while 80 per cent wanted a total or seasonal ban on set-netting within the sanctuary area. 
 Included in this number were Martin Holdgate, Director-General of IUCN, and Professor David Gaskin, world expert on marine mammals. 
 Gaskin, who is convinced that modern monofilament  gill-nets have caused serious declines in dolphin and porpoise populations worldwide, is convinced that coastal porpoise and dolphin species are in decline everywhere, and is alarmed at the situation. 
 He believes the set-net or gill-net to be a devastating piece of 
 equipment, and in &bquo;first-world&equo; country sees no excuse to continue fishing in this manner: &bquo;The counter-arguments of a handful of fishermen... not representative of the industry... should not be given any particular weight. 
 In no way do they have a mandate to wipe out a whole stock and possibly a whole species simply for their convenience in carrying on with an unsophisticated fishing method.&equo; 
 The Minister of Conservation, Helen Clark, established the sanctuary one week before Christmas 1988. 
 All commercial netting was prohibited within the sanctuary, and a ban was imposed on the use of all set-nets within the sanctuary during the months of November to February, thus enormously reducing recreational set-net use. 
 The Department of Conservation estimated that 60&ndash;80 per cent of the dolphin mortalities of the previous 4 years could have been avoided by such restrictions. 
 Reaction to the establishment of the sanctuary was mixed. 
 Conservation groups hailed the decision as enlightened, and there was little criticism from the fishing industry. 
 However, local amateur fishers were outraged. 
 Many felt that to be denied the use of a fishing net for 4 months each year was the removal of a fundamental human right. 
 Slooten and Dawson were accused of fabricating their data, and of failing to count dolphins accurately. 
 The controversy created by the research suddenly put Hector's dolphin firmly in the public eye. 
 Before the study began, few people knew about the dolphin, but the upsurge in public interest prompted many locals to claim that they were seeing more dolphins recently than ever before, whereas in fact they had probably just taken greater notice of something that had always been there. 
 Others agreed with the idea of a sanctuary, but suggested that it should be situated somewhere else where there would be no conflicts with recreational fishing, prompting Steve Dawson to draw the analogy of &bquo;putting a plaster on your bum to treat a boil on your forehead.&equo; 
 After a few months, the controversy settled down, and the Department of Conservation announced a 3-year research programme to provide the answers to key questions about the status of banks Peninsula population of Hector's dolphin. 
 The programme, which involves aerial surveys, DNA-fingerprinting, and photo-identification, will be a joint research effort between New Zealand and US scientists. 
 At the conclusion of the programme, the Minister of Conservation will reassess the regulations required to provide protection for the downunder dolphin. 
 The Hector's story may have a happy ending, as the establishment of entanglement. 
 Hector's dolphins are however still exposed to the hazard of set-net and, to a far lesser extent, trawl nets throughout the rest of their range in New Zealand. 
 Also, the levels of pesticide residues and heavy metals in their tissues are high, as might be expected in animals with a coastal habitat. 
 There is hope for Hector's, but it has certainly been saved from fishing nets at the last hour, and will need all the protection and help it can get if it is to survive through the next century.  
 Hector's dolphin is one of the four species of the genus Cephalorhynchus , all of which are found in different areas of the Southern Hemisphere at temperate latitudes. 
 The other species are Commerson's dolphin. 
 Heaviside's dolphin, and the Chilean black dolphin. 
 All are small, but Hector's is the tiniest, reaching only 1.4 metres (4 feet 6 inches) maximum length, and weighing no more than 40&ndash;47 kg (88&ndash;103 lb) when fully grown. 
 Its size and distinctive black and white markings have earned it the title of panda of the dolphin world, which portrays its lovable, almost cuddly qualities. 
 &bquo;Whatever we do or don't do, our children will have to live with.&equo; 
 Steve Dawson and Elizabeth Slooten, University of Canterbury, New Zealand  
 POISONED WATERS 
 Small cetaceans face many threats through the loss of their habitat. 
 Industrial poisons, oil spills, and an increasing amount of modern plastic debris foul the seas and rivers in which cetaceans live, while pollution, hydro-electric dams, and forest clearance destroy the specialised habitats of river dolphins. 
 TOXIC INDUSTRIAL WASTES 
 For decades, the major industrial nations have used coastal seas as the dumping ground and receptacle for a wide range of industrial and agricultural toxins and waste products. 
 Many dolphins and porpoises are particularly vulnerable to these poisons, because of both their coastal habitat and their position at the top of the food chain. 
 The most toxic residues from industrial society are rarely successfully neutralised or excreted by living organisms, and they tend to be increasingly concentrated in animal tissues as they are passed up the food chain. 
 Top predators, such as toothed whales and dolphins, can accumulate large quantities in their tissues if they keep eating contaminated prey. 
 Small cetaceans are additionally vulnerable because their bodies contain large volumes of fat and blubber. 
 Chlorinated hydrocarbons, which are some of the most persistent and environmentally damaging of the industrial chemicals, and the industrial organochlorides known as polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs), are particularly soluble in fatty tissues. 
 Arctic and tropical cetaceans are relatively free from chlorinated hydrocarbons, but those from temperate waters, especially industrialised coastal waters, are often heavily contaminated. 
 BELEAGUERED BELUGAS OF THE ST LAWRANCE RIVER 
 A century ago, as many as 5000 belugas or white whales lived in the St Lawrence River in eastern Canada. 
 Now the river has become so heavily polluted with toxic industrial wastes that the belugas are among the most contaminated mammals in the world. 
 In fact, they are so contaminated with PCBs alone that, under Canadian law, their corpses must be treated as toxic waste to keep the poisonous chemical from returning to the environment. 
 The level of PCBs in belugas has been measured as high as 1725 parts per million (ppm). 
 Fish are judged to be unfit for human consumption at just 2 ppm. 
 The belugas of the St Lawrence may now number only 400, and this local population is almost certainly doomed to extinction. 
 The beluga is closely related to the narwhal, and both are found mainly in the cold northern waters of Canada, Alaska, and the USSR. 
 Belugas can be found in all shallow waters, rivers, and estuaries of the Arctic, and seem to be limited only by temperatures higher than 15&deg;C (60&deg;F). 
 A rotund species, they are striking for their creamy white colour and remarkable range of sounds that can be clearly heard above the surface of the water. 
 These range from squeals &mdash; attributed by early mariners to &bquo;sea canaries&equo; &mdash; to a beautiful bell-like tone that is unique among cetaceans. 
 When they were plentiful in the St Lawrence, the belugas were often blamed for depleting fish stocks, and the Canadian government for  many years paid a bounty for each whale killed. 
 During the Second World War, trainee fighter pilots used them for target practice, and as recently as 1968, they were still being hunted for sport. 
 Now PCBs and other industrial pollutants are killing off the beluga. 
 Ironically, at the eleventh hour the plight of the belugas has been given a boost by the success of whale-watching cruises in the St Lawrence. 
 Public pressure on the Canadian and Quebec governments has resulted in the pledge of more than 2.4 billion dollars over the next 10 years to clean up the St Lawrence and create a marine sanctuary for the remaining belugas. 
 Much of the credit for the remarkable change in the attitudes of the Canadian public towards the St Lawrence belugas must go to ecologist Leone Pippard, commonly known as Our Lady of the White Whales. 
 It was her solitary research and activism during the 1970s which alerted the world to the fact that despite the end of large-scale hunting in the 1950s, numbers had continued to decline, and the whales were on the verge of extinction. 
 In 1979, the Canadian government accorded protection status to the St Lawrence beluga population. 
 During the same year, the first whale-watching vessel on the St Lawrence attracted only a handful of supporters, but a decade later, the numbers have swelled to over 60,000 tourists a year, with revenues from whale-watching now approaching 2 million dollars annually. 
 Ironically, tour operators are strictly forbidden from seeking out belugas, because they are an endangered species, but the beluga has nevertheless become a powerful symbol of ecological neglect for those who have experienced the 3-hour cruises, complete with detailed lectures about the animal's plight. 
 Even after they had received total protection status, beluga numbers in the St Lawrence continued to decline, and autopsies of dead whales during the 1980s revealed astonishing levels of toxic chemicals &mdash; in particular organochlorines such as PCBs, the insecticides DDT and mirex, and dioxin. 
 When whales eat contaminated prey, organochlorines go first to the digestive system, and are then deposited in fatty tissues. 
 Because they cannot generally be metabolised or excreted, organochlorines tend to accumulate gradually in the blubber, which in adult belugas accounts for 35 per cent of the body weight. 
 Conventional scientific wisdom has held that whales are relatively immune from the effects of toxic chemicals, because such contaminants were thought to be safely stored in the blubber, a tissue considered to be fairly inert. 
 Pierre Beland and Daniel Martineau were members of a research team which showed that the concept of blubber as an inert tissue was incorrect &mdash; the ratios of contaminants in samples from over 70 autopsied belugas has shown that toxins are continually exchanged between various tissues. 
 Beland and Martineau also discovered that male belugas were much more contaminated than females, and that year-old calves were, strangely, often the most contaminated of all. 
 However, female belugas, who bear a single calf every three years, have a mechanism for unloading organochlorines. 
 Small amounts of contaminants are transferred from mother to foetus, but much greater quantities are passed to the suckling young through her milk. 
 Whale milk is very rich in fats, making it an ideal carrier of organochlorines. 
 The massive contamination in the animals autopsied in recent years provides little cause for optimism. 
 By the time the St Lawrence River is restored to health, the belugas will probably be gone. 
 The sad fate of the St Lawrence belugas epitomises the problems faced by small cetaceans on an increasingly polluted planet. 
 In many ways, the St Lawrence belugas have provided a perfect opportunity for scientists to study the effects of contaminants on a wild whale population, since  they are isolated from other groups, and live in a river system known to be contaminated. 
 Sometime in the future belugas will return to a clean St Lawrence River, either naturally or by a programme of capture and release from other wild populations. 
 COASTAL CETACEANS SUFFER THE MOST FROM TOXIC WASTE 
 In the 1970s a study of dolphin and porpoise tissues, from several locations throughout the Pacific, demonstrated that coastal dolphins and porpoises are the most susceptible to accumulating toxic waste, especially those whose habitat is close to industrial discharges or runoff of agricultural chemicals. 
 California is the major industrial polluter of the eastern Pacific seaboard. 
 The oceanic input of PCBs from five southern California sewage treatment plants was estimated at nearly 200 tonnes per year in 1972. 
 One Los Angeles pesticide manufacturer alone was responsible for a continuous discharge of DDT at sewer outfalls for 20 years, dumping almost 250 kg (550 lb) per day into the ocean. 
 Not surprisingly, mean concentrations of DDT and related compounds were up to seven times higher in the blubber of male common dolphins from the southern California area than from any species sampled elsewhere in the Pacific, including Japan. 
 PCB residues in the blubber of the California bottlenose dolphin also exceeded previously published concentrations for cetaceans from all other parts of the world, except perhaps the Mediterranean coast of France, which have been reported to have a maximum concentration of over 2500 ppm. 
 The true effect on wild dolphin populations of prolonged exposure to chemical pollutants is hard to measure. 
 Because much of a dolphin's life is spent beyond the range of human observation, such basic characteristics as reproductive rates and life expectancy are much harder to measure than with birds and land mammals. 
 However, there is abundant anecdotal evidence of the effects of chemical pollution on the populations of small cetaceans inhabiting industrialised areas. 
 Until the nineteenth century, for example, bottlenose dolphins occurred in all the major estuaries in Britain, including the Thames and the Humber. 
 Now they can be found only in the Moray Firth in Scotland. 
 Whether the dolphins' population has declined or whether they simply avoid the more contaminated areas and have moved to remoter regions is not clear. 
 The harbour porpoise, common in the North Sea until the 1930s, has now disappeared from the Thames estuary, Firth of Forth, Firth of Tay, the Clyde, Tyne, Tees, and Mersey rivers, and the Bristol Channel. 
 In areas with only restricted opportunities for mixing and dilution of industrial wastes, such as the Baltic Sea, contamination of marine mammals is an especially pressing problem. 
 The common seals of the Wadden Sea vie with the St Lawrence belugas and Mediterranean bottlenose dolphins for the dubious distinction of the world's most PCB-contaminated animal. 
 Almost 80 per cent of the female seals in the Baltic are known to be sterile, primarily as a result of PCB poisoning, and by the year 2000, grey seals in the Baltic may well have become extinct. 
 DDT and PCB levels in the blubber of a few porpoises from eastern Scotland analysed in 1967 were considerably higher than in seals from the same area. 
 A similar result has been found in the Gulf of St Lawrence in Canada.  
 POLLUTION MAY CAUSE MASSIVE DIE-OFFS 
 At low levels of contamination, organochlorines such as PCBs may lower an animal's resistance to infection, and can be the cause of mass deaths. 
 During January 1989, for example, over 500 bottlenose dolphins were washed up on the Atlantic coast of France. 
 No obvious cause of death was found, but all the dolphins were heavily contaminated with PCBs. 
 In another incident, during the summer of 1987, hundreds of dead and dying bottlenose dolphins were washed ashore on beaches of the East Coast of the US, from New Jersey to Florida. 
 In the following 18 months, more than 750 emaciated dolphin bodies were washed ashore, although US officials now estimate that as many as 3000 dolphins may have died with similar symptoms. 
 Most of the dolphins that were washed up had died from internal haemorrhaging. 
 They had fluid in their lungs, enlarged spleens, bronchial pneumonia, and their skin peeled off like plastic food wrap. 
 Their immune systems had apparently broken down. 
 According to Greenpeace biologists, the dolphins all had high levels of PCBs in their tissues, although the official report blamed their death on poisonous algae in their fish prey. 
 Coastal cetaceans not only pick up chlorinated hydrocarbons, but also accumulate other industrial pollutants such as heavy metals. 
 Many industrial processes discharge to the environment such metals as zinc, copper, cadmium and, most dangerous of all, mercury. 
 Many governments are very strict about imposing restrictions on the importation of foodstuffs which contain excessive concentrations of heavy metals. 
 Japan in particular has been particularly conscious of the devastating effect of mercury poisoning after hundreds of Japanese died or were permanently crippled in the 1950s after exposure to mercury-contaminated fish. 
 The mercury had been discharged from a local chemical plant. 
 Surveys of dolphin tissues for mercury carried out in 1978 by Japanese scientists showed very high levels of mercury in local dolphins. 
 The highest rating was for the bottlenose dolphin, which had a mercury content as much as 130 times the maximum permitted level for human consumption (0.5 ppm). 
 For the striped dolphin, until recently the most commonly eaten species in Japan, the mean mercury level was 12 times the maximum allowable level. 
 PLASTICS AND THE MARINE DEBRIS PERIL 
 Plastic debris is filling up our oceans and is another modern peril that is taking its toll on dolphins and other marine mammals. 
 Lost or deliberately discarded fishing nets pose the biggest threat, but seemingly more innocent items like plastic bags, plastic pellets, and polypropylene packing tape can also be killers of wildlife. 
 Small whales and dolphins are not only caught in nets that are actively fishing, but also in set-nets that break away from their anchors, lost or discarded trawl nets, and, in particular, lost portions of the enormous oceanic drift-nets, which become &bquo;ghost nets'&equo; that float in the ocean and continue to catch fish and other marine life. 
 These drifting nets of thin monofilament nylon may each be up to 50 km (31 miles) in length, and portions are inevitably lost in bad weather. 
 In the North Pacific Ocean the 1987&ndash;88 driftnet fleet of roughly 1600 Taiwanese, Japanese, and Korean vessels was estimated to deploy 50,000 km (31,000 miles) of net each night for several months each year. 
 According to official Japanese government estimates, 0.2 per cent of the nets set each night are not recovered, although the rate of loss is probably much higher, perhaps as much as 2 per cent. 
 Even the official  Japanese estimates would result in 1100 km (690 miles) of netting being released into the North Pacific each year, with a life expectancy measured in decades, if not centuries. 
 These remnants may be rolled into balls of netting and sink, or may continue to catch fish, sea birds and marine mammals as they drift in the ocean currents, sinking with the weight of entangled wildlife, only to rise towards the surface again as the bodies decompose. 
 One segment of drift-net recovered from the Alaskan coastline was 1.5 km (1 mile) long and contained 99 dead sea birds, over 200 dead salmon and a seal skull. 
 The recent rapid expansion of Asian drift-net fleets into the South Pacific and Tasman Sea has raised fears of similar problems of entanglement of marine mammals in plastic netting lost or discarded in these areas. 
 The attitude to the disposal of plastics varies greatly among countries. 
 Korean skippers, for example, must pass an examination in plastics disposal before they are commissioned, and must keep a daily log to ensure that all plastic rubbish has been kept on board. 
 Observers frequently report that Japanese, Taiwanese, and Korean fishermen make every effort to retrieve net fragments for recycling. 
 Even with this care, however, so great are the quantities of drift-net in use that the loss of some of the millions of kilometres of netting deployed each year is inevitable. 
 Other forms of plastics also hold hazards for small cetaceans. 
 Plastic bags may be lethal when swallowed in mistake for food. 
 Minke whales, sperm whales, and killer whales have all been reported stranded on Australian and New Zealand beaches with their stomachs or throats full of plastic bags or sheets. 
 Discarded or lost fishing line and plastic strapping bands used in the fishing industry can form lethal collars for both dolphins and seals. 
 Once around a young marine mammal's neck, the plastic collar will slowly cut deeper into the animal's flesh as it grows, until the animal is throttled or dies of starvation or infection. 
 NOISE 
 Noise generated by industrial activity and boat traffic is transmitted especially well under water. 
 The noise from oil rigs is within the frequency range of dolphin vocalisations and can be detected from a distance of 80 km (50 miles) with hydrophones. 
 Noises of such intensity may seriously affect the ability of cetaceans to communicate and echolocate, especially in cold polar waters where ice cover reflects much underwater noise back from the surface. 
 Migrating bowhead whales are reported to give drilling ships in the Beaufort Sea a wide berth on their migrations. 
 Scientists report that the inner ears of Weddell seals in McMurdo Sound, Antarctica, have been damaged by seismic blasts. 
 OIL 
 Little is known of the general effects of oil on the distribution of small cetaceans. 
 When large quantities of oil are released after the break-up of a tanker, for example, sea birds appear to be more visibly affected than the smooth-skinned dolphins, possibly because cetaceans can choose to swim away from oil slicks, and do not have to keep returning through slicks to nesting sites on shore. 
 The effects of oil pollution on marine mammals are more severe in colder waters, not only because of the much longer time required for the oil to break down, but also because concentrations of cetaceans and other marine mammals are often larger in polar waters. 
  Conservationists have for many years been predicting the catastrophic consequences of a major oil spill in Arctic or Antarctic seas, and in early 1989, their worst fears were realised. 
 The Argentine resupply and tourist ship Bahia Paraiso  ran aground near major penguin rookeries in the Antarctic Peninsula, just offshore from the US research base of Palmer Station. 
 The vessel was carrying one million litres (more than a quarter of a million US gallons) of oil, diesel, jet fuel, and compressed gas. 
 A year later, the vessel was still firmly aground. 
 Thousands of birds, particularly skuas and their chicks, died from exposure to the spilt fuel, and the toll on seals and small whales is unknown. 
 Yet the Bahia Paraiso  tragedy seemed of little consequence compared with the disaster which occurred in northern polar waters only weeks later. 
 The 350 metre (1140-foot) supertanker Exxon Valdez  left the Alaskan oil terminal port of Valdez on the night of 24 March, loaded with 230 million litres (61 million US gal) of crude oil. 
 Within an hour and a half, the Exxon Valdez  had eluded the coastguard radar tracking system and plunged at full speed on to the rocks of Bligh Reef, rupturing eight cargo holds, each big enough to house a 15-storey building. 
 The environmental consequences of the accident, which oil companies described during legal hearings in the 1970s as a &bquo;one in a million'&equo; possibility, have been catastrophic. 
 Hundreds of kilometers of coastline were covered with a thick layer of oil 15&ndash;20 cm (6&ndash;8 inches) thick, with a mousse-like consistency. 
 The effects on small cetaceans are unknown, but 10 gray whales were found dead on Alaskan beaches in May. 
 The whales were coated with oil, picked up when they entered Alaskan waters on their summer migration from Mexico and California, to feed in the rich northern waters. 
 Prince William Sound appears ruined as a healthy marine environment for years, if not decades. 
 As even the remotest parts of the earth are threatened by modern industrial society, the future for not only dolphins but for all marine wildlife looks increasingly insecure. 
 ATMOSPHERIC POLLUTION 
 Adding to the problems caused by what is being dumped into the seas and waterways of the world are the profound and unpredictable consequences of atmospheric pollution. 
 Most threatening of these for the marine ecosystem is the exposure to increased ultra-violet radiation through the depletion of the ozone layer. 
 The combination of global warming and the increasing damage to the ozone layer will undoubtedly have profound effects on ocean productivity, currents and upwellings and will result in changes in the abundance and distribution of many marine species. 
 In an experiment carried out at Palmer Station on the Antarctic Peninsula in 1989, microscopic floating ocean plants (phytoplankton) were taken from the nearby bay and brought into the laboratory, where they were subjected to levels of ultra-violet radiation estimated to be equivalent to the amount of ultra-violet being transmitted through the ozone hole which has been developing in Antarctica each spring in recent years. 
 The plant's production dived, in some cases to as little as one-eighth of the normal rate.  
 PCBs, although no longer produced, were for 50 years widely used in industry &mdash; for example as cooling and insulating fluids and in the manufacture of plastics, adhesives, and lubricants. 
 They are usually colourless or pale yellow liquids, and are fire resistant, stable, soluble in fat, and highly toxic. 
 Because of their stability, they are hard to dispose of and are persistent environmental contaminants. 
 They can remain for many years in cold and hostile environments while retaining their toxicity, and they have a tendency to remain in living organisms. 
 They are carcinogenic and cause infertility in many species. 
 Almost all PCBs are believed to enter the oceans via the atmosphere, enabling even the most remote parts of the globe to become contaminated. 
 More than a billion kilograms of PCBs were probably produced, and a third of this is believed to have leaked into the environment because of careless disposal. 
 According to Joseph Cummins of the University of London, Ontario, the liberation of only a small proportion of the remaining PCBs would spell disaster for marine mammals. 
 The St Lawrence River drains the Great Lakes, and both Canadian and US industries have been pouring toxic wastes into the lake and river system for decades, creating an increasingly lethal environment for the beluga. 
 Their river habitat east of Quebec city has become a chemical soup of pollutants which probably causes a failure of their immune system or leads to a variety of other diseases such as bladder and other cancers, hepatitis, and perforated ulcers. 
 Autopsies have identified at least 24 different contaminants in their bodies. 
 Simple laboratory tests were able to show the acutely toxic effects of large doses of organochlorines, but it took years for high concentrations to accumulate in belugas that had consumed large quantities of lightly-contaminated food. 
 The stability of the organochlorines, an advantage in their industrial applications, ensured that they were not broken down in the natural environment. 
 By the time the routine disposal of organochlorines was recognised to be a hazard, major consumers in many ecosystems, such as the belugas of the St Lawrence, were already heavily contaminated. 
 The concentrations of DDT and PCB residues reported in many studies of dolphin and porpoise tissues have been shown experimentally to cause lowered fertility and premature births in both seals and sealions. exposure to PCBs can result in failure of the body's immune system. 
 DDT has been responsible for drastic population declines of many birds of prey, including fish-eating birds such as pelicans. 
 Small cetaceans would probably not fare better than birds after exposure to excessive quantities of organochlorines. indeed dolphins and porpoises may be particularly vulnerable because they apparently have a lower capacity for PCB degradation than birds. 
 &bquo;The belugas&equo; plight must be seen as a warning that marine life in general is threatened. 
 We must realize that time is running out faster than we think.&equo; 
 Leone Pippard  
 &bquo;There are clear signs that the oceans are dying. 
 And when the oceans die, forget it. 
 We are gone.&equo; 
 Leone Pippard, Our Lady of the White Whales  
 According to a US National Academy of Sciences study in 1975, the world's fishing vessels each year dump more than 24,000 tonnes of plastic packaging material and lose an additional 135,000 tonnes of plastic nets, lines and buoys. 
 Several thousand kilometres of fish netting is lost or discarded at sea annually. 
 Each day the world's merchant shipping fleet, by one reliable estimate made in 1982, discards 639,000 plastic containers into the sea. 
 Commercial gill-net fisheries should be phased out wherever suitable alternative techniques are available. 
 If they are not, monofilament nets must be replaced by biodegradable multifilament nets made out of a material like cotton, which are detectable by dolphin sonar. 
 More research should be carried out into how to modify nets so that dolphins are warned to keep Clear. 
 The wildlife toll exacted by lost and abandoned fishing gear is staggering. 
 According to an estimate by the entanglement Network, a coalition of 18 environmental groups in Washington, DC, lost or discarded plastic is killing up to 2 million sea birds and 100,000 marine mammals each year. 
 The proposal to use nuclear-powered icebreaking supertankers (the Arctic Pilot project) to transport oil and gas from the Canadian Arctic fortunately never proceeded past the planning stage. 
 Their noise would have undoubtedly caused enormous damage to the sensitive hearing of marine mammals. 
 Beluga whales emit distress calls when even a conventional icebreaker is 80 k (50 miles) away, and flee when such vessels approach within 40 k (25 miles). 
 LETTERS 
 Helping Saddam 
 You're right: the world owes a lot to &bquo;clear American leadership&equo; for keeping the peace in Europe and Asia (&bquo;All over bar the shooting&equo;, December 15th). 
 Curiously, you fail to ascribe Iraq's invasion of Kuwait to an absence of that same clear leadership in the Middle East. 
 There, by supporting Israel's occupation of various Arab slivers, America has done neither itself nor Israel a service. 
 Those whom it has encouraged are the likes of Saddam Hussein, who are fundamentally correct in claiming a link between the two occupations &mdash; hardly a flattering analogy but one for which many people may be about to pay for America's 30 years of pusillanimity in the Middle East.  
 Sydney RORY MCGUIRE 
 Don't malign Colombia 
 You betray an ironic and unfair image of a decent country which is facing difficult times when you refer (December 1st) to Colombia's &bquo;worn out political system&equo;; to its &bquo;corrupt and self-serving political elite&equo;; to assassination as &bquo;the usual fate of Colombian reformers&equo;; and to drug traffickers &bquo;who will get lighter terms in Colombia's porous prisons in return for squealing on their colleagues.&equo; 
 Narcotic drugs were introduced into Colombia by foreigners, and its illegal trafficking is sustained by an ever-increasing demand in developed countries that seem to lack the political will to combat abuse. 
 Many of the problems that you refer to in such a light-hearted manner are the result of this situation, which Colombia has been fighting, with a certain success. 
 Colombia continues to be democratic in every way, run by civilians, not generals, who have their own part to play. 
 It is a country in which drug traffickers, be they Colombians or of another nationality, are finding it very difficult to operate today.  
 Pully, Switzerland D. GARCES-GIRALDO 
 Barclays in Japan 
 Your article on the problems of foreign-owned stockbrokers in Tokyo (&bquo;Gaijin, gaijin, gone&equo;, December 22nd) has caused considerable offence within Barclays and has quite unfairly and incorrectly singled out for attack one of our middle managers, Michael Tomalin. 
 You blame him for saddling Barclays de Zoete Wedd with high overhead costs in putting our brokerage firm and our banking operations together in one building, a building which houses a number of our competitors, as you also point out. 
 Irrespective of the success of this integration, your claim was a travesty of the facts. 
 The decision was discussed and agreed at board level, including the amount of space taken. 
 To put the implementation entirely at the door of Mr Tomalin, who has since left Tokyo to take a key position in our head office, is nonsense.  
 London JOHN QUINTON Chairman Barclays Bank 
 Mail model 
 In your report on the Post Office (December 15th) you claim that the principle of setting price according to costs led Rowland Hill to favour a national stamp price. 
 What he really wanted was a two-tier price structure, with inaccessible places of &bquo;secondary importance&equo; facing a surcharge. 
 Hill was eventually persuaded to drop this proposal to gain acceptance for what he regarded as the greater reform: that price should be independent of distance. 
 It is also noteworthy that Hill was vehemently opposed to the statutory monopoly. 
 He advocated repeal of the legislation on the grounds that &bquo;it implies the removal of an offence from our statute book and the probable rise of a wholesome competition&equo;.  
 Exeter DAVID DE MEZA 
 Basque terrorism 
 Your estimate of 707 people killed by the Basque terrorist group, ETA, in 1968&ndash;90 is too high by at least 100 (December 1st). 
 My data, gathered painstakingly from the local Basque press over the past 15 years, suggest the number should be closer to 600. 
 Second, the Algerian negotiations between ETA and the Spanish government broke down over the government's unwillingness to accept in principle the Basques' right of self-determination. 
 ETA was not adamant in its claim to represent the Basque people. 
 As for your acceptance of the Spanish government's line that ETA is planning some sort of violence during the Olympics, the discovered documents do not prove anything. 
 ETA has had operatives in Barcelona for years, and the documents could reflect simply the continuation of these operations. 
 ETA has never engaged in attacks that might endanger such large numbers of bystanders, especially foreigners, even when presented with attractive targets.  
 Burke, Virginia ROBERT CLARK 
 Leaders' bazaar 
 Who ever heard of a pope born in the Vatican City (December 1st)? 
 Since that state has existed only since 1929, such an event would have been truly prodigious. 
 Even at the last conclave, in 1978, this hypothetical cardinal could at most have been only 49 years old. 
 The last time anyone so young was elected to the throne of St Peter was Clement VII in 1523. 
 In fact, the first pope elected after the creation of the Vatican City was its citizen, though by virtue of office rather than birth. 
 As secretary of state, Cardinal Eugenio Pacelli was resident in the Vatican when he was elected pope. 
 Indeed, had he been some eight years older, he would have been born a subject of the pope &mdash; but the Piedmontese put an end to that possibility when they invaded Rome in 1870. 
 Most of his 19th-century predecessors were: all except one pope was born a papal subject.  
 Taynuilt, Argyll GERARD MCKAY 
 I couldn't help but notice that you could not find an appropriate country for Brian Mulroney, Canada's prime minister. 
 As a Canadian who left the country because of the lack of adequate money for basic scientific research, neither can I.  
 Berne, Switzerland WILLIAM SHOTYK 
 Hard times again? 
 IN THEIR rather cheerful new outlook for the world economy, published late last month, forecasters at the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development were careful to point out that the risks of error were &bquo;on the downside&equo;. 
 Yes, indeed. 
 The question is, how far is down? 
 During the coming weeks economic policy-makers may have to deal with an exceptionally difficult series of hazards. 
 Rarely does a year start by offering so many opportunities for governments to make ruinous mistakes. 
 Or with so many echoes of the world's previous case study in economic and political error, the 1930s (see pages 17&ndash;22). 
 The OECD says that the American economy will grow by only a shade less than 1% in 1991, while Japan will manage nearly 4% and Germany (despite the difficulties of unification) 3%. 
 Most private forecasters now expect no growth in America this year, and lately each of their succeeding revisions has been down. 
 But even the gloomier numbers do not portray the scope for disaster. 
 For lack of any way to quantify the economic risks, they give no weight at all to some far-from-negligible probabilities. 
 Take a deep breath 
 In the past two weeks America and its allies have moved closer to war with Iraq. 
 A war might go well and be over quickly. 
 In that event, after a brief panic, the price of oil would fall sharply and stockmarkets would celebrate; the floor for the world economy would move up and into view. 
 But if a war went badly and looked likely to drag on, that would be a calamity not just in its own right. 
 The price of oil would probably rise to more than &dollar;50 a barrel and dig in for a stay of some months. 
 This would confront governments and central banks with the last thing they need: a two-part shock of slower growth and faster inflation. 
 Confidence would falter, stockmarkets would take a hammering, talk of a meek and mild recession in America would stop. 
 At the same time the prospects for political and economic stability in the Soviet Union continue to fade. 
 Russia's new threat to withhold tax revenues from the union's government is, in effect, a declaration of economic independence. 
 A violent struggle for economic and political control cannot be ruled out. 
 Another horror in its own right &mdash; but one which would also have wider economic implications. 
 Stockmarkets fell before Christmas on news of Edward Shevardnadze's resignation as foreign minister. 
 A bloodily turbulent Soviet Union would cast an economic shadow over Germany especially, but would damage business and consumer confidence more widely, at a time when it might already be extremely fragile. 
 Confidence is hard to measure, so worries about it are easy to dismiss &mdash; but when it goes you can generally tell by counting the dole queues. 
 Even without these dramas in the Gulf and the Soviet Union, America would be facing big economic risks in 1991. 
 The collapse of its junk-bond market and the fiasco of its thrifts have drawn attention to broader worries about the soundness of its financial system. 
 By historical standards, companies and consumers look badly over-borrowed and ill-prepared for a downturn. 
 The banks themselves are under stress, and so are the public institutions that would have to deal with any banking breakdown. 
 The Federal Reserve is struggling to allay fears of a &bquo;credit crunch&equo; &mdash; when banks are reluctant to lend except to the most creditworthy borrowers. 
 That is a monetary tightening of the most threatening sort, because central banks can do little about it. 
 They may lower interest rates, which increases the latent demand for credit. 
 But they must still rely on the banks satisfying that demand by lending more &mdash; and the banks may not oblige. 
 Another reminder of the 1930s is the recent breakdown of trade talks. 
 Exports are one way for America to soften the impact of sluggish demand at home; the undervalued dollar makes it all the easier, in effect, to import some vitality from Germany and Japan. 
 So this is an odd time to let the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade wither, or to be thinking of dismantling the post-1945 multilateral trading system in favour of a slide to managed trade and protection. 
 Of all the risks that face the world economy over the next few months, the most easily avoidable is this threat of trade war. 
 The European Community and America need to resume the GATT talks at once, patch up their quarrel over farm trade, and conclude the agreements on services and other issues that had seemed within reach when the talks were suspended. 
 Then, equally important, George Bush must sell that deal to Congress with far more enthusiasm than his officials have lately shown for the multilateral approach to trade reform. 
 For the rest, the best advice for economic policy-makers is to recall two principles of sound central banking &mdash; one forgotten in the 1930s and the other in the 1970s. 
 Stand ready to provide liquidity to a banking system in distress, but take care not to accommodate, with an increase in the money supply, an inflationary shock that hits the economy as a whole. 
 Easier to say than do? 
 Obviously. 
 That is why a third principle will also count for a lot in 1991. 
 Be lucky. 
 LEADERS 
 Towards the next Rushdie 
 Free speech has lost, and should not have done 
 THE cracking of Salman Rushdie is the saddest outcome of his two years in hiding: an apparently forced recantation, and nothing to show for it. 
 Mr Rushdie has agreed that there should be no paperback version of &bquo;The Satanic Verses&equo; and no more translations into foreign languages &bquo;while any risk of further offence exists&equo;. 
 But because he has not disowned his book, himself applying the match and hoisting it aloft on a stick, his gestures have done him no good. 
 Britain's Muslim leaders dismiss them. 
 The ayatollahs' death sentence stands. 
 Genuine conversions have sometimes been forced; St Paul's was hardly gentle. 
 Mr Rushdie's recommitment to the Islam of his birth leaves more room for doubt. 
 In all his writings from hiding he had increasingly found a brave and defiant secular voice: one that recognised a &bquo;God-shaped hole&equo; in life, but did not doubt that it could be filled by art, literature and imagination. 
 Imaginative writing, sacred in itself, could hold its own beside any religion. 
 It is a long way from that to his limp affirmation of the central tenets of Islam. 
 Before he cracked, Mr Rushdie had stumbled on a truth: that if free speech and free writing are to be defended in an age of increasing religious fervour, they must be defended with a zealot's passion. 
 Laws on slander and incitement aside, freedom of expression must be safeguarded as fiercely as is the honour of the Prophet by those Mr Rushdie has offended; pick at it, or suggest compromises, and the whole principle is threatened. 
 Mr Rushdie's opponents understand that. 
 Those who should have been his supporters never did. 
 The British government gave him protection, but backed the principle of free speech only as vigorously as was diplomatically comfortable. 
 Other western democracies did no better. 
 His publishers fell into panic, most bookshops caved in. 
 Everyone pleaded for compromise. 
 Yet religious belief has something to teach the rational secular world; some principles should be defended without recourse to a blurry halfway house. 
 The law should be the answer. 
 When the next Rushdie has his book put to the torch, incitement to violence over a book, whether for or against it, should be treated as a criminal offence. 
 Incitement to murder, by people living nominally under a country's law, should automatically lead to arrest. 
 Western governments should be prepared to protect not only writers, but publishers and bookshops; and Britain should get rid of its own unnecessary curbs on free speech, the laws against blaspheming Christianity. 
 A free-speech amendment to a bill of rights has had a certain success that might be emulated. 
 Like religious practice, the practice of free speech is often neither grand nor edifying. 
 It can turn the stomach. 
 Many who professed to revere the principle found it hard to like the example they were faced with in Mr Rushdie's case: the book unreadable and the writer a pain in the neck. 
 The next book may also be unreadable, and its author prickly, but maybe not: it could be a great work of literature, or politics, or science &mdash; or religion. 
 If free speech is to mean anything as a principle upon which democracy is based, it must be invoked regardless. 
 Wholeheartedly, this time, not piecemeal; and without giving up.  
 The caftan currency 
 How to get British interest rates down &mdash; and how not to 
 IT HAS been all too typically British. 
 A remedy for economic ills is suggested. 
 Its merits are exaggerated, its difficulties downplayed. 
 Belatedly, the government adopts the remedy. 
 Almost at once, those who had most favoured the change start squealing. 
 It hurts, you see. 
 Thus has been the pattern with sterling's entry into the exchange-rate mechanism of the European Monetary System. 
 The loudest complaints are coming from those who think that, through the use of too-high interest rates, the pound is being kept too high. 
 The Confederation of British Industry wants lower interest rates. 
 So does the Labour party. 
 A few Tory MPs echo the call in public; in private most do. 
 All these groans are based on confusion. 
 Worse, they are achieving the opposite of what they intend. 
 Because the economy is in recession, it is widely assumed that the government will and should cut interest rates. 
 That, after all, has been the stock response in previous slowdowns. 
 But the old rules have been changed by EMS membership, changed utterly. 
 Monetary policy is now geared to the exchange rate, not to domestic demand. 
 Interest rates will be cut only if sterling is persistently strong within the EMS. 
 Since it has been weak for the past two months, calling for cheaper money is as irrelevant as wanting trees to blossom in an Arctic winter. 
 The conditions do not exist, period. 
 A premium for uncertainty 
 The CBI and Labour are not in power, so why does their confusion matter? 
 Because their complaints are delaying the interest-rate cut they so desire. 
 The mere fact that the British are debating the pound's place in the EMS is enough to worry holders of sterling: perhaps the debate will end with the pound being devalued. 
 To compensate for that possibility, sterling-holders need higher interest rates than they would if they believed the pound would never be devalued. 
 That is what happened with, eg, the French franc. 
 In the early 1980s, when the French government was periodically devaluing the franc within the EMS, French short-term interest rates were seven to eight percentage points higher than German ones. 
 Today, the difference is less than one point. 
 The gap has narrowed because the French have long since accepted EMS disciplines, and cheaper money (as well as lower inflation) is their prize. 
 That same prize will elude the British for as long as they yearn for it publicly. 
 Careless talk costs jobs. 
 Ah, say the critics, so you admit that interest rates are being kept damagingly high. 
 The honest response is, yes, that may well be the case. 
 Just as the recession of 1980&ndash;81 was made worse by holding rates up in pursuit of a money-supply target, so today's recession could be intensified by the pursuit of an exchange-rate target. 
 The damage can be limited not just by a vow of silence from the government's critics, but also by intelligent fiscal action from the government itself. 
 This last point is awkward, because recent Tory chancellors have denied that fiscal policy has a role to play in managing demand. 
 Yet full EMS membership should cause the new chancellor, Norman Lamont, to rethink. 
 He would surely agree that the right aim is to have nominal GDP growing at around 5% a year. 
 But, since monetary policy is now geared to the exchange rate, that 5% cannot be achieved by manipulating interest rates. 
 To steer demand, the government must use its own spending, taxing and borrowing. 
 This points to a big difference between now and ten years ago. 
 In the midst of recession, the 1981 budget deliberately tightened fiscal policy. 
 The Treasury calculated that this would allow interest rates to tumble, which would revive demand. 
 It was right. 
 Today, though, there is no easy trade-off between fiscal and monetary policy. 
 No matter how tight the budget, rates may not be able to fall if sterling stays weak. 
 Since nominal GDP growth is probably decelerating fast, the budget may need to be loose &mdash; which risks being misinterpreted by the headline-writers and the markets as the Tories going soft. 
 Mr Lamont needs to start explaining that, via his budget in March, he will be seeking to manage demand. 
 There is one other thing for the government to do. 
 As soon as possible it should narrow sterling's EMS band, from its current 6% on either side of the central rate to the 2.25% that is standard for other EMS members. 
 Those who complain about dear money and strong sterling would doubtless see this as an even worse regime. 
 To them, the pound is already in a straitjacket. 
 Actually, it is more like a caftan. 
 The 6% band does little to reassure holders of sterling that the currency is safe from devaluation. 
 In its short life the EMS pound has fallen from a peak of DM3.03 to as low as DM2.86. 
 The narrow band would reduce the scope for incidental devaluation. 
 It would also allow Mr Lamont to show he does not contemplate any deliberate devaluation of sterling. 
 Both those changes would help the cause of cheaper money. 
 Without them, the pound will remain the European oddball &mdash; floundering, argued over, and therefore unloved.  
 Don't ban the bomb tests 
 There are safer ways to a safer world 
 AFTER four decades of nuclear build-up, the 1990s began as a disarmer's dream come true. 
 Thousands of Europe's tanks and guns are trundling to the scrap heap. 
 Next month the superpowers are expected to agree to cut their long-range nuclear arsenals by a third. 
 Next week in New York talks begin on something even more ambitious: the conversion of the Partial Test-Ban Treaty (which bans nuclear testing in the atmosphere, in space and underwater) into a comprehensive test ban (ending underground testing too). 
 From Nevada to Kazakhstan, from Xinjiang to the South Pacific, a test ban would delight the protesting locals. 
 It would, say its boosters, do a lot more besides. 
 Halt the nuclear arms race, for one thing; stop the spread of nuclear weapons, for another. 
 Nice, if it were true. 
 Unfortunately, it isn't. 
 Enthusiasm for a total test ban is strongest among those who want no nuclear weapons at all. 
 Their old argument was that, by unilaterally renouncing nuclear weapons, the West could somehow avoid the dangers of the nuclear age. 
 It could not. 
 Nuclear technology cannot be uninvented. 
 Deterrence &mdash; the knowledge that a strike by one side would provoke a devastating retaliatory strike by the other &mdash; was and still is the surest way to keep the peace in a dangerous world. 
 Cuts in the numbers of nuclear weapons have come because of carefully negotiated agreements that the superpowers have confidence in. 
 There can be more and deeper cuts. 
 But stability is the real problem, not numbers. 
 A test ban would destabilise the nuclear balance because neither side could be sure what effect it was having on the other. 
 Neither would a test ban stop the spread of nuclear weapons. 
 There is a mistaken notion that if the five declared nuclear powers (America, the Soviet Union, Britain, France and China) gave up testing weapons, other countries now trying to acquire them would stop. 
 Of the seven or eight countries that secretly have nuclear weapons, or are close to having them, only one (India) started building a bomb because it was worried about one of the big five (China). 
 The rest want the bomb because it is the biggest bang that money can buy and because they mistrust their neighbours. 
 Only three are suspected of having conducted a test. 
 Step by step 
 It is true that, without a test, a country like Iraq could not be sure that its bomb would go off. 
 But neither could its enemies be sure that it wouldn't. 
 Last year Mexico blocked agreement to tighten up the Nuclear Non-Proliferation Treaty, which polices world trade in nuclear fuel, because others refused to commit themselves to a test ban. 
 That was a pity. 
 A test ban is the least of the proliferators' worries. 
 So what is the next step towards reducing nuclear danger? 
 Nuclear disarmers are right in saying that a test ban would stop weapons builders trying out new and fancier designs. 
 But an end to new designs would also bring an end to more reliable and safer weapons. 
 And since those countries that have nuclear weapons are not disposed to get rid of them, some testing is needed to make sure that those they keep still work. 
 Yet, as military budgets come under increasing pressure and the pace of weapons development slows, the number of tests each year is declining. 
 A cue, perhaps, to talk about fixing a lowish number by treaty. 
 Nuclear tests are now limited to 150 kilotons. 
 There is nothing sacrosanct about the size of that bang. 
 Size is a trade-off between cleanness and accuracy: the lower the limits, the lower the risk of fall-out, but the greater the uncertainty that the test can accurately predict what a bigger explosion would do. 
 And although fall-out from tests has declined dramatically in recent years, a bit more uncertainty about predictions is a price worth paying in order win an agreement setting lower limits. 
 Any explosion of around 20 kilotons or more is fairly straightforward to check on. 
 Go much below that and the monitoring problems are vastly complicated by natural upsets, like earthquakes and even man-made chemical explosions (which would also make a comprehensive test ban pretty difficult to be sure of). 
 One advantage of this approach is that it allows time to test the technologies that build the confidence on which sensible arms control rests. 
 The other is that it makes it easier to encourage prickly China and France to join in. 
 To get down even to this level among the nuclear five, some pretty intrusive inspection (including challenges on site) would be needed. 
 To be confident that the technology of evasion was not outstripping the technology of verification, better radiation monitoring and satellite inspection would be needed. 
 Getting agreement to all of this among five powers would be hard enough. 
 Doing it worldwide would be a nightmare. 
 In a nuclear world the sensible aim is a less fragile, more stable nuclear balance at the lowest level of armaments on all sides. 
 That could in future go hand in hand with fewer, and smaller, nuclear tests.  
 The multi-storey car perk 
 Britain should kick the company-car habit 
 OH BLISS! 
 Oh poop-poop! 
 Oh my! 
 Oh my!&equo; 
 This cry, uttered in 1908 by a property magnate called Toad, marked the beginnings of the British disease of autophilia &mdash; an uncontrollable obsession with the motor car. 
 It is now epidemic. 
 Any foreign manager arriving in Britain is amazed to find that the permutations of Ford Sierra, Vauxhall Cavalier and the like that he must offer his staff now define the pecking order in British society. 
 He ignores them at his peril. 
 The epidemic took hold during the 1970s, when high rates of income tax and an attempt by successive governments to control pay made the company-owned car a good way of rewarding people surreptitiously. 
 Today over half the new cars registered in Britain each year are bought by employers, and 2m of Britain's income-tax payers admit to the Inland Revenue that they have a company car. 
 This is a pattern of car ownership without parallel in the world. 
 The company car is such a feature of modern British business that in teaching the noble art of firing people, the London Business School reminds trainee firers to demand the car keys from a dismissed employee promptly &mdash; not because these are today's equivalent of Dreyfus's epaulettes (which they are), but because the car, stuck immovably in the company car-park, may depress other executives. 
 Like that other British obsession, houses, the disease is sponsored by the state. 
 The Conservative government has made a half-hearted attempt to tax company cars &mdash; half-hearted because it fears upsetting natural Tory voters. 
 Despite rising ten-fold over the past decade, the tax on company cars is still just a fraction of the true value of the perk (see page 27). 
 But the taxman's generosity is only part of the problem: more pernicious is the way he imputes a set amount of taxable income according to the size of a car's engine. 
 As the tax burden is fixed, an employee offered a company car opts for the most potent and gadget-laden model, at a given engine-capacity, that his status entitles him to. 
 The average level of equipment of new cars sold in Britain is the highest in Europe. 
 Millions of British motorists are driving cars more plush than they would ever choose to own were they handed the extra money and told to spend it themselves. 
 There is mounting suspicion, too, that Britain's market in cars, car parts and servicing has been poisoned by this system. 
 Private car-owners have become second-class citizens. 
 They are offered smaller discounts than the purchasing moguls of companies, and are viewed with distaste in garages because of their tendency to quibble over bills or wonder whether they really need new tyres. 
 The company-car phenomenon is part of the reason why prices in the British car business stay stubbornly above those on the continent. 
 The parallel is with health insurance in America, where companies insure their staff &mdash; and medical bills are out of control. 
 The British habit is hard to break because cars are central to much of modern business. 
 It is difficult to draw a line between a company car that is a pure perk and one used constantly on the job by a salesman or service engineer. 
 Nor is there any reason why the state should tell firms how to attract and keep good staff in a country where qualified labour can be hard to find. 
 If company cars, company fitted-kitchens or company hi-fi seem to do the trick, sad but fine. 
 Devilish-sounding fixes, such as a rule that all company cars must carry the corporate logo in letters two feet high, would involve more government snooping than the problem is worth. 
 Don't snoop, but don't subsidise 
 What the state can and should do is make sure that tax does not distort the choices involved. 
 The present crude banding system on cars is a distortion and should be scrapped. 
 The taxman ought to require companies to reveal at the end of each tax year how much each company car insured for private use has cost them in depreciation, insurance, servicing and fuel. 
 It should then tax all of that as personal income, less the proportion of the car's annual mileage demonstrably clocked up on company business &mdash; commuting excluded. 
 The British sales rep might do even better out of this system than the current one &mdash; and grandees would do worse. 
 But whatever the proportion agreed with the taxman, the cost of superfluous luxury, of expensive servicing and of trading-in a fully-depreciated old faithful for a new machine would once again mean something to the wallet of Mr Toad's great-grandson. 
 &bquo;Oh despair! 
 Oh misery! 
 Oh poop-poop!&equo;  
 Linking the unlinkable 
 Israel won't and shouldn't pay for the freedom of Kuwait 
 GEORGE BUSH and Saddam Hussein may not scare each other, but they are terrifying just about everybody else. 
 Unless Iraq's dictator sounds the retreat in the next few days, he will soon be unable to meet the January 15th deadline set by the United Nations for the complete removal of his army from Kuwait. 
 Mr Bush will then have the UN's authority for war. 
 Because the American-Iraqi meetings that were supposed to offer a last chance for peace may not happen, nervous intermediaries, notably the European Community, are striving to keep diplomacy alive. 
 Diplomacy is better than war. 
 If another lot of talks can make Iraq obey the demands of the UN Security Council, then the chance to avoid further bloodshed should be gratefully seized. 
 But it is five months since Mr Hussein swallowed his neighbour and was instructed by the Security Council to disgorge it. 
 He has had ample time to understand what the world wants him to do. 
 That is why, no matter what the last-minute mediators may say, there is a danger that their aim will be interpreted not as an effort to secure Mr Hussein's compliance with demands that have somehow escaped his attention, but as an attempt to offer him an easy way out. 
 The beguiling way out is &bquo;linkage&equo; &mdash; Saddamspeak for disguising defeat in Kuwait as victory in Palestine. 
 It is hard to compromise on the need for Iraq to leave the whole of Kuwait: the Security Council has insisted, in stark black and white, that the withdrawal has to be complete and unconditional. 
 This demand has been reaffirmed, too many times to disown, by the United States, the Soviet Union and the European Community. 
 Linkage, though, is a vaguer notion, the sort of thing diplomats can really sink their gums into. 
 The whole world (except a few hardliners) would welcome a breakthrough in the Arab-Israeli conflict. 
 If part of the credit for a breakthrough could be claimed by Mr Hussein, and so induce him to pull his army out of Kuwait, why not solve two problems in a single bloodless stroke? 
 It sounds impossibly neat, and it is. 
 Linkage may get Mr Hussein out of Kuwait, but recovering Kuwait, though welcome in itself, is only part of what the world needs to achieve in the Gulf. 
 It has also to keep the Gulf safe in the future, and protect the world's access to oil. 
 That means keeping the chief local predator at bay. 
 If the chief local predator leaves Kuwait unbloody and unbowed, his over-mighty war machine will continue to menace his neighbours. 
 They can form alliances to contain him &mdash; buttressed, perhaps, by a residual force of Americans. 
 But it would be desperately hard, in the Arab world, to stand up to a man who could portray himself as a (literally) world-defying champion of Palestinian rights. 
 By definition, that is exactly what Mr Hussein would look like if linkage worked. 
 Clever western diplomacy could try to make him appear less heroic, by keeping the linkage vague, but then &mdash; unless he has belatedly realised the hopelessness of his position &mdash; he would see no benefit in it. 
 Having made Kuwait his 19th province and sworn never to leave it, he needs ringing international declarations on Palestine, not just hints and mumbles, to blot out the shame of retreat. 
 Indeed, the vaguer the linkage, the greater would be his need, after withdrawal, to show that he had achieved something real. 
 So linkage would not only turn Saddam into the colossus of the Gulf. 
 It could also tie his status as colossus to his subsequent performance in the Arab confrontation with Israel. 
 Many Arabs accuse the West of double standards in the Middle East. 
 Iraq is told to obey Security Council Resolution 660 and leave Kuwait at the point of American guns. 
 Israel stays unpunished in the West Bank, Gaza and the Golan Heights nearly 23 years after Resolution 242 called on it to get out. 
 It sounds unfair &mdash; to a visitor just arrived from Mars. 
 A Martian who had read the resolutions would know better. 
 Iraq's invasion of Kuwait was simple theft, for which Resolution 660 sets out a simple remedy: complete withdrawal, without conditions. 
 Israel's occupation arose from a pre-emptive war against neighbours who had massed on its borders and wanted it to disappear. 
 That is why Resolution 242 contains no condemnation of Israel. 
 It calls instead for a negotiated settlement based on two principles. 
 One is Israeli withdrawal from &bquo;territories &lsqb;not, deliberately, the  territories&rsqb; occupied in the recent conflict&equo;. 
 The other principle is the right of every state in the area to live in peace within secure and recognised borders. 
 Both sides are to blame for failing to put this land-for-peace formula into practice. 
 So are America and the Soviet Union, to the extent that they wasted too much energy signing up local partners for the cold war instead of organising a local peace. 
 But it is no surprise that one of the men who has done least to promote peace is Mr Hussein. 
 Lacking a land border with the Jewish state, he has little incentive to end the conflict with Israel and much to gain by posing, from a safe distance, as its uncompromising foe. 
 Palestine next 
 It would be a tragic error to buy this man out of Kuwait by awarding him the starring role in Arab dealings with Israel. 
 It is not impossible, if he fails in the Gulf, to make progress on Palestine, where the Arab uprising of the past three years has made it clear that Israel can no longer maintain a decent stewardship of the occupied territories. 
 The ending of the cold war has made Mr Bush's administration far readier than its predecessors to shake Israel's Likud government out of its self-destructive policy of permanent occupation. 
 The Palestine Liberation Organisation, until its recent flirtation with Saddamery, had seemed genuinely willing to make peace with Israel in exchange for a Palestine in the West Bank and Gaza. 
 This is a rare, potentially fruitful, combination of pressures and opportunities. 
 But Israel, a Kuwait-sized country, will make no concessions to an Arab world led by a victorious Saddam Hussein. 
 And the world, if it flunks its own test in the Gulf, will have no right to ask it to.  
 Murdoch on the brink 
 News Corporation may well survive, but imitators are unlikely to 
 FICTION has done its best to depict the megalomania of the media industry, throwing up characters like Lord Copper, Citizen Kane and Lord Gnome. 
 But the biographies of real moguls are often more extraordinary &mdash; the lives of Lord Northcliffe, Lord Beaverbrook, Bill Paley, Louis B. Mayer and William Hearst were mini-series in their own right. 
 By these extravagant standards, their natural successor, Rupert Murdoch, whose News Corporation owns a host of British and Australian papers, as well as Harper Collins and 20th Century Fox, seems rather boring. 
 Unlike other newspaper barons, he has no desire to see his face on the front of his newspapers; unlike other Hollywood moguls, he does not make the pages of the National Enquirer. 
 Instead, all Mr Murdoch's extravagance has gone into business. 
 He has built an empire through a series of gambles that often succeeded because rivals at first nearly died laughing &mdash; buying the Sydney Daily Mirror, starting the Australian, moving his British papers out of Fleet Street, launching the Fox television network. 
 In the 1980s he became the industry's pied piper, leading the way to the international conglomerate, crossing frontiers and combining different media. 
 However, Mr Murdoch has come dangerously close to an edge over which other debt-happy Australian entrepreneurs have already tumbled. 
 To place his bets he took on &dollar;8 billion in debt &mdash; which, because of dearer money and recession, he can no longer service. 
 News Corp is trying to persuade its 150 banks to agree to reschedule that debt with higher interest charges but later repayments. 
 There is talk of asset sales worth &dollar;2 billion, spread over three years. 
 It will be tough, but the odds are on Mr Murdoch coming through. 
 What can other businessmen learn from his predicament? 
 Mr Murdoch made two bad moves. 
 He paid &dollar;2.8 billion &mdash; &dollar;1 billion too much &mdash; for Triangle, an American publisher; and his latest gamble, satellite television in Britain, is taking longer to come good than he hoped. 
 Yet blaming Mr Murdoch's problems on two deals is like saying that the only sin of David Gower, England's most gifted cricketer, is flashing at balls outside the off-stump. 
 Mr Murdoch, like Mr Gower, has a way of playing that was bound to run into trouble. 
 Mr Murdoch's vice is debt. 
 He prefers to borrow rather than raise outside equity capital and thus dilute control. 
 Nothing wrong with that, in principle: a company that depended more on equity might not have the nerve to do things like founding Fox Television. 
 And many of the world's most stable firms are heavily in debt. 
 But their source of stability is usually a close link to a main bank which, especially in Germany and Japan, monitors management and, in effect, underwrites other banks' loans. 
 Careful as he is to cultivate bankers, Mr Murdoch borrows to avoid being controlled. 
 That gives him the space to make long-term bets, but also deprives him of advice against short-sightedness: borrowing sums that he can service only so long as the good times roll. 
 In need of the Hanson touch 
 Mr Murdoch's accounting does not help. 
 Australia's generous rules allow him to revalue intangible assets like newspaper mastheads, without saying specifically how much each asset is worth. 
 To get anywhere near an understanding of News Corporation's accounts, you usually have to wait for the figures it is obliged to file with America's Securities and Exchange Commission. 
 Even then, much mystery remains. 
 When times are good, ever-optimistic bankers still lend; in hard times, mysterious accounts add to creditors' suspicions. 
 These are general lessons. 
 What of the particular ones in the media? 
 Other conglomerates, particularly those looking for synergy, should be depressed by their mentor's plight. 
 There is no evidence that his empire makes sense &mdash; beyond engaging his own considerable talents. 
 The best parts run as separate units: the Fox network, for instance, shows only a handful of 20th Century Fox shows. 
 News Corp may well be worth more in pieces than together. 
 If Mr Murdoch had copied new conglomerates, like Britain's Hanson &mdash; which sells its successful turnarounds if a high bid comes along &mdash; he would be safe. 
 In other words, he should have treated the media business as being just like any other. 
 Failure to do that will always put a limit on even the most ambitious media barons.  
 BOOKS AND ARTS 
 Chinese politics 
 Understanding Mr Deng 
 DENG XIAOPING. 
 By David Goodman. 
 Sphere Books; 172 pages; &pound;4.99 
 THE story of Deng Xiaoping is the story of China's 20th-century revolutions. 
 His predecessor as leader of China's billion people, Mao Zedong, may have been the maker of many of those revolutions, but Mr Deng was the one who often cleaned up the debris and put China back on its feet. 
 More important, Mr Deng gave China a new revolutionary vision in the decade of reform from 1978; and, despite the fact that he now has no official position, he still holds the fate of China in his hands. 
 Although Mao has been the subject of countless biographies, David Goodman has written the first fitting biography of Mr Deng. 
 He covers his conversion from croissants to communism while in France in the 1920s, but reserves the bulk of his pithy and precise political biography for the events since 1949. 
 The unifying theme is that Mr Deng shaped an alternative political vision to Mao, in large part because he was in charge of a very different area during the Chinese civil war of the 1930s and 1940s. 
 While Mao controlled barely 1m people in Yan'an, Mr Deng had five times that number in Taihang, a far more economically successful region. 
 Mr Deng's experience in Taihang, as opposed to Mao's in Yan'an, shaped at least three distinctive features of his political strategy. 
 First, Mr Deng was more committed to the power of the Communist Party and to party discipline, although he also understood that as long as basic stability and prosperity were ensured, the party should guide but not govern. 
 Second, Mr Deng was less an idealist than a sensible moderniser and nationalist. 
 He understood far better than Mao that socialism had to be built gradually and on the basis of &bquo;capitalist production&equo;. 
 In demonstrating this point, Mr Goodman destroys the all-too-common misperception of Mr Deng as a pragmatist; the socialist vision is unwavering. 
 The Taihang experience is also used by Mr Goodman to explain one poorly understood basis of Mr Deng's power: his vast personal networks. 
 Indeed, as many of China's top leaders after 1949 worked in the Taihang region as in Yan'an. 
 By virtue of his connections, Mr Deng was able to re-emerge twice from political disgrace and is now able to rule China without formal power. 
 But service with Mr Deng in Taihang does not necessarily provide protection from purge; it did not help Zhao Ziyang, the former prime minister and party leader. 
 Mr Zhao was one prominent victim of the upheavals of 1989; the other was Mr Deng's reputation. 
 Yet as the &bquo;butcher of Beijing&equo; who called in the troops to restore order, Mr Deng was merely remaining true to his political vision and concern for party power. 
 Historians are fickle, and the eternally optimistic Mr Deng might take comfort from the fact that Mao's reputation survived the deaths of millions.  
 William Casey 
 Millionaire and spymaster 
 CASEY. 
 By Joseph Persico. 
 Viking; 601 pages; &dollar;24.95 
 IF RAGS to riches is still the American dream, William Casey lived his own version of it. 
 He did not quite begin in rags; he was the great-grandson of an Irish immigrant to New York, where his father worked in the cleaning department of the borough of Queens. 
 He went to a Jesuit school, served as an altar boy (as did his future enemies the Snowman and the Falcon, both now doing time for espionage against the United States), and read law at Fordham. 
 He began law practice, which was interrupted by the second world war. 
 In that war &mdash; as a young  lieutenant , junior grade, in the Navy &mdash; Casey found himself in charge of the intelligence operations in north-west Europe of the Office of Strategic Services; and spy-running, like venture capitalism, was in his blood from then on. 
 He made a large personal fortune, partly from fees, partly from shrewd investments. 
 His private life centred on a happy marriage, &bquo;steady as an ocean liner&equo; in his biographer's phrase, to a childhood friend; it produced one daughter. 
 Not for him the acrobatics that fiction attributes to the American rich. 
  Latish  in his life he decided to go into politics, but his chances seemed slight. 
 He was a large, shambling man, with a strong New York accent and a tendency to slur his speech; his powers as an orator were slim, and his prose style was unadorned. 
 As he once put it wryly to a friend, &bquo;the guys who have the brains can't get elected, and the guys who get elected don't always have the brains&equo;. 
 He came into politics sideways, as campaign manager for his friend Ronald Reagan; and his reward was an unprecedented appointment to the directorship of the CIA combined with a seat in the cabinet. 
 Between Casey and the news media there was a profound mutual distrust, equalled only by the mistrust between him and the intelligence committees of Congress. 
 As he put it, &bquo;I have to deal with guys on those committees who couldn't get a security clearance for a job in a post office&equo;. 
 He thought Congress irretrievably leaky; Congress thought him irretrievably unreliable. 
 He believed nothing should stand in the way of the security of the United States, and was less choosy than Congress about what means he took to preserve it. 
 He was also aware that he was clever, and rather enjoyed trying to bamboozle journalists who thought they might score off him. 
 Joseph Persico, in a telling biography based on a full understanding both of the man and of the processes through which he was trying to work, makes hay of Bob Woodward's pretensions to understand either, and displays Casey as a patriot &mdash; for good, bad and both together.  
 Eastern Europe's writers 
 Heroes? 
 What heroes? 
 BREATHING UNDER WATER AND OTHER EUROPEAN ESSAYS. 
 By Stanislaw Baranczak. 
 Harvard University Press; 258 pages; &dollar;22.50 and &pound;17.95 
 PERVERSE as it sounds, western writers and intellectuals have often looked on the persecution of their East European counterparts with something like longing. 
 While literature in the West concerns itself with little more than sex and other people's books, there on the farther shore writers matter. 
 They suffer; and they wrestle with the big themes of good and evil, heroism and betrayal, man and God. 
 True enough. 
 But, as Stanislaw Baranczak points out in his introduction to this collection of unfailingly graceful, learned and thoughtful essays, &bquo;the simplest definition of a dissident writer is a writer who wants to practise his profession in a normal way&equo;. 
 The desire for a normal life of love, work and friendship runs through these essays, cutting against the grain of the totalitarian state. 
 Mr Baranczak himself left Poland several years ago and now teaches literature at Harvard. 
 Although writers and writing are the subjects of most of these essays, the themes they present are essential to understanding both the extraordinary political changes that have swept through Eastern Europe, and the human condition under communism. 
 The common tenor of these writers and their works is resolutely anti-heroic. 
 Mr Baranczak finds in them a galaxy of individualists, an anti-universe to the communist state. 
 After all, he writes, &bquo;it was the revolution itself&hellip; that first exempted the individual from moral responsibility.&equo; 
 Thus Witold Gombrowicz's apparently anti-political call for &bquo;an elusive man who is a play of contradictions&equo; is really a fierce rebuke to the totalitarian preference for deathly form over vital chaos; and the absurdist satire on display in Yuz Aleshkovsky's &bquo;Kangaroo&equo;, whose protagonist eventually comes to believe the KGB's charge that he sodomised a marsupial in the Moscow Zoo &bquo;on a night between July 14th 1789, and January 9th 1905&equo; (note the dates), is &bquo;the only way for a free mind to cope&hellip; an abuse of official language that will overpower it and thus defeat it.&equo; 
 These writers stubbornly rebel against all straitjackets, even those offered with the best intentions. 
 Czeslaw Milosz, a great poet and the author of one of the classics of anti-totalitarian literature, &bquo;The Captive Mind&equo;, openly rebels at the heroic image in which he and his peers are cast by their western admirers. 
 &bquo;Perhaps,&equo; he has written, &bquo;some western writers are longing for subjects provided by violent historical change, but I can assure &lsqb;them&dollar; that we, ie, natives of hazy Eastern regions, perceive history as a curse and prefer to restore to literature its autonomy, dignity and independence from social pressures.&equo; 
 To Mr Milosz, literature's dignity resides not in politics but in a frankly metaphysical attempt to bridge awe and horror, to name the sorrow of mankind. 
 Whether such brave ideas can thrive in the rough tide of freedom alongside economic want and nationalist fervour remains to be seen. 
 But from these men and women there is much to be learnt.  
 The museum at Auschwitz 
 Preserving horror 
 AUSCHWITZ AND BIRKENAU 
 AS A symbol of Nazi war crimes, the Auschwitz concentration camp automatically inspires violent criticism and opinions. 
 But the site itself, now a museum and memorial in southern Poland, has had an equally stormy history. 
 In the past, Jewish, gypsy and other groups have complained about the museum exhibitions and disputed research into the camp's history; they have called the Polish curators biased. 
 An international commission composed of Poles, Jews, gypsies and others, including several Auschwitz survivors, has now been created to sort matters out. 
 The task will not be easy. 
 The Auschwitz museum was set up in 1955, when most visitors were Poles with immediate memories of Nazi occupation. 
 Now most of the camp's 700,000 yearly visitors, coming from Israel, Germany, America and elsewhere, think of the second world war as the distant past. 
 Curators think the exhibits should no longer deal with the camp alone, but should describe the historical circumstances: occupied Poland, Nazi Germany, the Drang Nach Osten and the Final Solution. 
 How did people live in the camps, how did some survive, how did some defend themselves? 
 Simply to show photographs of inmates, and to display the grisly collections of 3,500 suitcases, 29,000 toothbrushes and yards of human hair is no longer enough. 
 At the same time, exhibits must be low-key enough not to distract visitors from their own thoughts: Auschwitz is also a cemetery. 
 Most of the museum's present exhibits date from the era of Polish Stalinism, when communist historiographers called the Holocaust the &bquo;culmination of capitalism&equo; rather than a crime against all humanity, and a special crime against the Jews. 
 Some of the exhibits at the camp, particularly the small national exhibits designed by former communist countries, tend to reflect this view, emphasising communist resistance movements to Hitler, for example, over others. 
 Jewish groups and Jewish visitors to the camp find such omissions offensive. 
 Curators feel that much harm has been done by the museum's failure to articulate two indisputable facts. 
 Auschwitz was first created to liquidate the Polish intelligentsia, 270,000 of whom died there. 
 Later in the war, Auschwitz, together with the much larger Birkenau, was dedicated to the mass murder of Jews. 
 The failure of both Poles and Jews to understand that the camp is also a symbol of martyrdom for the other group has led to many controversies, most recently over the convent of Carmelite nuns which borders the camp. 
 (The story of that dispute is excellently told by Wladyslaw Bartoszewski in &bquo;The Convent at Auschwitz&equo;, published by Bowerdean Press.) 
 Failures of understanding aside, the history of the camp is still being revised, and each revision is painful. 
 Historians recently decided to lower the estimated number of Auschwitz victims, from 4m &mdash; a figure chosen by Soviet soldiers who liberated the camp in 1945 &mdash; to between 1m and 2m, an estimate based on transport documents which have only recently come to light. 
 Changing this number also meant changing the inscriptions on some of the camps' memorial plaques; some Jewish groups did not like the wording of the new inscriptions. 
 After several sessions the international commission resolved the problem. 
 Others are bound to arise; not least because, as the Soviet Union cracks apart, documents and material taken there after the war may drift back into the hands of historians.  
 In Gaudi's shadow 
 BARCELONA 
 A MILD, retiring man, Josep Maria Subirachs lives and works in a modest studio on the 108-year-old building site of Barcelona's Sagrada Familia cathedral. 
 The cathedral's architect, Antonio Gaudi, did the same until his death in 1926. 
 Yet Mr Subirachs's sculptures for the cathedral have placed him at the centre of a storm. 
 For this building, in which everything is done in the grandest and strangest way, Mr Subirachs is making 75 pieces that trace the Passion of Christ. 
 High up on the west face, his Christ defies the law of gravity. 
 The cross projects horizontally from the facade instead of rising vertically against it, so that the long emaciated body curves out at 90 degrees over the parvis, &bquo;as if about to plunge down on us,&equo; to quote the sculptor. 
 He has given one apostle Gaudi's face, and his robot-like Roman soldiers are copies of chimney-pots the architect designed. 
 Overall, however, his work is in austere counterpoint to Gaudi's luxuriant stone tableau of the Nativity on the cathedral's east face. 
 Mr Subirachs's angular and intense figures are both full of contemporary mal de vivre and reminiscent of Catalan Romanesque art. 
 Even so, an anti-Subirachs cabal has sprung up, calling for his work at the Sagrada Familia to be stopped for artistic and ideological reasons. 
 The artistic reason is that he is old-hat; Catalans prefer to be known for the airy constructions that are going up for the Olympic Games. 
 The ideological reason is that Mr Subirachs's works take further towards completion a cathedral Gaudi conceived as a bulwark against subversive new dogmas such as Marxism and anarchism. 
 One of Gaudi's sculptures, after all, shows an anarchist about to toss a grenade at a statue of the Virgin Mary. 
 Anti-clerical Catalans have long favoured leaving the Sagrada Familia as it is and landscaping the site. 
 Yet the anti-Subirachs lobby also includes Catholic traditionalists who have been so shocked by his naked Christ that they hold monthly prayer vigils. 
 The Socialist mayor of Barcelona, Mr Pasqual Maragall, refuses to take sides. 
 His grandfather, a respected poet, was a friend of Gaudi, whose nascent cathedral he compared to &bquo;a marvellous, budding flower&equo;; his uncle is a member of the Foundation that finances the building of the cathedral from donations and the sale of tickets to visitors. 
 Only restorations of Gaudi's own work are officially sponsored; but as long as people keep on giving, Mr Subirachs can keep working. 
 If he outwits his critics, he reckons his project might be finished by 2005.  
 Close, but no nightingale 
 THE CONQUEST OF PARADISE: CHRISTOPHER COLUMBUS AND THE COLUMBIAN LEGACY. 
 By Kirkpatrick Sale. 
 Knopf; 453 pages; &dollar;24.95. 
 To be published in England by John Curtis 
 ON MAY 1st 1893 President Grover Cleveland gave a speech to 300,000 people on a stretch of parkland beside Lake Michigan. 
 At noon, he pressed a gold and ivory button and the fun began: 
 At one and the same instant the audience burst into a thundering shout; the orchestra pealed forth the strains of the Hallelujah Chorus; the wheels of the great Ellis engine in Machinery Hall commenced to revolve; the electric fountains in the lagoon threw their torrents towards the sky; a flood of water gushed from the McMonnies Lake and rolled back again into the basin; the thunder of artillery came from the vessels in the lake; the chimes in Manufacturers Hall and on the German building rang out a merry peal, and overhead, the flags at the top of the poles in front of the platform fell apart and revealed the gilded models of the ships in which Columbus first sailed to American shores. 
 That contemporary account did not think to mention the 160 exhibition buildings connected by canals which were plied by gondolas and steam boats. 
 The  quatrocentennial  Columbus exhibition cost a staggering &dollar;30m: it drew more visitors than any previous event in history. 
 In 1893 America was ready to see Columbus as the great discoverer, the man who laid the foundations for a nation of bold entrepreneurs. 
 He had gone in search of gold and glory and they thought the better of him for it; even the composer of the &bquo;New World Symphony&equo; was careful to sound the horns of triumph. 
 (Dvorak devotees can count their blessings for his stubborn spirit; the composer's American patron had requested an opera about Hiawatha for the great occasion.) 
 How much has been learnt since then? 
 What is lined up for the quincentennial in 1992? 
 Not much, it seems. 
 &dollar;4m will be going into the Columbian world fair at Seville; the Dominican Republic is hoping to build a 390-foot lighthouse for &dollar;10m; 12 full-size replica ships will be setting sail for America (presumably from their commissioning countries), and the fifth Genovese Columbian conference will be exhibiting every plant of the New World. 
 This last project is an embarrassingly inappropriate tribute to a man who could not identify any plants, trees or birds that he saw on his journeys except by such vapid statements as &bquo;big and little birds of all sorts&equo;, &bquo;trees very green&equo;, and &bquo;many trees very different from ours.&equo; 
 When Columbus spotted the crop that was to become the chief source of Virginia's prosperity, tobacco, he dismissed it as a worthless weed; he did, on the other hand, find time to remark on the beauty of the nightingales in a country where none exists. 
 Columbus, more properly Admiral Cristobal Colon, is shown in Kirkpatrick Sale's forceful and wide-ranging book as a typical 15th-century profiteer. 
 He was not courageous. 
 He was frequently deceitful, as in his deliberate misrepresentations to his crew of the speed of their daily voyage. 
 He manufactured stories about the cannibalistic Caribs he never met: without the Admiral's inventive mind, Shakespeare's audience might never have encountered Caliban on Prospero's island. 
 He threatened his crew with having their tongues cut out if they would not swear that they had sailed along the coast of the Indies (they had, in fact, been sailing past Cuba). 
 As governor of the island of Espa&ntilde;ola, Colon ordered the hands to be struck off any native who failed to render up a quarterly tribute of gold or 25 pounds of spun cotton. 
 And this on an island where there appeared to be next to no gold and a few sparse cotton plants. 
 Mr Sale carefully provides the reader with this last piece of information 30 pages away from the news that Colon's determination to find gold on the island was rewarded. 
 In 1496 he was able to tell his royal employers that he had found a goldfield of El Doradan proportions, capable of producing up to 3 tons of gold a year, enough to justify the cost of his four expeditions. 
 Mr Sale speaks in the tongue of the times. 
 There is nobody now who does not feel uncomfortable about the way colonialism began. 
 The fascination of this book is in its clear-sighted debunking of the myths which many have fondly mistaken for historical truth: that Columbus was really aiming for Asia, that he and his sailors thought the world was flat, that Queen Isabella pawned her jewels to finance his trips and came down with her husband to wave him off from the docks, or even (a fondly-cherished delusion) that these were journeys of discovery rather than intentional acquisition and expansion of the Spanish empire. 
 On this aspect of the story Mr Sale is an invaluable guide and teacher, but he goes well over the top in his determination to present Columbus as the representative of a devilish western world driven only by the desire to rape, grab and despoil a land of innocence. 
 His is an uncompromising view, but the breadth of his scholarship and the skilful mix of historical fact, conviction and style make this an absorbing book.  
 Making films in Latin America 
 They kill horses, don't they? 
 A MAN has to be either rich or crazy to make films in Latin America these days. 
 It was not always so. 
 In the 1960s state money encouraged the growth of national film industries in many Latin American countries. 
 The glossy conventions of Hollywood were spurned in favour of a rough-hewn cinematic style more suited to the reality at hand. 
 These were heady days. 
 People spoke of a &bquo;Third Cinema&equo;, an &bquo;Imperfect Cinema&equo; and the &bquo;Aesthetic of Hunger&equo;. 
 In recent years, however, the film industry has become an extra that Latin American states can ill afford. 
 Debt, hyperinflation, currency devaluation and dwindling box-office have combined to make a high-risk business riskier still. 
 The golden days of state money are over, and joint ventures &mdash; co-finance and co-productions with European TV networks or private companies &mdash; are not always happy. 
 One Latin American director at the latest London Film Festival was desperately seeking ways of writing yet another French actor into his latest script: &bquo;It's a burden trying to be universal,&equo; he groaned. 
 Another director made it sound like a Faustian pact with the devil: &bquo;You have to be careful not to lose your soul&equo;, he whispered. 
 &bquo;Some co-productions turn out like badly-mixed cocktails.&equo; 
 Co-ventures of this kind certainly do little to change the stereotyped European image of Latin America. 
 They tend to be lush period pieces set in Amazonia with Spanish, Italian, French, British or even American actors in the lead roles. 
 These films, with their &bquo;touristic&equo; inventory of cockfights, hot mulattas, haciendas, rubber plantations and the odd dumb Indian, do nothing to temper what one Venezuelan director described as &bquo;European ignorance&equo; about Latin America. 
 &bquo;For most people, Venezuela is oil, Argentina the pampa and Colombia, drugs,&equo; he complained. 
 There are exceptions. 
 A new film from Argentina, Maria Luisa Bemberg's version of Octavio Paz's life of Sor Juana, a 17th-century Mexican nun and poetess, proves how successfully foreign actors can be integrated with a national cast: a French actress and a Spanish star play the leads. 
 And glamour does not always have to be imported. 
 The London Film Festival included a feature film from Ecuador, only the second the country has ever produced. 
 This ravishingly homespun film, played by an all-Ecuadorian cast, tells the story of &bquo;La Tigra&equo;, a mythical female version of the Latin American macho. 
 The Tigress's favourite trick consists of awakening her lovers with a rifle-butt and watching with delight as they hurl themselves naked from her window into a dungheap. 
 But the film's British audience had its mind on other matters. 
 &bquo;Was the horse killed for real?&equo; they wanted to know after one scene. 
 A shame-faced Camilo Luzuriaga, the film's director, had to admit that he and his crew lacked the technical know-how to fake a death. 
 Despite economic pressure to do otherwise, a handful of recent films capture raw and contemporary images of Latin America. 
 Some were shot on location in shanty towns or marginal neighbourhoods. 
 One Colombian film, which used non-professional actors to portray the lives of Medellin street kids, was so faithful to local speech patterns that one Argentine cinema-goer confessed he had understood a mere 10% of the dialogue. 
 The general mood of these films is sombre. 
 &bquo;What do we do now?&equo; asks a mother in present-day Argentina with her life in tatters around her. 
 &bquo;If you've got dough, there's no punishment,&equo; declares her young son, languishing in prison without an austral. 
 &bquo;Everything's more difficult these days,&equo; grumbles a bed-ridden pensioner in a Chilean film; and although, as it happens, he is referring to that day's crossword, the comment itself speaks volumes. 
 These films do not make for easy viewing. 
 Fat on a diet of &bquo;Robocop&equo; and &bquo;Rambo&equo;, Latin Americans may not jump at the chance to see them. 
 Accounting for the flop of his latest film, &bquo;Last Images of the Shipwreck&equo;, on the home market, an Argentine director said simply: &bquo;The shipwrecked don't want to see the shipwreck.&equo; 
 AMERICAN SURVEY 
 Trade 
 The other brinkmanship 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 FRETTING about the Gulf, Americans are paying little attention to another arcane game of bluff, deadlines and possible disaster. 
 The Uruguay round of trade negotiations broke up rancorously in Brussels in December after the European Community refused even to discuss a compromise text on agriculture. 
 Arthur Dunkel, GATT's director-general, is shuttling between capitals searching for a basis on which to resume talks. 
 As with the Gulf, a deadline looms: March 1st, the date by which a deal must be submitted to Congress if a &bquo;fast-track&equo; authority is to protect it from amendment. 
 Could this be a prelude to a trade war even more destructive of world prosperity than a military war? 
 Optimists say not. 
 Trade negotiations always look as if they were about to break down just before they succeed. 
 December's meeting showed conclusively that the Uruguay round cannot be completed without a deal on agriculture. 
 Behind the scenes both the Americans and the Europeans are working towards an agreement. 
 Another straw the optimists grasp is that two trade disputes between the EC and the United States have been headed off. 
 The &dollar;420m a year that America has been getting to compensate it for the loss in sales of farm products to Spain and Portugal after they joined the Community was due to run out in 1990. 
 Under threat of trade retaliation, the EC has extended it. 
 And both sides are being cautious in their reaction to import bans imposed for health reasons. 
 The EC is blocking pork and beef imports because it claims that American slaughterhouses are unsanitary; the Americans are blocking some wine imports because they have not tested a drug used in its production. 
 Rather than retaliate, though, the two are talking. 
 Even so, trade pessimists probably have the stronger case. 
 There are huge gaps to bridge in the Uruguay round in less than two months, in areas such as services and textiles as well as agriculture. 
 American negotiators say that they are not even talking the same language as the Community on farm support. 
 The Japanese are not helping: they sided with the EC in Brussels because they are not ready to permit any rice imports. 
 Nor is South Korea, where the Americans detect an official campaign to discourage imports. 
 But the biggest worry is America's disenchantment with free trade. 
 Many industries, fearful of foreign competition, have been lukewarm about the Uruguay round from the start. 
 A stream of trade complaints is ready to burst on the administration the day the round ends. 
 Hostility to foreign investment is another telling sign. 
 There is talk of extending &bquo;voluntary&equo; quotas on car imports to transplanted Japanese factories in America. 
 Manuel Lujan, the interior secretary, has grumbled loudly about a Japanese firm taking over a company operating under a government concession in Yosemite National Park. 
 As usual Congress reflects the mood. 
 Max Baucus, chairman of the Senate's international trade subcommittee, talks of ending the Uruguay round and protecting national interests with bilateral agreements, farm subsidies and use of section 301 of America's trade act to force other countries to open their markets by threatening to close America's. 
 Everybody accepts that there is no chance of an agreement to extend the fast-track deadline beyond the beginning of March. 
 Yet the alternatives advocated by GATT-bashers are unappealing. 
 A free-trade area for North and South America would take years to negotiate. 
 It would link countries that are almost all big international debtors &mdash; and so need to increase exports to third countries, not to each other. 
 The use of threats is at best an uncertain course leading to managed trade &mdash; and at worst a dangerous one leading to higher tariffs. 
 The administration has admitted that the American economy is in recession, which will make hard-pressed industries more vociferous in their demands for protection from &bquo;unfair competition&equo;. 
 A clear free-trade lead from George Bush to revive the Uruguay round is sorely needed.  
 Drugs in Tacoma 
 Needle delivery 
 SEATTLE 
 A SMOKY industrial Sparta to the high-tech Athens of Seattle, Tacoma often provides the punch-line for local jokes. 
 Yet it is Tacoma that is ahead of its time in its pioneering attempts to help drug addicts (rather a lot of them among its 160,000 inhabitants) from becoming AIDS sufferers as well. 
 From this month on, junkies need make only a telephone call to exchange their used, possibly-AIDS bearing, needles for new clean ones, delivered free of charge. 
 Tacoma's needle-exchange programmes are already thought to be showing results. 
 As many as half the New Yorkers who inject themselves with intravenous drugs may carry the AIDS virus; in the Tacoma and Seattle area only about 10% of the addicts are infected. 
 The virus is easily transmitted via needles &mdash; and addicts tend to have dirty habits. 
 One needle may serve a dozen or more customers. 
 The odds are that at least one of them carries the virus. 
 About 1m Americans are infected. 
 Tacoma's push for clean needles was started by Dave Purchase, a local drug counsellor. 
 In 1988 Mr Purchase set up his exchange operation in a street where there were a lot of junkies. 
 He bought used needles from drug takers, passed out new ones, and dispensed advice on how to sterilise needles with household bleach. 
 A year ago the Tacoma and Pierce County health authorities formalised the programme by offering to pay for it, creating the first publicly financed needle-exchange programme in America. 
 The new twist is that addicts (the programme serves 300&ndash;500 people a week) will be given a telephone number they can call to request new needles, which will then be delivered to a pre-arranged meeting point. 
 Their own addresses will tactfully neither be used nor asked for. 
 Based on the Tacoma model, needle-exchange programmes have been established in Seattle and several other American cities. 
 In October Tacoma was host to the first North American conference on needle exchanges; the participants studied European programmes, including one in Wales where the chemist's department of a supermarket serves as a needle-exchange centre. 
 Though hard evidence linking any such programme to decreased AIDS transmission is difficult to pin down, Tacoma's health officials believe that their system has cut &bquo;unsafe&equo; injections by half. 
 Opponents of the whole idea say that it subsidises drug abuse. 
 The moral issues are difficult. 
 William Bennett, a former drug tsar, was a vociferous foe, as is Louis Sullivan, the health secretary. 
 In New York a fledgling needle-exchange programme was scrapped last February. 
 Tacoma's own programme had to survive a court challenge at around the same time. 
 Even in San Francisco, perhaps the most AIDS-acclimatised city in the world, needle-exchange programmes lack official sanction. 
 However, the San Franciscan police usually look the other way when drug workers swap needles, sometimes by putting clean syringes in a pram and inviting junkies to step up and feed &bquo;the baby&equo;.  
 Texan banks 
 Throwing away the key 
 DALLAS 
 FEDERAL prosecutors have dealt a one-two punch to the savings-and-loan crooks,&equo; boasted Dick Thornburgh, the attorney-general. 
 A Texan jury on December 20th convicted Don &bquo;Big Daddy&equo; Dixon for using his bank as a personal piggy-bank; the next day prosecutors announced that they had squeezed a guilty plea from Edwin &bquo;Fast Eddie&equo; McBirney, who admitted to artful manipulation of deposits at Sunbelt Savings Association, the largest S&amp;L ever to fail in Texas. 
 Mr Dixon and Mr McBirney were two prime targets of federal efforts to uncover the rampant savings and loan fraud in the state. 
 The public's resentment of thrift operators and their accomplices is showing itself. 
 Juries are becoming more likely to return guilty verdicts in tough-to-prove cases &mdash; and judges more likely to slap on longer sentences. 
 Paul Coggins, a Dallas criminal lawyer who represents Mr McBirney, complains that the trials can be compared to drug-dealing trials in the 1960s when winning a conviction was as easy as dropping the dope on the courtroom table,. 
 The government had plenty of dope on Mr Dixon, who drew attention to himself with his lavish style of life, including a fleet of fancy jets and fast cars, and a two-week tour of fine French restaurants. 
 The flamboyant past owner of the now defunct Vernon Savings and Loan Association was charged with conspiracy to finance a &dollar;1m beach house in southern California by diverting a loan made to a developer buddy in Texas. 
 Prosecutors held the jury's attention by spicing the six-week trial with sex. 
 A former brothel owner testified that she provided girls to romp in a hot tub with Vernon board members at the beach house. 
 The jury found him guilty on 23 charges in a 38-count indictment. 
 After prosecutors presented evidence that he had money stashed away in overseas accounts, it was ruled that Mr Dixon must stay in jail until the judge sentences him in February. 
 Not even a plea from his six-year-old granddaughter to let Big Daddy go could free him. 
 His conviction ends the 3.5-year investigation into Vernon Savings, one of the first by the federal bank-fraud taskforce. 
 The taskforce has so far charged 544 defendants and won 385 convictions. 
 In Dallas 72 of the 94 defendants charged have been convicted. 
 And where sentences of three or five years were once common, judges are now giving ten years or more. 
 Mr Dixon's closest accomplice at Vernon, Woody Lemons, was sentenced to 30 years last year. 
 The public will have to be satisfied with vengeance rather than restitution. 
 The trial was streamlined: Mr Dixon's own lawyer points out that in a &dollar;1.3 billion S&dollar;L failure, the government came up with charges involving only &dollar;600,000. 
 Mr Dixon, who could theoretically be imprisoned for 120 years, faces maximum fines of only &dollar;5.75m.  
 Where cops are killers 
 SAN DIEGO 
 SIX YEARS ago San Diego's police were being killed at a higher rate than the police in any other big American city. 
 The tables have now been turned. 
 These days it is the San Diego cops who are doing the shooting, killing more people, proportionately, than any other police force in America. 
 It is a dramatic change, and not one that recommends itself to the city's residents. 
 Starting from 1986, policemen were given bullet-proof waistcoats and greater discretion in deciding when to use &bquo;deadly force&equo; against criminals. 
 Scarcely a voice was raised in protest. 
 Since then, only one officer has died in the line of duty. 
 But the police have killed 46 people in the past five years, including 12 last year. 
 And loud protests are suddenly heard. 
 The job of quietening them has fallen to Bob Burgreen, the chief of police. 
 The city now has the highest per-head rate of fatal police shootings in the country: double that of New York and nearly triple that of Chicago. 
 Such numbers, and the controversial circumstances of several of the shootings, have sent Mr Burgreen scrambling to give the impression that his department is not completely out of control. 
 The trouble started in May, when an unarmed navy man who had backed his pick-up truck into a sheriff's squad car was shot in the head by a deputy. 
 Three days later commuters inching along a motorway during the rush-hour watched as police chased and killed a Mexican man brandishing a garden trowel. 
 Other incidents include the shooting of a 12-year-old boy (armed with a handful of stones) and of an 80-year-old man in a wheelchair. 
 Led by a local chapter of the American Civil Liberties Union, a coalition of pressure groups demanded the reform of police procedures. 
 In response, Mr Burgreen undertook what he says is the most extensive study ever of the use of force by policemen. 
 The result was a &dollar;600,000 plan, announced on December 21st, to reduce the number of fatal shootings by a combination of extra training, electric stun-guns, rubber bullets and police dogs. 
 The stress was on making police behaviour less deadly, not on changing it. 
 Mr Burgreen was not able to offer his department's critics the reform they wanted above all others: improvement of San Diego's unusually weak system of investigating police shootings. 
 In virtually every other big city, detectives from a special &bquo;internal affairs&equo; division or the local district attorney's office conduct an independent investigation. 
 Not so in San Diego. 
 There, shootings are investigated first by colleagues of the shooter. 
 A report is sent to the district attorney, who then decides whether to pursue his own inquiry. 
 In the past five years that has happened in fewer than 15% of the cases; not a single officer has been found criminally liable. 
 Often the police were vindicated before autopsies were completed. 
 To have pursued the cases more vigorously, says Edwin Miller, the district attorney, would have been &bquo;a waste of time&equo;. 
 Criminologists disagree. 
 So does Mr Burgreen, who asked Mr Miller's office to start conducting independent investigations into all future police shootings. 
 Mr Miller refused. 
 So Mr Burgreen, doing all that he could, said he would add a civilian to his internal review board. 
 Nobody will be impressed.  
 New York's infrastructure 
 Time to make do and mend 
 NEW YORK 
 BRIDGES creak, roads subside, buildings collapse, fires rage in the subway: sure signs that New York's infrastructure is crumbling. 
 New Yorkers have always shown a greater genius for putting up new buildings than for repairing old ones. 
 But recent events have shown that they need to learn to make do and mend. 
 They build on a grand scale. 
 New York was long known as the imperial city &mdash; the place that drilled tunnels and threw majestic bridges across the East and Hudson rivers, whose railway stations celebrated beaux-arts architecture, and where rich visionaries went to town with such mighty groups of buildings as the Rockefeller Centre. 
 When a part of the city, such as the South Bronx, was worn out, the better-off people decamped to the suburbs. 
 They left behind solid homes for vandals and arsonists to destroy. 
 They also abandoned thousands of miles of electric cables and water pipes to rot in the ground. 
 An inquest by New York newspapers into a subway fire in Brooklyn that killed two people at the turn of the year is making plain the consequences of all this neglect. 
 The Emergency Medical Rescue Units that the city maintains to deal with such accidents were unavoidably delayed in getting to the scene. 
 Four out of five of their rescue vehicles were out of commission for repairs or oil changes. 
 Workers could not clear the tunnels of smoke while waiting for the rescue teams to arrive. 
 The fans that were supposed to force fresh air into this section of the subway and to draw stale air out had been stored in a warehouse in Ohio since 1977, awaiting installation. 
 Some of the 842 bridges that the city maintains are, it seems, in even worse condition than the subway. 
 City engineers have leaked to the press their previously private warnings to the city of hundreds of signs of hazardous corrosion on four big bridges that span the East river: the Brooklyn, Manhattan, Queensboro and Williamsburg bridges. 
 The engineers blame neglect by cent-wise-dollar-foolish politicians for the rusting girders. 
 The bridges, they say, have not been painted regularly and this penny-pinching has exposed their steelwork to the corroding effects of salt, pollution, water and debris. 
 New York's mayor, David Dinkins, has been in office for only a year, so is obviously not responsible for these decades of neglect. 
 He is nonetheless being held responsible for putting things right. 
 The timing of this challenge could hardly be worse. 
 Social problems are crowding in on a city where the body-count for murders rose from a record 1,905 in 1989 to a new record of more than 2,200 in 1990. 
 When the streets of New York begin to recall the Wild West, it is hard to find money for boring old repairs to bridges, roads, tunnels and subways.  
 Macho potatoes on the couch 
 GEORGE ALLEN, a football coach who died on new year's eve, deserves a footnote in political history. 
 From 1971 to 1977 he was the head coach of the Washington Redskins professional football team, and turned what had been a lacklustre bunch into a city's obsession. 
 (When two Washingtonians meet, anywhere in the world, one will quickly say: &bquo;How 'bout them 'Skins?&equo;. 
 It is a bit like a Masonic handshake.) 
 Feisty, secretive, determined to win, it was not surprising that one of Allen's fervent admirers was Richard Nixon, who, Washington legend has it, would call the coach during the dark hours of Watergate to discuss Redskin strategy and &mdash; who knows? &mdash; to get some tips on how to handle his own presidency. 
 Mr Nixon and his gang liked football terminology &mdash; gameplans, moving the ball downfield, playing tough defence and the like. 
 Now everybody talks like this: if you cannot understand the language of sport, you probably cannot follow American politics. 
 America's passion for watching and talking about sport (and, those ubiquitous joggers notwithstanding, the true passion is for watching not playing) deserves attention. 
 There is, for a start, so much of it to watch and talk about. 
 A determined armchair athlete on the east coast could have spent 11 consecutive hours watching college football on new year's day, and millions no doubt did. 
 The National Football League play-offs are about to begin, and the orgiastic blow-out of the Super Bowl comes at the end of the month. 
 Few Americans are revered in quite the way that sports stars are. 
 After reading Sports Illustrated's latest paean to Joe Montana, the quarterback of the San Francisco 49ers (&bquo;An 11-year-old named Matthew Hart had a brain tumour&hellip; 
 The meeting lasted 45 minutes&hellip; 
 Joe left. 
 Matt's crisis passed&equo;), all that is left to hear about the great man are the details of his virgin birth. 
 But the real point, argued Thomas Boswell of the Washington Post in an article last year, is that sport &bquo;has become central to what remains of our American sense of identity&equo;. 
 A television (or two, or three) in every home, the collapse of moral certitudes, the debasement of politics &mdash; all this, suggested Mr Boswell, means that sport has become &bquo;the meeting ground where we discuss our values&equo;. 
 Mr Boswell is not alone. 
 George Will, a political commentator of rarefied taste, is another who thinks that sport should be taken seriously. 
 He argues that if other Americans were as good at their job as baseball players are at theirs, the country's trade difficulties would be a thing of the past. 
 What should be made of all this? 
 Start with an obvious point, but one that is often forgotten. 
 Saying that Americans are obsessed with spectator sport is a bit like saying that life in Japan is bliss: something that is more true for men than for women. 
 A political life that is constantly framed in sporting terms, and which celebrates successes with high-fives and backslapping, is unlikely to be one that many women find congenial. 
 Add the fact that the dominating sport, American football, venerates the combination of meticulous planning with the sudden application of brute force, and you may have an explanation for the macho tone of much of American policy-making. 
 One reason, perhaps, why so few women choose a life in politics? 
 Then there is the living lie of &bquo;college sports&equo;. 
 Thousands of black students are exploited by being lured to college on the promise that their sporting skills will lead to a professional career &mdash; and then left ill-educated and forgotten (although the colleges are enriched by the television networks) when the career does not materialise. 
 Cities spend an enormous amount of money on building stadiums and bidding competitively for sports franchises; they predicate their enthusiasm on the assumption (for which there is no empirical basis) that a professional sports team enhances a local economy. 
 When the various negatives are put together, a case can begin to be made that sport is a destructive influence on American public life. 
 But not, at least in one way, an interfering influence. 
 For all the strength of its grip on American affections, the industry has not yet done a Hollywood: sporting stars, unlike some film stars, do not pretend that they know everything there is to know about matters from a nuclear winter to farm policies and demand to be listened to on them all. 
 Guess what? 
 Many Americans regret the fact that they now discuss sport with the passion that 200 years ago they brought to everyday debates on theories of representative government (and, as historians of the revolution have made plain, there really were such debates). 
 Perhaps the blame for this lies with the politicians. 
 For the great joy of American sport is its unpredictability. 
 Who would have thought, for example, that the University of Colorado, where the students wear tie-dye and ask in hushed tones if you would like more salad, would become the national college football champion? 
 Who would have thought that the Oakland As, celebrated by Mr Will and thought to be a collection of giants, would have been blown away in the World Series by a bunch of journeymen from Cincinnati? 
 National politics, by contrast, has become all too predictable: the Republicans win the White House; the Democrats hold Congress. 
 So what Richard Nixon should really have discussed with George Allen was how to set about reforming the wretched business of campaign finance.  
 Yes, no, maybe 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 BACK to business after the break, policy-makers in the administration and on Capitol Hill (the new Congress met on January 3rd) are a nervous lot. 
 Nervous about the prospect of a war, naturally. 
 But they are also nervous that the calculations they make in the next two weeks may determine who will win and lose the political battles of the next two years. 
 The Founding Fathers, in Article I, Section 8 of the constitution, decreed that &bquo;The Congress shall have the power&hellip; to declare war&equo;. 
 In any democracy, a government can commit its people to certain bloodshed only if it believes it has their support. 
 In America that principle of democratic statecraft is made formal. 
 It does not make life easy for George Bush, but neither does it make it easier for Congress. 
 Congressmen know that the stakes in the Gulf are of the highest. 
 They know that a mistake on their part could send a signal almost as disastrous as the one that Chamberlain sent Hitler at Munich in 1938. 
 And the Democrats among them also know that if they went on record against a war that turned out to be a great victory, President Bush would be even harder to beat in 1992. 
 Democrats are hence navigating, as one of them put it, between the Scylla of not wishing to undercut Mr Bush's diplomacy and the Charybdis of not wishing to give him a blank cheque. 
 They remember, acutely, the blank cheque that Lyndon Johnson got from Congress in the 1964 Gulf of Tonkin resolution that allowed him to fight in Vietnam. 
 Congressional leaders were set to meet the president on January 3rd, perhaps to find a course on which all could agree. 
 But any deal done between the leaders and the White House may be subject to full congressional approval. 
 And members have their own ideas. 
 On December 27th 110 of the 267 Democratic members of the House of Representatives signed a letter written by George Miller, a Californian Democrat who came into Congress in 1974 as part of the post-Vietnam wave of liberals. 
 His letter says that: &bquo;So long as neither the lives of American citizens nor our troops are subjected to immediate danger and the international economic embargo continues to exert substantial pressure against Iraq&hellip; offensive military action by the United States unwisely risks massive loss of life.&equo; 
 The Miller letter shows that, at present, there is little chance of a resolution being put to Congress that simply mimics the language of the UN Security Council resolution of November 29th. 
 This was one that said that member states might use &bquo;all necessary means&equo; (meaning force) to restore peace and security in the Gulf. 
 Mr Bush would dearly like a congressional resolution of this sort, passed by a big margin after a short debate. 
 But Mr Miller's letter explicitly reminds the president that the United Nations &bquo;does not commit, or authorise, the use of United States armed forces.&equo; 
 The number of signatories to the letter &mdash; and up to 50 other House Democrats might agree with its terms, as well as perhaps 25&ndash;30 of the 56 Democratic senators &mdash; means that a &bquo;UN&equo; resolution could pass Congress only with a majority small enough to be politically unacceptable, and might well fail. 
 That is uncomfortable for the president. 
 He can take no more pleasure from a second initiative that is making its rounds on the Hill. 
 Joe Kennedy, a Democratic member of the House, is crafting a resolution that would commit America to exhaust sanctions before it used force in the Gulf &mdash; and suggests that sanctions should run for at least six months from the passing of the resolution. 
 If such a measure were to be carried (and a similar one is likely to be introduced in the Senate), Mr Bush could use force only at the risk of a domestic, and indeed a constitutional, crisis. 
 In public the White House maintains that the president does not need a congressional resolution at all to use force. 
 Mr Bush, like other presidents before him, bases this on Article II, Section 2, of the constitution which says that &bquo;The president shall be commander in chief&equo;. 
 He points out that of some 200 applications of force by the United States, only five have been &bquo;solemnified&equo; (his word) by a declaration of war. 
 But this cuts little ice on the Hill, and not just with Mr Miller's men. 
 On December 29th Richard Gephardt, majority leader in the House, said that if the president waged war without a congressional resolution, &bquo;Congress has to reach for the only tool left to it, which is to cut off the funding of the war.&equo; 
 The day after those comments, Robert Dole, the Republican leader in the Senate, branded them as &bquo;incredible&equo;. 
 But in the same interview Mr Dole, as is his way, was a little less than helpful to the president. 
 He had a &bquo;gut feeling&equo;, he said, that the American people were not yet committed to war, and so he urged Mr Bush to pursue a meeting in Baghdad between James Baker, the secretary of state, and Saddam Hussein &mdash; as well as finding a date on which Iraq's foreign minister could come to Washington. 
 Perhaps in response to this call for negotiations (though that is something that the administration would not admit), Mr Baker is set to make another tour of allied capitals in Europe and the Middle East, during which he would, at the very least, be available for a meeting in Baghdad. 
 All this begs the question about the reliability of Mr Dole's gut. 
 In two careful analyses of the survey evidence over the past four months, the Washington Post and the American Political Report, an influential newsletter, have come to broadly similar conclusions. 
 Though the initial approval ratings for Mr Bush's handling of the Gulf (which were above 75%) have not been sustained, he has consistently maintained the support of about 60% of Americans for his general policy. 
 As to the use of force, there, too, a clear majority (one December poll by NBC and the Wall Street Journal shows 54&ndash;34% support) backs war if Iraq does not withdraw from Kuwait by January 15th. 
 There are two catches. 
 The first is that initial support of 60% is not high if the policy turns sour &mdash; if, for example, a war lasted more than the few days or weeks that Mr Bush seems to think it will take. 
 The second caveat is that even this amount of support is reduced when hypothetical compromises are put to the public. 
 In a Los Angeles Times poll in mid-December people were asked what policy they would support if Iraq pulled out of most of Kuwait but held on to an oilfield and some other land. 
 Given choices, 17% voted to remove American troops; 46% voted to leave the troops in place and enforce the embargo; and only 29% supported military action. 
 Publicly Mr Bush remains as determined as ever to force Iraq out of Kuwait, with no concessions. 
 He remains prepared to use force to do that. 
 He continues to speak of the possibility of using the Gulf operation to craft a new world order for the resolution of disputes. 
 But he must now know that an Iraqi d&eacute;marche around January 15th &mdash; perhaps a partial withdrawal from Kuwait &mdash; would make the use of force bitterly controversial at home. 
 And he must know that if there is a war, his political future depends on it being short and decisive.  
 Can the River of Grass flow again? 
 MIAMI 
 Men, with their engineering skills, ruined Florida's Everglades. 
 Now, with high-tech skills, they are trying to put things back as they were 
 IN THE heart of North America's largest freshwater marsh a rare female woodstork prepares to nest. 
 She will lay her eggs only if conditions there match an instinctive code programmed into her over thousands of years. 
 A computer, similarly programmed, is trying, at long last, to get things right for her. 
 And in a Miami courtroom, an hour's drive away, a federal prosecutor is assembling documents to try to prove a case of human neglect. 
 The survival of the Everglades, a watery and delicate expanse designated a world treasure by the United Nations, is now Florida's consuming passion. 
 Each season the evidence mounts that the national park is being driven towards ecological collapse. 
 The culprit is greedy man. 
 For decades he has ditched, diked and drained the edges of the Everglades until all that is left is a barely viable core. 
 What used to be swamp and marsh on the park's fringes are now the suburbs of Miami, Fort Lauderdale and Palm Beach. 
 These three cities form a single megalopolis occupying a sliver of coastline 20 miles (30km) wide. 
 Each of its 3.5m people pulls 200 gallons (750 litres) of water a day from the Everglades or its aquifer. 
 What is not consumed on bathing, watering lawns or irrigating golf courses goes on the sugar-cane plantations and tomato farms carved from the swamp. 
 A century ago, when the region was inhabited by Indians and rough pioneers, the Everglades &mdash; or &bquo;grassy waters&equo; to the Indians &mdash; encompassed a 250-mile-long system of lakes, marshes and rivers. 
 Its headwaters began in the swamps south of what is now Orlando and flowed into Lake Okeechobee at the centre of the system. 
 During each summer's rainy season, the lake's waters would spill over its southern rim and slide down towards Florida Bay. 
 Although rarely deep enough to cover the protruding blades of sawgrass, the glistening sheet of water (called the River of Grass by Marjory Douglas in her classic book on the region) would spread 60 miles wide, drenching 4m acres. 
 Land speculators, politicians and farmers saw profit in these wetlands. 
 The first efforts to drain them began in the 1880s, but the main push came after a hurricane in 1947 drove floodwaters over Lake Okeechobee's southern edge, drowning more than 2,000 people. 
 Congress ordered the Army Corps of Engineers to harness the natural system in an operation rivalled only in Holland. 
 The Everglades was carved into sections by an intricate network of canals and levees &mdash; 1,400 miles in all. 
 North of Lake Okeechobee, the meandering, 98-mile Kissimee river was  corralled  into a deep-water canal that ran dead straight into the lake; this changed the marsh into a prairie that became the state's main cattle and dairy-farming region. 
 A 25-mile strip of rich muckland south of the lake was designated for sugar-cane plantations, to be drained and flooded by huge pumps. 
 To provide water for farmers and city dwellers, three sections of the marsh were surrounded with dikes and set aside from development, each one a kind of captured remnant of Everglades, but wholly for man's use. 
 Nature was given its due, but only at the southern tip of the marsh. 
 Almost one-third of the original 4m-acre expanse was left in a natural state as the Everglades National Park. 
 But this area, too, was wholly dependent on engineers for its existence. 
 By the time the network was completed in the mid-1960s, it resembled a vast plumbing system with 18 huge pumps, each one big enough to suck in a car, driving 1 billion gallons of water through it each day. 
 The age-old cycle of wet and dry seasons had become irrelevant. 
 And the engineering marvel turned out to be a slow-motion natural disaster. 
 Wading birds, the barometer of any marsh's health, have been devastated. 
 Where once they flew in such flocks that they threw shadows over the earth, they now survive in a few straggling colonies. 
 A 1937 count found 300,000 wading birds in the Everglades; by 1988 the number had dropped to 15,000. 
 Only 500 woodstorks remain. 
 Lake Okeechobee is so full of nutrients, most of them traced to cow manure, that algae have all but suffocated it. 
 The sawgrass, which served as a vital part in the food chain, is being pushed back by cattails, a dense plant that thrives on the phosphate-rich water. 
 The alarm went out and environmentalists began to try to halt, if not reverse, the destruction of the remaining park. 
 But, unlike any other nature preserve, the Everglades today exists like a patient on life-support, completely dependent on the outside efforts of others to survive. 
 The challenge is to restore the flow of clean, fresh water and to recreate the seasons of wet and dry, flood and fire. 
 In 1989 a Miami lawyer, Dexter Lehtinen, filed a surprise lawsuit against the state and its water managers. 
 He accused the bureaucrats of civil neglect in not providing the park with the clean water it needs. 
 His suit, still pending, elicited howls from farmers and sugar-cane growers. 
 Environmentalists, including Mrs Douglas, now 100 years old, back the suit as part of their demand that the plantations be shut down despite the cost. 
 A compromise proposed by the state would force the farmers to carve artificial marshlands from their fields to serve as natural filters, cleansing the water before it is sent southward. 
 The main question is who will pay for the clean-up: farmers or all the state's taxpayers? 
 But something is already happening. 
 Beginning this year the water-flow into the park will try to mimic nature. 
 The water managers will push water in or hold water out according to a computer programmed with decades of data about rainfall and drought. 
 Or so it is hoped. 
 Check in the spring with the woodstorks. 
 ASIA 
 China 
 Two voices 
 FROM OUR CHINA CORRESPONDENT 
 GREETINGS for the new year to the Chinese readers of the People's Daily: 
 It is imperative to persist in the four cardinal principles &lsqb;adherence to socialism, the dictatorship of the proletariat, the leadership of the Communist Party, and Marxism-Leninism and Mao Zedong thought&rsqb;, oppose bourgeois liberalisation, smash the &bquo;peaceful evolution&equo; schemes of antagonistic international forces and inspire patriotism and socialist consciousness. 
 Greetings, too, from President Yang Shangkun to the foreign listeners of Radio Beijing: 
 China continues to open its door wide to the entire world, and friends from around the world are welcome to visit China. 
 Over the next ten years, China will become economically more liberal, internationally more friendly: 
 The leadership is guiding the Chinese people to implement firmly the reform and open policy put forward by Deng Xiaoping. 
 Since &bquo;bourgeois liberalisation&equo; is code for western, capitalist influences, and since &bquo;peaceful evolution&equo; is code for the capitalist subversion of communism, perhaps Mr Yang forgot to read his newspaper. 
 More likely, China is still trying to reconcile the irreconcilable: Marxism with a market economy, central control with the reality of powerful politicians in the provinces. 
 The People's Daily tells the Chinese what they are supposed to believe; Mr Yang tells foreigners what he would like them to believe. 
 How long this muddle can last is anyone's guess. 
 It was supposed to be resolved at the long-awaited, and delayed, meeting in Beijing of the party's Central Committee on December 25th-30th. 
 Some 171 full members and 107 alternate members (with 300 other sundry officials looking on) met to agree on the new &bquo;proposals for the ten-year programme (1991&ndash;2000) and eighth five-year plan (1991&ndash;95)&equo;. 
 In practice, they agreed only to more muddle. 
 The communiqu&eacute; offered plenty of jargon. 
 &bquo;The responsibility system with the household contract linking output to payment as the main form is in keeping with the present level of the productive forces in China's rural areas and must be maintained as a basic system for a long time to come&hellip; 
 Further efforts should be made to enhance the vitality of the enterprises, especially the large and medium-sized state-run enterprises&hellip; 
 It is necessary to handle properly the relations between the central and the local authorities.&equo; 
 The simple translation is, first, that the 750m people in the countryside, including 90m who work in what amount to private factories, cannot be sent back to the commune, however much China's old-guard ideologues might wish. 
 They must be allowed to make profits in a free market that co-exists with the planned economy. 
 Second, the state will continue to prop up inefficient state enterprises. 
 This may mean forcing the worst of them to merge with the best; it will certainly mean a widening of China's budget deficit. 
 Third, the state will attempt to squeeze more tax revenue from provinces intent on keeping as much money as possible for themselves. 
 The less simple translation is that the battle continues between economic reformists and those hardliners, led politically by the prime minister, Li Peng, and ideologically by the 86-year-old Chen Yun, who believe that quick reform leads only too quickly to bourgeois liberalisation and peaceful evolution &mdash; witness the student democrats in 1989 in Beijing's Tiananmen Square and the collapse of communism in the countries of Eastern Europe. 
 In which case, who is winning? 
 It is tempting to pick the reformers. 
 The seventh five-year plan just ended may have had its ups and downs, producing high growth in the first half of the plan's period, followed by inflation and then austerity in the second half, but overall it was a success: the economy grew by 7.5% a year, incomes for city-dwellers almost doubled and last year's grain harvest was the biggest ever. 
 The southern province of Guangdong, the five, low-tax special economic zones and the 14 &bquo;open cities&equo; are proof of the plan's promise to bring prosperity through economic liberalism. 
 Last month Shanghai even launched a computerised stock exchange. 
 But if the reformers are in the ascendant, why did their fragile 86-year-old leader, Deng Xiaoping, find it necessary to make an appearance on December 26th at a local election? 
 Given that Chinese elections have no element of uncertainty and that Mr Deng had not appeared in public for almost six months, perhaps he felt the reformers on the Central Committee were in urgent need of help. 
 Mr Li has made it plain that there will be no more special economic zones in the next ten years, and the praise in the communiqu&eacute; for the Dengist reforms smacks of insincere ritual. 
 The most likely surmise is that the hardliners are now more powerful than the reformers, but are unable to press home their advantage. 
 The reason they are more powerful is that economic liberalism did, indeed, help cause the tumult of 1989, by inspiring a dangerous mix &mdash; an overheated economy, rampant corruption and rejection of the party. 
 Equally to the hardliners' point, Mr Gorbachev's Soviet Union is a discouraging example of what happens when the party loosens its control of the economy and the people. 
 But the reason they cannot press on to victory is transparent: the central planning dear to people like Mr Li and Mr Chen stands no chance of coping with 20m or more urban unemployed, a labour force that will grow by 95m in the next five years and rising expectations of wealth. 
 The Central Committee reaffirmed an old pledge by Mr Deng: China's GNP will quadruple between 1980 and the end of the century. 
 So far, China is more or less on course. 
 But to remain so, it will have to give the market its freedom: no more fixed prices, no more production quotas, no more refusal to let bad enterprises go bust. 
 Until then the eighth plan, due to be rubber-stamped in March by the National People's Congress, will be planning only muddle.  
 Honestly, Kaifu triumphs again 
 FROM OUR TOKYO CORRESPONDENT 
 THINGS were looking bleak for Toshiki Kaifu. 
 Japan's prime minister, whose chief asset is his reputation for honesty, was under pressure to bring into his cabinet politicians who had been tainted with scandal. 
 But Mr Kaifu gets his share of luck. 
 In the last days of 1990 a new scandal broke. 
 A former cabinet minister, Toshiyuki Inamura, was charged with evading &yen;1.7 billion (&dollar;12.6m) of taxes on some &yen;2.8 billion of ill-gotten gains that he made in a shares racket. 
 Suddenly the pressure was off Mr Kaifu to take back the tainted men. 
 Mr Kaifu has been prime minister since August 1989. 
 He was originally seen as a stopgap, chosen almost solely for his respectability after two previous prime ministers had been forced to resign in quick succession. 
 Noboru Takeshita had to go because he received undeclared sums of money from the Recruit publishing-to-property conglomerate. 
 His replacement, Sosuke Uno, was forced out of office after only two months because of a sex scandal. 
 Despite pressure from the ruling Liberal Democratic Party, Mr Kaifu managed to keep his first two cabinets free of politicians who had been implicated in either the Recruit scandal or the earlier Lockheed bribery case. 
 Lately Mr Kaifu has been under pressure to hand out minor cabinet posts to some young stars within the party who had been tainted by the Recruit affair. 
 By doing so, reasoned the party's elderly barons, the way would be clear for a baron to take over as prime minister come the party's annual meeting in October (four of the party's five factional bosses were caught taking payoffs from Recruit). 
 Mr Inamura's misfortune has changed all that. 
 Mr Kaifu has agreed to reshaping his cabinet, but has insisted on keeping it clean. 
 Well, almost. 
 He has had to accept Kazuo Aichi, the new environment minister, who took money from the Recruit company before the famous shares-for-favours scandal broke. 
 Mr Aichi had had to withdraw his candidature for the governorship of Miyagi prefecture when it was revealed that he had been on the take. 
 For harmony's sake, Mr Aichi's sins are now deemed to be minor. 
 The &yen;7.5m (&dollar;55,000) that he received was peanuts alongside the sums that Recruit doled out to many of the ruling party's bigger names. 
 Besides, Mr Aichi made a clean breast of it, and he returned the money to Recruit. 
 Otherwise, Mr Kaifu has won a small but notable victory. 
 Barring mishaps, he can expect to see out the remainder of his two-year term as prime minister. 
 Plenty of problems lie ahead. 
 Delicate negotiations must be held with the North Koreans. 
 Uncertainty surrounds President Gorbachev's planned visit to Japan in April. 
 America seems critical of just about everything Japanese: its persistent trade surplus, its reluctance to liberalise rice imports, its failure so far to provide even a token force in the Gulf. 
 If Mr Kaifu fails to revive the parliamentary bill designed to support the anti-Iraq forces in the Gulf, the Americans are likely to ask for a lot more than the &dollar;4 billion Japan has so far promised to contribute towards the growing expenses there. 
 To get him though the difficult months ahead, Mr Kaifu has insisted on retaining Taro Nakayama as foreign minister and Ryutaro Hashimoto as finance minister. 
 Both have been in the cabinet since Mr Kaifu came to office. 
 The faction led by the former party secretary-general, Shintaro Abe, had demanded that Mr Nakayama (one of the faction's own men) must stand down to give another of the group some cabinet experience. 
 Although Mr Nakayama has been slowly winning respect abroad, his performance in the Diet (parliament) has been abysmal. 
 But with the Gulf and other problems pressing, Mr Kaifu argued that there was no time to break in a new foreign minister. 
 To keep Mr Nakayama, Mr Kaifu bought off the Abe faction by surrendering one of the two cabinet posts normally held by the small Komoto faction to which he himself belongs. 
 The valuable Ichiro Ozawa stays as secretary-general of the party. 
 Though not strictly a member of the cabinet, Mr Ozawa has given the prime minister considerable support and has in effect run the government's day-to-day business. 
 More important, he has the backing of the godfather of Japanese politics, Shin Kanemaru. 
 The cabinet that was announced on December 29th is like most other Japanese cabinets in which posts are distributed among the main factions according to their size. 
 Six ministers come from the Takeshita faction, five (previously four) from the Abe faction, four each from the factions led by Kiichi Miyazawa and Michio Watanabe, and now just one (apart from the prime minister) from the tiny faction headed by Toshio Komoto. 
 Among the grey or greying men in the government is one woman, Akiko Santo, a former actress, who will look after science and technology. 
 With an average age of 60 years, the new cabinet is a couple of years more spritely than its predecessor, a useful gain given the problems that lie ahead. 
 At least the Americans should be pleased with Japan's new budget. 
 Throughout the year-long &bquo;structural impediments initiative&equo; talks that ended last June, the Americans pressed the Japanese government to abandon its single-minded support of businessmen, farmers and other interest groups and do something instead about providing better amenities for its people. 
 Japan eventually agreed to spend &yen;455 trillion (&dollar;3.4 billion) on its infrastructure over the coming decade (see box, previous page). 
 The &yen;70.3 trillion (&dollar;520 billion) budget approved during a late-night cabinet meeting on December 24th is the first in post-war years to put priority on seeking a better way of life for the Japanese rather than achieving higher economic growth or increased exports. 
 The Japanese economy is expected to grow by only 3.8% during fiscal 1991 compared with this year's 5.2%. 
 Even so, the government has approved a 6.2% increase in total spending. 
 After being held more or less fixed for years, spending on public works is to rise by 5%. 
 The Americans should also be heartened that Japan's overseas aid will increase by 8%, and that defence spending is due to rise by 5.5% &mdash; only slightly less than usual. 
 Much defence equipment comes directly or indirectly from America. 
 Overall, Mr Hashimoto claims that the budget is economically neutral. 
 That, too, should mollify the Americans &mdash; at least, for the time being.  
 You won't know it in 2000 
 FROM OUR TOKYO CORRESPONDENT 
 JUST when they thought the good times were coming to an end, Japanese building firms are being given a batch of orders for huge infrastructure projects. 
 The budget for 1991 allocates the first tranche of the &yen;455 trillion (&dollar;3.4 trillion) that the government has agreed to spend on roads, railways, airports, housing, drains and other public works over the coming decade. 
 The amount represents a 73% increase over the &yen;263 trillion spent on public works during the previous decade. 
 As it happens, the Americans are partly responsible for the building firms' good fortune. 
 Last June, at the end of the year-long &bquo;structural impediments initiative&equo; talks, American trade negotiators argued that Japan should spend more money on improving the country's infrastructure. 
 The more resources that Japan devoted to its basic comforts, reasoned the Americans, the less it would have for featherbedding its export industries &mdash; and thus, just possibly, Japan's trade surplus with America might fall. 
 Though it was not admitting it, the Japanese government had been ready to do so all along. 
 The ruling Liberal Democratic Party had been looking for an excuse to reward its friends in the building industry for their financial support. 
 With local elections due in April 1991, the party knew that its candidates would be clamouring for lots of vote-winning enticements. 
 Promises of a new bullet train here, a relief road there, let alone an airport or large tourist attraction, are clearly likely to favour the ruling party in dozens of marginal constituencies. 
 The government is also aware that during the next ten years Japan has its last chance to provide more of the amenities that most westerners take for granted. 
 In the next century public money will be needed increasingly to provide pensions and better medical care for Japan's rapidly ageing population. 
 Finance officials have at last seen the logic of sprucing up Japan now. 
 Previously they have kept a vice-like grip on the national purse, pointing out that the government's debt of &yen;165 trillion (&dollar;1.2 trillion) is bigger than the combined debt of all the world's poor countries together. 
 As things stand, there is now one car for every 4.7 metres (5.1 yards) of road in Japan &mdash; a sixth of the space in America or France. 
 Worse, only 65% of Japan's roads are paved, compared with almost all of Britain's and Germany's. 
 No more than 41% of Japan's population is served by mains drains, compared with 95% in Britain and 73% in America. 
 Almost 40% of Japanese still do not have access to a flushing toilet. 
 Only 20% of electric cables are buried beneath the streets in Tokyo, compared with 100% in London and Paris. 
 One project that has captured the public imagination is the Trans-Tokyo Bay Highway. 
 It will have a bridge 5km (3.1 miles) long linking Kawasaki on the Tokyo side to Chiba on the eastern shore. 
 Another is the New Kansai International Airport being built on a man-made island in Osaka Bay. 
 The futuristic &bquo;mag-lev&equo; bullet train is expected to be whisking passengers between Tokyo and Osaka at 500kph within a decade. 
 Tokyo is to have a new underground line. 
 Road builders will benefit most from the government's largesse. 
 Japan's 4,000km expressway system is to be lengthened to 11,500km over the next ten years. 
 A 450km strip of road linking Tokyo, Nagoya and Kobe is alone expected to cost up to &yen;5 trillion, more than twice the cost of the Channel tunnel between Britain and France. 
 Because of the astronomical costs of urban and farm land the new expressways will take cheaper routes through mountainous regions where possible, relying extensively on bridges and tunnels. 
 There are plans for 11 new airports and ten airport expansions. 
 Tokyo will have a third airport. 
 Ports are to get longer piers to accommodate all the containers bringing in imports. 
 Will foreign firms get a piece of the action? 
 American and European firms are unlikely to get much of a look in. 
 Nine of the 25 foreign building firms granted licences to tender for contracts in Japan are South Korean. 
 Japanese contractors, hard pressed to find workers and keep costs down, prefer to do business with their neighbours. 
 The South Koreans offer cheaper materials and are willing to do more of the grunt work than Americans or Europeans are.  
 Throwing punches in Punjab 
 FROM OUR INDIA CORRESPONDENT 
 THE state is withering away in a very unMarxist fashion in Punjab. 
 In December Sikh terrorists called for a ban on radio broadcasts in Hindi, and to press home their point shot dead the station director of All India Radio at Chandigarh. 
 The radio staff promptly stopped all Hindi broadcasts. 
 The terrorists also said that all government work should be done in Punjabi, not English. 
 Frightened civil servants made the switch at once. 
 The terrorists also declared a code of conduct for all journalists in Punjab, including the representatives of national newspapers. 
 Under it, no journalist should use the expression &bquo;terrorist&equo; &mdash; the correct term is militant, freedom fighter or mujaheddin; no journalist should say that the Panthic Committee, a confederation of terrorist outfits, is based in Pakistan. 
 Journalists breaking the code will be sentenced to death, but they can appeal against the sentence to the Panthic Committee. 
 Every newspaper in Punjab and many outside have fallen in line with the code of conduct. 
 This is unsurprising: the terrorists &mdash; or militants or mujaheddin &mdash; have over the years killed 17 journalists. 
 Once they have pasted a few posters in a Punjabi town, the instruction on them becomes law. 
 Jeans and skirts have been banned in universities. 
 By killing two engineers working on a canal being dug to take water out of Punjab into the neighbouring state of Haryana, the terrorists have killed the project; nobody dares dig any further. 
 Their decrees are not all immoral. 
 They have forbidden cheating in exams, as a result of which all the students in some schools have failed. 
 They have frowned on the extraction of dowries from the parents of brides. 
 In the western parts of Punjab the terrorists have become the state. 
 They dispense justice, settle land disputes, give orders to civil servants (which are carried out with an alacrity unknown earlier). 
 They levy an income tax, but not very seriously: they get cash more easily by looting banks and demanding protection money from businesses. 
 The death toll in Punjab was almost 4,500 in 1990, the highest for any year. 
 Not all killings should be blamed on the terrorists or police. 
 With the breakdown of the administration, crime syndicates have come up in a big way. 
 Family feuds have given Punjab a tradition of violence dating back centuries, and in today's permissive atmosphere people use guns, not lawyers, to settle disputes. 
 The police are demoralised. 
 They unofficially pay bounties to armed freelances willing to take on the terrorists. 
 Officially, any youngster willing to wield a gun can join a police team for 30 rupees (&dollar;1.70) a day. 
 Unfortunately, many youngsters disappear with their guns, and some have joined the militants. 
 Politicians in Delhi keep talking of a political solution. 
 Many militants have been released, and some policemen think it a mug's game to act tough. 
 If an election is held in Punjab in May as promised, it seems certain that the militants will win, and that could mean the end of the careers (and perhaps lives) of tough cops. 
 The prime minister, Chandra Shekhar, has said repeatedly that he wants a political solution. 
 He says he is willing to amend the Indian constitution to give Punjab more autonomy, but not independence. 
 The militants say talks should be held under United Nations auspices in Geneva, on the basis of self-determination. 
 This would be unacceptable to other political parties, notably the Congress Party, which props up India's very minority government.  
 Death sentence 
 FROM OUR MANILA CORRESPONDENT 
 ONE of the most hated organisations in the Philippines, the Constabulary, was disbanded on December 31st. 
 This was the group, formally under army control, that operated as a death squad during the rule of Ferdinand Marcos. 
 While ostensibly chasing communists, it tortured and murdered Marcos's political opponents. 
 Members of the Constabulary practised robbery, extortion and kidnapping. 
 Their criminal ways continued even after Marcos was deposed. 
 Despite the Constabulary's evil reputation, it has taken three years to get a law though Congress that abolished the organisation. 
 The army fiercely resisted the move. 
 It fears it is losing power. 
 Most people in the Philippines, fed up with attempted military coups, hope that its fears are well founded. 
 INTERNATIONAL 
 Countdown 
 NOT since last August's invasion of Kuwait has an American-led war against Saddam Hussein looked so likely, or its human costs so high. 
 After January 15th Resolution 678 of the United Nations Security Council allows any country, at the request of Kuwait, to remove the Iraqis forcibly. 
 The American forces in and around the Arabian peninsula are now close to full fighting strength, with about 1,500 tanks and 1,300 aircraft already in place. 
 British and American troops are being hurriedly vaccinated against anthrax, after reports that Iraq has added biological weapons to its arsenal of missiles and chemicals. 
 If George Bush or Saddam Hussein is secretly preparing to climb down, neither gives any sign of it. 
 The Iraqi president spent new year's eve stirring stew for his soldiers in Kuwait. 
 He told them that Iraq had 60 divisions ready for war, compared with his enemies' 18, and would therefore win any battle for Kuwait, which was part of Iraq's &bquo;body and soul&equo;. 
 Mr Bush continues to say that Iraq must fulfil to the letter the UN's demand for an immediate, complete and unconditional withdrawal. 
 In December word was leaked to American newspapers that the president had resolved to fight, if war was necessary, even if it meant destroying his chances of re-election. 
 This unflinching march to the brink does not make it inevitable that war will begin the moment the deadline expires. 
 The Americans and their allies have always made it plain that January 15th was merely the point after which war would become authorised, not necessarily the date for attack. 
 Not all the American forces destined for the Gulf will have arrived there in time. 
 Even so, striking on or soon after January 15th would help Mr Bush underline, for the benefit of critics at home and abroad, the clear legal authority the UN has given him for military action. 
 Barring some abrupt turn in the diplomacy, the chances of fighting having begun in the next few weeks are high. 
 What has made the approach of the deadline even more worrying is the apparent still-birth of Mr Bush's proposal at the end of November to meet Iraq's foreign minister, Tariq Aziz, in Washington, and to send his own secretary of state, James Baker, to Baghdad. 
 Iraq accepted the proposal, but it seemed to evaporate, ostensibly because of an argument about dates. 
 On January 3rd, under pressure from members of Congress, Mr Bush offered a new idea: a meeting between Mr Baker and Mr Aziz, in Switzerland, between January 7th and January 9th. 
 The diplomatic impasse between Iraq and America has concentrated minds elsewhere. 
 In December, when a meeting between Mr Baker and Mr Hussein still looked possible, the European Community decided against starting talks of its own with the Iraqi leadership. 
 Separate talks, it was felt, would encourage Mr Hussein to detect a rift between the Europeans and Americans, and so draw the sting of the approaching deadline. 
 This week the Community had second thoughts. 
 Jacques Poos, the foreign minister of Luxembourg (which has just taken over the Community's rotating presidency), expressed the hope that he would be authorised to visit Baghdad on its behalf. 
 It is hard to imagine the countdown to war continuing without an intensification of diplomacy. 
 Yet getting talks started &mdash; whether between the Europeans and Iraq or, better still, the Americans and Iraq &mdash; is not the same thing as avoiding war. 
 What makes war likely is not that America and Iraq are not talking. 
 It is that they are not talking because they see no way to settle their differences. 
 Indeed, even before the argument over the date of Mr Baker's trip to Baghdad, the Americans said that he would not be negotiating, only warning Mr Hussein of the need to submit. 
 In any game of brinkmanship, it is possible that one side will collapse suddenly. 
 If Mr Hussein has decided to do so &mdash; by ordering a full or partial withdrawal from Kuwait before January 15th &mdash; he will find it less humiliating to say so to the European Community, or to Arab mediators, than to Mr Baker. 
 He can also be expected to make the most of whatever face-savers the mediators feel they can offer him. 
 Mr Poos hints that one such face-saver could be a promise of talks on Palestine. 
 Since August 12th Mr Hussein has repeated like a gramophone the refrain that he will not budge from Kuwait until Israel gives up the West Bank and Gaza. 
 But, in its Venice Declaration of 1980, the Community has already accepted the right of the Palestinians to self-determination. 
 With American acquiescence, the UN has recently endorsed the principle that an international peace conference on Palestine might be useful at an appropriate time. 
 Little more can be offered without handing Mr Hussein the propaganda victory the Americans and Europeans say they insist on denying him. 
 Besides, there is no solid reason to assume that Mr Hussein's will is going to be the first to break. 
 Over the past five months, despite everything that has gone wrong with his adventure in Kuwait, he has calmly refused to bow to pressure, whether political, economic or military. 
 On January 2nd NATO agreed to send 42 fighter aircraft to defend Turkey. 
 On the same day Mr Hussein raised the pay of his soldiers and promised a glorious future. 
 Perhaps he really believes that he can win a war in the Gulf. 
 Perhaps he will strike first.  
 Somalia 
 Mayor's end? 
 IT COULD be Liberia again. 
 On January 1st the rebels of the United Somali Congress claimed to have driven President Siad Barre into a bunker in the military airport, where he is defended by his favourite tanks. 
 The next day the rebels rejected the idea of peace talks, insisting that he should leave the country. 
 As in Liberia, there is no certainty that the president's removal would end the civil war. 
 The Congress is in shaky alliance with four other rebel movements. 
 This fight could be followed by another between rival claimants to the throne. 
 Somalia is mostly desert, and three-quarters of its 6m people are nomads, living from a mixture of camels' milk and fierce raids on other clans. 
 Mr Barre has stayed in power since 1969 by inviting various combinations of clans into his government, and silencing dissidents by prison or worse. 
 Many of Somalia's people have fled. 
 Mr Barre's brutality has made him plenty of enemies, and recently he has lost his knack for balancing the clans. 
 He is now backed mainly by the Marehan people. 
 If the president falls, they too may suffer. 
 The Hawiye clan, which dominates the rebel group currently threatening Mr Barre, is not thought to be vengeful. 
 But the numerous and well-educated Isaak people of the north, some 50,000 of whom have been killed by the government, are the type to settle scores. 
 Some observers are more optimistic. 
 Somalia, they say, has anyway been without effective government over the past year. 
 Mr Barre's writ is so limited that he is disparagingly known as the mayor of Mogadishu. 
 Besides, Somalia is sparsely populated. 
 Liberia's tribal bloodbath was especially awful in the cities' crowded slums. 
 Perhaps Somalia has more in common with Chad, another desert full of warlords, where the toppling of one gang by another caused no more than a bit of looting last month. 
 Outsiders prefer not to take chances. 
 Western governments are getting ready to evacuate the 500 foreigners, most of them Italian, who live in Somalia. 
 Italian and French frigates have set sail for Mogadishu. 
 The Italians have also announced that they want to send in transport aircraft. 
 The Somalis object to interference. 
 &bquo;Mogadishu is as peaceful as any European capital,&equo; the Somali embassy in Rome has explained.  
 An alternative to Saddam 
 FROM A SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN BEIRUT 
 IRAQ'S splintered opposition may at last have found its voice. 
 Representatives of 21 factions met in Beirut over Christmas to issue a joint call for Mr Saddam Hussein's overthrow in order to forestall war in the Gulf. 
 Ranging from Shia clerics to communists to Kurdish guerrilla chieftains to retired diplomats, the exiled leaders condemned both the invasion of Kuwait and the build-up of foreign forces in the region. 
 Fears that a war could ravage their country and force Iraqis to close ranks behind the regime pushed the bickering parties together. 
 General Hassan al-Nakib, formerly deputy chief of staff in the Iraqi army, argued there would be no need for any war if Mr Hussein were removed from power. 
 &bquo;It is not just for a blow to be struck against Iraq when Saddam's main victim has been innocent Iraqi people,&equo; he said. 
 The Iraqi opposition put on a credible show of unity in Beirut. 
 Confirmed secularists joked with Islamic fundamentalists at a high-security press conference called to mark the signing of a 12-point unity charter outlining a transition to democracy. 
 Leaders representing religious parties, Kurds, communists and pro-Syrian Baathists made up a steering committee which graciously answered reporters' questions. 
 By agreeing to the charter, apparently clinched by granting veto powers to all five members of the steering committee, the Iraqi opposition has ended years of factional wrangling. 
 Their differences are henceforth to take second place to the fight against Mr Hussein's regime. 
 The newly unified front has little influence inside Iraq, but members say its mere existence will refresh the embers of anti-Saddam feeling at home. 
 At this stage, says General al-Nakib, &bquo;It is important for the Iraqi people to feel there is an alternative leadership.&equo; 
 Jalal Talabani, secretary-general of the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan, believes that the creation of an opposition coalition should open the way to outside help. 
 If Mr Hussein falls, he says, the coalition will stay united long enough to hold elections in a &bquo;liberated&equo; Iraq. 
 Syria, Egypt and several Gulf states have recently given the coalition use of broadcasting equipment for a Radio Free Iraq. 
 Ayatollah Taqi al-Mudarrisi, spiritual leader of the radical Islamic Works Movement which claims to have organised three assassination attempts on the Iraqi president, says internal change in Iraq, without war, would be the best outcome for the whole region. 
 But, &bquo;by war or by peace, Saddam will be finished, and he knows this.&equo;  
 Suriname 
 Putting in the Bouterse 
 THE Dutch government is not fond of Lieut-Colonel Desi Bouterse, who runs the army and scares politicians in Suriname, the Latin American country which used to be Dutch Guiana. 
 On Christmas day they stopped sending aid to the country, because he had taken over its government yet again. 
 The Dutch had done the same in 1982, after a horrible massacre at the main army barracks in Paramaribo, the capital. 
 They cautiously resumed aid (at &dollar;58m a year) in 1987 after Mr Bouterse allowed a free election in which his own party fared badly; and were upset again last August when the chief police inspector was found with a bullet in his head near Mr Bouterse's office. 
 Mr Bouterse asked the Dutch for a visitor's visa in December. 
 They turned him down on &bquo;security grounds&equo;; a lot of the Surinamese living in Holland make it plain that they do not like him at all. 
 Three times in December he stopped over at Amsterdam airport, bound for Ghana and Switzerland and back to Paramaribo. 
 He was not allowed into the transit lounge or anywhere else on Dutch soil. 
 Suriname's president, Ramsewak Shankar, who was travelling with the colonel, was given a Dutch visa and protested at his countryman's exclusion. 
 But Mr Bouterse said Mr Shankar had not complained loudly enough, then claimed to be appalled when a Dutch newspaper photographed the president waiting forlornly in the rain for a meeting with the Dutch prime minister, Ruud Lubbers. 
 Mr Bouterse felt Suriname had been insulted. 
 Returning home on December 22nd, Mr Bouterse described Mr Shankar as a &bquo;joker&equo; and said he would resign. 
 Next day he had a better idea, and sent word to Mr Shankar that he would have to go instead. 
 The following day the army announced that the government had indeed been sent home. 
 The Dutch stopped their aid. 
 Mr Shankar and his prime minister, Henck Arron, duly resigned. 
 Two days later a figurehead president, Mr Johan Kraag, was sworn in with, as prime minister, Jules Wijdenbosch, leader of Mr Bouterse's party (which has only three seats in the 51-seat national assembly). 
 He promised free elections in 100 days. 
 Nobody believed him. 
 With only 400,000 people and lots of bauxite, there is no good reason why Suriname should not be as democratic as and rather better off than most of the little states of the Caribbean. 
 While Mr Bouterse stays in charge, that looks unlikely.  
 Syria and Egypt 
 Against Iraq 
 FROM OUR CORRESPONDENT 
 CAIRO AND DAMASCUS 
 AT FIRST it looked like tokenism. 
 Now the Arab contribution to the military alliance against Saddam Hussein is showing teeth. 
 If war starts in the Gulf, Saudi Arabia will be able to throw a big force &mdash; including about 500 tanks &mdash; into the fray. 
 And these troops have already been reinforced by some 45,000 Syrians and Egyptians, including three armoured divisions. 
 The Egyptian expeditionary force in Saudi Arabia was expected to reach its full strength this week. 
 It consists of Egypt's 3rd and 4th Armoured Divisions, plus the 145th Commando Regiment. 
 The total number of Egyptian fighting men in Saudi Arabia is put at about 27,000, with another 5,000 or so based in the United Arab Emirates. 
 These units are among the best trained and equipped in the Egyptian army. 
 Prince Khalid Bin Sultan, the Saudi general in command of the Arab and Islamic forces facing Iraq, is said to have turned pale when Egyptian commandos devoured live chickens and rabbits in a show of bravado. 
 Apart from sending troops, Egypt is helping in other ways. 
 It has waived the rules that used to bar nuclear-powered ships from using the Suez Canal, and seems to have given landing rights to American military transport aircraft. 
 Years of close military co-operation, including joint work in missile development, have given Egypt valuable information about its former Iraqi ally, which has presumably been passed on to the Americans. 
 Egyptian officials, including a former minister of defence, Muhammad Abu Ghazala, argue that Iraq's military strength has been overrated. 
 Egypt's President Hosni Mubarak, a former air-force pilot, talks like a reluctant warrior. 
 He appealed this week for last-minute talks to avert a horrific war, and his officials have implied that, if it came to a fight, Egyptian forces would not penetrate Iraq itself. 
 But the emphasis of officially inspired newspaper articles has switched from the need to defend the Saudi holy places to the need to liberate Kuwait. 
 Visitors to the Egyptian force in Saudi Arabia come away with the impression that it will not hesitate to join an attack if ordered to do so. 
 An Egyptian flanking manoeuvre through Iraqi territory north-east of Kuwait is possible. 
 The Syrian expeditionary forces have been slower to arrive, and their behaviour in the event of war is harder to predict. 
 But Syria's original token force of 3,200 men in Saudi Arabia and 600 in the United Arab Emirates has now been augmented by the arrival of a nearly-complete armoured division with Soviet-made tanks. 
 Up to 15,000 Syrian soldiers are now deployed in the Arabian peninsula. 
 Syrian officials are cagey about the mission of these troops. 
 At one point the official line was that they were there to restrain the Americans. 
 Like the Egyptians, Syria's men come under direct Saudi command, and the Saudis express confidence that they will obey whatever orders are given. 
 In Damascus some western diplomats argue that the Syrian army will keep out of any fighting, having achieved President Hafez Assad's political aim of putting him in alliance with Egypt and Saudi Arabia. 
 But Syria's press and television have lately adopted a more belligerent anti-Saddam tone. 
 Syria is unlikely to block an attack on Iraq, even if it does not join it. 
 Egypt and Syria already have strategic gains to show for their decision to rally round the Saudis. 
 Mr Mubarak has had his military debt to America forgiven, and hopes for further rewards if Egypt emerges as the saviour of the Gulf Arabs and their oil. 
 Egyptian public opinion ran strongly against Iraq after it invaded Kuwait. 
 Anger is now tempered by anxiety about the outcome of a war, but serious opposition to Mr Mubarak's policy has not, so far, emerged. 
 The gains for Mr Assad have also been large. 
 He has used the distraction of the Gulf to strengthen his hold on Lebanon and &mdash; to Israeli annoyance &mdash; improve relations with America and Britain. 
 In the Arab world Syria has atoned for its support of Iran during the previous Gulf war, and forged a lucrative friendship with Saudi Arabia. 
 Syria sponsored the recent reconciliation between Iraq's external opposition groups (see box on previous page), which might give Mr Assad useful influence with a post-war government in Iraq. 
 The greatest prize of all, after the successful removal of Mr Hussein, would be American help to recover the Golan Heights, which Israel conquered when Mr Assad was defence minister in 1967.  
 Ecuador 
 On the line 
 FROM A SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN QUITO 
 TRANQUILLITY reigns, more or less. 
 The drug war is a skirmish, the leftist gangs an irritant. 
 In those matters Ecuador refuses to imitate its turbulent neighbours. 
 It keeps its distance, too, from the latest Andean trend, for free-market economic reform. 
 If it does not follow that fashion, many observers fear the country will not sustain its usual calm. 
 The country's last president, a man of the centre-right, began by trying to liberalise things, but gave up. 
 After his election in 1984, Leon Febres Cordero lowered import barriers and subsidies, and ran a tight fiscal policy. 
 But in 1987 a huge earthquake smashed the trans-Andean oil pipeline which furnishes about half of Ecuador's exports. 
 Before it could be repaired foreign exchange ran short, and so did government income. 
 The president was more concerned about the loss of jobs. 
 He began a public-works binge, to keep people busy. 
 The public-sector deficit swelled to 10% of GDP. 
 Inflation soared. 
 In 1988 Rodrigo Borja, of the Democratic Left party, campaigned for and won the presidency with promises to help the poor. 
 By that he meant fighting inflation and running a tight fiscal policy. 
 The government deficit fell to 2.2% of GDP. 
 Inflation dropped from 86% in 1988 to 50% in 1989. 
 The highest protective tariffs were lowered, and the tax system was somewhat reformed. 
 These reforms, like Mr Borja's predecessor's, proved unpopular. 
 At the elections in June 1990, Mr Borja lost much of his congressional support, to fresh members who vie among themselves in opposition to the president. 
 Many are on the far left, others on the rabble-rousing populist right. 
 Serious economic reform seems blocked, at least until the next presidential election, due in 1992. 
 Politics, blocked, has turned macabre. 
 One day last October, as a Conservative politician, Alberto Dahik, rose to speak in Congress, a rival congressman launched a heavy glass ashtray across the chamber and hit him on the head. 
 A brawl ensued. 
 Several congressmen went home with black eyes and serious neck injuries. 
 In disarray, Congress elected as its president Averroes Bucaram, whose cousin Abdala, a right-wing populist, wants to be the country's next president. 
 (Abdala Bucaram spent much of 1990 in exile on charges, since dropped, of corruption as mayor of Guayaquil; his sister is mayor now.) 
 Soon after, Averroes Bucaram was voted out of his parliamentary post, but refused to leave quietly. 
 The police mounted an early-morning assault on his office, and Mr Bucaram came running out with his hands up. 
 Congressmen have been less pugnacious since then, and in exchange Mr Borja has stopped trying to reform things much. 
 He says he does not want to privatise loss-making state industries, or change the labour laws that make it virtually impossible for an employer to fire any employee. 
 He refuses to raise the real price of Ecuador's hugely subsidised petrol, even though the beneficiaries include Peruvian smugglers who sell the fuel across the border for ten times the Ecuadorean price. 
 Saddam Hussein has blundered to the rescue. 
 The country will get a windfall of about &dollar;250m this year from higher oil prices; that will raise government revenue by 13%. 
 GDP growth could top 2% in 1990, up from 0.2% in 1989. 
 President Borja may spend the windfall, or try to stock a &bquo;war chest&equo; for renegotiating Ecuador's &dollar;12 billion foreign debt. 
 Many businessmen think he should first try to help diversify exports. 
 Oil exports are expected to increase this year, but will soon fall back; domestic consumption is soaring (because the stuff is so cheap), and few new wells are being drilled in the forests. 
 One obstacle to new drilling is resistance by Indians, backed by Californian environmentalists. 
 After centuries of neglect, the indigenous people are waking up. 
 At the June elections, for the first time ever, they got together to block roads and occupy sites, demanding more land, and money for bilingual education. 
 Some indigenous activists say Ecuador's government had better pay attention, or face a guerrilla uprising like that in next-door Peru. 
 Meanwhile government workers have been striking for a share of the oil windfall. 
 Other Andean countries, spotting new opportunities in free trade, have agreed to get rid of most trade barriers by 1992. 
 Mr Borja, hounded by industrialists eager to protect domestic monopolies, is stalling. 
 The other Andeans say they will go on with free trade without Ecuador, if need be. 
 Ecuador could find itself very lonely indeed.  
 Argentina 
 Letting them out 
 FROM OUR ARGENTINA CORRESPONDENT 
 HE CRUSHED a military rising, then granted the army's long-standing demand that he should release its jailed generals. 
 By releasing five senior officers imprisoned for crimes committed while they ran the country, from 1976 to 1983, President Carlos Menem may have hoped to eliminate much of the discontent that lay behind three rebellions against his predecessor, Raul Alfonsin, and one against himself on December 3rd. 
 But the perpetual unrest in Argentina's armed forces may not be disposed of so fast. 
 The elderly men released by Mr Menem were the chiefs of the &bquo;dirty war&equo; against subversion, in which at least 9,000 civilians, unconvicted of any crime, died or disappeared. 
 The president has not exonerated the officers, nor declared them innocent. 
 He has merely set them free, while also freeing some of those whose acts they claimed as justification for their own misdeeds. 
 On his release General Jorge Videla, who unleashed both the military coup in 1976 and the campaign of repression that followed, promptly demanded vindication of the campaign, and was echoed privately by several serving officers. 
 The decision has incensed many civilians, and prompted demonstrations. 
 Yet it may not be enough to satisfy the many officers who refuse to admit that the army was guilty. 
 It is still less likely to placate the soldiers who backed the failed uprising of December 3rd. 
 The leaders of that mutiny included Colonel Mohammed Ali Seineldin, a notorious trouble-maker and veteran of uprisings against ex-President Alfonsin. 
 But, of the 600 men arrested after the failure of the latest rising, only six others had been in similar trouble before. 
 This latest coup was attempted not by officers anxious to vindicate the army's honour, but by disgruntled sergeants and corporals, most of them too young to have taken part in the dirty war. 
 The arrested 600 included 33 officers and 540 non-commissioned officers, the vast majority of them aged 33 or less. 
 They have plenty to be angry about. 
 Argentine sergeants, who these days can usually read and write, are seldom promoted to be officers. 
 Their pay and conditions are miserable and there are far more of them than the army can usefully employ. 
 Since the early 1980s the army's strength and budget have been cut in half. 
 The average number of conscripts in training has fallen from 80,000 to about 15,000. 
 The command structure has not been cut to match. 
 For every 250 soldiers there is a general, for every three soldiers an officer. 
 Sergeants and corporals outnumber private soldiers. 
 They have too few people to boss about, but no shortage of guns and grievances. 
 Mr Menem's show of leniency towards a few elderly officers may not keep them quiet for long.  
 African famines 
 Yet again 
 While the world watches the Gulf, hunger stalks Africa. 
 Our correspondents report from Khartoum and Maputo 
 THE rich world would love to forget Africa, but its miseries are too awful to ignore. 
 The United Nations' World Food Programme says that more than 20m Africans will depend on food aid this year &mdash; more, by far, than during the horrors in the Horn of Africa six years ago. 
 The Horn is the worst of Africa's endangered regions. 
 This is its third famine warning in four years, and the direst so far. 
 The UN reckons it will need to get 2.2m tonnes of food from outside this year, and wants another 1.6m for the rest of black Africa (see chart on next page). 
 That makes a total of 3.8m tonnes for all black Africa, the highest estimate the UN has ever made. 
 It dwarfs the 1.4m tonnes the UN called for, on average, in each of the three years 1987&ndash;89. 
 The previous warnings in the Horn were, like the present one, prompted by severe drought. 
 But disaster, when it came, was less severe than had been foretold. 
 The UN's predictions of famine owe more to art than science. 
 Aid workers use many methods. 
 They measure rainfall. 
 They watch markets. 
 When grain prices rise, a seasonal shortage is developing; if the rise carries through a harvest season, serious trouble is likely. 
 A fall in the price of meat suggests that there is no grain to feed livestock &mdash; but by the time this happens the famine is about to begin. 
 Satellite photographs offer earlier warning. 
 They show where vegetation is growing, but not what kind. 
 To determine whether the dark patches on the computer map mean weeds, trees or crops, aid workers have to visit the spot. 
 That is not always possible. 
 Predictions about Ethiopia's chronically drought-afflicted highlands are particularly sketchy, because civil war makes them hard to reach. 
 In Sudan, by contrast, forecasters claim to have visited all areas badly affected by 1990's drought. 
 In fact, little is known about drought's most likely victims, who often live beyond the reach of the aid workers' vehicles. 
 Nobody is sure how many people live in each region or how much they normally eat. 
 And peasants in areas prone to drought are good at surviving. 
 They collect seeds and wild berries, and dig up secret hoards of grain. 
 One bad year is rarely enough to produce famine. 
 Donors delivered a bit less than two-thirds of what was thought necessary after Ethiopia's 1989 crop failure. 
 It seems to have been enough, as was the amount delivered by the big but war-disrupted relief programme that followed the 1987 drought. 
 Both the 1987 and 1989 crop failures followed good years. 
 Partly because of anguish that they failed to anticipate Ethiopia's 1984&ndash;85 famine, and partly to cajole rich countries into giving lots of food, aid workers do tend to err on the side of exaggeration. 
 Yet complacency now would be wrong. 
 For Ethiopia and Sudan, it is the second bad year in a row (and the third bad year in four). 
 Reserves are known to be low in Sudan, and thought to be low in Ethiopia. 
 The UN says the two together need more than 2m tonnes of emergency food, and smaller agencies agree. 
 Even if only half that much were needed, a 20-tonne lorry would have to be loaded somewhere every eight minutes, day and night, for nine months. 
 No relief effort will work if war and politics get in the way. 
 In Sudan President Omar el Bashir's government has refused to admit to the famine, declaring only a &bquo;temporary food gap&equo; of 75,000 tonnes. 
 It has expelled aid workers who said more was needed. 
 Peasants in Western Sudan have already exhausted their berries and grain caches, and are starting to leave their villages in search of food. 
 If they settle in relief camps around the big cities, they will die of cholera and other epidemics. 
 Worse, the president promised on new year's eve to implement Islamic sharia law, which will probably aggravate his war against the non-Muslim rebels of Sudan's south. 
 Ethiopia is more hopeful, despite its civil wars. 
 The government has allowed food to arrive at the port of Assab, which it controls, and to be moved into the rebel-held province of Tigre. 
 Last month another group of rebels, the Eritrean People's Liberation Front, promised to be equally generous with the port of Massawa: it said it would allow food to be moved from there to the government-held town of Asmara. 
 Yet the Eritreans have shelled Asmara's airport. 
 Angola's Marxist government used to be as inhospitable to aid workers as Sudan. 
 But the ruling party's congress last month promised to establish a multi-party democracy. 
 The past year's thaw has made it possible for at least 35 non-governmental organisations to open up offices. 
 They have lost no time in sounding the alarm about an impending famine, which they say threatens 1.9m people. 
 Western diplomats in Luanda scoff at that figure, though they admit that many do need help. 
 The UN has organised &bquo;peace corridors&equo; to get food across the battle lines that divide the government and the UNITA rebels. 
 They have not been respected. 
 On December 20th the official news agency reported that rebels had destroyed a bridge in Huila province, across which 25 tonnes of relief supplies were supposed to have moved to two isolated garrison towns. 
 The next day the Angolan government said it would allow no more food into rebel-held areas, and the UN suspended its operation. 
 Mozambique also wrestles with the effects of civil war. 
 The 1m Mozambicans who have fled to Malawi are easily reachable. 
 Inside Mozambique it is hard to deliver anything safely. 
 In December a conference of donors pledged more than &dollar;1 billion in aid for 1991, including relief supplies for the central province of Zambezia, where at least 250,000 people were forced off their land last year by rebel or government attacks. 
 In December the Red Cross persuaded both sides to allow it to cross their battle lines. 
 The UN hopes to follow this up with ceasefires in Zambezia and the north-western province of Tete. 
 But much food aid is stolen as it is unloaded at the ports; and army-escorted convoys manage to lose up to a third of their cargoes on the way. 
 Mozambique produces only 15% of the food it needs to keep its markets stocked; theft is rife. 
 If a peace treaty brought those 1m refugees home from Malawi, the competition for food would get even fiercer.  
 The pardoners' tale 
 WHEN military dictators fall, the democrats who follow them must try to restore the rule of law, as well as rule by the majority. 
 They may therefore hope to arrange trials for criminals who served the dictator. 
 But trying military wrongdoers may annoy the armed forces, and provoke a fresh coup. 
 Over the new year holidays, the elected governments of Argentina (see previous page) and of Greece got tangled in the consequences. 
 Argentina's military dictatorship collapsed in 1983, its ruling generals discredited because they launched and lost the Falklands war. 
 The soldiers who ran Greece until 1974 were similarly discredited, because one result of their folly was the occupation by Turkey of northern Cyprus. 
 In both countries the democrats put the failed generals in jail &mdash; disgraced, but not forgotten by their fellow-officers. 
 Keeping old men in prison is a waste. 
 Letting them out can be damaging. 
 In Argentina President Carlos Menem looks even weaker since he released the generals. 
 The Greek prime minister, Mr Constantine Mitsotakis, looks downright incompetent: at first he said he would pardon the guilty men, then took that back and said he would merely release them. 
 There are better routes from dictatorship to democracy. 
 The transition is easiest when the dictators themselves take the initiative. 
 Turkey (until 1983) and Brazil (until 1985) were ruled by relatively law-abiding military juntas which, in the end, decided to hand over power. 
 They chose their own successors, had them elected, and watched while their prot&eacute;g&eacute;s acquired both democratic respectability and democratic unpopularity. 
 There was no chance that the ex-dictators would stand trial, and no real need for them to do so. 
 In Uruguay a junta that fought subversion almost as brutally as Argentina's collapsed under its own disagreements in 1984. 
 Genuine elections followed, but the democratic rulers did not dare put their military predecessors on trial. 
 When, at last, they were compelled to call a referendum on whether to do so, a solid majority voted not to try officers for crimes committed while they held power. 
 Chile's more recent difficulty is similar. 
 The old dictator, General Augusto Pinochet, called a referendum that he hoped would confirm him in power, and was baffled when he lost it. 
 Before stepping unrepentantly down (in 1989), he entrenched himself as commander of the army for six further years, intending thus to protect the criminals who had done the dirty work while he was president. 
 His successor, President Patricio Aylwin, has coped with that legacy not by trying soldiers for military murders, but by waiting for General Pinochet to discredit himself, as he is rapidly doing. 
 Chile's political soldiers are keeping quiet. 
 Democrats must respect the rule of law. 
 But the transition to democracy goes smoothest when military murderers are left unpunished &mdash; and unpardoned. 
 EUROPE 
 Supertsar without superpolicy 
 IF Gorbachev the Great is looking more and more like Mixed-up Mikhail, it is not just because he has an impossible job. 
 He has made several big mistakes. 
 One was his failure to hold a direct election for the presidency last year. 
 Mr Gorbachev might well have won such a vote, and added to his formal powers the authority he now lacks. 
 Then there was his failure to embrace the Shatalin plan for market reforms, which, for all its faults, would have meant a clear break with the centrally planned past. 
 And Mr Gorbachev was far too late in proposing a new deal to the various republics. 
 His current offer would have seemed attractive to them a couple of years back, but not now. 
 With luck, Mr Gorbachev may also have left it too late to make a fourth big mistake: returning his country to dictatorship. 
 Optimists reckon that reform has already gone too far to allow that. 
 But the pessimists include Edward Shevardnadze, whose sudden resignation as foreign minister set the tone at the meeting from December 17th to 27th of the Congress of People's Deputies, the Soviet super-parliament. 
 Mr Shevardnadze, worn out by the struggle for reform, used his resignation speech to the Congress to give warning that a new dictatorship was in preparation. 
 A hardline tirade by General Vladimir Kryuchkov, the head of the KGB, strengthened the impression that conservative forces were on the rise. 
 So did Mr Gorbachev's nomination of Gennady Yanaev, a Communist apparatchik, for the new post of vice-president (a fine choice, said that figurehead of Soviet conservatism, Yegor Ligachev). 
 The Congress approved most of the new powers Mr Gorbachev had requested, including direct control over the government and over a new security council. 
 These are powers which, if abused, could quickly turn him into a dictator. 
 What has brought about the change in Mr Gorbachev? 
 Perhaps, in a sense, there has been no change. 
 Nearly six years since Mr Gorbachev came to power, it is still unclear what sort of future he has in mind for the Soviet Union. 
 Suppose for a moment that Mr Gorbachev himself does not know what he has in mind; assume that he is just a moderniser with no clear idea where modernising leads. 
 The one certainty is that he has consistently sought to secure his own position, mostly by presenting himself as a sensible centrist between the extremes to his right and left. 
 He has continued to cling to the middle ground, but that ground has been shifting. 
 So long as radicals were on the rampage, staying in the centre meant leaning ever farther towards liberal reform. 
 Now that a reaction is setting in, Mr Gorbachev is leaning back towards the conservatives to keep his balance. 
 And he is still on his feet. 
 At last month's meeting of the Congress he showed again how he can play on the mutual fears of reformers and conservatives to get his own way. 
 He won few friends, but he won the votes that mattered to him. 
 The Congress approved in principal his draft Union Treaty (though the vote was taken in the absence of deputies from some of the most independent-minded republics, who boycotted the Congress). 
 It accepted Mr Yanaev as vice-president (but only after an embarrassing failure in the first vote and some heavyweight intervention by Mr Gorbachev). 
 And it granted Mr Gorbachev most of the new powers he had requested (though it rejected his clumsy proposal for a system of local inspectors to help enforce presidential decrees). 
 Now that he has these powers, what will he do with them? 
 People are unlikely to pay much more attention to his decisions just because there has been some fiddling with the constitution. 
 And enforcing his policies is only part of the problem. 
 The other part is having coherent policies in the first place. 
 Mr Gorbachev still lacks them in the two areas that matter most. 
 One is the economy. 
 Mr Gorbachev has again postponed a decision on what sort of economic system he is aiming for by referring the question of private land ownership to a referendum; when this will take place and exactly what it will ask are not yet decided. 
 Meanwhile, he enters 1991 without an economic plan or budget (so everyone is having to improvise with last year's targets), and without a prime minister to blame for mismanagement (Nikolai Ryzhkov, who for months had been under pressure to resign and was about to be sidelined anyway, had a heart attack on December 25th). 
 Most ominously, Mr Gorbachev faces a drastic loss of revenue to the central budget from the rebellious republics. 
 The three Baltic states are refusing to pay anything. 
 But the biggest loss will come if the giant Russian republic carries out its decision, taken last week, to cut its contribution to the central budget by more than four-fifths. 
 Unless Mr Gorbachev can persuade &mdash; or force &mdash; Russia and others to back down, he will either have to print roubles even more furiously than before (result: hyperinflation), or else he will be unable to pay for the huge central bureaucracy and, more seriously, for the army. 
 Of all the challenges thrown at Mr Gorbachev by Boris Yeltsin, the president of the Russian republic, this is easily the greatest. 
 Thus the muddle over the economy is inseparable from Mr Gorbachev's other main policy muddle: the relationship between the centre and the 15 Soviet republics. 
 &bquo;Preserving the union&equo; has become the president's first priority: a &bquo;sacred cause&equo;, he called it in his new year's message. 
 His strategy for achieving this by persuasion is not convincing. 
 The Federation Council, upgraded as part of his constitutional changes approved by the Congress, is meant to give the republics a share of central power and responsibility. 
 But it promises to be an unwieldy body, including the heads of 20 &bquo;autonomous republics&equo; as well as those presidents of the 15 fully fledged republics who agree to turn up to its meetings. 
 Mr Gorbachev's proposed Union Treaty is, like the matter of land ownership, to go to a referendum. 
 But that will not settle the trickiest question: whether those republics which are determined not to be part of the Soviet Union will be allowed their independence, or whether they will be kept in by force. 
 Fears of a crackdown have been strongest in the Baltic republics and Moldavia. 
 The Moldavians, given an ultimatum by Mr Gorbachev to settle their ethnic conflicts by the year's end, decided to compromise rather than test the president's readiness to resort to force. 
 Several bombs have gone off in Latvia; the locals think these were planted to give the army a possible excuse to move in. 
 On December 29th, in response to &bquo;provocations and threats made by the Soviet military leadership&equo;, the foreign ministers of Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania issued a statement calling on the Soviet Union to renounce the use of &bquo;further military force&equo; against the Baltic countries. 
 For now Mr Gorbachev is just managing to continue what he does best: keeping his show on the road. 
 The trouble is that nobody knows where the road leads. 
 And the show threatens at any moment to turn ugly.  
 The latest French revolution 
 FROM OUR PARIS CORRESPONDENT 
 THE French feel passionately about their native tongue. 
 In the absence of a monarchy, it has come to symbolise their national identity. 
 Clemenceau described it as &bquo;the genius of our race&hellip; the perfect vehicle for thought.&equo; 
 Anatole France, more effusive, likened it to a woman who &bquo;is so beautiful, so proud, so modest, so tough, so touching, so voluptuous, so chaste, so noble, so familiar, so crazy, and so good that one loves her with all one's soul, and one is never tempted to be unfaithful to her.&equo; 
 Yet it looks as if that most precious of ladies may be about to be raped &mdash; and what is more, by the very group of her countrymen set up to defend her honour and purity. 
 The French government has just approved a whole range of radical spelling changes, proposed by the government-appointed Conseil Sup&eacute;rieur de la Langue Fran&ccedil;aise, which will deform some of the most familiar French words, obfuscate their etymological origins and massacre many an adopted foreign word. 
 In the name of a claimed desire to simplify current spelling and remove anomalies and contradictions, it is now decreed, for example, that plurals of all foreign words will henceforth take an s , as in French. 
 Thus le rugbyman  (as the French call a rugby player) becomes les rugbymans  and they will play in matchs , not matches . 
 A singer of German songs will sing Lieds  rather than Lieder ; Bavaria will be spoken of as one of the German Lands  rather than L&auml;nder . 
 M&eacute;dia  and graffiti  (both already plural nouns) will become m&eacute;dias  and graffitis . 
 On the other hand, foreign words that already end in s , x  or z  &mdash; all legitimate plural endings in French &mdash; are now to remain invariable. 
 Thus a secretary will work for many boss  (not bosses ). 
 Words of English and other foreign origin will also become more difficult to recognise by the decision to remove the hyphen from many compound words. 
 Le fair-play  (which already takes a hyphen in French) becomes le fairplay , and le blue-jean  (which has already lost its s ) becomes le bluejean . 
 The Latin a priori  becomes the odd-looking apriori , and that useful little vade-mecum  becomes the much more cumbersome vad&eacute;m&eacute;cum  (complete with accents which are now to be added, where appropriate, to all borrowed Latin and foreign words, as in m&eacute;morandum , all&eacute;gretto , &eacute;delweiss , p&eacute;digr&eacute;e ). 
 Many compound French words will also lose their hyphens. 
 Some fusions seem sensible enough and in line with current usage, as in croquemonsieur . 
 But others seem designed to confuse, such as the curious vanupied  &mdash; formerly va-nu-pieds , meaning ragamuffin. 
 Other expressions, however, are to gain hyphens, as will all numbers over 100 (lesser numbers already have them); so 1,482 will now be written as mille-quatre-cents-quatre-vingts-deux . 
 In an attempt to get Frenchmen to pronounce borrowed words &bquo;properly&equo; (ie, with a French accent), all English words ending in er  are now to be written eur ; so le leader  and le speaker  become le leadeur  and le speakeur . 
 But, bafflingly for foreigners, when the er  is pronounced (in French) like mer  (sea), the word will keep its er  ending, as in docker , r&eacute;volver , starter . 
 In the interest of supposed consistency, circumflex accents are to be summarily abolished on all i  and u  vowels, despite their frequent help in indicating a missing s from a word's Latin root. 
 So if you want to invite the schoolmaster to taste some expensive oysters in August, you will henceforth have to invite the rather naked-looking maitre &agrave; gouter des huitres couteuses en aout . 
 The only exceptions to this rule will be where the circumflex indicates a change of meaning as in je&ucirc;ne  (fast) as opposed to jeune  (young), or in m&ucirc;r  (ripe) as opposed to mur  (wall). 
 The circumflex will stay on other vowels in order, you are told, to indicate (usually) an elongation of the vowel sound as in m&acirc;le , h&ocirc;tel  and &ecirc;tre . 
 Other oddities creep in with the attempt to harmonise plurals of French compound words. 
 All compound words will henceforth take an s  (or x , as appropriate) in the plural. 
 Thus the previously invariable apr&egrave;s-midi  (afternoon) and abat-jour  (lampshade) become apr&egrave;s-midis  and abat-jours  in the plural. 
 Fine. 
 But exceptions have had to be made for words like prie-Dieu  (prayer-stool), which will remain without an x  in the plural so as to avoid blasphemous implications. 
 And in order to accommodate the general rule it has been deemed necessary to deprive certain compound words, like s&egrave;che-cheveux , of their plural endings when used in the singular. 
 So if you want to use just one dryer for your hair, you will now have to use the curiously inefficient-sounding s&egrave;che-cheveu , as if you had only one hair to dry. 
 Many of the new rules seem as arbitrary as the old familiar ones. 
 In the name, once more, of consistency, all verbs ending in eler  or eter  will henceforth follow the pattern of the verbs peler  and acheter , always taking an accent as they decline, instead of sometimes doubling their last consonant. 
 Thus ruisseler  (to flow) becomes il ruiss&egrave;le  in the third person singular instead of the prettier il ruisselle . 
 However, an exception is to be made for appeler  n and jeter  (and their derivatives), which are to be allowed to continue to double their last consonant on the ground that these verbs are &bquo;more fixed in common usage&equo;. 
 More helpful, perhaps, for both native and foreign speakers of French is the decision to make accents correspond to the way words should be pronounced. 
 Thus &eacute;v&eacute;nement  becomes &eacute;v&egrave;nement  and cr&eacute;merie  becomes cr&egrave;merie . 
 The correction of certain anomalies also seems to make sense. 
 Boursoufler  (to swell, puff up) will take a double ff  as in souffler , and d&eacute;siller  (to open the eyes of, undeceive) becomes d&eacute;ciller  to show its link with cil  (eyelash). 
 But changes in (to foreigners) more familiar words look all wrong, whatever their linguistic justification. 
 Oignon  (onion) becomes ognon  on the ground that this is how it is pronounced (what would happen to Inglish if it were spelled phonetically?). 
 And your favourite relais  (inn) as you drive through France becomes a mere relai . 
 The French are interventionist by nature. 
 They are constantly seeking to impose changes from above on their language, rather than allowing it to live, breathe and evolve in a more natural way. 
 In 1740, for example, the Acad&eacute;mie Fran&ccedil;aise decreed spelling changes in one word in four. 
 In 1835 the oi  diphthong was systematically changed to ai  in accordance with modern pronunciation in words like fran&ccedil;ois . 
 More recently there has been the (largely ineffective) battle to stop the spread of franglais , involving the introduction of a law in 1975 and two subsequent government decrees banning the use of all American and English words and expressions in advertisements, official documents and on radio and television, whenever a French alternative was possible. 
 This time there is to be no law or sanctions. 
 The old spelling is to continue to be &bquo;tolerated&equo; until the new version has come into general use. 
 The government has nevertheless seen fit to give the new rules an official stamp by publishing them in its Journal Officiel , through which all new laws and decrees are promulgated. 
 All primary schools will be required to teach the new rules from this autumn. 
 New books and dictionaries are expected to contain the new spellings, while Proust, Racine and the rest will gradually be re-edited so as to make them conform. 
 A resistance movement is already emerging. 
 Twenty-four of France's better-known writers have decided to mark the new year by launching a national petition against the reforms. 
 They have set up a grand-sounding association dedicated to resisting the spelling changes. 
 Support is said to be flooding in. 
 The hole afair wood be a j&ocirc;ke if it wer not so seerius.  
 Italy 
 Rebellion in the ranks 
 FROM OUR ROME CORRESPONDENT 
 THE grand old men of Italy's Christian Democratic Party may be in for a shock. 
 Politics as they know it &mdash; the system that has kept them in power for the past 45 years &mdash; is being challenged by two younger men from their own party. 
 Mario Segni, a professor of law and Sardinian member of parliament, is the chief promoter of three referendums on electoral reform that are intended to reshape Italian politics. 
 Even the threat of these reforms may be enough to bring the government down. 
 The Christian Democratic prime minister, Giulio Andreotti, is afraid that his Socialist coalition partners will walk out on him if the referendums look like going ahead this year; by provoking a general election, the Socialists would automatically put off the referendums for at least 12 months. 
 The other rebel is Leoluca Orlando, a popular former mayor of Palermo who made his name fighting the Mafia. 
 He has promised to launch his own broad-based party before the next general election. 
 Like Mr Segni, Mr Orlando says electoral reform is essential if Italy is to escape from its &bquo;political quagmire&equo;. 
 The old system, both men argue, spawns weak governments and corrupt parties. 
 Whereas Mr Orlando has long been a troublesome hero for his party, Mr Segni does not look like a troublemaker. 
 A shy man from a conservative Catholic family (his father, ex-President Antonio Segni, belonged to the right wing of the Christian Democrats), he has rallied a wide range of supporters to his reform campaign: free-thinking radicals, communists, a Catholic bishop, trade unionists, the influential Rome daily La Repubblica and the top ranks of Confindustria, Italy's employers' association, as well as Mr Orlando himself. 
 Mr Segni's acolytes have collected more than 600,000 signatures in favour of his three referendums. 
 So long as these are approved by Italy's constitutional court, they must be put to the vote by mid-June. 
 Both Mr Segni, who is 50, and Mr Orlando, who is 43, reproach their party for its inability to bring in new blood and fresh ideas. 
 The party's ageing faction leaders, says Mr Segni, have turned into pure power brokers. 
 Mr Orlando, who last month took a deep breath and announced his intention of leaving the Christian Democrats to lead his own party, is the more bitter of the two. 
 After municipal elections last June, Mr Andreotti and the Christian Democrats' party secretary, Arnaldo Forlani, vetoed Mr Orlando's attempt to renew a coalition with the Communists and the Greens with which he had ruled for three of his five years as mayor of Palermo. 
 Mr Orlando was forced to step down as mayor despite his popularity with the voters. 
 Mr Orlando's departure from the party will be greeted with a sigh of relief by some. 
 But Mr Segni says it could be a mistake to underestimate the electoral force of la rete, the &bquo;network&equo; Mr Orlando wants to turn into a political party. 
 Mr Orlando, who says honesty is the sole credential for membership of his new party, could win votes both from disillusioned Christian Democrats and from former Communists disoriented by their party's recent change of name. 
 He has the tacit support of religious leaders in Italy's crime-ridden south. 
 Even the pope recently reproached local politicians on a visit to Naples for their self-interest and neglect of their constituents. 
 Mr Segni's proposed referendums on electoral reform are hotly opposed by Bettino Craxi's Socialist Party. 
 Mr Craxi thinks the new rules would penalise smaller parties such as his own; hence the speculation that he would rather bring down the government than allow the referendums to happen. 
 If it came to constitutional change, he would prefer it to involve the introduction of direct presidential elections &mdash; no doubt hoping that the first directly elected president would be none other than himself. 
 Mr Andreotti, inveterate beneficiary of the existing system, is hostile to Mr Segni's proposals, but has surprised his own party by expressing interest in Mr Craxi's idea. 
 Mr Segni says he resorted to referendums after more than ten years of fruitless debate within the party on institutional reform. 
 The referendums would, if approved, overhaul Italy's current system of pure proportional representation. 
 Referendums cannot be used to make significant changes in the voting system for the lower house of parliament. 
 So Mr Segni's targets are the Senate, Italy's upper house, and municipal assemblies. 
 Under his scheme they would be elected by something close to Britain's first-past-the-post system. 
 Small parties would be the losers; senators would have to pay more attention to their constituents and would be less beholden to their party machines. 
 The aim would be to produce clearer majorities and more responsive governments. 
 For Italy, it would be a mini-revolution.  
 Yugoslavia 
 Waiting for Slobo 
 FROM A SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN YUGOSLAVIA 
 IT IS an exercise in blinkmanship. 
 Serbia, Yugoslavia's largest republic, is trying to stare down Croatia and Slovenia, the two western republics that are threatening to go their own way. 
 They are returning the stare in the hope of forcing the powerful Serbs to blink first and let them leave. 
 On December 22nd Croatia's parliament in Zagreb adopted a new constitution which says that &bquo;Croatia remains a part of Yugoslavia until a new agreement among the republics, or until the Croat parliament decides otherwise.&equo; 
 The next day Slovenia held a referendum on independence. 
 The turnout was 94%, and 89% of the voters said Yes to a &bquo;sovereign and independent&equo; Slovenia, either within a Yugoslav confederation or, if that could not be achieved in six months, on its own. 
 Serbia tried to stop the Slovene referendum by asking the federal constitutional court in Belgrade to rule it illegal. 
 The court astonished everybody by deciding that it could not rule on the legality or otherwise of something that had not happened yet. 
 There was great relief in Croatia and Slovenia: bringing the court into play had been seen there (probably correctly) as a potential device for justifying an army intervention. 
 In anticipation of an army coup, Croatia and Slovenia had placed on alert the security forces under their control &mdash; the police and the newly formed gendarmerie, the so-called specijalci. 
 These &bquo;specials&equo; are still there, guarding public buildings in Zagreb and Ljubljana. 
 Civilian activists are positioned around army barracks, tracking army units' movements and reporting to special emergency headquarters. 
 But Croat and Slovene leaders have reiterated their willingness to sit down with the Serbs and others to work out how Yugoslavia could be turned into a body not unlike the European Community. 
 Bosnia &amp; Hercegovina and Macedonia, under their new non-communist leaderships, favour any new Yugoslav deal that would restrain Serbia. 
 Bosnia's new president, Alija Izetbegovic, a devout Muslim and a former political prisoner, has already had exploratory talks with Croat, Serb and Slovene leaders. 
 Macedonia's main nationalist party has welcomed both the Slovene referendum and the new Croat constitution. 
 But what of Serbia, which has the power to wreck any deal cobbled together by the others? 
 Its leader, Slobodan Milosevic (&bquo;Slobo&equo; to his friends), has for the past three years resisted any idea of a looser Yugoslavia. 
 On the contrary, he has pressed for a centralised federation in which Serbia would presumably play a dominant role. 
 Last month he and his Socialist Party (the renamed Communists) won both the presidential and the parliamentary elections; the victories were convincing, despite evidence of vote-rigging. 
 Some people in Serbia suspect that Slobo, an impulsive man, might one day decide to go it alone. 
 With Kosovo and Vojvodina under his belt and Montenegro to come (perhaps after a referendum there leading to that republic's formal incorporation into Serbia), he could have a respectable country to run. 
 But not just yet. 
 The biggest problem is Serbia's economy. 
 Many factory closures are on the way, with perhaps as many as 600,000 jobs at risk. 
 There is the heavy cost of occupying unhappy Kosovo, where 90% of the population are Albanians. 
 Neither Croatia nor Slovenia could afford to bribe Serbia into letting them go. 
 They themselves face the threat of social unrest over the coming factory closures. 
 But they can see that there are advantages, worth paying a price for, to an orderly, step-by-step separation, as the federal prime minister, Ante Markovic, reminded everybody recently. 
 He himself has an eye on the post of super-manager of a new Yugoslav &bquo;economic space&equo; and has called leaders from all the republics to talks on January 10th. 
 But even if, for sound economic reasons, bargaining about a new, looser Yugoslavia starts in earnest, much could go wrong. 
 An uprising in Kosovo, put down by force, could ruin the chances of accommodation between Serbia and the rest. 
 There could be trouble from the Serbs in Bosnia and Croatia. 
 The army's impatient colonels and majors may yet overrule the more cautious generals and decide to have a go. 
 So there is still an uncomfortably strong possibility that the Yugoslav confrontation may end messily, perhaps even bloodily, just as it might in the Soviet Union, where Yugoslav events are followed with special interest. 
 On December 24th in Moscow a Ukrainian member of the Congress of People's Deputies rose to welcome Croat and Slovene moves towards independence, but he was shouted down. 
 Neither in the Soviet Union nor in Yugoslavia have the centralisers blinked yet.  
 Czechoslovakia 
 Fissures in the Forum 
 FROM OUR PRAGUE CORRESPONDENT 
 JANUARY 1st dawned in Czechoslovakia and the world did not come to an end. 
 This despite the increasingly apocalyptic talk about the inflation and unemployment that would arrive with the launch on new year's day of a set of economic reforms: price liberalisation, the sale of small businesses and internal convertibility of the crown (meaning that Czechoslovak firms licensed to conduct foreign trade can now buy as much foreign currency as they want at the newly unified exchange rate). 
 Shops were empty from panic-buying ahead of Czechoslovakia's &bquo;big bang&equo; &mdash; which is turning out to be more like a big pop. 
 The changes will take several months to make much difference to most people's lives (price controls remain on basic foods, heating and transport; the auctions of small businesses will begin only at the end of January). 
 But the reforms are already having a big impact on the politicians, who are deeply divided about how best to deal with the social tensions the reforms are expected to produce. 
 In Civic Forum, Czechoslovakia's largest political group, divorce is in the air. 
 Cracks within the Forum have been apparent ever since last June's general election. 
 Some of its members interpreted the result as showing that voters preferred a broad movement such as the Forum to the sort of disciplined party that had misruled Czechoslovakia for more than 40 years. 
 But the Forum's new chairman, Vaclav Klaus, had other ideas. 
 Mr Klaus, who is also the finance minister, has used the Forum's regional activists as a base to gain backing for his own conception &mdash; a right-of-centre party with a stricter line of command. 
 Last month he emerged from a meeting in the northern city of Olomouc with support for his &bquo;Olomouc theses&equo;, which outlined his ideas for the Forum in advance of its conference, due to open on January 12th. 
 A long list of prominent politicians &mdash; including the foreign minister, Jiri Dienstbier, and a deputy prime minister, Pavel Rychetsky &mdash; promptly launched the so-called Civic Forum Liberal Club. 
 It aims to emphasise &bquo;human values and the rights of the individual&equo; during the process of economic reform. 
 This is widely understood as a call to arms to defend the movement against a takeover by Mr Klaus. 
 All the members of the Forum say they want to avoid a split at this month's conference; but most now reckon a split is unavoidable. 
 President Vaclav Havel, who counts many Liberal Club signatories among his closest friends, has refrained from taking sides. 
 But the club's rhetoric echoes his own recent comments that economic reform should be a &bquo;means to an end rather than a goal in itself&equo;. 
 In his new year's message he urged the government to mitigate its harshest effects. 
 According to the Klaus camp, the Liberal Club is in fact a group of left-wingers bent on slowing the pace of reform. 
 Mr Klaus and his supporters claim to be the &bquo;real&equo; liberals, with their hard-headed free-market philosophy. 
 But Mr Rychetsky argues that the Liberal Club is merely trying to safeguard the reforms by winning popular support for them. 
 Besides, say the Liberal Club's supporters, Civic Forum has a responsibility to carry out its programme and must continue to function until the next general election, in less than two years' time. 
 By all means let different groups within the Forum emerge, but they should remain within the movement until the election. 
 It is not clear how much of the argument is really about policy, and how much about personality. 
 Mr Klaus irritates a lot of people. 
 &bquo;Everyone knows that the Liberal Club is just a name for people opposed to Klaus,&equo; says a financial expert who shares the minister's economic ideas. 
 &bquo;He is a splitter. 
 He is one of the most able men I've ever met but he's a disastrous politician.&equo;  
 Germany 
 New Jews, old guilt 
 FROM OUR BERLIN CORRESPONDENT 
 WEST GERMANY'S immigration laws were famously liberal in guaranteeing asylum to political refugees. 
 Now, with the opening of Eastern Europe, united Germany has become the preferred destination for thousands of refugees fleeing hardship at home. 
 This is making Chancellor Helmut Kohl's government think about a new immigration policy. 
 Last summer Berlin's streets suddenly became home to thousands of Romanian and Bulgarian refugees, many of them gypsies, who took advantage of easy entry into soon-to-disappear East Germany to gain access to the West. 
 In recent weeks, however, it has been the sudden rise in the number of Soviet Jews that has alarmed the authorities. 
 Unlike their fellow Soviet citizens, Jews can now apply for passports and leave the Soviet Union with relative ease. 
 Many are leaving out of a fear of growing anti-Semitism. 
 They are mostly heading for Israel, but a lot would prefer to stay in Europe. 
 Rich Germany is a magnet. 
 This presents Germany, still haunted by guilt from the Nazi years, with an awkward problem. 
 The government wants to tighten immigration controls, but it does not want to be seen as anti-Semitic. 
 The L&auml;nder (federal states), which are responsible for integrating refugees, complain about the cost. 
 They want strict quotas introduced. 
 The premiers of the 16 L&auml;nder are due to meet on January 9th to decide what the quotas should be (some seem inclined to be far more generous than others). 
 The notion of quotas has angered the Central Council for Jews in Germany, whose chairman, Heinz Galinski, has said that this would represent a sinister form of selection. 
 The Council, for historical reasons an influential force in German politics, would like to see the Soviet Jews welcomed in Germany. 
 Israel, on the other hand, would prefer to draw them to the land of their forefathers. 
 The German government is treading carefully. 
 Immigration laws inherited from the former East German state, which were due to expire on January 1st, are being allowed to carry on for Soviet Jews arriving in Berlin. 
 Berlin is therefore still the destination for virtually all Soviet Jews arriving in Germany. 
 At present the authorities in Berlin are having difficulty coping with those who have arrived so far, though no more than 1,100 or so have come in the past few days. 
 But the numbers are expected to rise sharply. 
 BRITAIN 
 Making money out of museums 
 MOST self-respecting museum directors will now be counting up the takings from the holiday season. 
 Few can rival the Natural History Museum's offer of drinks beneath its dinosaur, but Christmas and new-year parties have become a nice little earner for museums and galleries right across the country. 
 They need the cash. 
 Despite an increase of 8.5% in the public subsidy for national museums in 1991&ndash;92, most are still struggling to come to terms with the squeeze imposed on their budgets by the Treasury over the past few years. 
 Many have responded, as the government intended, by becoming more entrepreneurial. 
 Parties aside, yesterday's dark and dusty treasure troves are now often approached through glossy souvenir-shops and high-tech caf&eacute;s. 
 Old attitudes linger, though. 
 The strongest rejection of the new approach tends to be a reluctance to charge for the product. 
 Of the 19 national museums that receive direct public grants, only eight demand a fee at the door. 
 Given the need for new sources of revenue, this seems odd. 
 Not so, says Sir David Wilson, director of London's British Museum and veteran of the anti-fee lobby: &bquo;Economic arguments should not always rule.&equo; 
 Though he admits he could do with the cash from ticket receipts (&pound;2.4m at the Science Museum in 1989, &pound;1.9m at the Natural History), Sir David argues that the British Museum &bquo;should be freely available to everyone &mdash; to stretch minds, stimulate their curiosity and provide for their academic needs.&equo; 
 If people have to pay to get in, goes the argument, fewer will turn up. 
 The Science Museum claims to have lost about 60% of its visitors in the 12 months after introducing a &pound;3.50 fee for adults in October 1988 (though the fall is based on a dodgy head-count, before entrance tickets provided the first precise numbers). 
 And surveys of visitors to the Victoria and Albert Museum, which has a voluntary charge, strengthen the suspicion that those lost are teenagers, often from London. 
 Neil Cossons, the director of the Science Museum, is confident the old numbers can be restored. 
 Experience elsewhere suggests he is right. 
 The National Museum of Wales, for example, saw an even more dramatic fall in visitors after introducing entrance fees in December 1988: 68,000 paid up to visit the main Cardiff branch of the museum in 1989, where 525,000 and 354,000 visitors were admitted free in 1987 and 1988, respectively. 
 (Again, the numbers are only a rough guide: plenty of the free visitors used the museum's &bquo;non-exhibition facilities&equo; &mdash; less coyly, its toilets.) 
 But John Bevan, who runs the museum's promotional activities, says the outlook on admissions has been brightening steadily; and the final tally for 1990 was 199,000. 
 Some places have even seen the publicity over new fees attracting extra visitors. 
 Alan Borg, the director of the Imperial War Museum, subscribes fully to the value-for-money school: museums that charge the customer, he says, are more likely to think harder about what he wants to see. 
 So the Imperial War Museum started charging in June 1989. 
 The result: monthly attendances immediately jumped by as much as 20%. 
 Paradoxical? 
 Not for the War Museum, where the season of peace and goodwill has found plenty of Rambo-esque revellers prepared to toast each other across tank turrets and artillery guns.  
 A palace revolution? 
 SPARE a thought for John MacGregor, Leader of the House of Commons. 
 While the rest of the nation was sleeping through old films on television or being towed across wintry landscapes by wheezing terriers, Mr MacGregor was spending much of his holiday deep in thought, pondering the modernisation of the Commons. 
 With a new prime minister and, in effect, a new government, it was perhaps inevitable that the ancient sillinesses of Britain's elected chamber should be a talking-point once more. 
 In the Conservative leadership contest, Douglas Hurd, the foreign secretary, made reform of the hours kept by the Commons one of his themes. 
 After winning, John Major patrolled the Commons tea-room, soliciting opinions on the subject from his backbenchers. 
 Few institutions in the western world have proved as resistant to change as the Commons. 
 The shock of the old is everywhere, in small things and great. 
 The layout of the chamber, with its in-built bias to confrontational politics, derives directly and in detail from St Stephen's chapel, where the Commons moved to in 1547. 
 At prayers, MPs turn towards their seats because they used to get tangled up in their swords if they tried to kneel. 
 The cumbersome and time-consuming method of voting, which involves each MP walking between two tellers and announcing his name, was partly designed to stop members sending their footmen to vote for them. 
 And so on. 
 There is an element of pleasing comedy in it all, and the loopiness of the Commons certainly adds to life's rich tapestry. 
 For an increasing number of MPs, though, its archaic inefficiency is getting in the way of its political effectiveness. 
 There are three often-repeated complaints about the way the Commons works. 
 First, the hours: business in the chamber starts, except on Fridays, at 2.30pm and can often last until the small hours of the morning &mdash; resulting in tired (and tired as a newt) legislators. 
 Second, MPs moan about the cramped conditions they work in. 
 Third, they complain about the way business is conducted, both in the chamber and in committees. 
 The hours question gets MPs most excited. 
 One of the latest recruits to the campaign for more normal working-hours is a Labour front-bencher, Harriet Harman, who argues that the current system helps keep women out of the clubby, late-night world of Parliament. 
 But Ms Harman, a London member, has angered many MPs whose families live in the north of England and Scotland. 
 They want a shorter working week, but are prepared to sit long and late while they are in London. 
 It now seems likely that a committee of inquiry into the hours and working practices of the Commons, staffed by senior MPs from all sides, could be announced shortly by the government. 
 Later this month, an official review committee of Labour MPs, which has already described the working hours as &bquo;largely indefensible&equo;, will produce proposals for a new working day, probably involving ministerial question-times during morning sittings, and an end to business by 7pm (compare the midday-to-7pm sittings of Congress). 
 If this flurry of activity really does lead to changes, expect a marvellous, Gilbert-and-Sullivan row. 
 A significant number of MPs have second careers in City boardrooms or the courts, and they will be furious at any curtailment of their activities. 
 Ministers would be angry, too &mdash; which might explain any reluctance on Mr MacGregor's part to push for morning sittings. 
 Richard Crossman, the Labour minister who introduced a failed attempt at morning sittings in 1967, wrote in his diary about the reaction of fellow cabinet ministers (&bquo;It's asking a terrible lot of us&hellip; 
 We're busy men&equo;). 
 The problem of lack of space is perhaps easier, since new parliamentary buildings giving around 100 more MPs their own offices should be ready by this summer. 
 Still, there will be severe overcrowding in the palace for at least another decade. 
 Most foreign politicians would be shocked by the conditions some MPs have to put up with, crammed together in dim corridors and insanitary Gothic broom-cupboards. 
 This, too, is nothing new. 
 One radical MP, William Cobbett, elected in 1833, wondered: &bquo;Why are we squeezed into so small a space that it is absolutely impossible that there should be calm and regular discussion&hellip; 
 Why do we live in this hubbub? 
 Why are we exposed to all these inconveniences?&equo; 
 (Tradition, William, tradition.) 
 Graham Allen, a Labour campaigner for better conditions, is one of many MPs who also want more research and computer help. 
 Though his proposals could cost the taxpayer another &pound;18m or so a year, they might help produce more effective constituency MPs. 
 In the conduct of business, most eyes are on a mooted change in the normal procedure for law-making, to encourage MPs to sit in select committees taking public evidence on bills before they discuss their details. 
 This would ensure that issues of principle could be dealt with before the painstaking, line-by-line consideration of parliamentary drafting. 
 Interestingly, this reform is strongly backed by those shadowy but influential Commons figures, the senior parliamentary clerks. 
 The great ragbag of reforms now being discussed behind closed doors will probably be displayed on January 17th, when the Commons is to debate a report on modernising its finances and management. 
 The debate could well lead to an overhaul of the arcane management of the Commons (with its &pound;80m budget for services and its 3,000-odd denizens) under the direction of a senior clerk, Donald Limon. 
 Would anyone outside that over-decorated mudbank, Westminster, really notice if the Commons was modernised? 
 Few enough; but the service offered to individuals seeking redress from their MPs could improve, and the executive in Whitehall might start noticing that the legislature was less quiescent and incompetent. 
 Never forget that parliamentary reform has affected the lives of most readers of this paper. 
 If you enjoy your Saturday snooze or a weekend round of golf, give some of the credit to Sir Robert Walpole. 
 That statesman, in 1732, persuaded the Commons to consider abandoning its regular Saturday sittings, so that he &bquo;might secure at least one day's hunting a week&equo;. 
 The habit of taking two days off proved popular in London. 
 According to Commons research, this may be the origin &bquo;of the weekend, which spread eventually to the public life of most of the world.&equo;  
 Still stuck over training 
 While the economy was booming, the Training and Enterprise Councils sounded like a neat solution to the skills shortage. 
 Now they are being squeezed by rising unemployment and falling profits 
 ALMOST two years after it was launched to the sound of grandiloquent claims from Tory ministers and loud cheers from businessmen, the Department of Employment's market-led training policy is in danger of falling apart. 
 The single most important aspect of the policy has been its introduction of training and enterprise councils &mdash; TECs, in the acronym-speak that clogs up all talk of the labour market. 
 Geared to local economic needs, dominated by businessmen rather than bureaucrats and financed by a mixture of public and private money, TECs originally promised a genuine break with the Whitehall-dominated past: a chance, at last, to give high-quality training the priority so often denied it for decades. 
 The prospects of success withered with alarming speed. 
 A few months ago, even the gruffest company bosses could be heard enthusing over jazzy Department of Employment leaflets. 
 Mixing their metaphors with exuberance, they talked of reversing the tide of history, delivering a skills revolution and mounting a crusade to make the British workforce the best trained in Western Europe. 
 Hundreds of chief executives agreed to act as unpaid board members of the fledgling TECs. 
 The Treasury, however, conspicuously failed to bring a bottle to this party. 
 Irritated by the idea at the heart of the initiative &mdash; mixing cash and staff from the public and private sectors &mdash; Treasury officials jumped in the other direction. 
 They pointed out that, because of a simultaneous fall in the numbers of unemployed and of teenagers, expenditure per head on training had been growing rapidly since the mid-1980s. 
 The Department of Employment promptly found its budget cut by &pound;120m in 1990&ndash;91 and by &pound;230m in 1991&ndash;92, with the most drastic reductions falling on the programme for training unemployed adults. 
 Michael Howard, the employment secretary, was left to make the best of this glum news by telling the TECs' directors &mdash; 1,200 of them, by December 1990 &mdash; that they could make up for a shortfall in cash from the Treasury by raising money from the private sector. 
 Shifting more of the cost of training to the private sector in this way might have posed a problem, even in a buoyant economy. 
 But the chilly economic climate has made a tricky situation desperate, in two respects. 
 Falling demand and rising costs are tempting many a finance director to curb spending on his firm's in-house training, let alone its contribution to the local TEC. 
 And TECs are having to deliver their promises, on dwindling incomes, just as the number of unemployed is rising sharply (see next page). 
 Unsurprisingly, many TEC directors think that they have been badly short-changed. 
 In public they have to boast about the training revolution they are supposedly leading. 
 In private the more cynical express a different view of their task. 
 The government, they say, is bluffing when it claims that TECs are intended to tackle Britain's persistent skills shortage. 
 In fact, the TECs are little more than a device for luring the private sector into tackling unemployment. 
 As the recession deepens, it is going to force the TECs into choosing between three undesirable options. 
 The first will involve cutting back on training for the unemployed. 
 Many chairmen might see this as a blessing: most are certainly keener on inventing new forms of high-level training than on managing anti-unemployment schemes like Employment Training (ET) and the Youth Training Scheme (YTS). 
 But in reality this option will be closed to all but a handful. 
 Virtually all the TECs still rely on government budgets which are heavily earmarked for ET and YTS. 
 And even the most optimistic TEC directors do not expect to raise more than 5% of their income from private sources. 
 The second option will be to forget about the skills revolution for a while and concentrate on helping the unemployed. 
 But the businessmen who are the driving force behind the TECs may feel diffident about administering a chunk of the welfare state. 
 The TECs' chairmen are already warning that budget cuts are forcing them to concentrate on alleviating the worst excesses of the training shortage, rather than on instigating innovative schemes. 
 &bquo;You cannot have world-class targets for training, with a third-world budget,&equo; says one. 
 The third option will require the TECs to boost their incomes by gobbling up as many government programmes and grants as they can find. 
 TEC directors have already persuaded the Home Office to hand them responsibility for smartening up the employment prospects of black and brown Britons. 
 They are also angling for control of the Careers Advisory Service. 
 And they have been pushing hard to shake money out of any European Community project that looks remotely applicable. 
 Accumulating grants in this way, though, is a time-consuming business and risks exposing a TEC's staff to all the rigours of inter-departmental bickering in Whitehall. 
 That ought to be enough to scare away even the most devoted private-sector champions of better training. 
 Robert Jackson, the employment minister, has a ready reply to criticisms of TEC funding. 
 He says that the skill shortages that followed cut-backs in the 1979&ndash;81 recession forced industry to recognise the importance of training. 
 Businessmen are now so convinced of the need to have a well-trained workforce &mdash; partly because of persistent skills shortages and partly because of the evangelising work of the TECs themselves &mdash; that they will cut almost anything before they cut their training budgets. 
 Mr Jackson is tantalisingly vague, though, about the question that worries most TEC directors: how will they be able to fulfil their contractual obligations to the unemployed, if the number of jobless people continues to rise sharply while the TEC budgets continue to shrink? 
 Worse, his thoughts on the matter hint at a general approach that sounds not much different from government attitudes in the bad old past. 
 He questions, for example, the idea that the only reason why people are out of work is that they lack skills. 
 Confidence and motivation often matter more. 
 He is critical of the high cost and low success rate of the ET scheme. 
 The government is getting much better value for its money, he claims, from Jobclubs which offer the unemployed services such as free telephones and confidence-boosting sessions, but which eschew training. 
 Above all, thinks Mr Jackson, business ought to learn from its past mistakes. 
 A key role for the TECs, in this view, will be to keep reminding employers of the lessons of the 1980s. 
 A legitimate task, no doubt. 
 But was it for this that the trumpets blew so confidently when the TECs appeared, less than two years ago?  
 Unemployment 
 NAIRUles OK 
 HOW high must unemployment rise to squeeze inflation out of the economy? 
 Higher than its current rate of 1.8m (6.2%), but probably not as high as it had to in the mid-1980s. 
 That is not just because inflation is raging less fiercely than it was in the early 1980s, but also because of improvements in the way the labour market works. 
 Economists talk about the &bquo;non-accelerating inflation rate of unemployment&equo; (NAIRU) &mdash; or, in simple English, the unemployment rate which stops inflation taking off. 
 The interaction between inflation and unemployment depends upon how well the labour market works. 
 The better it works, the lower is the rate of unemployment compatible with stable inflation &mdash; ie, the lower the NAIRU. 
 Putting an exact figure on Britain's NAIRU is rather like chasing a mirage, but changes in unemployment and inflation give clues to its general area. 
 In the halcyon days of the 1960s, it was lower than is dreamed of now: inflation and unemployment shuffled along together comfortably within ranges of, respectively, 0.8%-6.3% and 1.5%-2.6%. 
 By the early 1980s, it took an unemployment rate of 11% to bring inflation down. 
 After six years of rising unemployment, inflation dropped to a low point of 2.4% by July 1986. 
 In the second half of the decade the NAIRU seemed to become much less daunting, as unemployment fell without provoking much rise in inflation. 
 The number out of work fell from a seasonally-adjusted peak of 3.1m (11.2% of the workforce) in July 1986 to a low of 1.6m (5.6%) in March 1990, while the rise in earnings jumped by only two percentage points over the same period, to 9.5%. 
 There are two possible explanations for that pleasant interlude. 
 The NAIRU may, as the figures imply, have fallen sharply. 
 Or the link between inflation and unemployment may simply have been operating on a long lag, with the old, high NAIRU returning after several years to smack ministers in the face. 
 The answer is probably a bit of both. 
 Certainly, it takes time for workers and employers to react to changing conditions in the labour market. 
 Inflation did eventually accelerate, and tight-money measures have barely begun to halt it. 
 But the NAIRU is indeed likely to be lower these days &mdash; partly because the labour market works better, and partly because some of those out of work will not show up in the figures. 
 Weaker unions tend to mean that wages are more flexible. 
 Without unions fighting to keep up wages, employers are free to cut back costs by squeezing pay rather than by sacking marginal workers. 
 The rise in self-employment is also likely to increase the flexibility of earnings. 
 A company employing ten workers might lay off two in bad times; ten self-employed workers would probably carry on with a 20% reduction in their turnover rather than voluntarily go on the dole. 
 Self-employment will also tend to keep down the figures of those claiming unemployment benefit &mdash; and thus registering as unemployed &mdash; because some of the self-employed have not contributed enough to qualify. 
 Much of the rise in employment in the boom came in the marginal, part-time jobs generally done by women. 
 They will be the first to go in a slump. 
 Many of them will not have been earning enough to pay national insurance, so will not qualify for unemployment benefit &mdash; and will not affect the unemployment statistics. 
 Those whose husbands are earning will not even qualify for supplementary benefit. 
 Throughout the 1980s, changes were introduced in the benefits system, on the one hand keeping out ineligible claimants and on the other improving the system for putting jobless people in touch with vacancies. 
 That tightening-up process is still going on, and is likely to dampen the rise in the unemployment figures. 
 Britain's labour market may be working better, but it is still not working well. 
 Western Germany manages to maintain an inflation rate of 3% with an unemployment rate of 6.7%. 
 One obvious failing in Britain is the gap between the skills the workforce offers and those employers want. 
 That mismatch seems worse than it was ten years ago. 
 According to the Confederation of British Industry, in 1980 when unemployment was at the same level as now, around 5% of firms were reporting skill shortages; the equivalent figure in 1990 was around 25%.  
 Where there's a will, there's a home 
 INHERITANCE, once the preserve of the wealthy, will soon make most people richer. 
 The spread of owner occupation means that, in 30 years' time, between 70% and 90% of households are likely to inherit a property. 
 That much is predictable. 
 But how will the wealth be shared, and what will inheritors do with it? 
 A new study* by three academic researchers has tried to find out. 
 A previous attempt to guess the pattern of housing inheritance, by Morgan Grenfell, a merchant bank, in 1987, worked mainly from circumstantial evidence: from the rise in home ownership and house prices (to predict the amounts to be inherited) and from the rise in holdings of financial assets (to predict that inheritors would invest much of their new wealth in deposit accounts and shares). 
 The latest study has gone for first-hand evidence, by looking at Inland Revenue figures for bequeathed estates, and by conducting a couple of sample surveys. 
 Inland Revenue figures show that housing now accounts for 40% of the total value of inherited estates. 
 It looms large in middle-sized estates; not surprisingly, as the big increase in home ownership and house prices in the past 30 years has mainly benefited the comfortably-off. 
 Unpublished Inland Revenue figures show big regional variations in property inheritance. 
 Where home ownership is low, as in Scotland and Northern Ireland, housing made up 33% and 28.1% respectively of the value of inherited estates in 1980&ndash;81. 
 In England that year, homes accounted for 45.6% of the value of bequests. 
 Even in death, the north-south split survives. 
 Inheritance gives mainly to those who already have. 
 The researchers looked at a sample of 302 people who had inherited a house. 
 Half were in their 40s or 50s. 
 Professional and managerial households were four times as likely to inherit as were the least skilled or the unemployed. 
 Two-thirds of those who inherited a property promptly sold it. 
 Typically, roughly half the proceeds were invested; just over a quarter spent on buying another property or improving one; and the remaining quarter spent as part of the family budget. 
 A small, detailed survey found that older inheritors tended to put aside much of their cash to benefit their own children. 
 Because home ownership has grown so fast, and old people now live longer, the main impact of inheritance still lies ahead. 
 By 2031 the average number of homes passed on each year, excluding bequests to spouses, could be 343,000 &mdash; more than double the current average (see chart). 
 Some of those homes may already have been hocked by granny to pay for care in her declining years; and house prices may be depressed as inheritors who already own their homes sell those they inherit. 
 But more and more lucky people will be able to plan their retirement around the cash their parents leave them. 
 Unsurprisingly, the prospects for inheritance greatly interest financial institutions, which hope to offer inheritors new ways of spending their windfall. 
 Another study, by Mintel, a market-research company, covers some of the same ground as the academics' book (but costs &pound;795). 
 A survey of 295 property inheritors carried out for it by the Housing Research Foundation confirmed that two-thirds of inheritors promptly sold the houses they were left, whereas 22% moved into them. 
 Inland Revenue figures show a rise of nearly 10% a year in the post-tax value of bequests in the 1980s. 
 If that continues during the 1990s, inflation averages 5%, and homes account for half the value of all bequests, Mintel thinks property transfers between generations will rise from perhaps &pound;16 billion in 1990&ndash;91 to &pound;25 billion in 1999&ndash;2000. 
 Maybe. 
 More likely, the value of bequests will depend crucially on house prices &mdash; which will be depressed by all those inherited homes for sale.  
 BRITAIN THIS WEEK 
 Feeling the pinch 
 In his first broadcast interview as chancellor of the exchequer, Norman Lamont said there was too much pessimistic talk about the economy. 
 Then he warned of a stiff year ahead, with rising costs in the Gulf squeezing public spending, and membership of the ERM precluding any rapid reduction in interest rates. 
 Local councils in a dozen areas were granted High Court injunctions to prevent Sunday trading, but a handful of national store chains opened on the two Sundays before Christmas. 
 Just enough shoppers turned up to leave both sides of the Sunday-trading debate feeling vindicated. 
 How many businesses that went up in the 1980s might now come down? 
 A record number failed in 1990. 
 Waiting for war 
 John Major said he would visit Saudi Arabia, Oman and Egypt, starting on January 6th. 
 The Foreign Office moved to expel 67 Iraqis and eight staff from the Iraqi embassy. 
 The Ministry of Defence served call-up papers on 390 army reservists. 
 An earlier appeal had produced only 700 volunteers. 
 Undaunted, the navy asked for 2,500 volunteers from its own reserves. 
 Confidential Whitehall papers from 1960, released under the 30-year rule, struck an unusually topical note. 
 They showed the Foreign Office keen to encourage talks between the Iraqi and Kuwaiti rulers over their border dispute &mdash; but also adamant that Kuwait was the one area in the Gulf where the defence of oil supplies would justify the use of force. 
 Faces reddened at the Ministry of Defence when it was revealed that a thief had snatched top-secret documents about the Gulf from an unlocked car on December 17th. 
 The papers belonged to a staff officer, who left them unattended while he and his driver visited a used-car salesroom in Acton. 
 They were spotted on a near-by builder's tip and handed to the police. 
 Unexpected 
 The IRA declared a three-day Christmas truce. 
 Welcoming the initiative, Peter Brooke, the Northern Ireland secretary of state, suggested it might provide an opportunity for progress to be made in the province. 
 Unionist politicians accused him of naivety and dismissed the truce as a publicity stunt. 
 One man died and his brother was seriously injured after their car was fired on by soldiers at a checkpoint in South Armagh. 
 Cahal Daly, the recently installed Archbishop of Armagh, said he was &bquo;deeply disturbed&equo; and joined calls for an independent inquiry. 
 Sonia Sutcliffe, the wife of the Yorkshire Ripper, lost her libel case against the News of the World newspaper, over an article alleging a holiday affair with a Greek businessman. 
 She also had the costs of the case awarded against her &mdash; wiping out virtually all of the &pound;334,000-worth of damages won by her in previous court actions against the press. 
 Salman Rushdie followed up a meeting with prominent Muslims on Christmas Eve by announcing his conversion to Islam. 
 He also undertook not to publish any paperback version of &bquo;The Satanic Verses&equo; as long as it gave offence. 
 Mr Rushdie hoped the fatwa against him might be lifted. 
 Radical Muslim leaders in Bradford were unimpressed. 
 New vehicle registrations in November, at 148,700, were 19% lower than in November 1989 and the lowest seen in any November since 1979. 
 The Consumers' Association magazine, Which?, produced a sharply critical report on the services provided in airports. 
 BAA, the owner of eight airports including Heathrow, was blamed for neglecting the interests of passengers and allowing overpricing in airport shops. 
 Useful reading, perhaps, for the Monopolies and Mergers Commission, currently reviewing BAA? 
 Nanny knows best 
 The press got a new watchdog, as the Press Complaints Commission succeeded the Press Council on January 1st. 
 And the Broadcasting Standards Council began its monitoring of the small screen with a warning from its chairman, Lord Rees-Mogg, that television producers should not impose their own values if they offended the viewing public. 
 Signalling his commitment to a classless society, the prime minister bestowed peerages, knighthoods and other assorted gongs in the New Year's Honours list. 
 P.D. 
 James, a crime writer, became a baroness, and James Anderton, outspoken Chief Constable of Manchester, a knight. 
 School pupils must go on learning about 1066 and all that, declared the National Curriculum Council. 
 Advocates of traditional history-teaching welcomed the emphasis on events, people and dates. 
 One in the eye for progressive educationalists, after a hard battle?  
 Company cars 
 Queering the motor market 
 The tax break enjoyed by people with company cars distorts the market for new cars in Britain, putting private buyers at a disadvantage 
 A PECULIAR aspect of British business one-upmanship is to be found not in the office, but in the car park. 
 Here a salesman flaunts his status by showing the sunshine roof, electric windows and alloy wheels on his family saloon. 
 Managers gauge each others' prestige by comparing the sizes of their BMWs. 
 Directors say it silkily with a Jaguar or a Mercedes. 
 Cars, provided by the company, have become the physical symbols of the employees' progress through it. 
 Now take such ritual posturing and stage it nation-wide. 
 Car fleets have grown to the point where they dominate the national market for new cars: in 1990 more than half the 2m new cars sold in Britain were bought by companies and other organisations. 
 (Elsewhere in Europe, only Germany comes close, with about one-third of its market accounted for in this way. 
 In France the proportion is less than a fifth. 
 Most Americans do not even know what a company car is.) 
 More than 3m of the 22m cars (of all ages) now clogging Britain's roads are registered by companies or other organisations. 
 Some are police cars or rental vehicles, for example, but most are kept by individual drivers. 
 The recent row between Nissan and its British distributor owes much to the pressure that both have been under recently to break into the fleet market. 
 The Japanese company's Bluebird model, the first to be built at its Sunderland factory, never rated: dealers thought it lacked pzazz for executives. 
 So Nissan replaced it with a snappier car, the Primera. 
 But its privately-owned British distributor and dealer, Nissan UK, reckoned the Primera was too expensive to have much of a chance with fleet purchasers. 
 Relations between the car maker and its dealer were already strained by previous rows; so, on December 27th, Nissan UK was fired. 
 According to the Inland Revenue, 500,000 people were being taxed on the benefit of having a company car in the 1978&ndash;79 tax year. 
 Since then, company-car taxation scales have increased tenfold, but despite the supposed deterrent effect of this the number of people affected has risen to about 2m. 
 For company cars are still a bargain. 
 The driver of a 1.6 litre company car who can justify more than 2,500 business miles a year and whose petrol bills (including personal mileage) are paid for by the company, will be taxed as though the benefit were equivalent to an extra &pound;2,800 in salary. 
 For a basic-rate taxpayer, that would cost just &pound;700 a year. 
 But it actually costs about &pound;4,300 a year to buy, tax, insure and run a 1.6 litre car, according to the Monks Partnership, a firm of management-remuneration consultants. 
 For the executive, in other words, company money spent on his car is mainly a gift. 
 And never does this feel better than when he chooses a new car in the showroom. 
 Most employees select their company car from a list of vehicles within a certain price range. 
 Manufacturers, knowing that an extra few hundred pounds on the price will not be any deterrent, load their cars with all manner of profitable goodies from ten-speaker hi-fi systems to turbo engine-chargers. 
 Garel Rhys, a motor-industry economist at Cardiff University, reckons that if more cars were privately bought, the average British model would be much less lavishly equipped, and probably smaller. 
 As it is, not only is the average specification of cars sold in Britain the highest in Europe, but cars destined for the British market also tend to be bigger, with &bquo;upper-medium-sized&equo; cars disproportionately popular compared with elsewhere in Europe. 
 Prices are affected, too. 
 The Monopolies and Mergers Commission is currently investigating the pre-tax price of cars, which is some 30% higher in Britain than in, say, Belgium. 
 Carmakers claim that such figures do not compare similar models, and that the price differentials take no account of discounts given to British buyers. 
 The big fleet operators get the biggest discounts &mdash; putting the dealers under pressure to maintain higher prices for private buyers. 
 As company-car drivers tend to travel farther and more often on motorways, they consider themselves more experienced and skilful than private motorists, according to a recent survey by Gallup for General Accident, an insurance company. 
 Yet the survey also found the same drivers were far more likely to drive badly and to flout the law. 
 Almost half of the company-car drivers surveyed thought that it was acceptable to drive at 90mph on a motorway (20mph over the speed limit), compared with a quarter of drivers of privately-owned cars. 
 One third of them also admitted they would drive more carefully if they had to buy their own cars and pay all the running and repair costs. 
 BUSINESS 
 The value-subtractors of Eastern Europe 
 The standard approach to trade reform assumes that devaluing the currency makes firms competitive. 
 In Eastern Europe this may not be true 
 THINKING on economic reform in Eastern Europe has, up to now, drawn heavily on experience from the third world. 
 A reforming government first needs to &bquo;stabilise&equo; its economy &mdash; ie, cut its budget deficit and stop printing money in order to finance whatever deficit remains. 
 After that it needs to open its economy to international trade and, most likely, devalue its currency; this will align domestic prices with prices in world markets and force the economy to use resources more efficiently. 
 This advice makes sense for most developing countries, but is it relevant to Eastern Europe? 
 In one respect, at least, the answer is no. 
 The standard third-world prescription heavily underplays the role of private property. 
 In most developing countries, private ownership is already the rule. 
 Producers are obstructed by governments in all sorts of ways, but enterprises are, by and large, private. 
 In the ex-communist countries almost all enterprises are still owned by the state; that fact is directly and indirectly linked to just about every economic difficulty these countries face. 
 Governments are coming to understand the importance of privatising quickly. 
 However, the past year's changes in eastern Germany and Poland point to another mistake in the standard prescription: its advice on trade policy. 
 Eastern Germany and Poland opened their economies to the outside world all at once &mdash; eastern Germany on July 1st 1990, the day of its monetary union with western Germany; Poland on January 1st 1990, the day of its &bquo;Big Bang&equo; of economic reforms. 
 Since then both have seen output fall sharply. 
 Enterprises have sacked workers and are running at much less than their full capacity. 
 Many have shut down altogether. 
 Eastern Germany and Poland have this in common, even though their exchange-rate policies were quite different. 
 German monetary union converted old East German marks one-for-one into D-marks. 
 At such a rate the East German mark was handsomely overvalued. 
 Poland, in contrast, devalued the zloty by 31% on January 1st 1990. 
 This approach, according to the standard thinking, should have made Poland's producers more competitive. 
 Yet the fall in Poland's output since its reforms began has been at least as severe as in eastern Germany. 
 In some ways, the comparison is misleading. 
 Unlike Poland, eastern Germany can count on plenty of economic support in the form of subsidies and inward investment. 
 Even so, the sharp contraction in Poland's output &mdash; despite the fall in the zloty &mdash; raises doubts about the efficacy of devaluation. 
 In a book to be published soon (&bquo;The Order of Economic Liberalisation: Financial Control in the Transition to a Market Economy&equo;), Ronald McKinnon of Stanford University suggests a disturbing reason why devaluation may fail in Eastern Europe. 
 For most purposes it is enough to know that an enterprise makes losses &mdash; that its revenues are less than the sum of its wages, its cost of capital and its cost of material inputs (raw materials, components, energy and so on). 
 But, in principle, an enterprise might be so inefficient that its revenues fail to cover even the cost of materials. 
 Such an enterprise is an absurdity: it uses scarce capital and labour to subtract value from its other inputs (see chart). 
 Valuable metal, plastic, cardboard, rubber, energy go in at one end; Trabant cars worth less than the sum of these parts emerge at the other. 
 The distinction between making losses and subtracting value is crucial for exchange-rate policy. 
 Devaluation makes an enterprise more competitive by reducing its labour costs measured in foreign currency. 
 Note that devaluation does not affect the cost, measured in foreign currency, of capital or material inputs; in an open economy, these will command their world-market price. 
 A barrel of oil costs Poland so many dollars regardless of the zloty's exchange rate. 
 Even domestically produced coal has a given value in foreign-currency terms. 
 Because devaluation can cut labour costs, it can make a loss-making enterprise profitable. 
 But a value-subtracting enterprise loses money even if labour (and capital) are free. 
 It is a failure regardless of the exchange rate. 
 Value-subtractors have been spotted in many of the worst-run developing countries, but they are rare. 
 In Eastern Europe they are probably much more common. 
 Socialist central planners deliberately underpriced energy and other inputs. 
 So what might seem, at local prices, an ordinarily loss-making factory could be a value-subtractor. 
 Poland's price system now works, but even there the true extent of value-subtraction is hard to guess. 
 Many of the enterprises that have survived the first year of reform are still at risk. 
 They are hanging on by refusing to pay suppliers. 
 That cannot last. 
 In their recent joint report on the Soviet economy, the IMF and other multilateral agencies urged the Soviet Union not to move to free trade overnight, but to set a temporary tariff of 30%. 
 Their reason was that many of the country's enterprises will be uncompetitive at any &bquo;realistic&equo; exchange rate. 
 The idea of value-subtraction goes further: it deletes &bquo;realistic&equo;. 
 But the implication for policy is similar. 
 These countries should move gradually to free trade. 
 All-at-once liberalisation could flatten a large part of the economy overnight. 
 To give enterprises a chance to adjust and to avoid a crunch that would undermine support for further reform, governments might need to start with high tariffs, promising to eliminate them over, say, five years. 
 Adopting initial tariffs of even 100% would still be a bold reform; the implicit tariffs set by central planners approach infinity. 
 The third-world prescription was clear: liberalise trade immediately and leave privatisation for the longer term. 
 Poland did this. 
 Its reforms have not failed, but they are proving terribly painful. 
 Eastern Germany aside, the rest of Eastern Europe has been economically timid, and the Soviet Union has done next to nothing. 
 When these reluctant reformers are willing to take their chance, they might be wise to do the opposite of what Poland did. 
 They should privatise as fast as possible, and preferably all at once; but then go carefully on trade.  
 COMMODITIES BRIEF 
 The Economist indicators 
 EACH week The Economist publishes a set of commodity-price indicators. 
 Once a year these are published in summary form: last year's appeared in the issue of January 6th 1990. 
 The Economist indices are based on 1985=100, and are weighted by the value of imports into OECD countries in 1984&ndash;86 (net of intra-EC trade in farm products covered by EC subsidies). 
 After falling throughout 1989, commodity prices rallied in the first part of 1990. 
 In the three months to the beginning of May, the all-items index, measured in terms of SDRs, a basket of currencies, gained 15%. 
 But the rally did not last: over the whole year the SDR index fell 12%. 
 In sterling terms the fall was 18%, but the dollar index fell only 6% &mdash; its slide slowed by a weaker dollar. 
 Metal prices were the most volatile. 
 Low world stocks left the markets vulnerable to supply disruptions and encouraged speculative squeezes. 
 Lead experienced the biggest swing, hitting a ten-year high of &pound;800 a tonne in March. 
 The SDR metals index rose 39% between the end of January and September, before fears of recession, heightened by the Gulf, claimed back the gain. 
 Tin prices in Malaysia are now the lowest for nearly five years. 
 The downturn in the tyre industry hit rubber prices, which fell to a four-year low in Asia, despite purchases for the buffer stock and by the American government for its defence stockpile. 
 The Australian Wool Corporation, which controls wool marketing down under, lowered its floor price by 20% because of falling demand, but still had to buy 70% of the wool on sale at auction each week. 
 World cotton consumption was a record 86m bales, and the ratio of stocks to consumption was at an all-time low. 
 Small wonder that prices stayed high. 
 Surpluses pushed the SDR food index down 11% over the year. 
 Grain output rose by 6%, and wheat was in surplus for the first time in four years. 
 The Soviet Union had a near-record grain harvest of 236m tonnes. 
 Wheat futures in Chicago dropped to 13-year lows in November when grain sales to the Soviet Union petered out after that country ran out of cash. 
 In the last quarter of 1989 the Soviet Union bought 15m tonnes of American grain and soyabean meal. 
 But in the same period of 1990 it bought only 2m tonnes. 
 Brazil's 1990 coffee crop was only 22m bags, but world supplies remained plentiful. 
 Cocoa stocks reached a record 1.2m tonnes and a seventh year of surplus is forecast for the year to September 1991. 
 Political tensions in C&ocirc;te d'Ivoire briefly lifted cocoa prices above &pound;900 a tonne in May, after which they fell by 30%. 
 Tea sank to a two-year low of 89 pence a kilo in August as production increased.  
 Japan's industrial structure 
 Inside the charmed circle 
 TOKYO 
 Japanese firms prefer to conspire rather than compete with each other, complain American rivals, and now they are doing it in our own backyard 
 FAMILIES of firms with interlocking stakes in one another, known as keiretsu, have long dominated the Japanese economy. 
 In the eyes of foreigners trying to do business in Japan, they have become the symbol, and source, of the country's most exclusionary practices. 
 Six prominent keiretsu (networks of firms centred on the Mitsui, Mitsubishi and Sumitomo trading groups and the Fuji, Sanwa and Dai-Ichi Kangyo banking empires) group together 12,000 companies which between them have sales equivalent to a quarter of Japan's GNP. 
 Little wonder the keiretsu are feared and respected in Japan. 
 Now American politicians are starting to worry that Japan's keiretsu syndrome may be creeping into America. 
 Sander Levin, a congressman from Michigan, claims that Japanese car plants in the United States favour their keiretsu partners unfairly when ordering components. 
 A recent study by the University of Michigan suggests that 90% of the parts in Japanese cars built in America come either direct from Japan or from Japanese manufacturers which have set up shop in the United States. 
 A congressional study is under way to see whether any of America's antitrust laws are being breached. 
 There are also complaints in Japan, where foreign suppliers have long blamed their difficulty in penetrating the Japanese market on the closed ranks of the keiretsu. 
 A more complicated charge is that, by holding so many of each other's shares, keiretsu companies permit each other to pay out paltry dividends, freeing up large sums for capital investment. 
 Despite the moans of American companies, there is nothing inherently unfair about this. 
 Nor is it irrational: low dividends are often compensated for by other commercial advantages. 
 But it is true that, with some 70% of outstanding shares on the Tokyo Stock Exchange in the vaults of friendly business partners, Japanese firms are under little pressure to increase dividends and their managements have few fears of being replaced in a sudden stockmarket coup. 
 The origins of the keiretsu go back to the rise of Japan's great banking families in the 19th century. 
 By the 1930s the country's bankers had built vast mining-to-manufacturing conglomerates, known as zaibatsu, which became the driving force of Japanese militarism. 
 After the war, American occupation authorities disbanded the zaibatsu, but many of these companies later regrouped themselves after the Americans left and restrictions on cross-holdings and other ties were relaxed. 
 Today keiretsu companies often co-ordinate their investment plans, employment practices and even political donations. 
 The old-style conglomerates based around a bank which emerged from the pre-war zaibatsu differ markedly from newer groups that have sprung up since the second world war. 
 The former (eg, Mitsui, Mitsubishi, Sumitomo, Fuji, Sanwa and Dai-Ichi Kangyo) tend to be more loosely affiliated and more diversified. 
 The latter are more specialised, and usually based on a single large manufacturer. 
 Kenichi Imai, an industrial-policy expert at Hitotsubashi University in Tokyo, distinguishes five different types among the newer keiretsu: 
 Groups of semi-autonomous firms in a variety of fields revolving around a single manufacturer but with a web of cross-holdings in each other. 
 With 688 subsidiaries, Hitachi has the largest such family in Japan. 
 Groups formed as a result of a parent company, such as Matsushita Electric, spinning off its own operating divisions to form separate companies within the same field to act as suppliers, distributors and even retailers. 
 Groups resulting from a parent manufacturer establishing a pyramid of subcontractors and component suppliers. 
 Toyota is the best-known example. 
 Groups led by a company, such as NEC, an electronics firm, which have floated off old manufacturing subsidiaries and expanded into diverse new businesses by fostering affiliates. 
 Groups of firms related through the charismatic leadership of the parent company's founder or owner, such as Seibu Railway. 
 As Mr Imai's analysis makes clear, the term keiretsu is used to refer to so many different kinds of industrial groups in Japan that generalising about all of them, and especially complaining about them as a group, makes little sense. 
 Besides, most keiretsu are not nearly as exclusive as American critics claim. 
 Many are similar to large vertically integrated corporations in the West including such giants as Ford, General Electric, Daimler-Benz, Siemens or Philips. 
 The most insular, to outsiders, are descendants of the snobby, old zaibatsu and some of the newer vertically integrated manufacturers (especially Toyota). 
 Even so, the Japanese government's Fair Trade Commission reckons that the average firm even within the former zaibatsu relies on other group members for only 13% of purchases and 15% of sales. 
 Nevertheless, the predominance of keiretsu groups does often act as a brake on competition in Japan. 
 Mr Imai questions whether keiretsu companies really need to hold such large quantities of each other's shares. 
 Nor, says Mr Imai, should they be allowed to write off the exorbitant sums they spend on promoting group-wide harmony. 
 The &yen;5 trillion (&dollar;35 billion) that managers in Japanese companies spend annually on entertaining one another is more than they pay out between them in dividends. 
 American rivals might console themselves with the thought that this represents a hidden, but substantial, addition to the cost of capital. 
 Eliminating tax breaks on corporate entertaining would probably do more to break the power of keiretsu than beefing up Japan's feeble antitrust laws or passing intricate rules on cross share-holdings. 
 But it is difficult to imagine America's corporate leaders advocating a crackdown on executive wining-and-dining, even for the Japanese.  
 The lapse of luxury 
 PARIS, NEW YORK AND TOKYO 
 Snobby brands have been one of the success stories of the late 1980s. 
 Now luxury-goods firms are suffering a hangover that may last for years 
 MANAGEMENT&equo; is a little-used word in the lexicon of the luxury-goods business. 
 Instead, in a &dollar;52 billion-a-year industry obsessed with appearances, some companies seem to think that &bquo;creativity&equo; and &bquo;style&equo; rather than hard-headed business strategies are the keys to success. 
 Recession, a crisis in American retailing and the tarnishing of many once-snobby luxury brands are making them think again. 
 Over the past few years even badly managed luxury groups have made a profit, thanks to a booming world economy. 
 Lower income taxes and rising stockmarkets created a rapidly growing class of newly-rich consumers eager to flaunt their prosperity. 
 Purveyors of perfumes, porcelain and other expensive wares were more than happy to oblige yuppies and other brazen consumers willing to pay lavish prices for labels once only sported by the elite. 
 These companies stepped up production of &bquo;exclusive&equo; products and concocted hundreds of new items to sell, usually under the same upmarket brands. 
 Many firms made a fortune. 
 The members of the Comit&eacute; Colbert, an association of 70 of France's biggest luxury companies, increased their sales by a quarter in 1989 to &dollar;5.4 billion. 
 Christmas marked the end of this boom. 
 In America, which accounts for a third of all luxury purchases, shares of Tiffany &amp; Co., an upper-crust jeweller and a weathervane of the industry, fell on news of disappointing sales. 
 On the other side of the Atlantic, stores in Paris's chic Avenue Montaigne, a mecca for Japanese tourists, said that sales to foreigners had fallen sharply. 
 European luxury-goods firms blamed their poor Christmas performance on Iraq's August invasion of Kuwait. 
 For companies expert at peddling dreams, this is a dangerous bit of fantasy. 
 The Gulf is the least of the industry's worries. 
 A bigger headache, unlikely to go away even if the Gulf threat evaporates, is the weakness of both the yen and the dollar. 
 Though this is good news for American and Japanese firms, who share a paltry 11% slice of the luxury market, it is disastrous for European companies which account for the remaining 89% of sales (see chart on next page), but which sell nearly half of all their fancy products in America or Japan. 
 European exporters have pushed up prices in both countries to protect margins. 
 This is already beginning to backfire. 
 American consumers have shown a disconcerting willingness to substitute sparkling wine for champagne, off-the-rack imitations for pricey designer clothes. 
 They are also displaying a most unsnoblike taste for &bquo;replica brands&equo; &mdash; illegal copies of perfumes and bags that smell or look like originals, but cost a fraction of the price. 
 Replicas pose a serious threat to some luxury brands. 
 Hubert Joly of McKinsey, a management consultancy, says copies of perfumes took 10% of the American market in 1988, up from 1% in 1984. 
 Sales to budget-conscious American consumers will also be hit by a new luxury tax that began on January 1st. 
 This tax is set at 10% of the portion of the purchase price above &dollar;30,000 for cars and &dollar;10,000 for furs and jewellery. 
 Though some Americans went on a spending spree in December to beat the new tax, its introduction will almost certainly hurt sales in 1991. 
 Similarly, the likely phasing out of duty-free sales for people travelling within the European Community could also make many luxury items more expensive just as many of the newly-rich who fuelled the consumer boom are feeling newly poor. 
 Luxury-goods sales are falling precisely when lots of new competitors, attracted by what once looked like easy business, are jumping into the market. 
 In America, for example, 120 perfumes were launched in 1988 and 59 in 1989, compared with just 30 in 1980. 
 Competition could soon be even fiercer. 
 Shiseido, a Japanese cosmetics giant, plans to boost exports, which currently take a mere 2% of its production. 
 In the upmarket rag trade, where new fashion houses like Italy's Armani and Germany's Hugo Boss have pulled in the crowds, the story is the same. 
 Though French brands still account for nearly half of the luxury market, German, British, Italian and even a few Japanese and American brands are showing up on the shelves. 
 Faced with dwindling sales and stiffer competition, all luxury-goods firms need to turn to the boring disciplines that many have dismissed as suitable for widget-makers, but hardly appropriate for a trade where cachet brings in the cash. 
 In the harsher 1990s there will not be many corks popping at companies that fail to: 
 Reduce costs. 
 These have risen fast, especially the cost of advertising. 
 For example, launching a new perfume worldwide now costs an extravagant &dollar;50m. 
 To keep profits up, firms will need to lower costs or get more value for their money. 
 Mo&euml;t Hennessy Louis Vuitton (LVMH), a French group selling bags and booze, is doing the latter. 
 It plans to set up an in-house agency to manage its &dollar;400m-a-year advertising budget. 
 Cost-cutting means challenging accepted wisdom. 
 In December France's Balmain shocked the fashion world by pulling out of haute couture. 
 Heavily indebted, the firm could no longer afford to lose money making &dollar;20,000 outfits for a handful of wealthy women. 
 Other fashion houses, which also lose millions staging haute couture fashion shows, say these create an image that helps sell other profitable products. 
 Now that times are tougher, such costly publicity stunts are harder to justify. 
 Protect brands. 
 As Bernard Arnault, the boss of LVMH, points out, the hardest trick in managing luxury brands is &bquo;keeping a balance between volume and scarcity.&equo; 
 It is a trick that many groups, including Mr Arnault's, have yet to master. 
 By stretching brands across a wide range of products, some groups like Pierre Cardin, whose name appears on everything from fragrances to frying pans, have damaged their image. 
 Others like Louis Vuitton, which makes monogrammed bags, have made a once-classy item banal by saturating markets. 
 Only a handful of luxury groups have struck the right balance between mass-marketing and exclusivity. 
 So far, America's Ralph Lauren is one of them. 
 It cleverly created its Polo brand to exploit Americans' nostalgia for an English country life which never really existed except in Hollywood movies, and has been careful to use the brand only for top-of-the-range products. 
 Yves Saint Laurent, on the other hand, licensed its brand worldwide, but had to buy it back again when the licensees splashed YSL initials everywhere. 
 Control distribution. 
 Luxury firms can sell their wares at high prices only by keeping them &bquo;exclusive&equo;, even if only in the minds of shop-till-you-drop status-seekers. 
 America provides a cautionary tale. 
 Last year indebted retailers like Macy's frantically discounted to raise cash to meet interest payments. 
 The result, says Andr&eacute; Sacau of Orcofi, a French holding company with stakes in a range of luxury-goods makers, is that &bquo;buyers of luxury brands have been turned into bargain-hunters.&equo; 
 Rather than see their goods hawked by retailers on the brink of bankruptcy, luxury firms must act fast to protect their brands. 
 Italy's Gucci has already pulled its products out of hundreds of American stores. 
 Other companies, like Britain's Harrods, have set up their own shops within big stores or have bought their own boutiques abroad. 
 One of Orcofi's companies has even opened a shopping centre in Taipei that groups together shops selling only luxury goods. 
 Professional management will be needed to keep firms afloat, but it may not be enough to restore the explosive growth of the past few years. 
 That is because the luxury industry is also facing its nemesis: a self-righteous backlash against conspicuous consumption in America and Britain, though not yet in Japan. 
 A grudge against the &bquo;flaunt it&equo; Reagan and Thatcher years is in the air. 
 One sign of the times: the film &bquo;Bonfire of the Vanities&equo; flopped after critics accused it of being kinder to yuppies than the original Tom Wolfe novel. 
 Another sign is the campaign against the fur trade launched by animal-rights activists, which has led to the bankruptcy of several furriers. 
 Christian Lacroix, who gained notoriety as one of Paris's most flamboyant dress designers in the 1980s, has had to tone down his gaudy garments to get them into department stores. 
 Personal vanity and the taste for consuming conspicuously will always link within the human breast. 
 But a more puritan era of egalitarian austerity could make them a lot shyer &mdash; and for some time to come.  
 Corning's strategy 
 Time to get out of the  kitchen  
 CORNING, NEW YORK 
 AMERICA'S Corning prides itself on being lean and nice. 
 But like many other paternalistic firms, it may have to become a little meaner to stop its past from handicapping its future. 
 The company has been adept at moving into high-margin businesses such as laboratory services, optical fibres and speciality materials. 
 And yet this high-tech portfolio looks strange beside pots and pans, which continue to account for 28% of its sales. 
 Though far less profitable, Corning's kitchenware business encompasses the brand names &mdash; Pyrex, Corning Ware, Visions, Corelle &mdash; which have made the company, and the company town of Corning in upstate New York, world famous. 
 That explains why the firm has been so reluctant to shed its pots and pans. 
 Even so, sentiment may not protect it forever. 
 Neither James Houghton, chairman of the company since 1983 and a great-great grandson of its founder, nor his predecessor as chairman, his brother Amory, have proved sentimental about other products. 
 Under their leadership Corning has prospered by making well-timed exits from mature, slow-growing industries and equally well-timed entrances into young, fast-growing ones. 
 Mr Houghton still glows proudly when recounting Corning's role in helping to create the electric light-bulb after Thomas Edison came to the company in 1879 with his ideas. 
 &bquo;We really developed the processes for making incandescent light bulbs very fast, very cheaply,&equo; explains Mr Houghton. 
 Nevertheless when the growth of light-bulb sales and profits slowed in the 1970s, Corning promptly sold the business. 
 Similarly, Corning dropped the ceramic bricks used to line glass and steel furnaces, and passive electrical components such as resistors and capacitors, all cherished as traditional products at the company. 
 Being so fleet-footed, and tough-minded, has enabled Corning's managers to raise the company's return on equity from about 8% in 1983 to 15% in 1990. 
 Mr Houghton's ambition is to raise return on equity to 17&ndash;20% within five years, a performance that would put Corning into the top 25% of Fortune 500 companies. 
 This target looks realistic because Corning is only just starting to reap the rewards of patiently pursuing earlier long-term investments. 
 The company's pioneering effort in optical fibres failed to make a penny for 17 years, but is now set to make a fortune. 
 Hair-thin glass filaments that transmit information using light, optical fibres are now cheap enough to compete with copper; their reliability and security appeal to Pentagon generals. 
 In a similarly shrewd move the firm recently sold its laboratory-equipment business to Switzerland's Ciba-Geigy. 
 It has decided to concentrate on laboratory services instead. 
 Stiffer government regulations are persuading American hospitals and drugs firms to stop using small, local laboratories to test medical samples and new drugs, and to give their business instead to the kind of nationally known laboratories acquired by Corning. 
 The company also looks set to prosper from making the substrates which go into catalytic converters used to clean car-exhaust emissions. 
 Perhaps still more impressive is Corning's record in exploiting its technology through joint ventures, a notoriously difficult form of business. 
 The company participates in nearly a score of such ventures, some of them dating back to the 1930s. 
 Income from joint ventures produced about half of Corning's net profits last year. 
 So why does a company with such a history of agility and skill remain tied to pots and pans even though they act as such a drag on its performance? 
 To his credit, Mr Houghton admits to being &bquo;less than totally objective&equo; about these products. 
 &bquo;I used to run that business back in the late 1960s and early 1970s,&equo; he recalls. 
 One of the reasons Mr Houghton and his managers cite for staying in the pots-and-pans business sounds pretty lame: namely that the business was handicapped in the 1980s first by a recession at the start of the decade and then later by a strong dollar and so could now recover. 
 Another reason cited is more plausible: the contribution the business makes to corporate overheads and the way it is entwined with the company's other operations makes it difficult to detach from more profitable bits of the company. 
 But the real reason is almost certainly the devastating impact which selling the pots-and-pans business could have on Corning and other small towns that depend on the company for their prosperity. 
 Getting out of making pots and pans, says one Corning executive, would be &bquo;like cutting 200 umbilical cords.&equo; 
 That may be why Mr Houghton has given the job of turning round the kitchenware business to Richard Dulude. 
 Now near retirement after a long career in product development, Mr Dulude can presumably act without fear or favour. 
 He has his work cut out for him. 
 Corning's high-quality, high-priced pots and pans are more vulnerable to recession than more humble vessels. 
 Before Christmas, Macy's, the huge New York department store, was discounting Corning's products by up to 50%. 
 If price cuts on this scale continue, they will make retaining the kitchenware business an expensive, as well as a sentimental, indulgence.  
 British television 
 Wheel of fortune 
 IMAGINE you are bidding in an auction. 
 There are 15 items up for sale, but you may buy only two of them. 
 You do not know who the rival bidders are, who wants what, or how much they are likely to bid. 
 Even if you do make the highest offer for any particular item, the auctioneer can hand it over to another, friendlier-looking buyer instead. 
 That is the puzzle facing companies wanting to buy Britain's juiciest regional monopolies &mdash; its 15 commercial-television franchises (which include one nationwide breakfast channel). 
 Bids must be submitted by the end of April; winners will be announced by September. 
 Despite the bizarre method being used, dozens of foreign companies are likely to bid for the rare chance to invade a new broadcasting market. 
 Until now British TV licences were given away free, mostly to firms headed by establishment figures. 
 Though applicants had to demonstrate financial soundness and programming ability, they paid nothing for their regional monopolies, which guaranteed them a share of the &pound;1 billion-plus (&dollar;1.95 billion) of television advertising sold in Britain each year. 
 Once inside the &bquo;independent&equo; television (ITV) club, firms were rarely thrown out. 
 In the last round of contract awards, held in 1980, only two out of 15 ITV companies failed to get their licences renewed. 
 A new law, passed in November 1990, should change all that. 
 When the current round of licences expires at the end of 1992, new licence-holders will be (more or less) the firms that have paid most for them. 
 Not surprisingly, that makes existing franchisees nervous. 
 Since most depend heavily on broadcasting, they are desperate to keep their franchises. 
 Hanging on hardest will be the two London franchise-holders, Thames Television and its weekend equivalent, LWT. 
 London boasts more viewers than any other franchise area, and the highest proportion of rich ones. 
 Small franchises in rich areas, like the south-west of England and East Anglia will also be popular. 
 What happens to ITV firms that lose their franchises? 
 The larger ones hope to soldier on as independent producers. 
 Those owning rights to cheap-to-make, popular series could even do well; they will be able to charge much more for programming once out of the ITV club, which currently prices programmes on the basis of production costs. 
 Though Coronation Street, a downmarket soap, has lots of viewers, Granada, the firm that makes it, has to sell it to other ITV companies for a mere &pound;100,000 per episode. 
 That is only a fifth of what ITV companies charge each other for less popular, but, less economical, &bquo;quality&equo; drama. 
 Meanwhile, ITV companies are busy scraping together the highest bids they can muster. 
 For most, that means finding outside investment. 
 TVS is rumoured to be teaming up with Carlton Communications (a video distributor), Canal Plus (a French cable-TV company), and the Compagnie G&eacute;n&eacute;rale des Eaux (a utility with various media holdings). 
 Both French firms hold 10% stakes in TVS already. 
 Other ITV companies are also looking for partners &mdash; frightened of industrial espionage, one firm recently swept its London offices for listening devices. 
 Jettisoning people and property is another way to save money. 
 Thames has sacked 300 staff, Central 600. 
 ITV companies may be wrong to worry. 
 At the beginning of last year 70 franchise bids were expected, but more recent guesses have lowered the number to 30. 
 One reason is recession. 
 Less advertising spending makes the media conglomerates that are the most likely bidders poorer, as well as reducing the value of the franchises themselves. 
 Also at fault is the new broadcasting law, which rules out many potential buyers. 
 Firms based outside the European Community may not take controlling stakes. 
 British newspaper groups, satellite-television firms and companies owning radio stations are limited to 20% holdings. 
 Firms left in the running must pass high &bquo;quality thresholds&equo; to get their bids considered. 
 For example, a quarter of all programmes must be purchased from independent production companies; and a vague &bquo;proper proportion&equo; must be of European origin. 
 Bidders must also promise to show plenty of local news as well as educational and religious shows. 
 If an applicant's programme quality is deemed &bquo;exceptionally high&equo;, it may even win over a higher bidder. 
 To boost their credentials, bidders who do not already hold an ITV franchise need to acquire, or strike deals with, independent production companies. 
 The result has already been a bonanza for the founders of small production firms. 
 Many of these deals also indicate likely outside bidders for the franchises. 
 Chrysalis, a record-and-documentary producer, recently bought Red Rooster, an independent drama-maker. 
 CLT, a Luxembourg radio station, took a stake in Humphrey Barclay, another small independent. 
 Westinghouse, an American electronics conglomerate, is teaming up with Richard Branson's Virgin, a producer of records and television. 
 To pitch franchise bids correctly, firms need to be expert market-forecasters as well as programmers. 
 By the time new licensees start broadcasting in 1993, ITV stations will no longer enjoy a monopoly. 
 Satellite channels already claim 1.2m subscribers, and Britain's cable-television operators another 115,000. 
 Both numbers are expected to grow rapidly. 
 Still interested?  
 Snooze-along 
 AS THE number of television channels grows in countries such as Britain, more and cheaper programmes are needed to fill them. 
 Enter Art of Landscape, a no-script, no-actors alternative to game shows and repeats. 
 The recipe is mind-numbingly simple: shots of pretty landscapes set to classical music. 
 One episode features Emperor penguins set to Pachelbel's &bquo;Canon in D major&equo;. 
 The London company that produces the show claims 30m viewers in seven European countries and Japan. 
 But Channel Four, the only British broadcaster currently airing the series, has just announced its cancellation. 
 The programme attracts viewers, admits a Channel Four spokesman, but does not attract &bquo;any kind of interest whatsoever&equo; from advertisers. 
 Undaunted, the Art of Landscape's producers are hoping to sell the show to American stations.  
 America's car market 
 Showdown in Motown 
 DETROIT 
 WORKERS at almost half the American plants run by General Motors (GM), Ford and Chrysler are getting an unexpectedly long holiday. 
 Their factories will remain closed for up to six weeks in order to reduce stocks of unsold cars. 
 With consumer confidence at its lowest level in years, there is no longer any doubt in Motown that the American car market has entered its worst recession in a decade. 
 This alone is enough to overshadow the glitzy North American International Auto Show, which opens its doors in Detroit on January 10th. 
 But what will make the industry's traditional jamboree an even more painful experience for America's big three car makers is that the Japanese will hog the limelight with a clutch of flashy new models. 
 When the final numbers are tallied, sales of new cars and light trucks in the United States in 1990 will almost certainly have fallen by about 500,000, to 14m vehicles. 
 This is the lowest level since the slump in the early 1980s. 
 In 1991 sales are expected to slip to around 13.5m. 
 If war erupts in the Gulf, the figures could be even lower, concedes Robert Stempel, GM's chairman. 
 Although American car workers will get a lot more free time in the months to come, they will at least be better off than they were a decade ago. 
 In that recession hundreds of thousands of car workers were made redundant. 
 New union contracts guarantee that hourly employees will receive most of their pay even if laid off. 
 This will further dent the earnings of GM, Ford and Chrysler. 
 In the fourth quarter of 1990, analysts guess, GM lost as much as &dollar;1.2 billion. 
 Ford is estimated to have lost &dollar;250m and Chrysler up to &dollar;40m. 
 Developing urgently needed new models will be difficult and costly for all three. 
 At the Detroit show American car makers will unveil some new models, including GM's long-awaited replacement for the stodgy Cadillac Seville. 
 But the display hall will also be crowded with glamorous, new Japanese cars, like the Diamante, a luxury model from Mitsubishi. 
 The problem faced by Detroit's producers is that, while some new American cars have been panned as dumpy and boring, the Japanese have been rolling out a stream of glittering and highly praised new vehicles. 
 Honda's luxury-car division, Acura, is an example. 
 Last year it introduced its second-generation Legend saloon just four years after the first model was launched. 
 American manufacturers typically take about twice as long before replacing similar models. 
 Ford does not plan to introduce a completely new replacement for its Taurus family car until the mid-1990s &mdash; more than a decade after the car first appeared. 
 And even to meet that schedule Ford's president, Philip Benton, warns that his company may have to cut its dividend if earnings do not pick up in 1991. 
 Last year Detroit's car makers thought they were about to turn the corner in their battle against the Japanese. 
 They have been &bquo;closing the gap&equo; on productivity and quality with their Japanese rivals, says Mr David Cole, director of the Centre for the Study of Automotive Transportation at the University of Michigan. 
 Indeed GM's Buick division has climbed to the top in surveys of customers' satisfaction while its Cadillac division recently won a prestigious quality award. 
 But without sexy new cars, high quality will not be enough to maintain market share. 
 In 1990 the Japanese share of the American car market is thought to have increased by one percentage point, to a record 30%. 
 Many analysts predict the Japanese will gain another point in 1991. 
 Yet even the Japanese are finding the American car market tough. 
 Subaru of America, whose cars are made by Japan's Fuji Heavy Industries, is struggling and a few of the Japanese-owned car factories in America are also running below capacity. 
 But, overall, the Japanese are continuing to make gains as the American firms decline. 
 Toyota's ambitions alone should give Detroit nightmares. 
 In 1990 Toyota is likely to have sold 1m vehicles in the United States and to have produced about one-third of those vehicles in America. 
 By 1995 the company aims to have American sales of about 1.5m &mdash; making it as big in America as Chrysler. 
 With the opening of the company's fourth North American assembly plant in two years' time, Toyota will also have the capacity to produce almost 1m vehicles a year in America. 
 THE WORLD ECONOMY 
 Echoes of the 1930s 
 In 1991 the world economy faces, at best, a year of slow growth. 
 But what might it face at worst? 
 Reminders of this century's deepest depression are all too easy to find 
 IN THE days that followed the stockmarket crash of October 1987, investors dusted off their economic histories and recalled that the Wall Street crash of October 1929 had marked the beginning of a ten-year, worldwide depression. 
 Quite soon their fears faded. 
 Governments cut interest rates to spur demand. 
 The Group of Seven (G7) industrial economies grew, on average, by 4.6% in 1988 &mdash; a lot faster than in 1987. 
 For the next two years businessmen and governments saw inflation, not the threat of recession, as the real risk. 
 Though two of the G7 countries &mdash; Britain and America &mdash; now appear to be in recession, the likeliest outlook for the world in 1991 is a tolerable mixture of slower growth and lower inflation than of late, with a brighter year to follow in 1992. 
 The trouble is that in economics the likeliest result often fails to turn up. 
 If you ask what is the worst that might foreseeably happen, the answer at the start of 1991 is bleaker than for many years past. 
 As yet, few economists are contemplating this worst case. 
 The stockmarket crash of 1987 is remembered, if at all, as proof that governments have learnt to protect the &bquo;real&equo; economy from upsets in financial markets. 
 A mild recession may cause far more economic damage than a one-day stockmarket fall of, say, 25%, but it is much less unsettling. 
 A crash is a moment of panic when events are out of control and outlandish predictions become thinkable. 
 Mere recessions leave governments and central banks safely in command. 
 In both Britain and America, the financial markets seem quite reconciled to several quarters of slow economic advance, or even some retreat. 
 Economists at the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development reckon that Britain and America will both grow by .5&ndash;1% in 1991. 
 Private forecasters are a bit gloomier, especially about America: according to the averages worked out by Consensus Economics, a polling firm, America's growth will be just 0.1% this year. 
 That is still a far cry from the several years of falling output that would be needed to justify the term &bquo;depression&equo;. 
 Between 1929 and 1933 America's national income fell by more than half in money terms, and by more than a third in real terms. 
 Another good reason for calm is that today Britain and America can no longer create a global depression by themselves; Japan and Germany would need to join in. 
 In fact, those countries seem likely to grow strongly: the OECD predicts growth this year of 3.7% in Japan and 3% in Germany (including its struggling eastern part). 
 In the 24 industrial countries of the OECD, growth is expected to average 2% in 1991, rising to 2.5% in 1992. 
 Even if the forecasters are being far too optimistic, modern industrial economies are much better equipped to resist depression than were their predecessors. 
 One of the biggest economic changes of the past 60 years &mdash; prompted, as it happens, by the 1930s depression &mdash; has been the steady rise of taxes and government spending in relation to national income. 
 This has had its drawbacks, but also one undoubted benefit: when economies slow, tax receipts fall and public spending rises, automatically moderating the downturn. 
 So there are plenty of reasons to be unalarmed by the economic outlook for 1991. 
 The skills of the authorities in responding to stockmarket crashes, the spread of economic weight around the globe, the fact that the economic cycles of Japan and Germany seem unsynchronised with those of America and Britain, the role of taxes and public spending as automatic stabilisers in modern economies &mdash; all these are most reassuring. 
 The road to depression 
 Even so, parallels with the 1930s are far more compelling now than they were in 1987. 
 Though economists quarrel about the causes of the 1930s depression as inconclusively as they do about everything else, certain basic features are not in doubt. 
 Self-reinforcing contractions in output and employment start when people and businesses choose, or are obliged, to spend much less. 
 A necessary condition for a steep fall in demand is a widespread collapse in confidence, as people suddenly become worried about the future. 
 For the initial contraction to worsen into a depression, various corrective mechanisms (autonomous shifts in the way people and businesses behave, government policies, forces in the international economy) must then fail to work. 
 The Wall Street crash of 1929 was severe enough, by itself, to reduce wealth in the American economy substantially, and thus to cut personal and business spending (which had already been falling for two months). 
 The earlier mood of optimism was punctured, and output fell. 
 This was a bad recession. 
 It became the Great Depression as successive waves of bank failures rolled over America's monetary system. 
 Throughout the 1920s, small banks had been failing in America at a rate of hundreds a year: in 1926, for example, 976 banks out of 28,350 collapsed. 
 The economic downturn that began in 1929 was enough on its own to cause an initial increase in failures. 
 Then the trouble began feeding on itself. 
 People rushed to convert their bank deposits into cash. 
 As they did so, more banks failed. 
 So more people wanted to convert deposits into cash, more banks failed, and so on. 
 In 1933 roughly 4,000 banks shut their doors, and the United States was left with only half as many as it had had in 1929. 
 As banks closed, millions of people saw their savings disappear. 
 If you had a deposit in an American bank between 1929 and 1932, you had a one-in-ten chance of losing it. 
 The vicious circle of vanishing confidence and financial distress compressed the deposit-base of the economy: the supply of money shrank, so the depression deepened. 
 Today the most difficult and controversial questions about the depression of the 1930s concern its deeper causes, domestic and international. 
 Candidates include: the inability or unwillingness of the Federal Reserve to stem the banking panic and maintain the money supply; the failure to use fiscal policy intelligently (up to and including Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal after 1933); the uses and abuses of the gold standard (Britain deciding to go back on the gold standard in 1925 at the pre-1914 parity, then deciding to come off the standard altogether in 1931; the refusal of many countries, especially America, to follow gold-standard rules); the outbreak of trade war sparked by America's Smoot-Hawley tariffs in 1930; and so on. 
 There is no want of causes of the Great Depression. 
 The parallels 
 It might seem that 1991 cannot match this catalogue of ills. 
 Can't it? 
 Financial markets are jittery, as a war looms in the Gulf. 
 Such a war, if it went badly, might well cause stockmarkets to crash again. 
 It might also cause the price of oil to soar above &dollar;50 a barrel and stay there for some months. 
 That would both worsen the recession already under way in America and, by forcing inflation higher, make it harder for the Federal Reserve to continue easing monetary policy. 
 Confidence is vulnerable in many other ways. 
 The Soviet Union is falling to pieces; a bloody struggle for those pieces cannot be ruled out. 
 That would shatter Germany's present mood of economic optimism, already faltering as the difficulties of modernising what used to be East Germany grow clearer. 
 Property markets worldwide have crashed or look about to; especially in Japan, a collapse in land and property prices would have a powerfully contractionary effect on the economy as a whole. 
 America's financial system is under great strain: the savings-and-loan industry is crippled, banks and insurance companies are struggling, firms and consumers look over-indebted. 
 America and Europe have fallen out over farm trade; as a result, the negotiations at the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) have broken down. 
 Unless these talks can be revived, and succeed, a series of bitter trade battles, if not an all-out trade war, is possible. 
 For all these things to go wrong at once would be bad luck, to put it mildly. 
 But if the worst did happen, the necessary conditions for a depression &mdash; a dramatic collapse of economic confidence, and the inability of governments to restore it &mdash; might well be met. 
 Crunchy credit 
 Of the narrowly economic dangers, the fragility of America's banking system is potentially the most threatening. 
 Fears of a &bquo;credit crunch&equo; have prompted policy changes at the Federal Reserve in recent months: the Fed has cut its benchmark interest rate four times and, a bolder move, has reduced the amount of reserves that banks are obliged to hold with it against their customers' deposits. 
 This, in effect, is a tax cut for banks. 
 The American authorities cannot be accused, as in the 1930s, of unwillingness to act. 
 The question instead is whether the Fed's remedies will work. 
 A credit crunch is the name economists give to a sudden reluctance among banks to lend money. 
 It works in such a way that lower interest rates may fail to boost credit and demand. 
 Typically, a credit crunch happens when banks start to worry about the creditworthiness of their borrowers. 
 If borrowers are struggling, banks will suffer losses, and lending will be cut. 
 Borrowers will find it harder to refinance their loans, so they will struggle all the more, banks will suffer bigger losses, and so on. 
 This cycle is shown in the left-hand part of the first chart on this page (borrowed from Alan Budd, the chief economist of Barclays Bank). 
 A full-scale financial crisis happens if this sequence merges with another: if bank losses lead to fears about bank solvency, and thus to the withdrawal of funds, further bank losses and so on, as in the right-hand part of the chart. 
 This combination was the financial engine of the Great Depression. 
 A credit crunch &mdash; mild, as yet &mdash; is undoubtedly under way in America. 
 The 1980s saw a rising trend of bad debts, first in developing countries but more recently at home, especially in property loans. 
 The number of &bquo;problem banks&equo; monitored by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) rose sharply, and the big banks' credit-ratings were heavily down-graded. 
 This weakness of the banking system came during a period of rapid economic growth. 
 As the recession proceeds, things will get worse. 
 Consumers and businesses will find it difficult to service their heavy load of debt. 
 The debt-service burden of American (non-financial) businesses was equivalent to 16% of their cash flow in 1980; it is now roughly 20%. 
 This average conceals an important fact: many of the industries that tend to suffer most during recessions (suppliers of consumer durables, transport and communications, for example) have actually cut their debt-service burden since 1980; the biggest increases in debt service have been taken on by relatively stable industries (such as producers of services and consumer non-durables). 
 Nonetheless, consumers and businesses alike are, in the aggregate, deeper in debt than ever before. 
 America's household and (non-financial) corporate debt stands at some 130% of GNP. 
 According to estimates by Salomon Brothers, an investment bank, during four earlier credit crunches (in 1966, 1969&ndash;70, 1973&ndash;74 and 1980&ndash;81) this ratio was never more than 100%. 
 This heavy burden of debt, especially among consumers, is a plausible reason why spending has slowed in recent months: borrowers are striving to ease their financial position by spending less and saving more than they otherwise would. 
 Recessions often start because the demand for credit falls. 
 That need be no great problem: if it falls too quickly, central banks can cut interest rates, as the Fed has, to brake the decline. 
 There is a risk, though, that the supply of credit will start to fall faster than the demand; in other words, that a credit crunch will start to drive the process of credit contraction. 
 In that event, lower interest rates might not help. 
 Banks wishing to lend less would use lower rates to broaden the spread between their lending rates and the rates they pay depositors, rather than to make their loans cheaper. 
 Worries over corporate and consumer creditworthiness might shrink the supply of credit in a way that the authorities would find hard to reverse. 
 These difficulties are most obvious in America, but they are not confined to it. 
 After a period of exceptionally rapid growth in lending, British banks too have had to make big provisions for bad debts; defaults are growing faster than during the recession of 1980&ndash;81. 
 The Bank of England, responding to fears of a credit crunch, has asked banks to think twice before turning away would-be corporate borrowers. 
 Japanese banks also are struggling. 
 Their exposure to the property market is unusually large; a sharp fall in Japanese property values, long predicted but yet to happen, could make them wobble. 
 The fall in the Tokyo stockmarket since the second half of 1989 has hurt the banks, by reducing the value of their capital. 
 Several have recently seen their credit ratings down-graded by Moody's. 
 The squeeze on government 
 Even America, where the squeeze on banks is tightest, is still a long way from a banking collapse like that of the 1930s. 
 As they showed in 1987, today's central bankers have a better understanding of their responsibilities as providers of liquidity and lenders of last resort. 
 Also, thanks to deposit insurance, the threat of bank runs is far less now than it was in the 1930s; the FDIC (which insures deposits up to &dollar;100,000) was created expressly to prevent them. 
 Ominously, however, this confidence-promoting institution is itself undergoing a crisis of confidence. 
 The FDIC is badly underfunded; on some estimates, it is technically insolvent. 
 In a crisis, it would need a huge injection of public money. 
 The continuing bail-out of the FSLC, the FDIC's counterpart for the savings-and-loan industry, shows the scale of the trouble. 
 Capital spending by the Resolution Trust Corporation, the federal agency charged with disposing of bankrupt S&amp;Ls, will be &dollar;70 billion in the current fiscal year alone. 
 Such frightening costs undermine the credibility of the FDIC, because, if a banking crisis were to start, the government might find itself facing a credit crunch of its own. 
 Years of irresponsible budgets have obliged America's fiscal policy to work perversely at a particularly awkward moment. 
 In previous recessions, governments have added to the budget deficit, over and above the automatic increase caused by the business cycle. 
 The recent budget agreement means that in the current fiscal year, as America moves into recession, this discretionary component of fiscal policy is tightening to the tune of 1% of GNP, almost enough to cancel out easing in the automatic component. 
 Even so, the budget deficit will be at least &dollar;250 billion. 
 This demand on the international capital markets raises interest rates, aggravating the problems of debt and credit crunch. 
 It also deprives the government of any room for manoeuvre in fiscal policy should the recession turn out to be worse than expected. 
 Trade follies 
 In different ways, paralysis in monetary and fiscal policy played a critical role in 1929&ndash;39. 
 But the fate of the American economy, and hence the world economy, was sealed by activism where activism could only do harm &mdash; in trade policy. 
 A war of escalating protection and counter-protection combined with falling output to form yet another vicious circle. 
 The value of world trade collapsed from &dollar;3 billion a month at the start of 1929 to less than &dollar;1 billion a month by the beginning of 1933. 
 Will last month's breakdown of the GATT talks do for the 1990s what Smoot-Hawley did for the 1930s? 
 With any luck, no. 
 The talks are retrievable. 
 But if the negotiators do allow them to fail after all, or if the United States Congress rejects any compromise that may be worked out during the next two months, the effects will be disastrous. 
 Many trade disputes are pending, awaiting the outcome of the talks; failure would activate them immediately. 
 Protectionists in Europe and America would rejoice, as they buried their governments under demands for trade &bquo;remedies&equo; of every sort &mdash; a super-301 action here, a countervailing duty there. 
 The struggling economic reformers in Eastern Europe and the third world would despair. 
 In time, a world divided into trading blocks would be a real possibility. 
 It would be a world with much less trade. 
 That is a bad thing in itself, for it means less competition and more wasted resources. 
 Worse, in the short term, would be the economic dislocation caused by the retreat from today's multilateral trading system. 
 Business confidence and investment would surely suffer. 
 At a time when skilful economic leadership will be needed to manage a variety of financial and other difficulties, and when international economic stability is most desirable, the biggest industrial countries seem ready to engage in trade war. 
 Disaster-makers, start now 
 A year from now, in all likelihood, the world will look back on a merely disappointing year of little or no growth in Britain and America, of solid progress in Germany and Japan, of catastrophes skirted in the Gulf and the Soviet Union. 
 Even if everything that might go wrong does go wrong, it would require extra efforts of neglect, incompetence and ill fortune to fashion a depression even half as bad as that of the 1930s. 
 But do not dismiss the risk of something much worse than a &bquo;meaningful downturn&equo;. 
 If governments really want to shatter the world economy, January 1991 would be an unusually good time to start. 
 FINANCE 
 American banking 
 How banks merge 
 NEW YORK 
 Bankers and regulators agree that hundreds, even thousands, of American banks will need to merge if they are to survive the 1990s. 
 How these banks set about merging will make or break them 
 IF THE past is any guide, America's 10,000 independent banks will number nearer 6,000 before the decade is out. 
 Poor in capital but rich in bad loans, many will go bust; probably more will be able to merge with other &mdash; with luck healthier &mdash; banks. 
 If so, the coming mergers will only reinforce an already established trend. 
 During the 1980s the average annual number of bank mergers, 300-odd, was double the figure for the 1970s and three times that for the 1960s. 
 Through merging and going bust, the number of independent banks fell from 13,400 in the mid-1960s to 12,700 in 1980 and to the 10,000 today. 
 There are plenty of reasons for supposing that the merger trend will gain vigour. 
 For one, the legal barriers thrown in the way of interstate banking in the 1930s were progressively lowered after the mid-1980s, leading to the rise of &bquo;super-regionals&equo;. 
 From next year those barriers will be gone altogether. 
 America's populist politicians, who long considered big banking as anathema, now see that even America's largest banks look Lilliputian in comparison with Japan's and Europe's. 
 Put together, argue those concerned with America's financial muscle, California's Security Pacific, New York's Bankers Trust and a super-regional, NCNB (formerly North Carolina National Bank). 
 Presto: you have a bank with &dollar;250 billion in assets to outrank all but half-a-dozen of Japan's mightiest. 
 For now, such notions of bigness play well in political circles but thankfully not in all banking ones. 
 Commercial banks everywhere are realising that profitable banks may become big, but not the other way round. 
 Many are pulling back from international markets. 
 And most bankers have come to understand that their trade is in fact a collection of diverse lines of business, each with its own and quite different economies of scale. 
 Yet banks' most compelling concern is access to precious capital, and mergers could prove one of the quickest ways to get it. 
 Mergers, especially between banks serving the same area, are being seen as the swiftest route to big cost savings; these, in turn, free up capital. 
 A joint study by Keefe, Bruyette &dollar; Woods, a stockbrokerage that specialises in bank shares, and Ernst &dollar; Young, a firm of accountants, found that banks achieved an average 35% saving in costs when they joined forces (admittedly less than they expected). 
 A merger between Chase Manhattan and its New York neighbour, Chemical Bank, could free up more money than the two banks' combined net profit over the past five years. 
 Marriage counsel 
 Dandy in theory, dismal in practice. 
 In a study of 400 of the biggest bank mergers in the 1980s, FMCG Capital Strategies, a New York consultancy, found that four out of five deals failed miserably &mdash; to the point where they soon destroyed value for the acquiring bank. 
 That statistic should unsettle those bankers now contemplating a merger. 
 FMCG thinks it has found four preconditions that greatly enhance a merger's chances of success. 
 Not paying too much is one of these. 
 However, note that the measure of a &bquo;good&equo; price varies with the point of view. 
 An acquirer should concentrate on the discounted value of the acquired bank's cash flow. 
 An acquired bank will want to maximise the price-to-book value for its shareholders. 
 Opinion-influencing analysts and commentators concentrate on the potential dilution in earnings per share. 
 The other three preconditions, according to FMCG, are: that the acquiring bank has a proven record of controlling its non-interest expenses (that is, the costs of computer systems, branches, staff and so forth); that the acquiring bank will be getting a mix of businesses, which, combined sensibly with their own, add up to more than the sum of the parts; and that the two banks are physically close together. 
 Though many bankers forget it, control of non-interest expenses is the most vital of the quartet &mdash; cost-savings are after all one of the prime motives for mergers. 
 Successfully merging two banks requires a fast and ruthless attack on costs. 
 The hard decisions need to be taken early. 
 Banks that have been repeatedly successful with mergers have a blueprint for consolidation ready to be used the moment a merger is complete. 
 The steering committee implementing it should include the functional heads of finance, personnel, automation and operations at the two banks, under the chairmanship of a senior manager from the acquiring bank. 
 William Boardman, the executive vice-president of an Ohio-based super-regional, Banc One, reckons that readiness-to-roll is more crucial than anything else. 
 Banc One has a team of managers that does little but work on mergers, and with good results. 
 Mr Boardman's squad now has more than 50 to its credit. 
 In California, Wells Fargo's acquisition of Crocker National in 1986 is an example of a bigger deal that was planned and executed with military precision. 
 FMCG thinks that control of non-interest expenses creates a virtuous circle of its own. 
 The acquiring bank transfers its good habits to the acquired, so increasing the group's return on equity. 
 This boosts the group's share price, making the next acquisition easier. 
 Banc One sets basic yet strict financial targets for the banks it takes over, but it lets local managers decide how to meet them. 
 It then gives the process a stamp of its own by running league tables within the group that show how the various subsidiary banks are performing against each target. 
 In regular group confessionals, the worst performers on any measure have to explain themselves to their peers. 
 Newcomers find it an acutely uncomfortable experience, which, of course, is the idea. 
 The Ohio bank does not leave its newcomers to sink or swim by themselves. 
 One of its first acts is to hook a newly acquired bank into its own computer systems. 
 Properly done, absorbing one system into the other brings immediate savings, particularly from those systems used for processing large amounts of data. 
 Scrapping duplicate computer facilities and staff accounts typically for four-fifths of all potential savings, according to FMCG's John Moynihan. 
 The ability of a bigger bank to absorb a smaller one into its systems is a main reason why purchases of smaller banks bring up to three times bigger savings than mergers of equals. 
 Banc One has a rule that it will not merge with an institution that is larger than one-third its own size. 
 The bank's other reason for turning two computers quickly into one is to get the newly acquired bank on Banc One's own financial-reporting system. 
 That lets it use software that standardises such products as deposits and instalment loans. 
 As well as letting the head office in Columbus keep track of its new siblings, this builds in lower costs from economies of scale. 
 It also means that all staff across the group get familiar with the same range of products. 
 Banc One leaves in place most of an acquired bank's existing management, with a handful of parent-bank staff moving into some of the top jobs. 
 These people bring with them something of the evangelist's zeal. 
 This faith is now facing its toughest test, for Banc One has moved into Texas, where it has acquired some bust thrifts. 
 On the drawing board, the acquisitions make sense: they give Banc One new and young customers in the reviving Texas market to balance its ageing ones in the Midwest. 
 They also let the bank apply its consumer-banking skills in an underdeveloped state. 
 But the new mergers are its first in a state that is not contiguous to one in which Banc One already operates. 
 As much as anything, successful mergers depend upon the chief executive. 
 But even Napoleons need their armies. 
 It is here that the ability of banks to pull off mergers successfully is most at question. 
 The 1980s bear testament to the appalling condition of American bank management. 
 As the country sees more mergers, success will become ever more elusive.  
 Investing in Wall Street's woes 
 Modish shorts 
 NEW YORK 
 YOU can get almost anything in New York by telephone, from sandwiches to sex. 
 So why not tips on shorting the stockmarket? 
 For &dollar;2 a minute a new bear's hotline gives investors share tips instead of hot breath. 
 The service thinks that stocks are heading downwards. 
 Soon to be cheaper by the dozen, if the service's &bquo;famous whisper section&equo; was correct on December 31st, are such stocks as Federal Express, PepsiCo, Coca-Cola and McDonnell Douglas. 
 Shorting the market means selling shares you have borrowed. 
 You will do that because you think their price will be lower when it comes to delivering them back to the lender at an agreed date. 
 For those with the nerves for it, shorting was a grand way to make money in the American market for most of 1990, as the thrifts mess, the problems of the commercial banks, falling property prices and a bevy of highly borrowed companies going bust provided plenty of reasons for share prices to fall. 
 The shares of Goodyear, a tyre maker, lost 56% last year; Navistar, a lorry maker, fell by 45%; American Express was down 42%; and AT&dollar;T and Sears, Roebuck were both down by 34%. 
 Should the current recession or events in the Gulf turn truly nasty, selling stock short could also be the best way to make money in 1991. 
 So far, shorting is still a specialists' game, but a growing one. 
 Professional investors have put at least &dollar;5 billion to work on the short side of the market. 
 This is equivalent to five days' trading volume on the New York Stock Exchange, 2.5 times more than a couple of years ago. 
 Shorting has much more influence than its size would suggest. 
 This is because short professionals tend to concentrate their firepower. 
 In Citicorp, the stock with the biggest short position outstanding, shorts have borrowed and sold 17m shares, or some 5% of the equity. 
 Firms like Eli Lilly, Varity (formerly International Harvester) and GTE have also attracted large short holdings. 
 At LA Gear, a fashion-clothing company, shorts have borrowed and sold no less than 40% of the stock. 
 Such exposures are destroying long-held notions that it is somehow unpatriotic for American investors to sell short the shares of American companies. 
 The other inhibition is more pragmatic: fear of unlimited losses on short positions that might result from a sudden market rally. 
 This happened to many punters who shorted bank stocks last year just as the Federal Reserve eased interest rates and so triggered a sharp rally in bank share prices. 
 Shorting is not for maiden aunts. 
 Intrepid professional shorts, like George Soros, are even short of the Tokyo market. 
 The Feshbach brothers in California are betting that the equity of some American money-centre banks will someday be practically worthless. 
 Joseph Feshbach, whose Southgate Partners manages &dollar;900m in short positions, feels that the price of bank shares does not yet reflect the decline in property values. 
 Nor does he feel the stockmarket has fully discounted a recession. 
 Mr Feshbach mentions Itel, a rail-car leasing company, Westinghouse Electric, Wells Fargo and First Interstate as tomorrow's tumblers. 
 Ed Levy of Levy Harkin concentrates on potential bankruptcies, like Integrated Resources, or companies that he believes have borrowed too heavily for their own good, such as Panhandle Eastern Pipeline and Marriott Hotels. 
 But both Mr Levy and Mr Feshbach short for the long-term, as it were. 
 Michael Steinhardt, on the other hand, has become one of America's most successful investors by being an active short-trader. 
 Over the past two months Mr Steinhardt has juggled positions in banks, drugs and oil-service companies to build up a short portfolio of &dollar;640m. 
 His prime shorts are what he calls his &bquo;vestal virgins&equo;, growth stocks selling at or near their all-time highs. 
 These include the shares of Microsoft, Costco, Forest Labs, Autodesk, Sci-Med and Sara Lee. 
 The shorts are betting that theirs is an industry with a bright future. 
 The Dow, at around 2,600, is down 400 points from its peak. 
 This is a mere stumble compared with the near 50% fall during the mid-1970s bear market. 
 Just the sort of miserable fact that keeps a short giggling in his sleep.    
 The top tier 
 AAA/Aaa rated banks in the world as rated by Standard &amp; Poor's and Moody's 
 Iraq and a hard place 
 Investors on Wall Street have rarely been in such an uncertain state &mdash; which means big money is about to be lost and won 
 THERE are at least three reasons to be glum. 
 Investors in America's stockmarkets face the uncertainties of events in the Gulf as the January 15th deadline imposed by the United Nations approaches. 
 There is also the knowledge that rolling regional recessions at home combined into a national one sometime last autumn. 
 And there is the nagging doubt that weaknesses in the financial system will hamper the real economy's ability to pull through the hard days now at hand. 
 It all makes many believe that over the coming months share prices will drop below the levels at which they opened 1991. 
 On January 2nd the Dow Jones industrial average closed its first trading day of the year at 2,610.6 and the broader based Standard &amp; Poor's (S&amp;P) 500 at 326.5, 13% and 12% off their respective all-time highs. 
 Will these measures fall much farther? 
 If so, for how long? 
 The fate of Kuwait is likely to have more influence over the answers than anything else. 
 A quick and clean military victory for the American-led alliance (or, even less plausibly, a sudden withdrawal of Iraq from Kuwait) would be the best outcome both for the market and for the economy. 
 Oil prices would spike in a short war, but quickly fall back to perhaps &dollar;20 a barrel. 
 America could then get away with a mild and relatively short recession, provided the domestic financial system did not spring any surprises. 
 A long and inconclusive stand-off in the Middle East, when oil prices could probably edge down from their recent &dollar;28-odd a barrel, would string out the recession but not deepen it greatly. 
 There is enough crude being produced outside Iraq and Kuwait to keep the world economy afloat. 
 A lengthy war, though, would be another matter. 
 If oil prices pushed up to &dollar;40 for even a couple of months, and if Middle Eastern fields became damaged, the contraction in the American economy could be severe. 
 If history is any guide, the average length of a recession in the past 60 years has been 18 months, with the average bear market wiping out about half the gain made during the bull market it succeeded. 
 Typically, stockmarkets lead the recovery of the real economy by four to six months. 
 Assuming that the start of the current recession (which on January 2nd was officially acknowledged, at last) was some time in October, investors can look forward to the Dow tumbling to 1,800 by the late autumn of 1991. 
 Yet the current recession is far from average. 
 It follows the American economy's longest (eight years) peacetime expansion. 
 It is also being ushered in by an unusual duo: contracting credit and falling interest rates. 
 Last December the Federal Reserve adjusted its reserve requirements on time deposits to encourage banks to lend more. 
 At the turn of the year the Fed further nudged down interest rates to encourage the banks' customers to borrow more. 
 Banks are now cutting their prime rates. 
 With the yield on 30-year Treasury bonds at 8.25% and that on three-month bills at 6.6%, long- and short-term interest rates are now lower than they were at the end of the two previous deep recessions, in 1981 and 1973. 
 Since such low rates are failing to revive growth, some economists reckon that the yield on long-dated government bonds would need to drop to around 7% to have much effect. 
 (That figure, though, depends as much on the future price of oil and the level of the dollar as on the price of credit alone.) 
 Another characteristic of this recession is that financial and property businesses have been the first to feel the pain of collapsing prices and profits. 
 Manufacturing, which bore the brunt of the deep 1981 recession, is so far not badly scathed. 
 It is harder to predict the length of a financial-led recession than a manufacturing-led one. 
 One reason is that one clue for recession-watchers, the build-up of manufactured stocks (inventories), is not much of a guide to a financial recession. 
 This time round, other things being equal, that indicator suggests the second-shortest recession since the second world war: that is, between six and eight months. 
 The low level of stocks &mdash; manufacturers and retailers were cutting back even before the Iraqi invasion &mdash; is a main prop of the short-and-mild school. 
 Proponents of the long-and-severe recession point to finance. 
 They say that financial institutions' troubled assets, such as loans for property and highly-geared companies, will take years to sort out. 
 In the meantime, banks will want to shrink their assets. 
 The resultant liquidity squeeze will hurt their customers. 
 The recent excesses of the financial world inevitably invite comparisons with the 1930s, when share prices fell by two-thirds in the five years following the Great Crash of 1929. 
 The chance of the financial system collapsing again is real enough &mdash; particularly if Congress makes a mess of addressing the structural problems of America's banking system. 
 Parallels with the 1930s (see pages 17&ndash;22) are also prompted by the protectionist threat to world trade from the breakdown of the Uruguay round of GATT talks. 
 Those leafing through their history books for an earlier model for the current recession could linger fruitfully over the pages that cover the 1870s. 
 That post bellum decade was ushered in by financial scandals, bank panics and a restructuring of the financial system. 
 The recession of the 1870s was shallow, but one that took the economy a long time to climb out of. 
 With the recovery, though, came a boom that confirmed America's coming of age as an industrial and financial power. 
 Today's investor with a bent for history &mdash; and therefore an appreciation for the long term &mdash; would not be nearly as cheerless as his short-term friends. 
 The historian-punter would be sitting in bonds (which have rallied in the past few months) waiting patiently to switch back to equities, starting cautiously in the middle of this year, and so to ride the bull market of the mid-1990s. 
 That could only be upset by pig-headedness in the Gulf or dumb-mindedness in Washington. 
 Both of which are entirely feasible.  
 Europe's reluctant superbanks 
 PARIS 
 With American and Japanese banks beating a hasty retreat, the 1990s could be the decade of the European. 
 But don't bet your shirt on it 
 A RULE of thumb in banking is that those firms at the top of the industry's league tables are ripe for relegation. 
 In the late 1970s and the early 1980s, American banks headed the league, but third-world debt then dragged them down. 
 Japanese banks took the Americans' place. 
 They bid fiercely for business for most of the 1980s, until a collapsing Tokyo stockmarket brought their come-downance. 
 If European bankers now want to keep their newly won crown, they must resist the same temptation to lend, lend, lend. 
 European banks could stay at the top for longer than their predecessors. 
 American banks will need years to recover from the now souring loans to property developers and leveraged buy-outs that followed their third-world lending. 
 Last year 169 American banks, with &dollar;16 billion-worth of assets, failed; the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation now has some 1,100 rickety banks under observation. 
 Japan's banks are cutting back their business after years of reckless lending. 
 The city banks (Japan's version of commercial banks) were some of the worst culprits. 
 As the booming Tokyo stockmarket increased their capital backing, they increased their loan books by 80% in 1985&ndash;89. 
 As many of their domestic loans were backed by property, the banks were also betting that Japan's land bubble would not burst. 
 Some institutions, such as Mitsubishi Bank, are doing well to worry that it might. 
 According to the capital-adequacy regime negotiated under the auspices of the Bank for International Settlements (BIS) in Basle, banks must have capital equal to at least 8% of their assets (weighted according to their riskiness) by, in Japan's case, March 1993. 
 As Japanese banks can count 45% of unrealised gains on shareholdings as capital, Japanese banks with huge equity portfolios thought they would easily meet the deadline. 
 Yet the Tokyo stockmarket fell by two-fifths in 1990, leaving some banks no choice but to shrink to fit. 
 The chart shows the weakness of Japanese banks' overall BIS ratios even before the Tokyo market began to fall. 
 Among the big city banks, only Fuji, which has shed some of its assets, had made the 8% minimum ratio by the end of September 1990. 
 In contrast, most big American and European institutions are already at or above the BIS target. 
 Some, like Germany's mighty Deutsche Bank, are awash with capital. 
 Credit ratings are another measure of muscle. 
 These set Europe's banks apart from both the Japanese and the Americans. 
 While only Industrial Bank of Japan (IBJ), Japan's Norinchukin Bank and America's J.P. 
 Morgan have AAA debt ratings from both Standard &dollar; Poor's and Moody's, two big American rating agencies, Barclays Bank, Deutsche Bank and Union Bank of Switzerland are among the eight European banks in the same category (see table on next page). 
 Though proud of their strong balance sheets, most European superbanks have yet to imitate the Japanese by lending aggressively abroad. 
 There are several reasons for their caution. 
 First, not all European banks are as invincible as they look. 
 British ones &mdash; National Westminster, for example &mdash; have used doubtful property revaluations to improve their capital ratios. 
 State-owned French banks, such as Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais, have relied on share-swaps with other state companies. 
 Although such ploys help to boost banks' capital ratios, they do not bring in new cash. 
 Second, some European banks' profits have slowed with their economies. 
 British banks have suffered as high interest rates pushed property into slump. 
 French banks have also seen their bad debts rise swiftly. 
 Soci&eacute;t&eacute; G&eacute;n&eacute;rale, one of the country's biggest banks, had to raise provisions against dud loans by more than half in the first six months of 1990. 
 Spanish banks are also suffering from a novel dose of competition. 
 They are offering interest-bearing current accounts to customers, but attracting few new deposits. 
 Lastly, many European banks are wary of transatlantic lending. 
 Though margins on top-notch corporate loans have nearly doubled in the American market to about 50 basis points (hundredths of one percent), they must widen further before it is worth lending in the midst of a recession. 
 Even if margins oblige, Europeans should tread warily. 
 As American banks retrench, they will corner almost all the profitable business at home, leaving Europeans and a handful of Japanese banks to fight over deals that are either unprofitable or too risky to be of interest. 
 So some European banks may think of buying a cheap American network in a shake-out of America's banking industry. 
 They should think again. 
 Britain's Midland Bank has still not recovered from its purchase of California's Crocker Bank, saddled with third-world debt. 
 The Bank of Ireland and National Westminster have burnt themselves in New England. 
 NatWest Bancorp lost &dollar;140m in the first nine months of 1990, mainly because of dud property loans. 
 Rather than looking abroad, smart European bankers will already have realised that with banks like Chase Manhattan and Security Pacific pulling back from Europe, some of the best corporate business will now be up for grabs in their own backyards. 
 Others will have started to look east, where the German banks are already preoccupied. 
 As well as German banks, British, French and Italian ones could steal a march on American and Japanese rivals in what could be a huge East European market. 
 But it is Western Europe that will prove the toughest test for Europe's biggest banks. 
 Some, like Deutsche Bank and Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais, are piecing together hugely expensive pan-European bank networks in the firm belief that retail banking can be moved across borders. 
 If they can get this grandiose strategy to work, the 1990s will undoubtedly be the decade of the European bank. 
 If they cannot, then banking's rule of thumb will have been right once again.  
 Latin American debt 
 Money in the well 
 WHEN in March 1989 the American treasury secretary, Nicholas Brady, announced his plan to reduce the third world's commercial-bank debt, particularly Latin America's, he was criticised for being too vague. 
 Nonetheless, in an admittedly modest way, his idea is beginning to work. 
 The most recent and most improbable Brady-plan deal, between oil-rich Venezuela and its bank creditors, was completed before Christmas in New York. 
 Under the Brady plan, hard-up countries which carry out structural economic reforms that meet the approval of the International Monetary Fund qualify not only for partial debt forgiveness by the banks but also, in some cases, for new money. 
 The terms of each deal vary with individual governments' performance. 
 The IMF's managing director, Michel Camdessus, thinks that the Brady plan &bquo;may even be gaining momentum.&equo; 
 Once a country has reached a Brady-plan deal, it is on the road to financial respectability. 
 The first of the debt-reduction deals came before the Brady plan was announced and, indeed, paved the way for it. 
 In 1987 dirt-poor Bolivia, which cut inflation from 20,000% a year to less than 10%, was allowed to use borrowed money to buy back most of its commercial-bank debt at 11% of the face value. 
 It thereby cut its total bank debt from &dollar;1.5 billion to &dollar;259m. 
 There was no new money, for Bolivia would not have been able to service it. 
 This was followed by Mexico, which was in deep trouble, though not as deep as Bolivia. 
 Its agreement in February 1990 set a Brady pattern by offering three options to commercial-bank creditors. 
 In Mexico's case, these could get out of their exposure by converting their debt into new saleable bonds with guarantees attached, but worth 65% of the face value of the old paper. 
 Or they could convert their debt into new guaranteed bonds whose yield was just 6.5%. 
 Or they could keep their old loans but with new guarantees, at the same time providing new money worth 25% of their exposure's value. 
 Only 10% of the banks risked the new-money option, while 41% agreed to debt reduction and 49% chose a lower interest rate. 
 This saved Mexico &dollar;3.8 billion a year in debt-servicing costs &mdash; and dissuaded many banks from fleeing across the Rio Grande. 
 Venezuela stands in sharp contrast because the banks see it as a better bet than Mexico. 
 In its Brady deal they took a dim view of a proposal to encash the country's paper at just 45% of its face value, which attracted a mere 7% of the total debt tendered. 
 The substitution of old debt for new low-interest bonds offering 6.75% with guarantees was the most popular (38% of the debt tendered), followed by an option for banks to have their old debt guaranteed in return for providing new money worth 20% of current exposure (31%). 
 This should bring in &dollar;1.15 billion for Venezuela. 
 In third place (15%) was a clever idea of swapping old paper for new bonds whose interest rate rises in steps over six years as (or if) Venezuela's financial position improves. 
 Less popular (9%) was an option to exchange existing loans at a discount of 30% for paper paying interest at the LIBOR interbank rate plus almost 1%. 
 Improvident Costa Rica, which has lately been trying to behave better, was not treated in May 1990 with the respect accorded to Venezuela. 
 Most creditor banks decided to pull out. 
 About 65% took an option of letting Costa Rica buy back its paper at 15% of face value, while only 35% picked two types of low-interest bonds; there was no new money. 
 Costa Rica was delighted, nonetheless. 
 The deal cut its debt-servicing cost from &dollar;150m a year to &dollar;40m. 
 Uruguay has obtained new money in a deal due to be signed on January 31st. 
 Banks covering 28% of the debt said they would make loans equivalent to 20% of their existing exposure. 
 Banks with 33% of the debt agreed to swap their paper for new bonds that yield 6.34%. 
 But those covering 39% of the debt decided to sell out for 56% of the debt's face value. 
 The two most prudent Latin American governments, Chile and Colombia, do not seem interested in the Brady plan. 
 They have managed to refinance their debts and even obtain modest amounts of new money fairly painlessly. 
 A Brady-plan sell-off of their debt at bargain-basement rates might damage their standing. 
 Next to &bquo;do a Brady&equo; in the western hemisphere, according to Mr Camdessus, may be Jamaica. 
 Ecuador may also send a proposal to the banks shortly. 
 But three big absentees remain. 
 These are Argentina (with interest arrears of about &dollar;8 billion), Brazil (with arrears of about &dollar;9 billion) and shambolic Peru. 
 Argentina has recently been paying the banks &dollar;40m a month (equivalent to three days of the monthly amount due), but has had no formal discussions with its banks about a rescheduling. 
 Brazil's sporadic talks have led nowhere. 
 Peru is still trying to climb out of the mire left by its previous president, Alan Garcia. 
 If these governments want to win back the access to international capital markets that they need in order to expand and prosper, they will have to come up with some ideas of their own.  
 In the Rhode Island red 
 NEW YORK 
 IF AMERICA ever needs a banking tsar, Bruce Sundlun is your man. 
 If nothing else, he is decisive. 
 Just three hours after being sworn in to his new job on January 1st as governor of Rhode Island, the gravelly-voiced Mr Sundlun ordered the closure of 45 small banks and credit unions. 
 These had a privately run deposit-insurance scheme that was on the point of going bust, following the failure in October of the two-branch Heritage Loan and Investment of Providence. 
 True, Rhode Island is hardly the financial capital of America. 
 Some 300,000 accounts, containing &dollar;1.7 billion of deposits, are affected by the temporary closures, which in effect froze the accounts. 
 Even so, the episode has hurt the prestige of private deposit-insurance schemes. 
 These have been touted by free marketeers as an answer to the growing financial problems of the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC). 
 In a small way, private schemes also exist in Maryland and Ohio, though these too have been struggling of late. 
 Because they are small, both schemes would be hurt by a shock similar to the one that hit the Rhode Island fund. 
 The Rhode Island Share and Deposit Indemnity Corporation, as the fund was known, is now in voluntary financial conservatorship. 
 Its &dollar;25m reserve fund had been run down to around &dollar;8m after auditors, following a takeover of Heritage in October, found &dollar;13m missing from Heritage's tills. 
 Neither were the auditors able to find Heritage's former president, Joseph Mollicone, to inquire where the money might be. 
 Heritage's depositors just took what they could of their own money and ran. 
 The insurance fund has since doubled its reserves through a levy on its other members, but fears that it still has insufficient funds to cover its potential obligations. 
 All but two of the closed institutions in Rhode Island have applied to join either the FDIC's scheme or a parallel one run by the National Credit Union Administration. 
 Only the healthiest will get it, the agency says. 
 For the rejects, Mr Sundlun's next decision will be to decide how quickly temporary closure becomes permanent, and by how much he can limit the cost to Rhode Island taxpayers. 
 Just the sorts of skills that are going to be increasingly in demand in Washington. 
 SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 
 The big picture 
 As the echoes of the big bang died away, the universe evolved from a bland ball of gas into a lacy web of galaxies. 
 How? 
 PARTICLE accelerators are designed to push as much energy into as small a volume as possible, which makes them big and costly. 
 Early in the universe's history, though, such concentrations of energy were the norm. 
 In an attempt to get data from this natural laboratory, particle physics has become ever more entwined with cosmology. 
 The result has been a theory to explain what would in any earlier age have been inexplicable: the birth of the universe. 
 In general, the theory has been a success. 
 But it is not flawless. 
 Until recently some of its predictions were at odds with what astronomers see in the sky. 
 New observations go some way to patching up that discrepancy but also bring difficulties of their own. 
 As things now stand, there is no convincing explanation of the biggest fact of all: the overall structure of the universe. 
 This was one of the problems tackled at a bumper symposium held in Brighton last month on cosmology, particle physics and astrophysics. 
 It was sponsored by the University of Texas, the European Southern Observatory and the European particle-physics laboratory, CERN. 
 Although the 600 participants disagreed about much, they were almost unanimous in one belief: the universe began in a big bang. 
 A veil of ignorance hangs over the moment of creation. 
 Theory-builders have tried to peer behind it, but none agrees on what they see, nor on ways of telling which of their glimpses is true. 
 However, within a second of creation the universe reached a state about which there is plenty of agreement. 
 It was small, immensely hot and filled with a dense soup of the fundamental particles: quarks (which are heavy) and leptons (which are light). 
 It is this state that fascinates particle physicists. 
 Their abiding passion is the unification of forces. 
 Today's universe contains four observable forces &mdash; the electromagnetic and gravitational ones, which work over long ranges, and the weak and strong nuclear ones, which work only locally. 
 Inside particle accelerators it is possible to show that the weak force and electromagnetism are two parts of a single &bquo;electro-weak&equo; force. 
 Above a certain energy, the difference between electromagnetism and the weak force vanishes. 
 The next aim for particle physics is to find a theory that unites the strong force with the electro-weak interaction. 
 Such a grand unified theory (GUT) would describe phenomena that take place at energies unobtainable in any accelerator. 
 It would also describe the behaviour of the quarks and other particles immediately after the big bang. 
 So one way to sort out the various GUTs is to see which can be used to tell believable &mdash; and, ideally, testable &mdash; stories about the big bang. 
 As the roar of the big bang faded, the universe got larger and its contents cooled down. 
 The GUT era ended, and the quarks gathered together to make protons and neutrons. 
 Eventually things got cool enough for the protons and neutrons to fuse and form atomic nuclei; later still it was possible for electrons to cling to the nuclei, thus creating atoms. 
 By this stage the universe was a warm ball of gas, about half as hot as the surface of the sun. 
 From then on gravity dominates the story. 
 The gas falls into clumps, eventually producing stars, galaxies and all the other astronomical paraphernalia. 
 Not by faith alone 
 There are three good reasons to believe this big-bang story. 
 In the 1920s Edwin Hubble observed that distant galaxies look redder than nearby ones. 
 That &bquo;red shift&equo; means that the galaxies are receding, and the light from them is being stretched out. 
 The farther the galaxy, the redder its light, and so the faster it is receding. 
 Hubble's conclusion was that the universe was expanding &mdash; a conclusion that could be described in terms of Einstein's theory of relativity, which provided the mathematics for describing the &bquo;fabric&equo; of space. 
 The galaxies are embroidered on this fabric: as it expands, they move apart. 
 An expanding universe must have been smaller in the past. 
 The speed at which galaxies are now receding implies that the universe was infinitely compressed some time between 12 billion and 18 billion years ago &mdash; thus giving a date for the big bang. 
 Scientists have studied how the cloud of electrons, protons and neutrons that came out of the big bang would have coalesced to make nuclei and atoms; their studies correctly predict the proportion of various chemical elements in the universe. 
 Such calculations also provide an insight into particle physics. 
 The fundamental particles of which matter is made are arranged in generations. 
 Each generation contains two quarks and two leptons, of which one is an electron or something like it and the other a neutrino. 
 Members of three such generations have been discovered; until recently there was no evidence from particle physics to rule out more. 
 However, the proportions in which elements are produced in the big bang depend on the number of types of neutrino (the neutrinos play a role in moving energy around the fireball). 
 By the mid-1980s scientists working on the problem were sufficiently sure about the amount of helium in the universe to say that there were probably only three types of neutrino, and thus only three generations. 
 In 1989 experiments confirmed this. 
 The third piece of evidence for the big bang is that you can see it. 
 Light from distant places is not only red-shifted by the expansion of the universe, it is also old. 
 Light from some distant objects was emitted before the sun first shone, and has been making its way to mankind's eyes throughout the history of the earth. 
 The light from the big bang, though, has come much farther &mdash; it has been travelling since the time, less than 1m years after the moment of creation, when the universe became thin enough for radiation emitted by one atom to be unlikely to hit another. 
 That radiation, red-shifted from visible light into radio waves, now suffuses the cosmos. 
 The distribution of frequencies in this &bquo;microwave background&equo; is just like the distribution of frequencies given off by a hot gas. 
 The uses of inflation 
 One problem with the big bang is the neatness of the universe. 
 Most explosions spread things unevenly. 
 The universe, though, seems a rather regular place. 
 Although it is quite lumpy on a small scale, with matter gathered in planets and stars and emptiness in between, on larger scales the matter is surprisingly evenly spread. 
 A related problem is the evenness of the microwave background. 
 As NASA's recently launched Cosmic Background Explorer (COBE) confirmed, the background looks the same all over the sky, which implies that the cooling fireball which produced it was not given to clumpiness. 
 In the 1980s a new idea was added to the big bang to explain this evenness, and other problems. 
 Well before a billionth of a second had elapsed, when the universe was still only the size of an atom, it started to grow exponentially. 
 For a time briefer than the smallest period measurable by today's clocks, the universe grew ever faster, as energy stored up in some hitherto unsuspected field of force was released. 
 By the end of this period, it had grown to the size of a grapefruit &mdash; not much, admittedly, but a billion billion times larger than before. 
 It was all so sudden that the universe had no time to lose the smoothness it had when it was the size of an atom. 
 &bquo;Inflation&equo;, as this is called, got a rapturous reception when it was put forward in 1980, despite, or perhaps because of, its weirdness (cosmologists, after all, undergo years of training so that they can say things like &bquo;When the universe was the size of a grapefruit&equo; without blushing or laughing). 
 It does not explain all the peculiar initial conditions of the big bang; but it does provide some rationale for conditions that otherwise have to be accepted as given. 
 However, inflation also makes some demands on observers. 
 It requires that the density of the universe, a number known as W, be exactly 1. 
 Unfortunately, estimates of W based on the visible stars and galaxies were, at the time, much lower: around W=0.01. 
 The theorists were adamant, though, and thus began the hunt for the &bquo;missing mass&equo; &mdash; unobserved dark stuff that would bring W up to 1. 
 This dark matter is of special interest to the particle physicists. 
 The same calculations that so accurately predict the proportions in which the elements are made in the big bang also predict the amounts in which they are made. 
 If the universe consisted of just the elements cooked up in the big bang, then W would be about 0.1 &mdash; ten times larger than it appears, but ten times less than theory demands. 
 Rather than see this as a problem, the particle physicists see it as an opportunity. 
 It implies that 90% of the universe is composed of something other than everyday atoms &mdash; swarms of exotic particles never seen on earth. 
 The congregating flotsam 
 The problem of the missing mass is bound up with the other great problem of cosmology &mdash; where did the overall structure of the universe come from? 
 Stars congregate in galaxies. 
 Galaxies, too, tend to clump together in clusters, which in turn may be parts of superclusters. 
 Surveys of galaxies show large voids with virtually nothing in them, and filaments and walls made up of clusters and superclusters. 
 And new structure is always being found. 
 The size of the largest known structure in the universe seems to increase hand in hand with the scale of the largest maps. 
 Although inflation was invoked to make the universe smooth, it can provide a certain degree of clumpiness. 
 There will be fluctuations in the density of an inflationary universe. 
 They alone would not be enough to account for the clumpiness on intermediate scales that studies of the sky reveal; but there is a way to amplify their effects. 
 In a rare fit of parsimony, theorists suggested that the dark matter already invoked to bring W up to 1 might also serve to make large structures. 
 As the universe aged, the slightly over-dense areas left by inflation would draw dark matter to themselves because of the force of gravity. 
 Thus the dark matter would be spread around in a way that mimicked but exaggerated the initial fluctuations. 
 Everyday atoms would fall in towards the dark matter, and eventually form stars and galaxies, highlighting the peaks in the distribution of dark matter. 
 Computer models show that the best way of coming up with an inflationary universe that shows the same degree of clumpiness as the real one is to use dark matter that is &bquo;cold&equo;. 
 Cold dark-matter particles move slowly &mdash; hot ones move at nearly the speed of light. 
 Because hot dark matter is always rushing about, it wipes out details, and does not allow thin delicate structures like those seen in the sky. 
 During the 1980s, cold dark matter (CDM) became the most popular explanation of the large-scale structure of the universe. 
 At the Brighton conference, though, it came under attack from those who make maps of the sky. 
 A group based in Oxford and Cambridge produced a picture that shows the positions of 2m galaxies in the sky. 
 Although the map does not reveal how far away they are, and thus their three-dimensional layout, statistics derived from it show a higher degree of structure at large scales &mdash; supercluster size and upwards &mdash; than CDM would predict. 
 It is possible to make three-dimensional maps. 
 There are ways to measure the distance to nearby galaxies that do not rely on their red shift. 
 If you know that distance, you can work out what the red shift would be if it were due entirely to the expansion of the universe. 
 If the actual red shift is different, you have a measure of the galaxy's &bquo;peculiar&equo; movement. 
 That movement presumably stems from the galaxy being gravitationally drawn towards something. 
 Maps that use these peculiar motions to build up pictures of the amount of matter in space have been prepared by various researchers over the past year or so. 
 Using the movements of visible things to track down their invisible causes has a healthy set of precedents. 
 The rotation of the spiral arms of galaxies convinced astronomers that galaxies are embedded in haloes of dark matter, regardless of whether theory needed that dark matter or not. 
 Now the movements of whole groups of galaxies are providing estimates of W. At Brighton, Avishai Dekel of the Hebrew University in Jerusalem and Nick Kaiser of the University of Toronto presented maps derived from the peculiar velocities of galaxies using different methods. 
 The group Dr Kaiser works with finds W to be about 0.8; Dr Dekel and his colleagues find much the same. 
 This is by far the best evidence so far for the existence of a large amount of some sort of dark matter. 
 But the orthodox CDM model cannot draw much comfort from it. 
 The survey Dr Kaiser has worked on shows evidence of structure at a scale which he thinks is too large for CDM to explain. 
 A controversial survey done by astronomers at Durham and London may provide yet more evidence against it. 
 Looking a long way out along one line, it found &bquo;walls&equo; of galaxies at regular intervals. 
 Many are sceptical about that finding, but Dr Dekel feels that if something similar, of equal statistical validity, could be found along another line of sight, the CDM model would become untenable. 
 Oh dear, what can the matter be? 
 In the search for alternatives, eyes are turning away from faraway galaxies and towards the nearest and most humdrum piece of astrophysics: the sun. 
 The fusion reactions that power the sun must produce vast numbers of neutrinos. 
 But experiments designed to detect them fail to find enough. 
 That has led to a suggestion with far-reaching consequences. 
 There are three generations of neutrino just as there are of every other particle. 
 The sun produces first-generation, &bquo;electron-type&equo; neutrinos. 
 If on their way out of the sun some of these become second- or third-generation neutrinos, then they would slip through earthly detectors unnoticed. 
 Explaining this generation-skipping will require new physical theories; those should provide pointers towards a grand unified theory of the strong, weak and electromagnetic forces, or even a substantial portion of the GUT itself. 
 Sidney Bludman, of the University of Pennsylvania, argued in Brighton that the turncoat neutrinos suggest that GUTs come into the picture at lower energies than are normally expected. 
 Dennis Sciama, of the Institute for Theoretical Physics in Trieste, teased out the consequences the neutrinos could have for the dark-matter debate in a journal, Nature, a week before the conference. 
 Up until now there has been no need to believe that neutrinos have any mass at all. 
 If they do indeed oscillate between generations, though, they must have mass. 
 The mass of the first-generation neutrino is probably negligible. 
 But if each generation is heavier than the last, as is the case with quarks, then the third-generation neutrino could well be heavy enough to make W=1. 
 However, neutrino dark matter would not be cold &mdash; it would be hot, since the neutrinos would still be light enough to zip around. 
 The reason for preferring one's dark matter cold is that CDM is better at turning the density fluctuations of inflation-theory into wells in which galaxies can form. 
 Other origins for the structure might be as well or better served by hot dark matter. 
 The most popular alternatives are &bquo;flaws&equo; of various sorts. 
 As the big bang cooled off, the universe went through a series of transitions (for example, from the high-energy state when all the forces were the same to the low-energy state in which they are different). 
 These transitions would not occur altogether smoothly &mdash; flaws would be created, like the planes and lines formed when water freezes. 
 Cosmic strings &mdash; heavy, one-dimensional flaws that are really just strands of energy &mdash; had a brief spell in the limelight in the mid-1980s. 
 They have since run into some problems and it is often easier to invent a new theory than to repair yesterday's novelties. 
 According to Robert Brandenberger, of Brown University in Providence, Rhode Island, hot dark matter and cosmic strings can be used to produce large-scale structures like the ones actually observed. 
 Neil Turok, of Princeton University, favours a more complex, multi-dimensional type of flaw he calls a texture. 
 With CDM, the textures produce more clumpiness at large scales than inflation's density fluctuations can provide &mdash; which puts them in line with the observations. 
 What they might manage with hot dark matter is not clear. 
 The creation of strings, textures and their weird kin is traditionally kept in the earliest universe &mdash; about which less is known, providing more room for manoeuvre. 
 That means they would already be exerting their influence by the time the microwave background was born. 
 As yet, though, the best measurements of the microwave background show none of the tell-tale marks that such flaws would leave. 
 If measurements ten times more sensitive, already being planned, show the same thing, yet more radical ideas may be needed. 
 Unless, that is, the flaws appeared after the background glow. 
 David Schramm, of the University of Chicago, along with Chris Hill from Fermilab, the particle-physics laboratory just outside Chicago, has recently suggested that there may have been transitions after the microwave background was emitted. 
 Here again, neutrinos with mass might help. 
 At Brighton, Dr Schramm speculated that neutrinos might all have been massless until quite late in the story, when the average energy of the neutrinos would have dropped below some threshold, making the three neutrinos develop their masses. 
 Such a late transition could produce galaxy- and cluster-sized flaws. 
 Some will throw up their hands at such tottering edifices of supposition. 
 There is no doubt that more data are needed. 
 The universities of Chicago and Princeton are planning to dedicate a new telescope to producing a three-dimensional map of 1m galaxies. 
 Other deep surveys are underway. 
 New large telescopes may clarify how galaxies form &mdash; at present a surprisingly difficult puzzle &mdash; and why they cluster. 
 New studies will search for the tiniest blips in the microwave background. 
 Nor are the astronomers doing all the work. 
 Isolated detectors are sitting in laboratories around the world, waiting for a piece of dark matter &mdash; hot, cold, lukewarm or otherwise &mdash; to come along. 
 New observatories to spot neutrinos arriving from space are being built in Italian mountains, Canadian mines and perhaps the depths of the Pacific. 
 Fermilab and CERN will make new efforts to catch homegrown neutrinos changing their colours. 
 The next decade looks promising &mdash; especially for those who study the newly hot topic of neutrinos. 
 One of today's hypotheses may become orthodox; some new notion may sweep all before it. 
 By making more use of data from the sky, particle physics could well be freed, at least to some extent, from the dark caverns of ever-bigger atom smashers. 
 In so doing, it may also win new respect in other areas of physics, where many see it as a fascinating but over-costly irrelevance. 
 By predating everything else, particle physics may yet be able to underpin it all. 
 BUSINESS WEEK 
 Money matters 
 George Bush finally admitted that parts of the American economy are &bquo;clearly in a recession&equo;, claiming that the last quarter of 1990 will have been the worst. 
 The Commerce Department's index of leading economic indicators fell twice as much as expected during November. 
 Four big banks cut their prime lending rate by half a point to 9.5%. 
 Brazil has passed a law that allows five-year prison terms and heavy fines to be inflicted on multinationals that fail to restrain their prices. 
 The government puts particular blame on car makers and pharmaceutical companies for an inflation rate that in December was nearly 20%. 
 More than 226,000 new private businesses registered in eastern Germany in the first ten months of last year. 
 The Soviet Union and its Comecon trading partners switched from the so-called transferable rouble to the dollar for their rapidly diminishing trade. 
 Paying real money for imports will hurt Eastern Europe. 
 Cash flows 
 The Japanese spent &yen;5 trillion (&dollar;35 billion) on business entertaining in 1990, up a belt-busting 9.4% from 1989. 
 Another big Japanese property company has collapsed. 
 After chalking up debts of &yen;500 billion (&dollar;3.5 billion), Tokyo-based EIE is being rescued by five large Japanese banks. 
 The rescue should be Japan's second-largest ever. 
 Rupert Murdoch's media empire neared the rocks as he negotiated with 150 banks to reschedule virtually all of News Corp's &dollar;8 billion of debt. 
 As part of the deal he may be forced to sell assets worth &dollar;2 billion within the next three years. 
 With losses amounting to &pound;71m (&dollar;137m) in Italian life insurance, Guardian Royal Exchange, a British insurance company, is shedding two of three Italian subsidiaries it bought nearly two years ago. 
 General gloom means that GRE could face a total 1990 loss of &pound;100m. 
 A smart department store in London, Harrods, has signed an agreement with a Japanese trading company, Mitsubishi Corporation, to sell fashions through &bquo;signature shops&equo; in Japanese department stores. 
 The deal could generate annual sales of up to &pound;50m (&dollar;97m) within five years. 
 In a move which makes it Australia's largest distributor of spirits, Guinness has paid an undisclosed sum to Carlton and United Breweries for a half-share in Bundaberg rum, the country's largest selling spirit. 
 Bank statements 
 A complicated share swap between a top Belgian industrial group, Soci&eacute;t&eacute; G&eacute;n&eacute;rale de Belgique, and holding companies controlled by Albert Fr&egrave;re, a Belgian industrialist, will bring La G&eacute;n&eacute;rale nearer to the Fr&egrave;re family, which controls Groupe Bruxelles Lambert. 
 The new governor of Rhode Island closed more than half the state's banks following the collapse of a private insurance fund which guarantees deposits at 45 banks not insured by the federal government. 
 Order, order 
 Nomura held on to top spot in the annual Eurobond underwriting rankings while other Japanese firms slipped; Yamaichi dropped to tenth while London's CSFB shot up to second place. 
 The proportion of issues in dollars dropped in 1990 to 39.5% from 56% in 1989, while yen bonds doubled their share in the same period, to 12%. 
 Ecu bonds rose from 5% to 10%. 
 After a year of arguments, a new corporate watchdog, the Australian Securities Commission, came into being. 
 The commission has more money and wider powers than its feeble predecessor. 
 Four years after its launch, London's Third Market sank. 
 Set up to provide money for growing companies, the stockmarket failed to attract investors. 
 For the first time since 1979, western semiconductor companies gained market share from Japanese rivals last year, according to Dataquest, a market researcher. 
 Wheelies 
 Despite abandoning a planned &pound;34m (&dollar;66m) European airline venture with Belgium's carrier, Sabena, and KLM Royal Dutch Airlines, British Airways still wants an alliance with the troubled Sabena, but faces competition from other airlines pursuing the same goal. 
 Japan's second largest car maker, Nissan, is to cut its links with Nissan UK, the privately owned company that has had exclusive distribution rights for its cars in Britain for 21 years. 
 Nissan claimed that Octav Botnar, the reclusive owner of Nissan UK, is too difficult to deal with. 
 Mr Botnar is consulting lawyers. 
 After stalemate on the proposed merger between the two American airlines, Carl Icahn, owner of TWA, is set to make a formal offer for beleaguered Pan Am. 
 He has already hinted at a price of around &dollar;375m. 
 General Dynamics and McDonnell Douglas, builders of the super-expensive A-12 fighter for the United States Navy, want the Pentagon to bail them out of a possible &dollar;2.7 billion overrun on the development and production of A-12s. 
 That would put the cost at &dollar;7.5 billion. 
 ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL INDICATORS 
 OUTPUT, DEMAND AND JOBS 
 America's retail sales fell in November, for the fourth consecutive month, and were 1.7% lower than a year ago. 
 New figures for Canada, Sweden and Switzerland also show falls. 
 Japanese retail sales leapt 7.5% in the 12 months to September. 
 French industrial production rose 1.1% in the year to October. 
 Over the same period Canada's industrial output fell 2.8%. 
 Japan's jobless rate fell to 2.1% in November, after two months at 2.2%. 
 In the same month Swiss unemployment rose to the still modest rate of 0.7%. 
 PRICES AND WAGES 
 German consumer-price inflation fell to 2.7% in the 12 months to December, from 3.0% in November. 
 Japan's inflation jumped to 4.2% in the year to November, the fastest rate since 1981. 
 Canadian workers received a 5.4% wage increase in the year to October, a real rise of 0.6%; Italian employees got a 7.1% rise in the year to September, or 0.8% in real terms. 
 Switzerland's wholesale prices rose 0.7% in the 12 months to November. 
 ECONOMIC GROWTH 
 The OECD forecasts growth for industrial economies of an average of 2.0% in 1991, down from an estimated 2.8% last year. 
 That average conceals more than it reveals: the OECD expects seven countries to have real GNP growth of 3% or more. 
 Two economies are tipped to enjoy significantly faster growth than in 1990: Iceland (3.4%, compared with a decline of 0.1% in 1990) and New Zealand where GNP is forecast to &bquo;surge&equo; by 1.5%, after a dismal annual average of 0.3% during the past five years. 
 Only one country is expected to see its GNP decline between the two years: Sweden, with a 0.5% drop. 
 At the other extreme, Japan is predicted to be the OECD's fastest grower in 1991 (3.7%), followed closely by Turkey (3.5%), which was last year's top performer. 
 COMMODITY PRICE INDEX 
 The tin mines at Bom Futuro in the Brazilian Amazon near the border with Bolivia are open again. 
 But only 3,000 wildcat miners are digging at the mine, compared with 20,000 a year ago. 
 Miners blame the fall in world prices &mdash; down by almost half in 18 months, to &dollar;5,700 a tonne. 
 The mine was closed last September when Brazil informally agreed with the Association of Tin Producers to limit its tin exports to 38,000 tonnes in 1990. 
 Brazil produced more than 50,000 tonnes of tin in 1989. 
 Some 30,000 tonnes of it came from Bom Futuro and an estimated 12,000 tonnes were smuggled into Bolivia. 
 In 1990 output at Bom Futuro is likely to have totalled only 21,000 tonnes.  
 STOCKMARKETS 
 Though few investors would believe it, stockmarket indices rarely end a year worth less, in nominal terms, than they began it. 
 That is rarer still for a worldwide index. 
 Yet 1990 was an exception: thanks to economic slowdown, rising interest rates and Saddam Hussein, Morgan Stanley Capital International's world index ended the year 18.6% lower, in dollar terms, than it began it. 
 This is only the fifth time this has happened in 20 years: the others were in 1970, 1973, 1974 and 1981. 
 Of the 16 countries in our table only three produced gains for dollar-based investors and only two &mdash; South Africa and Hong Kong &mdash; in terms of local currency. 
 The wooden spoon was won by a frequent former champion: Japan. 
 There, a sharp rise in interest rates popped the market's speculative bubble. 
 Share prices ended 1990 38.7% down in yen terms. 
 TRADE, EXCHANGE RATES AND RESERVES Japan's visible-trade surplus widened to &dollar;62.3 billion in the 12 months to November, but its current-account surplus fell to &dollar;37.7 billion. 
 In the same period Britain's visible-trade deficit declined slightly to &dollar;30.8 billion; its current-account deficit shrank to &dollar;27.2 billion. 
 WORLD BOURSES 
 Renewed fears of war in the Gulf left stockmarkets depressed. 
 In Europe Madrid lost 2.0%, Frankfurt 1.9%, Paris 0.8% and London 0.6%. 
 Asian bourses also fell: Tokyo lost 1.1%, Singapore 1.5% and Hong Kong 1.2%. 
 Wall Street gained 0.5%. 
 MONEY AND INTEREST RATES 
 Britain's broad-money growth quickened to 14.4% in the 12 months to November; its narrow-money growth slowed to 3.1%. 
 Over the same period, Germany's broad money supply grew by 5.5%. 
 Australian banks cut their prime lending rate to 15.5%. 
 LEADERS 
 Europe's latest farming muddle 
 Though Britain is keenest to reform the common agricultural policy, it is foolishly resisting the chance of a change 
 DRIVEN by one of its recurrent cash crises, the European Community is considering yet another &bquo;revolutionary&equo; reform of its common agricultural policy. 
 The British government, for the sake of the world trading system and the welfare of its people, ought to support this vulnerable initiative. 
 Instead, it loudly criticises the changes suggested by Ray MacSharry, the EC's farm commissioner, while being less than forthright about its preferred alternative. 
 In 1990 the EC spent about &dollar;49 billion in state subsidies to farmers. 
 That was dwarfed by the &dollar;85 billion of extra help that came from European consumers, whose food prices were rigged way above world-market levels. 
 Americans, with whom the EC is arguing over farm subsidies in a struggling GATT round, spent almost the same amount (&dollar;47 billion) on government subsidies for farmers; but, as consumers, they provided much less additional help &mdash; a mere &dollar;28 billion. 
 European eyes are fixed on the first of these figures: public spending that is now shooting through the ceiling set in the EC's self-denying ordinance of 1988. 
 Yet it is the second figure, that &dollar;85 billion, that is the real scandal. 
 Price-rigging is chiefly what leads to four-fifths of EC farm support going to the richest one-fifth of its farmers. 
 It is particularly harmful to farmers elsewhere because the Community &mdash; with its guaranteed price of, eg, wheat, standing at 165 ecus (&dollar;225) per tonne &mdash; produces more than it needs, then dumps its surplus onto the world market. 
 That surplus has helped push the world price down to as little as 55 ecus per tonne. 
 Any decent reform of this nonsense has to start with a firm recognition that it is better to take money from taxpayers than from consumers. 
 This is for two reasons: (a) state subsidies to farmers are harder to disguise than rigged prices, and therefore harder to keep increasing; so even if the right reforms initially seem perverse &mdash; requiring EC governments to spend more on farmers &mdash; that will be only temporary. 
 And (b) rigged prices lead to the dumped surpluses that distort world trade; so the goal is to move the EC's intervention prices down towards world-market ones &mdash; down, as a minimum, towards what a truly efficient European farmer can survive on. 
 The closer to market reality prices can be moved, the less will anybody need to worry about EC farm surpluses. 
 A surplus is an embarrassment only when it is subsidised: unsubsidised, it becomes an export success. 
 It is now widely accepted that the thrust of EC farm support must move towards direct payments to farmers. 
 But direct payments for what? 
 Mr MacSharry's answer is: merely for being farmers on small farms. 
 For, eg, cereals, he wants to cut the EC's intervention price by 40%, using direct aid to compensate the 4m cereal farms of less than 30 hectares. 
 Only 300,000 cereal farms would be too large to qualify for full compensation &mdash; but they farm no less than half of the EC's cereals fields and produce almost two-thirds of its cereals crop. 
 For them the MacSharry treatment is grim: slashed prices, grants that taper away with increasing size of farm, and good land forced to lie fallow. 
 Gimme Gummer 
 Here is a poisoned chalice for Britain's farm minister, John Gummer. 
 Half of Britain's cereal farms rank among the big 300,000. 
 The MacSharry scheme would enrage these farmers and reduce the budgetary payments that Britain gets from the CAP. 
 But Mr Gummer knows that an unvarnished &bquo;what's in it for us?&equo; response is inadequate. 
 He adds that the MacSharry approach would penalise efficiency and preserve allotment-sized farms, and that farmers should receive grants for doing desirable things, not just for having small plots. 
 Instead, he wants more money paid to all farmers for environmental virtue, and much more for &bquo;set aside&equo; &mdash; paying for fields to remain uncultivated. 
 A CAP designed only to promote efficient farming would abolish itself forthwith. 
 The CAP's chief aim nowadays is to slow the rate at which struggling European farmers are leaving the land. 
 If it is to do this in a more precise, less trade-distorting way, it is bound to be less helpful to big and efficient farms than to small ones. 
 And set-aside? 
 That is an odd prescription from an apostle of efficiency: you pay your most productive farmers not to produce. 
 Mr Gummer should pick up Mr MacSharry's ideas and remould them to meet sensible criteria. 
 They should help small farmers, but not in a way that discourages them from getting larger or farming better: there must be no farming poverty trap. 
 A CAP reform should pay farmers for improving the look of the countryside &mdash; but proportionately to the physical results, and even-handedly between small farms and large ones. 
 It must correctly motivate the 40% of the EC's farmers who are only part-timers: that means that any income subsidies must be geared, however partially, to production. 
 And the new system must be fraud-resistant: that means that income subsidies must be dependent on farm-size too. 
 If the net result is a big change to who gets what from the EC kitty, that problem should be tackled directly through EC budget negotiations, not by warping the CAP. 
 There is a game that bedevils all discussion of CAP reform. 
 You propose a new wheeze to help farmers; I cite a specific nonsense that will result. 
 Any scheme that gives money directly to farmers is indeed bound to be more leak-prone, and need more bureaucrats, than a rigged-price system. 
 Such shortcomings must be set against the big truth &mdash; that today's CAP is a supremely insidious way of extracting &dollar;85 billion from consumers within the EC, and queering the pitch for farmers everywhere else.  
 Don't coddle or curb them 
 The pain in the world's airline industry can be eased best by more American-style deregulation, not less 
 ONCE a glamorous adventure, flying seems ever more like a trial to be endured or avoided. 
 Now the fear of renewed terrorism sparked by war in the Gulf has emptied airports and aeroplanes, giving airlines their harshest times in living memory. 
 Many claim they cannot survive without government help. 
 This week the European Commission extended a hand to Europe's carriers, relaxing rules barring subsidies and capacity-sharing for three months. 
 A few American airlines, financially crippled by the free-for-all in the deregulated American market, also want help. 
 Isn't air travel too important for governments to stand by while the industry collapses? 
 And surely the spectacle of American airlines gobbling each other up and then going bust suggests that government guidance is needed to preserve the orderly flow of airline flights? 
 Such a benign view of government refereeing of the skies is widely held outside America. 
 But it has always been wrong, and is more wrong today than ever before. 
 Lesson from America 
 Since its birth in the 1920s, air travel has been one of the world's most heavily regulated industries. 
 Government-organised cartels have stunted its growth. 
 Misplaced concern for national prestige has sustained in the air a costly mercantilism abandoned long ago for most earth-bound industries. 
 The moral is plain: any help for airlines should be tailored to the Gulf war and should not survive it. 
 Last year the European Community's governments reluctantly agreed to dismantle many of the rules protecting, and shackling, their own airlines after the scheduled completion of its internal market in 1992. 
 If the temporary air-travel hiatus caused by the Gulf war encourages the Brussels commission to falter in its commitment to deregulate, an overdue chance to extend the benefits of a free market beyond America's shores could slip away for years. 
 Those who fear change in Europe like to say that America's deregulation of its domestic airline industry in 1978 has resulted only in crowded airports and poor service. 
 In fact it has been a dazzling success, by almost every measure. 
 By 1990 the number of passenger-miles had increased by 95%. 
 Fares had fallen about 20% in real terms. 
 Passengers had saved more than &dollar;100 billion on their tickets, and enjoyed far more choice. 
 But most acts of deregulation have flaws and, in hindsight, America's freeing of the skies had two. 
 The first was a blunder by American officials: the lax enforcement of anti-trust rules. 
 This prompted big airlines to dominate the nation's largest airports and then to devour the fleet of small carriers that became airborne soon after deregulation. 
 Today 90% of America's domestic passenger traffic is carried by the eight largest airlines. 
 The second flaw was no fault of the Americans: their failure, despite repeated attempts, to persuade other governments to deregulate international flights. 
 With relatively small home markets, other countries feared that their national flag carriers would be swamped by big American airlines. 
 Even while freeing its market at home, America found itself locked into the pernicious logic of government-to-government deals abroad. 
 This month's tit-for-tat with Britain about the sale of landing slots at London's Heathrow airport, which provoked American officials into banning low-price fares across the Atlantic, is one perverse result. 
 This is why it is so vital that the EC's half-hearted plans to deregulate its airlines after 1992 should be strengthened, not diluted. 
 For the first time ever, the EC is forging an internal market large enough to offer America equivalent access and to support airlines that are really competing. 
 Europe and America should allow each other's airlines to fly anywhere, anytime. 
 Restrictions on investment in each other's airlines should go, and airlines would be allowed to merge, divest, start up or close down. 
 Europe's airport slots should be bought and sold like any other asset, as slots are in America, with new slots going to the highest bidder. 
 The dominance of airports by a single airline should be limited. 
 Lower fares, more choice and better service would be the rewards. 
 A pipe dream? 
 Only to those sedated by the past. 
 America has already shown that a free market in air travel works. 
 And the Bush administration is sending clear signals that it would welcome such a deal. 
 This week Samuel Skinner, America's transport secretary, reaffirmed his belief that the 25% limit on foreign ownership of American airlines should be raised to 49%. 
 Offered free access to Europe's market for American airlines, America would almost certainly reciprocate. 
 A genuinely free air-travel market in America and Europe would spark off a wave of restructuring among European airlines. 
 Glorious old names would disappear. 
 Either state-owned airlines would have to be privatised, or the Community's rules limiting state subsidies would have to be strictly enforced. 
 But there is no reason to think that airlines based in Europe could not compete in this expanded transatlantic market. 
 And these mergers and bankruptcies would barely affect passengers, as America's experience has shown. 
 So long as people want to travel, the money, aircraft and qualified staff are always available for some determined operator to keep services going, no matter what happens to individual airlines. 
 That is how free markets work. 
 Once rid of the tasks of allotting routes and setting fares, governments could concentrate on the function that rightly belongs to them: expanding the capacities of airports and air-traffic-control systems. 
 Chronic shortages of both cause most of the congestion and delays that reduce the quality of air travel. 
 Heavy-handed regulation of European airlines has done nothing to ease congestion, only kept fares twice as high as those in America. 
 Faced with the 1979 oil shock and recession, America did not flinch from deregulation. 
 Facing a similar mixture today, and with even more to gain, Europe should be just as brave.  
 Farewell, poll tax 
 Its least-bad replacement would be a tax on the value of each house and flat 
 FIRST catch your hare, said Mrs Beeton's famous cooking instructions for the jugged variety. 
 Any recipe for a successful reform of local-government finance in Britain should start in similar vein: first kill the poll tax. 
 The cabinet's current review of the tax now looks likely to heed this advice and go for the quick chop. 
 The spirit of the poll tax, though, threatens to live on. 
 Some Conservative members of Parliament would like to retain its principle &mdash; that everyone should pay something. 
 Other would-be reformers are going to the opposite extreme, trying to concoct complicated ways for people in one district to subsidise those in another. 
 These and other ideas do more to confuse than to clarify. 
 For political reasons as much as for economic ones, the government needs to come up with a scheme that is simple (so that its essence can be explained in one sentence) and seen to be fair (the duke pays more than the dustman). 
 To pull this off, the government should keep in mind some first principles. 
 Back to the rates, with a difference 
 On first principles, Adam Smith invariably had much to say. 
 His rules of taxation were that a tax should be fair, easy to predict, easy to collect and difficult to evade. 
 He also favoured the closest possible ties between those who were taxed and those who were doing the taxing. 
 Translated into today's idiom, the more that local government can rely upon its own tax base, the better. 
 Indeed, the best local tax would be one chosen and raised by each council as it saw fit, to cover what its voters had elected it to spend. 
 But that ideal runs straight into the fact that some areas of the country are richer than others, and they tend to be places that need less spending anyway. 
 So central government gets drawn in willy-nilly; and once it is handing out money, it will want to have some say over how it is spent. 
 For this reason local taxes will always be seen as part of the national tax structure. 
 They should therefore be consistent with the philosophy that underpins income tax: the more you have, the more you pay, leaving the poorest to pay little or nothing. 
 The poll tax cut across this, with its concept of a universal obligation. 
 But the idea of a tax as some kind of entry ticket for citizenship was always a nonsense: too many are able to dodge paying it. 
 As for the notion of a local tax as a payment for services rendered, it isn't. 
 When people must pay for services, regardless of whether they use them or not, they are paying a tax, period. 
 Local councils in England alone are now spending around &pound;40 billion a year. 
 This total would be cut by half if they transferred their educational budgets to central government. 
 There is some case for doing this, particularly now that Whitehall is laying down a core curriculum for all schools. 
 But no minister should suppose that this would provide a painless solution, for the government would have to raise its own taxes dramatically. 
 So assume the councils' needs stay at &pound;40 billion; it is hard then to see any single tax footing such a large bill. 
 A direct reassignment of national taxes, as in Germany, might do it &mdash; but would need a consensus between Whitehall and the town halls that Britain sorely lacks. 
 In short, local government's future financial base will have to be a hybrid &mdash; either of two or more taxes or of a tax-and-grants kind. 
 As Michael Heseltine, the environment secretary, appears now to have accepted, a property tax should be the dominant feature of the hybrid. 
 A sales tax would prompt border-hopping, tolerable in America but not in tiny Britain, and would fly in the face of EC moves towards greater harmonisation of indirect taxes. 
 A local income tax would give councils the power to jeopardise Britain's belated conversion to a belief in low direct taxation. 
 Property taxes, by contrast, would help to temper the British obsession with home-ownership. 
 Whatever its status as a castle, an Englishman's home today is easily the most familiar measure of his finances. 
 Most people have a far better idea of the value of their house than of their annual income tax. 
 And the information available on capital values in the housing market is correspondingly lavish. 
 To base a property tax on anything other than capital values would be perverse &mdash; even if alternatives like imputed rents and floor-space footage were inherently sensible, which they are not &mdash; and ways to compile and update the necessary data have already been examined in detail. 
 By introducing a tax on residential property that raised about &pound;14 billion, together with the &pound;12 billion that comes from taxing commercial property, and by allocating the remaining &pound;14 billion via the present system of grants, the government would be able to pronounce the poll tax dead. 
 Its replacement would still have to cope with the problem of big-spending councils; the old rows about rate-capping and poll-tax-capping would simply be called something else. 
 But remedies involving, for example, an extra tax payable by each person in a household would at the moment be madness: many councils would be left struggling with exactly the enforcement difficulties that have made the poll tax so hard to set up and administer. 
 In time it may be possible to find other, better remedies. 
 Once the Inland Revenue is fully computerised, it would be feasible to have a local income tax to supplement the property tax. 
 But such a big change would be desirable only if the structure of local government was reformed, to make it more responsive to local opinion. 
 It is not too early to start thinking about sweeping reforms, as history shows. 
 After all, a mixture of property and income taxes is exactly what was proposed by the Layfield report on local-government finance in 1976. 
 If the Tory party is embarrassed about the 15 wasted years, it should be.  
 Soft on banks? 
 Regulators should resist pressure to be lenient 
 IN 1988 regulators from the dozen richest countries devised a new set of capital standards for commercial banks. 
 They had two aims: to boost banks' financial strength, and to reduce the competitive advantage enjoyed by banks in countries with lax capital requirements. 
 Gripped by recession, some banks are now asking for at least temporary relief from these capital standards. 
 Regulators should say no. 
 The capital standards, negotiated through the Bank for International Settlements (BIS), are a natural scapegoat for the credit squeeze that is deepening the recessions in Britain and America and may provoke one in Japan. 
 When the rules take full effect at the end of 1992, banks will have to back every commercial loan with capital equal to 8% of the loan's value; half of that must be share capital or disclosed reserves (&bquo;core&equo; capital). 
 Less-risky assets require less capital backing. 
 Capital matters because it protects depositors (or, more realistically, the government guarantor of deposits) should a bank's loans go sour. 
 But rules that strengthen banks in good times can cripple them in recessions. 
 As bad loans proliferate, investors are less willing to buy bank debt and equity, making capital scarcer. 
 With less capital to go around, banks must make fewer loans. 
 The recession gets worse. 
 Why not, then, relax the BIS standards, or at least delay their enforcement? 
 Banks would lend money more freely and, in fattening their own balance sheets, would feed credit-starved economies. 
 The logic is seductive, but misguided. 
 Banks' need for capital is greatest when economies are in recession and borrowers cannot service their loans. 
 Aside from protecting depositors against losses, a large capital base will restrain a bank's impulse to make risky loans to maintain its profits in a depressed market. 
 America's thrifts debacle showed how dangerous that impulse can be. 
 When recession struck the oil-pumping south-west in the 1980s, thrifts in Texas and elsewhere pleaded for a relaxation of capital standards to help them grow out of trouble. 
 Regulators took pity on them. 
 Now taxpayers must pay hundreds of billions of dollars to clean up the mess left by under-capitalised thrifts. 
 People who trumpet the dangers of strict capital rules also exaggerate the benefits that leniency would bring. 
 Most large banks already meet the BIS standards, two years ahead of schedule. 
 In America, where the capital shortage is thought to be worst, there is ample capital around to underpin the current demand for bank lending. 
 According to New York's Federal Reserve Bank, even if America's banks backed outstanding loans with 50% more core capital than required, they would still have &dollar;40 billion of capital to spare. 
 What American banks lack is credit-worthy borrowers in the right places &mdash; an added reason why the rules that prevent America's banks operating nationwide should be scrapped. 
 British and European banks are comfortably above the 8% minimum. 
 So are Japanese banks, thanks to Japan's recent stockmarket rally (but they would slip back if the market did). 
 Tough for some 
 Some banks, including several of America's biggest, are indeed short of capital. 
 They face unpalatable choices. 
 They must either issue equity and subordinated debt at low prices or else shrink their balance sheets by selling off old loans and turning down new business. 
 A high cost of capital is a signal that investors do not trust banks to earn a reasonable return on their money at a reasonable risk. 
 Regulators must not muffle that signal by permitting banks to resume lending from a weaker capital base. 
 The BIS standards do have flaws, though not the ones that bankers complain of. 
 The rules make no distinction between triple-A loans and weaker credits, which can encourage banks to invest in high-yielding junk. 
 Nor do they take proper account of the risks banks run on their foreign-exchange and interest-rate positions. 
 These imperfections make it all the more important for regulators to enforce the BIS minimums and set higher standards for riskier banks.  
 Another chance for the UN 
 Small changes could bring big rewards 
 THE United Nations suffers about equally from people who want it to do everything and from those who think it can do nothing. 
 Until the Gulf war actually began, things at its headquarters on New York's East River were looking up. 
 The cold war was over. 
 America and Russia were solving third-world conflicts with the UN's help. 
 There was a chance it might grow into the international peacekeeper its founders had wanted. 
 Security Council resolutions aimed at getting the Iraqis out of Kuwait were a model of collective action against aggression. 
 When, in November, it blessed the use of force to achieve this goal, the fanfare was forgivable. 
 A new UN, it seemed, had been born. 
 False hope was duly dashed. 
 By authorising force, the UN did not get itself a say in the running of the war. 
 Its Military Committee, which the victors of 1945 had once hoped (for little more than the time it takes to shake hands) would in future enforce peace at the head of a world army, remained a jobless phantom. 
 Except for an unsuccessful trip to Baghdad before the allied air offensive, the UN's secretary-general, Javier Perez de Cuellar, has played a minor diplomatic part. 
 As middlemen since then, the Iranians and the Russians have pushed the UN further into the background and, at least until peace really does break out, the Americans have been happy for it to stay there. 
 On top of all this, there is some risk that the Soviet Union is returning to its hardline ways, which might include tilting back to Iraq. 
 If those worst fears were to come true, the Soviet-American consensus in the UN would quickly disappear &mdash; and with it the body's best hope of effectiveness. 
 The gloom of the UN-idealists and the &bquo;told you so&equo; from UN-doubters are both overdrawn. 
 The Gulf war has shown the UN's limits, but also its strengths. 
 As the war enters its final phase, the UN will probably return to prominence. 
 It has already made behind-the-scenes preparations to share the job of picking up the pieces. 
 Some weeks ago the secretary-general asked his staff to draw up plans to cover either an Iraqi withdrawal or an Iraqi defeat in the field. 
 A large peacekeeping force is now being assembled, ready to move at 48 hours' notice. 
 The idea is that it could supervise an Iraqi withdrawal or police the Kuwait-Iraq border if Saddam Hussein ordered a pull-out. 
 If his army were crushed and Kuwait taken by force, and if the allied forces were then eager to pack up and go home or found themselves no longer wanted, UN peacekeepers could step in. 
 Beyond those possible tasks lies a heavy load of work for the UN in what several Security Council resolutions call &bquo;restoring peace and stability to the area&equo; &mdash; that is, trying to prevent the next Middle East war. 
 That could include traditional diplomacy, peace-monitoring, the placing of tripwire forces on disputed borders and the policing of arms embargoes. 
 Making it smoother next time 
 If the UN fails the Gulf test, it will be doing no worse than the many outsiders who have tried their hands in the Middle East over the past six decades. 
 If it succeeds, it will be because it concentrates on achievable tasks. 
 The end of the cold war has given the UN a new chance. 
 But it is not about to flower into a world directorate with its own army. 
 Its best role is the diplomatic and peacekeeping one &mdash; which is quite different from peace-enforcing, since that involves imposing an end to fighting. 
 The achievable tasks could be much better done if several handicaps were eased. 
 Three of these are internal, involving the working of the UN machine. 
 The first is that peacekeeping is hand-to-mouth. 
 The UN must beg field radios, lorries and money for each operation. 
 It gets by because its officials are skilled improvisers. 
 This could be improved with, for example, a peacekeeping fund, a staff college for training peacekeeping officers, and special UN units earmarked in national armies, leading to a permanent peacekeeping force. 
 Weak direction from the top is a second handicap. 
 A new secretary-general is to be chosen this autumn. 
 Mr Perez de Cuellar says he will not stand again. 
 Too often the UN has had less than the best. 
 On the whole, it has suited the big powers to have mediocre or self-effacing diplomats. 
 This time the UN deserves someone of consequence &mdash; who might think of making a successful businessman his deputy in order to tackle the UN's nightmarish bureaucracy. 
 The third problem is the Security Council, or rather the latterday powers that want permanent seats on it. 
 The five that already have them &mdash; America, Britain, China, France and the Soviet Union &mdash; are discovering co-operation after years of blocking each other with vetoes. 
 But Germany and Japan, as well as several other not-so-rich but big countries, are knocking on the door. 
 Clever schemes abound. 
 The trick will be to get fairer representation without losing small-group decisiveness, and not to avoid tackling the problem because a perfect mix cannot be found. 
 The fourth handicap is external. 
 The UN machine works only when the big powers want it to. 
 They alone provide the current. 
 Nothing guarantees that the Americans and Russians will go on supplying it as they have done for the past couple of years. 
 Yet it would be odd logic not to repair the machine just because the current might one day be cut off again. 
 The Americans do not want to play the world's policeman on their own, and cannot afford to. 
 Even the nastiest Soviet generals do not seem to want to restore &bquo;international class struggle&equo; &mdash; stirring up third-world trouble for the West. 
 They can see that the UN gives them a position at the bargaining table. 
 Both powers know that the unappealing alternative is a return to the 1970s and 1980s, when America and Russia competed in the third world through warring clients.  
 His war, his peace 
 HE HAD another chance; it may have been his last. 
 Once again peacemakers put themselves between Saddam Hussein and the leaders of the alliance ranged against him. 
 Once again, by failing to opt clearly enough for peace, he seems to have opted for war. 
 Having raised the hopes of friend and foe alike &mdash; and especially of Iraqis, witness the ecstatic scenes in Baghdad last week &mdash; by agreeing for the first time to contemplate withdrawal from Kuwait, he was unwilling to commit himself unequivocally. 
 It could have been his peace. 
 After his broadcast on Thursday, it is more likely to be a new, and even bloodier, phase of his war. 
 The allies should not welcome this, though the argument for fighting on regardless of the latest Soviet efforts at peacemaking was neither bloodthirsty nor trivial. 
 In part it rested on the belief that in order to restore peace and security in the Gulf, as Resolution 678 authorises member states to do, it is necessary to destroy Iraq's capacity to wage war. 
 If the allies had agreed to a peace settlement before starting a land war, Mr Hussein would have been left at the head of a country whose air force and army were still largely intact. 
 Within a few years he could have looked almost as menacing as he did six months ago. 
 Better to finish the job now. 
 And, some would say, to finish Mr Hussein too. 
 Many Americans, probably including George Bush, as well as many of the Iraqi's Arab enemies, believe that there can be no lasting peace unless Mr Hussein has been humbled. 
 Otherwise, despite the rubble around him, he will have emerged from the war as an Arab hero, the man who took on and defied the Zionists, westerners and other infidels, and who will inevitably try to do it all again. 
 Unless his Kuwaiti venture is seen to be a manifest failure for him personally, runs the argument, the job will have been only half done. 
 It is this that has made some Americans say that, if Iraq agreed to withdraw from Kuwait, it must abandon its tanks and other heavy equipment. 
 Others have spoken of war crimes and reparations. 
 Humiliating and unrealistic conditions should set off an alarm in the coalition's collective head: they carry echoes from 1919 of Versailles, the treaty that ended &bquo;the war to end all wars&equo; and brought Europe, and the world, a new era of instability. 
 The allies' central aim in the Gulf is the unconditional expulsion of Iraq from Kuwait. 
 Achieving that aim will in itself amount to a manifest setback for Mr Hussein. 
 If he still appears a hero to some, that may be something the world can live with: for all his defiance, he will have thrown away everything Iraq gained from its eight-year war with Iran, and swallowed many mouthfuls of words about Kuwait remaining Iraq's 19th province for ever and a day. 
 The allies have to remember that, even if Mr Hussein were to fall upon his (or someone else's) sword tomorrow, he might be replaced the following day by someone just as dangerous and aggressive. 
 They have also, however, to remember their own troops. 
 If they are to throw themselves fully into battle by land and sea, they cannot wait for ever. 
 It is not reasonable to hold them too long while doves flutter between Moscow and Baghdad, while sandstorms gather and temperatures rise. 
 For soldiers, if it were done when 'tis done, then 'twere well it were done quickly. 
 Yet would it not have been better for them if 'twere not done at all? 
 So far, allied casualties have been astonishingly light; in a land war they will soon multiply. 
 Soon too the horrors that Mr Hussein has promised but has so far failed to deliver may start to materialise: nerve gas, biological weapons, blazing oil fields. 
 Kuwait, already pillaged, will suffer further devastation. 
 The coalition has rightly been ready to run these risks to get Iraq out of Kuwait; but so long as it could achieve that central aim, how much better to do so without further fear of all the weapons in a tyrant's armoury. 
 For Kuwait, not against Saddam 
 The other kind of cost of a land war will be measured in terms of the strain on the alliance. 
 Against many expectations, and despite a groundswell of popular support for Iraq in the Muslim world, the coalition has held together well. 
 Even the bombing of a shelter full of civilians in Baghdad last week has failed to split it. 
 But the longer the war goes on, the greater is the likelihood of more such tragedies. 
 The allies could, and should, do more to minimise the chances of further disasters; they could, for instance, stop bombing Baghdad, where the targets of greatest military value must have already been destroyed. 
 In a land war, however, the concern will not be just for Iraqis, whether civilians or soldiers, but for allied soldiers. 
 If it is indeed to be a land battle, that inevitably bloody affair will with luck be fast-moving, and people will see it as a struggle fought with a clear aim against an obdurate enemy and plainly moving towards an allied victory. 
 If so, public opinion in the western democracies would probably put up with quite a lot of blood and bodies. 
 But if it looks vindictive &mdash; more a battle for Saddam's head than for the liberation of Kuwait &mdash; public opinion in the West could soon turn. 
 And in the Muslim world, among people at large, the war may become ever more unpopular as it looks increasingly punitive and costly in terms of Arab life. 
 The disaffection could spread further. 
 Mikhail Gorbachev has been under increasing pressure at home, especially in the Soviet army, to salvage what he can of the old Soviet-Iraqi friendship. 
 His full support for the anti-Saddam coalition has not been universally popular: hence his latest diplomatic effort, which he must hope will still redound to his credit and give the Soviet Union a useful base on which to build a role in the post-war Middle East. 
 His difficulty is that, with his economic and diplomatic credit so low, he cannot afford to antagonise the West on the Gulf. 
 But neither can the West, and in particular Mr Bush, altogether afford to neglect the Soviet Union. 
 Its co-operation has been crucial to the international consensus legitimising the war. 
 All such considerations pointed rational men to peace. 
 Yet in the end, as in the beginning, the decision lay with Mr Hussein. 
 On August 2nd he needlessly started a war. 
 Time and again between then and the UN deadline of January 15th, he could have averted the allied counter-offensive that followed. 
 Last week, for the first time, he showed he was ready to contemplate withdrawal &mdash; but not unequivocally. 
 Had he shown himself unambiguously ready to start pulling out, the coalition would have surely had to offer him something, if not to save his face, at least to cover his backside: an American commitment to talk about any Middle Eastern issue whatsoever has already been given; the call for Iraqi reparations could still be waived. 
 What was lacking was a clear response from Mr Hussein that he genuinely wanted peace. 
 As the war enters its next phase, it is ever more plainly his war. 
 LETTERS 
 Occupational hazards 
 In an otherwise logical case against Saddam Hussein (January 12th), you again liken his adventure to other occupations, including that of northern Cyprus by Turkey. 
 The two cases have nothing in common. 
 In Cyprus the rights of a large Turkish population were routinely abridged by a majority bent upon union with Greece. 
 Northern Cyprus now has an occupier whose crime is to protect those rights and whose chief affront to the majority is to remain there passively. 
 This occupier is anxious to withdraw according to UN resolutions and proposals which the majority will not accept. 
 This situation needs resolution, but to compare it with the rape of Kuwait hardly strengthens your argument against Saddam. 
 Worse, the comparison gives the back of your hand to a country whose firm support of the principles you voice comes at a cost of real economic suffering and terrible danger.  
 Beloit, Wisconsin JERRY GUSTAFSON 
 Your otherwise excellent leader is marred only by its comparison of the occupation of the West Bank with those of Northern Cyprus and Tibet. 
 The occupation of the West Bank was a result of a war launched by third parties. 
 In northern Cyprus and Tibet, the occupier was the aggressor. 
 In similar vein, withdrawal from Nicosia and Lhasa is unlikely to imperil the inhabitants of Istanbul and Beijing. 
 I wish the same held true of Hebron and Jerusalem.  
 London PETER SUGARMAN 
 Liberate oil 
 It is my understanding that The Economist has had deep roots in free-market philosophy from its very start. 
 It is therefore unsettling to find you pushing an &bquo;energy policy&equo; for the United States and following the old, oft-disproven notion that we are &bquo;running out of oil&equo; (January 26th). 
 America has potentially quite large oil deposits, as well as enormous known deposits of natural gas. 
 Oil exploration in most promising regions is virtually prohibited by government edict, largely through the pressure of environmental extremists (with whom you seem to agree). 
 An &bquo;energy policy&equo; of government tends to strangle the development of economical and efficient energy sources, as any student of the free market would agree. 
 In addition, numerous examples show that private ownership is far more dedicated to conservation and protection of the environment. 
 Why not go back to your roots and advocate liberty?  
 Barstow, California LANNON STAFFORD 
 Lloyd's of London 
 Your article, &bquo;Leaking at the seams&equo; (January 26th), made reference to the vehicle being set up by the council of Lloyd's to reinsure open years of account. 
 Your correspondent went on to speculate about the likely cost of reinsuring through this vehicle the 1982 account of syndicates 317/661, managed by this company. 
 He says his speculation is &bquo;a best guess&equo;. 
 Rather, it is wild and uninformed. 
 The premium rate suggested by him would be equivalent to an amount in excess of &pound;1 billion (&dollar;1.95 billion) for a syndicate with a capacity of &pound;41m; this in addition to the losses already paid and reserved. 
 Such a figure would not suggest that a serious attempt was being made by underwriters to deal with a problem that could undermine the stability of the world's pre-eminent insurance market. 
 Lloyd's has put forward a constructive plan; it must not be allowed to flounder on rate. 
 Unless an equitable premium can now be arrived at, confidence in this new Lloyd's initiative &mdash; as well as the long-term future of the market &mdash; will be eroded.  
 London W.E. 
 BLOXHAM Chief executive R.H.M. 
 Outhwaite Ltd 
 Mining in Nauru 
 Your assertion that Nauru has claimed &dollar;60m in compensation from Australia (January 19th) is untrue. 
 Nauru has sought from the International Court of Justice a declaration of the liability of Australia for breaches of the trusteeship agreement and article 76 of the UN charter. 
 The question of compensation, however, has been reserved by Nauru at this stage of the proceedings. 
 Australia has contested, at this point, not the merits of the claim but the admissibility of the claim and the jurisdiction of the court in respect thereof. 
 Any damages received from the case will be used to finance rehabilitation of those parts of Nauru mined out by Australia; Australia carried out no rehabilitation of the island. 
 Although four-fifths of Nauru will be uninhabitable at the completion of mining, with careful planning and the necessary financial resources the island is certainly repairable over time. 
 Nauru was never paid &dollar;16m or any other compensation by Australia. 
 Your article included some gratuitous remarks about lifestyle and income. 
 They have no bearing whatsoever on the serious consideration of the merits of the Nauruan case.  
 London MARTIN WESTON Nauru Government Office 
 Problem-free cats 
 You write that recycling catalytic converters has its problems (January 12th). 
 Not so. 
 We have been recycling rhodium and platinum for some leading car makers for years, without any of the environmental problems associated with nuclear waste.  
 Alzenau, Germany HEINZ GIEGERICH DAR Deutsche Autokat Recycling 
 Gone to the dogs 
 You mentioned in &bquo;Language debased&equo; (December 24th) the hapless airline passenger being admonished in verbose, indirect terms, to &bquo;extinguish all smoking materials&equo; and to &bquo;deplane from the forward cabin&equo;. 
 Alas, the Gulf crisis has created a new phrase to frustrate travellers with little patience for this abuse of the English language. 
 The director of Dallas-Fort Worth international airport has assured the &bquo;flying public&equo; that extra steps are being taken to screen luggage for terrorist bombs. 
 His weapon of choice: &bquo;canine assets&equo;.  
 Chicago JOHN WOOD 
 START OF BOOKS SECTION 
 That anti-war feeling 
 Japanese stagefright 
 TOKYO 
 AS IF the current Japanese mood of entrenched pacificism needed any underlining, the Shiki theatre company and its ambitious director, Keita Asari, have produced an anti-war musical drama called &bquo;Rikoran&equo;. 
 Its theme is a blunt retelling of Japan's military aggression in Manchuria from the late 1920s until 1945. 
 This is not something the public knows much about; history textbooks are inadequate, and the older generation will not discuss it. 
 The play drew standing-room-only crowds at Tokyo's Nissay Theatre for the last part of its three-week run in January. 
 It will soon start a second run, from March 22nd to April 29th. 
 When it reopens, the theatre will provide simultaneous translation in both English and Chinese. 
 Japan's newspaper critics have added spice to the production by splitting into two camps. 
 Theatre critics object to the musical because it is an &bquo;idea drama&equo; that lacks believable characters; political columnists and professors praise its accurate rendering of historical events. 
 A headline on the theatre page of Asahi Shimbun read: &bquo;Plenty of Historical Remarks, Few Human Beings.&equo; 
 A page-one column in the same newspaper admired the play's moral honesty, insisting: &bquo;It is worth Prime Minister Kaifu's time to see the musical before his trip to South-East Asia.&equo; 
 The columnist added that war-time journalists were the &bquo;cat's paws&equo; of Japan's militarists, &bquo;reporting nothing but lies.&equo; 
 In fact, the first-night audience included Yasuhiro Nakasone and Noboru Takeshita, both former prime ministers, and Taro Nakayama, the present foreign minister. 
 According to Mr Asari, Mr Nakayama recommended &bquo;everybody&equo; to see it. 
 Also in the audience was 70-year-old Yoshiko Yamaguchi Otaka, the original Rikoran, whose autobiography provided much of the material for the script of the musical. 
 A singer of poignant songs, Rikoran was born near Mukden in Manchuria in 1920 of Japanese parents, but lived as a young girl with a Chinese family. 
 Accepted as Chinese, she became a superstar appearing in China and abroad. 
 Between 1938 and 1945 she performed in Manchuria, working for a Japanese propaganda outfit, the Manchuria Cinema Association. 
 In 1945 she was tried in a Chinese military court as a traitor, but was acquitted when she admitted her Japanese nationality and described how politically naive she was. 
 Today, Rikoran is Mrs Yoshiko Otaka, a member of the upper house of the Japanese parliament. 
 The musical opens with her trial; in the theatre on the first night, she was in tears. 
 Supposedly, the development of northeastern China began with the co-operation of Manchurians, Mongols, Chinese and Koreans; but the Japanese army, the Kwangtung, planned to control Manchuria as a colony of Japan. 
 It installed Pu Yi, the last emperor of the Ching dynasty, as a puppet, and tyrannised the Manchurians. 
 In the musical, Chinese are gunned down to suggest the actual massacre at the mountain village of Ping Ding Shan; and air warfare and the atomic destruction of Hiroshima are shown on film clips. 
 The effect is terrifying. 
 During an interview at the Shiki theatre company's offices in Tokyo, Mr Asari explained why he had produced the controversial musical. 
 &bquo;I wanted&equo;, he said, &bquo;to challenge the taboos about the Japanese in Manchuria. 
 Neither the political right nor left wants to tell what happened from the 1920s through 1945. 
 The right wing says it was a good thing, Japan's going into Manchuria to develop it; the left wing calls it bad. 
 Nothing about it is taught at school and we are criticised abroad for not repenting of the war.&equo; 
 Mr Asari remembers, as a seven-year-old elementary schoolboy, watching the Emperors Hirohito and Pu Yi ride together through Tokyo in a carriage in 1940. 
 He says he has never been able to get the image out of his mind. 
 In &bquo;Rikoran&equo; the Pu Yi of actor Masayoshi Yamaguchi is a comically astute man who realises that he is powerless as Japan's dupe in Manchuria. 
 In contrast, Rikoran is oblivious both to Japan's atrocities in China and to the real course of the war with the West. 
 She represents the ordinary Japanese who believed what was reported: first, that Manchuria was an idealistic experiment in Asian co-operation; and, later, that Japan was winning the Pacific war. 
 Mr Asari hopes his musical may do something to open blinkered Japanese eyes, to the future as well as the past. 
 &bquo;We need to face the frustrations left over from the second world war&equo;, he says. 
 &bquo;If the Japanese government were stronger, we could have done something to prevent the Gulf war. 
 This is not the time to escape reality.&equo; 
 He is right, though his play does not leave his audiences with much of a zest for battle.  
 Via dolorosa 
 ONLY a handful of artists have been sufficiently disturbed by the violence of war to capture it in their paintings: Goya certainly, Henry Moore in his air-raid shelter sketches, Picasso in his &bquo;Guernica&equo; perhaps, and, a step down, Paul Nash and Wyndham Lewis. 
 For the remainder, most of the pictures culled by M.R.D. Foot from the vast treasure trove of the Imperial War Museum in a handsome selection, ART AND WAR*, are no more than intelligent, technically competent commentaries on particular aspects of war in this century. 
 A few, largely born of the experience of the first world war, transcend illustration and illuminate, like flares, the nature of war in all its brutality. 
 One of these, Paul Nash's &bquo;The Menin Road&equo; with its two tiny indistinct figures scurrying across a shell-torn landscape, is used on the book's cover. 
 Having made his point so tellingly, Mr Foot makes no sweeping claims about his compilation, writing simply: &bquo;This is a book about war, more than about art&hellip; it is meant to contribute to the history of war, rather than to art history.&equo; 
 In his comments on the pictures he has selected, Mr Foot, a stalwart of these anonymous columns for many years, stays firmly in that perspective. 
 A friendly, anecdotal guide, he takes his readers gently by the elbow in explaining how, as depicted in the illustrations, war has developed. 
 In the end, it always circles back to Wilfred Owen's pity. 
 His tailpiece, most aptly, is Eric Gill's woodcut of an infantryman trudging along his Via Dolorosa. 
 Many, alas, still have to tread that road.  
 German cinema 
 Trabi dearest 
 BERLIN 
 ONE of the more bizarre products of German unification is the film &bquo;Go Trabi Go&equo;, a central-European road movie with a difference. 
 Forget the slick 1950s convertibles of &bquo;Wild At Heart&equo; or Wim Wenders's earlier work; this film pays homage to the Trabant, East Germany's contribution to the automobile Hall of Fame. 
 With the borders down, Udo Struutz, a 43-year-old teacher from the industrial hell-hole of Bitterfeld, is able to realise a lifelong dream: retracing Goethe's &bquo;Italian Journey&equo;. 
 With his loyal wife Rita and wild child Jacqueline, he loads up the family Trabi (affectionately known as George) and hits the road to the southern sun, leaving his bemused neighbours behind. 
 For the past 20 years George (the real star of this western-made film) has been a cherished member of the Struutz family. 
 Daughter Jacqueline was conceived on the back seat, and he was a witness at Udo and Rita's wedding. 
 Now he faces the biggest challenge of his existence &mdash; the devil-take-the-hindmost motorways of Bavaria, Austria and Italy. 
 Despite a few mechanical mishaps, loyal George manages to overcome the challenge and deliver the family to Rome. 
 Although the film is full of comments on the remaining cultural differences between east and west, it does not set out to make fun of the east Germans. 
 If anything, it is the westerners who become the butt of the jokes. 
 The family relatives in Bavaria &mdash; fat, bigoted, suburban and narrow-minded &mdash; are a wonderful and cutting send-up of the western German petit bourgeoisie. 
 Despite being a western production, the film script was written by the east-west team of Peter Timm and Reinhard Kloos. 
 The cast is also drawn from both eastern and western Germany, with Wolfgang Strumph, a Dresden cabaret artist, putting in a good bewildered performance as Udo. 
 Although it would be wrong to try to read too much into such a light-hearted production, Udo's reliance on Goethe as his travel guide (&bquo;200 years old and still topical&equo;) is surely a statement that, while political systems may come and go, German literature remains. 
 Public reaction to the film in Germany has been divided. 
 In the west it has had little success; in the east it has been a smash. 
 Some cinema-goers in Leipzig even confessed that the film had made them feel emotional and slightly nostalgic for their recent past. 
 The mood would seem to be temporary; judging by the ever-decreasing number of Trabants on eastern Germany's roads no one, when faced with the superior horsepower of Volkswagen, Audi and Mercedes, is that nostalgic. 
 Even silver-screen George changes with the times when, after an entertaining accident in Rome, he re-emerges as a convertible with a Renault 4 bonnet. 
 The popularity of the film in eastern Germany probably has a simple explanation. 
 With industries and jobs disappearing around them as they still try to find their way in the new Germany, many east Germans find it comforting to enjoy some harmless fun where, for once, they get the upper hand. 
 Although few would accept a Trabant now even if you paid them, the spluttering papier-mach&eacute; two-stroke still strikes an affectionate chord. 
 And the jokes remain. 
 How do you double the value of a Trabant, for instance? 
 Answer: fill it up with petrol. 
 Or make a film about it.  
 Puppet and string-puller 
 GUERRILLA PRINCE: THE UNTOLD STORY OF FIDEL CASTRO. 
 By Georgie Anne Geyer. 
 Little, Brown; 445 pages; &dollar;22.95 and &pound;14.95 
 THE last bogeyman but five or six, in that line of third-world menaces who give the United States a sense of purpose, lives uncomfortably close to home. 
 Fidel Castro is no far-distant Arab, but rules an island only 90 miles from Key West, on what might have been home ground had politics gone slightly differently less than a century ago. 
 When they snapped up the fragments of Spain's Caribbean empire, the Americans took Puerto Rico as a colony and subsidised it lavishly. 
 Cuba they merely took as a neocolony. 
 Their agribusinesses employed its labour cheap. 
 Their gangsters, from the profits of bootlegging, gambling and abortion, bought up its government. 
 From that moral swamp emerged the Creature with the Beard and the Big Cigar. 
 Those who think history is formed by impersonal forces find Mr Castro a large inconvenience. 
 Sure, the Soviet Union wanted to shove pins into its rival from as close up as possible. 
 Sure, Cuba's circumstances made part of its ruling class ultra-anti-American. 
 But without Mr Castro, Cuba and its 10m fairly poor people could never have become the nuisance whose finger excitable types discerned in pies all round the globe. 
 One man's obsession with America aligned Russian opportunism behind the Cuban sense of grievance. 
 Georgie Anne Geyer writes of that obsession. 
 She does not know much about world politics; she undertakes her &bquo;strange Odyssean intellectual and political adventure into the soul and psyche of this unknown leader&equo; in, she says, &bquo;a systematic journalistic manner&equo;. 
 This does not explain why she describes the movement of a crowd as &bquo;hydric&equo;, or locates the home of Mr Castro's father, the Galician ex-soldier Angel Castro, in a &bquo;nouveau wilderness&equo;. 
 Soon, though, she drops her fancy prose and concentrates on the relationship, almost sexual in its intensity, between Mr Castro and enough Cubans to keep him in power without the brutal repression that most Caribbean dictators go in for. 
 When she encounters a mess, like the ridiculous raid on the Moncada barracks that made Mr Castro's revolutionary reputation, she does not try to impose sense where there was none. 
 Instead of seeking to analyse Che Guevara's bungled revolutionary export-drive, she appropriately notes that its main consequence was to make black berets fashionable for a while. 
 She is stronger on personality than on political theory, pointing accurately at the similarities between Mr Castro and another Galician dictator, Francisco Franco. 
 General Franco used the army to get himself to power, then kicked it away. 
 Miss Geyer writes: &bquo;The new thing in history that Castro did was to destroy the Communist Party and create his own Fidelista Party, which he called Communist in order to stand up against the United States and to gain backing and to borrow power from the Soviet Union&equo;. 
 That is the point. 
 Communism, while it lasted, claimed to be about economics. 
 Mr Castro dabbled incompetently with communist economics, but had no economic ideas at all. 
 This deficiency he shared with a whole crew of leaders of third-world or so-called &bquo;non-aligned&equo; countries, who like him had gained power because they were against foreign rulers, not because they had any idea of what to put in place of foreign rule. 
 He stood out among them not only because he had a surer command of his people at home, but also because Cuba is where it is, so the Russians helped him much more than the rest. 
 Like many supposed puppets, Mr Castro learnt to tug on the strings that tied him to his masters' hands. 
 Because he concentrated on a single target while the Russians played their world-wide game, they sometimes failed to notice where he was pulling their fingers. 
 If the Soviet Union had kept proper watch on Mr Castro, it would never have let him pull it into the missile crisis of 1962. 
 Fortunately for the world, John Kennedy's team was wise enough to create the pause that allowed Khrushchev to pull back. 
 The Russians did not learn their lesson. 
 In the late 1980s the Cubans manipulated them into a needless confrontation in Angola, which lasted much longer than it should have done because, this time, the Washington team was clumsier. 
 In his 31 years of dictatorship Mr Castro shifted peripheral Cuba to the centre of the world stage. 
 Now the strings have gone slack, and he is waiting for the end. 
 His folksy speeches still beguile the faithful; he can grow eloquent on anything, even when comparing the dynamo-operated lamps of Russian bicycles to the simple purity of the unlighted Chinese alternative. 
 But his people are hungry, their clothes worn. 
 The Soviet subsidies are gone, the schemes for easy payments to the East Europeans who provided his machines are over. 
 The Miami Cubans are flexing their wallets for the return to a country whose people are healthier, better educated and less racially divided than when the exiles left. 
 Whatever the style of the transition, the new Cuban regime is unlikely to pose a political threat to the United States. 
 But the island that in the prohibition years after 1920 profitably ran the rum trade is well placed for bootlegging cocaine. 
 The colony that never was may find fresh ways to annoy the giant with which proximity entangles it.  
 Silent, upon a peak in Darien 
 THE PACIFIC. 
 By Simon Winchester. 
 Hutchinson; 456 pages; &pound;19.99. 
 To be published in America by Random House 
 DEEP, deep down, on a level only recognised by hints and murmurs, an inchoate, undefined sense of oneness, of coterminous identity is growing among some of the peoples and some of the places of the Pacific. 
 It cannot be quantified, nor described; if it exists, it can only be felt.&equo; 
 Clearly, Simon Winchester feels it &mdash; and goes to elegant, erudite and amusing lengths to persuade his readers to feel it, too. 
 They will be only half-convinced. 
 The quarter or more of the world's population who live around the rim of the Pacific are too diverse to be cutely grouped as the &bquo;Pacific man&equo; in the &bquo;Pacific century&equo;, so readily defined by fund managers and futurologists. 
 How can a single thread be drawn to link the peasants of Peru with the sararimen of Tokyo, or the rumbustious politicians of Australia with the venal cadres of communist China? 
 Look for the Pacific's &bquo;inchoate oneness&equo;, and the divisions become ever more obvious. 
 Mr Winchester admits the difficulty &mdash; and proceeds, undaunted, to sew as many threads as he can across the world's biggest ocean (&bquo;bigger than all the land surface of the earth, including Antarctica, and with Africa counted twice.&equo;). 
 He rightly emphasises the overseas Chinese, who do indeed get everywhere, be it Jakarta or Lima, and the Confucianism which underlies so much of East Asia's economic success. 
 Diligence, obedience and high savings rates are the powerful characteristics of neo-Confucian Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong and Singapore &mdash; and of every Chinatown from Los Angeles to Valparaiso. 
 Why those same characteristics come unstuck in Deng Xiaoping's China is a mystery to Mr Winchester, as to many others. 
 Where Mr Winchester's cross-Pacific connections become less sure is when they become tangible and man-made: the optical-fibre telephone cable that snakes beneath the Pacific from California to Hawaii and then branches out to Japan and Guam; the AsiaSat satellite and its fellow &bquo;birds&equo;, sitting on the equator to bounce across Asia the telephone calls of businessmen and the television dramas of Hollywood; the new Boeing 747&ndash;400, able to fly non-stop from Sydney to Los Angeles; and, odd as it seems, the Macintosh computer. 
 Faith in the icons of telephonics and flight is easy enough. 
 There are now more jumbo jets flying the Pacific than there are the Atlantic, and the financial power of Japan will probably, in the end, clog even the optical fibres of the new Pacific cable. 
 But the Macintosh? 
 Mr Winchester, a Mac-fan of many years and now the boss of a Mac-using electronic-publishing company, has an ingenious explanation: unlike the clumsy MS-DOS operating system that powers IBM computers and all their clones, the Mac can cope with comparative ease with the pictographic scripts and unusual phonetic alphabets of Asia. 
 Mr Winchester may well have a point, but he fails to mention the profitable presence of IBM in Japan, Hong Kong and Singapore. 
 In Asia, just as in America, Big Blue is still bigger than Apple. 
 But if Mr Winchester's iconography is sometimes suspect, his opus is almost unfailingly entertaining. 
 He writes brilliantly of the great circumnavigation of Magellan, of his own voyages around the Horn, through the Panama Canal or up the peak in Darien where Balboa (not Keats's stout Cortez) first spied the Pacific. 
 Mr Winchester's guide somewhat spoils that last triumph by showing him a press release &mdash; written, of course, on a Macintosh &mdash; from a man who had followed Balboa's footsteps two months earlier. 
 Mr Winchester is impressively knowledgeable about all manner of things, from the tectonic plates that inexorably grind against each other beneath the Pacific's waves to the steamer duck paddling furiously away in Patagonia (although sloppy editing has the duck paddling at 20 knots on one page and a more believable 12 on another). 
 Most of all, Mr Winchester writes in a way guaranteed to lure the reader on to the most improbable journeys. 
 Who else would follow a lump of iron ore from Mount Newman in Western Australia all the way to a Japanese smelter and on to the Nissan showrooms in California? 
 Or take a white Rolls Royce into Los Angeles gangland to interview Raul (&bquo;Pinky&equo;) Estoban &mdash; who gave story and photographs in return for being allowed to drive the car himself? 
 Or persuade the operators of a slow train to Ulan Bator to put his Beatles cassette on the public-address system? 
 Whether all this adds up to Mr Winchester's &bquo;inchoate oneness&equo;, scheduled to mature in a generation or so, is open to doubt. 
 Mr Winchester predictably proves his case for part of the Pacific rim, from Japan round to California, but not for the whole circumference &mdash; and certainly not for the islands dotted in the Basin, despite the charming Western Samoan girl who takes his bags at Los Angeles airport and quotes Robert Louis Stevenson to him. 
 Proper proof, of course, would catapult Mr Winchester into the company of ponderous scholars; one suspects that he (and his readers) would be happier if he remained simply one of literature's best travel writers.  
 East European poetry 
 Noisy witness 
 THE POETRY OF PERESTROIKA. 
 Translated by Carol Rumens and Richard McKane. 
 Iron Press; 128 pages; &pound;4.99 
 CHILD OF EUROPE. 
 Edited by Michael March. 
 Penguin Books; 254 pages; &pound;6.99 
 IN THE Soviet Union, poetry is at the centre of everyday life in a way that the West would find inconceivable. 
 It has a large, popular audience; books and magazines sell in their hundreds of thousands; it is a communal witness to the truth. 
 And this has always been the case. 
 &bquo;The Poetry of Perestroika&equo; is an anthology of poems that were written, or published for the first time, during the period when the bureaucratic grip was gradually loosened. 
 Many are concerned with the Soviet Union's place in the scheme of things; with the poets' sense of revulsion at what a nation could have done to itself; with an intense probing of the values of nationhood and nationality. 
 These poets are trying to speak for the lost generations, condemned forever to inarticulacy; and to speak aloud about simple things that they had been forbidden even to think about. 
 Unfortunately, the very fact that poetry has a central role in Soviet life means that much of it is conservative in form and predictable in content. 
 The Soviet poet, as a voice of the people, is expected to respond to public events &mdash; and noisily if necessary. 
 Even the best of poets reach for their pens when something important happens in the world. 
 In &bquo;The Tale of the Turnip&equo;, Yevgeny Yevtushenko writes about the virtual annexation of Russia by capitalist influences under the guise of &bquo;humanitarian aid&equo;; Andrei Voznesensky laments the bloodshed in Tbilisi in &bquo;Candles and Tanks.&equo; 
 Less predictable is the discovery that younger Russian poets also write the kind of private, introspective verse that is supposed to be peculiarly western &mdash; Polina Ivanovna's &bquo;No one's here&equo; is a good example of that. 
 What is never in doubt is the Russian poet's belief that he has an audience to address, and one, moreover, that is ready and willing to listen. 
 Time and again, these poets seem to be carrying, in the very tones of their voices, the burdens of the history and the suffering of the Soviet Union and its peoples. 
 These words by Bulot Okhudzhava, from a poem entitled &bquo;A poet has no rivals in fate&equo; (1988), sum up the Russian poet's vision of any individual: 
 When he reaches the end of his time 
 And his soul flies into the shadows, 
 When the field has been crossed, the deed done, 
 You must decide what his life was. 
 Whether bitter or sweet, whether holy 
 Or ravaged by war, ripped in two, 
 What was his, is now yours. 
 All yours. 
 Dedicated to you. 
 &bquo;Child of Europe&equo; is an anthology of poems from the post-war generation of East European poets, many of whom have not been translated into English before. 
 The outstanding voices here are Tomasz Jastrun from Poland, whose short, often sinister poems from the martial-law years, a time &bquo;many centuries ago and yesterday&equo;, make the reader uncomfortably aware that &bquo;what terrifies in the face of death is the fact that almost nothing has happened&equo;; and Gojko Djogo from Yugoslavia, whose work, steeped in folklore, has a robust, defiant humour. 
 This collection is a sampler only &mdash; there are no more than six poems from each poet &mdash; but it testifies to the way in which poetry can &mdash; and does &mdash; survive in the most unpropitious circumstances.  
 British theatre 
 A Toad for our time 
 THE lady on the left had queued all day for returns. 
 The one on the right had flown in from Finland. 
 A packed run of the &bquo;The Wind in the Willows&equo; at the National Theatre is drawing to a close, but it is clear that Alan Bennett has launched a new Christmas tradition in London. 
 As Toad might say, his version is extensively refurbished and complete with every modern convenience: the finest show on the river. 
 Kenneth Grahame, the man who gave the world this masterpiece in 1908, was an escapist. 
 His tale was a flight from a strained marriage into a dream world where sex did not intrude, and from a City career into an Edwardian idyll. 
 Business, free trade and comparative advantage belonged firmly on the other side of the Wild Wood. 
 Rat, Badger and Mole would not have been seen dead with The Economist: Mr Toad might have flaunted it unread on the hall table. 
 For Toad had the dreadful whiff of commerce about him. 
 His vulgarity offended the code of his tweedy circle. 
 He abused his inheritance, behaved extravagantly, and nearly got his comeuppance from the weasels &mdash; a violent proletariat who squatted in his house while he was doing time for car theft. 
 Luckily, his companions rallied round to beat these oiks back into cringing servitude &mdash; the cudgel being the only language such types understand. 
 Mr Toad became a paragon of self-effacement. 
 Or did he? 
 Small wonder that this plot is barely discernible in modern performances of &bquo;Toad of Toad Hall&equo;, the play that A.A. Milne wrote of &bquo;The Wind in the Willows&equo; in 1930. 
 The class-parable means much less to most Britons 60 years on. 
 And Milne's version was too cuddly and childish in any case. 
 It was high time for a fresh interpretation. 
 Mr Bennett has provided one. 
 His equivalent of Edwardian leisured escapism is today's green movement. 
 Railways are good. 
 Motor cars are bad. 
 Economic progress is deeply suspect. 
 Toad. 
 But Rat, I am going to show you the World. 
 Rat. 
 I do not want to see the World. 
 From what I have seen of it so far, it has very little to recommend it. 
 Everybody doing things, getting somewhere. 
 Toad. 
 You mean the rat race? 
 A nice riposte. 
 But what finally lures Rat into a caravan trip is Toad's promise of the landscape that every nimby commuter dreams of &mdash; &bquo;the England of heath and common and hedgerow, green roads and ancient tracks.&equo; 
 Meanwhile the lurking weasels are no longer a lower-class mob, but slick property developers intent on turning Toad Hall into a fully integrated leisure complex. 
 &bquo;The horror. 
 The horror!&equo; groans Badger. 
 The four heroes are modernised, too. 
 Toad is now more Bedales than Eton, more Groucho's than the Turf. 
 Mole is an Alan Bennett. 
 Badger is a retired schoolmaster, rather short on gravitas. 
 Rat remains his dapper, timeless self. 
 All are more complicated than in 1908, given to emotions such as jealousy that the original riverbankers never knew. 
 They even succumb, in the end, to the charms of a girl, which Grahame would have winced at. 
 The National Theatre's production is memorably staged. 
 Its set is a mechanised top hat, with road or river running round its rim, while the crown falls to become the countryside or corkscrews upwards to reveal the womblike houses of Rat, Mole, or Badger. 
 Mr Bennett's script is deft, making an actor's use of the rambling tale's much loved situations and pantomime moments. 
 But the script is ultimately too spare to do justice to the book. 
 Mr Bennett has bravely included the &bquo;piper at the gates of dawn&equo;, the chapter when Rat and Mole come into the presence of Pan, the ultimate environmental deity. 
 It does not work because the emotion and atmosphere in the rest of the play have been too slight to support it. 
 In short, this is a fine &bquo;Wind in the Willows&equo; for the 1990s; but neither Mr Bennett nor Mr Milne has written the stage version for all time. 
 If they could not, can anyone?  
 Australian jazz 
 Home-brewed 
 ARE non-American jazz players more or less doomed to imitation? 
 &bquo;Beyond El Rocco&equo;, a film by an Australian, Kevin Lucas, surveys the history of modern jazz down under. 
 El Rocco was Sydney's top jazz club in the 1950s, an atmospheric dive which dispensed both the worst coffee and the most daring music in town. 
 By the rigid conventions of its time, as one habitu&eacute;e recalls, it was &bquo;a den of iniquity&equo;, with a clientele &bquo;fascinated, intrigued and slightly terrified&equo; by the radical sound of bebop. 
 In stuffy Sydney, modern jazz made you feel liberated, or better yet, &bquo;hip&equo; &mdash; possessing, as the film says, &bquo;esoteric knowledge not shared by the mainstream.&equo; 
 But however enthusiastically they cultivated this aura, Australians were bound to feel themselves second-class citizens. 
 According to one, &bquo;At El Rocco we were middle class&hellip; white Anglo-Saxon Protestants, pretending to be black Americans&hellip; 
 We can never get it as good as the black people do, 'cause it's their music.&equo; 
 The 1960s saw some hectic Australian searching for a music that was &bquo;ours&equo;, not &bquo;theirs&equo;. 
 Some plugged into the energy and popularity of rock 'n' roll; others borrowed techniques from contemporary classical music. 
 Groups became not merely bands, but &bquo;ensembles&equo;, deploying electronics, synthesisers and, in one case, something called &bquo;crossover music theatre&equo;. 
 Furthest out, the leader of &bquo;Freak Out&equo; wanted his music &bquo;to throw away all conventional attitudes and conventional modes of playing.&equo; 
 Commercially, this led to disaster. 
 In the 1970s Australian jazz experienced the same calamitous slump that afflicted the music generally. 
 The film shows a reversal of fortune only towards the end of the decade, as the rock culture waned and jazz began to be studied in conservatoires. 
 Australian jazz in the 1980s was varied but rigorous; less concerned with baring one's soul at all costs than, as one woman saxophonist puts it, &bquo;achieving a good standard of playing&equo;. 
 But the essential spirit of adventure is still present too, in a quest for a jazz style that reflects the signal multi-cultural character of Australia. 
 One musician asserts that &bquo;it's silly for us to look at overseas models&equo;; another wonders &bquo;if Australians understand what their own musical traditions are&equo;. 
 Increasingly there are attempts to incorporate Asian and African elements, along with a sense of the Australian landscape itself. 
 Is it jazz? 
 Its roots can be traced to the heady sounds of El Rocco; but &bquo;Beyond El Rocco&equo; demonstrates that much of the inspiration of Australian jazz now comes from Australians themselves. 
 AMERICAN SURVEY 
 Airports 
 Unloved 
 DALLAS 
 PINPOINTING a tiny airport in Dallas as an &bquo;island of non-competition&equo;, Senator Robert Dole wants to repeal a quirky law that bars direct flights from there to his home state of Kansas. 
 He hopes to drum up the support of sympathetic congressmen who blame the law for high fares. 
 The Wright amendment, named after a former speaker of the House, Jim Wright, permits flights leaving Dallas's Love Field to fly only to cities in Texas and four neighbouring states. 
 Bizarre travel patterns result. 
 Dallasites can slash fares to San Francisco in half by hopping south to Houston and proceeding on to California. 
 Business travellers in Wichita, Kansas, often save &dollar;300 by driving three hours south to Tulsa, in Oklahoma, and catching a flight to Dallas. 
 Bargain hunters can book two round-trip tickets, say Dallas-Oklahoma City and Oklahoma City-Chicago, rather than fly direct from Dallas. 
 Mr Wright's law was passed in 1979 to ensure that the newer and bigger Dallas-Fort Worth International Airport would thrive (he represented Fort Worth). 
 It has: the expansive airport on the north Texas plains is the world's second busiest &mdash; 50m passengers passed through last year. 
 Love Field, just 15 minutes from central Dallas, was cited as one of the most under-used airports in a recent federal study. 
 Traffic has continued to shrink even though the city of Dallas repaved a runway and built a new control tower. 
 Southwest Airlines, the only commercial airline serving Love Field, cannot offer its cheap, short-hop service to those who want to fly over Louisiana, Arkansas, Oklahoma or New Mexico. 
 Repealers see the Wright amendment as another post-deregulation rule that helps the big airlines get bigger. 
 The Kansas attorney-general has sued the federal government, arguing that the law bars free access to ports. 
 Colorado airport officials recently passed a resolution denouncing it. 
 The Department of Transportation, once headed by Mrs Dole, has commissioned a study. 
 The Dallas-Fort Worth airport board has allies, though. 
 One study estimates it would lose 6m passengers a year to Love Field. 
 So American Airlines, which dominates DFW, has threatened to cancel its expansion plans there. 
 The country's largest carrier is not keen to face new battles at home when it is trying to spread its wings overseas, by buying TWA's slots at Heathrow. 
 Anti-noise protesters near Love Field have also squeaked in opposition. 
 Last year, the Texas delegation in the House sided with American Airlines against repeal and successfully blocked the relevant bill. 
 Mr Dole hopes this year to slip a repeal measure through the Senate attached to another bill, but it is too early to tell whether he has enough support. 
 Only Southwest Airlines, sitting squarely in the middle of the controversy, takes no side. 
 It has cornered many lucrative short-hop routes. 
 And if Love Field is opened up, American and other carriers are expected to swarm in, giving Southwest stiff competition.  
 As old as you feel 
 SOLDIERS GROVE, WISCONSIN 
 SINCE 1970 America's old folks have become richer and richer, mostly because of a steadily increasing flow of federal dollars. 
 Nearly half of the budget now goes directly into their pockets through social security (pensions) and other transfers and welfare programmes. 
 With so much spare cash floating around, it was inevitable that industrious entrepreneurs would pop up to try to claim it for themselves. 
 Among some of the more senior citizens in Soldiers Grove, a tiny town (population 560) in western Wisconsin, the new market is for the oldest profession. 
 For the past two years, police say, prostitutes have been doing a lively business in the Golden Acres apartments &mdash; a group of flats filled with retired old men. 
 The ladies' timing is impeccable: usually they turn up on the day that social-security cheques are due to arrive in the post. 
 This month some of them were hauled before a local judge and charged with exchanging sex for cash and, in some cases, durable goods &mdash; like cars. 
 Few people in Soldiers Grove believe the story. 
 But the police have two eye-witnesses to support their charges against the women, whom they describe as &bquo;sporadically employed&equo;. 
 Both of the witnesses &mdash; one aged 82, the other 73 &mdash; admit to having paid the prostitutes about &dollar;2,000 (at &dollar;100 per visit) for services rendered in 1989 and 1990. 
 Still, the case will be tough to prove. 
 Though apparently quite spry, the old men's memories are not what they once were. 
 Asked for details of the transactions, one replied: &bquo;I don't remember exactly what all took place.&equo;  
 &iexcl; Hola LA! 
 LOS ANGELES 
 THE contest to represent the first district on the Los Angeles Board of County Supervisors hardly sounds like national news. 
 However, the election of Gloria Molina on February 19th is a big milestone for  California's  enormous, but politically inactive, Latino (Hispanic) population. 
 Overnight Mrs Molina, a firebrand, has become one of the most powerful Latino politicians in America. 
 Los Angeles is the most populous county in America &mdash; bigger than 42 states. 
 Latinos account for a third of its 9m odd residents. 
 Yet Mrs Molina becomes the first Latino to sit on the county's governing board since 1872 &mdash; and the first woman ever. 
 The election itself came only after a decade of political squabbling. 
 Latino politicians claimed that the district boundaries discriminated against them. 
 Last year a judge forced Los Angeles to redraw its districts to create a special Latino one, based on areas with an especially high concentration of Spanish surnames. 
 There is now talk that more such districts will be created. 
 Mrs Molina, a Los Angeles city councilwoman, finished first in a January primary with 35% of the vote. 
 Her opponent in the run-off was Art Torres, a state senator who was once tipped to become California's first Latino governor. 
 Mr Torres's campaign was endorsed by a flock of top state politicians and the unions. 
 He also raised &dollar;1.2m &mdash; twice as much as Mrs Molina. 
 Mrs Molina, who won 55% of the vote in the run-off, triumphed by painting herself as an outsider and a reformer. 
 Mr Torres's two drunk-driving arrests did not help his cause. 
 For all her talk of shaking up the town's bureaucracy, Mrs Molina will have to learn some of her opponent's conciliatory skills to win a better deal for her constituents. 
 And political apathy reigns: despite the significance of the election, fewer than a quarter of Mrs Molina's constituents bothered to vote in the run-off.  
 Admiral Watkins's leaking energy policy 
 THE energy secretary found out this week what it is like to be stomped on by Washington's green lobby. 
 No sooner had James Watkins released what he called the &bquo;first edition&equo; of his national energy strategy (NES) on February 20th than the verdicts were delivered &mdash; in nice sound bites. 
 Too much on production, not enough on conservation. 
 A tragedy, not a strategy. 
 Like giving whisky to an alcoholic. 
 A grab-bag of missed opportunities and misplaced priorities&hellip; 
 Mr Watkins, a retired admiral, is unlikely to be upset by noisy environmentalists. 
 He has experience in wresting success from public-relations disasters. 
 In 1987 he took over Ronald Reagan's bickering AIDS commission after its previous chairman resigned in a huff. 
 Thanks to deft chairmanship and bluntness, he drew from it a respectable report that won praise for its forthrightness. 
 He has tried to work similar magic at the unwieldy Energy Department. 
 He has, for instance, been more open than his predecessors about the tens of billions of dollars that will have to be spent to clean up the department's shambolic nuclear-weapons plants. 
 And he has attempted to be equally frank in fashioning the NES, a task that has been spread over 18 months and umpteen public hearings. 
 The attempt has failed. 
 Until last autumn most energy lobbyists were guardedly positive. 
 Then the Energy Department went quiet, and word slipped out that the White House was gutting most of its proposed conservation measures while strengthening the emphasis on increased domestic production. 
 The lop-sided result is what riles the greens. 
 Mr Watkins can say that he sympathises with green views on the need for conservation but has been overruled by the troika that presides over George Bush's domestic policy: John Sununu, the chief of staff, Richard Darman, the budget director, and Michael Boskin, the chief economic adviser. 
 He will not be the first cabinet secretary to sell this line of being a decent person savaged by a three-headed Cerberus in the White House. 
 It makes a good story. 
 It is also a blatant bid to have it both ways. 
 Mr Watkins has after all signed and presented the NES. 
 If he really disliked what the beastly troika had done to it, he could have resigned &mdash; or, perhaps more effectively, threatened to. 
 Besides, the Cerberus has two good arguments on its side. 
 The first is tactical. 
 The administration's energy bill is bound to be heavily amended in Congress. 
 Mr Darman felt burnt by last year's clean-air act. 
 The bill put forward by President Bush in May 1989 went as far as he thought wise in loading new burdens on to industry. 
 Yet Congress merrily increased the load. 
 Mr Darman concluded that in future the administration should start tougher &mdash; even if that meant antagonising greens. 
 The second goes to the nub of energy policy: its economics. 
 Both Mr Boskin's recent annual economic report and the NES cogently make the case for relying on market forces in energy policy, with the government intervening only when prices are sending obviously wrong signals &mdash; usually because they do not reflect such externalities as environmental effects. 
 The economic report dismisses claims that America is unusually profligate in its energy use. 
 And it observes that the use of regulation or taxes instead of the market creates inefficiencies and slows economic growth. 
 Hence the thrust of the NES: leave it to market-driven energy prices to create incentives to conserve, while junking many regulatory restraints on oil, gas and nuclear production. 
 Half right. 
 The trouble is that governments have always intervened in energy, usually with a bias in favour of production. 
 Daniel Yergin's recent book &bquo;The Prize&equo; shows that oil has for decades been cosseted with tax breaks and government subsidies. 
 Mr Bush, a former Texan oilman, must remember such practices well. 
 Last year's budget agreement included new goodies for oil. 
 And if, as the NES proposes, the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge in Alaska is opened to drilling (lobbyists give this a 50&ndash;50 chance of passing through Congress), the government will ensure that the drilling happens. 
 Nuclear energy, above all, tests market enthusiasts. 
 Mr Watkins, once a commander of a nuclear submarine, has always been a believer in nuclear power. 
 So has Mr Sununu, who as governor of New Hampshire fought a long battle with the greens to open the Seabrook nuclear plant. 
 They share the conventional wisdom of the nuclear lobby that what has stopped America's nuclear industry in its tracks is what the NES calls an &bquo;impossibly cumbersome nuclear licensing process&equo; &mdash; of a kind that pro-nuclear countries like France do not allow. 
 Hence the proposal for a single-licence procedure, allowing no further challenges after a plant has been approved by the regulators and built. 
 The market has spoken 
 No doubt there is too much red tape and lawyering in the nuclear business &mdash; as in so much of American life. 
 But red tape is not the only or even the main problem. 
 It is just as likely that the market, left to itself, would not finance or build nuclear-power stations, not because of the greens but because of their poor rate of return. 
 Nor can the market get rid of or store nuclear waste. 
 Tellingly, the publicly owned Tennessee Valley Authority is the only utility to have expressed interest recently in nuclear power. 
 Mr Watkins is said to be keener on education than energy &mdash; indeed the NES includes plans to improve science education. 
 But if his NES is to survive the lobbying in Congress, both he and the White House beast may need educating themselves. 
 Faith in the paramountcy of the market must be consistent to be persuasive.  
 The Mafia and garbage 
 Refuse you cannot offer 
 NEW YORK 
 MOST New Yorkers are cynical about current efforts to clean mobsters out of their city's waste-disposal business &mdash; and with good reason. 
 Along with the building and waterfront trades, garbage collection is a stronghold of the organised-crime syndicates whose nefarious activities add so much to the cost of doing business in New York. 
 The Justice Department faces a struggle as it seeks at secret meetings to persuade big national operators like Browning-Ferris and Laidlaw Industries to bid for commercial garbage-collection contracts. 
 Household and public rubbish is carted away by the city's relatively efficient Sanitation Department. 
 But New York's 250,000 commercial concerns have to contract with private hauliers to have their rubbish removed. 
 Maximum rates are set by New York's Department of Consumer Affairs, but the city's 450 private garbage-disposal firms decline to compete with one another. 
 Grumbles from businessmen about bad service, extortionate prices and victimisation for trying to switch garbage collectors have provoked at least eight government investigations since the mid-1950s into racketeering in the city's waste-disposal industry. 
 None has loosened criminal control, though crooked operators are periodically sent to jail. 
 Two of the most notorious, Angelo Paccione and Anthony Vulpis, are serving 12-year terms for illegal dumping. 
 Only Salvatore Spinelli, a lawyer who represents many of the city's private hauliers, is able to say with a straight face that intimidation is &bquo;a myth&equo;. 
 Even big companies fear that the safety of their equipment and their employees will be at risk if they seek waste-disposal contracts in the city. 
 The same fear sustains extortionate bills in some other businesses. 
 At Manhattan's Fulton fish market in the shadow of Brooklyn Bridge, fishmongers pay about &dollar;1.40 to have 100lb of fish carried across South Street &mdash; the same price they would pay to have it carried all the way from the Gulf of Mexico. 
 The influence of the Genovese crime family in this &dollar;2 billion-a-year market is said to date back 70 years. 
 It has survived several challenges by federal investigators. 
 The latest is led by Frank Wohl, a court-appointed monitor. 
 In a report last summer, Mr Wohl said the market was dominated by an atmosphere of violence and extortion that significantly increased the retail price of fish in the city. 
 Independent transport companies that have sought to win business away from existing contractors in the Fulton market have had their lorries damaged and their workers hammered with loading hooks. 
 Although crowds have gathered to watch these beatings, the police are never able to find anybody who has seen anything. 
 The building trades are also riddled with extortionate practices, but here the influence of the Mafia is probably exaggerated. 
 Tradesmen presenting inflated bills have no interest in countering the popular belief that slow payers tend to end up in the Hudson River wearing cement slippers. 
 A particularly notorious den of restrictive, and extortionate, practices is the Jacob Javits Convention Centre, where the Democratic party will hold its convention next year to nominate its presidential candidate. 
 Exhibitors at trade shows in the convention centre complain that they are bullied into hiring tradesmen to perform such simple tasks as hanging a picture. 
 Labour costs at the centre are the highest in the country: &dollar;78.50 an hour of straight-time for an electrician, compared with &dollar;45 an hour at a comparable centre in Los Angeles and &dollar;28 in Atlanta. 
 Workers at the convention centre are said to take longer to complete a task than tradesmen anywhere west of Poland. 
 Exhibitors also complain they have to put up with the theft of their merchandise, and suspect their bills are inflated by &bquo;ghost&equo; workers, who are paid but do no work. 
 Like the rip-offs in rubbish collection and fish transport, these charges are under investigation. 
 New Yorkers confidently expect the inquiry to turn up nothing.  
 Anti-Americanism in Europe 
 From on high 
 IN THE words of George Bush, Americans are doing &bquo;the hard work of freedom&equo;. 
 So why is the rest of the world so ungrateful? 
 The Gulf war has not reduced the superciliousness of many Europeans about America one bit; if anything the reverse. 
 The yanks are castigated for their heartless reaction to the deaths of civilians in Baghdad (&bquo;the manner of the American military's response betrays something about its values,&equo; opined Britain's Independent on Sunday) and mocked for the fear of terrorism that has kept them away from Europe &mdash; thus cruelly hurting Europe's tourist business. 
 Theo Sommer, the editor of the influential German weekly Die Zeit, captured the intellectual mood in his country when he wrote that the Gulf war was a &bquo;last, almost spastic twitching of US supremacy.&equo; 
 In France, Jean-Pierre Chev&egrave;nement, who resigned as defence minister shortly after the outbreak of war, accused the United States a few years ago of &bquo;the organised cretinisation of our people.&equo; 
 Anti-Americanism is a slippery concept. 
 It is easily confused with opposition to particular American policies &mdash; rather as McCarthy used to accuse his enemies of &bquo;unAmerican activities&equo;. 
 The real thing goes beyond political disagreement and comes in two flavours: a distaste for American culture, and a systematic resistance to the exercise of American power. 
 Polls suggest that cultural snobbery is largely confined to intellectuals. 
 But they have been sneering at America since Sidney Smith, Fran&ccedil;ois Mauriac and George Grosz and will go on doing so long after Harold Pinter is gone. 
 Such people hate McDonalds, Coca-Cola, &bquo;Dallas&equo;, Rambo and other items of American popular culture largely because they are so&hellip; popular. 
 Ordinary people are more mature. 
 In Germany since the early 1960s, opinion polls have consistently shown around 50% of people saying that they &bquo;like Americans&equo; &mdash; whatever the prevailing political climate. 
 In Britain, attitudes to American foreign policy have fluctuated, but polls have always shown warm feelings towards the United States as a nation. 
 Since the 1960s the same has been true of France. 
 In Germany, recent surveys have shown 75% support for the war. 
 A week after the outbreak of war, one poll showed 85% of Germans opposing &bquo;anti-American trends&equo; among protesters. 
 In France, a poll taken around the same time showed 75% approval for the Americans in the Gulf. 
 In February 69% of Britons told pollsters they were satisfied &bquo;with the way the American government is handling the situation in the Gulf&equo; &mdash; up from 49% the previous month. 
 But the existence of a quiet pro-American majority in Britain, France and Germany is not proof against big changes in attitudes to America's role in the world. 
 In Britain both the Vietnam war and the Reagan years saw remarkable collapses of faith in the good sense of American leadership. 
 In May 1977, over 50% of Britons expressed confidence &bquo;in the ability of the United States to deal wisely with world problems.&equo; 
 By May 1984, after America had invaded Grenada and withdrawn from Lebanon, this figure had declined to less than 20%. 
 By contrast, the French were far keener on President Reagan than the Germans or the British. 
 In 1984 opinion polls showed that Ronald Reagan would have been decisively defeated had he been running for re-election in Britain. 
 In France he would have won easily. 
 The French were impressed by the image of a resurgent and technologically advanced America. 
 The Nouvel Observateur concluded that &bquo;even socialists think that America is chic.&equo; 
 Recent years have seen a revival of popular faith in America among Britons and Germans. 
 President Bush has enjoyed rising approval ratings, and communism's appeal has collapsed as fast as communism. 
 But Europeans are increasingly keen (1992 and all that) to see themselves as cultural pioneers and not to emulate the United States. 
 A recent poll showed that only 2% of Germans regarded the United States as a suitable model for their newly united nation &mdash; Switzerland topped the pops. 
 Intriguingly, the experience of the mid-1980s suggests that the pursuit of an independent line in Europe is likely to lessen fear and mistrust of the United States. 
 In 1984 Britain and Germany were quaking under the American nuclear umbrella. 
 Some 50% of Britons and 38% of Germans believed that Mr Reagan's foreign policy had increased the dangers of war in Europe. 
 Only a quarter of the French believed this, and yet their government had been engaged in a series of clashes with the Reagan administration on issues ranging from star wars to Nicaragua. 
 More friction meant less tension &mdash; a lesson for the new world order?  
 Arizona politics 
 Mud wrestling 
 PHOENIX 
 WHEN a lightning storm stopped the transmission of a televised debate between Arizona's two candidates for governor, Fife Symington and Terry Goddard, locals joked that even God was disgusted by Arizona politics. 
 A previous governor, Evan Mecham, was impeached and removed from office in 1988. 
 The state's two senators are both members of the &bquo;Keating Five&equo;, under investigation by the Senate for peddling their influence. 
 A tenth of its state legislators may be indicted following a corruption sting. 
 And the current campaign for governor is mired in mud. 
 A good state to govern? 
 Surprisingly, yes. 
 The sting &mdash; known locally as &bquo;Operation Desert Shame&equo; &mdash; is the most fun. 
 &bquo;Tony Vincent&equo;, supposedly a mobster from Las Vegas, offered various politicians inducements to help legalise casino gambling in the state. 
 His successes and failures are now collected on 200 video tapes, some of which have been shown on television. 
 &bquo;You sure there isn't a camera?&equo; one state assemblyman asked nervously, before he pushed &dollar;55,000 in cash into his gym bag. 
 &bquo;What's in it for me?&equo; was the favourite phrase of another. 
 &bquo;Everyone has their price,&equo; was the excuse of a third. 
 Seven of the state's 90 legislators have been indicted (together with 11 lobbyists). 
 Phoenix gossip reckons that another five politicians may soon be charged. 
 Another investigation, this time into lobbying on behalf of chiropractors, could thin the legislature's ranks still further. 
 Even before these upsets, Arizona was in the political dog house because its voters decided to cancel the Martin Luther King holiday. 
 This offended blacks and caused the removal of the 1993 Super Bowl to another state. 
 One politician argues that &bquo;Arizonans have broken through a shame barrier; they now just find it all funny rather than sad.&equo; 
 Bumper stickers proclaim &bquo;Honk if you haven't been indicted&equo;. 
 However, even the most fun-loving Arizonans are tiring of the governor's battle. 
 In November Mr Symington, a Republican developer, narrowly beat his Democratic opponent, Mr Goddard, at the ballot box, but he won only 49.7% of the vote. 
 Arizona law demands that the victor receive over 50%, so a run-off will be held on February 26th. 
 The November campaign was, if anything, a bit too earnest, with education the main issue. 
 The run-off has been nastier. 
 Mr Goddard, a former mayor of Phoenix who had been expected to win the November race easily, first lowered the tone by comparing Mr Symington to Charles Keating, the financier at the heart of the Lincoln Savings and Loan disaster. 
 Mr Symington's campaign was mildly cleaner until a recent commercial that finished with a picture of Mr Goddard being locked behind bars. 
 The irony is that, unlike many Arizona politicians, Mr Goddard and Mr Symington are respectable citizens. 
 Mr Symington was on the board of a savings and loan, as Mr Goddard's advertisements allege, but he resigned in 1984 when the thrift was still in good shape. 
 One explanation for all the flying muck is that, after such a long campaign, the candidates (whose views are similar on many issues) simply ran out of things to say. 
 In the television debate Mr Goddard sounded like a petulant school master who was sure that a pupil had done something wrong but couldn't prove it. 
 The odds are that barely one in three voters will bother to cast a ballot on February 26th. 
 That should favour Mr Symington because there are 90,000 more registered Republicans than Democrats. 
 It remains a race worth winning. 
 Rob Melnick, at Arizona State University, reckons that the economy will soon pick up again. 
 Acres of empty office space should attract investors. 
 Despite its reputation as a rest home for elderly Chicagoans, Arizona's average age is below the national average, and its education standards are higher. 
 Moreover, simply by being there the new governor will add a little stability to Arizona's politics. 
 Over the past 12 years the state has had eight governors. 
 There has also been a high turnover of state Senate leaders, House speakers and even local newspaper publishers. 
 Arizona, according to one columnist, E.J. Montini, &bquo;is like the kid who stole his parents' car and is out careering on to other people's lawns, crashing into garbage cans and running red lights.&equo; 
 Providing he can install a little discipline, the next governor may also be able to take the credit for cleaning up Arizona's politics. 
 One political consultant, Bill Jamieson, reckons that a new wave of young and unvenal state politicians has just arrived in Phoenix. 
 They claim as their spiritual leader Bruce Babbitt, Arizona's talented and common-sensical former governor who ran for president in 1988 and now works as a lawyer in Phoenix.  
 New world order: What's new? 
 Which world? 
 Whose orders? 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 THE inter-agency group charged with developing a post-war American foreign policy has an almost impossible job. 
 Inevitably it has had to lard its work with contingencies and question marks. 
 This much, however, seems clear: George Bush will insist that American policy reflects his belief in a &bquo;new world order.&equo; 
 The hardest task for his subordinates is to decide what the phrase (now often shortened to NWO and not to be confused with the airline that used to be called Northwest Orient) might mean. 
 Beyond saying that he sees a world where aggression is deterred and disputes settled peacefully, Mr Bush has not offered a definition. 
 Yet, if nothing else, the phrase shows how American foreign policy has been changed by the war in the Gulf. 
 A year ago, when the Soviet retreat from Eastern Europe seemed almost guaranteed, American strategists saw the prospect of a series of global partnerships. 
 One was to be with Japan (the very term &bquo;global partnership&equo; was coined for the American-Japanese relationship). 
 One was to be with Western Europe, led (pretty explicitly) by a united Germany. 
 State Department planners saw neither of these partnerships as necessarily limited geographically. 
 The Americans have long been eager for the Japanese to help Latin America's economies, and mused that the Europeans might want to shoulder a degree of responsibility for Africa. 
 When Mr Bush and Mikhail Gorbachev met in Washington in June 1990, a third partnership seemed possible. 
 Once the Soviet Union allowed pluralism in Eastern Europe, America was prepared to look for areas where Soviet help could come in handy. 
 James Baker, the secretary of state, told Congress recently that his review of Middle East policy convinced him long before the invasion of Kuwait that the &bquo;old view that we somehow did not want the Soviets involved is a mistake&equo;. 
 How have the past six months altered this picture? 
 The main change has been in attitudes to Japan and Western Europe. 
 Their view of the seriousness of Iraq's action, and the reaction it demanded, was different enough from Mr Bush's to scupper talk of global partnerships and replace it by what might be called contingent leadership. 
 Mr Baker has spoken of the renewed &bquo;need for American leadership&equo;. 
 Mr Bush says much the same. 
 Cheerleaders of the new policy, like Charles Krauthammer, a columnist, speak with approval of the new &bquo;unipolar&equo; world &mdash; in which &bquo;our best hope is in American strength and will, unashamedly laying down the rules of world order and being prepared to enforce them.&equo; 
 This &bquo;leadership&equo;, however, is not that of a gallant subaltern, charging the machine guns while his platoon has a smoke in the dug-out. 
 It is leadership only if America is convinced that others will follow &mdash; that is the contingency. 
 They can follow in kind, like Britain is doing in the Gulf, or they can follow in cash, like Japan and Germany. 
 But they must follow somehow. 
 Domestic politics dictates that. 
 The past six months have made it clear that latent isolationism can be inflamed if it is felt that the allies are shirking. 
 This is especially the case in hard economic times. 
 So the domestic political and economic cost of go-it-alone adventurism is one constraint on America's freedom of action overseas. 
 A second is the Soviet Union. 
 America's reaction to the Soviet peace plan for the Gulf was strikingly polite. 
 Mr Bush spoke of his &bquo;appreciation&equo; for Mr Gorbachev's communication of his plan. 
 His press secretary even said that the Soviet Union was still a superpower &mdash; not at all what the cheerleaders think. 
 A senior White House official recently said that the days when Soviet foreign policy was ideologically driven are gone. 
 That gives America opportunities to work with the Soviets that it did not have in the past. 
 At the same time, both the White House and the State Department recognise that Soviet foreign policy will be driven by Soviet national interests, and that these will not always coincide with America's. 
 Nobody is starry-eyed about a world condominium with Moscow, but nobody except some of the administration's conservative critics (who have had a field day trashing the Gorbachev plan for the Gulf) thinks the Russians can be ignored. 
 Colin Powell, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, put the matter most clearly (which is getting to be a habit) when he testified to Congress on February 19th. 
 He drew a distinction between what had changed &mdash; superpower rivalry defined by ideology &mdash; and what had not: Soviet military power. 
 The Soviet Union, he said, was the only country capable of destroying America in less than 30 minutes. 
 He went on to say that another enduring reality lies in America's interests across the Atlantic &mdash; expanding the definition of across-the-Atlantic to include the Middle East, both because of its considerable economic resources and because it was home to some of &bquo;our closest friends&equo;. 
 And he stressed American interests across the Pacific, home to another clutch of friends. 
 Save for a mention of the enduring reality of &bquo;the unknown&equo;, that was it &mdash; which begs a question. 
 The &bquo;new world&equo; that Mr Bush seeks to order is quite small. 
 It includes Europe, the Middle East, parts of Asia, Canada and Mexico. 
 Mexico apart (and for domestic reasons no American government can ignore Mexico), the administration is not much bothered with what goes on in Latin America. 
 It will vaguely push to expand trade with South American countries, but that is about it. 
 The same lack of interest marks America's policy towards Africa. 
 There is a sense that things are heading in the right direction in South Africa, and that is all. 
 India? 
 Pakistan? 
 Indonesia? 
 Never heard of them. 
 Leading where others follow 
 Perhaps the half-a-world that Mr Bush wants ordered is quite big enough. 
 But how the ordering is to be done remains an open question. 
 If every confrontation requires the dispatch of half a million troops half way round the globe, the NWO will have failed. 
 In the case of the Gulf, cover for America's use of force was provided by the United Nations, and this was useful. 
 That, needless to say, is one reason why America cannot ignore the veto-wielding Soviet Union. 
 But many in the administration remain sceptical about how useful the United Nations will prove to be. 
 For instance, Defence Department officials doubt that UN cover for the use of force could easily be obtained again. 
 Some officials have spoken of getting NATO to spread its wings, though they might have a hard time persuading the Canadians and Europeans of that. 
 But in the NWO America will always have to persuade someone: that, despite the fashion for unipolarity, seems likely to be its central fact. 
 Take post-war policy in the Gulf. 
 If America wants to bring a reconstruction bank into being, it will have to convince the Saudis and other Gulf states to cough up most of the money. 
 If it maintains its present determination to keep little more than a naval force in the region, it will have to convince others (the Egyptians? 
 The United Nations?) to provide a peace-keeping force on the ground. 
 If it is to make good on Mr Bush's hope that it may be possible to &bquo;settle the conflicts that divide the Arabs from Israel&equo;, it will have to convince the Israelis that they can be secure even shorn of the occupied territories. 
 This is but a particular example of a new truth. 
 America is fated by politics and economics at home to find willing backers abroad for its plans; it is doomed by continuing Soviet military might to have an eye always on Moscow. 
 It is not the unfettered giant that, tautly ready for a fierce ground war in the Gulf, it may appear to be. 
 ASIA 
 Thailand 
 North-east passage 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN ROI ET 
 THERE are two Thailands. 
 One, found almost exclusively in Bangkok and its suburbs, is the product of rapid industrialisation; its inhabitants enjoy incomes only a little below those of the  Portuguese . 
 Their rural cousins, who still make up 75% of the population, scratch a living from the soil. 
 The growing discrepancy is starting to make the villagers despair that any of the city's wealth will trickle down to them. 
 Looked at as a whole, Thailand has done well. 
 According to the World Bank, the proportion of Thais living below the poverty line fell from 59% in 1960 to 26% in 1986 and, with the three years of double-digit economic growth that followed, must have fallen much further since. 
 By the usual measures of third-world misery &mdash; infant mortality, unsafe water, calorie intake, illiteracy &mdash; Thais live at least as well as, if not better than, people in other countries with Thailand's GNP per person of about &dollar;1,000. 
 But Thailand is not a whole. 
 Esarn (the north-east) is the poorest bit of the country. 
 The Esarn diet includes such delicacies as tadpoles and joodjee beetles (found in buffalo dung). 
 They taste a lot better when you are hungry. 
 During the Vietnam war, Esarn had its own communist insurgency. 
 The fighting did not end until 1980. 
 Although many people in Esarn are poor, most have the bare necessities. 
 But they are aware of their relative poverty. 
 Now that electricity has been brought to nearly all the villages, the inhabitants can cluster around a television set and see how much better things are in Bangkok. 
 A comparison between life in the capital and in Roi Et, in the centre of Esarn, is startling. 
 Bangkok has a doctor for every 722 people; Roi Et can produce one for every 23,681 people, on a par with the Central African Republic. 
 More than 70% of Thailand's bank deposits are held by residents of Bangkok. 
 Most people in Roi Et have no money to deposit and cannot borrow from banks because they lack collateral. 
 The alternative is money-lenders who charge 6&ndash;10% a month. 
 The way to escape from the poverty of Esarn is to find work in Bangkok. 
 Parents usually keep their children at home for a couple of years after they have completed their six years of compulsory education. 
 When they are 15 or 16 they are sent off to work as building labourers, clothing makers or worse. 
 (Migrants from Roi Et specialise in driving taxis, usually lethally.) 
 If they are lucky, workers receive the legal minimum wage of 100 baht (&dollar;4) a day. 
 Many do not. 
 After a few years of gutting chickens for 14 hours a day, they are often thrown out of work by younger and cheaper competitors. 
 It is not only labour that the economic power of Bangkok is sucking out of the north-east. 
 Over the past 30 years the region's forest cover has fallen from 42% to less than 15%. 
 During the insurgency villagers were encouraged to chop down trees to deny shelter to the communists. 
 Now many villagers are being expelled from land they cleared. 
 This land, and other former forest land, is being planted with eucalyptus to supply pulp mills. 
 Then there is salt mining. 
 Salt water is pumped up from deep below the ground. 
 The salt crystallises and is carted away for use in soda-ash plants and glass-making. 
 The waste water is often dumped, making the surrounding land infertile. 
 Salt mining at the head of the Nam Siew river has made parts of the river twice as salty as the sea. 
 One result of environmental damage is the rise of peasant politics. 
 Esarn has 62 self-help organisations, most of which are in the business of agitation rather than welfare. 
 Activists have been shot in the towns of Buriram and Udon Thani. 
 In January policemen arrested the leaders of some farmers near the Cambodian border who are trying to save their land from eucalyptus plantations. 
 Bamrung Boonpanya, who helped to organise protests against the pollution of the Nam Siew river, says that trying to get the police to enforce the law was &bquo;like running after rats&equo;. 
 The police are in the pay of the entrepreneurs doing the mining, he claims. 
 However that may be, the entrepreneurs do have powerful friends in Bangkok: the finance minister has an interest in the glass industry; the interior minister has an interest in soda ash. 
 Whenever talk turns to the government, the name of General Chavalit Yongchaiyudh comes up. 
 He is believed to be honest and is known for his involvement in the army-backed project for &bquo;Green Esarn&equo;. 
 At the next election the general is expected to stand in Khon Kaen, in the heart of Esarn. 
 If he can convince the 19m north-easterners that he and his recently formed New Aspiration Party will give them a better deal, and he manages to form an electoral pact with the honest and popular governor of Bangkok, he could be on the way to becoming Thailand's next prime minister.  
 The joy of Chinese sex 
 FROM OUR CHINA CORRESPONDENT 
 IT MUST be the result of all that western decadence and spiritual pollution: the Chinese like sex. 
 The Shanghai Sex Sociological Research Centre, after questioning 23,000 people in 15 provinces, has concluded that 86% of Chinese approve of sex before marriage, 69% approve of extra-marital affairs, and more than 70% believe one purpose of sex is pleasure &mdash; not just, as Maoist traditionalists would have it, procreation and the dreary fulfilment of conjugal duty. 
 This should not surprise even the casual observer of China. 
 Miniskirts are now commonplace in Beijing, Shanghai and Shenzhen, and teenage couples (for whom pre-marital sex is no longer a rarity) canoodle publicly. 
 But the figures will still offend an instinctively puritanical government, and give ammunition to those who believe that the economic liberalism of the past decade is corrupting China's morals and weakening the family. 
 Actually, they have plenty of ammunition already. 
 The number of divorces, for example, rose to 750,000 in 1989, up from 440,000 five years earlier. 
 That is small compared with the number of marriages &mdash; 7.8m in 1984 and 9.3m in 1989 &mdash; but in Mao's day a divorce was considered an offence against socialism and so was almost impossible to obtain. 
 Moreover, prostitution and venereal disease, supposedly eliminated under Mao, are once again flourishing. 
 Officially reported cases of gonorrhoea, syphilis and other venereal diseases now number more than 375,000, which surely understates things. 
 Even the presence of AIDS, which the Chinese associate with the foreign wickedness of homosexuality, is now acknowledged. 
 So what should be done? 
 The State Council has launched a campaign against the &bquo;Seven Evils&equo;: prostitution; pornography; the kidnapping and sale of women and children; the trafficking and use of drugs; gambling; swindling through superstitions; and triads (criminal societies). 
 The campaign is needed to fight what the People's Daily says is &bquo;a struggle between socialist and capitalist ideologies&equo;. 
 But, as the Shanghai researchers discovered, some human urges respect no ideological boundaries.  
 Sri Lanka 
 Bad behaviour 
 FROM OUR SRI LANKA CORRESPONDENT 
 THE Mothers' Front is a new and potentially powerful human-rights organisation in Sri Lanka. 
 The government does not much care for it. 
 The defence minister, Ranjan Wijeratne, gave warning that a rally called in Colombo by the mothers would be violent. 
 He called for &bquo;democracy through good behaviour&equo;, a maxim that could have come from the mouth of Chairman Mao. 
 In fact the rally, on February 19th, attended by 10,000 people, passed off peacefully, as the organisers had said it would. 
 Mr Wijeratne's warning, however, dissuaded thousands more people from attending. 
 The Mothers' Front is demanding information about more than 40,000 people it says have disappeared in the past few years. 
 The mothers, says Mr Wijeratne in what sounds like an unfeeling remark, should have paid more attention to what their children were doing. 
 The government is concerned that most of the disappearances are blamed on the security forces. 
 Nearly all of them took place in the central and southern parts of the island, where the Sinhalese are in the majority. 
 A violent uprising by a Marxist-nationalist group, the JVP, was effectively but brutally crushed in 1989&ndash;90. 
 Thousands of bystanders disappeared in the process. 
 The government cannot ignore the growing political clout of the security forces. 
 They would grow restive, perhaps even rebel, if the government allowed the human-rights movement to develop too fully. 
 Their message to the politicians seems to be, &bquo;We protected you from the JVP. 
 Now it is your turn to protect us.&equo; 
 In the north and east, where the war with Tamil Tiger separatists continues, it is the army, rather than the government, that is taking the decisions. 
 A short-lived ceasefire broke down in January after army commanders demanded another chance to smash the Tigers. 
 President Ranasinghe Premadasa agreed, though he is said to have set a deadline for definite military results to be produced. 
 The army claims the Tigers are on the ropes. 
 The rebels replied on February 17th by killing 45 soldiers in an ambush on the northern coast where the army has some camps. 
 Farther north, in the Jaffna peninsula, where the rebels are strong, government aircraft have been bombing civilian areas. 
 Schools, temples and churches have been hit too many times in the past few weeks to be the victims of mistakes. 
 Many Tamils fear they are being softened up for another assault on Jaffna. 
 The authorities are said to take the view that the Gulf war will distract attention from civilian casualties in Jaffna. 
 Mr Wijeratne has suggested that civilians in the area &mdash; a million of them &mdash; should pack their bags and leave. 
 Few have the means or the inclination to do so. 
 Reports that occasionally emerge from independent sources in the north also criticise the Tigers for using civilians as cannon fodder, to try to win sympathy for their cause abroad. 
 On the part of both the government and the guerrillas, the behaviour is not very good for democracy.  
 Indonesia's Muslim dilemma 
 FROM OUR INDONESIA CORRESPONDENT 
 THE Javanese have a legendary fruit called the simalakama. 
 It kills your mother if you eat it and your father if you don't. 
 Indonesia's President Suharto, a good Javanese, may ruefully be recalling the legend these days as he ponders over what attitude to take about the Gulf war. 
 America, Japan and the other allies fighting Iraq provide the investment and aid money that supports Mr Suharto's ambitious development programmes. 
 On the other hand he does not want to jeopardise his shadowy courtship of Indonesia's 160m Muslims. 
 Well, maybe not 160m. 
 All Indonesians must have their chosen god stamped on their identity card. 
 (This precludes them from being irreligious communists.) 
 Some 90% choose Islam, but many chain-smoking, beer-drinking &bquo;ID-card Muslims&equo; are less than fanatical about their faith. 
 They are, however, almost universally cross about the bombing of their brethren in Iraq, the schooling ground for many of Indonesia's brightest Muslims. 
 (There is little love lost, on the other hand, for Kuwait, whose price-busting oil policy hit Indonesia and other producers.) 
 Whether or not they support Saddam Hussein's call for a holy war, there is a feeling that Islam should be solid for Iraq. 
 Add in the poor world's anti-Americanism and the mixture is potent: no one was very surprised that a bomb was planted in the American ambassador's residence in Jakarta soon after the war began. 
 The demonstrators against the war in the streets of the capital are using the weapon of Islamic solidarity to have a go at the western powers, and some are indirectly critical of Mr Suharto, who is assumed to be the West's friend. 
 The 69-year-old president is well aware of the potential of Islam as a political tool, and during his 25 years in power has done his best to regulate the influence of Muslim politicians. 
 Muslim political parties were involved in regional rebellions during the rule of President Sukarno in the 1950s. 
 By 1973 Mr Suharto had forced the Islamic parties into a single body &mdash; the United Development Party, whose leaders were carefully screened. 
 This screening proved so uncomfortable for the group's largest component, the Nahdlatul Ulama (NU) that, in 1984, it pulled out of competitive politics altogether. 
 The NU, a conservative, village-based organisation, turned to school-building and social work instead. 
 Mr Suharto has been tempting it back into his orbit by, for example, encouraging a Chinese business group to help it set up a bank, thus giving the NU's members a useful stake in the economic largesse that the government can dispense.  
 Golkar, Mr Suharto's own political grouping, has also done its bit to co-opt Islam. 
 Its coalition of bureaucrats, soldiers and other groups includes Muslim youth organisations and Islamic advisory councils. 
 The Muslim organisations that remain outside the fold, such as Muhammadiyah, an NU group with modernist ideas, dare not dabble in politics. 
 (Nevertheless, Mr Suharto's step-brother, Probosutedjo, recently gave a lecture to a Muhammadiyah conference in which he argued the need to re-elect the president in 1992.) 
 Not content even with this level of political castration, Mr Suharto has instructed the security forces to keep a close watch on what is said in mosques. 
 Preachers are paid to speak about the wisdom of Pancasila, the state philosophy. 
 The army stamps with efficiency on any uppity religious leaders. 
 Soldiers wiped out a village in south Sumatra's Lampung province in 1989 because a zealot was thought to be preaching fundamentalism (it has emerged he was just griping about land ownership). 
 With the lucrative business contracts that used to keep the generals happy being diverted to Mr Suharto's children, his military power-base is developing cracks, although so far they are barely perceptible. 
 If the army is going to be troublesome, Mr Suharto needs the Muslim masses clearly on his side to ensure he will have his way in next year's election. 
 Even if he stands aside, which is unlikely, he will want to retain the privilege of picking his successor. 
 To this end Mr Suharto has a number of gifts to distribute. 
 One was handed out last week. 
 Pupils in state schools were given permission to wear the jilbab headscarves that are the badge of good Muslim women. 
 For years the headscarf was frowned upon and sometimes banned on the ground that it encouraged dissent among children of different religions. 
 State banks, much to their chagrin, have been ordered to provide cheap insurance for pilgrims to Mecca: some 800 Indonesians died in the haj last year. 
 The government has announced with great fanfare the formation of Islamic courts for Muslim marital and social disputes. 
 In fact, according to lawyers, the new courts are little different to the ones they replace, but they appear to be generally welcomed. 
 Such concessions are designed for the Muslims who make up Indonesia's poor rural majority. 
 More educated Indonesians, though, expect more sophisticated prizes. 
 With this in mind, Mr Suharto has encouraged the formation of the Indonesian Association of Muslim Intellectuals, a group of thinkers, many of them educated in the West and several of them cabinet ministers. 
 Mr Suharto has been criticised for having too many Christians in his circle, among them the defence minister, some of his economic advisers and Chinese tycoons who control four-fifths of the country's private industry. 
 The new association is a way of drawing attention to the Muslim technocrats around the president. 
 Thinking about the dilemma captured in simalakama legend, Mr Suharto has clearly decided that, if he has to make a choice between wooing the Muslims and placating the West over the Gulf, the Muslims will have his full attention. 
 The Americans do not like receiving frequent reports of pro-Iraqi demonstrations throughout the Islamic world. 
 But, like the anti-war protests even in America's ally Japan, they do not have any effect on the course of the war. 
 That being so, the West can shrug its shoulders and live with them. 
 For his part, Mr Suharto can tell himself that the war will not be a lasting problem. 
 Keeping his Muslims loyal will be.  
 The economies of South Korea and Singapore 
 When dragons stumble 
 FROM OUR SEOUL CORRESPONDENT 
 The Gulf war has hurt Asia's oil-hungry, export-dependent dragons. 
 For two of them, Korea and Singapore, self-inflicted wounds are hurting more 
 THE juicy news in the cabinet reshuffle announced this week by South Korea's President Roh Tae Woo was a &dollar;1m-plus bribery scandal that involved the arrests of a presidential aide, several legislators and the chairman of a big conglomerate, and the dismissal of the construction minister. 
 The more significant news was that the government's chief economics officer, Lee Seung Yun, the deputy prime minister for economic planning, also lost his job, for unrelated reasons. 
 But what were those reasons? 
 South Korea's economy grew last year at a real rate of 9.2%. 
 If this is failure, what miracles will Choi Gak Kyu, Mr Lee's successor, be expected to perform? 
 None, by Korean standards. 
 The government is predicting real GNP growth of 7% this year, and Mr Choi will not be blamed even for such a &bquo;disappointing&equo; figure. 
 He will, however, be expected to do something about the severe imbalances that are masked by the wonderful overall figures for economic growth. 
 The won is high. 
 Exports, which used to be the engine of growth, are down and imports are way up &mdash; by so much that in 1990 Korea experienced its first current-account deficit in five years. 
 Inflation is zipping along. 
 The main explanation for all this is a money supply growing faster than anything else in Korea. 
 Until the 1980s Korea was in chronic current-account deficit; in 1986 it went into surplus. 
 Between 1985 and 1989 the dollar value of exports more than doubled; planners excitedly began to talk about Korea becoming a creditor nation. 
 The excitement ended last year, when higher wages, an overvalued currency and lower productivity growth took their toll. 
 Measured by the movement of the real effective exchange rate, Korean goods suffered a 22% loss in competitiveness from the end of 1985 to mid-1989. 
 It is not surprising that the value of exports grew by a mere 3% in 1990. 
 On the other side of the trade ledger, the booming domestic economy drew in 15% more imports last year than it had done in 1989. 
 Capital-goods imports, many of them for huge petrochemical projects, rose 14% in 1990. 
 The bill for imported energy was up by 42%. 
 The net result: a current-account deficit last year of &dollar;2.1 billion, and of &dollar;1.8 billion in January alone this year. 
 Domestic spending is not letting up, which is proving a decidedly mixed blessing for Korean industry. 
 Many companies unable to make it in tougher foreign markets had no such problems in the forgiving local market. 
 A lot of last year's unexported electronics gear now sits on crowded shelves in Seoul's small apartments. 
 Meanwhile, building companies have been stretched to the limit by the unslaked thirst for housing. 
 Strong demand helped push up consumer prices by an official 8.6% last year and, because of price increases by utilities, 2.1% in January alone this year. 
 But Korea's price index is a notoriously manipulated figure, and the educated guess in Seoul is that inflation is now in the mid-teens. 
 Naturally, employers are now facing yet another round of difficult wage negotiations. 
 Annual wage increases for manufacturing workers ran at around 20% for the three years preceding 1990. 
 Settlements were lower last year, but many bosses are convinced that, despite the government's call for single-digit increases, the high inflation rate means that wage negotiations this spring will be back to the old pattern. 
 Instead of exhorting virtue, the government might try to do something that is in its power, about inflation. 
 Over the years Korea's fast economic growth, unlike Taiwan's, for example, has done little to boost inflation. 
 However, inflation broke rank in the mid-1980s, when monetary policy was allowed to become too loose. 
 Since 1985 growth in the M2 measure of money has averaged 19% a year. 
 The government has not done much to restrain it. 
 A campaign against &bquo;luxury&equo; imports and severe tax penalties for property speculation have reduced some of the speculative fervour. 
 But the occasional &dollar;500m-worth of speculative trading on the Korean Stock Exchange on a single day &mdash; as happened on January 17th &mdash; and a booming kerb market make it clear that a great deal of loose cash is still swirling around. 
 Monetary growth was last seriously squeezed in 1984, during the autocratic tenure of President Chun Doo Hwan. 
 Korea's present crop of elected politicians have so far lacked the stomach for a war on inflation. 
 It seems improbable, but perhaps the affable-looking Mr Choi can convince them one is needed.  
 India 
 Inseparable 
 FROM OUR INDIA CORRESPONDENT 
 THE puppeteer is unhappy with his puppets. 
 Rajiv Gandhi, on whose Congress Party the minority government of Chandra Shekhar depends, appeared this week to be on the point of withdrawing his support. 
 But the speculation died on Tuesday when Congress announced that it would support the government in a financial debate in parliament starting on February 21st. 
 Mr Gandhi's manoeuvrings &mdash; which included four visits to the president, who can dissolve parliament &mdash; appear to have been designed to lure supporters from Mr Shekhar and from the previous prime minister, V.P. Singh. 
 Join Congress, Mr Gandhi seemed to be saying, and create a party strong enough to have a clear majority. 
 Congress and its allies are 50 short of a majority in parliament. 
 However, it soon became clear that fewer than 30 defectors would be available and that they would demand an unacceptable political price. 
 So the puppets will dance on, but Mr Gandhi will withdraw even further from public sight as their master. 
 One reason is the state of the economy. 
 Another is that he disapproves of Mr Shekhar's attempts to talk to terrorists in Punjab and Kashmir on terms that could threaten the unity of the country. 
 He is upset with the prime minister for not trying harder to create a non-aligned peace formula to end the Gulf war. 
 Lastly, Mr Gandhi has been critical of the decision to let American aircraft refuel in India on their way to the Gulf. 
 Indian Muslims, wooed by Congress, have been especially angered. 
 Mr Shekhar has managed to avoid a diplomatic row with America by quietly persuading President Bush to withdraw his request for permission. 
 Sooner or later, however, Mr Gandhi will decide to cut the puppets' strings and bring on another election. 
 But when? 
 Should he wait for a year, by which time the quarrel between Hindus and Muslims over the disputed Ayodhya mosque will have cooled down? 
 Or will he by then be associated in the public mind with the troubles of the economy? 
 The annual rate of inflation is running at almost 13%. 
 India's foreign-exchange reserves have been severely eroded by high oil prices and the loss of remittances from workers in Kuwait and Iraq. 
 Credit from commercial banks, usually &dollar;3m-4m a year, has dried up. 
 India's foreign-exchange reserves would have disappeared had it not borrowed &dollar;1.8 billion from the IMF in January. 
 Even that will be used up within a few months, when further recourse to the IMF will be inescapable. 
 With an election to fight, the last thing Mr Gandhi wants to defend is a dose of IMF discipline. 
 When negotiating its first IMF loan, the government agreed to trim its deficit in 1991&ndash;92 to 6.5% of GDP, down from 8.3% this year. 
 This will involve new taxes and a cut in subsidies, including the huge fertiliser subsidy regarded as critical in the farming areas that hold most of the voters. 
 The alternative would be to slash public spending, a policy that few Indian politicians of any persuasion favour. 
 Mr Gandhi is said to be horrified by the stiff budget in prospect. 
 The budget is due now, but it has been postponed for three months. 
 To tide it over, the government will seek from parliament a limited spending authority. 
 This will give Mr Gandhi a little time to consider his strategy. 
 The IMF is likely to refuse to lend any more money until the budget is settled, but the government hopes it will just about manage, helped by lower oil prices. 
 Some of Mr Gandhi's advisers doubt whether the party can win an election in the near future. 
 They say Congress might be wiser to team up with Mr Shekhar and any other small party willing to join a conventional coalition government. 
 The prime minister clearly thinks this is an excellent idea. 
 Mr Gandhi is far from sure.  
 Hollywood east 
 FROM OUR SOUTH-EAST ASIA CORRESPONDENT 
 LIKE Korea, Singapore has economic problems that most other countries can only envy. 
 Last year real GNP grew by 8.5%, and inflation was only 3.4%, lower than anywhere in Asia except Japan and Malaysia. 
 Growth this year is expected to be a tolerable 5%. 
 Even so, the managers of the island state's economy are fretting. 
 Their worries are easier to understand if you recall how much Singapore depends on foreign trade. 
 Last year exports equalled nearly 160% of the country's GDP. 
 Singapore has had better luck than  Hong Kong  at diversifying its export markets; but America is still a big one, and America is in recession. 
 It does not help that the Singapore dollar has been appreciating against not only the greenback but also the currencies of Singapore's three main trading rivals: Hong Kong, Taiwan and Korea. 
 The lion's share of Singapore's exports is produced by the 3,000-odd foreign companies that have set up on the island. 
 Its future depends on continually convincing these companies, and others yet to take the plunge, that it is the best place in South-East Asia from which to do business. 
 Many of them care less about the exchange rate than about what is shown on the chart on the right. 
 Over the past decade productivity in Singapore has risen fast, but not nearly as fast as nominal wages. 
 Singapore's trouble is that as soon as its economy starts to grow by more than 6&ndash;7%, the labour market tends to get tight. 
 This did not happen during the golden years of 1966&ndash;80: over that period GNP grew by an average of 10.4% a year and the workforce by 4.7%. 
 But during the 1990s the workforce is expected to grow by only 0.5&ndash;0.7% a year. 
 In the mid-1980s the government tried, disastrously, to deal with the labour shortage by increasing employers' contributions to the Central Provident Fund (the compulsory government-run pension scheme). 
 More expensive labour, the reasoning ran, would force the shutdown of sweat-shops, leaving only those businesses that could add plenty of value. 
 The economy did not appreciate being forced up-market; it went into a brief recession. 
 In 1986 the government reversed itself and cut employers' contributions to the fund (though they have since been allowed to rise again). 
 Now the government is trying another policy designed to achieve the same end. 
 At every opportunity senior ministers tout the idea of a &bquo;growth triangle&equo;, with Singapore at the apex, the Malaysian state of Johore to the north, and northern Sumatra and a string of Indonesian islands to the south. 
 The idea is picking up speed. 
 The first stage of a 60,000-hectare (150,000-acre) industrial park, in which the Indonesian government has invested &dollar;570m, has just opened on the Indonesian island of Batam. 
 The aim is to encourage a process that has already started: a shift of labour-intensive manufacturing away from Singapore to its lower-cost neighbours. 
 The thinking is that once all the mucky bits have been moved out, Singapore's well-educated workforce will specialise in research and development, marketing, finance and other services. 
 The tricky part will be to squeeze from service industries alone the entire 4% of annual productivity increases that the government wants for the economy as a whole. 
 Consider financial services, for example, which already account for nearly a third of GDP. 
 As more foreign banks and fund managers have arrived in Singapore, wages for experienced staff have risen sharply, as have office rents. 
 But, as banks all over the world know, higher wages and more computers often fail to result in higher productivity. 
 Perhaps the most intriguing question is how Singapore will fare with some new service industries. 
 It hopes to become a regional centre for medical care. 
 It also has ambitions to displace Hong Kong as the Hollywood of Asia. 
 The tycoon Deacon Chiu is building three film studios at his Tang Dynasty Village, which is due to open in the middle of this year. 
 The Singapore Broadcasting Corporation is building a further nine film and  television  studios in a complex to be called Television World. 
 Can this tightly-controlled society churn out inspired film producers? 
 INTERNATIONAL 
 The tranquillising of Kenya 
 FROM OUR EAST AFRICA CORRESPONDENT 
 THE old leader of Kenya's opposition announces a new and certainly illegal party. 
 He is not detained. 
 He is not even denounced by the government. 
 His plan draws no crowds into the streets. 
 The tranquillity seems odd after the demonstrations, riots and arrests that beset Kenya last year. 
 President Daniel arap Moi's Kenya African National Union (KANU) has learnt to tread more softly, to ignore rather than  lambast  its opponents, and to appear at least to consider political reform. 
 When Oginga Odinga's new party was announced on February 13th, it went unmentioned by local journalists. 
 Last year's riots, by contrast, were eagerly reported. 
 In the months leading up to them, KANU barons competed to insult multi-party advocates. 
 This helped transform a small disturbance into a full-blown campaign. 
 So did the mysterious attack on the home of a leading multi-party proponent. 
 So did the government's unapologetic and violent demolition of slums. 
 Unexpectedly, after activists had been arrested and street violence abated, the ruling party stopped besieging itself. 
 It forbore from interfering in August when the funeral of a dissident cleric (killed in what appears to have been a genuine road accident) turned into an anti-government rally. 
 It sent a special commission round the country to sound out grievances from the general public. 
 And it cleverly let pressure dissipate by allowing several months pass before revealing the commission's findings. 
 These recommended new electoral rules but left unchallenged KANU's supremacy. 
 Dozens of people had explained the need for a real opposition, but the commission simply ignored the issue. 
 It merely said that the president had never told it to question Kenya's one-party system. 
 The commission was denounced as cosmetic. 
 But the riots were four months past, the party was at least trying to seem reasonable, and Kenya's habitual political somnolence won the day. 
 This owes as much to the country's past success as to the ruling party's new tact. 
 A healthy economy in the 1960s and 1970s created a sizeable and conservative urban middle class. 
 It does not like riots. 
 Slum youths hurled bricks and fired shops not in support of Jeffersonian ideals, but because of their poverty. 
 The frightened middle class stayed home and stopped grumbling aloud. 
 A dose of old-fashioned repression dealt with some of the bold exceptions. 
 The two main leaders of the multi-party movement, arrested last July on the eve of the riots, are still held without charge. 
 The wife of one says her husband has been denied proper access to lawyers and medical care. 
 Thirteen others arrested during the ferment are being brought before the courts in two batches. 
 In both, defendants say they were tortured in detention; one says he was kidnapped from neighbouring Uganda. 
 Internal security police still dog real or imagined opponents, though not so blatantly as last year. 
 A few brave magazines take the government to task. 
 A few brave lawyers continue to represent the imprisoned dissidents, and to speak of human rights. 
 A semblance of opposition helps Kenya's case with the foreign donors without whom it cannot prosper. 
 It no longer indulges in slanging matches with the American embassy, which had hinted that Kenya's aid might suffer if it did not tolerate an opposition. 
 In return the Americans this month unblocked &dollar;5m in military aid that had been held up after last year's arrests. 
 Continued tact may prise money from other capitals. 
 Kenya needs it. 
 The main foreign-exchange earner is, or has been, tourism. 
 But the Saddam effect has emptied some hotels, crippled others, and brought predictions of dismal earnings this year. 
 The coffee industry, until tourism's rise the country's biggest earner, is in semi-collapse. 
 The shilling is sliding against hard currencies. 
 Inflation, around 12%, is lowish but bothersome. 
 Economic distress need not bring unrest. 
 Intrigue might. 
 The killing a year ago of Kenya's foreign minister, Robert Ouko, is still unsolved. 
 His burnt and tortured body was found on a brushy hill near his home in western Kenya. 
 The government refuses to release a Scotland Yard report on the death, and is instead running its own commission of inquiry. 
 The dead man's brother has gone to ground. 
 Lavish press coverage keeps the issue before the public. 
 The government says it had nothing to do with the case. 
 Kenya's tranquillity could vanish if it were shown to be involved: the killing prompted the first of last year's riots. 
 Meanwhile the government sometimes betrays its old paranoia. 
 This month the ruling party's organ absurdly accused Uganda of planning an invasion, inciting a ritual round of denunciation from party leaders. 
 Mr Moi himself occasionally gives off whiffs of his old sense of encirclement. 
 He has called for secret police to track down those spreading rumours of early elections, and recently warned golfers (who include many rich Kenyans) against anti-government talk on the fairways. 
 His insecurity will persist so long as he bottles up change, no matter how well his ruling party behaves.  
 Peru 
 Free to be poor 
 FROM OUR CORRESPONDENT IN LIMA 
 PRESIDENT Alberto Fujimori is striving both to stabilise the economy and to lead the country back into the international financial fold. 
 Everybody feels the pinch. 
 Recession is guaranteed for several months to come by higher taxes, higher interest rates and an exchange rate depressed both by a squeeze on the supply of local currency and by a surfeit of dollars from the booming trade in cocaine paste. 
 Times being hard, the vicious squabbles that have plagued Peru since the 1960s have broken out again, between raw-material exporters (who want freer trade) and manufacturers (who want still more protection). 
 To make things worse, after six months of stringent government austerity, the inflation rate for the month of January was almost 18%. 
 Last week, seven months after taking office, Mr Fujimori therefore reshuffled his cabinet. 
 The new finance minister, Carlos Bolona, was educated at Oxford and is as financially orthodox as they come in Peru. 
 He is expected to hasten Peru's rapprochement with the IMF, even as Mr Fujimori, the politician, hints at new measures to &bquo;avoid recession&equo;. 
 A new industry minister, Victor Joy Wa, took a third tack, announcing to startled industrialists that he will do away with all privileges for all manufacturers save exporters, who can expect reimbursement of taxes that &bquo;should not be exported&equo;. 
 Mr Fujimori's manoeuvrings with his ministers remain enigmatic. 
 But he clearly dislikes &bquo;mercantilists&equo;. 
 The word is much used by his closest adviser, Hernando de Soto, author of &bquo;The Other Path&equo; &mdash; a celebrated study of Peru's huge and dense informal sector of street vendors, cottage industries and red tape. 
 The message from Mr de Soto's Liberty and Democracy Institute (largely financed by contributors in the United States) is that vested interests with privileged access to the state (that is, mercantilists) hinder development and foment social discontent. 
 Mr Bolona, the new finance minister, is a former head of the institute's economics department. 
 Mr de Soto tells the president that it is not just the size of Peru's state sector, which includes several hundred companies as well as the ministries, that burdens the people via the fiscal deficit. 
 He argues that most harm is done by the state's imperviousness to ordinary Peruvians. 
 Mr Fujimori has now promised that new laws will be debated in advance by the general public. 
 For a start, the public will be invited to revise a plan that would liberalise controls on direct foreign investment and allow investors to repatriate all their profits. 
 Most political analysts think Peru's main problem is that it is deeply divided, by race, by geography and by extremes of income. 
 They detect something phoney in Mr de Soto's utopia of consensus, and something unconvincing in Mr Fujimori's commitment to it. 
 His real style, they believe, is authoritarian and his policies excessively sympathetic to the armed forces. 
 Mr de Soto was much offended when one of these commentators labelled him Rasputin. 
 But Mr de Soto goes down well in Washington, where he has helped persuade the authorities to take the previously unknown Mr Fujimori seriously. 
 Mr Bolona is equally welcome in financial circles in North America, where he worked for a time as a consultant on Latin American debt. 
 Some well-informed people suggest that the Americans may have played a discreet role in last week's cabinet reshuffle. 
 If so, it suggests that liberal policies will be implemented in Peru at least for a few months this year, whatever the general public thinks.  
 South Africa 
 Trial and error 
 FROM OUR SOUTH AFRICA CORRESPONDENT 
 IT SHOULD have been a good week. 
 On February 15th President F.W. de Klerk announced that most of the remaining obstacles to constitutional negotiations with the African National Congress (ANC) had been cleared away. 
 But the previous day a judge had adjourned the trial of Winnie Mandela, wife of the ANC's leader, who faces charges of kidnapping and assault. 
 One witness had disappeared, two more had been intimidated; doubts were aroused about the ANC's commitment to the rule of law. 
 Mr de Klerk is making progress, but towards what? 
 The basis of the new accord is the agreement of last August, whereby the ANC undertook to suspend its 30-year armed struggle &bquo;and related activities&equo;. 
 Did those words imply a halt to recruiting and training guerrillas, as well as to shooting and bombing? 
 The government insisted that they did. 
 The ANC said it had agreed to a ceasefire, nothing more. 
 The accord spells things out a bit. 
 It forbids infiltration of insurgents and arms into South Africa, the training of guerrillas in the country, and the establishment of &bquo;underground structures&equo;. 
 It rules out incitement to violence and threats of armed action (what Mr de Klerk calls &bquo;war talk&equo;). 
 But the ink was hardly dry when the ANC asserted its right to train fighters outside South Africa and to seek new recruits inside. 
 Mr de Klerk gave warning that any hostile forces found on South Africa's borders would be dealt with firmly. 
 Still, the two parties have moved towards the round-table talks that both want &mdash; although the government calls them a multi-party conference, whereas the ANC looks forward to an all-party congress, to be followed eventually by an elected constituent assembly. 
 The ill-feeling around Mrs Mandela's trial will make the talks tougher, especially because the ANC has identified itself closely with Mrs Mandela. 
 Each day, congress leaders have attended court, apparently on a roster. 
 Nelson Mandela is the most assiduous. 
 The trial is so entangled with the standing of the ANC that the right-wing Conservative Party has blamed the &bquo;state intelligence service&equo; for the disappearance of an important state witness; the party's argument was that the government wanted to persuade whites of the virtue of negotiations with the ANC, and found the trial embarrassing. 
 The government promptly got a court order requiring the party secretary and the editor of its newspaper to reveal their sources to a magistrate, or face indefinite imprisonment. 
 The state's missing witness, Gabriel Mekgwe, disappeared the night before he was due to give evidence against Mrs Mandela. 
 Two other state witnesses, Kenneth Kgase and Barend Mono, then said they were too frightened to give evidence. 
 All three men had allegedly been abducted by Mrs Mandela's bodyguards at the end of 1988. 
 Without their testimony the prosecution case could collapse when the trial reopens on March 6th. 
 If Mrs Mandela were convicted, her party would suffer. 
 An acquittal by default could be just as serious. 
 Mr Mekgwe was reportedly last seen in the company of three ANC men a few hours before he was due to give evidence. 
 The ANC's elliptical denial that it was &bquo;organisationally implicated&equo; has done little to calm white people's doubts about its commitment to the rule of law. 
 Mr de Klerk may, therefore, find it harder to get approval from the white electorate for whatever emerges from the negotiating table. 
 The ANC's peace agreement with Mangosuthu Buthelezi's Inkatha Freedom Party looks shaky too. 
 Since it was signed on January 29th there have been two massacres, with a total of at least 30 people killed. 
 The two organisations have established a joint Peace Implementation Committee, brought warring local leaders together for face-to-face talks, and jointly toured trouble spots. 
 Mr Mandela and Mr Buthelezi had promised to make joint visits to areas of tension. 
 They are still awaited.  
 Killer virus 
 FROM OUR CORRESPONDENTS IN LIMA AND LUSAKA 
 PROSPEROUS people rarely die of cholera. 
 The virus, whose main symptom is explosive diarrhoea, kills those who drink water mixed with sewage, are weak from disease or malnutrition, and do not get prompt care. 
 Until this year it had hardly occurred in Latin America since the first world war, when indentured workers stopped arriving from Asia. 
 By midweek it had killed 115 Peruvians in six weeks. 
 Peru's medical services have coped valiantly: untreated cholera can kill up to half of those infected, and the hospitals had treated 22,500 people for the disease. 
 But the capital's water supply leaks and its drains overflow. 
 The towns on the Pacific coast are crammed with people fleeing terrorism and hunger in the interior. 
 Sheltering in shanties, they have now been advised not to eat fish (so many will go hungry) and to boil water (yet they can scarcely afford fuel). 
 Neighbouring countries have closed their borders. 
 All Latin America fears that newly-poor Peru may have opened the door to the sickness of poverty. 
 Latin America's scare is Africa's sad normality. 
 Local outbreaks of cholera occur frequently in war-torn Angola and Mozambique, and sporadically elsewhere. 
 So far this month 465 deaths, and more than ten times as many suspected cases, have been reported in Zambia, black Africa's most urbanised country. 
 Like Peru, it has been made poorer by persistent misgovernment. 
 Last year there were some 200 cholera deaths in Zambia. 
 Rich countries help pay for medicine. 
 Sewers and wells might halt the disease, but cost much more. 
 From the Moluccas, Indonesia's eastern archipelago, 97 more cholera deaths have recently been reported. 
 There too the virus in people's bowels gets into other people's badly built water supplies. 
 The travellers' advice centre at the London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine says cholera vaccine is &bquo;of limited efficacy&equo;. 
 The best prevention is to boil or filter water, and eat only well-cooked food. 
 Being well-off helps too.  
 Trinidad 
 It's not funny 
 FROM A CORRESPONDENT IN PORT-OF-SPAIN 
 POLITICAL satire was out of fashion at this year's Trinidad Carnival. 
 An abortive coup last summer, and serious squabbling ever since, had taken the fun out of the island's favourite pool of jokes. 
 For once the economy was not to blame. 
 The only thing that has gone right for A.N.R. Robinson's National Alliance for Reconstruction (NAR) since its election with a huge majority in 1986 was Saddam Hussein's war. 
 The Iraqis invaded Kuwait the day an uprising by local &bquo;Muslimeen&equo; collapsed. 
 The rebels &mdash; whose version of Islam is North American rather than Arabian &mdash; went to jail, and the outside world forgot about them. 
 Trinidadians, disgusted by their violence (they captured Mr Robinson and shot him in the leg), nevertheless reckoned that poor people had a lot to grumble about, as the government slashed away at public spending to rectify past extravagance. 
 As the oil price rose, so did oil production. 
 The government could afford a slight relaxation of its austerity. 
 Devaluation and lower real wages helped exports. 
 The sugar crop was good. 
 Even tourism has held up, despite travel scares. 
 The government prudently used most of its bonus to rebuild the foreign-exchange reserves; it also restored the 10% cut made last year in public-sector salaries, and raised pensions by 5%. 
 More riskily, the budget announced in December was based on the assumption that the oil price would average &dollar;22 a barrel for the year; it is not much more than &dollar;17 now. 
 Nobody thanked the prime minister. 
 Junior ministers have been inviting the sack by asking him to resign. 
 According to the opinion polls, 60% of the electorate thinks he should have gone last August. 
 It is a bitter contrast with the mid-1980s, when the impatience of the multiracial middle class with the country's bad old habits gave birth to the NAR. 
 Trinidad's middle class, thinned by emigration, is small; most of its members are civil servants, recruited from across the country's racial spectrum. 
 Now they are impatient with a government that cut their pay by 10% (even if it restored the cuts later). 
 Multiracialism is not what it was, and the NAR has little support among the (largely Indian) rural sugar workers, or among the (mainly black) urban poor. 
 Soon after the party took office, many of its Indian supporters moved out to form their own United National Congress. 
 Black people are now moving back to the People's National Movement, which ruled for 30 years before Mr Robinson came to power. 
 It won the latest by-election, to replace a respected minister killed in the attempted coup, in a middle-class suburb of the kind Mr Robinson once fared best in. 
 The prime minister is taking the blame for the pain of trying to cure the economy. 
 Despite recent improvements, unemployment is more than 20%, and real wages are lower than they were in the early 1980s. 
 Recession has brought back racial politics. 
 Parliament must be dissolved by the end of the year. 
 Mr Robinson's one consolation is that in Tobago, his fief, Indian voters are rare. 
 EUROPE 
 Oscar for Babar 
 FROM OUR PARIS CORRESPONDENT 
 TEENAGE mutant turtles are already old hat in France. 
 A 61-year-old French elephant is all the rage: Babar is back. 
 The gentle green-suited elephant is everywhere &mdash; on dressing gowns, duvet covers, nappies, plates, carpets, soft drinks, television and now in a feature film, &bquo;Le Triomphe de Babar&equo;, which had its world premi&egrave;re in Paris last week. 
 Reassuring, virtuous and wise, Babar apparently provides a welcome escape from the violence and insecurity of the real world. 
 Babar was born into an upper-class French Protestant family one summer's evening in 1930. 
 To send her two young sons, Mathieu and Laurent, to sleep, C&eacute;cile de Brunhoff told them the story of a little elephant who left the forest to discover the town and learn the ways of men, before returning to his own idyllic land of the elephants to be crowned king. 
 The boy's father, Jean de Brunhoff, a painter, decided to illustrate the story. 
 &bquo;Histoire de Babar&equo; was published in 1931 and became an immediate hit. 
 Six other Babar volumes followed before Jean de Brunhoff's death at the age of 38 in 1937. 
 His son, Laurent, then aged 13, completed the colouring in the last two books. 
 After becoming a painter in his turn, Laurent decided to continue the Babar series, publishing his own first book in 1946. 
 In all, 30 Babar books have been written by the de Brunhoffs. 
 Translated into 17 languages, they have sold tens of millions of copies. 
 It was the launch of the animated Babar television series in 1989 that started the current Babar cult. 
 The 65 half-hour episodes (each costing &dollar;350,000) of the series were produced by a Franco-Canadian team in collaboration with Clifford Ross, an American painter and film producer who owns the world rights to Babar's animation and derived products. 
 (Some 300 Babar products are sold worldwide by 70 licensed companies.) 
 The same team has produced the new film. 
 The film and the television scripts were all sent for approval to Laurent de Brunhoff, who now lives in Connecticut. 
 Although he had to make some concessions, he has declared himself by and large satisfied. 
 And they all lived happily in Celesteville.  
 Going, going, glasnost 
 FROM OUR MOSCOW CORRESPONDENT 
 THE current crackdown on Soviet press and television is, like so many of President Gorbachev's policies, a probably unworkable muddle. 
 Full censorship makes people mistrust the press. 
 Mr Gorbachev has three instruments that, he hopes, will make the press more pliant while falling short of complete censorship. 
 The first sounds like a rare disease: GUOT. 
 This is the body that, supposedly protecting state secrets, issues lists of forbidden subjects. 
 According to its boss, most newspapers have signed agreements with his agency. 
 The second instrument is control of publishing and broadcasting equipment. 
 The Communist Party and various affiliates control nearly all Soviet printing presses and broadcasting stations. 
 Komsomolskaya Pravda, which has emerged as the most informative of all Soviet newspapers because it runs articles others refuse to print, depends on the Pravda printing house, which is owned by the party. 
 It has been reduced from six to five issues a week. 
 The editor of Ogonek complains that his reform-championing magazine is now hardly distributed outside large cities. 
 Control of broadcasting is even more complete. 
 The new head of Soviet state television and radio, Leonid Kravchenko, says he was appointed to do the president's bidding and thinks his job is to ensure that state television does not criticise the state. 
 Acting on this belief, he has: taken one of the most outspoken current-affairs programmes, &bquo;Vzglyad&equo; (Outlook), off the air; confiscated the property of the independent news agency Interfax, which was saved from closure only by the intervention of Boris Yeltsin and the Moscow city council; suspended a free-thinking television news show called &bquo;TSN&equo;; and consigned Radio Russia, Mr Yeltsin's mouthpiece, to a frequency where most of the population cannot hear it begin its broadcasts with phrases like &bquo;In another move reminiscent of Stalinism, President Gorbachev today&hellip;&equo; 
 Mr Kravchenko will not stop there. 
 At the beginning of February, his organisation, formerly a government department, was turned into a nominally independent company. 
 The significance of this is that the head of it, who had the status of a minister, need no longer be approved by the Soviet parliament, with the potential embarrassment of being rejected. 
 More insidiously, the change is a cover for sacking journalists who do not share his idea of what a state broadcasting company should be. 
 The only employee of this company so far is Mr Kravchenko himself. 
 He will decide who else will be employed. 
 The third instrument of control is self-censorship. 
 &bquo;Vzglyad&equo; and &bquo;TSN&equo; were singled out because they were among the few television programmes willing to challenge Mr Kravchenko. 
 In contrast, the main evening news programme, &bquo;Vremya&equo;, has voluntarily lapsed into stirring stories about tractors. 
 This instrument of control, however, is the least effective of the three because, in contrast to the good old days, parts of the press are refusing to be browbeaten. 
 Newspapers like Moscow News and Nezavisimaya Gazeta (Independent Newspaper) busily report what the president does not want to hear. 
 On January 17th, the day after Mr Gorbachev called for the suspension of a new law designed to guarantee press freedom, Nezavisimaya Gazeta published a white space on its front page captioned: &bquo;This is what Soviet newspapers will look like after political censorship is reimposed.&equo; 
 At the government-controlled newspaper Izvestia, the staff threatened to go on strike when their editor, who is a Kravchenko-like conservative, tried to get rid of his liberal deputy by giving him a cushy job as Madrid correspondent. 
 The conflict reached heights of black farce when the editor told a parliamentary meeting that his staff was betraying him, and ended his speech by having a heart attack. 
 All this suggests that gentle pressure will not work on the press. 
 Journalists who refuse to toe the line will have to be sacked. 
 But if they are, Mr Gorbachev's policy of trying to find a pliant press that people trust will also have failed. 
 Partial censorship will become complete censorship.  
 Reform in Eastern Europe: Hungary 
 Italy on the Danube 
 FROM OUR BUDAPEST CORRESPONDENT 
 Inefficient government and public services at the top, hard work and good entrepreneurship at the bottom: could Italy, we wonder in the third of our occasional articles on the good news from Eastern Europe, be a model? 
 HUNGARY has nearly run out of misfortune. 
 Economic statistics are losing their credibility and capacity to depress. 
 The four harbingers of East European apocalypse &mdash; the collapse of the Soviet Union as a trading partner, dear oil, government paralysis and civil disorder &mdash; visited last year and may have already done their worst. 
 When the gloom lifts, Hungary's famous pessimists will be surprised to discover how much has actually been going right. 
 Official Hungary is not a pleasant place to live in, say the statisticians: GDP fell by 5% in 1990 after a decade of near-stagnation. 
 Yet the officially measured real consumption in the past two years has been stronger than it should have been if the official measurement of GDP were accurate. 
 That suggests that the official measurement is wrong. 
 Count in private-sector output, much of which the statistics ignore, and the depression evaporates. 
 In unofficial Hungary, the private (mostly black) economy may provide 25&ndash;30% of GDP, says Istvan Gabor, a professor at the Budapest University of Economics. 
 That is up from 16&ndash;18% a decade ago and the share is growing fast. 
 Mr Gabor estimates that national output is roughly stable. 
 It just does not look that way sometimes because there are as many as three times more losers than winners from the economic transformation. 
 These losers make up the core of the 74% of Hungarians who in a recent opinion poll said they thought the economic situation had worsened. 
 But the winners make up with the size of their winnings what they lack in numbers. 
 The first Rolls-Royce went on sale in Hungary recently, joining the many Mercedes and BMW cars that have recently flooded the country, particularly in 1989. 
 Even after increases in customs duties staunched the flow, 27,000 cars were imported privately in 1990, over half bought by customs-exempt &bquo;invalids&equo;. 
 A typical Mercedes-owner would live in the hills of Buda, in one of the luxury apartment houses studded with satellite dishes that are constantly springing up. 
 Nearby is a new little grocery store selling expensive avocados, bottled prawns and kiwi fruit. 
 Only the dilapidated roads remind the visitor that this is Eastern Europe. 
 The depression is one myth; the sluggishness of privatisation another. 
 Bela Kadar, the minister of international economic relations, claims that Hungary has been the recipient of half of all recent foreign investment in Eastern Europe. 
 Most of the money has gone into joint ventures, which now number over 5,000. 
 Joint ventures have been the main means by which about a tenth of Hungarian state companies have been touched by privatisation. 
 Goulash capitalism 
 Joint ventures account for only a small part of Hungary's company start-up boom. 
 The number of enterprises grew from 14,400 at the end of 1989 to 23,300 in the third quarter of 1990. 
 Cynics retort that these are mostly shops, selling western consumer goods and damaging the balance of payments. 
 Maybe, but at least it is Budapest rather than Vienna shopkeepers who benefit from Hungarians' urge to splurge; and the availability of a wide range of goods has encouraged people to hold forints, the Hungarian currency. 
 Trade with the Soviet Union has collapsed since the new year, when hard currency replaced the rouble as the main medium of transaction. 
 The Hungarian trade ministry advises firms not to export to the Soviet Union without first getting bank guarantees (so far, few companies have managed to obtain one). 
 Officials reckon these will appear only after Moscow and the republics settle budget differences. 
 Until then, exports are on hold. 
 But it matters a lot less than it used to. 
 Hungary's trade with the Soviet Union accounted for 30% of total trade in 1980 but about 20% in 1990. 
 What is more, the volume may have reached bottom. 
 Laszlo Csaba, an economist at Budapest's Institute for Market Research, predicts that trade will recover later in the year as the opportunities for profit overcome bureaucratic obstruction. 
 In any event, shrinking East European markets have usefully pushed Hungarian companies westwards. 
 A 10% increase in the volume of hard-currency exports mitigated a 26% decline in rouble exports in 1990. 
 The boom in hard-currency exports led Hungary's dollar current account to improve by a remarkable 4&ndash;5% of GDP. 
 The last resort of the habitual pessimists is to admit that Hungary's opportunities are great, but that the government is bound to muff them. 
 Without Jozsef Antall, the argument goes, the government is paralysed. 
 Witness last October's petrol-price protests, when ministers rushed around like headless chickens because the boss was ill in hospital. 
 Mr Antall's health has improved. 
 And economic policy now has clearer direction since Mihaly Kupa was appointed finance minister and made economics supremo. 
 But according to one central-bank official, not even the quality of government is a condition of economic success. 
 Ministers should draw up a budget and then pack up for the year. 
 Italy, he jokes, should be Hungary's model. 
 Indeed, the parallels are striking: cumbersome coalition government, tax evasion, distrust of the state, and shambolic public services and infrastructure. 
 That is the bad news. 
 The hope is that Hungary, like Italy, will wake up one day, count its black economy and find it is rich.  
 Is Germany really united? 
 FROM OUR BONN CORRESPONDENT 
 NEARLY five months after regaining its national unity, Germany seems as divided as ever. 
 Economics partly explains the paradox &mdash; capitalist boom in the west, quickening collapse in the east. 
 But the main problem goes deeper and will take longer to solve. 
 Even before unity day last October 3rd, the euphoria over the fall of the Berlin Wall had evaporated and new friction was emerging between the two Germanies. 
 Now, according to an opinion poll this month, nearly 90% of Ossis (easterners) feel like second-class citizens in the united country they voted and demonstrated for. 
 True, they have D-marks, though their pay is less than half that in the west, and in principle full rights under the constitution. 
 But they do not feel treated as partners. 
 Often they are regarded as a nuisance; sometimes, in Wessi (western) cabarets, as good for a snigger. 
 Are they just being over-sensitive? 
 That is one of the friendlier charges Wessis level at their  brethren  in the &bquo;new federal states&equo; (a description Ossis loathe because it slights the history of regions like Saxony and Brandenburg). 
 The answer is No. 
 Start with politics. 
 In the government formed by Helmut Kohl after the election in December, every main ministry stays in western hands. 
 The Ossis have been fobbed off with one middling portfolio, transport, and two lightweight ones. 
 True, they would have had a stronger showing had not their former prime minister, Lothar de Maizi&egrave;re, stepped down before the election amid charges (which he denies, and which an inquiry looks set to discuss) that he used to work for the former East German secret police. 
 But Ossis have even been denied sought-after representational jobs too, like president or vice-president of the Bundestag. 
 Of the eastern deputies who pipe up in parliament, some (like the eloquent former communist Gregor Gysi) are heard out with wrath, most only with amused disdain. 
 At regional level the western states have for months managed to wriggle out of paying more than a fraction of the growing unity bill. 
 Under pressure from the federal government and the eastern states &mdash; some of which threaten to go to the federal constitutional court unless they get a better deal &mdash; the pfennig-pinching westerners are now ready to put up an extra DM15 billion (&dollar;10 billion) over the next four years. 
 That is not the sacrifice it may seem, because the western states are raking in lots of extra tax revenue thanks to the boom fuelled by demand from the east. 
 Meanwhile the eastern states are sliding towards a budget deficit of DM50 billion this year and many towns there are nearly bankrupt. 
 The easterners need qualified staff at least as much as cash. 
 State and local authorities struggle on with a handful of experts, usually on loan from the west, and an army of communist-trained bureaucrats lacking the faintest idea how a market economy works. 
 The judicial system is in chaos. 
 The eastern states say they badly need an extra 4,500 judges, 1,000 state prosecutors and 1,300 lawyers &mdash; not least to deal with the hundreds of thousands of property claims flooding in from the west. 
 So far only 130 western judges have turned up &bquo;on loan&equo;. 
 This is not the support that might have been expected for fellow Germans stuck on the communist side after 1945. 
 There are exceptions: retired professionals keen to help; entrepreneurial youngsters with pioneer spirit. 
 But, in the main, westerners fear a spell in the east will mean a kink in their careers, or that life will be too grey (&bquo;not even a decent pub&equo;, groaned one civil servant back from an eastern town he decided not to work in). 
 Only 19% of western schoolchildren, according to a recent poll, want to make contacts with eastern pupils. 
 Why has there not been more response? 
 Partly for lack of leadership. 
 Mr Kohl seems worn out, as well he may be, after the helter-skelter dash to unity last year. 
 After refusing tax increases to help pay the unity bill, he has now agreed to them to help finance the Gulf war &mdash; from an Ossi viewpoint an odd order of priorities. 
 President Richard von Weizs&auml;cker, often able to set the tone, has been unusually reticent since the storm he created last year by urging that the government should move from Bonn to Berlin (an issue that remains undecided). 
 Could it be that the Germans in the west did not want unity after all, despite those opinion polls over decades showing they did? 
 Hardly. 
 But the united nation they had in mind, when they thought hard about it at all, was probably not what they have been landed with. 
 Instead of acquiring fairly smoothly a bigger version of the cosy old federal republic, with its powerful economy and low political profile, they have inherited an unknown country packed with problems and with people who have mostly turned out to be German-speaking strangers. 
 At the same time they are told they must shoulder bigger world responsibilities. 
 Their reaction, towards the east and to the Gulf war too, has been to pay up and keep their heads down. 
 Ossis, mostly baffled by the society they thought they wanted, expect a sympathy most Wessis seem unable to muster. 
 To the relief of its neighbours, Germany achieved unity with virtually no upsurge of nationalism. 
 To complete unity it needs not just a flow of money from west to east but a sense of national solidarity. 
 That may come eventually. 
 But it is conspicuously absent so far.  
 Turkey 
 Ozalland 
 FROM OUR TURKEY CORRESPONDENT 
 AN UNEXPECTED variant of pillow politics is forcing the Turkish president, Turgut Ozal, on to the defensive. 
 The trouble started with the decision of his wife, Semra, to stand for the powerful job of head of the Motherland Party in Istanbul. 
 Having publicly backed his wife's move, Mr Ozal now finds himself at odds with the party he founded and led for more than six years as prime minister. 
 Mrs Ozal's supporters &mdash; among them many of those who deserted the party en masse in the 1989 municipal elections &mdash; like her attempt to dislodge the Islamic conservative wing, which now controls the party in Istanbul. 
 The Gulf war has divided the Islamic right in Turkey. 
 So now, argue those who want the party to be modern and secular, is the time to act. 
 Mrs Ozal's detractors claim that her candidacy is an example of third-world dynastic ambitions in the Peron mode. 
 As if to prove the point, some of those crying nepotism loudest are themselves close members of the family. 
 Yusuf Bozkurt Ozal, the president's brother and a member of parliament, opposes his sister-in-law's move into politics. 
 The president has accused the defence minister, Husnu Dogan, a younger relation and an orphan brought up in the Ozal household, of being nothing short of a Brutus for opposing Semra's decision. 
 To many middle-class women, Mrs Ozal is no distant Eva Peron but someone able to overcome familiar problems &mdash; including a set of overbearing in-laws. 
 Others admire her brassy style. 
 She has boldly paraded her stocky figure at charity fashion shows and at one time was famous for wielding equally chunky Havana cigars. 
 Now no longer just a colourful first lady but a full participant in politics, Mrs Ozal is forcing not only the Motherland Party but her husband to declare where they stand. 
 Constitutionally, the Turkish president stands above party politics. 
 In practice, Mr Ozal keeps both cabinet and party on a short rein. 
 When he was prime minister, this meant holding the Motherland Party together by playing off its various factions against each other. 
 Now, as president, Mr Ozal intends (many argue, at the insistence of his wife) that the party's &bquo;liberal&equo;, free-market wing should be seen to dominate. 
 With just under six years of office still to run, Mr Ozal presumably calculates that the party needs his popularity much more than he needs the party &mdash; particularly if there is to be an early general election to take advantage of an alliance victory in the Gulf war. 
 But he must worry that if his wife does not succeed in the party elections scheduled for March, then his own authority will be badly diminished. 
 Mrs Ozal is not having it all her own way. 
 At one local headquarters she found the door literally locked, and one lunch was boycotted by the very party bosses she intends to oversee. 
 The Ozals, however, are determined to win through. 
 Mr Ozal will throw his presidential weight behind his wife's campaign, not least because his own future is now linked to hers.  
 Soviet Union 
 Yeltsin's last stand 
 FROM OUR MOSCOW CORRESPONDENT 
 THEY had been nit-picking for weeks. 
 How much airtime should Boris Yeltsin, Russia's president, get on state television? 
 When? 
 On what channel? 
 Should his interview be recorded or transmitted live? 
 The event, when it came on February 19th, was worth the wait. 
 After half an hour's question-and-answer, Mr Yeltsin suddenly began reading from a prepared text: 
 I gave warning in 1987 that it is part of Gorbachev's character to search for absolute personal power. 
 Everything he has done has been aimed at bringing the country to dictatorship, to presidential rule as they call it. 
 I distance myself from the position and policies of the president. 
 I call for his immediate resignation and the transfer of power to a collective body, the Council of the Federation&hellip; 
 I believe in your support, in the support of the peoples of Russia, and I hope for it. 
 The relationship between the Soviet Union's two dominant politicians here reached its nadir. 
 The reaction was swift. 
 The next day Pravda, the Communist Party daily, accused Mr Yeltsin of seeking a showdown with the president that was tantamount to wrecking the country. 
 The Soviet parliament voted the address unconstitutional and set up a special committee, dominated by Communist hardliners, to send a formal appeal to the Russian parliament. 
 That indicates what might happen next: a vote of no-confidence in Mr Yeltsin in his own parliament which, because that parliament is increasingly under the sway of Communist deputies, might pass. 
 Mr Yeltsin's appeal looks like a gesture of despair after his failure to influence the central government. 
 Mr Gorbachev has recently proved himself determined to ram through conservative policies. 
 The day before Mr Yeltsin's broadside, the new prime minister, Valentin Pavlov, confirmed to parliament that he was planning to increase retail prices by an average of 60%, with wages and benefits to rise 50% in compensation. 
 Although Russia, along with the Ukraine and Belorussia, opposes this plan, there is little it can do to stop it. 
 Mr Yeltsin has lost his top three economic ministers in the past three months. 
 All have resigned in despair at the Russian government's inability to influence the central government. 
 Mr Yeltsin's best hope was to persuade four of the largest republics &mdash; Russia, Belorussia, the Ukraine and Kazakhstan &mdash; to club together and outline the powers of the central and republican governments. 
 This too is ending in failure. 
 Kazakhstan's president has called for Mr Gorbachev's union treaty to be signed at once, with negotiations over the details to follow. 
 Mr Yeltsin has one more option. 
 He fell from power in 1987, resigning from the Politburo over the slow pace of reform. 
 He bounced back by winning an overwhelming election victory. 
 He might try to do so again. 
 Russian law allows the direct popular election of the president. 
 If he loses a vote of no-confidence in parliament, he could yet try to force such an election, appealing over parliament's head to the voters &mdash; as he did on television this week.  
 Britain's re-entry 
 FROM OUR BRUSSELS CORRESPONDENT 
 THE influence of Britain on the European Community sank to an all-time low in 1989 and 1990. 
 Britain's partners became so fed up with Margaret Thatcher's strident opposition to economic and monetary union (EMU) and to political union that she was left utterly isolated at last October's Rome summit. 
 But three months is a long time in Euro-politics. 
 John Major has ended Britain's isolation. 
 Suddenly other EC countries are interested in what the British have to say. 
 Together with his foreign secretary, Douglas Hurd, and his chancellor of the exchequer, Norman Lamont, Mr Major has shifted the style, the tactics and even, to some extent, the substance of Britain's European policy. 
 Britain's heavy involvement in the Gulf war has also helped to restore respect for its views. 
 The calm, friendly manner of Mr Major and his ministers has impressed their colleagues. 
 At a meeting of foreign ministers earlier this month Mr Hurd opposed a German plan to send emergency aid to Israel, on the ground that the right procedures had not been followed. 
 But when he saw that others liked the plan he refrained from blocking it. 
 &bquo;Next time he asks us for something, we will find it harder to say no,&equo; said one of those present. 
 Many European diplomats doubt that Britain's new style will lead to new policies. 
 Yet British policy has already shifted subtly. 
 Foreign Office officials gleefully admit to being freer to launch new ideas, particularly on security policy. 
 The Foreign Office has moved some way towards the French idea that the Western European Union (WEU) should become the Community's forum for defence policy. 
 Mr Hurd's speech this week in Luxembourg, which called for the European Council (as summits are known) to have strong links with a reinforced WEU, would not have been made in Mrs Thatcher's day. 
 And in other debates, such as that on the European Parliament's powers, there are hints that British intransigence may soften. 
 Even the Euro-sceptical Mr Lamont has shifted the official line on EMU a few inches. 
 He says he wants a compromise acceptable to Britain and its partners &mdash; which means he does not want to stop other countries moving towards EMU. 
 Although Britain opposes the idea of a single currency, its officials play an active part in discussions on how EMU might work. 
 The Treasury's recent draft treaty revealed new thinking on some of EMU's details, with, for instance, an option for the new central-banking institution to be independent of governments (a suggestion that Britain had opposed). 
 The combination of smoother style and slight changes of substance has allowed Britain to build different alliances on different topics. 
 Mr Major has made a special effort to patch up relations with Germany. 
 The two countries are at opposite sides of the argument on political union, yet Mr Major and Chancellor Helmut Kohl get on well and share similar centre-right views. 
 They agree that there should not be a currency union before there has been much more economic convergence within the Community. 
 When they met this month, Mr Kohl made it clear that he wanted an agreement on EMU that does not oblige Britain to accept a single currency before it is ready to do so. 
 Mr Major got off to a stickier start with President Mitterrand, who neglected to tell him about the Gulf peace plan that France was about to launch in mid-January. 
 But Britain's view of the future of the EC has more in common with France's than Germany's. 
 Britain and France both want to maintain the authority of national parliaments and governments. 
 Britain therefore likes the French idea that the European Council should take on a larger role at the expense of the commission. 
 France has talked sweetly of promoting use of the &bquo;hard ecu&equo;, as Britain has proposed, on the way to EMU (for France, any alternative to the D-mark is appealing). 
 France is backing a British plan for a new organisation to run co-operation on terrorism, drugs, visas and immigration. 
 Such things are now handled by informal working parties of national officials; these are, in Britain's view, too messy. 
 The European Council would give guidance to this set-up for &bquo;inter-governmental co-operation&equo; and, as with &bquo;European Political Co-operation&equo; in foreign policy, the commission would be allowed to sit in. 
 Federalist countries such as Belgium and Italy recoil from this idea, as they want interior-ministry work turned over to the EC. 
 Britain seldom agrees with Italy about anything. 
 But most EC members are now no longer ashamed of being seen to strike tactical alliances with Britain. 
 This is particularly true of Spain and Holland, which resent Franco-German dominance. 
 Spain likes parts of Britain's hard-ecu plan since it could slow moves to EMU. 
 Holland often teams up with Britain in discussions on foreign policy, since both want to avoid any weakening of NATO. 
 Denmark and Holland usually back Britain when it champions free-market causes; yet, like Britain, they want the common agricultural policy to go on subsidising their large farms. 
 None of this will stop the Franco-German alliance from remaining the Community's dominant force. 
 Britain is not about to start writing joint papers with other countries, as France and Germany regularly do together. 
 Its outlook will remain uniquely short-term, pragmatic, suspicious of grandiose institutional change. 
 But Britain's views now count. 
 START OF BRITAIN SECTION 
 Repossessed homes 
 Snapped down 
 ALMOST the only corner of the housing market showing any perkiness these days is the trade in repossessed homes. 
 The Council of Mortgage Lenders announced on February 14th that the number of people who lost their homes last year because they could not keep up their mortgage payments nearly tripled from the year before. 
 For a government committed to widening home-ownership, it is an embarrassment; for a family that is evicted, it is a personal tragedy. 
 For some estate agents, though, it is a boon. 
 Most repossessions take place within the first three years of taking out a mortgage. 
 They soared last year, particularly among people who bought property early in 1988, often on generous mortgages that stretched monthly payments to the borrowers' limits. 
 These limits were then overshot by month after month of interest rates above 14%. 
 Most borrowers did not anticipate this; indeed, a 1989 survey by the Office of Fair Trading shows that only 37% of borrowers gave any thought at all to the likely future movement of interest rates when they took out a loan. 
 Most mortgage lenders stress that they are not keen to repossess homes. 
 They usually wait until mortgage payments are between three and six months in arrears before seeking repossession orders. 
 By the time court orders are granted &mdash; some six to 12 months later &mdash; most families have moved out. 
 Only a few go through the final humiliation of meeting the bailiff at the door and watching him change the locks. 
 This reluctance of lenders to repossess homes owes little to sentiment: few lenders want to sell assets into a falling market. 
 Building societies are legally obliged to sell repossessed properties at the best possible price. 
 But different societies tackle this obligation in different ways. 
 Some are reluctantly accumulating properties in the hope that prices will firm up later this year; others are taking the best prices they can get, without waiting. 
 Hugh Dunsmore-Hardy, the president of the National Association of Estate Agents, reckons quick sales by the societies have definitely pulled down prices. 
 They have also caught the eye of estate agents. 
 Several have recently set up services specifically to deal in repossessed properties. 
 General Accident Property Services, the third-biggest estate agent, now has a division that it reckons sells around one-third of all repossessed properties. 
 As Maureen Freeman, a GAPS director, points out, repossessed homes are a good buy: they are already vacant, the owner will not change his mind and there is no precarious chain of buyers and sellers to hold things up. 
 Hurry on down 
 The agents insist, naturally, that they are out to get a good price. 
 But a much higher premium than usual is being put on a speedy transaction. 
 Norman Mazure, a London estate agent, set up a special unit two years ago with Stickley and Kent, a large London chain of agents, to deal mostly with repossessed homes. 
 He claims the unit gets 60% of its properties under offer within six weeks. 
 Last year it sold 2,000 properties; it expects this year's total to reach 3,500. 
 This cuts two ways for the evicted home-owner. 
 When he hands in his keys, he no longer owns the house; but he is still liable for interest on the loan, until the house is sold and the loan repaid &mdash; so he wants the sale to be quick. 
 But the price raised by an estate agent desperate for his commission is now all too likely to be lower than the original mortgage taken out by the borrower. 
 So unless the luckless borrower is covered by an indemnity policy, he will be landed with a bill to pay the difference. 
 And if the difference is big enough, he can end up still burdened with a hefty home-loan &mdash; and no home to show for it.  
 Grocer profits 
 While other retailers are dropping like flies, supermarkets are making fat profits. 
 The good times are unlikely to last 
 TODAY'S subtly-lit supermarkets, where loganberries nestle against kiwi-fruit, are a world away from Jack Cohen's &bquo;pile it high and sell it cheap&equo; Tesco's. 
 After the price wars of the late 1970s, when many supermarkets were still conspicuous mostly for their general ugliness and grubbiness, the big chains decided to invest their way out of trouble. 
 It paid off. 
 They introduced rigid quality control, centralised distribution and electronic tills. 
 With town centres increasingly congested and car-ownership rising fast, people were keen to shop outside town. 
 So the supermarkets (with the exception of Kwik Save) also started closing their high-street stores and building big edge-of-town stores. 
 A relaxation of planning rules under Margaret Thatcher made this expansion easier. 
 The supermarkets then found that they could charge bigger margins on goods that were peripheral to their core business, processed foods. 
 Shoppers liked the quality, the fresh fruit, the hot croissants and chilled meals. 
 They still expected to get cheap baked beans, but would pay over the odds for high-quality fresh food. 
 The price gap between the supermarkets and other retailers has been shrinking ever since. 
 Most surveys show that a basket of food still costs a bit less at a supermarket than it does at an independent grocer's; but The Economist did not find that this week. 
 Of an arbitrary 13 goods, five were more expensive in the independents, seven more expensive in Sainsbury's, and one (tinned tomatoes) cost the same. 
 White cabbage was selling for 12p a lb at the greengrocer's and 29p a lb in Sainsbury's. 
 Fresh food is the most extreme example of the change that has come over the shops. 
 Ten years ago, there were a few incidental boxes of onions in supermarkets; in the new-age groceries, the shopper is usually greeted at the door by a banquet of fresh fruit and vegetables glowing with health. 
 The supermarkets' muscle enables them to demand quality yet keep farmers' prices down, and the gap between what they pay and what they charge has widened. 
 According to Verdict, a retail-industry analyst, the gross margin on fresh foods has increased from 21% in 1986 to 28% in 1990. 
 For some items it is even greater. 
 John Ricks, a farmer near Colchester, says his onions cost 9p a lb wholesale; packing and transport costs 10p; they sell in the supermarket for 29p. 
 In paper bags, at the local independent, they cost 15p. 
 The speedy, low-inventory distribution systems that big retailers have invested in have made things even more comfortable. 
 The supermarkets get paid cash by the customer a few days after the goods arrive in their shops, while they pay their suppliers between one and two months after delivery. 
 Suppliers admit they get more stability than in the past, but some complain of ruthless use of retail muscle. 
 They say that supermarkets will overestimate next year's requirements and then force farmers to discount. 
 Why does the farmer not switch to another retailer? 
 &bquo;It isn't so easy,&equo; says one. 
 &bquo;You've invested capital to tie in with their distribution system. 
 And if you are recognised as a supplier of one, the others may not be interested. 
 They insist on loyalty.&equo; 
 The retailers argue that their life is not all that cushy. 
 Net margins on sales may be better than those of their foreign counterparts (see table), but they have to employ more capital to build the new prettily-lit, out-of-town shops that the British want. 
 American retailers' building costs are lower, they say, because the price of land is lower. 
 On the continent, planning controls are often so tough that retailers cannot build expensive new shops and are stuck with their ugly, cheap ones. 
 Yet British retailers still get a better return on their assets. 
 Of the big foreign chains, only America's Albertson's makes a similar return; all the continentals do worse. 
 Gerd Krampe, of Rewe Leibbrand, a German retailer, gave clear advice to a recent conference of British retailers on the question of expansion abroad: &bquo;You stay at home with your nice profits.&equo; 
 But if British food retailers are in clover, why does some foreign beast not intrude on their patch? 
 For one thing, there are highish barriers to entry. 
 Building an up-to-the-minute superstore costs around &pound;25m (&dollar;49m). 
 And until a company has the volumes, it will not be able to get the same good terms from suppliers. 
 A German retailer, Aldi, is trying to move in. 
 It has opened a dozen shops with an intriguing new concept &mdash; pile it high and sell it cheap &mdash; and plans a chain of 200. 
 It stocks a relatively small range of products and plans to hit the supermarkets in the processed-foods business. 
 But Aldi says it has had trouble: the Office of Fair Trading is investigating Aldi's claim that suppliers, frightened of affronting their main customers, have been giving it the cold shoulder. 
 A judgment is expected any moment; but even if the OFT decides in Aldi's favour, the matter will still have to be investigated further by the Monopolies and Mergers Commission. 
 It could be many years before the Department of Trade and Industry decided to take action &mdash; or not, as in the case of the brewers. 
 Long before then, though, market laws look likely to prompt changes. 
 The supermarkets are still expanding furiously and expensively. 
 On January 29th Tesco launched a rights issue to help finance an investment programme averaging &pound;900m a year for the next three years. 
 Sainsbury, which has concentrated on the south, has just opened its first store in the north-east and is moving into Wales and Scotland. 
 There are plenty of distant, though real, risks. 
 People's eating habits may change: as in America, take-aways may bite a chunk out of the market. 
 An environment-minded government may increase petrol tax. 
 This could discourage people from driving ten miles to buy their groceries. 
 And success will bring its own problems. 
 So far, they have grown without competing too much against each other. 
 But in three years' time Sainsbury will hit the North Sea. 
 Tesco may not be able to get planning permission for any more stores. 
 According to Ian Davis of McKinsey, a management consultancy, &bquo;they will inevitably end up competing with each other in their push for increased market shares.&equo; 
 It may be, too, that the small independents, squeezed for so many years, are starting to fight back. 
 In 1986&ndash;89, the average annual decline in their market share was around 1%; in 1989&ndash;90 it fell by 0.3%. 
 Not surprising, when the corner-shop grocer is selling cabbage for 40% of the supermarket price.  
 Enter a different world 
 DEPARTMENT stores are the pride of British retailing. 
 They may not be so for much longer. 
 On February 19th Harrods announced that it would sack 600 of its workforce, on top of 90 redundancies last month. 
 Lewis's, a provincial chain of department stores which employed 3,400 people, is in the hands of the receivers. 
 And Allders, a chain of 11 stores that also operates duty-free shops in many of Britain's airports, has been plagued by rumours of financial difficulty in recent weeks. 
 The recession is hitting the stores hard. 
 As house sales have slumped, so has spending on department-store specialities like furniture, carpets and electrical appliances. 
 The one buoyant retail sector has been food, but few department stores sell much of that. 
 Government statistics out this week show that sales for &bquo;mixed retail businesses&equo; have grown only half as fast as sales for all retailers in the past three years. 
 Harrods itself has other worries. 
 The row over the Fayed brothers' acquisition simmers on, thanks to the Bank of England's embarrassment over Harrods Bank. 
 (As the governor had to confess to a Commons select committee on February 19th, banks are not supposed to belong to people publicly castigated for past mendacity &mdash; as the Fayeds were, by inspectors from the Department of Trade and Industry in 1988.) 
 But Harrods's biggest concern must be the generally worsening climate for all department stores. 
 Between 1980 and 1990 their share of total retail trade fell from 5.2% to 4.5%, according to Verdict, a retail analyst. 
 Several factors underlie this decline. 
 Department stores tend to be based in city centres and are losing trade to out-of-town sites. 
 Some groups have been buying into the new sites &mdash; as House of Fraser, which owns Harrods, has done at Meadowhall in Sheffield &mdash; but such an expensive strategy requires cool nerves in the present recession. 
 Meanwhile, specialist retailers like Dixons, an electricals chain, and niche shops like Tie Rack have been paring away at the department stores' share of the high-street market. 
 The big stores used to enjoy some competitive advantage from running credit accounts; the credit-card boom has put paid to that. 
 And the nature of the department store &mdash; stocking a little bit of everything &mdash; puts them at a disadvantage compared with more specialised retailers when it comes to exerting leverage over suppliers. 
 The one chain that may yet escape the decline is the John Lewis (&bquo;never knowingly undersold&equo;) Partnership, which continues to outrun its rivals. 
 Its turnover has tripled in the past decade; analysts reckon it now sells some &pound;450-worth (&dollar;880) of goods per square foot each year, against an average of &pound;216 for all department stores. 
 But even John Lewis has been feeling the pinch. 
 Sales in its department stores in the year to January 1991 were only 6.4% higher, by value, than in 1989&ndash;90 &mdash; and plunged by 16% on the previous year in the first, snowy week of February.  
 Primary schools 
 A classroom revolution? 
 Primary schools are in the middle of a big shake-up. 
 Some of the results may surprise the government 
 YOUR local primary schools have never been busier. 
 Headteachers shuttle between special courses on the national curriculum and evening classes on managing budgets. 
 Teachers spend their breaks preparing lesson plans, and their evenings swotting up on jargon. 
 Staff rooms are littered with glossy guides to assessment targets and fiendish charts of the new curriculum. 
 Young enthusiasts chat about SAT, AT, INSET, KS, PoS, and, above all, NC. 
 Some schools are so overburdened by all this activity that they have been forced to draft in extra staff to deal with the more mundane aspects of education &mdash; like teaching children. 
 No wonder everyone is so busy. 
 Primary schools are pioneering the most far-reaching shake-up of education in living memory. 
 Since October 1989 teachers have been delivering the first stages of a new national curriculum; and in the early summer they will start testing (sorry, assessing) all seven-year-olds on the three core disciplines: mathematics, English and science. 
 As if all this were not enough, schools have started managing their own financial affairs. 
 Heads may have gone into primary teaching because they liked young children; no matter. 
 Now they have to spend their mornings planning budgets and their afternoons paying bills. 
 Is the upheaval worth it? 
 Supporters of the reforms (by no means all of whom are Tories) argue that the new curriculum will introduce a little rigour into the soppy world of sand pits and colouring books. 
 For too long, over-indulgent teachers have churned out children for whom reading is a challenge and writing a mystery. 
 Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Schools is more of a lap-dog than a rottweiler. 
 But in mid-February it complained that a fifth of primary schools are offering sub-standard teaching in reading. 
 It singled out the upper reaches of primary schools for particular criticism. 
 Most 11-year-olds are not being encouraged to develop advanced reading skills; a small but significant number are illiterate. 
 Primary schools, it argued, are failing to stretch older children. 
 Many parents put it less politely. 
 Opinions differ over whether standards have actually been falling. 
 Some psychologists point to a decline in the mid-1980s and blame new-fangled teaching methods; others insist that things have always been this bad. 
 But even the most optimistic pundits agree that British schools are dismal compared with many rivals abroad. 
 Standard tests of numeracy and literacy reveal that English 11-year-olds are as much as two years behind their contemporaries in Germany and Japan. 
 Although teachers flinch at such international comparisons, most of them are surprisingly enthusiastic about the national curriculum. 
 More uniform arrangements will allow good schools to flourish, they say, while forcing bad ones to mend their ways. 
 A national curriculum, they add, will allow children to move schools without utterly disrupting their education; and objective assessment will enable both teachers and parents to see how well a child is doing. 
 Teachers also confess that, for the first time, they now know what they are supposed to be teaching and (thanks to the elaborate assessment targets) how well they are teaching it. 
 The fact that primary schools now teach technology and science is an added bonus. 
 Those who can't, account 
 The local management of schools (LMS) initiative, however, is altogether more controversial. 
 The theory must have sounded wonderful to the think-tankers who dreamed it up. 
 By making money follow the pupil, LMS will encourage good schools and penalise bad ones; and by delegating budgets to individual heads, it will cut down on time-wasting bureaucracy. 
 Those who know the children best can decide whether to splash out on a part-time assistant or a fancy computer. 
 The intended beneficiaries of LMS are rather more sceptical. 
 Though heads are delighted to have more autonomy &mdash; they will now be able to hire a plumber without going through the town hall &mdash; many feel that they are being buried under a mountain of paperwork. 
 Educationalists agree (and experience shows) that headteachers who are actively involved in teaching can galvanise a school: but LMS is turning even the most committed among them into under-paid chartered accountants. 
 It is impossible to spend much time teaching Johnny to read if you have a budget of &pound;500,000 (&dollar;980,000) to worry about. 
 Small schools with a handful of teachers find budget-management particularly irksome. 
 But it is pupil-driven financing that really upsets the heads. 
 One headmistress gives a pungent summary of the prevailing philosophy: &bquo;Market forces are very dangerous when you are messing with children's brains.&equo; 
 She hints that teachers and local officials will do their best to blunt the impact of the market. 
 Local heads will not allow a school run by a friend to go under. 
 Even heads who do not share this cartel mentality may find that aggressive expansion is not worth the candle. 
 Additional pupils bring extra costs as well as extra cash. 
 Over-zealous expansion may be counter-productive as well as burdensome: a good school may cease to be a good school if its classes are overflowing and its playgrounds full of makeshift accommodation. 
 Besides, some heads like to lord it over local parents &mdash; particularly over the pushy ones. 
 Like National Health Service consultants, they treat waiting lists as a sign of status rather than a symptom of failure. 
 The children now embarking on the national curriculum will still be in school at the turn of the century. 
 Perhaps one day an inspired current-affairs teacher will ask them about the long-term impact of the 1988 Education Act. 
 The more mischievous may suggest that, as an exercise in the once-discredited art of nationalisation, it was a huge success; but as an attempt to apply market forces to public services it made little difference. 
 Old habits die hard.  
 Spring sprung? 
 HOW does the song go &mdash; &bquo;De spring is sprung, De grass is riz, I wonder when D'election is&equo;? 
 Something like that; Bagehot's synapses are not all they once were. 
 At any rate, this is the seasonal question for MPs, as February snow gives way to thin, unconvincing sunshine. 
 Most election-timing talk is nonsense or propaganda. 
 Tory planners think the Labour party is talking up a May or June poll, trying to bounce them into an election while interest rates are still high. 
 John Major would prefer to wait. 
 But many of his backbenchers are getting over-excited (which is their constitutional function). 
 And the cabinet is divided on the issue (which is its). 
 The truth is bland: Mr Major will call an election if the opinion polls suggest he cannot lose. 
 Otherwise, he will hang on. 
 The party machines, however, are being oiled and watered for an early poll. 
 The 20 groups of Tory MPs asked by Margaret Thatcher last year to write policy papers for the next manifesto have been told to hand in their work to Number Ten by the end of the month. 
 The chairman, Chris Patten, will shortly sit down with the new head of the Downing Street policy unit, Sarah Hogg, to write the first draft of Mr Major's manifesto. 
 Both the Tories and the Labour Party are frantically fund-raising. 
 The Tories' problems are, on paper, worse. 
 The party's accumulated deficit &mdash; made up roughly half-and-half of overdraft and term-borrowings &mdash; will be nearly &pound;10m by the end of this financial year. 
 Meanwhile, Central Office's non-election expenses are running at an annual &pound;12m or so. 
 A leading fund-raiser and one of the party's three treasurers, Lord Beaverbrook, has said the election campaign itself could involve spending &pound;20m. 
 Add it all together and &mdash; unless they are prepared to go deeper into debt &mdash; the Tories are hoping to raise anything up to &pound;42m. 
 This compares with just over &pound;15m raised for the 1987 election. 
 No one thinks that the party, with its umbilical connections to business, will fail to outspend Labour several-fold in the campaign; but Lord Beaverbrook and his fellow treasurers, John Cope and Lord Laing, have their work cut out. 
 In theory, the Tory constituency parties could come to the rescue. 
 The Wessex area alone, according to its treasurer, John Strafford, has &pound;3m in local-party bank accounts. 
 Across Britain, Tory associations have enough to pay off the Central Office deficit and still spend plenty on local campaigning. 
 In practice, they so mistrust the secrecy and alleged profligacy of Central Office that they refuse to shell out. 
 According to one insider, local associations have still paid only half the &pound;3m quota they were asked for in 1990 &mdash; leaving Lord Beaverbrook and friends increasingly reliant on donations from rich individuals. 
 But patrons with deep pockets will not forever carry on subsidising an organisation seen by the local parties as so ramshackle. 
 The most muttered-against official is the director of campaigning, John Lacy, though no one in the organisation expects him to go before the election. 
 Meanwhile, the most urgent task Central Office has been set is nearly complete &mdash; to turn the three-week campaign programme arranged for Mrs Thatcher into one suitable for Mr Major. 
 This has involved finding him venues for walkabouts and group discussions, where his staff think Mr Middle-England will come over well on television, even as they cut down on those wearisome charades, campaign &bquo;photo opportunities&equo;. 
 All this, plus the commissioning of party-political broadcasts and advertising, is designed to have the Tories ready for a fight whenever Mr Major chooses &mdash; even as early as May. 
 But ministers and party officials would prefer a later poll. 
 One bonus of delaying an election until 1992 would be that Mr Major could use a summer reshuffle to continue reshaping the government he inherited from Mrs Thatcher. 
 If this happens, who will suffer? 
 Despite official denials, William Waldegrave, the health secretary, is unpopular in Downing Street. 
 This is partly because of his super-conciliatory attitude to the doctors. 
 But it also harks back to the leadership campaign, when this noted intellectual was reported as saying some unkind things about the cerebral quality of one candidate, a Mr John Major, who heard the reports. 
 But he would be moved sideways, rather than demoted. 
 Peter Lilley, the trade secretary, is thought to be underperforming in the Commons. 
 Both the Northern Ireland secretary, Peter Brooke, and the social-security secretary, Tony Newton, are also being spoken of as possible losers. 
 Candidates for the cabinet include John Patten, the Home Office minister; Tristan Garel-Jones from the foreign office; Michael Portillo, the environment minister; and Gillian Shepherd from the Treasury. 
 Richer Labour 
 Without having suffered the turmoil of a leadership contest, Labour can boast that it is better prepared for an election than the Conservatives. 
 It has an overdraft of just over &pound;1m, and its finance committee was told this week that, after hoarding trade-union and individual affiliations since 1987, the party would have some &pound;6m to spend in a May or June election &mdash; still much less than the Tories, but twice what it spent in the last election. 
 The party has been using some bright capitalist techniques to get itself in election-fighting mettle. 
 It has been taking on staff, including temporary organisers in the constituencies, whose contracts will expire four weeks after a general election. 
 And it has launched a successful &bquo;affinity&equo; credit card, which has just netted Labour &pound;250,000 in its first 12 months. 
 Labour's party-political broadcasts are being filmed now, and work is almost finished on planning the campaign diaries. 
 Does Labour really expect an early election? 
 Suffice it to say that Labour's internal opinion-polling, now being carried out by NOP, is being &bquo;front-loaded&equo; to give more information through this spring. 
 And Labour has friends in the advertising industry who will try to spot advertising space being bought up for fake corporate campaigns by pro-Tory companies for May or June. 
 What about the voters? 
 Opinion polling suggests that the British electorate would rather like an early election. 
 Whether they will feel as enthusiastic after being deluged for three weeks with the results of the &pound;30m-plus likely to be spent by the main parties is more questionable.  
 Toying with the Gulf 
 THE allied forces are not the only people fighting Saddam Hussein. 
 Manufacturers are hurriedly bringing out Gulf war model kits and war games to satisfy the armchair generals who want to fight it out for themselves. 
 Give or take the odd aircraft kit &mdash; including a bigger and better model of the Stealth fighter-bomber &mdash; there are few new products hitting the market. 
 But a lot of ingenuity is going into fresh packaging. 
 Almost all the military hardware committed to the Gulf was already available in kit form, with stick-on identification markings for a European war. 
 Gulf versions have been rushed out. 
 Humbrol, the French company that owns Airfix, Britain's biggest model manufacturer, now gives pride of place in its collection to Tornado, F-16, Mirage and even AWACS jets &mdash; hastily re-packaged as a &bquo;Gulf series&equo;. 
 Generally, smaller companies have been quickest at churning out new lines; one paint maker had pots of &bquo;desert pink&equo; paint on the shelves within a week of the first television pictures showing pink-coloured tanks. 
 The star of many a shop display, though, is a 22-inch high model Patriot missile; it can fly to a height of 600 feet. 
 It was about to be discontinued by its Colorado makers until the war dramatically boosted demand. 
 Some retailers have been doing a brisk trade in the new toys, others apparently have not. 
 Hamleys, the country's largest toy shop, claims it still sells more Concordes than Tornados. 
 Staff at London's Games Store had sold little of anything to do with the war until the war-games club of an American military base in Britain cleared them out of T-55 tanks (Iraq's main battle tank) and German armoured personnel carriers (used by the Saudis). 
 The T-55s, at least, would not have been much in evidence in their previous table-top forays against the Red Army. 
 Gulf board games, for people who want to slug out the war by pushing cardboard counters across a map, are also proliferating. 
 Any budding Napoleon with a few hours to spare &mdash; or a few days, for some games &mdash; can choose from titles such as &bquo;Butcher of Baghdad&equo;, &bquo;Gulf Strike&equo; and &bquo;Line in the Sand&equo;. 
 All of them are made in America, where this kind of stuff is more popular. 
 One exception, imaginatively titled &bquo;Gulf War: The Board Game&equo;, comes from a Malaysian company that discovered it could change an America v Russia contest into a Gulf version without rewriting any of the rules. 
 Other games sound more convincing. 
 Both &bquo;Gulf Strike&equo; and &bquo;Butcher of Baghdad&equo; claim to have been designed by advisers to the Pentagon. 
 Even such an exalted pedigree as this, though, has not been enough for some of Britain's big stores. 
 They have cleared their shelves of anything that could offend the public or bring down the wrath of the tabloids. 
 Most of them are sticking to a policy, adopted during the Falklands war, of not stocking war games until the war is over.  
 BRITAIN THIS WEEK 
 Bombers again 
 An IRA bomb at London's Victoria station killed one man and injured 38 other people hours after another exploded at Paddington station. 
 Police said other stations had not been evacuated because a warning call from the terrorists had been too vague. 
 Security cameras at Victoria, which could have filmed the bombers, had been switched off. 
 Subsequent bomb alerts caused travel chaos in the London Underground. 
 For two days running, thousands of commuters had to leave trains to walk along the tracks, some of them after being stranded between stations for six hours. 
 Interviewed on television, Sir Bob Reid, the chairman of British Rail, urged the government to spend up to &pound;2 billion (&dollar;3.9 billion) on improving the country's rail network. 
 That sinking feeling 
 Insiders at Westminster reported that the cabinet was poised to scrap the poll tax and replace it with a property tax. 
 Labour said Michael Heseltine, the environment secretary, was in a &bquo;fever of indecision&equo; over an alternative to Mrs Thatcher's flagship. 
 A U-boat, perhaps? 
 Britain's recession became official. 
 Government figures for October-December showed real gross domestic product had fallen, by 1%, for the second consecutive quarter &mdash; the conventional definition of recession. 
 Retail sales fell by 1.3% in January, despite some of the biggest price-cuts in the shops for many a decade. 
 Some of those who are spending should not be; the number of bouncing cheques rose by almost half on last year. 
 Lord Young, a former trade secretary, deliberately and seriously misled both Parliament and the European Commission when he pushed through the 1988 sale of Rover to British Aerospace, concluded an inquiry by a Commons select committee. 
 It also accused the trade and industry department of behaving unprofessionally over the sale and the inquiry. 
 Michael Heseltine, the environment secretary, rejected British Coal's plans to build a &pound;400m (&dollar;780m) superpit on green-belt land near Coventry as environmentally unfriendly. 
 A man was legally allowed to savour his first curry for three months. 
 Southampton's magistrates lifted an order temporarily restraining him from entering any Indian restaurant, imposed after he used threatening behaviour in a local tandoori. 
 They closed the case by fining him &pound;100 (&dollar;196). 
 Kenneth Clarke, the education secretary, poured cold water on the recommendations of a working party set up by his department to look at physical education. 
 It urged that all children should be taught to swim. 
 The idea was too expensive, said Mr Clarke. 
 Winners and losers 
 Long-term unemployment, defined as people out of work for more than a year, is rising for the first time in five years. 
 Michael Howard, the employment secretary, said the new total, at 525,000, was in line with the &bquo;interruption&equo; in the decline of the jobless total. 
 More signs of contraction in the service industries. 
 Barclays bank announced it is preparing to sack 15&ndash;20% of its 87,000 domestic employees. 
 Thomas Cook, a travel firm, asked 7,500 staff members to take voluntary pay cuts. 
 After warning had been given that poll-tax bills will average &pound;400 (&dollar;780) in April, Westminster council announced that residents will have to pay only &pound;176, down &pound;19 on last year. 
 Lady Porter, the council's leader, thought the occasion merited a second trumpet-blast &mdash; so she resigned. 
 Margaret Thatcher will be awarded America's highest civilian honour, the Medal of Freedom, when she visits the country next month, announced the White House. 
 Reports that electricity charges would go up by 13% in April set off a furore in the press. 
 Industry bosses were rumoured to be reconsidering their plans, possibly curbing the increases to 10%. 
 Brain-teasers 
 In an open letter to the government, 72 senior expatriate scientists representing Britain's &bquo;brain drain&equo; gave warning of severe economic and social consequences unless scientific research was given a higher priority. 
 MPs put the governor of the Bank of England in a tight spot over Harrods bank. 
 Robin Leigh-Pemberton told a Commons committee that banking laws prevented him from saying anything about the case of the Fayed brothers, the owners of Harrods, strongly criticised by official inspectors for their behaviour in acquiring the store in 1985. 
 When the conveyor belt stops, out come the text books. 
 More than 4,500 Ford employees have taken up the company's new education scheme to encourage them to learn a foreign language. 
 German is the most popular, though adventurous workers are opting for Norwegian, Greek and Russian. 
 BUSINESS 
 Corporate governance in Germany 
 Our crowd 
 BONN 
 WHEN it comes to mounting a defence against hostile bidders, big German companies can tap an influential old-boy network which, together with legal takeover barriers, can make them all but impregnable. 
 A rare glimpse of how this system works has been provided by the attempt of Italy's Pirelli to gain control of Continental, Germany's biggest tyre-maker. 
 Like some other German companies, Continental has a rule that no shareholder can own more than 5% of its voting rights. 
 Even so, Pirelli claims to have assembled an alliance controlling just over 50% of shareholders' votes, which might seem to give it victory. 
 But if Continental's supervisory board, which opposes the Pirelli bid, can muster one more vote than 25%, it can block even an offer supported by a majority of shareholder votes. 
 This is probably what will happen at a shareholders' meeting on March 13th, thanks to a closing of ranks by Germany's top industrialists. 
 Organising the defence, much to Pirelli's pique, is Deutsche Bank, Germany's biggest bank. 
 Ulrich Weiss, a top Deutsche executive as well as the chairman of Continental's supervisory board, originally favoured the takeover, according to Pirelli. 
 Mr Weiss denies this. 
 In any case, Deutsche is now wholly opposed and has coaxed powerful friends into buying Continental shares to help block the bid. 
 One is Daimler-Benz, the aerospace and vehicles group. 
 Its supervisory board is headed by Deutsche's boss, Hilmar Kopper, and a former head of Continental, Helmut Werner, sits on Daimler's management board, a second-tier of executive directors that actually runs the giant industrial firm. 
 Another ally is Volkswagen, the car maker; it too is led by a one-time head of Continental, Carl Hahn. 
 Even rival German firms have put aside their differences to jump to Continental's defence. 
 BMW, Daimler's chief competitor in the luxury-car market, is helping the tyre company. 
 Allianz, the largest German insurance group and a strong rival of Deutsche Bank's, looks likely to join the defence effort because its finance chief, Friedrich Schiefer, also sits on Continental's supervisory board. 
 The &bquo;rescue&equo; of Continental recalls a famous victory for Germany's business elite in seeing off a foreign interloper in the 1970s. 
 The Shah of Iran sought to buy a hefty stake in Daimler, Germany's most prestigious company. 
 German companies rallied round to form a holding company just to buy Daimler shares. 
 To this day the holding company owns a 25.23% blocking minority in Daimler. 
 Another 28.2% is held by Deutsche Bank. 
 Foreigners can win control of German firms, but usually only when the target company is in trouble and when no leading German firm objects to the acquisition. 
 Grundig is controlled by Holland's Philips, Standard Elektrik Lorenz by France's Alcatel and Triumph-Adler by Italy's Olivetti. 
 But when Germans decide a national asset is at stake, and the old-boy network starts buzzing, a foreign buyer's chance of victory is almost always low.  
 New Zealand farmers 
 Sell them sunny meadows 
 WELLINGTON 
 &bquo;ALTOGETHER too many damned sheep,&equo; was how George Bernard Shaw summed up New Zealand. 
 True, there are a lot of them &mdash; 58m compared with only 3m people. 
 But, unlike the rest of the rich world's sheep, they do at least stand on their own four feet without any government support. 
 While the European Community quarrels over subsidies with America and other farm exporters in the Uruguay round of world trade talks, New Zealand's farmers are showing that eliminating subsidies completely will not wipe out farming, but make it far more efficient instead. 
 In 1984 New Zealand farmers received an effective level of government aid (taking account of subsidies, minimum-price supports and so on) of 33% of the value of their output &mdash; almost as much as European farmers then received. 
 That year a Labour  government  uncharacteristically committed to free-market economic policies won office. 
 Over the next few years, all farm support was phased out. 
 For farmers this was a bruising experience. 
 The real net incomes of beef and sheep farmers have fallen by more than half since 1984, as have land prices in real terms. 
 The number of sheep has shrunk by 12m from its peak. 
 And now two of New Zealand's main export markets have been badly hit by political and economic troubles: the Middle East and the Soviet Union. 
 Despite this, Federated Farmers, the farmers' lobbying group, is not calling for a return to subsidies. 
 Its main gripe is the high level of tariffs on manufactured imports, still among the highest of the 24 rich countries in the OECD. 
 This amounts to a tax on farmers because they import most of their machinery and materials. 
 But New Zealand farmers could not be better placed for the day when (if) other rich countries lower barriers to food imports and abolish farm subsidies. 
 New Zealand's dairy and meat farmers have become the cheapest producers in the OECD, thanks to their country's mild climate and to their average herd size of 160 cows, compared with the EC's less-efficient average of only 20 cows. 
 Not only do other rich countries restrict access to their markets, the EC also dumps surplus food on world markets, depressing the prices on which New Zealand farmers depend. 
 As a result, they receive for their milk only a fifth of the price paid to European farmers, a third of the price paid to American farmers, and one-seventh of that paid in Japan. 
 Even at these prices New Zealand farmers earn a living. 
 If other countries eliminate farm supports and stop dumping surplus food abroad, then world prices of dairy produce might double and export prices for other food items would move upwards too. 
 With farm exports accounting for 70% of New Zealand's exports, that would be good news for the entire economy. 
 In the meantime, Owen Jennings, president of Federated Farmers, reckons that New Zealand farmers have to learn to market their produce, no matter what happens to subsidies elsewhere. 
 Though the easy life of acting as Britain's larder ended in the 1970s, they have been slow to add value to produce before exporting it &mdash; oven-ready lamb rather than frozen carcasses, fancy cheeses rather than plain cheddar. 
 Even if other countries reduce their subsidies, marketing will matter ever more as low-cost producers from Eastern Europe and other developing countries enter the world market. 
 New Zealand farmers have one big advantage in any marketing campaign: their country's sparklingly clean environment. 
 New Zealand lambs and dairy cows grow fat the old-fashioned way, by grazing in sunny meadows, not by munching bags of feed full of additives or wandering about on pastures drenched in chemical fertilisers, as their European and American cousins do. 
 Many consumers might be happy to pay a small premium for the reassurance of sunny meadows.  
 Lean, mean and through your windscreen 
 Having been exporters for decades, Japan's car makers are at last becoming real multinationals, with factories all over the world. 
 So they have to make a choice: should they stay Japanese, or try to blend in with the locals? 
 Our correspondent visited Nissan's plants in Tennessee and north-east England, and Toyota's in Kentucky, to find their answers 
 ONE goof made by Michael Dukakis during his campaign for America's presidency in 1988 was a speech attacking foreign investment. 
 He had chosen it as a desperate, populist issue, yet the audience was even cooler than the unenthusiastic crowds the embattled Democrat had faced elsewhere. 
 Unknown to him, the stump on which he was standing happened to be a car-parts plant owned by Italians. 
 Tell that story to one of America's many grumblers about Japanese investment and the response is that Mr Dukakis would never have made that mistake at a Japanese firm: he would have been able to tell the difference. 
 Japanese firms do not blend into their surroundings. 
 They are run by Japanese, the real decisions are taken at head office, foreigners have no chance of promotion, and all the fancy design work is done at home, leaving the overseas factory as just an assembly plant for imported components. 
 This is why Japanese car factories are known rudely as &bquo;transplants&equo;: unnatural organs vulnerable to rejection by their new body. 
 About 30 miles south of Nashville, in the small town of Smyrna, Tennessee, stands a reply to that description. 
 Nissan's ten-year-old car and truck plant is a huge complex of white, impersonal, low-slung buildings. 
 But outside the main entrance stands a tall flagpole, at the top of which flies as large a sample of the Stars and Stripes as any patriot could hope for. 
 This firm wears an American suit of clothing. 
 The Japanese presence has been pared to a minimum: only 25 Japanese managers, and few cultural references. 
 No morning exercises, and scarcely an ikebana to be seen. 
 By the production line stand basketball nets and ping-pong tables for use during breaks. 
 The boss, Jerry Benefield, is as American as they come. 
 He spent 18 years working for Ford, ending up as manager of its Dearborn assembly plant. 
 Most of his senior colleagues, and his predecessor, Marvin Runyon, came from the same stable. 
 Nissan is the extreme case among the seven Japanese car makers settling into America and the three that are in Britain. 
 Honda has more Japanese managers at its Ohio plant; Toyota in Georgetown, Kentucky, is somewhere in between. 
 But all face an awkward balancing act. 
 The more Japanese they are, the more criticism they attract, both locally and nationally. 
 Japanese never like to stand out in a crowd. 
 Yet the quicker they become local the greater the risk of degrading themselves to the styles and practices of their local rivals, losing the differences that account for their superiority. 
 The problem is an old one: Ford faced it in the 1920s when it shipped its mass-production methods across to old-fashioned, craft-based Europe. 
 Ultimately, as Ford did in Europe, the Japanese have to become local to succeed. 
 But in their own way, at their own pace. 
 Their superior methods of waste-free &mdash; what a fine new book* calls &bquo;lean&equo; &mdash; production and close relations with suppliers cannot work across oceans. 
 They have to be set up, in full, locally, with a minimum of imported parts and remote decisions. 
 At the same time, Toyota, Nissan and the others will find it hard to expand if they do not design their cars, and many of the parts contained in them, to meet local tastes and fashions. 
 Those car firms that build a more or less complete organisation for manufacturing, supply and design in America and Europe will be most likely to do well. 
 In other words, it will be those that do just what the grumblers demand &mdash; cutting imports, using local suppliers, doing R&amp;D on the spot &mdash; that will be most threatening to General Motors, Ford, Volkswagen, Peugeot and Fiat. 
 The area in which blending-in has to be most immediate is employment: factory workers have to be Tennesseans, Kentuckians or Geordies, dealt with in their own way. 
 Yet handling and recruiting people is a task at which the Japanese are famously different from their American or British counterparts. 
 So which are they, Japanese or local? 
 In some ways, a comparison between Nissan and Toyota in America and Nissan in Britain reveals as much about those two countries as it does about the firms. 
 Walk around the plants: though the machinery is similar, the atmosphere is not. 
 Nissan's British plant at Washington, in north-east England just south of Newcastle, may be slick by local standards, but is grubbier and more human than its older Tennessean cousin or Toyota's newer factory in Kentucky. 
 There is more litter, and piped pop music blares throughout the factory. 
 Rules seem less strictly enforced. 
 In America, many of the welders and fitters are women; in Britain, as in Japan, they are all men. 
 The trappings of Japaneseness are worn differently. 
 British workers felt uncomfortable with the slogans common in Japanese factories, so there is none, but the American plants are full of them: &bquo;Let's talk quality&equo;; &bquo;Quality today, success tomorrow&equo;; &bquo;Professional Results In Daily Efforts&equo; (spot the acronym); &bquo;Best die-change team, 1988&equo;. 
 Company uniforms are voluntary in all three plants, but seem less widespread among British workers (though almost universal among the managers). 
 While Nissan uses an American flag at Smyrna to underline its Americanness, the British plant has no such patriotic symbol but few Japanese decorations either. 
 Toyota seems less ashamed of its origins, with Japanese carp streamers and a huge red daruma plaster head in the factory for luck. 
 Superficially, there are other signs of Japaneseness &mdash; but they are often more &bquo;Japanese&equo; than many factories in Japan itself. 
 Toyota in Kentucky and Nissan in Britain emphasise their managers' open-plan, egalitarian offices. 
 Yet in Nagoya and Tokyo many top managers have private offices (as do Nissan's American managers). 
 Indeed, Nissan's original Japanese boss in Britain had his own office; it was the idea of Ian Gibson, his British successor, to move into the open. 
 Similarly, the absence of parking privileges and separate dining rooms, celebrated features of the Japanese firm abroad, exaggerate the absence of hierarchy at home. 
 But exaggeration is the point: the aim is to make things appear strikingly different from American and British equivalents. 
 Ways of negotiating differ markedly across the Atlantic. 
 Of the three plants, only the British one has a recognised trade union, the Amalgamated Engineering Union. 
 But local practice made a union appear essential; to have a single one &mdash; compared with the half-dozen common at other British car plants &mdash; was new. 
 Nissan's factory is not a closed shop, and membership is low (about 35% of total employment and 50% of the shop floor) though managers claim to have encouraged it. 
 And the main talking-shop with workers is not the union but a quarterly &bquo;company council&equo; with delegates elected by all employees. 
 At Smyrna, Nissan discouraged union membership, fighting off an effort in 1989 by the United Auto Workers to organise the plant. 
 The UAW has tried to recruit at Toyota, but with scant success. 
 In employment, then, these firms respond pragmatically to local conditions. 
 The same is true of wages. 
 To reduce the desire for formal negotiating sessions but to remove suspicions that workers in the American South are being treated as low-cost, both the American plants tie wages to national car-industry levels, taking an average of pay at American and other car makers. 
 Nissan in Britain, however, gives its union a role by holding pay negotiations every two years with no formal industry benchmarks. 
 Both American firms pay annual or biannual bonuses, and are searching for ways to link more of managers' pay to performance. 
 They argue that a balance must be struck between team spirit and individual rewards. 
 But Peter Wickens, Nissan's British personnel director, rejects the idea of productivity pay or bonuses for workers or managers. 
 It encourages &bquo;short-term thinking&equo;, he says. 
 He is also puzzled by the fact that the Smyrna and Georgetown plants both have a pool of job applicants selected for them by their state governments before they make the final choice. 
 Mr Wickens would not dream of handing selection or filtering to anyone else, whether the union or a local government. 
 That is his job. 
 Not quite in time 
 Although employment mixes local and Japanese flavours, manufacturing is firmly Japanese. 
 That, after all, is what gives Nissan and Toyota their competitive advantage. 
 The methods of quality control they use are Japanese, and can, they find, be drilled into Britons and Americans just as well as into Japanese. 
 Productivity, measured by cars per man-hour, is just as good as in Japan. 
 But a car factory is not an independent unit: it is part of a much wider network of manufacturers, deliverers, suppliers and designers. 
 Once parts and ideas come to the assembly line, the overseas factories are virtually as good or as bad as their Japanese counterparts at sending cars out of the factory doors. 
 But the whole process is still not as efficient. 
 The trouble is that none of the three firms is nearly as Japanese as the owners would like it to be. 
 Critics think this means that they prefer to import more parts and to retain control in Japan. 
 The truth is just the opposite. 
 In the Japanese style of manufacturing, two things are vital: the elimination of waste in production and stocks by &bquo;just-in-time&equo; delivery of parts; and close co-operation with parts-suppliers over quality as well as R&amp;D. 
 Both require proximity. 
 Production cannot be &bquo;just-in-time&equo; when parts are imported from thousands of miles away in Japan. 
 At Georgetown, Toyota keeps three days' worth of stocks of imported parts, compared with 1.5 days' worth of American parts &mdash; or four hours' worth at its Japanese plants. 
 It is not simply a question of distance: hundreds of miles in America can be crossed faster than 30 in crowded Japan. 
 Rather, what matters is the certainty of supply schedules. 
 Some &bquo;just-in-time&equo; delivery is possible: all three plants boast that their car seats are made by local firms to synchronise with the car assembly line. 
 But none can say that of other parts. 
 For some parts, the problem is scale. 
 Engines and transmissions are usually made by car firms themselves, but with larger production runs than for cars, so the small scale of overseas car output makes it still sensible to import most of these things from Japan. 
 Nissan now assembles engines at Smyrna and Washington from imported kits; it now plans to spend &dollar;600m on a new engine plant at Smyrna. 
 Toyota plans to make them at Georgetown when it doubles annual car output from 200,000 to 400,000 in the next few years. 
 Honda already makes engines abroad. 
 But with most parts the problems are quality, reliability and development. 
 Until the Japanese arrived in the 1980s, American and British suppliers had to meet lower standards than the Japanese demand. 
 They also had little experience either of designing parts together with the customer or of having the customer inspect (and interfere with) the suppliers' own factories. 
 The Japanese preference is to treat suppliers as if they were a department of their own firm &mdash; sharing design work and swapping ideas on quality control and manufacturing methods &mdash; but one that, because it is separate, is subject to market disciplines. 
 To achieve that abroad, they need not only to find suppliers willing to work in their way, but also to build a commercial relationship in which each is dependent on the other. 
 That takes time, but also requires scale: so long as the car makers' output &mdash; and thus demand for parts &mdash; is small, it is hard to force suppliers to change their ways. 
 The local world car 
 So far, no Japanese car maker has managed to reproduce its native strengths abroad. 
 For the time being, however, the weaknesses resulting from long supply lines and independent parts producers are being outweighed by other strengths, compared with American and European rivals. 
 For how long? 
 Many American and European firms are closing the gap in productivity and quality. 
 Some are even making cars that customers want. 
 If there is one thing that Japanese managers respond to, it is this sort of pressure. 
 What follows is that Toyota, Nissan and the others will seek to eliminate the weaknesses in their overseas production. 
 The logic of their own methods is thus pushing them to buy more parts locally &mdash; for their own reasons, regardless of political rules demanding higher local content. 
 All three claim local content of 60&ndash;80%, depending on the car. 
 But they will not match Japanese efficiency until they hit 100%. 
 There are two other things to be tackled before the Japanese can operate at full tilt. 
 The first is to shift more research and development out of Japan. 
 In a world instantly connected by a finger on a facsimile machine, it might seem unnecessary to decentralise research. 
 One lab, one set of engineers and a worldwide sales force would seem to be all that is needed if it is true that companies and markets are becoming more global. 
 Yet markets are not global: tastes differ, especially in cars. 
 And as it becomes easier and cheaper to span the globe, knowledge of local wrinkles is becoming more important, not less. 
 This need not apply to basic research and design. 
 Toyota need only have one team inventing electric cars or ceramic engines. 
 Some central components can be more or less standard, worldwide, notably the engine, for some tastes are universal. 
 But other sorts of research need to be done on the spot. 
 This can involve the whole car, where a market has a taste for a certain type (such as four-wheel drives in America). 
 Or, more often, it involves particular parts. 
 In any case, closer links with parts suppliers require designers and researchers to be nearby. 
 This is why all the big Japanese firms are setting up research centres in America and Europe. 
 This is not just a bending to political pressure to bring in higher-paid jobs; it is a commercial necessity. 
 What all of Japan's car makers are evolving towards is a worldwide structure something like this. 
 There will be a strong Japanese parent with two full-range subsidiaries, one in Europe and one in America. 
 Each of the three will design cars and components to match local tastes. 
 Ultimately, no parts will be shipped across oceans, though some designs will be. 
 But each will export cars to one another. 
 A &bquo;European&equo; car, for instance, would be designed and built in Britain for the local mass market, but also exported as a niche product to Japan and America. 
 This is close to what GM and Ford already practise in Europe, with one difference: the American firms' subsidiaries rarely trade cars or parts with their parent. 
 If anything, say the Japanese, they are too separate. 
 None of the Japanese firms is anywhere near its goal; they make only one or two models at each plant, which is too few. 
 Honda in Ohio may be the closest, with its wider model range and higher output, though the company's progress in Europe is slow. 
 In December Honda introduced in America a new Accord station wagon, the first Japanese car to be both designed and built abroad. 
 By the end of the decade, all will want to be doing this for their main cars in America and Europe. 
 A chance from the bottom up 
 The remaining task matters just as much, but it is trickier: to acquire, retain and exploit local managers. 
 This is more an opportunity to be grabbed than a threat to the survival of Japanese factories abroad. 
 The American and British managers of the Nissan and Toyota overseas plants are not about to quit. 
 In particular, they do not worry that they will never be chairmen of the parent companies. 
 Their chances of being chairmen of Ford or General Motors are pretty slim too; non-existent (on past experience) if they are a British manager at an American &bquo;transplant&equo; in Britain. 
 Nor is interference an issue. 
 There are few Japanese managers at Smyrna, Georgetown and Washington, and the few are seen as teachers, not meddlers. 
 The opportunity, rather, is this: apart from lean production and quality control, one of the big domestic advantages of the best Japanese manufacturers has been the way they garner information within their own firm and use it to take decisions. 
 Compared with the stereotyped western firm, they operate from the bottom up rather than the top down. 
 Information flows freely up the organisation and decisions are taken, or at least initiated, at relatively low levels. 
 The generals rarely send orders to the troops. 
 The troops send orders to the generals, for their approval. 
 In principle, that ought to make Japanese firms the ideal global companies. 
 Information should flow up the overseas subsidiaries and to the parent; decisions would be decentralised. 
 For that to happen, though, the foreign managers have to be treated as equals of the domestic managers. 
 They have to want to pass on information, have to trust that it will be taken seriously, and have to be given appropriate decision-making powers. 
 This is not needed merely to run the factories properly &mdash; which is what foreign managers' present jobs mainly amount to. 
 But it will become more of a factor as more design and development is shifted overseas. 
 Those dreaming up ideas for new cars, new seats, new air-conditioning systems will be non-Japanese managers. 
 If Nissan, Toyota and the others fail to tap this source they will still be formidable firms all around the world. 
 But if they succeed, overcoming barriers of language, culture and distance, they have the chance to grow on such a worldwide scale that they could overtake the world's two biggest car makers, General Motors and Ford, in a decade or so. 
 That enticing possibility is why they are bound to have a go.  
 High-definition television 
 On the blink 
 PARIS 
 QUEL chagrin. 
 Helped by heavy subsidies from the European Commission, France's Thomson and Holland's Philips have been busily developing a new European standard for high-definition television (HDTV), a new broadcasting technology that offers cinema-quality pictures on a TV screen. 
 Just when they were about to ask Brussels to impose the fruits of their labour as the official standard for European direct-broadcast satellites, someone at the French foreign ministry leaked a report which argues that their technology, called D2 MAC, is already out of date. 
 Although the Japanese have long led the commercialisation of HDTV, it is American technology that has caught the eye of French diplomats. 
 Specifically, they are impressed by the Digicipher system, developed jointly by General Instruments and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. 
 One of the biggest problems in HDTV is cramming into crowded airwaves the huge amounts of data needed to recreate pictures of lifelike clarity. 
 D2 MAC fudges that problem by offering a picture which, though far better than today's TV, is not as good as what HDTV will eventually provide. 
 Digicipher, by contrast, squeezes a full-blown HDTV signal into a smaller slice of the radio spectrum. 
 The French foreign ministry report, says Digicipher may be good enough to make the compromise solution of D2 MAC unnecessary. 
 Right or wrong, the report increases the chances of a row in Brussels at the end of February, when industry representatives meet to reconsider Europe's HDTV policies. 
 That meeting was never likely to be a happy one. 
 Though European regulations now say that D2 MAC should be the standard on all direct-broadcast satellites, few are lining up to use it. 
 On the contrary, one of the few broadcasters likely to use D2 MAC was recently shut down. 
 After a bruising fight for market share, British Satellite Broadcasting sold out to its rival, Rupert Murdoch's Sky Broadcasting. 
 The new company will beam its signal off Mr Murdoch's Astra satellite, which cannot handle D2 MAC signals. 
 The European Commission must now decide whether to give broadcasters a harder push towards D2 MAC or bow to lack of interest.  
 A cold wind blows through Europe 
 Will continental Europe follow America and Britain into recession? 
 EUROPE'S economies are diverging. 
 While Germany remains robust, Britain and Sweden are already in the grip of recession. 
 Which way will the rest of Europe go? 
 Though eastern Germany's economy has virtually collapsed, western Germany's shows few signs of faltering. 
 Industrial production surged 5.7% in the year to December while the volume of retail sales rose by 4.9%. 
 A regular survey carried out by IFO, a research institute, shows that business confidence has slipped slightly in recent months, but it still remains far higher than at any time in the 1980s. 
 Most forecasters still expect GNP growth of 3&ndash;3.5% this year, down from an estimated 4.6% in 1990. 
 France, Italy and Spain, on the other hand, have slowed sharply since last summer, with industrial output now below its level a year ago in all three countries. 
 The Gulf war has severely dented business and consumer confidence. 
 French retail sales fell by 3.6% in the year to November, while business confidence has fallen more sharply in the past two quarters than at any time in the 1980s. 
 Unemployment in France has started to rise again, from an already high level of 9%. 
 Many forecasters expect France's economy to grow by only 1.5% in 1991, down from 4% in both 1988 and 1989 and from an estimated 2.6% last year. 
 Italy's growth is also expected to slow, to around 1.5% this year, while forecasters have pencilled in 2.5% for Spain &mdash; barely half its average growth over the past four years. 
 What happened to the pull of the German locomotive? 
 The increase in German demand resulting from unification was supposed to boost economic growth in Germany's trading partners. 
 Instead, unification has proved a mixed blessing for the rest of Europe. 
 The Bundesbank's fear of inflation and the impact of unification on Germany's budget deficit have resulted in higher real interest rates in Germany &mdash; and hence in other countries that are members of the European Monetary System (EMS). 
 Unless governments accept a devaluation of their currencies against the D-mark, they have limited room to cut interest rates to revive flagging demand. 
 Member governments have two good reasons for resisting devaluation. 
 First, it would undo the anti-inflationary credibility that they have painfully won in recent years, and which is the precise benefit offered by EMS membership. 
 A loss of credibility could lead to higher interest rates in the longer term, as investors demand compensation for the increased risk of devaluation. 
 A second reason is that the D-mark is already overvalued, not undervalued, against most other member currencies in terms of its purchasing-power parity. 
 Indeed, since 1986 unit labour costs have risen more slowly in France than Germany, and by the end of this year France's rate of consumer-price inflation could be lower than Germany's. 
 Some economists argue, however, that German unification required a real appreciation of the D-mark to help shift resources from its current-account surplus into domestic investment and consumption. 
 If other countries resist a realignment, then a real appreciation can only come about if their inflation falls below Germany's, at the cost of slower growth. 
 Either way, devaluation against the D-mark would not solve the real cause of reduced export competitiveness in France and Italy, namely the weakness of the dollar. 
 For example, although France's trade deficit with Germany narrowed last year, its trade balance with America moved from surplus into deficit. 
 On top of this, Germany's trading partners have benefited less than they had hoped from increased demand in Germany. 
 Germany's trade surplus with the rest of the European Community did shrink last year, to DM65 billion (&dollar;40 billion) from DM94 billion in 1989. 
 But that was due more to slower growth in domestic demand &mdash; and hence slower growth in demand for German exports &mdash; on the part of its trading partners than to a big jump in German imports. 
 Germany's imports from France rose by only 7% last year in D-mark terms, well down from the 13% average rise in 1988 and 1989, even as the rate of growth in France's imports from Germany slumped from 15% to 1%. 
 In the fast lane 
 Despite these disappointments, it remains true that the stronger a country's trade links with Germany, the better its economy is holding up. 
 The latest available figures for Holland, Belgium and Austria (which, though not a member of the EMS, pegs its currency to the D-mark) show that output remains fairly buoyant. 
 All three economies are forecast to grow by 2.5% or so this year. 
 Exports to Germany are equivalent to 15% of Holland's GDP, 12% of Belgium's and 11% of Austria's, compared with only 4% of France's and 3% of Italy's and Britain's. 
 Holland actually moved into trade surplus with Germany last year. 
 Exporters in France, Italy and Britain are more exposed to the cheap dollar. 
 Not only do they send a bigger share of their exports to America, but they are also facing fierce competition from American firms in third markets. 
 One example: French and British aerospace exports are all invoiced in dollars. 
 Even Italy and France, however, should avoid recession in 1991. 
 Not only will Germany continue to provide some support for their exports, but neither of the two economies spent and borrowed with the abandon of the English-speaking world in the 1980s. 
 It is no coincidence that North America, Britain and Australia &mdash; the biggest borrowers and spenders &mdash; are now suffering the deepest downturns. 
 That remains the best reason for believing that continental Europe will remain a region of growth in a faltering world economy.  
 Young love, great riches, first tiff 
 Microsoft's partnership with IBM has made Bill Gates, Microsoft's founder, a billionaire and helped IBM become the biggest personal-computer maker in the world. 
 Is the romance over? 
 THEY were the glamour couple of the 1980s. 
 The unlikely marriage between tousled Microsoft and buttoned-down IBM created the hottest products in the decade's hottest industry, personal computers. 
 Celebrated everywhere, the duo had no reason to question their good fortune, and no need to wonder which their friends really liked best: IBM's earnest reliability or Microsoft's youthful creativity. 
 Now a setback has brought long-buried differences to the surface. 
 Computer-industry gossips wonder if the marriage can survive. 
 Premature though speculation of divorce may be &mdash; both Microsoft and IBM are quick to pledge their commitment to each other &mdash; even minor flaws in their domestic harmony will be closely watched. 
 Together, IBM and Microsoft set the technical standards that helped fuel the explosive growth of personal computers in the 1980s: &bquo;IBM-compatible&equo; hardware and Microsoft's DOS operating-system software, the basic program needed to run any computer. 
 Together, both companies are trying to set a new standard for the more complex computing world of the 1990s: a jointly developed operating system called OS/2. 
 But customers have been slow to embrace OS/2. 
 The frustration is driving Microsoft and IBM apart. 
 The eventual result may be new leadership for the personal-computer industry, or no clear leadership at all. 
 Since they first began holding hands, Microsoft and IBM have shared barely a care. 
 The men from Big Blue originally came to Microsoft's founder, Bill Gates, to license the programming languages that he had written for the early personal-computer enthusiasts, most of whom had built their own machines. 
 IBM also needed an operating system. 
 Gary Kildall, whose Digital Research created the CP/M operating system for the first generation of personal computers, did not jump at IBM's offer. 
 So in 1980 IBM came back to Mr Gates, then 25, who quickly bought a rudimentary operating system from another young company, renamed it DOS, and fixed it up for IBM. 
 DOS now sells about 17m copies a year, and Mr Gates's 40% stake in Microsoft is worth about &dollar;4 billion. 
 Today's success was created largely by yesterday's success. 
 Because it was IBM jumping into the computer market with Microsoft in 1981 &mdash; as opposed to yet-another bunch of blue-jeaned entrepreneurs &mdash; would-be competitors reckoned the couple's technology might be worth copying. 
 Microsoft's willingness to license DOS helped rivals to copy it and then use that technology as the basis for their own innovation. 
 The more people jumped on to the bandwagon, the more others wanted to join them. 
 Almost everybody in the computer industry expected something similar to happen with OS/2. 
 It hasn't. 
 Since its launch in 1988, sales of OS/2 have grown to only about 300,000 a year. 
 Nobody knows why. 
 Perhaps the relatively high price of the more powerful personal computers needed to run OS/2 has put off budget-minded companies. 
 Perhaps buyers are put off by the complexity of learning a new technology. 
 Or perhaps OS/2 simply solved problems that do not trouble most customers. 
 Whatever the reason, OS/2's adversity is pushing Microsoft and IBM apart. 
 Microsoft responds to slow OS/2 sales with a youthful eagerness to do better. 
 &bquo;We were wrong,&equo; admits Steve Ballmer, a top Microsoft executive. 
 He says both he and Mr Gates thought OS/2 would outsell DOS by 1992 at the latest. 
 It will not. 
 So Microsoft is now concentrating its efforts on a product customers do want to buy: Windows. 
 Windows does the most visible part of the job OS/2 was designed to do. 
 It helps users to juggle a variety of programs at once, each in its own window on the screen. 
 It is nowhere near as good as OS/2 at managing complex tasks, like getting computers to co-operate across a network. 
 But customers do not seem to care. 
 In nine months on the market, the latest version of Windows has sold 3m copies. 
 Microsoft is now trying to market Windows as a stepping stone to OS/2, by making it easy for users of Windows and writers of programs for Windows to migrate to OS/2 eventually. 
 Microsoft's enthusiasm for Windows annoys IBM. 
 For Big Blue, OS/2 is just one piece of a grand vision about how all of a company's computers can work together. 
 Any gains it might make by fiddling with its strategy for OS/2 would be offset &mdash; perhaps more than offset &mdash; by the confusion such fiddling would engender about IBM's overall strategy. 
 So IBM is publicly sticking to OS/2, though it is also quietly hedging its bets by incorporating into its grand scheme other products with many of the same capabilities. 
 Piece by small technical piece, these strategies are eating away at the consensus that originally made OS/2 seem a certainty as the computing world's next-generation technical standard. 
 Microsoft has set up Windows as a rival to a component of OS/2 called Presentation Manager, which is still backed by IBM. 
 Perhaps in retaliation, IBM has signed an agreement with Novell, a maker of personal-computer networks. 
 This could make Novell's products an alternative to Microsoft's networking software, called LAN Manager. 
 And IBM is financing an ambitious project by a young Californian company, Patriot Partners; it would let software companies write programs compatible with OS/2 and Unix, an operating system with similar capabilities originally created by AT&amp;T's Bell Labs. 
 With more and more options to choose from, customers and software developers are increasingly reluctant to plump for just one. 
 What makes this a particular problem for Microsoft and IBM is that, while the consensus on OS/2 is unravelling, its chief rival, Unix, is at last making headway. 
 When OS/2 was announced, Unix was dismissed as a flop because there were almost as many versions of Unix as people selling it. 
 Now various versions of Unix have been boiled down to two: one from the Open Systems Foundation, a consortium that includes IBM, Hewlett Packard and DEC, and one from Unix International, a consortium involving AT&amp;T and Sun Microsystems. 
 About 1m copies of Unix were sold in 1990. 
 A recent poll by DMR, a Canadian information-technology consultancy, shows that nearly as many American companies are planning to adopt Unix as OS/2. 
 This raises the possibility that OS/2 &mdash; and, with it, IBM's partnership with Microsoft &mdash; will get caught in a vicious circle, much like DOS got caught in a virtuous one. 
 Slow sales will encourage Microsoft to innovate and IBM to hedge, which will make customers cautious, which will slow sales, which will encourage further tiffs between the two companies, and so on. 
 It could all end in tears.  
 Japan's chip makers 
 Falling off the learning curve 
 TOKYO 
 JAPANESE manufacturers of memory chips are poised on the brink of a bloody price war. 
 The price of a 1-megabit dynamic random-access memory (DRAM) chip &mdash; the current workhorse of the Japanese semiconductor industry &mdash; has tumbled 40% since September, to around &dollar;4.50. 
 Falling prices for 1-megabit chips erode prices for the coming generation of 4-megabit DRAMs. 
 At &dollar;17 a chip, the price of 4-megabit DRAMs is already probably too low for semiconductor manufacturers to recoup the cost of the new production lines needed to make them. 
 The last time Japanese chip manufacturers faced a ruinous price war over a new generation of chips, they were saved by American stupidity. 
 This time they may not be so lucky. 
 In 1985, when Japanese chip makers last started slashing prices, America's government insisted that they raise them in order to protect the (virtually non-existent) American DRAM industry. 
 That agreement is about to expire. 
 Although America's electronics industries are keen for the government to renew the parts of this agreement that call for the Japanese to buy more American chips, their ardour for price-fixing has cooled. 
 Instead of government-rigged prices, they want little more than a reaffirmation of existing anti-dumping rules. 
 That may not be enough to save the Japanese from cutting each other's throats. 
 The main market for Japan's semiconductor makers &mdash; the American computer industry &mdash; has been sinking deeper into slump since August 1990. 
 Now chip sales in Japan are beginning to collapse as well. 
 As a result, big DRAM producers like Toshiba, Hitachi, Mitsubishi Electric and NEC have 4-megabit chips piling up in their warehouses, just as they start opening additional factories. 
 Over the past year Japanese semiconductor firms have spent a colossal &yen;850 billion (&dollar;6.7 billion) building more production lines for 4-megabit chips. 
 Each has been trying to outbid the rest in an attempt to gain market share and so exploit economies of scale. 
 Between them, Japanese semiconductor firms will produce 120m of the new 4-megabit chips for the year ending in March. 
 According to World Semiconductor Trade Statistics, customers are expected to buy 100m of these chips at most. 
 All told, demand for memory chips fell more than 16% in 1990. 
 Behind the brave faces of Japanese DRAM makers, anxieties are beginning to show. 
 Most are now talking about launching the next-generation DRAM, the 16-megabit chip, as soon as next month. 
 Previously it was not expected to reach the market until 1992. 
 Over the past couple of months all the leading Japanese DRAM suppliers &mdash; including Hitachi, Toshiba, NEC, Mitsubishi Electric and Fujitsu &mdash; have started shipping &bquo;engineering samples&equo; of 16-megabit chips. 
 So have Texas Instruments in America and Siemens in Europe. 
 Korea's Samsung will start doing so in a few weeks. 
 For the first time in its brief history, the semiconductor industry is going to be making, and trying to sell, three generations of memory chips in large volumes at the same time. 
 Prices should tumble as each cannibalises sales of the others. 
 A 4-megabit chip ought to sell for five times as much as a 1-megabit device, the price premium justified by the smaller space and lower power needed to provide four times the amount of memory. 
 Dataquest, a market-research company based in California, is now forecasting that a 4-megabit chip will cost barely three times more than a 1-megabit chip by next year (see chart). 
 More painful still, 16-megabit chips will hit the market at only nine times the price of existing 4-megabit DRAMs. 
 New generations of memory chips normally arrive at 30&ndash;40 times the price of the industry's mainstream product. 
 Pundits are now beginning to wonder whether Japanese chip makers may be preparing to &bquo;leap a generation&equo;. 
 Hitachi, Fujitsu, Toshiba, Mitsubishi Electric and Matsushita hurried out experimental 64-megabit models for last week's &bquo;Silicon Olympics&equo; (the annual conference in San Francisco where chip designers show off their latest inventions). 
 For semiconductor makers not already committed to building 16-megabit production lines, the case for going straight for the 64-megabit device looks increasingly attractive. 
 Fujitsu recently showed that 64-megabit DRAMs could be made using fairly conventional lithographic equipment, based on ultra-violet light rather than exotic lasers or X-rays. 
 In January Fujitsu announced that it will spend &yen;100 billion (&dollar;770m) next year getting its plant in Miyazaki prefecture ready for making 64-megabit chips. 
 Meanwhile, Japanese and American officials have begun negotiating a renewal of their semiconductor-trade pact. 
 The Americans are asking that the Japanese guarantee American firms 20% of Japan's chip market, up from 13% today. 
 Japanese officials plead that they do not have the power to carve up the market in this way. 
 They also calculate that the Americans already have 18% of the Japanese market. 
 Their figure includes chips made in Japan by subcontractors to American companies, exported for assembly into circuit boards and then re-imported. 
 There has not yet been much debate about prices. 
 But the Americans do not seem likely to force the Japanese to overcharge them for chips again.  
 Keeping mum 
 CORKY RA is the sort of entrepreneur who likes a challenge. 
 In the 1970s he bet his father he could open a vineyard in Utah, a state where drink and the devil are considered kissin' cousins. 
 Mr Ra won his wager by building a 40-foot-high pyramid in Salt Lake City, making sacramental wine in it, and selling the stuff to religious groups &mdash; wine made in pyramids was said by the ancient Egyptians to have supernatural powers. 
 His company, Summum, now sells &dollar;1m-worth of wine each year. 
 Seeking to diversify, Mr Ra (who was born the distinctly un-Egyptian Claude Nowell) jumped into an industry ripe for a little niche marketing: the funeral business. 
 Until Summum's arrival, burial or cremation were its two main products. 
 Taking his cue from the Egyptians, Mr Ra came up with a third: Mummification (with a capital &bquo;M&equo; because Summum, besides patenting the process, has somehow registered the word as a trademark). 
 For around &dollar;7,700 &mdash; rather more than the cost of a burial &mdash; clients can be pickled and preserved for eternity. 
 Another &dollar;26,000 buys a bronze, sealed sarcophagus filled with inert gas that kills body-eating bacteria. 
 The price also includes an engraved likeness of the deceased's face and clothing on the lid, just like King Tut. 
 One client &mdash; Summum has 130 so far &mdash; has specified a bejewelled &bquo;mummiform&equo; costing &dollar;150,000. 
 To help offset the expense, Mr Ra has persuaded America's IRS that, unlike conventional funerals, mummification funerals should be tax-deductible. 
 There is a snag. 
 None of Summum's clients has yet died. 
 So far only Butch, Mr Ra's dog, and Oscar, his cat, have succumbed. 
 Both now sit, mummified and in gold-leafed sarcophagi, in Summum's pyramid headquarters. 
 FINANCE 
 Japan's monetary policy 
 Wait for it 
 TOKYO 
 INVESTORS are convinced that the Bank of Japan will soon be forced to lower interest rates sharply. 
 They may be wrong. 
 Bond and share prices have rallied, discounting a full percentage-point decline in the official discount rate (ODR), which now stands at 6%. 
 The new benchmark ten-year government bond yielded 6.3% on February 20th, down from a peak of 7.9% (on a compound yield basis) at the end of September. 
 The stockmarket is up by around 30% from its low at the start of October. 
 The reason is a succession of statistics that suggest a rapidly weakening economy. 
 Bulls were further excited by a recent report on a government-owned television station that an ODR cut was imminent. 
 Though this was dismissed as groundless by Yasushi Mieno, governor of the central bank, it was seen as a trial balloon to test reaction. 
 Mr Mieno is still talking and acting tough because he is intent on bursting the speculative bubbles in shares and property. 
 To this end the ODR has been raised five times since May 1989. 
 Mr Mieno does not want to let up until he is sure the job is done. 
 True, there is growing evidence that higher interest rates, combined with stiff controls on bank lending, are producing the desired effect. 
 Money-supply growth is slowing: M2 plus CDs, the favoured measure, grew by only 7.3% year-on-year in January, after growth had peaked in May at 13.2% &mdash; the steepest slowdown since 1973. 
 The monetary evidence is supported by various other signs of weakness. 
 Private machinery orders collapsed in December, down 28% from the previous month. 
 Bankruptcies (mostly property-related) reached &yen;642 billion (&dollar;4.9 billion) in January &mdash; the second-highest monthly figure ever, and almost one-third of last year's total. 
 Mikuni &amp; Co, a credit-rating agency, thinks bankruptcies will total &yen;4 trillion this year and &yen;10 trillion in 1992. 
 This will not be good news for those banks left with the bad debts. 
 Even so, Mr Mieno seems in no mood to be pushed into premature easing. 
 To make that clear, the central bank hauled the overnight call-rate back up after the denied television report. 
 It was 8.2% on February 20th, compared with the 7.1% on three-month Euroyen futures, the best gauge of market expectations. 
 Apart from bursting bubbles, the Bank of Japan also wants to be sure inflation has peaked. 
 It has not yet. 
 Domestic wholesale prices were up 2.6% year-on-year in January. 
 Tokyo consumer prices in January were 4.2% up year-on-year, the biggest increase since December 1981. 
 The central bank would probably like to delay easing until at least one headline-grabbing bankruptcy confirms the damage done and inflation starts dropping. 
 Some fear that if Mr Mieno delays much longer, he risks overkill. 
 That could mean that, like America's Federal Reserve, he will later be trying to jump-start an economy already in slump.  
 Exploding services 
 AMERICA could have a current-account surplus &mdash; yes, surplus &mdash; in the first half of this year, for the first time since 1981. 
 Its deficit has been shrinking steadily, from a peak of &dollar;162 billion in 1987 to about &dollar;95 billion last year, as the cheap dollar has helped exports and sluggish demand at home has slowed imports. 
 And now America has found a miracle service export: security. 
 Contributions promised by the Saudis, Kuwait, Japan and others to help pay for the Gulf war count as invisibles receipts. 
 They could reach &dollar;45 billion-50 billion during the first half of 1991, if the &bquo;bills&equo; are paid promptly. 
 Meanwhile, if oil prices remain low, America's visible-trade deficit could shrink to around &dollar;40 billion in that period. 
 Add the two together, reckons Jan Duesing, an economist at Credit Suisse First Boston, and the deficit could &mdash; for a time &mdash; become a six-month surplus of &dollar;10 billion-plus. 
 So stand by for a new trade war, as America is accused of dumping subsidised security services on world markets? 
 Maybe not: Japan and the European Community don't seem much interested in this business, do they?  
 Japanese banks 
 Our survey of Japanese finance (&bquo;Downbeat&equo;, December 8th) included a table purporting to show Japanese banks' BIS capital-adequacy ratios as at September 1990, attributed to James Capel and from a study it made in October 1990. 
 We did not make it clear that the table showed not the banks' actual ratios but a hypothetical estimate of what they would have been had the banks not borrowed subordinated loans to boost their capital (as Japan's finance ministry let them do after June). 
 We are sorry for any misunderstanding or embarrassment this caused to James Capel and to the banks.  
 Jardine Matheson 
 Drifting apart 
 HONG KONG 
 HONG KONG's financial regulators and Jardine Matheson, its grandest trading house, are at odds. 
 Both are trying to present the disagreement as a storm in a teacup. 
 Yet it could turn nasty. 
 Jardines has threatened that, unless the regulators leave it alone, it may delist the shares of companies it controls from the local stock exchange &mdash; 14% of the market's capitalisation. 
 On the surface, the spat is over whether Jardines has broken a rule that forbids Hong Kong companies &mdash; directly or through subsidiaries &mdash; to buy their own shares. 
 At the end of last year Hong Kong's fledgling Securities and Futures Commission started looking into share purchases by Connaught Investors, part of the Jardine empire. 
 It is taking longer than expected. 
 What has emerged so far is this. 
 Connaught was set up as an investment vehicle after the 1987 crash. 
 Its aim, say its articles, is &bquo;to take advantage of investment opportunities in world equity markets, with particular reference to Hong Kong&equo;. 
 Its three shareholders &mdash; Jardine Matheson Holdings, Jardine Strategic, a subsidiary, and Hongkong Land (see the chart) &mdash; agreed to put up to HK&dollar;3 billion (&dollar;385m) of capital into Connaught, an amount that can be raised at any time. 
 Connaught was activated soon after the Tiananmen Square massacre in 1989, when Hong Kong share prices plunged. 
 This coincided with a change that extended the ban on share buy-ins to companies domiciled elsewhere. 
 Jardines had moved its domicile to Bermuda in 1984. 
 Beside various Hong Kong blue chips unrelated to Jardines, Connaught bought stakes in Dairy Farm, a supermarket chain, and Mandarin Oriental, a hotel group, both controlled by Jardines. 
 The argument is over a 3.4% stake that it has been forced to disclose in Jardine Matheson Holdings itself. 
 Jardines denies this is in breach of the rule. 
 If minority interests are taken into account, its stake in Connaught is 42%. 
 So Connaught is not a subsidiary, Jardines argues. 
 It further claims that neither Jardine Strategic nor Hongkong Land is in a position to exert &bquo;significant influence&equo; over Connaught &mdash; in which each holds 45%. 
 Underlying the bickering is longstanding tension between Jardines and the regulators. 
 For the past six months Jardines has been arguing that Hong Kong's largest companies should be granted &bquo;exempt listing status&equo;. 
 This would leave them free to ignore the non-statutory takeover code and Stock Exchange listing rules. 
 Hong Kong grew rich, says Jardines, thanks to a lack of rules, not meddling regulators. 
 Some of the regulators see Jardines' bluster as a tactic to secure room for manoeuvre in the run-up to 1997, when Hong Kong reverts to China. 
 That year will also be the 50th anniversary of the fall of Shanghai to the Communists, an event that ravaged the Keswick family fortunes. 
 Lessons learnt at their father's knee have made Henry Keswick, the chairman of Jardine Matheson, and his influential brother Simon deeply suspicious of the bosses in Beijing. 
 Jardine Matheson, having moved in 1984 to Bermuda, last summer had its shares listed in London and Luxembourg, and redenominated its accounts in American dollars. 
 This month its shares were also listed in Singapore. 
 So threats of delisting in Hong Kong sound plausible. 
 Delisting would do Jardine Matheson no good in Hong Kong (though it would certainly do less harm if it were attributed to a row with the regulators than, say, to lack of faith in the future of the place). 
 It would not help Jardines to protect its investment in Hongkong Land, which has HK&dollar;50 billion (&dollar;6.5 billion) tied up in Hong Kong property. 
 Yet almost half of Jardine Matheson's profits already come from outside Hong Kong. 
 Dairy Farm and Mandarin Oriental are expanding abroad successfully. 
 The group's offshore assets are protected from post-1997 skulduggery by its Bermuda domicile. 
 Such complete protection is impossible for Hongkong Land's buildings. 
 But safeguards are being prepared. 
 One already in place provides that should one of Connaught's three shareholders be taken over, it would lose its voting rights in Connaught. 
 Getting round the buy-in ban also could help. 
 The more cross-holdings there are, the less chance of success for any outside raid on Hongkong Land, even if it had semi-official backing from the Chinese  government . 
 And if Jardines sought to sell out of Hongkong Land, it would be better placed to demand a hefty premium for offering effective control without the need to buy out smaller shareholders. 
 So were the Keswicks forced out by communism yet again, this time much of their wealth would be intact.  
 Wall Street securities firms 
 Red ink flows 
 NEW YORK 
 LAST year was a dreadful one for Wall Street's securities firms. 
 For the first time since 1973, they lost money &mdash; &dollar;200m-plus among them, on estimated revenues of &dollar;53.4 billion. 
 In 1989 they had made &dollar;1.2 billion on &dollar;59.5 billion of revenues. 
 Firms that avoided the worst excesses of the wheeling-dealing 1980s are making steady profits, and much of the loss was due to expensive restructuring at Shearson Lehman (which spent &dollar;640m) and Prudential-Bache (&dollar;370m). 
 But even the likes of Morgan Stanley, Paine Webber and Salomon Brothers, though still in the black, saw profits crumble. 
 This week Salomon announced it was moving 750 clerical jobs to lower-cost Florida. 
 Since its peak in 1987, the industry has lost 60,000 jobs, 23% of the total. 
 As many more could go if parents like General Electric (Kidder Peabody), American Express (Shearson Lehman), Credit Suisse (First Boston) and Prudential Insurance (Pru-Bache) tire of bailing out their subsidiaries. 
 Prudential has poured more than &dollar;1 billion into Pru-Bache since acquiring it in 1981. 
 Pru-Bache lost &dollar;250m in 1990, its third loss in four years. 
 Now it has lost its boss, George Ball. 
 He spent 1990 watching his paymasters demolish the investment bank that he had spent the previous seven years building up for the Pru's assault on Wall Street. 
 Pru-Bache is to retrench to Bache's old strength of retail stockbroking. 
 Mr Ball was the first Wall Street boss to be axed since Peter Cohen went a year ago in the dismantling of another 1980s tower of babel, Shearson Lehman Hutton. 
 That is odd, because Wall Street's troubles are not just cyclical. 
 With one eye on the next deal and the other on the one after that, its grandees failed to spot the long-term slide in profitability, let alone reverse it. 
 In the fixed-commission mid-1960s, profit margins were about 25% on total revenue. 
 By the early 1980s they had halved; though pre-tax return on equity ran at around 40%. 
 Both figures are now negative. 
 One big reason was that firms failed to curb non-interest costs, notably pay. 
 From 1980 until the crash of 1987, too many people were paid too much. 
 It scarcely seemed to matter while the deals came rolling in. 
 After the crash, the number of people shrank, but not the survivors' pay-packets. 
 Meanwhile, the corporate-finance deals that had been generating big bucks for Wall Street's investment bankers were starting to dry up. 
 From 20% in 1980, investment banking grew to account for two-thirds of the business at the bigger houses in the go-go days. 
 Today its share is around one-seventh, as firms limp by &bquo;restructuring&equo; &mdash; ie, cleaning up &mdash; the messes they have made. 
 The hot new businesses on Wall Street are constantly changing. 
 So the slide in mergers and acquisitions did not have to mean disaster in itself. 
 But nothing much was replacing it. 
 Not even traditional agency broking was lucrative: small investors remained shy of the stockmarket, big institutions had the clout to pay the thinnest of commissions. 
 With costs still rising, profit had to fall. 
 How far depended on a firm's skills at trading for its own account. 
 Reality was starting to change Wall Street's profligate ways last year. 
 Back to basics was the new credo. 
 Unprofitable departments were closed. 
 Sackings multiplied. 
 Pay packets depended more on bonuses that were tougher to win. 
 At Morgan Stanley, Merrill Lynch and Salomon, some pay has started to arrive in the form of a firm's stock rather than by cheque. 
 These firms are not just saving cash. 
 They are trying, says Ira Kay, of the Hay Group of management consultants, to get their executives to think more like owners, and so pursue &bquo;shareholder value&equo;. 
 Many partnerships went public in the 1980s to secure capital, so the discipline that comes from handling one's own money had been eroded. 
 The recent surge in stockmarket volume and the hasty dusting-down of the houses' new-issue departments threaten to bring quick profit back to the industry and delude its bosses that the good times are returning. 
 Getting itself back into shape may yet again be pushed to one side. 
 Wall Street is notorious for having scant regard for the future and even less for the past. 
 There is a famous &bquo;tombstone&equo; advertisement, not 20 years yellow, of an equity issue for American Motors. 
 Not one of the 36 Wall Street houses in the underwriting syndicate now survives independently. 
 Unless today's firms learn to manage for profit, not just for the revenue generated by the next deal, it is a fair bet that in fewer years than that many of them will have gone the same way.  
 German property: unsure, but not unsafe 
 While commercial-property markets in America, Britain and Japan are in the doldrums, Germany's is still booming. 
 Until when? 
 AFTER tearing down one wall, the Germans are busy putting up thousands of others. 
 Attracted by rents that have risen faster than in all other European cities bar Madrid, developers have been throwing up office blocks on sites from Cologne and Munich to Berlin. 
 Foreign investors have been queueing up to buy them. 
 Property men are asking themselves whether this boom can last. 
 The answer is, probably not. 
 Some optimists are still talking the market up. 
 They reckon that prices and rents will continue to rise. 
 The reasons they offer are these: 
 First, German reunification. 
 This, they argue, will give a new lease of life to moribund markets in cities like Hamburg and Hanover, which lie close to the former border between the two Germanies &mdash; near the once feared Soviet army, that is, and some way from once all-important markets to the West. 
 Second, they point to the 13 big property investment funds run by German banks. 
 These already have property assets worth some DM15 billion (&dollar;10 billion), and are still adding to them. 
 In one recent deal, the DGI property fund, which is run by Deutsche Bank, paid an estimated DM200m for the Chase Bank Tower in the centre of Frankfurt. 
 Third, a growing number of European property investment funds are targeting Germany. 
 One such fund is the Pan European Property Unit Trust, which has a DM300m portfolio of properties. 
 This invests on behalf of a number of British and American pension funds, including those of state-owned British Coal and of the United Nations. 
 Another is the German City Estates Fund, sponsored by London and Edinburgh Trust, a British developer, and its owner SPP, a Swedish pension fund. 
 Lastly, more foreign direct investment should continue to pour into Germany. 
 Swedish investors have been the biggest spenders, splashing out some DM5 billion last year on German property. 
 Japanese institutions too have been eager buyers. 
 In December Nomura bought a stake in Frankfurt's Messeturm, Europe's tallest building, for an estimated DM500m. 
 That foreign money is the more welcome because German banks have not been open-handed. 
 Rather than follow their British and American counterparts, who fed a property frenzy with mezzanine debt, deep-discount bonds and other financial wheezes, Germany's more prudent bankers have consistently refused to lend more than two-thirds of the value of a development project. 
 Equity investors have made up the difference. 
 The banks have done developers one favour by staying in Frankfurt rather than heading for Berlin. 
 Prime rents in Frankfurt have risen from DM65 a month per square metre at the end of 1989 to DM85 (&dollar;64 a year per square foot; DM10 monthly per square metre is about &dollar;7.50 annually per square foot). 
 In December, Deutsche Bank boosted the market again by spending DM1.4 billion on a building next door to its existing headquarters. 
 For those with strong nerves and deep pockets, Berlin's property market looks attractive. 
 After barely moving for most of the 1980s, monthly rents on prime commercial properties in western Berlin suddenly leapt from DM28 at the end of 1989 to DM65 a year later, bubbling up on hopes &mdash; now dashed &mdash; that the Bundesbank would move to the city, and on speculation that it will eventually become Germany's seat of government. 
 The Berlin market is likely to remain tight. 
 There is hardly any vacant office space, while many new developments are on hold until the planning authorities have finalised a blueprint for the city. 
 Even without that decision, there are already signs that the new Berlin market will resemble London's. 
 In the &bquo;West End&equo;, formerly West Berlin, buildings will contain a mix of residential, retail and office accommodation. 
 The &bquo;City&equo;, formerly East Berlin, will be dominated by high-rise office buildings. 
 Some impatient firms cannot wait. 
 They have been paying ridiculous rents of up to DM120 for the little decent office space that now exists in eastern Berlin &mdash; about twice as much as they would pay for similar space in the western part of the city. 
 Other companies prefer to build their own offices. 
 Daimler-Benz, for example, has bought a large site on Potsdamer Platz, in the heart of the new Berlin. 
 Though big firms can afford to take a risk, private investors should think twice before buying in the east. 
 Roughly one-third of the sites in eastern Berlin are state-owned; establishing who owns the rest could take years. 
 Unwary buyers could find someone else laying claim to their property. 
 They could also find themselves having to pay to clean up pollution on sites they have bought. 
 Another snag is that construction costs in Berlin, already higher than in western Germany, are now rising as fast as rents. 
 Cooling off 
 Nevertheless, property folk may be tempted by eastern promise if markets in western Germany start to cool. 
 There are signs of this. 
 First, in some cities like Frankfurt some huge new office developments are nearing completion. 
 Once on the market, says Robert Orr, of Jones Lang Wootton, a London-based firm of chartered surveyors, these could quickly depress rents. 
 Second, high German interest rates have slowed the flow of money into property funds. 
 Meanwhile, some prices have risen even faster than rents, bringing lower yields. 
 So many funds have held back from investing. 
 Foreign investment too may dry up, as the initial post-unification euphoria fades. 
 So is the German commercial-property market about to crash? 
 That seems unlikely. 
 Prices and rents are likely to fall slowly in most cities, though there could be some serious casualties in the boiling Berlin market as sanity returns. 
 The difference in Germany will be that ailing developers will not risk pulling bankers down with them.  
 Swedish investment abroad 
 On ice 
 OVER the past two years, Swedish investors have come in from the cold. 
 After the last exchange controls were lifted in July 1989, Swedes rushed to invest abroad. 
 Recently, however, a nasty combination of wobbly stockmarkets, plunging property prices and a fragile domestic banking system has made them more cautious. 
 Foreign investment by Swedish individuals and financial institutions like Skandia, a big insurer, and SPP, a pension fund, has been huge. 
 In 1989 Swedes spent a net SKr28 billion (&dollar;4.5 billion) on foreign equities, followed by a net SKr20 billion in the first nine months of 1990. 
 They have spent even more on property: the Swedish International Property Association (SIPA) estimates the net flow of direct and indirect investment in foreign property at SKr70 billion in 1989&ndash;90. 
 As Sweden's stockmarket had a bad year in 1990, interest in foreign equities is unsurprising. 
 Most investors have headed for Germany, piling into car and construction companies. 
 Since the start of 1991, however, the Stockholm market has risen by 16%, outstripping London, Tokyo and New York. 
 So Swedes may think twice before rushing more money abroad. 
 They will also have to rethink their international property strategy &mdash; if they have one. 
 Though they have done well in Germany and Belgium (they now own one-tenth of all the office space in Brussels), Swedish investors have come a cropper in London. 
 According to Debenham Tewson &amp; Chinnocks, chartered surveyors there, Swedes invested &pound;1.6 billion (&dollar;2.5 billion) in British commercial property in 1989&ndash;90 &mdash; just as the market was about to crumble. 
 The reason was simple enough: Swedes buying property abroad had &mdash; not alone &mdash; more money than sense. 
 Mr Erik Sond&eacute;n, the managing director of SIPA, points out that in the tiny Swedish market values of investment properties have gone only one way over the past ten years: up. 
 With little international experience, most Swedish investors assumed other markets would do the same. 
 Falling property markets abroad have had a knock-on effect in Sweden. 
 Some heavily-indebted developers have run into trouble, causing problems for the finance companies that back them. 
 That in turn has worried the commercial banks that had lent money to the finance houses. 
 Bankers are now forcing developers to pull back abroad. 
 For the time being, this looks like the end of the Swedish spending spree. 
 Swedish investors are retreating and regrouping. 
 There has already been a rapid consolidation among Sweden's property investors. 
 But with their own economy in bad shape, and with the EC's single market just around the corner, the Swedes will soon be setting sail again.  
 Sorry, Auntie, I goofed 
 AT NOON last Friday, February 15th, Britain's rising equity prices, at 2303.8 on the FT-SE 100 index, stood within millimetres of their level &mdash; 2303.2 &mdash; at exactly the same moment 12 months earlier. 
 Great news, you might think, for Aunt Agatha, who had begun to fear that, instead of taking young Billy Whizzquid's advice and putting her savings under the professional management of a unit trust, she would have done better to put them under her mattress. 
 Alas, not so. 
 If she had cashed in her units at that day's prices, just two of 102 &bquo;UK general&equo; trusts recorded by Finstat (a Financial Times subsidiary) would have given her back 100% or more of the money she put in a year earlier. 
 The average would have been 88.4%, and 12 trusts achieved less than 80%. 
 Among 127 &bquo;UK equity income&equo; trusts, just two again were winners; the average was 87.2%, and 19 scored less than 80%. 
 Still, Auntie could have done far worse than that. 
 Capital growth, above all, is what the industry sells to distinguish itself from boring old building societies. 
 Had Auntie been fool enough last February to believe it, she had a choice of 190 &bquo;UK growth&equo; funds &mdash; and in 187 of them the growth was negative. 
 The highest flier soared to just 102.1%; the average was 79.3%; and the worst performer of all &mdash; stand up, MGM Special Situations Growth &mdash; managed 44.2%. 
 True, this is not quite fair to the industry. 
 Young Whizzquid and his City friends cannot be expected to toil on Aunt Agatha's behalf for nothing, and the spread between offer prices and bid &mdash; between what she puts in and what she could take out five minutes later &mdash; is around 6%. 
 Finstat's figures are dragged down by that spread, as a market index is not. 
 On the other hand, Finstat &mdash; unlike an index &mdash; adds back 12 months' income, assuming it to be reinvested in the trust. 
 That bridges much of the spread, but not all: it is worth maybe 5%, less 1% or so for the annual management fee that keeps Whizzquid on his toes. 
 True too, the FT-SE 100 is not the only index around. 
 The 667-share FTA All-Share index on February 15th was still 4% below its level of 12 months before. 
 Why pick the FT-SE to compare unit trusts with? 
 The short answer is, why not? 
 Any fool can buy a blue-chip index; Aunt Agatha could do it for herself, if she had the money and a stockbroker. 
 Unit-trust managers are paid for the share-picking and dealing skills that enable them to do better than elderly aunts (how much better is a question: supposedly index-tracking funds scored only from 88.4% to 93.2% over the period). 
 In sum, Auntie &mdash; and about 1.75m other Britons &mdash; was unwise to put her trust in units last year. 
 Good news, at least, you might think, for that industry's rivals, the investment trusts. 
 Wrong again. 
 The FTA investment-trust index over the same period achieved 88.2%. 
 True, that includes holdings abroad in earthquaked markets like Japan, so the comparison is a mite unfair. 
 But the moral is the same. 
 Aunt Agatha would indeed have been wiser to stuff her money under a mattress; or, better, in &mdash; yes &mdash; a building society, a bank or even, like great-grandpapa, 2.5% Consols.  
 Financial services in Europe 
 Single, but not level 
 BRUSSELS 
 THE 1992 programme is going to run a bit late for the European Community's financial-services companies. 
 The earliest that the whole &mdash; more or less &mdash; of the industry will be able to take advantage of its single market now looks like being mid-1994. 
 That is the European Commission's unstated timetable for EC member countries to implement its third life-insurance directive, whose draft it published on February 20th. 
 The directive, which follows a similar directive on non-life insurance published in draft a few months ago, is the last big element in its push to open financial markets that are still highly protected. 
 The broad idea is that financial-service companies should have the right to operate throughout the EC on the basis of a single &bquo;passport&equo;, issued by the supervisory authority in their home country. 
 The commission hoped to have the main services &mdash; banking, investment and insurance &mdash; all liberalised together at the end of 1992. 
 Now it looks as if only the banking directive, adopted by the Council of Ministers in December 1989, will be operative in time. 
 A draft investment-services directive was submitted by the commission to the council in January 1989, and is much further along the legislative road than the two insurance directives. 
 Yet the obstacles that it has run into make it probable that even it will miss the end-1992 deadline. 
 The directive would let investment banks and stockbrokers serve clients throughout the EC and trade on all EC exchanges, subject only to home-country control. 
 Problems arose last November, when France proposed to curb their freedom to trade securities outside recognised exchanges. 
 This has split the EC into the usual north/south, liberal/interventionist groups. 
 The 12 finance ministers will try again on February 25th, but progress is unlikely. 
 Eventually, a compromise will no doubt be reached; probably one saying that small investors should have their orders executed on official markets unless they want otherwise. 
 But all this will take time to negotiate. 
 The council is unlikely to adopt the directive formally much before the end of this year. 
 Governments will then be hard put to get it on to their national statute books by mid-1993. 
 Do the delays in the investment-services and insurance directives matter? 
 The EC is adept at missed deadlines, and end-1992 was never carved in stone. 
 The trouble is that banks, investment houses and insurers are now in competition with each other. 
 Banks therefore will have a head start over their non-banking rivals in selling competitive products across the EC. 
 Instead of the single, level playing-field for financial services that the Community talks of, the field will indeed be single but still sloping from one end to the other. 
 Senior commission officials say that it is up to national governments to get a move on. 
 This is wishful thinking. 
 On February 19th the British government began consulting with interested parties on last autumn's non-life-insurance draft directive. 
 This process will take months to complete, and only then, say the British, will they be able to begin serious negotiations in the Council of Ministers. 
 The draft life directive, while sharing some principles with the non-life draft, also poses new problems that will take time to resolve. 
 These concern such issues as consumer protection (that is, disclosure, supervision and so on); calculating technical provisions to meet insurers' liabilities; and the removal of certain national provisions like Belgium's ban on life-insurance policies linked to unit trusts. 
 Commission officials say that implementation of the banking directive cannot be delayed until the others too are ready to go into effect. 
 In theory, investment firms and insurers which, after January 1st 1993, feel that EC legislation discriminates against them, might take the commission or the Council of Ministers (or both) to the European Court of Justice for creating conditions of unfair competition. 
 Unlikely: court action is costly, and can easily last two years before judgment &mdash; by when the playing field should be level anyway.  
 The law of the City 
 Lawyers in the City of London grew rich as their financial clients did. 
 Now they too are feeling the pinch 
 IT HAS become clear these past few years that London's investment houses are rather worse at managing their own affairs than their clients'. 
 It is now becoming clear that the same is true of the City of London's many law firms. 
 The troubles of the law firms and of the finance houses are not unconnected. 
 The revenues that washed over both for much of the 1980s flowed from the same wellspring. 
 Business flourished in organising new issues of bonds and shares, loans, privatisations, property deals and much more. 
 League tables came to mean as much for lawyers handling mergers and acquisitions (M&amp;A) as for investment bankers. 
 With the October 1987 stockmarket crash and, now, a British recession, these revenues have vanished as capriciously as they arrived. 
 Securities, banking, property, corporate activity: the collapse of all these businesses is hitting commercial lawyers as much as City banks. 
 According to Acquisitions Monthly, Linklaters &amp; Paines topped the M&amp;A table in 1989 by advising on &pound;31.5 billion (&dollar;50 billion) of bids. 
 True, revenues do not fall in proportion, but last year's leader, Freshfields, handled &pound;5.8 billion. 
 Law firms are also bound to the fortunes of City houses in a more fundamental way. 
 The prospect of London's Big Bang in October 1986 set in train a process of consolidation among banks (British and foreign) and City stockbrokers. 
 As financial firms merged, long-standing relationships with lawyers inevitably were threatened. 
 Law firms started to compete more fiercely with each other &mdash; through &bquo;beauty parades&equo; and even on price &mdash; in a way that would have appeared unseemly a decade earlier. 
 To thrive in this new era, many law firms also merged. 
 London's biggest, Clifford Chance, with 1,000 fee-earners, is the product of a 1987 merger between two partnerships, Coward Chance and Clifford Turner. 
 The third-biggest firm, Lovell White Durrant, with 600 fee-earners, is a 1988 creation. 
 Others pushed out of their specialities into broader areas of business. 
 Firms began to poach partners and to recruit dozens of assistant solicitors and articled clerks. 
 And they paid. 
 Between 1987 and 1989 annual salaries for assistant solicitors rose by well over half, to &pound;20,000&ndash;70,000. 
 The pay that partners took out of their firms rose likewise, to &pound;60,000&ndash;300,000. 
 Some partners have got used to awarding themselves well over &pound;500,000 a year. 
 So long as fees rolled in, all this seemed justifiable. 
 Gross revenues for medium and big firms, for instance, grew by 36% in the year to April 1990, according to the Centre for Interfirm Comparison. 
 Average revenues per staff member leapt from &pound;75,000 to &pound;170,000. 
 Many firms &mdash; when else but at the peak of the property rush? &mdash; then signed up for plush, atriumed premises to house their new recruits. 
 Freshfields's new marbled offices off Fleet Street would pique the ego of the grandest City banker. 
 Herbert Smith, the tenth-largest law firm, with 425 fee-earners, has just moved into six floors (230,000 square feet) of the Broadgate complex, whose rents are already hurting investment banks. 
 Clifford Chance is committed to moving next year out of its half-dozen shoddy buildings into a shiny box, still under construction, on London Wall. 
 From management to limited liability 
 With the high costs of staff and premises, law firms are now more sensitive to down-draughts &mdash; and the recession is blowing over more areas of their business than ever before. 
 Middling and large law firms work on gross profit margins of around 20&ndash;25% (though margins of 50% are not unknown). 
 So unless they cut costs, a fall of that order in gross revenues would wipe out the profits that partners can share. 
 Since last summer, revenues from, eg, M&amp;A, property, issues of securities, and much corporate work have fallen by more than that. 
 The City's ten biggest commercial-law firms are not yet unduly panicked, and probably rightly. 
 Most have a core of solid businesses that ensure that at least parts of the firm are making serious money. 
 Clifford Chance &mdash; a legal undertaker to the Thatcher boom &mdash; has good litigation and insolvency departments. 
 Slaughter and May has a client list of blue-chip companies. 
 Ditto Linklaters &amp; Paines. 
 All the big firms have strong international links that cushion them somewhat from domestic troubles. 
 Small and medium-sized law firms are a different story. 
 Many of these grew wildly over the past few years, and have now seen business vanish. 
 Last autumn Speechly Bircham had to lay off 17 staff, including partners. 
 D.J. 
 Freeman, specialising in property, has laid off a dozen well-paid staff members. 
 Stories abound of partnerships that have not paid themselves for months. 
 Hard times are also showing up overhasty mergers, like the one two years ago between Withers and Crossman Block; they have now demerged. 
 In the current climate new mergers, such as the one this month between Lawrence Graham and Blyth Dutton, creating a 400-strong firm, will be much harder to make work. 
 With nowhere to shelter, some smallish firms may close. 
 Big or small, firms will now need management skills &mdash; a novel, often distasteful notion among lawyers &mdash; no less than legal ones. 
 Some august partnerships, such as Herbert Smith, long disdained the idea of working out what their profitable strengths were and then marketing them hard. 
 Other firms risk going too far the other way, imposing a too-narrow management &mdash; sometimes from outside the profession &mdash; and so alienating partners. 
 They will have to find the right balance between rule by unwieldy committee and by a chosen few (or fewer, as at Clifford Chance, which has a partners' council but where power, in practice, largely rests with the managing partner). 
 Partnerships are a legal stipulation for law firms, and, with unlimited liability, a burden for many. 
 For big firms with growing risks, the costs of professional-negligence insurance rival the rent bill. 
 Unsurprisingly, dinner-table talk often turns to incorporation and limited liability. 
 Many think that these will come before the decade is out. 
 Incorporation would also pave the way for multi-disciplinary practices, which the Law Society now bans. 
 Law firms could thus spread into a wider range of businesses, just as accountants have pushed into management consulting, and commercial banks into stockbroking. 
 Which is, given what has happened to accountants and bankers, a fairly frightening thought. 
 START OF SCIENCE SECTION 
 Cosmology 
 Born-again physics 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 SCIENCE has been accused, now and then, of leaving no space for religion. 
 This is not an allegation that can be levelled at Frank Tipler, a cosmologist at Tulane University in Indiana. 
 He not only has room in his science for God; he tries to create God using only some laws of physics, some simplifying assumptions, some outrageous extrapolations, and truly cosmic gall. 
 As Dr Tipler explained at the AAAS meeting, his first assumption is that life &mdash; in some form or other &mdash; will continue until the end of time. 
 According to at least some physicists, life can be reduced to a matter of information-processing. 
 The end of time, according to modern cosmology, would come about if the universe, which is presently expanding, eventually contracted under its own weight into a big crunch. 
 Everything would then be crowded together in a state of infinite density: the end of the universe. 
 It is here in the big crunch that Dr Tipler looks for God. 
 Cosmologists call the far end of time the c-boundary. 
 Although it can take a panoply of four-dimensional shapes, Dr Tipler prefers it to be a single point; in the manner of the 20th-century Catholic evolutionist and mystic, Teilhard de Chardin, he calls it the omega point. 
 Such a point would be mathematically equivalent to the sum of all other points in time and space. 
 Any ray of light, emitted anywhere in the universe at any time, will arrive at the omega point. 
 Should such a point exist, the end of the universe is 100 billion years away. 
 That is a fair stretch, but it is still a finite length of time. 
 How can an infinite intelligence and life everlasting exist within finite bounds? 
 To answer this difficulty, Dr Tipler distinguishes between &bquo;proper time&equo;, as measured by clocks, and subjective time. 
 The finite age of the universe is measured in proper time. 
 But, between any moment of proper time and the c-boundary, an infinite amount of information-processing is possible. 
 An infinite amount of information-processing allows an infinite amount of life and thought, and thus an infinite amount of subjective time. 
 The information-processing is made possible by the universe's collapse. 
 Every bit of information processed requires energy. 
 Gravitational collapse releases energy; and collapse to a single, dimensionless point releases an infinite amount of it. 
 The potential computing power gets ever bigger as the universe rushes towards the omega point. 
 What will the infinite wisdom of the universe do with itself as it rushes towards that point? 
 Dr Tipler suggests that it will occupy itself with the resurrection of the dead. 
 A computer programme of sufficient complexity, he (and many others) argue, can simulate any human mind to any level of detail required. 
 With infinite computing power, it would therefore be possible to create simulated copies of every person, cockroach, mushroom and Martian that had ever lived. 
 Dr Tipler argues &mdash; hopefully, but un-convincingly &mdash; that a natural tendency towards altruism will ensure that this resurrection is pleasant: heavenly, rather than infernal. 
 In theory it could be both: since any number of copies could be made there might be a surplus of &bquo;resurrected&equo; people. 
 Another difference between Dr Tipler's story and traditional religion is that man leads to God, not vice versa. 
 It is an extraordinary account, but then any vision of life at the end of the universe is bound to be. 
 Earlier this century, some cosmologists argued that it was impossible to theorise coherently about the beginning of the universe, let alone about the end. 
 Whether those arguments are valid or not, they have certainly not been a deterrent: the big bang is an ever-expanding field of research. 
 Dr Tipler's views have the charm of simple, powerful ideas taken to their absolute limits (if not beyond). 
 Given his assumptions, they may be as scientific as any discussion of such distant times and places can be &mdash; though hardly compelling.  
 All in the wrist 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 TOMORROW's moonstruck but musically unaccomplished lover may soon get a chance to serenade with the help of a computer. 
 The computer runs through the song while the serenader adds nuance and expression, straight from his own aching heart. 
 Scientists and musicians have struggled to add feeling to synthesised computer-music ever since Max Mathews first helped to teach computers to play, more than 30 years ago. 
 Now Dr Mathews, a computer musician from Stanford University in California, is trying to find a way of getting people to take charge of music's humanity. 
 At the AAAS meeting, he described his efforts to separate music into its components: the methodical, mechanical parts which suit a computer, and the subtler qualities through which a musician struggles to express his soul. 
 Traditional music teachers will probably frown at his invention. 
 Dr Mathews's &bquo;radio baton&equo; and the conductor program which comes with it promise to liberate musicians from the drudgery of scales and repeated exercises. 
 It is almost ready to go on sale. 
 He predicts that, within two years or so, people will be able to buy it for the price of a cheap piano. 
 In order to perform a pre-programmed masterpiece, all the player has to do is wave a small baton over an electronic array. 
 Radio transmitters in the baton and a surrounding set of receivers track the position and speed of the baton. 
 The computer translates this motion into musicianship. 
 The conductor program sets most of the controls on automatic pilot. 
 The computer takes care of the nuts and bolts of the composition, the component Dr Mathews calls its predetermined part. 
 This is the part that the composer intended the musicians to follow, no matter what. 
 In western music, he believes this consists of the piece's sequence of pitches. 
 If the player tampers with those, he is blamed for hitting a sour note, not praised for a daring interpretation. 
 The baton-wielder is left in charge of what Dr Mathews calls the music's expressive part. 
 This includes phrasing, changes in tempo and dynamic, the precise duration of notes and pauses, the way in which a sound begins and dies away. 
 The electronic batonist can establish his tempo by striking or approaching a surface with the baton, and can shape the music with baton sweeps in different directions. 
 Different sweeps &mdash; sideways, front and back, or up and down &mdash; each alter different musical attributes. 
 Dr Mathews himself can play both the radio baton and also the old-fashioned violin. 
 He finds the baton much easier. 
 It frees him from the awkward contortions of hand and wrist that make violin lessons and practice all too necessary. 
 He admits, though, that moving the baton in three dimensions does take some getting used to. 
 Perhaps the conductor program will indeed succeed in freeing musicians from the constraints of music's pre-determined parts &mdash; namely the notes. 
 People might also start to make a freer kind of music. 
 At the least, Dr  Mathew's  computer-instrument will put music within the grasp of would-be musicians who lack the time or inclination to learn how to play. 
 It might also unleash the musical gifts of the handicapped. 
 Unlikely as it may sound, the conductor program could prove the true value of practice. 
 It will reveal the limitations to the  interpretation  a player can give, say, Bartok's &bquo;Mikrokosmos&equo; without the long hours of practice and thought which are currently necessary for the mastery of both the piano and the music itself. 
 There may be some musical magic which only practice can bestow. 
 And if playing is too easy, it might take all the fun out of it. 
 Music teachers might not frown after all.  
 Sins of the fathers 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 The American Association for the Advancement of Science (AAAS) held its annual meeting this week in Washington, DC. 
 We report on fathers and fetuses; music; the universe as seen through the Hubble space telescope; and the resurrection of the dead, as seen by an imaginative cosmologist 
 DOCTORS have taught pregnant women to be an anxious lot. 
 Mothers have been warned that alcohol and tobacco &mdash; as well as various medicines and other chemicals &mdash; can injure a fetus. 
 This is only half the truth. 
 The evidence is growing that when a man is exposed to the same hazards before siring children, this too can damage the child. 
 Although some birth defects are caused directly in the womb, others can arise indirectly, through damage to sperm or eggs before fertilisation. 
 The effect of smoking may be one example. 
 It is so well known that women who smoke risk giving birth to underweight babies that the labels on cigarette packets in America caution that &bquo;smoking may complicate pregnancy.&equo; 
 What the labels fail to reflect are studies showing the same link with fathers who smoke. 
 According to Devra Lee Davis of the National Academy of Sciences in Washington, whose work was recently published in the Lancet, there are still plenty of things about male smokers that are not understood. 
 She noted, however, that cotenine, a substance that the body can break down only from nicotine, has turned up in the semen of smokers. 
 This may help to explain why male smokers have underweight children. 
 Meanwhile, at the Boston University School of Medicine, Gladys Friedler has been studying the offspring from the pairing of healthy female mice with male mice that have been briefly exposed to chemicals about a week before mating. 
 She described her studies to the AAAS meeting. 
 Some of the males were injected with morphine for a few days and some were given other drugs. 
 Still other male mice spent a single four-hour period inhaling nitrous oxide before being put with females (none of which had been exposed to hazardous chemicals). 
 This gas is better known to dental patients as laughing gas, but it is also a mainstay in the operating theatres of many hospitals. 
 In cases where both men and women have been regularly exposed to it at work, nitrous oxide has been linked to a high rate of miscarriages. 
 Mouse pups born in Dr Friedler's laboratory weighed less at birth and failed to grow or mature as fast as those born of fathers treated (for the sake of comparison) with either salt-water injections or compressed air. 
 The pups also suffered in other less obvious ways. 
 When they are eight weeks old, for example, mouse pups that have been conditioned using mild electric shocks to their feet readily learn to swim through a simple water maze. 
 But mice sired by fathers that had been given morphine learn more slowly. 
 Other effects were even more subtle. 
 Mammalian body temperature is controlled by processes in the brain, which are affected by morphine and other drugs. 
 When Dr Friedler injected morphine into the offspring of mouse fathers who had themselves breathed nitrous oxide, the body temperature of the offspring dropped less than was expected. 
 The underlying puzzle is what makes a male's sperm susceptible to environmental damage &mdash; even more susceptible, in the opinion of some scientists, than a female's eggs, whether fertilised or not. 
 The theory (and it is no more than a theory) goes something like this. 
 From puberty onwards, the testes of the human male (and those of other mammals) produce millions of sperm a day, each of which undergoes many cell divisions before being ejaculated. 
 This makes the sperm, like all rapidly developing cells, especially vulnerable to damage from chemicals or radiation. 
 Curiously, though, it remains more common to protect working women than working men against threats to reproductive health. 
 For example, when it was discovered in the 1970s that male workers in America and Costa Rica had been made permanently sterile by a pesticide called dibromochloropropane, the substance was banned. 
 But when it is discovered that a substance harms women's reproductive health, women of childbearing age are usually kept from jobs that might expose them to it. 
 A case now before America's Supreme Court is drawing attention to such bias. 
 Johnson Controls, a maker of car batteries with plants in 13 states, is pitted against the United Auto Workers Union. 
 The court is to decide (among other things) whether the company may continue to refuse to hire fertile women for jobs that require exposure to lead, or whether its policy is discriminatory. 
 Johnson maintains that men are less vulnerable than women to reproductive damage. 
 Even if this is true &mdash; and it is disputed by animal and human studies &mdash; the argument overlooks the fact that reproductive defects may appear in workers' female children. 
 Besides, the causes of some 60% of birth defects have yet to be discovered: it cannot be assumed that all of them travel down only the female line.  
 The space telescope 
 Salvaged sights 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 MISTY-EYED and shaky, the Hubble space telescope has been an embarrassment to NASA since its launch last April. 
 The mistakes made in the manufacture of the mirror, which is as smooth as could be desired but the wrong shape, have stopped it from seeing many of the faint objects it should be looking at. 
 A jitter, caused by the way the solar panels (which provide power) buckle when the telescope moves into and out of the earth's shadow, disturbs those observations that can be made. 
 The mirror's failing, which spreads starlight around in haloes when it should be concentrated in a point, has masked the effect of the jitter. 
 Were the mirror perfect, the jitter would still be spoiling observations &mdash; and NASA's image. 
 Despite its failings, though, the telescope still has unique abilities to make certain observations. 
 Under the right conditions, its two cameras can take pictures with unprecedented detail. 
 Its spectrographs can analyse the ultraviolet light given off and absorbed by stars, galaxies, gas-clouds and other celestial paraphernalia, something which earthbound observers cannot do because of the ozone layer. 
 Observers, using all the instruments, presented highlights of their results so far to the AAAS meeting. 
 The odd man out is the smallest instrument, the high-speed photometer, which has not yet managed to see anything because its work is hindered by the jitter. 
 Rather than making the observations that were originally planned, the telescope has been trying out various options to see what is possible, and at the same time producing pictures and results to reassure the public that all is not lost. 
 For this purpose, the work done by the spectrographs, which are less affected by the mirror than are the cameras, is not particularly useful, though it may well provide the greatest scientific interest for some time to come. 
 To the untrained eye, pretty pictures count for more than interesting spectra; neither are they without scientific interest. 
 The faint-object camera, for example, has produced images of a fascinating &bquo;Einstein cross&equo;. 
 What looks like a four-leafed clover in the centre of a galaxy is in fact a product of gravitational lensing; the four leaves of the clover are four different images of a quasar far more distant than the galaxy in which they seem to nestle. 
 The mass of that galaxy bends the rays of light from the quasar as relativity says it must, to produce these mirages. 
 Studying the cross reveals things about the galaxy doing the lensing: other lenses may reveal details about the objects they magnify. 
 The faint-object camera has also been looking at the remnants of the supernova which excited astronomers in 1987. 
 Around the debris of the supernova there is a ring made up of matter lost from the star before the explosion, now illuminated by the supernova's light. 
 Studies of the ring have improved estimates of the distance to the supernova. 
 There was a delay between the time the ring started to glow and the point at which the glowing reached its peak, because light from the near side of the ring arrived at the earth while light from the far side was still on its way. 
 The lag between near-side light and far-side light provides a measure of the distance across the ring. 
 An older and smaller satellite, the International Ultraviolet Explorer (IUE), has recorded the ring's changing brightness, but has been unable to produce a clear image of it. 
 With the IUE's data on the ring's real size and the Hubble's picture showing its apparent size, it is possible to measure the distance to the supernova to an accuracy within 5%. 
 Previous estimates have been accurate only to within 12%. 
 A nice piece of work; but bear in mind that a much more ambitious measurement, which would have taken the biggest chunk of the Hubble's observing time, is completely beyond the telescope's present capacity, because it involves seeing faint variable stars in far-off galaxies. 
 The wide-field/planetary camera has produced its share of dramatic pictures, including detailed ones of a storm on Saturn the like of which has not been seen for 60 years. 
 Perhaps its most spectacular snapshots are of a red giant star called h Carinae. 
 It is a star in serious trouble, with bright bloated lobes of gas swelling off it, announcing its death throes. 
 Theory says it will soon become a supernova, and though &bquo;soon&equo; in this context means within 1m years, no other star has been diagnosed as being closer to death's door. 
 According to present plans, the wide-field camera will be replaced by a space-shuttle mission in 1993. 
 Its successor will be better, and contain extra lenses that should offset the effects of the bungled mirror. 
 At the same time the malfunctioning solar arrays will be replaced, and the poor little photometer will probably have its place usurped by mirrors and lenses to clear the vision of the faint-object camera and the spectrographs. 
 Until then, the space telescope will continue to do what it can. 
 That is still a lot; but, for a machine which cost more than &dollar;2 billion to build and launch, and which costs &dollar;250m a year to keep running, it is not enough. 
 THE GULF WAR 
 Our article last week on the Pope, the war and Israel mistakenly translated inutile strage  as &bquo;useless struggle&equo;. 
 It should have been &bquo;useless slaughter&equo;. 
 The principle is the same: the Pope finds the present war inutile  both in itself and in its effects. 
 But we apologise nonetheless.  
 Waiting for Aziz 
 FIVE weeks into the war, it felt eerily like a replay of its tense beginning. 
 Once again Saddam Hussein appeared to have been given an 11th-hour chance to stop the slaughter; once again, the powerful American-led military coalition was crouched, set to pounce. 
 But in January the Iraqi leader's flat disdain for a diplomatic alternative made the start of the war to liberate Kuwait straightforward for America and its allies. 
 Now, with Iraq sending signals, however foggy, about its readiness to withdraw from Kuwait, the allies' decision has become tougher &mdash; and complicated by the definition of their war aims. 
 Iraq might, even at this stage, have stopped the war if it could have brought itself to accept, quickly, the diplomatic initiative advanced this week by the Soviet Union. 
 This proposes, in essence, that Iraq should get out of Kuwait straightaway in return for being left alone afterwards. 
 The effect of the air war on Iraq has been cruel. 
 Its deputy prime minister, Saadoun Hammadi, says that 20,000 Iraqis &mdash; soldiers and civilians &mdash; have been killed; American military men talk of Iraq's &bquo;horrendous&equo; military casualties. 
 The allies calculate that they have already dropped on Iraqi targets about one-quarter of the total tonnage of bombs dropped on Germany in the whole of the second world war, and destroyed one-third of Iraq's tanks and artillery in Kuwait. 
 But on Thursday afternoon (when The Economist went to press) the signals were dismal. 
 In a fumbling radio speech to his people, Mr Hussein spoke of fighting on &mdash; or leaving Kuwait on Iraq's own terms. 
 He said nothing of the Soviet plan. 
 It looked as if Iraq, once again, could be muffing its chance. 
 With allied generals proclaiming the absolute readiness, in all ways, of the coalition forces to move from air assault to combined land-and-air assault, a full ground battle seemed imminent. 
 Details of the Soviet initiative were kept secret but reports in the German newspaper Bild (Chancellor Helmut Kohl was noticeably the first foreign leader to be told about the proposal) and elsewhere revealed its outline. 
 The main point is that Iraq should withdraw immediately and completely from Kuwait (in line with UN Security Council Resolution 660, passed on the day Iraq invaded Kuwait). 
 In return, the Soviet Union pledges its support for the sanctity of Iraq's own borders, promises to veto any attempt to impose penalties on Iraq, including any trial of Mr Hussein himself, and commits itself to helping to arrange a subsequent international discussion of regional issues. 
 It proposes a timetable for withdrawal, laying down that the Iraqis should start to leave at once, within a day of a ceasefire, and that they should be allowed to do so safely. 
 All that was needed was a positive reply from Mr Hussein. 
 The proposal was handed to Tariq Aziz, Iraq's foreign minister, in Moscow on February 18th, with urgent instructions from Alexander Bessmertnykh, the Soviet foreign minister, to be brisk in delivering his boss's reply: with the American-led troops straining at the leash, he was asked to return in the shortest possible time. 
 But the minister's travels between Moscow and Baghdad, by way of Tehran, and back again, partly overland since the Americans said they could not guarantee his safety in Iraqi airspace, seemed dilatory. 
 Mr Aziz's initial reaction encouraged the Russians to believe that they would get a good reply, and get it promptly. 
 The minister's conversations with his Iranian opposite number, Ali Akhbar Velayati, led the Iranian to say that he thought Iraq was indeed ready to withdraw from Kuwait but might have conditions. 
 After much uncertainty it became plain that the Russians could not expect Mr Aziz to return to Moscow until late on Thursday; he was expected to go at once to see Mikhail Gorbachev. 
 Yevgeny Primakov, Mr Gorbachev's envoy in Gulf matters, had already appealed for the full ground war to be delayed until the Iraqis cough up their answer. 
 But dithering and equivocation could be fatal. 
 The Soviet initiative builds on the &bquo;peace offer&equo; broadcast by Iraq's own Revolutionary Command Council on February 15th. 
 This was rubbished by western leaders for its jumble of fantasy demands and conditions: George Bush called it a &bquo;cruel hoax&equo;; John Major, a &bquo;bogus sham&equo;. 
 But its importance was not in its wish-list. 
 For the first time Mr Hussein appeared to acknowledge publicly that to save Iraq (and no doubt himself) he must first surrender Kuwait. 
 Iraqis, battered by the intense bombing of Baghdad, joyously &mdash; and prematurely &mdash; celebrated the news that they might be about to lose their 19th province. 
 When the Soviet plan reached Mr Bush, he welcomed it politely but with undisguised dismay. 
 His first public comment was to say dismissively that it fell &bquo;well short of what would be required&hellip; 
 The goals have been set out. 
 There will be no concessions.&equo; 
 This was generally interpreted as an American rejection of the proposal, though the White House fell over itself to explain that it was not. 
 Since the proposal was addressed to Mr Hussein, it was not, in theory, for the Americans to reject &mdash; only to ignore. 
 However to ignore a diplomatic alternative, even an inadequate one, that got Iraq out of Kuwait would be difficult. 
 True, there would be argument about how or whether Iraq was to be made to conform with clauses in the 11 other relevant Security Council resolutions and horror at the thought of the Iraqi regime surviving with its army and air force still largely undestroyed. 
 Allied governments have sent the Russians several extra conditions to set before Iraq, most of them designed to make withdrawal as humiliating as possible for Mr Hussein. 
 The last thing they all want is a Saddam bloody but unbowed (President Bush, for the first time, last week urged the Iraqis to take matters into their own hands and force Saddam to &bquo;step aside&equo;). 
 But getting rid of the Iraqi dictator would be, as James Baker, the secretary of state says, a desirable side-effect, not the central objective endorsed by the United Nations and most countries in the world. 
 If Mr Hussein had the wit to get out of Kuwait before the Americans and their allies can push him out, the war would have lost its overriding purpose &mdash; and the coalition might at last have lost its cohesiveness. 
 But has he? 
 Probably he has not.  
 Saddam's microbes 
 ALLIED commanders fully expect the Iraqis to turn chemical weapons on them once the ground fighting starts in earnest. 
 They are less sure, but more afraid, of the possibility that Saddam Hussein has developed biological weapons as well. 
 Britain and America are worried enough to have produced enough serum to immunise their troops against anthrax, one of the biological agents he is most likely to have. 
 Like most countries, Iraq joined the Biological and Toxin Weapons Convention of 1972, under which signatories undertook &bquo;never in any circumstances to develop, produce, stockpile or otherwise acquire or retain&equo; such weapons. 
 The Iraqis claim that they have stuck by the convention, but are widely disbelieved. 
 The big question is whether they have mastered the complicated job of putting bugs from a laboratory inside a useful battlefield weapon. 
 The complication has less to do with breeding nasty bugs, more to do with keeping them alive. 
 They must survive the heat and other stresses involved in putting them into a warhead that can disperse them in a fine mist over enemy positions. 
 They are liable to die in storage. 
 And they must survive the launch itself. 
 If the warhead is delivered by artillery, the stresses of acceleration may kill the germs. 
 So may explosive charges used to burst the warheads open. 
 Spraying the aerosol is the best way to get them on to the enemy, but even this is difficult. 
 The germs have to be prevented from getting too hot or cold during the loading and flight of the aircraft that is to spray them. 
 The aerosol droplets have to be just the right size: too big and they may get trapped in noses, too small and they tend to be exhaled without staying in the lungs. 
 And it is necessary to fly low and slow directly over the enemy to spray him. 
 Anthrax is popular with germ warriors. 
 It is easy to make and its spores are tough. 
 Britain experimentally contaminated a Scottish island with them during the second world war, and the place was considered dangerous until 1986. 
 With a big dose, around 90% of the victims would die within 24&ndash;36 hours. 
 But biological weapons are unlikely to be much used on troops in combat, mainly because of the difficulties of getting the aerosols on to them without seeing them drift back on to those who released them. 
 In addition, soldiers in Saudi Arabia will get some protection from their gas masks, which will filter out more than 99% of aerosol particles.  
 Soviet hawks fly again 
 THE Gulf war has revived a strain of anti-Americanism in the Soviet army, dressed up as support for Iraq. 
 Since the war began, Soviet military commentators, including senior serving officers, have been expressing dismay at seeing Iraq's army, most of whose tanks and aircraft they supplied, pounded so relentlessly and effectively. 
 They questioned the American battle-damage assessments, and implied that the Iraqis were conserving their strength. 
 Major-General Viktor Filatov, the editor of a Soviet military journal, prophesied this month that the Americans would take a pasting once the ground fight began. 
 Startled by the systematic destruction of the force they had helped the Iraqis to build, the military critics have since grown bolder. 
 Until recently Saddam Hussein was supported only by a lunatic fringe in the Soviet Union; the leader of Pamyat, an anti-Semitic group, praised him for standing up to Zionism. 
 Then, on February 13th, a group of senior political officers from the army and KGB border guards openly condemned the war. 
 Mr Gorbachev's adviser on military affairs, Marshal Sergei Akhromeev, has said that the allied operation contravenes UN resolutions, which are concerned only with the liberation of Kuwait. 
 &bquo;Strikes&equo;, he said, &bquo;are being launched against the people and the Iraqi economy. 
 This cannot be tolerated any longer.&equo; 
 Marshal Akhromeev admitted that his views differed from Mr Gorbachev's. 
 He implied that those of all the top brass did too, and that the president was changing his attitude to the war because of that. 
 The widespread opposition, especially from some army members of parliament, to lending Soviet troops in any form to the anti-Iraqi coalition was one factor in the resignation last December of the Soviet foreign minister, Edward Shevardnadze. 
 New Times has pondered whether there would be such vehement opposition about sending &bquo;our boys&equo; abroad again if they were to be sent to fight for Iraq. 
 After 20 years of close co-operation, it would not be surprising if there were a pro-Iraq lobby inside the Soviet ministry of defence. 
 After more than 40 years of hostility, it is not surprising that there is an anti-American lobby too. 
 Some of the worries are genuine enough. 
 Iraq is after all only a few hundred miles from the Soviet Union's own (Muslim-dominated) southern border. 
 Early in the war Soviet southern troops were put on high alert. 
 Military pressure on Mr Gorbachev to find a quick way of ending the war stems from a bigger worry: that, by letting America take over conduct of the war, the Soviet Union will see its influence suffer in the region, especially if American troops stay on once the fighting is over. 
 The suspicion of America's motives is deep-seated and extends beyond its policy in the Gulf. 
 Many Soviet commentators, including Marshal Akhromeev, have criticised America's determination to keep NATO in being despite the collapse of the Warsaw Pact. 
 Soviet military planners tried to circumvent the treaty cutting conventional forces in Europe, because they thought the cuts agreed on by their foreign ministry went too deep. 
 They now point to another threat: that the Americans will use the Gulf battlefields to test new weapons and so keep an arms race going, for quality if not quantity. 
 Before the Gulf war the Soviet armed forces were already reeling from a series of knocks delivered by Mr Gorbachev: the arms-cutting treaties, unilateral cuts and reorganisations, and the switch to a cost-cutting &bquo;defensive&equo; doctrine. 
 To those Soviet generals determined to cling to the notion that the West remains a threat to Soviet security, the Gulf war represents another defeat for Soviet interests, whatever now happens to Iraq.  
 Europe's post-war plans 
 Doing its best 
 FROM OUR BRUSSELS CORRESPONDENT 
 WHEN three European foreign ministers trooped off to Moscow last week, Mikhail Gorbachev talked politely about the Gulf war but failed to mention the peace plan he was about to launch. 
 The European Community should by now be used to such snubs. 
 The EC has had little to say about the Gulf, and to that few have listened. 
 This bothers the commission's president, Jacques Delors, who thinks the Community has a part to play in the Middle East. 
 So, in varying degrees, do the 12 foreign ministers. 
 They have now decided, at a meeting in Luxembourg, that there is one thing the EC cannot do and three things it can. 
 It cannot offer the territorial guarantees or military equipment that provide &bquo;hard security&equo;. 
 It can help the softer sort by encouraging a variant of the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe. 
 A CSCE for the Mediterranean and the Middle East could encourage better behaviour by countries towards their neighbours and their citizens. 
 The Italians want such a group created right away, the British once the region's disputes are settled (whenever that may be). 
 Second, economic aid. 
 The Community is already giving some of this: it set aside 500m ecus (&dollar;685m) from this year's budget for the three &bquo;front-line&equo; states: Jordan, Egypt and Turkey. 
 It also has trade and co-operation agreements with several Middle Eastern countries and wants to have more. 
 It would like something similar to the G-24 that co-ordinates western aid to Eastern Europe. 
 The commission would act as secretary, rich Arab countries would pay the biggest whack. 
 The Saudis, according to the commission, like the idea. 
 In all, the EC has promised aid worth &dollar;7 billion to the region. 
 That is enough for now, thinks Britain's foreign secretary, Douglas Hurd. 
 The region's problems are mainly political, in his view, and he does not want more strains on the Community budget. 
 Southern Europeans, alarmed by the thought of a wave of immigrants, are keener, especially since their northern colleagues will pay a larger share. 
 American diplomats are more enthusiastic about the commission's economic plans than the British are. 
 But they are less enthusiastic about the third thing the Europeans want to do. 
 That is to try for a solution to the Arab-Israeli conflict through a United Nations peace conference.  
 Israel and America 
 Bad behaviour 
 OUTRAGEOUS and outside the bounds of acceptable behaviour&hellip;&equo; thundered the White House. 
 The culprit? 
 Israel, whose new ambassador in Washington had complained to the press on February 14th that America was giving Israel the &bquo;runaround&equo; on housing aid for Soviet immigrants (the administration wanted to be sure that &dollar;400m in loan guarantees, now agreed, would not be used to settle immigrants in the West Bank). 
 He added that the Americans had also failed to compensate Israel for its financial sufferings in the Gulf war. 
 George Bush dashed off a furious telegram to Yitzhak Shamir, Israel's prime minister. 
 By saying sorry, Israel cooled the spat &mdash; for now. 
 Israelis speak of a &bquo;Scud-induced honeymoon&equo; between themselves and the Americans. 
 A &bquo;respite&equo; might be more precise. 
 Israeli officials crow over America's new appreciation of their country's difficulties &mdash; all those maps, for instance, that drive home just how small Israel is &mdash; but there is not much reason to believe that post-war relations between the Bush administration and the Shamir government will be any cosier than the pre-war ones were. 
 Greed is the least of the problems, though the administration was not amused when Israel pushed its luck by suggesting that to help with its Gulf expenses &mdash; missile damage, the cost of the prolonged military alert, loss of tourism and so on &mdash; America might like to double the &dollar;3 billion it already gives Israel each year. 
 Israel hopes to extract the maximum from giving in to American pressure &mdash; applied by the withholding of aircraft identification codes &mdash; not to join in the war. 
 America, in the middle of destroying Iraq's army, and having given Israel Patriot air-defence missiles, crews and intelligence, is uncertain whether it should still be considered in Israel's debt. 
 The graver problems await the end of the war. 
 It is increasingly taken for granted that any post-war reordering of the Middle East will include a fresh bid to break the Arab-Israeli impasse. 
 And here the Shamir government is busy sending negative signals. 
 It has reiterated Israel's long-maintained refusal to consider returning any of the Golan Heights to Syria, adding, for good measure, that the Syrian regime is as bad as the Iraqi one. 
 And it has made it clear that any attempt to organise a system of regional arms control or supervision should exclude Israel. 
 Much worse, the Israeli cabinet now includes a far-right politician who advocates &bquo;transferring&equo; the Palestinians from the occupied territories. 
 It is said that Mr Shamir appointed Rehavam Zeevi, who runs a party called Moledat (Homeland), as minister-without-portfolio in his inner cabinet mainly for coalition reasons: he wanted to increase his narrow majority and to avoid being attacked from outside it by the extreme right. 
 To their credit, several cabinet members, including the defence and foreign ministers, opposed the choice of Mr Zeevi who is seen by many people as successor to the late Meir Kahane. 
 Yet the appointment shows how little Mr Shamir cares for America's good opinion &mdash; and how far his thoughts are from any Arab-Israeli accommodation. 
 Israelis, naturally, want Saddam Hussein resoundingly defeated. 
 But a convoluted new thought is breaking surface. 
 Maybe, it is murmured, an indecisive, messy sort of ending might be better for Israel than a clear-cut one. 
 Then, at least, Israel might not have to respond in a clear-cut way.  
 Arab monarchs 
 Jordan's Hussein at his wits' end 
 Tale of two kings: the rallying of their people to Saddam Hussein is causing trouble both for Jordan's Hussein and for Morocco's Hassan 
 FOR as long as most people can remember, the stocky figure, big head and proud, tight smile of Jordan's King Hussein have symbolised stability in the wildness of the Middle East. 
 The king was educated in Britain &mdash; at Harrow and Sandhurst &mdash; and seemed to share many of its values. 
 Now, however, he and his western friends are speaking a different language. 
 The king has starkly denounced the &bquo;savage&equo; American-led war against Iraq. 
 After one of his recent speeches, George Bush said that Jordan had &bquo;moved over, way over, into Saddam Hussein's camp&equo;. 
 The United States is reviewing the small amount of aid &mdash; about &dollar;55m a year &mdash; it gives its erstwhile friend. 
 The commonest explanation of King Hussein's behaviour is that he is only doing what he has always done best: surviving. 
 If you are king of a country in which six out of every ten people are Palestinians, and where Islamic fundamentalism is growing, you do not last long by siding with America against the man who is firing missiles into Tel Aviv. 
 There may be more to it. 
 People who know him well say the Kuwaiti affair has affected him deeply, chipping away at his pro-western instincts, and instilling in him a deep pessimism about the future of the region. 
 These days the king goes out of his way to remind listeners that he is the senior representative of the Hashemites, &bquo;the noblest family in Islam&equo; and the traditional guardians of Mecca and Medina until they were thrown out by the al-Saud family in 1925. 
 He called the speech that upset George Bush &bquo;an appeal from a Hashemite Arab to all honest Arab and Muslim leaders&equo;. 
 In it the king suggested that American plans for the Gulf were like the secret Sykes-Picot agreement of 1916, in which Britain and France carved up Turkey's former Arab provinces. 
 This is quite an insult. 
 The agreement contradicted the promise of Arab self-rule that Britain had made to Sherif Hussein of Mecca (King Hussein's great-grandfather) and has become a byword for duplicity. 
 For most of his life the king has been haunted by the Arab-Israeli conflict. 
 His decision in 1967 to support Nasser in the six-day war cost Jordan its western half and ended Arab control of Jerusalem, Islam's third-holiest city. 
 In 1988, after the Palestinians of the West Bank and Gaza had started their uprising, he made another fateful decision, renouncing Jordan's claim to the West Bank and handing over responsibility to the Palestine Liberation Organisation. 
 Since then his disenchantment with the West appears to have grown. 
 He talks of slavish American support for an intransigent Israel, and says this is why there is no peace. 
 The personal friendship between the Hashemite monarch and Saddam Hussein is harder to understand. 
 In December the king told the Washington Post that the Iraqi leader was &bquo;confident, determined to do his utmost, not for himself, but for the region and its future&equo;. 
 This was not the Saddam Hussein the rest of the world knows. 
 After negotiating a host of wars, coups and other crises in 38 turbulent years on the throne, the king is now showing the strain. 
 Grey-faced and grim, he is looking older than his 55 years. 
 His brother, Crown Prince Hassan, is 12 years younger and taking an increasingly prominent part in state affairs. 
 Some Jordanians suggest that, if the war ends badly for him, the king might let the crown prince take his place.  
 Hassan checked 
 FROM A SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN RABAT 
 HIS grip is of iron, his political skill is legendary. 
 But even King Hassan's powers are strained by the Gulf war. 
 When Iraq's tanks rolled into Kuwait last August, the Moroccan king again proved himself a staunch friend to America and Saudi Arabia. 
 His government was the first Arab one to condemn the Iraqi invasion, and the first to send troops (around 1,300 of them) to join the alliance in Saudi Arabia. 
 But his people overwhelmingly support Saddam Hussein. 
 The king has prudently deferred to them. 
 He has refused, so far, to bring the Moroccan troops home, but has issued a pamphlet explaining that they are not under allied command, and will not attack Iraq. 
 He has publicly criticised the bombing of Iraq, and gone out of his way not to offend his &bquo;dear Arab brother&equo;, Saddam Hussein. 
 On February 16th he called Iraq's conditional offer to withdraw from Kuwait &bquo;a positive step to peace&equo;. 
 No other member of the American-led coalition has said that. 
 On February 3rd he had tried to relax the tension by allowing a pro-Iraqi demonstration by the opposition, including the Islamic movement. 
 For this unprecedented event some 300,000 people turned out &mdash; so many, in fact, that they ran out of American, Israeli, French and British flags, and had to make their own crude copies before they could burn them. 
 The size and sincerity of the rally, for Iraq and against Morocco's traditional allies, seemed to rattle the king. 
 He has often shown himself ready to make concessions when faced with genuine mass discontent. 
 But he banned a further demonstration, planned for February 24th in Casablanca; and if the ban is not obeyed, there could be big trouble. 
 For most of his 30 years on the throne, King Hassan has ruled severely, in truly regal style. 
 (The budget is tight, but he is building his 11th, or maybe 12th, palace.) 
 Most of the middle class respects him, and many of the poor revere him. 
 One of his titles is &bquo;Commander of the Faithful&equo;, and many pious Muslims prefer him to more modern-sounding fundamentalists. 
 But these are hard times for Moroccans, what with a &dollar;22 billion foreign debt, a depressed market for the country's main export, phosphates, and the after-effects of a long drought. 
 The affair in the Gulf has made things much worse. 
 It has depressed the tourist industry, Morocco's biggest single source of foreign currency, and ended remittances from Moroccan workers in Kuwait. 
 Now the king's opponents seek to unite the discontented behind Saddam Hussein's banner. 
 Last December strikes turned into riots in which at least 33 people were killed and hundreds injured; 900 people were jailed, the ringleaders for 15 years. 
 The king says he will impose martial law if anything similar happens again. 
 Opposition politicians are screwing up their courage. 
 Faced with public anger about the Gulf war, the royal autocrat did make some concessions. 
 Maybe he might do the same on political reform.  
 SCHOOLS BRIEF 
 Of bees and lighthouses 
 This brief in our series on the modern classics of economics looks at a paper that is still as controversial as when it first appeared &mdash; and suddenly much more relevant to the debate on economic policy. 
 It set out to demolish traditional thinking on &bquo;public goods&equo; and &bquo;externalities&equo; 
 THE PROBLEM OF SOCIAL COST. 
 By Ronald Coase. 
 Journal of Law and Economics 2, October 1960 
 MOST economists, including many who would claim otherwise, find the paradigm of perfect competition indispensable for thinking about questions of resource allocation and microeconomic efficiency. 
 Every novice student learns the elementary propositions of welfare economics. 
 These assert that, under perfect competition, market forces will cause resources to be used in such a way that it is impossible to make somebody better off without making somebody else worse off &mdash; in this sense, perfect competition avoids waste. 
 Such a pattern of resource allocation is called a Pareto optimum. 
 While learning this, the novice student also learns that perfect competition does not exist. 
 It requires, among other things, that there be so many buyers and sellers that none can affect prices; if a firm cuts its output it will not push up the price. 
 It requires all the goods produced by different producers in any particular market to be &bquo;homogeneous&equo; (ie, identical). 
 It requires &bquo;perfect information&equo;. 
 It requires there to be markets not just for actual goods but also for &bquo;contingent goods&equo; (eg, the market for umbrellas in London next January if it is an unusually rainy month). 
 And so on. 
 One strand of modern research has devoted itself to the ferociously difficult task of building formal models that precisely state the conditions that are necessary and sufficient for competition to work, and describe whether and in what sense the result is &bquo;efficient&equo;. 
 The landmarks are &bquo;Existence of an Equilibrium for a Competitive Economy&equo; by Kenneth Arrow and Gerard Debreu (published in 1954) and &bquo;General Competitive Analysis&equo; by Mr Arrow and Frank Hahn (published in 1971). 
 That these were towering intellectual achievements is not in doubt; however, their influence &mdash; outside the narrow circle of specialists in pure microeconomic theory &mdash; was not great. 
 Almost all modern economists, however much they might resist such classification, are drawn to one of two camps. 
 The first believes that perfect competition is a useful paradigm that policymakers should take as a guide; this is the liberalising, deregulating, competition-promoting wing of the profession. 
 The other, the interventionist wing, holds that the paradigm is a dangerous one that policymakers should ignore. 
 In choosing where their loyalty lies, the prejudice that probably matters most is their view on public goods and externalities. 
 Smokestack economics 
 One of the assumptions underlying the idea of a Pareto optimum is that private costs and benefits are the same as social costs and benefits. 
 In practice, this is not always so. 
 The price you pay for your lawnmower does not reflect the cost to your neighbours of the noise it makes when you use it. 
 The price people and firms pay for their carbon fuels does not reflect the cost to everybody else of filling the atmosphere with greenhouse gases. 
 These are examples of externalities &mdash; the economic effects that a transaction has on third parties. 
 Most economists define public goods in terms of &bquo;non-excludability&equo; and &bquo;non-rivalrous consumption&equo;. 
 Clean air is an example of non-excludability: if some people incur costs to avoid pollution, those who do not pay cannot be excluded from the benefits. 
 They will be tempted to free-ride at others' expense, and producers of clean air would have trouble collecting payment for their services. 
 (In a sense, non-excludability is the obverse of externality.) 
 Clean air, by and large, also serves as an example of nonrivalrous consumption: by breathing, you do not perceptibly reduce the supply of air for others. 
 This means that, even if it were possible to deal with free-riders by making them breathe dirty air, it would be economically inefficient to do so. 
 If, at the margin, a good can be provided costlessly, efficiency demands that it be provided free. 
 This is another way of stating the old rule that price should be set equal to marginal cost. 
 Together, non-excludability and non-rivalrous consumption imply that clean air is a public good. 
 There cannot be an efficient private market for it. 
 The social benefits of maintaining the supply of clean air will exceed the private benefits of doing so. 
 Unless governments use taxes, subsidies and other forms of intervention to promote it, too little will be supplied. 
 The crucial question for policy-makers is this: how common are externalities and public goods? 
 For years it seemed they were common enough to turn the competitive paradigm into something of little practical use. 
 Standard examples were drummed into students' heads. 
 The favourite illustration of a public good was the lighthouse: the conditions of non-excludability and non-rivalrous consumption were both met, and it was obvious that if governments did not provide lighthouses nobody would. 
 The favourite example of an externality, odd as it might seem, was bee-keeping. 
 Here the externality was a benefit, not a cost: bee-keepers provide pollination services for local growers of flowers and fruit. 
 Because they are not paid for this service, there may be a socially less-than-optimal amount of bee-keeping. 
 Theory concerned itself mainly with asking what form government intervention should take. 
 For instance, part of the trouble in the clean-air example is that nobody owns the air; if somebody did, polluters would not be able to dirty it with impunity. 
 Traditional microeconomic theory stressed this link between property rights and efficiency. 
 It is part of the government's job, on this view, to allocate property rights in an efficiency-promoting way. 
 Then, in 1960, Ronald Coase of the University of Virginia published &bquo;The Problem of Social Cost&equo;. 
 Mr Coase argued that, as a rule, no form of government action is required to deal with externalities or public goods. 
 There is no need for taxes, subsidies and public provision; and so long as property rights already exist, there is no need for energetic policies aimed at shifting them around. 
 The article caused a rethink in microeconomics, a rethink that is still going on. 
 It spurred the growth of a distinct new branch of the subject, called &bquo;law and economics&equo;. 
 And it converted many more economists to the liberal, anti-interventionist wing of their trade. 
 Choo choo 
 Mr Coase's favourite case of externality was an American icon, the wood-burning locomotive &mdash; whose sparks, regrettably, were prone to set fire to farmers' fields. 
 According to the conventional thinking, what matters in such a case is the allocation of property rights. 
 Suppose farmers have a right in law to enjoin the railway company not to set fire to their fields: the result is that the company will fit spark-suppressing equipment to their trains, and there will be less damage to the farmers' fields. 
 Alternatively, if the company has an unfettered right to spray as many sparks as it likes, there will be plenty of damage to fields. 
 Mr Coase asked if this analysis was good economics, and showed that it was not. 
 His main point was simply that legal entitlements &mdash; property rights &mdash; can be bought and sold. 
 They are commodities whose exchange can be analysed like that of any other. 
 If farmers can legally insist that locomotives are spark-free, they can sell this right to the railway. 
 If the railway is free to spark as much as it likes, farmers can pay them to reduce the sparks that locomotives emit. 
 Not only that, but the outcome will be the same in either case. 
 Suppose farmers have a right to stop the sparks. 
 If this right to emit sparks is worth more to the railway than stopping the sparks is to the farmers (because suppressing sparks is costly, say), then the railway will buy the right to emit sparks from the farmers, and the damage will continue. 
 Suppose instead that the railway is entitled to emit sparks &mdash; but that this right is still worth more to the railway than to the farmers. 
 In that case, the right will not be sold, and the damage will continue. 
 There is one difference. 
 The initial allocation of property rights affects the distribution of income; in other words, if you own something, you are better off than if you do not. 
 But the allocation makes no difference at all to the amount of resources devoted to suppressing sparks. 
 Economic forces ensure that the same efficient allocation will happen in either case. 
 This idea is known as the Coase theorem. 
 Though quick to qualify it, people with a taste for economics usually react with delight to Mr Coase's insight. 
 Others find it annoying: &bquo;All very well in theory, but how often do you see deals like that in practice?&equo; 
 It is a fair question, and it deserves to be taken seriously. 
 Inspired by Mr Coase, economists began to look more carefully than before for transactions in property rights. 
 One of the most telling studies &mdash; because it scored a direct hit on the interventionists' favourite example &mdash; was a paper published in 1973 by Steven Cheung, then at the University of Washington: &bquo;The Fable of the Bees&equo;. 
 Down on the apiary 
 Mr Cheung examined the bee-keeping industry in Washington. 
 The state's farmers and bee-keepers might not have realised that they were coping with an externality, but that had not stopped them from organising a market. 
 Mr Cheung wrote: &bquo;It is easy to find conclusive evidence showing that both nectar and pollination services are transacted in the marketplace: in some cities one need look no further than the yellow pages of the local telephone directory.&equo; 
 But he looked beyond the telephone book, and studied pricing and contracts in some detail. 
 He found a surprisingly sophisticated pattern of prices (varying according to the sort of crop pollinated, the density of hives available, the risk of pesticides damaging the bees and so on). 
 Mr Cheung showed that this pattern of pricing was, by and large, efficient. 
 In 1974 Mr Coase turned his own attention to lighthouses &mdash; an example of supposed market failure with an even longer pedigree than the fable of the bees. 
 &bquo;The Lighthouse in Economics&equo; sketched the history of lighthouses in Britain since the 17th century. 
 It showed that lighthouses can be &mdash; and typically have been &mdash; provided by private enterprise. 
 In the early days, shipowners and shippers petitioned the Crown to let somebody build a lighthouse and charge a specified levy on the ships that benefited from it. 
 These charges were collected at the ports by agents for the lighthouses. 
 &bquo;The lighthouses were built, operated, financed and owned by private individuals, who could sell the lighthouse or dispose of it by bequest,&equo; Mr Coase found. 
 &bquo;The role of the government was limited to the establishment and enforcement of property rights in the lighthouse.&equo; 
 Responsibility for lighthouses was later shifted to Trinity House, a quasi-public body, but lighthouses continued to be financed by &bquo;light dues&equo; collected from ships, not from general taxation. 
 The Coase theorem and the further work it inspired have demolished the presumption that externalities and public goods automatically call for government intervention. 
 But they have not replaced it with a presumption that the market can always be left to get on with it. 
 The work of Mr Coase and his followers has made almost all economists, whether broadly liberal or broadly interventionist, more reluctant to generalise. 
 It has also suggested many lines of further research. 
 For instance, the Coase theorem admits that the market will fail if transaction costs are prohibitively high. 
 As a result, economists are much more interested than before in correcting inefficiencies by reducing the costs of doing business; pursuing efficiency through cleverer and more ambitious regulation is definitely out of fashion. 
 Some critics have argued that the Coase theorem stretches the idea of transaction costs too far &mdash; to the point at which the theorem becomes true (but uselessly so) by definition. 
 It is not much help to blame transaction costs for every market failure, as if that makes the failure somehow all right. 
 The theorem, and the model of competition it defends, are at their weakest when trying to account for deals struck between small numbers of transactors &mdash; in other words, when the assumption of many buyers and sellers does not hold. 
 This is not so much a matter of transaction costs as of the unpredictability of offer and counter-offer: it moves economics into the realm of game theory, where efficient outcomes cannot be taken for granted (see box). 
 Sceptics may be willing to concede on bees and lighthouses &mdash; and on many other examples hitherto thought to be market failures &mdash; but the case of clean air remains awkward. 
 It is hard to see how any entirely voluntary, market-driven approach to environmental economics could ever overcome, even in theory, the problem of free-riders. 
 Even here, however, Mr Coase and his colleagues have forced economists to think harder about how to use market forces to achieve green ends, rather than resort too quickly to the blunderbuss of regulation.  
 All in the game 
 THE assumption in traditional microeconomics of many buyers and sellers is all too crucial. 
 When agents are few enough for their decisions to affect others, they are bound to behave &bquo;strategically&equo; &mdash; ie, take those effects, and the likely response of other agents to them, into account. 
 In economics, such behaviour makes even the simplest transaction difficult to analyse. 
 This is the task of game theory. 
 In most bargaining circumstances a deal can be struck that will satisfy all sides. 
 But if there is no agreed way to settle on it, everybody may end up unhappy. 
 The classic illustration is one of the simplest games: the Prisoners' Dilemma. 
 Two prisoners are accused of a crime. 
 The prosecutor tells them that if they both confess they will go to jail for ten years; if neither confesses they will get two years; if only one confesses he (the confessor) will get just one year while his fellow prisoner goes down for 20. 
 If they can come to a binding agreement, the prisoners will both profess their innocence and be sentenced to two years. 
 But suppose they cannot. 
 Each prisoner will then see that &mdash; regardless of what the other does &mdash; he will be better off if he confesses. 
 Both will confess and get ten years. 
 Recently game theory has made strides. 
 Theorists can unravel the structure of extremely complicated games. 
 New research also stresses empirical work, using controlled experiments to see how people behave in real bargaining situations. 
 Fascinating stuff. 
 Unfortunately, it is all too obvious that voluntary agreements among small groups need not be efficient: when the numbers are small, markets are prone to fail. 
 BUSINESS WEEK 
 Making a living 
 With revenues plummeting, airlines clamoured for government support to help them through the bad times. 
 To give themselves ready cash, some American airlines want to keep a 10% ticket tax for up to a year before handing it over to the government. 
 In Europe, after yet another airline made cutbacks &mdash; Air France said it would reduce its wage bill by FFr600m (&dollar;118m) &mdash; the EC is to allow temporary subsidies and will relax rules on route-sharing. 
 More than 1,300 Soviet businessmen, managers and scientists from the state and private sectors are planning to form a business lobby to help fight for a market economy in the Soviet Union. 
 The move is in response to the strengthening of central controls. 
 The Gulf war came too late to help the profits of Turner Broadcasting last year, whose CNN broadcasts from Baghdad since the war started have sent viewership &mdash; and advertising revenues &mdash; soaring. 
 Although things are looking up this year, operating profits in 1990 fell to &dollar;201.3m compared with &dollar;266.1m in the previous year. 
 Canada's Reichmann brothers, whose Olympia &amp; York is developing Canary Wharf in London, sold their 9% stake in Allied-Lyons, a British food and drink group, for &pound;403m (&dollar;790m): useful, as property values slump. 
 Ford's and Volkswagen's Brazilian holding company, Autolatina, is to get rid of 8,000 car workers, 16% of its employees. 
 The company, which has a 60% market share, has seen sales drop by a fifth since November. 
 By adopting the third directive on life assurance, the European Commission cleared the way for a single European insurance market. 
 In the chair 
 Red faces at Hoesch, a German steel and engineering group, because its supervisory board has failed to agree on a new chief executive, and will now have to look outside. 
 Detlev Rohwedder created the vacancy when he stayed on as head of the Treuhandanstalt, the state agency dealing with the privatisation of east German businesses. 
 Formerly a European commissioner, and now the outgoing chairman of Britain's Civil Aviation Authority, Sir Christopher Tugendhat is to become chairman of Abbey National, a building society turned retail bank. 
 Televiews 
 American Telephone and Telegraph extended its &dollar;6.1 billion bid for NCR, an American computer maker, for a second time, to April 30th. 
 Though two-thirds of NCR shareholders have approved the offer, NCR's anti-takeover defences are delaying the purchase. 
 The German postal ministry discovered 23 illegal, private telephone networks in eastern Germany, including one formerly controlled by the secret police, the Stasi. 
 And yet, because of a shortage of telephone lines in the old east, and even though the government has a legal monopoly, it will allow the networks to go on operating for at least another year. 
 Of banks and bonds 
 After an American judge threatened to force Drexel Burnham Lambert into involuntary liquidation, the collapsed New York investment bank has reached a tentative settlement with its creditors. 
 They will cut their claims to an amount which can roughly be covered by the bank's remaining assets of &dollar;2.8 billion while allowing it to carry on operating. 
 Seeking to raise its capital base by up to &dollar;5 billion, Citicorp, America's largest commercial bank, is to sell 20% of its credit-card business for more than &dollar;1 billion. 
 One of the fastest-growing companies of the 1980s, the now-ailing Saatchi &amp; Saatchi, announced a second financial rescue package. 
 The first ran into criticism from some of its bondholders. 
 Saatchi is struggling to get its bankers, shareholders and bondholders to keep the firm going despite a slump in the advertising industry. 
 Trade and commodities 
 GATT's Uruguay round of trade talks jolted into action again &mdash; just. 
 The deadlock over farm-trade reform between Europe and America and its allies was broken when the EC agreed to negotiate cuts in the three areas of internal farm supports, border protection and export subsidies. 
 But Congress's fast-track mandate, good until March 1st, will have to be extended if real progress is to be made. 
 Political opposition and delays in agreeing upon its plan have forced a Japanese robotics maker, Fanuc, to withdraw its offer to buy for &dollar;10m a 40% stake in Moore Special Tool. 
 The Connecticut engineering company does a small amount of sensitive nuclear-weapons work for the American government. 
 After declining for months, the oil price shot up after Saddam Hussein rejected the Soviet Union's peace plan. 
 President Bush outlined his national energy strategy. 
 Among a mish-mash of other measures intended to reduce America's dependence on oil imports, he will allow more domestic exploration and promote fuel efficiency in cars. 
 ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL INDICATORS 
 OUTPUT, DEMAND AND JOBS 
 A gloomy week for statistics. 
 America's industrial production fell for the fourth successive month in January, by 0.4%, to give a 12-month decline of 0.9%. 
 In the past three months output has fallen by an annualised 10.8% from its level during the three previous months. 
 Britain's industrial output fell by 0.4% in December, to 4.2% below its level a year earlier. 
 The 0.9% drop in its GDP in the fourth quarter &mdash; the second fall in a row &mdash; made Britain's recession official. 
 In January unemployment rose in Britain, Australia, Spain and Switzerland. 
 PRICES AND WAGES 
 America's consumer-price inflation slowed to 5.7% in the year to January, and Britain's to 9.0%. 
 American wholesale prices rose by 3.7% in the 12 months to January &mdash; the slowest annual rise for six months. 
 In the same period Japan's wholesale prices climbed 2.1%. 
 In the year to December Japanese workers received a wage increase of 6.3%, equivalent to a real rise of 2.4%; British workers' pay rose by 9.8%, a real increase of only 0.5%. 
 ECONOMIC FORECASTS 
 Each month we publish a round-up of forecasts based on the averages of 170 seers polled by Consensus Economics. 
 Since January their forecasts of economic growth for 1991 have grown gloomier in all but three countries &mdash; Japan and Spain (where the forecast is unchanged) and America (where GNP is now expected to fall by 0.3% rather than 0.4%). 
 Worst off are Canada, where GNP is predicted to fall by 0.6% this year, and Britain, with a fall of 0.5%. 
 In 1992 the forecasters reckon that economic growth in the 13 countries will average 2.6%, down from last month's forecast of 2.7%. 
 The payoff is inflation, with lower estimates than last month in nine countries. 
 Inflation is now expected to average 5% this year, slightly down from January's estimate of 5.1%. 
 COMMODITY PRICE INDEX 
 Sales of soyabeans to the Soviet Union have helped to underpin prices, which rose to &dollar;5.80 a bushel in Chicago this week. 
 The Russians have bought 200,000 tonnes of beans with part of the &dollar;58m-worth of export credits recently allocated to soyabeans. 
 They could buy a further 41,000 tonnes. 
 However, American soyabean prices will come under pressure when the Brazilian harvest starts next month. 
 Brazil's 1991 crop is expected to fall to 17m tonnes, from nearly 20m tonnes in 1990. 
 Argentina's crop could be around 10m tonnes. 
 Farmers are short of cash, and are likely to step up sales early in the season, lifting exports from the two countries to near record levels over the next six months.  
 HOME BORROWING 
 When it comes to buying houses, the British are keenest of all. 
 Total mortgage debt in Britain rose from 32% of GDP in 1982 to 58% in 1989, by far the highest ratio in the big economies. 
 It is no coincidence that house prices rose faster in Britain in the 1980s (by an average of 5.9% a year in real terms) than elsewhere. 
 America was not far behind, with total mortgage debt equivalent to 45% of GDP in 1989. 
 America and Britain have the most liberalised financial systems and the most generous tax breaks on interest payments of the six countries in the chart. 
 In the more restricted financial climates of Japan, France, Germany and Italy, mortgage debt ranges between 7% of GDP in Italy and 25% in Japan. 
 In Germany, where mortgage interest payments are not tax-deductible and mortgage loans cannot exceed 60% of the value of a house (compared with 100% in Britain), home prices fell in real terms in the past decade. 
 TRADE, EXCHANGE RATES AND RESERVES 
 America's visible-trade deficit narrowed to &dollar;6.3 billion in December, bringing the total for 1990 to &dollar;100.4 billion, down from 1989's deficit of &dollar;109.4 billion. 
 Germany's trade surplus fell to &dollar;1.7 billion in December, trimming its 12-month surplus to &dollar;64.3 billion; its current-account surplus fell to &dollar;44 billion. 
 The dollar rose 1.9% during the week in trade-weighted terms and the yen fell 1.2%. 
 WORLD BOURSES 
 Stockmarkets rose strongly this week on hopes of peace in the Gulf and lower interest rates. 
 Tokyo touched 26000 for the first time since last August. 
 Milan surged 7.5% on expectations of a cut in capital-gains tax. 
 The world index gained 1.7%. 
 MONEY AND INTEREST RATES 
 America's narrow-money growth remained at 4.0% in the year to January. 
 Over the same period growth in broad money slowed to 7.3% in Japan and to 11.1% in Britain &mdash; its smallest annual increase since the series began in 1982. 
 Crude justice 
 Deal with oil spills in a way that cleans up fast and settles up later 
 A YEAR after the Exxon Valdez spilt its sticky cargo along the shores of Prince William Sound, the main oil-shipping countries are locked in bitter battle over how to pay to clean up such incidents. 
 The shipping countries of Europe and Japan want a system of no-fault compensation that would quickly foot the bill for scraping oil off the beach. 
 Powerful voices in the American Senate want the polluter to pay. 
 The senators may have principle on their side; the Europeans and Japanese have common sense on theirs. 
 At the root of the debate is a pair of treaties, produced 20 years ago after the Torrey Canyon disaster. 
 They established that, in the first instance, shipowners would automatically meet the cost of oil spills, through insurance cover which they would be obliged to carry; but the owners' liability was to be limited to a maximum of &dollar;18m. 
 Above that, up to a ceiling of about &dollar;65m, the cost would be paid by a fund, financed by a levy on oil importers. 
 Countries that signed receive compensation for spills, however they occur. 
 In 1984 new treaties were negotiated to raise shipowners' maximum liability to &dollar;78m, and the ceiling on payments for each clean-up to &dollar;260m. 
 They are still sitting on the shelf. 
 America has never ratified the treaties. 
 Enough countries signed the first lot to bring the fund into existence; but most are now waiting for America's signature before agreeing to enlargement of it. 
 The House of Representatives favours ratification; Senate opposition has been led by Mr George Mitchell, leader of the majority Democrats. 
 He objects to the treaties' limits on the liability of shipowners: only if damage was committed with &bquo;intent&equo; or with &bquo;knowledge that &lsqb;it&rsqb; would probably result&equo; can they be obliged to pay more than &dollar;78m. 
 Acceptance of this, says Senator Mitchell, would remove a deterrent to polluters &mdash; and take away from individual American states their right to set tougher environmental standards than the federal government does. 
 Mr Mitchell's own state of Maine is one of 18 that impose unlimited liability. 
 Clean up first, punish after 
 Much of Mr Mitchell's argument is true, but also unworldly. 
 Both punishment and compensation are necessary, but had better run on separate tracks. 
 Link them, and the main result will be interminable delay. 
 The bill for the damage when the Amoco Cadiz foundered off the coast of Brittany, before the compensation fund was set up, is still grinding through the courts, 12 years on. 
 The fund offers quick payments, while the alternative is much legal red tape at a moment when speed counts. 
 Fearful of punitive damages, companies will avoid doing anything that might later be seen as an admission of guilt. 
 Unlimited liability is a difficult concept to apply, and a guaranteed recipe for endless litigation. 
 As insurance companies realise that unlimited liability may mean just what it says, they will become deeply unhappy about insuring for it. 
 The Exxon Valdez was an oddity: one large oil company owned both tanker and oil, and employed the crew. 
 More typical is the confused plight of Ewing Oil and its rickety chartered tanker, familiar to viewers of &bquo;Dallas&equo;; or, in the real world, the American Trader whose load fouled southern California last month. 
 The oil in the American Trader was owned by BP America, but the tanker by a New York shipping company. 
 In future, there will be fewer Exxon Valdezes, because big oil companies will make sure that they do not own any oil until it arrives safely in port. 
 More oil will be shipped by small companies. 
 Already, roughly half the world's oil is carried by one-tanker companies, whose entire assets founder with a single wreck. 
 The existence of a compensation fund, says Senator Mitchell, would reduce the penalties for pollution. 
 A shipowner whose liability is automatically assumed up to a certain level, and strictly limited above that, will have less incentive to avoid a costly spill. 
 Actually, once the fund has footed a bill, it has in the past successfully pursued a polluter through the courts. 
 All that stuff about &bquo;intent&equo; and &bquo;knowledge&equo; might not save a future Exxon from damages in the American courts, if it transpired that a tanker captain was a known incompetent steering through a dangerous place. 
 Last year was the worst for tanker spills since 1980. 
 More oil is being shipped in less seaworthy vessels. 
 More than half the world tanker fleet is now over ten years old, and a squeeze on pay means more tankers are manned by inexperienced crew. 
 All these changes are making spills more likely still. 
 If America fails to sign the treaties, the enlarged compensation fund will be stillborn. 
 The main results will be less cash to clean up spills in countries that cannot afford an Alaskan scale of effort; higher insurance rates for oil tankers; and less seaworthy ships carrying oil down the coast of Maine. 
 It is a high price to pay for supporting senatorial principle, rather than pragmatism.  
 Gorbachev's greatest gamble 
 What happens if he really makes the break for a market economy? 
 CROSS your fingers. 
 One of the biggest economic adventures of all time is, with luck, about to begin. 
 It dwarfs even the extraordinary experiments under way in Poland and Hungary, and the one just starting in East Germany. 
 The challenge: to turn the Soviet Union into a market economy. 
 Surely that is what perestroika has been about these past five years? 
 Alas, no. 
 Mr Gorbachev has allowed joint ventures with western firms, promoted quasi-capitalist co-operatives, tried to trim the planning bureaucracy. 
 But this has been a mere flirtation with the market. 
 It was far short of unambiguous espousal, even though it upset the old planners. 
 Also, small point, it did not work. 
 Queues have lengthened, real incomes have fallen and inflation has soared. 
 Mounting chaos in the state's finances has threatened a collapse of the money economy and a retreat to 100% rationing. 
 Radical economists have argued for an escape to a market system before it is too late, but the conservative establishment has always over-ruled them. 
 No longer, maybe. 
 According to the hitherto reliable Interfax news agency in Moscow, Mr Gorbachev plans to introduce a daring set of reforms, a &bquo;180-degree about-turn&equo;, by July. 
 He may be willing to use his new powers as executive president to brush aside resistance. 
 The reforms were reportedly prepared by a group of specialists and astonishingly kept secret from the prime minister's cabinet. 
 What is known of them suggests two strong influences: Poland's &bquo;Big Bang&equo; and Mr Gorbachev's new personal economic adviser, Mr Nikolai Petrakov. 
 Mr Petrakov is one of the band of influential economists who have made the mental leap to the market (&bquo;We need a normal, civilised market,&equo; he says), and have been saying with growing urgency that Mr Gorbachev must join them, and bring the country with him. 
 The policy they have prepared is said to involve liberalising prices, freeing trade, selling state companies, smashing monopolies and moving rapidly towards a convertible rouble. 
 A fast track to currency convertibility is one of Mr Petrakov's pet ideas. 
 He has argued for the introduction of a convertible currency parallel to the existing non-convertible rouble. 
 Perestroika will not work without opening the Soviet economy to the West, he rightly reckons, and that will not happen properly until there is a hard rouble. 
 The West will face some difficult decisions if Mr Gorbachev really does make a dash for economic freedom. 
 A market three times the size of all the liberalising economies of Eastern Europe combined would suddenly be wide open. 
 The IMF, the World Bank and the GATT would swiftly face applications to admit a giant new member. 
 And western politicians would probably find themselves faced with a request for enormous help &mdash; including consumer goods to fill shops and soak up roubles &mdash; to contain the shock of a Soviet Big Bang. 
 Many roads to capitalism 
 The change would be traumatic. 
 In Poland Big Bang has piled on pain for consumers in the hope of taming inflation. 
 Success there is far from certain: it will come even harder in the Soviet Union. 
 It is not just the country's size, and its 70 years under communism (against Poland's 40). 
 Poles have so far accepted yet more economic misery because they trust their Solidarity-led government. 
 The Soviet leadership enjoys no such trust. 
 In backing a Petrakov plan, Mr Gorbachev risks popular unrest as well as revolt within the Communist party (and perhaps the resignation of his prime minister, Mr Nikolai Ryzhkov, if economic policy is rammed through by decree rather than through his government). 
 It would be a mighty gamble. 
 But Mr Gorbachev may judge the risks of non-reform to be even higher. 
 Would the gamble work? 
 It is easy to find fault with any programme for converting a planned economy back into a market one. 
 Czechoslovaks criticise the Polish way of doing it. 
 What is the point, they ask, of freeing the market when it is still monopoly-ridden? 
 In Prague the talk is of starting with a break-up of the monopolies, and letting the market rip later &mdash; but de-monopolising the economy might take a long time. 
 Mr Petrakov is in an understandable hurry, but his idea for a short-cut to a convertible currency could bring a wild ride. 
 A parallel &bquo;hard&equo; rouble might lead to hyperinflation in old roubles &mdash; unless budgetary control were tight enough to make roubles &bquo;real&equo; money anyway. 
 There is no proven recipe for undoing the communist economic mess, any more than there is a recipe for unbaking an inedible cake. 
 But you have to start somewhere. 
 The starting-point in Eastern Europe has been clear rejection of Marxist economics and clear commitment to a market system, complete with private ownership and private enterprise. 
 If Mr Gorbachev really does now intend to take that step in his own country, his political revolution is about to become an economic one too. 
 And the consequences could be even more startling, for better or for worse.  
 All his own work 
 WHEN you are deep in the valley and don't want your companions to realise how cold it is, talk loudly about the sunlit uplands. 
 That was John Major's ploy on Tuesday. 
 For a new chancellor, presenting a budget for an unpopular government, it was the best he could do. 
 For the British economy, with inflation rising and growth slowing, his budget will do little harm. 
 Neither judgment is quite the epitaph it seems at first sight. 
 To do little damage to the economy is, for a chancellor, a huge achievement. 
 Most of Mr Major's predecessors had no guiding principles for microeconomic things like the tax code, so they tinkered obsessively instead. 
 And most, in their macroeconomic management, lurched between unjustified fears of recession and unwarranted euphoria about growth. 
 Mr Major avoided these mistakes, at least in their extreme forms. 
 His sins of micro-commission were small; and the macro thing he did not do was hardly a new failure. 
 So-so little bits 
 The detailed changes to the tax system were mostly unambitious (see pages 29&ndash;34). 
 Mr Major was straightforward in raising most personal allowances in line with inflation, and most excise duties by slightly more. 
 That was the mark of an honest chancellor who is prepared to take a longish view. 
 Unfortunately, he then lost his way over cars and creches. 
 On company cars, he continued the policy of his predecessor, Mr Nigel Lawson, in recognising that perks provided by employers are just as much part of employees' remuneration as salaries are, and should therefore be just as taxable. 
 Then, bizarrely, he announced that the perk of a workplace nursery would no longer be taxable. 
 The House of Commons roared in (overwhelmingly masculine) approval. 
 Working mothers, it seems, are a motherhood issue. 
 The budget's biggest microeconomic change was on another motherhood issue, the treatment of savings. 
 When Britons are saving just 6% of their post-tax income, surely everybody agrees that they should be encouraged to do more. 
 It seems churlish to point out that most such carrots cause a diversion of savings from taxed to untaxed channels, not an increase in the absolute amount. 
 But there is a bigger caveat about what Mr Major did, a caveat about tax philosophy. 
 The best fiscal system is one which taxes any part of income or wealth that is spent on consumption, and exempts any part of them that is saved. 
 Mr Major, by picking on certain types of savings for exemption, moved further away from this ideal, not nearer to it. 
 He is moving back towards the bad practice of selective tax shelters, which Mr Lawson had undermined in his five years as chancellor. 
 The old system gave tax breaks for saving with life assurance companies; the new one gives them for saving with banks and building societies. 
 Mr Major's big omission was on macroeconomic management. 
 After eleven years of Thatcherism the government's macro policies have been transformed &mdash; for the worse. 
 Initially their aim was to set some rules and, as far as possible, stick to them. 
 This, it was hoped, would reassure the financial markets that fine-tuning, and the inflationary bias that went with it, was out, shunned, verboten, dead. 
 All those rules were for nominal measures &mdash; money supply, public spending and borrowing, growth in money GDP &mdash; rather than for the volume goals of output, jobs and expenditure that most earlier governments had pursued in vain. 
 The new principle was a good one, because it forced the government to live in a world where inflation matters and cannot be conveniently assumed away. 
 All those rules got forgotten, notably by Mr Lawson, who had done most to introduce them. 
 Trust me, he said &mdash; and then presided over an inflationary boom. 
 To his credit, he wanted to give the markets a new nominal rule, on the exchange rate, but was prevented from doing so by Mrs Margaret Thatcher's visceral dislike of the European Monetary System. 
 So Britain has been stuck with trust-me pragmatism. 
 The result is an inflation rate double that of the other large OECD economies, and interest rates that have to be kept higher than they otherwise would be &mdash; because moneymen, on the whole, are not the most trusting (read gullible) of types. 
 For Tuesday's budget, the man was different but the message was the same: trust me. 
 Mr Major produced some nominal figures, but none that proves he is an inflation-fighter. 
 He projects a fiscal surplus for 1990&ndash;91 of &pound;7 billion, the same as the outturn he now expects for 1989&ndash;90. 
 Simple extrapolation has been the pattern for five years now, to the point where the financial markets treat it as a game. 
 There is little to choose between a game-based policy and a trust-based one; both are miles from a rule-based system that the world could understand and the government would stick to. 
 The same applies to monetary targets, now just a melange of notes and coins; and to nominal GDP, which Mr Major didn't even mention. 
 Instead, he offered a pair of trust-mes: &bquo;I favour a strong exchange rate&hellip; 
 The moment I judge I can safely lower &lsqb;interest rates&rsqb;, I will.&equo; 
 That is Britain's macroeconomic policy, to go naked into the market place. 
 Not surprisingly, sterling shivers. 
 If it falls much further over the next few days, Mr Major will have no choice but to raise interest rates. 
 Unless, that is, he wants to be branded as the man who brought double-digit inflation back to Britain. 
 To the aid of the party 
 Mr Major may be chancellor of the exchequer but he is also the member of Parliament for Huntingdon and is on most short-lists to succeed Mrs Thatcher as Tory leader. 
 So his was a budget full of politics, with several points to make. 
 One mattered for him personally: he showed himself to be his own man. 
 He did not raise the ceiling on mortgage-interest relief, which Mrs Thatcher had pressed him to do. 
 He offered some minor Major themes, stressing the role of small businesses, small savers, charities and football: all of them got tax breaks. 
 And, most cunningly of all, he did not raise the starting level for higher-rate income tax. 
 It is now barely 1.5 times average earnings, so Labour's pledge to raise the top rate from 40% to (in effect) 59% can be made to sound threatening to millions of ordinary Britons. 
 Their frustrations used to be articulated by Mrs Thatcher, but she is now as likely to be a cause of them as a cure. 
 It is Mr Major who seems to sense the fears and hopes of middle Britain. 
 He is an ordinary bloke, everybody's idea of a bank manager. 
 Because his budget went down well with Tory MPs (see page 39), however, Mr Major has given Mrs Thatcher a valuable breather. 
 Had he produced a no-hoper, the pressure on her to quit this summer would have started growing on Tuesday evening. 
 As it is, she can now feel a little safer in one of her jobs, as leader of the Conservative party. 
 And what of her other job? 
 The clear message from the budget was that the next general election should be delayed until the last minute, in June 1992. 
 Several of the changes Mr Major announced will not come in until next year, and their effects will hardly be noticed for a while after that. 
 More, the economy is going to look grim &mdash; slow growth, fast inflation, an income squeeze, high interest rates &mdash; for a year or more. 
 But the sunshine in Mr Major's vision may be felt, just, by the end of 1991, with inflation down to 5%, growth recovering and interest rates on the wane. 
 In which case the member for Huntingdon could deliver a 1992 budget of generous tax cuts and more spending, with the markets roaring at the prospect of another Tory triumph. 
 That is not a prediction. 
 But there was just enough from John Major this week to suggest that it isn't a fantasy either.  
 Kohl's kingdom 
 How to live with a united Germany 
 HATS off to Helmut. 
 For a chap who was reckoned a bit of a bumbler by his friends and a bit of a bruiser by his country's neighbours, West Germany's chancellor may have surprised even himself this week. 
 He is now, beyond doubt, the power-broker of Europe. 
 East Germany's ringing endorsement of his plan for speedy German unity makes him the strongest contender to lead the strongest power in non-communist Europe. 
 That gives him clout not only in tricky talks with America, Britain, France and the Soviet Union over how the new Germany will fit into Europe, but also in negotiations within the European Community over what sort of Europe it will be. 
 No doubt about Mr Kohl's victory this week. 
 His worry is how to handle success. 
 Mr Kohl rightly sees the East German vote as a personal vindication. 
 He recognised the opportunity in last year's East German revolution and grabbed it. 
 He bamboozled all four of the occupying powers &mdash; including that arch-bamboozler Mikhail Gorbachev &mdash; into accepting fast-forward unity more or less on his terms. 
 And he made unity on those terms the campaign issue in East Germany. 
 At each stage Mr Kohl has followed his instincts, taken his chances &mdash; and won. 
 At each stage the opposition Social Democrats, both in East and West Germany, have hesitated &mdash; and lost. 
 But if Mr Kohl is now riding high, East German expectations are riding higher. 
 Not disappointing them will tax even his instincts. 
 To make swifter unity on West German terms more attractive to East Germans, Mr Kohl has all but promised that their savings will be converted, over time, from Monopoly-money Ostmarks into rock-ribbed D-marks at the ridiculously unrealistic rate of 1:1. 
 So far he seems as good as his word. 
 His economics minister is talking of currency union between the two Germanies by July. 
 Full economic and then political union cannot be far behind. 
 East Germans will get what they voted for, and much else besides. 
 Unity will not swiftly mean equality. 
 Even on the cheeriest estimates, it will take five or ten years to rescue East Germany's economy from 40 years of communism. 
 That will mean cutting subsidies &mdash; on food, housing and most other things East Germans buy &mdash; and shedding unproductive jobs. 
 East Germans who stay in work will have to work a lot harder as tough private bosses take over flabby state-run factories. 
 Not that anybody will miss the Wartburgs and Interflugs, those trademarks of failure. 
 And things could be worse. 
 Unlike Poland and Hungary, East Germany will not have to coax in private capital: the stuff will flood in from West Germany. 
 All the same, it will be a while before a freer East Germany also feels like a richer one to most of its people. 
 As times get harder, the Social Democrats may get their chance. 
 They (and East Germany's communists) argued throughout the election campaign for a slower road to unity, one that would give East Germans the chance to negotiate some safeguards for their livelihoods. 
 If monetary union goes badly, bringing either too much inflation to West Germany or industrial collapse to East Germany (and hence an even bigger flood of refugees to the West), Germany's voters may turn against Mr Kohl. 
 But the chances are that the momentum of this week's success will carry his Christian Democrats to victory in West Germany's election in December and then in all of Germany next year. 
 On present evidence, that would be welcome: a reunited Germany with Mr Kohl as its first chancellor is likely to be more prosperous, and stabler, than it would be under the Social Democrats. 
 The only Germany there is 
 Despite last month's bruising row over the fate of the German-Polish border, further Kohl victories would also be better for Germany's neighbours than Kohl defeats. 
 Most Europeans, Poles included, now accept that a united German democracy is a place they can live with, provided it stays securely anchored in the western alliance. 
 Mr Kohl says it should stay anchored. 
 Only the Russians and some German Social Democrats keep banging on about a neutral Germany. 
 Had the Social Democrats won in East Germany, Mr Gorbachev would have gained himself a valuable ally. 
 He may still try to insist on neutrality at the two-plus-four talks on Germany. 
 Or he may try to trade in that idea for something he might think would be almost as valuable, the withdrawal of all foreign troops from Germany. 
 It is there that Mr Kohl's fine political antennae could get the worse of him. 
 So far he and his foreign minister, Mr Hans-Dietrich Genscher, have stuck nobly to the view that Germany should remain a member of NATO, with some (no doubt far fewer) NATO troops staying on in what is now West Germany and with enough Soviet troops staying on in eastern Germany for a while to make the Russians feel better about it. 
 But no German, least of all the East Germans, would want Soviet troops to stay there indefinitely. 
 Rather than let the pressure grow for them to leave, Mr Gorbachev may offer to take them out &mdash; in return for the departure of the Americans and other NATO forces from West Germany. 
 If that seems to be the Russian price for full German unity, and if Mr Kohl's instincts tell him it is also his price for winning the next German election, he may be tempted to go for it. 
 Why shouldn't he? 
 Mr Gorbachev is already pulling troops and tanks out of Eastern Europe. 
 More will go by agreement later this year, after the Vienna talks on conventional forces in Europe. 
 Why put up with any foreign troops on German soil? 
 The answer is that American troops are in Germany, and elsewhere on the continent, not only to help defend Western Europe against a conventional Soviet attack, but also to keep the edge of the American nuclear umbrella pulled over Europe. 
 Even a demobilising Soviet Union will still be a nuclear-armed one. 
 And who knows who comes after the affable Mr Gorbachev? 
 Mightn't a European Treaty Organisation, either in NATO or in place of it, be able one day to do the protection-cum-deterrence job that America does today? 
 Perhaps. 
 But if push ever did threaten to come to shove, British and French nuclear weapons are unlikely to inspire the confidence in West Germany that America's much bigger armoury does. 
 Mr Gorbachev, and others, should remember that a shrinking of American protection for Germany could raise the tricky issue of how Germany will defend itself &mdash; including the until now unthinkable thought of German nuclear missiles. 
 German confidence will also depend on how robust Europe's other structures prove to be. 
 So far fears that West Germany will be too distracted by the rebuilding of East Germany to continue the building of the European Community have been exaggerated. 
 Economic and monetary union in Western Europe will be delayed until it is clear what effects the union in Germany will have. 
 But the post-1992 European single market remains as attractive as ever, to Germans east and west. 
 The real worries about Germany may come after the 1990s, when Germany is not only whole, free and rich, but has also begun to sense its real power. 
 Today's West Germany bends over backwards to be a reliable ally. 
 Would a democratic and successful Germany, bound into a democratic and successful Europe, have reason to do otherwise? 
 Defence might be one reason; there could be others. 
 Once assertiveness starts coming more naturally to Germany, as naturally it will, might the Kohl sort of Germany want to make its political weight in the Community match its economic power, and be more protective of German minorities across its borders? 
 It might. 
 But the only answer to that is for the West to build the most solid alliance it can with the only Germany it's got.  
 Tokyo's money crunch 
 Policy co-ordination lies at the root of Japan's financial troubles 
 FOR an economy that is supposedly manipulated to make it impervious to market forces, Japan has moved remarkably rapidly from joy to gloom. 
 Only a few months ago it was full of optimism, with real GNP growing at 5% a year, financial markets soaring, companies rushing to invest, and consumers strutting the streets with their furs and Rolex watches. 
 Now, with the Tokyo stockmarket's Nikkei index down more than 23% from its December 29th peak, with the yen sliding against the dollar and with interest rates on the up, the mood has switched to fear. 
 Everyone knows that the party is over. 
 The question is how bad the hangover will be, and not merely for Japan. 
 Nothing has changed in the bedrock of Japanese industry to cause this. 
 People work as hard as ever. 
 Innovation is even more frenetic. 
 Japanese companies are getting stronger and stronger, as they turn themselves from exporters into true multinationals. 
 But in the past five years the economy has been pulled along at an even faster pace than that merited by its industrial over-achievers. 
 The mechanism has been a rapid rise in share prices and a trebling in urban-property prices, which in turn have boosted consumption, revved up BMW sales and, for top-notch manufacturers and banks, reduced the cost of capital virtually to zero. 
 It is as if the 200mph financial economy overtook the 100mph real economy, but, with its slipstream, helped the slowcoach to accelerate. 
 This did not just happen by itself. 
 It happened with the help of a loose monetary policy, under which the central bank's discount rate was pushed down four times in 1985&ndash;87, to a historic low of 2.5%. 
 Japan's financial markets had been substantially deregulated in the previous three years, making them more sensitive to changes in the price of money. 
 But the supply of financial assets remained rigid, especially in the case of land and shares. 
 When demand rockets and supply stays fixed, there is only one way prices can move: up, often unsustainably fast. 
 Why didn't Japan's ever-prudent and oh-so-dominant bureaucrats step in to prevent it? 
 Partly because the financial fun enriched lots of powerful people in Japan. 
 Partly because cheap capital and a shot at some financial profits were just what exporters needed to help them deflect the blow of the strong yen after 1985. 
 But the main reason lay 7,000 miles away, in Washington, DC. 
 From 1985 to 1988 the chief target of Japan's monetary policy was America, not Japan. 
 In the name of international policy co-ordination, Japan held its interest rates down to support the dollar and to help America finance its external deficit. 
 In effect, Japan bailed out America &mdash; and is now facing the consequences. 
 The liberation of Eastern Europe and a worldwide rise in inflation have forced interest rates to rise virtually everywhere. 
 Japan's money policy had to tighten sharply, if the yen were not to collapse and if inflation was to be kept under control. 
 That is why on March 20th the Bank of Japan raised its discount rate from 4.25% to 5.25%, and why it will raise it again soon. 
 It is also why share prices are returning towards reality, and why many fear that property prices will soon do the same. 
 Japan has done too little, too late about tightening money policy and deflating its financial bubble. 
 By waiting so long, it has made itself vulnerable to a systemic collapse. 
 It may still avoid one, by luck or by a decisive further tightening now. 
 But meanwhile many Japanese eyes are turning back to the root cause: policy co-ordination and America. 
 When finance ministers from the biggest economies meet on April 7th, Japan will ask America to cut its interest rates to support the yen. 
 After all, the Japanese will say, we did it for you. 
 But America will be right to say no, as long as it has worries about its own inflation. 
 At that point, many will conclude that policy co-ordination is dead. 
 Partial partnership is worse than none 
 With any luck they will be right, at least in the form in which co-ordination has been practised since 1985. 
 Under the Plaza and Louvre accords, the policy has been a pretence. 
 The only thing that has been co-ordinated has been monetary policy, because participating countries, most notably America, refused to include fiscal policies at the same time. 
 The result was inflation, especially of Japanese asset prices. 
 It went on too long, until its recent shuddering halt. 
 There is no point in another try at partial co-ordination. 
 What is needed is either full co-ordination, or none at all, with countries concentrating on their domestic needs. 
 In America's case that should amount to the same thing. 
 The best way for America to help Japan would be to slash the budget deficit, lowering its demand for Japanese capital and thus helping the yen. 
 Helping Japan is not a popular theme in Washington. 
 But if the worst really came to the worst in Japan, the resulting mess could not simply be welcomed as come-uppance. 
 It would dry up the flow of Japanese credit to all American borrowers, private or public. 
 Then congressmen would no longer be resenting the arrival of Japanese investors in America. 
 They would be wailing at their departure.  
 Farewell, HQ 
 Should companies tear out their hearts to prosper? 
 A DECADE ago the sparkling new headquarters building and executive jet were corporate status-symbols, sure signs that your company had made it. 
 HQ was the place to be, and to be seen. 
 In the leaner 1990s that headquarters glamour is increasingly seen as gluttony &mdash; an unnecessary layer of bureaucracy and overheads. 
 One study estimates that the headquarters and related functions of big American companies gobble up almost a fifth of their annual profits. 
 Another estimates that British firms squander &pound;18 billion (&dollar;30 billion) each year by mismanaging corporate overheads. 
 Around the world, companies are pruning their headquarters teams in an attempt to save money. 
 Firms as diverse as ICI, IBM, Chevron and RTZ have each taken that route. 
 BP is the latest to do so: the world's third-biggest oil company is cutting its 540-strong head-office management team by a third; around 70 central committees are being disbanded. 
 Mr Robert Horton, BP's new chairman, says he is scraping the barnacles off the company's hull. 
 But need a group of businesses be under the control of a central corporate team at all? 
 Launching his bid for B.A.T Industries last year, Sir James Goldsmith argued that the tobacco-to-insurance group's headquarters team subtracted, rather than added, value. 
 By &bquo;unbundling&equo; itself in an attempt to fight off Sir James, B.A.T seems to be agreeing. 
 Make parents pay their way 
 Why should a mixed bag of businesses perform better under the direction of a headquarters team, rather than as individual firms responding to external commercial pressures? 
 The question goes to the heart of the debate between conglomerateers and knitting-stickers. 
 Much of the head-office slashing now going on is an attempt by conglomerates to act like specialists &mdash; while remaining conglomerates. 
 To justify its existence, a conglomerate's headquarters has to add more value than an independent business unit could get from outside advisers and banks. 
 It has to do something else as well. 
 A headquarters team must add more value to its businesses than any competing parent. 
 One way is by bringing about a once-and-for-all transformation in the structure and strategy of a business unit. 
 The HQ team at Britain's Hanson, for example, buys underperforming businesses, sells unprofitable or unrelated activities, then concentrates on generating cash from what remains. 
 Another approach is typified by BTR, an acquisitive British conglomerate which this month made a &dollar;1.6 billion bid for Norton, an American abrasives group. 
 Its 50-strong headquarters keeps an iron financial grip on some 500 profit centres, setting each business rigorous short-term targets. 
 BTR's headquarters leaves decentralised management teams to get on with the day-to-day job of running each business. 
 Both Hanson and BTR have prospered by matching specific management skills with a group of seemingly unrelated businesses. 
 Both firms have low headquarters costs &mdash; last year BTR's were less than .5% of net profits. 
 Impressive though they are, Hanson and BTR are too acquisitive to be comfortable models for ordinary industrialists. 
 So how to judge if your company's headquarters is worth its weight? 
 Hard as it is for bosses to accept it, head office delivers many services in the same way as would an outside subcontractor. 
 So make it compete with outsiders. 
 Only keep the function in-house if headquarters wins a contract. 
 What remains of the headquarters team should then be reorganised to make the most of computers, and exposed to the sort of cost-cutting techniques usually associated with the shop floor. 
 If all that fails, head for the jet. 
 LETTERS 
 Fear of a united Germany 
 It should neither be surprising nor intriguing that many European countries, as well as Israel, have viewed recent efforts aimed at German unification with scepticism and concern. 
 After all, Germany does have a disturbingly long tradition of attempts to expand and dominate militarily the European continent. 
 Twice in this century it has been the cause of global conflict, the lasting effects of which are still at issue today. 
 To say merely that &bquo;things are different now&equo; is hardly any consolation for the pain and bitterness of past experience and bears little assurance of a future political and military stability in Europe. 
 It is not up to us to forget or forgive the crime that Germany committed only a few decades ago; the only ones who might have done so died on the battlefield or, worse yet, in the gas chambers. 
 And if Germany is destined to become one and inevitably rise to a position of leadership in Europe, let us seriously consider the sceptics' view that it should at least not happen in our generation.  
 Cincinnati MOSES ALTSECH 
 Labour's pound 
 Your article on the economic policy of the Labour party (February 17th) concludes with a cautionary note about the spending plans of an incoming Labour government. 
 With Labour having scrapped its unilateralist defence policy, the ability of its economics team to manage the economy responsibly could become the major issue in the next election campaign. 
 Perhaps the debate about membership of the European exchange-rate mechanism (ERM) is relevant here. 
 Within the ERM a Labour government would presumably find its freedom to launch into an unwise, inflationary spending spree greatly restricted. 
 The credibility of the party's claims that it could safely be entrusted with the running of the British economy would thus be greatly enhanced. 
 Might such considerations explain Mrs Thatcher's reluctance to join the system, at least before the next election?  
 Ashford, Kent COLIN POULTON 
 Tooth and law 
 Your essay on the important role of co-operation in our ever-changing understanding of evolution (February 24th) is also an apt testimony to the unity of the sciences. 
 Darwin's idea of &bquo;survival of the fittest&equo; found a home in political philosophy in the form (albeit distorted) of social darwinism. 
 Likewise, Dr Lynn Margulis's theories, which hold that evolution advances as much through symbiosis as by tooth and claw, correspond to the late anarchist Kropotkin's theories of social evolution. 
 He argued that sociability, not ferociousness, is the greatest advantage in the struggle for survival. 
 He also held, dubiously, that were it not for the corruptions imposed by state and law, men would develop bonds of instinctive solidarity which would make government unnecessary. 
 We can at least be thankful that microbes are not subject to such corruptions.  
 Annapolis, Maryland JIM O'GARA 
 Perfect competition 
 Your perceptive articles on European airlines (January 20th) and high-speed travel in Europe (February 3rd) raise a number of issues for the contestable market-theory debate. 
 Baumol's theory of contestable markets states that consumer welfare can be maximised regardless of the number of firms in an industry, as long as it is greater than one. 
 Producers have to operate efficiently due to the pressure of potential &bquo;hit and run entry&equo; into the market. 
 If airlines can fly wherever and whenever they want to after the EC's liberalisation of aviation, experience will be similar to that of the United States, where empirical work suggests the market is &bquo;imperfectly contestable&equo;. 
 However, coupled with a European high-speed rail network, owned by an EC track authority with both national and private operators running trains on it, the high-speed travel market in Europe could well come as close to perfect contestability as anything. 
 The implication for competition policy would be profound, with the realisation that big operators are susceptible to hit-and-run entry from independent companies.  
 Lenton, Nottinghamshire TIM NORTHAM 
 Poland and Lithuania 
 In your article on the Lithuanian elections (February 17th), you state that Poland held Lithuania's capital, Vilnius, between 1920 and 1939. 
 While this is correct, you neglected to mention that Poland occupied the city against Lithuanian wishes, through the actions of the Polish army. 
 This is much less well known than the standard image of Poland as a nation constantly overrun by hostile forces. 
 Poland may well be worried at the prospect of a unified Germany, given its past history. 
 Lithuania should be just as concerned with the emergence of a free Poland, for the same reasons.  
 Perth, Australia RAY KALINAUSKAS 
 Is Canada dull? 
 Could it be that you are just a little bit jealous of The Great White North &mdash; a society, after all, rather less divisive and certainly more prosperous than decaying, decadent Britain? 
 I write as a joint citizen of Britain and Canada. 
 I value my Canadian citizenship rather more, however. 
 And a temporary sojourn in the murder capital of the United States reinforces the value of supposedly &bquo;dull&equo; old Canada. 
 Yes, peace, order and good government can be rather dull. 
 It is surprising, though, how many nations these days seem to crave it.  
 Washington, DC MICHAEL MCDOWELL 
 Why do you persist in calling Canada dull? 
 What is it you want? 
 Do you know that Canadians are the world curling champions? 
 Do you realise that the paint roller is a Canadian invention? 
 Have you ever heard Michael Wilson speak? 
 A country can only stand so much excitement.  
 Washington, DC FRANK POTTER 
 BOOKS AND ARTS 
 American life 
 Buffalo and sweat baths 
 GREAT PLAINS. 
 By Ian Frazier. 
 Faber and Faber; 290 pages; &pound;14.99. 
 Farrar Strauss &amp; Giroux; &dollar;17.95 
 THE Great Plains of the United States cover a huge swathe of land, about 600 miles wide, stretching some 2,500 miles south from eastern Montana and western North Dakota through parts of South Dakota, Wyoming, Nebraska, Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico and Oklahoma to west Texas. 
 For most Americans, it is simply what they fly over on the way to either coast. 
 Ian Frazier, a writer for the New Yorker, has taken this bleak and maligned region and given it life. 
 His glorious book is more than a history and more than a 25,000-mile travelogue, although it is also both of those. 
 It is an ode to the Great Plains, a psalm to the people who once lived there, who have tried to live there and who live there still. 
 Once called, inaccurately, the &bquo;Great American Desert&equo;, the plains region was generally ignored by white Americans until after the Civil War. 
 Then, with the railroads as chief boosters, the plains saw the arrival of thousands upon thousands of settlers. 
 They wiped out the buffalo, more or less wiped out the Indians and, eventually, were driven away themselves by loneliness, extreme weather, drought, and the loss of topsoil brought on by over-farming. 
 The region today is a sparsely populated land of ruined homesteads, small towns that have seen better days, farmers who are too reliant on unreplenishable groundwater, and missile silos. 
 Mr Frazier found more. 
 Down an almost impassable dirt track near McLaughlin, South Dakota, he found, with the help of an Indian hitchhiker called Jim Yellow Earring, the site of the cabin belonging to the famous Sioux chief, Sitting Bull. 
 Just off Highway 83 north of Wellington, Texas, he came across the abandoned house of Mr and Mrs Sam Pritchard, who were unlucky enough to have been at home when the gangsters Clyde Barrow and Bonnie Parker paid a call after their car had plunged off the road. 
 Three miles outside Strasburg, North Dakota, he found the  childhood  home of Lawrence Welk, a nationally-known accordion-player and band-leader. 
 Some of the modern-day folk are treasures. 
 Gerald Baker, a Mandan-Hidatsa Indian who is the park ranger at Fort Union Trading Post in North Dakota, once the &bquo;Times Square of the plains&equo;, taught Mr Frazier how to use a double-bladed throwing axe and offered him the honour of joining him in a ceremonial sweat bath. 
 Kathleen Claar, custodian of the Last Indian Raid Museum in Oberlin, Kansas, took him to a small cemetery to show him the grave of her husband and of Rick Read, the last man lynched in the state. 
 Le War Lance, an Oglala Sioux, stood on a street corner in New York city regaling Mr Frazier with the tale of his grandfather, the proud and independent Crazy Horse. 
 Through these encounters the Great Plains are unveiled with style and wit. 
 &bquo;The sky&equo;, we are told, &bquo;is like a person yawned and never stopped.&equo; 
 Buffalo skinners wore heavy clothes which they seldom changed. 
 Dried blood caked in their beards. 
 When a group of them walked up to a bar, they would reach into their clothes, and the last one to catch a louse had to buy. 
 The prostitutes who catered to them were a special type. 
 In Nicodemus, Kansas, the sole remaining town of black settlers on the plains, Mr Frazier says he found true joy watching the people at a dance. 
 He imparts it so generously to his readers that they may wish to follow him themselves.  
 Hans Eysenck 
 The LSE man 
 REBEL WITH A CAUSE: THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF HANS EYSENCK. 
 W.H. Allen; 310 pages; &pound;14.95 
 THIS is an autobiography with a difference. 
 As well as the usual smattering of quotations from the likes of Diderot and Montaigne, it features figures, diagrams, a glossary of technical terms and a bibliography &mdash; all the paraphernalia, that is, of an academic monograph. 
 The most revealing bit of the book is not a lyrical evocation of lost love but a graph showing Hans Eysenck's productivity over the years. 
 Each article or book chapter counts for one point; each book counts for ten; and the productivity trend, needless to say, is on the up and up. 
 Mr Eysenck has no time for English diffidence. 
 &bquo;Rebel With a Cause&equo; is an unabashed celebration of academic success and private fulfilment. 
 Mr Eysenck tells his readers, with obvious relish, that he has an extremely high IQ, a gift for language and a pellucid style; that he was a doughty boxer in youth and an excellent tennis player in maturity; and that he has always preferred principle and persecution to conformity and an easy life. 
 Quoting Bertrand Russell's dictum that if you hold unorthodox opinions in England you will be disregarded at first, persecuted if you persist, but finally canonised if you live long enough, he comments: &bquo;having experienced the first two stages, I seem to be approaching the third.&equo; 
 Inflation apart, Mr Eysenck had a dramatic, even an heroic, childhood. 
 Born in Berlin in 1916, he lived through defeat, mass unemployment and the rise of the Nazis. 
 His adolescent distaste for Hitler was sharpened by the fact that his mother remarried to a Jew, and in 1934 he went into exile, first to France and then to England, where he settled. 
 It must have been galling, to say the least, for a man from such a background to be accused of being a Nazi by student revolutionaries at the London School of Economics, whose only experience of a &bquo;fascist regime&equo; was being refused service in the college bar after closing time. 
 Mr Eysenck undoubtedly made large contributions to psychology. 
 He founded the Institute of Psychiatry and applied psychometric and experimental methods to the study of personality, long regarded as a soft option. 
 He is one of the great popularisers of science, blessed with a fluent, if over-declamatory, style. 
 It is difficult to imagine any of the jargon-junkies who preside over American psychology writing, for example, that &bquo;nothing filthy, disgusting, foul, loathsome, nauseous, offensive, revolting, vile, squalid, feculent, or obscene&equo; seems to have escaped the attention of modern &bquo;artists&equo;. 
 The pity is that Mr Eysenck leaves so many hostages to fortune. 
 His numerous critics will find plenty to amuse them in this volume. 
 One example is irresistible. 
 Having boasted at length of his near-photographic memory and profound passion for poetry, he ends his book by saying &bquo;I shall follow the advice of W.B. Yeats: &bquo;Do not go gentle into that good night/Old age should burn and rage at close of day.' 
 &equo; Whoops.  
 International crime 
 Not yet IBM 
 THE MAFIA. 
 By Claire Sterling. 
 Hamish Hamilton; 384 pages; &pound;15.99. 
 Published by Norton as &bquo;The Octopus&equo;; &dollar;19.95 
 THIS book ends with &bquo;The Dead (a partial list)&equo;, subdivided into &bquo;Distinguished Cadavers&equo; and &bquo;Mafia Losers&equo;. 
 Scanning the names of judges, senior policemen, politicians, journalists and hoodlums, together with the abrupt manner of their disposal &mdash; shot, strangled, dissolved in acid, fed to pigs &mdash; the reader is left in little doubt that, although today's Mafia may have grown into a global enterprise, it is still a long way from joining the ranks of the world's leading multinationals. 
 Contradict your boss in a big corporation, or fumble a marketing campaign, and you could lose your job. 
 Cross a Mafia boss, and you could end up as a protein supplement for Sicilian swine. 
 Claire Sterling sets out to prove that the Sicilian Mafia is an omnipotent organisation rapidly infiltrating the above-ground economy. 
 Her book, in fact, demonstrates the opposite. 
 Only in southern Italy does the Mafia wield the influence Miss Sterling claims it enjoys in America and dozens of other countries. 
 This is a loose, disjointed organisation, riven by strife, which can flourish only where weak or corrupt politicians have lost the will to enforce the law. 
 The Mafia is supposed to make gigantic sums of money. 
 Miss Sterling cites reports that the Sicilian branch alone allegedly made a &dollar;30 billion profit in 1989, and that the American and Sicilian Mafias combined enjoy an annual turnover of &dollar;250 billion. 
 Scores of anecdotes in this book make these figures look highly unlikely. 
 Vincenzo Napoli, allegedly one of the Sicilian Mafia's top men in New York, was arrested after trying to peddle diamonds, guns, stolen paintings and dope to an undercover American police officer. 
 Napoli's proceeds from months of negotiations amounted to a paltry &dollar;6,500. 
 Another top Mafia man, who is supposed to have directed billions of dollars-worth of heroin shipments, spent a decade hanging around Knickerbocker Avenue, a run-down neighbourhood in Brooklyn. 
 The best method the Mafia can think of for distributing its heroin in America is a chain of pizza parlours, where the sons of top mafiosi are frequently offered jobs as a favour to their fathers. 
 Does this sound like the behaviour of men directing a criminal operation boasting an annual turnover four times that of IBM? 
 Even conceding that the drugs trade generates large flows of cash, the idea that the Mafia is a single, stable organisation which has survived for the past 50 years largely intact is plainly wrong. 
 The lives of top Mafia bosses are nasty, brutish and short. 
 They shoot and blow each other up with reckless abandon. 
 A significant number of them end up in jail for long prison terms, often at an age when less adventurous corporate executives are retiring to the golf course. 
 Luciano Leggio, the Sicilian capo who, according to Miss Sterling, claims controls most of the world's heroin trade, has languished behind bars since 1974 and is likely to stay there for life. 
 No business enterprise, however flexible or innovative, could survive such violent upheaval. 
 A better description of the Mafia would be as a network of criminal contacts regularly exploited by shifting alliances of ruthless drug-traffickers and extortionists, who flourish where politicians and policemen are venal or lazy. 
 Sicily has been both the home and haven of the Mafia because politicians throughout Italy have found it convenient to tolerate, rather than prosecute, its activities. 
 The same applies to countries as different as America and Switzerland. 
 Energetic international regulation of banking and tax laws, making it impossible for the mafiosi to launder their ill-gotten gains, would quickly destroy the Mafia and with it the myth of an irrepressible global conspiracy.  
 Italian opera 
 Diminuendo 
 ROME 
 IN THE week that Luciano Pavarotti, arthritic in knee but glorious in voice, was making his triumphant return to the London stage, the operatic news from home was alarming. 
 Although ticket sales may be steadily rising in all 13 of Italy's big opera houses, these owe their survival &mdash; as opera houses do almost everywhere &mdash; to lavish state subsidies; and this season the subsidies have been cut in half, down to &pound;204m (&dollar;329m). 
 Next year another cut will bring them to a mere &pound;182m. 
 As Carlo Fontana, the manager of Bologna's Teatro Comunale, puts it, animosamente: &bquo;We shall simply be obliged to shut down.&equo; 
 With the exception of Verona's open-air summer season in its Roman arena, opera in Italy routinely loses money. 
 Even La Scala, where an opening-night stall seat goes for &pound;500, rarely comes close to breaking even. 
 Each ticket-holder at any Italian opera costs the state an additional &pound;100; &pound;250 in the case of smaller opera houses, such as La Fenice in Venice. 
 And still they boo if the mood takes them. 
 Opera managers, for once, are not simply weeping and wailing; they are trying to adjust to the cuts as best they can. 
 For a start, they have agreed that only eight opera stars will be paid their top wage per performance, &pound;15,000 (&dollar;24,165): Jose Carreras, Mr Pavarotti, Placido Domingo, Alfredo Kraus, Ruggero Raimondi, Samuel Ramey, Mirella Freni and Montserrat Caball&eacute;. 
 However, as Mr Fontana points out, singers' stipends make up only 19% of opera-house budgets. 
 He believes that the houses can survive next year only if they start making their own videotapes of performances, make a habit of exchanging productions among the 13 houses and pray for the arrival of pay-television in Italy. 
 The chief and perhaps insurmountable fault in the Italian opera scene is its dominance by the political parties. 
 Almost everyone on yearly wages in the opera houses owes his or her job to party pull and, once hired, the unions see to it that they are not sacked. 
 An entire production of Strauss's &bquo;Ariadne Auf Naxos&equo; had to be cancelled in Rome last month when the management tried to fire seven members of the orchestra and three dancers. 
 Incompetent as they were, their jobs were untouchable. 
 The eight superstars judged worthy of maximum pay (they could earn much more in Chicago or Tokyo) include only three Italians, Mr Raimondi, Mr Pavarotti and Miss Freni. 
 On top of everything else, Italy is running out of opera singers, probably because the theatres have to spend their money on things other than academies for voice-training. 
 This month's annual Maria Callas international competition for new voices awarded first prizes to a Japanese soprano, Michie Nakamaru, and an Italian mezzo-soprano, Serena Lazzarini. 
 The male contestants, the jury found, were not worth a mention.  
 When is deception not deception? 
 The art of the fake 
 WE MIGHT well be stirred by the sudden prospect of ruins, but once we knew them to be artificial our pleasure would evaporate,&equo; wrote Kenneth Clark in his 1928 &bquo;Gothic Revival&equo;. 
 &bquo;There has come to be something shocking in the discovery that a seeming castle is only a cowshed. 
 It is a sham; it is telling a lie. 
 Our critical outfit is no longer complete without the weapons of morality.&equo; 
 Clark had chanced upon one of the abiding ironies of the century: that this most stridently liberal of times manages to be the most illiberal in its insistence that things should be &bquo;genuine&equo;. 
 This irony is at the heart of the British Museum's witty and challenging exhibition, &bquo;Fake? 
 The Art of Deception&equo;, which runs until September 2nd. 
 Mark Jones, the exhibition's curator, has taken on the dual task of tracing the history of forgery from archaic Babylon to contemporary California, while at the same time tracing the history of how forgery is understood. 
 Neither is straightforward. 
 Some of the objects on show are clearly and satisfyingly &bquo;fake&equo;, in the sense that their sole intention is deception for some form of gain. 
 Thus the show establishes an unlikely moral continuum between a &bquo;fur-bearing trout&equo;, cobbled together by an anonymous naturalist in Victorian Canada, and the Zinoviev Letter, forged by a White Russian cell in 1924 with the (successful) intention of queering the Labour party's pitch in the general election of that year. 
 So far, so good: but other objects are more tricky. 
 Is a Rembrandt etching produced from the artist's own plate, but after his death, a fake? 
 Or does it become one when that plate is restored by another hand (as with Rembrandt's &bquo;Christ Healing the Sick&equo;?) 
 A flower study by the seventeenth-century Flemish painter, Baptiste, is certainly by the artist, and bears his signature: but the blooms (and signature) were pieced together from pirated canvases. 
 A &bquo;genuine&equo; Baptiste? 
 And should an original and lovely &bquo;Samuel Palmer&equo; sketch or &bquo;Vermeer&equo; canvas be any less valued when it turns out to be by Tom Keating or Henricus van Meegaeren? 
 When the young Raphael painted in the style of Leonardo, he was invited to redecorate the Vatican. 
 When Keating painted in the style of Palmer, he was picked up by the Fraud Squad. 
 So much for liberalism. 
 The uncovering of frauds is fascinating in itself. 
 The &bquo;Botticelli&equo; shown here, for example, was cast in doubt when Clark, then a young man, thought the face too like that of a twentieth-century screen goddess. 
 The robe, too, is painted in Prussian blue, a pigment not introduced until the eighteenth century. 
 The piece is still lovely; it was sold in 1930 for &dollar;25,000. 
 But it may be as little as a century old. 
 Perhaps the most audacious thing about this exhibition is that the British Museum should have countenanced it at all. 
 It is set, after all, in a museum which is a perfect Periclean Ionic temple: but it is not a temple, not in Ionia, and was built 2,300 years after Pericles's death. 
 Most of the 600 artefacts on show, too, come from the BM's own collection. 
 One of the exhibition's most striking images is the so-called Townley Discobolus. 
 The Discobolus, a life-size model of a discus-thrower, was a Hellenistic reworking of a classical sculpture in the first place, but that did not stop the BM from buying it; fakes seem to get less fake with age. 
 When it was irrefutably demonstrated to the museum's elders in 1809 that the statue's head was not genuine, however, its potential fakeness became a threat. 
 The museum did what any other body might have done: it firmly denied the veracity of the new evidence, not owning up until 1861. 
 Truth is a mutable commodity, even among its purveyors. 
 Perhaps the greatest irony, though, is that the birth of the great museums in the last century did as much as anything to foster the idea that there was a single, empirical truth to be told. 
 By narrowing the field of what is &bquo;real&equo;, museums like the BM have broadened the definition of what is false. 
 Mr Jones's catalogue introduction claims that &bquo;Fakes?&equo; may well &bquo;affect our conception of reality (sic) itself&equo;. 
 Unfortunately for the British Museum, the first examples of that reality experienced by the viewer on leaving the exhibition are the rooms containing its Roman collection. 
 One thing that has not changed with the passing millennia, however, is the rage of the man whose work is forged. 
 In 1506 D&uuml;rer sued Marcantonio Raimondi for producing forged engravings of his &bquo;Life of the Virgin&equo; series. 
 In 1981 David Hockney scrawled &bquo;This is not my work&equo; across a drawing purporting to be Hockney's &bquo;Colourful head-dress&equo; of 1963. 
 According to Mr Jones, the modern forger's energies are more usually expended on producing counterfeit Rolexes or Lebanese &bquo;Johnnie Hawker&equo; Red Label whisky than on fine art. 
 One artist who managed to turn the tables on this trend was an American painter, J.S.G. Boggs. 
 In October 1986 Mr Boggs's drawing of a &pound;5 note was exhibited at London's Young Unknowns Gallery. 
 In October 1987 it featured as an exhibit of an altogether different type, in a private criminal prosecution at the Old Bailey. 
 Mr Boggs was acquitted, but has subsequently been prosecuted in Australia for drawing Australian dollars. 
 Curiouser and curiouser.  
 The man after Mikhail? 
 GAINST THE GRAIN. 
 By Boris Yeltsin. 
 Jonathan Cape; 215 pages; &pound;12.95. 
 Summit; &dollar;19.95 
 BORIS YELTSIN, maverick and volleyball enthusiast, is the only plausible rival to Mikhail Gorbachev for the first freely elected president of the Soviet Union. 
 As Mr Gorbachev's popularity wanes, the question of whether Mr Yeltsin is suited for such a job becomes more urgent. 
 On the evidence of this book, he is far better suited to winning the election than to succeeding in the presidency. 
 Boastful, overbearing and bumptious, he emerges by his own account as the eternal mocker of authority, rarely the effective wielder of it. 
 Here is young Boris Nikolayevich fearlessly exposing his primary-school teacher as a sadist; deprived of his right to secondary education by vengeful teachers, he triumphantly appeals over their heads and continues his studies. 
 Here is conscientious Boris Nikolayevich, completing his graduate dissertation in one month rather than the usual five and then refusing the automatic promotion for which this would normally have qualified him, resolving instead to spend a year laying bricks, mixing concrete and becoming one of the boys. 
 There again is the brave Boris Nikolayevich facing up to a murderous convict who has been given work on a building site and is threatening foreman Yeltsin with an axe; sheer strength of will sends the man packing and the construction team gets the work done on time. 
 Presumably Mr Yeltsin was doing all this in the name of some ideas or policies, but he barely mentions them. 
 He seems not to have thought, for example, about the future role of the Communist party or the way in which elections &mdash; of which he is a living symbol &mdash; might shape a future Soviet Union. 
 The book seems concerned with defending Mr Yeltsin rather than propounding a set of distinctive policies; it gives an unsettling impression that this man does admirable things out of vanity. 
 Ironically, this also makes his autobiography unsatisfactory even as a self-portrait. 
 Mr Yeltsin is a successful career communist who fought his way up through the construction-industry bureaucracy to become first secretary of Sverdlovsk, his home town and one of the largest cities in the Soviet Union. 
 This background is shared by other prominent politicians, notably the prime minister, Nikolai Ryzhkov, who also comes from Sverdlovsk and also made his name in the industrial bureaucracy. 
 Yet the book makes no attempt to explain why the rebellious Mr Yeltsin turned out so differently from the establishment Mr Ryzhkov. 
 It therefore gives little hint of what makes its author so extraordinary a figure. 
 Similarly, Mr Yeltsin, like Mr Gorbachev, was born into a peasant family during the calamitous 1930s and came to political maturity during the first days of Khrushchev, when hope began to dawn after Stalin's long night. 
 A generation of politicians is now in power whose opinions have been shaped not only by the Stalinist dictatorship but also by the defeat of the first attempts at reform. 
 It would be revealing to know more about the lessons Mr Yeltsin draws from this historical experience, yet the experience &mdash; along with Khrushchev's name &mdash; is all but absent from the book. 
 This lack of reflectiveness and disinclination to make policy has contributed to the failure of the Interregional Group of Deputies, an informal club of MPs, to turn itself into an effective parliamentary opposition. 
 Mr Yeltsin is its best known member and probably the only one who could give it party discipline and a distinctive ideology. 
 In fact, it has neither; and because of this, Mr Yeltsin himself is often underestimated. 
 Last September, by his own account, he was bundled into a car late one night and dumped into the Moscow river. 
 A police investigation found no evidence that this had happened; Mr Yeltsin refused to press charges and, in front of the parliament, dismissed the events as &bquo;a joke&equo;. 
 The story would have sunk most politicians yet, six months later, Mr Yeltsin is the front runner for the post of president of the Russian federation &mdash; a post which, according to the logic of Mr Gorbachev's decentralising reforms, will become the second most important in the country. 
 His success shows that Mr Yeltsin has a useful service to perform for Soviet democracy. 
 He can be the scourge of the corrupt old guard. 
 Only a bully could have stood up to the bullying party bureaucracy; Mr Yeltsin has taken them on at their own game and beaten them. 
 The best parts of his book reveal the Honecker-like corruption that weaves around the top of the Communist party and embraces even Mr Gorbachev himself. 
 This might one day play a powerful role in the reaction against the president. 
 The book has one last virtue: it is, at least when it talks about people other than Mr Yeltsin, far more entertaining than most books by western politicians. 
 Here, as proof of glasnost, are some of Mr Yeltsin's opinions of his former colleagues: 
 Dmitri Yazov:&equo; completely lacks the grounding for the post of defence minister.&equo; 
 Vadim Medvedev: &bquo;His grossly sententious remarks and stale vocabulary that reeked of hack journalism were unbearable.&equo; 
 Mikhail Gorbachev: &bquo;growing more and more fond of his own voice. 
 It was obvious that power was exerting its hold over him; he was losing his grip on reality, possessed as he was by the illusion that perestroika was developing widely.&equo;  
 Art theft 
 Mrs Gardner's folly 
 BOSTON 
 AN UNCONSCIOUS irony lies behind this week's massive art theft from Boston's Gardner Museum. 
 The sense of outrage has almost as much to do with the invasion of a hallowed shrine of old Boston as with the robbery. 
 Yet Mrs Gardner, a New Yorker, was cold-shouldered by Boston nineteenth-century society as a pushy outsider whose Parisian dresses were viewed with horror by the matrons of Back Bay. 
 &bquo;Pray, who undressed you?&equo; one wit inquired, hoping to embarrass her. 
 He failed. 
 &bquo;Worth,&equo; she answered. 
 &bquo;And didn't he do it well?&equo; 
 It might be said that the museum was Mrs Gardner's revenge; Fenway Court, the remarkable Italian palazzo which she built well outside respectable Boston among the city's breweries and distilleries, was named by her The Isabella Stuart Gardner Museum. 
 It was created as a monument to her own taste; her will left clear instructions against any alteration at any time to the collection of paintings, statuary and furniture. 
 The moving of a single chair would be sufficient reason for the museum to be instantly dissolved. 
 Boston might have succeeded in snubbing Mrs Gardner, but she made sure that they would never forget her. 
 A friend of Henry James who shared his passion for Venice (although the novelist had reservations about her creation of a fake palace in his home town), Mrs Gardner transferred her passion from clothes and jewels to art in the 1890s. 
 One of her first purchases has become the museum's biggest loss: &bquo;The Concert&equo; by Jan Vermeer, bought at an auction in Paris for FFr29,000. 
 Two years later she began using Bernard Berenson as her buyer of Italian old masters, although it might be said that Berenson was using her, praising each new find in breathless superlatives in order to get the best price out of his patroness. 
 No fool, Berenson went in for finding &bquo;Isabellas&equo;; Mrs Gardner fancied herself as America's answer to Isabella d'Este, the great Renaissance art collector. 
 Her favourite Isabella (later demoted to &bquo;Lady in a Turban&equo;) was snapped up for the museum in 1896, a few weeks before one of Berenson's best finds, a Rembrandt self-portrait. 
 Next year brought her a Titian and in 1898 Berenson persuaded her to buy Rembrandt's only known seascape. 
 A fine of &dollar;200,000 for violating customs laws brought her collecting to a halt in 1904, but two years later the museum was open and Mrs Gardner was collecting again. 
 Mrs Gardner was a regal custodian of her palace museum. 
 Visitors were allowed entry only in batches of 200; no sketches or notes were permitted on the premises; future directors were obliged by her will to live in situ, on the fourth floor (a rule which has been broken only by the present director). 
 In her own lifetime, the owner's formidable presence helped to keep the treasures safe. 
 &bquo;Tapestries Slashed&equo;, ran a dramatic headline in one paper; in fact, the would-be vandal had  scarcely  taken her scissors out of her pocket before Mrs Gardner swooped on her and called the police. 
 It is unfortunate that Mrs Gardner's thoroughness did not extend to laying down the law about insurance. 
 It was only after the two thieves dressed up as policemen had escaped last Sunday with treasures conservatively estimated at &dollar;200m that it was revealed that they were uninsured. 
 No clear pattern has been found in the theft. 
 The Vermeer has gone, but the Titian was left untouched. 
 Two Rembrandts have gone, including the priceless seascape, but not the self-portrait. 
 Other losses are a superb Manet, five paintings by Degas, a Shang Dynasty beaker and a landscape by one of Rembrandt's pupils. 
 There is not much comfort for the museum in the knowledge that celebrated works are impossible to fence; the idiosyncratic choice of stolen works strongly suggests that one buyer's taste was being followed and that they are destined to be hidden away in a private collection, possibly in South America or Japan. 
 The museum has been closed since the robbery. 
 Concern for the safety of the remaining masterpieces makes it unlikely that  future  visitors will be able to enjoy the relaxed atmosphere which was one of the museum's greatest charms. 
 Until now, Fenway Court has always retained the feeling of a private home, enhanced by such domestic touches as little vases of flowers, evening concerts and even a table laid out as if for tea; it never seemed wholly incredible that Mrs Gardner herself would suddenly stroll through the door. 
 In her charm, alas, lay her folly.  
 Politics and the countryside 
 Born-again greenery 
 TITMUSS REGAINED. 
 By John Mortimer. 
 Viking; 281 pages; &pound;13.99 and &dollar;19.95 
 WHO are more preposterous: the developers marching round southern England drawing up plans to turn some of the world's most pleasing countryside into toytown suburbs; or the nouveau-rural Volvo commuters looking for trendy ways to stop them? 
 With even-handed ridicule, John Mortimer spends much of this novel making you laugh at both. 
 This is the sequel to &bquo;Paradise Postponed&equo;, which charted the rise of Leslie Titmuss &mdash; a rural version of Norman Tebbit &mdash; from country yokel to cabinet minister. 
 &bquo;Titmuss Regained&equo; is the story of how Titmuss, like the present Conservative party, attempts to go green. 
 He does so as an expedient: to protect his newly acquired country manor, threatened by a new town, and to conserve the votes of the green-welly brigade. 
 One of Mr Mortimer's more subtle themes is the way these new-found principles throw Titmuss into an ideological tangle. 
 How can he reconcile his selective greenness with a recent speech to the construction industry condemning conservationists as &bquo;the rich socialists who live in their converted farmhouses&equo;? 
 &bquo;Free scope for market forces and commercial development&equo;, Titmuss muses, &bquo;must be balanced against the claims of the environment, and there was, surely, more environment round Rapstone Valley &lsqb;his country seat&rsqb; than almost anywhere else in the British Isles.&equo; 
 Yet this is a politician not given to balancing market forces against anything: as unreal an animal, implies rich socialist Mr Mortimer, as a green Tory party in real life. 
 Political novels rarely work well both as politics and as literature. 
 Mr Mortimer wisely limits his literary aim to writing a &bquo;good bad book&equo;: highly entertaining, but with no great subtlety of characterisation or plot. 
 As in Dickens, things are mainly black and white. 
 That makes a light read, with the serious points easily digestible. 
 And even characters who seem unconvincing become enjoyable representatives of their times. 
 Mr Mortimer does not confine his message to high politics. 
 He caricatures a host of little people shaped by the 1980s, from hillbillies-turned-entrepreneurs to fund-raisers who have learnt to make money out of charity. 
 Most are judged harshly; the exception, a quiet country doctor whose simple life is upset by the forces unleashed by Leslie Titmuss, betrays Mr Mortimer's prejudice. 
 For all his irreverence about &bquo;Nimbies&equo;, he clearly believes there is some genuine rural idyll worth preserving. 
 Threatened by a new motorway or housing development near his home in the Chilterns, Mr Mortimer would probably be the biggest Nimby of them all. 
 AMERICAN SURVEY 
 The census 
 One, two, three&hellip; 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 COUNTING Americans is not easy but the law insists that it be done. 
 The Founding Fathers declared that an &bquo;enumeration&equo; should take place every ten years so that members of the House of Representatives can be fairly apportioned among the states. 
 Easy for them to say. 
 When Americans reply to the twenty-first national census on April 1st, they will take part in a statistical marathon costing &dollar;2.5 billion and employing 8,500 full-time and 500,000 part-time staff. 
 It took two years for the Bureau of the Census to draw up the list of 106m households to which, on March 23rd, it posted its questionnaires. 
 Millions of other Americans &mdash; mainly those living in rural areas, in institutions, and in certain housing estates &mdash; will have personal visits from census-takers either to deliver or pick up the forms. 
 So will anybody who fails to return the questionnaire. 
 Other groups merit special treatment. 
 Census-takers have already trudged across Alaskan snow to count the Aleuts and Eskimos who quit their winter villages when the spring comes. 
 On March 20th their colleagues fanned out across cities to shelters, soup kitchens and street corners in order, for the first time, to try to count the homeless. 
 Most people will be asked 14 questions about their age, sex, race, marital status and the kind of home they live in. 
 One in six will get a longer form asking 59 questions about such things as housing loans, commuting patterns and job history. 
 In the end, the Census Bureau expects to find that the total population is about 250m, is getting older, is still moving from the north-east and midwest to the south and west, and that metropolitan areas grew more rapidly in the 1980s than in the 1970s. 
 It will also, eventually, accumulate a mass of fine detail: on how many people have flush-toilets, for instance. 
 A new and controversial question will find out how many couples of the same sex are partners (or, more accurately, how many are prepared to report the fact). 
 The information will become known a bit faster than it used to be. 
 The technology used by the bureau has improved. 
 Bar-code-reading &bquo;wands&equo; will check in the questionnaires as they arrive at various offices. 
 The answers &mdash; read from microfilm by an optical scanner &mdash; can now be processed in district offices. 
 These changes should allow the bureau to release the first summary reports in late spring next year, some six months or so earlier than in 1980. 
 For the first time, the bureau will compile population figures for the whole country by &bquo;street blocks&equo; that will be defined by roads, rivers, county boundaries and the like. 
 A computerised-map system known as Topologically Integrated Geographic Encoding and Referencing or TIGER will organise data from the census according to geography. 
 This should enable computers to give highly detailed information: how many people live within a radius of a certain point, for example, or how many live along a river's flood plain. 
 Can't please everyone 
 By its nature a census is political. 
 The American one has to decide how many members of Congress each state should have. 
 The bureau will tell the president this on December 31st. 
 It will tell the states by April 1 1991 about the shifts in their populations that call for changes in state and local constituency boundaries. 
 These figures not only lead to partisan squabbles and gerrymandering but also affect the amount of money that states and local jurisdictions receive from the federal government. 
 Some &dollar;39 billion in grants each year &mdash; for housing, education and roads &mdash; depends on the census. 
 This makes everybody worry about the result, wanting to make sure that the numbers are properly added up. 
 The counting of the homeless &mdash; and the arguments about how exact the results will be &mdash; is one manifestation of this. 
 Minority groups have traditionally been under-counted, particularly in big cities. 
 In an attempt to change that, the Census Bureau has launched a vigorous campaign to get as many people as possible to answer its questions. 
 To help, it has hired 300 specialists, half of them black and all but two from minority groups, to work with ethnic groups. 
 The bureau has designed colourful posters and brochures in different languages, aimed at audiences that include minorities, religious congregations and businesses. 
 Public-service advertisements have been sent to newspapers, magazines and television programmes. 
 Some 5,000 towns and cities have agreed, at the bureau's urging, to run their own census-awareness programmes. 
 Los Angeles took the census as its theme for its float in the Rose Bowl Parade. 
 But those who stand to lose the most from under-counting want more to be done. 
 After every census, the bureau conducts its own internal estimate of how many people it missed: in 1980 it thought it had missed 1.4% of the population, including 5&ndash;6% of blacks (and perhaps as many as 18% of black males). 
 This was made worse by a slight over-count of whites &mdash; people with two homes, for instance, tended to be double-counted. 
 This time the losers, including the cities of New York, Los Angeles, Chicago and Houston, and the US Conference of Mayors, have taken the bureau to court to try to make it agree to change its initial 1990 findings and to add in its estimated under-count. 
 The bureau has said it will consider doing so if its estimates are good enough. 
 This will not be the only lawsuit. 
 After 1980 the bureau &mdash; which most people believe does as good a job as can be expected &mdash; had 52 suits filed against it. 
 The Founding Fathers would have been amazed.  
 Religion 
 Shelters of the Lord 
 SEATTLE 
 THE Rev Robert Schuller is possibly the best known television minister in America. 
 Yet he has a problem that most video pulpiteers do not. 
 He has a real church to manage. 
 And although his glitzy Crystal Cathedral in Garden Grove, California, is not everybody's idea of a parish church, in its own way that is what it is. 
 Balancing the dual roles of minister to the world and shepherd to his own flock has taken its toll. 
 Early in March Mr Schuller announced that he was bringing a Seattle minister, the Rev Bruce Larson, to Garden Grove as his &bquo;co-pilot&equo;. 
 It could be a rough flight. 
 The Crystal Cathedral is invariably full on Sunday. 
 But most of the 8,000 people sitting in the glass house are tourists drawn by Mr Schuller's fame (he is seen by about 1.3m American households each Sunday) and the eye-popping spectacle of the cathedral designed by Mr Philip Johnson. 
 But church membership has plunged from nearly 8,000 in 1984 to about 2,000. 
 Mr Schuller's local congregation is not altogether happy with his imperial style and church finances are suffering. 
 Enter Mr Larson, the well-liked pastor of Seattle's 3,600-member University Presbyterian Church, who has 22 books to his credit and is witty and literate behind a pulpit. 
 But it is his organisational and fund-raising skills that Mr Schuller most coveted: in ten years Mr Larson doubled his church's membership with people who are wonderfully ready to whip out their wallets. 
 Whether Mr Larson will ever start his new job, scheduled to begin in June, might be disputed by Mrs Elizabeth Prophet. 
 Mrs Prophet, also known as Guru Ma, has predicted a nuclear cataclysm for April 23rd. 
 In response nearly 3,000 of her followers, members of the Church Universal and Triumphant, have packed their possessions and fled to 33,000 acres of church-owned land in Montana's Paradise Valley. 
 There they are busily ferreting away food, medical supplies and weapons with which to build a new world after the current one is reduced to a moist cinder. 
 The church's property is honeycombed with underground shelters. 
 Forecasting doom is a habit of Mrs Prophet's. 
 She earlier proclaimed that last October would be the end of life on earth. 
 Church members are again braced for disappointment should April 23rd pass quietly. 
 This will simply mean that Guru Ma's prayers for peace were answered. 
 Such proof of her powers may help Mrs Prophet in her other pursuit: a down-payment of &dollar;10,000 is usually required to ensure a place in her post-nuclear world. 
 Montana officials have responded to Mrs Prophet's ideas of Armageddon like battle-hardened bureaucrats. 
 Until church members complete a sewer system, they have been forbidden to use their newly hewn bomb shelters.  
 The politics of death 
 SAN FRANCISCO AND WASHINGTON, DC 
 ONE of the most striking differences between the United States and other advanced industrial countries is America's enthusiasm for execution. 
 Over the past few years several rather unexpected countries &mdash; Cambodia, Haiti, Romania (admittedly after executing Nicolae Ceausescu) and, the latest recruit, Namibia &mdash; have joined most of Western Europe and Latin America in abolishing the death penalty for ordinary criminal offences. 
 Since 1976, when the Supreme Court re-established that the death penalty was constitutional, 13 American states have executed 121 people, and the number is on the rise. 
 Most of the executions have been in the old South. 
 But now California is poised for its first execution in 23 years. 
 Mr Robert Harris was convicted in 1978 of the particularly callous murder of two teenage boys in San Diego. 
 The state Supreme Court recently rejected his latest habeas corpus petition; his execution is scheduled to take place at 3am in the gas chamber at San Quentin prison on April 3rd. 
 There are 277 people, besides Mr Harris, waiting in the prison's five-tiered death row. 
 Mr Harris had applied for a clemency hearing before the governor, Mr George Deukmejian. 
 But on March 20th, a week before the hearing was due, he withdrew his request, saying that he could not expect a fair hearing from the governor and had no wish to take part in an &bquo;empty game&equo;. 
 Mr Deukmejian, who was elected governor in 1982, has been trying for a mighty long time to get the death penalty enforced in California. 
 For several years he was frustrated by the state Supreme Court, which reviews all death sentences: over a nine-year period the court reversed 64 of 68 sentences. 
 But in 1986 the governor led a successful campaign by the state's voters to remove the chief justice, Miss Rose Bird, and her two liberal colleagues. 
 The court now upholds three-quarters of the death sentences it reviews. 
 In many countries besides America, public opinion strongly supports capital punishment &mdash; undeterred by the fact that no criminological study has ever been able to prove that it reduces crime. 
 Recent surveys find 80% of Americans in favour, though the proportion drops when they are offered the alternative of a life imprisonment that genuinely means for life. 
 Only once, in 1966 when there had been a lot of discussion on the ethics of capital punishment, did a Gallup poll find that American support for death as the punishment for murder had fallen below 50%. 
 Surveys show similar results in other countries. 
 The difference is that, in America, politicians are more likely to follow public opinion on this question, not try to change it. 
 As Mr Michael Dukakis found to his cost in 1988, voters equate opposition to the death penalty with being soft on crime, support for it with being tough. 
 The 1990 election campaigns are confirming that this lesson was well learnt: candidates are indulging in ghoulish rivalry in support of execution. 
 In California all three candidates for governor have promised to keep the gas chamber busy. 
 Miss Dianne Feinstein, a former mayor of San Francisco, jumped ahead of Mr John Van de Kamp, her main rival for the Democratic nomination, largely because of a television commercial in which she stressed that she was pro-choice on abortion and strongly in favour of capital punishment &mdash; a stand that some critics have summed up as pro-death. 
 Mr Van de Kamp, the state attorney-general, who admits to a personal distaste for execution, has responded with a commercial in which he boasts of sending people to death row &mdash; while, in the background, the camera dwells on a close-up of the gas chamber. 
 The Californian pattern is repeated elsewhere. 
 In the recent Democratic primary for governor in Texas, one candidate, Mr Mark White, put out a gruesome commercial in which he strode triumphantly past photographs of the people who had been executed while he was governor in 1983&ndash;87. 
 He still lost. 
 But Mr Jim Mattox, one of the two Democrats who will be competing in the run-off election for the party's nomination on April 10th, tried in similar vein to take credit for executions even though, as Texas's attorney-general, he is involved with civil cases, not criminal ones. 
 When his rival, Mrs Ann Richards, received unwanted support from a prison newspaper, the Mattox campaign quickly adopted the slogan: &bquo;Jim Mattox. 
 There are no endorsements for him on death row.&equo; 
 The death penalty has featured in campaigns in Florida; in Georgia, where Mr Andrew Young, the former mayor of Atlanta who is now running for governor, has said that capital punishment is sometimes necessary; in Michigan, where the Republican Senate candidate, Mr Bill Schuette, has attacked Democratic Senator Carl Levin for opposing it; in one of this week's congressional by-elections in New York. 
 There is irony in the last example. 
 Mr Mario Cuomo, New York's governor, has led the way in showing that a politician can stand up to the capital-punishment lobby. 
 In vetoing repeated efforts by the state legislature to adopt the death penalty (it is still one vote short of a veto override), Mr Cuomo has taken the moral high ground &mdash; and does not seem to have lost votes by doing so. 
 The death penalty is on Congress's agenda too. 
 The Supreme Court under Chief Justice William Rehnquist is unhappy about the long delays between sentencing and execution. 
 There are around 2,400 people on death row; 20 times the number executed in the past 13 years. 
 Mr Harris has been on California's death row for 11 years and has appealed under habeas corpus eight times. 
 Last year a commission recommended a limit of one such appeal, together with extra safeguards about the quality of legal representation. 
 Mr Rehnquist urged Congress to adopt these changes. 
 But on March 14th he was overruled by a majority of federal judges on the Judicial Conference which sets court policy. 
 The conference recommended increasing the chances of a second appeal as well as toughening the standards for legal representation (there are reports of cases where people sentenced to death had been represented by law students). 
 The Senate will probably go along with the conference's wishes. 
 It may be more hesitant than the House of Representatives about extending the death penalty, for instance for drug-dealing. 
 And it does not like the idea of executing people who are mentally retarded or who committed their crimes when they were juveniles, though the Supreme Court has refused to rule either unconstitutional. 
 The Senate Judiciary Committee has also been studying evidence that the death penalty discriminates against black Americans. 
 Reports reviewed recently by the General Accounting Office showed that capital punishment was more likely to be imposed if the murder victim was white rather than black. 
 The evidence of a similar bias towards the death penalty for black rather than white murderers is less good, but still quite persuasive. 
 Congress may adopt a racial-justice amendment that would allow blacks to appeal against conviction on the ground of systematic racial bias. 
 Forgotten in this debate is the issue of cost. 
 Some death-penalty supporters advance the argument that it is unfair on taxpayers to expect them to finance a convict's imprisonment for life. 
 Yet, thanks to the cumbersome appeals procedure, each execution currently costs between &dollar;2m and &dollar;5m, four or five times what it costs to keep someone in prison for life. 
 And if, as Congress is contemplating, the quality of legal representation is raised to offset any dilution of the appeals procedure, those costs are unlikely to fall much. 
 Is there any real chance of an American change of heart? 
 Advocates of capital punishment are unmoved at the prospect of the United States being increasingly isolated among developed countries: such countries, they argue, have less violent crime than America has. 
 California's first execution may open the floodgates. 
 What are needed are more Mario Cuomos, politicians who are prepared to put moral and practical argument above political expediency.  
 Foreign aid 
 I know my wallet's somewhere 
 PRESENTED with the bill for the celebration-of-democracy party, President Bush and his legislators on Capitol Hill are searching, or making a great show of searching, their pockets. 
 Congress scolds the administration for not being forthcoming enough in its proposals for aid to Eastern Europe. 
 The White House scolds Congress for being dilatory in finding cash for Panama and Nicaragua. 
 The partygoers wait. 
 Mr Bush livened the act last week when he said he was giving Congress until March 27th to decide which current defence programmes should be trimmed to raise &dollar;870m for Panama and Nicaragua (money that is supposed to come from the 1990 Pentagon budget). 
 Otherwise, he said, congressmen should hand the job over to him &mdash; and he snapped his fingers to show how quickly and easily he could cut defence spending by that measly amount. 
 It was a vigorous performance that went down well with a public that is feeling a mite embarrassed about not putting its money where America's mouth was once so loud. 
 Congressmen, relieved that they no longer have to shed their reputations in fighting over Nicaragua, are quite keen to find the &dollar;300m that is seen as an inaugural present for Mrs Violeta Chamorro on April 25th. 
 But they have had since January to come up with the &dollar;570m that Mr Bush requested as emergency aid and compensation for post-invasion Panama. 
 Congressmen are reluctant to make a defence cut that might pain them in their own districts. 
 And some of them want most of the money to go to Eastern Europe. 
 As they bicker, Panama is flat broke. 
 America's economic sanctions failed to dislodge General Manuel Noriega but squeezed the economy dry; the invasion that did dislodge him left a war-battered city, with some 18,000 people homeless and unemployment soaring. 
 To show &bquo;solidarity with the poor&equo;, and hoping, politely, to shame the Americans into faster delivery, President Guillermo Endara spent the first half of March fasting in Metropolitan Cathedral. 
 In less polite ways, Panama may be pushing its luck. 
 It is, for instance, asking for compensation for the guns confiscated by American troops because they belong to the Panamanian government. 
 But the Americans, apart from the fact that they probably provided the guns in the first place, paid out &dollar;1m to persuade people to hand them in. 
 A different, and harder, set of problems is raised by Eastern Europe. 
 The administration and Congress agree on the need to help the new or emerging democracies but disagree on almost everything else: how much aid should be given, where it should come from and who should control it. 
 Congress, having pooh-poohed Mr Bush's first proposals as inadequate, appropriated &dollar;433m for Poland and Hungary in fiscal 1990. 
 Mr Bush is now suggesting &dollar;300m for all Eastern Europe in fiscal 1991; the Senate and the House think this too little. 
 The lion's share of whatever figure is agreed would go to Poland and Hungary: Czechoslovakia has not, as yet, requested direct aid (President Vaclav Havel, speaking to Congress, concentrated on the importance of helping the Soviet Union); Romania, so far, gets mainly subsidised food; there are no plans for helping Bulgaria; East Germany has West Germany; Yugoslavia gets almost no direct aid. 
 Mr Lawrence Eagleburger, the deputy secretary of state who has been given the job of co-ordinating America's help for Eastern Europe, was told by Congress that the money the administration has in mind is too modest, but that its ideas about who should control the distribution of this money are immodest. 
 The question is whether the congressional Democrats or the Republican administration should run the programme. 
 Mr Bush's men are trying to establish the administration's authority: they want to be able to decide freely where the money goes and in what form; and they want to be allowed to shift it at will from one country, and one programme, to another. 
 At present about 85% of foreign aid is earmarked by Congress for specific purposes in selected countries: unlucky countries that have not been singled out for earmarked money are vulnerable to savage cuts. 
 Mr Bush, and his secretary of state, Mr James Baker, are trying to get more control for themselves, advocating &bquo;constructive consultation&equo; with Congress as an alternative to earmarking. 
 Members of the House Foreign Affairs Committee got an early taste of this when they asked Mr Eagleburger how the administration proposed dividing up that &dollar;300m for Eastern Europe: his answer, again and again, was &bquo;I don't know&equo;. 
 The dispute over control spills into the dispute about where the money should come from. 
 When the Republican leader in the Senate, Mr Robert Dole, suggested that 5% be taken from the five top recipients, he killed two birds with one shock-horror proposal: he sent a signal to the Israeli government, and he queried the sacrosanct nature of the earmarked programmes. 
 Mr Bush's insouciance in snapping &dollar;870m for Panama and Nicaragua from the 1990 defence budget suggests that extra foreign aid for Eastern Europe could, without too much difficulty, be trimmed from the 1991 defence budget. 
 With the president &mdash; though not his defence secretary &mdash; proposing cuts in that budget by the day, the consensus is that there will be a peace dividend in fiscal 1991 of at least &dollar;12 billion. 
 The new democracies have a respectable claim to some of that dividend but America's inclination, at present, is that it should all go to reducing the budget deficit.  
 Goodbye Quarry Heights? 
 PANAMA CITY 
 MILITARY planners are once more talking about US Southern Command leaving Panama. 
 No decision has been taken but the move could be as early as the summer. 
 Southcom controls all American military activity in Central and South America, covering 19 countries and 8m square miles. 
 Its headquarters staff includes six generals, headed by its controversial commander, General Maxwell Thurman. 
 Removing Southcom headquarters from Quarry Heights, a hill with a commanding view over Panama City and the canal, will still leave 13,000 American troops in Panama dispersed among nine bases. 
 Under the Panama canal treaties, the United States is to hand over all military facilities to Panama in a gradual &bquo;draw-down&equo; before the end of 1999. 
 Debate on Southcom's future, which has dragged on for years, was put on hold when American relations with General Noriega reached rock-bottom. 
 With him removed, the way has been reopened. 
 Seven new sites in the United States are under consideration; the likely favourite is the MacDill air force base at Tampa in Florida.  
 Cab, sir? 
 NEW YORK 
 SURPRISING: there are people in New York who say that the city is too rude. 
 A group called New York Pride is trying to persuade fellow citizens to show more civility. 
 The idea, supported with advertisements and an &bquo;anti-scowl&equo; logo, is that the city would be a less fearsome place if people were nicer to each other. 
 Will New York's taxi-drivers, known everywhere for their direct approach, heed this message? 
 A special commission handles 500&ndash;800 complaints a day. 
 Cabbies have been known to overcharge, to threaten passengers and to hurl their luggage around with little concern as to where it lands. 
 Yes; The Economist's own inspector can report. 
 Every taxi-driver he encountered was polite, indeed charming. 
 Two went so far as to offer to reduce the metered fare after having taken a wrong turn in error. 
 &bquo;My goodness, I do apologise&equo;: or words to that effect. 
 Clearly the tide of beastliness has turned.  
 Connecticut 
 Weicker redux 
 NEW HAVEN 
 WHEN Mr William O'Neill, the governor of Connecticut, announced on March 20th that he would not run for re-election, he gave two reasons. 
 First were the &bquo;political realities&equo; that faced him; second, he said, was his fear that he would have to campaign negatively in order to succeed. 
 The political reality is that Connecticut is suffering from the economic slowdown that has hit most of the north-east. 
 Last year Mr O'Neill was obliged to raise taxes by &dollar;1 billion and to cut both spending and staff (though the state's budget deficit is still expected to rise above &dollar;90m this year). 
 His popularity rating dropped accordingly. 
 A large cast of characters was lining up to challenge Mr O'Neill before he announced his decision (and others may now join the battle). 
 The challengers include two congressmen and a heterodox former Republican senator who stirs strong emotions on both sides of the political fence. 
 The ex-Republican is Mr Lowell Weicker, a blunt critic of the conservative wing of the party, who was unseated in 1988 after a number of prominent right-wing politicians supported his Democratic opponent. 
 Mr Weicker will now run as an independent. 
 He has neither a running mate nor a campaign headquarters, but when he announced his bid he shot to the top of the polls. 
 This prompted two Republican candidates who are faring poorly to invite Mr Weicker back to the party; he refused. 
 The leading Republican and Democratic contenders are Representatives John Rowland and Bruce Morrison. 
 Mr Rowland is a man in the mould of Vice-President Dan Quayle: young, handsome and hawkish. 
 He has supported the MX missile, star wars and chemical-weapons production. 
 He has visited Vietnam several times to search for missing American soldiers, a venture that plays well in his district which is home to a lot of ex-servicemen. 
 Mr Morrison has been likened to another vice-president, the late Hubert Humphrey. 
 A former legal-aid attorney, Mr Morrison is unusual in accepting, even welcoming, a liberal label.  
 White and black Chicago 
 &bquo;MARIA PAPPAS for County Commissioner&equo;, &bquo;Raul Villalobos for State Attorney&equo;, &bquo;William Patrick O'Malley for Judge&equo;. 
 After five minutes in Chicago, where every lamp-post is festooned with flyers, where every office is up for grabs, and where every name proclaims the city's ethnic diversity, a visitor swims in the sheer exuberance. 
 So much for the handwringing about the decline of the political process that goes on in Washington. 
 In a year without a presidential contest, in elections that were merely primaries &mdash; and mainly for local offices &mdash; around 45% of registered voters turned out on March 20th. 
 This would not be bad by any country's standards. 
 But there is more: Chicago's elections, once notoriously corrupt, now seem pretty clean. 
 One of the contests on Tuesday was the primary election for Illinois's next governor. 
 After 14 years in office the state's Republican governor, Mr Jim Thompson, is standing down. 
 As expected, Mr Jim Edgar, Illinois's secretary of state, won the Republican party's nomination. 
 But his young challenger, Mr Steven Baer, won around a third of the vote with little money and no organisation. 
 All he did was to say &bquo;no&equo; to tax increases and to abortions. 
 His relative success was proof that the managerial style that Mr Bush has adopted in Washington has not doused the passions of those conservatives who like their right-wing politics raw. 
 Chicago was reminded that defeating an incumbent member of the House of Representatives is not easy. 
 Two members of Chicago's congressional delegation, Mr Sidney Yates and Mr Gus Savage, faced strong challenges. 
 Yet both won. 
 Of the two, Mr Yates, who will be 81 in November and has been in Congress almost without a break since he was first elected in 1948, had the easier time of it. 
 His admirers think of him as a national treasure, rather like the works of art of which he is Congress's most passionate defender. 
 His critics say that his main contact with his Chicago district is a fond wave from the aeroplane as he travels from Los Angeles to Washington. 
 His challenger, Mr Edwin Eisendrath, a city alderman, had tried to stitch together a coalition of young apolitical professionals and &bquo;reform&equo; Democrats. 
 He failed. 
 Mr Savage, like Mr Yates, is an original, but only his most devoted fans would think him a lovable one. 
 More than any other black member of the House, he plays the racist card. 
 He has cultivated a reputation on the black south side of Chicago as a battler, and he spices this reputation with attacks on the &bquo;racist white media&equo;. 
 In Washington he is considered an ineffective legislator and not a nice man (his latest scrape involved the allegation that he had sexually harassed a Peace Corps worker while on a jaunt to Africa). 
 But it is different at home. 
 His coup this time was to read a list, shortly before polling day, of Jews who had contributed to the campaign of his challenger, Mr Mel Reynolds. 
 Mr Reynolds, a dignified man who was Illinois's first black Rhodes scholar, wondered if Mr Savage would like to ban Jewish contributions to the United Negro Colleges Fund. 
 For a while, after the polls closed, it looked as if Mr Reynolds might pull off a stunning upset. 
 But those early returns were from the middle-class parts of the district. 
 When the poorer south-side wards started to report, it became clear that Mr Savage was back. 
 His victory speech started by being vicious and unforgiving &mdash; and ended by calling for harmony. 
 Unfortunately, Mr Savage has half a point. 
 The local contests showed just how racially polarised Chicago politics remains. 
 Witness the race for the presidency of the Cook County board of commissioners. 
 It was won by Mr Richard Phelan, a white political novice with a lot of money and appeal in the rich white suburbs; he beat Mr Eugene Pincham, a black judge. 
 Mr Savage promptly claimed that black Chicagoans support white Democratic candidates, but that the converse does not hold &mdash; even when the black candidate is someone as respected as Harold Washington, mayor of the city from 1983 until his death in 1987. 
 New Daleymen 
 The surprise winner on election night was Mr Richard Daley, who is now Chicago's mayor. 
 It was a surprise because the candidates who emerged from the famous political machine put together by his late father (also Richard Daley) did poorly. 
 But the mayor had studiously avoided endorsing any of the old pols running. 
 In a host of minor races, younger and mildly reformist Democrats came to the fore. 
 None of them would necessarily call himself a Daleyite, and Mr Daley would deny that he was creating a Democratic machine anything like the one that his father ran with such effect. 
 He launched himself, after Mayor Washington's death, on a reformist clean-government ticket and is supported by people sternly opposed to the old-style goings-on. 
 Nonetheless, something seems to be happening; a new political machine may be being cranked up. 
 Plainly, Chicago is doing well. 
 Inner-city areas, such as the Clybourn Avenue corridor and River North, are being revived by young professionals who have decided that the suburbs are boring. 
 This gentrification is taking place cheek by jowl with large public-housing projects, exactly the kind of urban renewal that pessimists thought American cities would never again be able to manage. 
 The fly in the ointment, and a huge one, is that this new Chicago, new Democratic party, and new city government is white (or anyhow non-black). 
 The most popular politician among the 40% of the city that is black may well be Mr Savage. 
 Therein lies a warning. 
 ASIA 
 AIDS? 
 What AIDS? 
 FROM OUR SOUTH-EAST ASIA CORRESPONDENT 
 BANGKOK 
 IN THE dirt-poor villages of northern Thailand, the birth of a son used to be cause for celebration. 
 Over the past decade daughters have become more popular. 
 A few years' work in the brothels of Bangkok can earn girls more money than their families ever dreamt of. 
 Some even married foreigners. 
 And the brothel-owners paid for the restoration of village temples and schools to help keep up the supply of young girls. 
 Many of these girls are now coming home with AIDS. 
 In one small village in Phayao province, in the north-east, 33 girls are reported to have the disease. 
 And the villagers' reaction &mdash; to ignore the problem as much as possible &mdash; is shared by the Thai government. 
 According to official figures, as of February 1st 141 Thais had died from AIDS and 14,116 were infected with HIV, the virus that causes the disease. 
 In all of Asia only India had more cases &mdash; and India's population is 15 times Thailand's. 
 The official Thai figures underestimate the true extent of infection. 
 Thailand is an ideal place for the virus to spread. 
 Thai society condemns almost no behaviour, except criticism of the royal family. 
 The country has a huge population of heroin addicts, homosexuality is widely practised, and men of all ages and from all classes make regular use of the big cities' vast red-light districts. 
 Thailand's health ministry says there are about 80,000 prostitutes in the country; the police reckon there are at least eight times that number. 
 The size and range of the country's sex business may mean that Thailand is in for the world's fastest upswing in HIV infection. 
 The fragmentary evidence is frightening enough. 
 Dr Vicharn Vithayasai, from the University Hospital in Chiang Mai, northern Thailand's biggest city, has recently carried out surveys there and in nearby towns and villages. 
 He thinks that in Chiang Mai alone 30,000 people are infected with HIV. 
 A series of tests was carried out among the prostitutes who came voluntarily to venereal-disease clinics in late 1989. 
 The lowest proportion revealed to have the virus in their blood was 44%, the highest 72%. 
 In July 1988, when Dr Vicharn started to do tests, only 0.6% were HIV-positive. 
 Low-class hookers, who charge no more than 50 baht (&dollar;2) a time and entertain as many as 20 customers a day, had the highest rates of infection. 
 Five samples of 100 men each &mdash; probably not chosen at random &mdash; showed that 2&ndash;6% of Chiang Mai's male population carry the virus. 
 Many of them pass it on to their wives; 1% of the women who came for pre-natal tests at the hospital were HIV-positive. 
 Government spokesmen say Chiang Mai is untypical: prostitutes in Bangkok found to be infected are often sent home to the north, where they continue to practise the only trade they know. 
 It is hard to argue the point since no broad surveys have been carried out in Bangkok, but what is known offers little ground for hope. 
 Drug addicts, for instance, seem just as widely infected in the capital. 
 Bangkok is well supplied with &bquo;shooting galleries&equo; where pushers go down lines of addicts giving them all a fix with the same needle. 
 In 1987 only 1% of Bangkok addicts who sought medical treatment were infected with HIV. 
 By April last year more than half were. 
 Mr Chatichai Choonhavan, Thailand's prime minister, is busy trying to hold his unstable coalition together. 
 Last November he refused to chair a conference on AIDS for fear it might cause panic. 
 Most other efforts to air the issue in public have been suppressed. 
 The moguls of Thailand's flourishing tourist industry do not want bad news to interfere with good times, especially among all those single men who crowd Bangkok airport. 
 It does not move them that the cost of looking after the hundreds of thousands of Thais who are likely to be infected by 1995 will far exceed that of a few cancelled holidays.  
 Imelda on trial 
 THE former first lady of the Philippines, Mrs Imelda Marcos, does not believe in dealing with underlings. 
 She has written to President Bush offering to hand over part of her late husband's fortune for distribution to the poor in the Philippines. 
 In return, she says, the body of Ferdinand Marcos should be let into the Philippines for burial. 
 Mrs Marcos may believe that America still has the final say in Philippine affairs; after all, America persuaded her husband to call the election that led to his downfall in 1986. 
 Or she may simply be trying to snub President Cory Aquino, who refuses to allow Marcos back, even through he is dead; and has barred Imelda too. 
 Mrs Marcos does not say how much money she would turn over, or how big the Marcos fortune is. 
 It is probably a wise precaution in view of allegations that the couple stole billions of dollars from their country. 
 Mrs Marcos went on trial in New York this week, on March 20th, by coincidence the day on which the contents of her letter to Mr Bush was disclosed. 
 Like all of the Marcos affairs, the trial promises to be complex. 
 Mrs Marcos &mdash; improbably described by her lawyer as &bquo;a small, fragile woman&equo; &mdash; is accused of fraud in connection with her purchases of property in New York. 
 Mr Adnan Khashoggi, a Saudi arms dealer, is being tried with her, accused of helping out in the property deals. 
 In Manila the Philippine government testily rejected Mrs Marcos's offer of help to the poor, and continued its interminable task of trying to get its hands on the Marcos money. 
 This week art experts have been valuing &bquo;old master&equo; paintings bought by the couple and left behind when they fled to America. 
 Like much of the Marcos story, at least some of the paintings are thought to be fakes.  
 Behind the screen 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN TOKYO 
 FOR a man seen in America as an oriental devil incarnate, Mr Shintaro Ishihara, co-author of the notorious &bquo;The Japan that can say no&equo;, is an appealing fellow. 
 A natty dresser who looks much younger than his 57 years, he is everything that Americans ask for in Japanese politicians: charismatic, decisive, articulate, a natural leader. 
 Visiting senators and journalists who meet him generally go away charmed. 
 It is what he stands for that they don't like. 
 So he is setting out to change that. 
 He is putting it about that he is in favour of one of America's most important &mdash; and sensitive &mdash; trade demands: that Japan should open its markets to rice imports. 
 It sounds unbelievable: a well-known right-winger advocating the import of an item supposedly sacred to Japanese culture. 
 But Mr Ishihara has made a career out of being shocking, and he has a good motive. 
 He represents the Shinagawa area of Tokyo, and so has no worries about offending farmers. 
 Nor is he part of any of the Liberal Democratic party's main factions; instead, he runs his own small &bquo;study group&equo;. 
 He says that a lower rice price would not only help his constituents but also make Japan's economy stronger &mdash; which is, after all, a good nationalist aim. 
 He sneers at the arguments against it: self-sufficiency and the tired old cultural card. 
 Baloney, he says. 
 The reputations outside Japan of Mr Ishihara and his co-author, Mr Akio Morita of Sony, could do with some buffing up. 
 Their book caused a storm in America last year, mainly because of inflammatory passages suggesting Japan might sell technology to the Russians to spite the United States. 
 The book prospered in Japan &mdash; more than 1m copies have been sold &mdash; but Mr Morita regrets his part in the venture. 
 He has withdrawn his chapters from an authorised English translation due later this year, and is about to spend a month in America mending fences. 
 It is a considerable sacrifice: last month Mr Ishihara sold the world rights to Simon &amp; Schuster for &dollar;275,000 &mdash; even though without Mr Morita's parts the book will be slim. 
 Mr Ishihara does himself no harm by playing the renegade. 
 He is popular in Japan, more like a movie star than a politician (partly because his brother, Yujiro, was a real film star until he died last year). 
 The public also remembers Mr Ishihara's early career as a novelist. 
 In 1956 his book &bquo;Season of the Sun&equo;, which won the Akutagawa award, struck several chords in a Japan seeking to restore its confidence. 
 In one famous passage the hero vents his frustration by masturbating through a paper shoji screen &mdash; a sign of contempt for yet another revered symbol of Japanese culture. 
 The proud flouting of taboos remains the Ishihara style.  
 Thailand 
 The general's manoeuvres 
 FROM OUR SOUTH-EAST ASIA CORRESPONDENT 
 THAI democracy is a delicate flower. 
 Since the beginning of this year Mr Chatichai Choonhavan's coalition government has been agonising over whether General Chaovalit Yongchaiyudh will resign as commander-in-chief of Thailand's armed forces. 
 It is widely assumed that the general, who has been doing his best to fan the speculation, will try to become prime minister after he leaves the army. 
 &bquo;An attempted coup without tanks,&equo; is how a diplomat described the frenzy of political haggling in which Bangkok is now engaged. 
 General Chaovalit has talked of resigning before. 
 He may yet decide to serve out his term as army chief until 1992, when he reaches the retirement age of 60. 
 However, even in the fluid world of Thai politics, this time he may have gone too far to turn back. 
 He has said, and subsequently confirmed, that he will step down shortly after March 27th, when the King is due to award him a medal. 
 His successor has been named. 
 The general's resignation, if it does happen, will be the culmination of months of political manoeuvring. 
 In January, as charges of corruption began to mount against the government, Mr Chatichai offered General Chaovalit a job in the cabinet. 
 The general thought he could do better, and for a time considered launching his own party. 
 This costly option was rejected. 
 Instead, the general has been playing politics outside the cabinet. 
 A mysterious strike at Bangkok's port, which handles more than 80% of the country's trade, was settled only after the general intervened. 
 Last week Mr Chatichai again offered General Chaovalit a job, this time as defence minister and deputy prime minister. 
 But the general wants to be prime minister. 
 He sees no reason to give up his present powerful job for anything less. 
 Thai coups may be a thing of the past, but the army is probably in a stronger position now than it ever was. 
 When Mr Chatichai was elected in 1988 he arranged an informal slicing of the pie with the armed forces. 
 The civilians would look after the waves of foreign investment lapping into Thailand, while the armed forces would retain their grip on many state-owned enterprises and would be given a free hand to run Thailand's relations with its neighbours. 
 The army has profited nicely from acting as a conduit for arms supplies to the resistance armies fighting in Cambodia and from its control of the timber and gem trades with Cambodia, Laos and Burma. 
 It has been alarmed by Mr Chatichai's dream of turning Indochina &bquo;from a battlefield into a marketplace&equo;: this would end the army's grip on the border trade. 
 Mr Chatichai has to rebuild his government's popularity if he is to fend off General Chaovalit. 
 He is pinning some hope on a cabinet reshuffle. 
 Mr Pramual Sabhavasu, the finance minister, will probably have to go. 
 Mr Pramual is a self-made baht-billionaire. 
 A government commission is now investigating how these billions were made. 
 Ministers are spending so much time wondering who else might go that little governing is getting done. 
 This paralysis may ensure that, after three years of breathtaking growth, the Thai economy has a hard rather than a soft landing. 
 Mainly because of Mr Pramual's opposition a much needed increase in interest rates was delayed until last week. 
 The government is running the Oil Fund, designed to maintain stable oil prices, at a deficit rather than risk passing on price increases to consumers. 
 Viewing this mismanagement, General Chaovalit claims that all politicians and businessmen are corrupt. 
 Bangkok, he says, is another Babylon. 
 He sees himself as the man to even out inequalities and re-impose Buddhist order. 
 Will be get a chance to try out his ideas? 
 Many Thais believe the question is when, not if.  
 Japan 
 The lad does well 
 FROM OUR TOKYO CORRESPONDENT 
 MR TOSHIKI KAIFU, Japan's prime minister, may still be a little wet behind the ears but, not for the first time, he has confounded his more experienced rivals. 
 Since returning from the weekend meeting in Palm Springs, California, to which President Bush summoned him early this month, Mr Kaifu has seized the high ground at home in Japan's efforts to avert a trade war with the United States. 
 His efforts may yet come to naught. 
 But for the first time in his eight months in office, Mr Kaifu now has a chance of pulling off a coup big enough to ensure his survival as prime minister. 
 Before the Palm Springs meeting, trade talks between Japan and America were going nowhere. 
 An evidently shaken Mr Kaifu returned from Palm Springs convinced that trade relations were not a problem but a crisis. 
 This time, Mr Kaifu was convinced, the Americans would not be shut up with a promise here, a concession there. 
 He convened a group within the cabinet to wrest control of Japan's end of the two countries' Structural Impediments Initiative (SII) talks from the civil servants. 
 In doing so, Mr Kaifu has neatly tied a handful of fortunes &mdash; his own included &mdash; to a successful outcome in the talks. 
 Senior members of the ruling Liberal Democratic party have started to criticise ministries for not taking American complaints seriously. 
 For the first time, civil servants accustomed to running Japan as they see fit are feeling the hot breath of their political masters on their necks. 
 The home affairs ministry had been against American requests to relax the law that protects small shopkeepers by making it hard for supermarkets and department stores (big importers all) to open branches in their neighbourhoods. 
 Now Mr Keiwa Okuda, the new home affairs minister, wants to scrap the store law; he even chastises the trade minister, Mr Kabun Muto, for tolerating half-way measures from his bureaucrats. 
 The government's interim report on the SII talks, expected in April, will now say that the store law should be scrapped, possibly as early as 1992. 
 Japan's somnolent Fair Trade Commission is also being shaken awake. 
 Since Palm Springs, the commission's chairman, Mr Setsuo Umezawa, has been telling everyone that he would welcome an increase in the penalties for anti-competitive behaviour. 
 His bluff is to be called. 
 The interim SII report will spell out the new powers that the commission will shortly have at its disposal, including higher penalties (currently 1.5% of the profits earned from operating a cartel). 
 Mr Kaifu's success in budging the government on all this suggests that powerful people are working on his behalf. 
 However, his allies in the cabinet &mdash; the finance minister, Mr Ryutaro Hashimoto, the party secretary-general, Mr Ichiro Ozawa, and Mr Okuda, the home-affairs minister &mdash; are all ardent followers of the former prime minister, Mr Noboru Takeshita. 
 It was Mr Takeshita who picked the unknown Mr Kaifu to serve as a prime ministerial seat-warmer until the Recruit scandal died down sufficiently to return the job to one of the usual party bosses. 
 Things did not go according to Mr Takeshita's plan. 
 Mr Kaifu has turned out to be more of a winner than a cipher. 
 His direct ways won enough support among the voters for the Liberal Democrats to enjoy a bigger-than-expected victory in last month's election for the lower house of parliament. 
 With every fresh success for the 57-year-old prime minister, it becomes that much harder for a member of Mr Takeshita's generation to reclaim the top job. 
 After the election, the bosses allowed Mr Kaifu to continue as prime minister on the strict understanding that he would hand over to a heavyweight like the former foreign minister, Mr Shintaro Abe, when the going got rough. 
 Party officials half expected the trade talks to break down eventually, at which point Mr Abe would make his entrance. 
 No one imagined that Mr Bush would intervene as abruptly as he did, or that Mr Kaifu would go off to Palm Springs without so much as a by-your-leave to the party barons. 
 Mr Takeshita, who subsequently wangled a meeting with Mr Bush to chat about the SII talks, has spent the past couple of weeks trying to get back into the limelight. 
 He has a good reason. 
 Mr Abe, who was to succeed Mr Takeshita as prime minister before the Recruit scandal intervened, is not a healthy man; he has had to return to hospital. 
 The most tantalising of opportunities has thus opened up for Mr Takeshita: the chance to be prime minister again. 
 To seize it he must not let Mr Kaifu get all the credit if the trade talks succeed. 
 But Mr Kaifu is in no mood to let anyone steal his thunder. 
 It is a piece of Japanese competition that can only delight the Americans.  
 China 
 A dictator's way 
 FROM OUR CHINA CORRESPONDENT 
 TIME does not seem to mellow China's prime minister, Mr Li Peng. 
 &bquo;Only socialism can save China,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;Only socialism can develop China&hellip; 
 If we do not uphold socialism and leadership by the Communist party, we can expect no stability in the country, no unity among the people and no rejuvenation of the Chinese nation.&equo; 
 China has learned to be sceptical on that score, but on March 20th Mr Li was talking to the theoretically converted &mdash; the 2,700 delegates to the annual National People's Congress in Beijing. 
 In case their faith was wavering, Mr Li, misleadingly dressed in a western business suit instead of the again-fashionable Mao garb, added a reminder of the inevitability of class struggle: &bquo;While fostering socialist democracy and the socialist legal system, we must intensify dictatorship by the socialist state apparatus.&equo; 
 But what does Mr Li's brand of socialism portend for the 1.1 billion people who endure life in the world's most populous nation? 
 The immediate answer is an intolerance of dissent &mdash; be it political or economic &mdash; and a doctrinaire mistrust of the world outside the Middle Kingdom. 
 China has been observing the 150th anniversary of the outbreak of the first opium war. 
 The schools, Mr Li said, must alert children to &bquo;the crime committed by imperialists in their aggression against China so as to heighten vigilance against the imperialist strategy of peaceful evolution&equo;. 
 Peaceful evolution? 
 That is code for seduction by capitalism &mdash; the temptation to which Eastern Europe has so eagerly succumbed. 
 Mr Li, aged 61, does not rule alone. 
 He owes his position to the support of his elders, who, like the Russian-trained prime minister, are steeped in the dogmatic authority of central planning. 
 Hence the unwillingness of the senior (and supposedly retired) leader, Mr Deng Xiaoping, to pursue the economic reforms he began in 1978 to their logical conclusion in a free market. 
 Even for old conservatives, though, a return to central planning carries no guarantee of a stress-free future. 
 Ever since September 1988, Mr Li's government has been pressing an austerity programme to cool the economy. 
 The tools of the programme are exactly the ones that Mr Li intends to use in the future: central-bank control of credit and state-set levels for production and prices. 
 The results have hardly been inspiring. 
 True, inflation has been brought down from around 30% a year during the gung-ho days of the disgraced party chief, Mr Zhao Ziyang, to single figures. 
 But industrial output has fallen in four of the past five months. 
 Some 200m peasants have no real work, and unemployment in the cities is at least 4%. 
 Factory bonuses have been replaced by compulsory pay deductions to buy government bonds, and many enterprises say they cannot buy the bonds because they no longer have any cash. 
 It is a nightmare that would test the most brilliant economist. 
 Mr Li is not an economist, but at least he recognises some of the imperfections of the policy his economists tell him to follow. 
 Industry had stalled because, Mr Li admitted, his State Council, or cabinet, had &bquo;failed to adopt timely and rigorous measures for macro-control and apply effective methods&equo;. 
 The belated correction: investment in agriculture will be increased by 30%; curbs on the money supply will be relaxed; loans will be given to exporters and indebted state enterprises; &bquo;specialised groups&equo; will be set up to break &bquo;debt chains&equo; between enterprises. 
 It sounds suspiciously like a &bquo;stop-go&equo; recipe for the alternation of inflationary booms and resource-misallocating busts. 
 What happens next? 
 The great fear of China's leaders is not that western conspirators will weave more plots but that China's people, enraged by corruption and scornful of slogans, will take to the streets, as they did last June, to demand instant solutions that the government cannot possibly provide. 
 In the days of Chairman Mao, author of the disastrous Great Leap Forward and the Cultural Revolution, the party could belittle such dangers. 
 Today's China is very different. 
 The reforming years of Mr Deng and Mr Zhao have ended in inflation and corruption &mdash; but not before China achieved annual real GNP growth in the 1980s of 10.5%, the world's highest after Oman. 
 The challenge of Mr Li and his comrades is to meet the popular expectations inspired by that growth. 
 To do that, China, with a foreign debt of over &dollar;40 billion and with precious few new foreign credits since the bloodshed of last June, needs foreign trade and foreign friends. 
 Judging by his performance at the opening of the congress, Mr Li is content to be friendless.  
 Murmurs of the Taiwanese unmentionable, independence 
 FROM OUR CHINA CORRESPONDENT 
 TAIPEI 
 STUDENTS in their thousands gather at the Chiang Kai-shek Memorial Hall, Taiwan's holiest of holies, to demand democracy; teenage idealists begin a fast; daubings (one is the Chinese character for &bquo;pig&equo;) disfigure Chiang's monument. 
 As aged members of the National Assembly &mdash; some in wheelchairs, others with canes &mdash; vote a new six-year term for President Lee Teng-hui, one student slogan reads: &bquo;If the old thieves don't quit, democracy will never come.&equo; 
 It all seems like last year in Beijing's Tiananmen Square. 
 It isn't, quite. 
 President Lee too wants the &bquo;old thieves&equo; to retire, even though, on March 21st, some 96% of them endorsed his unopposed candidature. 
 Mr Lee recognises the 752-member assembly for what it is &mdash; an anachronism instinctively opposed to the reforms begun three years ago by the late President Chiang Ching-kuo (a son of Chiang Kai-shek) and carried on by Mr Lee. 
 Only 84 assemblymen were chosen by the people of Taiwan; the rest last faced the voters in China itself, before they had to flee the mainland's victorious communists in 1949. 
 Some 40 assemblymen are now in their nineties; almost half are octogenarians. 
 Death will before long end their mockery of representative government. 
 Yet even old men can stomp about. 
 The reason Taiwan's normally placid students got upset is that the assembly is showing unexpected signs of vigour. 
 The assemblymen have precious few functions to perform for their &dollar;4,000-a-month salaries and free board and lodging; they merely meet every six years to elect a new president and vice-president. 
 But the assembly also has the power &mdash; never used &mdash; to amend the constitution. 
 This month its old-guard steering committee decided a better constitution would include annual meetings by the assembly, and powers for it to initiate laws and to veto bills from the legislature. 
 Incidentals were a quadrupling of salaries and the extension for an extra three years, until 1996, of the terms of the 84 Taiwan-elected members. 
 The implication was obvious: the present National Assembly intended to defy death and select a compliant successor to Mr Lee in 1996. 
 What should have been equally obvious to the assemblymen was the fury they were thus provoking, including megaphonic demonstrations by the opposition Democratic Progressive party to coincide with the students' protests. 
 By March 19th the ruling Kuomintang had twisted enough old arms in the assembly to ensure that it would drop its plans. 
 What next? 
 It is easy to dismiss recent events as the exuberance of youth and the last power struggle of the impotent old. 
 The facts speak otherwise &mdash; first because Mr Lee is no longer exempted from attacks by his own Kuomintang colleagues; second because the students and the opposition, which won 40% of the vote in December's legislative and local elections, have forced Taiwan's rulers to seek their advice in mapping the island's future. 
 The two are connected, since they both involve the tactics and ideals of the president. 
 Mr Lee, who is the first leader to be Taiwan-born and Taiwan-bred, has a taste for reforms that go too far and too fast for the old-guard mainlanders. 
 He weakens Taiwan's adherence to the Three Noes &mdash; no contact, no negotiation and no compromise with the &bquo;bandit regime&equo; on the mainland &mdash; by easing the rules for travel and trade between Taiwan and China. 
 By giving more or less free rein to the more extreme parts of the opposition, he encourages talk of Taiwan's independence. 
 Eleven members of the Democratic Progressive party elected to the National Assembly have been barred from taking their seats because they will not take an oath of loyalty to the Republic of China (the official name for Taiwan), only to the Republic of Taiwan. 
 Independence may be a reality in fact if not in name, but it contradicts the dream of a united China that both the Kuomintang and the communists of Beijing hold dear &mdash; so dear that China has always threatened to use force if Taiwan declared independence. 
 Somehow Mr Lee has to carry the old guard with him, not least because the mainlanders dominate the legislature as well as the National Assembly. 
 But the price of party unity is youthful impatience. 
 It was the president's problems with the old guard that almost led to a challenge to his authority. 
 Around 150 assemblymen wanted to nominate a rival team: Mr Lin Yang-kang, a Taiwanese, for president, and General Chiang Wei-kuo for vice-president. 
 Mr Lin is popular enough, but the choice of Mr Chiang, another son of Chiang Kai-shek, looked suspiciously like an attempt to renew the Chiang dynasty. 
 Eventually, the two men said they would not stand. 
 The Kuomintang has to accept change. 
 Taiwan's economic growth has been probably the world's fastest over the past two decades. 
 The island's 20m people now have an income per head of well over &dollar;7,000 a year. 
 A sturdily middle-class society does not sit easily atop political immobility; and, indeed, Taiwan has been experimenting with reform for the past three years. 
 The president, at least, has recognised the challenge. 
 He got the students to leave the Memorial Hall by promising a &bquo;National Affairs Conference&equo; to reach a &bquo;consensus on issues such as constitutional reform and mainland China policy&equo;. 
 Such a conference is one of the students' demands. 
 The others are a timetable for democratic reform, the scrapping of &bquo;temporary provisions&equo; which allow the constitution to be suspended while the &bquo;communist rebels&equo; rule China; and the disbanding of the National Assembly. 
 The demands are easier stated than met. 
 Only the National Assembly has the power to amend the constitution or vote itself out of office &mdash; an unlikely prospect given that only 50 or so assemblymen have accepted the government's offer of a &dollar;175,000 tax-free retirement pension. 
 One demand would be met, said Mr Ma Ying-jeou, a Kuomintang Central Committee member, if the president ended the &bquo;temporary provisions&equo; by formally declaring the communist rebellion to be over. 
 An odd proposal, but no odder than the belief sustained for 40 years that the Kuomintang would return to Beijing to rule all of China. 
 In their convoluted way, the Taiwanese may be thinking of power-sharing with Beijing. 
 Or they may be thinking about the unthinkable: independence for their tiny &mdash; but vastly more successful &mdash; China. 
 INTERNATIONAL 
 How Brazil's new president turned off the money 
 FROM OUR BRAZIL CORRESPONDENT 
 THE latest piece of Brazilian economics is of a kind to make heads spin. 
 The new president, Mr Fernando Collor de Mello, has cast aside the timid economic adjustments that have failed to cure Latin America's sick borrowers. 
 He offers the unassailable proposition that without money there can be no inflation. 
 President Collor's plan combines free marketeering and authoritarian intervention in a bewildering but roughly equal mix. 
 He launched it on March 16th, the day he took office, and thus fulfilled his campaign promise to &bquo;leave the right wing indignant and the left gasping.&equo; 
 He has locked away &dollar;115 billion in private savings and taxed wealth to the hilt. 
 The businessmen who last year jostled to fill Mr Collor's campaign chest now sound like the turkeys who cackled for an early Christmas. 
 The trade unions and the left are protesting about a drop in real pay and the prospect of mass unemployment. 
 Yet the first opinion polls showed almost 60% of those questioned behind the president. 
 Congress, which has frustrated so many earlier reformers' ambitions, will heed that sign. 
 Within a month, the president needs congressional approval for his package of 22 provisional measures. 
 No one doubts that, if the programme is rigorously carried out, inflation, which had topped 80% a month when the new government took office, will collapse. 
 Fiscal, monetary and administrative reforms, and the elimination of almost all subsidies, are designed to squeeze &dollar;35 billion out of the government deficit. 
 Last year the government had a budget deficit equal to 8% of GDP. 
 This year it intends to run a surplus equal to 2% of GDP. 
 All this will fall hard on the private sector. 
 The chief of the federal police, Mr Romeu Tuma, now doubles as chief inspector of taxes, with new legislation to punish evasion. 
 Taxes on share dealings, gold trading, large fortunes and even farm income spell the end of an era for Brazil's rich &mdash; unless they find the loopholes. 
 Nobody can dodge the monetary reform. 
 For five days before the president's announcement all banks were closed, by order. 
 People with interest-bearing deposits (and, with inflation roaring away, no sensible person held cash) now find most of what they used as ready money locked away. 
 Depositors in overnight money-market accounts &mdash; which total around &dollar;70 billion &mdash; have seen 80% of their assets frozen for 18 months. 
 Those with deposits in savings accounts fared even worse: all but &dollar;1,000 of each deposit is put out of circulation. 
 The limits on cash withdrawals were so strict that many companies found themselves without cash even to pay wages. 
 The banks, threatened with the loss of many lucrative transactions (and with expensive computer networks to maintain) were not co-operating with the authorities, who talked of sending the police round to see that they did. 
 Once again, the Brazilians get a new currency. 
 Last week's &bquo;new cruzados&equo;, ravaged by inflation, are blocked and replaced by cruzeiros (which happens to be what the currency was called up till 1986). 
 Those who want to get at the frozen part of their savings in the old currency will have to buy new currency from the central bank, at auctions where it will cost them well over its face value. 
 Meanwhile, the government claims that old currency left in interest-bearing accounts should hold its value, so long as it is not spent. 
 The impact of the freeze was instantaneous. 
 As soon as the banks reopened everybody was short of cruzeiros to spend. 
 Share trading collapsed, the gold price plummeted and the black market for dollars vanished. 
 The immediate effect should be a deep recession; that must be what the government intended. 
 But, showing his interventionist hand, the president warned employers that, if they lay off too many workers, six-month job security will become mandatory. 
 Even more interventionist was the one-month compulsory &bquo;truce&equo; imposed on prices. 
 But the policemen sent to see that shops obeyed the rule had little work to do: there was no money to push up prices. 
 On pay, the bad old tradition of linking monthly wage rises to the government estimate of monthly inflation was preserved &mdash; with the difference that only half of March's 80% decline in the value of pay-packets will be made up in April. 
 The president tried to soothe the unions by promising that, as inflation drops to zero in a few weeks, real pay will increase. 
 Yet the president's radicalism unfortunately did falter when it came to the public sector. 
 Electioneering, he had talked tough about getting government off the backs of the people. 
 His great plan did little to curb the spendthrift state. 
 The country has about 6m public employees of all kinds. 
 Closing a raft of useless federal establishments will get rid of only some 80,000 of them. 
 No dismissals have been announced among the millions who get their pay from the state and municipal administrations, which are anyway being exempted from the liquidity squeeze. 
 The president's disappointing administrative reform will pare off public spending worth only 0.5% of GDP. 
 The initial privatisation programme looks relatively timid. 
 There had been talk of privatisations worth &dollar;16m; in the event the take will be half that. 
 Banks and financial institutions will be forced to buy privatisation certificates, but will gain only the dead twigs of the state sector. 
 The heartwood &mdash; the oil, steel, communications and electricity companies &mdash; is being saved for later; nationalists will resist a sell-off, while employees will cling to their pay-packets. 
 There is little comfort for foreign creditors hoping for an end to the six-month moratorium on debt payments. 
 The Central Bank has frozen all remittances of profits, dividends and interest. 
 The Collor administration wants to start fresh debt talks next month, while insisting that annual interest payments must not exceed &dollar;5 billion, half of what normally comes due. 
 Yet the government, by bravely liberalising imports and by treating foreign investors more favourably, hopes in the longer run to push Brazil at last into the corral of &bquo;model debtors&equo;, with access to overseas money and to debt relief under the Brady plan. 
 Traps ahead 
 The president will have to get his scheme through the courts. 
 A lot of people suspect that blocking savers' access to their money violates the new constitution's explicit ban on compulsory loans to the government. 
 Mr Collor seems to fear so; at least, he has produced legislation preventing judges from granting interim injunctions to allow depositors access to their money. 
 This looks even more unconstitutional &mdash; but while the lawyers debate that question, the government could be holding the monetary line. 
 In Congress the fight could be tougher yet. 
 An election is due in October. 
 The 10% of the people rich enough to have savings accounts will be yelling for their money. 
 Businessmen &mdash; especially Mr Collor's original fans, from the subsidy-hooked north-east &mdash; will be lobbying and bribing as usual. 
 Yet the polls show that most voters want inflation stopped, and the main opposition, the Workers' party, while formally denouncing the plan as &bquo;authoritarian, demagogic, privatising and favourable to foreign capital&equo;, may merely wish it were in a position to do likewise. 
 Few doubt that the Collor plan will pass Congress. 
 The president wants it entire. 
 His economy minister, Miss Zelia Cardoso de Mello, wants changes, if any, to be coherent, so promptly began negotiating concessions with the parties. 
 She points out that the cash squeeze could be relaxed quickly if Brazilian inflation really does perish from a single shot. 
 Then she and the president can set about hacking away as vigorously at the wasteful government machine as they have at the sheltered private sector.  
 Colombia 
 By an editor's mistake we described (March 17th) the drug baron Gonzalo Rodriguez Gacha as the Colombian government's main surviving enemy. 
 Soldiers killed him in December; the main survivor is Mr Pablo Escobar.  
 Egypt's taste for tittle-tattle 
 FROM OUR CAIRO CORRESPONDENT 
 EIGHTEEN-YEAR-OLD Miss Ghada Ahmed Musa, a good Muslim girl from Egypt's poor southern province of El Minya, loved to listen to a lurid radio serial called &bquo;Alarm Bells&equo;. 
 Inspired by the show, she dreamed up a tale of a Christian boy who blackmailed Muslim girls by luring them to an apartment where hidden video cameras filmed them in indecent postures. 
 A gang of Muslim extremists believed her story, and the results were dire. 
 Earlier this month they attacked property belonging to Coptic Christians, burning their churches, shops and homes. 
 Nothing, it seems, is too fanciful for Egypt's rumour mill; especially sex, violence and sectarianism. 
 Three years ago riots were sparked by a ludicrous tale that Christians had used American-designed spray guns to stain Muslim women's clothing with indelible crosses. 
 Last year's fantasy was that Mossad, the Israeli secret service, had sent prostitutes to Egypt to spread AIDS, and had contaminated fruit and vegetables with the AIDS virus. 
 This year the minister of agriculture was said to have ruined the tomato crop by importing sterile seeds from Israel &mdash; because (rumour had it) his grandfather was Jewish. 
 The very latest Cairo tittle-tattle is that President Hosni Mubarak (who has a reputation for honesty) has made himself rich by taking a cut from every barrel of oil exported. 
 That false report was falsely attributed to The Economist in order, we are flattered to suppose, to give it a wholly undeserved credibility. 
 How can such fictions flourish in a country with the freest press in the Arab world? 
 Well, since barely half the population can read or write, many people still rely entirely on that notoriously unreliable medium, word of mouth. 
 Few of those who can read actually believe what is said even in the more responsible newspapers; like many Middle Easterners they prefer the racy, outlandish explanation. 
 Egypt's laws of libel are weak and journalistic standards low. 
 Some papers gleefully printed the video-blackmail story as fact. 
 There is something, too, which Egyptians share with people everywhere: eagerness to believe the worst, for the thrill of a good yarn.  
 Israel 
 Go on, try 
 FROM OUR ISRAEL CORRESPONDENT 
 EVEN by the exacting standards of Israeli politics, Mr Shimon Peres of the Labour party faces a tough task. 
 On March 20th President Chaim Herzog gave him first shot at forming a new government to replace the fallen Likud-Labour coalition. 
 The president evidently assumes that Labour is likelier to muster a majority in parliament. 
 Yet only 60 of the Knesset's 120 members supported Mr Peres; Mr Yitzhak Shamir, the Likud leader, got the other 60. 
 The 15-month-old coalition fell on the issue of peace with the Palestinians. 
 Mr Shamir, besieged by his party's hawks, refused to accept America's terms for holding Israeli-Palestinian talks in Cairo to prepare the election he had himself proposed for the occupied West Bank and Gaza. 
 Labour, exasperated, broke the coalition. 
 Now the question is whether enough members of the Knesset are keen enough on the peace talks to support a government led by Mr Peres. 
 Israel's system of proportional representation gives tiny parties disproportionate power. 
 Four religious parties led by elderly rabbis hold 13 seats in the Knesset, controlling the balance between Labour and its friends on the left and the Likud and its friends on the right. 
 In the past the rabbis have concentrated on tilting the balance between the religious and the secular in Israeli life further their way. 
 Because of their attachment to Judaism's holy places, the religious parties have often seemed closer to the Greater Israel policy of the Likud than to Labour, with its belief in exchanging territorial concessions for peace. 
 But the religious parties also claim to embody the ancient Jewish wisdom of survival and compromise. 
 Rabbi Ovadia Yosef, the worldly mentor of the Sephardic (oriental Jewish) party known as Shas, brought Mr Shamir's government down, when five of Shas's six Knesset members abstained in a no-confidence motion. 
 In fact Shas split; Rabbi Yosef likes Labour much more than his colleagues do. 
 Mr Peres has an initial three weeks to put together a coalition; then it is Mr Shamir's turn to try. 
 The rabbis are skilled brinkmen. 
 Labour seems assured, for the moment, of the support of one religious party, the ultra-orthodox Agudat Israel, and Mr Peres has said he hopes to form a majority government as quickly as possible. 
 Or he might aim for a minority government dependent on the votes of six Arab members of the Knesset. 
 If all fails a new election is possible &mdash; or a new Labour-Likud coalition. 
 Mr Shamir, who now leads a caretaker government, must play for time while doing his utmost to talk the religious parties out of making a deal with Labour. 
 So long as he can block Labour, his own party will stick together. 
 But the Likud is seething with ambitious men like Mr Ariel Sharon and Mr David Levy. 
 If Mr Shamir fails, his party will be riven by a bitter leadership struggle which will, in turn, help Mr Peres. 
 And Middle East peace? 
 When Mr Shamir's government fell apart, it was closer than ever before to accepting the American terms for talks with the Palestinians, even though in the end Mr Shamir proved too much of a hawk to start talking. 
 Unfettered by the Likud, a Labour government could stride towards peace &mdash; but on the slenderest of parliamentary mandates.  
 Guatemala 
 Breaking the rules 
 THE government of the United States wants to show it is on the side of the angels, but finds too few of them in Central America. 
 It has just taken the unusual step of calling home its ambassador to Guatemala &bquo;for consultations&equo;. 
 The ambassador, Mr Thomas Stroock, had earlier complained of &bquo;the inability of the Guatemalan government to protect the human rights of its citizens&equo;. 
 The State Department had accused Guatemala of &bquo;failing to investigate effectively, to detain or prosecute&equo; people in the security forces or half a dozen armed groups who took part in &bquo;extrajudicial killings&equo;. 
 In return Guatemala's president, Mr Vinicio Cerezo, accused Mr Stroock of meddling in Guatemalan affairs. 
 There was a pause in the killings. 
 It may not last long. 
 Human-rights groups have been denouncing Mr Cerezo since his election in 1986. 
 Amnesty International says the killings have been carried out by &bquo;police and military agents in civilian clothes and uniform&equo;. 
 Americas Watch, a well-informed group based in Washington, says &bquo;the military remains a law unto itself&equo;. 
 On March 11th it named 35 people who, it said, had probably been murdered by &bquo;government forces&equo; since November 1988. 
 Bad though it is, the figure suggests that Guatemala is not yet back to the horrors of the early 1980s when death squads, organised by military presidents, murdered at will. 
 In 1982, for example, 54 of the country's 2,400 lawyers were killed. 
 They accounted for a tiny fraction of that year's death toll. 
 President Cerezo is accused not of murder but of neglect. 
 He replies that investigations are under way. 
 But little has been done. 
 The public prosecutor's offices are hopelessly undermanned. 
 There are 30 prosecutors for the country's 90 courts; only five of them are supposed to handle the 17 courts in Guatemala City. 
 To be sure, Guatemala has some of the virtues of a poor Latin American democracy. 
 It is gearing up for its second consecutive presidential election in November, with candidates ranging from far right to soft left, and front-runners representing the centre. 
 The press is competitive. 
 Trade unions are spreading: teachers staged a long strike last year. 
 The government's spending programme is the subject of vigorous debates. 
 The defence minister, General Hector Gramajo, is trying to turn the army into a professional force. 
 But Guatemalans can enjoy their freedom only if they stick to the unwritten rules. 
 Those linked in any way with the half-dozen Marxist guerrilla groups, or who are vaguely suspected of being &bquo;subversives&equo; by the country's right-wing extremists, may be shot at, bombed, tortured or killed. 
 When Mr Cerezo, before his election, stood up against successive military regimes the rightists tried to kill him. 
 Guatemala is divided against itself. 
 It is one of the world's most unequal societies, with rich landowners on the fertile lowlands and illiterate Indians (about half of the population, speaking 20 separate languages) scraping a living in the Mayan highlands. 
 There is economic growth and American agricultural investment, but little justice. 
 Left-wing guerrillas think their cause worth killing for, and better-armed right-wingers strike back. 
 The United States can influence Guatemala's government and restrain its army by the aid it gives. 
 The upshot of President Bush's efforts to exercise this influence is a cut in 1990 of 68% in Guatemala's military aid and of 23% in economic aid. 
 Mr Stroock may be visiting Washington again soon.  
 Ivory Coast 
 Worn out 
 FROM A CORRESPONDENT IN ABIDJAN 
 IN THREE decades at the top, President F&eacute;lix Houphouet-Boigny transformed a tropical slum into a model for Africa. 
 Now it is being  transformed  back again. 
 In 1980 the Ivory Coast was the World Bank's star pupil; in December 1989 Mr Michel Camdessus, managing director of the IMF, said its economic crisis was &bquo;deep and serious&equo;. 
 In mid-March there were riots in the capital after students demanded payment of their overdue grants and cuts in the cost of university meals and accommodation. 
 The president deployed the weapon with which he has calmed past discontents, saying he would announce his heir-apparent. 
 For that purpose Mr Houphouet, who is at least 85, brought forward to June the five-yearly congress of the ruling party that is his personal tool. 
 The conference was originally scheduled for November. 
 &bquo;I want my successor to be known while I am alive,&equo; he explained. 
 The student riots were the tip of a tree of discontent. 
 Some 97,000 families will be affected by cuts of up to 40% in civil servants' pay, part of a World Bank/IMF plan to reduce government spending. 
 The decree was greeted by further demonstrations. 
 The government responded by ordering cuts in the prices of essential goods, including food and petrol, and a 5% to 10% &bquo;solidarity tax&equo; on private-sector workers, designed to equalise the misery. 
 The usual chorus of public-sector workers &mdash; university lecturers, school teachers, representatives of official trade unions &mdash; has been formed to oppose the austerity programme. 
 A senior academic was arrested &bquo;for carrying unsigned tracts&equo; of a kind that had been circulating throughout the city for a month. 
 Mr Laurent Gbagbo, the country's most prominent opposition politician and the leader of a clandestine political party, the Ivorian Popular Front, was put under house arrest. 
 He blames foreigners for the country's troubles. 
 So does the president; but most, and most justly, he blames world commodity markets. 
 Between 1986 and 1989 the prices of the country's two main exports, coffee and cocoa, halved, and so did export earnings from them, to &dollar;776 million from &dollar;1.5 billion. 
 The state marketing board passed on the losses to producers. 
 With the public-sector pay cuts, the government has now hit the towns as hard as the country. 
 Businessmen and politicians (often the same people) are blamed for overspending on prestige projects &mdash; including the president's &dollar;250 million basilica &mdash; and for luxurious living. 
 In place of his old magical rhetoric, the president quietly joined the rough popular outcry against the Lebanese traders who run most of the businesses in the country and who help most politicians with their private affairs. 
 A brave few are calling, quietly, for the old president to go. 
 As he fumbles, calls for multi-party democracy increase. 
 Pressure from the people, and from the French government, has in the past few weeks nudged some neighbouring West African dictatorships the same way. 
 In Benin in February a national constitutional conference of notables brought an end to the regime of General Mathieu K&eacute;r&eacute;kou and laid plans for a general election next year. 
 In Gabon too, President Omar Bongo has been forced to announce political reforms. 
 Mr Houphouet-Boigny has been a political giant, a supreme operator. 
 Should he be forced not only to retire but to leave behind a multi-party state, the example will be widely noted in Africa. 
 If, as some think, the French are at last cutting their losses in the Ivory Coast, they may use their influence to leave something healthy behind.  
 Namibia 
 Freedom trail 
 FROM OUR SOUTH AFRICA CORRESPONDENT 
 MR SAM NUJOMA is the latest on the liberation trail that has led so many Africans from jail and exile to the presidency of their country. 
 When South Africa's President F.W. de Klerk was a lad, his people treated the territory that is now Namibia as a fifth province of their own country. 
 At the ceremony enshrining Namibia's nationhood, at midnight on March 20th, Mr de Klerk &mdash; vanquished by, of all people, the UN &mdash; smiled dutifully as his flag came down. 
 The best way to face irresistible change is to behave as if it were welcome. 
 Namibia's new rulers, who have good reason to bear rancour, seem to have put it aside. 
 Their political and economic plans are designed, as far as such things can be, to remove the fears of settler citizens and settler firms. 
 Namibia is almost all desert, and its wealth lies almost entirely under the ground. 
 Without white men's capital and white men's skills the place cannot function. 
 Mr Nujoma is accepting the inevitable as much as Mr de Klerk. 
 One of the things Namibia's new president must accept is that he lacked the two-thirds majority in the constituent assembly he would have needed to push through plans supported only by his party, SWAPO. 
 At the one-man-one-vote election for the assembly, Mr Nujoma got his majority. 
 The runner-up, with almost 29% of the votes, was the Democratic Turnhalle Alliance. 
 It includes people from 11 of Namibia's tribes, including the white one. 
 Its co-founder and leading spirit is an Afrikaner farmer, Mr Dirk Mudge, who foresaw by a dozen years that his people would need allies for survival, and broke away from the whites-only Nationalist party to find black and brown ones. 
 Some far-sighted Nationalists in South Africa itself are wondering whether they should do the same. 
 A multi-tribal alliance of their own is their only chance of hanging on to power when white rule ends at last. 
 EUROPE 
 The face of a new Germany 
 FROM OUR BONN CORRESPONDENT 
 AFTER the best week of his career, crowned by the unexpectedly decisive victory of the centre-right Alliance for Germany in the East German election on March 18th, Mr Helmut Kohl is well on the way to becoming chancellor of a united Germany, possibly next year. 
 Even his many critics admit that Mr Kohl is a mightily impressive election campaigner. 
 He proved the point again this time, first by personally ensuring that the Alliance (of three pretty diverse parties) was formed at all, then by drawing huge crowds on his six election stomps through East Germany. 
 The Kohl factor was not the only reason the Alliance, dominated by Christian Democrats under Mr Lothar de Maizi&egrave;re, routed the much-touted Social Democrats, but it was probably the decisive one. 
 With less than nine months to go to the West German election on December 2nd, the East German result also strengthens Mr Kohl's hold over his centre-right coalition in Bonn. 
 Some people in the liberal Free Democratic party, the junior partner in the government, had been toying with the idea of switching their support to the Social Democrats after December. 
 They will be less keen now. 
 The Christian Social Union, the Bavarian sister-party of Mr Kohl's Christian Democrats, is also discomfited. 
 It had seen the East German poll as a possible stepping-stone to countrywide influence, but the results hardly look like that. 
 Wherever its East German ally, the German Social Union, did well, the Christian Democrats did far better. 
 All that might have made Mr Kohl even more overbearing than he has been in recent weeks, to the dismay of West Germany's allies and neighbours. 
 But in his first public comments after the March 18th triumph the chancellor carefully began by praising the western allies, especially America, for making a united, democratic Germany possible. 
 He had already agreed that the &bquo;two-plus-four&equo; talks between the Germanies and the victorious powers of 1945 &mdash; the United States, the Soviet Union, Britain and France &mdash; should start just before the East Germans voted: thereby underlining that foreigners have as much interest as Germans in the issue of unification. 
 And he has made it clear that an all-German election should be held next year at the earliest, not as a quick substitute for the West German one in December. 
 Does Mr Kohl's greater public caution mean that the process of unification will be slowed? 
 Hardly. 
 Economic and monetary union between the two German states (GEMU) may actually come sooner than many people have expected. 
 The government's official line is that it is aiming for an agreement with East Germany on monetary matters by the end of next month; it does not deny reports that D-Day for GEMU could be July 1st. 
 But there are signs that East Germans may get hard D-marks for their funny-money Ostmarks even earlier, as a nice surprise before the summer holidays. 
 Despite what he privately calls Russian &bquo;poker-playing&equo; over a united Germany's relationship with NATO and the Atlantic alliance, Mr Kohl still hopes for an accord in the &bquo;two-plus-four&equo; talks by the autumn. 
 This in turn would be &bquo;acknowledged&equo; by a meeting of the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe (CSCE) by the end of the year. 
 The external aspects of German unity would then be just about settled. 
 And the internal ones? 
 Although the centre-right Alliance handsomely won the East German election, it does not have the two-thirds majority in parliament needed to change the constitution to allow unification to go ahead. 
 The Alliance, like Mr Kohl, favours making use of Article 23 of the West German constitution, which would allow East Germany to join the Federal Republic quickly; the Social Democrats, whose support will be needed, favour Article 146, which could mean working out a new all-German constitution first. 
 Might this mean years of delay? 
 Almost certainly not. 
 Senior East German Social Democrats believe that even the slower process under Article 146 could be completed this year. 
 They are aware of the danger of putting themselves in the same opposition boat as the Party of Democratic Socialism, formerly the communist party, which has its doubts about unity. 
 Besides, with GEMU, which no East German politician dare oppose, East Germany will already have yielded its monetary sovereignty to the West German Bundesbank and with it a lot of its room for political manoeuvre. 
 Foot-dragging over political union will then seem pretty pointless. 
 With all this, some people might feel sorry for Mr Oskar Lafontaine, the Social Democrat who will be challenging Mr Kohl for the West German chancellorship in the December election. 
 Mr Lafontaine favours a slow road to unity, underlines the costs and stresses for West Germany, and seemed ill at ease on his campaign appearances in the East. 
 He scheduled the announcement of his chancellor-candidacy for March 19th on the assumption that he would bask in the reflected glory of a victory by the East German Social Democrats the day before. 
 As it turned out, his timing could not have been worse. 
 Spare your sympathy. 
 Mr Lafontaine is artful, tenacious and (unlike Mr Kohl) a fine orator. 
 He reckons the chancellor has awakened get-rich-quick expectations in East Germans which are likely to be disappointed. 
 And he believes that West German voters may revolt when they realise still more clearly that they will have to foot the bill for unity. 
 There is something in that. 
 Even with a new economic miracle somewhere ahead, it will take years for the East Germans' standard of living to come close to that of their rich cousins. 
 Mr Kohl talks about five years, some economists of at least a decade. 
 Moreover, although private investment will play much the biggest role in the East's economic renewal, the government in Bonn will have to give big subsidies to the East German social-security system. 
 Just bringing East German pensions up to the West German level could cost the Bonn exchequer DM6 billion (&dollar;3.5 billion) a year. 
 But here too Mr Kohl is in luck. 
 The West German economy is again growing faster than expected (latest forecast: 4% in real terms this year), so more tax revenue is flowing in. 
 That bodes well for the government's aim to pay the East German bills without either raising taxes or boosting borrowing greatly. 
 Naturally, the tricky business of welding the Germanies together could still bring nasty surprises. 
 But Mr Kohl, usually underestimated in his eight years as chancellor, has never looked more firmly in command or keener to carry on.  
 Funny thing, democracy 
 FROM OUR BONN CORRESPONDENT 
 HE first, and almost certainly the last, free election in a separate East German state was a decidedly odd affair. 
 The Social Democrats were expected to emerge on top thanks to traditional backing from workers in the industrial south. 
 Instead, the conservative-led Alliance for Germany (Christian Democrats, German Social Union and Democratic Awakening) grabbed nearly 60% of the workers' vote and won easily overall. 
 Why? 
 Largely because the Alliance, especially its weightiest backer, Mr Helmut Kohl, clearly drummed home that it aimed for quick German unity, with D-marks in the East &bquo;within months&equo;. 
 Quite a lot of white-collar workers and farmers were ready to wait on unity a bit, as Social Democrats and other leftist parties proposed. 
 But the &bquo;industrial proletariat&equo;, sick of rotten working conditions and low pay in Ostmarks, rallied to the conservative call. 
 What would Marx have thought? 
 Hardly less surprising was the strong showing of the Party of Democratic Socialism, as the communists now call themselves. 
 You might have thought almost no one would back the successor to an organisation that collapsed in disgrace only months ago after 40 years of misrule. 
 In fact, 1.9m East Germans gave them their votes. 
 The party won the support of people who fear change and apparatchiks who have most to lose from it &mdash; hence the thumping 30% the party won in East Berlin. 
 The new-model communists had as their standard-bearer Mr Hans Modrow, the prime minister widely judged (rightly or wrongly) a pretty honest chap. 
 And it had the most money of its own to spend on the election campaign, though unlike many of the other parties it got no western aid. 
 In the days when the communists dominated the rubber-stamp Volkskammer, the Christian Democrats were their loyal vassals. 
 It is ironic to think that, if the ex-communist Socialists and the revived Christian Democrats joined forces now, they still would have an easy parliamentary majority. 
 By sad contrast, the people who led the bloodless revolution last autumn &mdash; many of them artists, writers, musicians and teachers &mdash; were eclipsed at the polls. 
 Alliance 90, bringing together leading opposition groups including New Forum, scored less than 3%. 
 Yesterday's heroes ran an amateurish campaign and, in the main, are no fans of quick unity. 
 One last oddity. 
 The East German economics minister-designate is Mr Elmar Pieroth, until recently a leading West German Christian Democrat. 
 He now recommends that East Germany stay in Comecon and fulfill its commitments to the Soviet Union and other eastern partners. 
 That, he reckons, will keep a lot of East Germans in jobs while they learn western ways. 
 Small wonder that only four months after the Berlin Wall came down East German satirists are finding it hard not to be outdone by reality.  
 M&eacute;nage &agrave; deux 
 FROM OUR PARIS CORRESPONDENT 
 ARM British and French congratulations to Mr Helmut Kohl for his allies' victory in the East German election are not the best gauge of how the West German chancellor is viewed in London and Paris. 
 For a while now, Mrs Thatcher and President Mitterrand have had a communication problem with Mr Kohl. 
 As a result, they are communicating much better with each other. 
 They want their governments to do the same, especially on defence. 
 Mrs Thatcher found Mr Kohl unreliable in last year's row over new short-range nuclear weapons for NATO. 
 Mr Mitterrand was put out by a whole series of German slights, culminating in the chancellor's hesitations over Economic and Monetary Union before the European Community's summit in December. 
 Both leaders were caught short by Mr Kohl's speech to the Bundestag not long after the opening of the Berlin Wall, in which he threw his weight behind German unification. 
 What, the British and French leaders asked, might he do next? 
 And what should Britain and France do about it? 
 An answer came in talks in Paris on January 20th. 
 The two leaders have had their differences. 
 But he agreed not to complain about her market-minded vision of the Community and she not to bully him about France's half-in, half-out position in NATO. 
 Instead, they would concentrate on France's and Britain's common interests. 
 The two agreed to set up a &bquo;process&equo; or &bquo;structure&equo; by which the two governments could together study issues such as the future of NATO and the Western European Union, British-French nuclear co-operation and joint positions on disarmament. 
 Officials are coy about the details. 
 The shyness is most noticeable in Paris, where there is a wish to avoid anything that smacks of a French-British axis. 
 &bquo;What could we do with Mrs Thatcher that was not anti-German?&equo;, a senior adviser to the French president asks rhetorically. 
 Yet discretion may not last. 
 One idea is that before or at the next French-British summit in late spring, the foreign and defence ministers on both sides will meet to review progress. 
 &bquo;There is a lot of blood coursing in the veins on all this,&equo; a top Whitehall man says. 
 The most pressing need is for close consultation on Germany. 
 Since the &bquo;two-plus-four&equo; process began, Britain and France have been in tune, notably on a place for Poland when the talks turn to frontiers. 
 The British official at the two-plus-four talks is the Foreign Office's political director, Mr John Weston. 
 He is a political-military expert who was number two at the British embassy in Paris during the late 1980s; he is gathering round him other ex-Paris hands. 
 British and French defence co-operation has been &bquo;thickening&equo; for around two years. 
 The armies are talking about closer planning of things like use of French ports. 
 French troops are not about to come back under NATO command. 
 Nor is France responding to pressure to take American troops if they leave Germany. 
 But one idea going around is that French troops might be mixed in with brigades from Britain or other NATO countries on a multinational &mdash; ie, non-NATO &mdash; basis. 
 The chance that Britain would work with the French on the new air-launched nuclear missile they have developed is on again, after Mrs Thatcher had all but made up her mind to buy American. 
 Focusing on European defence when most people, especially in Germany, are thinking about peace dividends has its drawbacks. 
 A minor but telling incident: a big army exercise scheduled for last week in which French soldiers were, for the first time, to do mock battle alongside British troops in West Germany was called off at the last moment because of East Germany's election. 
 Still, while the Germanies bill and coo, Europe's two hawks are watching, and clucking.  
 The EC and a united Germany 
 Don't panic 
 THE prospect of a rapid merging of the Germanies has provoked a fashionable fatalism about the future of the European Community. 
 Having rediscovered nationhood, the theory goes, West Germany is bound to lose interest in its postwar surrogate, the EC. 
 So Project 1992 will grind to a halt. 
 Economic and Monetary Union (EMU) won't happen, nor will the progress towards European political union that it was supposed to advance. 
 The fatalism is pervasive because it is shared by two opposing camps &mdash; frowning European idealists and smiling national realists. 
 The frowners fear that the ideal of European union will fade just when it is usefully poised to temper the return of nationalism to Europe in general and Germany in particular. 
 German protestations of good Euro-intentions do not soothe these frowners. 
 They want German Euro-deeds, now. 
 Prominent frowners include Jacques Delors, Helmut Schmidt, Fran&ccedil;ois Mitterrand and his foreign minister, Roland Dumas. 
 The French accent of this list is no coincidence. 
 Many French politicians take for granted a Europe in which France shares a lead; they sense it is at risk. 
 The smiling realists are relieved that good old-fashioned national interest may burst out of the straitjacket of Brussels directives. 
 What idealists see as the &bquo;binding in&equo; of a powerful Germany, Mrs Thatcher would call being lashed to it. 
 The smilers are relieved that the removal of the iron curtain has revealed a broader, more variegated Europe, full of national pride and unripe for Euro-regulation. 
 Mr Jacques Calvet, the head of Peugeot, the French carmaker, is a smiler. 
 He never liked the prospect of a pan-European car market into which Japan would enjoy relatively free access. 
 So he argues that &bquo;it would be wild madness to continue calmly writing pieces of paper and making directives. 
 Directives to do what? 
 What is the common future? 
 I don't know.&equo; 
 Conveniently. 
 Is the common view justified? 
 Our answer divides into three parts, involving, first, the completion by the end of 1992 of the single market set out in the EC White Paper of 1985; second, the plans that stretch beyond 1992 for changes to the Treaty of Rome that will set up EMU and further increase the legislative power of the Community; and third, the difficulties of bringing East Germany into the EC. 
 Project 1992. 
 Certainly, some tough market-building decisions are looming for the Germans &mdash; in particular, attempts to create European regimes for road transport and the insurance business that will hurt German interests. 
 These may reveal a new German prickliness. 
 But, so far, government officials involved in negotiating the 1992 directives cannot point to instances of the Germans becoming more obstructive. 
 Indeed, West German officials in Brussels find that the prospect of German unity can make it easier to extract concessions from Bonn: the words &bquo;but minister, this will be taken as a sign of German nationalism&equo; work wonders. 
 The one exception is that the opening of the inter-German frontier has complicated the campaign for the frontier-free movement of people within the EC, because it has become impossible to say where the EC's secure external frontier is. 
 Yet, even without this complication, people-movement was already one of the most difficult parts of 1992. 
 Beyond 1992. 
 The prospect of German unity has whetted appetites on the continent for more rapid moves towards political union, and not only in France and Italy. 
 The Danes, too, who tended to side with Britain in resisting this idea, have become noticeably more enthusiastic of late. 
 But West Germany, always cautious about monetary union, has shrugged aside attempts by the Italians to bring forward by several months the start of the inter-governmental conference that will discuss the road to EMU. 
 This week President Mitterrand renewed the call for an early conference. 
 Mr Delors, for whom EMU is the next castle in his European crusade, wants to drive EMU forward too. 
 He hopes to sweeten EMU for the Germans by mixing in reforms to boost the powers of the European Parliament, which the Germans are keen on. 
 (Tell that to Mrs Thatcher.) 
 This is the line-up of worriers that Mr Helmut Kohl will try to soothe when he goes to Brussels this Friday. 
 The signs are that West Germany will still insist that the EMU negotiations start after its election on December 2nd, not least because the fusion of the Ostmark and the D-mark will inevitably distract minds in the Bundesbank and the finance ministry that could otherwise be thinking about EMU. 
 Sticking to an existing timetable scarcely amounts to loss of German interest. 
 East German entry. 
 Here is where the frowns/smiles are most justified: EC-German argument will be hard to avoid. 
 How strictly will EC rules on subsidies, product safety and the environment be applied to East German products? 
 How long will East Germany's grace period last and will the grace (on, say, the sale of shoddy products) extend into West Germany? 
 When will East Germany become eligible for EC regional aid, and for how much? 
 Who will pay? 
 How free to move will be the up to 200,000 resident aliens in East Germany, many from Vietnam, and some 30,000 Polish guestworkers? 
 How long will Russian oil and Czech coal be allowed to flow into East Germany on cheap long-term contracts? 
 The devil in such details could come to infect Germany's attitude to the EC as a whole. 
 But the Germany-aloof thesis remains, so far, more a plausible presumption than a fact. 
 Closet nationalists and protected industrialists would be wise not to count on Germany to release them from the awful fate of an open-market Europe and more moves towards European union.  
 Soviet Union 
 The tremors 
 FROM OUR MOSCOW CORRESPONDENT 
 THE tectonic plates of Soviet politics are slipping. 
 After the dramatic changes of recent weeks &mdash; the creation of a powerful new presidency, the ending of the Communist party's guaranteed right to rule, Lithuania's attempted secession from the Soviet Union &mdash; comes the jockeying for power in the new Soviet Union. 
 It begins just as President Gorbachev embarks on his most radical policy changes yet: a new economic strategy and, possibly, a new treaty of the union. 
 Among the different groups now contending for influence, the most important are the democratic reformers, the men and women who stood in recent local elections on platforms that broadly advocated multi-party politics and bolder economic change. 
 A few months ago they were a rag-bag of local pressure groups. 
 As the final election results come in from all over the country, it is clear they will be helping to run many Soviet towns and cities. 
 In Leningrad, candidates supported by the main reformist umbrella organisation, Democratic Elections 90, won 28 of the city's 34 seats in the Russian parliament. 
 In Moscow, the equivalent organisation, called Democratic Russia, won 55 of the city's 65 parliamentary seats. 
 By contrast, only nine of the 49 regional party secretaries in Russia &mdash; the bulwarks of party authority outside Moscow &mdash; were elected. 
 These results will step up pressure for roundtable talks between party and reformers, along the lines of those held last year all over Eastern Europe. 
 There they eventually led to coalition governments. 
 Even before the elections, the Communist party boss of Moldavia, Mr Petru Luchinsky, had proposed such a roundtable. 
 At a recent meeting of the party's Central Committee, President Gorbachev opened up the prospect of a future coalition government when he talked of &bquo;equal possibilities for the Communist party and other political and social organisations.&equo; 
 The old monolithic Communist party has become an anachronism. 
 But two things still matter a great deal. 
 One is whether Communists continue to see the president as their leader, or start to feel he has abandoned them. 
 In an impassioned speech to the Congress of People's Deputies, Mr Dmitri Likhachev, who since the death of Andrei Sakharov has emerged as the conscience of the nation, argued that if President Gorbachev had to give up his party post (as some radicals have demanded) this &bquo;will lead again to a civil war&equo;. 
 The second issue is how &mdash; no longer whether &mdash; the party will split. 
 One faction, called the Democratic Platform, wants to turn the Communist party into a social democratic one. 
 This group is demanding that delegates to the party congress next July be directly elected by rank-and-file members. 
 This would deprive party bosses of control over the election. 
 If it does not get its way, the Democratic Platform has threatened to leave the party, abandoning it to conservatives like Mr Yegor Ligachev, who has renewed his strident criticism of Mr Gorbachev. 
 That could also drive the country towards the dangers that the venerable Mr Likhachev foresees. 
 In recent weeks, the armed forces have shown renewed signs of unease. 
 In early February, the chief of the general staff, General Mikhail Moiseev, sharply attacked the party's military policies and accused it of failing to stem the tide of anti-military sentiment now sweeping the outlying republics (5,000 Lithuanians, for example, recently refused their call-up papers on the ground that the Geneva convention allows people to refuse to serve in the army of an occupying power). 
 Tensions are bound to rise over two issues. 
 The first is the economy. 
 According to Radio Moscow's Interfax, a news service, and Commersant, a magazine of the Union of Co-operatives, after a five-year dither the Soviet Union has at last opted for a Polish-style Big Bang for its economic reform. 
 Mr Gorbachev may well use his powers to rule by decree to push the reform through. 
 The second point of tension concerns a proposed new treaty of the union, under which republics would voluntarily surrender certain powers to the central government. 
 Under the present system they can exercise only the powers which the central government chooses to delegate to them. 
 Hitherto, Mr Gorbachev has resisted a new treaty. 
 Party leaders in many republics have been openly demanding one: it seems only a matter of time before the president offers them what they are asking for. 
 That is academic in the case of the Baltic republics. 
 They want secession from the union, not a new treaty binding them into it. 
 In Estonia and Latvia, pro-independence candidates seem to have won a majority of seats in the republics' parliaments even in the first round of the local elections on March 18th. 
 The two may soon follow Lithuania into direct conflict with Moscow. 
 Mr Gorbachev's government has responded to Lithuania's declaration of independence by ordering ministries in Moscow to impose direct control over transport, communications and many factories in the republic. 
 The president has ordered the police and KGB to prevent the construction of new customs posts. 
 Most controversially, on March 21st he directed Lithuanians to surrender all weapons. 
 Lithuania's president, Mr Vytautas Landsbergis, promptly called the decree illegal, and said it could be implemented only by &bquo;brutal armed force&equo;. 
 Who will blink first?  
 Solidarity 
 A good thing while it lasted 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN WARSAW 
 OR longer than most Poles can bear to remember, their country has been in crisis. 
 It still is. 
 Indeed, less than three months after Big Bang, the start of the Solidarity-led government's package of strict austerity and radical market reforms, Poland is in ruins. 
 Not literally, of course. 
 The buildings and the factories are still there, drab and decaying; so are most of their occupants, down to the morose, chain-smoking soldiers who sit on guard in every official building. 
 But the political and economic landscape of Poland has changed beyond recognition. 
 It is not just that many of the old structures of central planning have been demolished, or that much of the government is now in the hands of people who still refer to themselves quite unselfconsciously as &bquo;the opposition&equo;. 
 The bigger point is that nothing in Poland is static any longer. 
 Even Solidarity may soon be no more. 
 That is not the official story. 
 In public, at least, Solidarity is sticking together. 
 For one thing, the people elected Solidarity to govern and it has been governing for barely seven months. 
 It still has an enormous job to do. 
 Some 60 bills are now clogging parliament on everything from privatisation to local government, with more on the way. 
 Solidarity ministers, who this time last year were huddled in places like Warsaw's scruffy Czytelnik caf&eacute; plotting nothing more ambitious than the legalisation of their union, now wake up each morning to the daunting task of building a new democratic Poland on the rubble of the old communist one. 
 The other reason for keeping Solidarity solid is the economy. 
 No other government, so the argument runs, not even a completely freely elected one (Poland's election last year was only partly free), could have detonated Big Bang and survived. 
 The fallout has been dramatic. 
 In January rampaging inflation (70% in that month alone, on top of a rate for the previous 12 months estimated at 700&ndash;900%) and a tight wage squeeze produced a 40% drop in the average Pole's standard of living. 
 And that was 40% off what was already, after almost 15 years of economic decline, one of the lowest standards of living in Europe. 
 Economic reform has so far meant that Poles can gaze in wonderment at now well-stocked meat stalls they have no money to buy from. 
 The outlook for the rest of this year is bleak. 
 Although inflation is already sharply down (possibly to as low as 4% this month), so is much else. 
 Anxious talk of inflation has given way to even more anxious talk of a steep recession that would wring much of Poland's industry out of existence. 
 In the first two months of this year industrial production dropped by 29%. 
 The hard men at the finance ministry have promised to review the austerity measures at the end of this month. 
 But according Mr Marek Dabrowski, a deputy finance minister, the screws will not be loosened much until there are signs that Polish industry is adjusting to the real world. 
 One consequence will be unemployment. 
 The number of Poles officially looking for work shot up from 9,600 in December to 220,000 last month. 
 It is widely expected to soar to 1m-2m this year. 
 Even Solidarity expects what people, with increasing irony, call its &bquo;halo effect&equo; to start wearing off soon. 
 As it does, old divisions that were welded over by the fight against communism will reappear. 
 Some already have. 
 Trade-union Solidarity is at odds with political Solidarity over who should bear the brunt of recession. 
 Farmers' Solidarity is at odds with urban Solidarity over the high cost of credit. 
 Religious Solidarity is at odds with secular Solidarity over such things as abortion, crosses in the classroom and religious education in school. 
 And Solidarity's leader, Mr Lech Walesa, is increasingly at odds with Solidarity's prime minister, Mr Tadeusz Mazowiecki, over everything from the style of government to the speed of economic reform, from the presence of Soviet troops to the date of Poland's next general election. 
 It is not that one part of Solidarity supports the free-market experiment and another doesn't. 
 &bquo;There is no third way for Poland,&equo; says Mr Jan Litynski, a former member of KOR, the pre-Solidarity Committee for Workers' Defence. 
 Now a left-leaning Solidarity MP with close ties to trade unionists, he points out that the only choice is between more recession and less recession. 
 Indeed it is &bquo;the left&equo; (if it still makes sense to talk of left and right in Poland) that is most desperate to present a solid front in support of market economics. 
 What Poland needs, quips Mr Bronislaw Geremek, Solidarity's hirsute and widely respected parliamentary leader, is a liberal-conservative-social-democratic-rural party. 
 Part of the left's problem, admits Mr Geremek, is that the communists have sullied the term &bquo;socialist&equo; beyond redemption, even though people respond favourably in opinion polls to such left-wing causes as social justice and equality. 
 The communists' final insult, says Mr Geremek, was to pinch the words &bquo;social democracy&equo; for their new title. 
 The left's discomfort wins little sympathy from the Mr Jaroslaw Kaczynski, a Walesa loyalist whose choir-boy looks barely mask his ambition. 
 It was Mr Kaczynski who helped broker the deal that put a Solidarity prime minister in power last August. 
 He now edits Solidarity's weekly newspaper, but probably not for long. 
 With the blessing of both Mr Walesa and senior Catholic churchmen, he is already working to set up an avowedly Christian party. 
 It can expect to pick up a lot of support both from mainstream Solidarity and from the squabbling peasants' parties. 
 The new party will emerge out of the Solidarity chrysalis when Mr Walesa judges the time is right to give the venture his full blessing. 
 The benediction may not be long in coming. 
 At a minimum, Solidarity is expected to present more than one list to the voters at the next general election &mdash; if it has not already formally split by then. 
 Nobody is prepared to predict what next month's Solidarity congress will do and nobody knows exactly when the next election might be. 
 According to the round-table agreement with the now defunct communist party, Mr Mazowiecki's government, containing communist interior, defence and foreign-trade ministers and working under a communist president, was to last until 1993. 
 Now it is not expected to go on much beyond spring of next year. 
 But if Big Bang turns to crash and Poles lose their unPolish patience with the austerity plan, or if Solidarity cannot contain its differences any longer, a fresh election could come as early as this autumn. 
 That would probably suit Mr Walesa. 
 He has been stamping his feet impatiently in Gdansk waiting for the call to be Poland's first non-communist president in more than 40 years. 
 That prospect fills the Solidarity left with gloom. 
 For them Poland's dream ticket would combine the dignified Mr Mazowiecki as president with the brainy Mr Geremek as prime minister. 
 They were probably saved from an early Walesa push for the presidency by the recent row with West Germany's Mr Helmut Kohl over the permanence of Poland's western border. 
 Worried about Germany, Poles stopped worrying about Soviet troops in Poland and began to feel rather relieved that their current president, General Wojciech Jaruzelski, was so well connected in Moscow. 
 But Mr Walesa will not hold off forever. 
 He is known to have been angry last autumn when Mr Mazowiecki, the man he picked for prime minister, chose his cabinet without consulting him. 
 Mr Mazowiecki also said pointedly at the time that he was not prepared to replace one philosophically biased government (a communist one) with another philosophically biased government (an avowedly Catholic one). 
 And Mr Walesa is probably miffed, too, that opinion polls show Mr Mazowiecki to be more popular than he is. 
 The two men now barely speak to each other. 
 Asked about differences with Mr Walesa, the prime minister merely rolls his eyes heavenwards. 
 But it is not just this personality clash that is driving Solidarity-as-we-know-it to extinction. 
 Solidarity was born as a protest movement, not a political party. 
 It drew together Poles who had little else in common save a hatred of communist rule. 
 If it hangs together too long, it will create a dangerous lack of public debate. 
 Without healthily competing parties, Poland's brave experiment with free-market economics risks having no solid political base to rest on. 
 Solidarity's time may soon be past.  
 France 
 Dauphin surplus 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN RENNES 
 NOT once in the 19-year life of France's modern Socialist party had a party congress ended without a piece of paper to carry away. 
 Yet that was the outcome of the Socialists' two-yearly congress in Rennes on March 15th-18th. 
 Delegates hooted in disgust or yanked up their ties to imitate nooses. 
 Watching balefully from afar was the party's ultimate, though lame-duck, boss, President Mitterrand. 
 An open split, he warned the party, would almost certainly cost it the 1993 general election. 
 Once back in Paris, red-faced party leaders hurried to repair the damage. 
 At a 12-hour meeting that ended early on March 21st, they found a compromise. 
 Mr Pierre Mauroy, an ex-prime minister and party workhorse, will stay on as the party's first secretary. 
 A vague statement of principle papers over policy disputes. 
 The quarrel will go on, because the real issue is power. 
 The congress at Rennes was the opening shot in the battle to succeed President Mitterrand. 
 His influence on the party is weakening. 
 Two years ago he backed away from imposing a favourite, Mr Laurent Fabius, also an ex-prime minister, as first secretary. 
 Now aged 73, Mr Mitterrand is unlikely to run again for president in 1995. 
 The Mitterrand &bquo;current&equo; or faction, which once controlled 60% of the party, has split. 
 To simplify, the yuppie half of Mr Mitterrand's old support has gone to Mr Fabius, a smooth technocrat who is president of the National Assembly. 
 The other half, mainly schoolteachers and low-paid officials, has gone to the traditionalists led by Mr Mauroy and Mr Lionel Jospin, the minister of education. 
 Mr Fabius sees the party's future as a loose campaigning machine on American lines. 
 Mr Jospin wants it to remain more &bquo;fraternal&equo;, with its clublike network of 200,000 paid-up members. 
 The prime minister, Mr Michel Rocard, was hoping for better from its break-up. 
 He won the support of only a quarter of the delegates to the Rennes congress. 
 More popular with the public than with his party, Mr Rocard would make a strong Socialist candidate for president. 
 Yet he has a timing problem: can he last five years as prime minister, even assuming the Socialists survive a parliamentary election in between? 
 He worries &mdash; wrongly, it now seems &mdash; that Mr Mitterrand will do anything to cheat him of the succession. 
 Someone Mr Rocard should worry more about is Mr Jacques Delors, another Socialist popular with voters, whose mandate as president of the European Commission is up in 1992. 
 He was a smiling, sun-tanned observer at Rennes. 
 BRITAIN 
 Palaver 
 FOREIGNERS must wonder &mdash; and this year more than usual &mdash; why the British budget causes such a fuss. 
 Every spring Britain faces an avalanche of punditry before, during and after the not-so-great event. 
 This year, for the first time, live television coverage of the chancellor's speech had 3m people absorbed in details of complex restructurings of VAT reliefs. 
 In America, a sensible country, the president would expect his budget to be top of the evening news only on a very slow day. 
 France, West Germany and Japan have an even better arrangement: no &bquo;budget day&equo;, as such, at all. 
 Is this the secret of rapid growth and low inflation? 
 To be fair, Britain's budget does matter more than most &mdash; even though, unlike the others, it is concerned with gathering revenue rather than spraying it around. 
 America's budget is a mere spending proposal, usually intended for instant rejection. 
 The documents travel from printing press to wastepaper basket in one uninterrupted motion. 
 Other countries' budgets are less frivolous than America's, but the process is stretched out and therefore less exciting than Britain's. 
 Oddly enough, many parliaments expect to modify government plans, which takes time. 
 Britain's is content to debate it all after the decisions have been made, and then pass the lot virtually unamended. 
 Even the protection of the House of Lords is lacking, thanks to a spot of bother Lloyd George had in 1911. 
 Their lordships cannot amend the finance bill. 
 Britain's eccentricity is not entirely harmless. 
 This year City pundits, working hard to get themselves quoted in the media, bid up their idea of a suitably tough budget. 
 In the space of a few weeks they went from favouring broadly no change in taxation (which is what the chancellor gave them) to yearning for the rod &mdash; in one case a tax rise of &pound;5 billion-10 billion. 
 Budget palaver and acute short-termism seem to go hand in hand.  
 The healer's art 
 IT WAS absorbing political theatre. 
 A new chancellor, unexpectedly shifted from the foreign secretary's post a few months earlier, delivered a &bquo;budget for savers&equo;. 
 His limpid style and flashes of wit overcame Labour heckling, tickled the press and brought a smile to jaded Tory backbenchers. 
 Even his modernising, pipe-smoking Labour opponent was amused and nodded at times. 
 Was this chancellor the next prime minister? 
 Yes, indeed &mdash; for it was Harold Macmillan presenting his 1956 budget, watched from the gallery by a youthful John Major. 
 The grown-up version, now chancellor himself, would doubtless cringe at the Macmillan rhetoric of 34 years ago &mdash; &bquo;we must all be expansionists&hellip; 
 The problem of inflation cannot be dealt with by cutting down demand&equo;. 
 But there are irresistible parallels, too. 
 Not only is there Mr Major's new vehicle for small savers, acronymed TESSA and a reminder of the introduction of the premium bond and Ernie. 
 Macmillan also left income-tax rates alone, hit cigarette-smoking and made stern noises about public expenditure; and he presided over the highest interest rates for decades &mdash; bank rate was a horrific 5.5%. 
 In 1956, of course, the Conservative party was heading for one of the few post-war political events unequivocally more damaging to it than the current poll-tax furore &mdash; the Suez crisis. 
 Macmillan became prime minister with the job of healing a divided and warring party. 
 Standing around the lobbies, bars and corridors of the Commons after Mr Major's 1990 budget speech were plenty of Tories ready to speak of the new chancellor as a possible &bquo;healing&equo; prime minister. 
 &bquo;Sell Heseltines, buy Majors,&equo; said one right-winger. 
 &bquo;Healing balm, not a violent emetic,&equo; said another. 
 And Mr Major himself could not have been more emollient. 
 He transformed the atmosphere in the budget-day chamber. 
 Where his predecessor, Mr Nigel Lawson, was all dry-ice and thunderflash, Mr Major was courteous and measured. 
 He even developed a nice line in badinage with the unusually genial Labour leader, Mr Neil Kinnock. 
 The two men seem genuinely to like one another. 
 Tory members who felt that Mr Lawson regarded them as intellectual pigmies (as, doubtless, he did) are puffed up with pleasure at how this kinder, gentler chancellor listens to them. 
 Some members of the backbench Tory Treasury committee are under the impression that they virtually dictated his budget &mdash; which is harmless and quite touching. 
 Backbenchers also noted, and liked, the political populism that is starting to become the Major hallmark &mdash; good news for the football-watching, pipe-smoking, beer-drinking man on a modest income, less good news for directors with free flats and swanky company cars. 
 He was prepared to buy off political pressure, as over workplace nurseries, in a way Mr Lawson would surely have disdained. 
 All this means that Mr Major has improved his chances of succeeding Mrs Thatcher and might even be a serious contender if she retired early. 
 More importantly, by giving the impression that the government's control-room department is neither flustered nor panicky, his confident, self-possessed performance has bolstered the prime minister's own position just when she needed that support most. 
 During Mr Kinnock's amusing budget counter-attack, she sat with Mr Major and Mr Kenneth Baker, the party chairman, squeezed protectively around her. 
 The trio's body-language was eloquent. 
 Some Conservative spoil-sports fear the impact of the budget will be short-lived. 
 Certainly, Mr Major did not frame his budget with much of an eye on the next dreadful six months &mdash; and may yet be forced to raise interest rates. 
 But for most Tories, excluding a minority who thought he was too soft, this budget was welcome relief. 
 One cautionary note: Mr Major's real Tory hero is not Macmillan nor Mr Lawson, but the late Iain Macleod. 
 Macleod used to say that budgets which were praised at Easter would be condemned by the autumn. 
 City of philosophers 
 The only budget announcement that might have influenced the mid-Staffordshire result was the doubling of the savings limit for those entitled to claim poll-tax relief. 
 In that long thin strip of middle England, with its old towns and charmless Birmingham commuter-belt estates, Tory canvassers heard time and time again that voters wanted to punish the government for the poll tax. 
 When Sir Geoffrey Howe, the deputy prime minister, spoke in the town of Stone to grey-haired party loyalists, five out of the seven questions addressed to him were stingingly hostile. 
 One self-described Heathite Tory said that the message from the doorsteps was of profound disillusion with Mrs Thatcher. 
 Dr Samuel Johnson, the most famous son of Lichfield, in the south of the constituency, described it as a city of philosophers. 
 Faced with the poll tax, most of its modern citizenry have sounded distinctly unphilosophical these past few weeks. 
 A Tory campaign machine on full throttle generally encountered sour looks and sullen stares. 
 Depressingly, the Labour party managed to run an entire campaign without exposing its candidate to genuine scrutiny at public meetings. 
 As in the 1987 general election, the Conservatives were readier to put themselves on the line &mdash; to be made fools of, as might be, by voters and journalists. 
 The Labour candidate, Mrs Sylvia Heal, who rarely departed from script, is said to be a personal friend of Mr Kinnock. 
 This has been the case with three out of the past four successful Labour by-election candidates: a slow but novel way for Mr Kinnock to stamp out dissent in his parliamentary party. 
 The most interesting aspect of the Labour campaign was, however, its glossy, middle-class niceness. 
 A Labour campaign document championed the &bquo;traditional values and firm foundations of the mid-Staffordshire way of life&equo; and complained that its &bquo;serenity&hellip; has been shattered in recent times&equo; by crime. 
 This essentially conservative message was reinforced with the comfortable-sounding election slogan: &bquo;Vote for what you value&equo;. 
 Gazing down from his plinth in Lichfield, you could almost hear Dr Johnson muttering: &bquo;Socialism, Sir, is a cow, which will yield such people no more milk &mdash; and so they are gone to milk the bull&equo;.  
 Bankers and brokers 
 Tidying up 
 Changes to banks' bad-debt provisions; lower taxes on futures dealings; abolition of stamp duty on share dealings 
 IT IS just as well that Britain's banks chose 1989 to increase their provisions on third-world loans. 
 If they had not, they would have been vulnerable to a Conservative chancellor's most unlikely weapon, a windfall-profits tax. 
 They feared such a punishment for insolently pointing out that Mrs Thatcher's pet plan for student loans was a non-starter. 
 Instead of a windfall-profits tax, which cost them &pound;375m in 1981, the banks merely have to suffer the pin-prick of a delay in claiming tax-relief on those same provisions which hit their profits. 
 Banks made provisions of up to around 70% against total third-world loans, and assumed they would get tax relief as if they had actually lost money. 
 Under the chancellor's proposals the Bank of England will decide how much will be immediately available for relief &mdash; probably an average of 50%. 
 Relief on the rest will be taken at the rate of 5% a year. 
 The chancellor's threats that the banks should be more cautious about selling credit in Britain will have little effect. 
 Most will follow Barclays and write to their customers asking for permission to post them corrupting materials. 
 But the bright side for the chancellor is that there should be higher bank profits to tax, especially if interest rates fall. 
 The TESSAs (tax-exempt special savings accounts) he introduced will allow banks to raise more, cheap retail deposits. 
 Two measures should do a good deal to grease the wheels of the City's securities business. 
 By exempting pension funds and unit trusts from income tax on trading profits from futures and options dealings, he has managed to clear up an uncertainty that has kept many investing institutions shy of London's derivatives markets. 
 The line that the Inland Revenue has hitherto drawn between investment and trading has been exasperatingly unclear. 
 The abolition of the 0.5% stamp duty on shares will also please institutions more than private investors. 
 That is because institutions pay proportionately much less on dealing commissions (which average around 0.2%) than do private clients (about 1.5%). 
 The chancellor tied the abolition of duty to the planned arrival, in 1991&ndash;92, of the London stock exchange's Taurus. 
 Though Mr Major called Taurus a dealing system, it is not: it is a paperless settlement system, which means it will be rather hard to put a stamp on anything. 
 That is why, if the stock exchange had built Taurus many years ago, as promised, it could also have ensured the earlier abolition of stamp duty.  
 Advertising 
 Single marketing 
 As the Community juggles with new rules on advertising, the advertising business is gearing up to do battle in Brussels and Strasbourg 
 BRITAIN'S advertisers are worrying that European Community legislation is set to reach parts that other laws do not reach. 
 The European Parliament's vote on March 14th for a complete ban on tobacco advertising has sharpened the advertising industry's fears that moves towards harmonising laws will mean, in liberal Britain, tighter regulation on ads for drugs, drink, food and financial services. 
 Meanwhile the health and consumer lobbies fear the opposite &mdash; that harmonisation will mean the unravelling of national controls. 
 Unfortunately for the advertisers, the first battle has been over the least defensible product. 
 Britain bans cigarette advertising on television, but, with tough restrictions, allows other tobacco advertising. 
 EC laws already passed are stiffer. 
 From next year, cigar and pipe-tobacco advertising will be banned from British television. 
 Viewers as well as advertisers may regret it. 
 Cigar advertising is some of the funniest on the small screen. 
 Hamlet advertisements rely on the &bquo;humour of suffering&equo;, featuring unfortunates scrabbling under lavatory doors for errant rolls of loo paper or watching airport carousels chew up their luggage: the victim, by lighting a Hamlet cigar, becomes the spiritual victor. 
 Castella offers a different brand of joke-hero: the ingenious angler who beats the rest by treating the fish to Des O'Connor on a submerged stereo system, until they leap from the water to escape the torture. 
 Now the European Parliament wants tougher restrictions still. 
 Despite a heavyweight (and possibly counterproductive) lobbying effort by the tobacco companies, its March 14th vote was aimed at a complete ban on all tobacco advertising &mdash; a business worth &pound;46m in Britain in 1988. 
 The commission in Brussels has vetoed the Strasbourg parliament's line: Brussels knows that Britain and West Germany would never agree to a total ban. 
 But Strasbourg's anti-nicotine brigade has won a consolation prize: the health and social-affairs commissioner, Mrs Vasso Papandreou, has promised to look at a ban in the future. 
 These moves on tobacco-advertising have alerted British admen to a growing enthusiasm within the commission for introducing rules product by product. 
 They believe the commission is unfriendly towards advertising and the parliament, made up of health-obsessed, anti-materialist children of the 1960s, is even worse. 
 Led by Britain's Advertising Association, which brings together the advertisers, the agencies and the media, the advertising lobby is gearing up to defend products which they reckon are most vulnerable: 
 Food. 
 A proposed directive suggests that manufacturers should not be allowed to refer to helpful recommendations by health bodies (&bquo;The Intestines Inspectorate says fibre is good for you. 
 Frizzo is 79.3% fibre&equo;). 
 It would also ban the distinction between natural and artificial ingredients. 
 Drugs. 
 Lobbying by pharmaceutical companies has already watered down a proposed directive which at first suggested forcing them to include detailed information on dosage and usage on  advertisements . 
 The companies are watching carefully lest other lobbyists try to slip the tougher provisions back in. 
 Financial services. 
 The original draft directive proposed that advertising should be limited to the sort of details a business card carries. 
 Companies have got the directive weakened, but worry that it may be beefed up again. 
 Alcohol. 
 Booze companies fear that tobacco's closest relation may be in for the same treatment: there have been rumours that a directive is being prepared. 
 Booze sans fronti&egrave;res 
 Not everyone is opposed to more controls on advertising. 
 Those who favour a tighter regime are just as unhappy about the EC's approach to date. 
 They feel that, on alcohol advertising in particular, the EC has ducked the issues posed by a single market and satellite broadcasting; and that as a result regulations may be cut back to the loosest common denominator. 
 A directive which comes into force next year will set rules on television advertising across frontiers. 
 After much lobbying, it has ended up as a liberal edict. 
 The standards it sets on promotion are lower even than Britain's. 
 In Britain, by industry agreement, gin, whisky and vodka are not advertised on television. 
 But other sorts of drink may be advertised, so long as they do not link consumption to social or sexual success &mdash; thus eliminating the predictable drink-this-and-score line. 
 France allows no alcohol commercials on television at all. 
 The broadcasting directive will allow cross-border advertising of all sorts of alcohol. 
 So a German satellite station could, while conforming to EC law, beam Cognac advertisements into Britain, which Britain's whisky manufacturers would be unable to counter with domestic panegyrics on the pleasures of the malt. 
 Similarly, a British satellite station could broadcast beer commercials to France, while French television could not. 
 That could leave broadcasters, manufacturers and admen, faced with competition from less-restricted foreigners, pressing their governments for more liberal treatment. 
 The control lobby worries that governments, faced with this anomaly, will simply decide to loosen their own controls and allow advertisers to deluge the airwaves with booze ads. 
 Unlikely, say the drinks companies: given its penchant for regulation, the EC would soon bury them in a pile of new directives.  
 A budget for savers not sterling 
 John Major's first budget pleased the Tory party but scared the financial markets. 
 Our coverage begins with the biggest thing he did, then turns to the biggest thing he left undone. 
 On page 40 Bagehot looks at the politics 
 EVERY chancellor faces two main economic tests at budget-time. 
 One is to offer a coherent and persuasive statement of the government's macro-economic policy, and the other is to make the tax system work better. 
 This year politics and economics conspired to make the first almost impossible. 
 Mr Major therefore made a stab at the second &mdash; though it might seem that after 11 years in office, Mrs Thatcher's radical government should have had all the time it needed for tax reform. 
 In an impressive performance he delivered enough of substance, together with a dose of populism, to satisfy his side of the Commons. 
 But when the City looked at the gap where macroeconomic policy should have been, it took fright. 
 Sterling slumped. 
 The affable Mr Major has some worrying days ahead. 
 Some of the tax reforms in this budget, however, will have a large and lasting effect. 
 Whatever the chancellor's motives, it is a mistake to dismiss his budget for savers as mere window-dressing. 
 This chancellor has the best possible reasons for reviving &bquo;the culture of thrift&equo;. 
 The slump in household saving, from 14% of disposable income in 1980 to just 5% last year, was partly to blame for the rise in inflation that now plagues the government. 
 Why did saving collapse in the first place? 
 The answer is awkward: financial deregulation. 
 The Tories are proud of the way they let the building societies wrestle the banks for customers, and vice versa. 
 The retail-finance industry changed in many ways as a result &mdash; but most of all in lending for house purchase. 
 There, a gale of competition swept Britain from a Soviet-style queueing system to one in which people could quickly and conveniently borrow as much as they were able to service, from any of a wide choice of lenders. 
 This change of financial environment had profound economic effects. 
 It made monetary policy difficult, because the meaning of &bquo;money&equo; was no longer clear. 
 The flood of credit into the housing market fuelled house-price inflation and, in due course, inflation in the wider economy. 
 People borrowed and spent more, and saved less. 
 Not for the first time, therefore, a government keen on deregulation has been upset by the results. 
 Mr Major won't hear of re-regulation (in the form of credit controls, say) but he does think it a pity that lenders behave so &bquo;irresponsibly&equo;. 
 The personal savings rate has already started to bounce back, and is sure to rise further this year. 
 The present hysteria about reckless lending may therefore fade before long. 
 However, if it produced the right sort of pro-saving policies in the meantime, the hand-wringing would have served a useful purpose. 
 Over the long term, if Britain saved more it could grow faster. 
 And the long-term reason for under-saving is not the after-shock of financial deregulation (a temporary worry) but the anti-saving bias that is built into the tax system. 
 Put simply, the bias is this: people save out of taxed income, and the interest earned by their savings is then taxed again. 
 Will Mr Major's reforms make a difference? 
 His most interesting proposal follows the Treasury tradition of stealing, but slightly spoiling, the ideas of Mr Mervyn King, a professor at the London School of Economics. 
 The chancellor unveiled the tax-exempt special savings account, or TESSA. 
 After 1991 people will be able to deposit &pound;1,800 a year over five years in a special account in any bank or building society. 
 If none of the capital is withdrawn within the five years, then all the interest is tax free. 
 TESSAs are similar to personal-equity plans (PEPs), which also shelter savings from tax, but they should appeal to less sophisticated savers. 
 That should help TESSAs to increase, rather than merely divert, saving. 
 Mr King reckons that the net increase could be big: if 4m take out a TESSA, private saving could rise by about 30%. 
 Take-up on that scale could make Mr Major's first budget a lot more memorable than it first appeared. 
 Mr Major also increased the annual limit on investment in PEPs from &pound;4,800 to &pound;6,000 and allowed them more scope to buy unit trusts. 
 Since the scheme was launched in 1987 690,000 plans have been taken out for a total of almost &pound;1.5 billion. 
 For many small investors the attraction remains small. 
 Aside from the risk and complications, fees offset most of the tax break. 
 Mr Major's third pro-saving policy was to abolish the composite-rate tax on bank and building-society deposits. 
 At present, interest on deposits is paid after deducting a fixed rate of tax, which cannot be reclaimed by non-taxpayers. 
 This arrangement was convenient for the taxman, but unfair. 
 From April, when married couples are taxed separately, 5m married women will get their own tax allowance to set against income from savings. 
 Counting pensioners and children, 14m savers should not be paying tax, but have to under current legislation. 
 From April 1991 their interest will be tax-free. 
 Piecemeal reform makes the tax system more complicated, and is not the best way to promote saving. 
 Ideally income tax would be replaced by an expenditure tax: all saving would then be tax-deductible, and all spending would be taxed. 
 It would take a bold, reforming chancellor and an economy where everything was going right. 
 Mr Major is conceivably the chancellor, but Britain in 1990 is certainly not the economy.  
 Water industry 
 Paying for purity 
 Gradually, directives from the European Commission are affecting business life in Britain. 
 The next two articles describe their inroads into the businesses of water and advertising 
 NERVOUS Tories in search of solace like to compare the poll tax to the privatisation of the water industry. 
 Pundits predicted that the sell-off would be a disaster &mdash; a money-loser in the City and a vote-loser in the country. 
 Four months later the Tories see it as an unqualified success, propelling the man who presided over it, Mr Michael Howard, into the political big league. 
 The share issue, they note, was massively over-subscribed; investors are making a healthy profit; and consumers are as cheerful as ever. 
 Are they? 
 In the past week or so householders throughout the country have been opening their April water bills and gaping. 
 The post-privatisation product looks and tastes no different; but its price everywhere is sharply higher. 
 The ten privatised water authorities have lifted their prices by just under 13%; the 29 statutory water companies (which have always been in the private sector and supply water, but not sewage services, to about a quarter of the population of England and Wales) have increased theirs by over 15%. 
 Irate customers who bother to complain to their local water executives will be told the rises are no higher than were forecast. 
 Elaborate pricing mechanisms &mdash; the K-factors and all the rest &mdash; were set up by the government before the sell-off; they were aimed at helping the industry, which had long been a victim of under-investment, to pay for a capital-spending programme of at least &pound;18 billion over the next decade. 
 These pricing formulas will ensure that prices continue to rise for several years: in Northumbria, for example, prices could more than double by the mid-1990s. 
 Tying the hands of the regulator 
 But prices will also be driven by other cost increases that are less easily quantified and controlled. 
 Many customers will have to foot the bill for water meters, which most companies will eventually install. 
 Above all, the water companies may pass on to their customers any new costs caused by changes in environmental regulations. 
 These are likely to be hefty in the next few years as the European Community (EC) tightens the rules on drinking water and imposes new ones on sewage disposal. 
 Old hands in the water industry are critical of the Brussels commission. 
 They complain that its standards are unreasonably high. 
 The EC demands, for example, that water should contain only 50 millionths of a gram of nitrates per litre, whereas the World Health Organisation claims that 100 millionths is acceptable. 
 The other big complaint is that the commissioners are constantly raising their standards and are insensitive to national differences in such things as the colour of water (Britain has a lot of discoloured water, because it has a lot of peaty soil). 
 In privatising water, the government has set up a regulatory regime biased towards raising quality rather than controlling costs &mdash; and this has played straight into the hands of the commission. 
 Unable to justify the privatisation of a natural monopoly on familiar grounds such as competition and consumer choice, the government chose instead to emphasise regulation, boasting that privatisation would separate the provider from the regulator &mdash; or, to use a phrase much quoted by Mr Howard at the time, the gamekeeper from the poacher. 
 The regulatory regime does too little to protect cost-conscious customers. 
 The Office of Water Services (OFWAT) is headed by a director-general &mdash; Mr Ian Byatt, a former Treasury official &mdash; who is required by law to protect the financial health of the industry. 
 This obligation comes ahead of any other consideration, including charges to the customer. 
 And the director-general has little freedom of manoeuvre. 
 He is stuck with the same rigid pricing arrangements for the next five years. 
 If it now emerges that the Department of the Environment was over-generous to any of the water authorities last year, OFWAT has no choice but to live with the consequences. 
 Sceptics in the City think that Mr Byatt's organisation &mdash; a staff of 100 based in Birmingham &mdash; is too small to deal with a huge and complicated industry. 
 Thames Water is one of the biggest water companies in the world; Cholderton and District Water Company near Salisbury is run by a man and his wife, and supplies water to a couple of small villages on a private estate. 
 Both are regulated by Mr Byatt. 
 As well as being biased towards the purity lobby, the regulatory regime is worryingly complex, contrasting dramatically with the streamlined arrangements for gas and telecoms. 
 In addition to the secretary of state for the environment, the director-general of water services, and the EC commissioners, regulators include the Monopolies and Mergers Commission (which has already stepped in to prevent unwelcome mergers); the local authorities (responsible for monitoring and controlling the standard of clean water supplies); the Drinking Water Inspectorate (the auditor of technical standards); the National Rivers Authority (responsible for monitoring and controlling pollution in rivers, lakes and coastal waters, and for maintaining sea walls); Her Majesty's Inspectorate of Pollution, HMIP (which grants consents for the release of toxic substances into the environment); and the Ministry of Agriculture, Fisheries and Food (responsible for granting consents for disposals at sea). 
 Duplication and bickering are endemic. 
 Relations between Lord Crickhowell, head of the NRA, and the office of HMIP are cooling fast. 
 The central problem with the set-up, however, is that no single body is charged with calculating the opportunity costs of environmental bossiness. 
 The regulators in Brussels have only one interest: raising standards. 
 They have no qualms about forcing member countries to spend money on water they might think could be better spent elsewhere. 
 The captains of the water industry are happy to go along with Brussels. 
 The enormous investment programme is precisely what makes the industry exciting to City investors, since it underpins rising revenues. 
 The fact that the costs of this programme fall entirely on captive consumers is all too convenient. 
 &bquo;The purer the better&equo; might be a reasonable motto for a substance as indispensable as water. 
 But the quantities of lead and nitrates which the EC is making a fuss about are so small that they represent a negligible &mdash; perhaps even a non-existent &mdash; hazard to health. 
 And since only about 3% of water is drunk, while a great deal is used for cruder purposes, much of the industry's investment will be flushed down the drain. 
 British consumers will have to find &pound;90m to meet the EC's directives over the next few years; might this large amount of money not have been better spent, say, in building hospitals and schools? 
 Mr Nicholas Ridley, who, as secretary of state for the environment, masterminded the privatisation, likes to think of himself as a scourge of high-minded meddlers and an advocate of consumer choice. 
 Yet the regulatory regime he put in place is a meddlers' charter. 
 For years to come, the public will be watering the garden with money.  
 Personal taxes 
 See you next year 
 Basic and top rate of income tax unchanged; personal allowance raised in line with inflation (7.7%); top tax band unchanged. 
 Excise duties on spirits, cigarettes and petrol to rise by 10%, other duties in line with inflation 
 IN EVERY budget since 1982 the Conservative government has either reduced income taxes or national insurance contributions. 
 Mr Major bucked the trend. 
 He lowered the threshold for the highest rate of income tax in real terms, but otherwise the budget hardly changed the income-tax system. 
 This pleased those who feared big tax increases, but disappointed the fiscal purists who hoped to see the removal of anomalies. 
 The chancellor fully indexed personal income-tax allowances. 
 But by freezing the top-rate threshold he gathered &pound;400m. 
 Was that the best way? 
 Mr Major raised the tax on company cars 20% (yielding &pound;200m), but taxing them at their full value would have collected another &pound;300m. 
 Scrapping the income ceiling at which employees stop paying the 9% national insurance contribution would have attacked another anomaly. 
 As it is, basic-rate taxpayers who earn more than the &pound;16,900 ceiling face a marginal tax rate of 25%, while those earning less than the ceiling face a rate of 34%. 
 The chancellor is clearly no stickler for fiscal purity. 
 He exempted employees from tax on the fringe benefit of company nurseries. 
 He introduced tax relief for charitable donations of between &pound;600 and &pound;5m, and raised the limit on relief for donations under the payroll-giving scheme from &pound;480 to &pound;600 a year. 
 He also increased, from &pound;8,000 to &pound;16,000, the amount of savings which disqualify a person from claiming housing benefit and poll-tax benefits. 
 This will cost about &pound;120m. 
 Tory backbenchers consider it money well spent. 
 Those hoping for a green budget were disappointed. 
 Despite the reams of analysis of new environmental taxes, Mr Major did next to nothing, except raise petrol duties by 10% and widen the tax difference between leaded and unleaded petrol by less than 2p, to 16p a gallon. 
 Mr Major resisted the temptation to leave some excise duties unchanged in order to hold down the inflation rate. 
 Most duties were raised in line with inflation; those on spirits and (non-pipe) tobacco were increased by 10%. 
 These increases will add half a percentage point to the inflation rate. 
 The duty on spirits had fallen in real terms in every year since 1982 &mdash; a total fall of more than 20% &mdash; raising worries about the health implications. 
 The budget leaves the real value of taxes (duties and VAT) on beer, cigarettes and petrol some 40&ndash;50% higher than when Mrs Thatcher took office in 1979. 
 Pipe smokers and whisky drinkers have done much better, with a fall in duties of around 20%, while wine drinkers have had a ball, with a 30% fall in tax. 
 Is it just coincidence that the previous chancellor was fond of a spritzer? 
 The present one left vehicle excise duties at &pound;100, unchanged for the fifth year running. 
 The government's aim is evidently to shift the taxation of motorists on to petrol; this will link the tax more closely to vehicle use, and so provide a greater incentive to economise on fuel. 
 Not exactly memorable, was it? 
 Mr Major, the economical populist, may be less frugal next year.  
 The economy 
 Nobody understands me 
 Public-sector debt repayment of &pound;7 billion in 1989&ndash;90, and again in 1990&ndash;91; target for M0 set at 1&ndash;5%, no target for M4; &bquo;commitment&equo; to EMS membership reaffirmed; interest rates to stay &bquo;as high as necessary&equo; 
 THE economy faces a severe slowdown and possibly a recession over the coming months. 
 The government is running a large budget surplus and expects to carry on doing so. 
 This used to be called a tight fiscal policy. 
 And the government has pushed short-term interest rates to 15%. 
 Even allowing for inflation, that is dear money. 
 So are financiers calling for a relaxation of these stringent measures, to cushion the coming slump? 
 No, they are threatening a sterling crisis because the fiscal and monetary tightening has not been brutal enough. 
 Strange times. 
 Just when it is vital to get policy on sterling right, the task has become virtually impossible. 
 Though the next general election may be more than two years away, the markets have already started taking bets on the outcome. 
 This has produced a nastily vicious circle. 
 At least for the moment, the Conservative government has wrecked its popularity by pursuing misconceived projects such as the poll tax. 
 The Labour party's lead in the opinion polls has shot above 20 points. 
 So it has dawned on the financial markets that the enemy might actually win the next election. 
 That, it thinks, would be bad. 
 Sell sterling. 
 The pound comes under pressure and the government is forced to keep interest rates high. 
 This is immensely unpopular in the country and makes a Labour victory more likely. 
 Sell sterling. 
 And so on. 
 This might be called Kinnock's Revenge. 
 For years the Labour party has been the victim of the City's fears of its policies. 
 Now the government is the victim of the City's fears of Labour's policies. 
 Indeed, at this rate the City's fears of Labour's policies could make the difference in getting Labour elected. 
 Such calculations must have weighed with Mr Major. 
 A tougher budget, even if economically desirable (which is highly doubtful), might have widened Labour's lead in the polls. 
 So, after luxuriating in its hair shirt for a few days, the City would have sold sterling anyway. 
 The only advice for a Tory chancellor in this position is, don't ever get into this position. 
 Perhaps that is not quite the only advice. 
 The heart of the government's economic difficulty is sterling, and the credibility of Mr Major's indications (if that is not too strong a word) that he will defend it. 
 The markets, and the employers who are busy fuelling wage inflation, expect a depreciation. 
 Mr Major's budget failed to change their minds. 
 He cannot see why. 
 The cry of many a chancellor in distress has been &bquo;Nobody understands me.&equo; 
 Which is precisely the point. 
 Mr Nigel Lawson was rude and arrogant &mdash; exactly what a chancellor should be. 
 If he said he would defend the pound, you knew he would do it or bust. 
 With that sort of credibility, the task becomes feasible &mdash; and probably at lower interest rates than Britain now has. 
 Mr Major is nice, and listens to people who disagree with him. 
 He therefore seems capable of compromise. 
 Fatal. 
 And although Mrs Thatcher has none of these defects, she is known to be not averse to the occasional run on sterling. 
 The effect is the same: British interest rates embody a Thatcher-Major premium. 
 Membership of the EMS might go some way to remedy this, though a firm change in rhetoric (&bquo;no question of a realignment&equo;) would also be needed, and even then the ride would be far from smooth. 
 Increasingly, the argument that membership should wait until Britain's inflation is down looks wrong. 
 It is like saying &bquo;when we have restored our credibility, we shall take firm steps to restore our credibility&equo;. 
 In the meantime, just how bad are things going to get? 
 The chancellor can hardly be accused of complacency. 
 The Treasury's once-formidable forecasting record has taken some knocks of late, so a lot of the predictions in the budget have been carefully pitched on the gloomy side. 
 (Let the next errors be nice surprises, for a change.) 
 In particular, the Treasury now seems to be more pessimistic than most City economists about inflation and the current-account deficit. 
 In the short term, the full indexation of excise duties and the introduction of the poll tax are likely to push the inflation rate to 9% in April. 
 But the Treasury forecasts that it will then fall to 7.25% by the end of this year (this seems to assume no fall in the mortgage rate) and to 5% in the second quarter of 1991. 
 Several economists in the City expect a bigger fall, to perhaps 3&ndash;4% by mid-1991, as interest rates start to fall, and the poll tax, the rise in excise duties and the mortgage-rate increase drop out of the figures. 
 The Treasury has stuck to its earlier forecast of a &pound;15 billion current-account deficit this year. 
 It expects a smaller invisibles surplus than before, but the forecasters are a lot more optimistic about visible trade: exports are booming. 
 Most City forecasters expect a bigger fall in the current-account deficit. 
 Goldman Sachs, for instance, is fore-casting a deficit of &pound;11 billion. 
 Look forward to a miserable 1990 and a fast-improving 1991, vicious circles permitting.  
 BRITAIN THIS WEEK 
 Blue days 
 The chancellor, John Major, presented his first budget. 
 Monetary targets were left virtually unchanged and the fiscal stance was broadly neutral. 
 Minor reforms were mostly aimed at encouraging savers: Mr Major introduced TESSA, a tax-exempt savings account, and abolished stamp duty on shares. 
 Football got &pound;100m to improve safety. 
 Tory MPs gave Mr Major high marks for style and content. 
 Labour's response was noticeably muted. 
 The City gave an initial thumbs-down, selling sterling to a new low against the D-mark. 
 In a Financial Times poll of senior businessmen, 70% said the budget made little or no difference to their companies or their view of government policy. 
 A budget concession on the poll tax offered more relief to pensioners with savings. 
 Labour MPs howled for a retrospective rebate in Scotland, where the poll tax came in last year. 
 Treasury sums said the rebate would be worth &pound;4m, but would cost more to fix. 
 Better than expected, the February current-account deficit was &pound;1.4 billion; the trade deficit figure was the same &mdash; net invisibles vanished. 
 The BBC hotted up its coverage of the budget by giving breakfast-television viewers the wrong number for a telephone information-line. 
 It connected callers with Sexy Susie, offering a range of non-financial adult services. 
 Lord (Victor) Rothschild, former head of Downing Street's think-tank, died. 
 Scales of justice 
 David Waddington, the home secretary, announced that he has asked the chief constable of the West Midlands to investigate the conviction of the Birmingham six, who were jailed for an IRA bombing 16 years ago. 
 Legislation to allow Nazi war criminals to be put on trial passed its first reading in the Commons. 
 The home secretary announced plans to set up a special police unit to investigate suspects. 
 Two senior policemen were suspended after the Court of Appeal decided that a junior colleague had been convicted of robbery on fabricated evidence. 
 He had been picked out at an identification parade only after his photograph had been shown to the prosecution witnesses &mdash; three criminals who got shorter sentences for helping the police. 
 The Court of Appeal heard that a witness whose evidence sent another man to jail for murder in 1988 had been bribed by police. 
 The convicted man's counsel said that Mr Kevin Sarbutts was given &pound;6,500 by an assistant commissioner at Scotland Yard after the trial. 
 A detective inspector then took &pound;500 back &bquo;as his drink for the boys&equo;. 
 Rate for the job 
 Brighter prospects for low-paid women workers. 
 Both J. Sainsbury and Marks &amp; Spencer upgraded their sales assistants, mostly women, to bring their pay closer to that of warehouse workers, mostly men. 
 Both retailers offered the women big rises on the basis of the regrading. 
 &bquo;There is no sex angle on this,&equo; said an M&amp;S director. 
 The health secretary, Kenneth Clarke, said he would examine a proposal to pay people to look after frail elderly relatives instead of putting them in homes. 
 He claimed that residential homes cost about &pound;170 a week per person. 
 Muddle and mayhem 
 Security at the Shorts company's guided-missile plant in Belfast was exposed again. 
 Only 17 months after Loyalist workers smuggled missile parts out of the factory, the IRA smuggled two bombs into it. 
 Extracts from an official report on last summer's Marchioness riverboat disaster were released by the member of Parliament in whose constituency the accident happened. 
 The report, originally due for publication later in the spring, criticises the Department of Transport for not fully applying lessons from previous, less serious collisions on the river. 
 Shell, recently fined over &pound;1m for an oil spillage, got into more trouble. 
 An explosion injured six workers and devastated a petrochemical plant at its Stanlow oil refinery, near Ellesmere Port, leaking solvent into the Mersey. 
 The ghosts of Bannockburn walked abroad, as Scotland's rugby team brought down the much-fancied England XV at Murrayfield by 13&ndash;7 and scooped all the prizes from the five-nations international championship. 
 That leaves the Scots with just the All Blacks to beat, this summer. 
 Heathrow airport on Friday March 16th recorded its highest-ever number of aircraft take-offs and landings: 1,162 in all. 
 June temperatures hit the south of England for a day, with London in the 70s. 
 An expert on ladybirds from Cambridge University said that they had begun their egg-laying two months early, in time to double the usual crop of adults this summer. 
 Finding a quiet spot on a south-coast beach could be hard.  
 Companies 
 Tinker, tinker 
 Cuts in corporation tax for small businesses; VAT and BES changes; &pound;100m for football safety; tax relief for TECs 
 RED ink is splattered all over Britain's companies. 
 Heavy capital investment led to a record &pound;23.4 billion financial deficit last year. 
 Company borrowing soared by an annualised &pound;64 billion during the first three quarters of 1989 &mdash; the fastest rise ever. 
 Net interest payments were 69% higher than in 1988, and unit labour costs are soaring. 
 All this means that the investment boom is over. 
 The Treasury reckons that, after climbing 8.75% in real terms last year, fixed business investment will fall by 1% in 1990. 
 Business failures in England and Wales rose 10% last year, after falling since 1984. 
 The business lobby has been squealing for everything from accelerated depreciation allowances to a Business Development Board to grant cheap loans. 
 In the event, only small firms received a budget fillip. 
 Small companies used to pay a reduced rate (25%) of corporation tax on profits of up to &pound;150,000; Mr Major raised the threshold to &pound;200,000. 
 Firms will no longer pay the top rate (35%) until their profits hit &pound;1m &mdash; up from &pound;750,000. 
 These changes will benefit about 20,000 small firms. 
 Britain now has &bquo;the most favourable structure of corporation tax rates for small companies anywhere in the EC&equo;, says Mr Major. 
 The chancellor also adjusted Britain's VAT rules. 
 Until now firms have had to pay the tax on all their sales, even when customers have left bills unpaid. 
 From April 1991 all written-off debts more than two years old will qualify for relief from VAT. 
 Mr Major also raised the threshold for VAT registration by &pound;1,800, to &pound;24,500, and simplified registration requirements. 
 The annual limit for investment raised under the Business Expansion Scheme was raised to &pound;750,000. 
 The only big businesses to receive a boost were oil companies: they will be allowed to write off the total cost of shutting down offshore oil fields against any corporation tax incurred during the last three years of a field's working life. 
 Whether, close to the end of its days, an oilfield will produce enough profit to offset the hefty cost of abandonment is debatable. 
 Mr Major scored a more convincing goal with Britain's football clubs, cutting the Pool Betting Duty from 42.5% to 40% for five years. 
 The savings &mdash; altogether &pound;100m over the period of the scheme &mdash; are to help pay for safety improvements at football grounds. 
 In the nick of time: according to one recent report 80 out of 92 league clubs are technically insolvent. 
 The chancellor made business contributions to Training and Enterprise Councils (TECs) tax-deductible. 
 TECs are private-sector-led bodies that will be responsible for providing or co-ordinating training programmes in their area. 
 Eventually, all 16-year-olds will be given a voucher to spend on a programme of their choice. 
 This scheme has drawbacks. 
 For starters, demographic trends are against it. 
 The number of people aged 16 to 19 will fall by about a quarter by 1994. 
 Employees who are already earning good money will see little point in spending their vouchers. 
 Worse, the courses which training agencies are likely to offer will be narrow: typing for secretaries, plumbing for plumbers. 
 Tomorrow's job market is more likely to need flexible workers. 
 BUSINESS 
 Microsoft 
 What comes after seven fat years? 
 SEATTLE 
 &bquo;QUIT while you're on top&equo; seems to be the philosophy of Mr Jon Shirley, president of Microsoft, the leading supplier of software for personal computers. 
 Microsoft's sales should top &dollar;1 billion in the year to June 1990. 
 Profit is soaring. 
 The company has added to its strength in systems software &mdash; particularly the DOS operating system which comes with every IBM-compatible personal computer &mdash; with a range of word-processors, spreadsheets and other applications software. 
 With more than &dollar;20m-worth of Microsoft shares, Mr Shirley will sail off into the sunset in June, when he plans to retire. 
 On March 19th he named his successor, Mr Michael Hallman, most recently the manager of 13,000 employees in the computer-services division of Boeing. 
 Mr Hallman faces a different set of challenges from those that greeted Mr Shirley in 1983. 
 Mr Shirley reckons that the greatest of these will be developing closer links with customers. 
 Traditionally, Microsoft has concentrated on creating products &mdash; and left the courting of customers to its dealers or to the computer makers who sold its DOS operating system with their machines. 
 Though it still has no intention of selling directly, Microsoft wants a bigger say on how its products should be used. 
 So the company is shifting its attention from selling individual products to selling a range that can work easily together. 
 Instead of impressing its customers with the ease and convenience of, say, Microsoft's &bquo;Word&equo; word-processing program, the company hopes to wow them with the way that &bquo;Word&equo; can incorporate charts or query a remote database for the latest sales figures. 
 But selling linked products is more complicated than pushing individual ones, because customers require more help in making things work. 
 Equally important, the more Microsoft talks to customers, the greater its chances of convincing them to adopt its new OS/2 operating system as the foundation on which to build office automation. 
 Sales of OS/2 have gone more slowly than some at Microsoft had hoped. 
 The slower the growth, the more time AT&amp;T will have to strengthen the challenge to OS/2 from its rival Unix operating system. 
 Mr Hallman's experience at Boeing will have left him well versed in the problems of a large computer-user. 
 But making the transition from user to supplier can be tricky. 
 Apple Computer's relationship with Mr Allan Lorenz, who was hired from a giant insurance firm, CIGNA, to beef up Apple's appeal to corporate accounts, ended in tears. 
 And yet unlike Mr Lorenz, who joined a company perennially being reorganised, Mr Hallman will lead a relatively stable management team. 
 In addition to installing basic systems for accounting, cost-control and distribution, Mr Shirley helped to create a layer of reliable executives who could translate the technical visions of the company's chairman and founder, Mr Bill Gates, into products that got out the door, on time and to budget. 
 Though Mr Gates remains in charge of technology in this technology-driven company, he is backed up by seven &bquo;gurus&equo;. 
 These seven wise men guide small teams of young programmers. 
 Each team specialises in a set of functions &mdash; eg, handling text or drawing graphs. 
 The teams work to guidelines that ensure that their creations can work with those of their colleagues. 
 Though Microsoft offers its programs on three different operating systems &mdash; DOS, OS/2 and Apple Macintosh &mdash; only about one-fifth of the program need be tinkered with to shift from one computer to another. 
 The most important job for Mr Hallman will be to get on with his chairman, Mr Gates. 
 Aged 34, Mr Gates is bright, opinionated, decisive and every bit as sure of himself as one would expect from a man who was a billionaire by the age of 30. 
 Mr Shirley reckons Mr Hallman will need two qualities. 
 Anyone working with Mr Gates must take decisions on the spot; studies and committees fray the billionaire's patience. 
 Second, Mr Hallman must avoid worrying Mr Gates with administrative and financial detail. 
 Mr Gates would be happy to get his financial information from the quarterly report to shareholders &mdash; so long as he can be confident that the news will be as consistently good as it has been during Mr Shirley's seven years in charge.  
 Surviving the Drexel whirlwind 
 NEW YORK 
 The American public crowed when the junk-bond market collapsed. 
 But junk bonds helped many successful businesses, which now face hard times 
 EVERYBODY is dancing on the grave of Drexel Burnham Lambert &mdash; everybody but entrepreneurial America, that is. 
 The hundreds of businesses that have grown with the help of the &dollar;200 billion-plus market for high-risk, high-yield securities created by Drexel do not share the American public's jubilation over the investment bank's demise, which came after paying a &dollar;650m fine on six counts of mail and securities fraud. 
 When 200 of Drexel's former employees appeared on an hour-long television show recently, their host, Mr Phil Donahue, told them exactly what most Americans probably do think of them. 
 You not only were arrogant, you were snobbish, and in lots of ways, very impolite and mean&hellip; 
 Nobody likes you. 
 You're Wall Street yuppies and you've got a bad image&hellip; 
 I mean you are mostly white, mostly north-eastern, Yale, Harvard types. 
 You are mostly Republican. 
 You were raised in Connecticut. 
 You never ride the subway. 
 So who gives a damn about you guys? 
 Drexel's 11,000 ex-employees may not be drawn from the rainbow coalition, but lots of consumers and workers in America have reason to like some of what they did very much. 
 The junk-bond market that these Drexel yuppies and their mentor, Mr Michael Milken, created has financed many successful companies. 
 Only about 2,000 of the 23,000 companies in America that have annual sales of &dollar;35m or more can hope to issue debt that wins an investment-grade rating. 
 Until Drexel came along, the rest were denied access to the corporate-bond market on anything like reasonable terms. 
 Mr Milken opened the door. 
 As the head of Drexel's bond-trading department, until he was dismissed after being charged with securities fraud, Mr Milken convinced many (mainly institutional) investors that the higher yields on bonds that carried a below-investment-grade rating compensated for the extra risk. 
 Drexel successfully pioneered a mezzanine layer of financing between equity and bank debt for medium-sized American companies. 
 The collapse of Drexel has drawn the public's attention to over-borrowed companies struggling to service high-yield debts. 
 That concern is myopic. 
 Most of the 1,000 issuers of junk bonds have put the money they have raised to good, and sometimes brilliant, use. 
 One such company is Mr William McGowan's MCI. 
 It introduced the world's first fibre-optic telephone network with a &dollar;3 billion issue arranged by Drexel. 
 Milken bonds helped Mr Ted Turner's CNN grow into an international supplier of television news. 
 Hasbro, the maker of the G.I. Joe line of dolls, is another success. 
 High-yield-bond sales through Drexel helped finance the acquisitions that have turned Hasbro into America's biggest toy company. 
 Other businesses can be touted as triumphs by other investment banks. 
 The fortunes of Levi Strauss have been restored by junk bonds arranged by Salomon Brothers. 
 The jeans maker's bonds are trading above par, even in a badly depressed market. 
 Kroger, a client of Goldman Sachs, has become the country's second-largest grocery chain with the help of junk bonds. 
 Such success stories are being ignored. 
 The institutional investors that charged into junk bonds in the 1980s have now headed off at a gallop in the opposite direction. 
 The market is scarcely functioning. 
 Drexel, which used to commit &dollar;3 billion-5 billion of its own funds to market-making, has stopped even quoting prices on 3,000&ndash;4,000 junk bonds. 
 Mr Greg Meredith, a bond specialist at Salomon Brothers, notes that only two recent junk-bond issues have been floated successfully: by Goldman Sachs for Kroger, and by Merrill Lynch for Sullivan Graphics. 
 Amnesia has blotted out all memory of the companies that prospered after issuing junk bonds. 
 Only the failures linger. 
 Many of them, like the stores empire assembled by Mr Robert Campeau (owner of Bloomingdale's and Bon March&eacute;), Resorts International, a casino operator, and Paramount Petroleum would probably have gone into bankruptcy whatever happened. 
 But the collapse of the junk-bond market is a big blow to the scores of companies which were planning new offerings. 
 Drexel's collapse is especially painful for those junk-bond issuers which had counted on the investment bank to restructure their debt. 
 Some Drexel orphans are too small to merit the attention of the big Wall Street investment banks. 
 They are flocking to such company doctors as Mr Bob Sind's Recovery Management Corporation in New York. 
 &bquo;As long as Drexel was there,&equo; says Mr Sind, &bquo;they always managed to find a way to struggle from debt-payment date to debt-payment date.&equo; 
 The treatment prescribed has a familiar ring: rigorous financial analysis followed by cost-cutting, asset sales and then negotiations to convince creditors that rescheduling beats liquidation. 
 Restructuring is more complicated for the bigger junk-bond casualties. 
 Other sources of finance are hard to tap. 
 The flight to quality by investors has made equity financing prohibitively expensive for all but the soundest of companies. 
 The commercial-paper market offers only short-term financing. 
 The bond market is again exclusive. 
 And America's hard-pressed banks are in no mood for adventurous lending. 
 Matters have been made worse by the way investment banks scrambled to do junk-bond deals after federal investigators closed in on Mr Milken. 
 Standards went by the board as they sensed a chance to break Drexel's dominance of the junk-bond business. 
 Many of the deals struck in this frenzied atmosphere are sure to go sour eventually, sending more companies to the brink. 
 They will join companies already there. 
 The biggest is RJR-Nabisco, a food-and-tobacco giant taken private early last year in a record &dollar;25 billion leveraged buy-out. 
 RJR's credit rating is being ruined by junk bonds whose interest rates are supposed to be reset by May 1991 at a level that restores them to 100% of their issue prices. 
 These bonds are trading at well below 70% of their issue prices. 
 The message is obvious: RJR will have to restructure its debts to avoid default. 
 Macy's, a department-store chain, is in nearly as much trouble. 
 It lost &dollar;39m in the three months to January 27th, the Christmas quarter that usually produces its biggest profit of the year. 
 Southland Corporation, the operator of America's 7-Eleven convenience stores, is also struggling. 
 On March 22nd, Ito-Yokado, a Japanese retailing giant, and its subsidiary, 7-Eleven Japan, offered to buy 75% of the company. 
 The collapse of the junk-bond market has put the kibosh on a management buy-out of Wickes, an engineering and home-furnishings company. 
 The investment bankers that bought Wickes last November have already sold more than &dollar;400m in assets and are taking it private. 
 Mr William Farley, who acquired a slew of manufacturing companies with junk-bond financing arranged by Drexel, has had to resort to a bridging loan from banks to finance his acquisition of West Point-Pepperell, a textile giant. 
 Two or three years ago signs of such vulnerability would have attracted lots of predators, from home and abroad. 
 Times have changed. 
 The &dollar;1.6 billion that BTR, a British conglomerate, has offered for Norton, an abrasives maker, is the first big hostile takeover bid made in America so far this year. 
 With the collapse of Drexel and the junk-bond market, there are many more eager sellers of corporate assets than eager buyers. 
 Expect a wave of friendly mergers and alliances that do not require new money, either equity or debt.  
 Indonesia's conglomerates 
 Time to grow up 
 JAKARTA 
 THE world's fifth most populous nation is waking up. 
 Indonesia now exports more manufactured goods than oil. 
 Corruption has been tamed, though far from eliminated. 
 The government seems committed to deregulation. 
 Foreign investment, mainly from Japan, is pouring in. 
 The economy is expected to grow 7% this year. 
 This should all spell good news for Indonesia's two leading conglomerates, the Salim and Astra groups. 
 But, molly-coddled by the government for years, they may not be equipped to stand on their own two feet. 
 The two groups dominate the cement, flour, car and motorbike markets. 
 They also play a leading role in financial services, agribusinesses and timber. 
 Both companies are facing similar dilemmas. 
 They are Chinese, family-run empires whose aged founders remain at the helm, creating inevitable speculation about succession squabbles and, more importantly, about whether such a style of management will continue to work for billion-dollar conglomerates with international ambitions. 
 Both companies are closely identified with the government of 68-year old President Suharto, who has ruled the country for 24 years. 
 When his reign ends, they could fall on hard times. 
 Increasing their market share domestically might serve only to increase political resentment. 
 The other way to grow &mdash; by producing goods of export quality &mdash; will be a stiff test of whether these groups are the product of commercial logic or government patronage. 
 Of the two, the Salim Group is the biggest. 
 Like most family companies it is tight-fisted with information. 
 Analysts guess its annual sales are over 8.5 trillion rupiah (&dollar;4.6 billion). 
 The company's 74-year-old founder, Mr Soedono Salim (better known by his Chinese name of Liem Sioe Liong) has turned presidential favours into a personal fortune worth at least &dollar;2 billion. 
 Government patronage can be a two-edged sword. 
 When a Jakarta bureaucrat decided in the early 1980s that Indonesia should develop a steel industry, Mr Liem was &bquo;encouraged&equo; to put up 40% of the &dollar;800m cost of the Krakatau Steel project. 
 This shows few signs of ever being profitable. 
 Ultimately the government will probably bail out Krakatau as it bailed out Mr Liem's Indocement, South-East Asia's largest cement producer, which faced bankruptcy in 1985 after expanding too rapidly. 
 In turn, Mr Liem bailed the government out by floating 10% of Indocement's shares on the booming Jakarta stockmarket last December, raising &dollar;335m, and then using the money to repay most of the government's investment. 
 Selling more shares to foreigners and a growing Indonesian middle class would be the cheapest way for the group to finance further expansion and defuse some of the widespread resentment at Mr Liem's success. 
 Astra is trying a similar route. 
 On March 16th an offer for 30m new shares in Astra International closed, heavily over-subscribed and raising 446 billion rupiah. 
 Once the shares start trading on April 4th, the public will own 12.4% of Astra; the International Finance Corporation (IFC, the World Bank's private-sector arm) 5.4%; and the controlling Soeryadjaya family the remaining 82.2%. 
 Astra makes more sense as a public company than the Salim Group, mainly because its core businesses are obvious and integrated. 
 Over 75% of its operating profit (148.2 billion rupiah in 1989) comes from making and selling cars and motorbikes. 
 Last year it accounted for 48% of the 178,000 cars sold in Indonesia and 57% of the 289,000 motorbikes. 
 Its best-selling model is the Kijang, a tin box developed through a joint venture with Toyota. 
 The Indonesian government is keen to push up the local content of cars. 
 Astra has set up 21 component-making joint ventures with Japanese companies, which are attracted by low Indonesian wages. 
 These ventures will spearhead Astra's planned export drive. 
 It has already bought a component distributor in Canada and is starting one in Virginia. 
 Astra likes to believe that the quality of its management, blessed with the IFC seal of approval, sets it apart in Indonesia. 
 Mr William Soeryadjaya (Chinese name: Mr Tjia Kian Liong), the 67-year old seigneur, is a founder-member of the Euro-Asia Centre at INSEAD, the Paris-based business school where Astra's middle managers get sent for a spot of polishing. 
 The company's INSEAD alumni have yet to prove their skills in an openly competitive market.  
 The return of Perrier 
 EauKay 
 PEOPLE who sell stuff in glass bottles apparently do not throw stones. 
 In the five weeks since Perrier, a French bubbly-water company, was struck by a contamination scare, its competitors have been exquisitely polite about its travails. 
 Small wonder. 
 The industry has a booming though fragile market to protect. 
 In America, bottled-water sales have grown from &dollar;1.2 billion in 1983 to &dollar;2.6 billion in 1989. 
 Last year Britons swigged water worth about &pound;150m (&dollar;243m), 60% more than in the previous year. 
 Perrier's coy advertising, aimed at yuppies everywhere, made bottled water fashionable. 
 Other companies quickly moved to siphon off a share of the new business. 
 Nobody wants to see that flow become a trickle. 
 Perrier's comeback campaign is already being shown on television in France, and appearing in the press and on radio in America. 
 It is due to appear in Britain on March 28th. 
 Bottle labels will still describe Perrier's water as &bquo;naturally carbonated&equo;, although lots of extra fizz gets pumped in above ground. 
 The company has also neatly glossed over the fact that with this added gas (extracted from water from a second underground source) come added nasties, including benzene, which have to be taken out before bottling. 
 For over six months faulty filters were letting benzene through. 
 Perrier's first explanation for the contamination of its water was that a worker at its French plant had mistakenly used the wrong sort of cleaning fluid on bottling equipment. 
 It took four days for the company to identify the real cause. 
 Even now advertising copy declares, &bquo;The spring water itself was never at issue. 
 It's still as pure as it has been for thousands of years.&equo; 
 No mention of what has to be taken out to make the bubbles &bquo;natural&equo;. 
 Perrier's French television advertisements eschew weighty health talk in favour of Gallic schmaltz. 
 &bquo;I knew you'd come back, that you wouldn't drop me like that,&equo; breathes a husky male voice. 
 &bquo;Don't cry, you'll spoil your beautiful new label.&equo; 
 A curvaceous green bottle murmurs in reply: &bquo;I'm not crying; it's happiness.&equo; 
 The British version, to be launched on April 4th, will initially involve a &bquo;we're back&equo; theme, then return to puns on the word &bquo;eau&equo;. 
 America's offering is still under wraps. 
 Frivolity is a better marketing strategy for the bottled-water industry than actually telling consumers about its products. 
 Just like tap water, bottled water contains a host of minerals &mdash; and too much of some of them is bad for you. 
 Because such minerals are normally present at levels far below safety limits, this usually does not matter to public health. 
 It does matter to an industry whose selling point is purity. 
 Last year Archives of Environmental Health, an American science journal, published analyses of 31 mineral-water brands. 
 A startling 24 failed to meet standards laid down for public water supplies. 
 Studies like this explain why manufacturers have not started a slanging match. 
 &bquo;Any statement from us would have been highly irresponsible,&equo; says a marketing manager at Nestl&eacute;, producers of Ashbourne, an English bottled water. 
 Perhaps a better word would be suicidal. 
 The industry's solid front seems to have worked. 
 Retailers claim bottled-water sales have not dropped much. 
 Perrier's competitors have had to put their plants on 24-hour shifts to cope with added demand from the unaccustomed absence of the once ubiquitous green bottles. 
 Their good fortune probably will not last. 
 A straw poll covering 40 London restaurants and two large liquor-store chains unearthed only one outlet not intending to re-order Perrier when it becomes available again. 
 American sales are expected to recover quickly too.  
 Martyrs to their share price 
 NEW YORK 
 THEY'RE laughing all the way to the funeral,&equo; said one corporate wit. 
 This unpleasant humour was prompted by the stockmarket's reaction to the death from heart failure on March 18th of Mr Roland Berner, the 80-year-old chief executive of the Curtiss-Wright precision engineering company. 
 The day after the announcement of Mr Berner's death, on the evening of March 19th, the price of Curtiss-Wright's shares rose &dollar;7.5 to &dollar;59.5 on hopes that some or all of Curtiss-Wright may now be sold. 
 &bquo;It's a very morbid reaction,&equo; said a company spokesman. 
 It is also part of a growing trend. 
 The shares of Campbell Soup jumped &dollar;4.875 to &dollar;38.25 when Mr John Dorrance, the retired chairman and son of the founder of Campbell Soup, died last April at the age of 70. 
 Colleagues described Dorrance as a gentlemanly, compassionate man with a lot of moral commitment. 
 Industry analysts were more interested in the fact that he controlled enough shares in the world's biggest soup maker to veto any takeover bid. 
 They hoped a row between his sisters and his cousins and his aunts would make the company less acquisition-proof. 
 Members of Dorrance's extended family have indeed disagreed in public over whether or not the company should be sold. 
 Quaker Oats has expressed an interest in buying it. 
 So far, Campbell remains independent. 
 Occidental Petroleum is another &bquo;death-watch company&equo;. 
 The shares attracted buyers when Occidental's 91-year-old boss, Dr Armand Hammer, slipped in the bath three years ago. 
 Speculators also think that Peter Grace, 78, head of the conglomerate W.R. Grace, and Mr Lew Wasserman, 77, chairman of the MCA entertainment business, might be more valuable to their companies dead than alive. 
 Investors rushed into the shares of the Amerada Hess oil company when they heard that its chairman Mr Leon Hess, 75, had gone to hospital. 
 They rushed out again when they learnt that the patient was not Mr Hess, but his wife.  
 The drug industry in Japan 
 Sedated by bureaucrats 
 JAPAN'S pharmaceuticals industry is an oddball. 
 Like carmaking and machine-tool manufacture, it grew big and profitable in a protected domestic market, its products have become world class and its firms are trying to go global. 
 Yet the industry is a feeble exporter and will probably always remain so. 
 Why is it so different from other Japanese manufacturers? 
 The answer, according to Mr Michael Reich of the Harvard School of Public Health, is that the industry has been nurtured by an arm of the Japanese government that had no interest in exporting, making it a victim of government intervention. 
 That is a perverse reversal of Japan's controversial government backing for export drives in other industries. 
 In a recent article in the California Management Review, Mr Reich points out that, as a bailiwick of the Ministry of Health and Welfare, the industry was out of bounds to the Ministry of International Trade and Industry (MITI) and so never had bureaucrats helping or prodding it to export. 
 Instead the Japanese drug industry has been shaped by national health policy, whose primary goal was to create a stable supply of up-to-date drugs. 
 The government helped drug makers by keeping out foreigners (though not foreign drugs under licence), limiting competition with heavy regulation and providing firms with substantial profits. 
 That left them little incentive to export. 
 When the aims of the health bureaucrats changed, so did the way drug makers had to operate. 
 It was only when the government started to cut drug prices after 1980, because it wanted to stop health bills rising further as the population greyed, that the drug makers were pushed into thinking about export markets. 
 Until then, Japanese drug firms' poor R&amp;D and their emphasis on selling imported drugs had left them in poor shape to compete internationally. 
 Enervated by years of living fat and happy off a cosy domestic market, firms did not respond to price cuts by trying harder to export, as health bureaucrats had hoped. 
 What did spur them was the invasion by foreign drug multinationals of the Japanese market after restrictions were relaxed in the 1980s. 
 Since then better R&amp;D and new products have made Japanese companies internationally competitive. 
 Yet the export drive predicted for nearly a decade has yet to happen. 
 It may never come. 
 The industry is already seeking to get round its international weaknesses &mdash; particularly one all foreign drug companies face everywhere, dealing with the regulatory complexities of drug approvals &mdash; through licensing agreements with local firms abroad as well as joint ventures, and overseas R&amp;D and production. 
 So instead of an export binge, the industry is more likely to go straight to offshore production in America and Europe. 
 That would be a neat salve for trade friction.  
 East European telecoms 
 Don't hang up 
 WARSAW 
 WHATEVER their politics, Poles expect to wait up to 20 years for a new telephone. 
 Hungarians are used to waiting between five and ten years. 
 Once a telephone has been installed, it is often useless. 
 For several months last winter, residents of Warsaw who had a telephone number beginning with three could not call anyone whose number began with four. 
 Tackling this catastrophe is a top priority for every East European country. 
 They know that luring foreign investors will be impossible if foreigners cannot make telephone calls. 
 With their rudimentary networks, Eastern Europe could leap-frog to the latest technology &mdash; though that is a daydream, given that no country in the region has the expertise or the money to do so. 
 Local telecoms-equipment makers can supply only feeble 1950s gear; and foreign exchange is so scarce that importing fancy western hardware or technology is impossible. 
 Despite this, western companies are queuing up to win contracts. 
 The risk for any foreign telecoms-supplier is enormous, but so are the possible returns. 
 The traditional markets of western equipment companies are growing slowly, if at all. 
 By contrast, forecasts TRC, a British consultant, East European spending on equipment (including Russia's) could double to &dollar;30 billion by 2000, not far behind that of America's. 
 Because of the need for foreigners, East European telecoms markets could become far more open than those in any continental West European country. 
 Every week brings announcements of international deals. 
 The best example is Hungary. 
 It plans to invest &dollar;6 billion-7 billion in its telephone network over the next ten years. 
 It hopes to attract foreign investment and technology by liberalising and privatising the industry and encouraging joint ventures. 
 Hungary plans to sell half of BHG, the country's largest telecoms-equipment manufacturer, to private investors. 
 Last month BHG formed a joint venture with Kapsch and Schrack, two Austrian equipment makers, and Canada's Northern Telecom. 
 Nor does collaboration stop at equipment manufacture. 
 In December last year Hungary signed a contract with US West, one of America's seven local-telephone companies, and Ericsson, a Swedish manufacturer, for a cellular telephone system. 
 Hungary is not alone. 
 Poland is aiming for a type of deregulation akin to America's break-up of AT&amp;T. 
 The government wants to set the technical standards of Poland's public network and to retain the power to set ceilings on consumer prices. 
 But officials insist that Poland's national telephone company, PTTP, will be protected only for a few more years and will then be left to go bankrupt if it cannot compete against privately owned network operators. 
 Like Hungary, Poland is using tax breaks and special currency provisions in an effort to compensate for the lack of a convertible currency. 
 By 1991 Poland plans to allow foreign companies to repatriate 15% of their profits. 
 Such details matter because western telecoms companies can make only limited investments until they know when and how they might gain a return. 
 East European countries are thus competing for the best western companies just as western companies are competing for contracts. 
 Still, western firms look at Eastern Europe as a step towards winning valuable Russian contracts. 
 Going there directly can be hard as Alcatel, a French equipment maker, found out. 
 Last year its deal with Krasnaya Zarya, a Russian equipment producer, was scuppered by Cocom, the international committee that vets the flow of technology to the eastern block. 
 Cocom is more relaxed about Eastern Europe than it is about Russia. 
 Pyramid Research, a Boston-based consultancy, reports that western companies hope to use joint ventures in Eastern Europe to strengthen trading ties with Russia in preparation for the day when Cocom relaxes its controls. 
 Now that the tussle has begun in earnest, the East European telecommunications industry can only grow more confused. 
 Whatever happens Eastern Europe's long-suffering consumers, numbed by a lifetime of busy signals, can only benefit. 
 Crowley and Ericsson, two western firms, claim that only six-nine months and &dollar;100m would be needed to fit seven Polish cities with mobile-telephone networks compatible with the existing systems. 
 Most users would then have to wait only a couple of hours for a new telephone. 
 &bquo;Two hours instead of 20 years,&equo; marvelled a recent Polish newspaper article.  
 Colloring the currency 
 Brazil and Argentina's governments have recently taken drastic steps to wipe out their four-digit inflation rates. 
 Will they succeed? 
 ORTHODOX economists believe that governments can wipe out accelerating inflation only by balancing their budgets and sharply reducing the monetary growth. 
 The snag is that in countries with persistently high inflation hardly anyone holds paper money; instead they put all earnings in index-linked bonds or interest-earning savings accounts. 
 So the only way to squeeze the money supply is to reduce the public's savings. 
 The attempt to do this lies behind Brazil's and Argentina's latest anti-inflation programmes. 
 Brazil's and Argentina's previous anti-inflation plans were based on the belief that high inflation is caused by its own momentum. 
 If workers believe inflation is likely to accelerate, they will demand high enough wages to compensate for expected increases in prices. 
 Businesses will then put up prices to pay for the wage increases. 
 Inflation, if it is accommodated by central banks, spirals upwards. 
 The first of Argentina's and Brazil's more recent batch of anti-inflation programmes, introduced in June 1985 and February 1986, tried to break inflationary expectations by freezing prices, pegging the exchange rate to the dollar, and fixing wages. 
 The hope was that inflation could be arrested by decree, without a fall in output or a cut in living standards. 
 That was the theory. 
 But inflation was also caused by too much purchasing power in the economy. 
 The anti-inflation programmes failed because they hardly cut government spending. 
 The Argentine and Brazilian budget deficits stayed at 7% and 5.5% respectively of GDP in 1987. 
 In early 1986 Argentina's price controls started to slip, and in October of the same year Brazil's crumbled too. 
 Inflation rose soon afterwards. 
 The lesson seemed clear. 
 Any attempt to reduce inflation permanently would require a deep cut in government spending and tight control over the money supply. 
 In January 1989 the Brazilian government seemed to acknowledge this. 
 Its new package, known as the Summer plan, proposed severe cuts in public spending, as well as a wage and price freeze and a new currency. 
 In 1989 direct government expenditure on agricultural and industrial subsidies fell, in dollar terms, by 56% compared with 1988. 
 Despite this, the government was unable to fire many civil servants: Congress objected. 
 In 1989 the central government's salary bill rose by 20% in dollar terms on the previous year. 
 The attempt to reduce liquidity in the economy through high real interest rates was the government's main mistake. 
 In January 1989 outstanding government bonds, whose coupon-rate was tied to the market interest rate, amounted to a hefty &dollar;75 billion. 
 In December 1988 the monthly real interest rate was 0.8%; by the following December it had risen to 4.3%. 
 As real interest rates rose, so did the cost of servicing the government's debt. 
 The central government paid &dollar;20 billion in interest payments and amortisation in 1989, twice as much as it paid in 1988. 
 The owners of the government debt were in large part Brazilian private investors, and (indirectly) those who had savings accounts in banks. 
 As government debts increased, the public became richer, and spent more. 
 Since their savings were completely liquid (ie, they could be withdrawn immediately from banks), they were equivalent to cash. 
 High interest rates thus increased the effective money supply. 
 By April 1989 price controls started to crumble and monthly inflation rose from 5% in March 1989 to 73% this February. 
 Argentina's government failed to arrest inflation for much the same reason. 
 The public held almost all the local currency in seven-day time deposits, which paid a monthly real interest rate of about 10%. 
 The government borrowed from the banks about four-fifths of these deposits, to finance its deficit. 
 As in Brazil, the high real interest rates made the public richer, increased the government deficit, and fuelled inflation. 
 In January President Menem's government unilaterally converted seven-day time deposits over 1m australs (&dollar;560) into ten-year dollar bonds that paid international interest rates. 
 At a stroke the government removed about 70% of the local currency from the economy. 
 But these deposits constituted a small part of the total assets of the Argentines, since most people kept their wealth in dollars. 
 The government started printing more money soon after the savings-freeze and inflation has picked up again. 
 Mr Fernando Collor de Mello, Brazil's new president, plans to eliminate Brazil's savings (or monetary) overhang in two ways. 
 On March 16th he froze savings in excess of 50,000 new cruzados (&dollar;1,000 at the official rate) and four-fifths of funds (or 25,000 new cruzados, whichever is highest) in overnight accounts for 18 months. 
 This amounted to a withdrawal of &dollar;115 billion from the economy, about a third of Brazil's GDP. 
 Second, he proposed to turn the budget deficit of 7% of GDP in 1989 into a surplus of 2% of GDP. 
 Thus the government announced sweeping increases in taxes and cuts in the public sector; it aimed to scrap all the remaining state subsidies, sell off state assets, and fire about 80,000 workers (a small proportion of public employees). 
 The government will auction cruzeiros (the new currency which will replace the cruzado) for the savings in the frozen accounts. 
 The exchange rate will be determined by the demand for the new money and the amount of cruzeiros the government is willing to supply. 
 This will be the critical test for the government. 
 If it auctions off too few cruzeiros, it risks destroying the economy, as there will not be enough money to pay for anything. 
 But if the government sells too many cruzeiros, Brazil's inflation rate will remain high. 
 The Brazilian package combines a liquidity and fiscal squeeze of such austerity that, if it sticks, it will almost certainly wipe out inflation. 
 The drawback to both this and the Argentine scheme is that, having frozen the public's savings, both governments will find it difficult (or expensive) to borrow in the future. 
 Given the history of borrowing by the Brazilian and Argentine governments, this may be no bad thing.  
 Corporate structure 
 Why big might remain beautiful 
 CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS 
 Big companies are out of fashion. 
 But one distinguished academic argues they will continue to dominate world markets for decades to come 
 THE 1990s, say the most fashionable of management gurus, will be the decade of the small, networked company. 
 Layers of management will be stripped away, and all except core functions will be subcontracted to more efficient, specialist firms. 
 Big companies, the argument runs, are inefficient, stifle innovation and dissipate wealth. 
 One dissenting voice is that of Mr Alfred Chandler, emeritus professor of business history at Harvard Business School. 
 Mr Chandler is best known for his book &bquo;The Visible Hand&equo;, published in 1977, which chronicled the rise of managerial capitalism in America and won him a Pulitzer prize. 
 The big industrial company, says Mr Chandler, has been the engine of economic growth for the past 100 years, and will continue to be so for the next 100. 
 This does not mean that big companies cannot fail as frequently as small companies. 
 Indeed their collapse is often more spectacular because of their size. 
 But a ten-year study of 200 large firms in America, West Germany and Britain (the basis for his new book, &bquo;Scale and Scope&equo;, to be published by Harvard University Press in April) has left Mr Chandler convinced that successful companies evolve in remarkably similar ways. 
 And to succeed in the long run, they have to grow big. 
 Mr Chandler argues that the economies of scale and scope bestowed by size have been grossly undervalued by the &bquo;small is beautiful&equo; brigade. 
 In the four years after John D. Rockefeller in 1882 combined 40 oil companies into the Standard Oil Trust (begetter of Exxon, still the world's biggest oil company), scale economies cut refining costs by two-thirds. 
 That gave Standard a stranglehold on the oil market which it might still enjoy had not America's trustbusters split the company up. 
 Equally important are economies of scope: big firms can use the materials and processes employed to make one product in the manufacture of related goods, as Japan's consumer-electronics companies did in the 1970s, using the same factories that had previously churned out cheap transistor radios to manufacture televisions and videos. 
 But size is only a start. 
 If a company is to become enduringly successful, says Mr Chandler, it must make two kinds of what he calls &bquo;first-mover&equo; investments. 
 One is to create national &mdash; preferably international &mdash; marketing and distribution networks. 
 The other is to invest in a hierarchy of managers: lower and middle managers to oversee day-to-day operations, senior managers to coordinate and plan. 
 That hierarchy need not be cosily ensconced at headquarters: it can be the sort of decentralised management network beloved of management gurus such as Mr Tom Peters. 
 But even in a decentralised company, says Mr Chandler, bigness is better. 
 First movers, then, are not always the entrepreneurs who invent a product; but they will be the first to build an organisation which can fully exploit its economies of scale and scope. 
 To compete globally with established first-movers, newcomers have to build plants of comparable size, invest in a similar distribution network and train a rival managerial hierarchy: a tall order. 
 This argument, however, ignores the effects of new technologies on markets. 
 The West's mechanical-typewriter makers were dethroned when Japanese companies like Brother poured electronic models (which employed wholly different manufacturing technologies) into the previously unassailable typewriter markets. 
 But look at the new companies which take the place of the old order, says Mr Chandler: almost all have followed the first-mover formula and grown big. 
 IBM was not the first company to produce mainframe computers (Remington Rand, Raytheon and Philco were all pioneers), but it was the first to make vast first-mover investments in integrated production, distribution and management for the introduction of its System 360 in 1964. 
 By going global before its rivals and by investing heavily in managerial expertise, IBM launched itself as the world's biggest computer company. 
 It still is. 
 Failure to make first-mover investments can scupper industrial potential. 
 William Perkin, an Englishman, invented the first man-made dyes in 1856. 
 Britain had many comparative advantages in dye-making, including plenty of coal (the raw material for dyes) and a vast textile industry. 
 Yet West Germany's Bayer and Hoechst went on to dominate the industry (by 1913 Germany produced 90% of the world's dyes) because, unlike British companies, they made the essential first-mover investments in production, distribution and management. 
 Why, if big remains beautiful, have big companies performed so badly during the past two decades, especially in America and Britain? 
 Firms can easily dissipate their first-mover advantages, as Henry Ford did after the first world war by sacking many of his best senior managers. 
 America's carmakers did much the same in the 1980s by failing to respond to the growing Japanese competition in America's small-car market. 
 But diversification is the main villain. 
 Facing fiercer competition after the second world war, firms found that the fastest way to grow was to diversify. 
 Encouraged by management theorists, big firms convinced themselves that they could apply their existing pool of manufacturing and management experience to any business. 
 But diversifying companies found it much harder to exploit economies of scale and scope in these new fields &mdash; usually, says Mr Chandler, because they failed to make the same kind of first-mover investments they had made in their primary businesses. 
 What diversifiers should have done instead, reckons Mr Chandler (a point on which he is in wholehearted agreement with folk such as Mr Peters), was to concentrate their resources on &bquo;reinventing&equo; their existing businesses. 
 The big chemical companies did just that (after first rashly diversifying) in the 1980s by shifting emphasis from commodity chemicals to pharmaceuticals and biotechnology. 
 The biggest flaw in Mr Chandler's argument is that it applies more readily to industries where fast changes in technology do not seem likely. 
 The small firm needling the big multinational may be only a nuisance for the time being, but if it latches on to a new and successful technology and makes all the right first-mover investments it may be tomorrow's market leader. 
 Minnows who want to become corporate Moby Dicks might take a leaf out of Compaq's book. 
 Founded in 1982, Compaq ran itself from the start as &bquo;a major company in its formative stage&equo;, not just &bquo;a small company with big plans&equo;. 
 It is now America's eleventh-biggest computer maker. 
 FINANCE 
 Hard times for Japan's corporate cash-raisers 
 TOKYO 
 THE clobbering of their portfolios by Tokyo's tumbling stockmarket (down 23% on the Nikkei index since January) has made 1990 a terrible year for those Japanese companies that dabble in stocks as a way of boosting their business profits. 
 Now many are finding that their access to cheap capital is being painfully squeezed as well. 
 This week Japan's four leading brokerages (Nomura, Daiwa, Nikko and Yamaichi) agreed to stop issuing and underwriting new shares, convertible bonds and warrant bonds by Japanese companies for at least a month. 
 The securities firms are trying to prop up the tumbling stockmarket by cutting the supply of new issues. 
 On March 22nd the market reacted by falling a further 3.1%, which took the Nikkei index below 30,000 for the first time since December 1988 to close at 29,843. 
 The big four have asked all Japanese corporations with equity-financing plans to postpone them for the time being. 
 Sumitomo Metal Industries agreed to shelve its &yen;300 billion warrant-bond issue. 
 Nintendo, a video-games maker, pulled its issue of convertible bonds. 
 Yasuda Fire &amp; Marine cancelled its plans for offering 50m new shares. 
 Even before the securities houses announced their decision, the advantages of issuing new equity had slumped along with the Nikkei. 
 This has been a favourite route in the past five years when Japanese companies have needed money to build new factories or buy assets abroad. 
 They have been issuing equity instruments (eg, convertible bonds and warrant bonds) on the capital markets rather than going to their bank managers for costly old-fashioned loans. 
 It has usually cost them less than 0.5% to raise capital by issuing dollar-denominated warrants (ie, Eurobonds with warrants that give the buyer the right to buy the shares at fixed prices in four or five years' time) in London and then using swaps to get the money back into yen. 
 That has been much nicer than paying the 5% or so charged on bank loans even when interest rates in Japan were at a record low. 
 Since March 20th, when the Bank of Japan raised its discount rate by a further 1% (to 5.25%), the banks have been warning corporate customers that loans will now cost more than 7%. 
 While the stockmarket was rising steadily, even companies stuffed with cash rushed to issue equity. 
 Toyota has so much cash that it could be mistaken for a mini-bank, not a carmaker. 
 Since 1986 it has raised &yen;843 billion (&dollar;5.6 billion) by issuing convertible bonds in Japan and warrant bonds in Europe (see table on next page). 
 In the past financial year companies listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE) raised a staggering &yen;25 trillion through various forms of equity financing &mdash; up 65% over the previous year. 
 Now, as interest rates go up, the cult of equity ends too. 
 Matsushita, a giant consumer-electronics group, recently postponed an issue that was planned to raise &yen;150 billion. 
 Then a large supermarket chain, Seiyu, shelved its &yen;45 billion issue. 
 A similar issue expected from an office-automation manufacturer, Ricoh, was also abandoned. 
 Dozens of other companies have fled the capital markets. 
 Financing woes have even spread to the steel industry &mdash; which until now has always enjoyed special treatment from the banks, brokerages and officialdom. 
 Sumitomo Metal Industries, Japan's third-largest steel company, has abandoned at least the first phase of a big refinancing scheme. 
 Kawasaki Steel is now saying that it might have to do the same. 
 Despite its enormous restructuring problems, Big Steel has not been Japan's greatest raiser of cash. 
 Japanese banks have gobbled up more, and until recently accounted for around half of all equity capital raised by Japanese companies. 
 Over the past two years Japan's five largest city (ie, national commercial) banks raised &yen;3 trillion (&dollar;21 billion) in total &mdash; to help them meet the new capital-adequacy requirements set under the auspices of the Bank for International Settlements (BIS). 
 With their low capital ratios (ie, equity as a proportion of assets), Japanese banks were accused in the mid-1980s of unfair competition for international clients. 
 By March 1993, under new BIS rules, banks wishing to do business internationally must have a capital-to-asset ratio of at least 8%. 
 Even though they still have three years to go before the BIS deadline, Japan's five leading city banks (Dai-Ichi Kangyo, Sumitomo, Fuji, Mitsubishi and Sanwa) have all cleared the 8% hurdle. 
 The cash was raised when share prices soared. 
 The peak was reached on December 29th at 38,916 on the Nikkei. 
 The most aggressive of the bunch, Sumitomo Bank, has issued some &yen;930 billion (&dollar;6.6 billion) in fresh equity and convertible bonds, and now has a capital-adequacy ratio of 10.6%. 
 All Japanese banks want to be in Sumitomo's shoes. 
 To be on the safe side, they feel that they need to have equity ratios of at least a percentage point or two above the BIS minimum. 
 But the falling yen is now making that especially hard to achieve on the sinking stockmarket. 
 Over a third of the banks' assets are denominated in foreign currencies, and particularly in dollars. 
 Each time the yen slips, the larger these dollar-based assets loom in the banks' balance sheets &mdash; and the more they have to scrounge for additional yen-based equity at home in order to prevent their capital-adequacy figures from slipping back below the BIS requirement. 
 Japanese banks are also hard hit by the steady rise in interest rates. 
 Where once the banks had access to regulated supplies of cheap money, they now have to raise nearly 70% of their funds in the open market. 
 Since last May, when the Bank of Japan ended its easy-money policy, there have been four increases in the official discount rate (from 2.5% to 5.25%). 
 The impact of these rises on the banks' cost of funds has been sobering. 
 For nearly nine months now, money-market instruments (eg, call money and discount bills) have had higher interest rates than even the yields on ten-year government bonds. 
 Whenever the so-called yield gap (long minus short rates) goes negative, and stays so for longer than two business quarters, past experience suggests that the banks get badly bruised. 
 Analysts' best guesses are that the underlying operating profits of the big city banks will be down by as much as 30% for the financial year now ending. 
 Normally, they would seek to make that up by selling some of their huge holdings of securities. 
 But the banks do not cherish the thought of being distressed sellers in a declining stockmarket. 
 &bquo;What this all means,&equo; says Mr Stuart Matthews of Barclays de Zoete Wedd's Tokyo branch, &bquo;is that the banks will find it increasingly difficult to raise large amounts of equity.&equo; 
 All of them (bar Sumitomo Bank) still need to raise additional capital. 
 To do so, they will have to issue a good deal more paper than they would normally like. 
 The market will have difficulty in mopping this all up. 
 So some banks will be forced to rely on retained earnings for shoring up their capital-adequacy ratios &mdash; unless they are ready to put up with a much slower growth in assets (which few seem prepared to do). 
 Mr Matthews reckons that about half of the banks' retained earnings comes from securities gains. 
 Even when the stockmarket was soaring, the Bank of Japan was unhappy about letting the banks rely on securities profits for bolstering their capital bases. 
 With the Tokyo stockmarket in retreat, the central bank is likely to be even more leery about this now.  
 Wall Street worriers 
 New York has so far ignored Tokyo's woes. 
 Optimistic investors hope that America's economic growth is picking up, which would be good news for company profits. 
 They are probably wrong 
 FOR the first time since April 1987 America's stockmarket is again bigger than Japan's. 
 New York overtook Tokyo on March 19th when its stockmarket (as tracked by Morgan Stanley Capital International) was capitalised at &dollar;1.8 trillion compared with falling Tokyo's &dollar;1.7 trillion. 
 American investors feel that their domestic economy is not as weak as they previously feared. 
 The Dow Jones industrial average closed on March 20th at 2,739, not far below its all-time high of 2,810 on January 2 1990, and well above this year's low of 2,553. 
 Bulls argue there are increasing signs that America's manufacturers may be pulling out of last year's recession, when the whole economy kept growing only because of the dominant service industries. 
 In the third and fourth quarters of 1989 after-tax profits of companies in the Standard &amp; Poor's 500 index were respectively 24% and 13% below those of a year before. 
 In the first three months of 1990, the guess is that they were again about 13% lower than in the first quarter of 1989, but there are now hopes that it was the last drop for a while. 
 Mr Stefan Abrams, an investment analyst at Kidder Peabody, thinks earnings will start rising again in the second quarter. 
 He says that the airline and motor industries have seen their worst, that semiconductor orders are rising (IBM's share price is up by 10% so far this year), and prices of metals such as aluminium and copper have rallied. 
 The American stockmarket now trades on a not-cheap price-earnings ratio of 14 based on Wall Street's profit estimates for 1990. 
 Rising expectations of stronger economic growth have helped keep the dollar relatively strong.The snag is that a stronger economy might mean higher inflation and therefore higher interest rates. 
 That prospect has been worrying bond investors. 
 Long-term Treasury-bond yields were as low as 7.75% towards the end of 1989. 
 Bond prices have since fallen and yields risen, partly because of inflation worries, but more because of a worldwide liquidity squeeze which has caused bond yields to rise virtually everywhere. 
 The 30-year Treasury bond yielded 8.45% on March 20th. 
 Consumer prices in February rose by a larger-than-expected 0.5%, or an annualised rate of 5.8%. 
 Wall Street is starting to wonder how long the Federal Reserve can continue to ignore such evidence of rising inflation, despite pressure from the White House to lower interest rates. 
 The markets are sending the opposite message to the Fed. 
 Bond yields are above the federal funds rate of 8.25%. 
 That suggests monetary policy may be too easy, not too tight. 
 The stockmarket is vulnerable to any hint of Fed tightening and higher interest rates. 
 So far these prospects are not discounted. 
 Shares yield only around 3%, 5.5 percentage points below the return on Treasury bonds. 
 Such a gap is justified only if company earnings start improving in the months ahead. 
 Fed tightening could deliver a blow to such hopes. 
 Given Wall Street's wild swings of mood, the fears of recession that were dominant there barely two months ago, and have now see-sawed back to hopes of recovery, could so easily see-saw back. 
 The scope for share prices to rise further looks limited. 
 If the economy is picking up steam, the recovery may be nipped in the bud by renewed Fed tightening. 
 If the economy is weaker than it now appears &mdash; because, as some economists suggest, the government's data have been inflated by unseasonably warm weather in January and February &mdash; then shares could fall sharply to reflect continued declines in company earnings. 
 A third possibility is stagflation, where the economy refuses to recover but the rate of inflation does not fall, so reducing the central bank's ability to ease credit. 
 So far the Fed has talked tougher about inflation than it has acted. 
 But its chairman, Mr Alan Greenspan, and other Fed governors have begun to remind financial markets that inflation, not recession, remains their main problem. 
 Any hint of Fed tightening could cause even more chaos than usual, because of the precarious condition of much of America's financial and property markets: the legacy of the huge growth in debt during the 1980s, and the main cause of worry now. 
 Even if manufacturing America looks relatively healthy, financial America does not. 
 The glum symptoms range from junk-bond distress to the destruction of wealth caused by falling property values and the thrifts debacle. 
 Banks are under pressure from zealous regulators to raise reserves against shaky loans, and to be cautious about making new loans. 
 As a result, banks want to lend money only to the most creditworthy. 
 The results of the banks' self-imposed credit rationing, and of the mounting creditor distress, are beginning to show in the leap in outstanding commercial paper issued by non-financial companies. 
 This has jumped to more than &dollar;140 billion, from &dollar;125 billion in late November. 
 Much of the rise in commercial paper outstanding is a counterpart to the decline in bank lending. 
 Since November commercial and industrial loans at America's money-centre banks have fallen by about &dollar;6 billion. 
 In January 1990 the total debt of government, business and consumers in America was 7.6% higher than a year before. 
 That was the lowest rate of increase since March 1971, but was still faster than the growth in money supply. 
 M3 is rising at just 3.3% year-to-year. 
 Ms Nancy Lazar, an economist at C.J. Lawrence, views this as a better measure than M2, which is growing at a faster 6.1% year-on-year: deposits have been flowing out of savings and loan institutions, which do not show up in M2, and into banks, which do. 
 Slowing growth in debt and money-supply should both be contractionary influences on the economy, and ones that are doubly bearish for the stockmarket. 
 The 1980s boom was fuelled by rapid growth of debt. 
 Between 1982 and 1989 non-financial debt as a percentage of America's GNP rose from 140% to 185%. 
 Previously this ratio had remained stable for more than 20 years. 
 If the growth of debt continues to slow, either because banks grow more cautious or because borrowed money cannot be paid back and has to be written off, this will send share prices lower. 
 The extent of the fall will depend on how far liquidity contracts.  
 Midland Bank 
 A battered bride 
 BRITAIN'S third-biggest clearing bank looks fit more for a wake than a wedding. 
 If Midland does tie the knot with Hongkong and Shanghai Bank, it may need some help up the aisle. 
 The bank, which has assets of &pound;62 billion (&dollar;100m), is Britain's sickest high-street bank. 
 Midland reported a loss of &pound;261m in 1989. 
 Even before provisions against third-world debt and local-authority swaps, Midland made only &pound;616m in 1989 &mdash; 11% less than a year earlier. 
 Almost three years after his appointment as chairman and chief executive, Sir Kit McMahon has still not solved any of Midland's three core problems: a big third-world-debt portfolio, high costs, and low-yielding assets. 
 Compare Lloyds Bank, the smallest of the big-four clearers, with Midland. 
 Lloyds has assets of &pound;57.5 billion and last year made a profit, before principal third-world-debt provisions, of &pound;910m. 
 Midland, with &pound;5 billion more in assets, could only make two-thirds as much profit as Lloyds. 
 Such weakness stops Midland from generating much-needed capital: it can retain a mere &pound;300m this year. 
 Lloyds generated more than &pound;450m. 
 Not surprising, Midland's balance sheet looks ropey. 
 Even after the &pound;383m the bank got from selling a 14.9% stake in itself to the Hongkong Bank and the &pound;1.1 billion it raised from a rights issue and the sale of its Scottish and Irish banks, Midland still struggles to keep its third-world debt provisions up to the level of its rivals. 
 Over the past year the bank has managed to raise its provisions from 30% to 50% of its loans to poor countries while rivals have hiked theirs to the 70% level. 
 Its third-world debts of &pound;4.3 billion still leave Midland vulnerable to non-performing loans. 
 Midland's cost-to-income ratio is at 72.4%; all its big clearing-bank rivals have ratios under 67%. 
 The income side of the ratio has also let Midland down. 
 Midland Montagu, the bank's investment-banking arm, has mismatched its books, betting on a fall in British interest rates when in fact they rose. 
 That cost Midland about &pound;100m last year. 
 Except in the unlikely event that rates soon plummet, it could cost the bank up to &pound;100m this year. 
 Since his arrival, Sir Kit McMahon has shunned the clearing-bank careerists who traditionally peppered Midland's senior ranks. 
 The trouble is that his men have done just as badly as the old guard. 
 Mr George Louden, a former managing director of Holland's Amro Bank, presided over Midland Montagu's celebrated mismatch. 
 Mr Gene Lockhart, a brash American former management consultant, was made head of Midland's computer-systems and group operations in 1987. 
 The bank's rationalisation programme has still not yielded the &pound;200m of savings hoped for. 
 In 1988 Mr Kevin Gavaghan was brought in from the Burton Group, a British clothes retailer, to be the bank's marketing director. 
 His flashy marketing campaigns have done little for the success of Midland's new products. 
 Even Midland's star turn &mdash; domestic banking, which increased its profit from &pound;418m in 1987 to &pound;500m last year &mdash; is beginning to falter. 
 In 1989 Midland increased its domestic banking division's bad-debt charges by 53%, from &pound;51m in 1988 to &pound;78m. 
 Midland's domestic provisions, at 1.1% of domestic assets, are now the highest among the high-street banks. 
 With its main shareholders, M&amp;G, a unit-trust group, which owns 6.9%, and the Kuwait Investment Office (10%), already nursing losses, Midland seems likely to be heading for the altar before long. 
 Whether the Hongkong Bank will be the one waiting is a mooter question.  
 Hip hype 
 DON'T get into PR, get into IR: Investor Relations. 
 That is the message from a growing band of crisp-cuffed investment-bankers-turned-IR folk. 
 Three such smoothies recently opened the doors of their brand-new consultancy, Frew Dale Macmaster, in London's Harley Street, better known for medical doctors than image surgeons. 
 Investors still need convincing that such firms offer more than mere placebos. 
 IR was born in America in the 1940s to service the nation's host of small private investors (47m of them at the latest count). 
 The first shareholder-relations programmes, run by AT&amp;T and General Electric, consisted simply of a telephone-answering service for routine inquiries. 
 Now IR is big business. 
 The National Investor Relations Institute (NIRI) lists 2,250 members, 20% of whom are consultants. 
 These people no longer chat up Joe Blow of Idaho: they talk to Wall Street analysts and to serious-money managers across America. 
 In Britain investor-relations consultants are newer. 
 They blossomed in the 1980s, thanks to: 
 Surging mergers and acquisitions &mdash; &pound;21 billion (&dollar;33 billion) worth of British companies were taken over in 1989, compared with &pound;6.3 billion five years earlier. 
 Growing institutional shareholder power (pension-fund assets shot up from &pound;40 billion in 1979 to &pound;250 billion in 1989). 
 A healthy distrust since Big Bang in October 1986 of stockbrokers' research. 
 Investor-relations people dress up their jobs, as well as their persons, to the nines. 
 Shares, goes the patter, are products like any other and so deserve the same marketing effort. 
 What Mr Chris Meakin, head of investor relations at B.A.T Industries, says he aims for is a &bquo;congruence of expectations&equo; between investor and management. 
 Aha. 
 Spoil-sports maintain that IR is merely a new name for what companies have been muddling along at anyway: arranging meetings between management and institutions, co-ordinating the annual general meeting, and producing the annual report. 
 IR folk claim they do it better. 
 The institutions that the finance director talks to are chosen on the basis of detailed share-register research, rather than who is free for lunch. 
 Roadshows get slicker &mdash; at the fun ones shareholders enter quizzes and win safaris. 
 Analysts' presentations happen at the dolphinarium rather than in a boring hotel. 
 What do investors think of it all? 
 Not much, it seems. 
 When big investors get on the telephone they expect to be put through to the chairman, not &bquo;lumbered into a PR-type department&equo;. 
 Of 60 fund managers asked last year, 55 did not regard IR officers as their primary company contacts; 33 thought that British industry did not need any more IR consultants.  
 Hongkong and Shanghai Banking Corporation 
 A suitor of convenience 
 HONGKONG 
 Merging Midland, Britain's third-biggest and feeblest bank, with Asia's biggest non-Japanese bank, Hongkong and Shanghai, might solve immediate problems for both. 
 But it could also create a sprawling bank with a mountain of bad debt. 
 These two articles look at the banks' problems 
 WHAT would you do if you were chairman of Hongkong and Shanghai Bank? 
 Your bank dominates the profitable Hongkong retail market, with its population of hard-working small businessmen and savers. 
 It has a lucrative niche financing trade in the world's fastest-growing economic region. 
 On the other hand, you cannot get much bigger in Hongkong; some of Asia's strongest economies are closed to foreign banks; and what will happen to your base and best source of profits after Hongkong returns to Chinese rule in 1997? 
 Mr William Purves, the bank's chairman since 1987, has decided to stick to a strategy developed in the late 1970s. 
 The bank then decided that remaining a regional bank was too risky, so it should try to become an international one. 
 During the 1980s it bought Marine Midland, a commercial bank based in upstate New York; Carroll, McEntee &amp; McGinley (CM&amp;M), a primary dealer in American Treasury bonds; and James Capel, a London firm of stockbrokers. 
 It also tried to buy the Royal Bank of Scotland, but was blocked by the Bank of England, ending up instead with a 14.9% stake in Midland. 
 None of these investments has yet made a decent return. 
 Hongkong Bank steered clear of the mania to lend to third-world countries that peaked in the early 1980s. 
 But through Marine Midland and its stake in Britain's Midland Bank, it is exposed to dodgy third-world debt, as well as to the tumbling property market in north-east America and the troubled British economy. 
 The bank's other forays have not been any more successful. 
 CM&amp;M and James Capel, with their highly competitive markets, both barely break even. 
 On March 21st, exasperated by James Capel's performance but also peeved that it was seeking a fresh (Japanese) parent, Hongkong Bank forced Capel's popular chairman, Mr Peter Quinnen, to resign. 
 A push to build a banking business from scratch in Australia has ended in near-disaster. 
 Its list of down-under clients is embarrassing: Mr Christopher Skase's defunct media conglomerate, Qintex; a bankrupt trans-Tasmanian property developer, Equiticorp; Rothwell's, a dud Perth-based merchant bank; the fraud-ridden National Safety Council of Victoria; and Mr Alan Bond, to whom the bank is thought to have had almost &dollar;1 billion in loans outstanding at the peak, a figure now cut by half. 
 Of all its international forays, only Hongkong Bank of Canada has been a clear success. 
 But it is too late to turn back the clock on the bank's international expansion. 
 The change in the outlook for Hongkong following last June's massacre in Tiananmen Square demands that Hongkong Bank be able to negotiate with a future Chinese government from a position of strength. 
 History suggests that Hongkong Bank should expect the worst after 1997; it lost all but one of its 33 branches in mainland China in 1949. 
 Europe remains the big hole to plug in its international strategy. 
 The bank looked at 30 possible acquisitions there after the Bank of England opposed its 1981 bid for Royal Bank of Scotland. 
 All were either too expensive or too narrowly based. 
 Then in 1987 Midland Bank got itself in such a mess that it was on the receiving end of a laughable offer from the Saatchi &amp; Saatchi advertising empire. 
 Midland accepted help from a more natural partner. 
 Hongkong Bank bought a 14.9% stake in Midland, paying &pound;4.75 a share (Midland's shares price is now &pound;3.43). 
 It signed a standstill agreement under which it promised not to increase its holding for three years. 
 Both agreed to explore possible areas of co-operation. 
 That agreement expires in November. 
 Mr Purves is tight-lipped about what happens then. 
 He recently vexed rumour-mongers, who bet on a bid for Midland sooner rather than later, by declining to disclose Hongkong Bank's inner reserves when the bank reported its 1989 results on March 13th. 
 The Bank of England will require such disclosure if Hongkong Bank wants to take over or merge with Midland. 
 Mr Purves revealed on March 13th that the bank's property holdings had been revalued in the group's balance sheet at HK&dollar;13.8 billion (&dollar;1.8 billion) &mdash; over twice most analysts' estimates. 
 This surplus lifted disclosed shareholders' funds to HK&dollar;52.7 billion. 
 Add the two together, throw in HK&dollar;13 billion of hidden reserves and Hongkong Bank's &bquo;true&equo; shareholders' funds could be HK&dollar;78 billion, or over HK&dollar;13 a share, against a stockmarket price of HK&dollar;7. 
 Such a revaluation might make a paper and cash offer for the remaining 85% of Midland's shares feasible. 
 However, the Bank of England would probably insist that, in the event of such a bid, Hongkong Bank became a British bank. 
 A preferable alternative for both sides would be a merger. 
 One way would be to form a holding company to which both banks would issue shares in proportion to their shareholders' funds. 
 This would enable Hongkong Bank to avoid paying a packet for goodwill and for it to remain a Hongkong bank while Midland remained British. 
 Hongkong Bank is determined to be the senior partner after any merger. 
 Grafting its expatriate Scottish culture onto Midland's stay-at-home heritage could be hard. 
 Hongkong Bank's backbone is a cadre of 450 &bquo;international officers&equo; &mdash; mostly Anglo-Saxon males (or Scottish-accented Celts). 
 All the people who matter know each other well and so can take decisions fast. 
 This tradition of fostering decentralised decisions and a degree of buccaneering, safeguarded by a highly conservative balance sheet, has enabled Hongkong Bank to prosper in the fast-wheeling markets of Asia. 
 It is the only one of the old British colonial banks to have made good in the modern world. 
 Midland could be its passport for survival after 1997 &mdash; though, like all Hongkong passports these days, a costly one.  
 EMU and the European Commission 
 View from a room 
 BRUSSELS 
 A YEAR after the European Community's central-bank governors produced what is known as the Delors report on economic and monetary union, the European Commission has at last written its own credo on EMU. 
 The commission's plan, which is to be discussed by EC finance ministers at the end of March, sticks closely to the Delors report with one big exception. 
 It drops central bankers' insistence on centrally-set rules for members' budget deficits. 
 The paper's final wording is a classic piece of commission fudge. 
 No centrally imposed rules on countries' budgetary policy; instead, there will be &bquo;binding procedures&equo;. 
 Governments would have to submit to the council of finance ministers rules or guidelines on budgetary policy that would go into national law. 
 These would have to be stringent enough to ensure that the country's borrowing did not put pressure on national or Community interest rates. 
 The commission hopes that peer-group pressure would persuade member states to comply with the council's rulings on their budgetary plans, which would be taken on a majority vote. 
 But if a country refused to implement good enough budget rules, the Community would apply penalties, eg, the withholding of EC regional funds. 
 This does not sound much more liberal than the old idea of binding rules. 
 The difference, says a senior commission official, is that &bquo;binding procedures&equo; means interfering only with the real basket-cases (a euphemism for Greece, Italy and Belgium, which respectively run budget deficits of 19%, 10%, and 6% of their GDPs). 
 But there is no question, says the official, that &bquo;budgetary sovereignty must be given up.&equo; 
 Why? 
 The commission accepts that one country's excessive borrowing would not bust the EMU apart. 
 But it thinks that to rely solely on market forces is a messy way of reining in a big borrower. 
 Markets can take time to wake up to excesses, and in the meantime over-borrowing by one member-state could cause a lot of pain for others. 
 And when, eventually, market forces do take effect they can correct too sharply. 
 One proposal by the commission would reduce the market's chances of working efficiently. 
 The Community would &bquo;have no obligation to rescue a member state in budgetary difficulty&equo;. 
 But the commission does not exclude the possibility of a bail-out, and says that the EC might provide conditional assistance. 
 This makes it less likely that investors would encourage a dissolute borrower to mend its ways by withholding finance. 
 Mr Jacques Delors has another reason for favouring binding procedures. 
 He believes in the need for a Community macroeconomic policy. 
 He wants countries to be made to co-ordinate their fiscal policies so that monetary policy does not have to take take all the strain. 
 Mr Delors claims that &bquo;binding procedures&equo; do not break the principle of &bquo;subsidiarity&equo; &mdash; the idea that decisions should be taken at EC level only when it makes sense to do so. 
 The transfer of budgetary sovereignty would help EMU work more smoothly. 
 Yet for those &mdash; including many British politicians &mdash; who reckon EMU would work adequately without binding procedures, the commission's plan sacrifices subsidiarity.  
 Gobble, gobble, squawk 
 IF THE Hongkong and Shanghai Bank goes ahead with a takeover of Midland Bank, it may have to replace the pair of bronze lions that grace the entrance to its headquarters with a more appropriate symbol &mdash; such as a couple of ducks. 
 A new study of bank takeovers in America in the 1980s* indicates that four out of five acquisitions are flops. 
 They fail to benefit the acquiring bank and destroy some of its value. 
 The study was conducted for the Bank Administrative Institute, an industry think-tank, by FMCG Capital Strategies, a financial-services consultancy. 
 It covers some 400 of the biggest bank takeovers between 1922 and 1988. 
 The study's main measure of an acquisition's success is the subsequent course of the acquirer's share price compared with the share-price movement of a group of similar banks. 
 For banks that fall prey to others, the study finds, the experience was in one sense rewarding. 
 The value of the shares in a hypothetical portfolio of acquired banks rose by 420% over the period studied, against a 160% increase for a portfolio of wallflower banks. 
 For the banks doing the taking over, it is a different story. 
 Instead of vulture banks, the study suggests that turkeys might be a better name for those whose stock prices were on average 15% lower than that of their peer group &mdash; or dead ducks for those 25% lower. 
 The study's long-term tracking of the impact of acquisitions suggests that 80% of the acquiring banks fall into one of these two categories (in a ratio of three to two respectively). 
 Only one in five was an eagle, ie, its share price soared above that of its peer group. 
 Five and six years after an acquisition, the average acquiring bank's share price is 30&ndash;40% lower than that of its peer group and the acquirer is likely to be taken over. 
 The FMCG study says there are four key preconditions for eagle acquisitions. 
 First, the acquiring bank should be strong in controlling its non-interest expenses. 
 Second, the price paid for the acquisition must not be excessive. 
 The study recommends that the acquired bank's discounted cash flow following the acquisition must exceed the price paid for it, for the acquisition to be considered reasonable value. 
 Third, the target bank's business mix must contain the inherent value to repay the premium that the acquirer will have to pay to make the takeover successful. 
 And last, the closer the target bank is to the acquirer, the better the chance of value creation, because expense control is more easily managed. 
 If there is some consolation for bankers amidst all this destruction of value, it is that for some eagles practice makes better, if not perfect. 
 A flock of American eagles have successfully made more than one takeover. 
 They include First of America, First Union, United Jersey and five super regionals &mdash; Wells Fargo, Banc One, Fleet/Norstar, Barnett and Midlantic.  
 * &bquo;Analyzing Success and Failure in Banking Consolidation: The Implications for Bank Acquisition Strategies.&equo; 
 Bank Administration Institute. 
 1990.  
 London's stock exchange 
 Hobson's option 
 THE traded-options market in London could be about to play Lithuania to the stock exchange's Russia. 
 A score of the City's biggest securities houses would like to tear the options market (LTOM) from the giant and bureaucratic International Stock Exchange (ISE), which many feel has smothered LTOM since its inception in 1978. 
 Curiously, some bits of another bureaucracy, the Bank of England, are encouraging the secessionists. 
 LTOM has never established itself in the way that foreign counterparts have done. 
 One barometer of health &mdash; LTOM's volume of contracts traded compared with the volume of underlying stocks &mdash; is less than half of that at the European Options Exchange in Amsterdam or the Chicago Board Options Exchange. 
 LTOM has failed to entice private clients, who account for only 20% of its business but are the lifeblood of options markets overseas. 
 And it has failed to capitalise on London's dominant position in financial Europe. 
 Thus the market is now a money-loser: it needs 47,000 contracts a day to break even, but manages barely 30,000. 
 There is bad blood between the options market's leading dealing firms and the stock exchange. 
 The dealers say that barely anyone on the ISE's ruling council has experience in the derivatives markets. 
 They resent the ISE's bungling negotiations over a logical merger between LTOM and LIFFE, London's financial-futures exchange. 
 Rather than confront the exchange's Byzantine politics again to try to revive the merger talks, a nascent derivatives association is considering starting a brand-new options market, possibly under LIFFE's arm &mdash; or even with the European Options Exchange. 
 Any such declaration of independence would be a blow to the ISE's reputation, at a time when the exchange is trying to reform itself. 
 On March 19th a long-awaited report on reforms to the domestic-equity market was presented to the exchange council by a committee chaired by Mr Nigel Elwes of S.G. Warburg. 
 Two of the report's main proposals concern the use of a central limit-order system, and the use of a &bquo;green strip&equo;, whereby small-customer orders automatically go to the market-maker offering the best advertised price. 
 (At present, securities houses offer their private clients the best price in the market, even if they are not offering it on their screens.) 
 Such systems are designed to re-establish a central market in British shares. 
 They would show that the private client is still loved in today's institutional world. 
 Yet some big securities houses are up in arms over the Elwes report. 
 They feel that these systems are expensive and unnecessary, especially since they undermine firms' existing facilities for small orders. 
 In the council meeting, Kleinwort Benson and UBS Phillips &amp; Drew objected strongly to the two proposals. 
 Also an agency broker objected to a proposal that orders currently crossed within a firm be exposed to market-makers first. 
 Nor is there a guarantee that the Office of Fair Trading, an old sparring partner of the exchange, will take kindly to some proposals. 
 As well as steering the Elwes report through all the flak, the ISE's new chief executive, Mr Peter Rawlins, has to oversee a reorganisation of the exchange's businesses. 
 That will mean cutting the jobs of one in ten of the ISE's 2,800 staff, and the creation of three new divisions. 
 Each with their own board, they will oversee primary markets, trading markets (where the ISE's domestic- and international-share systems will eventually be crunched together), and settlement. 
 Under the new arrangements, due for approval on April 2nd, the traded-options market will in theory gain more autonomy by falling outside this structure. 
 That is unlikely to be enough to appease the secessionists. 
 EASTERN EUROPE MOVES RIGHT 
 No halfway house 
 Having thrown out communism, East Europeans are rejecting social democracy too. 
 But there are worse things to be avoided than that 
 IT SEEMS an age, but only months ago democratic socialists in Eastern Europe thought they would gain from communism's fall. 
 People wanted to be rid of neo-Stalinist regimes, they argued, but were not eager for cut-throat capitalism. 
 They were mistaken. 
 Given the chance last Sunday, East Germans not only dished the communist would-be reformers who succeeded Erich Hon-ecker but the civil-rights campaigners who had brought his wretched regime down and the Social Democrats who hoped to replace them both. 
 The hopes of the left across Eastern Europe were dashed. 
 Its citizens have seen how the capitalist half of Europe lives and they want a share. 
 True, East Germany is special. 
 It is taking a short cut to the consumer society that other East Europeans cannot take, by collapsing into West Germany's arms. 
 But voters in the rest of Eastern Europe too may well be looking for prosperity first from right-wing parties. 
 Communists and Social Democrats are struggling in Hungary, where a two-round parliamentary election starts on March 25th. 
 In Romania, the government led by the reform communists who overthrew the dictatorship of Ceausescu has made so many mistakes that it may get a bad surprise in the parliamentary and presidential elections on May 20th. 
 Czechoslovakia's voters will choose a new parliament on June 8th. 
 Communists, Socialists and other left-wing parties there are trailing behind the umbrella reform group, Civic Forum, which is running the government in the meantime. 
 Poland's next general election is not due until 1993, but there are local ones on May 27th &mdash; and meanwhile the government is already well set on the capitalist road. 
 Even Bulgaria has promised free elections, though not yet set a date. 
 All this has come in a quite unexpected rush. 
 For most of the past two years, after the first cracks in the ice were heard, Eastern Europe's future used to be seen something like this. 
 Reform communists would gradually open up power and share government with non-communist opponents. 
 Competition would slowly replace planning. 
 Private ownership would grow gradually, with small firms multiplying even as big ones stayed in state hands. 
 A few economists dared to imagine an eventual move to a full market economy, but hardly anyone thought this would happen quickly. 
 Instead, many reformers continued to talk, at least in public, of an East European &bquo;third way&equo; between Soviet communism and western capitalism. 
 But last year history left gradualism behind. 
 In one country after another, &bquo;reform communism&equo; proved empty. 
 Once the Soviet veto on change was withdrawn, there was suddenly no stopping point halfway. 
 Communist power collapsed. 
 Democratic socialists began to ask themselves if there really was a &bquo;middle road&equo;. 
 There may be. 
 But it is not one that voters seem much interested in. 
 The straight road west 
 The upheaval began in Poland, where governments had avoided direct Russian intervention by snuffing out change themselves, in 1956, 1970 and again in 1981. 
 In the semi-free election last June, all but one of 100 seats in the upper house went to Solidarity-backed candidates. 
 The same would have happened in the lower house if Solidarity's share of seats had not been limited in advance to 35%. 
 In the aftershock, the communists' allies there deserted them for Solidarity. 
 A new government under Mr Tadeusz Mazowiecki, the first non-communist prime minister in 40 years, took over in September, committed to sweeping free-market reforms more reminiscent of Latin America than Sweden. 
 When Czechoslovakia's quiet revolution came last November, reform communism was on the menu for less than a week. 
 The Communist party had kicked out most reformers after Warsaw Pact tanks put an end to the Prague Spring in 1968. 
 In the meantime, the reformists' belief in socialist answers had wavered. 
 The new president was not Alexander Dubcek, spokesman of &bquo;socialism with a human face&equo;, but Vaclav Havel, one of the founders of the human-rights movement Charter 77. 
 In Hungary, reform communism of a sort had existed ever since the Russians crushed the October uprising in 1956. 
 Janos Kadar, who led Hungary from then till 1988, offered some cultural and economic freedom in return for obedience to Moscow. 
 His successors, who have presided over the past year's changes, hoped they too could massage their way to keeping power. 
 Reformers led by Mr Imre Pozsgay and Mr Rezso Nyers changed even the communist party's name. 
 People still turned their backs. 
 These men are bitterly wondering why they have not had more thanks for nursing Hungary towards democracy. 
 Economic ideas have changed in step. 
 &bquo;Not long ago, we thought the important thing was to remove industry from state control, not ownership,&equo; says Mr Marton Tardos of the Free Democrats, Hungary's free-market liberal party. 
 The idea of a market economy based on private property was taboo. 
 All sorts of alternatives were canvassed: worker-management, worker ownership, &bquo;social ownership&equo;, under which public services like health and transport would own industrial shares. 
 Yugoslavia's worker-management was once offered as a model. 
 At its very mention, East European economists today tend simply to roll their eyes. 
 Instead, market-minded liberals have seized the controls. 
 Economic success, they believe, rises in the West. 
 Poland's finance minister, Mr Leszek Balcerowicz, is imposing a harsh stabilisation programme. 
 &bquo;Poland is too poor for social experiments,&equo; he likes to say. 
 The zloty is now, in theory, convertible. 
 Prices are free. 
 Soft credit is being squeezed. 
 Privatisation is on its way. 
 His Czechoslovak equivalent, Mr Vaclav Klaus, may be winning his fight inside the government for &bquo;market economics without adjectives&equo; &mdash; meaning, for a start, a tough budget and early privatisation. 
 In Hungary, a new government will have to say yes or no to the drastic subsidy cuts and industrial shutdowns that free-marketeers say are needed. 
 These economic Robespierres have got the policy initiative partly because they are ready to take risks that others balk at. 
 Hundreds of books have been written on the transition from capitalism to communism, but not the other way. 
 There is no known recipe for unmaking an omelette. 
 Many people in Solidarity thought the communists should be left to take the tough measures needed to clear up the mess they themselves had created &mdash; and pay the electoral price. 
 In Czechoslovakia's Civic Forum, there are doubts about how fast reform should go. 
 Hungary's Democratic Forum, whose Hungary-first populism puts it on the right, also objects to the pace of reform that the Free Democrats want. 
 These people worry about a backlash if free-market policies stall or if the social cost is too high. 
 Solidarity ministers are already having to sweet-talk workers out of striking. 
 How much, how soon? 
 That the argument is no longer between capitalism and something else does not mean there is no argument. 
 The questions now are about the timing and completeness of change. 
 Not everyone accepts Machiavelli's advice that rulers should dispense favours slowly and inflict pain all at once. 
 What, for instance, in economies where 80% or more of industry is in state hands, is a plausible calendar for privatisation? 
 Some right-wing Polish economists want a clear-out sale of state industry in one go. 
 The Free Democrats talk of selling off 35&ndash;40% of Hungary's business assets in 2&ndash;3 years and 80% within ten years. 
 Who will buy the shares? 
 Selling state assets itself will bring little competition to over-centralised economies, if private monopolies replace state ones. 
 Is there a broad enough base for popular capitalism? 
 How much worker ownership should there be? 
 Will state holding companies be needed? 
 Should foreign shareholdings be limited? 
 How is economic pain to be shared out? 
 How much social spending should there be to soften the transition? 
 Socialists or social democrats in Eastern Europe tend not to be doctrinaire in their answers. 
 They accept the goal of an enterprise economy, but want it tempered by social concerns, with a place for worker-ownership. 
 Mr Jan Jozef Lipsky, a veteran Polish socialist and a co-founder of KOR, the Workers' Defence Committee, says of Mr Balcerowicz's programme, &bquo;When the car's in a sharp turn, you don't snatch the wheel.&equo; 
 He believes there should be a place for employee share-ownership plans, but not covering more than, say, 15% of industry. 
 Even one of the most left-wing members of Czechoslovakia's Civic Forum, Mr Petr Uhl, who now runs the Czech news agency, says that &bquo;only a market can allow the consumer real freedom of choice&equo;. 
 So far, the debate about economic policy has been confined largely to technocrats and foreign advisers lodged in expensive hotels where one night costs around the average worker's monthly wage. 
 Among voters, the longing for the consumer society is mixed with concern about the costs of a market shock-treatment. 
 In Poland, even one outside adviser to the World Bank worries openly about what he sees as a lack of feeling among Mr Balcerowicz and his advisers for the political realities around them. 
 Mr Bronislaw Geremek, the leader of Solidarity's parliamentary group, counters that &bquo;Thatcherist policy is not a danger for Poland because it is unrealisable with our handicaps, but it is needed to budge the deadweight of the planned economy.&equo; 
 People's fears, though, are realistic enough: fear of price rises, of vanishing pensions, of losing the benefits that softened the drabness of life &mdash; low rents, cheap transport, subsidised food. 
 The fears of bureaucrats and industrial workers are simpler still: hard-driving new bosses at best, at worst the sack. 
 In Poland and Hungary, despite economic centralisation, traditions of local control have sprung up in many industries. 
 They will be hard to break. 
 The previous Polish government failed to shut down the famous Lenin shipyard in Gdansk. 
 When a wealthy American, Mrs Barbara Johnson, offered to buy it, workers rejected her tough conditions for streamlining and layoffs. 
 Ambivalence and fear 
 On top of all this is an ambivalence about imitating the West. 
 The division of Europe at least protected the East from facing up to its thousand-year feeling of backwardness. 
 There is envy, but also fear, of westerners, who seem so at home with the intricacies of capital markets and proportional representation. 
 The frequent remark that &bquo;it was all so much simpler under communism&equo; is not always said with total irony. 
 These conflicts are reflected in opinion polls. 
 &bquo;Social democracy&equo; scored better than &bquo;communism&equo; or &bquo;liberalism&equo; when Poles and Hungarians were asked how they now felt about these &bquo;isms&equo; in a poll that was organised recently by a French firm, Conseils-Sondages-Analyses and Le Journal des Elections. 
 Some 70% of Hungarians quizzed and 60% of the Poles thought social democracy was &bquo;a system with a future&equo;. 
 They were not directly asked what &bquo;social democracy&equo; meant. 
 One suspects its high rating owes less to a fondness for social-democratic parties with close trade-union links than to a loose wish for economic efficiency plus social justice. 
 That hunch is borne out in answers Hungarians gave to more probing questions. 
 Some 42% of them thought that economic liberals were best at handling the economy (against 18% who thought social democrats were); and 50% thought unions should be independent of social-democratic parties (though 39% thought the opposite). 
 Capitalism brings losses as well as gains. 
 In these countries, a certain income equality has been achieved in the past 40 years, if one leaves aside the party privilegentsia, black-marketeers and writers or performers with access to foreign earnings. 
 An equality of poverty, westerners may say. 
 Yet nobody knows how people will react if some suddenly get a lot richer and some a lot poorer. 
 Do East Europeans want their capitals to resemble New York, with its skyscrapers of wealth alongside slum ghettos? 
 In Hungary in 1977, the top-earning fifth of households got 32% of total household income, the bottom fifth 11%. 
 In Poland in 1982, the best-off fifth of &bquo;employee households&equo; &mdash; anybody not on a farm or retired &mdash; got 31% of total &bquo;employee&equo; income. 
 In both countries, the income differences had been narrowing. 
 For comparison, in Britain, at the end of the 1970s, the gap between rich and poor was considerably wider than that in Hungary or Poland, and has widened further since. 
 The dangers for democracy 
 The hard work in Eastern Europe is just beginning, and not just economic. 
 While free markets are to be introduced, free constitutions are to be written. 
 This will be one main job of the new parliaments in Czechoslovakia and Romania. 
 Poland's parliament is already drafting one, to be ready, it is hoped, by mid-1991. 
 Hungary's new parliament will have to decide how to choose a president, and how strong he will be. 
 Investors, especially foreign ones, want political stability, to go with economic growth. 
 Governments want both. 
 So do voters. 
 But getting both will not be easy: they don't necessarily go together. 
 Governments must both deliver economic success &mdash; hard enough &mdash; and yet avoid too much short-term social injustice, which may be harder still. 
 If they fail on either count, they are in trouble. 
 And trouble may not mean just the change of ruling party that it would in Western Europe. 
 After the first world war, most states in central and eastern Europe got more or less democratic constitutions. 
 Admiral Horthy soon ended chaos and democracy alike in Hungary. 
 By 1926 Poland was under a military strongman. 
 Romania's king ended democracy there. 
 The failures of the Weimar republic spawned Hitler. 
 Austria functioned as a semi-democracy, only Czechoslovakia as a real one, until Hitler crushed them. 
 &bquo;We are are building democracy on a slippery surface,&equo; says Mr Petr Pithart, the premier of the Czech lands (Bohemia and Moravia). 
 Society, he says, has been &bquo;flattened out&equo;, with consequent risks of demagogy and nationalism. 
 A leading Solidarity activist, Mr Adam Michnik, argues that the real arguments in Eastern Europe will be less between economic liberalism and social-democracy than between an open, tolerant vision of society and more bigoted or authoritarian ones. 
 Where it survives at all, belief in a special East European road may be strongest in parties with a nationalist tinge, like Hungary's Democratic Forum. 
 This sort of thing was common between the wars, when one East European country after another tried to keep out foreign goods and capital. 
 &bquo;Nostrification&equo;, as it was pompously known, was a dream. 
 Poland, for example, was too poor. 
 By the 1930s, 40% of its industry was owned by foreigners. 
 This time round, how patiently will touchy Poles put up with working to German standards for German bosses in German-owned firms? 
 For the moment, however, Solidarity and Czechoslovakia's Civic Forum continue to enjoy huge credit. 
 As in Spain after Franco, they can probably count for some while on a &bquo;democracy bonus&equo;: people will put up with hardship as the price of freedom. 
 In Czechoslovakia the big argument is inside Civic Forum. 
 How thorough a reform programme should it put forward? 
 Some of its leaders fear a revival of left-wing parties waving the banner of social justice. 
 Others argue that any new government must have a clear mandate for change. 
 At the moment, unelected technocrats are being asked to provide economic reform from above. 
 In Poland, Solidarity too is more threatened by its own internal arguments than by the Socialist or Peasant parties. 
 Some people think the parliamentary election should be brought forward from 1993, to give the government legitimacy and to open the way for a new president &mdash; Mr Lech Walesa? &mdash; in place of General Jaruzelski. 
 Both Civic Forum and Solidarity want to hang on to the one-nation sense of anti-communism (and anti-Sovietism). 
 Both are keen to remain as &bquo;movements&equo; rather than &bquo;parties&equo;. 
 The distinction, which may seem over-fine to westerners, matters in countries where the word &bquo;party&equo; meant a monopoly of political life. 
 Yet the fraternal phase of revolutions does not last. 
 Movements in time tend to become ragged coalitions in disguise, denying voters the chance to make clear choices. 
 In Hungary the issue is whether stable governments can be formed from the wide band of parties produced by a complex electoral system. 
 But here too there may well be a democracy bonus, as politicians of all the big parties try to make the system work, knowing that voters will be quick to punish failure. 
 It is harder to be confident about Romania, if only because politicians there, of whatever stripe, mostly treat their opponents as liars and scoundrels. 
 Forecasts about the course of democracy tend to swing from optimism to despair with alarming speed. 
 In Poland, Hungary and Czechoslovakia former enemies who by rights should, and quite probably do, detest each other are vigorously horse-trading today. 
 Romania seems to lack that valuable sense of compromise. 
 It may yet serve as an unhappy reminder that there are divides greater than those between modern capitalism and modern social democracy. 
 SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 
 The promise of atomic eyes 
 IMAGINE a gramophone needle so sensitive that it could detect the individual atoms on a record. 
 Crudely speaking, this is the principle behind a breed of microscopes that may turn out to have as much impact on the microchip-production line as they have already had in the laboratory. 
 The scanning-tunnelling microscope (STM) was devised by Dr Gerd Binnig and Dr Heinrich Rohrer at IBM's Zurich laboratories in 1981. 
 It is the first of a rapidly growing family of microscopes based on the idea of moving a needle over a surface to sense its shape. 
 The STM works by putting a voltage on the needle so that a tiny current flows to the surface. 
 It flows despite the fact that there is an insulating vacuum between the tip and the surface: thanks to the vagaries of quantum mechanics, electrons can &bquo;tunnel&equo; through the gap to produce a current. 
 If the vacuum gap diminishes slightly, as it does when the tip approaches a bump on the surface, the current increases. 
 A feedback system moves the tip away from the surface to keep the current constant. 
 And the amount the tip is moved reveals the height of the protuberance, even if it is only a single atom high. 
 The STM is also sensitive to the electronic properties of a surface. 
 For instance, in gallium arsenide (often touted as an eventual successor to silicon in the microchip industry), the gallium and arsenic atoms form a type of bond in which each gallium atom &bquo;borrows&equo; an electron from an arsenic atom. 
 This affects the STM, as Dr Joseph Stroscio and Dr Randall Feenstra at IBM's Watson research laboratories in New York state have shown. 
 If a negative voltage is applied to the tip, pushing electrons into the surface, the gallium atoms will show up clearly in the STM, because electrons will flow into the surface most when the tip is above a gallium atom. 
 Likewise, the arsenic atoms appear if the voltage is positive. 
 Circuitous progress 
 Taking snaps of single atoms is a feat worthy of a Nobel prize, and the STM got one for its inventors. 
 It may turn out to earn rather more than that in the semiconductor industry. 
 If the silicon chips coming off a production line begin to fail, ordinary optical-microscope pictures of the minute circuitry can often help to sort out what is going wrong. 
 However, the dimensions of the smallest circuit-parts will soon have shrunk beyond the limit that optical microscopes can resolve. 
 Traditional electron microscopes, which emit beams of electrons and watch them bounce off the surface, can see much smaller details but their pictures usually give only a poor impression of the relief of the surface. 
 The STM can give an accurate one; and the smallest circuit features are still several hundred atoms in size &mdash; easy for the STM to resolve. 
 Various companies have sprouted their own STM products. 
 Digital Instruments in California has been marketing a Nanoscope since 1986. 
 It has sold over 300 of them, at around &dollar;70,000 each. 
 According to the company, the market is expanding fast: three-quarters of its sales were made in the past 18 months. 
 Industry, at least in America and Europe, has been slow to show interest. 
 Digital Instruments still relies on universities and research institutes for about half of its sales. 
 But the Japanese have decided that anything with the slightest chance of helping to make better microchips deserves a close look. 
 The company has sold to most big Japanese chipmakers and many manufacturers of electronic and optical-storage discs. 
 Japanese industry now accounts for nearly a third of sales. 
 Other firms are profiting too. 
 Britain's WA Technology, based in Cambridge, started selling STMs three years ago from the dining room of one of the company's founders. 
 It has now sold around 15. 
 The company is a relatively rare thing for Europe: a successful high-technology start-up. 
 More typical of European STM builders is Omicron, a West German specialist in vacuum equipment, and Struers, a Danish company that makes metallurgical equipment. 
 Both are established firms which see STMs as a logical extension of their business. 
 Some makers are aiming at specialist niches. 
 NHK, an American firm based in Michigan, sells an STM that can be run at extremely low temperatures. 
 This makes it popular for studying superconductors (materials that conduct electricity without resistance at low temperatures). 
 Seiko in Japan has developed an STM capable of accurately placing the needle anywhere on the five-inch wafers of silicon on which microelectronic circuitry is printed before it is diced into chips. 
 Most of the companies that have bought STMs are still working out what to do with them. 
 A few have already introduced them as analytical tools in their product-development laboratories. 
 But sales will not really take off until they become a standard quality-control feature on production lines. 
 Already, though, some STM makers have their sights on other markets. 
 Digital Instruments will soon be selling a version of the Nanoscope that works in an electrolytic bath. 
 Such a device can be used to study the quality of electroplated metal films or to investigate corrosion as it happens. 
 The company expects the makers of electrolytic batteries (like the ones in cars) to be big customers for its new product. 
 Many other ways of using the STM are pouring out of research laboratories and are likely to make their way to market. 
 One example: last year Dr Kumar Wickramasinghe and an IBM team in New York demonstrated a version of the STM that is sensitive to temperature. 
 The needle and sample are chosen so that they form a thermocouple: a device that produces a voltage if the point at which the two materials meet is hotter than its surroundings. 
 If light of a certain colour shines on the surface, molecules on the surface will absorb the light and heat up so that they &bquo;glow&equo; in the STM picture. 
 Since different molecules absorb different colours, this microscope can be used to make a microscopic chemical analysis of the surface. 
 Some researchers think the STM may have a more distant future not just analysing molecules and microcircuits but helping to make them. 
 By dipping the STM needle in a drop of organic molecules on a piece of graphite, and then briefly applying a large voltage to the tip, Dr John Foster and colleagues at IBM's research laboratories in San Jose, California, have shown how to fix a single molecule at a specific point on the graphite. 
 In addition, further pulses of volts can be used to dissect the molecule or to remove it altogether. 
 Another feat of microengineering was demonstrated by Dr Russell Becker and a team at AT&amp;T Bell Laboratories in New Jersey. 
 By briefly touching the metal tip on a germanium crystal, moving the tip to another part of the crystal and then applying a large voltage, they placed a single germanium atom at the new spot. 
 One day, the team hopes, it will be possible to build tiny circuits atom by atom.  
 Russian science 
 Rockets into ploughshares 
 MOSCOW 
 SCIENCE and technology are supposed to be two keystones of Mikhail Gorbachev's attempts to liven up the Soviet economy. 
 But perestroika came late to the Soviet Academy of Sciences, and the reforms introduced over the past two years have yet to take effect. 
 &bquo;The academy was too sleepy in the beginning,&equo; Dr Roald Sagdeev, a radical academician and former director of the Space Research Institute, told The Economist. 
 &bquo;It began to overhaul itself only as a result of demands from the public and from individual scientists.&equo; 
 The academy had become little more than a rubber stamp for huge prestigious projects drawn up by the industrial ministries. 
 What power it had was in the hands of an aging bureaucracy. 
 By 1988 age-limits had been set for top posts and the way they were filled had become more democratic. 
 New faces appeared in the academy and its institutes; unpopular projects, like plans to divert Siberia's rivers to southern desert areas, were dropped. 
 Old habits die hard and Dr Sagdeev believes the changes are superficial. 
 &bquo;As long as top officials are nominated by the party or through party bosses like Yegor Ligachev, perestroika in the academy will be a phantom.&equo; 
 Fundamental science was a casualty of the &bquo;period of stagnation&equo; &mdash; it got less than 9% of Soviet spending on science in 1988. 
 Things appear to be improving. 
 In 1989 500m roubles was allocated to basic research; earlier this year, overall finance for science was increased by 30%. 
 Dr Sagdeev approves, but does not expect the trend to continue, given the budget deficit. 
 The way science money is allocated has also been changed. 
 Instead of going directly to the academy's institutes, much of it is now awarded to projects by committees representing science and industry. 
 Last year 6,200 projects competed, of which 3,860 received money. 
 But, says Dr Sagdeev, a large part of the money is still spent to support unprofitable institutes. 
 Getting industry to adopt new technologies has long been a problem. 
 For decades the main aim of every enterprise was to meet or exceed government-set output targets rather than to improve production methods. 
 Now institutes are being encouraged to seek contracts from industry, with the aim of eventually becoming self-financing. 
 Such contracts so far account for around 15% of most institutes' funds. 
 Dr Sagdeev is concerned that it should not exceed 50%, &bquo;otherwise institutes will lose their stability and become preoccupied with ad hoc projects.&equo; 
 New institutions have been created to foster links between science and industry, &bquo;interdepartmental technology centres&equo; known as MNTKs, which represent research institutes, ministries, government departments and enterprises. 
 So far 23 have been set up, 17 involving academy institutes. 
 These 17 have produced goods worth 500m roubles. 
 The problem, Dr Sagdeev points out, is that in some cases government ministries and departments still have control. 
 He does not think MNTKs will last; they are &bquo;a form of transition from a state-run system to an independent one&equo;. 
 Dr Sagdeev reports that morale among scientists is very low. 
 In the old days, researchers in the military sector were pampered while scientists in civil research were ill-equipped and badly paid, with few prospects for promotion or international recognition. 
 But instead of bringing civilian scientists up to the standard of their military colleagues, many Soviet scientists feel there has been a levelling down. 
 The government is trying to boost the ailing economy by converting the defence industry to civilian production. 
 This has meant big cuts in some scientific areas. 
 The academy &bquo;cut out funding of projects which had nothing to do with military programmes &mdash; space research was one victim&equo;. 
 And space research is Dr Sagdeev's own field. 
 This might help to explain why he is not optimistic about the future of Soviet science.  
 Scanning horizons 
 THE scanning-tunnelling microscope (STM) has one drawback. 
 It works well on metal or semiconductor surfaces, but insulating materials are a problem. 
 No current can be made to flow from the STM's needle on to their surfaces. 
 Dr Binnig, co-inventor of the STM, and his colleagues in Zurich have developed a solution: a needle made of diamond, say, can be made to sense an insulating surface by exploiting the weak repulsive forces that exist between atoms. 
 The needle will move up and down because of these forces. 
 Its motion can be detected &mdash; for example, by deflecting a laser beam that bounces off a mirror attached to the needle. 
 Such a device is called an atomic-force microscope (AFM). 
 Although the AFM cannot quite achieve the resolution of an STM, it is likely to have its uses in microelectronics. 
 Optical discs, for example, are made of insulating material; although they can be coated with a thin metal film and put under an STM, an AFM could examine a product without destroying it. 
 Digital Instruments will start delivering AFMs this spring, many to Japanese optical-disc manufacturers. 
 They hope to sell 100 by the end of the year. 
 Variants of the AFM abound. 
 The magnetic-force microscope, developed at IBM's Watson research laboratories in New York, uses a magnetic needle made of nickel which is sensitive to variations of the magnetic field on a surface. 
 Such a microscope can easily form images of the individual bits of magnetic information. 
 In its development laboratories, IBM is using the microscope to check the quality of magnetic-storage discs. 
 In one case it was able to show that tracks of information were being written too closely together, thus partially erasing each other. 
 At the same laboratory, Dr Clayton Williams and colleagues have developed a type of AFM for measuring the distribution of atoms of a &bquo;dopant&equo; in semiconductors. 
 Dopants are used to tailor the electronic properties of different parts of circuitry. 
 When a voltage is applied to the tip of the AFM needle (which is kept far enough away from the surface so that no tunnelling current can flow), the dopant's electrons are disturbed and exert an electrostatic force on the tip. 
 The resulting motion of the tip can be used to measure the amount of dopant atoms below it. 
 Researchers around the world have only a dozen or so AFMs, compared with hundreds of STMs. 
 When AFMs become more widely available, they seem sure to make a hit in biology. 
 Most interesting organic substances are non-conducting, and biologists like to put their samples on insulating glass slides. 
 Dr Paul Hansma and colleagues at the University of California at Santa Barbara have already produced AFM pictures of individual amino acids making up a peptide chain. 
 Some researchers think that scanning microscopes could eventually be used to read off the sequence of amino acids that form DNA. 
 Today's techniques for DNA sequencing are comparatively laborious and indirect. 
 The microscope could even move from reading to writing. 
 One idea on the horizon is to alter the structure of molecules with an AFM &mdash; making it the ultimate precision tool.  
 Objects of desire 
 Databases are being taught how the world works, and thus becoming more than mere filing cabinets 
 THE computers that most companies want do not beat grandmasters at chess, attempt to predict the weather, or do scientists out of a job. 
 One of their main uses is simply to store and sort information &mdash; in &bquo;databases&equo;. 
 The past two decades of database development have been rather boring. 
 The aim of such work has been to realise the ideal of &bquo;relational-model&equo; databases, as defined by Mr Ted Codd, a researcher at IBM, in 1970. 
 This task has often seemed to combine the pedantry of library theory with the incomprehensibility of computer science. 
 Now that the goal has finally been reached, the fun can begin. 
 What makes the new round of work potentially so profitable is the scope it offers for experiment. 
 Plenty of new technology had to be devised to implement relational databases. 
 But the work was dictated by Mr Codd's theory. 
 Today's wave of experiments has no such rulebook: anybody with a good idea can try it out, and perhaps strike gold. 
 One fruitful source of experiment is to apply ideas from &bquo;object-oriented&equo; programming languages to databases. 
 To see why, start with a look at the pros and cons of Mr Codd's creation. 
 His relational model is a theory of what data is and how it can be stored and retrieved. 
 It provides a series of rules and techniques for ensuring that each piece of information is stored in only one place in the database. 
 And it shows how to build up descriptions of complex data from these &bquo;atomic&equo; pieces. 
 The advantages of such a computerised filing system are reliability and flexibility. 
 It has one, and only one, place for everything. 
 But there are costs too. 
 Although for many applications the costs are negligible, they raise their heads too often to be ignored. 
 Reassembling, say, all the designs for all the parts which make up a jet engine can be a time-consuming task on a relational database. 
 Worse, all the details of that task have to be specified in detail by a programmer, who can be overwhelmed by the complexity of the data he is trying to manage. 
 As one wag noted, storing information in a relational database is a bit like storing a car in a filing cabinet &mdash; engine under &bquo;E&equo;, wheels under &bquo;W&equo; and so on. 
 It is all there, but there is a lot of reconstruction to do after getting it out. 
 Object-oriented programming offers techniques for boosting efficiency and hiding complexity. 
 They work by building into the database some knowledge about the world it records. 
 Instead of maintaining a distinction between programs (the computer's rules for thinking) and data (what it thinks about) the idea of object-oriented programming is to create abstract &bquo;objects&equo; that contain both. 
 An object describing an employee might record data like name, rank and salary, and also contain programs like &bquo;raise salary&equo; and &bquo;promote&equo;. 
 Implicit in the object-oriented approach are a wealth of ideas for databases. 
 One of the most important is using information about the type of data stored in order to to prevent howlers. 
 To a conventional database, data is data is data. 
 No distinction is made between a number that records salary and one that records the number of parts in a warehouse in St Louis. 
 If a programmer adds the two together, the database will not complain, though the programmer's boss might. 
 Object-oriented systems keep track of the qualities of quantities, and complain about attempted daftness. 
 In addition to catching errors, object-oriented systems can shelter the user from the complexity of dealing with lots of different kinds of data. 
 They keep track of which procedures work on which types of data-object. 
 Adding feet and inches, for example, requires a procedure different from adding metres; displaying graphics is different from displaying text. 
 Because they store appropriate procedures with each type of data-object, object-oriented databases never forget such details. 
 The information contained in the definition of objects can also boost efficiency by reducing the time needed to retrieve complex collections of data. 
 Computer-aided design systems, for example, might define an &bquo;object&equo; called &bquo;jet engine&equo;. 
 When an engineer calls up the plans for a jet engine, the information in the definition of that object allows the system &mdash; automatically and efficiently &mdash; to retrieve the plans for all its sub-components. 
 There is more. 
 Ideas from object-oriented programming may also help databases to communicate better with the programming languages that modify their data &mdash; and to tell the difference between two items which coincidentally have the same characteristics. 
 Increasing quantities of these bright ideas are making the leap from laboratory to marketplace. 
 Several American companies now offer object-oriented databases &mdash; among them Symbolics (noted for computers that run the LISP programming language), Ingres (maker of a best-selling relational database), and start-ups including Servio Logic, Ontologic and Object Design. 
 Others, including Hewlett-Packard, have research prototypes in the wings. 
 Each reflects the concerns of its creator. 
 Symbolics, predictably, offers a particularly good link between its database and LISP. 
 One of its clients, Houston Power and Light, uses the object-oriented system to help schedule maintenance of its power stations. 
 The system manages not only data about maintenance crews and equipment, but also rules that specify how long crews can work, which stations can be taken off-line without blacking out the city, and so on. 
 Servio Logic has tried to make its object-oriented database easy to modify, on the grounds that complex data is likely also to be fast-changing. 
 Hewlett-Packard has sacrificed some speed for flexibility and compatibility with relational databases. 
 Computer-aided design companies, by contrast, have concentrated on tapping the speed offered by object-oriented techniques in assembling and modifying vast quantities of blueprints and design data. 
 Time and competition will tell which ideas will prosper, and which will be forgotten.  
 Ants 
 Old colonials 
 CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS 
 PICK a good story and just tell it,&equo; is the advice given to aspiring scientists by Dr Edward O. Wilson. 
 He has certainly picked one of the best for himself. 
 A lifetime's devotion to ants has made him the principal authority on the subject. 
 Last week Harvard University Press published the first conspectus of myremecology since 1910, by Dr Wilson and Dr Bert Holldobler (a fellow Harvard professor). 
 * Why, they ask, have ants been relatively neglected by other biologists? 
 Put all the world's land animals on a pair of scales and 10% of the weight would be ants. 
 But it is their achievements, not their weight, which distinguishes them. 
 Ants are the world's secret workers. 
 Together with termites they turn most of the earth's soil, enriching it, draining it and airing it. 
 They are among the most important disseminators of plant seeds; and they eat perhaps 90% of the corpses of small animals. 
 Dr Wilson argues that if ants were to disappear, most of the world's ecosystems would be dangerously destabilised. 
 Still, it is not that he wants biologists to give them more credit for maintaining the planet. 
 Rather he thinks that ants' social organisation and skills should make them at least as rewarding to study as the birds and mammals on which animal behaviourists have focused. 
 One reason why ants are so sophisticated is because of their complex language of chemical communication, which Dr Wilson has done more than anyone to elucidate. 
 An average ant colony might use around 12 different types of signal, most of them conveyed by means of chemical &bquo;pheromones&equo; secreted on to the ground by various glands and then sniffed in the air by other ants. 
 Another reason for their success is a lack of sex. 
 Workers do not reproduce, so to propagate their genes they must protect their nest, thus ensuring that the queen &mdash; their relative &mdash; can reproduce copiously. 
 One type of ant is understandably known as the kamikaze ant. 
 Another is a walking bomb: a Malaysian species of carpenter ant ruptures an enormous poison-filled gland during fights, spraying poison over the enemy as it explodes. 
 Explaining social behaviour &mdash; such as such selflessness &mdash; in terms of biology (especially genes) is a hallmark of sociobiology, of which Dr Wilson is regarded as the father. 
 Although most ants are accomplished fighters and hunters, there are also many farmers among them. 
 Ants of the genus Hypoclinea are the only known genuine nomads, apart from some tribes of man. 
 They keep livestock &mdash; in the form of mealybugs which feed on sap &mdash; and move them continuously to fresh pastures, placing them on new plants and trees when the old ones have been sucked dry. 
 Nutrients from the sap are passed on to the ants in the mealybugs' excrement. 
 The most sophisticated farmers are the leaf-cutting ants, which cultivate fungus on fresh vegetation thanks to an assembly-line of specialised castes. 
 Co-operation within a colony, especially by means of labour-dividing castes, is probably what ants are most famous for. 
 One &bquo;super-colony&equo; of interconnected nests, spread over 2.7 square kilometres in Hokkaido, Japan, consisted of some 306m workers and over 1m queens. 
 But genuine co-operation between colonies seems always to boil down to pure parasitism. 
 Often one colony will enslave another of the same species, or one species will exploit another. 
 Queens of the North African Bothrio myrmex decapitans take control of colonies of Tapinoma ants. 
 They let Tapinoma workers drag them into their nests, then they find the Tapinoma queen, sit on her back and do what they have evolved to do best: slowly saw off her head. 
 The new queen takes over as sole reproducer and soon swamps the colony with her own offspring. 
 The honeypot ant, Myremocystus mimicus, enslaves other colonies of its own species. 
 Territorial disputes give rise to elaborate tournaments in which workers extend their legs to walk on stilts and drum their antennae on each other's abdomens. 
 When one colony is markedly smaller than the other and so cannot field an imposing team, it is raided, the queen is killed, and workers, pupae and larvae are carried off to be set to work in the victors' nest. 
 The kings (or rather, queens) of slave-owners are the Amazon ants, who are splendid at killing and enslaving other ants but have grown so dependent on their slaves that they cannot dig their own nests, care for their young or even get their own food. 
 Dr Wilson works hard to find evolutionary explanations for most of such oddities of ant life. 
 And he and his fellow sociobiologists have high but distant hopes of doing the same for man. 
 If sociobiologists have tended sometimes to describe higher societies (such as man's) too much as if they were simpler ones, some entomologists have been guilty of the reverse. 
 Here is William Wheeler, the last great encyclopediast of ants (1910), describing Amazon ants at home: they sit about in stolid idleness, or pass the long hours begging the slaves for food or cleaning themselves and burnishing their ruddy armour. 
 No doubt they also do crossword puzzles when it rains. 
 * &bquo;The Ants&equo; by Bert Holldobler and E. O. Wilson. 
 Harvard University Press; 732 pages; &dollar;65. 
 ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL INDICATORS 
 OUTPUT, DEMAND AND JOBS 
 America's industrial production recovered in the 12 months to February, rising 0.9% compared with a rise of 0.1% in the year to January. 
 Britain's industrial output slowed in January, leaving it only 0.3% up on the year, compared with a 1.2% increase in the year to December. 
 Britain's jobless rate edged down to 5.6% in February, but the fall was the smallest since the present decline began in 1986. 
 Australia's unemployment rate rose to 6.5% in February, the highest for a year. 
 Holland's was 5.4% in January, down from 6.3% a year ago.  
 PRICES AND WAGES 
 America's 12-month consumer-price inflation edged up to 5.3% in February. 
 Its wholesale prices were unchanged, trimming the annual rise to 5.1%, down from 5.8% in January. 
 Japan's wholesale prices rose 3.5% in the year to February, the smallest year-on-year increase for four months. 
 Japanese earnings rose by 5.9% in the year to January, equivalent to a real pay increase of 2.8%; Britain's workers had a pay rise of 9.3%, a real increase of 1.5%.  
 WEST GERMANY 
 What will be the impact on the West German economy of its forthcoming unification with East Germany? 
 A little like the curate's egg, reckons Consensus Economics, a consultancy which polls other forecasters. 
 Its consensus forecast suggests that a united Germany would see its GNP growth rise by a net 0.6 of a percentage point in 1991, relative to that of West Germany, and by half a point in 1992. 
 But inflation is expected to be 0.4 percentage points higher in both years, while interest rates might rise by half a point in 1991 and perhaps by 30 basis points in 1992. 
 The consensus forecast says Germany's current-account surplus will fall swiftly: to DM88 billion (&dollar;52 billion) in 1991, compared with a forecast of DM96 billion for an un-united West Germany.  
 COMMODITY PRICE INDEX 
 Metal prices have risen 29% from their lows in late January. 
 Lead, normally the dullest of metals, has seen the most spectacular advance. 
 Fuelled by low stocks and production problems, prices have almost doubled during the period. 
 Cash lead hit a ten-year high of &pound;800 (&dollar;1,300) a tonne in London this month. 
 The Samin smelter in Sardinia has been closed since last August, with a loss of 68,000 tonnes, and is unlikely to reopen until June. 
 Producer stocks have been below five week's consumption since the second half of 1989. 
 Stocks on the London Metal Exchange had almost halved to 12,900 tonnes since the beginning of the year, before recovering sharply to 16,475 tonnes this week.  
 INTERNATIONAL BORROWING 
 Borrowing on international capital markets in 1989 was little changed from 1988's level, at &dollar;360 billion for medium- and long-term bonds and loans. 
 There was, however, a swing from bonds and bank lending to equity-related bonds. 
 Some 97% of the equity-related bond issues were by Japanese companies; the market reached a peak of &dollar;28 billion in the second quarter, easing back to &dollar;16 billion in each of the third and fourth. 
 Fixed-rate bonds (&bquo;straights&equo;) were again the most popular, at &dollar;154 billion. 
 This total disguises the fact that offerings in dollars and yen both rose 17%, but Swiss francs and D-marks fell sharply because of their rising interest rates. 
 Syndicated loans fell 23%, due to fewer corporate restructurings and property financings. 
 Floating-rate bonds amounted to &dollar;17 billion in 1989.  
 TRADE, EXCHANGE RATES AND RESERVES 
 America's visible-trade deficit widened to &dollar;9.3 billion in January, boosted by a surge in oil imports. 
 Its 12-month deficit edged up to &dollar;109.6 billion. 
 West Germany's trade surplus climbed to &dollar;72.7 billion in the year to January. 
 France's trade deficit rose to &dollar;6.9 billion in the year to February. 
 In trade-weighted terms the dollar fell 0.4% during the week, the D-mark rose 0.5% and the yen lost 1.1%.  
 WORLD BOURSES 
 A one-point rise in Japan's discount rate pushed Tokyo below 31,000 for the first time since January 1989; during the week it lost 5.6%. 
 Wall Street ignored January's poor trade figures, rising 2.4%. 
 London climbed 1.6%, but reacted coolly to Britain's budget.  
 MONEY AND INTEREST RATES 
 In the year to February America's narrow-money growth quickened to 1.9%, Japan's increased to 0.7% and Britain's accelerated to 6.4%. 
 In the same period America's broad-money supply rose by 3.3%, Japan's by 11.8% and Britain's by 17.9%. 
 BUSINESS THIS WEEK 
 Sundowners 
 Tokyo stocks plummeted before and after the Bank of Japan raised its discount rate from 4.25% to 5.25%, the fourth increase in ten months. 
 The yen fell too, pushing the total market capitalisation of the Tokyo exchange beneath that of the New York exchange for the first time in three years. 
 Japan's four leading brokerages, Nomura, Daiwa, Nikko and Yamaichi, agreed to stop issuing new shares, convertible bonds and warrant bonds for Japanese companies both in Tokyo and in the Euromarkets for at least a month. 
 They are trying to prop up the tumbling stockmarket by cutting the supply of new issues. 
 But who would want to issue now anyway? 
 Brazil's financial markets were immobilised by the inflation-fighting plan announced by Fernando Collor, the newly elected president. 
 The plan created a new, free-floating currency called the cruzeiro, and froze deposits worth about &dollar;115 billion. 
 London's International Stock Exchange said it would cut 350 people from its staff of 2,800 in the first stage of a big slimming campaign. 
 The second stage of the rocket carrying Intelsat 6, the world's biggest communications satellite, failed to separate. 
 So Intelsat 6 is stuck in a uselessly low orbit until a space shuttle can be persuaded to collect it, or until it falls down. 
 The &dollar;150m satellite is not insured. 
 With spring warming the northern hemisphere and OPEC unable to agree on cuts in production at the cartel's meeting in Vienna, oil prices tumbled to their lowest level this year. 
 In January, in contrast, high oil prices pushed the cost of America's oil imports to a record level. 
 Happy together 
 D-mark bond prices fell, but the currency soared as East Germany's conservative Alliance for Germany won 48% of the vote in the country's first free election. 
 Bonn promises monetary union by June 30th, but the Alliance needs two-thirds of the parliamentary vote before it can complete unification. 
 The European Commission made its first concrete proposal on monetary union. 
 It called for a EuroFed to co-ordinate monetary policies. 
 It also asked member states to replace their currencies with the ecu, eventually. 
 New beginnings 
 Wall Street whizz-kid Don Carter is entering a new stage of his career. 
 After pleading guilty to stealing &dollar;1m from his clients he may go to jail. 
 VPI Group, which paid &dollar;75m for Mr Carter's company in 1987, is not amused. 
 Ito-Yokado, a Japanese retailing giant and its subsidiary, 7-Eleven of Japan, offered to buy 75% of Southland  Corporation , which operates America's 7-Eleven chain of convenience stores. 
 Southland is a casualty of the collapse of the junk bond markets. 
 The offer depends upon its debt being  restructured  successfully. 
 Terrific trade 
 The value of world merchandise trade grew by over 7% in 1989 to top &dollar;3 trillion for the first time, reported GATT. 
 America climbed back to the top of the exporters' league table after three years in second place to West Germany. 
 California's Getty Museum bought Van Gogh's Irises from Alan Bond for &dollar;40m. 
 Mr Bond bought the painting for a record &dollar;53.9m in 1987. 
 Everybody chip in 
 Six of America's leading technology companies &mdash; including IBM, Du Pont and Micron Technology &mdash; teamed up with Perkin-Elmer managers to buy that company's electron-beam business. 
 Though its technology, which makes chips, has won much praise, Perkin-Elmer did not think it could profit in the face of Japanese competition. 
 A task force sent out by the House of Representatives' banking committee estimates that sorting out America's savings and loan mess could cost as much as &dollar;162 billion more than the &dollar;50 billion authorised by Congress less than a year ago. 
 Deals on wheels 
 President Bush proposed a near-doubling of federal spending on airport expansion over the next five years &mdash; but would pay the bill with a controversial departures tax. 
 Tate &amp; Lyle began talks with Berisford, another British sugar company, about a possible merger. 
 America's Federal Highway Administration said it might invest in smart roads which could warn drivers of traffic jams and electronically collect tolls for using the road. 
 New departures 
 Details of new economic reform in the Soviet Union emerged. 
 The government says it will break up state monopolies, liberalise prices, set up an independent central bank and introduce a single rouble exchange rate. 
 Peter Quinnen, head of James Capel, a top British stockbrokerage, resigned. 
 The firm's parent, the Hongkong and Shanghai Bank, despaired at James Capel's lack of profits. 
 Nevertheless, it was unamused by Mr Quinnen's attempts to find a new (Japanese) owner. 
 LEADERS 
 Superglue Gorbachev 
 By holding the party together, he holds the country back 
 IT IS a pity that Mikhail Gorbachev survived the move to oust him as leader of the Communist Party last month. 
 A pity because, had he lost that job, the party would almost certainly have split. 
 And a split is what is needed if democratic politics is to develop in the Soviet Union. 
 Haven't the Communists already become an irrelevance, in a country that is changing so fast? 
 Alas, no. 
 Mr Gorbachev himself, in deciding to battle on as their leader, clearly does not think so. 
 True, the party is a shadow of its Leninist self. 
 It has lost a great deal besides its guaranteed monopoly of power: its sense of purpose, its old dominance over the economy, many of its perks &mdash; these have gone, along with 1.8m members last year alone. 
 But that still leaves it with about 16m people, vast assets and a formidable ability to mobilise and disrupt. 
 However the Soviet drama unfolds, the Communist Party or its derivatives are bound to play a big part. 
 The non-Communist forces, in contrast, are scattered. 
 Certainly, assorted nationalists now dominate half a dozen outlying republics, and Boris Yeltsin can stir the masses. 
 But Mr Yeltsin has no political party. 
 In his Russian heartland the democrats, repeating the mistakes of their predecessors before 1917, have failed to organise themselves into a cohesive opposition. 
 They are hopelessly fragmented. 
 An issue that typically divides them &mdash; and caused the largest opposition group, the Democratic Party, to split at its congress last month &mdash; is whether to compromise with the Communists or to work for their complete removal. 
 Recognise your weakness 
 The argument is academic. 
 For the moment the democrats in Russia are far too weak to take power on their own. 
 Cohabitation with reform-minded Communists is their only chance of breaking out of their lonely weakness. 
 The trouble is that the reform-minded Communists are still in bed with barely reformed Stalinists. 
 The Communist Party now contains an extraordinary range of opinion, from old believers to reformers who are closer in outlook to middle-of-the-road democrats than to their hardline comrades. 
 Some of the reformers recently banded together as &bquo;Communists for Democracy&equo; and gave Mr Yeltsin a vital bit of support in the Russian parliament. 
 But it will be hard to accept that these people are serious about democracy &mdash; or can do much more to further its cause &mdash; so long as they stay in the same party as democracy-haters. 
 Bolsheviks and Mensheviks, please 
 Hence the need for a split. 
 Last summer, at the Communists' congress, an attempt by the so-called Democratic Platform to break the party in two failed miserably (in the end it was the Platform that collapsed). 
 Despite all their differences, the Communists are still holding together. 
 Why? 
 One reason is emotional. 
 For many Communists, it is hard to break with the party that looked after them, that they believed in, that their parents fought for. 
 Another reason is strictly practical. 
 The party is rich in buildings, printing presses, holiday homes; if it were to break into bits, there would be a battle over who kept the goodies. 
 Before a split, better make sure you are with the majority faction (or Bolsheviks), for the Mensheviks are likely to lose out. 
 However, these emotions and practicalities are no longer what really prevents the party from coming unstuck. 
 The superglue is Mr Gorbachev. 
 Reformers see him as protection against the Stalinist wing they still fear (and many of them hope that maybe, deep down, he is still on their side). 
 Hardliners reckon that without him they could not withstand a reformist onslaught for long. 
 As for Mr Gorbachev himself, he is desperate for the party to stay in one piece because he knows that, once on their own, neither hardliners nor reformers would be likely to want him as their leader. 
 He would still be state president, but he would lose his real power base. 
 That is why he manoeuvred frantically, and brilliantly, to fend off the challenge to his party leadership last month. 
 The best that can be said of his success on that occasion is that it postponed the period of uncertainty that a split in the party would bring. 
 But that is a prize that will not last. 
 It may now be time to risk the uncertainty of a split. 
 Without Mr Gorbachev as party boss, a rapid realignment of forces would take place, making it possible for a coalition-for-democracy to line up against the coalition-for-clampdown. 
 With him as party boss, the current impasse will continue.  
 Aid and enterprise 
 The World Bank needs to change, but America's prodding is unhelpful 
 THE Bush administration has blocked a capital increase for the International Finance Corporation (IFC), an arm of that large and unloved bureaucracy, the World Bank. 
 America wants the Bank to change its ways, and lend less to the third world's governments and more to its private businesses. 
 This demand is not quite as plausible as it looks, though it deserves to be taken seriously. 
 America's way of pressing it, however, could hardly have been more absurd. 
 America has attacked the bit of the Bank expressly designed to promote private enterprise in the developing countries. 
 The IFC makes equity investments in companies and stockmarkets; lends directly to private businesses; tells governments how to privatise state-owned enterprises; helps to establish new capital markets; and so forth. 
 In short, it does on a small scale what America wants the World Bank to do on a bigger scale. 
 The administration should be the champion of the IFC, not, as during the past few weeks, its worst enemy. 
 The art of development lending 
 If the row over the IFC's capital increase is not settled soon, work will be delayed that, according to the administration itself, badly needs to be done. 
 But the main question posed by America will still need to be answered: should the Bank as a whole recast itself as a lender to private enterprise? 
 That would be a big change. 
 The Bank's articles of association require an official guarantee for its loans; in effect, they oblige the Bank to lend to governments. 
 Without the guarantee it would be hard for the Bank to keep its high credit rating; without that rating, poor borrowers would have to pay more for their Bank loans. 
 The goal of the World Bank is clear enough: to promote growth in poor countries. 
 The best way to do that is to help businesses flourish. 
 In almost all countries, state-owned enterprises are far less efficient than their private counterparts; governments, shielded from market pressures, are often careless and profligate investors. 
 But lending directly to private businesses may not be the best way to help them. 
 Enterprise in the third world tends to be hampered less by lack of capital than by bad economic policies and missing infrastructure. 
 If policies are to improve, third-world governments need to be subjected to a shrewd combination of pressure and advice. 
 And if the infrastructure of schools, health centres, roads and irrigation is to be created, governments will often need to borrow; such investments are long-term and yield no direct cash returns, so private lenders are unlikely to be keen. 
 Here is the gap that the Bank is equipped to fill: by lending for infrastructure (or to ease the financial burden of changes in economic policy), and by tying advice and policy-strings to these loans, it can meet both needs. 
 In this way the operations of the Bank and the IFC are complementary. 
 Without a foundation of good policy and adequate infrastructure, help to the private sector from the IFC or anywhere else is likely to be wasted. 
 The balance between the Bank's traditional operations and those of the IFC should be shifted further in the latter's direction; that is why the IFC's capital increase ought to go ahead. 
 But the present definition of responsibilities is broadly correct. 
 In other words, America's officials have missed the point. 
 What matters is not to rethink the Bank's role, but to make the Bank as good as possible at the job it already has. 
 Nearly half of the Bank's borrower-governments break their promises about economic policy. 
 Partly for that reason, too many projects yield poor returns. 
 Sometimes the Bank's investments fail in other ways, too, causing environmental or social harm. 
 Without a doubt, the Bank can do better. 
 Lewis Preston, its new president, must make it more skilful and more efficient. 
 Above all, though, the Bank should be harsher on bad economic policy &mdash; even when (America, please note) this annoys governments which the Bank's rich-country shareholders would prefer to be friends with.  
 The Palestine puzzle 
 There is an opportunity for peace behind the brick wall James Baker found in Damascus and Jerusalem 
 HAVING offered America's help to make peace between Israel and the Arabs, James Baker has discovered something odd. 
 America wants peace in the Middle East more than Arabs or Israelis do. 
 Indeed, the governments of the region seem quite ungrateful when the well-meaning secretary of state turns up on their doorsteps. 
 He offers them another unsettling peacemaking idea; they invent another excuse for turning it down. 
 The question during Mr Baker's recent tour was whether Israel's Yitzhak Shamir or Syria's Hafez Assad would run out of excuses first. 
 For over 30 years Israel had no need of excuses. 
 No Arab state except Egypt was willing to talk peace. 
 In 1982 the Arabs relented, but said that (a) they needed the cover of an &bquo;international conference&equo; and (b) that Yasser Arafat's Palestine Liberation Organisation would have to be present, too. 
 Until the cold war ended, Israel could rely on America objecting to (a) because an international conference required the participation of the Soviet Union. 
 That objection has gone. 
 As for (b), by supporting Iraq in the Gulf war Mr Arafat made himself so unpopular that most Arab governments no longer want him to be involved. 
 One by one, Israel's reasons for declining to go to a peace conference are being whittled away. 
 The main obstacle now is the United Nations. 
 Syria says the UN should have a starring role at any conference. 
 Israel would prefer it to play no part at all. 
 The issue is not quite as petty as it seems. 
 Israel thinks Syria wants the UN there because Mr Assad has not accepted, in his heart, the need for face-to-face negotiation with the Jewish state. 
 He would like to rig the conference so that Israel goes on trial, with America as its attorney and the United Nations as judge and executioner. 
 Given the UN's notorious unfriendliness to Israel (remember the General Assembly's Zionism-is-racism resolution), the Israeli complaint has some force. 
 But it is also, in a way, just another excuse. 
 The naive observer of Mr Baker's travels might wonder why Israel wants excuses. 
 Ordinary Israelis pay a heavy price &mdash; in regular wars, occasional bombardment by ballistic missiles, random knifings by hate-filled Palestinians &mdash; for the absence of peace. 
 Opinion polls show that many of them are prepared to sacrifice territory to end the conflict. 
 Except for the stateless Palestinians, nobody else in the Middle East stands to gain more from peace. 
 So why suspect Israel, of all countries, of trying to sabotage Mr Baker's peace mission? 
 The answer lies in drawing a distinction between Israel and its present government. 
 After half a century of rejection by the Arab world, Israelis have reason to doubt whether handing back the territories they captured in 1967 would make any lasting difference to Arab attitudes. 
 If they think peace is impossible, they will hang on to the extra layer of defence these territories provide. 
 But it is neither fear of the Arabs, nor a belief in the impossibility of peace, that explains the attachment of Mr Shamir's Likud Party to the West Bank. 
 He, and the leaders of the extremist parties in coalition with him, are motivated primarily by ideology. 
 They say the West Bank is Israel's land, literally by divine right. 
 The sad thing about the past decade is that, by playing upon (and then hijacking) the legitimate fears of their secular compatriots, these ideologues have come to dominate Israel's politics. 
 The do-nothing temptation 
 In theory, Mr Shamir's obstinacy on territory leaves Mr Baker with four options. 
 He can work towards a peace that does not entail Israel leaving the West Bank; he can force Israel out of the West Bank by applying economic pressure; he can give up altogether; or he can try to break that Likud armlock on Israeli politics. 
 In practice, only the last two of these options look feasible. 
 If Israel stays permanently in the West Bank, the Arabs will not offer peace; and the American Congress is not likely to support sanctions against Israel. 
 So Mr Baker can either give up, or he can work at weakening Likud. 
 Giving up is not usually the American way, but it does have some attractions. 
 If the Americans accepted that the Israel-Palestine problem was insoluble, at least for now, they could concentrate on what really matters to them in the Middle East. 
 This is not the fate of the Palestinians, but avoiding another Arab-Israeli war. 
 That prospect is anyway slight so long as Soviet-American cosiness continues and Iraq's war machine remains broken. 
 An America that stopped trying to &bquo;solve&equo; the conflict could still try to keep it manageable: by promoting arms control, say, or making Israel treat the Palestinians more gently. 
 In the Gulf war many Arab regimes supporting the alliance were uncomfortably aware that the Palestine issue was being used against them. 
 Some might be happy to see it pushed, temporarily, to the margins. 
 The idea of giving up sounds enticing, but it would be a mistake. 
 The conflict over Palestine is not insoluble, if the Arabs bring to the table a peace offer that ordinary Israelis feel they can safely accept. 
 Indeed, it is fear of the other side proving reasonable that makes Mr Shamir, and the extremists on the Arab side, strive so hard to block the road to negotiation. 
 Only one outside power is capable of removing those roadblocks. 
 Mr Baker must keep up the peacemaking.  
 Rethinking NATO 
 Change it as times change, but do not split it up 
 NOW that the blush of embarrassment at their mixed showing in the Gulf war has worn off, Europeans have gone back to doing what they do best: dickering over abstractions. 
 In Washington this week Germany's Helmut Kohl insisted that uniting Europe would not mean undermining NATO. 
 But Europe's obsession with clearing a path to a common foreign and defence policy risks doing just that. 
 With the cold war declared over, a lot of Europeans wonder whether they still need a NATO. 
 A lot of Americans are meanwhile disenchanted with an alliance that commits them to defending a Europe that could do more for itself &mdash; especially a Europe that offers America so little, so ungraciously, in return. 
 Without some clear thinking about what Europeans and Americans still need from one another, the transatlantic partnership that has kept Europe safe for half a century will break apart. 
 Neither side relishes a divorce. 
 Even France, ever prickly about American influence, wants some American soldiers to stay in Europe. 
 The Soviet Union may now be a tamer neighbour, but with more tanks and guns than NATO-Europe's armies combined, and with its nuclear missiles pointing westwards, it still poses a big potential danger. 
 If push ever did come again to shove, American muscles would be needed to push back. 
 Large non-Soviet dangers exist, too. 
 The war in the Gulf was a reminder of the instability along NATO's southern flank; long-range missiles are spreading dangerously in the third world; Eastern Europe is never short of alarming political wobbles. 
 Such common risks to the interests and values they all share still give the allies plenty to fret about collectively. 
 Why, then, is their alliance at risk? 
 One threat comes from Europe's desire to carry its Euro-integration into foreign policy, security policy and ultimately defence policy. 
 Euro-visionaries claim it is possible to strengthen European defence co-operation in collaboration with America, not in competition with it. 
 That sounds like a fine formula. 
 But the more Europeans insist on taking decisions on security and, eventually, defence matters without America, the more miffed Americans are liable to feel. 
 No defence collaboration without representation will be the refrain, as Americans increasingly ask themselves what is in it for them. 
 Ask not what America can do for you 
 The old answer to sceptical Americans, trotted out by Europeans whenever transatlantic ties were strained in the past, is that the United States is in Europe defending its own interests, not just those of Europe. 
 America was founded on a rejection of the things it disliked about Europe. 
 But the 20th century showed that, whatever the distractions in other parts of the globe, America turns its back on Europe at its peril. 
 Since it always ends up being drawn back to Europe, a presence that can be swiftly reinforced makes better sense than a withdrawal followed by a panicky rush back when some new danger arises. 
 Anyway, with the Soviet threat on the wane and the Europeans proposing to take on more of the burden that is left, the cost to the United States of staying on in Europe will henceforth be smaller. 
 The trouble is that such verities are no longer enough. 
 The fading of the cold war has not only changed what Europeans can expect from America, it has changed what Americans expect of Europe. 
 In the past Europe looked to America for support against a predictable Soviet threat to the survival of European democracy. 
 Today America must be able to look to Europe for support in containing less predictable threats to the values they have in common from outside Europe. 
 There's the rub. 
 It is not just the attraction of European union that encourages France and Germany, in particular, to push for a common European defence: it is that of America-distancing. 
 Although France wants American soldiers in Europe, America's leadership in the Gulf war (in which France at least played a part) seems only to have confirmed French fears that military co-operation outside Europe means American domination. 
 And although Mr Kohl promises that Germany will eventually amend its constitution and shoulder its proper military responsibilities in the world, he would prefer to sell that to his own people as a pro-European gesture than as a pro-American one. 
 The risk is that the professed desire of Europeans to co-ordinate their policies more closely masks a prospect of joint inaction. 
 Euro-hopefuls argue that if Europe had already been committed to a common foreign and security policy, its military contribution in the Gulf would have been swifter and more effective. 
 Really? 
 Unlike NATO, which came together for collective defence, the European Community includes neutral Ireland and may soon include neutral Sweden and Austria too. 
 How long would America have had to wait for the Community to pull all its members behind a common policy? 
 And how blurry would that policy have had to be in order to be described as common? 
 This is why NATO has no real substitute. 
 It is not just the presence of American troops that protects Europe; it is the habit of collective policy-making with America, joint exercises, the rehearsal of such war-winning concepts as the land-air battle, and a collective infrastructure. 
 These are things Europe cannot do effectively on its own. 
 These are habits that must now be reworked to meet threats that are vaguer, more elusive and spread across more of the world than precisely identified units of the Soviet army. 
 The task may be daunting &mdash; the weary-minded would say impossible. 
 But it is far more worthwhile than being polite about an old alliance, and equipping it with new &bquo;pillars&equo; that crumble when the next unexpected bugle sounds.  
 Patient persuasion needed 
 The British government could be a lot clearer about who its health reforms are designed to help 
 THE long-overdue reform of Britain's national health service (NHS) started on April 1st and quickly turned into a shouting-match. 
 The Labour Party insists that self-governing trusts (hospitals which choose to opt out of health-authority control and manage their own affairs) are in fact opting out of the NHS altogether; and that doctors who control their own budgets are going to turn queue-jumping at hospitals into a business practice. 
 By making these charges, Labour has boosted its longstanding efforts to persuade voters that the Tories have a secret agenda for the NHS: privatisation. 
 If it manages to make that charge stick, it will have got itself a powerful vote-winner. 
 The Conservatives, first under Margaret Thatcher and now under John Major, will have only themselves to blame. 
 The reforms deserve something better than the babble that has followed them from birth. 
 Their essence &mdash; setting up a division between the buyers of health care (usually health authorities) and its providers (often hospitals) &mdash; represents a huge improvement in the running of the NHS. 
 The job of the buyers is to assess the health needs of people in their area and then see that those needs are met as quickly and effectively as possible. 
 The job of the providers is to come up with best combination of service and cost. 
 This split will force the NHS to pay more attention to the needs of patients and less to the convenience of doctors. 
 It will link the income of hospitals to their success in attracting patients. 
 It will bring greater clarity into choosing how to spend public money on health. 
 All these are excellent aims. 
 They should also be relatively simple to explain, and to understand. 
 Yet the government has long managed to appear as though it was teaching Pythagoras to four-year-olds. 
 Putting patients first 
 Shifting to a patient-driven health system was never going to be easy &mdash; especially not for the Tories. 
 After the Red Army, the NHS is the largest employer in Europe. 
 Its staff, who will be shaken up, are visible and well-organised; the patients, who will benefit, are unorganised. 
 But the government did a singularly poor job in getting its patient-centred message across. 
 The 1988 white paper which introduced the reforms was sensibly called &bquo;Working for Patients&equo;; to listen to ministers and other Tory politicians, it might have been called &bquo;Working for Accountants&equo;. 
 Right from the start, the people who dreamed up the reforms made the mistake of including buzz-words &mdash; the &bquo;internal market&equo; and &bquo;opted-out&equo; are the most glaring examples &mdash; which seemed intended to flatter Mrs Thatcher rather than to inform Mr Average. 
 Tory politicians compounded this mistake by talking too much about means, too little about ends. 
 They waxed lyrical on the virtues of introducing business-like methods and improving resource management. 
 They hardly mentioned the patients. 
 To have any chance now of holding his own, the new health secretary, William Waldegrave has, first, to explain how the old-style NHS failed its patients. 
 Hospitals kept them waiting for scarce beds, but sat on acres of land in the middle of booming cities. 
 Health authorities complained that they could not afford expensive drugs, but failed to use their buying power to drive down prices from all their suppliers. 
 In London the NHS spent heavily on state-of-the-art medical equipment for hospitals, but invested too little in primary care for Londoners. 
 British nurses were among the best trained in Europe but &mdash; thanks to the restrictive practices of the medical profession &mdash; were given the most limited responsibilities. 
 Mr Waldegrave should next spend more time explaining how the reforms will help put patients first. 
 Performance-related pay for general practitioners (GPs) &mdash; an innovation bitterly resisted by the British Medical Association &mdash; is already driving up rates of childhood immunisation and of testing for cervical cancer. 
 Some hospital trusts in the inner cities may be shedding staff, but others in the suburbs and the shires are recruiting new staff and cutting waiting-lists. 
 Budget-holding is encouraging GPs to perform minor operations themselves rather than put patients on hospital waiting-lists. 
 Before the reforms, GPs routinely referred patients with rheumatoid arthritis to hospital-based rheumatologists. 
 The waiting time was about six weeks, and each booking cost the NHS &pound;150. 
 Now budget-holding GPs are finding it quicker and far cheaper to do the job themselves. 
 Mr Waldegrave should also point out that his reforms will make the NHS more equitable as well as more efficient. 
 Money will be awarded to health authorities according to the size and needs of their populations, not (as now) by vague tradition. 
 Getting such truths over should not be impossible. 
 The reforms enjoy the support of a growing number of people in the medical profession itself. 
 The health authorities are belatedly starting to explain their new role to the people they are supposed to serve. 
 Many other European countries, regardless of the political complexion of their governments, are reforming health care along internal-market lines (see page 30). 
 Dr Waldegrave to post-natal care, quickly.  
 ICI digs in 
 There is no public-policy reason to oppose a bid. 
 There are plenty of reasons why ICI should be shaken up 
 ALTHOUGH more than a week has passed since Hanson bought 2.82% of Britain's ICI, the only certainty about that stake is that the world's fourth-largest chemicals company will never be the same again. 
 By Thursday morning there was still no takeover bid for ICI. 
 Nor, perhaps, will there ever be one. 
 But, rightly, ICI is acting as if a bid is imminent, preparing its defences and making plans for itself in a way that guarantees that much will change at the firm. 
 Meanwhile, the kite that Lord Hanson has flown is bobbing around in the political and financial winds. 
 It is doing so in a way that does not give wind a good name. 
 The most bothersome political breeze is the idea that, on public-interest grounds, officials &mdash; whether in Britain or the European Community &mdash; must consider (ie, reject) a takeover by Hanson of a company of the size and prominence of ICI. 
 There are only two possible grounds for worrying about the ownership of ICI: national security, and competition. 
 If Saddam Hussein or Colonel Qaddaffi were bidding for control of a firm that employs 130,000 people, makes explosives and could be made to make chemical weapons, that would be reason for concern. 
 James Hanson is not Saddam Hussein. 
 Nor is there any likelihood of competition being diminished, except in the case of one minor product, titanium dioxide. 
 ICI, in its involvement during the 1980s in illegal cartels for polypropylene, PVC and other materials, has been shown by the EC to threaten competition more on its own than Hanson ever has. 
 The public may be interested in whether a bid is made, but it has no legitimate interest to defend. 
 If what was at stake was the existence of ICI, rather than its ownership, then concern would be understandable. 
 Many people would lose their jobs if the firm were to go bankrupt; skills and research would be lost; for Britain's largest manufacturer to vanish would be quite a blow. 
 But takeovers are not the same as bankruptcies. 
 Nobody is going to pay &pound;10 billion (&dollar;17 billion) or more just in order to destroy ICI. 
 Which brings in the financial tornado: the myth of the stripper. 
 Lord Hanson's firm, it is said, is an asset-stripper, not a real business, and is therefore not fit to buy a firm like ICI. 
 This term, a throwback to the early 1970s, is well past retirement age. 
 If Hanson sells assets that do not work fruitfully together, it is not stripping them; it is finding them new and better homes. 
 ICI itself acted as a new home when in 1985 it spent &dollar;750m on the chemicals operations of Beatrice, an American group then being bought by Kohlberg, Kravis, Roberts, a firm similar to Hanson. 
 Doubtless ICI thinks that it has provided a good home for those stripped assets. 
 And in its &dollar;1.7 billion purchase of Stauffer, another American chemicals firm, in 1987 it did a passable impersonation of Hanson, paying for most of the bid with &dollar;1.15 billion of asset sales. 
 ICI cannot argue that the buyers of its assets would all be rogues, especially now that the party-time stockmarkets of the late 1980s have been sobered up by recession. 
 No public interest, no asset-stripping: how, then, should ICI respond? 
 By recognising that it has more to learn from Hanson than to fear. 
 In their different ways, Hanson and ICI are doing much the same thing: running a portfolio of businesses. 
 Ever since it was formed in a merger 55 years ago, ICI's portfolio has had to change with the times. 
 Hanson's investment is a clue that change is again overdue. 
 Imperial strip-tease 
 Hanson does not simply buy companies and break them up. 
 It buys them, sells some bits quickly, but then keeps the rest to manage for the long term. 
 Its choice of what to buy, sell or keep (see page 103) depends on clear eyes, not dreamy hopes. 
 It nurtures humdrum businesses such as bricks and tobacco. 
 In some areas, such as titanium dioxide, a pigment for paints and plastics, it is challenging ICI on innovation. 
 It sells businesses it does not think it will be good at, such as those in high-technology, volatile markets. 
 ICI also owns commodity businesses, where basic research counts for little. 
 But it differs from Hanson in its attachment to fancier activities, where men in white coats are essential. 
 It thinks, presumably, that it is good at everything it does. 
 Its profits record, which has been far from outstanding, suggests that it is wrong. 
 Concentrating on what you do well is not solely a Hanson preserve. 
 When the British government sold its last stake in BP in 1987, the oil firm realised that it might be vulnerable to a bid, so it began to strip itself. 
 Its mines, for instance, were worth more in the hands of RTZ, which bought them. 
 ICI has done nothing so bold. 
 It has nibbled at the problem, closing down its fertiliser business after failing to sell it. 
 Just as B.A.T started unbundling itself when Sir James Goldsmith bid for the tobacco group in 1989, so must ICI. 
 Discussions at the firm during the past 12 months (see page 98) suggest that many ICI staff already accept this. 
 The worst response would be the sort that has already begun to be hinted at for ICI: protecting itself through a tangle of joint ventures. 
 That was what Lord Weinstock did when his GEC seemed threatened two years ago. 
 The likeliest outcome would be to make a bureaucratic, clumsily managed conglomerate even more bureaucratic and more clumsy. 
 To protect Britain's biggest manufacturer by making it less efficient: now that should really worry the public.  
 In praise of touts 
 Why scalping is in the public interest 
 TICKET touts are not known for their flair for public relations. 
 They loiter outside the big match with fistfuls of grubby tickets priced at many times their face value. 
 Their customers are free not to buy. 
 But they do, and then feel cheated. 
 The grandees of sport and theatre are distressed. 
 Real fans, they say, need protecting; profiteering must be stopped. 
 Persecuting the tout &mdash; and, if possible, prosecuting him as well &mdash; has become a sport in itself. 
 Earlier this month a bill began its passage through California's legislature which would sentence touts, or scalpers as it calls them, to a fine of &dollar;1,000 or a year in jail. 
 A law passed in Pennsylvania last summer gives touts a &dollar;5,000 fine or two years behind bars. 
 When governments refuse to legislate, as in Britain, sport's organisers dream up complicated schemes to prevent touting. 
 Whinges about the black market for centre-court tickets are as much a part of the Wimbledon tennis championships as thunderstorms are &mdash; but this year's new rules mean that any tout reselling tickets at Wimbledon next month could end up in a magistrate's court. 
 Yours for a tenner, guv 
 Such repressive measures are entirely misguided. 
 Perhaps touts spend their free time mugging old ladies and fencing stolen cars. 
 By all means prosecute them for that. 
 But when they are scalping, they are working in the public interest. 
 Touts make money when the demand for their tickets greatly exceeds the supply at the official price. 
 Under such circumstances a ticket can be worth less to its owner than to somebody else; if so, a sale will benefit both parties. 
 However much the buyer may complain, he acted voluntarily: he is better off than he would otherwise have been. 
 In this transaction the tout is merely an agent. 
 In return for his scalping services, he rightly takes a cut. 
 Remember that the scalper sometimes loses money. 
 He takes risks &mdash; that the big stars will be there on the day, that rain will not stop play. 
 Those risks can turn sour, as they do for any pin-striped market-maker. 
 The tout has other costs to cover, too: these include not just his time, but also the capital cost of his initial outlay and the psychic cost of being a social outcast. 
 Remember, too, that he is hardly ever a monopolist: he works in fierce competition with fellow scalpers. 
 So the scalper's cut is not a monopoly rent, but a fair price for a service efficiently rendered. 
 The real question is why the scalper's services are needed in the first place. 
 Sometimes, as with theatres, underpricing happens because organisers choose not to set their prices according to the market &mdash; charging the same for tickets on Saturday night as on Wednesday, for instance. 
 In sports, season tickets set the same price for all events, regardless of popularity. 
 Promoters have their reasons for pricing this way; having done so, they should see that touts provide a useful service. 
 When demand outstrips supply by the widest margin, the reason is usually that the original seller is trying to rig the market &mdash; as at the FA Cup final, or Wimbledon. 
 Privileged insiders get tickets at knockdown prices, while others are excluded. 
 Real fans should thank the touts for exposing such wicked goings-on. 
 That's right: scalpers are fighters for justice, too.  
 India's trial 
 ASSASSINATION, said Disraeli, never changed the history of the world. 
 He may have been right, in his day. 
 But the bomb that killed Rajiv Gandhi this week sent its blast through an India already on the edge of tragedy. 
 That is why a single act of political barbarism, in the southern town of Sriperumbudur on the night of May 21st, may yet smash the world's biggest democracy into sectarian fragments. 
 Mr Gandhi's murder came in the middle of a general-election campaign that had already been marred by more killing, intimidation and vote-grabbing than India had seen in any of its nine previous elections. 
 Sikh separatists, Assamese secessionists, Tamil militants, Bihari gangsters, Kashmiri guerrillas &mdash; all had provided bloody evidence, well before the election, of an India sliding towards ungovernability. 
 The lofty idea that India could endure as a secular democracy of diverse peoples had come under open attack from the Hindu chauvinists of the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). 
 Despite being an affront to the memory of Mahatma Gandhi, the founding father of independent India, the BJP's attack had been immensely popular. 
 Equally depressing, in its implicit rejection of the notion that merit deserves reward, was the cynical appeal made to the lower castes and the Muslims by V. P. Singh's Janata Dal Party. 
 Yet India contains not just the forces of fragmentation, but also reserves of strength. 
 One is the refusal of its generals, in contrast to their counterparts in Pakistan and Bangladesh, to be drawn into politics. 
 The other is the resilience of the union. 
 Even in its infancy, India was strong enough to survive the assassination of Mahatma Gandhi in 1948. 
 Decades later, in 1984, the sense of unity was still strong enough to calm the sectarian anger that followed the murder of Rajiv Gandhi's mother, Indira. 
 Mr Gandhi's murder is a new and testing tragedy. 
 But neither as a national leader nor as a party politician was he as commanding as his mother or his grandfather, Jawaharlal Nehru, India's first prime minister. 
 Why should his death, however tragic, threaten irreparable damage to an institutional structure of such proven strength? 
 The answer lies in India's recent wasted years, for which Mr Gandhi was partly responsible. 
 He was a charming man, and a brave man (his decision to lower the wall of security between himself and the voters must have encouraged his assassins). 
 But he lacked the intellectual force which his mother and grandfather had, and which he needed if he was to fulfil his ambition to drag India &bquo;into the 21st century&equo;. 
 The opportunity was there: when he became prime minister after his mother's assassination by Sikh extremists, he carried with him the goodwill and sympathy of both parliament and public. 
 He talked of opening the economy to the modernising forces of technology and the market, and of ending the corruption that pervades every stratum of an infinitely stratified country. 
 He calmed secessionist sentiment by dealing constructively with the regional parties of Kashmir, Assam and Punjab. 
 Ultimately, though, he failed. 
 By the time he and the Congress Party were humbled in the 1989 election, his administration had fallen prey to all the usual vices of Indian factionalism. 
 Party colleagues, notably Mr Singh, deserted him, and his own reputation was tarnished by allegations that he had taken bribes from Bofors, a Swedish arms company. 
 Out of office, he played the politics of Machiavelli. 
 Chandra Shekhar's minority government rested on the support of Congress &mdash; support which Mr Gandhi then chose to withdraw, thus bringing about the present election. 
 When he died, India was still too far from the 21st century. 
 Can it complete the journey, as one nation, without him? 
 Since his widow, Sonia, has declined appointment in his place as president of the Congress Party, his murder will probably mark the end of the Nehru dynasty which has ruled India for 40 of its 44 years of independence. 
 The Nehru creed was of India as a secular union. 
 Its doctrine was self-sufficiency and the Fabian socialism that Nehru's generation imbibed during the struggle against colonialism. 
 The creed still makes sense but, as both Mr Gandhi and Mr Singh began dimly to realise in the 1980s, the doctrine does not. 
 The necessary journey 
 After this week's murder, India's first task is to keep the idea of secularism alive. 
 Only under a secular constitution can a nation of nearly 850m people that is divided and then sub-divided by race, religion and caste stay peacefully together for the journey ahead. 
 Lal Krishna Advani's BJP argues that a nation that is 80% Hindu can peacefully assume an official Hindu identity. 
 The argument is both dangerous and disingenuous. 
 India's minorities are huge &mdash; Muslims alone number 100m &mdash; and spread throughout the country. 
 When the banner of religion is raised as a banner of politics, blood will flow, just as it has done in Belfast, Beirut and Colombo. 
 India of all places should know that. 
 Vast numbers died in the 1947 partition of Muslim Pakistan from Hindu-dominated India. 
 Last year's attempts by the BJP to build a Hindu temple on the disputed site of a mosque in Ayodhya sparked off murderous riots across the nation. 
 Indira Gandhi's assassination was itself an act of revenge by her Sikh bodyguards, after hundreds of Sikhs were killed during the clearing of extremists from their Golden Temple in Amritsar. 
 That is why, in the short run, it matters enormously who was responsible for Mr Gandhi's assassination. 
 If, as the government's first reports suggested, the blame lies with disaffected Tamils, so much the better &mdash; the Indian masses care little about the problems of Tamil separatism in Sri Lanka. 
 Heaven forbid that Sikhs or Muslims are to blame. 
 To Congress, the task 
 When the election campaign resumes, the responsibility for India's future could well revert to the Congress Party. 
 It was already showing strength in the exit polls, and may now be boosted by a sympathy vote. 
 That is a better outcome than an India dominated by the likes of the BJP, or by the Marxist members of Mr Singh's National Front coalition, or by the woolly minds of Mr Chandra Shekhar's Socialist Janata Dal. 
 Congress's hands may be soiled, but at least they are experienced, a fact which the voters have begun again to appreciate. 
 If the party can command India's electoral centre, it stands a chance of keeping India secular, at one and at peace. 
 An India that overcomes its present political trial will still have work to do. 
 It must be fierce about preserving Nehru's creed of secularism, but equally fierce about ditching the failed policies of economic interventionism and self-sufficiency that he attached to it. 
 India's economic failure is not the cause of the hatred between its religions, but it makes the hatreds worse. 
 A country where the average income is only &dollar;350 a year, and where the poor jostle for space as well as food, will never find it easy to bind up its factional wounds. 
 Mr Gandhi was probably the last of the Nehru rulers, of whom the Congress Party is a creation. 
 But he had the unhappy knack of making enemies in the party. 
 The end of family rule may now give Congress a chance to reunite. 
 If Congress brings itself to adopt the economic freedoms which have made so much of Asia rich &mdash; but which India's intellectual and social elites have smugly rejected &mdash; the yearned-for 21st century is within its grasp. 
 If it fails, the world's biggest democracy will be even less able to survive the next assassin's blow. 
 LETTERS 
 Trustbusting 
 As one of the bright-eyed and Washington-bound young lawyers from Columbia referred to in your leader (&bquo;America's timid trustbusters&equo;, April 27th), I question your nostalgia for American antitrust enforcement in the 1960s. 
 The period you so fondly remember was dominated by activist and economically unschooled regulators and judges. 
 They blocked efficient economic combinations that posed no competitive risk to anyone, except the merging parties' slower-footed rivals. 
 In one notable Supreme Court decision, the government was allowed to bar a merger of two Los Angeles supermarket chains whose combined market share was only 7.5%. 
 The government acknowledged that this merger posed no immediate risk to consumers, but reasoned that other chains in the area might follow the example. 
 With logic like this carrying the day, it is little wonder that one dissenting judge observed that the only rule of law governing merger cases in this period was that the government always won. 
 Levels of antitrust enforcement in the United States have moved in cycles. 
 Things have begun to swing towards more enforcement after a period in which, as you note, the Sherman and Clayton acts were forgotten and the authorities charged with enforcing them were starved of resources. 
 Given the political pressures that often drive antitrust policy, a consistently optimal level of enforcement may be too much to ask for. 
 I hope, however, that you will not think me Panglossian when I suggest that we are now not far from that point. 
 At least we are much nearer than we were in the era your rose-coloured glasses have alighted upon.  
 Chicago GILAD OHANA 
 You seem to think that 1960s' antitrust law enforcement was wonderful because the government &bquo;took on giants the size of AT&amp;T and IBM and broke up a merger of Procter &amp; Gamble and Clorox.&equo; 
 In fact, the government &bquo;took on&equo; AT&amp;T in the 1970s, and it was the Reagan administration of the 1980s &mdash; the villain of your piece &mdash; that secured real relief and brought on the phenomenal competition enjoyed today by refusing to accept the cosmetic settlement that had been negotiated by the Carter administration. 
 And do you seriously believe that the American or world computer industry would be better today if IBM had been broken up into five pieces 20 years ago, as the 1960s and 1970s trustbusters proposed? 
 Or might we still be awaiting the development of personal computers by some Japanese company? 
 The proof is in the pudding. 
 The antitrust policy of the Reagan administration was part and parcel of an overall effort to get the government out of the market, and to permit competition to set prices and production. 
 The result was low inflation, job creation that was the envy of the developed world, and general prosperity. 
 QED.  
 Washington, DC JEFFREY ZUCKERMAN 
 The uneducated English 
 University is where a small range of closely related subjects is studied in depth. 
 In England, therefore, university starts at the age of 16 and lasts for five years. 
 At the end of the second year there is a stiff examination that knocks out about a quarter of the students. 
 The others move to different premises, where nearly all of them are given degrees three years later. 
 Your suggestion for A-levels, to keep one in-depth subject and cover five or six others at a lower level, will not work (April 27th). 
 Universities will accept applications mostly from youngsters who have done well in their in-depth subject, so 16-year-olds will still have to make the decision about their careers at an age when many are not ready, and two years before most other Europeans. 
 The decision-making age must truly be shifted from 16 to 18; the way to do that is to increase the number of A-levels to six for university entrance, and require passes in all of them. 
 Some first degrees should also be lengthened to four years. 
 Nothing else will have the necessary teeth to convince youngsters &mdash; and the world &mdash; that we really mean it.  
 London JOHN SHEPHERD 
 What I fear is that A-levels will be diluted without at the same time lengthening degree courses, particularly mathematical ones, to maintain standards. 
 This point must be addressed by those in and out of government and education before changes are made. 
 Please don't let the pattern of the change from O-levels to  GCSE  be repeated, introducing yet another mismatch, this time between school and university.  
 Oxford R.C.E. DEVENISH 
 What you advocate is similar to the International Baccalaureat, a successful school-leaving certificate pioneered by the International School in Geneva and now accepted by reputable universities worldwide, including Britain. 
 Graduates pass final examinations in a minimum of six subjects, three at a higher level, similar to A-level, and three at a lower level. 
 For one of their higher-level subjects, students prepare during their last school year an &bquo;extended essay&equo;; in effect, a mini-thesis. 
 Several schools in Britain already teach the Baccalaureat syllabus.  
 Gex, France TEUVO LEHTI 
 You criticise the A-level system for reducing the number of students in higher education and for leading to narrowly educated people. 
 I was raised in Britain where I took my A-levels and went to university, but I now teach at an American college. 
 You seem to be impressed by the percentage of youngsters in higher education in America. 
 Their quality, however, is appalling. 
 I teach students who are often illiterate, who do not know how to use a hand-held calculator, who have never seen a film with subtitles or read a classic work of literature, and who cannot spell even the name of important people in their field (for example, psychology majors who spell Freud as Frued). 
 America survives, as in the past, by attracting bright and motivated people from other nations of the world.  
 Pomona, New Jersey DAVID LESTER 
 The meaning of hostage 
 It was good to see references at last to what I had always understood to be the correct meaning of hostage (April 27th) &mdash; that is, &bquo;a person given to another as a pledge&equo; (Oxford dictionary). 
 My emphasis is on &bquo;given&equo;: it denotes a degree of willingness on the part of the giver. 
 Those wretched people held by Saddam at the start of the Kuwait invasion were prisoners. 
 Hostages are a useful as well as a time-honoured gesture of mutual trust. 
 Even the British have found it so. 
 In South Arabia as part of the Pax Britannica in the 1950s and 1960s, when some local robber baron was &bquo;persuaded&equo; to stop plundering caravans, he was invited to surrender a hostage to authority, as a gesture of future good faith. 
 This he usually did, and often it was his eldest son. 
 If the &bquo;host&equo; had been the Imam of the Yemen, some filthy prison might have been his lot. 
 What the British did, however, was to send him to school. 
 It worked a treat.  
 Kalamunda, W. Australia MICHAEL CROUCH 
 Corporate money 
 I would like to dispute the parallel drawn between J.P. 
 Morgan and Michael Milken in your otherwise fine survey of international finance (April 27th). 
 The contrasts between the two men are far more telling. 
 Pierpont Morgan personified the old Wall Street establishment, which was based on exclusive relations between bankers and companies. 
 Although Morgan could be arbitrary and intrusive with companies he financed, he insisted on sound, professional management and &mdash; with some notable exceptions &mdash; conservative financial policy. 
 Generations of Morgans sat on the boards of General Motors, U.S. Steel, General Electric. 
 Mr Milken was an anti-establishment maverick who financed raiders lacking any experience in companies they bought. 
 Far from trying to develop their targets for the long haul, the Milken minions broke them up for quick gain. 
 With Mr Milken's pronounced bias towards debt, he and his raiders left companies in a far more precarious financial shape than they found them. 
 He typified a decade in which financial machinations stymied long-term corporate growth.  
 Brooklyn RON CHERNOW 
 You refer to a recent study of mine on the success and failure of leveraged buyouts. 
 The interesting finding of the study, which you did not mention, was that there were differences in pre-buyout performance between companies that successfully underwent LBOs and those that failed. 
 These differences included pre-buyout cash-flow trends and margins. 
 Although the small sample size and bias in selection limits the predictive power of some of these measures, it demonstrates that there are real differences that distinguish companies that are suited for high temporary debt from those that are not. 
 The other finding of note is that debt levels at the time of the buyout, and increases in debt associated with the buyout, are not good predictive measures in judging the potential for success in a transaction. 
 The successful LBOs in my study, as a group, had higher debt levels at the time of the buyout than those that later failed. 
 The successful LBOs as a group also experienced greater increases in leverage with the buyout. 
 This is not to suggest &bquo;the more the better&equo;; but that there appear to be other measures that portend failure better than leverage ratios. 
 Based on the other findings of the study, a focus on cash flow (or sellability of assets) to pay down the debt would be more fruitful.  
 New York HARVIN MOORE 
 There is an error in chart 4 of your survey; starting from the same initial point, the curve representing the traditional view of the value of a firm should rise initially and then fall, as the level of debt increases. 
 Your article omits a further important strand to the debate over the past 15 years as to the optimal level of borrowing for firms. 
 Merton Miller argued in 1977 that investors, when deciding between a company's debt or equity, will be concerned with the returns after both corporate and personal taxes. 
 Since much of equity returns are in the form of capital gains, at least in the long run, which are taxed only on realisation, personal tax on equity returns is generally in effect much lower than that on the returns to investing in a company's debt. 
 Thus the corporate-tax advantage of debt is reduced by the personal-tax advantage of equity.  
 Norwich C.G.C. PITTS 
 Worrying about Quebec 
 In &bquo;All change&equo; (April 27th), the Reform Party of Canada, led by Preston Manning, is represented as separatist, and its supporters as having &bquo;a good riddance to Quebec&equo; attitude which must be purged. 
 In fact, Mr Manning has repeatedly stated that he and the party would much prefer that Quebec remain as part of Canada, but not at any price. 
 The qualification is not unreasonable. 
 The man representing English-speaking Canada in its negotiations with Quebec is the prime minister, himself a loyal Quebecker from a Quebec riding &lsqb;constituency&rsqb;. 
 The conflict of interest is glaringly obvious, but the only likely alternative in the current parliament seems to be the leader of the opposition Liberal Party &mdash; Jean Chretien, a French Canadian who for years represented Quebec ridings as a minister in Pierre Trudeau's era. 
 Is it any wonder that Canadians worry?  
 Saanichton, British Columbia J.R. 
 JACKSON 
 Hong Kong's new airport 
 I wish to put on the record a different view of the proposed new airport in Hong Kong (April 13th). 
 The concerns expressed by the Chinese leadership are, in my opinion, fully justified. 
 The proposal was given the green light in a post-Tiananmen panic by people who will probably be living in Hampshire when, and if, the airport is built. 
 Along with Douglas Hurd, this expatriate clique continues to exhibit all the hallmarks of the King Canute school of diplomacy and administration. 
 That the project may now be delayed by Chinese inquisitiveness should be seen in the context of the fact that the current administration had dithered for 15 years on the project. 
 The typical small businessman in Hong Kong now has business interests in southern China, to complement his existing connections through kinship, and would much prefer that a cheaper project be put in place, with a view to the needs of Greater Hong Kong as they will be in the 21st century &mdash; this after full consultation with the Chinese authorities.  
 Hong Kong STEPHEN BROWN 
 Australia's political woes 
 Your article on the Australian Labor Party's troubles (April 20th) cites a figure of A&dollar;1 billion being channelled through an account controlled by Brian Burke into the party's federal campaign funds. 
 The figure should be A&dollar;1m. 
 The sum of A&dollar;1 billion is the amount lost by the Western Australian State Labor government in its business ventures (mainly with Labor Party donors) from 1983 to 1990. 
 The wider issue at stake is the philosophy behind Labor's current problems: the corporatist approach to government. 
 In Western Australia we have had the corporatist experiment. 
 It failed; the loss on our government's business venture is around A&dollar;700 per head. 
 The experiment has been repeated both in Victoria and in South Australia, where again it failed; again at enormous expense. 
 The lesson for Australia, and indeed for Britain, is to beware a Labor Party that has dropped nationalisation, but not intervention, from its agenda.  
 South Perth ANDREW GRAY 
 Precedent Bush 
 I was surprised to note a major historical inaccuracy in your excellent article &bquo;The Democrats' dilemma&equo; (April 20th), when you state &bquo;Mr Bush might be flattered to be the first unopposed president.&equo; 
 George Washington, former subject of George III, ran twice unopposed for the presidency of the United States of America.  
 Thornwood, New York CHARLES BOWEN 
 You  frivolously  suggest that Mr Bush might be flattered to be the first unopposed president. 
 James Monroe earned this distinction in 1820.  
 Greenwich, Connecticut PETER BOER 
 BOOKS AND SECTION 
 The man who never was 
 KILL THE MESSENGER. 
 By Bernard Ingham. 
 HarperCollins; 398 pages; &pound;17.50 
 WHEN Margaret Thatcher travelled the world as prime minister, she took a bulldog with her. 
 This jowl-shaking, glowering personification of Britishness was her press secretary, Bernard Ingham &mdash; now Sir Bernard. 
 Prizing anonymity in his dealings with the media, he became public property. 
 By the end of a decade in Downing Street, he was as essential to the Thatcher caricature as her steel-framed handbag. 
 Looking back, almost everything about Mrs Thatcher's 12 years seems touched with gothic melodrama &mdash; the political landscape was illuminated not by daylight but by periodic lightning-flashes. 
 Sir Bernard was no exception. 
 He has been likened to Shakespeare's Iago, to the Scottish grave-robbers Burke and Hare, to an ogre, to a rottweiler. 
 He became, in short, a story in his own right, the man who was said to have used his great power as Downing Street's anonymous twice-daily briefer to belittle ministers whom Mrs Thatcher intended to dispose of. 
 Sir Bernard denies the charge. 
 In two of the best-known cases &mdash; his description of John Biffen as a &bquo;semi-detached&equo; member of the cabinet and of Francis (now Lord) Pym as the depressive wartime radio character Mona Lott &mdash; he goes out of his way to explain what went wrong. 
 But first some background is needed. 
 The &bquo;lobby&equo; is the shorthand term for the club of political journalists who attend off-the-record briefings with the prime minister's press secretary. 
 These occur twice a day and may not, under rules drawn up by the journalists themselves, be mentioned in print. 
 The source of the information and views, which are widely distributed just before evening and morning newspaper deadlines, is therefore hidden. 
 If ministers or others who are attacked by Downing Street at such meetings object, they have no come-back. 
 Officially, the briefings never took place. 
 Sir Bernard complains that in the case of the Biffen and Pym briefings, his comments &bquo;were dragged out of me. 
 They were neither premeditated nor authorised. 
 They came off the top of my head.&equo; 
 And, further, &bquo;the circumstances in which they came to be made were never reported by journalists.&equo; 
 Hardly surprising, this, since they were made at lobby briefings. 
 Such incidents might have caused Sir Bernard to have second thoughts about the system; but he defends it with passion. 
 In recent years he has set himself up as a crusader for higher press and broadcasting standards, regularly harking back to the golden days of his journalistic apprenticeship in Yorkshire, where every fact was triple-checked and every speculation ruthlessly suppressed in the Hebden Bridge Times. 
 Yet his criticism has not, by and large, been for the tabloid newspapers whose standards fell to new lows during the 1980s; instead, he has reserved his bile for investigative journalists, particularly if they worked for television, and for those newspaper reporters who decided to boycott his lobby briefings. 
 Here this reviewer must admit an interest: as political editor of The Scotsman in those days, he was one of the latter. 
 The anti-lobby group's tactic, which became a habit, was to report particularly sensational comments made by Sir Bernard or his underlings and to name the source. 
 This was done by comparing the shorthand notes of several senior lobby members who willingly handed them over. 
 The result was predictable: the briefers stopped attacking ministers and others in the old style. 
 To that extent, the lobby revolt was a success. 
 But Sir Bernard was outraged; and since, throughout this account, he goes on about his rectitude and his impartiality as a civil servant, it is worth quoting him on what happened to journalists who fell out with him. 
 At the time of the lobby revolt, &bquo;No one could have been in any doubt that if they went over to &lsqb;the rebel papers'&rsqb; side, they would cook their goose with Number Ten.&equo; 
 As for Brian Redhead, a BBC radio presenter who had the temerity to call him a conspiracy, &bquo;His failure to apologise meant that he never got another interview with Mrs Thatcher as prime minister.&equo; 
 Sir Bernard has nothing but contempt for politically embarrassing journalism. 
 A string of distinguished television current-affairs programmes are dismissed as being soft on criminals and terrorists; TV programme-makers turn out to be pretentious, corrupt, cynical and generally &bquo;nauseating&hellip; these saintly people, living off the fat of the land, try to kid you that they are guardians of the common weal!&equo; 
 As for media prizes, &bquo;There is only one qualification for a media award these days: the undermining of elected authority.&equo; 
 Despite his sneering tone, Sir Bernard is undoubtedly right that too many journalists, brought up on Watergate, see themselves as saintly crusaders and all government as conspiracy. 
 There is a good, critical book to be written about the limits and excesses of journalistic campaigning. 
 It is not this one. 
 He had his merits, this strange protector of the Iron Lady; he was courageous, decisive and a punishingly hard worker. 
 But his tenure of the prime minister's press office lowered its reputation and damaged Mrs Thatcher's image. 
 His book has interesting passages about the author's boyhood and his later disenchantment with trade unionism. 
 For the rest, it is distasteful where it is not dull. 
 Sir Bernard's many friends will fear he has not done himself justice. 
 His many enemies will crow that he has.  
 Why communism fell 
 Wounded pride 
 THE PATRIOTS' REVOLUTION. 
 By Mark Frankland. 
 Sinclair Stevenson; 352 pages; &pound;16.95. 
 COMMUNISM. 
 Edited by Geoffrey Stern. 
 Amazon Publishing; 256 pages; &pound;19.95. 
 To be published in America by Macmillan 
 THE upheaval that shook Eastern Europe felt so natural that it seems pointless to ask why it happened. 
 Given a chance to break loose from neo-Stalinism, with its bullying, one-party corruption and food queues, any normal country would. 
 Yet what looks obvious in hindsight was not at all obvious before. 
 Up to 1989, Eastern Europe looked to most people depressed but stable. 
 Nobody dreamed of so swift a break. 
 A common explanation is that these revolutions came from outside: East Europeans simply took the chance offered by Mikhail Gorbachev's Sinatra doctrine to &bquo;do it their way&equo;. 
 A twisted variant is the conspiracy theory: change was started, at Soviet behest by local communists who wanted limited reform to save the system. 
 In Eastern Europe the idea that every sparrow's breath is measured out in Moscow dies hard. 
 A more flattering explanation is that this was an economic revolt from below. 
 By the end of the 1980s, easterners were watching the West's economies accelerate out of sight. 
 Another treats the upheaval as a crusade for liberty led by a few heroic dissidents. 
 This is why many books on the big change in Eastern Europe read either like privatisation brochures or &bquo;The Lives of the Saints&equo;. 
 In his finely written record, Mark Frankland gives due weight to all these factors. 
 But his eye is too keen and his feel for the different histories of these nations too strong to slip into one-answer explanations. 
 As his title suggests, he thinks that national pride &mdash; battered not merely by communist but by pre-war failure &mdash; played a large part. 
 Many easterners are still not convinced by the virtues of unfettered markets, and only a handful were in any active sense dissenters under the previous regime. 
 Almost all of them, though, did agree on getting rid of the Russians. 
 Mr Frankland's book is a pleasure to read. 
 His aim is not to mock or preach but to explain one country to another, and his sense of the absurd keeps him from becoming solemn. 
 He can catch a mood or scene in a phrase. 
 Nicolae Ceausescu's famous palace in Bucharest looms &bquo;like an iceberg through fog&equo;. 
 A dissident intellectual passing out leaflets at a factory gate reminds him of a nervous child offering a sugar lump to a large horse. 
 The future, Mr Frankland suggests, will be complicated. 
 Half a century ago, sincere East European communists expected liberation from the Nazis and the arrival of socialism to be &bquo;a big bang followed by eternal happiness&equo;, in the sardonic words of Jacek Kuron, a Polish Solidarity activist. 
 Nobody reading Mr Frankland's book is likely to think there are magical solutions for Eastern Europe after communism. 
 A useful complement for people interested in communism's travails is an excellent illustrated history of the movement from 1848 to the present day, edited by Geoffrey Stern. 
 With 48 maps and hundreds of contemporary illustrations, it is a model of lively, popular history, doubling as a handy reference book.  
 Bob Dylan gets old 
 Subterranean half-century blues 
 FOLKNICK, bluesman, balladeer, gospel entertainer, country-and-western star: Bob Dylan, all these and more, was born Robert Allen Zimmerman 50 years ago in the small town of Hibbing, Minnesota. 
 His parents, Abraham and Beattie, were ordinary, respectable, middle-class Jews who owned an electrical-goods store in the town; his grandfather, who left Russia in the 1920s, had been a peddler and a shoemaker. 
 Why did he change his name? 
 Partly because, like any adolescent, he needed a different identity for himself; but partly, perhaps, because he had always been an admirer of outlaws and vagabonds and especially of Matt Dillon, star of &bquo;Gunsmoke&equo;. 
 The spelling, on the other hand, may have had something to do with the poet Dylan Thomas, then an intensely romantic and dissolute figure. 
 Dylan's earliest musical influences were country music (the two Hanks, Snow and Williams) and rock 'n' roll (while still at school he had an ambition to join Little Richard's band). 
 But by the time he went to college in Minneapolis he was playing folk music on an acoustic guitar and learning to blow &mdash; not suck &mdash; the harmonica. 
 In 1961 he took off for New York city to pay his respects to his latest hero, hobo and folk singer Woody Guthrie, then dying of Huntington's Chorea; and he returned to Minneapolis later that year a-singing and a-playing, mumbling and slurring his words, just like Woody himself. 
 He had also acquired one of Woody's suits of clothes, which he wore for his debut performance at Gerde's Folk City in Greenwich Village. 
 He was written about enthusiastically in the New York Times, offered a recording contract by CBS Records, and by the end of that year was cutting his first album. 
 The second and third albums, &bquo;Freewheelin&equo; (1962) and &bquo;The Times They are a Changin&equo; (1963), established him as a real and original talent, as both singer and songwriter, with a message that seemed as arresting and vital as the times through which he was fortunate to be living. 
 In April 1962 he wrote &bquo;Blowin' in the Wind&equo;, and within a short space of time he had been adopted as the spokesman of the civil-rights movement. 
 The 1960s had found its chronicler and its prophet. 
 But prophets rarely live comfortably for long in their own &mdash; or other people's &mdash; company, and in 1965 Dylan horrified his faithful audience by selling out to commerce. 
 He picked up an electric guitar at the Newport Folk Festival, assembled a band behind him and played loud enough to raise the roofbeams &mdash; just like he had done in his high-school days. 
 The troubadour of dissent had metamorphosed into a rock 'n' roll Rimbaud. 
 Folk-rock was born. 
 Audience hostility drove him onward &mdash; and inwards. 
 He lived and played and wrote and toured frenetically for the next couple of years, working night and day &mdash; with just a little help from Benzedrine,  Methedrine , and anything else that would speed him up or slow him down. 
 These were the years of &bquo;Subterranean Homesick Blues,&equo; &bquo;Highway 61 Revisited&equo; and &bquo;Blonde on Blonde&equo;, arguably his most creative period. 
 Then, in the summer of 1966, came the motorcycle crash &mdash; and everything stopped. 
 The press reported it as a big accident. 
 In fact, it was nothing more than some fractured vertebrae and minor concussion. 
 But it gave him an excuse to retire for a while, to re-assess things. 
 When he went back into the recording studio, the results sounded like painful attempts at self-parody or worse. 
 It was not until 1974 that his ability to write and perform at his best gelled again, with the release of &bquo;Blood on the Tracks&equo;. 
 Later in that decade, God put a hand on his shoulder and Brother Bob was born. 
 For a time he disported himself on stage like some hell-fire preacher, but since then the message of his songs has been more mixed again: even returning, sometimes, to his great old theme of disaffected love. 
 There have been Dylanologists almost as long as there has been a Dylan for them to write about. 
 Clinton Heylin, author of the latest biography, &bquo;Dylan: Behind the Shades&equo; *, ranks amongst the most assiduous, having co-founded the Telegraph, a quarterly magazine devoted to the study of Dylan's life and work, and written an extraordinarily detailed chronology of his hero's life. 
 Mr Heylin is not a graceful writer, but his thorough knowledge and his generous use of interviews makes this the fullest account of the star so far. 
 Paul Williams's thesis in &bquo;Bob Dylan: Performing Artist&equo; ** is that the best &mdash; indeed the only &mdash; way of getting to grips with the importance of Dylan's work is by treating it as performance art, since that is the way the man himself seems to treat it. 
 The book has many keen insights into the nature of the Dylan achievements, but it is marred by a fault common to many who write about this man: idolatry. 
 Mr Williams's central argument can be tested by listening to &bquo;Bob Dylan: The Bootleg Series&equo; **, a set of five albums containing many rare and unreleased recordings from all periods of his career. 
 From these it is clear that the star created mayhem in any recording studio. 
 Suspicious of session musicians, he has never been in the habit of sharing his thoughts about chord sequences or the like; his co-artists have been expected to listen hard and play along if they can. 
 If a number is not right on first or second playing, it is dropped, and the star moves on to something else. 
 He is a great improviser &mdash; many of his best lyrics have been written on the wing. 
 And these records provide fascinating evidence of all this quirkishness, mostly in alternative and earlier arrangements of the best-known songs. 
 Dylan's voice has always been his greatest asset, carrying a huge range of emotions. 
 But it is never pretty. 
 He seems most himself when snarling like a caged animal, droning and whining like a buzz saw, hacking at his guitar as if he is chopping wood. 
 In spite of the fact that even the best of his songs can seem surprisingly flat on the page, his vocal performance compels a belief in the aptness of the words. 
 What seems miraculous, when all is said, is that a man driven by so many acts of perversity should have been embraced so widely.  
 American mortgages 
 The terrible two 
 A STATE OF RISK: WILL GOVERNMENT-SPONSORED ENTERPRISES BE THE NEXT FINANCIAL CRISIS? 
 By Thomas Stanton. 
 Harper Business; 225 pages; &dollar;24.95 
 WHEN he retired in January as chairman of America's Federal National Mortgage Association (usually known as Fannie Mae), David Maxwell received a handshake of &dollar;27m. 
 This caused a few gasps, as well it might. 
 It was a huge amount for an institution which, though run like a private-sector company, has its credit risk implicitly underwritten by the federal government. 
 Fannie Mae is hardly a household name outside Washington, where it lobbies fiercely, and Wall Street, for whom it is a big client. 
 The unlovely Fannie and her duopolistic cousin, the Federal Home Loan Mortgage Corporation (Freddie Mac), are the best known of that obscure underbelly of the American political system known as government-sponsored enterprises. 
 During the 1980s these quasi-government agencies became a convenient means of off-balance-sheet financing; so much so that they have now amassed nearly &dollar;1 trillion-worth of obligations underwritten by the American taxpayer. 
 Thomas Stanton's courageous book is the first comprehensive study of these monsters, revealing their history, how they work today and how, with better regulation, they might escape a repeat of the &dollar;500 billion savings-and-loan fiasco. 
 That parallel is apt. 
 Enterprises like Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac have a unique advantage over private-sector competitors: they can keep all their profits, but their losses are picked up by the taxpayer. 
 In practice this means they can borrow more cheaply than banks and thrifts which, being unable to compete with them, have increasingly decided to join them. 
 Lending institutions now sell more and more of their mortgages to Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, which in turn package them into securities and sell them to investors. 
 Because they can borrow at subsidised rates, government-sponsored enterprises tend to grow until they dominate their field. 
 In 1970 only 8% of all residential-mortgage debt in America carried some form of federal-government guarantee. 
 By 1989 the figure had grown to 38%, an extraordinary risk for the American taxpayer to be asked to bear. 
 These enterprises are now almost as big as that other mammoth contingent liability of America's socialised credit system, federally insured deposits. 
 At the end of 1989 the outstanding securities of the former totalled &dollar;874 billion, compared with &dollar;959 billion for the latter. 
 Mr Stanton has some worthy thoughts on how to ensure the safety and soundness of these shadowy leviathans. 
 He has an (American) liberal's instinct that they could be valuable instruments of federal policy in pursuit of woolly-sounding social goals, providing they are properly regulated. 
 His concern is that they are out of political control. 
 An obvious starting point is to increase their wafer-thin capital requirements. 
 Some would argue that these enterprises have no place in a capitalist system, and should therefore be privatised as soon as possible. 
 In reality they are too powerful to be challenged head on, although the thrift horrors did at least prompt the first congressional hearing into their finances for more than 30 years. 
 They will survive unscathed and largely unregulated until their activities unleash another financial disaster; at which point this book will be a useful starting point for moppers-up.  
 Under the apple tree 
 &bquo;I SAT where I had sat before, and the same bliss entered me. 
 Then I looked up. 
 All around me, pouring down from the sky on the garden, on the roofs of the surrounding houses, was an intense fine white light, a soft flaky blizzard of slightly pearly white light. 
 I knew this was the Paramatman Light, the light of the Absolute&hellip; 
 I studied the apple tree I had gazed at before. 
 It was leaping in stillness to receive the Light. 
 It seemed, in that brilliant silence, to be flinging open all the pores and cells of its being to the Light that poured into it. 
 I prayed for the ardour of the fruit tree, the passive rapture of the long grasses, the patient infinite receptivity of the stone walls that also pulsed and shivered with love of the Light.&equo; 
 This passage comes from Andrew Harvey's HIDDEN JOURNEY*, an extraordinary account of his spiritual experiences at the hands of a teacher from an ashram in southern India. 
 It is the second of Mr Harvey's voyages of self-discovery: in the first, &bquo;A Journey in Ladakh&equo;, written eight years ago, he began to embrace Buddhism under the influence of a monk in exile from Tibet. 
 Some will think him a spiritual butterfly, some an intellectual too ready to be hoodwinked; but his searching has a definite progress to it, and the heights and depths encountered in this book make it clear that he is getting somewhere, often against his own will and inclination. 
 Few writers can communicate this most difficult of subjects. 
 Mr Harvey does so with a clarity and beauty of expression that make his book worth reading even by those who will be sceptical of what he describes. 
 Best of all, he is not a proselytiser, much less a saint. 
 Having made all kinds of good resolutions after Ladakh, he fell out of them as soon as he returned to his usual academic haunts in Oxford and New York; painfully, he tried again. 
 His story is that of every modern man longing for enlightenment, stumbling, worrying and &mdash; just occasionally &mdash; glimpsing what he hardly dares to look for.  
 The Cannes film festival 
 Bonjour les Fran&ccedil;ais! 
 CANNES 
 A GENUINE European cinema still exists, untainted by the blandishments and violence of contemporary Hollywood: and this year's Cannes festival has proved it. 
 The French industry easily led the field with a huge panorama of most of the 100 or so films made during the year, ranging from the work of new directors (such as Eric Rochant's &bquo;Aux yeux du monde&equo;, a taut thriller about the kidnapping of a school bus) to those little comedies and histoires d'amour, so beloved by the French, which never seem to get exported. 
 The older generation was particularly well represented, with films by Agn&egrave;s Varda and Jacques Rivette (who both pre-date the original nouvelle vague). 
 Miss Varda's entry, &bquo;Jacquot de Nantes&equo; was a poetic, affectionate evocation of the childhood of director Jacques Demy, her late husband, who was brought up in Nantes. 
 Delicate period details of the 1940s show how Demy's infatuation with cinema developed; the film even includes some of his apprentice efforts. 
 Mobile location shooting all over the town is intercut with brief clips from his greatest successes, including &bquo;Lola&equo; and &bquo;Les Parapluies de Cherbourg&equo;. 
 Miss Varda has succeeded in making a film without false nostalgia or sentiment, and the glowing black-and-white images (with an occasional burst of colour) have a sustained rhythm and elegance which correspond to Demy's own infatuation with song-and-dance films. 
 Demy himself, looking dangerously ill, adds commentary to part of the film. 
 Several international critics shied away from the prospect of Mr Rivette's four-hour &bquo;La Belle Noiseuse&equo;, which won the Special Jury Prize. 
 They missed a near-masterpiece, his best work since &bquo;C&eacute;line and Julie go Boating&equo;. 
 A painter (Michel Piccoli) decides to re-create an abandoned portrait of a famous courtesan and employs a new model (Emmanuelle B&eacute;art) who soon reveals a strong will of her own. 
 Much of the film shows the painter simply going about his task, first scratching outlines on parchment and then on to the canvas. 
 Mr Rivette's control over these lengthy scenes is phenomenal. 
 He also achieves a subtle contrast between the sensuous country exteriors and the darkened studio &mdash; every camera movement is beautiful and necessary and the playing fastidious, with Mr Piccoli virtually becoming the obsessed artist before the viewer's eyes. 
 It is difficult to find another film with which to compare it; Mr Rivette virtually hypnotises his audience. 
 At first glance, it seems hardly necessary to make another film about Van Gogh; but Maurice Pialat, who began his career in the late 1960s, has found a new approach by showing the artist not as a great figure of his times but as a tormented, talented painter living in a village among ordinary folk. 
 Mr Pialat's rejection of some famous episodes, such as the artist cutting off his ear, puzzled some members of the audience; so did the relatively unhysterical depiction of the relations between the artist and his brother. 
 But Mr Pialat's feeling for la vie quotidienne and languid afternoons on river banks, contrasted with the bustle and frenzy of the Paris scenes, amply compensate for a lack of historical detail. 
 Mr Pialat also shares with Mr Rivette a capacity for shaping and controlling long sequences. 
 The final sections of &bquo;Van Gogh&equo; are particularly masterly: as the painter painfully dies in the little village inn, his friends lament his passing for a moment and then get on with the business of the day &mdash; shopping, washing clothes, preparing for work. 
 C'est la vie. 
 These and other impressive works from Cannes, including the new Kieslowski and Angelopoulos films, will be seen at the next London Festival. 
 It is a pity that Britain, now supposed to be a fully paid-up part of Europe, cannot seem to produce auteurs of anything like this calibre. 
 AMERICAN SURVEY 
 Phoenix 
 Rising from Kuwait's ashes 
 PHOENIX, ARIZONA 
 FIVE years ago the only things that Phoenix and Kuwait city had in common were a desert setting and an urban landscape of glittering modern buildings. 
 Now that Phoenix has buildings without an owner, and Kuwait has owners without a building, a new link has been forged. 
 Charles Keating, once a successful Phoenix property developer, has become the bankrupt symbol of the multi-billion dollar savings-and-loan debacle. 
 But the buildings he developed during his heyday are still there and the federal government is keen to find buyers for them. 
 They seem to have found takers in Kuwait. 
 The connection began in the late 1980s. 
 As Mr Keating struggled to finance one of his most lavish developments &mdash; the marble and glass-encrusted Phoenician hotel &mdash; the Kuwaitis stepped in to take a 45% stake in the project. 
 The collapse of the Keating empire, and the destruction of much of Kuwait city by the occupying Iraqis, might have been expected to dim Kuwaiti interest in hotel development in Phoenix. 
 But the Kuwaiti royal family appears to be made of sterner stuff. 
 At the beginning of April, Sheikh Saud Nasir al-Sabah, a member of the royal family and Kuwait's ambassador to America, visited Phoenix in order to reacquaint himself with the Phoenician. 
 He then met members of the Resolution Trust Corporation, which is charged with disposing of the property of bankrupt thrifts. 
 Although Kuwait, without oil revenues and faced with a tremendous rebuilding task, is said to be short of ready cash, the ambassador made it clear that his country is keen on buying the RTC's interest in both the Phoenician and Crescent hotels (another Keating project). 
 According to the RTC, negotiations between the two parties are underway. 
 The connection between Phoenix and Kuwait is likely to extend well beyond the fate of these luxury hotels. 
 Phoenix has a lot of under-employed property developers and Kuwait has a lot of re-building to do. 
 During his spin around Phoenix, the ambassador remarked that the climate and surroundings reminded him of home. 
 By the end of his visit he had met the owners of several Phoenix-based construction companies and a trade delegation is to visit Kuwait. 
 America West Airlines, which is based in Phoenix, is rumoured to be thinking of starting a service between Phoenix and Kuwait. 
 It is hard to imagine a large demand for this extraordinary flight &mdash; not from holiday-makers, certainly. 
 The potential customers are hungry Phoenix developers and construction workers heading for the battered remains of Kuwait city.  
 Tale of a letter 
 MOSCOW AND WASHINGTON, DC 
 HOW did Grigori Yavlinsky, an economist who works as informal adviser to Boris Yeltsin, come to play so large a part in the aid-for-economic-reform debate? 
 The story starts in Moscow in April, when he received an invitation from the &bquo;G7 Council&equo; to a conference later that month in Washington. 
 Though the conference was to take place at the State Department, the council is a purely private body, the brainchild of Johnson Smick International, a firm of Washington consultants. 
 Before leaving, Mr Yavlinsky contacted Yevgeny Primakov, the member of Mikhail Gorbachev's national security council responsible for economics. 
 Mr Primakov asked him to remind the meeting that the Soviet Union wanted to attend the G7 summit in London. 
 Mr Yavlinsky did so, and for good measure outlined a programme for radical reform supported by western aid. 
 During the conference (big cheeses from the State Department were dropping in and out all the time) Mr Yavlinsky was told that, if his request were serious, it would need the imprimatur of both Mr Primakov and Mr Gorbachev. 
 Mr Yavlinsky asked David Smick, of Johnson Smick, how he might get his ideas taken seriously. 
 Mr Smick, no slouch, suggested that he write an article for the International Economy, a magazine that Johnson Smick publish, in the form of a letter to the G7. 
 In Moscow Mr Yavlinsky and a team worked round the clock on the details of the programme. 
 Within three days he and Mr Primakov had written the letter to the G7: that is, the article for Mr Smick's magazine. 
 It promises that the Soviet Union will pursue &bquo;a rigid fiscal and monetary policy&hellip; liberalisation of prices&hellip; an extensive programme of privatisation and demonopolisation&equo;. 
 In exchange it asks the G7 to draw up an aid programme, to reschedule Russia's foreign debt, and admit the country into the IMF and the World Bank. 
 On May 4th the letter was faxed to Mr Smick. 
 On May 5th Mr Yeltsin told Mr Yavlinksy that &bquo;if that's so, all the &lsqb;Soviet&rsqb; republics will have to pool their efforts&equo; &mdash; in effect putting the weight of the republics behind the programme. 
 Mr Yeltsin telephoned Mr Gorbachev and 90 minutes later Mr Yavlinsky and Mr Primakov were in the president's office. 
 Mr Gorbachev endorsed the letter, giving Mr Yavlinsky the authority to negotiate a new reform plan with western aid. 
 The next day Mr Gorbachev met Fran&ccedil;ois Mitterrand, the first western leader to hear of the plan. 
 On May 11th he called George Bush, recovering from a wobbly heart, to sound him out. 
 In Washington, meanwhile, Mr Smick struggled to have the five-page letter translated. 
 A copy found its way to Robert Zoellick, the under-secretary of state for economic affairs. 
 In Moscow Mr Yavlinsky met Jeffrey Sachs and Graham Allison, two Harvard professors with close links to the administration. 
 By May 20th all three were back at Harvard, to flesh out Mr Yavlinsky's plan (which, according to Mr Allison, is based on a study conducted last December by the IMF and the World Bank). 
 On May 21st Mr Yavlinsky and Mr Allison came to see Mr Zoellick, who was once a student of Mr Allison's. 
 Mr Smick, who had created one of the scoops of the year, was left cursing that his magazine comes out only every two months.  
 Baying at the rules 
 SEATTLE 
 EACH year in King county 16,500 stray dogs and cats are officially put to death. 
 Ron Sims, a county council member, has had enough of this slaughter. 
 He has therefore proposed that pet-owners should be obliged to sterilise their dogs and cats unless they pay &dollar;100 per animal for a breeder's licence. 
 In this way, he hopes, the county, which contains the city of Seattle, can control its exploding pet population. 
 Mr Sims's idea has got the county yapping. 
 Animal-breeders, who accuse him of trying to drive them out of business, organised a protest on May 8th, when hundreds of people sent Mr Sims bits of dog-food. 
 His supporters are no less shrill. 
 Animal-welfare activists published a brochure with a photograph of a dewy-eyed puppy and fluffy kitten on the cover; the same two animals are shown inside, dead after euthanasia. 
 People are upset because there is a growing problem with unwanted pets. 
 Each year about 15m dogs and cats are destroyed in America. 
 Professional breeders blame irresponsible pet-owners. 
 But the Humane Society of the United States says that nearly 40% of the animals that wind up in shelters are pure-breds or their mongrel offspring. 
 Pure-bred dogs are flooding into pet shops from &bquo;puppy mills&equo; in the mid-west, where a farm with 50 bitches can produce upwards of 1,000 puppies a year. 
 Even expensive and exotic breeds &mdash; such as the loose-skinned Japanese shar peis which sell for &dollar;1,000 &mdash; are often seen in shelters. 
 The reluctance of pet-owners to be &bquo;educated&equo; has led to an outburst of sterilisation schemes. 
 San Mateo county, south of San Francisco, is polishing the wording of a sterilisation ordinance passed in November. 
 A similar rule may be proposed in New York city. 
 Oregon has a dozen bills pending that have to do with cutting down the number of pets. 
 But the legality of a sterilisation order may be questionable, and it would certainly be hard to enforce. 
 Perhaps it might make more sense to restrict people to a fixed number of pets. 
 A licence then would be required to exceed that number, or to advertise animals for sale. 
 Civil libertarians would be up in arms but it would mean fewer animals whose final romp is into a killing-room.  
 Gathering nuts in May 
 WASHINGTON, DC AND MOSCOW 
 The Soviet Union's overriding need for money has made Mikhail Gorbachev try to end the chill in his relations with the West 
 THE gleam in President Gorbachev's eye is no less than a new Marshall Plan to reorganise the Soviet Union's economy, financed by the world's seven leading industrial countries, the G7. 
 Short of this, he wants the Soviet Union tied more closely into the western economy, even as the ending of the cold war tied it closer to western diplomacy. 
 But in Washington these overtures, which happen to have been delivered in a thoroughly unorthodox way, are being sniffed at most gingerly. 
 The lobbying of America has been a curious off-the-books exercise (see box on next page). 
 On the Soviet side, the main figure is a young economist, Grigori Yavlinsky, who has no formal job in the Soviet government but was the originator of the &bquo;Shatalin plan&equo; for radical economic change. 
 He has now drafted a programme of economic reform backed by aid from the West. 
 Mr Gorbachev has endorsed both the plan and the idea of soliciting western aid. 
 So in the past few weeks Mr Yavlinsky, Vladimir Shcherbakov, the Soviet minister in charge of economics, and Yevgeny Primakov, an aide to Mr Gorbachev, have all visited America trying to work out the terms of an aid-for-economic-reform package. 
 The Americans helping them, or listening to them, include a mixture of officials and academics, particularly from Harvard. 
 Jeffrey Sachs, a Harvard economist who has advised the Polish government, has suggested that an aid package of &dollar;30 billion a year for five years might be in order. 
 The State Department has responded cautiously to Soviet lobbying. 
 Its view is that any help from the West for the Soviet economy must be &bquo;catalytic&equo;: that is, it must ensure genuine radical reform. 
 The Americans now await a final version of the Yavlinsky plan, at present being drafted at Harvard by a joint Soviet-American team of academics. 
 One idea in the wind is that Mr Gorbachev should be present at the mid-July meeting of the G7 in London. 
 The Americans are not rushing to welcome him, worrying lest the very presence of Mr Gorbachev might bounce the West into agreeing to an aid package before it could be sure that economic reform was locked into place. 
 The Germans sound no less discouraging: Mr Gorbachev should not be invited, they say, if no aid is likely to be offered to him. 
 One damn thing after another 
 Soviet-American relations have been going through a bad patch since the beginning of the year, troubled by the crackdown on the Baltic states, differences in the Gulf war and an arms-control quarrel. 
 On all three issues conservatives in the Soviet Communist Party and army have been trying to reverse the combination of change at home and co-operation with America abroad. 
 But the conservatives' influence has lately seemed on the wane. 
 The new overtures, reflecting the country's overriding economic troubles, point to a further lessening of their sway over Mr Gorbachev. 
 One difficulty between the two countries is the date of the next Soviet-American summit. 
 Expected early in the year, it had been postponed, ostensibly because of the Gulf war. 
 In fact the Americans have gone cool on the idea. 
 They are annoyed by Soviet attempts to fiddle last year's treaty on conventional forces in Europe (CFE). 
 The Soviet Union has reclassified three army divisions, all with heavy equipment, as naval forces, and has claimed that they are thereby excluded from the terms of the treaty: a trick the West calls cheating. 
 The row shows some signs of being settled. 
 General Mikhail Moiseev, the Soviet chief of staff, visited Washington this week for talks aimed at narrowing the difference between the two sides. 
 Unless this business is settled, the Americans are unlikely to agree to a Bush-Gorbachev summit. 
 Americans were bothered not only by the Baltic crackdown in January but by the Soviet reaction to American complaints about it. 
 These complaints were pretty mild, and aid was not suspended. 
 But the Soviet foreign minister, Alexander Bessmertnykh, called America's reaction to the bloodshed &bquo;purely emotional&equo;, and gave warning that Soviet-American relations were in a fragile state. 
 In March Mr Gorbachev himself remarked on this supposed fragility. 
 This was pretty clearly an attempt to nudge the Americans towards saying yes to an aid programme for the Soviet Union. 
 The curiosity is that the programme would give western hands much power over the reshaping of the Soviet economy. 
 The Baltic states featured in a Senate debate on May 15th on a Soviet request for &dollar;1.5 billion-worth of food credits. 
 This debate can be taken as something of a dry-run of the political battle should a formal request for really massive aid be delivered. 
 Farm-state senators, led by Robert Dole, a Republican from Kansas, argued for granting the credits, albeit with strict conditions. 
 On the other side were both conservatives such as Jesse Helms, a Republican from North Carolina, and liberal Democrats such as Paul Sarbanes from Maryland. 
 Bill Bradley, a Democratic senator from New Jersey who probably knows as much about the Soviet economy as anybody on Capitol Hill, led the opposition to the credits. 
 He argued that aid would betray the Baltic states, and, just as important, would remove the Soviet Union's incentives to put its house in order. 
 Mr Yavlinsky, talking to The Economist, conceded that Mr Bradley's doubts on the capacity of the Soviet economy to distribute aid were valid. 
 But the way to get things right, he argued, was to adopt his plan, under which the Soviet authorities and the G7 countries would implement the reforms together. 
 In this way, he said, western critics could assure themselves that the terms of such a package were being met. 
 The Americans, cautiously encouraged by the weakening of conservative influence, are waiting to see what happens next in Moscow. 
 As if in response, the Supreme Soviet passed a new emigration law on May 20th. 
 If the fine print turns out to be okay, this will eventually clear the way for America to grant most-favoured-nation trading status to the Soviet Union. 
 But that would seem a trifle if a request for something like &dollar;150 billion of western aid were soon to appear on the G7's table.  
 Utah 
 More than Mormons 
 SALT LAKE CITY 
 THE first Mormon migrants made the long trek west to what would become Utah in the 1840s to escape religious and political persecution. 
 Today's newcomers are as likely as not to arrive from the opposite direction: businessmen seeking to escape the pollution, water shortages, high taxes and labour costs of southern California. 
 The south-western desert states (Arizona, New Mexico, Nevada and Utah) have largely escaped the current recession, having suffered theirs five years ago. 
 They now compete for the modern migrants. 
 All four need the skills, and the new jobs they bring, to wean their economies from their reliance on mining and ranching. 
 None is having more success in diversifying than Utah. 
 Utah, in particular, needs all the new employers it can find. 
 Its population has grown by two-thirds since 1970; it now stands at 1.7m. 
 Immigration has a lot to do with this, but so do the social mores of a state that is still 60% Mormon. 
 The Church of the Latter Day Saints abhors divorce and abortion as much as it does alcohol and caffeine. 
 Utah has the highest fertility rate in the country, and the biggest and youngest households. 
 Mixed with an old-fashioned respect for education, this means that tens of thousands of new jobs have to be generated each year to keep up with the prodigious output of mothers and universities. 
 The state's long-established mining and energy industries no longer provide enough work. 
 Companies such as Geneva Steel and Kennecott Copper are now shrinking, not expanding. 
 Utah's natural-resources boom of the 1970s was stopped in its tracks, first by the recession of the early 1980s and then by the oil bust later in the decade. 
 Utah's economic planners want aerospace, bio-medical and computing firms to take up the slack. 
 They use a sophisticated cost-benefit computer model to work out how far they should go in luring any given company with tax breaks or grants of land. 
 Attracted by the lion's share of a &dollar;10m industrial assistance fund, a bit of McDonnell Douglas has already arrived, bringing with it more than 1,000 jobs. 
 Utah's computer industry is starting to tempt firms out of southern California. 
 So far it is still largely home-grown. 
 The state has the largest agglomeration of computer companies in America after Silicon Valley and Route 128 in Massachusetts. 
 Brigham Young and the University of Utah have excellent computer-science schools. 
 Yet, like other places, Utah has to turn to low-tech services to soak up its growing numbers of literate job-hunters. 
 Salt Lake City has become the telemarketing capital of America for mail-order firms and reservation services. 
 Credit-card processing provides lots of jobs. 
 Tourism, too, is a growing industry, which the state hopes to boost if Salt Lake City is awarded the winter Olympics in 1998. 
 Much of southern Utah is rugged national parkland that the federal government would like to preserve as wilderness. 
 This is where old and new Utah come into conflict. 
 Upstate city-dwelling environmentalists are not much welcomed by conservative and strongly Mormon southerners who have mined, logged and ranched the land for decades. 
 They would need a lot of convincing before accepting that tourism is a better bet.  
 Solarz, the name they know elsewhere 
 SITTING in the antechamber to his congressional office, Stephen Solarz, the loquacious representative for New York's 13th congressional district, is taking a five-minute lunch break and wondering whether to run for president. 
 Mr Solarz concedes that &bquo;some people have been urging me to run&equo;. 
 Pressed for names, he mentions his father. 
 Mr Solarz is unlikely ever to be president. 
 Yet he already has an international reputation. 
 He is living proof that an individual congressman with energy and knowledge can turn himself into a foreign-policy entrepreneur. 
 He will be giving a demonstration of this art in the days running up to June 3rd, by when George Bush must decide whether to renew China's trading privileges, known as most-favoured-nation status. 
 Mr Bush is keen to make the renewal of MFN unconditional; Congress would like to make it conditional on China improving its human-rights record. 
 If Congress and the administration are to avoid a head-on clash, and a presidential veto, a compromise must be struck. 
 This, characteristically, is where Mr Solarz comes into the picture. 
 As head of the Asia and Pacific subcommittee of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, he has arranged hearings on American-Chinese relations for the week before Mr Bush must announce his decision. 
 Mr Solarz's knack for generating publicity, his network of contacts in Asia, his influence with the administration and his reputation for knowing what he is talking about &mdash; rare enough among congressmen who spout on foreign affairs &mdash; give him clout. 
 If he gets his way, MFN will be renewed with a few &bquo;achievable&equo; conditions attached. 
 In the right circumstances, Mr Solarz has been able to give a nudge or two to history. 
 His long interest in the Philippines made him pivotal in preparing American opinion for the abandonment of Ferdinand Marcos (President Corazon Aquino later hailed him as &bquo;the Lafayette of the Philippine revolution&equo;). 
 When the Cambodian peace talks in Paris broke down in 1988, it was Mr Solarz, along with the Australian foreign minister, Gareth Evans, who pushed successfully for an expanded UN role in the transitional peace settlement. 
 These were well-known issues. 
 Congressman Solarz also beavers away on the duller stuff that most of his colleagues see little point in pursuing. 
 By slipping a neat little amendment into an aid bill, or pressing the State Department to take notice of human-rights violations, the two or three people in Congress who take an interest in an &bquo;obscure&equo; part of the world can be disproportionately influential &mdash; and be sure of making headlines in the country concerned. 
 Mr Solarz is celebrated in Hong Kong because he argued for (and got) more American visas for anxious would-be emigrants. 
 He is notorious in Islamabad because he argued for the cut-off in American aid to Pakistan, implemented last autumn. 
 At home the action that has drawn most attention in the past year was his vote in favour of war in the Gulf. 
 Not only did Mr Solarz support a war that most liberal Democrats regarded as an invitation to disaster, but he actively pushed for confrontation with Iraq &mdash; linking arms in the process with such unlikely conservative allies as Richard Perle and Jeane Kirkpatrick. 
 Mr Solarz's supporters would say that his courage in the Gulf war was typical of a politician willing to buck the conventional liberal wisdom when the facts demand it. 
 His opponents would demur. 
 They would suggest, or insinuate, that Mr Solarz, who is Jewish, is part of Israel's &bquo;amen corner&equo; &mdash; to use a phrase made famous by a conservative columnist, Pat Buchanan. 
 There is certainly a protective touch about Israel in Mr Solarz's public utterances on the Middle East. 
 For a man who was leading the campaign for sanctions against South Africa, when that was still a hopeless liberal cause, he has been notably diffident about such things as collective punishment and detention without trial in the Israeli-occupied territories. 
 In part this is simple pragmatism. 
 Mr Solarz's Brooklyn district is one of the few districts in America where Jewish voters form the majority. 
 It would require suicidal altruism to take up the cudgels for the Palestinians. 
 Yet an unsuccessful war in the Gulf might have left Mr Solarz vulnerable to the charge that he had put Israel's interests above America's. 
 As it is, he emerged as one of the few Democrats to have had a &bquo;good war&equo;. 
 He is still regularly mentioned as a possible secretary of state should the Democrats regain the White House. 
 Know your own bridges 
 That is a plausible, if distant, goal. 
 By contrast, a &bquo;Solarz for President&equo; campaign sounds improbable: the congressman has spent much more time in Asia than in Iowa. 
 The only part of the United States in which he seems to take a consistent interest is Brooklyn. 
 Even there his grasp sometimes seems a little shaky. 
 Mr Solarz was once involved in a debate about the collection of tolls on the Verrazano bridge that links his district to Staten Island. 
 It is the sort of dull nitty-gritty subject believed to be vital for the survival of any self-respecting congressman. 
 Mr Solarz, it turned out, did not even know which side of the bridge the tolls were collected on. 
 He lost the vote heavily. 
 For most politicians, this kind of thing is the route to swift oblivion. 
 But a little local vagueness may not harm Mr Solarz. 
 He thinks that his district, which contains many recent immigrants to America, takes pride in having a congressman who cuts a figure on the world stage.  
 Where to be a bum 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 WITH the approach of Memorial Day, the official start of summer, all right-thinking Americans are looking forward to long days at the beach. 
 Stephen Leatherman, director of the Laboratory for Coastal Research at the University of Maryland, has done them a favour, ranking America's beaches for beauty, water temperature, quality of sand and the like. 
 Most of the American east coast is unlike anything found in Europe. 
 Where the ice-age glaciers affected the Atlantic coast &mdash; only as far south as northern New Jersey &mdash; there are cliffs, headlands and sandy coves, as in Europe. 
 But from New Jersey all the way round to Texas, the hinterland of the coast is dead flat and the beaches stretch for many miles. 
 Sand dunes are often the highest elevation not just on the coast but for miles inland. 
 This huge stretch of coastline is dominated by offshore barrier islands built by the surf out of drifting sand. 
 On the Outer Banks in North Carolina, for example, there are about 300 miles of sandy beaches. 
 The islands are fragile, with a topography constantly changed by wind, wave and hurricane. 
 Development on a third of the barrier coast has been controlled by law since 1982; no federal flood insurance is available for building on controlled beaches. 
 Unless replenished, many beaches gradually disappear as their sand is carried away into deep water. 
 The beach at Ocean City, Maryland, has to be continually re-made. 
 By 1980 Miami beach had all but totally eroded, and with it the town's tourist business; sand was then sucked from the sea-bed and the beach rebuilt. 
 The tourists are now back. 
 Mr Leatherman's own favourite stretch of sand is Kapalu beach on Maui, in Hawaii. 
 He knows whereof he speaks. 
 In 20 years, he reckons, he has examined 650 separate American beaches. 
 It's a tough job, but somebody has to do it.  
 The economy 
 Choose your yardstick 
 SHORT and shallow is still how most economists like to describe America's current recession. 
 So why does it feel deep and steep to many businessmen and consumers? 
 Look more closely at the numbers. 
 Real GNP fell by only 1.1% between the third quarter of last year and the first quarter of this. 
 Even if output continues to decline at a similar pace in this quarter before it picks up in the next (as most forecasters expect), the total peak-to-trough decline will look much shallower than the 2.7% average drop in GNP during the eight recessions since the second world war. 
 Other economic indicators, however, paint a gloomier picture. 
 Although the classic definition of a recession is two successive quarters of falling real GNP &mdash; implying that the recession started in the fourth quarter of last year &mdash; the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER), America's official business-cycle watcher, uses a different yardstick: the monthly indicators for employment, industrial production, real business sales and real personal disposable income. 
 After whizzing these numbers through its computer, the NBER reckons that the economy peaked in July of last year. 
 This makes the recession already ten months old. 
 So short of an immediate recovery, this recession will be longer than the 11-month average length of recessions since the war. 
 Geoffrey Dennis, an economist in the New York office of James Capel, a British securities firm, has tried to gauge the depth of this recession compared with previous ones, using the monthly indicators instead of GNP. 
 The chart on the next page shows how industrial production has fared since last July compared with the past three recessions. 
 In each case, the beginning of the recession is set equal to 100. 
 The 1973&ndash;75 and 1981&ndash;82 recessions both lasted 16 months; the 1980 recession, triggered by new credit controls, just six months. 
 Industrial production fell 4.8% between last July and April (the latest figure available). 
 This was more than it fell during the same stage of both the 1973&ndash;75 and 1981&ndash;82 recessions, but less than the short, sharp fall in 1980. 
 Looking at the other indicators, employment dropped 1.4% in the nine months to April. 
 This was much more than in the same period of 1973&ndash;75, slightly more than in 1980 and similar to the decline in the first nine months of the 1981&ndash;82 recession. 
 Business sales have also fallen more sharply than at the same stages of the 1973&ndash;75 and 1981&ndash;82 recessions. 
 Conclusion: so far, the economy is contracting at a pace that is remarkably similar to America's two deepest post-war recessions. 
 One reason that the monthly indicators look worse than the figures for total GNP, is that industrial production and business sales exclude certain factors that bolster GNP. 
 One of these is that stocks have been only modestly run down compared with previous recessions; another is the boost to government spending from the Gulf war. 
 However, Mr Dennis also reckons that the current GNP numbers (still subject to revision) may be under-estimating the true steepness of the current downturn. 
 For this recession to equal the previous record of 16 months it would have to drag on for another six months. 
 That is unlikely; indeed, the worst seems to be over. 
 In April industrial production rose by 0.1%, the first increase for seven months; retail sales fell by only 0.1%, after a big upward revision for March which transformed a 0.8% fall into a 0.4% rise. 
 In the same month housing starts rose and the unemployment rate fell from 6.8% in March to 6.6%. 
 On a gloomier note, employment continued to decline and car sales remained depressed. 
 The sharp drop in America's trade deficit this year reflects the weakness of domestic demand. 
 In March America had its smallest monthly trade deficit for almost eight years: &dollar;4 billion compared with a monthly average of &dollar;8.5 billion in 1990. 
 The decline was mainly due to lower non-oil imports, which fell at an annual rate of 14% between the fourth quarter of 1990 and the first quarter of this year. 
 Figures for America's total current account (to be released next month) may even show a small surplus, or at least a rough balance &mdash; thanks partly to payments by foreign governments towards the cost of the Gulf war. 
 J. P. Morgan, a New York bank, is optimistically forecasting that the current account for the year will be in balance, compared with a deficit of &dollar;99 billion in 1990. 
 Other forecasters are looking for a deficit of around &dollar;50 billion. 
 But do not expect American protectionists to give up: next year, as domestic demand revives, the deficit will surely widen again.  
 Civil rights 
 Don't quota me 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 CONGRESS is about to make another bid to reverse the Supreme Court's latest rulings on discrimination in hiring and firing. 
 Twenty years ago liberal justices on the court laid down a series of laws against discriminatory employment practices. 
 But the balance on the court changed and conservatives took over. 
 In half-a-dozen cases during 1989, the court made it much harder for blacks, Hispanics and women who were seeking compensation for job discrimination. 
 In one case, Wards Cove Packing Co v Atonio, the court ruled that the onus lay with the plaintiff to prove a precise case of discrimination. 
 Last October George Bush was asked to sign a bill that tried to restore things to the more liberal way they were between 1971 and 1989. 
 The president vetoed the bill &mdash; and the Senate failed by a single vote to override his veto. 
 Republican opponents of the bill had managed to raise terror among businessmen that they would end up having to adopt hiring quotas in order to avoid costly discrimination suits. 
 At last November's election in North Carolina, Senator Jesse Helms showed how emotive an issue quotas could be among white voters. 
 He beat off Harvey Gantt, his black Democratic challenger, with television commercials suggesting that whites were losing jobs to less qualified blacks. 
 Enraged at seeing their cause thus mugged, Democratic leaders in Congress were willing to perform political somersaults to get some sort of civil-rights legislation through. 
 In an attempt to grab the Republicans' &bquo;hot-button&equo; issue, the Democrats are now dressing themselves up as the anti-quota party. 
 They emphasise that the latest civil-rights bill explicitly forbids the use of quotas &mdash; which, in any event, have been established as illegal. 
 The bill also bans another common practice that seems set to become as emotive as quotas: &bquo;race-norming&equo;, in which the score on federal employment aptitude tests is adjusted upwards for blacks and Hispanics. 
 The bill accepts the administration's demand for a &dollar;150,000 limit on the punitive damages that women may seek from companies that practice discrimination (although there is no limit on compensatory damages). 
 This measure, says Don Edwards, a Californian congressman who is one of the bill's sponsors, has won over 15&ndash;20 southern Democrats who had been worried about the crippling effect of punitive damages on small businesses. 
 With those southerners on board, Mr Edwards believes Congress may have a chance of overriding another presidential veto. 
 And, since this new bill is in essence the same as last October's, a veto is what it will probably get. 
 A new civil-rights law, in whatever form, is bound not to address the ingrained attitudes that still work against blacks. 
 Just how prevalent these are has been demonstrated in a new survey by the Urban Institute. 
 It arranged for groups of identically qualified white and black applicants to apply for the same jobs in Chicago. 
 It found that in 20% of the cases the white man advanced further than the black. 
 Blacks were given the edge in only 7% of cases. 
 START OF ASIA SECTION 
 In Congress with the family 
 FROM OUR DELHI CORRESPONDENT 
 SINCE Indian independence in 1947, the main question before Indian voters has been whether they were for or against the Nehru-Gandhi family. 
 The Congress Party and the dynasty have gradually merged, as the family has undermined yet sustained the party. 
 Congress once had an independent existence. 
 During the struggle against British rule, spearheaded by Congress, the party threw up dozens of notable leaders. 
 But after 1947, Nehru began to assert his supremacy and sack party chiefs who opposed him. 
 Even so, several titans of the independence movement survived him and one &mdash; Lal Bahadur Shastri &mdash; succeeded him. 
 Shastri died in 1966, and Indira Gandhi staked her claim. 
 Party bosses, nicknamed &bquo;The Syndicate&equo;, decided to make her prime minister, expecting to manipulate her while using her name to get votes. 
 But she won at their game, splitting the party in 1969 to assert her supremacy over the bosses &mdash; and she was vindicated when voters gave her a huge majority. 
 After this, few colleagues dared oppose her and the once-proud party became a bunch of family retainers. 
 When she lost the 1977 election because of the &bquo;emergency&equo; imposed in 1975&ndash;77, some party bosses decided to kick her while she was down. 
 Once again she split the party and proved in subsequent elections that the people regarded her family as the real Congress. 
 After that, any chief minister daring to build his own political base stood in danger of being turned out. 
 In one interview a chief minister of Karnataka, Gundu Rao, heatedly denied the suggestion that he had any political base in his state at all. 
 He said his only political base was Indira Gandhi. 
 After successive purges, the party ceased to have any pretension to ideology. 
 Mrs Gandhi's eldest son Sanjay, later killed in an aeroplane crash in 1980, helped her in the running &mdash; and the destruction &mdash; of the party. 
 Crooks signed up to enjoy the benefits of corruption and to lend their power. 
 In his first year as leader, Rajiv Gandhi threatened to throw out the thugs. 
 But he soon found it expedient to use unsavoury characters to control even nastier ones further down the party line. 
 Mr Clean became Mr Congressman. 
 When the chief minister of Maharashtra became uppity earlier this year, Mr Gandhi arranged for dissidents to mount a campaign to get rid of him, and relented only after the chief minister ate humble pie. 
 Congress was stained during the 1980s by the Bofors case, a scandal which suggested the party had received millions of dollars from the Swedish gun manufacturer as part of a &dollar;1.2 billion deal for howitzers. 
 The impulse to appoint Rajiv's Italian-born widow, Sonia, in his place was surely another sign of a family business in distress. 
 She sensibly said no.  
 Japan 
 Those devious Europeans 
 FROM OUR TOKYO CORRESPONDENT 
 THE trade warriors of Japan and America understand each other, even though their battles may be fierce. 
 No such understanding exists between Japan and the European Community. 
 &bquo;Inadequate, distant, even indifferent&equo; is how the Community's ambassador in Tokyo, Jean-Pierre Leng, describes their relations. 
 Such was the background to the four-day visit to Japan starting on May 22nd by Jacques Delors, the Community president, and its trade commissioner, Frans Andriessen. 
 The Europeans are getting anxious about Japan's rising trade surplus with the Community. 
 After shrinking slightly over the past few years, the gap grew to nearly &dollar;10 billion during the first four months of this year, up from a little over &dollar;6 billion for the same period in 1990. 
 For its part, Japan is becoming increasingly nervous about protectionist trends in Europe. 
 Japanese firms fear they will be locked out of &mdash; or at least restricted from freely entering &mdash; what, from January 1993, is planned to be the world's largest single market. 
 Japan believes the key to better relations with the Europeans is to discuss political issues rather than trade problems. 
 The Gulf affair gave the two sides something interesting to talk about. 
 Both Japan and Europe could have a part to play in President Bush's &bquo;new world order&equo;. 
 Japanese officials noticed that politics, not trade, was mostly discussed when Mr Delors visited Washington in April. 
 They had rather hoped that political questions would take up at least as much time as trade problems during this week's visit to Japan. 
 Mostly they have been disappointed. 
 One disappointment is over a proposed joint declaration by Japan and the Community. 
 This would be similar to the one the Community signed with America covering political and cultural co-operation as well as trade. 
 The Japanese would like such a declaration to involve regular summit meetings, perhaps as often as twice a year, between the Japanese prime minister and the Community president &mdash; like the informal meetings that Toshiki Kaifu has been having with President Bush. 
 Mr Delors and his colleagues did show guarded enthusiasm for the proposal. 
 But the declaration is going to take longer to work out than the Japanese had hoped. 
 It may be signed just before, or even during, the London summit meeting of the Group of Seven leaders in July. 
 Before signing anything, the Community negotiators boringly want to see some &bquo;results oriented&equo; agreements on trade matters. 
 Top of their list are Japanese car exports. 
 The Community wants Japan to agree to limit its car sales to no more than 16&ndash;17% of the market by 1998. 
 In 1990 Japan had 12% of the car market in Community countries, and its share is expected to rise. 
 The limitation sought by the Community includes Japanese cars made in European countries. 
 Japan says this makes a mockery of the heavy investment by Japanese motor manufacturers in Europe. 
 The Japanese negotiators are particularly worried by the increasing influence of protectionist French and Italians in the Community. 
 With Europe in recession and fears about unemployment, Britain and other countries which could previously be relied upon to put the case for a freer market (and a bigger share for themselves of Japanese investment) are no longer being heard. 
 Diplomats in Tokyo see the British in retreat over computers and electronics as well as cars. 
 The French and the Italians had ICL &mdash; the Britain-based computer maker recently bought by Fujitsu &mdash; thrown out of a number of collaborative projects financed by the Community. 
 The Japanese see France's new prime minister, Edith Cresson, as the biggest threat to closer political and cultural as well as economic ties with the European Community. 
 This may be unfair on her, but it probably helps the Community to have Mrs Cresson threatening to block Japanese exports if &bquo;reciprocal access&equo; is not given to European goods in Japan. 
 American negotiators have opened the Japanese market for a variety of goods by threatening to let loose the protectionists in Congress. 
 The Community has rejected the notion of linking &bquo;reciprocal access&equo; to negotiations on Japanese car imports, but it talks menacingly about the &bquo;balance of mutual interests&equo;. 
 In his discussions with Mr Kaifu this week, Mr Delors made much of the &bquo;spirit of reciprocity&equo; and the need for &bquo;fairness and balance&equo; between Japan and the Community. 
 Foreigners are not supposed to talk in such Japanese-like riddles. 
 Life would be a whole lot easier, mutter government officials in Tokyo, if the devious Europeans would only behave more like the tough but plain-speaking Americans. 
 Well, perhaps. 
 The American vice-president, Dan Quayle, arrived in Japan on May 20th for two days of talks that touched on everything from Japan's closed market for car-parts to its total ban on rice imports. 
 It has been a hard week for the trade warriors.  
 ONE OF Japan's greatest sumo wrestlers of all time, Chiyonofuji, bowed out of the ring for good last week, defeated by an 18-year-old called Takahanada who promises to become the youngest yokozuna (grand champion) of all time. 
 Two days after his downfall, the 35-year-old Chiyonofuji (known as &bquo;The Wolf&equo; to millions of admirers) announced the end of an illustrious career with the ritual cutting of his hair's top-knot. 
 Chiyonofuji was the Muhammed Ali of the sumo ring. 
 Small by traditional standards, handsome and far too athletic-looking, he used pure muscular strength allied to unnerving concentration and flawless technique to compensate for his lack of body weight. 
 In his 22 years in the ring, Chiyonofuji racked up a record 1,045 wins and 31 Emperor's Cups &mdash; just one short of the record held by his celebrated predecessor, Taiho. 
 His example inspired a new generation of muscular young wrestlers to train hard with weight-lifting and press-ups instead of just eating. 
 Already sumo experts are calling the equally athletic and handsome Takahanada a worthy replacement. 
 A gracious Chiyonofuji noted that Takahanada, in his deep attachment to each bout, was totally different from other sumo wrestlers. 
 Another &bquo;Wolf&equo; in the rearing?  
 Boat people, delivered daily 
 FROM OUR HONG KONG CORRESPONDENT 
 WHAT number comes next in the following series: 179, 558, 344, 148, 291, 80? 
 Hong Kong officials dread to think. 
 These are the daily arrivals of Vietnamese boat people in the British colony, beginning with Friday May 17th. 
 Those who sailed in this week brought the population of Vietnamese in Hong Kong to more than 50,000. 
 So far Hong Kong is coping, just. 
 A holding camp designed for 480 boat people has been brimming with more than 1,000. 
 Around 4,000 places are still empty in the more permanent camps. 
 At present rates the vacancies will be gone by mid-June. 
 All this has come as an unpleasant surprise to Hong Kong's officials. 
 Hong Kong's people wonder why the Vietnamese are housed and clothed, while illegal immigrants from China are sent packing. 
 Last year 6,652 boat people landed in Hong Kong, down from more than 34,000 in 1989. 
 In the first 20 days of May this year, almost four times as many Vietnamese arrived as in all of May 1990. 
 The total so far for 1991 already surpasses the figure for all of 1990. 
 No one has a convincing reason for this. 
 Some say it is because no boat people have been returned home against their will since December 1989. 
 Why it should have taken more than a year for this to soak in is unclear. 
 Others speculate that a bad harvest around Hanoi may be to blame (though the new arrivals do not seem to be starving). 
 Some even point to the &bquo;encouragement&equo; offered by the batty suggestion of an American congressman that boat people should be sent to help rebuild Kuwait. 
 Whatever the explanation, many people in Hong Kong have had enough. 
 Legco, the largely toothless legislature, has vowed not to authorise spending for new camps. 
 One Legco member says that, if forced repatriation is not resumed, Hong Kong might have to stop offering boat people first asylum (it might, that is, push the refugees back out to sea). 
 Clinton Leeks, the colony's top refugee official, is to meet the Americans next month in an effort to soften their adamant opposition to mandatory repatriation. 
 The trouble is that small boats make headway a lot faster than big governments.  
 Hong Kong 
 Sky's the limit 
 FROM OUR HONG KONG CORRESPONDENT 
 A CONSTRUCTION project, even a huge one, does not normally become a point of constitutional principle. 
 But that is what has happened with the airport Hong Kong wants to build as part of a &dollar;16.3 billion infrastructure programme. 
 China, which takes over the British colony in 1997, refuses to bless the undertaking &mdash; and thus open the way for private financing of part of it &mdash; until it has wrung several concessions from the British. 
 Because these concessions would in effect make China a partner in running Hong Kong before 1997, the British say no. 
 Meanwhile, the site for the airport is yet to be reclaimed from the sea off Lantau island; and Hong Kong's confidence in its future, which the project was meant to bolster, sags still further. 
 The latest episode in this depressing process ended in Beijing on May 22nd. 
 Teams of officials from Britain, Hong Kong and China had spent five days haggling over the many points of disagreement left over from the visit of Douglas Hurd, the British foreign secretary, to China last month. 
 Optimistic leaks had it that the negotiators were making good progress on a statement of &bquo;principles&equo;. 
 In the end, they agreed only &bquo;to take stock and keep in touch&equo;. 
 If the British were indeed talking about principles, it was a mistake; it is a mistake to negotiate with the Chinese about generalities. 
 China's own demands are said to be precise. 
 If Britain guarantees that the Hong Kong government's financial reserves will be above a certain level come 1997, and if the airport's costs are below a certain level, and if Hong Kong neither raises taxes nor issues debt to pay for the airport, and if China has a say not just on the airport but also on other franchises Hong Kong grants and, come to think of it, on other &bquo;important&equo; matters &mdash; if all that is conceded, then Hong Kong can have its airport. 
 Britain has been resisting much of this, but none too skilfully. 
 With the airport, it was not defending strong ground in the first place. 
 The estimated cost of the project, which includes a port and transport links as well as the airport proper, took everyone's breath away, not just China's. 
 Several Hong Kong businessmen question the price, and an opinion poll last month found that the man in the Hong Kong street also had his doubts. 
 The behaviour of the Hong Kong government did not help matters. 
 After years of assuring everyone that China could be trusted to carry out the 1984 British-Chinese agreement on Hong Kong in good faith, the colonial administration found itself after Tiananmen Square presiding over a population which knew that China could not be trusted at all. 
 In October 1989, as a &bquo;confidence-building measure&equo;, Sir David Wilson, Hong Kong's embattled colonial governor, announced the airport project &mdash; but did not tell China beforehand. 
 The Chinese may have been cavalierly treated since then. 
 They claim to have received information late and in fragments. 
 Last October, just before a visit to Hong Kong by a Chinese team of experts looking into the airport, the Hong Kong government suddenly announced that a bridge that is a big part of the project would be paid for entirely with public money; before, it had said the bridge would be private. 
 The Chinese were deeply insulted. 
 Mr Hurd, whose trip last month to Beijing was ill-prepared, paid the price. 
 No agreements had been laid out beforehand. 
 He talked tough on his way to Beijing (the message was that &bquo;if China doesn't agree to reasonable terms, the airport project will be scrapped&equo;), then retracted when there. 
 Worse, he wanted to discuss principles. 
 Worse yet, the British foreign secretary, the highest-ranking western visitor since Tiananmen, found himself negotiating with Chinese messenger boys. 
 The mistakes would matter less if China had good intentions, which it does not. 
 It is likely that Li Peng, the prime minister, still tastes the personal gall of 1m people in Hong Kong taking to the streets after Tiananmen to call for his ejection from office. 
 China is using every negotiating device, and it is master of them all, to carve out as big a place for itself as it can in pre-1997 Hong Kong. 
 Britain knows it has to preserve Hong Kong's autonomy. 
 It is not so good at knowing how to do it. 
 It has to tell China where it will not give way, and then start (as Mr Hurd first threatened) to walk away. 
 Otherwise, expect more scenes, like this week's, of unknown officials engaged in incomprehensible negotiations &mdash; and no airport.  
 Vietnam 
 Will success spoil the party? 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT 
 HANOI 
 THE 101st anniversary of the birth of Ho Chi Minh on May 19th got only a muted celebration in Hanoi. 
 But at least it gave the 13 septuagenarian members of Vietnam's ruling Politburo, most of them groomed by Ho, another chance to contemplate their uniqueness. 
 They pulled off the seemingly impossible by defeating the French, the Americans and the Chinese. 
 They might even do it again, this time by rebuilding Vietnam's economy without in the process being forced to relinquish the Communist Party's grip on power. 
 The party's efforts to save its skin will be tested on June 17th, when its delayed seventh congress is due to start. 
 The congress, which will last between seven and ten days, is supposed to chart Vietnam's future to the year 2000 and beyond. 
 The party has learnt from past mistakes. 
 At the sixth congress, in 1986, irate delegates rejected a ridiculously optimistic programme that had been drafted in secret by Le Duan, the then secretary-general. 
 This time it has circulated for public comment drafts of five documents. 
 So far, the central committee has received more than 10,000 letters suggesting how these documents could be improved. 
 Most of the criticism has been pretty tame, though one dissident, Colonel Bui Tinh, a revolutionary hero, waited until he got to Paris to say he believed the draft documents were &bquo;totally out of contact with reality&equo;. 
 The colonel is now an ex-party member and would be unwise to go home. 
 The key document is a report on the past five years and proposals for the future. 
 It is in its 14th draft, and has been &bquo;improved very much&equo; by public criticism, according to Le Dang Doanh, an economic adviser to the central committee. 
 It has shrunk to a third of the original draft's 120 pages. 
 Its broad outlines are clear. 
 Most important, the party knows it must improve the country's living standards if it is to stay in power. 
 This means that doi moi, the policy of economic renovation launched at the previous congress, cannot be reversed. 
 The IMF has, rather fulsomely, praised Vietnam's economic policies as an &bquo;exemplary reform programme&equo;. 
 The missing bit in the programme is investment. 
 Soviet subsidies to Vietnam ended in late 1990, and the American embargo &mdash; which includes a veto on IMF loans to Vietnam &mdash; looks set to stay for the immediate future. 
 Vietnam will want to get cash from as many foreign countries as possible, to avoid becoming dependent on a single new big brother. 
 This leads on to politics. 
 It is necessary to improve the quality of the party's leaders, and to separate the functions of party and state. 
 The National Assembly, due to meet in July, is to draft a new constitution, the main aim of which will be to shift the blame for future mistakes from the party to the state apparatus. 
 &bquo;Lively discussions&equo; are expected in the congress on what can be done to help the casualties of economic reform. 
 About 1.7m people are reckoned to be unemployed in Vietnam, and the pay of 1.2m civil servants is stuck at an average of 80,000 dong (&dollar;10) a month. 
 Almost every employee must moonlight in second, even third jobs simply to subsist. 
 The pace of reform, to avoid too much further hardship, will also be debated. 
 The potentially most divisive argument will be about who should be in charge during the dangerous period ahead. 
 The party newspaper Nhan Dan reports that at least two-thirds of the next 124-strong Central Committee, to be elected at the end of the congress, will be under 60. 
 Most of its present members are over 60. 
 In the Politburo Nguyen Van Ling is expected to stay on as secretary-general, even though he is 75 and said to be in poor health. 
 He is seen as the only man who can keep the peace between those who want to slow the pace of reform and those who want to speed it up. 
 What of the people? 
 Do they want to continue to be ruled by communists? 
 &bquo;Eastern Europe can cope with two to three bad years; we are on the edge of starvation,&equo; says Do Duc Dinh, a Hanoi economist. 
 The government-run newspapers tell of instability elsewhere in the communist world. 
 Flirtation with multi-party politics would bring chaos to Vietnam, they say. 
 In the north, the party can count on fairly widespread support. 
 In the south, those who reject communism seek to escape, preferably to America through the &bquo;orderly departure programme&equo;. 
 About 10,000 people are leaving each month in this way, and the government is granting exit visas faster than America can admit them. 
 Dissent is discouraged by the presence of the security forces and the army. 
 Yet the party is nervous. 
 &bquo;Only as long as people see their life improve each year will they accept the leading role of the party,&equo; says a Central Committee member. 
 That is realistic. 
 Officials take heart that the economy has not collapsed since the withdrawal of Soviet aid. 
 When America does lift its trade embargo, they believe that Vietnam will receive help from the IMF and massive Japanese investment. 
 The question then might be: can the one-party system steer its way to economic triumph? 
 Optimists in the party point to Malaysia, Singapore and Indonesia, which have managed rapid rates of growth while the same party has stayed in power. 
 Singapore's People's Action Party is particularly admired. 
 It was, of course, presiding over a capitalist economy. 
 Have the Hanoi optimists thought of that?  
 South Korea 
 The sacrifice 
 FROM OUR SOUTH KOREA CORRESPONDENT 
 ACCORDING to the rules that govern South Korea's annual outbreak of student protests, it should be just about time for petrol bombs to give way to more agreeable activities. 
 But the unusual intensity of this year's protests has left both the students and the government wondering about the price of peace. 
 One  sacrificial  lamb has been offered. 
 The prime minister, Ro Jai Bong, submitted his resignation on May 22nd after more than a week of public roasting. 
 Other government ministers may be on the way out. 
 The past month has seen more violence and death than any of the student groups had anticipated. 
 Seven students have died after setting fire to themselves. 
 Their &bquo;martyrdom&equo; &mdash; in student eyes &mdash; followed the death of a student beaten by police. 
 Another student, also beaten, is said to be in a coma. 
 Although the students have won converts to the notion that the riot police use excessive force, they have yet to win much support for their demands. 
 Chief among them is that the &bquo;undemocratic regime&equo; of President Roh Tae Woo should be toppled. 
 The students say the formation in 1990 of the ruling Democratic Liberal Party &mdash; actually a coalition of parties &mdash; was a crime against democracy. 
 But most Koreans do not agree. 
 The vast middle class seems bored with the notion of taking to the streets when the government is still offering gestures of conciliation. 
 This does not mean that all is well for the government. 
 Mr Roh and his alliance of squabbling factions are worried by stories in the newspapers hinting that officials in the government's security organisations are jockeying for power. 
 Such people are more interested in civil order than civil rights. 
 Mr Ro earned the boot for failing to detect the public's sensitivities on this point. 
 In an aggressive television appearance on May 9th he denied there was any &bquo;national security powerbase&equo; in the government. 
 Koreans expect their statesmen to behave with calmness, even when questioned closely. 
 During the week before Mr Ro's resignation, many leading members of the ruling party made public comments backing his departure. 
 The problem for President Roh is finding a suitable replacement for Mr Ro and possibly other ministers. 
 Mr Roh's advisers had urged him to delay any cabinet reshuffle to avoid the impression that he was simply responding to the students' demands. 
 He had also hoped to use any cabinet changes as a basis for offering policy announcements timed to boost the ruling party in the second round of local elections due to be held towards the end of June. 
 This strategy was scrapped when it became apparent that the government needed to take some action before the students revved up again for another outbreak of violence. 
 Even with Mr Ro's departure, the conflict is likely to recede only slowly.  
 A tale of two workers 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN HANOI 
 MANY of the 180,000 Vietnamese working in Eastern Europe have lost their jobs following the collapse of communist regimes there. 
 Do they carry home hopes that Vietnam's Communist Party will suffer the same fate? 
 Apparently not. 
 Take two examples. 
 In April 1987 Neuyen Chi Hoi started work in the canteen of an East Berlin shoe factory. 
 He was paid 700 ostmarks a month (&dollar;385 at the official rate) and given free lodging in a three-room flat shared with seven other Vietnamese. 
 Every two months he was allowed to send 20 kilos of goods home to his family. 
 Mr Hoi returned home in August 1990, much to the relief of his family, who had read in the newspapers that Germany was in chaos. 
 Yes, he says, he does meet fellow Vietnamese workers who used to be in Germany but, no, they do not discuss politics. 
 A severance payment of DM3,000 (&dollar;1,740) has enabled Mr Hoi to buy a house and spend the past nine months as a man of leisure. 
 He is thinking of opening a small shop. 
 Pham Hong Khang, an engineer, had a less happy time in Bulgaria. 
 In April 1988 he was sent there as leader of a team of 400 construction workers. 
 &bquo;The one thing I learned is that no one does any building during times of political instability.&equo; 
 His men stopped being paid, and there was nothing to buy with the money they had. 
 Their sordid dormitory was attacked by hooligans. 
 Most of the Vietnamese were glad to be sent home. 
 &bquo;Bulgarians used to ask, &bquo;Don't you want to take our demonstration home with you? '. 
 I came back and saw that most Vietnamese workers don't care about politics. 
 What they want is a job.&equo; 
 Mr Khang hopes the Communist Party will &bquo;blow some new wind into our lives&equo;. 
 Neither he nor Mr Hoi intends to make a public fuss if it does not.  
 Death among the blossoms 
 FROM OUR DELHI CORRESPONDENT 
 FLOWERS always decorate Indian election campaigns. 
 The heat sweetens their smell. 
 Rajiv Gandhi, his car bouncing towards a rally in Sriperumbudur in southern India, was covered in garlands by hands that reached through the open window. 
 He was determined to be accessible during the campaign: in the past he had been accused of being too aloof. 
 As they arrived, he asked the local candidate, with whom he was travelling, what he should speak about. 
 The candidate thought village development the most suitable subject. 
 Gandhi walked towards a platform to begin his speech and was blown to pieces by a bomb, along with 14 other people. 
 The bomb may have been concealed in a bouquet of flowers. 
 Gandhi was killed on May 21st, the day after the first of three days of voting in the general election. 
 The electoral process stopped abruptly with the death of the man most likely to be prime minister. 
 As the army was deployed to keep order, the remaining two polling days were postponed until June 12th and 15th. 
 The expected violence broke out at the news of his death. 
 Supporters from his Congress Party burned buses, cars and shops and attacked police stations. 
 Police fired on protesters. 
 At least eight people were killed and many more injured; but things could have been much worse. 
 After his mother's assassination, in 1984, some 3,000 Sikhs were killed in Delhi. 
 Part of the reason there has been so little bloodshed is that nobody yet is certain who killed Mr Gandhi or why. 
 The Tamil Tigers, a separatist group in Sri Lanka, are suspects, since Mr Gandhi had complained that they were becoming a parallel government in Tamil Nadu. 
 He used this as an excuse to force the prime minister, Chandra Shekhar, to sack the pro-Tiger state government earlier this year. 
 One theory is that the bomb was detonated by remote control, a method used to kill Ranjan Wijeratne, Sri Lanka's defence minister, earlier this year. 
 Another possibility is that a woman had a bomb wired to her, and that it went off as she gave flowers to Mr Gandhi. 
 The Tigers have denied responsibility; but they usually do for their atrocities. 
 Sikh terrorists killed Gandhi's mother, and had vowed to get him too. 
 During this election campaign, they have killed an average of 15 people each day in Punjab, including eight candidates, and have tried to kill two prominent candidates in Delhi. 
 But Gandhi had plenty of enemies who would like to boast of his murder: a group like the United Liberation Front of Assam, separatist terrorists in the north-west of the country, could equally well be the culprit. 
 A caller to a newspaper claimed responsibility on behalf of the &bquo;Commander of the Combined Forces&equo;; but this is reckoned to be a hoax. 
 It is clear, though, what killed him: the current of political violence that runs from separatist terrorism to the small-time brutality of local hatreds. 
 Around 200 people were killed in the six weeks of election campaigning, and nearly 200 on the first day of voting. 
 Over the past year, some 2,000 people have been killed in Hindu-Muslim riots, and about 150 in protests against job reservations for particular castes. 
 Illegal arms and bomb factories have been set up in many parts of northern India to fuel the conflicts. 
 The violence fills the void of modern India: the institutions on which independent India was proudly built no longer work. 
 The state is seen as corrupt and callous, incapable of delivering justice or prosperity to the people. 
 India's old-style intellectuals, who preach democracy, secularism and Fabian socialism, are falling silent, belatedly aware of their impotence. 
 Violence is both cause and effect of this failure. 
 Hoodlums hired by virtually all parties use arms and muscle at election time, partly to capture polling booths, partly to repel attempted captures by rival parties. 
 Booth-capturing is no longer seen as an outrage and has become a normal part of electoral strategy, particularly in lawless Bihar. 
 In booths where the presiding officer reports a capture, a second poll is made. 
 But in many booths the presiding officer is in cahoots with the capturers, or may be too terrified of local toughs to protest. 
 Hoodlums have longer arms than the law. 
 The current Indian election was spread over three days to enable security forces to move from one area to another; but even so the chief ministers of Uttar Pradesh and Bihar are reported to have used musclemen to capture booths in the first round of the election. 
 The election commission has therefore countermanded voting in several seats and ordered a re-poll in more than 1,000 booths. 
 Never before has there been such open abuse of power by those who are supposed to set standards for the people. 
 The police and civil service are seen as oppressors and terrorists. 
 The law courts are venal and can take decades to decide a case. 
 The rule of law does not seem to work in settling people's grievances. 
 What seems to work is violence and money, and all political parties are engaged in a mad race to maximise the use of both. 
 Indians believe that nothing much happens to bandits any more since so many of them have links with politicians, and some have even become ministers. 
 The army, long seen as standing above the fray, dirtied its reputation in Kashmir earlier this year. 
 Sent in to suppress separatism, its behaviour has only fostered the movement. 
 Stories of torture, murder and mass rape are widespread. 
 Indians' disillusion with the state is compounded by the failure of successive governments to deliver economic growth. 
 Politicians cling to the rhetoric of socialism while supporting a system which delivers great riches to few businessmen, and profitable cuts to the civil servants and politicians who hand out licences. 
 Indira Gandhi swept the 1971 election crying &bquo;Garibi hatao&equo; &mdash; end poverty &mdash; and Indians, still poor, feel cheated. 
 Most Indians have no chance of bettering themselves. 
 They live in little rooms and spend their days on overcrowded streets. 
 Nerves fray easily. 
 On the pavements, pedestrians bump into each other rather than step aside, and small offences turn quickly into shouting matches. 
 Among frustrated people, violence sparks easily. 
 Amid this moral decay, religious, ethnic and caste crusades have a growing appeal. 
 People find a purity in them which they do not find in secular, national parties. 
 And an increasing number of people are willing to kill in the name of causes which they find holier than the discredited law of the land. 
 Hence the burgeoning popularity of the Bharatiya Janata Party: a fringe party of Hindu extremists only a few years ago, it looks as though it could be part of a government after the election. 
 As institutions weaken, individuals take over. 
 So Congress, clinging to the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty as the country's only stable political landmark, elected Sonia Gandhi, Rajiv's widow, as party president. 
 That decision exposed the party's bankruptcy: with no leader of stature to replace Mr Gandhi, they turned to a woman whose only political asset was her name, which, the party hoped, would bring in the sympathy vote that swung Rajiv into power after his mother's death in 1984. 
 Sonia Gandhi, however, has shown an extreme distaste for politics. 
 When Rajiv was persuaded to go into the family business by his mother in 1980, Sonia was against it. 
 She was happier being the wife of an airline pilot. 
 Sonia refused the party presidency, not surprisingly; and the stock markets, which had plunged at the news of Rajiv's death and risen at the news of her election, plunged again. 
 Her decision has left Congress headless and embarrassed at having exposed its weakness. 
 The party is unlikely to give up on Sonia. 
 It is worth remembering that, when Indira asked Rajiv to go into politics after his elder brother's death in 1980, he put out a statement saying that he had no such intention. 
 Sonia might be persuaded to keep a seat warm for her daughter: Priyanka is only 20 (the minimum age for a seat in the lower house is 25) but is said to be sharp and keen on politics. 
 After all these years, a non-family member will have little authority. 
 One possibility, P.V. 
 Narasimha Rao, is a former foreign minister whose ill-health means he cannot hope to become a permanent head of the party. 
 For that reason, he might be acceptable as a temporary chief. 
 Sharad Pawar, chief minister of Maharashtra, is by far the strongest Congress state leader. 
 Narain Dutt Tewari of Uttar Pradesh could be a contender if he wins the state election being held alongside the parliamentary one; but he may be beaten by the BJP. 
 There is some talk of a collective leadership, but that would not last. 
 Congress might still garner sympathy votes. 
 Before the assassination, opinion polls gave the party 225 to 310 seats out of 537. 
 Votes have been cast in 40% of the seats. 
 Congress might just be able to form the next government alone; if not, it would try to split bits off other parties. 
 If that did not work, a coalition would have to be built. 
 One possibility, given the strong showing of the BJP and the equally strong antipathy to its views amongst other parties, is a secularist line-up. 
 Indians of many parties have been terrified by the prospect of escalating Hindu-Muslim violence, highlighted in Meerut in Uttar Pradesh during the first round of voting, when 19 people were killed. 
 Such an alliance would bring together Congress, the breakaway Socialist Janata Dal run by Chandra Shekhar, and the Janata Dal of V.P. Singh. 
 The Communists, implacable enemies of the BJP, would give their support. 
 That prospect may be less depressing than a future dominated by the BJP, but it leaves little room for optimism. 
 Coalitions have never worked in India, which is why the country has always returned to the comforting but damaging embrace of Congress and the Nehru-Gandhi family. 
 INTERNATIONAL 
 The man who killed millions 
 AT THE bitter end the dictator ran for it. 
 President Mengistu Haile Mariam, who misruled his country for 14 years, fled on May 21st to Zimbabwe, where his retreat was prepared. 
 The rebels, whose advance had brought them within 50 miles (80 km) of the capital, Addis Ababa, were undecided whether to fight on. 
 Mr Mengistu handed over the reins, ad interim, to Lieutenant-General Tesfaye Gebre Kidan. 
 He commanded the government troops in Eritrea, and chaired the court martial in 1989 which disposed of 12 of his fellow-generals for plotting an anti-Mengistu coup. 
 Yet he passes for a moderate within the fierce revolutionary council, the Dergue. 
 His appointment as vice-president in April was intended to buy time. 
 If the rebels were prudent they would hold the line where it is, and take advantage of the peace talks that the American State Department has by steady diplomacy arranged for them in London. 
 But they are divided. 
 The junta is dominated (as Ethiopia has always been) by men who speak Amharic. 
 The main rebel movements represent other regions. 
 The Eritrean People's Liberation Front stands for secession (following a referendum) of its own relatively developed region. 
 The Ethiopian People's Revolutionary Democratic Front, whose leaders are Tigreans, wants autonomy and elections, but no votes for feudalists and capitalists. 
 The smaller Oromo Liberation Front, which also favours devolution rather than secession, speaks for the people outsiders call the Galla, the second-largest of Ethiopia's many peoples. 
 (A smaller complication is the presence near Addis Ababa of nearly 20,000 Falashas, black Jews whom the Israelis may now be tempted to rescue in an Entebbe-style commando raid.) 
 The failure of the Mengistu regime is shown by the success of this uneasy coalition. 
 Ethiopia's army is immense, with some 430,000 men; but they are mostly unwilling conscripts, and the Soviet Union has cut off their supplies. 
 By some accounts front-line soldiers on both sides have lately taken to doing local deals with each other, so fewer people die than the officers report. 
 The chief victims are, as usual, civilians. 
 The harvest has been bad. 
 With fighting on the highways, it is harder than ever to shift food to where it is needed. 
 Earlier this year the World Food Programme was reckoning that some 5m people were at risk of famine in the north of the country; if so, some 1.2m tonnes of grain would be needed to feed them, of which a bit over half has been pledged by donors. 
 As the rebels advanced, the roads were blocked to civilian traffic. 
 Food, whether as aid or as normal trade, could not be moved from the ports to the people who needed it. 
 The aid agencies were starting to sound panicky, as well they might. 
 The horrors of the Ethiopian famine of 1984&ndash;85 are too vivid to be easily forgotten. 
 As long as President Mengistu held on, there was a real chance that it might all happen again. 
 If the Americans with their peace talks do get the parties together, their first business will be to arrange a truce so that food can move. 
 It is hard to see how such a regime could have survived for so long, after bringing such unexampled disaster on its people. 
 Ethiopia, fortunately, is a special case. 
 The junta that overthrew the old Emperor Haile Selassie in 1974 brutally eliminated the tiny, rich and greedy elite around him. 
 That left nobody who could run anything. 
 Soviet ministries were ordered to fill the gaps, and sent their discards. 
 Ethiopia became a punishment station for rejects from one the world's most incompetent bureaucracies. 
 Under that influence the Ethiopian soldiers tried, literally, to imitate Stalin; to jump a multi-ethnic feudal state, with no transition, into communism. 
 They slaughtered kulaks, and transformed vast, unproductive private estates into vast, unproductive state farms. 
 Farmers who stored food from a good harvest were shot for hoarding. 
 Merchants who bought food in surplus areas for sale in drought districts were shot for profiteering. 
 Provincial discontent, however justified, was met with repression. 
 Soviet aid for the army was not matched by aid for civilian development. 
 By the end the regime was spending more than 70% of its revenue on weapons, and practically nothing on roads, water supplies, schools and the rest. 
 Pressure from western governments, unwilling to contemplate another famine on their domestic television screens, forced the junta last year to loosen up control of farms and trade; but too late. 
 Other African countries find natural sponsors in the West, in the form of their former colonial masters. 
 Ethiopia's period under colonial rule, by the Italians in the late 1930s, was too short to earn much salutary guilt from the ex-colonists. 
 If Ethiopia falls apart, nobody outside will weep for it; nor, if it holds together, will any outsider pay the vast bill for putting it to rights.  
 Iraq 
 The man they hate to love 
 SO LONG as Saddam Hussein is still around, George Bush repeated this week, Iraq can expect no mercy on trade sanctions. 
 At the same time the Americans, like others involved in the Kurdish operation, are crossing their fingers in hope of an agreement between Mr Hussein and the Kurdish leaders negotiating with him in Baghdad. 
 If he, and the authority he carries, were not there, an accord might be impossible. 
 Scepticism about the value of his word has been laid to one side; western governments want a respectable, and reasonably fast, way out for their troops in Kurdistan. 
 An agreement on Kurdish autonomy would bring the Kurds back to their towns and villages, rendering a western military presence superfluous. 
 The reports drifting out of Baghdad suggest that an accord of some sort is on the way. 
 Masoud Barzani, who leads the Kurdish delegation, says the two sides have managed to agree on most of the 20 points at issue, but are still arguing on the exact limits of the autonomous zone. 
 Other reports suggest, plausibly, that the hottest argument now is about money, in particular what proportion of oil revenue should go to the Kurds &mdash; and, perhaps, which Kurds. 
 If it pays reparations, Iraq will not have much oil money left. 
 The history of autonomy agreements and their non-implementation is lamentable. 
 Mr Barzani's father, Mullah Mustapha, fixed a splendid agreement in 1970 that came to nothing, helped to extinction by treachery on both sides. 
 (Mr Barzani was thick with Mr Hussein's Israeli and Iranian enemies; Mr Hussein probably tried to get Mr Barzani assassinated.) 
 There is theoretical discussion of some kind of international guarantee to ensure that what is agreed now will be implemented later, but no sign of what form this might take. 
 The Kurdish delegates, to underline the point that they too are Iraqi, speak up against any violation of sovereignty; they may also be proposing that the Kurdish guerrillas be somehow absorbed into the Iraqi armed forces as a local militia protecting the autonomous zone. 
 All this alarms the non-Kurdish Iraqi opposition (although the Kurdish package is said to include promises on a free multi-party system). 
 The Kurdish refugees want to see Saddam's promises enforced by American power; some of the 500,000 who fled to Turkey have drifted home, but not the 1m who fled to Iran. 
 Yet the confusion in Dohuk, a Kurdish city left empty by the flight of refugees, shows how all decisions hung on an autonomy agreement. 
 The Americans and British, intent on not getting stuck in the town, wandered in and out talking of electricity and sanitation, then said they would send a few soldiers for a short time. 
 The United Nations, having agreed with the Baghdad government that some 500 UN security men can be stationed in Iraq, sent ten guards in five white Land-Rovers from its Geneva office. 
 Iraq's soldiers retreated a few miles from the town; its policemen were still there masquerading as traffic cops. 
 To prepare for the Great Return, Iraqi workmen were this week assiduously painting zebra-stripes on the deserted streets. 
 EUROPE 
 European defence 
 All dressed up, but not ready to go 
 FROM OUR BONN, MADRID, PARIS AND ROME CORRESPONDENTS 
 Even if Europeans could agree on which institution to rely for their future defence, would Europe's armies be ready for a fray? 
 ONE of the great virtues of the Soviet armed forces was that for 40 years West Europeans and Americans could agree that they were the main threat to NATO. 
 That feeling of certainty has gone. 
 NATO's politicians and defence planners are struggling to agree on what threats Europe now faces and on what sort of common defences it should have in future. 
 While they argue, those whose task it is to make sure the troops will be there on the day have to get on with more practical jobs. 
 Though the current talk is about establishing multinational units and of creating a European rapid-deployment force that could be sent off at short notice to cope with unexpected contingencies, Europe's armies have too many of the wrong sorts of forces, doing the wrong jobs. 
 Not only is the chief enemy of old melting away, the chief ally is doing likewise. 
 Of the 300,000 or so American troops based in Europe until the start of the Gulf crisis last summer, perhaps only 100,000, maybe fewer, are expected to remain. 
 The days when Europeans could idly theorise about &bquo;burden-sharing&equo; with America and building a &bquo;European pillar&equo; inside NATO are over. 
 The burden is now suddenly upon them. 
 The pillar to support it, however, is looking decidedly shaky. 
 Europe has no shortage of citizens in uniform. 
 The armies of Britain, France, Germany, Italy and Spain &mdash; the core of any new European defence force &mdash; number close to 2m (although cuts and reorganisations are on the way). 
 But legal restraints, plus the political difficulty in today's Europe of sending conscripts off to far-away fights, leads to the obvious question: would they fight? 
 During the Gulf conflict most attention in America and Britain was directed at Germany's constitutional inability (some would say unwillingness) to commit any troops outside NATO territory. 
 But others were constrained too. 
 Unlike Britain, which has an all-professional army, France is hampered by a law that prohibits conscripts, though not volunteers, from being sent off to foreign wars. 
 Any conscript who may have wanted to go to the Gulf would have had to volunteer or to join the Foreign Legion, the paratroops or the naval infantry &mdash; units which are all made up entirely of volunteers. 
 In the event France sent 10,000 ground troops (compared with Britain's 45,000). 
 Despite having an army of 285,000 (to be cut to 250,000 over the next three years), France would have been hard-pressed to do more. 
 Italy likewise has a clause in its constitution banning the use of its armed forces &bquo;to settle international disputes&equo;. 
 Italy got around this by declaring the Gulf operation an &bquo;international constabulary measure&equo;. 
 But Italy's contribution &mdash; ten Tornado aircraft, two frigates and two naval auxiliary ships &mdash; was still small, compared with the size of its armed forces. 
 That has increased pressure to move to a more professional army. 
 The Italian army chief of staff, General Goffredo Canino, also wants an all-volunteer rapid intervention force composed of five brigades with, in all, 30,000 men. 
 According to a study by Italy's joint chiefs of staff, a manpower shortage may lead to the army being cut by up to half over the next 20 years. 
 The idea of a professional army is increasingly popular in Spain, too. 
 A poll taken earlier this year showed 80% support for abolishing conscription. 
 Even then Spain's army might not turn up when needed. 
 Another opinion poll, published in the magazine Cambio 16, found that only 8% of those questioned were prepared to die for their country. 
 If it's not money, it's philosophy 
 Even if they were razor-keen to fight, not all of Europe's armies are well enough organised or armed. 
 Italy's and Spain's lack the training and much of the arms to play a credible part in a future European force. 
 Spain in particular, with its relatively large, shambling army (a relic from the Franco era) cut off behind the Pyrenees, has been under pressure from NATO to put more money into its air force and navy. 
 But with defence spending already falling away (this year's defence budget is 7&ndash;8% in real terms below last year's), the chance looks bleak. 
 Of the other two big continental powers, Germany is busy absorbing the former East German army and cutting the new all-German force to a promised limit of 370,000 men, as agreed to in the European conventional arms-control treaty in Paris last November. 
 Once this is done, it will have one of the strongest and best organised military forces in Europe. 
 Germany's chancellor, Helmut Kohl, is determined that, despite opposition from the left, his country should then pull its proper weight. 
 Last month extra German troops were sent to Iran to help cope with the refugees flooding in from Iraq. 
 That is a start. 
 But until a majority of Germans, and not just their chancellor, decide how far Europe's interests are worth defending, the Bundeswehr will be hobbled. 
 France has other worries. 
 Ever since de Gaulle pulled France out of NATO's integrated military command in 1966, there has been a remarkable national consensus behind defence policy. 
 This may be about to change. 
 France's nuclear weapons swallow up almost a third of defence spending. 
 That was sustainable so long as France faced an unquestioned nuclear threat from the Soviet Union, and needed to respond with only small-scale military operations overseas (in Chad, for example, or Gabon). 
 Until the Gulf war it had never had to contemplate a high-tech non-nuclear war. 
 In the Gulf, France's lack of modern heavy armour pushed it into a glamorous, but marginal, job on the flank. 
 Although he insists there will be no change in France's basic strategy, President Mitterrand has called for a national debate on defence. 
 Money complicates matters. 
 The slow but steady rise in France's defence spending has begun to turn down this year. 
 In addition to the cuts in its ground forces, some military orders have had to be postponed. 
 The nuclear arsenal is to be remodelled around submarines and aircraft, and land-based missiles phased out. 
 But the real difficulty for France, as might be expected, is philosophical. 
 Although it has kept NATO's military command at arm's length all these years, France does not want to see the Americans, still the basis of Europe's security and stability, pull out completely. 
 Yet it wants to emphasise the Europeanness of any future European defence collaboration. 
 With both France and Germany in two minds about how and where Europe should be defended, even remodelled European armies will find it hard to march in step.  
 At the moment of creation 
 Political power in the Soviet Union is like matter at the beginning of the universe. 
 The dense mass known as the Communist Party is splitting into a bewildering variety of elements. 
 Our Moscow correspondent offers a cosmic guide 
 THE drag of tradition may yet cause the Soviet Union's big bang to collapse back on itself. 
 But through the confusion, the outline of a multi-party system can already be picked out. 
 There are two key distinctions. 
 One is between &bquo;centralisers&equo; and &bquo;regionalists&equo;: those who want control to remain in Moscow and those who want it to spread down to republics and localities. 
 The other is between &bquo;authoritarians&equo; and &bquo;democrats&equo;, the classic struggle between the advocates of a strong state and the believers in popular sovereignty. 
 Democrats tend to be free-marketeers (known, confusingly, as the left), authoritarians tend to be central planners (who are known as the right). 
 But democrats are not necessarily for de-centralisation. 
 And some thorough-going Communists, such as the Ukraine Communists and the so-called Centre Block, want more powers for the republics. 
 A big test for all these groups is the election for Russia's president, due to be held next month. 
 This pits the incumbent, Boris Yeltsin, who is moderately democratic and for the republics, against Nikolai Ryzhkov, an orthodox Communist. 
 A third candidate, Vadim Bakatin, is the closest of the three to Mikhail Gorbachev. 
 As the chart shows, Mr Gorbachev is &mdash; or tries to occupy &mdash; dead centre on both the democrat-authoritarian and the regionalist-centraliser lines. 
 The Communist Party is still the only organised political group with both money and power. 
 It has five main groups within it, a sign, some members say, of its democratic character. 
 The first three overlap. 
 These are: 
 1. 
 The Communists of Russia. 
 These are old party bosses who believe in strong central government, not least because it confirms their own power. 
 Their leader, Ivan Polozkov, has backing from local officials across the Russian republic. 
 They have about a quarter of the seats in the Russian parliament. 
 Boris Yeltsin's victory at a recent session of the parliament has weakened them. 
 2. 
 The Marxist Platform. 
 These are mainly party intellectuals who still profess communism, but want it to be less centralising and more democratic. 
 Their leader, Alexander Buzgalin, wants some co-operation with reformers. 
 3. 
 Soyuz (Union). 
 This, strictly, is a pressure group of more than 500 deputies in the Soviet parliament, rather than a faction of the Soviet Communist Party itself. 
 But nearly all its members are Communists. 
 They have acted as parliamentary cannon fodder for the &bquo;black colonels&equo;, Nikolai Petrushenko and Viktor Alksnis, who want a nationwide state of emergency. 
 Prodded by its chairman, Yuri Blokhin, Soyuz is beginning to edge away from the colonels and towards the reformers. 
 It has also now taken the first steps towards setting up a country-wide party. 
 4. 
 Communists for Democracy. 
 These are reform Communists. 
 Their demands are much like those of the ill-fated Democratic Platform &mdash; reformers who quit the party but failed to organise themselves into a workable opposition. 
 Their chief aim is to transform their party into an ordinary election-fighting group rather than a semi-official civil service. 
 5. 
 Entrepreneurial Communists. 
 Odd as the label sounds, this group has influence beyond its size. 
 Under Pavel Bunich, these Communists for Business, as they might be called, want to reconcile entrepreneurship and planning. 
 When two or more members of the &bquo;democratic opposition&equo; meet, one leaves to form a new party. 
 The largest, the Democratic Party, claims 25,000 members. 
 It split at its second congress in late April. 
 Gary Kasparov, the world chess champion and head of the party's Moscow branch, accused the party's leader, Nikolai Travkin, of insufficient hostility to Mr Gorbachev, and quit. 
 One organisation, Democratic Russia, unites most of these groups. 
 It can bring hundreds of thousands of people into big-city streets in support of Mr Yeltsin. 
 Their favourite, however, belongs to no party. 
 Another problem for Democratic Russia is that it, too, is splitting. 
 Its radicals, who dominate the leadership, want no truck with Mr Gorbachev. 
 Its other wing might be called &bquo;coalition builders&equo;. 
 This includes the mayor of Moscow, Mr Gavriil Popov, who recently quit the leadership. 
 His group hopes to gather together reform Communists such as Edward Shevardnadze and Mr Bakatin (both former ministers) and the Communists for Democracy. 
 What might come out of this cosmic turmoil? 
 Mr Gorbachev last month signed an agreement with nine republics which, amongst other things, proposed elections to a new Soviet parliament sometime next year. 
 If that agreement is carried through, new alliances may form as the election nears. 
 A widely shared dream is for the Communist party to split, leaving its old-guard (the Communists of Russia, Soyuz and the Marxists) to form a socialist party and the reformers (the Entrepreneurial Communists and Communists for Democracy) a social-democratic one. 
 This might just be led by President Gorbachev, in alliance with Democrats who, in turn, had shed their radical wing.  
 Inside an ancient quarrel 
 FROM A SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN CROATIA 
 IF ONLY it were a battle of flags. 
 Croatia's towns and villages are flying their opposing banners and their referendum posters, which both proclaim: &bquo;for&equo;. 
 Croat posters demand a &bquo;for&equo; vote for a &bquo;sovereign and independent&equo; state. 
 Croatia's Serb villages demand a &bquo;for&equo; vote for union with Serbia. 
 Both have now been endorsed, with massive majorities, by their respective electorates. 
 Croatia's rebel Serbs live in a string of southern villages in an area called Krajina near the town of Knin, and in another string of villages in Slavonia to the north. 
 Their ancestors defended these old border regions of the Austro-Hungarian empire from the Turks. 
 Today they have their own militias, guns and roadblocks. 
 They fly the flags of the republic of Serbia, Yugoslav flags and historic flags adorned with the initials of the motto: &bquo;Only Serbian unity will save the Serbs&equo;. 
 Amongst their gunmen are Chetniks, named after Serbia's wartime anti-communist resistance, who come from Serbia proper. 
 In Knin, Croat-owned shops have been smashed and looted. 
 Some of Croatia's 600,000 Serbs (out of a population of 4.6m) have seen an independent Croatia before. 
 Tens of thousands of their fellows were murdered by the forces of Croatia's wartime fascist state in the most bestial way. 
 Ruined churches still stand as testaments to the women and children burnt alive in them during those years. 
 Serb villagers egged on by propaganda from Serbia fear the nightmare is returning. 
 Mad rumours circulate about Croatian doctors determined to murder them. 
 Most Croatian Serbs do not live in Krajina but are scattered through the republic. 
 The behaviour of Serbs in Krajina and Slavonia is turning their Croat neighbours against them. 
 &bquo;Most of Zagreb's Serbs probably came out to vote in Croatia's referendum because they were scared,&equo; said a Serb historian. 
 &bquo;They just wanted to be seen as loyal citizens.&equo; 
 Many of them are losing their jobs, but they cannot move to Serbia because its economy is in even worse shape than Croatia's. 
 Instead of outrage at last week's blocking of the succession of Stipe Mesic, a Croat, as Yugoslavia's new president, officials in Zagreb smile at the propaganda coup handed to them by Serb politicians in Belgrade. 
 It helped make up the minds of waverers on the question of independence and it sent a signal about Serbian intentions to the outside world. 
 &bquo;For too long the international community has swallowed the Serb propaganda line,&equo; said Zvonko Lerotic, an advisor to Croatia's president, Franjo Tudjman. 
 For months Croatia's politicians have said that, if a looser Yugoslavia were not soon formed, they would have to go it alone. 
 Politicians in Belgrade have tried to call their bluff. 
 But with the hardening of the mood in Krajina and shootings in Slavonia something far worse is emerging. 
 The federal army has been called in to act as a buffer in areas of high tension. 
 Politicians in Zagreb have no trouble in imagining them as the advance guard of a new patrol on the frontiers of a greater Serbia. 
 No city could look more normal than Zagreb. 
 Its smartly dressed citizens go about their business as if nothing was happening. 
 But fear lurks beneath the surface and is beginning to paralyse normal life. 
 One Serb said: &bquo;The problem is that no one knows what will happen. 
 Serbs are being isolated and isolating themselves.&equo; 
 One Croat student said: &bquo;On the day of the referendum I was woken up very early in the morning. 
 There were people in the street shouting the name of Croatia's wartime fascist state. 
 It made my flesh creep.&equo; 
 Croatia's referendum was a joyless affair. 
 Over the last few months the republic had been buoyed by waves of euphoria. 
 Depression has now set in. 
 &bquo;We want our own state, we want our flag,&equo; said a museum curator, &bquo;but in this situation we cannot plan anything. 
 We think about where to send the children abroad if there is war. 
 All we want is for things to go back to normal.&equo;  
 Yugoslavia 
 The lookers-on 
 GEOGRAPHY lessons in Yugoslav schools used to start with the teacher pointing out that the first letters of the names of the states surrounding Yugoslavia added up to the word brigama, &bquo;worries&equo;. 
 Now it is the turn of Yugoslavia's neighbours &mdash; and nations beyond &mdash; to do the worrying. 
 Ideally, they would like a united, democratic Yugoslavia. 
 Overlook secession in Yugoslavia and who knows what precedent this might set. 
 But they are no longer sure what they can do to prevent a break-up if it comes. 
 Yugoslavia is going to be a problem, in bulk or in bits. 
 The main issue for its western friends is becoming how to limit the damage. 
 Rivalries between Serbia and Croatia, Yugoslavia's two largest republics, seem to be near breaking-point. 
 To nudge Serbia, which can be blamed for much of the recent trouble, towards better conduct, and to discourage any thought of an army coup, the United States earlier this month cut off aid to Yugoslavia. 
 The Nickles amendment, passed by Congress last November, gave Yugoslavia until May 6th to end the repression of ethnic Albanians in Kosovo, on pain of losing about &dollar;5m worth of technical aid in the fiscal year 1991. 
 This is small change, even by Yugoslav standards. 
 But the amendment also obliges the United States to oppose &bquo;by word and vote&equo; any further lending to Yugoslavia by the World Bank and the International Monetary Fund. 
 There was dismay in Belgrade. 
 The federal prime minister, Mr Ante Markovic, rang up President Bush earlier this week pleading for the administration's help. 
 The president promised Mr Markovic, whom he had backed on previous occasions, that he would give it. 
 In Washington, the administration has now let it be known that it will work for the softening of the amendment's consequences, provided &mdash; and forgetting Kosovo for the moment &mdash; that Stipe Mesic, a Croat, is no longer obstructed by the Serbs from taking up the post of chairman (for one year) of Yugoslavia's eight-member presidency. 
 Mr Mesic should have done so on May 15th, in line with a procedure used since the actual adoption of the rotating presidency in 1980. 
 But Serbia, with the provinces of Kosovo and Vojvodina, which it controls, voted against and Montenegro, Serbia's ally, abstained. 
 Mr Mesic had the votes of Croatia, Bosnia, Macedonia and Slovenia, which were not enough for a majority. 
 The Serbian action angered the Americans, who had been assured by Borisav Jovic, the previous chairman-president (a Serb), and Slobodan Milosevic, Serbia's leader (an old-style communist), that Mr Mesic would not be opposed. 
 The blocking of Mr Mesic's appointment could push Croatia and Slovenia into secession before the end of June. 
 By then these republics want agreement on making Yugoslavia a confederation of sovereign states. 
 Otherwise they will break away. 
 Slovenes voted for this last December; in Croatia on May 19th 94% of those voting (in an 83% turnout) opted for a sovereign Croatia (see box on previous page). 
 The Bush administration hopes that the message will have got through, both to Serbia, which is in an economic mess, and to the Yugoslav army. 
 Many army officers dislike the thought of Mr Mesic as their supreme commander (one of the jobs of the presidency's chairman). 
 But they also want their salaries paid. 
 The Americans hope that the installation of Mr Mesic would bolster Croats and Slovenes who hang back from independence now; that Mr Markovic and his economic reform would win a reprieve; and that time might be gained for Serbian opposition to Mr Milosevic to grow. 
 For President Bush and James Baker, his secretary of state, the break-up of Yugoslavia would not be as alarming as that of Iraq. 
 Yet they reckon it could set a bad example elsewhere in Eastern Europe (Czechoslovakia) as well as in bigger, more important places (India and, when their worries turn that way, the Soviet Union). 
 Others lower down the administration share this concern but doubt whether Yugoslavia can hold together in its current form. 
 Many European diplomats feel the same way. 
 European politicians continue to plead, sincerely, that Yugoslavia should endure. 
 But behind the scenes some countries have (unlike the Americans) already begun planning for a different outcome. 
 They are, as one senior British official puts it, &bquo;adapting to new realities without necessarily encouraging them&equo;.  
 &hellip; and unto Poland, what is God's 
 FROM OUR WARSAW CORRESPONDENT 
 DURING his most recent visit to his native Poland in 1987, crowds chanting &bquo;Down with communism&equo; greeted Pope John Paul II. 
 Since then, communism has fallen, and his once-faithful compatriots will no longer welcome him with the same fervour when he arrives for his fourth visit on June 1st. 
 He may even meet some Poles who demonstrate against him. 
 While nine Poles in ten call themselves Roman Catholics, they are discovering, with the help of a free press, that they disagree, sometimes violently, over the Catholic church's role in their public life and private morality. 
 It may come as a shock. 
 That the end of communism could also prove to be the end of the Catholic church's unquestioned moral authority in Poland was the last thing the church hierarchy expected when the Solidarity leader, Tadeusz Mazowiecki, himself a long-time Catholic activist, became the first non-communist prime minister in 1989. 
 The triumph of Solidarity was seen by many as a triumph for the church, which had preached against communism, harboured Solidarity activists, and paid for underground presses throughout the dismal 1980s. 
 The pope himself may even have hoped that the fall of communism might inspire decadent Western Europe to renew its faith, and help spread Catholicism into the Soviet Union. 
 The first difficulties began to appear last year after the Mazowiecki government, without consulting the public or the parliament, decreed that children should be taught religion in schools, in effect making Catholicism close to a state religion. 
 Many who did not object to this in principle disliked the high-handed way it was adopted. 
 Questions were raised about the power of a shadowy &bquo;Government-and-church Council&equo;, headed by Mr Mazowiecki and leading members of the episcopate, which had considerable influence over many government decisions. 
 The crack widened recently after the Polish primate, Cardinal Jozef Glemp, announced his desire to end the &bquo;communist-inspired&equo; separation of church and state. 
 Several newspapers and magazines opened their pages to a full-fledged debate, complete with angry letters, editorials, and articles with headlines like &bquo;Are we ruled by clergy?&equo; 
 For the first time since the end of censorship, the Polish press (long plagued by communist traditions of slanted reporting) conducted a public argument neutrally and eloquently. 
 Meanwhile, a group of Catholic senators was trying to push through parliament a bill banning abortion and granting &bquo;full human rights&equo; to the foetus in time for the pope's visit. 
 This set off another heated debate. 
 Cardinal Glemp objected to a proposal to hold a national referendum on the issue. 
 &bquo;There are certain eternal values which cannot be put to referendum,&equo; he announced. 
 Poll on poll has suggested that over half the population believes abortion should be legal as a matter of course, and that nearly 90% say it should be legal in certain cases. 
 Last week, parliament finally decided not to vote on the bill, effectively putting off the decision until after parliamentary elections in the autumn &mdash; and perhaps forever. 
 Not everyone is surprised by the changing mood. 
 The western image of Poland as a highly orthodox Catholic nation was always slightly amiss. 
 Poles flocked to churches during the darkest years of martial law partly because the church was the only legal form of opposition to communism. 
 Anti-clericalism is as deeply embedded among Polish peasants as is faith in the Virgin Mary. 
 Now that it is no longer traitorous, popular antagonism towards the Catholic church has become open. 
 Insults that Poles once directed at &bquo;reds&equo; (communists) are now aimed at &bquo;blacks&equo; (priests). 
 Churches have been vandalised and an altar built for the pope's visit was burned down. 
 President Lech Walesa has played a curiously neutral role in this debate. 
 Though he describes himself as &bquo;pro-life&equo;, he did nothing to push the anti-abortion bill through parliament. 
 His visit to Israel this week had a double purpose. 
 One was to answer the commonly held feeling abroad that he and many of his countrymen were anti-Semitic. 
 During his speech to the Israeli Knesset, he asked forgiveness from Jews who may have suffered in the past at Polish hands. 
 The other aim was to promote the argument for religious toleration among Poles. 
 Mr Walesa has now apparently decided to stress the more open-minded traditions of Polish patriotism &mdash; Poland was once a central European melting pot &mdash; and to distance himself from the foreigner-hating sort of nationalism to be found among some Polish politicians and churchmen. 
 This loud public debate is part of a larger change in Poland. 
 It is one sign among many that the country is at last moving away from post-communist politics and towards modern European democracy. 
 The change began with the anguished division of the old Solidarity opposition into warring factions last year. 
 That split ended an era, but brought about the birth of real political parties. 
 For a politician to proclaim faith in Solidarity and a Catholic God is no longer enough to win votes. 
 Grassroots organisation, posters, advertisements and arguments are needed too. 
 More change is coming. 
 This week the Solidarity trade union &mdash; the workers, that is, bereft of old leaders who have gone on to other things &mdash; led a two-hour nationwide protest strike. 
 Other strikes (notably among Warsaw's transport workers) have called for a loosening of the government's tight monetary policy and an end to wage control. 
 After a long fight to beat inflation, the government does not feel sympathetic to these demands. 
 Class divisions have reappeared: private entrepreneurs grumble that ungrateful workers have forgotten how bad things were a year ago. 
 Once, the fight against communism seemed to unite the nation beneath the Black Madonna of Czestochowa, the Polish white eagle, and the memory of the martyrs of World War II and Stalinism. 
 No longer.  
 France 
 As you were 
 FROM OUR PARIS CORRESPONDENT 
 IN THE words of the Gaullist leader, Jacques Chirac, France's eagerly awaited new government has turned out to be the former Rocard government minus Michel Rocard. 
 Or more or less. 
 There may be a few more Mitterrand loyalists, a few less Rocard supporters and non-Socialist centrists, and one more woman (seven out of 46 ministers, including the new prime minister, Edith Cresson). 
 But all of the most powerful posts &mdash; economy, foreign affairs, defence, interior, justice, education &mdash; are filled by the same old faces. 
 Mrs Cresson's appointment is being taken as a shift to the left, particularly in view of the exclusion of seven of the centrist ministers, and as a shift towards protectionism, with the departure of Roger Fauroux, the old cabinet's loudest free-trader. 
 But this has yet to be reflected in policy. 
 Mrs Cresson is more interventionist than her predecessor and has made cutting unemployment a priority. 
 But economic policy will remain in the competent, liberal hands of Pierre B&eacute;r&eacute;govoy. 
 He heads a new &bquo;super-ministry&equo;, covering industry, foreign trade, post and telecommunications, commerce and the budget, as well as economy and finance. 
 Lack of cash leaves little room for manoeuvre on social policy. 
 (Lionel Jospin, education minister and the titular number two in the government, turned down the social-affairs ministry for that very reason.) 
 Defence and foreign policy, including Europe, remain under the direct control of the president. 
 Like Mr Rocard in 1988, Mrs Cresson decided not to call for a vote of confidence on her new government's programme, outlined to parliament on May 22nd. 
 The Socialists' meagre ranks, already 16 short of a clear parliamentary majority, have been further depleted by the appointment of a fresh bunch of nine Socialist deputies to the government. 
 French ministers must give up their seats to substitutes, who then have to wait a month before they may vote. 
 The six former Socialist deputies dropped from the government &mdash; including Mr Rocard &mdash; cannot automatically reclaim their seats but, having persuaded their substitutes to stand down, must win a by-election. 
 Mrs Cresson has already several times hinted that parliament may be dissolved if the conservative opposition tries to block government bills. 
 However, her warnings are aimed less at the right than at the Communists and their 26 deputies, who would fare badly in an early general election. 
 A poll of voting intentions &mdash; published on May 21st, but taken before Mrs Cresson's appointment &mdash; indicated that the two main right-wing parties would easily win a general election with 40% of the vote, giving them around 336 seats (47 more than an absolute majority). 
 The Socialists would come a poor second with 26.5%; the Communists could expect no more than 7%. 
 Mrs Cresson's appointment may have helped the Socialists somewhat but cannot have done much for the Communists. 
 It is little surprise that they are saying that for the time being they will give Mrs Cresson the &bquo;benefit of the doubt&equo;. 
 Mrs Cresson will nevertheless need all her negotiating skills to steer her bills through parliament. 
 Communist support cannot be counted on for the tough measures needed to balance the social-security budget, reform state pensions and increase government revenues. 
 Further cuts in government spending will be needed to give a promised new boost to industry. 
 Despite the reduction in the number of centre ministers, Mrs Cresson knows she will still often need the abstentions, if not the votes, of the 39 centre deputies. 
 As she herself has said, &bquo;One always needs to govern more in the centre than one wants. 
 Compromises are sometimes necessary.&equo; 
 BRITAIN 
 Bouquet of barbed wire 
 THE annual Chelsea flower show, mecca for gardening England, opened this week. 
 Among the sea of sweet old ladies giving hints on pruning roses is a police stand, with two members of the constabulary dispensing advice on an equally prickly issue: garden theft. 
 Judging by the interest shown so far, their display could become a fixture of the show. 
 The police can only guess at the scale of the problem, for stealing from gardens is not treated separately in station crime-books. 
 A survey last August by the Consumers Association suggested that one garden in 20 had been burgled in the past two years, and that the average value of each theft was &pound;130. 
 These amount to rich pickings, given that more than 20m British households have a garden. 
 Garden criminals range from gnome-snaffling pranksters to professionals who swoop on country houses at night armed with a crane and a lorry, ready to snatch everything from &pound;20,000 orchids down to the last &pound;700 Koi carp in the pond. 
 Garden machinery is the most popular swag &mdash; a grass-cutting tractor costs over &pound;1,000. 
 Ordinary tools and plants are next into the bag. 
 Most of them find their way back to garden centres to be re-sold. 
 A raid on a centre in Northumberland last year netted &pound;200,000-worth of loot. 
 At the flower show, Constable Offer and his colleague are trying to persuade gardeners to be more security-conscious, and security firms to be more garden-conscious. 
 They are also dreaming up gadgets. 
 Their breakthroughs include a burglar-proof hanging basket, an anchoring system to keep tables and chairs from wandering and a coded ignition button for lawn-mowers. 
 Their blueprint for a sort of gun-rack for spades and hoes has been taken up by one manufacturer. 
 Chelsea's crime-fighters prescribe a combination of fencing, trellises and prickly plants. 
 Floodlights help, too, as do perimeter alarms. 
 Gardeners might also fork out &pound;2,000 for a statue-alarm &mdash; now commonplace in gardens owned by the National Trust. 
 Every gnome should have one.  
 Is London turning? 
 DESCRIBING a slow arc past the grand but desolate-looking County Hall, once home of the Greater London Council (GLC), the good ship Natitia noses down the green, greasy Thames. 
 At its prow Neil Kinnock grins at a firing-squad of cameramen. 
 The Labour leader is on his way to launch his party's manifesto for London, &bquo;A World Class Capital&equo;. 
 Just too small to be noticed from the boat, a graffito on County Hall reads &bquo;Come back, Ken&equo;. 
 Ken Livingstone, now a humble Labour backbencher, was leader of the GLC and guru of those who believed rainbow-coalition politics was coming to Britain. 
 Then Margaret Thatcher spoiled their fun by abolishing the council five years ago. 
 He remains a potent symbol. 
 One Tory MP, musing on a possible slogan for the capital, warned of &bquo;red tape, red ink and Red Ken&equo;. 
 Labour, which says it will create a Greater London Authority to fill the hole left by the &bquo;spiteful&equo; destruction of the GLC, promises the new body will not be a re-creation of Mr Livingstone's power-base, but a leaner, hungrier outfit. 
 The GLC's high-spending, snook-cocking leftism made London politics exciting. 
 But the explosion of post-1960s Marxism inside the London Labour Party, of which it was a symptom, became steadily more unpopular and venomous during the 1980s. 
 The last hard-left council, Lambeth, now close to organisational and political collapse, still sends shivers down voters' spines across the capital. 
 Even now, according to internal polling, Labour is doing worse in London &mdash; some three points behind &mdash; than in the rest of the south. 
 Yet London contains around 25 Labour-winnable marginal seats. 
 If Mr Kinnock is to make it to Downing Street, the party needs to win almost all of them. 
 As a region, London matters much more to Labour's ambition than Scotland or Wales does &mdash; or even both together.  
 The new manifesto, with its lists of promises for a better urban environment and less-congested transport system, enjoyed a good reception &mdash; including a laudatory front-page endorsement from London's only daily newspaper, the strongly anti-Labour Evening Standard. 
 This is partly because Labour has picked up a mood of unease about the city among its residents, fearful of Frankfurt taking over its role as Europe's financial capital, and jealous of Paris's self-confidence and infrastructure. 
 A poll suggested 46% of Londoners would leave if they could. 
 (Though the city has never been a paradise, especially in warm weather. 
 Swift cursed 280 years ago, &bquo;May my enemies live here in summer!&equo;) 
 More prosaically, Labour hopes to benefit from the extra pain of high mortgages and from the southern recession. 
 The city's jobless rate is already 7.3% and rising &mdash; compared with 2.6% in the 1980 recession and 9.3% in the worst month of the 1980s, July 1986. 
 There are more unemployed Londoners than unemployed Scots (though the rate in Scotland is higher). 
 Labour's employment spokesman, Henry McLeish, was startled to find that male unemployment in London marginals like Streatham, Hornsey, Lewisham West and Dulwich was worse than in his own Fife seat and in some of the grimmer parts of Glasgow. 
 The Tory counter-attack will be to remind London voters that, since they tend to earn above the national average, more of them will suffer from higher Labour taxes. 
 But so far Labour is better organised to get its message over. 
 Its London frontbenchers work as a team, backed by a campaign committee which was set up under the chairmanship of the shadow Commons leader, Jack Cunningham, after bad local-election results in London a year ago &mdash; and which produced the London manifesto. 
 Though the Tories are less organised, they still have plenty of ammunition. 
 Londoners may agree with Labour that their city &bquo;is losing the confidence of the people who live and work there&equo; because of its dirt, noise, congestion and crime; but they are probably not yet convinced that voting Labour will provide the remedy. 
 Lambeth &mdash; whose leader, Joan Twelves, resigned this week &mdash; has been run notoriously badly by a Labour-controlled council and is almost a byword for filth and incompetence. 
 Though the Tories will savage Labour's local-government record, some Tory London MPs argue that will not be enough. 
 John Bowis of Battersea would like to see London get its own government department, like Wales and Scotland. 
 James Arbuthnot, of Wanstead and Woodford, argues that if the Labour-run Association of London Authorities and the Tory-run London Boroughs Association were to merge, they could provide the &bquo;voice for London&equo; its voters still apparently hanker after. 
 Other Tory MPs admit privately that an elected authority for London makes sense; they fear Mr Kinnock has stolen a march on them. 
 But it takes a long time to regain trust. 
 If Ms Twelves is an image of the past that Mr Kinnock wants London to forget, the Oscar-winning actress Glenda Jackson is how he would prefer Labour to look. 
 Miss Jackson, who stood grinning with Mr Kinnock as their vessel churned down the river, is the Labour candidate for Hampstead and Highgate, one of the Tory marginals. 
 Though some local followers complain that she spends too much time in West End theatres and not enough in party meetings, Miss Jackson seems well-informed about her part of London, down-to-earth and fully committed to becoming a Labour MP. 
 She may well succeed. 
 Whether enough other Labour hopefuls win through in the ring of nondescript suburban and outer-London seats may ultimately depend on whether voters are more impressed by Labour's dismal record in the city, or by its attractive and well-packaged promises. 
 At the moment it seems that Labour is poised to pick up a good swathe of its targets &mdash; but not, yet, quite enough of them to put Mr Kinnock safely into Downing Street. 
 As the main parties ponder the fateful nature of the developing contest in the capital, London and its doings will climb steadily up their agendas. 
 If Labour fails to break through, Mr Kinnock could rightly blame Ms Twelves and her like. 
 It would be the final revenge of Lambeth &mdash; where John Major was once a councillor, as was Mr Livingstone. 
 The visionary hymn &bquo;Jerusalem&equo;, sung by generations of Labour people dreaming of a socialist paradise, was written by another Lambeth resident, William Blake. 
 A good omen for Mr Kinnock? 
 Perhaps. 
 But Blake also wrote that &bquo;Jerusalem fell&hellip; from Lambeth's vale&equo;.  
 Engineering 
 Leaner but no fitter 
 The government has launched yet another initiative to help boost manufacturing industry. 
 But nothing seems to stem the decline of engineering 
 THE recession of 1980&ndash;81 was the worst anybody in the engineering business had seen; now plenty of people think the current recession is causing still more grief. 
 The Engineering Employers' Federation (EEF) reckons the industry, which employs 45% of Britain's manufacturing workers, will shed around 100,000 jobs this year. 
 Few areas of engineering have escaped. 
 The consumer goods that engineers make tend to be the kind of things that people buy when they move house, like cookers and fridges. 
 Demand has wilted with the collapse of the housing market. 
 These goods are also expensive, so people defer buying them when they are hard-up. 
 Towards the end of 1990, volume sales were running 20% below the levels of 1988 and 1989. 
 The car market has been similarly hit by deferred purchases: car sales in April this year were down 24% on April 1990. 
 Capital goods depend on industrial investment; and businesses, like consumers, cut spending as interest rates rose. 
 In the previous recession electronics were to some extent protected from the slump by companies' enthusiasm for replacing old technologies with new. 
 This time around, the computerisation curve has flattened out, so the electronics industry has been hit as hard as any. 
 As bad luck would have it, the only industries in which Britain has clung to a world-lead &mdash; defence and aerospace &mdash; have both been affected by politics as well as economics. 
 Defence spending, untouched by the previous recession, is falling as the cold war thaws. 
 The extent of British defence cuts is still anyone's guess, even in Whitehall; but the Defence Manufacturers' Association reckons real annual spending will fall to about 75% of 1990's figure within five years. 
 The export market has not taken up the slack, so redundancies are coming thick and fast. 
 Rolls-Royce and British Aerospace have also been feeling the slump in civil aviation: the hangover after a spending boom, the post-liberalisation troubles of the American airline industry and the hiccup over the Gulf war have all cut into demand for new aeroplanes. 
 Going down and staying down 
 Engineering tends to emerge late from recessions, and the EEF sees no upturn before the second half of next year. 
 Still, all these markets (except perhaps defence) will eventually recover. 
 The big worry for British engineering companies is that this recession, like the previous one, will increase the rate at which their share of world markets is shrinking. 
 Britain's engineering industry went into trade deficit in 1983 for the first time (see chart). 
 The industry did not shriek too loudly: the strength of demand over the next few years kept everyone reasonably happy. 
 Now that the bad times are back again, people inside and outside the industry are wondering why, after all the pain of the 1980s, it remains so weak. 
 The previous recession sorted out two fundamental problems: overmanning and troublesome unions. 
 Plenty of others remain, not least the shortage of engineers &mdash; not so much of graduates as of technicians. 
 The industry blames successive governments' lack of interest in vocational training; perhaps the new training plans announced by the prime minister this week will help to fill the gap. 
 But there is little incentive to become an engineer in Britain. 
 According to Egor, an employment consultancy, an experienced engineer in Britain earns a net 21,700 ecus (&pound;15,500), compared with 29,600 ecus in Italy, 33,400 ecus in France and 42,500 ecus in Germany. 
 The big oddity is why pay remains low for skills that an industry needs but cannot find.  
 A related weakness has been the lack of effective co-operation between industry and higher education. 
 The industry secretary, Peter Lilley, has just announced a government initiative to address this problem, as part of a wider drive to improve all manufacturers' handling of technical innovation and to push forward what Mr Lilley calls a cultural revolution in British business. 
 Measures like these sound wearily familiar, just like solutions to that traditional bugbear, the City's short-termism. 
 (Mr Lilley's package has a treatment for that, too: more publicity for companies' spending on R&amp;D &mdash; as though City analysts might be persuaded by the civil servants to give research more importance.) 
 Another standard complaint of engineers is that too much government R&amp;D money goes into defence &mdash; nearly half, compared with 36% in France, 13% in Italy, 9% in Germany and none in Japan. 
 And Britain's state aid for industry generally falls far short of the sums seen in other countries. 
 According to the EC, in 1986&ndash;88 the Italian government spent 3,136 ecus per employee, the French 1,456, the German 1,135 and the British 806. 
 The single brightest area of engineering at the moment is the car industry, largely as a result of investment by Nissan, Honda and Toyota. 
 The Japanese are coming to the rescue in other areas, too. 
 This week Sony announced a big expansion of its Bridgend television plant. 
 At 60% of the price of a German worker, the Briton evidently has his advantages &mdash; so long as he is trained, managed and financed by foreigners. 
 Just as well, perhaps, that Mr Lilley has also announced plans this week to send more engineers off to be tutored in Japan.  
 Foreign policy 
 But can we opt out of the EC? 
 SIX months ago, the Tory party was riven by disagreements over Europe. 
 The issue was one big reason for Margaret Thatcher's downfall. 
 Her successor, John Major, was thought to be a pragmatist who would heal the split on Europe. 
 Yet so far Mr Major has been the most European-minded prime minister since Edward Heath. 
 Most Tories are delighted. 
 The Euro-sceptics argue that Mr Major has established himself as a good European merely to carry credibility when he vetoes monetary union. 
 But Mr Major is not so Machiavellian. 
 The signs are that he is prepared to sign up for the emerging versions of both political and monetary union. 
 If he does, the row in the Tory party could re-ignite. 
 Mr Major has already asked Chancellor Helmut Kohl and other EC leaders to delay any decisions, at least until the EC summit at Maastricht in early December: presumably he expects to call an election this autumn. 
 He has been assured that the old EC custom of never embarrassing member governments just before an election will still apply. 
 There will be no attempt to force the pace at the Luxembourg summit next month. 
 Some old Euro-hands doubt whether anything will really be decided until the Lisbon summit in June 1992. 
 Even so, alarm bells are beginning to sound at Westminster. 
 The European Reform Group, led by Jonathan Aitken, a longstanding Euro-sceptic, now has 72 Tory MPs in its ranks and is increasingly active in harrying the government in late-night debates. 
 This week Bill Cash persuaded 105 other Tory MPs to sign a motion congratulating Mr Major for resisting the latest proposals for political and monetary union. 
 It was clearly intended as a warning to Downing Street. 
 Mr Cash is a leading Euro-sceptic, who was elected chairman of the Tory backbenchers' European committee in a surprise coup last December. 
 Europhile Tories shrugged off those 106 signatures. 
 They claimed that Mr Cash had told MPs his motion had the personal support of Mr Major. 
 (In fact, Mr Major had remained studiously neutral.) 
 But the Euro-sceptics got support from an unexpected source on Monday evening. 
 At a dinner organised by the Conservative Philosophy Group, David Owen, the Social Democratic leader, launched a broadside against both monetary and political union. 
 He argued that Britain ought to use its veto and &bquo;draw a line in the sand&equo;. 
 His stance could further embarrass Mr Major. 
 It also, incidentally, sits oddly with the widely peddled idea that Dr Owen is seeking a place in the Major cabinet. 
 The Foreign Office reckons no veto will be needed on monetary union because the latest deal proposed by Jacques Delors, the present of the EC commission, would not commit Britain to adopt a European currency until the House of Commons wanted to. 
 The realisation that Britain would not be obliged to accept a single European currency may dampen the opposition at Westminster. 
 Indeed, some Tory Euro-sceptics like Teddy Taylor now see such a deal as the harbinger of a two-tier Europe in which Britain would be able to &bquo;opt out&equo; of policies it did not like. 
 But opting-out of a political-union deal would be impossible. 
 Although the Foreign Office may say that the mooted treaty on political union would have only a marginal impact on the EC, it would clearly diminish national sovereignty. 
 The Community's authority would be extended to many areas, like health and education, where it now has no legal remit; majority voting in the Council of Ministers would be reinforced; the European Parliament would be given extra power to block laws it does not like; and a small step might be taken towards a common EC defence policy. 
 Mr Major clearly intends to fight hard to minimise any constitutional changes. 
 The French may help him. 
 They are proposing a scheme for keeping foreign, defence and home-office issues out of the hands of EC institutions and subject to control by European summits. 
 If this is accepted, Mr Major will be able to present it as a step away from supranationalism. 
 And he should be able to claim some success for British ideas, too. 
 The treaty will probably include a clause on &bquo;subsidiarity&equo;, the principle that the Community should act only on issues where it is inappropriate for decisions to be taken by national governments. 
 And it may endorse the British idea that the EC Court of Justice should have sanctions to enforce its judgments on reluctant countries (one bit of supranationalism that Britain backs). 
 None of these points will mollify the biggest Tory sceptics. 
 They are prepared to vote against the government, even at the cost of a damaging row just before an election. 
 The case for an autumn poll rests, m'lud.  
 There's a lot of it about 
 HEALTH-SERVICE reform is in fashion. 
 At the moment 18 of the 24 OECD countries are either planning or implementing a major shake-up. 
 Most reforming governments are using one or more of the three principles that underlie the reorganisation of Britain's national health service (NHS): separating buyers of care from providers of care; forcing the providers to compete for contracts from buyers; and making money come with the patient. 
 Britain may be odd in spending such a low percentage of its national income on health. 
 But it is in the mainstream in using managed competition to secure value for money. 
 In insurance-based health systems, the purchasers (public or private insurers) are in theory separate from the providers. 
 In practice the relationship between the two has been all too cosy. 
 Since the mid-1980s governments have tried to make a reality of the division. 
 The aim has been to make purchasers much more prudent and to force providers to compete for business. 
 In Holland the Dekker reforms of 1987 obliged purchasers to choose between providers, and encouraged people to shop around among insurers. 
 The Germans are asking their &bquo;sickness funds&equo; (which collect payroll taxes and arrange for care) to cancel contracts with inefficient hospitals and are obliging hospitals to publish details of their costs. 
 In Bavaria doctors are being offered budgets to help make them more choosy about patient-care. 
 In the United States, Health Management Organisations were introduced in the early 1970s to hold down the formidable costs of American medicine by encouraging more competition between providers. 
 Several governments that had no division between purchasers and providers are busy creating one in order to encourage managed competition. 
 In Sweden the county councils (which are responsible for health care) have started awarding contracts to those health centres and hospitals that provide the right services at the right price. 
 One county, Kopparberg, has handed over most of its budget to family doctors and made them responsible for buying services from competing providers. 
 In Finland local authorities are being turned into the purchasing agents &mdash; with a range of powers and responsibilities that look remarkably similar to those being assigned to the district health authorities under the Tory reforms. 
 Most countries have discovered the benefits of money following the patient. 
 The Swedish reforms give patients more freedom to choose who treats them and make the resources allocated to doctors (including their pay packets) dependent on the number of patients they can attract. 
 Medicare &mdash; the American programme for the old &mdash; pays hospitals for each patient they treat. 
 Even in Leningrad, hospitals are financed according to the number of patients they treat. 
 These reforms have a common aim: to control escalating costs by improving efficiency rather than cutting patient care. 
 They also have a similar impact, shifting resources from hospitals to primary care. 
 In Dublin, for example, two teaching hospitals were closed in 1987. 
 Throughout Europe vested interests in the medical profession, supported by opposition parties hungry for votes and journalists eager for copy, have mounted vigorous protests in favour of the status quo. 
 Courageous governments have preferred better patient care to a quiet life.  
 It's hurting, but is it working? 
 Inflation is proving more stubborn than the prime minister says &mdash; despite a much deeper recession than he ever thought likely 
 ON ANY sensible measure&equo;, John Major told the annual dinner of the Confederation of British Industry this week, the government is winning the battle against inflation. 
 That was not a lie, perhaps, but it was terminologically inexact. 
 Measures of inflation have proliferated this spring, so a figure can be found to support virtually any position. 
 Awkwardly for the government, however, the most sensible measures are the gloomiest: according to some of them, inflation is still rising. 
 And yet the recession, whose task is to drive inflation down, is anything but an illusion. 
 Indeed it is so severe that the fabric of the economy is beginning to suffer long-term damage. 
 The &bquo;headline rate&equo; of inflation is tumbling nicely: it fell from 8.2% in the year to March to 6.4% in the year to April. 
 But this was due to a variety of special factors &mdash; especially lower mortgage-interest rates and the net effect of the recent changes in the poll tax and value-added tax. 
 To find the underlying rate of inflation, it is necessary to look past such distortions. 
 Underlying inflation was 7.4% in the year to April (according to the economics team at Goldman Sachs in London), virtually unchanged from the year to March. 
 But remember the advice of Robin Leigh-Pemberton, governor of the Bank of England: the 12-month inflation rate reflects what happened a year ago as much as what happened last month. 
 Underlying inflation during the past three months gives a more up-to-date reading. 
 On this basis, inflation stands at more than 7% (at an annual rate) and has actually crept up since January (see chart). 
 The evidence is undeniably muddled. 
 Inflation in producer prices (as opposed to retail prices) has risen in recent months; surveys of business opinion suggest that inflation in manufactured-goods prices is falling sharply. 
 Only this much is clear: the battle against inflation is far from won, and is proving bloody. 
 Many businessmen are complaining that this recession is even worse than that of the early 1980s (especially in engineering &mdash; see next page). 
 The figures say the recession is bad, if not quite that bad. 
 Output has fallen more slowly this time, and unemployment has risen less fast. 
 Admittedly, the claim that things are better than in 1980&ndash;81 leaves a lot to be desired as a pre-election boast. 
 Even so, the autumn might be a plausible time for the election. 
 The decline in output seems to be coming to an end, so the economy is at or near the trough. 
 Unemployment will still be rising this October (and for months after that) &mdash; but output should be expanding. 
 Headline inflation, further distorted by changes in interest rates, could be as low as 4%. 
 Underlying inflation will be falling by then, too. 
 The economy will look a lot fitter, but it will not emerge from the downturn without injury. 
 Recessions cause firms to scrap equipment; they also discourage new investment, all the more so if interest rates are high. 
 As a result, the economy's stock of capital grows more slowly, or even shrinks. 
 This, in turn, reduces the ability of companies to supply any later upturn in demand, so inflationary bottlenecks are encountered at lower levels of economic activity. 
 Measuring physical capital makes measuring inflation seem child's play. 
 Official figures for manufacturing show a capital stock that increased gently but persistently throughout the 1970s and 1980s. 
 However, these figures do not capture the effect of scrapping. 
 Estimates by Bill Martin of UBS Phillips and Drew take scrapping into account and show, plausibly, that the stock of capital fell sharply in the early 1980s. 
 Mr Martin predicts that plant capacity will shrink by 3% this year (compared with a fall of 8% in 1980). 
 This will worsen the outlook for employment, and force the government to keep monetary policy tight for fear of a renewed upsurge in inflation. 
 The Treasury has few options. 
 If sterling were not in Europe's exchange-rate mechanism (ERM), the chancellor, Norman Lamont, might be tempted to cut interest rates, let the pound slide and worry about the inflationary consequences later. 
 In fact the ERM does not preclude a small cut in interest rates soon, because sterling has lately been strong. 
 If the calls of the CBI and others for such a cut had not been so loud, the pound would probably have been stronger still, making it possible to cut rates even sooner, and by more. 
 All this leaves Mr Major, like so many of his predecessors, earnestly trying to talk down wages. 
 Hopes that the ERM would make such exhortation unnecessary have so far been dashed. 
 Pay settlements are still running at more than 9%. 
 Smaller wage rises would make it possible to have lower inflation at a higher level of output &mdash; a combination that clever manipulations of macroeconomic policy (interest rates, exchange rates and budget deficits) have always failed to achieve. 
 So Mr Major is urging industry to drop the practice of the automatic annual pay-rise. 
 Fat chance. 
 Ask the governor of the Bank of England, another great believer in wage-cost discipline and exhortation. 
 The Bank's annual report, published this week, shows that his annual &bquo;emoluments&equo; went up 17% last year.  
 Sloppy rules and soppy songs 
 ON MAY 22nd the Radio Authority accepted bids for Britain's first national commercial-radio franchise. 
 Because the new station will not be allowed to broadcast what it wants, only three small companies were interested in the offer. 
 The winner will be announced in two months' time. 
 In theory, there should be lots of pent-up demand for commercial radio in Britain. 
 Since the BBC's four stations carry no advertisements, radio takes only 2% of Britain's total advertising spend. 
 In America, which has many more stations, radio takes 7%. 
 Spotting that gap, the government decided to auction licences for three new national commercial-radio stations. 
 It was the music station, dubbed INR1, that was auctioned on May 22nd. 
 All good free-market stuff. 
 Except that, under the Broadcasting Act, passed last November, not more than a quarter of the music INR1 broadcasts can be &bquo;pop&equo;. 
 As defined by the House of Lords (rockers all), that meant music with a &bquo;strong rhythmic element and a reliance on electronic amplification&equo; &mdash; ie, almost anything using a microphone. 
 Last month the Radio Authority, headed by 71-year-old Lord Chalfont, tightened up the definition to cover all singles that hit the charts after 1960. 
 So Elvis Presley's &bquo;Love Me Tender&equo;, which came out in 1956, will not count towards the pop quota, but Luciano Pavarotti's &bquo;Nessun Dorma&equo;, theme tune to the 1990 World Cup, will. 
 Potential bidders were disappointed. 
 The new formula rules out the sort of easy-listening rock channel, aimed at 25-35-year-olds, that advertisers would prefer. 
 &bquo;Since INR1 has been made off-limits to baby-boomers it has become a lot less attractive,&equo; says Tim Schoonmaker, head of radio at EMAP, a magazine publisher once expected to bid. 
 Other big potential buyers, like the Daily Telegraph and Carlton Communications, a video-duplication firm, agreed, and decided not to bid either. 
 So whichever of the three small bidding groups emerges with the franchise will get it relatively cheap. 
 Short-changed on the sale, the taxpayer is going to get some bland programming too. 
 Showtime Radio, a group of private investors led by Sir Peter Parker, ex-chairman of British Rail, wants to broadcast musicals and TV theme-tunes. 
 Classic FM, a consortium led by GWR Group, a local radio-station owner, plans to offer &bquo;classical music in a pop format, ie, no more than 45 minutes at a time&equo;. 
 Radio Clyde, the third bidder, would run INR1 on the same lines as Melody Radio, a London station that it operates for Hanson &mdash; ie, lots of the Carpenters and Frank Sinatra. 
 Their lordships will love it.  
 BRITAIN THIS WEEK 
 Embattled 
 The political parties warmed up for a general election by bickering over whether the new health trusts remain part of the national health service. 
 William Waldegrave, the health secretary, rejected nurses' demands that he delay the government's NHS reforms because patients (they said) are suffering. 
 An outcry over the savaging of a six-year-old girl pushed the government into announcing emergency legislation banning fighting dogs. 
 About 10,000 American pit-bull terriers could be destroyed. 
 Breeds like the pit bull and the Japanese tosa &bquo;have no place in our homes&equo;, said Kenneth Baker, the home secretary. 
 John Major told the Confederation of British Industry that interest rates will soon fall because the government is winning the battle against inflation. 
 Next day the CBI's director-general, John Banham, suggested the next cut could not come soon enough. 
 Out of 100 Conservative ministers and backbenchers interviewed by the Independent, 77 thought the party had been right to get rid of Margaret Thatcher. 
 Even so, a Commons motion attacking a single European currency and independent central bank (both Thatcherite bogies) attracted the signatures of more than 100 Tory MPs. 
 Names and addresses 
 Two white papers on further and higher education included a proposal to abolish the distinction between universities and polytechnics. 
 Other recommendations: more status for vocational qualifications, and training credits for every 16-year-old school-leaver. 
 Neil Kinnock launched another Labour manifesto, this time setting out the party's plans for London,  centring  on a new elected authority. 
 The Greater London Authority would have strategic powers over transport, big building developments, and the police and fire services. 
 Best of all, it would (allegedly) pay for itself. 
 House prices will rise by only 2% over the rest of the year, thanks to rising unemployment and the large number of house repossessions, said UBS Phillips &amp; Drew, a firm of stockbrokers. 
 A 10% price increase was predicted for 1992. 
 The right address could bring in the buyers. 
 According to a survey of property valuers, 25% of those searching for a new home would prefer to live in an Avenue, while 20% would like a Lane. 
 Nobody likes gritty urban-sounding titles like Terrace and Street. 
 The prime minister re-defined the responsibilities of the Tory chief whip. 
 Richard Ryder is now a &bquo;trouble-shooter&equo;, licensed to chide those who cause party splits in the run-up to the general election. 
 Law and order 
 The police risk losing control of the streets to lager louts, vandals and drug dealers, the Police Federation conference was warned. 
 Ian Westwood, head of the federation's Manchester branch, blamed the demise of the traditional bobby on the beat. 
 His successors now carry body armour in their patrol cars. 
 The Bar Council, the governing body of barristers, approved plans to ensure that at least 5% of its members and pupils will come from ethnic minorities. 
 It also asked large company clients to make sure that black and Asian lawyers get at least 5% of their work. 
 Scrap the monarchy, abolish the House of Lords and get a written constitution &mdash; a few of the proposals in the Commonwealth of Britain Bill presented to the Commons by Tony Benn, a Labour MP. 
 No harm in trying, anyway. 
 The Law Society recommended the appointment of a minister of justice to end the &bquo;shambles&equo; caused by half a dozen Whitehall departments having responsibility for administering the judicial system. 
 Counting the cost 
 Liquidations have reached their highest level for over 20 years, according to a survey by Peat Marwick McLintock, a firm of accountants. 
 Company failures in the first quarter of 1991 were up 77% on the same period last year. 
 A City businessman who swindled investors out of millions of pounds to finance his search for a perfect gambling system was jailed for four years. 
 Nicholas Young laid over &pound;10m-worth of bets in five years &mdash; at least a third of it with other people's money. 
 Ten students at Kent University admitted taking part in a &pound;400,000 telephone fraud. 
 They were caught using an electronic tone pad to bypass call charges at kiosks on their campus. 
 The tendency for too many people to take automatic pay increases came under fresh fire. 
 The prime minister called for more restraint, in the wake of an article in the Bank of England's Quarterly Bulletin noting the continued problem. 
 Then the Bank revealed that its governor had been given a 17% salary rise last year. 
 BUSINESS 
 Productivity pick-up 
 AMERICA'S recession may have a silver lining. 
 A productivity shake-up appears to be taking place that could boost the economy in the 1990s. 
 This would be good news: America had the worst productivity record of the seven big industrial economies in the 1980s, with average growth of only 1% a year &mdash; less than half that in Europe or Japan. 
 On the face of it, the 1990s look no better. 
 Non-farm productivity rose by an annual rate of 1% in the first quarter of this year, barely offsetting a fall in the fourth quarter of 1990. 
 But look again. 
 Productivity usually collapses in the early stages of a recession because firms are slow to lay workers off. 
 The 0.1% productivity rise in the first six months of this recession compares with an average fall of 1.2% (at an annual rate) in the same period of the past four recessions. 
 Stephen Roach, an economist at Morgan Stanley, an investment bank, sees these productivity gains as evidence of the impact on American companies of stronger global competition. 
 In this recession firms have been much quicker to trim their fat. 
 Indeed, instead of waiting for demand to slump, manufacturing firms cut jobs by 2% in the year before the recession took hold, lifting productivity by 4% in the year to the third quarter of 1990 &mdash; four times the typical gain in efficiency at that stage of the cycle. 
 Better still, by delving deeper into the figures Mr Roach finds that the biggest gains are in America's inefficient service industries. 
 In the past two quarters manufacturing output per man-hour fell by an annual rate of 1.1%, roughly the same as in previous recessions, but non-manufacturing productivity &mdash; a good proxy for services &mdash; rose by an annualised 1.2% compared with a typical decline of 1.5% in past recessions. 
 Analysing productivity figures may sound duller than predicting the depth of the recession. 
 But here lies the key to America's competitiveness well beyond the recovery.  
 Is Tinseltown about to meet its Terminator? 
 LOS ANGELES 
 By any standards, being a big Hollywood studio ought to be a remarkably good business. 
 But it remains an industry to work in, rather than invest in 
 THIS Memorial Day holiday weekend marks the start of America's summer movie season. 
 By Labor Day, on September 2nd, Americans should have shelled out &dollar;2 billion on cinema tickets &mdash; close to half the annual box-office take. 
 The names in lights will include Arnold Schwarzenegger in Carolco's &bquo;Terminator 2&equo;, which may have cost &dollar;90m by the time it hits the screen; Kevin Costner as Robin Hood; and Julia Roberts in &bquo;Dying Young&equo;, a Fox weepie. 
 The rumour mill, however, is full of likely failures. 
 If Hollywood gossips are correct, then &bquo;Hudson Hawk&equo;, a &dollar;40m romp starring Bruce Willis and released by Tri-Star, may be one of the early victims. 
 This time last year the studios proudly produced an expensive list of star-packed sequels only to see their audience disappear to cheap films like Paramount's &bquo;Ghost&equo; and Disney's &bquo;Pretty Woman&equo;. 
 All this marked the start of a dreadful year for Hollywood. 
 After a boardroom tussle at Paramount, its studio chief, Frank Mancuso, quit. 
 Columbia, now owned by Japan's Sony, has become as well known for the high spending of its management team, Peter Guber and Jon Peters, as its films; Mr Peters has now taken a back seat. 
 Two mini studios, MGM-Pathe (see also page 111) and Orion, have lurched from one corporate drama to the next. 
 Even Disney, the most successful studio of the late 1980s, has had a tough time launching Hollywood Pictures, the baby sister of its Touchstone studio. 
 Last year, thanks to costly stars, the average film cost &dollar;26.8m to make and a further &dollar;11.6m to launch &mdash; plus, say, another &dollar;10m for overseas marketing. 
 Only 30 out of the 410 films launched last year raised more than &dollar;20m at the American box office (half of which goes to the cinema owner anyway). 
 Even &bquo;Batman&equo;, supposedly one of the most successful films of all time, has not officially made a net profit &mdash; partly because it paid around &dollar;50m to Jack Nicholson. 
 Piles of pessimistic reports from stockbrokers suggest that Hollywood is set for a crash. 
 Yet Tinseltown remains the undisputed home of an industry whose revenues are growing (in real terms) at around 7% a year. 
 In 1990, says Jeffrey Logsdon, an analyst at Seidler Amdec in Los Angeles, American box-office receipts accounted for only &dollar;2.5 billion of the industry's &dollar;7.8 billion in domestic income; overseas markets added a further &dollar;6 billion. 
 New technology, like video discs, or new politics, such as the opening up of Eastern Europe, have delivered new audiences. 
 If Hollywood is about to crumple, then it is its own fault. 
 Tinseltown is a three-tier society. 
 On the top level are six big studios: Warner, Disney, Columbia/Tri-Star, Paramount, Fox (which is part of News Corporation) and Universal (Matsushita). 
 They own their studios, distribution systems and libraries, and have sister television companies. 
 Mr Logsdon reckons Warner and Disney's filmed-entertainment operations will probably produce &dollar;440m in operating cash flow this year (before paying interest). 
 Fox, helped by the success of &bquo;Sleeping with the Enemy&equo; and &bquo;Home Alone&equo;, looks set for a record year. 
 Universal and Paramount may do less well than last year. 
 Only Columbia, which has launched a costly film schedule, looks likely to call on its parent for cash. 
 The second group of &bquo;minor majors&equo; includes MGM and Orion, which do not own studio lots and which have much smaller distribution systems and libraries than the majors; Carolco, which does not distribute its films; and New Line, which makes smaller movies. 
 The third group is a mixed bag of smaller companies, including some distributors, such as Miramax, and some talent-based producers, such as Imagine (which is based around one director, Ron Howard). 
 Most published figures about film profits are meaningless. 
 Films usually prepare four sets of accounts. 
 The most truthful one is a simple cash-in/cash-out ledger the studios keep for themselves. 
 Accounts are also kept for shareholders, but American accounting laws allow studios to guess how well a film will do in each of its markets (an invitation either to claim profits early or to put off losses); for the tax man (ditto); and for various stars who have been promised shares of a film's net profit &mdash; a figure which a studio wants to keep as low as possible. 
 Take, as a hypothetical example, the fairly successful film shown in the table on the next page. 
 Despite grossing &dollar;100m at the box office, the film, which cost &dollar;30m to make, has lost &dollar;10m. 
 Yet the studio has charged itself a &bquo;distribution fee&equo; of &dollar;20m. 
 That is on top of the main costs of releasing a movie: advertising and printing the film. 
 Most of the distribution fee, which can be around 30% of the film's rental income, goes to the studio. 
 Thus it is a fair guess that if Carolco's &bquo;Terminator 2&equo; brings in over &dollar;120m at the American box office, its distributor, Tri-Star, will make &dollar;20m. 
 Such distribution profits are one of the three historic advantages that the big studios have inherited. 
 The second is their enormous libraries of films, which usually produce enough money to cover their overheads. 
 If a big studio has a bad patch, as Fox did until a year ago, then the library can carry the studio. 
 By the same token, the easiest way for a big studio to commit suicide is to sell its library &mdash; as MGM has. 
 The last cushion the big studios can rely on is sheer size. 
 Even with the advantages of other income sources, studios depend on a few hits to pay for a large number of duds. 
 A decent portfolio of 15 films costs over &dollar;400m a year to produce. 
 The films may not be released until the following year and probably will not break even (including interest costs) until three years after that. 
 &bquo;It would take at least &dollar;1 billion to start a studio from scratch&equo;, reckons one mogul who adds that &bquo;even then it would need a lot of luck.&equo; 
 Conversely, the same rules stack the odds against small production firms. 
 They either have to take too much of the risk themselves, or give away too much of their potential reward. 
 After a few hits most brag that they can compete (Britain's Goldcrest is a famous example) and then find that one big failure (&bquo;Revolution&equo;) destroys them. 
 New Line, the most interesting independent, is taking a different tack. 
 According to its chairman, Robert Shaye, it &bquo;mimics the financial structure of big studios without competing with them.&equo; 
 It will release a dozen or so films this year with an average cost of &dollar;5m, all aimed at audiences too small for the big studios to chase. 
 New Line has ploughed its profits from &bquo;Nightmare on Elm Street&equo; and &bquo;Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles&equo; into buying other firms' film libraries and setting up a distribution system. 
 Income from the library almost covers New Line's overheads of &dollar;14m a year. 
 Your bill, Mr Morita 
 By and large, most businesses would give their hind legs to be in an industry which was growing at 7% a year and where there were huge barriers to entry. 
 But the big studios' weakness is the cost of talent. 
 Shortly after each new market is discovered, actors demand more money. 
 Last year costs climbed faster than revenues; this year they may well do so again. 
 Despite appeals from studio bosses at Disney, Warner and Columbia for restraint, this summer's line-up shows scant sign of cost-control. 
 &bquo;Terminator 2&equo; is the most expensive film yet made &mdash; and has prompted worries about the health of Carolco, even though pre-sales to distributors seemed to have covered all the film's costs. 
 Studio bosses insist that next year's pictures &mdash; currently being negotiated &mdash; will be cheaper. 
 There will be fewer big action pictures and more romantic comedies. 
 Less cash will pour into marketing. 
 And, although stars will still receive hefty cheques, the supporting cast will be less expensive. 
 &bquo;If Warner made &bquo;Bonfire of the Vanities' today it would have just one big star not three&equo;, argues one insider. 
 Michelle Pfeiffer was expected to be cast alongside Michael Douglas in Carolco's forthcoming &bquo;Basic Instinct&equo;; in the end a less-costly actress, Sharon Stone, was chosen. 
 Whether such modest dieting is enough remains to be seen. 
 Hollywood has plenty more fat to lose. 
 But, it also has a well-proven knack of persuading outsiders to foot the bill for its excesses. 
 Carolco recently raised close to &dollar;100m from several European investors, including Giovanni Agnelli of Fiat. 
 Columbia's recent spending spree has partly been paid for by Sony. 
 And Disney's current production run is being financed partly by &dollar;200m given by a group of Japanese investors on terms that make other studios green with envy.  
 Compaq 
 A star is fallen 
 ALAS, poor Compaq. 
 Once everybody's favourite fledgling PC maker, the firm &mdash; now fully grown with annual sales of &dollar;3.6 billion &mdash; is starting to suffer the same ills that it used to lampoon in its big bad competitors. 
 Having posted shining results for years, Compaq recently warned that its second-quarter sales will be 15% down on 1990's figure, and that profits will tumble by close to 80%. 
 Some shareholders are suing the firm for not warning of poor results earlier. 
 Rod Canion, Compaq's chief executive, sold most of his own shares in the company, about &dollar;10m-worth, back in February. 
 What went wrong? 
 Founded in 1982, Compaq built its reputation by beating IBM at its own game. 
 Compaq's PCs were more powerful (and portable) than IBM's, but ran all the same software, at the same price. 
 Backed up with lots of advertising aimed at upmarket buyers, the formula worked like magic. 
 Net profits climbed from &dollar;3m in 1983, when the firm was floated on the stockmarket, to &dollar;455m in 1990. 
 As the company grew, smaller clone-makers, also building to IBM's software standard, started trying the same tactics on Compaq itself. 
 In 1986, when Compaq launched the first PC using Intel's powerful new 80386 chip, it was months ahead of its competitors. 
 But last October, when the firm launched a notebook-sized computer using Intel's even more advanced 80386SX, several other manufacturers had already announced similar machines. 
 Today, the computer industry's most exciting products are workstations &mdash; powerful, big-screened computers used by scientists and stock traders &mdash; and ever-smaller portable computers. 
 Ordinary PCs, Compaq's bread-and-butter, have become fairly standardised. 
 &bquo;If you're looking for something really new, like pen-based computers or multi-media, Compaq doesn't stand for that,&equo; says Stewart Alsop, editor of PC Letter, a trade journal. 
 As Compaq's products become more like other firms', they are starting to look overpriced. 
 Last year Dell Computer, a Texan maker of IBM clones, launched a withering series of advertisements comparing its machines with Compaq's dearer models. 
 In one, Dell's laptop computer, priced at &dollar;3,899, is dubbed &bquo;the lap of luxury&equo;; Compaq's equivalent, at &dollar;6,799, the &bquo;lap of lunacy&equo;. 
 Compaq is seeking an injunction to force Dell to tone down the ads. 
 In April, partly in response to Dell's campaign, Compaq cut its prices by up to a third. 
 More cuts may follow. 
 This year the American PC market is forecast to grow by less than 10%, a far cry from the 20% annual growth that computer makers are used to. 
 To keep market share, IBM has just cut prices on its PCs for the third time this year. 
 California's Apple Computer did the same thing in a bigger way last October, when it halved the price-tag on its popular Macintosh model. 
 Although volume sales of the Mac almost doubled as a result, Apple's margins slumped. 
 On May 20th the firm said it was cutting its workforce by a tenth. 
 Battered by PC price wars, Compaq would like to escape into other, faster-growing markets. 
 In 1989 it launched the moderately successful SystemPro server, a machine used to move information about between PCs. 
 Next year the firm may come out with a workstation. 
 But Compaq's unusual distribution system is making the transition from PCs to bigger machines hard. 
 &bquo;When you enter this kind of environment, after-sales service and training are just as important as the product itself,&equo; says Gian Carlo Bisone, head of Compaq's European marketing. 
 But unlike many computer-makers, Compaq makes all its sales through dealers, rather than by using its own sales force. 
 That is a good cheap way to sell PCs, but many dealers cannot cope with bigger, more complex machines.  
 Inside ICI 
 Knife-sharpening 
 AS BOSS of ICI, the besieged British chemicals giant, Sir Denys Henderson has a lot to be worried about. 
 The news that Hanson may be preparing to bid for ICI has been met by a united front on the ICI board. 
 But this follows a year of debate about strategy during which some senior ICI board members appeared unhappy about the way Sir Denys has been running the firm. 
 On all boards, disagreements are the stuff of which decisions are made. 
 Yet the past year's debate at ICI contains clues about how the firm might now run and reshape itself &mdash; even if Hanson leaves it alone. 
 Sir Denys, a 58-year-old Scot and a lawyer by training, took over from Sir John Harvey-Jones in 1987 (who is now chairman of The Economist but was not consulted for this article). 
 His succession was unchallenged. 
 ICI's chairmen have traditionally been picked from its cadre of executive directors (now nine). 
 The two other potential candidates, Ronnie Hampel and Tom Hutchison, who joined the board in 1985, were deemed to have had too little boardroom experience. 
 While Sir John tended to favour a consensus style of management, Sir Denys has been more authoritarian, taking more direct responsibility for decisions. 
 None of ICI's board members, however, has been ungentlemanly enough to express differences in public. 
 Nor has there been any direct challenge to the chairman. 
 In February it was unanimously agreed that Sir Denys should continue as boss until he reached the retirement age of 62, making him the longest-serving chairman since Sir Paul Chambers, who ran &mdash; and dominated &mdash; the company from 1960 to 1968. 
 Since early last year, when it became clear that sales and profits were falling, the board has been pondering how ICI should be rationalised. 
 In 1990 the company saw its pre-tax profits drop by 36% to &pound;977m (&dollar;1.7 billion) on sales of &pound;12.9 billion. 
 Three months ago the firm announced a &pound;300m reorganisation, sorting the group into seven different areas. 
 Every business, it was pledged, would be scrutinised; unpromising ones would go. 
 But there was no haste about it: apart from that reorganisation and one major disposal, the fertiliser business, little has yet been done. 
 During the past year there have been some differences between Sir Denys and other members of the board. 
 Although all ICI's board members have endorsed the reorganisation (which they all claim to be a radical one), it seems that both Mr Hampel and Mr Hutchison initially favoured a different course for ICI. 
 Though both may now be too old to aspire to run the company (they are 59 and 60, respectively), they clearly remain ambitious. 
 Mr Hampel, who is on the firm's takeover-defence team, hides a strong will beneath an affable exterior. 
 He is seen as the visionary on the board, and has worked in a number of the company's divisions. 
 Mr Hutchison is more direct and earnest, and has spent nearly all his career in ICI's bulk-chemicals business. 
 He was responsible, under Sir John, for cuts and closures in the group's petrochemical and plastics divisions during the early 1980s. 
 David Barnes, who joined the board in 1986 and is the only obvious successor to Sir Denys, has also argued for a different approach. 
 With a background in ICI's pharmaceutical and paints operations, he told The Economist a year ago that a case could be made for hanging onto the jewels and getting rid of the tarnished tinsel. 
 As yet, there is little sign of this happening. 
 All three directors would probably have liked ICI to narrow its broad span of interests to just two: a bulk commodities business and a value-added specialties business. 
 If that were to happen, the large volume-plastics business, including polypropylene and EVC, the firm's PVC joint venture with Italy's EniChem, would have to go. 
 So would ICI's caustic-soda and chlorine business, which supplies raw materials to EVC &mdash; a throwback to ICI's vertically integrated days. 
 All in all, around &pound;3.5 billion of the company's annual turnover might be chopped out. 
 In avoiding such disposals, Sir Denys undoubtedly has the support of the managers who head ICI's industrial business units. 
 The industrial-chemicals division gives a host of reasons why it should stay with ICI: synergies with other parts of the group; benefits from research (after the second world war the by-products from the dyestuffs industry became, by chance, raw materials for the pharmaceuticals business); the strength of the ICI name; and so on. 
 But nowadays only a small fraction of raw materials is supplied internally, and drug innovation is far less a matter of luck. 
 Ironically, the specialties business, which ICI unanimously wants to retain, sees its connection with ICI more as a hindrance than a help. 
 It guards its independence and tries to avoid wasting time with ICI's corporate matters. 
 So far ICI has not revealed what its defence against takeover would be. 
 One theory has the company entering into a series of joint ventures; an unlikely suggestion has ICI's pharmaceuticals business merging with Wellcome, a British drugs firm. 
 But what would happen if Hanson pulls out? 
 One prospect being touted is that institutional investors, who at the end of 1990 held 73% of ICI's shares, will insist on splitting the job of the group's chairman and chief executive in two. 
 That approach has recently been recommended for all listed companies by Britain's Institutional Shareholders Committee. 
 Sir Denys would then take the role of chairman, while Mr Hampel would become chief executive &mdash; and push through a radical restructuring plan?  
 Japanese car parts 
 My home, my car 
 OSAKA 
 LET'S Enjoy Your Car Life&equo; is the slogan written in big English letters to lure customers into Autobacs Seven's 300 or so service stations. 
 Osaka-based Autobacs, Japan's equivalent of Britain's Kwik-Fit, is a specialist retailer with an estimated 30% share of the car-accessory market. 
 It is a Kwik-Fit with a difference. 
 About two years ago Autobacs cleaned up its oily-rag image. 
 Car owners needing their wheel or battery changed are now greeted by men clad in bright orange uniforms and natty caps. 
 At each outlet there is swanky retail space, used to sell every imaginable kind of car accessory, from compact-disc players and car televisions to designer car seats, sporty steering wheels and even perfume to make leather seats smell sweeter. 
 This makes sense in Japan where (because of stellar house prices) most young single professionals still live at home with their parents and have cash to spend, and where people do not make a habit of throwing bricks through car windows and stealing things. 
 Consequently, for lack of a better alternative, the car has become the favoured means of personal expression, or as an Autobacs Seven director, Kenzo Kido, puts it, &bquo;the equivalent of life space. 
 The car is most young people's house.&equo; 
 The abundance of mobile living rooms is clear from the firm's own client base. 
 Mr Kido says that almost 70% of the company's customers in the Tokyo area are under the age of 29. 
 This specialist market is set to boom in Japan, even though the market for new cars is mature. 
 There may be 32m cars on the road in a country of 123m people &mdash; but, as yet, only 6% of them are fitted with compact-disc players. 
 Autobacs, which made a pre-tax profit of &yen;7.3 billion (&dollar;51.7m) on sales of &yen;110.4 billion in the year ended March 31st, has the means to finance further expansion. 
 Shareholders' equity of &yen;44.6 billion represents nearly 60% of total assets. 
 Margins are high, because 30% of sales are the company's own brands. 
 Autobacs' batteries are half the price of those sold in an ordinary garage. 
 So confident is Autobacs that since April last year new franchisees have had to pay the firm a commission of 2% of sales. 
 The next biggest competitor, Royal, charges no commission. 
 About 260 of Autobacs' outlets are franchised and about 25% of the goods sold at these stores are own brands. 
 This is a sign of strength, since franchisees are under no obligation to sell the firm's brands. 
 The company plans to have 500 branches in Japan by 1994, and hopes to repeat its success internationally. 
 In the past year it has set up outlets in Singapore and Taiwan. 
 With the company's founder, Toshio Sumino, still acting as chairman and president, and owning 16% of the firm, Autobacs is the sort of entrepreneurial company investors like. 
 This is why its share price has nearly quadrupled since it went public in March 1989. 
 But with a price-earnings ratio of 62 using next year's official earnings forecast, the company's shares are hardly cheap.  
 Manufacturing 
 Less is more 
 SUCCESSFUL firms are easy to spot but hard to explain. 
 Management gurus have done their best, picking over the bones of &bquo;world-class&equo; firms in the hope of coming up with the Magic Formula. 
 The result: a fad for every season. 
 McKinsey, a consultancy, has taken a different approach. 
 It studied a big selection of firms from a single industry &mdash; machine-tool making in western Germany &mdash; in an attempt to discover what makes the sheep sheep, and goats goats. 
 In all, the consultants pored over 39 firms, which had an average of 4,200 employees and annual sales of DM900m (&dollar;520m). 
 The companies were ranked on various measures of corporate success (ranging from returns on sales and equity to rates of growth of sales and profits), and were then split into three groups: top performers, average firms and laggards. 
 Overall, the annual sales of the top performers grew at 4.5 times the rate of the underperformers; their returns on those sales were 2.5 times higher. 
 At the heart of this success was simplicity. 
 The best-performing firms made a narrow range of products &mdash; one for every DM100m-worth of sales, compared with four per DM100m in the less successful companies. 
 The best firms' products also used up to 50% fewer parts than those made by their less-successful rivals, so they were faster, simpler and cheaper to manufacture. 
 That, in turn, meant that quality came built-in: though they had fewer workers looking after quality control, the best companies had fewer defects and less waste. 
 Oddly, the most successful firms spent proportionately less on product development. 
 That, says McKinsey, is because they spend money where it is needed rather than on grand castles in the air. 
 The best firms favoured continuous, incremental product improvement, with new developments passed rapidly on to customers. 
 Product development was seen as a &bquo;joint venture&equo; with both customers and suppliers. 
 (The most successful companies had, on average, far fewer of each, but nurtured closer and longer-term relationships with them.) 
 New products developed by the best-performing machine-tool makers tended to start their lives with &bquo;fuzzy&equo; specifications, allowing for significant design changes before they reached the customer. 
 Compared with their less-successful rivals, the best-performing firms had fewer managers, shorter lines of communication and a higher proportion of skilled workers; they also spent six times more per employee on education and training. 
 Unsurprising, then, that their labour productivity was far higher than their less-successful rivals. 
 The productivity of their capital equipment, however, was lower: the top firms spent money on technology (like flexible-manufacturing systems) designed to get the most out of employees, rather than trying to replace men with machines. 
 One of the biggest differences between the best and worst firms in the industry was in their attitude to the future. 
 The least-successful machine-tool manufacturers were preoccupied with quality assurance and service &mdash; in effect, with making amends for shortfalls in their products. 
 The most successful firms were far more worried about the calibre of their product designs and materials &mdash; with, as McKinsey puts it, &bquo;designing instead of repairing&equo;. 
 The moral: success is never having to say you're sorry.  
 How Hanson holds the reins 
 Hanson, say its detractors, is no more than an artful asset-stripper. 
 Its admirers say it is the consummate manager. 
 ICI would like to know which is right 
 CORPORATE governance&equo; may be an ugly phrase, but it is a hot topic. 
 Managers, the argument runs, should put shareholders first; and shareholders should be more involved with managers. 
 The corporate-governance lobby reckons that the best way to bring this about is to boost the powers of non-executive directors. 
 But mention Hanson to those same lobbyists, and they will mutter about &bquo;corporate vandals&equo; and &bquo;asset-strippers&equo;. 
 This is odd, for Hanson in many ways behaves as the model non-executive director. 
 The corporate-governance issue emerged strongly in the 1980s as investors found that bosses talked of putting shareholders first while pursuing their own dreams at shareholders' expense. 
 But shareholders were not free of blame. 
 Often they lacked day-to-day knowledge of the firms they had invested in, and had a tendency to sell their shares the instant a firm hit trouble. 
 Hanson's style tackles these problems, according to a study* by London Business School. 
 There are two quite different sorts of manager in Hanson, argues the study, written soon after the firm bought the Imperial Group in 1986. 
 The bosses of each of the individual businesses within Hanson behave like any executive manager, running the firm's day-to-day business, planning, budgeting and so on. 
 Hanson's head-office managers, however, have no day-to-day managerial role: instead, they fix the business managers' sights on shareholder returns, and reward or penalise them as their performance varies. 
 In other words, they do what an effective non-executive director would do. 
 It is the tension between these two roles that gives Hanson its strength. 
 The problem of business managers pursuing their own ends while shareholders foot the bill is tackled head-on. 
 Managers must dream &mdash; that is how they get good ideas &mdash; but their dreams must be profitable. 
 Each year business managers draw up a budget and suggest a series of financial targets. 
 These are then agreed with head-office managers. 
 Results this year are expected to be better than last. 
 In most firms, financial planning is seen as a nasty chore, and nobody really believes that the numbers agreed will actually be achieved. 
 In Hanson, the budget, once agreed, is a contract between business managers and headquarters. 
 Each month's results are picked over in the business's board meeting, with a head-office manager present in a non-executive role. 
 Any shortfall must be explained. 
 If headquarters is uneasy with the excuses given, it sends a &bquo;flying squad&equo; of accountants to check it out. 
 Headquarters motivates managers to meet targets in time-honoured style: carrot and stick. 
 There is a generous stock-option scheme, and performance-related pay that can, in some cases, double basic salaries. 
 Failure, on the other hand, leads to fairly swift dismissal. 
 In most firms, top management incentives are thinly disguised executive perks: not in Hanson. 
 It works 
 This management style appears to have paid off in the long and short terms. 
 Ever Ready, a battery maker, was losing market share to Duracell and made pre-tax profits of only &pound;4.2m when Hanson bought it in 1981. 
 Hanson promptly sold its R&amp;D activities to Duracell. 
 By 1990 the firm's profits had reached &pound;47m, thanks partly to the launch of a long-life battery to rival Duracell's. 
 Imperial's profits from cigarettes surged to &pound;225m last year, while its market share remained buoyant. 
 SCM Chemicals, another Hanson buy and one of the world's top titanium-dioxide suppliers, moved into &bquo;green&equo; products faster than its rival ICI &mdash; itself now in Hanson's sights. 
 All this works only if Hanson's headquarters performs well in its non-executive role. 
 Lord Hanson makes a virtue of this. 
 &bquo;We aim&equo;, he says in the LBS study, &bquo;to invest in good basic businesses, producing essential products for which there is a clear continuing demand. 
 We avoid areas of very high technology&hellip; &lsqb;and&rsqb; businesses which are highly capital intensive and where decision-making has to be centralised.&equo; 
 Most bosses think they can run virtually anything; Hanson is far more modest. 
 Hanson buys firms either because it believes them to be under-managed, or because it believes the firms' existing managers have over-extended themselves. 
 Hanson's most striking acquisitions &mdash; like those of Imperial and Ever Ready &mdash; displayed both failings. 
 This simple notion can make huge profits. 
 After buying Imperial for &pound;2.5 billion, Hanson promptly sold off the group's Courage and Golden Wonder businesses, as well as various smaller bits. 
 That raised &pound;2.3 billion &mdash; so businesses worth &pound;1.4 billion cost Hanson almost nothing. 
 How Hanson's profits are split between its deal-making and its stable of businesses is hotly debated. 
 County NatWest calculates that in the first half of the year to September 1991, Hanson made &pound;150m interest on its cash pile and &pound;60m-70m from selling a subsidiary &mdash; in all, 37% of its total pre-tax profits of &pound;588m. 
 The Hanson style can, of course, go wrong if headquarters misjudges a business and pushes its bosses to pursue targets that are too demanding. 
 Little in Hanson's track record suggests this has yet happened; but the best defence strategy against Hanson is for its target to demonstrate that its business is volatile, capital-hungry and high-tech. 
 Hanson is likely to add value to any business in which there is a mix of activities that Hanson can run, and those it cannot. 
 As all Hanson businesses are for sale at all times, why should headquarters asset-strip a good long-term business for short-term gain? 
 As Anthony Alexander, the group's chief operating officer in Britain, put it, &bquo;If we think we can get more for them than they are worth to us, we will sell.&equo; 
 The only real worry is that, to finance a strategy driven by buying other firms, Hanson keeps a large cash balance &mdash; &pound;7 billion at the last count. 
 The longer this lies unused, the more reason shareholders have to ask whether they might prefer to invest their money themselves. 
 So, the argument runs, Hanson is under pressure to make a big acquisition, soon. 
 Lord Hanson will not want to ruin a fine track record by acting in haste. 
 More likely, he will sit on the cash until a good chance turns up. 
 But, as a good non-executive director will know, sometimes the best thing to do with shareholders' money is give it back.  
 Team spirit 
 NEW YORK 
 BUSINESSES usually celebrate booming demand. 
 Why then are the firms selling clothes and other goods imprinted with the logos of American sports teams so po-faced about their fat export order-books? 
 Overseas business could hardly be better. 
 Sales of products licensed by Major League baseball clubs, for instance, look set to increase 30-fold in Europe this year, to &dollar;60m. 
 The puzzle is solved by Bob Fellice, international sales manager at Starter Sportswear of New Haven, Connecticut. 
 Like other firms licensed to market these products by American colleges and professional ball-clubs, Starter Sportswear worries that, after rising like a rocket, exports could drop like the stick. 
 American sports, Mr Fellice notes, are becoming far more popular overseas. 
 Television coverage has won American football a big following in Britain. 
 Basketball stars from the United States have helped promote the sport in Italy and Spain. 
 But most overseas buyers of the clothes are not sports fans &mdash; they are slaves to the fashion for Americana. 
 Such fads have a nasty way of evaporating. 
 The 26 Major League baseball clubs share these worries. 
 Americans wear T-shirts emblazoned with the names of teams that are successful. 
 When a baseball team does badly, so do domestic sales of its products. 
 But most foreigners could not care less about a team's performance. 
 They buy the clothes for their designs and fetching colours. 
 Australians are put off by the gold-and-green of the Oakland A's baseball team. 
 These are Australia's national colours and so lack the prized all-American look. 
 Nothing, however, could be more American than the name and image of the New York Yankees. 
 The team's products easily outsell those of other American baseball clubs overseas, even though the Yankees have had a mediocre record on the field in recent years. 
 Japanese buyers are the exception. 
 They are keenest on clothes imprinted with the logos of sports teams of American colleges which have a high academic reputation. 
 Places like Harvard, Yale and Princeton &mdash; where brains, in theory at least, beat brawn.  
 Hot air over Germany 
 OBSTRUCTION and protectionism do not stalk only big companies. 
 Small firms can be more vulnerable because trade wars can turn into costly and time-consuming dog-fights &mdash; as Don Cameron, a British manufacturer of hot-air balloons, has found. 
 Mr Cameron's company, Cameron Balloons, is a world leader in its field. 
 It makes standard pear-shaped hot-air balloons for enthusiasts, and specially shaped ones for advertising or big egos &mdash; like the hot-air balloon it made for the late Malcolm Forbes in the shape of the American publisher's French chateau. 
 Cameron Balloons exports three-quarters of its balloons. 
 Until recently Germany accounted for a fifth of its total sales. 
 Along with the nylon balloon itself, the company also supplies components such as willow-and-cane baskets, burners to heat up the air inside the balloon, gas cylinders and control valves. 
 But in the past year German authorities withdrew approval for certain components which Cameron and some other hot-air balloon manufacturers have been using worldwide for the past 20 years. 
 Mr Cameron claims there is no reason for this other than to favour Germany's balloon makers. 
 Take Cameron's stainless-steel gas cylinders. 
 It took a five-year tussle with the Luftfahrt Bundesamt, the German body which sets aeronautical regulations, before the cylinders were approved for use in hot-air balloons. 
 Yet they are still grounded. 
 The reason is that a different body, the Technischer &Uuml;berwachungs Verein (t&uuml;v), has to approve gas cylinders that are transported by road. 
 And hot-air balloon cylinders do travel by road &mdash; between flights. 
 The t&uuml;v, though, will not give approval. 
 When the t&uuml;v did not reply to his letters, Mr Cameron visited it in Essen. 
 But he claims his request for details of the regulations was refused on the ground that they are &bquo;very severe&equo; and that Cameron Balloons would find it impossible to meet them. 
 Meanwhile, says Mr Cameron, almost identical stainless-steel cylinders produced by a German competitor and developed under a government subsidy have been approved by the t&uuml;v. 
 Mr Cameron has now complained to the EC &mdash; which is meant to have created an EC-wide 1992 regime for pressure vessels. 
 An official at the t&uuml;v said an offer had now been made to help the British company meet its rules &mdash; the ones Cameron thinks it already meets.  
 Grumman 
 Shooting star 
 BETHPAGE, LONG ISLAND 
 GENERAL Norman Schwarzkopf's praise for the JSTARS battle-management aircraft in the Gulf war has managers at Grumman glowing. 
 The electronic wizardry of Grumman's JSTARS helped turn the land battle for Kuwait into a &bquo;turkey shoot&equo;. 
 The company could use a little good news. 
 Along with Northrop and McDonnell Douglas, Grumman is among the most financially-stretched of America's big defence contractors. 
 And it has suffered an extraordinary series of mishaps over the past decade. 
 The well-publicised success of JSTARS may help the company to survive, but its future is still far from rosy. 
 Grumman veterans bear the scars from the company's many setbacks, especially the export triumph Grumman scored when it sold lots of F-14 Tomcats to Iran under the shah. 
 That became a public-relations disaster when anti-American mullahs grabbed power there. 
 As Robert Myers, Grumman's laconic president, says now: &bquo;I guess that sale wasn't too good a move from the State Department's standpoint.&equo; 
 The attempt Grumman made in the 1970s to reduce its dependence on Pentagon and NASA contracts produced an excellent delivery truck for the post office. 
 Hardly anybody has noticed. 
 Instead, attention has centred on the poor performance of the 851  Flexible  buses that Grumman sold to New York's Metropolitan Transport Authority in 1980. 
 They broke down so often and so grievously that they were all withdrawn from service within three years. 
 The president of the transport authority called the buses &bquo;junk&equo;. 
 Grumman finally coughed up &dollar;40m in 1988 in settlement of the legal claims against it. 
 By then the company seemed set to make a fresh start under a new broom. 
 John O'Brien became chief executive in 1988 and proved an impressive and popular boss. 
 But Mr O'Brien had to resign abruptly last summer when he became the subject of a grand-jury investigation into possible illegal loans from a military sub-contractor. 
 After such stumbles, Grumman is understandably thrilled by a belated and unambiguous triumph: the success of JSTARS. 
 The electronic gadgetry, integrated by Grumman into a modified Boeing 707 aircraft, is the air-to-ground equivalent of the air-to-air AWACS air-surveillance system. 
 The machine flies over friendly territory, but its huge side-looking radar can pick out enemy ground targets up to 200 miles away, allowing it to direct air, artillery or missile strikes against them. 
 A military historian has compared the advantage JSTARS conveys to playing a game of chess in which you can see your opponent's pieces but he cannot see yours. 
 General Schwarzkopf demanded that JSTARS be rushed into service for Desert Storm after he had seen the system tested in a NATO exercise. 
 His foresight was vindicated. 
 In the final stages of the war JSTARS allowed allied forces to detect and destroy the convoys of Iraqi vehicles fleeing Kuwait. 
 Even if this persuades Congress to agree to the 22 JSTARS the Pentagon wants to buy and also helps the company to export the aircraft, Grumman will still have to cut its workforce further. 
 It has already reduced it from a peak of 36,000 to around 26,000. 
 Grumman's speciality is naval aircraft, mainly the veteran A-6 ground-attack aircraft and the F-14 Tomcat fighter, both designed to operate from aircraft carriers. 
 Grumman's order-book, however, is thinning. 
 No relief is in sight, according to George Shapiro, an aerospace-defence analyst at Salomon Brothers, a New York investment bank. 
 The Pentagon's procurement budget has fallen from &dollar;97 billion in 1985 to about &dollar;67 billion in the current fiscal year and further cuts are in prospect. 
 Grumman cut its capital spending to &dollar;50m last year, or under half the &dollar;105m it charged to depreciation and amortisation. 
 To try to climb out of the hole it is in, Grumman has come up with a plan to turn its F-14 fighter into a ground-attack aircraft. 
 The idea is that this aircraft could fill the gap in the navy's procurement schedule caused by the recent cancellation of the A-12 stealth machine that the navy was developing. 
 Despite the fact that the navy will now need a new aircraft of some sort to fill the gap until a brand-new attack machine, so far called only the AX, can be produced, the outlook for Grumman is bleak. 
 The F-14 is based on elderly technology, and it would be extremely expensive to produce a workable bomber from it, something on the order of &dollar;50m a copy. 
 The navy reckons it can buy updated versions of the McDonnell Douglas/Northrop A-18 for around &dollar;35m each &mdash; less capable, perhaps, than Grumman says its F-14 derivative would be, but with the defence budget under tremendous pressure, the &bquo;sticker price&equo; makes all the difference. 
 Few seasoned observers believe the Grumman scheme has a chance. 
 Before the success of JSTARS, the manufacturer of the Wildcats, Hellcats and Avengers that helped America win the second world war looked likely to fade away. 
 Barring another honourable war, that may yet be Grumman's fate &mdash; if slightly delayed. 
 START OF FINANCE SECTION 
 Funny, money 
 HONG KONG 
 THE latest version of The Economist's rough-and-ready guide to relative currency values, our annual Big Mac index, published in April, showed that the Hong Kong dollar was the currency most out of line with the American dollar. 
 A Big Mac in a Hong Kong McDonald's costs half as much as one bought in a big-city McDonald's in the United States. 
 Since Big Macs are the same the world over, the Hong Kong dollar must surely be much undervalued against the greenback &mdash; and even more so against many other currencies if, as seems likely, America's dollar is itself still generally undervalued. 
 Hong Kong's dollar has been yoked to America's at the rate of 7.8 to 1 since 1983. 
 The link was put in place to provide some stability at a time of political turbulence in the British colony. 
 Weightier things than hamburgers suggest it is now time for a realignment. 
 Hong Kong's inflation rate, around 14% in the year to April, is more than twice that of the United States. 
 This is consistent with the view that the currency is undervalued: Hong Kong's goods and services, unnaturally cheap in dollar terms, are being pulled up in price toward international levels. 
 A better way to get the same result, you might think, would be to adjust Hong Kong's currency, not its price tickets, by vigorously upvaluing the Hong Kong dollar against the American one. 
 The Hong Kong government fears the market may be thinking the same way: in late April it announced legislation to formalise the power of local banks to pay negative interest rates on Hong Kong dollar deposits (just as Swiss banks did at one time when the Swiss wanted to discourage an inflow of foreign money into the Swiss franc). 
 All folly, says John Greenwood, the chairman of G.T. Management (Asia), a fund-management company. 
 Mr Greenwood, who was the main architect of the currency link, thinks the present rate is about right. 
 Compare the unit prices of Hong Kong's export goods with wholesale prices in America, he says, and you will find that both have risen since 1983 by about 3.5% a year. 
 So if the rate was right then (many doubt it), it is now. 
 If the currency is not misaligned, why is Hong Kong's inflation so high? 
 One answer is rising wages. 
 These have been driven up, first, by a labour shortage, brought about by the ending of free immigration from China in 1980, and now by increasing emigration from Hong Kong; and, second, by the colony's swift move up-market as manufacturers have relocated low-wage factories to southern China, leaving higher-paid jobs in Hong Kong, where their influence has pulled up wages in what would otherwise be poorly paid jobs. 
 This has not undermined Hong Kong's competitiveness, however, because Hong Kong's overall labour productivity is still rising faster than America's. 
 From this point of view, Hong Kong's inflation &bquo;problem&equo;, argues Mr Greenwood, is really no problem. 
 So why bother with corrective measures? 
 Not everyone agrees with the dollar link; some would prefer the Hong Kong currency to be tied to a basket of currencies. 
 But the link has worked. 
 After the Tiananmen Square massacre, when the Hong Kong stockmarket fell by a quarter, the Hong Kong dollar did not flicker. 
 With more political troubles looming, the authorities will defend the link, at its present rate, ferociously; since the market believes that, they may not have to. 
 And what about the Big Mac index? 
 A reasonable measure, say Hong Kong critics, among the currencies of countries of similar structure and similar wage levels. 
 But in Hong Kong the hamburger faces tough low-cost competition from older kinds of speedy foods. 
 Even Big Macs at times need to be taken with a pinch of salt.  
 American credit cards 
 The non-banks muscle in 
 NEW YORK 
 ASK an American banker to point out the bright spots in his beleaguered industry, and he will probably point to credit cards. 
 While other ventures such as property lending faltered, American consumers piled up credit-card debt and tolerated interest rates three to four times the rate of inflation. 
 That generated a bonanza that kept many troubled banks afloat. 
 No more. 
 Sobered by recession, Americans are kicking the plastic-debt habit. 
 Many have decided that the eight credit cards which, on average, they carry, three of them issued by banks, are more than enough. 
 Banks are competing fiercely for a share of the slower-growing market. 
 The bank-controlled Visa and MasterCard networks, with more than 75% of the general-purpose cards market between them, are fighting a discount war with American Express to keep shops and restaurants loyal as recession slows their billings, while fending off powerful non-bank competitors, led by AT&amp;T and Sears Roebuck, who want to join their networks. 
 Margins &mdash; at last &mdash; are being squeezed. 
 While consumer-loan interest rates fell by six percentage points in the decade, those on bank-affiliated credit-card balances stood pat at almost 20%. 
 Yet Americans kept on borrowing. 
 They charged &dollar;366 billion to general-purpose credit-cards last year, more than five times as much as in 1980; outstanding credit-card debt rose sevenfold to &dollar;177 billion over the decade. 
 This was manna for the banks. 
 Their return on equity in credit cards was three or four times that in any other line. 
 At Citibank, America's biggest issuer, three-fifths of consumer-banking profits last year came from cards. 
 Fat and happy, banks saw no point in competing for customers with lower fees or interest rates. 
 Instead, they competed on service. 
 Citibank, for example, will refund the difference if a customer finds he has not bought his goods at the best advertised price. 
 Travel insurance and other services that once came only with cards like American Express's gold card became commonplace. 
 Then last year AT&amp;T launched its Universal card, shattering the banks' complacency. 
 It charged no entrance or annual fees to its first card-holders, and a variable interest rate on outstanding balances which worked out at .5-.75 of a percentage point below the bank cards' average. 
 AT&amp;T has become one of the top seven card-issuers, at least in the number of cards issued if not in charge volume. 
 Its introductory offers, plus a discount on long-distance telephone calls, have now been dropped, as the company seeks to wring profit out of the 9.8m cardholders it has bought itself. 
 Bank issuers have responded to the non-bank challenge with a blaze of publicity about how they are cutting their own fees, which are typically &dollar;20&ndash;40 a year, or waiving them for new card-holders in the first year. 
 Interest rates have edged down, and more banks are switching to variable interest rates pegged to their prime lending rate. 
 That can lower rates by two or three percentage points. 
 The Universal card is such a threat to banks because, unlike Sears' six-year-old Discover card, it has been linked to the Visa and MasterCard networks from the outset. 
 To achieve this, AT&amp;T formed a partnership with Universal Bank, a small bank from Columbus, Georgia, which formally issues and handles the cards, although the telephone company handles all the marketing. 
 Bearing the Visa or MasterCard logo is the key to making big money, because so many outlets accept them. 
 Nearly 2m merchants accept Visa cards in America and some 7m worldwide. 
 Sears' Discover card is accepted by 1.2m; not bad for a network built from scratch since 1985, but clearly still short of critical mass. 
 According to the Nilson Report, a Californian publication that follows the industry, Citibank's Visa/MasterCard and Sears' Discover cards have roughly the same number of holders (20.4m and 21.6m respectively), but Citibank's card brought it &dollar;600m in net revenue against Discover's &dollar;117m last year. 
 This was mostly because the &dollar;40.3 billion charged to its cards was far ahead of Discover's &dollar;19.4 billion, and because Citibank had built up three times as much outstanding debt as Discover. 
 Sears is yet to recoup its investment in Discover. 
 Joining the Visa network would give it the leg-up it needs. 
 It has bought a dud Utah thrift, MountainWest, which was already a Visa card-issuer. 
 On this, it plans to piggy-back a new version of Discover, called Prime Option. 
 If it could merge this with its store account customers, it would become America's biggest card-issuer. 
 The banks are unthrilled by such ideas. 
 They want to keep the more-lightly regulated non-banks out of Visa and MasterCard. 
 Visa has (since 1989) a rule barring issuers of rival cards, such as Sears and American Express, or any affiliates. 
 Sears is challenging this in a case now before a Denver appeals court. 
 If it wins, other non-banks, such as General Motors' finance arm and the Bell telephone companies, are likely to launch their own Visa cards. 
 Visa's rule-book bristles with other conditions that keep non-banks at bay. 
 Visa has final say over the artwork on Visa cards. 
 Members may not put a second account number on a card. 
 This would stop, say, Sears putting on a Prime Option Visa card its own store account numbers or numbers for other financial services that it offers through its Dean Witter subsidiary. 
 Visa has recently closed a loophole that let AT&amp;T put a telephone number on its Universal cards. 
 Another newish rule forces most of a card's receivables to be held by the issuing company, not its parent. 
 This hampers the small banks that the non-banks use as a conduit for their services. 
 These do not have the capital to carry large volumes of receivables. 
 The rule also pushes up costs, since a non-bank cannot route all its card business through its main finance department. 
 Such rules are already starting to raise antitrust eyebrows at the justice department.  
 The kindness of chapter 11 
 America's chapter 11 bankruptcy is too kind to a troubled company's existing managers and shareholders, and too harsh on creditors 
 AMERICAN firms with serious money troubles have two choices &mdash; formal bankruptcy through chapter 11 of the 1978 Bankruptcy Reform Act, or an informal rescheduling of their debts, known as a &bquo;workout&equo;. 
 Chapter 11 is not cheap &mdash; often lasting for years, with fat legal fees to pay &mdash; compared with workouts. 
 So you might think few firms would opt for the formal route. 
 You would be wrong. 
 A new study* by academics at the London Business School and the University of California at Los Angeles finds firms choosing chapter 11 and workouts in roughly equal numbers. 
 This is no surprise, reckons the study. 
 The bosses of a troubled firm and the shareholders that appoint them choose between chapter 11 and workouts. 
 Both do nicely from chapter 11; other creditors do not. 
 Chapter 11 works by allowing top management to get the firm out of trouble by drawing up a rescue plan that can involve restructuring the firm and writing down creditors' claims on its assets. 
 After all, reckoned America's lawmakers, these bosses know most about what needs to be done &mdash; never mind that they got the firm into trouble in the first place. 
 Workouts do the same, but with much less legal tussle. 
 Chapter 11 is different from British &bquo;receivership&equo;, where the courts mostly sack existing management and put a finance &mdash; but, some would say, not a business &mdash; expert in charge. 
 For managers, the nice thing about chapter 11 is that it protects the firm from its creditors until a rescue deal is sorted out; and the firm can stop paying its interest charges. 
 This protection seems sensible enough; firms need a breathing space if they are to recover. 
 But it also sets up a fight between a firm's shareholders and its other creditors. 
 Without chapter 11, if a firm were shut down and its assets sold off, the spoils would go first to senior creditors &mdash; banks and others that had lent the firm money. 
 Only when senior creditors were paid in full would junior creditors, and after them preference shareholders, get some cash. 
 When all these are paid, ordinary shareholders get what is left, which is usually not much. 
 This all changes under chapter 11. 
 Shareholders, who know they will get peanuts if the firm is wound up, want the firm to keep trading in the hope that it will come good. 
 Creditors, on the other hand, can be damaged every day that the firm trades without a rescue package. 
 They may lose both because of missed interest payments and because of the legal fees that have to be paid from the firm's shrunken assets. 
 Managers have two good motives to avoid a deal with creditors for as long as they can: they keep their jobs longer, and they work for shareholders, who do not want a deal either. 
 Senior creditors must battle not only with shareholders, but also with junior creditors. 
 Under chapter 11, two-thirds of creditors, of preference shareholders and of equity shareholders must separately back a deal before it can go ahead. 
 If junior creditors account for more than a third of the creditors, they can force concessions from their senior partners. 
 What happens, reckons the study (which looked at 88 big, troubled firms, 41 in chapter 11 and 47 in workouts, between 1983 and 1990), is that creditors give up some of their seniority rights as a carrot to get management to agree to a deal. 
 The study compared what each type of creditor &mdash; holders of debt, preference shares and equity &mdash; would have expected to get if strict legal priority had been applied with what they actually got. 
 The 41 chapter 11 deals gave some &dollar;878m to claimants that was not, by the terms of loan agreements, due to them (see chart). 
 Shareholders, arguably entitled to nothing, got around a third of the benefit. 
 Junior creditors got just over half, and preference shareholders the rest &mdash; all at the expense of senior creditors. 
 This was on top of much bigger write-downs of creditors' claims under chapter 11 deals &mdash; on average 47% of pre-deal face value, compared with 23% in workouts. 
 Workouts take the battle between creditors and shareholders a step further. 
 As chapter 11 is so bad for senior creditors, management and shareholders have a big advantage. 
 If the senior creditors refuse to make a deal it likes, the firm will simply file for chapter 11 protection. 
 So in workouts, too, creditors may be willing to give up their seniority rights. 
 This, the study finds, is the case. 
 In fact, senior creditors give up even more in workouts than in chapter 11 deals, although the write-downs of their claims tend to be a lot less. 
 Of the &dollar;1.7 billion shifted from losers to gainers in workouts, senior creditors gave up &dollar;1.3 billion. 
 This is less odd than it looks: it pays creditors to avoid the delays and legal costs of chapter 11. 
 In effect, then, chapter 11 says it is better to keep a firm running than to honour debt agreements. 
 This is fine for managers and employees, who (or many of whom) keep their jobs, and for shareholders, who would otherwise face large losses. 
 It is also good for politicians, who are spared having to explain job losses, and, as ever, for lawyers. 
 Yet it may be bad for other firms, even sound ones, since lenders will become increasingly wary, and may charge higher interest rates overall to make up for their higher risks. 
 One answer would be for the judges ruling on applications for chapter 11 to get tough in backing creditors' claims against the firm. 
 There is some sign of this. 
 The academics had earlier studied chapter 11 between 1978 and 1984; the amounts gained by shareholders at the expense of senior creditors were even higher then than in the more recent cases. 
 Alternatively America could move towards a more British system of receivership, which puts creditors before shareholders, and is more likely to end in the firm simply ceasing to trade. 
 That is not as bad as it sounds. 
 Worthwhile parts of the firm will be bought by some other firm that can make use of them &mdash; perhaps better use than the existing management.  
 Taxing Britain's building societies 
 Double standards 
 THE British government has just refused to undo, by retrospective legislation, a decision of the law lords that invalidated all interest-rate swaps conducted by local authorities. 
 It is now trying to ram through retrospective legislation to undo a decision of the law lords that ought to save Britain's building societies from what they consider double taxation. 
 The tax saga &mdash; and the would-be retroactivity &mdash; goes back to 1985. 
 At that time the tax that banks deducted from interest payments to depositors was passed on to the taxmen each quarter. 
 But building societies paid only once a year. 
 The government decided to level the playing field: the societies also must pay quarterly, from April 1986. 
 The snag was that their accounting years often did not coincide with the April-March tax year. 
 If a society's year ended in, say, September, it passed on the tax the following January. 
 So &mdash; the taxmen argued &mdash; in the new system, tax due on interest payments in the gap from October 1985 to April 1986 would get stuck in the society's pocket. 
 So special rules were made to deal with this. 
 Unfair, cried the societies. 
 Their January payment, whatever accounting year it was based on, met their full tax liability for the ongoing fiscal year. 
 They would not escape tax for October 1985 to April 1986 at all; the special rules meant double taxation. 
 The rules were reworded in 1986. 
 One society, the Woolwich, then challenged them in court: won, lost on appeal, then won again before the law lords last October, and retrieved &pound;91m (&dollar;160m) of tax and interest thereon from the Inland Revenue, plus another &pound;6m due after a further appeal-court victory of detail this week. 
 Victory came, ultimately, on a technicality, not the double-tax issue. 
 But the law lords did pronounce, obscurely, on that. 
 They seem to have accepted both that (a) some interest payments had indeed &mdash; but for the special rules &mdash; stood to escape tax; yet (b) the normal January 1986 tax payment covered liability for that fiscal year &bquo;including tax on interest paid after the end of a society's accounting year&equo; &mdash; which was, &bquo;in a sense, to tax &lsqb;those sums&rsqb; twice&equo;. 
 Not so, the Treasury still insists. 
 Take the (extreme) example of a society which, during the gap months, had paid ten times as much interest as usual. 
 Its tax bill, but for the special rules, would not have reflected that &mdash; which suggests the gap was a real one. 
 Whatever justice may say, the whoopee in the building societies' camp was soon cut short. 
 Claiming that it is merely cleaning up a technicality, the government, in clause 50 of the current finance bill, is cheerily trying to rewrite the law, retroactively, five years after the event. 
 Whether or not this succeeds &mdash; some senior Tories are in revolt &mdash; the Woolwich can still laugh: by bizarre custom, the new clause would let it, having won in court, hang on to its winnings. 
 Others, from the Leeds, claiming &pound;57m, plus interest, to the tiny Greenwich (&pound;1.9m) are not amused. 
 At least the government can answer those who say its attitude to retroactive legislation is inconsistent. 
 Not at all. 
 One decision will save local authorities at least part of the &pound;500m they owe banks on contracts which they freely entered into. 
 The other will save the Treasury &pound;250m (&pound;400m, interest included) screwed out of unwilling building societies. 
 In both cases the government's beneficiary is itself.  
 The Federconsorzi affair 
 Fiasco italiano 
 IT IS a rare event &mdash; in the industrialised world, at least &mdash; for a state-owned enterprise to go bust, leaving banks with billions of dollars' worth of bad loans. 
 Something like that is about to happen in Italy. 
 Federconsorzi, a state-run agency that provides financial services to farmers and owns large chunks of Italy's food-processing industry, was taken over by government administrators on May 17th with debts of 4.2 trillion lire (&dollar;3.3 billion). 
 Among its creditors is the hapless Banca Nazionale del Lavoro (BNL), which has loans and other exposure to Federconsorzi worth 430 billion lire. 
 BNL owns one-quarter of a factoring company headed by Luigi Scotti, who just resigned as president of Federconsorzi. 
 BNL last made headlines in 1989, after revelations that an American branch of the bank, in Atlanta, Georgia, had extended unauthorised trade credits to Iraq worth some &dollar;3 billion. 
 Italy's other big state-owned banks have also lent money to the bust group. 
 Most at risk, according to Michele Pacitti, of a British investment bank, County NatWest, are Italy's small farmers' banks, the casse rurali. 
 It is unclear how much of the group's debt, if any, is covered by government guarantee. 
 Federconsorzi's slide toward insolvency is a saga of patronage, corruption and excess. 
 Italy's monarchy set up the agency 100 years ago to provide services to some 90 regional consortia that helped farmers and food companies sell their output and buy supplies. 
 Initially, the system worked well: Federconsorzi used its national clout to bid up the price of farmers' crops and bargain down the cost of their supplies. 
 With the advent of democracy after the second world war, however, Federconsorzi, like many of Italy's state agencies, became a tool of party politics. 
 The Christian Democrats used it to win the votes of farmers. 
 The agency began to make loans to farmers and food companies against their production and to hold back on demanding payments for goods it supplied. 
 When customers unsurprisingly got into trouble, it obligingly increased its advances. 
 It rarely pushed a non-paying customer into bankruptcy. 
 Instead, it would take over some assets, often the least valuable ones. 
 Thus Federconsorzi found itself owning some unprofitable bits of Italy's food industry, such as a milk and cheese producer called Polenghi Lombarda and a jam company called Massa Lombarda. 
 It also owns an insurance company, Fata, and has a stake in an ailing private bank. 
 Farmers, officials and the Mafia found other, illegal, ways to siphon money out of Federconsorzi's regional affiliates. 
 One scam entailed boosting the weight of produce by soaking its wooden or paper containers in water. 
 Another used Federconsorzi to defraud a state scheme that paid farmers to destroy their surplus output. 
 Farmers took several payments for each load of produce and inflated their yield reports. 
 (One orange-growing region in Sicily was so productive, on paper, that California sent agronomists to discover how.) 
 About ten years ago the agriculture ministry, which runs the agency, made a half-hearted attempt to staunch its losses. 
 It hired a competent manager from the private sector, Silvio Pelizzoni, but gave him little power. 
 Mr Pelizzoni worked hard to restructure the group, by selling its industrial stakes and turning the property owned by the regional consortia into a chain of stores. 
 This plan alone would not have restored the group's fortunes. 
 But the Christian Democrat politicians on the agency's board repeatedly blocked even these modest plans. 
 Now there is reason for hope. 
 Italy's new agriculture minister, Giovanni Goria, unmasked the Federconsorzi's frightful financial and appointed a troika to administer the group. 
 The next, more difficult step will be to clean up the mess. 
 Mr Goria plans to liquidate Federconsorzi's assets in order to pay off some of the group's debt (although he is unlikely to force the group into formal bankruptcy). 
 The banks would be forced to absorb large losses. 
 Mr Goria wants banks to give the group a discount on interest payments for 1989 and 1990 and to forgo interest for 1991. 
 That could cost the banks some 700 billion lire. 
 Whatever the outcome, banks are sure to suffer from their ill-judged business with Federconsorzi. 
 Do not assume they are necessarily innocent victims. 
 Franco Piro, president of the finance commission in the lower house of Italy's legislature, plans to investigate the banks' role in the Federconsorzi fiasco.  
 London's securities firms 
 Better can mean worse 
 STOCKBROKERS have picked up the airline habit: flying merrily on heedless of a leakage of cash. 
 In 1990, say the latest numbers in the London Stock Exchange's quarterly review, they lost a collective &pound;350m (&dollar;625m). 
 But Wall Street also lost money (for the first time) in 1990, so perhaps London is just part of a wider trend. 
 Not entirely so. 
 The London firms' revenues plummeted by a third from 1989's level. 
 But this was not just the effect of slower markets and smaller volumes on commission and fee income. 
 Thanks to big one-off dealing losses at certain firms, overall profits from equity trading slumped by over 50%, to less than &pound;400m. 
 Meanwhile, for all the gloomy talk of tight budgets and an end to City lunches, the London firms managed to shrink their costs in 1990 by a mere 3% &mdash; less than Wall Street managed. 
 Never mind, say market optimists: the first quarter of 1991 promises to make up much lost ground. 
 Equity turnover shot up in February and March. 
 Earnings from the recent spate of rights issues and flotations will be fat. 
 Dealing spreads, pared wafer-thin after Big Bang, have widened a bit. 
 Even the government's re-entry into the gilts market as public borrowing has risen is seen as a sign of hope. 
 The optimism looks misplaced, even though 1991 will probably prove a better year than 1990. 
 (Two words of warning: the past few years have revealed an odd seasonal pattern of a good first quarter followed by three bad ones; and, true to form, April and May this year have proved less rewarding than earlier months. 
 Also, a possible Labour government would mean no nice little privatisation earners.) 
 The industry is still stuffed with excess capacity, mostly taken on for Big Bang and the freak year of boom that followed (until the 1987 crash). 
 Though some firms have pulled out, there are still too many market-makers in both gilts and equities, which holds down everyone's earnings. 
 And though bonuses have all but disappeared, basic staff salaries remain too high &mdash; and staff numbers have yet to fall below pre-Big-Bang levels. 
 Other costs seem equally hard to cut (staff costs account for less than a third of the total). 
 With masterly understatement, the Stock Exchange report says that, compared with 1986, firms now have &bquo;higher and possibly more rigid cost structures.&equo; 
 Nor has much been done to attack the soft commissions (payments in kind) given to fund managers to attract their business. 
 Even for those firms that are managing to wash their faces, the return on the capital employed in the markets, itself much more than before Big Bang, is puny. 
 For most of the time since 1986, many parent companies would have done better putting their money safely in a bank deposit than risking it in the securities markets. 
 No wonder they are losing patience. 
 In February the chairman of National Westminster Bank, Lord Alexander, warned his investment-banking arm, County NatWest, that it had to become profitable within two years or face possible closure. 
 Branch bank managers, tired of cross-subsidising overpaid, loss-making City yuppies, applauded. 
 This points to the real worry about 1991: not that it will not be good enough, but that it will be too good. 
 At the start of the year, several firms were steeling themselves for the tough, face-losing decision to pull out of some markets &mdash; or out of the securities business altogether. 
 Now they have been given a fresh lease of life, inviting the (wrong) conclusion that the need for a further shake-out is past. 
 A bright future for London's securities firms would, oddly, be nearer if in the next few months they once again lost oodles of cash.  
 Swedish krona 
 Basket case? 
 AFTER staying single for 14 years, Sweden has again hitched its currency to others in Europe. 
 On May 17th the krona was pegged to the ecu, within 1.5% either side of a central rate of SKr7.40. 
 Sweden used to be part of the &bquo;snake&equo; (predecessor of the European exchange-rate mechanism), but quit in 1977, so that it could keep control of its own economic policy. 
 That &bquo;control&equo; was not wisely used: of the 13 countries that The Economist follows each week in our statistical back pages, Sweden has by far the highest inflation, 10.9%. 
 The ecu link may provide a firmer anchor for inflationary expectations. 
 Since a 25% devaluation in 1982, Sweden's central bank has in fact kept the krona stable against a mainly trade-weighted basket of 15 currencies, including seven non-ERM ones. 
 But the dollar's weight, 21.9%, was double what it would have been on a purely trade-weighted basis, so its slide between 1985 and 1990 dragged the krona down against ERM currencies. 
 Between 1985 and early this year, the krona lost about 25% against the D-mark. 
 Though its timing caught out the markets, the krona/ecu link has been on the cards for some months. 
 In October sterling joined the ERM, and Norway tied its krone to the ecu. 
 Britain is Sweden's second biggest trade partner, Norway its fourth. 
 Until October, ERM members took about 40% of Sweden's exports; add in Britain and Norway, and that becomes more than 60%. 
 Secondly, Sweden, once against joining the European Community, has said it will apply for membership in June. 
 The ecu link is a first step towards membership of the ERM. 
 A wisely modest step too. 
 The ERM provides for &bquo;non-member countries with strong economic and financial ties with the EC&equo; to become associate members. 
 But when Norway and Austria (the schilling is pegged to the D-mark) applied for associate membership last year, they got a cool reception. 
 New members, it seems, are currently an unwanted distraction. 
 Though announcement of the link allowed short-term interest rates to fall by a percentage point to 11.4%, and pushed Swedish share prices up 3.5% in a day, it caused chaos in the lucrative Stockholm business of &bquo;basket arbitrage&equo;. 
 In this game, investors borrowed dollars and other currencies according to their share in the krona basket, converted them into krona, and re-invested in Swedish securities with bigger returns than the cost of the borrowed funds. 
 At one point last autumn, when Swedish rates rose to 17%, such deals yielded a net annualised return of 8%, with little exchange-rate risk. 
 No longer. 
 The switch to an ecu link left basket players owing billions of dollars, with no predictable relationship between the krona and the dollar. 
 Rushing to buy the dollar (mainly by selling D-marks) to cover their dollar loans, they pushed it up four pfennigs within an hour.  
 Gone with the wind? 
 LOS ANGELES, PARIS AND CANNES 
 IT COULD make a great movie. 
 Backed by a powerful French state-owned bank, a little-known Italian businessman buys a famous Hollywood film studio. 
 After a brief and unsuccessful career as a mogul, he is suddenly ousted by the bank. 
 A stake in the business, which has come near to bankruptcy, is put up for sale. 
 If a buyer cannot be found fast, rumour goes, the bank may lose hundreds of millions of dollars. 
 Worried French politicians demand an investigation into the bank's links with the Italian. 
 This story, though, is true. 
 In May 1990 Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais helped Giancarlo Parretti, the Italian chairman and chief executive of Pathe Communications, to finance Pathe's &dollar;1.3 billion acquisition of MGM. 
 In April this year, however, the bank forced him to step down as head of Pathe, after its film and television business, MGM-Pathe, narrowly escaped bankruptcy. 
 This month Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais gave Pathe (of which Mr Parretti and his family control 80%) until December 1st to sell a 40% stake in itself, or in MGM-Pathe, to cut its debt. 
 If that target is not met, the bank will have the right to sell 51% of Pathe or MGM-Pathe. 
 At the film industry's annual jamboree in Cannes, the MGM affair was a hot topic of conversation. 
 Mr Parretti, it seems, has been no Sam Goldwyn. 
 He sold many of the rights to MGM's film library to help finance his takeover. 
 The studio got little cash to pay for new films. 
 He gave his 22-year-old daughter Valentina a prominent role in the finances of the company (she, like his wife, is now a director). 
 Films had to be delayed for shortage of money, and some cheques bounced. 
 Fed up with waiting for &dollar;15m, one group of creditors filed a petition in an American court in March to force MGM-Pathe into liquidation. 
 It was saved by a &dollar;145m loan from Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais. 
 The state-owned bank's involvement has raised eyebrows among French politicians. 
 Some wonder why the bank stuck with Mr Parretti, even though his attempt to take over a French cinema chain in June 1990 was blocked on the grounds that it would &bquo;threaten public order&equo;. 
 Fran&ccedil;ois d'Aubert, the centrist vice-chairman of the French National Assembly's finance committee has asked for details of the bank's dealings with Mr Parretti. 
 The bank has stalled a public inquiry by pointing out that the relationship was handled by Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais Bank Nederland (CLBN), a Dutch subsidiary over which the French authorities have no control. 
 CLBN became a big provider of film finance in the early 1980s. 
 Georges Vigon, chairman of its executive board, encouraged Frans Afman, a senior manager, to expand movie lending after the bank's property and commodities businesses ran into trouble. 
 Mr Afman built up a profitable portfolio of loans, mostly to small, independent film studios and heavily secured. 
 Only a few of these loans, including one of &dollar;50m to the Weintraub entertainment group, have since turned sour. 
 One of CLBN's clients was the Cannon group, controlled by two Israeli producers, Yoram Globus and Menahem Golan. 
 They introduced Mr Parretti to CLBN in 1987, presenting him as a potential investor in their company. 
 Mr Afman was unwilling to lend to him. 
 Mr Vigon then took over the Cannon account himself. 
 By the end of 1987 CLBN was making loans to companies controlled by Mr Parretti. 
 Unhappy, Mr Afman resigned from the bank in July 1988, though he was retained as a consultant until the end of last year. 
 How much Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais is owed by Pathe remains a mystery. 
 A spokesman for CLBN refuses to say, though describing suggestions of &dollar;1.5 billion as &bquo;ridiculous&equo;. 
 What is known is that the bank has lent Pathe &dollar;250m to finance the MGM purchase, plus an undisclosed sum linked to the sale of some of the rights to the studio's film library. 
 There is also the &dollar;145m loan to protect MGM-Pathe from bankruptcy. 
 A small clue is the 40% of MGM-Pathe that the bank wants sold. 
 Mr Parretti paid &dollar;1.3 billion for MGM. 
 If &mdash; most improbably &mdash; that figure still holds good, 40% would mean around &dollar;500m. 
 The bank says the sale would leave it owed &dollar;125m. 
 Add the two to reach &dollar;600m-plus. 
 Of course that simple arithmetic may be wrong. 
 Rather less simply, some people close to Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais think it may also have lent money to Florio Fiorini, a Swiss-based Italian associated with Mr Parretti. 
 Some of this may have been channelled into Pathe, where Mr Fiorini is still co-chairman. 
 What is surprising is that alarm bells within the bank did not bring action earlier. 
 Given the size of the loans to Mr Parretti, Alexis Wolkenstein, the head of the bank's international division, and Jean-Yves Haberer, the bank's chairman, can hardly have been unaware of its growing involvement with him. 
 The same applies to Mr Vigon at CLBN. 
 In July 1988 Mr Vigon replaced Jean Naville, a director of Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais in Paris with responsibility for, among other things, Western Europe. 
 Mr Naville retired and subsequently joined one of Mr Parretti's companies. 
 The bank is now keeping its fingers crossed that its &dollar;145m emergency loan will be enough to turn MGM around. 
 It may not be. 
 First, about half of it will be used to pay creditors and to meet legal fees connected with the bankruptcy proceedings. 
 Second, the studio must still meet heavy interest payments until it can reduce its debt. 
 Third, although Alan Ladd, the highly respected chief executive of MGM-Pathe, thinks he can release 13 films this year, costing an average of &dollar;8m-10m each, their prospects must be open to question. 
 Most films cost &dollar;20m-&dollar;30m. 
 True, one real blockbuster could solve MGM's problems. 
 But the studio's recent record of new releases has been dismal. 
 &bquo;Rocky V&equo;, for example, was expected to gross over &dollar;100m at the box office. 
 In fact, it took in roughly &dollar;40m. 
 MGM-Pathe may have to be sold. 
 Even then, would it bring in enough to repay Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais's lending? 
 Happy endings rarely happen off-screen. 
 The bank has one consolation. 
 Tomorrow is, as Vivien Leigh said, another day.  
 Japanese property companies 
 One saved, dozens to go 
 TOKYO 
 PROPERTY companies continue to go bust in large numbers in Japan. 
 The authorities have so far managed to prevent a chain reaction. 
 Until when? 
 The latest test came with confirmation that Asahi Juken, Japan's second biggest condominium developer, is in trouble. 
 A private, Osaka-based company with over 1,500 employees, it owes &yen;570 billion (&dollar;4.1 billion). 
 But it is too big to be allowed to fail. 
 The snag is that it has no main bank behind it. 
 Instead C. Itoh, a trading company, has been forced to lead a support operation. 
 C. Itoh is said to be the largest creditor, having lent Asahi Juken around &yen;50 billion. 
 It will now have to lend another &yen;30 billion. 
 Only on this condition have four creditor banks, the Industrial Bank of Japan, the Long-Term Credit Bank, Mitsui Taiyo Kobe Bank and Nippon Credit Bank, and five creditor non-banks agreed to lend an additional &yen;27 billion. 
 This will pay some bills for now. 
 But it is unlikely that C. Itoh will take over other creditors' debts, the traditional role in Japan of a main bank. 
 So Asahi Juken's fate hangs in the balance. 
 It hopes to sell properties (mostly land, because condominiums are fetching only distress prices) worth &yen;100 billion-200 billion to reduce its borrowings. 
 This will not help a property market under pressure. 
 According to Teikoku Data Bank, in the first four months of this year bankruptcies, mostly property-related, totalled &yen;2.6 trillion, &yen;855 billion of that during April. 
 This exceeds the annual total in any of the past four years. 
 More will follow. 
 The data bank's research shows that 45% of Japanese property companies have debts greater than two years' worth of their sales and 32% have debts greater than three years of sales. 
 THINK-TANKS 
 The carousels of power 
 &bquo;Those who desire to win the favour of princes generally endeavour to do so by offering them those things which they themselves prize most, or such as they observe the prince to delight in most.&equo; 
 Niccolo Machiavelli 
 WHEN Machiavelli sat down to write &bquo;The Prince&equo;, he was feeling anxious. 
 Unemployed after many years in government service, he wrote his handbook of advice to new rulers in an attempt to win a job with the incoming Medici administration. 
 The Machiavelli problem would be instantly recognisable to hordes of would-be and once-were government officials in today's world: &bquo;policy intellectuals&equo;, as Americans call them. 
 They would not recognise his workplace. 
 Displaced from power, he had to toil in a humble farmhouse outside Florence. 
 Today he would sit in a think-tank, cosseted by secretaries and flattered by a stream of calls from talk-show producers. 
 The &bquo;policy intellectuals&equo; still strive to present their conclusions as impartial expertise. 
 But, like Machiavelli, they are forever tugging at the sleeves of politicians. 
 Think-tanks, sitting uneasily half-way between government and universities, are institutions that embody this ambiguity. 
 Societies in which a broad consensus dominates political thinking &mdash; such as Germany and Japan today and the United States in the late 1950s and early 1960s &mdash; tend to respect the think-tanks' claim of neutrality. 
 But when consensus breaks down, as it did in Britain and the United States in the late 1970s, think-tanks become more avowedly ideological. 
 Their new role is to challenge conventional wisdom. 
 They can articulate the instincts of dissidents in the language of the academy, and suggest ideas that bridge the gap between instinct and policy. 
 Many American think-tanks, such as the Washington-based Institute for International Economics, still cling to an aura of academic detachment. 
 But an increasing number, typified by the conservative Heritage Foundation, define themselves above all by the fact that they hold a coherent body of ideas, and want to spread them. 
 Think-tanks sprout in America to an extent undreamed of elsewhere. 
 A recent book &mdash; &bquo;The Idea Brokers&equo;, by James Smith &mdash; identifies over 1,000 private ones, around 100 in Washington alone. 
 They range from the Brookings Institution, with its vast battleship of a building on Massachusetts Avenue, to tiny lobbying outfits with offices the size of a doctor's waiting room. 
 They thrive in America for two good reasons. 
 First, a lot of rich foundations are ready to pay good money to people to sit and think. 
 Second, the American system of government is peculiarly open to such chosen thinkers. 
 Each new administration in Washington appoints not only the heads of its departments, or ministries, but also a lot of people further down the departmental ladder. 
 Groups like the Council of Economic Advisers and the State Department's Policy Planning Staff &mdash; government think-tanks, in effect &mdash; absorb more outsiders. 
 The two houses of Congress employ a bureaucracy with a huge appetite for independent research. 
 Plenty of work here for thinkers who can catch the political tide. 
 The revolving door between government and think-tanks is well-established. 
 Both Zbigniew Brzezinski, who headed the National Security Council under Jimmy Carter, and Robert McFarlane, who did the same job for Ronald Reagan, joined the Centre for Strategic and International Studies on leaving office. 
 Brent Scowcroft, now head of the NSC, once worked there. 
 When Ronald Reagan took office, no fewer than 20 of the research fellows at the neo-conservative American Enterprise Institute (AEI) joined his administration. 
 Now that Mr Reagan has left power, many of his appointees, such as Jeane Kirkpatrick and Richard Perle, are working at AEI. 
 Every American think-tank director has a dream and a nightmare. 
 The dream is to house the next administration; the nightmare is to house the last one. 
 AEI seems to have managed both in the course of a decade. 
 The first lot of American research institutes, just before the first world war, was more politically innocent. 
 It was not until the 1960s, when &bquo;think-tank&equo; entered the popular vocabulary, that these bodies became a natural bridge between universities and government. 
 In those days think-tanks were intoxicated by the new sophistication they could apply to their work by way of computers, games theory and other novelties. 
 The Rand Corporation, based in Santa Monica in California, pioneered the application of &bquo;systems analysis&equo;. 
 Like the Urban Institute, founded in Washington in 1968 after racial riots across America, it thrived not on private philanthropy but on research contracts from the government. 
 The rise and fall of technocracy 
 With a sociologist, Daniel Bell, proclaiming &bquo;the end of ideology&equo;, technocrats were in vogue. 
 To President Kennedy the great issues related &bquo;not to basic clashes of philosophy or ideology but to ways and means of reaching common goals &mdash; to research for sophisticated solutions to complex and obstinate issues.&equo; 
 It was up to the politicians to define the ends: an end to urban poverty, victory in Vietnam. 
 The think-tanks would provide the means. 
 Failure both in Vietnam and in the war on poverty discredited technocracy. 
 Conservatives, in particular, argued that the &bquo;liberal establishment&equo; and the think-tanks it favoured &mdash; Brookings, the Rand Corporation, even the grand old Council on Foreign Relations in New York &mdash; embodied a stifling and wrong-headed orthodoxy. 
 They set about building what Sidney Blumenthal, a journalist, calls a &bquo;counter-establishment&equo;. 
 Because the old think-tanks were dominated by liberals, conservative alternatives were required. 
 During the 1970s the AEI expanded, and new organisations such as the Heritage Foundation and the Manhattan Institute for Policy Research were founded. 
 The latter was created by William Casey, who became Ronald Reagan's campaign director and then head of the CIA. 
 The conservative think-tanks set about the prevailing wisdom on welfare policy at home, detente with Russia abroad. 
 By 1981 much of the intellectual spadework for the Reagan presidency had been done. 
 Their apparent success prodded Democrats to start building a counter-counter-establishment. 
 The Progressive Policy Institute was set up by the Democratic Leadership Council, which is on the right wing of the Democratic Party. 
 The Economic Policy Institute, born in 1986, is a bit further left: like the Heritage Foundation, but the other way round, it sees itself as a rebel fighting conventional wisdom. 
 Britain's gadflies 
 The shift from an above-it-all &bquo;objectivity&equo; to an open confession of partisanship took place in Britain too, at around the same time. 
 Thatcherism, like Reaganism, drew heavily upon the work of bright neo-conservatives outraged by the &bquo;years of stagnation&equo; in the prime ministerships of Harold Wilson and James Callaghan. 
 There were British think-tanks before Margaret Thatcher became prime minister. 
 But, with the notable exception of the free-market Institute of Economic Affairs (widely regarded in the 1960s, by people who now wish they hadn't, as a home for impractical crackpots), they were guardians of the chalice of consensus. 
 The big three &mdash; the Royal Institute of International Affairs (Chatham House), the Policy Studies Institute and the National Institute of Economic and Social Research &mdash; still see themselves as purveyors of well-researched common sense. 
 The director of the Policy Studies Institute, Bill Daniel, acknowledges a belief that consensus is attainable if you &bquo;establish the facts and get people of good will together.&equo; 
 To Britain's neo-conservatives that was, at best, naive. 
 Together with Sir Keith Joseph, Mrs Thatcher founded the Centre for Policy Studies (CPS) in 1974. 
 Its current director of studies, David Willets, says the CPS started by assuming that &bquo;a lot of the research put out by established think-tanks had a basic bias in favour of increased government spending and an essential belief in the rationality of government.&equo; 
 With a tiny staff (currently seven, including secretaries), the CPS sponsored pioneering work on many of the ideas that came to define Thatcherism &mdash; privatisation, the &bquo;enterprise culture&equo;, a monetary explanation for inflation. 
 Its close links to the policy unit in the prime minister's office (staff members swapped jobs between the two places) ensured that its arguments were heard. 
 As in America, the success of Britain's neo-conservative think-tanks prompted imitation from the other side. 
 In 1988 a group of left-wing luminaries, led by Lady (Tessa) Blackstone, launched the Institute for Public Policy Research. 
 This is formally independent of the Labour Party, but has close links with its leaders. 
 The fall of Mrs Thatcher seems to leave Britain's neo-conservative think-tanks out on the end of a creaking branch. 
 Bill Daniel sees them as &bquo;gadflies who flourished while their princelings were in power&equo;, and foresees a steep decline in their influence. 
 The CPS, seeking to prove him wrong, has installed Britain's new prime minister, John Major, as its patron. 
 But sticking with the Conservative establishment may mean that the CPS loses its claim to radicalism. 
 The organisation's uncertainty is shown by its decision not to have any particular point of view on the future of the European Community: a decision that makes more jaws than Mrs Thatcher's drop. 
 Oddly, the think-tank that seems closest to catching the next intellectual wave is the one whose collapse seemed most logical a year ago. 
 The Social Market Foundation was set up to serve David Owen's Social Democrats, a party that no longer exists. 
 But its name contains the latest buzz-word. 
 The Conservative Party's new chairman, Chris Patten, has told Marxism Today of his interest in the German idea of a &bquo;social market&equo;, which believes it is possible to unleash capitalism's efficiency but also to keep it under the supervising eye of society: to combine the engine of individualism and a communal conscience. 
 Mr Patten even mused that the Conservative Party might set up a think-tank on the lines of Germany's Konrad Adenauer Stiftung, the research arm of the governing Christian Democrats. 
 If Germany is indeed to be the model, British think-tanks may soon be scrambling back towards technocracy and the politics of boring old consensus. 
 No ideology please, we're German 
 At first sight, it is surprising that German think-tanks should be notable for unideological pragmatism. 
 The biggest institutes &mdash; the publicly financed research departments of the Konrad Adenauer foundation and its Social Democratic equivalent, the Friedrich Ebert Foundation &mdash; are, after all, the offspring of political parties. 
 Partisanship should be their middle name. 
 In fact, their relations with the parties they serve sharply restrict their ability to tackle controversial topics. 
 Conclusions, even subjects, embarrassing to the party are unlikely to be pursued. 
 Immigration is a pressing and difficult issue. 
 It would naturally commend itself to an American think-tank. 
 The party ones in Germany are reluctant to consider so awkward a matter: almost anything you say is liable to embarrass the particular group of politicians you have to worry about. 
 Asked about research into immigration quotas, Josef Tiessing of the Adenauer foundation shifts uneasily on his leather sofa. 
 &bquo;This is a political question,&equo; he says, &bquo;it is not a scientific question.&equo; 
 Those tempted to wander over that dividing line can be forcefully reminded of it. 
 One research project, into who would control Soviet nuclear weapons if the Soviet Union broke up, was abruptly abandoned last year. 
 Too political. 
 The distinction between &bquo;scientific&equo; and &bquo;political&equo; research is not just a dodge to help the big German foundations avoid embarrassing their patrons. 
 It is observed, almost as carefully, by the think-tanks that are not dependent on party money or approval. 
 Something German is at work here. 
 There is a tendency to insist that a researcher's work should be &bquo;value-free&equo;. 
 This reflects two German habits: an old one, an academic tradition that takes the &bquo;science&equo; bit in social science very seriously; and a newer yearning for consensus, for believing that all sensible people really agree with each other. 
 Since 1959, when the Social Democrats embraced capitalism, German politics has been a large clustering around the centre, with only a few dissenters on the margins. 
 Meinhard Miegel, once a Christian Democratic politician, who heads the Institut f&uuml;r Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft (Institute for Economics and Society) in Bonn, could think of no influential German think-tank &mdash; even the one run by Greens &mdash; that did not accept the basic tenets of the social market. 
 Mr Miegel set up his think-tank in 1977. 
 He was not out to break the mould, just to collect better data. 
 He recalls thinking: &bquo;This is crazy, we are trying to run a party without facts.&equo; 
 His institute works on issues ranging from demography to labour shortages. 
 Inevitably, given his background, its research has found its most appreciative audience among Christian Democrats. 
 But its deliberately non-partisan approach is no pose: it helps to shape the institute's choice of research subjects, the way its conclusions are presented, and so, indirectly, the whole tone of debate in the country. 
 In Germany interest groups like to present their views as the product of exhaustive research rather than of a distinctive philosophy. 
 Will German think-tanks ever go the way of some of their English-speaking counterparts, and plunge into the deep waters of ideology? 
 Some see signs of a tendency in that direction. 
 They look in particular at the appointment in 1988 of Michael St&uuml;rmer, a conservative historian with a philosophical bent, as head of the Stiftung f&uuml;r Wissenschaft und Politik (Foundation for Science and Politics) in Ebenhausen, near Munich. 
 This institute, with over 150 researchers, does a lot of work for the federal government: it specialises in data, not policy recommendations. 
 The appointment of Mr St&uuml;rmer, a friend of Chancellor Kohl and a man often seen on television, made some of the staff fear they were going to be &bquo;politicised&equo;. 
 So far, they seem to have feared wrongly: Ebenhausen stays in the good, solid German tradition. 
 The Germans have not yet created what Americans and Britons would call a real think-tank. 
 That requires the revolving door. 
 People with bright ideas must not only carry their opinions out of politics and into the research institutions, but must regularly move back the opposite way when the call comes. 
 In Germany, so far, the door separates two largely distinct worlds. 
 East is east but Moscow is west 
 If American think-tankers would find Germany odd, they would be floored by Japan &mdash; but would cock an interested eyebrow when they went to the Soviet Union. 
 In Japan, as in Germany, love of consensus and the absence of a revolving door leave little room for unorthodox views peddled by independent institutes. 
 The main think-tanks are offshoots of big firms or finance houses: the Nomura Research Institute, the Daiwa Research Institute, the Mitsubishi Research Institute. 
 These bodies produce voluminous reports crammed with data on subjects that interest their sponsors. 
 They are good at description, less so at analysis, which might disagree with the boss's views. 
 The research arms of Japan's securities firms have been relentlessly bullish throughout a 48% decline in the value of the Tokyo stockmarket. 
 The curious processes of Japan's decision-making reverse the usual relationship between government and &bquo;policy intellectuals&equo;. 
 In America and Britain, even to some extent in Germany, think-tanks set out to influence the government. 
 In Japan the government tends to see academics as a useful way of influencing public opinion: how handy if they can be persuaded to open public discussion of a policy change the politicians want to make. 
 In the Soviet Union, on the other hand, there is no longer any pretence that academics can be above the tumult of political conflict. 
 If consensus breeds academic complaisance, chaos does the opposite. 
 Many members of the Moscow research institutes have hurled themselves into politics, as advisers to Mikhail Gorbachev or Boris Yeltsin or as politicians in their own right. 
 The big think-tanks are still the state-financed offshoots of the Soviet Academy of Sciences. 
 These include the Central Economic and Mathematical Institute (TSEMI) and the Institute of the World Economy and International Relations (IMEMO). 
 But, since glasnost, they have lived in a different world. 
 Compare the role of TSEMI under Brezhnev and Mr Gorbachev. 
 In the mid-1960s the Kremlin, seeing that the economic system was not working, briefly flirted with the idea of changing it. 
 TSEMI was given the job of producing an alternative to the ideas of the state planning agency, Gosplan. 
 But the Kosygin reforms, as they came to be known, were ditched. 
 TSEMI dutifully fell quiet. 
 A quarter of a century later, when Mr Gorbachev was feeling reform-minded, it was a head of department at TSEMI, Stanislav Shatalin, who drafted the &bquo;500-day plan&equo;, a proposal for sweeping free-market reforms. 
 They eventually proved too sweeping for Mr Gorbachev. 
 But this time the TSEMI man kept on talking, and threw in his lot with Mr Yeltsin. 
 Most of the Moscow think-tanks have now aligned themselves with Mr Yeltsin. 
 The revolving door has begun to rotate. 
 When Edward Shevardnadze resigned as foreign minister, he at once set up the first privately financed think-tank in the Soviet Union, the Foreign Policy Association. 
 This is expected to be a ginger group for &bquo;new thinking&equo; in foreign policy. 
 The oddity is that, just when the Soviet Union is discovering the merit of think-tanks engaged in ideological combat, the American scene has gone quiet. 
 It was Michael Dukakis who said that what matters is &bquo;not ideology, but competence&equo;. 
 Yet it is George Bush who seems to have adopted that numbing proposition as a personal creed. 
 In today's Washington, where ideology is a murmur of distant guns but technocrats have not quite recovered their old authority, the think-tanks seem at a loss; many of them are cutting the size of their staffs. 
 The dog-days will not last. 
 The United States of the 1990s has a manifest need for independent thought. 
 The great issues of domestic policy &mdash; the budget, the proper handling of welfare, education, race relations &mdash; stay unsolved. 
 That grand-sounding &bquo;new world order&equo; is still a phrase in search of a meaning. 
 Modern Machiavellis have plenty to think about. 
 SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 
 Particle physics 
 Man overboard 
 THE physics of tiny particles tends to attract the big: big machines, big budgets and big personalities. 
 America's Superconducting Super Collider (SSC), to be built in Texas, will be the largest and most expensive machine in the world. 
 One of the biggest names in the field, though, will not be there. 
 The SSC's director, Roy Schwitters, has decided that he can do without the participation of Samuel Ting, from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, who wanted to develop one of the two huge experiments that will make use of the machine. 
 Dr Ting, who has won one Nobel prize (for a particle he named after himself) and would dearly like to win another, has something of a reputation. 
 He affects a certain disinterest in theory, preferring extremely precise experiments that will pick up whatever is going on to those designed with a particular new discovery in mind. 
 He is determined to get authoritative results, and demands that his associates be similarly single-minded. 
 An experiment run by Dr Ting is not a casual affair; to say that he is strict is, he agrees, an understatement. 
 He can be charming. 
 He can also be ruthless. 
 He has more than his share of enemies. 
 At present, Dr Ting is running L3, the largest of the four experiments on LEP, the biggest accelerator at CERN, Europe's particle physics laboratory near Geneva. 
 L3 is a collaboration between institutes and universities from a dozen countries, with more than 600 physicists taking part. 
 Like all the four LEP detectors, L3 has produced excellent results. 
 It has not, to Dr Ting's disappointment, produced any shocks. 
 Only one of the detectors has hinted at finding something new, but the evidence is thin and the experimenters are keen not to make any premature fuss. 
 Dr Ting's proposal for the SSC was like L3 but bigger. 
 He called it L*, pronounced el-star, in homage to its hosts in the lone-star state. 
 On paper, L* looks just the ticket for the SSC &mdash; an ambitious experiment with a good pedigree, run by a famous physicist with an international set of collaborators. 
 The SSC is sometimes keen to be seen as a laboratory for the world, though at other times it remains America's bid for leadership. 
 Last January, when Dr Schwitters chose an American team to build one of the two detectors for the SSC, he put off his decision on L*. 
 An advisory committee had voiced doubts about L*'s management and cost &mdash; likely to be more than &dollar;700m, of which the SSC would pay only &dollar;250m. 
 He asked Dr Ting to set those doubts at ease. 
 One of the problems perceived in Dr Ting's autocratic management was that it does not endear him to the more easy-going American physicists; and there were few large American institutions taking part in L*. 
 The people who end up with detectors on the SSC will be benefiting from a huge American investment (attempts to raise money abroad are meeting with little success) and they will be in a position to dominate American particle physics for a decade, so such considerations carry some weight. 
 Another worry was that, if something happened to Dr Ting, the team he held together would fall apart. 
 In fact, that was already happening. 
 Institutes in Germany and Switzerland withdrew from L* amid some acrimony, which increased doubts about paying for the project. 
 The SSC also apparently got differing accounts of the project's finances; the participants in L* did not always say the same thing as the management. 
 A restructured management failed to convince Dr Schwitters and the committee that Dr Ting was loosening up. 
 So Dr Schwitters decided not to pick L*. 
 The SSC will hold a meeting in June, when all sorts of would-be participants will try to come up with a new detector. 
 In part because the other detector is already looking more expensive, there will be a lot of pressure to keep this new one cheap. 
 Many of the collaborators in L* have been invited &mdash; making it clear that the quarrel was with Dr Ting, not his colleagues. 
 Not all of them will go. 
 An angry Dr Ting will now concentrate his considerable skills and energy on building a detector for a new machine at CERN, called the LHC. 
 The LHC will do some, though not all, of what the SSC will do. 
 If CERN's members give it the go-ahead, it will be ready sooner than the SSC, for which it will be the only competitor. 
 If Dr Ting climbs on board in Geneva, the competition may well become a grudge match.  
 The uses of diversity 
 ARMED with microscopes, miniature drills and an infinite capacity for taking pains, a few palaeontologists have redrawn their profession's picture of early life. 
 For several decades they have been studying superbly preserved fossils from the rocks of the Burgess shale, found in the Canadian Rockies, which are among the earliest fossils of complicated organisms. 
 The creatures had previously been forced into convenient taxonomic pigeon-holes, whether they fitted or not. 
 The result was to hide their variety. 
 When the revisionists looked into the pigeon-holes without preconceptions, surprising novelties stared back at them, some with five eyes, some with none. 
 Many of these animals, rather than being simple precursors of sophisticates yet to come, were quite unlike anything ever seen elsewhere. 
 To some, the huge variety of life in the Burgess shale has been an inspiration. 
 Stephen Jay Gould of Harvard, a friend of the Burgess revisionists, wrote a popular book about their bounty, &bquo;Wonderful Life&equo;. 
 The history of life, he argued, could have followed all sorts of paths. 
 The weird anomalies of the Burgess shale could have gone on to found evolutionary dynasties while the distant forebears of humanity perished in the ooze. 
 Others, though not denying Dr Gould's point about the contingent nature of evolution &mdash; no true Darwinist can &mdash; are less enamoured of the diversity. 
 They feel that there is a danger of being dazzled by it and thus of missing a unique opportunity to make sense of the early history of animal evolution. 
 The debate centres on taxonomy, the classification of creatures. 
 A phylum is a group of species which share a basic body plan and thus, presumably, a common ancestor. 
 Today there are 30 phyla around, more or less (some borders are a bit murky). 
 According to work done in the 1970s and 1980s, there could have been up to 32 in the rocks of Burgess shale alone, including many never seen anywhere else. 
 By comparing the number of phyla, one can say, as Dr Gould does, that there was a wider range of life in one little patch of sea floor than in all today's oceans &mdash; though that conclusion ignores the fact that today's oceans contain whales, jellyfish, barnacles and octopuses, whereas the Burgess sea contained only little creepy-crawlies. 
 The Burgess animals have been taken from established phyla in which they did not fit and put into new ones. 
 So new phyla were created to accommodate a few bizarre animals. 
 However the fossils can also be reinterpreted to fit back into old phyla: 
 Wiwaxia looks like a small Belgian chocolate covered in scales, with some bigger spikes pointing out here and there. 
 Simon Conway Morris of Cambridge University, who played a big part in the first reinterpretation of the Burgess animals, thinks Wiwaxia has no living relatives, but is probably related to other fossils he and his colleagues have found in northern Greenland. 
 Nick Butterfield of Harvard, though, thinks Wiwaxia is related to a scaly worm, part of a known phylum, which is also found in the Burgess shale. 
 His view is based on similarities he sees in the scales. 
 The question is not yet decided, one way or the other. 
 Hallucigenia is one of Dr Conway Morris's greatest finds, an aptly named creature that balances on 14 stilts and waves seven tentacles in the air. 
 However, in last week's Nature new fossils found in Burgess-like rocks from China were described by Lars Ramskold from the Swedish Museum of Natural History and Hou Xianguang from the Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology. 
 The fossils appear to be relatives of Hallucigenia, with flat scaly plates reminiscent of its spines (though not leg-like) and similar tentacles. 
 If they are relatives, then Dr Conway Morris's Hallucigenia is the wrong way up: its tentacles, not its spines, were its legs. 
 Dr Conway Morris has always said there could be other ways to make sense of Hallucigenia, and agrees that the new interpretation may be better. 
 Hallucigenia's tentacles appear to be singletons; if they are in fact legs, they should come in pairs. 
 Dr Ramskold has found traces of extra tentacles on one of the only two really good specimens of the species there are, at the Smithsonian Institution in Washington, DC. 
 He is not allowed to dissect the fossils, though, since they are at present irreplaceable. 
 The new interpretation seems to push Hallucigenia, the Chinese fossils, and some other species around at the time (including another of the Burgess oddballs, Aysheaia) into the arthropod phylum, with insects, crabs and trilobites. 
 It may be that they are in fact onycophorans, a group of arthropods now represented by caterpillar-like velvet worms that burrow through dead wood in Australia. 
 Anomalocaris is the biggest predator among the Burgess animals, and one of the hardest to interpret. 
 For a long time some of its parts &mdash; its mouth and its eating appendages &mdash; were classed as separate animals. 
 Once a definitive picture of it was produced, it was given its own phylum. 
 Des Collins, of the Royal Ontario Museum, doubts that it deserves quite such an honour. 
 Dr Collins has the great advantage of being allowed to go out and get new fossils from the Burgess site &mdash; everyone else has to make do with what is already in museums. 
 He has found several different types of Anomalocaris; from studying the whole lot, he thinks he can make a case for saying that it belongs with the arthropods, not out on its own. 
 Putting the Burgess  weirdos  into more conventional groups whittles away at some of the shale's apparently huge diversity. 
 A more thorough-going approach is to revise the way taxonomy is done. 
 Today's way of grouping things into phyla reflects today's world. 
 It is hardly surprising that it is a poor fit for animals removed from the present by hundreds of millions of years of evolution. 
 Enter Derek Briggs, of the University of Bristol: along with Dr Conway Morris and under the tutelage of Harry Whittington, also of Cambridge, he did much to prise the Burgess fossils from their original mistaken pigeon-holes. 
 Dr Briggs and Richard Fortey (of London's Natural History Museum) have been looking at new ways of classifying the various arthropods in the Burgess. 
 Their approach, instead of valuing the unique, seeks out the common. 
 Using their shared characteristics, the animals can be arranged into a sensibly small number of groups, joined by the common ancestors with whom the shared features began. 
 The approach allows researchers to see how the diversity &mdash; still large and exciting &mdash; came to be, rather than simply marvelling at it. 
 It also shows that, if classed in groups natural to them, rather than in groups based on their remote descendants, the Burgess arthropods are not such a disparate lot. 
 It is possible to do this sort of analysis only within the arthropod phylum, because only that has enough species, with enough measurable features. 
 But what holds true within one phylum may well hold true across them. 
 In the end, the answers will come as they always do &mdash; from the ground. 
 When Burgess revisionism started in the 1960s, the site in Canada was unique. 
 Now Burgess animals and their relatives are found in Greenland, China and elsewhere, as well as at other sites found by Dr Collins near the original one. 
 As more fossils are found, the sense of wonder will no doubt be stirred again, but the systematic research aimed at providing a more complete picture will continue. 
 The message of the Burgess shale &mdash; that there has always been variety, and no one can say in what forms it will survive until it has done so &mdash; remains. 
 The fascinating details of how it came to be are still waiting to be found.  
 Diabetes 
 Sweetmeat solution 
 THERE are two big drawbacks to transplant surgery &mdash; the propensity of the body's defences to reject foreign tissue, and the shortage of donors with organs to give. 
 Scientists in America claim to have found a way round both. 
 They take tissue from an animal and wrap it in plastic before transplanting it. 
 The animals have little choice about being donors, and the plastic prevents the transplant from being recognised and rejected. 
 If the promising results of animal experiments are borne out, this technology could be used to cure diabetes. 
 Although diabetes is usually caused by a pancreas unable to do its job, it is not treated by replacing the offending organ. 
 The proximate cause of the symptoms of diabetes is normally a lack of insulin, a hormone produced in the pancreas to control the body's sugar levels. 
 To alleviate the symptoms, about one in five diabetics in rich countries injects himself regularly with insulin. 
 This makes up for some of the failings of the pancreas, but it leaves the diabetics reliant on an insulin supply, and unable to fine-tune the level of insulin in the way that a healthy pancreas would. 
 Pancreas transplants have been tried, but the surgery is complex, the tissue delicate and the danger of rejection always there. 
 The operation rarely succeeds. 
 A refinement is to transplant only the so-called beta cells of the Islets of Langerhans, the picturesquely named nodes of tissue which actually produce the insulin. 
 Although this simplifies the surgery, it does not overcome the rejection problem. 
 Besides, there are nowhere near enough dead people with healthy pancreases, nor families willing to give permission for transplants, to provide for all the millions in need. 
 The new artificial pancreas has been developed by an American company called Biohybrid Technologies, and the Harvard University Medical School. 
 The Biohybrid pancreas consists of beta cells from animals wrapped up in a patented acrylic plastic and implanted under the skin or in the abdominal cavity. 
 Cells from dogs and cattle have been used so far, but pancreases from any slaughterhouse would probably do. 
 The implant is about the size of a saucer, 3.5 inches (9cm) across and an inch deep. 
 It is connected to an artery and a vein, so that blood flows through it and supplies the beta cells. 
 The holes in the plastic membrane are small enough to keep out white blood-cells, the parts of the immune system which recognise and reject foreign tissue. 
 Other chemical signals carried in the blood can get through, though. 
 These, which are common to all animals, tell the beta cells how much insulin to make. 
 William Chick, president of Biohybrid Technologies, says his device has been tested in diabetic laboratory dogs. 
 Several have been kept alive for up to eight months. 
 Their blood-sugar levels stayed virtually normal. 
 He thinks that when he goes on to test the device in human patients, it should prove successful over long periods. 
 If not, the device can always be recharged with a syringeful of living beta cells. 
 In the next year and a half Dr Chick expects to apply to America's Food and Drug Administration for permission to test his device in people. 
 In about five years, if things go well, Biohybrid pancreases could become widely available. 
 Animal tests have shown no harmful side-effects at all. 
 One cause for concern is that blood flowing through artificial organs tends to clot, which can lead to a stroke or to coronary heart disease. 
 The plastic membrane is treated to prevent this, and animal trials have shown no increased risk of clotting. 
 The same approach could be used to make other animal tissues into useful transplants. 
 Dr Chick is working with a chemicals firm, W. R. Grace, on an artificial liver. 
 Such &bquo;organs&equo; may alleviate problems which are caused by malfunctioning cells. 
 They might supply things that are missing, or clear up things in over-supply, detoxifying the blood. 
 They are less likely to solve problems when the structure, not just the chemical function, of an organ needs to be provided.  
 Illuminating manuscripts 
 MONKS and scribes were the data-processors of the Middle Ages, gathering, copying and disseminating information. 
 The fruits of their labour now attract scholarship as much as, over the centuries, they have attracted dust. 
 But how to wring new information from a few old pieces of vellum and papyrus? 
 One answer, according to two scholars at the University of Illinois, is to use modern data-processing. 
 James Marchand studies Gothic, the oldest teutonic language with any written remains. 
 It sheds light on the origins of modern English, German and the Scandinavian languages. 
 Unfortunately, only one Gothic text, the Codex Argenteus, a piece of the New Testament written in silver ink on purple parchment, survived the downfall of the Goths. 
 Dr Marchand is undaunted by this shortage of raw material. 
 Just as computers overwrite out-of-date files on their disks, monks used to scrape useless manuscripts clean and recycle them. 
 Such overwritten parchments, called palimpsests, often bear traces of the old beneath the new. 
 The monks of Bobbio, in northern Italy, wrote many of their books on looted Gothic bibles. 
 Dr Marchand has devised a technique for reading the texts they got rid of. 
 First he takes black and white photographs of the parchments in ultra-violet light. 
 This makes the ink on the parchment, including the faint traces of the original Gothic, fluoresce like a white shirt in a disco. 
 Then he feeds the pictures into a computer, which cuts each picture into 1m tiny elements and records the precise shade of grey of each one. 
 The later text, much darker in the picture than the earlier one, can then be edited out of this digital image. 
 The earlier text thus revealed can be made more legible by a program that enhances the contrast, picking out the Gothic letters from the surrounding gloom. 
 So far, Dr Marchand has recovered nine biblical fragments in Gothic. 
 He has also revealed notes written in the margins of Latin manuscripts by Gothic hands and then rubbed out by later owners. 
 From these sources he is piecing together the vocabulary and grammar of Gothic. 
 Rather than recovering lost languages, John Friedman is recovering lost lives. 
 The scribes he studies worked in the 14th century &mdash; 800 years after Dr Marchand's Goths had relinquished Italy. 
 He is trying to trace their careers through their handwriting. 
 Identifying handwriting is normally a tortuous and time-consuming job, not to be undertaken lightly. 
 If it could be computerised, anonymous documents could be sifted to find those with the same author. 
 Dr Friedman has put parts of 200 manuscripts from northern England into his computer. 
 The machine can be made to look for common letter groups and then display them, massively magnified, together on the screen, helping a human expert to decide if they match. 
 Dr Friedman wants to make the computer more than just a clever magnifying glass. 
 By using a statistical technique called cluster analysis, he hopes to teach the machine how to make the matches for itself. 
 Quill-written characters consist of a series of more-or-less straight strokes, simple enough for a computer to turn into numbers and analyse, but complex enough to vary from scribe to scribe. 
 With the aid of rare signed texts, Dr Friedman is programming his computer to recognise the shapes of strokes in the hands of various writers. 
 It can already distinguish the signed texts of a single author from those written by other scribes. 
 When it, or its descendants, learns to classify anonymous documents, the copiers of the Middle Ages will be revealed by the data-processors of today. 
 TYPOGRAPHY BRIEF 
 TYPOGRAPHY BRIEF 
 The changed face of type 
 This week The Economist appears for the first time in its own new type-face &mdash; known as Ecotype. 
 It could never have been designed but for a revolution that has shaken up one of the world's oldest industries 
 TYPOGRAPHY was once an arcane discipline, with its own system of measurement, its own language and a technology that depended largely upon pencil and paper. 
 But the computer has revolutionised the art. 
 Within the past six years, the business of making text presentable has become everybody's concern. 
 The authors of reports and memoranda are now expected to decide how what they have written should appear to the reader. 
 Page make-up and graphics programs allow anybody able to use a computer to change a type-face or its size, to paste in pictures and to lay out the text in almost any manner. 
 In a trice, office machines can set the type and print it out in fine detail. 
 Technical standards unite this cottage industry of desk-top publishing with the presses of newspaper and magazine publishers. 
 This means that, to an author sitting at the keyboard of, say, an Apple Macintosh, the biggest of printing presses has become no harder to instruct than a laser-printer down the corridor. 
 The programs that have brought typesetting to the desk top have also made it less laborious and costly than ever before to design an entirely new type-face. 
 Moreover, it will not be long before common-or-garden programs can vary the weight and shape of letters instantaneously, as well as setting them on the page. 
 This was once a world reserved for specialists. 
 In the new anarchy, the author is becoming both compositor and type designer too. 
 The conservative radical 
 The technology of printing now has virtually nothing in common with the wooden presses and lead type of 15th-century pioneers like Johannes Gutenberg or Nicolas Jensen. 
 Yet, curiously, the science that has changed the presentation of text has brought it back under the control of a single person, just as it was when the first presses printed. 
 The revolution in printing has remained invisible to most people. 
 This is partly because its product, type, must be familiar if it is to be legible. 
 That makes readers naturally conservative, sometimes to the point of absurdity. 
 In 1479 Cardinal Giuliano della Rovere, later to become Pope Julius II, asked his scribes to copy out by hand a printed text of Appian's &bquo;Civil Wars&equo;. 
 Gutenberg tried to mimic the gothic calligraphy of his own time when he invented modern printing, because anything else would have been hard to read. 
 Gothic type remained widely used in Germany and Austria until the 1930s. 
 Similarly, when designing type-faces in Renaissance Venice for new editions of classical literature, Jensen and Griffo (who worked for Aldus Manutius, the first modern publisher and editor) both used the hand-written roman letter-forms of the humanists as their models. 
 Legal, medical and religious texts, however, were still printed in gothic faces. 
 Italic type came from the rapid, flowing writing of chancery scribes. 
 Thus calligraphy was the source of the ornaments which still decorate most type-faces, despite efforts earlier this century to dispose of them (see box). 
 These earliest faces and the French versions of them, which were derived during the first half of the 16th century by type-founders such as Garamond, remain the models for most type-faces. 
 The question is not why readers should be conservative, but why type-founders should have found so many excuses to redraw the alphabet. 
 There are at least 10,000 type-faces in existence; nobody knows exactly how many. 
 No more than a few hundred of these are used with any frequency. 
 Fewer than 50 are used outside advertising &mdash; and most of these bear strong resemblances to each other. 
 It is no accident that the explosion in the number of type-faces began towards the end of the 19th century when advertising and branded goods came into their own. 
 You need only to look at commercial copy or displays to see how powerfully a type-face complements the message it is conveying. 
 A sign warning trespassers printed in the copper-plate script normally reserved for wedding invitations would inhibit nobody. 
 The need to catch the attention of browsers and quickly to tell them that Parker pens are elegant, or that Toshiba personal computers are high-tech, has spawned most of these &bquo;display&equo; faces. 
 They tend to be be used sparingly, because they are tiring and distracting to read. 
 Type and technology 
 Technology is a more subtle spur for change. 
 New ways of printing make unforeseen demands upon an old face, while at the same time giving the typographer scope to design problems away. 
 This applies particularly to those types, like Ecotype, which are meant for  continuous  reading. 
 For example, some of the finer type-faces are corrupted by cheap, popular computer printers. 
 Bits of some letters are lost; the strokes of others become uneven; spaces are filled in by toner, making an e, say, indistinguishable from an o. 
 Such difficulties are not restricted to desk-top publishing. 
 At one time The Economist was printed in England and shipped around the world. 
 It is now sent by facsimile, every Thursday, to each of our four (soon to be five) printing sites in three continents and distributed from there. 
 Our former type-face, called Goudy Old Style, was designed in America in 1915, before the facsimile had been dreamed of. 
 Even a sophisticated fax can corrupt its letters. 
 Hence the unevenness of some of our issues. 
 Fortunately, technology often brings solutions to its own problems. 
 The technical trick that has made cheap laser-printers possible has also brought type design and typesetting to a far wider market. 
 It was commercialised in California by two entrepreneurs called John Warnock and Charles Geschke, who formed a company in 1982, called Adobe. 
 But before looking at the idea behind this revolution in printing, consider its consequences. 
 The previous generation of photo-typesetters cost anything up to &dollar;300,000 each. 
 Today, because the personal computer and laser-printer are mass-produced and work using cheap electronic components, anybody can publish text of almost professional quality for an investment of only &dollar;3,000. 
 Adobe reckons that by the end of 1990 more than 40m copies of its type-faces were in use. 
 This year alone 3m laser-printers will be sold, according to BIS Strategic Decisions, a consultancy. 
 Each machine comes with a standard set of at least 35 different type-faces. 
 More faces can easily be loaded on to a machine, like stocking a larder with exotic ingredients. 
 Far from banishing paper from the office, the computer and its attachments have made memos, brochures, reports and forms simpler and cheaper to produce. 
 The advantages for the printing industry have been enormous. 
 True, the actual business of typesetting has been lost by printers to desk-top publishers. 
 Against that, though, each type-face that a software company has title to stands to be widely licensed, and the demand for professional printing from computer-owning desk-top publishers has become much greater. 
 If this revolution has a name, it is PostScript, the technical standard that Adobe invented, which many competing computer makers, laser-printer makers and the publishing industry have settled on. 
 And if PostScript has a leading light, it is Pierre B&eacute;zier, a French mathematician. 
 Mr B&eacute;zier was the first to realise how to write a description of a curved surface that did away with lists of cumbersome mathematical co-ordinates. 
 It was a piece of pure mathematics that could easily be applied to letters and pictures on a page. 
 Better with B&eacute;zier 
 Imagine laying a piece of graph paper over an enlarged copy of a character and making a list of all the squares which it covers. 
 Computerised composition and the previous generation of photo-typesetters, which came into their own during the 1970s, described characters in this way, known as &bquo;bit-mapping&equo;. 
 The trouble with bit maps is that they are inflexible and expensive. 
 This was partly because each brand of typesetting machine tended to have a different way of preparing the bit-map, but it also had to do with the very nature of the technique: rotating the letters, making them larger or smaller, or altering them in any way involved a new bit-map. 
 Mr B&eacute;zier saw that a shape &mdash; any shape &mdash; could be described as a set of mathematical equations to fit the series of curves which formed its outline. 
 These equations can be scaled up or down, rotated, or anything else, without having to redefine them. 
 Computer programs can take care of the mathematics, as long as the designer tells them what shape he wants. 
 What is more, a technical standard for representing letters which uses B&eacute;zier curves does not depend on any characteristic of the machine which is doing the printing: the same set of curves can be used to drive a professional typesetter or a cheap laser-printer (though most fonts have to include &bquo;hints&equo; which help coarser machines interpret the curves). 
 Type designers also benefit. 
 The development of new fonts used to be the business of companies like Linotype and Monotype, which built typesetters with proprietary technology. 
 These type-faces encouraged customers to buy a particular make of machine. 
 Now there is an open technical standard. 
 Anybody can buy type-design programs like Fonto-grapher and FontStudio off the shelf and create new type-faces, confident that his design can be sold to the owner of almost any laser-printer or typesetter. 
 The design process is also more simple too. 
 A designer need only draw on a computer screen the letter forms that he likes and the machine will convert them automatically into B&eacute;zier curves. 
 Laser-printers can instantly show him how his efforts appear in print. 
 Ten years ago Eiichi Kono, a Japanese designer based in London, spent 18 months redrawing the face used on the London Underground. 
 Every letter had to be drawn, photographed, reduced, revised and photographed again. 
 He reckons that today the same job would take only three months. 
 Six years ago The Economist thought about introducing a face called Excelsior Insertio into the paper. 
 It would have cost &dollar;110,000 to produce the appropriate bit-maps for our former typesetter. 
 Because of PostScript, nine fonts of an entirely new type-face, Ecotype, were produced for roughly half of that cost (see box). 
 Soon PostScript (and one of its rivals, called TrueType, which is the brain-child of Apple and Microsoft, two suppliers to the personal-computer market) will be added to the nuts and bolts of computers so that their screens accurately display the page about to be printed. 
 Already programs are being written that will automatically define the amount of white space each character of a new type-face needs in which to breathe, if it is not to look cramped (at the moment this time-consuming procedure is done by eye). 
 Meanwhile, the price of laser-printers halves every four years or so, and their resolution and speed continue to improve. 
 Colour-printing will soon become almost universal. 
 Typewriter script, which became the world's most familiar type-face between 1867 and 1985, will have taken less than a decade to change from a staple into a mannerism.  
 Anatomy of a letter 
 TYPE design still reflects its origins as a craft. 
 The first typographers were silver- and goldsmiths: their skill working with metals was needed to produce moulds from which lead characters could be cast. 
 Even though letters are no longer cast, type-setters still talk of the &bquo;leading&equo; (white space) between lines. 
 The top row of letters shows an example of the early 15th- and 16th-century seriffed faces, which were the model for many later type founders. 
 &bquo;Modern&equo; type-faces, first designed in the 18th century by men like Bodoni and Baskerville, emphasised the contrast between the thick and thin parts of a letter. 
 In the 1920s and 1930s designers dispensed with ornamentation. 
 This led to sanserif type-faces, like Gill Sans. 
 Though many people find sanserif faces attractive, almost every experiment suggests that text set in them is harder to read than serif faces.  
 How to get a face lift 
 HE first letter that a typographer designs is the o. 
 The slope of the o determines the character of the rest of the face: the more it leans towards the left, the less room the letter takes up and the denser the face as a whole. 
 The designer uses the o to help design the other letters: first to define the shoulder of the n; from that, the h. 
 Join up the bottom of the h to make a b, and then flip it over to make the d, the p and the q. 
 Next the designer moves on to the exceptions, such as a and s, all the while bearing in mind the axis he established with the first letter he designed. 
 Because programs can store any segment of any letter, this process is far less laborious than it once was, though it still took around three months for the nine fonts which make up the Ecotype family. 
 Another eight months was devoted to working out the spacing between characters. 
 Then came all the fine-tuning and the test runs, which took roughly three months to complete. 
 No typeface suits all uses. 
 Ideally a page should look evenly grey, so that the eye glides over it with as little distraction from the writing as possible. 
 Ecotype is designed with the newspaper in mind. 
 It is more robust in form than many faces, which will help it withstand facsimile transmission. 
 Because this newspaper commonly uses numbers, italics and small capitals (in which abbreviated names, such as UN, appear), special care has been taken to make these unobtrusive. 
 BUSINESS THIS WEEK 
 Opportunity costs 
 The United States widened its rift with the World Bank when it rejected a compromise on a capital increase for the International Finance Corporation, the arm of the Bank that deals directly with the private sector. 
 America wants the Bank as a whole to shift its attention to private enterprise. 
 The Federal Reserve's Alan Greenspan said the Fed would do what it could to ease America's credit crunch. 
 Along with other agencies, it would try to remove rules that impeded increased bank lending. 
 Five South American presidents signed an accord to resurrect an Andean free-trade zone by the end of 1995, more than 20 years after it was set up. 
 Responding to other free-trade zones that have been set up in the region, Bolivia, Colombia, Venezuela, Peru and Ecuador will progressively reduce tariffs and other regional trade barriers. 
 Lunchtime O'Business 
 Western Germany tops the European league for business spending at &dollar;31.9 billion. 
 The average British businessman doesn't stint on wining and dining, spending &pound;1,940 (&dollar;3,370) a year. 
 Though they stay at good hotels (&dollar;2,150 a year), Britons prefer not to travel abroad. 
 Going for a mere &dollar;50m, the Empire State Building is up for sale. 
 King Kong's climbing frame is not such a bargain though; complex leases will keep any new owner's hands off the property until 2076, America's tercentenary. 
 Faced with having to raise cash to reorganise, LTV, under protection from its creditors, is to sell off its Dallas-based aerospace and defence subsidiary for at least &dollar;500m. 
 Martin Llowarch, chief executive of recession-hit British Steel, resigned after more than 20 years with the company. 
 It had been widely assumed that he would succeed Sir Robert Scholey when the chairman steps down. 
 British leisure group Brent Walker, in debt to its banks to the tune of &pound;1.2 billion (&dollar;2.1 billion), announced a year-end loss of &pound;256m, with further losses to come this year. 
 But the company is confident the banks will keep it from bankruptcy by accepting a reorganisation plan. 
 Intent on reducing costs by around &dollar;400m, Apple Computer is considering sacking around a tenth of its 15,600 workers. 
 Sharp cuts in its prices in the autumn doubled its market share, but lowered profits. 
 Bucking the chemicals-industry trend, and in its first full year since demerging its textiles businesses, Britain's Courtaulds announced an 11% profit increase to &pound;186.3m (&dollar;344m) for the year to March. 
 It made a hefty restructuring provision, indicating more disposals. 
 Germany still has the world's most expensive industrial electricity, with Italy not far behind. 
 Italy's prices went up 14% last year, more than twice the rate of inflation. 
 Wings and wheels 
 The profits of British Airways plunged for the year ending in March. 
 Recession and the Gulf war wiped 62% off pre-tax profits, reducing them to &pound;130m (&dollar;240m) from 1989's &pound;345m. 
 With higher-fare payers slow to return, BA expects further losses in a normally buoyant first quarter. 
 The dispute between Nissan Motor of Japan and Nissan UK, its privately owned British distributor, must be settled by arbitration in Japan, the British high court ruled. 
 The Japanese car maker has cancelled Nissan UK's sole right to distribute Nissan vehicles in Britain. 
 In the first year-on-year increase since last July, West European car sales rose for April by 8.4% to 1.3m, compared with April 1990. 
 The demand for new cars in unified Germany is strong. 
 Renault and Volvo, partners in a carmaking alliance, announced poor quarterly results. 
 Renault's market share is shrinking; Volvo's car business is still losing money. 
 City limits 
 Takeo Masuno, president of Japan's Kyowa Saikama Bank, resigned. 
 The bank lent money to a speculator charged with extortion. 
 London securities houses had their worst year ever in 1990, with 3,000 job cuts and losses of &pound;353m (&dollar;630m), compared with a &pound;500m profit in 1989. 
 To help the New York Stock Exchange's slipping share of global trading in equities, the Securities and Exchange Commission is to allow after-hours trading for a two-year trial period from June 13th. 
 Jersey-based bank, TSB Channel Islands, 51%-owned by the TSB Group, called in the police after discovering &bquo;irregularities&equo; linked with foreign-exchange dealings. 
 The London stock exchange has announced that Taurus, its new and overdue paperless settlement system for shares, will be launched in May 1992. 
 Dial for profit 
 BT, Britain's biggest telecommunications company, saw a 14.2% increase in pre-tax profits to &pound;3.1 billion (&dollar;5.7 billion) for the year to March 1991, on sales of &pound;13 billion, thanks, it says, to better cost controls. 
 ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL INDICATORS 
 OUTPUT, DEMAND AND JOBS 
 Britain's real GDP fell in the first quarter, the third drop in a row, leaving it 2.5% down on a year ago. 
 Its industrial output also fell, by 3.5% in the 12 months to March. 
 Over the same period French industrial production rose 1.9%, but Sweden's output fell 2.1%. 
 The number of jobless in Britain rose in April for the 13th consecutive month, bringing the unemployment rate to 7.6%. 
 Holland's jobless rate fell to 4.7% in March. 
 British retail sales plunged 3.5% in April, a fall of 2.4% from a year earlier. 
 PRICES AND WAGES 
 Britain's 12-month rate of consumer-price inflation fell to 6.4% in April, its lowest for more than two years. 
 In the same month Sweden's inflation rate rose to 10.9%, the highest in our table; Holland's rate remained at 2.6%. 
 Japan's wholesale prices edged up by just 0.1% in the year to April, and Swiss producer prices fell 0.1%. 
 British workers received a 9.0% pay rise in 12 months to March, equivalent to a real increase of 0.7%.  
 The following paragraph does not appear in the printed version 
 HOUSEBUILDING A good leading indicator of economic activity is residential construction. 
 As interest rates rise, housing starts fall, signalling a downturn; later, a revival of housing starts usually precedes the recovery. 
 In all four countries shown in the chart, starts fell in the last quarter of 1990. 
 In America, slow population growth means that housing starts have been falling for years. 
 Even so, the figures show no end to the recession: starts fell by 36% during the past year, and are still dropping. 
 Britain's figures, belying most other recent indicators, are less gloomy: though hugely down on 1988, its housing starts touched bottom months ago. 
 Japan and western Germany are in much better shape. 
 Starts in both those countries are at levels close to those of a 
 End of unprinted paragraph 
 IRELAND 
 The Irish economy has achieved an impressive hat-trick in recent years: strong growth (real GDP grew by an average of 5% in 1989 and 1990); low inflation (now less than 3%); and a current-account surplus. 
 The black spot is its unemployment rate of 14%, which is more than double the OECD average. 
 The Irish government has reduced its borrowing requirement from 19% of GDP in 1980&ndash;84 to 3% of GDP last year. 
 Its public debt has fallen to 111% of GDP from a peak of 131% in 1987, but this is still the second highest (behind Belgium) of any industrial economy. 
 The OECD, in its latest review of Ireland, forecasts that growth will fall by more than half this year, to 2.2%; and it worries that the government's hard-headed policies are going soft. 
 COMMODITY PRICE INDEX 
 The worst may soon be over for Australian wool farmers. 
 The government has been forced to release 100,000 bales of wool from its 4.7m stockpile to cover a shortfall in supplies at auction following a recent surge in consumer demand. 
 Australian wool prices have jumped 17% in two weeks and are now only 18% below the reserve price of A&dollar;7 a kilo that was abandoned in February. 
 (Prices then plunged 40% in the first free-market auctions for 17 years.) 
 Last week 96% of the 60,000 bales on offer were snapped up; Japanese buyers accounted for 35%. 
 Since February buyers have taken up 1.5m bales, double the amount in the same period last year.  
 CURRENCIES 
 The best way to measure shifts in a country's exchange rate is to use its trade-weighted (or &bquo;effective&equo;) exchange rate. 
 This is an index of the average of all its bilateral rates, weighted by the pattern of trade with other countries. 
 For instance, other EMS currencies account for 72% of the French franc's trade-weighted basket, and the dollar accounts for 44% of the yen's. 
 As EMS currencies are pegged to each other and account for a big part of each other's baskets, the stability of the trade-weighted values of the French franc and the D-mark compared with the dollar and the yen is no surprise. 
 Despite its recent rally, the dollar's trade-weighted exchange rate is still 34% lower than in 1985. 
 The yen has been the strongest currency over the past six years: its trade-weighted index is about 35% higher than in 1985. 
 TRADE, EXCHANGE RATES AND RESERVES 
 America's visible-trade deficit narrowed to &dollar;4.0 billion in March, thanks to lower imports; it was the smallest monthly deficit for nearly eight years. 
 Canada's 12-month trade surplus rose in March to &dollar;9.9 billion, three times its size a year ago. 
 Sweden's trade surplus also rose, to &dollar;4.5 billion in the year to April. 
 The yen's trade-weighted value gained 1.0% during the week. 
 MONEY AND INTEREST RATES 
 America's broad-money growth slowed to 2.2% in the year to April. 
 In the same period Japan's broad money supply grew by 5.1%, compared with growth of 13% a year earlier. 
 Australian banks cut their prime lending rates from 15% to 14.25%. 
 LEADERS 
 Should trade go green? 
 How to stop protection for the environment becoming protectionism in trade 
 DEEP-green environmentalists are nervous of free trade. 
 They see in it a threat to the right of each country to protect viridian quirks: quaint old farming practices, bottle-recycling schemes that depend on local breweries or milkmen. 
 In fact, freer trade can be a friend to greenery. 
 If third-world countries could export more textiles, their need to sell their timber would be less desperate; if Europe's farmers were not protected, land values would be lower, so they would have less incentive to farm intensively. 
 But, as next week's meeting of OECD environment ministers will acknowledge, as some countries grow greener the interests of the environment and the interests of freer trade may seem to diverge. 
 The line between protecting the environment and protectionism of a more familiar kind can indeed be worryingly thin. 
 If, say, Dutch voters want a tax on non-refillable drinks containers, surely they should have their way &mdash; even if, in effect, such a tax favours local bottlers. 
 But what if America bans wine containing traces of a pesticide banned there but used in Europe? 
 Or if Japan penalises large cars, which are mainly foreign-built? 
 Such exceptions to the essence of free trade need careful monitoring, by a body like GATT. 
 Some guiding principles are beyond doubt. 
 Damage to trade will be minimised if many countries agree to harmonise their environmental rules. 
 Those rules should anyway be non-discriminatory &mdash; so if a government taxes imported gas-guzzlers, it should tax home-made ones, too. 
 And ardent environmentalists should keep a sense of proportion. 
 It would clearly be wrong to restrict all imports from a country which broke one particular environmental agreement. 
 Beyond that, the going gets tougher. 
 Should governments be free to ban imports of things they fear will become extinct? 
 Before doing so, they ought to ask whether a well-policed market could bring better results. 
 If countries with dwindling elephant herds were allowed to sell a small quantity of ivory each year, they would earn foreign exchange, and thus have an incentive to conserve their herds. 
 And what about imports of toxic waste? 
 It is not obvious that governments should always be free to ban them. 
 As companies grow cleverer at finding new uses for the by-products of industrial processes, today's toxic waste becomes tomorrow's chemical feedstock. 
 If chemistry changes faster than legal definitions, an international agreement designed to protect a country's citizens may end up protecting its manufacturers. 
 Harmonising green penalties on manufacturing processes will generally be wrong. 
 If one country's chemical companies face tough standards for water discharges, that is no reason to penalise imports of chemicals from other countries that impose weaker standards. 
 Different standards may be environmentally appropriate: a smoking chimney in the Australian outback does less harm than one in the Ruhr valley. 
 Free trade or free riders 
 More and more, the environmental harm that ministers discuss is global or regional, not national. 
 Acid rain and marine pollution hurt neighbouring countries; ozone depletion and global warming threaten the entire planet. 
 Just after the environment ministers return from the OECD, their officials go to Washington to start negotiating a treaty on climate change. 
 Their toughest problem will be that of free riders (see page 71): countries that want to enjoy the benefits of an agreement without curbing their own output of global-warming gases. 
 Free-riders risk damaging not just their own climates but, perhaps irreversibly, the climate of every other country &mdash; indeed, the very existence of some tiny countries. 
 On ozone depletion, which harms everyone, the Montreal agreement accepted that trade sanctions could be used against free riders. 
 It provided for a ban on imports of ozone-gobbling chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs), of products containing CFCs, and of products which used CFCs in their manufacturing process. 
 Extended to a climate-change agreement, however, such a rule would be far trickier. 
 The main global-warming gas, after all, is carbon dioxide, given off mainly by burning fossil fuels. 
 If some countries agree to curb the fossil fuels they burn, ought they to penalise the energy-intensive products of free-riders that do not? 
 Only in the last resort, under careful international policing and after all other attempts at persuasion have been exhausted. 
 Without those heavy caveats, greenery will become one more excuse to foul up trade.  
 Futures in the money museum 
 The growth of the global Zero Overspending Organisation has brought low a once proud species 
 PITY those poor currency dealers. 
 The signing, in the ZOO framework, of the World Monetary and Banking Assimilation Treaty (WOMBAT) has written them out of history. 
 Like Russian aristocrats after the revolution (and, of course, before the restoration), many now drive cabs or wait in restaurants. 
 Some have adapted, with commendable ease, back to their ancestral profession, and sell fruit from market barrows. 
 They were doomed from the day &mdash; admittedly belated &mdash; in 2007 when the European Community's economic and monetary union (EMU) became reality and its 29 currencies merged in the ecu. 
 Soon America was clamouring for the dollar to be let in: its burden of debt to oil-rich countries, which since the late 1990s had refused payment in dollars, had become too great. 
 Then the yen joined the queue. 
 It had survived Japan's notorious propensity to consume and the idleness of its workers, with the huge trade deficit in cars and electronics that these had brought. 
 But it could not resist the collapse of business confidence after leading politicians were found to have refused corporate bribes on moral grounds. 
 In 2015 the Treaty of Atlantic and Pacific Investment Regions (TAPIR), cooked up by the EC's crafty Turkish president, duly brought the dollar and the yen into the ecu, and thus, automatically, the shekel and the tael of the Chinese Imperial Republic. 
 Some 4,000 of the 13,000 currency dealers who had flourished in the 1980s struggled on, trading the remaining independent currencies. 
 There was still money to be made arbitraging between the rial and the pula, the cedi and (until Argentina and Britain signed the bilateral Puerto Stanley AUK accord) the austral. 
 But their days were numbered. 
 One by one, governments gave up sovereignty for stability and acceded to the TAPIR. 
 By 2040 only a handful of currency dealers remained, huddled in tatty offices in Tirana and Ulan Bator, trading the lek against the tugrik. 
 The rest had left finance, bar a few who retrained for the burgeoning futures markets in right-to-pollute certificates and manual-job options. 
 Remember those? 
 Last week Frankfurt finalised the WOMBAT negotiations with Albania and Mongolia, and their currencies were absorbed into the Global Numismatic Unit (GNU), so named because one specimen was &bquo;minted&equo; (made in metallic hard-copy form) into what our grandmothers used to know as a &bquo;coin&equo;. 
 But the currency traders will not be forgotten. 
 In a corner of the London Museum of Financial History &mdash; blue-rinsed heads will remember it as the Bank of England &mdash; stands a glass case. 
 It contains a striped shirt, one towelling sock, now grubby, but still recognisably white, and several decayed strips of red material, thought to have had some connection with men's trousers. 
 Whatever trousers may have been. 
 Or indeed men.  
 Reform in year two 
 South Africa's President de Klerk must resist the temptation to by-pass the disorganised ANC 
 THIS time last year he unbanned black parties, suspended the death penalty and went on to free Nelson Mandela, the world's most famous political prisoner. 
 On February 1st, at the opening of South Africa's no-blacks parliament, President F.W. de Klerk will deal some more blows to what remains of apartheid. 
 He will probably announce the scrapping of residential segregation, and an end to blacks' exclusion from most South African land. 
 The world will applaud, and rightly press on with the lifting of sanctions. 
 But a glance at the Soviet Union should be enough to remind Mr de Klerk that it is far easier to dismantle his predecessors' oppressive structures than to build a new democracy in their place. 
 All last year the government promised that talks on a new constitution would start in early 1991. 
 It had every reason for haste. 
 Political violence was rampant, and still is: it cost at least 3,000 lives in 1990. 
 The longer the bloody transition is drawn out, the more damaging the effects on potential investors in South Africa. 
 Besides, many of the government's constitutional ideas are remarkably similar to those of Mr Mandela's African National Congress (ANC): both would apparently be happy with universal suffrage, proportional representation, and an independent judiciary to enforce a bill of rights. 
 Yet 1991 has arrived. 
 Unless Mr de Klerk's speech concedes more than expected, talks remain months away. 
 Rise above the muddle 
 The government and the ANC are bickering over the preconditions for negotiation &mdash; matters such as the bringing home of exiles and the release of political prisoners. 
 Mr de Klerk's people say the Congress is dragging its feet because it is too disorganised to talk. 
 After years of inactivity in exile, the ANC has difficulty doing anything fast. 
 It is unsure of its policies, and has been slow to recruit members and persuade them that the time for talks has come. 
 The contrast between sluggish ANC and dynamic ruling party is summed up in the fates of their old leaders, each of whom suffered a stroke in 1989. 
 Oliver Tambo staggers on as president of the ANC, though he is hardly strong enough to deliver a speech. 
 His counterpart, P.W. 
 Botha, was pretty swiftly dumped. 
 To keep morale up, the ANC plans to do what it does best: organise &bquo;mass action&equo;, including demonstrations next Friday, when Mr de Klerk announces his latest reforms. 
 This provocation contains a temptation for the president. 
 With foreigners applauding him, he may wonder whether he needs to worry about the disorganised ANC. 
 He may continue to insist that, if the ANC's exiles are not to be prosecuted when they come home, they must list their past crimes &mdash; even though this condition is delaying their return, and therefore the talks. 
 Why not, he may wonder, carry on with his unilateral reforms while letting the drive for give-and-take negotiations on the constitution fall into second place? 
 Because that would plunge the country deeper into violence. 
 With a meeting between Mr Mandela and Chief Buthelezi, the leader of the rival Inkatha Freedom Party, now in the offing, hopes have risen that the township violence may soon be over. 
 Yet those hopes could quickly be dashed. 
 Despite its internal disorder, the ANC remains quite capable of spreading chaos to every corner of the land. 
 White tribalists claim that the ANC lacks support beyond the Xhosa people, who are disproportionately represented at its head. 
 But polls suggest that it may be the most popular party within all the black linguistic groups; and the fighting in the mostly-Zulu province of Natal between the ANC and Inkatha shows that plenty of South Africa's 8m Zulus take the ANC's side. 
 To get talks with the ANC started, Mr de Klerk must do everything possible to free political prisoners and bring home refugees. 
 At the same time he must go on reassuring other parties &mdash; some of whom bloody-mindedly reject negotiation &mdash; that their views will be heard. 
 The president's unilateral reforms will achieve little if he does not talk to blacks.  
 My company, right or wrong 
 Whether to accept a takeover bid is a decision for shareholders, not for the board 
 IMAGINE that you buy a car from a local garage. 
 A few days later someone offers you nearly twice what you paid. 
 Thrilled, you agree to sell. 
 Suddenly the garage owner, whom you still employ to maintain the car, hauls you into court to block the sale. 
 The price is too low, he argues, and the new buyer is not a fit and proper custodian for this precious vehicle. 
 Sounds absurd? 
 This is pretty much what Charles Exley, chairman of NCR, is doing to his shareholders. 
 On December 5th American Telephone &amp; Telegraph (AT&amp;T) bid &dollar;6.1 billion for NCR, America's sixth-largest computer maker, after merger talks had turned into a shouting match. 
 Since then both firms have been stuck in court, while Ma Bell tries to get round a series of legal obstacles erected by Mr Exley and his board of directors. 
 On January 16th AT&amp;T claimed the owners of 70% of NCR shares had said they want to accept the firm's offer. 
 On January 21st it forwarded to NCR written requests from owners of 51% of the shares for a special shareholders' meeting, at which AT&amp;T will seek to oust the NCR board. 
 Nevertheless Mr Exley is determined to frustrate the bid. 
 In other words, he wants to make it legally impossible for the shareholders, who employ him, to sell their shares to the highest bidder. 
 This kind of legal legerdemain is one of the most damaging legacies of the takeover binge of the 1980s. 
 Opposed bids now elicit the emotive vocabulary of combat. 
 The &bquo;defending&equo; firm's use of any legal ploy, including &bquo;poison pills&equo; designed to make the acquisition indigestible, is cheerfully assumed to be fair. 
 Too many people have forgotten that a bid, even one opposed by directors, is simply an offer to buy shares, not a struggle to the death. 
 No one is compelled to sell. 
 No one should be compelled not to sell either. 
 Those general truths need to be seen in the context of this particular bid. 
 Ma Bell can hardly be described as a raider set on rape and pillage. 
 Indeed it says that it wants to hand its own computer business over to NCR's managers, and has pledged not to close the firm's factories or sack its workers as a result of the merger. 
 AT&amp;T makes the classic, albeit dubious, argument that telecoms and computer businesses fit together strategically. 
 Mr Exley has some good counter-arguments. 
 He points out that AT&amp;T's computer business has repeatedly failed, something which even AT&amp;T admits. 
 Combining it with the well-run NCR could merely produce a bigger failure. 
 Perhaps NCR's shareholders should agree with him. 
 But most of them do not &mdash; which is their right. 
 This makes Mr Exley's position distinctly odd. 
 He argues that AT&amp;T's &dollar;90-a-share bid is &bquo;grossly inadequate&equo;: strong language for shares that were trading for only &dollar;48 before AT&amp;T's interest became public. 
 He claims the shares are worth &dollar;125, though how he chose this number is a mystery. 
 Not content with putting his case, he is threatening to use NCR's poison pill to increase drastically the cost of the bid and to invoke an anti-takeover law in Maryland, where the firm is incorporated, that would freeze any bid for five years. 
 So AT&amp;T is trying to oust Mr Exley and his board, which includes some of the people it once hoped would run its own computer business. 
 Let the owners decide 
 Mr Exley is behaving as if NCR's directors, not its shareholders, are the real owners. 
 This is in character. 
 He has been a vocal champion of the occasionally fashionable view that a company should be run in the interests of &bquo;stakeholders&equo; &mdash; its employees, suppliers and customers, and the regions where a company operates. 
 In the long term, he argues correctly, this is in the shareholders' interest too. 
 But shareholders own the firm: the decision should be theirs. 
 Most of NCR's owners want to sell the company to AT&amp;T. 
 Besides, the only stakeholders with an indisputable interest in stopping the sale are NCR's top managers, who were careful to get the board to boost their own severance packages on the day Ma Bell made its bid. 
 The only other clear winners from a protracted contest would be both firms' lawyers.  
 The Yeltsin factor 
 How the reformers in the Soviet Union might still regroup and win 
 NO EMPIRE has ever shrunk without a fight. 
 Mikhail Gorbachev's Soviet Union had once seemed the enlightened exception, but now only proves the bloody rule. 
 The street battles of Vilnius and Riga show a brutal determination to keep the Soviet empire together. 
 Yet eventually, like other empires that outlive their time, from Charlemagne's to the Habsburgs', shrink it will. 
 The attempt to hold it together at gunpoint may succeed only in blowing the Soviet Union apart more violently. 
 Thus more is at issue than whether the Lithuanians, Latvians and Estonians should be allowed to go or be made to stay. 
 The struggle for control over the Baltic republics is rapidly being overtaken by a bigger struggle for power in the Soviet Union. 
 Although he has military might on his side and a readiness to use it, as reformist push meets reactionary shove the newly reactionary Mr Gorbachev is by no means certain to win. 
 This is not the first time Mr Gorbachev has shown his brutal streak. 
 But every time he has used force in the past &mdash; as in Azerbaijan a year ago &mdash; he has been able to portray himself as defender of both law and order. 
 This time it is different. 
 Whether he gave the command to open fire in Vilnius and Riga or is cynically refusing to condemn the thuggery of his troops in order to put pressure on the Baltic republics, he has taken the side of order against law, acting in defiance of those republics' legally elected parliaments. 
 If he can do it in the Baltic lands, he can do it elsewhere. 
 Now he talks of revoking some of the freedoms, including a freer press, that the Soviet parliament brought into being last year. 
 He may yet suspend parliament itself. 
 In the past, whenever he has erred on the side of too much order, the judgment inside the Soviet Union and outside has been that &bquo;Gorbachev is as good as we'll get&equo;. 
 The likeliest alternative always seemed to be worse. 
 But now Mr Gorbachev has made himself the unpalatable alternative. 
 Supporters from his reforming days have deserted him; some have denounced him. 
 In the past few months he has sided with those in the party and the army who have long wanted a crackdown. 
 Yet it is not clear how firmly they have sided with him. 
 It was Mr Gorbachev, after all, who got them into this mess. 
 Worse for them, whether they go on backing Mr Gorbachev or opt for some other tough guy, the rattle of gunfire has not had the intended effect. 
 In the Baltic republics it has pushed determined but otherwise peaceable people to defend themselves as best they can. 
 And it has galvanised others, such as Russia's president, Boris Yeltsin, to stand by them. 
 Mr Yeltsin is not everybody's idea of a hero. 
 Like Mr Gorbachev, he was once a party apparatchik. 
 He is a populist who is unfussy about which grievances he exploits to get attention. 
 Alongside some respectable advisers, he seems to attract a rabble of supporters more loyal to the man than to the cause. 
 And he has made a lot of easy promises that he has not yet had to keep. 
 Even so, Mr Yeltsin seems determined to keep the reformers' colours flying. 
 He has shown courage in coming to the defence of the Baltic republics. 
 He has stuck by radical plans for economic reform in Russia. 
 If a deal is eventually to be wrung out of a reluctant Kremlin to break the deadlock over the Baltic republics, much will depend on how much support Mr Yeltsin can muster. 
 The sort of Soviet Union we can do business with 
 Thanks to Mr Gorbachev's reforms, the reformers have some muscle. 
 Not only the Baltic republics but all the others too stand to lose from a crackdown. 
 They may not all want to leave the Soviet Union (indeed, whatever shape it takes in the future, Mr Yeltsin's Russia will expect to be leader of the pack), but neither do the union's supporters want to hand back the new economic and political freedoms that they have won. 
 Four republics &mdash; Russia, the Ukraine, Belorussia and Kazakhstan &mdash; have already agreed to negotiate a limited union treaty among themselves, which other republics can join if they wish. 
 Between them these four represent 80% of the Soviet people, a solid core of a new union. 
 But it is one thing to thumb your nose at Mr Gorbachev over the Kremlin wall, as many thousands did in a demonstration in Moscow last weekend. 
 Or to jeer at the discredited Baltic Communists who rode in behind the thugs, proclaimed themselves in charge in Lithuania and Latvia and then scuttled for cover. 
 It is quite another to stand defiantly in front of the guns and hold your ground. 
 The Yeltsin coalition is new and untested. 
 Its supporters in the streets may melt away at the first sign of trouble. 
 That is why it needs quickly to be made clear just how high the cost of a crackdown might be. 
 Neither party nor army is solid. 
 There are plenty of army officers, by no means all of them supporters of radical causes, who think the army should not be used to settle political arguments with the republics. 
 A determined show of political resistance from Mr Yeltsin and his supporters in other republics might help convince many old-fashioned Russian nationalists that hanging on to the Baltic republics is not worth a fight. 
 Western governments cannot intervene directly to support the reformers. 
 Neither should they encourage Soviet people, in the Baltic states or elsewhere, to take risks that they would not otherwise take. 
 This is an argument that the Soviet people must settle for themselves. 
 But if President Bush decides to go to Moscow next month for his planned summit meeting with Mr Gorbachev, he can deliver America's condemnation of the violence in person. 
 He can also make a point of talking to Mr Yeltsin and other republican leaders to offer them moral support. 
 Meanwhile the West can add to the cost of a crackdown. 
 The billions of dollars in aid promised to the Soviet economy should still be on offer: but only to a leader prepared to take the army out of politics and keep the promise of reform. 
 At home and abroad, Mr Gorbachev has an awful lot to lose from a fight.  
 Who's winning? 
 WARS in the Middle East do not finish after six days any more. 
 Yet, at the end of a week of alternating euphoria and gloom, the sober verdict so far must be that the military side of this war is going well for the allies. 
 The likeliest thing to go wrong is the politics, and even the politics is manageable unless the war drags on too long. 
 Why so confident? 
 On the military front there is still time for the war to turn bad, particularly when the ground battle is joined in earnest. 
 But the first week was one-sided. 
 Allied casualties amounted to a score of airmen killed or captured. 
 Although Iraq's losses are harder to assess, there is no doubt that the American-led coalition has dumped a huge tonnage of bombs inside both Iraq and Kuwait. 
 Not every bomb has hit its target, but in Baghdad &mdash; the only place western journalists have been able briefly to observe &mdash; many clearly did. 
 Even if progress is slower than expected, and it may not be, nothing that has happened so far gainsays General Colin Powell's claim after six days of fighting that the allies, unopposed in the air, are systematically dismantling Saddam Hussein's ability to wage war, and doing so at remarkably small cost to themselves. 
 A good beginning does not rule out a calamitous ending: that is the way of war. 
 Indeed, there are already some setbacks. 
 Hardly any Iraqi combat aircraft have been destroyed, which means that they may still try to intervene in the land battle, or to hit harder than Scud missiles can at Israel and Saudi Arabia. 
 But, outclassed and outnumbered, most will be destroyed as soon as they take to the air; and if they do not take to the air they do not matter. 
 As for Mr Hussein's chemical weapons, they could still inflict horrible injuries on the allies if they are used. 
 But at least they will take nobody by surprise. 
 They have been known about, and planned against, since the first allied troops started arriving in Arabia. 
 The allies' biggest visible flop at the outset of this war has been the failure to knock out the launchers of Iraq's Scud missiles. 
 General Norman Schwarzkopf rightly describes the military value of these missiles as negligible. 
 A week after he first lobbed Scuds into Tel Aviv, Mr Hussein had managed only to kill three elderly women. 
 Thus far, with help from its friends, Israel has shown impressive restraint. 
 Still, the Scuds matter. 
 The attacks on Israel &mdash; and the war in general &mdash; are making a deep impression on Iraq's neighbours and could yet detach the Arab members of the alliance. 
 The most direct risk of an Arab exit is an Israeli entry: the very response that Mr Hussein has been hoping for. 
 So far the Israelis have resisted the provocations, and maybe the alliance could stand it if even if their forbearance fails. 
 While the war continues, the danger of the Arab regimes on America's side changing sides is smaller than many outsiders fear. 
 The ruling families of Saudi Arabia and the smaller oildoms of the Arabian peninsula have staked their futures on American power. 
 They know that, if America fails, their own days are briskly numbered. 
 Egypt and Syria have a smaller stake in the war, but they also have sound pragmatic reasons for seeing off a rival. 
 Although some popular sentiment may go Mr Hussein's way, both regimes are efficiently repressive enough to keep public opinion buttoned up. 
 But the bombardment of Tel Aviv has exposed another split, one that could, in time, prove just as dangerous to the allies: the division between Arab governments and the people they govern. 
 Many Arabs, including many who are nominally members of the anti-Saddam coalition, cannot conceal their glee at the attacks on Israel. 
 The defence minister of Syria, which has sent a division of tanks to help Saudi Arabia, admits to having felt &bquo;overwhelming joy&equo; at the missile attacks on &bquo;occupied Palestine&equo;. 
 Tens of thousands of Jordanians and Algerians say they are eager to join the fight on Iraq's side. 
 Even Egyptians, whose soldiers may well be sent in on the allies' side, hate the spectacle of a fellow Muslim, a defier of Zionists, being shot up by America's whizz-bang weaponry. 
 They want Mr Hussein to lose, but do not want his army to crumble ignominiously, as their own did in 1967. 
 That would look too much like another Arab defeat at the hands of the West. 
 The world v Saddam, not America v the Arabs 
 All this is evidence, if any were needed, that the allies must tiptoe as carefully as possible in this region of broken pride and prickly sensitivities. 
 The trouble is that tiptoeing is desperately uncomfortable when you are trying to win a war at the same time. 
 It becomes virtually impossible when your enemy is trying to inflame every atavistic passion in order to defeat you. 
 Mr Hussein, previously secular, has now ordered the words Allahu Akbar (&bquo;God is great&equo;) to be embroidered on the Iraqi banner. 
 Not content with that, he has declared a jihad (holy war) against the infidels and asked all of the world's Muslims to join in. 
 Will they? 
 Probably not. 
 Because governments in the Middle East have a habit of declaring holy war at the drop of a hat, their people have learnt to give cautious answers to the call to arms. 
 Mr Hussein may declare Iraq's war against the allies to be a jihad, but Saudi Arabia returns the compliment, and has organised a fatwa (religious decree) to prove it. 
 The danger is in the longer run. 
 Americans, with no colonial history in the Middle East, tend to see the war against Mr Hussein as a police action against an international thug. 
 They are right, but they should expect no gratitude after it is over. 
 Even now the post-war Arab myth that this was a titanic clash of cultures and religions, of high-tech rich against low-tech poor, is taking root across the region. 
 The war needs to be won, and surely will be. 
 The worry is that it could release a host of uncontainable resentments. 
 That is a risk that has to be taken to defeat Saddam. 
 But the West should know that, however long it takes to end the battle against the Iraqi tyrant, it will take much longer to end the bitterness he has tapped in the unhappy Middle East. 
 START OF LETTERS SECTION 
 Gun-happy 
 Your article on crime in America (December 22nd) suggests that laws severely restricting access to firearms would somehow have the happy effect of bringing peace and tranquillity to the United States. 
 You note that the American murder rate is consistently four or five times worse than that suffered by West European countries and that 60% of American murders are committed with firearms. 
 Using the FBI's figures for 1989 of 8.7 murders per 100,000 citizens, the West European rate would be between 1.7 and 2.2 murders per 100,000. 
 The 40% of American murders committed without firearms scars the United States with a non-gun murder rate of 3.48 victims per 100,000, exceeding the total European rate. 
 You argue that either luck or strength is needed to kill without firearms &mdash; yet, in 1989 alone, 3,458 Americans were cut, slashed, or stabbed to death, and another 1,128 were bludgeoned to death. 
 More than 1,000 others were murdered with what the FBI calls &bquo;personal weapons&equo;; ie, hands, feet, fists. 
 Perhaps America is simply a more violent society after all.  
 Kennesaw, Georgia STEPHEN MCKELVEY 
 Little evidence supports your conclusion that &bquo;Reducing the number and use of handguns is the surest possible way of reducing the amount of violent crime.&equo; 
 In 1989, according to the FBI, Washington, DC, had 17 homicides per 100,000 population; New York city had 22.7. 
 By contrast, Burlington, Vermont, had 4.6, and Nashua, New Hampshire, just 3.4. 
 Both New York and Washington have far stricter gun controls than either Vermont or New Hampshire. 
 You state that &bquo;without a gun, the row in the bedroom would not end with a corpse.&equo; 
 Yet, in 1989, according to the FBI, only 15% of all murder victims were related to their killers; 39% were &bquo;acquainted&equo; with their murderers, but this figure would include, say, a drug dealer killed by a fellow gang member, or even a police officer murdered by a suspect whom he or she had once arrested. 
 Better schools and housing, and more jobs would all help America's crime  problem . 
 So would more police, speedier courts, and better prisons and drug-treatment programmes. 
 Some gun control (competence tests, licences for carrying handguns) makes sense. 
 But it will have little impact on crime and if it serves merely as a pretext for disarming honest citizens, it will prove a serious mistake.  
 New York ADAM KASANOF 
 You omit the influence of the coroner. 
 In England a death is reported to the coroner if a doctor is unable to certify that he is sure that death was caused by some disease. 
 The coroner orders an investigation, usually including a post-mortem examination and sometimes an inquest. 
 The coroner issues the death certificate, usually ascribing death to a disease found during the post-mortem examination. 
 This makes it difficult for a murder to go unrecognised and discourages those planning murders. 
 In Canada and the United States there are coroners, but they are rarely used. 
 It is much too easy to fail to recognise a murder for what it is.  
 Breadsall, Derbyshire D.A. 
 HOWELL 
 Selling Rushdie 
 Your leader about Salman Rushdie (January 5th) says: &bquo;His publishers fell into panic, most bookshops caved in.&equo; 
 This is incorrect. 
 All our bookshops continued to sell &bquo;The Satanic Verses&equo; and, with only a few exceptions where serious threats had been made, the book was always on display. 
 To my knowledge, the book was on display in nearly all independent bookshops. 
 It is quite inaccurate to say the publishers panicked. 
 They continued to keep the book in print and supply it. 
 &bquo;The Satanic Verses&equo; was readily available and on display in bookshops, and remained a bestseller for many months.  
 London SIMON HORNBY Chairman W H Smith Group 
 The value of devaluation 
 Your article &bquo;When devaluation breeds contempt&equo; (November 24th) gives a misleading impression of adjustment programmes supported by the World Bank. 
 First, the Bank does not advocate devaluations that lead to undervalued currencies. 
 Large real depreciations were needed during the 1980s to bring exchange rates back to equilibrium. 
 Second, the Bank has long recognised that adjustment takes time. 
 The change in relative prices brought about by devaluations may harm output in the short term, but this is offset by faster growth in the longer term. 
 The only alternative to devaluation is to make deeper cuts in domestic spending, which would result in higher social costs. 
 Third, the Bank emphasises that devaluations must be accompanied by other policies. 
 These include strict fiscal and monetary policies to avoid inflation; deregulation of domestic goods markets; reform of the trade regime; measures to remove constraints on factor employment, saving and investment, and to strengthen private and public institutions; and steps to protect the poor during the transition. 
 Your concern about the ability of commodity exporters to adjust in this way is understandable. 
 But remember that many of the East Asian &bquo;dragons&equo; were commodity exporters. 
 They successfully diversified their economies through structural reform and sound macroeconomic management. 
 They also prevented their currencies from becoming overvalued.  
 Washington, DC JOHANNES LINN Acting vice-president The World Bank 
 Polish joke 
 On a recent visit to Warsaw I found that many of the street names had been changed during the past year. 
 Generally, names of various &bquo;socialist heroes&equo; have been replaced by those of Polish patriots. 
 A somewhat more creative approach, however, was demonstrated in renaming the former &bquo;Street of the Red Army&equo;. 
 It is now &bquo;Sesame Street&equo;.  
 New Brunswick, New Jersey ALAN GOLDMAN 
 START OF BOOKS SECTION 
 The best listening 
 PARIS 
 APPROPRIATELY enough, Mozart-year sees the largest recording project in the history of the industry. 
 The Mozart Record Edition, in 45 volumes by Philips, will put into print all the master's works, even fragments previously unrecorded. 
 It includes performances by such great Mozartians as Sir Colin Davis and the late Belgian violinist, Arthur Grumiaux. 
 But by emphasising the newest recordings with the latest sound techniques by younger artists (who can thus effectively be marketed in the future), other great Mozartians like Clara Haskil and Igor Markevitch must languish in the back of the catalogue. 
 Decca is offering a more modest Mozart sampler of about a dozen compact discs. 
 Its publicity concentrates, as Philips's does, on artists who have recorded complete cycles of works: Christopher Hogwood's set of the symphonies, for example, or Vladimir Ashkenazy's complete piano concertos. 
 Apparently lost in the shuffle are the violin sonatas recorded 15 years ago by Radu Lupu with Szymon Goldberg, an astonishing violinist. 
 As a teenager, Goldberg was leader of the Berlin Philharmonic under Furtw&auml;ngler in the 1920s; in the 1970s he was still in fine form, and his recordings should surely have been re-released on this occasion. 
 Even more patchy is Deutsche Grammophon's &bquo;Mozart's Masterpieces,&equo; another set of reissues where the unwary consumer may find himself with the superb piano artistry of Maurizio Pollini for one concerto, but the rather less impressive playing of Friedrich Gulda for another. 
 The &bquo;Requiem&equo; and &bquo;Coronation Mass&equo; are heavily-laden late performances by Herbert von Karajan, a strange contrast with the splendidly vigorous treatment of other works by John Eliot Gardiner and Leonard Bernstein. 
 The best general advice for the consumer is to buy the masterpieces as Amadeus wrote them: one at a time, and with loving care. 
 Interested listeners might look to the less renowned record labels, such as Capriccio in Germany, which has issued a superb recording of Mozart songs by Mitsuko Shirai, a soprano, and her pianist-husband Hartmut Hoell. 
 And, last but not least, they might re-read the scores while listening. 
 Perhaps the most laudable project of the Mozart bicentenary is the publishing by Baerenreiter Verlag in Kassel of the complete musical scores in paperback, a 20-volume set at a reasonable price. 
 Unlike any interpretation, however persuasive, the notes on the page are, after all, what the man wrote.  
 What makes a European? 
 EUROPE: A HISTORY OF ITS PEOPLES. 
 By Jean-Baptiste Duroselle, translated by Richard Wayne. 
 Viking; 424 pages; &pound;25 
 &bquo;COMMITTED&equo; history is not something Jean-Baptiste Duroselle believes in, or so he says. 
 All the same, he has written a book committed to proving that Europeans ought to unite. 
 Their shared experiences over the past 2,000 years, he argues, bring them together more than their conflicts force them apart. 
 Published simultaneously in eight European languages (as part of a European initiative backed by Frederique Delouche, a banker), it is clearly intended to serve a purpose. 
 Europe is a peculiar continent. 
 Defined by its filigree shoreline to the west, its eastern limits are somewhat arbitrary if you accept, as Mr Duroselle appears to, de Gaulle's vision of a Europe stretching &bquo;from the Atlantic to the Urals&equo;. 
 Many of its countries are relatively small and it is geographically more diverse than any other continent. 
 Its peoples, the book argues, were from the earliest times a mish-mash of white races. 
 Long before there was any conscious thought of unity, there was shared experience. 
 In pre-historic times megalith-builders from Portugal to Denmark erected huge stone structures in place of simple burial grounds: symbols both of similar beliefs in some form of after-life and evidence of an extraordinary capacity to organise. 
 Later, the continent benefited from the culture of Greece and the political efficiency, law and administration of Rome. 
 The Judaeo-Christian influence introduced the notions of a single God and of man's equality in the eyes of that God. 
 Missionaries travelling throughout Western Europe established Latin as the lingua franca by the end of the seventh century. 
 Europeans, by contrast with the peoples of other continents, were to become noticeably more curious and impatient with the world as they found it, and more inclined to tamper with its workings. 
 For four centuries after the Renaissance, Europe &mdash; and only Europe &mdash; developed modern science, despite having once lagged behind the Arabs and the Chinese. 
 Europe was first to establish networks of cities, to set up universities, to allow discussion about reason versus faith, to reject both Caesaropapism and theocracy, to develop the idea of the balance of power, to introduce habeas corpus and the jury system. 
 The French Revolution left Europe with new notions of liberty and equality which, however, America took far more seriously than Europeans did. 
 Europe was first to industrialise and thereby throw up the indigent urban proletariat, who in their turn founded the first labour organisations which spawned Marxism and fascism, both truly European ideologies. 
 But Europe was split by nationalism, and by its own internal rivalries as local space ran out and European powers rushed for the colonies. 
 (In fact, Mr Duroselle seems almost to believe that the worst aspect of colonialism was the way it divided European nations that might otherwise have come together.) 
 And Europe was split by the attempts of those who sought to unite it by force. 
 Napoleon and Hitler gave European unity a bad name. 
 As a term, &bquo;Europe&equo; was first used in 732 at the Battle of Tours, when the armies fighting the Saracens were no longer made up simply of Christians. 
 But it was not until 1693 that William Penn first proposed a form of European union. 
 Others followed, among them Castlereagh, Victor Hugo, Nietzsche and a French foreign ministry memo of 1930 which referred to the &bquo;European Community&equo;. 
 (Ironically, the idea was rejected at the time by almost everyone, fearing for their sovereignty. 
 The enthusiastic ones included Bulgaria and Czechoslovakia which, a mere 18 years later, found themselves on the wrong side of the Iron Curtain to be eligible for membership.) 
 Post-war America was in favour of a united Europe to stand more firmly against the Soviet Union, and successive American administrations grew irritable with the Europeans for failing to believe that unity in Europe could be as simple as it was in America. 
 Mr Duroselle is cataloguing, first, a tendency for Europeans to be more similar than they are different, although their very diversity is what marks them out; and second, the various aspirations &mdash; if not actual attempts &mdash; to bring Europeans into conscious, and voluntary, union. 
 He makes a convincing case for links of various sorts and degrees between West European countries going back as much as 5,000 years, but his thesis has one weakness. 
 The book calls itself a history of the European peoples. 
 All the European peoples. 
 But there are moments when one is not sure whether Mr Duroselle has really made up his mind who belongs with the Europeans and who does not. 
 There is one noticeable omission in the cavalcade he has lined up to speak for Europe: Mikhail Gorbachev and his &bquo;common European house&equo;. 
 In November 1983 Milan Kundera wrote an essay for Le D&eacute;bat, in which he argued that Russia could never really be considered part of Europe because it had for so long been dominated by Caesaropapism, where the civil emperor is also the supreme religious leader. 
 Western Europe had wriggled out of that one by the end of the 11th century. 
 Mr Kundera was strongly attacked for his view, and Mr Duroselle appears to be avoiding the issue. 
 He does not begin to describe what the effect was on Russia of by-passing the Reformation, the Counter-reformation and the Enlightenment; instead, in an effort to be friendly, he mentions things Russian from time to time. 
 He must have started writing his book a long time ago. 
 The final chapter is no more than a scrappy addition with rather a lot of photographs of by now familiar faces from November 1989. 
 Where do these newly liberated countries (East Germany apart) fit into the picture? 
 With each other? 
 With Western Europe? 
 Or only on the fringes, allowed in after promises of exemplary behaviour? 
 And, once again, what about the Russians, whose literature and music have always been welcomed as thoroughly European? 
 For the sake of the stability of the continent, &bquo;bona fide&equo; Europeans ought to be sure what they think.  
 Central America 
 The enduring conquest 
 THE HERITAGE OF THE CONQUISTADORS. 
 By Samuel Stone. 
 University of Nebraska Press; 241 pages; &dollar;35 
 LONELY among the Indians whom they had subjugated, and whom they therefore feared, the Spanish squireens who settled in Central America almost five centuries ago kept themselves to themselves, and married their children to those of their friends. 
 The descendants of those alliances still run the region, and Samuel Stone (from Costa Rica) has the genealogical tables to prove it. 
 He argues, too, that the resolve of the settler families to keep control can help explain why Central America is a political, economic and cultural mess. 
 The conquistadors' descendants have often been challenged &mdash; from outside by British and then North American capitalists, from within by (to use the author's formulation) &bquo;the Communist Party or Arab and Jewish minorities&equo;. 
 Mr Stone argues that they have repelled both foreigners and foreign ideas; that liberalism was junked before it was given a chance to work, socialism implanted without a bourgeoisie, communism introduced without a proletariat. 
 It is more complicated than that, of course. 
 In Guatemala and Honduras there were large Indian populations, which the settlers coerced to clear and cultivate large estates. 
 Government relied on force, not justice, and still does so. 
 Farther south there were few natives to enslave. 
 Costa Rica's settlers had to till their own land, which limited the size of their estates. 
 Unthreatened by a brown majority, they developed the peaceable and democratic little state that Mr Stone is proud of. 
 Yet all but one of Costa Rica's 38 presidents, since it became independent in the 1840s, shared descent from a single conquistador, Cristobal de Alfaro; he was also a progenitor of seven presidents of next-door Nicaragua, two of El Salvador, and one each of Guatemala and of Honduras. 
 Most of these men, by intermarriage, were also descended from other conquistadors. 
 Alfaro's descendants in next-door Nicaragua include the Somoza family that ruled from 1933 to 1980, displacing their cousins, the Lacayos and the Chamorros, who had provided ten previous presidents. 
 The chain was briefly broken in the 1980s, when Nicaragua was run by the Ortega brothers, upstarts (on the wrong side of the blanket) from the post-Conquest &bquo;new aristocracy&equo;. 
 But it is back to normal now. 
 Since the election of 1990 the president is once again called Chamorro, her chef de cabinet (and son-in-law) Lacayo. 
 Outsiders behaved as if the Nicaraguan revolution were about ideology. 
 For its main participants it was more of a family row. 
 Mr Stone seems fond of the bizarre dynastic arrangements he studies, tending to deplore the rise of the Arab families who are transforming politics in Honduras (and, for that matter, in Ecuador and Argentina and Brazil). 
 He thinks it is a waste of time for foreigners to try to help change things in Central America. 
 If educated people without conquistador bloodlines can never rise far, it is no use giving scholarships. 
 Foreign aid to the public sector will be grabbed by grandee ministers; aid to the private sector will mostly help the grandees who run it. 
 But change is creeping in all the same. 
 Fundamentalist missionaries challenge the settlers' church. 
 Schools excite the ambitions of the Indians. 
 Elections have to be less bogus when supervised by Yankee foundations with cash and counsel. 
 Only one descendant of the conquistadors now runs a genuine, old-fashioned Latin American absolutism. 
 His name is Fidel Castro.  
 Wolfgang-san 
 TOKYO 
 COUNT on Japan to offer something a little different to the memory of Mozart. 
 One piece of memorabilia is a bottle of sake, &bquo;Mozart K.001&equo;, fermented to the strains of the master's music; the other is an unfinished Mozart symphony completed by a Japanese composer. 
 Back in 1987, the Mozarteum in Salzburg asked Shigeaki Saegusa whether he would like to complete Mozart's score for the &bquo;Sinfonia Concertante in A for Violin, Viola, Violoncello and Orchestra&equo;. 
 Mr Saegusa's first instinct was to refuse; he thought he could not do it justice. 
 Mozart had written only 50 of a proposed 415 bars of music, and had sketched in the outline of the melody for the next 80 bars. 
 The heart of the work was missing. 
 But the foundation asked him again, and he agreed to complete it. 
 Mr Saegusa calls the finished piece &bquo;an ode to Mozart from the Orient,&equo; explaining that the new music is his own, rather than a supplement to Mozart's. 
 Those who have seen it &mdash; it will not be heard until a concert in Salzburg in December &mdash; agree that it is a hybrid between Mozart's incomplete score and Mr Saegusa's style, based on principles of Japanese music. 
 In the new middle section a violin, a cello, and a viola play Mozart's melody while strings and a harp suggest the oriental music of the koto, an ancient stringed instrument, and the bamboo-reed sho. 
 Those unable to get to Salzburg &mdash; where an estimated 300,000 Japanese will be bound this year &mdash; may eventually listen to Mr Saegusa's m&eacute;lange in the Wave, a glossy modern building in the fashionable Roppongi district of Tokyo. 
 The Wave is dedicated to selling music. 
 On the fourth floor is Mozart House, a room which features 3,000&ndash;4,000 Mozart CDs, portraits of the maestro on the wall, and an Empire couch to sit on to listen to his music being played continually. 
 Everything but the couch is for sale.  
 What an anniversary should do for Mozart 
 From child to man 
 SALZBURG 
 ALMOST a year remains before the 200th anniversary of Mozart's death on December 5th. 
 Yet for months the world's promotions industry has been busy marking &mdash; and marketing &mdash; the event. 
 All is not lost; the mania is not an epidemic: this weekend (January 27th) is the 235th anniversary of the composer's birth, and only Britain's Radio 3 went overboard on it. 
 But throughout the year &mdash; grandly proclaimed as &bquo;Mozart Year&equo; by some kind of promotional General Will &mdash; the world will be in grave danger of suffering from surfeit. 
 It will be more difficult than ever to see the composer as he really was, and is. 
 Mozart is being promoted all over the world as the bewigged darling of the gods, the product of a golden age of innocence and delight. 
 The composer's father, Leopold, unwittingly started the rot over two centuries ago when he took the six-year-old Mozart to market, as it were, on the celebrated tour of Europe's courts and palaces. 
 To this day the world sees him that way. 
 His very name (zart is German for tender, delicate, graceful, even ethereal) adds fuel to the legend. 
 Although all epochs have helped themselves to this or that aspect of Mozart, all have over-emphasised the &bquo;charm&equo;. 
 The reason is clear: it sells products. 
 The image weighed on Mozart even during his lifetime. 
 At the age of 22 he wrote to his father from Paris: &bquo;What annoys me most is that these idiots in France still think I am seven years old, because that is when they first knew me.&equo; 
 It was an image that spread and took root everywhere, bringing with it a tradition of atrocious performances &mdash; sloppy, flat and prettifying &mdash; that lasted throughout his lifetime, for the entire 19th century and for too much of the 20th. 
 Eighteenth-century audiences were quite happy to be fed agreeable background music; it was their equivalent of muzak, played uniformly and without criticism. 
 In the 19th century a pall of dullness settled over the limited Mozart repertoire that was performed. 
 It was further weighed down when German literature seized on the &bquo;demonic&equo; in Mozart and press-ganged him into its own camp, and by a tendency to put a romantic sheen on performances, which replaced uniformity by even worse distortion. 
 But condescension was the general attitude. 
 Nietzsche summed it up: &bquo;Mozart, a delicate and lovable soul, but quite 18th-century, even when he is serious.&equo; 
 It was Gustav Mahler and Richard Strauss who had the insight and courage to start, at the turn of the century, the long process of discovery and purification which is leading to a redefinition of Mozart. 
 And yet, with honourable exceptions, the syrupy brand of Mozart still stalks (or rather, minces around) the concert halls and opera houses of the world. 
 To his credit, Sir Thomas Beecham never put up with it; nor did Karl B&ouml;hm, nor the Glyndebourne pioneers before and after the second world war. 
 But the 150th anniversary of Mozart's death in 1941 brought only eulogies of the standard old-fashioned kind (as well as some Nazi-inspired pan-Germanic accretions), and Mozart was still on his ornamental pedestal for the commemoration of his 200th birthday in 1956. 
 Yet something was stirring. 
 Wolfgang Hildesheimer's biography, which was one of the studies marking a sea-change in perceptions of Mozart, was published in 1977. 
 By that time, scholars in various countries were throwing new light on the composer's music, life and times, providing performers with new insights &mdash; and also making way for the populist boom that began with Peter Shaffer's play and film &bquo;Amadeus&equo;. 
 Milos Forman's film presented a new Mozart, foul-mouthed and barely sufferable; but still, essentially, a child. 
 The bicentenary year is an opportunity and a challenge, as well as a danger: an opportunity to take stock and to hear and see Mozart at his best, a challenge to clear away the sentimental cobwebs and let Mozart speak, but a danger that the world will be engulfed in mass-marketed whimsy. 
 The Austrian authorities in Vienna and Salzburg are at pains to contain the worst excesses, but there is no stopping the Mozart T-shirts, socks, toasters, puzzles, bottle-openers, Swatches, mayonnaise, cheese, scent, a K&ouml;chel cook book, a hamburger called Mozart and well over 100m marzipan-filled &bquo;Mozartkugeln&equo;. 
 A chamber-pot is said to be on offer with Mozart on the  outside  and Salieri inside; and in the bookshops, serious biographical and analytical works are well hidden under a catch-crop of sugary Mozart nostalgia. 
 As for commemorative musical events, some promoters jumped the gun by a year; others have been so keen not to be upstaged that January has already seen dozens of concerts. 
 Hundreds more will follow, prompting Mr Hildesheimer to suggest that the best commemoration would be not to perform Mozart at all until next year, so that everyone could realise what they had been missing. 
 Small hope of that. 
 The Lincoln Centre in New York plans to perform every note Mozart ever wrote; in Switzerland Lucerne is vying with Vienna to put on all his church music, spread over 46 events; Geneva will hear all his piano concertos in seven concerts. 
 Vienna's trump cards include concerts in the palaces where Mozart made music. 
 Apart from the well-known operas, to be given in full in all the main opera houses, the early ones will be appearing, notably in Nice but also elsewhere; in London the Barbican Centre's &bquo;Mozart 200&equo; promises an imaginative variety of events, including a billiards tournament. 
 And everywhere there are to be seminars on Mozartian themes and exhibitions, the most ambitious in Salzburg and Vienna. 
 Over the past 30 years, musicological, historical and biographical research have all led towards a new Mozart. 
 They have been helped by the spread of a non-reverential way of thinking. 
 The result is cleaner, brighter performances, often on contemporary instruments. 
 Although these are sometimes slavishly historical, or played at a frenetic tempo (as if over-eager to cast off the stately past), the benefits of such experiments are clear. 
 The best of today's Mozart (not easy to come by) sacrifices none of his classical elegance, but also contains the robustness and vigour that come from within the music. 
 Is it too much to hope that, in spite of the worst excesses of this year, Mozart will at last be allowed to grow up?  
 Japan and America 
 No yes-man 
 THE JAPAN THAT CAN SAY NO: WHY JAPAN WILL BE FIRST AMONG EQUALS. 
 By Shintaro Ishihara. 
 Simon &amp; Schuster; 158 pages; &dollar;18.95 
 GIVEN that Japan is America's closest ally in the Pacific, there is a remarkable amount of suspicion, contempt and even downright hatred between the two countries. 
 Into that briar patch in 1989 dropped a book, published in Japan and called &bquo;No&equo; to ieru Nihon&equo; (&bquo;The Japan that Can Say No&equo;) by a politician, Shintaro Ishihara, and the chairman of Sony, Akio Morita. 
 Calling on Japan to stand up for itself when dealing with America, the book was a huge success, selling more than 1m copies. 
 But in Washington it caused a nasty row. 
 The Pentagon made an unofficial translation, which did the rounds on Capitol Hill. 
 The book was treated like a declaration of war. 
 That notoriety explains why Simon &amp; Schuster paid &dollar;275,000 for the translation rights, the highest sum ever paid for a Japanese book. 
 It also explains why Mr Morita hastily withdrew his chapters of the book, for fear of the damage it might do to Sony's sales. 
 That left Mr Ishihara with just half of what was already a short book. 
 So, for the English edition, he has added five new chapters, consisting mostly of advice to America to balance his previous advice to Japan. 
 And it explains a painfully careful translation: to avoid accusations that the English version has been gelded, all changes have been marked with square brackets. 
 What remains puzzling is why the book should have been notorious at all. 
 Mr Ishihara is no more than an entertaining distraction in Japanese politics: a member of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party, but one with no power base and whose views count for little. 
 He made his name in the 1950s as a prize-winning and rather racy novelist. 
 As such he is popular, but not as an ideologue: with his late actor brother, Yujiro (known as Japan's James Dean), he formed one of the country's most glamorous families. 
 Perhaps it was Mr Morita's name that gave the book its bite? 
 This, too, is unlikely, for Mr Morita has long been a noisy critic of America and was saying nothing new. 
 Moreover, to any serious reader the book seems fourth-rate, at best. 
 The original part consists of a string of factual claims, many of which are quarter-truths or plain wrong. 
 He claims, for instance, that American missiles depend on microchips made in Japan: the truth is that although many are bought from Japan, they are a basic sort and thus replaceable. 
 He also claims that a dispute between the two countries in 1988&ndash;89 over a new Japanese fighter plane, the FSX, arose because America was afraid it would be too good and might be able to shoot down American aircraft. 
 In fact Americans (wrongly) wanted Japan to buy their fighters to narrow America's trade deficit. 
 There were also fears that Japan planned to do just what America does: use defence spending and research to help build a civil aerospace industry, and thus beat Boeing. 
 Yet to focus on the facts is to miss the point. 
 Mr Ishihara writes as a politician, giving his hunches rather than the fruits of real research. 
 These are that Japan now matters as much to America as America does to Japan, and that it would do both some good if Japan acted accordingly. 
 Unsurprising, perhaps, but in a country that for 40 years has acted like a poodle it is striking to find a Japanese suggesting that it now has the strength of a rottweiler. 
 It is also uncomfortable for those in range of the teeth.  
 Soviet history 
 Country boy makes half-good 
 KHRUSHCHEV REMEMBERS: THE GLASNOST TAPES. 
 Translated by Jerrold Schecter. 
 Little Brown; 219 pages; &pound;14.95 and &dollar;19.95 
 IN THE early Gorbachev years every public mention of Nikita Khrushchev's name was a thrill for thinking Russians and western Kremlin-watchers. 
 Not only had Khrushchev denounced Stalin's crimes; the new warriors of perestroika, including Mikhail Gorbachev himself, were for the most part the Khrushchev generation, whose youthful idealism had coincided with that small post-Stalin thaw. 
 Yet this book, filling in the gaps Khrushchev left when the bulk of his reminiscences were smuggled out to the West in the early 1970s, is the most depressing reading for Mr Gorbachev. 
 Time, these past 30 years, might just as well have stood still. 
 &bquo;There is apparently some great defect in our system,&equo; concluded Khrushchev from his pensioner's park bench as he compared what he saw of the capitalist West with the shoddy goods, poor food and massive waste of the supposed workers' paradise. 
 If only he could find the switch to throw or the knob to turn that would liberate the real potential of communism. 
 In power, it never occurred to him, just as it did not occur to Mr Gorbachev until it was too late, that it was the system itself that was rotten through and through. 
 The Soviet economy has gone from bad to chaos. 
 The memoirs, like the man, are a mixture of the comic, the naive and the knowing. 
 The Marx brothers might have shown more tolerance than Karl Marx for Stalin's antics: throwing food at guests unwise enough to nod off at table during his interminable late-night dinner parties, or racing round in meetings &bquo;cursing like a cab driver&equo;. 
 Khrushchev survived to recount his disgust in part because he was a self-taught country boy. 
 Stalin never imagined Khrushchev could succeed him. 
 That was only one of Stalin's mistakes. 
 Khrushchev could never forgive him for the cruelties and stupidities that brought Russia so close to defeat by Hitler. 
 Even as German troops attacked, orders came to forge swords from knives and to prepare petrol bombs to meet the advancing Wehrmacht; there were no rifles. 
 Those men who might have planned sensibly for the inevitable war with Germany had all been shot. 
 Marshal Voroshilov, the man who helped Stalin cut the Soviet army to pieces in the 1930s, is described as &bquo;the biggest bag of shit in the army&equo;. 
 Most extraordinary of all, in 1942 a despairing Stalin even offered to trade the Ukraine, Belorussia and parts of Russia itself for peace. 
 Hitler never bothered to reply. 
 Most of Khrushchev's political career was covered in the first two volumes, but some good titbits have been saved till last. 
 During the Cuban missile crisis, Fidel Castro wanted the Soviet Union to fire its nuclear weapons at America. 
 But, says Khrushchev, Mr Castro failed to understand that all the Soviet Union was trying to do was to deter America from invading Cuba. 
 Was it? 
 Nobody will know until glasnost unlocks more of the Soviet archives. 
 And anyway, after all those years as a non-person, who can begrudge Khrushchev his gloss on history?  
 Surrealism 
 Dali World 
 FOIX 
 SALVADOR DALI was a genius at self-promotion. 
 In Figueres, his Catalan hometown, he set up his own museum (which has also become his mausoleum since his death two years ago), with its own foundation to administer it. 
 Not even Dali, however, thought of designing a surrealist town and naming it after himself. 
 Others may be doing it for him. 
 Until the artist's death, the foundation consisted mainly of international personalities and members of his entourage, all named by him. 
 Pending a new appointment, its secretary is Francesc Verg&egrave;s, his former bank manager, who advised the ageing &bquo;Senor Dali&equo; &bquo;to spend his money but not to sell a painting unless he had to&equo;. 
 Thanks to this shrewd advice the Spanish state, the sole beneficiary of Dali's will, has inherited 183 paintings and hundreds of drawings, photographs and other objects &mdash; besides his house in Portlligat and Pubol castle, which he had bought for his wife Gala. 
 Of the 183 paintings, 56 are for Madrid's Reina Sofia Centre for Contemporary Art. 
 They include &bquo;Atomica Melancolica&equo;, &bquo;Invisible Man&equo;, &bquo;In Search of the Fourth Dimension&equo; and &bquo;The Great Masturbator&equo;, which the mayor of Figueres unsuccessfully tried to keep for his town. 
 The remaining works will be displayed alternately in Barcelona and Figueres. 
 The heart of Dalilandia will continue to be that &bquo;gigantic surrealist whole&equo; (to quote the artist), the &bquo;Teatre-Museu&equo;. 
 The museum was designed &bquo;to foster universal recognition of his genius&equo;; but behind the facade, adorned with eggs and loaves of bread, the paintings show the painter's particular love for the local landscape and coastline. 
 As Dali once said, &bquo;Where else but in my own town can the most extravagant and solid facets of my work endure?&equo; 
 Visitors seem to agree. 
 Numbers have risen from 135,000 in 1975 to 640,000 in 1990. 
 To cash in on this pilgrimage, the foundation is considering including the Portlligat house and Pubol castle in &bquo;Dali tours&equo;. 
 But the most ambitious financial venture is a project to build on the Catalan coast a holiday resort called Cosmo Dali, complete with a yacht harbour and leisure park. 
 The architecture is to be reminiscent of Dali's floppy watches, Venuses with drawers and rubber pianos, while other surrealist props that crowd his paintings will inspire sculptures and park entertainments. 
 Financing is expected to come from foreign investors, and the project is backed by the Catalan government. 
 Could Dali be the Catalan answer, at last, to Mickey Mouse? 
 AMERICAN SURVEY 
 Communal living 
 Get together 
 SEATTLE 
 THE American house is a domestic fortress, protected by garage doors that snap shut like a clamshell when the occupants come home each evening. 
 No house built in the past four decades has a front porch (verandah, for Britons); Americans prefer the private world of their expansive back lawns. 
 Here they re-live the life of a pioneer in the wilderness, when the nearest living soul was 20 miles away. 
 This is not cheap: housing costs eat up 44% of a typical wage-earner's income, as opposed to 14% in the 1950s. 
 A few brave souls are about to try reversing the trend, through &bquo;co-housing&equo;. 
 The idea is that people band together to buy property, then design and build a cluster of single-family homes. 
 The goal is to save money and recapture a way of life. 
 The first co-housing project in America, in Washington state, will break ground soon. 
 The project will house about 45 adults and 25 children near the town of Winslow on Bainbridge Island, a 30-minute ferry trip across Puget Sound from Seattle. 
 The island's isolation and woodsy beauty have made it wildly popular in the past few years; prices for many single homes have jumped above &dollar;300,000. 
 Families in the co-housing group will be able to buy a two-bedroom house for about &dollar;160,000. 
 The project's 30 houses will be built in clusters and spread over a five-acre site. 
 Co-housing might seem to carry the ideological baggage of communes from decades past. 
 But most of the people in the Winslow group are professional and middle-class &mdash; doctors, teachers, executives. 
 Many have already played the traditional American housing game. 
 What seems to be driving them is a desire to create the small-town feeling that is fast disappearing in America. 
 Frequent moves, combined with the anti-social nature of the American home, have created suburbs full of people who scarcely know one another's names. 
 Co-housing proponents envisage a setting where people agree to assume local responsibilities. 
 To that end the residents of the Winslow group will share cooking chores in a central &bquo;common house,&equo; as well as helping with childcare and maintenance. 
 Co-housing is not an American invention. 
 It has its roots in northern Europe, particularly Denmark, where more than 120 co-housing projects have been built since 1972. 
 Co-housing groups in other parts of America are watching the Winslow project closely. 
 But the idea of staking a claim to a piece of land is deeply rooted in the American psyche. 
 Americans successfully resisted a push towards cluster housing and common open space when those ideas were in vogue 20 years ago.  
 A chicken in every pot 
 DALLAS 
 AT THE beginning of the 20th century Texan lobbyists could get more or less what they wanted so long as they kept politicians supplied with the three Bs: beefsteak, bourbon and blondes. 
 Things have not changed all that much. 
 Texas still has about the weakest campaign-finance laws of any big state, and some of its politicians still rely on lobbyists to pay for everything from trips and meals to golf tournaments. 
 So Ann Richards's first act as governor was to call for the adoption of an emergency ethics law &bquo;with some teeth in it.&equo; 
 The current push for reform started in 1989 with &bquo;Chickengate&equo;. 
 A wealthy Texan chicken magnate, Lonnie &bquo;Bo&equo; Pilgrim, walked on to the floor of the state Senate and handed &dollar;10,000 cheques to several legislators during the debate on a bill about compensating workers for job injuries. 
 Although this is a legal thing to do in Texas, an uproar over the shameless display of influence-peddling prompted most of the recipients to return the money (mostly only after they had cashed the cheques). 
 The fuss died down, but has now surfaced again. 
 The Democratic speaker of the Texas House of Representative, Gib Lewis, was indicted in December for failing to report a gift from a local law firm. 
 Mr Lewis and the law firm, Heard Coggan Blair and Williams, say they did nothing illegal and defend the payment as a business agreement. 
 Mr Lewis admits he also took a trip to a Mexican resort with members of the law firm, but denies reports that a female employee was provided to entertain him. 
 The speaker has, in the past, paid a fine for not disclosing fully his property ventures with lobbyists. 
 Since 1970 three out of five Texan speakers, and a couple of dozen other lawmakers, have been indicted. 
 Mrs Richards says it is high time to rid Austin, the capital city, of practices that critics say stink as much as Mr Pilgrim's chicken-processing plants. 
 The question is not whether a reform bill will pass but how strong it will be. 
 Politicians, uncomfortable in the spotlight, publicly back some sort of reform package that might take away a few of their perks. 
 According to a study by the new lieutenant-governor, Texas stands alone among the ten biggest states in its lack of power to enforce its rules on ethical behaviour. 
 Not that there is much to enforce. 
 Texas puts no limits on campaign contributions by lobbyists, or on spending by candidates. 
 Any gift or campaign contribution is legal so long as it is reported. 
 Lobbyists are barred from contributing while the legislature is in session; the savvy Mr Pilgrim worked the Senate floor during an emergency meeting. 
 Lobbyists must report contributions without specifying whom they gave them to. 
 In 1989 lobbyists spent &dollar;2.2m entertaining anonymous politicians. 
 Texan lawmakers, who are paid only &dollar;600 a month for their public service, argue that they cannot afford to live in Austin. 
 So they take advantage of a rule that permits them to spend money left over from their campaigns on themselves. 
 They are supposed to report gifts over &dollar;250, but often do not. 
 Reform groups have called for drastic measures, perhaps following California's lead in limiting the number of terms a politician can serve in office. 
 Unlikely.  
 George Bush's critics 
 A PROPHET is not without honour, save in his own house. 
 Washington has not yet made up its collective mind about George Bush. 
 Some of his achievements are cheered by all, or nearly all: the way in which he stitched together an international coalition against Saddam Hussein; the way he managed to use the United Nations to prosecute American policy; his courage. 
 But he has not convinced his hometown audience that the larger goal of the Gulf war &mdash; the crafting of a new world order &mdash; amounts to more than a string of words. 
 And some go on to accuse him of tunnel-vision, saying they doubt whether he ever really wanted a peaceful settlement in the Gulf; whether he now has a view of what American policy after the war should be; and whether his single-minded determination to win the war is blinding him to other dangers. 
 Part of the problem is that Mr Bush is not a character with whom cynical Washingtonians feel comfortable. 
 Whatever else he is (part mean-spirited political campaigner, part Texas oilman, and more) he is indisputably a Yankee patrician, with an abiding sense of noblesse oblige. 
 He was a war hero. 
 He came to political maturity when the world was wrecked; he sees himself as a man who can put back together what others have broken. 
 Less than two days after the bombing started, he talked about America's post-war &bquo;healing&equo; mission. 
 He holds some old-fashioned values to be self-evident, and they have informed his view of Iraq's actions. 
 &bquo;This&equo;, he has said, &bquo;is black and white, good and evil&equo;. 
 Few Washingtonians talk like this, perhaps because few of them are Yankee patrician war heroes, perhaps because politics has rubbed the gleam off them. 
 And Mr Bush, unlike John Kennedy, who came from a not dissimilar background, has found it difficult to communicate his beliefs to others. 
 Perhaps his parents taught him that sounding gushy is bad. 
 And &bquo;vision&equo; is something vulgar Reaganites had. 
 His speech to the country on January 16th on the outbreak of war proved yet again that the president is no orator. 
 For people already inclined to be critical of Mr Bush, it is easy to leap from saying that he cannot articulate a policy to saying that he does not have one, or that such policy as he has is flawed. 
 Was there a choice? 
 His fiercer critics argue that from November 8th, when he announced a doubling of American troops in Saudi Arabia, Mr Bush was obsessed with the need for war against the man he had demonised. 
 After the UN Security Council vote on November 29th he was trapped by a timetable: war had to be fought after January 15th. 
 A cooler customer, it is suggested, would somehow have sought and found a diplomatic solution. 
 To some extent, this charge is unprovable, either way. 
 Though the world's press has done its best, huge gaps remain in public knowledge of the road to war. 
 The details of diplomatic manoeuvring &mdash; what messages other Arabs took from Washington to Baghdad, what the Russians did, how the American charg&eacute; d'affaires in Baghdad kept busy for five months &mdash; remain unknown. 
 Either nothing happened that did not happen on CNN, or, more likely, much that happened stayed under wraps. 
 That caveat notwithstanding, those close to Mr Bush insist that there was an effort to get a non-military solution, and that if Saddam Hussein had reached out for it he could have walked away from Kuwait with something gained from his adventure. 
 From the time of Mr Bush's speech to the UN General Assembly in October to the last-minute pleas of Javier Perez de Cuellar, the UN secretary-general, an array of sweeteners was on offer. 
 That Iraq never once even nibbled at the goodies has convinced the administration that diplomacy was always doomed, because Mr Hussein meant to hold on to Kuwait no matter what. 
 But did the administration misjudge Iraq's military power of resistance? 
 Too early to know, say officials, and anyway that question really has a different target: it was the press and Wall Street that got euphoric in the early days of war, and then came down with a bump, not the administration. 
 Another charge is that Mr Bush has given too little thought to the nature of a post-war settlement. 
 Officials find this criticism maddening. 
 The National Security Council, they insist, hums with meetings on just this, but the meetings cannot get very far until more is known about how the post-war world looks. 
 For a start, they argue, America has already told Jordan that it wants to be friends again (watch to see if America leans on Israel to be more accommodating to Jordan's need for water). 
 The most pungent criticism of the president may be that so much of his attention is on the Gulf, and so little of it elsewhere. 
 This is understandable, but it is still dangerous. 
 Above all, the administration has barely responded to Mikhail Gorbachev's swing to oppression in the Soviet Union. 
 Neither Mr Bush nor James Baker, his secretary of state (who talks about Lithuania and Latvia with the visible enthusiasm of someone who has just sucked a lemon), can yet bring himself to think anything but the best of Mr Gorbachev, so helpful last year in Europe, so kind this year in the Gulf. 
 This could indeed be a weakness in Mr Bush's determination to defeat Iraq.  
 Women 
 Breaking through 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 POLITICAL marriages have their uses. 
 On January 14th the unlikely figure of Bob Dole, the Senate Republican leader, took time off from the Gulf to call for a statutory commission to find out why women have not broken through the &bquo;glass ceiling&equo; that keeps them from top management jobs. 
 The reason for his interest? 
 Could it be that his wife Elizabeth, who was secretary of labour until three months ago, wanted another push in the campaign she launched last May? 
 Many men (but few women) deny the existence of subtle impediments that make it particularly difficult for women, blacks, Hispanics and even those talented Asians to make it to the top. 
 They now have to contend with a survey of corporate America conducted jointly by an executive-recruitment firm, Korn/Ferry, and the University of California at Los Angeles. 
 In 1989 only 3% of top American managers were female and only 1.5% were from a racial minority. 
 The proportions had barely changed since 1979. 
 The score for American women is also strikingly lower than the 8% reached by their British sisters. 
 Overt sex or race discrimination is illegal. 
 But the impediments are often so subtle that they fall foul of no law. 
 And few of the people who hit the glass ceiling are inclined to go through the additional pain of a complaint to the government or a court case. 
 This is why Mrs Dole got the Labour Department to look at the personnel records of nine big companies around the country. 
 The results should appear in March. 
 Officials expect them to show that there is indeed an obstacle at middle-management level. 
 They hope also to learn what part is played by each firm's promotion procedures, training, pay structures and family policies. 
 Nobody can object to collecting and analysing such information (despite a few worries about confidentiality). 
 The arguments come over what to do about it. 
 Some claim that the numbers are bound to improve now that more than half the country's workforce is female or from a minority. 
 But they have been saying that for 20 years. 
 The Labour Department can cajole companies to break the ceiling themselves before someone does it for them. 
 It can also threaten to cancel federal contracts with any firms that refuse to change. 
 This would hurt, since a quarter of American firms have such contracts. 
 Businesses are worried lest pushing things too fast leads to the adoption of quotas for women and minorities. 
 The spectre of quotas was the reason that businessmen gave for opposing the civil-rights bill the president vetoed last October. 
 Congress is likely to reintroduce this bill soon. 
 The administration's left hand may continue to fight it as a quota measure, while its right comes close to endorsing quotas to break the glass ceiling.  
 Terrorism 
 High anxiety 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 DETROIT'S mayor publicly muses about imposing a state of emergency in his city. 
 Rumours circulate of bombs in New York's subway system, and the poisoning of water wells. 
 Army surplus stores report a stream of buyers for gas masks, water-purification tablets, survival knives &mdash; even combat boots. 
 American businessmen and tourists are busy cancelling their trips to Europe. 
 American students, unlucky enough to be studying in that endangered continent, are warned by their embassies not to talk loudly in public. 
 Saddam Hussein threatened that it was in his power to sponsor terrorist attacks on the countries ranged against him. 
 Once war broke out, the security measures at the White House and the Pentagon, already stricter than nearly anywhere else in America, were stepped up. 
 On Capitol Hill the number of policemen on active duty was doubled. 
 In nearly every government building coats and briefcases are thoroughly searched (as never before), credentials checked and rechecked by nervous guards. 
 At airports all over the country passengers who fit the &bquo;profile of potential terrorists&equo; have been questioned; sniffer dogs sniff away. 
 Officials at the Super Bowl, to be played on January 27th in Tampa, Florida, have announced that no portable cameras, radios or televisions (de rigueur for football fans) will be allowed inside the stadium. 
 Americans, threatened by nothing more bellicose to their north and south than Canada and Mexico, are not accustomed to thinking they are in a battle zone. 
 When travelling in Europe, they are shocked to see uniformed men, toting automatic weapons, roaming through airports and train depots. 
 Saddam's threats, combined with the memory of the destruction of Pan Am Flight 103 over Scotland, have caused a huge reduction in travel. 
 TWA has cancelled half its international flights. 
 Staying at home is not that reassuring either. 
 Nearly 30% of Americans all over the country surveyed by the Washington Post said they feared their city would be subject to a terrorist attack. 
 The jitters are worst in the capital, where 61% of people are fearful.  
 Kids' stuff 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 THREE teenage boys were arrested last May for throwing 15-pound landscaping stones off a bridge over the main motorway that runs around Washington. 
 Police suspected that the boys, whose fun and games hurt a lot of people, were on drugs. 
 Now two of them have been convicted and sentenced to nearly 40 years in prison. 
 And the form of drug they had indeed been taking &mdash; a legal drug, as it happens, called alcohol &mdash; is under attack from the surgeon-general. 
 They had been drinking Cisco, a fruity, wine-based fluid that smells and tastes like a mixture of cough syrup and bathtub gin. 
 Its appeal, however, lies not in its fragrant bouquet but in its potency: some teenagers call it &bquo;liquid crack&equo;. 
 Though packaged to look like a low-alcohol spritzer &mdash; all soft lines and pastel colours &mdash; a 12-ounce bottle of Cisco is as intoxicating as five shots of 100-proof liquor. 
 Since Cisco first appeared in shops last year, local hospitals have reported an unusual number of teenagers (who tend to like the relatively weak &bquo;wine coolers&equo;) checking in with alcohol poisoning after drinking the stuff. 
 Hearing such complaints, the National Council on Alcoholism and Drug Dependence began a public campaign against Cisco's manufacturer, the Canandaigua Wine Company of New York. 
 It says the company's marketing of Cisco is dangerously deceptive; it induces unsuspecting teenagers to guzzle it as if it were a standard spritzer. 
 On January 9th Antonia Novello, the surgeon-general, joined in. 
 Though the company has already muted Cisco's marketing (dropping the slogan: &bquo;It takes you by surprise&equo;), Mrs Novello says it must do more &mdash; perhaps change the bottle's shape and colour. 
 If Canandaigua refuses, she says she may ask the Federal Trade Commission to force it to. 
 Echoing the logic of the gun lobby (&bquo;guns don't kill people; people kill people&equo;), the company's chairman argues that the problem is not with his product, but with under-age drinking. 
 This is not without its glimmer of truth. 
 Teenagers are not as stupid, or as innocent, as Mrs Novello and her well-meaning allies would make out. 
 In all likelihood, most teenagers drink Cisco precisely because it is a cheap (&dollar;3 a bottle) way to get drunk quickly.  
 Texas 
 More spirit than power 
 HOUSTON 
 TWO and a half years after she made national headlines with her searing attack on George Bush at the 1988 Democratic national convention, Ann Richards was inaugurated as Texas's 45th governor on January 15th. 
 Narrowly victorious in a mudslinging campaign, Mrs Richards &mdash; a divorced mother of four &mdash; became the first woman to hold the office since 1935. 
 She promised &bquo;a new Texas&hellip; where opportunity knows no race, no gender, no colour&hellip; 
 Government must stop telling people what they want and start&hellip; hearing what the people want.&equo; 
 Fine, but Mrs Richards inherits a lot of problems. 
 Texas faces a budget deficit of over &dollar;4 billion, with more in prospect &mdash; and is bound by a pay-as-you-go statute. 
 Mrs Richards was quick to declare that education is her highest priority. 
 But a week later the Texas supreme court greatly complicated her task by unanimously declaring Texas's new law on school finance, laboriously agreed upon after four special sessions, to be unconstitutional. 
 Compared with her fellow-governors in California and New York, Mrs Richards's power is limited. 
 One thing she can do is to make appointments to the state's numerous policy-making commissions and boards. 
 She used this power to pay off some political debts and to make a political statement by appointing Alison Walton Leland, a Houston stockbroker who is widow of a much-liked congressman, Mickey Leland, to the Texas A&amp;M University board. 
 Mrs Richards views her new office as a bully pulpit. 
 Her first target was the state's car-insurance industry, which is seeking its largest rate increase in 32 years; she reckons this is unjustified. 
 Other battles loom. 
 Texas has no company or personal income tax, and the former, at least, may soon be seriously discussed. 
 Already there is talk of a Richards-for-vice-president movement in 1992. 
 That is wildly premature. 
 But she is starting with spirit.  
 The law 
 How close to your client? 
 LOS ANGELES 
 FEW lawyers think it right to have affairs with their clients, but should the law prohibit it? 
 California's state bar is considering a proposal that would ban attorneys from having sex with their customers, unless they are married to them or the relationship began before they became clients. 
 The ban, the first of its kind, would affect 120,000 Californian lawyers &mdash; and cause havoc for the scriptwriters of &bquo;LA Law&equo;. 
 The ban is one of four draft rules the bar is currently looking at. 
 The others are less fierce, but still prohibit any relationship that might affect a lawyer's ability to handle a case properly. 
 Last December an appeal court ordered the retrial of a convicted murderer when it was revealed that his wife had had an affair with his lawyer. 
 The debate is the result of a campaign by Lucille Roybal-Allard, a Democratic assemblywoman from Los Angeles. 
 Miss Roybal-Allard originally wanted the ban to apply only to divorce, probate and child-custody cases. 
 She introduced a bill in 1989, obliging the bar to consider a ban, after a case in which two women accused Marvin Mitchelson, a big-cheese divorce lawyer, of sexual assault (he denied the charges and settled out of court). 
 Miss Roybal-Allard argues that a lawyer who is sleeping with a divorce client may not try too hard to reconcile husband and wife. 
 The state bar would prefer to set a blanket rule governing all types of lawyers. 
 It has argued that a total ban on sex may be unnecessary; it would prefer to have rules that prevent a lawyer from bullying a client to have sex. 
 The Los Angeles bar &mdash; home to 26,000 lawyers &mdash; reckons that its existing rules, which &bquo;prohibit sexual relations with a client when such relations would impair the parties' decision-making abilities&equo;, are sufficient. 
 A total ban might also be opposed as an unconstitutional invasion of privacy. 
 If the state bar decides against a complete ban, Miss Roybal-Allard may introduce a new bill requiring it to have one. 
 It could go through: people are impatient with lawyers and their charges. 
 Doctors already have a rule against having sex with their patients, and it is illegal for American psychiatrists. 
 There are even whispers that such standards should apply to journalists.  
 Arab-Americans 
 The perils of hyphenation 
 LET us have no patience with the enemy or anyone whose veins carry his blood.&equo; 
 That sentiment, expressed early in the second world war by a journalist called Henry McLemore, epitomised the attitude of many Americans when war broke out in 1941. 
 The decision to intern 110,000 Japanese-Americans was a wholesale violation of civil rights. 
 Their fate is an uneasy memory for the 2.5m Americans of Arab descent. 
 Albert Mokhiber, president of the Arab-American Anti-Discrimination Committee (ADC), does not believe that anybody in the government wants to intern Arab-Americans. 
 But the unease remains. 
 Within days of the outbreak of war, prominent Arab-Americans were being visited by the FBI and asked about their knowledge of international terrorism. 
 True, the FBI can help protect Arab-Americans: there have already been some scattered incidents of violence. 
 But Mr Mokhiber fears that pointed questions from the FBI could help to turn Arab-Americans into &bquo;a suspect class&equo;. 
 &bquo;Two worlds have collided and both of them are ours,&equo; says James Zogby, director of the Arab-American Institute. 
 Suddenly in the spotlight, Arab-Americans are torn between the urge to stress their loyalty and the alarm they feel about the latest turn in Middle East events. 
 They are represented both in the armed forces and in the peace marches. 
 Their organisations were split over the original decision to send troops to the Gulf: the National Association of Arab Americans (NAAA) supported the build-up, while the ADC, a larger organisation, opposed it. 
 This diversity of opinion was to be expected. 
 Arab immigrants to the United States have been drawn from all over the Middle East. 
 The first wave, mainly from villages in Lebanon and Syria, started to arrive in the 1880s. 
 Like other immigrant groups, they tended to congregate in certain areas, Detroit and nearby Dearborn in particular. 
 Many became prosperous and assimilation was quick. 
 But by the 1970s it had again become respectable to stress ethnicity: Arab-Americans, like blacks, Poles, Italians and Jews, became more interested in their roots. 
 And, as the second and third generation of Arab-Americans began to look back across the Atlantic, they were joined by a new wave of immigrants from the Middle East, many of them Lebanese, Palestinians and Iraqis displaced by the political upheavals in the region. 
 The mingling of new and old immigrants (both groups well-educated) strengthened the growing sense of connection between Arab-Americans and the Middle East. 
 There was a darker side to the growth of Arab-American consciousness. 
 The oil shocks of the 1970s, and the widespread sympathy for Israel in the United States, led to a new sense of vulnerability. 
 The NAAA and the ADC were formed with a dual purpose: to provide legal protection for Arab-Americans against discrimination, and to lobby for a change in America's policy towards the Arabs and Israel. 
 Ranged against the far more powerful pro-Israel lobby, the groups have so far had little impact on policy. 
 But Mr Zogby of the Arab-American Institute believes that the war in the Gulf, far from setting the cause back, may be a moment of opportunity: &bquo;The United States&equo;, he says, &bquo;now knows that it will need to build bridges to the Middle East. 
 Arab-Americans are a national resource that needs to be utilised.&equo;  
 Battling for an oil policy 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 TELLING Americans about the outbreak of war, George Bush conspicuously omitted one word: oil. 
 The war, the president insists, is about higher principles than control of a grubby liquid in the ground. 
 Only up to a point: without oil Saddam Hussein would not have invaded Kuwait; nor would his invasion have threatened the West's security. 
 There has been little talk of America's dependence on oil imports &mdash; or its missing energy policy. 
 The conventional wisdom on energy policy is that it is better not to have one. 
 Americans, it is said, are profligate consumers of energy. 
 They will not accept higher energy taxes or any restrictions on their right to drive. 
 Jimmy Carter's doomed efforts to launch a war against the country's dependence on imported energy will always be associated in the public mind with queues at petrol stations. 
 This shows that Ronald Reagan was right: Americans' preferred energy policy is no policy at all. 
 As usual, conventional wisdom may not be wholly right. 
 Americans certainly use lots of energy, but less prodigiously than they once did. 
 In 1985 their consumption was roughly the same as in 1973, even though real GNP had increased by a third. 
 Thanks to low oil prices, that pattern was broken after 1985, when energy use once again rose in line with GNP. 
 However, dependence on oil has fallen: its share of energy consumption is now just over 40%, down from 47% in 1973. 
 Opinion polls have revealed that, while Americans are reluctant to pay more for energy, they dearly want to be less reliant on imports from the Gulf. 
 Hence Mr Bush's decision in 1989 to edge away from pure Reaganism by asking his energy secretary, James Watkins, to put together a national energy strategy. 
 Admiral Watkins submitted the result of his consultations on December 21st. 
 This turned out to be a list of policy options from which Mr Bush was to choose &mdash; with luck in time to unveil a complete plan in his &bquo;state of the union&equo; message on January 29th. 
 Officials refuse to talk openly about the options. 
 But the war has clearly derailed the timetable. 
 Mr Bush has had only one meeting to discuss energy strategy, on January 8th. 
 His White House advisers are said to be worried that the Energy Department is still too keen on conservation and regulation. 
 Domestic oil interests, mindful of Mr Bush's background as an oilman, would prefer there to be more emphasis on encouraging domestic production. 
 Others want to push harder for a revival of nuclear energy. 
 And Mr Bush's economic advisers fear that any extra regulation could further damage an already weak economy. 
 Now a new factor looms: soft oil prices. 
 For several months it has been obvious that the oil market is, as Joseph Stanislaw of Cambridge Energy Research Associates puts it, long on crude. 
 Demand has fallen; stocks are high; tankers are full; thanks to extra Saudi pumping, production is back to the level of last August. 
 With the outbreak of war, the administration has belatedly agreed to tap its strategic petroleum reserve. 
 For the next six weeks America, Japan and Germany will between them sell more than 2m barrels a day. 
 Though the markets remain nervously responsive to war news from the Gulf, they now seem to discount a serious threat to Saudi production. 
 Barring disasters, thinks Mr Stanislaw, the price could soon be &dollar;15 a barrel or less, not the &dollar;40-plus that was once feared. 
 That would be a welcome boost to the American (and world) economy. 
 But as Phil Sharp, chairman of the House of Representatives Energy Committee, gloomily acknowledges, it would also remove the pressure for an energy strategy. 
 America is running out of its own oil. 
 Despite intensive drilling, production has steadily fallen from its 1973 level of 9.2m barrels a day; the government's energy forecasters think it could be less than 6m b/d by 2000. 
 But the world is not running short. 
 So if prices after the war stay low, there will be a strong temptation to keep using the stuff as before &mdash; even if America's dependence on imports rises, as the forecasters predict, to 55% of oil consumption from today's 42%. 
 Two groups may act to stop such complacency. 
 First, the environmentalists. 
 The Natural Resources Defence Council is co-ordinating a green energy strategy that will cite the clean-air act, the risk of pollution and the threat of global warming as arguments for reducing the use of fossil fuels. 
 The second group is, surprisingly, congressmen. 
 Mr Sharp plans legislation. 
 So does his opposite number in the Senate, Bennett Johnston of Louisiana. 
 Congress is not at its best when trying to reconcile the special interests that flock round energy bills. 
 What might it consider doing? 
 Measures to boost supply are not particularly promising. 
 Even if America's coasts, and the Arctic National Wildlife Reserve, were once again opened to drilling, the results would not offset the decline in production. 
 Reviving the moribund nuclear industry would be tough and unpopular, and could take many years to produce more power. 
 Many congressmen are keen to revive research into renewable energy sources like solar and wind power. 
 It is striking that federal spending on research and development into energy was halved in the 1980s; R&amp;D into renewable energy alone fell from &dollar;700m in 1981 to &dollar;115m in 1989. 
 The most hopeful source of extra energy could be natural gas. 
 America and Canada have masses of it, and burning it does little environmental damage. 
 Michael Baly, president of the American Gas Association, reckons that within ten years gas could be a substitute for 2 billion barrels of oil &mdash; an eighth of current American oil consumption. 
 Now that gas prices have been been freed from control, he says, the industry can guarantee supplies to utilities and industrial users. 
 Congress and state regulators could speed up the construction of pipelines. 
 And more cars and lorries are switching to liquefied natural gas. 
 The most contentious part of the energy agenda remains conservation. 
 Not that anybody (even in the oil industry) opposes it. 
 But there is plenty of dispute over how to encourage it. 
 Higher taxes, the most sensible route, are probably out &mdash; both for the usual political reasons and because this year nobody wants to reopen last October's budget agreement. 
 The administration would like more states to follow California's lead in allowing electricity companies to reap profits from their customers' investments in conservation. 
 But it is firmly against heavy-handed regulation, such as a sharp increase in mandatory fuel efficiency for cars. 
 There are more imaginative regulatory ideas that harness the price mechanism and market forces. 
 Jessica Mathews of the World Resources Institute is pushing a &bquo;sipper-guzzler&equo; fuel-economy plan that would impose a levy on new cars whose fuel-consumption rate was below a set figure &mdash; say 27 miles to the gallon &mdash; and use the proceeds to offer rebates for cars above it. 
 Another idea is a &bquo;feebate&equo; scheme under which levies on petrol would be linked to car-insurance premiums. 
 The result would be that those who drive more would pay more for their insurance. 
 Last year's clean-air act, which Mr Bush proudly signed in November, introduced the idea of tradable pollution permits as a regulatory measure that embraced market forces. 
 Something similar might be done for energy, if higher taxes remain off-limits. 
 But the first requirement is for Mr Bush, who has the best bully pulpit from which to push for change, to show that whatever happens to oil prices he remains serious about fashioning an energy strategy. 
 After fighting a war at least partly because of the Gulf's oil, he certainly should be. 
 INTERNATIONAL 
 Chile 
 Trust the general 
 FROM OUR SANTIAGO CORRESPONDENT 
 DICTATORS' offspring often disappoint their parents. 
 The elder son of Chile's ex-dictator and (still) army commander, General Augusto Pinochet, may be a case in point. 
 A congressional committee has been inquiring into why Augusto Pinochet junior, who calls himself an international arms adviser, received cheques worth nearly &dollar;3m from the army, apparently for his share in a rifle factory, and whether the old general knew his son stood to benefit. 
 Mr Pinochet junior, asked if he used his father's name to get business, replied: &bquo;One does not invoke the name of God.&equo; 
 Relations were already tense between the generals and the elected government of President Patricio Aylwin, which took office last March. 
 Just before Christmas all troops were recalled to barracks for 24 hours. 
 Publicly, officers called this a &bquo;routine liaison exercise&equo;. 
 In private, they said it was a warning that they stood four-square behind their chief, and that they would not accept behind-the-scenes pressure on him to resign. 
 Three weeks later the high command again said hands off, with a reminder that it could still mount a coup. 
 The case of the &bquo;pinocheques&equo; is not the only case of apparent corruption that has come to light since the general left power, though it is the one that may touch him directly. 
 A Santiago judge is investigating allegations that senior army officers ran a large illegal banking operation known as la cutufa, army slang for a raffle. 
 Investigations are also going on into the state holding company, Corfo, the housing ministry and a state-owned bank where new officials have uncovered high-handed property transfers and loans made either to the army as an institution or to individual officers. 
 It seems, for example, that the army simply took over a presidential residence-cum-bunker, built in Santiago for General Pinochet. 
 It is further alleged that the last-but-one head of the secret police quietly sold to his wife and family a mansion which the service had commandeered and used as a torture centre in the 1970s. 
 These allegations have shattered the army's image, not least in its own eyes, as a band of seagreen incorruptibles, brutal perhaps, but honest. 
 From this high moral ground the army had expected to challenge the record of human-rights abuses during its 17 years in power that has been compiled by a &bquo;commission for truth and reconciliation&equo; made up of seven lawyers from across the political spectrum. 
 The commission has been collecting evidence about the torture and &bquo;disappearance&equo; of the military regime's political opponents, from victims and their families and from the armed forces. 
 The commission's report, due to go to the president by early February, will eventually be published. 
 It will name only the victims, not their torturers. 
 Leaked accounts say it finds that army units were far more deeply involved in the repression than were the navy, the air force or the police, whose chiefs have all taken command since the coup of 1973. 
 The allegations of corruption, too, have not so far touched the other three services, which have kept quietly clear of the row between the army and the government. 
 President Aylwin has been careful to keep the issue of military corruption quite separate from that of human-rights offences. 
 The common factor could be General Pinochet himself. 
 At the age of 75, he is the last of the four leaders of the original military junta, the last to talk still of the high crusade against communism. 
 He looks and sounds ever more of an anachronism. 
 But he still commands the army, and the loyalty of many of its officers.  
 Liberia 
 Presidents galore 
 FROM OUR WEST AFRICA CORRESPONDENT 
 MONROVIA 
 AFTER a bloody year, Liberia's mayhem shows no sign of letting up. 
 Troops from five West African nations have managed to bring peace to the capital at least. 
 But bands of armed rebels from sundry factions still extort food from villages, some of them across the border in neighbouring Sierra Leone. 
 Despite the mess, lots of Liberians long to take charge. 
 On January 20th Harry Moniba became the third man to lay claim to the presidency. 
 A fourth rival stood down recently in the interests of the public good. 
 Mr Moniba is a freemason and one of Liberia's many PhDs. 
 He lost his old job as vice-president in July after suggesting that his boss, Samuel Doe, should resign to stop the country's civil war. 
 Doe tried to kill him, and persevered as president until he himself was killed. 
 The civil war went on anyway. 
 Mr Moniba and other Doe cronies, for want of anything better to do, have spent the past five months in Sierra Leone plotting their comeback and slandering their rivals. 
 These include the interim administration led by Amos Sawyer, a medical doctor whom the West African peacekeepers back. 
 He has achieved little since November besides getting to know the gadgets in the presidential motor cars. 
 Neither he nor the exiles have done anything to help the starving people who wander the streets of the capital, Monrovia, looking for food and a future. 
 Every month, say officials of the UN's World Food Programme, less than half the required 6,000 tonnes of rice arrives in the city; M&eacute;decins Sans Fronti&egrave;res reports that 20 children die of starvation in the city's hospitals each day. 
 The rich in Monrovia are better served. 
 They welcomed the recent reopening of a nightclub &mdash; the first since fighting in the city ended in December. 
 The club is owned by Eddie Dunn, protocol chief to Dr Sawyer's interim government. 
 Mr Dunn brought in beer, spirits and mixers on a United Nations relief flight, insisting this was a minister's right. 
 Gifts of rice and oil from the Jehovah's Witnesses were left behind on the tarmac in Sierra Leone to make room for the booze. 
 The nightclub, called &bquo;Lipps&equo;, sells the beer at &dollar;20 a can, and claims to be the cheapest place in town. 
 There are plenty more villains. 
 Prince Johnson, the rebel who sliced off Doe's ears before (according to Mr Johnson) forcing him to eat one while Mr Johnson chewed on the other, has given up asking to be president but is now surrounded by a team of &bquo;advisers&equo;. 
 They say the interim administration is failing because &bquo;they are too poor, they are all school teachers, and they are not rich enough to be politicians&equo;. 
 Only the rich stay above corruption in Liberia. 
 The Johnson camp has come to prefer Charles Taylor, the third self-proclaimed president and a man Mr Johnson was once keen to shoot. 
 Mr Taylor controls most of the countryside, and Mr Johnson plans to meet him soon. 
 Two days before he tortured Doe to death, Mr Johnson hugged and embraced his future victim, and told him that they should join sides. 
 Mr Taylor should not let Mr Johnson get too close.  
 Africa's imploding dictatorships 
 IN ANGOLA and Mozambique, superpower disengagement gave peacemakers new hope. 
 Elsewhere in Africa, the end of foreign patronage may also mean the end of the corrupt leaders it has sustained. 
 The Russians and the Americans should be glad when they finally drop Ethiopia's President Mengistu and Zaire's President Mobutu. 
 Unfortunately, their countries may collapse with them, certainly if they follow the examples of Liberia and Somalia, where superpower disengagement has brought the opposite of peace. 
 Aid, given on condition that it is spent on genuine development, can till the soil for home-grown growth. 
 But aid given to governments purely to buy strategic services, without any sensible economic conditions attached, merely keeps bad rulers in office. 
 America lavished &dollar;1 billion on Liberia in the 1980s, partly because it provided the freed slaves who settled the country last century, mainly because Liberia gave a home to a Voice of America transmitter, a navigation beacon, a relay station for diplomatic communications, and a huge airfield where arms could be discreetly trans-shipped. 
 The sponsored regime stole the aid money, until Americans and ordinary Liberians were equally fed up. 
 Last year the president was killed by rebels whom the Americans did not try to stop. 
 Chaos ensued. 
 Somalia, similarly, enjoyed handsome presents. 
 Its dictator, President Siad Barre, ditched the Russians for the better-heeled Americans. 
 They bought the chance to use the naval base at Berbera, and to balance Soviet influence in Ethiopia next door. 
 In the capital the Americans built a vast embassy, with restaurant, swimming pool, tennis courts and so on. 
 As in Liberia, they did not buy much development. 
 Mr Barre's charms faded with the communist threat. 
 Last year the Americans did not bother to renegotiate access to Berbera when their lease expired. 
 As American interest shrivelled, so did the government. 
 Last month rebels fought their way into the capital, and wrecked it. 
 Government soldiers helped. 
 The army blew a hole in the barrier round the Americans' fine embassy, and sacked it.  
 Zimbabwe's land 
 Families' value 
 FROM OUR ZIMBABWE CORRESPONDENT 
 IN THE muddy red fields of Musengezi, a lesson in land reform is on display. 
 On one side of the road the cotton plants stand knee-high in well-tended rows; on the other they are besieged by weeds and reach to just above the ankle. 
 The healthy cotton is grown on family plots, the neglected crop on land farmed by co-operatives. 
 There are signs that the lesson is being learnt: like other land reformers before him, Zimbabwe's President Robert Mugabe is trading collective ideology for private efficiency. 
 With a bit of luck, his example may impress fellow black nationalists across the border in South Africa. 
 Since independence in 1980, white landlords have freely sold the government enough land to resettle 52,000 black families on projects like the one at Musengezi. 
 Last year, when the constitutional ban on forced purchase expired, Mr Mugabe promised to buy up half the remaining white farmland at prices he would set. 
 His motive was political: to reward the peasants who fought his independence war against Ian Smith's white government, and to relieve the crowding in the communal lands where blacks had been herded. 
 But Mr Mugabe wants resettlement to be efficient, too, and is absorbing the Musengezi lesson. 
 The Commercial Farmers Union, which speaks for the 4,300 white farmers, says that too much resettlement could endanger Zimbabwe's special status as an African country that can feed itself. 
 It estimates that by forcibly buying 6m hectares (15m acres) from whites the government will cause national farm production, currently at Z&dollar;2.2 billion (&dollar;840m), to drop by Z&dollar;500m. 
 Exports, at Z&dollar;1.5 billion, would fall by nearly a third. 
 The government disagrees, pointing out that recent studies, including one by the World Bank, show that Zimbabwe could get along fine with a commercial farming industry half its current size. 
 Labour-intensive crops like maize and cotton are sometimes more efficiently produced by humble farmers with lots of children than by rich ones with smart machines. 
 The government has decided to back private ownership. 
 Officials laugh ruefully at the miserable performance of collective farming, and suggest it may be phased out. 
 They also aim to resettle promising farmers, whereas in the early 1980s it was the poorest, not the most successful, who were given newly purchased land. 
 The most radical new idea would allow resettled farmers to purchase title deeds, payable over 20 years. 
 That would help the government to recoup some of the cost of resettlement, while giving farmers an incentive to improve their own plots.  
 Making the best of Cuba's bad job 
 FROM A SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN HAVANA 
 THE government's emergency food programme, according to a joke doing the rounds in Havana, is like God; everyone talks about it but nobody can see it. 
 As Fidel Castro's revolution entered its 33rd year this month, shortages of food and consumer goods were the most obvious of the many challenges to Cuba's Caribbean version of socialism. 
 Almost all food is now legally available only to those with ration books. 
 The state markets where food could be bought off ration have been shut down. 
 Cubans used to eat a lot of meat. 
 This year their new year's dinner was not the traditional pig, but 12 ounces of frozen chicken a head and three bottles of rum to a family. 
 To persuade the population that austerity falls upon rich and poor alike, the interior ministry has begun arresting people for &bquo;economic crimes&equo;. 
 The political effect is increased by tasty rumours that the children of senior officials are among those detained. 
 As a communist nation that is also part of the third world, Cuba finds its economy in double trouble. 
 Its trade with capitalist countries, like that of its Latin American neighbours, was squeezed in the mid-1980s, when it had to re-negotiate payments of hard-currency debts. 
 Its trade with the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe therefore climbed to 85% of the total. 
 Now their trade organisation, Comecon, has crumbled. 
 Last October Mr Castro declared a &bquo;peacetime special period&equo; &mdash; a kind of economic state of emergency, or survival programme for Cuban socialism. 
 It involves drastic measures to cut the use of energy and materials: 750,000 Chinese bicycles are on order, factories have been shut down. 
 Workers who lose their jobs are sent to farm camps, along with bureaucrats doing two weeks' hard labour. 
 The idea is that recruits from the towns will weed the crops. 
 It is harder to defeat the chronic low productivity of the state farms, and the frailties of the distribution chain. 
 These Cuban weaknesses have long been veiled by imports of grain and tinned meat. 
 For foreign exchange, the government hopes to develop the tourist business and its chief pride, biotechnology. 
 For years foreigners have been unable to make up their minds whether Cuba's showpiece investment in genetic engineering is an expensive folly or the foundation of a high-tech economy. 
 Cuba's investment, and its scientists, have at least been taken seriously. 
 The doubt has been whether Cuba could sell its products in hard-currency markets without subjecting them to years of tests. 
 The Russians seem ready to buy untested products. 
 Mr Yuri Petrov, the astute Soviet ambassador in Havana, says that this year, as well as the usual nickel, citrus fruit and 4m tons of sugar, his country plans to buy Cuban pharmaceutical products worth &dollar;730m, including in particular the hepatitis-B vaccine developed at Havana's Biotechnology Institute. 
 In return, Cuba is promised the Soviet oil that provides 90% of its energy. 
 Mr Petrov says oil shipments in 1991 will be &bquo;not less&equo; than in 1990; at 10.5m tonnes, that was barely enough. 
 The new agreement with the Soviet Union is for one year, rather than five as in the past. 
 All Cuba's trade is under new rules. 
 From the beginning of 1991, prices for everything except sugar are meant to be set at world market rates, whatever they may be. 
 The balance of trade with the Soviet Union is to be paid in dollars, though loans are promised to cover that. 
 Most government-to-government purchasing is over; Cuban agencies must negotiate with hundreds of Soviet firms. 
 And all deals could be off, unless there is a government in Moscow that chooses to keep its promises. 
 Trade with other former members of Comecon is to be in hard currency, if it takes place at all. 
 Many of the East European firms from which Cuba obtained machinery have shut down, or turned to more lucrative business. 
 The Cubans hope to make their own spare parts and replacements; lest that should fail, the state has set up a breeding-station for draft oxen. 
 Mr Castro seems to have drawn three political lessons from communism's demise in Eastern Europe. 
 The first two are that bureaucrats and Soviet imperialism are unpopular. 
 The third is that small reforms lead to big ones. 
 So, while playing up anti-Yankee nationalism, he has streamlined the Communist Party's secretariat, sacking petty officials. 
 Later this year the party will hold a congress, only the fourth Mr Castro has convened in three decades. 
 The preliminary debate has already started. 
 When it seemed to be getting out of hand, he insisted that its aim was to improve the system, not to change it. 
 The debaters, for fear of being called dissidents, fell into line. 
 Unlike Eastern Europe's fallen leaders, Mr Castro was once a genuine revolutionary. 
 Many Cubans still like and respect him. 
 Others want more political openness, but value their health and education services. 
 Perhaps only a minority would like to see their island taken over by the Miami exiles. 
 But unless Mr Castro can cut the grumbling food queues, the Cubans' Caribbean patience could run out. 
 ASIA 
 The dwindling Japanese 
 FROM OUR TOKYO CORRESPONDENT 
 JAPAN'S young women, like their sisters in other rich countries before them, are now marrying later, putting off having their first child longer and then choosing to have fewer children in all. 
 The statisticians' dry figures are beginning to reflect these flesh-and-blood decisions. 
 In 1989 the Japanese fertility rate fell to a post-war low. 
 (The fertility rate is the average number of children a woman would have if she lived to the end of her child-bearing years and bore children at the prevailing rate for each age during that period.) 
 It was 1.57 children per woman in 1989, well below the 2.1 that is needed to prevent the population from eventually declining. 
 It was a shade below even the 1.6 recorded during the ill-omened year 1966 &mdash; on the ancient Chinese calendar, the Year of the Fire-Horse. 
 Any girls born that year would, by tradition, have been fated to make men unhappy, and would thus have been hard to marry off. 
 Many would-be parents decided not to risk it, and waited until 1967. 
 Today's decline in the fertility rate does not have as superstitious, or short-lived, a cause: it has been going on steadily since 1970. 
 If it continues, Japan is in for a shock. 
 Until now Japan has been the rich world's youngster: people 65 and over still account for only 11.5% of the population. 
 But Japan is about to creep ahead of America in its share of old people. 
 By 2000 it will have passed both France and Britain, and will be nosing up on the real geriatrics, Germany and Sweden. 
 The nightmare of officials is that Japan's fertility rate might keep going down until it hits western German levels &mdash; 1.28 at present. 
 If Japanese women were to continue having children for the rest of this century at their 1989 fertility rate of 1.57, Japan's population would inch up from today's 123m to 126m in 2005. 
 Thereafter it would fall, reaching 115m in 2025. 
 But if, beginning in 1990, the Japanese began reproducing at western German rates, Japan's population would peak earlier, at 125m in 2003, and fall more sharply, to 112m in 2025. 
 Japan's government is already fretting over the economic consequences. 
 From April, child benefits are to be raised in the hope of encouraging parents to produce a few more babies. 
 For the government, pensions are the biggest worry. 
 Every retired person in Japan today is supported by 5.3 people of working age. 
 By 2000 this figure will have shrunk to 3.8. 
 Everything else being equal (which it won't be, of course), payroll taxes and social-security contributions would have to increase by as much as 40%. 
 In less than a decade Japan could have moved from being the most lightly taxed OECD country to being one of the most heavily taxed. 
 Officials agonise: will the Japanese then become as eager to shirk work as the Swedes are? 
 Some economists at Sanwa Bank take an even gloomier view. 
 The conventional guess, based on the ups and downs of the business cycle, says that Japan's GNP will grow by 3&ndash;4% in 1991, then bounce back to 5% or so for years thereafter. 
 The Sanwa economists, looking instead at Japan's contracting labour force, the decline in the savings rate as the population ages, and the heftier welfare bill that will soon start coming due, think that GNP growth will average only 2&ndash;3% for the rest of the 1990s and may fall lower still after that. 
 This is a perfectly respectable analysis, based on the idea that an economy's long-run growth cannot exceed the growth in its labour force. 
 In practice it overlooks two things. 
 One is the effect of technological progress on productivity growth. 
 The other is that Japan has, for the next decade anyway, an easy way of expanding its labour force even though population growth is slowing down. 
 How? 
 Forget about immigration. 
 Japan's ruling Liberal Democrats would no more dare sanction an open-door policy for Asia's migrant workers than would Britain's Conservatives risk letting in thousands more from Jamaica or Pakistan. 
 One way the labour force can keep growing is if the retirement age goes up. 
 That will happen to some extent (and will also take some pressure off pensions). 
 But Japan will enjoy a different spur to growth. 
 Its share of women in work is higher than most rich countries' (see chart), but their work tends to be in more menial jobs. 
 Sooner or later, the social practices that keep Japanese women out of good jobs will be swept away by economic circumstances. 
 The upgrading should give Japan a decade or two before the big problems of an old workforce have to be faced.  
 Bougainville 
 Peace in prospect 
 FROM the earliest days of European conquest in the Pacific, the people on the island of Bougainville were regarded as stubborn and easily provoked. 
 But the Germans admired them for their toughness and energy and in 1898 persuaded Britain, which then ran Bougainville, to swap the island for some German possessions elsewhere in the Pacific. 
 The British were glad to dispose of these &bquo;Huns in black skins&equo;. 
 Germany added Bougainville to its territory in what is now Papua New Guinea. 
 When, in 1975, PNG won its independence from Australia (which had been running the place since 1949), Bougainville formally became part of the new country. 
 Resentment about the link has continued ever since; it is the main cause of the present rebellion in Bougainville. 
 In an effort to bring peace to the island, PNG held talks with the rebels last August on board a New Zealand warship moored off Bougainville. 
 They came to nothing. 
 This week the two sides met again, this time in Honiara, the capital of the Solomon Islands. 
 On January 24th they announced the signing of the &bquo;Honiara accord&equo;. 
 This proposes that a force made up of soldiers from Pacific countries be invited to Bougainville to restore peace. 
 Papua New Guinea will end its blockade of Bougainville. 
 PNG soldiers will stay out of the island and the &bquo;Bougainville Revolutionary Army&equo;, which has led the rebellion, will be disbanded. 
 The accord will be reviewed every six months. 
 If either side dishonours it, the accord will be scrapped. 
 Sir Michael Somare, PNG's chief negotiator, called the accord an &bquo;important and historical document&equo;. 
 However, it does not deal with the central point of the rebellion: Bougainville's desire for independence. 
 By treating the rebels as equals, PNG appears to be conceding it in all but name. 
 Despite the blockade, Bougainville has been managing quite well as a self-proclaimed independent country. 
 Most of the 300,000 people live off the land and no one has gone hungry. 
 A few luxuries have been smuggled in by canoe from the Solomons, which Bougainville is geographically and culturally close to. 
 Medical supplies are scarce, but as a prelude to this week's talks PNG allowed some to come in from Australia. 
 No country has so far recognised Bougainville's claim to independence. 
 Any that might would be warned off by Australia, which takes a protective interest in its former colony. 
 Australia would be happy if the accord led to the reopening of the Panguna copper mine, one of the world's biggest. 
 It was closed because of the rebellion. 
 When it was operating, the mine was managed by an Australian subsidiary of Britain's RTZ. 
 Bougainville is in a strong position to demand concessions in the talks that will follow the accord. 
 One demand is for compensation for damage done to the land by open-cast mining. 
 But many of the islanders are against any deal with PNG. 
 They believe they would be better off on their own. 
 Tourism, neglected by PNG, has potential. 
 For one thing Bougainville, the scene of some of the fiercest fighting in the second world war, is a largely untouched museum of wrecked warplanes. 
 Somewhere in the jungle, awaiting the homage of patriotic Japanese, is the remains of the aircraft of Isoroku Yamamoto, who planned the attack on Pearl Harbour.  
 Australia 
 Keating's turn? 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN SYDNEY 
 IT IS an old joke, but it sums up the present mood in Australia. 
 If you had only two bullets, who would you shoot among Saddam Hussein, Yasser Arafat or Paul Keating? 
 Answer: Paul Keating, twice. 
 His bluntness, often amounting to personal abuse, has won Australia's treasurer (finance minister) few friends. 
 Add this to the state of the economy &mdash; production down, unemployment up and interest rates still high &mdash; and it is hardly surprising that he is deeply unpopular. 
 Yet Mr Keating continues to believe that he will be Australia's next prime minister. 
 Even more alarming for some Australians, this could come sooner rather than later. 
 Although Bob Hawke says he intends to lead the Labor Party into the next general election, due by 1993, the toppling of Margaret Thatcher has shown that even the mightiest are vulnerable. 
 Like Britain's Tory Party before Mrs Thatcher fell, the Labor Party is way down in the opinion polls. 
 It is 18 percentage points behind the Liberal-National coalition. 
 As in Britain last year, there is plenty of speculation about changing the leader. 
 In some remarks at the National Press Club in December, Mr Keating gave credence to this speculation by saying, in effect, that he would make a better prime minister than Mr Hawke. 
 The remarks were supposed to be private, but they were too juicy for the journalists to keep to themselves. 
 There, though, the comparison between Britain and Australia ends. 
 Why would the Labor Party exchange Mr Hawke for someone even more unpopular? 
 Still, some observers say that Mr Keating already leads the party. 
 He is its intellectual driving force. 
 His supporters say that if, in the end, he decided to quit, it would be a disaster for the economy. 
 He has made mistakes, but nobody is more committed to opening up Australia's still-stuffy economy. 
 Mr Keating's main mistake was to loosen monetary policy by too much after the 1987 stockmarket crash, fuelling an unsustainable boom. 
 But he was not the only finance minister in the world to do that. 
 He is still respected in the financial markets, even though voters disagree. 
 Could Australia get out of recession in time for the next general election? 
 It could, easily. 
 A lot of the figures are grim. 
 Real GDP fell in three of the four quarters in the year to September, with output down 6.4% at an annual rate in the third quarter. 
 Unemployment has already risen to 8.1%, from 5.9% in late 1989. 
 Slow growth abroad is depressing commodity prices and the government will need to keep monetary policy tight for some time to avoid re-stoking inflation and the current-account deficit. 
 The Reserve Bank (the central bank) has cut its interest rate by six percentage points over the past year, yet it is still 12%. 
 Even so, there has already been one triumph: inflation fell to 6% in the year to the third quarter, the lowest rate for 18 years apart from a brief spell in 1984&ndash;85. 
 Growth could well have picked up, and unemployment fallen, by the time Labor has to face the voters again. 
 Whether as finance minister or prime minister, Mr Keating will still have plenty to do. 
 Top of the list is labour-market reform. 
 Back in 1983 many economists were sceptical about the wage accord negotiated by the Labor government with the unions. 
 Yet it has restrained pay. 
 Real wages in Australia have fallen by 5% over the past seven years; in Britain they have risen by almost 20%. 
 The trouble is that the system cramps productivity gains. 
 In the 1980s Australia's labour productivity was one of the lowest in the OECD. 
 The accord might also act as a floor to wages during the recession. 
 The total wage rise of 6.25% built into the 1990&ndash;91 accord looks too high. 
 A weak labour market offers Mr Keating a chance for reform, if only Labor and the unions would let him. 
 Many Labor politicians, believing deregulation has failed, hanker after old policies. 
 They like a recent report by the Australian Manufacturing Council, which calls for the government to support industry and promote exports. 
 The Labor Party might learn something from New Zealand. 
 Its new National government plans to abandon compulsory unionism and centralised wage fixing. 
 New Zealand's previous Labour government found itself unable to complete the job of economic liberalisation, and its members bickered among themselves. 
 Voters got fed up and threw Labour out. 
 The lesson for Australia's Labor Party is clear: be bold under Mr Keating or prepare to bow out.  
 Ordeal of an honest cop 
 FROM OUR SOUTH-EAST ASIA CORRESPONDENT 
 BANGKOK 
 JANUARY has not been a distinguished month for the Thai police. 
 An attempt was made to blow up a police chief. 
 Another police chief was sacked. 
 And some pro-Iraqi terrorists apparently escaped arrest. 
 The terrorists first. 
 On January 19th the American embassy in Bangkok told the police that weapons and explosives had been moved out of &bquo;an embassy of an Arab country involved in the war&equo;. 
 The Americans refused to confirm publicly that the embassy was Iraq's. 
 Westerners in Bangkok were advised to keep their heads down for 48 hours. 
 The assumption was that the police had been given enough information to pick up the terrorists quickly. 
 But they were not nabbed, and the warning was extended by a week. 
 At buildings considered potential targets soldiers took over from police. 
 Diplomats expressed no more than disappointment at the lack of progress (but that's why they are diplomats). 
 For their part, Thai officials reject the suggestion of a link between the failure to get the would-be bombers and the sacking of the national police chief, Police-General Sawaeng Thirasawat. 
 But he was under a cloud anyway after his men failed to find who had placed a bomb in the office of Major-General Seri Temiyaveh, the head of the Bangkok police department's crime-suppression division. 
 Right after the explosion, on January 8th, the prime minister said the bomber had to be found within two weeks. 
 By midnight on January 21st no leads had been uncovered. 
 General Sawaeng was sacked two hours later for &bquo;ineptness&equo;. 
 General Seri has a reputation of being an honest copper. 
 On taking office last year he told his men they must drop their &bquo;vested interests&equo; &mdash; a polite term for rake-offs from gambling dens, short-stay hotels and other sinful activities in Bangkok. 
 The Siam Rath Weekly, a Thai-language magazine, claimed that junior police officers in the division could make 50,000&ndash;60,000 baht (&dollar;2,000&ndash;2,400) extra a month from these sources; for senior officers, it could be as much as 5m baht a month. 
 General Seri's predecessor as head of the crime-suppression division, and his leading opponent within the police force, is one of the graduates of the Chulachomklao Military Academy who now run the Thai armed forces. 
 Thus the problems in the division became yet another battleground between the civilian government and the military. 
 Faced with a loss of income, General Seri's officers attacked him in leaflets and graffiti. 
 They lampooned him on the division's radio station. 
 Newspapers speculate that the 1lb of TNT that went off 25 minutes before the general arrived in his office was the next stage of this campaign. 
 The public breakdown of discipline in the crime-suppression division has at last destroyed the faith of many Thais in the police. 
 Organised crime and corruption have grown along with the rest of the economy. 
 Local gangsters field private armies; intimidation and assassination of business rivals are commonplace. 
 There are signs of increased activity in Thailand by the Japanese yakuza, Chinese triads and now by international terrorists as well. 
 The appointment of General Seri was supposed to show the government's resolve to fight the criminals. 
 It has shown instead how deeply entrenched the &bquo;vested interests&equo; have become.  
 A quarrel in a far-away country, of which Asia knows nothing 
 Practically all the governments and most of the people in Europe and North America back the alliance against Saddam Hussein. 
 At the least, they understand something big is at stake. 
 It is different in Asia. 
 Our correspondents throughout the region report 
 SADDAM HUSSEIN has fewer detractors in Asia, the American-led operation against him fewer sympathisers. 
 Mostly, though, Asians find the whole thing an embarrassing distraction that they wish would just go away. 
 Seoul's English-language Korea Times caught the mood. 
 Its interview with the Iraqi ambassador, published on January 16th just hours before the allies attacked, was dramatically headlined: &bquo;Economy vital sector for Iraq-Korea ties&equo;. 
 Like it or not, however, Asian countries are inevitably being drawn into the conflict. 
 The economic consequences are impossible to ignore. 
 For the poor countries of the Indian subcontinent and for the Philippines, the loss of remittances from the hundreds of thousands of workers in Iraq and Kuwait pinches badly. 
 For everyone in Asia, higher energy prices hurt even more. 
 Petrol prices are up nearly 30% in South Korea, and supplies are down by perhaps half in India. 
 The Philippines has succumbed to war fever. 
 Shops in Manila have been stripped bare in panic buying, there have been runs on banks, and the government has advised city-folk to grow vegetables in their gardens and to stop ironing clothes to save energy. 
 The terrorism that the West dreads has already struck in Asia. 
 The Iraqis sent two of their own men to plant a bomb in an American-run library in Manila on January 19th. 
 It went off prematurely, leaving half of one of the Iraqis on a nearby roof and the other under arrest. 
 It worries Thailand that the bombers were carrying air tickets to take them back to Bangkok, which they had left for Manila in December. 
 The day after their attack, the American embassy in Thailand gave warning that it knew of a &bquo;credible threat&equo; to American, British and Australian interests in Bangkok. 
 The Thais suspect that Japan's Red Army Faction, which has old ties to Middle Eastern terrorism, may be involved. 
 Asia's governments have responded to the war with varying degrees of enthusiasm, discomfort and cynicism. 
 Top of the cynics is China. 
 The Chinese have given just enough support to the allies to bring themselves back into favour with the western governments, particularly America's, that had spurned them after the Tiananmen Square massacre in 1989. 
 At the same time they have kept their support tepid enough not to threaten their pose as the Palestinians' champion. 
 Thus China backed the Security Council's moves against Iraq until the resolution authorising force, on which it abstained. 
 It calls on Iraq to leave Kuwait but also opposes the allied attack. 
 As usual with Chinese foreign policy, this suits the government &mdash; though not necessarily the Chinese in the street. 
 The American embassy in Beijing is said to have received envelopes containing a few yuan as contributions from ordinary Chinese to the war effort; and young would-be volunteer fighters have offered their services at the Kuwaiti and Saudi embassies. 
 Probably, such gestures say more about the Chinese people's view of their own government than about their solidarity with Kuwait. 
 The stoutest backing for the allies has come from Australia, Singapore and the Philippines. 
 Last August Australia sent three naval ships to the Gulf; Bob Hawke, the prime minister, made it clear in December that they would be put under American operational control and could well see combat. 
 This week parliament gave his policy its strong support, and most Australians are with Mr Hawke too. 
 A Gallup poll published on January 15th showed 57% in favour of using force to expel Iraq from Kuwait, and 54% for Australia joining in the fighting under American command. 
 Singapore is sending a 30-man army medical team: a token of its long-standing conviction that aggression has to be punished wherever it happens. 
 Even Corazon Aquino, the Philippine president, has opted uncharacteristically for firmness. 
 She has backed the allied attack on Iraq &bquo;without reservations&equo;, and the Philippines has a medical team in Saudi Arabia. 
 Yet forthrightness is far from most Asian leaders' minds. 
 Mahathir Mohamad, the Malaysian prime minister, dreamily says he wants the bombs to stop falling on Iraq and also for Iraq to leave Kuwait. 
 New Zealand, which used to have a habit of joining up with its main western allies in other people's fights, has ruled out sending soldiers. 
 The neutralist and anti-American feelings let loose during the prime ministership of David Lange in 1984&ndash;89 have taken their toll: nearly two-thirds of New Zealanders like this stand-offish attitude. 
 India knows its quest for peace talks through the Non-Aligned Movement will bear no fruit, but it is in keeping with the popular mood. 
 Indians tell the poll-takers that their country should stay clear of the whole business. 
 Hindus blame George Bush and Saddam Hussein equally for the war. 
 Three-quarters of Indian Muslims blame Mr Bush, and 45% of Muslims think that Iraq will actually win the war. 
 South Korea, which has a large and tough army, also has bad memories of its experience in contributing soldiers to America's effort in Vietnam. 
 It is relieved that the most the Americans now want (apart from money, naturally, of which the Koreans are putting up &dollar;220m) is for Korea to take over more of the job of defending itself, thus freeing American troops and equipment based in Korea for duty in the Gulf. 
 Two countries that have sent fighting men to the Gulf &mdash; Pakistan (with 10,000 soldiers in Saudi Arabia) and Bangladesh &mdash; are twisting and turning over their decision, mainly because it is so unpopular. 
 Reverential pictures of Saddam Hussein are on display in Pakistan's big cities. 
 Nawaz Sharif, the Pakistani prime minister, is under particular pressure from within his own party. 
 To reduce the criticism, he is spending this week touring Middle Eastern capitals on a showy &bquo;peace mission&equo;. 
 Nobody, however, is squirming more than Japan's government, whose indecision and vacillation since the Kuwait saga began have irritated everyone, the Americans above all. 
 The government's efforts to get a bill through parliament allowing soldiers to be sent to the Gulf in non-combat roles came to nothing. 
 The long dither that preceded the commitment of &dollar;4 billion to the alliance took the shine off the contribution. 
 The Americans have been pressing for much more money. 
 One rumour is that they are asking Japan to kick in 20% of the cost of fighting the war. 
 Once again this week the government of Toshiki Kaifu was manfully trying to agree on something &mdash; and once again hesitating. 
 A press conference Mr Kaifu had scheduled for Wednesday evening to explain what the government had decided was called off at the last minute. 
 By next day, though, the government confirmed that Japan will contribute &dollar;9 billion more to the Allies, a figure that had already been leaked. 
 The figure, a generous one, neatly fits the American demand. 
 If the war is indeed costing the &dollar;500m a day that the Japanese say the Americans are estimating, then a 20% Japanese contribution would amount to around &dollar;3 billion a month. 
 A three-month war equals a &dollar;9 billion bill for Japan. 
 The money can be raised by higher taxes, a government bond issue or a combination of both. 
 Higher taxes could well sink Mr Kaifu with the voters: a 3% consumption tax in 1989 lost the ruling party the upper house. 
 One course being considered is to issue short-term deficit-financing bonds and to increase taxes on oil and oil products, an idea that Japan's oil industry has already begun lobbying against. 
 Any proposal will be in trouble if it has to be approved by the upper house of parliament as well as the lower house. 
 The upper house is controlled by a Socialist opposition totally against both the war and Japan's having anything to do with it. 
 The opposition will be particularly upset by a proposal, also announced on Thursday, to send Japanese military aircraft to the Middle East to move refugees, which it calls &bquo;evacuees&equo;, to Asia. 
 This would be the first time that Japan's &bquo;self-defence&equo; forces had operated far from home. 
 Even if Mr Kaifu can deliver a package, he will probably be doing so in the teeth of public opinion (especially if a tax increase is involved). 
 A telephone poll conducted by TV Asahi on January 17th found only 25% in favour of the war and 53% against. 
 Non-white man's non-burden 
 Why do Asians see the Kuwait affair so differently from Europeans and Americans? 
 In much of Asia one answer is Islam. 
 Anywhere there are sizeable Muslim populations the war against Iraq is being portrayed by the devout as an attack by the West on Islam, however poorly this squares with the facts. 
 Those Pakistani pictures of Saddam Hussein show him at prayer. 
 India's Shia Muslims, who were antagonistic to Mr Hussein over his war against Iran, have rallied to him with surprising haste. 
 Mr Abdul Halim Arshat, the secretary-general of Malaysia's leading Islamic political party, has claimed that &bquo;support for Iraq is necessary as the real motive of the US is to kill off the Muslims in Baghdad and to destroy the city.&equo; 
 His party has appealed for volunteers to help Iraq in non-combat roles; 20 gung-ho young men have stepped forward. 
 West v Islam shades imperceptibly into West v East. 
 There is an undercurrent of feeling all across Asia, even in the rich parts, that this is a white man's war, a new outbreak of old-fashioned colonialism. 
 Anti-colonialism is a powerful theme in modern Asia. 
 Japanese who admit their country was wrong in its aggressions of 1930&ndash;45 nonetheless point out that in part they were trying to rescue Asia from western colonialism. 
 This appeal has been known to override other considerations. 
 During the second world war Burmese and Indonesian nationalists allied themselves with the Japanese, finding them a useful lever against the colonial power and in some ways preferable to it. 
 In India at the same time Subhas Chandra Bose collaborated first with the Germans and then with the Japanese against the British Raj. 
 He was widely seen by Indians as a hero then, and still is. 
 The biggest reason for Asia's sceptical eye on the Gulf, though, is that not many Asians are convinced the fight makes any difference. 
 Yes, it is too bad about the Kuwaitis; but oil is a commodity and Iraq will have to sell it just as Kuwait did. 
 If it does not, the stuff can easily be bought elsewhere. 
 Yes, Saddam Hussein is a bad man, but that is a problem for his neighbours, especially the Israelis, not us. 
 Behind the indifference is the assumption that the basis of Asian security will not be affected. 
 America will win, it is thought, and win handily enough that it will not want to withdraw from Asia: so China, Japan, whoever, should pursue its own interests and wait for things to return to normal. 
 Some disagree with this line of thinking &mdash; notably Ichiro Ozawa, the secretary-general of Japan's ruling party, who has been arguing for Japanese soldiers to be sent to the Gulf in a non-combat role &mdash; but they have not had much luck making their case. 
 The result? 
 If they were not told the embarrassing source of these words &mdash; and perhaps even if they were &mdash; most Asians would give a vigorous nod of approval to the sentiments expressed by Neville Chamberlain when Germany annexed the Sudetenland in 1938: &bquo;How horrible, fantastic, incredible it is that we should be digging trenches and trying on gas-masks here because of a quarrel in a far-away country between people of whom we know nothing.&equo; 
 EUROPE 
 Comme vous &eacute;tiez 
 FROM OUR PARIS CORRESPONDENT 
 ONE war, at least, is over. 
 Six weeks after battle was joined over the proposed &bquo;rectification&equo; of French spelling, the resistance fighters appear to have won the day. 
 The Acad&eacute;mie Fran&ccedil;aise, that illustrious guardian of the French language, set up by Richelieu in 1635, last week in effect buried the very reform for which it had voted unanimously nine months earlier. 
 By 23 votes to six, the Academy decided that the changes in spelling rules &mdash; proposed by a working party of the government-appointed Conseil Sup&eacute;rieur de la Langue Fran&ccedil;aise under the chairmanship of the Academy's own permanent secretary &mdash; should not be enforced in any way (not even through school circulars or inclusion in new dictionaries), but should be made subject to the &bquo;test of time&equo;. 
 The Academy has &bquo;reserved the right to confirm or annul&equo; the changes after an undefined &bquo;period of observation&equo;. 
 A happy precedent already exists: three years ago the Academy agreed to abandon a series of spelling changes that it had proposed in 1975, but which had never found their way into common usage. 
 This time the spelling changes had the backing of the government as well as of the Academy. 
 But the government is unlikely to press ahead with what the Academy has disavowed. 
 So it looks as if cameramen (rather than the proposed cameramans) will be able to get on with their work in the Gulf; the beloved accent on ab&icirc;me will not fall into the abyss; and the whole affair will have been a non-&eacute;v&eacute;nement.  
 Reform in Eastern Europe: Poland 
 Look on the bright side 
 FROM OUR WARSAW CORRESPONDENT 
 Bad news about Eastern Europe is drowning out the good news. 
 Wrongly. 
 In a series of articles, we aim to start redressing the balance 
 GLOOM and doom are all the rage in Eastern Europe. 
 Poland, one year after starting a strict anti-inflation programme, is said to be a particularly terrible place. 
 Statistics are cited to prove the depth of popular misery: falling real wages, rising unemployment, a catastrophic drop in production, a general collapse of living standards. 
 But look more closely at the statistics, look at what is really happening on the streets and in the shops, look at how people's lives are changing, and it becomes clear that things are not nearly as bad as they are painted. 
 True, the Polish reform has had its faults. 
 Privatisation has been too slow. 
 The dominant state industry still awaits a proper shake-out. 
 Inflation remains 5% a month, a big improvement on a year ago but still worrying. 
 Yet all these faults suggest that the reform, far from being too bold, has not been bold enough. 
 The government reckoned that Poles were having to cope with about as much economic pain as they would tolerate. 
 Life has certainly been tough in Poland over the past year. 
 But has it really been tougher than before? 
 Official figures greatly exaggerate the drop in industrial production (which is said to have fallen by almost a third last year). 
 One reason is that previous years' figures were bloated by communist managers with an interest in padding their production numbers to get bonuses or promotion. 
 Performance was measured against the plan, not the market. 
 Now, in contrast, managers are tempted to under-report their performance, to avoid taxes. 
 If some factories are now producing fewer feet-breaking shoes and unusable machines than they were a year ago, so much the better. 
 And if others are producing smaller amounts of goods that people actually want to buy, fine. 
 One steel factory in Silesia found that it could no longer afford to make the heavily subsidised, high-quality steel it used to produce before the new budgetary regime, so it began to make smaller quantities of low-quality steel, which it found could be exported to Germany at a profit. 
 Factories reducing production in order to change their technology or improve quality &mdash; even factories going bankrupt &mdash; are excellent signs of industrial restructuring. 
 Many economists say bankruptcy figures in Poland are still too low. 
 But what really distorts the official statistics is that they are based almost entirely on the state economy. 
 They fail to account for the boom in private enterprise. 
 Any visitor to Poland immediately sees what the figures fail to reflect. 
 Every Polish town now has its street market, where everything from imported toothpaste to once-unavailable Polish ham can be bought. 
 Queues have virtually disappeared. 
 Some estimates of the size of the private sector do exist. 
 The Polish government's statistical office believes that the output of private industry (excluding farming) grew by 50% over the past year, and that it now accounts for 18% of national income, up from 11% in 1989. 
 The number of people employed in private enterprise, the government's statisticians guess, grew by more than 500,000 in 1989, bringing the total to between 1.8m and 2m people. 
 Keeping it private 
 But much of Poland's private industry goes unrecorded. 
 Private traders, plumbers, carpenters and truckers under-report their income, fearing Poland's high taxes. 
 Average income in the private sector is probably about three times that in the state sector, but no one knows for sure. 
 What about the &bquo;30% drop in the standard of living&equo; so often referred to? 
 This number comes from comparing the figures of 1990 with those of 1989 &mdash; a year of hyper-inflation, when wages grew astronomically. 
 A comparison of 1990 with 1987 yields a drop in real wages of only 2&ndash;3%. 
 Even this fails to account for some unmeasurable changes. 
 Polish housewives no longer have to spend two hours a day in queues, and they can choose between 15 brands of mineral water, when once only one diesel-flavoured Polish brand was on offer. 
 Another seldom-mentioned change in the Polish standard of living is the increase in dollar purchasing-power brought about by the newly stable zloty. 
 At the black-market rate for the dollar, the average Polish monthly wage in October 1987 was &dollar;40. 
 In October 1990 it was &dollar;131. 
 This means that, though many foreign goods are still way out of reach for most Poles, others are suddenly at fingertip-end. 
 Psychologists speculate that much of the current dissatisfaction with the economy is caused by the presence of previously unattainable consumer products like VCRs, which are now available but still too expensive for most Poles. 
 The most misleading figures are those on unemployment. 
 Commentators, both in Poland and abroad, are fond of repeating that unemployment went &bquo;from zero to 1.2m&equo; in the past year: up to about 7% of the labour force. 
 But &bquo;zero&equo; refers to the communist era, when unemployment officially did not exist. 
 When the government first began to register the jobless and offer unemployment money, thousands of people, including housewives, who had never held jobs signed up. 
 Traders and other private entrepreneurs also signed up in order to supplement their unregistered incomes. 
 The ministry of labour suspects that about half of the unemployed have indeed been laid off, but other evidence suggests that at least in some parts of the country the proportion is much lower. 
 In most big cities advertisements for workers, from plumbers to car mechanics, go unanswered for weeks. 
 If the news is really not so bad, why hasn't the government said so? 
 Partly because for the past year the finance minister, Leszek Balcerowicz, and the former prime minister, Tadeusz Mazowiecki, stuck to a policy of preparing the nation for the worst. 
 The current government wants to change this approach, which helped Mr Mazowiecki lose last month's presidential election. 
 Yet it still finds that the official statistics-gathering system is designed to measure the state economy, but not the rapidly growing private one. 
 It is also true that public complaining, impossible under the old regime, has grown enormously with the advent of a free press. 
 Things may well have been a lot worse five years ago. 
 But back then there was no open way to blame the government, and no way at all to vote it out.  
 No surrender in Vilnius 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN LITHUANIA 
 TO BE in the Baltic states is to be in the West. 
 Vilnius is an image of Europe before modernisation. 
 In the old town, streets barely altered since the 18th century circle the university. 
 From the old town a broad boulevard, called Gedimino (formerly Lenin Avenue), leads to the parliament building. 
 Before it gets there a barricade of grey concrete blocks daubed with &bquo;Free Lithuania&equo; and &bquo;Independence for Baltic Countries&equo; has been drawn across the street. 
 Behind it lies a scene out of a medieval siege. 
 The parliament building sits in a square like the keep of a castle. 
 At the heart of the square, 24 hours a day, old women sing hymns to a statue of the Virgin, below which hangs a list of the 14 Lithuanians killed by Soviet troops on January 13th. 
 Portable kitchens dispense free cups of tea. 
 People cluster around wood fires to keep off the night chill. 
 Classical music &mdash; Handel and hymns &mdash; fills the square with reminders of the western values at stake. 
 Barbed wire and every lump of building material that the Lithuanians could lay their hands on have been commandeered for self-defence. 
 These serve as billboards for symbolic displays. 
 Text books are impaled on the barbed wire: &bquo;A history of the Communist Party&equo;, &bquo;An Introduction to Marxism-Leninism&equo;. 
 Every inch of the wire is festooned with cartoons of Mikhail Gorbachev as Stalin, Hitler or Saddam Hussein. 
 But the defences have no military significance. 
 Tanks would roll over them in moments. 
 Inside the parliament building Lithuania's last redoubt is being prepared. 
 The building is as bland as a modern concert hall: a place of marble floors, wide foyers and sweeping staircases. 
 Last summer, strolling down the steps, Lithuania's deputy president remarked that: &bquo;Yes, it's a fine building but difficult to work in. 
 We prefer something with historical resonance.&equo; 
 The Lithuanians believe that their history will soon be made in it. 
 The parliament has become a garrison. 
 Sandbags block the entrances. 
 Sleeping bags are piled on windowsills. 
 On top of them lie hunting rifles and gas masks. 
 At night &mdash; when an attack is most likely &mdash; the temperature falls below freezing because the heating has been switched off. 
 People sleep on the floor or huddle round television sets. 
 Some 300 young men are waiting in the parliament to be killed. 
 Like the barricades outside, the Lithuanians' hunting rifles are military toys. 
 The building cannot realistically be defended. 
 If Soviet soldiers get in to the parliament there will be a bloodbath. 
 The army may have been holding back because it is reluctant to make martyrs. 
 By resorting to guns, even toy ones, are the Lithuanians forfeiting the rights of democrats and putting themselves on the same level as the Soviet troops? 
 The Lithuanians reckon the moment has arrived for defending their country with every means they have. 
 The nation is haunted by what happened in 1940, when it metaphorically came out with its hands up as Soviet tanks rolled in while world war was raging. 
 The young men in the parliament have taken an oath of allegiance to the Lithuanian state, swearing to defend it to the death.  
 France 
 Rebellion on the right 
 FROM OUR PARIS CORRESPONDENT 
 TWO conservative rebels are set to test public support for an upheaval within France's ailing right-wing opposition. 
 The rebels deliberately provoked the parliamentary by-elections to be held on January 27th by resigning last month both from their parliamentary seats and from their party, the neo-Gaullist Rassemblement pour la R&eacute;publique (RPR). 
 Michel Noir, the dashing young mayor of Lyons, and Mich&egrave;le Barzach, an ex-minister of health and a former prot&eacute;g&eacute;e of Jacques Chirac, the RPR leader, are standing for re-election as independents against official RPR candidates. 
 It is the fourth time since Mr Chirac's humiliating defeat in the presidential election three years ago that the discredited yet seemingly immovable leadership of the right has been challenged. 
 Until the unexpected Socialist victory in 1981, the right had held undisputed sway in France for quarter of a century. 
 Conservatives had come to believe that they were the rightful rulers of the country. 
 With Fran&ccedil;ois Mitterrand's re-election for a second seven-year term in 1988, they had to face the demoralising prospect of being out of power for 14 years. 
 Many, particularly among the younger deputies, were convinced that something radical had to be done. 
 But what? 
 One persistent idea has been that the two main moderate right-wing parties, the Rassemblement pour la R&eacute;publique and the Union pour la D&eacute;mocratie Fran&ccedil;aise, must get together if they are to have any chance of regaining power. 
 But each time this has been tried, it comes up against the apparently irreconcilable rivalries of the three figures who have dominated the French right for the past 15 years &mdash; Jacques Chirac, Val&eacute;ry Giscard d'Estaing and (to a lesser extent) Raymond Barre. 
 Past attempts to remove the old leaders have all failed. 
 Mr Noir and Mrs Barzach are counting this time on the growing public irritation with the leadership squabbles and on general disillusionment with party politics to boost their cause. 
 Opinion polls suggest that the two rebels have attracted a lot of sympathy. 
 Mr Noir's popularity rating has jumped 12 points since his resignation, making him the person on the right whom the French would &bquo;most like to see playing an important role in the future&equo;. 
 Much of his new support has come from the left, however. 
 Among right-wing voters, he still ranks only fifth in popularity (Mr Chirac comes top). 
 He is nevertheless expected to have an easy win in the Lyons constituency he has represented for the past 13 years. 
 The interest lies in the size of his victory. 
 Mrs Barzach will have a much more difficult time retaining her seat in the 15th arrondissement of Paris, which she has represented for only the past three years and where she is standing against the well-established local RPR mayor (and deputy mayor of the capital). 
 A victory for her would be regarded as a particularly bitter blow for Mr Chirac, who has been campaigning in support of her rival. 
 Mr Noir, Mrs Barzach and a third rebel RPR deputy, Jean-Michel Dubernard (who is standing for re-election against Mr Noir's son-in-law in Lyons), claim they have no desire to form a new party, despite their launch this week of a glossy 35-page &bquo;Contract for a New Democracy&equo;, which bears all the hallmarks of a party manifesto. 
 It diverges widely from the RPR's official line on many points, notably in its wholehearted support for European political and monetary union. 
 If elected, the three dissidents say they will continue to sit in the opposition as independents. 
 They will nevertheless be eagerly awaiting signs of defections to their ranks among other right-wing deputies. 
 Many will be tempted; few are likely to take what still looks like a suicidal step.  
 Setting up shop 
 FROM OUR BUCHAREST CORRESPONDENT 
 THE lights are going on in Bucharest. 
 For years its shops have been empty and dark (they had no bulbs). 
 Today a shopping revolution is taking place in the Romanian capital. 
 Every day new private shops and kiosks open selling a range of goods simply never seen before, from pineapple juice to fax machines. 
 With astonishing speed prime spots in streets known for fashionable shopping before the second world war are being snapped up. 
 People who want to open more shops complain that it is becoming ever harder, and more expensive, to find and bribe the correct official responsible for allocating premises. 
 Every month the authorities are issuing up to 14,000 new business permits, many of them for shops and stalls. 
 Foreigners are interested too. 
 An Italian entrepreneur has taken over a whole department store to sell western goods in Romanian currency. 
 He plans to use the money to build holiday homes for Italians on the Black Sea. 
 Bucharest's shops are supplying a population deprived for years of everything but the poorest-quality basics. 
 But there is a snag. 
 Many will sell only for hard currency and all are expensive. 
 Since the leu is not yet convertible, shopkeepers have no choice but to pass on their hard-currency costs to the customers. 
 Few of the goods available in the new shops are made in Romania. 
 So far the shopkeepers are surviving, because demand is so great, but few are yet admitting to doing anything other than breaking even. 
 The shops are supplied by a variety of means. 
 Either their owners travel abroad or, increasingly, they can buy from Bucharest wholesalers (many of whom are Arabs). 
 Some shopkeepers have foreign partners who supply them. 
 Others have asked to have their shop classified as a consignatie, or &bquo;commission&equo; store. 
 In these, people who have been abroad bring foreign goods for sale. 
 The shop takes a commission on sales and the seller has helped pay for his trip. 
 Despite the high prices, goods are moving. 
 A kilo of bananas costs the equivalent of a day's wages. 
 Since bananas have not been seen in Romania for years and many children have never eaten one before, they sell quickly. 
 So do other goods, such as batteries, which are rarely found in state shops. 
 Alcohol and western cigarettes are best sellers. 
 Many of the new shops look a mess. 
 They jumble together shampoos, toys, chocolate, clothes, electronic goods and hair slides. 
 The owners say that they are so new to the game that for the moment they are selling everything because they do not know what will eventually prove profitable. 
 The rest of the economy remains in deep trouble, with the government hesitant to introduce painful reform, especially in subsidised state industry. 
 The government is happy to see visible signs in Bucharest's new shops that at least something is changing amid the general economic gloom. 
 But it is not overjoyed that so many shops are concentrating on whisky and cigarettes. 
 &bquo;At first I was upset by this development,&equo; said one official, &bquo;but then I realised that with so many places selling the same things either they would go bust or they would have to channel their efforts into other, more necessary things.&equo; 
 Not yet. 
 But the prices of some goods are coming down. 
 For the first time in the lives of many Romanians, they can &bquo;shop around&equo;.  
 EC farm reform 
 That's the way the money goes 
 FROM OUR BRUSSELS CORRESPONDENT 
 IN REAL markets, oversupply causes prices to fall. 
 Production drops and supply and demand return to balance. 
 In the Alice-in-Wonderland world of European agriculture, farmers are paid more to grow more even when nobody wants to buy what they produce. 
 Further, the EC's common agricultural policy (CAP) seems virtually reform-proof: efforts over the years to undo its worst nonsenses have had little success. 
 Now, under the internal threat of unmanageable surpluses and external (mainly American) demands for cuts in its export subsidies, the Community is trying again. 
 American pressure by itself will not succeed in reforming the CAP, as the deadlocked GATT talks on trade liberalisation clearly show. 
 But the piling-up of EC surpluses of beef, dairy products and cereals could &mdash; up to a point. 
 The thrust of the reforms being prepared by the farm commissioner, Ireland's Ray MacSharry, and his colleagues is to reduce guaranteed prices and to pay more income support to farmers. 
 Europeans pay twice for the Community's farm madness: as consumers and as taxpayers. 
 Consumers pay inflated food prices because their market is insulated by levies from lower-priced imports. 
 Taxpayers pay the subsidies needed to dump overpriced EC surpluses abroad. 
 For example, although they do not know it yet, EC taxpayers will probably end up paying &dollar;580m on a cut-price sale of 200,000 tonnes of butter to the Soviet Union which is currently being completed. 
 The EC price for a tonne of butter is the equivalent of &dollar;4,000; the Russians are to pay &dollar;1,100, and the EC budget will cover the difference. 
 The deal is not affected by this week's decision to slow down part of the emergency aid agreed upon by the Twelve in December because of the repression in the Baltic republics. 
 The Community could signal displeasure by refusing to do any other special deals with Moscow. 
 The trouble is that no other country is prepared to pay even as much (ie, little) as the Russians for surplus EC butter; much of it would go rancid in the Community's cold stores. 
 Each minor modification of the CAP has been hailed by its authors as the definitive reform. 
 The introduction of a timid levy on milk producers 12 years ago was supposed to end dairy surpluses: &bquo;A new start for the CAP&equo;, said a European Commission document at the time. 
 In 1986, with the Community still awash with milk, production quotas were imposed on dairy farmers. 
 Guaranteed support was also cut for beef. 
 Britain's farm minister at the time, Michael Jopling, said this agreement was &bquo;probably one of the most important reached since the inception of the CAP&equo;. 
 In 1988 &bquo;stabilisers&equo; were introduced limiting the amount of cash paid for each type of product. 
 All to little avail. 
 Costs have continued to rise (see chart). 
 The current dip in farm spending as a proportion of the total EC budget merely reflects higher outlays on the Community's regional and social programmes. 
 Dairy surpluses exceed 500,000 tonnes; a near-record 700,000 tonnes of unsold beef are in EC storage. 
 Excuses abound: world markets have collapsed, diet-conscious Europeans are eating less red meat, some people in Britain fear it will give them mad cow disease. 
 Mr MacSharry wants to lower milk quotas and to cut guaranteed prices for dairy products, cereals and beef. 
 These cuts would be offset by a variety of direct payments to farmers. 
 But some would get more than others. 
 At present 20% of Community farmers receive 80% of CAP cash. 
 These are the big, efficient producers who need less protection against price cuts. 
 Mr MacSharry's plan, therefore, is to direct income support towards smaller farmers. 
 He also wants to push farmers to take land out of production and to pay them grants if they tend their non-productive land in an environmentally-friendly way or use less chemical fertilisers and pesticides on their crops. 
 Many of these schemes have been tried before in small doses. 
 This will be the most comprehensive reform package yet, if Mr MacSharry can get it past his commission colleagues later this month and adopted in the spring by farm ministers. 
 EC members are already reacting informally to the MacSharry plan. 
 If the need for reform is unquestioned, his approach is not. 
 Cost is one problem. 
 A switch from price support to income support comes dear. 
 Budget costs would rise further, not fall. 
 Governments are picking out the bits of the plan they do not like. 
 Officials in Britain, Holland and Denmark find Mr MacSharry's bias in favour of small farmers unacceptable because it would discriminate against their large producers. 
 In Ireland and the south of the Community, where farms tend to be small, governments generally back Mr MacSharry. 
 Nor do these countries object to spending more EC money, which comes mainly from their richer northern neighbours anyway. 
 Germany, deferential (as always) to its farm lobby, is against price cuts. 
 It would prefer to limit production through a greater use of quotas and the withdrawal of more land from production. 
 France does not know which way to go. 
 It has large and influential cereals and sugar barons in the north, but it has many small livestock farmers as well. 
 Whom should it favour? 
 It will probably not have to choose. 
 By the time farm ministers are through, the cutting edge of the MacSharry reform will be blunted. 
 To get ministerial approval it will need to contain something for everybody, in the best tradition of EC compromises.  
 As Germany dreams 
 FROM OUR BONN CORRESPONDENT 
 AN EARLY casualty of the Gulf war has been the idea that the European Community can act as a unified power. 
 The widely differing behaviour of EC members has prompted Britain's prime minister, John Major, to say that a common foreign policy must go beyond mere words and extend to action, and that the Community is clearly not yet ready for that. 
 Britain, always cool about the Community's ambitions, might be expected to say told-you-so. 
 But even Jacques Delors, the president of the European Commission, has called the Community's response &bquo;ineffectual&equo;. 
 &bquo;Ineffectual&equo; is an understatement in the case of the EC's most powerful member. 
 Germany's response to the Gulf war so far has been a week of hand-wringing and of big, mainly anti-American demonstrations. 
 This may be a relief for those who feared that a bigger Germany would be a militarily pugnacious Germany. 
 But it has given rise to two main worries among western diplomats in Bonn. 
 One is that the Americans, already cutting their forces in Germany sharply, may decide to pull them out altogether. 
 The other is that efforts to forge a European foreign and security policy (loudly backed in principle by the Germans) may be doomed. 
 Some thoughtful Germans, such as Volker R&uuml;he, general secretary of the ruling Christian Democrats, argue that now more than ever the Europeans should speed moves to form a multinational force that includes German soldiers. 
 But in light of the German response to events in the Gulf, and to a lesser extent in the Baltic, allied diplomats give this scheme little chance. 
 Even if the Germans were to join, it is argued, they would probably hedge their participation with so many conditions that the force would be useless. 
 Is this a temporary over-reaction by Germany's friends, sour because their support for German unity seems to have brought them little solidarity now? 
 Well, the Bonn government has put up DM3.3 billion (&dollar;2.2 billion) to help the countries struggling to put things right in the Gulf, and it says it will raise more, but this still leaves it well behind Japan. 
 Some demonstrators have turned out to support Israel and Lithuania. 
 The Frankfurter Allgemeine has drummed home the case against Saddam Hussein. 
 Atlantik-Br&uuml;cke, an outfit that fosters German-American ties, has launched a campaign to help families in Germany of allied servicemen sent to the Gulf. 
 But these things stand out because they go against the trend on the streets &mdash; and in parliament. 
 While allied airmen risk their lives in the Arabian desert, politicians in Bonn squabble over whether Germany is bound by treaty to aid Turkey, a NATO partner, should it be attacked by Iraq. 
 The opposition Social Democrats even urge the recall of the 18 elderly Alpha jets already sent by Germany to Turkey, and demand a Gulf ceasefire. 
 The Turks are understandably angry. 
 &bquo;I think Germany has become so rich that it has completely lost its fighting spirit,&equo; said Turkey's President Turgut Ozal on German television. 
 Chancellor Helmut Kohl is said by aides to favour stronger backing for the allies but feels constrained by empty coffers and by a constitutional provision which arguably bans the use of German forces outside the NATO area. 
 Never much of an orator, Mr Kohl has not sounded convincing in his calls for solidarity with the Gulf allies; and his reaction to Soviet bullying in the Baltic has been inept. 
 The Balts, he argued, should take 100 small steps to independence, not ten big ones &mdash; odd advice from the man who quick-marched Germany to unity. 
 Naturally, Germans are sensitive about war after their own defeat and destruction, followed by decades of division. 
 And when Mr Kohl speaks in a way he hopes will not antagonise the Kremlin, he does so with an eye on the 350,000 Soviet troops still sitting in Germany. 
 But would it not seem natural for the people who were helped to escape from Hitler now to help those who are resisting Saddam Hussein, and to understand the desire for liberty of the Balts? 
 After Auschwitz, would you not expect Germans to take every conceivable care to stop German arms filtering through to where they could threaten Israel? 
 Yet Iraq has been acquiring German weapons for years and Germany is now pledging, for the umpteenth time, finally to block the holes in its arms-export controls. 
 Many Germans seem to have convinced themselves that by &bquo;taking Gorbachev at his word&equo; (to borrow a phrase of the currently almost speechless Hans-Dietrich Genscher, the foreign minister), they could ensure that things went well in the Soviet Union; and that Saddam Hussein could be shifted without war. 
 With both illusions shattered, they are reacting irrationally. 
 That is bad for their allies and themselves, but it is hardly new. 
 As the poet Heine put it in 1844 in &bquo;A Winter's Tale&equo;, the land belongs to the French and the Russians, the sea to the British, but the Germans &bquo;are the unchallenged rulers of the kingdom of dreams.&equo;  
 The two sides of the Soviet barricades 
 FROM OUR MOSCOW CORRESPONDENT 
 THE bloodshed in the Baltic states has polarised the Soviet Union. 
 On the one side are democrats, economic reformers and secessionists. 
 Their leader is Boris Yeltsin. 
 On the other, supporters of order, of economic conservatism and of keeping the union together at all costs. 
 Their leader &mdash; or puppet? &mdash; is Mikhail Gorbachev. 
 President Gorbachev continues to behave as if the middle ground were still there, because without it he is nothing. 
 He built power by playing off left against right, searching for compromises. 
 But compromises no longer look possible in the wake of the killings in Lithuania and in Latvia, where four people died on January 20th when pro-Moscow &bquo;black berets&equo; attacked the republic's interior ministry. 
 Policies emerging from the Kremlin look increasingly desperate. 
 Events in the Baltic states are one sign. 
 The first act of the new prime minister, Valentin Pavlov, is another. 
 This was a currency reform, by which 50- and 100-rouble banknotes stopped, at a few hours' notice, being legal tender. 
 Soviet citizens were given three days to exchange them for lower-denomination notes. 
 And no longer will they be allowed to take more than 500 roubles a month (about twice the average monthly wage) out of their bank accounts. 
 The idea is to mop up some of the surplus spending power that is causing inflation. 
 But bank deposits will not be affected by confiscation. 
 And cash savings may not be cut by as much as the government hopes. 
 Citizens cannot exchange more than 1,000 roubles each. 
 The idea is that only rich people who have saved more than 1,000 roubles in high-denomination notes will be hurt. 
 But almost everyone will know someone who can help them get round the limit. 
 Economically, the main consequence of the reform will be to destroy people's confidence in the banking system &mdash; hardly a desirable outcome. 
 It will also hurt co-operatives (semi-private businesses), which handle large sums of cash and are the only truly dynamic sector of the Soviet economy. 
 Politically, however, the reform is easy to explain. 
 Confiscating savings has long been a demand of the most reactionary groups who think that all private business is conducted by &bquo;the mafia&equo;, which the confiscation is supposed to hurt (actually, the most criminalised businesses hold much of their savings in dollars and gold). 
 Bowing to their demands puts the new government squarely on the side of the anti-reformers. 
 That it was going in this direction anyway had already been signalled by the resignations &mdash; often amid recrimination &mdash; of every one of Mr Gorbachev's top economic advisers: notably Stanislav Shatalin (who gave his name to the rejected &bquo;500-day&equo; plan to convert the Soviet economy to capitalism) and Nikolai Petrakov (who was the president's personal economic guru). 
 Civil war? 
 Economic reform is dead. 
 The Soviet constitution is discredited. 
 The centre ground has vanished. 
 If this is a prelude to the final struggle over reform &mdash; even to civil war &mdash; then what are the forces on each side? 
 Overwhelming power lies with Mr Gorbachev and his allies. 
 The army has 4m men. 
 Its high  command  is dominated by authoritarians who have fought off arguments that conscription be ended and Communist control over the army be scrapped. 
 The Communist Party, it is true, has retreated into the background. 
 But for a time in 1990 it seemed likely to split apart. 
 Not only did it emerge largely intact, it has been busy setting up shadowy &bquo;national salvation committees&equo; in whose name the army has been operating. 
 The KGB has survived and is even taking on new tasks, such as distributing western food aid. 
 As for the government and the civil service, virtually all of it is loyal to the president. 
 The only significant exception seems to be the foreign ministry, whose former chief, Edward Shevardnadze, resigned because &bquo;dictatorship is coming&equo;, and whose current minister is a fellow &bquo;new thinker&equo;. 
 True, some of these institutions are divided. 
 Junior army officers support the idea of a volunteer force and one of their leaders, Major Vladimir Lopatin, is now an adviser on military affairs to Mr Yeltsin. 
 The interior ministry is split between local police forces loyal to republican parliaments and the &bquo;black berets&equo; controlled by the interior ministry in Moscow. 
 If one of these groups were to go over to the other side &mdash; as the army did in Romania &mdash; the balance of forces would be altered. 
 But so far, divisions in the army and police seem not to have hampered their operational abilities. 
 Or have they? 
 The Baltic crackdown has been hesitant. 
 This may be partly because neither the president nor the high command is confident that parts of the army might not rebel. 
 Stories circulate about regiments that refused to go to Vilnius, and of officers who refused to fire once there. 
 The army is mindful of its prestige, and the strength of public feeling was shown by the huge turn-out (over 300,000 people) for an anti-military rally in central Moscow on the first Sunday after the killings in Vilnius. 
 Among the supporters of what can be called, for want of a better term, the democrats are three important groups. 
 First, the Russian Orthodox church, which regularly shows up in opinion polls as one of the most respected institutions in the country. 
 The head of it, who in December was urging his flock to respect law and order, called the military operation in Vilnius &bquo;a sin&equo;. 
 The second is the press. 
 To run a proper dictatorship, you cannot afford to have newspapers denouncing your actions. 
 But that is what the most popular newspapers are now doing. 
 The third is the loose grouping of leaders of republics and nationalist parties. 
 One of the most significant results of the repression in the Baltic states has been to recreate an alliance between Russian radical politicians and Baltic nationalists. 
 In 1989 and early 1990, they worked together through the so-called Inter-Regional Group of deputies. 
 The group fell apart in the spring of 1990 when the Balts began to stay away from the &bquo;foreign&equo; Soviet parliament, while Russia's democrats squabbled among themselves. 
 By flying to Estonia immediately after the army's attack on the television tower in Vilnius and uncompromisingly condemning it, Mr Yeltsin swung Russia's democrats behind the Baltic nationalists. 
 It is tempting to say that this will make no difference. 
 But the alliance, if it holds, would reduce Mr Gorbachev's options in one crucial respect: he would find it hard, if not impossible, to close down the Baltic parliaments without extending the crackdown to Russia itself. 
 And that would mean tackling the hugely popular Mr Yeltsin himself.  
 BRITAIN THIS WEEK 
 A deep breath 
 Senior ministers did their best to dampen &bquo;it'll all be over soon&equo; fever. 
 The prime minister warned MPs that the Gulf war would not be &bquo;an easy or painless business&equo; and readied them for &bquo;difficult news&equo; to come. 
 Labour's leaders backed Mr Major's rejection of a ceasefire during which peace talks might, just might, start. 
 Television pictures of captured British airmen intensified calls for Saddam Hussein's removal to be added to the list of war aims. 
 Mr Major hoped other Iraqis would deal with their leader; &bquo;I will not weep for him,&equo; he added. 
 Tom King, the defence secretary, demanded proper treatment for prisoners of war. 
 The prime minister appealed for international financial help for the Gulf conflict. 
 He expects Germans, Japanese and anyone else who has not sent forces to contribute to a &bquo;war chest&equo;. 
 Norman Lamont, the chancellor, warned that the cost of the fighting could limit scope for tax cuts in his March budget. 
 It was reported that the first four days of the war had cost Britain &pound;100m in ammunition and lost equipment. 
 Home front 
 Weekend opinion polls showed strong public support for the government's Gulf strategy. 
 A poll for the Sunday Times found that 80% support British military involvement and 60% believe Kuwait's liberation is worth British lives. 
 British Muslims meeting in Bradford attacked &bquo;British- and American-led aggression&equo; in the Gulf and demanded the immediate withdrawal of non-Muslim troops. 
 Hardliners threatened to fight back if other Britons took violent exception to such views. 
 Food importers said supermarkets were stockpiling tinned supplies and gave warning that there would be shortages of pilchards and corned beef within a few weeks. 
 Frightening figures 
 Deeper and deeper was the basic recession message in the British Chambers of Commerce quarterly economic survey. 
 Manufacturing and service industries recorded a drop in home orders; and 21% more manufacturers expect to shed jobs than increase them. 
 The government reported the biggest fall in manufacturing output since 1981. 
 The Central Statistical Office celebrated its 50th birthday (seasonally adjusted, of course). 
 It was originally set up by Churchill, who wanted better statistics to manage the war economy. 
 The government is still waiting. 
 With the going rate for pay settlements running at 9&ndash;10%, average earnings will remain stubbornly high, said a research organisation's report. 
 Income Data Services predicted that only lower inflation is likely to slow settlements down. 
 Real incomes for farmers have not been lower since the second world war, according to the Ministry of Agriculture. 
 Family farmers have been worst hit; their incomes fell by 14% last year, and almost 6,000 left the land for greener pastures. 
 More of the same 
 A &pound;950m scheme to build an east-coast motorway linking the north-east with the Channel tunnel was proposed in a report sponsored by the European Commission, local councils and private companies. 
 Supporters claim the new road would give the north-east better access to European markets and help create 60,000 new jobs. 
 A new government scheme will try to help London's homeless by pumping &pound;3m into provincial projects to help people before they even get to the capital. 
 Virginia Bottomley, a health minister, said many of the 3,000 people sleeping rough in the city might have stayed at home had they been given enough attention earlier. 
 Senior Tories pressed Michael Heseltine, the environment secretary, to discuss radical changes to the poll tax. 
 The home secretary, Kenneth Baker, launched a &pound;4.5m campaign to recruit thousands more special constables. 
 The government aims to field 25,000 of these part-time policemen, dubbed &bquo;hobby bobbies&equo; by derisive full-timers, by 1994. 
 Sons and keepers 
 Nicholas Mosley, the son of the 1930s fascist leader, Sir Oswald Mosley, won the &pound;22,000 Whitbread Book of the Year award with a novel called &bquo;Hopeful Monsters&equo;. 
 A park keeper was ordered to pay &pound;800 compensation to the owner of a &pound;1,000 model yacht he sank. 
 The official was convicted of criminal damage for ramming the craft with a motorboat, then whacking it with a shovel. 
 All because it had ventured on to a lake where models were banned. 
 BRITAIN 
 Making the munitions 
 THE Americans call them &bquo;load, assembly and pack&equo; factories. 
 They are the heavyweight addresses of the defence business: the places where all the complex components of a standard modern weapon are assembled. 
 The one responsible for putting together the JP233 since July 1985 has been Royal Ordnance's Glascoed site: 1,000 acres of low-lying ground, with an obliging screen of hills on every side, deep in the countryside of mid-Gwent. 
 It has been turning out bombs and shells since 1939, and the Gulf war has already begun to embellish a colourful history. 
 On the Saturday night after the outbreak of war, the general manager of Glascoed got a telephone call from the Ministry of Defence. 
 It had suddenly found itself desperately short of a special washer &mdash; waxed and made of felt &mdash; that is a vital bit in the detonation process inside the RAF's latest 1,000lb bombs. 
 Next morning a team of Royal Ordnance workers was specially assembled for the job. 
 The washers were made by early afternoon and a site manager drove with them in his car to an RAF service depot in southern England. 
 They were fitted into bombs in the Gulf on Monday &mdash; without a shred of ministry paperwork intruding at any point. 
 Glascoed has been steadily gearing up its operations in bigger ways, too. 
 The output of 120mm shells for the British army's tanks has been doubled. 
 Two crash programmes in December and January have boosted production of 81mm mortar bombs for both the British and the American forces &mdash; and the British design has been adapted to make it fit the slightly different mortar used by the Americans. 
 The site's workforce has been cut from 1,600 to about 1,000 over the past three years. 
 The huge improvements in productivity have borne up well in recent months. 
 To keep existing contracts on schedule while meeting emergency requirements from the ministry, the site has moved from a five-to a seven-day week, and working hours since early November have more or less doubled. 
 The management at Glascoed says scope exists for output to be pushed a lot higher. 
 During the second world war the plant kept 19,000 people busy (assembling, among other things, Barnes Wallis's bouncing bombs for the dam-busters). 
 Today Glascoed's external appearance is largely unchanged and its scale is as awesome as ever. 
 Black steam-pipes criss-cross the 1,000 acres as they always have done, hissing here and there through open valves. 
 Ageing railway wagons continue to run along old lines, now turned orange with rust. 
 A few special projects, like the JP233, have merited tailor-made concrete bunkers. 
 But elsewhere neatly swept asphalt pathways still connect hundreds of modest brickwork sheds, built in the 1940s and nestling within protective earthen ramparts where generations of rabbits have nibbled the grass to a close trim. 
 Inside these workshops, the impact of modern technology is rather more evident. 
 Sealed chambers and closed-circuit televisions are on hand for weapons that must bring together electronic gadgetry, steel casings, perfectly packaged propellants and warheads of high explosive. 
 Crates bristle with numbered codes and sinister acronyms. 
 Visitors are courteously chaperoned through a world of euphemisms, where fearsome killing devices are always &bquo;stores&equo;, explosives are &bquo;energetic materials&equo; and accidental bangs are &bquo;events&equo;. 
 It is still possible to open a door and find a dozen women sitting quietly round a bench sewing small squares of silk, with all the cloistered intensity of medieval seamstresses. 
 Not every component of a modern tank shell is made by computer. 
 Whatever the mix of capital investment and labour, new designs only rarely emerge from Glascoed: each has to have survived the tortuous processes of ministry procurement and the logistical rigours of subcontracted production &mdash; often involving half a dozen other factories, sometimes more. 
 The gestation period from first inquiry to first completed shipment is rarely less than a couple of years. 
 In normal times, that is. 
 On January 7th the Ministry of Defence asked Glascoed and its sister factories in Royal Ordnance whether it might be able to produce a new marker-version of its 155mm artillery shell. 
 Twelve prototypes were delivered within a fortnight and successfully fired in trials on January 21st. 
 Earlier this week the management was confidently expecting firm production orders within a matter of days.  
 British Muslims 
 Trouble at the mosque 
 The Gulf war reveals the growing determination of Britain's Muslims to find a political voice. 
 It also reveals their divisions 
 A COUPLE of miles away from Westminster, the Gulf war is being debated with even greater passion than in the Commons itself. 
 In Brick Lane, east London, the mosques are broadcasting fierce denunciations of infidel aggression; the newspaper-stands bristle with titles fulminating against American imperialism; youths in the street shout support for Saddam Hussein. 
 And their shouts find echoes in the industrial towns of the Midlands and the North. 
 Christian Britain may be reconciled to war; Muslim Britain is in uproar. 
 On January 21st Muslim leaders from all over the country gathered in Bradford to denounce &bquo;military aggression against Iraq&equo;. 
 After calling for non-Muslim forces to be withdrawn from the Gulf, they cursed the Saudi Arabian government for inviting them there in the first place, and took a side-swipe at Israel for having occupied the West Bank in 1967. 
 They agreed to set up a Supreme Council of British Mosques to consider how British Muslims should respond to Saddam Hussein's call for a holy war. 
 Mr Sher Azam, convener of the meeting and president of the Bradford Council of Mosques, said the government had shown a &bquo;total disregard&equo; for British Muslims when it decided to go to war. 
 &bquo;If the government continues to ignore us and deny our presence in this country,&equo; he asked, &bquo;what right has it to demand 100% loyalty from us for action?&equo; 
 Even moderate Muslims agree that Mr Azam's question will become increasingly difficult to answer if the war drags on for months and if the allies damage some of the holy sites of Shia Islam in Iraq. 
 They fear a backlash from the war. 
 Rightly: arson attacks on mosques in Surrey and West Yorkshire suggest something like that may already have begun. 
 Fast coming of age 
 Muslims started to arrive in Britain in large numbers about 30 years ago. 
 Today there are about 1m in the country. 
 Two-thirds are of South Asian origin: over 400,000 from Pakistan, perhaps 12,000 from Bangladesh, up to 100,000 from India and another 100,000 or so from East Africa of South Asian descent. 
 The rest are Middle Easterners or black Africans. 
 Concentrated in the cities &mdash; London, Birmingham, Bradford, Rotherham and Glasgow in particular &mdash; Muslims are the fastest-growing religious group in Britain. 
 This growth owes more to the birth-rate than to evangelism: Muslims are younger than the rest of the population (half the South Asians are under 16) and usually have large families. 
 Over the past decade Muslims have learnt to stand up for themselves. 
 To some extent they have been driven to this by brutal economics. 
 Generally less well-educated than other ethnic groups, and more likely to lack jobs and live in grim houses, Pakistanis and Bangladeshis have been hit by the closure of run-down Bradford mills and ancient Birmingham factories. 
 But religious righteousness has been a more potent force than economic despair. 
 For many British Muslims, resurgent Islam is now vying for their sympathies against secular liberalism. 
 The Salman Rushdie affair is a vivid example. 
 The Rushdie business drove a wedge between secular society and Muslims; it also strengthened the hold of religious leaders over their flock. 
 When Bradford Muslims burnt copies of &bquo;The Satanic Verses&equo; and effigies of its author, right-thinking liberals cringed; when the government refused to ban the book as blasphemous, even moderate Muslims felt insulted. 
 Since then young Muslims have been abandoning bars and clubs for mosques and Islamic study groups. 
 Reforming the blasphemy law is only the first item on a lengthening Muslim agenda. 
 They insist that Muslims should be subject to Islamic rather than British family law &mdash; a privilege they enjoyed in India under the Raj. 
 And they demand a wide range of special arrangements for their children: single-sex schools for adolescents, special school-uniforms and halal meals, and science courses which eschew references to Darwinism and evolution. 
 Muslim children, they argue, should be excused art, music and dance. 
 Most Middle Eastern governments approve of this politicisation of British Muslims. 
 They have been contributing generously to the upkeep of the 800 mosques in Britain; all they ask in return is a say over the appointment of the imam. 
 The most generous patron, Saudi Arabia, has invested more than &pound;50m over the past decade. 
 Even Iraq has done its bit. 
 Saddam Hussein contributed &pound;2m to a mosque in north Birmingham, and his name is still emblazoned in giant letters on the front of the building, startling motorists speeding past on the Birchfield fly-over. 
 Plenty of silent minorities 
 Politicised Islam has inevitably thrown up a new type of politician. 
 Mr Kalim  Saddiqi , the head of the pro-Iranian Muslim Institute, is perhaps the most adept at grabbing the headlines. 
 He publicly endorsed the death sentence on Salman Rushdie &mdash; an act which oddly failed to get him charged with the crime of incitement to murder &mdash; and wants to set up a Muslim parliament. 
 A Siddiqi speech usually includes a few references to the &bquo;corrupt bogheap of western culture&equo;. 
 But it is a mistake to think that Mr  Saddiqi  speaks for the majority of Muslims. 
 He does not &mdash; and neither does anybody else. 
 Muslims are just as divided as Christians: by ethnic origin (they hail from areas as far apart as Turkey and Nigeria); by language (as well as Arabic, their native tongues include Urdu, Bengali, Hausa, Swahili and Farsi); by doctrine (three-quarters are Shias and the rest are Sunnis); by money (Kuwaiti bankers do not usually invite Bradford textile-workers to their Knightsbridge dinner parties); and by politics. 
 The 15 or so parties that claim to speak for British Muslims are constantly at war with each other. 
 While the Muslim Institute is a platform for the loud-mouthed Mr Siddiqi, the Association of British Muslims is studiously moderate. 
 The Islamic Foundation is a vehicle for the Jamaats, a Saudi Arabian-financed sect. 
 The Islamic Party of Great Britain is the invention of politicised white converts. 
 Even ethnically united communities are deeply divided on points of doctrine. 
 Pakistani-dominated mosques are riven by violent squabbles between Deobandis (who are religious purists but political moderates) and Barelvis (who are political activists but doctrinal eclectics). 
 Mr Rushdie succeeded for a while in obscuring these inter-Muslim differences. 
 Saddam Hussein is likely to exacerbate them. 
 Textile workers in Bradford and Brick Lane may regard Saddam as a liberator: the metropolitan middle classes despise him as a thug. 
 Zealots may feel their blood quicken when they hear calls for a holy war; many of the imams who denounce the presence of infidel troops on Islamic soil know they owe their livelihoods to Saudi money. 
 Brown separatists and white mosque-burners may exploit the Gulf conflagration in the next few weeks or months. 
 But perhaps the new assertiveness of British Muslims should be seen as a sign not of isolation but of integration. 
 Cherishing the dream of returning to their homelands, the first generation of Muslims held themselves aloof from British politics. 
 Today they are asking to be heard &mdash; even on such an explosive subject as the war in Arabia.  
 A nation on the alert 
 WAR, not for the first time, has brought the best out of Britain. 
 Since the bombing raids began over Iraq, Britons have flocked to join the army (inquiries in London have quintupled); to give blood (in Plymouth alone, more than 1,600 people volunteered in the first few days, and 110,000 followed suit across the country); and to say their prayers (Winchester Cathedral reported that the congregation for Matins last Sunday was up by a half on the usual number). 
 On the grimmer side, the national health service, which only weeks ago was apparently closing down vital wards, said this week that it was fully prepared to look after thousands of war casualties. 
 Voluntary organisations up and down the country, from the Samaritans to the Women's Royal Voluntary Service, were standing by to help bereaved families. 
 Support for the war has been strong. 
 An opinion poll in the Sunday Times showed that 80% of the population backed Britain's military involvement, and 60% thought it was worth the loss of British servicemen's lives to regain Kuwait. 
 So far, this war is more popular than were those in Korea, Suez or the Falklands at the outset &mdash; though that may simply reflect the fact that casualties have so far been so light. 
 Naturally, everyone is helping the war effort as they see best. 
 The Sun newspaper has asked pretty girls to volunteer as pen-pals for &bquo;our boys&equo; in the Gulf. 
 By Tuesday, January 22nd, more than 2,500 had offered their epistolary services. 
 The local council in Aldershot ruled that soldiers serving in the Gulf would not have to pay poll tax; but Whitehall refused to follow America's example of allowing the troops in the Gulf not to pay income tax. 
 Although the government reported that the first four days of the war had cost Britain &pound;100m in ammunition and equipment, the cost is so far proving light for Mr Average. 
 Queues formed at petrol stations before the war started. 
 Then it turned out there was a glut of oil; within a week, petrol prices had fallen back to pre-August levels. 
 The Lloyd's insurance market opened for trade on a Sunday for the first time in its 300-year history. 
 Flagmakers were reported to have increased their output by 50%. 
 The threat of Iraqi terrorist attacks has prompted some elaborate security precautions. 
 Tanks and policemen armed with submachineguns have been deployed at airports; members of Parliament have been issued with special badges to identify themselves inside Westminster. 
 But the most nervous people in London, it is unkindly said, are the policemen outside the still-functioning Iraqi embassy in Kensington. 
 The media have quietly rejoiced at the economic impact of war. 
 Newspaper circulation has soared: by between 50,000 and 100,000 for most national papers, a welcome rise at a time when advertising has slumped. 
 The papers have vied to meet ever-later deadlines: The Times produced two 6am editions which were sold to commuters into London. 
 The city's Evening Standard produced its first Saturday paper in 16 years. 
 Radio and television have done even better. 
 The audience for the BBC's nine o'clock news doubled to 13m on the day war broke out, and that for ITN rose by a third. 
 Dozens of extra news bulletins were transmitted and Radio-4 FM launched a continuous war-news service. 
 Executives at the BBC were delighted by something John Major said in the Commons. 
 Just after the war began the prime minister was asked by a Conservative backbencher to condemn the BBC for announcing that it would avoid calling British troops &bquo;our troops&equo;. 
 (In fact, the corporation had been wrongly reported on this score and had issued no such edict at all.) 
 Instead, Mr Major praised the corporation's &bquo;remarkable&equo; reporting and noted the need to keep a proper balance &bquo;precisely because so much of the world listens to the BBC.&equo; 
 The government has already promised extra cash to pay for longer transmissions for the BBC's World Service in Arabic and Persian. 
 On the down side, domestic broadcasters decided to ban any songs or plays that could cause offence. 
 The BBC blacklisted 67 pop songs, including John Lennon's &bquo;Give Peace A Chance&equo;. 
 Even popular television war comedies were taken off the air, for fear of jarring too awkwardly with endless hours of Gulf coverage. 
 Meanwhile, other entertainments paled. 
 Cinemas in central London showing &bquo;Air America&equo;, a new film about the war in Indochina, were almost empty.  
 Camels in London 
 IF BRITISH foreign policy in the 20th century has anything to teach the world, it is how to win important wars and lose the subsequent peace. 
 This time, though Britain is a junior partner in the Gulf war, the Foreign Office is working overtime to do better. 
 In their great mock-palazzo in Whitehall, FO ministers and mandarins are brainstorming about a possible Middle East peace conference and a post-war security structure for the region. 
 The first fruits of their mental endeavour are a sobering awareness of the likely complexities of the post-war Middle East and an unease about the meagre quantity of strategic thinking going on in other European and Arab capitals. 
 But some decisions have been reached already. 
 Despite the urgent desire of some of the smaller Gulf states to return to a 1950s world where their security was assured by British soldiers, the foreign secretary, Douglas Hurd, is determined that there will be no return to an &bquo;East of Suez&equo; policy. 
 Britain might take part in naval manoeuvres or keep military supplies in the region, but will refuse any request to station troops there. 
 Since the Foreign Office believes there will be a similar reaction from Washington (where thinking about inevitably hazy post-war possibilities is also going on, but is impenetrable to outsiders), this leaves the potential for a serious power-vacuum. 
 A vital British policy objective, therefore, is to persuade the Saudi government to finance Egypt as the regional policeman, since Egypt has a large army and population but little money. 
 Though the diplomatic courtship is at an early stage, the Foreign Office is optimistic about such a marriage of convenience. 
 Despite tough talk about holding Saddam Hussein and his officers accountable for any war crimes, there is little enthusiasm in London for seeking jurisdiction inside Iraq after the war, or pursuing a defeated Iraqi president through his country. 
 The prime minister, John Major, has neatly sidestepped questioning from the Tory right about making Saddam a target. 
 The thought of being forced to invade and administer Iraq is nightmarish. 
 Aside from that, the thorniest post-war issue is pretty clear: how to persuade Israel to discuss a withdrawal from the occupied territories? 
 At this point, conspiracy theorists start asking whether the recent upheavals in British politics will affect foreign policy. 
 The Foreign Office has always been deeply pro-Arab, or &bquo;Arabist&equo;, and remains so &mdash; a matter partly of culture and partly, perhaps, of guilt about the past failures of British policy in the region. 
 Mr Hurd himself is mildly pro-Arab, but the key Arabists are the head of the diplomatic service, Sir Patrick Wright (who has served in Beirut, Cairo, Damascus and Jeddah), and David Gore-Booth, head of the Middle East desk. 
 In the old days Margaret Thatcher, who was instinctively pro-Israeli, kept the Arabism of the Foreign Office under her thumb. 
 After the 1986 Hindawi affair (which involved the attempted bombing by a Syrian agent of an El Al jet in London), senior Foreign Office men were opposed to breaking diplomatic links with Syria; Mrs Thatcher insisted. 
 In 1988, when a Conservative backbencher, Robert Adley, tried to get diplomatic relations restored, Foreign Office ministers briefed him on British preconditions. 
 Mr Adley persuaded the Syrians to agree to these. 
 He returned triumphantly; but Downing Street undermined the mission before it started &mdash; and ignored it afterwards. 
 When Mr Adley, along with Mr Gore-Booth and others, was asked to help restore relations with Syria last year, before the outbreak of war, he and the Foreign Office asked for a specific promise that Mrs Thatcher would not intervene again &mdash; and got it. 
 (President Assad told him on that occasion that Saddam Hussein was like a chain-smoker: &bquo;He cannot help lighting another one before he has finished the first. 
 Only with Saddam, it is wars, not cigarettes.&equo;) 
 Mr Adley has since had a letter from the deposed Mrs Thatcher, welcoming the eventual restoration of relations with Syria. 
 But the point remains: Mrs Thatcher was a lot less Arabist than the Foreign Office. 
 Without her, British government attitudes could change. 
 Mr Major sounded chilly in his first meeting with the Israeli prime minister, Yitzhak Shamir, and Mr Hurd was rudely snubbed during his visit to Jerusalem in October, after the Temple Mount killings. 
 So, goes the conspiracy, the Foreign Office can now give free rein to its instinctive Arabism. 
 Since it is also instinctively pro-European, as well as pro-Arab, Britain will adhere to a tougher European line on Israel after the war, even at the risk of offending the Americans. 
 It sounds a convincing theory. 
 It is being discussed on the diplomatic circuit and it will no doubt bubble up at Westminster. 
 But it is incomplete, and probably wrong. 
 First, Mr Hurd himself is sceptical &mdash; and amused &mdash; about the aspirations of some other EC countries which, while taking no part in the war, dream of a grandiose role for themselves in creating peace conferences afterwards. 
 He believes there must be a conference, and that it should probably include the permanent members of the United Nations Security Council. 
 He also believes that Israel, and the Soviet Union, are among the countries that could be addressed by a joint Euro-foreign-policy. 
 But beyond that, Mr Hurd is unpersuaded that flocks of Eurocrats will be much help. 
 And he knows that nobody can just order Israel to attend, or sign on other people's dotted lines. 
 Second, though some senior men at the Foreign Office are Arabist, there are other officials who balance their influence. 
 The number two there, Patrick Fairweather, is no Arabist (to the extent that, after winning a point at one Foreign Office meeting, he exclaimed: &bquo;Great to win one over the &lsqb;expletive deleted&rsqb; camels!&equo;). 
 Nor is Stephen Wall, the Foreign Office man who has been picked to replace Sir Charles Powell as the foreign-affairs adviser at Number Ten. 
 So British policy is unlikely to lurch. 
 A settlement of the Arab-Israel dispute would be a great prize, but a cool even-handedness would be needed to grasp it. 
 Meanwhile, as ministers' eyes glaze over at the thousand &bquo;what ifs&equo; thrown up by war, they would do well to remember Lord Salisbury's deflatingly modest dictum from more than a century ago: &bquo;The first object of a treaty of peace should be to make a future war improbable.&equo;  
 Drawing blueprints for defence 
 The Gulf war will revive a debate about where to draw the line between commercial sense and military prudence 
 THE British defence industry has taken a battering from the government over the past decade. 
 In the early 1980s came competitive procurement &mdash; the idea that officials should shop around the world for arms, rather than restrict themselves (like officials in most other western countries) to buying from domestic suppliers. 
 Then in 1987 the Royal Ordnance factories, responsible for well over half the total needs of their owner, the Ministry of Defence (MOD), were privatised &mdash; and pitched, in the process, into a root-and-branch reorganisation. 
 Most recently of all, the industry was shaken by signals from Whitehall last year that the size and shape of the armed forces might be transformed. 
 The Gulf has exposed all these initiatives to the biggest test of all. 
 With a real war now happening, do the changes imposed on the defence industry (or under active consideration) still look sensible? 
 Or will they need reassessing, given their importance for Britain's entire defence strategy? 
 The possibility of a dramatic reduction in the size of the armed forces has been examined in &bquo;Options for Change&equo;, a paper prepared for Margaret Thatcher last year by Alan Clark, the defence-procurement minister, and still covered in secrecy. 
 Within the industry, the war has made little difference to most people's expectations: the reduction, they say, is going to happen. 
 Just before Christmas, Sir Peter Levene, the head of procurement at the MOD, sent a letter to all defence industry suppliers asking them to postpone sending invoices to the department for a month: officials needed to remedy a &pound;400m (&dollar;780m) overrun on their year-to-date budget. 
 The fighting in the Gulf will lift this financial pressure only temporarily. 
 As defence-industry consultants try to work out the consequences, some predictions are unchanged. 
 For example, annual purchases of ammunition seem likely, by the mid-1990s, to be at least 25% down on 1989 levels. 
 But the main goal of the 1990s could be to transform a big, heavily armed standing army into a more flexible force, capable of rapid deployment around the globe. 
 Here the Gulf war has jolted assumptions. 
 Flexibility may need redefining, if armies are going to combine smallness with the punch needed to go on the offensive against countries like Iraq equipped with lots of state-of-the-art T-72 tanks. 
 In this sense the present conflict is going to underscore the greatest danger of any strategy that implies a substitution of firepower for manpower &mdash; the risk that the demobilisation day will arrive but the new weapons will not: weapons like the new multiple-launch rocket system that the British army was originally scheduled to start receiving in 1984. 
 It had ordered 54 of them &mdash; but second thoughts on the sourcing postponed their arrival by five years, so only 12 are ready for use in the Gulf. 
 One business that would certainly hope to benefit from any extensive re-equipping of the forces is Royal Ordnance, the subsidiary of British Aerospace that bought the MOD's factories. 
 In 1987 it had 16 sites and 15,000 workers; now it has 11 sites and 11,000 workers. 
 With output in almost all areas either steady or up on pre-privatisation days, the company already looks hugely more efficient in the private sector. 
 But is Royal Ordnance still able to serve the country as it used to? 
 In September it was asked by the MOD how much scope it had to lift ammunition production (it provides about 45% of the ministry's total purchases). 
 The answer was mixed: virtually no scope at all for 155mm artillery shells (which sent the MOD scurrying off in search of extra supplies on the world market); but plenty for 120mm tank shells. 
 The company also made it clear that it would stretch every resource to meet ministry demands, regardless of its new commercial status. 
 It seems fair to say it has (see box on next page). 
 There is no disguising one powerful constraint on Royal Ordnance, however. 
 For many types of work, its maximum production capacity is well below the level of ten years ago. 
 And in the struggle to turn the company into a lean commercial outfit, some lines have been discontinued altogether. 
 It no longer makes 9mm rounds for small arms, or Giant Vipers, a weapon that may play a vital role in opening up Iraqi minefields during an allied offensive. 
 No doubt the army has lavish stocks of both; but no capacity has been retained in Britain to make more of them at short notice. 
 The same even goes for the JP233, arguably the most useful offensive weapon of the war so far. 
 This is the 4.5-ton &bquo;pod&equo;, two of which are strapped to the belly of every Tornado aircraft sent out to disable an Iraqi airfield: the pod disgorges high-explosive bombs that leave craters, as well as anti-personnel bombs to complicate the task of clearing up the damage. 
 About a year ago the MOD told the main contractor, Hunting, that it had all it needed. 
 That may be enough to see the RAF through the present war. 
 But only export orders have kept the production lines going since then. 
 Now the export contracts have been met, so those lines may soon be abandoned. 
 If they are, JP233 production would again require a 2.5-year lead-time. 
 And just as the MOD has chosen to let such production lines be closed down, rather than pay contractors for the cost of mothballing them, so too has it cast a cold eye on the plight of domestic defence electronics companies. 
 Competitive procurement seems to have beached several British firms. 
 Plessey and the biggest bit of Ferranti have been swallowed by GEC; Racal appears to be retreating from the market; Thorn EMI last year put its defence business up for sale. 
 Only when it comes to the nuclear deterrent or matters of top intelligence-gathering is the short-term commercial approach deliberately shelved. 
 And on the various powerful but unseen committees that sit in contemplation of Britain's future defence policy, the consequent evaporation of any strategic productive capacity in less glamorous areas is causing unease. 
 If the government ever agreed to return to its old uncommercial ways, there are, in theory, three ways it could do so. 
 It could aim to copy the Pentagon's example, devoting a portion of the MOD's budget to looking after a mothballed version of any production line judged a strategic asset. 
 Critics of this idea say it would be ludicrously expensive. 
 Second, Britain could aim for a mini-version of the American policy, selecting just a few vital weapons. 
 In effect, this is the policy of the French, Germans and Italians. 
 Or, third, Britain could conclude that modern weapons are simply too costly for any single country of its size to make them on its own &mdash; and could stick to international joint ventures in future. 
 But with which countries? 
 As the MOD has shopped around Europe for additional supplies of 155mm shells, some of the responses have done little for any future spirit of co-operation. 
 The Belgians abruptly rebuffed a request for free stores; the Dutch and the Germans eventually agreed, but on sale-or-return terms. 
 Meanwhile, British and American servicemen have been busy inspecting each other's kit out in the Gulf. 
 Did someone say Westland? 
 BUSINESS 
 The cost of keeping cool 
 The key to a successful world-climate treaty will be the balance between winners and losers 
 OFFICIALS from the world's environment ministries meet in Washington, DC, early next month to start work on a treaty on global climate change. 
 The aim: to persuade countries to reduce their output of greenhouse gases, which are thought to be warming the world faster than ever before. 
 The prospect of a convention has drawn economists into unfamiliar fields of international politics. 
 Global warming, unlike the sort of pollution that economists have traditionally thought about, does not arise in, and cause harm to, a single country. 
 It is not analogous to sewage dumped in a river or to soot from a smoking chimney. 
 Greenhouse gases, produced by every country on earth in varying amounts, may change the climate of every country. 
 In the case of a polluted river, the remedy lies in the hands of a national government. 
 In the case of global pollution, no world government exists to make polluters pay. 
 Ultimately, an effective greenhouse treaty will need the voluntary co-operation of sovereign powers. 
 Why should they co-operate? 
 They are likely to do so only if the perceived benefits exceed the expected costs. 
 By co-operating, countries can increase the benefit they receive, relative to the cost. 
 For an individual country, acting alone, huge efforts will make little difference. 
 To take one example, if Britain stopped burning fossil fuels altogether, the world's output of carbon dioxide &mdash; some 6 billion tonnes a year &mdash; would fall by only 160m tonnes. 
 The prospective reduction in global warming &mdash; and thus the benefit to Britain's climate &mdash; would be correspondingly small. 
 But a cut of ten times that amount in the whole world's output of carbon dioxide, shared among all countries, would not only cost Britain far less: it would bring bigger benefits in climate stability. 
 Although no country has an interest in individual self-sacrifice, every country will have an interest in cheating &mdash; &bquo;free riding&equo;, as economists call it. 
 A climate treaty is peculiarly vulnerable to free riders. 
 The governments going to Washington next month understand that; and in working out what to sign up for, they will know more about the likely costs of taking action than about the benefits. 
 Scientists still know little of the regional impact of global warming, and of its effect on agriculture. 
 Some countries (like the Soviet Union) hope that warmer weather, more rain and the fertilising effects of extra carbon dioxide will boost their farm output. 
 If so, why worry? 
 Some scientists argue that nastier outcomes are more likely; and that wise countries will insure against the incalculable risk that the consequences of climate change might be catastrophic. 
 More is known about the possible costs of curbing output of carbon dioxide, the main greenhouse gas. 
 A survey* of studies of costs has just been published by the OECD's general economics division (which shows how mainstream economists are being drawn into what was once a green ghetto). 
 All studies assume that unchanged policies will lead to a rise in carbon-dioxide output. 
 So policies to cut gas output below the current level will imply a larger and larger reduction below projected levels as years go by. 
 Not surprisingly, most studies expect that such policies will result in a cut in the growth of global GDP (none expects an increase). 
 Projected slowdowns vary from study to study, but are mainly between 0.1% and 0.3% a year. 
 Even such apparently small reductions in GDP growth imply big cumulative differences in the long run. 
 The main growth in carbon-dioxide output will be in developing countries. 
 So they risk losing most potential economic growth if a climate treaty sets ceilings on emissions. 
 But without the co-operation of developing countries, the growth in their output of carbon dioxide would swamp any cuts by industrial countries. 
 An important point to emerge from one of the studies reviewed is that policies vary a good deal in the effect they will have on trade patterns and terms of trade &mdash; and thus on both the overall loss of global welfare and the regional distribution of that loss. 
 One recent study** looks at four ways in which a treaty might, over the next 40 years, cut global emissions to 50% less than the levels they would reach without a change in policy. 
 Such measures would need very high rates of carbon tax, raising revenues that would be roughly equivalent to a tenth of world product. 
 The paper shows that global welfare losses may be lowest (see table) if a carbon tax is levied by energy-consuming countries and kept by them. 
 Losses would be twice as high if energy producers imposed a carbon tax and kept the revenues for themselves, or if a tax were levied by a world agency which then shared out the revenue in proportion to each region's population. 
 Losses would be highest with a per-person ceiling on emissions, so third-world countries could expand greenhouse-gas output as their populations grew. 
 Much energy-intensive industry would then decamp to the third world. 
 How awkward 
 The best treaty will aim for the smallest loss in world welfare. 
 It will also face the fact that those who lose least may have to compensate those who lose most, if free riding is to be checked. 
 Apart from wielding the stick of trade sanctions &mdash; a worrying measure &mdash; the main option will be the carrot of cash transfers. 
 Will the gainers be happy to hand money over to the losers? 
 Such a transfer is difficult to achieve at the best of times. 
 In this particular case, note one disturbing implication of the table: the biggest losers from a consumption tax will be the oil exporters. 
 Their support for a tax will need to be bought &mdash; and they include countries like the Soviet Union and Saudi Arabia. 
 Aid for them anyone? * &bquo;A survey of studies of the costs of reducing greenhouse-gas emissions&equo;, by Peter Hoeller, Andrew Dean and Jon Nicolaisen. 
 Working Paper 89, OECD. 
 ** &bquo;The international incidence of carbon taxes&equo;, by John Whalley and Randall Wigle. 
 University of Western Ontario.  
 Europe's way with chips 
 First in an occasional series on the idiocies of trade protection 
 WITH saviours like the European Community's bureaucrats, the electronics industry of Europe hardly needs enemies. 
 European prices for memory chips, a key component of computers and other electronic equipment, are about to rise by 10&ndash;15%, according to estimates by Dataquest, a firm of analysts. 
 Memory-chip prices are falling in most other parts of the world. 
 Thanks to the gnomes of Brussels, Europe now has an economics-defying arrangement which raises European chip prices as demand falls. 
 Early in 1990 the European Commission began setting minimum prices for Japanese memory chips sold in Europe. 
 Because Japanese firms supply the vast majority of the world's memory chips, these prices are in effect a floor price for all memory chips. 
 To prevent the Japanese from &bquo;dumping&equo;, the commission estimates Japanese production costs every quarter and then forces the Japanese to price above these estimated costs. 
 Herein lies the rub. 
 Most of the costs of producing a memory chip are fixed, because of the elaborate factories and equipment needed. 
 So when the Japanese cut production in a slumping market, as they are doing this year, these high overhead costs are spread over fewer chips. 
 Normally the Japanese would have to accept the squeeze on profit margins resulting from higher costs per chip and lower prices &mdash; and indeed memory-chip prices are falling in most markets as producers chase slumping demand. 
 In Europe, however, the commission's cost-based price-fixing formula nonsensically forces prices up. 
 Jim Eastlake, an analyst at Dataquest, reckons that most chip consumers were (sensibly) expecting memory-chip prices to fall by 5&ndash;10% in the first three months of 1991. 
 Instead, European buyers could pay some &dollar;23m more than the &dollar;200m their chips would probably have cost them if the market had been left to itself. 
 America is abandoning a similar price-fixing arrangement for memory chips after suffering just such nasty shocks. 
 Has nobody in Brussels noticed?  
 America's robot industry 
 The lonely and the brave 
 DETROIT 
 AT THEIR giant Hamtramck assembly plant in Detroit, employees of General Motors give the robots they work alongside typically American names like Joe or Bob. 
 But the robots carry more formal titles painted on their sides, like ABB or Kawasaki. 
 These are anything but American. 
 Despite once dominating the industry &mdash; and even controlling the basic patents that forced foreign competitors to licence their technology &mdash; America's robot makers are a vanishing breed. 
 They may soon be extinct. 
 There were once more than 60 American makers of robots, but only a few remain. 
 In September 1990 the last top American producer of large robots fell into foreign hands when Cincinnati Milacron, a machine-tool company, sold its industrial-robot division to ABB, a Swedish-Swiss engineering giant. 
 Yet apart from strong foreign competition, the dwindling number of American robot producers is also partly the result of over-ambitious expectations and bad planning. 
 Westinghouse's flirtation with robotics is typical. 
 In 1983 it bought Unimation, a company credited with inventing the industrial robot. 
 Unimation's hydraulic robots could once be found in most American car plants. 
 But Unimation stuck with complicated and leak-prone hydraulic technology, whereas foreign rivals switched to simpler and more reliable robots driven by electric motors. 
 In 1988 what remained of Unimation was sold to Staubli, a Swiss company, which also makes the Puma range of robots. 
 Because domestic firms backed the wrong technology, American customers bought imported robots rather than home-made ones. 
 Another problem was that they bought too few, regardless of their origin. 
 &bquo;American companies have not been good at putting robots to work&equo;, says Fred Sitkins, a specialist on robots at Western Michigan University. 
 The figures seem to suggest otherwise: robot orders by American firms reached a record &dollar;514m in 1989 and &mdash; despite a softening American economy &mdash; they were at roughly the same level in 1990. 
 That is still a lot less than the &dollar;2 billion of robot sales once forecast for 1990. 
 The reason that sales have not boomed is that many customers have been disappointed at what robots do for them. 
 Eli Lustgarten, an analyst with Paine Webber, claims much of the blame lies with American customers themselves, who saw robots simply as a way to replace labour. 
 The best way to use a robot is to help an existing workforce improve manufacturing reliability and quality. 
 Though Japanese firms have used robots to ease their labour shortage, they have stressed most their use in boosting quality. 
 An embittered Joe Engelberger, the founder of Unimation, believes the reason for America's robot failure is that &bquo;we have bean-counters running our companies. 
 The Japanese have engineering and manufacturing people.&equo; 
 When Mr Engelberger appeared on television in 1967 with one of his earliest robots, the only calls he got from Americans were from showbiz agents trying to book his &bquo;act&equo;. 
 The Japanese paid his way to Japan to explain his invention. 
 The Japanese reckon that there are currently 275,000 robots operating in Japan. 
 Applying a stricter American definition, the number of Japanese robots is probably closer to 175,000, says America's Robotic Industries Association. 
 Either figure dwarfs the 37,000 robots operating in American factories. 
 And while half of all American robots are making cars or trucks, Japan's robots are performing a much wider variety of jobs. 
 Three-quarters are outside the car industry, doing everything from handling food to bottling cosmetics. 
 Among the surviving American robot makers is GMF, which is a joint venture between General Motors and Japan's Fanuc. 
 There is also Adept Technology, a firm that specialises in small assembly-robots. 
 Adept has produced about 3,000 robots since it was founded in 1983. 
 &bquo;We have never met the expectations of analysts, but a lot of industries haven't,&equo; says the company's sales director, Peter Mills. 
 Adept may not remain independent for long. 
 Bert Thorvaldsson, the manager of robot development at ABB, describes small American robot companies like Adept as &bquo;excellent takeover targets.&equo;  
 The Tribune Company 
 Big Apple bites back 
 PRESIDING over the collapse of one of America's largest newspapers has been a humbling experience for the Tribune Company, a Chicago-based media group that is proud of its reputation for tough management. 
 When the company announced on January 16th that it would close the New York Daily News within 60 days if it could not settle a crippling strike at the newspaper, Wall Street breathed a sigh of relief and the company's share price soared. 
 No one disputes that the Tribune Company, publisher of the Chicago Tribune among other papers, had to do something about the decade-long trickle of losses at the Daily News, America's oldest tabloid and New York's largest-circulation newspaper. 
 But the company reacted clumsily to the unexpected strength of union resistance. 
 A strike, declared on October 25th, has pushed losses to an estimated &dollar;1m a week. 
 In the last three months of 1990, the Tribune Company recorded its first quarterly loss since going public in 1983. 
 Most disturbing is the fact that the company spent an entire year preparing for the strike, convinced that it had to end overmanning and weaken the unions' grip on production if the newspaper, despite a circulation of 1.1m, were ever to become a money-maker. 
 The Tribune Company had already won a similar battle in Chicago in 1985 and seemed confident that it could repeat this profitable victory in New York. 
 Though the Daily News has continued to publish without its workers, managers did not expect that the unions would persuade news-stands, sometimes with strong-arm tactics, to stop selling the paper. 
 As a result circulation has fallen by half, and big advertisers have drifted away. 
 Union officials speak scornfully of the Tribune Company's assumption that tactics which worked in Chicago would succeed in New York. 
 While other media groups relied on acquisitions for growth, the Tribune Company concentrated on wringing more profits out of existing properties in its newspaper, television and entertainment empire. 
 For the past decade this has worked. 
 Since 1983, the company's revenues have climbed from &dollar;1.6 billion to &dollar;2.5 billion in 1989, and profits have tripled to &dollar;242m. 
 But after the company's debacle in New York, &bquo;sweating&equo; assets much further may prove impossible. 
 Asked to describe their company, Tribune executives talk soberly about a belief in basic management skills and the heartland virtues of thrift and common sense. 
 Striking workers at the Daily News are unimpressed. 
 They describe the same company as ruthless and stupid. 
 Unable to impose their idea of common sense on the Daily News's unions, Tribune managers are now intent on either selling or closing the paper. 
 Various buyers, including Britain's Robert Maxwell, have been mooted. 
 But a paper that has lost half its readers and most of its advertisers, while retaining its cantankerous and costly unions, is unlikely to be an attractive proposition in the middle of a recession. 
 Perhaps ruthless and stupid is a good way to describe the paper's unions.  
 Beckoning, not begging 
 LEIPZIG 
 AFTER a slow start in 1990, eastern Germany may attract more companies and investors this year. 
 According to a recent survey, industry in western Germany aims at least to triple its investment in the east to about DM10 billion (&dollar;6.7 billion). 
 Throw in the financing planned by service firms as well as public spending on eastern telecoms and railways, and the 1991 total could exceed DM50 billion. 
 Better, but not yet good enough. 
 Some experts reckon that up to DM1 trillion will be needed to bring the ramshackle east up to western scratch. 
 Siemens, an electricals group, is one of the biggest investors in eastern Germany. 
 It already has a labour force there of 15,000 and plans to double that over the next year or two, investing around DM1 billion. 
 Volkswagen and Daimler-Benz are building new car factories in the east, at a cost of DM5 billion and DM1 billion respectively. 
 Big western German utilities, stores, banks and insurance companies have also established operations there. 
 Officials of the Bonn government and the Treuhandanstalt, the Berlin-based agency given the task of privatising thousands of state-owned firms, are keen that non-German companies move into eastern Germany too. 
 Of the 400 state-owned firms which the Treuhand sold last year, netting DM2.5 billion, almost all went to western Germans. 
 Yet foreigners &mdash; the French and the Austrians are showing most interest &mdash; may be playing a bigger role than these official statistics suggest. 
 Many foreign firms are investing through their western German subsidiaries. 
 One example is Opel, part of General Motors, which is building a new vehicle plant in the east costing DM1 billion. 
 Others include Unilever, BP, Coca-Cola and RJR Nabisco. 
 Asea Brown Boveri, the Swedish-Swiss engineering group, has bought an electrical-equipment maker and plans joint projects with a score of other eastern firms. 
 Much of the business will be funnelled through ABB's large unit in western Germany.  
 Suing drug companies 
 Take two pills and lie down 
 IF HISTORY is anything to go by, the legal action being brought in Britain by 3,000 patients against Wyeth (a subsidiary of American Home Products) and Switzerland's Hoffmann-La Roche will either be dismissed or settled out of court for a pittance. 
 The case is one of the biggest suits ever brought against the drug industry. 
 Claimants allege that the two firms failed to warn doctors about the addiction patients say resulted from prolonged use of Ativan and Valium, prescribed to treat anxiety. 
 After a few highly publicised cases such as Britain's thalidomide scandal in the 1960s, product-liability laws were strengthened everywhere to make it easier to sue drug companies. 
  Nevertheless , most people still find it harder to get compensation from drug firms for errant products than from almost any other type of manufacturer. 
 Whether in Britain, litigious America or anywhere else, it is hard to prove that a single drug is responsible for causing harm, especially if patients are being prescribed a cocktail of medicines. 
 Years can pass before the unwanted effects of a drug are spotted and, even then, they may occur in a tiny fraction of patients. 
 Sometimes a drug's side-effects resemble the symptoms of the disease being treated. 
 Patients taking Ativan and Valium for long periods may suffer acute anxiety when they stop. 
 The irony is that the costly approval-procedures which drug firms so regularly complain about can be their best shield against liability claims. 
 To win approval, drugs must first go through a series of animal and clinical tests which are reviewed by government drug-approval agencies. 
 This has turned drug regulators into unwitting protectors of drug companies. 
 There are other obstacles. 
 Because so few drug-liability claims have ever been decided in court, no one is clear what responsibilities drug firms should bear. 
 If a drug company receives letters of complaint from a few reputable doctors who have prescribed its product, should it then withdraw the product or warn other doctors of the problem? 
 The drug industry points out that either course could harm more people than it helps, particularly if thousands are  benefiting  from the treatment. 
 The problem is made worse because consumers are rarely told of the risks associated with drugs: most, not unreasonably, expect their medicine to do them good. 
 A survey of 56 different painkillers conducted recently by Britain's Consumers' Association found that instructions accompanying most products were inconsistent, inadequate and unclear. 
 Only three out of 26 aspirin bottles carried warnings against use by pregnant women. 
 The European Commission recently drafted legislation requiring drugs firms to supply more details to consumers. 
 Better-informed people might be more cautious about the pills they take &mdash; and even less able to sue if things go wrong.  
 Etak 
 Rupert Murdoch's map maker 
 LOS ANGELES 
 STRAPPED for cash, a beleaguered Rupert Murdoch has promised his 150 frustrated bankers that he will sell bits of News Corporation to reduce its &dollar;8 billion of debts. 
 On the block is likely to be one of Mr Murdoch's stranger diversifications: Etak, a maker of electronic maps. 
 Like so many of Mr Murdoch's gambles, the potential pay-off of his stroll into California's Silicon Valley is enormous &mdash; but too far away to help pay his debts today. 
 Etak, which derives its name from the Polynesian word for navigation, was founded by Stan Honey. 
 He sketched out its original business plan on the back of a napkin in 1983 (a time when napkins were home to many new ideas). 
 In 1985 Mr Honey launched the Etak Navigator, a &dollar;1,400 in-car navigation system, which could guide a driver to any address he punched into the system. 
 Yet the Navigator may end up as a &bquo;how not to&equo; in a business-school marketing class. 
 Though Mr Honey's detailed computer maps got rave reviews from specialists, fewer than 3,000 were sold. 
 Mr Murdoch bought the firm for &dollar;25m in 1989 and convinced Mr Honey that what he had inadvertently built was a publishing company, not a maker of high-tech electronics. 
 So Etak stopped making Navigators and instead opted to sell a software map which runs on hardware made by other firms. 
 The maps have been a big hit with government departments and firms with large vehicle fleets, a market once considered of only peripheral interest by Mr Honey. 
 Also promising are electronic versions of the Yellow Pages and other directories, complete with thousands of computerised maps. 
 Mr Honey may yet crack the private-car market too. 
 General Motors, which owned the exclusive licence to build the technology in its new cars, recently gave permission to Etak to license other car makers. 
 On January 10th Bosch/Blaupunkt, a German car stereo company, launched Travel Pilot, basically an updated version of the Navigator which uses Etak software. 
 Priced at around &dollar;3,500 &mdash; expensive, but still less than 5% of the cost of a new Mercedes Benz sports car &mdash; it is more likely to be seen in Beverly Hills than in Baltimore. 
 With Bosch's name behind it, Travel Pilot may sell where Navigator failed; if so, mass-market systems cannot be far behind. 
 Eventually, portable devices may even be used by pedestrians. 
 Of such stuff are entrepreneurial dreams made. 
 Mr Murdoch may not have the time or the money to wait. 
 Etak could become somebody else's gamble.  
 Investment in eastern Germany 
 Socialist paradise full of serpents 
 LEIPZIG 
 ECONOMIC union between the two Germanies last July was supposed to produce an investment boom: western businesses would pour money across the border to make use of skilled workers in the east and grab a share of a growing new market. 
 So far this has not happened. 
 Though some big firms have boldly marched eastward, investment in the former East Germany has been slower than expected. 
 The reasons for the disappointment can be seen from the struggles to survive of three once-successful companies based around Leipzig. 
 This was the commercial heart of the former East Germany, and once the site of Eastern Europe's biggest trade fair. 
 Forty years of communism have left Sternburg, one of eastern Germany's biggest breweries, with a jumble of crumbling buildings that house decrepit machines fuelled by filthy lignite coal. 
 Since July nearly 60 western competitors have invaded Sternburg's market. 
 Saddled with debt, the company cannot compete. 
 After producing beer for more than seven centuries, the brewery is likely to go out of business soon unless it can find a rich western partner. 
 Janetzki, a maker of electronically-controlled centrifuges for hospitals, once exported to 45 countries. 
 Since July the bureaucrats of the foreign-trade monopoly who knew how to sell its products abroad have been sacked. 
 Sales at home have collapsed, because hospitals in the former East Germany cannot afford expensive gear. 
 Mansfeld, a metal products and processing group, has ruthlessly cut its staff in half, to 23,000, chopped unprofitable businesses and signed up sales partners in the west. 
 But it cannot raise the DM550m (&dollar;367m) it wants to invest without a government guarantee. 
 It is fighting government efforts to sell its healthiest businesses, arguing that the rest of the group may collapse if they go. 
 All three firms are crushed by debts built up under the communists. 
 Unless German taxpayers allow the Treuhandanstalt, a trust set up last year to privatise eastern Germany's 8,000 state firms, to write off many of these debts, none of these companies has much chance of surviving. 
 Eastern firms are burdened with debt now calculated at DM100 billion. 
 Any solution in sight? 
 Some firms will be told to sell off non-essential assets to cut their debt. 
 The government is determined not to forgive all the debts, but most experts reckon that some relief will eventually have to be granted. 
 Yet plenty of other problems are also hampering investment: 
 More than 1m Germans, in both parts of the country, have claims on property expropriated by the communists. 
 This has put off many potential investors fearful of being entangled in the courts for years. 
 The government thought it had solved the problem by ruling that, in disputed cases, &bquo;important&equo; investment needed to create jobs should be allowed to proceed and that former owners would have to accept compensation. 
 But the law has too many loopholes to reassure nervous investors. 
 There are not enough people qualified to help sort out the mess left by the communists. 
 For example, the Leipzig office of the Treuhand, one of 15, has only 43 people to deal with 800 companies queuing to be privatised. 
 Local authorities are packed with officials lacking any knowledge of a market economy and swamped by paperwork as thousands of property claims are made. 
 A communist old-boy network of managers and officials is still at work, shunting influential jobs to old comrades and hindering the break-up of old empires. 
 A desperate Treuhand dumped 15 old-guard regional directors last year, replacing them with people from western Germany. 
 But there are not enough westerners available to run thousands of eastern firms. 
 Cleaning up eastern Germany's disastrous pollution could prove ruinously expensive for many businesses. 
 Switching to oil or natural gas, cleaner than indigenous lignite, will prove costly for firms like Sternburg, Leipzig's struggling brewer. 
 As a result western companies have been especially reluctant to buy eastern chemical plants and other polluting or energy-intensive businesses. 
 Most investors in any industry have preferred to build new factories rather than take over existing businesses. 
 A dismal picture, especially when eastern Germany's crumbling transport network and malfunctioning telephones are added to the list of woes. 
 Even so, the flow of new money into eastern Germany is expected to grow this year (see box on previous page). 
 Many experts believe the flow could become a torrent if the government ever comes to grips with the debt and property problems still hanging over the east.  
 Pan Am fights for its life 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 WHEN Eastern Air Lines, which had flapped along in chapter 11 bankruptcy for nearly two years, finally shut down on January 18th, one of the concerned onlookers was Pan Am's boss, Tom Plaskett. 
 It is not that Pan Am minded a rival going under; indeed, Pan Am may now be able to raise ticket prices on east-coast routes where Eastern had offered big discounts. 
 The problem is that Pan Am is also in chapter 11 and some people are wondering if the airline that pioneered many of America's routes across the world will soon follow Eastern into liquidation. 
 Pan Am insists not. 
 Its &bquo;business as usual&equo; slogan has helped to get passengers accustomed to flying on bankrupt airlines. 
 But the people who were stranded by Eastern's closure may now think twice about that. 
 Still struggling, Pan Am convinced its creditors at a meeting on January 22nd that it should be allowed to continue operations. 
 Britain's Civil Aviation Authority had just recommended approval of the sale of Pan Am's routes out of London's Heathrow airport to United Airlines. 
 Pan Am says more than a sale is involved; it has a new marketing deal with United that will help prop up its other operations. 
 Yet some of the creditors, including Boeing, General Electric and the federal Pension Benefits Guarantee Corporation (PBGC), were also creditors of Eastern. 
 They had pleaded with the bankruptcy judge to close down Eastern last autumn, but instead he allowed it to remain airborne and continue to run down its cash resources. 
 There is now little left for the creditors to salvage from the airline's wreckage. 
 These creditors will be determined not to let the same thing happen to Pan Am. 
 The airline's safest route remains a merger or takeover. 
 One difficulty is its unfunded pension obligations, which the PBGC says amount to some &dollar;800m. 
 That has not discouraged a rival, TWA, from offering to buy the airline. 
 Pan Am has rebuffed TWA's first advances. 
 With a change in the rules over foreign ownership of domestic airlines now likely (see main story), there may soon be more bidders. 
 Anyway, TWA is not an attractive partner because big debts are forcing it to sell assets too. 
 TWA's domestic network, based on a hub in St Louis, would help fill gaps in Pan Am's route structure. 
 But two weak airlines do not make a strong one. 
 Perhaps the biggest obstacle in any merger would be the personality clash between Mr Plaskett and TWA's boss, Carl Icahn.  
 Business in Thailand 
 Empires in the east 
 BANGKOK 
 A booming economy in Thailand has not reduced the domination of the country's powerful Chinese families 
 SINCE the second world war, a handful of Chinese families have reigned over Bangkok's economy, which accounts for over half of Thailand's output. 
 As the Thai economy boomed over the past three years, becoming the fastest-growing in the world, many commentators predicted that these great families were bound to lose their grip. 
 Large investments in Thailand by multinationals, and torrid family squabbles, suggested that their influence was on the wane. 
 Yet Thai business remains as much a family affair as ever. 
 The fortunes of some families have, indeed, grown no greater, or even diminished. 
 But other powerful families have thrived in Thailand's boom years. 
 Most of the leading Thai-Chinese business empires are still controlled by their founders, many of whom started life at the bottom and have assumed Thai names. 
 Take Chuan Ratanarak. 
 Born in southern China in 1920, he first came to Thailand with his family at the age of six. 
 At the end of the second world war he was working as a docker in Bangkok's harbour. 
 By the early 1950s he had his own firm, loading ships. 
 Today he controls the Bank of Ayudhya, Thailand's fifth-largest bank, and Siam City Cement, the country's second-largest cement producer. 
 Mr Chuan's progress from trading to banking to manufacturing is typical of the breed, says David Scott, the Bangkok representative of W.I. Carr, a stockbroker, and author of a study of Thailand's nine top families. 
 Although banking remains important, the most profitable area for expansion in recent years has been manufacturing. 
 Another family, the Chokwatanas, have established one of the most impressive manufacturing empires. 
 Thiam Chokwatana, the founder, opened a shop in 1942. 
 From this humble beginning the family has built the Saha Pathana group, a collection of over 60 companies, 18 of which are now listed on the stockmarket. 
 Despite its size, Saha Pathana remains a family concern &mdash; each of Mr Thiam's eight children controls at least one of the listed companies. 
 The third son, Boonsithi, is being groomed to take over when his father dies. 
 With the help of Japanese partners, the group competes successfully in everything from detergents to lingerie against the likes of Unilever, Procter &amp; Gamble and Colgate. 
 The group had a net profit margin of 30% last year. 
 Or so it claims. 
 The truth is that most Thai-Chinese business empires are so complex that no outsider, including bankers and minority shareholders, can ever know their real state of health. 
 Such complexity also thwarts any over-ambitious family member. 
 A good example is a recent struggle for control of the Sophonpanich empire. 
 Until his death in 1988, Chin Sophonpanich was the undisputed father-figure of Bangkok's Chinese community. 
 The empire he created was based around Bangkok Bank, South-East Asia's largest, and included palm-oil plantations and hospitals among other things. 
 After his death seven heirs, by two wives, could not agree on the group's future. 
 Mr Chin had foreseen this difficulty and made sure that no child had majority control of any of the family companies. 
 Eventually the squabbling died down. 
 Chatri Sophonpanich, the second son, has now assumed his father's mantle. 
 Sometimes, however, even the most tangled arrangements cannot contain a Chinese family quarrel. 
 The Tejapaibuls (banking, brewing, distilling and property) used to be the most powerful family in Thai business. 
 Disagreements between the founder's ten sons, most of whom have had two or more wives and so lots of their own children, nearly tore the group apart. 
 For each family on the way down, there is one on the way up. 
 The Chearavanont family's Charoen Pokphand group (poultry, animal feed, petrochemicals and, most recently, a joint venture with British Telecom to triple the number of telephone lines in Thailand) is Mr Scott's favourite to &bquo;become the dominant business empire in Thailand by 2000&equo;. 
 Another contender may be the emerging empire of Thaksin Shinawatra, who began by distributing IBM computers in Thailand, set up the country's first cable-television operation and has now received permission to establish his own cellular-telephone network. 
 Over the past two years his workforce has increased tenfold. 
 What really sets Mr Thaksin apart is that he comes not from southern China but from Chiang Mai in northern Thailand.  
 Pirelli and Continental 
 No thank you 
 IN BRITAIN and America, hostile takeovers are often nasty affairs. 
 In most of continental Europe they are not only rare, but conducted with such exquisite politeness that the adjective &bquo;hostile&equo; seems inappropriate. 
 On January 21st, after three months of discussions, the managers of Continental, a German tyre maker, gave up trying to convince Pirelli, an Italian competitor, to drop its plan to merge the two firms and rejected any further talks. 
 Nicely, of course. 
 Continental says it does not need the hassle of a complex merger. 
 Instead, it has vaguely proposed some form of co-operation or alliance with Pirelli. 
 But making tyres is a commodity business in which economies of scale matter a lot. 
 The industry is dominated by Michelin, Goodyear and Bridgestone, each two to three times the size of either Continental or Pirelli. 
 Small wonder that the Italian company is keen on merging. 
 The two smaller European producers' chances of staying competitive against much larger rivals are slim. 
 Pirelli first approached Continental last September to propose a transfer of Pirelli's tyre operations to Continental. 
 In return, the Italian company wants a controlling stake in the merged firm. 
 To reassure worried German managers, Pirelli stresses that Continental would remain a German company and would keep control of its own brands. 
 Though Pirelli insists its approach is &bquo;friendly&equo;, it also claims the support of a majority of Continental's shareholders. 
 Horst Urban, Continental's boss, is unimpressed with Pirelli's elaborate scheme and rightly sees it for what it is: a takeover. 
 He remains determined to fend off the Italians. 
 The deadlock may be broken by Alberto Vicari, a German despite his Italian name, who represents a group of shareholders who control 5% of Continental's stock. 
 On December 12th Mr Vicari called for an extraordinary general meeting to clear up the uncertainty over the firm's future. 
 Faced with a shareholders' meeting in Hanover on March 13th, Mr Urban and his managers are on the defensive. 
 Continental's managers and supervisory board urged shareholders to vote against several of the resolutions proposed by Mr Vicari. 
 Among them is one that would lift restrictions on the voting rights of shares. 
 Another resolution would force Mr Urban to come up with a merger proposal involving Pirelli's tyre business in time for Continental's annual general meeting in June. 
 Continental gives several reasons for rejecting Pirelli's advances. 
 Few are convincing. 
 It maintains that a merger will do more harm than good because the merged group would lose orders from German car firms worried about depending on a single supplier. 
 But a merged group might limit such losses by arguing that Pirelli and Continental do not sell the same type of tyres. 
 The German firm also argues that Pirelli is heavily dependent on risky markets like Brazil, Argentina and Turkey. 
 Yet Continental plays down the benefits that the merged firm might get from expanding sales in America and Europe, the world's two biggest tyre markets. 
 It also makes no mention of the value of the Pirelli brand name, which is associated with fancier, higher-margin tyres. 
 Continental is worried that, after a merger, Pirelli would also seek large job cuts in Germany. 
 With tyre firms around the world laying off thousands of workers, Continental may end up cutting even more workers if it remains independent.  
 Ground control, we seem to have a problem 
 The world's airlines are facing their biggest-ever shake-out 
 AIRLINES all over the world are losing frightening sums of money. 
 Some are going broke. 
 In a desperate bid to stay airborne, most are laying off staff, cancelling services, and selling routes and aircraft to anyone with ready cash. 
 On top of that, regulators are changing the rules of the game almost every week: in the latest move, on January 23rd, America decided to relax its rules on the foreign ownership of its airlines. 
 Many airlines are so confused or battered that they no longer have anything resembling a clear business strategy. 
 What has gone so badly wrong? 
 Barely a year ago investors were swarming around the airline business like bees around a honeypot; airlines were forging grand global alliances. 
 The war in the Gulf has not helped. 
 But the troubles of the industry began well before Iraq's invasion of Kuwait sent the price of jet fuel from 60 cents a gallon to more than &dollar;1.30. 
 Airlines everywhere have expanded too rapidly. 
 In America they were encouraged to do this by over-eager lenders and a scramble to assemble nationwide route-networks after the industry was deregulated in 1978. 
 Transfixed by what they saw in America, airlines elsewhere expanded to get ready for the increased competition expected in their own skies. 
 Meanwhile, wage costs, maintenance bills and interest charges grew more rapidly than the number of passengers. 
 When recession began to cut traffic in America last year, many airlines were too weak to cope. 
 Now the fortunes of non-American carriers may be about to nosedive. 
 America is the biggest single air-travel market, accounting for more than 40% of all the world's airline passengers. 
 Passenger numbers in America more than doubled in the decade after deregulation, and fares (adjusted for inflation) declined by a fifth. 
 Scrambling for growth, America's airlines changed the way all airlines operate. 
 They built hub-and-spoke route systems based on a few large airports, rather than a web of direct, non-stop flights. 
 Though this makes many passengers change aeroplanes, it is highly efficient for the airlines themselves. 
 Equally efficient are the powerful, computerised reservation systems developed by American carriers. 
 These not only sell flights but also juggle capacities and fares in order to squeeze the last cent of revenue out of every aircraft seat. 
 Both the reservation systems and the hub-and-spoke networks pioneered by American carriers have been copied by airlines elsewhere. 
 As airlines grew, their large cash flows were used to justify huge borrowings for takeovers and expansion. 
 Growing competition sent smaller carriers, many of them start-ups after deregulation, to the wall. 
 By last year nine airlines were carrying more than 90% of domestic passengers in America, compared with 15 airlines in 1984. 
 Now it is the turn of some of those big boys to suffer. 
 While the strongest (American, United and Delta) have been getting stronger, the weakest (Pan Am, Continental and Eastern) went bankrupt. 
 Pan Am (see box on next page), Continental and Eastern have been able to stay aloft only under the protection of creditors provided by chapter 11 of America's bankruptcy laws. 
 On January 18th Eastern's court-appointed manager grounded the airline. 
 Eastern never recovered from a crippling strike in 1989 and now faces liquidation. 
 Continental, Eastern's sister airline in the former Texas Air group assembled by Frank Lorenzo &mdash; once the industry's most aggressive wheeler-dealer &mdash; is struggling with &dollar;2 billion of debt. 
 Other carriers are in trouble. 
 TWA is heavily in debt and is slashing its European services by almost half. 
 The debacle among the weaker airlines is producing easy pickings for America's big three. 
 TWA is selling its London services to American. 
 Pan Am is selling its London routes to United. 
 Delta has increased its dominance at Atlanta, the world's busiest airport, by buying some of Eastern's gates. 
 American and United get their strength from strong route networks which draw in huge numbers of passengers. 
 Possessing the two biggest computer-reservations systems in the world does no harm either. 
 Delta benefits from a modern fleet of aircraft with low operating costs. 
 But even these giants are having trouble. 
 American Airlines made a &dollar;215m loss in the fourth quarter of 1990, while on January 23rd Delta reported that it went &dollar;208m into the red during the same period, the biggest quarterly loss in its history. 
 If America's airline industry continues its present rate of consolidation, it could soon be dominated by American, United and Delta. 
 This is the opposite of what deregulation set out to accomplish. 
 Sam Skinner, the American transport secretary, believes that even if there are fewer airlines in America &bquo;robust competition will continue&equo;. 
 But in order to try to keep some of America's weaker carriers in the air he has decided to increase the limit on the stake a foreign investor can hold in an American airline from 25% to 49%. 
 It may be too late. 
 Although some airlines, like British Airways, have been keen to invest in an American carrier, it is a difficult time for any airline to go shopping. 
 The entire industry is scaling back. 
 Air Canada is selling its headquarters building in Montreal. 
 Germany's Lufthansa and Scandinavia's SAS are trying to make huge savings in their operations. 
 Even Asian carriers, based in the world's fastest-growing travel market, are worried about declining numbers of passengers from America and Europe. 
 Singapore Airlines, usually one of the world's most profitable carriers, reckons the outlook is &bquo;grim&equo;. 
 Airlines are also not sure what their global plans should be, because the rules keep changing. 
 On January 22nd Britain's Civil Aviation Authority called for the rule that stops new airlines from using London's Heathrow airport to be scrapped. 
 This rule is stopping American and United from taking over their ailing rivals' services. 
 Mr Skinner's decision to increase the limit on foreign investment in American carriers is seen in the industry as an exchange for Britain allowing American and United into Heathrow. 
 British Airways, which dominates Heathrow, was supposed to have a marketing agreement with United to share passenger traffic. 
 Now they will compete directly instead.There is even a possibility that the United States and the European Community will trade the rights for their respective airlines to operate within each others' internal markets. 
 The European Commission is trying to deregulate the European airline market, but it wants to stop short of America's &bquo;open skies&equo; policy. 
 Europe's competition authorities are also keen to avoid the consolidation seen in America. 
 They want to give new competitors more of a chance, even if it means intervening in the market to do so. 
 Earlier this month Britain's Civil Aviation Authority took the unprecedented step of ordering British Airways to surrender some of its slots at Tokyo's Narita airport to Virgin Atlantic, a small British competitor. 
 With governments around the world privatising airlines and opening routes to competition, the industry's old cartels are crumbling. 
 But airlines are also trying to retrieve some security, and reduce competition, with alliances and mergers. 
 Air France, for instance, has gobbled up its main French rivals, Air Inter and UTA. 
 Some alliances have come unstuck. 
 On December 31st a plan by British Airways and Holland's KLM to take a 20% stake each in Belgium's Sabena, and then to develop Zaventem airport in Brussels as a European hub, was abandoned. 
 Amid all this turmoil and red ink, the aircraft manufacturers (America's Boeing and McDonnell Douglas, and the European consortium, Airbus Industrie) together with the jet-engine makers (America's General Electric and Pratt &amp; Whitney, and Britain's Rolls-Royce) are nervously sitting on the biggest backlog of orders in their history. 
 Some 3,000 aircraft are scheduled for delivery. 
 America's airlines alone have more than &dollar;130 billion-worth of aircraft on order. 
 Many of the orders were based on over-optimistic plans for expansion rather than the replacement of existing aircraft. 
 Many of these aeroplanes may now never be built. 
 With so many airlines strapped for cash and with costs increasing, passengers should not expect many more fare-wars. 
 Indeed, Mr Skinner reckons there is not an airline in America that is now covering its costs. 
 Airlines will start pulling out of unprofitable routes rather than fighting for market share. 
 In March British Airways will stop flying the ferociously competitive London-to-Dublin route, after 44 years of service. 
 When competitors pull out, get taken over or go bust, fares go up. 
 At eight of America's big hub airports where one airline commands 75% or more of departures, air fares are more than 18% higher per mile travelled than the national average. 
 The only certainty in this airline shake-out is that, ultimately, it is going to cost the traveller a lot.  
 BRITAIN'S MOST ADMIRED COMPANIES 
 Top Marks 
 With the help of Loughborough University's department of management studies, we asked 1,800 of Britain's businessmen and financial analysts to name their corporate heroes 
 BUSINESS buffs spend many a dull hour poring over balance sheets, share prices and financial ratios in search of the best-performing firms. 
 But crunched numbers do not mean everything. 
 Solid profits and a strong balance sheet help make a great company, but they may not be enough to make it admired. 
 Admiration counts. 
 If they like you, your customers will buy more, your employees and suppliers will work harder and your shareholders will be more loyal &mdash; which is useful to fend off predators. 
 This is the second survey commissioned by The Economist to discover which are Britain's most admired companies; the first was published in September 1989. 
 Participants were sent a list of publicly quoted firms in their industry, chosen on the basis of market capitalisation. 
 In all, 230 companies in 23 industries (a slight change from our previous survey) were covered. 
 Those polled were then asked to rank firms in their industry (except, for businessmen, their own company) by eight criteria: quality of management; financial soundness; quality of products and services; ability to attract, develop and retain top talent; value as a long-term investment; capacity to innovate; quality of marketing; and community and environmental responsibility. 
 In all, 64% of those polled responded to the survey. 
 This subjective appraisal produces three separate categories of winner: leaders on each of the eight criteria, 21 sectoral stars, and an overall top 20 of Britain's most admired companies. 
 The three tables show the results. 
 The strength of this method is that managers give their views on their peers &mdash; in other words, on firms they should know something about. 
 But is it right to aggregate sectoral views to produce an overall national ranking? 
 The alternative is subjectively to rank all-comers: so participants were also asked to assess British companies in any industry, not just their own, by the same eight criteria &mdash; a question not asked in 1989. 
 The same trio of firms that occupied the top three overall places in 1989 took the honours again this time (see table 1). 
 The order of merit, however, has changed. 
 Last time Shell Transport and Trading came first, Glaxo was second, and Marks and Spencer came third. 
 This year Marks and Spencer has leapt to the top slot, Shell is now second and Glaxo third. 
 The scores for the top 20 are remarkably close: less than 11 points separate Marks and Spencer from Wessex Water in 20th place. 
 Outside the top three, change has been more drastic. 
 Gone from the top 20 are BP, Carlton Communications, Grand Metropolitan, M&amp;G and Pilkington; so, thanks to a stalled property market, are Greycoat, Rosehaugh and Tarmac. 
 In come Allied Colloids, Rentokil (both chemicals companies), Reuters, RMC (a building-materials group), United Biscuits, S.G. Warburg, Wellcome and recently privatised Wessex Water. 
 ICI, in sixth place last time, has fallen to 12th: still heavily dependent on commodity chemicals, ICI's restructuring has not made it as immune to the industry's boom-bust cycles as it had hoped. 
 Rolls-Royce has risen from 14th to fourth; our participants rated it Britain's most innovative firm, and the one with the highest-quality products. 
 Why is Marks and Spencer so admired? 
 Partly because it is profitable: its pre-tax profits have tripled over the past ten years, to &pound;604m (&dollar;980m) on sales of &pound;5.6 billion (in some 30 countries) in the year to March 1990. 
 Its balance sheet is rock solid. 
 But the firm is more than just a money-maker; it is the consummate all-rounder. 
 In six of the survey's eight categories it took one of the top three places; it took top place (see table 3) in its ability to attract and retain the ablest employees, its long-term investment value and its community and environmental responsibility. 
 Marks and Spencer started being nice to its employees, customers, suppliers and neighbours decades before it was fashionable to do so. 
 In the 1890s Michael Marks, the firm's founder, put wooden platforms behind his market stalls to keep salesgirls' feet warm; these days the company pays for everything from in-house dentists to local community projects. 
 All this results in a rare phenomenon: Marks and Spencer is a company people are fond of. 
 This does not make it immune from recession: this year Marks and Spencer will restructure (ie, cut) its head-office staff. 
 The survey also pointed to two weaknesses: marketing (where it failed to make the top ten) and capacity to innovate (where it came seventh). 
 In fact the firm is an innovative retailer &mdash; it pioneered sell-by dates and cash refunds, and has one of the most sophisticated in-store credit-card operations in the business. 
 It just does not shout about it. 
 Much the same is true of Shell Transport and Trading. 
 Quietly, Shell invests in its businesses at the rate of some &dollar;10 billion a year &mdash; a level which Sir Peter Holmes, its chairman, says will not change, Gulf war or not. 
 Shell never fights costly bid battles, but spends &dollar;1.5 billion a year steadily buying oil and gas assets. 
 It has no net debt, and &dollar;6 billion in the bank. 
 Odd that our participants rated its financial soundness below that of Land Securities, one of Britain's few financially secure property companies. 
 Our survey rates Shell most highly for its management quality, where it took first place (see table 3). 
 Managers often view a job at Shell, where they are given plenty of decisions to make early on in their career, as an alternative to taking an MBA. 
 The company seems to have been forgiven for its oil spill in the Mersey estuary in 1989; it came third in &bquo;community and environmental responsibility&equo;, only one place down from last time. 
 Of the three most admired firms, Glaxo may have to struggle hardest to keep its place. 
 In awe of Zantac, an anti-ulcer treatment that is now the world's best-selling drug, our participants awarded Glaxo top-three places for innovation, product quality and marketing. 
 The firm recently introduced Serevent, an anti-asthma drug, and will this year launch Imigran, a new migraine treatment, in Europe. 
 Sales of each could top &dollar;1 billion a year. 
 Not all is running Glaxo's way. 
 Zantac makes up an ominously high 50% of the company's revenues. 
 Two recent scientific studies suggested that Glaxo's two new drugs could have harmful side-effects. 
 And doctors and governments alike are debating how to curb the excesses of drug promotion. 
 One of their targets could be Glaxo. 
 What of our second question, which allowed a vote for any firm? 
 Here Hanson, which makes just two appearances in our tables (sixth in management quality, eighth in financial soundness), cleaned up, with a quarter of respondents voting it Britain's best firm. 
 Marks and Spencer was second with 14% of the vote, Glaxo third with 11% and Shell a distant sixth with just 4.1%. 
 In the free vote's individual categories, Hanson was rated first for management, financial soundness and long-term investment value. 
 So why did its industrial-sector peers only award Hanson fourth place, which left it out of our overall top 20? 
 One reason is that its rag-bag of products is hard to evaluate; another is that Hanson appears to have a poor image on community and environmental responsibility. 
 But there may be a baser reason: fear of Lord Hanson's &pound;7 billion war-chest. 
 Full results 
 The data underlying this survey are available as a report from The Economist, price &pound;15 (&dollar;30). 
 To order, please contact Linda Denli on 071 839 9104 or write to her at 25 St James's Street, London SW1A 1HG. 
 Please make cheques payable to The Economist Newspaper Ltd. 
 THE GULF WAR 
 Battered, hunkered down, but Iraq's army is undefeated 
 OUR strategy to go after this army is very, very simple. 
 First we're going to cut it off, then we're going to kill it.&equo; 
 With those blunt words about the fate of Iraq's army, General Colin Powell, America's top soldier, briefly revived the faith of Americans in Operation Desert Storm. 
 The reassurance, at a Pentagon briefing on January 24th, was welcome, and well timed. 
 After a week of fighting, the war that had begun with a thunderous high-tech blitzkrieg in the skies over Baghdad had not yet delivered visible proof of victory. 
 By any statistical measure, the first week had gone the alliance's way. 
 Its aircraft and cruise missiles have pounded installations throughout Iraq and Kuwait by day and by night. 
 These attacks have inflicted widespread and in some cases irreparable damage in preparation for the ground offensive. 
 But hopes of a quick and cheap victory, raised by the seemingly unblemished success of the first surprise attack on the night of January 16th-17th, are fading. 
 The air campaign has not been an unqualified success in any of its missions. 
 The first strikes concentrated mainly on command-and-control centres, Scud launching sites, military supply lines, support installations and plants working on nuclear and chemical weapons. 
 A big effort was mounted against airfields, radars and anti-aircraft batteries in an attempt to gain air superiority. 
 The elite Republican Guard, the best trained and equipped of the Iraqi ground forces, are deployed along the northern border of Kuwait. 
 They were hit early on, and on January 21st the allies announced that they were shifting more of their attacks to the dug-in ground forces. 
 Little is known publicly about the effects of the air raids on supply lines and ground troops, except that Iraq's anti-aircraft guns and missiles have continued to fire. 
 General Powell admitted that the Iraqi command network, linking President Saddam Hussein with his battlefield commanders, was still functioning, as were five of Iraq's original 66 air fields. 
 Iraqi chemical-weapons factories had suffered &bquo;considerable damage&equo;, but much of Mr Hussein's existing chemical stockpile was dispersed and could still be used in bombs, short-range rockets and artillery shells. 
 The most striking Iraqi achievement so far has been the saving of its air force, a feat that owes more to engineering than combat. 
 According to the Americans, a handful of dogfights during the first week produced a lopsided result: nearly a score of the most modern Iraqi French- and Soviet-built fighters shot down in the air for the loss, possibly, of a single American fighter. 
 Most of Iraq's 800 or so aircraft have spent the war on or under the ground in well-protected shelters and hiding places. 
 The Americans put the first-week total of Iraqi aircraft destroyed, on both air and ground, at 41; the British estimate is gloomier. 
 Allied spokesmen make light of the fact that so many enemy aircraft remain intact. 
 While they are on the ground, it is argued, they pose no danger; if they fly, most will be shot down. 
 General Powell admits to their &bquo;latent capability&equo; but insists the allies now have &bquo;air superiority&equo;. 
 The morning after the general's briefing, Iraq brought its latent air capability out of hiding, and tried to hit allied warships in the Gulf. 
 Two Mirages, said the allies, were shot down &mdash; both by the same Saudi fighter. 
 The threat from the air 
 Further raids can certainly be expected. 
 The Iraqis possess a number of Sukhoi SU-24 ground-attack aircraft, similar in quality to the British Tornado. 
 If a group of these took off and penetrated Israeli or allied air defences they could each wreak more destruction &mdash; with chemicals or high-explosives &mdash; than a flock of Scuds. 
 Moreover, the survival of Iraq's aircraft has meant that allied pilots keep having to return to Iraqi airfields to crater the runways. 
 This has taken a heavy toll of British Tornadoes, which pass low over the airfields to deliver their JP-233 runway-busting mines and bombs. 
 The Scuds themselves have been a nuisance, the allies having under-estimated both the number of Iraq's launchers and the ability of the Iraqi crews to conceal them. 
 In addition to the launch vehicles provided by the Soviet Union, Iraq has apparently invented a makeshift disposable launcher of its own. 
 The Scuds fired so far have done no direct military damage, but the hunt for their launch sites has diverted many allied aircraft from other jobs. 
 Although these missions may be scaled down if the alliance's Patriot missiles continue to destroy almost every incoming Scud, a fear remains that Iraq might be able to replace the conventional warheads with chemical ones. 
 The Americans claim that Iraq's two surviving nuclear reactors (unlike the one Israel knocked out in 1981, these were small research reactors) have been completely destroyed, along with many of Iraq's chemical and biological weapons plants. 
 From videofilms shown to reporters in Saudi Arabia, and the reports of the few journalists who spent the first days of the war in Baghdad, other successful hits can be independently verified. 
 They include the headquarters building of the Iraqi air force, power stations, communications towers, telephone exchanges and various hangars and hardened bunkers. 
 Most Iraqi cities are reported to be without electricity or telephones. 
 So far the war's great unknown is the impact of the allied air offensive on Iraq's main ground forces. 
 About 12,000 sorties were flown in the first week &mdash; about half of them bombing raids, the rest involving air refuelling, reconnaissance, fighter cover and the like. 
 It was claimed early in the campaign that the Republican Guard had been &bquo;decimated&equo; from the air. 
 That claim has not been repeated, despite reports of many bombing runs against the Guard by America's gigantic B-52s. 
 For the bulk of the allied forces &mdash; those on land and sea &mdash; the war has not yet started. 
 On land there was minor skirmishing: on January 18th American marines came under artillery fire near the east coast of Saudi Arabia, hitting back with aircraft, helicopters and artillery. 
 On January 23rd American and Iraqi patrols collided on the Saudi-Iraq border just west of the westernmost tip of Kuwait. 
 Almost certainly, other border skirmishes have gone unreported; allied helicopters and American A-10 tank-busting aircraft regularly patrol the frontier attacking ground targets inside Kuwait. 
 At sea the American navy has fired more than 100 cruise missiles from a battleship, cruisers and at least one submarine. 
 Many air sorties have come from American carriers in the Mediterranean, the Red Sea and in the dangerously restricted waters of the Gulf itself. 
 On January 21st allied forces destroyed some Iraqi anti-aircraft batteries operating from oil rigs in the northern Gulf; the next day American  aircraft  sank two Iraqi ships, one a minelayer. 
 Awaiting the real war 
 It takes two to tango, the United Nations secretary-general observed after pre-war talks with Saddam Hussein. 
 The commanders of Operation Desert Storm are beginning to feel the same way. 
 After a week of fighting, Mr Hussein's war machine has done virtually nothing but hunker down and wait to be attacked. 
 Attacked, promises General Powell, it will be &mdash; once its supply lines along the Euphrates valley have been severed and its men and equipment softened up from the air. 
 The question nobody seems able or willing to answer is when the ground attack may come. 
 General Norman Schwarzkopf, the American commander in Saudi Arabia, says he is in no special hurry: as the war goes on the Iraqis become weaker, the allies stronger. 
 But as the air war progresses, new targets become harder to find. 
 The allied commanders must also consider how long they can continue the air campaign without wearing out their airmen. 
 Until now the allied air forces have been going to enemy positions; once the ground forces move in, the enemy air force will have to come up to fight. 
 At that point there will be a different air war to fight, for which crews must be kept fresh. 
 At the outset of the campaign, allied spokesmen suggested the air-only phase was expected to last about ten days. 
 But there have been delays. 
 Bad weather has hampered the bombers that lack modern night-attack equipment. 
 Clouds and fog have made it difficult, sometimes impossible, to conduct reconnaissance. 
 This argues for extending the bombing campaign. 
 On the other hand, it is becoming apparent that air attacks alone are not likely to win the war. 
 Public support for the war could wane if no visible progress is made towards the main goal of ejecting the Iraqis from Kuwait.  
 Making 'em pay 
 FROM OUR WASHINGTON CORRESPONDENT 
 THE fighting on the ground may be nothing compared with the fighting over who pays the bill. 
 Congressmen by the dozen are demanding that Japan, Germany, Saudi Arabia &mdash; indeed anyone but America &mdash; should be tapped for the costs of Desert Storm. 
 At the Group of Seven meeting in New York on January 20th-21st, Nicholas Brady, America's treasury secretary, asked his Japanese and German colleagues to dig deeper into their pockets. 
 The table shows the latest numbers for contributions so far, set roughly against ability to pay and interest in the Gulf measured by reliance on imported oil. 
 One problem with the burden-sharing debate is finding out what operation Desert Storm is costing. 
 The Pentagon is cagey. 
 Before fighting broke out, Congress was talking of an annual cost of some &dollar;30 billion. 
 Now the cost is thought to be in the range of &dollar;500m-1 billion a day. 
 On January 22nd Alan Greenspan, chairman of the Federal Reserve, suggested that it would be at the low end of that range largely because much of the equipment being used would not be replaced. 
 In effect part of the war is being fought from stocks. 
 Mr Greenspan also said it would be wrong to pay for the war with a tax increase or surcharge. 
 Congress will continue to demand more help from the allies.  
 Turkey 
 One eye on the sky, one on CNN 
 FROM OUR TURKEY CORRESPONDENT 
 AS WAR broke out, Turkey tiptoed. 
 Was it going to war? 
 &bquo;I don't know,&equo; said a senior foreign ministry official, agreeing that the question was the right one. 
 &bquo;Not yet,&equo; said the government's official spokesman. 
 On reflection he advised consulting the foreign ministry. 
 Nobody, least of all the press corps plane-spotting outside Incirlik air base, believed the first official tale: that the waves of American aircraft returning with their bomb pods empty had been off on a training exercise. 
 In the days that followed, the government tried to make things clearer. 
 Turkey was not in a state of war and would not open a second front against Iraq unless its own territory was attacked. 
 Headline writers, pointing to Incirlik, declared the front already open. 
 The government still insists that allowing Turkish air bases &bquo;a more comprehensive role&equo; is a far cry from the dispatch of Turkish armoured columns over the border. 
 Some Turks, nervous about Scud missiles and chemical warheads, suspect one thing might lead to the other. 
 On the first day of the war the prime minister, Yildirim Akbulut, asked the national assembly not only to sanction the use of the bases for American bombing raids but also to allow the Turkish armed forces themselves to go on the offensive. 
 Rather oddly, Turkey's cardboard neutrality won the approval of Iraq's ambassador in Ankara. 
 It was not until the bombing had been going on for almost a week that the Iraqi foreign minister issued a protest. 
 There is really no mystery about this contradiction. 
 Iraq does not want yet another enemy. 
 And NATO's secretary-general, after all, has reminded Iraq that an attack on Turkey would be an attack on all the allies. 
 The calculation of Turkey's president, Turgut Ozal, is that Iraq will not attack Turkey and that Saddam Hussein will soon be out of a job. 
 &bquo;I am not a gambler,&equo; the president told a television interviewer, &bquo;I am an engineer.&equo; 
 Turkey has committed itself to its friends, in the expectation that its commitment will be rewarded. 
 Television goes along with this. 
 Much of its coverage consists of retransmissions of CNN with simultaneous translation; yet when CNN reported that people were leaving Adana, the city near the Incirlik base, state-run television showed a film about sailing holidays. 
 The political opposition, on the other hand, is not convinced. 
 Turkey, it says, has gone to war and thereby surrendered to the Americans. 
 Suleyman Demirel, leader of the right-wing opposition (who faced similar criticisms in his day), has accused Mr Ozal of turning Turkey into the USS Saratoga. 
 The left-wing opposition argues that Turkey has undone in a moment decades of diplomacy in which the country presented itself as a force for Middle Eastern stability. 
 The government, it says, is letting Turkey's fate be decided by the way the war turns out. 
 If the war goes on for long, the anxieties will increase. 
 By Thursday no Iraqi missile had fallen on Turkish soil, but the debris of a misfired Patriot anti-missile missile had, and air-raid sirens had gone off in Adana. 
 The country has made few preparations for civil defence. 
 In Istanbul, a universe away from any front, telephone calls now often go unanswered, bills are left unpaid, business life is affected. 
 One anxious socialite complained that five of her dinner invitations had been cancelled. 
 The Turkish people are sitting tight, watching the skies and CNN.  
 Boots, boots, boots 
 FROM A CORRESPONDENT IN DHAHRAN 
 IF TRUTH is the first casualty of war, boots are the second. 
 Most armies march into new wars wearing the boots designed, too late, for the previous ones. 
 The commander of Desert Storm hopes, like Wellington, to solve this problem and leave a bootprint in history. 
 General Norman Schwarzkopf rose through the army ranks on his feet, as an infantryman. 
 For 35 years, he says, he has had his feet abused by regulation army footwear that was always redesigned a little too late. 
 When the American troops arrived in the Saudi desert last August they were mainly shod in 1960s canvas-topped &bquo;jungle boots&equo;, unchanged since Vietnam. 
 In the searing Saudi heat the steel plates in the boots, designed to protect soldiers from stakes in the jungle, heated up like a blacksmith's anvil. 
 Two holes along each instep, meant to let water from Vietnam's swamps run out, merely let sand seep in. 
 The black leather bits that cover the toes and heels absorb heat and bake the soldiers' feet. 
 Supply sergeants scouring Saudi shoe-shops came up with a bewildering variety of non-regulation footwear: zippered beige Saudi military desert boots, Omani army boots, Israeli army desert boots, even imported hiking boots. 
 It took General Schwarzkopf to restore order. 
 Reviving a battle he had begun two years ago with military-equipment designers, he insisted that his men needed boots of beige suede with speed laces, ankle-supports, lightweight nylon material, a sand-blocking closure and arch-support. 
 When army designers sent him prototypes, he sent them back. 
 He designed his own pair of boots and test-walked them in the desert. 
 With luck the Schwarzkopf desert boots will start arriving in May. 
 With luck, they won't be needed.  
 Egypt steadfast 
 FROM OUR CAIRO CORRESPONDENT 
 MUSLIMS! 
 Your brothers are being annihilated. 
 Hurry to aid Iraq in its heroic steadfastness!&equo; 
 The anti-government weekly with this banner headline sold out in Cairo within hours. 
 As war approached, most Egyptians remained solidly anti-Iraqi. 
 As hostilities began, some of them began to waver. 
 Egyptians like an underdog; many of them privately admit to thinking that, whatever his faults, Saddam has guts for standing up to Uncle Sam. 
 Opposition parties, the Muslim Brotherhood and the spokesmen of some significant professional associations want Egyptian troops pulled out of Saudi Arabia. 
 They contend that the original objective &mdash; to protect the holy places of Islam &mdash; has been hijacked by the war-mongering regime of President Hosni Mubarak. 
 Fundamentalists and Arab nationalists applaud the missile attacks on Tel Aviv. 
 Concerned about possible unrest, the government has extended the mid-year university recess and cancelled public sporting events. 
 Still, Egyptian officials are confident that the rightness of their cause, bolstered by a non-stop barrage of anti-Saddam verbiage from the state-controlled media, has eliminated serious obstacles to Egypt's Gulf policy. 
 The president himself has quashed rumours that Egypt has been pursuing an Arab peace initiative, and rejected the idea of any ceasefire until the Iraqis have promised to withdraw from Kuwait. 
 He has said Egyptian troops would remain in the Gulf until they complete their mission, which he describes as aiding Kuwait under joint Arab defence agreements. 
 Western diplomats have no doubt that Egypt's 32,000-man contingent is ready to fight. 
 Unless Israel unleashes disproportionate retaliation for the missile attacks, Egypt has no intention of shaking the alliance. 
 Asked about his country's likely reaction to an Israeli counter-strike, the Egyptian ambassador in Washington said simply, &bquo;Don't worry about us.&equo; 
 More than anything, public opinion is confused. 
 Egyptians have recent memories of being beaten at the hands of western-backed armies. 
 Bitter experience prompts many Egyptians to feel that Saddam Hussein is repeating the mistakes of Gamal Abdel Nasser, whose sabre-rattling brought disaster in the 1967 war. 
 They recall the wisdom of Sadat, who chose to seek an armistice in 1973, saying that he could fight Israel but not the United States as well. 
 Pragmatism rules, but for how long? 
 &bquo;Time is the key,&equo; says Fahmy Huwaydi, an authority on Islamic movements in Egypt. 
 He believes that the radical opposition's shrillness is merely an effort &bquo;to ring bells to attract attention.&equo; 
 But if the war drags on too long, and the Iraqi people suffer too visibly, more people will grow angry that Egypt is involved. 
 Whether the radicals' anti-western rage takes wider hold depends on the outcome of the war. 
 It is only 20 years since, to general relief among Arabs, America and Britain closed their bases in Libya and the Arabian peninsula. 
 Egyptians, wary of historical backsliding, would not like to see them reopen. 
 They are afraid, too, that Israel might expand into the space left by Iraq's collapse. 
 If the West is not careful to attend to such concerns, it could foster the fury that has not come.  
 The Maghreb boils over 
 &bquo;TREMBLE Jews, the army of Muhammed has returned.&equo; 
 Thus cried the legions of Islamic fundamentalists in Algiers this week. 
 Israel has a public-relations problem in North Africa. 
 Iraq's Scud attacks on Tel Aviv brought delirious joy, while governments struggled to contain the emotions. 
 Algeria called up reservists and sent troops to guard government buildings and western embassies. 
 King Hassan of Morocco closed schools and banned street rallies. 
 Mauritanian police used tear gas to stop pro-Iraqi demonstrators reaching foreign embassies. 
 The Tunisian government replaced scheduled television programmes with news and solemn music. 
 Mauritania is one of Iraq's few remaining allies. 
 The other governments of the Maghreb are dangerously out of step with the mood of their people. 
 Most have condemned both Iraq's invasion of Kuwait and the presence of western troops in Saudi Arabia; Algeria and Morocco were prominent in the fruitless search for an &bquo;Arab solution&equo;. 
 Popular support for Mr Hussein grows with each bomb that falls on Iraq. 
 The governments, nervous, are playing for time. 
 Algeria, Morocco and Tunisia have made announcements vaguely sympathetic to Iraq and critical of the allied bombing. 
 But Morocco's opposition parties want King Hassan to bring home the 1,500 troops he sent to join the multinational force. 
 Algeria's biggest opposition party, the Islamic Salvation Front (FIS) says the government should train volunteers for Iraq. 
 Like many Islamic parties, the FIS used to get its money from Saudi Arabia, and criticise the barbarous treatment Mr Hussein meted out to his own Islamic opposition. 
 But once it became clear that most Algerians supported Iraq, the FIS quickly did the same. 
 A pro-Iraqi demonstration on January 18th mobilised a crowd of some 400,000. 
 Tunisia's main Islamic party, Ennahdha, was expected to exploit the conflict in the same way, but has been strangely absent from the streets. 
 Its leaders say it does not want to be responsible for any disturbances. 
 More to the point, perhaps, around a hundred of its most active members were arrested last month. 
 The regime most sorely embarrassed by the war is that of King Hassan of Morocco. 
 He is pro-western, and has had generous aid from the Saudis and Kuwaitis. 
 But most Moroccan newspapers have come out for Iraq, praising its missile attacks on Tel Aviv. 
 The opposition parties support Iraq, and so does the Constitutional Union, which is in the ruling coalition. 
 The American attacks on Iraq, it said, were intended to &bquo;bludgeon the Iraqi people and the Arab world, to force them to submit to Israeli arrogance.&equo;  
 The Arabs 
 The Saudis' world asunder 
 The war against Iraq is the biggest trauma for Arabs since the six-day war of 1967. 
 We report from Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Jordan and North Africa 
 MISSILE attacks on Saudi Arabia at unsociable hours have left the place bleary-eyed and jittery. 
 Not much work gets done. 
 People talk about the news and the government more critically than they did before. 
 War has brought to the surface things that are normally hidden. 
 For a start, people would like to know more. 
 Before January 20th Saudi television, with un-Saudi openness, was broadcasting CNN live. 
 But the news broadcast after the first missile attack failed to mention it. 
 Now CNN material is recorded and edited, omitting such details as pictures of the missile attacks on Saudi Arabia and anything to do with Israel. 
 Rich people with satellite dishes can get CNN live. 
 Others listen to British, American or Israeli radio. 
 Many Saudis have left the Eastern Province and Riyadh; the road from the capital to Jeddah is jammed with traffic. 
 Expatriate workers are nervous. 
 Those without gas masks sit out attacks holding napkins to their mouths. 
 The country would come to a halt if its 4m expatriate workers left. 
 Yet Saudis, a security-conscious lot, fear that those who stay may exploit the disorder if Riyadh is badly damaged. 
 They know that the foreigners have no love for a country that pays them and despises them, and they fear looting and riots. 
 A high-ranking Saudi, carrying a gun for the first time in his life, said it was for use not against Iraqis but against &bquo;certain other nationalities&equo;. 
 The Saudis themselves are increasingly of one mind. 
 The early opposition to the presence of foreign troops seems to have receded, partly because the soldiers have kept out of sight: with no bars or visible girls, there is no way of turning Dhahran into Saigon. 
 According to an office worker, &bquo;some of these people in the mosques are preaching against the Christians, and some people are listening. 
 But mostly now the Saudi people only want to kill Saddam.&equo; 
 Bazaar rumour has it that as many as 100 of these anti-American clerics have been locked away; but the government has taken no public stand against them. 
 Businessmen are enjoying their first boom for ten years. 
 Accommodating the exiled Kuwaitis has given a boost to the depressed property market, especially in the Eastern Province, where rents have tripled in the past year. 
 Flats empty for years are now occupied. 
 Refrigerators, cookers and furnishing materials are sold out. 
 Conservatives and liberals are both having a field day, taking liberties on the assumption that the government is too concerned with avoiding trouble to suppress them. 
 The religious police (mutawa) were recently pricked into action by the horrifying sight of Saudi women demonstrating for the right to drive. 
 Since then the mutawa have infuriated westernised Saudis, who prize their freedom to drink whisky in private, by busting into people's houses. 
 The government has done little to stop them. 
 The liberals, for their part, drew up a petition asking King Fahd for a consultative assembly, modernisation of the legal system and controls on the mutawa. 
 The petition was never delivered but the muttering about it has persuaded the king to promise a consultative assembly once all this is over. 
 He made the same promise nine years ago, during the siege of the Grand Mosque at Mecca. 
 A building for the assembly was indeed built, but now stands empty. 
 The government is plainly trying to generate a sense of nationalism, previously absent in this tribally divided country. 
 The royal family does not go in for oratory, so the policy is evident mostly in endless American- and British-made videos on television, boasting of Saudi Arabia's military and industrial prowess. 
 Even sceptics admit that there is a greater consciousness of national identity than in the past. 
 Nationalism may fill the gap left by the crumbling of old shibboleths of Arab and Islamic unity. 
 People are now saying what they think about their fellow-Arabs. 
 There is much criticism of the way foreign policy has been run. 
 &bquo;We thought we could pay people off,&equo; says a businessman, &bquo;and look who we paid most: the Iraqis, the Yemenis, the Jordanians, the Palestinians.&equo; 
 People expect that the cheque-book will be opened more discriminatingly in future, that the alliance between the Gulf states will be strengthened, and that Egypt will be the principal regional ally. 
 Defence policy, too, has come in for complaint. 
 Some Saudis were shocked to find how small their army was. 
 But it could be argued that the policy of spending on bases rather than on troops has paid off since Saudi Arabia has been able to accommodate, with astonishing ease, a multinational army 20 times the size of its own. 
 Now there is talk of a 180,000-strong army. 
 That could be hard: Saudis prefer desk jobs in air-conditioned offices. 
 It could also be dangerous. 
 The government kept the army small in the past mostly because it had noticed that autocratic regimes with large armies are vulnerable to military coups. 
 And even with a larger army, the Saudis do not seem to think that they would be able to protect themselves. 
 Nobody says so officially, but many people believe the Americans have come to stay. 
 &bquo;This is an international zone,&equo; says a businessman, &bquo;we need international protection.&equo; 
 There would be some opposition to American bases, he said, but most people face the prospect with equanimity. 
 It would, of course, do wonders for local business.  
 Israel 
 Keeping out 
 FROM OUR ISRAEL CORRESPONDENT 
 A MEETING of Israel's war cabinet on January 23rd, the day after an Iraqi Scud missile hit a block of flats in Ramat Gan killing three people, ended in a rare and thunderous silence. 
 Israelis, used to instant retaliation, do not like being sitting ducks. 
 America's Patriot anti-missile batteries, hastily airlifted to Israel from Germany after the first two Scud attacks, failed to stop a third attack but worked well the following night. 
 Israel's decision not to respond, at least for the moment, makes perfect sense. 
 American and allied aircraft are already pounding away at the fixed and mobile missile launchers concealed in the desert of south-western Iraq. 
 Israel, justifiably proud of its military prowess, has had to admit that it has nothing special to offer. 
 Its contribution to the war is to stay outside, cheering from the sidelines, absorbing the occasional painful jab from Saddam Hussein. 
 Vengeance has to wait. 
 Any military response would have to be closely co-ordinated with the allies. 
 And, according to some sources, America has withheld electronic identification codes, without which Israeli pilots flying over Iraq would risk clashing with allied aircraft. 
 If there were an Iraqi missile strike so serious that Israel felt it had to retaliate, an air corridor would have to be cleared by the American command in Saudi Arabia to allow the Israeli raid. 
 It is an unfamiliar situation for the Jewish state. 
 Benefits for Israel, in gratitude for its restraint, have been quick in coming. 
 The Iraqi missile attacks have provoked a wave of rare sympathy for a country that has been cast as the regional baddy. 
 The failure to attend to the Palestinian problem was put aside as Israel stood its ground with dignity. 
 Images of London's wartime blitz were conjured up as children taught their parents how to use gas masks. 
 &bquo;Internationally,&equo; the Jerusalem Post noted, &bquo;Israel suddenly finds itself in a glare of warm light as excruciatingly awkward as it is refreshingly flattering &mdash; a position of strength based almost entirely on passivity. 
 Oddly, perhaps ominously, the war has in many respects gone better for Israel to date than for any other single party (with the possible exception of CNN).&equo; 
 Israel felt emboldened to ask America for massive extra economic aid to pay for the damage caused by the state of emergency, the prolonged military alert &mdash; and the arrival of hundreds of thousands of new Soviet Jewish immigrants. 
 It already has the Patriots (deployed round the country's main cities and manned by American crews until Israeli servicemen can be trained to use them) and the almost permanent presence of America's deputy secretary of state, Lawrence Eagleburger. 
 Before the invasion of Kuwait George Bush and Yitzhak Shamir had barely spoken. 
 Now, it seems, they are seldom off the telephone.  
 The fragile rules of war 
 THE faces were grey and bruised, the voices faint; the eyes stared desperately, like actors seeking a prompt. 
 &bquo;I think this war should be stopped so we can go home,&equo; said Flight-Lieutenant Adrian Nichol; &bquo;I don't agree with this war.&equo; 
 He was one of seven captured allied airmen shown on everybody's television on January 20th. 
 The British secretary of defence, Tom King, said he had &bquo;the gravest suspicion&equo; about how their statements had been obtained. 
 Possibly their bruises were simply the effect of ejecting on to hard sand from a fast aircraft. 
 Parading captives on the screen is now a routine part of war. 
 American soldiers (and, to a lesser extent, British ones) are given orders on how to deal with a televised interrogation. 
 They may disclose only their name, rank, date of birth and serial number &bquo;or equivalent&equo;; if bullied, their best technique is to send up the unseen questioner. 
 One American pilot mocked his captors' accents, others gave wooden answers. 
 But they looked miserably cowed, a sight calculated to dispirit their colleagues who must fight on.  
 The Geneva Convention of 1949 sets the rules on treatment of &bquo;victims&equo; of war. 
 Each side claims a closer reading than the other. 
 The convention, invigilated by the International Committee of the Red Cross, cannot much mitigate the horror of war. 
 But it can make things a lot better for the sick, wounded and prisoners, as it was meant to. 
 (Islam, incidentally, has almost identical rules covering the decent treatment of victims of war.) 
 Article 13 of the Third Geneva Convention, specifically on prisoners of war, repeats the limits on the information they may be required to give. 
 They may be questioned, but must be &bquo;at all times protected, particularly against acts of violence or intimidation and against insults and public curiosity.&equo; 
 If torture was involved in the pilots' remarks this week &mdash; and many remember the UN investigations of Iraq's treatment of prisoners during the war with Iran &mdash; the rules were broken. 
 If not, Iraq's television show was not technically worse than the photographs that same day in western newspapers, showing the backs of Iraqi prisoners, forlorn beside a fence. 
 On January 21st, however, the Iraqis said they were placing prisoners of war near &bquo;scientific and economic targets&equo;, liable to air attack. 
 That is explicitly contrary to Article 23 of the third convention, whereby the presence of a prisoner may not &bquo;be used to render certain points or areas immune from military operations.&equo; 
 He is to be afforded shelter from bombardment &bquo;to the same extent as the local civilian population.&equo; 
 President George Bush announced immediately that using prisoners as shields was a war crime, for which Saddam Hussein would be held accountable. 
 America's war aims may now be expanded to include Mr Hussein's capture and trial. 
 War-crimes trials remain controversial, not least because the winners sit in judgment; even Nuremberg left a bad taste in the mouth. 
 But the concept of war crimes was new then, and the categories vague. 
 The Geneva Convention has clarified them; but the Iraqis say that the allies are themselves committing war crimes by attacking civilians.  
 Jordan in the middle 
 DEJECTION, elation and worry followed fast on one another's heels. 
 Jordanians were dejected by the beating Iraq was getting, elated by the news that Iraq had made good its threat to strike Israel with missiles, worried lest Israeli retaliation drag Jordan into the war. 
 King Hussein's biggest fear is that Jordan &mdash; wedged between Israel and Iraq, and with an army that is no match for either &mdash; should become a killing ground. 
 Having failed to stop the war, the king's main aim is to keep Jordan out of it. 
 Since that can best be done by bringing the war to a speedy end, he has begun a new round of diplomacy aimed at a ceasefire and peace negotiations. 
 He has appealed for a halt to the fighting, warning anybody who will listen that the Arab world is headed &bquo;for a period of turbulence like never before&equo;. 
 Jordan's foreign minister, Taher Masri, has asked ambassadors from several non-aligned states including India, China and Yugoslavia to help end the carnage. 
 He is planning to go to Tehran to initiate peace moves through the Islamic Conference Organisation. 
 Some of the Palestinians in Jordan put their hopes in a wider war. 
 The failure of diplomacy to win them a homeland has left them hoping that Israeli retaliation against Iraq will split Syria and Egypt from the anti-Iraq alliance and open a new Arab-Israeli conflict. 
 Jordan's parliament, where the pro-Iraq Muslim Brotherhood is strongly represented, also seems less interested in peace than in joining forces with Iraq. 
 In an emergency session on January 18th, it praised Iraq for playing &bquo;its historic role in resisting the great Satan who is threatening every Arab country.&equo; 
 Yet King Hussein is still perceived as one of the most moderate leaders in the region. 
 On January 21st President Bush held out an olive branch: some of the Arab countries supporting Iraq, he said, still had an important role to play in the future Middle East. 
 This understanding from the &bquo;Great Satan&equo; will do the king little good at home, but his position may be stronger than it looks. 
 His support for Iraq has won him backing from all quarters, from western-educated intellectuals to Muslim Brothers. 
 And the growth of an emerging democracy over the past two years provides an outlet for his critics' denunciations. 
 FINANCE 
 Big-bank mergers 
 Lead, California 
 NEW YORK AND LOS ANGELES 
 IF ONLY. 
 On January 22nd Security Pacific, America's fifth-largest bank, confirmed a newspaper report that it had held merger talks last year with 11th-ranked Wells Fargo. 
 The result would have been a Californian bank second in size only to New York's Citicorp. 
 A pity, say analysts, that it did not come off: America's biggest-ever bank merger could have led to a barrelful of such deals &mdash; and not before time. 
 America is awash with banks, 10,000 of them. 
 If the system is to return to profitability, some must merge (or fail). 
 Few, though, have the strength for any but the most modest mergers. 
 Any spare capital, regulators have insisted, must be committed first to strengthening balance sheets weakened by unwise lending, or to takeovers of the rump of the thrift industry. 
 The consolidation of banking that started in the 1980s has paused for much of the past year. 
 Yet several big mergers will be needed, if some of the large money-centre and super-regional banks are not to risk following Bank of New England down the hole. 
 The risks would be less if Congress were to act quickly on reform proposals provided by the administration, which could attract new capital into banking from outside, and break down the barriers that have hampered the growth of strong banks. 
 But Congress is going slow. 
 Mergers, if they come, will not embody lofty dreams of expansion. 
 The aim is to cut costs enough to scrape through today's recession. 
 Some savings would come from job cuts and closures of geographically competing branches. 
 Far more would come from combining computer systems. 
 Though banks have proved inept at merging, big ones in the same market should be able to achieve 30% cost savings. 
 For a pair like, say, Chase Manhattan and Chemical Bank, that would free more cash than the two's combined profits of the past five years. 
 For all their logic, big-bank mergers have proved tricky to arrange. 
 On January 23rd Citicorp's chairman, John Reed, said the bank would have to raise its capital by a half because the Fed thinks it is under-capitalised. 
 That will mean &dollar;3 billion-4 billion, only half of which he plans to get from further cost-cutting. 
 Where will the rest come from? 
 Mr Reed says Citicorp will not consider a merger for at least six months. 
 Regulators worry that mergers of two large, weak banks might just create one weak giant bank. 
 And who is to run the result? 
 Especially in New York, few bosses would favour a merger that left them as number two. 
 Security Pacific and Wells would have got round that by letting Wells's 59-year-old chairman, Carl Reichardt, head the merged bank for a couple of years of fierce cost-cutting, a Reichardt trademark, before handing over to Security Pacific's chief executive, Robert Smith, who is four years younger. 
 Banks being lemming-like institutions, many analysts believe that, once one big merger is pulled off, others will rush to follow. 
 And though Security Pacific says its talks with Wells Fargo were discontinued and that &bquo;no further talks are currently under way or contemplated,&equo; most bank analysts like to believe that they will be picked up again at some point &mdash; unless the banks find other partners first. 
 California's banking market is relatively strong. 
 Only 3% of all Californian banks' &dollar;260 billion in loans are problem ones, as against 6.4% of New York banks' &dollar;480 billion. 
 The four big banks &mdash; Bank of America and First Interstate complete the quartet &mdash; have 70% of the market. 
 Compared with the New York retail giants, they look paragons of banking virtue. 
 That owes much to the long prosperity of California's economy and its (until now) robust property market. 
 Both are today showing signs of weakness, but they are still far short of the east-coast mess. 
 California will allow out-of-state banks to enter its market from this year, so its big banks have for several years sought to concentrate on growing bigger in the local retail market through buying smaller banks and thrifts. 
 The original aim was to beat off Citicorp's expected arrival. 
 Now strong regionals, such as Banc One, Bancorp Hawaii, NBD and NCNB are the rivals. 
 The weaker of the big four are the two from Los Angeles, Security Pacific and First Interstate. 
 The latter was hurt by bad property loans in its Arizona and Texas subsidiaries. 
 But it is picking up; provided its core Californian property portfolio does not spring any unpleasant surprises, First Interstate could be an attractive buy. 
 Soon after its talks with Wells Fargo fell through, Security Pacific announced that it was cutting back its international operations, once a big growth area, because of bad loans in Britain and Australia that had contributed to a &dollar;230m fourth-quarter loss. 
 It will now concentrate on retail lending in California and across the Pacific. 
 With more scope left to cut flab, a slimmer Security Pacific must remain attractive to a would-be cost-cutter. 
 Of the two stronger banks, both from San Francisco, Bank of America, now well recovered from its flirtation with oblivion, has signalled its national ambitions by expressing an interest in parts of what is left of Bank of New England. 
 At home, it will probably content itself with continuing to fill gaps in its branch network by buying thrifts. 
 Wells Fargo is the enigma. 
 Under Mr Reichardt's knife, it has cut its international operations to concentrate on California, and earned a reputation as one of America's best-run banks. 
 Yet doubts remain about its heavy lending to property developers and over-borrowed companies. 
 Mr Reichardt's admirers say that if any American banker knows how to lend to property developers it is he &mdash; he was once one himself &mdash; and where better to do it than California? 
 Yet he could hardly finesse or cost-cut his way out of a serious downturn there. 
 If it has not already come, First Interstate should be expecting a telephone call soon.  
 American municipal bonds 
 You too? 
 NEW YORK 
 ACROSS America, state governments are preparing budgets for their coming financial years. 
 At least 34 states expect to be spending more than they collect. 
 Though all but Vermont are required by state law to balance their budgets, many will cheerfully borrow to plug the gap rather than raise taxes or cut spending. 
 This might look like good news for the huge municipal-bond market. 
 It would be &mdash; if the deterioration in credit quality gnawing at the financial system had not reached this market too. 
 Borrowing looks an odd route to a &bquo;balanced&equo; budget, but it is mostly within the letter of the law. 
 The discipline of the credit markets is meant to keep states from straying too far from the spirit of it. 
 So it does &mdash; up to a point. 
 After repeated downgradings, the bonds of New York, which has run a deficit in six of the past eight years, are now rated barely above junk-grade. 
 New York is planning for another deficit this year. 
 Like Massachusetts and Arizona, two other free-borrowing states whose credit is barely investment-grade, it will probably have to pay at least one percentage point more on new bonds than highly rated states. 
 How state governments approach the budget deficits now facing them will determine whether the coming year sees a further round of downgrading of public authorities' credit ratings. 
 States escaped relatively unscathed last year; not so cities and counties, which are less constrained by the law in matters of budgetary irresponsibility. 
 Last year Standard &amp; Poor's lowered its ratings on a record 474 issues of municipal bonds, worth &dollar;48 billion. 
 True, many were housing issues, hit because the banks and insurance companies supporting them, such as Citibank and Executive Life, had been downgraded. 
 But even if such issues are excluded, there were far more downgrades than upgrades, and many more than in 1989. 
 Defaults tell a similar story. 
 Last year 91 municipal issuers defaulted on &dollar;1.3 billion-worth of bonds, according to the Bond Investors Association. 
 That is not much in an outstanding total of &dollar;800 billion &mdash; three times the size of the junk-bond market &mdash; but it was still the third-worst year, by value, since the association started to keep records in the 1950s. 
 Little wonder that municipal-bond insurance is a growing business. 
 Market-watchers are talking of an approaching crisis, as recession spreads from east to west. 
 The states face a combined budget deficit of upwards of &dollar;30 billion, on the basis of Federal Reserve figures. 
 Many cities and counties are little better placed, as each layer of government passes down the spending obligations but not the money to fulfil them. 
 Philadelphia has been on the brink of going bust for months. 
 Its paper is now junk-grade. 
 New York city is reviving unhappy memories of its near-crash in the 1970s. 
 Its A-minus rating has been put on probation, out of fear of ballooning deficits; it might indeed have met sterner treatment had 1989 not been a mayoral election year. 
 The pressures that brought about last year's downgradings will intensify, says Vickie Tillman, Standard &amp; Poor's managing director responsible for municipals. 
 Recession is eating into the growth in revenues from sales, corporate and personal income tax, which on average account for 70% of state revenues. 
 Slowing property markets, especially in the east and north-east but now spreading west, are hurting property taxes and associated fees. 
 Federal aid is shrinking. 
 Meanwhile, state reserves are at their lowest in decades. 
 At the same time demand for spending is increasing. 
 Recession and rising unemployment have increased welfare demands. 
 States and local governments are having to shoulder more of the cost, much of it, such as environmental provisions and Medicare, under federal mandate. 
 Notably in New England and California, the adjustment between old expectations of ever-better social services, paid for by an ever-growing economy, and the new recessionary reality is a large one that will have to be made quickly. 
 The municipal-bond market has only just got over the jolt it received from federal tax changes in 1986 that removed tax breaks for some large buyers of new issues, notably banks and insurance companies. 
 In 1985 new issues topped &dollar;200 billion; in 1986 they were halved. 
 By last year they had crept back only to &dollar;113 billion, and that mostly thanks to some hefty refinancing of old high-coupon issues from the early 1980s to take advantage of lower interest rates. 
 At Moody's Investors Service, Daniel Heimowitz, executive vice-president for public financings, reckons that &mdash; assuming only a mild recession &mdash; new issues may reach &dollar;130 billion this year. 
 He thinks some states and cities will resort to pump-priming their economies with spending on things like roads, airports and waste-management. 
 But at what price? 
 Those governments that borrow short-term to cover their immediate cash-flow problems, without moving to put their finances on a sound footing, are likely to be given an even harder time by investors and credit-raters alike. 
 And even if that does not happen at once, it will in the coming years, when there will be fewer workers and new-property owners to pay taxes, and more elderly in need of welfare services.  
 Bonds away 
 NEW YORK 
 ALTHOUGH the bond market generally has been yo-yoing with the fortunes of the Gulf war, one issue is selling like hot bagels. 
 The day after the first bombs hit Baghdad, Israel aimed a &dollar;100m deep-discounted zero-coupon issue at small investors in North America. 
 The bonds will return only around 7% a year, but &dollar;21m-worth had been sold by January 23rd. 
 That is a blistering pace, given that the typical investment is a modest &dollar;2,500. 
 The chief executive of State of Israel Bonds, Meyir Rosenne, says that he expects the issue to sell out in two weeks, something that would take him ten weeks in normal times. 
 Most of the sales have been in New York, where the bonds are being promoted with a radio advertising campaign &mdash; &bquo;So our dollars can pay for war, your dollars pay for peace.&equo; 
 Daily newscasts about the Scud attacks on Tel Aviv provide potent free advertising. 
 The money will help Israel to provide housing and jobs for immigrants. 
 The country's biggest usual source of foreign exchange, tourism, has dried up since August. 
 Having raised &dollar;766m last year from dollar-denominated bonds, it aims for &dollar;1 billion this year. 
 It will probably get that and more, with Saddam Hussein as a salesman.  
 Swiss banking 
 Goodbye, cartels 
 ZURICH 
 A RUDE shock has hit Switzerland's bankers. 
 They are being forced &mdash; by politicians, if you please, as if politics were something serious like money &mdash; to compete. 
 Jean-Pascal Delamuraz, Switzerland's economy minister, is sweeping away some of the 20-odd price-fixing &bquo;conventions&equo;, a Swiss euphemism for cartels, that have stifled competition in the domestic market for the past half-century. 
 In September he backed the federal cartel commission's attack on the &bquo;fidelity&equo; clause. 
 This stopped banks in the bond-underwriting syndicate run by the country's big three &mdash; Union Bank of Switzerland (UBS), Swiss Bank Corporation (SBC) and Cr&eacute;dit Suisse &mdash; from taking part in issues organised by other banks. 
 The clause was abolished at the end of 1990. 
 So too were fee-fixing agreements covering securities dealing. 
 This has already led to stiffer competition among private banks. 
 Rather than charging clients commission on account transactions, some firms like Bank Julius Baer &mdash; one of the biggest private banks, specialising in fund management &mdash; and Morgan Stanley have introduced fixed management fees. 
 Not all bankers are convinced of the need to change. 
 Of the big three, only Cr&eacute;dit Suisse has inched towards a new fee structure; UBS and SBC prefer to wait and see. 
 Not that they can afford to wait for long. 
 A new generation of canny investors who have inherited family fortunes will quickly switch banks if they think they are getting a raw deal. 
 The cold wind of competition is blowing down the Bahnhofstrasse, Zurich's bank-strewn high street, just as the bankers' other problems were growing anyway. 
 With stock and bond markets in the doldrums, their trading operations have been badly hit. 
 Julius Baer recently announced that its profits fell by nearly a fifth last year, to SFr35m (&dollar;28m), thanks largely to lower commissions on share deals. 
 The banks have been stung by rising Swiss interest rates. 
 Several years ago they could offer mortgages at an interest rate of roughly 4%, fixed for an initial period of four years. 
 But then short-term interest rates rose unexpectedly, and customers shifted money from low-interest savings accounts to high-interest deposit accounts. 
 That left the banks paying more for funds, but unable, for a long time, to raise the cost of mortgages to compensate. 
 Many fixed-rate mortgages are now being refinanced at interest rates of around 8%. 
 Not all, of course, is gloom. 
 Making money out of the misfortune of others has long been a speciality of Swiss banks. 
 The country's reputation for political stability and banking secrecy still brings in footloose cash from trouble-spots around the world. 
 On some estimates, perhaps another SFr15 billion was added to the existing SFr1.5 trillion hoard during the first month of the Gulf crisis, and more has no doubt followed. 
 America's banking troubles have also brought in business: Swiss banks have been flooded both with deposits and loan requests from blue-chip American firms. 
 Yet, for the moment anyway, the bankers have lost their Midas touch. 
 Faced with fierce competition, many of the country's 380 or so small and medium-sized banks will merge or be taken over. 
 On January 15th Hentsch &amp; Cie and Darier &amp; Cie, two Geneva-based private banks, tied the knot, and more will no doubt follow. 
 UBS has been getting an average of one inquiry a day from small banks looking for a bigger uncle. 
 Unless business picks up soon, some of the 245 foreign-owned banks in Switzerland may have to shut up shop. 
 The big three banks too are suffering. 
 Most analysts reckon their profits fell by 10&ndash;20% last year. 
 And they too are having to respond. 
 Just before Christmas SBC announced that it would cut 500 jobs in Switzerland as part of an economy drive. 
 Shocked clockwatchers at other banks in Zurich are turning up to work earlier, and leaving later, in a bid to avoid the chop. 
 As well as cutting costs, Swiss banks must also revise their pricing policy: while they over-charge for some services, others, such as payment transfers, are still surprisingly cheap. 
 The big banks must also learn to innovate. 
 Cautious by nature, they have missed money-spinning opportunities in new businesses like portfolio insurance and financial derivatives. 
 New markets should help them to catch up. 
 Switzerland already has a two-year-old automated futures and options exchange for blue-chip stocks called SOFFEX. 
 Now it is the stockmarkets' turn for electronic treatment. 
 Later this year, three of Switzerland's seven bourses &mdash; Zurich, which handles two-thirds of all business, Geneva and Basle &mdash; will be linked by the Swiss Electronic Exchange, which will allow computerised trading in some stocks. 
 That still leaves Swiss banks with a handicap: an indecisive government, still dithering over the reform of a stamp tax of up to 3% on some transactions. 
 Since total taxes on financial services bring in over SFr9 billion a year in revenues, politicians are reluctant to vote for change. 
 If they do not change, tax revenue may fall anyway, as business leaves for friendlier haunts.  
 The dollar's flight path 
 Where will the dollar head when peace breaks out? 
 DURING the two months or so before the first shots were fired in the Gulf, the dollar rose. 
 It gained 10% against the yen and 5% against the D-mark from its lows of October and November. 
 As war got nearer, so it rose further. 
 Many people expected that, if war broke out, it would rise further still as investors sought safe havens. 
 In fact, once the fighting began, the dollar lost 3% against the yen and the D-mark overnight. 
 The obvious explanation is that the first reports of allied successes suggested that the war would be short. 
 Yet the dollar did not move strongly up again when the gloomier reality sank in. 
 Perhaps because its safe-haven credentials already looked shaky: it had also fallen when Iraqi tanks first rolled into Kuwait. 
 One factor which investors look for in a safe haven is liquidity. 
 In times of trouble, therefore, they tend to keep a bigger share of their portfolio at home and sell some foreign assets. 
 If so, currencies of net debtor countries would be expected to fall (as more is pulled out than returns home); those of creditor countries to rise. 
 In previous international crises, America was the world's biggest creditor; today it is the biggest debtor. 
 This may be why the dollar slipped. 
 More immediately, the war could, on some estimates, increase America's monthly budget deficit by two-thirds while it lasts. 
 Whatever the impact of the Gulf, America's deteriorating economy suggests that the dollar could fall further in the short run. 
 Alan Greenspan, the chairman of the Federal Reserve, is worried about the sharp slowdown in monetary growth. 
 The broad measure, M3, grew by only 1% in the 12 months to December, and actually fell for the last three months of 1990. 
 The Fed has cut its target for the federal-funds rate five times in the past three months, to 6.75%. 
 Even though this is barely above the rate of inflation (6.1%), it stands ready to cut rates again. 
 So dollar deposits are already earning less &mdash; and, on top, the Fed looks less worried by inflation than other central banks. 
 The Bundesbank, by contrast, remains obsessed with inflation (Germany's current rate is a &bquo;horrific&equo; 2.8%). 
 It has been threatening to increase interest rates if the German government does not raise taxes to trim its widening budget deficit. 
 There were fears that this might cause frictions at the meeting on January 21st of the finance ministers and central bankers of the Group of Seven (G7) big industrial economies (America, Britain, Canada, France, Germany, Italy and Japan). 
 Higher German interest rates would not only put downward pressure on the dollar, but also worry those other members of the European exchange-rate mechanism (ERM) whose economies are slowing, or &mdash; in Britain &mdash; actually in recession. 
 As it turned out, events in the Gulf seem to have encouraged the Bundesbank to put international concerns first. 
 The final G7 communiqu&eacute; referred to the conditions in which global interest rates would be cut, not raised. 
 But anybody expecting the G7 to meet the Gulf war with a bold plan to stabilise currencies was disappointed. 
 The G7 members did no more than reassure the financial markets about their readiness to intervene to curb volatility. 
 Exchange-rate targeting and economic-policy co-ordination are, it seems, out of fashion. 
 This is partly because the G7 had other matters on its agenda, such as how to share out the burden of paying for the Gulf war and the issue of debt relief for Egypt and Poland. 
 But currency stabilisation has been pushed to one side for another reason as well. 
 The three big economies are at different stages of the economic cycle: while America is struggling with recession, Japan and Germany are still fighting inflation, giving rise to differences in interest-rate policies and attitudes towards the risk of inflation. 
 Changing course 
 Although the dollar remains risky in the short run, most economists reckon that it will rally in the medium term. 
 Why? 
 It looks cheap. 
 Goldman Sachs, an American investment bank, reckons that the dollar is undervalued by an impressive 35% against the D-mark and yen. 
 The bank estimates that its purchasing-power parity (ie, the exchange rate which would equate the prices of a similar basket of goods and services in the two countries concerned) is &yen;203 (its current rate is &yen;132) and DM2.25 (DM1.49). 
 Goldman Sachs forecasts that the dollar will be &yen;142 and DM1.75 in a year's time. 
 The gap between American interest rates and those abroad could soon start to narrow. 
 Interest rates on D-mark deposits are currently almost two percentage points higher than those on dollar deposits, despite Germany's much lower inflation. 
 But by mid-year American interest rates should have bottomed as the economy starts to recover, while rates in Germany and Japan could by then be falling, as their economies slow. 
 Japan is likely to cut first. 
 Its broad money growth has slowed sharply, from 13.2% in the 12 months to May 1990 to 8.6% in the year to December. 
 The Bank of Japan has already nudged down overnight rates; if the spring pay round shows wage rises to be moderating, it could then cut the discount rate. 
 Current-account imbalances are shrinking rapidly. 
 This year America's deficit and Germany's surplus are forecast to be less than half as big, as a percentage of GNP, as they were at their peak; Japan's surplus may be only a quarter of its peak level. 
 This will undermine the idea that the dollar needs to stay cheap. 
 Three reasons for buying the dollar before the war is won. 
 Unfortunately, there is no reason why economists should be any better at predicting that date than they are at predicting currencies.  
 British local-authority interest-rate swaps 
 Rotten boroughs 
 HUNDREDS of millions of pounds are at risk. 
 So is the City of London's good name, and the creditworthiness of Britain's local-government councils. 
 And court cases could drag on for years. 
 Prepare yourself for these laments now that Britain's law lords, its highest court, have ruled that interest-rate swaps between councils and banks, related to billions of pounds of underlying debt, are unlawful. 
 Seventy-eight British and foreign banks stand to lose &pound;500m-600m (about &dollar;1 billion) from the decision. 
 One of the most active swap peddlers, the TSB, has already set aside &pound;76m. 
 Other banks caught in the market are Barclays, Midland, and a crowd of American, European and Japanese banks. 
 They plan a political and legal blitz to undo the decision's effects by new legislation. 
 At the height of their activity, local councils accounted for perhaps one-third of a &pound;30 billion market in sterling interest-rate swaps. 
 They had blue-chip credit standing, and were among the few counterparties with plenty of fixed-rate interest payments to swap for floating-rate ones. 
 The banks' best customer was the London borough of Hammersmith and Fulham. 
 It graduated from simple swaps to new-fangled instruments, such as options on swaps. 
 All told, the borough conducted 592 swap deals, related to some &pound;6 billion of underlying debt, far more than the council had actually borrowed. 
 When the borough treasurers went on holiday, say City folk, so did the money brokers who brought all this business to the banks. 
 In 1988, as interest rates rose, so did the burden of the floating-rate payments that Hammersmith had swapped into. 
 It began to lose money, and would now owe banks some &pound;250m-300m if its contracts were enforced. 
 Hammersmith's auditor has argued in three courts that the deals are not enforceable, since councils had no power in law to engage in such deals. 
 Its woes wrecked the thriving swaps business between banks and local authorities. 
 Under instructions from the Audit Commission, which oversees local-government finances, all councils suspended payments to the banks in November 1989. 
 On January 24th the law lords annulled not just Hammersmith's swaps, but more than 1,000 others arranged between banks and 130 councils over the past nine years. 
 Banks are aghast. 
 Both the Bank of England and the Audit Commission had blessed swaps as tools for managing interest-rate risk. 
 There had been some hope that the law would distinguish between such deals, part of normal prudent treasury management, and others, essentially speculative, as if the council were in the finance business itself. 
 An earlier appeal-court ruling had made that distinction, but the lords did not. 
 Now, say the banks, no deal is sacred in the City. 
 Several French bankers stormed out of one meeting, grumbling that Britain's legal standards had sunk to the level of Venezuela's. 
 But the banks have no monopoly of principle. 
 While they chased the business of a few gambling councils, some City lawyers were already arguing that councils could enter into swaps only to hedge interest-rate payments on normal borrowings. 
 Most councils were doing just that. 
 But the caps, floors, collars and other fancy products traded by Hammersmith had little to do with the council's debt: they were sheer punts on interest rates or, indeed, evasions of central-government borrowing limits. 
 Now banks and councils have to sort out the mess. 
 A negotiated settlement is out of the question: the councils have no legal power to pay banks money on open contracts annulled by the lords' decision. 
 The banks want legislation that would provide that power. 
 So, it seems, does the Bank of England, fearful that the fiasco will drive financial business from London to upstart continental centres. 
 And banks say that John Major's Treasury and local-government ministers have given them a more sympathetic hearing than Margaret Thatcher's. 
 Most of the councils would like to fulfil their contracts. 
 Few gambled as Hammersmith did, and they can afford the small sums they owe. 
 If they are not allowed to pay, credit will become more expensive: by a full half percentage point, suggests one local-government official. 
 Yet the government cannot easily undo the damage wrought by the courts. 
 It will be reluctant to propose a law to make banks &pound;500m richer at the expense of local taxpayers. 
 And there are few precedents for the sort of retroactive legislation the banks want. 
 Even if these obstacles are overcome, just which deals should be deemed legitimate (or at least open to settlement)? 
 All, or only &bquo;normal&equo; ones? 
 In practice, that distinction would be hard to define. 
 Any legislation might have to allow, somehow, for the special problems of Hammersmith. 
 If the government does not back legislation, banks will demand restitution: the unwinding of both open swap positions and hundreds of past deals too. 
 That could involve a flood of lawsuits against reluctant councils. 
 Some banks also have a hit list of people whom they threaten to sue for damages. 
 Targets include brokers who brought the swaps business to the banks, accountants who approved councils' financial statements, and the councils themselves. 
 In the end, banks would probably come out slightly ahead. 
 Lawyers, of course, would grow rich.  
 Leaking at the seams 
 The Corporation of Lloyd's, London's peculiar insurance market, is three centuries old. 
 Can it keep afloat even another ten years? 
 HAUNTED by catastrophes past, Lloyd's of London faces a bleak future. 
 Some wonder whether, in any recognisable form, by 2000 it will even be there. 
 This matters to more than just those smooth scions of the British upper class who work in this singular insurance market, or to those who pledge their wealth, as &bquo;names&equo;, to back the market's underwriting syndicates. 
 Though this collective of co-operatives pulls in only as much premium income as some of Britain's big insurance companies, Lloyd's is synonymous with British insurance. 
 An enfeebled Lloyd's would harm the City of London's international standing. 
 It was this thought that held the British government back from putting Lloyd's firmly under its thumb during the fraud-ridden years of the late 1970s and early 1980s. 
 The market has since done much to polish up its self-regulation, though it is still far from squeaky-clean. 
 Today, however, the biggest problem that faces David Coleridge, who took over this month as chairman of Lloyd's, is not one of scandal, but of profits. 
 In the next couple of years these will prove uniformly bad, underscoring the steady loss of competitiveness from which Lloyd's has suffered recently. 
 The market's share of world premium income was 2.2% in 1983, but only is only half that today. 
 The latest published figures for Lloyd's show &pound;575m (&dollar;950m) of pre-tax profit in 1987 (Lloyd's syndicates close their accounts only after three years), down slightly on the record profits of 1986. 
 That was before a blast of natural and man-made catastrophes in 1988&ndash;90 sent insurance claims pouring into Lloyd's: the fire on the Piper Alpha oil platform, the spillage from the Exxon Valdez, the San Francisco earthquake, Hurricane Hugo and a spate of European gales. 
 Worse, these disasters coincided with falling premium rates in almost every one of the market's businesses. 
 Today Chatset, an independent consultancy, reckons Lloyd's will post a meagre profit for 1988 (see the chart overleaf) and a loss of more than &pound;850m for 1989, the first loss since 1967. 
 Many of the 26,500 names would therefore love to follow the 6,000 who have already shaken the dust of Lloyd's from their feet these past three years. 
 Yet half the names could not leave even if they wanted to: they are locked into the 58 (out of a total of 401) Lloyd's syndicates that have been unable to close one or more of their past annual accounts, so unquantifiable are the liabilities stacking up against them. 
 Many of the resultant 92 &bquo;open years&equo; have to do with old American liabilities &mdash; for asbestos-related risks, for example, and pollution &mdash; whose scale was undreamt-of when the insurance (or, more usually, the reinsurance) policies were underwritten. 
 The most notorious case concerns the 1,600 names on 31 Outhwaite syndicates. 
 These face losses, mainly on asbestosis claims, of up to &pound;1 billion; since Lloyd's names have unlimited liability, many will be bankrupted. 
 A case that looks set to rival Outhwaite in notoriety concerns two Feltrim syndicates, where at least &pound;200m of losses are emerging on &bquo;excess-of-loss&equo; insurance in 1987&ndash;89. 
 Nor do the market's commercial troubles end there. 
 Other unsuspected &bquo;long-tail&equo; claims are now hitting it, notably untold billions of coming dollars for professional negligence. 
 Most visible are the claims arising out of the gross mismanagement during the 1980s of America's savings-and-loan institutions. 
 Open years are proving to be open wounds for Lloyd's. 
 Upsets unlimited 
 Those names in the worst-hit syndicates &mdash; and the members' agents who are meant to represent them &mdash; are squealing. 
 They want some kind of &bquo;market&equo; solution &mdash; by which they usually mean spreading losses around to other, unaffected names. 
 In the past the ruling council of Lloyd's has refused to contemplate anything that would appear to mutualise names' losses. 
 That, it rightly argues, would defeat the whole notion of risking individual wealth for individual gain. 
 Yet many names do not believe that the losses for which they are being asked to stump up were incurred just through bad luck. 
 Many suspect individual cases of fraud or negligence; some think that the conflicts of interest that run deep at Lloyd's prevent proper self-regulation. 
 By forming action committees, names are starting to fight back. 
 If, as expected, the 1,700 aggrieved names on the Feltrim syndicates appoint solicitors at the end of this month, then some 15% of all names would be part of such action groups. 
 That is a statistic that ought to alarm any Lloyd's insider. 
 There are signs that the council of Lloyd's is starting to listen to the names' cries. 
 It has asked the Department of Trade and Industry for approval to set up a vehicle to provide names with a way of getting out of open years. 
 Due to start in March, the vehicle, dubbed &bquo;Leopardcover&equo;, would be backed by the market's central fund. 
 Names on open years would, on payment of a premium meant to reflect commercial conditions, be granted unlimited cover for future liabilities. 
 In the past Mr Coleridge is said to have sworn (&bquo;over my dead body&equo;) that he would not countenance such a guarantee fund. 
 But he later changed his spots enough to insist on Leopardcover as a condition of accepting the market's chairmanship. 
 Not that the new fund would come cheaply. 
 At a best guess, a name on an Outhwaite syndicate would have to cough up some &pound;750,000 in premiums to clear an original exposure of &pound;30,000 to the syndicate. 
 That comes on top of the tens of thousands of pounds in claims that the name will already have had to pay. 
 These high premiums, once paid, will only hasten the departure of names from Lloyd's. 
 Shoot the albatross 
 That is why Lloyd's now needs to question its hallowed notion of unlimited liability, which makes names liable down to the last button on their boxer shorts. 
 Unlimited liability is said to underpin the integrity of a Lloyd's insurance policy. 
 Now that names no longer get the tax breaks that were long the market's main attraction, it is an outdated nonsense. 
 Introducing limited liability would change Lloyd's beyond recognition. 
 It would bring in outside capital, mostly from corporate members, now barred. 
 That capital and experience would give Lloyd's a bigger, global strength, as it became dominated by fewer, larger groups. 
 These would be better able to market its strengths (which are being shown to advantage during the Gulf war, for which Lloyd's is putting together imaginative war insurance where other markets fear to tread). 
 Though private names could still co-exist in this new world, they would soon be the minority. 
 Many members' agents, and many syndicates that rely on those agents for business, would perish. 
 Hence the fierce resistance among the professionals to limited liability. 
 Mr Coleridge inherits a market that has made some sensible moves to improve its competitive edge. 
 Previously the world's largest user of punch-cards, Lloyd's switched to an electronic network at the start of this year. 
 Until this year, syndicates had to decide which of four market divisions to operate in &mdash; marine, non-marine, aviation or motor. 
 Now syndicates can offer tailor-cut policies that cross those lines. 
 Yet much more needs to be done. 
 A cumbersome bureaucracy has grown up at Lloyd's that panders to the market's parochial interests rather than to its wider good. 
 By arguing, amongst other radical things, for limited liability, the new chairman could change that &mdash; and he is already making the right noises. 
 Whether Mr Coleridge wants to crown a successful career by pulling down the edifice in which he has enjoyably spent his working life is another matter entirely. 
 SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 
 Supply and command 
 ONE problem with a high-tech war is that it requires so much technology. 
 Millions of parts and supplies must be got to the right place at the right time, which is something American military forces have not always been able to do. 
 In the Spanish-American war of 1898, troops arrived in Florida with only winter clothing. 
 (The British had cornered the khaki-drill market for the Boer war.) 
 Heat-stroke caused casualties before the enemy fired a shot. 
 Operation Desert Storm, by contrast, seems so far to have been supplied without a hitch &mdash; thanks to computers. 
 Like its industry, America's armed forces spent much of the 1980s automating their warehouses and distribution systems. 
 Much of the equipment &mdash; and many of the management techniques &mdash; now supplying troops in the desert are the same as those working in factories back at home. 
 The air force, for example, keeps track of its stock on a &dollar;200m system built under contract by Computer Sciences Corporation in El Segundo, California, using IBM mainframe computers and off-the-shelf database software from Computer Associates in New York. 
 One obvious difference between military and commercial systems is the built-in security. 
 A bigger one is sheer scale. 
 A factory might manage a few thousand kinds of parts; the air force has to cope with over 6m. 
 Part of the trick of managing such diversity, as many businesses have learnt, is global specialisation. 
 The air force divides responsibility for spare parts among seven centres. 
 One is Hill Air Force Base in Ogden, Utah, which is in charge of parts for F-16s. 
 Technology links these centres into a network capable of shipping parts quickly to wherever they are needed. 
 If a bomber in Saudi Arabia breaks down, a technician requests parts from a computer in his repair bay. 
 If the computer cannot find the part at the local air base, the request is automatically forwarded, via satellite, to the right place back in America. 
 The computer in Ogden, or wherever, finds the supply nearest to where it is needed. 
 In most cases it can then tell automated warehouse equipment to fetch the part from the shelf and send it to the shipping area. 
 At every warehouse, computers monitor stock levels and re-order from the factory when they fall below a minimum. 
 That minimum level can be adjusted by other systems that predict the need for parts, given past maintenance patterns and expected operations. 
 Though about 95% of orders are placed without human intervention, people can, of course, monitor and override any of the system's decisions &mdash; eg, to ensure that it is not ordering &dollar;2m missiles because of a statistical fluke. 
 More important, forces on the ground can track the progress of an order &mdash; so commanders know exactly how long they will be waiting for spares and can plan accordingly.  
 The uncontested arena 
 THERE is one sphere of battle in which America has always had supremacy: the one that surrounds the earth. 
 Iraq has launched a rocket into space but it has never put a satellite into orbit. 
 America's satellites have the high ground to themselves. 
 Some are communications and weather satellites not unlike their civilian brethren. 
 Others are more specialised. 
 According to John Pike, an analyst with the Federation of American Scientists, there are six optical-reconnaissance satellites in the &bquo;Keyhole&equo; series currently thought to be in orbit. 
 Three are straightforward KH-11s, of which one has been up for more than six years; three are advanced KH-11s. 
 These satellites carry photomultipliers, which amplify the light they receive, and infra-red cameras, which can see at night. 
 They have telescope mirrors comparable in size to the one on the Hubble space telescope &mdash; but, one hopes, not afflicted by the Hubble mirror's distortions &mdash; and produce images good enough to make out an object the size of a paperback book. 
 Such pictures can be transmitted to ground stations anywhere in the world, mainly by means of SDS relay satellites. 
 The KH-11s may be able to transmit directly to the allies' command centre in Saudi Arabia. 
 Whether it goes through computers in America or in the desert, the information can be with commanders in the field in a matter of minutes. 
 As well as these visual-reconnaissance satellites there is also a radar-imaging satellite, at one point called Lacrosse (its name may have changed). 
 This uses synthetic-aperture radar, which exploits the fact that the radar is moving to build up three-dimensional images of the terrain below. 
 The technique requires lots of data and lots of computing. 
 The data get to the ground-based supercomputers through the TDRSS relay satellites, which can cope with more data than the SDS. 
 Lacrosse can focus on a small area and resolve details down to perhaps a metre, or sacrifice clarity to cover a larger area. 
 It can see through clouds, which over the past week have stymied satellites using visible light, and even penetrate the soil. 
 It can probably spot moving targets, and give their speed and direction. 
 Because metal, wood and stone reflect radar waves differently, Lacrosse may also be able to spot the difference between real targets and elaborate mock-ups. 
 Also looking down, but from a much higher orbit, is a Defence Support Programme satellite (DSP). 
 Its orbit takes it around the world once every 24 hours, so it appears to stay at one point in the sky. 
 From there it looks for the infra-red &bquo;signature&equo; of a rocket's exhaust. 
 When it sees one, it informs the troops on the ground. 
 Near the DSP satellite, and in lower orbits as well, there are signals-intelligence satellites that can monitor radios and radar. 
 Together with snoopers in aircraft and on the ground, these satellites helped form a picture of Iraq's command and control network and air defences. 
 Lower down are the 15 satellites of the Navstar Global Positioning System (GPS). 
 These transmit coded signals containing information from highly accurate atomic clocks on board. 
 If there are four satellites visible, a military user on the ground with a portable receiver can use the discrepancies between their time-checks to get a measurement of his position accurate to well under ten metres. 
 Civilian users cannot decipher as much information from the satellites' signals and thus get fixes that are less precise. 
 There are thousands of receivers on tanks, ships and aircraft in the Gulf. 
 Unfortunately, to guarantee that four satellites will always be visible would require 24 of them &mdash; and there will not be that many around for another few years. 
 It is thought that in the Gulf at the moment the GPS provides full cover only at night.  
 The microchip war 
 OUR nation has pursued for decades the policy that has substituted machines and technology for human lives. 
 I think especially in this environment we will continue to pursue that policy.&equo; 
 His suggestion that America should make Saddam Hussein the target of its attack cost General Michael Dugan his job as air-force chief of staff last September. 
 But what he said about the role technology would play in the war seems to have been as accurate as the laser-guided bombs shown on television. 
 The technology that has been substituted for human lives on the widest scale is that of the microprocessor. 
 Just as microchips have infiltrated the home and office, so they have invaded the battlefield. 
 The differences between today's weapons and those of the second world war are not unlike those between a 1940s gramophone and a compact-disc player, armed with a laser and stuffed with chips. 
 It does the old job much better and some new jobs too. 
 Although microchips give machines only a smidgen of intelligence, that can go a long way when sensibly applied by human masters. 
 In some cases, the microchip takes a man's place in facing danger. 
 A Tomahawk cruise missile does the job of a bomber. 
 It is programmed with a flight plan telling it how to get from a nearby &bquo;way-point&equo; to its target, and with a set of pictures of how the terrain it will pass over should look to its radar altimeter. 
 It can thus check that it is on course. 
 These map programs take a fair bit of work, and cannot be drawn up on the launching ship; the sailors load a ready-made map into the missile, and tell it how to get to the initial way-point. 
 When the missile nears its target, it stops relying on radar and turns on a more acute guidance system. 
 This compares what the missile sees through a light-sensitive sensor in its nose with pictures of the target stored in its memory. 
 As missiles go, a Tomahawk is supremely gifted. 
 But it can only carry one 1,000lb (455kg) warhead, or a set of 166 bomblets which can be dropped in three batches. 
 An F-15E, America's newest fighter-bomber, can carry a weapons load of up to 24,500lb (11,113kg). 
 The Tomahawk also fails fairly often. 
 Of the 104 launched on the first day of the war, it seems, 10&ndash;20 fell from the sky. 
 The Tomahawk cannot change course, choose alternative targets, fight off opposition or bring back pictures of the damage done. 
 If a commander thinks it essential to destroy something right away, he will still send bombers. 
 For difficult but less vital tasks, a disposable &dollar;1m Tomahawk is a cheap alternative to a bomber and its crew. 
 No cleverer than it ought to be 
 Most military chips do not replace men. 
 They protect them and improve their ability to cause damage. 
 The obvious benefits have been seen in videotapes showing missiles and bombs hitting targets with extreme precision. 
 This, in theory, saves lives on the other side &mdash; a concern that has been rare in recent wars, but seems to carry some weight in this one. 
 Much of the precision comes from laser guidance. 
 This trick has been used since the last few years of the Vietnam war, and does not rely on any particularly outlandish circuitry. 
 Its success comes from its determination to do one thing as well as it can. 
 Such monomania has been useful to warriors since long before the silicon age. 
 Laser-guided bombs have a small sensor in their nose, and little fins. 
 The two are linked via a microchip. 
 If the sensor is pointed straight at something reflecting the light of a laser beam &mdash; distinctive in its brightness and colour &mdash; the bomb's tiny mind is happy. 
 If the laser light wanders off centre, the bomb uses its fins to change its direction and angle of fall until the light is once again centred. 
 Such simple circuits control many types of missile &mdash; radar seekers and heat seekers, for example. 
 The innovation of the laser-guided bomb is that you can aim at anything: just point the laser at it, and the bomb will fall on it if it can. 
 During night missions inside Iraq, the laser shines from the belly of the bomber, and is kept on target by the pilot or the weapons officer, with the help of electronics that compensate for the aircraft's movements. 
 Lasers may later be used by troops to mark out tanks for attack. 
 Most missiles with pretensions to cleverness are brighter than a laser-guided bomb, but not as clever as a Tomahawk. 
 Some weapons home in on infra-red sources, some on radar, others just go where they are told. 
 Some, like the Stand-off Land Attack Missile, SLAM, or the Israeli-produced Have Nap, can be &bquo;flown&equo; by pilots looking through the missile's television eye, while sitting at a safe remove in aircraft. 
 In getting the bombs to where they can be used, air crews are helped by extensions to their senses &mdash; infra-red vision, light amplification and radar for night flight &mdash; all of which rely on electronics. 
 &bquo;Avionics&equo; circuits help them manoeuvre. 
 They are protected by electronic countermeasures (ECM) which confuse enemy radar by sending out electronic noise and spurious signals. 
 Just as missiles can be guided from aircraft that did not launch them, so jamming can be done by someone else on the bomber's behalf; division of labour pays off in battles, too. 
 The extra range provided to sensors and accurate weapons by modern electronics allows some jammers and bombers to &bquo;stand off&equo; &mdash; another way in which technology saves lives. 
 The possibilities of linkage 
 Microchips also let things happen at inhuman speed. 
 The Patriot missile system is a good example. 
 At its heart is a sophisticated &bquo;phased-array&equo; radar, a stationary gridwork of tiny radar transmitters controlled by computer. 
 By putting the elements in the radar out-of-step with each other to various degrees, the computer can use the array to make a radar beam that can flit across the sky and track a number of targets almost simultaneously. 
 When the system picks up an enemy, alerted by a DSP early-warning satellite (see box) or an AWACS aeroplane, the radar starts tracking it. 
 When it comes into range, the system launches an interceptor. 
 This missile is not particularly clever, but the computers that control it and the radar are. 
 As the interceptor streaks up, the radar tracks it as well as the incoming target. 
 The radar beam which tracks the Patriot missile carries instructions updating it on which way to go to head off the enemy. 
 When the interceptor gets close to its target, it is used as a second radar receiver. 
 Beams that bounce off the target are received by the interceptor, which passes the information back to the ground. 
 The computers then use it to check the guidance instructions. 
 If the target uses ECM &mdash; Scuds do not, but aeroplanes can &mdash; then the relatively powerful computers on the ground can have a good crack at sorting out information from disinformation. 
 The Patriot is a complicated system of launchers, radars, communications and control. 
 The assembly of weapons into systems, spread wide in space but linked by little strings of data, typifies microchip warfare. 
 Machines can keep the disparate parts of such a system co-ordinated much better than men can. 
 An as-yet-unproven system called J-STARS, getting its baptism of fire in the Gulf, illustrates the point. 
 J-STARS uses large air-borne synthetic-aperture radars to create images of the terrain 100 miles (160km) or more away, and identify moving objects like tanks and trucks. 
 That information is sent to tactical computers in control stations to produce guidance for artillery and missiles &mdash; the American army's new tactical missile system has been designed to operate as part of such a set-up, hitting targets more than 100km (60 miles) off. 
 Not all computers are in the front line. 
 Some are tacticians and some are back-room boys, dealing with logistics (see box above) and military planning. 
 Desert Storm, with its thousands of sorties a day, could have been planned without computers (the Schlieffen plan launched the first world war with sweat and brainpower, little more); but computers allow the plans to be fine-tuned and to be altered quickly. 
 And some computers find their niche as boffins, designing ever-fancier gadgets. 
 The F-117A, the &bquo;stealth fighter&equo;, is a product of computers. 
 Much of its stealth comes from a design that minimises the chance of radar waves bouncing back the way they came. 
 In the 1970s, when it was designed, computers were hard put to work out how to minimise the radar reflected from curved surfaces &mdash; so the F-117A is made up of flat ones. 
 The more modern B-2 bomber is more rounded. 
 The F-117A's shape also makes it unstable; without on-board electronics constantly helping the pilot, the stealth fighter would be almost impossible to fly. 
 Your bill, sir 
 Microchip warfare is undeniably impressive, but it is clearly not flawless. 
 It is always at the mercy of the people who design and use it. 
 It can have faults in its design, or it can be used incorrectly (correct use needs trained skills). 
 It can also be betrayed. 
 Information from the French, American and Russian experts who helped set up Iraq's air defences will have helped in their defeat or circumvention &mdash; a jammer which knows how the enemy radar &bquo;thinks&equo; has a great advantage. 
 The high-technology route is extremely expensive; the sophistication of America's weapons and the plaintiveness of its calls for burden-sharing are directly related. 
 The cost of weapons often means they are in potentially short supply, all the more so because once commanders find that a weapon works, they want to use it for everything. 
 The weapons are expensive partly because they are made of expensive components, but also because they are time-consuming to develop. 
 The &bquo;new&equo; systems being used in the Gulf have all been more than a decade in development. 
 The long gestation comes from the fact that, although mechanical and chemical engineering hold few surprises &mdash; if the design looks all right the thing will probably work &mdash; electronic engineering carries no such assurances. 
 All programs have bugs, and need endless refinement. 
 High-tech weaponry has certainly kept down casualties during the air war (it will have less ability to do so on the ground). 
 Whether it allows the exercise of force to be more controlled and effective has yet to be seen. 
 There are still no accurate assessments of damage available. 
 It is clear, and unsurprising, that Patriot missiles sometimes fail. 
 It is easy to deduce that other systems do, too; many targets are being hit again and again. 
 The pictures of precision attacks provide only anecdotal evidence of effectiveness. 
 Smart weapons can clearly produce a dazzling display. 
 Whether they can win wars has yet to be proved. 
 BUSINESS THIS WEEK 
 The long road 
 World stockmarkets reacted with relief and optimism at the start of the Gulf war, but some of the gains were wiped out when the first hopes of a quick victory faded, and the Soviet Union turned violent again. 
 Finance ministers of the Group of Seven industrial countries agreed to intervene in financial markets if need be. 
 The group also rewarded Egypt for its part in the Gulf alliance by agreeing to write off more than a third of the country's debt to foreign governments. 
 Poland, in the forefront of reform in Eastern Europe, may soon be relieved of a similar proportion of its &dollar;45 billion debt. 
 Oil prices fell sharply, then rose a little on renewed fear of war damage. 
 Saudi Arabia cut production by at least 10% because the world is awash with oil. 
 The Uruguay round of trade talks cannot restart until Japan's position on agricultural reform shifts more, America's State Department said. 
 Most people had thought Europe was the problem. 
 Air turbulence 
 Britain's Civil Aviation Authority recommended that Heathrow airport, closed to new entrants since 1977, be opened to more airlines. 
 If this is approved, British Airways, which holds 38% of the available slots, will suffer. 
 But the way will be clear for American Airlines and United Airlines, to buy the London services of TWA and Pan Am. 
 Faced with an airline industry desperate for cash, America's transport department is to relax restrictions on foreign investment in American airlines. 
 The ceiling of 25% ownership is to be raised to 49%. 
 This will allow Holland's KLM to keep a big investment in Northwest Airlines. 
 With bookings down dramatically in reaction to the Gulf war, TWA is to cut European flights by nearly half and lay off 2,500 people. 
 In chapter 11 for nearly two years after labour problems, and crippled further by the Gulf war, America's Eastern Air Lines at last closed down after 62 years in the air. 
 Pass the buck 
 America's largest commercial bank, Citicorp, plans to lop &dollar;1.5 billion a year from its annual operating costs, twice the amount it announced in December. 
 The move will add thousands more redundancies to the 8,000 already announced. 
 A future merger is not ruled out &mdash; but will not be explored just yet. 
 Two of America's biggest banks, Security Pacific and Wells Fargo, admitted that they discussed a possible merger last year, a move that would have produced the second-largest bank in America. 
 They insist that all talks are now off. 
 Salomon Brothers, a big investment bank, was fined &dollar;1.3m by the New York Stock Exchange. 
 An employee cooked its program-trading books to defraud six clients in 1987. 
 America's Congressional Budget Office called on the Federal Reserve to cut interest rates. 
 Gearing up 
 France's state-controlled car maker, Renault, got a capital boost of FFr10 billion (&dollar;2 billion) from the government and from Volvo, a Swedish car maker with a 20% stake. 
 The European Commission, which last year made Renault start repaying FFr6 billion of state aid, did not object. 
 The European Commission did object to aspects of a proposed link between Fiat, Italy's big car maker, and Alcatel-Alsthom, a French electronics giant. 
 The alliance could be anti-competitive, the commission said. 
 Meanwhile the Fiat group announced a drop in operating profits of more than half, to 2.1 trillion lire (&dollar;1.7 billion). 
 A range of ozone-friendly coolants for air conditioners and refrigerators, designed to replace CFCs, was unveiled by the Delaware-based Du Pont chemical company. 
 The range will compete with one already produced by ICI, but General Motors wants Du Pont to supply a coolant for its 1994 cars. 
 Business as usual 
 Britain's monopolies commission decided that a state-owned Finnish company, Kemira, should not be allowed to buy ICI's fertiliser business. 
 It would have reduced the number of manufacturers in Britain from three to two. 
 ICI says it may now have to close down the business. 
 A big British tobacco and insurance group, B.A.T, moved into the East European cigarette market. 
 It has set up a joint venture with Hungary's state-owned producer, which makes 40% of the country's cigarettes. 
 About &pound;20m (&dollar;39m) will be spent on modernisation and expanding production. 
 Illegal tender 
 The law lords, Britain's highest court, ruled that hundreds of swaps transactions between banks and local governments are unlawful. 
 Eighty-odd British and foreign banks stand to lose &pound;500m-600m on open swaps positions. 
 The Soviet Union &bquo;reformed&equo; its currency by simply cancelling its 50-rouble and 100-rouble banknotes (worth &dollar;2.50 and &dollar;5 apiece at the street exchange-rate). 
 The aim was to prevent hyperinflation. 
 The predictable result was chaos. 
 ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL INDICATORS 
 OUTPUT, DEMAND AND JOBS 
 Britain's industrial output fell by 2.8% in the year to November, the sharpest year-on-year fall since June 1981. 
 In the same period France's industrial production fell by 0.8%, and Sweden's by 4.2%. 
 Germany's retail sales soared by 9.2% in the 12 months to November. 
 The ranks of Britain's unemployed grew by 80,000 in December, the biggest monthly increase for ten years; the unemployment rate rose to 6.5%, its highest level since June 1989. 
 Australia's jobless rate eased to 8.1% in December, down from 8.2% in November. 
 PRICES AND WAGES 
 Britain's consumer-price inflation slowed to 9.3% in the year to December, helped by falling petrol prices. 
 In the same period Canada's inflation rate stuck at 5.0%, while Sweden's slowed to 10.9%. 
 Japanese workers received a pay rise of 5.1% in the year to November, equivalent to a real rise of 0.9%. 
 Britain's workers received an increase of 9.8%, which was wiped out by inflation. 
 Germany's wholesale prices edged up 1.5% in the year to December. 
 ECONOMIC FORECASTS 
 Our monthly round-up of economic forecasts is now based on the averages of 170 seers polled by Consensus Economics, up from 150 in the past; it also, for the first time, looks at prospects for 1992. 
 The forecasters are growing gloomier. 
 America, Canada, Britain and Sweden are all now expected to see a fall in economic output this year; America's GNP is forecast to shrink by 0.4%. 
 In 1992 the forecasters think growth will recover, rising by an average of 2.7% in the 13 countries &mdash; an optimism that may wane as this year wears on. 
 Inflation is forecast to average 5.1% in 1991, falling to 4.1% in 1992. 
 Sweden is expected to stay bottom of the league this year and next &mdash; though its growth is forecast to resume, and its inflation to fall, in 1992. 
 COMMODITY PRICE INDEX 
 World sugar prices have fallen 40% in the past nine months to under &dollar;220 a tonne for raw sugar, the lowest since May 1988. 
 The world sugar surplus is expected to climb to 1.9m tonnes in the current season, putting prices under further pressure. 
 The slowdown in the world economy and higher prices in Eastern Europe because of subsidy cuts have both squeezed demand, and the Gulf crisis accounts for a loss of some 350,000 tonnes of sales to Iraq and Kuwait over the past six months. 
 Sugar production is likely to be a record 110m tonnes in 1990&ndash;91. 
 Brazil expects to export over 1m tonnes, twice its estimate a few months ago. 
 India's output also looks set to top last year's record.  
 TARNISHED GOLD 
 The price of gold plunged 7% in a single day immediately after the Gulf war broke out &mdash; evidently on hopes that the war would be brief. 
 This took the price back to where it was before Iraqi tanks rolled into Kuwait last August. 
 Gold seems to have lost its old role as a safe haven. 
 In December 1979 and January 1980, by contrast, when the Soviet Union invaded Afghanistan, the gold price leapt from &dollar;470 per ounce to &dollar;850 within a month. 
 Investors who bought at the peak have lost heavily; today the price is only around &dollar;380. 
 Central banks are the biggest holders of gold. 
 World official gold reserves are worth about &dollar;350 billion at today's prices. 
 The biggest official gold hoarder by far is America, which holds 27.9% of the world's central-bank gold reserves. 
 Germany is in second place with 10.1% of the total. 
 Japan, surprisingly, has only 2.6% of the pot. 
 TRADE, EXCHANGE RATES AND RESERVES 
 America's visible-trade deficit narrowed to &dollar;9.7 billion in November, down from a revised &dollar;11.0 billion the previous month. 
 Canada's trade surplus widened to &dollar;1.1 billion in November, while Sweden's fell to &dollar;249m in December. 
 In trade-weighted terms the yen gained 1.4% on the week and the D-mark 0.5%. 
 Sterling was unchanged, while the dollar was down by 2.1%. 
 WORLD BOURSES 
 Most stockmarkets rebounded after the start of war in the Gulf. 
 Stockholm enjoyed the second-biggest one-day rise ever, which left it 7.3% up on the week. 
 New York gained 4.5%, and Paris 4.4%. 
 Tokyo finished the week almost unchanged. 
 MONEY AND INTEREST RATES 
 In the year to December Japan's broad-money growth slowed to 8.6%; in the same period Britain's narrow-money growth slowed to 2.7%. 
 Canadian banks lowered their prime rates by half a point to 12.25%; America's federal-funds rate eased to 6.25%. 
 LEADERS 
 Uneducated English 
 Why A levels must go 
 WHAT should Britain do about an examination attacked by the country's employers' organisation, by the heads of four-fifths of its secondary schools, by its university vice-chancellors and even by the Prince of Wales? 
 Probable sad answer: cling to it as part of Britain's eccentric genius. 
 This will be the way with the Advanced, or &bquo;A&equo; level, exam taken by a brainy minority of English 18-year-olds (the Scots have more rational arrangements). 
 Having resisted repeated attempts to kill it off, the A level looks set to survive the latest upheavals in British education almost unchanged. 
 The losers will be another generation of English schoolchildren. 
 To those who have watched the curious competition between Britain's prime minister and its leader of the opposition to talk down their achievements at school, the durability of the A level is not surprising. 
 The English think that sixth-form education is only for swots. 
 Most British youngsters feel it is a waste of time, and only 35% of 17-year-olds are still in full-time study. 
 Given that over 20% of A-level papers are failed, that is reasonable: why gamble two years of lost earnings on studies that may leave you with no certificate at all? 
 Knowledge on the cheap 
 The disadvantages of A levels are obvious. 
 Bright 16-year-olds abandon all but two or three academic subjects, thus ensuring that scientists remain unread, and arts students maths-blind. 
 Those who do not take A levels in foreign languages or in science drop those subjects after &mdash; at most &mdash; five years of study. 
 One deplorable result of this early specialisation is that university science and engineering departments choose their students from the minority of sixth formers who knew at 16 that they wanted to continue with maths and science. 
 All who were undecided are ruled out. 
 So why does this intellectual self-mutilation continue? 
 It suits some powerful people that A levels should survive. 
 The exam has economic advantages that endear it to Whitehall's purse-keepers. 
 Those high failure rates make it an efficient way of screening out teenagers who might later fail a university course. 
 The exam educates youngsters cheaply up to a level that is not reached in other countries until someone has been at university for a year. 
 Not only does teaching a teenager at school cost less than half as much as at university. 
 A levels reduce the length of most English university courses to three years. 
 Scotland, which has a broader exam taken after only one year in the sixth form, keeps a higher proportion of 16-year-olds on at school &mdash; and its university courses normally last four years. 
 The exam also has its academic defenders. 
 Lecturers, especially scientists, find it easier to teach students who have already specialised in their chosen subjects for two years. 
 And England's private schools, whose pupils account for a quarter of sixth-formers and of A-level passes, know that parents will pay for the prospect of a smooth path to university. 
 In fact, students who have taken a subject at A level do not, by the end of their courses, do better than those who have kept off it &mdash; as a recent study of economics graduates showed. 
 Many science and engineering departments already struggle to find enough students with good A levels. 
 Some run efficient remedial courses, which could surely be used for youngsters who had taken a broader sixth-form course. 
 How would such a broader system work? 
 Some want a revolution as thorough as the one that has changed the exams taken by British 16-year-olds. 
 They cite Germany's Abitur, where school-leavers are graded in eight subjects, and where their grading wins them entry into an apprenticeship if they do not go to university. 
 That might encourage more young Britons to stay on at school in their quest for a good job. 
 A more modest first step would be to scrap A levels and insist that university entrance should require five or six AS levels &mdash; a conventional exam with a smaller syllabus than A levels &mdash; topped up with a specialist paper in one chosen subject. 
 That might not greatly increase the number of youngsters who stayed on at school. 
 But it would at least ensure that Britain had a more broadly-educated elite &mdash; and more broadly-educated political leaders.  
 America's timid trustbusters 
 Restricting competition is not the way to make industry more competitive 
 A BRIGHT-EYED young lawyer comes to Washington from Yale, Harvard or Columbia. 
 He is hired as a federal trustbuster by the Justice Department or the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) and is out to make a name for himself. 
 How does he do it? 
 Not any longer by taking on really big businesses involved in anti-competitive mergers or practices. 
 Actions against the biggest American firms are rare &mdash; so rare as to make the FTC's current investigation of the business practices of Microsoft in computer software a real surprise. 
 Nowadays the government's lawyers appear more interested in the publicity a case will win them than anything else. 
 Nintendo, a household name, is accused of fixing the prices of its home-video games. 
 It is big &mdash; but it also happens to be Japanese, and so presents a juicy target. 
 A college football association is charged with conspiring to limit the number of college games that football fans can see on television. 
 Kreepy Krauly USA Inc is alleged to set retail prices for its swimming-pool cleaning devices. 
 Such cases are not trivial. 
 They are nonetheless a big comedown from the 1960s, when federal trustbusters took on giants the size of AT&amp;T and IBM and broke up a merger of Procter &amp; Gamble and Clorox. 
 They also sit oddly with the vow of federal trustbusters to put an end to the years of neglect when President Reagan virtually suspended the nation's antitrust laws by cheerfully failing to enforce them. 
 And they sit uncomfortably next to the strident calls for antitrust laws and enforcement to be relaxed in order to help American firms take on Japanese and European rivals. 
 When they are accused of timidity, trustbusters bristle. 
 Antitrust policy in America, they say, is still stricter than in Europe and far stricter than in Japan. 
 American companies can and do bring private antitrust suits &mdash; a remedy denied to British companies. 
 Anyway, the American business scene has changed vastly since the main antitrust statutes were written: the Sherman act of 1890 and the Clayton act of 1914. 
 It is true that America's economy is more open today, exposing many big firms to foreign competition. 
 This does not make it impossible for a domestic market to be dominated and then abused, but it is far less likely to happen. 
 If General Motors, Ford and Chrysler were foolish enough to conspire to fix prices, they would quickly lose market share to Toyota, Volkswagen and Hyundai, at home as well as abroad. 
 The lack of balance 
 The trouble begins with the consequent changes in antitrust laws and policy. 
 Under the guise of making American industry more internationally competitive, Congress has become ever laxer in its attitude to collusion. 
 The Sherman act was amended in 1982 to exclude trade or commerce with foreign nations. 
 The National Co-operative Research Act of 1984 permits companies to do joint research without running the risk of treble damages from civil antitrust suits. 
 The courts have shown a similar bias, though usually for a different reason. 
 Most of the federal judges appointed by President Reagan are so convinced the market has its own fail-safe mechanisms for everything that it is hard to imagine them upholding a challenge to any merger. 
 This is to miss the point. 
 America is changing, and some laws and policies will have to become sterner to reflect the changes. 
 Grants of immunities to whole industries against antitrust laws no longer make any sense. 
 For example, consumers have long railed against the way insurance companies are permitted to fix prices, allocate territories and to tie the provision of one service to the purchase of another. 
 Even big insurers like Hartford and Cigna admit that these practices give the industry a bad name. 
 Now that much of American industry is exposed to international competition, barriers against foreigners in the transport business also look odd. 
 Yet foreign ships are still not permitted to ply American ports, and most foreign airlines are forbidden to compete with American airlines on domestic routes. 
 Formal and informal discrimination against foreigners in public-procurement contracts by American state and local governments serves only to fleece taxpayers. 
 Scores of other nonsenses would come to light if the Bush administration demanded a thorough overhaul of the country's anti-competitive laws and practices. 
 The principles are clear: competitiveness starts with stiff competition and low barriers to entry. 
 Thus armed, any young lawyer could serve the public good, not just his own.  
 World body seeks head 
 A more effective United Nations needs a new sort of leader to run it 
 THE secretary-general of the United Nations, Javier Perez de Cuellar, is a skilled and decent man. 
 But the limits of his approach to the job have become painfully apparent. 
 He was late joining the effort to talk Saddam Hussein out of Kuwait. 
 In the frightful aftermath of the war, he dithered about UN protection for fleeing Kurds and presided over the horrendous first muddle in UN relief work. 
 His term ends on December 31st and he does not want another one. 
 The Perez approach &mdash; backstage diplomacy when the big powers permit &mdash; did not start with him. 
 Previous UN bosses have had to tip-toe round the twin dangers of Soviet veto and American mistrust. 
 Within the limits set for him, Mr Perez de Cuellar did well. 
 As the freeze between America and the Soviet Union thawed, he helped ease or end a string of bloody little wars between their third-world friends. 
 That now must seem a distant, simpler time compared with the messy, open-ended tasks facing today's UN. 
 Nowadays it can more or less count on getting asked routinely to sanction, shape or run a new form of global riot-control that none of the big powers, not even America, is ready to do alone. 
 Iraq is a grim model of what kind of thing the next secretary-general should expect to have thrown at him. 
 The UN is being asked to police Iraq's border with Kuwait; to decide how much oil Iraq sells abroad and what it can buy in return; to make sure Iraq destroys any nuclear- or chemical-weapons plants; and to get ready to protect Kurdish enclaves when American, British and French soldiers leave. 
 Nor do the new orders pouring almost daily into the UN's kitchen end with Iraq. 
 Britain's prime minister, John Major, this week suggested that the UN should limit the world traffic in arms. 
 Many Russians vaguely hope the UN will help to make their dangerous nuclear-power plants safe. 
 To cope with even part of this (and to send back the more far-fetched requests), the UN needs a master chef, not a harassed waiter. 
 A new secretary-general must be in place by the end of the year. 
 The rulebook says the General Assembly elects him. 
 In reality, the choice is up to the five countries with permanent seats on the Security Council &mdash; America, Britain, China, France and the Soviet Union. 
 Usually they do this in a last-minute scramble, giving the new chief no time to prepare. 
 That method produced Kurt Waldheim, who forgot to put wartime service in the German army on his curriculum vitae. 
 This time the five have agreed to start looking now, and to have a candidate by October. 
 A last-minute appointment is not the only trap. 
 African delegates are arguing that, as past heads of the UN have come from Asia, Europe and Latin America, it is Africa's turn. 
 The idea of turns is wrong. 
 The secretary-general does not represent a continent. 
 There are indeed good candidates from Africa, but none has a continental right to the inside track. 
 The new secretary-general must also be firm enough to reform two dozen UN agencies. 
 Many are in a vicious circle of mismanagement and underfunding, as governments, fed up with incompetence, squeeze their cash. 
 The once effective High Commission for Refugees is a sad example. 
 Go for some class 
 Edward Shevardnadze, who resigned as Soviet foreign minister last December, might have been the right sort of UN leader. 
 He is a democrat with the skill, nerve and ingenuity to push the limits of the possible. 
 Choosing him would soften the third-world grumble that the UN was becoming an American puppet. 
 Mr Shevardnadze with an American as his deputy would make a formidable team. 
 Alas, Mr Shevardnadze speaks almost no English or French and may not want the job. 
 All the same, he is the sort of man that is needed. 
 Recommending a strong secretary-general can sound like touting safe airlines or honest stockbrokers. 
 Nobody wants the other sort. 
 Yet the big powers have tended to pick high-grade but unadventurous diplomats who give them a quiet life. 
 That suited them when there was little that they could agree the UN should do. 
 Now that they are giving it some serious work, they need a leader who can talk confidently to them and who can behave with authority on the world's television screens. 
 That sort of secretary-general may at times disagree with one or both of them. 
 But, in policing the world, the big powers, above all America, ought to want someone who will stand firm in tough times: a partner, not a patsy.  
 Prize fighter 
 America should spend more on improving the technology of its weapons, and less on actually making them 
 MILITARY technology advances by fits and starts. 
 One of its most notable starts took place this week, when the Americans selected the sleek and curvy YF-22 to be their next-generation air-combat fighter. 
 This remarkable aircraft, when it joins the air force in about ten years, will render all other fighters obsolete at a stroke. 
 It will be quiet, manoeuvrable, virtually invisible to radar and capable of supersonic flight without the use of afterburners. 
 Does America really need to leap a whole generation ahead in fighter technology, to build an aeroplane that can beat undreamed-of Russian fighters of the undreamed-of Russia of the next century? 
 The YF-22 was conceived in the days of the cold war, and many of its exotic features were developed to defeat predicted Soviet advances that may or may not now materialise. 
 The Gulf war showed up a big American lead over Soviet weaponry. 
 It laid to rest the charges of unreliability and less-than-advertised performance that have long dogged the Pentagon. 
 That technological lead was maintained &mdash; widened &mdash; for 40 years by diverting money and engineering talent into war machines and away from Walkmen. 
 Its results are weapons already far better than needed to defeat second-rate enemies, which may be the only ones to worry about once the Soviet Union has imploded. 
 So, goes an alluring argument, America can rest on its military laurels. 
 The thesis assumes that all enemies other than the Soviet Union will have second-rate weapons. 
 This is just not true. 
 Many American, Russian, British and French high-technology weapons will fall into other countries' hands. 
 The Brazils and the Chinas will gradually develop the capacity to build (and sell) potent weapons of their own. 
 One day America may find itself facing the last generation of its own weapons, which it had sold to its enemy in friendlier times. 
 If it had stopped innovating, the match would then be equal. 
 In electronics, the leading edge is being advanced by civil research, not military, and the products of this research are thus widely available on the open market. 
 Unexpected breakthroughs in unexpected lands will decide future wars, as arquebuses decided Pavia and Maxim guns Omdurman. 
 So though it is hard to imagine the stealthy fighter-bombers, map-reading cruise missiles and pinpoint bombs that won the Gulf war being beaten by Brazilian, Chinese or Russian weapons for decades, there is a good argument for what will now in effect be an arms race by America against itself. 
 It was, moreover, shown over Baghdad that dropping one clever bomb can cost less, kill fewer civilians and risk fewer airmen's lives than the indiscriminate use of cheap, dumb ones. 
 By these criteria, some high-tech weapons are cost-effective to develop, even if enemy weapons stagnate. 
 Research but do not build 
 The question is not whether to develop ever-better weapons, but how much to spend on doing it. 
 The Bush administration has proposed cutting the proportion of GNP spent on defence from 6.4% in 1985 to 3.6% in 1996. 
 If the threat of (big) wars is small, it will make sense to spend more of that money researching and developing weapons and less on putting them into full-scale production &mdash; or on training and feeding expensive troops. 
 For certain technologies, notably strategic defence against nuclear weapons, researching makes more sense than deploying a half-baked system. 
 Only 15% of America's defence budget goes on research and development. 
 Suppose that instead of paying Lockheed, Boeing and General Dynamics &dollar;65 billion to build 648 of the new fighters, and thus partly freezing the technology for 20 years, the Pentagon asked for just 72 operational aircraft, plus spares and trainers, and then kept the production line ticking over. 
 That would be more expensive per aircraft, certainly, but it would recognise two realities. 
 The F-15 is capable of dealing with all foreseeable large threats for some time; and if a new Russian regime started to develop a better fighter, America would still be able to beat it into large-scale production of an improved version of the YF-22. 
 Perhaps the best MIGs can already challenge the F-15; perhaps the best radars can detect it, which is why only stealth fighters bombed well-guarded Baghdad. 
 But, in the days of computer simulations, it surely makes little sense to crank the whole military-industrial complex up to producing a great fleet of YF-22s. 
 Stay ahead by deploying modest quantities of state-of-the-art aircraft, to dogfight over Arizona.  
 Lenin's curse 
 THE news from the Soviet Union has been bad, is now awful, and will get worse. 
 That depressing truth is, alas, one that Mikhail Gorbachev still refuses to accept, as he stumbles around in a trap set by Lenin two-thirds of a century ago. 
 The most obvious cause for alarm is the Soviet economy. 
 It has been in accelerating decline for more than a decade, but the crunch is fast approaching. 
 On figures that are probably far too kind, real GNP was a staggering 8% lower in the first three months of this year than in the same period last year; investment is dropping fast; foreign trade has shrunk by a third. 
 The miners' strikes that have paralysed about one-third of Soviet pits are slowly breaking backbone industries, such as steel, gas and chemicals. 
 Oil production, the chief earner of money to pay for grain and other imports, is falling sharply. 
 And this week the IMF made public what everyone has been saying in private: that there can be little foreign help on offer until the Soviet Union reforms its &bquo;rotten&equo; economy. 
 If the economy's future looks bleak, Mikhail Gorbachev's future looks no better. 
 Despite the piece of paper he was waving this week, committing nine of the 15 republics to keep on talking about the preservation of the union, he has lost the confidence of much of the Communist Party he leads and of the parliament that elected him president. 
 The Soviet people who once cheered him on now jeer at him. 
 He governs, so far as he is able to, on borrowed time because none of the groups contending for power yet feels strong enough to make a grab for it. 
 The good news is that this gives Mr Gorbachev one last chance to pull away from disaster. 
 It would mean taking up an idea first mooted last year, but abandoned as too risky: a full coalition between more cautious reformers like himself and the radicals led by Boris Yeltsin. 
 A deal would need two big concessions from Mr Gorbachev that he balked at last year. 
 First, those (mainly Baltic) republics that want their full freedom would have to be allowed to negotiate their way out fairly. 
 Mr Gorbachev began this week to inch in that direction. 
 Then most powers over the economy would have to be devolved from the centre to the republics that chose to remain. 
 Unless Mr Gorbachev, or whoever succeeds him, proposes to rule from a tank turret, both these points will eventually have to be conceded anyway. 
 Attempts to intimidate the Baltic republics have only stiffened their resolve. 
 The row between the republics and the centre has driven the economy ever more steeply into decline: foreign investors have been frightened off, republics have thrown up trade barriers against each other, and tax revenues owed to the centre are not being paid. 
 A coalition is now the only way to bring a truce in this damaging &bquo;war of laws&equo;. 
 But if disaster is to be averted, time bought needs to be put to good economic use. 
 Last year Mr Gorbachev rejected a package of radical economic reforms in favour of quarter-measures, fearful that the centre would have to forfeit too much power and that social costs &mdash; higher prices, steeply rising unemployment &mdash; would be too great. 
 Since then his authority has ebbed alarmingly anyway. 
 His quarter-measures have brought higher prices, and also provoked massive strikes, but without any prospect of stabilising the economy. 
 The threat of hyperinflation is now all too real. 
 There is still a way out of this economic mess, if Mr Gorbachev can summon up the courage to take it. 
 It would mean reversing himself on three points: price reform, budget discipline and privatisation of land and property. 
 A government promise to liberalise prices next year is so far just that: a promise. 
 Letting markets, rather than bureaucrats, set prices is the only way factories will get both the signals they need about what people really want to buy and the incentive to economise on costs. 
 But the signals will get through only if there is budget discipline: if, in other words, the still massive indirect subsidies to factories &mdash; tax exemptions, soft credits, loans &mdash; are cut at the same time. 
 These muffle market signals and keep too many loss-making factories in business. 
 Sale of the century 
 The third big feat required of a reforming new government would be to force open the market to competition. 
 That means breaking up and selling off the state-owned monopolies. 
 It is an enormous task. 
 Category by category, more than a third of Soviet goods measured by value (from sewing machines and locomotive cranes to coking equipment) are produced in a single factory. 
 Prices fixed by private monopolies such as these would be no truer a reflection of the market than those fixed by the state. 
 Competition must therefore come from freer imports, too. 
 And hand-in-hand with the sale of factories should go not only the sale of shops and workshops to people who have goods to sell and services to offer, but also the sale of land and housing &mdash; both anathema to many in the land of Lenin &mdash; to soak up roubles and give people a personal stake in reform. 
 All this is what, slowly and still painfully, is happening in Eastern Europe. 
 Yes, Mr Gorbachev would say, but look at the capitalist misery it causes in places like Poland and eastern Germany. 
 That misses the point. 
 Times may be hard in those places, but note how few people are clamouring for a return to the let's-stay-poor-together socialism of the past. 
 What is more, painful remedies have been most readily accepted from those governments unburdened by past mistakes and old dogmas. 
 Hence the need for a coalition government in Moscow that would have the credibility which Mr Gorbachev's jaded administration now lacks. 
 But would &mdash; indeed could &mdash; Mr Gorbachev go for it? 
 It may be that by now his authority is too weak to hold up his end of a coalition bargain. 
 It may be that the gap between Mr Yeltsin's policies and Mr Gorbachev's is too great. 
 Mr Gorbachev still thinks the old system can be reformed. 
 Mr Yeltsin does not. 
 Mr Yeltsin's followers accept the need for a pluralistic, market economy. 
 Mr Gorbachev talks of the market, yet insists on preserving &bquo;our socialist choice&equo;. 
 That is the nub of what really bothers Mr Gorbachev. 
 Proud of what his country could be, he set out six years ago with the aim of building a modern, more pluralist but still communist Soviet Union. 
 Yet if he has watched Eastern Europe closely he will have seen that, however the transition begins, be it by round table, coalition government or free election, once Communists give up part of their power they quickly end up losing it all. 
 Similarly, once state socialism is abandoned, there is no third way around the market that does not lead straight to economic disaster. 
 Mr Gorbachev's dilemma is not new. 
 Through more than 70 years of Soviet history, Leninist logic encouraged the belief that somehow the Soviet Union, however badly run, could ignore the laws of economic gravity. 
 It cannot. 
 With the ground rushing up to meet him, Mr Gorbachev must decide between the revolution he grew up believing in and the welfare of the people in whose name that revolution was made.  
 Put pay to the vote 
 Blushes and risk are the ways to deal with directors' pay 
 THERE is nothing more tempting than a rich, powerful scapegoat. 
 That is why Britain's Institute of Directors has this week been rudely attacking the government for allowing the business renaissance of the past decade to be &bquo;torpedoed by runaway inflation&equo;. 
 Yet those who sail in fragile craft should hesitate before launching their own torpedoes. 
 The directors themselves offer a rich and powerful target to an audience that should matter more to them than politicians: their own workers. 
 On both sides of the Atlantic, boardroom pay has raced ahead, offering an inflationary example to workers being lectured about the need for restraint. 
 A recent survey by the British Institute of Management showed that directors of larger companies had an average pay rise of 22.7% in 1990. 
 This week shareholders in Tesco, the supermarket chain, learnt that their chairman had a juicy special offer last year: a rise of 328% in his income, to &pound;1.48m (&dollar;2.6m). 
 Recently Chrysler shareholders studying the American car firm's losses were distracted by Lee Iacocca's pay for 1990: &dollar;4.6m. 
 Can this be justified? 
 In one way it can, for directors' pay-slips can be misleading now that many are rewarded with bonuses connected to their firm's performance. 
 Pay in 1990 will reflect the firm's profits in 1989, rather than its current losses. 
 Yet the bosses' bonanza has continued, albeit at a reduced rate, into the recession. 
 A survey by Hay Management Consultants estimates that boardroom pay in Britain was still rising at an annual rate of 10&ndash;14% in the last six months of 1990, although profits had long been tumbling. 
 Directors reply that their pay needs to reflect global norms. 
 It is true that the market for top managers is more international than that for bus-drivers; some of Britain's best companies are run by Americans (Glaxo's Ernest Mario, for example) and some of America's best have Britons at the top (J.P. 
 Morgan's Sir Dennis Weatherstone). 
 But it is only a tiny minority that is likely to move. 
 This explains some of the headline-grabbing individual pay, but not the rising averages. 
 Another argument for fatter bonuses is that pay tied to performance encourages managers to act in shareholders' interests. 
 And since high fliers can also start their own firms or do a management buy-out, boardroom pay has to offer some of the rewards of entrepreneurship. 
 But it has failed to match the risks. 
 For too few directors does pay fall by as much when performance sags as it rises in good times. 
 And the reward for dismissal is a golden handshake of several years' pay. 
 When an ordinary worker fails, he is sacked. 
 The embarrassment of riches 
 Contracts should be changed to introduce more risk, even if some directors then have to be paid more. 
 But it is not the level of pay that is the real problem. 
 It is how it is determined. 
 In most companies, top people's pay is set by a group of non-executive directors. 
 A report from Britain's Institutional Shareholders' Committee this month argues that this should be extended. 
 It confirms that directors should have no say in their &bquo;compensation package&equo;, but adds that all the details, including how bonuses and share options are set, should be in the annual report. 
 This would be useful, but it does not go far enough. 
 Non-executive directors are not wholly independent. 
 They are usually recruited by the other directors; and most are executives in other firms, so they benefit from generous benchmarks for the &bquo;market price&equo; of directors. 
 The missing link is the shareholders. 
 At the annual general meeting (AGM) they vote on the annual report and on the appointment of all directors. 
 The law should be amended to say that a separate resolution to approve directors' pay must be passed by every company's AGM. 
 Few meetings would dare to vote down a pay rise, but the threat of such a vote &mdash; and the awkward, embarrassing questions that might accompany it &mdash; would be a valuable restraint.  
 Airbus's German cousin 
 Germany's newly regrouped aerospace industry wants to give birth to a new jet aircraft. 
 Guess who will pay? 
 A FUNNY thing happened to an Airbus wing on its way to the European consortium's assembly line in southern France. 
 The wing left Britain adorned with a giant sticker that said &bquo;First Airbus A340 wing from British Aerospace, Chester.&equo; 
 It arrived with a new sticker: &bquo;Erster Airbus A340 fl&uuml;gel von Deutsche Airbus, Bremen.&equo; 
 The wing had stopped off in Germany merely for some flaps to be fitted. 
 Germany's aerospace industry is ambitious. 
 As well as doodling plans for supersonic jets, it wants to build a new family of airliners. 
 The dispute between America and the European Community over subsidies for Airbus is already bitter enough. 
 If Germany goes ahead, it will grow even nastier. 
 Germany cannot afford to build a new airliner on its own, any more than Britain or France can. 
 That is why the three countries, along with Spain, got together 20 years ago to pool resources in the Airbus consortium and buy their way into a business dominated by Americans. 
 Airbus has captured 30% of the world market with an impressive family of airliners. 
 Last year the consortium made its first &bquo;operating profit&equo;. 
 With a record order book, it now has a slim chance of starting to repay a bit of the &dollar;13.5 billion that it has received in government subsidies. 
 Some of those subsidies went into persuading Daimler-Benz to take over most of Germany's aerospace industry (see page 87), by guaranteeing it against some future losses risked in making Airbuses. 
 But Daimler's aerospace subsidiaries, now called Deutsche Aerospace (DASA), want to take a 50% stake in another European aircraft-making consortium. 
 France's Aerospatiale and Italy's Alenia, both state-owned aerospace groups, each plan to take 25%. 
 This consortium will jointly sell propeller-driven aeroplanes which the companies already make. 
 But it also wants to build a family of jets with 80&ndash;130 seats. 
 The first will cost &dollar;2.5 billion to develop. 
 As sure as Concorde's nose is pointed, the partners' governments will have to subsidise this by coughing up so-called &bquo;launch aid&equo;. 
 Taxpayers at angels five 
 DASA thinks there is a gap in the market for small jets. 
 There may well be; but the rush for it is already on. 
 Both Boeing and McDonnell Douglas are making shorter versions of their small jets, and Holland's Fokker wants to make a bigger version of its 100-seater. 
 Even Airbus plans to shrink its 150-seat A320, but could be forbidden to do so by DASA and Aerospatiale, which between them control 75% of Airbus. 
 Making a bigger or smaller version of an existing aircraft would cost less (about &dollar;400m, reckons Airbus), but the new consortium says an all-new jet would be more efficient and so more attractive to airlines. 
 If so, it would make more sense and cost less in subsidy to build that new winner within Airbus. 
 Italy can always become a partner for this project. 
 DASA reckons Airbus is best suited to building large airliners, not small ones. 
 How then does Boeing manage to make aircraft of all shapes and sizes? 
 DASA's motives smack of industrial machismo and a desire to see its name on the nose of a jet. 
 It already supplies Fokker with fuselages for Fokker's small jet and could make that product its own by buying the Dutch company for less than &dollar;1 billion. 
 But, as Eric Jan Nederkoorn, Fokker's chairman-elect, observes, government money is not forthcoming to buy foreign companies, only to create German jobs. 
 The second point is that subsidised competition will mean more subsidy for Airbus &mdash; competition in subsidy. 
 DASA's challenge to Airbus's smaller aircraft threatens to drag Airbus back out of profit. 
 Airbus will anyway soon be passing the hat around again for an enormous 700-seat aeroplane, much bigger than the Boeing 747. 
 With runways congested, a jumbo-jumbo might make more sense than a small jet. 
 But why should taxpayers finance it? 
 America's trade  negotiators  are losing patience. 
 They have already complained to GATT about Daimler's takeover subsidies and want state aid to be limited in future. 
 As he has done for years, Jean Pierson, Airbus's boss, replies that Boeing and McDonnell Douglas get billions of dollars of &bquo;indirect&equo; support from defence programmes and NASA contracts. 
 It is a row that may never be fully resolved. 
 But the whole affair of Airbus and its new cousin lies in the deepest shadow that menaces Europe's single-market project: the old-world urge to subsidise, to protect jobs and to create national champions remains depressingly intact. 
 LETTERS 
 Kurds in limbo 
 The emetic smugness of your comments on the Kurds (&bquo;Want another war?&equo;, 
 April 13th) is, I suppose, typical of the modish caricature of realpolitik now being applied to the Middle East. 
 The West's involvement in Iraq gave it responsibility for dealing actively with the situation there, despite the mealy-mouthed excuses for allowing Saddam Hussein to survive. 
 Our leaders funked that responsibility, and the Kurds and Shiites are paying for it. 
 Your implicit comparison of the ordeal of the Kurds with the Palestinians in Gaza is despicable. 
 The Kurds have been and are being massacred, and are dying of neglect &mdash; our neglect &mdash; by the tens of thousands because they tried to escape that massacre, which we did nothing to prevent. 
 Where is the parallel with Gaza in that? 
 Most grotesque of all is your complacent opening about &bquo;the tyrant suitably deflated&equo;. 
 Suitably? 
 Saddam Hussein is still tyrant of Iraq, butchering human beings as usual. 
 What, pray, is suitable about that? 
 &bquo;Conveniently&equo; would be a better word, and would refer, correctly, to the ugly cowardice that has led to this bloody mess. 
 The Economist, of all newspapers, ought to have the nerve, and the decency, to give it its proper name. 
 Instead, you follow the West's leaders in evoking an intellectually insulting parody of raisons d'&eacute;tat. 
 One understands, even expects, that from politicians. 
 But you?  
 Manchester HERB GREER 
 The Americans should not intervene militarily to help the Kurds. 
 When George Bush called for Saddam to be deposed, it was clear that: he did not want the Kurds to do it (that would displease Turkey, Syria, Iran and Russia, and therefore, everybody else); he did not want the Shiites to do it (that would please Iran and so displease everybody else); and he was not sure if he wanted the Sunnis to do it (because that might make the Kurds and the Shiites do it, too). 
 No, what was really wanted was a coup by a more acceptable Baathist general who would keep Iraq in shape without strutting around alarming everyone. 
 No doubt the now dispossessed Kurds and the Shiites have been surprised to learn that they did something they should not have done in the interests of geopolitical reality. 
 But, really, if they didn't understand what was meant by &bquo;depose&equo;, they deserve all the trouble they got.  
 Melbourne C. O'MEARA 
 A case to be heard 
 If memory serves, Adam Smith once proposed that the independence of the Scottish judiciary might be guaranteed by setting aside a tract of the Highlands for their exclusive use. 
 The fruits of this estate would have provided the judges' stipends, insulating the judges from all risk that a government might reduce their pay if they offended it. 
 This, surely, is the answer to the problem of how to pay central bankers (April 20th). 
 There must be oodles of territory in Saxony and Thuringia that used to be owned by the East German government. 
 Should not Germany now make a grant of this land to the nascent Eurofed? 
 Apart from guaranteeing the independence of central bankers, the scheme would also usefully encourage them in those habits of prudence and careful husbandry which are so necessary to their calling.  
 Chevy Chase, Maryland BARCLAY ST DUNSTAN 
 Debt and democracy 
 You miss the point in your leader (April 13th) when you argue that the recent deal to cut Poland's official debt by half should be the exception rather than the rule. 
 Your comparison is to Latin America, when the most direct precedent is for the debtors of sub-Saharan Africa. 
 They, like Poland, are indebted mostly to governments. 
 Many African debtors are also struggling to implement economic-reform programmes. 
 And, while not denying the severity of Poland's problems, the scale of economic hardship and poverty facing Africa makes them stand out as candidates for debt relief. 
 Yet the amount of African debt relief &mdash; through the Group of Seven's 1988 Toronto agreement &mdash; has been pitiful (saving debtors only &dollar;100m a year in cash flow, according to the World Bank). 
 Current proposals for further action have yet to be implemented, including that made by John Major (as chancellor of the exchequer) at last September's Commonwealth meeting of finance ministers. 
 Does the famine now threatening 29m Africans have to dominate our television screens before African debt carries the same political weight?  
 London BEN JACKSON 
 You mention in your commentary on African democracy (March 2nd) that Botswana is the only democratic former British colony in Africa. 
 You overlook the Gambia and Mauritius. 
 Although the Gambian People's Progressive Party has dominated the scene since independence, the country has maintained a multiparty system since the 1960s. 
 Freedom House has listed the Gambia in the &bquo;free&equo; category of our annual survey since the break-up of the confederation with Senegal in 1989. 
 Mauritius, a former colony of both Britain and France, has had periods of emergency rule, but qualifies today as a multiparty, parliamentary democracy.  
 New York JOSEPH RYAN GEORGE ZARYCKY Freedom House 
 The borders of inanity 
 You suggest keeping an eye on Switzerland, New Zealand and Canada as potential enemies (March 16th). 
 Too late! 
 A few years ago, the Reaganites surveyed New Zealand's record: democratic since its foundation; relatively civilised in its treatment of indigenous people; no civil wars; no attacks on neighbours; support in both world wars, Korea and Vietnam. 
 All of this paled when compared with the crime of taking a position on ship-borne nuclear weapons, which displeased the administration. 
 New Zealand was declared unfit to be an American ally and share in defence intelligence. 
 Next time you come up with a hypothetical outer limit of inanity, better check with Washington before publishing; it may already be in effect.  
 New York BRIAN JONES 
 BOOKS AND ARTS 
 Arms and the man 
 LOVE of great cities and vainglorious public monuments comes naturally to despots, and Saddam Hussein is no exception. 
 Since the Baath Party came to power in 1968, it has filled the burgeoning city of Baghdad with new roads, monuments, redevelopment zones and 45 new shopping centres. 
 The boom went on through, and despite, the eight-year war with Iran, and that war then produced its own characteristic public monuments. 
 None was more famous or strange than the notorious Victory Arch; and in his latest book, THE MONUMENT*, Samir al-Khalil weaves round the arch a fascinating and thoughtful study of totalitarianism and art. 
 The arch consists of two sets of colossal forearms, each weighing 20 tons and higher than the Arc de Triomphe, which seem to burst from the ground at opposite ends of a 90-metre public space. 
 The forearms are Saddam's, reproduced exactly from life on a scale of 40:1, down to the very follicles. 
 At the base, broken nets spill out 5,000 Iranian helmets retrieved from the battlefield. 
 Each forearm extends a giant sword to form an arch 40 metres high. 
 A seven-metre flagpole at the point of intersection completes the grand design. 
 As Mr Khalil points out, the arch is both a literal image of Mr Hussein (those are his arms and no one else's), and a giant reflection of how he sees himself. 
 Above all, however, it is a testimonial to official myth. 
 Announced in 1985, more than three years before the end of the war with Iran, and publicly dedicated on August 8th 1989, the arch exists to commemorate a victory that never happened. 
 Mr Hussein appeared for the dedication on a white horse, a traditional symbol of virility and purity that is linked to Ali, the grandson of the Prophet. 
 It was Ali's martyrdom that led to the great schism in Islam between Sunni and Shia; but here the Victory Arch becomes confusing. 
 As all Iraqis know, Saddam himself is Sunni, despite his claim to descent from Ali; and the putative victory over Iran was presumably won by all Iraqis, Shia and Sunni alike. 
 Scarcely a year after the dedication, Saddam invaded predominantly Sunni Kuwait. 
 Shortly afterwards, he annulled the war with Shia Iran. 
 This leaves the meaning of the arch more ambiguous than ever. 
 That the monument is only the latest manifestation of a long and miserable tradition of big lies and big art should come as no surprise to readers of &bquo;Republic of Fear&equo;, Mr Khalil's previous study of contemporary Iraqi politics. 
 But his new book is as comprehensively knowledgeable, caustically funny and subliminally alarming about western history and culture as it is about Iraq. 
 Mr Khalil ranges over pop art and Plato, Las Vegas and Nuremberg, dictatorship and kitsch, Hannah Arendt and Arab unity. 
 Is the arch, he wonders, the equivalent of Warhol's soup can, a sort of apotheosis of accepted public reality? 
 Is it a parody of the platonic republic, where politics, art and philosophy come together? 
 And what will Iraqis come to make of it, when they eventually speak their minds?  
 Saddam Hussein 
 Still in charge SADDAM HUSSEIN: A POLITICAL BIOGRAPHY. 
 By Efraim Karsh and Inari Rautsi. 
 Brassey's; 307 pages; &pound;17.95. 
 The Free Press; &dollar;22.95 
 IF HE is really so crafty, how come he blundered into Kuwait and gave the Americans a reason to hammer him? 
 If he is a blunderer, how is he still in power? 
 Somewhere between these two questions lurks an answer to the puzzle of Saddam Hussein. 
 The authors of this excellent biography plump for the fox, not the blunderer. 
 But, as well as being shrewd, their Saddam is amoral, paranoid and utterly devoid of convictions. 
 That is both why he has survived and why he has led his country to disaster. 
 The conventional view of Mr Hussein is that his two invasions &mdash; of Iran in 1980 and Kuwait in 1990 &mdash; were vast and gratuitous mistakes. 
 Their devastating consequences, it is true, can hardly be overstated. 
 And yet Efraim Karsh and Inari Rautsi argue pretty persuasively that the first invasion was more reasonable than it seemed, and that the second was caused by the first. 
 Before he invaded Iran in 1980, Mr Hussein tried hard to get on with the Islamic zealots who had just seized power in Tehran. 
 Eager to export their revolution, they rebuffed him. 
 When they persisted in calling on Iraq's Shia majority to rise up and overthrow his Sunni-based regime, he was forced into war. 
 This was not, the authors argue, because of some grand design, but because he was anxious, with reason, about his own political survival. 
 He hoped a short campaign would teach Iran the benefits of non-interference in Iraqi affairs, but was sucked instead into an eight-year fight. 
 The sacrifices of war made Iraqis hungry for the fruits of victory. 
 Since these could not be tasted while Iraq's oil revenues were low, Mr Hussein sought to raise his revenues by stealing Kuwait's. 
 The authors argue that this too was an act of desperation, not part of a grand design; and that he construed his famous interview with the American ambassador, April Glaspie, as a &bquo;green light&equo;. 
 As soon as he realised his mistake he tried to go into reverse, but once America sent troops to Saudi Arabia the dictator was trapped: only then did he make Kuwait the 19th province and drop all talk of withdrawing. 
 On the evidence of this biography, Mr Hussein's greatest aids to survival have been his amorality and lack of ideology. 
 Hitler was driven by a political vision, albeit a perverse one. 
 Mr Hussein is driven only by paranoia and a powerful lust to survive. 
 This makes him free to wear whatever ideological clothing suits the fashion of the moment. 
 He is, variously, a militant secularist or a pious Muslim; a socialist or a free-marketeer; a proud Iraqi or a proud pan-Arabist; the scourge of the West or the pragmatist on whom the West can safely rely. 
 Right now Mr Hussein finds it convenient to pose as a conciliator prepared to grant autonomy to the Kurds he has displaced and, in relations with the rest of the world, to let bygones be bygones. 
 How wretched it would be if, because it had no other solution to the problems of Iraq, the world pretended to believe him.  
 Anthologies 
 Xanthippe and rhubarb 
 THE OXFORD BOOK OF ESSAYS. 
 Edited by John Gross. 
 Oxford University Press; 680 pages; &pound;17.95 and &dollar;30 
 &equo; HAPPY are they that go to bed with great music&equo;, wrote Sir Thomas Browne, &bquo;like Pythagoras&equo;. 
 The endearingly eclectic 17th-century doctor is represented in this book by his tour de force &bquo;On Dreams&equo; which, as well as any other, fits Dr Johnson's definition of an essay as &bquo;a loose sally of the mind&equo;. 
 Some are looser than others. 
 Trollope nearly loses control on the subject of The Plumber, a man &bquo;doubtless aware that he is odious&hellip; to be put down with the tax-gatherer as being as certain as fate and as inexorable.&equo; 
 Trollope reaches the point of wondering whether a plumber could go to heaven, before sweet reason intervenes: &bquo;we do not see why he should be debarred if cabinet ministers be allowed to enter.&equo; 
 This big book contains 140 essays by nearly as many authors. 
 Their subjects include insects (the wasp, the fly and the moth); places (Pennsylvania, Provence, La Paz); people (Bishop Creighton, Beau  Brummell , Botticelli); abstractions (Truth, Death, the Future of the Potato Crisp) and many more besides. 
 The usually-amusing, Belloc, Wilde and Betjeman, can be disappointing; others &mdash; Lamb, Forster and even Churchill &mdash; display an alarming taste for whimsy. 
 These cavils aside, most of the essays are very good indeed. 
 There is a particularly lucid and elegant celebration of the philosophy of Christianity by a neglected Victorian, J.A. 
 Froude; de Quincey's justly famous meditation On the Knocking at the Gate in &bquo;Macbeth&equo;; and a typical piece of philogyny by Robert Graves. 
 He puts the case for Xanthippe (aka Mrs Socrates), whose husband's &bquo;homosexual leanings, his absent-minded behaviour, his idleness and his love of proving everyone wrong would have endeared him to no wife of mettle.&equo; 
 There are definitions: &bquo;Anger is one of the sinews of the soul.&equo; 
 There are useful similes: a degenerate aristocrat &bquo;is like rhubarb, a contemptible shrub that springs from a noble root&equo;; and there are aphorisms galore. 
 &bquo;It is a mistake to assume that people think. 
 They wobble with the brain, and sometimes the brain does not wobble.&equo; 
 &bquo;It is always necessary to be loved but not always necessary to be admired.&equo; 
 &bquo;We can only be pessimists before breakfast.&equo; 
 Samuel Butler offers his readers a helpful hint: &bquo;to know whether you are enjoying a piece of music or not, you must see whether you find yourself looking at the advertisement of Pears soap at the end of the programme&equo;. 
 Evelyn Waugh is also free with his advice, this time on how to move in well-informed circles: &bquo;introduce quite unknown names with such an air of authority that no one dares challenge you&equo;, or ask frequent obscure linguistic questions, for instance, &bquo;Tell me, is much demotic Armenian spoken in Cairo now?&equo; 
 When Thurber offers his &bquo;Ten Rules for a Happy Marriage&equo;, he eschews, he says, such time-worn admonitions as &bquo;Don't keep a blonde in the guest room&equo;, in favour of his own, eg, &bquo;The good wife allows the mosquito to bite her when her husband is reading aloud&equo;. 
 There are many other gems. 
 Randall Jarrell is painfully funny on Bad Poets, and Joseph Addison on a trip with Sir Roger de Coverley to Vauxhall is pure delight. 
 G.K. Chesterton on the artifice of the simple life is enough to turn a Green purple, Orwell on Gandhi is subtle and sinewy and James Baldwin on being the first black man in a Swiss valley is dignified and sad. 
 Clive James should have stayed with book-reviewing: his destruction of &bquo;Princess Daisy&equo; must be the funniest thing he ever wrote, even though he admits that &bquo;to pour abuse on a book like this makes no more sense than to kick a powder-puff&equo;. 
 To return to Dr Johnson, this book perfectly illustrates his sonorous maxim: &bquo;We are all prompted by the same motives, all deceived by the same fallacies, all animated by hope, obstructed by danger, entangled by desire and seduced by pleasure&equo;. 
 It is a seductive anthology.  
 An abscess of complacency 
 THE TRUTH ABOUT CHERNOBYL. 
 By Gregori Medvedev. 
 I.B. Tauris; 252 pages; &pound;14.95. 
 Basic Books; &dollar;22.95 
 &bquo;I AM familiar with the feelings of operators at the beginning of an accident&equo;, writes Gregori Medvedev, the chief engineer at Chernobyl in the 1970s. 
 &bquo;In the first split second you experience a feeling of numbness, of complete collapse within your chest and a cold wave of fright&hellip; the needles of the automatic printer drums and the monitoring instruments are swinging in all directions.&equo; 
 At 1.24am on April 26th 1986, the 14 men in the control room of reactor number four at Chernobyl witnessed the first stirrings of what was to become the worst nuclear accident in history. 
 Mr Medvedev describes forthrightly how incompetence in the Soviet nuclear industry led to the disaster, and how a lack of foresight and a desire to evade responsibility needlessly exacerbated its consequences. 
 This courageous book, written in Russia a year after the accident and now published in English, is a thorough and passionate condemnation of the Soviet way of doing things. 
 The accident began with an experiment, to see if power could be supplied to the reactors' cooling pumps using only the momentum of the stations' own turbines. 
 If external supplies of electricity to the pumps were lost for any reason, such an operation would be essential to stop heat accumulating in the core. 
 But the experiment was poorly designed: there were no special safety measures, and the reactor's emergency safety system was disconnected so that it would not spoil the experiment. 
 Many of the officials in Moscow who approved of the experiment were not qualified to weigh up its dangers. 
 Others had grown complacent, partly because previous Soviet accidents had been kept secret in order to persuade the public of the benefits of nuclear power. 
 The experiment was doubly dangerous because, under certain conditions, the RBMK reactors at Chernobyl are of a particularly unstable kind. 
 Operating rules are designed to overcome this inherent instability; but that night, in a hurry, the operators broke them. 
 A series of explosions shook the plant. 
 About 700 tons of graphite and 70 tons of uranium fuel from the core of the reactor, all lethally radioactive, spewed on to the tarmac and the roof of the turbine hall. 
 Another 50 tons of fuel evaporated, releasing ten times as much radioactivity into the atmosphere as was released at Hiroshima. 
 Yet so sure of themselves were they, that for 17.5 hours after the blast the power-station management insisted that the reactor remained intact and that it was only an emergency watertank that had exploded. 
 It should have been a simple matter to check, but the dosimeters for measuring radioactivity were locked in a safe and the panel in the control room was dead. 
 The managers refused to believe the word of a physicist who inspected the plant, and who was to die of radiation sickness a few weeks later. 
 Instead they relied on (and quoted) machines which had a maximum reading of one five-thousandth of the dose some were actually receiving. 
 Blinkered management cost many lives. 
 Operators received lethal doses of radiation while needlessly reconnecting the water supply to the devastated reactor. 
 Some workers received lethal doses because the rest of the site was not evacuated. 
 Night fishermen fished at the outflow to the power station until morning, by which time they were dizzy, vomiting constantly, and their skin had acquired a nut-brown nuclear tan. 
 There was no evacuation from the company town of Pripyat, where 50,000 people lived, for more than 36 hours. 
 A man in Pripyat sunbathed on his balcony throughout the next day. 
 Later that evening he was taken to hospital, vomiting uncontrollably. 
 Countless small examples show the authorities' lack of foresight. 
 The infirmaries at the plant were shut, Chernobyl's medical centre was not equipped to take nuclear cases, there were few iodine pills to distribute &mdash; although they are the only way of preventing radioactive iodine from accumulating in the thyroid. 
 Helicopter pilots dumping sand and boric acid onto the reactor to damp down the nuclear reaction were unprotected until they slipped lead plates under their seats. 
 These failures, however, were merely symptoms of a larger failing in Soviet society. 
 The deputy chairman of the council of ministers, Boris Shcherbina, forbade evacuation of the countryside around Chernobyl until a government commission had arrived from Moscow. 
 At a press conference on May 6th, after the scale of the disaster had become apparent, he understated the radioactivity near the reactor by a factor of a million. 
 At the same press conference, the head of the committee on the use of nuclear energy explained that &bquo;science requires victims.&equo; 
 Against this, the conduct of the electricians, the nuclear operators and the firefighters seems both heroic and hopeless. 
 This book is not beautifully written and is not always easy to understand; technical details sometimes remain unexplained, and a bewildering cast of Russians bob in and out. 
 But it has the compelling authority that only intimate knowledge and great indignation can bring. 
 Mr Medvedev does not moralise; he does not need to; but he cannot resist commenting, and the reader can only, with sadness, agree. 
 &bquo;An abscess, long hidden within our society, had just burst: the abscess of complacency and self-flattery, of corruption and protectionism, of narrow-mindedness and self-serving privilege.&equo;  
 Sergei Prokofiev 
 Art and state 
 IN 1948, the Soviet Central Committee passed a notorious resolution aimed at Soviet composers. 
 It accused them of &bquo;contempt for melody&equo;, &bquo;neuropathic discords&equo; and &bquo;formalist perversions.&equo; 
 Sergei Prokofiev, whose centenary occurs this week, was among the most notable of its victims. 
 In his younger, more confident days he could quip that &bquo;formalism is the name given to music not understood on first hearing&equo;; but by 1948 he was less resilient, and the situation more threatening. 
 In a public statement he agreed meekly that &bquo;the resolution has shown us the goals towards which we need to strive to serve the Soviet people better&equo;. 
 For the next five years, until his death in 1953, he ground out anodyne pieces. 
 Prokofiev's fate was particularly poignant because of his long-standing reputation as an enfant terrible. 
 Entering St Petersburg Conservatory at 13, he shocked his professors with his angular harmonies, jagged rhythms and plangent colours. 
 Pronounced &bquo;an extreme leftist&equo;, his energy enchanted Diaghilev, who commissioned a ballet from him. 
 In his autobiography Prokofiev admitted that he was &bquo;not used to denying himself anything&equo;, and he was not about to see a promising career inconvenienced by the Russian Revolution. 
 Leaving Russia in 1918, he began building an international reputation for uncompromising modernism. 
 In America he seemed the embodiment of the new age, &bquo;the Bolshevik pianist&equo; who played as if he had &bquo;steel fingers, steel biceps, steel triceps&equo;. 
 As a composer he proved himself adept at large dramatic forms laced with fantasy and irony, epitomised by his opera &bquo;The Love of Three Oranges&equo;, which had its premiere in Chicago in 1921. 
 He was based by now in Paris, but Russia haunted him. 
 In 1927 he made a triumphant visit there, and convinced himself that the large-scale dramatic compositions he favoured would suit the Soviet vision. 
 His international reputation would do credit to Soviet music; state support would enable him to compose without having to earn his living on the concert platform. 
 In interviews, Prokofiev began to protest that he was no longer &bquo;the enfant terrible of discord&hellip; 
 I have become simpler and more melodic.&equo; 
 That being so, &bquo;I must immerse myself in the atmosphere of my homeland.&equo; 
 He returned for good in 1936, but his timing was bad. 
 The great purges were about to begin, and his younger rival, Dimitri Shostakovich, had just been violently denounced for the supposed perversions of his opera &bquo;Lady Macbeth of Mtsensk&equo;. 
 At first, the darkening official mood seems not to have troubled Prokofiev. 
 He supposed that he could painlessly adjust his style to the demands of Stalinism, and indeed his return produced three of his most enduring pieces, the ballet &bquo;Romeo and Juliet&equo;, his music for the film &bquo;Lieutenant Kij&eacute;&equo; and his charming children's work, &bquo;Peter and the Wolf&equo;. 
 Yet the state decreed, at first, that &bquo;Romeo and Juliet&equo; should have a happy ending; production of that and other pieces was inexplicably delayed or cancelled; and his favourite operatic director, Vsevelod Meyerhold, was arrested in June 1939 after publicly defying accusations of &bquo;artistic errors&equo;. 
 He was executed shortly afterwards. 
 Such events must have undermined even Prokofiev's naive, self-centred confidence. 
 During the war, he revised his cherished operatic version of &bquo;War and Peace&equo; again and again, in line with requests to make it more &bquo;patriotic&equo;. 
 It would still not be performed until after his death. 
 However, his dynamic Fifth Symphony was acclaimed in 1945. 
 So, at first, was the much darker Sixth. 
 But in the devastating Resolution of 1948, the Sixth was singled out for criticism and removed from the repertoire. 
 Ill, ageing and in despair at trying to reconcile artistic integrity with the official line, Prokofiev began turning out his feeble hymns to the state. 
 His characterless Seventh Symphony won a Lenin prize. 
 Six months after the work's premiere, he was dead. 
 Shostakovich summed up his colleague's fatal misconception: &bquo;He came to Moscow to teach them and they started teaching him.&equo;  
 Cinema 
 Alas, poor Mel 
 AUSTRALIAN he-man Mel Gibson, best known for &bquo;Mad Max&equo; and &bquo;Lethal Weapon&equo;, has picked up kinder notices for his &bquo;Hamlet&equo; than perhaps he or anyone else expected. 
 Put it down to inverted snobbery. 
 He tries so hard that it seems churlish to deny him a few points for effort. 
 This film marks Franco Zeffirelli's third cinematic flirtation with Shakespeare. 
 In 1967 he made a gross, slap-and-tickle version of &bquo;The Taming of the Shrew&equo; with Richard Burton and Elizabeth Taylor. 
 In 1968 he shot a &bquo;Romeo and Juliet&equo; with virginal teenagers, a sort of Renaissance &bquo;Love Story&equo;. 
 His &bquo;Hamlet&equo;, except in the vigorous and exciting duel scene at the end, lacks elegance, poetry and even a point of view. 
 Other Hamlets have been as wrong-headed: Laurence Olivier's of 1948, perhaps, which charted &bquo;the tragedy of a man who could not make up his mind&equo;, or Grigori Konzintsev's Marxist version of 1964. 
 But at least they were novel slants on the play. 
 Mr Zeffirelli's seems to be mere opportunism. 
 He wanted to see what would come of it if Mel Gibson played the prince, and he gets his answer. 
 The soliloquies have all the subtlety of a bullet train, and Mr Gibson is clearly intellectually out of his depth. 
 Inadequate acting has been the bane of all Mr Zeffirelli's Shakespeare films. 
 He is a skilled choreographer of action scenes; in his &bquo;Romeo and Juliet&equo;, the street fighting between the Capulets and the Montagus feels as modern and relevant as &bquo;West Side Story&equo; (which took the theme and modernised it). 
 In general, however, his contribution to the cinema has been disappointing compared with his work for the legitimate theatre and the opera house. 
 At Covent Garden he dominated opera production in the 1950s and early 1960s. 
 Several of his productions, including &bquo;Cavalleria Rusticana&equo; and &bquo;Tosca&equo;, are still in the repertory &mdash; sweeping realist interpretations  with  an abundance of arresting stage pictures. 
 By contrast, his films &mdash; &bquo;Endless Love&equo;, &bquo;The Champ&equo;, &bquo;Brother Sun, Sister Moon&equo; &mdash; have none of that striking visual quality and are cloyingly sentimental. 
 His failures underline the difference between theatre and film direction. 
 However gifted, a theatre director is no more than a metteur en sc&egrave;ne. 
 His talents are at the service of the text. 
 A film director, however, is much more than this. 
 The way he frames a shot or moves his camera and the pace he establishes through editing amount, in the end, to his own view of the world. 
 Film can cruelly expose limitations, and nowhere more so than in the case of the gloomy Dane and the blue-eyed wonder.  
 Our European ancestors 
 Forests of gold 
 PEOPLE who think of themselves as &bquo;European&equo; may be fascinated, or at least enlightened, by &bquo;The Celts&equo; a new exhibition that runs until December at the Palazzo Grassi in Venice. 
 Despite a bad press in the ancient world, the Celts are ancestors no one should be ashamed of. 
 They are now hailed as nothing less than the first Europeans. 
 An interlinked ethnic tribe, they founded settlements that stretched from the Isles of Arran to Asia Minor; and between 600BC and 600AD they virtually ran the show on the continent of Europe. 
 Like all foreigners who pestered the ancient Greeks and Romans, the Celts were dismissed by contemporary chroniclers as barbarians. 
 They did not speak Jove's language; they went to war clad only in shields and were, as Plato sternly put it, &bquo;given to excess in drink.&equo; 
 In that state they became &bquo;sylvan demons&equo;, &bquo;either falling into a deep slumber or looking around for a fight.&equo; 
 Plus &ccedil;a change. 
 The exhibition includes some delicately-worked gold jewellery, most of it found in Celtic tombs in the past 100 years: typically gold or silver torques, or saddle and bridle decorations of gold, silver, coral and enamel. 
 These were items buried with their princely owners, male and female; the Celts, in a touch worthy of Obelix, also provided a whole roasted boar and a sharp carving-knife. 
 Some Celtic gods are on view in the form of sculpture. 
 One of them has a handle-bar moustache; another wooden deity, dredged not long ago from Lake Geneva, has a formless face, like those that melt and distort in Francis Bacon's paintings. 
 The &bquo;Celtic belt&equo; was heavily forested in those days, as was Italy in pre-Roman times, and two large, rococo-ceilinged halls in the Palazzo Grassi have been turned into forests. 
 One is a realistic, pitch-dark forest of oaks &mdash; an ideal place for hide-and-seek in almost treeless Venice. 
 The other &bquo;forest&equo; consists of 36 black metal columns, each with two brightly-lit &bquo;portholes&equo; for viewing, either through a magnifying-glass window or, on the other side of the tree-column, in its natural size, a display of brooches, rings, ankle bracelets and other stupendously crafted objects. 
 As a Celtic expert writes in the show's catalogue, &bquo;Theirs is the first, the oldest, the greatest and the most illuminating ornamental art that Europe has ever known.&equo; 
 The 795-page catalogue is worth the journey to Venice by itself, and is likely to remain the layman's definitive Celtic history book for some time to come. 
 Celtic excavations began in earnest only in the last century, and much remains untouched. 
 In a rock-salt mine near Salzburg, for example, the salt has preserved (in shafts sometimes 350 metres deep) workers' tools, torches, swatches of finely woven cloth and a 2,600-year-old moccasin of calfskin. 
 Scalpels have been found, tools for working leather, moulds for glass beads and agricultural tools of the kind that were still being used until farming became mechanised. 
 With these objects, in their millennium of power, the Celts seem to have had a splendid time scraping and whipping Europe into shape. 
 AMERICAN SURVEY 
 Arthur Sulzberger's news that's fit to print 
 AS CHILDREN, Arthur Ochs Sulzberger and his sister Judith were so close that their father called them Punch and Judy. 
 Arthur's nickname has stuck &mdash; and is apt. 
 As publisher and chief executive of the New York Times, he is bashed about the ears by almost everybody he meets. 
 Mr Sulzberger reckons his newspaper &bquo;is slightly left of centre on social issues and slightly left of centre on economic issues but is rapidly becoming more conservative on everything.&equo; 
 This sounds safely mainstream, yet readers seethe with complaints. 
 Jews complain that the Times betrays Israel, feminists that it is chauvinist, southerners that it is pro-Yankee, priests that it is anti-Catholic. 
 Liberals say it is too right-wing; conservatives that it is too left-wing. 
 The paper gave fuel to its detractors last week when it named the woman who has accused Edward Kennedy's nephew of raping her in Palm Beach at Easter. 
 Naming rape victims without their permission is thought to be a bad thing. 
 And the Times was not even mould-breaking. 
 It named the woman because NBC News had done so the day before. 
 Typical, say the critics, of a paper that pretends to lead, but actually follows. 
 Yet most of these critics admit that the Times is one of the world's great newspapers, perhaps the greatest. 
 This is often conceded only grudgingly. 
 The paper goes against the American grain in being an elitist institution in a country that extols the common man. 
 Even the motto that runs beside its masthead every day is sniffy: &bquo;All the news that's fit to print.&equo; 
 Mr Sulzberger is unapologetic about the elitism. 
 He is pleased that the newspaper's &bquo;demographics&equo; &mdash; ie, its readers' income and education levels &mdash; are high. 
 There will be &bquo;no comics, no horoscopes, no handicapping of horses&equo; so long as he is in charge. 
 Although he is now a few months past the usual retirement age of 65, Mr Sulzberger has not disclosed when he will go. 
 He will say only that he will probably stay on as chief executive after he steps down as publisher. 
 His son, Arthur Ochs junior, alias Pinch, is expected to succeed Punch as publisher. 
 This would give him control of editorial policy. 
 For it is as publisher, not as chief executive, that Mr Sulzberger decides whom the newspaper will endorse in an election. 
 The process is not democratic. 
 &bquo;If it gets to a crunch and there is a vote, I win,&equo; is how he puts it. 
 Whether the Sulzberger family will ask Pinch to become chief executive as well is more doubtful. 
 Pinch's interests lie on the editorial side. 
 Not all his sisters and his cousins and his aunts are convinced that he is ready to run a business that takes in 32 regional newspapers, 17 magazines, five network-affiliated television stations and three newsprint mills. 
 Whatever happens, family control over a newspaper that Punch's grandfather, Adolph Ochs, bought in 1896 will be sustained. 
 The stock is divided into voting and non-voting shares, and the voting shares are concentrated in family hands. 
 Mr Sulzberger thinks this serves the public interest. 
 Most of the best newspapers in America, he contends, are family-owned. 
 As befits the owners of an elitist newspaper, the Sulzbergers are patricians. 
 Punch served a stint in the newsroom but failed to develop into a news-hungry reporter. 
 (Old hands recall how Punch, on a day off from the Paris bureau in 1955, saw a sports car plough into the crowd at Le Mans and kill 87 people; no other reporter from the newspaper was there, yet it never occurred to Punch to call his office.) 
 The other top editorial people have a better news sense but they are not immune to the old-money patina: all have centrist views with a pro-establishment tinge. 
 The editorial excellence of their newspaper is founded on its financial success &mdash; and this is not assured. 
 Its dowdy appearance is a handicap. 
 The restrictive practices of stubborn unions keep the new colour-printing presses idle. 
 The circulation continues to climb: in 1990 it was up to 1.1m on weekdays and 1.7m on Sundays. 
 But the amount of paper needed to produce the obese Sunday edition can cost three times its &dollar;1.50 cover price. 
 To prosper, the newspaper needs to attract lots of advertising. 
 As advertisers see it, the Times is neither one thing nor t'other. 
 It is not really a city newspaper. 
 It has won 63 Pulitzer prizes, more than any other newspaper, but only one of them for local reporting. 
 Though its national edition is available for breakfast on the west coast, the Times is not really a national newspaper either. 
 The breadth of its coverage of foreign news is unrivalled, but most of its readers are in greater New York. 
 Fair but no fun 
 Mr Sulzberger thinks he has the answer. 
 Across America, as in New York, the Times will continue to appeal to the rich and influential. 
 But to be required reading for top people, it will somehow have to become less inhibited without losing its fanaticism about accuracy and fairness. 
 In its business coverage, it lacks the muck-raking skills of the Wall Street Journal and the international thoroughness of the Financial Times. 
 On politics, it has none of the Washington Post's killer instincts. 
 The columnists on the op-ed pages are more bloody-minded than they used to be, but in its editorials the Times remains the voice of American public policy. 
 The best source for its reporters in a foreign land may well be the American ambassador. 
 Punch's newspaper has to think about being a little less boring.  
 Snowed under 
 ASPEN, COLORADO 
 JESUS RODRIGUEZ, a 26-year-old Mexican immigrant, lives in Aspen, Colorado &mdash; America's poshest ski resort. 
 Mr Rodriguez is not rich or famous. 
 He is one of 3,000 latino workers who have moved into Aspen's Roaring Fork Valley, replacing anglo &bquo;ski bums&equo; as caretakers of the rich. 
 The number of latinos has tripled in the past year. 
 Like most of Aspen's 12,000 workers, the latinos live &bquo;down valley&equo; from Aspen, crammed into mobile homes. 
 They work silently behind the scenes &mdash; washing dishes, lugging supplies, making beds and shovelling snow. 
 Toothy anglo teenagers still greet guests at the &dollar;300-a-night hotels. 
 Not everybody is pleased about the influx. 
 A letter in a local newspaper advocated sending latinos &bquo;back to Burritoville.&equo; 
 There have been several arrests, following knife fights between drunk latinos. 
 Yet most people welcome them. 
 Employers like their diligence. 
 Old residents say they have more in common with the latinos than with the ultra-rich who have taken over their valley. 
 There is a valley-wide &bquo;cultural competency&equo; campaign to build bridges. 
 Schools and employers are teaching languages. 
 Role-playing seminars are intended to help people learn tolerance. 
 Health workers are offering bilingual pre-natal care classes at churches. 
 Several local agencies are planning to hire bilingual staff. 
 The city has established a latino-anglo task force. 
 Officials from the Department of Justice, charged with smoothing cultural relations, praise Aspen's response to latino workers as exemplary. 
 Mr Rodriguez and his wife have even tried skiing. 
 But they say &dollar;40 for a lift ticket would be better spent on books. 
 Mr Rodriguez's plan is to get a high-school diploma, then win a pilot's licence.  
 Women officer cadets 
 Lost cause 
 COLUMBIA, SOUTH CAROLINA 
 OF THE American troops in the Gulf war, 6% were women. 
 Twelve women died (five in action) and two were taken prisoner. 
 By all accounts, females acquitted themselves well. 
 Be that as it may, the last two state-supported military schools that refuse to admit women cadets are fighting a rearguard action for their cause. 
 Representatives of one, the Virginia Military Institute, argued in court earlier this month that admitting women would destroy the school's camaraderie, forged through rigorous physical and psychological training in an atmosphere totally without privacy. 
 The Citadel, in Charleston, South Carolina, also says that admitting women would destroy the experience of attending an all-male military academy. 
 If female cadets are admitted, the Citadel &bquo;would be required to change an educational philosophy which has been tested and proven sound for almost 150 years,&equo; declared William Risher, chairman of its board of visitors. 
 A federal judge is expected to rule soon on the constitutional issue at hand &mdash; whether a state-owned institution can bar half the state's citizens from applying for admission because of their sex. 
 Spokesmen for both schools say they will obey the law if they are ordered to admit women, but they will do so grudgingly, as they did with blacks in the 1970s. 
 Their opposition goes deep. 
 Both the Citadel and VMI consider themselves to be repositories of the southern chivalry and military prowess tested so harshly during the Civil War. 
 That lost cause was started in 1861 by Citadel cadets who fired the first shots at Fort Sumter, outside Charleston. 
 &bquo;These institutions instil and cultivate in their cadets what were once commonly referred to as the virtues of southern manhood &mdash; honour, chivalry and devotion to God, state and family,&equo; wrote one alumnus in a letter to a newspaper. 
 Women have been enrolled at West Point, the United States Naval Academy and the Air Force Academy since the mid-1970s, when Congress passed a law that required women to be admitted to the federal military academies. 
 In 1990 a woman rose to the top at West Point, by becoming brigade commander and the first female captain of the corps of cadets. 
 But VMI's lawyers suggested at the court hearing that West Point has &bquo;gone soft&equo;, that its discipline records show a pattern of sexual tension in the 15 years since women were admitted &mdash; and that these have led to &bquo;substantial, deep-seated problems.&equo;  
 Skiing 
 Matures 
 VAIL, COLORADO 
 EXCEPT at the highest of America's ski resorts, the lifts have stopped and the instructors have moved on to Argentina or New Zealand. 
 In Colorado the season that ended on April 14th was probably the second-best ever: it attracted nearly 10m skiers. 
 But in the country as a whole, the number of skiers was down for the third year running, and was no higher than 12 years ago (see chart on next page). 
 The obvious conclusion is that skiing has become a mature industry, which will have to get used to little or no growth. 
 The financial problems at some ski resorts suggest that skiing &mdash; the quintessential 1980s yuppie holiday &mdash; is no place to put your 1990s money. 
 Charles Goeldner, of the University of Colorado, disagrees. 
 He says the variable pattern of snowfall does more to affect the figures than anything else. 
 The past few years have been poor snow years for frustrated skiers. 
 But increasingly the vagaries of the weather are mitigated by snow-blowers. 
 Mr Goeldner reckons that resorts in Colorado have invested more than &dollar;500m in snow-making machines and fast lifts in the past decade. 
 The true success of the American skiing industry has been to adapt to the ageing of its customers. 
 When skiing first became something akin to a mass-tourism business, it was a young person's holiday. 
 Throughout the 1980s, the number of young people skiing has declined. 
 The once-young are still keen. 
 Between 1977&ndash;78 and 1989&ndash;90, the proportion of skiers aged 18&ndash;24 fell from 28% to 12%; the proportion aged 35&ndash;44 increased from 19% to 30%. 
 This growth in what the tourism business winsomely calls the &bquo;silver generation&equo; would not have been possible without big changes in boots and bindings. 
 The ski resorts have done their bit too, grooming many of their slopes to a baby-bottom smoothness that is less fun for adolescent hot-doggers but easier on older legs. 
 However, after a number of fatal accidents this year, some people are questioning whether grooming is such a great idea. 
 It allows novice skiers to travel too fast and they then get out of control and hit a tree. 
 People are also more impatient. 
 A neophyte taking a skiing holiday used to spend the first week in excruciating, character-forming exercises. 
 The new breed of skier expects to be able to ski from day two. 
 The most important marketing device in the industry has nothing to do with skiing at all. 
 Wander round Colorado in the summer, from international conference to music festival, and it quickly becomes clear how much effort the resorts have put into making themselves year-round destinations. 
 Mr Goeldner thinks that one day the summer revenue of Colorado's ski towns will exceed the winter one.  
 A nation of boy scouts 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 VOLUNTARY service has a long history in America. 
 In 1835 de Tocqueville admired &bquo;the extreme skill with which the inhabitants of the United States succeed in proposing a common object for the exertions of a great many men and inducing them voluntarily to pursue it.&equo; 
 When he came into office George Bush set out to make this national characteristic a centrepiece of his domestic policy, referring to &bquo;a thousand points of light&equo;. 
 Ever since November 1989, the White House has been doggedly nominating daily &bquo;points of light&equo; in an attempt to draw the nation's attention to outstanding examples of voluntary service. 
 One day it is a group of prison inmates in New Jersey who teach illiterate fellow-prisoners to read. 
 The next it is two sisters in Rhode Island who run a summer camp for mentally retarded children. 
 In the past two weeks the administration has stepped up its campaign to encourage voluntary service. 
 The 12 days between April 15th and April 26th were set aside for a &bquo;points of light celebration of service&equo;. 
 A record called &bquo;Points of Light&equo; was released by Randy Travis, a country singer whom Mr Bush likes. 
 Daily events were arranged in cities around America and each day was given a theme. 
 On April 19th it was drug prevention in Kansas City. 
 The next day it was on to Kalamazoo, Michigan, and family and community. 
 The jamboree was set to culminate on April 26th with singing and dancing on the White House lawn. 
 Liberals are suspicious of the hoopla, and of the policy. 
 They fear that welfare is being privatised: if charities build shelters for the homeless and philanthropists feed the poor, the government saves money. 
 Poor Americans might be left at the mercy of luck and charity. 
 The glow from a thousand points of light seems less reliable than that from the lightbulbs of a well-financed bureaucracy. 
 Gregg Petersmeyer, director of the White House's Office for National Service, denies that Mr Bush's rhetoric is simply a ruse to allow the government to shed expensive responsibilities. 
 He argues that &bquo;points of light&equo; provide a middle way between reliance on the welfare state and the belief that economic growth alone can cure deep poverty. 
 No government programme, says Mr Petersmeyer, can persuade a teenager not to drop out of school, or not to try drugs. 
 That is the job of a family. 
 Where a family no longer exists, neighbourhood organisations can provide a web of family-like relationships. 
 Is it working? 
 A recent Gallup poll found that 98m adults are involved in voluntary service, a 23% increase in two years. 
 Perhaps sensibly, Mr Bush's campaign appeals more to enlightened self-interest than to self-sacrifice. 
 Barbara Lohman of the Points of Light Foundation (a non-profit organisation set up at the instigation of the White House) says that today's volunteers are &bquo;not turned on by the martyrdom thing.&equo; 
 The slogan of the latest &bquo;points of light&equo; campaign reflects this. 
 &bquo;Do something good. 
 Feel something real&equo;, it urges.  
 Vietnamese-Americans 
 Their bonnie lies over the ocean 
 WESTMINSTER, CALIFORNIA 
 For many of its 1m Vietnamese citizens America is a temporary refuge, not a new home. 
 Violent though a few of them are, they are beginning to succeed. 
 The fourth in our occasional series on America's ethnic groups 
 THIS weekend is &bquo;Quoc Han&equo; for Vietnamese-Americans, or &bquo;black April&equo;, on which they commemorate the anniversary of the fall of Saigon. 
 As on every other Saturday morning, the inhabitants of Little Saigon in Orange county will crowd around their televisions to watch an hour and a half of Vietnamese programmes. 
 There are the usual singers and some local news, but the main item is an often grisly tour of Vietnamese refugee camps around the world. 
 The highlight is &bquo;Nhan Tin&equo; (or missing persons), which gives individual inmates a few moments to appeal to relatives living in America, Canada or Australia. 
 Little Saigon, a district of Westminster in Orange county, is the Vietnamese-American capital. 
 Around 400,000 Vietnamese live in California, part of the state's 3m Asian population. 
 When the first Vietnamese arrived in 1975 after the fall of Saigon, the federal government tried to spread them around the country. 
 A few stayed where they were sent &mdash; there are many fishermen in Louisiana and Texas &mdash; but many have filtered back to Orange county. 
 The first wave of refugees included many of the richest and best-qualified Vietnamese. 
 For instance, Nam Tran, who presents the Saturday television programme, used to work in the American embassy; her husband was a pilot in the Vietnamese air force. 
 But three in every four Vietnamese-Americans arrived or were born in the past decade. 
 The newcomers, mostly fishermen or peasant farmers who came as boat people, have been less successful than the first wave. 
 Mixed in with both groups are the Chinese who lived in Vietnam and ran many of its businesses. 
 Nevertheless the biggest division in the Vietnamese community is not racial or economic, but generational. 
 Older people still regard America as a refuge; younger people regard it as a new home. 
 Asked &bquo;would you go back and live in Vietnam if the government changed?&equo;, 
 Nam Tran says she would, but her children would not. 
 Although Vietnamese children often finish first in Californian high schools, their parents and grandparents sometimes live miserable lives. 
 Many stay at home because they cannot drive. 
 If they venture out to Little Saigon's caf&eacute;s, it is to bicker about (Vietnamese) politics or read one of the 20-odd Vietnamese newspapers. 
 The humiliation for some is that they cannot talk to their English-speaking grandchildren. 
 The ghost of Ho Chi Minh has followed the Vietnamese into Orange county. 
 Several of the South Vietnamese ministers his followers ousted now live in California. 
 In theory, any contact or hint of rapprochement with the communist regime is traitorous. 
 People who speak out in favour of negotiations receive death threats; businessmen who openly trade with Vietnam have received letter bombs. 
 Politically hyphenated 
 Such a stand might look principled, were it not a sham. 
 Many of the denouncers pop up in hotels in Hanoi. 
 Travel agents in Little Saigon advertise air tickets and tours to Bangkok, which, just coincidentally, link up with tours of Vietnam. 
 One of the biggest businesses in Little Saigon is sending money to Vietnam. 
 The average family sends back &dollar;100 a month and pays a &dollar;10 fee to send it, part of which goes to the Vietnamese government. 
 The latest ruse is to send a fax promising to pay dollars, which can be converted by relatives into cash in Vietnam. 
 Again, the faxes are technically routed through Bangkok. 
 Occasionally the FBI cracks down on attempts to smuggle money. 
 A much bigger criminal challenge comes from Vietnamese gangs. 
 A recent siege in Sacramento left three Vietnamese gang members and three hostages dead. 
 Before the gun battle started the Vietnamese youths issued extravagant demands, including one for a flight to Thailand so they could fight communists. 
 Most gang crimes are less political, more efficient and are not reported to the police. 
 The victims are usually other Vietnamese. 
 Gangs tend to pick on houses rather than businesses, torturing a family until it hands over its money (many Vietnamese keep all their cash at home). 
 Some gangs tour America, staying in motels and stalking the Vietnamese with a torn-out copy of the &bquo;Nguyen&equo; page in the local telephone book or with the help of local fixers who point out the rich pickings in each city. 
 There are even some all-girl gangs, including one called the Wally Girls. 
 Yet America's Vietnamese may well become another immigrant success story. 
 They already form America's third biggest Asian group after 1.3m Chinese and 1.5m Filipinos. 
 Though they have not so far emulated the economic success of other Asians, they share many of their qualities. 
 They work hard; they have a strong family sense and a keen appreciation of education. 
 So far most of the business successes are small family-owned ones: groceries, restaurants, garages. 
 Because language remains a problem, many Vietnamese have become technicians or engineers. 
 If a Toshiba computer breaks down in America, the chances are that it will be mended by a Vietnamese engineer in California. 
 Little Saigon has a host of new shops and offices. 
 In 1980 there were only two banks; now there are nine. 
 In one of Little Saigon's trendier shops a video screen shows footage of Vietnam shot amateurishly through the window of a moving car. 
 In a decade's time, it may well show rock videos &mdash; and perhaps &bquo;Miss Saigon&equo;.  
 Boston harbour 
 The muck stops here 
 BOSTON 
 IN 1988 George Bush came to polluted Boston Harbour, held his nose and made the muck a metaphor for Michael Dukakis's political liabilities. 
 The harbour and the metaphor are now nagging Mr Dukakis's Republican successor, William Weld. 
 Unable to resolve the mess generated by the &dollar;6 billion, court-mandated harbour clean-up, Massachusetts has been hit with a ban on nearly all new sewer connections in the Boston area. 
 The ban applies to both new construction and renovations, and will cause havoc to the building industry in a state already in economic difficulty. 
 For the moment, it means that recently completed properties cannot be connected to the sewage system in 43 towns and suburbs. 
 They thus cannot be occupied. 
 From the offices of New England Telephone to a weight-training room beneath the baseball field at Fenway Park, doors to new facilities are shut tight. 
 The order threatens to stop construction projects worth hundreds of millions of dollars at Harvard University, the Dana-Farber Cancer Institute and St Elizabeth's Hospital, among others. 
 The proposed site for the mud to be dredged out of the harbour is Walpole, chosen by the Massachusetts Water Resources Authority in 1989 after a five-year search. 
 Walpole got full environmental approval, but it already has a state prison, and local residents were successful twice last year in lobbying the legislature to reject bills that would have made the land available for the harbour clean-up. 
 Though the state hopes to convert much of the sludge into commercial fertiliser, a back-up dumping site must be found for work to begin. 
 Mr Weld, who inherited this confusion from the Dukakis administration, made it worse last year when, during the election campaign, he promised to find another place to dump. 
 But his plea for a four-month stay on the sewage ban while this search was completed was dismissed by David Mazzone, the federal judge overseeing the clean-up project, and rejected by a federal appeals court. 
 Mr Weld therefore submitted a bill this week to try once again to transfer the Walpole site &mdash; and satisfy the judge. 
 The legislature should say yes to this. 
 But although the hunt for a substitute will go on, it looks increasingly likely that judicial pressure will make Walpole swallow the slime and Mr Weld his promise. 
 Such a blow to the governor will be particularly ironic: while serving as federal prosecutor for Massachusetts in 1984, he was closely involved in preparing the suit that forced the clean-up of the harbour.  
 How to make anti-poverty policies popular 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 THE thoughts of think-tanks usually arrive at wrong moments and sink into oblivion. 
 Academics can be heard ruefully regretting that their analysis of some pressing problem has not sold in Washington, only on campuses. 
 Occasionally, though, a think-tank is lucky and its latest thoughts land in the middle of a policy debate. 
 A new collection of 19 papers published by the Brookings Institution (&bquo;The Urban Underclass&equo;, edited by Christopher Jencks and Paul Peterson) has arrived when both the administration and Congress are discussing anti-poverty policy. 
 The book will provide a fact-lode that politicians can quarry for years. 
 Like any self-respecting academics, the Brookings authors do not agree on what the problem is, let alone how to cure it. 
 For a start, Mr Jencks, of Northwestern University, casts doubt on the idea that different kinds of social problems &mdash; unemployment, crime, teenage pregnancy, educational failure &mdash; move in lockstep. 
 Mr Jencks argues that while long-term male joblessness and unwed parenthood have got worse, school drop-out rates have improved; and the number of violent crimes (other than homicide) and the proportion of the population on welfare are at least not getting worse. 
 Mr Jencks concludes that to search for a comprehensive policy to tackle the underclass is a waste of time; different policies are needed for different problems that may be only loosely related. 
 The Brookings papers give politicians a choice. 
 They can decide that America's problem is the &bquo;ghetto poor&equo; &mdash; the phrase that William Julius Wilson, of the University of Chicago, now prefers to &bquo;underclass&equo;. 
 Or they can decide that the main problem is that relative poverty got no better during the prosperous 1980s. 
 If policy were to concentrate on the ghetto poor &mdash; those socially segregated in inner cities whose manufacturing jobs have fled to the suburbs &mdash; it could be aimed at very few places. 
 Successful efforts to rescue the ghettos in just four cities (Chicago, New York, Detroit and Newark) would have a dramatic effect on the numbers at the bottom of the heap. 
 But if the intention is to reduce relative poverty, policy would have to range over Appalachia and Mississippi as well as all the big cities. 
 The larger aim prevails in Washington. 
 The topic at the moment is what to do about the working poor, particularly those with children. 
 Even more than other industrial countries, America has seen a shift in the age distribution of poverty. 
 Between 1970 and 1986, says Mr Peterson of Harvard, the proportion of the elderly living in poverty fell by half; the proportion of children increased from 15% to 20%. 
 Concentrating on the working poor with children has obvious political charms. 
 Congress works by building coalitions; to aim at just the ghetto poor &mdash; wholly urban and overwhelmingly black &mdash; would attract too narrow a coalition. 
 According to the Urban Institute, 74% of the working poor were white in 1988. 
 The Progressive Policy Institute, a think-tank allied to the right wing of the Democratic Party, the Democratic Leadership Council, makes the point that &bquo;working-poor Americans are not vastly different from everyone else who works.&equo; 
 Beating the tax 
 The working poor's main problem is the poverty trap &mdash; the tax penalty that poor families face when they move from welfare to work. 
 Until April 24th two options, not mutually exclusive, were under consideration. 
 The first was Daniel Patrick Moynihan's year-long effort to cut the payroll tax that pays for social security (old-age pensions). 
 For the working poor, social-security payments typically make up the largest part of their tax bill. 
 But on Wednesday the Senate voted overwhelmingly against a procedural motion that would have allowed the cut to be introduced later in the year. 
 Senator Moynihan now says that his plan is dead. 
 The second option is to concentrate resources on the earned-income tax credit (EITC). 
 The EITC is a credit to employed family heads with children. 
 The value of the credit tapers off above a certain earnings level, and disappears just above &dollar;20,000 a year. 
 After expansions in 1986 and 1990, it is now the prime instrument for alleviating poverty among those who work &mdash; perhaps 11m households now receive it. 
 When changes made to the scheme in 1990 are fully phased in, families may get more than &dollar;2,000 a year. 
 George Bush's budget for fiscal 1992 proposed a number of changes to the EITC, such as credit for health-insurance premiums. 
 The administration prefers changing the EITC to increasing the minimum wage, which it fears would increase unemployment and inflation. 
 The EITC, which puts cash rather than benefits (like food stamps) into the hands of the poor, fits with its general philosophy of &bquo;empowerment&equo;. 
 So would the most intriguing proposal now doing the rounds in Congress. 
 This is to increase the personal tax exemption (the amount by which taxable income is reduced for each person in a household). 
 In 1948 the exemption was set at &dollar;600 a person; in 1990 it was &dollar;2,050. 
 According to recent evidence before the House of Representatives select committee on children and the family, had the exemption been indexed from 1948 it would now be worth &dollar;7,800. 
 A mix of Republicans and Democrats are looking at the exemption. 
 Pat Schroeder, the Democratic chairman of the select committee, favours increasing it. 
 Dan Coats, a Republican senator from Indiana, would like it doubled. 
 The problem, needless to say, is the cost, which nobody knows but would be huge. 
 Mr Coats awaits figures for his plan from the Treasury, which will collectively blanch when it sees them. 
 Eugene Steuerle of the Urban Institute, who also favours increasing the exemption, accepts that it might take many years to reverse the effects of its shrinkage. 
 Still, at least the interlocking issues of taxation, welfare and the family are now on the political map. 
 The most pressing of all the problems of family poverty, however, remains the least soluble. 
 This is the inexorable increase in the proportion of children born out of wedlock (see chart on previous page). 
 Mr Jencks, careful as ever, points out that the figures can mislead. 
 The proportion of out-of-wedlock births has increased so much mainly because the number of births to married couples has sharply declined. 
 He points out that in 1960, married black women could have expected to have 3.49 children; if they had continued to reproduce at this rate, the out-of-wedlock rate among black women would have increased from 23% in 1960 to just 29% in 1987, and gone almost unnoticed. 
 Instead, black married women stopped having so many children; black unmarried women continued to have them as before. 
 Births outside marriage are rising among whites as well as blacks. 
 Two-parent families in which the parents stay married have become anything but &bquo;normal&equo; (even though the divorce rate seems to be falling). 
 Changes to the tax and benefit structure, and expanded economic opportunity in the ghetto, may reduce the number of children born outside marriage. 
 But they may not.  
 The speeding ghost 
 IT IS the less curvaceous and futuristic of the two. 
 But the YF-22 has won a long, hard dogfight against its rival prototype, the YF-23, to become the air force's next fighter. 
 The winner was put together by Lockheed, Boeing and General Dynamics, and will be powered by Pratt &amp; Whitney engines. 
 These companies, and the sub-contractors on their team, will now proceed with full-scale development. 
 On present plans, 648 aircraft will be produced, at a cost of &dollar;65 billion-95 billion, the first ones coming off the production line in early 1997. 
 Unless it can pull some rabbits from a hat, the losing consortium, led by Northrop and McDonnell Douglas, will see the YF-23 (which resembles its sleek and costly stablemate, the B-2 bomber) consigned to a museum. 
 The YF-22's most useful quality is its ability not to show up on radar, including radars of a sensitivity not yet invented. 
 Nothing is invisible to radar, but a stealthy aircraft shows up over the background noise only at so close a range that radar, which has dominated air and combat for two generations, is virtually useless against it. 
 There is more to the YF-22 than stealth. 
 It produces no smoke, and its heat output is so controlled that it is not much warmer than the surrounding air and therefore hard for infra-red devices to detect. 
 It can outmanoeuvre any fighter flying today. 
 And it can fly supersonically using only its normal engines; with no gas-guzzling afterburners to feed, it can go much farther at such speeds than any of today's machines. 
 Until now virtually any fighter could be modified to drop bombs, but the YF-22 may never do so. 
 The reason is that all the weapons must fit inside the radar-screening fuselage to prevent their unstealthy shapes from giving the aircraft away. 
 The weapons bay is too small to accommodate much of a bomb: it is designed to take the AMRAAM, a new air-to-air missile that uses its own radar to hunt down and destroy enemy aircraft. 
 The competition was close. 
 The YF-22 proved more manoeuvrable than its opponent, although marginally less stealthy. 
 It cannot have done the YF-23 any good that it was unable to kick the AMRAAMs out of its weapons bay on demand. 
 And cost was undoubtedly a factor: the winner was a little cheaper. 
 But some observers believe that what tipped the balance was a belief in the Pentagon that the management of the Lockheed-Boeing-General Dynamics team was stronger. 
 Whether or not this is true, the team can certainly muster more money among its members. 
 If the programme's costs spiral, the government would stand more chance of enforcing penalty clauses. 
 ASIA 
 Look, I can read 
 FROM A CORRESPONDENT IN KERALA 
 THE state of Kerala is where history is often made in the Indian subcontinent. 
 Christianity came to Kerala in the first century. 
 More recently, the state has been run by the Communist Party of India and its allies; and, unlike communists elsewhere, they retain power through free elections. 
 Now Kerala is the first of India's 25 states to have achieved pretty well universal literacy. 
 A recent United Nations report says that 90% of the adult population are literate. 
 The rich countries reckon to have at least 95% of their adults literate. 
 In India as a whole the figure is about 40% (see chart). 
 Kerala is a fertile state laced with rivers and canals. 
 Most of its 26m people have enough to live on. 
 Life expectancy is reckoned to be 69 years, compared with an average of 57 for the whole of the country. 
 The princely state of Travancore-Cochin, which was absorbed into Kerala in 1956, promoted education, bringing in extra teachers from outside. 
 Back at the start of this century, more than a tenth of Travancore's adults were literate, twice the rate of the whole of the subcontinent. 
 By 1981 some 81% of Kerala's adults were literate. 
 A big effort was made in the late 1980s to try to get just about everyone over 15 to read and write, using more than 20,000 volunteer teachers, 14,000 of them women. 
 The opposition in the state legislature, Rajiv Gandhi's Congress Party, is rather sulky over the achievement. 
 It, too, wants people to be literate and complains that its offers to help have been ignored. 
 The main voluntary agency dealing with literacy is Marxist. 
 Most of the money for the campaign has come from the central government and the United Nations, but it seems to be Marxist enthusiasm that has put it to good use. 
 The chief minister, 70-year-old Krishnan Nayanar, claims that because people are literate, Kerala has less crime and alcoholism than elsewhere in India. 
 It is a compliment to Mr Nayanar that the central government wants to copy Kerala's methods of using volunteer teachers by the thousand. 
 One plan being talked of is to close all India's universities for a year, during which students and graduates would move into the impoverished rural areas to teach villagers to read and write. 
 Certainly, something drastic needs to be done to spread literacy. 
 Otherwise, by the turn of the century, India will surely be among the world's least literate countries.  
 Japan 
 In search of a job 
 FROM OUR TOKYO CORRESPONDENT 
 JAPAN has, in effect, two prime ministers. 
 Toshiki Kaifu holds the title, but Noboru Takeshita is his master. 
 Both flew to foreign parts this week. 
 Both need to be seen on Japanese television hobnobbing with the good and the great around the world. 
 Each is eager to present himself as the most qualified man to head off protectionist measures and to restore Japan's good name, which lately has been looking a little tarnished. 
 At stake is the leadership of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party, and thus the job of prime minister, which will be decided in October. 
 Mr Kaifu's destinations were five South-East Asian countries, Malaysia, Brunei, Thailand, Singapore and the Philippines. 
 He had planned to make this tour in January, but postponed it because of the Gulf war. 
 Mr Takeshita flew to Washington for a heart-to-heart chat with President Bush. 
 Each man must struggle to convince the party and the public that he is the right choice to guide Japan in the coming years. 
 Mr Kaifu was a stop-gap prime minister plucked from obscurity in 1989 after more prominent politicians were touched by the Recruit shares-for-favour scandal. 
 Mr Takeshita was damaged by the scandal and had to resign as prime minister. 
 He wants another chance. 
 The barons of the party have done their best to avoid public arguments during the local elections. 
 The last of the elections took place on April 21st, delivering, as it happened, a handsome victory across the country for candidates backed by the Liberal Democrats, and defeat for the socialists. 
 Perhaps this shows that the popular resentment against politicians' financial shenanigans &mdash; which lost the party control of the upper house of parliament &mdash; has at last abated. 
 If so, this is a good time to tackle tricky chores. 
 Mr Kaifu and his cabinet have steeled themselves to send four minesweepers, two support vessels and some 500 Japanese servicemen to the Gulf. 
 It is the first time since the end of the second world war that the Japanese navy has ventured overseas. 
 Although belated, the gesture will win Mr Kaifu kudos in Washington, and guarantee a warm welcome for him at the London summit of rich countries' leaders in July. 
 On his return from South-East Asia Mr Kaifu will face two unpleasant tasks. 
 One is getting through parliament changes to a law that protects small shopkeepers at the expense of big stores, the chief outlets for foreign goods. 
 Small shopkeepers tend to support the Liberal Democrats, but Mr Kaifu wants to please a more important supporter, Mr Bush. 
 The other tricky operation, opening up Japan's rice market, will also please the Americans. 
 A breakthrough could revive the Uruguay round of GATT talks, stalled since December. 
 Mr Kaifu might accumulate enough successes to impress his party when it decides who should lead the country for the next couple of years. 
 No one has seriously thought of Mr Kaifu as a two-term prime minister. 
 But, given the paucity of alternatives, a wiser and more experienced Mr Kaifu (supported by the Americans) could survive as the compromise candidate. 
 Such thoughts have not escaped so consummate a politician as Mr Takeshita. 
 He professes not to want the job of prime minister, saying he has had his turn and is proud of his achievements. 
 Few take such pronouncements seriously. 
 As leader of the Liberal Democrats' largest and wealthiest faction, Mr Takeshita wields enormous clout. 
 Mr Kaifu has no power base of his own and is prime minister only on Mr Takeshita's say-so. 
 That say-so is about to be withdrawn. 
 When the party's secretary-general, Ichiro Ozawa, resigned recently, Mr Takeshita placed in the job one of his most faithful lieutenants, Keizo Obuchi. 
 Mr Obuchi will do Mr Takeshita's bidding. 
 Mr Takeshita's immediate aim is to show the Americans that he is as adept in international affairs as in domestic politics, and that they are wasting their time on a boy like Mr Kaifu. 
 Dealing with international trade and security is a man's job. 
 After talking with Mr Bush, he plans to go to Beijing for some grown-up conversation with the Chinese prime minister, Li Peng. 
 If it is true that the Japanese have pardoned the politicians implicated in the Recruit affair, Mr Takeshita may indeed feel that the time is ripe for his return.  
 China 
 A matter of status 
 FROM OUR CHINA CORRESPONDENT 
 IF KUWAIT deserves liberation from an aggressor, why not Tibet? 
 The question enrages China, which gobbled up Tibet in 1951 (to few protests at the time). 
 Yet it is a question raised with increasing effect by Tibet's exiled spiritual leader, the Dalai Lama. 
 Earlier this month he was rapturously received by the American Congress; he was also briefly entertained by President Bush at the White House. 
 This &bquo;hurt the feelings of the Chinese people&equo;; worse, it came from a man China considers &bquo;an old friend&equo;. 
 But there was more to Mr Bush's move than meets the eye. 
 The president believes good relations with China matter a lot for American interests in Asia. 
 By reversing his previous stand and meeting the Dalai Lama, Mr Bush was perhaps taking the steam out of a growing congressional effort to do something that would injure a lot more than China's pride: the cancelling of China's most-favoured-nation (MFN) trading status. 
 MFN means giving a country the tariff treatment enjoyed by your least restricted trading partner. 
 It is a staple of the multilateral trading system, and is extended by the United States to all but a handful. 
 China has had the status since 1980, when America waived a law (originally intended to benefit Soviet Jews) that prohibits MFN for countries which restrict emigration. 
 Congress, incensed by the Tiananmen massacre of June 1989, last spring urged Mr Bush to revoke China's MFN status. 
 Instead, he renewed it for a year; by June 3rd he has to decide whether to do so again. 
 Never mind the inconsistencies of using the tools of free trade to secure human rights (nobody is trying to deprive Iraq, for instance, of its MFN status): Congress thinks China should have MFN only if it treats its people better. 
 Accepting this logic, President Bush last year argued that China had ended martial law, and so deserved a renewal. 
 This year he can point to&hellip; well, the trials of more than 700 dissidents, more political prisoners, repression in Tibet. 
 Anti-China congressmen have new allies this time around: protectionists. 
 China's austerity programme last year cut both domestic consumption and (partly through trade restrictions) imports. 
 America's bilateral deficit with China thus rose by two-thirds, to &dollar;10.4 billion, its biggest after the deficits with Japan and Taiwan. 
 By April 30th Carla Hills, the American trade boss, must decide whether to cite China as an &bquo;unfair&equo; trader. 
 If she does (probably over China's failure to respect copyrights and patents), the opponents of MFN for China will have another weapon in their armoury. 
 All this is worrying Hong Kong more than anyone. 
 The British colony, already fretting over whether China will give its nod to an expensive new airport in the territory, can ill afford the economic blow of a change in China's status. 
 Hong Kong manufacturers employ perhaps 2m workers in southern China, and last year nearly 58% of Hong Kong's total exports consisted of re-exports from China. 
 Take away China's MFN, and American tariffs on these goods would go up as much as tenfold. 
 The Hong Kong government guesses that what would follow is a fall of 5&ndash;7% in the colony's total trade, and of a third in its rate of GDP growth. 
 And China? 
 The Chinese have been inching back towards economic reform. 
 They have begun micro-devaluations, to help the yuan converge with economic reality. 
 And they have decided to issue part of their deficit-financing bonds to the market at attractive interest rates, instead of forcing them down the throats of reluctant workers (though the lack of a secondary market may still make them unappetising). 
 Such reforms would be unthinkable in the chaos after a revocation of MFN. 
 The Chinese, like most people in Hong Kong, do not believe it will happen. 
 But, for the first time, they have had their ambassador in Washington speak publicly about the issue. 
 Mr Bush, not before time, has shaken the complacency of China's leaders.  
 Ballots and bullets 
 FROM OUR INDIA CORRESPONDENT 
 INDIA has long had terrorists who kill and maim to secure secession for various of its 25 states. 
 They may soon be joined by elected sympathisers. 
 The prime minister, Chandra Shekhar, is insisting on holding elections to the state assemblies in Punjab and Assam, as well as next month's national parliamentary poll. 
 Both states are plagued by secessionist militants, and both are at present ruled &mdash; with the army's help &mdash; directly from Delhi. 
 Together, they threaten a tear in the fabric of the world's largest democracy. 
 But terrorism or not, the prime minister says that it is wrong to deprive any state of its elected legislature. 
 Others, including the Congress Party of Rajiv Gandhi (once, but no more, the ally of Mr Shekhar), disagree. 
 They say that fair elections in Punjab and Assam are impossible &mdash; and so the outcome will be decided by bullets, not ballots. 
 Moreover, those elected might then declare independence and seek foreign intervention to aid their cause. 
 Mr Gandhi concludes that there should be no elections in the two states until terrorism is controlled. 
 Mr Shekhar replies that a flawed election is better than no election. 
 Beneath this surface of high principle swirls an undercurrent of political opportunism. 
 Mr Shekhar came to power last November by leading 60-odd defectors out of the ruling Janata Dal, and forming a minority government with the support of Congress. 
 He is now in danger of political disappearance. 
 His band of defectors, called the Socialist Janata Dal, cannot hope to win more than a handful of seats in the coming general election. 
 However, if he can form an alliance with militants elected from Punjab and Assam, he might just hold the balance of power in a hung parliament. 
 So in wooing militants he is not seeking only to heal the wounds of Punjab and Assam &mdash; he is following the one strategy which might sustain him in power. 
 Mr Gandhi (who, admittedly, has long preached toughness against terrorism) is equally practical. 
 The coming general election is likely to be a close one &mdash; and Punjab and Assam may make the difference between a Congress victory and defeat. 
 The party is unlikely to win even one of the 13 seats from Punjab, and perhaps only three or four of Assam's 14 seats. 
 Since the rest of India will go to the polls between May 20th and 26th, Mr Shekhar had wanted Punjab and Assam to vote in that same week. 
 But local calls for special security will delay voting in the two states until June &mdash; after the swearing-in of the new federal government. 
 If that government is headed by Mr Gandhi, Mr Gandhi could conveniently decide to abort all elections in Punjab and Assam. 
 Not that that would stop the terrorists from acting pretty well as they pleased. 
 In large sections of Punjab they extort money (calling it taxation), hold courts, decree what local newspapers should print and even decide what dress schoolchildren should wear. 
 Hindus have long fled the rural parts of Punjab; now some Sikhs are joining the exodus, disgusted by terrorist excesses that led to 3,787 deaths last year and about 1,500 so far this year. 
 The militants are split between degrees of intransigence, which could make them vulnerable at the polls. 
 Some have called for a boycott of the elections, but most are likely to back the faction of the Akali Dal, the Sikh political party, led by a former police officer, Simranjit Singh Mann. 
 Mr Mann insists that Punjab must be a homeland for the Sikhs, brought into being by a UN-supervised plebiscite. 
 On some occasions, he suggests an autonomous Punjab loosely federated to India; on others he demands outright independence. 
 He wants to be friends with America because he thinks only American intervention will secure his aims (he offered in the Gulf war to send 200,000 Sikhs to fight on the American side). 
 Mr Mann's candidates will include some now in jail for terrorism. 
 They will almost certainly win. 
 If he comes to power, he will release most jailed Sikhs &mdash; so demoralising the police still further. 
 This may not seem the best way to promote democracy or the unity of India. 
 But there are cogent arguments for Mr Shekhar's &bquo;soft&equo; approach: negotiating with militants helps fragment their ranks; persuading them to take part in elections draws them into the constitutional process. 
 Indeed, Mr Mann fears being assassinated by extremist Sikhs who shelter across the border in Pakistan. 
 The most cynical argument, of course, for the soft approach is that if Mr Mann takes part in the election and triumphantly declares Punjab's independence, the federal government can sack him and resume rule from New Delhi. 
 But what of Assam, a state very different from Punjab? 
 The United Liberation Front of Assam is a Marxist outfit operating from the jungles of Myanmar (Burma), and wants an independent country for the Assamese people. 
 However, the Assamese are in a minority in several parts of the state, outnumbered by various tribes and by immigrants from Bangladesh (hence several bloody clashes between the ULFA and militant tribesmen). 
 So, however much terror it inspires, it is far from certain that the ULFA will control a majority of Assam's legislators. 
 Nonetheless, the ULFA has the support of a fair chunk of the population and, more important, is in cahoots with the Asom Gana Parishad, the regional Assamese party that ruled the state till it was sacked last year. 
 Indeed, information from sacked ministers and sympathisers in the police ensured that the ULFA's leaders all evaded the army crackdown that followed. 
 The ULFA may now simply oblige the Asom Gana Parishad to accept its nominees as candidates for election. 
 That may go against the grain for some AGP leaders, who entered politics as advocates of non-violence. 
 But their main aim is to rid Assam of &bquo;foreigners&equo;, by which they mean virtually all Bengalis, whether from Bangladesh or not. 
 In power, they found it legally difficult to identify and expel illegal immigrants, so many now think the ULFA has the more effective solution. 
 There are no easy solutions, effective or otherwise. 
 In Assam and Punjab, neither Mr Gandhi nor other national leaders have clear ideas on how to combat electoral sympathy for the terrorists. 
 Cracking down on terrorists can be a first step, but not the last.  
 Vietnam and America 
 Toehold in Hanoi 
 FROM OUR SOUTH-EAST ASIA CORRESPONDENT 
 THE Americans have agreed to open a temporary office in Hanoi. 
 When this was announced on April 20th they stressed that the office's sole purpose will be to investigate the fate of the 2,278 Americans still listed as missing in action in Indochina. 
 It will not be an embassy in disguise. 
 And yet the Vietnamese government is hoping. 
 Might this be the beginning of the end of America's trade embargo against Vietnam, a hint that diplomatic relations will be established between the two countries? 
 Not yet. 
 The important reason for the visit to Hanoi by a team under General John Vessey was to find out whether Vietnam will accept a number of conditions attached to normalisation of relations. 
 Vietnam's foreign minister, Nguyen Co Thach, hemmed and hawed and told reporters that he had &bquo;not yet accepted and not yet rejected&equo; the conditions. 
 To sceptical ears in Washington, this will sound like a diplomatic no. 
 The Vietnamese government says it is already meeting one condition: helping in the search for any American soldiers who may still be in the country. 
 It is American demands about Cambodia that it dislikes. 
 The Americans want Vietnam to press the regime in Cambodia to sign a peace treaty. 
 America's restrictions on its citizens visiting Vietnam would then be lifted. 
 America would start to ease its trade embargo when the UN arranges a Cambodian ceasefire; its veto on lending by the World Bank and the IMF would be relaxed once the ceasefire had lasted six months. 
 Diplomatic relations would have to await a freely elected government in Cambodia. 
 The American plan is designed to deflect criticism of the Bush administration's Indochina policy. 
 The American Congress is wary of helping the non-communist resistance in Cambodia, for fear of helping the fierce Khmers Rouges. 
 American companies are keen to scout out business opportunities in Vietnam. 
 European directors of the World Bank and IMF, some of whom want to help Vietnam make economic reforms, criticise the American veto. 
 Japan wants to get on with rebuilding Vietnam. 
 Vietnam, though, is unsure what to do. 
 It has declined to press its Cambodian friends to accept a UN peace plan that would involve disarming their army. 
 The resistance would have to be disarmed too, but documents said to have been captured from the Khmers Rouges give details of plans to hide their troops in the jungle. 
 However, pragmatists in Hanoi point out that the Vietnamese economy is near to collapse after the end of Soviet subsidies, and any step towards lifting the trade embargo must be taken, however humiliating. 
 Hanoi conservatives counter by pointing out that what the economy needs most &mdash; cash &mdash; will not come immediately, and not at all if the ceasefire breaks down. 
 The Vietnamese and their Cambodian friends say that any peace plan so far offered could easily be subverted by the Khmers Rouges. 
 Hun Sen, the prime minister of Cambodia, has withdrawn an earlier promise to allow the Khmers Rouges' leaders to stand in any election. 
 They must be punished before the peace process can begin, he now says. 
 This gives China an argument for continuing to supply the Khmers Rouges. 
 &bquo;Khmers Rouges don't listen to anyone; how to persuade them is a very big problem,&equo; Prince Norodom Sihanouk, the former king of Cambodia and one-time captive of the Khmers Rouges, told Taro Nakayama, Japan's foreign minister, this month. 
 Add this to the illness of Hun Sen, the only member of the Cambodian regime who appears willing to risk his future to give peace a chance, and Cambodian peace looks a long way off. 
 Normal relations between Vietnam and America must be just as far away.  
 Malaysia 
 PAS principles 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN KOTA BHARU 
 IS KELANTAN, the most conservative of Malaysia's 13 states, waking from its traditional torpor? 
 Last October the Kelantanese elected a state government dominated by the Parti Islam se-Malaysia (PAS), which opposes the country's ruling United Malays National Organisation (UMNO) and has promised to govern according to the principles of Islam. 
 In the following months Kelantan was swept by Gulf war fervour, of the anti-American variety. 
 New-born babies were named Saddam, as was a smart new restaurant in Kota Bharu, the state's capital. 
 The PAS government called for 17,000 volunteers to go to the aid of Iraq. 
 Poor organisation and a lack of cash ensured that none left before the war ended. 
 &bquo;I would have been very happy if as many volunteers as possible had gone,&equo; says Annuar Musa, the federal government's minister for youth and sport. 
 Mr Annuar is from Kelantan, which helps explain why, at the tender age of 34, he has the tricky task of preventing PAS from achieving its goals. 
 Much more rests on Mr Annuar's success than just his career. 
 UMNO, which has ruled Malaysia continuously since independence, was humiliated in October's elections. 
 It lost all 39 state-assembly seats and 13 national ones to PAS and its allies, the most important of which is Semangat '46, a breakaway group from UMNO. 
 Malay unity, according to UMNO doctrine, is the only way for Malays to regain control of an economy unfairly usurped, most Malays believe, by Chinese immigrants and their descendants. 
 But what PAS is attempting in Kelantan &mdash; rule by Islam &mdash; threatens Malay unity. 
 If it succeeds, Malays in other states may want more Islam, strengthening the religious hardliners within UMNO. 
 In a country where only 52% of the 16m people are Muslim, UMNO moderates recognise that religious zealotry could lead to communal tension and economic decline. 
 The leader of this threat is Nik Aziz Nik Mat, a humble-mannered man who was elected chief minister of Kelantan after a working life spent teaching in the mosque next to his birthplace. 
 So far he has proved to be no stern ayatollah. 
 Gambling has been banned but proposals to ensure Muslims do not drink have been relaxed, and the 5% of the state's population who are Chinese have been reassured that they will get their Tiger beer. 
 Pre-election talk about cutting off thieves' hands and stoning adulterers is no longer heard. 
 The government still intends to introduce Islam's sharia law, but only once the people have been &bquo;educated&equo;, a process expected to take at least three years. 
 UMNO's hope is that inexperience will be the chief minister's downfall. 
 &bquo;He has no inkling of what administration is about,&equo; says an UMNO senator. 
 With one exception, nor do any of the other PAS members of the state's executive council. 
 Meanwhile, UMNO is using the tactics that come with experience: Malaysia's prime minister, Dr Mahathir Mohamad, is ostracising the Kelantan chief minister and putting the squeeze on the state's budget, two-fifths of which comes from the federal government. 
 The constitution guarantees federal payments, but that does not mean they have to be made on time. 
 Already some state civil servants are receiving their salaries late. 
 Supplies of heavily-subsidised fertiliser were stopped immediately after the election and a federal development office was opened in Kota Bharu on March 1st. 
 &bquo;We want to make sure the people know where the money comes from,&equo; says Mr Annuar. 
 That does not mean that UMNO's tactics will work. 
 The Kelantanese are a perverse and parochial bunch &mdash; &bquo;like Yorkshiremen&equo;, says one foreign resident. 
 When they elected PAS, they knew that after 12 lavish years of UMNO rule, development spending might decrease. 
 But the Kelantanese put Allah and their sultan before cash. 
 It is Sultan Ismail Petra who probably holds the key to Kelantan's future. 
 He retains the influence, if not the constitutional power, of a feudal monarch, has little time for Dr Mahathir and is related by marriage to the leader of Semangat '46. 
 Keen to give the new government of his state a chance to work, he has politely rebuffed Mr Annuar.  
 Philippines 
 Danding's run 
 FROM OUR MANILA CORRESPONDENT 
 IN THE history of spectacular comebacks few people can rival Eduardo Cojuangco. 
 When Ferdinand Marcos fled to Hawaii in 1986 after being deposed as president of the Philippines, his close friend Mr Cojuangco went with him. 
 In November 1989 he decided it was safe to come home, arriving in a private aircraft on a remote airstrip. 
 Last week Mr Cojuangco came close to getting back on the board of San Miguel, the country's largest firm, which he once controlled. 
 Next year he may run for president. 
 Mr Cojuangco comes from one of the families that have long controlled business and political affairs in the Philippines, and to some extent still do. 
 The president, Corazon Aquino, is a cousin and no doubt would rather not be. 
 She regards the return of &bquo;Danding&equo;, his family nickname, with some alarm &mdash; understandably so, since Mr Cojuangco is an accomplished and defiantly wealthy player of politics. 
 Her government sequestered shares in San Miguel held by Mr Cojuangco and his two brothers. 
 On April 16th the Philippine Supreme Court decided that the three Cojuangcos could vote at a shareholders' meeting on April 19th, although the shares themselves remain sequestered. 
 The meeting was adjourned to allow the government time to appeal against the Supreme Court decision. 
 If there is no appeal or if it is rejected, Mr Cojuangco is expected to be voted back to the board. 
 He has other litigation pending which, if successful, could give his supporters a majority of seats on the board. 
 It is assumed that Mr Cojuangco would then become chairman of San Miguel, as he was in the Marcos days. 
 Shares in some 30 other companies have been sequestered and put in the control of the Presidential Commission on Good Government, the body set up by Mrs Aquino to untangle the financial affairs of the Marcos era. 
 The Supreme Court decision, if it sticks, will be a severe setback to the commission's work. 
 It is assumed that holders of other sequestered shares will now try to regain their voting rights. 
 The intricacies of financial litigation are, however, of less interest to the man in the Manila street than the renaissance of Danding Cojuangco. 
 He is still barred from many corporate towers from which he ran his empire. 
 But he has told former executives to extract themselves from jobs they managed to find in the Aquino era and hold themselves ready. 
 He is probably rich enough, with or without San Miguel, to make a serious bid for the presidency. 
 He is the first of the so-called Marcos cronies to have stood up to the Presidential Commission on Good Government, and as a result is seen as a man of action. 
 However, he will not run for office if he thinks he could lose. 
 He will instead seek to be a kingmaker. 
 There are already about a dozen people with presidential ambitions. 
 The vice-president, Salvador Laurel, would love to take over from Mrs Aquino, with whom he fell out soon after taking office. 
 Fidel Ramos, a former army chief and now defence secretary, could point out to voters that he had loyally defended the president in the numerous coup attempts against her. 
 Juan Ponce Enrile believes he is in with a chance, despite being charged last year with rebellion in connection with an attempted coup. 
 Oscar Orbos has done well as Mrs Aquino's aide, but at 40 may be too young for the big job. 
 Ramon Mitra has proved to be a competent Speaker in the House of Representatives. 
 And so on. 
 There are no women contenders, unless Imelda Marcos is included: she would be eligible if the government allowed her to return from the United States, and if she survived any legal moves against her. 
 Mrs Aquino seems prohibited by the constitution from standing again. 
 But her endorsement should count for a lot. 
 Quite a few people want to be her friend. 
 INTERNATIONAL 
 Brazil's frontier justice 
 FROM OUR BRAZIL CORRESPONDENT 
 RIO DE JANEIRO 
 THERE were several witnesses to the drunken knife-fight in which a factory worker, Jose Vicente Anunciacao, murdered another worker in the north-eastern Brazilian city of Salvador. 
 That was in mid-April. 
 The witnesses did not get a chance to give evidence against the killer in court. 
 Some 40 of the victim's friends dragged Anunciacao from his bed the night after the crime and bludgeoned him to death with bricks and clubs. 
 That same evening, in a town not far from Salvador, police repelled an assault on the local jail by a mob of 300 people who were planning summary justice for a prisoner accused of raping and murdering an 11-year-old girl. 
 Police in Salvador noted that in their city, on average, there has been a mob lynching every three days for the last three years. 
 Brazil, with its 150m people, is a very large country with astonishingly few national institutions that work properly. 
 The inertia of the justice system (which in some places barely exists) is notorious. 
 In Rio de Janeiro, for example, a clerks' strike recently paralysed the courts for three months. 
 Justice in Rio is normally so slow that the effect on law enforcement is almost negligible. 
 The justice minister, Jarbas Passarinho, acknowledges the surge of bloody crime and popular vengeance in Brazil. 
 The minister says he feels humiliated by the lynchings, which he attributes to the &bquo;absence of government&equo; in many areas. 
 Sometimes aggrieved and frustrated citizens take matters into their own hands. 
 Sometimes there is more than that to a lynching, as the work of Lino Jose Durrewald showed. 
 He is an amateur photographer, living in a bare-knuckles gold-mining boom town called Matupa on the southern rim of the Amazon basin. 
 He had a video camera on his shoulder last November, when a mob doused three thieves with petrol and looked on as they burned. 
 &bquo;Who has a revolver here? 
 He's suffered enough,&equo; says a voice on the tape. 
 The victim's voice pleads: &bquo;Let me die, please&hellip;&equo; 
 Mr Durrewald was so terrified by what he had recorded that he did not circulate his tape until the federal authorities had agreed to protect him. 
 Federal investigators concluded that the thieves (they were caught in the act) had been shot with revolvers on the order of a local police captain who then, with the help of a town official, instigated the lynching to mask the shooting. 
 One suspect, having survived the shooting, was burned alive. 
 This kind of police misbehaviour encourages many Brazilians to believe that the only way they can deal with crime is to fight fire, so to speak, with fire. 
 Some criminals seem to share that conviction. 
 In early April two young farm labourers, Valdecir Ferreira and Altair Gomes, narrowly escaped death when a mob 1,500-strong stormed and set fire to the prison where they were being held for the gory knife murder of a taxi-driver, in the state of Parana. 
 The police managed on this occasion to whisk the two away to a more distant jail. 
 Next day a newspaper reporter asked the young men if they thought it would have been fair for the crowd to kill them. 
 &bquo;In a way no, in a way yes,&equo; Mr Ferreira philosophised. 
 &bquo;When I saw death coming towards me I began to think it had been a bad business for me to kill that guy.&equo;  
 Canada 
 All change 
 FROM OUR CANADA CORRESPONDENT 
 OTTAWA 
 TEN months ago he suffered a heavy setback in constitutional reform. 
 He then watched separatist parties advance on him from both eastern and western Canada. 
 Now the prime minister, Brian Mulroney, has regrouped for a counter-attack. 
 The most significant move in his cabinet reshuffle on April 21st was to shift Joe Clark from external affairs, where he had been nimble and sensible, to be the minister responsible for constitutional affairs &mdash; that is, in charge of saving Canadian unity. 
 First, Mr Clark must roll back Preston Manning's Reform Party, which has spread rapidly through western Canada from its base in Mr Clark's native province of Alberta. 
 The job is to purge the good-riddance-to-Quebec attitude among Reform Party supporters, and to get backing in the western provinces for a further set of constitutional changes, incorporating Quebec's insistent claim to be recognised as a distinct society. 
 Then the government must offer the French-speaking Quebeckers an alternative to their demands for political sovereignty, which have grown in volume (if not in clarity) during the past winter. 
 In effect, Mr Mulroney is asking the man he supplanted as Conservative prime minister to complete the job which, after last year's fiasco about the Meech Lake constitutional reform package, he himself has no longer the credibility to perform. 
 Shifting Mr Clark prompted two dozen other moves. 
 Most observers expect Barbara McDougall to be impressive at External Affairs, after her apprenticeship with the immigration portfolio and as a junior finance minister. 
 The deputy prime minister, Don Mazankowski, will make a more jovial finance minister in the run-up to the next election than Michael Wilson, whose demotion &mdash; to a handful of trade and industry posts &mdash; has been covered with talk of the undoubted need for Canada to become more competitive in a free-trade area that may soon include Mexico. 
 Mr Mulroney has balanced Canada's regions in his cabinet, providing significant seats (defence, health and welfare, environment) for his colleagues from Quebec, while pushing forward the Albertans, Messrs Clark, Mazankowski and the leader of the House of Commons, Harvie Andre. 
 The prime minister's critics say all this is happening too late; that he should have regrouped last autumn, and that the Canadian Titanic may founder even while the ministers switch deckchairs. 
 But there are signs that the prime minister has got his timing right and is setting a shrewd course. 
 An opinion poll for the Globe and Mail and the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation produced surprising results from Quebec: while most people there strongly demand change, only 10% want full independence and 52% wish their province to remain within Canada. 
 The winter of commissions that promoted or predicted a sovereign Quebec has faded. 
 Springtime has also brought the federal Liberal leader, Jean Chr&eacute;tien, out with a nine-point plan that mixes the acceptable parts of the Meech Lake package with a promise of native self-government and other elements to attract western Canadians. 
 Mr Clark and Mr Chr&eacute;tien may indeed contrive to rebuild national unity on a new set of compromises.  
 The West Indies 
 Getting together 
 FIVE million West Indians are proud to share a cricket team. 
 But when it comes to ruling themselves, they maintain 13 separate governments (while Britain still runs five tiny territories as colonies). 
 An English-speaking population half the size of Cuba's is scattered over 2,000 miles, from the Bahamas in the Atlantic to Guyana on the American mainland &mdash; more still, if you go by way of Belize &mdash; complete with more than a dozen governors-general, parliaments, prime ministers, judiciaries and bureaucracies. 
 West Indians belong to a single post-colonial culture; mainly black, emphatically multiracial, with politics that are on the whole admirably democratic (the big exception, Guyana, has the worst economy too). 
 Fragmentation makes no sense. 
 Miniature governments are expensive to run, and ineffective in promoting their people's interests in the face of an indifferent world. 
 The West Indians could sell tourism, or promote local interests (in sugar, bananas, bauxite and so on) far better together than apart. 
 The schemes of their economic alliance, Caricom, rarely come to much, because its members buy little from each other, and compete in selling to the outside world. 
 After a quarter of a century of divided independence, some West Indian rulers are tired of the insignificance to which miniaturisation condemns them. 
 From the rest of the Americas they hear talk of regional alliances and free trade. 
 Four microstates in the Eastern Caribbean &mdash; Dominica, Grenada, St Lucia and St Vincent &mdash; are summoning a constituent assembly to talk about merging their sovereignty. 
 Caricom is pointing cautiously the same way. 
 Its leaders have set up a West Indian Commission under the chairmanship of Sir Shridath Ramphal, a former secretary-general of the Commonwealth. 
 The commissioners are doing what West Indians are best at, and talking to everybody imaginable &mdash; including their exile communities in Britain, Canada and the United States &mdash; about whether, and if so how, to work more closely together. 
 They are old enough to remember the early days of independence, when the departing British pushed them towards a pan-Caribbean federation of English-speakers; but the people of Jamaica, the largest potential member (with 2.5m people now), killed that by voting against it in a referendum. 
 Things have moved on since then. 
 Even in the tiniest countries, distinctive political habits &mdash; not to mention distinct political dynasties &mdash; have evolved. 
 The English-speakers have noticed that five times as many people in the Caribbean share many of their preoccupations, but speak other languages. 
 The West Indian Commission's report (like practically everything in the Americas) should be ready for the Columbus quincentenary parties in 1992. 
 It is unlikely to recommend any dramatic merging of its members' sovereignty. 
 But there is a lot of useful co-operation to be done short of that.  
 Cuba checks out 
 THE Cubans have pulled out of what used to be the People's Republic of the Congo, and is now just the Congo Republic. 
 In July the last 17,000 Cuban soldiers will leave Angola. 
 That will be the end of Fidel Castro's military adventures in Africa. 
 A paralysed economy at home, and the substitution of pragmatism for ideology by most Africans, has left his international brigades without a role, having lost (by their own admission) more than 2,000 dead. 
 The graveside eulogy could be: they came, they suffered, and then they went home. 
 Soon after he took Havana, in 1960, Mr Castro began stressing Cuba's African cultural heritage, and packed off soldiers to fight there in the name of international socialism. 
 As early as 1963 Cubans were helping Algeria in a border conflict with Morocco. 
 Che Guevara, before his demise in a South American jungle, led an ineffectual campaign against the  secessionist  Moise Tshomb&eacute;, in what is now Zaire. 
 At the start of the 1970s, before the Russians sent fighting men to Africa and with the Americans stuck in Vietnam, Cuba was exporting revolution. 
 Soon its international pioneers mustered 50,000 troops, from Ethiopia to Guinea-Bissau, supporting such dubious revolutionaries as Idi Amin in Uganda. 
 Then came Angola's civil war, which began before the Portuguese colonists left in 1975. 
 The Americans backed one faction, the South Africans crept in behind another. 
 The new Marxist government was saved only by a Cuban expeditionary force of at least 20,000 men, with logistical back-up from the Soviet Union. 
 Now the South Africans have gone from Angola, and its government is reforming in ways that quite please the Americans. 
 Cuba's role is over. 
 It is not only Africa's Marxists who thank the Cubans. 
 Along the coast of Angola's Cabinda enclave, and of the Congo to the north of it, lies a rich oilfield. 
 Western oil companies exploit it: Cuban troops have defended their interests. 
 That was not what international socialism was for. 
 Nor did socialist theory predict the fate of Cuba's commander in Angola, General Arnaldo Ochoa Sanchez. 
 In 1989 he confessed at a show trial to trafficking in gold and ivory, and was shot. 
 He was probably not guilty.  
 West Africa 
 Drumroll 
 FROM OUR WEST AFRICA CORRESPONDENT 
 TIME, weariness and creditors are pushing out West Africa's old dictators. 
 As they go, one of their justifications for behaving dictatorially is starting to look strong. 
 They tried to build nations; as they depart, so does the idea of nationhood. 
 War, repression and increasing poverty have driven ethnic groups in upon themselves. 
 As pluralism creeps in, so does tribal tension. 
 This is especially dangerous in a region where political frontiers, arbitrarily drawn by old colonial powers, divide the tribes. 
 After days of fighting between the army and the people in Togo, where President Gnassingb&eacute; Eyad&eacute;ma has ruled for 24 years, a truce was agreed in mid-April. 
 The president made the agreement with the traditional chiefs of the B&eacute; district of the capital, Lom&eacute;, the leaders of the local Ewe people. 
 They had never liked Mr Eyad&eacute;ma, who belongs to the Kabye people, because he filled the top army posts with his fellow-Kabyes. 
 So, when Kabye soldiers shot 26 anti-government Ewes, the Ewe chiefs of Lom&eacute; called their people to the sacred grove of B&eacute;, to mourn the dead and plan revenge. 
 The president, knowing that this foretold more terrible violence, asked the chiefs to call off the protest, thereby depriving his army of a further excuse for slaughter. 
 The streets fell quiet. 
 Mr Eyad&eacute;ma, on national radio, pleaded for an end to &bquo;the conflict of this tribal nature&hellip;&equo;. 
 It sounded more like a truce than the end of the conflict. 
 When the Ewe of B&eacute; called for guns, the Kabye said they would find guns too. 
 Most of the Kabye living in Lom&eacute; had been rounded up for protection by the army, saying their houses had been ransacked by the Ewes. 
 Mr Eyad&eacute;ma cannot long hold on to power. 
 When he goes, the Ewes may want to redress the balance. 
 The consequences could spread across the border. 
 Back in 1986 the president accused the Ewes of mounting a failed coup against him, claiming that the plot involved Ghana's leader, Flight-Lieutenant Jerry Rawlings; Mr Rawlings is an Ewe on his mother's side (his father was Scottish). 
 The tribe was divided in 1957, after the British and French dismantled their empires in Africa. 
 The division has poisoned the neighbouring countries' relations &mdash; further complicated because the official language of Ghana is English, that of Togo French. 
 In Liberia, too, tribal rivalries envenom the bitter civil war. 
 Neighbouring countries' governments have intervened in favour of their own people. 
 The French-speaking governments of Burkina Faso and C&ocirc;te d'Ivoire have backed the rebels, while English-speaking West African governments have sent troops to prevent the rebels taking power. 
 Other ancient fears are emerging, as West Africa moves out of dictatorship towards something else. 
 In March Benin held its first multi-party presidential contest, amid north-south rivalries similar to those in neighbouring Togo. 
 The day after he took office, the newly elected president, Nic&eacute;phore Soglo, was rushed to hospital in Paris. 
 In Benin, many people thought they knew what had happened. 
 The defeated dictator, Mathieu K&eacute;r&eacute;kou, with the power of a once-great chief, had willed his rival's sickness by sorcery.  
 Elderly scraps of paper 
 FROM OUR ISLAM CORRESPONDENT 
 TWICE before the Kurds have been offered generous deals by Iraq's Baathist government &mdash; only to find them snatched away. 
 It was not just the Iraqis' perfidy that did them down. 
 In March 1970 Saddam Hussein (the Iraqi regime's strong man, but not yet president) negotiated a deal with the late Mullah Mustafa Barzani that stated: &bquo;The people of Iraq are made up of two principal nationalities, the Arab nationality and the Kurdish nationality.&equo; 
 The deal stipulated that Kurdish, along with Arabic, should be a national language. 
 A Kurdish autonomous area would be established after four years; a Kurd appointed vice-president of Iraq; only Kurdish-speaking officials should serve in the region. 
 Mutual suspicion killed this agreement. 
 Soon after signing it Barzani said, &bquo;It is all a ruse. 
 I knew it before I even signed.&equo; 
 A year later a dramatic attempt to assassinate him left a smoke-trail leading back to Mr Hussein. 
 In 1973 Barzani repudiated his signature. 
 The Iraqis' suspicions of his links with Iran, Israel and America (he was on the CIA's payroll) were reinforced when, that year, he said: &bquo;If support were strong enough we could control the Kirkuk oilfield and give it to an American company to operate&equo;. 
 In 1974 the Iraqis came up with a detailed law for the autonomous area that was far more restrictive than the 1970 agreement and in no way reflected its accommodating spirit. 
 It provided for Kurdish legislative and executive councils, but real power was retained by the central government in Baghdad. 
 Within weeks, fighting broke out. 
 Talks were resumed in 1984 between Saddam Hussein and one of the Kurdish factions, represented by Jalal Talabani. 
 Because of the pressures of the Iran-Iraq war, then in its fourth year, the Kurds won concessions that went beyond the 1970 agreement. 
 The autonomy of the Kurdish zone was to be strengthened, in an area expanded to include Kirkuk; there were to be new and free elections to Kurdish councils; the Kurds, having asked for a fair share of oil revenue, would be allotted 25&ndash;30% of the total Iraqi budget. 
 Whether this deal had a more serious chance than the 1970 one of being put into force cannot be known. 
 Both sides, but particularly the Iraqis, wanted to gain time. 
 The break came when Turkey's foreign minister arrived in Baghdad to assert that the Kurdish autonomous area with the proposed expanded powers was too autonomous for Turkey's liking, and that the agreement, at that point awaiting signature, should not be implemented. 
 Dependent on the pipeline through Turkey for its oil exports, Iraq complied with its big neighbour's wish and dropped the Kurdish deal. 
 It also, the same year, granted Turkey the right of hot pursuit of dissident Turkish Kurds across the frontier. 
 Fighting between Kurds and Iraqi troops was resumed until, in 1988&ndash;89, the insurrection was savagely put down.  
 Iraq's Shias 
 God helps, so does Iran 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT 
 KHORRAMSHAHR 
 WHEN darkness falls, Kalashnikov-toting Iraqi Shia fighters slip home across the border from safe havens in Iran. 
 In groups of 10 to 30 men, on foot or in jeeps, they cross the barren plain between the frontier and the Tigris, to the Shia cities and the settlements around them. 
 At night, gunfire echoes across the Shatt al-Arab. 
 By day, plumes of black smoke rise from the Iraqi side. 
 Iraq's defeat in Kuwait inflamed the Shias of southern Iraq. 
 By mid-March, their uprising had been brutally put down by Saddam Hussein's Republican Guard. 
 But resistance continued. 
 Iraqi mujaheddin are fighting a guerrilla campaign that appears to be growing in scope and intensity. 
 From Iranian territory the rebels' radio station, &bquo;The Voice of Revolutionary Iraq&equo;, claimed that the guerrillas had killed 400 Iraqi soldiers in Basra during the night of April 22nd. 
 The mujaheddin aim to weaken the Iraqi regime by attacking its defeated and demoralised forces. 
 Some seek revenge for atrocities committed in suppressing the Shia uprising. 
 Most of the fighters follow the Iraqi Shia leader, Ayatollah Mohammed Baqr al-Hakim, who heads the coalition called the Supreme Assembly for the Islamic Revolution in Iraq. 
 The Iraqi government has accused Iran of arming the mujaheddin and sending Iranian Revolutionary Guards, disguised as Iraqis, across the frontier to fight. 
 The Iranians deny that, but in practice provide safe havens and allow the mujaheddin to come and go. 
 A stone's throw from the Iraqi border post to the west of Khorramshahr, a senior officer of Iran's Revolutionary Guard vigorously denied that his men, who swarmed around the area, were involved in what he called Iraq's &bquo;Islamic revolution&equo; &mdash; which, he said, would one day (&bquo;God willing&equo;) succeed. 
 As he spoke, a jeep sped past carrying boxes of ammunition and explosives, and ten Iraqi mujaheddin with Islamic slogans on their headbands. 
 In the fruit bazaar in Khorramshahr, an Iraqi Shia claimed that he had fought in Basra the previous night. 
 He said the Iranians were giving their fellow Shias plenty of support, including weapons and transport. 
 The flow of Shia refugees from Iraq into southern Iran, which peaked in mid-March, has slowed but not ceased. 
 Hundreds still cross the frontier each day, mainly well away from the main frontier posts controlled by Iraqi troops. 
 A Swedish Red Cross official, whose team is building a field hospital for refugees near Khorramshahr, reckoned that 30,000&ndash;40,000 Iraqis had passed through the town since early March. 
 He said similar numbers had crossed farther north at Bostan and Mehran, and thousands more at minor crossing points along the rugged frontier. 
 His estimate that 150,000 Iraqi Shias had sought refuge in Iran is exactly three times the figure given by the Iranian interior minister (although the Iranians have no obvious reason to underestimate the number of refugees). 
 The first arrivals came with cattle, chickens, cars and trucks. 
 Those who came later, more hurriedly, often arrived on foot with only their clothes. 
 But the refugees' horror stories have not changed. 
 They tell of women murdered by Iraqi soldiers, because husbands or sons had joined the rebellion; of heavy shelling of residential areas; of summary executions of anybody suspected of aiding the rebels; of bodies left lying in the streets. 
 Iranians, and the Iraqis whom they protect, make huge claims: 500,000 Iraqi Shias slaughtered, and 800,000 hiding in the marshes of southern Iraq &mdash; in addition to those who have sought safety in Iran, or in the buffer zone along the Kuwaiti border. 
 Be that as it may, terrible things clearly happened. 
 Those who have left their homes are short of food and at risk from foul water. 
 The summer heat is coming on. 
 Yet they are too fearful of reprisals to go home. 
 Even if they do, with water-pipes and power-lines destroyed, conditions there are almost as bad. 
 &bquo;All the assistance will go to Baghdad and the Sunnis,&equo; said a Shia refugee. 
 &bquo;It is another punishment for our rebellion.&equo; 
 Those Shias who escaped into southern Iran are housed in transit camps around Khorramshahr and the other main points of entry (see map on previous page). 
 Between Khorramshahr and the Iraqi border, transit camps have been pitched by the Iranian Red Crescent near the battlefield of Shalamcheh, where tens of thousands of Iranians and Iraqis died in the eight-year war between their countries. 
 Iraqi children play beside the minefields, their deadly contents peeping from the khaki earth. 
 The hideous transit camps are emptying. 
 From one in Khorramshahr, 800 refugees have gone to a better, cooler site near Dezful, 200 km (120 miles) north. 
 But many Iraqis fend for themselves. 
 People in a bombed-out residential quarter by the Karun river say it is better than living under canvas, although the nearest tap is 500 metres away. 
 After two and a half months, very little outside aid has reached the refugees in southern Iran. 
 Most support comes from the Iranian Red Crescent, with donations of food and clothing from private individuals. 
 Aid officials agree that conditions are far better than for the wretched Kurds stuck on the freezing mountains. 
 But in July and August the temperature in the south will soar into the hundreds. 
 Disease is inevitable. 
 Ayatollah al-Hakim has criticised the Arab world for ignoring the &bquo;bloodbath&equo; in the Shia south. 
 His political group fears that, by making a deal with the Iraqis, the Kurdish leaders may be letting down their comrades. 
 The Shia movement stands by the agreement made last December in Damascus, when all Iraqi opposition groups made Mr Hussein's overthrow their aim. 
 &bquo;We could never open talks with such a barbarous regime,&equo; its spokesmen say.  
 Liberated ways 
 THE Kuwaitis are probably still rich enough not to care too much what others think of them, even the Americans. 
 Yet on April 22nd James Baker, the secretary of state, broke his Arab-Israeli peace-seeking odyssey for a side-trip to Kuwait, where he had stern if diplomatic words with the emir and the crown prince. 
 He was apparently speaking for George Bush, who had been upset both by the tales of torture in an Amnesty report and by the inadequacy of the Kuwaiti government changes. 
 Sheikh Saad, the crown prince and prime minister, admitted that there had been abuse of human rights in the early days of the country's liberation but implied that, with the regime back in control, all was well. 
 This is not what Amnesty says. 
 Its report, published on April 19th, speaks of hundreds of people, most of them Palestinian, arbitrarily arrested, many tortured and &bquo;scores&equo; of people killed by the Kuwaiti armed forces and members of the resistance. 
 &bquo;These violations are continuing and appear to be largely unchecked,&equo; it says. 
 War-crime trials are due to start soon. 
 The fear is that, even if the random atrocities stop, prisoners will be found guilty on the basis of torture-induced confessions, and executed. 
 The new government brought in to replace the one that resigned a month ago turns out to be little more than a royal-family reshuffle. 
 Only five members of the Sabah family are now in the cabinet, instead of seven, but the family (especially the crown prince's branch) retains the top jobs: prime minister, foreign affairs, defence and interior. 
 The opposition, a diverse and mostly respectable group of people who have been clamouring for a bit of say in the new Kuwait, did not get even a token position. 
 An election is promised some time next year, but critics are alarmed by the appointment of Sheikh Salem as deputy prime minister and foreign minister; in his old job as interior minister, Sheikh Salem had no time for the regime's opponents. 
 As a bad sign of liberated times, the opposition tried to call a press conference on the morning of Mr Baker's arrival, only to find it did not have official permission to do so.  
 Epidemics 
 The time of cholera 
 THE sickness will not go away. 
 Cholera, brewed in the foulness where sewage runs into the drinking water, is an ever-present menace to the poor of Africa and South Asia. 
 In refugee camps, and where sanitation has been smashed by war (as in Baghdad and Basra) it is the aid-workers' nightmare. 
 The disease has now reinvaded the American tropics, whence it had been absent since migration from Asia was cut off by the world upheavals of 1914&ndash;18. 
 Peru is the first victim. 
 Nobody yet knows who took the disease there. 
 How it spreads is all too obvious, in the filthy shanty-towns to which poor and ignorant countryfolk are driven by misgovernment and terrorism. 
 One of the few luxuries within their reach is ceviche, a delicious mess of chopped raw fish with onions and lemon; since fish feed near sewers, and are caught by people who wash (if at all) in sewer-water, they are perfect for spreading infection. 
 As the cholera panic spread, Peru's normally sensible president, Alberto Fujimori, sought to calm it by eating (with his cabinet ministers) a dish of ceviche, on television. 
 The panic died down, the fish-vendors' business picked up, the cabinet survived &mdash; but thousands whose fish was less fresh began to suffer the cholera pangs; explosive diarrhoea and rapid dehydration, which can lead to rapid death. 
 The result was disastrous for Peru's economy too. 
 Neighbouring countries closed their borders, both to travellers and to goods that might carry the infection &mdash; particularly fish, Peru's speciality. 
 But the cholera has spread into Ecuador, where tens of thousands of people live in shanty-towns without clean water. 
 Worse, it was carried across the Andes into Peru's provinces on the upper Amazon, whence it is inexorably moving downstream into Brazil &mdash; much richer than Peru, but with even worse social services. 
 Peru's hospitals and clinics, short of medicines and everything else, managed to defend the people against the worst ravages of the disease. 
 In past epidemics, the doctors reckoned that one in ten of those infected would die. 
 In Peru, some 140,000 people have been treated, and more than 1,000 have died. 
 It is very bad. 
 It could have been much worse. 
 Last December a similar outbreak of cholera struck Zambia &mdash; another nation crippled by misgovernment and low copper prices. 
 The number of cases is not recorded; the number of deaths is officially put at 855, and may have been much higher, since diarrhoea is so common there that it often goes unreported. 
 The authorities closed most schools and institutions, and ran a hygiene campaign on radio and television. 
 Overseas aid came in from many quarters (including South Africa); the landlocked Zambians brought in health officials from all their neighbours to try to limit the spread of the disease, which nevertheless struck Malawi. 
 The worst is over: of 130 nursing centres opened in Zambia at the height of the epidemic, the authorities have now closed 80. 
 Only about 100 patients remain in care. 
 Given reasonable precautions and a small amount of money, cholera can be effectively fought. 
 New and simple techniques of rehydration make most deaths &mdash; except of the very young and old &mdash; preventable. 
 The onset of infection should be preventable too. 
 All you need is a clean water-supply and an efficient way of getting rid of human excrement. 
 Investment is better than cure. 
 In Bangladesh, where cholera broke out a month ago and may already have infected 30,000 people, they know that perfectly well. 
 They just can't afford it.  
 When Saddam smiles, make sure you count his teeth 
 THAT self-preserver extraordinary, Saddam Hussein, has once again shown that he knows when and how to cut his losses. 
 This has made him a rather accommodating man for his ex-enemies to deal with. 
 The rub is the general conviction, based on the man's record, that the same pragmatism, unencumbered by ideology or ethics, that leads him to sign an agreement one day will lead him to renege or cheat on it the next. 
 Having survived the war, Mr Hussein is riding the post-war humiliations. 
 His wounded country needs time and international tolerance to recover and, accepting the inevitable, he is buying time with a series of compromises. 
 The main surprise is his agreement, in principle, that Iraq's 3&ndash;5m Kurds should have their own autonomous region. 
 But there are other signs, or apparent signs, of reasonableness. 
 Though he denounced the American-led initiative to establish protected enclaves in the north as an infringement of Iraq's sovereignty, he did not intervene as western soldiers got on with what is indeed a mighty infringement. 
 He has signed an agreement that allows the United Nations to set up and administer humanitarian centres all over his country. 
 He objected strenuously to the terms of the ceasefire resolution passed by the UN Security Council on April 3rd; but he accepted it (as indeed he had to) and is obeying its terms, more or less. 
 His regime met the deadline, imposed by the Security Council, to provide a list of its most dangerous arms, including its chemical weapons and ballistic missiles. 
 The next stage is for the UN secretary-general on May 18th to say how he proposes to set up a commission that will, in the 45 days after that, develop a plan for inspecting and destroying these weapons. 
 The inspection, when it comes about, could be a first test of Mr Hussein's new smiling face: he is already suspected of cheating, particularly when he denies that he has any biological weapons. 
 The big switch came on April 24th. 
 Meeting in Baghdad, Mr Hussein and the Kurdish leaders, all smiles and hugs, agreed on self-rule for the Kurds &mdash; and, less plausibly, on democracy for all Iraq. 
 The tragedy of the mass exodus of Kurds from their towns and villages was caused more by the panic-struck memory of not-long-ago horror than by fresh savagery. 
 Now Mr Hussein has offered the Kurds the autonomy they had been prepared to fight and die for. 
 This is vintage Saddam: over the past 21 years he has swung between killing Iraqi Kurds and offering them more self-rule than the Kurds in Turkey, Iran or Syria can dream of. 
 The history of earlier agreements, with some of the reasons why they collapsed, is summarised on the next page. 
 The precedents &mdash; dark deeds, distrust, broken faith &mdash; are not good. 
 But the negotiators, led by the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan's Jalal Talabani and including the nephew of Masoud Barzani, the leader of the Kurdish Democratic Party, claimed that this time it could all be different. 
 Their personal safety was guaranteed by an old-fashioned exchange of hostages: senior Iraqis travelled to Arbil to put themselves in Kurdish hands &mdash; taking a risk, given Mr Hussein's record in disposing of unwanted colleagues. 
 The new agreement's principles &mdash; there are no details yet &mdash; are based on old deals that came to nothing. 
 The negotiators say there should be an autonomous region for the Kurds in northern Iraq, based on an abortive plan made in 1970, but including the oil city of Kirkuk (oil revenues to be shared). 
 This is what most of Iraq's Kurds wanted, and until now have been denied. 
 For good measure, and to show the regime's non-Kurdish opponents that they are not trading democracy for autonomy, the Kurds asked for free elections throughout the country. 
 Mr Hussein seems ready, at this stage, to go along with the principle of democracy. 
 The talks will be resumed after Mr Hussein's birthday on April 28th. 
 The best hope of an autonomy deal surviving &mdash; forget about democracy &mdash; is the bleakness of the alternative facing Mr Hussein: an ambivalent slab of northern territory run for an indefinite period by foreign armies, and therefore largely outside Iraqi control. 
 A big American contingent, with growing help from British, French and other troops, is establishing a protected Kurdish enclave in the north-west corner of Iraq; the area, at present about 1,500 square miles (nearly 4,000 square km), may be extended. 
 The first &bquo;tent cities&equo; for a few thousand people have been set up in the plain near Zakho. 
 But the 700,000 refugees perched on either the Iraqi or the Turkish side of the mountain frontier are slow to be tempted down. 
 Dependent on relief helicoptered to them by the American armed forces, the mountain refugees are still losing their young and their old to malnutrition, cold and disease. 
 Before descending to a potential lowland trap they want their long-term safety to be assured. 
 The Americans talk optimistically of a 60&ndash;90 day stint before handing over to notional, yet-to-be-sponsored, UN peacekeepers. 
 Adding to the refugees' fears were hundreds of Iraqi special police, sauntering peacefully through Zakho with their automatic rifles. 
 The Americans had demanded that the Iraqi army be withdrawn from the area. 
 Mr Hussein quickly complied, but sent the police instead &mdash; no doubt to signify his continuing sovereignty, as Iraqi policemen do in the buffer strip along the Kuwait border. 
 The allies, though, insist that the Kurds must not only be safe but be made to feel safe, which means no armed police; British commandos were sent to see them off. 
 The Turks, no longer under pressure to take the refugees in, question why the Kurds are being coaxed into half-way camps, rather than taken directly all the way to their own abandoned front doors. 
 Some of their old fears of a Kurdish entity in Iraq faded when they were contemplating only a &bquo;protected&equo; enclave, taking in Kurdish towns and villages, and turning to Turkey for succour. 
 &bquo;When I look I don't see a Kurdish state,&equo; said Turkey's ambassador to Iraq, &bquo;just 400,000 miserable people.&equo; 
 Iraq's rulers hope that an autonomy deal will undercut all plans for enclaves, large or small, within their borders. 
 The agreement guarantees Kurds their safe return &mdash; but who is to be the guarantor of their long-term safety and freedom? 
 EUROPE 
 Unwanted guests 
 FROM OUR BONN CORRESPONDENT 
 FROM the way Soviet soldiers sometimes carry on, you would think they had not heard there had been a change in Germany. 
 In several incidents in the eastern part of Germany over the past two months the Russians have continued to act like occupiers &mdash; and drawn only mild reproof from the German government. 
 On April 19th a Soviet sentry shot and wounded a German major who was driving away after peeking through his binoculars at a Soviet ammunition depot. 
 A similar incident had occurred at the same spot ten days earlier, though nobody was hurt then. 
 The Germans reckon it wise to keep tabs on the 350,000 or so Russian troops still in the east &mdash; guests, as it were &mdash; until the end of 1994, when the last one is due to have gone home. 
 They also believe that they have the right to snoop and that the shootings violate the German-Soviet treaty signed last year. 
 Yet the German foreign ministry has merely tut-tutted and the defence minister, Gerhard Stoltenberg, has called off the peeking, at least for the moment. 
 A month earlier the government was startled to learn that the Soviet defence minister, Marshal Dmitri Yazov, had turned up to inspect his troops in the east without telling the Germans. 
 A protocol slip-up, muttered the men from the German foreign ministry. 
 They made a bit more fuss soon afterwards when Erich Honecker, the former East German leader, was whisked out of a Soviet military hospital in the east and flown to Moscow, beyond the reach of German prosecutors. 
 The Russians agreed they were legally at fault. 
 But they have not handed Mr Honecker back. 
 He is now at Krasnoyarsk, near Moscow, because officials in the capital told him to move on. 
 Chancellor Helmut Kohl evidently wants to avoid making still more trouble for Mr Gorbachev, whom many Soviet officers and Communist hard-liners blame for &bquo;losing&equo; East Germany. 
 But the main reason for Germany's mild reaction is that relations between Germans in the east and Russian troops there are already so tense. 
 Russen raus (&bquo;Russians out!&equo;) has been daubed on barrack walls, Russians have been barred from local shops, some even roughed up. 
 A public fuss about sovereignty, the government reckons, might inflame feelings even more and touch off really ugly incidents, maybe bloodshed, in an area already smarting from the harsher side of unity, collapsing firms and soaring unemployment. 
 Hence the resolve in Bonn, so far, to keep quiet and hope the last Soviet soldier goes home before the end of 1994.  
 France 
 Rocko and his bothers 
 FROM OUR PARIS CORRESPONDENT 
 MICHEL ROCARD, the French prime minister, is in trouble. 
 Until now he has managed to push bills through the National Assembly, even though his Socialists are in a minority there, by making little deals with the conservatives or with the Communists. 
 In the past three weeks, Mr Rocard has had to withdraw three bills, at least temporarily, for fear of defeat. 
 A fourth squeaked through on a single disputed vote. 
 The bills were no more controversial than usual (save perhaps one on electoral reform in the regions). 
 Both conservatives and Communists have simply toughened their attitude to the government. 
 There are several reasons for this. 
 As a rule, the politicians of the mainstream right fight each other with more zest than they do the Socialists. 
 Scenting weakness perhaps, they are, for the moment, firing in unison on the Socialists. 
 On April 10th, the two main conservative parties, the neo-Gaullist Rassemblement pour la R&eacute;publique (RPR) and the Union pour la D&eacute;mocratie Fran&ccedil;aise (UDF), even signed an election pact. 
 This will almost certainly not erase the loathing Jacques Chirac and Val&eacute;ry Giscard d'Estaing, the two parties' leaders, feel for each other. 
 Yet it makes the right more united, on paper, than at any time since it lost office three years ago. 
 A campaign scandal is threatening to tar several Socialist leaders, including more than one minister and perhaps even President Mitterrand himself. 
 Though all parties take laundered campaign money, the Socialists have had the ill-luck to get caught in several big recent scandals, and the stupidity to try to cover them up. 
 Last autumn, a zealous policeman from Marseilles wrote a best-selling expos&eacute; of Socialist involvement in a huge embezzlement of public money in south-east France. 
 Recently, an examining magistrate from Le Mans ordered the seizure of documents from the Paris headquarters of Urbatechnic, a consultancy which serviced the Socialist Party. 
 When a high-up official tried to take the magistrate in charge off the case, fellow judges said, &bquo;Enough&equo;. 
 On April 19th, three local appeal judges ordered the investigation re-started. 
 Opposition leaders called on the two ministers at the ministry of justice to resign. 
 Mr Rocard's troubles do not stop there. 
 As growth in France's economy slows (to an expected 2% this year after two years near 4%), unemployment (currently 9.2% of the workforce) is rising and budget receipts dropping. 
 For a party whose left wing has long complained that French price stability was won on the backs of the poor, this is a tricky moment. 
 The finance minister, Pierre B&eacute;r&eacute;govoy, appeared this week to rule out an increase in either taxation or the budget deficit. 
 The prime minister, by contrast, is said to be against more spending cuts. 
 There is inevitable talk of a government reshuffle, but it is unclear what good removing Mr Rocard would do. 
 Though both his and the president's popularity have dipped, perhaps in a post-Gulf-war let-down, they remain France's most popular politicians. 
 Some Socialists want a more socialist prime minister, who might extend a hand to the Communists. 
 Even were a suitable one found, this would not obviously better the party's chances in the general election due two years from now. 
 Mr Mitterrand repeated last week that he sees no reason to change prime minister &bquo;for the moment&equo;. 
 Opposition leaders say they want an early general election. 
 But they could not be sure of winning and they know perfectly well that Mr Mitterrand has no reason to dissolve parliament so long as there is even a small risk that his party might lose. 
 Contrary to what the right is claiming, France's government is not paralysed. 
 Five bills have been passed since the re-opening of parliament on April 2nd. 
 If Mr Rocard runs into new difficulties, he can always push important bills through with the swift and effective parliamentary guillotine &mdash; an arguably undemocratic device he has already used 11 times over the past three years.  
 Germany 
 Kohl has been here before 
 FROM OUR BONN CORRESPONDENT 
 EVEN his worst foes cannot accuse Helmut Kohl of making life easy for himself. 
 Two days after his party's thumping defeat on April 21st in the Rhineland-Palatinate state election, the chancellor publicly urged that the federal parliament and government be moved from Bonn to Berlin. 
 He hedged a bit, saying that the shift might take up to 15 years and that a ministry or two might stay behind. 
 Still, howls erupted from pro-Bonners, not least within Mr Kohl's Christian Democratic Union and its Bavarian sister party. 
 The finance minister, Theo Waigel, wailed that he has no money to pay for a move to Berlin, costed (depending on the interest of those doing the sums) at between DM6 billion (&dollar;3.4 billion) and DM125 billion. 
 Mr Waigel is a Bavarian born and bred who has little love for Bonn but none at all for the former Prussian capital. 
 Why has Mr Kohl spoken out now after keeping quiet ever since last year's German unity treaty, which named Berlin as capital but left open where the government and parliament should be? 
 The answer is partly that the vote in Rhineland-Palatinate, which lies just below Bonn, is now out of the way; partly that he may regain some of his lost esteem in eastern Germany, where voters are heavily for Berlin; but not least that Mr Kohl has almost always come back fighting after getting a slap in the face. 
 The result in Rhineland-Palatinate, Mr Kohl's home state, must have hurt. 
 The Christian Democrats got only 38.7% of the vote, against 45.1% four years ago, and are being booted out of the government for the first time since the state was founded 45 years ago. 
 The Social Democrats jumped to 44.8% from 38.8% and can choose to form a coalition with either the Greens or the Free Democrats, which is likelier. 
 There were some local reasons for the defeat. 
 The Christian Democrats had a colourless premier, who was at odds with a too pushy local party chairman. 
 The Social Democrats had a strong candidate in Rudolf Scharping, who was leftish enough to keep the backing of the party faithful, calmly reassuring on economic matters to middle-of-the-road voters. 
 But the clinching reasons were national: alarm at the soaring cost of German unity and fury at the government's recent decision to raise taxes, after it had said last year that it would not. 
 As a result the Social Democrats are now in government in 10 of Germany's 16 L&auml;nder, or states, and have a 37&ndash;31 majority in the Bundesrat, the second chamber of the federal parliament. 
 Small wonder there is now talk in Bonn that the Social Democrats in the Bundesrat may block legislation; that Mr Kohl, though chancellor, may be dumped by his party, as Ludwig Erhard once was; or that his centre-right coalition with the Free Democrats will split, as the centre-left one led by Helmut Schmidt did in 1982. 
 Dismal though things look for Mr Kohl, they are not as bad as that. 
 Losing the majority in the Bundesrat, which may veto tax legislation, is a nuisance but not a disaster. 
 Both Mr Schmidt and his predecessor, Willy Brandt, more than got by as government leaders without a majority in the upper house. 
 So, most probably and with a bit more wheeling and dealing, can Mr Kohl. 
 The line-up in the Bundesrat is less clear than it appears. 
 The Social Democrats are in coalition with the Free Democrats in Hamburg, which has three Bundesrat votes, and with the Christian Democrats in Berlin, which has four. 
 Blocking Mr Kohl's legislation may be hard to organise in practice. 
 Nor are the Free Democrats likely to pull out of Mr Kohl's government now, though some of them hope the chance will come to join the Social Democrats in government again after the next general election in 1994. 
 In 1982 they could desert Mr Schmidt for Mr Kohl because they and the Christian Democrats together had a majority in the Bundestag, the lower house. 
 By contrast, they and the Social Democrats, who both slumped in last December's general election, do not together have a majority there now. 
 As for possible Christian Democratic rivals to Mr Kohl, there is only one: Wolfgang Sch&auml;uble, the interior minister and a former head of the chancellery. 
 He is in a wheelchair after being shot last year. 
 Mr Kohl helps keep Mr Sch&auml;uble's stock high by referring to him as a future chancellor, but by &bquo;future&equo; he does not mean &bquo;soon&equo;. 
 More bad news for Mr Kohl looks almost certain this year. 
 There are two more state elections to come, in Hamburg on June 2nd and in Bremen on September 29th. 
 Both are Social Democratic strongholds and Mr Kohl can hope for no respite in either. 
 Unemployment in eastern Germany is likely to go on rising this year. 
 Even on Berlin, Mr Kohl may not get his way. 
 It is not certain that a majority of the parliament will follow him when a free vote is held on the question of where Germany's government should be. 
 The Bundestag is due to vote on June 20th, the Bundesrat the next day, although the upper house cannot stop the lower one from leaving if it wants to. 
 All are tough challenges for a chancellor who seems nonetheless determined to battle on.  
 Kaliningrad 
 Inside Russia's western enclave 
 FROM A SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN KALININGRAD 
 IT USED to be the east Prussian city of K&ouml;nigsberg, where the philosopher Immanuel Kant worked and died. 
 Since 1945, when it was annexed from Germany by the Soviet Union, it has been Kaliningrad. 
 After British wartime bombing and a Soviet programme of Russification, few traces of its 700 years of almost uninterrupted German history remain. 
 In the city centre the only German buildings still standing are the ruin of the Gothic cathedral and the former stock exchange, which is nowadays the Palace of Culture for Sailors. 
 Today over 90% of the 900,000 people living in the Kaliningrad region are Russian. 
 Native Germans were pushed out in 1947, their place taken by immigrants from the east. 
 Since then traces of the German past have been eradicated. 
 This westernmost part of the Soviet Union used to draw little attention, except from spies. 
 It was virtually a fief of the Soviet armed forces. 
 The navy, in particular, prizes its warm-water ports. 
 In the spa town of Svetlogorsk old German villas are kept for members of the Baltic Fleet; civilians make do with bleak concrete blocks. 
 Six weeks ago it was still a closed city. 
 Some areas, known locally as &bquo;the zone&equo;, are still closed to civilians. 
 On country roads between Kaliningrad and Poland the traveller passes fields where MIG fighter aircraft graze. 
 Although Kaliningrad is part of the Russian Federation, it is set apart. 
 Hence the sudden doubts about its future. 
 If Lithuania succeeds in leaving the Soviet Union, Kaliningrad would become an enclave. 
 That would revive its forbidden or forgotten German history. 
 Among the people of Kaliningrad, fears about the future abound. 
 They have been exacerbated by rumours that ethnic Germans from Soviet Asia are to be moved into the Kaliningrad region and allowed to set up an autonomous republic there. 
 The government in Moscow persistently denies that any such plans exist, but the arrival over the past year of some 20,000 Germans from Kazakhstan has kept the rumours alive. 
 Attitudes to Germans, though, are mixed, the more so because of an influx of German visitors from the west. 
 They are the vanguard of an expected wave of Heimattouristen, former residents paying sentimental visits to their former homes. 
 Tourism is already changing the city in unexpected ways. 
 In the centre of the town, where the Prussian royal palace used to stand, looms a huge and still unfinished building known as the House of the Soviets. 
 Now it is to become a hotel, catering mainly for German tourists. 
 With German unification fresh in the memories of local people, some fear that the &bquo;eastern territories&equo; might one day revert to Germany as well. 
 Germany, all the same, represents a welcome source of foreign investment. 
 Some German companies have visited Kaliningrad to talk over joint ventures. 
 Much of their interest can be traced to the persistence of Friedrich Christians, the chairman of the supervisory board of the Deutsche Bank. 
 Mr Christians, whose own connections with the region go back to his days as a young soldier, believes that Kaliningrad could have a future as a free-trade zone linking east and west. 
 When he first raised the idea with Mikhail Gorbachev and Edward Shevardnadze in 1987, he got little response. 
 Since then the Russian Federation has taken the initiative. 
 Last year the Russian parliament named Kaliningrad one of six potential free-trade zones to be set up within the Federation. 
 A plan for the free-trade zone has been drawn up by Juri Matochkin, head of the Kaliningrad Technical Institute, and is awaiting approval from Russia's parliament. 
 It envisages the scrapping of customs duties for imports and exports which help the growth of the local economy. 
 Foreign investors would be allowed to take long leases on land, and the under-utilised port would be thrown open to foreign traders. 
 But Mr Matochkin is wary of excessive German influence. 
 He would like to see German investment &bquo;diluted by the involvement of other EC countries&equo;. 
 Ordinary people seem less worried than officials about German influence. 
 Many pointedly refer to themselves as &bquo;K&ouml;nigsberger&equo; and few feel threatened by the influx of German tourists and money into the region. 
 They say they feel both Russian and central European. 
 The climate, the landscape and what remains of German architecture all set Kaliningrad somewhat apart from the government in Moscow 600 miles to the east. 
 A Russian newspaper, the K&ouml;nigsberger Kurier, carries long articles on the town's German culture. 
 Relations between government and people in Kaliningrad have improved as both sides have come to realise that the region's precarious geographical location calls for new ways of thinking. 
 One example was the decision not to destroy the ruins of the German cathedral, where Kant is buried. 
 He may even have the town named after him. 
 At the back of some people's minds lurk fears that their region may one day become an island universe again. 
 A glum joke is doing the rounds in Kaliningrad: &bquo;The pessimists here are learning Lithuanian. 
 The optimists are learning German. 
 And the realists are studying the operating instructions of the Kalashnikov machine gun.&equo;  
 Gorbachev bends to survive 
 FROM OUR MOSCOW CORRESPONDENT 
 THE Soviet Union's quarrelling politicians may have come to a truce, perhaps something more. 
 Just what the agreement struck this week between Mikhail Gorbachev, the Soviet president, Boris Yeltsin, the Russian one, and eight other republican leaders will in the end amount to cannot be said. 
 But some sort of step back from the brink was essential. 
 Strikes are coming faster. 
 The economy is collapsing. 
 The government's response has been to impose an unpopular and inflationary emergency programme. 
 The Communist Party is splitting under the strain. 
 The elected parliament is more and more discredited. 
 Divided by national and political loyalties, the country is being torn apart. 
 Round-table talks, or a coalition government, or both, look the only way out. 
 In the first three months of this year, 1.2m man-days were lost to strikes. 
 That is a lot less than in the same period in 1990 (9m man-days), but this year those first three months also saw a startling 8% fall in GNP. 
 But, ominously, official trade unions, which formerly supported the government, are now throwing in with independent miners. 
 One such group, the miners' and steel workers' union, held a two-hour strike in Sverdlovsk, a heavy industrial centre earlier this month. 
 This was just a warning. 
 Other workers are copying them. 
 Russia's prime minister has managed to get two big coal mines back to work, but only after a promise that the Russian republic would get control over the mines. 
 Miners may now keep 20% of their output to sell at free-market prices. 
 That could encourage others to strike. 
 Workers in the oil industry want to sell oil for dollars. 
 Soon there could be wholesale transfers of industry to republican control. 
 That would wipe out one of the central government's most important sources of power: control over foreign-currency earnings. 
 Striking miners have also asked for the resignation of President Gorbachev, the transfer of power to the Council of the Federation (made up of the presidents of the different national republics), and new elections to the Soviet parliament. 
 Round-table talks, bringing together the heads of the republics and other big players, could lower the tension. 
 Several members of the Council think this a good idea. 
 Boris Yeltsin, Russia's president, wants talks between himself, Mr Gorbachev, republican leaders, Communist Party representatives and strike leaders. 
 The president of Kazakhstan has gone further and demanded the setting up of a coalition government. 
 Support for a round table is also building among Mr Gorbachev's men. 
 In June of last year Mr Gorbachev met secretly with leaders of the radical opposition. 
 This paved the way for the agreement with Mr Yeltsin on the so-called &bquo;Shatalin plan&equo; for a truly radical economic reform. 
 In the end the plan was repudiated by Mr Gorbachev and rejected by the Soviet parliament. 
 But the ideas in it still form the core of the Russian government's alternative economic plan. 
 Recently, two of Mr Gorbachev's advisers, Vadim Bakatin, a member of the new National Security Council, and Georgy Shakhnazarov, the president's personal political adviser, have said the president is reconsidering the idea of a coalition. 
 A round table might set an early date for new parliamentary elections. 
 It could also stop the central government from imposing half-baked measures in the guise of reform, which is largely what has been happening until now. 
 The government's anti-crisis programme, unveiled this week (see page 93), is brave in parts but fails to tackle the essential task of privatisation and cannot work without the agreement of republican governments. 
 The anti-crisis plan will mean further deep cuts in living standards which, if Eastern Europe's experience is anything to go by, will be tolerated only if people support their leaders. 
 Opinion polls suggest that no more than 10% of the population trusts the Soviet government. 
 Dissatisfaction will worsen as the full effects of recent massive price rises are felt. 
 But a round table, if it is to work, will also need the co-operation of conservatives in the Communist Party. 
 On April 24th, the party's Central Committee met to hang the blame on Mr Gorbachev for the economic mess. 
 Demands for his resignation as party leader were loud. 
 Many party officials oppose the ideas, such as privatisation and greater powers for the republics, that a round table would be likely to discuss. 
 Mr Gorbachev, all the same, managed to beat off this challenge to his leadership. 
 The party's importance may in any event be dwindling. 
 At the start of the year, it had seemed to be regaining influence. 
 According to the head of the party's Moscow branch, it was a late-night row in the party's Politburo that finally persuaded Mr Gorbachev last autumn to ditch the Shatalin plan. 
 Party people were behind the shadowy &bquo;committees for national salvation&equo;, on whose behalf Soviet soldiers killed 19 people in the Baltic states early this year. 
 Now party influence looks as though it is again on the wane. 
 Last year, 1.8m members left, leaving some 16.5m behind. 
 In the Russian parliament, some conservative deputies led by Colonel Alexander Rutskoi have split from the main phalanx of the party to support Mr Yeltsin. 
 Round-table talks may in effect have already begun. 
 On April 23rd, the day that parliament endorsed the anti-crisis programme, Mr Gorbachev met leaders of nine republics (excluding the six refuseniks &mdash; the three Baltic states plus Georgia, Armenia and Moldavia). 
 What emerged was a declaration broadly supporting the anti-crisis programme, but altering it in several crucial respects. 
 Some of the price rises, for instance, are to be reconsidered. 
 The republics are to go ahead with economic-reform plans of their own on the basis of the now changing programme. 
 The declaration even hinted that the six might really be allowed to leave the Soviet Union. 
 This is the clearest evidence so far that Mr Gorbachev is willing to change his government's plans in order to share authority with the federation council &mdash; the first step towards wider talks.  
 The strain of Spain 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN MADRID 
 SPAIN'S five years in the European Community have seemed like a long honeymoon. 
 It is hard to find Spaniards who will say a word against the venture which symbolises their escape from Francoism and their re-entry into world affairs. 
 Spain's joining has coincided with a boom in foreign investment. 
 Economic growth in 1986&ndash;90 averaged 4.5% a year. 
 EC regional aid, worth 2.5 billion ecus (&dollar;3 billion) a year to Spain, buys roads, railways and dams. 
 El Dorado, it seems, has been found in the jungles of Brussels. 
 As the EC got ready last year for two inter-governmental conferences &mdash; on economic and monetary union (EMU) and on political union &mdash; Spain sounded like a firm believer in a federal Europe. 
 By the time the conferences actually began in December, it had realised that real interests were at stake. 
 Spanish officials from the prime minister, Felipe Gonzalez, on down, have since defended these with a pugnacity that has upset federalists. 
 The Spanish worry that moving too fast towards monetary union could leave Spain and others behind. 
 They want at least a five-year transition period before Europe's exchange rates are locked for good. 
 This is partly because Spain wants &bquo;economic union&equo;, by which it understands more aid for poorer countries, to be in place to cushion the shock of the monetary sort. 
 On political union, too, Spain has begun to backslide. 
 The Spanish opposed the introduction of majority voting in the Council of Ministers on environmental laws unless a special fund was set up to help poorer countries meet EC standards. 
 One recent EC rule on air pollution would have cost Spain Ptas300 billion (&dollar;2.8 billion) to enforce, according to Spanish officials &mdash; if it had not used its veto to win a let-out for its factories to continue burning dirty brown coal. 
 Spain also opposes majority voting on pay-and-conditions laws that could raise payroll costs. 
 Spain likes those bits of political union that come free: more law-making power for the European Parliament and majority voting on some areas of foreign policy. 
 The Spanish think the Community should aim for a common defence policy. 
 Yet Spain's keenest interest is money. 
 It has taken a closer look at what it pays and what it gets out of its Brussels El Dorado, and it is not happy. 
 Largely because of Spain, talk about political union also means talk about money. 
 The EC duns members for a fixed share of their VAT receipts. 
 High-spending Spaniards pay a lot of VAT, so Spain pays a large whack to Brussels. 
 As for what it gets in return, Spain gets little farm money, as it has few rich farmers (who get most from Europe's upside-down farm policy) and little research and development money, as it lacks high-class laboratories. 
 To their surprise, the Spanish have found that they now get back from Brussels scarcely more than they put in. 
 To remedy this, the Spanish want the EC's regional funds to pay for its hospitals and schools. 
 More radically, they want automatic subsidies from rich members for poor ones. 
 Luxembourg, the conference chair, has ignored these ideas in its draft treaty. 
 Only Greece, Portugal and Ireland support them. 
 Carlos Westendorp, Spain's new minister for Europe, says that, unless the rich give ground, Spain may block political union. 
 Even if the two conferences end on schedule before the December 31st, a strain between Spain and its partners will still remain. 
 Next year the EC has to make a budget plan for the following five years. 
 Spain is almost certain to repeat its demand for automatic subsidies. 
 Rows are brewing over Spain's disregard for EC anti-pollution laws. 
 Tighter rules, many Spaniards think, will cramp economic growth. 
 Spain has no Green party as such and Spanish politicians are convinced green measures do not win votes. 
 Applying environmental laws is up to Spain's regional governments, most of whom still think of emission standards as how fast building permits are issued. 
 Spain's truculence is, in a sense, the proof of its maturity: no longer need it impress fellow members. 
 The result is by no means negative. 
 Spain has found one role as champion of the EC's poor countries, another as a bridge-builder between the Community and North Africa. 
 (It is pushing the idea of a Conference on Security and Cooperation in the Mediterranean.) 
 Despite the frictions, Spain's marks &mdash; European citizenship, which it proposed, and a long transition to EMU &mdash; look set to appear in the final treaties.  
 BRITAIN THIS WEEK 
 Taxes and tantrums 
 The government announced that it will replace the poll tax with a council tax. 
 The property-based tax will sort all 22.2m homes into seven bands according to their market values. 
 The top rate will be no more than 2.5 times the bottom rate. 
 The poor will be exempt. 
 Alas, the poll tax will linger on, in less expensive form, until April 1993. 
 In an impassioned attack on school standards, delivered on St George's day, the Prince of Wales said something to please almost everyone. 
 He lambasted self-styled educational experts for ignoring Shakespeare. 
 He sneered at over-specialised education. 
 And he lamented the endless squeeze on cash. 
 The threat of nationwide rail disruption moved nearer when union leaders rejected a &bquo;final&equo; 7% pay offer. 
 Tough times 
 The chancellor of the exchequer, Norman Lamont, told sceptical businessmen at the annual Institute of Directors' conference that the economy would recover in the second half of the year. 
 The businessmen accused the government of delivering too much inflation and too few tax cuts. 
 The sharpest rise in shop sales for almost 12 years encouraged hopes that the worst of the recession is over. 
 The CBI pointed out that the rush to beat the VAT increases might have encouraged a shopping spree. 
 The current-account deficit jumped from &pound;227m in February to &pound;432m (&dollar;789m) in March. 
 And a survey by the Association of British Chambers of Commerce argued that a deepening recession is hitting London hardest. 
 London's public transport is the most expensive in Europe, a survey revealed. 
 Large European cities charge an average of 71p (&dollar;1.22) a journey. 
 London Regional Transport charges &pound;1.40. 
 A man who grew 1,659 cannabis plants said he was a &bquo;heavy smoker&equo; and claimed that they were all for his own use. 
 The Court smoked him out and convicted him of supplying the stuff. 
 Labour Party plans for a national minimum wage were criticised by the AEU engineering union, which fears an erosion of skilled workers' pay differentials. 
 In one of the bloodiest weeks in its history, the BBC announced that it intended to cut jobs by more than 1,000. 
 The corporation needs to save &pound;25m (&dollar;43m) a year. 
 More job losses are in the pipeline. 
 Skoolgate 
 John Major, the prime minister, dithered before remembering how many O-levels he has (six). 
 Neil Kinnock, Labour's leader, claimed that everybody remembers that sort of thing and then got his own score wrong. 
 (He claimed seven, but has eight). 
 The nation looked on, bemused. 
 The number of parents sending their children to private schools has risen for the eighth year running, despite a downturn in the economy and an upturn in school fees, the Independent Schools Information Service revealed. 
 Fifty parents of seven-year-olds forced the head of a Cardiff primary school to suspend testing the national curriculum by threatening to take their custom elsewhere. 
 They said the children were suffering from exam nerves. 
 Too much decentralised buying by the National Health Service means the service squanders millions by failing to use bulk orders to get the cheapest prices, the National Audit Office claimed. 
 Good ideas 
 The ingenious products singled out by this year's Queen's Awards for Export Achievement included: pop-up greeting cards, a flushable colostomy bag, and a device for putting the froth on the top of canned Guinness. 
 The poll tax failed to get a mention. 
 Manchester will be Britain's bid for the Olympic Games in 2000. 
 John Major waxed philosophical on his career prospects. 
 &bquo;I'm going to try as hard as I can. 
 But I'm very young, and if it goes wrong, I can always do something else.&equo; 
 The &pound;30,927 (&dollar;53,000) prize for winning the London Marathon went to a teacher from Siberia. 
 He earns &pound;5 a month. 
 Gerald Ratner, chairman and managing director of Britain's biggest jeweller, said that his business success was founded on selling people what they wanted: &bquo;total crap.&equo; 
 Detectives in Bristol said that they are having to catch buses to investigate burglaries because of a shortage of police cars. 
 BRITAIN 
 Lairds and adders 
 SHOW an adder to a Scotsman and he will reach for his dirk. 
 The hills, it seems, are a-slither with these serpents. 
 They are a menace to farm animals and a threat to children. 
 It is a rare Scotsman who does not have a tale or two about a favourite pet or a loved relative who has been felled by their fangs. 
 Show an adder to a southerner and &mdash; provided it is a safe distance away &mdash; he will deliver a lecture on endangered species. 
 Unlike rats, adders do not thrive among the motorway flyovers and take-away-kebab houses of metroland. 
 Tom Langton, a campaigner on behalf of adders, has managed to find only one adder colony in the whole of Greater London. 
 Novelists are unlikely to imitate Thomas Hardy and dispatch a character with an adder bite. 
 The House of Lords recently provided the scene for a tussle between Scottish common sense and southern sentimentality. 
 In January the government, bowing to pressure from the Nature Conservancy Council, amended the Wildlife Protection Act to extend the full protection of the law to the adder. 
 The Scottish lairds were furious. 
 They pointed out that adders might be endangered in some parts of the country but they are thriving north of the border. 
 A succession of warm winters has led to an explosion in the adder population, as the moles and voles they prey upon have got more plentiful. 
 On April 16th Lord Kimball asked for a clarification of the act. 
 Is it fair for a stockman or a shepherd to face a &pound;2,000 (&dollar;3,390) fine if he harms an adder to protect a child or a farm animal? 
 Lord Kimball, who has a hill farm in Altnaharra Lairg, Sutherland, says adders are a particular menace to calves, dogs and sheep. 
 Horses are sensible enough to shy away at the sound of a hiss. 
 But calves are incurably curious, dogs are irrepressibly aggressive, and sheep are just plain stupid. 
 Over the past year he has had eight sheep, one suckle-calf and a ram bitten by adders: the ram died. 
 The spring, he says, is a particularly perilous time in adder-land: as they emerge from hibernation, adders are too groggy to slip away from potential threats but their fangs are filled with several months' worth of venom. 
 Only last week his daughter's terrier was bitten by one. 
 Lord Kimball got the clarification he wanted. 
 In dire emergencies Scotsmen can still reach for their dirks without risking their wallets.  
 Demography and public spending 
 Grizzled Albion 
 NE day, Britain may boast the lowest public spending as a percentage of GDP &mdash; and hence the lowest level of taxation &mdash; of the seven big economies. 
 The secret? 
 Britain became an elderly nation before others started to turn grey. 
 In the 1980s Britain's public spending fell by more as a percentage of GDP than that of any other big industrial economy: from 47% in 1982 to around 40% last year. 
 That still left it well ahead of America's 36% and Japan's 33%. 
 But Britain now has the lowest ratio of spending to GDP in the European Community. 
 The fall has now been halted by recession. 
 As Britain grows older, it may be partly reversed. 
 But other big industrial countries will be ageing even faster. 
 As they do, budgets for health care and pensions will rise. 
 In Britain that pressure will be weaker, partly because Britain already has the oldest population among the big OECD countries. 
 Almost alone among its peers, Britain will see over the next 20 years a small decline in its old-age dependency ratio (the number of people aged over 65 as a proportion of the working population). 
 Even though the decline will be succeeded by a modest rise, Britain's dependency ratio over the next 40 years should rise by only eight percentage points, to 31%. 
 Contrast that with the other big six industrial economies, where the ratio will rise by 16 percentage points, to 36%. 
 A study by the OECD tries to forecast what all these extra grey heads mean for public spending in different countries over the next 40 years, assuming that government policies remain unchanged. 
 The study assumes that spending on pensions as a proportion of GDP increases in line with countries' old-age dependency ratios. 
 This implies that average pensions rise in line with wages. 
 Spending on health services, which the old also use more than younger people, is forecast by multiplying the expected number of people in each age group by the average real spending for each group in 1980. 
 Assume, for the moment, no increase in the relative price of medical care: the ratio of public spending (excluding debt-interest payments) to GDP will rise by only 8% in Britain, from 33% to 36%. 
 In the other six big countries, the ratio will grow up to four times as fast. 
 As a result, by 2028 Britain could have the lowest ratio of public spending to GDP of any big economy. 
 Britain might do better still. 
 The OECD's figures assume that pensions rise in line with wages. 
 But in Britain, unlike some other countries, benefits are linked to prices; so as real wages rise, spending on pensions falls relative to GDP. 
 In reality, governments are unlikely to allow a gap between living standards of workers and pensioners to get wider for ever. 
 The quirks of demography have implications for future tax policy. 
 Make the more realistic assumption that the cost of medical care rises 2% a year faster than prices in general. 
 In that case, every big country apart from Britain will need to raise its taxes (or cut other spending) by an average of 3% of GDP by 2030 to pay for extra spending on old people and to prevent a rise in the ratio of public debt to GDP. 
 But Britain, with few more old folk to care for and a debt-to-GDP ratio already on a declining trend, will have room to cut its taxes by 2.2% of GDP. 
 That is enough to dock 6p off the basic rate of income tax and still keep the public-debt ratio stable. 
 Forty years may be a long time to wait for a 19p basic rate of tax. 
 But most of the gap between Britain and other countries opens up within the next 20 years. 
 The British already pay less tax, relative to GDP, than the citizens of the other main EC countries: 39% of GDP compared with an average of 44% in Germany, France and Italy. 
 Tim Congdon, chief economist at Gerrard and National, a discount house, believes that by the end of the century that 5% gap could have trebled. 
 Britain's tax burden could be 15% lower as a share of GDP than the rest of the EC's. 
 Other European countries will need to start raising taxes sooner to pay for their old people. 
 But once Britain's economy recovers, he thinks, spending should resume its downward trend, thanks to the Thatcher legacy of expenditure control, falling debt-interest payments and defence cuts. 
 That sounds too good to be true. 
 But Mr Congdon's figures and those of the OECD show that Britain has the opportunity to become one of the the lowest-taxed nations in the OECD. 
 The key word, of course, is &bquo;opportunity&equo;. 
 To a Labour government it might provide the opportunity for much more spending on schools, hospitals and roads.  
 The Major gang 
 Earning an ism 
 WILL John Major ever earn an ism after his name, as Margaret Thatcher did? 
 Never, say the sceptics: the man does not stand for anything. 
 They ought to look again, for Mr Major is putting together a group of clear-minded, like-minded ministers and advisers, just as Mrs Thatcher did. 
 In time, the results may look coherent enough to be defined as Majorism. 
 Either way, they will be different from Thatcherism. 
 The Major gang is strong on economics. 
 For some, that means macroeconomics: hence the promotion of Sir Terence Burns to be permanent secretary at the Treasury, after 11 years as the government's chief economic adviser. 
 Others are much more interested in microeconomic questions, like tax reform, local-government finance and the role of subsidies and benefits. 
 The top micros are Bill Robinson, who has been brought into the Treasury as a special adviser; and Sarah Hogg, head of Mr Major's policy unit in Downing Street. 
 They make a powerful trio. 
 The Treasury's writ runs as wide as ever, so Sir Terence will be able to use its top job to steer the priorities and ideas of the whole of Whitehall. 
 Mr Robinson could have a wide brief as well, so long as he keeps the chancellor's confidence. 
 And Mrs Hogg has more of Mr Major's ear than almost anybody else in government. 
 What will they do with their power? 
 None of them is temperamentally inclined to be an activist on macroeconomic policy. 
 Unemployment is rising, but inflation is falling and interest rates with it, so the economy will pick up in due course. 
 With the pound locked into the European Monetary System, the most and the least the government can do is ensure that nominal demand does not collapse. 
 If ministers itch to do more, they will be told to calm down. 
 Sir Terence, in particular, is still furious that inflation bounced back into double figures, after all the pain of getting it below 5% in the mid-1980s, and ascribes it to the delay in joining the EMS. 
 He can count himself lucky not to have been blamed for the bounce by his political masters. 
 A hands-off approach to macroeconomic management has the great virtue of leaving both hands free for microeconomic tasks. 
 Mr Major's advisers share a broad preference for fiscal neutrality &mdash; ie, not using tax breaks to favour certain kinds of economic activity and to penalise others. 
 Top of their wish-list would be the scrapping of tax benefits for housing. 
 Company cars are another favourite target. 
 Mr Lamont and Mr Major listen to these arguments; Mrs Thatcher would not touch them. 
 The other big difference in the Major approach is at the bottom of the income scale. 
 Both Mrs Hogg and Mr Robinson are seriously interested in the way the cake is cut, not just in how fast it can expand. 
 They would like government to do more for the weakest and the poorest, by direct transfers of income (witness the rise in child benefit) as well as by boosting educational standards. 
 But they will be quick to point out to ministers that &bquo;helping the poorest&equo; can often lead to poverty and unemployment traps, as any state benefit aimed just at low-income households will discourage them from earning more or getting a job if it is withdrawn as soon as they do so. 
 Yet universal payments (like child benefit) are expensive, so the Treasury dislikes them. 
 That points to a possible cause of friction within the Major gang. 
 The prime minister and his advisers will sometimes want to do things that cost a lot of money; the Treasury will want to rein back. 
 The sense of harmony and purpose among Mr Major's advisers is bound to be tested before long. 
 Just as well they have something else in common: they have known each other a long time, and are all good friends. 
 With one bound, he was&hellip; 
 John Major has escaped the toils of the poll tax. 
 He may soon be caught in other local-government traps 
 THERE is something to be said for a government creating horrible problems for itself. 
 The roar of applause when it later rids itself of them may boost its popularity at a critical moment. 
 The announcement of a replacement for the poll tax on April 23rd improves the government's prospects in the council elections on May 2nd. 
 The proposed council tax, which offers something to each lobby, is a slick political trick. 
 But the proposals also create a host of future problems by promising to tinker with local government's structure. 
 By returning to a property tax, the government answered the principal objection to the poll tax: its unfairness. 
 The council tax is a sort-of-wealth-tax, with bills determined partly by the value of the biggest asset most people own and partly by how much each council spends. 
 Owners of second homes will pay half the full rate on them. 
 On the other hand, the council tax is also a bit-of-a-poll-tax. 
 Single people get a 25% discount under the council tax. 
 This answers Tory demands that the tax should be related to the amount that a household uses local services. 
 So widows in large houses (who always feature prominently in arguments about property taxes) will not do as badly as under the rates. 
 Some Tory MPs feel the discount is not large enough: after consultation, it may be increased. 
 Central to the tax are the bands into which homes of different value will be sorted. 
 These are also designed with an eye to reassuring those who did well out of the switch from rates to poll tax. 
 It ensures that the range of possible bills is limited. 
 The top bills will be only 2.5 times as much as the lowest bills, and the highest band is for houses worth over &pound;160,000 (&dollar;274,000). 
 So the 46% of houses in Barnet that the government reckons will be in the top band will all pay the same amount, irrespective of their value. 
 Barnet is unusual: as the table shows, most households in the country will fall conveniently into the five lowest bands. 
 In general, the tax will shift the burden towards the south's richer homes and away from the north, because the government intends to tailor its central grants to equalise, roughly, the tax on like houses under like-spending councils. 
 In a place like Kingston-upon-Hull in Humberside, 68% of homes are in the lowest (&pound;40,000 and under) band, and fewer than 1% are in either of the top two bands (more than &pound;120,000). 
 This is politics, not mathematics: Tory marginal seats tend to be in poorer areas &mdash; particularly in the north-west &mdash; with cheaper houses. 
 There are uncomfortable exceptions, though. 
 In Bath (Chris Patten, party chairman, majority 1,412) the biggest chunk of homes is in the top band. 
 Those with two adults will pay &pound;682, compared with a &pound;489 poll tax. 
 Sceptics hunting for flaws in the tax have quickly spotted one potential problem. 
 The banding system looks neat and simple but could lead to a mess. 
 A taxpayer in Lambeth whose house was valued at &pound;121,000, for instance, would save &pound;111 if it were valued instead at &pound;119,000; so councils could find themselves swamped with appeals. 
 The proposed reform leaves councils no more &bquo;accountable&equo; than before. 
 Those who are not responsible for raising taxes are not likely to be responsible about spending them. 
 Under the poll tax, councils raise 11% of the money they spend. 
 That proportion will not change under the new system, and council budgets will still be capped. 
 So these proposals continue the centralisation intensified in the 1980s. 
 The new snare 
 The government has learnt the foolishness of meddling with local taxation. 
 Now, with reckless abandon, it promises to meddle with local-government structure. 
 It wants to set up a local-government commission to review the structure of local government across England. 
 It believes that one-tier authorities would be better than the two-tier authorities that exist everywhere except the metropolitan areas. 
 This is a quiet coup for the Association of District Councils, which has been lobbying hard against the counties ever since the districts lost power to the counties in the 1974 reforms. 
 Although the ADC has a Tory majority, most of the work is done by the &bquo;Big 11&equo; (cities like Swansea and Hull), of which six are Labour, two Tory and the rest hung. 
 The government consultation paper insists that it is not gunning specifically for county or for district councils. 
 But since the thrust of the argument is for grass-roots power and the paper refers implicitly to unpopular counties created by the 1974 reforms, the districts are less worried than the counties that contain them. 
 Already there are mutterings in the shires. 
 Councillors have their pride, their power and their perks, and do not like the idea of being abolished. 
 Most of those under threat are Tories, since the bulk of both county and district councils are Tory-run. 
 So the government risks a revolt by those rural stalwarts who do much of the legwork during general elections, as well as years of ill-mannered squabbles as the two sets of councillors argue their worth to the commission. 
 The government says that the introduction of single-tier authorities will save money. 
 It might; but a forthcoming study by the University of Birmingham's Institute for Local Government on the abolition of the West Midlands Metropolitan County Council in 1985 suggests that it will not necessarily prove cheaper. 
 The study found no savings resulted from the change, and some spending increased. 
 In some areas of council responsibility, there are clear economies of scale. 
 Take food hygiene: it is cheaper for a large council to set up a laboratory to service several districts than for each of the districts to have its own. 
 Other services &mdash; like the police and fire brigade &mdash; do not make administrative sense in smaller areas. 
 So ad hoc multi-council boards, run by officials accountable to nobody in particular, had to be set up in the metropolitan areas after 1985. 
 Since those officials are not under the thumb of councillors worried about rates increases, they are less likely to be frugal. 
 Critics fear that ad hoc boards, neither accountable nor thrifty, will proliferate. 
 The government believes that people will love it for abolishing counties like Humberside, which proud Yorkshiremen have always refused to acknowledge. 
 This is optimistic. 
 Before 1994, the suggested date for introducing reforms, it may decide that the change is not worth the political and administrative pain.  
 The new men at work 
 IT WAS Julian Critchley &mdash; genial man of letters, biographer of Michael Heseltine, wholesale supplier of parliamentary anecdotes (repeat orders a speciality) and also a Tory MP &mdash; who noted that &bquo;politicians are happiest when talking, at their most miserable when making up their minds.&equo; 
 His biographee would dissent; Mr Heseltine believes in politicians as shirt-sleeved doers. 
 For the cabinet as a whole, though, talking about the need to replace or reform the poll tax proved easier than finally deciding on its replacement. 
 The story of how ministers did so provides the first substantial evidence about how John Major's government is functioning behind closed doors. 
 The first point is that both ministers and officials involved in the review stress the lack of drama, tantrum-throwing and brinkmanship. 
 Instead, it was &bquo;collegiate&equo; and &bquo;a classic example of old-fashioned cabinet government&equo;. 
 It suits the powers-that-be to draw a distinction between the livid chiaroscuro of Mrs Thatcher's reign and the plain, cool daylight of the current regime. 
 And, though there is truth here, there is propaganda too. 
 Take the first ingredient, without which this week's announcement about a local property tax would have been impossible &mdash; the &pound;4 billion (&dollar;7 billion) switch to value-added tax (VAT) in the Budget. 
 Mr Major had been taking private soundings about such a move before Christmas. 
 Some Ministers told him the switch should be to income tax; others, including Kenneth Baker, the home secretary, suggested VAT. 
 In February the switch &mdash; known to insiders as &bquo;Big Bertha&equo; &mdash; was agreed upon by Norman Lamont, the chancellor and by Mr Major. 
 Just the two of them: nobody else was involved. 
 The cabinet was informed as late as possible; even ministers on the poll-tax review committee were not told what was coming. 
 So much for traditional cabinet government. 
 Before the budget, because of the problem of trying to find money to cut the local bills, little progress had been made. 
 Mr Major and Mr Heseltine had both agreed that the amount of money raised by local government had to be slashed; that capping of council spending should stay; and that some form of property tax was inevitable. 
 The government's much-vaunted desire to consult operated only within those limits. 
 A local income tax, for instance, was never considered. 
 After the budget, despite Mr Lamont's coup, potentially dangerous strains remained. 
 Mr Heseltine was working for a 50:50 hybrid tax, split between property and head-tax. 
 The Treasury, which other departments felt had been engaging in the review only half-heartedly until mid-March (and which was urged to take a greater role by Mr Major), was damned if it was going to see its VAT switch spent on anything that could be tagged &bquo;son of poll tax&equo;. 
 By contrast, the Scottish Tories had been lobbying to keep the maximum personal element. 
 Mr Major used his new policy adviser, Sarah Hogg, to ensure that Downing Street was putting its own ideas in to the review. 
 More important, he made it his priority to ensure that the departments worked together, not against each other. 
 Ministers who might have resented a particular proposal were seen by Mr Major privately before the relevant meeting and &bquo;squared&equo;. 
 Early on, he asked John Wakeham, his one-time boss as chief whip, but now energy secretary, to attend meetings of the review committee, acting as an independent source of party-wise political advice and, later, as a fixer. 
 One minister, asked to distinguish between the way Mr Major led the review and the way Mrs Thatcher might have behaved, says: &bquo;He interfered more &mdash; and more often &mdash; and earlier &mdash; than she would have done.&equo; 
 But that interference may well have kept the review on course, as the clock ticked on and the derision from Labour grew louder. 
 One example is the way that Mr Heseltine ungrudgingly retreated from his 50:50 preference. 
 This was critical, since it took the new tax from being a hybrid to being a loosely-disguised property tax. 
 Although there is some ill-feeling in Whitehall about the way the environment team leaked some (nutty) ideas, Mr Heseltine's behaviour in committee is praised by other ministers. 
 Every one of many variations of the proposed tax went from the Treasury team &mdash; Mr Lamont; Sir Terence Burns, shortly to become permanent secretary there; and Andrew Edwards, its local-government guru &mdash; to be crunched through the environment department's computer. 
 This partly explains why the review took the time it did, since the computer can spend nearly four days running a full set of figures. 
 But it produced critical evidence about how different designs of tax would hit marginal seats and heartland Tory ones. 
 The result is a tax designed to raise cash from better-off voters in safe Tory areas and push it towards the marginals. 
 The final breakthroughs were over such devilish details as the spread of the banding system for valuing houses, and the extent of exemptions. 
 They came, not during committee meetings in Whitehall, but after informal chats at ministers' houses during the Easter holiday. 
 If the tax was to be announced before the May 2nd local elections, time was getting short. 
 Mr Major used Mr Wakeham and the chief whip, Richard Ryder, as go-betweens, shuffling between Mr Heseltine and Downing Street, to settle the details. 
 On April 5th the Treasury team started its final burst of work &mdash; the last details to be sorted out were on the exemptions from the tax, and the scrapping of the hated poll-tax register. 
 On April 10th the Scottish secretary, Ian Lang, returned to London believing he could sell a modified property tax to his suspicious party. 
 On April 15th the new tax was in shape. 
 This thumbnail sketch of a complicated web of negotiations says some unexpected things about Mr Major. 
 Far from being a natural cabinet chairman, he intervened and interfered repeatedly &mdash; mostly to speed up decision-making. 
 Just as under Mrs Thatcher, the crucial choices were decided in small committees: although there were open discussions at full cabinet meetings during March, there is no evidence that they changed a jot or tittle of the tax. 
 And Mr Major happily used freelance fixers like Mr Wakeham to defuse potentially difficult committee meetings. 
 The new style is becoming clearer. 
 It is different from  hers , but not quite so different as some suggest.  
 Regional policy 
 Uncollected Eurocash 
 THE government is now in the curious position of urging 30 local authorities to spend more. 
 If they do not, Britain will be unable to claim money waiting for it in Brussels. 
 The European Regional Development Fund gives money to depressed areas, with projects financed 50&ndash;50 by the ERDF and the local authority. 
 Britain has been allocated 1.2 billion ecus (&pound;830m) of ERDF money for 1988&ndash;91. 
 About 700m ecus are still waiting to be collected, partly because spending tends to bunch at the end of a period and partly because Britain's system of local-authority finance means that some councils cannot use the money. 
 Unlike other countries, Britain does not allow the money to go straight to the local authorities to which it has been allocated. 
 Because the Treasury wants to have the final say on all public spending, however financed, each year's chunk of ERDF cash is merely regarded as one source of finance for the total that authorities are permitted to spend each year. 
 The accounting is one thing: getting hold of the money is another. 
 Britain can collect it from Brussels only when the local authorities to which the money was allocated send in bills to show it has been appropriately spent. 
 Because of those government controls on local-authority spending, however, some councils do not have enough money to stump up their 50% contribution. 
 So in West Cumbria none of the &pound;5m (&dollar;8.5m) of ERDF money allocated over the three years has been spent. 
 In order that the cash can be claimed from Brussels before December 31st, the end of the EC's financial year, the Treasury will be giving local authorities in West Cumbria, and other councils in a similar fix, an extra capital-spending allocation. 
 Moreover, because of yet another Treasury safeguard to make sure that EC money does not sneak past its scrutiny of public spending, local authorities are not allowed to make up their own 50% by getting contributions from businesses or charities. 
 So the kind of joint ventures which the EC &mdash; and in theory the British government &mdash; has been encouraging are not allowed. 
 In Newcastle, for example, the government forbade the use of private-sector money with ERDF money to set up a training centre. 
 In 1989 Britain promised to reform its system of dealing with receipts from Brussels to lighten the Treasury's touch somewhat. 
 Nothing has been done. 
 The commissioner with responsibility for regional development, Bruce Millan, met Peter Lilley, the trade and industry secretary, Ian Lang, the secretary of state for Scotland, and David Hunt, the secretary of state for Wales on April 25th, partly in order to try to persuade them to sort things out. 
 How often does Brussels have to beg countries to take money from it?  
 Hail the Gaels 
 GAELIC is the ancient language of Northern Ireland's Catholics, the language the IRA likes to use to splatter its slogans around the province. 
 But Gaelic is also the ancient language of the many Northern Irish Protestants whose families came from Scotland. 
 A recent revival of enthusiasm for Gaelic among both lots of people is giving them a rare common interest. 
 In the 1911 census, the most recent complete record of Gaelic-speaking, only 2% of the population said they could speak the language. 
 In a 1987 survey, though, 17% of those under 25 claimed some knowledge of Gaelic. 
 The first sign of the boom in Gaelic came when a Gaelic-speaking school on Belfast's Falls Road &mdash; the Bunscoil &mdash; saw the number of applicants soar. 
 It now has 450 pupils. 
 Another three primary schools have sprung up, and there are 18 Gaelic-medium nurseries. 
 For adults, there are now around 60 Gaelic night-classes in West Belfast. 
 The BBC is encouraging the fashion by offering an annual prize for the best Gaelic radio play. 
 The spread of Gaelic among Protestants is slower but more significant, given that its nationalist associations have generally led Protestants to view the language with suspicion. 
 The Maze prison records several Protestants among its 122 enrolments for Gaelic classes. 
 Ballyhackamore, a Protestant enclave in east Belfast, has mustered enough enthusiasts for a class. 
 A class in County Down has a Presbyterian parson among its pupils. 
 Ian Adamson, one of the keenest Protestant Gaelic speakers, who inherited his interest from a Gaelic-speaking great-grandmother from western Scotland, claims that in the 19th century, when Catholics were turning from Gaelic to English, Protestants helped to keep the language alive. 
 The first books to be printed in Ireland were published by the Anglican Church of Ireland: a Catechism and a Book of Common Prayer in Gaelic. 
 BUSINESS 
 The flawed vision of Edzard Reuter 
 BONN 
 With a series of bold acquisitions in the 1980s, Edzard Reuter turned Daimler-Benz into one of the world's biggest industrial conglomerates. 
 His strategy is not working 
 THROUGHOUT the mid-1980s a fierce battle raged for control of Daimler-Benz, the luxury-car maker which seemed to epitomise the industrial prowess of a resurgent West Germany. 
 On one side was Werner Breitschwerdt, Daimler's chief executive, a plodding engineer committed to keeping the company focused on the manufacture of its superbly engineered cars. 
 On the other side were Alfred Herrhausen, the dynamic boss of Deutsche Bank, Germany's biggest bank and Daimler's leading shareholder, and Herrhausen's candidate for chief executive, the visionary Edzard Reuter, son of a famous German politician. 
 Herrhausen and Mr Reuter wanted to accelerate Daimler's hesitant steps towards diversification, turning it into a huge manufacturing conglomerate capable of leading German industry to a high-tech future and big enough to compete with the giants of American and Japanese industry. 
 In 1987 this exciting duo triumphed. 
 The dull Mr Breitschwerdt disappeared into early retirement and Mr Reuter took his place. 
 Now it looks as if the wrong side won. 
 Herrhausen is dead, killed by a terrorist bomb in 1989. 
 Mr Reuter struggles on without his support to weld a group of large, still separate companies into a coherent whole. 
 This is not proving easy. 
 Morale in many parts of the Daimler empire has plummeted. 
 Ever fond of the grand gesture, Mr Reuter began much-ballyhooed collaboration talks with Japan's Mitsubishi family of companies early last year, but these have so far yielded little. 
 Profits have stagnated. 
 On April 22nd Daimler announced a 5% rise in sales to DM85.5 billion (&dollar;53 billion) in 1990, though operating profits fell by 10%; the company had a 6% rise in net earnings, to DM1.8 billion, only because of a lower tax bill. 
 The new fields into which Mr Reuter has taken the group since the mid-1980s &mdash; aerospace, electricals and financial services &mdash; are either yielding little or are deep in the red. 
 Analysts estimate that 90% of the firm's profit still comes from the sale of Mercedes cars, its original business. 
 It is still too early to judge the strategy, say Mr Reuter's supporters within the company. 
 The fruits of diversification will be clear even to the most sceptical observers in another few years, they claim, when the company's new subsidiaries will help Mercedes build still better cars while the company's ability to throw resources into fast-growing high-tech areas will give it an edge in those markets. 
 Maybe. 
 But, thanks both to Daimler's bad luck and bad judgment, the odds against this ever happening are high &mdash; and getting higher. 
 Take the plight of Deutsche Aerospace, the company Daimler has cobbled together out of two aircraft makers, MBB and Dornier, and MTU, an engine maker. 
 For decades Bavaria-based MBB, with its odd mix of brilliant &bquo;ideas men&equo; and bureaucrats ferreting for state subsidies, was a notoriously hard company to run. 
 It is also an old rival of Dornier. 
 Thus, even in ideal circumstances, merging these two companies was bound to be tricky. 
 But reduced East-West tension has made this even more difficult, clobbering defence sales, which account for roughly half of Deutsche Aerospace's revenues. 
 The company's intake of new orders shrank by 43% last year. 
 There will be much worse to come if the German government decides, as it may, to pull out of the European Fighter Aircraft project on which Deutsche Aerospace was counting for future revenues. 
 That puts more pressure on J&uuml;rgen Schrempp, Deutsche Aerospace's tough boss, to expand and improve his civilian operations. 
 He has already signed joint-venture deals with France's Aerospatiale to make helicopters and with America's Pratt &amp; Whitney to make aero-engines, and he thinks that his company is now big enough to strike more such international agreements. 
 But Mr Schrempp is also running into snags. 
 The German government, forced to cover currency losses on Deutsche Aerospace's work for Airbus, the pan-European aircraft consortium of which it is a member, is reluctant to put up yet more taxpayers' money to back Mr Schrempp's ambitious and controversial scheme to build a 130-seat regional airliner outside the Airbus consortium. 
 This plan has already alarmed the other Airbus partners. 
 The company is also squabbling with state governments about how it should distribute its work, and jobs, within Germany. 
 Not least, Mr Schrempp's empire-building has ruffled feathers inside Daimler itself. 
 Perhaps least enchanted with Mr Schrempp are managers at AEG, the electrical-equipment manufacturer which was Daimler's biggest acquisition. 
 AEG has had to hand over to Deutsche Aerospace its lucrative aerospace and defence division, its second-largest unit. 
 The company has also lost promising operations to other bits of Daimler. 
 Its research institutes in Ulm, Berlin and Frankfurt have been put under the centralised control of the Daimler holding company in Stuttgart. 
 Part of its data-processing and marketing activities have been gobbled up by DEBIS, Daimler's new division offering financial and information services. 
 Small wonder that Heinz D&uuml;rr, AEG's long-serving chief executive, left at the end of last year to take on the unglamorous job of running Germany's state-owned railway company. 
 His successor, Ernst Georg St&ouml;ckl, will have to do even more pruning because AEG lost DM205m last year. 
 First on the block may be the money-losing Olympia office-equipment division. 
 Daimler's inability to turn around AEG since buying it in 1985, after AEG had already itself failed to stem heavy losses, has damaged morale at the company. 
 Spirits are also low at Munich-based MBB, where many employees resent being directed from Stuttgart. 
 Conversely, managers in Stuttgart at Mercedes-Benz, Daimler's car-making heartland, are just as resentful of watching firms like MBB and AEG lose most of the profits they earn. 
 Mercedes-Benz's proud engineers also loathe being lumped in with companies making everything from washing machines to weapons. 
 Such resentments are beginning to take a visible toll on the company. 
 Mercedes's offices have recently been searched by state prosecutors, acting on anonymous tips that Daimler illegally exported weapons-carriers to Iraq and that a senior manager had evaded tax. 
 Daimler denies any wrongdoing. 
 But what bothers the company's bosses is that the tip-offs contained enough circumstantial detail to indicate the source was a fairly high-ranking employee, perhaps an indication that disaffection with Mr Reuter's strategy is spreading. 
 Whatever the truth, the unwelcome publicity could not come at a worse time for Mercedes &mdash; just as it is launching its new top-of-the-range &bquo;S&equo; model after 12 years of development. 
 With the latest &bquo;S&equo; series, and other new models either recently introduced or about to be, Mercedes aims to head off the challenge posed by a stream of new models from an arch-rival that has stuck to its last, BMW, and the looming threat posed by a fleet of new Japanese luxury models. 
 One of the few bright spots at Daimler is DEBIS, the financial-services operation which has turned in a modest profit on sales of DM3.8 billion since being set up last year. 
 Much of its business still comes from within Daimler itself. 
 But it may be the one part of Daimler that is able to do a deal with some of the Mitsubishi companies, which are eager for a way into trading, finance and other service businesses in Europe. 
 Daimler's recent decision to take a 10% stake in Metallgesellschaft, a leading German supplier of environmental technology including vehicle-parts recycling, also makes some sense. 
 This was the kind of diversification Daimler should have pursued all along, rather than chasing grandiose &bquo;synergies&equo; which probably do not exist. 
 Mr Reuter remains unrepentant, at least in public. 
 And Deutsche Bank continues to back him, despite Herrhausen's death. 
 But there are hints that the bank would like to surrender its high-profile seat at the top of the company's ruling supervisory board, probably when Mr Reuter steps down in two or three years. 
 By then Mr Reuter's pleas for more time will be history. 
 Daimler will either be a monument to his original vision, or just another lame duck.  
 Asia's airlines 
 Beautiful young things 
 BANGKOK 
 THIS weekend is the start of Golden Week, the traditional kick-off for Japan's holiday season. 
 But any residents of Tokyo who tried to make a last-minute airline booking were probably disappointed. 
 In Bangkok non-stop flights to Europe are also full up. 
 Asian airports are almost as congested as ever. 
 The airlines that fly between them were hit much less severely than American and European rivals by the slump in air travel during the Gulf war and they are bouncing back more quickly. 
 Though Asian airlines experienced some Gulf-war decline in traffic, they escaped the near-collapse suffered by many American and European carriers. 
 Australia's Qantas, hammered by a 50% drop in business on its vital long-haul routes, was the one exception. 
 But Japan Air Lines (JAL) experienced only a 3.5% drop in the number of passengers carried on international routes in the year to March 31st. 
 Analysts expect Singapore Airlines, the world's most profitable airline, to announce a healthy net profit of just over S&dollar;800m (&dollar;450m) for the same fiscal year, down from S&dollar;1.2 billion the previous year but still not bad. 
 Taiwan's China Airlines boasts that 80% of its seats are filled (many American carriers have to settle for 60%). 
 Asian airlines have two basic advantages over their western competitors. 
 First, air traffic in the Asia-Pacific region is growing at a faster rate than anywhere else in the world. 
 Before the Gulf war the International Civil Aviation Organisation forecast that international scheduled-passenger traffic in the region would grow by 10.5% a year to the end of the century, compared with global growth of only 6.7%. 
 The war and a slowdown in the global economy may trim this forecast, but only slightly. 
 The second factor is more important: Asian airlines remain untouched by the deregulation that has swept America and is beginning to inject new competition into Europe. 
 The Manila-based Orient Airlines Association is an informal but effective cartel that fixes fares and shares out business. 
 The main aim of the region's governments, which control or own many of the airlines, is to keep international fares high enough to subsidise low domestic fares. 
 The busiest routes are carved up by bilateral deals between the national airlines at either end. 
 Before the Gulf war, the cartel sanctioned two fare increases, which have yet to be reversed despite the subsequent fall in fuel prices. 
 Such coddling has made Asian airlines profitable, but inefficient. 
 Their least-profitable routes are those across the Pacific, where they are forced to compete with American airlines, for which these routes are the most lucrative. 
 The biggest threat to this cosy world comes from within. 
 Governments in the fastest-growing markets in East Asia are tentatively encouraging domestic competitors. 
 All Nippon Airways was first allowed to fly internationally five years ago and is now a serious rival to JAL on some routes. 
 Kumho, a thrusting South Korean conglomerate that is determined eventually to challenge Samsung and Daewoo, started a carrier called Asiana three years ago. 
 Despite losses of 46 billion won (&dollar;65m) last year, Asiana still aims to have a sizeable fleet of 68 aircraft by 1999. 
 In Taiwan, Eva Airlines is expected to start international flights in July. 
 Singapore Airlines and Hong Kong's Cathay Pacific, two of the biggest Asian carriers, cannot be forced to fly loss-making domestic routes. 
 Webs of bilateral deals protect them from the full brunt of competition. 
 From their secure bases &mdash; at least, in Cathay's case, until China takes over Hong Kong in 1997 &mdash; they are expanding aggressively, to prepare for the day when they will have to compete. 
 Despite the hiccup of the Gulf war, Cathay has not cancelled any of the 17 aircraft it has ordered or any of its options on another 29. 
 Singapore's plans to update and expand its fleet are even more ambitious. 
 It has 36 aircraft on order and 34 under option. 
 When these are delivered, it will sell most of the 43 aircraft it now owns to keep its fleet the youngest &mdash; and hence cheapest to maintain &mdash; in the world. 
 The average age of Singapore Airlines' aircraft is only four years and nine months. 
 Ah, youth.  
 The cost of the car 
 Road space is scarce and valuable. 
 Usually it is also free. 
 The results are smog and traffic jams, which proper pricing would discourage 
 THE past few decades have seen an astonishing growth in road traffic almost everywhere. 
 In Britain, for example, the average daily traffic per mile of road grew by 34% between 1978 and 1988, and by 52% on motorways. 
 Now governments and cities are starting to listen to economists, who have been telling them for years that the use of road space should not be a free gift to motorists. 
 Of course, motorists in most countries pay taxes: on the purchase price of a car, on a licence to use it, and on petrol. 
 But the first two taxes increase the cost of owning a car, not of driving it. 
 And they are often low compared with the true costs of using road space. 
 Even petrol taxes make no distinction between where a car is used, or when, which greatly affects the costs imposed on others. 
 Some of the costs of driving fall on the owner, who pays in cash for fuel and in time and irritation for sitting in traffic jams. 
 But the government pays for repairing roads; other road-users pay for the delays caused by congestion; society at large pays for air pollution, noise and road accidents. 
 Indeed David Newbery, of the department of applied economics at Cambridge University, argues* that the costs of accidents may be as large as all the other costs that vehicles inflict on society taken together. 
 If drivers had to pay all these costs, they would be discouraged from making journeys where the benefits of travelling are less than the costs. 
 There are few places in the world where the costs are higher than southern California. 
 In Los Angeles workers joke that the rush hour begins at 5.30am and goes on to 8.30pm. 
 Several studies reckon that sitting in traffic jams costs Angelenos around &dollar;9 billion a year in lost output. 
 According to the California Assembly Office of Research, the region's cars cause another &dollar;4.7 billion in environmental damage. 
 And worse is to come. 
 The Los Angeles basin may attract around 5m new residents by 2010. 
 On recent trends, state officials reckon that the region's current average speed of 35mph (56kph) will drop to 19mph. 
 The number of vehicle miles travelled will increase by 68%. 
 What can be done to persuade drivers to meet the true costs of their journeys? 
 A new study** throws up some interesting answers. 
 The study's author, Michael Cameron, thinks that roads should be treated like telephone lines or the electricity supply: if customers want to use them at peak times, they should pay more. 
 Congestion costs vary hugely with time. 
 As Mr Cameron puts it, &bquo;At the very time when most people want and need mobility &mdash; during the morning and evening peak periods &mdash; the system actually carries fewer of them than it does at various off-peak times.&equo; 
 During rush hours, freeways may carry fewer than 1,300 cars per hour, per lane; at offpeak hours, 1,800. 
 Mr Newbery puts it rather differently for Britain: cars using city centres at rush hour, he calculates, incur marginal costs more than 100 times higher than cars on the average motorway or country road. 
 Without pricing, road-building provides no relief. 
 Underpriced trips simply increase until congestion is as bad as before, and smog worse. 
 In countries with good public transport, extra roads also suck people away from buses and trains; so more public spending on roads raises total travel costs. 
 Nor does cheaper public transport help much. 
 In southern California, where only 6% of travel to work is by public transport, most users would otherwise have been passengers in cars, not drivers. 
 In Europe, too, subsidising public transport mainly leads to new journeys rather than a switch from private cars (though additional travel may, in turn, generate economic benefits). 
 If drivers paid the true costs of road use, they might switch to less congested times, or make fewer journeys. 
 In southern California the average number of passengers per journey is 1.13. 
 If that rose even to 1.5, travel times would drop by nearly a quarter and pollution by around a fifth. 
 The bluntest way to encourage this would be to increase petrol tax. 
 To reflect the true cost of pollution and congestion in California, Mr Cameron estimates that petrol taxes would have to be raised from today's 28 cents per gallon to &dollar;3.25. 
 Even if this were politically possible, which it is not, petrol taxes punish the rural lunch-time driver at the same rate as the urban peak-time driver, when the latter causes far more harm. 
 Instead, Mr Cameron recommends the following measures (whose effects are set out in the chart): 
 Make people pay more for rush-hour trips, using electronic scanners. 
 Make employers offer workers a cash alternative to free parking. 
 If worker-parkers had to pay &dollar;35 a month, it would double the cost of most commuting trips. 
 Charge more for parking in shopping centres. 
 Introduce a smog tax which would rise with the number of miles travelled (and the dirtiness of the vehicle). 
 Deregulate private minivan services, which are currently prevented from serving many areas. 
 Mr Cameron thinks his scheme would produce cleaner air, fewer cars and a 7mph increase in average driving speeds. 
 But how to persuade drivers of its merits? 
 In Britain Mr Newbery's calculations suggest that, if road-use was correctly priced, the pattern of use would change but total revenues from motoring taxes might not. 
 California taxes on drivers are lower and congestion worse. 
 Proper road prices would raise the motoring tax burden. 
 Mr Cameron has an answer. 
 Instead of the state swallowing all the income, he suggests it should go to more efficient motorists. 
 Each driver would be given a free monthly allowance, which a meter would debit electronically every time a driver entered or left a freeway. 
 At the end of each month motorists would discover their balance and sell any remaining units.  
 American Telephone &amp; Telegraph 
 The wrong choice? 
 AT&amp;T should split itself into two separate companies, one to manufacture equipment, the other to provide telephone calls. 
 Its acquisition of NCR is moving the company in precisely the opposite direction 
 IT WAS in December last year that American Telephone &amp; Telegraph (AT&amp;T) put in its first takeover bid for NCR, an American computer-maker. 
 Five months later, the two firms are within a whisker of agreeing on a deal. 
 While NCR's shareholders are celebrating, Ma Bell's are likely to suffer the inevitable hangover. 
 Not only is AT&amp;T probably paying too much, it should not have been trying to buy the firm in the first place. 
 That is because AT&amp;T's best bet for maintaining growth is to divide its manufacturing businesses from its telephone arm, not to buy more of them. 
 AT&amp;T's original offer valued NCR at &dollar;6.1 billion, or &dollar;90-a-share. 
 At 15 times NCR's falling earnings, the offer was already generous. 
 Now the deal looks likely to go through at a whopping &dollar;7.5 billion, about &dollar;110 a share. 
 Ma Bell is prepared to pay so much because the firm's chairman, Robert Allen, is convinced that the computer and telecommunications industries are converging. 
 In the technical sense he is correct. 
 Telephone switches are just big computers in disguise. 
 Companies that use computers have been connecting them to each other for a decade, often using AT&amp;T's telephone lines. 
 Taking note, AT&amp;T assumed that success in one business meant success in the other. 
 It set up its computer division in 1984, as soon as it was allowed to. 
 The assumption was wrong. 
 Computer-making essentially remains a manufacturing industry, telecoms a service business. 
 To succeed, telephone companies need marketing flair. 
 Once-stuffy AT&amp;T has surprised everyone by displaying plenty of this. 
 The company has concocted new gimmicks such as cut-price Mothers' Day calls or new services such as call-blocking facilities for single women. 
 It has also been deftly successful with its new Universal credit card. 
 But making and marketing computers require a different set of skills: manufacturing efficiently, shipping products rapidly and then providing complicated technical support to finicky business customers. 
 Though the technology that telecoms and computer firms use is similar, success in telecoms services does not necessarily bring success in the computer, or telecoms-hardware, business. 
 Painfully, AT&amp;T has already been forced to recognise that. 
 Analysts reckon AT&amp;T has invested &dollar;2 billion in its computer division since its birth, and that it is still losing &dollar;200m a year. 
 Even when the purchase of NCR is complete, computers will still make up less than a fifth of AT&amp;T's business. 
 More than 60% of AT&amp;T's &dollar;36 billion of sales comes from telephone calls, the remainder from sales of telephone equipment &mdash; the big computer-like switches that work telephone exchanges, and the smaller ones, called PABXs, that offices use to route calls internally. 
 And here lies a contradiction at the heart of AT&amp;T's original business, even before it tried to get into computers. 
 Since trustbusters broke up America's Bell system in 1983, AT&amp;T's biggest switch-customers have been the seven regional &bquo;Baby Bells&equo; born of the break-up. 
 But they are also some of AT&amp;T's toughest rivals in telecoms services. 
 AT&amp;T and the Babies do not compete on the provision of basic telephone services, since under the terms of the break-up AT&amp;T may carry only long-distance calls, the Baby Bells only local ones. 
 But they do compete in advanced services like electronic mail and computer-data networks. 
 These can either run off the public-telephone network, or off the smaller PABXs that control businesses' own in-house telephone systems. 
 While the Baby Bells try to sell corporate customers advanced services using their own networks, AT&amp;T offers the same lot of customers PABXs which allow them to do exactly the same things. 
 Meanwhile, it sells big switches to the Baby Bells themselves. 
 It is hardly surprising, then, that AT&amp;T's switch-sales to the Babies have suffered as a result. 
 Ten years ago AT&amp;T supplied all of America's exchange-switches. 
 Now that share has fallen to 42%. 
 Most of the rest has gone to foreign-based switch suppliers such as Canada's Northern Telecom, Japan's NEC and Germany's Siemens. 
 Hamstrung at home, AT&amp;T needs to do more business abroad. 
 Only 13% of the firm's sales come from outside America. 
 Mr Allen has said he wants to see that percentage double by the mid-1990s. 
 But that will make AT&amp;T's service and equipment-manufacturing businesses step on each other's toes again. 
 Over the past few years foreign telephone companies, and the Baby Bells, have been snapping up stakes in newly privatised telephone companies in New Zealand, Mexico and Argentina, and mobile-telephone franchises even in rich countries such as Britain and Germany. 
 Curiously, AT&amp;T has stood aside from this scramble, apart from filing a joint offer to build Poland's mobile-telephone system. 
 Ma Bell's coyness is hard to fathom. 
 It may be afraid to annoy foreign network-operators with new local services and so jeopardise the chances of selling them equipment, which has accounted for much of AT&amp;T's recent growth. 
 Staying friendly with foreign telephone firms also helps in other ways. 
 The customers AT&amp;T is keenest to serve are global firms wanting global services. 
 Last September AT&amp;T launched a &bquo;virtual private network&equo; covering Japan, Britain, France, Canada and Belgium, which gives firms luxuries like coded dialling over public networks. 
 Another service allows firms with offices in different countries to have centralised telephone bills. 
 Setting up such products needs the co-operation of foreign telephone-network operators. 
 AT&amp;T could find such co-operation elusive if it was also competing with them. 
 The obvious way for AT&amp;T to escape the conflicts of interest between its equipment and service businesses is to split them, perhaps doling out new shares in the two new firms to existing shareholders on a pro-rata basis. 
 At least that would give each half of the business a free run to compete with a growing horde of competitors. 
 Though that might benefit AT&amp;T's shareholders, the idea is heresy to most employees of the firm. 
 AT&amp;T fought hard to hang on to its equipment businesses through telephone deregulation &mdash; the Justice Department took the firm to court on the issue in 1949 and again in 1974. 
 And having just fought for NCR, Mr Allen is unlikely to propose such a break-up.  
 Soviet economic reforms 
 Plenty of shock, no therapy 
 MOSCOW 
 THE &bquo;anti-crisis programme&equo; of the Soviet prime minister, Valentin Pavlov, is the third tranche of an economic-reform plan that began in January with the confiscation of 50- and 100-rouble notes and continued in early April with huge price rises. 
 It is likely to be the last chance to rescue the economy from chaos. 
 Such is the speed of decline (GNP in the first three months of 1991 was 8% lower than it had been in the same period of 1990, imports were 45% lower) that, if this plan fails, the next one may be either an economic state of emergency imposed under martial law, or a kaleidoscope of programmes started by republics after the Soviet Union breaks up. 
 Unfortunately the good parts of Mr Pavlov's new plan are likely to be overwhelmed quickly by the bad. 
 To work, any Soviet economic plan must do two things. 
 First, stabilise the macroeconomy. 
 This means cutting the budget deficit, freeing prices and trade, and preventing accumulated savings from causing an inflationary expansion of demand. 
 Second, create the microeconomic conditions under which enterprises can thrive. 
 This requires privatisation. 
 But any plan must also meet a third, political, condition: it must settle arguments between centre and republics over who controls policy. 
 Judged as a plan for macroeconomic stability, the programme is less bad than its many critics claim. 
 It is based on the so-called &bquo;main guidelines&equo; adopted by the Soviet parliament last September after it had rejected the widely acclaimed Shatalin plan. 
 However, parts of the radical Shatalin plan reappear in the new programme. 
 All prices, it says, will be freed by October 1992. 
 If implemented, this would correct the main weakness of early April's price reforms, which left most prices fixed by government fiat. 
 It would also improve upon January's brutal monetary reform, which tried to deal with savings by confiscating some of them: the new plan would raise interest rates to encourage consumers to leave their money in the bank. 
 It would also open the economy to world trade by allowing easier conversion of roubles into hard currency and repatriation of hard-currency profits. 
 Hyperinflation will still be a threat unless government borrowing (financed by printing money) can be cut. 
 Here, too, the plan borrows from Mr Shatalin. 
 A moratorium is supposed to start next month on all new projects financed by central government. 
 Projects pencilled in for this year which have not yet started will also be postponed. 
 New plans to cut central &mdash; and republican &mdash; government spending are to be agreed upon for the second half of the year. 
 Worryingly, the plan contains few details on how spending on the army and the bureaucracy will be cut &mdash; and it is excessively vague on other points. 
 But it does suggest one reform which, if it went through, would deal with many such doubts. 
 It proposes setting up a sort of Federal Reserve system of central banks in which all 15 republics would be represented &mdash; and which would be told not to lend to the government. 
 This, in effect, would outlaw the inflationary creation of money &mdash; a drastic change, if it happens. 
 All this will benefit the economy only if enterprises respond. 
 That is why privatisation is essential. 
 Mr Pavlov's programme recognises this. 
 One-third of small enterprises &mdash; shops, restaurants and so on &mdash; are supposed to be privatised by the end of this year, two-thirds by the end of 1992. 
 The plan also says republics should continue their efforts to sell land to peasants. 
 But this is not nearly enough. 
 Dismayingly, the plan does not explicitly endorse the private ownership of land. 
 It rejects any idea of giving enterprises away (the only way to privatise in a hurry). 
 Instead, a central fund for state property will be set up to sell large and medium-sized companies. 
 The programme talks of selling a piffling 10% of them. 
 Where sales go ahead, workers are to get a stake. 
 Eastern Europe shows that worker-owned factories can be as inefficient as state-owned ones &mdash; and a lot harder to shut down. 
 The programme gives absurd powers to the central government. 
 It will have the authority, for example, to block sackings and changes in the pattern of production. 
 Unless privatisation is delegated to the republics, the microeconomic conditions necessary for reform are most unlikely to be met. 
 But if the republics are to undertake reform for themselves, agreement must be struck between the central and local governments both on the central-bank system and on who owns which factories. 
 Mr Pavlov said that the anti-crisis programme will work only if it is backed by all 15 republics. 
 That will not happen. 
 The six  refusenik  republics &mdash; the Baltic three, Moldavia, Georgia and Armenia &mdash; want nothing to do with it. 
 For the rest, the plan contains two stumbling blocks. 
 The first is a proposal to outlaw &bquo;political strikes&equo;, use force where the ban is flouted (as it will be) and arrest strike leaders. 
 This is the part of the plan that has attracted most criticism. 
 Though Mr Gorbachev and nine republican leaders signed a declaration broadly supporting the plan on the day the parliament approved it, few republican leaders are likely to agree to use force to break strikes. 
 Second, there is a problem over tax collecting. 
 Republics collect taxes but are refusing to pass them on to the central government. 
 They have contributed only 39% of what the central government requires them to hand over in the first three months of the year. 
 Rapid agreement on the anti-crisis programme &mdash; and bolder measures besides &mdash; might forestall disaster. 
 So might the decision to let the republics go it alone on economic reform. 
 Otherwise, it is too easy to imagine what might happen next. 
 If the republican governments pressed for full wage-indexation, the central bank would be unable to keep its promise not to finance budget deficits by printing money. 
 That would mean that the best part of the programme &mdash; its price reform &mdash; would only cause inflation (already in three digits) to spiral out of control. 
 Meanwhile, thanks to the bad parts, output would fail to recover. 
 In short, things would get worse, leaving a stark choice between civil war or martial law.  
 Another slip-up for Exxon 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 AN INDEPENDENT judiciary is a glorious thing &mdash; in the abstract. 
 In practice, it can be a giant headache, as both the Justice Department in Washington and the Exxon oil company have just discovered. 
 A decision by Russel Holland, a federal district judge in Alaska, on April 24th has, in effect, wrecked a painstakingly worked-out settlement to the messy aftermath of the Exxon Valdez oil-spill of March 1989. 
 Exxon had pleaded guilty to four misdemeanour criminal-pollution charges in return for an agreement that more serious felony charges would be dropped. 
 The plea bargain agreed between Exxon, the Justice Department and the state of Alaska had set the company's total liability at &dollar;1 billion: &dollar;900m of this was a civil settlement to meet costs incurred by the government in cleaning up the 11m gallons of oil spilt into Prince William Sound; the other &dollar;100m was a fine, payable to the Treasury, to settle the four criminal charges. 
 It was this second part of the deal that Judge Holland rejected, stunning environmentalists as well as the company. 
 In his opinion the criminal fine was &bquo;simply not adequate.&equo; 
 He feared that other oil companies might view the fine as an acceptable cost of doing business. 
 The judge's decision cannot be over-turned, and it leaves Exxon facing some unappealing choices. 
 It can withdraw its guilty pleas and go to trial. 
 It can let its guilty pleas stand and then take its chances in court. 
 Or it can negotiate a new deal with the Justice Department &mdash; with no guarantee that this will be any more acceptable to Judge Holland. 
 Exxon has 30 days to consider its next step. 
 Both Judge Holland and Charles Cole, Alaska's attorney-general, insist that rejection of the criminal fine need not affect the larger civil settlement. 
 But, according to the federal Justice Department, the whole package is now in peril. 
 The snag is that a clause in the civil settlement allows Exxon to withdraw from the entire agreement if part of the plea bargain is rejected by the courts. 
 This fresh blow came just as Exxon felt it was struggling free from the morass of the Alaskan spill. 
 The judge's decision was handed down on the same day that Exxon announced that first-quarter profits for 1991 had leapt 75% over the same period last year, to &dollar;2.24 billion. 
 And the final year of the company's three-year commitment to cleaning up the Alaskan coast is about to begin.  
 Ratnering about rubbish 
 RETAILERS have an old saying that you will never lose money by underestimating public taste. 
 But should you gloat about it? 
 In a speech to Britain's venerable Institute of Directors on April 23rd, Gerald Ratner, the eponymous boss of Britain's biggest jewellery chain, said the secret of his company's success was selling &bquo;total crap&equo;. 
 To the delight of his audience, Mr Ratner went on to describe some of his favourite crap. 
 A pair of earrings sold by Ratners outlets for 99p (&dollar;1.70), he reckons, will probably fail to outlast a prawn sandwich (which is admittedly dearer). 
 An imitation book with curled up corners and antique dust &bquo;is in the worst possible taste,&equo; he confirms, &bquo;but we sold a quarter of a million last year.&equo; 
 The previous day, Ratners announced that, despite the recession, pre-tax profits edged up by 1.7% last year, to &pound;110m (&dollar;195m), on sales up by 24%, to &pound;1.1 billion. 
 In 1984 Mr Ratner took over from his father a small loss-making chain of jewellers which now has more than 2,000 shops in Britain and America. 
 In the past seven years Mr Ratner has gobbled up rival retailers, including H. Samuel and Watches of Switzerland (which must be wincing at the boss's cheap-and-cheerfulness). 
 In America the company owns the Sterling chain and in October last year it bought Kay Jewellers for &dollar;425m. 
 Mr Ratner, who is 41, quickly got rid of the snobby atmosphere which prevails in most independent jewellery stores. 
 With posters screaming constant cut-price offers, the original Ratners chain is defiantly down-market. 
 Baked beans are sold with more decorum. 
 But Mr Ratner is clearly giving customers what they want. 
 His shops rake in more money per square foot than most other British retailers. 
 Though the flippant Mr Ratner has said similar things in private before, the strident headlines produced by his speech seem to have shaken him. 
 Customers will understand that his comments were made &bquo;tongue in cheek&equo;, he now says. 
 Besides, they will not be put off because they know a bargain when they see one. 
 Some of his staff even suggest the boss's remarks might boost sales. 
 But Paul Deacon, a retailing analyst with Goldman Sachs, reckons that this last claim is a load of you-know-what.  
 The power of Power 
 AGOURA HILLS, CALIFORNIA 
 IN THIS rural suburb of Los Angeles, a 59-year-old from New England has become the car industry's most revered, and feared, oracle. 
 A good word from Dave Power can turn a car into an enormous hit; a bad word can wreck it. 
 Mr Power's company, J.D. Power and Associates, is the most influential market-research company in the car business. 
 A former financial analyst with Ford, Mr Power set up shop in 1968. 
 But he climbed to his current pre-eminence only after spotting that the competitive battleground in the car market was shifting from styling and speed to quality. 
 In 1981 he launched the first of a series of closely watched consumer surveys. 
 The best known of the Power surveys is the Customer Satisfaction Index, which asks 30,000 drivers to rate the quality of their vehicles and the standard of service provided by dealers a year after their purchase. 
 Other surveys in the Power stable measure the opinions of owners three months (the Initial Quality Survey) and five years (the Vehicle Dependability Index) after purchase. 
 Mr Power says that if the 1980s were the decade of quality, then the 1990s will be the decade in which car makers pay more attention to distribution. 
 By that Mr Power means everything from advertising to warranty repairs, which can together account for about 35% of the price of an average car in America. 
 In Europe and Japan such costs are an even greater proportion of the final price. 
 So what does the expert reckon is the best car to buy? 
 Mr Power gives his stock reply: &bquo;You should be dealing with a retailer you feel comfortable with.&equo; 
 Some help. 
 Mr Power himself drives an 1987 Oldsmobile. 
 That never did very well in any of his surveys.  
 GM's Buick division 
 Making them like they used to 
 FLINT, MICHIGAN 
 ONCE a car to aspire to, Buick lost its lustre and was heading for the scrapheap. 
 Now in the middle of a recession which is shaking the rest of America's car industry, Buick is enjoying a remarkable rebound. 
 It has done it the old-fashioned way, with teamwork, better quality and new models that appeal to its customers. 
 But Buick faces another challenge: those satisfied customers are mostly old. 
 It has to find a way to appeal to younger drivers. 
 Buick's turnaround has given its parent, the ailing General Motors (GM), plenty to ponder. 
 For the first half of the 1991 model-year (which began on October 1st 1990), Buick's sales have risen by 6.6%, compared with an 8.8% fall in all American car sales. 
 Buick's share of the market has grown by about a percentage point, to 6.5%. 
 That is still well below the 9.2% share it had in 1984. 
 But Edward Mertz, the division's general manager, predicts an 8% share by the mid-1990s. 
 Given Mr Mertz's success since taking over in 1986, his prediction should be taken seriously. 
 Buick was one of the main victims of GM's disastrous attempt to automate its way out of trouble. 
 After spending hundreds of millions of dollars turning the division's manufacturing complex in Flint, Michigan, into a high-tech wonderland designed to beat the Japanese, GM's bosses considered closing it down. 
 Buick's robots either failed to deliver what was promised or they broke down. 
 So, frequently, did relations between management and labour. 
 Under threat of death, Buick at last achieved the changes the rest of GM is still struggling to make. 
 To keep their jobs, employees and managers began to pull together as a team. 
 Improving quality became the top priority. 
 The company even tore out some of its expensive robots. 
 The sales department refused to accept any cars from the factory which did not meet rigid quality guidelines. 
 These efforts paid off when J.D. Power and Associates, an influential market-research firm (see box), ranked the Buick LeSabre as the most trouble-free of all cars made in America. 
 Buick also sorted out its muddled product line and drew up a marketing plan that helped it sidestep the most intensely competitive part of the American market. 
 Though noted for conservative and traditional models, like the Buick LeSabre, the division was also selling high-performance cars like the Grand National. 
 That was a mistake, says Darwin Clark, Buick's marketing manager. 
 &bquo;Image is very, very delicate. 
 We can't be a premium American car line this year and go after the boy racer the next,&equo; he explains. 
 With most car makers chasing after baby-boomers, Buick decided to concentrate on the generation of buyers longing for &bquo;traditional American elegance&equo;, a euphemism for cars that appeal to upper-middle-income buyers in their 50s and 60s. 
 Many of these buyers are turned off by the sleek lines and road-sensitive ride of classy European marques such as BMW and Mercedes-Benz. 
 Buick decided to shed cars which did not fit its image, like the Grand National. 
 This was not easy. 
 A vast corporate reorganisation had stripped GM's car divisions of most of their individual design and engineering operations, resulting in scores of bland, look-alike models. 
 With some wheedling and needling, Buick won a little more freedom. 
 One impressive result is the &dollar;26,000-plus Park Avenue, which has received rave reviews. 
 Buick has even revived the Roadmaster, a name last used in Buick's heyday 30 years ago for massive, popular hunks of steel and chrome. 
 Because much of Buick's success is based on sales to the over-50s, its target customers will eventually be replaced by greying baby-boomers &mdash; the very customers it once steered away from. 
 Baby-boomers were weaned on imports. 
 &bquo;They're in a group driving BMWs, Mercedes and Acura (the luxury brand of Honda),&equo; admits Mr Clark. 
 &bquo;To show up in a new Buick is a risk not everyone wants to take. 
 We've got to find a way to make it OK to buy a Buick.&equo; 
 Securing Buick's position as the marque of self-assurance may be the toughest job of all. 
 FINANCE 
 New England's Fleet/Norstar 
 A brilliant deal &mdash; for some 
 NEW YORK 
 FIFTEEN years ago few would have picked out the blue-collar Industrial National Bank of Rhode Island to emerge in the 1990s as the pre-eminent banking power in patrician New England. 
 Yet this is the position in which Fleet/Norstar Financial, as Industrial National has become, is about to find itself. 
 On April 22nd, it was named as the successful bidder in the government's auction of the failed Bank of New England. 
 That will increase Fleet/Norstar's assets by 40% to &dollar;47 billion, catapulting it into the top rank of American banks. 
 The bid, made in partnership with Kohlberg Kravis Roberts (KKR), the group that made its name in the leveraged buy-out binge of the 1980s, enhances the deal-making reputation of Fleet/Norstar's chairman, Terrence Murray. 
 Fleet/Norstar and KKR will pay the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) &dollar;125m for the bank, 80% of that in stock, and will inject &dollar;500m of new capital. 
 For that the new owners will get &dollar;16 billion in deposits at 323 branches spread across Massachusetts, Connecticut and Maine, where Fleet/Norstar currently has 231 branches (plus 329 in New York). 
 They will also get a largely clean loan-book. 
 The FDIC will keep the worst &dollar;5.5 billion of Bank of New England's &dollar;20 billion of assets, and promises for the next three years to take back any more loans that go bad. 
 In sum: heads Fleet/Norstar wins, tails the taxpayer loses, on top of the &dollar;2.5 billion (10% up from the previous estimate) that is already down the drain. 
 Why? 
 The deal has precedents in the purchases in recent years of bust Texas financial institutions by BancOne and NCNB. 
 And the FDIC says the deal was at least better than those offered by the other bidders, Bank of America and Bank of Boston. 
 But there were other, unstated, reasons. 
 New England politicians lobbied hard for ownership of Bank of New England to stay in the region. 
 That offered a chance to merge away New England's banking overcapacity. 
 Fleet has already said it expects &dollar;350m a year of cost savings. 
 Bank of America would have brought extra competition that threatened to remove the surplus capacity the unpleasant way &mdash; by sending some other bank to the wall. 
 Fleet/Norstar got the nod over the larger Bank of Boston for two reasons. 
 First, it is stronger and better managed. 
 Though it also has been scarred by the decline of the region's economy and property markets &mdash; it lost &dollar;48.5m last year, mainly because of bad property loans &mdash; it has suffered less than Bank of Boston. 
 Second, the regulators were looking for an infusion of capital from outside the banking industry. 
 The &dollar;283m KKR was packing outgunned Bank of Boston's outside investor, Warren Buffett. 
 The regulators have made a big effort to prevent KKR's involvement openly breaching the famous walls between banking and commerce. 
 Twice in the past regulators have rebuffed attempts by KKR to invest in banking. 
 The Bank of New England sale was itself restructured three times so that the letter of the law was not broken. 
 For their &dollar;283m the 75 investors that KKR represents will get preferred stock, convertible after three years into Fleet/Norstar stock at &dollar;17.65 a share, plus 6.5m warrants for newly issued Fleet/Norstar stock exercisable immediately at the same price, the last closing price before the purchase was announced. 
 This could give them almost 16% of Fleet/Norstar. 
 The deal looks likely to be as sweet for KKR's investors as for Fleet/Norstar. 
 The bank says it expects its new purchase to break even in the first year and to be operating at a profit of &dollar;150m-200m a year over the following three years. 
 That should help keep Fleet/Norstar's share price rising. 
 It was already up &dollar;3 the day after the announcement, giving KKR investors an immediate paper gain of &dollar;70m.  
 Insider trading 
 The law and the bond-dealer 
 NEW YORK 
 AMERICA'S Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has set a sturdy hare running, one that has been lurking in the undergrowth for 15 years. 
 What securities should be traded in the central market, with publicly quoted prices and all the transparency of information, price discovery and fair-trading practice that go with it? 
 Just companies' equity, or their debt as well? 
 This hare has been aroused by an exchange of letters between Donald Riegle, chairman of the Senate banking committee, and the SEC's ambitious chairman, Richard Breeden. 
 Both are concerned about possible insider trading in the junk-bond market. 
 This is thought to be widespread, and is causing institutional investors, big holders of junk from the late 1980s, to complain that they are getting a raw deal. 
 The SEC's New York office is making informal inquiries into several instances when a share price moved up ahead of a favourable announcement about the restructuring of the company's debt. 
 The suspicion is that members of creditors' committees had used information gained in that role to deal in the equity market, or to trade the relevant junk bonds directly. 
 It is a fair bet that this suspicion is right. 
 Traders at securities houses have long argued to the SEC that they need access to information about the current credits of the companies whose debt they are trading. 
 The commission has been non-committal over whether there should be Chinese walls between the issuing and trading sides of Wall Street firms' junk-bond desks. 
 And when the bankruptcy trustee decided that the members of the creditors' committee in the Federated and Allied Stores chapter 11 proceedings could not trade the companies' shares, the SEC supported a (successful) challenge to the decision, launched by the Fidelity fund-management group. 
 It was afraid that institutional investors would be scared away from serving on committees of creditors. 
 Though there is clearly a potential conflict of interest, it is far from clear that the law against insider trading would be broken by a firm that took advantage of it. 
 This is a grey area. 
 A narrow interpretation of the law, favoured by the courts, requires a breach of fiduciary trust. 
 Such trust, say the courts, is inherent in an equity but not in a debt security, which is governed by contractual relationships, leaving no fiduciary trust to be broken. 
 This, to those interested in the purpose of the insider-trading law, is lawyers' hair-splitting. 
 But one main purpose, protecting the small investor, barely arises with debt securities. 
 A further potential conflict of interest arises when the investment funds of securities firms buy the junk bonds of companies to which the firm might wish to act as financial adviser in a takeover or restructuring. 
 The bondholding may help the firm get its foot in the door to win the business; and once it is inside, the firm will be tempted to propose a restructuring of the company's debt in ways that will benefit its own holdings. 
 Such questions have been raised over the investments of Goldman Sachs's Water Street Fund in the bonds of Tonka and of JCI. 
 Granted that the firm has not broken the law, is the law what it should be? 
 At the SEC, Mr Breeden argues that there is sufficient law to tackle insider-trading abuses in debt securities and other conflicts of interest if they occur. 
 He admits that there is little case-law to prove him right. 
 (Even the jailed junk-bondster Michael Milken was convicted for wrongdoings with equities, not junk bonds.) 
 Mr Breeden does not want Congress to give him new law &mdash; and subject his agency to the crossfire of vested interests that this would involve &mdash; until the courts have tested whether existing law is sufficient. 
 SEC staffers are looking for a suitable test case to take to court. 
 That will not be easy. 
 If there is one thing murkier than how insider-trading law applies to debt securities, it is the market for those securities. 
 Trading involves only a handful of traders who make the markets and a relatively closed universe of institutional investors. 
 It was in 1975 that Congress made the SEC set up a National Market System for securities, which required efficient execution of transactions, fair competition among broker-dealers and the availability of price quotes. 
 At that time, it was proposed that municipal and government debt be included along with equities, and the law was appropriately phrased. 
 However, it was applied mainly to equities. 
 The largest centralised bond market is the New York Stock Exchange's automated bond system, which allows subscribing member firms to enter and execute bond orders through computerised terminals in their offices. 
 Some 3,000 investment-grade bonds are listed there. 
 Debt markets, however, have expanded greatly since then, and debt instruments performing much like equities have proliferated. 
 It is time to consider adding to the central market for equities at least all debt securities that have become quasi-equities, such as junk bonds. 
 This would not please traders, who would lose opportunities to exploit the inefficiencies of the market as it is now constituted. 
 But their interests should surely give way to the greater public good in enhancing confidence in the integrity and fairness of the capital markets. 
 That will become especially important in the coming global battle between exchanges for international securities-trading business. 
 The screen-based systems of the exchanges now make it feasible to disseminate price quotations for debt securities and to report transactions. 
 The PORTAL system of the National Association of Securities Dealers (NASD), developed for trading Rule 144A securities, has the capacity to handle both debt and equity securities. 
 From this NASD has developed, at the SEC's request, a prototype screen-based quotation and trading system for high-yield and other fixed-income securities. 
 Mr Breeden says it appears to offer a &bquo;very significant&equo; improvement to market information and transparency. 
 SEC staffers are busy working out whether and, if so, how to force the debt market out of the dark hidey-holes that its traders, for now at least, prefer. 
 Recommendations are due on Mr Breeden's desk by the end of May.  
 Under plain cover 
 Europe is slowly learning the American habit of private placement 
 IF YOU want to know what the future holds for Europe's financial markets, the best guess is usually to look at America's present. 
 American inventions like swaps, commercial paper and asset-backed securities have already reshaped Europe's financial terrain. 
 If the pattern holds, Europe will have thriving private-placement markets within a few years. 
 Behind private placements lies a simple premise: the fussier investors and issuers become about the design of their securities, the less they will want to deal in the standardised paper available on the public markets. 
 Instead, issuers place their paper privately with small groups of pension funds, insurance companies and other institutions. 
 That logic has created a giant market in America. 
 Europe already has private markets for securities &mdash; such as Germany's Schuldscheine &mdash; but they are mostly plain-vanilla. 
 As so often in finance, the next step is to make things more complicated. 
 Spreading the idea in Europe, however, will not be a simple matter of transplanting an American invention. 
 American firms issue paper privately mainly to skirt the burdensome disclosure rules set by the Securities and Exchange Commission. 
 European regulators are generally less particular, so companies have less reason to escape disclosure by issuing privately. 
 Private securities are also harder to sell in Europe because investors there are less adventurous than their American cousins. 
 Despite these handicaps, Europe's tiny private-placement market is growing fast, to judge from the prosperous glow emanating from banks in the business. 
 Goldman Sachs says its private-placement business in Europe has doubled every year for the past few years. 
 One of Goldman's private-placement specialists is moving from New York to London to take charge of the bank's European business. 
 The European capital-markets operation of J.P. 
 Morgan earns a &bquo;significant share&equo; (Morgan coyly refuses to say how significant) of its income from &bquo;structured&equo; &mdash; ie, complicated &mdash; private placements. 
 Several trends have boosted Europe's private-placement markets: 
 European institutions have grown warier of the public markets and less suspicious of private ones. 
 They used to believe that investing in big, publicly traded issues would keep their portfolios liquid even in a bear market. 
 That illusion was shattered by RJR Nabisco's leveraged buy-out, which turned the blue-chip company's paper into junk. 
 Now investors place less trust in liquidity and more in their own judgment about a security's risks and potential return. 
 And banks now provide almost as much liquidity for private securities as for public ones. 
 Regulators have undergone a similar conversion. 
 In several European countries they are allowing insurance companies and other institutions more scope to invest in custom-tailored private placements. 
 Europe's tax system, a hotch-potch of quirky national systems and criss-crossing treaties, inspires many a private placement. 
 Banks are busily designing privately placed securities that exploit the many available tax loopholes. 
 Custom tailoring 
 Most European private placements belong to one of two categories: securities designed to appeal to a small group of investors, and those tailored to suit a particular issuer. 
 Since buyers and sellers rarely want the same paper, the banker in the middle usually dips into his bag of swaps and options to transform one side of the deal into something more conventional. 
 Medium-term note (MTN) programmes are the vehicle for most investor-driven private placements. 
 These deals usually start when a banker persuades an investor to take a certain punt, a gamble on the oil market, for example. 
 The banker then designs a security to give the investor that exposure. 
 To find an issuer, he turns to his stable of MTNs, pre-arranged programmes under which a company can issue a variety of securities. 
 The bank sells the issue to the investor (booking a generous fee for the service). 
 Because the issuer has no desire to take an oil punt opposite to the investor's, the bank will swap the issuer's oil-related payments for conventional interest obligations. 
 After the Gulf war, Goldman Sachs arranged such a transaction between SEK, Sweden's export-credit agency, and investors seeking to make money by selling oil options, then commanding high prices because of the volatility in the oil market. 
 Goldman came up with a &bquo;bull oil-linked transaction&equo; &mdash; a high-yield security with a redemption price linked to the price of oil. 
 SEK obligingly issued a security paying 10.4%, 2.4 percentage points above the market rate. 
 Goldman swapped that obligation back into a market rate of 8%. 
 The investors enjoy a high yield, but accept a diminishing pay-off on the security if oil prices fall below &dollar;15. 
 Other private placements are designed mainly for issuers, often to exploit tax loopholes. 
 Dozens of French companies, for example, discovered they could raise money that acts like capital but enjoys the tax break granted to debt through &bquo;instantly repackaged perpetual securities&equo;. 
 Through J.P. 
 Morgan, which invented the technique, they issued perpetual debt, using part of the proceeds to buy a zero-coupon bond issued by a triple-A borrower. 
 When the zero-coupon bond matures, in, say, 15 years, the French debt-issuer uses the money to pay off the principal. 
 That is why tax authorities treat IRPs like debt. 
 The balance of debt left (after the cost of the zero-coupon), being irredeemable, counts as equity or near-equity on the issuer's balance sheet. 
 Twists like these, banks hope, will spur the creation of a private-placement market to rival America's. 
 It will not happen quickly. 
 Japanese institutions, once the biggest consumers of privately placed paper from Europe, have bought much less since the Tokyo stockmarket crashed last year. 
 Dutch insurers are reckoned to be the boldest European investors in private placements, but are now proceeding cautiously. 
 Aegon, a big Dutch insurer, says that less than 1% of its 55 billion guilder (&dollar;28 billion) portfolio is invested in structured private placements. 
 Investment bankers come calling, the insurer says, but &bquo;their ultimate goal is not the same as ours&equo;. 
 They want to sell, but Aegon is not sure it wants to buy.  
 America's world tourists: the one-eyed lead the blind 
 NEW YORK 
 FOR all the talk of global markets, America's small investors have remained far more parochial than their counterparts in Europe. 
 They have a big stockmarket in their own backyard. 
 It works well. 
 They can understand the companies. 
 Settlement does not take a fortnight (whatever that may be). 
 And you can buy the shares in good ol' dollars. 
 Stay-at-home Americans missed out on the best of the world's bull market in the 1980s. 
 With American stocks this week again confronting the record books and confounding the experts, the S&amp;P 500 index is 2.5 times as high as in 1980. 
 Whoopee. 
 Prices in the rest of the world, measured by Morgan Stanley's Europe, Australia and Far East (EAFE) index, have risen twice as far. 
 Playing foreign markets is not for the faint-hearted. 
 It would have taken a bold investor to put 40% of a stock portfolio in the Tokyo market in the mid-1980s, even though that was what Japan's share of global stockmarket capitalisation had become. 
 Bad timing is even more likely abroad than at home. 
 And the best calculations can be screwed up by currency movements. 
 Little wonder that, as American investors slowly discover the outside world, they are turning to mutual funds to handle its complexities. 
 There are now some 40 global equity funds (which invest around the world including America), and 60 international ones (which invest only outside America). 
 That is nearly treble the number five years ago. 
 At the end of last year they had &dollar;13 billion and &dollar;9 billion of net assets respectively, according to Lipper Analytical Services. 
 That is still only a combined 5% share of the total holdings of mutual funds. 
 But new funds are popping up by the day &mdash; from plain-vanilla stock funds, such as National Funds' National Global Allocation Fund, which boasts the guru-economist Henry Kaufman as its asset allocator, to exotica such as Scudder Stevens &amp; Clark's Short Term Global Income Fund, which will invest in short-term debt securities. 
 The managers of such funds are on the stump, spreading the message that their day has come at last. 
 Apart from preaching diversification, they proclaim that the 1990s will see a flight to quality, meaning (often illogically) the world's biggest companies, wherever they may be. 
 The funds do not, in practice, restrict themselves to big companies. 
 Even so their search for quality evidently needs some sharpening. 
 Adding foreign stocks to an American portfolio, which is what a global equity fund basically does, seems to produce better performance than investing in American ones alone. 
 But how much better? 
 Purely foreign funds (the international ones) have trailed the EAFE index by miles. 
 To put it crudely, the experts may (perhaps) have done better than the widow in Boise, Idaho, would have done for herself, but still a lot worse than using a pin.  
 Japanese corporate liquidity and investment 
 Drying up 
 TOKYO 
 HOW much money do Japanese companies have? 
 The answer will decide whether Japanese capital investment will stay strong and whether companies will have to sell their shareholdings. 
 Most important of all, it could decide whether Japan's monetary policy will be eased or kept tight. 
 The Bank of Japan thinks the answer is: a lot, implying strong investment, few sales and tight money. 
 When the March figure for money-supply growth was released late last week, showing year-on-year growth in its favoured monetary measure, M2 plus CDs, at a record low of 4.9%, the central bank was quick to squash any hopes that it would lower interest rates. 
 Officials said the supply of money remained high relative to economic activity, and that companies that did not speculate excessively in land and shares in recent years had plenty of liquidity. 
 Those that did, however, continue to go bust in droves. 
 Bankruptcies, mostly property-related, totalled &yen;1.76 trillion (&dollar;13.1 billion) in the first three months of this year, according to the Teikoku Data Bank. 
 On April 22nd Shizushin Lease, a leasing firm, filed for court protection against its creditors with debts of &yen;256 billion. 
 One reason the central bank has been able to keep money tight is that the victims of bankruptcy have so far been mainly property- or finance-related companies with few employees. 
 Where a manufacturing company has had problems, a rescue has been mounted. 
 Thus Nissan, a car maker, said earlier this month it would guarantee &yen;100 billion of loans for its affiliate Ikeda Bussan, a car-seat maker, which has lost lots of money in the stockmarket. 
 By one measure, corporate liquidity is indeed high. 
 The figure for companies' cash, deposits and marketable securities relative to their quarterly sales was 63% in 1990, well above the 45% or so that was normal between 1974 and 1986, before the liquidity boom. 
 Things are less comfortable measured against corporate investment: the ratio is well down from its 1988 peak, and heading for a level not seen since the 1974 recession. 
 Meanwhile, the gap between (non-financial) companies' reported profits and capital spending is rising: at &yen;20.9 trillion, in calendar 1990 it reached 4.9% of GNP, a level not seen since the mid-1970s. 
 Profits have further to fall (17.5% in the current fiscal year, suggests S.G. Warburg). 
 So either investment will also fall or companies will have to raise lots of fresh cash. 
 How? 
 Last year's stockmarket crash has made it harder to issue equities. 
 In 1989 equity-related issues reached a record 6.5% of GNP. 
 Last year they totalled about 2.5% and this year are unlikely to exceed 2%. 
 Banks will not take up the slack. 
 Bank lending is weak, thanks to the Bank of Japan's controls on credit growth and the need to meet international capital-adequacy standards. 
 Banks are also carrying a number of weak companies, hoping that all will come right in the end. 
 For all these reasons, bank-loan growth will be as low as 6% this year, suggests another broker, W.I. Carr, compared with 20% in 1990. 
 When they do lend, banks will increasingly favour big companies. 
 That is already happening: lending to small firms rose only 5.5% last year. 
 Insurance companies aim to plug the gap. 
 Domestic loans a year ago accounted for only 35% of life-assurance companies' &yen;116 trillion in assets; they expect to allocate up to 60% in the present financial year. 
 But they are no longer flush with cash. 
 For the first time in 42 years, the seven biggest companies reported a smaller rise in assets in the financial year to March 31st than in the year before, as uncompetitive savings policies matured and were not renewed. 
 Companies can always try selling the securities they hold, and are doing so: they were net sellers of more than &yen;1.2 trillion of Japanese shares in the first quarter of this year. 
 Fortunately for the Tokyo stockmarket, this selling was absorbed by foreign investors, who were net buyers of more than &yen;2 trillion. 
 There is no guarantee that this will last: the foreigners were selling again last week. 
 Mitsui OSK, Japan's second-largest shipping company, has just announced that it is to close its tokkin accounts (short-term stockmarket-punting money) to help pay for its capital spending. 
 How much can Japan's corporate punters sell before they set the market sliding under their feet?  
 Talking about the dollar, worrying about the economy 
 The world's eyes are on the soaring dollar. 
 The real battle, though, is not over exchange rates but interest rates. 
 The American government wants them lowered. 
 The Bundesbank wants them kept up. 
 It is right 
 THE finance ministers and central bankers of the seven main industrial economies (the G7) will be meeting in Washington, DC, on April 28th. 
 In drafting their communiqu&eacute;, should there be one, they will spare no effort to appear united and quietly confident about the state of the world economy. 
 In fact, they are neither of these things. 
 As the currency markets know only too well, a potentially damaging row over interest-rate policy has broken out. 
 The Americans want lower rates; the Germans (with Britain cheering from the sidelines) do not. 
 This is not the first such row of recent times. 
 The previous one was much in the news shortly before the stockmarket crash of October 1987. 
 As then, America's government wants the Bundesbank to lift its eyes from narrow domestic objectives and adopt a more &bquo;global perspective&equo; &mdash; that is, to cut interest rates. 
 This message has been carried around Europe in recent days by the normally reticent Nicholas Brady, America's Treasury secretary. 
 If the advice is not heeded, he warns, the current recession may spread and deepen. 
 Also as in 1987, the Bundesbank looks unwilling to go along. 
 Its president, Karl Otto P&ouml;hl, has long believed that his first and only duty is to keep inflation low in Germany. 
 This has often led him to tighten monetary policy while everybody around was urging him to ease. 
 In other respects, however, the circumstances are oddly different from those of 1987. 
 In the summer before the crash, the dollar seemed ready to topple (as indeed it did after Black Monday); in the spring of 1991 it is soaring. 
 Why then does America make the same request? 
 The answer is that under any and all circumstances, America's Treasury believes that the Federal Reserve's monetary policy is strangling the economy. 
 Its advice to Mr P&ouml;hl is therefore consistent, after all. 
 In 1987 lower interest rates in West Germany would have made it possible to prop up the dollar (as the G7 countries had earlier promised they would) without raising American interest rates. 
 In 1991 lower interest rates in Germany would virtually oblige the Federal Reserve to cut American rates, in order to brake the dollar's rise. 
 Mr Brady does not, in fact, give a fig for global perspective or, for that matter, the dollar's value on the foreign exchanges; he wants further cuts in American interest rates. 
 Thanks to the dollar's recent strength, the Treasury may be granted its wish even if Mr P&ouml;hl continues to insist on doing his job. 
 From its trough in February the dollar has climbed 21% against the D-mark. 
 This is as much because the D-mark is weak as because the dollar is strong; the dollar has gained only 8% against the yen. 
 This rise against the D-mark is despite a dramatic widening of the interest-rate differential in Germany's favour over the past six months. 
 German short-term interest rates are now fully three percentage points higher than America's (see chart). 
 Since Germany's actual and expected rates of inflation are lower than America's, the gap is even wider in real terms. 
 Powerful forces must be at work to overcome a differential of this size. 
 Financial-market analysts cite three. 
 First, the dollar is still &bquo;fundamentally undervalued&equo;, and by quite a margin &mdash; that is, a dollar buys much less abroad than it does at home. 
 According to this criterion of purchasing-power parity, the dollar should be roughly DM2.25, not DM1.74; &yen;200, not &yen;138; and &dollar;1.40 to the pound, not &dollar;1.71. 
 Second, post-Gulf confidence about the American economy is growing. 
 The main measures of consumer optimism have recently turned up, and spending seems to be reviving. 
 Orders for durable goods fell unexpectedly in March, somewhat damping the new enthusiasm, but the financial markets seem convinced that the recovery, albeit a slow one, is about to start. 
 Third, outsiders' confidence in the German economy has collapsed. 
 Helmut Kohl's electoral defeat in Rhineland-Palatinate and the increasingly fearsome economic slump in eastern Germany have prompted an unaccustomed flight from the D-mark. 
 In their communiqu&eacute;, the finance ministers could usefully point out that the current despair over eastern Germany is overdone. 
 However, the three forces buoying the dollar could well drive it higher over the coming weeks, especially if the G7 meeting gives muffled signals. 
 Until recently officials had issued no public signals at all. 
 Then, on April 23rd, Europe's smaller central banks sold dollars in concert to check the currency's rise. 
 But that was timid stuff. 
 Without firm action to peg the dollar from either the Bundesbank or the Federal Reserve, such intervention is likely to have, at most, only a small and temporary effect. 
 Just now the intentions of the Bundesbank and the Fed are especially unclear, because of arguments at both institutions over who is in charge. 
 In recent weeks stories (strenuously denied) have circulated of disagreements between the Fed's chairman, Alan Greenspan, and the members of the committee that decides the Fed's interest-rate policy: Mr Greenspan, it is said, is in more of a hurry to push rates down than are his colleagues. 
 Mr P&ouml;hl meanwhile is trying to ensure that, when the Bundesbank is restructured to accommodate new representatives from eastern Germany, his own power to insist on a rigorously anti-inflationary policy is not diluted. 
 Add to these uncertainties Mr Brady's new calls for global perspective, and the outlook for monetary policy could hardly be foggier. 
 Whatever becomes of the dollar, new economic forecasts from the IMF suggest that Mr Brady is wrong. 
 The Fund's economists reckon that recovery is about to start in America, and that output there will grow next year by a perfectly respectable 2.7%. 
 Easing American monetary policy now would affect the economy only after a delay of months. 
 It would not bring the recovery forward; instead it would add demand to an economy which, by that time, already had plenty. 
 The IMF's projections also show that America's recession has failed to curb its inflation decisively: according to the forecast, inflation will average 5% this year and 4% in 1992. 
 In other countries too, inflation will be a worry right at the start of the coming upswing. 
 It is a time for Germanically cautious central banking.  
 Mexican debt 
 To him that hath not 
 ASK any hard-headed financier, and he will tell you that debt relief never works: public money given to help struggling debtor nations will end up in the hands of the lenders &mdash; the banks whose over-readiness to lend helped to land the debtors in trouble in the first place. 
 So the &bquo;Brady plan&equo; for debt relief, since 1989 America's main way of cutting the commercial-debt burdens of poor countries, was widely expected to fail. 
 It has not. 
 A new study* shows that Mexico, the first country to do a Brady deal, did nicely; its creditors did not. 
 The Mexican deal, set up in 1989, continued a series of debt firsts for Mexico. 
 In 1982 it was Mexico that kicked off the international &bquo;debt crisis&equo; by refusing to meet its interest payments. 
 It went on to a leading role in the &bquo;Baker plan&equo;, Brady's predecessor, based on debt rescheduling and new loans, not debt relief. 
 This did no good: Mexico's interest payments soared while the economy got worse. 
 By the end of 1988 it had foreign debts of &dollar;100.4 billion, of which &dollar;70.6 billion came from 600 commercial banks. 
 Though Mexico was putting its economy right &mdash; tight fiscal policy and structural reform cut inflation from 159% in 1987 to 20% in 1989 &mdash; huge financing needs blocked any real progress. 
 Over the period 1989&ndash;94, says the study, Mexico stood to need over &dollar;50 billion; despite direct foreign investment, official loans, and bilateral deals, it was &dollar;23 billion short. 
 The Brady plan tackled this need head on. 
 Baker-style rescheduling and new money might have cut short-term financing needs, but could make no difference in the medium term. 
 Total debt would stay the same, or grow. 
 Yet without medium-term stability, flight capital &mdash; Mexican citizens held an estimated &dollar;50 billion abroad &mdash; would not return. 
 The Brady plan's answer was to cut Mexico's debt burden outright. 
 This meant swapping old loans for new, with foreign public funds backing the new debt. 
 Some &dollar;48.9 billion of Mexican debt had been rescheduled under the Baker plan in 1983&ndash;84 and 1986&ndash;87. 
 Under the Brady deal, the banks that made these swaps were asked to tear up the old loans and choose among three new deals in their place. 
 They could cut the face value of their loans by 35%, but get the old interest rate on what was left; keep the original face value, but cut the interest rate to 6.25%; or swap old debt for new debt at the old rates and face value, but with a promise to lend up to 25% more money, and without any of the security (in the form of zero-coupon bonds held by America's Federal Reserve) that the two more generous options offered. 
 To help guarantee the new loans, the World Bank, the IMF and Japan's government stumped up &dollar;3.9 billion of new money. 
 The deal, says the study, was good news for Mexico. 
 It cut net payments to creditors by &dollar;4 billion a year between 1989 and 1994 &mdash; twice as much as rescheduling would have done. 
 The &dollar;23 billion financing gap was filled. 
 More important, it gave Mexico the breathing space it needed to tempt back flight capital and boost GDP growth. 
 It worked. 
 Mexico is now the star economy in Latin America. 
 The creditor banks, reckons the study, did less well. 
 Before the deal the debt covered by the relief package traded at &dollar;19 billion on the secondary market; after the deal it was worth &dollar;19.1 billion-&dollar;19.9 billion. 
 Most of the &dollar;3.9 billion debt-relief money went to Mexico, not the banks. 
 Usually, the study points out, the creditors expect to get the lion's share of any debt relief. 
 The reason is simple. 
 If a deal goes ahead, the debtor gets more money, or owes less debt; it can pay back more of every remaining unit of debt than before the deal. 
 But the deal will work only if enough creditors, in Mexico's case 90% of them, agree to new &mdash; that is, worse &mdash; loan terms. 
 The trouble is that each creditor wants all the other creditors to sign new loan deals, while he keeps his original loan agreement, so that there will be more money, and he gets a bigger slice of it. 
 This is the classic &bquo;free-rider&equo; problem. 
 Economists have taken it for granted that to get round it, creditors will in practice need to get most of the benefit from debt relief. 
 Mexico solved the problem by ensuring that any banks that tried to ride free would lose everything. 
 Mexico, in effect, refused to honour the old loans &mdash; creditors either signed up to one of the three new deals on offer, or lost all their money. 
 Normally, any government trying this sort of trick would soon be being ordered to pay out in the courts. 
 But Mexico had the support of the big western governments; legal action was likely to be futile. 
 Western support for tearing up existing loan deals, then, held the key to Mexico's success. 
 But Mexico got this support only because it had sorted out its economy. 
 The same will apply to future Brady deals. 
 Countries with large commercial-debt problems will get no help from the Brady plan unless, like Mexico, they take on the drastic economic reforms that western governments demand as the price of their support. 
 This is right: without reforms, Brady money would be wasted money. 
 But Mexico shows that, where there is the political courage, the Brady plan can really work.  
 Barclays de Zoete Wedd 
 Limey, go home 
 WHEN Britain's Barclays de Zoete Wedd (BZW), the investment-banking arm of Barclays Bank, snapped up 40 American share salesmen and analysts from a recently defunct Drexel Burnham Lambert, there was much waffle about &bquo;global&equo; equity strategies and the like. 
 By dumping the new arrivals less than a year later, BZW, chaired now as then by Sir Martin Jacomb, has shown up its American adventure for the opportunistic grab it was. 
 The episode is another reminder of just how shaky are the foundations upon which the international aspirations of many of the City of London's securities houses are built. 
 When Drexel's former equity head, Arthur Kirsch, let it be known last spring that Drexel's entire American-equity department might be had as a going concern, BZW did not pause to carry out market research on the venture. 
 At the very least it might have asked itself how it intended to make money selling American shares to Americans at a time when Wall Street's native giants were incapable of doing so. 
 Instead, BZW found itself in a race against County NatWest, rival offspring of another British clearing bank. 
 By dithering over a deal (for a matter of hours, says BZW; five days, says County), BZW missed getting the cream of the ex-Drexel staff. 
 Mr Kirsch now heads County's securities arm in America. 
 County's share of New York Stock Exchange trading has grown sixfold, to 1.6%. 
 The business has even made a bit of money this year. 
 Slicing off BZW's New York limb is a simple enough job; operating on the firm's Tokyo branch, a more deeply grafted part, will prove altogether harder. 
 Yet, mostly because of the collapse of the Japanese equity-warrant market, BZW's Tokyo business swung from a profit of &pound;30m (&dollar;50m) in 1989 to a &pound;30m loss in 1990, three-quarters of all BZW's equity losses last year. 
 While foreigners on Wall Street have largely failed to break into the domestic-equity business, the gaijin houses on the Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE) have won Japanese institutional business at the expense of the big four Japanese securities houses, mostly because the foreigners offer better research. 
 Yet in terms of market share, BZW stumbles near the bottom of the league of 25 foreigners in Tokyo. 
 At the same time it has been lumbered by its parent bank with needlessly big headquarters in Tokyo's most expensive rented building. 
 BZW's cheapest option &mdash; pulling out of Tokyo &mdash; is barely feasible, given that it got its TSE membership only last November after much huffing and puffing from Margaret Thatcher when she was prime minister. 
 The price of BZW's ill-considered worldwide expansion in equities has already been paid by Howard Coates: in February he was sacked as head of the firm's equities division, though he remains with BZW. 
 Mr Coates appears to have carried the can for a strategy that had the enthusiasm of some of those at the top of Barclays Bank, as well as of David Band, BZW's chief executive, and of Sir Martin, who is also a deputy chairman of the parent bank. 
 Mr Coates's replacement, Jonathan Davie, thinks that, in Britain, the firm is well placed to benefit if share-trading volumes continue at the pace of the first quarter of this year. 
 Under Mr Coates, the British-equity business was put on a sounder basis &mdash; first by carefully working out the profitability of each of its institutional clients and, second, by then sacking a fifth of its British-equity team. 
 In Japan Mr Davie wants to boost its weak sales side; he also wants to get into the highly lucrative business of index arbitrage by next February. 
 The trouble is that many other firms want to do the same, so the profits of the business will probably be lower by then. 
 In the meantime the Japanese equity operation continues to be BZW's biggest money-loser. 
 Even if BZW now gets its core equity business on a sounder footing, it still has two potentially divisive problems. 
 The first is deciding what kind of investment bank it ought to be. 
 In London, the firm, created for London's 1986 Big Bang by the merger of a stockbroker and stockjobber, has a formidable team of bond and equity salesmen; it also has good contacts with company finance-directors and treasurers. 
 The combination wins BZW mandates for new issues of securities. 
 Rather than stick to these &bquo;origination&equo; strengths, however, BZW has tried to build the kind of corporate-finance department long boasted by old-established merchant banks that advise on mergers and acquisitions. 
 Sir Martin, like his head of corporate finance, Graham Pimlott, were both once at Kleinwort Benson, just such a merchant bank. 
 Creating a brand-new department at BZW has proved expensive (annual costs run at &pound;20m-30m), which is raising internal questions about its viability. 
 The second problem concerns relations between Barclays and BZW. 
 These have understandably been strained by the collapse of BZW's profits to &pound;5m last year, as well as by the &pound;110m the bank had to pay last November to buy out most of the 200 former partners who together owned a fifth of the investment firm. 
 As a result, BZW must boast the highest number of millionaires of any City house. 
 Sir Martin has long fought BZW's corner at Barclays. 
 Many of those who run BZW are his men, including Mr Band. 
 Yet in November he retires as BZW's chairman, to be replaced by Sir Peter Middleton, currently permanent secretary to the Treasury. 
 Without Sir Martin, the men and policies he stood for will undoubtedly come under fresh scrutiny. 
 Which is never a bad thing. 
 WHAT CHERNOBYL DID 
 Not just a nuclear explosion 
 The effects of what happened at Chernobyl five years ago this Friday will earn a double place in the history books 
 FIVE years ago the fall-out from the world's worst nuclear accident began to show up on radiation-monitoring equipment in Scandinavia. 
 Within days satellite photographs had found the place where something had gone appallingly wrong, in the northern Ukraine, in the Soviet Union. 
 Only after two weeks did any serious Soviet account of the disaster &mdash; a tale of bungling bureaucratic incompetence, clouded by secrecy &mdash; begin to filter out. 
 The world was, and remains, shocked. 
 But in the Soviet Union itself, on this anniversary of the horror on April 26th, people are not just remembering a five-year-old bungle. 
 The bungling has never stopped. 
 The story of Chernobyl's medical and environmental aftermath is now emerging in the Soviet Union as confusedly as the story of the original accident. 
 It comes out in bits and pieces, usually unconfirmed. 
 Cover-ups are still attempted. 
 Some Soviet scientists have recently reported leaks in the vast, allegedly airtight, concrete sarcophagus that encases the smouldering remains of the infamous reactor number four. 
 Radioactive dust is said to be escaping from 800 pits in the area in which dangerously contaminated debris was buried soon after the accident. 
 Statistics are all over the place. 
 Vladimir Chernousenko, the scientific director of the 20-mile exclusion zone around the reactor, claims that the number of immediate Chernobyl deaths &mdash; still officially listed as 31 &mdash; could in fact total as many as 7,000. 
 All the men who worked to shovel radioactive waste off the roof of the reactor, he has told British viewers on Thames Television's &bquo;This Week&equo; programme, are probably dead or dying. 
 Other Soviet organisations have claimed that the accident may yet cause up to 300,000 deaths. 
 Reports measuring the effect of lower radiation dosages conflict with these scare stories, sometimes drastically. 
 The International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) in Vienna is close to finishing its report on the first systematic study of the Chernobyl region by outsiders. 
 Most scientists expect that it will show, as in Hiroshima and Nagasaki, that low doses of radiation have no detectable effect on humans or animals in the first years after an accident. 
 Real changes will show up only in the next ten or 20 years, and even then they may be hard to monitor against the confused background of deteriorating conditions in today's Soviet Union. 
 Whatever the scientists ultimately conclude, all of their data will immediately be disputed, dismissed, changed, and used to further the case of competing politicians in the Ukraine, in neighbouring Belorussia, and in the central government in Moscow. 
 The bitterness of the debate shows that not all of Chernobyl's damage was medical and environmental. 
 Equally important, if not equally quantifiable, were the psychological and political effects of the accident, which finally destroyed &mdash; both in the Soviet Union itself and for outsiders &mdash; the myth of Soviet technological infallibility, and any remaining belief in the honesty of Soviet officialdom. 
 Chernobyl is a big reason why the Ukraine and Belorussia, in 1986 docile republics dominated by Brezhnevite Communists, now have mass strikes and increasingly pugnacious independence movements. 
 A flicker of glasnost, which went out 
 Why, five years later, are respectable scientists still unable to agree on the extent of the damage? 
 Had it occurred in the West, competing teams of scientists from many different countries and institutions would have carried out a mass of surveys of the victims and of the environmental damage. 
 Scores of research projects and endowed chairs would have been set up. 
 Because it happened in the Soviet Union, the Chernobyl post-mortem began in secrecy. 
 Inhabitants of Pripyat, the town nearest to the reactor, were told nothing for 36 hours, and not tested for signs of radiation sickness until much later. 
 Even during the evacuation &mdash; more than 180,000 people were moved &mdash; most of them were not told what had happened. 
 Because the accident went unmonitored during the first few vital hours and days, certain statistics will never be available. 
 Nobody knows, precisely enough to be of scientific or medical use, how much radiation was released into the air, how far it spread, and what the original doses received by people underneath it might have been. 
 Western scientists were not allowed on the scene then, and for many months afterwards had only restricted access. 
 For early data it is necessary to rely on Soviet sources, and Soviet equipment, alone. 
 Yet Grigori Medvedev, the chief engineer at Chernobyl in the 1970s, says in his recent book (see page 125) that Soviet-made Geiger counters registered high levels of radiation on men who had not yet been into the zone, and nothing at all on those who had recently emerged from it. 
 Since then some of the most sensitive parts of the story have been deliberately kept secret. 
 The fate of most of the soldiers and volunteers who fought the fire at the plant, exposing themselves to vast doses of radiation, remains a mystery. 
 This is almost certainly because the decision to send them in during the later stages of the accident was political (western-made robots might have been used instead, had the new Soviet leader, one Mikhail Gorbachev, been willing to let the West learn the extent of the disaster). 
 The Soviet government is still nervous of letting the world know what happened to these people. 
 Many subsequently returned to their homes, all over the Soviet Union, where the local doctors may not know that they worked at Chernobyl and may therefore not recognise subsequent cancers or other problems as radiation-linked. 
 A Communist Party directive quickly classified all information about Chernobyl victims as secret. 
 Even where secrecy was not ordered from above, the squabbling Soviet bureaucracy worked against the efficient collection and distribution of data. 
 In the Ukraine alone at least five different institutions, each with different kinds of equipment of varying quality, are conducting Chernobyl-linked biological and environmental research, which they do not share with one another. 
 All of these institutions are in conflict with their counterparts in Belorussia and with the top Soviet nuclear institute, the Moscow-controlled All-Union Centre for Radiation Research. 
 The struggle is for both money and power. 
 The central authorities in Moscow know that, if they keep tight control over the information they possess, they will also keep their contacts with foreigners and their access to foreign money; Soviet scientists have been known to try to sell Chernobyl statistics to the West. 
 So, to get information about the effects of Chernobyl radiation on Ukrainians, the Ukrainian health ministry is reduced to begging Moscow for local medical statistics. 
 Even when they wanted to be helpful, badly trained Soviet doctors and under-equipped scientists were a hindrance. 
 Morris Rosen, of the IAEA, says that the outside study &mdash; the first to be conducted with the full co-operation of the Soviet government &mdash; ran immediately into technical problems. 
 It got, for instance, not too few statistics but too many, of dubious relevance. 
 Soviet doctors, uncertain what a radiation-related health problem might be, recorded many ailments. 
 To nobody's surprise, they discovered extremely high levels of anaemia, diabetes, bronchial disorder and child deaths &mdash; which might have been the result of poor diet, pollution and the general mess of the Soviet economy. 
 When western doctors went in to look for thyroid and other illnesses, they could not tell whether the apparent increase they discovered in these things was due to radiation or to the fact that no one had done such a thorough diagnosis before. 
 The IAEA scientists found that some medical equipment, and certain techniques of medical examination (such as those used to test for thyroid problems), were unfamiliar to Soviet doctors, and tended to produce different results depending on who used them. 
 This fatal triad &mdash; incompetence, secrecy and bureaucratic squabbling &mdash; added to the fears of those who lived within reach of the disaster's effects. 
 The Soviet people got no systematic reports. 
 Their newspapers provided odd bits of information, such as plutonium-poisoning maps that frightened readers rather than reassuring them because they did not know how to interpret them. 
 Figures purporting to show the amount of radiation in a given place failed to distinguish between natural, background radiation and radiation caused by the accident. 
 No one ever explained what the danger zone was, or that people living outside the no-go area might still be in danger of contamination. 
 Months after the accident, the town of Narodichi, well outside the no-go zone, was found to be polluted, when other towns within the zone were relatively free of radiation. 
 All this increased the natural confusion and suspicion. 
 In Kiev information collected from local hospitals by Greens, showing high rates of infant mortality, were not checked against statistics in similar cities elsewhere in the Soviet Union. 
 In one recent poll 399 out of 400 patients at the Centre for Radiation Studies in Kiev said they did not believe what their doctors told them. 
 Even among those not so badly affected, ignorance about radiation produces powerful if sometimes irrational fear. 
 At vegetable markets in Kiev old ladies argue over the relative radiation levels found in carrots and cabbage. 
 Women leave, afraid to bear children in a city so close to the reactor. 
 Even in the western Ukraine, far away from Chernobyl, headaches and sleeping troubles are put down to the disaster. 
 No figures can quantify this fear. 
 It was certainly magnified by the forced evacuation, the disruption of living habits, the loss of familiar homes and farms, the government's immediate lies. 
 And, as the Soviet Union deteriorates in other ways, the fear and cynicism grow stronger. 
 The political radiation 
 Mass anxiety is never without political consequences, and in a totalitarian society there is no more radical emotion than disbelief. 
 For millions of people in the Ukraine, Belorussia and the rest of the Soviet Union, Chernobyl was a huge new revelation of their government's untruthfulness. 
 If the newspapers lied to cover up such a disaster, they would lie about other things too. 
 That the falsehoods concerned a nuclear power plant sharpened the dismay. 
 For in the Soviet Union nuclear energy is a potent symbol of high technology and modernity. 
 When Soviet citizens began to question the merits of nuclear energy, they were questioning one of the most basic assumptions of their system: that communism would lead them into the high-tech future, and that the high-tech future would be greatly better than the present. 
 Because the Soviet government's promise to bring the modern world into even the most backward of the republics was a pillar of the union's legitimacy, the Chernobyl disaster also led the republics to question the need for the union. 
 If the centre could no longer deliver the goods, reasoned many Ukrainians and Belorussians, the union itself no longer had any purpose. 
 After such a blow to belief in the government's honesty and in its all-seeing ability to fix things, the leap to anti-communist opposition was all the easier to make. 
 This happened very quickly. 
 In the old days, local politicians fought one another to obtain the prestige, jobs and money which came with a nuclear power plant. 
 Today Ukrainians see their nuclear experience as an example of Moscow's environmental imperialism, on a par with dumping toxic waste in Africa. 
 The disaster was quickly followed by the birth of Rukh, the Ukrainian independence movement. 
 &bquo;Chernobyl helped us to understand that we are a colony,&equo; says Sergei Odarich, the secretary-general of Rukh. 
 By April 1988, on the second anniversary of the Chernobyl eruption, fear had made the previously obedient people of Kiev brave enough to hold their first post-glasnost street demonstration. 
 The issue remains central to the actions of the Ukrainian opposition. 
 The miners now on strike have put the closing of the remaining Chernobyl reactors high on their list of demands. 
 Opposition politicians gain popularity by demanding a bigger exclusion zone (see map), lower levels of &bquo;acceptable&equo; radiation in food, air and water, and more compensations for Chernobyl's victims. 
 Now the political consequences have spilled over into Belorussia, and especially into the Gomel area, the part of Belorussia nearest Chernobyl. 
 The Belorussians believe that more than 70% of the fall-out landed on them. 
 They contrast this angrily with their Communist-dominated government's proud claim to be the only republic still handing over its budget dues to Moscow. 
 &bquo;Look how little money we are getting to clean up Chernobyl&equo;, was the complaint during last week's strikes in Minsk. 
 All over the rest of the Soviet Union, the Chernobyl explosion was a powerful force for making people think about the environment. 
 During the past two years work on seven nuclear power stations has been halted, two existing ones have been closed, and the planned construction of four more has been cancelled. 
 Elsewhere in the neighbourhood suspicions of nuclear power have grown just as strongly. 
 Poland has stopped building the only atomic plant it had in mind. 
 The Germans have shut down the remaining Chernobyl-style RBMK-1000 nuclear plants in the eastern part of their now united country. 
 Nuclear nervousness predates Chernobyl; but what happened there greatly strengthened it. 
 The effect on Gorbachev 
 Did the explosion reach even into Mr Gorbachev's foundations? 
 It is worth looking at the way the Soviet leader's behaviour changed in the course of the crisis. 
 His first reaction was the standard, old-style Soviet one: disappear, set the jaw, don't say anything in public. 
 The first comments on Soviet television, three days after the explosion, were curtly uninformative. 
 The Kremlin's first reaction to western reports was an attempt to say the West was trying to make a mountain out of a molehill. 
 Then, after 18 days of stonewalling, Mr Gorbachev at last came out and faced the issue. 
 Perhaps the disaster had reinforced the belief already taking shape in his mind, that something was deeply wrong with the Soviet system. 
 Perhaps the enormity of the facts and figures reaching his desk enabled him to overcome, for the first time, the old Marxists who were already resisting his attempts to change the way things were done. 
 Others certainly remember Chernobyl as a turning-point. 
 Marshal Sergei Akhromeev, now Mr Gorbachev's military adviser and, at the time, the man who organised the evacuation of Pripyat and entombed the stricken reactor, says that the two most memorable days in his life were the German invasion of his country in 1941 and the day of the Chernobyl explosion. 
 Seven hours after he learnt of the accident, &bquo;it was already clear to me how dreadful the consequences were.&equo; 
 He was in regular telephone contact with Mr Gorbachev. 
 For whatever reason, tactics changed abruptly on day 18. 
 All would be revealed, Mr Gorbachev said on national television, for the Soviet people had a right to know. 
 Soviet television crews were taken to the site, telegenic Soviet doctors were produced to discuss the likely consequences. 
 Reports of the disaster, albeit strictly censored ones, were shown to the Soviet public for months afterwards. 
 This was Mr Gorbachev's first important act of international public relations and domestic damage-control. 
 It was also his first signal to the Soviet press that old habits were no longer good enough. 
 It led to unprecedented openness towards the IAEA. 
 It was the birth of glasnost. 
 The attempt at honesty about Chernobyl had strict limits, and was neither thorough nor consistent; but it was a break, never mind an incomplete one, with the Soviet past. 
 The cost is high, in two ways 
 Five years later, as glasnost and perestroika go sour together, the economic consequences of the Chernobyl disaster are still being calculated. 
 The building of the now leaking sarcophagus alone cost an astonishing amount of money, on the best estimate available. 
 As much again, or more, may be necessary to replace it. 
 Even if the political will were there, the money to put it all right again is not. 
 The governments of an independent Ukraine and Belorussia would find it almost as hard to raise the cash as the Soviet government has done. 
 Even higher costs come in the form of lost land and buildings. 
 Some 5m hectares of Ukrainian farmland and 1.5m hectares of forest are now contaminated. 
 In Belorussia 20% of the agricultural land can no longer be used. 
 The distribution of food, never well organised, has been badly disrupted. 
 Even more expensive for a nation with an acute housing shortage is the loss of whole towns. 
 Pripyat stands today like a ghost city, its abandoned ferris-wheel creaking in the wind, its expensive, paved streets empty of pedestrians. 
 Some members of the Ukraine's anti-communist opposition suspect that the cost of evacuating contaminated areas is the chief obstacle to the discovery of new danger zones. 
 &bquo;Human beings are replaceable, land and buildings are not,&equo; says a local Green, Volodymir Tikhii. 
 Still, the demand grows for more compensation, for better-defined danger zones, for tougher restrictions on food grown in contaminated areas. 
 The subject continues to fuel Ukrainian and Belorussian demands for independence. 
 And yet it is as if the Gorbachev regime, having half-learnt its lesson in 1986, has forgotten it again. 
 Problems with the Chernobyl power station continue to be dealt with on a crisis-by-crisis basis. 
 Just a year ago one of the still-functioning reactors was closed down after another emergency released a small cloud of radioactive vapour into the air. 
 The Soviet government, which once seemed to have recognised the danger of secrecy, evasion and falsehood, may now be slipping back into old ways, in even bigger matters than nuclear power. 
 In the end the consequences of Chernobyl may be more than a horrifying collection of statistics about unleashed radiation, deformed lives, premature deaths. 
 Because the disaster revealed something about the basic nature of the Soviet system, at a moment when it had at last become possible to do something about that system, the political consequences may prove the most profound of all. 
 BUSINESS THIS WEEK 
 Economical truths 
 As the D-mark weakened following a poor election result for Germany's ruling Christian Democrats, the dollar hit a 16-month high. 
 European central banks stepped in to stem its rise. 
 Amid dire warnings from Valentin Pavlov, the Soviet prime minister, that industrial production would plunge and millions of jobs would be lost, the Supreme Soviet endorsed his emergency plan to rescue the Soviet economy. 
 But the plan needs the co-operation of the republics. 
 With the federal government under increasing strain, Yugoslavia devalued the dinar for the second time in four months, this time by 31%. 
 Suzuki is to take a 40% stake in a joint venture to make cars in Hungary. 
 It will be the first Japanese car-maker to go into business in Eastern Europe. 
 Electronic soup 
 AT&amp;T's hostile bid for NCR turned a lot friendlier when Ma Bell met the computer company's asking price of &dollar;110 a share, though none of the &dollar;7.5 billion will be in cash. 
 With an eye to cutting costs, AT&amp;T Microelectronics and Japan's NEC are jointly to develop basic technologies to make new generations of chips. 
 Meanwhile, as Europe's electronics companies demand that the European Commission protect them from Japanese competition, NEC is thinking of taking a stake in Groupe Bull, France's loss-making state-owned computer maker. 
 Another setback for Japan's NHK. 
 A rocket explosion at Cape Canaveral destroyed a satellite being sent up by the public-broadcasting company, possibly wrecking its chances of starting to broadcast commercial high-definition television in November. 
 Keeping account 
 Guinness Mahon, a British merchant bank 65%-owned by Bank of Yokohama, gave warning that bad debts will plunge it into an after-tax loss of &pound;35m (&dollar;67m) for the six months to March 31st. 
 This prompted the Japanese bank to cover the loss with a &pound;50m rights issue. 
 Another British merchant bank, Kleinwort Benson, owned up to writing off loans totalling &dollar;23m which it had sunk into an American partnership controlled by one of its directors. 
 Even more embarrassingly for the struggling bank, it had to fork out a further &dollar;2.4m to end the agreement. 
 Results from American investment banks exceeded expectations, confirming the recovery in the securities business. 
 An increase in underwriting and trading volume produced sharp gains in the quarterly net incomes of Salomon, Morgan Stanley and Alex Brown. 
 Salomon more than doubled its first-quarter net income, to a record &dollar;273m. 
 Fleet/Norstar and Kohlberg Kravis Roberts beat Bank of Boston and Bank of America in the battle to buy Bank of New England. 
 Fleet, which with KKR will pay &dollar;625m, becomes the largest bank in New England. 
 American banks will have to write down by a further 10&ndash;20% their medium- and long-term loans to Brazil and Argentina, increasing pressure on the second-quarter earnings of some of the big banks. 
 Looking good 
 A consortium led by Lockheed and also involving Boeing and General Dynamics beat out a rival consortium of Northrup and McDonnell Douglas to win a &dollar;65-billion order to build the next generation of America's stealth fighter. 
 Over 20 years the Lockheed-led group will develop and produce 648 aircraft. 
 Pratt &amp; Whitney is to build the engines. 
 The amount spent on European television advertising will double by 2000, to &dollar;27.5 billion in real terms, according to Zenith, a subsidiary of Saatchi &amp; Saatchi. 
 And while more than &dollar;1 billion was spent on advertising on satellite television in 1990, that will quintuple by the end of the decade, taking a fifth of all advertising expenditure. 
 American oil companies did well in the first quarter, helped by fat profits on refining. 
 Mobil's net earnings rose to &dollar;710m, up by 78% on the same period of 1990. 
 Amoco, not far behind, rose 72% to &dollar;803m. 
 Strong gains came from other oil producers too, including Texaco, Chevron and Occidental. 
 Pay up 
 At Lloyd's of London insurance market, 3,000 names (investors) are being asked to come up with &pound;100m (&dollar;170m). 
 The names, on marine syndicates 406 and 448, will have to cover 1988 underwriting losses relating to asbestosis and pollution claims in America. 
 A judge in Alaska rejected part of the &dollar;1 billion settlement of the Exxon Valdez oil spill, saying it was too lenient. 
 The ruling could mean years of further delay. 
 The Senate passed a bill to reform American futures markets that will tighten trading rules, increase market surveillance and transfer oversight of stock-index futures to the Fed. 
 And in London pit trading of equity options is to move to the small screen. 
 Germany's privatisation agency, the Treuhand, launched the largest D-mark commercial-paper programme so far, to raise DM2 billion for east German restructurings. 
 With more and more restaurants dropping the expensive charge card, American Express is to lower its fees, but only to those outlets that file charge records electronically. 
 In Japan Amex is joining with Sumitomo Bank to issue personal charge cards and make loans. 
 SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 
 The poor man's space-probe 
 APART from expensive moonshots, meteorites are man's only source of rocks from outer space. 
 Stones from the sky arrive infrequently, so there is a premium on discovering old falls to feed the voracious appetite of science. 
 One of the best places to rummage for these antiques is Antarctica. 
 Any rock lying around on the frozen continent stands a good chance of being a meteorite as &mdash; the occasional ice-piercing mountain aside &mdash; there is nowhere else to come from but the heavens. 
 And antarctic meteorites have two added bonuses: they are refrigerated and they are free from contamination by other rocks. 
 In an impure world, they retain the purity of their chemical message. 
 Americans and Japanese have been collecting in Antarctica for years. 
 European scientists have decided that they need to catch up. 
 The EUROMET project, with a budget of 400,000 ecus (&dollar;480,000), has been given the job of building an EC meteorite mountain, and teams of hardy Euro-researchers are already out scavenging. 
 Ian Franchi, of Britain's Open University, and his colleagues have just spent three weeks on crampons and skidoos, combing the ice sheet for these itinerant boulders. 
 The first haul of 264 specimens has now arrived at the Open University's base in Milton Keynes. 
 Europe's scientists are waiting to pounce. 
 What do they hope to discover? 
 Most meteorites are thought to come from the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter. 
 Since rocks of different composition absorb and reflect light differently, astronomers can usefully classify the asteroids into 16 groups on the basis (more or less) of their colours. 
 Meteorites fall into similar groups. 
 For example, Vesta, the fourth-largest asteroid, reflects light in a unique way: some 50 meteorites match it closely. 
 So by examining meteorites it is possible to discover what some of the asteroids are made of without ever having to visit the asteroid belt. 
 A few of the rarer sorts of meteorite have been chipped off much larger blocks: the Moon and Mars. 
 Presumably they were thrown clear of these planets by the impact of yet bigger meteorites. 
 In the case of lunar stones it is relatively easy to tell whether or not this has happened: there are the expensive Apollo samples to compare them with (most lunar rocks are chemically similar). 
 The Martian ones were harder to identify. 
 Sometimes they have gas trapped inside them. 
 Analysis of the light absorbed by the atmosphere of Mars reveals a picture of what it is made of; it matches the gas in the meteorites. 
 So the rock-scavengers know that they have got bits of the Martian surface without having to go there. 
 One Martian meteorite already recovered from Antarctica, which has been analysed at Milton Keynes, contained significant amounts of organic chemicals. 
 Collected elsewhere, these might have been written off as terrestrial contamination. 
 Since they come from Antarctica they are almost certainly genuine. 
 This does not mean that life has been found on Mars. 
 &bquo;Organic&equo; does not, in chemical jargon, mean biological; it means of the type found in living creatures. 
 This is quite a find nonetheless. 
 The American Viking craft that landed on Mars reported that there was no organic material there &mdash; another victory for the poor man's space-probe. 
 Not all meteorites arrive with a whoosh and a bang. 
 Plenty of small ones just float down through the atmosphere like dust &mdash; which, at a tenth of a millimetre across, is pretty much what they are. 
 Two Frenchmen, Michel Maurette and Michel Pourchet, comprise a second EUROMET team. 
 They set themselves the difficult task of disentangling this cosmic dust from the earthly sort. 
 Once again Antarctica, pristine and pollution-free, beckoned. 
 Mr Maurette, who works at the CNRS Nuclear and Mass Spectrometry Centre near Paris, and Mr Pourchet, a glaciologist from the University of Grenoble, devised a scheme to prise micrometeorites from the continent's icy grip using hot water and careful filtration. 
 Fire and ice 
 Even that turned out to be no simple task. 
 The ice to be melted must be of the transparent blue variety, which is free from fine cracks through which the hot water can drain. 
 Such ice is rare and generally found near the coast. 
 Having taken such pains to avoid industrial contamination and natural dust, the team ran into a novel form of pollution that repeatedly clogged their filters: penguin feathers. 
 However, perseverance paid off and, after melting and filtering 256 tonnes of ice, the team came up with 10,000 micrometeorites. 
 Some, they believe, are truly ancient. 
 The meteorites that are fragments of asteroids are sprightly youngsters of a mere 4.6 billion years or so. 
 But micrometeorites often have a loose texture, which suggests that they have never been part of anything big, heavy and hot. 
 Many probably pre-date the solar system, having perhaps been protected inside comets. 
 Some, more recently arrived, may have been captured directly from interstellar space. 
 A few of the more peculiar large meteorites also seem to contain cosmic dust. 
 Edward Anders at the University of Chicago, and Ernst Zinner of Washington University in St Louis, Missouri, have identified crystals of diamond, graphite and silicon carbide. 
 The last two appear to come from several different red giants &mdash; stars nearing the end of their lives &mdash; that shed their atmospheres into space as they died. 
 These red giants were probably close neighbours of the infant sun and the ejected matter fell into the solar nebula. 
 The diamonds carry evidence of the explosion of a supernova. 
 Since some astronomers believe that the shock wave from a supernova would be needed to trigger the formation of a solar system, direct evidence of such an explosion would be illuminating, to say the least. 
 The new pages of the meteoritic book waiting to be read in Paris and Milton Keynes may provide such evidence. 
 Or they may yield a piece from another planet, such as Mercury. 
 This is one Euro-mountain that can never grow too big.  
 Superconducting ships 
 Unpropelled to stardom 
 KOBE 
 A BOAT that can run swiftly and silently without a churning propeller has been the dream of naval commanders ever since the first submarine slid gurgling beneath the waves. 
 The American navy has been tinkering for decades with &bquo;silent drives&equo; to out-fox the sonars on enemy ships. 
 The Soviet navy has been doing so as well. 
 Both have experimented with ways to propel a vessel using giant superconducting magnets and powerful electric currents instead of conventional screws. 
 A Japanese shipbuilder, Mitsubishi Heavy Industries, has now joined the race. 
 Its silent prototype &mdash; a 30-metre-long surface craft called Yamato-1 &mdash; is to be launched in the next month or two. 
 It, too, uses a superconducting electro-magnetic propulsion (SEMP) system to slide silently through the water. 
 But, unlike the American or Soviet prototypes, the Yamato-1 is no warship in the making. 
 It is the basis for a range of ocean-going ferries and cargo vessels that Japanese shipbuilders hope to sell in a decade's time. 
 The Japanese work on SEMP drives began in 1985 under the auspices of the Ship and Ocean Foundation. 
 By 1987 trials had begun using a 2.6-metre model in the foundation's test tanks in Tsukuba, the &bquo;technopolis&equo; north-east of Tokyo. 
 From the Tsukuba results, a design for a 30-metre hull was developed by a team led by Seizo Motora of Tokyo University. 
 Refinements for the propulsion system came from a group working with Kensaku Imaichi at Osaka University. 
 Ships using SEMP drives rely on the &bquo;Lorentz force&equo; for propulsion. 
 This is the thrust that is generated when a magnetic field is applied vertically downwards into the water and an electric current discharged horizontally across its path. 
 The result (which can be deduced from Fleming's left-hand rule &mdash; the only two-fingered gesture in the school syllabus) is a force at right angles to both the current and the magnetic field &mdash; ie, along the main axis of the boat. 
 The trick is to pack as much magnetic punch into as small an amount of seawater as possible. 
 That means using magnets made of a superconducting material such as niobium-titanium alloy. 
 Operating at temperatures close to absolute zero (-273C), super-magnets deliver the most powerful fields available and consume practically no electricity while operating in their superconducting (ie, loss-free) state. 
 The Mitsubishi boat has two main SEMP drives, each with six superconducting magnets wrapped around its own duct through which seawater is drawn. 
 Electrodes inside each duct pass a current across the seawater as it flows through the duct. 
 The resulting Lorentz force causes the water to be squirted energetically through the exit nozzle. 
 Together the Yamato-1's two SEMP drives provide enough punch to push the 185-ton (525-cubic metre) experimental craft through the water at eight knots. 
 So far, the Ship and Ocean Foundation has spent some &yen;5 billion (&dollar;36m) on the Yamato-1 and its SEMP drives. 
 The private foundation fostered wide support for the project by sprinkling money over lots of Japanese manufacturers. 
 One set of thrusters was made by Toshiba, the other by Mitsubishi. 
 Kobe Steel supplied the liquid-helium refrigerator for super-chilling the magnets close to absolute zero. 
 Sumitomo Electric developed the superconducting coils for one set of thrusters, while Furukawa Electric provided the other set of coils. 
 The vessel itself was built by Mitsubishi in its Kobe shipyard. 
 More money has been promised to cover the coming sea trials. 
 The purpose of the Yamato-1 is to demonstrate the principles embodied in the SEMP drives. 
 With a top speed of only eight knots, it will not win any blue ribands. 
 It will not even compete with ordinary propeller-driven ships &mdash; let alone hydrofoils or hovercraft that skim the surface at 40 knots or more. 
 Ultimately, though, a ship with no rotating parts in its engine room should be not only quieter, smoother and more efficient than a conventional vessel, but a good deal more reliable as well. 
 Because the thrust propelling the ship is directly proportional to the current applied to its seawater electrodes, it should be easy to control. 
 Reversing the polarity of both thrusters would bring the vessel to a rapid halt; swapping the polarity of just one of them would let it turn on a sixpence. 
 Japanese engineers reckon that ships with SEMP drives ought to fill a niche between conventional bulk-carriers and speedy surface-skimming craft &mdash; providing a means of carrying, say, 300&ndash;400 passengers at 25&ndash;30 knots. 
 To become commercial, though, the magnets will have to be made at least two-three times more powerful and a good deal lighter than they are today. 
 Not an insurmountable problem, say the designers. 
 Since it is the world leader at fashioning new-fangled superconductors made from thallium and bismuth (which work at higher and more convenient temperatures), Sumitomo Electric sees no reason why it should not be supplying coils for sea-going SEMP vessels before the decade is out.  
 Aluminium and heart disease 
 Troubled waters 
 IMAGINE a line drawn across Britain from the Severn estuary to the Wash. 
 North of the line there is a significantly higher risk of sudden death from heart disease than there is south of it. 
 Above the line, broadly speaking, colder, wetter regions of well-weathered rocks produce soft drinking-water; south of the line, younger rocks lead to harder water. 
 Could these facts by any chance be related? 
 Derek Birchall, a senior scientist at ICI, based in Runcorn, argues that a vital something possessed by the harder waters of the south can help to explain its lower rate of sudden heart attacks. 
 He thinks that the magic ingredient is silicon: a relative deficiency of silicon in soft water lets aluminium concentrations build up, especially under the conditions produced by acid rain. 
 It is this increased amount of aluminium that may damage the heart by interfering with its electrical activities. 
 Aluminium is the third most abundant element on earth. 
 Too much of it in the body causes anaemia, heart disease, bone disorders and fatal dementia. 
 Yet most people never suffer the consequences of aluminium poisoning. 
 Why not? 
 According to Mr Birchall, the answer could be that they are protected by silicon and that the main biological job of silicon is simply to help living things keep aluminium out. 
 Silicon is one of several elements that biochemistry textbooks like to describe as a &bquo;required trace element whose precise biochemical role is still unknown.&equo; 
 True, silicon is involved in the formation of bones and connective tissue &mdash; tendons, ligaments and cartilage &mdash; but nobody quite knows how. 
 Without silicon, plant growth is retarded and animals do not grow properly (they also suffer damage to their bones and cartilage). 
 Everything returns to normal when silicon is reintroduced into the diet. 
 What Mr Birchall noticed was that a diet lacking in silicon seems to have the same effect as one rich in aluminium. 
 Most of what is known about acute aluminium poisoning comes from studying patients treated for kidney failure by dialysis. 
 This treatment concentrates aluminium in the blood, and the anaemia, bone disorders and dementia that result from aluminium poisoning all respond to a reduction in aluminium levels in the dialysis water. 
 Mr Birchall also knew that acid waters, which contain higher levels of aluminium, are lethal to fish. 
 But when he kept salmon in water with lethal levels of aluminium and much higher silicon concentrations, not only did the fish survive, they absorbed less aluminium than other fish kept in normal water. 
 Aluminium likes silicon: it has a greater affinity for inorganic silicate than for anything else. 
 In water it forms aluminosilicates, which are inert as far as living organisms are concerned, so long as the level of acidity stays low &mdash; the silicon will make the aluminium separate out harmlessly. 
 But if the acidity rises (for example, because of acid rain), it dissolves and can enter organisms. 
 The reason why aluminium is so toxic is that living things mistake it for iron. 
 The atoms of the two metals have similar sizes and carry the same electrical charge. 
 But whereas organisms can prevent a lethal build-up of iron by wrapping it in a protein called ferritin, no such defence exists against aluminium. 
 To make matters worse, the protein that transports iron inside organisms, called transferrin, also carries aluminium. 
 Unless there is some way to block it early on, aluminium has virtually free access into cells &mdash; which is where it does most of its damage. 
 In cells, aluminium interferes with the release of calcium (among other things). 
 This disrupts the message system that cells use to communicate with one another, in which electrical impulses are carried across membranes by charged atoms of calcium and chloride. 
 If cells do not communicate efficiently, the organs they are a part of &mdash; be they hearts, brains or bones &mdash; cease to work properly. 
 Some work needs to be done before the connection between aluminium and heart disease is proved to everyone's satisfaction. 
 But Mr Birchall has started a hare that many researchers will be watching.  
 Not a goat to goad 
 THANATOSIS sounds a nasty thing to have; in fact it can be a clever thing to do. 
 Some insects, snakes and other preyed-upon creatures &mdash; most famously the opossum &mdash; have perfected the useful trick of feigning death if captured in order to escape when a predator relaxes his grip. 
 But that is not what the myotonic, or &bquo;fainting&equo;, goat is up to. 
 Frighten or surprise one and it will stiffen and keel over in what appears to be a dead faint. 
 Less than a minute later it will be on its feet again as if nothing had happened. 
 The whole performance seems utterly pointless. 
 And dangerous for the goat: a myotonic goat picking himself up from his umpteenth collapse of the day might wonder why natural selection had not taken its course long ago and dispensed with his unhappy breed. 
 That it did not do so may in part be due to the late H.H. Mayberry, from Marshall County, Tennessee, who in the early 1880s paid a stranger from Nova Scotia &dollar;36 (about &dollar;800 in today's money) for four of the goats on the strength of their &bquo;strange fits or fainting spells, the like of which had never been seen before&equo;. 
 Many of the goats described in the 30 or so scientific studies that have since been published on the phenomenon (the earliest in 1904) can be traced to those bred and cared for by Mayberry. 
 Whether his fainting goats were a new mutation or part of an older breed remains unclear. 
 In his prize-winning paper, &bquo;The Myotonic Goat: A Historical Perspective and Description of Hereditary Myotonia in an Animal Model&equo;, James Atkinson of Vanderbilt University in Nashville, Tennessee, notes that the goats' condition closely resembles Thomsen's disease, a hereditary disorder in people that causes spasms and rigidity in certain muscles when any attempt is made to move. 
 The sudden movement of a frightened myotonic goat trying to flee triggers a rapid stiffening of limbs, back and neck that either leaves the creature unable to move or causes it to topple over, legs rigid and outstretched. 
 The goat remains conscious throughout, no doubt cursing its parentage. 
 Transforming a herd of myotonic goats into a passing-out parade is not as easy as it sounds. 
 Warm goats are less prone to fainting, as are pregnant or (oddly) dehydrated ones. 
 Old, cold goats tend to be easiest to topple. 
 Repeated attempts to provoke an attack may cause the symptoms to disappear altogether. 
 The garish shirt that caused a myotonic goat to faint at first sight may have little effect once the animal has grown used to its owner's poor taste. 
 Fainting goats have come a long way since the days when farmers used them as decoys to protect herds of sheep from coyotes (coyote arrives; goat faints and is devoured; sheep escape). 
 Like pot-bellied Vietnamese pigs, the goats are fast becoming trendy pets, changing hands at up to &dollar;1,000 a time and catered for by groups like the International Fainting Goat Association (newsletter: Fall in Love With Fainters) and the Tennessee Fainting Goat Association. 
 Fainting derbies are planned, with owners competing to see whose goat can faint fastest &mdash; premium fainters spend most of their lives horizontal. 
 Perhaps Mayberry should have let evolution take its course after all. 
 INTERNATIONAL FINANCE 
 Gamblers, masters and slaves 
 Corporate finance is being blamed for a mass of political, social and economic ills. 
 But, argues Bill Emmott, that is to confuse cause and effect 
 WHEN the capital development of a country&equo;, warned Maynard Keynes, &bquo;becomes the by-product of the activities of a casino, the job is likely to be ill-done.&equo; 
 As with many of the epigrams to which England's most famous economist was prone (when he wasn't prone in his Cambridge bed placing his college's stockmarket bets), it would be hard for a reasonable man to disagree. 
 Casinos sound such arbitrary and decadent places; nobody would want their economy's fate to be determined in one. 
 Yet a casino is exactly what many bosses, politicians and pundits believe to have been the home of Anglo-American corporate finance in the past five years or more: a den of greed and chance in which the only way to win is to fix the roulette wheel. 
 That is a harsh judgment to make of the freest-flowing and most sophisticated (that is, complicated) financial markets the world has ever known. 
 Yet it is fast becoming conventional wisdom about the liberal markets of America, Britain, Canada and Australia, both at home and abroad in their less financially liberal rivals, such as Germany, Japan and France. 
 The financial booms of takeovers, junk bonds, bundling and unbundling have come and gone, leaving behind successes and failures but also &mdash; and most importantly &mdash; some powerful lobbies among the losers. 
 Main Street is pitted against Wall Street, industry against the City of London. 
 More broadly even than that, for the first time since the 1930s finance is taking centre stage in debates about economic policy, industrial competitiveness and even relative political power. 
 Apart from the casino, another favoured metaphor is that of master and slave. 
 In Anglo-American finance, it is held, the proper order of things has been reversed: finance should be the slave of industry, but has instead become its master. 
 Companies have shouldered too much debt, to play their own financial games or to avoid being taken over; the balance of risk and reward has become skewed; the ethics of advisers and intermediaries have come into question; the market has departed from good sense and sound financial principles, and has passed, with Alice, into a looking-glass world in which words, prices and obligations mean only what people claim they mean, nothing more. 
 Little has altered to make finance in America and Britain suddenly different from the way it was 10, 20 or even 30 years ago. 
 Both countries have, however, moved sharply into recession at a time when economic growth in Japan, Germany and France has remained strong. 
 The coincidence of free financial markets with relatively poor economic performance therefore seems more potent than during the 1970s, when inflation and dear oil slowed the whole industrial world. 
 And while free markets have become even freer, relative economic performance has seemed to get even worse. 
 At the same time the creatures on either side of the divide between finance and industry &mdash; banks, investment banks and companies &mdash; are all squealing. 
 Freed from restrictions about who to lend to or how much to pay to depositors, and freed from the responsibility of supporting their corporate clients through thin times, American and British commercial banks are weaker than at any time in the past 50 years. 
 They have more dud loans and narrower profit margins than before &mdash; and certainly more than their German, French or even Japanese rivals. 
 Investment banks made hay while takeovers shone, but now find themselves with too many overheads, too few profits and no friends at all. 
 Corporate customers have been freed to borrow wherever they like, to raise money in new ways, even to compete with their banks. 
 Yet they, too, complain of aches and pains, of being squeezed by a &bquo;credit crunch&equo; under which borrowing has become harder even while interest rates have been falling. 
 Having survived the spate of hostile bids from rivals and raiders, they now feel under attack from a different direction. 
 Thanks to all this, finance has moved out of the spreadsheet and into the political arena, the courtroom and even into trade negotiations. 
 American congressmen will soon be debating the most radical financial reform that country has contemplated since the 1930s, one that could change the links between finance and industry by ending the old separation between commercial and investment banks, and by allowing industrial firms to own banks. 
 At the same time, finance is becoming inextricable from questions of industrial policy: do differences in the cost of capital, or in how it is provided, or in the way in which firms are owned, affect firms' competitiveness in America, Europe and Japan? 
 An ugly new phrase is anguished over in America and in Britain: corporate governance. 
 Is this now in servitude to the financial markets? 
 Europeans are edging towards setting up a single capital market with consistent rules about takeovers and the rights of shareholders. 
 But many are alarmed by what they have seen in Britain and America. 
 And Japan, many people's paradigm of how finance should serve industry, has recently had markets that did the best impersonation of a casino anywhere. 
 Regulators are busily clearing up the mess. 
 Yet European and American rivals believe that Japan's casino helped its industry become more competitive rather than harming it. 
 In this storm about finance, one phenomenon attracts more of the thunder and lightning than any other: the takeover bid, especially the sort that is &bquo;hostile&equo; to incumbent managers. 
 The frequency of such bids has made it seem that stockmarket valuations are arbitrary, that bidders are stealing money from somebody else rather than creating wealth, and that American and British managers spend too much time shuffling assets and too little investing (that is, building factories) for the future. 
 Many recent takeovers involved debt: the move of companies out of equity and into debt sounds like a deliberate move away from health and towards sickness. 
 Since no one would willingly make such a choice, there must be coercion involved. 
 All that, at least, is the conventional wisdom. 
 Yet when a wisdom becomes as conventional as this one, it is time to question it and even to think the opposite. 
 It is also time to worry, for such a strong consensus generally has an over-reaction on its coat-tails, one that could do more damage than the action to which it is a response. 
 There may well be problems in the freeish markets of Britain and America. 
 But the difficulty with finance is that the more fluent a market becomes, the harder it can be to trace the original cause of an outcome. 
 Money is like a body of water; a pebble dropped in here, a sluice gate opened there, can send ripples or waves that erode coastlines or flood cities far away. 
 Junk bonds and hostile takeovers are mechanisms and outcomes rather than causes in themselves; building sea walls against them will not deal with their origins. 
 The water will find other ways to transmit the forces which it is carrying. 
 The aim of this survey is to separate effects from causes, which are sometimes financial, often political. 
 It will begin with puzzles rather than solutions, for the growing disillusion with free financial markets comes laden with paradox. 
 Tempting as it is, the idea of free markets as casinos or slave-masters sits uncomfortably with many of the other big changes that have swept over international finance. 
 If the criticisms are fair, a great deal else needs to be reconciled with them.  
 Backward, and yet forward 
 A principled, worldwide massage parlour owned by everybody: doesn't that sound better? 
 FOUR puzzles stand as bouncers against the idea that corporate finance has descended into the gambling den. 
 All are ways in which modern finance has appeared to progress and to become more helpful to corporate treasurers and to underlying economies, not less. 
 The first is a puzzle that will not surprise those who put economists alongside journalists and car dealers in their not-to-be-trusted rankings. 
 It is that, during the time when Anglo-America's takeover frenzy was at its peak, financial economics at last got the recognition it deserved. 
 In 1990 three American financial economists &mdash; Harry Markowitz, William Sharpe and Merton Miller &mdash; shared the Nobel prize for economics. 
 Five years earlier another American finance theorist, Franco Modigliani, had also been given the prize. 
 There is a famously long time-lag between when work is done and when the Nobel committee doles out accolades for it. 
 Yet there had also been a long lag before financial markets began to apply many of the points these academics made. 
 Yes, apply: for although theoretical, their prize-winning work was relevant to the real world. 
 And it was in the 1980s that it was finally applied, in particular the ideas contained in two articles by Mr Modigliani and Mr Miller in 1958 and 1963. 
 These established the three principles &mdash; known as the Modigliani-Miller propositions, or MM &mdash; that have fathered much of the thinking about corporate finance ever since. 
 Briefly (for MM will reappear later), their point was that whether a firm raised its money through debt or equity did not, itself, affect the firm's value. 
 Nor did its dividend policy. 
 Other things mattered to value, especially tax and the incentives given to managers, and would determine whether a firm had borrowed &bquo;too little&equo; or &bquo;too much&equo;. 
 Sounds familiar? 
 In large measure, America's spate of takeovers, leveraged buy-outs, recapitalisations and so on came straight out of Modigliani and Miller. 
 The ideas may not always have been understood, or properly applied. 
 Or you might argue that they were misleading after all. 
 But the puzzle remains: far from departing from &bquo;sound principles&equo; of finance, the frenzy was moving towards them. 
 Puzzle number two is that other changes in financial markets were meanwhile making it easier for such principles to apply. 
 All around the world, markets have become less arbitrary, not more so, as barriers to the flow of capital across borders have been lifted. 
 Since Japan and Britain scrapped their exchange controls in 1979 and remaining European controls disappeared during the late 1980s, investors have been far freer to seek out the best returns and to diversify their risks. 
 Markets that were kept apart by government barriers, by blockages to information or by differing perceptions of a borrower's creditworthiness have been bridged by free flows, by computers and by a vast new trade in the swapping of debt. 
 In more and more instruments, the law of one price is free to apply: close financial substitutes are allowed to be swapped for one another, so trading (arbitrage, in the argot) can ensure that they fetch the same price. 
 Currencies, commodities, government and corporate bonds: all are now issued and traded around the clock and around the world. 
 Cross-border flows in and out of stockmarkets have also grown rapidly, though equities are still not easily substitutable for one another across borders. 
 They retain their national character thanks to differences in accounting, disclosure and tax, and to restraints &mdash; some official, some from inertia &mdash; on institutional investment in foreign shares. 
 Those and other imperfections do raise questions about differences in the cost of capital between companies and countries. 
 But they do not alter the basic fact: markets now operate more fluently, reliably and consistently. 
 Treasurers in the massage parlour 
 Free, cross-border flows at the touch of a computer key: this suggests unreliable &bquo;hot&equo; money rather than the loyal cold sort. 
 Perhaps, but at the same time the means to cope with market movements have developed enormously, bettering the lot of corporate treasurers all around the world. 
 Twenty years ago the treasurer's job was simple and none too arduous. 
 His basic task was ensuring that his company did not run out of money. 
 To finance any investment plans decided on by his board, he kept a pretty stable relationship with the firm's banks. 
 Now he has to work far harder. 
 But this is more out of opportunity than necessity. 
 Bit by bit, the treasurer's range of choice has widened beyond the basic questions of whether or not to borrow or to raise equity capital. 
 Should the debt be at a fixed or a floating rate? 
 In which currency? 
 When should these decisions be changed? 
 Should an instrument come with an option attached allowing investors to buy or sell at particular prices? 
 Is it worth paying a fee to have a cap or floor put on the interest rate? 
 Broad, liquid markets in securities &bquo;derivative&equo; from the basic shares and bonds have given treasurers the chance to make more choices about the financial structure and risks adopted by their companies. 
 Each decision involves a calculable opportunity cost of not having opted for something else. 
 In this sense, finance has become not the treasurer's master but a far more obedient slave. 
 Companies can massage and manipulate their finances better than ever before. 
 In principle, they can fix their financial risks and get on with the job of dealing with the commercial ones. 
 Or they can opt to take financial risks. 
 But it is their choice. 
 For the people, against the people 
 Perhaps the greatest puzzle of all, however, is essentially political. 
 It is that the view of Anglo-American finance as a casino full of rapacious capitalists has become popular at the same time as those countries' companies were being taken over by the people themselves. 
 Or, rather, by their pension funds. 
 In 1950 more than half the shares on the New York stockmarket and in London were owned by individuals. 
 By 1989 a survey showed that London's figure had fallen to 21.3%; there are no recent figures for New York, but the trend is similar. 
 Dominance has passed to institutional investors, which mainly means pension funds and life-insurance firms. 
 Company chairmen deplore this: they say they want &bquo;wider share ownership&equo;, to get ordinary people back into the stockmarket. 
 Yet in fact that is the opposite of what they want. 
 Pension funds represent the wide ownership of shares. 
 Rightly or wrongly, what chairmen want is to narrow ownership back into the hands of rich individuals. 
 Pension funds have been around for a century or more, but their modern form was set in 1950 when Charles Wilson, then president of General Motors, set up a fund for his workers. 
 Unlike most of the other 2,000 pension funds then operating in America, the GM fund did not principally invest in the company's own shares nor limit itself to fixed-income securities. 
 It sought to provide for workers' retirement by broad, diversified investment in the American economy, that is, in equities. 
 In effect, it chose to pay for workers' deferred consumption by staking a claim on America's corporate profits. 
 Once GM's union agreed to the plan, a bandwagon rolled: within a year 8,000 new plans had been written, all along the same lines. 
 This idea of the diversified, fully funded scheme (that is, run to match assets with present and future pension liabilities) has been applied most widely in America and Britain, where its principles have been written into law; it has also spread into Japan but scarcely at all into Germany, where company pension reserves frequently remain invested in the firm's own shares. 
 The change has produced what Peter Drucker, in a 1976 book, &bquo;The Unseen Revolution&equo;, called pension-fund socialism: the only successful form of socialism ever implemented. 
 The profits from capitalism are redistributed to millions of people, not through taxing and public spending but through collective investment trusts. 
 If industry is anyone's slave, it is these people's. 
 And they have a long-term interest in maintaining industry's prosperity, for that is what pays their pensions. 
 Hence the puzzle: the biggest and most immediate beneficiaries of the takeover boom of the 1980s &mdash; that is, those shareholders who sold to bidders &mdash; were retired Americans, present and future. 
 The people took most of the money, but decried it as a decade of greed. 
 Four questions for corporate finance 
 One man's efficient, interconnected global market is another man's arbitrary and nationally divisive casino. 
 One man's new tricks to manage cash flows and control risk are another's source of financial enslavement and greater risk-taking. 
 One man's benign, pension-fund socialism is another's source of short-term greed. 
 With that sort of divide, the task for policy-makers and treasurers alike of working out what problems exist &mdash; let alone what to do about them &mdash; becomes hazardous. 
 Yet the puzzles themselves provide a route-map. 
 The problem throughout is to identify what motivates financial participants to choose one option rather than another in pursuing the basic aims of any corporate system: to create wealth and to keep on doing so. 
 The issues boil down to four questions about corporate finance: 
 What sort of financial structure &mdash; rich in debt or rich in equity &mdash; is better at helping a firm create wealth? 
 What is a firm worth? 
 Does the cost of capital for firms vary between countries, and if so why? 
 Does the way in which a firm is owned affect the answers to the first three questions? 
 America is the closest thing to a financial laboratory for these sorts of questions, so it is there that most of the answers should be sought. 
 In the past century the institutions and the external stimuli affecting the relation between finance and industry have been chopped and changed. 
 Once, banks cuddled up close to industrial firms. 
 Now, they are further apart. 
 But one thing has been ever-present: the takeover. 
 From Morgan's nose to Milken's wig 
 In America takeovers never die. 
 They only change their form 
 &bquo;HOSTILE takeovers do not happen here, because of our culture; they are against our way of doing business.&equo; 
 Who might say that? 
 Currently, similar phrases can be heard in Japan, France and Germany, among others. 
 Until 1958, when Siegmund Warburg masterminded a hostile bid by an Anglo-Canadian consortium for British Aluminium, it would also have been said in both Britain and America. 
 Though it was not the first hostile bid &mdash; Charles Clore and Isaac Wolfson beat it by several years &mdash; the aluminium battle was a prototype for future bids in which a buyer made an offer to the shareholders of a listed firm against the wishes of its managers. 
 Yet, for another 15 years or so, people in Wall Street and the City of London still told visitors that hostile bids were taboo. 
 Now they are two a penny &mdash; or rather they were until 1990. 
 Soon enough, they will be again. 
 But are they really new? 
 It depends on how you define &bquo;hostile&equo; and how you answer the question: hostile to whom? 
 America's first hostile bids did not go over the heads of the managers, but that did not make them friendly. 
 In those days the owners were the managers. 
 One of America's earliest takeover battles was in 1868, when Cornelius Vanderbilt fought Jay Gould, Jim Fisk and Daniel Drew for the Erie Railroad. 
 This trio controlled it, but did not own most of the shares. 
 Their successful defence, apart from moving their headquarters to a New Jersey hotel protected by a gang and three cannons, was to issue themselves a mountain of new shares (which was illegal, but they bribed the judges). 
 The following year a battle between Erie and another railway, the Albany and Susquehanna, ended in a real fight between two armies of thugs. 
 The tactics have changed. 
 But there is nothing new about takeovers, as such. 
 Nor is there anything especially American or British about them. 
 What changes, or what differs between countries, is why they happen and how they take place. 
 And this is not determined by culture or the rapaciousness of financiers. 
 It is set by two main things: the economic circumstances of the day, and the way in which firms are owned. 
 Morganatic mergers 
 The rush of mergers and acquisitions in America in the 1980s was not the largest the country has ever known. 
 It was in nominal, dollar terms, and measured by the number of firms involved. 
 But, as the table shows, after adjustment for inflation some of the mergers that took place during this century's three previous spates of restructuring &mdash; 1897&ndash;1904, 1925&ndash;30 and the late 1960s &mdash; were as big as the top takeovers of the 1980s. 
 And measured in proportion to the size of America's economy (see chart 3), the consolidation around the turn of the century was far bigger. 
 The first and biggest wave of this century contained none of today's hostile offers. 
 Many of the mergers were designed to set up monopolies to raise prices in industries such as steel, electric power and railways. 
 The firms created include General Electric, Eastman Kodak, International Harvester and U.S. Steel. 
 The original shareholders were chiefly entrepreneurs who had set up their own firms during the previous half century, such as Cornelius Vanderbilt, John Rockefeller and Andrew Carnegie. 
 Most had by then gone public, but still controlled their firms. 
 There was no need to pit shareholders' interests against management. 
 The issues were simpler: what price to pay to the current proprietors? 
 Setting that price was not a friendly process. 
 The seller, if he is to receive cash or debt securities rather than shares, would want a price that reflected as fully as possible the value to the buyer of creating a monopoly (and thus the lost chance for the seller to do it himself). 
 The buyer would want the price to be well below the value of his monopoly, to maximise his profits. 
 According to Ron Chernow, in his recent book &bquo;The House of Morgan&equo;, many negotiations took place in all-night sessions in the &bquo;black library&equo; of J. Pierpont Morgan, he of the bulbous, acne-ridden nose and the investment bank that then dominated American finance. 
 Essentially, the talks were hostile: Morgan used the threat of price war to force firms to sell out and merge. 
 The formation of U.S. Steel in 1901 was Morgan's biggest deal, forging together 11 firms that accounted for half America's steel industry. 
 In some ways the deal could have been done yesterday. 
 Morgan paid &dollar;480m (in bonds, not cash) for Carnegie Steel, a price Andrew Carnegie later felt was &dollar;100m too low. 
 U.S. Steel was floated at a market capitalisation of &dollar;1.4 billion (about &dollar;22 billion in today's money, well behind the 1989 takeover of RJR Nabisco, but many times larger as a proportion of stockmarket value or GNP). 
 The bond and share issues were handled by a syndicate of 300 underwriters (though dominated by a handful), whose fees totalled &dollar;57.5m (now around &dollar;1 billion). 
 Its share price began at &dollar;38, soared to &dollar;55 but then crashed to &dollar;9 during a market collapse in 1903. 
 By early 1904, according to Mr Chernow, its cash flow could not even cover its dividends. 
 A reckless deal driven by short-term greed? 
 Yes, but the firm, now called USX, is still America's biggest steelmaker. 
 The most notable thing about the whole period from 1894 until 1929, however, was the close relationship between banks and industry. 
 The shift from family ownership to full stockmarket-listings marked the first time when the owners of American firms ceased to manage them. 
 Instead banks, led by J.P. 
 Morgan, held big equity stakes in companies, had seats on the board and kept a close eye on management. 
 Banks had shareholdings in each other; so did industrial firms, even competing ones. 
 When firms were restructured, these links gave the various shareholders some community of interest in the outcome, and in rescuing one another during hard times. 
 This is essentially the keiretsu system now used by Japanese industrial groups. 
 It is also a model for what many would like to see after America's banking system is reformed this year. 
 But is it a good model? 
 The idea is stuffed with ironies. 
 Pierpont Morgan was attacked by populist Democrats &mdash; whose descendants now argue for closer links between banks and industry. 
 He was attacked for at least two good reasons. 
 One was that the most direct beneficiaries of this way of doing things were a handful of banks &mdash; J.P. 
 Morgan, Kuhn Loeb and four others. 
 Competition among them was a sham. 
 Their fees for issuing securities or handling reorganisations were huge. 
 For them, greed was good. 
 The other was that although most Morgan companies prospered, so they should have: they were monopolies, or implicit cartels thanks to the cross-shareholdings. 
 Morgan and others gave birth to the modern American corporation, but ensured that its mouth contained a silver spoon. 
 A recent study by Bradford De Long of Harvard University concluded that the presence of a Morgan partner on a company's board added up to 30% to a share's value. 
 But it is impossible to say whether this was because the partner's monitoring of management boosted efficiency or because the Morgan association generally indicated a monopoly. 
 The enduring point is that close links did not make finance the slave of industry. 
 In Morgan's time, it was the other way around. 
 Or, less charitably, the consumer became the slave of both. 
 Goaded to spread his efforts to Europe, Pierpont said &bquo;America is good enough for me.&equo; 
 William Jennings Bryan, the Democrats' unsuccessful presidential candidate, replied: &bquo;Whenever he doesn't like it, he can give it back.&equo; 
 Nor did close links between banks and industry prevent panics and crashes, booms and slumps, though there were fewer than in the late 19th century. 
 Into the 1980s 
 This does not mean the idea would never work, buttressed perhaps by better antitrust enforcement. 
 But it would come with costs. 
 Henry Kaufman, the Wall Street economist known as Dr Doom, fears precisely this sort of outcome from this year's banking reform: a corporatist structure whose benefits to insiders would come from concentrating ownership and limiting competition. 
 Lucky for some, unlucky for others. 
 Nothing could seem further from the days of J.P. 
 Morgan than the life and times of Michael Milken, evangelist of junk bonds, shy wearer of a toupee and now resident of a federal prison. 
 In the takeover boom of the 1980s which Mr Milken came to epitomise, banks and firms stood far apart. 
 Investment banking had been legally separated from commercial banking since the 1930s; and in the 1960s and 1970s firms ceased to want bankers of either sort on their boards, because of conflicts of interest. 
 Most bids were hostile, or were responses to actual or threatened hostile bids. 
 The only monitor for management was the market. 
 But was it really so different? 
 The similarities begin, perhaps, with symbols. 
 It is not long ago that Mr Milken was being lionised as the greatest revitaliser of American business since J. Pierpont Morgan. 
 Even his employer, the now bust Drexel Burnham Lambert, can trace its origins to Drexel and Company, a Philadelphia bank which in 1871 created a partnership called Drexel Morgan. 
 This was J.P. 
 Morgan's forerunner and whose junior partner was Pierpont. 
 The biggest similarity, however, is financial. 
 What Mr Milken did was to make huge pools of capital available to finance takeovers. 
 A range of investors &mdash; banks, savings and loan associations, insurance companies, rich individuals &mdash; stood ready to buy high-yield (&bquo;junk&equo;) bonds. 
 Mr Milken offered a stamp of approval to both sides: investors trusted that he offered only good deals, not bad ones; takeover bidders and bank lenders to the bids got a &bquo;comfort letter&equo; from Mr Milken assuring them that the finance would be there if the takeover went ahead. 
 As an intermediary he offered liquidity and unrivalled knowledge of both sides of the market. 
 In return he earned billions. 
 Pierpont Morgan did much the same. 
 He acted as syndicator for huge pools of capital. 
 His name served as a seal of approval that a deal would go ahead and that it would be profitable. 
 He was paid for that seal and for his unrivalled knowledge. 
 He too made billions. 
 This is not to condone what either did. 
 Mr Milken was able to offer good deals because he was often breaking the law. 
 The risks to investors in some deals turn out, with hindsight, to have been badly understated which, in turn, helped to create crazily high prices. 
 Morgan was creating monopolies. 
 He was more involved with the businesses and the actual mergers than Mr Milken ever was, but not necessarily to the good. 
 At the end of their eras, both men became the subject of investigations: Mr Milken's in court last year and Morgan's in front of Congress's Pujo committee in 1912&ndash;13. 
 Unlike Mr Milken, though, Morgan did not go to jail. 
 The real differences between the mergers of the 1980s and previous waves do not lie either in the hostility of the bids or the nature of the financing. 
 They lie in why the restructuring took place and in the forms of ownership and capital structure that were assumed to be superior to the old. 
 As an Irish prime minister once said after listening to a long debate between his cabinet colleagues: &bquo;I understand how it works in practice. 
 But how does it work in theory?&equo; 
 Theories at the bottom of their jargon 
 Do markets know the price of everything but the value of nothing? 
 INVESTORS, traders, bankers and managers often operate with only a partial model in mind about why they are doing whatever it is they are doing, and what principles lie behind it. 
 Yet the past five-ten years have been remarkable for the amount of attention given in America to such principles. 
 Management consultancies, forever eyeing profitable fashions, have set up teams specialising in the valuation of firms, often staffed by former academics. 
 Current academics have become financial consultants themselves as well as highly-paid expert witnesses in court disputes. 
 Many of their theories have led corporate America hurtling towards debt. 
 Valuation lies at the heart of all takeovers, however they are financed. 
 A firm is worth whatever somebody else will pay for it. 
 That in turn is simply (but not uncontroversially) defined: the buyer is paying for the future flows of cash that the firm is expected to generate, over and above its costs. 
 The present value of those future flows should then be worked out by discounting them with an interest rate equivalent to the firm's cost of capital, the weighted average of its cost of borrowing and of equity. 
 Put another way, the cost of capital is the cost to lenders and investors of not having done something else with their money: the rate of return they could expect to earn on investments of equal risk. 
 To its lenders and investors, the firm has a value only if it is earning more than its cost of capital. 
 Otherwise, the financiers should have put their money elsewhere. 
 There is plenty of room for debate about this calculation &mdash; over how to guess at future cash flows, over what period to take, over how to work out the cost of capital, to name but three. 
 It can be made more complicated by trying to value the choices that managers could make to affect their future cash flows, such as closing a factory, and the choices that are contingent on other choices. 
 But the simple formula is enough to show what the variables are. 
 So why were so many firms &mdash; and bits of firms &mdash; bought and sold in the 1980s, and why did their values vary so much? 
 The basic answer lies in the guesses about future cash flow. 
 If someone thinks they could raise that future flow, they will pay more for the firm. 
 They might think they can do so by managing it better, by motivating the managers better, by putting the firm together with something else, or in other ways. 
 They might be wrong, but that does not affect the issue (not at the time of the bid, anyway). 
 In turn, they will be able to buy only if they can raise the money to bid, which depends on investors' assessment of the risk and likely return. 
 That assessment might also be wrong (clue to a later article: junk-bond default rates) or it might be distorted by some other influence (clue: federal deposit insurance). 
 Valuation is often misunderstood. 
 Theorists say that a stockmarket is &bquo;efficient&equo; if prices take account of all information that is available that might affect a firm's future cash flow. 
 Efficiency sounds like a strong claim, but actually it is pretty weak: all it means is that current information is available to everyone, either because they know about it or because enough people do, so that it is fully represented in the price. 
 But how, the misunderstanding goes, can a market be efficient when on October 19th 1987 the New York stockmarket was suddenly and inexplicably worth 23% less than it was on October 16th? 
 The answer is that valuation is based on guesses about the future. 
 &bquo;Efficiency&equo; does not mean that the market is sufficiently clairvoyant to gauge the cash flow of General Motors for the next 30 years or more. 
 The market is a combination of thousands of guesses, affected by feelings as well as facts. 
 Guesses are fickle creatures. 
 It is the same for takeovers. 
 In the early 1900s buyers of firms guessed they could raise cash flows through economies of scale and by limiting competition. 
 They were mostly right. 
 In the 1960s buyers thought they could raise cash flows by forming conglomerates, applying their management skills and diversifying risk. 
 They were mostly wrong, but it took several years to find out. 
 So the merger boom went on for a while, still fuelled by this false belief. 
 In the 1980s buyers thought they could raise cash flows by breaking up these conglomerates, by giving managers different incentives and controls, and by exploiting more fully tax breaks for debt interest. 
 It is still too soon to say in how many cases this was right. 
 But it is well-grounded in theory. 
 And the theory helps show why sometimes the idea was taken too far. 
 Enter Modigliani and Miller 
 Apart from the hurt feelings of departing managers, the most common reason for worrying about America's spate of takeovers in the 1980s was that it pushed firms heavily into debt. 
 This sounds unsafe. 
 It need not be. 
 Which is also why many of the takeovers may have been healthy rather than reckless. 
 The reason is grounded in the most basic issue of corporate finance. 
 Should a firm raise its money from its shareholders or by borrowing? 
 On the face of it, the answer might well be debt. 
 Debt is cheaper than equity, since investors take on less risk when buying it. 
 So to lower the cost of capital and raise the firm's value, should you not fill your boots with it, at least until you get so close to bankruptcy that shareholders and creditors start to demand higher returns to balance the risk? 
 The first innovation by Franco Modigliani and Merton Miller was to show that this is wrong. 
 If, on its own, borrowing more created value, then an arbitrage opportunity would arise between the two sorts of security. 
 As the firm takes on more debt, so the cost of equity (the total return demanded by investors) must rise in proportion. 
 The debt-equity ratio has no effect on the firm's value (see chart 4). 
 That depends only on its future earning power (that is, how well it is run) and on how risky is the sort of business it is in. 
 Like most economic theories, this MM proposition is true only &bquo;on certain assumptions&equo;. 
 Naturally, they are unrealistic. 
 But it is the assumptions that matter. 
 By showing in what circumstances a firm's value would not be affected, Messrs Modigliani and Miller provided clues for the circumstances in which it might be. 
 The most important one, pointed out by the duo in an article in 1963, concerned tax. 
 America is one of the few countries that, in effect, taxes corporate income twice: once as corporation tax, and a second time as personal-income tax, when the income is paid out as dividends. 
 But interest payments on debt are treated as a cost of doing business, and so are deductible from profits before tax. 
 This means that the value of a firm would indeed rise as it took on more debt because it was paying less of its earnings out to the taxman. 
 In other words, more of the earnings would be available to pay to the other claimants, that is, shareholders and creditors. 
 Rather than the flat line seen in chart 4, the value of a firm would in fact slope upwards as the debt-equity ratio rises (see chart 5). 
 The implication was startling. 
 It suggested that if a firm had low debts and was paying a lot of corporate tax its managers were actually being incompetent: while proudly keeping their credit ratings high, they were handing their shareholders' money to the taxman. 
 To do their shareholders a favour, they ought to borrow more. 
 The value they were handing unnecessarily to the taxman offered a fine incentive to bidders to come along and do this for them. 
 It is surprising that markets did not react sooner to this. 
 In 1963 the corporate-tax rate in America was around 50%, giving firms a powerful incentive to borrow more. 
 They did so gradually during the 1960s &mdash; raising the share of cash flow taken by net interest payments from 5% in 1960 to 15% in 1970 &mdash; but then cut back. 
 By the time they began to rush more eagerly towards debt, in the mid-1980s, the Tax Reform Act of 1986 seemed to reduce the incentive by lowering the corporate-tax rate to 34%, as well as aligning personal-income-tax rates with those for capital-gains tax, removing one bias for investors towards long-term gains rather than immediate dividends. 
 However, the act gave with one hand and took away with another: for it also removed a tax credit for investment and the possibility of accelerating the write-down against tax of depreciation. 
 This, Mr Miller has argued (in a 1990 article in the Journal of Applied Corporate Finance called &bquo;The MM Propositions After 30 Years&equo;), left the incentive to borrow as high or even higher than it was in 1963. 
 The discipline of debt 
 What other things might have affected firms' decision about whether (and when) to respond to this incentive? 
 There are three main possibilities: 
 Bankruptcy costs. 
 Although a firm's value might rise as it borrows more, the closer it gets to bankruptcy the higher will be its cost of borrowing. 
 Lenders will want to be compensated more for the risk of default. 
 Some creditors will demand extra protection, such as restrictive covenants attached to their loans laying down what the firm must do if things go wrong. 
 Bankruptcy proceedings also involve lots of spending on lawyers and accountants, and they distract managers from running the business. 
 According to Edward Altman, a finance professor at New York University, there are also indirect costs: some customers choose not to deal with vulnerable firms, and suppliers demand better terms. 
 These affect firms in some industries (manufacturing) more than others (retailing). 
 He has adapted the MM diagrams accordingly (see chart 6). 
 Thanks to tax incentives, a firm's value will rise as its debt-equity ratio rises; but after some point (its optimal debt ratio) the costs of financial vulnerability outweigh the tax savings, and the value falls. 
 These costs are not constant, however. 
 In particular, the cost of bankruptcy depends on the legal and institutional framework for handling it. 
 The easier it is to use courts or, even better, private agreements to sort out disputes between creditors and shareholders while the firm continues to operate, the lower the costs will be, and the greater the incentive to skate closer to the edge. 
 That is exactly what happened. 
 In 1978 America's federal bankruptcy code was rewritten in order to make it easier to file for bankruptcy, to reorganise under the protection of chapter 11 of the code, and then to re-emerge as a going concern even under the same management. 
 That in effect reduced directors' worries about bankruptcy, pushing them to borrow more. 
 Prudence versus liquidity. 
 Managers might not borrow as much as they should, on paper, if they want to retain a large reserve of borrowing power in case of problems. 
 That will depend on their view of the liquidity of both debt and equity markets: the more liquid they think these are, the less likely they are to sit on cash or to refrain from borrowing, and the more likely they are to pay large dividends. 
 If it feels easy to raise fresh equity from shareholders then dividend pay-outs will be high, for managers can easily ask for the money back again. 
 In the 1980s free-flowing, borderless markets did indeed make borrowing and capital-raising appear easier. 
 So reserves of borrowing capacity became less vital. 
 Concentration of ownership and control. 
 One trouble with being owned by conventional shareholders &mdash; whether they are pension funds or a mass of individual investors &mdash; is that ownership is dispersed and the pressure on managers is eased. 
 In that case switching away from equity and into debt offers two potential advantages: it tends to concentrate ownership (both equity and debt) into fewer hands that may care more about how the firm is run; and it provides a clear discipline for managers. 
 The value of equity can dribble gradually away with hardly anyone noticing; the share price simply falls. 
 But the value of debt provides a clearer and earlier discipline: interest payments have to be made. 
 Quite rightly and rationally, many American takeovers in the 1980s were driven by these theories. 
 If a firm was not maximising its future cash flows, and hence its value, an opportunity opened up for a bid. 
 A main way in which many firms were failing to maximise their value was in not exploiting the tax incentive to borrow. 
 The incentive to borrow was raised still further by a reduction in the costs of bankruptcy and an increase in market liquidity. 
 And high levels of debt offered one possible solution to problems of how to discipline managers. 
 Theory, meet practice 
 Corporate America has plenty of problems. 
 But debt is not one of them 
 FROM 1984&ndash;90 guesses that cash flow could be higher if assets changed hands or if a firm's financial structure was changed were made in &dollar;1.7 trillion-worth of cases in America. 
 In the period after 1986, many of those guesses were in the form of leveraged buy-outs, the use of debt finance to buy a firm from its existing shareholders and to make it a private company. 
 Such LBOs accounted for &dollar;216 billion-worth of deals in 1984&ndash;90, peaking at a total of almost &dollar;54 billion in a single year, 1989, before halving in 1990. 
 At the same time, firms not taking part in takeovers took on more debt, either gradually or in so-called &bquo;leveraged recapitalisations&equo; &mdash; in effect self-takeovers in which firms' existing shareholders swapped some of their equity into debt. 
 This habit also reached a peak in 1989. 
 It will take several more years before most of these guesses will be proved to have been right or wrong. 
 However, some judgments can already be made. 
 One is that corporate America has not, as a whole, burdened itself with an excessive amount of debt. 
 There are debt problems in America, but they lie elsewhere &mdash; with the federal government, with consumers and in weakened financial institutions. 
 Another is that some guesses were quickly proved to have been wrong and ended up in bankruptcy. 
 They did so mostly because the transactions depended on the new debt burden being temporary while bits of a firm were sold, but the burden turned out to be lasting. 
 A third is that many of the buy-outs and recapitalisations succeeded because the managers knew something the shareholders did not about future cash flows. 
 But the fourth is that some of the financing was priced too low &mdash; for revealing reasons. 
 Start with debt. 
 The state of corporate America 
 If a business takes on more debt, its calculations can be thrown out by two things: if the interest cost of servicing the debt rises by more than was expected; and if the cash flow earned by the business falls by more than had been planned for. 
 British firms have been struggling with the first of these for the past 18 months, and for the past six or so have also suffered from the second. 
 American firms have been luckier: their interest rates have been falling, so the state of their cash flow has been the main worry. 
 From 1982 to 1989 the debts of non-financial firms in America rose by nearly 12% a year, way ahead of the 8.3% average annual growth for the previous three decades. 
 The debt-service ratio (the proportion of cash flow taken by net interest costs) rose to 20%, an all-time record. 
 That ought, on paper, to have made corporate America worryingly more vulnerable to recession, and to a downturn in cash flow. 
 It hasn't. 
 According to Stephen Roach, a senior economist at Morgan Stanley in New York, these overall figures disguise a radical change in the distribution of debt between industries. 
 And that distribution has become more safe, not less. 
 When Mr Roach first made this point in late 1988, many economists thought he was being too sanguine. 
 But now that America's recession has arrived, testing his view, the consensus has moved towards him. 
 Cyclical industries &mdash; those in which cash flow bounces up and down in booms and slumps &mdash; lowered their debt-service ratio during the 1980s, from 20% in 1982 to around 13% by 1988. 
 As cash flow has suffered, so the ratio has risen again, as it always does during recessions for these industries, which include transport, construction, communication and the manufacturing of durable goods. 
 But the big rises in indebtedness came in industries where cash flow is more stable, such as public utilities, services and the manufacturing of non-durables such as food and tobacco. 
 These industries' debt ratio hit 25% in 1985 and again last year (see chart 9). 
 No industry's cash flow is entirely stable; some of the services included in Mr Roach's definition may be more cyclical than they once were, since many are now handling tasks subcontracted by manufacturing firms (such as cleaning, waste disposal or advertising) and thus shift with the fortunes of factories. 
 This recession is proving especially painful for firms in advertising, retailing, the media and financial services. 
 But the broad point still stands. 
 Driven by the tax incentive identified by Modigliani and Miller, firms in the industries most able to resist recession have taken on most of the debt. 
 Chart 10 further shows that these industries also enjoyed much stronger growth in pre-tax profits in 1982&ndash;89 than did cyclical ones. 
 That is as appropriate an outcome as any theorist could have hoped for. 
 Corporate America could have been damaged in other ways by the takeover spree. 
 It might have been induced to spend lots of money on dividend payments and on buying back shares, to boost share prices and keep shareholders sweet. 
 It might have invested too little in building its capital stock, thus perhaps enfeebling itself in future competition with foreign rivals. 
 All of this happened during the past ten years. 
 But it is not at all clear that high dividends have been damaging, in themselves. 
 Nor is it likely that the fashion for takeovers and debt was responsible for America's poor rate of investment. 
 During the 1980s corporate America did pay out a large share of net profits in dividends, and it did spend billions on share repurchases. 
 But, as chart 11 shows, in 1982&ndash;89 the growth in dividends slowed in the stabler industries where most of the takeovers and borrowing were taking place and where profits were rising, while it accelerated in cyclical industries. 
 In any case there is nothing wrong in principle with handing money to shareholders through dividends or share repurchases (as long as it is tax-efficient); the money is not lost to the economy since it will be invested elsewhere. 
 And in the liquid and buoyant capital markets of the 1980s, firms knew they could raise the money again quickly if they needed it. 
 Chart 12 suggests what was going on behind these financial flows. 
 Investment in new fixed-capital stock did slow worryingly in America. 
 But it did so most sharply in the cyclical industries, where little of the takeover fun was happening. 
 Reviving investment will be one of America's biggest challenges in the next few years. 
 But the blame for its weakness cannot be laid directly at the feet either of the takeover or of debt. 
 It must be laid elsewhere. 
 In the valley of debt 
 The problem of excessive debt is narrowly focused 
 THOSE figures of Mr Roach even fit most people's chosen method of analysis: the anecdote. 
 Think of the manufacturing industries fighting head to head with Japan &mdash; cars, semiconductors, computers, telecommunications. 
 None of these has been prone to takeover bids. 
 General Motors and Ford have not been dogged by raiders &mdash; more's the pity. 
 The tyre industry did attract bids (including that of Firestone by Bridgestone, a Japanese firm), but that is true the world over (note Pirelli's bid for Continental in Germany). 
 So did the airline industry. 
 But most of the frenzy was elsewhere. 
 It is in the more stable industries that LBOs hit the headlines, including the biggest of them all, the &dollar;25 billion purchase of RJR Nabisco, a tobacco and food firm, by Kohlberg Kravis Roberts (KKR), a buy-out specialist. 
 Accordingly, it is in these industries that the search for success and failure must be concentrated. 
 The record so far is mixed. 
 There is no evidence to suggest that buy-outs are associated with cuts in spending on research and development, nor on investment, nor in any drastic way even in overall employment. 
 But some buy-outs have ended in the bankruptcy court or in acute distress. 
 Some conclusions are apparent, however, that help to show why buy-outs take place and what separates the wheat from the chaff: 
 A study by Tom Copeland, a finance academic turned consultant at McKinsey, of six LBOs among its clients found that half of the value created in the buy-outs came as a result of unexpected falls in interest rates. 
 In other words, their timing was lucky. 
 Mr Copeland also worked out what would have happened if a competing firm in the same industry had merely taken on the same amount of debt as the LBO did, without being bought out. 
 He found that in half the cases it would have done better than the buy-out. 
 In other words, the managers at the LBO could have achieved similar results without a buy-out; what they were doing was seizing the gain for themselves. 
 In such cases the guesswork about future cash flow is well-informed and thus the risks lower. 
 Later in the 1980s, shareholders became wiser to this and sought ways to narrow the knowledge gap between themselves and the managers. 
 The profitability of LBOs fell and the premiums paid to shareholders rose. 
 The excesses of overpayment in 1987&ndash;89 were made worse by a simple point: companies, whether buying themselves out or releveraging themselves in competition with outside bidders, paid their investment-bank advisers fees linked to whether the transaction was completed or not. 
 The investment bank therefore had a powerful incentive to make sure its client won its bids, regardless of whether it was paying too much. 
 Some buyers in effect paid their advisers millions to send them bankrupt. 
 Overpayment in debt causes more problems than overpayment in equity. 
 When one firm buys another and pays too much equity, shareholders suffer. 
 But they typically do so in silence and the firm remains in business. 
 If you pay too much in debt, you risk defaulting on interest payments; when you do, it causes more public fuss and pits creditors against one another. 
 For this reason, mistakes in the LBO boom have caused more fuss than mistakes in the merger boom of the 1960s, even though &mdash; so far at least &mdash; there have been fewer of them. 
 A big reason for over-leveraging lay in the very nature of this buy-out boom. 
 Much of it was not simply about shifting equity into debt, though that played its part. 
 It was about unravelling the merger mistakes of the 1960s: splitting up conglomerates, or else buying a firm and selling off divisions that were remote from its main business. 
 Such a purchaser would, in effect, buy a firm that he did not want to own for long in its present shape. 
 This is where most of the problems lie &mdash; and where the gambles were made. 
 In those circumstances, according to Mr Altman of New York University, the calculation about what capital structure to adopt became rather different from the conventional sort. 
 A choice between debt and equity was made on the assumption that this choice did not have to stand the test of time. 
 Think back to Mr Altman's diagram (chart 6) showing how bankruptcy costs affect the value of a firm and its optimal debt capacity. 
 A buyer for the long haul would not skate far past the optimal point and towards bankruptcy costs. 
 But unbundlers did, for they were borrowing for a short haul before assets could be sold: in that time, they assumed their guesses about cash flow would be pretty safe and that asset prices would carry on rising. 
 Mr Altman's colleague, Harvin Moore, made a study of LBOs in November 1990 for the Comptroller of the Currency. 
 He compared 11 successful buy-outs with nine failures (defined by bankruptcy, bond defaults or a restructuring caused by financial distress). 
 All LBOs begin with mindboggling levels of debt, way beyond those that Messrs Modigliani and Miller thought feasible. 
 But that is because the debt is temporary. 
 Chart 13 shows Mr Moore's findings: in the successful sample the average ratio of long-term debt to assets was 62.4% after the LBO had been made but it fell to 37.6% by the third year as assets were sold and debt paid off. 
 In the unsuccessful sample the initial ratio was lower &mdash; 46.4% &mdash; but it then rose to 52.7% by the third year and 71.1% in the fourth (by which time only four of the nine buy-outs survived). 
 Much of the buy-out boom was based on this kind of bet. 
 A raider &mdash; either the existing management or a buy-out specialist such as KKR &mdash; in effect took a gamble rather like that taken every day by a stockmarket dealer or currency trader. 
 They took assets on to their books assuming they would sell them at a profit shortly afterwards. 
 They did so with huge amounts of debt, not because that was the ideal financial structure but because the debt market was more liquid than the equity market. 
 Mr Milken could rustle up debt investors with a handful of telephone calls. 
 But this sort of gamble, based on a short-term guess, could go badly wrong. 
 It could go wrong simply if asset prices began to fall or if cash flows ebbed. 
 That is what happened in 1989&ndash;90. 
 It could go even more wrong if the forces encouraging lending or determining the risk of bankruptcy were to change. 
 That is what is happening now. 
 When the goalposts move 
 Corporate finance that looked right under the old rules can look drastically wrong if the rules change 
 THE assumptions under which a firm dives into temporary debt can be changed in a number of ways. 
 Interest rates could soar, asset prices could fall or cash flows could dry up. 
 But there are two other ways in which things could change drastically, making what seemed like a good idea turn very bad indeed. 
 One is if the providers of finance suddenly change their behaviour. 
 Another is if the limiting factor for all debtors &mdash; the cost of bankruptcy or near-bankruptcy &mdash; suddenly changes for the worse. 
 Both of these are happening in America, as a result of government policy or judicial decisions. 
 Mention junk bonds to an American manager and you had better duck. 
 These high-yield debt securities are considered to be instruments of the devil. 
 Michael Milken, their chief advocate, is now behind bars. 
 Yet at least one member of America's financial establishment thinks they are still worth studying. 
 J.P. 
 Morgan, the epitome of prudent finance and standard-bearer for intimate relationships between banks and their corporate clients, has formed a junk-bond research group. 
 As so often, the Morgan bank's judgment is sound. 
 There is nothing wrong, in principle, with junk bonds. 
 They are an unsecured loan, generally to a borrower with a low credit rating. 
 Both of these aspects should mean that the loan's yield is higher than for secured lending and for loans to highly rated borrowers. 
 As long as that yield compensates lenders for the extra risk, these bonds should find a ready market. 
 The trouble is that in 1982&ndash;90 the yield was not high enough. 
 Now that lenders have realised that, they have departed, shocked, from the market. 
 But they will return. 
 The yield on junk bonds did not compensate for their risks, for two related reasons. 
 The first was that the market was too young to have built up a proper record of likely default rates, especially during a recession. 
 The second was that a large group of junk-bond investors &mdash; the savings and loan associations &mdash; had an extra leg-up into high-yield investment because of federal insurance of their source of cash, deposits. 
 Junk bonds have been around, in one form or another, ever since the 1800s. 
 From 1950 until 1970, however, most American firms borrowed chiefly from banks. 
 In 1970 there was only &dollar;7 billion-worth of high-yield bonds outstanding, most of them originally issued as top-notch debt but later downgraded by rating agencies and the market. 
 The junk-default rate in that year was high: 11.4%. 
 But for the next two decades, as the volume of junk outstanding rose to &dollar;15 billion in 1980 and then &dollar;201 billion in 1989, the default rate stayed low. 
 Hence the choice of dates in a 1989 study on the market by Drexel Burnham Lambert, chief publicist for the instrument: 
 Between 1971&ndash;88, annual high-yield-bond default rates have averaged 2%&hellip; 
 Higher spreads from high-yield bonds have historically overcompensated for the default rate&hellip; historical evidence indicates that general economic downturns are not closely correlated with peak high-yield default rates&hellip; 
 Well, they are now. 
 As chart 14 shows, the annual default rate on junk bonds edged up in 1989 to 4% and in 1990 doubled to 8.7%. 
 This year it could reach 12&ndash;15%. 
 Even during the good periods, quoting the annual rate was misleading: the proportion of all bonds outstanding that defaulted in any given year was kept low by the huge proportion of new issues in 1986&ndash;90. 
 The cumulative default rate &mdash; the proportion of bonds originally rated as junk that eventually defaulted &mdash; always looked more alarming, at around 30%. 
 That will also rise this year. 
 Until the past two years Drexel was right that the total return from investing in a diversified portfolio of junk bonds overcompensated for the default rate. 
 These bonds paid three-five percentage points above yields on Treasury bonds. 
 According to Edward Altman, that would have been enough to compensate for an annual default rate of 5&ndash;6% &mdash; around three times actual default rates &mdash; so the returns looked delicious. 
 With hindsight, they were not so tasty after all. 
 Mr Altman has worked out what yield spreads above those on Treasuries would be needed to compensate for default rates at current levels. 
 The sums are complicated by another factor: when a bond goes into default, an investor can expect to recover some of its value when assets are sold off. 
 In 1985 recovery rates for junk debt were as high as 40%. 
 Last year, as asset prices slumped, they fell below 20%. 
 If they stay that way and if the default rate were to rise as high as 15%, the spread over Treasuries would have to be 15 percentage points to make junk break even. 
 Currently, the spread is about ten points, suggesting that the market expects a default rate of about 10%. 
 Moral hazard meets the junk bond 
 In such a young, fast-growing market as that for junk, many investors were bound to be novices. 
 Most were big institutions; at the end of 1988 30% of junk outstanding was held by insurance companies, 30% by mutual funds and 15% by pension funds. 
 But this market was new to them and to their own investors and trustees. 
 When junk became a dirty word in 1989&ndash;90 and Drexel Burnham went bankrupt, these investors panicked. 
 One sizeable group pulled out as a direct result of government policy, however: the savings and loans, or thrifts. 
 They had invested in junk in the first place because of government policy, accounting for 7% of bonds outstanding at the end of 1988. 
 Thrifts were banned by law from investing in equities which were deemed to be too risky. 
 But they were encouraged to take other risks because their basic business (lending for house purchase) was getting unprofitable, because supervision by federal examiners was weak and because federal deposit insurance in effect underwrote any risks they cared to take. 
 This moral hazard sent them lending billions to property developers and investing billions in junk bonds. 
 With their own risk underwritten, any yield over Treasuries looked attractive. 
 The thrifts' eagerness to buy helped keep that spread down. 
 This made junk finance look cheap as well as liquid. 
 One of Mr Milken's readiest pools of capital was in the thrifts. 
 But when thrifts went bust in their hundreds in 1989, necessitating a federal rescue that could cost the taxpayer &dollar;500 billion or more over the next 30 years, the goalposts were abruptly moved for junk borrowers, too. 
 The thrifts-rescue act of August 1989 at first contained a clause banning thrifts from holding junk bonds, later weakened to require them to place them in special subsidiaries insulated from deposit insurance. 
 The effect was the same: junk was suddenly less attractive, and anyway much of it was now in the hands of federal rescue agencies keen to sell as quickly as possible. 
 Thrifts should never have been subsidised and led into junk in the first place. 
 But, knowingly or not, junk issuers borrowed on the assumption that the subsidy would stay. 
 When the rules changed, the junk market collapsed. 
 So did marginal issuers still owing their &bquo;temporary&equo; debts. 
 The price of distress 
 Changes in bankruptcy rules can cause more bankruptcies 
 METHODS of dealing with failure differ around the world. 
 But the cost to a firm &mdash; or, rather, its owners and creditors &mdash; of entering liquidation is similar. 
 The destruction of share values, the need to auction assets, the cost of paying accountants and lawyers: these vary, but not by a huge amount. 
 What does differ, however, is the probability of liquidation: in other words, whether owners, creditors and the law will send a firm to the wall or rescue it. 
 That probability can, in turn, affect a firm's cost of doing business. 
 In recent years, Americans have come to admire the Japanese and German ways of dealing with this. 
 Typically, Japanese and German firms have main banks that step in when their client is in financial difficulties, and reorganise its management and its debts. 
 By reducing the probability that a firm will fail and by reducing creditors' potential losses in the event of difficulty, this helps to reduce the costs a firm takes on as it takes bigger risks and nears bankruptcy. 
 From 1979 until 1990 America evolved its own version of this. 
 Fewer firms there have main banks, so that option scarcely exists. 
 But nevertheless two lines of defence stand before liquidation: 
 Chapter 11 of the bankruptcy code. 
 This was rewritten in the bankruptcy-reform act of 1979, to make it easier for firms to use. 
 Under supervision by a bankruptcy court, a firm in chapter 11 draws up a reorganisation plan which it then negotiates with the creditors while a judge arbitrates. 
 Similar legal provisions exist in Germany and Japan but big firms rarely resort to them. 
 Private out-of-court negotiations. 
 These are closest to the Japanese and German ways, but without a main bank to act as kingpin. 
 Shareholders and creditors agree to restructure debts and payment schedules and, often, to swap debt for riskier equity. 
 This sort of method is typical for international firms: Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation recently completed a huge private renegotiation with its 150 banks. 
 For companies, the private work-out is better &mdash; as long as the claims that have to be reorganised are not too complicated. 
 The legal fees are lower, the firm's reputation is (more or less) preserved and it is quicker. 
 Sales and investments are likely to be less affected than in a chapter 11 filing. 
 A successful private deal also means that creditors and shareholders have reached a voluntary consensus, which binds them in to the firm's future health. 
 And, for a deal to be reached, not all creditors necessarily need to be involved. 
 Filing for chapter 11 can make sense in other circumstances. 
 If there are hundreds of trade creditors (as for a retailer) or a lot of liability suits (for example, for asbestos sufferers), then firms benefit by using the courts. 
 They can also carry on getting credit through a special &bquo;debtor-in-possession&equo; facility: when Campeau, a highly leveraged Canadian-owned retailer, filed for chapter 11 last year it quickly got &dollar;700m of credit, which kept its Federated and Allied stores open for business. 
 Watch those goalposts 
 Arrangements for reorganisation, in or out of court, sound like a formality; a fixed outside factor of doing business. 
 They are not. 
 The way they operate affects the calculations and sentiments of investors, which in turn affects the returns required to compensate for risk. 
 If they did so in a consistent way, that would be fine. 
 But when the rules and circumstances change, those calculations are thrown out. 
 In the past two years it has become much harder in America to use the private method of dealing with distress. 
 That method is exactly the one best suited to LBOs or recapitalised firms that have overpaid for themselves and cannot meet their debts. 
 Chart 15, from Karen Wruck at the Harvard Business School, shows part of the answer why: in a highly leveraged firm, default is triggered by the inability to meet payments to claimants accounting for a much larger proportion of the firm's value than in a firm with more equity; and the loss to creditors of failing to agree on new terms is thus potentially bigger. 
 In LBOs, creditors are often also shareholders, making them less likely to jostle for advantage when times get tough. 
 They will not always agree. 
 But they have strong incentives to try. 
 Three things have made this harder to do. 
 One could not have been avoided: the collapse of Drexel Burnham Lambert. 
 Until its demise, Drexel had not only cornered the market in issuing junk, it had also built a reputation with investors for reorganising the debts if a borrower neared default. 
 It made hundreds of private &bquo;exchange offers&equo; of new paper for old. 
 In a way, its function was similar to that of a Japanese main bank or of Pierpont Morgan in his prime. 
 With its departure and the collapse of the junk market, no one else has taken over the role. 
 The other two were avoidable, however. 
 The first came from Judge Burton Lifland of the bankruptcy court. 
 In January 1990 he gave a ruling regarding LTV, a steel firm in chapter 11, that brought big private negotiations virtually to a halt. 
 He ruled that if bondholders agree to a private swap of new bonds for old then their claim in any future legal case (for example, a chapter 11 filing) will be based only on the market value of their new bonds. 
 It sounds technical. 
 But it abruptly changed the incentives for creditors. 
 Previously, a bondholder could swap his old paper for new bonds with the same face value but, say, different rights and terms, without closing his options if the firm later went to chapter 11. 
 Now if he makes the swap he risks reducing his ultimate claim from, say, a &dollar;1,000 face value to the &dollar;400 market value. 
 This makes creditors much less likely to agree to private work-outs. 
 The second came in the 1990 tax act. 
 This changed the rules about the tax treatment of out-of-court settlements. 
 The benefits to the firm of debt forgiveness are now taxable if it happens privately, but remain tax-free if it happens under chapter 11. 
 From bad to worse 
 Judge Lifland's decision may have been right. 
 So may the 1990 tax act. 
 So was the way in which the Treasury department, Congress and federal deposit insurers jumped on thrifts' investments in junk bonds. 
 All these and more were right to criticise the excessive prices paid in some bids and buy-outs, pushed by subsidised money and investment bankers' greed for fees. 
 The trouble is that, after the event, all of these make the situation worse rather than better. 
 Financial decisions &mdash; how much to borrow, how much to lend, at what price &mdash; made under one set of rules and incentives go wrong when the rules change. 
 Until the goalposts moved, roughly half of publicly listed firms in financial trouble opted for the private route. 
 Now, more companies will end up in chapter 11 bankruptcy. 
 Just when banks and pension funds are trying to get more involved in the management of firms they lend to and own, so their opportunity to do so has been narrowed. 
 Judges will be in charge, and lawyers and (again) investment bankers will pocket the fees. 
 The price of financial distress has been raised. 
 Rather than moving towards the much vaunted Japanese way of doing things, America is moving in the opposite direction. 
 That is a pity: the price of financial distress is just about the only way in which the cost of capital for firms plausibly differs between the two rivals over the longer term. 
 Capital in competition 
 The cost of capital is widely misunderstood. 
 So are the policies that affect it 
 IF ONLY America's economy were isolated from the rest of the world, there would be less worrying about takeover bids, junk bonds, debt and bankruptcy rules. 
 Admittedly, some of the policies that cause problems with these things &mdash; federally subsidised capital, double taxation of corporate profits, bankruptcy laws &mdash; are decided upon as if America was, indeed, an island unto itself. 
 But it is damage wrought on the international competitiveness of American firms that really gives pause for thought. 
 The worry takes two main forms: that American managers spend too much time thinking about short-term earnings rather than making long-term investments; and that American firms face a higher cost of capital than Japanese or German rivals and so reject investment projects that others eagerly accept. 
 In most managers' minds, these worries are linked. 
 The same complaint about the cost of capital can be heard in Britain, Canada and Australia. 
 One reason is that interest rates are affected by government policy, so the cost of capital can be blamed on government (ours). 
 Similarly, interest rates appear open to manipulation and hard-to-prove subsidy, so differences across borders can also be blamed on governments (theirs). 
 Either way, the complaint crops up again and again. 
 At the World Economic Forum in Switzerland in early February, a Canadian politician was heard to complain that his country's free-trade deal with America could not work because Canadian interest rates are five percentage points higher than American ones, unfairly hampering Canadian business. 
 In the same month America's National Advisory Committee on Semiconductors, a joint government-industry lobby, blamed its own industry's decline on America's high cost of capital. 
 Britons complain about it all the time: nominal interest rates at 15&ndash;20%, depending on the borrower, make most managers believe that their capital costs more than anybody's. 
 These complaints have one thing in common: they are wrong. 
 Or, at least, they are misleading, directing attention at the wrong things. 
 They are based on misconceptions about what the cost of capital is, and what affects it. 
 The fact that there are misconceptions is, however, important in itself. 
 For there is a vast gap between what businessmen think their cost of capital is and what most finance theorists say it is. 
 Like many theories, the verdict of the corporate-finance academics is not terribly helpful at first sight. 
 Their view is that the after-tax cost of capital in America, Britain and Japan is roughly the same for companies posing similar risks, after adjusting for inflation, government barriers to the flow of capital and currency risk. 
 The clues about how this can be helpful &mdash; and how even academics disagree about actual costs of capital &mdash; are in the &bquo;after adjusting for&equo; part of that statement. 
 The price of debt 
 Capital comes in two forms &mdash; debt and equity &mdash; so there are two areas in which costs could differ. 
 Debt is the most straightforward. 
 If most big countries still had exchange controls or other barriers to the free flow of money across borders, then costs of debt could differ widely. 
 The fact that Japanese people save more of their incomes, for instance, might lower borrowing costs for Japanese companies. 
 But the barriers no longer exist. 
 If Japan has lots of savings, in principle anyone can borrow them. 
 Despite that, interest rates do differ between countries, which is why borrowing costs appear so diverse. 
 In 1987&ndash;89 Japanese interest rates fell to record lows, with the central bank's discount rate at 2.5% and prime-borrowing costs for Japanese companies around 4&ndash;6%. 
 That compared with prime rates for American firms of 10% or so. 
 An albatross round the neck of American business? 
 First note that if you argue that, you must now logically think that the disadvantage has gone: prime-borrowing rates in Japan have risen to over 8%, roughly level with those in America. 
 It is misleading, however, to compare nominal interest rates. 
 If a firm is assessing an investment project and comparing costs with revenues, the earnings from that investment will be affected by inflation. 
 So the interest rate should also be adjusted for inflation. 
 In real terms borrowing is now cheaper in America, since real interest rates there are only 2&ndash;3% compared with 4&ndash;5% in Japan. 
 In Britain they are 3&ndash;4%. 
 Nominal interest rates do count: high rates hurt, for instance, if cash flows are falling in a recession and leaving less available to service debts. 
 But that is different from a decision about an investment project, in which future guesses about profits are compared with capital costs. 
 In open, borderless capital markets, it is hard for borrowing costs to diverge very far. 
 Otherwise, an American or British firm suffering from high domestic interest rates ought simply to borrow in a different currency, say yen. 
 Not all firms can do this, but most can. 
 It is harder to tap international markets for short-term capital (though not impossible: Eurocommercial paper provides a way), but it is the cost of long-term capital that ought to be compared with potential investment projects. 
 When firms borrow abroad, however, they need to switch the cash into whatever currency they are going to have to spend the money in. 
 If they just make a straight currency exchange, they will still be liable for the yen interest payments. 
 Instead, they could swap their yen debt for a dollar or sterling debt through the international swap markets. 
 Either way, there will remain a difference in borrowing costs. 
 But it is clear what causes it: the risk of currency movements. 
 When American or British real interest rates have exceeded Japanese or German ones, the main reason has been the risk that the dollar or pound will fall in value against the yen and D-mark. 
 That in turn reflects macroeconomic policy and the course of the economy: inflation, trade balances, productivity, fiscal and monetary policy. 
 The cost of debt capital is an outcome, not a cause in itself. 
 The other source of differences in borrowing costs is the risk of the borrower itself. 
 Apples must be compared with apples, not oranges. 
 If General Motors has a worse credit rating than Toyota, its borrowing costs ought to be higher. 
 They are, so there is no surprise there. 
 Again, borrowing costs are an outcome, not a cause: an unsuccessful company faces higher borrowing costs. 
 But that is not why it is unsuccessful. 
 The one qualification to this comes at the margin. 
 As outlined in the previous article, the probability of bankruptcy is partly determined by the institutional arrangements for dealing with financial distress; that in turn affects the costs incurred by a firm. 
 For marginal firms, Japan's way of dealing with financial distress lowers their costs in comparison with American firms in the same condition. 
 A later article will argue that this lowering of costs does not eliminate them altogether but rather transfers them. 
 In Japan, that ability to transfer and spread costs is increasingly under pressure. 
 It may not last more than another few years. 
 But for the time being it gives Japanese firms a small advantage. 
 Might their biggest advantage, however, lie in their most inscrutable institution of all, the Tokyo stockmarket? 
 Warrants on the wild side 
 Japanese equity warrants were like junk bonds: mispriced, misleading and, for some issuers, mistaken 
 MEASURING the cost of the other source of capital &mdash; equity &mdash; is far harder and so more controversial. 
 With that warning in mind, the outcome for Japan in the 1980s is nevertheless surprising: its only clear advantage in the cost of equity capital came while it had a wild, speculative market in shares, land and warrants in 1987&ndash;89. 
 And that has now gone. 
 The crudest approach to measuring the cost of equity &mdash; the equivalent of comparing nominal interest rates &mdash; is to compare price-earnings ratios for stockmarket indices in New York, London and Tokyo. 
 The reciprocal of the p/e ratio &mdash; the earnings yield &mdash; is thought to measure the claim by shareholders on a firm's cash flow, so the higher the p/e the lower the cost of capital. 
 Conveniently, since 1983 or so p/e ratios in Japan have been high, reaching a peak of 60&ndash;70% in late 1989 compared with 12&ndash;15% in America and Britain, suggesting a big gap in capital costs. 
 (Inconveniently, they have been low in Germany, but doubtless German firms' cheap capital comes from somewhere else.) 
 There are several problems with using p/e ratios. 
 One is that differences in accounting methods between countries mean that p/es are misleading, because earnings are measured in different ways. 
 If Japanese accounts are redrawn using American methods, the p/e ratios fall by 30&ndash;50%. 
 Another is that earnings yields do not necessarily measure investors' claim on a firm's cash flow. 
 Dividend pay-outs are much lower in Japan and Germany than in Britain and America, but this is not the only or even the main source of returns to shareholders: they receive capital gains (indeed they prefer them in Japan, where dividends are taxed much more heavily than capital gains) and, especially in Japan, gain business advantages through shareholdings in customers or suppliers, for instance. 
 The result is that if a Japanese firm was systematically making investments using its earnings yield as a measure of the cost of capital, it would soon be making a loss. 
 It would be paying out more than it was earning. 
 And if capital gains turned to losses, investors would stop providing capital. 
 Moreover, dividends are often low or non-existent, and p/es high, when a firm is enjoying or about to enjoy fast growth. 
 For that reason, high-tech firms often pay little or nothing in dividends, in America and Britain as well as Japan. 
 This does not mean their cost of capital is low. 
 Investors provide the cash expecting high returns; to get the money, a firm must be looking at pretty profitable investment opportunities. 
 Japanese firms have enjoyed faster growth than American ones, so, on this basis, you would expect dividends to be lower. 
 Might Japanese firms face a lower cost of capital because their investors are more patient? 
 Not really; the time period over which the returns are expected to arrive should not affect the investors' overall requirements. 
 Remember opportunity costs: in coughing up the money for one project, investors are still comparing it with other possible projects. 
 Regardless of what returns Japanese investors are thought to require, the returns they have received were spectacular in 1980&ndash;89. 
 Total returns (dividends plus capital gains) on investments in the Tokyo stockmarket were a compound 28% a year in dollar terms, compared with 17.5% in New York. 
 It is implausible that, having received a fat return yesterday, investors will meekly shovel tomorrow's cash into an unpromising project. 
 The fact is that projects in Japan are profitable, both for firms and investors. 
 Unsurprisingly, they attract capital. 
 Blowing bubbles 
 There remains one way in which the cost of equity might be low, albeit for a limited period. 
 This is if shares were overpriced &mdash; that is, if prices were unsustainably high. 
 In that case, it would be attractive for a firm to issue equity today knowing that its share price would fall tomorrow. 
 But if investors also believed share prices would fall, they would demand a higher price for their money. 
 So this opportunity depends on a difference of opinion: investors thinking that prices are going to carry on rising, while firms rush to exploit what they see as a temporary state of affairs. 
 This is a plausible description of what happened in Japan in 1987&ndash;89, admittedly a long &bquo;temporary&equo; period. 
 Share prices soared in Tokyo, pushed by a loose monetary policy, falling inflation and a simultaneous rapid rise in land prices (which offered both collateral for share investments and rising asset values for firms owning land). 
 As share prices rose, companies rushed to issue Eurobonds with warrants attached that were convertible into shares if the share reached a pre-fixed exercise price. 
 In effect, they were issuing equity; the bond yields were low (2&ndash;4%) because buyers bet that share prices would rise beyond the exercise levels, providing big capital gains and cheap switches into equity. 
 When the warrants are exercised, the issuer can use the proceeds to repay the bonds. 
 Was this cheap capital? 
 Most issuers thought so, because of the low yields. 
 Did it affect their investment projects? 
 Some firms' behaviour suggests that it did, but not simply by making them invest more in Japanese factories. 
 If a firm made an issue thinking that Japanese assets were overpriced, it would be more sensible to invest the proceeds in assets thought to be underpriced, such as American buildings or companies. 
 That is exactly what happened: Japan's net exports of long-term capital soared to &dollar;130 billion a year, much larger than the country's current-account surplus. 
 Into Japanese hands fell Rockefeller Centre in New York, Firestone in Ohio and Columbia Pictures in Hollywood. 
 Into American hands, therefore, fell some of the capital. 
 Alternatively, if a firm made its issue thinking share prices were indeed going to rocket (for that is what the low yields implied), then it could be worth its while to take the cash and invest it back into equities or other financial instruments. 
 That, again, is what many firms did, speculating on the capital markets rather than building factories. 
 Even if they did not speculate, many could raise warrant bonds at yields of 3&ndash;5% and put the money in bank deposits at higher rates. 
 The effect of apparently cheap capital was not as simple as it might appear. 
 Pop 
 Today the capital does not even look cheap. 
 The crash of the Tokyo stockmarket during 1990 left a mountain of these warrants far below their exercise prices. 
 If they stay below, the issuers will have to borrow at current higher interest rates to repay the bonds. 
 Taken as a whole, the cost of capital in Japan in 1988&ndash;93 will not have been as low as it seemed. 
 According to Baring Securities, a prominent trader of warrants in Tokyo and London, there were &dollar;120.2 billion-worth of Japanese warrant bonds outstanding as of mid-February. 
 At that time, when the Nikkei 225 index was trading at 26,230, more than half by value of the warrants outstanding were more than 20% &bquo;out of the money&equo;: in other words (see table), they needed the issuers' share prices to rise by at least that amount to reach the exercise price. 
 Out of that &dollar;67.8 billion-worth, around &dollar;5.7 billion-worth were more than 50% out of the money. 
 Nissan, Japan's second-biggest car firm, has a &dollar;1.5 billion issue with an exercise price of &yen;1,600. 
 Its share price is around half that. 
 In practice, however, share prices would have to rise by a bit more to convince holders to convert warrants into shares, since by switching from bonds into equities they would be taking an extra risk. 
 If, on the other hand, the Nikkei index were to fall by just 20% from its mid-February level, it would leave a total of &dollar;114 billion-worth out of the money. 
 The stockmarket's all-time low, remember, was a little over 20,000, reached at the end of October 1990. 
 There is plenty of time before most of these warrant issues expire. 
 Only &dollar;2.5 billion-worth expire this year and &dollar;20.4 billion in 1992. 
 The big bulge &mdash; 284 issues, worth &dollar;64 billion, including the Nissan issue cited earlier &mdash; comes in 1993. 
 So the Nikkei has two years or so to rise the 20&ndash;50% needed to bail the issuers out. 
 That would be moderate by past standards, though it would imply a return to high p/e ratios. 
 Even at 26,230, the average p/e ratio was still 45. 
 For the issuers, however, two effects are already clear. 
 One is that the equity market, whether for warrants issues or straight equity, is more or less closed. 
 In January there was just one public issue of equity. 
 Except in small quantities or special cases, money now has to be raised through debt. 
 The second is that even if the stockmarket does eventually rise by enough to persuade holders to exercise the warrants, issuers will have to plan and to some extent act as if it will not. 
 If they wait and see, they would risk joining a rush of borrowing when the bonds have to be repaid, forcing interest rates higher. 
 So many firms will try to raise the money earlier, to avoid the rush hour. 
 When they do so, the refinancing will cost far more than the warrant yields originally suggested &mdash; around 8&ndash;10%, at current interest rates, rather than the 3&ndash;5% or less on the warrants. 
 These equity-related issues are Japan's equivalent of America's junk bonds. 
 Not directly, for the instruments are different: one is equity, the other high-yield subordinated debt. 
 But like America's junk bonds, Japan's warrants were mispriced. 
 They appeared to offer a free lunch, complete with cigars and brandy. 
 As with junk, the offer appeared to be available even to pretty second-rate companies. 
 Japan seemed to have invented a new way to create ultra-cheap money. 
 It had not. 
 As with junk, the bill eventually arrived. 
 The new state of corporate Japan 
 Some Japanese companies are now more equal than others 
 IT IS a beguiling place, Japan: no sooner have westerners worked out how things work there than the country slips from their grasp. 
 In corporate finance, the conventional view in America and Britain still is that Japanese firms rely for most of their money on friendly banks that they have been wining and dining for years. 
 That high gearing lowers their cost of capital (Modigliani and Miller again, because of tax deductions), the friendly bank lowers the risk of bankruptcy and the firm is left able to take a jolly long-term approach to research and investment. 
 This was true once, but is now out of date &mdash; about seven years out of date, in fact. 
 The warrant boom of 1987&ndash;89 was the last phase of a long period of dramatic change for Japanese companies and their bankers. 
 When 1981 began, the average debt-equity ratio of firms listed on the Tokyo Stock Exchange (TSE) was 2.75. 
 Bank borrowing accounted for 64% of their external financing. 
 Banks also owned equity stakes in their clients, but their real influence came from debt: companies' big exposure to bank debt gave the lenders control rather as if they held equity. 
 Yet, beginning roughly in 1984&ndash;85, companies, especially the bigger ones, deserted the banks. 
 Money was cheaper elsewhere. 
 At first, they went to the bond markets, especially offshore ones, raising dollars or Swiss francs and swapping them for yen. 
 Firms raised more external finance than they needed, using the surplus to repay bank debts and build up excess cash. 
 The second phase began in 1986, when the Tokyo stockmarket began to soar: firms switched to equity, starting with ordinary issues and private placements, but then issuing convertible and warrant bonds (see chart 18, overleaf). 
 In the fiscal year ending in March 1990, the debt-equity ratio for TSE-listed firms was only 1.07. 
 Their ratio of debts to total assets had fallen below 30%, having ranged between 40% and 50% for most of the 1960s and 1970s. 
 They are still close to their banks, but the bankers kowtow to them, not the other way around. 
 Some of the biggest firms, in fact, have balance sheets far stronger than those of the banks: Toyota has cash and deposits worth &yen;1.8 trillion (&dollar;850 billion). 
 It received net interest and dividends in the 1990 fiscal year that accounted for more than 20% of its operating profits. 
 Meanwhile, the banks are slowly slipping over a cliff. 
 After the party 
 The long trend of the 1980s has come to an end, along with the crash of the Tokyo stockmarket in 1990 and the collapse of warrants. 
 The crash has hurt banks far more than companies. 
 But the change will affect companies, too. 
 Their fortunes will become more divided than before: some are waking up from the party with happier memories than others. 
 The party was brought to an end deliberately, by the Bank of Japan. 
 It raised interest rates five times from mid-1989 to mid-1990, in the hope of squeezing the speculative bubbles in the stock and property markets before they burst on their own. 
 So far the policy has succeeded: the stockmarket fell by 48% from peak to trough, but has since recovered about a third of its losses. 
 Bank lending to the property market dried up, some property firms have gone bust and land prices have begun to slip. 
 But, so far, a cataclysmic crash has been avoided. 
 Those were the central bank's explicit aims. 
 But it also had implicit ones. 
 In effect, its tight-money policy is intended to bring about a shift in the domestic economy that might have happened in the early 1980s but which kept being postponed. 
 The aim is to shift bits of the economy out of low-tech, inefficient manufacturing and cartelised, inefficient services, such as wholesale and retail distribution. 
 It was postponed first by the weak yen in 1982&ndash;85 which boosted exports and protected domestic industries from imports, and then by low interest rates and the soaring stockmarket in 1985&ndash;89 which cut financial burdens, allowed weak firms to make speculative profits to cover ordinary losses and made capital seem temporarily cheap. 
 Now that those phases are over, the shift is beginning. 
 The Bank of Japan is trying to force inefficient firms to go out of business. 
 It is happening in two main ways. 
 One is that high interest rates have raised financial burdens directly for weaker firms that are still net debtors. 
 Economic growth is slowing &mdash; from 5.6% in 1990 probably to less than half that in 1991 &mdash; and with it corporate profits. 
 The other way is that commercial banks are themselves caught in a vicious squeeze. 
 Their capital, required by Bank for International Settlements' rules to exceed 8% of their assets, has been depleted by the stockmarket's fall. 
 BIS rules allow them to count 45% of unrealised gains on shareholdings as part of their capital, but those gains have now shrunk. 
 Their profits are weakening thanks to tougher competition, loan write-offs and a rising cost of funds. 
 There is no generalised credit crunch in Japan, but particular firms are being hurt. 
 Property developers have been the first to suffer, with credit lines cut off, interest costs rising and prices beginning to slip. 
 It is spreading to other firms too, as banks weed out their client lists in order to raise profits and cut asset growth. 
 The immediate result is simple: bankruptcies are on the rise. 
 The total liabilities of corporate failures in Japan fell in 1989 to &yen;1.2 trillion, the lowest for a decade. 
 In 1990 the total rose to &yen;2 trillion, but January 1991 alone brought &yen;400 billion-worth. 
 Mikuni &amp; Co, an independent credit-rating agency, reckons bankruptcy liabilities will double this year, to around &yen;4 trillion. 
 But that will not be it: the firm predicts liabilities will peak at &yen;12 trillion in 1993, before falling by half during the following year or two. 
 Mikuni bases its forecast on past relationships between bankruptcies, the ratio of bank lending to GNP, and interest rates. 
 The socialisation of credit risk 
 If it happens, this corporate death toll is unlikely to include famous names. 
 The gap between the financial state of Japan's biggest and strongest firms &mdash; generally those familiar in the West &mdash; and the smaller and weaker ones has widened. 
 In the past that gap was bridged by the commercial banks who, in effect, took from the strong (which included themselves) to give to the weak. 
 Credit risk was spread, or socialised; riskier firms did not suffer the full burden of their riskiness. 
 But now the banks are themselves too weak to offer a bridge. 
 Almost certainly, the bankruptcy wave of 1991&ndash;93 will bring an end to socialised credit. 
 The most striking thing about the boom in issues of convertible and warrant bonds in 1987&ndash;89 was how many firms were involved. 
 In the early 1980s only around 200&ndash;300 companies issued bonds abroad. 
 By the end of the decade more than 1,200 had their snouts in the trough. 
 On an American basis, their credit ratings ranged from triple A to junk. 
 But the yields on their bonds varied by far less than the ratings would suggest. 
 Similarly, the range of interest rates charged on bank loans was much narrower than it would be in America or Britain. 
 According to Ryuji Yasuda, a consultant in McKinsey's Tokyo office, this has started to change in the past six months. 
 As the bankruptcies roll in and loan write-offs grow, it will change even more. 
 Yields in the Swiss capital market for Japanese firms' bonds are already beginning to reflect the range of issuers' credit ratings. 
 There is scarcely any corporate-bond market in Japan, because issuing costs are too high; but if new rules bring those costs down and the market revives, it is likely to have a wider range of yields than before. 
 Banks cannot afford to allow socialisation to continue. 
 The top dozen, well-known Japanese banks remain strong. 
 Their capital ratios are close to the BIS target of 8%. 
 So are those of the best regional banks. 
 But even these cannot afford to act as nursemaids to more than a few sick clients. 
 Underneath them stand thousands of weaker regional banks, mutual banks and credit unions, as well as non-bank banks such as leasing firms. 
 These are the ones that will be hurt most directly by bankruptcies among property firms and smaller industrial companies, for those are their main clients. 
 Like America's thrifts, mutual banks and credit unions rushed to lend to property developers in the hope of finding new sources of profit. 
 As those developers go bust and along with them the credit unions, larger banks will be goaded to take their weaker brethren over. 
 In the end, the consolidation of Japan's banking industry will make it stronger. 
 But while it happens, the big banks will be taking the strain of the smaller ones. 
 They cannot at the same time absorb and spread the credit risks of their corporate clients as well. 
 Something has to give. 
 Top companies are changing, too. 
 Even among the biggest and best known firms, financial performance is becoming more important in separating sheep from goats. 
 Chart 20 shows McKinsey's demonstration of this for firms in cars and electronics. 
 The gap between the operating incomes of Toyota, Honda and Nissan is not all that wide. 
 But in 1990 Toyota's financial profit lengthened its lead over Honda and Nissan, both of which made financial losses. 
 In electronics, finance has narrowed the gap: Matsushita's financial profits brought it level with Hitachi and closer to Toshiba. 
 The &yen;64 trillion question, however, is what all this will mean for relations between big banks and big companies. 
 Both are becoming more conscious of the cost of capital and the need to use finance profitably. 
 Big firms have long ago weaned themselves off their dependence on the banks who, in the 1960s and 1970s, supported them through thin times and thick. 
 Now that the banks are in thinner times, might rich companies come to their rescue instead? 
 Up to a point they will, but they cannot afford to let rescuing the banks sap their competitiveness, whether against other Japanese firms or against foreign ones. 
 The old tight links between banks and firms related to them in their industrial groups have gone. 
 This does not mean, however, that in the way they run themselves Japanese firms are going to become like American and British ones. 
 Communities of interest 
 The key to ownership and control in Japan is not the bank but the tangled web that shareholdings weave 
 IF JAPANESE companies no longer depend on banks for their finance, and if banks will soon no longer provide such a generous service in dealing with bankruptcy by socialising credit risks, might Japan soon have the symptoms of America and Britain: hostile takeovers and arms-length corporate governance? 
 It might, if close links between banks and firms were the be-all and end-all of the Japanese system. 
 But they are not even the heart of it. 
 Most largish Japanese firms are members of some kind of industrial group. 
 The closest sorts of group are called keiretsu, and have familiar names like Mitsui, Mitsubishi, Sumitomo and so on. 
 Some were based on the pre-war zaibatsu family-run conglomerates, others are centred on a big manufacturer such as Toyota, Nippon Steel or Matsushita. 
 Altogether, these groups account for about a quarter of all sales by Japanese firms. 
 Most other firms are also members of a looser group of some sort. 
 However close the group, the most important feature is the same: reciprocal, interlocking shareholdings between members. 
 In diagrams of the complicated networks of shareholdings that make up these groups, banks are usually placed in the centre. 
 This makes them look like the controlling force, the spider in the middle of the web. 
 Banks are important and often do take a leading role, but they are not the spider. 
 The bank is at the centre because it is usually the only firm that does business with every other member of the group and thus also owns a small (typically 3&ndash;5%) shareholding in all the other members. 
 Despite that, the bank is not essential. 
 Weaken its links to the other members and the group will not fall apart. 
 The reason is that Japanese groups are not centrally controlled. 
 Nor are they decentralised in the true meaning of the word: powers belonging to the centre are not devolved to peripheral firms. 
 They are more like a federal system. 
 The centre, if there is one, is in effect granted its limited powers and influence by the members of the group, the states. 
 The power lies with the members. 
 Even the federal analogy is too strong for most groups. 
 They are communities of interest, sharing opportunities and obligations. 
 Carl Kester of Harvard Business School usefully puts it another way in a recent book, &bquo;Japanese Takeovers: the global contest for corporate control.&equo; 
 Western managers talk about the need for firms to pay attention not just to shareholders but also to other &bquo;stakeholders&equo; such as customers, suppliers, employees and neighbours. 
 Mr Kester points out that the difference in Japanese firms is that the stakeholders that matter most &mdash; customers and suppliers &mdash; are also shareholders. 
 Employees are sometimes shareholders through stock-ownership schemes, but are mainly taken care of through labour laws and guarantees of lifetime employment. 
 Neighbours are more or less ignored. 
 But those with whom the firm has a business relationship own shares in it. 
 And it owns shares in them. 
 These groups are simply federations of business relationships. 
 Firms within them see no conflict between the interests of shareholders and those of stakeholders, because they are one and the same. 
 These interlocking shareholders have an interest in each other's prosperity, partly because they do business with one another, partly because they have invested in each other. 
 Unlike a pension fund in either Britain, America or even Japan, these interlocking shareholders have strong economic reasons to care about the performance of the firms in which they own shares. 
 Unlike the cross-shareholdings seen in America in the era of Pierpont Morgan, the links are not usually between competitors so do not necessarily indicate a cartel. 
 There are other economic advantages. 
 A manufacturer can work closely with its suppliers, co-operating on the development of new components, for instance. 
 It is like being part of the same company, but without the drawbacks. 
 Unlike in a firm that is a jack of all trades, the supplier is an independent business subject to market disciplines rather than another bit of a big bureaucracy. 
 From the supplier's point of view, the relationship is better than simply one based on contracts, price and open bidding. 
 Though the supplier has no guarantee of the business, it has an advantage and, once it has the business, the firm can be fairly sure it will keep it for a long time. 
 It can thus invest on the assumption that the contract will not last for merely a year. 
 The community dividend 
 An immediate result of this sort of mutual ownership has already been mentioned in the article on the cost of equity: dividend pay-outs are an incomplete measure of the commercial benefits obtained by shareholders. 
 As chart 21 shows, Japanese firms pay on average only 30% of their post-tax profits as dividends, higher than in Germany but lower than in Britain or America. 
 Nevertheless it is important to note that dividend pay-outs have not always been this low. 
 In the early 1970s pay-outs were 50&ndash;60%, similar to American levels. 
 Since then two things have changed. 
 The web of cross-shareholdings has extended much further into Japanese business. 
 Though it has long existed, it has spread wider as the Japanese economy has matured and become more open to competition, especially from overseas. 
 That has led firms to try to protect business relationships through buying shares. 
 The second change has been in share prices themselves: in the 1980s they soared. 
 This handed shareholders bumper capital gains, making virtually all investors &mdash; individuals, foreigners, pension funds, life insurers and interlocking holders &mdash; less worried about dividends. 
 Capital gains are a better proxy for the full benefits from interlocking holdings, since they ought in principle to absorb the value created in all the businesses involved. 
 In 1990, however, these capital gains went into reverse. 
 Although some of the share-price losses have now been regained, the crash has nevertheless destroyed investors' confidence that there will always be healthy gains. 
 As a result, most firms are talking about paying higher dividends. 
 The finance ministry has long acted to prevent dividends slipping any lower by setting a rule barring firms from issuing new equity if they pass or reduce their pay-outs. 
 Now it is twisting arms to get dividends raised. 
 Most of the interlocking holders do not care about dividends. 
 But the trouble is that they do not account for anything like all the shares of most firms. 
 Other holders, like individuals, pension funds and foreigners, do care about dividends but did not worry while share prices were booming. 
 And one hybrid of an interlocking holder and the ordinary sort &mdash; the life-insurance firm &mdash; cares deeply about dividends nowadays. 
 Life insurers sold policies with yields which could easily be paid in a rising stockmarket but not when it falls. 
 They are now suffering redemptions. 
 Unless share prices revive, their best hope of keeping up their yields and thus remaining competitive with other savings instruments comes from higher dividends. 
 The healthiest poison pill 
 This pressure for higher dividends will, if it is sustained, push firms towards more borrowing (to pay the dividend) and less dependence on equities. 
 Unless higher dividends are paid, the cement holding the groups together will weaken. 
 Rising share prices gave all shareholders a common interest; now their interests have, to an extent, diverged. 
 Life insurance firms are an important species of &bquo;safe&equo; shareholder. 
 But they are a hybrid because, although closely associated with particular groups, they are not part of the web of cross-shareholdings. 
 They cannot be: they are mutuals, owned by their policyholders. 
 Although this pressure for higher dividends is unsettling for the system of cross-shareholdings, it is unlikely to be fatal. 
 The basic motive for continuing with the groups &mdash; the cementing of business relationships &mdash; remains as strong as ever. 
 That is also why the weakening of links with banks and the pressure for higher dividends are unlikely to lead to a spate of hostile takeover bids in Japan. 
 Plenty of mergers take place, often under pressure even if not overtly hostile. 
 But the American or British sort of open tender over the heads of managers is unlikely to catch on. 
 The reason is not culture, nor because such bids are somehow taboo. 
 It is because a bid generally threatens too many entrenched interests. 
 Although it is possible in principle that a bidder might offer a high enough price to compensate suppliers and customers for the relationship benefits they derive from their shareholdings, it is unlikely. 
 And the target firm's value generally depends, in any case, on those relationships continuing. 
 Apart from arms-length shareholders such as foreigners, pension funds and individuals, investors typically stand to lose too much from a change of ownership. 
 They may not have monitored the firm's management terribly closely. 
 But if and when a bid comes they are likelier to use it as a stimulus to change or otherwise discipline the incumbent management rather than selling out. 
 The structure of corporate governance thus provides its own sort of poison-pill defence: if a bid were to succeed, all sorts of costs would be incurred because of harm to relationships. 
 The cross-shareholding system is protective, but the protection is provided by owners who care directly about the fate and performance of the firm. 
 It is not principally provided by banks, though these might supply a new director or two if things go wrong. 
 All this makes the Japanese system decidedly different from that with which it is often carelessly linked: continental Europe. 
 The European communities 
 Beware simple comparisons between Britain and continental Europe 
 IF CORPORATE governance and the virtues or vices of free financial markets had been agonised over as much in 1985 as they are now, continental Europe would have ruined many of the most popular and simplistic conclusions. 
 These days, it is widely assumed that monitoring of firms by close, caring banks is a better way to run things than the arms-length institutional ownership of America and Britain. 
 Yet in 1985 free-market Britain seemed to be outpacing the rest of bank-monitored Europe, which was in the throes of &bquo;Eurosclerosis&equo;: slow growth thanks to closed markets, protected managers and workers, and backward technology. 
 In many eyes, control by Deutsche Bank and its fellows was responsible even for West German sloth. 
 This mainly goes to show the error, which is all too common, of seeing causes where there are only correlations. 
 Do free markets in finance and takeovers produce a healthier economy than those where regulation is tighter and shares are more closely held? 
 Look at chart 22 overleaf and draw your own conclusions. 
 Only one point stands irrespective of the period taken: Japan has shown all the other rich countries a clean pair of heels. 
 Since 1950 America and Britain have been the slowest. 
 But if you measure from 1960&ndash;90, America draws level in real GNP growth with West Germany, and then overtakes it both for 1970&ndash;90 and 1980&ndash;90. 
 Few American businessmen believe that their economy has fared as well as Germany's, but it has. 
 For the latest decade, even Britain moves up the field: it and America both outpaced France and West Germany. 
 France, under-rated by many, has outgrown Germany throughout the postwar period. 
 If the figures are for real GNP per head then West Germany would fare better, because of its slow growing (and latterly falling) population, than America which has had millions of new immigrants. 
 But even on real GNP per head, Britain outpaced West Germany in the 1980s. 
 French connections 
 On average, continental Europe does conform to the stereotypical comparison with Britain: more universal banks, closer links between banks and industry, more restrictive rules on shareholdings and voting rights, far fewer hostile takeovers. 
 Slowly, the European Community is edging towards laws that might make rules on shareholdings and takeovers more homogeneous and more liberal, though a deal is many years away. 
 But even now, the average conceals as much as it reveals. 
 From 1982 until 1988, French companies behaved rather as Japanese ones did: they ran free of their banks. 
 When the 1980s began, they relied on banks for 71% of their external financing and carried debts equal to 68% of their assets. 
 Suddenly this changed, prompted first by the Socialist government's nationalisation of the main banks and, later, by a bout of liberalisation and the revival of the Paris stockmarket. 
 Bank debts were paid back and replaced with equity in a spate of fund-raising that put French firms ahead of the British as equity issuers (see chart 23). 
 By 1988 bank borrowing accounted for only 53% of their external financing; debt equalled only 63% of their assets. 
 Since then, however, this has gone into reverse, in two different ways. 
 Companies have rushed back into debt, mainly to finance overseas acquisitions, especially in Britain and America. 
 French firms arrived late at the foreign-investment auction and paid high prices as a result. 
 For instance, Saint Gobain, a recently privatised glassmaker, outbid Britain's BTR to buy Norton, an American maker of abrasives, for FFr11 billion (&dollar;2 billion) just a few months before America's recession began. 
 Accor, a hotel group, took the Motel 6 chain off the hands of Kohlberg Kravis Roberts (which had bought it a year earlier in an LBO) for FFr7 billion at around the same time. 
 Michelin, a tyre firm, bought Uniroyal Goodrich in America for &dollar;1.5 billion and is now staggering under the debts and a fall-off in its business. 
 Many in France assume the government will have to (or choose to) rescue it from bankruptcy. 
 The other reversal of the 1980s was that banks accelerated their purchases of equities. 
 French banks had always had broad powers, but a new banking act in 1984 broadened them still further. 
 They responded by pushing hard into corporate finance, seeking to use shareholdings as a door-opener. 
 Cr&eacute;dit Lyonnais, one of the two big banks that are still state-owned, isolated all its long-term holdings of shares in a new firm, Clinvest, and began to add to them. 
 It buys minority stakes, usually of less than 10%, and stresses that the stake is friendly &mdash; that is, it will not be sold to a hostile bidder. 
 Clinvest avoids firms in which other banks hold a stake: it wants to be on its own, so that it can be more influential. 
 All the main banks stress that they do not want to boss firms around in the German style, nor do they want to send in managers or directors. 
 Nor do they intend to underwrite other banks' loans if the firm goes under; they say they will take part in rescues, but not as guarantors. 
 What they want is business, not as an exclusive right but as a first option. 
 In that way, the French banks are trying to be Japanese, to set up a community of interest between themselves and their clients. 
 Despite the changes of the past ten years or so, there is little sign in France of an active takeover market. 
 There have been a few hostile bids, most notably that by Paribas for a conglomerate, Navigation Mixte. 
 But shareholding rules make hostile bids hard to win. 
 Firms have a panoply of shares with different levels of voting rights. 
 The bank stakes also stand in the way. 
 Mutual funds (unit trusts in Britain) have become big shareholders in France, but few are run by independent groups; most are subsidiaries of banks which in turn can influence decisions during bids. 
 The arrival of an American-style takeover market is not impossible, but it is extremely unlikely. 
 Nevertheless French firms have aped many of the practices of American bidders. 
 Notably, they have shuffled assets with just as much vigour. 
 American critics of the &dollar;25 billion buy-out of RJR Nabisco in 1988&ndash;89 lamented this treatment of a &bquo;fine old American company&equo;, yet conveniently forgot that it had only been formed in 1985 when R.J. Reynolds merged with Nabisco Brands, which in turn had only been formed in 1981 when Nabisco merged with Standard Brands. 
 RJR Nabisco promptly sold bits of itself to pay back its buy-out debts, including Del Monte foods (to Britain's defunct Polly Peck) and its biscuit division to a French group, BSN. 
 That left BSN burdened with FFr14 billion of debt, which it reduced by FFr3.1 billion in December by selling its champagne businesses to Mo&euml;t-Hennessy-Louis-Vuitton (LVMH), an ambitious French luxury-goods firm. 
 In mid-March LVMH reduced its debts by selling part of those businesses, the Lanson brand, only three months after it had bought it. 
 Remember Mr Altman's notion of &bquo;temporary debts&equo; incurred during takeovers? 
 That is just what both BSN and LVMH were up to. 
 Across the Rhine, there is less toing and froing. 
 And, despite Pirelli's well-publicised assault on the Continental tyre firm, there is little sign of an active takeover market developing. 
 In Germany there are too many obstacles: 
 Few firms have gone public, despite an increase in interest in the stockmarket in recent years. 
 Out of the 2,300 or so public limited companies (Aktiengesellchaften, or AG), only 619 have ordinary shares quoted or traded on the stockmarket (which is 80 more than at end-1989). 
 The amount of shares floating freely is tiny. 
 The total capital of all those AGs is smaller than that of the 360,000 so-called private limited companies (GmbH). 
 Voting rights of shares can be limited by firms' articles of association. 
 Asko, Mannesmann, Bayer and even Deutsche Bank itself limit any one shareholder to 5% of the votes; at Hoesch the figure is 15% and at Volkswagen 20%. 
 It often takes a 75% majority to change those rules: possible, but difficult. 
 Banks own small stakes of their own and can rally support against a bidder. 
 More to the point, they vote as proxies for private shareholders who typically deposit their shares in the bank's custody. 
 Those proxy votes must be used in support of incumbent management unless the shareholder specifically instructs the bank otherwise. 
 Admittedly, banks are obliged to send full offer-documents to such shareholder-depositors. 
 But apathy often works for the status quo. 
 German stability 
 This does not mean that restructuring and financial change cannot take place. 
 But it takes a different form, chiefly private transactions. 
 There has been some increase in equity finance, by listed firms as well as new entrants, but it is restrained by a system giving pre-emptive rights to existing shareholders (as in Britain, shareholders must be given first grabs at new issues), under ponderous rules that mean an issue takes three weeks. 
 That problem of delay and a tax incentive for investors lead most firms to rely on private placements (Schuldscheine) or on bank finance. 
 Exactly what role the banks play in monitoring management is hard to pin down. 
 They often have directors on firms' supervisory boards, the second tier of German boards which is required by law and includes elected representatives of the workforce. 
 But they are bankers, not industrialists; they are scarcely more qualified than any other director to tell managers what they should or should not be doing. 
 Most supervisory boards meet only twice a year. 
 For those reasons, banks' clearest role is at times of crisis; the firm needs their financial support, and they act to rally other supporters. 
 Julian Franks of London Business School and Colin Mayer of City University have studied the restructuring during the 1980s of three German firms: AEG, an electricals firm; MAN, a mechanical engineer and truck maker; and Bayer, a chemicals firm. 
 Formally, the process was similar to that in America. 
 Of the three, only AEG filed for court protection from its creditors (in 1982) under the Vergleich rules, which are similar to America's chapter 11. 
 Bayer and MAN both restructured privately. 
 There were two big differences, however. 
 The most important is that the restructurings took longer: eight years in AEG's case, four years in MAN's. 
 During that time dividends were cut or passed and there were plenty of closures and redundancies, but spending on R&amp;D and on capital investment was maintained. 
 Neither Bayer nor MAN was in the same desperate straits as AEG; but even in the electricals firm's case capital spending fell sharply as a percentage of sales only in 1982. 
 It paid no dividend until 1988. 
 The second difference is that turnover on the management and supervisory boards was high: AEG had eight departures and 11 new arrivals on its management board in 1980&ndash;89; Bayer 11 departures and seven arrivals; MAN two departures and seven arrivals. 
 In America, whether in or out of court, the managers who led the firm into the ditch often remain at the controls while it is pulled out. 
 British balance 
 The British way is a bit of a compromise &mdash; as you might expect. 
 Britain had a big takeover boom in 1985&ndash;89, with plenty of bitterly fought hostile bids; but none was financed with junk bonds. 
 It was only the last and biggest headline-grabber &mdash; Sir James Goldsmith's failed bid in 1989 for B.A.T Industries &mdash; that threatened to bring junk to London. 
 And few bids have ended up in bankruptcy. 
 One or two leveraged buy-outs have failed, including the biggest, that for Magnet, which makes kitchen furniture. 
 But most failures &mdash; so far &mdash; have been firms that never went near the merger market. 
 Nevertheless, British firms did take on much more debt in 1988&ndash;90, after almost a decade of using record profits to slim debts. 
 Since most takeovers were financed in cash, some of those debts went to pay for them. 
 The burden of interest payments as a proportion of cash flow rose to a record 34% last year, as these bigger debts met high nominal interest rates and fading cash flows. 
 When debts become too large to bear, British firms also use debt-restructurings and the bankruptcy laws. 
 Compared with Germany, however, the banks are more distant from their clients, which can make restructuring deals harder to complete. 
 The saga at Saatchi &amp; Saatchi is a case in point; the advertising group's &bquo;main bank&equo; is its investment bank, S.G. Warburg. 
 Warburg may have raised some of the finance that has now led Saatchi &amp; Saatchi into trouble, but it is by no means an underwriter of the firm's financial future. 
 The big difference in Britain &mdash; which American opponents of takeovers look up to &mdash; is the country's voluntary but powerful Takeover Code. 
 This, together with laws that protect minority shareholders, makes takeovers both easier and harder. 
 Easier, in the sense that it bans Germanic tricks to limit the transfer of ownership; but more difficult by requiring an offer to be made to all shareholders at the same price, once a firm has accumulated 30% of the shares. 
 It prevents repeat bids within a year and bans bidders from acting in undisclosed concert with other people. 
 Most notably, it bans firms from frustrating a bidder by crippling themselves with debt or swallowing poison pills. 
 Even so, the chief British worry is similar to the American one: that ownership of shares by uncaring institutions, and provision of debt by distant banks and capital markets, mean that the takeover is the only means of managerial discipline. 
 Only when a firm is put into play or bid for is the management's performance given any scrutiny. 
 Messrs Franks and Mayer have found evidence to question this, though it does not disprove it. 
 They tracked all the involuntary departures reported in the press of chief executives and chairmen of British firms in the first six months of 1988. 
 They found 55. 
 Half of those were initiated inside the firm, but most of the others were initiated by shareholders. 
 Only 14 were due to takeovers. 
 Someone, somewhere, is exerting some discipline. 
 Your obedient servant 
 Give a financial market bad instructions and it will carry them out with ruthless efficiency 
 NO MAN is a hero to his valet: the close and obedient servant sees all the weaknesses and vulnerabilities of his master. 
 So it is with the financial servant and its industrial master. 
 Weaknesses in industry and in its political, legal and social surroundings are observed by the financial system in their finest detail. 
 Worst of all, finance is less discreet than the valet. 
 It passes on its master's frailties for all to see. 
 That has been the case most clearly in America in the past dozen turbulent years. 
 The financial system was given more freedom than before, but that made it an even more ruthless broadcaster of economic frailties. 
 The incentive given to savings and loan associations to invest as riskily as they could, the blind eye turned to supervision of thrifts and banks alike, the abolition of tax credits for investment: all were passed on almost without friction by the smooth wheels of finance. 
 Computer buffs have a different phrase for it: garbage in, garbage out. 
 Changes in macroeconomic policy, in taxes, in bankruptcy laws, in the opinions of judges &mdash; all have left their mark on finance, and on its users and abusers. 
 International differences in the cost of capital are determined in the same way, generally through the mechanism of currency risk. 
 But finance should not itself be blamed. 
 It is the incentives under which financial users and providers operate that should take the rap and which require attention. 
 For finance is more often an effect than a cause. 
 Users of finance, most notably companies, operate within the limits imposed from outside: taxes, the cost of money, the rules and institutions governing financial distress. 
 Addressing the effect solves nothing if the cause remains. 
 The financial pressure will simply find another way in which to express itself. 
 Most prominent among the effects singled out for blame is the hostile takeover, both in America and in Britain. 
 It is easy to understand why, for the hostile takeover brings with it a language and an atmosphere of conflict that sounds destructive and sometimes is. 
 It exposes capitalism in the raw: huge profits to be made from risking huge sums of money, often in a matter of weeks, while ordinary people wait, innocently and impotently, for a verdict that will affect their jobs and lives. 
 Often, both in America and in Britain, hostile takeovers have been shown to be reckless, mistaken and damaging. 
 The firms involved have ended up bankrupt or deep in debt, healthy companies turned into cripples. 
 Yet the hostility of takeovers is a distraction, a sort of white noise. 
 In a market in which mergers and takeovers are possible, they will take place in one form or another: which form is adopted will reflect the circumstances of the day. 
 Whether the incumbent managers like or dislike the offer made by a bidder is only one side of the story. 
 Much more important is whether the bid was sensible in the first place. 
 The most perplexing thing is that the evidence shows that many bids are not a good idea. 
 Yet managers continue to propose them. 
 Shareholders do well from selling but not from buying: many mergers and takeovers fail to generate the gains in efficiency and thus cash flow on which the bids were based. 
 The only difference with hostile takeovers may be that the prices are higher. 
 Even that is not clear: many of the break-up bids of the past decade made good economic sense. 
 The most disturbing fact is this: although it may be too soon to pass final judgment on the merger wave of the 1980s, on current evidence this wave was much more successful (or less unsuccessful) than the merger waves of the late 1960s and early 1970s that took place in both Britain and America. 
 Fewer of those mergers, designed to build diversified conglomerates, were &bquo;hostile&equo; in the sense that they went over the heads of incumbent managers. 
 But they were a disaster nonetheless. 
 The mergers of the 1960s were almost certainly the biggest collective error ever made by American business (and copied by British firms). 
 Synergies from diversification did not exist. 
 It was not possible merely to apply management skills and manuals across different sorts of business. 
 American and British firms built fat integrated bureaucracies at just the time when Japanese firms were arriving in international competition with their lean, mean communities of interest. 
 This was a colossal mistake, made by the managers, for the managers. 
 Problems of socialism 
 Today's obsession with preventing another round of hostile takeovers is like the habit of generals always to be fighting the last war. 
 Instead, attention should be turned to the universal problem that lies behind the takeover trend: the separation in capitalism of ownership and control. 
 The fact that shareholders are no longer also running the firms they own has been chewed over at least since the 1930s. 
 In that decade the owners were lots of individual investors; now they are pension funds acting on behalf of lots of savers. 
 The post-war switch to Peter Drucker's pension-fund socialism has altered the form in which ownership is separated from control &mdash; and made hostile bids likelier to succeed &mdash; but it has not changed the basic issue. 
 Anglo-American shareholders are investors holding a portfolio of betting slips, punters rather than proprietors. 
 They are not equipped to care much about the management of the individual firms they own, nor would it be sensible for them to do so: their benefits come from the market's general performance, not from the particular. 
 The benefits to managers, meanwhile, arise from the use and misuse of other people's money. 
 There are some signs that the market is itself seeking to bridge this gap between ownership and control. 
 The potential benefits from doing so lay behind some (but not all) of the takeovers and LBOs of the 1980s. 
 One common way was for managers themselves to take over ownership. 
 Another was for portfolios of firms to be owned not by a pension fund but by a specialist financial or management group: Kohlberg, Kravis, Roberts or Hanson, which buy, break up and set strict financial controls for what remains; Clayton &amp; Dubilier or Forstmann Little, which exert direct supervision over managers; Berkshire Hathaway, which is a more remote but patient investor. 
 In effect, these and other private boutiques are doing the caring and monitoring that investment institutions cannot do for themselves: the boutiques' finance comes from pension funds, insurers and big companies. 
 General Electric is Forstmann Little's biggest investor. 
 Clayton &amp; Dubilier's latest deal is a buy-out of a chunk of IBM that makes typewriters and other lowish-tech bits and pieces. 
 The world's biggest computer maker still needs this division as a supplier, but was failing to run it profitably; so it is selling it to its managers and Clayton &amp; Dubilier, leaving them to run it but still with a supply contract to IBM. 
 In a way, this is like the Japanese method: a community of firms tied to one another's fortunes. 
 Pension funds and other institutional investors are also trying to change their ways. 
 The big funds realise that, in practice, they cannot sell out of most companies they own for they will always need them in their portfolios. 
 So they are looking for ways to use their voices rather than their feet to influence management. 
 As this develops it will be helpful; but it is not a complete solution, for institutions will never be sufficiently well-equipped to intervene in the thousands of firms they own. 
 Efforts to increase such caring should be given government help wherever possible. 
 Two prominent New York takeover lawyers, Martin Lipton (who invented the &bquo;poison pill&equo; defence) and Steven Rosenblum, have proposed a way to help institutions get involved: elect board directors for five-year terms during which they would be sackable only for criminal or scandalous behaviour. 
 Managers would prepare a five-year plan for the firm, a sort of election manifesto. 
 Their pay would be linked to the plan's success, and only to that. 
 The information gap between executives and shareholders would be bridged by employing an independent, outside consultant to study how the firm is being run and whether the strategy is correct &mdash; a five-yearly management audit. 
 Mergers and takeovers would be possible at any time, but only with the board's consent. 
 Hostile bids would be possible only at the five-yearly meetings. 
 This idea is almost certainly impractical, and would merely bunch hostile bids in the run-up to the scheme's implementation and to each five-yearly meeting. 
 Nevertheless it contains two clues for ways to improve things. 
 One is the role of the independent audit. 
 As long as shareholders are principally distant institutions, it will become ever more important to ensure that the annual auditing of accounts is done in as independent and thorough a way as possible; if shareholders wished, that audit could then be extended into more general strategic matters. 
 Independence requires, however, two things missing in Britain and America: the regular rotation of auditors; and the banning of conflicts of interest between work done for the shareholders (auditing) and the increasing amount the same firms do for the managers (consultancy). 
 The second clue comes from Messrs Lipton and Rosenblum's idea of tying managers' pay to long-term performance. 
 In recent years the idea of linking pay to performance has caught on, with stock options and with pay linked to measures such as earnings per share or profit margins. 
 But the links have commonly been flawed in two ways: they have involved little risk of penalty for poor performance; and they have been tied to short-term measures (generally year-by-year). 
 Too many top managers leave after a strategy has failed, clutching pay-offs big enough to guarantee their family's security for several generations. 
 This makes a nonsense of any incentive scheme. 
 The penalty for failure should be heavy; but, by the same token, the rewards for long-term success could be higher than they are today. 
 Michael Jensen and Kevin Murphy of Harvard Business School found, in a 1990 study, that the average pay of chief executives of big American firms had barely caught up, in real terms, with what similar bosses received in the 1930s. 
 But they also found that bosses' pay is often less variable than that of ordinary workers. 
 It should be high, but it should also vary a lot. 
 And it should give managers an incentive to invest &mdash; both in themselves and in their company's strategy &mdash; for the long term. 
 In the short term, we are all dead 
 As long as they are disinterested punters rather than caring proprietors, institutional shareholders will tend to take the money and run during takeover bids rather than backing incumbent management. 
 That is unavoidable. 
 The gap between ownership and control will persist, but will be bridged if people find bridge-building profitable or permissible. 
 For the most part, however, the solution will lie more on the managers' side than the shareholders': the managers need to be given incentives that make them less likely to make the colossal errors of the 1960s. 
 It may be some comfort to know that short-termism is not exactly a new concern. 
 Return to Maynard Keynes, writing in the 1930s: 
 The spectacle of modern investment markets has sometimes moved me towards the conclusion that to make the purchase of an investment permanent and indissoluble, like a marriage&hellip; might&hellip; force the investor to direct his mind to the long-term prospects, and to those only. 
 And in the long term, as Keynes might also have said, we will keep on worrying about the short term. 
 ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL INDICATORS 
 OUTPUT, DEMAND AND JOBS 
 British unemployment reached more than 2m in March, recording the biggest monthly increase ever. 
 The rate increased to 7.4%, from 7.0% in February. 
 The jobless rate in Holland remained at 4.9% in February. 
 Britain's retail sales jumped 3.7% in March, the largest monthly increase in nearly 12 years, as shoppers rushed to beat April's deadline for higher value-added tax. 
 In the year to January, Japan's retail sales grew by 4.3%. 
 In the 12 months to February, Britain's industrial production fell 2.5% and French output rose 1.7%. 
 PRICES AND WAGES 
 The 12-month increase in German producer prices slowed to 1.8% in the year to March. 
 Over the same period Japanese wholesale prices rose by 1.0% and Swiss prices edged down 0.1%. 
 British workers received a 9.3% pay rise in the 12 months to February, equivalent to a real pay increase of just 0.3% after allowing for consumer-price inflation. 
 Over the same period Swedish workers received a 4.4% pay rise &mdash; a real cut of 7.3%. 
 BUSINESS CONFIDENCE 
 Dun &amp; Bradstreet's worldwide survey of sales expectations shows signs of improvement in the second quarter of 1991. 
 German businessmen take a much more cheerful view of their economy than currency traders, who have lately driven the D-mark down: the balance of German companies expecting sales to rise over those expecting sales to fall is 69%, the widest margin in the chart. 
 The balance in Japan is also healthily positive, at 54%, only slightly down on the first quarter of the year. 
 The balance in America, though much lower at 36%, has flattened out. 
 Business confidence in Britain is still extremely weak, but improving: pessimists exceed optimists, with a negative balance of 4%, but that compares with a negative balance of 19% in the first quarter. 
 COMMODITY PRICE INDEX 
 A shortage of zinc caused by supply disruptions and, some say, manipulation of the market forced the cash price of zinc to more than &dollar;1,400 a tonne, and to a premium of &dollar;240 over the forward price on the London Metal Exchange last week. 
 This drew a flood of zinc to the LME; stocks rose by 34,300 tonnes to 102,800 tonnes &mdash; almost a seven-year high. 
 Those forced to borrow zinc overnight had to pay a premium of up to &dollar;100 a tonne. 
 In similar circumstances in December 1989, the LME imposed a limit of a premium of &dollar;20 a tonne. 
 This time it took no formal action. 
 Some fear this may have harmed the LME's reputation, and could drive prices, which have fallen by 50% in two years, still lower.  
 EXPORTS 
 In 1990 the value of world trade in merchandise was &dollar;3.5 trillion, according to the GATT. 
 That was a rise of 13% over 1989. 
 In volume terms trade expanded last year by 5%, slower than the 7% in 1989; the GATT expects growth to slow again this year. 
 The champion exporter of 1990 was Germany, with foreign sales of &dollar;421 billion, or 12.1% of the world total. 
 America, number one in 1989, came second in 1990, with exports of &dollar;394 billion (11.4%). 
 America yielded first place despite its exports rising 8.5% in volume terms, compared with a rise of only 1.5% for Germany; and it would still have done so even if unification, which added &dollar;22.5 billion to the exports of the former Federal Republic, had never happened. 
 The reason is last year's 16.5% rise in the D-mark against the dollar. 
 Between them, Hong Kong, Taiwan and South Korea now account for 6.2% of world trade. 
 TRADE, EXCHANGE RATES AND RESERVES 
 America's visible-trade deficit shrank to &dollar;5.3 billion in February, bringing the 12-month total to &dollar;95.6 billion. 
 In March Britain's current-account deficit widened to &dollar;789m, but its 12-month shortfall narrowed to &dollar;17.1 billion. 
 In the 12 months to February Canada's visible-trade surplus increased to &dollar;9.7 billion. 
 Holland's current-account surplus for 1990 grew to &dollar;9.6 billion. 
 WORLD BOURSES 
 Wall Street rose to an all-time high but ended the week 1.9% down as hopes of a cut in American interest rates faded. 
 Hong Kong fell 4.0%, Tokyo 1.2% and London 0.6%. 
 Singapore was the table's best performer, climbing 2.7%. 
 The world index fell 3.1%. 
 MONEY AND INTEREST RATES 
 The growth in Japan's broad money supply slowed to 4.9% in the year to March; its narrow-money growth quickened to 1.7%. 
 In the same period, Britain's broad-money growth fell to 9.9%, while M0 rose 2.7%. 
 Spain's broad money grew by 13.8%. 
 LEADERS 
 Never mind the width 
 A healthy economy needs involved shareholders, not numerous ones 
 SID, Joe Sixpack, Mrs Watanabe &mdash; call them what you will, modest private investors are getting an extraordinary amount of attention from the world's big stockmarkets. 
 In America corporate bosses and Wall Street are in rare agreement about the need to get retail investors back onto the shareholding registers. 
 In Japan the securities industry, whose profits have been built on shares sold to housewives in the Japanese equivalent of Tupperware parties, is desperately worried that last year's stockmarket crash may have brought the party to an end. 
 And in Britain company chairmen agree with the chancellor of the exchequer, Norman Lamont, about the need for &bquo;wider share ownership&equo;, but only wish that he had done more in his budget last week than simply to promise to bring privatisation sales direct to the high street. 
 Everyone, it seems, wants individual investors. 
 Can anyone remember why? 
 If they can, they are keeping quiet about it. 
 There is an iron law of finance: the harder that financial folk campaign for something, the tougher the padlock you should put on your wallet. 
 Most of those pressing for more individuals in the stockmarket have an interest in doing so. 
 That would be fine, if their interest happened to coincide with that of the economy. 
 But, in its usual sense, wider share ownership does not. 
 What the economy needs is narrower ownership. 
 Stockbrokers, politicians and company chairmen hanker after retail investors for the same, simple reason: they think they are chumps. 
 Stockbrokers, especially Japanese ones with fixed commissions, like individual buyers because they are a softer touch for the hard sell. 
 Politicians like them because holding shares may persuade people to vote against parties keen on renationalising former state businesses. 
 As for chairmen, they do not like having to print millions of copies of their annual reports or having to answer tedious questions at their AGMs from Disgusted of Worthing. 
 But they are keen on the average private investor because he does not expect to have lunch once a quarter and is less likely to sell out during a takeover bid. 
 In other words, he is a longer-term investor than the short-sighted institutions. 
 Feel the quality 
 Long-term: that is another of today's business motherhoods, along with wider ownership. 
 But long-term investors do not guarantee a healthy economy. 
 The nature of the investor's interest matters as much as the length of his nose. 
 The trouble with most retail investors is that they are ignorant, and in no position to educate themselves. 
 They are pure punters, unable to monitor whether a board of directors is doing its job &mdash; which is why boards like them. 
 They punt for the long term, but protect incumbent management. 
 What an economy needs is shareholders who have both a long-term interest in the companies they own and the desire and ability to apply some discipline to managers. 
 What an ordinary individual needs is to have a slice of his savings invested in the company he works for, and the rest spread widely so as to spread his risk, through unit trusts (mutual funds), life-insurance policies or pension funds. 
 These institutions represent the wide ownership of shares, held in trust for millions of people. 
 But institutional ownership is not proving ideal for economies, because fund managers are poorly placed to monitor firms. 
 Their inadequacy is often disguised by the tax incentives that many governments give to institutional saving. 
 But the point remains: retail ownership is often a move in a worse direction, not a better one. 
 That is why the slogan should really be &bquo;narrower share ownership&equo;. 
 The aim of public policy &mdash; and of chairmen who do not merely want protection &mdash; should be to lean in the direction of involved shareholders, those who have a direct interest in a company's fate. 
 This can take several different forms. 
 It can mean firms owned and disciplined by specialist boutiques such as Hanson and Kohlberg Kravis Roberts, which in turn attract institutional money. 
 It can mean management buy-outs, with staff becoming proprietors, helped by bank loans. 
 It can mean share-option schemes, so that top executives have their wealth tied (in both directions) to their firm's long-term performance. 
 It can mean employee share-ownership schemes, especially if companies are small enough for workers to feel they can make a difference. 
 Whatever the form of ownership &mdash; and there is plenty of room and need for experiment &mdash; the aim is the same: to bridge the gap between ownership and control that has grown ever since companies ceased to be run by proprietors in the first half of this century. 
 Well-meaning (as opposed to self-interested) campaigners for wider share ownership may have the right problem, but they are advocating the wrong solution. 
 The opposite of popular capitalism is not the unpopular sort. 
 It is prosperous capitalism.  
 America's wasted blacks 
 GENERATION ago America convulsed its society and changed its laws to free black people from discrimination. 
 Legally and socially, no country on earth tries so hard to be free of racism. 
 Yet no country is so obsessed by race. 
 It infects almost every debate. 
 George Bush makes a campaign television commercial about crime, but it features a black criminal, so he is called racist. 
 The FBI prosecutes a cocaine-using mayor and is accused of racism because he is black. 
 The army that fought in the Gulf was disproportionately black, so there were cries that blacks would die for a white quarrel. 
 Car dealers are found to offer better deals to white people than black. 
 AIDS kills more blacks than whites. 
 The high blood pressure of black men was blamed by a medical report on discrimination. 
 A film director turned the Jewish judge in &bquo;The Bonfire of the Vanities&equo; black, to avoid giving offence. 
 Race is still America's top domestic issue. 
 No wonder. 
 The average black boy is more likely to go to prison than university. 
 His life expectancy is falling and he is seven times as likely to be murdered as a white boy. 
 In parts of the country, a black man between the ages of 15 and 25 is more likely to be killed than was an American soldier in Vietnam. 
 The chances are almost two-to-one that he was brought up in a fatherless household. 
 The median family income of blacks is just 56% of that of whites. 
 Despite all its efforts, America still has its racists. 
 In January a national poll found that most whites think blacks are lazy, less intelligent and less patriotic than whites are. 
 David Duke, a former Ku Klux Klan grand wizard, won almost two-thirds of the white vote in the Louisiana Senate race last year. 
 And in one poll 29% of blacks were willing to countenance the idea that AIDS was created by whites to eradicate blacks. 
 Race is genetic, poverty is not 
 But is racism the cause of black deprivation? 
 Historically, yes. 
 Blacks would have been better off now if, after being shipped to America in chains, they had been allowed the same freedom to prosper as willing immigrants were. 
 But what about today? 
 The progress America has made in dismantling discrimination is extraordinary. 
 A generation ago in the South, blacks could not even go to white lavatories or be buried in white cemeteries &mdash; let alone compete for good jobs or live in white suburbs. 
 Since then blacks have got richer at almost the same rate as whites, but they have not caught up at all. 
 In recent years they have fallen back. 
 Is that because discrimination lingers on? 
 Many black-rights groups claim that black deprivation is the result of continuing racism, and that reversing discrimination will rescue blacks from poverty. 
 A growing number of black intellectuals, and white politicians, disagree. 
 Ending what remains of racism is eminently desirable, they say, but it will do little to improve the lot of the poorest blacks. 
 It suits both white guilt and black anger to sustain the myth that racism is still the main problem. 
 The irony of black power is that just as whites once used skin colour as a source of privilege, so blacks now use it as a source of entitlement. 
 At one university, professors have demanded higher pay for black professors &mdash; because they are black. 
 At another, black students (but only blacks) are paid for improving their grades, a Pavlovian training in the mentality of entitlement and a perpetuation of the idea of blacks as victims. 
 Are they? 
 First, confront the one thing everybody avoids discussing. 
 Deep in their minds some whites have begun to think again what their ancestors thought, that blacks are genetically inferior in the traits that count for economic success, and that this is proven by the fact that blacks have lost ground as discrimination has retreated. 
 Therefore, think some whites, the plight of blacks is a problem that cannot be solved. 
 That conclusion is utterly unjustified. 
 The underclass is disproportionately black by historical accident, not genetics: blacks migrated to the northern cities at an unlucky moment, just as manufacturing jobs were disappearing to take new form in the suburbs. 
 They are trapped there by crime, drugs, unemployment and poor education. 
 The cultural variant on this argument holds that black family structure &mdash; more single mothers and itinerant fathers &mdash; is the source of black disadvantage. 
 Certainly, single-parent families are commoner among blacks, are worse for children and are perversely rewarded by the welfare system (see pages 21&ndash;23). 
 But they are more symptom than cause. 
 Rural blacks in the South stick together more. 
 Yet would a white child born into the same conditions as the most disadvantaged inner-city black (to a drug-taking, teenage, single mother, say) be more likely to succeed than a black? 
 Quite possibly &mdash; but not because of present discrimination. 
 That white can see, by looking at other whites, that he is capable of success in lots of different ways. 
 A black can envisage success most easily as a musician or a footballer. 
 Which is why, in recent years, policy has increasingly turned to &bquo;affirmative action&equo; (American for positive discrimination) in the hope that better black role models will result. 
 But affirmative action is a two-edged sword. 
 It suggests to the black who gets the job, and the white colleagues he meets, that he did not get there on merit, but because of the colour of his skin. 
 Racial resentment follows. 
 In 1990 Jesse Helms defeated a black opponent in a Senate race in North Carolina after running television commercials showing imaginary whites being rejected for jobs because affirmative action had given those jobs to blacks. 
 Job preferment stigmatises those who do not need help, starts a backlash from whites and reinforces the myth of racial inferiority, the most pernicious effect of which is that blacks have believed it as much as whites. 
 Above all, affirmative action assuages white guilt. 
 For some individuals, affirmative action may still do more good than harm. 
 But the real problem is that it reaches mainly those who need it least. 
 The chief beneficiaries of affirmative action are university students and black businessmen, who are the blacks most likely to succeed anyway. 
 It does not touch most poor blacks' lives. 
 And yet it dominates the debate. 
 Democrats in Congress are determined to reverse the Supreme Court's recent anti-affirmative-action rulings. 
 They want to reintroduce the bill President Bush vetoed last year; they claim it will merely allow blacks to sue those who discriminate against them. 
 Republicans reply that the bill enforces racial &bquo;quotas&equo; on employers. 
 The whole argument is a diversion. 
 Blacks need to realise that affirmative action cannot solve their most serious problems, whites need to remember that affirmative action does not make it an advantage to be born black. 
 Two bad ideas clutter the debate. 
 The first is black separatism, in vogue in universities (racially separate degree-ceremonies and fraternities are popular with the people most angry at apartheid) and with extreme black activists. 
 But who can doubt that, if the two races were to &bquo;separate&equo;, the blacks would be the poorer? 
 They live in a mainly white country, just as South African whites live in a mainly black one. 
 Integration is the best hope for both. 
 Black separatism is like the free East Germans choosing to rebuild the Berlin Wall. 
 The second bad idea is reparations. 
 A few years ago Japanese-Americans were compensated for being interned during the second world war, and some (mostly white) people have begun to point out that blacks have yet to be compensated for centuries of slavery. 
 In other words, for a steep sum, whites could buy the right to forget their guilt. 
 In reality that would only increase white racism and try to solve with money a problem that cannot be bribed away.  
 A better idea is to forget such racially minded solutions altogether. 
 If America were to attack the reasons for the underclass's existence, the beneficiaries would be disproportionately black. 
 Whites need to recognise that blacks cannot hope to prosper in any numbers while they are confined to ghettos of crime, poverty and lousy schools, and that it is society's duty to do something about it. 
 That means the same law enforcement in inner cities that the rest of the country expects and receives. 
 Firmness on crime is what most inner-city blacks cry out for: their life is made hell by muggers, pimps and drug dealers. 
 (And four Los Angeles policemen beating a black man 56 times after stopping him for speeding does not count as better law enforcement.) 
 It means gun control, which urban blacks want, but many whites illogically hate. 
 It means treatment, not just punishment, for drug takers. 
 It means expensive policies from governments and companies to lure better teachers and school managers into the cities, to build transport links to the suburbs where the jobs are, to train young people for jobs. 
 Whites have retreated to the comfortable suburbs, whence they contribute to a city's costs but avoid paying its taxes or providing work for its underclass. 
 Such policies are not cheap or easy, but nor is the waste of black America's talent. 
 Helping themselves 
 Black leaders in turn need to recognise that such measures will do far more to help poor blacks than any amount of affirmative action, reparation, calls for black separation, or courses designed to teach that Socrates stole his ideas from ancient black Egyptians. 
 Their duty is to tell blacks that although group political activism can stop discrimination, growing rich, wise and safe is then up to the individual &mdash; to hammer home a message of homework, punctuality, saving and self-discipline, the things that helped America's immigrants get off the floor. 
 Some black leaders already say this. 
 Most still prefer the rhetoric of victimisation or separatism. 
 Unless something like this is done, America's blacks will suffer the same collapse of morale that American Indians have. 
 In 1965 Lyndon Johnson told Congress that &bquo;If we stand passively by while the centre of each city becomes a hive of deprivation, crime and hopelessness&hellip; if we become two people, the suburban affluent and the urban poor, each filled with mistrust and fear for the other&hellip; then we shall effectively cripple each generation to come.&equo; 
 A generation has passed, and the crippling goes on.  
 No escape 
 Out of sight, never out of touch 
 TIME is money. 
 Or is money time? 
 It certainly used to be. 
 Before the first world war, and even after it, the rich were notable not just for having money but for having the leisure to enjoy it. 
 The world divided into the idle rich and the labouring poor. 
 Nowadays things are reversed. 
 The rich tend to work 18-hour days, and some of them burn themselves out at bond desks and on trading floors before they are 30. 
 As for the poor, they have no money because they are out of work; they pass their time watching game shows on television. 
 It's the labouring rich and the idle poor. 
 Of course, modern tycoons have yachts and private aircraft and tropical islands, but do they enjoy them? 
 Not much. 
 It is not just the matter of staff: you can still find them if you are rich enough. 
 The trouble is the telephone. 
 You cannot get away from it. 
 You are expected not just to have one by you, but to answer it or, if you cannot (because you are &bquo;in a meeting&equo;), then to have a secretary to take messages and make sure that calls are returned. 
 Not returning calls is a grave crime in today's culture. 
 It is all right to tell a whopper on an answering machine (&bquo;We're sorry that we cannot answer your call right now&equo; is either a lie or a statement of the obvious), but no one will forgive you for not &bquo;getting back&equo; to him later. 
 It is this that turns a get-away-from-it-all holiday into a get-away-from-only-a-bit-of-it one. 
 The technology that supposedly enables you to telecommute from Tahiti to your office in London or Chicago in fact brings the damn office on to your patch of surf-swept sand. 
 Italy's greatest modern industrialist, Enrico Mattei, used to have to take to the air in his private jet in order to get away from the telephone and think. 
 He would be in trouble today. 
 Bells ring, or warble, or bleep, almost everywhere: on aircraft, in cars, in trains, in the street, in restaurants, even in concert halls. 
 Comment is free, fax are sacred 
 It is tough not only on you but also on your deputy. 
 Because you are always available, he never gets a chance to take any decisions while you are away. 
 Norman Lamont was right. 
 When Britain's chancellor of the exchequer introduced his new tax on mobile telephones last week, he called them &bquo;one of the greatest scourges of modern life&equo;. 
 But when he is away from his desk does he leave all the decisions about running the British economy to one of his colleagues? 
 Not likely. 
 It is not such fun being number two any more. 
 The devolution of power, whether to the deputy chairman or the deputy prime minister (remember Sir Geoffrey Howe?), becomes rarer by the day. 
 Technology concentrates power at the top. 
 And because you have to be bursting with energy and health to do the top jobs, they have to be given to younger men. 
 Number twos tend therefore to be passed over (except for the top job in America, for which agreeably relaxed standards of industry have been set by a recent incumbent). 
 So time is not money. 
 Nor is money time. 
 Time is relative &mdash; and Einstein has a lot to answer for.  
 The common name of Irishman 
 The south could do much to reassure the north 
 PATIENCE has been rewarded: talks on the political future of Northern Ireland should begin shortly after Easter. 
 Assuming no last-minute collapse, that will be a triumph for Peter Brooke, the Northern Ireland secretary. 
 Two years ago few people thought he could cajole the island's two separate tribes &mdash; sprung from Protestant planters on the one side and Catholic Gaels on the other &mdash; into meeting at all. 
 But what happens now will depend not on a strategy cooked up in Westminster, but on what Irish politicians from north and south of the border choose to make of each other. 
 Beyond that, the future of the island will be determined by one test above all: the willingness of the republic to take stock of its past failings &mdash; and to build on recent signs that a self-confident and modern state is in the making. 
 The republic's long estrangement from the six counties of the north was never meant to be. 
 The British architects of the original partition did not see it, 70 years ago, as a supporting wall for the new Irish state they were hurriedly trying to build. 
 Separating the province from the rest of the island was just a way of sidestepping the Protestant minority's implacable hostility to a British withdrawal. 
 Time, many believed, would see an inherently absurd partition quickly dismantled. 
 Their reasoning was sound. 
 Britain's strategic interest in the province has evaporated, as people hoped it would. 
 And the anomalies of a divided Ireland remain as absurd as ever: both bits can be almost equally foreign to the casual English visitor, are often equally hostile to Westminster, and have long been equally illiberal on moral issues like abortion and homosexuality. 
 But sound reasoning led those original optimists astray for two reasons. 
 They underestimated the ruthlessness with which the Unionists, unhappy at the poverty and popery to the south, would (with Westminster's shameful connivance) exploit their rigged majority in the north to assert the province's Protestant identity. 
 And they overestimated the attraction to all Irishmen, Protestant and Catholic, of belonging to the newly independent state. 
 Fewer shades of green 
 Now the old Stormont-based hegemony in the north has been swept away, destroyed by its own excesses in the half-century to 1972 &mdash; though the poisonous legacy of those years lingers on in terrorism. 
 So what has become of that other bulwark of partition, the unattractiveness of the republic to its Protestant neighbours? 
 A narrow sectarian outlook has blighted Irish society for decades. 
 The influence of the Catholic church is less suffocating today than it was two generations ago, but it is still striking to outsiders. 
 Contraceptives cannot be sold freely &mdash; Ireland's Family Planning Association has just been fined in the courts for putting condoms on sale in a Dublin record store &mdash; and divorce is illegal. 
 The fate of attempted reforms has only added to the north's alienation, as Catholic bishops have time and again pulled Dublin's politicians by the ear &mdash; &bquo;a question&equo;, as the senior archbishop put it earlier this month, &bquo;of legislators respecting the moral convictions to which people adhere, and which are influenced by their membership of the church.&equo; 
 Nor has conventional Irish politics given northern Unionists much cheer. 
 The two main parties, defined by Ireland's civil-war allegiances in the 1920s, coexist in a murky world of unprincipled favour-mongering. 
 The dominant Fianna Fail long ago gave up any pretence of offering Ireland a coherent vision for the future &mdash; a failure epitomised, for many, by the wanton destruction over the past 20 years of Georgian Dublin, once one of Europe's finest cities. 
 Above all, from a Unionist point of view, the republic's government has behaved with crass insensitivity in clinging to a constitution that still calls explicitly for a unitary state. 
 But Ireland is changing. 
 Membership of the European Community since 1973 has helped attract foreign companies in droves, while better management of a virtually strike-free economy has transformed its performance in the past few years. 
 Despite huge debts and a still disproportionate reliance on farming, an enviable record of strong growth and low inflation matches an appetite for change that ought not to be surprising in a society where half the population is under 28 (and more than half the nuns and priests are over 60). 
 It is evident in the vitality of the arts &mdash; hardly a city in the country now lacks for an international festival &mdash; and it contributed last year to the remarkable election of Mary Robinson, only in her mid-40s and impatient with old ways, to the (largely honorary) post of president. 
 What is needed now is a new spirit of political leadership in Ireland, able to respond to the changing social mood as effectively as Charles Haughey's government has responded since 1987 to the changing economy. 
 This would not bring an instant end to the island's problems. 
 Unionists may not be ready to judge the republic on its merits for years yet, and the hatred bred by three centuries of religious animosity is not going to be bartered away by any group of politicians. 
 But the emergence of a strong, secular republic in the south could do much to encourage a better neighbourliness in the north. 
 Without that, no talks will ever amount to more than the briefest of encounters.  
 Persians bearing gifts 
 Rafsanjani offers a pragmatic foreign policy &mdash; but so, it was thought, did Saddam Hussein 
 FROM cop to robber to cop again: Iran is once more urging its protective services, through some kind of joint security system, on the smaller neighbours whom, for most of the 1980s, it was threatening to gobble up. 
 For a good reason, but also for a bad one, this latest change in Iran's persona is being looked at seriously. 
 The Islamic Republic has changed in one fundamental respect since the death of Ayatollah Khomeini two years ago. 
 It seems to have persuaded the Gulf kingdoms and sheikhdoms that it is no longer a militant exporter of Islamic revolution. 
 If Iran, weary and broke after its war with Iraq, has waved goodbye to its proselytising days, this is a valid reason for easing it out of its isolation and back to the position in Gulf politics which, from the shah on, it has craved and which reflects the size of its population and length of its coastline. 
 Ancient hostility between Iranians and Arabs is mirrored in the squabble about whether the Gulf should be called &bquo;Persian&equo; or &bquo;Arabian&equo; or, the boring compromise, neither. 
 Iran's ayatollahs, having established their own Islamic state in 1979, sought to spread the Islamic word, urging militant factions in Arab countries to rise up and overthrow their traditional, often repressive, rulers. 
 But all Iran could foment was unrest, not revolt &mdash; and it was further discouraged, after Iraq's invasion of Kuwait, by the loyalty that most Islamic fundamentalist parties showed to Saddam Hussein. 
 After managing, more successfully than most, to be neutral in a Gulf drama that saw two of its deepest fears come true &mdash; Iraq's territorial expansion and America's intervention with guns &mdash; Iran was presented with a new chance for trouble-making by Mr Hussein's defeat. 
 It took it: there is no doubt that it is helping the Shia rebels in southern Iraq and, to a lesser extent, the more successful Kurds in the north. 
 But it has supplied this help without objection from Arab governments which, though alarmed at the prospect of Shia ascendancy in Iraq, want most of all to see Mr Hussein out. 
 So on March 26th Saudi Arabia signalled Iran's return to international respectability by resuming the diplomatic relations that had been broken in 1987 after an appalling incident at Mecca when 400 pilgrims, most of them Iranian, were killed. 
 The smaller Gulf states had already decided that, under threat from their ex-champion Iraq, they should sensibly make up with their ex-enemy Iran. 
 Egypt, also on March 26th, opened an interests section in Tehran. 
 Soon after Saddam's invasion, Europeans were quick to decide that, with the graver threat from Iraq, relations should be patched up with Iran. 
 Britain resumed diplomatic links; the EC dropped sanctions; western  businessmen  queued to offer their services. 
 Only America, more inclined than Europe to judge things in black or white rather than tones of grey, and still embarrassed by its bizarre secret opening to Iran during Mr Reagan's presidency, remains cool. 
 Iran has made it plain that it would take it amiss if it were left out of any post-war security arrangements for the Gulf &mdash; but even more amiss if outsiders (read Americans) were to stay on. 
 Since it is now pretty clear that the Americans do intend to stay on, probably setting up a base in Bahrain, the chances of Iran joining a co-operative policing system in the near future are remote. 
 Yet, if it can be fixed, it would probably be safer to have Iran inside such an arrangement than outside it. 
 Look inwards 
 The bad reason for accepting Iran as a reformed character lies in the automatic business of letting Iran's star rise when Iraq's falls, and vice versa. 
 Iraq and Iran have long been regarded as strategic counterweights. 
 But it would be folly to repeat the mistake, made with Iraq, of allowing foreign-policy merit to blot out oppression at home. 
 Mr Hussein was embraced by the West in the 1980s because he was trying to contain the mad mullahs across the border; all else was ignored. 
 President Ali Akbar Rafsanjani's moderation in foreign policy seems to have carried the day in Iran; hardliners are vociferous in parliament and elsewhere (the Islamic Republic allows more debate than the shah ever countenanced), but they are out of power. 
 Yet Iran is still a darkly repressive regime. 
 Amnesty International, in a report last December, said that nothing at home had changed &bquo;to alleviate gross violations of human rights&equo;. 
 Political opponents continue to be arbitrarily arrested; the death sentence against Salman Rushdie has not been lifted; at least 13 western hostages (six Americans, five Britons and two Germans) are still held by pro-Iranian kidnappers in Lebanon. 
 Mr Rafsanjani's pragmatism deserves pragmatic acceptance. 
 But the lesson from the Iraqi experience is that a regime that behaves badly to its own people is likely to behave badly to its neighbours too. 
 LETTERS 
 Go east, young men 
 Has the time not come to investigate the factors which led to the move west from the 13 colonies in North America, to consider how these might be created to apply to a move east from the Urals to provide a similar development in potentially the greatest storehouse of raw materials and energy? 
 I have witnessed this expansion in parts of North America for nearly 60 years, first working as a student with a pitchfork on the harvest in Alberta. 
 A few years later, visiting Moscow after passing through the Ukraine during the great famine, I was asked, &bquo;How did North America expand west, but we have failed to expand east?&equo; 
 Were the necessary factors to be applied, would there not be a great upsurge of outside experience and help, from Nordic cold-weather techniques, Israeli water-usage, Japanese capital and many trained young people eager to meet modern challenges?  
 London DOUGLAS DODDS-PARKER 
 Mixed emotions 
 As an Iranian-American Jew with Iraqi grandparents, I experienced the unfolding of the Gulf war with mixed emotions. 
 For my adopted country America, I felt much pride and admiration. 
 I can only hope the experience encourages America to apply better judgment in its selection of &bquo;allies&equo;. 
 For my native country, Iran, I felt a surge of admiration. 
 After having suffered from domestic fundamentalism and a devastating war, the Iranians showed impressive judgment by staying on the sidelines. 
 For them I hope the experience reinforces their movement away from fanaticism and fundamentalism. 
 For my emotional home Israel, pride and admiration are also in order. 
 May they come out of it more secure, but level-headed and magnanimous towards the Palestinians. 
 I am sad for the suffering of the Iraqi people. 
 I am sadder yet that with all their sacrifices, the Iraqis have yet to rid themselves of their biggest problem, the scourge of Saddam.  
 New York RODNEY EZRAPOUR 
 The tragedy of Cyprus 
 In his &bquo;analysis&equo; of the situation in Cyprus, Jerry Gustafson (Letters, February 23rd) claims that Turkey's only crime is to protect the rights of the Turkish Cypriots. 
 Obviously, then, the fact that 200,000 Greek Cypriots (a third of the population) were kicked out of their homes by the Turkish invaders, thus becoming refugees in their own country, is not a crime, according to Mr Gustafson; nor is the fact that 80,000 settlers were imported from Turkey in an attempt to alter the demographic composition of the island; nor is the fact that 1,619 people are still reported as missing in action almost 17 years after the invasion; nor is the fact that the Turks are destroying every trace of the 3,000-year-old Greek culture that exists in the occupied territories, a fact that even the Turkish Cypriot press often reports. 
 But the most outrageous claim he makes is that Turkey &bquo;is anxious to withdraw according to UN resolutions and proposals which the majority will not accept.&equo; 
 Obviously, Mr Gustafson has not been doing his homework, otherwise he would know that there are 48 UN resolutions calling for the withdrawal of all foreign troops from Cyprus, and the restoration of its territorial integrity and sovereignty. 
 Claiming that the (Greek Cypriot) majority does not accept these resolutions is plain absurd, given that it is that majority that initiated almost all of them.  
 Madison, Wisconsin SOFRONIS CLERIDES 
 A hundred yellow ribbons 
 It is unassailable that the 1973 song, &bquo;Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Old Oak Tree&equo;, brought the symbol of the yellow ribbon to national attention in the United States (March 2nd). 
 However, it must have some earlier source. 
 During my basic training in the army in 1968, one of the traditional marching songs we used went like this: 
 On her hair 
 She wore a yellow ribbon 
 She wore it in the Springtime 
 And in the month of May. 
 And if you asked her 
 Why the Hell she wore it 
 She wore it for her lover who was far, far away 
 Far away, far away, 
 Oh, she wore it for her lover who was far, far away. 
 Because this song was simply handed down from one generation of drill sergeants to another, the symbolism may have origins much earlier than a superficial analysis may indicate. 
 Was there evidence of yellow-ribbon use during the Crusades? 
 At the home bases of Viking raiding parties?  
 San Diego JEFFREY GETTLEMAN 
 As a schoolboy in the 1940s I learnt a folk song with the verse: 
 Around her hair she wore a yellow ribbon, 
 She wore it in the winter and the merry month of May; 
 And when they asked her why the yellow ribbon, 
 She said &bquo;It's for a soldier who is far, far away.&equo; 
 Such a song probably originated in 18th-century England, perhaps even during the American War of Independence, whence the victors captured it along with &bquo;Yankee Doodle&equo;.  
 Lewes, East Sussex ALAN WOLFE 
 I understand that ribbon-wearing to symbolise support for troops was a practice employed in England several centuries ago. 
 In the United States it dates back at least to the Civil War; the 1949 John Ford-John Wayne movie, &bquo;She Wore a Yellow Ribbon&equo;, underscores the practice's lineage. 
 Yellow is the official colour of the United States Cavalry, used in the piping of uniforms and on regimental standards. 
 The alleged inspiration of the song from Pete Hamill's story was the subject of a lawsuit in the 1970s and some have suggested that Mr Hamill's story is fiction, not fact.  
 New York THOMAS BERNER 
 In response to your assertion that the yellow handkerchief was transmuted into a ribbon because &bquo;you can't find anything to rhyme with handkerchief&equo;, I must point out that, in the song, the word ribbon never rhymed with anything. 
 &bquo;Ribbon&equo; was used for its trochaic rhythm rather than any rhyming qualities. 
 It just wouldn't be the same singing &bquo;Tie a yellow hankie 'round the old oak tree.&equo;  
 Woburn, Maryland DAVID PLATT 
 Dismal science fiction 
 Although economics may not be a staple of mass-market science fiction, it is hardly ignored, as you say in your final schools brief on economics (March 9th). 
 The works of the most influential modern writer in the genre, Robert Heinlein, are suffused with economics. 
 He is widely credited with coining the phrase &bquo;There ain't no such thing as a free lunch&equo; in his novel &bquo;The Moon is a Harsh Mistress&equo;, about a revolution which replaces a command economy with a market economy. 
 It is ironic that your educational piece did not recognise Mr Heinlein, as he clearly recognised your educational role. 
 In his last novel, a mother offers this advice to her son: &bquo;Money. 
 Donald, any question that starts out &bquo;Why don't they &mdash;&equo; the answer is always &bquo;Money&equo;&hellip; 
 &lsqb;I&rsqb; f you intend to cope with the jungle out there, you need to make the Wall Street Journal and similar publications such as The Economist your favourite comic books.&equo;  
 Woolwich OLIVER MORTON 
 Hard on small airlines 
 Be careful not to make one mistake when you advocate the American model of airline deregulation (February 23rd). 
 Don't permit frequent-flier programmes. 
 The frequent-flier coupons in practice become the property of the flier, not his employer (who paid for the ticket). 
 They thus add to the business flier's personal income, income on which no personal income tax is paid. 
 Business fliers fly with the airline that will most quickly give them the necessary coupons to go to, say, Hawaii with the family. 
 The result has been to reward the biggest airlines, which incidentally go to the most attractive places for leisure travel, and to destroy the small carriers which go to a limited number of places.  
 Oxford, Ohio ROBERT THORNTON 
 Opening up to gas 
 So the arguments of the gas companies on open access are disingenuous (&bquo;Flare play&equo;, March 2nd). 
 Rather, this is true of your reporting. 
 Open access may work in Britain, but in continental Europe, where there are a limited number of gas-merchant companies, it would be a different story. 
 These firms aggregate demand and buy from a handful of gas producers, which supply nearly half of Europe's gas from beyond mainland Europe, and will supply much more soon. 
 In this way, favourable long-term contracts are negotiated between supplier and merchant, contracts which benefit consumers both directly and via Europe's trade balance. 
 Open access would lead to the demise of such long-term contracts. 
 How could gas companies give any guarantees to gas suppliers, especially on gas volume, if their customers could by-pass them at any time? 
 Without long-term contracts the chain of confidence of gas production and supply would be broken. 
 The savings calculated in the EC study which result from open access in Europe are based on improbable assumptions. 
 An alternative consultants' study calculates losses more realistically at between 600m and 1.8 billion ecus (&dollar;740m-2.2 billion).  
 Brussels PETER CLAUS Eurogas 
 Feet of clay 
 &bquo;California uses 35m acre-feet of water a year. 
 An acre-foot is an acre covered a foot deep in water, or 326,000 American gallons (271,000 imperial gallons).&equo; 
 If you are going to give quantities in three different units, could at least one of them be metric, please?  
 San Francisco PETE FERREIRA 
 The other Cuba 
 Your knowledge of Cuban history is small (&bquo;Puppet and string-puller&equo;, February 23rd). 
 You think that Cuba before Castro was decayed and corrupt; that the United States dominated Cuban history, and that the only ruler was Batista. 
 Batista was evil for Cuba, but in 1944 he permitted free elections and, after the opposition won, the governments were as democratic as in any western country. 
 Cuba continued its economic progress, was among the top three countries in Latin America, and corruption was no worse than in many developing countries. 
 During the second Batista dictatorship there was corruption, there was poverty, but no revolution was needed to suppress these. 
 The Cubans only wanted free elections. 
 It is deplorable that the Americans took a lot of land cheap from Cubans and Spaniards. 
 But Cuban investment in Cuba grew from &dollar;50m in 1899 to &dollar;1.5 billion in 1929; 62% of sugar production was in Cuban hands in 1958, whereas in 1935 they had only 13%. 
 Above all, the democratic rulers in Cuba stood always in the face of the Americans as any small country should stand in the face of its biggest market and closest neighbour. 
 As for the &bquo;moral swamp&equo;, Havana had the same levels of prostitution as London or any big city. 
 The average Cuban in the United States has better moral values and more love for the family than the average American.  
 Chicago JOSE TRUJILLO 
 In &bquo;Publishing in Cuba&equo; (February 9th) you say that &bquo;local scientists are trying to fathom out how to turn sugar cane into paper&equo;. 
 Once sugar has been extracted from the cane, the by-product, bagasse, can indeed be made into paper (or burnt to make steam and power). 
 During my visits to Cuba I have seen how important for the country's economy and how well managed the bagasse-based paper industry is. 
 Printing, writing, and tissue papers, corrugated cardboard and wrapping paper are of excellent quality. 
 The only thing that cannot be managed is the economic manufacture of newsprint.  
 Draguignan, France SEPPO RAISANEN 
 Paying for unity 
 Your article, &bquo;Is Germany really united?&equo; 
 (February 23rd), failed to mention one of the most dramatic causes for the lack of western German enthusiasm in the unity question; the federal election campaign last autumn. 
 The parties of Helmut Kohl's coalition, citing wildly optimistic economic forecasts, promised Ossis (easterners) the moon, yet insisted that the powerful German economy and the unsinkable D-mark would somehow pay for everything. 
 Warnings from the opposition that the government's &bquo;No Tax Increases&equo; slogan was no more than a vote-gathering lie were rebuffed as fear-mongering and, better still, as unpatriotic. 
 The result? 
 The clearly necessary tax increases required to pay for unification are now being forced down very unprepared throats. 
 Mr Kohl's glossy coating of the bitter pill of economic union undoubtedly won him votes, but the coating has already proved to be thin. 
 Should the pill prove too bitter, it will add considerable strain to already tense east-west relations.  
 Hamburg NICHOLAS MINDE 
 Punitive damages 
 Your article on the American Supreme Court's recent ruling on punitive damages (March 9th) misleads in one respect. 
 Insurance companies do end up paying most of the punitive damages in the United States, but not because they have sold punitive-damages insurance to businesses. 
 State law forbids the insurance of punitive damages in much of the country, including California, New York, Illinois and Pennsylvania. 
 Insurance companies pay most punitive damages because they themselves are the defendants that juries are most likely to punish substantially. 
 In the most common case, the jury punishes an insurer for egregiously mishandling a health or property claim submitted by its own customer. 
 The recent Supreme Court decision involves just such a case.  
 Ann Arbor, Michigan KENT SYVERUD 
 Not a ghost of a chance 
 &bquo;Caruso would give concerts in New York's Yankee Stadium&hellip; 
 &equo; (March 9th). 
 A neat trick. 
 Caruso died in 1921. 
 Yankee Stadium was built in 1922.  
 Canberra S.P.K. BROWN 
 BOOKS AND ARTS 
 Early capitalism 
 The sculptor and the banker 
 MOUNTAINS OF DEBT. 
 By Michael Veseth. 
 OUP; 246 pages; &pound;24 and &dollar;29.95 
 FLORENCE, the city state of Michelangelo and Leonardo, also nurtured a phenomenon that was equally lasting: the system of production and trade that in a more developed form became known as capitalism. 
 In the Florence of the 1420s, says Michael Veseth, an American professor of economics, he would have been &bquo;pretty much at home&equo; with the institutions dealing with business and government finance. 
 Florence created the first income tax, complete with personal exemptions and dodges. 
 It also thought up the idea of converting public debt into more or less permanent debt at fixed interest, the system known as funding. 
 The natural resources of Florence were no more than the four elements available to all simple communities since antiquity: earth, air, water and fire. 
 Mr Veseth notes that it was the &bquo;fifth element&equo;, the creative spark, that made Florence rich, commercially and artistically. 
 The essence of the fifth element, he says, was probably the same for Bardi the banker as for the sculptor of David. 
 When the spark died, the economy declined, and so did the quality of art. 
 In his refreshing book Mr Veseth looks at Victorian Britain, which improved on Florence's commercial ideas, particularly public debt, and also went into decline; and at present-day America, which is deeply in debt but might, he argues, avoid decline if it takes brave decisions. 
 He does not pursue into modern times his lively thought about the connection between commerce and art; wisely, perhaps. 
 The Pre-Raphaelites may do for the Victorians. 
 But the fifth element that motivated Wall Street appears to have come up only with Norman Rockwell and Jackson Pollock.  
 British history 
 Dithering to Damascus 
 &bquo;THE HOLY FOX&equo;: A BIOGRAPHY OF LORD HALIFAX. 
 By Andrew Roberts. 
 Weidenfeld and Nicolson; 308 pages; &pound;25 
 APPEASEMENT is one of those supercharged words, like terrorism and fascism, whose use in any argument is the verbal equivalent of going nuclear. 
 It is particularly potent for Britons. 
 As the shameful precursor to the glory of 1940 and the Dunkirk spirit, it is an essential part of the national myth. 
 Without it, would Margaret Thatcher have been so determined, last August, that Saddam Hussein had to be humbled? 
 After Chamberlain himself, Lord Halifax has always been painted (not least by that famous amateur painter, Churchill) as the high priest of appeasement. 
 The intensely religious former viceroy of India and wartime ambassador to Washington has had a bad write-up. 
 His involvement in peace-feelers after the German invasion of France has been portrayed as verging on treason. 
 Yet Halifax was within a whisker of becoming Britain's wartime leader and, as this new study makes clear, was central in turning the Chamberlain government away from appeasement and towards war preparations. 
 Certainly, he was blind to the true nature of Hitler and Nazism until the autumn of 1938. 
 He announced at the beginning of that year that &bquo;if Hitler had worn a dhoti he could have mistaken his mystical approach to life for that of Mr Gandhi&equo;. 
 He made clear to Hitler that Britain would not fight to uphold the Versailles treaty and, for far too long, held to the hope that the Third Reich's territorial ambitions would cease after it had vacuumed up all ethnic Germans. 
 He was ready to hand over African colonies to appease Hitler. 
 He tried (with some success) to censor anti-Nazi sentiments in the British media. 
 These acts were shameful. 
 Yet his new biographer, Andrew Roberts, demonstrates (with the aid of much newly-available archive material) that once he realised his hopes of avoiding war by being nice to Hitler were doomed and dangerous, Halifax was just as relentless in his anti-appeasement stance. 
 The almost Damascene conversion came literally overnight on September 24th&ndash;25th 1938, according to this account, after the German rejection of the Anglo-French plan for dismembering Czechoslovakia. 
 From then on, Halifax stood for rearmament, new military strategies and political unity ahead of the coming war. 
 Appeasement caused by blindness was followed by delaying tactics and doublespeak intended to buy time. 
 Britain had been unable to protect Czechoslovakia or Poland in 1938&ndash;39, and every month before a possible invasion meant more aircraft, guns and ships. 
 Halifax strung along various minor European royals, sub-statesmen and Italian go-betweens who offered an &bquo;honourable peace&equo;. 
 If this was treason then Churchill, who approved of the tactic, was a traitor too. 
 Halifax, however, was always more equivocal; he was trying as late as the battle for France to keep the option of peace talks open, if they could preserve the independence of the British Empire. 
 Mr Roberts's narrative account of the crucial months grips and convinces. 
 He acquits, with only moderate difficulty, Halifax of many sins commonly attributed to him. 
 His account of Halifax's great service to his country &mdash; when he stood aside from the offer of the wartime premiership, leaving it for Churchill (then regarded as an unstable gangster by Chamberlainite Tories) is considerably more convincing than Churchill's own highly-coloured account. 
 But beyond that, Halifax emerges from these friendly pages as just the cold, compromising nobleman of legend. 
 The more Mr Roberts strains to show his charming side, the less convincing he seems. 
 Halifax was a snob; was not a true democrat; did ludicrously misunderstand Hitler; and dithered when decisiveness was needed most. 
 The appeasement myth was right in this respect: Halifax would have been a disaster for Britain. 
 For realising it himself, he deserves some thanks.  
 Black film directors 
 That Hollywood shuffle 
 NEW YORK 
 POLICE are at war with a gang of drug dealers; the dealers transform a huge Harlem apartment building into a crack factory that throws the city into a state of Boschian depravity. 
 This is &bquo;New Jack City&equo;, a film that contains good-looking street-smart cops and villains, violence, sex and even a final triumph of good over evil. 
 In its first weekend it took in &dollar;7m. 
 Seats were so scarce that people killed each other to get them. 
 Mortified, producers and director put out a statement insisting that their film, despite its brutality, showed &bquo;positive role models&equo;. 
 The words are revealing; for this is a black film, not only with a mostly black cast but also with a black director, Mario Van Peebles. 
 Mr Peebles is best known as a film and television actor. 
 Inexperienced as well as black, he would have stood no chance of a studio contract as recently as five years ago. 
 Times have changed. 
 The 1991 season promises at least seven big-studio releases by black directors, more than in the past ten years. 
 Robert Townsend (&bquo;Hollywood Shuffle&equo;) and Spike Lee (&bquo;Do the Right Thing&equo;) both have new films coming. 
 Mr Lee, to add to his swagger, has also been hired to lecture on film at Harvard. 
 Already highly successful in popular music, dance and commercial television, blacks have found the movies a tougher nut to crack. 
 The cost of film-making is only part of it. 
 From the industry's earliest days, blacks in American films were routinely typecast as servants, childlike entertainers or sexual aggressors; in D.W. Griffith's silent classic, &bquo;Birth of a Nation&equo;, the Ku Klux Klan was presented as the saviour of the postbellum South. 
 Yet as early as this blacks were also making their own films: &bquo;race films&equo;, shown in all-black theatres during the years of segregation. 
 Today's new generation of black directors has been spurred on by two particular success stories. 
 One is the popularity of performers such as Richard Pryor and Eddie Murphy, whose films have unprecedented appeal for whites as well as blacks. 
 The other is the story of Melvin Van Peebles, father of Mario. 
 Van Peebles p&egrave;re soured on Hollywood after directing the now-classic comedy &bquo;Watermelon Man&equo; (1969), about a suburban businessman who wakes up one morning to find himself black. 
 He followed that with &bquo;Sweet Sweetback's Baadasses Song,&equo; the crudely made, picaresque saga of a sexually defiant rebel, starring himself, which he distributed to theatres in black neighbourhoods. 
 It made a fortune and spawned an almost decade-long string of Hollywood imitations, the &bquo;blacksploitation&equo; films, built around the exploits of virile leading men. 
 Following the example of Mr Lee's low-budget hit, &bquo;She's Gotta Have It&equo;, young black directors began making small independent films, some of which earned national distribution deals only after their directors sweated to get the films made. 
 The stories are familiar enough. 
 Mr Townsend financed &bquo;Hollywood Shuffle,&equo; about a black actor in Hollywood, on credit-card cash advances. 
 Charles Lane's first feature, &bquo;Sidewalk Stories&equo;, was a silent black-and-white film shot on the cold streets of New York during two weeks in February, when Mr Lane's actor friends had no other work. 
 Those ordeals, however, taught some young blacks how to make cheap films that looked expensive. 
 Most black directors' budgets are pegged at around &dollar;7m, compared with the &dollar;25m-40m spent on the average Hollywood film. 
 (Mr Lee's new film &bquo;Jungle Fever&equo;, an exception, is said to have cost around &dollar;19m.) 
 Black films remain small beer; they are doing little to shape the movie business. 
 A black-owned film studio is still a distant dream, and the Hollywood studios have yet to experience their first black-directed box-office failure, which will test their willingness to entrust big budgets to black directors. 
 The most likely development is that studios will imitate the music business and create separate divisions devoted to films for black audiences, where black producers who know their market best will determine what films are made. 
 The result may transform black American films into a two-tier system, with commercially successful directors on top and independent film-makers at the bottom, scrambling for scarce money. 
 So what's new?  
 Islanders all 
 A BOOK of great beauty, Jonathan Kingdon's ISLAND AFRICA* is ostensibly about why certain animals and plants live in certain parts of that continent. 
 But scientists are impressed by the way Mr Kingdon has identified the sequence of evolutionary accidents that led to Africa's strange mosaic of rich ecosystems; and conservationists find in it a way to explain rarity and extinction. 
 Most people will simply revel in the pictures. 
 Mr Kingdon can draw anything, from a diagram of a skinned agwantibo to a magical collage of Namaqua flowers. 
 This is a book that marries the old tradition of the explorer-naturalist with that of a modern scientist. 
 Mr Kingdon, who has lived in Africa all his life when not teaching zoology and art at Oxford, can exemplify any point he makes with an anecdote and a case history: from beetles in Namibia to monkeys in Zaire, chameleons in Cameroon or giant groundsels on Mount Kenya. 
 His breadth of knowledge is amazing enough. 
 But his ability to capture, in four little sketches in the margin, the way a flying squirrel prepares to leap from a tree, is astounding. 
 The theme of his book is that Africa, to an ecologist, is like an archipelago of overlapping islands. 
 There are the great islands of savannah and veld in East and South Africa, the little islands of mountain forests from Cameroon to Kilimanjaro, island-like lakes from Malawi to Turkana, islands of rain forest from Liberia to Uganda, real islands off the coast from Sao Tome to the Seychelles and man-made islands of conservation, from the Kruger to the Serengeti. 
 Islands are where species form, as populations that are isolated from each other by the intervening space begin to diverge. 
 And thence begins the ecological richness of Africa.  
 The seers 
 LONELY HEARTS OF THE COSMOS. 
 By Dennis Overbye. 
 Harper Collins; 432 pages; &dollar;25. 
 Macmillan; &pound;17.50 
 ASTRONOMERS, by the nature of their art, seem otherworldly. 
 While mundane scientists poke and prod at nature with the tools of experiment, astronomers on their mountains simply observe her, in all her heavenly glory. 
 Of all these seers, those with access to the greatest mysteries are the cosmologists. 
 Not content with stars and galaxies, they try to understand the whole universe, its provenance and fate. 
 Like Moses, they climb their mountains alone, communing with creation if not the creator. 
 They bring back down the laws of nature, if not of God himself. 
 If all this sounds rather mythic, it is because it is a myth. 
 Astronomy may be a calling; it is also a day-to-day job (albeit done at night). 
 Astronomers may travel into the depths of space and time, but on their return they must still convince their colleagues of the truth of what they saw. 
 They have to compete for telescope time, to make sure that no one beats them to crucial measurements. 
 They have to fight for their theories, and face failure when they fall &mdash; for no science is written on tablets of stone. 
 It is this tension between the grandiose themes of cosmology and its mundane workings that sits at the heart of Dennis Overbye's superb book. 
 Mr Overbye chooses to begin and end his 50-year review of these fascinating realms with Allan Sandage, the anointed successor to Edwin Hubble, the man who, in the late 1920s, first convinced his peers that the universe was expanding. 
 Hubble found that the starlight of distant galaxies was &bquo;Doppler shifted&equo; along the spectrum so that they appear red, which means they are receding. 
 The redder the light, the farther and faster the galaxy. 
 Dr Sandage has spent much of his life as the custodian of Hubble's legacy, trying to show how that relative redness can be turned into an absolute distance. 
 It is a monumental task, performed through thousands upon thousands of  finicky  observations and measurements. 
 It has embroiled Dr Sandage in such controversy that at times he has almost completely withdrawn from the world. 
 Since Dr Sandage embarked on his quest, the world of cosmology has changed radically. 
 When astronomical cosmologists started to make interesting noises about the extreme heat and density of the Big Bang, the moment of creation that set Hubble's expansion off, other physicists began to take notice. 
 The big bang was an interesting place &mdash; a lot of people wanted to play there. 
 Physicists started working on theories to explain the early universe: what particles populated it, what properties it bequeathed to the present. 
 These were bright young theorists, not seasoned observers. 
 Previous generations had dined in black ties in the panelled dining rooms of observatories that were male preserves; the new breed ate &bquo;primeval pizza&equo; in basements around physics labs. 
 Under the influence of these ideas, and the technological advances that have come with them, cosmology has changed. 
 New instruments, especially the electronic detectors that collect light so much more efficiently and less fussily than the old emulsion plates, have removed some of the art from observing. 
 Today's organised and systematic searches of the skies record far more red-shifts in a year or so than Dr Sandage has measured in his life &mdash; and have, in doing so, found strange currents, superimposed on the overall expansion, in which galaxies flow like twigs on a stream. 
 Mr Overbye describes the changes in theory and observation accurately, engagingly and enthusiastically, though his prose is occasionally Doppler-shifted towards the purple as he dashes from subject to subject. 
 But he also allows time for reflection, which brings the book a sense of perspective that most popularisations lack. 
 The reader is always aware that although he knows and mostly likes the people he is writing about, he is not necessarily taken in by their ideas. 
 Mr Overbye does not accept that theories currently in vogue are necessarily true. 
 And even if they are, he does not feel bound to like them. 
 Talking of &bquo;inflation&equo; &mdash; a neat theoretical idea of exponential growth in the early history of the universe that disposed of a lot of problems in the marriage between theoretical physics and cosmology &mdash; he refuses to subscribe to the overwhelming enthusiasm with which many scientists discuss the subject: 
 When I contemplated this great vista, I despaired. 
 Inflation seemed like a pyrrhic victory, almost a tease. 
 It made the universe more savage and unknowable than I had ever dreamed&hellip; 
 What could we know about the greater universe? 
 The same process that guaranteed that our own cosy little universe was smooth and safe also guaranteed that everything interesting and fundamental was swept hopelessly, permanently out of reach. 
 Some may think that a mere journalist has no right to hold views about such things. 
 But it is by mixing the personal and the cosmic in his reporting, just as the scientists mix them in their lives, that Mr Overbye has managed to write such a good book.  
 The Lydian hoard 
 And so to court 
 NEW YORK 
 ANY day now, the Turkish government will pit its strength in court against New York's mighty Metropolitan Museum of Art. 
 At issue is whether a foreign country can identify and successfully demand the repatriation of antiquities that it admits it did not even know existed until they turned up in a museum's collection. 
 Turkey has an excuse for its ignorance: the objects, it says, were looted from tombs where they had lain undisturbed for 2,500 years. 
 In bringing the case, the Turkish government is presenting itself as a great ally of archaeologists. 
 It maintains that they can only benefit if it secures the return to Turkey of the so-called Lydian hoard: Lydian, Archaemenid Persian and other Anatolian artefacts dating back to 600&ndash;500 BC which, it contends, were looted in 1960&ndash;66 from tombs in the Ushak region of Turkey. 
 If they win, the Turks say that art dealers and museums will have to exercise far more care in future over the provenance of antiquities they acquire. 
 This, in turn, will make it harder for diggers to profit from the crude &mdash; and illegal &mdash; looting of ancient sites. 
 Throughout the 1960s and 1970s many of Turkey's 3,000 archaeological sites were pillaged, including sacred tombs. 
 Thousands of objects were smuggled out of the country. 
 The Metropolitan's first move in this case was to invoke the statute of limitations to block Turkey's demand for the return of antiquities acquired by the museum through gifts and purchases about 20 years ago. 
 This tactical defence has been weakened by a ruling made recently in another case, where the Guggenheim Museum was seeking the return of a stolen Chagall painting from a private collector. 
 Like the Metropolitan, the collector made her purchase in good faith, never suspecting that the painting was stolen. 
 The court decided that victims of art thefts should be protected against the usual requirement in civil cases that the owner must make some effort to recover stolen goods within three years; it ruled that the clock does not start ticking for the statute of limitations until the victim locates the stolen artworks and asks for their return. 
 The Turkish government has hired two top lawyers to represent it: Harry Rand and Lawrence Kaye of the Park Avenue law firm of Herrick, Feinstein. 
 They have vigorously contested in court the Metropolitan's assertion that the Turkish government was tardy in pursuing its claim. 
 Turkey's experts, they said, needed the co-operation of the Metropolitan to be able to ascertain whether the objects formed part of the Lydian hoard. 
 Far from co-operating, however, the Metropolitan sought to &bquo;mislead, confuse and divert&equo; investigators by, for instance, labelling objects from the Lydian hoard &bquo;East Greek Treasures&equo;. 
 The State Department's legal adviser on cultural matters, Ely Maurer, will not discuss the Lydian hoard. 
 But he makes no secret of his pleasure over the ruling in the Guggenheim case. 
 The United States government is embarrassed by the way Americans have recently extorted money from foreign governments for looted artworks. 
 Mr Maurer cites the deal announced in January that allowed the Texan heirs of an American soldier to collect &dollar;2.75m from Germany for the return of stolen medieval artefacts known as the Quedlinburg treasures. 
 Klaus Maurice, the secretary-general of the German quasi-governmental agency that negotiated the deal, said at the time: &bquo;If we had pursued the lawsuit in Dallas, the legal fees would have greatly exceeded the amount we agreed to pay.&equo; 
 The State Department is pleased the Turkish government is not letting the legal costs deter it from pursuing its claim to the Lydian hoard. 
 The case promises to make murky laws clearer in the world's largest art market &mdash; to the benefit of all honest people in the art world, as well as to archaeologists.  
 It's tough 
 PARIS 
 COMICAL&equo; and &bquo;absurd&equo; was how Jean-Paul Rappeneau greeted the news that the Oscar for the best foreign film had gone not to his &bquo;Cyrano de Bergerac&equo;, which had received five nominations, but to a Turkish-speaking Swiss film, &bquo;Journey of Hope&equo;. 
 &bquo;What do you expect?&equo; sighed the culture minister, Jack Lang, illogically: &bquo;America is interested only in America.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cyrano&equo; won a paltry Oscar for best costumes. 
 The biggest disillusionment, however, came from the way some American journalists have been roughing up G&eacute;rard Depardieu, the larger-than-screen hero of &bquo;Cyrano&equo;. 
 Mr Depardieu had been nominated for an Oscar. 
 If he lost out to Jeremy Irons, his fans said, it was because he was the victim of a feminist-puritanical cabal. 
 Bulky as a lumberjack, Mr Depardieu has a Falstaffian gusto for life. 
 In Claude Berri's latest film, &bquo;Uranus&equo;, he knocks back a whole bottle of wine without pausing for breath; although he insists that it was merely coloured water, his fans believe otherwise. 
 Mr Depardieu also delights in adding lurid colour to his teenage days on the streets of Ch&acirc;teauroux. 
 He sought shelter at night with prostitutes, and earned money in various unlawful ways. 
 When his home town made him an &bquo;honoured citizen&equo; some years ago, he reminded friends that &bquo;they used to fling me in jail&equo;. 
 He has dismissed as &bquo;dirtying, disgusting and unfair&equo; charges in Time and the Washington Post that he took part in a gang rape at the age of nine. 
 That is the kind of exploit he might well claim after a drink or two, expecting his audience first to gasp, then to roar with laughter. 
 Unfortunately, Americans appear to have no sense of the Gallic tradition of ribald humour that goes back to Rabelais. 
 In France, his fans prefer to dwell on Mr Depardieu's street-to-screen success story. 
 He has now appeared in 60-odd films. 
 His roles range from transvestites to teenage murderers, though some viewers complain that, whatever the film, he is always playing himself: massive, extravagant, scruffy-haired. 
 Directors confess to a moment of panic when, as one puts it, &bquo;he rushes onto the set like a bull&equo;. 
 Yet another, Bertrand Blier, senses that behind the clowning &bquo;there is a terrible sense of anguish.&equo; 
 When he recently received a C&eacute;sar, France's answer to the Oscars, Mr Depardieu lumbered up to the stage, giggled as if half-drunk and whispered &bquo;It's tough being alive and lonely&equo;. 
 &bquo;Actors,&equo; he once said, &bquo;are rather like gangsters: people on the edge of society, ruthless people who suffer.&equo; 
 At 42, he has discovered that success has a bitter taste, too. 
 But, though Oscarless, he is delighting American audiences with his boorish manner and fractured English in Peter Weir's &bquo;Green Card&equo;. 
 It will take more than a few scandal-mongers to sink him. 
 AMERICAN SURVEY 
 Wild food 
 They're only mushrooms 
 BOYNE CITY, MICHIGAN 
 Looking for an unusual spring holiday? 
 Try morel hunting in Michigan 
 IT IS an unusually warm Saturday morning in early May as the crowd begins to gather in Boyne City. 
 This hamlet in northern Michigan is the Hollywood stereotype of a sleepy little town, but on this particular morning tension crackles in the air: everyone is waiting for the start of the day's big event. 
 Suddenly the siren on the fire truck begins to wail, and a caravan of cars winds its way out towards the edge of town. 
 At a place known in advance only to a few, the motorcade comes to a halt. 
 &bquo;Go,&equo; the starter shouts, and 200 people dash into the woods. 
 After almost an hour, the members of Nancy Weber's group are ready to turn back. 
 Their feet are sore and their bags are empty. 
 &bquo;Let's take a look over this one last hill,&equo; she pleads, climbing the ridge. 
 The woman leading the group spots a stand of dead apple trees. 
 Letting out a shriek, she races towards them and thumps down on the ground. 
 &bquo;They're mine,&equo; she says, wrapping her arms around a clump of morel mushrooms. 
 It is every man for himself in Boyne City's National Mushroom Championship, a race to collect the most morels. 
 &bquo;During the contest, it's fair to tackle someone if necessary; you do whatever it takes,&equo; says Stan Boris, a Charlevoix picker who has won 11 of the past 14 championships. 
 For the fungally uninformed, morels are the most prized of the world's mushrooms. 
 Jimmy Schmidt, the nationally renowned chef and owner of Detroit's Rattlesnake Club, considers them part of &bquo;a holy trinity&hellip; caviar, morel mushrooms and truffles.&equo; 
 (Truffles are fungi but not mushrooms.) 
 They can be stuffed and souffl&eacute;d, stirred into soups and baked with Brie. 
 But to most morel fanatics the best way to serve them up is saut&eacute;d in butter with a hint of salt and fresh ground pepper. 
 Taming the wild ones 
 The taste is good enough to send half a million people a year squirrelling around in the woods of northern Michigan, in search of something that is often no more than a couple of inches high and is usually hidden under a thick pile of forest-floor debris. 
 You can easily spot morel-mushroom hunters. 
 They walk like Groucho Marx. 
 Novices usually try to make friends with old hands, but that is not always easy. 
 Larry Lonik, author of &bquo;The Curious Morel&equo;, tells the tale of a man in Williamsburg who knew a special spot: &bquo;People would try to follow him, but he'd just sit down under a tree and wait them out. 
 His son-in-law, on the old man's deathbed, asked where the spot was and he wouldn't tell him. 
 They found the spot several years later.&equo; 
 According to some tourism officials, morel hunters pump more money into Michigan's economy than all the duck- and deer-hunters combined. 
 Joe Breidenstein says that last year he organised &bquo;morel weekends&equo; for 220 families. 
 There are annual morel festivals in four Michigan towns. 
 In Meswick hunters can find lodging in the Mushroom Cap Motel and tip back a few beers at the Mushroom Bar at the end of a long day's tramp. 
 Other locals supplement their regular incomes by collecting, then selling, morels to the tourists. 
 Fresh-picked morels can go for up to &dollar;25 a pound; dried, for &dollar;15&ndash;20 an ounce. 
 With that kind of price tag, it is not surprising that a long string of American entrepreneurs &mdash; including even Thomas Jefferson &mdash; have tried to find a way to cultivate various Morchella species. 
 Until four years ago, all attempts had failed. 
 But then the secret of growing morels was unlocked by a company called Neogen in East Lansing, Michigan. 
 The Neogen people are as tight-lipped about the process as soldiers about the location of nuclear weapons. 
 The process is now licensed to Morel Mountain, a subsidiary of Domino's Pizza. 
 They are supplying about 150 pounds of fresh morels a week to customers around the country. 
 Eventually they hope to quadruple production. 
 When the cultivation process was first announced, many were the sceptics who did not believe that farmed morels would ever be able to match those from the wild. 
 But &bquo;the taste is as good as natural,&equo; insists Mr Lonik, who also wears the hat of Morel Mountain marketing director. 
 For one thing, he says, &bquo;we can pick them at the peak of flavour maturity. 
 Our commercial mushrooms have no dirt, no bugs, no bits or pieces, no little growing things at the bottom of the box.&equo; 
 Morels are not unique to Michigan. 
 In Europe a closely related species, also called the morel, is equally prized by gourmets. 
 American morels can be found all along the Canadian border. 
 Even parts of Ohio and California can provide a field day for patient pickers. 
 But Michigan is, by all accounts, the home of the best.  
 An apology 
 LOS ANGELES 
 ALONG with many other newspapers, we may have given the impression that California was suffering from a five-year drought (&bquo;The other desert war&equo;, February 16th). 
 We may have further suggested that a droplet of rain falling on southern California was as likely as a sincere comment at the Oscars &mdash; and that young Californian children would probably never see a cloud in their lifetime. 
 We now realise that these claims are totally unfounded. 
 Soon after our article (perhaps as a direct result of it), it began to rain &mdash; and has barely stopped since. 
 San Diego has now had twice as much rain this year as in the whole of a normal year. 
 We hereby admit that California is, in fact, a lush paradise, where it is perfectly sensible to grow crops such as rice and alfalfa with subsidised water. 
 We deeply regret suggesting that farmers, who use around four-fifths of the available water, should be bullied into trading their cheap water with the cities. 
 In our defence we would say that the state's water supplies are still only around half of what is normal at this time of year, and that many Californians, currently refilling their swimming pools and reflooding their orange groves, may live to regret it. 
 In the meantime we offer our apologies to Neptune, Boreas and Thor, and have agreed to pay a substantial sum in damages should they care to collect it.  
 Action replay 
 DALLAS 
 MUCH as Dallas would like to wipe the assassination of John Kennedy from its memory, it cannot. 
 Oliver Stone is the latest to stir things up, as he prepares to begin filming &bquo;JFK&equo; in April. 
 The film director is pursuing the style of his earlier films, about the Vietnam war and about a pop group called the Doors. 
 He wants access to the sniper's perch on the sixth floor of the Texas School Book Depository, from which the fatal shots were fired. 
 But the Dallas county commission, which owns the building, denied his request after a highly charged debate in which the director was labelled a provocateur. 
 Mr Stone's co-producer accused the commission of censorship. 
 It offered the seventh floor as a compromise, saying the film-maker was &bquo;lucky to get that&equo;. 
 A recent survey by James Pennebaker, a Dallas psychologist, found people split into two camps: 1963 residents, who want to forget, and more recent arrivals and the young, for whom the assassination is ancient history. 
 Mr Stone's film is certainly not dreaded by all. 
 Hundreds donned their full early-1960s gear, or paraded in their cars, in the hope of being cast as extras in the film. 
 This image-conscious city got some relief from being the place where Kennedy was killed as a result of &bquo;Dallas&equo;, a television series glorifying the pluck and greed of the oil patch. 
 But reminders, often bizarre, that November 22nd 1963 marked Dallas as &bquo;the city of hate&equo; crop up frequently. 
 There was the son of a Dallas police officer who held a press conference last autumn to &bquo;confess&equo; that his dead father was the &bquo;second gunman&equo; some believe fired at the president from a grassy knoll. 
 Next came a court battle in which Earl Ruby won control of the gun that his brother Jack used to kill Lee Harvey Oswald, two days after the assassin's arrest. 
 Eight conspiracy theories about the killing are given considerable space in a museum housed on the sixth floor of the School Book Depository, called simply The Sixth Floor. 
 The commissioners said they denied Mr Stone's request to use this floor for fear of disrupting museum visitors. 
 The building stood empty for 25 years, and was nearly torn down. 
 For years the city's leaders resisted putting a museum in it. 
 Now The Sixth Floor contains a glass-encased sniper's corner, a photograph of the Kennedy clan, and a framed anti-Kennedy newspaper advertisement sponsored by an oil tycoon, H.L. Hunt, and other prominent Dallas businessmen.  
 Savings and Loans 
 Building on the rubble 
 DALLAS 
 COULD something good emerge from the multi-billion-dollar disaster known as the S&amp;L bail-out? 
 Consider the conjunction of two events. 
 Home ownership in America is falling for the first time since the Depression, just as the savings-and-loan collapse has made the government the largest single owner of property after foreclosing on bankrupt thrifts. 
 In 1989 Congress put two and two together, in a programme to sell the government's houses to the poor. 
 Representative Henry Gonzalez, the chairman of the House Banking Committee, thought somebody should benefit from the S&amp;L collapse. 
 Mr Gonzalez, who represents the modest Hispanic city of San Antonio, Texas, shepherded the affordable-housing programme through Congress as part of the S&amp;L bail-out. 
 Now he is unhappy with the way the programme is working. 
 Under the affordable-housing programme, houses valued at under &dollar;67,500 and apartment complexes are held off the open market for 90 days after a thrift is seized by the government. 
 During that time, the Resolution Trust Corporation (RTC), the agency created to liquidate thrifts, must offer the properties to local housing agencies or poor people. 
 They include people like the Wisdom family of Dallas, who bought a two-storey, red-brick house from the RTC for &dollar;60,000. 
 Up to then, Mr Wisdom's income as a construction supervisor had been too small to buy a house for his family of five. 
 The abandoned house they bought needs repairs, but the agency helped to pay for some of the necessary work. 
 But for every house sold from the agency's inventory &mdash; 2,728 by the end of last year &mdash; two more were not. 
 Some 2,600 houses have already passed the 90-day limit without offers, making them available for sale to any buyer. 
 After a disappointing first round of sales in Texas, where half of the affordable housing is located, the agency extended its offer and advertised a sealed-bid auction to drum up interest. 
 The auction produced 642 bids on 217 houses, and no bids on 371 houses. 
 Housing activists argue the agency could sell more houses if it were more adept at reaching its target market. 
 Poor buyers need to be coaxed and coddled, they say, and they are not in the habit of visiting estate agents. 
 Yet the RTC is relying only on estate agents to sell its houses. 
 The Association for Community Reform Now (ACORN), a national non-profit housing group, is pressing the agency to try something new &mdash; like hiring them. 
 ACORN sued the government last autumn for failure to do things required by the affordable-housing law. 
 The settlement will probably name ACORN as a clearing-house for properties. 
 It comes only after the group's members in Chicago broke into boarded-up houses and occupied them. 
 The slow pace of sales under the affordable-housing programme cannot be ascribed only to the cumbersome RTC bureaucracy. 
 A more fundamental problem is that the agency is being asked by Congress to do two diametrically opposed things. 
 Selling houses to the poor may not be compatible with minimising the losses to taxpayers, which requires selling assets at the best price available. 
 Peter Monroe, president of the RTC's supervisory board, said in a recent interview that he has got &bquo;a pretty clear message from Congress&equo; that he is not running a social service. 
 Mr Monroe said the agency would do nothing about reports that investors in Texas and Arizona were buying apartments owned by failed thrifts before the 90-day period was up. 
 The rules do permit the RTC to give away worthless properties to housing groups to use as shelters for the homeless. 
 A few have been turned over to groups in Arkansas, Florida and Texas. 
 By the time the agency finishes its massive job, it could have a lot more worthless property on its hands.  
 Water 
 River rivalry 
 ATLANTA 
 THE Chattahoochee river seems tranquil enough as it meanders 385 miles from north Georgia's mountains past Atlanta, along the Alabama border and across the Florida Panhandle, finally spilling into the Gulf of Mexico. 
 Yet this gentle river, plied by suburban canoeists and pumped by farmers into peanut fields, has become a battle-zone in a three-state water war. 
 Georgia is feuding with Florida and Alabama over who has rights to the Chattahoochee (its name means &bquo;painted rock&equo; in Cherokee). 
 Atlanta, Georgia's capital, draws about 70% of its drinking water from the river. 
 Last summer Atlanta proposed taking twice as much &mdash; up to 529m gallons a day &mdash; from the Chattahoochee and Lake Sidney Lanier to quench suburban growth over the next 20 years. 
 Alabama filed a federal lawsuit to block the plan, saying development along its eastern border would suffer if Atlanta took so much water. 
 Florida protested that lower river levels might upset the delicate ecology of Apalachicola bay, and sink the area's oyster industry. 
 Without more water, Georgians reply, their state will have to restrict growth, costing it 680,000 jobs and &dollar;127 billion in wages by 2010. 
 The lawsuit has been delayed since September, when the three states vowed to reach an out-of-court compromise. 
 But closed-door negotiations have yielded little more than words. 
 Some Georgian officials suspect that Alabama is deviously trying to steal development away from Atlanta by turning off the city's tap. 
 One threatened to call out the National Guard to defend Atlanta's water rights. 
 The question at the heart of the dispute is who owns a waterway that begins in one state but flows into others. 
 Georgia insists the Chattahoochee belongs to it, because the headwaters are within its boundaries. 
 Alabama and Florida reply that it is a resource to be shared by all three. 
 The issue rarely surfaced in the showery south-east until a string of droughts in the 1980s. 
 Water was so scarce that lawn-sprinkling in the suburbs became a criminal offence. 
 The Chattahoochee was too shallow to keep barges afloat in the navigable waterway south of Atlanta. 
 Although rainfall has now returned to normal, Georgia's leaders remain keenly conscious that water is a scarce commodity, to be carefully managed. 
 They have devised a new plan calling for a dozen man-made lakes to store rain and to render the Atlanta region &bquo;drought-proof&equo; for the next half-century. 
 That, too, is raising the neighbours' ire. 
 Political and business interests in Alabama have flocked to public hearings by the bus-load, angrily saying that the reservoir system will diminish the quality and quantity of water flowing into their state. 
 They vow to fight the system in court, if necessary. 
 If in doubt, pass the buck. 
 Georgia, Alabama and Florida agree on one point. 
 The Army Corps of Engineers, which manages the Chattahoochee river system, should conduct a &dollar;1m, five-year study of the region's long-term water needs. 
 And a judge may have to sort out the immediate squabble. 
 William Sumption, director of a private water-development group in Alabama, says: &bquo;It seems we may need Daddy to tell us where the toys are on the floor, and how to share them.&equo;  
 William Reilly's green precision weapons 
 AS A paid-up green, William Reilly has not always looked comfortable in the Bush administration. 
 George Bush chose him to run the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) at a time when he still thought he could co-opt and not alienate the green lobby. 
 Mr Reilly, a veteran conservationist, scored early by helping to push through the first revision of the clean-air law in 13 years. 
 Since then he has been repeatedly outmanoeuvred. 
 He lost battles with the chief of staff, John Sununu, over global warming and wetland preservation. 
 His relations with the budget director, Richard Darman, especially over energy policy, are appalling &mdash; Mr Darman calls him a &bquo;global rock star&equo;. 
 When Congress last year held up legislation to give the EPA cabinet status, wanted by Mr Bush, some people saw the vengeful hand of Mr Darman at work. 
 Mr Reilly has now embarked on a job which even the cynical Mr Darman should applaud. 
 He is trying to use risk assessment and economics &mdash; grubby workman's tools that most greens are too fastidious to touch &mdash; to redirect both the EPA's priorities and its approach to regulation. 
 For all the Reaganite vilification heaped on it, the EPA grew, prospered and regulated mightily in the 1980s. 
 But its efforts were, in the words of a recent scientific report commissioned by Mr Reilly, &bquo;inconsistent, unco-ordinated and&hellip; less effective than they could have been.&equo; 
 Too much attention was paid to low-damage but high-publicity cases like oil spills and the famous toxic waste in Love Canal, not enough to habitat loss and global warming. 
 Much of the clean-air act is aimed at acid rain, which a giant official study has concluded is virtually a non-problem. 
 A telling sign of misplaced priorities, in the eyes of many critics, is the EPA's concentration on health. 
 Something like two-thirds of the agency's staff members work on health-related, not environmental, rules. 
 At times it has behaved more like a cancer-prevention than an environmental agency, making such scientifically dubious decisions as wanting to remove asbestos from school buildings and to ban substances with a microscopically small risk of causing cancer. 
 Only 2&ndash;3% of cancers are caused by man-made things anyway. 
 Does this over-enthusiasm matter? 
 Mr Reilly says yes, for two reasons. 
 One is that environmental protection is too expensive to indulge in without thought of costs and benefits. 
 It will soon take more than 2.5% of America's GNP just to comply with existing rules. 
 But the bigger point is that pursuing wrong priorities discredits greenery as a whole &mdash; just when it needs friends to defend it from hard-pressed businessmen and rabid deregulators. 
 Mr Reilly says he wants to stop being reactive. 
 He would rather list the EPA's concerns in order of priority, so that the agency can &bquo;take aim before we open fire&equo;. 
 Because it has followed public opinion in the past, the EPA has always taken the view that governments are there to stop people having to run risks, however small. 
 Hence, for instance, some of the more onerous provisions of the clean-air act that will produce doubtful benefits at huge cost. 
 The EPA has an enormous education job on its hands, which should be directed at green enthusiasts and sceptics alike. 
 Identifying priorities is only a start. 
 The next task is to tackle them in the most sensible way. 
 Above all, this means using the economic incentives offered by the market, not regulations to &bquo;command and control&equo; things. 
 The Bush administration is proud of the pioneering use of emissions-trading in the clean-air act, which it hopes will cut sulphur-dioxide output for just over half the cost of equivalent regulation. 
 But that did not originate at the EPA. 
 The EPA exists to regulate things, not to see the market do the job for it. 
 Mr Reilly will have to make his own bureaucracy reform itself. 
 Even the greenest greens are coming to accept market forces (and the value of a growing economy) as a help in cleaning up the environment. 
 Eastern Europe has shown that non-market economies with slow growth can pollute the environment more than most. 
 But, to be really effective, Mr Reilly's enthusiasm needs stretching. 
 He could start with the federal government itself. 
 The defence and energy departments, impervious to markets, are among the country's biggest polluters. 
 And there is a dreadful stew of federal subsidies and tax breaks (for such things as logging in Alaska, irrigation in California, grazing on federal land in Nevada) that actually subsidise those engaged in making the environment worse. 
 A dose of market reality for get-the-government-off-our-backs westerners could benefit the environment &mdash; and save the taxpayer money. 
 Taxophobia 
 The best economic incentive to achieve environmental goals is often a tax, for it brings home to consumers the external cost of their consumption without clumsily trying to regulate it away. 
 Yet the government has always found it safer to regulate companies than to tax consumers, and Mr Bush is especially averse to taxes. 
 Though he is too politically cautious to admit it in public, Mr Reilly knows he needs taxes as a weapon in the environmental arsenal, even if they are disguised under another label. 
 Watch for two tests in the coming months. 
 One is the revision of the clean-water act, which will be ineffective unless it includes taxes or fees on the use of pesticides and fertilisers that leach into rivers. 
 The second will come over fuel-economy standards. 
 Congress and the administration may go for a sharp rise in the average miles per gallon required of car makers, instead of the much more efficient solution of higher petrol taxes. 
 Mr Reilly may bask in the credibility he has established as Mr Bush's green man, even without being in the cabinet. 
 But his biggest fights are yet to come.  
 Missouri 
 A rising reverend 
 KANSAS CITY, MISSOURI 
 AS THE song from &bquo;Oklahoma!&equo; would have it, everything's up to date in Kansas City. 
 The latest sign of modernity is the election of the city's first black mayor, Emanuel Cleaver, on March 26th. 
 Mr Cleaver's victory over his fellow city-council member, Bob Lewellen, in a non-partisan run-off election, was not the first for a black politician in this predominantly white city. 
 Alan Wheat has been Kansas City's congressman since 1982. 
 The run-off election for mayor was, remarkably enough, marked by quiet debate on the issues. 
 Neither candidate took a party line and neither raised race. 
 Mr Cleaver, who is 46, is an ordained Methodist minister, who was ordered by his bishop in 1983 to choose between the ministry and politics (he donated most of his council salary to charity). 
 He is typical of the moderate blacks now being elected in many states. 
 He tends to be less radical and confrontational than the most nationally prominent black politician, the Rev Jesse Jackson, and more willing to work with the establishment to achieve his goals. 
 Mr Cleaver was endorsed by the Kansas City Star, as well as by other mainstream organisations including a group of black Republicans. 
 Although no one would claim that Kansas City is now a model of racial harmony, it does make a sharp contrast to St Louis, Missouri's other main city. 
 There, politics and politicians frequently divide along racial lines. 
 The city's mayor, Vincent Schoemel, who is white, is constantly squabbling with its leading black  politician , the comptroller, Virvus Jones. 
 On April 2nd voters in St Louis will choose between two slates of candidates for the city's school board. 
 One slate of two blacks and two whites, backed by the city establishment, is facing a slate which includes white supremacists linked to David Duke, a Louisiana politician and former Ku Klux Klansman. 
 They are campaigning against the city's controversial school-desegregation programme, which involves busing pupils. 
 If elected, the anti-busing slate would join five like-minded school-board members elected earlier, giving the faction control of the board. 
 The prospect of their victory has prompted the federal judge overseeing the school-desegregation plan publicly to warn the candidates not to make promises he will not allow them to keep.  
 A Euro jigsaw puzzle for George Bush to solve 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 WITH a good deal of head-scratching, with a shuffle here and a waffle there, America's diplomats are trying to decide what the country's European policy should be. 
 They are not finding it easy. 
 In 1989 and 1990 America's goals for Europe could be simply stated. 
 They were, first, to encourage the Soviet withdrawal from Eastern Europe; and, second, once the pace of that withdrawal had become apparent, to assist in the birth of a united Germany, firmly anchored to the western alliance. 
 As the Americans saw it, both goals required them to reassure those parties who felt nervous about what was going on. 
 That meant, above all, that America would signal to the Soviet Union that it had no intention of rubbing Moscow's nose in its defeat. 
 It also meant reassuring West European countries worried about a unified Germany that America intended to maintain troops at the heart of the continent. 
 This reassurance, though commonly assumed to be directed at the British, was almost equally directed at Europe's smaller countries. 
 One Washington ambassador of a small West European country says that America kept his government more closely informed of the progress of the &bquo;two-plus-four&equo; talks on German unity than did the West Germans, French or British. 
 That was as far as the Washington consensus on European policy went. 
 There were always some in the State Department who thought the policy might be pushed a little further: who thought that a unified Germany might become a big partner for America in the same way as is (say some) Japan. 
 But others doubted whether that would happen, and events from the middle of 1990 have broadly proved the sceptics right. 
 Germany's Chancellor Helmut Kohl was unable or unwilling to deliver what the Americans thought he had promised at the Houston summit it last July &mdash; political muscle to make progress on farm-reform at the GATT talks. 
 And Germany's self-absorption with unity meant that its response to the Gulf challenge was feebler than the Germanophiles would have wished. 
 It is nevertheless significant that, however much anti-German growling there has been on Capitol Hill since the invasion of Kuwait, little has been heard within the administration. 
 From the president down, the policymakers have always appreciated that Germany was bound to go through a period of introversion. 
 The administration was, however, disturbed by the angst-ridden quality of German policy during the autumn. 
 It was a bit cross (and told the Germans so) when Germany seemed to think it could have a debate about whether Turkey, a NATO member, was entitled to the benefits of the same collective security which Germany has enjoyed for more than four decades. 
 But there never was a threat to a new German-American special relationship, since there never was such a special relationship to begin with. 
 America's reminder to Germany of the value of NATO is one piece of a jigsaw puzzle that is growing more difficult to solve. 
 In place of the easy verities of a year and a half ago, America now has to cope with a Europe &mdash; both east and west &mdash; in a state of flux. 
 In the east, the new democracies are trying to modernise their economies; in the west, the countries of the European Community are considering the scope and shape of a common foreign policy &mdash; and therefore, unavoidably, common defence and security policies as well. 
 Not all Americans enjoy what they see, at either end of the continent. 
 The Bush administration has always liked to say that Eastern Europe holds a special place in its heart; Americans love the praise heaped on them in Washington when East European heroes like Lech Walesa and Vaclav Havel come to call. 
 When Mr Walesa was in Washington last week, George Bush took the opportunity to forgive an additional &dollar;800m of Poland's debt to America (it has now forgiven 70% of it). 
 And the administration is worried about the possible break-up of Yugoslavia, a state some Americans like to think they invented. 
 Champion of the east 
 But the administration is far from sure that Western Europe shares its love for the new democracies of the east or its concern for Yugoslavia. 
 One senior State Department official has said privately that West European countries treat East European ones with &bquo;contempt&equo;. 
 America believes that the future prosperity and security of Eastern Europe are nothing like guaranteed. 
 That is one reason it is so keen that East European products, especially its competitive farm products, should have free access to West European markets. 
 Increasingly, however, some in the administration think that trade will not be enough to anchor Eastern Europe to the prosperous West &mdash; which means that policy-makers are considering the ticklish question of the future of the European Community. 
 Americans are scrupulously careful to say nothing on the record about enlargement of the Community: that, they say, is a matter for the Europeans. 
 In private, however, the view is gaining ground that eventual membership of the Community by those East European countries that want to join it would be a good idea. 
 Here is one place where America's concern with Eastern Europe bumps up against the Community's own deliberations. 
 Another such bump comes over the future of NATO. 
 American officials say that, after a year's careful thought, the new democracies of Eastern Europe have come to the conclusion that NATO is a splendid thing: a watchdog against any future Soviet attempt to re-establish hegemony over Eastern and Central Europe (see page 47). 
 The Americans are telling East Europeans that they should not think they can join NATO &mdash; that would break the &bquo;don't gloat&equo; rule &mdash; and they do not mean to imply, either, that NATO's security perimeter has been extended to the Soviet-Polish border. 
 But at the same time their concern with Eastern Europe is one more reason that they do not want West Europeans to do anything that weakens NATO. 
 That is why some Americans have been bothered by suggestions from Paris, Bonn and Brussels that (in the words of Jacques Delors, speaking in London on March 7th) the Western European Union (WEU) should be &bquo;the melting pot for a European defence embedded in the Community, the second pillar of the Atlantic alliance&equo;. 
 Norway and Turkey &mdash; from America's viewpoint, NATO members vital to containing the Soviet Union &mdash; are not members of the WEU. 
 France is a member of the WEU but not of NATO's military organisation. 
 Both French and European Community officials making their springtime visits to Washington have been anxious to dispel American anxieties. 
 One senior official of the European Commission said recently that, had there been a common Community defence policy, it would have committed forces to the Gulf. 
 The British, who have less grandiose plans for the WEU as a &bquo;bridge&equo; between the Community and NATO, doubt that. 
 So the stakes are high. 
 But American policy is nothing like formed, which explains European complaints that they hear different things from different Americans. 
 European diplomats say that Reginald Bartholomew, the under-secretary of state for security assistance, has warned them against doing anything with the WEU that undermines NATO or freezes out the Americans from security talks at which they think they are entitled to be present. 
 Yet, according to French sources, when Fran&ccedil;ois Mitterrand complained about the tone of Mr Bartholomew's warnings at his recent meeting with President Bush on Martinique, the American president did not know what had been going on. 
 European policy has not yet recaptured the attention of Mr Bush, still preoccupied with the Gulf. 
 Some time this year, it will have to. 
 ASIA 
 Japan, Gorbachev and the price of peace 
 FROM OUR TOKYO CORRESPONDENT 
 BUYING territory rather than seizing it has honourable precedents among nations. 
 The Americans bought Louisiana from the French and Alaska from the Russians. 
 The case of four islands in the Kuriles is a bit different. 
 They were part of Japan until Russia occupied them at the end of the second world war, and the Japanese feel they are justified in wanting them back. 
 But, as with Louisiana and Alaska, it looks as though money will settle the matter. 
 Japan plans to offer the Soviet Union a deal worth &dollar;26 billion for the islands. 
 To make the offer especially palatable it proposes to accept two now and the other two later. 
 The exchange would be spread over five years. 
 Previously Japan has demanded that all four be handed over together. 
 It says something for the delicacy of the proposal that it comes not from the Japanese government, but from the ruling Liberal Democratic Party. 
 The party's secretary-general, Ichiro Ozawa, was in Moscow on March 25th to make the final preparations for Mikhail Gorbachev's visit to Japan starting on April 16th. 
 While there, he spent two hours outlining the new Japanese thinking to the Soviet president. 
 By all accounts, the Soviet Union sees the bullying Mr Ozawa &mdash; the power behind Toshiki Kaifu's government &mdash; as someone it can do business with. 
 Even so, the official response from Moscow so far has been muted. 
 Hints have been dropped that the two smaller islands, Shikotan and the Habomai rocks, might be returned &mdash; in line with the pledge that the Soviet Union made in 1956 but later withdrew. 
 More promising hints about the islands are expected from the Soviet foreign minister, Alexander Bessmertnykh, who was due in Tokyo on March 29th to agree on Mr Gorbachev's itinerary. 
 Few people in Japan expect Mr Gorbachev to make more than a few diplomatic utterances about the islands while in Tokyo. 
 But at least the new developments should ease the diplomatic impasse that has kept relations between Japan and the Soviet Union frozen for 46 years. 
 Japan's stance over what it calls its Northern Territories has been that there can be no peace treaty between the two countries until all four of the islands (Etorofu, Kunashiri, Shikotan and Habomai) are returned. 
 Only then will Japan consider granting aid to the Soviet Union. 
 Only then, too, will Japanese business have the confidence to invest heavily in joint ventures to help the Soviet Union develop the mineral treasures of Siberia. 
 Included in the deal would be &dollar;4 billion worth of emergency loans from the Export-Import Bank of Japan to help provide the Soviet Union with consumer goods. 
 These loans would be granted quickly. 
 A further &dollar;4 billion would be made available for reimbursing the Soviet Union for moving its citizens off the islands, withdrawing the troops stationed there, and paying compensation for the loss of property. 
 The Japanese government would also guarantee an additional &dollar;8 billion of private-sector loans, mainly for oil and gas projects in Sakhalin. 
 And a final &dollar;10 billion would be offered at low interest rates as part of a long-term economic plan to help the Soviet Union build some decent factories and roads and exploit its natural resources. 
 Officials in the Liberal Democratic Party have spent months building a consensus for the plan, both within the sceptical foreign ministry and among businessmen, who are even more dubious. 
 Japanese businessmen have horror stories about joint ventures in the Soviet Union. 
 Most have grown tired of trying to deal with rigid management, the country's continually changing laws and the ban on repatriating rouble profits. 
 The Soviet Union has stopped paying its bills. 
 Japanese trading companies are owed nearly &dollar;400m for exports and cannot get an answer about when they might be paid. 
 Trade between Japan and the Soviet Union slipped 3% last year to a tiny &dollar;5.9 billion. 
 The islands deal has been approved by two of Japan's most influential businessmen, Gaishi Hiraiwa, chairman of the Keidanren (Federation of Economic Organisations), and Rokuro Ishikawa, chairman of the Japan Chamber of Commerce. 
 Without their approval, the government would be powerless to act. 
 The message sent to Moscow was thus unambiguous: do the diplomatic deal and Japanese businessmen will come knocking on the door again. 
 Mr Gorbachev would like them to do a great deal more. 
 He is expected to use his address to the Diet (parliament) during his visit &mdash; the first by a Soviet head of state &mdash; to try to get a commitment from both the Japanese government and its businessmen to back a hoary old proposal: the formation of an economic group among the countries surrounding the Japan Sea, that is, the Soviet Union, the two Koreas and Japan. 
 Dog-eared it may be, but the idea is being given a new lease of life by the rapprochement between the Soviet Union and South Korea, the thaw in relations between Japan and North Korea, and now a likely peace treaty between Japan and the Soviet Union. 
 But China, Taiwan and the ASEAN countries, as well as Japan, are leery about so exclusive a grouping. 
 Polite noises are all that Mr Kaifu and his colleagues would prefer to make about the &bquo;Japan Sea development zone&equo;. 
 But they are aware, too, that the stakes involved in Mr Gorbachev's visit are uncommonly high. 
 Their names will be in Japanese history books if they can persuade the Soviet leader to hand back the islands. 
 If the matter is badly handled, Mr Kaifu's reputation, already in question, could be ruined. 
 Having taken the initiative on the Northern Territories, officials of the ruling party are worried that they may not get all the co-operation they need from the civil service. 
 What if the Soviet negotiators are baiting a bear trap for Japan's amateur statesmen &mdash; just as the North Koreans did last autumn? 
 At that time the Japanese foreign ministry distanced itself from the Liberal Democrats' mission to Pyongyang organised by the party's strongman, Shin Kanemaru. 
 The civil servants watched with barely concealed glee as the ruling party became embarrassed when the North Koreans demanded compensation not only for Japan's colonial rule but also for all the years since. 
 Mr Kanemaru's reputation took a dive from which it has not recovered. 
 The party is hoping that, this time, the &dollar;26 billion bribe is big enough to do the trick. 
 After all, Louisiana went for Dollars15m and Alaska fetched only &dollar;7.2m &mdash; about 2 cents an acre.  
 Pakistan 
 Running to market 
 FROM OUR PAKISTAN CORRESPONDENT 
 FOR a man running a leisurely sort of country, Nawaz Sharif has moved with astonishing speed. 
 Three months after becoming prime minister, he is already putting in place a vast programme to privatise the state-owned businesses that have been a drag on the country since they were nationalised by Zulfikar Ali Bhutto in the early 1970s. 
 Mr Sharif's urgency is understandable. 
 Pakistan's economy has suffered from losing cheap Kuwaiti oil and American aid, which has been suspended as a result of America's suspicion of Pakistan's nuclear-weapons programme. 
 It also has a deeper problem: fiscal indiscipline, manifested in a budget deficit running at 7% of GDP. 
 Privatisation might help fix some of the economy's ills; but it is already bringing problems as well. 
 The prime minister's economic programme includes deregulating the foreign capital market, privatising 115 state-owned businesses &mdash; including the banks &mdash; within a year, and encouraging private investment in transport, communications and energy. 
 Exchange controls are already being eased: Pakistanis can now operate foreign-currency accounts in local banks with no questions asked. 
 Privatisation has begun. 
 Most state industries have lost money for decades. 
 One study estimates that in 1987 the combined assets of all public-sector companies had a net return of 0.14%. 
 Sartaj Aziz, the finance minister, says he wants to &bquo;cut his losses of &dollar;1 billion every year&equo;. 
 Two years ago Benazir Bhutto was thinking along the same lines. 
 But she was stalled by opposition from labour groups affiliated to her party. 
 The new prime minister, a businessman, is not so constrained; and his moves have won him plaudits from his private-sector friends. 
 They complain that the state's domination of the economy has been suffocating: public investment has risen to 8.5% of GDP compared with private investment of 6.5%. 
 But putting the policy into practice may not be easy. 
 The government has made a mess of its showpiece, the privatisation of the profitable Muslim Commercial Bank. 
 The government rejected the highest offer, fudged the auction rules, then accepted a revised offer from the third-highest bidder, who was given 26% of the bank's shares. 
 Rivals got a stay order from the courts, though after a backroom deal in mid-March the government got its way. 
 Accusations of political favouritism abound, and some mud has stuck on the prime minister. 
 Labour is causing trouble, too. 
 Some 300,000 people work in state-owned enterprises, and many owe their jobs to political patronage. 
 Industrial unrest is likely. 
 The government hopes that the sale of a chunk of its &dollar;30 billion assets will help refill its depleted treasury. 
 But some people worry that the private sector does not have enough cash to mop up much of this vast sale, while others fear that the government may become so involved with selling the state's assets that it forgets about the pressing problem of widening its tax base. 
 Although servicing the deficit takes up nearly 30% of government spending, fewer than 0.1% of Pakistanis pay direct taxes. 
 Agriculture (26% of GDP, compared with 24% for industry) is not taxed. 
 Fiscal reformers &mdash; including members of the present government &mdash; have argued for years that it should be. 
 But now that it is in power, and dependent on an assembly made up largely of landowners, the government seems to find that option less attractive.  
 Happy families 
 FROM OUR DELHI  CORRESPONDENT  
 INDIA'S population is 844m and expanding by almost 18m a year, according to a census published this week. 
 This is alarming, except by African standards: India's growth rate of 2.22% a year is far exceeded by Africa's 3.2%. 
 India spends &dollar;400m a year on birth control, much of which is wasted. 
 Sterilisation is undergone mainly by older people who have had families. 
 Those who have the operation get a 100-rupee (&dollar;5) reward. 
 Small families are commonest in the cities. 
 There health care is available and people can generally find some cash. 
 Moreover, city Indians do not feel they need lots of children to look after them when they are old. 
 Literacy seems to be a factor in keeping the family to a manageable size. 
 In India as a whole literacy is 52%. 
 But in the southern state of Kerala, where literacy exceeds 90%, the population growth is only 1.2% a year.  
 A breather 
 THE drawbacks of smoking are barely noticed in Asia. 
 Chinese, Indians and Malays puff away to the delight of cigarette manufacturers. 
 In Taiwan, though, which likes to keep up with the West, there is a growing feeling that smoking should not be encouraged. 
 The government has started an advertising campaign that will draw attention to health hazards. 
 Soldiers will no longer be given free cigarettes. 
 Smoking has been a useful earner for the government. 
 Its Tobacco and Wine Monopoly Bureau received &dollar;1.6m in taxes in 1988. 
 No matter: as evidence of its sincerity to try to improve the health of the Taiwanese, the government has decided to change the name of the cigarette that has 90% of the market. 
 It is called Long Life.  
 India 
 In the money, sort of 
 FROM OUR DELHI CORRESPONDENT 
 BEING very poor is customary in India. 
 But it appears to be getting less so, if government figures are to be believed. 
 A new survey says, rather precisely, that the proportion of Indians below the poverty line fell from 48.3% in 1977&ndash;78 to 29.2% in 1987&ndash;88. 
 Since India's population grew by nearly a quarter over that period, this means that about 80m people managed to clamber above the poverty line in a decade. 
 The government gets its data from a national survey conducted every five years. 
 The poverty line is put at consumption per person of about &dollar;11 a month, just about conceivable in India though it may sound impossibly low to a westerner. 
 That still leaves at least 250m Indians living in abject poverty, but at least life appears to be getting a little better for the rest. 
 There are several reasons for the improvement. 
 During the 1980s, although the population grew by more than 2% a year (see box), real GNP grew by nearly 6%, well up from the 3.5% a year in the first three decades of independence. 
 This was thanks in part to the gradual liberalisation of the economy. 
 Though India still fails to reach anything like its potential for growth, trickle-down may be working. 
 Anti-poverty programmes have helped. 
 One of them provides income-earning assets to families: sewing machines, for example. 
 These schemes are notorious for corruption, but something has got through to the poor. 
 Increasing urbanisation has led to higher incomes. 
 The proportion of the population dependent on agriculture stayed unchanged at around 70% for several decades, but is now falling. 
 The remittance economy is growing. 
 Migrants to towns send money home to relations. 
 Migrants to the Gulf and Britain send home more. 
 Several decades of education, including technical education, have had an impact on productivity. 
 The liberalisation of the economy has helped technocrats to start hundreds of new industries. 
 Perhaps the most convincing indication of a dent in poverty is marketing information showing that the boom in consumer durables in the 1980s was by no means limited to the top 10% of the population. 
 The bottom 60% bought 33% of the wristwatches sold in India, 22% of the small black-and-white televisions, 46% of the bicycles and 36% of the radios. 
 People in the countryside now buy 72% of the radios and 45% of the motorcycles that are sold. 
 If indeed poverty is less pervasive, why are so few people saying so? 
 The non-Congress political parties do not want Rajiv Gandhi to get any credit for it. 
 Many academics and journalists who gave warning that liberalisation and the Congress Party culture were fattening the rich at the expense of the poor are understandably silent. 
 As for Mr Gandhi, he does say occasionally that his government reduced poverty, but does not press the point. 
 The state apparatus has become so corrupt and exploitative that the common man sees it as an enemy. 
 Those rising above the poverty line think they have succeeded in spite of the government. 
 If a villager migrates to Bombay and makes a living as a hawker, he probably has to bribe a cop to stay in business and pay off the local mafia don. 
 If he is better off, he is unlikely to thank Mr Gandhi.  
 She shall return 
 IT LOOKS as though Imelda Marcos will be allowed back into the Philippines. 
 The question is when. 
 The president, Cory Aquino, confirmed weeks of rumour on March 21st when she said that the ban on Mrs Marcos would be lifted so that she could go on trial in Manila, but only when the government had decided what to charge her with. 
 The Philippines has been wondering what to do about Mrs Marcos ever since she fled to Hawaii with her husband Ferdinand when he was deposed by a revolt in 1986. 
 When Ferdinand died in 1989 Mrs Marcos seemed to be the only link to the billions of dollars that the Philippines claims the Marcos family stole during his presidency. 
 Some &dollar;350m is said to be in Swiss banks. 
 The Swiss Supreme Court says that any money will be released to the Philippine government only after a number of conditions have been met. 
 One condition is that Mrs Marcos must be charged by the end of this year. 
 A government lawyer has said that charges will be filed in four or five months. 
 But the government is not having Mrs Marcos back yet. 
 Last week the Philippine consulate in New York refused her application for a passport. 
 Were it not for the prospect of seizing the Swiss money, it is doubtful whether the Philippines would be ready to allow Mrs Marcos home this year or any other year. 
 Marcos is still a powerful name in the Philippines. 
 Mrs Marcos has gained in stature during her exile. 
 No one sneers about her weakness for shoes these days. 
 That, anyway, was a piece of propaganda by the Aquino government. 
 The story that she has no artistic taste was shown to be a lie in January when a collection of her old-master paintings sold well at Christie's in New York. 
 She put on a brave show when she was tried in New York last year in connection with some property deals. 
 Mrs Marcos was found not guilty in New York. 
 Supposing she were found not guilty in Manila on whatever charges the government brought against her? 
 Heavens, as a free woman, she might even run for president in 1992.  
 China 
 Three hours with Li Peng 
 FROM OUR BEIJING CORRESPONDENT 
 IT IS not easy to feel sorry for China's prime minister, Li Peng. 
 He tends to look either smug or surly, and he will long be associated with the Tiananmen Square massacre of June 1989. 
 But in Beijing on March 25th, as he plodded through a three-hour speech at the opening session of China's annual parliament, the National People's Congress, some at least of the 3,000 delegates must have felt a twinge of sympathy. 
 Mr Li was faced with the task of trying to make sense of China's eighth five-year plan and a ten-year &bquo;development strategy&equo;. 
 At the same time he had to sound confident about the ultimate triumph of socialism, against all the evidence that it has failed. 
 And at his back are China's octogenarian power-brokers, biding their time before throwing him to the wolves. 
 The new economic programmes are muddled compromises between the ambitions of growth-seeking reformers in the coastal provinces and the desperate efforts by Beijing's central planners to keep a grip on the economy. 
 Over the next decade GDP growth is supposed to average 6%. 
 This compares with an average of 9% achieved in the 1980s, and is lower than reformist economists and provincial leaders had hoped. 
 Defending the modest target, Mr Li said, &bquo;An excessively high growth rate is liable to end up destabilising the economy.&equo; 
 The government remains fearful of a recurrence of the overheating and inflation of late 1988, which led to an austerity programme still notionally in force. 
 Looking back on that period, Mr Li lamented, &bquo;Some sectors of the economy were so decentralised that the state's ability to exercise macro-control was weakened.&equo; 
 That is the nub of the problem. 
 The ten-year programme represents not so much a strategy for growth; it is more a guess at the government's ability to rein in the booming provinces of the southern coast and the Yangtze delta. 
 There, where &bquo;the state's ability to exercise macro-control&equo; is already tenuous, the economy is working reasonably well. 
 Where the state's control is stronger, the economy is a disaster. 
 At least a third of state-owned enterprises, still the backbone of the economy, are losing money. 
 As a result, the government's budget deficit has ballooned, to 15 billion yuan (&dollar;2.9 billion) in 1990. 
 Disregarding China's quaint practice of counting disbursed government borrowings as revenue, the true deficit reached 48 billion yuan last year, up 35% on the previous year. 
 The amount of money forked out in subsidies to loss-making state enterprises was 57 billion yuan. 
 Presenting his budget this week, the finance minister, Wang Bingqian, used his favourite word for the third year running to describe the state of the public purse: &bquo;grim&equo;. 
 He moaned, with justification, that &bquo;People all&hellip; wonder why the financial picture is becoming more and more serious.&equo; 
 Then he put his finger on the reason: &bquo;State finance was required to&hellip; safeguard overall political and social stability.&equo; 
 Li Peng listened. 
 But a fear of mass urban unemployment grips the prime minister even more powerfully than that of inflation. 
 So Mr Li made it clear that the state will go on bailing out the inefficient state-owned juggernauts, as well as subsidising a range of things from rice to city rents. 
 Mr Li was more confident when he turned to politics. 
 China has been cheered up by the difficulties the emerging democracies of Eastern Europe face as they try to change their old communist ways. 
 The lesson for China was clear. 
 Mr Li was in full cry with warnings against the plots of the &bquo;hegemonists&equo; (that is, the Americans) to effect a &bquo;peaceful evolution&equo; to capitalism in China. 
 &bquo;Socialist China will stand rock solid in the east,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We must uphold the people's democratic dictatorship.&equo; 
 The ghosts of Chairman Mao and Uncle Joe must have nodded in agreement. 
 This year's parliament is intended to include the final rites over the 1989 protests as the judiciary reports on its recent &bquo;successes&equo; in jailing the leaders of the demonstrations. 
 Mr Li's future still depends on public amnesia about the massacre. 
 Two pairs of hands were missing from the dutiful applause that greeted his speech. 
 China's senior leader, Deng Xiaoping, did not deign to put in an appearance. 
 But behind the scenes the 86-year-old reformer is believed to be working to bring his economic programme back to life. 
 His ousted prot&eacute;g&eacute;, the former party chief Zhao Ziyang, sacked in June 1989 for supporting some of the demands of the protesting students, remains a delegate to parliament. 
 But, as last year, he has &bquo;asked for leave&equo;, say officials. 
 To condemn him too publicly would reopen wounds within the party. 
 So Mr Zhao, it seems, is to remain in political purgatory, from where he will continue to haunt Li Peng's dreams of stability. 
 INTERNATIONAL 
 Mali and Benin 
 Dying dinosaurs 
 EXTINCTION is bound to hurt somebody. 
 In Mali last week a monster in the throes of death sent a squad of victims ahead to await his ghost. 
 At the orders of Moussa Traor&eacute;, who was a lieutenant when he took over Mali's government in 1968, soldiers fired on rioting crowds. 
 The army said that, in three days, it had killed 27 people; diplomats said that well over 100 had died, and that was just in the capital, Bamako. 
 The army decided enough was enough: the generals arrested Mr Traor&eacute; and said they would move towards elections. 
 In Benin, meanwhile, another veteran dictator was showing that there is a better way out. 
 Mathieu K&eacute;r&eacute;kou was a colonel when he took power in 1972 in what was then Dahomey. 
 He has ruled autocratically ever since, helped by handouts and guidance from France, and with French soldiers in the background. 
 His economic failure has been less forgivable than Mr Traor&eacute;'s: Benin is more fertile and has a better-educated population than Mali. 
 But in the manner of his going Mr K&eacute;r&eacute;kou wins hands down. 
 He organised a presidential election in the first round of which, on March 10th, he was beaten into second place by his prime minister, Nic&eacute;phore Soglo. 
 Neither man won an outright majority. 
 In the run-off poll on March 24th Mr Soglo won two-thirds of the vote, and will now become president. 
 Like so many of the men now rising to leadership in poor countries, he has done a stint at the World Bank, and is regarded as capable. 
 But even an angel would have trouble to better people's lives and calm the rivalry between the peoples of the south (where Mr Soglo comes from) and the Muslims of the dry north (Mr K&eacute;r&eacute;kou's people). 
 France did its bit for Mali's transition. 
 French businessmen no longer lobby for special privileges in African ex-colonies now almost worthless as producers or customers. 
 French officials realise that the way they have subsidised Africans is the wrong one. 
 West African currencies, because of their rigid link to the French franc, are tied through the European Monetary System to the German mark, so have been heavily &mdash; and damagingly &mdash; upvalued against the American dollar. 
 Above all, France's rulers acknowledge the folly of propping up incompetent dictators. 
 Last June President Fran&ccedil;ois Mitterrand told the assembled autocrats of French-speaking Africa that their countries should become more democratic. 
 Some, including Mr K&eacute;r&eacute;kou, acted on that. 
 The rulers of Chad, Togo and Mali boldly disagreed; so did the Americans' friend, King Hassan of Morocco. 
 In Mali Mr Mitterrand's injunction was greeted with joy by the educated: the lawyers, teachers and civil servants fed up with Mr Traor&eacute;'s arbitrary and impoverishing misrule. 
 He merely tightened the screws. 
 The result was mass disorder, attacks by masterless mobs on anything that stood for authority or wealth, and the army's brutal reaction. 
 With luck, Africa's anti-democrats will learn the lesson of his fall, and choose Benin's better way.  
 South Africa 
 In play again 
 FROM OUR SOUTH AFRICA CORRESPONDENT 
 AN HONOURABLE return to international sport is within South Africa's reach. 
 The country's athletes have been excluded from the Olympic Games since 1960, because of apartheid. 
 The organisers of other international sports followed the Olympic lead. 
 Thanks in part to the sportsmen's pressure, much has changed in South Africa. 
 A committee of the International Olympics Committee (IOC) has been to see if the changes qualify the country for readmission. 
 On March 25th it met President F.W. de Klerk, who promised that racially discriminatory laws would be off the statute book by the end of June. 
 The IOC's director-general, Fran&ccedil;ois Carrard, praised the president. 
 The first condition for South Africa's return to the Olympics was that apartheid laws should be eradicated; it looks as though that will be met. 
 The Olympic officials also require integration between South Africa's quarrelsome and sometimes racially based sporting administrative bodies, and the assent of the Association of National Olympic Committees of Africa. 
 That body's president has welcomed the formation of the National Olympic Committee of South Africa (NOCSA), representing all sorts of rival sporting associations, whose chairman, Sam Ramsamy &mdash; a veteran campaigner for the sports boycott &mdash; now wants to get South Africans back into international competition. 
 NOCSA has to hold its fractious members together, and sustain the boycott until the apartheid laws are gone. 
 One of its constituents, the Confederation of South African Sport, dominated by whites, sometimes threatens to break the boycott by hiring foreign celebrities for local tours. 
 On the field, the racial barriers are coming down. 
 Soccer, followed passionately by blacks, is regulated by a single football association. 
 Athletics is not far behind. 
 The two controlling bodies for cricket are on the point of unifying. 
 Even in rugby, the Afrikaners' passion, the formation of a single non-racial administrative body is imminent; the octogenarian rugby boss, Danie Craven, has long thought it a game for robust men of all races, and in 1988 angered Mr de Klerk by sending an emissary to contact, among others, the African National Congress &mdash; one of whose leaders is now working to dismantle the boycott. 
 Amid the ironies, black South Africans remember that the Olympic boycott began in horrified reaction to the massacre of March 1960, in Sharpeville, when the police shot 69 unarmed black people dead and wounded many more. 
 On March 24th, in the township of Daveyton, the police shot at least 12 black people dead. 
 In a separate episode on March 26th at least 15 people died in intra-black fighting.  
 Colombia 
 Cooling it 
 FROM A CORRESPONDENT IN BOGOTA 
 POLITICS in Colombia has long been violent but boring. 
 Liberals and Conservatives fought over and then shared power, serving in each other's governments. 
 Opponents of the two great parties were either forced into, or chose, the mountains and jungles as guerrillas. 
 In recent months an open, multi-party system has begun to emerge. 
 Violence continues, from left-wing guerrillas, right-wing &bquo;social cleansing&equo; squads who murder even children, and from cocaine gangsters. 
 But politics has come alive. 
 South America's most rigid political system is heading for a stirring, if risky, conflict of powers. 
 The issue is a seemingly dull one &mdash; constitutional reform. 
 But the winner should be democracy and, perhaps, eventually, peace. 
 In December Colombians elected a constituent assembly charged with rewriting the 1986 constitution. 
 After 15 years in which a corrupt and self-serving Congress had failed to reform either itself or the constitution, the assembly's job is to give the country modern democratic institutions that encourage greater voting participation. 
 Many people, starting with President Cesar Gaviria, a Liberal, see this as vital to persuade Colombians that change can come through votes rather than bullets. 
 The assembly itself is proof of this. 
 Its 70 members have been elected under new, fairer rules. 
 The result is that no party has a majority. 
 Liberals and Conservatives are balanced by M-19 (a former guerrilla movement that is evolving into a social democratic coalition), and by the National Salvation Movement, a dissident Conservative group. 
 Minority representatives, including two Indians, have seven seats; three other guerrilla movements have been given seats in return for disarming. 
 Pessimists see this fragmentation as a recipe for disaster, particularly since the Supreme Court ruled that the assembly is sovereign and can decide what it likes. 
 President Gaviria has found that he wields little power even over the 24 members from his balkanised Liberal Party. 
 Earlier this month they decided to give their &bquo;full support&equo; to the government's own constitutional blueprint, while &bquo;preserving ideological independence&equo;. 
 What that meant became clear when Horacio Serpa, the Liberal who is one of the assembly's three co-chairmen, came up with 15 constitutional drafts of his own. 
 Mr Gaviria has sensibly decided to operate at arm's length, seeking influence through private meetings with all sides. 
 He appears content to be the father, rather than the designer, of the new constitution. 
 The assembly divided itself into five committees and 26 sub-committees to dissect the 131 draft proposals it has received. 
 But though there is plenty of scope for debate over the details, such as whether God should appear in the preamble, there is consensus on many bigger points. 
 Congress will be reformed, abolishing its patronage and powers to vote under-the-table payments to its members. 
 New electoral rules will mean that at least part of Congress will be chosen by voters from all over the country, undermining the power of regional party bosses. 
 There will be stricter limits on the state-of-siege powers that have been used by all governments for the past 40 years. 
 Changes in the system of justice are likely to be introduced in cases involving organised crime, to speed trials and strengthen Colombia's impotent courts. 
 To entrench these reforms, a majority in the assembly wants to dissolve Congress and call fresh elections. 
 The left-wingers of M-19, with (by coincidence) 19 assembly seats, have a particular interest in this. 
 Elected last March only days after M-19 laid down its arms, the 312 members of Congress include just one representative of the movement. 
 By contrast, the Liberals are not amused. 
 They won 61% of the vote for Congress in March, but only 27% in December (when far fewer people turned out to vote for the assembly). 
 Liberal leaders last week accused the assemblymen of plotting a coup d'&eacute;tat of &bquo;unforeseeable consequences&equo;. 
 &bquo;A dog that barks doesn't bite,&equo; replied Antonio Navarro, the leader of M-19. 
 He is confident that the government and the army will accept what the assembly decides. 
 This is likely to include a constitutional ban on the extradition of cocaine traffickers &mdash; the issue at the heart of Colombia's domestic drugs war. 
 An attempt to include such a ban sank the last effort at constitutional reform, made by Congress in 1989. 
 This time the government has little choice but to accept. 
 Mr Gaviria is personally popular, and his own job is not questioned by the assembly. 
 The only victors in a head-on clash between president and assembly would be the hardliners on both sides &mdash; the dinosaurs in Congress, and the two largest guerrilla groups, the FARC and the ELN. 
 They have exposed the army's weaknesses with a three-month campaign of economic sabotage, and show little interest in a government offer of talks that might allow them to join the assembly. 
 Public opinion in Colombia is overwhelmingly hostile to extradition. 
 Mr Gaviria is trying to do without it anyway. 
 He wants cocaine traffickers tried in Colombia, by strengthened courts. 
 In January five &bquo;faceless&equo; courts with 82 selected judges were set up. 
 They will try cases on paper, anonymously, to stop intimidation. 
 At the same time the government has offered reduced sentences and a promise not to extradite traffickers who surrender and confess. 
 This has coaxed the three Ochoa brothers, who run a blue-chip Medellin cocaine business, to give themselves up. 
 But the man the government wants most, Pablo Escobar, is still on the run, holding two prominent journalists hostage. 
 He seems to want the policemen who are pursuing him sacked (for &bquo;human-rights violations&equo; against his hired killers), and a cast-iron pardon from the assembly. 
 That might give Mr Gaviria real problems.  
 Palestinians in Kuwait 
 Revenge is blind 
 FROM A CORRESPONDENT IN KUWAIT CITY 
 KUWAIT will not be at peace until Saddam Hussein is removed,&equo; says a Kuwaiti army lieutenant. 
 There is shooting almost daily in the capital as roaming snipers attack military checkpoints; small-arms fire only, say the authorities. 
 But a car bomb is reported to have gone off in the Palestinian quarter of the city and a police station has been blown up (the interior ministry says by an accidental explosion). 
 The Palestinians are blamed, plus any Iraqi soldiers who may still be lurking around the place. 
 Also blamed are other Arabs &mdash; Lebanese, Sudanese, Yemenis and Jordanians &mdash; who were brought in by the Iraqis to help police Kuwait. 
 Such recriminations are fatal in a place where more than half the residents are not Kuwaiti. 
 The disorder is made worse by antagonism between the Kuwaitis who stayed and those who left. 
 The Kuwaitis who stayed, and claim to have resisted the Iraqi occupation, are growing impatient with the soldiers who waited in Saudi Arabia until the American-led offensive recaptured their country. 
 Some of them feel they have been by-passed in the new security structure that is being set up with American advice; American officers are present at most police briefings. 
 But the resistance people, allowed to keep the arms they took from the Iraqis, have their own network in the police and the army. 
 House-to-house searches have ceased, at least for the moment, but the arrests continue. 
 Last week some 20 Iraqi soldiers and Palestinians were rounded up. 
 There have been reports of torture. 
 Some, but only some, members of the resistance distinguish between the Palestinians who were brought in by the Iraqis to do a bit of their dirty work, and Kuwait's large and long-established Palestinian population. 
 Some Palestinians worked with the resistance; one woman was tortured and killed for luring Iraqi officers into places where hit-teams could attack them. 
 Others are ready to say that they were better off when Kuwait was Iraq's 19th province. 
 A widow with two children points out that the Iraqis doubled her welfare cheque; now it has stopped altogether. 
 For a time after liberation the Palestinians got no food or fuel rations. 
 There is still talk of a mass expulsion of Palestinians. 
 The martial-law administrator, Crown Prince Saad, says that nobody will be expelled unless he or she is known to have collaborated with the Iraqis. 
 On one Kuwaiti count there were 20,000 collaborators.  
 Give a little, take a lot 
 FROM OUR NEW YORK CORRESPONDENT 
 IRAQ'S ambassador to the United Nations has said that his country is ready to return the &dollar;1 billion in gold and currency it looted from Kuwait. 
 But there is no word that Saddam Hussein is ready to return to his own people the &dollar;10 billion he is accused of looting from them by skimming Iraq's oil revenue for the past ten years and taking kickbacks from foreign contractors. 
 The allegations of personal profiteering by Mr Hussein and his family arose from a Kuwaiti-commissioned investigation into Iraq's assets by Kroll Associates, a New York firm of financial gumshoes. 
 The Kuwaitis wanted to know if Iraq had assets that had escaped the freeze imposed in August. 
 Kroll said that it had detected &dollar;2.4 billion in Iraqi-controlled deposits at some 50 banks. 
 These deposits, made by various people and companies, were under the control of the Hussein family; Saddam's half-brother, Barzan, is said to have run the operation. 
 The Kroll investigation also found that over the past ten years some &dollar;10 billion had either been salted away in banks or used to buy shares of western companies. 
 Kroll estimates that shareholdings controlled by Mr Hussein are worth at least &dollar;1 billion: not bad for one man's retirement savings. 
 The money came from skimming 5% of the &dollar;200 billion Iraq earned from its oil since 1981, from taking a 2.5% kickback from contracts with Japanese companies, and from working a scam on letters of credit with other foreign contractors. 
 The largest Saddam-controlled holding is allegedly the 8.4% stake held by Montana Management in Hachette, a French publishing firm. 
 Mr Hussein is also said to have an indirect stake in Matra, a French arms company (which is also a shareholder in Hachette), and in Germany's Daimler-Benz. 
 Hachette says that Montana was a passive minority investor about which it knew no more than it had been told by Montana's Swiss lawyer: that it represented investors from several Gulf countries. 
 Montana is a Panama-based holding company with Iraqi directors. 
 Iraq's shareholdings in America seem to have been restricted to a machine-tool firm in Ohio and an engineering consultancy in California. 
 Both companies are thought by western intelligence to be part of Iraq's international arms-procurement network and both have links with Anees Wadi, a suspected Iraqi agent who was expelled from Britain last year. 
 If confirmed, these revelations make a bit of a mockery of the financial sanctions imposed on Iraq in August. 
 At the time it was insisted that virtually all Iraqi and Kuwaiti money in the West had been identified and frozen. 
 But billions of dollars seem to have eluded the financial dragnet. 
 This raises troubling questions. 
 Western efforts to keep criminal money out of the banking system are based on the premise that banks can identify their customers, even when they act through nominees. 
 If Mr Hussein slipped by, so can others.  
 Turkey and the Kurds 
 Trying to please 
 FROM OUR TURKEY CORRESPONDENT 
 OZAL'S magnanimity has shamed us.&equo; 
 Words of praise for Turkey's president do not come easily from the guerrilla warriors of the Kurdish Workers' Party (PKK). 
 But their leader, Abdullah Ocalan, is now transmitting messages from PKK headquarters &mdash; no longer a camp in the Syrian Bekaa Valley but an apartment in a Damascus suburb &mdash; that are not dissimilar from those coming from ministries in Ankara. 
 What is Turgut Ozal up to? 
 Until lately, Turkey's worst fear was thought to be a vacuum in northern Iraq, leaving room for an autonomous Kurdish entity &mdash; which, in its turn, would be a beacon for the separatist movement on Turkish soil. 
 American officials assured Turkey during the Gulf war that the United States would not even contact the Kurdish opposition in Iraq. 
 After the war was over, Mr Ozal let it be known that Turkey itself had held talks with Iraqi Kurds, including Jalal Talabani, the leader of the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan and a critic of Mr Ocalan's extremism. 
 Mr Talabani is said to have reassured his hosts that autonomy was the limit of his ambitions. 
 He seems to have been told that, though Turkey remained opposed to an independent state in northern Iraq, it supported some restoration of Kurdish rights. 
 The trouble is that the country where the Kurds have fewest rights is Turkey. 
 To counter this, Mr Ozal is pressing for a modest change that would allow Turkey's Kurds the right to speak their own language. 
 His parliamentary supporters have reacted with an inventive set of procedural obstructions, but Mr Ozal continues to press for further constitutional amendments &mdash; one of whose side-effects would be to allow publications and possibly broadcasting in Kurdish. 
 Even the opposition, whose platform Mr Ozal appears to have mounted, accuses him of recklessness. 
 Mr Ozal may now be rivalling the PKK (as violent in its tactics as are the soldiers sent to crush it) for popularity among the 12m Turks who claim some ethnic Kurdish connection. 
 Only a fraction of these Kurds have any confidence in an independent Kurdish state, but Turkey has previously denied them even cultural freedom. 
 Mr Ozal may believe that an established Kurdish group in northern Iraq might help to control the more radical PKK. 
 This would be more convincing if some deal could be struck with Syria, which gives the PKK money, arms and sanctuary. 
 In Washington this week Mr Ozal made it clear that he does not want either a Kurdish state or a divided Iraq. 
 The public softening of Turkey's attitude towards the Kurds may, in the end, be less a change in policy than recognition of the difficulties in controlling what happens across the border in northern Iraq. 
 Turkey has neither cause, nor sufficient lack of sense, to want to become militarily involved. 
 But it can at least hope it will not be handicapped by its inability to control events on its own side of the frontier.  
 One more try 
 FROM A CORRESPONDENT IN ARBIL 
 THE rumble of gunfire echoes across emerald hills. 
 Helicopter gunships can be seen attacking Kurdish positions near Mosul to the west. 
 The Iraqi army is trying to crush the rebellion. 
 But in Arbil, in the heart of rebel-held territory, the Kurdish guerrillas exude confidence. 
 Every northern town, they say, is under their control except Mosul, which they claim to have surrounded. 
 They have pushed south to within 100 miles of Baghdad, and talk optimistically of marching on the capital. 
 Masoud Barzani, the leader of the Kurdish Democratic Party, claims, against the evidence, that if his men took Mosul the road to Baghdad would be wide open. 
 The rebels say they have captured 30,000 of the government's men. 
 Two small groups of captives were shown to reporters in Zakho and Dahuk. 
 Some said they were glad to be out of the fighting: &bquo;We are not prisoners, we are guests,&equo; in the words of one. 
 In Zakho a peshmerga commander paraded defectors, mostly Kurds. 
 One, who said he was an intelligence officer in the Republican Guard, volunteered that &bquo;many people have tried to kill Saddam.&equo; 
 The peshmerga have dealt harshly with some supporters of the regime. 
 In a village near Dahuk they executed 17 Baath Party officials. 
 This ruthlessness may be foolish, discouraging officials and army officers from defecting. 
 Most of the guerrillas seem to have joined the rebellion during the past three weeks. 
 Men aged 60 are fighting alongside young boys. 
 They are not short of weapons and ammunition. 
 They have Soviet-made rifles, mortars and rocket-propelled grenades, and they have captured tanks, guns and armoured personnel carriers from the Iraqi army &mdash; though how many of these are usable, and how many of the Kurds can drive them, is not clear. 
 Mr Barzani says the fall of Saddam Hussein is merely a matter of time. 
 But Mr Hussein is far from giving up, and the Kurds, his victims in the past, may become victims again.  
 United Nations 
 Peacefire 
 THE five permanent members of the Security Council have approved a draft resolution for a ceasefire in the Gulf War that defines a victor's peace. 
 It calls on Iraq to accept the 1963 border with Kuwait and threatens it with &bquo;all necessary means&equo; &mdash; diplomatic jargon for war &mdash; if this is breached. 
 The Americans kept the United Nations at arm's length during the fighting of the war. 
 Now, it seems, UN observers will police the border. 
 This will not be all the UN is called on to do. 
 The resolution demands the destruction of Iraq's chemical and biological weapons, and the handing over of weapons-grade nuclear material to the International Energy Agency. 
 The UN is also being asked to garner Iraq's oil revenues and use a portion to pay compensation for the damage done during the occupation of Kuwait and the war that followed. 
 Setting up a mechanism for this would fall to the secretary-general. 
 Unenthusiastic about the entire Gulf episode, he is not thrilled at this unprecedented task but he must obey the Security Council. 
 To earn money that would then be taken away to pay reparations, Iraq must be allowed to export oil. 
 Once it agrees to the other two bits of the resolution, the sanctions committee (which has overseen the embargo since August) would lift the export ban. 
 The ban on imports would remain. 
 The French among others worried about who would be paid first, Iraq's pre-war creditors or those damaged by the war. 
 A way round has been suggested: oil sales would pay pre-war creditors; Iraq's frozen assets would compensate for war damage. 
 Iraqis meanwhile suffer. 
 At the request of a UN under-secretary-general, Martti Ahtisaari, who had just visited Iraq, the sanctions committee decided last week to let Iraq buy food for hungry people and generators to work sewage plants. 
 Under the resolution, the sanctions committee would review matters every two months and let Iraq import more if &bquo;humanitarian&equo; need required. 
 Iraq would pay for this from oil earnings after reparations were paid. 
 Some non-permanent members of the Council complain that imposing a punitive peace should not be the job of the UN. 
 But the expectation is that the resolution will pass, more or less as drafted.  
 Oil pollution 
 Local troubles 
 BLAZING oil wells and a huge oil slick are emblems of the destruction that is a part of war. 
 Yet, for all the suffering they will cause in Kuwait &mdash; killing people as well as thousands of animals &mdash; such pollution is not a catastrophe on a planetary scale, as some had predicted. 
 Mercifully, the Asian monsoon, and most of the marine life of the Gulf, are expected to emerge unscathed. 
 According to Kuwait's oil industry, up to 6m barrels of oil are burning every day, four times the country's pre-war production. 
 About 650 wells are on fire. 
 Many of those in the neutral zone between Saudi Arabia and Kuwait (where the oil pressure is low) have already burnt out, others will soon do so. 
 The 500 wells in Kuwait's northern fields would burn indefinitely, but for the efforts of the fire fighters, who will shortly begin the task, lasting one or two years, of extinguishing them. 
 The plume of smoke from these fires now covers about 15,000 square kilometres (5,800 square miles) and has drifted as far as Iran. 
 Near the burning oil fields its effects are marked: the temperature has fallen by 10&ndash;20 degreesC (18&ndash;36 degreesF), the light is only 1% of normal. 
 Although the soot is harmless, acid rain, unburnt hydrocarbons and diminished sunlight will affect plants and animals. 
 People living in Kuwait will be exposed to smog and pollution as severe as in any industrial town in the 1950s. 
 Those who used to live near the oil wells, in Ahmadi, will probably desert their houses. 
 But the contamination is local: beyond 200km (125 miles), its effects are negligible. 
 The plume of smoke is safely confined to the lower atmosphere, which means that it is soon mixed with fresh air and removed from the sky by rain. 
 If the smoke had climbed to the upper atmosphere, it could have remained airborne for months, travelling much farther and possibly affecting the world's weather patterns. 
 The computer model at Britain's Meteorological Office predicts that the fires' effect on this year's monsoon will probably not stand out against the monsoon's annual variations. 
 Although more oil is ablaze than was first thought, there is less oil at sea. 
 Recent estimates of the size of the slick put it at 2.5m-3m barrels of oil, not the 7m-barrel monster that had been feared. 
 According to the Cambridge-based World Conservation Monitoring Centre, almost all of this oil has already been washed ashore or is in the shallows along 200km of Saudi coast; it has not moved down to the southern Gulf, where most of the turtles and dugongs live. 
 Even so, 10,000&ndash;20,000 birds have perished.  
 Latin American integration 
 Getting together 
 BRIGHT economic schemes have a habit of not working in South America. 
 Begun in the 1960s, a Latin American Free Trade Association and a Central American Common Market petered out. 
 Undeterred, the presidents of Argentina, Brazil, Paraguay and Uruguay are trying again. 
 On March 26th in Asuncion, the Paraguayan capital, they signed up for a four-nation Southern Cone Common Market by the end of 1994. 
 The geography is right. 
 The idea might even work. 
 The plan is to create a market of 190m people, accounting for more than half the GDP of Latin America and the Caribbean. 
 If it works, it will attract foreign investment. 
 There will be economies of scale. 
 Competition will help to keep inflation down. 
 Export-led growth will &mdash; if it works &mdash; be boosted by a tariff-cutting programme due to start in June; after Brazil and Argentina began gingerly reducing their tariffs in 1987, trade between them increased from &dollar;1.35 billion that year to &dollar;2 billion in 1990. 
 The new scheme provides that, by December 31st 1994, the four countries are to share a common external tariff, with free movement of goods and services among themselves. 
 This is a race; in Europe it will have taken 35 years from the signing of the Treaty of Rome to attain the European Community's planned single market in 1992. 
 Barring coups, the four Southern Cone presidents will all still be in office in 1994, and have set themselves a target that is also a spur. 
 The biggest difference between their economies, and the hardest to even out, is inflation. 
 Brazil's rate last year was 1,800%, Argentina's 1,344%, Uruguay's 129% and Paraguay's about 40%. 
 Co-ordination of economic policies is far away. 
 Argentina is moving faster than Brazil in removing barriers to trade and investment. 
 Uruguay's economy is fairly open. 
 Paraguay's is open wide, with smuggling its biggest earner, so people have much to lose if the incentive to smuggle is reduced by tariff reductions. 
 But all four presidents are committed to cutting fiscal deficits, privatisation and policies dear to the IMF. 
 Fernando Collor of Brazil, who went off the rails last month by ordering a doomed price freeze, still proclaims himself a free-marketeer. 
 Carlos Menem of Argentina is hell-bent on freeing trade. 
 Andres Rodriguez of Paraguay has signed up with the IMF. 
 Luis Lacalle of Uruguay, tenaciously liberal, dreams of making his small country the region's Switzerland. 
 The United States administration is closely watching the response to President Bush's call for tariff freedom throughout the Americas. 
 Carla Hills, his trade representative, who knows an export market when she sees one, is negotiating the framework for a free-trade agreement with the four, who together may be strong enough to strike a tough bargain.  
 The Maghreb 
 Whatever he did, they love him 
 FROM A CORRESPONDENT IN RABAT AND TUNIS 
 MILLIONS of Tunisians, Algerians and Moroccans first heard the news of Iraq's defeat from foreign radio stations. 
 It surprised most of them. 
 They had preferred to believe their own state-controlled media, which had predicted an Iraqi victory. 
 They had been swift to support Saddam Hussein. 
 Some believed his claim that the invasion of Kuwait was the first step towards the liberation of Palestine, and/or a blow in favour of the Arab poor (of which the Maghreb has its share). 
 Others applauded him for standing up to America. 
 Now that the truth of Iraq's defeat is sinking in, and their former hero is seen to have feet of clay, some Maghrebis are turning their frustration not against him but against the West. 
 Angry students have burnt the Stars and Stripes, the Tricolor and the Union Jack on the streets of Algiers. 
 They see the war as an unequal contest between a 30-nation coalition and a lone Arab country, the purpose of which was to destroy the only Arab state capable of standing up to Israel. 
 Others ask why the West responded to Iraq's invasion of Kuwait while failing to do anything about Israel's occupation of Arab land. 
 Some reserve a special anger for France, the Maghreb's former colonial power, because of what they see as a betrayal of its politique Arabe. 
 Distant though it is from the Gulf, the Maghreb has been deeply affected by the war. 
 The governments in Tunis, Algiers and Rabat fear that new frustrations will inflame their countries' economic problems. 
 All three countries were already in a deep recession last summer, which the war has made worse. 
 Officials fear that opposition groups, especially Islamic fundamentalists, will exploit the crisis to increase their influence and, indeed, several opposition leaders have quickly realised that political capital can be made by following the public mood. 
 In Algeria the main Islamic party, the Islamic Salvation Front, FIS, smoothly switched support from Saudi Arabia (a generous benefactor) to Iraq. 
 The FIS, which won most votes in the local elections in June 1990, hopes to profit later this year when some 40 parties take part in the country's (and the Arab world's) first fully democratic parliamentary election. 
 If the fundamentalist factions drop their differences to form a coalition, they could sweep the board: a prospect dreaded by many Algerians who do not want to emerge from long years of joyless socialism only to face even more joyless Islamic militancy. 
 King Hassan of Morocco repaid old debts to the Gulf states by sending 1,500 troops to defend Saudi Arabia. 
 But the opposition parties demanded their return, and the king had to promise that they would not be used except defensively, not even to eject Iraq from Kuwait. 
 The tensions generated by the Gulf war have not caused as much unrest as December's strikes and riots. 
 But there could be more trouble if the king does not open up the political system or do something about the great disparities of wealth. 
 In Tunisia, in many ways the most developed and westernised of the North African countries, the government itself took a pro-Iraqi line. 
 It is therefore losing American aid and, probably, Saudi subsidies. 
 President Ben Ali has called for austerity. 
 But the Tunisian opposition has not fared well, either. 
 The main (though illegal) Islamic party has been split by the Gulf war. 
 Its exiled leader, Rachid Ghannouchi, came out strongly in favour of Iraq, and some of its more extreme members attacked the offices of the ruling Democratic Constitutional Rally. 
 But its three top officials inside Tunisia, including its deputy leader, Abdelfattah Mourou, who has close links with Saudi Arabia, condemned the Iraqi invasion of Kuwait. 
 The government jailed 100 or so of the party's leading members on charges ranging from graffiti-writing to incitement of violence. 
 Mr Mourou, whose efforts to reassure Tunisians of his party's moderate aims have earned him the nickname &bquo;Mr Valium&equo;, has now suspended the party's operations. 
 That may lead to a new, quieter Islamic party under his leadership.  
 The Kurds' bid for freedom 
 SADDAM HUSSEIN'S defeat has given Iraq's Kurds an unprecedented chance to win the autonomy &mdash; or independence &mdash; they have long sought. 
 The Iraqi army is demoralised; Iran is ready to be helpful; Turkey is less unfriendly than in the past. 
 In the first few days of the revolt the Kurds' peshmerga guerrillas ousted the army, secret police and Baath Party &mdash; the three pillars of Mr Hussein's regime &mdash; from most of Iraqi Kurdistan, including the oil city of Kirkuk. 
 Thousands of members of the jash, the pro-government Kurdish militia, swapped sides. 
 The rebels captured the headquarters of Iraq's 1st and 5th Army Corps &mdash; getting hold of heavy armour they had never before had. 
 How long can they keep this up? 
 The civil war could well swing the other way now that Mr Hussein, having crushed the rising in the Shia south, is unleashing the full force of his Republican Guards upon the Kurds. 
 The Kurds are still in with a chance. 
 But their best opportunity for independence came, and went, soon after the first world war, when Britain and France were carving up the defunct Ottoman empire. 
 At first the allies decided that the Kurds and the Armenians should be given states of their own in what is now eastern Turkey. 
 The 1920 Treaty of S&egrave;vres provided for this, and for the Kurdish vilayets, or provinces, of Kirkuk and Mosul to join &bquo;Kurdistan&equo;, if they wanted to. 
 But S&egrave;vres was rejected by the Turkish nationalist leader, Kemal Ataturk, and was superseded by the 1923 Treaty of Lausanne. 
 Plans for a Kurdish state vanished. 
 The vilayets of Mosul and Kirkuk were annexed, together with their oil wealth, by Britain in 1925 to the newly-created Arab state of Iraq. 
 For the Kurds this was a tragedy. 
 Before the war they were split between two empires: Ottoman and Persian After 1925 they were split between four states: Turkey, Iran, Iraq and Syria (there are also a few Kurds in the Soviet Union). 
 They may be the fourth largest national group in the Middle East, after the Arabs, Persians and Turks, but their hope of an independent Kurdistan appears to have vanished. 
 At best, Kurds are discriminated against; at worst, repressed. 
 In Turkey they are not officially recognised as a distinct ethnic group but called &bquo;mountain Turks&equo; (see story on next page). 
 In Iran they have cultural rights, but their attempt to win autonomy after the 1979 revolution was crushed by Iran's Revolutionary Guards. 
 In Iraq the government failed to deliver the autonomy it promised in 1970, and punished the Kurds after their rebellions in 1974&ndash;75 and 1986&ndash;88 with executions, mass deportations and the demolition of thousands of villages. 
 The Kurds' efforts to improve their lot have been blocked by their own tribal and ideological divisions, and by international indifference to their cause. 
 They have gone some way to healing their internal rifts. 
 Iraq's half-dozen Kurdish parties stopped fighting each other in 1987 to form the Kurdistan Democratic Front, committed to democracy for Iraq and autonomy for Kurdistan. 
 Only the PKK in Turkey still demands independence. 
 Now, in northern Iraq, the Kurds' worst fear is that history may repeat itself. 
 EUROPE 
 Those who live in the grey area look for a gleam in the west 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN WARSAW, PRAGUE AND BUDAPEST 
 ONE advantage for small countries in large empires is that they do not have to think up a defence policy: their armies do what they are told. 
 Now that Czechoslovakia, Hungary and Poland have their independence back, they must look after their security for themselves. 
 After 40-odd years of dependence, the change is daunting. 
 Since dropping communism, they have gone through three stages in thinking about security. 
 First, people humming Beethoven's ninth symphony looked forward to peace and joy as Soviet soldiers withdrew and democracy took root. 
 This happy mood lasted roughly until last autumn. 
 As heads cleared, it was seen that dangers remained: a potential flood of refugees from the Soviet Union or the Balkans, the internal tensions of poverty and ethnic division, the giant still next door. 
 By January, Soviet troops had cracked down in Lithuania, Soviet troop withdrawals from central Europe had ominously stopped. 
 This unnerved the three countries and confirmed their instinct to look westward. 
 But their economies are too backward for membership of the European Community. 
 Neither are their armies about to join NATO. 
 Their Soviet-made weapons do not fit with the West's. 
 More to the point, the West thinks that pushing NATO's frontier to the Soviet border would, at the moment, help just the wrong people in Moscow. 
 Nerves have since steadied. 
 Not content with the military winding-up of the Warsaw Pact this month, Poland, Czechoslovakia and Hungary now want its political skeleton to be dismantled. 
 They would also like the old democracies to look upon their young ones with a more compassionate eye. 
 They do not expect security guarantees. 
 They will not wear their knuckles out knocking at the West's door, so long as they feel it will be opened to them before too long. 
 In the meantime, they are learning to live in what the Poles call a &bquo;grey area&equo;, the Czechoslovaks and Hungarians a &bquo;vacuum&equo;. 
 The first thing the three must do is disentangle themselves from the past. 
 This means bidding Soviet troops adieu, working out new treaties of good neighbourliness with the Soviet Union, and turning their own soldiers into national armies rather than Soviet appendages. 
 In Czechoslovakia the last Soviet tank moved out this week. 
 In Hungary the last combat units are due out on March 31st. 
 Support troops are to be out of both countries by the end of June. 
 The Poles wanted all Soviet troops out before 1992. 
 As the Soviet army in Germany has to cross Poland to get home (unless it goes by sea), the Poles have asked for compensation for the trouble this causes. 
 In reply, Soviet generals grumbled that Kutuzov's troops on their return from the Napoleonic wars did not have to pay for forage as they crossed what is now Poland; the Poles, they said, were showing scant gratitude for their liberation in 1945. 
 But tempers have cooled. 
 Poland's foreign minister, Krzysztof Skubiszewski, hopes that a deadline for final Soviet withdrawal can be fixed soon, and that big combat units will begin leaving this spring. 
 To speed their return, the Poles suggest their workmen might build housing for them at home &mdash; with German money. 
 The new treaties with the Soviet Union also pose problems. 
 At last, the three countries are negotiating as fully sovereign states. 
 Hungary's draft treaty is typical. 
 Each country promises not to threaten the other's interests. 
 Yet the Soviet Union is still trying to define Hungary's security interests by insisting that it must stay neutral, or something close to that, for the treaty's 20-year life. 
 As for &bquo;de-Sovietising&equo; their armed forces, the three are drawing up new tous-azimuths defence policies, which identify no single enemy. 
 Civilians are taking charge of the soldiers. 
 Hungary and Czechoslovakia already have civilian ministers, and Poland will soon. 
 Senior officers in all three countries have almost all been trained in the Soviet Union. 
 Except for those deeply discredited, few are being purged. 
 Change will be gradual. 
 But already there are contacts with western staff officers. 
 Hungarians have begun to train at Sandhurst, Britain's main officer-training college. 
 As cogs in the Soviet military machine, the three countries' armies used to sit mainly near their western borders. 
 Where cost permits, some units are now being shifted eastward. 
 All three countries would like smaller armies with better weapons, manned more by professionals and less by conscripts. 
 They all want to shop around for new western weapons, and are exploring joint-purchasing schemes to cut the cost. 
 But it is bound to be expensive, and defence budgets are being cut. 
 A half-recruit, half-volunteer army is years away, reckons the Hungarian defence minister, Lajos Fur. 
 By themselves, there is not much these countries could do to stop a determined assault by one of their big neighbours. 
 On the other hand they are too exposed to allow themselves the Costa Rican solution of doing without armies altogether. 
 Jiri Dienstbier, Czechoslovakia's foreign minister, thinks the purely military element in their security is small. 
 &bquo;Military doctrine?&equo; he asks with a laugh. 
 &bquo;It makes sense for the United States. 
 But for Czechoslovakia?&equo; 
 Yet he accepts that these countries need small, defensively equipped armies that could make a potential attacker think twice. 
 They want ties that link them more to each other &mdash; through mutual defence pacts &mdash; and to the West, if it can be done without infuriating the Soviet Union. 
 That includes ties to the European Community, the Council of Europe and one day perhaps even the Western European Union, if not NATO itself. 
 They all like the Conference on Security and Co-operation in Europe, while accepting its limitations. 
 They favour regional groups such as the Pentagonale (Austria, Czechoslovakia, Hungary, Italy and Yugoslavia), which Poland would like to make a hexagon. 
 Leaders of Poland, Czechoslovakia and Hungary met at Visegrad in Hungary on February 15th to promote co-operation on these issues. 
 Flimsy as each thread may seem, such a network, they hope, can start to bind the three peoples together, and link them to other European countries whose help might gradually reduce their sense of insecurity. 
 It could help to tie down east-central Europe's old western bugbear, Germany. 
 It could even be a restraint on a democratic Soviet Union, as President Havel of Czechoslovakia suggested at NATO last week. 
 Even a conservative restoration in the Soviet Union would not bring back communist rule to these countries, they believe. 
 But they keep Soviet might in mind, however remote the threat now seems. 
 With exuberant lack of tact, Mr Dienstbier says, &bquo;From NATO we want to know that, if we were threatened, we'd be treated at least as Kuwait, if necessary.&equo;  
 Soviet Union 
 Undermined 
 FROM OUR MOSCOW CORRESPONDENT 
 WE MUST stage a really hefty strike in order to get the system changed.&equo; 
 Thus a Soviet coal miner on his union's attempt to do what Solidarity did in Poland &mdash; bring the Communist government down. 
 A quarter of the country's coal miners have been on strike for three weeks demanding the resignation of President Mikhail Gorbachev, the dissolution of the Soviet parliament and the transfer of power to the Federation Council, composed of the elected leaders of the 15 republics. 
 So sweeping are these demands, however, that they might be met only if large numbers of other workers support them, or if the miners bring the Soviet economy to a halt. 
 Neither seems likely. 
 The coal strike alone will not cause the economic disaster that the Soviet government is pretending it will. 
 Coal is used for only three purposes: heating houses, generating electricity and making steel. 
 Of these, steel making has been worst hit. 
 Soviet steel mills need 346,000 tonnes of coking coal a day but are getting only 200,000. 
 Coke reserves are said to have dwindled to only 700,000 tonnes &mdash; two days' supply. 
 That might suggest impending disaster. 
 But few miners believe these figures (given by the metallurgy minister); if they were true, more than the 19 steel mills closed so far would have been affected. 
 Metal-making industries have undoubtedly been hit hard. 
 But coal accounts for only 19% of Soviet energy production. 
 So the strike, which has reduced total coal output by less than a third, will reduce all energy supplies by only 6%. 
 Damaging, but hardly economy-halting. 
 The miners have also failed to win the kind of support from other workers necessary to bring the government down. 
 True, railway workers in Moscow and air-traffic controllers have voiced support. 
 Russia's independent Union of Drivers has sent trucks to the coal fields to distribute the food donations that have poured in from all over the country. 
 But this is far from decisive. 
 Things may change after April 2nd, when retail prices are to rise by 60%, though most workers are too afraid of plunging the country into chaos to give the miners whole-hearted support by staging their own strikes. 
 Still, the strike is significant. 
 It has already lasted longer than the one two years ago, a tribute to the organisational powers of the independent miners' union, which unites the various strike committees that sprang up in 1989. 
 The union has managed to keep the strike going even though Siberian miners are pressing for political changes only, while miners in the Ukraine, where living conditions are particularly wretched, also want large wage rises. 
 When the Soviet parliament invoked emergency laws to postpone the strike for two months, the union refused to call it off &mdash; in effect, daring the government to end it by force. 
 The strike is also a vivid demonstration of the problems facing both Mr Gorbachev and Boris Yeltsin. 
 The Soviet president was able to end the strike of 1989 by posing as the miners' ally. 
 This time he is the target of their action, while the miners are repeating virtually word for word the demands Mr Yeltsin made in a television broadcast two weeks before the strike began. 
 But Mr Yeltsin himself has been unable to give the miners public support because their strike threatens Russia's stubborn attempts to plough its lonely furrow of economic reform. 
 Indeed, the only politician to emerge from the strike with his credibility strengthened has been the president of Kazakhstan, Nursultan Nazarbaev, who was able to persuade local miners to return to work, promising better conditions and his support for their demands.  
 Budapest 10, Warsaw 1 
 FROM OUR WARSAW CORRESPONDENT 
 BUDAPEST 
 WITH so many western companies, consultants, bankers, venture capitalists and others setting up offices there, Budapest's telephone directory cannot keep up. 
 A whole new service industry &mdash; office design &mdash; has sprung up in the city, and the demand for furniture, secretaries and commercial space has pushed up prices. 
 The rent of an office in central Budapest (&pound;42, or &dollar;75, per square foot per year, according to a recent survey*) is higher than in Vienna. 
 In Warsaw, meanwhile, office rents first rose in anticipation of a similar flood from the West and then fell when the westerners failed to appear. 
 Some furniture is available (IKEA, a Swedish firm, has opened up nearby) but the supply of English-speaking secretaries exceeds demand, so their salaries stay around &dollar;400 a month. 
 Westerners come and go, crowding into the Marriott, Warsaw's only top-class hotel, but few bother to set up shop. 
 So while Budapest feels like a gold-rush town, Warsaw remains sleepy. 
 Why? 
 Both countries have embarked on serious reform. 
 Hungary has some advantages for investors (reforms began earlier, laws are better, debt is being paid), but Poland, with 36m people to Hungary's 10m, offers a far bigger future market. 
 The answer, businessmen say, lies in the living conditions. 
 It is hard to pay people enough to get them to live in Warsaw. 
 Nazi soldiers burnt the city to the ground in 1944, and it had the bad luck to be rebuilt, for the most part, by tasteless Stalinists. 
 Public transport now barely exists, the streets are filled with pot-holes. 
 Winters are grey, summers are hazy with pollution and the telephones are getting worse not better. 
 Some have suggested that, to attract foreign investment to Poland, the country's capital should be moved to Cracow. 
 Budapest, by contrast, benefits from crumbling but attractive architecture, and has dozens of new expense-account-friendly restaurants that happily take credit cards. 
 The climate is Balkan rather than north European; springtime is lovely. 
 It is possible, more or less, to make a long-distance telephone call. 
 One businessman from Chicago, in Budapest for three years, describes his &bquo;unbelievable luck&equo; in landing a job there. 
 A western management consultancy reports that one of its employees has already defected to a Hungarian company. 
 Such are the whims of westerners. 
 But the results show in the statistics: more than &dollar;1 billion invested in Hungary last year, less than &dollar;100m in Poland. 
 Well-laid plans are all very well, but things beyond the control of economists or politicians can make one country's reform happen faster than another's.  
 Reforming Eastern Europe 
 Dismal science 
 FROM A SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN PRAGUE 
 NOT so long ago, Polish, Czechoslovak and Hungarian reformers met one another at secret border meeting points, carrying  sheaves  of hand-typed documents. 
 These days they meet at conferences like one this week in Prague, sponsored by the Institute for Policy Research and the Centre for Institutional Reform and the Informal Sector. 
 This one was more highbrow than most, bringing together economists from all over Eastern Europe and the West as well. 
 Astonishingly, they all more or less agreed on broad policy. 
 No one much disputes the idea that reform will have to involve deregulation, demonopolisation, a tight monetary policy and, above all, fast privatisation. 
 Anyone who so much as hints at a &bquo;third way&equo; between communism and capitalism is considered naive; there is simply no time to try more experiments. 
 The economists agree that reforms should happen as fast as they are technically possible, whether ordinary citizens want it that way or not. 
 But the economists differ on the details. 
 Arguments rage over privatisation. 
 The Czechoslovak voucher scheme, which will apportion shares in state enterprises to the general public, was received with scepticism by the Poles (who want to do the same thing a different way) and with disdain by the Hungarians (who think state enterprises should simply be sold). 
 Many disagree about the sequence of reforms. 
 The Hungarians have put privatisation and foreign-trade liberalisation before currency convertibility; the Poles have done it the other way round. 
 Western economists tend to talk at length about theory; the easterners are mainly interested in practice. 
 This division closely mirrors the one between &bquo;regional specialists&equo; and other economists, many of whom have marked the way from Latin America to Eastern Europe with a trail of academic papers. 
 The &bquo;regional specialists&equo; gently remind their colleagues about the non-economic factors which affect economic reform: hostility towards western investment, popular reactions to price rises, the difficulty of changing management behaviour overnight. 
 The economists even argue over what to call the region. 
 &bquo;Eastern Europe&equo; sounds as if it might include the unreforming Soviet Union. 
 &bquo;Central Europe&equo; is too vague and precious. 
 One suggestion was FSEs (formerly socialist economies) or a variant, HSEs (historically socialist economies). 
 ECE (East Central Europe) was proposed, along with EME (emerging market economies). 
 No one hit upon a neater, nobler solution: the fast-reforming economies of Europe, or the FREE.  
 The balance of European power 
 FROM OUR BRUSSELS CORRESPONDENT 
 HE last time that the European Community tried to create a &bquo;political union&equo;, 30 years ago, it all ended in tears. 
 General de Gaulle's plan foundered on Dutch fears that the new body would threaten Community institutions. 
 The same Franco-Dutch argument has become pivotal in the current inter-governmental conference on political union. 
 The 1985 Single European Act shifted the balance of power away from governments towards the European Commission. 
 More majority voting in the Council of Ministers made it harder for members to block laws; that strengthened the hand of the commission, which has the sole right to propose laws. 
 The European Parliament gained certain rights of amendment. 
 Now the balance is swinging back. 
 Jacques Delors, the commission's president, sees the commission's monopoly of initiative as the foundation of its power; it obliges the commission to lead. 
 But governments now believe that if they are to tackle new subjects at a European level they must tighten their control. 
 In foreign and security policy, and in interior-ministry collaboration, the commission will have no monopoly of proposal; nor will it have much say in carrying out policy. 
 For economic and monetary union (EMU), the commission is desperate to have the sole right of proposal in exchange-rate decisions and in policing macro-economic policy. 
 It will be humbled, and may even find that the EC monetary committee &mdash; which consists of mere central-bank and finance-ministry officials &mdash; will usurp its preparatory role for meetings of finance ministers. 
 The parliament faces a lowly consultative role in EMU and in foreign policy but will pick up new powers in normal EC business. 
 The European Council, the periodic summits of EC leaders, will be the real winner. 
 Most countries (including Germany and Britain) broadly back a French model that resembles the fa&ccedil;ade of a Greek temple. 
 The entablature, the European Council, straddles a series of pillars: the old EC, the new EMU, foreign and security policy, and interior-ministry co-operation. 
 The whole edifice will be known as the &bquo;European Union&equo; (a term to note if you want to shine at dinner parties). 
 The Treaty of Rome will cover only the EC; the other pillars will be governed by new treaties. 
 The European Council began to meet in 1974, at the prompting of France, which wanted the EC to have a guiding authority similar to the French presidency's. 
 The new treaties will define that role and extend it. 
 In foreign and security policy the European Council will, like the French presidency, decide as well as guide; it will have links with the Western European Union, a defence pact of nine Community members. 
 France would give the European Council a secretariat. 
 Only Holland bluntly opposes this French design. 
 The Dutch foreign minister, Hans Van den Broek, sees it as a step back to &bquo;inter-governmentalism&equo; &mdash; where the European Parliament does not count and where a weakened commission cannot stop little countries getting clobbered by big ones. 
 He also worries that any EC role in defence could weaken NATO. 
 The French sneer that, because Mr Van den Broek gets on badly with his prime minister, Ruud Lubbers, he cannot bear to see the summiteers running the show. 
 But Mr Van den Broek's concerns are based on deep-rooted principles that stretch back 30 years. 
 In February 1961 de Gaulle appointed a diplomat, Christian Fouchet, to chair a committee of EC governments on political union. 
 The &bquo;Fouchet plan&equo; that ensued called for a summit every four months; for foreign, defence and education ministers to meet regularly; and for a special secretariat. 
 In March 1962 the draft treaty was about to be signed by all six countries, when, at the last moment, de Gaulle changed the text. 
 Out went references to the Atlantic alliance and to &bquo;respect&equo; for the existing communities (economic, atomic, and coal and steel). 
 De Gaulle added economic policy to the goals of political union, which seemed to menace those communities. 
 Holland refused to sign, fearing that de Gaulle had a hidden agenda for the new body to rival NATO, to deter British entry, to undermine the communities and to enshrine their domination by France and Germany. 
 The Dutch were probably right, to judge from a handwritten note de Gaulle gave Chancellor Konrad Adenauer at that time: &bquo;The supernational organisms of the six, which tend inevitably and abusively to become irresponsible superstates, will be reformed, subordinated to governments and used for the normal tasks of the council and technical business.&equo; 
 Strains of that thinking can be seen today in France's wish that the commission and the parliament should not become too powerful. 
 But Gaullists and Thatcherites should not get too excited. 
 President Mitterrand does not see the European Council, as de Gaulle saw the Fouchet plan, as a means of stalling European integration. 
 France stresses that, because the European Council has the people with clout, it can propel the Community forwards &mdash; as in Brussels in 1988, when it settled budget rows, and in Rome last October, when it gave the conference on EMU a mandate. 
 The European Council already has a life of its own that can act against national interests. 
 It generally works by consensus, so a country can veto its conclusions. 
 But in practice, if most countries want to go ahead with something, they may well ignore a lone dissenter. 
 The Rome conclusions on EMU are now viewed as a quasi-treaty &mdash; although Britain never signed them. 
 Mr Delors should not lament too loudly. 
 Although the balance of power is shifting against the commission, in absolute terms it will gain power. 
 The EC will extend its sway and decide more by majority voting. 
 In the new domains such as foreign policy, the commission will for the first time have a right to propose. 
 And the president already has a seat at the future high table, the European Council.  
 The new design for NATO 
 FROM OUR SPECIAL CORRESPONDENT IN BRUSSELS 
 FOR two years NATO has been fretting about its new place in the world, if any, after the fading of the Soviet danger, if fade it does. 
 The alliance is now nearing a series of big decisions. 
 Work is progressing on a study that will affect the security policies of western countries for years to come. 
 France recently decided to take part in all of the study's three stages. 
 This will make agreement more difficult, but far more valuable when it comes. 
 NATO's permanent council is carrying out part one, on politics. 
 Part two, a study of a new strategy, is the responsibility of a group under Michael Legge, a Briton who serves as assistant secretary-general for policy and plans. 
 Part three, on new military arrangements, is the work of the military committee, the highest military body in the alliance. 
 At first it was hoped that the study could be ready this spring. 
 Now the goal is to complete it in time for an autumn summit. 
 In an ideal world the political framework and the broad strategy should have come first; then the military men would have designed a plan to fit them. 
 But the generals could not afford to wait, and started work well before they could get any useful political guidance. 
 They have been trying to design a new force structure that would both live within the expected budget cuts and be capable of responding effectively to all imaginable crises. 
 The large forces that most NATO countries fielded to guard the alliance against the Warsaw Pact provided enough flexibility to deal with most crises outside Europe, such as the Gulf war. 
 But, with sharply reduced forces, this flexibility will no longer come naturally. 
 It must be planned. 
 The details of NATO's new look are not yet settled, but the general shape is already clear. 
 In place of the &bquo;layer cake&equo; of eight allied army corps lined up along what used to be West Germany's eastern border, there will be maybe half as many. 
 Most will be farther back, although there may be some &bquo;guard formations&equo;, perhaps a German corps, well forward. 
 The one American corps (down from the two that were there before the Gulf war) and a couple of German ones will probably remain national formations. 
 But one or two others will be multinational corps made up of three of four national divisions. 
 Some units will be maintained at full strength; others will rely on large numbers of reserves. 
 At least one high-readiness multinational corps is expected to be a rapid-deployment force that could be sent from central Europe to keep the peace or do battle elsewhere. 
 The whole corps would not necessarily go. 
 Any of its elements could be sent as part of a package, shaped either to the military job that needed doing or to the political reality of which countries were willing to join in. 
 It could go as a joint European-American force, or as a purely European one. 
 All NATO members now broadly accept that the alliance will continue to be their main defence against a threat to Western Europe; that its integrated military command will still control any military operations there; and that its commander will continue to be an American. 
 This will help towards satisfying one of the main goals of the new strategy: to maintain American troops and interest in Europe. 
 But the study must also decide on NATO's attitude towards other sorts of troubles, known collectively (if a trifle inaccurately) as &bquo;out-of-area&equo; conflicts. 
 There are three main sorts to worry about: disturbances in Eastern Europe; attacks on NATO countries from outside the old Warsaw Pact area (say, an attack on Turkey by Iraq); and, knottiest of all, conflicts such as the Gulf war, which fall outside the NATO treaty. 
 Much will depend on the role France is prepared to play. 
 There is little possibility of France rejoining the alliance's integrated military command, which it left in 1966; that would be a French political retreat. 
 If France moves towards greater participation in NATO, it must come into something new. 
 So the search is on for an acceptable new arrangement for increased French involvement in the military affairs of the alliance. 
 Some sort of association of the Western European Union (WEU) with NATO now seems part of the answer. 
 One idea is to set up alternative decision-making processes for &bquo;out-of-area&equo; operations. 
 The allies could decide which of these to use in a given crisis. 
 For example, the nine-member WEU (perhaps with the other five European NATO members sitting as observers) could decide on the operation of a European Reaction Force, at least part of which might be drawn from forces committed to NATO. 
 But the NATO council would deal with any use of a purely NATO Reaction Force. 
 The trick is to find a way of giving the Europeans enough of a feeling that they can pursue security policies of their own without at the same time forming a European defence association that would drive the Americans away. 
 A tall order, but the price of failure could be the end of collective security for the West.  
 Italy 
 March hare 
 FROM OUR ROME CORRESPONDENT 
 WHEN Italy's President Francesco Cossiga was first elected in 1985, he compared his largely ceremonial job to that of an English monarch. 
 &bquo;My prerogatives&equo;, he said with a touch of pride, &bquo;are similar to those of the Queen of England.&equo; 
 Picture the public stupor were the queen to indulge in a 40-minute televised monologue, as Mr Cossiga did last week, in which she claimed the right to dissolve parliament, &bquo;even against parliament's will&equo;. 
 Is Italy's president, as L'Espresso suggested earlier this month, &bquo;out of control?&equo; 
 Mr Cossiga's televised remarks, in which he announced that he had no intention of accepting a cabinet reshuffle and might even call an early election, caused a political storm. 
 The prime minister, Giulio Andreotti, who was away at the time, was welcomed home on Monday March 25th by headlines announcing a showdown with Mr Cossiga. 
 By Tuesday it was all over. 
 After an hour-long meeting in the presidential palace, a hangdog Mr Cossiga announced that he and Mr Andreotti were in full agreement. 
 Mr Cossiga's televised outburst was the latest in a series of controversial incidents. 
 A year ago, having for the previous five years been one of the quietest incumbents of the Quirinale Palace, Mr Cossiga announced his intention &bquo;to shake a few pebbles out of my shoes&equo;. 
 In September he startled Italians by lashing out at one of Sicily's most popular fighters against the Mafia, Leoluca Orlando, an ex-mayor of Palermo, who was guilty in Mr Cossiga's mind of damaging the Christian Democratic Party. 
 (Mr Orlando soon left it in order to found a new movement of his own.) 
 Then the leaders of the Lombard League, a new party that raked in millions of votes from frustrated northern Italians in regional elections last year, were branded men of &bquo;criminal, foolish and shameful&equo; political design. 
 Earlier this month Mr Cossiga publicly hurled the epithet &bquo;son of a&hellip;&equo; at a British journalist who described Italy's military contribution to the Gulf war as a &bquo;token force&equo;. 
 Pleas in the press for more presidential self-control have only exacerbated an increasingly tormented Mr Cossiga, who seems to see plots on all sides. 
 He reacts strongly to any suggestion &mdash; and there have been several over recent months &mdash; that his emotional ups and downs are part of a manic-depressive syndrome. 
 Mr Cossiga is particularly sensitive on one score: his own part, as junior minister of defence, in setting up the secret counter-insurgency network known as Gladio. 
 Fearing that any investigation into this anti-communist network might be a prelude to his own eviction from the presidential palace, Mr Cossiga has tried to fight off all attempts to question him about Gladio. 
 The president is fond of repeating that the members of Gladio were &bquo;patriots&equo;. 
 His more startling assertion in a long television interview last week that some members of the banned P2 masonic lodge were also &bquo;patriots&equo; brought Mr Cossiga within a hair's breadth of provoking a constitutional crisis. 
 During an improvised press conference last Saturday he complained, in a highly emotional manner, of an overpowering sense of political isolation before going on to suggest he might force an early election. 
 Although Mr Cossiga has now backed down, it was his most serious mishap to date. 
 He has said he is determined to remain in office until his term expires in July 1992, but Mr Andreotti's wobbly five-party government may find it ever harder to coexist with such a tempestuous president. 
 Bettino Craxi, whose Socialist Party is Mr Andreotti's Christian Democratic Party's main partner in government, has already upped the stakes. 
 A mere reshuffle, he says, is not enough. 
 He wants a new government, possibly with constitutional reform at the top of its agenda &mdash; including a blueprint for a stronger presidency, a job Mr Craxi wants.  
 BRITAIN 
 Tough at the top 
 With opinion polls showing a Labour revival, John Major faced his roughest ride since becoming prime minister. 
 Commons debates on the budget, poll-tax changes and a no-confidence motion allowed Neil Kinnock, the Labour leader, to exploit Tory divisions and a gathering sense of public disillusionment with Mr Major's cabinet. 
 The prime minister's fourth-term vision failed to excite the party faithful at the Conservative Central Council meeting in Southport. 
 John Major juggled a pledge to privatise the rail and coal industries with plans for a citizens' charter to guarantee public services. 
 Nigel Lawson, a former chancellor, suggested that the government's indecision over the poll tax called into question its ability to govern. 
 The government was threatening to spawn a &bquo;son of poll tax&equo;, he said. 
 A furious John Major hit back by telling MPs that his government had done the things Mr Lawson had wanted but failed to do. 
 Clean breaks 
 Peter Brooke, the Northern Ireland secretary, told the Commons that formal Ulster talks could now go ahead between nationalists, Unionists and the British and Irish governments. 
 Mr Brooke said Sinn Fein, the political wing of the IRA, was debarred from participation by its support for violence. 
 The Labour Party unveiled plans for a women's ministry, which would have a seat in the cabinet. 
 The ministry's brief would be to &bquo;make sure women's voices are heard loud and clear in the very centre of power&equo;. 
 Unlike over the past 11 years, say. 
 The current-account deficit narrowed to &pound;192m (&dollar;377m) in February, thanks to falling imports and rising invisible exports. 
 Brace yourself and chuck them out, urged National Tie Week. 
 According to the Guild of British Tie Makers, men form &bquo;strong emotional bonds&equo; with their ties and hang on to them, hoping they will come back into fashion. 
 Financial matters 
 Two men who helped George Blake, a Soviet spy, to escape from prison in 1966 could become the first British authors in recent history to have royalties seized by the courts. 
 They have written a book about the escape, but now face trial. 
 A High Court judge said they would earn nothing from the book, if convicted. 
 Derek Hatton, Liverpool council's former deputy leader, was charged with conspiracy to defraud the city's ratepayers. 
 Police investigating council property deals raided the offices of Wimpey, a construction group. 
 Wimpey is challenging the removal of documents. 
 Women have been left behind in the struggle for pay equality, said a report by the Equal Opportunities Commission. 
 Their average earnings have stayed at two-thirds of men's for the past decade, with employers segregating the sexes in job grades, said the commission. 
 The &bquo;very seed corn&equo; of Britain's science base was being threatened by panic cash cuts forced on research councils, said a House of Lords committee report. 
 The government announced a pilot scheme to issue 45,000 training vouchers in 11 areas. 
 The vouchers will be worth &pound;1,000 or more, depending on the youngster's requirements. 
 They will be issued by Training and Enterprise Councils to school-leavers, who will present them to employers offering training or to training centres. 
 Cruel blows 
 The poor are getting poorer no matter what the government says, said a report from Bristol University. 
 The study claims that the real incomes of the poorest 20% of the population fell by an average of &pound;160 (&dollar;275) in 1979&ndash;89. 
 New crime figures for England and Wales confirmed 1990 as the worst year on record, with recorded crimes up 17% to more than 4m. 
 The biggest rise was in property-related crime, especially burglary and car-theft. 
 A march through central London to mark the anniversary of last year's poll-tax riot passed off peacefully. 
 Disappointed protesters complained that the government had reformed the tax just to spite them. 
 Rover's return 
 Living out of a suitcase away from home and family has become one of the main causes of stress among businessmen, concluded a survey by the Confederation of British Industry. 
 The Kennel Club launched a health-care plan to allow dog owners to get cheap hi-tech treatments like cancer therapy and cataract surgery for their pedigree pooches. 
 The glad tidings coincided with news of the first dog, a spaniel, to be fitted with a cardiac pacemaker. 
 BRITAIN 
 God appears in Knightsbridge 
 A BIBLE'S throw from Harrods, guitar-strummed folk songs waft out of a church. 
 The congregation sways, hands aloft. 
 American Pentecostalism has travelled a long way from its roots in the southern states. 
 At Holy Trinity, Brompton, all four priests are Old Etonians, one of the churchwardens is a former private secretary of Margaret Thatcher's, and it is not unknown for members of the congregation to go on to a wedding reception in St James's Palace. 
 At the end of one recent service, a message from a clairvoyant told of three men suffering from chest pains; not three but four sufferers stepped up to the altar to be healed. 
 A prayer was said for Iraqi soldiers, that they might die with the name of Jesus on their lips and be saved from eternal damnation. 
 Somebody stood up to give a spontaneous and emotional &bquo;prophecy&equo;. 
 Speaking in tongues, as the disciples did at the original Pentecost, is said to be commonplace. 
 Much of this new energy is imported: Holy Trinity follows the ideas of a Californian preacher called John Wimber, a man with no formal theological training who leads a body called the Renewal Movement. 
 But a native evangelism is also flourishing. 
 George Carey, installed as Archbishop of Canterbury on March 27th, belongs to that wing of the Church of England. 
 His interpretation of the New Testament's essentials is literal: &bquo;I believe&equo;, he says, &bquo;that Jesus was crucified, buried and that his cold, dead body was raised alive by God.&equo; 
 He has been friendly with Holy Trinity's vicar since teaching him at theological college in Durham. 
 The Church of England has declared the 1990s to be the Decade of Evangelism; but some people think evangelism is already doing too well. 
 Attendance at traditional churches declined by 9% between 1979 and 1989, but the guitar-strummers' numbers are swelling. 
 Not only is fundamentalism growing fast outside the Church of England &mdash; attendance at the independent churches that practise this sort of Christianity increased from 44,000 in 1979 to 108,000 in 1989 &mdash; but there is also a boom inside the Church of England itself, at places like Holy Trinity. 
 Holy Trinity's young recruits are put on a ten-week course, followed by a residential weekend concentrating on &bquo;the person and work of the Holy Spirit&equo;. 
 The time and dedication demanded do not seem to put people off: the course is so popular that it has had to shift from a country house to a conference centre on an industrial estate in the Midlands. 
 Activism works. 
 Until recently, one of Holy Trinity's neighbouring churches was closed, and two others looked like going under. 
 Since 1985, when this team started its evangelising, they have been filling up; congregations sometimes top 1,000. 
 Not everybody is in tune with the guitar-strummers. 
 Some Church of England traditionalists feel ill at ease among the open-necked shirts. 
 The church's numerous middle-of-the-roaders are concerned: although the charismatic movement tends to be pro-women (the new Archbishop of Canterbury got into trouble for saying it was a &bquo;heresy&equo; to suggest that women should not conduct services), it is also anti-abortion, anti-homosexual and preoccupied with the devil. 
 Satan must be pleased to be so fashionable again.  
 Health-service reforms 
 Watered-down medicine 
 A year ago, the proposed health-service reforms were plainly losing the government almost as much support as the poll tax. 
 On April 1st they will be implemented. 
 Why has the row gone away? 
 THE biggest shake-up in the national health service since its foundation in 1948 is about to take effect. 
 Health authorities will now start buying health care from a range of competing providers. 
 Hospitals that have chosen to opt out of health-authority control and become self-governing will start running their own affairs. 
 General practitioners (GPs) who want to run their own budgets will be able to do so. 
 When this scheme was unveiled, it terrified laymen (including many Tory MPs) almost as much as it infuriated doctors. 
 It lopped points off the government's rating in the opinion polls. 
 The Labour Party had a merry time playing up the problems and piling up the votes. 
 But the launch is not being heralded by strikes in the hospitals or protests in the streets. 
 Labour will limit its protests to the predictable press conferences. 
 And the mighty British Medical Association (BMA), whose harrumphing once looked like destroying the programme, has been reduced to squabbling about doctors' terms of employment. 
 Margaret Thatcher deserves some of the credit for this sudden silence: in her last cabinet reshuffle she replaced the pugnacious Kenneth Clarke with the patrician William Waldegrave. 
 Mr Clarke made no secret of his contempt for the BMA: Mr Waldegrave is a regular visitor to its palatial headquarters. 
 Mr Waldegrave told doctors what they wanted to hear: they were doing a wonderful job and the NHS was not being turned into a tawdry commercial business. 
 But the greatest contribution Mrs Thatcher made to selling the reforms was to lose the Tory leadership. 
 Mr Waldegrave admits that this has made his job a lot easier. 
 Every speech John Major makes about improving the public services and creating a social-market economy helps to comfort nervous voters. 
 Mr Major does not look like a prime minister with a secret agenda up his sleeve. 
 He even uses the NHS himself, unlike his combative predecessor. 
 So far the Labour Party has given Mr Waldegrave a remarkably easy ride. 
 (He has much more to fear from the Thatcherite rump, which has nicknamed him &bquo;our flexible friend&equo;.) 
 Labour strategists claim their recent silence has been deliberate: they do not want to divert public attention from the poll-tax pantomime. 
 There are more solid reasons, though. 
 The Labour Party is paying the price for over-stating the case against the reforms. 
 Robin Cook, the shadow health minister, insisted that the Tories were preparing to dismantle the NHS. 
 Old ladies worried that hospitals would be either closed down or privatised. 
 But on April 1st the worriers will find that the NHS is still firmly in the public sector &mdash; financed from taxation and free at the point of delivery. 
 Mr Cook may prefer silence to eating his words. 
 What of the BMA? 
 Last year it mounted a formidable campaign against the reforms: posters mocked Mr Clarke for ignoring medical advice, and leaflets in every surgery criticised the government for undermining the NHS. 
 Today the BMA's grumbles are muted. 
 It claims that it is as unhappy as ever with the reforms: the NHS is still short of cash and the reforms are much too bureaucratic. 
 It has simply changed its strategy, abandoning tub-thumping for negotiation. 
 The truth is that a triumphant BMA is gloating. 
 The reforms have been diluted. 
 The government has backed down on performance-related contracts: doctors in inner-city areas will have to meet lower targets to win their bonuses. 
 At first the health authorities will have to place their contracts where they have placed them in the past. 
 Opted-out hospitals will not be able to borrow on the capital markets or pay junior staff more than other hospitals. 
 In the first year, GP budget-holders will have to return some of their savings if their budgets prove too generous. 
 The London regions have temporarily been exempted from plans to finance all health authorities on the basis of the size and health of their populations &mdash; the idea at the heart of the reforms. 
 These days the buzz phrases in the Department of Health are equal access for everybody and winning more resources. 
 The health service may have acquired a new set of Thatcherite clothes: the bulky form beneath is still that of Nye Bevan.  
 Rifkind tries to build a model railway 
 The government thinks it can see how to sell the railways piecemeal to the private sector. 
 It is less clear how to introduce real competition 
 JOHN MAJOR is determined to sell British Rail. 
 He said so again on March 23rd. 
 But his Privatisation Express has many features that are lurchingly familiar to the average London commuter. 
 It is running late; it is overcrowded (with expert consultants); and the public is being given no information about its route. 
 Things had been moving so slowly in recent months that some Conservative MPs, like Robert Adley, the railway buff who chairs the Tories' backbench transport committee, were convinced that privatisation was about to be dropped altogether. 
 But the prospect of an early general election has concentrated minds. 
 A committee of three ministers &mdash; Roger Freeman (transport), Francis Maude (Treasury) and John Redwood (trade and industry) &mdash; has been working on the railway sell-off; and the group drafting the Tory election manifesto has been trying to distil the trio's ideas into an appetising few paragraphs. 
 Mr Freeman told the Commons on March 13th that no conclusions have yet been reached about the &bquo;timing or method&equo; of privatisation; but his boss at the transport department, Malcolm Rifkind, has already rejected some ideas. 
 Against the advice of BR's senior managers, he has decided not to sell BR in a single lump. 
 He fears this would merely create a private-sector monopoly and would not improve the service. 
 Mr Rifkind is also opposed to a scheme for selling BR in seven regional packages, originally canvassed by the Centre for Policy Studies as a romantic way of returning to the pre-1948 system. 
 Mr Rifkind believes it would be foolish to split BR by region when the present management has split it by business; besides, the government would have to subsidise all the privatised regions, since none of them makes money. 
 The current thinking is to sell off freight services first. 
 Freight, already profitable, should boom as (a) road congestion rises; (b) the opening of the Channel tunnel cuts the cost of trans-Europe rail trips; and (c) new technology makes it easier to switch piggy-back trailers between lorries and trains. 
 BR has been slow to exploit the opportunities now opening up. 
 Only last year it suddenly shut its Speedlink service for individual wagonloads of freight. 
 Too many of its customers, from the newspaper industry to the Post Office, have been shifting to lorries because rail is unreliable. 
 Richard Hope, the editor of Railway Gazette, says that &bquo;the railways are failing and failing badly, especially in international freight.&equo; 
 Private companies have already shown they can do better. 
 A quarrying firm in the West Country, Foster Yeoman, now runs 35 private trains a week to deliver its stone. 
 It uses a BR crew. 
 Another firm, Tiger Rail, is bidding to run three trains a week to carry china clay from Cornwall to Scotland. 
 And Charterail, a private company in which BR has a 25% share, has developed a fast-growing national business by offering a door-to-door lorry-and-train service. 
 Passenger services will be trickier to privatise, both because they are less profitable and because, unlike wagons, passengers have votes. 
 Inter-City, the next candidate for privatisation, makes money, so it should not be too hard to find a buyer. 
 But Regional Railways &mdash; with 47% of the network and &pound;500m (&dollar;875m) annual subsidy &mdash; will be much tougher to market. 
 Mr Rifkind's inclination is to split it up and offer it for tender, perhaps line by line, in the way that provincial bus services have been deregulated. 
 Bidders would be guaranteed a public subsidy, but would have to compete on price and quality. 
 Companies that were awarded routes might have the right to run services for, say ten years, before their franchise would be put up for sale again, like ITV companies. 
 A snag is that breaking up the network into such small pieces might produce large diseconomies of scale in buying rolling-stock. 
 Network South-East, the London commuter system, remains a headache. 
 The government wanted to stop subsidising it by the end of 1991&ndash;92, but has now given up that idea. 
 Ministers also accept that it would be difficult to allow competing services into each London rail terminal. 
 Instead, they hope to divide the network into several sub-regional groups in the hope that, say, Marylebone commuter trains would compete with Waterloo trains by a mysterious process known in Whitehall as &bquo;emulation&equo;: Waterloo commuters, envying the breakfasts served on Marylebone trains, might perhaps demand fatter sausages. 
 Many other questions remain unanswered. 
 The first is whether ownership of the national track should be split off from the running of services, as recommended by Kenneth Irvine of the Adam Smith Institute. 
 Such a split should clarify the distribution of costs and make it easier for competing train services to run on the same track. 
 Opponents point out that competing services ran on Britain's first railway, the Stockton-Darlington line, opened in 1825, but were abandoned as impractical after 1830. 
 Still, the idea is now gaining respectability. 
 The European Commission last year proposed that all EC railways should separate track operation from running services, in the hope that it would then be easier to open up national railways to outside competition. 
 And Sweden successfully split its railway track from services in 1988. 
 Mr Rifkind is lukewarm about the idea. 
 He fears that a private-sector British track-owner would be a monopolist with little incentive to be efficient. 
 Besides, as BR executives cogently argue, the quality of the track and the services that run on it are increasingly linked. 
 The next advance in signalling will be the introduction of computers-in-the-cab. 
 Would that count as a track cost or a running cost? 
 Some Tories fondly imagine that privatisation will eliminate the need to subsidise the railways. 
 Not so. 
 Although the public subsidy has been halved in the past ten years, the growth of passenger traffic has stalled with the recession. 
 Meanwhile property sales are in the doldrums, and the government has reneged on its agreement to let BR raise commuters' rail fares by a real 3.5% a year. 
 On top of this BR now has to find an extra &pound;100m a year to pay for an unnecessarily large safety programme, one result of the Clapham rail crash. 
 With these developments, BR reckons it may need an extra &pound;300m from the government to balance its books for 1990&ndash;91. 
 The case for privatising British Rail has little to do with saving money: private companies will probably have to waste even more on safety to avoid charges of putting profits before lives. 
 Nor is the sale of BR's divisions likely to raise much for the Treasury. 
 Although its assets are notionally worth &pound;10 billion, their market value as a going concern must be far less. 
 Rather, the best argument for privatisation is that it would allow the railways to expand their services. 
 Investment would no longer be subject to an annual ceiling set by the Treasury (which, for example, is currently stopping BR buying up-to-date Networker trains to help relieve congestion on lines in Kent). 
 Innovation would be encouraged; new lines might be opened more readily. 
 Above all, privatisation ought to oblige staff to start serving passengers better. 
 Although BR is belatedly training its staff to do just that, it is unlikely to have much effect. 
 In a privatised railway, the staff could be as customer-minded as the cabin crews of British Airways have become, perhaps with encouragement from profit-linked bonuses. 
 And the cosy civil-service culture of the railway, where poor managers are never sacked, could be turned upside down. 
 BR has indeed become more commercial over the past decade. 
 Its subsidies are now tiny by comparison with Europe (Italy subsidises 91% of the cost of its rail commuters, Britain less than 10%); its trains are faster than every national service apart from France and Japan. 
 And it is even becoming reliable: 90% of BR's commuter trains arrive within five minutes of schedule, against only 65% in Germany. 
 But privatisation offers the best hope of producing even bigger gains in the years ahead.  
 Labour can win 
 THESE have been feverish, unhappy days for John Major. 
 Few of his ministers are saying, even in private, that they expect him to lose the next election. 
 Economic recovery will save the day, as inflation tumbles later this year, they assure one another. 
 But there is a nervousness about, a fit of the jitters that means the Easter holiday comes just in time. 
 The overt problem has been, as usual, the poll tax. 
 Michael Heseltine's ungainly hybrid replacement received a poor reception from Tory activists gathered at Southport last weekend. 
 Ministers gave different interpretations of the hybrid. 
 Mr Major made a wooden speech. 
 Poor polls, one showing Labour ahead by six points, were followed by an attack by a former chancellor, Nigel Lawson, who questioned the government's ability to govern. 
 All quite predictable, say the Tory optimists. 
 Since the poll-tax disaster broke, the government has been &mdash; as one cabinet minister puts it &mdash; retreating from Moscow under hostile fire. 
 Mr Heseltine, seen by many Tory faithful as Margaret Thatcher's assassin, was never going to get a good reception in his first post-coup party speech. 
 &bquo;He was standing there with the blood still on his cuffs,&equo; one MP explained. 
 Give it a few months, goes the cheery Tory argument. 
 By then the party's wounds will have healed. 
 The voters will be delighted with their lower poll-tax bills; falling interest rates will be delivering cheaper mortgages. 
 And if not in June, victory will arrive in the autumn, or in 1992, instead. 
 (The Tories' computer has produced a range of later options. 
 An election announcement in Mr Major's speech to the Conservative conference on October 11th, followed by a November 7th poll, is a popular one.) 
 Perhaps. 
 But not all economists think late 1991 and early 1992 will be a time of milk and honey. 
 Unemployment may still be rising quite sharply; underlying inflation will not be much lower than it is now; sterling may need to be supported by a rise in interest rates. 
 Two recent reports from UBS Phillips &amp; Drew and Midland Montagu both plump for an early election, largely on economic grounds. 
 So the argument that Mr Major needs only to wait for the inevitable victory, after the inevitable economic recovery, should be taken with a fistful of salt. 
 And there is more to politics than economics. 
 People may vote with one hand on their wallets, but their guesses about future prosperity are tangled up with judgments of the competing politicians. 
 These judgments are always crude, occasionally wrong. 
 Caricatures tend to be sketched early, and then to stick. 
 For years, Neil Kinnock was seen by voters as kind but incompetent. 
 It has taken the Tories' current enthusiasm for copying Labour policies &mdash; and this week's signal from the Bank of England that it favours a form of credit controls &mdash; to start to blur that image. 
 Mrs Thatcher's withering contempt was far more damaging. 
 Now Mr Kinnock is trying for revenge, using the poll-tax confusion to portray Mr Major as a wimpish ditherer, or a dithering wimp. 
 This is not (only) vulgar abuse. 
 It is the lethal essence of the political art. 
 If it works, Mr Major has had it. 
 Mr Kinnock's caricature was coloured in by Mr Lawson. 
 He quoted a former French Radical prime minister, Pierre Mend&egrave;s-France, &bquo;who said that &bquo;to govern was to choose'. 
 I agree with that. 
 To appear to be unable to choose is to appear to be unable to govern.&equo; 
 To the extent that Mr Lawson was criticising the &bquo;son of poll-tax&equo; announced by Mr Heseltine, he was quite right. 
 Given the choice of a property tax or a modified poll tax &mdash; either of them offensive to a large swathe of Tory MPs, both of them defensible &mdash; Mr Major chose a bit of both. 
 The expensive, complex hybrid will come unstuck. 
 But Mr Lawson must have known that the timing of his words meant he was going much further than that. 
 Mr Major was being attacked by Labour as innately incompetent to lead. 
 By seeming to agree, Mr Lawson knifed his one-time Treasury assistant in the back. 
 Why? 
 Jealousy? 
 Or did Mr Lawson simply let his natural rudeness get the better of his judgment? 
 And the man is rude: in the same debate, he was questioned by John Townend, a Tory MP who, while not exactly Socrates in a suit, is a perfectly amiable cove. 
 Mr Lawson responded pleasantly: &bquo;I am glad that my honourable friend raised that issue because, although it is an absurdity, it is believed by many people other than my honourable friend, who understandably picks up things that he hears other people say.&equo; 
 The dithering charge is mostly unfair. 
 Mr Major has taken plenty of decisions &mdash; Norman Lamont's budget was full of bold strokes. 
 But the local-tax fudge is dangerous because it concentrates attention on a great dilemma facing Mr Major: how do you lead a party that has just overthrown Margaret Thatcher? 
 If Mr Major had tried to copy her whip-cracking style, he would have failed. 
 He would have been acting out of character and trying on something his party had wearied of. 
 But as the Tory wagon-train breaks away from Mrs Thatcher's trail, Mr Major's gentler style inevitably means slacker reins. 
 Meanwhile, every Tory has a subtly different view about how sharp is the angle of divergence, so emphasising the impression of drift. 
 Small wonder some MPs ask: where is the party being driven? 
 Or even: is anyone driving at all? 
 One wry Tory, using a different metaphor, asks: &bquo;Whose is the hand on the hand on the tiller?&equo; 
 (His answer is that the unseen hand belongs not to Adam Smith's market forces but to Chris Patten, the leftish party chairman. 
 That is hardly an answer that helps Mr Major.) 
 Part of the truth is that Mr Major is dog-tired, physically drained after his wisdom-tooth infection, the leadership campaign, the Gulf war, the poll-tax furore. 
 For those who wish to see, there are signs of a distinctive Major philosophy &mdash; some of it Thatcherite, some of it Labourish. 
 Given enough time, he can pull his party together. 
 He will be perkier, and more impressive, after a short break. 
 But time is limited. 
 Tory Central Office knows it needs to win back hundreds of thousands of skilled working-class voters who are no longer sure quite what (or who) the Conservative Party is for. 
 These were the people who deserted Labour in the 1980s and became Thatcher supporters, but were never Tories. 
 They owe Mr Major no automatic allegiance. 
 This week it is suddenly plain. 
 Yes, the Conservatives can lose. 
 Yes, Labour can win.  
 Eyebrow-raiser 
 THE governor of the Bank of England is living dangerously. 
 On March 21st Robin Leigh-Pemberton said he was confident that the Bank would eventually be independent of political control. 
 Only a few days later, in evidence to a parliamentary committee, he had the temerity to recommend controls on mortgage lending &mdash; in direct conflict with present government policy. 
 Mr Leigh-Pemberton reckons such controls might help to prevent another explosion in house prices and borrowing as interest rates fall. 
 Much of Britain's current economic mess is due to the surge in home borrowing in the late 1980s, much of which was spent on things other than houses. 
 The Bank of England's latest Quarterly Bulletin says Britain's system of housing finance is the least regulated in Europe. 
 Nowhere else, for example, can home-buyers borrow 100% of the purchase price. 
 The Labour Party has pledged that, if elected, it will introduce credit controls as an alternative to high interest rates. 
 While the party's definition of &bquo;credit controls&equo; is vague, it clearly has in mind reserve requirements on banks. 
 Without exchange controls, goes the standard retort, commercial customers could easily dodge such controls by borrowing from abroad. 
 This, though, hardly applies to the home-loans market. 
 Several economists in the City reckon that controls on mortgages (not their own, of course) would be helpful, and that leakages would be small. 
 But limiting the size of a loan &mdash; to, say, a certain percentage of the value of a house or a multiple of the borrower's income &mdash; would mainly curb the borrowing by first-time buyers. 
 Better by far to tackle equity withdrawal on big loans, where better-off house-buyers borrow &pound;20,000 more than they need for a house-purchase, to buy that flashy car they have always wanted. 
 But how to do it? 
 Perhaps John Major, already well into the habit of stealing Labour's clothes, will come up with the right formula. 
 He ruled out credit controls when he was chancellor of the exchequer &mdash; but he also attacked the banks, in his 1990 budget, for their carefree personal lending. 
 He also threatened to impose guidelines, unless they took voluntary action. 
 They have been warned.  
 Horse racing 
 Looking for a better bet 
 As the flat season begins and politicians think about reforming racing, the toffs of the turf are whinnying and stamping their feet. 
 Ignore them 
 THE bookmaking barons like to be called Alfie or Len; the people who run the Jockey Club, racing's official regulator, prefer glossier titles. 
 Both camps have long been bound together by a shared interest in the punter's pound. 
 Now they are scrapping over the same pound &mdash; and over the betting levy, which the Horserace Betting Levy Board redistributes from punters to those who run the racing business. 
 Recently, some members of the Jockey Club have been throwing insults at the big commercial bookmakers and the state-run betting system, known as the Tote. 
 By earning millions from racing and giving pennies back, says the Jockey Club, the bookmakers are sucking the sport dry. 
 In reply, the bookies wonder whether managing a whelk stall might be a better-sized challenge for the Jockey Club's skills. 
 There is a particular reason for the current shouting-match. 
 Throughout the winter and into the spring, the home-affairs committee of the House of Commons has been discussing the future of the levy. 
 As the Jockey Club sees it, British racing is in terminal decline. 
 Racehorse owners recoup just a fifth of their costs, on average. 
 So they are quitting, along with breeders, in unprecedented numbers. 
 Trainers by the dozen are being forced to sell their stables. 
 The only thing that can save the sport in the country where it was born is a large injection of prize money. 
 Economic consultants are now being hired &mdash; by the Jockey Club and the influential Marquis of Zetland, for instance &mdash; to point out the obvious: British prize money is pretty paltry by international standards. 
 In Britain the average prize money per flat race last year was &pound;7,700 (&dollar;13,000); in Hong Kong &pound;17,000 and in Japan an extraordinary &pound;66,000. 
 Through the levy, gamblers in Britain paid 0.9% on their bets, or &pound;40m, to racing in 1990; in France, through the state-owned bookmaker, they paid five times that rate. 
 The solution, claim racing's blue-blooded interests, is to force the punter to pay more, either through a monopoly tote (the Marquis's wish) or a higher levy (the Jockey Club's). 
 That way, the Earl of Glenleisure and Johnny Stockbroker would be better kept in oats. 
 And more money might trickle down (they maintain, rather improbably) to those 50-year-old wage-slaves called stable-lads, who cost so much less to keep than the nags they look after. 
 Horse racing's decline was deepened by last year's collapse in bloodstock values. 
 Yearling sales brought in a third less than 1989's &pound;70m. 
 But that decline came hard on the heels of the mid-1980s, when prices rose to absurd heights. 
 It has been accentuated by the Gulf war: Arab princes, not wishing to parade their sybaritic ways too openly these days, have vanished from the auction ring. 
 British owners used to blame the princes for making racing prohibitively expensive; now they blame them for making it prohibitively cheap. 
 Everybody is protesting too much. 
 The sport is actually in reasonable health. 
 Between 1980 and 1990 the average attendance at Britain's 67 racecourses grew from 4,600 to 4,900; the number of owners from 16,400 to 18,000; and the number of racehorses in training from 10,650 to nearly 13,000. 
 Betting turnover doubled, to &pound;4.5 billion. 
 The average levy per horse rose from &pound;1,640 to &pound;2,700. 
 The average subsidy paid from the levy cash for each race meeting doubled, to &pound;34,000. 
 A windfall of an annual &pound;8m from satellite-television royalties dropped into racing's lap. 
 True, betting turnover is now set to shrink in real terms this year, and the levy with it. 
 In March the Levy Board said it would cut its contributions to prize money by a tenth. 
 Yet less subsidy is precisely what racing needs. 
 For the subsidy has encouraged amateurish management and an uncommercial approach. 
 Too many racecourses offer stale sausage rolls and queues for the Portaloo. 
 After 240 years, the Jockey Club has just got its first chief executive. 
 On course for the future? 
 It is a remarkable sign of mollycoddling that racing has kept its levy at all. 
 The levy probably survived because Margaret Thatcher &mdash; unlike the 19th-century Earl of Rosebery, who said he would rather win the Derby (he did that twice) than be prime minister (once, briefly) &mdash; was uninterested in racing. 
 Her first home secretary, William (now Lord) Whitelaw, was not one to draw her attention to it. 
 Though they resent it, Britain's biggest off-course bookmakers &mdash; Ladbroke, Coral and William Hill &mdash; all agree on the benefits of a levy. 
 Up to a point, the more money that racecourses spend, the more exciting the races, the more punters therefore spend, and so on. 
 The trouble is that the levy is an unsatisfactory mechanism for allocating cash. 
 Racecourses, in an effort to win more of the levy pot, lay on too many races with too few horses. 
 Gamblers disdain four-horse races. 
 If the parliamentary committee wishes to see Britain's racing transformed, it should forget about tampering with the levy rate. 
 Instead, it should recommend privatising the Tote &mdash; a state-owned hangover from the times before commercial betting was legal &mdash; and reforming the laws on gambling. 
 Since betting was legalised 30 years ago, bookmakers have not been allowed to do anything that might &bquo;stimulate&equo; a punter to bet. 
 By law, therefore, bookies' offices have to be seedy reminders of the 1960s &mdash; an outrageous imposition when, for many, the Saturday punt is the week's intellectual activity. 
 Bookmakers should be able to offer the service any way people want it &mdash; with pubs, cocktail bars or five-star restaurants attached. 
 The racing industry could help itself by improving what its new management consultants have taught it to call the &bquo;product&equo;. 
 Sunday racing would do wonders; but when a bill to allow this came to a crucial vote in the House of Lords three years ago, the Jockey Club's then senior steward, Lord Fairhaven, did not bother to attend. 
 Even without Sunday racing, the sport could do much to make itself more interesting. 
 It could, for instance, spend more money on lowly flat races and less on the grander occasions, like the Derby, where the winner is anyway rewarded by high bloodstock values. 
 It could auction the on-course bookmaking pitches to the highest bidders, instead of charging an annual &pound;10 fee that costs &pound;20 to collect. 
 And it could move two of the biggest races of the flat and jumping seasons, the Derby and the Cheltenham Gold Cup, from their hallowed mid-week slots to a Saturday. 
 That move alone would be worth around &pound;2m. 
 BUSINESS 
 Jack Welch reinvents General Electric &mdash; again 
 NEW YORK 
 On April 1st Jack Welch completes ten years as head of General Electric. 
 One of the most controversial &mdash; and praised &mdash; bosses in American industry, he now wants to make his firm &bquo;boundary-less&equo;. 
 It will not be easy 
 THOUGH frequently touted as one of America's best managers, Jack Welch bristles at the word &bquo;manager&equo;. 
 He prefers &bquo;leader&equo;: a chief executive who provides vision and values. 
 For Mr Welch the difference is crucial. 
 He thinks most businesses are over-managed and under-led. 
 Generally people know more about their own jobs than their bosses do, he says. 
 The best thing managers can do is get out of their way. 
 Do not be tempted to dismiss such corporate homilies as boardroom hokum. 
 GE's record in the ten years since this restless Irish-American became the company's chief executive at the early age of 45 is impressive, especially considering GE's size and diversity. 
 Under Mr Welch's stewardship sales have increased from &dollar;26.8 billion in 1980, the year before he took over, to &dollar;58.4 billion in 1990, an annual growth rate of over 8% and a third better than inflation. 
 Profits in the same period have grown by 11% a year, from &dollar;1.5 billion to &dollar;4.3 billion. 
 The workforce has been slashed from 410,000 to below 300,000. 
 Return on equity has averaged nearly 19% a year. 
 After moulding GE so decisively, Mr Welch is determined to transform its culture and organisation into what he awkwardly describes as a &bquo;boundary-less&equo; company. 
 Mr Welch wants GE to be an enterprise where: (a) internal divisions blur, and everybody works as a team; (b) suppliers and customers are partners; (c) there is no segregation between foreign and domestic operations, and each GE business is just as much at home in South Korea and Paris, France, as it is in South Carolina and Paris, Texas. 
 Such a transformation may prove far more difficult to achieve than the chopping and changing of the past decade. 
 Despite its success, even Mr Welch's decisive restructuring has suffered lots of setbacks. 
 His purchase of Kidder Peabody soured when the New York investment bank's top deal-maker was jailed for insider trading. 
 Faulty compressors in GE's refrigerators cost the company &dollar;300m in extra warranty costs. 
 Mr Welch geared up the company's locomotive-manufacturing business for a much-ballyhooed revival in American railways that never happened. 
 His incursion into the sale of automated equipment to factories cost GE huge sums of money. 
 Nevertheless, Mr Welch is routinely cited as one of America's best businessmen, mainly because he has kept GE's huge juggernaut performing well while others have foundered. 
 Equally remarkable, Mr Welch has won his kudos not by turning around a firm in trouble but by matching the performance of his predecessor, Reginald Jones, who doubled sales and tripled profits in eight years. 
 Like all bosses of conglomerates, Mr Welch likes to call his firm something different. 
 GE, he says, represents &bquo;integrated diversity&equo;. 
 Whatever the euphemism, GE is a classic conglomerate. 
 Its 13 main business lines, each large enough to be a Fortune-500 company, have about as much in common as ice cream and cement. 
 They stretch from aero-engines and power stations to the NBC national-television network to electric lighting to plastics to medical-diagnostic gadgets through to a huge near-bank, General Electric Financial Services. 
 The challenge for the chief executive of such a sprawling firm is to introduce a clear sense of direction and to get sales and profits to grow faster than the American, and preferably the world, economy. 
 Mr Welch earned his nickname &bquo;Neutron Jack&equo; when he committed GE to stick only with businesses that were number one or number two in their markets: a policy since copied by Siemens of Germany and Electrolux of Sweden, among others. 
 Those businesses that did not meet this exacting standard would, vowed Mr Welch, be &bquo;fixed, closed or sold&equo;. 
 He has been as good as his word. 
 In the first Welch decade, GE sold &dollar;10 billion-worth of companies and bought &dollar;25 billion-worth. 
 It stopped making television sets. 
 It pulled out of mining and consumer electronics, and moved into medical equipment. 
 Big purchases included RCA (an entertainment group, one of whose subsidiaries was NBC), Kidder Peabody and, more recently, the Borg-Warner chemicals business and Hungary's Tungsram lighting company. 
 In knocking these businesses together and into shape, Mr Welch raised GE's annual growth rate in labour productivity from 1.9% in his first five years to 4.4% in his second five years by axing whole layers of managers as well as tens of thousands of factory and clerical jobs. 
 This has traumatised a company that traditionally gave its employees an implicit job-for-life promise. 
 And it has earned Mr Welch a reputation for arrogance and ruthlessness that he finds embarrassing. 
 GE, he insists, is &bquo;hard-headed but warm-hearted&equo;, offering redundant employees job-placement help and retraining as well as generous severance benefits. 
 Though tinkering will continue, everybody at GE is relieved that massive restructuring seems to be over. 
 However, if the determined Mr Welch gets his way, building the boundary-less company could make the 1990s just as traumatic. 
 Internally, GE has already done much to dismantle the bureaucratic command-and-control systems that beset so many of America's big businesses. 
 Acting in line with his belief that &bquo;the people who are closest to the work really do know it better&equo;, Mr Welch came up two years ago with an anti-bureaucratic device called &bquo;the work-out.&equo; 
 At work-outs, people who often have no occasion to speak to one another during the day &mdash; hourly workers, salaried managers and union leaders &mdash; are summoned to the corporate equivalent of a New England town meeting. 
 The pioneering work-outs quickly developed into savage attacks on the worst examples of corporate bureaucracy &mdash; ten signatures on a minor requisition, artificial dress codes. 
 Managers were encouraged by corporate head office to eradicate such excesses at the work-outs, not to refer them to committees or put them through the proper channels. 
 This ploy was supposed to increase confidence in the system. 
 It did. 
 Once employees are satisfied that work-outs are not mere talking shops, they are eager to suggest ways their jobs can be done better. 
 GE welders, for instance, won permission to select and order the machines they use &mdash; purchasing decisions once reserved for the company's white-collared engineers. 
 So far, so good &mdash; but also so limited. 
 Mr Welch's other &bquo;boundary-less&equo; goals will be harder to achieve: partnership with customers and suppliers, and a truly global business. 
 GE's customers seem happy enough, but some suppliers, when guaranteed anonymity, say they are not. 
 They tell such horror stories as GE putting up sales teams from competing suppliers in the same hotel and then moving from room to room asking each supplier to think about reducing its bid for the contract. 
 Suppliers grumble that GE keeps their margins on contracts so thin that they have to cut corners to fulfil them. 
 This may fatten GE's profits but it sits oddly with talk about a partnership with suppliers. 
 Globally, GE has yet to tailor itself to fit its ambitions. 
 The company's overwhelmingly American board of directors and senior management still suffer from a not-invented-here arrogance. 
 Far from addressing such insularity, the work-out system as initially conceived tended to reinforce the parochialism of GE's managers by making them even more introspective. 
 The corrective that Mr Welch has prescribed is bold enough to suggest that his second decade as chief executive could be as radical as the first. 
 To supplement work-outs, he has come up with a global best-practices programme. 
 GE scours the world for companies which are better than GE itself at some specific aspect of business and then asks to pick their brains. 
 In return GE promises to share with them the knowledge it gains &mdash; in effect, to provide management-consultancy services for free. 
 Only businesses that are direct competitors are excluded. 
 Some companies GE has approached have said no; others have insisted on anonymity. 
 Most are flattered to be asked. 
 GE has gone to Ford for ideas on new-product development and employee involvement; to Hewlett Packard for ideas on partnership with suppliers and quality improvement; to Digital Equipment for ideas on asset management; to American Express for ideas on customer satisfaction; to Honda for ideas on product development. 
 The squad of operating managers that GE sends to each model company is kept small &mdash; typically no more than ten people per visit. 
 The case studies they produce later form part of the curriculum at Crotonville, the company's management-development school a few miles up on the Hudson river from New York. 
 A big snag remains. 
 The best-practices approach cannot address weaknesses until GE is ready to acknowledge them. 
 The uniformity of its top executives is the crucial case in point. 
 Mr Welch quickly acknowledges that GE has put up a sorry performance in having only four women among its 120 top people. 
 He is determined to find better ways to recruit and develop talented women. 
 Yet when he and other top men at GE are asked why the company has only one foreigner on its 19-member board of directors, they insist that this is no obstacle to making the company truly global. 
 Instead they tick off the names of influential foreigners in GE's hierarchy and cite the company's large international sales and profit figures. 
 They kid themselves. 
 Most GE managers are Americans who have spent nearly all their working lives with the company. 
 The figures on international operations are less impressively global on closer examination: GE's international revenues of &dollar;15.4 billion in 1990 turn out to include &dollar;6 billion of direct exports from the United States. 
 About 21% of the company's 298,000 employees work outside the United States (compared with 45% of IBM's 374,000 and 49% of Ford's 367,000). 
 Some GE businesses, like aero-engines and plastics, have always had a global outlook. 
 Others are developing one. 
 GE Lighting, Thomas Edison's 112-year-old business, was almost totally American until it acquired a majority stake in Hungary's Tungsram 15 months ago. 
 With the recent purchase of the lighting interests of Britain's Thorn EMI, it has increased its share of the European market tenfold, from 2% to 20%. 
 Other businesses remain as parochial as ever: appliances and broadcasting, for instance. 
 In other words, GE's global performance is patchy at best. 
 For the company to realise its ambitions, and to become a truly boundary-less organisation, Mr Welch will have to heed his own oft-quoted advice. 
 Face reality, even when doing so is painful.  
 Japan's aircraft makers 
 Out in the cold 
 TOKYO 
 JUST a year ago Japan's aircraft makers were confidently planning to grab 10% of the world market for commercial jets by 2000, twice their current share. 
 After decades of trying to become big competitors, they were determined to learn as much as they could as suppliers to America's Boeing, the world's biggest civil-aircraft maker, and then to stand on their own. 
 But Japanese companies' business with Boeing is now under threat, forcing them to rethink their strategy. 
 Some are even chasing orders from Airbus, Boeing's European rival. 
 With fewer defence contracts around, American aircraft manufacturers such as Rockwell and McDonnell Douglas have been pressing Boeing to redirect subcontracting work towards them and away from the Japanese. 
 Given America's recession, Japanese suppliers assume they will lose new orders to American rivals for political and protective reasons. 
 Another setback for Japan's aircraft makers is the coming gap in military orders at home. 
 Production of the Japanese industry's two principal profit earners &mdash; the F-15J fighter and the P-3C anti-submarine aircraft, both built under licence from the United States &mdash; will peter out in a few years' time. 
 After that there are no plans to build new aircraft except for the controversial FSX, a new support-fighter based on the American F-16 that Mitsubishi Heavy Industries is developing with General Dynamics of the United States. 
 Even the FSX has been plagued by delays, most of them political. 
 The first prototype is not expected to be airborne until 1998. 
 Until production on the FSX builds up, Japanese plane makers are going to be short of work. 
 Industry analysts at Cr&eacute;dit Suisse in Tokyo expect the military side of the aircraft business in Japan to stagnate between now and 1995. 
 A third problem for Japan's airframe firms is their failure to become full partners in Boeing's 777 project in 1990. 
 Boeing did offer Japan's big three airframe makers (Mitsubishi, Kawasaki and Fuji Heavy Industries) a chance to learn some of the tricks about selling big commercial jets &mdash; but at a price. 
 The Japanese firms have to share in more of the risk than they did as suppliers for Boeing's 767 model and yet will have only what is politely termed &bquo;project status&equo; &mdash; ie, they will be contractors who can make suggestions but have little real clout. 
 Small wonder that Japan's aircraft industry is trying to reduce its dependence on Boeing. 
 Kawasaki Heavy Industries recently won an order from British Aerospace to supply skin panels for the A321 Airbus, Japan's first big order from the Airbus consortium. 
 Sumitomo Precision Products, a Japanese supplier of hydraulic pumps and propellers, also grabbed an Airbus contract for landing-gear parts from Britain's Dowty group. 
 Japan's leading textile maker, Toray Industries, is supplying carbon-fibre components to Airbus Industrie as well. 
 Meanwhile, the government is prodding Japan's aircraft firms to collaborate with more foreigners. 
 The Concorde-replacement project being promoted by the Society of Japanese Aerospace Companies, for instance, brings together nine manufacturers in six countries. 
 Such projects may be pie-in-the-sky, but at least they enable Japan's fledgling plane makers to rub shoulders with firms from Europe and the United States. 
 In one sense, though, Japan's aircraft makers are in a stronger position than many of their more experienced rivals abroad. 
 For them aircraft represent only a small part of their huge engineering and shipbuilding businesses. 
 And all of them are making so much money these days out of replacing the world's ageing fleet of oil tankers that they can accept losses on their aircraft business in order to keep their foot in the door for the day, however distant, when they can compete with their own aeroplane.  
 Europe's energy monopolies 
 What, me compete? 
 ANYTHING that pleases consumers, entrepreneurs, environmentalists and free-marketeers shines like a good deed in a murky world. 
 When it emanates from the European Commission in Brussels and casts confusion among Europe's biggest monopolists, puzzlement is added to dazzlement. 
 If the competition commissioner, Sir Leon Brittan, has his way, there may soon be an end to the state energy monopolies that dominate electricity and gas production in the European Community (EC). 
 In a surprisingly bold move, Sir Leon is threatening court action by June against governments in ten countries (only Germany and Belgium escape) on the grounds that their state energy monopolies distort cross-border competition in contravention of the EC's founding Treaty of Rome. 
 Sir Leon's goal is a single market in electricity and gas across Europe. 
 That, in turn, is supposed to reduce prices. 
 In a free market, polluting coal-fired power stations and unpopular nuclear ones should be less competitive because of rising environmental costs. 
 With luck they will be replaced by small, efficient gas-burning power stations built by new entrants to Europe's energy business. 
 Europe currently produces three-quarters of its electric power from nuclear and coal-fired power plants. 
 Expansion of either now faces fierce opposition from environmentalists. 
 So exploiting the capacity of existing stations has become a priority. 
 If peaks and troughs were traded more efficiently &mdash; ie, if stations could buy power from others when local demand is high, and sell to others when it is low &mdash; their theoretical 12% capacity margin might cope with further demand growth for years to come. 
 But that requires a real single market. 
 Formally, the road to a single energy market started with a directive last year that compelled countries to let electricity or gas pass through their grids or pipelines in transit from one neighbouring country to another. 
 But this common-carrier principle has produced little such trade because negotiations were soon bogged down in technical committees full of engineers from the very monopolies that stood most to lose from cross-border competition. 
 Now Sir Leon is determined to compel governments to open up their energy markets to supplies from other EC countries, even if the internal-distribution monopolies remain untouched. 
 Dismantling these will be the commission's next move. 
 Meanwhile, removing barriers to cross-border electricity and gas trade should start eroding the monopolies from within and benefiting consumers immediately. 
 The common-carrier directive on its own had a big flaw: it encouraged the flow of subsidised energy from one country to another. 
 So France, which built far too much nuclear capacity with cheap government-backed loans, exports electricity to Britain and Italy at absurdly low rates. 
 With international competition and new entrants, national monopolies such as France's will at least have to come clean about costs and pricing if only to prove that they are not breaching the Rome treaty's clauses against unfair competition. 
 Meanwhile state-owned energy monopolies have come up with their own solution to generating more electricity without angering local environmentalists: moving their power stations to Eastern Europe. 
 ENEL, Italy's electricity monopoly, is planning to build a 13,000MW gas-fired station in the Soviet Union: a quarter of the output will be sold to Italy. 
 EDF, France's electricity monopoly, and Framatome, its state-controlled nuclear-reactor builder, are using German and Italian money to build two 900MW nuclear plants in Hungary. 
 The Germans and Italians will be repaid in electricity. 
 Neat: the rich West gets the power; the poor East gets the power stations. 
 In America this ploy is known as the California syndrome, after the hypocrites who invented out-of-state nuclear power.  
 Brazil's coffee industry 
 Brewing a quota 
 IF THE members of the OPEC oil cartel think times are tough, they should consider the plight of coffee producers. 
 After their system of export quotas broke down in 1989, world coffee prices almost halved. 
 Many producers are eager to cobble together another market-sharing cartel, but so far have failed to recruit Brazil, the Saudi Arabia of the world coffee-market with a share just over 20%. 
 They may be about to get their way. 
 On March 21st Brazil's economics ministry stopped issuing permission to export the country's coffee, causing uproar at home, turmoil in the international coffee market and an insider-trading scandal that could prove embarrassing for the government of President Fernando Collor de Mello. 
 The economics ministry has kept mum about why it made its decision so abruptly, but most in the industry assume it is a first step towards rejoining an international quota system. 
 The move will not halt Brazilian exports immediately, because many exporters have received registration for shipments abroad up to a year in advance. 
 Brazil's experience of the free market has not been happy. 
 In 1987, two years before the coffee cartel collapsed following arguments over quota allocations, the country had enjoyed a record crop of 43m bags (a bag is 60kg). 
 World exports that year were 70m bags &mdash; of which Brazil's quota was only 16.5m bags, according to the Economist Intelligence Unit, a sister company of The Economist. 
 Without the restriction of a coffee agreement, Brazil had thought that it would be better able to increase its exports and regain its former market share. 
 In fact the abolition of quotas seems to have cost Brazil about &dollar;1 billion in lost revenues &mdash; though this is difficult to judge, because Brazilian production also dropped precipitously as poor weather, soil conditions and falling world prices cut output in marginal areas. 
 Nevertheless, some Brazilian coffee exporters have done well after being liberated from bureaucratic controls, which means that Brazil's coffee industry is now divided on what the country's next move should be. 
 In any case, restive exporters are unlikely to let the government maintain its ban on new exports for long. 
 Unfortunately for Brazil, even if the economics ministry succeeds in uniting the country's industry behind quotas, there will be  plenty  of arguing before any international system can be set up. 
 With &dollar;1.5 billion of coffee exports last year, Colombia's share overtook Brazil's for the first time. 
 Other Latin American producers will also be reluctant to cut recently expanded exports to restore Brazil's earlier quota. 
 The high-quality arabica beans which they grow have become more popular than the robusta variety grown in Africa and, to some extent, in Brazil. 
 Oddly, consuming countries are also members of the International Coffee Organisation, which policed the old cartel. 
 They saw the cartel as a necessary evil to make the market less volatile and to restrain producers themselves from trying to corner the market in coffee futures. 
 Getting both producers and consumers to agree to any new set of quotas is likely to take months, perhaps years, of haggling &mdash; one reason why coffee prices fell back within hours after jumping 15% on the news of Brazil's ban on new exports. 
 There is no shortage of coffee. 
 Nevertheless that blip was long enough for someone to make a tidy profit. 
 The daily volume of coffee-futures contracts on the Coffee, Sugar &amp; Cocoa Exchange in New York leapt from 8,000 on a typical day to 15,000 on the day before the ban. 
 American officials are investigating whether there was any insider trading. 
 Brazil's eventual choice is clear, if unpalatable: either forgo a quota system which could help raise and stabilise prices, or enter the quota system but formally give up market share to other producers.  
 The entertainment industry 
 Not so thrilling 
 LOS ANGELES 
 BILLY CRYSTAL introduced this year's Oscars by reflecting that &bquo;no Americans are fighting anywhere in the world &mdash; except at Paramount.&equo; 
 For all its claims to have put its house in order, America's second-biggest export industry refuses to grow up. 
 Last week Frank Mancuso, Paramount's long-serving studio chief, left the company and promptly issued a writ claiming &dollar;45m in damages. 
 Martin Davis, Paramount's autocratic chairman, had appointed Stanley Jaffe as chief operating officer without first consulting Mr Mancuso. 
 How rude. 
 Such boardroom pique may not be unique to Hollywood, though it is characteristic of the shenanigans that have always plagued the entertainment industry. 
 What makes this behaviour more worrying is the fact that the industry is now dominated by recently-assembled global media conglomerates or big electronics firms who can ill afford it. 
 Japan's Matsushita and Sony have each invested more than &dollar;5 billion over the past few years in America's entertainment business, while Time and Warner have merged in the belief that big companies can best exploit a proliferating array of new media. 
 Unfortunately such empire-builders seem to have overlooked the fact that selling the same names and images a thousand different ways also hands unprecedented power to film and pop stars, whose soaring demands have sent movie and recording costs spiralling. 
 Last year the average cost of making a picture rose 15%, to &dollar;26.8m; and the cost of releasing it rose 25%, to &dollar;11.6m. 
 Despite lots of talk about cutting costs, each of the top studios currently has at least one money-losing blockbuster on its books. 
 The most startling example is &bquo;Batman&equo;, one of the most successful films in recent years, which has made a loss (see table) according to a recently leaked profit-and-loss statement. 
 How could this happen? 
 Part of the answer lies in the &dollar;112m listed as &bquo;negative and advances&equo;. 
 This includes the actual production cost of the movie (probably around &dollar;50m) and advances under &bquo;gross profit&equo; participation clauses awarded to &bquo;talent&equo;, such as Jack Nicholson who, perhaps appropriately, played a villain called &bquo;The Joker&equo;. 
 These clauses give the talent a percentage of the movie's gross receipts. 
 Often these percentages rise along with the film's revenues. 
 As a result, Mr Nicholson himself may have received more than &dollar;50m. 
 Even so, Warner may have made a &bquo;profit&equo; out of the film after all, by charging itself a huge distribution fee. 
 Film actors are not the only ones getting vastly rich: some pop stars command sums that would have been unthinkable only a decade ago. 
 In 1977 the music industry gaped when Prince received &dollar;1m to make three albums for Warner Brothers. 
 This month Janet Jackson signed a deal with Virgin Records to make the same amount of music for more than &dollar;30m. 
 And on March 20th her brother Michael completed his long-running negotiations with Sony. 
 The details of the contract remain secret, but industry insiders speculate that Mr Jackson will receive more than &dollar;110m for six records. 
 Both Virgin and Sony are taking big gambles on the Jacksons. 
 In Janet's case, the success of her two latest albums, which sold a combined total of 14m copies, are no guarantee of future hits. 
 Even the biggest stars rarely sell 6m copies (as Janet must do if Virgin is to make a profit) for more than a couple of records. 
 But it is Michael Jackson's deal which may set precedents the music business will later regret. 
 As part of a sweeping agreement, Mr Jackson will do more than make music for Sony; he will also run his own record label, Nation Records, under the auspices of a new media company, the Jackson Entertainment Complex, a 50&ndash;50 joint venture with Sony Software. 
 And he will appear in at least one feature film for Columbia, which Sony owns. 
 As a singer, Mr Jackson is a certifiable megastar. 
 Though he has not released a record in five years, his success in the 1980s was astronomical: his three solo albums sold more than 75m copies altogether, his two home-videos 1m each. 
 But there is no evidence that Mr Jackson's popularity can be extended to other media, such as film. 
 Efforts at turning him into a sort of global brand &mdash; a line of shoes for L.A. Gear, toys called &bquo;Michael Jackson's Pets&equo; &mdash; have failed miserably. 
 And the idea of this odd man, his chimpanzee and oxygen tent in tow, running a business is bizarre.  
 Magazine publishing 
 Rich and titled 
 EVEN nerds can read. 
 America's computer buffs spent &dollar;110m last year buying magazines about their machines, and computer makers another &dollar;670m advertising in them. 
 One of the publishers most successful at catering for this hunger for information is International Data Group (IDG), a firm that has grown big by breaking many of the management rules cherished by other big publishers. 
 Founded in 1967 by Patrick McGovern, a market-researcher, IDG has grown with the industry it covers. 
 Today the company boasts 150 titles in 49 different countries, each dealing with a slightly different aspect of the computer trade. 
 Last year IDG reported &dollar;431m in sales net of commissions to its ad-space salesmen, and made after-tax profits of &dollar;25m. 
 Remarkably, Mr McGovern has never had to sell equity in his firm to outside investors, though he has given away nearly 30% to motivate employees. 
 Mr McGovern also claims to be free of the banks, never having incurred much long-term debt. 
 How did he do it? 
 By staying decentralised, and by starting most new magazines cheaply in-house, rather than by acquiring them, which is what most publishers do if they want to grow quickly. 
 &bquo;We think small is beautiful. 
 If people have total control over their business they will have the best possible emotional involvement,&equo; he says. 
 IDG is divided into 78 business units, each turning over about &dollar;6m a year. 
 The company as a whole employs 3,800 people, but only 22 of them are at corporate headquarters in Boston. 
 Every month each unit manager receives a report on how all the other units are doing. 
 Each unit is ranked according to profitability and profit growth, which helps spur competition between IDG managers and &mdash; with any luck &mdash; encourages them to learn from each other. 
 Units have lots of independence. 
 After being hired &bquo;I sat here for five weeks waiting for a telephone call,&equo; says Terry Chellew, the boss of IDG's British magazines. 
 But decentralisation &bquo;only works as long as you have got the right management team in locally,&equo; he admits. 
 His predecessor's pet title, Computer News, closed after running up big losses. 
 Although only financial control is centralised, IDG reaps some advantages from being a global group. 
 Articles can be shared by publications in different countries. 
 &bquo;People are very cautious in their own country about talking to the press. 
 But then they fly off to Stockholm and have a couple of drinks. 
 They're amazed that what they thought was a quiet little Swedish story appears round the world the next day,&equo; says Mr McGovern. 
 Fewer will be amazed if Mr McGovern keeps bragging. 
 Despite its undoubted success, IDG has lost parts of its core home market for many of the same reasons it has succeeded abroad. 
 America's two most popular PC magazines, PC Magazine and PC Week, are both owned by a rival, Ziff Communications. 
 IDG never spent the money necessary to make InfoWorld, IDG's biggest PC title, competitive, claims one former employee. 
 According to Communications Trends, a market-research firm, Ziff held 37% of the American market for computer magazines in 1990, up from 34% the previous year. 
 IDG's share has stuck at 27%. 
 In order to expand away from America's competitive magazine market, Mr McGovern has started spending his money in some new, riskier ways. 
 In 1990 he launched ten titles in Eastern Europe and Russia. 
 This year he plans still more. 
 Last April he spent &dollar;25m purchasing a small chain of PC-training schools in America. 
 Computer-training is a fast-growing market, but a very different one from publishing. 
 Like most successful independent entrepreneurs, Mr McGovern loves talking big about his company. 
 In 1987 he predicted that IDG's sales would reach &dollar;1 billion in 1990. 
 Now the &dollar;1 billion goal has shifted to 1993 and he talks of &dollar;5 billion by 2000. 
 Again, like most successful entrepreneurs, he knows the value of showmanship. 
 Employees' Christmas bonuses are handed out personally. 
 At a managers' jamboree in Beijing, he dressed up as Confucius. 
 In Boston he was Benjamin Franklin. 
 To his senior executives' chagrin, Mr McGovern always flies economy class and is proud of it. 
 Maybe so, but he splashes out when he gets there. 
 The Economist interviewed him in a chintzy suite at Claridge's.  
 Tycoonski 
 WARSAW 
 CONTRARY to popular belief, not all Poles are penniless factory workers perpetually on strike. 
 Wprost, a Polish weekly, recently published a list of the 100 wealthiest Poles, revealing who managed to make money and how during 45 years of Communist rule. 
 Topping the list is Barbara Piasecka-Johnson, who does not really count: she inherited her &dollar;550m fortune from her husband, chairman of America's Johnson and Johnson company, whom she met while working as a maid in his house. 
 At number two is Wojciech Fibak, who turned his professional-tennis earnings into a &dollar;50m property empire and a unique collection of 19th-century Polish art. 
 The real entrepreneurs begin at number three with Piotr Buchner, who is the co-owner of import-export firms in Poland, Britain, Switzerland and Panama, and number four, Aleksander Gawronik, a former money changer and self-made banker. 
 He founded the Bank Poznanski, one of Poland's first private banks, and now estimates his monthly income at several hundred thousand dollars. 
 Sixth on the list is Henryk Stoklosa, a senator whose fortune comes from an animal-waste-rendering business which has an estimated monthly turnover of &dollar;2m. 
 In numbers seven, 13 and 66 are a clothing-manufacturer, Leonard Prasniewski (who is said to fly to his summer home by helicopter); Mieczyslaw Wilczek, a meat-packer; and an ex-bureaucrat, Ireneusz Sekula. 
 All are currently co-owners of a mysterious consulting firm called Pol-Nippon, a Polish-Japanese joint venture that, among other things, is bidding to build a refinery and port near Gdansk. 
 Mr Wilczek was best known as minister of industry under Poland's last Communist government. 
 Mr Sekula is best remembered as vice-premier in the same government. 
 Both still have close ties to Poland's old Communist Party, as do most of the other top 100. 
 Many of those engaged in &bquo;export&equo; were cheating customs regulations; many of those involved in &bquo;trading&equo; were cheating state companies. 
 One who does not have ties to the old regime is ninth on the list: Janusz Lekszton, a 29-year-old Gdynia-based entrepreneur whose firm, EL-GAZ, produces gas stoves, pipes and other building materials. 
 Mr Lekszton's future plans include a private television station and an airline. 
 Other brave souls fought regulations and anti-capitalist prejudice to produce wire, cosmetics, costume jewellery, doors and windows, spectacle frames, potato crisps &mdash; all cheap consumer products which big state companies overlooked or made badly. 
 There is one media mogul: number 92, Joanna Stolarska, publisher of the Polish edition of Playboy. 
 Presumably for tax reasons, most refused to list their incomes and the magazine compiled its list with educated guesses, as Forbes and Fortune do with their much longer, global rich-lists. 
 But the Polish 100 are getting richer. 
 When asked what cars they preferred to drive, most named Mercedes and BMW, with one or two expressing a fondness for private aircraft.  
 Tricks of the trade 
 The huge current-account imbalances of the 1980s are disappearing fast. 
 Good news? 
 Maybe. 
 But be warned: trade flows are less and less useful as indicators of economic performance 
 BOTH America and Britain will probably run current-account surpluses in one of the next few months. 
 A couple of years ago this would have sounded like fiction; soon it may be fact. 
 America is likely to have a current-account surplus in the first or second quarter of this year, thanks to the &dollar;40 billion-50 billion promised by foreign governments to help pay for the cost of the Gulf war. 
 These payments are included in official transfers in its invisibles balance. 
 America's visible-trade balance is also shrinking, so some forecasters are expecting a current-account deficit as small as &dollar;20 billion-30 billion (0.3% of GNP) for 1991 as a whole. 
 Meanwhile, Britain's current-account deficit of &pound;20 billion (&dollar;31 billion, or 3.6% of GDP) in 1989 fell to an annual rate of only &pound;4.1 billion in the six months to February, and the odd monthly surplus may soon appear. 
 Germany's current account, which shifted into deficit in January, is also likely to be near balance for the year as a whole, while Japan's current-account surplus is now running at a quarter of its 1986 level. 
 Indeed, the average current-account balance (ignoring whether the balance is a surplus or deficit) of the big seven industrial economies is forecast to fall to only 0.6% of their collective GNP this year, down from a peak of 3.0% in 1986. 
 Economists and politicians are already celebrating the disappearance of these huge external imbalances &mdash; even those who only a few years ago claimed that current-account deficits did not matter. 
 The shrinking of trade imbalances is welcome, not least because a smaller American deficit and a smaller Japanese surplus will still the clamour of protectionists. 
 But the fact remains that current-account balances are becoming less and less helpful as a guide to economic performance, let alone as a goal for economic policy. 
 Current-account imbalances caused fewer headaches than many economists predicted in the 1980s. 
 This was partly because the increasing integration of world capital markets has made it easier to finance current-account deficits. 
 When exchange rates were fixed and capital movements were restricted, a current-account deficit was financed mainly by running down limited foreign-exchange reserves. 
 Today, with highly mobile international capital, large deficits can be sustained for much longer. 
 But financial liberalisation and the greater integration of the world economy have not only made current-account deficits easier to sustain; they have also made trade flows less useful as an indicator of national competitiveness. 
 As a result of the expansion in foreign direct investment, trade deficits are no longer purely national concepts: a large chunk of a country's exports and imports may be accounted for by foreign firms with bases there. 
 The gross outflow of direct investment abroad by the five big OECD economies increased sevenfold between 1983 and 1989. 
 One of the driving forces behind this recent expansion is the growth of services. 
 Unlike goods, many services, such as hotels and restaurants, cannot be traded; instead, companies have to establish businesses abroad. 
 Foreign direct investment by manufacturers has also grown rapidly over the past decade as firms chased lower costs, moved closer to their markets and tried to dodge protectionist barriers. 
 Today a car manufacturer might make engines in one country, steering wheels in another and then assemble the car in a third. 
 This integration of production across national borders tends to increase the overall volume of world trade because a good changes hands at various levels of production and not just at the final stage. 
 In a book published last year by the Royal Institute of International Affairs, &bquo;Global Companies and Public Policy&equo;, DeAnne Julius estimated that trade between firms and their overseas affiliates accounts for more than half of all trade between OECD countries. 
 A third of America's exports go to American-owned firms abroad. 
 Another third is accounted for by the goods shipped by foreign firms in America to their home country. 
 There is another way in which trade figures today mean less than they once did. 
 Firms can choose to supply an overseas market either by exporting to it or by locating production there. 
 Locally produced sales by American firms in Japan, however, do not count as exports, nor do their local purchases of inputs count as imports. 
 But from the firm's point of view the local sales of a subsidiary are as much foreign sales as any export is. 
 On this basis, Ms Julius reckons that the total foreign sales of American companies are five times the value of their recorded exports. 
 And 11 of the 12 biggest OECD countries sell more in America through foreign subsidiaries based there than through exports. 
 If America's &bquo;trade&equo; balance is measured on the basis of nationality of ownership rather than residency (ie, adding the sales, net of local purchases, of overseas subsidiaries to the recorded trade balance and deducting all intra-firm flows to avoid double counting), then in 1986 America's recorded visible-trade deficit of &dollar;144 billion is transformed into a &dollar;57 billion surplus. 
 Doing the same calculations today would probably give America the world's biggest trade surplus. 
 Now that capital and entrepreneurship are free to cross borders, the old trade measures may conceal as much as they reveal. 
 National competitiveness &mdash; if that is defined as the ability of a country's firms to compete in world markets, whether through export or overseas production &mdash; may be more important, at least to businessmen. 
 The more a nation's companies locate factories abroad, the smaller will be that country's recorded exports, yet its manufacturers may still be expanding their share of world markets. 
 Whether this is a better measure of national competitiveness is still unclear. 
 It would find few backers among politicians worried about jobs and living standards rather than market share. 
 Foreign direct investment will go on growing, and probably faster than trade. 
 In which case, international rules on competition policy and direct investment will start to replace trade policy as the most contentious areas of economic relations.  
 Come back, Waltons 
 NEW YORK 
 MORALISTS may bemoan the decline of the traditional American family. 
 But the companies that sell consumer goods in America feel real grief at its passing. 
 They can no longer rely on conventional market research to predict accurately the spending habits of ageing baby boomers or their children. 
 This has huge commercial consequences: household-related spending accounts for 20% of America's GNP. 
 According to figures from the Census Bureau, among all households the share of traditional homes (a married couple with one child younger than 18 living at home) has declined from 40% in 1970 to 26% last year. 
 But the reason that market researchers have been thrown a baby-boomerang by this goes beyond rising divorce rates and smaller families. 
 Fewer Americans are marrying at all, according to Dick Hokenson, a demographer at Donaldson Lufkin &amp; Jenrette, a New York stockbroker. 
 He reckons that 20% of the baby-boom generation will never marry. 
 The figure for all preceding generations is 6%. 
 Who knows what the next generation will do? 
 As a result, becoming an adult and setting up a household no longer mean the same thing. 
 Yet a surprisingly large proportion of market research is still based on the spending patterns of the baby boomers' parents, and so implicitly assumes that they are all but identical. 
 This is plainly wrong, though no one is sure just how wrong. 
 Try selling nappies and dogfood to someone who lives alone and never intends to have a baby or a dog. 
 FINANCE 
 Japanese property 
 Still shaky 
 TOKYO 
 HOPES are growing among policy makers, bankers and developers that Japan's property market is bottoming out. 
 The Bank of Japan even cites this sanguine view as a reason not to be pushed into a premature easing of monetary policy. 
 It is the celebrations that are premature. 
 Continuing monetary tightness is squeezing property speculators. 
 In February every measure of the money supply slowed. 
 The most important, M2 plus certificates of deposit, grew by 5.5%, year-on-year, down from 11.8% as lately as October. 
 That suggests that a credit crunch is taking place, especially since banks are still under orders from the central bank not to increase lending to property companies beyond the overall rate of loan growth, which has itself been restricted since October. 
 Property companies became hooked on borrowing in recent years. 
 In five years to last September, Japan's 50 biggest increased their borrowing by 330% to &yen;14 trillion (&dollar;10 billion), according to a new survey by Tokyo Shoko Research. 
 Most worrying are smaller companies which borrowed heavily but do not have big banks behind them. 
 An extreme example is MDI, a quoted housing developer whose borrowing rose 23-fold in those five years. 
 The combination of tight money and high debt is causing more than token distress. 
 Bankruptcies, mostly property-related, totalled &yen;931 billion in the first two months of 1991, and the total will rise in the new financial year, starting April 1st, as banks pull the plug on other overborrowed customers. 
 The banks have been holding off up till now, because they did not want loan losses further to dent their earnings, already hit by the stockmarket fall, in the current financial year. 
 Japanese banks have great flexibility in this: they do not have to declare loans non-performing until after a year of non-payment of interest (as against 90 days in America). 
 A growing number of companies are already publicly known to be distress sellers of property. 
 Barclays de Zoete Wedd has compiled from media reports alone a list of would-be sellers of around &yen;1 trillion worth. 
 They include Azabu Group, which plans to sell 60 properties worth around &yen;200 billion by the end of June; Itoman, a trading company which hopes to sell and lease back its Osaka headquarters for &yen;80 billion as a first step towards paying off its debt of &yen;1.3 trillion, much of it owed to Sumitomo Bank; and MDI, which wants to unload &yen;50 billion out of &yen;150 billion worth of residential property that it holds for development. 
 A total of &yen;1 trillion may seem puny in a property market which is valued, in theory, at &yen;2,000 trillion. 
 But such sales are important: property bulls have always argued that prices cannot fall because there are hardly ever any transactions. 
 And the figure includes only those companies that have publicly admitted their readiness to sell. 
 The real amount for sale is probably several times higher. 
 The weakest sector is the residential-apartment market, where price discounting and subsidised financing are on the increase. 
 Recruit Cosmos, once the centre of a political scandal, has through its finance affiliate been lending money to would-be buyers of its flats at only 0.6% annual interest for the first five years. 
 In January, for the first time since April 1985, fewer than 50% of new apartments in the greater Tokyo area were sold; Daikyo, Japan's leading apartment-block developer, had a nationwide sales rate of only 47%. 
 The real picture is even worse, since 10% of contracted sales fall through, as buyers pull out because they are nervous or cannot get the finance. 
 Meanwhile, plenty of new flats are being built and coming on to the market: developers have rushed to get their projects completed in the hope of selling before demand dried up. 
 Conditions are firmer in the office market, where rents and values are underpinned by a vacancy rate of just 0.2% in the central business district of Tokyo. 
 Whether this will persist is another matter. 
 A survey late last year by Mori Building, a big development company, calculated that 85m square feet (7.9m square metres) of office space is scheduled to be built &mdash; in large blocks alone &mdash; in the 23 wards of Tokyo over the next five years, 87% more than was completed in the past five. 
 Optimists say that fast-multiplying electronic equipment rather than people will take up the space. 
 Even if this is true, it cannot last. 
 Companies will start start moving their back offices from central Tokyo to cheaper areas. 
 The nearly completed World Business Garden building in Chiba, 30 minutes by train from central Tokyo, offers ultra-modern office space at a monthly rent of &yen;5,000 per square metre (&dollar;40 a year per square foot) one-sixth of rents in Tokyo's prime office buildings.  
 Swiss stockmarkets 
 Joining the world 
 GENEVA 
 AT LONG last there are moves afoot in Switzerland to give stockmarket investors a better deal. 
 They come not a moment too soon, if Switzerland is to preserve its position as a front-ranking international financial centre. 
 For years investors have complained that the Swiss markets are too fragmented, too illiquid, too opaque and too expensive. 
 That did not matter much when rich foreigners used Switzerland simply as a safe home for their money. 
 Now that trading counts for more, it matters a lot. 
 Some 30&ndash;40% of the share capital of listed Swiss companies is owned by foreigners. 
 Swiss pension funds and insurance companies, meanwhile, own little. 
 Swiss moneymen say that, to persuade these conservative institutions to step up share buying, reforms are essential. 
 The stockmarkets are already changing. 
 Under pressure to cut costs, the big banks that dominate Swiss securities trading were no longer prepared to deal at seven regional exchanges, each with its own rules, regulations and supervisory body (or none). 
 By mid-1991, the banks have announced, they will take all securities trading to the three biggest exchanges: Zurich and &mdash; well behind &mdash; Geneva and Basle.The exchange in Lausanne closed in January; Neuch&acirc;tel and St Gallen follow on March 31st. 
 In June Berne will swap its traditional open-outcry system for telephone trading; but now that the big banks will no longer deal there in stocks quoted elsewhere, its future looks dim. 
 The Basle exchange too, with a turnover only a seventh that of Zurich, may not survive in the longer term if Swiss Bank Corporation, its biggest trader, decides to pull out. 
 Unification of the Swiss markets will become a practical possibility next year, when the three main bourses jointly introduce a fully computerised trading system. 
 This is due to start with bonds by mid-1992 and with the most widely traded equities perhaps a few months later. 
 Enthusiasts, pointing to the success of Switzerland's three-year-old electronic futures and options exchange, SOFFEX, say the SFr35m (&dollar;24m) project is essential to cut dealing costs, improve reporting of transactions and boost turnover. 
 But they admit that far more important will be a proposed new law on market supervision and investor protection, the first draft of which is expected in late spring. 
 It will provide a national regulatory system and a regulatory body to replace those of individual cantons. 
 A group of experts commissioned by the finance ministry is thought to have recommended much self-regulation, as in London. 
 But there is already a head of steam in parliament to make the proposed voluntary takeover code legally binding. 
 The planned rules would also cover reporting of trades, regulate brokers and other intermediaries, oblige quoted companies to provide better information and provide the beginnings of a system of investor protection. 
 Moneymen hope that parliament will act faster on this than it has on company-law reform. 
 Plans to revise that law, which dates from 1936, have been discussed for decades, and have been before legislators for eight years. 
 The law, framed to ward off takeovers from Nazi Germany, allows companies to refuse share registration, and so voting rights, to anyone they do not like &mdash; aggressive foreigners, for example. 
 The resulting tiered share structure, with some shares open only to Swiss, and bearer shares or other instruments for outsiders, has limited the market and depressed prices. 
 The immunity of Swiss companies to unfriendly or foreign takeovers came in for a pounding in 1988 after Nestl&eacute; took over Rowntree, a British confectioner, causing noisy British complaints about the lack of reciprocal opportunities. 
 Switzerland's parliamentarians, who until then had favoured continuing restrictions on foreigners, hastily changed their minds. 
 That year Nestl&eacute; &mdash; which accounts for a tenth of the Swiss stockmarket &mdash; opened its register to overseas investors, and a number of other companies have followed suit. 
 A new law, expected to be in force by 1993, would allow companies to restrict individual shareholdings to a given percentage, but would bar non-registration of shareholdings unless the company otherwise could not continue normal operations. 
 That is a reference to the &bquo;Lex Friedrich&equo; on foreign landholding. 
 Companies with a lot of land &mdash; notably insurance companies &mdash; have to show they are at least two-thirds Swiss-owned. 
 Bankers and others are already campaigning for relaxation of this law, to allow foreign investment in such Swiss companies. 
 Companies will also be under pressure not to apply narrow limits on shareholdings. 
 Nestl&eacute;'s 3% limit sounds low, but to reach it you would have to put &dollar;600m into Nestl&eacute; shares. 
 Smaller companies would be well advised to be more flexible if they want to attract pension-fund investment. 
 Hopes of attracting institutional cash have also been raised by a law limiting the proportion of assets that pension funds and insurance companies can hold in land, but increasing what they can hold in shares from 30% to 50%. 
 The institutions say they intend to raise the equity weighting in their portfolios from under 10% to perhaps 15% by the mid-1990s. 
 This could mean an extra SFr6 billion a year going into shares, says Bank Vontobel in Zurich. 
 But so far there has been little sign of it. 
 The key to winning institutional investment may lie elsewhere, in a revision of the hated stamp duty of up to 3% on securities transactions. 
 The finance minister, Otto Stich, reluctant to lose the SFr2 billion of revenue the tax brings in, is not being helpful. 
 He is prepared to drop the tax only on bond transactions between foreigners, and even then only if he can replace the lost revenue by introducing a broadly based value-added tax. 
 This unpopular idea goes to popular vote on June 2nd, under Switzerland's direct democracy. 
 Moneymen are not banking on the outcome.  
 European pension funds 
 Outside the cocoon 
 BRUSSELS 
 THE single market in Europe's financial services is supposed to come into being at the end of 1992. 
 The European Commission, busy with banking, investment services and insurance, has now realised, late in the day, that as long as 700 billion ecus-worth (&dollar;850 billion) of pension-fund assets remain wrapped in national rules, single the market cannot be. 
 Most EC governments restrict pension funds' freedom to invest as they choose. 
 Any such limits (beyond those of essential prudence) are in breach of the directive on free movement of capital, which came into force last July. 
 They still abound. 
 Portuguese and Danish funds may not invest in other countries. 
 Italian funds cannot hold more than 20% of their money in private companies. 
 No more than 5% of a German fund's assets can be in overseas bonds. 
 Belgian funds must put 15% of their technical reserves into Belgian government bonds. 
 As for management, Spain and Portugal exclude foreign firms. 
 Next month the commission plans to publish two draft directives on this topic. 
 The first will aim to remove restrictions on where the funds can invest, and who can manage them. 
 The second will seek to allow people to subscribe to pension funds in countries other than the one in which they live. 
 At present, a multinational company cannot run just one fund for all its staff; an employee moving from Britain to Spain has to join a different fund. 
 Other countries will smell British self-interest in these directives, and not just because Sir Leon Brittan is the commissioner who dreamed them up. 
 Freeing the pensions market will benefit firms with knowledge of international markets and fund management &mdash; notably, firms in London. 
 Since &mdash; outside the public sector, or some industry-wide schemes &mdash; only Britain offers &bquo;portable&equo; pensions, carried by employees from job to job, British pension funds can expect to win recruits from other countries. 
 They have, in any case, an appealing track record: their annual average return in the 1980s was (in dollars) 14%, compared to 9% for Belgian funds and 8% for those in Holland. 
 The Community's pension funds are already concentrated in Britain and Holland: pension-fund assets in Holland are equivalent to 81% of local GDP; in Britain, 55%; in Germany, 6%; in France and Belgium, 2%. 
 Most French and German employees contribute to schemes which do not involve invested funds, and so will not be covered by any EC directives. 
 Many French companies run &bquo;pay-as-you-go&equo; schemes, financing pensions from current contributions. 
 German companies typically hang on to employees' contributions and write pension liabilities on to their balance sheets. 
 Even among funded schemes there are wide variations. 
 British funds favour higher-risk assets such as equities. 
 Those in mainland Europe lean to bonds, loans and mortgages. 
 Thus German funds &mdash; some conventional funds do exist there &mdash; hold 35% of their assets in loans. 
 British funds have 86% of their assets in marketable securities, those in Germany 44%. 
 Of Sir Leon's aims, the hardest to realise will be to give people the right to join a foreign fund. 
 The directive will require mutual recognition of the various regulatory systems, and lay down general principles for national supervisors. 
 Funds will need &bquo;sufficient&equo; assets to meet liabilities, and be &bquo;sufficiently&equo; diversified and &bquo;sufficiently&equo; liquid. 
 There will also be rules to limit the amount that a fund can invest in its sponsoring company. 
 The directive will try to bridge differences in national tax and labour laws. 
 In a Spanish fund, more than half the members of its decision-making board must be employee representatives. 
 Britain has no such rule. 
 No pan-European fund could respect all 12 of the EC's current labour laws. 
 The directive will seek to compromise, saying, perhaps, that employee representatives should make up half the board. 
 British employers will no doubt object. 
 Tax will be an even tougher nut. 
 Some countries give tax relief on contributions to pension funds, others on benefits. 
 The directive will not require a unified tax system, but will insist that governments recognise certain national forms of fund as equivalent for tax purposes &mdash; so that, for instance, the British government would give relief on a British resident's contribution to a fund abroad. 
 Since tax questions have to be settled by unanimity in the Council of Ministers, the directive on pension-fund membership is promised a slow passage. 
 Pension-fund investment and management should prove easier. 
 Yet, although that directive will need only a qualified majority vote, it is unlikely to whisk through the council. 
 Governments will dread the prospect of funds shifting capital abroad. 
 Although it has few pension funds, France will be especially suspicious of liberalisation. 
 Any change elsewhere will intensify the debate in France on whether pay-as-you-go gives pensioners a good deal. 
 Were French employees to shift their contributions into conventional funds, today's pensioners would suffer and the government might have to step in. 
 The thought that the City of London is likely to gain most will not increase French enthusiasm.  
 Credit-rating agencies 
 Beyond the second opinion 
 THESE are the best of times for Moody's and Standard &amp; Poor's (S&amp;P), the two American companies that dominate the world business of rating government and corporate debt. 
 They earn their bread reckoning up for investors the risk of default. 
 When defaults proliferate, as they do during and after recessions, the two firms wield enormous clout in financial markets. 
 Their duopoly is not secure. 
 Their chief American competitors, Fitch and Duff &amp; Phelps, are redoubling efforts to win business. 
 In Europe, where credit ratings are not yet universal, the two face competition from IBCA, a decade-old specialist in bank credit. 
 Investment banks too are starting to publish opinions on credit, just as they do on equities. 
 But no one is about to oust Moody's and S&amp;P as market leaders. 
 Several trends have boosted the credit-raters' importance: 
 Recession. 
 The world's economic downturn has triggered a rash of defaults in commercial paper and long-term debt, particularly by unrated issuers. 
 In 1990, Moody's reckons, companies defaulted on &dollar;22 billion of bonds, the highest nominal figure in 20 years. 
 That has prompted investors to demand ratings from more issuers of debt and to take the ratings more seriously. 
 Cross-border finance. 
 Not long ago European companies could issue paper on the strength of their names alone; domestic investors would buy, believing that famous companies do not go bust. 
 Now some have &mdash; and foreign investors, less credulous anyway, are more needed than they used to be. 
 Less known companies certainly will not get cash from them without ratings, preferably from the two top firms. 
 Financial innovation. 
 Asset-backed debt, hybrid securities and the like are not new, but they are appearing more often. 
 Banks are issuing a stream of securities backed by mortgages, credit-card receivables and other assets stripped off their balance sheets. 
 The rating of such &bquo;structured financings&equo; is the fastest-growing segment of the raters' business. 
 Regulation. 
 Regulators are increasingly relying on ratings to measure and control risks undertaken by the institutions they oversee. 
 America's Securities and Exchange Commission, for example, recently restricted money-market funds' investments in low-rated commercial paper. 
 Normally issuers invite, and pay, the agencies to rate their debt (though Moody's, to the irritation of more than one issuer, has sometimes rated debt uninvited). 
 They are often aghast at the results. 
 At worst, a poor rating can put a company out of business. 
 At the least it is likely to drive up the cost of borrowing. 
 That happened in February when S&amp;P and Moody's downgraded some of Chrysler's debt. 
 The American car maker had guaranteed an issue of &dollar;1.1 billion of debt with interest rates linked to its credit ratings. 
 When the ratings fell, its interest bill jumped by &dollar;38m a year. 
 Upgraded companies, rare these days, can save correspondingly. 
 The markets' obsession with credit ratings has spawned a sideline for investment banks: advising clients how to spruce up their presentations to the rating agencies. 
 Poor ratings are especially bad for banks and other financial companies. 
 Because of their low ratings, some of America's biggest banks pay more for short- and long-term funds than do their industrial customers. 
 They can no longer lend at a profit to well rated corporate borrowers. 
 The business goes to stronger banks. 
 Issuers wish Moody's and S&amp;P were not so powerful: more competition among credit-raters might limit the damage caused by one bad rating. 
 Institutional investors, the main users of the ratings, share that wish. 
 The head of bond research at one large American institution calls the concentration of power in Moody's and S&amp;P dangerous. 
 Both do a good job, he says, but &bquo;I would rather see more judgments out there in the market.&equo; 
 Some investors complain that Moody's and S&amp;P were slow to recognise the financial deterioration of American banks and of certain state governments. 
 Some think the agencies' analysts risk becoming too friendly with the companies they rate. 
 More cogently, some observe that these analysts track the credit quality of up to 35 companies apiece, and are paid significantly less than equity analysts on Wall Street. 
 The second-tier agencies hope to exploit these feelings. 
 Duff &amp; Phelps, a Chicago-based company, recently merged with a competitor, and now claims to rate nearly three-quarters of corporate bonds publicly issued in America. 
 Fitch was acquired by new owners in 1989 and promptly raided senior executives from Moody's and S&amp;P. 
 In Europe, IBCA recently began rating debt issued by British industrial companies. 
 Robin Monro-Davies, its chief, says IBCA intends to become a full-fledged rater of European debt. 
 With only 26 analysts, mostly banking specialists, it still has far to go. 
 Some second-tier agencies have adopted a kind of ratings machismo that promises investors harsher verdicts than those handed down by Moody's and S&amp;P. 
 Fitch recently published tough criteria for rating bond insurers, companies that use their financial clout to secure triple-A ratings for bonds issued by local governments and other issuers. 
 Fitch reckons that not all bond insurers deserve the top rating; those that do, it believes, suffer because investors do not trust the triple-As assigned to the insured debt by Moody's and S&amp;P. 
 The agency plans to assign its own ratings to bond insurers. 
 Moody's and S&amp;P try to stay above this fray. 
 The principles of credit rating are immutable, they insist; their credit opinions are never swayed by the judgments of others. 
 This is hard to believe, but impossible to disprove. 
 Yet the top two do not feel as smug as they may sound. 
 Investors say both have improved their services since they started to face serious competition. 
 And though Moody's and S&amp;P rate nearly all big debt issues in America, they are not taking Europe for granted. 
 S&amp;P has expanded largely through joint ventures and acquisitions. 
 It owns half of a French rating agency, ADEF, and all of Nordisk, a Swedish firm. 
 Its overseas staff has risen three-fold in the past five years, to 75 analysts. 
 Moody's says a quarter of its staff is non-American. 
 It rates four-fifths of Euro-commercial paper and two-thirds of longer-term Eurobonds. 
 Competitors could challenge Moody's and S&amp;P more easily if the two leaders made more mistakes. 
 They do not make many. 
 In 20 years only one company with an investment-grade rating from Moody's has defaulted on long-term debt &mdash; Manville, a single-A company that went bankrupt voluntarily to protect itself from asbestosis lawsuits. 
 A New Zealand finance company, DFC, defaulted on its commercial paper in 1989 while still carrying a prime rating by S&amp;P. 
 The agency says it relied on a government commitment to provide liquidity, but the government reneged. 
 Moody's and S&amp;P sell reams of information on the companies they rate, but say little about themselves. 
 Though the collapse of the junk-bond market cut business in 1990, both agencies make money. 
 But, both being owned by larger companies &mdash; Moody's by Dun &amp; Bradstreet, S&amp;P by a publishing firm, McGraw-Hill &mdash; they need not disclose their financial details, and do not. 
 Lucky folk, they do not need credit ratings.  
 Regional, but less super 
 NEW YORK 
 WHO in his right mind would want an American bank anyway? 
 Banking profitability &mdash; not to mention a good many banks &mdash; has collapsed over the past decade. 
 Last year one in seven of the country's more than 12,000 banks was unprofitable, and one in four of the 49 biggest. 
 This year does not promise to bring much improvement. 
 For the 11 big money-centre banks whose statistics Salomon Brothers records, return on assets fell in 1990 to about 0.3%. 
 If there is any silver lining to their dark cloud, it is the dubious one that the super-regional banks &mdash; for most of the 1980s the successes of American banking &mdash; also are on their way down (or, like Bank of New England, out). 
 While, as the chart shows, the money-centre ones appear in the autumn of 1990 to have touched bottom and to be on the way up again. 
 Among 24 regional banks, 11 managed an acceptable return on assets of more than 1% in 1989, and on equity of at least 15%. 
 This year just five did so. 
 The recession on the east coast has taken a heavy toll of banks there. 
 All banks are suffering from a mounting pile of bad loans, especially against property, and the slowing of commercial lending. 
 The regional ones seem just to have hit the trouble later. 
 Over the year the total of their non-performing loans rose by 32%, against 26% for the money-centre banks. 
 Write-offs also rose faster at the regionals than at the money-centre banks. 
 The other vital factor for banks' profitability in today's harsh climate is cost control. 
 Here the regionals started with the advantage of not being as bloated as the big banks in the first place, and most of them have stayed that way. 
 But they too have been losing this battle. 
 For the money-centre banks, non-interest expenses as a percentage of operating revenue had reached 75% by the end of the fourth quarter of last year, against 70% one year before. 
 For the regional banks the ratio increased from 64% to 68% over the same period. 
 In the longer term, the best of the regional banks, such as Banc One (based in Columbus, Ohio), First Wachovia (North Carolina) and NBD Bancorp (Michigan), ought to prosper. 
 Regionals tend to have natural franchises and are likely to get the best pickings of whatever expanded powers commercial banks may get out of the pending reform of the financial system, once Congress gets round to letting it happen. 
 They are also starting to attract some of the best young talent away from the money-centre banks &mdash; and good brains allied to the skills of good management are almost as scarce as profits in America's banking parlours these days.  
 Junk bonds twitching in the morgue 
 America's junk-bond market refuses to die, though some of the returning life in it may be strictly temporary 
 FOR a supposed corpse, America's junk-bond market has developed an unnerving habit of sporadically twitching into life. 
 Prices perk up, trading volume revives and stories of return from the grave are polished up. 
 Yet the promised resurrection of the &dollar;200 billion-plus market has never quite happened. 
 The current convulsions began a year ago. 
 They halted as the invasion of Kuwait brought home fears of recession. 
 Now they have started again, as investors convince themselves that the worst of the recession is over; as some junk-bond issuers take advantage of falling interest rates and the stockmarket rally to refinance their debt more cheaply or turn it into equity; and as bond-raiders speculate in distressed companies that they think may restructure themselves or be taken over. 
 The yield to maturity on the active-issues index of Donaldson, Lufkin &amp; Jenrette, a Wall Street brokerage, fell below 19% last month for the first time since September. 
 But this remains an erratic market. 
 Among the big gainers, Tonka's 16.5% 1997 bond, Macy's 14.5% 1998, Southland's 14.5% 1995 and RJR Nabisco's 17% 2007 have all seen their price rise by half or more this year. 
 The rise in the Tonka bond was helped by a takeover bid from another toymaker, Hasbro. 
 Harcourt Brace Jovanovich and Morningstar Foods were two other junk issuers who attracted similar bids from firms looking for cheap assets. 
 This has led vulture-investors to the bonds of other prospective bid victims such as USG, a building-materials group, American Standard, which makes plumbing fixtures, or Burlington Industries, a textiles firm. 
 None of this is for the faint-hearted. 
 Eastern Airlines, long a takeover candidate, found itself in bankruptcy, not the arms of a suitor. 
 And taking over debt is harder than taking over equity. 
 It needs the near-unanimous assent of holders. 
 Some have learned to play hard-to-get. 
 This can quickly turn into a game of bluff. 
 Among half a dozen debt restructurings called off last year were those of Southland and Insilco. 
 Both later filed for Chapter 11 protection. 
 Issuers are increasingly seeking pre-packed bankruptcies as part and parcel of restructurings, to deal with awkward bond-holders. 
 Another stimulus to the market has come from issuers buying back bonds, to retire the debt entirely or swap it for new equity. 
 Though such a swap is a better deal for a company's bond-holders than for shareholders, shareholders have been prepared to accept the dilution, reckoning that cutting debt more than offsets it. 
 When McCaw Cellular Communications announced it was to swap &dollar;600m of its junk bonds for stock, the price of the bonds shot up. 
 RJR Nabisco's plans to buy back &dollar;1.5 billion of its debt were received in much the same way. 
 The vultures have been buying up other bonds likely to be similarly treated. 
 They include bonds of Dr Pepper, a soft-drinks maker, Duracell Holdings, which makes batteries, and the Time Warner entertainment group. 
 Only a few junk-bond issuers will be able to use debt-for-equity swaps. 
 There has to be an underlying business attractive to equity investors. 
 A rising equity market helps. 
 Otherwise, junk issuers wanting to cut their debt might have to resort to the bankruptcy courts to encourage their debt-holders to accept stock. 
 If the current pace of repurchases is sustained, more than &dollar;10 billion of bonds could vanish this year. 
 Last year repurchases totalled &dollar;7 billion, among total subtractions from the market of &dollar;13 billion. 
 This was more than offset by &dollar;22 billion of additions, half from &bquo;fallen angels&equo;, formerly investment-grade debt downgraded to junk during the year. 
 True new issues amounted to a mere &dollar;1.2 billion, against &dollar;24 billion in 1989 &mdash; the last year before Drexel Burnham Lambert, nurturer of the market, went under. 
 Despite the recent activity in the secondary market, many of the factors that caused the contraction in the primary market last year remain in evidence. 
 They continue to be sources of selling pressure. 
 The weakness of the economy still makes it harder for companies to service their debt. 
 The rating agencies continue to downgrade bonds. 
 Defaults continue to rise. 
 Last year they doubled to &dollar;18 billion, including Campeau and Continental Airlines. 
 With big increases in the numbers of bonds falling due over the next three years, defaults seem sure to rise further. 
 Regulators are still trying to get tougher about the junk in financial institutions' portfolios. 
 The biggest holders are insurance companies. 
 They hold almost a third of junk bonds outstanding. 
 The industry is split over whether to set itself a 20% or 35% ceiling on the percentage of assets that junk bonds can account for. 
 Some states are imposing their own more restrictive caps. 
 The Resolution Trust Corporation, the federal agency that takes over bust thrifts, also has a multi-billion junk-bond portfolio that came with its dilapidated charges. 
 It has sold some &dollar;3 billion of junk bonds. 
 Some congressmen are pushing it to sell the rest as fast as it can. 
 The agency wants to keep them as collateral for a securitisation package it plans to sell later this year. 
 And it does not want to knock the stuffing out of a fragile market. 
 The junk-bond industry has been indulging in some quasi-securitisation of its own. 
 Salomon reckons that last year &dollar;2.3 billion-worth of junk bonds were re-packaged as collateralised bond obligations (CBOs), and that currently up to &dollar;1 billion-worth are being touted to investors. 
 If CBOs can be developed as a market, junk bondsters hope that it would provide a new source of demand. 
 Another twitch.  
 Sid's mini-flutter 
 OVER a quarter of British adults &mdash; 11m of them &mdash; own shares, says a new survey done for the Treasury and the London stock exchange. 
 In 1983 the total was only 2m. 
 But the habit is barely skin-deep. 
 The startling rise is mostly due to the privatisations of state companies, boosted with high-profile advertising and low share prices. 
 Over 6m first-time shareholders &mdash; the admen's &bquo;Sid&equo;, the character who bought British Gas &mdash; got their shares in one of the state sell-offs. 
 Buying these shares was good news. 
 If Sid put &pound;100 (&dollar;175) into each of the big privatisations and sold his shares on the first day of trading &mdash; as many such investors did &mdash; he would (before expenses) have got back an extra 41%. 
 Yet patience would have paid still better. 
 If Sid chose to hang on, he could now sell his shares for around 85% more than he paid &mdash; a far better deal than he would have got buying the market as a whole. 
 If he had put a second &pound;100 into the FT-SE index each time he bought from the state, the resulting shares would now be worth only a little over a third more than he paid. 
 Should Sid still hang on? 
 Well, the market will probably be up a year from now, and if he holds shares in all the ex-state companies (36, less two taken over) his risks are tolerably spread, with worthy water companies balancing clouded bits of aerospace. 
 All he need fear is a general postponement of Britain's economic recovery. 
 The real Sid, though, is not like that. 
 On any risk analysis, he should sell and run back to his building society: over half of Britain's 11m shareholders own shares in only one company, three-quarters in one or two. 
 Still, many of these Sids can surely afford such a flutter on the stockmarket: one quarter of the 11m own shares worth less than &pound;500 &mdash; &dollar;875 or, more simply, in any currency, peanuts.  
 Santander and First Fidelity 
 Into the breach 
 ARE European banks about to invade America &mdash; again? 
 On March 19th Banco de Santander, Spain's brightest bank, bought a stake in First Fidelity, a bank with &dollar;28 billion of assets and 550 branches in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. 
 The sirens that drew Santander into America's shattered banking market could tempt other European banks as well. 
 For Santander, First Fidelity is a bargain on two counts. 
 Even after this year's vigorous rally in their share prices, American banks are cheap by historical standards. 
 Santander paid &dollar;220m for its 13% stake in First Fidelity (and for an option to raise the stake to 23%), roughly the same amount as the stake's book value. 
 Britain's National Westminster, by contrast, paid 2.4 times book value for its ill-fated venture into New Jersey. 
 What makes First Fidelity look even cheaper is the weakness of America's dollar. 
 In peseta terms, the cost of American assets has fallen by about 5% in the past year. 
 Even if First Fidelity's shares stagnate, Santander can expect to make a profit on a recovery of the dollar alone. 
 Still, Santander is brave to sail through shoals that nearly wrecked other foreign venturers. 
 NatWest's American subsidiary lost &dollar;350m in 1990, mostly on making loans to shaky companies; its chief executive has just quit. 
 Marine Midland, a subsidiary of the Hongkong and Shanghai Bank, lost &dollar;300m last year for the same reason. 
 Because it owns First New Hampshire Bank, Bank of Ireland took a bath in New England, America's most depressed banking market. 
 First Fidelity, at least, is on the way up. 
 Its new chairman, Tony Terracciano, cleaned up the balance sheet last year by taking a special &dollar;300m provision. 
 That means Santander should not have to worry about the dud property loans plaguing other banks in the region. 
 The bank also slashed non-interest costs from 70% of income to 60% in 1990. 
 It now feels healthy enough to expand. 
 In February First Fidelity bought &dollar;2.5 billion of deposits and 48 branches from a bust savings bank in New Jersey. 
 Armed with new capital from Santander, it can expand further. 
 James McDermott, president of a bank-share specialist, Keefe, Bruyette &amp; Woods, expects First Fidelity to look for branches and banks in Connecticut and upstate New York. 
 That will make other capital-rich European banks envious. 
 Several have been window-shopping, mostly in recession-blighted regions where banks can be bought cheaply. 
 France's state-owned Banque Nationale de Paris briefly considered buying parts of Bank of New England, which went bust earlier this year. 
 Bank of Scotland was a disappointed bidder for two Texas banks. 
 Royal Bank of Scotland pulled out of negotiations to buy Bank Worcester, in Massachusetts, at the end of 1990. 
 Jealous of Santander's alliance, other European banks will be tempted to forge their own ties with well-managed, expansion-minded American banks. 
 Their envy would be misplaced, argues Christopher Wheeler, an analyst at Lehman Brothers in London. 
 Santander, he says, &bquo;has no business&equo; investing in American banks. 
 It is earning a healthy 20% return on capital on banking in Spain, its home market. 
 Unless First Fidelity beats that (few American banks do), the investment will prove a waste of shareholders' money. 
 And where is the synergy? 
 Financial products manufactured in Spain are unlikely to sell in suburban New Jersey. 
 First Fidelity and Santander talk of using each other's networks to offer trade financing to their customers. 
 But that, the American bank admits, is not the primary reason for the tie-up. 
 Emilio Botin, Santander's chairman, asserts that the First Fidelity stake &bquo;fits perfectly&equo; with Santander's other American alliances, a small shareholding in a financial group, Kemper, and a co-operation agreement with an insurer, Metropolitan Life. 
 How? 
 First Fidelity does not plan to sell MetLife insurance through its branches, even if the law is changed to allow it. 
 Equally puzzling is Santander's promise not to take majority control of First Fidelity. 
 That makes the investment look like little more than a punt on First Fidelity's shares &mdash; a profitable punt, perhaps, but a punt nonetheless. 
 After a history of foreign misadventures, other European banks should think twice before they follow Banco de Santander into America's treacherous banking market.  
 A job for Atlas and Hercules combined 
 WASHINGTON, DC 
 The World Bank has too many people costing too much and working in the wrong place. 
 It also has a new president. 
 So? 
 THE World Bank that Mr &lsqb;Lewis&rsqb; Preston takes over&equo;, crooned the Washington Post a week ago, &bquo;is in sound condition.&equo; 
 Financially maybe, otherwise not. 
 Insiders admit that by both external and internal measures, it has failed badly during the 1980s to live up to its promise. 
 Notably it did not respond coherently to the third world's debt burden, and to ten years of stalled poor-country growth, probably because it did not overhaul its own ponderous bureaucracy. 
 A retired chairman of J.P. 
 Morgan, Mr Preston, the bank's new president, will need all his organisational skills if (rightly) he decides in September to make that bureaucracy his first target. 
 What it needs is some Herculean stable-cleaning. 
 His predecessor, Barber Conable, who retires after five years in the seat, understood the size of that task when he arrived. 
 But he used the wrong tools. 
 In theory, he sacked thousands of staff. 
 But he then told each layer of management to appoint the layer below it. 
 They duly reappointed old friends, and the Bank's already notable tendency to fiefs and feudalism was reinforced. 
 Mr Conable therefore hands over a 6,000-strong Bank with annual staff costs of over &dollar;900m, &dollar;150,000 a head, bloated by perks such as first-class air travel. 
 On top of this, add 1,000 consultants, hired to do the work which the bank is &mdash; let us pretend &mdash; too understaffed or overworked to do for it itself. 
 The figures are absurd. 
 So is the concentration in Washington. 
 Only one-tenth of the staff work in poor countries. 
 When World Bankers do visit those countries, unco-ordinated teams fall over each other. 
 Czechoslovakia's finance ministry, for instance, is in despair these days as ten separate teams, each with a score of staff, crawl around its country. 
 Lack of direction led to meandering aims at the World Bank during the 1980s. 
 True, during his tenure Mr Conable quickly identified a number of themes &mdash; notably the environment and the role of women &mdash; that are now becoming central to development policy. 
 Yet only recently has he been affirming what he sees as the Bank's main job: to attack outright poverty &mdash; measured, for instance, in crude terms of calorific intake. 
 That ought to have been the World Bank's priority all along. 
 That it was not is largely due to the Bank's over-chummy relationship with client-country governments. 
 Economic orthodoxy over the past decade has rightly stressed the role of the private sector in development. 
 The Bank readily accepts this. 
 Yet in practice it has strengthened some countries' public sectors at the expense of their private ones. 
 Its lending has reinforced India's inept socialist policies. 
 In Colombia industries have been kept in the public sector just to get World Bank finance. 
 Some insiders argue that the Bank is ill-adapted to encourage private enterprise, because its articles of agreement forbid it to lend to the private sector. 
 These people, as well as America's Treasury, argue for changes to the articles. 
 Others say the best way to get private sectors working is to reform the public sector: the World Bank can use its clout with poor countries to insist on structural reforms when it lends them money. 
 A bit late: the bank's growth in lending, and therefore its leverage, except in a few countries like China, Vietnam and Argentina, is likely to slow in the coming years. 
 The conflict between public and private sectors is affecting relations between different bits of the World Bank group. 
 The International Finance Corporation (IFC), the Bank's private-sector arm, can make loans to the private sector as well as equity investments. 
 There are celebrated examples of bad communication between the Bank and the IFC; and the sides have confused clients by offering different prices for the same services. 
 A wide-ranging review (dread words) is now going on to resolve the conflicts. 
 It is more than just goodwill that rests on the outcome. 
 The IFC badly wants to double its capital with an injection of &dollar;1.3 billion from its government shareholders. 
 America's Treasury is blocking the move. 
 It thinks that even the IFC, particularly in the area of privatisation, is not adventurous enough. 
 It also wants the IFC to be less transaction-hungry and to talk more to governments about policy. 
 Since that would mean that the World Bank would talk less to governments, one of the Treasury's main reasons for bullying the IFC is in order to get at the Bank. 
 This is the world into which Mr Preston steps. 
 He is a man used to having his orders carried out, and there is no doubt that he has the toughness needed for cleaning out the bank. 
 An east-coast patrician in the style with which George Bush feels comfortable, he will also not flinch at meeting the rich heads of poor states. 
 In taking the job, Mr Preston, who two years ago insisted that J.P. 
 Morgan shake the dust of third-world debt from its feet (it made provisions against its entire exposure), now shows commendable sympathy for the world's ill-fed poor. 
 There's the rub. 
 The World Bank presidency has a habit of surrounding its occupants with a warm, well-meaning aura. 
 More than at any time in his 64 years, Mr Preston now needs his cool, commercial banker's brain. 
 And no sympathy at all for the well-fed hordes who stand in what should be his way. 
 AMERICA'S BLACKS 
 A world apart 
 America is riding high on a wave of post-Gulf confidence, but one part of the country is still missing out: the poverty-ridden ghettos where millions of black Americans live. 
 George Bush cannot afford to ignore them 
 ABSORB these figures about America's cities. 
 Nearly half of black teenagers in the city of Chicago fail to graduate from high school. 
 In Washington, DC, in 1989 nearly four times as many black men were jailed in the district's prison as graduated from its public schools; the leading cause of death among young black men is murder. 
 In the country as a whole a staggering two-thirds of black babies are born to unmarried mothers; 43% of black children are, by government criteria, born poor; many do not live to see their first birthday. 
 Last year's unemployment rate among blacks was 10.5%, more than twice that for whites. 
 Sealed off in inner-city ghettos, by-passed by fly-over freeways, black America is suffering out of sight. 
 Has America turned its back on its inner-city blacks? 
 Not all of them: a black middle class has mushroomed, from about one in ten blacks in 1960 to more than a third today. 
 But a scissors effect is cutting through America's blacks (see chart on next page). 
 Measured by the government's official poverty line &mdash; which counts as poor a family of four with an income below &dollar;12,675, in 1989 dollars &mdash; the proportion of blacks stuck at the bottom has refused to budge from around a third for the past 20 years, compared with a tenth of all whites. 
 The plight of inner-city blacks affects the whole of America. 
 The cost of the welfare system has skyrocketed: spending on all federal programmes more than tripled between 1965 and 1987, from &dollar;141 billion to &dollar;520 billion (in 1988 dollars). 
 During the rest of the 1990s the number of youngsters entering the workforce each year will be smaller than at any time since the second world war; but two-fifths will be from minorities, mostly Hispanics and blacks. 
 Corporate America is starting to wake up to all this. 
 Last year a group of 45 Fortune 500 chief executives and university presidents, known as the Business-Higher Education Forum, published a report saying that the country could not ignore the growing isolation of its inner-city minorities. 
 The authors, Steven Mason, president of the Mead Corporation, and Clifton Wharton, chairman of TIAA-CREF, the nation's largest private pension fund, say: &bquo;The population as a whole is ageing, the growth of the workforce is slowing, and the twin burdens of greater productivity and supporting an ageing population will fall mostly on younger workers&hellip; 
 Our society cannot afford to lose a single one of its young people.&equo; 
 True, not all the inner-city poor are black: on the west coast many are Mexican; in New York lots are Puerto Rican. 
 But wholly disproportionate numbers are black, and stuck in the nastiest parts of the most dangerous cities: Washington, DC, is over 70% black; Detroit 63%. 
 It is difficult to tease apart the chiefly race-caused problems from those caused by inner-city economics. 
 But policies intended for the poor in general, which are politically more acceptable than those designed for specific racial groups, will aim at a big section of blacks too. 
 Can't work, won't work 
 When Americans talk about an &bquo;underclass&equo; in their cities, they do not simply mean the poor; they mean poor but healthy young people who cannot or will not, but anyway do not, get a job. 
 The images are vivid: an unmarried mother who lives off welfare cheques; a young man who drifts from girlfriend to girlfriend, selling drugs to get by. 
 Estimates of the size of this underclass vary hugely from about 5% to 50% of all the poor &mdash; 2m-15m people, of whom some two-thirds are black, a tenth Hispanic. 
 Liberals tend to stress the &bquo;cannot&equo; work. 
 Smoke-stack industry jobs that used to pay a decent wage have been wiped out. 
 Twenty years ago mid-western steel workers could earn &dollar;20 an hour; today, it is hard to find replacement jobs in the service industries that offer &dollar;6&ndash;7 an hour. 
 In real terms, median black family income in the mid-west has fallen by nearly a third in the past 20 years, from &dollar;24,690 to &dollar;17,400. 
 For many young blacks, the only jobs that offer a secure future and steady income are in the armed forces. 
 Conservatives tend to stress the &bquo;will not&equo;: jobs exist, but people do not take them; jobs do not pay enough, or people do not try hard enough to find them. 
 Even with the country in recession, suburban papers are filled with wanted ads for waitresses, cleaners and cooks. 
 The view is widespread: a recent poll by the National Opinion Research Centre showed that 78% of whites think blacks are more likely than whites to &bquo;prefer to live off welfare&equo;. 
 The truth lies somewhere in between. 
 Hamburger-flipping jobs (&bquo;McJobs&equo;) that pay the minimum wage (&dollar;3.80 an hour in 1990) are fine for teenagers, but not for parents trying to support a family. 
 Inner-city blacks often see better-paid jobs as beyond their reach: they ask for too many qualifications, they are too far away, there is nobody to look after the children. 
 A hand up, not a hand-out 
 What irks conservatives most is their belief not only that inner-city blacks are unwilling to take jobs, but that the government pays to keep them unwilling. 
 The welfare system, runs this view, makes things worse because it discourages people from working and rewards undesirable behaviour. 
 The welfare hand-out that pains critics most is that given to poor, unmarried mothers: Aid to Families with Dependent Children (AFDC). 
 One of the most eloquent critics has been a conservative writer, Charles Murray. 
 He argues that, in seeking to protect children from poverty, AFDC has eased the financial strain of raising children alone; so more women do so. 
 His evidence: more and more babies were born to unmarried women during the past 30 years &mdash; which is when social-welfare spending shot up. 
 His prescription: abolish welfare. 
 Mr Murray's argument does not fit the facts. 
 First, there is no evidence that in states where AFDC payments are generous more children are born outside marriage. 
 Second, the lion's share of increased welfare spending since the 1960s has been on programmes most people approve of: social security (pensions) financed by tax on earnings, and medical insurance for old people (Medicare). 
 Spending on AFDC, in real terms, fell by nearly a fifth between 1975 and 1989 &mdash; the period that saw the biggest growth in illegitimate births. 
 It is even harder to blame an over-generous welfare system for joblessness among young men. 
 In America, unlike Europe, youngsters who have not paid unemployment contributions cannot claim welfare at all. 
 Many survive by &bquo;hustling&equo;: doing odd jobs here and there, often illegally. 
 The perverse result, in many poor neighbourhoods, is that a young man lives off his mother's or pregnant girlfriend's welfare cheques, or both. 
 Going out with girls who have babies is good news; the more girlfriends the better. 
 On Chicago's south side the day the monthly cheque arrives is nicknamed &bquo;mother's day&equo;, because that is when absent sons and husbands turn up. 
 So Mr Murray's criticism does have an important grain of truth in it. 
 Although AFDC is not generous, it may still be attractive. 
 In 1989, in a state with average AFDC payments, a single woman with two children who took a job at the minimum wage (then &dollar;3.35 an hour) would earn a paltry &dollar;33 more each month than if she did not work at all and stayed on welfare. 
 Research by David Ellwood, at Harvard University, shows that the surest way for a woman to escape poverty, and get off welfare, is not to work but to get married. 
 Mr Murray's solution is drastic. 
 A more measured response is not to abandon welfare but to shift the carrots: make welfare reward work. 
 In current White-House-speak: give people a hand up, not a hand-out. 
 If benefits were not deducted when mothers worked, they would not discourage working; if some benefits were available only for working mothers (child care, for instance), they would encourage it. 
 Liberals and conservatives are beginning to find common ground on one point: welfare should be strictly temporary &mdash; a transition back to work. 
 After the 1988 Family Support Act, states must help to provide one year of child care for mothers who leave welfare for a job or training. 
 Nursery education for poor children, like Head Start, undoubtedly improves later school performance. 
 What about young men (and young women without babies)? 
 Unlike Europe, America is against welfare payments available to everybody without a job, even those who have never worked. 
 Instead, policy concentrates on making work pay. 
 Some suggest tinkering with the tax system: raise the ceiling for tax-free earnings, or boost the earned-income tax credit for low-earners. 
 Others would like the minimum wage raised. 
 However, since young men are largely excluded from welfare benefits, they are best helped by programmes other than welfare reform. 
 Those mean streets 
 Five o'clock at State Street station, in downtown Chicago, and the platforms groan with homeward-bound commuters, wrapped up against the winter frost. 
 Peer more closely at the faces: on one side, heading south, all are black; on the other, heading north, nearly all are white. 
 According to one 1989 study, Chicago is the most racially segregated city in America, just beating Cleveland and Detroit. 
 Ending legal segregation has not been enough to end segregation itself. 
 Rich blacks have indeed moved out of the ghettos; but estate agents, anxious to protect property prices, still steer even rich blacks away from the nicest, lily-white suburbs. 
 For poor blacks, without money to move, living in an inner-city ghetto can mean days without seeing a white face. 
 The scale of segregation stuns: Chicago's black south side covers 50 square miles &mdash; bigger than the whole of Paris within the p&eacute;riph&eacute;rique. 
 This separation breeds prejudice; worse, it isolates young blacks from the white world that will judge them when they leave school. 
 No amount of insisting that black fashion, black history and black speech are as valid as white alters the fact that to get a decent job means to work where being able to &bquo;act white&equo; pays. 
 As one suburban employer in Chicago, whose staff deal with clients in the office, comments: &bquo;I just can't afford to take on somebody who says the plural of &bquo;woman&equo; is &bquo;womans&equo;.&equo; 
 It is not getting better: a recent study of 60 cities showed that black and white speech patterns are drifting further apart. 
 According to William Julius Wilson, of the University of Chicago, himself black, poor blacks are even more isolated because any rich blacks who can get out do so. 
 Gone are the movie-halls and lawyers' offices on Chicago's south side, once the ritzier part of town for blacks. 
 Shabby brick apartments stretch for block after block, dotted with little more than the odd liquor store, fried-chicken shack and cheque-cashing shop, well buttoned up with wire mesh and bullet-proof glass. 
 Policemen patrol only in cars. 
 Poor neighbourhoods, argues Mr Wilson, have lost great numbers of working people who used to set examples to local children. 
 Work habits (such as waking up every day to an alarm clock) that often flow over into responsible social attitudes (such as being a good father) are not being learnt. 
 It is hard for black youngsters, growing up in poor areas where few people have jobs, to see that &bquo;making it&equo; requires hard work and discipline. 
 Those who do &bquo;make it&equo; and can afford the status symbols &mdash; the heavy gold chains, the Nike trainers &mdash; are drug dealers; and, in Chicago, most drug traffic is controlled by gangs. 
 Along with rap artists and basketball players, these are the black men the black boys look up to. 
 Jobs, too, have left the ghettos; new jobs now grow quickest in the (white) suburbs. 
 Northeastern Illinois Planning Commission reckons that jobs in Du Page county, suburban Chicago, will grow by a whopping 120% between 1980 and 2010; in the city of Chicago, by a measly 6%. 
 Most programmes that try to move people and jobs have little success. 
 Enterprise zones &mdash; which seduce businesses into poor areas with attractive tax breaks &mdash; are currently back in vogue at the federal Department of Housing and Urban Development. 
 But experience shows that few companies will budge without vast incentives; most firms recruit few local people; some leave when tax holidays end; and zones work only when there are few of them in any one area. 
 Moving people has also been tried, for instance by giving housing subsidies to poor people so that they can move out of inner-city slums and rent new homes in the suburbs. 
 Research shows this can nudge up work rates; but, like busing schoolchildren from black to white areas, it can be political dynamite. 
 There are few votes to be won in the rich white suburbs by promising to move poor blacks there. 
 One logical fix to this geographical mis-match is for inner-city blacks to commute out from the ghettos to the suburbs. 
 The snag is getting there: public transport often links up white suburbs with the city centre, but not with poor black segments in between. 
 And few ghetto blacks have cars. 
 An answer from the private sector: &bquo;dedicated&equo; bus routes. 
 Suburban Job-Link, a Chicago employment agency, runs buses from North Lawndale, the city's poorest neighbourhood, where the unemployment rate runs above 20%, out to three western suburbs, where it barely hits 5%. 
 Costs are split between employers and workers; over 600 people travel each day; most work in light-manufacturing jobs, not services; and each earns an average hourly wage above &dollar;6 &mdash; nearly twice the minimum wage. 
 Similar private bus services operate in a dozen cities. 
 The public sector could take note. 
 From the bottom up 
 One of the more curious recent products of the Bush administration has been the hyping up of a new anti-poverty idea in terms that sound more like black radicalism of the 1960s. 
 The buzzword is &bquo;empowerment&equo;: let people manage their own affairs. 
 It suits the right: it encourages individual responsibility. 
 It suits the left: it hands over control to local people. 
 What does it mean? 
 A lot of words, and a few concrete proposals. 
 The driving force behind empowerment is Jack Kemp, secretary of housing and urban development. 
 Mr Kemp has been trying for several years to prod the White House into launching a serious anti-poverty programme. 
 Last autumn he won round one when President Bush appointed him to lead a cabinet &bquo;empowerment task force&equo;, told to come up with specific proposals. 
 Take decisions away from bureaucracies and give them to people: that is the principle. 
 The practice is to let parents choose freely their children's schools, let people buy their own homes, let public-housing tenants run their own estates. 
 Admirable goals; but with only a modest prospect of helping inner-city blacks. 
 Critics say Mr Kemp is an Alice in Wonderland. 
 Buying a house is not high on many poor blacks' shopping lists. 
 Successful tenant-management, like the running of Kenilworth-Parkside, a housing project in Washington, DC, and one of Mr Kemp's favourite examples, depends heavily on finding dedicated organisers. 
 If empowerment means anything, it is economic: empowerment to escape poverty. 
 The classic route, proved time and again by waves of immigrants, is education. 
 America is failing its blacks nowhere more than in its schools. 
 In poor black areas it is common for half the class to fail to graduate (which, in America, means merely failing to stay in school until you are 18 &mdash; there is no national exam for school-leavers). 
 But no amount of tinkering with parental choice or national testing alters one main problem: many young black children do not even turn up to classes. 
 They cannot see the point. 
 They are distracted by the glamour and excitement of drugs and gangs; they get little discipline at home; they fail to connect getting a good job with finishing high school. 
 Larry Hawkins, president of Chicago's Institute for Athletics and Education, thinks he has an answer: stop battering on a closed door, and try an open one. 
 If the one thing that inner-city black children will go to school for is sport, use it to keep them there. 
 &bquo;It is not sport for sport's sake,&equo; says Mr Hawkins, who is an ex-Harlem-Globetrotter, &bquo;but a way of imposing a structure on undisciplined lives: in a sports team they turn up regularly, on time, in uniform, and train hard. 
 This habit spills over into their schoolwork.&equo; 
 He and his colleagues coach competitive basketball in schools across the city. 
 They also act as mentors to the children, discussing the pressures of drugs and gangs, and how to cope with schoolwork. 
 The results are persuasive: those who take part regularly in his sports programmes at school are only one-third as likely to drop out as those who don't. 
 For the droppers-out, there is little choice but to spend more on training. 
 Federal employment and training programmes were sliced in half during the 1980s, from &dollar;12.8 billion to &dollar;5.6 billion, in real terms. 
 If the will fails 
 For all the talk, dishing out control to individuals has its limits. 
 One example: black churches, which organise services from financial credit to remedial education, carry enormous influence in poor black neighbourhoods, and offer the kinds of local leadership that Mr Kemp so much wants to nurture. 
 More than three-quarters of black Americans belong to a church, and nearly half go to church every week. 
 But if the state supported church groups it would provoke a constitutional row, because the constitution separates church and state. 
 Another example: the empowerment that cities crave is a share of the taxes raised in their rich suburbs. 
 Suburban schools gleam with modern gadgetry, while inner-city schools lack basic text books. 
 But a proposal to re-draw the tax-boundary line between them would win little favour in the rich suburbs. 
 The slums in America's great cities are shameful. 
 They are a damning indictment of the richest country in the world. 
 The problems that fester in them are not peripheral: they constitute America's main domestic challenge today. 
 The nation now has a quarter of a century's worth of anti-poverty experiments to draw on. 
 That poverty persists despite these efforts is less a reason to give up than a reason to learn from what works and what does not. 
 George Bush could now cash in on the country's post-war confidence by launching another war on the black home-front. 
 America cannot afford to let down its blacks for much longer. 
 SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY 
 The Baltimore affair 
 Ignoble 
 CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS 
 WHEN it was published in a journal called Cell in April 1986, &bquo;Altered Repertoire of Endogenous Immunoglobulin Gene Expression in Transgenic Mice Containing a Rearranged Mu Heavy Chain Gene&equo; did not seem to be the stuff of history. 
 It was not. 
 It offered evidence for a theory of the immune system about which most researchers were curious but sceptical. 
 The findings could not be repeated and the theory died. 
 But the paper lived on &mdash; in congressional hearings, in national newspapers and in heated disputes wherever two or more scientists were gathered together. 
 After five years of controversy it is about to be laid to rest. 
 And the corpse stinks. 
 In a report to be published shortly, the Office of Scientific Integrity of the National Institutes of Health (which paid for the research reported in the paper) concludes that key data for the paper were faked. 
 This is naughty, but not earth-shaking. 
 It happens. 
 What is more disturbing is how long it can take to uncover such things when big reputations are at stake. 
 The Cell paper had six authors. 
 One was Thereza Imanishi-Kari, who was then an immunologist at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT). 
 It is her work which has been the target of investigations by the National Institutes of Health (NIH) and a House subcommittee chaired by Congressman John Dingell, and of less formal inquiries at MIT and Tufts University Medical School, in Boston, where she now works. 
 Another author was David Baltimore, a Nobel prize-winner who is now president of Rockefeller University. 
 Dr Baltimore's scientific work and contribution to the paper have never been questioned. 
 But the case is widely referred to as &bquo;the Baltimore affair&equo; because of the surprising lengths to which he has gone to defend Dr Imanishi-Kari. 
 It was a researcher in Dr Imanishi-Kari's laboratory, Margot O'Toole, who first questioned the paper. 
 She was puzzled by her inability to repeat its results and even more puzzled by the data that purported to support them. 
 But in the early summer of 1986 review panels at MIT and at Tufts (which was in the process of hiring Dr Imanishi-Kari) both concluded that the paper's main finding was not affected by Dr O'Toole's criticisms and that no published corrections were required. 
 Dr Baltimore said the same thing &mdash; and repeated it in an article published in the summer of 1989, arguing that &bquo;the errors that have been identified in the Cell paper were inconsequential to the conclusions.&equo; 
 Most people who were not immunologists quite reasonably believed him. 
 According to Dr O'Toole, Dr Baltimore told her in 1986 that she could write a letter to Cell about it, but that he would publish a rejoinder. 
 In the summer of 1986 Dr Imanishi-Kari asked Dr O'Toole to leave the laboratory at Tufts where they both then worked. 
 She has been unable to get an academic job since; she did not get a job in science until 1990, when she was hired by Genetics Institute, a biotechnology company founded by one of her few supporters, Mark Ptashne of Harvard. 
 The NIH report, noting that Dr O'Toole &bquo;suffered substantially for the simple act of raising questions about the accuracy of a scientific paper&equo;, describes her actions as &bquo;heroic in many respects&equo;. 
 It is less enamoured of Dr Baltimore's role. 
 Even after an earlier NIH panel found &bquo;significant errors of misstatement and omission&equo; in the paper, he called for &bquo;all scientists&equo; to support Dr Imanishi-Kari. 
 The statements of Dr Baltimore's which the NIH's Office of Scientific Integrity finds &bquo;most deeply troubling&equo; were made to the NIH last year. 
 They concern data which were not published in the original paper, but which Dr Imanishi-Kari gave to an NIH panel in order to support her published claims against Dr O'Toole's criticisms. 
 One panel member said that they had been ready to &bquo;throw out&equo; the whole study until the notebook with this new data was produced. 
 The panel asked for the new data to be published as a correction to the original paper. 
 This was Dr Baltimore's comment to the NIH: 
 In my mind you can make up anything you want in your notebooks, but you can't call it fraud if it wasn't published. 
 Now, you managed to trick us into publishing &mdash; sort of tricked Thereza &mdash; into publishing a few numbers and now you're going to go back and see if you can produce those as fraud. 
 Last week, when drafts of the latest NIH report began to circulate, Dr Baltimore finally asked for the Cell paper to be retracted.  
 Anti-ulcer drugs 
 Too much acid 
 GOTHENBURG 
 IN THE world of pharmaceuticals it is not only marketing men who go for the hard sell. 
 Scientists also seem to. 
 Glaxo, the world's second-largest drugs firm, makes half of its sales from ranitidine, an ulcer cure which, under the brand name of Zantac, is the world's top-selling drug. 
 The drug now faces its first serious contender in omeprazole, made by Astra, a Swedish firm. 
 Glaxo's scientists say omeprazole should be used sparingly because it might cause cancer; Astra believes its drug is no more dangerous than ranitidine and has worked hard to prove it. 
 A battle royal is under way. 
 In 1990 sales of omeprazole reached &dollar;400m. 
 Astra wants more and hopes to convince regulators in America that its drug is safe for widespread use (most other countries have already waved it through). 
 In May 1990 an advisory committee of America's Food and Drug Administration (FDA) said omeprazole could be used to treat all duodenal ulcers, not just those which cause severe gut conditions. 
 But the FDA has not yet given this approval. 
 In the early 1980s Astra suspended clinical trials of omeprazole when it was found that high doses of the drug caused cancer of the stomach lining in rats. 
 By 1985 Astra said it had found out why, and that the problem would not affect people. 
 Anti-ulcer drugs work by reducing the concentration of gastric acids that destroy the gut. 
 Ranitidine binds to H2-receptors in the gut wall, preventing a natural body-chemical, histamine, from binding to them (such drugs are known as H2-antagonists). 
 Histamine triggers acid production in cells. 
 Other cells, apart from those carrying H2-receptors, also produce gut acid. 
 Omeprazole works differently, inhibiting the enzyme that pumps acid out of gut cells regardless of what stimulates acid production. 
 However, when acid-levels in the gut are low, a hormone known as gastrin is released; this induces an abnormal growth of stomach cells. 
 Because it is so good at suppressing acid, omeprazole acts as a powerful boost to gastrin production. 
 Fortunately increased gastrin production does not seem to cause any untoward effects on people. 
 At low doses of omeprazole doctors believe they can avoid any danger of cancer. 
 The H2-antagonists have had their own complications. 
 Two were abandoned in the mid-1980s when they were discovered to cause cancer in rats. 
 Last year Astra revealed the results of a two-year study it had conducted on ranitidine; at high doses it promoted cancers in the stomach. 
 It says Glaxo failed to spot this in its animal studies. 
 Glaxo rightly points out that Astra used very high levels of ranitidine, several hundred times the normal human intake and far greater than the doses of omeprazole Astra fed to rats. 
 Astra refuses to conduct further rat studies with lower doses of ranitidine, saying that this is Glaxo's job. 
 Glaxo has not produced any data about the effect of ranitidine on rats using Astra's methods, but says there is no evidence that ranitidine promotes the formation of dangerous levels of gastrin at therapeutic doses. 
 In February 1990 Glaxo published a letter in the Lancet claiming that omeprazole was also capable of damaging DNA and hence causing cancer, based on a newly developed test. 
 Rats are first dosed with drugs, the surface layer of their stomach linings removed and the rate of DNA synthesis is estimated. 
 Loxtidine (one of the H2-antagonists dropped in the early 1980s) was given a clean bill of health by the same test. 
 As a result of these findings Glaxo stopped clinical trials comparing ranitidine with omeprazole for ethical reasons. 
 In the same issue of the Lancet, Astra replied that Glaxo's new test was scientifically unsound because it did not account for normal cell division (which would also stimulate DNA synthesis). 
 Glaxo believed it was unnecessary to do this because cells sitting on the inner surface of the gut wall do not divide. 
 But since the gut wall undulates, it is easy to contaminate the sample with cells from just below the surface, which do. 
 Astra then quickly arranged a meeting with top gastroenterologists in London in April 1990 at which Glaxo was denounced. 
 It seems Glaxo omitted to say in its letter that at higher doses omeprazole did not stimulate DNA synthesis excessively. 
 Glaxo acknowledges the omission, but says at higher doses known cancer-causing agents do not promote DNA synthesis. 
 Earlier this year Chie Furihata and her colleagues at the Institute of Medical Science at the University of Tokyo published findings supporting Glaxo's thesis. 
 She, however, also added chemicals which inhibit normal cell division. 
 Omeprazole again failed the test. 
 Astra says her methods do not fully exclude the possibility of normal DNA replication and cannot repeat her results. 
 There the debate stands, for now. 
 The cost of such wrangling is huge. 
 Astra does not expect to make a profit on omeprazole for a few years yet, and &mdash; unfortunately for Astra &mdash; Glaxo has the resources to continue the scientific tussle.  
 Weighing up the neutrino 
 The little neutrino could cause big problems for the physicists' picture of the universe 
 IMAGINE light deprived of its ability to illuminate and you get a fair idea of the insubstantiality of neutrinos. 
 They do almost nothing &mdash; they can pass through planets without noticing them &mdash; and weigh almost nothing. 
 At least, present theories do not say they should weigh anything, and observation has suggested that if they do weigh something, it is next to nothing. 
 But recent experiments have called that finding, and much else, into question. 
 In laboratories in Canada, California and England, observations of heavy neutrinos are causing gentlemanly but intense controversy. 
 Neutrinos are born in nuclear decays, typically in beta decay: one of the neutrons in an atomic nucleus turns into a proton, giving off an electron in the process. 
 Some of the energy given off is carried away by the electron, which is detectable, some by the neutrino, which is not. 
 The amount of energy carried by the electrons is thought to be spread smoothly across a spectrum. 
 However in 1985 John Simpson, of the University of Guelph, in Ontario, Canada, found a kink in his measurements of the beta-decay spectrum of tritium (a radioactive form of hydrogen). 
 In this line of work, both energies and masses are expressed in electron volts (Einstein showed that masses could be considered as energies). 
 A neutron weighs about 1 billion eV: an electron weighs 500,000 eV (which can be written as 500 keV, where 1 keV is 1,000 eV). 
 Neutrinos are thought to weigh less than 20 eV, if anything. 
 Dr Simpson found that the spectrum's shape changed at an energy about 17 keV below that of the most energetic electrons emitted by tritium, which led him to suggest that there might be an extra component to beta decay. 
 Although most of the time the energy not carried by the electron was taken away by an everyday massless neutrino, sometimes it was carried by a neutrino that weighed a comparatively large 17 keV. 
 If the electron did not leave behind enough energy to give the neutrino its mass, then that extra type of decay involving fat neutrinos would not happen. 
 Hence the kink: above it, no heavy neutrinos are ever given off. 
 Below it, they are. 
 Dr Simpson's results were immediately pounced upon and found wanting by other groups, who used a different type of instrument and saw no effect. 
 Working with a graduate student, Andrew Himes, Dr Simpson decided he had overestimated the number of fat neutrinos, but that he still saw them, both when repeating his work on tritium and when looking at the beta decays of sulphur. 
 The two also produced criticisms of the experiments that saw nothing. 
 Still, since only one group saw anything, and half a dozen could find nothing, nobody felt obliged to take the 17 keV neutrino too seriously. 
 Last year, though, a group led by Eric Norman at the Lawrence Berkeley Laboratory in California declared that it had seen evidence for a 17 keV neutrino in radioactive decays of carbon-14. 
 Their evidence was a bit messy, but it breathed new life into the debate. 
 Then Dr Himes and Nick Jelley, with whom he is now working in Oxford, repeated Dr Simpson's sulphur experiment with a more carefully conceived piece of apparatus and new calculations about sources of error. 
 Early this year they announced that they had found the 17 keV neutrino again, with a far greater degree of sensitivity than any previous experiment. 
 A heavy scene 
 There are two reasons why Dr Himes and Dr Jelley have not convinced the world that Dr Simpson was right. 
 One is to do with equipment. 
 All the experiments in which the neutrino has been seen used solid-state detectors &mdash; crystals of silicon and lithium or of germanium &mdash; to measure the electron-energy spectrum. 
 It is also possible to measure the energy of electrons using a more tried and tested type of instrument called a magnetic spectrometer. 
 The no-neutrino results have been achieved using magnetic spectrometers. 
 So it is not implausible for critics to say that the solid-state detectors are unreliable and somehow bring about a sharp distortion in the spectra. 
 Nobody has convincingly worked out how such a distortion might occur, but the notion that odd things can happen in the solid state is firmly entrenched in many minds. 
 The problems encountered when making a 17 keV neutrino fit with what is known about the universe are the second reason for scepticism. 
 The &bquo;standard model&equo; of particle physics, which explains everything seen until now by particle experimenters, contains three generations of subatomic particles. 
 Each generation has four members: two quarks, an electron-like particle and a neutrino. 
 The neutrino normally given off in beta decay is a first-generation neutrino, and called an &bquo;electron neutrino&equo;. 
 Theory allows that if any of the neutrinos have mass then neutrinos of one generation can find themselves turning into neutrinos of another generation. 
 The way to make sense of the 17 keV neutrino is to make it a mixture of an electron neutrino and a third-generation &bquo;tau neutrino&equo; &mdash; with the mass provided by the tau neutrino. 
 But one cannot just say that the tau neutrino is heavy and leave it at that. 
 Theories about how particles come to have mass work only for particles that can spin in two different ways &mdash; clockwise and anticlockwise. 
 Massless electron neutrinos spin only one way: if you could see one coming towards you, it would always appear to be spinning clockwise. 
 But a 17 keV neutrino would have to be able to spin both ways. 
 So suppose that the tau neutrino comes in two forms &mdash; right- and left-handed &mdash; while its first- and second-generation cousins do not. 
 This is not an elegant solution. 
 It means the standard theory of the fundamental force underlying beta decay, the weak interaction, will need something of an overhaul. 
 Inelegance is not the only problem: the 17 keV neutrino does not fit happily into the big bang. 
 The calculations that describe how the chemical elements were cooked up in the turmoil of creation say that there were three types of neutrino around to help things on their way. 
 A right-handed form of the tau neutrino would bring the number up to four, which is too many. 
 Those theorists trying to repair the weak interaction should be able to fix it so that the right-handed tau neutrino is much less likely to interact with other matter than the left-handed one is, and thus stays aloof during the big bang. 
 But appease the cosmologists and the astrophysicists start to worry. 
 In 1987 detectors in Japan and America picked up a ten-second burst of neutrinos from the collapse of a giant star. 
 The burst took ten seconds because a dying star's core is so dense that even neutrinos bang into things on their way out. 
 If electron neutrinos can turn into yet-more-aloof right-handed tau neutrinos, though, they can get straight out without hitting anything. 
 They would stream from the core unhindered, in well under the ten seconds observed. 
 There is also the problem of the neutrino mass. 
 The number of tau neutrinos created in the big bang can be worked out; if they did not decay into other particles, and weighed 17 keV, then the universe would be more than 200 times heavier than it appears &mdash; so heavy that it would have collapsed in on itself in a big crunch eons ago. 
 That means the heavy neutrinos must decay into something far less massive, quite quickly. 
 And they must do it without letting off any light, or the sky would be aglow with the death throes of neutrinos to this day. 
 There is a way to make neutrinos decay without producing light &mdash; you can achieve almost anything in this sort of physics, as long as you are willing to do nasty things to pretty theories &mdash; but it involves conjuring up yet another new particle. 
 A sensible theorist's approach is to hope that the fat neutrino goes away. 
 But will it? 
 Dr Jelley and Dr Himes have been making measurements of the beta decay of radioactive nickel (nickel was used in the magnetic-spectrometer experiment most widely respected, one done at Canada's Chalk River national laboratory). 
 They have not finished analysing their data and getting it ready; still, their current bullishness about their earlier result is not that of people who already know their next experiment to have failed. 
 Many other experiments are planned, or in progress. 
 The experiment that Dr Himes and Dr Jelley seem to acknowledge as a potential make-or-break is one being planned by another Oxford physicist, David Wark, who will use a particularly well-understood and trusted magnetic spectrometer at Britain's national physical laboratory. 
 Under the experimental onslaught being marshalled, most expect the 17 keV neutrino to wither and die. 
 But if Dr Wark's experiment finds it, or if any respectable magnetic spectrometer defects to the heavy-neutrino camp, then the fax machines of the physicists' world will be clogged with ideas. 
 Why things have mass is one of the great questions; why things are arranged in generations is one of the others. 
 Massless electron neutrinos playing at being heavy tau neutrinos might help solve either or both. 
 Imaginations fettered by today's highly successful orthodoxy will break free. 
 As the universe changes, so does the way that physics gets done. 
 If the 17 keV neutrino were proved to exist, far more detailed surveys of beta decay would start to pin down its properties and to look for others. 
 If such a revolution comes about, there will doubtless be a role for the huge accelerators physicists have built to construct and test the standard model over the past few decades. 
 But for a while, the frontier of experimental physics will be open to anyone with a fax machine, an electronic mail-box and a reasonably good university laboratory. 
 BUSINESS THIS WEEK 
 Cross-border checks 
 Private detectives employed by the Kuwaiti government claim to have discovered that Saddam Hussein has hidden assets in more than 40 banks around the world, &dollar;2.4 billion of which are not frozen by UN sanctions. 
 Kroll Associates of New York said around &dollar;10 billion of Iraq's &dollar;200 billion oil revenues had been skimmed off in 1979&ndash;89. 
 A network of Iraqi front companies owns around &dollar;1 billion of shares in European countries, including an 8.4% stake worth FFr357m (&dollar;62m) in France's Hachette, the world's sixth-largest publishing company. 
 Despite an official ban, from 1982 to 1989 West German companies supplied Iraq with arms and the technology to help make nuclear weapons, poison gas, and missiles, in all worth around DM1 billion (&dollar;600m). 
 Embarrassed, Germany promises to tighten trading laws. 
 After years of haggling with EC regulatory authorities, Monsanto's hormone drug BST, which boosts milk yields, was cleared for use within the EC. 
 Brazil suspended export registrations for its coffee. 
 London futures prices rose 15% to &pound;670 (&dollar;1,170) a tonne, but fell within hours: coffee is plentiful and a new international deal on export quotas is a long way off. 
 Heavy trading in New York before Brazil made its announcement smelt like insider trading. 
 Money in mind 
 Having abolished its formal queue in September 1989, the Bank of England is operating an informal &bquo;calendar&equo; for rights issues. 
 Bass made the largest call this month. 
 The brewer hopes to raise &pound;558m (&dollar;976m). 
 The District Court in Topeka, Kansas, fined James and Linda Newton &dollar;75,000 for spreading false and malicious statements associating Procter &amp; Gamble with satanism, one more in a long line of lawsuits the company has filed. 
 In the past ten years P&amp;G has dealt with 150,000 letters and telephone-calls about satanism and soap powder. 
 Britain's debt-crippled Saatchi &amp; Saatchi won shareholder approval for a &pound;225m (&dollar;395m) rescue package. 
 Earlier, the advertising group had announced a pre-tax loss of &pound;5.2m (&dollar;10.1m) for the final quarter of 1990. 
 Britain's National Westminster Bank tightened the reins at its American firm Natwest Bancorp, in a bid to control its losses, which reached &dollar;352m last year, mainly because of bad company loans. 
 It has replaced Bill Knowles, head of Bancorp for ten years, with a Natwest career man, John Tugwell. 
 Resolution Trust Corp, the agency cleaning up America's savings and loan mess, is to sell 215 more S&amp;Ls, with assets totalling &dollar;38 billion, by September 30th. 
 For FFr100m (&dollar;17.5m), American Express has bought a 2% stake in Club M&eacute;diterran&eacute;e, a French group that ranks third among European tour operators, and runs holiday villages in exotic places. 
 Meanwhile, Amex's chairman, James Robinson, took an &dollar;800,000 cut in pay last year because of poor profits, leaving him with a miserly &dollar;1,798,077. 
 The boss of Salomon Inc, John Gutfreund, also took a pay cut, down to &dollar;2.26m, reflecting the investment bank's 36% drop in net income. 
 But with record pre-tax earnings of &dollar;492m in 1990, Salomon's Phibro Energy subsidiary was able to hand over &dollar;20m to its boss, Andrew Hall. 
 On line 
 IBM and AT&amp;T, America's behemoth computer and telephone companies, announced they are adapting their network-management systems so that customers can connect them more easily. 
 Smaller communications companies are likely to have to follow the new standard. 
 Europe's biggest joint semiconductor research programme, JESSI, booted ICL out of three of the five projects in which it was taking part. 
 Fujitsu of Japan bought 80% of Britain's biggest computer maker last year. 
 Groupe Bull, France's state-owned computer firm, announced pre-tax losses for 1990 of over FFr6 billion (&dollar;1 billion). 
 About half the loss resulted from operations, half from restructuring. 
 The previous day Bull took out a newspaper advertisement promising to do better in future. 
 After his Mirror Group Newspapers is floated in April, Robert Maxwell is stepping down as chairman of Maxwell Communication Corporation, and making his son Kevin chief executive. 
 Maxwell senior wants to concentrate on bringing his new purchase, the New York Daily News, back to life. 
 Motoring costs 
 France's state-owned car maker, Renault, suffered an 87% plunge in profits last year, to a net FFr1.21 billion (&dollar;196m) from FFr9.29 billion in 1989. 
 A 1.3% decline in European car sales worsened a slip in Renault's market share from 10.4% to 9.9%. 
 The firm even lost ground in France and Spain, its stronghold markets. 
 The total cost to car makers of employing labour is lowest in Britain, at &dollar;15.80 an hour. 
 Socialist Sweden came out at a hefty &dollar;27.10. 
 ECONOMIC AND FINANCIAL INDICATORS 
 OUTPUT, DEMAND AND JOBS 
 Australia's GNP grew by 0.6% in 1990, after falling by 0.7% in the year to the third quarter. 
 The improvement was helped by a tax change that inflated gold exports. 
 Australia's economy still looks shaky: industrial production fell by 1.5% in the year to January, the seventh consecutive month of year-on-year decline. 
 Sweden's GNP fell by 0.5% in 1990; the last fall was in the year to the first quarter of 1987. 
 Belgium's industrial output rose by 5% in the year to November, the same as in October but up from 3.5% in November 1989. 
 PRICES AND WAGES 
 Britain's consumer-price inflation slowed only slightly to 8.9% in the year to February; food prices rose sharply in the month because of bad weather. 
 Canada's consumer prices were unchanged in February, slowing annual growth to 6.2%. 
 In the same month France's consumer-price inflation stayed at 3.5%. 
 Belgium's wholesale prices were unchanged in January compared with a year ago. 
 Italy's rose by 8.1% in the year to December.  
 Following paragraph not in printed version 
 UNLEADED PETROL 
 Even green western Germany has been put to shame by Japan's and America's commitment to lead-free petrol. 
 Japanese refiners stopped producing leaded petrol in December 1987. 
 Americans have almost worked through the gasand lead-guzzling Cadillacs of the 1970s. 
 Yet Europe is growing greener. 
 Lead emissions from British vehicles fell by more than half between 1975 and 1988. 
 New EC legislation means that, from 1993, all new cars must be fitted with catalytic converters, which cannot tolerate lead. 
 By 2000 the great majority of cars will run on unleaded fuel. 
 Spain has plenty of catching up to do. 
 But the real villains are the Luxembourgers and Italians who stubbornly continue to buy leaded petrol, even though many of their petrol stations offer the cleaner alternative.  
 End of unprinted paragraph 
 EXPORTS 
 Growth in the volume of world merchandise trade slowed last year to 5%, down from 7% in 1989. 
 Officials at the GATT predict a further slowdown in 1991. 
 But the value of world trade grew by 13% in 1990, to a new record of &dollar;3.5 trillion. 
 Helped (a lot) by the dollar and (a little) by unification, Germany again became the world's biggest exporter, elbowing America out of the top slot after just one year. 
 Had Germany been unified in 1989, it would have stayed top. 
 Exports from third-placed Japan were also up &mdash; but only by 4.5%. 
 Eastern Europe stirred: Poland's exports to the European Community rose by 40% in 1990, and Hungary's by 28%, but the Soviet Union's exports fell by 5.5% to &dollar;103 billion. 
 Exports from developing countries as a whole were up by 13% in 1990. 
 COMMODITY PRICE INDEX 
 World wheat production is forecast to fall by 40m tonnes in 1991&ndash;92, to 555m tonnes, according to the International Wheat Council. 
 This season's record output has been the result of exceptional weather and yields. 
 The projected fall next season, beginning July, is based on reduced planting and normal yields. 
 The wheat crop in the United States will be 17% lower, while output in the Soviet Union will fall 14%. 
 World wheat consumption is forecast to stagnate at 570m tonnes. 
 Demand in developing countries is limited by a shortage of cash and by plentiful rice supplies. 
 As stocks fall, wheat prices should regain their usual premium over maize, reducing the amount of wheat used in animal feed.  
 FOREIGN RESERVES 
 Last week's box on official reserves was mugged by statistical gremlins, making a nonsense of some of the numbers. 
 Sorry. 
 This week's chart shows the correct figures. 
 Japan (not the United States, as suggested last week) still boasts the world's biggest official foreign reserves: at the end of January it had some &dollar;79 billion-worth (including foreign currency, SDRs and its reserve position at the IMF, but excluding gold). 
 But Japan's reserves have fallen by almost a fifth since the end of 1988. 
 Over the same period America's reserves have doubled, to &dollar;74 billion, to put it in second place; back in 1988 it was in only sixth place. 
 All the European countries in the chart except Britain now have fatter official reserves than in 1988. 
 The only developing country with large foreign reserves is Taiwan, in third place. 
 TRADE, EXCHANGE RATES AND RESERVES 
 Britain's current-account deficit shrank to &pound;192m (&dollar;377m) in February; the 12-month visible-trade deficit fell below &dollar;30 billion for the first time since mid-1988. 
 In the year to February France's visible-trade deficit stood at &dollar;11.2 billion. 
 In trade-weighted terms the dollar rose by 1.1%, the yen rose 1.2% and the D-mark fell 0.8%. 
 WORLD BOURSES 
 Most stockmarkets lost ground after their recent gains. 
 London fell by 2.4% and New York by 2.2%. 
 Frankfurt dropped by 3.3%, thanks to fears of higher interest rates and a downturn in the bond market. 
 Johannesburg hit a record high, ending 0.2% up. 
 MONEY AND INTEREST RATES 
 Britain's prime-lending rate was cut by 0.5% shortly after the budget, to 13.5%, down from 15% in February. 
 America's narrow-money supply grew by 4.4% in the year to February, up from 3.9% in the year to January. 
 Its broad money grew by 2.2%. 
 The Heritage 
 THE woods seem but just freed from the horror of primeval sea, if that is not primeval sea washing their bases. 
 Capella hangs low, pale, large, moist and trembling almost engulfed between two horn of the wood upon the headland, the frailest beacon of hope, still fluttering from the storm out of which the land is emerging. 
 Then, or at home looking at a map of Britain, the West calls, out of Wiltshire and out of Cornwall and Devon beyond, out of Monmouth and Glamorgan and Gower and Caermarthen, with a voice of dead Townsends, Eastaways, Thomases, Phillipses, Treharnes, Marendaz, sea men and mountain men. 
 Westward, for men of this island, lies the sea; westward are the great hills. 
 In a mere map the west of Britain is fascinating. 
 The great features of that map, which make it something more than a picture to be imperfectly copied by laborious childish pens, are the great promontories of Caernarvon, of Pembroke, of Gower and of Cornwall, jutting out into the western sea, like the features of a grim large face, such a face as is carved on a ship's prow&hellip;. 
 To the eyes of a child they stand for adventure. 
 They are lean and worn and scarred with the strife and watching. 
 Then gradually into the mind of the child comes the story that justifies and, still more, inspires and seems to explain those westward-pointing promontories. 
 For, out towards them continually have the conquered races of the world retreated, and their settlements give those corners a strangeness and a charm to our fantastic sympathies. 
 Out from them conquerors in their turn have gone to found a legend like the Welsh Madoc, an empire like the men of Devon. 
 The blood of conquered and conqueror is in our veins, and it flushes the cheek at the sight or thought of the west. 
 Each man of us is as ancient and complicated, as lofty-spired and as deep-vaulted as cathedrals and castles of old, and in those lands our crypts and dark foundations are dimly remembered. 
 Edward Thomas wrote these words in 1908, at a period of comparative ease and tranquillity, when he had gone about the South Country these twenty years and more on foot, especially in Kent between Maidstone and Ashford and round Penshurst, in Surrey between London, Guildford and Horley, in Hampshire round Petersfield, in Wiltshire between Wootton Bassett, Swindon and Savernake. 
 The people are almost foreign to me, the more so because country people have not yet been thrown into quite the same confusion as townspeople, and therefore look awkwardly upon those who are not in trade &mdash; writing is an unskilled labour and not a trade &mdash; not on the land, and not idle&hellip;. 
 Yet is this country, though I am mainly Welsh, a kind of home, as I think it is more than any other to those modern people who belong nowhere. 
 &hellip; These are the &bquo;home&equo; counties. 
 A man can hide away in them. 
 The people are not hospitable, but the land is. 
 This concern with his own roots was a frequent preoccupation in his writing. 
 In spite of the touches of mystification he employed in many autobiographical references scattered through twenty years of publishing, it is possible to detect the complicated temperament he had inherited. 
 But this is only one side of the picture. 
 In verse and prose he was hell-bent on facing himself when things were out of joint; the scalpel-probe is counterbalanced by the unlearned, incurious manner in which he found deepest ease and joy out of doors &mdash; a way of healing he had discovered early in life, although he did not consider himself a naturalist. 
 Philip Edward Thomas was born in London on 3 March 1878 at 10 Upper Lansdowne Road North, now 14 Lansdowne Gardens, just off South Lambeth Road, where his parents occupied rooms let by a Mrs Legge. 
 It was their first London home after their marriage in Wales some time in 1874&ndash;5. 
 His father, Philip Henry Thomas, had distinguished himself in a Civil Service Examination (Executive Branch) and had been posted to a staff clerkship for light railways and tramways at the Board of Trade. 
 According to family tradition, Mr Thomas (1854&ndash;1920) had once been a pupil-teacher in his home town of Tredegar, a flourishing iron and coal community. 
 The poet's grandfather, Henry Thomas, was a fitter by trade and followed a typical path of migration in the early nineteenth century. 
 Like many Welshmen in and around the Neath and Swansea valleys, he had made his way from the more rural communities of West Glamorganshire and Carmarthenshire, up the valleys towards Brecon, and then moved eastwards towards the concentration of new industries at Dowlais, Merthyr, Rhymney, Tredegar, Beaufort, Ebbw Vale, and Pontypool. 
 From this area, at the heads of the East Glamorgan and West Monmouthshire valleys, some moved later southwards towards Newport. 
 This first wave of West Walians to the new industrial areas of north-eastern South Wales brought a distinctive radical, nonconformist, and Welsh-speaking element to a pastoral community that had remained largely conservative and unchanged from the late seventeenth century and was slowly losing the old Welsh language &mdash; rapidly so in Monmouthshire &mdash; and along with it any acute sense of separate national identity. 
 The racial mixture was soon to be sharpened, as the mid-century railway boom got under way, by new waves of immigrants from Ireland, the Forest of Dean, Herefordshire, and Somerset, but already the social, political, and religious pattern of the new South Wales and the eastern valleys of Monmouthshire had been firmly set for another century. 
 Henry Thomas and his son, Philip Henry, were probably Welsh speakers who both married women from Gwent. 
 The poet's paternal grandmother, Rachel Phillips, was a native of Abertillery (or Blaenau Gwent) where a native Welsh tradition had survived, as it had in the Tredegar of her youth. 
 She eventually carried the Welsh language with her, later in life, to the clannish Welsh community that developed around the Great Western Railway works in Swindon. 
 For Henry Thomas had left Tredegar for railway employment in Swindon and one of his sons, the Uncle Harry who features in the Swindon holidays described so lovingly in The Childhood of Edward Thomas , was a fitter at the Swindon GWR works until he set sail for South Africa in 1891. 
 The poet never knew his grandfather, who &bquo;had long been dead&equo; when Edward first visited his father's mother at Swindon in 1888. 
 The Eastaway and Treharne names still retained in the Thomas family indicate that originally the family came from the coastal region of Glamorgan between Neath and Gower. 
 Cross-channel traffic between South Wales and the coast from Weston to Ilfracombe, with settlement of Somerset and Devon families along the Welsh coast, is attested in the parish records that survive from the seventeenth century. 
 The use of &bquo;Treharne Thomas&equo; as a family name was preserved in the Pontardulais cousins with whom Edward spent his Oxford long vacations. 
 They too were a family of skilled craftsmen and, like so many of the first two generations of South Wales industrial settlers, retained a small interest in country matters, raising pigs and often keeping a pony or two on the outskirts of their villages. 
 Little is known about Philip Henry Thomas's life and career before he settled down in Lambeth with his Newport-born wife Elizabeth, grand-daughter of Alderman William Townsend (1795&ndash;1877) on her father's side and a sea-captain named Marendaz on her mother's side. 
 In his Edward Thomas  (1937), Judge Robert P. Eckert &mdash; who corresponded frequently with the poet's maternal aunt, Margaret Townsend, and his youngest brother, Julian &mdash; describes the father as a &bquo;practical, self-made man&hellip; a short, stocky welshman, a dark, good-looking man&equo;. 
 Margaret Townsend had spend some time helping her sister with the large growing family, especially during the frequent pregnancies, and she had lived with the poet's mother in Stow Hill, Newport, until the move to London. 
 Margaret certainly visited &bquo;Edwy&equo; (the family name for the poet) at Oxford and corresponded with him subsequently from the USA until his death. 
 She probably supplied the adjective &bquo;practical&equo; for Eckert. 
 I was once told that Philip Henry Thomas, while preparing himself for the Civil Service examination, had followed his period as a pupil-teacher with a post connected with the railways which were expanding rapidly in industrial South Wales in the 1860s and 1870s. 
 His third son, Theodore, eventually became technical head of London Transport; Ernest, the second son, trained to become an art teacher but spent most of his life in industrial design and advertising; the poet, too, possessed strong, capable, craftsman's hands and the poet's daughter, Myfanwy, still treasures many examples of her father's skill as a carpenter and metal worker. 
 Her brother, Merfyn, began training with his uncle as a motor engineer and eventually became a technical journalist. 
 In the half-fictional The Happy-Go-Lucky Morgans , and in the pruned record of The Childhood , Thomas has left detailed accounts of his extending interest in &bquo;Butterflies, Moths and Pigeons&equo;, in fishing, in birdnesting of all kinds, with the skills and making of implements that accompanied these activities. 
 It is surprising how little the poet's father shared in these games and sports, which could have helped form a natural bridge of intimacy with his six sons as they began to go their several ways. 
 The father's preparation for the Civil Service Examination &mdash; probably as rigorous an academic test as the external London matriculation examinations of the first forty years of this century &mdash; had given him command of three languages, Latin, French, and German, and a powerful interest in political and philosophical topics. 
 His impact on one side of the new society he had entered in the Battersea district is recorded in an obituary tribute in the Clapham Observer, Tooting and Balham Times  of Friday 24 December 1920: 
 By the death, at the age of 66, of Mr. Philip Henry Thomas which took place after a long illness, on Saturday the 18th instant, at his residence at 13 Rusham Road, Battersea loses a citizen who has been active for 40 years in championing the cause of Liberalism in this borough&hellip;. 
 Coming to London as a young clerk attached to the Board of Trade, it was not long before he began to take an interest in political affairs, and his remarkable gift for public speaking was developed at the old Battersea Parliament, to which belonged many men who have since played important roles in public life&hellip; including Stanley (now Lord) Buckmaster, John Burns and Horatio Bottomley&hellip;. 
 Although invited by the Liberal Party to be their candidate for the Clapham Division 20 years ago or more, &lsqb;he&rsqb; was unable to accept the invitation, and contented himself with speaking for the Liberal or Progressive candidate at every available opportunity in many elections. 
 On his retirement from the Civil Service six years ago&hellip; he became President of the Clapham Liberal Association, and at the General Election of 1916 was the chosen parliamentary candidate for the new constituency of South Battersea where he put up a strong fight against odds for what he firmly and honestly believed to be the tight. 
 He lost two sons in the Great War&hellip;. 
 Besides his political activities Mr. Thomas also found time for lecturing on literary, philosophical and ethical subjects in many parts of the country, and at one time he lectured almost every Sunday in the Town Hall for the Battersea Ethical Society. 
 He was a brilliant speaker and lecturer. 
 Latterly he became prominent in Positivist circles and occupied until recently the pulpit at the little-known Church of Humanity in Holborn. 
 His sympathies were also with the poor and the oppressed, and in him Democracy has lost an intellectual, enlightened and patriotic advocate of England's faith, honour and advancement. 
 When Edward was two, and a second child was expected, Mr Thomas moved house (the number cannot now be traced) to Wakehurst Road, one of the rows of recently built small houses parallel to Battersea Rise and between Clapham and Wandsworth commons. 
 There Ernest, Theodore, and Reginald were born within six years, but Edward's recollections of this time are sketchy. 
 Before his tenth birthday, with another child (Oscar) on the way, the family moved yet again to 61 Shelgate Road, a much larger detached house four streets nearer to Battersea Rise and Wandsworth Common. 
 Near to a school and a cemetery and with an older house (with its orchard and coachhouse) at the end of the road, this spacious house remained Edward's home until he left Oxford. 
 His father was now well-established in his career and though never affluent they were comfortably off. 
 Edward recalls his earliest years at Wakehurst Road: I have only one clear early glimpse of my father &mdash; darting out of the house in his slippers and chasing and catching a big boy who had bullied me. 
 He was eloquent, confident, black-haired, brown-eyed, all that my mother was not. 
 By glimpses I learnt with awe and astonishment that he had once been of my age. 
 &hellip; I can hear but never see him telling me for the tenth or hundredth time the story of the Wiltshire moonrakers&hellip; and many another comic tale or rhyme. 
 &hellip; &lsqb;My parents&rsqb; were sober reverent people without a creed, though their disbelief in Hell and the Devil almost amounted to a creed. 
 My father and I made merry over the Devil and the folly of believing in him as we supposed many did. 
 He used to try different chapels or different preachers, sometimes taking me with him, more especially when he had become an almost weekly attendant at a Unitarian Chapel&hellip;. 
 Chapel and Sunday-school were to me cruel ceremonious punishments for the freedom of Monday to Saturday&hellip;. 
 The best of life was passed out of the house and out of school. 
 Otherwise, in these early years before the age of twelve, the references to his father are few and nebulous: &bquo;My mother played the piano a little; my father sang &bquo;Bonny Mary of Argyle&equo; to her accompaniment.&equo; 
 &bquo;The pleasure of being top, and nothing else, except the interest of my father, made me do such homework as I did in the evenings&hellip;. 
 My father made me attend evening lectures for a time on sound, light, and heat &mdash; with no effect.&equo; 
 A little later, two references uncover a less severe view of P. H. T. After a talk with his mother about misuse of pocket-money, in order to buy new pigeons, &bquo;I confessed. 
 My father spoke to me angrily. 
 As I hated anger and blame, I became wretched. 
 The result was that very soon indeed afterwards my father came with a very sad but kind face in to the room where I sat alone and told me he was sure I should not do that sort of thing again. 
 His shaking hands with me made me feel half hero, half saint. 
 Naturally I did not do quite that sort of thing again.&equo; 
 Edward entered Battersea Grammar School as a &bquo;free scholar&equo;. 
 One master earned respect and obedience without fear from nearly all his class, by being a just, quiet, serious man, even of speech and kindly&hellip;. 
 With slow wrinkling his stiff face relaxed now and then into a feminine tender smile. 
 After a time I found myself frequently addressing him as &bquo;Father&equo;, so naturally did he touch the gentle docile side of me. 
 The one time I ever cried in school was when he blamed me with a severity that seemed to hurt him&hellip;. 
 My father probably went over the &lsqb;Shakespeare&rsqb; plays with me when I was doing my home-work, but his taste was for directly elevating philanthropic and progressive literature. 
 Or was it only with a view to inspiring a love of virtue that he read &bquo;Abou Ben Adhem&equo; and how he &bquo;loved his fellow men.&equo; 
 There follows an account of Edward's slight involvement in his father's political activities, especially his schoolboy advocacy during the Home Rule election when his &bquo;enthusiasm pleased my father&equo;. 
 But from the same Grammar School period Edward recalls in detail &bquo;the Sunday dinner anger, which became almost a regular thing,, with the boys tittering and refusing to discuss the topic of the morning's sermon until they received a lecture or abuse from their father, at this &bquo;almost the only meal as a rule which the whole family had together&equo;. 
 Philip Henry expected a late-Victorian respectable pattern of behaviour from his sons. 
 Edward, school apart, was living a much more exciting life at the ramshackle, free-and-easy household of a friend, and exploring the common around his home in ever-increasing circles in the company of a few youths of similar tastes. 
 The qualities of independence, singularity of viewpoint, and readiness to move far afield in pursuit of his inner wishes (a characteristic of his father's early career) were beginning to appear in the son. 
 Three of Edward's brothers (Ernest, Theodore, and Julian) recorded brief memories of their eldest brother in 1947. 
 They recall his taste for long walks of twenty to twenty-five miles in rural settings away from Battersea, his passion for fishing in ponds and canals, and his accurate enlightening knowledge of birds, trees, insects, and flowers. 
 Their recollections also emphasize his aloofness, shyness, sudden love of fun, and self-contained nature. 
 They give no sense of a close-knit family unit, but they make it quite clear that when Edward writes of adventures in and around London commons, or at Swindon, the word &bquo;we&equo; invariably includes one of them. 
 He was diffident &mdash; unlike Ernest who was good at all games &mdash; and preoccupied with his country pursuits, but they found him companionable; himself capable of long hours of solitude, he could always find acquaintances ready to share his company for a time; but only a few dedicated companions shared his exacting singleminded concentration on these occupations. 
 He has recalled drily that as a schoolboy he found it easy to get his own way. 
 His own statements, supported by his brothers', disclose a resilient, self-reliant nature counterbalancing his sensitive response to the natural world. 
 Photographs and recollections confirm that in features and colouring he resembled his mother. 
 She was hesitant, shy, reserved, &bquo;more than pretty&equo; in the eyes of the &bquo;eldest son she loved best of her many sons&equo;. 
 The Childhood , with its insistence on only those memories that could be recalled clearly, supports Eckert's belief that there was a silent but complete understanding between them: 
 My mother I can hardly see save as she is now while I am writing. 
 &lsqb;In 1913.&rsqb; 
 I cannot see her but I can summon up her presence. 
 She is plainest to me not quite dressed, in white bodice and petticoat, her arms and shoulders rounded and creamy smooth. 
 My affection for her was leavened with lesser likings and with admiration. 
 I liked the scent of her fresh warm skin and supposed it unique. 
 Her straight nose and chin made a profile that for years formed my standard. 
 No hair was so beautiful to me as hers was, light golden hair, long and rippling. 
 Her singing at fall of night, especially if we were alone together, soothed and fascinated me, as though it had been divine, at once the mightiest and the softest sound in the world. 
 Usually perhaps there was a servant, but my mother did everything for us ii the house, made many of our clothes and mended them, prepared and gave us food, tended us when sick, comforted us when cold, disappointed, or sorrowful. 
 The one terrible thing I witnessed as a small child was my mother suddenly rising from the dining-table with face tortured and crying, &bquo;I am going to die&equo;. 
 My father took her on his knee and soothed her&hellip;. 
 For her younger sister I felt a similar affection and admiration. 
 &hellip; She sang livelier songs, e.g. from Patience , than my mother ever did. 
 But she did not know our ways and her complaints or corrections were harsh by comparison with my mother's. 
 The Thomas household had five sons by the time Edward was ten years old. 
 Welsh servants aid mother's helps came aid went, aid some he &bquo;admired aid enjoyed admiring for their sweet looks or language or presence. 
 The only woman I had anything to do with regularly was my mother, aid except at meals aid bed time I did not see much even of my mother. 
 Occasionally we played cards or draughts together ii the evening.&equo; 
 On Sunday, sitting between his father aid mother ii the Unitarian chapel, he only knew that where people were sad and solemn I was overcome, half-suffocated by the sadness aid the solemnity. 
 What was read aid preached was to me airy nothing. 
 I knew of no virtues except truthfulness, obedience, self-sacrifice, total abstinence from alcoholic drinks&hellip;. 
 As for self-sacrifice it was mostly incredible. 
 But I liked to please my mother and keep undisturbed the love that was between us. 
 I sometimes did little unexpected kid things out of my tenderness for her, and was always glad to be the one to take up tea for her if she was unwell, and so on, or to help her with the housework when she was servantless. 
 &hellip; My mother never attempted to add to the religion of the chapel. 
 On the contrary she roused my indignation at the two conspicuously Christian aunts who had made her childhood in that dark house at Newport miserable. 
 If she or I had taken more trouble I might have been convinced that all religious people were cruel hypocrites. 
 The Childhood  makes only three other references to his mother. 
 One is a brief account of the birth at home of the sixth son, Julian: the others refer to her active role as intermediary between the sons and the father. 
 One passage, when Edward was a scholar at Battersea Grammar School, sums up the general atmosphere of 61 Shelgate Road, as the poet recalled it twenty years later: 
 We had very few visitors, none to turn us inside out. 
 Once a lady aid a daughter, remote cousins or friends of friends, came, and the girl left me with a yearning heart for some days and a curiosity for years like my curiosity about the lost childish books. 
 Christmas was eagerly awaited for, but the day itself meant chiefly watching for the postman, disappointment, chapel, a heavy dinner and crackers, some squabbling comparisons of our presents, tea&hellip; supper&hellip; 
 The disappointment is vivid yet of the Christmas day when the postman arrived at last, hours late, and brought me only a long narrow box of crackers. 
 We children gave no presents to one another or to our parents: we were content to send out a few picture cards paid for by our parents, to people who would send us cards. 
 The faculty for ceremony or festival was not in any of us. 
 Our boy friends seldom came to the house. 
 Nor were we very anxious that they should, knowing that we should be constrained by the presence of father or mother. 
 For we had one way at home, another abroad. 
 He had severely limited the scope of his autobiography: &bquo;I depict not what I was  but what I see when I look back&equo;, he told Eleanor Farjeon. 
 The Childhood , perhaps, gives too joyless a picture of the tendrils of home that Thomas brought with him from boyhood. 
 In his sixteenth year he had the confidence to begin to write descriptive nature essays for publication in journals and newspapers. 
 In this he was encouraged by the Unitarian minister Mr Tarrant and a new friend, the literary critic James Ashcroft Noble. 
 Such tangible paid recognition of Edward's literary interests gained the approval of his father, who had himself remained a dedicated, aloof, self-improving student at home while his sons gave full rein to their athletic, roaming, rumbustious interests &bquo;abroad&equo;. 
 Mr Thomas wished his sons to enjoy the best education he could provide, partly as a means of fulfilling their intellectual potential, but even more as a necessary upward step on the social-economic scale. 
 Edward recalls this attitude clearly among the Swindon-Welsh cronies of his paternal grandmother: &bquo;They used to remark how well my father was doing, my grandfather who had long been dead having only been a fitter&equo;. 
 The fear of a &bquo;few stern five minutes&equo; with his father, who wanted him to leave Battersea Grammar School for the neighbouring public school St. Paul's, and had arranged for him to have special lessons in Latin verse and in Greek, kept him steadily at school work, although he knew he &bquo;could do better at lessons if I wished&equo;. 
 His vital interest was exploring the countryside with his school friend Arthur Hardy, as he records it in A Sportsman's Tale : &bquo;We had spent the best ten years of life together and after that saw one another about twice a year&hellip; 
 Most of those ten years which had bound us together were spent out of doors.&equo; 
 They had first met on a school paperchase when they strayed off course and returned late after nightfall. 
 From that year onward we two went through most of the stages into which the ordinary man's love of Nature is divided. 
 First the wild unconscious play when we hardly distinguished between the open fields and the neighbourhood of towns except that we preferred the fields. 
 Then, very soon, the hunting stage when we deliberately played at savages. 
 Then the time of collecting eggs, flowers and insects, of stuffing birds and animals. 
 And not long before we left school, the poetical stage when we read poetry out of doors, or rather I did, while he listened. 
 There was not a poet's emotion which we did not heartily believe ourselves to share, evoked by the poem but not imitated from it. 
 What had come to the poets in their most serene or passionate moments we glided into as easily as we gathered flowers for Maud or Blanche or Mabel, as we lay in the grass with our eyes divided between the books, the land and the clouds. 
 From the hundreds of volumes at home, including Shakespeare, Chaucer, Spenser, Shelley, Keats, Byron, Tennyson, and Browning, the boys were encouraged to learn selected poems for recitation; but Edward does not record where he had found and read Darwin's Descent of Man  and books of travel, sport, and natural history, especially the many copious draughts of Richard Jefferies. 
 It seems safe to assume that Jefferies, like Waterton, Buckland, Wallace, and Charles Kingsley, would have been on his father's shelf. 
 Mr Thomas was a Comtean Positivist. 
 The gilt-edged selection from Tennyson into which he dipped, before reading him more extensively (around his fifteenth year), belonged to his mother. 
 Edward's early memories are softer in tone when they describe his visits with her to relations in the Welsh Border counties and especially to Herefordshire. 
 From The Childhood , and even more from some conversations I recorded with the poet's second cousin (T. Trehame Thomas) in 1966&ndash;7, there are hints that Mrs Thomas's family proudly preserved the memory of Alderman Townsend and his descendants: the Tedmans at a vicarage in Much Birch, near Hereford; another great-uncle at Limpley Stoke near Bath with an interest in the development of Edward's French grammar; and many more who had either been abroad and returned to moderate affluence in the Border counties (according to Mr T. T. Thomas's recollections) or had settled abroad in Africa or in the USA, like Edward's aunt Margaret. 
 She had received a sound enough education to act as a governess to children with parents overseas and, later, as a secretary-companion to American ladies. 
 There are substantial hints that if paternal family experience encouraged Edward to extend his interests, both in preparing for a career and in his natural history pursuits, along practical and fact-gathering lines, the subtler influence of his mother and her family gave approval to the sudden spurt of interest in the affective literature of Richard Jefferies and, even more, to the reading of poetry for its own sake. 
 When he wrote The Childhood  at the age of thirty-five, Thomas associated this sudden interest in poetry with a sex-stirred liking for a &bquo;tall thin freckled girl of about my own age with good rather large features, dark hair and grey eyes, and an austere expression&equo;. 
 The double-sided nature of the sixteen-year-old boy who arrived in the History Eighth at St. Paul's among a group of conventionally well-educated youths two years his senior &mdash; who seemed to him grimly earnest and thinking only of work and success and speaking in more re fined voices than he was used to &mdash; is clearly shown by Thomas's two attempts at writing fiction, The Happy-Go-Lucky Morgans  (1913) dedicated to &bquo;My Father and my Mother&equo; with its epigraph from Hardy, &bquo;But now &mdash; O never again&equo;, and an unpublished work of &bquo;Fiction&equo; (his title) which he abandoned in the early summer of 1914. 
 The novel is a curious mixture of autobiography, fantasy, speculation about poetry, and Welsh legends (modelled obliquely on the Arabian Night)  that begins as a &bquo;story of Balham and of a family dwelling in Balham who were more Welsh tlian Balhamilish&equo;. 
 Initially it gives a fairly accurate account of the Jones family who are described briefly in The Childhood . 
 This factual structure is intermingled with anecdotal family memories of the once popular London Welsh poet Lewis Morris, with some echoes of the people who encouraged Edward in his earliest published writings, and with an even more substantial use of Welsh and Swindon topics now missing from the numerous notebooks. 
 The tone of the descriptions and conversations of Mr Morgan of Abercorran House and his curiously assorted friends (Aurelius, Mr Torrance and Mr Stodham) is cheerfully loving in its recall of the London commons and the Wiltshire and Welsh countryside upon which Edward was to draw for much inner satisfaction throughout his adult life. 
 Equally necessary to the book's structure is the character of the housekeeper Ann, a straightforward transfer of Edward's own mother into the world of the kitchens of his cousins in Pontardulais with their attractive young women and idealized Welsh &bquo;Mams&equo;. 
 Ann stands for all the women of common-sense, warm affection, and practical piety that Edward repeatedly attempted to sketch realistically or to record in dream-like settings in his essays and sketches. 
 She supplies the book's hasty conclusion after the death at Lydiard Constantine of Philip &mdash; a partial picture of one side of the Battersea Grammar School Edward: At this point the people of Abercorran House &mdash; even Jessie and Aurelius- and the dogs that stretched out in death like blessedness under the sun, and the pigeons that courted and were courted in the yard and on the roof, all suddenly retreat from me when I come to that Spring in memory; a haze of ghostly, shimmering silver veils them; without Philip they are as people in a story whose existence I cannot prove. 
 The very house has gone. 
 The elms of the Wilderness have made coffins, if they were not too old. 
 Where is the pond and its lilies? 
 They are no dimmer than the spirits of men and children. 
 But there is always Ann. 
 Ann, in 1913, would have been the same age as Edward's mother and, from family hearsay, Ann's sentiments resemble closely the practical, optimistic piety of Mary Elizabeth Thomas. 
 The Happy-Go-Lucky Morgans  is in no way a conventional novel. 
 As far as one can tell from his letters, he was pleased with it although it did not sell. 
 The book adds a distinctive, more cheerful gloss to the boyhood and early youth of a precocious young writer who later, on his own testimony, suffered bouts of depression of different degrees of intensity from the age of sixteen onwards. 
 Gradually, in the novel, the friends of the Morgans grew up and &bquo;acquired preferences which were not easily to be adapted to that sunny, untidy house&hellip; 
 They said it was different: but they were wrong; it was they themselves were different, the Morgans never changed. 
 In this way young men of the neighbourhood discovered that they were no longer boys. 
 They could no longer put up with that careless hullabaloo of lazy, cheerful people, they took offence at the laziness, or else at the cheerfulness.&equo; 
 We are left in no doubt that the author, from first to last, approves the viewpoint of the people of Abercorran House. 
 The additional Celtic (and gypsy-like) lore he draws upon to fill out a flimsy plot is firmly placed within the suburban London life between Clapham Junction and Richmond Park. 
 The one exception is the final chapter, &bquo;The Poet's Spring at Lydiard Constantine&equo;. 
 Writing this from the standpoint of the narrator (Arthur) looking back to the sixteenth (and last) year of Philip, the youngest child of the Morgan household, we are told that Arthur kept a diary of that year &mdash; as indeed Edward had kept such a diary and later printed it in The Woodland Life . 
 Again, in reference to Philip's new-found love of poetry and Shelley, driving out his old enthusiasm for birdnesting, Arthur states &bquo;I have beside me the book which taught Philip this sad bliss, this wisdom. 
 The fly-leaves are entirely covered by copies in his handwriting of the best-loved poems and passages &lsqb;of Shelley&rsqb;.&equo; 
 This notebook survives and its dated notes can be checked against Arthur's account of the spring spent at Lydiard Constantine. 
 In the novel, Philip became ill and was left behind there to die while Arthur returned to London and began a new course of study. 
 Philip died and was buried at Lydiard Constantine, near Swindon. 
 In some obscure way Thomas recognized (in 1913) that his decision to become a writer at the age of sixteen closed the door on a career that would have pleased his father. 
 There are no overt clues to help us. 
 The nearest we get is Helen Thomas's introduction to the 1932 edition of The South Country  about the life he had chosen, oft en suffering &bquo;despair and humiliation&equo;, but always finding in the country &bquo;the comfort he so passionately sought&equo;. 
 The eighty notebooks in the Berg Collection refer to a process of discovery, loss, and rediscovery throughout his writing life. 
 But there is no unequivocal statement as to why or how his life took a firm direction at this time. 
 Philip, perhaps, stands in part for his earlier carefree schoolboy self between the age of eleven and fifteen &mdash; the &bquo;foolish years&equo; was his later name for them. 
 The open nature of this schoolboy Philip Edward Thomas, with his ready absorption in the Morgans' sporting activities, held some charm for the disappointed middle-aged writer. 
 The positive outlook of the Morgan family &mdash; based on a real-life family &mdash; is present even in the mysterious final chapter, with its faint suggestion of the Arabian Nights: 
 We were not merely ready to welcome strange things when we had walked half a mile up a lane and met no man, but we were in a gracious condition for receiving whatever might fall to us. 
 We did not go in search of miracles, we invited them to come to us. 
 What was familiar to others was never, on that account, tedious or contemptible to us. 
 I remember that when Philip and I first made our way through London to a shop which was depicted in an advertisement, in spite of the crowds on either hand all along our route, in spite of the full directions of our elders, we were as much elated by our achievement as if it had been an arduous discovery made after a journey in a desert. 
 In our elation there was some suspicion that our experience had been secret, adventurous, and unique. 
 As to the crowd, we glided through it as angels might. 
 Sometimes in our rare London travels we had a glimpse of a side street, a row of silent houses all combined as it were into one gray palace, a dark doorway, a gorgeous window, a surprising man disappearing&hellip; 
 We looked, and though we never said so, we believed that we alone had seen these things, that they had never been seen before. 
 We should not have expected to see them there if we went again. 
 Many and many a time have we looked, have I alone in more recent years looked, for certain things thus revealed to us in passing. 
 In his recall of clearly remembered events in The Childhood  Thomas was determined not to be led astray by reverie and adult speculation. 
 His method was to include the remembrance of moods and apprehensions as well as images and incidents. 
 In these autobiographical investigations, he seems to follow an aim he had noticed in L'Intelligence des Fleurs  where, at times, Maeterlinck &bquo;seems to be striving to look at scientific facts in a poetical manner&hellip;. 
 He advocates the instinct, the imagination, the unconsciousness, by means of the intelligence which he esteems so far beneath them&hellip;. 
 His detached, even, and quite uncontroversial manner makes him a valuable auxiliary of liberal thought.&equo; 
 Thomas presents his own pre-adolescent boyhood in a similar spirit. 
 The boy's hedonistic love of naturalist pursuits is linked to a sense of oneness and wonder, if only at rare recorded moments. 
 The significance of such insights was reinforced later by his reading of Jefferies' Amateur Poacher  and The Story of My Heart . 
 Holidays spent in Swindon or Wales, a time of freedom from the severities of classroom timetables and disciplines, gave opportunities for naturalistic pursuits in a setting more favourable even than the widening circle of his weekend and holiday explorations of London and Surrey commons with Arthur Hardy or his own brothers, themselves an essential escape from domesticity, homework and discipline. 
 Swindon and, by extension, the Jefferies country around Coate won a permanent place in Thomas's life because of the indissoluble friendship that developed between him and the old man called &bquo;Dad&equo; Uzzell. 
 Here was a character, like his Uncle Harry, who offered a way of life quite different from the one Mr Thomas hoped to provide for his six sons. 
 Dad Uzzell appears in many guises in Thomas's stories, and travel books; parts of him &mdash; and stories told by him &mdash; are an important strand in some of the wayfaring characters found in the pre-enlistment poems. 
 In As It Was  Helen has left her own warm-hearted account of the &bquo;tiny honeymoon&equo; she and Edward stole and spent in &bquo;the cottage of his old gamekeeper friend&equo; Dad and his wife Granny. 
 But in the Colbeck Collection there is a manuscript of about 2,300 words which Edward wrote in 1895; it is corrected in his much later I handwriting and is entitled &bquo;Dad&equo;. 
 The following extracts from it, written before Edward had met Helen Noble but after he had left St. Paul's catches the effect the old man had upon the young would-be writer: 
 We were roach fishing, larking about perhaps more than anything else, and could catch nothing; you see it was a scorching day and the water bright and clear as crystal. 
 Suddenly with a tremendous stroke an old man close by threw a tiny fish up in the air and down it fell. 
 It was Dad&hellip;. 
 Then we had a little talk, but it did not end there. 
 Chance acquaintance like this ripened into friendship. 
 We found he had a whole store of out of door knowledge which he was quite ready to impart. 
 In spite of his clothes &mdash; what difference did clothes ever make in a good strong man &mdash; he looked a finely made fellow, and we became secretly his admirers. 
 No man at his age ever had a straighter back, that we were sure of, straight and strong, it was as the ground ash stick he always carried. 
 His clear steel blue eyes looked you full in the face without a spark of insolence. 
 It was a kind intelligent eye too, though he could twist a rabbit's neck on occasion with the nonchalance of a professional poacher. 
 Time had left few furrows on that bull strong face, sunburnt like his sinewy neck&hellip;. 
 He used to tell us with a sparkle of pride of enormous weights lifted by him in his youth, and of fights where he felled a man like a bullock. 
 Recalling the mad days of youth in fact, a fierceness almost brutal, showed itself, and destroyed the symmetry of his face. 
 In such moments he was not himself, for age had quelled the turbulent spirit, and tamed what must have been a fierce temper indeed&hellip;. 
 But in knowledge of nature beyond that required in poaching &mdash; which is very considerable &mdash; Dad was even more erudite. 
 He had climbed trees for the blue hawk's nest, and knew its eggs and their markings; the hawfinch, that parrot of the woods with its strange cry and saucer nest, was common in his time. 
 He knew exactly where to look for the nest of any bird we were likely to come across and by certain local circumstances was unerringly guided to a nest hidden deep perhaps in a thorn bush&hellip;. 
 One failing he had in common with most labourers on the soil, much inaccuracy in bird nomenclature. 
 Thus he thought there were two distinct birds, chaffinch and pie finch, and yet called them indiscriminately twinks or pinks!&hellip; 
 Bird notes, not songs, he could emulate to the life, and had I believe made use of this faculty in trapping birds. 
 The hollow note of the bullfinch that is almost ventriloquial in its effect, came as easily from his lips as the chuckle of a jackdaw or the chiding of a sparrow hawk at its prey. 
 I remember being highly amused at his rendering of a young rook's cry whilst gobbling a worm: it was perfectly true to nature&hellip;. 
 Such were only a few of the multitude of his accomplishments. 
 By pointing out a flower or describing a rarity he could make a walk supremely interesting and was indeed a charming companion on any expedition in the fields. 
 There was not a herb or flowering plant of any sort to be met on our walks that he did not know, and hardly one that was not invaluable as a remedy for some complaint. 
 He certainly had no intention of allowing the old lore concerning herbs to die out. 
 Dried specimens of any sort were always kept by him and roots of many more. 
 Such knowledge as he was full of is fast decaying and it is interesting to come across this old exponent of time-honoured homely skill. 
 He might have made a doctor as well as a poacher&hellip;. 
 In modem history as it affected his class he was well informed as ever, and had a memory overflowing with detail. 
 He was bitter against the Church and State though a more truly orthodox man never breathed, and insisted that there was a separate system of law for rich and poor. 
 When bread was a shilling a loaf and men earned less than ten shillings from a long week's work, his father or some other relation was among the most bitterly rebellious against a system that could tolerate such things. 
 Every man poached then, and his family with the rest. 
 He remembers hearing it said that each man in one gang at least vowed to kill or disable the keepers if they attempted to thwart their attacks on the game. 
 It was a wild time, and even the old women were poachers, he said, with the aid of a harmless looking dog that barked only when they reached the cottage with a fresh killed rabbit. 
 Latterly Dad had sobered much when he was no longer able to perform his old feats of strength and daring. 
 To make amends perhaps for the past he had turned tee-totaller and finally Salvationist. 
 It was a strange step from poacher to street comer preacher, but was doubtless sincere. 
 He was loud against &bquo;these new religions&equo;; his woodland life and really intense sympathy with Nature could not overcome his adherence to traditional views of religion. 
 Dad Uzzell, as much as the writer Ashcroft Noble, was a powerful formative influence on Thomas in the eighteen months between his abandoning St. Paul's and entering Oxford. 
 Edward, according to his younger brother's memories, had always shown a rebellious independence of spirit against domestic or external authority. 
 The example of Dad Uzzell was before him for the rest of his life. 
 This self-confessedly wilful boy always contrived to have a great deal of his own way and seemed able to follow his bent whenever the weather permitted. 
 In the long darker evenings, school and home life brought together (however unwillingly at first) the complementary joys of reading and the learning of languages, which led in late adolescence to a much-praised gift for descriptive writing based on his explorations and observations of the natural world. 
 He was establishing a pattern of behaviour that with minimal alterations was to become essential to his habitual well-being: long walks with a selected companion, in place of the organized games and sports of boyhood and middle-school days; the acquisition of semi-rural skills &mdash; fishing, bird nesting, skinning pelts, skilful carpentry, well-arranged collecting of eggs and butterflies and specimens; and, always, the adventure of trespass and unusual exploration that was, in some frenetic way, aimed at the rapid expansion of suburban villa London into older, more rural surrounding communities. 
 As his own prose essays on &bquo;Nature&equo; were being admired by the adolescent girls in the Young People's Guild at the Unitarian chapel, and approved by the minister, by his father and by Ashcroft Noble, and eventually published in sectarian and national journals, Edward discovered the English poets, first slowly under imposition and then, in a rush, in his father's wide-ranging library. 
 This boy, in spite of a studious shyness with most adults and many girls, had somehow acquired a self-confidence based, not so much on achievement in games or school work, but on a sense of the rightness of what he was doing with his own free time. 
 As he explored Merton, Wimbledon, or south and east of South Croydon with Arthur Hardy, &bquo;We had no single definite object now that no eggs were to be found. 
 Talking, and looking at the earth and the sky, we just walked about until it was dark. 
 Students we were not: nothing was pursued to the uttermost. 
 We merely became accustomed to the general life of the common birds and animals, and to the appearances of trees and clouds and everything upon the surface that showed itself to the naked eye&equo;. 
 He wrote the last words of The Amateur Poacher  &mdash; a gospel, an incantation &mdash; as an epigraph on all his own books. 
 His self-assurance comes out now in his attitude to school work: &bquo;I did not like not being able to answer a question, particularly if another boy could&equo;. 
 Edward learned his lessons quickly, but he was never happy in the various schools to which his father sent him. 
 Probably he resented and resisted the thrust of his father's ambition for all his sons, but especially for Edwy, the eldest, so obviously gift ed with the academic ability for professional or &bquo;establishment&equo; success. 
 (Unfortunately, there is no hint of the conversations that took place at this time between Lloyd George and Mr Thomas as they took their daily morning walk &bquo;across the park&equo; from the underground station at Westminster.) 
 While Edward kept himself out of trouble with parents and schoolmasters without extending himself, he never, not even at St. Paul's, acquired the social ease of his schoolfellows. 
 The History Eighth, which had assimilated G. K. Chesterton and E. C. Bentley immediately before Thomas's short stay there, could not quite swallow him, nor he them. 
 A public school was more alien to his nature than his father realized: this son was not cut out for a smooth ascent of the ladder of preferment. 
 The &bquo;foolish years&equo; as a Battersea Grammar school boy confirmed certain attitudes that Edward Thomas never abandoned and that he passed on to his children. 
 He held on to his love of unregimented activity in the open air, away from encroaching London suburbia, and he cherished a sense of belonging to another country &mdash; Cambria or Gwalia, Glamorgan or Gwent &mdash; in addition to the still strange city he was slowly beginning to explore along both banks of the Thames. 
 This dual heritage sharpened the sense of himself as a fused centre between the dream world of a long-vanished civilization and the natural world he observed scientifically. 
 Supported by a work ethic to which his father gave eloquent support in lectures and in writing, he acquired imperceptibly habits of concentrated intellectual enquiry. 
 From his mother, and her more easy-going and less consciously nonconformist relations, he found sanctions for that profound exploration of sensations that were given early expression in his gift for &bquo;composition&equo;. 
 His sense of the long, mixed past of his own family, and the need to rebel against the purpose &mdash; if not the pattern &mdash; of his upbringing, left him neither passionately involved in everyday things, nor yet coldly indifferent to the other people. 
 The persona  of &bquo;the Watcher&equo;, which dominates his best writing, was already being formed: his way forward lay somewhere between social openness and egotistical restlessness. 
 He makes the point in The Childhood , as he describes his half-holiday explorations with Arthur Hardy: &bquo;We merely became accustomed to the general life of the common birds and animals&equo;. 
 These purposeful wanderings in nearby London commons were the nearest he could come to the idealized world he had found in The Amateur Poacher . 
 &bquo;What I liked in the books was the free open-air life, the spice of illegality and daring, roguish characters &mdash; the opportunities so far exceeding my own, the gun, the great pond, the country home, the apparently endless leisure &mdash; the glorious moments that one could always recapture by opening the Poacher &mdash;  and the tinge of sadness here and there as in the picture of the old moucher perishing in his sleep by the lime kiln, and the heron flying over in the morning indifferent.&equo; 
 These experiences he could share with Dad Uzzell, but not with his own father. 
 Following his nature, and before his sixteenth birthday, Edward Thomas had somehow combined a love of nature and of literature, twin aspects of realized contemplation that were to characterize his life as a writer of prose and verse. 
 St. Paul's and Helen Noble 
 SEEN through the Willow-tree&equo; was the title given by Edward Thomas to an unpublished, corrected, but incomplete essay dated 24 December 1902. 
 Underneath he added &bquo;which would be a good title for my next book or for all my work&equo;. 
 The essay evokes the second phase of his life between his fifteen months at St. Paul's School from January 1894 until Easter 1895, his courtship and marriage to Helen Noble, his three years at Oxford from October 1897 to June 1900, his year as a poverty stricken journalist in London, and his determined move to Bearsted in September in 1901: 
 There is a willow before my house. 
 It is covered in ivy by day and by night in mystery and when I lie in bed I see men and women through it passing by. 
 I see it fantastically in the pages of books I read and in a true sense I see life through the leaves of the willow tree. 
 It is I suppose an ordinary willow. 
 In summer it is not so dense but that I can find the blackbird wherever it sings among its branches and not in Winter so agile but that its changing patterns are conspicuous against the sky, its sound an appreciable susurration using the harp strings of the wind. 
 And always in its straight bole I have a stop watch to tell me whether the slowest clouds are sliding and at what a pace a storm is travelling. 
 From my childhood days it was little more than a map, a puzzling weaver, a many tailed whip in the hands of the north wind. 
 On its bush I once traced a gracious face that soothed some half-controlled tears, and once a leer that agitated some nervous mood of loneliness. 
 But the leer and the face have gone. 
 Nor has anything quite so definite taken their place. 
 How often I have watched, nay studied it, and wasted more honest words upon it than I can &lsqb;on&rsqb; most men!&hellip; 
 I have hinted that the dawn has many times come to me through the leaves of the willow, but it is less the tree itself nowadays that transmits things seen to my mind &mdash; than something of which the willow is a visible type. 
 I saw once the head of a dear friend among the leaves and was less astonished at what first seemed an apparition than by his disentangling himself and in the flesh bidding his good morning, so accustomed was I to looking for my thoughts and news among the leaves. 
 Men and books I see through Nature in the first place&hellip; 
 Edward Thomas's fifteen months at St. Paul's helped to shape the early pattern of his life as a writer: I was considered to excel in this form of rhetoric. 
 So seriously, too, did I take myself in it, that from the time I was sixteen I found myself hardly letting a week pass without writing one or two descriptions &mdash; of a man, or a place, or a walk &mdash; in a manner largely founded on Jefferies' Amateur Poacher , Kingsley's Prose Idylls , and Mr. Francis A. Knight's weekly contributions to the Daily News , but doubtless with tones supplied also by Shelley and Keats, and later on by Ruskin, De Quincey, Pater, and Sir Thomas Browne&hellip; 
 While I was afflicted with serious English composition and English literature, I was reading Scott, Fenimore Cooper, Henty, and the travellers, because I loved them; I was also thinking and talking in a manner which owed little to those dignified exercises, though the day was to come when I spoke very much as I wrote&hellip; 
 There is no doubt that my masters often lent me dignity and subtlety altogether beyond my needs. 
 (&bquo;How I Began&equo;, January 1913.) 
 When Edward Thomas entered the History Eighth at St. Paul's in January 1894, he was at least seventeen months younger than the seven pupils who had joined the class in the previous July or September and who were to leave it the following June. 
 We have reports of his school progress for the two half-years ending July 1894 and December 1894 (he left school at Easter 1895 before the July report). 
 The reports by his form master R. F. Cholmeley are in typical school-report phraseology: 
 July 1894. 
 Latin  &mdash; Much to learn: starts a long way behind the rest: &mdash; works well. 
 French  &mdash; Weak as yet. 
 Divinity and English Literature  &mdash; very fair Mathematics  &mdash; Weak. 
 Map Drawing  &mdash; Very Fair. 
 General Remarks  &mdash; Does his work very steadily; backward in languages, but gets on. 
 I wish he seemed to take more interest in life generally. 
 December 1894. 
 Classics &ndash; Backward; improves, Greek very little. 
 French  &mdash; knows little, improving. 
 Mathematics  &mdash; Fair, making some progress. 
 Drawing  &mdash; Good. 
 General Remarks : I should say quite the ablest in the form considering his age. 
 He has no taste for languages, but his history is very good. 
 I wish he were a more sociable person. 
 Both reports square with the poet's clinical memory later in The Childhood . 
 He felt isolated. 
 He travelled to and from home alone, and soon he decided to eat a few buns in the classroom while reading Jefferies, or else to have lunch outside school. 
 He was not asked to play games because he was excessively shy and unaccustomed to Rugby football, although he had played soccer and cricket at Battersea Grammar School, but without the distinction of his second brother Ernest. 
 No one at St. Paul's shared his interest in natural history and &bquo;the naturalists, whom these boys knew nothing of. 
 &bquo;'What are you reading, Thomas?&equo; asked one of the boys who already wore a scholar's gown. 
 &bquo; The Gamekeeper at Home&equo; , said I. &bquo;The gamekeeper's place is in the woods,&equo; said he. 
 And I kept silence, not venturing to remark that the woods were his home.&equo; 
 Often, a victim of his paralysing shyness, he walked along the far side of the Thames, &bquo;sometimes in such wretchedness that I wanted to drown myself. 
 He realized that his own interests were not favoured at school by boys or masters: 
 I felt unimportant, isolated, out of place, and only not despised because I was utterly unnoticed&hellip;. 
 I had now a faint ambition, both definite and indefinite, to do something in connection with learning or literature. 
 My father wished me to try for a history scholarship and I occasionally read as hard as it was possible to do without any interest in history beyond the attempt to memorize facts&hellip;. 
 I never had any grounds for differing from the historian I had last read. 
 The other boys either had enormous appetites for books of many kinds, or they had native wit. 
 I seemed to have nothing. 
 But when the two scholars had gone up to (Oxford, &bquo;I began to be near the top of the form&hellip; but still everything at school was an aimless task performed to the letter only. 
 It cost me many night-hours the more because I was reading of one thing and thinking of another.&equo; 
 He had failed to gain a scholarship to St. Paul's and one assumes that his father decided that his son's lack of ambition and apparent aimlessness about a career did not justify the money spent on a schooling that should naturally lead to Oxford or Cambridge, and thereafter to the Civil Service. 
 After fifteen months Edward left St. Paul's on the tacit understanding that he would read at home for the competitive administration examinations of the Civil Service. 
 Edward Thomas's own narrative of his public-school days is substantiated by memoirs collected in the late 1940s by Rowland Watson and partially supported by reading between the lines of the &bquo;Fiction&equo; which Thomas abandoned in 1914. 
 In 1945, Lucian Oldershaw, with E. C. Bentley a member of the History Eighth at St Paul's when it was first created in July 1893, recalled Thomas at school and during his early days at Oxford: 
 Thomas was two years younger than I and I never met him till the year I left St. Paul's School (1894). 
 The meeting to me was memorable. 
 It took place at the house of my friend R E. Vernede, himself a poet of some promise and a novelist of some performance who was also killed in the &bquo;14&ndash;18&equo; war. 
 We had talked books and Thomas and I left together and went on talking books. 
 We walked for hours about the streets of Notting Hill and talked and talked. 
 What we talked about (it was mainly the classical poetry of the eighteenth century!) did not seem to matter much. 
 I felt we were communing with something deeper than words. 
 I felt something of the same awe and excitement I had experienced four years before when tramping round and round Warwick Gardens with Chesterton, debating the execution of Charles I. Here was someone who ought to have been a member of the Society that G. K. C. had dominated at St. Paul's from 1891 to 1893. 
 When we parted about. 
 midnight, physically tired but spiritually exalted, I found myself quoting what I could recall of Keats' sonnet, a new planet had swum into my ken. 
 I feel today the excitement of that encounter almost as keenly as I did when it took place over fifty years ago. 
 Despite its eulogistic tone Oldershaw's memory seems more credible than E. C. Bentley's half-humorous, half-invented sketch of Thomas aged sixteen during his first half-year at St. Paul's: &bquo;It was Walker &lsqb;Frederick Walker, the High Master&rsqb; too, who had made this possible by clearing the &bquo;History Eighth&equo;, the first recruits to which included my friend Oldershaw and myself, soon to be joined by an exceptionally reserved and quiet boy who usually had in his pocket a rat or so, and a few snakes, which he would shut in his desk with books, and occasionally peep at stealthily &mdash; Edward Thomas the poet.&equo; 
 Few Pauline contemporaries noticed the change in Thomas from an animal carefreeness into the youth who &bquo;had quite a number of temptations to print, and at the age of fifteen easily gave way&equo;. 
 Mr. Tarrant, the minister of the Unitarian church which the Thomas family now attended regularly, had encouraged Edward in his outdoor tastes with much kindness and persuaded the editor of a children's paper to print his early holiday-task descriptions of country walks: But like all other grown-up people he inspired me with discomfort, strangeness, a desire to escape&hellip; 
 However, I think the minister had something to do with the essays I wrote and the natural history notes I kept day by day besides the almost daily entries in a general diary&hellip; 
 My father wanted me to go on to a Public School and I received special lessons in Latin Verse and in Greek.. 
 &lsqb;My father&rsqb; used to talk to me of books and take me to lectures. 
 At Kelmscott House I heard Grant Allen recommending State endowment of literary genius: I saw William Morris and I was pleased and awed. 
 But nothing I ever heard at home attracts me to literature or the arts. 
 One significant external event which placed the attraction of a literary career before the young essayist was the minister's decision to introduce Mr and Mrs Philip Henry Thomas to the family of James Ashcroft Noble, the critic and journalist. 
 Noble had returned in 1894 from Liverpool to London and, after some months attending the fashionable Bloomsbury Square chapel where Stopford Brooke preached to a large intellectual gathering, had decided to join the Unitarian chapel close to their new suburban home at 6 Patten Road, Wandsworth Common. 
 Mr Tarrant &mdash; kindly portrayed in The Happy-Go-Lucky Morgans  as Mr Stodham &mdash; later introduced Edward to Mr Noble (the father of his future wife) who was slowly dying of a malignant, tubercular throat disease but was still actively engaged as &bquo;Paul Pelican&equo;, an influential journalist and critic. 
 Frequent visits to the Noble home, across Wandsworth Common, began in early April 1895 before Edward celebrated his release from St. Paul's with a three-day walk from London to Marlborough in order to spend the summer term with his paternal grandmother at Swindon. 
 From there he made frequent visits to Jefferies' Coate Farm and Reservoir, to well-off Townsend cousins in Clifton, and to the neighbouring Downs. 
 He returned to Surrey on 21 July 1895. 
 Apart from a family holiday at Eastbourne during the last fortnight in August, he remained at Battersea Rise until he revisited his relations at Swindon from 15 February to 28 March 1896, when he broke off his stay in order to visit Mr Noble. 
 But Noble was in the last week of his life, and proved too ill to see his favourite pupil or to hear read the letter of sympathy and comfort which Edward had sent him. 
 The 1895 visit to Swindon, in place of the summer term at St. Paul's, repeats an earlier pattern in Edward's life between schools before he won a scholarship to Battersea Grammar School and while his youngest brother Julian was born into the already over-crowded house at 61 Shelgate Road. 
 Then he caught glimpses of the freer way of life of his father's bachelor brother and, as he explored and fished along the canal, got to know Dad Uzzell who remained a surrogate father-figure for the rest of Edward's life. 
 But during this 1895 Swindon visit Edward kept the detailed diary of &bquo;Field Notes&equo; that was later incorporated into The Wood-land Life . 
 His articles on &bquo;Nature&equo; topics, too, had begun to appear in the various journals where Noble had influence, New Age , the Speaker , and the Globe . 
 Probably the idea of collecting the articles and publishing a book with Mr Noble's own publishers, Blackwoods, was beginning to take shape even before Easter 1895. 
 Certainly Edward's last (and only surviving) letter to the critic suggests that the period of mentorship had lasted for a reasonable time, probably at least a year. 
 It records, too, the young pupil's development from an observer &mdash; of plants, birds, trees and animals &mdash; into a detached recorder of what he had seen. 
 (&bquo;Your good influence and help has sometimes draw me from the enwrapping pleasure of scenes which before held me alone with them. ') 
 After the August family holiday at Eastbourne, &bquo;Edwy&equo; became a frequent welcome visitor to Mr Noble's friendly house. 
 The father found him a ready substitute for his own dead infant son, Philip, and often called the young writer &bquo;Phil&equo;. 
 The mother, who attracted and welcomed happy young men to the house, was a little put out by Edwy's rather shy and serious manner. 
 The elder Noble daughter, Irene, was already launched on her own secretarial career and, at this time, was a close friend of the writer, Richard le Gallienne, a proteg&eacute; of her father. 
 The youngest daughter Mary, a gifted academic in later life, was still at one of the Girls' Public School Trust schools at Wimbledon, and the only son, Lancelot, was at Merchant Taylors' School. 
 Helen, the second daughter, had left the Wimbledon school when she was sixteen and was at home helping her mother to run the house and, as his fatal illness developed, to assist in nursing her father, to whom she was particularly close. 
 As the friendship between father and youth developed, Helen frequently ran from the kitchen to open the door to him and occasionally saw him out. 
 For Ashcroft Noble had never forbidden his study to children, and Helen later recalled seeing Edward at the end of a visit still standing by a bookcase and reluctant to leave. 
 After one such visit she insisted on a chaste goodbye kiss. 
 Her father encouraged Edward to take the freedom- and country-loving Helen on one of his famous long walks in and around London and Surrey commons. 
 Eventually, after one false start, when Edward assumed (wrongly) that Helen would not come, they set off in late November '95 for a short walk to Wimbledon, followed four days later by a trip to Croydon. 
 Thereafter Helen frequently walked to meet him or to accompany him on his return home across Wandsworth Common and on January 1896 they had their first long walk to Richmond. 
 In the Diary included in The Woodland Life  Edward notes under 7 January 1896: &bquo;Year opens mild, with the happy songs of blackbird and thrush thick in the woods; green shoots rising everywhere; all life is quick and glad; the fallow deer idle in the tempered sun under the oaks at Richmond, or sip the water through budding buttercups and weeds. 
 Wood-pigeons crowd to the oaks at sundown, chattering loudly&equo;. 
 In his notebook under 9 January is the single phrase &bquo;Richmond w. 
 HN.&equo; 
 Before he left for his six weeks stay in Swindon that spring he had first called her &bquo;sweet&equo;, she recalled four months later, &bquo;in the little passage, near the willows, near the farm&equo; on Wandsworth Common. 
 They corresponded regularly while he was away, although her mother had forbidden it. 
 Arthur Hardy, Edward's close Battersea school friend and constant country companion, was a welcome visitor to 6 Patten Road. 
 He acted as go-between postman, and from time to time he walked with Helen across and around the Common and talked to her a great deal about Edward. 
 Helen believed that their acquaintance would ripen into a warm friendship, equalling her affection for Jane Aldis, but did not believe that she and Edward could ever fall in love, so convinced was she of her own &bquo;ordinariness&equo;. 
 Arthur assured her she was &bquo;quite decent&equo; and that Edward would stick to her. 
 Helen, however, was still imprisoned in the fears and longings that had marked her life during the first years of puberty and was obsessed with the idea that she would never marry and have children. 
 In six letters from Swindon Edward poured out to her his hopes, his feelings, and his frustrations, and sent poems addressed to her. 
 A week after Edward's return from Swindon in March 1896 Mr Noble died. 
 Edward's parents sent their condolences, attended the ceremony at chapel and graveside, and Mrs Thomas visited the widow. 
 Edward, too, was a frequent and welcome visitor, for Mrs Noble, and her children, were fully aware of his special place in Ashcroft Noble's affection. 
 Mrs Noble gave Helen, as a keepsake, Edward's last letter to her father. 
 Helen and Edward now met frequently on the Common, and she visited her father's grave with him as he tended it with wild flowers. 
 After a fortnight's visit with her mother to her aunt Mrs Poole at Ramsgate, Helen decided that she must earn some money and, if possible, live away from home where her mother's grief-stricken restrictions and excessive dependency &mdash; so she thought &mdash; would curtail that freedom of action and expression in which her father had encouraged her. 
 Apparently, too, Mrs Noble was becoming dubious about the friendship with Edward and the consequences that might follow the hasty pell-mell nature of her second daughter. 
 The Nobles were not well off, and Helen's departure as a nursemaid to the Webbs at 9 Lancaster Place, Cliftonville, Margate, seemed a welcome relief to the widow. 
 Edward was still living at home, preparing without a coach for the Civil Service examination. 
 He was equally busy with his nature walks (frequently with Arthur Hardy), writing papers for acceptance or rejection by the Globe , the Academy  and the Speaker  (earning 22&amp;&frac12; guineas by June), but, most significantly of all, as he later obliquely confessed in &bquo;How I Began&equo;, writing almost daily letters to Helen. 
 Their fiercely preserved notion of honest, controlled friendship had moved sharply into an expression of mutual love &mdash; symbolized, as Helen insisted in all this early correspondence, by the purity and truthfulness of their 26 Edward Thomas  kisses. 
 In deference to her mother's prudent requests Helen had asked him to write only one letter a week. 
 None of Edward's have survived, but to judge from the cross-references in the forty-five extant replies from Helen &mdash; which Edward preserved carefully and in order for the rest of his life &mdash; he wrote about sixty between 15 May and 27 July 1896. 
 The intensity of their love, and their readiness to speak to each other directly from the heart, fed rapidly on this period of enforced absence, made tolerable &mdash; and enhanced &mdash; by the writing of letters. 
 (It was a pattern that repeated itself, and Helen oft en recognized its therapeutic value for herself and Edward at moments of difficulty throughout their married life.) 
 During the month after her father's death each of them had discovered the need to explore hitherto suppressed areas of feeling and half-knowledge that stood between them and a clearer knowledge of the selves they were now fully determined to offer to each other. 
 For Edward it was the third of many stages on his career as a writer: 
 Myself and English, as she is taught in schools, came to a conflict and gradually to a more and more friendly agreement through the necessity of writing long letters daily to one who was neither a schoolboy nor an elder, the subject of the letters being matters concerning nobody else in the world. 
 Now it was that I had a chance of discarding or of adapting to my own purpose the fine words and infinite variety of constructions which I had formerly admired from afar off and imitated in fairly cold blood. 
 There was little cold blood about the topics discussed in these Margate letters. 
 Edward was eager to see and to understand the precise nature and functioning of female anatomy and physiology; Helen, with equal insistence on their purity of motive and the intense trust in him that love had given her, was surprised by joy, sustained by daydreams of their future Eden together, and fired by his frank letters with their confessions of his adolescent fight against erections, nocturnal emissions, and occasional masturbation. 
 She gave him all that she knew &mdash; chiefly from conversations with her close friend, Jane Aldis, and from a small book on physiology belonging to her father which she read secretly until it was removed. 
 They believed in exact equality between man and woman. 
 They showed little regard for the ceremony of church weddings, although they both hoped to find some form of acceptable New Testament-based belief for themselves without benefit of clergy; they believed, in Lamarckian fashion, that the physical match and spiritual preparation of parents would ensure a &bquo;better&equo; offspring, as one essential step to a better world. 
 Edward, a great believer in cold baths and the restorative power of long walks (of between 25 and 50 miles), began to use dumb-bells in order to tone up his body and produce more muscles. 
 Helen used some of her earnings to hire a bathing machine and develop her swimming. 
 Above all she sought &mdash; and hoped &mdash; to prepare herself in every way for modern motherhood, free of the restrictions that had marked her own unhappy upbringing. 
 Under Edward's direction she shared his reading: some Shelley, some Byron, Milton, more Wordsworth, Ruskin, Carlyle and always, Jefferies. 
 (Helen introduced him to The Story of My Heart.) 
 She sympathized with and approved of, if never quite comprehended, Edward's intense love of the special happiness that he found in the heart of the country when absorbed with his rare intensity in sights, sounds, and scents. 
 He sent her some of his notes of what he had seen in their walks and frequently let her see his &bquo;papers&equo; before they were copied out for the editors. 
 She sent him one long descriptive prose account, but kept her own poems to herself This exploratory phase of their amorous correspondence was interrupted on 23 June. 
 Edward and Arthur Hardy were spending a short farm holiday at Horsmonden, a 2&frac12; hour train journey away from Margate. 
 Helen got away for one day and they spent nine hours together in the open air. 
 She had set off from Margate before eight o'clock and for a short time she fell asleep in his arms. 
 They picnicked, and explored the countryside not too far from Lambkin Farm, still quite unaware of the passionate natures they kept in check. 
 (&bquo;To lie innocently then with you seems my ideal for the present&equo;, Helen wrote in August.) 
 They must have talked long and hard about their future, and from now on Helen believed that other people would probably regard them as being &bquo;engaged&equo; &mdash; a term she hated because of the overtones of male dominance and female sexual ignorance that went with it. 
 When she returned to Margate after 10.30 that night she found a letter from Edward, posted before they had met, awaiting her. 
 She assured him that his apprehensions about her travelling late at night were quite unfounded: she and her sisters had been allowed to travel about unaccompanied in Southport and London since the age of twelve or thirteen. 
 Until Helen spent a week at home in early October, they did not meet again for four months; and when the Webb family were at Rotherfield for two months in August and September, there are no letters or notebooks to fill the gap. 
 Except for a few letters from Helen to Jane Aldis, there is nothing until January 1897. 
 Edward returned to his &bquo;little study at home&equo; and, with her encouragement, began serious study for the Civil Service examination. 
 She knew that he &bquo;ought always to live in the country; and someday you will with me&equo;; for the present, she encouraged him to carry out his father's plans. 
 &bquo;Be brave and strong at your work, dear. 
 I mean your examination work, for in your other work you need no encouragement, for you like it so much as it is yourself finding expression in words.&equo; 
 She hopes (&bquo;in a money sense&equo;) that he will &bquo;get the Civil Service post: Nice to have a little money to spare above the necessaries of life.&equo; 
 (A wry comment from two young people who sometimes had to delay posting letters until they could find a few pennies for stamps.) 
 &bquo;When I first knew you, you would have been full of despair and melancholy at the thought of clerical life, but now though there is a faint hint of it you are full of hope and joy.&equo; 
 She asks him to recognize his father's wisdom in trying to encourage him to work for a steady position and shares his anxiety about delays with Blackwoods, over the publication of The Woodland Life . 
 Impulsive by nature and eager to experience fully the love that she knows will be hers for life, Helen is scrupulous in her demands on his friendship and earnest in her desire to learn by his side. 
 The &bquo;H. T.&equo; who wrote As It Was  and World Without End  can be heard just beneath the surface of these youthful letters written nearly thirty years before. 
 While Helen's day was filled by the demands of her young charges and the vain attempts of Mrs Webb to train her in some orderliness in domestic affairs, Edward continued to tend her father's grave. 
 He was still a favourite with her sisters and brother and he was Helen's principal source of news about her home. 
 His moods, as reflected in her letters, remained volatile and while he continued his triple tasks &mdash; preparation for the examination, deciding the final shape of his first book, and producing a spate of articles, many of which were published &mdash; there are continuous references in her letters to his indifferent health and to his repeated determination to live chastely with her until circumstances alter. 
 The pattern of their future life together was already taking shape. 
 Helen believed unshakeably in his genius and was determined to enable him to realize his potential as a writer &mdash; a poet, like Shelley, she believed at this rime &mdash; without sacrificing her own strong desire for freedom of independent action, untrammelled by the stuffy conventions of the elders she suspected of hypocrisy. 
 She wished to offer herself in complete love, without demanding in return any limit to his interest in other people. 
 So convinced was she that &bquo;Love conquers all, that she was prepared at all times to forgo conventional ties if they interfered with his development. 
 Her faith in him was severely tested later, especially in 1908 and again in 1913; but she drew on deep reservoirs of resilience until the anxieties of his last year as a soldier began to sap her energies as housekeeper, mother, and gardener. 
 Although he made a huge bonfire of his papers and correspondence in 1916, and kept it going for a few days, Edward preserved all her letters along with his notebooks. 
 They were part of the story of his heart and, re-read now, one recognizes that the Helen Noble of these letters is incorporated in part into the texture of poems like &bquo;After you speak&equo; and &bquo;And you, Helen&equo;: 
 I would give you back yourself, 
 And power to discriminate 
 What you want and want it not too late,&hellip; 
 And myself, too, if I could find 
 Where it lay hidden and it proved kind. 
 Her letters, like his own comment in 1913 on his letters to her, suggest that at eighteen he had begun for her eyes alone the long process of self-discovery with assured confidence of her support. 
 The following extracts from one letter portray the Helen recalled by Eleanor Farjeon in 1958: &bquo;Of her he said: &bquo;During the nine months before her baby is born, her face is one perpetual smile. 
 My wife could be the happiest woman on earth &mdash; and I won't let her.&equo; 
 He said she wrote better letters than any woman he knew &mdash; &bquo;only it is a different letter each time you read it.&equo; 
 I have said nothing of your letter. 
 What indeed can I say. 
 All the most lovely words of love and passion could not express one tenth of what I feel for you. 
 And your letter is you&hellip; 
 You have my soul now, all my thoughts are yours; only a short time before you can have all of me, even my poor body which I now strive to make purer and better, healthier and stronger for that time. 
 but before that time comes we must often be together. 
 If possible we must spend that time at Coate &lsqb;where Edward then was&rsqb;, and now I long to go to Horsmonden, for every place where you have lived and been happy, is to me dearer than any others. 
 And yet, though I feel so sure that we shall spend a lovely but short time together somewhere alone, yet when I think calmly I grow despairing, for if I went to stay with you, anywhere in the same house and alone, nothing would induce mother to believe me really innocent and pure in heart. 
 It would break her heart. 
 And it is not that she knows me to be bad or weak, or you either, but her conventional mind could not grasp that a thing so often impure, can be made absolutely and perfectly pure. 
 Yet somehow we must do it&hellip; 
 What an exquisite verse from Shelley you quoted. 
 It makes me long for a complete collection so that I might read on, especially the verse you mention but do not quote. 
 Do you know sweetheart I have often wondered since I knew about things whether a brother or sister ever did love with such a love as ours. 
 Oh I used to think &bquo;how beautiful&equo; if such a thing were possible, but I had no idea that such love was thought vile. 
 It seems so natural and pure, so perfect. 
 It is too pure for this impure world, therefore they condemn it as vile. 
 Tell me more of it&hellip; 
 I must say my thoughts to you. 
 Did you know I feel that if I thought (and if you ever did, I should know it as soon as the thought had crossed your brain) you doubted my perfect love, truth, sincerity and striving for goodness, I must indeed give up all the good I have gained, and gain daily, by your love and mine. 
 I should become bad, selfish, a curse to myself and to all who knew me. 
 Life for me would be empty and not life, a mere dragging on of weary time, perhaps not that. 
 I feel like a wretched bird here, taken from its loved mate and caged, trying to sing cheerfully to its poor lonely loved one, but failing fearfully&hellip;. 
 I had your last dear letter this morning (Tuesday), and I feel after your loving, passionate one how mine must seem cold. 
 Yet the words you will not count. 
 Only see me as I write this, throbbing with love and passion, yearning to kiss you, to talk with you. 
 And now I have a terrible thing to tell you. 
 Mrs Webb has never paid me. 
 My money was due on the 11th, and when I have posted this, my last stamp will be spent, and I shall have to wait 'till she remembers. 
 So this will have to be my last letter rill then&hellip;. 
 Dearest heart, sweetest one, lover so good and pure, think when indeed we shall both caress a little soul, a little body, ours to love, to form, to live for and love. 
 When each day shall add strength to its limbs, and its love. 
 When its fairness of mind and body shall be our aim in life, when its beauty shall be our pride our joy. 
 Just yours and mine, no one  else's . 
 There shall be no shadowy third. 
 We will teach it to be pure as we count pure, not the vile purity of the world. 
 We will teach it to have all beauty, we will teach it that love is the most beautiful thing, and never need wax cold, as years go by. 
 We will teach it to love as we its parents purely everlasting . 
 What a future! 
 How sublime, and to you it is as beautiful as to me, else all its beauty would be gone. 
 And now I must say goodbye&hellip;. 
 P.S. Tell me more of the brother and sister of sweet Shelley. 
 I must save up for all of him. 
 Browning too I want, and Keats. 
 Helen spoke on to the page, indiscriminately, in ink, in pencil, in her bedroom, out on the park seat while her charges slept, or on the beach after bathing. 
 She keeps nothing hidden from Edward, so confident is she of his love and so secure in her belief in the future that lies before them, unconventional and home-based: 
 I think I must have suffered as you before I knew of things relating to sex. 
 I am now nineteen and until I was seventeen I was ignorant as any babe. 
 But my ignorance was not only mental torture, but my body seemed to suffer the intensest agony. 
 And when I first got an inkling the little was far worse than none, and I became melancholy and miserable. 
 Neither father nor mother had ever breathed a word, and my first knowledge was thrust upon me &mdash; by happening to read quite unwittingly a pamphlet &mdash; it was by Stead, exposing and giving such ghastly details of prostitution&hellip; 
 It pleases me very much here. 
 I have three little girls aged 8, 6 and 4, and one boy of seven, and they bath and dress together. 
 They sleep in the same room with each other, and look beautiful when I am putting them to bed, jumping and hopping about quite naked, rejoicing in the freedom of no clothes. 
 And it makes me wish that it could always be so. 
 But when they get a little older, they will cover their bodies up and the boy shall never again see his sisters' beauty. 
 O! how wicked it all is, how far from any beauty or ideal. 
 I remember once when I was a very little girl. 
 We were living at Southport and we were being bathed by mother before the kitchen fire, and I was getting undressed and being helped with the buttons by the housemaid. 
 And when it came to the last garment, I pulled that off as well, glad as children always are, and I hope always will to be undressed and free, and stood in what Janet calls &bquo;birthday clothes&equo;. 
 And I remember to this day, though I was so small, that mother was very angry with me, for unclothing myself before the servant, who was a very nice girl who had been with us for a long time. 
 And that is how children are brought up&hellip;. 
 I know plenty of girls who do not know what marriage means until the bond is sealed and there is no escape. 
 Then the facts are burst upon them, and they shrink from their husbands in loathing and horror. 
 Oh Lord! 
 What horrors and impurities and wickedness exist under convention's cloak. 
 At 12 my children shall be told simply and truthfully and clearly what their infant minds can well grasp. 
 The rest a little later. 
 I have suffered too much to let my children face the same suffering&hellip;. 
 In all you say about parents and children living in sweet sympathy and perfect knowledge of each other, in freedom of speech, comrades, friends confiding in each other, telling all and being listened to, and taught, in all this I entirely and wholly agree. 
 That kind of family life is the ideal, the only real family life, the one to which I aspire&hellip;. 
 Again I agree with you when you say that equality of husband and wife is an absolute necessity to the well-being of the family&hellip;. 
 The kind of modesty Tennyson speaks of I hate. 
 It means nothing, it shows nothing, except sometimes betrays its very vileness it would hide. 
 Do you know one of the very first things I noticed and liked in you, was the way you shook one's hand, and looked straight at one as you said goodbye. 
 The &bquo;step demure&equo; and &bquo;downward lids&equo; offend me, and never bring me a sense of virtue&hellip; 
 I am not really a coward or even a &bquo;nervous&equo; person. 
 Solitude, darkness, or the horrible crowd which one sees always in such places as this never make me the least afraid&hellip;. 
 Even in little things we agree. 
 I have always hated that vulgar pomp with which the rite of marriage is coupled. 
 It jars against all my ideas of decency, I should hate it. 
 Mother and father were married without any of that kind of thing. 
 Edward's preservation of these letters uncover the debt he owed to Helen who brought his idealistic, passionate nature &mdash; with its violent occasional swings of mood &mdash; into closer contact with her own dreams and desires for fulfilment of her love, in perfect sexual freedom between them, leading to motherhood. 
 She tells him all and, one assumes from hints and a few quotations in her letters, he does the same to her. 
 As she uncovered herself to him &mdash; &bquo;for I love, and there is no loneliness, no misery, no doubt and ignorance, no hoping for that which seems vain as there used to be, but never will be again&equo; &mdash; one glimpses the ideal that enabled her to accept without question the life that lay before them. 
 Later, in 1908, they had to plan once again how to combine their joint ideal of a free domestic relationship with the solitude that Edward's nature demanded as a price to be paid for his self-discovery as a writer. 
 Even now, at eighteen, he suspected the dark recesses within some of his moods, so unlike his usual shy, yet company-loving, social manner. 
 Helen was confident that her love would remove all doubts: &bquo;I do not &bquo;darkly feel&equo; what it is I love in you. 
 I know it is all of you, body and soul&hellip; there is nothing dim or mysterious in our love that we cannot fathom or understand., It was a creed she held tenaciously &mdash; sometimes blindly &mdash; to the end of her life. 
 &bquo;How I began&equo; 
 IN his last letter to Ashcroft Noble, Edward tried to express his thanks to the dying man for the new direction he had given to his life: 
 I would try and tell you what I have been thinking; though I once told you I cried because I was incapable of thought&hellip;. 
 Your good influence and help has sometimes drawn me from the enwrapping pleasure of scenes which before held me alone with them&hellip; 
 You had made ways clear which before had been dark or fearful with doubt&hellip; 
 You have brought life where there was uncertainty&hellip; perhaps in part you have made me know myself, understood before by you. 
 Already, in March 1896 it would seem, Thomas had decided on a career as a writer. 
 Seventeen years later, in &bquo;How I Began, he reflected on the process with controlled detachment: 
 With short intervals, from &lsqb;eight or nine&rsqb; onwards I was a writer by choice. 
 I began several diaries, carrying on the entries in some of them as far as February. 
 By the time I was fourteen or fifteen, I did more; I kept a more or less daily record of notable events&hellip; they were above syntax and indifferent to dignity&hellip; 
 I was obliged to write essays&hellip; where I gave myself up to an almost purely artistic rendering of such facts as I remembered, and such opinions as I could concoct by the help of memory, fancy, and the radical and the free-thinking influence of home&hellip; 
 I virtually neglected in my writing the feelings that belonged to my own nature and my own times of life &mdash; an irreparable loss, whether great or not. 
 Later in his article, he pinpoints &bquo;the necessity of writing long letters daily&equo; to Helen as the beginning of his departure from nature descriptions &mdash; initially written as talks to be given to the Young People's Guild at the Unitarian chapel &mdash; or his dignified school essays. 
 The letters gave him the chance of &bquo;discarding or of adapting to my own purpose the fine words and infinite variety of constructions which I had formerly admired from afar and imitated in fairly cold blood.&equo; 
 These early letters to Helen are now lost and are merely reflected in her long replies from Margate and Rotherfield. 
 Undoubtedly they were chiefly concerned with the &bquo;feelings that belonged to his own nature,. 
 They accept that he is to become a writer and a poet. 
 His autobiography &mdash; from birth to his entry into St. Paul's and now known as The  sources throw light on the youthful nature journalist who became Edward Thomas, prose writer, literary critic, and poet. 
 One is his novel, The Happy-Go-Lucky Morgans ; the other, an incomplete work entitled Fiction  which Thomas conceived as a continuation of his Childhood  autobiography. 
 It was written rapidly (and compulsively) in early 1914, in an attic room in Selsfield House with some resemblance to his own study bedroom at 61 Shelgate Road where his writing began and where Helen later gave birth to his son. 
 He abandoned it after Robert Frost had read the entire work, approving the Childhood  section but condemning the Fiction  as too introspective. 
 The unguarded nature of the latter, which was never worked over by Thomas, provides occasional glimpses of the youth who left St. Paul's after his seventeenth birthday in order to achieve a twofold purpose: ostensibly to please his father by attending a few practical evening classes and in the day by preparing himself for some form of Civil Service clerical post, while privately, he sought the freedom of a young nature-writer who was determined to collect his papers into a book. 
 This decision to live by his writing was a necessary element in a personality that established firm contours quite early. 
 How did this early decision come about? 
 The Fiction  records part of the rapid maturing, although his growing friendship with Helen Noble lies outside it. 
 The story is carefully dated to support the &bquo;fiction&equo; that the narrator had left grammar school and entered the Civil Service between April 1894 and January 1895. 
 (Helen and Edward began their acquaintance in the autumn of 1895.) 
 It is almost as if Thomas was trying to create, in fiction, an alternative pattern his life might have followed. 
 Biographical reconstruction based on Thomas's tales and sketches can be a mistaken exercise. 
 His imagination rested firmly on observed fact and carefully preserved records: his extant notebooks abound in transcriptions of scenes and encounters, interlarded with direct quotations from ordinary speech. 
 (One notable relic is the second volume (Men) of a two-volume group entitled Things and Men : it is full of snippets of conversation and descriptions spread over the period 1897 to 1910, frequently used in his books and papers in order to restrain his fancy and keep his feet firmly on the ground.) 
 Those who know Thomas well, like W. H. Hudson, were convinced that all his fictitious characters were dominated by recognizable traits of Thomas himself. 
 They could hear him speak unequivocally through his characters. 
 Yet in his Edward Thomas , R.P. Eckert argues that the young Edward had explored the Surrey and Wiltshire countryside in solitude with a fantasy companion called Philip who later reappeared as &bquo;The Other Man&equo; in In Pursuit of Spring  and, even more noticeably, in Thomas's early poem The Other . 
 Eckert did not know the real Arthur Hardy's share in these juvenile expeditions, nor had he seen the then unpublished A Sportman's Tale  which amplifies the sustained friendship between these two Battersea Grammar School pupils. 
 The fictional Philip &mdash; in The Happy-Go-Lucky Morgans  &mdash; was a compound creation based partly on Ashcroft Noble's long-dead infant son, also named Philip. 
 The imagined Philip ceases to exist at the time of the older critic's death; the real tribute to Mr Noble was Thomas's finest book, inscribed to his memory. 
 Ashcroft Noble was part-owner of the three weeklies that published his &bquo;Paul Pelican&equo; articles and accepted Thomas's early essays; and he was also connected with the Edinburgh firm of Blackwood that was to publish those essays in book form. 
 How reliable, as an autobiographical source, is The Happy-Go-Lucky Morgans ? 
 It certainly draws heavily upon Thomas's memories of people and incidents from his youth and early student days and many similarities exist between the bookish Mr Torrance and Mr Noble. 
 The narrator (of the Morgans)  is called Arthur and it is Arthur who survives the death of Philip and goes on to become a writer of some undefined kind on the model of David Copperfield  and Great Expectations . 
 The places inhabited by these characters are drawn directly from Edward's first-hand observations around Wandsworth, and on holidays spent in Wiltshire and West Wales. 
 The world of this novel is as much his country as the wild, half-derelict countrified pockets around the rapidly developing suburbia of Wimbledon, Kensington, and Battersea which the fictitious Philip and Arthur explored as thoroughly as the real Arthur Hardy and Edward had explored the parts of London commons which they called &bquo;Our Country&equo;. 
 Edward's second and third brothers, Ernest and Theodore, have recorded how occasionally they too shared these nature explorations and fishing expeditions in the London woodlands and around Swindon. 
 Their memories emphasise his intrepid, iconoclastic, and freedom-loving wilfulness. 
 Ernest wrote: 
 The only time we really spent together was in the summer holidays&hellip; with our grandmother at Swindon. 
 We went fishing in the Wilts. and Berks. 
 Canal, but sometimes on blazing afternoons, we would trespass in the fields and search for eggs. 
 A branch of one tree hung out over a pond ending in a spray of twigs resting on the water. 
 And there, was a moor-hen's nest and eggs. 
 Edwy was out on the branch almost within reach of the eggs when we were caught redhanded by the farmer on horseback&hellip; 
 The matter was settled by our father with a donation of 5s. to the local hospital. 
 Theodore recorded: 
 For one of so gentle a character he could be extraordinarily defiant of gamekeepers, and threatening letters to my father passed on to him with added threats were not of the slightest avail. 
 He did no wilful damage but regarded himself as entitled to go where he wished for the purpose in his mind without regard to the rights of ownership and the alleged presence of man traps and spring guns. 
 He was scornful of the latter&hellip;. 
 I met him returning from one of the Penn ponds with the largest pike of the year swinging by his side and a look of sheer elation on his face. 
 He would be about 16 years old then but his sources of pleasure changed little with advancing years though his opportunities became less&hellip;. 
 A large fish on his or my line was always an occasion for excitement for Edwy and he would jump into the water with his gaff if he thought it the only way to land it. 
 Weather was no deterrent for him and was never allowed to interfere with his plans&hellip;. 
 On his best days Edwy was a good companion because of his immense knowledge of country sights and sounds. 
 Even on his worst (silent) days he was easily stirred by the song of a human or a bird, by the laugh of a woodpecker, the bark of a pheasant, the sight of a rare butterfly, or the bark of a fox in the darkness &mdash; with his easy and melodious way of putting over his knowledge&hellip; 
 There was companionship in his silence because it was born of a deep reserve which required help at times to find expression. 
 Throughout his life Edward had a passion for solitary swimming, often for an hour at a time, in the sea at Felpham in Sussex, in the small lakes in the Black Mountains, or the larger ones in the Lake District. 
 Silent and solitary he often was, as Eckert knew from the evidence of Margaret Townsend, Thomas's aunt, but he was eager at all times to share his country knowledge with young people. 
 Children particularly who knew him well, and spent time in his company, invariably recall his ease of manner with them and his absorption in their pursuits. 
 Edward was born on the third of March, and the advent of spring is a constant theme, and symbol of renewal, in everything he has written. 
 The fictional Eastertide death of Philip at Lydiard Constantine (in Swindon), leaving the narrator to continue the kind of life that Thomas himself followed in his preparation for matriculation at Oxford in October 1897, reads like a youthful reaction to the actual death of Ashcroft Noble on Good Friday 1896. 
 It is as though Edward, in 1896, had abandoned the career &bquo;as Philip&equo; which Noble had made smooth fur him as readily as, seventeen years later, he allowed the fictional Philip to die. 
 In real life, Edward returned unexpectedly from Swindon to visit the Noble household and, though unable to see his dying mentor, became a support to Mrs Noble and her daughters, while his friendship with Helen grew into love. 
 She was determined to leave home; Edward, according to one of Helen's letters to Janet Aldis, &bquo;haring&equo; his father who still wished his son to enter the Civil Service in spite of the modest success of his articles and the prospect of a first book being published. 
 The sudden death of Philip in the novel is one of the few references in Thomas's work traceable to the impact of the elder critic's death upon him and the Part it played in hardening his determination to become a writer. 
 As he says in the Childhood , he had his full share of determined wilfulness to follow his bent. 
 Apart from the stray references to external events in the letters between Helen and Edward, the incomplete Fiction  is a fuller guide to the decisions Thomas was making between Easter 1895 and the summer of 1896 than reinterpretation of the Morgans  novel. 
 The plan of his outward life and activities is succinctly given in the Diary that forms the last third of The Woodland Life . 
 The fiction  was planned in three or four parts and I assume that most of the first and second parts was incorporated into The Childhood , the initial manuscript of which is in a notebook identical with the extant one, fiction  II &bquo;begun 12. iii. 
 14 Part II begins p. 86&equo;. 
 The preceding twenty-five pages describe a long walk taken by Philip Parrish (in his thirteenth year) with his uncle Richard. 
 It includes a first glimpse of Stonehenge and their eventual arrival at the home of another widowed uncle, Mr Morgan, who lives at Jefferies farm with his daughter Catherine. 
 She resembles closely the &bquo;buxom Welsh cousin named Florence, who was probably eight or nine years my senior&equo;, so described in The Childhood , with whom he spent &bquo;the most blissful hours&equo; in country walks from his grandmother's Swindon home to Shaw or Lydiard when he was ten or eleven. 
 &bquo;I suppose I had a sort of unfettered adoration for her without knowing it. 
 I never saw her after that summer.&equo; 
 Uncle Richard resembles Edward's Uncle Harry and has not a little of Dad Uzzell in his make-up, too. 
 In the Fiction , before he and his uncle arrive at the farm, Philip the narrator describes the image of Catherine that remained from the earlier encounter: 
 I wish I could say exactly what I saw. 
 Paint it I cannot because I am not a painter. 
 I could not even give instructions to a painter. 
 Neither do I believe that a painter could have painted it &mdash; had he seen what I saw. 
 She was beautiful. 
 She had dark but glowing brown hair. 
 I had not yet decided whether her eyes were grey or hazel. 
 Yes! she was beautiful but above all she was blessed and kind and sweet, and I never thought of her as beautiful. 
 It was her face chiefly that I saw brightening and fading away in my mind's eye. 
 Or perhaps I ought to say it was her spirit, since it resembled not at all any portrait that could have been painted. 
 And this spirit brought with it a suggestion rather than the clear outline and colour of the mayblossom dress. 
 I saw what she was &mdash; what she was to me &mdash; not what she seemed or would have appeared to be in a photograph or common portrait. 
 For it was not pure ocular seeing, or I should have seen her as a girl of the age which I have now reached. 
 She was not that. 
 She was not of any age but an immortal loveliness. 
 The eyes alone could never have given me so profound a sense of Spring, of Maytime and the blossoming of hawthorn upon the heaths and wild cherry at the border of the beech copses. 
 More often than not the face peered at me through leaves. 
 When faintest it was a face imagined among flames. 
 The story paints an idyllic picture of many meetings and walks between the lad and Catherine before he and Uncle Richard resume their walk and return home, after a brief visit to Philip's brothers who are orphaned and live elsewhere. 
 There follows a winter of adolescent wretchedness and, as Part III  of the fiction  begins, the narrator describes its surviving effect on him still, almost twenty years later in 1914: 
 I think now that her predominance has done in justice to lesser things in my life, as indeed it may still do. 
 I fear it is even now doing so. 
 It is urging me on over the years bidding me neglect those that were without Cathenne, where as I set out to tell the story of my life, the dull with the bright, the gray with the green, all the Sundays Mondays and Tuesdays of it at least sufficiently to suggest them. 
 Moreover if I were to fly there  what should I do but renew sorrows and incur perhaps insupportable difficulties in attempting to record them. 
 Yet I must still think it my duty, without reconsidering whether or not it be worthwhile, to continue this plain record of what (I know) need not have been plain but for the accident that I am a niggler without impulse, not an imaginative artist. 
 When I get out of my train at Victoria and look about me at the other two hundred &mdash; mostly strangers, not least so those whose names as early schoolfellows dawn on me when they disappeared, &mdash; I sometimes think that one or two of us ought to speak out instead of just voting and making a remark in the complaint book once or twice a year and writing to a newspaper less often. 
 Therefore I will continue. 
 When Edward Thomas decided to send The Childhood  to Eleanor Farjeon for typing, he declared it impossible to recapture precisely &bquo;what he was&equo; as a youth. 
 The fiction , however, reads like an attempt to break out of this self-imposed restriction. 
 Its genesis perhaps was the unsuccessful attempt by Thomas and his walking companion Jesse Berridge, on the journey that became In Pursuit of Spring , to collaborate on a fiction that would include a passionate youthful love, courtship, and marriage. 
 There is no evidence among manuscripts and notebooks to decide this point. 
 Undoubtedly, in March 1914, nine days after his thirty-seventh birthday, at one of the lowest ebbs in his fortune (but soon after he had received a grant from the Royal Literary Fund), Thomas speculated in fictional form upon another path his life might have taken if he had left grammar school at sixteen and followed his father's plan of a career in the Civil Service. 
 The narrator of the Fiction , Philip Parrish, is an orphan living with his uncle but with many brothers scattered elsewhere. 
 He has an uncle called Mr Morgan who lives somewhere in Wiltshire and an aunt in Salisbury. 
 The story of Part III  begins in a London suburb after he leaves grammar school and goes to evening classes: 
 From that school of mingled games, friendliness and lessons I went with but a short pause to one where lessons were business, and a very serious business indeed since most of the scholars had already begun to work in offices and came here in the evenings to qualify themselves to earn more money and more leisure. 
 In the pause I studied by myself first at home, then at my aunt's home at Salisbury. 
 There it was that I really began to read. 
 As he explores the poetry of Byron at Salisbury he works hard at his arithmetic and English composition until he is &bquo;chosen as fit to enter the Civil Service, to hold for the rest of my active life time the pen that is mightier (when you get a good one) than the sword (when you get a bad one).&equo; 
 The remaining five pages of the manuscript give a dispiriting account of the office life he leads, the sonnets he writes, the girls and prostitutes he sees but does not meet. 
 Some of these pages round off the last bits of The Childhood  after he had sent the bulk of it, with Frost's approval, to Eleanor Farjeon for typing. 
 The Fiction  was his last attempt at personal writing in 1914 before he decided, by whatever hidden processes, that the best solution to his apparent obsession with introspection and self-analysis was to cross over into the world of poetry, with its quite different but equally stringent laws and regulations. 
 The Fiction , like In Pursuit of Spring , unveils areas of experience that he felt compelled to probe, in order to retain his dignity. 
 The three following quotations, taken from Part II of the manuscript, recover a few hitherto unsuspected facets of Thomas the young pre-Oxford writer. 
 One refers to his fourteenth year, a little later than the visit to Catherine at Jefferies farm, when he had changed greatly. 
 I had become a good and conscientious boy. 
 Sometimes I used actually to go to a church in my religion, not to one peopled by a clergyman, choir boys, bald old men, and ladies with feathers in their hats, but to an empty church. 
 I know that I went there when the change I have spoken of must have been already complete. 
 My uncle in the evening had read aloud something where the line was quoted The child is father to the man and these words insinuated themselves not into the stony ground and thistles of my mind but into the dark rich soil that brings forth a hundred fold. 
 The first result was a dream that very night. 
 In my dream I flew through a twilight until I reached a forest of enormous trees. 
 Here I alighted and began to walk into the wood in search of something. 
 Seeking without knowing what and going deeper into the forest, I noticed that I was not alone. 
 Other boys and girls were flitting hither and thither among the trees, singly, without a word or a sign of communication with one another. 
 A few were older, many were younger, than I. Some like myself were looking about them. 
 Others had found what they sought. 
 These, when I passed them, I saw to be sitting or kneeling beside cradles, rocking them, or singing, or gazing intently. 
 The children were very much like the angels of resurrection which I had seen over tombs. 
 What was inside the cradles at first sight terrified me. 
 Several that I saw were very old, bearded, emaciated and grim and deathlike, instead of babies, grown men. 
 All were asleep. 
 I was, however, soon relieved. 
 &bquo;The child is father to the man&equo; said one of the tenders of cradles in a pause in his song. 
 Instantly I understood everything. 
 These were children tending the men and old men to whom they were fathers. 
 I was a father. 
 What I was in search of was my son. 
 After some wandering among nurseless cradles I recognized him by some unsuspected instinct &mdash; a pallid moustached old baby. 
 I bent down to look more closely. 
 With a scream I hid my eyes. 
 All had been in vain. 
 My son was dead. 
 And here ended the dream, but not the growth of that seed sown by Wordsworth's poem&hellip; 
 He then relates hearing the ringing of a church bell, dressing quickly, racing towards the nearest church which was shut, not a sound: 
 I laughed and awoke. 
 It was a dream, but the disappointment and dreariness remained with me. 
 The words &bquo;The child is father to the man&equo;, had haunted me all the morning. 
 Beginning by a fantastic attempt to construct pedigrees where sons were their own fathers, I became gradually so involved that I remember wondering if God the Father were in truth only the child that grew up into Jesus Christ. 
 That afternoon I meant to search the Bible for information, though I knew little of it. 
 Every room in the house contained some form of Bible and I took up a large ancient looking one and opened it as if it had been a door into a cave. 
 What I saw and read was &bquo;Our Father which art in Heaven&equo;. 
 I read no more. 
 My curiosity had ceased, swallowed up by a kind of dreamy awe which from that day increased in me very greatly. 
 All that was necessary to bring it on in more or less its full force was the sight of the Bible, its cover or open page, or its mere name, or the sight of a church, or the sound of any bell ringing solemnly, from Big Ben down to the bell of the Sunday muffin men. 
 The next extract refers to a period in Salisbury when Philip Parrish works eight hours a day in preparation for his Civil Service examination without too many lapses into dreaming. 
 He closes his book at seven and goes walking and then reads. 
 Although &bquo;Milton and Wordsworth exalted me&equo;, he eventually buys a complete Byron for two shillings and reads Childe Harold . 
 I actually wanted someone to share the excruciating sad pleasure I got from some of the words&hellip;. 
 Once I had desired a world made good and right and pure, as I conceived, by a Liberal statesman benevolent and omnipotent. 
 Now I was in a perfect world of ocean, mountains and great waters, of mighty men mightily acting or speaking, Napoleon and Byron himself. 
 I had discovered that without which life must be worse than death. 
 From that day onwards I was alive. 
 I knew happiness. 
 As I came down into Salisbury that day I knew for the first time that I had been happy. 
 I used the word happy, repeating it to myself through the streets. 
 When I came to the Market Cross I stopped. 
 I had forgotten my way and had to look all round me slowly until I recognized the street which I had used a hundred times before. 
 The fact is that I had never seen it, or known what I was seeing, until that day:&hellip; 
 Above all the people were strange. 
 The faces of all, of men more than women, and of dark men particularly, puzzled and fascinated and alarmed me. 
 I saw eyes as unkindly as stuffed fox's. 
 What must some of those mouths have said or done! 
 There was something cabalistic about the bandy legs of a road sweeper, who stood with his back to me leaning on his outstretched broom as on a catamaran while he lit his pipe&hellip;. 
 One beautiful face in a shop brought into my mind an undraped statue I had seen somewhere and we blushed together. 
 And I believed that to others I who looked thus strangely upon them, I also was strange. 
 A feeling that I was horribly conspicuous made me wish to hide myself. 
 For the people were no longer a negatively friendly element which the individual slid into and out of&hellip;. 
 Perhaps I discerned something they had in common, but what I saw chiefly was that they were different from me. 
 I was alone. 
 I knew that I was alone, and I found myself saying over my name to myself to intensify my individuality to bring about a conviction that though alone I was strong. 
 Thenceforward I was always wanting to take the joys of solitude and of society in their extreme forms, and was alternatively miserable from the lack of company or the presence of uncongenial company. 
 I remember how both feelings entered into me in the course of one evening&hellip;. 
 I walked into the town feeling like a pirate or Border robber descending upon capon-fed middlemen, moneylenders, retired or expecting to retire. 
 But with the first dazzle of the lights all was changed. 
 I was depressed. 
 I had no magic that could open to me any one of those dark doors, lighted windows. 
 I was alone and I hated it. 
 I wanted men, yet I looked into the faces and with hatred. 
 The third section describes Parrish's success in the Civil Service examination and his growing disillusionment with his fellows and the vacuity of their leisure hours: 
 On hearing that I had a place among successful candidates I was excited with pleasure. 
 I had won a race; I had gratified my aunt and uncle. 
 Above all I was pleased to have assured myself an income exceeding that on which some men had written great poetry, others had done great deeds, many had been free and happy. 
 That I did not care about my work was, I thought, an outrage. 
 It could not get hold of me and stifle me; for it would employ only my hands and a certain section of my knowledge; the rest of me would be free: after office hours my escape would be absolute; and then the holidays would enable me, according to my powers and my wishes, to live another life as different as that of Jekyll from that of Hyde. 
 I did not find, however, among my colleagues many who were conceivably poets, heroes, or exceptionally free men in their holidays and spare time&hellip;. 
 Already I think I found it painful to see so much vacuity without leisure, indolence without refinement. 
 The young men of my own age twirling their canes, pushing into one another sideways, tilting one another's hats, made me angry &mdash; was it because they at least had achieved contentment, and I only contempt? 
 There was no misbehaviour. 
 Every one else was virtually a special constable. 
 &hellip; The women were better. 
 They always had to be constrained in public, Sundays or not; and if anything they were less so on Sunday, when sometimes their clothes were pretty, and at least were seldom black, navy blue or grey as the men's were invariably&hellip;. 
 I no longer saw them, indeed, as legless beings on self moving pedestals as I had done at Salisbury but from being so constantly restricted in movement it seemed that they must be incapable of movement. 
 Perpendicular without intermission, taking steps of the same length at the same intervals, their arms hanging useless and helpless they were no better than trussed chickens but for their faces which, even in repose, suggested movement no less than a bird's wings&hellip;. 
 Was I really different? 
 Why could I never go about arm in arm with two or three others and stare at girls? 
 But I could not be content just to walk alongside a pretty one and hear her giggling. 
 In fact the whole scene of bare common and compact streets looked hopelessly inadequate for two sexes of a race that had produced Byron's poetry and might again do something like it. 
 I was writing sonnets myself, but that did not satisfy me. 
 I looked round for a living man to admire and follow. 
 I used to remember that&hellip; and there the fiction  ends. 
 The Fiction  adds a little to one's understanding of what he was becoming in the eighteen months immediately before his courtship of Helen Noble. 
 His passion for his cousin prefigures many subsequent unfulfilled arousals later in his life exactly as, in moments of heightened sensibility, he reveals an almost Puritan recoil from any way of life that was not earnest, spiritually fruitful, and socially useful. 
 Yet he was not a prig. 
 The Fiction  captures an iron determination to undertake the hard work necessary to realize his own ideals. 
 It suggests, too, the knife-edge path traversed by the adult writer between his overpowering response to physical and natural beauty and the self-defeating sense of unworthiness that he normally characterises, and displays, as a hampering shyness, a fear of rejection. 
 In most of his literary reviewing, the fineness of his critical discrimination and the clarity with which he expresses it draws fruitfully on this special shyness. 
 He refused to be dogmatic, occasionally wrote a modest puff for a friend, was incapable of brashness, and in judgement of people and books had the ability to suspend belief and disbelief. 
 This last quality &mdash; encouraged by Ashcroft Noble &mdash; he had learned to recognize in himself during the period of growth between the boy naturalist of The Childhood  and the much-sought-after undergraduate writer of Lincoln College who breathes freely through the ornate pages of his own Oxford . 
 Is the Fiction  too slight a foundation to build on for some understanding of these intermediate years? 
 Fortunately, in addition to Helen Thomas's absorbing, unselfconscious account of their courtship and the first years of their marriage, letters still survive which chart the growth of love. 
 Here, in sequence, are quotations from Helen's letters to Janet Aldis: Do you remember Janet?, when I saw you last I told you of a plan I had made, regarding the boy who father is taking up, and who writes Nature sketches. 
 I think it will succeed although it will take ages, for he is fearfully shy, and I am likewise affected. 
 He wants a girl friend and I want a boy friend, and as I like him (or at least what I know of him) and I think  he likes me, I think it would be good for both of us if we could be friends. 
 I wonder if we shall. 
 (2 January 1896.) 
 I and the Thomas boy are very slowly making way. 
 He wrote and asked father if I might go out with him on one of his long walks. 
 To my surprise he said I might. 
 So I was in a great state of elation. 
 But to my disappointment Edward never turned up for me. 
 And when he came last night and was asked the reason, he said he never dreamed I would be allowed to come. 
 But he is going to take me some day this week to some lovely woods he knows. 
 Last night I was in a furious rage because Edward asked me to go to his home this afternoon, and he would show me some flowers and nests he thought I would like to see. 
 So I gladly consented. 
 But that little plan was soon put a stop to, for mother would not let me go by myself, and there was nobody to go with me. 
 Did you ever hear such awful tommyrot in your life? 
 I call it very wrong. 
 Mother says What would Mrs. Thomas think? 
 I say if she thought till she was tired, she could not possibly think of any wrong&hellip;. 
 Isn't it simply ludicrous? 
 Here I am eighteen years old, and in a great state of elation because I was going out with a boy. 
 It is disgusting and immoral and a disgrace. 
 Why we may go walks together, and not go to his house where there is all his family I simply cannot imagine. 
 It is too deep for me&hellip; 
 I am going to ask Edward what his views on the subject will be. 
 I rather think he will be very broadminded. 
 He looked awfully amazed when mother said I could not go with him to see his books. 
 (6 January 1896.) 
 Your remarks about Edward pleased too. 
 Whatever made you think that the idea &mdash; of course quite impossible, though for the sake of argument we will not imagine it so &mdash; myself and Edward going away together was simply unconventional. 
 Nothing was further from my thoughts; my reason would be simply enjoyment, and if it was the most commonplace thing to do my delight would not be decreased one bit. 
 The novelty or improperness of the idea is not its alarm&hellip; 
 You scoff at me and my &bquo; one &equo; man friend, you who have so many, but dear girl I have learnt more in the short time of my friendship with Edward, more of the world, of men as distinct from women, and man as an individual than in all my life I have learnt before. 
 You and Osman, you and the Fry, though you have told me of your perfect freedom and exchange of ideas etc. were never freer than Edward and I. Sometimes I wonder that I can speak to him as I do, never before having known a boy, and having only you at times to &bquo;let out, on. 
 Already this freedom has benefited him, and when I know of the good I have done him, I feel that freedom is the only way to greater purity&hellip; 
 All this is feeble no doubt, my words I mean. 
 I only wish I had the power of putting down my thoughts in clear and sensible language. 
 (27 July 1896.) 
 These quotations &mdash; and many more letters to Edward &mdash; amplify, in their chatty, less intense manner, the picture of early courtship recalled by Helen in 1924&ndash;6 in As It Was  and World Without End . 
 Edward acknowledges her effect on him in a letter &mdash; one of numerous happy, affectionate letters to &bquo;My dearest Friend&equo; &mdash; from his lodgings at 113 Cowley Road, Oxford, 29 January 1898 (the third of his letters to her after his return to Oxford for the Lent Term): Take care of yourself my dearest friend. 
 I often fear for you in many ways, quite unreasonably it may be. 
 Don't go about much; no late returning in crowded streets from Earl's Court or elsewhere; no dissipating jabber and smoking and drinking with the Andrews &lsqb;where Helen was employed&rsqb;. 
 By the way, do you drink wine when I am not here ? 
 I would much rather you did not. 
 Probably you do not care enough for it to create a liking and a need, which we shall never be able to satisfy nevertheless, avoid it unless principle and pleasure and interest all advise it. 
 &mdash; It is my great resting place, that you are well: truly it is more than health to me, and gives me an untroubled fancy which is good for my work and my temper. 
 Tell me therefore of it, little one. 
 Even if I seem often cold in my letters and not noticing your words. 
 I have not often coldness with you, sweet heart; yet I often feel that you teach me to love you. 
 You remember, how once in my self-unconfidence, I asked you to take care of me until my age settled into true understanding of love? 
 But I do love without limit or doubt, you only, your body and spirit and memory. 
 After Edward arrived in Oxford in October 1897, the regular correspondence between him and Helen gives a fairly full picture of his life until he and Helen and their eight-month-old son, Merfyn, settled temporarily in lodgings, first at Atheldene Road, Earlsfield and then, nearer to both their parental homes, at 7 Nightingale Parade, Balham. 
 This same period is also covered by a series of long letters from Edward to Harry Hooton, an older man who had married Janet Aldis and, increasingly, by correspondence between Edward and Ian MacAlister, who became one of Edward's staunchest friends. 
 (There are, too, some revealing letters from Helen to MacAlister.) 
 But there are few definite sources for Thomas's activities &mdash; and even less for his thoughts, opinions, and attitudes &mdash; during the period between 30 March 1896, the end of his nature diary (the appendix to The Woodland Life ), and his entry into Oxford. 
 Helen Thomas's As It Was  is a principal source. 
 The brief memories written for R. L. Watson in the late 1940s by the poet's second and third brothers say nothing about this period. 
 Some of the experiences drawn upon in the Fiction  belong to the blank period between October 1896 and January 1897, for which no letters from Edward and Helen survive. 
 When the correspondence resumes in January 1897, the change of mood is evident from a letter Helen sent to Janet Aldis the previous November from Margate: 
 This letter is going to be devoted to my affairs in connection with Edward&hellip; the other day he asked me if I thought you would care to go for a walk into the country somewhere. 
 I said I was sure you would, and gave him your address&hellip; 
 He would not care to take you home to his house to tea, he hates his father so, but I suggested both going to our place, you will do this won't you? 
 The little mother &lsqb;Mrs Noble&rsqb; would be so glad to see you both&hellip; 
 He may be shy at first, but after a while he will get over that: he is not half so shy as he was, of course not. 
 The dear boy is very passionate, and his love for me making life now utterly happy, at the same time fills me with a sense of great responsibility. 
 But the happiness would not be so intense were this feeling absent. 
 Mother and lots of other people would say we were too young to love truly, they would have us wait for our &bquo;years of discretion&equo;; at what age one is supposed to be abnormally discreet I do not know, all I know is that I have not arrived there yet, and I hope I never will. 
 I do not believe that youth is incapable of true and lasting love&hellip; 
 I, since the time when I first became morally certain I was in love, seem to have grown years older&hellip; 
 There is a purpose in living now, a sense of good in living which I did not know before. 
 I suppose we are what is called engaged, though it is different somehow. 
 We at first wanted to know each other, then knowing became friends, and every day as our knowledge increased, greater liking, deeper sympathy, and so on to love and feeling our love, knowing it to be true, pure, and everlasting; then the desire for the perfect life of unity, and then of giving the world the benefit of our love by a little child. 
 And so for that time we live now, both of us, and we are perfectly happy, and the waiting is not weary, but good and happy for us both. 
 We are young and youth is said to be fickle, mutable, and we have both looked at the possibility of ourselves not being exceptions to that supposed rule. 
 We cannot imagine it, yet it is possible, and if such a change did come to one of us, there would be pain for both and merely afterwards friendship&hellip; 
 Edward never proposed to me, I never &bquo;accepted&equo; him, yet here we are just as much engaged and much more so than lovers of whom I have read. 
 This love was the outcome of our friendship, just as our friendship was the outcome of our acquaintance; there was no break only a very gradual difference. 
 I can hardly remember the first time I felt that we loved each other. 
 It was all perfectly beautifully natural, like the blossoming of a flower. 
 Helen's mother wished her daughter to return home from the Webb family. 
 There is a hint that the older people generally frowned on meetings between Edward and Helen similar to their innocent day at Horsmonden. 
 Helen was planning to leave Mrs Webb &mdash; now safely delivered of her next child &mdash; and to seek employment in London and live at home. 
 There was talk of sending Edward for a short health-restoring visit to Swindon. 
 Having opened negotiations with the publishers Blackwood after Mr Noble's death and having agreed to their request that he should supplement his choice of eleven country essays with a diary of his observations &bquo;in English fields and woods&equo; from 1 April 1895 to 30 March 1896, he was busy reading the final proofs of The Woodland Life . 
 The nature of his ill health is undisclosed but his &bquo;wild discontent&equo; was finally healed by two events. 
 The first was Helen's return to 6 Patten Road for a ten-day holiday before she began work in London as governess to Horst, the young son of M. and Mme Roman who lived at the Hotel Metropole. 
 The second, referred to obscurely in Helen's last letter from Margate, was Mr Thomas's decision that Edward should not take up a Civil Service post, but instead prepare himself for an Oxford entrance scholarship. 
 Probably Edward, like Parrish in the fiction , had done extremely well in the Civil Service examination and this evidence of his academic ability, together with the favourable critical reception of The Woodland Life , convinced his father that Edward was now worthy of financial support. 
 There is no firm evidence either way. 
 Helen never intended her As It Was  to be an accurate account of their young lives, and there are no letters because they met often. 
 From February '97 onwards Helen is helping him to buy some newly needed textbooks. 
 In April, while on a protracted stay with Janet's parents in Walsall, she complains of his extremely hard work, and in early May she first states that he is working for Oxford entrance. 
 By now a new restriction had been placed on their friendship by both parents. 
 Helen's new employers departed mysteriously and suddenly, and Helen was sent to Rugby almost at once to help Mrs Sery, an &bquo;excitable, merry French Woman&equo;, with her young son. 
 She stayed a week and then joined Janet Aldis for an indefinite visit at her parents' home in Walsall, where Mr Aldis was a housemaster at Queen Mary's School. 
 Returning Edward the proofs of his book, Helen commented: &bquo;This has indeed been a fair spring for us, though they had made it a winter. 
 Poor fools, how can Winter come, when we love.&equo; 
 When she arrived at Walsall, she informed Edward that Mrs Noble, after sending her earlier a &bquo;vulgar and jeering&equo; letter in which &bquo;She does her best to make me doubt you&equo;, had forbidden them to meet or correspond until Helen reached years of discretion &mdash; her twenty-first birthday on 11 July 1898. 
 Helen regretted giving her consent, because she intended to see Edward and to write to him. 
 She hated even more the absence of honest dealing with her mother. 
 Eventually she gave her mother an undertaking for a limited period and hoped Edward would agree. 
 &bquo;We must hope before you go to Oxford mother will have relented enough at any rate to make writing to you possible.&equo; 
 Edward agreed. 
 He had often, in their earlier correspondence, spoken of a test or ideal that he wished to impose on himself as a rein on his passionate temperament and his over-eager response to physical beauty and joy. 
 He explained to Helen the painful discomfort of his frequent erections while they walked together and his determination to avoid masturbation. 
 The absence of any letters between them from mid July until October suggests that they deliberately refrained from regular letter writing for a time. 
 After early May, Mrs Noble relented to some extent. 
 Helen was called home to help her sister, Irene, in her employment and during this ten-week secretarial stint she and Edward met frequently on the Common as Helen returned from her work. 
 But difficulties were placed in their way. 
 Helen, having once given her word, was uneasy about their infrequent meetings and pleaded with him to support her resolve: 
 We both have work to do, we each have a duty, yours your work, mine to help my Mother, and surely our love will help us more than anything to do well. 
 And our love does not depend on anything, though for years we saw nothing of each other, still we should love. 
 And I feel if now we deny ourselves our greatest delight and say our love alone shall make us strong, our strength shall not depend on anything but our love then indeed I think we shall be creating an independence of each other, which can only make our binding sympathy more perfect&hellip;. for the present, for the 14 months before I am 21 then I have after much real thought, much consideration decided that it would be best for both of us to be separated&hellip; 
 I have not a strong mind, or will, nor am I unselfish, and so knowing well my faults I ask you to help me. 
 Consider it all well, look into yourself, and tell me soon how you feel. 
 Write to me that is best&hellip; 
 Come here to see me if you will; mother asks you, and I want you, but it is for you to come or not as you feel best, or as you like. 
 Edward accepted the immediate need to support Helen's decision and maintain Mrs Noble's good opinion of him. 
 A few hasty notes in July show that he continued to visit 6 Patten Road, and occasionally to have dinner there, until their separation became a reality, when Helen took up a resident post as governess with the Wards, at 33 Bath Road, Bedford and Edward spent August with his father's relations at 17 Woodville Street, Pontardulais, while his younger brothers became pupils at a small denominational school in Ammanford. 
 In September, when Edward had any spare time and Helen was free from work, they met frequently at the National Gallery, where they examined minutely Greek male and female statues, or at Janet's lodgings. 
 Mindful of the gaps in his reading, and aware of the range of books in Mr Noble's library now denied to him, Edward and Helen scoured the second-hand bookshops for bargains and texts necessary for his matriculation test in October. 
 The serious business of gaining an Oxford scholarship and some measure of financial independence had begun and, for a time, gave Edward the drive necessary to matriculate easily as a non-collegiate student at Oxford, to live in lodgings there, and to attend a full course of lectures to prepare himself for an entrance scholarship to Balliol, Merton, or Lincoln. 
 The self-discipline and lessened dependence on each other that Helen had hoped for had had some effect on Edward, as his first letter to Helen from his Oxford lodgings shows: 
 My dearest friend, As yet I can do little more than write comfortable letters containing matter of fact and ordinary news. 
 For I have so far lived almost wholly the outer life which is so distressing to think of and to endure. 
 Never, perhaps, have I so lived for such a long time together. 
 The cause of it is evident enough: such a call on my brains merely; and of my brains, only that portion which says one and one made three, says how do you do, says I will now dine. 
 But it is evident it will soon alter. 
 When I am settled, there is no reason why my life should not be as placid, and there is much reason why it should be far more placid, than at home. 
 Until then I wait. 
 Until then my writing to you, my own sweet little one, must taste even as harsh as my conversation and look now are&hellip; 
 I cannot even tell you how my work will be though I know very certainly that it will demand long attention if I am to pass Responsions and get a scholarship. 
 Therefore you will understand short rare letters. 
 (17 October 1897.) 
 The period of epistolary self-restraint lasted until the beginning of 1898. 
 The schoolboy writer of nature articles had found a new purpose around which to weave his dreams of a future with his &bquo;anemone maiden,. 
 As his own free reading expanded, with greater leisure and the wealth of Mr Noble's books, he had begun to match his nature writings against the ideal world of the nineteenth-century English poets. 
 In one notebook (dated 24 April to 22 June 1897) he had first written an essay on the &bquo;London Night&equo; and then wrote across it, 
 This is a mere exhibition of my inability to write plain prose, and more terribly, my impotence&hellip; 
 Now I am off to write my sonorous senselessness in prose. 
 I wonder shall I ever delight, touch, or interest one human soul that is strange to me? 
 That vanity about captivating girls with my account of the wild flower is long past. 
 With all my heart I hope for the failure of that first book &mdash; no, volume, of mine, from beginning to end not trash, but heartless pretence. 
 Do they prate of observation ? 
 My dull eyes were better out, than thus to walk through life, a sort of inferior lynx, a moral mole, or bat. 
 Such self-disgust appeared to have physical causes or manifestations: a pattern that was to repeat itself at irregular intervals for the next twenty years. 
 In an earlier notebook, dated 10 March '97, he recorded: My limbs fall in, tremble, yield, I am a wreck, even of what I was last Spring. 
 Today I started under a rainbow, towards one of those western panoramas of pure cloud that rest there in vain, but could not reach. 
 It is hard. 
 For the spirit still is bright and swift, the eye capable of all delight; but what can that avail, when I cannot, here, in the street, submit to my impulse or sensation, but must be a creature of body, where the body is all, the spirit in subjection to it? 
 If I look up to the blue sky, as yet I must when it is blue and bright suddenly, it is in spite of the heavy limb and relaxing back that will drag me down or cause me to hasten home. 
 Already, at the age of nineteen, he was experiencing the morbidity which occasionally harassed him and which he described sixteen years later in a chapter on the &bquo;character&equo; of Keats: 
 He was himself the first discoverer of that &bquo;morbidity of temperament&equo;. 
 That he did discover it, that he had a wonderful self-knowledge &mdash; not mere self-analysis &mdash; calm and penetrating, never coldly submissive, is a proof that it was not the whole truth. 
 The morbidity was the occasional overbalancing of his intense sympathy, his greatest passive power&hellip;. 
 He was for &bquo;a delicious diligent indolence&equo;, for a passiveness allowing the intellectual powers to come very gradually to ripeness. 
 When he was in a room with people, unless he was following a definite thought, he was so open to their influence that the identity of everyone pressed on him and annihilated him:&hellip; 
 At one time he left off animal food, as he said, that his &bquo;teeming brain&equo; might not be in a greater mist than was natural to it. 
 And there seems no doubt that this intense life of the mind often reached a point either of aching or of languor. 
 The word &bquo;ache&equo; is one of his constant, significant words. 
 This perceptive study makes it clear that Thomas refused to accept the &bquo;morbidity of temperament&equo; as the only key to understanding the man. 
 There is so much of Keats that he admired &mdash; his pugnacity, his social concern, his gusto, his direct presentation of the moment's phases of mind and moods of temperament &mdash; that one becomes aware of the impress of Thomas's own mind and experience through his comments on Keats: &bquo;Because he was then in the midst of his greatest period, and had to find vent for the pressure of poetry within him, he had to live away from Fanny Brawne, at Shanklin and Winchester: had he been near her long, at this time, love and poetry together, not to speak of the &bquo;hateful literary chit-chat&equo; of Hampstead, would have been insupportable. 
 When he wrote verses directly to her he proved it.&equo; 
 Keats  was written rapidly at Selsfield House in 1913 some months before he began his work there on the Childhood  and the Fiction . 
 Reliving Keats, love for Fanny Brawne, Thomas (away from home and family) was tapping the subterranean channels of his own courtship and early days as a writer. 
 Except in his early letters to Helen, his reticence about his passionate courtship is almost complete &mdash; a fact that may explain, if not excuse, the coldness with which many of his friends and family received Helen's slightly idealized accounts of their life together in As It Was  and World Without End . 
 His yearning letters to her from Wales and Oxford corroborate amply her direct narrative of their passionate, loving sexuality. 
 She remembered incidents vividly and, when she wrote her books, she had their letters to each other and all his notebooks (most of which are now in the Berg Collection), carefully dated between November '95 and June '97. 
 The first four are mainly nature observations similar to the Diary printed in The Woodland Life . 
 They record on 9 January 1896, &bquo;Richmond with HN&equo; and that 1896 &bquo;opened mild with song of Robin and blithe-heart Blackbird&equo;, that in April and early May he was &bquo;at Surrey&equo; and the next month he paid visits to Chipstead and Horsmonden. 
 He noted his reading and his earnings: &bquo;Thoreau I am now reading with interest and pleasure. 
 &bquo;There can be no very black melancholy to him who lives in the midst of Nature and has his senses still.&equo; 
 ( Walden ).&equo; 
 Typically, he notes a list of payments received for journalism, in the first half of 1896: Globe  &mdash; 4 guineas for 4 items; Speaker  &mdash; &pound;14.15.0 for 7 items; and New Age  five at 10&shilling;6 each. 
 The fourth and fifth notebook record an extended period (13 June to 14 November 1896) spent successively at London, Horsmonden, Mumbles, Langland Bay, Carswell Bay, Bishopston, and Pwll Du &lsqb;Gower&rsqb;, and then September spent at Pontardulais. 
 On his return to London he makes the following comment on the period 8 to 14 November, presumably spent with Helen Noble: &bquo;The holiest and best of pleasures. 
 It cannot be forgotten or surpassed though gone for ever. 
 All life quickens. 
 Mine most of all. 
 Why should I not be proud. 
 But I must be. 
 This heat makes me so. 
 Envy and lust and wrong cannot reach such moods.&equo; 
 Thomas discussed the relationship between love and poetry much later in Feminine Influence on the Poet : &bquo;The love-poem is not for the beloved, for it is not worthy, as it is the least thing that is given to her, and none knows this better than she unless it be the lover&hellip;. 
 It may open with desire of woman, but it ends with unexpected consolation or with another desire not of woman.&equo; 
 He recalls, without explicit statement (though their letters affirm it), the way in which he and Helen interwove poetry with their own voyages of mutual discovery: We treat them &lsqb;poems&rsqb; as parts written for ourselves to act, in the spirit, as they were written by the poet, in the spirit. 
 There is much of the poetry of Shelley and of Spenser, for example, written since they knew a woman, which has no mention of woman, and yet is full of love and fit to awaken and to satisfy love&hellip;. 
 At this time when youth is most exultant, this poetry is thumbed night and day; a page is opened at random, as Virgil used to be, for a word big with fate. 
 This is still (in 1910) the unmistakable voice of his early letters to Helen: it confirms the &bquo;David&equo; portrayed in As It Was . 
 During their courtship they believed that his true future was to be a poet. 
 Like his father, Edward was a born teacher, and he guided Helen's reading further into his own thorough knowledge of Wordsworth, Shelley, and Byron. 
 Apart from Dickens, their prose reading reflected the radical attitudes of their Unitarian upbringing: Hazlitt, Carlyle, Cobbett, Ruskin, and William Morris besides numerous progressive pamphlets. 
 The influence of Pater &mdash; which lies beneath Edward's undergraduate article on the &bquo;Frontiers of English Prose&equo; with its carefully argued refusal to draw distinctions between prose and poetry &mdash; developed during his first non-collegiate year at Oxford. 
 Six months before he sat his Final Schools examination, he recorded the change he had observed in &bquo; My Writing  &mdash; it seems daily to become poorer though my mind is slowly growing. 
 My letters perhaps improve &dollar;these were chiefly those sent to Helen, Harry Hooton and Ian MacAlister&rsqb;, and perhaps indicate the line of my future efforts. 
 But as it is I feel before the world as Sidney before Stella (Sonnet L) 
 So that I cannot  chuse  but write my mind, 
 And cannot  chuse  but put out what I write.&equo; 
 This twin need to find adequate expression for his own nature, and to share it with others, remained constant for the rest of his life. 
 The Long Green Day: Oxford 1897&ndash;1898 
 &bquo;IN Oxford nothing is the creation of one man or one year&equo;; the subtle blend of antiquity and urgent immediate concerns masks the change that nine (or twelve) short terms can make upon the most transient undergraduate. 
 Edward Thomas was no exception to his own precept. 
 A month before he went up in 1897 his father's first cousin (and namesake) had been struck by the lad's awkward manners, silent gaucherie, unsuitable dress, and down-covered chin; three years later Edward returned the visit in a colours blazer, accompanied by his wife and his eight-months-old son. 
 He was now an Oxford graduate with a second class Honours degree awarded in the History schools, who had published a series of papers in London journals during his Oxford career. 
 These were obvious external changes. 
 The less apparent development of character and literary ambition seems adequately chronicled in numerous surviving letters to Helen Noble and to Harry Hooton, soon to be the husband of Janet Aldis. 
 Edward early knew the deficiency of his letters to Hooton: &bquo;It is a weariness to fumble for truth and completeness, and after all to feel the failure at both. 
 Living words alone could speak plain. 
 Truly my living words could vindicate me; ask Helen, if they would not., The necessary complement to the epistolary picture of his Oxford life is his own book Oxford , published three years after he came down. 
 There his intense affection for the place, its people, its buildings and its surrounding countryside still shines clearly, although Thomas's Oxford is grossly distorted for us today. 
 Some time ago&hellip; in a high attic I heard once again the laud or summons or complaint of bells&hellip;. 
 Once again I felt the mysterious pleasure of being in an elevated Oxford chamber at night, among cloud and star, &mdash; so that I seemed to join in the inevitable motion of the planets, &mdash; and as I saw the sea of roofs and horned turrets and spires I knew that, although architecture is a dead language, here at least it speaks strongly and clearly, pompous as Latin, subtle as Greek. 
 No one can walk much in the Oxford country without becoming a Pantheist. 
 &hellip; Everywhere the fancy, unaided by earlier fancies, sets to work very busily in these fields. 
 I have on several afternoons gone some way towards the beginning of a new mythology, which might in a thousand years puzzle the Germans. 
 The shadowy, half-apprehended faces of new deities float before my eyes, and I have wondered whether Apollo and Diana are not immortal presences wheresoever there are awful trees and alternating spaces of cool or sunlit lawn&hellip;. 
 Often I saw a clean-limbed beech, pale and slender, yet firm in its loftiness, that shook delicately arched branches at the top, and below held out an arm on which a form of schoolboys might have sat, &mdash; rising out of fine grass and printing its perfect outlines on the sky, &mdash; and I could fancy it enjoyed a life of pleasure that was health, beauty that was strength, thought that was repose. 
 From his digs at 113 Cowley Road, Thomas wrote his first letter to Harry Hooton: &bquo;My dear Mr. Hooton, I matriculated today before the Vice-Chancellor of the University, and, in consequence, I am left a little freer of time and heart: for until then, I feared failure in what turned out to be the easy matric. exam., and worked to the exclusion of almost all else: which is the explanation of time and heart.&equo; 
 It was the formal beginning of a lifelong friendship with &bquo;someone more sure and staid&equo;, eight years his senior. 
 During his first term at Oxford Hooton received long letters on a wide range of topics. 
 They uncover the gap left in Thomas's intellectual development by the death of Ashcroft Noble and his own sense of the inadequacy of his preparation for the nine terms spent at University between October 1897 and his final viva voce examination in July 1900. 
 &bquo;You will purge me and my mood, as my Pater used to purge my writing of its excess&hellip;. 
 Restless that I am, I often pray that someone would cage and rule me entirely. 
 Just as, in writing, I think little men should be bound to mere journeyman work. 
 .. I have changed out of the paternal democracy into a conservatism that believes in Caesar, Pope and the fierce God of Battles &mdash; almost.&equo; 
 Many more revelations and assertions were to follow. 
 He spent the first three terms as a non-collegiate student (a &bquo;tosher&equo;), preparing himself for Responsions by means of three hours' daily tuition directed towards entrance scholarships to Balliol in November and Merton in January (which he failed to win), and then to Lincoln College, which he won easily in March 1898 because of the mature quality of his style and approach in the general essay paper. 
 He had failed Responsions twice, in December and April before the Lincoln examination and he knew that if he did not pass in June his Oxford career, in spite of his entrance scholarship, would end abruptly. 
 Edward overworked in his lonely digs &mdash; &bquo;the first time I ever truly worked&equo; &mdash; and in these early letters to Hooton he discovered new qualities in his nature. 
 (&bquo;Would you believe me if I called myself a Puritan? 
 I admire the Puritan and Puritanism; and so far, my maidenly debauchery of habit still leaves me a Puritan in life. 
 This, however, becomes sheer self-description.&equo;) 
 He passed Responsions that June and began to look forward to the payments he would get for his journalism &mdash; especially for his &bquo;prose poems&equo; in the Speaker . 
 He and Helen were planning to save money for their future life together. 
 Six papers had been accepted for publication during his first Oxford year, but he was as little pleased with them as with The Woodland Life : &bquo;I am impatient to get to Lincoln College&equo; he wrote to Hooton. 
 &bquo;One thing I hope to get there &mdash; religion. 
 I find such a need of that, as an informing spirit in all r do and am. 
 If I can be serious enough, I hope to find satisfaction in the Church of England: it will be my fault if I don't. 
 I want, as Milton says in those pathetic closing lines of his Epic, &bquo;a place of rest&equo;&hellip; 1 am too doubtful about my own writing to think of making an effort towards completing another volume. 
 I shall wait. 
 Perhaps some good will come of rivalry and comparisons &mdash; if there is any for me &mdash; at College. 
 I hope so. 
 I have need of such comparison, otherwise my writing is of a hothouse type.&equo; 
 At the end of July, with Responsions successfully behind him as well as a happy celebratory birthday outing for Helen spent with Harry and Janet, Edward was still as hesitant as in his early letters to Hooton: &bquo;May I bring a paper in manuscript and talk it over with you? 
 I am so discontented with my work. 
 Other people's approbation and censure is all insipid and uncritical, so does not help; and I have no ground for confidence in myself. 
 Without my capacity for perseverance in such work as mere dictionary reading, I should despair. 
 I am constantly called a fool, because I have not that literary indigestion which throws up what it feeds on, every week or so.&equo; 
 He had come a long way, he believed, since the Speaker  paper (October 1897), &bquo;Shadows of the Hills&equo;. 
 An evocation of his previous summer holiday in Pontardulais, it was the first of many papers about the half-fantasy Malory-like character of a knight called Basil of the Woods or the Knight Solitary: &bquo;all very sublime but a little uninteresting to everyone but myself. 
 As a child of 16, I was supposed to have some gift of description; now I have not a particle of descriptive power&hellip;. 
 It all rests upon a possible impressionableness in me, and relies a good deal on mystery or mist., The allegory in &bquo;Shadows of the Hills&equo; is crystal-clear, in spite of the involved style: &bquo;For Nature took him and held him fast like a jealous lover&hellip; 
 But he might not always meet her calling or her waiting, for men, too, were bidding him to the sound of axe and plough and sword.&equo; 
 Thomas found himself ill-equipped to answer this bidding call effectively: This doubt of myself is the more powerful, because I see how all along my senses are so powerful. 
 Everything affects my senses and thereby my soul; nothing my mind, and thereby my soul. 
 I am impressed like a child by grand size, grand sound, vastness in anything, infinity: that sums me up. 
 I am like the cow at the sea shore, bound by the motion of the waves. 
 I am like the child spell-bound by the accumulated powers of the night, &mdash; darkness, the sound of silence, loneliness, infinite possibility, all mingled in a vast horror. 
 That is what touches me. 
 In my affections it was the same. 
 I do not mean a sexual strength &mdash; of that I have little &mdash; but a union of all my senses simply carries me past all reflection, sometimes into a beautiful ease, sometimes into filth and futility&hellip; but always I am passive. 
 Open to all the influences of Nature and man, but giving little: running like a senseless stream&hellip; 
 Ala I want my writing to be is modest, restrained, colourful, truthful&hellip;. 
 For me, I think the last paragraph in my paper in the Speaker  of the week before last &lsqb;&bquo;Shadows of the Hills&equo;&rsqb; was pretty good; but it ought to be in verse. 
 It is a sort of Addendum to Wordsworth's &bquo;Ode&equo; &mdash; but very erratic and only half true. 
 He was still writing verses but, according to Hooton's notes, he abandoned them at the end of this year under the influence of Pater. 
 In these letters to Harry he frequently mentions his excessive response to beauty in men, women, and children. 
 He had discussed it often with Helen and both had agreed that such frankness was a necessary act of truth-telling between them. 
 Even if their love were to die, nothing should disturb their friendship. 
 A letter to Hooton, describing an early November Sunday walk in uncongenial company, introduces the topic naturally and typically: 
 The only alleviating point in the walk was the number of pretty women and girls; so as I delight in looking at such, I very rudely looked into the eyes of those that passed. 
 And I never want really to go beyond looking at them&hellip;. 
 It always has been so with me, and will be. 
 Also, in my thought it is neither vulgar nor stupid. 
 &mdash; I get an extraordinary pleasure thus. 
 And let me explain what I meant by that silly passage in my last letter, about expensively dressed girls. 
 It was this. 
 My cousins are rather wealthy, and so wear rich dresses, which 
 I am never tired of hearing &mdash; oh, those sounding silks, so uncomfortable, so gorgeous. 
 Yet I like comfortable dresses, too: why not? 
 All I don't like is, rags, ill taste, ill-shapes&hellip;. 
 My feeling for girls has still the same nervous reverence of childhood or earliest boyhood, rather increased if anything, and only too excessive to be chivalrous. 
 In my childish days I remember I used to fear to touch the little girls' sleeves; so it is now. 
 If I retain any true innocence it is here. 
 Impulses of attraction towards beautiful forms or faces troubled him frequently for the next two years at Oxford. 
 He saw no inconsistency between such temporary infatuations and the matrimonial ideal he presented now to Hooton, as he had already discussed it with Helen: &bquo;I am not at all sure that there is anywhere a loftier, while there could be no sweeter, perfection than that of a household&equo;. 
 Helen, too, was frequently informed of his over-readiness to fall in love with an attractive outward appearance, even as he constantly restated his heavy dependence upon his engrossed love for her: 
 We men, we know not what loftiness we might reach if only for a few small hours we could by carefulness of life, morally and physically so exact ourselves that scarce any utmost purity of air were too perfect for us. 
 Perfect we cannot be, either by accident or ignorance (like your sweet ignorance, little one), or by strenuous effort; but we can be so near perfection that, from our present and ordinary level, that nearness would seem perfection itself. 
 Sweetheart you can almost do this. 
 You can. 
 Nevertheless do not tell me of it, even to confirm me; for it is what we cannot analyse or arrange, any more than the rich simplicity of childhood. 
 His letters to Helen range freely, without the stilted asides of his early long letters to Hooton. 
 They are a genuine substitute for the talk and shared companionship that was missing from his first year at Oxford. 
 For during this first term the long regular letters to Harry Hooton appear to be a substitute for letters to Helen and a roundabout way of informing her of his progress. 
 Mrs Noble, he said, thought him completely immoral and his own parents were chary of allowing Helen to visit him in his study bedroom at Shelgate Road as she used to do, although, he informed Harry, &bquo;Mother knows Helen so well and likes her so much.&equo; 
 One of Mr Thomas's conditions, supported by Mrs Noble, was that Edward and Helen should not correspond when he left for Oxford, and they agreed to this for the first term. 
 They made plans to meet in Harry's room sometimes dating the Christmas Vacation which Edward devoted to intense preparations for an entrance scholarship to Merton and continuous work at Latin and Mathematics for Responsions. 
 Besides he read Meredith, Hardy, Pater, Jefferies, some Flaubert (&bquo;for my French is fairly good&equo;), and began a more careful study of German. 
 When he and Helen could spend time alone, their passionate unconsummated loving convinced him that but for the &bquo;rich simplicity of childhood&equo; that characterized her, her &bquo;capacity for content&equo;, her &bquo;virginity of sentiment and soul&equo;, their love-making would be dangerous, &bquo;if my nature were more masculine and daring&equo;. 
 The consistency of her love still surprised him. 
 He was consumed with desire for the possession to come and whenever he could he tried to add to the 45&shilling; in the Post Office Savings Bank so that they could spend some time away together with Dad Uzzell. 
 She, he found, &bquo;though bold, how modest&hellip; just as when first I kissed at your sweet asking, little one, by the winter gorse&equo;. 
 &bquo;I seem to expect the whole happiness and sweetness to come from you&equo;, he wrote as he warned Helen that she should find a real need for patience with him. 
 Already, after a few months' acquaintance, he complained to Harry of &bquo;this hideous analysis which so masters me&equo; and he tried to express Helen's profound effect upon him: &bquo;I always wonder when I look at her or think of her. 
 I don't know why &mdash; or care. 
 But I always wonder, as if a film had been taken from my eyes and I saw new worlds.&equo; 
 As always in his letters (even to Helen) self-scrutiny creeps in &mdash; one aspect of the puritan streak he recognized in his own nature: 
 How vain I feel is an attempt for me with all my weight of immorality and worry and dull (not bad) health to sweeten you who are so pure and without care and of bright health. 
 Ignoble creature that I am! 
 Yes, sweetheart, I feel it in several ways; by contrast, for example, with my idyllic dreaming of two or three years ago; there is a change. 
 Not a change of nature, I hope, and believe: still, a development as the World calls it, though I can not think it is development for the better. 
 My youth flies from me, so. 
 No more can I find, if not content, yet a gorgeous enjoyment, in mere dreams, where men have no past. 
 As to dreams, day dreams, not only do they no longer impose upon me an innocent belief, but they become less glorious, less real, less natural, and less frequent. 
 This I perceive plainly. 
 And you? 
 It must be that you also perceive it. 
 Surely you see a difference between me, who wrote long, incoherent, and enthusiastic letters, enjoyed perfectly the songs of birds and the sight of a sundown, believed in the possibility of perfect happiness, perfect beauty, perfect purity, and a perfect world, all perfected, too, by that thing Nature which was so real to me; a difference between me then and thus, and what I am now, dull unenthusiastic, unimaginative, but more coherent and prudent, though still imprudent enough to write such things as that Sonnet, which even you esteem bad, I think&hellip;. 
 One other thought I will write&hellip; you are even now as you were, and ever must be, beautiful, pure and passionate. 
 I say this last, only because it is at the bottom of my mind, deep hid and permanent, not because it is least. 
 As the Lent term progressed, besides his letters to Helen and Harry (containing verses, some of which survive) and his quick recovery from his failure to gain an entrance scholarship to Merton, he had renewed an acquaintance with MacAlister &mdash; an old Pauline friend &mdash; who visited him each Sunday. 
 Although feeling hard-pressed by the prospect of Responsions (for four days) followed a week later by the Lincoln entrance examination, he became more confident of a future life as an Oxford student and eager to extend his male friendships and meet the challenge of competition from his equals and betters. 
 Between the two examinations he spent a few necessary days of recuperation at Swindon, spending some time with Dad Uzzell. 
 The letter quoted above was begun at Didcot Station, then continued at his Cowley Road digs, and rounded off at the end of the first day of the Scholarship exam after six hours of hard writing. 
 Were he to fail he would be ashamed to show his face at home &bquo;because all failure is probably due to my own indolence and lacking self-control to help myself out of day-dreaming.&equo; 
 After a request for stamps, he describes a few enjoyable, healthy hours out of doors walking with Dad from ten to three without a rest: We met a country girl, pale faced, delicate, tall, wrapped up to her neck in winter clothes &amp; feeling cold in spite of all; her eyes were timid &amp; weak; evidently she was suffering as girls do, &amp; was going out to get the fresh air. 
 She hardly dared answer the old man's &bquo;Good Morning&equo;; and as for me, I expect she was afraid of me. 
 I had such queer desires to speak to her, to give her my flowers, to kiss her hand, but did not of course, partly from cowardice, partly because she, however innocent, would probably be afraid; and the old man was there, too. 
 But how I longed to be gallant, as they say; to ask her if I might kiss her on both cheeks if I gave her my two violets. 
 Silly that I am! 
 But I am at least honest in this. 
 All simple &amp; partly lovely women attract me, &amp; not merely attract me, but I want to be something to them. 
 Not a dangerous disposition I think; though it might be if my nature were more masculine &amp; daring. 
 Why! 
 I should have been as timid as the girl herself, if she had looked at me! 
 You are not angry or jealous, are you? 
 I could excuse you if you were, too. 
 Tell me if you think it bad. 
 For you know I often wonder what sort of morality it is that keeps men from anything but superficial intercourse with any woman but their wives: yet I hate adultery &amp; all the intermediate stages; and what men of free habits in this way I have known, I have detested. 
 Suffice it, that I had a few moments of fanciful pleasure. 
 I ran back half a mile of road to get a glimpse of her in the distance, though we had passed her half an hour before, &amp; of course she was out of sight on the Downs. 
 She was not at all good-looking, or graceful, or winning, but a mere maiden; possibly not even a country girl, but a London servant at the great house of Burdcrop nearby. 
 His letters from Oxford in his third term, after gaining the Lincoln History Exhibition, are much shorter, less introspective, and full of details about his writing, his plans for the future, his increased reading but, above all, his growing friendship with MacAlister who felt that &bquo;his intimate outpouring to me was something of a comfort to him&equo;. 
 They talked endlessly at MacAlister's rooms in Merton, where Thomas could also measure himself against two further acquaintances, Fyffe and Wharton. 
 At last he began to sense that when he entered Lincoln he would keep his end up in spite of the sketchy nature of his post &mdash; Pauline preparation for the Oxford Final History Honours School. 
 MacAlister summed up his special quality: &bquo;While I knew more in my narrowly specialised subjects, he was far above me intellectually and in general maturity of mind.&equo; 
 It was a quality often recalled by Oxford contemporaries. 
 &bquo;Three of us were elected to Exhibitions at the same time, and I recall the maturity of his literary powers as contrasted with the callow essays we had to take up to Owen M. Edwards each week.&equo; 
 (Norman G. Brett James, later Bursar at Lincoln.) 
 MacAlister proved an ideal walking companion on the weekends as they explored Bagley Wood, Godstow Nunnery, the elmy hills of Cumnor and Radbrook, the churchyard at Hinksey with its elms against the sunset. 
 Everywhere, Thomas later recalled, &bquo;a suspected presence of a hidden melodist, as a conversation &bquo;would grow and blossom between Headington and Wheatley or Osney and Eaton.&equo; 
 His briefer letters to Harry Hooton &mdash; avoiding those &bquo;terrible letters I used to throw at you last term as it might be from the fruitless monotony of this place&equo; &mdash; now explain his reading. 
 As yet he had not succumbed completely to the seductive prose of Pater and was reading the &bquo;artificial but interesting Marius &equo; side by side with Scott, Meredith, Hardy's Jude , and Flaubert's letters. 
 He was attracted to the latter's extravagant precepts on style, in contrast to Pater: &bquo;What a small man Pater is. 
 He is always talking  about style: he has yet words of the absurdest that occur in every page, bland, delicate, dainty; one blushes to read them.&equo; 
 Thomas could now look back on the papers he had begun, or completed and sold in his first two terms, as &bquo;vain stuff&equo; but he continued to write verses, which were sent to Harry and Helen. 
 He detected a slackening off in his examination work, once he had gained his Exhibition &mdash; &bquo;a moral weakness, neglect of order in my work and play&equo;; often these &bquo;moods&equo; sent him back to his digs almost beside himself. 
 The only cure for the &bquo;silliness of his brain&equo; was to return to reading, or to write an article. 
 He read Johnson's Dictionary because he felt (from Flaubert) that he needed &bquo;a scientific and accurate vocabulary&equo; and, when further stimulated by Marius , he asked Helen to read his recent papers aloud to discover if the &bquo;sounds jar&equo;. 
 To her he confessed that he hoped residence at Lincoln would banish his &bquo;moods&equo; and in the same letter he reflected on his own mother's &bquo;love and uncertainty, in her melancholy unconfident way&equo;. 
 Above all, despite frequent irritation with Helen over trivial expenses and her unbusinesslike attitude to her wages, he relied heavily on her temper, &bquo;her genius for joy&equo;, to help him break free of these moods. 
 He is &bquo;loyal only to Nature in a vague way&equo;; he reads obscene books and then worries at frequent seminal emissions. 
 &bquo;My nature is fickle &mdash; a little insane &mdash; and entirely barren in soul, and in these &bquo;moods of distrust&equo; he needs her love. 
 &bquo;How utterly you love life. 
 Nothing lies hidden in you.&equo; 
 As the term draws to an end, his desire for her dominates his letters. 
 He faces their need to use contraceptive devices, but is ignorant of the facts. 
 (&bquo;This century, thinks too much, certainly talks too much, of love. 
 Human beings need many things as well as love, if not more. ') 
 When Edward invited Harry to Oxford for Eights Week he informed him of his expectations from Lincoln College. 
 In such moments of confession he frequently strikes a prophetic note about his future life as a writer. 
 There is no hint that he would ever abandon his decision to earn his living as a writer. 
 On this he was adamant and unswerving, however much his father might extol the supreme chance at Oxford to make contacts for a future career, as yet undefined. 
 Edward's first year at Oxford, with its long hours of set daily lectures and prepared reading, its loneliness punctuated by long walks, longer letters, and occasional forays in search of new friendships, formed a gentle transition from the two years of freedom he had enjoyed, since leaving St. Paul's, towards the severer demands that family and social demands were to make upon him. 
 Here were the seeds of inner conflict that were never completely resolved and here, too, especially in his next five terms of collegiate life, Oxford offered him opportunities of escape from the worries of ordinary living. 
 His letters to Helen, in particular, uncover the head for business, the punctilious sense of irritable rightness, and the concomitant sudden bouts of self-distrust that marched alongside his desire for an extended life of idealized perfection, similar to the intense moments of joyful peace he had discovered for himself during walks. 
 He finds his own words for the mood in a letter to Helen on 6 May '98: &bquo;I am glad my unkind letter allowed you nevertheless to write me so sweet a reply, and besides, to be so sweet tempered, and, as I hope, unhurt save for a moment. 
 It was of course not anger. 
 Did I use the word? 
 It was irritation, doubtless the result of some ill doing or extravagance on my own part, making me hate to see its image elsewhere. 
 Yet, as I said, you are not extravagant, I am. 
 That is enough.&equo; 
 The unkind letter he refers to gives an informed introduction to their subsequent life together and is here given in full with its immediate predecessor. 
 Together they form the best picture of their love as Edward described it to Harry before his life at Lincoln began: &bquo;For some reason or another we are happier now than ever before. 
 It is a happiness so mild and cool that it is like a kind of saintliness after passion: yet it is not satiety&hellip; for if she has any unhealth, it is from me; and that more of her lips than in her heart.&equo; 
 113 Cowley Road. 
 2. v. '98. 
 The little blue flower, &bquo;robin-run-in-the-hedge&equo;, which probably looked like violet on the first, distant glance, is ground ivy . 
 My dearest friend, And did you have a happy May day? 
 With all the flowers- and the birds- and the presence of the Sea, the purity &amp; brightness of your own heart could surely take a day nearly perfect. 
 I only hope it did not rain, as, for most of the daylight, it did here. 
 Night at any rate you had fine, as we had, with a high clear moon &amp; just a few stars lost here &amp; there among folds of cloud. 
 So I am desiring, though not more than half expecting, a letter tomorrow morning to hear how you spend your day, &amp;, because you were certainly happy, in what ways you directed your happiness. 
 A thousand pities that the child who was probably with you is not something nearer perfection! 
 And I reflect that if you remember to post early, the letter will come here by the first post! 
 I spent a crowded lonely day. 
 It was so funny &mdash; as I walked along, rather disconsolate in the rain, at midday, I suddenly recollected it was Mayday, &amp; knowing I ought to be bright &amp; rejoicing I forthwith was so, at least for a time. 
 You with a mind full only of natural &amp; unembarrassing thoughts, &amp; of me, probably awoke early and remembered &amp; rejoiced; perhaps you had even prepared for it, &amp; went happy walks, singing, garlanded. 
 I am almost glad I was not there, lest I should have spoiled your tranquillity. 
 It would have been a richer joy &mdash; but, indeed, as I so often tell you, I delight to picture you in a childlike serenity. 
 I hope it was yours. 
 With all the crowding work, and a little pleasure, too, I would have written to you yesterday, only I partly feared to, because I had a proposal to make, which it would have been unseemly to make the apparent cause of my haste. 
 It was this &mdash; you have now, or should have, at least a sovereign left out of your monthly pay &amp; what survived of the 15&shilling; from the Bank; so is it not best to send it all to me at once? 
 Your expenses, beyond stamps, which I can provide for you, will be nothing, I suppose, at Sandgate &mdash; no railway fares, &amp;c &amp;c. 
 If this seems well-&amp; why not? &mdash; pray send at one;. 
 Only, by the way, I see a large number of Scotts here, uniform with yours &amp; mine, at only 1&shilling; each, yet quite clean &amp; good, &amp; not incomplete like those in bookseller's row; of which, would you care for me to buy one or two &mdash; Ivanhoe, Nigel &amp;c? 
 I wish I could buy them myself, &amp; had hoped to; but the Speaker  rejection makes it impracticable. 
 By the way I shall send another paper to Perris at the end of the week. 
 Shall I send this old friend (or enemy)? 
 You see it is much altered, filed and shaped. 
 Please return it at once, or when sending the postal order. 
 As to the one I sent in before, it was written so quickly, that it could not be good. 
 Perhaps I shall never rewrite it. 
 It is all  obscure, &amp; not  purposely either. 
 By the way also, I have begun the Tristran &amp; Isould story, today, after much hesitation, with a snatch of talk between Kheydius &amp; Palomides. 
 I hope I shall be able to compress it sufficiently. 
 You do seem to be fortunate in going to Sandgate. 
 What a place it is! 
 Here I see few flowers, save such as water bubbles, though the fields &amp; country generally are the richest I have ever seen. 
 I fancy you like a queen &mdash; a princess rather &mdash; in all those flowers. 
 Would that I were fit to woo you as what you seem &amp; are, sweet heart! 
 Now goodbye! do I not seem happy, or at least sordidly content? 
 Never mind! 
 You will kiss me, or I will kiss you. 
 Sweet little one, I hope you are beautiful now. 
 Goodbye. 
 In life I am your truest fondest friend Edward, and you ever my own sweet little one Helen, anemone maiden. 
 Goodbye, sweet heart. 
 Does this reach you as you come down from bed? 
 I hope you are well &amp; looking forward to the sunshine. 
 Goodbye. 
 4. v. '98 
 I have no stamps at all, nor money, here. 
 If you could send one soon, I should be glad. 
 It was very mean of me, I know, after the sweet beginning of your letter &amp; the pleasure I had from it, to be very angry at the end. 
 Not only mean; perhaps it was utterly baseless. 
 But unless you spent a lot on flowers and balls for the children and on Mary's birthday present, considering that you had our 15&shilling; and some 5&shilling; or more  yes more of your own a month ago, on which no calls but fares need have been made, to which was added about 30&shilling; (or more?) lately, and from it all not 30&shilling; was spent on the dress, you should have a sovereign left: add to this the wages of this month to come, and there should remain, after 35&shilling; to the spectacle man, fully a sovereign, which, considering our needs for the future &amp; also your promises, nay, certainties, at which I laughed, should go to the bank. 
 A pretty sentence indeed! but my feathery head is blazing with the stupidity of all this together with my own unamiability and ungentleness of behaviour. 
 I can not help it. 
 I am certain of my facts &amp; calculations; so there are but two alternatives: either you have spent, not extravagantly, since you are not extravagant, but sillily &amp; thoughtlessly, which really is far worse. 
 What your present needs are, is another thing, but surely 10&shilling; should cover them. 
 I won't write a word more now, but go to my work, cool down, go out, and in the evening post this letter with proofs of my regret, though not recantation, and also proofs of some joy or success I may have this afternoon in fields now rejoicing in sunshine after rain, &mdash; to delight my own sweet little one, too tolerant, too childishly submissive, not by nature, which would be weak , but by love for me, which is strength . 
 Goodbye, little one. 
 I hope you are only passingly depressed by my letter &amp; that what I can write later on will erect your spirits. 
 In fact I wrote a song yesterday &amp; if you are good you shall have it, supposing you care. 
 Believe me, to conclude, tho' I have no business head, for large &amp; lengthy affairs, I am keen enough in figures &amp; small matters, &amp; always was; so that I can not be disputed. 
 If you think me wrong, it simply means you have, as I used to say, let money &bquo;slip through your hands&equo;: and remember we cannot afford to despise money. 
 As you do, very beautifully &amp; genuinely, I know &amp; delight to reflect. 
 Later  I did manage to get out, immediately after dinner, &amp; fortunately, for now I am back, it rains hard, as it has done every day now for a week. 
 Yet it is very beautiful rain, at least in the country, clear, sweet, musical, with a bright sky usually overhead, &amp; oftentimes a rainbow. 
 I think I am in a kinder mood now, and my only worry is that  dulness  and thickness of brain which I think I have often mentioned before. 
 I fancy it comes from over reading, so I do as little as I can. 
 My relief is a pipe &mdash; really it is a relief. 
 just now, for instance, I could not sit &amp; do nothing, since that only irritates my brain; &amp; it was then only my pipe that enabled me comfortably to read Rousseau's &bquo;Julie; or the New Heloise&equo;. 
 That is a book you must often have heard of &mdash; a series of letters between two lovers; Julie and Saint-Preux. 
 They are very pretty, but somewhat ludicrously sentimental; that is, when one reflects that it was Rousseau that wrote them. 
 I suppose you know the old story &mdash; French of the 12th century &mdash; about Heloise and Abelard and their strange love? 
 By the way, after writing to you on Sunday, the mood came, and I wrote the story of Kheydius, 12 close pages, straight off, almost satisfactorily, too. 
 It will take me a long time to correct &amp; copy, though: when I have done so, of course you shall have it. 
 I am pleased with what you say of &bquo;The Time after Anemone&equo;. 
 You prove to me that it gives just the very impression I desired. 
 As to the song I talked of &mdash; Here it is. 
 If you can see my meaning, it is well. 
 The thing has little music &amp; little choiceness of words, but I fancied at the time it was genuine enough. 
 I can not ask you to judge . 
 But is it better than the verses beginning &bquo;Cottage on the Wye&equo;? 
 (1) Weary of April's 
 over-sweet-Anemone &amp; 
 Marigold &mdash; I turned my feet 
 To her the meek and bold. 
 (2) &bquo;Let me but speak to thee, or thou 
 To me, unhastily, of naught: 
 Of love not now,&equo; 
 I moaned with heart distraught. 
 (3) Wistfully smiling, then, she stept 
 To lift me with love's best, though 
 Looked not, but wept 
 And cared not to reply. 
 (4) Repose restored, oh! cruel 
 bliss &mdash; To her sweet toil she rose and 
 wove &mdash; Ah! bitter 'tis ( or ) And would not kiss.) 
 We cannot always love. 
 One merit it has &mdash; each verse is exactly the same in metre &amp; accent. 
 But here I am talking blissfully about myself in the old fashion! 
 And can you pardon me for coming to such a conclusion as that in the last line of my verses? 
 I think it is very true. 
 Now I think I must run away. 
 I will post this at once so that you will have it by tomorrow's first post. 
 I hope it will not prove an utterly hateful letter. 
 Goodbye, sweetheart. 
 The sun shines without rain once more. 
 Will you kiss me, or will you be unkind just a little while? 
 Tell me. 
 In life I am your truest friend Edward, and you ever my own sweet little one Helen, my anemone maid, and dearest friend. 
 Sweet heart, goodbye&equo;. 
 Edward approached his third attempt to pass Responsions in a confident and relaxed mood. 
 As he &bquo;crammed&equo; his Latin and algebra, he read Don Quixote  and Boccaccvo and set aside time to read twenty pages of Goethe and twenty pages of Malory daily. 
 But a week before the examination he became restless and peevish. 
 He told Helen he must have gone off his head: he had written three lots of verses in one week (including the one on Old Margaret and Headington Hill printed in Collected Poems , p. 458). 
 His confidence was justified and in mid June he is home at 61 Shelgate Road and their correspondence becomes a thin trickle of notes and letter-cards as they make arrangements to meet when Helen was free from her work. 
 Although he had passed Responsions and had few debts at Oxford except for books, his father was already apprehensive about the cost of an Oxford education, with Ernest in his final year of training to be an art-teacher and Reggie with a consuming passion for Shakespeare and the stage, and no other interest. 
 Dory had already begun his motor-engineering apprenticeship, but Oscar and the young Julian, like Reggie, had still to be provided for. 
 Mr Thomas, as so often before, turned to his relatives for help. 
 Edward and Reggie were to spend six weeks or so with his cousins in Pontardulais, while Ernest and Oscar stayed with relations in Cwmavon. 
 There were plans for the younger children to join Watcyn Wyn's private academy (for ministerial candidates and others) at Ammanford where the Welsh preacher-bard Gwili (the Revd John Jenkins, later Principal of the Baptist Theological College at Banger and Archdruid of the Gorsedd of the Welsh National Eisteddfod) was a tutor. 
 He and Edward became close friends with a shared interest in poetry, nature-study, fishing, and the classics. 
 Edward was glad to escape from Shelgate Road: his father seemed to undermine his self-confidence and made him out to be &bquo;several kinds of fool&equo;. 
 At the home of his paternal uncle he was very much at home. 
 His aunt had little or no English and Edward the merest smattering of a few isolated Welsh phrases. 
 She hoped he would study regularly in the small front parlour &mdash; &bquo;the best room&equo; &mdash; but he preferred the roomy kitchen with its large table, coal-fired oven, and brass furnishing around the hearth and the hobs and the mantlepiece. 
 This was the hub of her universe and here the family assembled after a day's work, in the coal-mine or (like Edward's beautiful elder female cousin) the local tinworks. 
 Supper was the banquet time for married children and their families. 
 In the mornings he worked in the kitchen while his aunt baked or cooked or sewed; here in the evenings he absorbed the sense of the impact of new industries on an older more settled way of life which, much later, found its way into the stories and sketches of his best Welsh work, Rest and Unrest  and Light and Twilight . 
 Increasingly during the next fifteen years the triangle formed by Swansea, Pontardulais, and Ammanford &mdash; with the fr owning eminence of Carreg Cennen Castle in the distance &mdash; provided him with a retreat and a source of healing as he faltered towards his final realization as a poet. 
 Apart from their long walks and interminable conversations and evening singsong, or their expeditions to ancient monuments, he and Gwili and his cousins assisted with the harvest, binding sheaves and even mowing bracken with a scythe. 
 Assured by Helen that their new way of making love brought no ill effects for her (&bquo;Happy and bountiful Helen&equo;) he wishes her to understand his satisfaction away from her: &bquo;You would laugh to know what my amusements are! &mdash; mere jests of the slightest character; rough simple ways; and very little thought. 
 It is certainly good for me physically, though I am a little dubious about its ultimate good. 
 They are too lenient: that makes it flattering. 
 Believe me, these scrappy notes do not represent my feeling which is deep, continuous, and steady.&equo; 
 He seemed to live his life throughout the summer on two levels: with Gwili and in his own writing and deeper probes into Pater's works he was moving towards the standpoint of his article &bquo;The Frontiers of English Prose&equo; (in Literature , September 1899), that a &bquo;most noticeable fact is the apparent destruction of the boundaries between poetry and prose, and between verse and prose&hellip;. 
 Poetry had been too long and too harshly divided from prose.&equo; 
 As far as I can discover, except for the rough translation of a poem by Watcyn Wyn in his Wales  (1905), there is no further mention of verse of any kind in Edward Thomas's letters after this Long Vacation. 
 This absorption into a different community, quite other than anything he had experienced since childhood, into which he had the natural right of entry accorded by his Welsh cousins because of the tie of blood, required a few more Long Vacation visits before he could articulate its meaning for his own mature intellectual development. 
 Gwili tried to interpret for him the power of Welsh literature and especially the &bquo;renaissance&equo; of modern Welsh poetry of which he was himself a part, but Edward had only a smattering of Welsh and, judging from rough translations of folksongs and simple lyrics, he was disinclined to carry his studies further. 
 In September he recorded a very detached impression of his stay: &bquo;The Welsh see so clearly, so abundantly, filling every space of air with a lovely form in firm white. 
 Why don't they carve like Greeks? 
 Instead, their poetry, prose and verse is full of pictures., He proved much more responsive to Welsh songs and music and, as Gwili's elder sister sang for him and showed a strong interest in him, he assures Helen that he is &bquo;a very harmless fool&equo; and that his known views on promiscuity and marriage have not changed. 
 Although he had kept up his reading &mdash; particularly in Greek and French &mdash; and written some stories for the Speaker , he believed his intellect had been let sleep. 
 If he was ever to be an artist, he should strive for more balance. 
 &bquo;I wish my sight were not so powerful and so cunning&hellip;. 
 Time always mellows my impressions, if they are not at all strong.&equo; 
 Early in September the four Thomas brothers were told to make ready for the journey home, where Ernest had to re-sit for his Teacher's Certificate, and Edward was left with scarcely a month to reassure Helen of his faithfulness and to make his final preparations before beginning his historical studies with Owen M. Edwards. 
 He approached his first term at Lincoln College &bquo;fairly well &amp; in exceedingly good temper&hellip; 
 Human beings have never touched me so nearly as now when &bquo;Nature&equo; was so close: I think, too, I never before struck such firm roots into human hearts&equo;. 
 His Welsh cousins and their friends flattered and cosseted him; he was treated as a gentleman-scholar, sharing much of the natural respect of late nineteenth-century Wales for the scholar-preacher-bard, of which his new friend, Gwili, the theologian-bard, was an excellent example. 
 Edward knew he was being pampered and, in his letters to Helen about his friendship with Gwili's sister, he confessed that &bquo;in fact it was partly you that I saw when I held her: I hope I shall never forget her; then I shall feel that it is possible to love another even though I am all and ever yours, little one. 
 But I won't reason on it.&equo; 
 After his return to London from Pontardulais, Edward and Helen were finding it more difficult than ever to contain their desire for complete sexual union. 
 Before he had gone to Wales, her employers had allowed him to visit Helen in her own room. 
 She was already twenty-one and their self-imposed tests of constraint were severely strained. 
 After their first post-Wales reunion, on the evening of 19 September '98, he wrote to her fearfully about the results of their intimacy: 
 Dearest friend &mdash; Let me know soon if you are quite well, and tell me just how you are feeling. 
 For I think you cannot help pondering on our meeting last night. 
 And quite rightly. 
 You, poor little one, were the victim of a pure overwhelming desire, and I of a smaller desire by no means pure; and I feel much more abject than if that desire had been satisfied. 
 I was trying to think in the correct way about right and wrong as I travelled home last night. 
 Of course all kinds of schemes came &mdash; we would read stiffly together etc. 
 Somehow I feel as if it were purer &mdash; certainly it would be honester- &bquo;to do the thing we fear&equo;. 
 But nothing of course would induce me to make a miserable thing out of you and a fool of myself. 
 Could we not find out some means? 
 You understand. 
 He confesses he hasn't the face to make enquiries about methods and means of contraception, even in the most indirect way. 
 Nothing came of his enquiries and the first ten days of October passed uneventfully with his praise of Helen's &bquo;lovely portion of that maidenliness which you shall never lose&equo;. 
 He settled down again to work (&bquo;lessons and literature&equo;), with some hours spent at Wimbledon with Arthur Hardy &bquo;in the warmth and strange visible light of the late afternoon&equo;, and enjoyed the kindness around Which I never felt so much as of late, when it looked as if I was soon to cast it away with such apparent rudeness&equo;. 
 He was well received by Mrs Noble and her daughter Mary, and he planned to visit Mr Tarrant, the Unitarian minister, before spending the evening with Harry Hooton. 
 He assured Helen, &bquo;I did not know I loved you so tenderly until this trial, sweetheart&equo;. 
 Before he left for Lincoln College on 14 October '98, Helen was peremptorily given a week's notice by Mrs Andrews who had secretly been reading Edward's letters and now accused Helen of &bquo;illicit connexion&equo; with him. 
 Helen cheerfully returned home, but apprehensive about the effect of this &bquo;ghastly suspicion&equo; on her hysterical mother. 
 Edward sent to Mrs Andrews &bquo;a short note, fulfilling the two duties, of thanks for her past undoubted kindness, and of a request for a &bquo;character&equo; (virtually) when you leave. 
 The note is formal and discreet, I think. 
 As far as I see, all is well: you at any rate are serene&hellip;. 
 Until we meet, I remain silent &mdash; just a little excited, but still secure on what I know .&equo; 
 Helen worked out her last week's notice in utter loneliness with the sympathetic support of Janet and Harry Hooton and the staunch championship of Mrs Beatrice Logan who had offered Helen employment with her. 
 Edward, now in Oxford, felt obliged to write home to his mother with full details of the affair and for the next fortnight pondered the steps he should take. 
 &bquo;Is it any good to write to a Solicitor?&equo; he asked Hooton. 
 &bquo;As for me, I can only shrink and plan a slinking away out of sight, since I love life too much to die.&equo; 
 Soon this mood of despair evaporated under the influence of serene letters from Helen, who flourished among the intimate circle of artistic Bohemian young people &mdash; including the poet Charles Dalmon and the actor Franklin Dyall &mdash; who lived in Hammersmith and spent a great deal of time at Mrs Logan's large house which had been furnished and decorated in William Morris style. 
 Looking back later, Helen recalled three things about this new life, so different from the unhappy days when she and Edward discovered that his passionate letters to her were being read by Mrs Andrews: &bquo;The beauty of it delighted me, and I thought it the perfect setting for these people with their freedom of manner and thought&hellip;. 
 I look back upon this household as having been &mdash; after &lsqb;Edward&rsqb; &mdash; the strongest influence in my life. 
 &lsqb;He&rsqb; used to make fun of their serious cults of puritry and freedom and nakedness&hellip;. 
 They regarded no convention, and I did not see till later that their unconvention was almost as intolerant as my parents, convention., Helen stayed with Mrs Logan &mdash; who was awaiting a divorce &mdash; dating Edward's first year at Lincoln. 
 She was now a companion and friend rather than a nursemaid and domestic servant; she prepared herself to run her own household and developed her skills as a needlewoman. 
 Most of all she found there strong support for the mutually independent role of husband and wife that she and Edward had developed over two years of frustration and parental disapproval. 
 Her love for Edward was constant and rocklike: she matured during these months, but she did not change. 
 Like Edward she knew the &bquo;reason why we don't marry is not our immaturity but impecuniousness&equo;.  
 Thomas Hobbes (1588&ndash;1679) 
 Thomas Hobbes was born near Malmesbury in 1588, the son of the local vicar and his wife. 
 The education he received culminated at Oxford and, like others both before and after, he was later to complain of the diet of scholasticism he was fed there. 
 His time was often spent, he said, looking at maps in the local bookshops, following voyages of exploration such as those of Francis Drake. 
 After Oxford he was recommended as tutor to the son of William Cavendish, First Earl of Devonshire. 
 This was Hobbes's eventual making. 
 It resulted in employment and patronage for life. 
 It introduced him to enlightened learning and a sophisticated life of foreign travel, and enabled him to move in the scientific circles centred round Sir Charles Cavendish. 
 It also led to his enjoying a considerable reputation on the Continent, where he became acquainted with leading intellectuals such as Marin Mersenne, Pierre Gassendi, and Rene Descartes. 
 His association with the Devonshires put him a little in public life, but for the main his world was, unlike Bacon's, largely an intellectual one. 
 This is not to say it was quiet, for Hobbes published controversial Objections  to Descartes's Meditations  (1641), and was involved in acrimonious arguments with leading mathematicians about his attempts to square the circle. 
 He also engaged in open controversy with John Bramhall, Bishop of Derry, about liberty and necessity. 
 Against the complex political events of the Civil War (1642&ndash;51), Commonwealth, and Restoration (1660), his political and religious views, or their supposed implications, became notorious and were often vilified. 
 His life of study and writing lasted until his death, in 1679 at the age of 91. 
 Hobbes wrote sometimes in Latin, sometimes in English. 
 By his middle years he had published little, and the ideas for which he is remembered did not begin to develop until then. 
 He is most famous for his political philosophy, which is embodied in his Elements of Law , completed by 1640 though not published until 1650; in his De Cive  (&bquo;On the Citizen&equo;) of 1642; and, in particular, in his Leviathan  (1651), a classic and perenially studied account of man's move from a primitive state of nature, in which life is &bquo;solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short&equo;, into an organized society, with absolute power vested in the hands of a supreme authority. 
 But Leviathan  contains more than this, for political philosophy is just one part of an ambitious and systematic three-part account of the Elements of Philosophy . 
 This deals with physics (with &bquo;bodies natural&equo;), with moral philosophy (with the &bquo;dispositions and manners of men&equo;), and, finally, with political philosophy (with the &bquo;civil duties of subjects&equo;). 
 The later parts of this grand scheme are logically dependent on the earlier so that, via his moral philosophy, Hobbes's political philosophy is ultimately dependent on his physics. 
 But a concern with the political unrest preceding the Civil War caused the third part, De Cive , to be prematurely &bquo;ripened and plucked&equo; before the first two, De Corpore  (&bquo;On Body&equo;, 1655) and De Homine  (&bquo;On Man&equo;, 1657). 
 The way in which the three parts of Hobbes's system are meant to hang together and the methodology by which they are worked out in detail is, of course, most fully explained in its first part, De Corpore . 
 Hobbes complains of the lack of philosophical progress his predecessors have made. 
 Like farming, at a time when vines and corn grew haphazardly here and there but were not cultivated, philosophy has never been properly and methodically developed. 
 He recognized that some attempts had been made to cultivate the seeds of Natural Reason into something worthwhile. 
 But, with some few exceptions, the main results had been disputatious wrangling. 
 The natural philosophy of the ancient Greeks &bquo;was rather a dream than science&equo;. 
 Indeed, Hobbes says, &bquo;I believe that scarce anything can be more absurdly said in natural philosophy, than Aristotle's Metaphysics .&equo; 
 People are sensible to ignore these fruitless attempts at philosophy and &bquo;content themselves with daily experience&equo; and common sense, even if this is merely &bquo;feeding upon acorns&equo;. 
 In the hope of rectifying this unsatisfactory state of affairs, Hobbes aimed to lay bare &bquo;elements&equo; or seeds from which &bquo;pure and true&equo; philosophy might grow, if carefully cultivated by a method which he will describe. 
 &bquo;Most men wander out of the way, and fall into error for want of method, as it were for want of sowing and planting, that is, of improving the reason.&equo; 
 Given a method, we can avoid mistaken ideas which, confirmed by the authority of the past, have taken deep root, like weeds in men's minds. 
 Hobbes's references to previous lack of philosophical progress and the disputatious wrangling of the prevailing scholastic philosophy, and his distaste for ideas based solely on the foundation of authority, are all reminiscent of Bacon. 
 So, too, is his stress on the importance of finding, and following, a methodical route to knowledge. 
 But Bacon and Hobbes were not alone in these ideas. 
 It was shortly after his time at Oxford, on his first journey to the Continent, that Hobbes found that others were dissatisfied with scholasticism; and we have already noted that an interest in method was characteristic of the seventeenth century. 
 So these ideas in Hobbes are an expression of a prevailing wave of thought, a wave which moves on through Gassendi and Locke. 
 Despite the aridities of scholastic philosophy, Hobbes did think that, over the centuries, the seeds of natural reason had borne some fruit. 
 Three notable instances were the geometry of Euclid, the work done on the motion of falling bodies by Galileo, and the discovery of the circulation of the blood by William Harvey. 
 Hobbes's discovery of geometry and his growing sense of the importance of motion in understanding the world were milestones in his intellectual development. 
 Were it not for these he would not have produced any of the philosophy for which he is now remembered. 
 Geometry and motion, both separately and intertwined, are a pervasive presence in his Elements of Philosophy . 
 In 1629 Hobbes returned to the Continent on a second tour, as tutor to the son of Sir Gervase Clinton. 
 There, in Geneva, in a gentleman's library, he came across a copy of the Elements of Geometry , in which Euclid methodically organizes and systematically lays out a large amount of geometrical knowledge. 
 The book was open at Pythagoras' discovery about the relative lengths of the sides of a right-angled triangle, and Hobbes was amazed by Euclid's proof of this complex idea. 
 He was stunned by the rigour, clarity, and persuasiveness of the reasoning by which Euclid got this interesting theorem from a small initial collection of obvious axioms, elementary postulates, and clear definitions. 
 From that moment Hobbes was, Aubrey tells us, &bquo;in love with geometry&equo;. 
 The idea that knowledge could be firmly established and disputes resolved if we began from clear beginnings always remained with Hobbes. 
 The rational procedures of Euclid's Elements of Geometry  inspired his own Elements of Philosophy . 
 But, though it was Euclid's method that first inspired him, the subject-matter of geometry also caught his interest and was something he worked on throughout his life. 
 One result he claimed was a proof that the circle could be squared. 
 Given his initial thought that properly established geometrical results would not be disputable, it is ironical that this claim led to lengthy and acrimonious argument, and brought Hobbes into some disrepute. 
 Finally, besides working on geometry and being influenced by its methods, Hobbes gives it, as the science of simple motions, a foundational role in the explanatory system of his Elements . 
 Not only Euclid, but Galileo too, had grown something worthwhile from the seeds of natural reason. 
 In his attempts to understand the paths taken by projectiles and falling bodies, he had &bquo;opened to us the gate of natural philosophy universal, which is the knowledge of the nature of motion &equo;. 
 Hobbes met Galileo, then an old man, in Florence in 1636, on a third visit to the Continent. 
 But his fascination with motion, the &bquo;gate of natural philosophy&equo;, had probably been with him from the beginning of that decade. 
 It seems to have begun somewhat unexpectedly, when he was involved in a discussion which led to the question &bquo;What is sense?&equo; 
 It occurred to Hobbes that since knowledge, whether systematically developed or not, begins with sense-perception, we should not pride ourselves on knowing much if we do not understand what sense-perception actually is. 
 In thinking about this he &bquo;luckily&equo; (as he says) hit upon the idea that matter in motion is the key. 
 His idea was not, simply, that matter in motion causes sense-perception, but that our sensory ideas just are  motions in matter. 
 This led him to think that everything, in one way or another, could be matter in motion. 
 From then on, the idea of motion was always to the forefront of his mind and central to his philosophy. 
 Hobbes's two obsessions, geometry and motion, first came together in the early 1630s in a Short Tract on First Principles . 
 This deals with motion and sense-perception, and is laid out, after the manner of Euclid, as a series of formal demonstrations. 
 But they became even more closely connected when Hobbes began to think of geometrical figures in terms of the motions which would generate or produce them. 
 Geometry itself was seen as the science of &bquo;simple motions&equo;. 
 Against the background of an Ockhamite distinction between faith, or &bquo;inspired divinity&equo;, and philosophical knowledge, Bacon had divided &bquo;Philosophy&equo; into Natural Divinity, Knowledge of Man, and Natural Philosophy or Knowledge of Nature. 
 Though not as obsessive as Bacon, Hobbes shares not only an interest in the classifications of areas of study, but also something of the actual divisions. 
 He distinguishes &bquo;faith&equo; from knowledge proper which, as &bquo;Philosophy&equo;, is divided into &bquo;Natural Philosophy (or &bquo;physics&equo;) and &bquo;Civil Philosophy&equo; (that which is concerned with man). 
 In its turn, &bquo;Civil Philosophy&equo; is divided into &bquo;Ethics&equo; and &bquo;Political Philosophy&equo;. 
 Hobbes's systematic conception of politics as dependent on ethics and then, via ethics, on physics, means that his natural philosophy must be looked at first and in most detail. 
 But it is important to remember that not only &bquo;natural&equo; but also &bquo;civil&equo; philosophy comes under Hobbes's general definition of philosophy. 
 Both of them are &bquo;such knowledge of effects or appearances, as we acquire by true ratiocination from the knowledge we have first of their causes or generations: And again, of such causes or generations as may be from knowing first their effects.&equo; 
 Taken broadly, this view of philosophical knowledge as having to do with &bquo;causes&equo; shows Hobbes to be under the same Aristotelian influences as Bacon. 
 There are, indeed, some similarities between them, but there are also differences. 
 By &bquo;effects&equo; or &bquo;appearances&equo;, Hobbes means the ordinary observable qualities and properties of things or phenomena, or those things and phenomena themselves. 
 So his &bquo;effects&equo; or &bquo;appearances&equo; are tantamount to Bacon's &bquo;natures&equo;. 
 But when he speaks of &bquo;causes&equo; he means, he says, either &bquo;efficient causes&equo; (which produce, or bring effects and appearances about) or, in the case of what he calls &bquo;entire causes&equo; (the combination  of causes and  their effects), a combination of efficient and material causes. 
 Officially he does not share Bacon's acceptance of formal causes, and even his agreement with him about the relevance to human actions of the final causes of Aristotelian tradition is qualified by the thought that, in the end, they are reducible to efficient causes. 
 The stress on efficient or productive causes means that, though Bacon's natural philosophy includes Divinity, Hobbes's excludes the theological study of a God that is eternal and ingenerate. 
 Causation for Hobbes is, of course, essentially a matter of motion, and his example concerning the circle gives a good initial insight into this. 
 It also illustrates the associated idea, that philosophy is either a knowledge of effects acquired from knowledge of generative causes, or a knowledge of causes acquired from knowledge of generated effects; and it also brings geometry into relation with motion, for it describes geometrical figures in terms of the generative motions which cause them. 
 A circle is a shape on which all points are equidistant from some point lying inside. 
 This means we can work out how a given circle might have been produced or drawn: perhaps it was traced by the movement of one end of a rigid rod whose other end was fixed, perhaps by a weight whirled round on string. 
 When we reason in this way, from the properties of the figure to possible methods of its construction, we are reasoning from effects or appearances, to their efficient causes or generating motions. 
 But suppose we have a figure which, though it looks perfectly round, may in fact be slightly flattened on two sides, and in reality be an ellipse. 
 If we knew how it was produced, for example not by moving a pencil round on one end of a taut thread, but along one fixed at both ends, we could conclude that it really is an ellipse and not a circle. 
 Reasoning in this way, we acquire knowledge of an effect or appearance from knowledge of its generative cause. 
 It is interesting to note that this example shows that what underlies Hobbes's rejection of formal causes is, perhaps, no more than an impatience with what the Aristotelians  said about them, and a desire to disassociate himself from that tradition. 
 For it is not clear that the generative or productive motions which &bquo;cause&equo; a circle really are put forward as &bquo;efficient&equo; causes; Hobbes has a tendency to speak of them in ways which make it not inappropriate to think of them in terms of some notion of &bquo;formal&equo; cause. 
 His example makes it seem that the circle is not simply a detachable result of, or something which can be considered in isolation from, certain motions, but rather something whose very nature and properties are essentially tied up with its method of production. 
 He seems to invite us to think of the circle as something which embodies , or is a continuing expression  of, the motions which generate it; and this involves our thinking of those motions in a way which makes them less like efficient causes than like formal causes, at least as Aristotle intended them. 
 Philosophy, for Hobbes, is not simply knowledge of effects (or causes) based on knowledge of causes (or effects). 
 To be &bquo;philosophical&equo;, knowledge must be a product of reason or &bquo;true ratiocination&equo;. 
 As such it differs from &bquo;knowledge by sense&equo;. 
 Sensory images, which we refer to events outside us, are produced in us by motions. 
 Some become associated in our minds when they recur in the same order. 
 Because of the order of occurrence of certain images, we remember that fair mornings follow red evenings. 
 Remembered sequences form our &bquo;experience&equo;, the written record of which is &bquo;history&equo;, both &bquo;natural&equo; and &bquo;political&equo;. 
 Our own &bquo;experience&equo; and the authority of written &bquo;history&equo; give us prudence and foresight. 
 They lead us to form expectations on the basis of present signs: a prudent man will take a violently red morning sky as a sign of impending storm. 
 Hobbes would be foolish to deny the pragmatic importance of the knowledge given by wide experience and history, and he certainly does not do so. 
 But he is at pains to stress that it is not philosophical knowledge, not true science. 
 &bquo;Sense and Memory of things, which are common to man and all living creatures&equo; are knowledge, but &bquo;because they are given us immediately by nature, and not gotten by ratiocination, they are not philosophy.&equo; 
 Though true science, or ratiocinative knowledge, differs from experiential knowledge, it nevertheless begins with it. 
 &bquo;History&equo;, says Hobbes, is &bquo;most useful (nay necessary) to philosophy.&equo; 
 Even so, the significance it has for Hobbes is nothing like that which it had for Bacon. 
 The laborious compilation of exhaustive &bquo;histories&equo;, or tables of instances, is an essential first stage of Bacon's method, the second of which consists in the scrutiny and examination of these many and varied instances to find their common form. 
 So the examination of historical instances is never really left behind. 
 They are either systematically collected, or studied for patterns and regularities. 
 For Hobbes, however, though such &bquo;histories&equo; or lengthy records of experience are of great prudential value and interest, the application of his ratiocinative method does not demand them. 
 The immediate sense-experiences with which his method begins are not part of a systematic record, and are very quickly left behind as one digs below their surface. 
 The distinction between rationalism and empiricism relates to a distinction between knowledge acquired by reason and knowledge acquired by the senses. 
 Bacon is an &bquo;empiricist&equo;, not because of some theory which shows that sensory experiential knowledge is superior, or prior, to knowledge acquired by reason, but because of methodological concern for advancing and improving the first kind of knowledge. 
 Hobbes, on the other hand, is more of a theorist, less of a methodologist than Bacon: his distinction between experiential and ratiocinative knowledge is considered and explicitly made. 
 He has, indeed, been further contrasted with Bacon by being called a &bquo;rationalist&equo;, for he allows only the product of ratiocination or reason to count as &bquo;philosophy&equo; or &bquo;science&equo;. 
 But he hardly dismisses experiential knowledge out of hand. 
 It is, indeed, where philosophy must begin. 
 To see what role this typically empiricist claim has in Hobbes's thought, we should look at the details of his account of philosophical knowledge, knowledge acquired by reason or &bquo;true ratiocination&equo;. 
 Hobbes &bquo;s talk of &bquo;true ratiocination&equo; is an indication that he has some theory of what reason or ratiocination is, some explanation or analysis of it. 
 According to this, ratiocination consists in &bquo;composition&equo; (or &bquo;synthesis&equo;) and &bquo;resolution&equo; (or &bquo;analysis&equo;). 
 These ideas have a long history going back to sources such as Aristotle, Archimedes, Galen, and Boethius. 
 A classic and developed account of the resolutio-compositive method of reasoning was given by Zarabella, a member of the influential group of sixteenth-century thinkers associated with the University of Padua. 
 With various mathematical refinements, it was this method that Galileo, one-time professor at Padua, used in studying the motion of falling bodies. 
 It was also advocated by William Harvey, another ex-Paduan. 
 Given his admiration for the scientific achievements of Galileo and Harvey, it is no surprise that Hobbes shares their methodological ideas. 
 The central idea of the resolutio-compositive method is that, to understand some complex matter, one must understand its parts, and how they fit together. 
 So the initial stage in the discovery of the unknown cause of a given observable effect is resolution or analysis of the effect into parts. 
 Then, once the causes of these parts are known, the cause of the original effect can be demonstrated by composition, or synthesis, of these partial causes. 
 The distinction between discovery of causes by resolution and demonstration of the effects of certain causes by composition, was coupled with another, that between what is &bquo;more known to us&equo; and what is &bquo;more known to nature&equo;. 
 Effects, or appearances, are immediately known to us by our senses. 
 We are directly presented with them in our ordinary experience, and so must start with them in any investigation into hidden and unknown causes. 
 But, though they are therefore &bquo;more known to us&equo; and come first &bquo;in the order of our knowledge&equo;, effects or appearances in fact depend on, and are secondary to, their causes. 
 Their causes come first &bquo;in the order of things&equo; and are &bquo;more known to nature&equo;. 
 The method of resolution, which begins with effects and seeks for causes, was traditionally called the &bquo;method of discovery, invention, or investigation&equo;; so the direction or &bquo;order of discovery&equo; is from &bquo;effects to causes&equo;. 
 The method of resolution which begins with causes and demonstrates their consequent effects was called the &bquo;method of proof or demonstration&equo;; so the direction or &bquo;the order of proof or of things&equo; goes &bquo;from causes to effects&equo;. 
 It was usually supposed that teaching should follow the order of discovery, for then the student is made to begin with familiar things. 
 These ideas can be found in Hobbes. 
 The two directions of thought he distinguishes, from effects to causes, and from causes to effects, are discussed by him in terms of resolution or analysis, and composition or synthesis. 
 There are differences of detail, of course; for example, he seems undecided about whether teaching should follow the order of discovery, or of proof. 
 What is most important, however, is that he embodies them in a distinction, crucially important for his thought, between two sorts of science: &bquo;indefinite science&equo;, which &bquo;consists in the knowledge of the causes of all things&equo;, and the study of some &bquo;limited&equo; question about the &bquo;cause of some determined appearance&equo; such as heat. 
 The first of these concerns the attempt to construct a general theoretical framework in terms of which we can answer the &bquo;limited&equo; particular questions of the second. 
 &bquo;Indefinite&equo; science is obviously extremely important, for without some understanding of what general shape a causal explanation should take and of what concepts it should use, it would not be possible to give a detailed, or&equo; limited', causal account of the particular causes of some particular effect. 
 A &bquo;limited&equo; inquiry, one &bquo;into the cause of some determined appearance&equo;, requires an initial process of resolution. 
 For, though the particular thing or phenomenon in whose cause we are interested is presented in experience as a unified whole, it may in fact have &bquo;parts&equo; into which it can be rationally analysed. 
 A man, for instance, is a whole whose parts are his having a certain shape, his being alive, and his being rational. 
 Resolution into these parts is necessary in order to find their respective causes. 
 Once the parts and their causes are known, rational synthesis, or composition, can take place. 
 Given knowledge of the parts and their causes, synthesis will culminate in knowledge of the causes of the whole with which we first began in experience. 
 Clearly, though, doing this in any &bquo;limited&equo; particular case requires some background idea of what sort of thing a cause is, and how causes can be composed or combined. 
 It requires, that is, that we have some &bquo;indefinite&equo; science. 
 Hobbes outlines how the methodical procedures of resolution and composition will result in such a science. 
 He also, however, goes some considerable way towards actually producing the fundamental explanatory framework of this science which is a requisite for any &bquo;limited&equo; inquiry. 
 Like &bquo;limited&equo; particular science, general &bquo;indefinite&equo; science begins with the presentations of sense-experience, and with the analysis of composite wholes into parts. 
 Its interest is not in the particular parts of particular kinds of thing, however, but in those parts which all material things have in common. 
 Before we can know the cause of, say, rationality, by which men are distinguished from other things, we need to know the causes of those parts which all material things have in common, for example occupation of space, solidity, shape, and movement. 
 As in Euclid's development of geometry, these &bquo;universal things&equo; and other important basic notions need explication by clear definitions. 
 Hobbes defines &bquo;place&equo; as the &bquo;space which is possessed or filled adequately by some body&equo;, and &bquo;motion&equo; as &bquo;the privation of one place, and the acquisition of another&equo;. 
 He says that some definitions, such as that of &bquo;place&equo;, do not express the causes of what they define, for there are none. 
 But other &bquo;universal things&equo;, such as shape and extension, do have causes, and their definitions must express them. 
 Basically, however, there is just one cause: &bquo;the causes of universal things (of those, at least, that have any cause) are manifest of themselves, or (as they commonly say) known to nature; so that they need no method at all; for they have all but one universal cause, which is motion.&equo; 
 We are already familiar with Hobbes's fascination with motion, and how it seemed obvious to him that motion was the one basic cause. 
 But if it is not by any application of the resolutio-compositive method that we know that all causation is a matter of motion, how can we be sure that it is? 
 The value of this idea can really be judged only by reference to the value of the whole explanatory framework of &bquo;indefinite&equo; science, at whose basis it lies. 
 Perhaps someone could come up with some better idea. 
 But Hobbes is certain that as to &bquo;those that say anything may be&hellip; produced by&hellip; substantial forms &hellip; and other empty words of schoolmen, their saying so is to no purpose&equo;. 
 In what way, then, is motion the cause of shape? 
 We have already seen something of what Hobbes has in mind when we considered his idea of the generation of a circle. 
 A solid cube has two-dimensional plane surfaces, and these have linear sides. 
 One might define the lines which form the cube's sides as the shortest distances between pairs of points; but this would not express their motive cause which Hobbes conceives them to have. 
 He defines a line as the result of &bquo;the motion of a point&equo;; a surface, similarly, is the result of &bquo;the motion of a line&equo;. 
 Given these definitions we can ask, more specifically, just what motion of a point produces a straight line, and what a circular; what motion of a straight line produces a square, and what motion of a circle produces a sphere. 
 From this &bquo;kind of contemplation&equo;, says Hobbes, has &bquo;sprung that part of philosophy which is called geometry &equo;; and he gives some detailed results of his own geometrical contemplations (including an attempt to square the circle) in the second and third parts of De Corpore . 
 Geometry, then, is concerned with the production of figures by various motions. 
 After it, says Hobbes, our thoughts should turn to what is, in effect, mechanics: &bquo;the consideration of what effects one body moved worketh upon another.&equo; 
 We should consider what happens when one moving body comes into contact with another: &bquo;what way, and with what swiftness, the invaded body shall move; and, again, what motion this second body will generate in a third.&equo; 
 After the sciences of geometry and of motion comes &bquo;physics&equo;. 
 Hobbes first describes this, in the introductory part of De Corpore , as a part of &bquo;indefinite&equo; science, the working out of a theoretical structure in terms of which particular &bquo;limited&equo; questions are answered. 
 But later, when details come to be worked out, it appears as a part of the &bquo;limited&equo; investigation into the causes of particular effects. 
 Its first concern is the phenomenon which, years earlier, had so intrigued Hobbes, and which engendered his interest in motion: the phenomenon of sense. 
 In sense-perception we have a conscious awareness of material things around us, such as trees and stones, things which we can later represent to ourselves in memory and imagination. 
 But not everything has this ability: the stones and trees which we can see and remember do not, themselves, have the capacity to &bquo;represent&equo;. 
 Hobbes found it remarkable that some, but not all, things had conscious awareness and perception: &bquo;Of all the phenomena or appearances which are near us, the most admirable is apparition itself&hellip; namely, that some natural bodies have in themselves the patterns almost of all things, and others of none at all.&equo; 
 From the point of view of Descartes, Hobbes's great French contemporary, this is not so remarkable. 
 According to him, there is a strict dualism between mind, whose essence it is to think and perceive, and material, unthinking, extended body. 
 So things such as ourselves, which perceive and have conscious awareness, do so because they are (or have) minds. 
 They are of a completely different sort from purely material things, such as trees and stones, which are only objects of perception, and not themselves perceivers. 
 In his Objections , appended to the first edition of Descartes's Meditations  (1641), Hobbes rejects this. 
 He does not deny the existence of mind, and he does not deny that it is the province of mind to think and perceive. 
 But he does say that mind is nothing essentially different from body, and is, in fact, &bquo;nothing but the motions in certain parts of an organic body&equo;. 
 According to this materialistic point of view, sense-perception is a matter of motion in the body of the perceiver. 
 Objects outside of a perceiver generate motion, which is propagated through sense-organs to the heart and the brain. 
 Because the parts of our bodies already have their own natural motion, there is a reaction to the motion produced from outside; and from &bquo;the reaction&hellip; a phantasm or idea hath its being&equo;. 
 It is because this reaction is directed outwards against the invading motion that the phantasms are experienced as though they were the external objects which initially caused them. 
 As noted, Hobbes seems undecided whether &bquo;physics&equo; (which includes his explanation of sense-perception) is included, along with geometry and mechanics, as part of the basic explanatory framework which he calls &bquo;indefinite&equo; science. 
 He is perfectly clear, however, that &bquo;indefinite&equo; science is as I have just described it: a basic explanatory framework. 
 He is perfectly clear that it is in the terms provided by this framework that we are able to answer any &bquo;limited&equo; question about the causes of particular phenomena. 
 &bquo;If a cause were to be rendered of natural appearances in special as what are the motions and influences of the heavenly bodies and of their parts, the reason hereof must either be drawn from the parts of the sciences above mentioned, or no reason at all will be given, but all left to uncertain conjecture.&equo; 
 In a manner more or less true to this claim, Hobbes devotes the last part of De Corpore  to answering some particular questions about the motion of the planets, the tides, the weather, and gravity. 
 Rather than follow him into this detail, it is more important here to underline an important general characteristic which Hobbes says the claim has. 
 Bacon's method was aimed at discovering the formal causes of particular phenomena. 
 He believed that, by its means, we could arrive at certainty on such matters. 
 But, besides the fact that the details of his method cannot be read into many of the advances made in the sciences, his promise of certainty has come to seem inappropriate. 
 Theoretical explanations in the sciences tend to be of an essentially hypothetical nature. 
 Other than the fact that they provide a satisfactory explanation, there is often no independent test of their truth. 
 The suggested causes of a given phenomenon cannot always be independently observed, and so it is hard to rule out the possibility of there being explanations alternative to the one proposed. 
 This is recognized by Hobbes's method. 
 Unless we explain in terms of a framework based on the idea of the motions of material body, we are left with &bquo;uncertain conjecture&equo;. 
 But even explanations in such terms, however certain they may be, are still &bquo;conjecture&equo;. 
 &bquo;There is no effect in nature which the Author of nature cannot bring to pass by more ways than one.&equo; 
 Use of the explanatory framework provided by his &bquo;indefinite&equo; science, together with the application of the resolutio-compositive method to particular observed phenomena, can only result in a hypothesis about its unobserved generative causes. 
 Hobbes is quite explicit about this. 
 All we can find out &bquo;by the appearances or effects of nature, which we know by sense, &lsqb;are&rsqb; some ways and means by which they may be, I do not say they are, generated&equo;. 
 Beginning with the phenomena of sense, and by the use of our explanatory framework, we form hypotheses about their causes. 
 These hypotheses can be tested against further experience and experiment, but hypotheses they remain. 
 Having reached some understanding of Hobbes's method in terms of its application in natural philosophy, we should recall that that subject, which deals with &bquo;bodies natural&equo;, is simply one part of philosophy as such, and not the only part to which the resolutio-compositive method is to be applied. 
 Its importance is that the other parts depend on its results for their complete explanations. 
 They are, in their order of dependence: moral philosophy or ethics (which deals with &bquo;the dispositions and manners of men&equo;), and political or civil philosophy (which deals with &bquo;the civil duties of subjects&equo;). 
 De Corpore  contains only hints about these sciences, and their further development is in the other two parts of Hobbes's Elements of Philosophy  &mdash; De Homine  and De Cive . 
 Natural philosophy, or that part of it which is physics, will already have dealt with man to some extent, in considering the phenomenon of sense-perception. 
 Moral philosophy, then, deals not with man's ability to &bquo;represent&equo; in perception, but with what Hobbes calls the &bquo;motions of the mind&equo; &mdash; desire, aversion, love, and benevolence. 
 In studying these to find their causes we need to have done some natural philosophy, because these motions of the mind have their causes in sense and imagination. 
 Just as Hobbes rejects Descartes's view of sense-perception as having to do with an immaterial mind, so his moral philosophy is purely materialistic, and appeals only to the idea of matter in motion. 
 Hobbes had learnt from his scientific hero, Harvey, that one of the motions in the body is that of the blood circulated by the heart. 
 Like Harvey, he took the heart to be &bquo;the original of life&equo;, and of crucial importance. 
 It is &bquo;the fountain of sense&equo;, for, by the &bquo;vital motion&equo; it produces, it governs what we perceive, think, feel, and desire. 
 Motions from outside of the body often affect this &bquo;vital motion&equo;, either helping or hindering it, and our awareness of these changes constitutes pleasure and pain. 
 Learning from experience which things help or hinder the blood's motion, we come to develop appetites and aversions; we come to hope for what produces pleasure, and to fear what produces pain. 
 In Hobbes's view, humans always act according to desires, and so always act so as to produce the increase in vital motion, which is pleasure. 
 On the surface of it, Hobbes's view of human nature as being completely egocentric is open to objection. 
 Is there not such a thing as pity? 
 Are we not sometimes benevolent towards our fellows? 
 Anyone who find, Hobbes's view intellectually attractive will easily hit upon his thesis that someone who feels pity is simply moved by the self-centred thought &bquo;that the like calamity may befall himself&equo;, and that people are benevolent only because this produces self-satisfaction. 
 But the arguments of Bishop Joseph Butler, in his anti-Hobbesian Sermons on Human Nature  (1726), suggest that the structure of human nature is more complex than this. 
 One might do things out of a self-loving pride, but this is not benevolence; and though a benevolent person may gratify himself, this is not what he is aiming at, and is not the principle of his action. 
 It does seem possible to act on desires in a free, and relatively deliberate, way. 
 In an extreme case, someone may act on them for the reason that, or on the principle that, &bquo;a little bit of what you fancy does you good&equo;. 
 It does not seem that we necessarily are always simply taken, let alone overtaken, by our desires, so that they act themselves out in us as the force of the wind acts on a leaf. 
 But the having of a principle of action, as opposed to the unreflecting impulsive acting out of a desire, has, in fact, no place in Hobbes's scheme (unless such principles are taken simply to be settled general desires). 
 This is made clear in his controversy with John Bramhall, Bishop of Derry, on the subject of free will. 
 According to Hobbes, we act &bquo;by a certain impulsion of nature, no less than that whereby a stone moves downward&equo;. 
 For him, there is no faculty of the will. 
 There is no such thing as deciding to do something, at least as this is usually understood. 
 What we might think of as a process of deliberation and choice about our desires is, for him, simply the interplay and jostling of desires amongst themselves; and what we call &bquo;will&equo; is simply the desire that wins. 
 But though desire determines actions in this way, there nevertheless is, argues Hobbes, a sense in which we can be free. 
 Indeed, unless our desires do determine our actions, we are not free. 
 There is no loss of liberty in being carried along on our strongest desire, even when, because of the external circumstances of physical threat, that desire is to turn away from satisfying some other desire. 
 We are unfree, not when our strongest desire is displaced by an even stronger one, but when it is thwarted by external circumstances and becomes impossible of realization. 
 It is plain from all of this how moral philosophy is taken to depend on natural philosophy. 
 The phenomena it studies, such as pity and benevolence, are explained in terms of a basic desire for pleasure, and aversion to pain, and in their turn these are explained in terms of the &bquo;vital motion&equo; of the blood. 
 In short, &bquo;the dispositions and manners of man&equo; have their causes in motions, the complexities of which are the province of natural philosophy. 
 In a similar way the phenomena of political philosophy, &bquo;the civil duties of a subject&equo;, are, we shall see, reduced to, or explained in terms of, their causes in our basic desire for the pleasurable enhancement of the blood's vital motion. 
 It might appear that, in order properly to understand the moral causes of political phenomena, we need in the end to have understood the natural phenomena which cause moral phenomena. 
 In fact, however, this is not Hobbes's view. 
 He does not think that we need to have studied, in moral philosophy, the reduction of the &bquo;motions of the mind&equo; to natural philosophy in order to understand, in political philosophy, the causes of &bquo;the civil duties of a subject&equo;. 
 For the &bquo;motions of the mind&equo;, our desires and aversions, and what they may lead us to do, are not theoretical constructs known only by &bquo;ratiocination&equo;, and introduced as an intermediary stage in the reduction of political to natural philosophy. 
 They are known &bquo;by the experience of every man that takes the pains to observe those motions within himself&equo;. 
 It does not take the explanations of moral philosophy about the relation of our desires and aversions, and hopes and fears, to the motion of the blood, to tell us that &bquo;unless they be restrained by some power, &lsqb;men&rsqb;&hellip; will always be making war upon another&equo;. 
 This &bquo;may be known to be so by any man's experience, that will but examine his own mind&equo;. 
 Political philosophy can be &bquo;grounded on its own principles sufficiently known by experience&equo;. 
 So, although the events leading up to the Civil War made it seem desirable to Hobbes to write De Cive  before the completion of De Homine , his finding this possible was not inconsistent with his conception of a three-part ordered system of Elements of Philosophy . 
 Hobbes was especially proud of the political part of his contributions to philosophy. 
 Galileo had already opened the door to natural philosophy, and Hobbes supposed he was following Gilbert, Kepler, Gassendi, Harvey, and Mersenne, through it. 
 But it was he himself who, he says, opened the door to political philosophy. 
 He claims to have been the first to produce any. 
 Indeed, he thought De Cive  contained things of a rather different nature from anything so far in political philosophy: it contained demonstrations  of its conclusions. 
 Apart from its demonstratively worked-out &bquo;indefinite&equo; framework, natural philosophy is essentially hypothetical. 
 The phenomena it explains are given to us in experience; they are not produced by us, their causes are not directly knowable, and we can only hypothesize, in the terms of our theoretical framework, about what they are. 
 The geometrical part of that framework is demonstrable because, says Hobbes, the geometrical shapes which are its objects can be created by ourselves. 
 For the same reasons, political philosophy can be demonstrated. 
 For one thing, the &bquo;motions of our mind&equo;, which are the causes of political phenomena, are known directly to us in our experience. 
 For another, the state, or civil society, the object of political philosophy is, like the objects of geometry, of our own creation. 
 In an important passage he writes: 
 As The science of every subject is derived from a precognition of the causes, generation, and construction of the same; and consequently where the causes are known, there is place for demonstration, but not where the causes are to seek for. 
 Geometry therefore is demonstrable, for the lines and figures from which we reason are drawn and described by ourselves; and civil philosophy is demonstrable, because we make the commonwealth ourselves. 
 But because of natural bodies we know not the construction, but seek it from the effects, there lies no demonstration of what the causes be we seek for, but only of what they may be. 
 In order to understand the state, we need, in accordance with the resolutio-compositive method, first to consider the parts out of which it comes into being. 
 We must look at what people would be like outside of, and prior to, civil society. 
 We must &bquo;consider men as if but even now sprung out of the earth, and suddenly, like mushrooms, come to full maturity, without all kind of engagement to each other&equo;. 
 It does not matter to Hobbes whether men were ever actually in such a &bquo;state of nature&equo;, but he suggests that the American Indians are in one somewhat like it. 
 This is one sense in which we ourselves &bquo;make the commonwealth&equo;. 
 But in fact there are two, for, as Hobbes says, &bquo;we are the matter  and the artificer &equo; of the state. 
 The second sense emerges as we follow his explanation of how the civil state would come into being out of a state of nature, by the making of contracts. 
 Given Hobbes's view of egocentric human nature, according to which people always act in such a way as to produce pleasure and avoid pain, it is plain how they will behave in an ungoverned state of nature. 
 Living solely by their hopes for what, in effect, will enhance their &bquo;vital motion&equo;, and fear of what will impede it, they exist in a state of perpetual fear, suspicion, and competition. 
 In what has become a classic description of this unpleasant and unstable world, in which peaceful planning and long-term effort is pointless, Hobbes says that: 
 in such a condition, there is no place for industry; because the fruit thereof is uncertain: and consequently no culture of the earth; no navigation, nor use of the commodities that may be imported by sea; no commodious buildings; no instruments of moving, and removing, such things as require much force; no knowledge of the face of the earth; no account of time; no arts; no letters; no society; and which is worst of all, continual fear, and danger of violent death; and the life of man, solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short. 
 In such a state, driven by the worst fear of all, that of sudden death, and given that they are all approximately equal in power, it would seem to be in men's interests that they reach some agreement, each to have only as much liberty as he is prepared to allow to others. 
 But could such an agreement be reached, and would it be kept? 
 A person's real self-interest would lie in his  not keeping to such an agreement, while others did. 
 But why should others, driven by their  self-interest, keep the agreement? 
 Trust, as such, is not an element in Hobbesian human nature. 
 &bquo;The dispositions of men are naturally such, that except they be restrained through fear of some coercive power, every man will distrust and dread each other.&equo; 
 What is needed is some mechanism for enforcement  of the agreement, so that it would be in no one's interest to break it. 
 &bquo;Covenants, without the sword, are but words, and of no strength to secure a man at all.&equo; 
 An agreement is needed, not merely to give up an amount of liberty, but to put it into the hands of some sovereign power. 
 Men need, in effect, to say to each other, &bquo;I authorize and give up my right of governing myself, to this man, or to this assembly of men, on this condition, that they give up their right to him and authorize all his actions in like manner.&equo; 
 From the unlikely beginning of an extreme and unremitting egocentricity, Hobbes has thus explained how it is possible that a civil society can come into being. 
 Both personally, and in his political philosophy, Hobbes placed a high premium on peace and stability. 
 To some temperaments his state of nature might seem exciting and full of challenge. 
 But from Hobbes's description it seems as though its very contemplation filled him with a trembling, timorous fear. 
 For him, an established and stable state was a necessary condition for the satisfaction of men's desires; the peace it offered was its rationale and justification. 
 This explains the premature publication of De Cive  in 1642, the year in which mounting resistance to the established monarch, Charles I, resulted in the outbreak of the Civil War. 
 Leviathan  was published in 1651, two years before Charles was beheaded and Cromwell became Protector of the Commonwealth. 
 Such turmoil, Hobbes thought, arose from ignorance of political and moral science: the cause of civil war is &bquo;that men know not the causes neither of war nor peace&equo;. 
 He claimed to demonstrate these causes. 
 Sovereignty is, and must be, absolute and undivided. 
 The Puritan appeal to individual conscience, the conflicts between Parliament and King, all rest on a misunderstanding of the nature of sovereignty, and its relation to the governed. 
 Hobbes had left England for Paris in 1640, believing that his political views made this prudent and, as mathematics tutor to the future Charles II, he was associated there with the exiled English court. 
 By 1652 he was back in England where, in the event, he was able to prove acceptable to Parliament. 
 Some said at the time that Leviathan  had been written for Cromwell, and indeed Hobbes did say that it supported a &bquo;conscientious obedience to the present government&equo; of the Protectorate. 
 Then, finally, in 1662, he apologetically asked Charles II not &bquo;to think the worse of me, if snatching up all the weapons to fight against your enemies, I lighted upon one that had a double edge&equo;. 
 Whatever the complexities of Hobbes's personal motivations, there was no theoretical inconsistency in all of this. 
 He did, indeed, have a marked preference for a monarchy, arguing for it as the &bquo;most commodious government&equo;. 
 But this is, he says, simply a matter of probability. 
 All he claims to have demonstrated is the necessity for some absolute sovereign power or other; according to his theory, this could as easily be a democracy or an aristocracy as a monarchy. 
 Moreover, it follows from this necessity for an absolute sovereign, that an eventual transfer of allegiance is inevitable when the &bquo;sovereign&equo; fails to govern, and keep the civil peace. 
 In accordance with his political views, Hobbes found no room for religious dissent from an established church with the absolute sovereign as its head. 
 Religious dissent is, indeed, one source of civil unrest. 
 But, although a professed and conforming Anglican, he was often reviled as an atheist. 
 This was largely as a consequence of his undoubted materialism, according to which all that exists is matter in motion. 
 To say that anything spiritual, such as God or the soul, is &bquo;an incorporeal substance, is to say in effect, there is no&hellip; spirit at all&equo;. 
 But, just as Hobbes does not deny we have a mind or soul, so he does not deny the existence of God. 
 Apart, however, from his existence as a corporeal omnipotent first cause, all else about God was a matter of faith. 
 If the gate of natural philosophy, the ultimate foundation for Hobbes's political philosophy, had been opened by Galileo, others had entered through it along with Harvey. 
 Hobbes mentions Marin Mersenne and Pierre Gassendi as two who had &bquo;extraordinarily advanced&equo; the subject. 
 Hobbes had formed a close friendship with Gassendi during his meetings with him in Paris, in the circle of scientists and philosophers which centred round Mersenne. 
 According to Aubrey, &bquo;they loved each other entirely&equo;, and Hobbes never mentioned him &bquo;but with great honour and respect&equo;. 
 He is the subject of the next chapter. 
 Pierre Gassendi (l592-l655) 
 Pierre Gassendi was born at Champtercier, in the south of France, in 1592. 
 His life was spent in the Church, in teaching, and in private study. 
 A Catholic priest and Canon of Digne, he was also Professor of Philosophy at Aix, and of Mathematics at the College Royale in Paris. 
 He was in close contact with many prominent intellectuals and scholars, such as Kepler, Galileo, Hobbes, Descartes, and Mersenne, and was very highly regarded both inside and outside France, where he lived until his death in l655. 
 His writings, with their discussions of the nature of science, contain the basis of a theoretical empiricism. 
 But he was also interested in the substantial factual detail of astronomy, anatomy, and the physics of motion. 
 He made, and published, many observations on these matters, having been persuaded by Snell, the celebrated Dutch mathematician, that there was some point in studying nature as well as books. 
 He was a vegetarian and teetotaller and, in Hobbes's view (so Aubrey tells us), &bquo;the sweetest-natured man in the world&equo;. 
 Only controversy with Descartes was able to disturb his mildness. 
 Despite his fame amongst his contemporaries, Gassendi has been overshadowed by those whom he influenced &mdash; perhaps because of the modesty and undogmatic nature of his arguments, which lie buried in lengthy, copiously annotated Latin works. 
 An English summary of some of these appeared in 1654, and Francois Bernier produced a famous French abridgement between 1674 and 1678. 
 But some of his work is still not available in modern French, and most of it not in English. 
 He is best known now for his Objections  (1644) to Descartes's Meditations , which are remarkable for the vituperative annoyance which runs through them. 
 Although they constitute a thorough attack on Descartes's rationalism, Gassendi's empiricism is developed elsewhere. 
 Chapter 1 has described how one of the movements in seventeenth-century thought was the rejection of scholastic philosophy in general, and its account of scientific explanation in particular. 
 The rejection of the theory of hylemorphism, according to which natural phenomena and the properties of things are to be understood in terms of form and matter, is implicit in Bacon. 
 Though he spoke of &bquo;forms&equo; as the explanatory factors in things, his conception of them differs, as we saw, from that of the Aristotelians. 
 The rejection is there in Hobbes too; for him the basis of explanation is matter in motion. 
 The picture of the universe as a mechanical affair of matter in motion did not originate, but rather was painted afresh, in the seventeenth century; it was derived from the atomic theory of the ancient Greeks, Democritus and Epicurus. 
 But as dissatisfaction with scholastic theory increased, so did acceptance of ancient atomism, and Gassendi has a prime responsibility for its revival. 
 According to Gassendi's own report, he was dissatisfied from the start with the Aristotelianism he was taught as a student. 
 He quickly discovered, however, that other schools of philosophy, despite proud boasts to the contrary, had nothing better to offer. 
 Consequently, in a spirit of scepticism, he came to distrust all dogmatic claims to knowledge. 
 The unsatisfactoriness of the competing claims of various philosophers first led him to the belief that scientific knowledge of nature was unattainable by the human mind. 
 Unlike Bacon, who supposed that his method of inquiry would give certainty, he concluded that judgement on such matters ought to be suspended. 
 It was possible to see both good and bad in any view, and this proved &bquo;the vanity as well as the uncertainty of human knowledge&equo;. 
 Gassendi thus provides a notable example of the influence of the rediscovery in the sixteenth century of Sextus Empiricus' Outlines of Pyrrhonism , to which reference has already been made. 
 The markedly sceptical attitude and arguments which run through his writings are derived from Sextus, and from others, such as Michel Montaigne and Pierre Charron, who were themselves influenced by Sextus. 
 Even though he was dissatisfied with Aristotle's teachings, Gassendi was required, as professor of philosophy, to expound them to his students, just as his own professors had expounded them to him. 
 He dutifully did this. 
 But by way of indicating that they were not, and could not be, the final truth, he appended a series of objections to his lecture course. 
 Shortly after leaving Aix he published them as Exercises in the Form of Paradoxes against the Aristotelians  (1624). 
 The whole tone of these is somewhat scathing. 
 Indeed, Gassendi acknowledges that &bquo;in this matter it is especially difficult not to write satirically&equo;. 
 Though immensely enjoyable to read, the Exercises  give no impression that Gassendi is doing the best by his opponents before attacking them. 
 Of course, much of that would have been done in his lectures, to which the anti-Aristotelian Exercises  are an appendix. 
 He does go some way towards outlining counter-arguments and replies, but his style is the playful one of a cat with a mouse. 
 His initial general complaints about the whole tenor, style, and intellectual bent of the Aristotelians are of the common seventeenth-century sort, which were outlined in Chapter 1. 
 They are there in Bacon, and in Hobbes, and they are there again in Locke. 
 The Aristotelians are conservative and obstructive to the progress of philosophy and knowledge. 
 They go in for querulous and disputatious argument. 
 Their real interest is in point-scoring and success in debate, not in the advancement of genuine knowledge. 
 They focus on words and arguments, not on real things and observations. 
 They look too much to the past, and have an undue reliance on the words and works of their master Aristotle. 
 They think that all knowledge is to be found by perusing him, and not by looking at the real world. 
 They comment on, gloss, and interpret his writings, and spend too little time in empirical observation and investigation. 
 In common with Bacon, Gassendi does not say that Aristotle is completely valueless: he acknowledges the greatness of his mind. 
 His criticisms are directed more at his followers, who fail to recognize, not only that other great past minds have something to teach, but also, more importantly, that there could be great minds in the future. 
 These, perhaps by building on parts of Aristotle, will be able to advance knowledge even further than he did. 
 Gassendi's criticisms are not all of this general sort, however. 
 He launches a detailed attack on the many aspects of scholastic teaching which had their basis in the logical works of Aristotle's Organon . 
 One of these is its account of what scientia , or an organized body of knowledge, is like. 
 Though our more recent notion of a developed science, such as physics or chemistry, is directly descended from this, our conception of how such sciences come about, and the methods of investigation appropriate to them, differs in certain important respects from that of the Aristotelians. 
 In large measure, these differences are due to the criticisms of the Aristotelian scheme made by some of those who are treated in this book, and in its companion, The Rationalists . 
 According to the Aristotelian picture, scientia , or knowledge proper, is knowledge of what is necessary and cannot be otherwise. 
 Strictly speaking, there can be no &bquo;knowledge&equo; of things that are so, but that could have been otherwise. 
 What was called &bquo;opinion&equo; has to do with contingent facts of this sort. 
 To have such &bquo;scientific knowledge&equo; of, say, the facts that man is the only animal with a sense of humour, that gold dissolves in aqua regia , or that triangles have angles equal to two right angles, is to know that these things must be so and cannot be otherwise. 
 And this involves having a demonstrative understanding of the causes why these things have these properties. 
 In general terms, Bacon and Hobbes accept the Aristotelian idea that scientific understanding involves knowledge of causes. 
 Gassendi accepts it too. 
 But, in a more explicit and forceful way, he objects to the particular account of such knowledge in which this general idea was embedded by Aristotle and his scholastic followers. 
 To demonstrate that something necessarily has a certain property, so the theory runs, is to show, by means of a syllogistic argument from certain axioms or first principles, that it has it. 
 The logical theory of syllogistic arguments was developed in great detail by Aristotle, and survives to this day in introductory logic textbooks. 
 In itself, there is nothing wrong with it. 
 What was wrong was the scholastic insistence that all arguments, all reasoning, could, and should, be put into this form. 
 In particular, what was wrong was their idea that &bquo;science&equo; should consist of demonstrative syllogisms, and their view of what the premisses of these should be like. 
 According to this account, to serve as satisfactory starting-points for scientific demonstration, the first principles, or axioms, need themselves to be indemonstrable; otherwise a demonstration would be needed of them. 
 They need to be &bquo;better known to nature&equo; too, prior in the order of things to the conclusions established on their basis. 
 If they were not, then, as we saw in the echoes of this theory which can be found in Hobbes's resolutio-compositive method, the proper order of demonstration would have been reversed. 
 They are of two sorts. 
 Some are things that have to be known if anything at all is to be known. 
 Common examples are general principles of reasoning, such as the law of non-contradiction (that nothing can both be and not be), and the proposition that, if equals are taken from equals, then equals remain. 
 Others are special to the subject-matter under consideration. 
 They pick that subject out and define it. 
 As the English word &bquo;science&equo; might lead us to expect, scientia  falls into various bodies of knowledge, or sciences, distinguished by their different subject-matters. 
 Each science has to do with its own genus, or &bquo;kind&equo;, which is divided by &bquo;differentia&equo; into various species. 
 Geometry deals with plane figures such as triangles and squares. 
 Similarly, biology has as its subject the genus &bquo;animal&equo;, a genus which falls into various species such as &bquo;dog&equo; or &bquo;horse&equo;. 
 Each science needs to be prefaced by an account, or definition in terms of genus and differentia, of the various species with which it deals. 
 A syllogism with premisses of this sort gives a demonstrative understanding of the causes why things necessarily have the properties they do, because the definitions with which it starts are definitions of the &bquo;forms&equo; of these things, and formal causes are one of the four kinds of cause which Aristotle distinguished. 
 According to the hylemorphic theory of the scholastics, each individual thing or substance is a combination of &bquo;matter&equo; ( hyle ) and &bquo;form&equo; ( morphe ), and it is because something has the form it has, that it is the kind of thing it is. 
 The definition of the species &bquo;man&equo; is supposed to give a real definition of man, an account of his &bquo;form&equo;, &bquo;essence&equo;, &bquo;nature&equo;, or &bquo;substantial form&equo;. 
 &bquo;Definition&equo;, Aristotle says, &bquo;reveals essential nature.&equo; 
 But besides &bquo;natures&equo;, &bquo;essences&equo;, or &bquo;substantial forms&equo; of the various genera and species, there are properties which members of that species universally and permanently have, and it is the aim of &bquo;science&equo; to tell us why they have them. 
 Though all triangles have angles equal to two right angles, having this is no part of their essence or definition. 
 The complete essence or form of a triangle is to be a three-sided plane figure. 
 Nevertheless, even though having angles equal to two right angles is not part of a triangle's essence, it is because it is a three-sided plane figure that it has them. 
 Properties of this sort were supposed to &bquo;flow&equo;, &bquo;derive&equo;, or &bquo;emanate&equo; from the form. 
 As Aquinas says, &bquo;a thing's characteristic operations derive from its substantial form&equo;. 
 The essence, or form, of a species accounts for the properties of that species, and a definition of it provides the means of demonstrating that the species does have those properties, and why it has them. 
 Facts about the properties of a given species are exactly the facts that a &bquo;science&equo;, with its initial definitions, is meant to give causal knowledge of. 
 Science is knowledge of what is necessarily the case, and of why it is so. 
 The properties of a species necessarily belong to things of that kind, and the essence, or definition, of that species is the cause, or reason, for their having them. 
 So one has acquired scientific knowledge when one has a series of syllogisms which, on the basis of &bquo;formal&equo; definitions and other first principles, demonstrates that certain properties of a species must belong to it. 
 Just as essences or forms give rise to those properties, so definitions of those forms, when used as premisses, give rise to conclusions about those properties. 
 Scientia , or scientific knowledge, consists of syllogisms such that the derivation of conclusions from their premisses mirrors the &bquo;flowing&equo; of properties from forms. 
 This theory was backed up by an elaborate logical system which gave strict rules for the production of unambiguous definitions of species in terms of their genus and their difference from other related species, and for the validity and relevance of syllogisms. 
 Along with others, Gassendi obviously felt that this whole elaborate conceptual structure was obstructive to, rather than productive of, knowledge. 
 It too easily degenerated into a concern with trivial verbal classifications, and artificial categories. 
 To begin with, we have no need, he argues, of Aristotelian logic, and are not helped by it. 
 We have no need formally to be told to avoid ambiguities. 
 Anyone with a desire for truth will unreflectingly and instinctively do this. 
 The rules of an artificial formal logic will not guide one in the search for the natures of things. 
 Just what routes will logic produce to lead me to the complete knowledge of the nature of a flea?&hellip; 
 Is it truly the province of logic to examine, to uncover, and consequently to explain the nature of things, rather than the province of Physics and the other sciences instead? 
 What olfactory sense is logic endowed with that it sniffs out and runs to ground the hidden nature of things? 
 Anyone trying to understand something will naturally compare it with other things to find similarities and differences. 
 No one thinks explicitly in terms of genus and differentia, and the scholastic rules for definitions. 
 No one is helped by doing so, or by reporting his discoveries in a tortured, tidied-up, formal account. 
 The Aristotelian talk of definitions &bquo;does not reveal nature to us, but only does the same as the man who promised to discover a treasure and then says &bquo;look where it is hidden and you will find it.&equo; 
 Not only are we not helped by scholastic logic to acquire knowledge of the forms, natures, or essences of things, and to see how other properties flow from them, but also it is extremely doubtful whether such knowledge is possible anyway. 
 We just do not know the natures we are supposed to know, or how various properties follow from them. 
 What is the &bquo;essence&equo; or &bquo;nature&equo; of a horse, and why does it follow from this that a horse has a certain type of head or feet, or lives to the age it does? 
 What is the &bquo;form&equo; of a flea, and will it explain its ability to digest blood, and to move with agility? 
 &bquo;What qualities result from that form deep within him, and how?&equo; 
 &bquo;Rational animal&equo; had been suggested as a definition of the &bquo;nature&equo; of man; but this appears to be no more than a specification of some of his properties. 
 The formal definitions of the Aristotelians are either unattainable, or hardly serve their intended purpose. 
 Even ignoring the fact that they were meant as definitions of natures or essences, Gassendi finds something wrong with the idea of finding universal propositions for the premisses of a scientific syllogism. 
 It is doubtful that universal propositions of any sort can be got. 
 Unless we perform the impossibility of checking all their instances, they always risk falsification by one counter-instance. 
 &bquo;You will surely tell me that this universal proposition is true &bquo;Every man is a biped&equo;&hellip; 
 And yet if I refer you to no other example than that little one-legged girl whom we saw not so long ago in our Provence, doesn't your universal statement collapse?&equo; 
 There is a good illustration here of how Gassendi's attacks do not take his opponents as seriously as might be. 
 It was not, for them, simply a matter of supposing that what held true in some cases would hold in all, but of their coming to see a particular case as an instance of an intuitively recognizable universal truth. 
 One need not mechanically check a large number of triangles to see that some of what holds of one will hold of all. 
 He is too quick, moreover, in his offhand dismissal of the thought that the girl was &bquo;abnormal&equo;: &bquo;You may say whatever you want; still it is enough to make your universal declaration false if one single case contradicts you.&equo; 
 The unsympathetic nature of his criticisms is also illustrated by what he says about the requirement that such universal premisses be &bquo;better known&equo; than their conclusions. 
 That all men laugh is supposed to be demonstrated from the premisses that all men are rational and that all rational things laugh. 
 But surely, says Gassendi, it is &bquo;better known&equo; that all men laugh than that all rational beings do. 
 As we saw in connection with Hobbes's method, however, the traditional idea was not, as Gassendi chooses to suppose, that a demonstrated conclusion should be &bquo;more known&equo; to us , or first in the order of knowledge. 
 It was that it should be &bquo;more known&equo; to nature , first in the order of things. 
 Finally, Gassendi attacks the idea that proofs must be syllogistic in form. 
 Even Aristotle's own practice contradicts this. 
 &bquo;Indeed, if Aristotle was a master of the art and handed his philosophy down to us very carefully, shouldn't he have proven everything in the most perfect form, especially when he insisted upon it himself &mdash; unless perhaps he intended to make fun of us?&equo; 
 Running through Gassendi's forthright rejection of the Aristotelian apparatus of definitions of &bquo;forms&equo; and syllogistic demonstration of scientific knowledge, is something more positive. 
 He frequently implies that knowledge is to be had by experience and by careful observation of the world. 
 Farmers, sailors, and chemists get by perfectly well on the basis of everyday experience, without recourse to Aristotelian logic. 
 If anything can help us uncover the natures of things, it is not logic, but physics, and the other observational sciences. 
 If there is an &bquo;instrument&equo; of scientific knowledge, it is not the content of Aristotle's Organon , but &bquo;painstaking experience&equo;. 
 Logic does not provide the means of distinguishing the true from the false. 
 &bquo;Experience is the balance in which the truth of any matter is to be weighed, such as whether fire is hot or not, whether the sun is bright or dim.&equo; 
 But we must not build too much, at this early stage in Gassendi's thought, on these positive aspects of it. 
 We should remember that he does not claim definitely to be refuting the Aristotelians, but merely to be pointing out what may be said against them. 
 His aim is not to show that one way of acquiring knowledge is better than another, but that &bquo;learning and human knowledge are weak and uncertain'. 
 I cannot, he says, &bquo;really persuade myself that the truth of things can be perceived by mortal men&equo;. 
 So, even though he continually contrasts the value of everyday experience with the emptiness of Aristotelian procedures, he in fact goes on to argue that everyday experience also is powerless to give us knowledge of the nature of things. 
 The arguments he uses here are standard ones, taken over bodily from the ten &bquo;tropes&equo; of the Greek sceptics as presented in Diogenes Laertius' Life of Pyrrho , and Sextus Empiricus' Outlines of Pyrrhonism . 
 They purport to show that judgement should be suspended on all matters. 
 There are many things that &bquo;our experience shows us&hellip; by the testimony of the senses&equo;; for example &bquo;that fire is hot and tends upwards, that water is cold and flows downhill, that honey is sweet&equo;. 
 But there is reason to think that our senses do not take us to the heart of things. 
 To mention only the first &bquo;trope&equo;, there are great differences between animals, in the manner of their birth, their way of life, their physical constitution, and so on. 
 Consequently &bquo;they have senses that are affected in different ways&equo;, and perceive things differently. 
 So Gassendi pursues two lines of thought in his Exercises against the Aristotelians . 
 On the one hand, he rejects the idea that we can attain knowledge in the form of demonstrative understanding that certain things must be so, an understanding based on knowledge of the real natures or essences of things. 
 Aristotelian logic does not provide any basis for such knowledge. 
 On the other hand, he argues that knowledge of &bquo;inner natures or necessary causes&equo; is not attainable on the basis of sense-experience either. 
 As a consequence, &bquo;it becomes apparent&equo;, he says, &bquo;that no proposition that makes assertions about the nature of a thing according to itself can be affirmed with confidence.&equo; 
 This is so not only in physics, but also in mathematics, which, we might have supposed, does provide knowledge of the real natures of numbers and geometrical figures, and demonstrations about the causes of their properties. 
 A mathematical proof about some property of a triangle does not, Gassendi thinks, give demonstrative understanding of its cause. 
 It merely reveals that the triangle does indeed have it. 
 &bquo;When a mathematician proves some proposition you had not known, he accomplishes no more than a man who discloses the contents of a casket&hellip; by opening it up.&equo; 
 But there is more to Gassendi's final position in his Exercises  than this. 
 Undoubtedly he has argued that on no  account is knowledge of necessary causes or real inner natures possible. 
 Neither Aristotelian logic nor sense-experience can get us it. 
 But does this mean that no  knowledge is possible? 
 Are the sceptics right in saying nihil sciri , that nothing can be known? 
 If knowledge, properly speaking, is knowledge of necessary causes, or real inner natures, then they are. 
 But is knowledge like this? 
 Might not what we acquire on the basis of sense-experience, knowledge of the appearances of things, count as knowledge? 
 If so, then where the Aristotelians go wrong is not so much that their procedures do not get us knowledge, as that they have a restricted or incorrect notion of what knowledge actually is. 
 Of course, the same fault should then be laid at the sceptics' door. 
 In saying that our senses restrict us to appearances and that therefore we know nothing, they would mistakenly be supposing that knowledge is exclusively knowledge of necessary causes and inner natures. 
 They would have failed to recognize and acknowledge that what we have on the basis of sense-experience is worth having, and worthy of the name of knowledge. 
 Gassendi shows some tendency to endorse this line of thought. 
 He hints that it would be wrong to &bquo;persist in regarding knowledge as the certain and evident cognition of a thing, obtained through an acquaintance with its necessary cause, or by a proof&equo;, for then &bquo;knowledge through experience or appearances would not merit the name of knowledge&equo;. 
 Perhaps one should &bquo;allow that a certain knowledge derived from our experience of the appearances of things should be termed genuine knowledge&equo;. 
 He himself, he says, does &bquo;not belong to the party that would condemn the common and familiar ways of speaking&equo;, according to which we know many things at the level of appearances, such as that I am now seated rather than standing, and that fire appears hot rather than cold. 
 So, despite his presentation of sceptical arguments against knowledge of the nature of things, Gassendi does, nevertheless, hint that &bquo;it may well be that the basis for knowledge does exist&equo;; even though this will be &bquo;a knowledge of experience and, I may say, of appearances&equo;. 
 It can still be said, he suggests, &bquo;that there are some things capable of being known, though they are still not ones that can be known with an Aristotelian knowledge, but only experientially, or according to appearances&equo;. 
 There is a hint of something else, too, when he considers the suggestion that, even though the senses take us no further than appearances, perhaps the understanding can penetrate further to the inner natures of things. 
 Of course, he denies that it can. 
 But he expresses this by saying that we &bquo;can proceed no farther by reasoning than to things which must be exposed again to experience or which can be evidenced by means of some appearance&equo;; and this seems to suggest something new. 
 It seems to allow that, although we must begin and end with appearances, we might find it possible and advantageous in doing so to interpose conjectures about their hidden causes. 
 But, so far as the Exercises  goes, all of this is underplayed. 
 Gassendi does not develop the thought that &bquo;the labours of the most outstanding philosophers&hellip; need not be considered useless just because they have not produced an Aristotelian knowledge for us so far; for they have produced another sort which is more true and useful, namely knowledge from experience and the appearance of things.&equo; 
 Nor does he flesh out the suggestion of improving and extending our knowledge of appearances through the mediation of hypothetical conjectures about hidden causes, causes which are &bquo;evidenced&equo; by appearances. 
 We must turn to Gassendi's later work, the Syntagma Philosophicum  (&bquo;Philosophical Treatise&equo;) for a more confident development of these ideas. 
 The Syntagma  grew out of an interest Gassendi formed, not long after the publication of the Exercises , in the Greek philosopher Epicurus. 
 The Exercises  were ill-received, and Gassendi seems to have decided that he might make more headway against the Aristotelians by systematically presenting an alternative point of view, rather than by direct argument against them. 
 His initial intention was to publish something on Epicurus merely as an appendix to the Exercises . 
 But his interest grew as he worked, and he began to aim at a comprehensive expository commentary on Epicurus. 
 The eventual result was the posthumous publication, in 1658, of the Syntagma , which uses the medium of a commentary on Epicurus as a vehicle for an account of Gassendi's own thought. 
 For some centuries now an, &bquo;epicure&equo; has been someone overly devoted to sensual pleasure and luxury. 
 Epicurus did, indeed, place supreme value on &bquo;pleasure&equo;; but he thought of this as the calm tranquillity and freedom from anxiety which would be achieved by realizing that there is no life after death, and that we are not subject to outside divine influences. 
 Epicurus taught, therefore, a thoroughgoing materialism according to which our world is simply the chance production of atoms coming together in their fall through an infinite void. 
 There are gods, but they too are only material combinations of atoms, and our own consciousness ceases at death on the disintegration of our material bodies. 
 Such a picture &mdash; derived essentially from the earlier atomist Democritus &mdash; may seem bleak to some, but to Epicurus and his followers it was productive of the calm ataraxia  he valued. 
 Epicurus' influence on Gassendi relates to his taking pleasure and pain as the measure of what is good, and sense-experience as the criterion, or measure, of truth. 
 As for the first, it should be remembered that for an Epicurean the worst pain is the groundless fear of what may happen after death, and that excessive unnatural desires are painful too. 
 As for truth, Epicurus, rather like Hobbes centuries later, took sense-perception to be simply the effect of objects on our material souls. 
 Accordingly, our sensations simply are as they are, and error enters only when we make mistaken judgements on their basis. 
 A distant square tower really does look round; any mistake lies in judging that it is  round, and can be corrected by further sense-experience. 
 Not only did Gassendi take sense-experience to be the criterion or measure of truth, he also adopted Epicurus' atomistic view of the universe. 
 In studying Epicurus, Gassendi found confirmation for the embryonic idea of the Exercises , that sense-experience might give us something worthwhile and valuable even though it cannot give us knowledge of necessary causes and of the natures of things. 
 More and more, he saw importance in experience. 
 Perhaps it is not as useless as Aristotelian logic and can lead, if not to knowledge of necessary causes and natures, then to something worthwhile nevertheless. 
 This development in his thought coincided with an ever-increasing interest in detailed, experimental, physical matters. 
 Gassendi begins by addressing a question first raised by the Greek sceptics, as we saw in Chapter 1. 
 Is there such a thing as a &bquo;criterion&equo; of truth? 
 Do we have any &bquo;instrument&equo; or means of getting at the truth? 
 The traditional choice, which Gassendi outlines, was between the senses on the one hand, and the mind, understanding, or reason on the other. 
 Against their opponents, the dogmatics, the sceptics had argued, by means of their &bquo;tropes&equo; or &bquo;modes&equo;, that neither sense-experience nor intellectual thought can be a &bquo;criterion&equo; or &bquo;instrument&equo; of truth. 
 Though this, in effect, had been Gassendi's official position in the Exercises , he now hopes to find a way between the dogmatics and the sceptics. 
 He hopes to show that, although we cannot know quite what the former say we can, nevertheless we can still know more than the latter allow. 
 With this aim in view, he makes explicit that what the sceptics deny is the possibility of knowledge of &bquo;the inner nature of things&hellip; what the things are in themselves&equo;; when they say that there is no criterion of truth, &bquo;they are not speaking of what things appear to be and of what is revealed by the senses&hellip; but of what things are in themselves, which is so hidden that no criterion can disclose it&equo;. 
 Given this, we must recognize that knowledge of appearances is not, in itself, such a worthless thing; what we know on the basis of sense-experience is perfectly good for many purposes. 
 Even if we cannot get at &bquo;the truth itself&equo; and &bquo;be admitted into the very inner shrines of nature&equo;, we can at least &bquo;glimpse&hellip; some slight image of it&equo;, and &bquo;live among certain of the outer altars&equo;. 
 It is absurd to &bquo;yearn to fly like the birds&equo; when we have feet to get us where we want to go. 
 Furthermore, and perhaps more importantly from the point of view of answering the sceptics, even though we cannot directly get at the hidden real natures of things, perhaps our knowledge of appearances will enable us to do so indirectly. 
 &bquo;The truth in question is hidden, lying concealed beneath appearances; we must then inquire, since its nature is not open to us, whether it is still possible to know it through some sign and whether we have a criterion by which we may recognize the sign and judge what the thing truly is.&equo; 
 In his elaboration of this suggestion, whose seeds were already present in the Exercises , Gassendi draws on classical Greek thought, according to which there are three sorts of &bquo;hidden&equo; thing. 
 Some things, such as whether the number of stars is odd or even, are totally hidden; we shall never, could never, come to know the truth about that. 
 Others are merely temporarily hidden, such as whether there is fire behind a building which obstructs our line of sight; we could come to know about this by going to see. 
 But the notion of things which are naturally hidden is most important for Gassendi. 
 Unlike temporarily hidden things, these cannot &bquo;become evident by their own nature&equo;, but we can &bquo;nevertheless know and understand &lsqb;them&rsqb; through something else&equo;. 
 The pores in the skin are a classic example: they &bquo;cannot become perceptible to us by themselves, but yet their presence in the skin can be deduced from sweat&equo;. 
 The sceptics did not deny that by means of what was traditionally called an &bquo;empirical&equo; sign we might be led to indirect knowledge of something temporarily hidden: smoke from over the building is a sign that there is a fire behind. 
 What they did deny were &bquo;indicative&equo; signs, by which we could be led to indirect knowledge of something naturally hidden, such as pores in the skin. 
 Gassendi says they were simply wrong about this. 
 The existence of such pores is undoubtedly hidden from us, &bquo;for pores cannot be seen&equo;. 
 Nevertheless, &bquo;sweat is of such a nature that it would not appear upon the skin unless pores existed through which it could pass from inside to the outside&equo;. 
 There simply are such &bquo;indicative&equo; signs, and they are presented to us in sense-experience; on their basis we can reason to the hidden things which they &bquo;indicate&equo;. 
 What, then, of the arguments of the sceptics that we cannot claim knowledge about reality? 
 Gassendi accepts them, but draws their sting. 
 It is, indeed, true that all that is manifest to us is appearances. 
 However, such knowledge is, in itself, no useless thing. 
 Again, even though things do appear differently to different people, this is due to differences in the people, not to there being no reality behind the appearances. 
 It is the same heat in the sun that melts wax and hardens clay, and it is possible, perhaps by the use of indicative signs, to investigate the underlying causes of dissimilar effects. 
 If someone should succeed in doing this in some particular case, says Gassendi, 
 he will be considered to have nothing less than full acquaintance with the nature of the thing and to share in the knowledge of it. 
 For no matter how much it is objected that it cannot be stated definitely from these considerations just what the thing is like according to its nature, but only what it is like in respect to one thing or to another, it may still be said what there is in it which makes it appear to be this in respect to one thing and that in respect to another; and consequently it may be said both to be one thing according to its nature and to be this or that in respect to other things. 
 In general terms, Gassendi's notion of such &bquo;hidden things&equo; or &bquo;natures&equo; is entirely in accordance with tradition and the contemporary usage of his time. 
 It is &bquo;the underlying component of all properties, faculties, and operations&equo; of some thing. 
 It is the &bquo;underground spring, so to speak&equo; of the properties of a thing which are known to us by our senses. 
 According to the Aristotelians, the nature of a thing is, specifically, its &bquo;substantial form&equo; as explained in their hylemorphic theory. 
 As we saw earlier, in this and the first chapter, this theory holds that things are a combination of form and matter, and it is by appeal to their form that one would hope to explain why things have the properties they do. 
 Gassendi's suspicion of the Aristotelian account is evident from his Exercises , and his study of Epicurean philosophy provided him with an alternative. 
 The atomic theory suggests a different picture of the nature of matter, and a different form of explanation from that given by hylemorphism. 
 Gassendi adopted it enthusiastically and argued for it at great length. 
 According to it, the properties of things are to be explained and accounted for, not in terms of real definitions of their forms, but by reference to the atoms which make them up. 
 A thing's properties, and its actions and reactions on other things, are understood instead in terms of the shapes, sizes, motions, and consequent mechanical reactions of its atomic constitution and make-up. 
 Just as his theoretical awareness of the importance of sense-experience as a basis for science went along with an increasing interest in practical, experimental investigation of the world, so his theoretical advocacy of Epicurean atomism went along with his actual use of it in his own work; for example, in an account he gave of various optical phenomena produced by the sun. 
 Gassendi does not claim, of course, that it is any more than a hypothesis that the properties, changes, and actions of things are to be explained by reference to their atomic parts. 
 The idea that they are is not supported by our immediate experience. 
 But it is, he thinks, more plausible, intelligible, and fruitful than any other. 
 In this he had the agreement of the &bquo;new philosophers&equo; of his century. 
 The increasing popularity of a broadly corpuscularian or atomistic approach to explanation is largely due to Gassendi's endeavours on its behalf. 
 Despite its attractions as the basis for scientific explanation, classical atomism had the drawback of having its roots in Epicurus' materialistic atheism. 
 For this reason, the seventeenth century looked on it with varying degrees of embarrassed caution and suspicion. 
 As a Catholic priest, Gassendi believed in God and the immortality of an immaterial soul. 
 His adoption of classical atomism was, consequently, not a wholesale one, and he made various changes in its basic principles. 
 Rather than being eternal and having motion because of their fall through the void, the atoms are, for Gassendi, created and directed in their motion by God. 
 Finite in number, the limited material world they make up is not all there is, for, besides an infinite God, we have immaterial souls. 
 He was sympathetic to the Epicurean ideal of a tranquil mind. 
 He believed that the study of nature was conducive to this, but he rejected the connection of this ideal with atheism. 
 The fact that we could only hypothesize via &bquo;indicative&equo; signs about the natures of things should not lead to discontent. 
 There are things which God has not given us to know, and we must learn to accept this patiently. 
 Gassendi has argued that, despite what the sceptics say, it is possible, by inferring back, to arrive at some truth about hidden things. 
 It is, he says, the province of physics and the other sciences to seek the truth in their own areas. 
 But logic, which he defines as the &bquo;art of clear thinking&equo;, can provide &bquo;general precepts and rules, common to all branches of learning. 
 &bquo;Clear thinking&equo; falls into four parts, &bquo;forming clear ideas, stating propositions clearly, making clear deductions, organizing thought clearly.&equo; 
 We will not follow Gassendi in much of this, but it will be of interest to note what he says in so far as it relates to experience. 
 On the forming of clear ideas, Gassendi has some good words to say about Bacon. 
 He praises him for insisting that we free ourselves from the Idols, get rid of preconceived notions, and form our ideas on the basis of properly conducted experiments. 
 He praises him too for his advocacy of careful and methodical procedures based on careful consideration of individual cases. 
 Much of what Gassendi says about the acquisition and formation of ideas became commonplace among later empiricists, being developed by Locke in more detail and at much greater length. 
 &bquo;Every idea which is held in the mind takes its origin from the senses&hellip; &lsqb;it&rsqb; either comes through the senses, or is formed from those which come through the senses.&equo; 
 All our ideas are derived from experience, and he argues, against Descartes, that there are no innate ideas which are with us at birth. 
 A blind man lacks the ideas of colour because he lacks the requisite experience, and a man &bquo;deprived of every sense&hellip; would have no idea of a single thing&equo;. 
 But the acquisition of ideas from experience is not a straightforwardly passive matter. 
 We can have ideas of things we have not experienced. 
 We can form the idea of a golden mountain, or of a centaur, by combining and adapting others we already have from experience. 
 On the same basis, we can get ideas from descriptions given to us by others. 
 Similarly, although anything that exists is particular and individual, we can have general ideas. 
 On the basis of our ideas of particular men, we can form a general idea of &bquo;man&equo;, and by abstracting differences from the ideas of &bquo;man&equo;, &bquo;horse&equo;, and &bquo;lion&equo;, we can form still more general ideas, such as that of &bquo;animal&equo;. 
 The fourth part of Gassendi's Logic has to do with the organization of thought, or method . 
 In accordance with the traditional scheme, he distinguishes methods of investigation and discovery from methods of teaching, and refers to the old notions of analysis and resolution, composition and synthesis. 
 Discoveries need to be checked, of course, so Gassendi adds the method of judgement or assessment. 
 This too uses analysis and synthesis: analysis if the discovery to be checked has been made by synthesis, synthesis if it was made by analysis. 
 As he remarks, this is what we do in arithmetic when we check additions by subtraction, and vice versa. 
 Though Gassendi followed Epicurus in taking sense-experience as the criterion, or measure, of truth, and that on which our judgements should be based, he combines this criterion with its traditional rival, reason. 
 Though all our knowledge &bquo;is in the senses or derived from them&equo;, it is not always simply a matter of sensory information. 
 &bquo;The senses&hellip; ultimately provide the material&equo;, but reason, or &bquo;the innate force and power of the understanding&equo;, has its place too. 
 There are cases where the senses are sufficient. 
 As Gassendi insists in his Objections  to Descartes, there is no need forever to be distrustful of them. 
 Judgements based on the senses often are incorrect; but, as Epicurus noted, they can be corrected by further appeal to the same authority. 
 A tower may seem round from a distance, but there is no need to doubt our closer observation that it is square. 
 Sometimes, moreover, experience can show that our reasoning is superficial and incorrect, as when we learn from it that, despite what we might think, an arrow fired upwards from a moving ship will not fall behind but back on to it. 
 At other times, however, reason can correct the appearances of sense; from the waxing and waning of the moon, according to how it is illuminated by the sun, we can deduce that it is a globe, and not the flat disc it appears to be. 
 Furthermore, as when we infer from observed sweat the existence of pores in the skin, reason can lead us from what can be perceived to what cannot. 
 Gassendi's empiricist views on the derivation of our ideas from sense-experience, on natural philosophy and its foundation in carefully considered observation, and his stress on the explanatory value of Epicurean atomism, were already well known to Hobbes and others when they were formally introduced into England via the publication, in 1654, of Walter Charleton's Physiologia Epicuro-gassendo-Charltonia: a Fabrick of Science Natural upon the Hypothesis of Atoms, Founded by Epicurus, Repaired by Petrus Gassendus, Augmented by Walter Charleton . 
 Charleton was involved from its early days with the subject of the next chapter, The Royal Society of London for the Improving of Natural Knowledge. 
 The Royal Society of London for the Improving of Natural Knowledge (1660&ndash;) 
 In Chapter 1, and along the way, we have seen how a characteristic feature of seventeenth-century thought was its anti-Aristotelianism. 
 In general, the Aristotelians were thought to lay too much stress on words and books, terminology and merely verbal classifications, and debate and controversy, and too little on things and observation of the world. 
 More specifically, the scholastic conception of scientia , or scientific knowledge, was thought to be an inappropriate model for empirical knowledge of nature. 
 Particularly in connection with Bacon and Gassendi, we have seen how, in opposition to it, there began to develop a conception of &bquo;natural philosophy&equo;; a body of knowledge based firmly on the experienced facts of experiment and observation, rather than on the intellectual strait-jacket of the logic and categories of Aristotelianism. 
 It needs to be stressed, what this chapter may serve to illustrate, that developments of this sort should not simply be identified with a few individual thinkers. 
 Noteworthy individuals, such as Bacon, Hobbes, or Gassendi, are not isolated mountains in a flat desert landscape. 
 They have an influence on an intellectual scene which encompasses a whole host of lesser thinkers, and they act as focuses for movements of thought which find powerful expression in them before passing on, often changed, or with added force. 
 The anti-Aristotelianism and the newly emerging concept of natural philosophy were, then, not private but public developments. 
 So much is this the case that, in the mid-seventeenth century, they came together in a formally institutionalized way in the founding of the Royal Society of London for the Improving of Natural Knowledge. 
 This, along with parallel societies in other European countries, was a tangible and conspicuous product of the anti-traditionalism of the period. 
 Moreover, just as natural science as we know it today is, to an important extent, a product of seventeenth-century philosophical ideas, so one of the pillars of the orthodox scientific establishment in England now is the Royal Society. 
 To be elected a Fellow, or FRS, is a mark of the highest prestige. 
 The Royal Society had its early beginnings in informal meetings and discussion groups, and became properly institutionalized in the 1660s, shortly before receiving Charters from Charles II. 
 On the list of its early members are such notable names as Robert Boyle, popularly remembered now for his work on the expansion of gases, Christopher Wren, the architect of St Paul's Cathedral, John Evelyn, the diarist, John Locke (who will be the subject of the next chapter of this book), Robert Hooke, remembered now for his work on elasticity, and, perhaps the most famous of all, Isaac Newton. 
 Not long after its foundation, Thomas Sprat was commissioned to write the Society's History . 
 The prefatory ode, by the poet Abraham Cowley, relates how philosophy has been &bquo;kept in nonage&equo; by people who, jealous of their authority, concentrated on words rather than on things, on &bquo;sports of wanton wit&equo;, on &bquo;pageants of the brain &bquo;, rather than on &bquo;the riches which do hoorded lye in Natures endless treasurie&equo;. 
 Throughout the History , and other writings of the period, are scathing references to traditional teaching, in particular to that of the Aristotelians. 
 The very motto of the Society, &bquo; Nullius in Verba &equo; (&equo; In the words of no one else'), encapsulates this general rejection of the authority of the past. 
 Even if they were sufficiently eminent, not all of the members of the Royal Society would have a place in the History of Science as we might think of it now. 
 There was no expectation then, as there is now, that an FRS would have made any distinctive and weighty contribution to the experimental or theoretical sciences. 
 It has been estimated that, in its early days, only about one third of Royal Society Fellows were scientists. 
 The interest of the rest of the &bquo;virtuosi&equo; (as they were known) was a more general one in the &bquo;new philosophy&equo; and its aims; for the fact is that the Royal Society provided a focus for a whole movement of thought. 
 Though modern empirical experimental science is one of the more obvious products of that movement, the Society was not narrowly restricted to science in any modern sense. 
 It was more broadly philosophical, and encapsulated a generalized dissatisfaction with scholasticism and tradition. 
 It must be realized, moreover, that there is a hidden complexity to the apparently simple fact that the natural science of later centuries is a product of that time. 
 It is not as though there always was a clear conception of what such a science would be like, and as though all that was lacking was success in producing it. 
 It is, rather, that the very idea of a body of knowledge about the world, of the sort we have now, the very idea of a natural science, was being forged at the time. 
 As we have seen, scientia , or scientific knowledge as the seventeenth century understood it, was not something which could be obtained from an observation-based study of the natural world. 
 Even when such a study became established, with worked-out conceptual underpinning, it was not called &bquo;natural science&equo;, but &bquo;natural philosophy&equo;. 
 Science, as the seventeenth century traditionally understood it, was not something that could result from activities of the sort advocated by the Royal Society. 
 This meant that the new &bquo;natural philosophy&equo; stood in need, not merely of practical development, but also of intellectual justification and explanation. 
 Not merely science, but also the idea  of science, was at issue. 
 It is, of course, precisely the concern with such matters, the concern with &bquo;method&equo; and the nature of &bquo;natural philosophy&equo; that has often been the topic of discussion in previous chapters. 
 The frontispiece of Sprat's History  shows a spacious study lined with books and scientific instruments. 
 Beyond can be seen the outside world of &bquo;Natures endless treasurie&equo;, with a telescope trained on the heavens. 
 In the room, Fame places a wreath on a bust of Charles II, which is flanked by two people. 
 One is Lord Brounker, then President of the Society. 
 The other is Francis Bacon, with the title &bquo; Artium Instaurator &equo; (&bquo;Instigator of Skills&equo;). 
 One could imagine the room to be one in Bacon's House of Solomon, about which Joseph Glanvill remarked that it was &bquo;a prophetic scheme of the Royal Society&equo;. 
 The influence of Bacon on the Royal Society is frequently testified to by its members. 
 Sprat says that he &bquo;had the true imagination of the whole extent of this enterprise, as it is now set on foot&equo;. 
 We should take this to refer not only to Bacon's schemes for collaboration in natural philosophy, schemes actually embodied in the existence of the Royal Society, but also to his very conception of that subject. 
 Abraham Cowley compares Bacon to Moses, leading the way through a barren wilderness bereft of knowledge, and pointing out the promised land. 
 In Bacon's books, Sprat says, &bquo;are every where scattered the best arguments, that can be produced for the defence of Experimental Philosophy; and the best directions, that are needful to promote it&equo;, while according to Glanvill &bquo;all the main heads of natural history have received aids and increase from the famous Bacon, who led the way to substantial wisdom, and hath given most excellent directions for the method of such an history of nature&equo;. 
 Boyle refers to him again and again, &bquo;one of the first and greatest experimental philosophers of our age&equo;. 
 According to Sprat, then, and others of the Society, knowledge was to be had by turning away from the teachings of the scholastics, from their undue concentration on words, to the world itself. 
 This meant, first and foremost, following Bacon in the making of natural histories. 
 They were to be the basis of a new natural philosophy, and were advocated both by practising experimenters and by theoreticians. 
 Robert Hooke urges in his Micrographia  that &bquo;the science of nature has already too long been made only a work of the brain and fancy: It is now high time that it should return to the plainness and soundness of observations on material and obvious things.&equo; 
 Henry Power speaks of the need to &bquo;lay a new foundation of a more magnificent philosophy&hellip; that will empirically and sensibly canvass the phenomena of nature&equo;. 
 Glanvill says that one of the more important ways of advancing knowledge is &bquo;by enlarging the history of things&equo;, for such a natural history is &bquo;fundamentally necessary to all the designs of science&equo;. 
 Sprat tells us that in pursuit of Bacon's aim of making &bquo;faithful records, of all the works of nature or art, which can come within&hellip; reach&equo;, the Royal Society sent out, world-wide, letters and questionnaires on all conceivable topics, discussing and debating the replies at their meetings. 
 The compilation of natural histories was only one part of Bacon's method. 
 It was, similarly, only one strand in the ideas of many in the Royal Society. 
 In general, however, it was not the second part of Bacon's Inductive Method that found favour. 
 We have already seen that Hobbes and Gassendi diverged from Bacon's belief that the scrutiny of natural histories would enable one to reach certainty about the causes of things, and thought that one could produce conjectures and hypotheses at best. 
 For Hobbes, such hypotheses were in terms of his &bquo;indefinite&equo; science based on the idea of matter in motion; for Gassendi, they were in terms of the Epicurean atomic or corpuscular theory which he adopted and developed. 
 It was these ideas that found favour with the Royal Society. 
 It was the belief of many of its members that if explanations and theories were to be given for the facts collected in their natural histories, they were to be given in mechanical terms, specifically in terms of the corpuscular theory. 
 This comes out notably in the case of Robert Boyle, for he, more than most, defended, explained, and provided experimental illustrations for the corpuscular hypothesis. 
 His Origin of Forms and Qualities according to the Corpuscular Philosophy  (1666) is a masterpiece of criticism of the Aristotelians' substantial forms, a detailed classic exposition of the corpuscular theory he wishes to put in their place, and, finally, a compendium of experiments and results, all explained and analysed in corpuscularian terms. 
 The works of the &bquo;new philosophers&equo; of the seventeenth century give the impression of confident invulnerability. 
 Particularly in their polemical passages they have a freshness and directness, such assurance that the world is now their  oyster, that it is easy to forget that they did not go uncriticized. 
 But criticisms there were. 
 For example, Meric Casaubon, a prolific classical scholar, made out a good case for supposing there to be much of human value in the tradition he wished to defend. 
 He objected to the stress the virtuosi laid on observation and experiment, on the grounds that it was likely to lead to atheism. 
 &bquo;Men that are much fixed upon matter&hellip; may&hellip; forget that there be such things in the world as Spirits&hellip; and at last that there is a God, and that their souls are immortal.&equo; 
 He advocated &bquo;Notional&equo; studies which, having &bquo;nothing to do with the senses&equo;, are &bquo;therefore more divine&equo;. 
 He suggested, also, that an undue concentration on the new natural philosophy might lead to a certain intellectual arrogance. 
 &bquo;May not a man go too far in this study, and overvalue his progress so far, as to think nothing out of his reach?&equo; 
 So far as Gassendi and (as we shall see) Locke were concerned this objection is misplaced for, having a modest and moral view of our proper concerns, they retain an element of scepticism about man's ability to know. 
 But Casaubon is not without insight in his idea that the committed experimental philosopher may come to think that all areas of human concern and experience are legitimate grist to his mill. 
 In illustration of the absurdity of this &bquo;scientific&equo; arrogance, and teaching a lesson which is just as applicable today, he appeals to a story Gassendi told about a friend who watched a fight between a louse and a flea through a microscope. 
 The man claimed to have learnt self-control, temperance, and forbearance from his observations, and to have &bquo;profited more to rule his passions in the rest of his life, than he had done by any thing that he had heard, or read before&equo;. 
 Casaubon ridicules the idea that the straightforward collection of factual data about fleas and lice can provide the moral and civilizing education of the sort given by a study of the wise and sensitive works of humane literature. 
 He sarcastically suggests that the story was probably invented &bquo;to gratify some friends, who would be glad to hear what use can be made, even in point of life and manners, of a microscope&equo;. 
 Casaubon was not alone in his criticisms of the new experimental philosophy for its atheistical tendencies. 
 The claim that its concentration on things material meant a neglect, or even a denial, of things spiritual, a forgetfulness of God, was a common one. 
 According to Richard Baxter, for example, it led to the arrogance of &bquo;idle boys who tear out all the hard leaves of their books and say they have learned all when they have learned the rest&equo;. 
 The new philosophers &bquo;cut off and deny the noblest parts of nature and then sweep together the dust of agitated atoms and tell us that they have resolved all the phenomena in nature&equo;. 
 It was, moreover, an accusation to which its adherents in the Royal Society were extremely sensitive. 
 Though Hobbes had already made enemies of John Wallis and Seth Ward, two of its founder members, over his claim to have solved the geometrical problem of squaring the circle, it was at least partly due to his association in the popular mind with a materialistic atheism that he never became a Fellow. 
 Indeed, &bquo;the weightiest, and most solemn part&equo; of Sprat's History  is &bquo;to make a defence of the Royal Society, and this new experimental learning, in respect of the Christian Faith&equo;. 
 A common defence, and one for which Robert Boyle is prominent, was to develop the idea that, since the natural world is God's creation, the study of it leads towards, not away from, things spiritual. 
 &bquo;The knowledge of the works of God proportions our admiration of them, they participating and disclosing so much of the inexhausted perfections of their author, that the further we contemplate them, the more footsteps and impressions we discover of the perfections of their Creator.&equo; 
 It is interesting to note, moreover, that Locke, Boyle, and, particularly, Glanvill, all cite witchcraft as an observable phenomenon which directly shows the existence of a spiritual realm. 
 Though their general concentration on observation of the material world was thought to encourage atheism, it was the new philosophers' revival of Epicurus' atomistic conception of the world which particularly aroused criticism. 
 Despite the fact that Gassendi and Boyle took care to find a place for God and the soul in their revivals of the theory, its adherents had perpetually to struggle against the undeniable fact that Epicurus had introduced it as a foundation for his explicit materialistic atheism. 
 One early member of the Royal Society was John Locke, who was elected in 1668. 
 Though Locke did go in for some experimental work, his main contribution to the ethos of the Society was to do what Bacon had quite failed to do. 
 He provided a theoretical justification for the method of collecting natural histories. 
 More generally, he gives a lengthy defence and articulation of the idea that knowledge is ultimately dependent on the senses. 
 For this reason, Locke is often called the father of modern empiricism. 
 John Locke (1632&ndash;1704) 
 The son of a lawyer and stern Puritan Parliamentarian, John Locke was born in Somerset in 1632, and died in Essex in 1704. 
 He was educated at Westminster School and Christ Church, Oxford, where he studied, and later taught, subjects such as logic, moral philosophy, rhetoric, and Greek. 
 He was interested in medicine too, and it was as medical adviser that, in 1666, he entered the service of Lord Ashley, later the Lord Chancellor and Earl of Shaftesbury. 
 These academic and scientific interests did not fully occupy him. 
 He also became involved in Protestant politics as secretary to Shaftesbury who, in the early 1680s, took part in the attempt to exclude James, the Catholic Duke of York, from succeeding to the throne of his brother Charles II. 
 From 1675 to 1679 Locke travelled and studied in France; and from 1683 to 1689 he was in exile in Holland, his political views and associations having made it necessary for him to flee England. 
 He returned after the &bquo;Glorious Revolution&equo;, which replaced James II by the Protestant William of Orange. 
 He then began a period in which he combined private study and writing with public service as Commissioner of Appeals and of the Board of Trade and Plantations. 
 Locke wrote and published on a considerable variety of topics: not only on various branches of philosophy, but also on education, economics, theology, and medicine. 
 He is famous mainly for An Essay Concerning Human Understanding  (1690) and his Two Treatises of Government  (1690). 
 But his Letters concerning Toleration  (1689&ndash;92), Some Thoughts concerning Education  (1693), and The Reasonableness of Christianity  (1695) are important too. 
 Though it did not appear until relatively late in his life, Locke had been working on the Essay  since about 1660. 
 As he explains in the &bquo;Epistle to the Reader&equo;, he began it after a discussion in which it occurred to him and his friends that they might get further with the problems which concerned them if they were first to &bquo;examine our own abilities, and see, what objects our understandings were, or were not fitted to deal with&equo;. 
 The eventual result of this examination was the Essay , whose explicit aim is to &bquo;enquire into the origin, certainty, and extent of human knowledge; together, with the grounds and degrees of belief, opinion, and assent&equo;. 
 According to one of its members, James Tyrrell, the group had been concerned with the &bquo;principles of morality and revealed religion&equo;. 
 Presumably they were asking how the principles of morality are discovered and known to be true, and discussing the role of revelation as a source and foundation of morality and religion. 
 This would certainly explain how they came to feel the need to have some wider understanding of how, and to what extent, we can acquire knowledge of any sort. 
 Locke's particular interest in religious and moral knowledge, and his more general interest in knowledge as such, falls in with the widespread concern with such matters which was consequent on the sixteenth-century rediscovery of ancient Greek scepticism. 
 He speaks of a kind of intellectual pessimism, a &bquo;despair of knowing anything&equo;, into which it is possible to fall after repeated failures in the search for knowledge. 
 Men often &bquo;raise questions, and multiply disputes, which never coming to any clear resolution, are proper only to continue and increase their doubts, and to confirm them at last in perfect scepticism&equo;. 
 Given the arguments of the sceptics, such failures are only to be expected of course; aiming to replace anxious intellectual despair with a calm peace of mind, the traditional Pyrrhonian response would have been to advocate suspension of judgement. 
 Like Bacon and Hobbes, whose forthright reactions are that what is really needed is simply the adoption of a correct method, Locke does not immediately follow this traditional course; but he advances the more circumspect suggestion that we should first stand back and investigate our capacity for knowledge. 
 We should see if there is a &bquo;horizon&hellip; between what is, and what is not comprehensible by us&equo;. 
 If we find that human faculties and understandings are such that knowledge is necessarily limited, we might more easily and &bquo;with less scruple acquiesce in the avowed ignorance&equo; of what lies beyond the horizon, and &bquo;employ &lsqb;our&rsqb;&hellip; thoughts and discourse, with more advantage and satisfaction&equo; about what lies within our reach. 
 Some such open acceptance of our intellectual limitations would not be unrelated to Pyrrhonian ataraxia  or peace of mind; but although Locke does, indeed, conclude that the truth often outruns our ability to know it, he certainly does not accept that nothing  can be known. 
 Although he does not adopt the frontal assault of Bacon on the &bquo;perfect darkness&equo; of a despairing scepticism, and eventually advocates a patient acceptance of our limitations, these limitations are, for him, not complete. 
 He concludes that, although there are indeed some things we cannot and would be immodest to hope to know, there are others that we can know. 
 Moreover, what we can know, such as our duties and obligations to each other and to God, is just what we need to know; and in many other cases we have beliefs sufficiently well-founded for the purposes of our everyday life. 
 &bquo;Men have reason to be well satisfied with what God hath thought fit for them, since he has given them&hellip; whatsoever is necessary for the conveniences of life, and information of virtue.&equo; 
 Gassendi had suggested that it shows improper pride for a person who has feet to take him where he wants to go to &bquo;yearn to fly like the birds&equo;. 
 Using this very image, Locke dwells on the thought at greater length, and provides a sharp contrast to the opinion of our own day, that unlimited scientific research is a valuable end in itself which needs no justification. 
 He stresses that &bquo;our business here is not to know all things, but those which concern our conduct&equo;. 
 Against this background Locke begins his inquiry into the origin and extent of knowledge. 
 Noting that we do have many ideas and beliefs, he asks what is perhaps the most basic question of epistemology: &bquo;How comes&hellip; &lsqb;the mind&rsqb; to be furnished? 
 Whence comes it by that vast store of &lsqb;ideas&rsqb;?&hellip; 
 Whence has it all the materials of&hellip; knowledge?&equo; 
 His answer is ringingly clear, and firmly places him as an empiricist. 
 &bquo;I answer, in one word, from Experience : in that, all our knowledge is founded; and from that it ultimately derives itself.&equo; 
 This answer is worked out in detail as the Essay  proceeds, but it is important at the outset to see what it amounts to. 
 We can do this by considering the reply Locke makes, in an early draft of the Essay , to an objection which he might seem to invite. 
 The objection is that much of what we know could not have been learnt on the basis of experience. 
 We know that all numbers are either even or odd, and that a whole is equal to the sum of its parts. 
 But we surely do not know these on the basis of experience. 
 As Henry Lee, one of Locke's critics, put it, such 
 general  propositions&hellip; &lsqb;are&rsqb; certainly true&hellip; yet we can come to no knowledge of them merely  by our senses; because they  cannot reach to all the particulars included in the subjects of them. 
 Our senses  may inform us that any single  whole is equal to all  its parts; but not that all wholes in the world are so, unless we could suppose, that we had seen or felt them all. 
 For this reason, many in the seventeenth century would have said that such knowledge, together with knowledge of undoubted moral principles, such as that promises should be kept, is innate. 
 It cannot be learnt from experience, and so must be something with which we are innately endowed. 
 Locke obviously recognized the implausibility of supposing that experience gives us these pieces of knowledge; experience cannot account for their certain applicability to all  wholes, all  numbers, or all  promises. 
 But his response is to reject the dichotomy which the objection presupposes: that such knowledge is either learnt from experience, or is innate. 
 He reiterates that all knowledge is &bquo;ultimately&equo; derived from the senses, but explains that this does not mean that it directly comes from it. 
 What experience initially and directly provides is not fully fledged knowledge itself, but &bquo;the materials of knowledge&equo;, what he calls &bquo;ideas&equo;. 
 Our knowledge that all wholes are equal to the sum of their parts, or that any number is either even or odd, presupposes, or is expressed in terms of, the ideas of &bquo;whole&equo;, &bquo;part&equo;, &bquo;number&equo;, &bquo;evenness&equo;, and &bquo;oddness&equo;. 
 It is these ideas  that come from experience. 
 Once we have them, our reason considers them and we come to see that wholes are equal to the sum of their parts, or that all numbers are even or odd. 
 It is not part of Locke's empiricism that we know these things by observation and experience. 
 What experience gives us is not knowledge itself, but the ideas which form the material basis for knowledge. 
 This means that Locke has not only to substantiate the claim that all ideas are derived from experience, but also to explain how it is that our reason gets from those ideas to certain items of knowledge which others said were innate. 
 Not everyone recognized this second requirement. 
 Like Locke, Samuel Parker rejected innate knowledge. 
 He objected (and Locke would have agreed), that since truths such as that any number is even or odd are quite obvious and self-evident, it would be pointless for God to have imprinted them on our minds. 
 But, unlike Locke, Parker omitted to account for this self-evidence, and so laid himself open to the objection of James Lowde, a defender of innateness, that such truths would not have been self-evident were they not innate. 
 It is precisely because they are innate, Lowde said, that they are obvious and self-evident to us. 
 These truths &bquo;owe their clearness and evidence to their being thus imprinted. 
 &hellip; The needlessness of imprinting such evident notions cannot be argued from their present clearness; because it is their being thus imprinted or thus connatural to our minds that makes them so.&equo; 
 The bulk of Book 1 of the Essay  consists of arguments against innateness. 
 It is often thought that these are supported by the arguments in Book 2 for the view that all ideas, the materials of knowledge, come from experience. 
 But Locke's real target in Book 1 is not innateness of ideas, but innateness of knowledge. 
 His arguments against innateness have their complement, not in Book 2, but in Book 4, where he explains how we come to have knowledge by reasoning about our ideas. 
 It is true that sometimes he does attack innate ideas; but this is merely an indirect strategy. 
 Since no knowledge could be innate unless its materials or constituent ideas were, any argument against innate ideas is, in effect, an argument against innate knowledge. 
 The innately known truths which some people postulated were not all of a piece. 
 They were all &bquo;obvious&equo; truths; but some were non-evaluative propositions, such as that wholes equal the sum of their parts, while others were various principles of morality. 
 Locke's motives for rejecting them, accordingly, vary from case to case. 
 His worry about the &bquo;practical&equo; principles of morality is that the doctrine of their innateness prevents people working them out for themselves. 
 Mistakenly supposing that their moral beliefs are innately given, people are liable to continue to accept what they have been taught as young children. 
 As for abstract &bquo;speculative&equo; principles, Locke's attacks on them stem partly from his dissatisfaction with scholasticism. 
 &bquo;Axioms&equo; or &bquo;maxims&equo;, such as that wholes equal the sum of their parts, were among the premisses of the demonstrative syllogisms of the doctrine of scientia , and some seventeenth-century developments of the doctrine said that they were innate. 
 His motives aside, Locke's actual arguments against the doctrine of innate knowledge tend not to show it false, but only unnecessary, or lacking sound support. 
 For one thing, all knowledge is explicable on the basis of the abilities we have to find it for ourselves. 
 For another, there are, in fact, no propositions with a universal acceptance, and therefore none which need to be explained by supposing them to be innate. 
 He does not, however, make the powerful point which had some currency at the time, that even were there universally accepted beliefs which were innate, this would not make them true, and so something we knew . 
 Believing our intellectual abilities to be God-given, he presumably thought that, had they not been sufficient for our needs, God would not have supplemented them by innately endowing us with anything other than truth. 
 Locke's claim that prior to experience the mind is &bquo;white paper, void of all characters&equo;, and that all its ideas, the materials of knowledge, come from that source, had been made earlier by Gassendi, but he defends and explains it at much greater length. 
 &bquo;Experience&equo; is, in fact, a dual source of ideas. 
 Some ideas come from &bquo;sensation&equo;, from our sensory interaction with the world. 
 &bquo;Our senses&hellip; do convey into the mind, several distinct perceptions of things&hellip; and thus we come by those ideas we have of yellow, white, &lsqb;etc.&rsqb;&equo; 
 Others, such as the ideas of perceiving, willing, and doubting, come from &bquo;reflection&equo;, from our &bquo;perception of the operations of our own minds&hellip; as it is employed about the ideas it has got &lsqb;from sensation&rsqb;&equo;. 
 But all the contents of our thought, however abstract and removed from experience they may be, have their source there. 
 All those sublime thoughts, which tower above the clouds, and reach as high as Heaven itself, take their rise and footing here: in all that great extent wherein the mind wanders, in those remote speculations it may seem to be elevated with, it stirs not one jot beyond those ideas, which Sense  or Reflection , have offered. 
 Locke's contemporaries often criticized his continual talk of &bquo;ideas&equo;, for which he apologized. 
 &bquo;Ideas&equo; have played a part in philosophy at least as far back as Plato, for whom they had a reality of their own quite apart from any relation they might have to our minds. 
 For Locke, however, they are &bquo;whatsoever is the object of the understanding when a man thinks&equo;; and his conception of them as essentially mind-dependent things is derived from Descartes. 
 According to this conception, ideas may be internal sensations like pain; they may be perceptions of external objects and their qualities. 
 They can be the medium of memory and imagination; they can figure in thinking, and in the understanding of language. 
 Locke was not much interested in their exact nature: are they mental states or modifications, like waves in the sea, or mental entities in their own right, like flotsam on it? 
 He thought that the answer to such questions was of little consequence for what he wanted to say. 
 It is plausible to say that our ideas of various colours, of various material things such as gold or sheep, or of processes and activities such as dancing and wrestling, derive from experience. 
 But what of the ideas we have of a centaur, of God, of infinity, or of an as yet unbuilt house? 
 We have had no experience of the objects of these ideas. 
 Locke's distinction between complex  ideas, and the simple  ideas which are their component parts, copes with this. 
 For simple ideas we are certainly directly beholden to experience. 
 But though the parts of a complex idea must, in some way, have come from experience, the complexes themselves need not have, for we can construct them from their parts. 
 This appeal to the idea of analysing complex mental thoughts into constituent simples was made earlier by Gassendi, and also carried on by philosophers in later centuries. 
 Locke does not mean, though, that ideas are necessarily received in their simplicity : complexes can be got directly from experience, and do not always actually have to be built up from experienced simples. 
 Indeed, he may not mean that they ever are received in their simplicity. 
 Sometimes he implies that they can be, but at other times he speaks as though they are always &bquo;observed to exist in several combinations&equo;. 
 In this latter case we get to simples by a process of &bquo;Abstraction&equo;. 
 Locke aims to defend his view that all our ideas derive from experience by consideration of cases such as &bquo;Space, Time, and Infinity, and some few others&equo;. 
 Besides being good test cases, Locke obviously finds these ideas intrinsically interesting too. 
 One thing that appears in his discussion of them is a preparedness to say that a &bquo;simple&equo; idea may not be absolutely, and in all contexts, simple. 
 Evidently he thinks of the distinction as being no more than a useful device for developing and explaining his claim, that all ideas derive from experience. 
 We have seen that Locke agrees that some things which we know, such as that all numbers are even or odd, could not be learnt directly from experience, and that he explains that he never meant otherwise, for what experience gives us is not knowledge itself, but its materials in the form of ideas. 
 But we have also seen that he denies that such knowledge is innate and that its self-evidence arises from its being imprinted on our minds prior to all experience. 
 What then does  he think? 
 How does  knowledge arise? 
 Knowledge, Locke says, is &bquo;the perception of the connection and agreement, or disagreement and repugnancy of any of our ideas&equo;. 
 Certain propositions are true because the relevant ideas are connected and related to each other in such a way as to make them true. 
 Any number is even or odd by virtue of there being a connection between the idea of &bquo;number&equo; and those of &bquo;evenness&equo; or &bquo;oddness&equo;. 
 It is by &bquo;perceiving&equo; these relations between ideas that we come to have knowledge. 
 As Locke says, &bquo;in some of our ideas there are certain relations, habitudes and connections, so visibly included in the nature of the ideas themselves, that we cannot conceive them separable from them, by any power whatsoever&equo;. 
 Many of us know that the three angles of a triangle add up to two right angles, and we know it because we &bquo;perceive that equality to two right ones, does necessarily agree to, and is inseparable from the three angles of a triangle&equo;. 
 Sometimes the perception of connection between two ideas is direct, we perceive it &bquo;immediately&hellip; without the intervention of any other&equo;. 
 This gives us &bquo;intuitive&equo; knowledge, as when we see immediately that two and one are three. 
 At other times a connection can be perceived only indirectly via the medium of other connections and ideas. 
 Our knowledge of the angles of a triangle is of this &bquo;demonstrative&equo; sort, since here one has to &bquo;find out some other angles, to which the three angles of a triangle have an equality; and finding those equal to two right ones, &lsqb;one&rsqb; comes to know their equality to two right ones&equo;. 
 Where either intellectual incapacity or lack of any actual connection means that we can neither intuitively nor demonstratively perceive a connection, then, &bquo;though we may fancy, guess, or believe, yet we always come short of knowledge&equo;. 
 This account of knowledge seems to disqualify much that we might ordinarily count as such. 
 It is plausible to see our geometrical knowledge as based on &bquo;perception&equo; of connections between various ideas. 
 But what of the knowledge that iron rusts when left out in the rain? 
 What of the knowledge that gold is malleable, and pencil lead not? 
 This surely is based on observation, experience, and informal experiment, not on intellectual perception of any connection between ideas. 
 Doesn't Locke &bquo;s definition rule it out from being knowledge at all? 
 Indeed it does, and Locke recognizes such cases where, because there is &bquo;a want of a discoverable connection  between those ideas which we have&hellip; we are&hellip; left only to observation and experiment&equo;. 
 He explicitly says they do not constitute &bquo;knowledge&equo; but what he calls &bquo;belief&equo; or &bquo;opinion&equo;. 
 &equo; Demonstrative' and &bquo;intuitive&equo; knowledge, acquired by perceiving connections between ideas, is &bquo;certain and universal&equo;. 
 When we rationally see a connection between being a triangle, and having angles equal to two right angles, we see that all  triangles must  have angles like that. 
 We cannot &bquo;conceive&hellip; &lsqb;the connection&rsqb; separable from the ideas&equo;. 
 On the other hand, when we can intellectually see no connection between, for example, being gold and being malleable (when we have learnt of this property of gold only from experience), we do not know that gold must  be malleable. 
 We may &bquo;believe&equo;, or be of the &bquo;opinion&equo;, that it is universally and certainly true that it is; but, in relying on experience and observation, we do not &bquo;know&equo;. 
 Locke's distinction between &bquo;knowledge&equo; and &bquo;belief&equo; or &bquo;opinion&equo; has, in effect, been acknowledged by later philosophers. 
 Though they more usually refer to a later distinction of Hume's, between &bquo;relations of ideas&equo; and &bquo;matters of fact&equo;, recent philosophers have commonly distinguished cases where we proceed, in Locke's words, by &bquo;the contemplation of our own abstract ideas&equo; from those where, because there is no &bquo;discoverable connection&equo; between our ideas, we have to fall back on observation and experiment. 
 They have tended, however, to treat this as a distinction between two sorts of knowledge , rather than between knowledge and something else. 
 What Locke calls &bquo;knowledge&equo; they have called &bquo;a priori knowledge&equo;; what he calls &bquo;opinion&equo; or &bquo;belief&equo; they have called &bquo;a posteriori&equo; or &bquo;empirical knowledge&equo;. 
 Locke's distinction can be related to earlier ones too. 
 It echoes Gassendi's distinction between knowledge of natures and necessary causes, on the one hand, and the experience- and observation-based knowledge of appearances, on the other; it echoes Hobbes's between philosophical knowledge or knowledge based on &bquo;true ratiocination&equo;, and what he calls &bquo;experience&equo;. 
 At various points it is also related to the scholastic distinction between knowledge and opinion. 
 This last comparison is worth elaborating. 
 Just as, for the Aristotelians, knowledge or scientia  has to do with necessities, with what must be so and cannot be otherwise, so, for Locke, &bquo;knowledge&equo; is universal and certain. 
 This is not to say that Locke accepts all the details of the scholastic account of scientia  any more than Gassendi did. 
 He does not think that knowledge is acquired by demonstrative syllogisms which have maxims and definitions for premisses; in many places in the Essay  he criticizes various parts of this view. 
 The relationship between the Aristotelians and Locke on &bquo;opinion&equo; is less straightforward. 
 Unlike scientia , the pursuit of which was the proper use of man's reason, mere opinion was traditionally supposed to be not worthy, or even capable, of systematic attention; the very word &bquo;system&equo; was out of place with it. 
 Like Gassendi, however, Locke thinks &bquo;opinion&equo; worth having and searching after. 
 Observation and experiment in order to discover the properties of things in the material world is a worthwhile activity; so much so that Locke sometimes honours its results with the more dignified term &bquo;experimental knowledge&equo;. 
 In effect, he thinks that there can be a system or body of &bquo;opinion&equo;; this, after all, is what the new &bquo;natural philosophy&equo; is. 
 But despite the transitional talk of &bquo;experimental knowledge&equo;, Locke insists that &bquo;natural philosophy is not capable of being made a science&equo;. 
 &bquo;Natural philosophy&equo; does not consist of &bquo;knowledge&equo;, which arises from perception of connections between ideas, but of &bquo;opinion&equo;; and Locke still associates the word &bquo;science&equo; with scientia  and &bquo;knowledge&equo; proper. 
 To this extent, Locke agrees with the scholastic, Thomas Sergeant, that &bquo;the way of experiments cannot be a true method to science&equo;. 
 But, even if not properly speaking a science, it is still worthy of systematic pursuit. 
 The idea of a systematic and serious, observationally and experientially based study of nature, called &bquo;natural philosophy&equo;, was one which Locke shared with others of course, and in particular with his colleagues in the Royal Society. 
 It goes along with the common complaint that there are areas and methods of serious investigation which are just not touched by scholastic doctrines. 
 A further complexity in the comparison between Locke and the Aristotelians is that their &bquo;opinion&equo; concerns contingencies, things which are so, but which might have been otherwise. 
 At first sight this may seem so for Locke too. 
 He denies that we know  that gold is malleable, because for us there is no &bquo;universal certainty&equo; about it. 
 Unless we make it trivially true that gold is malleable, by explicitly including malleability in our idea of it, we can perceive no connection between the ideas of gold and malleability; our observation and experiment do not tell us that gold must  be malleable; we have no knowledge  that it is. 
 But the fact that we  can perceive no connection does not, for Locke, mean that there may not be one there. 
 So, while for the scholastic tradition &bquo;opinion&equo; concerns contingencies, for Locke it concerns what seem  like contingencies to us, but what, in reality, may be universal certainties. 
 He explains this important possibility, of there being connections which we cannot perceive, in terms of features of various sorts of complex idea. 
 The distinctions between kinds of complex idea are considered at some length in the Essay . 
 Having divided ideas into simple and complex, he introduces three sorts of complex idea: &bquo;modes&equo;, &bquo;substances&equo;, and &bquo;relations&equo;. 
 He does not say a lot about relations, and often treats them along with modes. 
 They concern &bquo;comparing&equo; or &bquo;referring&equo; one thing with, or to, another. 
 The property of being whiter is an obvious example, for one thing is compared with another when we say it is whiter than the other. 
 They also concern the mind being &bquo;led&equo; from one thing &bquo;to something beyond&equo;. 
 When Caius is mentioned as being a husband, our minds are led to a woman whose husband he is. 
 Much more is said about &bquo;substances&equo; and &bquo;modes&equo;, and the distinction between them is important in Locke &bquo;s theory of knowledge. 
 The ideas of &bquo;triangle&equo; and &bquo;gratitude&equo; are modes, those of &bquo;gold&equo; and of &bquo;man&equo; are substances. 
 Their &bquo;complexity&equo; is relatively straightforward. 
 The idea of a triangle is made up from the ideas of being a closed figure, and having three straight sides; the idea of gold from those of yellowness, malleability, and fusibility. 
 But why is one a &bquo;mode&equo;, and the other a &bquo;substance&equo;? 
 &equo; Substances' are ideas of &bquo;things subsisting by themselves&equo;. 
 It is plain from Locke's examples that they (or, strictly, the things of which they are ideas) are naturally occurring kinds of material thing or stuff. 
 They are, in fact, just the kind of thing the natural philosopher might be interested in. 
 Like both the Aristotelians and Gassendi, Locke talks of their &bquo;natures&equo; or &bquo;essences&equo;, but in doing so he makes a sharp distinction between &bquo;real&equo; and &bquo;nominal&equo; essence. 
 The scholastics would have recognized some such distinction. 
 Besides a &bquo;real&equo; definition which exhibits the &bquo;form&equo; or &bquo;essence&equo; of what a thing really is, a form which explains the possession by a thing of its characteristic properties, they allowed for a &bquo;nominal&equo; definition which captures only those properties themselves. 
 But, like Gassendi, Locke rejects &bquo;forms&equo;. 
 For him, definitions are not &bquo;real&equo;, they do not define things; they are nominal and define words. 
 The definition of gold is simply what we  mean by the word, the complex idea or nominal essence we  have in our minds when we speak of it. 
 This idea or nominal essence  will vary from person to person; goldsmiths know more properties of gold, and so have a different idea of it than does a child. 
 What, then, of Locke's &bquo;real essence&equo;? 
 Following Gassendi and Boyle, he rejects the forms of the scholastics as explanations of why material things have the properties they do, and substitutes instead an adapted Epicurean atomism as the basis for explanation. 
 Accordingly, for him, the real essence of gold, which accounts for and explains those properties of gold with which we are familiar, and which constitute our idea or nominal essence of it, is its corpuscular or atomic constitution. 
 Locke's distinction between the real and nominal essence of substances, and the way in which the corpuscular hypothesis figures in his conception of the world, which he shares with other anti-scholastics of the time, is brought out nicely by his analogy of the Strasburg Cathedral clock. 
 Locke's contemporaries marvelled at this human creation just as they marvelled at nature as seen through the microscope. 
 The clock did a lot more besides telling the time of day. 
 For example, it incorporated a globe of the heavens with a revolving sun and moon, an astrolabe showing the positions of the planets, statues which sounded bells, and a mechanical cock. 
 Gassendi spoke of our not knowing the corpuscular nature of things, the &bquo;inner shrines&equo; of nature, but only their appearances; similarly, the &bquo;gazing countryman&equo;, as Locke calls him, would know only the clock's outer show, and not its internal mechanism. 
 The &bquo;nominal essence&equo; of the clock is the idea we have of it and, as with gold, this will vary from person to person. 
 One observer may have been particularly impressed by the figure of Death sounding the hours on a bell, and his idea will include that. 
 Another, who did not pass by on the hour, might think, not of Death, but of the astrolabe showing the positions of the planets. 
 Though different in detail, these ideas are similar, in that they both derive from the clock's observable characteristics and behaviour. 
 For Conrad Dasypodius, however, the mathematician at Strasburg Academy who designed and planned the clock, the nominal essence would be radically different. 
 He would understand in detail the working of the mechanism of the clock, which enables it to function as it does. 
 His general idea, his &bquo;nominal essence&equo; of the clock would be an idea of what is, in effect, its &bquo;real essence&equo;. 
 This work of art provided an analogy for works of nature such as gold. 
 They both have observable features and properties. 
 The clock has moving hands and figures; gold is yellow, malleable, soluble in some acids, and not in others. 
 Then, just as the clock, and clocks like it, have a certain inner mechanical constitution from which these features arise, so has gold in the view of those who adopted the corpuscular hypothesis. 
 The different performances of other clocks correspond to different mechanisms; the differences in quality of different substances, the yellowness of gold, or the silvery colour of lead, similarly correspond to differences in the shape, size, arrangement, and state of motion of their corpuscles. 
 But there is an important difference between the clock, which is what Locke calls an &bquo;artificial substance&equo;, and naturally occurring substances such as gold. 
 The clock's designer would know the details of its real essence whereas, says Locke, none of us know the real essence of gold. 
 Our sensory capacities are too limited. 
 Beyond conceiving it in corpuscular terms, we have no idea of it. 
 For the horologist the nominal essence of the clock is  an idea of its real essence; in this he differs from the gazing countryman, to whom the nominal essence is simply some combination of various observable features. 
 But so far as natural substances go we are all gazing countrymen. 
 The nominal essence of gold, our idea of it, is not an idea of its real essence. 
 Properties of the kind which go to make up our nominal essence of gold are divided by Locke into &bquo;primary and original&equo; and &bquo;secondary&equo; (and also &bquo;tertiary&equo;). 
 This famous and much-discussed distinction between primary and secondary qualities has historical antecedents in Galileo, Descartes, and Hobbes. 
 Since it was generally associated with the corpuscular theory of matter it was a common idea in Locke's time, though its details, and the arguments from which it was derived, were not always the same. 
 Primary qualities belong not only to observable substances such as gold, but also to the minute corpuscles which make them up. 
 A piece of gold has solidity, extension, shape, &bquo;mobility&equo; (is in motion or at rest), and &bquo;number&equo; (is one piece), and according to the corpuscular theory the gold's corpuscles have these qualities too. 
 Secondary (and tertiary) qualities, such as colour and taste (and solubility in certain acids), belong to a piece of gold but not to its corpuscles. 
 According to the corpuscular theory these secondary (and tertiary) qualities arise from the arrangement, the &bquo;texture&equo;, of the solid, shaped, and mobile corpuscles which constitute gold, and so are not to be attributed to the corpuscles themselves. 
 Of course, like its colour, gold's primary qualities of solidity and extension also result from its consisting of solid, extended corpuscles. 
 What distinguishes them from secondary (and tertiary) qualities is that they are those features which corpuscles need to have in order to account for all  the qualities (primary, secondary, and tertiary) of the substances which they make up. 
 Because observable substances consist of arrangements of insensible corpuscles, they are able to act on each other and on our sense-organs in certain ways. 
 Interaction between the corpuscles of gold and those of sulphuric acid results in these arrangements being changed, a change we describe as the solution of gold in the acid. 
 Interaction between the corpuscles of an almond and those of our taste-buds results in the production, in our minds, of a certain idea, that of sweetness; though quite how such causation between the physical and the mental takes place is, Locke says, a mystery which we do not understand. 
 Similarly, via the intermediary of reflected light rays, interaction between the corpuscles of gold and those of our eyes produces in us the idea of yellowness. 
 Secondary qualities of objects are those arrangements of its corpuscles which cause certain ideas in us  as sentient beings. 
 Tertiary qualities are those arrangements which change, or can be changed by, the corpuscular arrangements of other things . 
 Fire causes the idea of pain in us, and snow causes ideas of coldness and of whiteness. 
 However, while we think of pain simply as an idea caused in us by interaction between the fire and our bodies, we think of the snow as being, in itself, white and cold. 
 Locke suggests that his corpuscular account of objects, and our perception of them, gives us no reason to think of snow's coldness and whiteness like this. 
 We do perceive snow as being cold and white in itself; but since our doing so is a result of the texture  of primary-quality corpuscles, there is no need to suppose snow really is as we perceive it. 
 Snow does have a certain corpuscular arrangement, which fits it to produce ideas of coldness and of whiteness in us; but just as there is nothing in fire resembling our idea of pain, so there need be nothing in snow resembling the whiteness and coldness it appears to have. 
 The case is otherwise with respect to primary qualities. 
 In order to explain how we perceive objects as having shape, and being solid, we need to suppose objects have those properties in the way they appear to have. 
 Besides defining substances as complex ideas of &bquo;distinct particular things subsisting by themselves&equo;, Locke also says that the main component of such a complex is &bquo;the supposed, or confused idea of Substance&equo;, something he also calls &bquo;substratum&equo; or &bquo;pure substance in general&equo;. 
 Locke's references to &bquo;Substance&equo; or &bquo;substratum&equo; have become notorious, and there are different accounts of what he means by them. 
 Often they are taken as implying a rejection of the kind of view which was held by Bertrand Russell and, less recently, by Isaac Watts. 
 According to this view the grammatical difference between nouns and adjectives marks no real difference between things and their properties: a material thing, a substance, is no more than &bquo;a bundle&equo; of properties. 
 As opposed to this, Locke is often supposed to be saying that, in addition to properties, things have a &bquo;substratum&equo; which &bquo;supports&equo; their properties. 
 According to a second account, Locke's &bquo;substratum&equo; should not be related to such abstract logical questions about the difference between &bquo;things&equo; and &bquo;properties&equo;. 
 It should be identified either in a general way with matter as understood by the corpuscularians or, more specifically, with the particular arrangements or &bquo;textures&equo; of corpuscles which constitute real essences. 
 There is a further topic in connection with Locke's complex ideas of substances which needs some discussion. 
 There are various particular material substances such as gold and lead, of which we have various ideas. 
 What do they have in common that makes them material substances? 
 What, in other words, is our &bquo;idea of Body&equo; as such? 
 In Locke's view, it is an idea of &bquo;an extended solid substance, capable of communicating motion by impulse&equo;. 
 His belief that solidity is an essential part of body was shared with others, such as Boyle and Newton. 
 According to the rival belief of the Cartesians, however, body was constituted by extension alone, and not also by either solidity or the ability to communicate motion. 
 Descartes says that &bquo;the nature of matter or of body&hellip; does not consist in its being hard, or heavy, or coloured&hellip; but solely in the fact that it is a substance extended in length, breadth, and depth.&equo; 
 Locke rejects this, though his arguments against Descartes's identification of body with extension tend to be little more than initial difficulties. 
 He objects that extension, by itself, is insufficient to constitute body; this property of filling space, like the ability to communicate motion in collisions, must depend on something else . 
 This, he says, is solidity or &bquo;impenetrability&equo;. 
 Furthermore, &bquo;body&equo; is so plainly different from &bquo;space&equo; that extension cannot be its whole  essence. 
 Body can be divided into parts which can be moved away from each other; space cannot. 
 Body is not, or is not necessarily, unlimited; space is. 
 If body and space were identical there would be no empty space, and motion would be impossible. 
 But Descartes had already given answers to objections such as these. 
 The difference between space and body is only &bquo;in our mode of conceiving it&equo;. 
 Motion is  possible even without empty space; so long as things simultaneously move into each other's places, motion is as possible in a plenum as in a crowd. 
 Although Descartes advocated a broadly &bquo;mechanical philosophy&equo;, according to which the material world was to be understood in terms of matter and motion, he was not a standard corpuscularian or atomist. 
 It follows from his identification of body and extension that there can be no empty space or vacuum, no Epicurean &bquo;void&equo; in which the atoms move. 
 Cartesian matter is continuous, and there are no discrete atoms. 
 The world is ultimately to be understood in terms of swirlings or &bquo;vortices&equo;, in a matter which is identical with extension or space, not in terms of collisions of solid, impenetrable atoms moving in an otherwise empty space. 
 The more usual and non-Cartesian belief, that matter consists of discrete solid particles, raises the question of how these cohere together into the larger extended bodies of our ordinary experience. 
 Locke asks how the &bquo;solid parts of body&hellip; &lsqb;keep&rsqb; united, or cohere together to make extension&equo;. 
 Given his scepticism about our ability to penetrate to the real essences of things, it is not surprising that he finds that none of the much-discussed contemporary theories on offer provide a satisfactory answer, and concludes that we are simply ignorant about this. 
 The extension of body, which for Descartes is its whole essence, is not for Locke the only consequence of what he sees as its essential property of solidity. 
 The third part of the idea he says we have of body, its ability to communicate motion by impulse, follows from solidity too. 
 We have, however, no more real understanding of this ability than we do of cohesion. 
 The two important kinds of complex idea which Locke distinguishes are &bquo;substances&equo; and &bquo;modes&equo;. 
 The former, as we have been seeing, are ideas of material things, such as sheep, or of kinds of material stuff, such as gold. 
 Their characteristic properties, many of which are included in our complex idea or nominal essence, are what the natural philosopher might collect, observe, and list in a &bquo;natural history&equo;. 
 They result from their real essences, the arrangement of corpuscles which make them up. 
 What, then, are &bquo;modes&equo;? 
 As Locke defines them, they &bquo;contain not in them the supposition of subsisting by themselves, but are considered as dependences on, or affections of substances&equo;. 
 Given this and various of his examples, such as &bquo;triangle&equo; or &bquo;procession&equo;, they seem to be ways in which the substances on which they depend may be ordered, organized, or arranged. 
 A triangle is not a material thing, but a shape which material things may have, an arrangement into which they can be put. 
 A procession is not a material thing, but a certain organization of material things. 
 Locke describes modes as combinations of &bquo;scattered and independent ideas&equo; which are &bquo;put together by the mind&equo;. 
 He describes them as &bquo;creatures of the understanding&equo;, unlike substances which are &bquo;works of nature&equo;. 
 This does not mean that they cannot be found in the world; a child may wonder what shape or arrangement a triangle is, and have it pointed out to him. 
 It seems to mean that, whereas we form ideas of substances by observation of commonly conjoined properties and qualities, the modes we form depend on human conventions, purposes, and institutions. 
 People form collections of ideas into modes, &bquo;as they have frequent use of in their way of living and conversation, leaving others, which they have but seldom an occasion to mention, loose and without names.&equo; 
 We have no name for the killing of an older man, but do have a name for the killing of one's father. 
 Our ideas of substances, their nominal essences, are not ideas of their real essences. 
 Our idea of gold is simply an idea of some of its observable properties, which are supposed to flow from its real essence. 
 Our nominal essences of modes, however, are  ideas of their real essences. 
 With many of Locke's examples of modes it is not easy to see how this can be. 
 Since it is not easy to see a distinction between their characteristic properties and some essence from which they flow, one might be tempted to think that, when Locke speaks of a coincidence of their real and nominal essence, he means that the notion of a real essence does not really apply to modes. 
 But when he says that the real and nominal essences of a mode, such as a triangle, coincide, he really does mean what we should expect him to mean: that our idea of a triangle is like the horologist's idea of the Strasburg clock, an idea of its real essence, and not like that of the gazing countryman, an idea of some of its properties. 
 The real essences of modes are not corpuscular, of course. 
 Triangles are not material things, but shapes which material things can have. 
 But this does not mean that they have no essence from which their characteristic properties arise. 
 Locke says that 
 figure including a space between three lines, is the real as well as nominal essence of a triangle; it being not only the abstract idea to which the general name is annexed, but the very essentia , or being, of the thing itself, that foundation from which all its properties flow, and to which they are all inseparably annexed. 
 But it is far otherwise concerning that parcel of matter, which makes the ring on my finger, wherein these two essences are&hellip; different. 
 Here Locke draws a parallel between modes such as triangles, and substances such as gold and the Strasburg clock. 
 Gold has various properties as a result of its insensible corpuscular constitution; the clock has certain characteristic features as a consequence of its internal mechanism. 
 Similarly, a figure of three lines enclosing a space, which is the idea we have of a triangle, has various properties as a consequence of being constructed in that way, properties such as having internal angles equal to two right angles, and external angles equal to internal opposites. 
 Locke's thought is that, just as we can distinguish between the characteristics of gold (or the clock), and its corpuscular constitution (or internal mechanism), so we can distinguish between the characteristic properties of a triangle, and what accounts for or explains them. 
 We might think of the real essence of a triangle, &bquo;three lines enclosing a space&equo;, as instructions for making such a figure: it is how that figure is constituted. 
 When a figure is drawn according to these instructions it will, as a consequence, have various properties which a geometer might have predicted. 
 Similarly, to take another case, we might think of the real essence of a circle, a figure which bears a constant relation to some one point, as an indication of how, along Hobbesian lines, to generate or construct one. 
 It is as a result of being so constructed, and of being the figure it is, that a circle has its characteristic properties. 
 Given that &bquo;knowledge&equo; is the perception of connections between ideas, and that where this perception is lacking we have only &bquo;belief&equo; or &bquo;opinion&equo;, it is Locke's view that geometry, unlike natural philosophy, constitutes a &bquo;science&equo;, a body of &bquo;knowledge&equo;. 
 It is also his view that our abstract ideas of modes, such as triangles and other geometrical figures, are ideas of their real essences, unlike those of substances, such as gold, which are merely ideas of observable properties which arise from their real essences. 
 These two views go together. 
 If our idea of gold were of its real essence, 
 then the properties we discover in that body, would depend on that complex idea, and be deducible from it, and their necessary connection with it be known; as all properties of a triangle depend on, and as far as they are discoverable, are deducible from the complex idea of three lines, including a space. 
 It is because we know the real essences of geometrical figures that that subject consists of &bquo;certain and universal knowledge&equo; obtained by a priori intuition or demonstration. 
 But we do not know the real essences of the substances of natural philosophy, so all that we can do is to observe and list their properties, and form only beliefs and opinions about them. 
 Substances afford matter of very little general knowledge; and the bare contemplation of their abstract ideas, will carry us but a very little way in the search of truth and certainty. 
 &hellip; The want of ideas of their real essences sends us from our own thoughts, to the things themselves. 
 Since Hume, philosophers of an empiricist turn of mind have tended to suppose that any &bquo;knowledge&equo; obtained by a priori perception of connections between ideas is trifling and empty of content, and that the price paid for the necessity and certainty of such &bquo;knowledge&equo; is a loss of information. 
 In this respect Locke is not an empiricist: he does not think that geometrical knowledge or, for that matter, the knowledge we would have in natural philosophy if we knew the real essences of substances, is empty and trivial. 
 Having external angles equal to internal opposites follows  from being a figure of three lines, but is no more a part  of that idea than being yellow or malleable would be part of a detailed idea of the corpuscular constitution of gold. 
 In not finding a priori knowledge trivial, Locke does not fit our modern textbook descriptions of &bquo;an empiricist&equo;. 
 He further fails to fit them in his belief that natural philosophy fails to be a science simply because we are ignorant of the relevant real essences, not because there are no necessary connections in nature. 
 Modelled as it is on the a priori science of geometry, his ideal of a scientific natural philosophy is that of a textbook rationalist. 
 It is unattainable, not because of the nature of things, but because of the nature of our faculties. 
 All of this forms a central part of Locke's answer to his initial question about the extent of human knowledge, and whether there is a horizon between what we can and cannot know. 
 Our knowledge is bounded by our ideas, and extends only so far as they are ideas of real essences. 
 But geometrical figures are not the only modes, and so are not the only things whose real essences we can know. 
 The ideas of morality are modes too, and Locke thinks that with proper application we could develop a systematic science of ethics similar to that of mathematics and geometry. 
 This possibility of a demonstrative science of ethics caught the imagination of Locke's friend William Molyneux, who pressed him to produce it. 
 Locke replied that he  could not do it; it would take someone of the intellectual stature of Newton. 
 He believed, moreover, that although man's reason had gone some way in &bquo;its great and proper business of morality&equo;, the progress had been slow. 
 Yet, even though moral rules and principles are neither innate, nor easy to acquire by reason, no one need remain ignorant of his duties and obligations: the Bible gives us them. 
 &bquo;The Gospel&equo;, Locke explained to Molyneux, &bquo;contains so perfect a body of ethics, that reason may be excused from that enquiry.&equo; 
 But taking our morality from the Bible does not necessarily mean merely taking it on trust and authority, and abandoning all thought of moral knowledge . 
 Though our reason may fail us in discovering  moral truths, it need not in verifying  what the Bible says. 
 We can find justifying arguments for its ethical contents, even if we could not come to them on our own. 
 So long as, in the end, our grasp of them rests upon reason, we have knowledge, no matter how it was first suggested. 
 But even though justification by hindsight is easier than discovery, some people are still not rationally able to see the truth of the Gospels for themselves; even though the Bible does point the way to moral knowledge, most people &bquo;cannot know, and therefore they must believe&equo;. 
 Where &bquo;belief&equo; is based not on experience and observation, but on the revelation of the Gospels, Locke speaks of &bquo;faith&equo;. 
 Here he directly develops the interest which he and his friends in the discussion group had, and which had led to his starting work on the Essay : the relation and interplay between knowledge and reason on the one hand, and faith, belief, and revelation on the other. 
 His general theme is that reason has supremacy over revelation. 
 In that it gives us &bquo;knowledge&equo;, as opposed to mere &bquo;belief&equo; or &bquo;faith&equo;, of course it has; but Locke also means that revelation must be answerable to reason. 
 If the Gospels gave a moral truth already known by reason, this would verify the Gospels, not our reason. 
 Reason is more certain than revelation, and cannot be made any more certain by it. 
 We need to be certain that the revelation stems from God; and we cannot be as certain of this as we are of our reason-based knowledge of the particular truth in question. 
 This means that nothing contrary to  reason can be accepted on the basis of supposed revelation. 
 It would &bquo;be to subvert the principles, and foundations of all knowledge&hellip; if&hellip; that we certainly know, give way to what we may possibly be mistaken in.&equo; 
 Though moral truths do not, at least in principle, lie outside of reason, and beyond the horizon of our knowledge and understandings, some things do. 
 Though not &bquo;contrary&equo; to it, they are &bquo;above reason&equo;. 
 We have already seen some such things in the area of natural philosophy, things of which, &bquo;by the natural use of our faculties, we can have no knowledge at all&equo;. 
 Others have been the subject of revelation; for example, &bquo;that the dead shall rise, and live again'. 
 But, that revelation can tell us things &bquo;above reason&equo; does not make it superior to it. 
 Reason cannot decide the truth or falsity of what is revealed in such cases, but can decide whether the revelation is genuine. 
 A revelation from God is bound to be true, &bquo;but whether it be a divine revelation, or no, reason  must judge&equo;. 
 Furthermore, our salvation does not depend on our putting &bquo;faith&equo; in anything &bquo;above reason&equo;. 
 It is open to us simply by the use of our natural faculties. 
 God has &bquo;given all mankind so sufficient a light of reason, that they&hellip; could not (whenever they set themselves to search) either doubt of the being of a God, or of the obedience due to Him&equo;. 
 This idea that the essentials for salvation are never &bquo;above reason&equo; sits uneasily with what Locke has already said about the practical difficulty of working them out for oneself. 
 A slow-minded or busy person can be thankful that the Bible &bquo;contains so perfect a body of ethics that reason may be excused from the enquiry&equo;, but the position of those to whom it is unavailable is not entirely happy. 
 Locke's belief in the relevance of reason to religion and morality, and his claim that salvation can be won on its basis alone, were common from the time of the Restoration into the eighteenth century. 
 The Civil War had seen an outburst of religious fanaticism and the extremes of what was called &bquo;enthusiasm&equo;. 
 With the Restoration there came a reaction against the supernatural and mysterious, against private &bquo;revelations&equo; and &bquo;inspiration&equo;. 
 Moderation and reasonableness began to come to the fore. 
 Thomas Sprat refers to &bquo;the late extravagant excesses of enthusiasm. 
 The infinite pretences to inspiration, and immediate communion with God.&equo; 
 He is clearly relieved that &bquo;the fierceness of violent inspirations is in good measure departed&equo; and that &bquo;the universal disposition of this age is bent upon a rational religion&equo;. 
 For Locke, the regulation by reason of &bquo;faith&equo;, or &bquo;belief&equo; based on revelation, distinguishes it from the &bquo;ungrounded fancies&equo;, &bquo;the conceits of a warmed and over-weening brain&equo;, which are characteristic of &bquo;enthusiasm&equo;. 
 Divine inspiration and revelation are not their own guarantees, and we must always ask &bquo;How do I know that God is the revealer of this to me?&equo; 
 Otherwise, &bquo;how great soever the assurance is, that I am possessed with, it is groundless; whatever light I pretend to, it is but enthusiasm.&equo; 
 The movements of Cambridge Platonism (involving Henry More, Benjamin Whichcote, and Ralph Cudworth), and of Latitudinarianism (involving many members of the Royal Society, such as Sprat and Glanvill) encouraged the idea that, by itself, reason could provide the essentials of religious belief and the means to salvation. 
 At first, this stress on &bquo;natural religion&equo;, as it was called, did not necessarily mean the abandonment of Christianity as revealed in the Scriptures; so long as it was not inconsistent with reason, it could be accepted. 
 But towards the end of the century the ideal began to emerge that not merely the essentials, but also the whole of religion could be discovered by reason, and that nothing &bquo;above reason&equo; should be a part of it. 
 Even though he did not actually advocate it, Locke certainly did much to foster such rational deism. 
 To inquire into &bquo;the original, certainty, and extent&equo; of human knowledge was the explicit aim of Locke's great masterpiece, the Essay . 
 But in following him through that aim, we nevertheless have left untouched some of the ideas for which he is famous. 
 Because of Berkeley's criticisms of them, Locke's views on language and abstract ideas, views which were implicit in the discussion of nominal essences, are best left for the next chapter. 
 For the remainder of this one we will look at his account of personal identity and the mind, and then at his political philosophy. 
 Locke's discussion of personal identity, which was added in the second edition of the Essay  on the suggestion of Molyneux, has been of lasting interest to philosophers. 
 Early on he makes a general point, one taken up by later writers, that there is a relativity about identity. 
 If we ask &bquo;Is this what was here last year?&equo; it matters what kind of thing this  is. 
 If we are referring to a mass of matter we can say that it is the same so long as it consists of the same particles, whereas if we are referring to a living body this need not be so: &bquo;a colt grown up to a horse, sometimes fat, sometimes lean, is all the while the same horse: though&hellip; there may be a manifest change of the parts.&equo; 
 In this second case, identity consists in matter being continuously arranged in a similar way so as to &bquo;partake of the same life&equo;. 
 The point is important for, when he turns to personal identity, he insists on a distinction between two ideas which &bquo;the ordinary way of speaking&equo; runs together: the idea of &bquo;man&equo;, and the idea of &bquo;person&equo;. 
 The identity of a man is basically no different from that of any other animal. 
 It consists in &bquo;nothing but a participation of the same continued life, by constantly fleeting particles of matter, in succession vitally united to the same organized body&equo;. 
 The idea of a person, however, is not the idea of a living body of a certain kind. 
 It is that of &bquo;a thinking, intelligent being, that has reason and reflection, and can consider itself as itself, the same thinking thing in different times and places&equo;. 
 A person &bquo;is self to itself now&equo; and is always conscious of his present thoughts, feelings, and actions; similarly, he &bquo;will be the same self as far as the same consciousness can extend to actions past or to come&equo;. 
 Locke's description of a person as &bquo;a thinking, intelligent being&equo; does not mean that the continuity of self-consciousness which constitutes personal identity is the continuity of some immaterial substance, a soul, mind, or spirit, which is self-conscious, for he is clearly unhappy with a Cartesian view of this sort. 
 Descartes distinguished two sorts of substance, souls (or minds or spirits), and matter (or body). 
 Each has &bquo;one principal property&hellip; which constitutes its nature or essence&equo;. 
 In the case of body this, as we have already seen, is extension; in the case of mind it is thought. 
 Persons, for Descartes, are mental or immaterial thinking substances. 
 I am, says Descartes, &bquo;a substance the whole essence or nature of which is to think. 
 &hellip; This &bquo;me&equo;, that is to say, the soul by which I am what I am, is entirely distinct from body&hellip; and even if the body were not, the soul would not cease to be what it is.&equo; 
 Just as he disagreed with him about the essential or principal properties of body, Locke disagreed with Descartes about the mind. 
 For one thing, besides &bquo;thought&equo;, a further essential property in our idea of mind is the &bquo;power of exciting motion in body, by will, or thought&equo;. 
 Moreover, as Descartes means it, the view that thought is essential to mind is the view that the mind &bquo;always thinks, and that it has the actual perception of ideas in itself constantly, as long as it exists&equo;. 
 It is the view that actually occurring thought, rather than the mere ability or capacity to think, is essential to mind. 
 For Locke, however, actually being engaged in thought is not essential to a mind or soul. 
 For him, thinking is to the soul as motion, not extension, is to the body. 
 Just as a material body may or may not actually be moving, so a mind may or may not actually be thinking. 
 By &bquo;thought&equo; Descartes did not just mean deliberation, or some strictly intellectual activity; he took it to include other forms of consciousness, such as imagining and feeling. 
 But Locke's disagreement with him does not stem from this. 
 However widely one takes &bquo;thought&equo;, it is neither self-evident nor a fact of experience that we are always actually thinking. 
 As Locke says, &bquo;every drowsy nod shakes their &lsqb;the Cartesians'&rsqb; doctrine.&equo; 
 Besides disagreeing with Descartes about the exact constitution of our idea of mind, Locke also disagreed with the claim that we know the real nature of mind. 
 Specifically, we do not know that minds are immaterial substances whose nature does not go beyond those properties we think are essential to them. 
 The power to move a body, and the ability to think, do constitute our idea of mind. 
 But we neither understand this power nor know, as Gassendi had already argued against Descartes, &bquo;wherein thinking consists&equo;. 
 We do not know, for instance, whether thought might not have a purely material basis, instead of being the unexplained property of an immaterial substance. 
 It follows from Descartes's view of mind that personal identity consists in the continuation of an immaterial substance, a mind or soul. 
 According to Locke, however, the question is &bquo;what makes the same person , and not whether it be the same identical substance, which always thinks in the same person, which in this case matters not at all&equo;. 
 The identity of a horse can be preserved through changes of matter; it does not depend on the identity of a continued material substance, but on &bquo;the unity of one continued life&equo;. 
 Similarly, the identity of a person does not depend on the continuity of an immaterial substance, a mind or soul. 
 &bquo;It being the same consciousness that makes a man be himself to himself, personal identity depends on that only, whether it be annexed only to one individual substance, or can be continued in a succession of several substances.&equo; 
 The Cartesians concede something like this in the case of brute animal life. 
 Not wanting to say that it has an immaterial soul, they allow that a horse has a continued identity despite changes of matter. 
 So, since they claim to know the complete and final story about the nature of mental substance, it is incumbent on them to show that it is impossible for the same consciousness to be transferred from one substance to another. 
 In truth, however, we just do not know whether this is  impossible. 
 Perhaps it is, perhaps it is not; our ignorance shows that what we mean when we speak of personal identity is continuity of consciousness, not of substance. 
 Moreover, for all we know about the nature of thought, it might be possible, it might even be necessary, that the substances whose succession could continue a personal consciousness are material, not immaterial at all. 
 Even supposing that consciousness need not, or even cannot, have its basis in material substance, it is possible not only that the same personal consciousness be associated with different immaterial Cartesian substances, but also that the same immaterial substance be associated, at different times, with different consciousnesses. 
 The analogy between the identity of a living body and that of personal identity makes this plausible. 
 Not only might one living body consist of different particles of matter, but also different bodies (mine and the sheep that I eat, for example), might consist of the same matter. 
 For Locke, then, personal identity consists in an identity of consciousness, and not in the identity of some substance whose essence it is to be conscious. 
 He agrees with the &bquo;more probable opinion&hellip; &lsqb;that&rsqb; this consciousness is annexed to, and the affection of one identical immaterial substance&equo;, but, expressing his general scepticism about the extent of our knowledge, he says we really do not know the truth of the matter. 
 Locke aroused considerable controversy with his suggestion that &bquo;since we know not wherein thinking consists&equo;, it may be, for all we know, that nothing more than matter is necessary for thought, and that God might have &bquo;given to some systems of matter fitly disposed, a power to perceive and think&equo;. 
 For one thing, it would have seemed to count against the idea of immortality, for it was commonly argued that only something immaterial could be immortal. 
 Locke's view is, however, that &bquo;&lsqb;all&rsqb; the great ends of morality and religion, are well enough secured, without philosophical proofs of the soul's immateriality&equo;. 
 If  God can make matter think in this world, and give us material &bquo;souls&equo;, he can do so in the next. 
 Whether we are purely material or not we cannot know; but being so would not be inconsistent with immortality, and we have the guarantee of revelation that we are, in fact, immortal. 
 Locke's tentative suggestion about the possibility of thinking matter would have seemed to lead to atheism too; but he was quick to point out to his critic, Edward Stillingfleet, that the suggestion that we  might be purely material does not involve the denial of all spiritual immaterial beings; if we are  thinking matter, it needed a spiritual God to make us so. 
 Even apart from these wider consequences of his thought about persons, Locke's idea that their identity consists in continuity of self-consciousness came under attack. 
 Thomas Sergeant, Joseph Butler, and Thomas Reid reasserted a continuous mental substance as the basis of personal identity, and said that the Lockean continuity of self-consciousness made no sense without it. 
 Reid developed a rather more interesting objection, one made earlier by Berkeley, which puts the case of a general who is conscious of things he did as an officer, but no longer conscious, as he was when an officer, of what he did as a boy. 
 For Locke, it was argued, the absurdity would follow that while the general is the same person as the officer, and he the same as the boy, the general is not the same person as the boy. 
 Something of what Locke would have said to this is already contained in the Essay . 
 It appears that, despite the way he first introduces the topic of personal identity, his detailed interest is not so much in what makes a person the same over time, but in the sense one has of oneself, one's past deeds and actions, and the relation of this to questions of moral praise and blame. 
 In a famous sentence he says that &bquo; Person &hellip; is a forensic term appropriating actions and their merit; and so belongs only to intelligent agents capable of a law, and happiness and misery.&equo; 
 At one point he talks of the extension over time of &bquo;a personality&equo; rather than of &bquo;a person&equo;, and might have said that, even if the general knew what he did as a boy, it could be nothing to him, no part of his adult conception of himself, and so not a matter for guilt or blame. 
 We do not, Locke points out, punish a person for what he did when temporarily insane, and we speak of him as having been &bquo;not himself&equo; or &bquo;beside himself&equo;. 
 He allows that, despite his claiming to have no consciousness of them, a court may punish a man for his drunken actions, but this is only because it cannot be sure of distinguishing in the defendant's plea &bquo;what is real, what counterfeit&equo;. 
 We may be assured that, on the Judgement Day, &bquo;no one shall be made to answer for what he knows nothing of&equo;. 
 What is important is what a person is &bquo;concerned and accountable&equo; for, what he &bquo;owns and imputes to&hellip; self &equo;, what his &bquo;conscience &lsqb;is&rsqb; accusing or excusing him&equo; of. 
 Reid's objection, which has been reiterated over the years, is often supplemented with its converse. 
 Is it not possible for a person to &bquo;remember&equo; something he never did? 
 Indeed, does not Locke himself raise this objection when he asks why &bquo;one intellectual substance may not have represented to it, as done by itself, what it never did, and was perhaps done by some other agent&equo;? 
 The extent to which this is an objection to Locke's actual views will depend, as in the case of the brave officer, on whether they concern what makes a person at one time the same as he is at another, or concern moral matters of praise and blame. 
 What is clear is that, in the above passage, he is not making the objection against himself. 
 The possibility raised there is intended for the Cartesians to deal with. 
 It is their view, and not any of his, that makes personal identity consist in the identity of the same thinking substance. 
 Locke's political philosophy is mainly contained in his anonymously published Treatises of Government  (1690). 
 He says in the preface that his hope is, &bquo;to establish the throne of our great restorer, our present King William; to make good his title, in the consent of the people.&equo; 
 William had come to the throne two years earlier, in 1688, after the Glorious Revolution against the Catholic James II; but although the Treatises  do contain material which could be seen as after-the-fact justifications of the Revolution, they were not written for this reason. 
 Having been started some ten years earlier, they were substantially complete by the early 1680s. 
 They were composed in the years of the Exclusion crisis, during which Locke's patron, Shaftesbury, and others, sought to exclude James, then Duke of York, from the succession to the throne, and argued for government by consent and for the right to religious dissent. 
 The Treatises  supported such arguments, and it was his having, and being suspected by the government of having, such seditious views that made it necessary for Locke to flee to Holland in 1683. 
 The First Treatise  is now less studied than the Second , for it is of less lasting philosophical importance. 
 It consists mainly of criticism of the theories of absolute monarchy and the divine right of Kings, for which Robert Filmer had argued in his posthumously published Patriarcha  (1680). 
 According to Filmer, God granted to Adam, as the first King, an absolute and total political authority which was transmitted to his heirs. 
 A divinely guaranteed monarch has absolute authority over his subjects, and is answerable, not to them, but to God. 
 Locke finds the theory quite unworkable; for example, it cannot be used to justify any actual political authority, since it is impossible to show of any particular monarch that he is a genuine heir to Adam's original authority. 
 The Second Treatise  seeks to find some other more workable foundation for political authority. 
 Though it does not deny that subjects do have a duty to God to obey their ruler, it insists that rulers are not absolute, and themselves have duties to their subjects. 
 This means that if a ruler's commands did not deserve obedience, resistance to them might be justified. 
 Locke builds his theory on the idea of people living in a state of nature, in families and loose groups, without any political authority over them. 
 His state of nature is not Hobbes's, for it is not composed of individuals following their natural instincts and living in fear of each other. 
 Whether or not he does it, every person has a duty to God not to &bquo;harm another in his life,&hellip; liberty,&hellip; or goods&equo;, and so has a parallel right to defend himself against such attack. 
 But if people have a right to their possessions, what makes them theirs ? 
 Why should a hut in which someone lives count as his? 
 Why does the ground which a family happens to cultivate belong to that family? 
 In Filmer's view, just as absolute political power was given to Adam by God, so the whole earth was given him too; hence, subjects have neither political power nor any right to property and possessions. 
 Locke's response to this, his labour theory of property, is famous. 
 For Locke, God made all men free and equal and set no one in power over them; similarly he gave to all men the earth and its fruits by which to support their life. 
 This certainly means that Adam's heirs cannot be alone in having a right to private property, but in saying this, it does not explain how such a right arises in the first place. 
 By itself, this denial of Filmer's view could entail a theory of communal property. 
 Locke further explains, therefore, why one man should have a right to this land and these crops, another to that. 
 The land someone cultivates is necessarily his : this is simply a special case of the fact that each man unquestionably has a right to his own life and labour, and so has the right to the products of that labour. 
 &bquo;Whatsoever then, he removes out of the state that nature hath provided, and left it in, he hath mixed his labour with, and joined to it something that is his own, and thereby makes it his property.&equo; 
 Even though people in the state of nature have rights and duties concerning the lives, liberty, and possessions of themselves and others, it does not follow that these are respected and obeyed. 
 Perhaps they will be unclear in the complexities of particular cases. 
 Perhaps, too, someone may lack the power to defend his rights, or he may go too far in his own defence. 
 Having these possibilities in mind, people agree to unite, and to &bquo;enter into society to make one people, one body politic, under one supreme government&equo;. 
 They leave the state of nature &bquo;by setting up a judge on earth with authority to determine all the controversies and redress the injuries that may happen to any member of the commonwealth&equo;. 
 This does not mean that they put themselves into the hands of an absolute authority. 
 Unlike Hobbes, Locke believes that people under an absolute authority are not really in civil society; effectively they are still in a state of nature, for they may need to defend their rights against that authority. 
 The judge of Locke's civil society is not absolute, but answerable to &bquo;the will and determination of the majority&equo; in his dealings with individual rights and duties. 
 The views and wishes of the majority form a court of appeal against the decisions of their ruler. 
 For Locke, &bquo;the consent of any number of freemen capable of a majority&equo; produces the continuing existence, as well as the actual beginning, of any political society. 
 Locke faces the objection that there is no historical evidence for his account of the creation of political authority. 
 Certainly, no present authority could be justified by appeal to any such explicit consent. 
 People are simply born into civil societies, and come under their laws and authority without choice. 
 His answer depends on a distinction between tacit and explicit consent. 
 By remaining in society, one gives one's tacit consent to it. 
 His suggestion that one is always &bquo;at liberty to go and incorporate himself into any other community, or to agree with others to begin a new one&hellip; in any part of the world, they can find free and unpossessed&equo; has been ridiculed, and is even less plausible now than when he made it. 
 But his whole account can perhaps be understood so as to avoid such objections. 
 Given its basic anti-absolutist thought that, whether within or without political society, men have a right to life, liberty, and possessions, it can be seen as a kind of picturesque metaphor which, in explaining the structure of legitimate political authority, reveals it to be based in the consent of the governed. 
 The notion of tacit consent gains further plausibility when one sees that a possibility of legitimate resistance or revolution follows from the idea that the ultimate basis of authority is the &bquo;will and determination of the majority&equo;. 
 For this means that &bquo;the community perpetually retains a supreme power of saving themselves from&hellip; their legislators, whenever they shall be so foolish, or so wicked, as to lay and carry on designs against the&lsqb;ir&rsqb; liberties and properties&equo;. 
 Locke is anxious to defend his political philosophy against the accusation that it encourages  rebellion. 
 Even the doctrine that political power is divinely given may not, in the particular circumstances of some cruel tyrant, actually prevent rebellion. 
 Moreover, whatever one's account of political power, no one would urge a revolution &bquo;upon every little mismanagement in public affairs&equo;. 
 But the question of when  rebellion or revolt is justified needs an answer. 
 Unsurprisingly, Locke's is that &bquo;The People shall be Judge&equo;. 
 In 1692 Locke's Irish friend, William Molyneux, recommended the Essay concerning Human Understanding  to the Provost of Trinity College, Dublin. 
 &bquo;So wonderfully pleased and satisfied&equo; was he with it that, as Molyneux wrote to Locke, &bquo;he has ordered it to be read by the Batchelors in the College, and strictly examines them in their progress therein&equo;; and so it came about that Locke's masterpiece was on the curriculum which faced George Berkeley, the subject of the next chapter, when he entered Trinity as a student in 1700. 
 George Berkeley (1685&ndash;1753) 
 George Berkeley was born near Kilkenny in Ireland in 1685. 
 He studied languages, mathematics, and philosophy at Trinity College, Dublin, where he became a Fellow in 1707. 
 He was ordained into the Anglican Church in 1710. 
 In his early travels to London he met various intellectuals and literary people such as Joseph Addison, Alexander Pope, and Jonathan Swift. 
 In the 1720s, having become disillusioned with what he saw as a decline in the moral and spiritual standards of European culture, he formed the project of founding a college in Bermuda for the sons of English settlers and natives, both from Bermuda and the American mainland. 
 With a Royal Charter, and parliamentary approval, he left in 1728 for America. 
 Having reached Newport, Rhode Island, he decided to start the college there, but, despite promises, financial support was not forthcoming, and he returned to England. 
 In 1734 he was appointed Bishop of Cloyne, eventually moving to Oxford in 1752, where he died the next year. 
 His Bermuda project, his attempt to develop tar-water as a cure for the dysentery which followed the hard Irish winter of 1739&ndash;40, and his evident concern for his parishioners, were all born of a kind and generous character. 
 According to Pope he had &bquo;ev'ry virtue under heav'n&equo;, while his wife said that &bquo;humility, tenderness, patience, generosity, charity to men's souls and bodies, was the sole end of all his projects, and the business of his life&equo;. 
 Berkeley's ideas were formulated early. 
 His Essay towards a New Theory of Vision  was published in 1709, and was followed the next year by his master-work, A Treatise concerning the Principles of Human Knowledge . 
 Despite its readability the Principles , as it is known, was neither well received nor, in Berkeley's view, properly understood. 
 Consequently he attempted more explanation of its doctrines in his Three Dialogues between Hylas and Philonous  (1713). 
 He wrote also on the theoretical bases of the sciences of motion ( De Motu , 1721) and mathematics ( The Analyst , 1735). 
 In common with his central philosophical works, these are imbued with religious belief and feeling, something which is explicitly the subject in his Alciphron  (1732). 
 Berkeley's philosophy marks the turn of the tide against the world picture which had developed in the seventeenth century, and which had reached one of its classical expositions in Locke's Essay . 
 Though he did not reject the methodology and interests of the &bquo;new philosophy&equo;, nor attempt to go back beyond it to some earlier view, he thought that, in allowing too much to materialism, philosophy had taken a wrong turn. 
 As in Gassendi and Locke, the &bquo;new philosophy&equo; was often anti-sceptical in intent, and its advocates were often not complete materialists, in that they genuinely thought to find room for religion, God, and the soul. 
 Berkeley, nevertheless, thought that to concede anything to materialism was to concede too much, and that any element of materialism inevitably led to scepticism and atheism. 
 In a sincere attempt to display the importance of God in the scheme of things, Berkeley sought to rebuild the &bquo;new philosophy&equo; on the more solidly religious foundations of a complete and thoroughgoing spiritual immaterialism. 
 According to the standard seventeenth-century view, there exist, independently of and antecedently to our perception of them, material bodies. 
 Given the distinction between primary and secondary qualities, such material things are not quite as they appear; unlike their extension, their colour (for example) is nothing but an ability, stemming from their atomic or corpuscular constitution, to cause certain ideas in our minds. 
 According to some, this material world was all that exists. 
 For Hobbes there is no immaterial  God, nor are there immaterial  souls or minds. 
 God and minds do exist, but materially so. 
 Thinking and perceiving, which might naturally be attributed to an incorporeal mind, are simply complex motions in matter. 
 But most of those who thought there was a material reality were not uncompromising materialists of a Hobbesian sort. 
 Most of them believed in an immaterial reality too. 
 Though Locke does allow the possibility that matter might think, he tends to the view that we do have immaterial minds; and for him there certainly is an immaterial God. 
 For many in the seventeenth century this immaterial God was an important part of their whole world-view. 
 He not only created the material world but also, like a divine watchmaker, set it going by an initial injection of motion, and kept it going by occasional adjustments. 
 Like many others, Berkeley objected to the complete materialism of Hobbes. 
 But he was equally unhappy with the typical alternative, with what he saw as the uneasy combination of materialism and immaterialism. 
 It failed to allow God his proper place, and was really no better than complete materialism. 
 It ultimately led, he believed, either to scepticism about the very existence of the world or, by quite misunderstanding God's relation to that world, to atheism or complete materialism. 
 At least Hobbes was consistent for, as Berkeley noted, &bquo;Matter once allow'd, I defy any man to prove God is not matter&equo;. 
 The uneasy combination of materialism and immaterialism, which in Hobbes is resolved into a complete materialism, is resolved by Berkeley into a complete immaterialism in which God has a role far more crucial than in the standard seventeenth-century view. 
 Starting with the more usual anti-Hobbesian belief in an immaterial God and perceiving minds or souls, he went one step further and said that this is all there is. 
 He took this to be a truth &bquo;so near and obvious to the mind, that a man need only open his eyes to see&equo; it. 
 All the &bquo;furniture of the earth,&hellip; all those bodies which compose the mighty frame of the world&equo;, he says, &bquo;have not any subsistence without a mind.&equo; 
 If they &bquo;do not exist in my mind or that of any other created spirit, they must either have no existence at all, or else subsist in the mind of some eternal spirit.&equo; 
 Startlingly bold as this idea is, the arguments for it were initially contained in just the first thirty-three short sections of the Principles . 
 Berkeley wrote more fully in the Three Dialogues , but this work was unfortunately hardly better understood than the Principles  itself. 
 The basic problem he encountered was getting across why his own complete immaterialism was not itself more overtly and explicitly sceptical than the standard view that there exist both material bodies and incorporeal minds or spirits. 
 Since, as the very titles of his books illustrate, his immaterialism was explicitly and primarily put forward as an antidote or corrective to scepticism and atheism, it was important that he explain this. 
 The Principles  is subtitled as an inquiry into the grounds of &bquo;Scepticism, Atheism, and Irreligion&equo;; according to its preface it will be useful &bquo;particularly to those who are tainted with scepticism, or want a demonstration of the existence and immateriality of God, or the natural immortality of the soul&equo;. 
 The Three Dialogues  aims to demonstrate &bquo;the incorporeal nature of the soul, and the immediate providence of a Deity: in opposition to Sceptics and Atheists&equo;. 
 According to Berkeley, the usual combination of materialism and immaterialism leads to scepticism because of its &bquo;supposing a difference between things  and ideas &equo;. 
 Once a distinction is made between our perceptions of material things and those things themselves, &bquo;then are we involved all in scepticism &equo;. 
 For it follows from this distinction that we see only the appearances of things, images of them in our minds, not the things themselves, &bquo;so that, for aught we know, all we see, hear, and feel, may be only phantom and vain chimera, and not at all agree with the real things&equo;. 
 One person who clearly distinguished mental ideas and material things in this way was the French Cartesian, Nicolas Malebranche. 
 According to Malebranche, in his Search after Truth  (1675), we do not see material things in the world directly. 
 The &bquo;immediate objects&equo; of our minds are &bquo;ideas&equo;. 
 When we see the sun, he says, the &bquo;immediate object&equo; of our perceiving mind is not the sun itself &bquo;but something that is intimately joined to our soul,&hellip; an idea &equo;. 
 When we perceive an object there is an idea of it &bquo;present to&equo; our mind. 
 But it is possible that we have such an idea when there is no external thing like it. 
 &bquo;It often happens &lsqb;as in dreams and fevers&rsqb; that we perceive things that do not exist.&equo; 
 Against the background of this account of perception as something indirect , with ideas figuring as intermediaries between our minds and material things, Malebranche discusses what reason we have for our usual supposition that the material world exists at all. 
 Descartes had thought that its existence could be demonstrated on the basis of God's goodness. 
 God would not give us ideas and perceptions which inevitably lead us to suppose a world, unless there actually was one. 
 But Malebranche rejected various parts of Descartes's proof, concluding that theoretically the material world was no more than a possibility, and could be accepted only on the basis of faith. 
 This obviously reintroduces the scepticism which Descartes had hoped to avoid, and it increases when Malebranche goes on to argue that our perceptions of a material world could not anyway be caused by that world even if there were one, but must be caused by God. 
 This, as Berkeley comments, is &bquo;a very precarious opinion&equo;. 
 It supposes &bquo;without any reason at all, that God has created innumerable beings that are entirely useless, and serve to no manner of purpose&equo;. 
 Malebranche makes the material world not just a bare possibility but a redundant one too. 
 Besides finding the seeds of scepticism about a created world in Descartes and Malebranche, whose theories of perception involved both material things and ideas, Berkeley found them in Locke too. 
 He also found that Locke, once having made a similar distinction, provided no good reason for belief in a world over and above the ideas we have of it. 
 Unlike Descartes, who felt the need to prove their existence, and Malebranche, who was certain he could not, Locke simply had no doubt that material things existed and caused our ideas: &bquo;The actual receiving of ideas from without&hellip; makes us know, that something doth exist at that time without us, which causes that idea in us.&equo; 
 But he was completely unsure how matter could affect mind, and Berkeley fastened on this. 
 If we cannot understand how body &bquo;should imprint any idea in the mind&equo;, our having such ideas &bquo;can be no reason why we should suppose matter or corporeal substances, since that is acknowledged to remain equally inexplicable with, or without this supposition&equo;. 
 The scepticism towards which, in Berkeley's view, much seventeenth-century philosophy implicitly tended, is not unrelated to the traditional Greek scepticism which was brought to light in the sixteenth century. 
 The arguments rehearsed by Sextus Empiricus purported to show that, because perception of secondary qualities such as tastes and colours varied from person to person, we cannot know how things really are in respect of these. 
 But in the seventeenth century some philosophers, such as Descartes and Malebranche, had extended this to saying that tastes and colours are, like pains, simply subjective modifications, and are not properties of material objects after all. 
 Malebranche had argued, moreover, that the argument from the relativity of perception was just as applicable to primary qualities such as extension and motion: what looks small to me will seem large to a mite; some movements may be too slow for the human eye to detect. 
 Because of his Cartesianism, Malebranche could not go so far as to say that material objects were not really extended or in motion, but Pierre Bayle had argued that such restraint was unjustifiable. 
 In his Dictionary  (1697), Bayle points out that although the &bquo;new philosophers&equo; do not set out to be sceptics, they go even further in extending sceptical arguments to the conclusion that smells, colours, and tastes, &bquo;are perceptions of our soul and that they do not exist at all in the objects of our senses&equo;. 
 But, asks Bayle, why not go further still? 
 Why cannot the same thing be said about extension? 
 &bquo;Why could not an entity that had no extension be visible to us under the appearance of&hellip; extension?&equo; 
 Perception of extension is subject to relativities too, the same thing appearing to be different shapes according to our view. 
 So it is not by &bquo;their own real or absolute extension that bodies present themselves to our minds&equo;, and we have no reason not to conclude that &bquo;they are not extended in themselves&equo;. 
 From his reading of Descartes, Locke, Malebranche, and Bayle, Berkeley had become sensitive to, and appalled by, the sceptical tendencies of the new philosophy. 
 He might have rejected Malebranche's extension of the arguments about relativity of perception from secondary to primary qualities; he might have rejected the further conclusions Bayle said should be drawn from them. 
 But, with some appearance of paradox, he does not. 
 Instead, he wholeheartedly takes them over: they show up materialism as an inadequate position and leave the way open for his spiritual immaterialism, with God at its centre. 
 He would have preferred it had their arguments led directly to immaterialism, and showed not merely that we do not know what qualities material objects have, but indeed that they have none, or even that there are no such objects. 
 But although by themselves they do not take us this far, they do at least point the way. 
 They do show that primary qualities, as we experience them, are on an equal footing with secondary qualities, and are simply perceptions or ideas in the mind. 
 Why not, then, take the hint and cut through the sceptical problems the arguments invite, boldly saying that if all we know are ideas, then ideas are all there are? 
 Faced with the evidently troublesome distinction between things and ideas, Berkeley in effect collapses it; he concludes that ideas are things . 
 As he explains, &bquo;Those immediate objects of perception, which according to &lsqb;some&rsqb;&hellip; are only appearances of things, I take to be the real things themselves.&equo; 
 This is not to say that there are ideas and no things : that would be the ultimate scepticism. 
 What he proposes is to change &bquo;ideas into things&equo;; and to do this is not  to deny the existence of a world of things. 
 Certainly, he is denying the world of the philosophers, a world of objects beyond direct perception. 
 But he is not, he claims, denying the world of common sense, not denying the reality of a world of directly perceived objects. 
 Given the distinction, between ideas and things, which leads to scepticism, is it not wisest, asks Berkeley, to say that our ideas are  things, &bquo;to trust your senses, and laying aside all anxious thought about unknown natures and substances, admit with the vulgar those for real things, which are perceived by the senses&equo;? 
 But Berkeley's claims that his Immaterialism avoided the scepticism endemic in his predecessors, and restored philosophy to the beliefs of sound common sense, were not accepted. 
 His view that there is no reality other than minds or spirits, and their ideas, was taken to be scepticism run riot. 
 All Berkeley's arguments, according to Hume, &bquo;though otherwise intended, are, in reality, merely sceptical&equo;. 
 To Leibniz he was &bquo;The Irishman who attacks the reality of bodies&hellip; &lsqb;and&rsqb; belongs to the class of men who want to be known for their paradoxes&equo;. 
 Saying that he ought to be able to get through a closed door as easily as an open one, Swift is supposed to have left him standing on the doorstep. 
 Dr Johnson begged a Berkeleian not to take his leave from the group he was with, &bquo;for we may perhaps forget to think of you, and then you will cease to exist&equo;. 
 Berkeley robustly denied all this. 
 &bquo;We are not for having any man turn sceptic , and disbelieve his senses; on the contrary we give them all the stress and assurance imaginable; nor are there any principles more opposite to scepticism, than those we have laid down.&equo; 
 He is not, he says, one who &bquo;detracts from the existence or reality of things&equo;; and anyone who thinks otherwise &bquo;is very far from understanding what hath been premised in the plainest terms I could think of&equo;. 
 It is possible, however, that Berkeley's evident sensitivity to charges of scepticism is rooted not simply in his cherished hope that they are false, but also in some dim feeling that they are not completely unjust. 
 For indeed they are not, and it is understandable that they should have been made. 
 His proud boast is that &bquo;the same principles which at first lead to scepticism , pursued to a certain point, bring men back to common sense&equo;, and that rather than being a purveyor of wild and new paradoxes, he has &bquo;unite&lsqb;d&rsqb; and place&lsqb;d&rsqb; in a clearer light that truth, which was before shared between the vulgar and the philosophers&equo;. 
 What he has done, he explains, is to combine the belief of his philosophical predecessors that &bquo;the things immediately perceived, are ideas which exist only in the mind&equo; with the common-sense belief that &bquo;those things&hellip; &lsqb;we&rsqb; immediately perceive are the real things&equo;; and these two, put together &bquo;do in effect constitute the substance of what I advance&equo;. 
 But because he accepts something  from the philosophers' view, a view which leads to scepticism, he himself runs the risk of it. 
 Even though he does accept common-sense beliefs, he also accepts something from the philosophers which common sense would not. 
 With those he attacks he shares the premiss that all that we are directly aware of are ideas, which have no existence apart from a perceiving mind. 
 In doing so he diverges from common sense. 
 He is right to insist that he rejects the material world of philosophers , such as Descartes and Malebranche, a world that is only indirectly perceived  r=itvia  our ideas. 
 This is clearly what he  r=itwants  to reject. 
 But in agreeing with the philosophers that all we know are ideas, he runs the risk of rejecting altogether any real world. 
 The non-philosophical &bquo;vulgar&equo; do not think that all we know are ideas. 
 Berkeley's desire to support non-sceptical common sense, while accepting from the philosophers something common sense would not, gives an awkward complexity to what he says. 
 Berkeley sees that, to his identification of mental ideas with real things, &bquo;it will be objected that we see things actually without or at a distance from us, and which consequently do not exist in the mind&equo;. 
 The point that in dreams we see things &bquo;as existing at a great distance&equo; indicates that this objection can be answered, but he acknowledges that some explanation is needed. 
 Indeed, it was a consciousness of this problem that led to his earlier book, The New Theory of Vision . 
 Its conclusions are, in fact, more limited than those of the Principles . 
 They apply only to sight, and leave the reader assuming that, unlike what we see, what we touch exists independently of the mind. 
 But Berkeley already had his more general immaterialism in mind. 
 He saw the problem of visual  perception as a particular difficulty for it, and, wishing to proceed gradually, he intended the New Theory  to prepare the way for the Principles . 
 The New Theory  has two explicit aims: to reach an understanding of how objects can be perceived by sight as having size, position, and arrangement in space; and to discuss the differences between sight and touch. 
 Distance, says Berkeley, must be perceived by the mediation of something else for, &bquo;being a line directed end-wise to the eye&equo;, it is not perceived &bquo;of itself&equo;. 
 It had been held that we &bquo;judge of distance&equo; as we do &bquo;a conclusion in mathematics&hellip; by virtue of geometry and demonstration&equo;. 
 According to the science of optics, light travelling from objects enters the eyes at differing angles according to distance; the further away an object is, the more nearly parallel are the light rays from it. 
 Diagrams illustrating this are familiar from books on optics, and the idea was that distance is calculated and judged by means of these angles. 
 Berkeley denies that we go in for such calculations in judging distances. 
 We are not aware of these lines and angles of theoretical geometrical optics; they cannot be the intermediary by which we perceive distance. 
 What the intermediary is is awareness of our eye-movements. 
 According to distance, different eye-movements are required for focusing on different objects. 
 Berkeley infers from this that, lacking experience of such eye-movements, a blind man who gained sight &bquo;would, at first, have no idea of distance by sight; the sun and stars&hellip; would all seem to be in his eyes, or rather in his mind&equo;. 
 He argues further that what we see, &bquo;the immediate objects of sight&equo;, are not things in space at a distance from us, but ideas in the mind. 
 Our visual world is an immediately present one of colours and flat two-dimensional shapes. 
 When we say that what we see is a mile away, we must mean that were we to move forward a mile, we would be &bquo;affected with such and such ideas of touch&equo;; and so Berkeley concludes that the things we see are not the same as those we touch. 
 In the case of hearing and touch this is clear; strictly speaking, what we hear is not a coach in which we might travel, but rather its noise. 
 The same goes for the coach we see. 
 &bquo;A man no more sees and feels the same thing than he hears and feels the same thing.&equo; 
 Having explained judgements of distance, Berkeley turns to judgements of size. 
 Since what we see is not what we touch, and since the former are ideas in the mind, which change in size as we move forwards to some thing, the actual size he is concerned with must be that of the tangible object. 
 This, he says, is judged on the basis of the size, distinctness, and vigorousness of the visible object. 
 We learn from experience that certain visible appearances are connected with tactile objects of a certain size at a certain distance from us. 
 Distance and size, says Berkeley, are seen in the way that &bquo;we see shame or anger in the looks of a man&equo;; though invisible themselves, these feelings are &bquo;let in by the eye along with colours and alteration of countenance, which are the immediate objects of vision&equo;. 
 Moreover, just as the connection between certain looks and shame is one which we learn solely by experience, &bquo;without which&hellip; we should no more have taken blushing for a sign of shame than of gladness&equo;, so is the connection between certain visual experiences, and distance and size. 
 For Berkeley, then, what we see and what we touch are different things. 
 Visual size is not tactile size, visual extension and motion are not tactile extension and motion. 
 Why then, it will be asked, do &bquo;visible extension and figures come to be called the same name with tangible extension and figures, if they are not of the same kind with them&equo;? 
 Visible ideas are signs and indications of tangible ideas, and have a constant and universal connection with them which was &bquo;learnt at our first entrance into the world; and ever since, almost every moment of our lives, it has been occurring to our thoughts, and fastening and striking deeper on our minds.&equo; 
 It is no wonder that what we see becomes identified with, and spoken of as if it were the same as, what we touch. 
 The connection between the visible and the tangible is conceived by Berkeley as having been set up by God. 
 &bquo;The proper objects of vision constitute an universal language of the Author of Nature, whereby we are instructed how to regulate our actions in order to attain those things that are necessary to the preservation and well-being of our bodies.&equo; 
 Experience teaches us which tangible objects to expect after certain visible objects. 
 This &bquo;visual&equo; language is of immense use. 
 A sighted person can make predictions about the future course of tangible experience &mdash; falling over a precipice or hitting a wall &mdash; which to a blind man &bquo;seem as strange and unaccountable as prophecy doth to others&equo;. 
 The New Theory of Vision  explicitly teaches that what we see is not what we touch, and exists only in the mind, not in an external space. 
 But what of the mode of existence of tangible objects? 
 The quite unambiguous teaching of the Principles  is that they, too, are mind-dependent ideas. 
 All objects, such as trees, stones, and books, whether in their tangible or visible aspects, are such that their &bquo; esse  &lsqb;their mode of existence&rsqb; is percipi  &lsqb;to be perceived&rsqb;, nor is it possible they should have any existence, out of the minds or thinking things which perceive them&equo;. 
 Though the upshot of Berkeley's theory is relatively easy to grasp, what he says in its support is somewhat inadequate. 
 Consider, he says, that when we speak of the existence of a sensible thing we mean that we are  perceiving it by various of our senses, or could  perceive it were we suitably placed. 
 &bquo;The table I write on, I say, exists, that is, I see and feel it; and if I were out of my study I should say it existed, meaning thereby that if I was in my study I might perceive it.&equo; 
 This might seem reasonable enough. 
 It allows that the existence of a sensible thing need not consist in its actually being perceived  but, rather more weakly, in its being perceivable ; in allowing this it would certainly be more acceptable to common sense. 
 But it hardly supports the conclusion which, without further ado, Berkeley draws from it: that it is not possible that sensible things &bquo;should have any existence out of the minds or thinking things which perceive them&equo;. 
 According to this, the existence of sensible things consists solely in their actually being perceived . 
 That the argument will not do as it stands is, in fact, conceded in the Three Dialogues , where Berkeley allows Hylas to make the point that, although the existence of a sensible thing might consist in its being perceivable  (as in the premiss), it does not (a fixed upon matter&hellip; may&hellip; forget that there be such things in the world as Spirits&hellip; and at last that there is a God, and that their souls are immortal.&equo; 
 He advocated &bquo;Notional&equo; studies which, having &bquo;nothing to do with the senses&equo;, are &bquo;therefore more divine&equo;. 
 He suggested, also, that an undue concentration on the new natural philosophy might lead to a certain intellectual arrogance. 
 &bquo;May not a man go too far in this study, and overvalue his progress so far, as to think nothing out of his reach?&equo; 
 So farer argument Berkeley suggests that it would be a &bquo;manifest contradiction&equo; to suppose that sensible things might exist &bquo;unperceived&equo; or &bquo;distinct from&hellip; being perceived by the understanding&equo;. 
 He uses three premisses: that houses, mountains, and rivers, are what we perceive by sense; that what we perceive by sense are &bquo;our own ideas or sensations&equo;; and that ideas cannot exist unperceived. 
 He concludes from these that houses, mountains, and rivers cannot exist unperceived. 
 Given that &bquo;ideas&equo; are things which, like sensations and feelings, are essentially mind-dependent, the third premiss is something with which the philosophically sophisticated would agree; it is, too, something with which the vulgar, if persuaded to consider the matter, could easily be brought to agree. 
 The second, Berkeley says, is &bquo;evident&equo;. 
 No doubt it would have been so to Descartes, Malebranche, and Locke: they  might have agreed with Berkeley that what we perceive are ideas. 
 But it would hardly have been so to the &bquo;vulgar&equo;. 
 What would have been evident to them, of course, is the first premiss; so, although Berkeley's surprising conclusion follows validly from his three premisses, these are not all equally acceptable both to the &bquo;philosophers&equo; and to the common sense of the &bquo;vulgar&equo;. 
 Though accepting both the first and the third, the philosophically unsophisticated would reject the second. 
 Berkeley's predecessors, on the other hand, would accept both the second and the third, and reject the first. 
 The &bquo;contradiction&equo; in thinking that things might exist &bquo;distinct from&hellip; being perceived by the understanding&equo; is &bquo;manifest&equo; neither to the philosophers nor to vulgar common sense. 
 Despite his claim that he does not make things into ideas but only ideas into things, the feeling remains, as, in effect, Berkeley concedes, that &bquo;all that is real and substantial&hellip; is banished out of the world&equo;, and that everything has been made into &bquo;so many chimeras and illusions on the fancy&equo;. 
 He proceeds to show, therefore, that with only ideas at his disposal, he can nevertheless distinguish between reality and illusion. 
 There is, he says, &bquo;a rerum natura , and the distinction between realities and chimeras retains its full force &mdash; &lsqb;even though&rsqb; they both equally exist in the mind, and in that sense are alike ideas &equo;. 
 He points out that sometimes we have control over our ideas, and sometimes not: often we can set ourselves to imagine what we want; at other times, however, as in broad daylight, &bquo;it is not in my power to&hellip; determine what particular objects shall present themselves to my view&equo;. 
 Furthermore, it happens that our ideas are sometimes &bquo;more strong, lively, and distinct&equo; than at others. 
 Berkeley does not elaborate on this second point, but presumably is gesturing towards the difference between actually experiencing something, such as heat, and remembering or anticipating it. 
 Finally, ideas sometimes have a &bquo;steadiness, order, and coherence&equo; and come in &bquo;a regular train or series&equo;: &bquo;when we perceive by sight a certain round luminous figure, we at the same time perceive by touch the idea or sensation called heat .&equo; 
 Berkeley uses these three facts about ideas to distinguish &bquo;ideas of sense&equo; from &bquo;ideas of imagination&equo;. 
 Perception of reality is a matter of having &bquo;ideas of sense&equo;, which have the characteristics of being involuntary and not subject to our control, of being strong and lively, and of having a coherence and order. 
 Illusions, dreams, and fancies, on the other hand, consist of &bquo;ideas of imagination&equo; which are voluntary and subject to our wills, and which lack both lively strength and orderly coherence. 
 It appears to have escaped Berkeley's attention that not all imaginary things, for example a drunkard's pink rats, are voluntary and lack the vivacity of the real thing, and also that, when I set myself to imagine something, I can make my ideas as orderly and coherent as I like. 
 It is interesting to note that his three criteria for distinguishing reality from illusion can be found also in the works of those philosophers, such as Descartes and Locke, whose view he rejects. 
 Unlike Berkeley, they held that there are both ideas and a world of things which cause them. 
 But this does not mean that they did not face the troublesome question Berkeley faces, of how to distinguish between illusion and reality. 
 They still needed to explain when those ideas were faithful perceptions of a real world, and when not. 
 For them, however, the involuntariness, vivacity, and coherence of certain ideas is evidence that they are caused by  real things; for Berkeley it means they are  real things. 
 The notion of our sometimes involuntarily having ideas in coherent series, continues the New Theory of Vision  's doctrine that God has established connections between the ideas of sight and those of touch. 
 Unlike the voluntary &bquo;ideas of the imagination&equo;, which are the product of our own will, the involuntary &bquo;ideas of sense&equo; are produced in us by God. 
 Their being excited in us in an orderly fashion &bquo;gives us a sort of foresight, which enables us to regulate our actions for the benefit of life&equo;; and this testifies to God's wisdom and benevolence. 
 Berkeley's seventeenth-century predecessors were as anxious as he was to suggest that the regularity of nature is a manifestation of God's goodness; but in making an independent material world the cause of ideas, they give God a less crucial role than Berkeley does. 
 The uneasy feeling that, despite his claim to make things out of ideas, Berkeley has &bquo;banished all that is real and substantial out of the world&equo;, can be articulated by suggesting that, whatever philosophers might want to say about &bquo;real things&equo;, common sense will want to speak about them in ways which, at least at first sight, are not licensed by their being constructed out of ideas. 
 Ideas, it seems, cannot be made into things, because various truths about them are not suitable for transmutation into truths about things. 
 According to Berkeley, real things are dependent on, and do not exist outside of, perceiving minds; according to common sense, however, they are independent of our perception of them. 
 It does, therefore, seem to follow from Berkeley's view, that &bquo;bodies are annihilated and created every moment, or exist not at all during the intervals between our perception of them&equo;. 
 It is true that, by contrast with those that constitute &bquo;imaginary things&equo;, the ideas that constitute &bquo;real things&equo; are , for Berkeley, independent of the human mind: they are not subject to the voluntary control of the mind that perceives them. 
 But, at least to begin with, this is not sufficient. 
 Pains are not subject to our will, we do not choose to feel them, but this does not lead us to say that they have an existence independent of our experience of them. 
 Something more of the requisite independence could be achieved by Berkeley's doctrine that ideas which are not subject to our own will are produced in us by God: the independence of a real thing, its having some continuity despite interrupted perception of it, could be explained in terms of a continued readiness on God's part to excite the requisite ideas in us at suitable moments. 
 But although God does have the role in Berkeley's philosophy of accounting for the continued perceivability of real objects apart from our actual perception of them, it is not quite in the way we have just described. 
 So keen is Berkeley on the idea that the existence of real objects consists in their actually  being perceived, that he appears to explain their continuity, not by a readiness on God's part to excite ideas in us , but rather by God's own  continued perception. 
 &bquo;When I deny things in an existence out of the mind, I do not mean my own mind in particular, but all minds. 
 &hellip; There is also some other mind &lsqb;i.e. God's&rsqb; wherein they exist, during the intervals between the times of my perceiving them.&equo; 
 And this  explanation fails to solve a further problem. 
 Besides having a continuous existence independent of perception, the real things of common sense are public . 
 Not only do I suppose that the desk in my study exists when neither I nor anyone else is there to perceive it, I suppose that I, and everyone else, can perceive the same  desk. 
 Berkeley's making of ideas into things needs to do justice to the thought that we all (including God, for Berkeley) perceive the same things. 
 If the continuity of real things consists in their actual perception by God, in what does their publicity (to us, and also to God) consist? 
 Berkeley's account of continuity seems unable to explain publicity in any way sufficiently akin to that of the perception-independent world of vulgar common sense. 
 Given his belief that the idea that objects exist independently of a perceiving mind contains &bquo;a manifest contradiction&equo;, one might expect Berkeley to provide some explanation of why anyone should mistakenly have it. 
 He goes some way towards doing this in terms of what he calls &bquo;the doctrine of abstract ideas&equo;. 
 According to this, we can have, for example, an idea of colour alone and as such , an idea abstracted from any thought of particular extended things with their particular colours. 
 It thus lends support to the materialistic view that it makes sense to think of objects in abstraction from a mind which perceives them. 
 Can there be, Berkeley asks, &bquo;a nicer strain of abstraction than to distinguish the existence of sensible objects from their being perceived, so as to conceive them existing unperceived&equo;? 
 So sure is Berkeley of the ultimate impossibility of this abstraction that he even says that he will let his whole case rest on it. 
 Why cannot one think of &bquo;sensible things&equo; such as trees and tables apart from their being sensed? 
 &bquo;Surely there is nothing easier than to imagine trees&hellip; in a park&hellip; and nobody by to perceive them.&equo; 
 According to Berkeley, this does not show that he is wrong. 
 One can indeed imagine a tree without anyone perceiving or having ideas of it, but in imagining it one is oneself  having ideas of it. 
 &bquo;The mind, taking no notice of itself, is deluded to think it can and doth conceive bodies&hellip; without the mind.&equo; 
 Despite Berkeley's comment that &bquo;a little attention&equo; to this will enable anyone to see how successfully it makes his point, this argument has provoked a considerable amount of detailed discussion. 
 In Berkeley's view, the mistaken doctrine of abstraction is also involved in the distinction between primary and secondary qualities, a distinction which he rejects along with the materialism it involves. 
 It cannot be, he says, that &bquo;figure, motion, and the rest of the primary or original qualities do exist without the mind&hellip; &lsqb;while&rsqb; colours, sounds, heat, cold, and such like secondary qualities&hellip; are sensations existing in the mind alone&equo;, for &bquo;extension, figure, and motion, abstracted from all other qualities, are inconceivable&equo;. 
 Primary qualities must, therefore, be &bquo;where&hellip; the other sensible qualities are&hellip; to wit, in the mind and nowhere else&equo;. 
 In the Introduction to the Principles , Berkeley spends a considerable time arguing against the doctrine of abstract ideas. 
 This is justified by his belief that abstractionism does more than obscure the truth of immaterialism. 
 The &bquo;Principles&equo; of his title are those &bquo;of Human Knowledge&equo;, and what motivates his objection to materialism is that it leads to scepticism and atheism. 
 Materialism is a &bquo;false principle&equo; which &bquo;stay&lsqb;s&rsqb; and embarrass&lsqb;es&rsqb; the mind in its search after truth&equo;; it raises specious problems, it draws us &bquo;into uncouth paradoxes, difficulties, and inconsistencies, which multiply and grow upon us as we advance in speculation&equo;. 
 Now although Berkeley pictures the doctrine of abstraction as a support of the &bquo;false principle&equo; of materialism, it is additionally a &bquo;false principle&equo; in its own right. 
 &bquo;Besides the external existence of the objects of perception, another great source of errors and difficulties, with regard to ideal knowledge, is the doctrine of abstract ideas .&equo; 
 Directly and of its own accord, it has &bquo;not a little contributed towards spoiling the most useful parts of knowledge&equo;: &bquo;the plainest things in the world, those we are most intimately acquainted with, and perfectly know, when they are considered in an abstract way, appear strangely difficult and incomprehensible.&equo; 
 The doctrine of abstract ideas stems from a concern with what, when it was debated in the Middle Ages, was called &bquo;the problem of universals&equo;. 
 Though Berkeley's interest in the problem connects with his immaterialism, he is continuing a discussion to which not only the Aristotelians, but also Hobbes, Gassendi, and Locke, made contributions. 
 It will be convenient, therefore, to make some mention of their views on the matter. 
 considered in an abstract way, appear strangely difficult and incomprehensible.&equo; 
 The doctrine of abstract ideas stems from a concern with what, when it was debated in the Middle Ages, was called &bquo;the problem of universals&equo;. 
 Though Berkeley's interest in the problem connects with his immaterialism, he is continuing a discussion to which not only the Aristotelians, but also Hobbes, Gassendi, and Locke, made contributions. 
 It will be convenient, therefore, to make some mention of their views on the matter. 
 These views concern the fact that the singular particular things which we can point to and pick out with the words &bquo;this&equo; and &bquo;that&equo;, and to which we often give names, such as &bquo;James&equo; or &bquo;John&equo;, are not thought of as being merely  particular. 
 Like many other particulars, James and John are both men; &bquo;this&equo; and &bquo;that&equo; may both be triangles. 
 What, then, is the mode of existence of these general &bquo;universals&equo;, such as &bquo;man&equo; or &bquo;triangle&equo;; and how do they figure in our knowledge and thought? 
 How, that is, do they relate to the particular things which are instances of them, and to our minds when we think of those things as  men, or as  triangles? 
 According to &bquo;realist&equo; theories, such as those of Plato and Aristotle, besides the particular things we perceive, there are &bquo;universals&equo; which are essentially general. 
 For Plato these &bquo;universals&equo; were located as ideal Forms in an abstract world which was accessible to our intellect and thought. 
 The particular things of the perceptible world &bquo;partook&equo; or &bquo;shared&equo; in them. 
 According to the less extreme realism of Aristotle and many of his followers, &bquo;universals&equo; were dependent for their existence on sensible particulars, which &bquo;embodied&equo; them, often as their &bquo;forms&equo; or &bquo;natures&equo;. 
 A particular man is some matter with the general form of humanity &bquo;impressed&equo; on it. 
 By a process of &bquo;abstraction&equo;, moreover, it was possible for these general notions to be &bquo;impressed&equo; on our minds or intellects, thus making it possible for us to think in terms of them. 
 In the Middle Ages such realist theories were often denied. 
 There are, it was said, no essentially general entities, whether existing apart from particular things, or embodied in them. 
 All things that exist are particular and singular. 
 At times this anti-realism took the form of an extreme nominalism, according to which the words &bquo;man&equo; and &bquo;triangle&equo; are general only in that they are used of a number of different things. 
 There is no general nature in common to those things, and any idea we have is never general or abstract, but always of some particular thing. 
 On this view, the generality of the word &bquo;man&equo; is no different from that of &bquo;John&equo; which, after all, can itself be used of a number of things. 
 At other times the anti-realism took a conceptualist form, according to which universality is a matter of our ideas or concepts. 
 Though all things that exist in the extra-mental world are particulars and singular, it is nevertheless possible for us to form essentially general or abstract ideas. 
 Hobbes was certainly an avowed anti-realist. 
 For him there was &bquo;nothing in the world universal but names; for the things named are every one of them individual and singular&equo;. 
 But whether he was a pure or consistent nominalist is unclear. 
 He does say that the word &bquo;universal&equo; is &bquo;never the name of any thing existent in nature, nor of any idea or phantasm found in the mind&equo;. 
 When &bquo;man&equo;, &bquo;stone&equo;, or &bquo;living creature&equo; is said to be &bquo;universal&equo;, we are not to understand that &bquo;man, stone&equo;, etc. ever was or can be universal, but only that these words, &bquo;living creature&equo;, &bquo;stone&equo;, etc., are universal names , that is, names common to many things. 
 Thus the name &bquo;man&equo; is simply a name used for a number of particulars, and any idea of &bquo;man&equo; is always an idea of some particular man, and simply reminds us of other particulars. 
 Yet it is not arbitrary that the idea of this particular should remind us of these and not other particulars, and that these and not the other particulars should have the same name used of them. 
 &bquo;One universal name is imposed on many things, for their similitude in some quality.&equo; 
 This reference to similitude is suggestive of realism, in its invocation of some common, shared, universal property. 
 Gassendi was an anti-realist too. 
 In answer to &bquo;obscure and spurious questions such as whether universals may exist by themselves, whether they are only in the mind, whether they exist separate from things or only with them&equo;, he says that these &bquo;great universals are nothing more than&hellip; common nouns&hellip; that can be applied to more than one object&equo;. 
 He agrees, then, with what he ironically calls &bquo;that mad opinion&equo;, that there is &bquo;no universality outside of thoughts or names&equo;. 
 Unlike Hobbes, however, he allows that ideas or concepts can be general, universal, or abstract, and need not be of particulars. 
 He talks of forming &bquo;the universal concept of a man from having seen Plato, Socrates, and others&equo;. 
 He speaks, too, of properties which Plato and Socrates &bquo;share&equo;, and of their &bquo;similarity&equo; to each other, and this again seems to reintroduce an element of realism. 
 Locke's views on this matter are similar to Gassendi's, but are developed at greater length. 
 How, he asks, &bquo;come we by general terms, or where find we those general natures they are supposed to stand for?&equo; 
 Unlike Hobbes, he does not think that words are general by being collective names for a number of particulars; &bquo;they do not signify a plurality.&equo; 
 They are general by being &bquo;made the signs of general ideas&equo;. 
 As for these general ideas, ideas of particular things, they come to be general by our &bquo;separating from them&hellip; &lsqb;any detail&rsqb;&hellip; that may determine them to this or that particular existence&equo;. 
 Thus, the abstract &bquo;idea&equo; of &bquo;man&equo;, what Locke calls a nominal essence, differs from that of &bquo;Peter&equo; and &bquo;Paul&equo; 'in the leaving out something, that is peculiar to each individual; and retaining so much of those particular complex ideas, of several particular existences, as they are found to agree in.&equo; 
 For Locke, then, &bquo;general words signify&hellip; a sort of thing&equo;; and they do this by being a sign of an abstract idea or nominal essence in the mind, &bquo;to which idea, as things existing are found to agree, so they come to be ranked under that name; or&hellip; be of that sort&equo;. 
 In urging against the Aristotelian realists that &bquo;general and universal, belong not to the real existence of things; but are the inventions and creatures of the understanding&equo;, he is, of course, reaffirming from a different angle his rejection of their &bquo;forms&equo;, and their talk of the possibility of there being &bquo;real&equo; definitions of things. 
 Though Berkeley mentions the scholastics, &bquo;those great masters of abstraction&equo;, it is Locke on whom he particularly focuses in his criticism of abstract ideas. 
 &bquo;Whether others have this wonderful faculty of abstracting their ideas &equo;, he ironically says, &bquo;they best can tell.&equo; 
 For his part, he cannot &bquo;abstract one from another, or conceive separately, those qualities which it is impossible should exist so separated&equo;. 
 He cannot form an idea of extension as such , which is &bquo;neither line, surface, nor solid, nor has any figure or magnitude but is an idea entirely prescinded from all these&equo;. 
 He cannot &bquo;frame a general notion by abstracting from particulars&equo; to form an &bquo;abstract idea&equo; of &bquo;man&equo; 'wherein, it is true there is included colour, because there is no man but has some colour, but then it can be neither white nor black, nor any particular colour; because there is no one particular colour wherein all men partake.&equo; 
 For Berkeley, an idea must be an idea of a particular, a particular line, or a particular man. 
 This means that ideas cannot be abstract , but it does not mean that they cannot be general . 
 A general use  can be made of ideas of particulars. 
 The idea of a particular line can be &bquo;made to represent or stand for all other particular lines of the same sort&equo;. 
 A justification for talk of abstract ideas is that it provides an explanation of how our thought and knowledge can be general; &bquo;how we can know any proposition to be true of all particular triangles, except we have first seen it demonstrated of the abstract idea of a triangle.&equo; 
 Berkeley's suggestion that particular, non-abstract ideas can be general in their use enables him to do this. 
 Geometrical demonstrations which prove something to be true of all triangles do not do so by proving it to be true of an abstract triangle to which all triangles correspond. 
 &bquo;The idea I have in view whilst I make the demonstration&equo; may be of a particular  right-angled triangle with sides of a certain length, but I may, nevertheless, be sure that it holds of all right-angled triangles if, by not mentioning the ways in which it differs from them, I use this one to stand for them all. 
 Though &bquo;the diagram I have in view&equo; includes particular details, &bquo;there is not the least mention made of them in the proof of the proposition.&equo; 
 In what ways have the false doctrine of abstraction, and the equally mistaken materialism to which it lends support, been a &bquo;great source of errors and difficulties&equo; in our search for knowledge? 
 What &bquo;disputes and speculations, which are esteemed no mean parts of learning, are rejected as useless&equo; by the adoption of correct principles of knowledge? 
 Berkeley remarks that the opinion that words like &bquo;good&equo; and &bquo;happiness&equo; &bquo;stand for general notions abstracted from all particular persons and actions&equo; has &bquo;rendered morality difficult, and the study thereof of less use to mankind&equo;. 
 He also points out, in passing, that various questions of the sort which have cropped up in earlier chapters of this book, such as whether matter can think, and how it produces mental sensations, &bquo;are entirely banished from philosophy&equo; by the adoption of immaterialism. 
 He says rather more, however, about their ill effects on natural philosophy, mathematics, and religion. 
 So far as natural philosophy, the first of &bquo;the two great provinces of speculative science, conversant about ideas received from sense&equo;, is concerned, the confusion engendered by materialism is great. 
 As Berkeley points out, sceptics &bquo;exaggerate, and love to enlarge on&equo; that part of the seventeenth-century picture of the world according to which independently existing material things have a real essence of which we are ignorant. 
 &bquo;We are miserably bantered, say they, by our senses, and amused only with the outside and show of things.&equo; 
 Given Berkeley's immaterialism, however, the idea that things have real essences (be they scholastic forms or corpuscular constitutions), which are the cause of their properties, simply has no place. 
 Natural philosophy should not be thought deficient because we are ignorant of the ultimate causes of the characteristic properties and regular behaviour of things. 
 Such uniformities and regularities are not part of an independent material world, but simply a matter of what ideas God excites in our minds. 
 They are not &bquo;the result of any immutable habitudes, or relations between things themselves, but only of God's goodness and kindness to men in the administration of the world&equo;. 
 Since there are no natures or essences, there is nothing closed to natural philosophy. 
 It can do all there is for it to do, which is to discover regularities among our God-given ideas, and to systematize these in the most useful way. 
 In Chapter 5 we saw how natural philosophers, such as Boyle, tried to defend themselves against charges of encouraging materialistic atheism by suggesting that, since the natural world is God's creation, the study of it leads towards, not away from, things spiritual. 
 An argument of this kind seems much more plausible when proposed by Berkeley; it no longer seems like special pleading when set against the background of his God-centred, immaterialist view of the natural world. 
 Berkeley offers Newton's achievements in illustration of how the hidden rules, or &bquo;laws of nature&equo;, by which God excites ideas in us can be discerned and systematized. 
 Newton was sufficiently imaginative to see not only that &bquo;there is something alike&equo; in the falling of a stone and the rising of the tides, but also that all bodies &bquo;have a mutual tendency towards each other&equo;. 
 Berkeley believes, however, that Newton's presentation of his theories in his Principia  or Mathematical Principles of Natural Philosophy  (1687) were flawed by his tendency to abstractionism. 
 The talk of absolute , as well as relative, time, motion, and space, wrongly supposes &bquo;those quantities to have an existence without the mind&equo;, and conceives them in abstraction from our observations. 
 Mathematics is the second of &bquo;the two great provinces of speculative science&equo; to which Berkeley turns his attention. 
 He is forthright in his view that its practitioners, too, are involved in &bquo;the errors arising from the doctrine of abstract ideas, and the existence of objects without the mind&equo;. 
 His worry is not that these errors undermine any of their actual results: &bquo;that the principles laid down by mathematicians are true, and their way of deduction from those principles clear and incontestable, we do not deny.&equo; 
 It is, rather, that the errors that they make permeate their philosophy of mathematics, their account of its foundations, of what their subject is about, and in what direction it should develop. 
 Arithmeticians fail to see that the function of numerical symbols and signs is to enable us to deal in general ways with groups of particular sensible things. 
 They think, instead, that they stand for &bquo;abstract ideas of number &equo;, which they take to be the province of their subject. 
 This misconception has meant that their work has not been &bquo;subservient to practice&equo;, and able to &bquo;promote the benefit of life&equo;. 
 It has meant that it has been &bquo;abstracted from&hellip; all use and practice&equo;, and has become a purely speculative matter of &bquo;high flights and abstractions&equo;. 
 Since numerals do not stand for &bquo;numbers in abstract&equo; but for &bquo;particular things numbered&equo;, the misguided interest in the properties of such abstractions has really been a trifling concern with mere language or formalism. 
 As for geometers, their work is misdirected not only, as in arithmetic, by a false belief in abstract ideas, but also by the erroneous materialism that the &bquo;objects of sense exist without the mind&equo;. 
 For these mistakes have led to the belief that extension , the subject-matter of geometry, is infinitely divisible, a belief &bquo;thought to have so inseparable and essential a connection with the principles and demonstrations in geometry, that mathematicians never&hellip; make the least question of it&equo;. 
 In its turn, this belief has led to &bquo;geometrical paradoxes&equo;, and is &bquo;the principal occasion of all that nice and extreme subtility which renders the study of mathematics  so difficult and tedious&equo;. 
 According to Berkeley, however, finite extension is not infinitely divisible, and any problems and questions which rely on its being so are spurious. 
 Any particular finite extension is simply an idea in our minds, and cannot have more parts than the finite number we perceive it to have. 
 It is only when one supposes that, as well as such ideas, there is either &bquo;extension in abstract&equo; or extended, external, material things which might have parts we cannot perceive, that one might come to believe in the infinite divisibility of finite extension. 
 For Berkeley, human knowledge must be concerned either with ideas, or with the minds or spirits which perceive them; for apart from these there is nothing. 
 Mathematics and natural philosophy are concerned with ideas, and Berkeley now turns from them to spirits, of which God is a special case. 
 We have been thought to be &bquo;ignorant of the nature of spirits&equo;, he says, because we have no &bquo;idea&equo; of spirit. 
 In fact, however, our knowledge here is not so deficient as has been imagined. 
 It is, indeed, true that we do have no &bquo;idea&equo; of spirit. 
 It is &bquo;manifestly impossible there should be any such idea &equo;, for we can have no sensory experience of spirits. 
 They are active things which perceive, think, and will, and these properties cannot be represented in a passive idea. 
 But this does not mean that the words &bquo;soul&equo;, &bquo;spirit&equo;, or &bquo;spiritual substance&equo; are meaningless. 
 In the Dialogues  Berkeley shows awareness of the possible accusation of unfair dealing: he admits &bquo;spiritual substance; although &lsqb;we&rsqb;&hellip; have no idea of it&equo;, while he denies that &bquo;there can be such a thing as material substance, because &lsqb;we&rsqb;&hellip; have no notion or idea of it&equo;. 
 His reply is that we have no idea of material substance because matter is an impossibility and could not exist; whereas, though we can have no sensory idea of spiritual substance, minds are not an impossibility and could exist. 
 Indeed, one knows by reflection that one's own soul or mind does exist. 
 Though Berkeley offers little explanation of this last claim about our own  minds, he says more about our knowledge of the existence of other minds. 
 Both other spirits like ours, and God, are known &bquo;by their operations, or the ideas by them excited in us&equo;. 
 Spirits are not perceived by sense; they are not ideas but things which have ideas. 
 But we do perceive people's bodies , and these behave in such a way as to show that they are accompanied by &bquo;a distinct principle of thought and motion &lsqb;i.e. a mind&rsqb; like to ourselves&equo;. 
 It is in a similar way that the existence of God is revealed to us. 
 The only difference is &bquo;that whereas some one finite and narrow assemblage of ideas denotes a particular human mind, whithersoever we direct our view, we do at all times and in all places perceive manifest tokens of the divinity&equo;. 
 At the end of the Principles , Berkeley reminds us that his &bquo;main drift and design&equo; has been to &bquo;inspire my readers with a pious sense of the presence of God&equo;. 
 His success in this depends directly on the success of his immaterialism, for it is obvious how it continually points the way towards God. 
 Though there are some things which &bquo;human agents are concerned in producing&equo;, it is plain that &bquo;the works of Nature, that is, the far greater parts of the ideas or sensations produced in us, are not produced by, or dependent on, the wills of men&equo;. 
 They must be produced by some other spirit, and if we attend to their &bquo;constant regularity, order,&hellip; magnificence, beauty, and perfection&equo;, we see that they must be produced by an &bquo;eternal, infinitely wise, good, and perfect&equo; spirit, which is God. 
 Materialism, on the other hand, leads us away from God. 
 It leads either to problems about the relation between God and the world (for example, to a denial that it is His creation) or, as in the case of &bquo;Epicureans, Hobbists, and the like&equo;, to the attempt to reduce everything to matter. 
 &bquo;How great a friend material substance hath been to atheists  in all ages, were needless to relate. 
 All their monstrous systems have so visible and necessary a dependence on it, that when this corner-stone is once removed, the whole fabric cannot choose but fall to the ground.&equo; 
 According to David Hume, the subject of the next chapter, Berkeley's account of abstract ideas was &bquo;one of the greatest and most valuable discoveries that has been made of late years in the republic of letters&equo;. 
 Berkeley held, as we have seen, that an abstract general idea is simply an idea of a particular thing used to stand for other such ideas; and it is clear that what Hume applauds is Berkeley's refusal to accept any ideas other than those of immediate and concrete experience. 
 It is just this denial of anything beyond what is directly given in experience that marks Berkeley out as an empiricist. 
 His attempt to identify the real world of perceived objects with our perception of it, and his denial of any experience-independent material reality, are the most obvious examples of this. 
 But his account of natural philosophy, which rejects any inner mechanisms or real essences &bquo;hid&hellip; behind the scenes&equo; which would purport to explain &bquo;those appearances which are seen on the theatre of the world&equo;, is a clear example too. 
 Indeed, just as Berkeley's immaterialism foreshadows the phenomenalist theory of perception developed by the so-called Logical Empiricists of this century, so his view, according to which the aim of science is not to provide explanations of nature's regularities but only to arrive at concise and useful descriptions of them, foreshadows their instrumentalism. 
 Despite Berkeley's claim that &bquo;we do at all times and in all places perceive manifest tokens of the divinity&equo;, the important place occupied by God in his philosophy will inevitably seem as far removed from immediate experience as the material world of seventeenth-century philosophy seemed to Berkeley. 
 We should not forget, however, that Berkeley's own commitments are to God rather than to the predetermined demands of some idealized empiricism. 
 COMMON LAW AND EQUITY 
 Equity and morality 
 Apart from Common Law and Statute Law, the most important department of our legal system is Equity. 
 We sometimes use the term &bquo;equity&equo;, or words corresponding to it, in popular language as if it was something altogether outside law. 
 We speak of a judgement in a particular case or of a rule laid down in a judgement as being undoubtedly according to law, but as being &bquo;unfair&equo; or &bquo;unjust&equo; or &bquo;inequitable&equo;. 
 In cases of this sort we are really passing a moral judgement upon the law. 
 Such a moral judgement in no way affects the law. 
 It may be a reason why the law should be altered by statute; it does not prevent it from being law, or affect its operation, as long as no alteration in the law is made by statute. 
 But when a modern lawyer uses the terms &bquo;law&equo; and &bquo;equity&equo; he does not mean to say that equity is not law. 
 He is speaking really of two different kinds of law &mdash; the Common Law on the one side, the rules of Equity on the other &mdash; which are equally law. 
 They are rules which are not merely morally but legally binding: they are enforced by the courts. 
 The relation between law and equity 
  The distinction between law and equity occurs in other systems. 
 Thus the ius honorarium , developed by the praetor's edict, played a vital part in the development of Roman Law. 
 But while in Rome ius honorarium  was administered in the same courts as the ius civile , in England law and equity, until the judicature Act 1873 came into effect in 1875, were administered in different courts. 
  These two sets of rules, though distinct, must not be looked upon as two co-ordinate and independent systems. 
 On the contrary, the rules of Equity are only a sort of supplement or appendix to the Common Law; they assume its existence but they add something further. 
 In this way Equity is an addendum  to the Common Law. 
  Further, the rules of Equity, though they did not contradict the rules of Common Law, in effect and in practice produced a result opposed to that which would have been produced if the Common Law rules had remained alone. 
 A Common Law right was practically, though not theoretically, nullified by the existence of a countervailing equitable right. 
 In this sense we may speak of a &bquo;conflict or variance&equo; between the rules of Law and the rules of Equity, in the language of section 25 (sub-section 11) of the judicature Act 1873 (now replaced by section 49 of the Supreme Court Act 1981). 
  Though since the judicature Act came into force in 1875 the rules of Common Law and Equity are recognized and administered in the same court, yet they still remain distinct bodies of law, governed largely by different principles. 
 In order to ascertain the rights to which any given set of facts give rise, we must always ask  what is the rule of Common Law?  what difference (if any) is made in the working of this rule by the existence of some rule of Equity applying to the case? 
  Like the Common Law, the rules of Equity are judicial law, i.e. to find them we must look in the first instances to the decisions of the judges who have administered Equity. 
 But some branches of Equity, like some branches of the Common Law, have been restated with amendments and additions in codifying Acts, such as the Partnership Act 1890. 
 History 
 At the end of the thirteenth century we find three great courts definitely established: King's Bench, Common Pleas, Exchequer. 
 All are King's Courts, as opposed to the Communal Courts of counties and hundreds, Lord's Courts, or Ecclesiastical Courts. 
 Each has its proper sphere, but in course of time each of them extends its jurisdiction, so that the same matters may often be dealt with indifferently by any one of them. 
 All these three administer substantially the same law, which, by the time of Edward I, is already called Common Law, because it is a law common to the whole of England; and it is becoming a fairly definite body of rules, capable of growth and expansion in various directions, but still with well-marked boundaries which cannot be transgressed. 
 These courts continued to exist till 1875, and are known as the Common Law Courts. 
 Standing outside these courts is the Chancellor. 
 He is not originally a judge, nor has he a court. 
 He is the head of a great Government office &mdash; what may be called the secretarial office; he is &bquo;the King's Secretary of State for all departments&equo;; whatever writing has to be done in the King's name is done by the Chancellor or through him and his officers. 
 In one way the Chancellor is already brought into relation with the administration of justice, though not so as to enable him to modify the law at his pleasure. 
 The writs, i.e. the King's commands that a person shall appear in one of the King's Courts in answer to a claim, are issued in his name, as they still are today, and are issued from his office. 
 Many writs are already framed and well recognized to meet the cases that usually arise; you can have them for the asking, if you pay the fee. 
 The question whether a man who considers himself wronged has a claim which he can make good will depend on the answer to the question: Is there a writ to meet his case or, if there is not one, can one be framed which the King's Courts will hold good? 
 The Chancery, i.e. the Chancellor's office, has a power (Statute of Westminster II 1285) of framing new writs in cansimili casu  &mdash; i.e. to meet new cases sufficiently like those for which writs already exist &mdash; and new writs are from time to time framed. 
 But here the Common Law Courts manage to get the last word; for they acquired the power, in the fifteenth century, to decide whether the writ is good or not, and if not, the fact that the plaintiff has got the writ will not help him. 
 In deciding whether a writ is good or not the judges will be guided by the already accepted Common Law principles. 
 Now it will sometimes happen that the working of the law and procedure of the Common Law Courts will result in particular cases in injustice and hardship. 
 We might feel inclined to say: Well, that is a pity, but it would be a greater evil to interfere; it would be worse to make the law uncertain than to leave a particular hardship unredressed. 
 That was not the way that our ancestors looked at the matter. 
 Law and morality were not yet clearly distinguished, nor could one even say that the whole of law or justice was to be found in any one court; the Ecclesiastical Courts, and Local Courts of many different kinds, administered a justice which was not the justice of the Common Law Courts; so the thought was natural that even the King's justice was not exhausted in the power conferred on his courts. 
 A reserve of justice remained with the King, and so those who could not get relief in the King's ordinary courts might, with some hope of success, petition the King and his Council for redress, if not as a matter of right at least as a favour. 
 These petitions in practice were referred to the Chancellor, who was the chief minister and secretary and the most learned member of the King's Council. 
 In course of time these petitions came to be addressed direct to the Chancellor himself. 
 Putting aside what does not concern us here, cases where the petitioner asked for redress against the King himself, we may note two kinds of cases where this extraordinary relief is asked for: 
  where the petitioner has suffered an undoubted legal wrong &mdash; been assaulted and beaten, or turned out of his property, but for some reason cannot get redress, because he is poor and his opponent is rich and powerful, because juries are corrupt or timid. 
 In this class of cases redress was given in the Middle Ages sometimes by the King's Council and sometimes by the Chancellor. 
 In the sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries this jurisdiction was abandoned by the Chancellor and passed to the Court of Star Chamber. 
 When the Court was abolished in 1641 the Common Law Courts had become strong enough to give adequate redress. 
  Cases of transactions which give, at any rate, a moral right, but a right which the Common Law Courts cannot or will not protect. 
 In particular we find the cases of what are called &bquo;uses&equo; or trusts &mdash; transactions whereby a man legally transfers land to another, but with an understanding that the transferee will hold it for the benefit of the former, or for the benefit of those whom he will name in his will. 
 The Common Law has already very strict notions as to the kinds of rights in land which it will protect, and the methods of transfer which it will allow. 
 Uses and trusts the Common Law will not recognize; wills of land, it has decided, are void (unless established by local custom &mdash; it was not till 1540 that a statute was passed giving power to leave land by will). 
 But the practice of creating these uses and trusts was popular and was growing, and the absence of all legal protection for them was a great hardship. 
 So we find, by the end of the fourteenth century, that persons are directing petitions to the Chancellor, claiming that they have at least a moral right to the benefit of these uses, and begging him to give them help against the legal owner who is setting up his Common Law rights against them. 
 Now the Chancellor is at this time usually an ecclesiastic, commonly a bishop, and, as such, interested in, and, at least in his own opinion, a good judge of questions of morality or &bquo;conscience&equo;. 
 He is commonly spoken of as the keeper of the King's conscience. 
 What can he do to help the humble  suppliant ? 
 He cannot interfere directly with the proceedings of the Common Law Courts; he cannot issue a new writ which will have much chance of being held good by those courts. 
 But he can do this: he considers the petition, or Bill, as it is called; if he thinks there is anything in the case, he issues a writ which requires the person complained against to appear, not in a Common Law Court, but before himself, and answer the petition on oath. 
 The writ is called a subpoena , because it requires him to appear upon pain of forfeiting a sum of money. 
 When the defendant comes before the Chancellor, he will have to answer the Bill on oath. 
 This is very different from the Common Law procedure, which will never compel, or even allow (at that time), one of the parties to an action to give evidence; but it is a procedure, and the only procedure, which is suitable for trying such questions as uses and trusts, for which no open public acts, no formal documents may be available as evidence. 
 So, too, the Chancellor tries the whole case himself; he does not &mdash; as must be done in Common Law cases &mdash; send it to be tried by a jury. 
 It is true that in later times particular questions arising in a case before him, suitable for trial by jury, are sometimes directed by the Chancellor to be so tried. 
 Suppose now that the Chancellor has decided in favour of the petitioner, and has held that the land which legally belongs to the defendant ought to belong, or, &bquo;in conscience&equo;, in equity, morally, does belong to the petitioner. 
 What will he do? 
 He cannot reverse the rule of Common Law; he cannot interfere &mdash; at least directly &mdash; with proceedings in the Common Law Court; he cannot say that the legal owner is not  the legal owner. 
 What he can do is to say that the legal owner cannot in conscience, in equity, make use of his Common Law right for his own benefit; he must use it for the benefit of the man for whom he holds it in trust. 
 He does not stop at saying so. 
 He can, if the legal owner will not act as equity and conscience dictate, punish him, if necessary, by putting him in prison. 
 He can even indirectly, but effectively, interfere with the legal owner's attempts to enforce his legal rights by action in the Common Law Courts. 
 He cannot forbid the Common Law Courts to try an action; but he can forbid a man to bring it, or to go on with it, or to take advantage of the judgement which he has got, and can put him in prison if he does not obey. 
 He has the less scruple in issuing such orders because he can say that he is really doing what is in the man's own highest interest. 
 If he is doing what is against conscience, he is injuring his soul &mdash; remember that the Chancellor is an ecclesiastic &mdash; and it is better that he should be prevented from inflicting such injury on himself. 
 This sort of interference, which had started as a matter of special favour in special cases, gradually becomes a regular practice. 
 It becomes popular; uses and trusts become part of the ordinary machinery by which people deal with their property; they even lend themselves to abuse, which has to be checked by Acts of Parliament in the fourteenth, fifteenth, and sixteenth centuries. 
 The Chancellor develops what in effect is, and comes to be known as, a court &mdash; the Court of Chancery. 
 And then that general principle of Equity, which began as the mere application of moral sense to particular cases, develops into more and more definite rules. 
 If a Chancellor has decided that certain conduct in one case is against conscience, he is likely to decide that similar conduct is against conscience in another: the chances are that another Chancellor will decide the same. 
 You get what in reality is a new set of rules of law &mdash; rules which you can rely on as likely or certain to be applied uniformly in the future. 
 And you get a new set of rights &mdash; rights which can be enforced in the Chancellor's Court side by side with the Common Law rights, which alone can be enforced in the Common Law Courts, the former in effect, though not in theory, overriding the latter. 
 You even get to think of two sorts of ownership. 
 From saying that a thing ought to belong to a man, that it ought to be used for his benefit, you come to saying that it actually is  his, &bquo;in equity&equo; or &bquo;in conscience&equo;. 
 A few points in the development of Equity may be here noted. 
 In 1535 Henry VIII struck a blow at uses in the Statute of Uses. 
 The King's main object in forcing the Act through Parliament was to regain the revenue from the perquisites enjoyed by a feudal lord and paid or owed by his tenants, known as the incidents of feudal tenure which had been depleted by the practice of conveying land to uses (see below, Chapter 5). 
 The statute enacted that where A was  seised  (i.e. possessed) of a freehold interest in land, to the passive use that he allow B to enjoy the land, B's equitable interest should be turned into a legal interest. 
 The result was that in these cases the separation between legal and equitable ownership ceased. 
 But this separation still continued in the cases to which the statute did not apply &mdash; e.g. if the trustee had active duties to perform, or if he was possessed, not of a freehold, but of chattels real or personal to another's use. 
 Moreover the effect of the statute, in preventing the separation between legal and equitable estates in the cases to which it applied, was nullified in the latter half of the seventeenth century by the decision of the Chancery to protect trusts declared upon the uses which the statute had turned into legal estates. 
 If X gave land to A to the use of B, B got the legal estate by the Statute of Uses; but if X gave land unto and to the use of B in trust for C, B was the legal owner of the land and C the equitable owner. 
 Thus, under the name of trusts, equitable rights in land grew up again and flourished. 
 From the Reformation onwards the Chancellor was usually a layman: Bishop Williams under James I and Charles I was the last clerical Chancellor. 
 Again the Chancellor comes to be usually a lawyer: Lord Shaftesbury under Charles II was the last Chancellor who had never been a practising lawyer. 
 All this tends to create a more definitely legal character for the rules of Equity. 
 Meanwhile Equity is adding new fields of jurisdiction. 
 In the sixteenth century and the beginning of the seventeenth, fraud  and accident  &mdash; especially the accidental loss of a document &mdash; are regarded as matters peculiarly appropriate for relief in a Court of Equity &mdash; matters which a Common Law Court cannot sufficiently deal with. 
 Mortgages form a special subject which the Chancellor deals with. 
 A man borrows money and transfers his land to the creditor, making the creditor legally owner. 
 He promises to pay on a definite date. 
 If he keeps his promise, his land is to be returned to him; if not, it is to belong to the creditor for ever. 
 Suppose by mistake or accident he fails to repay on the day named, is it fair that he should be held to the terms of the deed? 
 Equity says no, and soon goes so far as to lay down a rule that a mortgage is a mere security for money, and something quite different from a genuine transfer of the ownership. 
 The debtor remains in a sense owner; he has a new sort of equitable ownership, &bquo;an equity of redemption&equo;, which he is only to lose after the court has given him ample opportunity to repay, and it becomes plain to the court that he cannot or will not pay. 
 In the seventeenth century the Chancery had to struggle for its independence against the Common Law Courts. 
 They resented the way in which the Chancellor interfered &mdash; in effect though not in theory &mdash; with their judgements, by prohibiting the man who was successful at Common Law from putting them into force. 
 A great quarrel broke out between Chief justice Coke and Lord Ellesmere, the Chancellor: it was decided by King James I in favour of the latter. 
 Under the Commonwealth there were proposals for reforming, and even abolishing, the Chancery. 
 Its extraordinary jurisdiction in civil matters was compared with the extraordinary jurisdiction of the now defunct Star Chamber in criminal matters. 
 These proposals came to nothing. 
 Somewhat similar proposals at the time of the Revolution of 1688, for subjecting the Chancery to the control of the Common Law Courts, were rejected. 
 It was clear that Chancery was doing work which the Common Law Courts could not or would not do, and without which men's rights could not be sufficiently protected. 
 Equity had come to stay as part of the law of the land. 
 The work increases. 
 The Master of the Rolls, who is originally a very subordinate officer, with charge of the documents of the court, comes to be at the end of the seventeenth century a judge who can hear Equity cases, though there is an appeal from him to the Chancellor. 
 For a long time these two between them do most of the Equity work, though the Court of Exchequer has also developed an Equity jurisdiction, an &bquo;Equity side&equo;, which, however, is handed over to Chancery in 1842: it is now administered by the Queen's Bench Division of the High Court. 
 The work of the court was too much for the judges; and this cause of delay was aggravated by the dilatory character of the procedure, and by the time which some of the Chancellors took to consider their decisions. 
 At the beginning of the nineteenth century we find Lord Eldon sometimes keeping a case for ten years to think over, and not delivering judgement till perhaps most of the parties were dead and most of the property had gone in costs. 
 Early in the nineteenth century additional judges, called Vice-Chancellors, were appointed &mdash; first one, later three; and a Court of Appeal in Chancery, intermediate between the Vice-Chancellors and the House of Lords, was established in 1851. 
 The old dilator procedure was reformed in 1852. 
 The Chancellor gradually retired from acting as judge of first instance, and reserved himself for the Court of Appeal in Chancery and for the House of Lords. 
 Finally, the judicature Acts in 1873&ndash;5 abolish the old Court of Chancery, as they abolish the Common Law Courts and certain other courts, and establish a new court &mdash; the High Court of justice &mdash; which has all the powers of a Court of Common Law and a Court of Equity, and in which both sets of rules, the rules of Law and the rules of Equity, are administered; but in which, if there is &bquo;conflict or variance&equo; between them, the rules of Equity are to prevail. 
 The court has now three divisions: a Queen's Bench Division, a Chancery Division, and a Family Division (successor to the probate, Divorce, and Admiralty Division, of which something will be said in Chapter 3). 
 The Queen's Bench and Chancery Divisions are no longer distinct courts, though, as a matter of working convenience, matters which involve mainly the Common Law come before the Queen's Bench; those which largely involve Equity come before the Chancery Division. 
 But there is no hard and fast line: a plaintiff will often have a choice in which division he will start his action, and the rules of Law and Equity are equally applied in both. 
 The main spheres of modern equity 
 Before discussing the effect which the judicature Acts have had in combining Law and Equity in one court, it will be convenient to note some of the branches of Law in which Equity has made important additions to the Common Law and done work which the Common Law could or did not do. 
 First in the law of property. 
 The trust is still with us. 
 We make settlements by which we provide that property shall devolve from one person to another within the limits which the law allows, e.g. to a man, then to his wife, then to be divided among his children. 
 Before 1926, if we were dealing with real  property in the strict sense, i.e. freeholds and copyholds, it is true that the trust was not necessary. 
 Common Law allowed us to cut up a freehold estate into successive estates, each recognized by Common Law. 
 But we shall see that, since 1925, this is not possible (see p. 86), so that the only way in which future interests in any kind of property can be created is through the machinery of a trust. 
 So with mortgages. 
 Till 1926 we had not invented a way of mortgaging property without creating equitable interests. 
 Before 1926, either the debtor conveyed the legal right to a mortgagee, and retained an equitable interest &mdash; the &bquo;Equity of Redemption&equo; &mdash; or else he retained the legal right himself, and gave an equitable interest to the lender, as by a deposit of title-deeds. 
 The latter form of mortgage is still possible; but, instead of the former, a form of mortgage has been invented under which both mortgagor and mortgagee take legal estates (see pp. 96&ndash;9). 
 Very characteristic in connection with these equitable interests is the doctrine of notice, or, more fully, the doctrine that an equitable interest is good against everyone who gets hold of the property, unless he has the legal ownership and acquired the property for value without notice, i.e. without knowledge of, and without reason to suspect, the existence of the equitable interest. 
 At the present day, however, the rights of the purchaser of the legal estate for value without notice are diminished by the Land Charges Act 1972, which has in certain cases prevented such a purchaser from defeating the rights of the equitable owners, by enabling certain rights in the land to be registered, and providing that registration is equivalent to notice. 
 Common Law knows next to nothing of notice. 
 At Common Law either you have got no rights at all, or you have rights which are good against everyone, notice or no notice. 
 That doctrine of notice has got into the Common Law in one or two places, e.g. in the law about the sale of goods in market overt, and in the law of negotiable instruments; but, broadly speaking, whenever you have got rights which depend upon notice, you may be pretty sure that you are in the sphere of Equity. 
 Then as regards contracts. 
 Notice, first, the doctrine of undue influence. 
 Common Law treated a contract as voidable if made under duress, i.e. threats of violence to life or limb; it took no account of more subtle forms of pressure &mdash; the unfair advantage taken of a man in distressed circumstances, the influence exercised in certain relations, such as that of a guardian and his former ward, or solicitor and client. 
 But Equity treated such pressure as a ground for holding the transaction voidable. 
 It would not allow it to be enforced against the promisor; and if property had been transferred, the recipient was treated as holding it for the benefit of the person who had parted with it, and as bound to restore it. 
 So in the case of fraud and misrepresentation Equity interfered, though Common Law took account of them too. 
 It is not clear that the rules in Common Law and Equity were quite the same on these subjects; but, at any rate, Equity had a special protection for the party who had suffered. 
 Common Law might enable the defrauded party to resist an action brought against him on the contract; Equity could order the document to be handed up and destroyed or cancelled. 
 That might be a necessary protection in order, e.g., to prevent a cheque obtained by fraud from getting into the hands of an innocent holder, who would be in better position than the original party to the fraud. 
 So, too, Equity might order a document executed under a mistake to be rectified; Common Law would at most treat it as void. 
 Then there are the rules about time and penalties. 
 Common Law would treat a provision in a contract as to time as being &bquo;of the essence of the contract&equo;, meaning that if a certain act was not done by one party within a certain stipulated time, he should lose all rights under the contract; Equity treated such a provision in general as not being of the essence of the contract, but as giving a right only to damages. 
 Again, where a contract provides, e.g., that A shall pay &pound;100 on 1 January next, and if he does not do so, shall pay &pound;200, Equity would not allow the &pound;200 to be claimed, but treated it only as a security for the &pound;100 with interest. 
 The equitable rules about penalties were, however, to a large extent already introduced into the Common Law Courts by statutes passed at the end of the seventeenth and early in the eighteenth century. 
 Again, we have the rules about the assignment of rights under contract. 
 A owes money to B. Common Law regards this as purely a relation between A and B. B agrees with C that C shall have the right to claim the debt from A. Common Law pays no attention, C cannot claim the debt. 
 The most that can be done is that B may allow C to use his name to claim the money. 
 But Equity treats the debt as transferable. 
 It will compel B to let C make the legal claim in his name; in the last resort it might allow C to take proceedings in Equity in his own name against A. Thus it came to be said that &bquo;in Equity debts and choses in action are assignable&equo;. 
 Further, we must notice the law about married women. 
 Common Law put the wife, both as regards rights and liabilities, in a very subordinate position to her husband. 
 Her tangible movable goods simply became her husband's property. 
 Debts due to her might be collected by the husband; and if that was done, of course the money was his. 
 If he did not collect it, and the wife survived him, the claim for the debt remained hers. 
 Her freehold and copyhold land, it is true, remained her own; but the husband had the enjoyment of it at least during the continuance of the marriage. 
 Neither could dispose of the inheritance without the consent of the other. 
 Leaseholds were in a position very much like debts. 
 The husband had a right to dispose of them for his own benefit while he lived, and his wife had no power of disposition during that time, though, if she survived him, and they had not been disposed of, they would be hers again. 
 Further, no married woman could make a will without her husband's consent, nor (with trifling exceptions) make any contract, except as agent either for her husband or for some other person: it would have been absurd to let her contract when she had no free property out of which she could pay. 
 But then about the end of the seventeenth century Equity invented the separate use for married women. 
 Property might be given to a trustee upon trust for the separate use of the married woman, free from the control and liabilities of her husband. 
 Now, if it had simply been given to the woman, Common Law would have said, &bquo;We can pay no attention to this separate use. 
 If it is the woman's, it comes under the husband's control, in spite of anything you say to the contrary.&equo; 
 But then the property was not given to her; it was given on the face of it to the trustee. 
 Common Law could not prevent the trustee employing it for the wife's benefit, and Equity would compel him to do so. 
 And then Equity went one step further. 
 Suppose a man knows nothing of trusts and trustees, but has heard something of the separate use, leaves property &mdash; say &pound;1,000 &mdash; to his married daughter &bquo;for her separate use&equo;. 
 The husband pounces on it; the Common Law makes it his. 
 But Equity will not be balked. 
 True, the &pound;1,000 belongs to the husband at law &mdash; there is no denying it; but Equity will compel him to apply it for the wife's benefit. 
 Has not the testator, in fact, declared a trust in saying &bquo;for her separate use&equo;? 
 Nothing easier than to turn the husband into a trustee for his own wife. 
 And so this property held for the wife's separate use comes to be her &bquo;separate estate&equo; in Equity. 
 Equity treats her as if she was the unmarried owner of it; it lets her dispose of it as she pleases in her lifetime, it lets her leave it by will, it even lets her make contracts which can be enforced against it, and against it only. 
 And then Equity gets afraid of what it has done. 
 If the wife can so easily dispose of this property, it may be that her husband will coax or bully her into parting with it to him or to his creditors, and so it allows her a privilege which no other grown-up person of sound mind in the country can enjoy. 
 The will or settlement may impose the restraint on anticipation. 
 In that case, no act of the married woman is to affect her right to the capital or future income of the property. 
 It is just because the whole of this institution of married women's property existed in Equity only that Equity could mould the institution just as it pleased. 
 Thus it was through Equity that a married woman acquired a limited and special capacity to own property and to make contracts. 
 We shall see that in the nineteenth century this limited and special capacity was extended with some modifications to all married women (see pp. 50&ndash;4); but that in 1935 it was swept away, and married women were given the same capacity to own property and make contracts as a man. 
 And then, finally, look at what Equity can do for the successful plaintiff &mdash; the &bquo;remedy&equo;, the &bquo;relief&equo; which it can give him. 
 With few exceptions the only thing that Common Law can do is to give him money compensation. 
 If you have been wrongfully turned out of your land, then, it is true, Common Law will put you back into possession; but this is practically the only exception from the rule that the Common Law remedy for every wrong and every breach of contract is damages . 
 With the one exception mentioned, Common Law will not order a defendant to do anything except pay money. 
 It is a much easier order to enforce. 
 It is easier to say whether a man has paid the money or not than to say whether he has complied with other orders; and if he fails to pay, it is easy to get the money by selling his goods, if he has any. 
 But it is not always satisfactory to the plaintiff. 
 It may not be money that he wants; and even if he would be satisfied with money, it may be very hard to say what would be a fair compensation for his loss, and a jury may not be the most suitable body for assessing it. 
 Suppose a contract for the sale of land; the seller refuses to perform it. 
 In the eye of the Common Law there is plenty of land as good elsewhere; but the purchaser has set his heart on just this piece of land, and damages (even if liberally assessed, which is not always the case) are not what he wants. 
 Or suppose the purchaser backs out. 
 It may be of vital importance to the seller to get the money instead of the land; but he will rarely succeed in getting more than his out-of-pocket expenses. 
 Or suppose, again, that your neighbour has agreed with you that he will not open a public house or carry on a school of music next door, and does and threatens to continue doing one or the other; or that you have a right to light for your windows, and he threatens to erect a building within three feet of them. 
 In all such cases you may not be satisfied to receive even large damages for the wrong done; and what the amount of damages is to be may be very uncertain. 
 At any rate, if damages are the only thing to be got, your wealthy neighbour might buy the right to annoy you. 
 It was to meet cases of this kind that Equity invented the great remedies of specific performance  and injunction : specific performance to compel a man actually to do what he has promised &mdash; to give you the land in return for the money, to pay you the purchase money in return for the land; injunction to forbid him to do what he has promised not to do or what he has no right to do &mdash; to forbid him to open the public house or the music-school, to forbid him to build so as to block up your light, even to compel him to pull down the objectionable wall; the last sort of injunction is called mandatory . 
 The effect of the Judicature Acts 
 Now, what have the judicature Acts 1873 and 1875 done? 
  It may be noted that these acts were replaced by the Supreme Court of judicature (Consolidation) Act 1925, which has itself now been replaced by the Supreme Court Act 1981 and by certain provisions in the Limitation Act 1980 (consolidating earlier Limitation Acts). 
  They have established a single court with all the powers both of a Court of Law and a Court of Equity. 
 The distribution of work between the divisions of that court is only a matter of convenience; the Queen's Bench Division can never say &bquo;here a matter of Equity is involved; we cannot decide it&equo;, or the Chancery Division &bquo;this is a question of Common Law; you ought to have gone to a Common Law Court&equo;. 
 At the worst the plaintiff who starts in the wrong division will be removed to another division, and may have to pay the expenses, if any, incurred by his mistake; but he cannot fail altogether for his mistake. 
  Multiplicity of proceedings is avoided. 
 Suppose a dispute about a piece of land. 
 A is the legal owner; B has an equitable claim. 
 Under the old system A takes proceedings in the Common Law Courts to establish his rights; B has no legal defence; he must go to the Court of Chancery to get, among other things, an injunction to forbid A to go on. 
 Under the Judicature Acts no injunction can be granted by one division of the court against proceedings in another division; but in every branch of the court an equitable right may be directly asserted and may be pleaded as a defence to a legal claim. 
 So, again, suppose A is blocking up B's light. 
 Under the old system B might have had to bring two actions against A: in the Common Law Courts to get damages, in the Chancery to get an injunction to forbid the continuance of the building. 
 He can now get both in the same action, because the same court can both give damages and also grant an injunction. 
 Or suppose that A has broken his contract to sell land to B; here, again, B might have had to bring one action in a Common Law Court for damages, and another in the Chancery to compel specific performance. 
 Or, again, A has a purely legal claim against B; but in order to prove his case he wants to make B disclose facts or documents which support A's claims. 
 There A would have had to take proceedings for &bquo;discovery&equo; against B in Chancery to get the disclosure, and another action in the Common Law Courts for his actual claim. 
 He now brings an action in the High Court, in the course of which he gets an order for discovery, B is compelled to disclose the documents which he has that support A's case, and A may be allowed to administer interrogatories to B &mdash; questions in writing which B must answer also in writing but upon oath. 
  On the other hand, the old Chancery practice which compelled B to go through the whole of A's story and give an answer upon oath to everything said in it has disappeared; the evidence in the ordinary course is given viva voce  in court when the trial comes on. 
  The Acts introduced a whole code of procedure, the Rules of the Supreme Court, which in various ways assimilated the Common Law and the Equity procedure, taking the good points of both. 
  The 25th section of the Act of 1873 dealt specially with a number of points in which there was a difference between Law and Equity, of which the following may here be mentioned: 
  Mortgages. 
 Common Law treated the mortgagee as the owner of the land in case of the ordinary legal mortgage; Equity treated the mortgagor as still being in a sense owner. 
 It is true that it would not prevent the mortgagee taking possession, though it made his position in some degree uncomfortable if he did take possession. 
 But suppose that, as usually happens, the mortgagor is left in possession, and that a stranger turns him out, or tries to do so. 
 Common Law found a difficulty in protecting him against the stranger. 
 The mortgagee would have to be joined as plaintiff. 
 The Judicature Act decided that as against a stranger the mortgagor in possession must be treated as owner. 
 He can sue in his own name. 
 We shall see that the Law of Property Act 1925 has changed the form of the ordinary legal mortgage (see pp. 96&ndash;9). 
 But the same rules as before are applicable to a mortgagee who takes possession, and to a mortgagor who is in possession. 
  Assignment of debts and choses in action. 
 Here you remember that Common Law would not recognize the assignment; Equity in effect would, by compelling the assignor to lend the use of his name to the assignee for the purpose of suing the debtor, or, in the last resort, allowing the assignee to sue directly against the debtor, but requiring him, as a rule, to make the assignor a defendant. 
 Here the Judicature Act made a definite alteration in the law. 
 It left the old equitable assignment untouched, and it may be used still. 
 But it created a new kind of assignment, which was a legal assignment in the sense that the assignee might sue directly in his own name without making the assignor a party; but it made certain special requirements: 
  the assignment must be absolute,  it must be in writing,  notice in writing to the debtor is required. 
 (This series of provisions in the Judicature Act is repealed and substantially re-enacted in section 136 of the Law of property Act 1925.) 
 None of these requirements applies to an equitable assignment, but priority as between two assignees of the same debt depends on priority of notice to the debtor, and for this purpose an unwritten notice is unavailing. 
 On the other hand, the new kind of assignment resembles the equitable assignment in being subject to equities, i.e. to claims or defences which the debtor or other person might have set up against the assignor. 
  The rules of Equity as to stipulations about time and other provisions which would not be held by Equity to be of the essence of the contract, are to prevail in all cases. 
  Finally, the 25th section (now substantially re-enacted by section 49 of the Supreme Court Act 1981) contains a general provision that in all other matters where there is a conflict or variance between the rules of Law and the rules of Equity the latter are to prevail. 
 This last provision looks so sweeping that there is a danger of supposing that it has swept away all difference between legal and equitable rights. 
 That would be a great mistake. 
 One might imagine, for instance, that it has turned equitable estates and rights into legal estates and rights. 
 That is not so. 
 The great characteristic of equitable estates, namely that they will be destroyed if the legal estate gets into the hands of a purchaser for value without notice, still holds good. 
 A is a trustee of property for B, i.e. A has a legal right which he is bound to use for B's benefit; B is said to have an equitable right to it or an equitable estate in it. 
 Since the Judicature Act, just as much as before it, if A sells the property to C, who knows nothing of the trust, and transfers the legal ownership to him, B's rights to the property are destroyed; he can only look to A for compensation for the breach of trust. 
 Or, again, one might suppose that this section has extended equitable doctrines to cases to which Equity did not apply them, because they formerly never came into a Court of Equity. 
 One might suppose that since they now come into a court with an equitable jurisdiction, the equitable doctrine must be applied. 
 We shall see that Law drew a clear distinction between innocent and fraudulent misrepresentation. 
 The latter was regarded as a tort, for which an action for damages was available. 
 But damages could not normally be obtained for an innocent misrepresentation. 
 Equity regarded the distinction as of less importance, in the sense that if a representation were untrue, whether to the knowledge of its maker or not, and were a material factor in inducing another party to enter into a contract with him, that party was entitled to rescind the contract if he were plaintiff, or resist specific performance if he were defendant. 
 The passage of the judicature Act tempted some people to think that damages might now be obtained for innocent misrepresentation. 
 But the impression was soon shown to be erroneous. 
 Apart from fraud, and certain exceptional cases, damages could be obtained only if the representation were fundamental, so as to constitute a condition, or must be ranked as a warranty, collateral to the main contract, such as a statement concerning the soundness of a horse. 
 However, the Law Reform Committee in 1962 recommended that courts should be permitted to award damages, at their discretion, in all cases involving innocent misrepresentation. 
 This was substantially enacted by the Misrepresentation Act 1967 (see also pp. 124&ndash;5), and now the court may treat a contract as still subsisting despite the existence of innocent misrepresentation, and award damages to the injured party, instead of rescinding the contract. 
 The general result of the fusion of Law and Equity has been, then, not to alter substantive law, but rather to alter and simplify the procedure. 
 In order to find out what the substantive law is, we must still go back to the time when Law and Equity were administered in different courts; we may still have to picture to ourselves distinct proceedings taken about the same matter in those courts, and work out the result of those separate proceedings. 
 Yet signs are not wanting that the mental effort of doing so is one which will become more and more difficult as the memory of the distinct courts of Law and Equity dies out; and perhaps already the unified jurisdiction of the High Court, and the statutes which have codified certain branches of Common Law and Equity, have produced some results which could hardly have been given by any combination of proceedings in the separate courts, or by the development of the law solely by means of cases decided in them. 
 OTHER BODIES OF ENGLISH LAW 
 There are three other main bodies of English law: probate, Divorce, and Admiralty, which were developed in jurisdictions distinct from the Common Law Courts and the Court of Chancery. 
 It is not intended in this book to deal specially with the law administered in the modern Restrictive practices Court, Employment Appeal Tribunal, or other specialist tribunals.) 
 In these other bodies of law we see more influence of foreign law than elsewhere in our legal system. 
 The church courts 
 From William the Conqueror onwards the Church Courts are separated from the Lay Courts: the Bishop has his court; the Archbishop a superior or prerogative court; from him before the Reformation there is an appeal to the pope. 
 The law of these courts is the Church or Canon Law &mdash; the Common Law of the Western Church. 
 That law was formed by ecclesiastical lawyers who knew the Roman Law. 
 It was first systematized by Gratian of Bologna in the twelfth century. 
 It was the law of the Church in England, as in other parts of Western Europe, though within limits local and provincial variations were possible. 
 Though these courts were in no sense treated as subordinate by the King's Courts, the latter would issue prohibitions to prevent them from dealing with matters that did not concern them. 
 But the scope of their actual and proper jurisdiction was large. 
 With a great part of the matters with which they dealt we have not much concern. 
 Their exclusive claim to punish clergymen for ordinary offences has long since disappeared; the power to try and punish laymen for immorality has become practically obsolete; their jurisdiction over the matters of ritual, and ecclesiastical offences of clergymen, such as heresy, still remains and is still exercised by them. 
 In the struggle between them and the King's Courts for jurisdiction over ecclesiastical property &mdash; the right to present a clergyman to a living, for instance &mdash; the King's Courts were successful at an early time in getting and keeping the jurisdiction in their own hands. 
 But in two matters which concern primarily what we should consider the civil rights of everyone, the Church Courts long retained their jurisdiction: the disposition of the goods of the dead, and questions of marriage and divorce. 
 Probate and administration 
 As regards the real estate of the deceased, it is settled by the end of the thirteenth century that he can make no will, except where there is a local custom to that effect. 
 But as regards his goods and chattels, which include his leaseholds, it is early admitted that he has at least a limited power to dispose by will &mdash; limited because his wife and children may have rights which he cannot override. 
 These restrictions on testation had disappeared over the greater part of England early in the fourteenth century, but they survived in the province of York till 1692, in Wales till 1696, and in London till 1724. 
 If he makes no will we can hardly say that there is in early times any common law as to how his goods shall be divided; much or all will depend on local custom. 
 The Common Law takes little interest in the goods, which are of far less importance, and especially of far less public importance, than the land. 
 Now the Church has a definite interest in the goods of the deceased. 
 The religious belief of the time requires at least a substantial part of his property to be devoted to the good of his soul. 
 If he makes a will, as most men do, it is almost certain that he will set apart a considerable proportion for the saying of masses; if he should neglect to do so, and in the twelfth and thirteenth centuries it is regarded as almost a sin to die without making a will, the Church ought to make the provision which he has failed to make for his soul. 
 Thus the Church Courts assume a jurisdiction over dead men's goods. 
 If there is a will &mdash; and wills at that time are very easy to make, mere word of mouth is sufficient &mdash; the Bishop's Court is the proper place in which it must be proved; the Bishop's Court will see that the executor carries out his duties properly. 
 If there is no will, then the Bishop will take charge of the goods that the deceased leaves, and make a suitable disposition of them. 
 The Bishop seems to have had a wide discretion, which was not always well exercised. 
 Two statutes provided a remedy. 
 In 1285 the &bquo;Ordinary&equo;, i.e. the ecclesiastical superior who has the jurisdiction, is required by statute to pay the debts of the intestate, just as the executor (i.e. the person appointed by the will to carry out the will) is required to pay them. 
 In 1357 he is required by statute to entrust the administration of the property to the near relations of the deceased. 
 This statute originated the office of administrator . 
 The administrator is the person who, in the absence of an executor, must deal with the deceased's property, pay his debts, and make a proper division among those entitled. 
 He receives what are called letters of  administration , which give him the title to the property; even where there is a will, but no executor is appointed, there must be a grant of letters of administration cum testamento annexo , &bquo;with the will attached&equo;. 
 It is true that the Ecclesiastical Court is not the only one which deals with the goods of dead men; the executor or administrator may have to sue in the Common Law Courts to recover the claims or property of the deceased, and the deceased's creditors can sue him there. 
 But neither the Ecclesiastical Courts nor the Common Law Courts are well adapted to settle the numerous conflicting rights of creditors, legatees, and next of kin; trusts are often involved, and during the last two centuries the most effectual and usual method of asserting a claim to or against the estate of a deceased person is to get the estate administered in Chancery. 
 That court tells the executor or administrator what to do, or takes the whole estate under its charge and distributes it. 
 But all this supposes that there is already a will proved, or letters of administration granted by the Ecclesiastical Court. 
 Without probate of the will or letters of administration, neither executor nor administrator can take any steps in any other court of law, for the executor's proof of his title, and the administrator's title itself, can only be given by the Ecclesiastical Court. 
 That court keeps the key which unlocks the estate. 
 The Reformation left the jurisdiction untouched; and it lasted into the middle of the nineteenth century. 
 There were as many Probate Courts as there were dioceses, in addition to the Prerogative Courts of the two Archbishops, and a number of courts in places called Peculiars, places outside a bishop's jurisdiction, and under a special ecclesiastical jurisdiction of their own. 
 The appropriate court was usually the court of the diocese in which the deceased's property happened to be; if there was property in several dioceses, it was necessary to apply to the prerogative Court. 
 The records of these numerous courts were often badly kept, and there might be damage or loss of the original wills which the courts kept under their custody. 
 In 1857 the whole of the jurisdiction of the Ecclesiastical Courts in Probate and Administration was taken away and was vested in a new court &mdash; the Court of Probate. 
 The Statutes of Distribution 1670 and 1685 established a code for the distribution of the property of intestate persons modelled largely on Roman law. 
 But till 1857 this code was subject to local customs in the province of York, in Wales, and in London which gave different rights to the wife and children. 
 We shall see that since 1925 this code is now replaced by a new scheme of intestate succession, which applies to all the property of a deceased person (see pp. 111&ndash;13). 
 Marriage and divorce 
 This also, from an early time in the Middle Ages, fell largely into the hands of the Ecclesiastical Courts. 
 They assume a jurisdiction to declare whether a marriage has taken place or not, whether there is any impediment which makes it void or voidable. 
 Questions of legitimacy may also be decided by them. 
 They grant also what is called a divorce a mensa et thoro , or rather what we should call a judicial separation, i.e. they release the parties from the duty of living together on grounds of cruelty or misconduct; but a divorce in the modern sense, which allows the parties to marry again, is not recognized by the medieval church in the case of any marriage which is originally valid. 
 After the Reformation it looks for a moment as if the Ecclesiastical Courts would allow even a divorce in the modern sense; but the attempt fails, and the only way of getting a complete dissolution of marriage is by special Act of Parliament (and so the law remained, for persons domiciled in Northern Ireland, up to 1939). 
 This Divorce Act was only allowed after proceedings had been taken both in the Ecclesiastical Courts for separation, and in the Common Law Courts for damages. 
 The expense of the combined proceedings was enormous, and made divorce a luxury of the very rich. 
 Here again, in 1857, statute took away the whole of the matrimonial jurisdiction from the Ecclesiastical Courts and vested it in a new court, the Divorce Court, which was enabled to do not only everything that the Ecclesiastical Court could have done, but also what previously needed the combined efforts of the Ecclesiastical Courts, the Common Law Courts, and an Act of Parliament. 
 Admiralty 
 The Middle Ages knew a number of courts with a maritime jurisdiction, which were mainly local courts, e.g. the court of the Cinque ports. 
 They knew also a Law Merchant which was different from the Common Law and had an international character, a law founded on the commercial customs of merchants and seafaring men of all nations. 
 It, too, was administered in local courts held in fairs and towns. 
 Gradually these courts decayed, partly owing to the jealousy of the Common Law Courts, which interfered with them and extended their own jurisdiction. 
 In the course of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries the Law Merchant, apart from maritime law and prize law (see p. 40), was absorbed into the Common Law; thus the law of such matters as Bills of Exchange came to be part of the law of the land, and came to have a specially English character. 
 On the Continent mercantile law is still regarded as something separate from the ordinary law. 
 The Admiral, whose office dates from the end of the thirteenth century, has at first no jurisdiction apart from the discipline of the fleet, but in the course of the fourteenth century we find him assuming a jurisdiction to punish crimes, such as piracy, committed at sea, as well as a civil jurisdiction over shipping and commercial matters. 
 The law and procedure of his court have an international rather than a purely English character; it administers a law which is to be found in the medieval maritime codes, such as the Laws of Oleron and the so-called Law of Rhodes; in the background, as a supplementary law, is the Civil or Roman law. 
 Its procedure is that of Roman law: the parties can be examined on oath. 
 But the Admiralty Court also suffers from the jealousy of the Common Law. 
 Its criminal jurisdiction is, in the sixteenth century, vested in a set of commissioners welcome in practice to be invariably judges of the Common Law Courts. 
 Its civil jurisdiction was encroached upon, as contracts made and wrongs done abroad or at sea were brought within the jurisdiction of the ordinary courts by fictions, such as the pretence that such towns as Bordeaux were within the area of, say, Cheapside, so that many international commercial transactions were considered to be purely municipal. 
 Prohibitions were issued to prevent the Admiralty from dealing with any case that the Common Law Courts could deal with. 
 The result of this struggle, which lasted through the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, was to confine the court to a very limited jurisdiction, dealing with purely maritime matters, such as salvage and damage by collision at sea. 
 It still retained such jurisdiction, and received some increase and confirmation of it, in the nineteenth century. 
 The Maritime Law which it administered &mdash; though it gradually became more English and less international &mdash; still retained a peculiar character. 
 For instance, the rule of contributory negligence applicable to collisions at sea differed from that established by the common law of tort. 
 Under the Common Law, proof that the plaintiff had been guilty of contributory negligence, and that he had the &bquo;last opportunity&equo; of avoiding the accident, entirely deprived him of his remedy. 
 (This rule has, as we shall see, been altered by the Law Reform (Contributory Negligence) Act 1945; see p. 138.) 
 Maritime Law divided the loss, at first equally, but now, under the Maritime Conventions Acts 1911, in proportion, as far as possible, to the degree of fault. 
 The Admiralty had from the first a &bquo;prize&equo; jurisdiction, i.e. a jurisdiction to determine all questions as to the ownership of ships and goods captured at sea by a belligerent. 
 The leading principles of prize law were settled by Lord Stowell during the Napoleonic wars; and they were the basis of the prize law which was applied in the 1914&ndash;18 and 1939&ndash;45 wars. 
 The modern Courts 
 The Acts of 1857 which established the probate and Divorce Courts provided that the ordinary judge of these courts might be the same person as the Admiralty judge. 
 Thus it was a natural step that in 1875 the Probate, Divorce, and Admiralty jurisdictions should be entrusted to a single division of the High Court. 
 However the disparity between the three jurisdictions became marked in the course of the present century, and a reorganization was brought about by the Administration of Justice Act 1970. 
 The Probate, Divorce, and Admiralty Division was abolished and a new Family Division of the High Court put in its place. 
 This new Division deals with Divorce and other aspects of family law, as well as non-contentious probate, while contentious Probate is now assigned to the Chancery Division, and Admiralty matters to the Queen's Bench Division. 
 PERSONS AND PERSONAL RELATIONS 
 Unborn persons 
 Even before birth a human being is not without legal recognition, for the antenatal life is protected by the Infant Life Preservation Act 1929. 
 The Irish courts have held that a child which was born deformed in consequence of an injury to its mother, caused by the fault of a railway company on whose line she was travelling, could not recover damages; but the decision turned on the view that the company, not having means of knowledge of its presence, owed no duty towards it. 
 In England, however, the birth of many children suffering from deformities caused by their mothers having taken the new drug thalidomide prescribed by doctors during their pregnancy resulted in the enactment of the Congenital Disabilities (Civil Liability) Act 1976. 
 Under this Act a child born alive, but suffering from a physical or mental defect as a result of something which happened before its birth, has a right of action for damages if the defendant would also have been liable in tort for what occurred to the parent if sued in time. 
 In the law of property, a child conceived, but not yet born, will be treated as born, at any rate where it is for its advantage that it should be so treated. 
 For instance, even a bequest to persons &bquo;born previously to the date of my will&equo; will include a person born within due time afterwards. 
 But if the child is never born alive, things will remain as if it had never existed. 
 Further, by wills and settlements, provision may be made for those who may come into existence at a future time, subject to the rule against perpetuities, which forbids any disposition which is not certain to take effect (if it takes effect at all) within lives in being and twenty-one years afterwards; but a life in being includes a person en ventre sa mere  at the time when the will or settlement takes effect. 
 (Certain detailed modifications of the effect of the rule against perpetuities are now enacted by the Perpetuities and Accumulations Act 1964.) 
 Infants 
 At birth a child enters the condition of infancy &mdash; a condition which ceases at the age of 18 years, or rather, at the first moment of the day preceding the eighteenth birthday. 
 In what follows the term &bquo;infant&equo; will be used in its strict sense of a person who is in the condition of infancy as above defined. 
 It would be a mistake to regard the condition of infancy as one of uniform incapacity throughout and for all purposes. 
 In Criminal Law the material periods are those up to 10 and between 10 and 14 years. 
 A child under 10 incurs no criminal liability for its acts; a child over 9, but under 14, incurs no such liability, unless it is shown that it had sufficient capacity to know that its act was wrong. 
 A person above the age of 13, though under 18, does not differ in general as regards criminal liability from a person of full age, though modern legislation has made special provision for the trial and punishment of persons under 17. 
 The Marriage Act 1949 provides that a marriage between persons either of whom is under the age of 16 is void. 
 Marriages of persons over that age, but under 18, are completely valid; and the only check on such marriages without the consent of parents or guardians is the difficulty of getting them celebrated by the clergyman or proper officer without making a false declaration, which involves penal consequences. 
 There is no general rule which exempts infants from liability for &bquo;tort&equo;, i.e. civil injury other than breach of contract or trust. 
 An infant who damages another by carelessly running into him on his bicycle is liable just as a person of full age would be. 
 practically, the liability is not often of much value to the injured person, for the infant probably has no property available to satisfy it, and his parents are not liable for his acts. 
 In two ways, however, the liability of an infant for civil wrongs is restricted. 
 It sometimes happens that the wrong is so closely connected with a contract that the enforcement of liability for the wrong would in effect amount to an enforcement of the contract. 
 Suppose that an infant who has hired a horse injures it by careless riding. 
 In such a case an adult might be held liable either for breach of his contract to use proper care or for a wrong independent of the contract; an infant has been held not to be liable at all. 
 Again, some wrongs, such as fraud, in their essence involve a guilty state of mind, and in such cases the extreme youth of the wrongdoer may be inconsistent with the existence of such a state of mind. 
 It is in respect of property and contract that the incapacity of infancy has its most general operation. 
 This incapacity is a one-sided one. 
 Property (other than a legal estate in land) may be transferred, and binding promises may be made to an infant, but in general he is unable to make a binding disposition of his property or to make binding promises to others. 
 As regards property, it should be noticed that law and practice, to a large extent, make it unlikely that property of any considerable value will come into the direct ownership of an infant. 
 When property passes on death, it will go in the first instance to the executor appointed by will, or the administrator appointed by the court, who are charged with the duty of dealing with it and transferring it to the persons entitled (see p. 114). 
 Similarly, under the settlements which people of property commonly make, the property will be in the hands of trustees. 
 The infant cannot give a receipt which executors, administrators or trustees can safely take. 
 They must therefore retain the property to which an infant is entitled till he attains full age, and meanwhile deal with it under the directions of the will or settlement or under the orders of the court. 
 But if the trust has been created after 1925, the Trustee Act 1925 gives power to the trustees to apply the property for the maintenance and advancement of the infant. 
 In some cases trustees may relieve themselves by transferring it into the control of the court. 
 Where an infant actually has in his hands tangible movable property, it would seem that he has a power of disposing of it, of which the limits &mdash; if such there are &mdash; have not been determined. 
 It cannot be supposed, for instance, that a sale by a normal infant of his own books or minor personal effects could (in the absence of fraud or unfair dealing) be called in question. 
 It is clear that a payment made by him for goods bought is binding, though payment could not have been enforced against him. 
 A gift of a large sum of money by an infant was after his death held valid. 
 But the bulk of &bquo;property&equo;, in the modern sense of the word, is not of this kind. 
 Equitable estates in land, which are the only interests in land which infants can now have, can only be disposed of by writing; and a writing or a sealed writing is necessary to the transfer of such things as stocks and shares, claims against debtors, and interests in property held by others upon trust. 
 In all such cases the rule would seem to apply that the infant's acts are &bquo;voidable&equo;; they become binding on him only if, after attaining full age, he fails within a reasonable time to repudiate them. 
 The rule has been relaxed so as to enable infants to make a binding settlement of their property upon marriage, but only with the sanction of the court. 
 Except soldiers and airmen when on active service and mariners while at sea, no infant can dispose of his property by will. 
 But in some cases a person of the age of 16 can make what is in effect equivalent to a disposition by will: a member of a Trade Union or Friendly Society may, for instance, at that age nominate in writing a person to receive moneys payable on his death by the Union or Society. 
 The contracts of an infant are at Common Law voidable. 
 But in this connection the word &bquo;voidable&equo; has two senses. 
 In the case of contracts creating continuing or recurrent liabilities incident to the disposition or holding of property, such as a settlement or a leasehold tenancy, the infant, on attaining full age, becomes bound unless within a reasonable time he takes steps to repudiate liability. 
 In all other cases &mdash; as, for instance, a sale of goods or a contract for services or a loan of money &mdash; the contract was voidable in the sense that the infant would not, on attaining full age, become liable unless he took steps to ratify it. 
 As regards this latter class of contracts, the Infants' Relief Act 1874 very much altered the law. 
 Contracts for the loan of money and supply of goods to infants and &bquo;accounts stated&equo; with infants were made altogether void, while the possibility of ratification was taken away from all those contracts which required ratification to make them binding upon him after attaining full age; and even a new promise to perform the contract, whether made upon a fresh consideration or not, could not be enforced by action. 
 These provisions gave rise to uncertainty largely because the courts showed a marked reluctance to interpret them according to the ordinary meaning of such words as &bquo;void, and they also gave rise to injustice because under the Common Law an infant could still sue an adult upon a contract unenforceable against himself and incapable of ratification by him. 
 To the general invalidity of infants' contracts the Common Law recognized the exceptions of contracts for necessaries and contracts for the infants' benefit, and these exceptions are not affected by statute. 
 Contracts for necessaries include contracts for such goods, lodging, and instruction as are reasonably necessary for the infant, having regard to his station in life and his needs at the time of the contract. 
 The party who supplies the infant does so at his peril; it will not avail him that he did not know that he was dealing with an infant, or that he thought that his position in life was such as to make the goods necessary, or that he did not know that the infant was already sufficiently supplied. 
 Of contracts for the benefit of the infant, so far as they do not coincide with contracts for necessaries, a contract for the employment of the infant, where his position in life makes employment desirable for him, is a typical case. 
 The unsatisfactory state of the law resulting from the Infants' Relief Act 1874 has now been remedied by the Minors' Contracts Act 1987, which is based upon recommendations of the Law Commission. 
 The 1987 Act restores the Common Law principle to contracts for the loan of money and supply of goods to infants, and to accounts stated with infants, so that they are now voidable (but not void) or unenforceable against them. 
 On attaining majority, or within a reasonable time thereafter, an infant may ratify a contract which is otherwise unenforceable against him or voidable at his option, and he can do this by unilateral act. 
 Furthermore, any new agreement entered into on majority whereby the infant undertakes to repay a loan advanced during minority is valid. 
 A guarantee of a minor's contractual obligation is also enforceable against the guarantor even if the infant's contractual obligation is unenforceable. 
 Finally, the 1987 Act provides that where a minor has acquired property under a contract which is unenforceable against him, or which he has repudiated on the grounds of minority, he may be required by the court, when it thinks it &bquo;just and equitable&equo; to do so, to return the property, or else property representing that which he has acquired (without prejudice to any other remedy available to the plaintiff). 
 In this way an infant may be compelled to provide restitution for property unfairly obtained. 
 Parents and guardians 
 In some systems of law the disability of persons under full age is helped out by the powers of the parent or guardian, who can represent the child, and, by acting on his behalf or giving concurrence to his acts, can make dispositions of his property and contracts binding on him. 
 Of such an institution we see but the rudiments or isolated survivals in English law. 
 Our medieval law of guardianship was concerned mainly with infants who were heirs of land; and though the &bquo;guardian in socage&equo; &mdash; the nearest relation of the infant to whom the infant's land cannot descend &mdash; has not been abolished, the practice of settlement and of appointing trustees in whom the land, or at least powers over it, are vested, renders rare the occasions on which the very limited powers of such or any kind of guardians can be exercised over an infant's land. 
 At the present day they have no powers over the infant's land. 
 A conveyance to an infant does not vest the legal estate in him, but operates only as an agreement to execute a settlement in his favour. 
 This means that the grantor must execute a principal vesting deed and trust instrument, holding the land meanwhile as trustee for the infant. 
 If land is given to an infant by will or conveyed to him on an intestacy the legal estate vests in the representatives of the deceased who hold it in trust for the infant. 
 Over other property of an infant, neither parents nor guardians have now &mdash; if they ever had &mdash; any effective powers, except such as a will or settlement or an order of the court may give them; they cannot, for instance, give a valid receipt for a legacy or money payable to the child. 
 For purposes of litigation, it is true, an infant can and must be represented by an adult, who will be called &bquo;the next friend&equo; of an infant plaintiff, the &bquo; guardian ad litem &equo; of an infant defendant; but such a next friend or guardian represents the infant only for the purposes of the particular lawsuit, and is not necessarily, though he is commonly, the infant's parent or general guardian. 
 Broadly speaking, then, the powers and duties of parents and guardians relate not to property, but to the care and custody of the infant's person. 
 Under the Guardianship of Minors Act 1971, as amended by the Guardianship Act 1973 and the Domestic Proceedings and Magistrates' Courts Act 1978, both father and mother are equally entitled to the care and custody of the infant; and in case of a dispute between them the court must, in coming to a decision, regard only the welfare of the infant. 
 Furthermore, the Child Abduction Act 1984 makes it an offence for any parent or guardian to take or send a child out of the United Kingdom without the consent of any other person who is a parent or guardian of the child. 
 Under the Social Security Act 1971, a man is liable to maintain his wife and children, including those of whom he has been adjudged the putative father, and a woman is liable to maintain her husband and children. 
 Neither father nor mother can deprive themselves of their rights, except in the case of a separation agreement between husband and wife; and even such an agreement will not be enforced by the court if the court considers it not to be for the child's benefit. 
 On the death of father or mother the guardianship devolves on the surviving spouse; but either can by deed or will appoint guardians to act with the survivor. 
 The court has always had power to take a child out of the custody of a parent or guardian in cases of misconduct or unfitness, and in such cases, or in the absence of any lawful guardian, to appoint a suitable person as guardian. 
 Thus in a case in 1969, where the 10-year-old child born in England of Spanish parents had been very unhappy during the seventeen months he had spent with them in Spain, and had then lived happily for several years with foster parents and their six children in England, the court refused to make an order that care and control should be granted to the parents, one of whom was in poor health. 
 Expert evidence was given to the effect that the chances of the child adjusting to a new life in Spain were very slim, and that failure to adjust would have very serious consequences on the child's development. 
 The court held that the rule that the welfare of the child is to be the first and paramount consideration applies not only to disputes between parents, but also to a dispute between parents and a third party. 
 Similarly, a parent or guardian may apply to have an infant made a ward of court if such an order would protect the infant's property from his own possible rash activities. 
 A ward of court cannot be taken out of the jurisdiction of the court, nor can any change be made in his or her position in life, without leave of the court. 
 Thus to marry such a ward without the consent of the court is punishable as a contempt of court. 
 The court's powers in regard to the protection and custody of children are constantly revised by Parliament, as for example in the substantial Family Law Act 1986 and the Children Act 1989. 
 The powers of parents and guardians include the power of administering reasonable punishment, and such a power may be delegated by them to others, such as schoolmasters, under whose control the child is placed. 
 Legitimacy 
 Broadly speaking, one may say that every child is legitimate which is born during the continuance of a marriage or within due time afterwards. 
 The presumption that the husband is the father of his wife's children is one that can be overthrown only by evidence of the most cogent, even though not of the most direct, kind. 
 Until recently there were several legal disadvantages for anyone born illegitimate, though a series of statutes progressively reduced their number, and the Law Commission recommended the total abolition of the concept of illegitimacy. 
 Now at last this has been achieved, first in Scotland by the Law Reform (Parent and Child) (Scotland) Act 1986, and then in England and Wales by the Family Law Reform Act 1987, with the result that in law there is now no distinction made between those born in and those born out of wedlock. 
 Thus illegitimacy is no longer taken into consideration in determining the rights of succession of an illegitimate person, or the rights of succession to his estate, or the rights of succession traced through an illegitimate relationship. 
 Again, illegitimate relations are included among the dependants who are entitled to claim compensation for the death of a person caused by an accident at work. 
 Adoption 
 Until 1926 English law did not recognize the institution of adoption. 
 An Act passed in that year gave power to the court to make an adoption order. 
 On the order being made, all the rights, duties, and obligations of the parents or guardians of the adopted child are extinguished, and these rights, duties, and obligations vest in the adopter. 
 If a husband and wife are the adopters they have the same rights as against one another, and as against the adopted child, as if they were the child's natural father and mother. 
 By an Act of 1934 an adopted child acquires the same rights as a natural child to benefits under what was then the Workmen's Compensation Act 1925 (this Act is now replaced by the Social Security Act 1975). 
 By the Adoption Act 1958, property of adopter and adoptee is to devolve in all respects as if the adoptee were the child of the adopter, born in lawful wedlock. 
 Finally, the Adoption Act 1968 extends the powers of courts in the United Kingdom over adoption, and enables effect to be given in the United Kingdom to adoptions made in other countries; and the Adoption Act 1976 consolidates all the earlier enactments relating to adoption. 
 The adopter must fulfil one of the following requirements:  be over 21; or  be the parent of the adoptee, where the other natural parent is dead, or cannot be found, or there is some other reason justifying the exclusion of the other natural parent. 
 If a sole adopter is a male he cannot adopt a female, unless the court is satisfied that there are special circumstances which justify the adoption. 
 Except under special circumstances the parents, guardians, or persons liable to contribute to the support of the child must give their consent to the adoption. 
 The court must be satisfied that all persons whose consent is required understand the legal effect of the adoption. 
 It must also be satisfied that the adopter has not received nor agreed to receive, and that no person has made or given or agreed to make or give to the adopter, any payment in consideration of the adoption, except such as the court may sanction. 
 Other conditions may be imposed by the court as it sees fit. 
 Married women 
 Women, though at one time excluded from most public functions, were never by reason merely of their sex in a substantially different position from men as regards criminal liability, property and contract, if we except the rule (now nearly obsolete) which prefers males to females in the succession to real estate on intestacy. 
 A married woman, on the other hand, had at Common Law a very peculiar status involving both disabilities and privileges. 
 The Criminal Justice Act 1925 abolished the presumption that an offence committed by a wife in the presence of her husband is committed under his coercion. 
 But the rigour of the criminal law is relaxed in her favour by the provision of the same Act that, on a charge against her for any offence, other than treason or murder, it is a good defence to prove that the offence was committed in the presence of and under the coercion of her husband. 
 She does not become criminally liable merely by assisting her husband to escape punishment for a crime which she knows him to have committed; and it is only within certain limits that husband and wife are competent, and within narrower limits that they are compellable, to give evidence against one another, in criminal proceedings. 
 Under the Law Reform (Husband and Wife) Act 1962, husband and wife, subject to certain discretionary powers of the court, can sue each other. 
 An account has already been given of the proprietary and contractual disabilities of married women at Common Law and the creation by the Court of Chancery of an equitable separate estate which a married woman could freely deal with and bind by her contracts, so far as no restraint on anticipation had been imposed, and which, in any case, she could dispose of by will. 
 But this equitable separate estate existed only where it was created by a will or settlement, or in the comparatively rare cases where the Court of Chancery exercised its jurisdiction to compel a husband to make a settlement upon his wife. 
 Married women of the classes in which settlements and elaborately drawn wills were unknown thus remained subject to the Common Law. 
 When the Legislature determined to reform the Common Law rules two courses were open to it. 
 It could either provide that all married women should hold their property as their separate property &mdash; thus giving to all married women the right to dispose of their property and to make contracts binding it which formerly could only be given to them by a will or a settlement; or it could adopt the more straightforward course of making the capacity of a married woman to own property, make contracts, and incur liability for torts the same as that of a man. 
 In 1882 the Legislature took the first of these courses. 
 As a result of the Married Women's Property Act 1882, and later Acts, the capacity of a married woman to own property, to make contracts, and to incur liability for torts was different from that of a man. 
 Her property was her separate property (that is, separate from her husband, so that only a married woman could have such property), and, by means of a settlement, she could be restrained from anticipating it. 
 By her contracts or her torts she could bind only her separate property. 
 She could not bind herself personally, with the result that she could not be made a bankrupt, unless she was carrying on a trade. 
 But in 1935 the Legislature decided to take the second and more straightforward course. 
 By part I of the Law Reform (Married Women and Tortfeasors) Act 1935, a married woman was put into the same position as a man with respect to her proprietary and contractual capacity, and, except in relation to her husband, with respect to her liability for torts. 
 Existing restraints upon anticipation were preserved, but even these were swept away by the Married Women (Restraint upon Anticipation) Act 1964. 
 And, by the Married Women's Property Act 1964, any money derived by a wife from an allowance made by her husband for housekeeping purposes, or any property acquired out of it, is deemed, in the absence of any agreement between them to the contrary, to belong in equal shares to the husband and wife. 
 The Law Commission has proposed that property (other than land, insurance policies and annuities, or property bought or transferred for business purposes) bought by either spouse for their joint use and benefit should automatically belong to both unless they agree to the contrary; and legislation to this effect is awaited. 
 The Matrimonial Homes Act 1967 (as amended by the Matrimonial Homes and Property Act 1981) gives a spouse who is in occupation of the matrimonial home, but does not occupy it by virtue of an estate, interest, contract, or statute, protection against eviction from the dwelling without the necessity of obtaining leave of the court. 
 If such a spouse is not in occupation, he or she may enter and occupy the home with leave of the court. 
 These rights are called &bquo;rights of occupation&equo;, and where the leave of the court is necessary the court may make such orders as it thinks just and reasonable having regard to the conduct of the spouses, their needs and financial resources, the needs of the children, and all other circumstances. 
 Rights of occupation normally only continue during the subsistence of the marriage and the existence of the other spouse's estate or interest in the home, and they amount to a charge on the other spouse's estate or interest. 
 In the last few years the courts have contrived in effect to extend the substance of a right of occupation to a mistress who has lived on an originally permanent basis with a man, but who has now lost her partner either through death or as a result of some form of desertion. 
 In one case, decided in 1975, Lord Justice James commented: &bquo;The popular meaning of &bquo;family&equo; in 1975 would, according to the answer of the ordinary man, include this woman as a member of the man's family.&equo; 
 And in another case, decided in the same year, the Court of Appeal held that a mistress was entitled to a beneficial interest in the house she had shared with her lover even though he had left it to marry another woman. 
 It is small wonder that the practice has grown up in recent years of referring, however inaccurately, to a mistress as a &bquo;common law wife&equo;. 
 By the Domestic Violence and Matrimonial proceedings Act 1976, protection against eviction from the dwelling a mistress has shared with her lover was introduced, and a host of cases decided under the Act have proved the efficacy of this enactment to safeguard a woman's residential rights, often against physical violence by her former partner. 
 The husband will be presumed, in the ordinary case where husband and wife live together, and she orders goods to meet the household needs, to have authorized her to pledge his credit for that purpose, unless he has supplied her with sufficient ready money. 
 But there is no general rule that the husband is liable for his wife's debts. 
 The husband may, for instance, decide that the needs of the household shall be provided for by a housekeeper, and that the wife shall have no authority to contract on his behalf. 
 And the shopkeeper who supplies goods to a married woman without inquiry is not entitled to assume that she has her husband's authority. 
 It is only when the husband, by meeting the liabilities which his wife has incurred (whether for necessaries or not) to a particular tradesman, has &bquo;held her out&equo; as his agent, that the tradesman is entitled to hold the husband liable until he has received notice to the contrary. 
 The notice sometimes published in the papers to the effect that Mr Smith will no longer be liable for his wife's debts has a much more limited operation than is generally supposed. 
 It is unnecessary as regards persons whom the husband has not by his previous conduct induced to look to him for payment; it is ineffectual as regards those who do not happen to see the advertisement. 
 Another risk run by the shopkeeper who deals with a married woman is that he may find that, though she has property, her husband is insolvent. 
 In such a case, if the wife contracted as agent for her husband, and disclosed that fact to the shop, she incurs no personal liability. 
 Liabilities for contracts and torts incurred by a married woman before marriage are binding on her, and also on her husband to the extent of any property which he may have acquired from her, as under a marriage settlement. 
 Torts committed by the wife during marriage render her liable, but, since 1935, impose no liability on her husband unless he has authorized or ratified them. 
 It can be seen that by piecemeal legislation great strides have been made towards equality between the sexes as regards legal status, rights and liabilities. 
 Though total equality might be hard to achieve because of the biological differences between the sexes, the legislation has perhaps been rounded of by the Equal Pay Act 1970 and the Sex Discrimination Acts 1975 and 1986. 
 Under these Acts, and with only minor exceptions, employers, educational establishments, and those who provide goods, facilities and services to the public (e.g. banks, building societies, finance houses, and landlords) commit a civil offence if they do not provide men and women with the same opportunities and services. 
 An Equal Opportunities Commission, set up by the 1975 Act, oversees the working of the Acts: it may conduct formal investigations, and seek to enforce the law by civil proceedings. 
 Marriage and divorce 
 Historically there seems to be no doubt that the English Common Law required nothing for the celebration of a marriage beyond the declared agreement of the parties, which might take the form either of a declaration of present intention, or of a promise to marry followed by actual union. 
 This was the general law of Western Europe in the Middle Ages. 
 The House of Lords, however, in the nineteenth century decided in an Irish case that the Common Law had always required the presence of an ordained clergyman. 
 The question is now for England an academic one; for statutes, ranging from 1753 to 1986, have prescribed the formalities necessary for a valid marriage. 
 A marriage must be celebrated either in the presence of a clergyman of the Church of England, or (since 1836) of a Registrar of Marriages, or (since 1898) of an &bquo;authorized person&equo;, who is usually the minister authorized by the trustees of a Nonconformist place of worship. 
 Two other persons must be present as witnesses. 
 The celebration must take place between the hours of 8 a.m. and 6 p.m., and must be preceded by a publication of banns or the obtaining of a Registrar's certificate or a Bishop's or Registrar's licence, and unless a special licence is obtained from the Archbishop of Canterbury, must take place in a recognized place of worship or Registrar's office situate in the district in which one at least of the parties resides. 
 Special provisions have been made for death-bed marriages, marriages at home for the housebound, marriages in prisons, hospitals and places of residential care for disabled people, and for the celebration of the marriages of members of the naval, military, and air forces and their daughters in chapels licensed by the Admiralty Board or by a Secretary of State. 
 The marriages of Jews and of members of the Society of Friends are exempt from these provisions, and may be celebrated according to the rules of these religious bodies. 
 In any case provision is made for preserving a record of every marriage celebrated in the country. 
 The law concerning nullity and divorce has been considerably reformed in recent years, and is now mostly governed by the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973. 
 A failure to conform to the legal requirements in contracting a marriage will render that marriage void. 
 A marriage is also void on the ground of nearness of relationship if it is entered into  between ascendants and descendants, e.g. parent and child, grandparent and grandchild, 
  between brother and sister, uncle and niece, nephew and aunt, 
  between persons who, by reason of the previous marriage of one of them, are related in a way corresponding to one of the relationships above mentioned. 
 Under this third prohibition, therefore, a marriage between a stepson and his stepmother was void, but the Marriage (prohibited Degrees of Relationship) Act 1986 has provided an exception. 
 Now a man may marry his stepmother or stepdaughter, or a woman her stepfather or stepson, provided that the younger person is aged at least 21 and has not at any time before reaching the age of 18 lived as a child of the family of the older person. 
 The same Act permits marriages between in-laws, subject to the same provisos, and also provided that the former spouses have died. 
 By a series of Acts ranging from 1907 to 1960 exceptions had already been made permitting a man to marry his deceased or divorced wife's sister or half-sister, his niece by marriage or his aunt by marriage; and a woman may marry her deceased or divorced husband's brother or half-brother. 
 Under the Adoption Act 1976, a marriage between a child and one who has once adopted it is prohibited, but not a marriage between the adoptee and one of the adopter's own children. 
 But the relations by blood or marriage of a wife are not regarded as being related to the relations of her husband: thus if A and B are two brothers and C and D two sisters, the marriage of A with C will be no bar to the marriage of B and D. 
 A marriage celebrated between two persons, one of whom is at the time validly married, is in any case void; and any person knowingly entering into such a marriage is guilty of bigamy. 
 The following are also void: marriages between parties who are not respectively male and female; marriages between persons, either of whom is under the age of 16 (see p. 43); and a polygamous marriage entered into outside England and Wales, if either party was at the time domiciled in England and Wales (for domicile, see pp. 61&ndash;3). 
 In 1985 however, the Law Commission did recommend that a marriage entered into by a man or woman domiciled in England and Wales should not be invalid merely because it is entered into under a law which permits polygamy, provided that neither party is already married. 
 If remains to be seen whether this will be implemented. 
 The law of nullity covers not only cases where the purported marriage was void, but also those where the marriage, though initially valid, is voidable, and thus may be set aside. 
 A marriage is so voidable if it has not been consummated because of the incapacity of either party, or because of one party's wilful refusal to consummate it; if the marriage was entered into without the consent of either party (e.g. by reason of duress, mistake, or unsound mind); if at the time of the marriage one party was suffering from mental disorder of such a kind as to render him or her unfitted for marriage, or from venereal disease; or if the wife was at the time of the marriage pregnant by some other person than her husband. 
 Nullity of marriage must be carefully distinguished from divorce. 
 The effect of a decree of nullity, broadly speaking, is that the marriage is treated as if it had never existed. 
 A petition for divorce, however, postulates the existence of a valid marriage, which the court is asked to terminate. 
 Divorce of this kind was first introduced into English law by the Matrimonial Causes Act 1857, and from then until 1969 it was based upon the doctrine that some matrimonial offence (such as adultery or desertion) must have been committed by one spouse before the other could obtain relief. 
 A break with this doctrine was made by the Divorce Reform Act 1969, now replaced by the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, as amended in 1984, and the present position is that the sole ground on which a petition for divorce may be presented is that the marriage has broken down irretrievably. 
 Such a petition may not, without the special leave of the court, be presented until one year has elapsed since the marriage. 
 Some link with the doctrine of the matrimonial offence has been retained by the further provision that the court may not decide that a marriage has broken down irretrievably unless the petitioner can establish one or more of the five following circumstances: 
  that the respondent has committed adultery, and the petitioner finds it intolerable to live with the respondent; 
  that the respondent has behaved in such a way that the petitioner cannot reasonably be expected to live with him (or her); 
  that the respondent has deserted the petitioner for a continuous period of at least two years preceding the presentation of the petition; 
  that the parties have lived apart for a continuous period of at least two years immediately preceding the presentation of the petition, and the respondent consents to a decree being granted; or 
  that the parties have lived apart for a continuous period of at least five years immediately preceding the presentation of the petition. 
 The behaviour alleged under &ndash;  above would amount to a matrimonial offence, while the circumstances covered by  amount to the first recognition in England of a right of divorce by mutual consent. 
 Absence for seven years, coupled with the fact that a petitioner has no reason to believe that his or her spouse is alive, will enable him or her to ask the court to make a declaration that death is presumed and that the marriage is dissolved. 
 Although divorce is now much easier to obtain than ever before, legislation has since 1963 encouraged efforts at reconciliation. 
 A petitioner's solicitor must now certify that he has discussed the question of reconciliation with his client, and suggested the names of suitably qualified people to help. 
 Furthermore, resumption of cohabitation for any period up to six months is not in itself to be taken to condone the behaviour of the spouse which gives rise to the ground for divorce. 
 A judicial separation may be obtained upon proof of any one of the five bases for divorce mentioned above, save that there is no need to prove that the marriage has broken down irretrievably. 
 This does not, like a divorce, enable the parties to marry again, but it releases them in other respects from the duties of married life. 
 Upon a decree for dissolution of a marriage or judicial separation, the court may make orders for the custody, maintenance, and education of the children, for financial provision to be made for the wife, and for varying marriage settlements. 
 Separation and maintenance orders can also be obtained from magistrates' courts. 
 The recent reform of the grounds for divorce has been mirrored as regards proceedings in magistrates' courts by the Domestic Proceedings and Magistrates' Courts Act 1978, a statute enacted as the result of recommendations made by the Law Commission. 
 Magistrates' orders may now be obtained on four grounds: 
  that the respondent has failed to provide reasonable maintenance for the applicant; 
  that the respondent has failed to provide, or make a proper contribution towards, reasonable maintenance for any child of the family; 
  that the respondent has behaved in such a way that the applicant cannot reasonably be expected to live with the respondent; or 
  that the respondent has deserted the petitioner. 
 The fact that divorce is in many cases equally desired by both parties makes it probable that there may in fact be some collusion between them. 
 Collusion, which used to be a bar to divorce, is no longer prohibited, and indeed a Committee chaired by Mrs Justice Booth recommended in 1985 that the parties should in future be entitled to file joint petitions for divorce. 
 But sometimes material facts are suppressed, or on the other hand one party may petition for divorce without the other party being aware of the proceedings. 
 For this reason an interval of six weeks elapses between the decree nisi , which is made upon the hearing of the case, and the decree absolute, which finally dissolves the marriage and enables the parties to marry again, though the court has power to expedite the decree absolute in a suitable case. 
 During this interval any person may intervene to show cause, on the ground of, e.g., the suppression of material facts, why the decree should not be made absolute, and a public officer, the Queen's Proctor, is especially charged with the duty of intervening. 
 Insanity 
 The nature and degree of insanity which will afford a defence to a criminal charge has from time to time been a matter of considerable discussion. 
 Where the defence arises our courts will act upon the so-called &bquo;M'Naghten&equo; rules, propounded by the judges in response to questions addressed to them by the House of Lords. 
 An accused person is presumed to be sane, until he can prove the contrary. 
 He will be criminally liable unless he was so insane as either &bquo;not to know the nature and quality of the act he was doing&equo;, or &bquo;not to know that what he was doing was against the law&equo;. 
 If he committed the crime under an insane delusion, his liability depends on the question whether he would have been liable had the facts been as he imagined them to be. 
 But uncontrollable impulse, caused by mental defect, is not at present accepted as exempting from criminal liability, except that it may serve to reduce murder to manslaughter (see pp. 167&ndash;8). 
 When a jury is satisfied that the act was committed, but that at the time the accused was so insane as not to be legally responsible, it brings in a special verdict of &bquo;not guilty by reason of insanity&equo;, though the accused is then ordered to be detained during the &bquo;Queen's pleasure&equo;. 
 Detention (at Broadmoor) is usually lifelong, and for this reason insanity is not often pleaded, except very occasionally as a defence to a prosecution for murder. 
 But even in murder cases it is now far more favourable to the accused for him to plead instead diminished responsibility, and for most practical purposes this defence has replaced that of insanity in criminal law. 
 As regards civil rights and liabilities, insanity has a very restricted operation. 
 A marriage contracted by a person so insane at the time as not to appreciate the nature of the obligations of the married state may be set aside at the suit of either party. 
 The marriage of a person who has been judicially declared insane is totally void, and the same is said to be true of any disposition of property made by such a person. 
 In general, however, the contract of a mentally disordered person is fully binding on him unless the other party was aware that he was so insane as not to understand the nature of the transaction. 
 If these conditions are satisfied, the party suffering from mental disorders, on recovering his sanity, or those entitled to act on his behalf, may repudiate or confirm and enforce the contract. 
 A person who is mentally disordered appears to be liable for wrongs, unless his disorder excludes some specific state of mind which forms an essential part of the wrong. 
 Drunkenness due to one's own fault is in itself no defence to a criminal charge; and this is probably true also of drunkenness not due to one's own fault &mdash; though no doubt the fact that it was not due to one's own fault would be a ground for mitigation of punishment. 
 In all cases drunkenness may be material as showing that the accused had not the intention which forms part of the essence of the crime charged. 
 Mental disease caused by drunkenness is in criminal law treated as on the same footing with insanity. 
 In the matter of contract, drunkenness is regarded as having the same effect as insanity. 
 The crown and its servants 
 The Queen, in her private capacity, is incapable of incurring liability, and no proceedings by way of action or prosecution can be taken against her. 
 Government Departments can, however, under the Crown Proceedings Act 1947, be sued  for the recovery of property,  for breach of an ordinary commercial contract, but not for that of a contract of service, a contract dependent upon a future grant of money by parliament, nor, it seems, one in which the Crown purports to fetter its own future executive action, or  for a tort. 
 Servants of the Crown, from the highest executive, administrative, or military officers downwards, enjoy no general immunity for their public acts from either civil or criminal proceedings; and the command of a superior, even the command of the Queen, is no defence to any such proceedings. 
 It is, of course, true that such officers in many cases have powers which enable them to do lawfully what a private person might not do, but the question whether their acts are justified by their powers must be decided in proceedings before the ordinary courts. 
 A servant of the Crown is not himself liable for contracts made by him on behalf of the Crown, nor is he liable as a principal for the acts or defaults of his subordinates unless expressly authorized or subsequently ratified by him. 
 judges enjoy an almost complete immunity in respect of acts &mdash; even corrupt and malicious acts, happily rare in our history &mdash; done by them in their judicial capacity. 
 A judge of an inferior court, in order to entitle himself to this immunity, must, however, show that in reality, or at any rate upon the facts disclosed to him, he had jurisdiction in the matter in question. 
 Foreign sovereigns and the ambassadors of foreign states are immune from the jurisdiction of the English courts unless they voluntarily submit themselves to it, but the actual extent of the immunity is not free from doubt. 
 Nationality and domicile 
 Aliens, i.e. those who are not British citizens, are excluded from public office and public functions such as the parliamentary franchise. 
 They have no enforceable right to enter British territory, and in some cases the Government is authorized by Statute to exclude and even expel them from the United Kingdom. 
 Some provisions of the criminal law apply only to British citizens; an alien cannot own a British ship or a share in one; and some other disabilities have been imposed by Statute, especially on former enemy aliens. 
 But in general the position of an alien in private law does not differ substantially from that of a British citizen. 
 The rule forbidding an alien to hold English land was abrogated in 1870. 
 A radical change in the law relating to British nationality was effected by the British Nationality Act 1948. 
 This reflected the conception of common citizenship between the various parts of the British Commonwealth. 
 The essence of the scheme was that British nationality in the United Kingdom was achieved through citizenship of the United Kingdom and Colonies. 
 This citizenship was attained  by birth in the United Kingdom,  by descent,  by registration, 
  by naturalization, or  by incorporation of territory. 
 However the weight of immigration to the United Kingdom of men and women from other Commonwealth territories, whether dependent or independent, necessitated a further change in 1981. 
 The British Nationality Act 1981, which currently governs this topic, is based upon the aim, seen in many other countries, of making a person's nationality or citizenship accord with the country with which he is most really connected. 
 Under the Act, which now replaces that of 1948, British citizenship is restricted to those with close personal connections with the United Kingdom, the Channel Islands or the Isle of Man. 
 A child born in the United Kingdom will be a British citizen if the father or mother is a British citizen or settled in the United Kingdom in the sense of being entitled to stay indefinitely. 
 Children born in the United Kingdom to students, visitors or illegal immigrants no longer automatically acquire British citizenship at birth, but they will still be able to register as British citizens if either parent later becomes a citizen or settles in the United Kingdom, or if the child has spent the first ten years of its life in the country. 
 A child born abroad will be a British citizen by descent if either the father or mother was born or adopted in the United Kingdom or acquired citizenship by registration or naturalization. 
 There are provisions for registration as British citizens of other children who do not automatically gain British citizenship by descent provided that there is some parental or grandparental link with the United Kingdom. 
 There is also provision for the gaining of citizenship by naturalization by the Home Secretary. 
 An alien woman does not, as formerly, assume British citizenship automatically on marriage to a British citizen. 
 Conversely a woman who is a British citizen does not automatically lose her British citizenship on marriage with an alien. 
 Loss of citizenship may be brought about in three ways,  naturalization in a foreign country,  in case of double citizenship, declaration of renunciation of British citizenship,  revocation of a certificate of naturalization. 
 More important for most purposes of private law than citizenship is domicile. 
 The question, for instance, whether the goods of a person who dies intestate ought to be divided among his relations according to the rules of English or of some foreign law, will be decided by an English court, not according to the citizenship, but according to the domicile of the deceased at the time of his death. 
 A person's domicile is the country which is in fact or in the eye of the law his permanent home for the time being. 
 Seeing that our law refuses to contemplate the possibility of any person either being without a domicile or having more than one domicile, the rules on this subject are not only intricate but highly artificial. 
 In 1987 the Jaw Commission recommended some radical change and simplification, but this has not yet been adopted. 
 For the present we may note that every person is considered to start life with a &bquo;domicile or origin&equo;, which will be, as a rule, the domicile of his father at the time of his birth; and that this domicile of origin continues until it is shown that some other domicile has been acquired, and is restored whenever an acquired domicile is lost without the acquisition of another. 
 Formerly the domicile of a wife was necessarily the same as that of her husband, but under the Domicile and Matrimonial Proceedings Act 1973 the wife's dependent domicile was abolished: now her domicile is determined according to the same rules as for a single person. 
 The substitution of citizenship for domicile in cases like that mentioned, after the manner of the law of some foreign countries, even if desirable on general grounds, would not solve the questions which arise when the laws of different parts of the same national territory, e.g. of England and Scotland, or of two states of the United States of America, come into competition. 
 It is obvious that a pretty problem arises when the test of domicile refers the English courts to the law of a country which applies the test of citizenship and it happens that the citizenship of the person in question was British. 
 Corporations 
 Bodies or groups of human beings may have legally recognized rights and duties, which cannot be treated as the rights and duties of the members. 
 Such bodies are known as corporations, or (to distinguish them from the corporations sole, to be mentioned later) corporations aggregate. 
 The marks of a corporation are:  perpetual succession, i.e. the death or withdrawal of members, or the addition of new members from time to time, does not impair the continuity and identity of the body: &bquo;in like manner&equo;, as Blackstone says, &bquo;the river Thames is still the same river, though the parts which comprise it are changing every instant';  the use of a common seal as evidence of at least the more formal acts of the corporation; and  the capacity to sue and be sued by its corporate name. 
 The legal recognition of corporate character may be obtained either by a charter from the Crown, as in the case of most of our older corporations, like the Hudson's Bay Company, some universities and their colleges, as well as of some more recent ones; or directly by means of an incorporating Act of parliament, as in the case of certain public utilities; or indirectly through an Act of Parliament like the Companies Act 1948 (which has been amended by several later Acts of the same name, and consolidated by the Companies Act 1985), which offers corporate character to any number of persons (usually not less than seven) associated for a lawful object, who are willing to comply with the statutory requirements as to registration and otherwise. 
 As a being capable of having legal rights and liabilities, a corporation is a person in the eye of the law. 
 So far as English lawyers have theorized about the nature of corporate personality at all, they at one time for the most part accepted the doctrine of the Canon Law, that such personality is a mere fiction of the law with no basis in fact. 
 But this doctrine has been largely supplanted by a later doctrine that such personality is real, and is analogous to the personality of individuals. 
 It is impossible here to enter into the details of this controversy, but it may be noticed that 
  the &bquo;fiction theory&equo; must remain unsatisfactory unless it can explain what are the real facts in terms of individual rights and duties which underlie the fiction, and this it seems unable to do. 
 It does not seem possible to explain away the legal rights and duties of a body as being merely the rights and duties of the individuals composing it; and 
  the notion of a corporate personality is not confined to law. 
 We habitually think of the actions of nations and of societies as distinct from the actions of the individuals composing them, and we attribute moral qualities to such actions, and moral rights and duties to nations and societies. 
 In fact it is impossible to deny the reality of the life and personality of many various groups and societies. 
 It is because the State has recognized this fact that the law has insisted that, for a legal life and personality, these groups and societies must get the authority of the State, and submit to its conditions. 
 The reason for this insistence is obvious. 
 As Burke said, &bquo;Liberty when men act in bodies is power&equo;. 
 The State can never be indifferent to the creation of a power or powers which may rival its own. 
 The legal capacity of corporations differs in some respects from that of individuals, partly from the nature of the case, partly as a consequence of the fact that their personality is an artificial one. 
 It is obvious, for instance, that they cannot enter into family relations. 
 Their amenability to the criminal law can never be the same as that of natural persons, though this has been increased by the powers conferred on judges and magistrates, by the Criminal Justice Act 1948, to impose a fine instead of imprisonment. 
 On the other hand, a corporation can own property; it can acquire rights and make itself liable under a contract; it can be a trustee; it can incur civil liability for wrongful acts, and even for those which involve a definite state of mind like fraud or malice. 
 For the making of contracts by a corporation the Common Law required a document under the corporation's common seal, except in matters of trifling importance or daily necessary occurrence. 
 Even apart from such exceptions, however, a contract not made in the required form, but completely performed on one side, might be enforced. 
 The Common Law rule was partly destroyed by the Companies Acts, and, under the Corporate Bodies&equo; Contracts Act 1960, contracts can now be made on behalf of all corporations in the same way as between private persons. 
 Under the doctrine of ultra vires , there is a limit in point of substance on the transactions into which a corporation may enter. 
 A Common Law corporation (i.e. one created by Charter from the Crown) is, it is true, presumed to have the contractual capacity of an individual. 
 Prima facie such a corporation has the power to do with its property all such acts as an ordinary person can do, and to bind itself to such contracts as an ordinary person can bind himself to. 
 Even if the Charter should contain restrictions on its freedom of action, acts transgressing such restrictions are probably not void, though they may be a ground for revoking the Charter. 
 But a corporation created by or in pursuance of an Act of Parliament is subject to the rule that it has only such powers as are expressly conferred, or are necessarily or reasonably incident to the fulfilment of the purposes for which it is established. 
 Acts done in excess of such powers are legally void, and will if necessary be restrained by the courts. 
 Thus a company directly created by special Act of Parliament will be restricted to acts necessary or reasonably incident to the objects specified in the Act. 
 Yet one of the alterations effected in English law by the European Communities Act 1972 is that a person in good faith will not be prejudiced by any ultra vires  transactions of a company, provided that the transaction was authorized by the company's directors. 
 It is therefore not unlikely that before long Parliament may abolish the ultra vires  rule in company law altogether. 
 In any case a company formed under the Companies Act has a considerable power of altering the objects stated in the Memorandum of Association which is signed by its first members at the formation of the company, subject to the power of the holders of fifteen per cent of its shares or debentures to apply to the court to cancel an alteration. 
 This power may serve a number of purposes. 
 It may prevent extraordinary powers, like that of compulsorily acquiring land, from being abused for unauthorized purposes; it may prevent a corporation, constituted for purposes of public utility, from endangering those purposes by engaging in other activities; it may protect the creditors of a company from the dissipation of the company's capital, to which alone, in the case of a limited company, they can look for payment, and the members from seeing their contributions applied to purposes for which they did not bargain. 
 The Companies Act 1967, now consolidated in the Act of 1985, considerably strengthens the controls over the auditing of company accounts and the form of directors&equo; reports. 
 Among the matters which now have to be disclosed are directors&equo; share dealings in their companies, and the amount of any contributions to political causes. 
 In addition to corporations aggregate, English law attributes a continuous legal personality under the name of &bquo;corporations sole&equo; to the Queen, and to the successive holders of certain offices, especially the holders of ecclesiastical offices, such as bishops, and rectors and vicars of parishes. 
 The conception, however, as applied to the Queen, and to these ecclesiastical persons, has not, for historical reasons, produced satisfactory results. 
 But it is a useful conception; and it has been applied by Statute to some public officers, such as certain Ministers and the Official Solicitor. 
 Societies and institutions 
 There are no prohibitions against the formation of associations or societies for any lawful object &mdash; religious, social, political, philanthropic, or the like. 
 The law does not, however, regard such societies (unless formally incorporated) as having any corporate personality; it sees only individuals, owning property, it may be, in common, with rights and duties towards each other flowing from the contract, or rather series of contracts, to be found in the society's rules; for on every change in the membership a new contract must be implied. 
 Such contract or contracts may be varied if, and only if, the rules so provide, by a majority of the members or by a specified majority. 
 The common property, if it is more than mere cash in hand or at the bank, will be vested in trustees who must deal with it in accordance with the rules or with any trust expressly declared, and it can be made liable for obligations incurred by, or on behalf of, the society. 
 But no liability for tort can be enforced against a Trade Union for acts done in contemplation or furtherance of a specific trade dispute (within strict limits), and possibly not against other unincorporated societies. 
 Where the objects of the society are charitable in the legal sense, which includes the relief of poverty, the advancement of education or religion, and other purposes beneficial to the community, formalities prescribed by older statutes have been abolished by the Charities Act 1960, which, however, provides for compulsory registration of all charities not especially exempted. 
 If the objects of the society are not charitable, the rule against perpetuities (see p. 42), from which charities, provided that they are to begin within the perpetuity period, are exempt, will make void any gift of property by way of permanent endowment, whether made by will or otherwise; but there is nothing to prevent gifts or bequests from being made to a non-charitable society in such terms that it can, at any time, dispose of the capital at its pleasure. 
 The rules of a society and the trusts which bind its property will, in many cases, fetter its freedom of action and the application of its property, in a way very similar to the restrictions which the doctrine of ultra vires  imposes on a corporation; and in the case of some unincorporated societies, such as registered Trade Unions and Friendly Societies, which have received a peculiar status by Statute, the rule of ultra vires  has been held directly applicable. 
 But, subject to considerable restrictions on the furtherance of political objects, a Trade Union is empowered by Statute since 1913 to devote its funds to any lawful objects authorized by its rules for the time being. 
 Some systems of law recognize as legal persons, not only corporations, but institutions, such as hospitals or places of education; but this conception is unknown to our law. 
 We either treat as a corporation a group of persons &mdash; usually the governing body of the institution, though it may include individuals who are beneficiaries and have no share in the government (for instance, the scholars of a college) &mdash; or else the property of the institution must be vested in a number of individual trustees, who are bound to apply and deal with it for the purposes of the institution. 
 Agency and partnership 
 Agency may be regarded as an extension of legal personality. 
 Not only in law, but in ordinary life, we look upon an act done by one man in pursuance of another's orders as done by the person who gives the order. 
 Moreover, there seems to be nothing artificial in principle in holding the acts of an employee done in the course of his employment as equivalent to the acts of the employer. 
 These principles, are, however, applied in different degrees in the respective spheres of Criminal and Civil Law. 
 A man is not punishable for a serious crime committed by another unless he has actually instigated the commission of a crime, and then he will be punishable though the crime committed may differ in some degree from that which he instigated. 
 It may be noted that in Criminal Law anyone who aids, counsels, or procures the commission of an offence is liable to be tried and punished in the same way as if he were a principal offender. 
 But in the case of minor offences, and especially statutory offences, which are anti-social rather than immoral, a man may be punished even for the unauthorized act or default of one in his employment. 
 In the case of wrongful acts, which involve civil liability apart from breach of contract or trust, a distinction is drawn between a servant and an independent contractor. 
 A servant is one over whom the employer reserves the control and direction of the mode in which the work is to be done. 
 The master is liable for wrongful acts and defaults of his servant &mdash; though they may be unauthorized or even forbidden by him &mdash; so long as they are done within the scope of the employment. 
 An omnibus company was held liable for the act of one of its drivers, who overturned a rival omnibus while racing with it and obstructing it, although directions had been issued to the driver forbidding such conduct. 
 The independent contractor is one who has agreed to do a piece of work, but is to be left free to choose his own method of doing it. 
 In such cases the employer is not liable in general for any wrong which consists in the improper carrying out of such work, though he will, of course, be liable if unlawful acts are done which he has actually authorized. 
 Contracts made by any agent in pursuance of the principal's instructions are binding on, and operate for the benefit of, the latter. 
 Further, the employment of an agent may be such as to give him an authority to contract on behalf of his principal generally with regard to a wider or narrower class of affairs; and as between the principal and third parties such authority cannot be limited by restrictions imposed by the principal, but not known to third parties. 
 The fact that a person is acting under the instructions or on behalf of another is no defence to civil or criminal proceedings brought against the agent for tort or crime. 
 On the other hand, an agent acquires no rights under contracts made by him on behalf of his principal; and where the existence of the principal is known to those contracting with the agent, the latter, as a rule, incurs no liability for such contracts. 
 Where the principal's existence is undisclosed, the other contracting party, on discovering it, has an option whether he will hold agent or principal liable. 
 When a person purports to act on behalf of another, but without his authority, the latter may subsequently ratify the act of the former, and thereby draw to himself both the benefit of, and the liability for, the act. 
 But if there is no such ratification, the agent will be liable to those who contract on the faith of the authority which he professes to have. 
 No special form is necessary for the appointment of an agent, except that an agent who is to execute documents under seal in the name of his principal must be appointed by a &bquo;power of attorney&equo;, which is itself a document under seal. 
 Revocation by the principal, his death, and in some cases his insanity, put an end to the agent's authority, though in general a revocation will be inoperative as against those to whom the principal has held out the agent as having authority, and who have no notice of the revocation. 
 Moreover, modern legislation has made possible (within limits) the creation of an irrevocable power of attorney, so that even knowledge of the principal's death or insanity will not affect the validity of acts done under it. 
 An agent must not, without his principal's knowledge and consent, receive any reward or commission from those with whom he deals on his principal's behalf, or derive any profit from transactions entered into on the principal's behalf beyond the remuneration agreed upon. 
 Both civil and criminal liability are incurred by the corrupt giving or receiving of such commission. 
 In partnership, which is &bquo;the relation which subsists between persons carrying on a business in common with a view of profit&equo;, every partner is an agent of the firm and of the other partners for the purpose of the business of the partnership. 
 A firm is not in England a legal personality distinct from its members, though in Scotland a firm is a legal person distinct from the partners of whom it is composed (partnership Act 1890, s. 4 ). 
 In an ordinary partnership each of the partners is liable without limit for all the debts and obligations of the firm. 
 The severity of this rule has been the more acutely felt because the existence of a partnership, which needs no special form for its creation, has often been inferred &mdash; less often, it is true, in recent years than formerly &mdash; from the fact of the receipt by a person of a share of the profits of a business. 
 Since 1907 the law has permitted the formation of &bquo;limited partnerships&equo;, which must be registered and must consist of at least one general partner, who is liable without limit, and of one or more limited partners, each of whom is not liable beyond the amount contributed by him on entering into the partnership. 
 A limited partner is forbidden, on pain of rendering his liability unlimited, to take any part in the management of the business, and has no power to bind the firm. 
 But limited partnerships are rare, private companies, which were sanctioned the next year by the Companies Act 198, having proved more popular. 
 No partnership, whether limited or unlimited, may consist of more than twenty persons. 
 Enemy status 
 In time of war, persons for the time being residing or doing business in an enemy country, whatever their nationality or domicile, are disabled from suing in the English Courts; but, if sued here, they will so far as possible be given an opportunity of defending themselves. 
 Every communication for commercial or other purposes, by those in this country, with such persons or bodies is a criminal offence (&bquo;trading with the enemy'), unless licensed by the Crown. 
 Any contract or transaction, the formation or execution of which involves such communication, is (or, if made before the war, becomes) void. 
 PROPERTY 
 The conception of property 
 There is, perhaps, nothing more difficult than to give a precise and consistent meaning to the word &bquo;property&equo;. 
 The word &bquo;estate&equo; is often used to denote the whole of a man's proprietary rights, more especially after his death. 
 This sense of the word &bquo;estate&equo; must not be confused with the special meaning which it has in regard to interests in land (see p. 78). 
 When we speak of a man of property, we may think, perhaps, in one of two ways. 
 First, we may think of the traditional or even oldfashioned type of man with tangible material things which belong to him &mdash; land and houses, horses and cattle, furniture and jewellery and pictures &mdash; things which he may use or destroy (so far as that is physically possible); from which he may exclude others; which he may sell or give away or bequeath; which, if he has made no disposition of them, will pass on his death to persons related to him. 
 Alternatively we may think of the more modern figure of a man whose wealth lies in his investments in stocks and shares. 
 Whichever type of man we think of, we may find it difficult to say whether by &bquo;property&equo; we mean the things themselves or the aggregate of rights which are exercised over them. 
 To confine the word to either sense would hardly be possible without pedantry; though, on the one hand, we may agree that a thing which has no owner &mdash; a rare event in a civilized country, except in the case of a few things, like wild animals at large &mdash; is not property, and, on the other, we may often avoid confusion by using the word &bquo;ownership&equo; for the most extensive right which a man can have over material things. 
 But, further, we shall find that our conception of property relates to many things which are not tangible or material. 
 Our man of property may be an author or a patentee, and we shall hardly be able to say that his copyright or patentright is not part of his property, or even to avoid speaking of his ownership of the copyright or patent. 
 He will have debtors: his bank is a debtor to him for the amount standing to his credit; his investments of money are claims to receive payment from the State or from corporations or individuals. 
 Such debts and claims are not rights over any specific tangible objects; they are mere rights against the State or the corporation or the person liable to pay. 
 Yet these rights are transferable, and will pass on his death to his representatives. 
 We cannot exclude them from our notion of property or deny that in a sense, at any rate, he is the owner of them. 
 On the other hand, his &bquo;property&equo; clearly does not include all his rights. 
 To say nothing of his general right of liberty or reputation, his rights as a husband or a parent are not proprietary rights, nor is his right to recover damages for personal injury or defamation; but we may include among proprietary rights the right to recover damages though unliquidated (i.e. of uncertain amount until settled by a judge or jury) for breach of contract, or, probably, even for injury to his property. 
 Generally speaking, we shall include under the notion of a man's property in its widest sense all rights which are capable of being transferred to others, of being made available for payment of his debts, or of passing to his representatives on his death. 
 Ownership and possession 
 Turning to rights over tangible things, we must notice the distinction between ownership and possession. 
 The owner of a thing is the person who has, in the fullest degree, those rights of use and enjoyment, of destruction, and of disposition, which have been mentioned above &mdash; subject, of course, to the general rules of law which protect the rights of others, to certain limited rights which he or his predecessors may have created in favour of others, and, in the case of land, to rules imposed by statute under which local and other authorities may purchase property compulsorily. 
 The owner of a firearm is none the less owner because the law prohibits him from discharging it in a public highway; the owner of a field does not cease to be owner because the public or a neighbour has the right to use a footpath across it. 
 The essence of ownership, then, is that it is a right or an aggregate of rights. 
 Possession, on the other hand, is primarily a matter of fact. 
 If the owner of a watch is robbed of it by a thief, the owner's rights as rights remain intact; the thief acquires no right to the watch as against the owner. 
 But the owner's possession, and with it his actual power to exercise his rights, is for the time being gone; he must recover the watch &mdash; as he may even lawfully do by his own act &mdash; before he can be said to be again in possession of it. 
 So, too, the owner of land may be out of possession, and another without right may be in possession. 
 In this case the forcible retaking of possession is prohibited under penalties by statute; but the retaking, though punishable, is none the less effective to restore the possession. 
 The cases of the thief and the squatter have been taken as the clearest instances of possession acquired without any right whatever. 
 But possession may be lawfully acquired, and yet be unaccompanied by ownership. 
 An owner who delivers a car or a bicycle by way of loan or hire to another parts with the possession to him, but does not cease to be owner. 
 The same is true of one who delivers articles to another in order that the latter may bestow his labour upon them. 
 Such voluntary transfers of possession are called bailment, and the person who so acquires possession is a bailee of the goods. 
 In none of these cases do we think of the owner as having parted with the right of ownership, though it may be that the contract between the parties creates rights in favour of the bailee which the owner cannot use his right of ownership to override. 
 If we try to analyse the conception of possession, we find two elements. 
 In the first place, it involves some actual power of control over the thing possessed. 
 In the second place, it involves some intention to maintain that control on the part of the possessor. 
 The nature and extent of the control and intention necessary to constitute possession will vary with the circumstances, and particularly with the character of the thing of which the possession is in question. 
 possession of a house, for instance, will be evidenced by acts different from those which would suffice for possession of a strip of waste land. 
 The occupier of a private house (but not the owner of a house who had never entered into possession of it) would probably be considered to be in possession of anything placed or left in it &mdash; at any rate unless it was concealed &mdash; while the occupier of a shop has been held not to be in possession of a thing dropped in a part of the shop to which the public had access. 
 By a somewhat artificial rule, a servant who receives a thing from his master for the master's use is deemed not to be in possession of it, though the contrary is true where he receives it from a stranger for the master's use. 
 So far we have thought of ownership and possession as sharply distinguished &mdash; the one a matter of right, the other of fact. 
 Nevertheless, possession is a fact which has an enormous legal significance, a fact to which legal rights are attached. 
 In the first place, actual possession is evidence of ownership, and, except in cases where ownership is based on a system of public registration, it is hard to see how any ownership can be proved, otherwise than by going back to some prior possession. 
 If A claims the ownership of land by reason of B's bequest or sale to him, this only raises the question, On what is B's ownership based? and ultimately we shall have to rest content with saying that the root of A's title is the possession of some predecessor, X. Such evidence, however, is not conclusive. 
 The presumption of ownership which follows from A's or X's possession may, for instance, be rebutted by a rival claimant, Y, who can show that he or his predecessor was in possession, and that A or X wrongfully dispossessed him. 
 In the second place, possession is not merely evidence of ownership, but (subject to the rights of the owner) is itself and for its own sake entitled to legal protection. 
 If A has been disturbed in his possession by a trespass committed by B, or even if B has deprived A of possession, A's claim to legal protection or redress against B cannot be met by B's plea that C and not A is the true owner. 
 The finder of goods is entitled &mdash; except only against one who can show himself to be the owner &mdash; to legal protection against all the world. 
 Nor is this right of the possessor based on any responsibility on his part to the owner. 
 The Postmaster-General (later the Minister of Posts and Telecommunications) was held entitled to recover damages for the loss of the mails destroyed by the fault of a colliding ship, though he was not the owner and disclaimed all responsibility to the owners for the loss. 
 This right to redress which the law confers on the possessor is independent of, and at least as old as, if not older than, the legal protection given to the owner. 
 The possessor's right is even spoken of as a &bquo;special property&equo;, in contradistinction to the &bquo;general property&equo; of the owner. 
 It is a right which he may transfer, and which on his death will pass under his will or according to the rules of intestacy. 
 Lastly, we may notice that even a wrongful possession, if continued for a certain length of time, matures into what may be, for practical purposes, indistinguishable from ownership. 
 A wrongful possession of land for twelve years, or of goods for six years, destroys not only the former owner's right to recover the land or goods by action, but also his title; and so the possessor has the best of titles known to the law &mdash; a possession which no one can dispute. 
 Real property and personal property 
 Between the ownership of land and of goods every system of law must needs draw distinctions, which are founded on the nature of the subject matter. 
 But the distinctions drawn by English law were, till the passing of the Property Acts, which came into force on 1 January 1926, founded, not so much on the nature of the subject matter, as upon the historical accidents in the development of the English law of property. 
 Property was divided into the two categories of real property and personal property; and personal property was divided into two categories of chattels real and chattels personal. 
 Real property included most of the interests in land recognized by the law, and other rights, such as easements and profits (see p. 82), annexed to the land. 
 This property was called &bquo;real&equo; because, from the first, it was recoverable specifically by a real action. 
 In fact anything thus recoverable was real property. 
 property thus recoverable developed a set of legal characteristics which caused it to differ considerably from property which was recoverable only by a personal action; and so, though the real actions have long been abolished, and for a still longer time disused, the differences between real and personal property survived. 
 Not all the interests in land known to the law were included in the category of real property. 
 Interests in land for a term of years (leaseholds) were originally regarded, not as interests in the land, but as contractual rights. 
 The lessee was protected, not by a real action, but by a personal action against his lessor, in which he could recover, not the land itself, but only damages to the breach of his landlord's contract to allow him the use of the land. 
 Hence his interest is personal property, and is classed as a chattel, though, by reason of its close relation to real property, it is distinguished as a chattel real. 
 Leaseholders long since obtained remedies for the specific recovery of their land: and those remedies were in fact far superior to the old real actions. 
 But because these interests in land were protected by personal and not by the real actions, they developed a set of legal characteristics which caused them to differ from the interests classed as real property. 
 Notable differences were to be found in the rules as to succession on intestacy and in the variety of estates and interests which could be created in these two kinds of property. 
 All property other than real property and chattels real is classed as chattels personal. 
 Chattels personal consist either of tangible goods, or of intangible rights such as patents, or stocks and shares. 
 They differ from real property in two main respects. 
 First, chattels personal can be owned, while real property is held mediately or immediately of the Queen. 
 Secondly, until 1926, at law (as opposed to equity) no limited interests in chattels personal could be created &mdash; the notion of estates had no application to chattels personal till the Law of Property Act 1925 made it possible to create an entailed interest in them. 
 In this respect equity differed from the common law. 
 We shall see that it was always possible to settle chattels personal upon trusts for various persons with limited interests (see pp. 86&ndash;7, 101&ndash;5). 
 Tenure 
 In the medieval period, it was a very significant legal commonplace that full ownership of land was possible for no person save the King. 
 Those commonly called landowners were regarded as &bquo;holding&equo; their land, by various forms of &bquo;tenure&equo;, of the King. 
 Of these the most honourable, but at the same time the most burdensome, was tenure by knight service, which involved many irksome &bquo;incidents&equo; (see Chapter 2, note 2). 
 The incidents of  socage  tenure consisted of fixed, and nominal, agricultural services. 
 By the Statute of Tenures 1660, all free tenures (with insignificant exceptions) were converted into  socage . 
 Though 1660 marked the end of feudalism in its political aspect, in the sphere of private law it continued to cause many difficulties, which were not removed until 1925. 
 One practical Mark of its survival was the doctrine of escheat. 
 If a socage tenant died without heirs and intestate, his land escheated, i.e. went back to the lord of whom it was held, who in practically all cases had come to be the King. 
 A statute called Quia Emptores  (1290) had enacted that whenever a tenant alienated his land for an estate in fee simple, the alienee should hold, not of the alienor, but of the alienor's lord. 
 The long-term result of this statute was that practically all land held by free tenure had come to be held of the King. 
 Escheat was swept away, together with the old law of intestate succession, by the new scheme introduced by the Administration of Estates Act 1925. 
 Estates in possession 
 The different types of tenure marked out the leading characteristics of the different forms of land holding known to the law; but they told us nothing of the nature and incidents of the various interests which those who held by these tenures might have in the land. 
 It is this question of the nature and incidents of these interests which we must now consider. 
 The word used by English law to denote the tenant's interest in the land is the word &bquo;estate&equo;. 
 An estate is a portion of the ownership of the land, more or less limited in time. 
 This limitation in time is most clearly seen in the case of a life estate, whether it be an estate held for the life of the tenant, or what is called an estate pur autre vie , one held for the life or lives of some other person or persons. 
 The holder of such an estate in land is, like an owner, entitled to the possession, use, and enjoyment of the land, and he can dispose of his interest; but at the death of the person by whose life the extent of his estate is measured, the estate comes to an end, and nothing passes from the holder. 
 Even the holder's enjoyment is restricted (unless he be declared &bquo;unimpeachable for waste') by consideration for the rights of those who have subsequent estates in the land. 
 He must not diminish the capital value of the land by the commission of acts called &bquo;waste&equo;, such as cutting timber or opening mines. 
 At the other end of the scale we have the estate in fee simple. 
 Such an estate is practically equivalent to ownership. 
 It confers full rights of possession and enjoyment (unrestricted by any rules as to waste) and full rights of disposition whether during the tenant's lifetime or by his wife. 
 If he dies intestate, the land will pass to his relations entitled in that event (see pp. 112&ndash;13 for the modern law on this subject). 
 Only in the event of his death intestate and without relations so entitled, will the estate come to an end, and the land pass to the Crown. 
 The limit in time is here practically non-existent. 
 Intermediate between the life estate and the estate in fee simple is the estate tail. 
 The tenant in tail has full rights of possession and enjoyment without regard to waste. 
 Nor does the estate come to an end with the tenant's death: it passes to his heirs, but only to a limited class of heirs, &bquo;the heirs of his body&equo;, that is, his descendants. 
 (For the rules of inheritance for ascertaining the heir, see pp. 111&ndash;13.) 
 The line of descent may be further restricted by making the estate an estate in tail-male, i.e. one descendible only to males and only in the male line, or conceivably (though in practice this appears never to be done) in tall-female descendible only to and through females. 
 There is even an estate known as an estate in &bquo;special tail&equo;, inheritable only by the issue of the tenant by a certain wife or husband. 
 In the latter case, if the wife or husband dies without issue the tenant is said to be tenant in tail, &bquo;after possibility of issue extinct&equo;, and his rights are substantially no greater than those of a tenant for life. 
 Before 1926 a tenant in tail had no power to dispose of his estate by will; but a tenant in tail in possession could in his lifetime, and still can, bar the entail by a deed, i.e. he can turn it into a fee simple estate. 
 If his estate is not in possession, e.g. if it is limited to A for life and then to B in tail, A is the &bquo;Protector of the settlement&equo;, and B cannot bar the entail without A's consent. 
 We shall see that, since 1 January 1926, the only one of these estates which survives as a legal estate is the estate in fee simple. 
 The others exist only as equitable interests. 
 Their incidents are similar to the incidents of the old legal estates, though certain important changes have been introduced (see p. 86&ndash;7). 
 Estates in futuro  
 Before 1 January 1926 there were three main varieties of legal estates in futuro . 
  Reversions and remainders . 
 An estate for life was less than an estate tail, and both were smaller than a fee simple. 
 Suppose now that a tenant in fee simple granted the land to another to hold for life or in tall. 
 If he did nothing more he would still retain his fee simple, but he would have deprived himself of the right to present possession and enjoyment of the land; his estate would become a future estate, which would again become a present estate, an &bquo;estate in possession&equo;, only when the smaller estate, the &bquo;particular estate&equo; which had been carved out of it, came to an end. 
 For the time being, what was left to him was called a reversion. 
 Further, he might by the same instrument grant a present estate, say for life, to A, followed by an estate for life or in tail to B, and, if he wished, as many further particular estates (for life or in tail) to other persons successively as he pleased, ending up, if he thought fit, with an estate in fee simple to some person named. 
 Each of these future estates was called a remainder. 
 No reversion or remainder, however, could be placed after a fee simple. 
 Each of these future estates, though it gave no present right to possession or enjoyment, was treated as something already in existence, which could be disposed of and would descend (so far as it is inheritable) just like a present estate. 
 If, for instance, A was tenant for life and B tenant in fee simple in reversion or remainder, B's death before A's would not destroy the estate in fee simple, but B's heir, or the person to whom B had conveyed it by deed, or left it by will, was entitled to come in on A's death. 
 So again, if A was tenant in tail, and B tenant in fee simple in reversion, the failure of A's issue at his death, or at any later time, would vest the fee simple in possession in whatever person then represented B. In such cases ownership, we may say, was cut up into lengths called estates. 
 None of the holders of an estate, except the tenant in fee simple when in possession, was fully owner, but each as he came into possession was a &bquo;limited&equo; owner. 
  Shifting and springing uses . 
 We have seen that, if A held land to the use of B, the Statute of Uses turned B's equitable estate into a legal estate (see p. 23). 
 Now it was possible for a settlor who conveyed land to A to direct him to hold to the use of B; and then to direct that, on the happening of an event, e.g. B's marriage, B's use should shift to C. This use in favour of C was a shifting use. 
 Or the settlor could direct that in a certain event a new use should spring up in D's favour. 
 This use in favour of D was a springing use. 
 When the use in favour of C or D arose, C or D's uses were turned into legal estates by the Statute of Uses. 
  Executory devises . 
 The Statute of Wills 1540 gave testators power to create future legal estates by their wills. 
 These estates were known as executory devises. 
 We shall see that since 1 January 1926 none of these future legal estates can be created, but that similar results can be effected by the creation of future equitable interests through the medium of a trust. 
 Co-ownership 
 Co-ownership entitles two or more persons concurrently to the possession and enjoyment of the same land. 
 Before 1 January 1926 it could take three forms: coparcenary, or tenancy in common, or joint tenancy. 
 Coparcenary existed if a person died intestate leaving two or more females as his heirs. 
 They took the land as coparceners. 
 When two or more persons took as tenants in common, the share of each was treated as a separate item of property which could not only be transferred by him in his lifetime, but which would pass on his death to his representatives. 
 In the case of joint tenancy, on the other hand, the rights of each (except the last survivor) are extinguished by his death so as to increase the interest of the survivor or survivors. 
 A joint tenant might, however, transfer his interest in his lifetime (though not by will); and such a transfer would, before 1 January 1926, have had the effect of making the transferee a tenant in common with the other or others, though the others continued as between themselves to be joint tenants. 
 Any one of a number of co-owners was entitled to have the property &bquo;partitioned&equo;, i.e. divided, or at any rate to have the property sold and his share paid out to him. 
 Where a number of trustees are appointed they are always made joint tenants, in order that, on the death of one, the whole property may be vested in the survivors; but in other cases joint tenancy is inconvenient and rarely occurs. 
 We shall see that since 1 January 1926 the only one of these three forms of co-ownership which exists as a legal estate is joint tenancy (see p. 87); but that both coparcenary and tenancy in common exist as equitable estates. 
 Both ownership in common and joint ownership may exist in the case of chattels personal as well as in the case of land. 
 Other interests in land 
 Besides the interests in land which are known as estates, and which, when they are present estates, give a right to possession of the land, English law, like other systems, recognizes rights of a more restricted kind. 
 Among these we may notice easements , such as rights of way, rights of light, rights to take water or to discharge water over the land of another. 
 A true easement must always be &bquo;appurtenant&equo; to a piece of land. 
 An individual cannot, for instance, as such have a right of way over my land, but only as owner of some adjacent piece of land. 
 Rights similar to easements may, however, exist in favour of the public, e.g. a public high-way; or in favour of a limited class &mdash; e.g. the fishermen of a village may by custom have the right to dry their nets on a piece of land, the inhabitants of a village may have a right to use the village green for purposes of recreation. 
 Profits &agrave; prendre  are rights to take things of value (other than water) from land, such as the right of common pasture, or rights of fishery (commoners, it should be noticed, are not owners of the common). 
 Such rights, though commonly appendant or appurtenant to land &mdash; there is little practical difference between the two phrases &mdash; are not necessarily so. 
 They may exist in favour of individuals, and in some cases in favour of a limited class, but, with the exception of the public right of fishing in tidal water, they cannot exist in favour of the public at large. 
 The effect of long-continued possession of land in extinguishing adverse rights, and so converting the possession into what is indistinguishable from ownership, has already been referred to (see p. 76). 
 Different in theory, but similar in effect, are the provisions of the Prescription Act 1832, under which rights to easements and profits &agrave; prendre  may be established by reason of enjoyment for a period of not less than twenty years in the one case, and not less than thirty in the other. 
 Special rules as to the acquisition of public rights of way by lapse of time have been made by the Rights of Way Act 1932. 
 A rentcharge is the right to receive an annual sum out of the income of land, usually in perpetuity, and to distrain if the payments are in arrear; the owner of the land is also personally liable to pay, and further remedies against the land have been given by statute. 
 In some parts of the country it has been the practice to sell freehold land for building, and to take the price in the form of a perpetual rentcharge created by the purchaser; this practice took the place of the more common building lease. 
 The Rentcharges Act 1977 prohibited the creation of further rent-charges, and provided also for the extinguishment of all existing rentcharges at the end of sixty years starting on 22 July 1977, or on the date the rentcharge first became payable, whichever is later. 
 Alternatively a rentcharge may, under the 1977 Act, be bought out by a lump sum payment. 
 The right to take tithes, i.e. a share of the produce of the land in kind, originally vested only in ecclesiastical persons and bodies, was at the Reformation transferred in many cases to laymen, though tithes continued to form the most important kind of ecclesiastical endowment. 
 Under the legislation of the nineteenth century tithes were commuted into tithe rentcharge, an annual sum varying with the price of corn. 
 In 1936 tithe rentcharge was abolished. 
 Tithe owners were compensated by the issue to them of redemption stock charged on the Consolidated Fund, and land charged with tithe was charged instead with redemption annuities payable to the Crown. 
 Such redemption annuities were originally intended to be payable till 1996, but they were ended by the Finance Act 1977, and the final payments (of double the normal sum) were made on 1 October 1977. 
 The rights of presentation to livings in the Church of England, known as advowsons, which are often in the hands of laymen, are also regarded as interests in land. 
 But the effect of a Measure of the Church Assembly of 1923 has been to render advowsons virtually inalienable, except in the case of a sale of land to which an advowson is appendant. 
 Chattels real 
 The most important class of chattels real are leasehold estates. 
 A leasehold estate is measured by a fixed period of time; it is often called a term of years, though a tenancy for weeks or months is equally a leasehold. 
 There is no superior limit; a term of 1,000 or 10,000 years (such terms actually occur) is still a leasehold. 
 Nor does a term cease to be a leasehold because it is determinable by an event which may happen, or which is certain to happen, within the term &mdash; e.g. if A holds land for 99 years or for 999 years, &bquo;if he shall so long live&equo;, he is still a leaseholder, though it is nearly or quite certain that he will not outlive the term. 
 A freeholder may grant a lease of any duration, though unless he is a tenant in fee simple, or the lease is made under the powers given by the Settled Land Acts, the lease will fail when the lessor dies. 
 A leaseholder (unless prohibited by his own lease) can himself grant a lease for any term less than that which he holds; a grant for an equal or greater term would be merely a transfer of his own interest. 
 Between the grantor of a leasehold and the tenant (lessor and lessee) there is a relation of tenure, and while the lease subsists the lessor has a reversion. 
 The most important incident of the reversion is the lessor's right to the rent reserved by the lease, generally substantial and often equal to the full annual value of the property. 
 This right he can enforce not only by action, but also by a form of self-help known as distress, the seizure of any goods, whether belonging to the tenant or a stranger, which may be found on the premises. 
 Originally this was merely a method of putting pressure upon the tenant, but the distrainer has had, since the end of the seventeenth century, a power to sell the goods and so pay himself, the surplus (if any) going to the owner. 
 Legislation has largely restricted the right to distrain goods found upon the premises but not belonging to the tenant. 
 The rights and duties of the leasehold tenant are, as a rule, explicitly provided for by the terms of the lease, which will contain covenants such as those relating to payment of rent, repair, cultivation, and building, or forbidding the carrying on of certain trades. 
 Such covenants, so far as they relate to the premises leased, are binding on and enforceable by assignees both of lessor and lessee. 
 The lessor is usually further protected by a proviso allowing him to re-enter and put an end to the lease in the event of the tenant's failure to pay rent or observe the other covenants. 
 A proviso for re-entry in the event of the tenant's assigning or underletting the premises without the lessor's consent was sometimes enforced in the most oppressive way; but, under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1927, a proviso that the consent is not to be unreasonably withheld is implied; and in this case, and in other cases, with one or two exceptions, the courts have power to give relief to the tenant. 
 Moreover, in most cases, the right to re-enter cannot be exercised until the tenant has been given an opportunity of making good the breach of covenant. 
 At the end of the lease the tenant must yield up the premises, together with all buildings, fixtures, trees, and plants thereon, including even what he has himself added; but to some extent this rule is relaxed in favour of trade and agricultural fixtures; and a right to remove tenants&equo; fixtures may be given by the terms of the lease. 
 Under the Agricultural Holdings Act 1948, tenants of agricultural land, and under the Landlord and Tenant Acts 1927 and 1954, other lessees, are entitled to claim compensation from their landlords for many improvements made by them, and also, in some cases, compensation for the disturbance by reason of notices to quit. 
 Recent legislation has had some effect in keeping rents within reasonable bounds, and in providing security of tenure for tenants against landlords; and under the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987 many residential tenants now have a right of first refusal where the landlord proposes to dispose of his interest in the property. 
 A special form of leasehold is the tenancy from year to year, which continues until notice to put an end to it is given by either party. 
 In ordinary cases the notice must be a six months&equo; notice, ending with a completed year, but in the case of agricultural tenancies the Agricultural Holdings Act 1923 requires a full year's notice. 
 Another variant is the shorthold tenancy, created by the Housing Act 1980, whereby the lessor and lessee agree to a fixed-term letting of a period not less than one and not more than five years certain, carrying with it automatic security of tenure for the period agreed. 
 Closely akin to leaseholds, and like them classed as personal interests in land, are tenancies at will and at sufferance. 
 The former is a tenancy made by the agreement of the parties on the terms that either may put an end to it at any moment at the shortest notice; the latter arises where a tenant whose interest has expired continues in possession without the landlord either assenting or dissenting. 
 The Leasehold Reform Act 1967 for the first time introduces leasehold enfranchisement, whereby a lessee is entitled to compel his lessor to sell him the freehold upon payment of compensation on a scale fixed by the Act. 
 By no means all leases come under these provisions. 
 For a tenant to claim the benefits of the Act he must show that his tenancy is of a house, that it was originally granted for more than twenty-one years, that the rent payable is less than two-thirds of its rateable value, and that the rateable value is itself not in excess of certain modest limits. 
 A side effect of the Act, however, has been that many owners of leasehold property no longer regard such investments as sound and they have voluntarily negotiated the sale of freeholds even where the property concerned did not fall within the provisions of the 1967 Act. 
 The Property Acts 
 The three main objects of these Acts are, 
  to get rid of the artificial distinctions which the historical development of the law had drawn between land and movable property &mdash; leaving only those distinctions which are due to the natural qualities of these two forms of property; 
  to assimilate the law relating to chattels real and real property, and, so far as this is possible, the law relating to land and movable property; and 
  to simplify and cheapen dealings in land. 
 The principal changes in the law by which the framers of these Acts have sought to effect these objects can be summarized as follows: 
  One of the leading differences between real and personal property was their devolution on intestacy. 
 The Administration of Estates Act 1925 has, as we shall see, provided a uniform scheme of intestate succession for all kinds of property. 
 Similarly, if a man died without heirs and intestate, the process by which the land devolved to the Crown was different. 
 Real property escheated to the Crown: personal property devolved on the Crown as bona vacantia . 
 Escheat has been abolished, and all property in such a case devolves on the Crown as bona vacantia . 
  The abolition of escheat has meant the abolition of the last of the practical consequences of free tenure. 
 Tenure is now only important as between a lessor for a term of years and his lessee. 
  Great simplifications have been made in the law as to estates and interests in land, with the result that the law of property has been made very much more uniform. 
  The Law of Property Act 1925 reduces the number of legal estates in the land to two &mdash; a fee simple absolute in possession, and a term of years absolute. 
 The estate of the tenant from year to year is included in the term of years absolute; and the interests of a tenant at will and at sufferance are still recognized. 
 The other estates exist, but as equitable, not as legal, interests. 
  Estates tail, which formerly could only be created out of freeholds, can now, as equitable interests, be created out of any kind of property; they are known as &bquo;entailed interests&equo;, and can be barred not only inter vivos  by a deed, but also by a will, provided that the tenant in tail's interest is in possession, and provided that he specifically refers in his will to the entailed property or the instrument creating it. 
  The Statute of Uses has been repealed; and future legal estates in real property cannot now be created. 
 Such estates can now only be created as equitable interests by means of the machinery of a trust. 
 This has always been the only way in which future interests in personal property can be created. 
 The result is that future estates and interests in all kinds of property are now assimilated. 
  Legal tenancy in common gave rise to great difficulties in the tracing of titles to land, because it was necessary to investigate separately the title of each tenant. 
 It is therefore abolished as a legal estate. 
 When formerly two or more persons would have taken as legal tenants in common, they take now as joint tenants on trust for the tenants in common; and no severance of this legal joint tenancy by alienation or otherwise is allowed. 
 Owing to the changes made in the law of intestate succession (see pp. 111&ndash;13), coparcenary can exist only in the case of an entailed interest. 
  For a long period real property was only liable to certain of the debts of its deceased owner: chattels real and personal were always liable to all the debts of a deceased person which survived his death. 
 Even when real property was made liable to all these debts, it was made liable by a different process and in a different order from personal property. 
 The Administration of Estates Act 1925 has provided a uniform method for the administration of all the property of a deceased person. 
 Conveyances of land 
 From a very early period the courts have been opposed to restrictions upon the free alienation of land. 
 In the thirteenth century they got rid of old restrictions which fettered the freedom of alienation in the interest of lords or heirs. 
 The Statute of Quia Emptores  1290 gave free power of alienation inter vivos  to all tenants in fee simple; and the effect of the Statute of Wills 1540 and the Statute of Tenures 1660 was to give a free power of testamentary disposition. 
 We have seen that the rule against perpetuities is designed to regulate or to prevent practices which would restrict the free alienation of land. 
 It follows that the law which regulates the modes in which landowners can exercise this power of alienation &mdash; the law of conveyancing &mdash; has always been an important part of the land law. 
 It has had a long and complicated history; but, at the present day, the form required by law for the creation and transfer of estates and interests in land is both uniform and simple. 
 Generally speaking, one may say that apart from dispositions by will, a deed, i.e. a sealed writing, is necessary, though leases in possession for not more than three years at the best rent obtainable without taking a premium may still be made without a deed or even by word of mouth. 
 But an agreement evidenced by writing and for value, to confer an interest in land, is specifically enforceable in equity, and an attempted disposition for value by unsealed writing will be treated as equivalent to such an agreement. 
 Moreover, even at common law a lease which ought to be made by deed but is not will not completely fail of effect, if possession is taken and rent paid under it; the tenant will be treated as tenant from year to year upon the terms of the lease so far as they are applicable to such a tenancy. 
 The trouble and expense involved in all dealings with land is still very great in the absence of any general provision for preserving any public record of title. 
 Upon a sale of land the purchaser is normally entitled to have produced to him and to investigate the deeds recording previous transactions in the land going back for fifteen years (Law of Property Act 1969: formerly the period was thirty years); and though this period is sometimes reduced by agreement, the shortening of the period throws a risk on the purchaser, who is not only bound by all legal interests in the land which actually exist whether he discovers them or not, but also by all equitable interests which he would have discovered if he had insisted on an investigation for the longer period. 
 Obviously no purchaser can, without expert assistance, make the investigation, of which the result will depend on the effect of numerous technical documents, such as settlements and mortgages. 
 Supposing that the result of the investigation is satisfactory, and the purchase is completed, a subsequent purchaser must again go through the whole process; the results of each investigation are practically thrown away for the future. 
 To do away with the evils of this system, as well as to guard against dangers of fraud and forgery, a Land Registry was established by the Land Transfer Act 1875, which was amended and extended by the Land Transfer Act 1897, both Acts being repealed and replaced by the Land Registration Acts 1925&ndash;1988. 
 The ideal of land registration is that a government office, after investigating the title, enters the applicant upon the register as owner, and furnishes him with a certificate in accordance with the entry; the entry is conclusive as to his right, and no further investigation of the previous title can subsequently be necessary. 
 At ever subsequent dealing with the land a new entry must be inserted on the certificate. 
 One may compare such a public certification of the title with the stamp on a coin, which attests the genuineness of the metal, whereas the system of private investigation of title is as if a man was obliged to employ an expert analyst to test the genuineness of the coins which might be tendered to him. 
 Such a system of registration has been found to work well in other countries, and there can be no doubt that it can, and will, be made universal with us. 
 Though we have not yet attained a full system of compulsory registration, we may be said to be moving, surely and at an increasing pace, in that direction. 
 Registration was made compulsory under the Act of 1897 in the Counties of London and Middlesex &mdash; now Greater London, as provided by the London Government Act 1963. 
 The Land Registration Act 1925 exhibited an intelligible reluctance to hurry extension to other parts of the country until sufficient time had elapsed for testing the general effects of the property legislation of 1925. 
 This period was fixed at ten years, and so it became possible, after the beginning of 1936, to extend compulsory registration to any county in England and Wales. 
 Extension is now going forward on a large scale, delays being due partly to the necessity of thorough surveys, partly to the shortage of skilled staff. 
 The compulsory system now covers virtually all built-up areas, and about 90 percent of the total population of England and Wales. 
 Since 1988 the register of title has been open to inspection by the general public. 
 parallel with this registration, under the Commons Registration Act 1965, the registration of common land and rights of common has now been completed. 
 Settlements 
 The way in which wealthy Englishmen have dealt with their capital has changed greatly in the last hundred years or so. 
 At the beginning of the Victorian era, family property usually meant land. 
 The concern of the wealthy landowner was to continue as long as possible the wealth and social status of the family. 
 The law relating to family settlements was therefore concerned with the ways in which limited interests could be created in favour of various members of the family, stretching out as far as possible into the future. 
 What had to be watched therefore was the perpetuity rule. 
 There was no thought in those days of the Commissioners of Inland Revenue or of inheritance tax. 
 With the increase of industry and commerce in the nineteenth century, and especially with the development of joint stock companies with limited liability, investment in money rather than in land became the most convenient and popular form. 
 Essentially such investments were of two types: either in fixed-interest securities, mainly Government stocks, or in stocks and shares of public companies on the Stock Exchange. 
 Government stocks were safer. 
 Interest payments were assured. 
 And, above all to the Victorians, the capital was secure. 
 The pound sterling maintained a steady value during the Victorian era, and in the then current atmosphere of British security and superiority the possibility of any erosion of the value of the pound was unthinkable. 
 On the other hand, investment in shares of public companies quoted on the Stock Exchange (&bquo;equities') introduced the risk of dependence upon the fortunes of the company selected. 
 There were bad times as well as good. 
 Investment in equities involved risk. 
 Such investments were not therefore available to trustees, without specific authorization. 
 But large fortunes were made this way. 
 The capitalist system needed investment of private capital to make it grow. 
 It is only since 1945 that the inevitable inflation of the currency has led investors to think that &bquo;equities&equo; are safer than gilts; for they maintain a value even if the value of the currency deteriorates. 
 And it is only in the slump of 1929&ndash;33, and more recently in 1973&ndash;5, 1987, and 1989, that catastrophic falls in Stock Exchange values have shown the true vulnerability of equities. 
 At the time of writing the investor may often be uncertain where to turn. 
 In the last twenty years there have been times when he would have done better to return to investment in land. 
 The development of the money economy and the decrease in the status attached to ownership of land led to change in the form of family settlements. 
 No longer is the settlor trying to retain the family mansion and parkland in the family for ever. 
 He is trying to establish and retain a block of capital available for the members of his family for as long as he can do so. 
 And now the main enemy is not the perpetuity rule, but fiscal legislation. 
 It is no good to tie up the property by a series of limited interests for as long as the law will allow, if the bulk of the capital will have disappeared to the Revenue authorities in the meantime. 
 The main problem of the present-day settlor is so to draft the limitations of the settlement as to attract the least amount of income tax and inheritance tax. 
 To achieve this end, a wide and detailed knowledge of fiscal legislation and tax-planning technique is required. 
 Only the most general comments will be made here. 
 In order to understand the changes which have taken place in the practice relating to family settlements since the Victorian days, a brief description will follow, first of the standard form of eighteenth-century settlement of land, and then an outline of a modern tax-saving settlement. 
  Settlements of land . 
 We have seen that landowners have from early times sought methods of retaining their land in the family. 
 It must be protected against spendthrift or incompetent successors, against creditors and moneylenders, against improvident sales, and, until the Forfeiture Act 1870, against forfeiture for treason. 
 These objectives could be achieved by ensuring that no member of the family is ever capable of alienating the fee simple. 
 A series of limited interests makes the alienation of the land very difficult, and, if skilfully done, impossible. 
 The most sophisticated method of tying up land in strict settlement developed in the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries. 
 Possession of the land was to follow the normal order of succession to land, as would a hereditary title if one existed in the family. 
 Provision needed to be made for dowager widows, and for younger sons and for daughters, and perhaps for other persons. 
 All this could be done by giving a life estate to the head of the family; with the remainder to his sons successively in tail-male, with remainder to the daughters in tail, subject to a rentcharge in favour of the life tenant's widow upon his death, and in favour of any other persons desired to be benefited; and with power to the trustees to create long leases in the property for the purpose of charging the lease in order to provide portions for younger sons and daughters who did not inherit the land. 
 Thus the property was tied up for a generation. 
 Upon the death of the life tenant, his eldest son, the remainderman, would then be tenant in tail in possession. 
 He would be able, provided that he was of age, to bar the entail and dispose of the fee simple. 
 In order to avoid this situation, the practice was to effect a resettlement each generation. 
 This was done upon the eldest son attaining the age of 21 years. 
 He then became able to bar the entail, but, being tenant in tail remainder only, he could only effect a total bar by disentailing with the consent of his father, the tenant in possession. 
 By an arrangement between father and son, a disentailment could be effected; but not so as to alienate the fee; rather to reduce the son's interest to a life estate in remainder, with remainder to his issue successively in tail. 
 He could be compensated by an annuity charged upon the land. 
 The limitations are then to the father for life, remainder to the son for life, remainder to the son's issue successively in tail, and subject to terms concerning rentcharges and portions as desired. 
 The land is then tied up for another generation. 
 This procedure, carried out each generation, could tie up the land indefinitely. 
 The system was not obnoxious to the perpetuity rule, because each settlement and resettlement was designed to comply with the rule, and the perpetuity period began afresh from the time of each resettlement. 
 The industrial and commercial expansion of the nineteenth century required land to be available for development. 
 Profits were available for landowners who were willing to develop the land by opening coal-mines, building factories, or developing in other ways. 
 It was not possible to raise the necessary capital, or to sell or grant a long lease to developers, where the only marketable title was the life estate of the head of the family. 
 This would be the situation pending a resettlement. 
 It was in the interest of the public and of the landowners to make land freely alienable. 
 This was effected by the Settled Land Acts 1882 and 1925. 
 The problem, in short, was to find a system where the landowner could continue to create all the beneficial interests he wished in favour of members of the family, and, at the same time, would be able to deal with the land, by sale, long lease, or mortgage, as if he were a sole owner. 
 The dilemma was solved by the principle of over-reaching. 
 The Settled Land Act 1882 provided that the tenant for life should have power to sell, grant leases, or mortgage the land, giving to the purchaser, lessee, or mortgagee a title free from the beneficial interests under the settlement. 
 Capital money was, however, always to be paid, not to the life tenant, but to trustees, who were to hold the money upon the same trusts as those upon which the land had been held. 
 Thus, on sale, the purchaser got a clear title from the tenant for life, free from the limitations of the settlement. 
 The beneficiaries lost their interests in (say) &pound;100,000 worth of land, but received exactly the same interests in &pound;100,000 of money. 
 The transaction is regarded as a change of investment. 
 The policy was continued, with a number of amendments, in the 1925 legislation. 
 Thus all land, however tied up it may be by complex entails and other interests, has since 1882 been alienable by the tenant for life under his statutory powers. 
 Much the same result could be achieved by creating a trust for sale of the land; that is to say, by conveying the land to trustees upon trust to sell, and to hold the income of the land until sale, and the proceeds of sale, upon trust for beneficiaries in any desired order. 
 Here the over-reaching principle is clear. 
 The beneficial interests are attached to the proceeds of sale. 
 And, further, the equitable doctrine of Conversion operates, treating as done that which ought to be done, to effect a notional conversion in equity of the land into the proceeds of sale. 
 Since 1925 the same interests can be created in personalty as in realty, and all the beneficial interests which can be created under a settlement can similarly be created behind a trust for sale. 
 We have seen that settled land is always alienable by the tenant for life. 
 He sells or retains as he thinks fit. 
 Under a trust for sale the trustees obviously can sell, and they are given by statute a discretionary power to retain. 
 Thus, the two procedures are alternative methods of creating settlements of land. 
 The trust for sale has the enormous advantage of being available also for trusts of personalty, or of mixed land and personalty, and is also more convenient for creating discretionary trusts, which of course have no life tenant. 
 The strict settlement method is rarely used at the present day. 
 But many older titles are still dependent upon an understanding of its conveyancing procedures. 
  Modern Settlements . 
 A modern settlement, which will usually be of personalty or of mixed fund of land and personalty, will be designed so as to attract the lowest possible tax liability. 
 The income of a trust is liable to income tax at the rate applicable to the beneficiary to whom the income is paid. 
 Thus, lower rates will be payable if the income is paid to beneficiaries with low incomes. 
 Capital gains tax is payable by the trustees when investments are sold, or when the trust is terminated in whole or in part, and a beneficiary becomes entitled absolutely against the trustees to some property within the settlement. 
 Inheritance tax is payable on property which passes on a death, other than from a husband to a wife or vice versa. 
 Property passing on a death is defined in the Finance Act 1894, as amended by the Finance Act 1969, and includes: property owned absolutely by the deceased, property given away by the deceased within seven years of death, and property in which the deceased owned a limited interest within seven years of his death. 
 Thus, on the death of a life tenant, the property passes and inheritance tax becomes payable upon the capital value of the fund in which the deceased held his interest. 
 For the purpose of establishing the rate at which inheritance tax is payable, all property (with certain exceptions) passing on the death is aggregated together. 
 It will be obvious that the old-fashioned strict settlement, containing a series of life and other limited interests, is poorly designed for inheritance tax purposes. 
 In order, therefore, to avoid inheritance tax, the settlor should make the settlement seven years before his death, and the settlement should be designed to benefit the beneficiaries without giving limited interests to them. 
 These requirements were substantially met before 1969 by the creation of discretionary trusts, by which property is given to trustees upon trust to apply the income on capital in favour of such one or more members of a group of beneficiaries as the trustees shall in their absolute discretion determine. 
 None of the beneficiaries has any interest in the property &mdash; except in respect of income on capital actually paid to him. 
 Until 1969 no property passed upon the death of a member of a class of beneficiaries under a discretionary trust, and no estate duty (the precursor of inheritance tax) was therefore payable for the duration of the trust. 
 This was too wide a loophole for the tax planners: no wonder inheritance tax is called a voluntary tax. 
 The Finance Act 1969 provided, in effect, that on the death of a beneficiary what in 1974 became capital transfer tax, and by the Finance Act 1986 inheritance tax, should be payable upon the proportion of the capital which corresponded to the proportion of the income which the deceased had received within a certain period before his death (usually seven years). 
 payments of capital do not attract inheritance tax liability, except in so far as income earned by the fund has not been paid out. 
 To the extent that income has been retained, payments out are treated as income. 
 Thus discretionary trusts have lost many of their fiscal advantages. 
 Their flexibility, however, enables the trustees to make payments in a manner most suited to all the circumstances, including especially the needs of individual beneficiaries and the fiscal situation. 
 It is not possible here to say more about the different types of trust which are commonly created at the present time, nor of the powers and duties of the trustees, nor of the methods of administration. 
 Specialist books on these topics need to be consulted. 
 A wide variety of choice of settlement is available. 
 The individual settlor must express his wishes to his legal advisors, and they will recommend the most appropriate type of trust to meet the particular situation. 
 The main point to understand here is that different types of trust are designed to meet different situations. 
 The past century has seen the standard form of family trust change from the old strict settlement based on successive limited interests and designed to keep specific land in the family, to the discretionary trust of personalty designed to give no interest to anybody for inheritance tax purposes. 
 No one can say what the next century will bring. 
 Most recently the Law Commission in 1989 recommended replacement of the dual system of trusts for sale and Settled Land Act settlements by a new trust machinery applicable to all trusts of land. 
 Trustees would hold the legal estate on trust with a power (though not a duty) to sell and a power to retain. 
 As at present, they would be able to overreach equitable interests; and the Law Commission considers that the simplicity of such a new system would outweigh any possible disadvantages. 
 It remains to be seen whether this suggestion will become law, but the only really confident prediction must be that so long as capitalism remains, trusts will continue to change and develop so as to meet changes in social conditions and the tax structure. 
 Mortgages of land 
 We have seen that, under the ordinary form of a mortgage of freehold land used before the property Acts, the legal estate was conveyed to the mortgagee, so that at law he became the owner of the property; but that the mortgagor was treated by equity as the owner &mdash; he had an equity of redemption, which was an equitable estate in the land; and he could only be deprived of his equity of redemption in certain defined ways, e.g. by foreclosure or sale. 
 To permit this method of mortgaging land to continue would have been quite contrary to the policy of the Property Acts, which is that the owner of property shall be able to convey to a purchaser a good legal title free from all equities affecting that property. 
 The real owner, the mortgagor, could not convey any legal title because he had none; and the legal owner, the mortgagee, could only convey a title subject to the mortgagor's equity of redemption. 
 For this reason the Property Acts have revolutionized the modes of creating mortgages and some of their legal effects. 
 A legal mortgage can now be effected in one of two ways: 
  The mortgagor demises the land to the mortgagee for a term of years absolute, subject to a proviso that the term shall cease when the mortgagor repays the loan. 
 If the mortgagor is a lessee for years he effects the mortgage by a sub-lease. 
 A second legal mortgage can be created by leasing the land to the second mortgagee for a term longer by at least one day than the term limited to the first mortgagee. 
  The mortgagor creates by deed a legal charge upon the land. 
 Both these methods of creating a mortgage give the mortgagee a legal interest in the land. 
 Other methods can be used if it is desired to give him only an equitable interest in the land. 
 Thus if A borrows money from B, and deposits with B the title-deeds of his land as security for the loan, B has an equitable mortgage on A's land. 
 In the case of such deposits the rule that writing is required for the creation of interests in land is dispensed with. 
 Whether a mortgage is legal or equitable, the mortgagee can enforce his security by applying to the court for an order for foreclosure. 
 Upon proof of the mortgage the court will make an order for foreclosure nisi , under which an officer of the court is directed to find what is due for principal, interest, and costs, and the mortgagor is ordered to pay within six months from the time when the amount is certified. 
 If he fails to do so, the mortgagee will be entitled to an order of foreclosure absolute, the effect of which will be to vest the mortgaged property in him absolutely, but at the same time to prevent him &mdash; even if the property should prove insufficient &mdash; from claiming payment from the mortgagor, except upon terms of giving him a fresh right to redeem. 
 As an alternative to foreclosure, the court may direct a sale of the property, and this may be fairer to both parties, since any surplus upon such sale will belong to the mortgagor, while the mortgagee may still sue for any deficiency. 
 In order to redeem, the mortgagor must give six months&equo; notice or pay six months&equo; interest. 
 He may apply to the court if his right to redeem is disputed. 
 Without any application to the court, the mortgagee, if his mortgage is a conveyance of the legal estate or ownership, may take possession; but this course is hazardous, since he may be called upon in a redemption action to account strictly not only for profits actually received by him, but also for those which he might but for his default have received, and all such profits, so far as they exceed the interest due for the time being, must be set off against the principal. 
 A mortgage may contain a clause giving the mortgagee a power of sale, and such a power (subject to certain conditions) is now implied in ever mortgage made by deed. 
 If the power is exercised, the proceeds are applicable in the same way as the proceeds of a sale ordered by the court, and the mortgagor will remain liable to pay any deficiency. 
 A power for the mortgagee to appoint a receiver who will collect the rents and profits is also now implied in mortgages by deed. 
 To appoint a receiver is more convenient for the mortgagee than taking possession. 
 Since the receiver is the mortgagor's agent, the mortgagee is not responsible for the receiver's acts and defaults; and any surplus beyond the outgoings (including the receiver's remuneration) and the interest due, must be paid over to the mortgagor, and will not go in reduction of the principal. 
 Mortgagor and mortgagee have each, while in possession, considerable powers of leasing land mortgaged by deed, unless, in the case of the mortgagor, the deed excludes them. 
 The changes made in the form of a mortgage have led to great changes in the law as to the priority of successive mortgages on the same land. 
 In outline the modern rules are as follows: Mortgagees, whether legal or equitable, of a legal estate, rank according to the date at which they have registered their charges under the Land Charges Act 1972. 
 But this rule is not so simple as at first sight it looks, for it means, not that priority is gained by registration, but that it is lost through failure to register. 
 If any mortgage, other than a mortgage accompanied by transfer of the title-deeds, is unregistered, it is void as against a subsequent mortgagee, whether he registers his mortgage or not. 
 A mortgagee who takes the title-deeds cannot register, and his position as against that of a mortgagee whose mortgage is registrable and registered is at present, for lack of judicial decision, merely conjectural. 
 The better opinion is that the pre-1926 priorities of the legal over the equitable estate, and of the earlier in time over the later, still apply, except in so far as they are abrogated by the provisions of the 1925 legislation. 
 In certain cases, a prior mortgagee may make further advances to the mortgagor which will rank in priority to subsequent mortgages. 
  If he had no notice of a subsequent mortgage when he made his further advances &mdash; but registration of a subsequent mortgage is equivalent to notice. 
  If the prior mortgage was made expressly to secure a current account or other further advances, and further advances are made by the prior mortgagee, he can hold the land as security for both the original loan and the further advances, unless he had notice of a subsequent mortgage &mdash; registration (except in certain special cases) is not equivalent to notice. 
  If the mortgage deed imposes an obligation on the mortgagee to make further advances he gets priority for these advances even though he had notice of a subsequent mortgage. 
 If the mortgage is a mortgage of the equitable estate, the priority of successive mortgagees depends upon the order in which they give written notice to the trustees or other persons holding the legal estate. 
 This rule, which was formerly applicable only to equitable interests in choses in action and personal trust funds, now applies to equitable interests in all kinds of property. 
 Goods 
 The transfer of goods is most commonly made by merely handing them over, and such a transfer is equally effectual whether the transfer is for value or by way of gift. 
 An unconditional contract of sale of goods which are specific and ready for deliver is sufficient to transfer the ownership without any delivery. 
 When goods are on board ship, the indorsement and delivery of the bill of lading (which is an acknowledgement of receipt of the goods given by the master of the ship) transfers the ownership. 
 Further, goods may be transferred without delivery by deed, and where the transaction is for value even by writing without seal. 
 Such deeds or instruments as a rule require for their validity to be registered under the Bills of Sale Acts (1878 and 1882), which have been passed to prevent persons from obtaining credit by continuing to remain in possession of goods when they have secretly transferred their interest in them to others. 
 In recent years the courts have frequently granted an injunction to restrain a defendant to a civil action from disposing of any of his assets, or removing them from the jurisdiction of the court. 
 A bill of sale is commonly used as a means of mortgaging goods (see p. 105), but it may also be used as an out-and-out conveyance. 
 The property in British ships can only be transferred by means of a bill of sale which is registered in the shipping register. 
 There are a few exceptions to the general rule that no one can make a transfer of goods who is not the owner. 
 A person who receives current coins for value and in good faith, and a purchaser of goods in open market (&bquo;market overt') in good faith, acquires a good right even from a thief. 
 So, too, the Factors Act 1889 protects persons who receive goods in good Kith and for value from a mercantile agent to whom goods have been entrusted by the owner for the purpose of being sold or pledged. 
 Intangible personal property 
 A patent is the exclusive right granted by the Crown of &bquo;using, exercising, and vending&equo; an invention. 
 Such grants are based on the Statute of Monopolies 1623, which, while in general prohibiting the grant of monopolies, made an exception in favour of patents &bquo;for the term of fourteen years or under for the sole working or making of any manner of new manufactures within the realm to the true and first inventor or inventors of such manufactures, which others at the time of making such letters patent and grants shall not use&equo;. 
 The validity of a patent still turns mainly upon the question whether it complies with this enactment. 
 The term of the grant is sixteen years, but where it appears that a patentee has been insufficiently remunerated, the Court may extend the term for a period not exceeding five, or, in an exceptional case, ten years. 
 As a condition of obtaining the patent, the applicant must furnish a specification (which in all ordinary cases is open to public inspection), showing the nature of his invention and the method of carrying it into effect. 
 A register of patents is kept at the patent Office, and assignments and licences to use patents must be entered upon it. 
 In some cases a patentee can be compelled to grant a licence to use his patent on reasonable terms. 
 Copyright, which under the Copyright Act 1956 extends to every original literary, dramatic, musical, and artistic work, including photographs, sculpture, and architecture, means the sole right of producing or reproducing the work in any material form, and of performing, or in the case of a lecture, delivering, it in public; it includes the sole right of translation and of converting a dramatic into a non-dramatic work, and vice versa, and of making gramophone records, movie films, and similar devices for the mechanical performance of the work. 
 As a rule the right is first vested in the author, and continues for fifty years after his death; but in the case of photographs and gramophone records the original owner of the negative or plate is treated as the author, and the right lasts for fifty years from the time when the negative or plate was made. 
 The right is personal property, and passes upon the death of the owner to the persons named in his will or entitled upon his intestacy. 
 It is assignable in writing by the owner during his lifetime; but in spite of any assignment or agreement made by the author, it will revert to his representatives twenty-five years after his death. 
 The right to registered trade marks grew out of the rules of common law and equity, under which a trader who passed off his goods upon the public as those of another was held liable to damages and an injunction at the suit of the latter. 
 These rules still exist (see pp. 146&ndash;8), but they have been supplemented by statutory provisions which enable a trader to acquire by registration at the Patent Office the exclusive right to use a distinctive trade mark in connection with his goods. 
 Words (other than invented words, e. g. &bquo;tabloid') which directly refer to the character or quality of the goods, and names of places, cannot be so appropriated. 
 The right to a trade mark can be assigned only in connection with the goodwill of the business concerned in the goods for which it has been registered, and comes to an end with that goodwill. 
 The transfer of interests in the National Debt and public funds and in the debts of municipal and other public authorities, and of debentures, stocks, and shares in companies, is governed by numerous statutes. 
 Such interests cannot be transferred without writing, and in most cases a deed is required; in any case the transfer is not complete except by entry in the books of the Bank of England or of the body or company concerned. 
 Something has already been said as to the assignment of ordinary debts and &bquo;choses in action'; and the law relating to negotiable instruments &mdash; bills of exchange, cheques, and promissory notes &mdash; will be dealt with in the next chapter. 
 Trusts 
 The reader who has followed what was said in the second chapter will already have appreciated the nature of the trust, one of the most characteristic institutions of English Law, and its enormous importance as a part of our law of property. 
 The importance of trusts has been greatly increased by the property Acts, because, as we have seen, it is only by means of the trusts that future interests in land can now be created (see p. 87). 
 Except that trusts of land must be created by writing, a trust may be created by any sufficient expression of intention to create it, whether the legal ownership is transferred to another to hold as trustee or remains with the creator of the trust, who in that case will himself be the trustee. 
 (It may be noted that equitable rights may themselves form the subject of a trust. 
 A, who has an interest in property held by B upon trust for him, may hold that interest upon trust for D, or transfer it to C upon trust for D.) If, however, an attempt is made to create a trust by transfer to a trustee, but the transfer itself fails from a defect in form &mdash; where land, for instance, is transferred by unsealed writing, or the transfer of shares in a company has not obtained some necessary consent of the Treasury &mdash; the trust also will fall, unless the transaction is one made for value, a term which includes settlements or agreements for settlement in consideration of a contemplated marriage, but not of one already celebrated. 
 So too an attempt to make a direct gift, which fails because the proper method of transfer is not employed, will not take effect as a trust. 
 On the other hand, a trust will not fail because the intended trustee refuses to undertake it, or, in the case of a trust created by will, dies before the testator. 
 A disposition, as distinct from creation, of a trust, whatever its subject-matter, must be in writing, and the term &bquo;disposition&equo; includes a mandate by the beneficiary to his trustee to hold it on behalf of someone else. 
 Trusts arise not only by a direct expression of intention but also by an inference or implication which may or may not correspond to any actual intention. 
 Thus an agreement for the sale of land makes the vendor a trustee, subject to the payment of the purchase money, for the purchaser. 
 Upon a bequest to a trustee upon trust for a beneficiary who predeceases the testator, the trustee will hold the property for the benefit of the testator's representatives. 
 A gratuitous transfer of property into the joint names of himself and another will be presumed to be made upon trust for the person transferring, unless there is something to show that a benefit to the transferee was intended; such intention will be presumed where the transfer is made by a father to his child. 
 Again, a person who acquires property for his own benefit by taking advantage of his position as trustee will be treated as holding it for the benefit of those entitled under the trust. 
 When all the possible beneficiaries are of full age and under no disability (such as that of an infant or lunatic), they may put an end to the trust by requiring the trustee to transfer the property to them or to dispose of it according to their directions; and this is so in spite of any direction to the contrary in the settlement, such as a direction that payment is not to be made to a beneficiary till he reaches the age of 25. 
 The duties of a trustee may be indefinitely varied by the terms of the instrument which creates the trust, and may range from a mere duty to make a legal conveyance to the beneficiary at his request, and in the meantime to permit him to possess and enjoy the property, to extensive and onerous duties of management, sale, investment, and application of capital and income. 
 Apart from certain exceptional cases, a trustee is entitled to no remuneration for his trouble, unless the terms of the trust so direct, and is liable not only for dishonest dealing with the trust property, but for all loss due either to non-observance of the directions in the settlement and the general rules of law, or to failure on his part to act up to the high standard of care which equity and statute law require of him. 
 The range of permissible investments, for instance, is defined by statute in so far as the settlement makes no provision; but, even within the limits of investment allowed by statute or settlement, a trustee may incur liability by want of due care in exercising his discretion. 
 Any failure of duty in a trustee, however innocent morally, is a breach of trust. 
 In practice, however, and especially in the matter of investments, the older picture of an inexorable equity exercising unrelenting vigilance over the trustee's conduct is passing. 
 It would be impossible to persuade anyone to act as trustee unless the discretion entrusted to him were very liberally conferred, and it is now possible for a trustee to delegate to an agent, not merely pieces of business requiring especial skill, but the whole business of the trust, and escape liability so long as he acts in good faith. 
 In cases of doubt, a trustee may protect himself by obtaining, at the cost of the trust property, the direction of the court, and the Trustee Act 1925, s. 61, had enabled the court to relieve a trustee, who has acted honestly and reasonably and ought fairly to be excused, from liability for breach of trust. 
 The Variation of Trusts Act 1958 gives the court wide powers to vary trusts and sanction dealings with trust property in the interests of beneficiaries. 
 Upon the death or retirement of a trustee, the surviving trustees have, in the absence of any provision in the settlement, the power of appointing another in his place. 
 The court also has a power to appoint new trustees and to remove a trustee for unfitness or misconduct. 
 The rights of the beneficiaries under a trust, as has already been seen, are interests in property closely analogous to legal interests, and but little inferior to them in security. 
 Not only do they hold good against the trustee himself, and against his creditors during his life-time and his representatives after his death, but also against all to whom he may have transferred the property, and who cannot show that they acquired it for value and without notice of the trust. 
 Even where a trustee has misappropriated trust property the fund may still preserve its identity, and, so long as it can be identified, the rights of the beneficiaries will attach to the fund into whatever form it may have been converted by him. 
 If he has used it to swell his bank balance, it will be presumed that, in drawing on that balance, he has drawn out his own money before touching trust money; if he has made an investment with trust money &mdash; even an investment which is itself a breach of trust &mdash; that investment is still trust property, to which the trustees&equo; creditors have no claim. 
 We have seen that the difficulty of obtaining the gratuitous services of suitable persons to act as trustees has necessarily led to the practice of reposing an ever wider range of discretion in those who can only thus be persuaded to act. 
 The present danger is perhaps not so much that an honest trustee may be unfairly penalized as that a dishonest trustee may with impunity inflict loss on the beneficiaries. 
 The provision sometimes inserted in a settlement for giving remuneration to a professional man who is one of the trustees is open to considerable objection since it may give him an interest in incurring expense, and will, in any case, tend to make the other trustees leave the management mainly in his hands. 
 An Act of 1906 instituted the office of public Trustee. 
 This officer may be appointed trustee under any will or settlement, either as a mere &bquo;custodian&equo; trustee, in whom the ownership of the trust property is vested, leaving the active duties to other trustees; or as an ordinary trustee, with powers and duties of management. 
 Fees in proportion to the value are payable in respect of all property in the hands of the public Trustee; but his remuneration, like that of other Government servants, is a fixed salary. 
 The Consolidated Fund of the United Kingdom is liable to the beneficiaries for the acts and defaults of the Public Trustee and his subordinates. 
 In recent years, however, the Public Trustee has only had a small and declining proportion of the total work of trusteeship and executorship (see p. 114), and in 1972 a Committee of Enquiry recommended that no new work should be taken on, and that the office be wound up and merged with that of the Official Solicitor. 
 But this recommendation, accepted by the Government at the time, was later rejected by the Government in 1974. 
 The Public Trustee's office therefore continues to discharge the work it retains, though the volume of this work is still declining, and the administration of the office was in 1988 combined with that of the Official Solicitor. 
 Mortgages and pledges of personalty 
 Mortgages  can be made of chattels personal as well as of land. 
 A mortgage of debts and of equitable interests in personalty can be made in the form of a conveyance by the mortgagor to the mortgagee with a proviso for redemption. 
 The priority of successive mortgagees depends on the date when the mortgagee gives notice to the debtor or trustee. 
 Mortgages of shares are usually made by depositing the share certificate with the lender. 
 This, like a deposit of title-deeds in the case of land (see p. 97), creates an equitable mortgage. 
 Priority, as between successive mortgagees of shares, is determined by the date at which the mortgages were effected, as a company is under no obligation to accept notices by mortgagees. 
 A mortgage of tangible property is made by a deed, which is called a Bill of Sale; and, under the Bills of Sale Act 1882 (as modified by the Consumer Credit Act 1974), it must be in the form given in the schedule to the latter Act, and attested and registered as required by that Act. 
 It cannot be given in consideration of any sum under &pound;30. 
 The priority of successive mortgagees depends upon the order in which successive Bills of Sale are registered. 
 The Bills of Sale Acts do not apply to documents accompanying transactions in which the possession of the chattels passes. 
 Therefore they do not apply to pledges. 
 A pledge  is a security upon goods created by the actual transfer of the possession of the goods themselves, or of such documents of title to goods as bills of lading, but without the conveyance of any legal ownership. 
 A pledge carries with it a power of sale, but there is nothing corresponding to foreclosure. 
 The business of pawnbrokers, which consists in lending money upon pledges of goods, is the subject of special statutory regulation. 
 Liens 
 The term lien  is used in different senses. 
 A common law or possessory lien is the right to retain goods, money, or documents which are in one's possession until payment of some claim due from the owner. 
 It commonly arises in respect of services rendered in relation to the property, as in the case of the carriage of goods; but in some cases, like those of a solicitor and banker, the lien may be asserted in respect of the general balance due from the customer. 
 An innkeeper has a lien for his charges upon the traveller's goods brought to the inn, and, contrary to the usual rule, has by statute been given a power of sale over such goods. 
 Liens of this kind, being mere rights of retention, are lost as soon as possession is given up. 
 The equitable lien of the vendor of land, who has conveyed the property without receiving payment of the purchase money, is quite independent of possession, and gives a right to have the property sold under an order of the court. 
 Maritime liens upon ships and cargoes are also in the nature of mortgages or charges independent of possession. 
 They arise in respect of damage done by collision, and upon advances of money or the rendering of services, such as salvage, in times of emergency. 
 Inasmuch as the later advance or service is beneficial to the holder of an earlier lien, it will, as a rule, rank in priority to it. 
 Execution and bankruptcy 
 When judgement has been obtained against a man in respect of any debt or liability, it will be enforced, if need be, by execution, i.e. the court will make an order, under which a sufficient part of the debtor's property is seized and sold or otherwise made available for payment. 
 At one time execution might be made against the debtor's person, and he could be kept in prison indefinitely in default of payment. 
 Since 1869 imprisonment for debt has been rare, and by the Administration of justice Act 1970 it has been completely abolished, and replaced by the remedy of attachment of earnings, i.e. a procedure whereby a portion of the debtor's earnings may be directed by the court to be paid direct to the creditor. 
 When a person's property is insufficient for payment of his debts, it would obviously be unfair that the creditors who first obtain judgement and execution should be paid in full, leaving nothing to those who may try to enforce their claims later; nor is it desirable that a man should indefinitely remain under a load of debts which (it may be through no fault of his own) he is unable to meet. 
 This is the justification of the law of bankruptcy, originally applicable only to traders, but now, with few exceptions, to all insolvent persons. 
 A corporation cannot be made bankrupt; but a company formed under the Companies Act 1985 or similar earlier Acts can be wound up, and its property distributed, according to rules similar to those applicable to bankruptcy. 
 The debtor or a creditor presents his petition to the Bankruptcy Court of the district in which the debtor resides or carries on business &mdash; in London, the High Court; elsewhere, normally one of the County Courts. 
 An act of bankruptcy must be proved, and under this term are included various acts, which show the debtor's insolvency or his intention to delay or defraud his creditors. 
 If this is proved, the court makes a preliminary order, called a &bquo;receiving order&equo;, which protects the debtor's property and prevents creditors from suing him without the leave of the court. 
 The debtor may then (with the court's approval) make a composition or scheme of arrangement with his creditors; but if this is not done he will be adjudicated bankrupt, and the whole of his property (not including property of which he is himself a trustee, or &mdash; up to the value of &pound;250 &mdash; the tools of his trade and the necessary clothing and bedding of himself and his family) will vest in the &bquo;official receiver&equo; (a public officer) or some other trustee, and become divisible among his creditors who prove their debts. 
 Previously the limit was &pound;20, but it was raised to &pound;250 by the Insolvency Act 1976, now replaced by the consolidating Insolvency Act 1986. 
 Rates and taxes, wages of clerks and servants, and some other claims are, within limits, paid in preference to others, and the rights of secured creditors, such as mortgagees, are not prejudiced by the bankruptcy; but in general the distribution will be made rateably. 
 Voluntary settlements (in particular family settlements made after marriage) are set aside by a bankruptcy if made within two years before; and even if made within ten years before, unless it is shown that at the time the bankrupt was able to meet his liabilities without the settled property. 
 At any time after adjudication a bankrupt may apply to the court for his discharge, which, if granted, will enable him to start again, stripped of his property, but (with certain exceptions) free from any claim which might have been proved against him in the bankruptcy. 
 But the discharge may be refused or postponed if he has been guilty of certain offences or misconduct in connection with the bankruptcy, or if his assets are insufficient for the payment of 50p in the &pound;, unless this is shown not to be due to the debtor's fault. 
 Wills 
 A testator had, before 13 July 1939, an unlimited power of disposition by will over all his proprietary rights which survive him, including, since 1925, an entailed interest in possession. 
 But on and after that date the Inheritance (Family Provision) Act 1938 gives to the dependants of a testator, and the Intestates&equo; Estates Act 1952 gives to those of an intestate, power to apply to the court for a reasonable maintenance out of the estate, if such is not provided by the will, or the law of intestacy, or the combined operation of will and law where the intestacy was only partial. 
 The 1938 Act was repealed and replaced by the Inheritance (provision for Family and Dependants) Act 1975, which increases the range of dependants who may apply for provision on death and gives the court wider powers than previously existed so that it can make whatever type of order may be most appropriate in the circumstances. 
 Dependants are defined in the 1975 Act as a wife or husband; a former spouse who has not remarried; a child of the deceased (including an illegitimate or adopted child); a person who was treated by the deceased as a child of the family in relation to any marriage of the deceased (e.g. a child of the deceased's wife by a former marriage); and any other person who was being wholly or partly maintained by the deceased immediately before his death. 
 To qualify in this last category a dependant need not have been related to the deceased, and thus a mistress would be included. 
 Furthermore there is no qualifying period during which the applicant must have received maintenance from the deceased. 
 &bquo;Maintained&equo; means that the deceased was making a substantial contribution in money or money's worth towards the reasonable needs of the applicant, and he did not receive full valuable consideration for this: thus food and shelter are included in the definition. 
 The court may attach to its grant such conditions as it sees fit. 
 The maintenance ordered may be in the form of a lump sum, by way of periodical payments of income, or by transfer or settlement of specific property, or the variation of a settlement. 
 Such payments to a spouse will normally end if he or she remarries, but the original provisions in the 1938 Act excluding a child from further benefit on attaining the age of majority or on marriage have been repealed by the 1975 Act. 
 The court must take into consideration the nature of the testator's property, the pecuniary position of the dependant, his or her conduct to the testator, and any other relevant circumstance, and the testator's reasons for the dispositions made by him in his will. 
 For the making of a will compliance with the following formalities is now necessary: 
  The will must be in writing. 
  It must be signed by the testator or by some person in his presence and by his express direction. 
  The signature must be made or acknowledged by the testator in the presence of two or more witnesses, both present at the same time. 
  The witnesses must attest and sign the will in the testator's presence, or acknowledge their signatures in his presence. 
 A soldier or airman on active service, or mariner at sea, can make an informal will, even by word of mouth, which will be valid provided that his communication to his audience was not a mere statement, but a request to him to see his intention carried out. 
 The Administration of justice Act 1982 also sets out the form of an international will recognized as formally valid in all countries subscribing to the Convention on International Wills. 
 Any legacy or benefit given by the will to a witness or to a witness's wife or husband was formerly void, though the will as a whole was unaffected. 
 But the Wills Act 1968 provides that if a will is already duly executed with two other qualified witnesses, the attestation of any person who would have been caught by this rule must be disregarded. 
 A testator can revoke his will at any time during his life. 
 But breach of a contract not to revoke it will subject his estate to a claim for damages. 
 Furthermore, if two parties (usually, but not necessarily, husband and wife) make &bquo;mutual wills&equo;, with identical ultimate beneficiaries, the death of one of the parties without alteration of his will may have the effect of binding the survivor to make no alteration, in the sense that a trust will arise, under which the terms of the will must be fulfilled. 
 A will is revoked 
  by the marriage of the testator, unless it appears from the will that at the time it was made the testator was expecting to be married to a particular person, and that he intended that the will (or a particular disposition in the will) should not be revoked by that marriage, and that marriage takes place. 
  By the making of a new will or of a codicil or other writing executed with the same formalities as a will, so far as such later document is inconsistent with the will. 
 A codicil is really a supplementary will, and is generally used for making some alteration in a will without revoking it as a whole. 
  By burning, tearing, or otherwise destroying a will, if this is done by the testator or any person in his presence and by his direction with the intention of revolting it. 
  A complete and intentional obliteration of a will or any part of it, so that what was written can no longer be seen, amounts to a revocation of what is obliterated; but merely striking words through with a pen or altering them has no effect, unless the cancellation or alteration is signed by the testator and attested by two witnesses like a new will. 
 Where, after a testator has made a will, his marriage is dissolved or annulled, the will takes effect as if any appointment of the former spouse as an executor were omitted, and any devise or bequest to such former spouse lapses. 
 The accidental loss or destruction of a will has no effect upon its validity, and its contents may be proved by the production of copies or drafts, or even by the recollection of persons who have seen it or heard it read. 
 Bequests of real estate are technically known as devises, bequests of personalty as legacies. 
 A legacy may be specific, i.e. given in terms which show that a particular thing and no other is meant (e.g. &bquo;my only gold watch&equo;, &bquo;my Oxford City stock'). 
 A legacy which earmarks, not a particular thing, but a particular fund or collection out of which it is to come (e.g. &bquo;one of my three violins') is called demonstrative. 
 A legacy which earmarks neither thing nor collection (e.g. &bquo;a violin&equo;, &bquo;&pound;500') is called general. 
 A bequest of the surplus is called residuary. 
 A specific bequest will fail, if the testator parts with the thing before death. 
 But a demonstrative legacy, if the fund out of which it is to come ceases to exist before the death, becomes payable as a general legacy. 
 Devises are of two kinds only, specific and residuary. 
 The interests of all persons who take under a will can take effect only after payment of the debts of the deceased. 
 Under the Administration of Estates Act 1925, real and personal estates are equally liable to the payment of these debts. 
 Under the Administration of justice Act 1982, where a will contains a devise or bequest to a child or remoter descendant of the testator, and the intended beneficiary dies before the testator, leaving issue who are living at the time of the testator's death, then, unless a contrary intention appears in the will, the devise or bequest passes to the issue living at the testator's death. 
 For the purposes of this provision, such issue include illegitimate children and any persons conceived before the testator's death and born living thereafter. 
 When a bequest fails through the death of the person for whom it was intended, and does not pass under a residuary bequest, as must necessarily be the case if the bequest which falls is itself residuary, the property will be dealt with as upon an intestacy. 
 Intestacy 
 Before 1926, when a person died wholly or partly intestate, the distribution of his property differed widely according as it was real or personal estate. 
 The real estate descended to the heir in accordance with rules laid down by statutes of 1833 and 1859. 
 The personal estate was distributed in accordance with rules laid down by the Statutes of Distribution of Charles II's and James II's reigns. 
 The Administration of Estates Act 1925 has repealed the Statutes of Distribution altogether, and has confined the operation of the statutes of 1833 and 1859 to three specific cases. 
 This Act has been further amended by the Family Provision Act 1966. 
 Apart from these cases, the entire property, other than that in which the deceased's interest ceased at his death, is held by the executors or administrators on trust for sale, in the first instance for the payment of his debts, and then for distribution as laid down in the Intestates&equo; Estates Act 1952, which has replaced the relevant provisions of the Act of 1925. 
 Since, however, cases concerning property which has devolved according to those provisions will for many years continue to come before the courts, they are summarized in a note at the end of the book. 
 The present rules are: 
  Rights of surviving spouse . 
 He or she takes &mdash; 
  All the personal chattels (that is chattels such as furniture, motor cars, and articles of household or personal use or ornament, but not chattels used for business purposes). 
  If there is issue, &pound;75,000, free of inheritance tax. 
  If there is no issue, &pound;125,000, free of inheritance tax. 
  If there is issue, a life interest in half the remaining estate, which may, at his or her option, be redeemed for a capital payment. 
 The other half, and the reversion in the first half, are held on the &bquo;statutory trusts&equo; for the issue. 
  If there is no issue, but there are parents, or, failing them, brothers and sisters of the whole blood, then the spouse takes half the remaining estate absolutely, the other half going to parents, or being held on the &bquo;statutory trusts&equo; for brothers and sisters, as the case may be. 
  The claims of the spouse override absolutely those of all relations remoter than those mentioned in . 
  Where part of the estate consisted of a &bquo;matrimonial home&equo;, i.e. a house in which the surviving spouse was resident at the time of the death, the spouse may normally require the representatives to appropriate the deceased's interest in the house in or towards the satisfaction of his or her absolute interest in the estate. 
 The phrase &bquo;statutory trusts&equo; calls for some explanation. 
 The term &bquo;issue&equo; includes not only children, but also the children of children who have predeceased the intestate. 
 The scheme is that these take an &bquo;absolutely vested interest&equo; only on the attainment of 18 years or marriage. 
 Until then, the property is held in trust for them. 
 Should a child die before attaining an absolutely vested interest, his interest passes on to those next entitled, that is to say, other children, a parent, brothers and sisters of the whole blood, a surviving spouse, or remoter relatives if there is no surviving spouse. 
 The personal representatives have the powers to maintain and advance children given to trustees by the Trustee Act 1925. 
 In order to equal the shares of the children, any sum paid by the intestate to a child by way of advancement or on the marriage of the child must be brought into account. 
 An advancement means a sum of money paid to a child to start him in business or to make a permanent provision for him; it does not include casual payments given as a present or to help to tide over temporary difficulties. 
 The interests of the children, if there is no surviving spouse, absolutely override those of any other relatives. 
 Under the Children Act 1975 an adopted child has the same right to succeed on the intestacy of his adoptive parent as any other child born to that parent. 
  Rights of parents . 
 Where there are no issue and no surviving spouse, the parents, if both are alive, take the property in equal shares. 
 If only one is alive, that parent takes all. 
  Rights of brothers and sisters of the whole blood . 
 If spouse, issue, and parents are all lacking, the property is held on the statutory trusts for brothers and sisters of the whole blood, or the children of deceased members of that class. 
  Rights of remoter relatives . 
 It must be emphasized that relatives remoter than parents, or brothers or sisters of the whole blood, and children of such brothers and sisters deceased, can succeed to no part whatever of the estate, if there is a surviving spouse. 
 If there is no spouse, they take in the following order,  brothers and sisters of the half blood;  grandparents in equal shares;  uncles and aunts, who are brothers and sisters of the whole blood of a parent of the intestate;  uncles and aunts who are brothers or sisters of the half blood of a parent of the intestate. 
 Class  take the property absolutely. 
 In the case of Classes , , and  the property is held on the statutory trusts, as in the case of issue. 
 Thus, just as grandchildren can take, so can nephews and nieces and first cousins. 
 But in the case of these classes, the rule relating to the bringing into account of advances does not apply. 
 Executors and administrators 
 Even if a will does not give property to trustees, the property, whether real or personal, does not go directly to those for whose benefit it is given, nor does property passing on intestacy go directly to those entitled under the rules above stated. 
 It vests in the first instance in &bquo;personal representatives&equo;, namely the executor appointed by the will, or where there is no will or no executor appointed under the will, in the administrator &mdash; usually a person interested in the property &mdash; appointed by the court. 
 The public Trustee may be appointed as executor or administrator (but see pp. 104&ndash;5). 
 The executor or administrator, whose duties in many ways resemble those of a trustee, must in the first instance discharge the funeral expenses, the cost (including the payment of inheritance tax) of obtaining probate of the will or &bquo;letters of administration&equo;, and the debts of the deceased. 
 It is only after these claims are discharged that the executor or administrator will transfer the property to those entitled; or, if the property is settled by will and the executor is not himself trustee, to trustees for them. 
 In many cases, as where the persons entitled are not of age, or not yet in existence, or not to be found, an executor or administrator will have to retain the property in his hands for a considerable time, though he may sometimes relieve himself by a payment or transfer into court, and in any case he can obtain the direction of the courts when doubts arise as to the proper course which he should take. 
 SUN, RAIN AND SPEED 
 1976: the year of the drought, of cricket fields that turned brown or white through the absence of water, and of Tony Greig's announcement that his team were going to make the West Indies grovel. 
 It was not one of the shrewdest remarks ever made. 
 A few months earlier, West Indies had encountered any number of problems in Australia and had lost the series 5&ndash;1; they had then beaten India 2&ndash;1 at home, the last match being won when no fewer than five Indians were unable to bat in the second innings. 
 England had lost two series to Australia and looked a fairly ordinary outfit; despite their experience in Australia, West Indies looked to have the better all-round team, and Greig's &bquo;forecast&equo; seemed altogether ill-advised. 
 Presumably he intended it to fire up his own team, but predictably it did just that to the opposition. 
 It was, though, a gesture that was pretty much in character, for he never lacked confidence from the moment he scored 156 in his first county match for Sussex. 
 Almost six feet eight inches (2 metres) tall, he seemed larger than life in most of his actions, blond, handsome, with great charisma that was much better suited to the Test arena than to the county grind; a Test batting average of 40 compared to a career average of 31 shows this perfectly. 
 In his maiden Test in 1972, he top-scored in both innings and took five wickets, an all-round performance he was able to sustain for the whole of his Test career of 58 consecutive matches, scoring almost 3,600 runs with eight centuries and taking 141 wickets at 32 with fast-medium (or, as in 1973&ndash;4 when he had an outstanding series, off-spin) bowling. 
 Strong and brave &mdash; his 110 against Lillee and Thomson on an uneven Brisbane pitch in 1974&ndash;5 was an innings of real courage &mdash; he loved to drive off the front foot, could hit the ball vast distances and was very much a crowd-pleaser. 
 There were one or two controversial incidents, such as the Kallicharran run-out, over the years, but it was generally agreed that these arose from misplaced exuberance rather than any darker motives; and despite his South African origins, there were few complaints when he replaced Denness as captain in 1975.  
 After the battering the team had taken in Australia, he realized that the first job was to restore morale, and he did manage to instil some of his own determination into his players. 
 There was a warmth and a charm about him that made for easy relations with most people, even the press, and they helped him build up the confidence that was needed all round. 
 He was unfortunate to come up against West Indies, playing four fast bowlers for the first time, when he was still an inexperienced leader and the memory of Lillee and Thomson was still raw. 
 Perhaps if he had met them after the confidence gained by a successful tour of India in 1976&ndash;7, when his captaincy was much praised, the story might have been different. 
 In this 1976 series he was still unsure of himself tactically, gave the impression that he had little plan of campaign thought out, and often seemed to be changing his bowling and field settings more on a whim than on a good tactical basis. 
 Yet after the success in India, it appeared that the job was his for the foreseeable future &mdash; only for the news to break at the beginning of the 1977 season that, when in Australia for the Centenary Test, he had used his position to recruit players to Kerry Packer's World Series Cricket. 
 The outrage was enormous, he was stripped of the captaincy and, although he played in the Tests of that year, his career was over. 
 In retrospect, it seemed almost inevitable that someone as colourful as Greig should find a wholly novel way of bringing about his own downfall.   
 Tony Greig. 
 When the stumps only come up to your knees you have to be larger than life. 
 His opposite number, Clive Lloyd, had already been through the two formative experiences of his captaincy. 
 During the heavy defeat in Australia he was criticized for not being able to instil spirit into a losing team, and was fully aware of his shortcomings. 
 But, for one thing, the sheer size of the defeat made him and his players determined that it would never happen again and, for another, the power of Lillee and Thomson made him realize just what a potent weapon a battery of fast bowlers would be. 
 just a couple of months afterwards, playing India in Trinidad with three spin bowlers in his team, he saw them reach 406 for 4 to win the match, only the second time a team had passed 400 runs to win a Test. 
 The spinners Padmore, Jumadeen and Imtiaz Ali did the bulk of the bowling and, as far as Lloyd was concerned, it was they who had let him down. 
 The fact that Holding (who had 6 for 65 in the first innings) and Julien conceded four an over from 34 overs and the spinners only just over two an over from 105 was of less significance than the spinners' inability to bowl batsmen out. 
 His long-held belief that spinners could not be trusted had been vindicated, and from now on Test cricket would take on a new dimension. 
 Whether you think that dimension has been for the good of the game will probably depend on your nationality. 
 Lloyd, a cousin of Lance Gibbs, made his Test debut against India in 1966&ndash;7 and scored 82 and 78 not out. 
 Eighteen years and 110 Tests later he bowed out, with Nemesis unable to resist shaking her fist at him. 
 In his last Test at Sydney in 1984&ndash;5, having wrapped up the series with three victories in the first three games and not having lost for 27 Tests since 1981&ndash;2, his team suddenly collapsed to an innings defeat, the architects of which were Bob Holland and Murray Bennett &mdash; spinners both. 
 Clive Lloyd is one of the best-loved cricketers ever to walk on to a field, but after the relentless domination of his four-man pace attack there must have been many people who permitted themselves a smile at the news. 
 Obviously, the pitch had been prepared for the spinners, but since West Indies had prepared many of their own pitches for their speed merchants they could hardly complain. 
 Even then, Lloyd went down fighting with 72 in his last innings; it took him to a total of 7,515 runs at 46, with nineteen centuries. 
 His batting could be awesome in its power. 
 Six feet five inches (1.9 metres) tall, left-handed, bespectacled, with a loose, ambling walk that always seemed so relaxed, he wielded a three-pound (1.35-kilo) bat with enormous strength and delighted in sending the ball vast distances. 
 So often there was an explosive quality about his batting which was very difficult to contain, and his driving in particular was magnificent. 
 David Lloyd, his captain at Lancashire, tells a story that once in a Gillette Cup  match against Gloucestershire at Old Trafford, Clive Lloyd edged a ball from Mike Procter so hard that it went for six. 
 Procter's anger at this annoyed Lloyd so much that he told his captain he was going to hit him over the pavilion; and he did just that &mdash; next ball. 
 Until his knees failed him and the cartilages were removed, he was also one of the finest of all cover fielders, with electrifying speed and a pin-point throw that seemed barely credible. 
 After the knee operation he moved to the slips, and of course proved pretty useful there, too. 
 He had made his debut for Guyana (then British Guiana) in 1963&ndash;4 as a nineteen year old, and joined Lancashire in 1968. 
 The association with Lancashire lasted until 1986 and was always a happy one, for he was enormously popular with the fans and with his team-mates. 
 His contribution over the years was massive, especially in the one-day competitions, and his loyalty and dedication to his adopted county became legendary. 
 Off the pitch he gave much time to helping young players, while on it his play was never selfish, always for the team rather than his average; and there were times when he batted in great pain rather than let the side  down. 
 He even played his part as a support bowler, whose right-arm leg-breaks or medium pace could be quite economical. 
 The fearsome tale of the gigantic bat, sucking the blood of bowlers and fielders alike. 
 Clive Lloyd in full flow. 
 Lloyd's Test career was not quite the succession of personal triumphs that Sobers had enjoyed. 
 At the end of 1971, playing for a World XI in Australia, he badly injured his back when diving to attempt a catch and spent a month in hospital. 
 At first it seemed that his career might even be over, but he fought back. 
 It took a while to establish himself back in the team as his form was poor and he was not originally selected for the visit of the Australians in 1972&ndash;3. 
 When Sobers dropped out with knee trouble, Lloyd took his place, and on his home ground in the fourth Test made 178; thereafter he would miss one or two games through injury but, apart from the Packer hiatus, his position was secure. 
 It was clear, too, that Kanhai, who had taken over the leadership from Sobers, was coming to the end of his career and that whoever took over from him would have the opportunity for an extended run in the job if he were successful. 
 Lloyd believed that the lean years at the end of Sobers' tenure were the result of an unprofessional approach, with not enough thought given to the problems; under Kanhai this improved somewhat, but after he had failed to beat Denness's team the job was given to Lloyd. 
 Since his experience of captaincy was limited, he had not believed he would be appointed; but he had had his hopes, and had thought a lot about the team's problems. 
 The first priority was to re-establish the team unity that had been allowed to dwindle, with the result that there had been much arguing and bickering The old inter-island rivalries that Worrell had eradicated had surfaced again, and he knew the team would accomplish little until these disappeared. 
 He asked his players for their loyalty to him, in return for which he would do his best to improve their conditions. 
 He asked them to adopt a more professional approach, to harden their attitude and not capitulate when things became tough, as they had sometimes been prone to. 
 He decided that the only way to become the best team in the world was to adopt a killer instinct; to play fairly and sportingly, but to be tough and uncompromising. 
 He wanted to be a winner rather than a good loser. 
 Obviously he was then lucky that a lot of outstanding players began to come into the team at the same period, men like Richards, Greenidge, Roberts, Holding, Croft, Garner, and he had material of the highest class on which to work. 
 But there had been unsuccessful sides in the past that had been packed with outstanding individuals who had not coalesced, or been moulded, into a good team . 
 The credit for West Indies' world domination from the mid-1970s onwards must lie very largely with Lloyd.  
 The emphasis on pace bowling meant that he found himself in a rather curious position. 
 On the one hand, he was loved for his own great ability, his loyalty to his teams, his concern for youngsters and all the other good work he did off the pitch, and for his warm, relaxed character that made him friends in many places. 
 On the other hand, his determination to win became such that he frequently appeared to condone his fast men bowling in an intimidating fashion, which obviously led to criticism from press and public. 
 The prime requirement for opposing batsmen became courage rather than skill, and it was all unnecessary since they were such fine bowlers that they could dismiss teams cheaply when bowling in an orthodox manner. 
 When they gave quite unacceptable displays of dissent, such as Holding kicking down the stumps or Croft deliberately barging into an umpire who had no-balled him, Lloyd did nothing to discipline them in public view. 
 Then again, his fast-bowling policy, more than any other factor, has hastened the decline of the spinner, a decline that has been hugely to the game's detriment; and with a seemingly inexhaustible supply of young speed men reaching the Test team and creating further successes, there is little sign that the decline might be halted. 
 One of the attractions of the game has always been its diversity, and, whatever success they bring, a relentless stream of fast bowlers ultimately becomes boring. 
 By the time of the 1988 tour of England, there were signs that the fans were realizing this, for Test attendances were well down on those of the 1984 tour. 
 Admittedly, the weather was worse, English fortunes were at a low ebb, and the higher charges may well have deterred many people, especially the Caribbean fans; but one suspects that some thousands of people simply could not face the prospect of yet another day almost entirely given over to fast bowling. 
 Lloyd captained West Indies 74 times, winning 36 and losing just 12, and he twice won the Prudential World Cup. 
 He was the most successful Test captain of all time and one of the greatest as well. 
 He accomplished the most difficult of all sporting tasks: not just taking his team to the top but keeping it there. 
 If only he could have been just a little less ruthless about it along the way. 
 Two of the first three games of the 1976 tour were easily won, so that any English optimist who thought that their Australian experiences might have knocked the stuffing out of West Indies had to ponder anew. 
 After the MCC match there was no longer much reason to hope. 
 Greenidge and Lloyd top-scored as West Indies declared at 251 for 9, and then Holding, Roberts and Holder, restricted MCC to 197, only Gilliat, the captain,  having a substantial knock, and Amiss ducking into a bouncer which left him with four stitches in his scalp. 
 Injuries to two MCC bowlers helped Richards and Gomes both make centuries, and Lloyd declared at 248 for 3, setting a target of 303. 
 Then, in Wisden's delightful words, &bquo;it was the turn of the three pace bowlers to wreak havoc and so produce a feeling of contentment in the minds of their colleagues for the Test series ahead&equo;. 
 In other words, they bowled them out for 83, Extras top-scoring with 21; since most of the team either were or would be Test players, that feeling of contentment must have seemed well justified. 
 England sprang a surprise by recalling 45-year-old Brian Close for the first Test at Nottingham. 
 The centre-piece of the match, though, was a wonderful innings of 232 off just 313 balls by Viv Richards, who was in the middle of his annus mirabilis . 
 It was his fifth Test century of the year, and he passed 1,000 runs for the year in his eighth match. 
 With Kallicharran, who made 97, he put on 303 for the third wicket, with some wonderful strokes all round the wicket that culminated in 36 runs off his last 13  balls before holing out on the boundary. 
 The rest of the wickets fell fairly quickly for a total of 494. 
 Brearley, on debut, went for nought, but Steele, first with Edrich and then with Woolmer, made a century and took the score to 226 for three. 
 Then wickets tumbled, and sixteen were still needed to avert the follow-on when the eighth went down; but Old with a bruised wrist, and Snow saw them to safety and the innings made 332. 
 Brian Close recalled to the colours in 1976 at the age of forty-five. 
 Murray and Kallicharran watch him play a ball from Julien. 
 Needing to score quickly, West Indies made 176 at nearly five an over, despite some fine bowling from Snow, when Lloyd declared with five wickets down, setting England the task of surviving for five and a quarter hours or scoring 339 to win. 
 Brearley stayed for a while but, after Steele failed, Edrich and Close, two experienced old soldiers, came together and stayed together. 
 In due course, Lloyd conceded the draw and gave the ball  to his batsmen, and the match petered out with England at 156 for 2. 
 No one was in any doubt who had controlled it. 
 England then had the best of the Lord's Test; true, West Indies lacked Richards, who was ill, but Edrich was absent too. 
 Greig won the toss but England then batted poorly, scraping their way to 197 in the first day, although only 80.4 overs were sent down in six hours, Close's 60 being the best effort. 
 Underwood then had a good day, making 31 and with Old taking the score to 250, then taking 5 for 39 as West Indies were all out for 182. 
 Only Greenidge and Lloyd kept them afloat as Snow and Underwood bowled really well and the fielders backed them up. 
 On Saturday morning the gates were closed early with thousands locked out, only for the whole day to be lost to the weather; had just an hour or two's play been possible there would almost certainly have been a result. 
 As it was, on the fourth day England batted steadily but without much conviction, Steele and Close the top scorers, and were all out on the last morning for 254, leaving West Indies to make 323 runs in a minimum of 294 minutes. 
 Roberts finished with 10 for 123, and then watched his colleagues make little   attempt at first to get the runs. 
 Kallicharran took nearly two and a half hours over 34, while Fredericks was grafting away at the other end. 
 Only when Lloyd came out did the runs begin to flow, but when the final twenty overs began another 154 were still needed. 
 Lloyd claimed the last half hour, but when he was out at 233 for 4 he indicated that as far as he was concerned that was that. 
 Greig, characteristically, decided differently and insisted on playing on; two more wickets fell and the match finally ended at 241 for 6 when, with only three balls left, a win became impossible. 
 The redoubtable David Steele &mdash; courage, determination, skill and runs against Lillee and Thomson in 1975 and the West Indies pacemen in 1976. 
 A brief Test career but a glorious one. 
 Lord's 1976. 
 A balletic leap from Alan Knott to dismiss Clive Lloyd. 
 Before the Old Trafford Test, West Indies had four games and won them all, one of which involved bowling out Yorkshire for 90 when only 110 were wanted to win. 
 for the Test, Richards and Edrich returned and, with various fast bowlers injured, Mike Selvey was called up for England. 
 He celebrated by taking a wicket with his sixth ball and two more by the time he had bowled twenty; when Hendrick got Lloyd, West Indies were 26 for 4. 
 It was up to Greenidge and, apart from being dropped on 26, he did them proud. 
 King's 32 was the only other score in double figures, while Greenidge's 134 out of 211 represented 63.5 per cent of his team's total, a proportion that has only once been exceeded in all Tests. 
 England  they achieved this &mdash; just. 
 37 for 2 overnight became 71 all out after eighty-five minutes next morning, with Holding finishing with 5 for 17. 
 The difference in the bowling attacks then became rather noticeable; by soon after tea on the third day, West Indies had rattled up 411 for 5 when Lloyd declared, with 50 from Fredericks, 135 from Richards, and Greenidge becoming only the second West Indian after Headley to score a century in each innings against England. 
 Roy Fredericks always favoured the square cut. 
 Knott and Old watch Pat Pocock receive the treatment at Lord's in 1976. 
 With a deficit of 552 and thirteen and a quarter hours left, obviously only the weather was going to save England, so there was not the least justification for the barrage of short balls that Holding and Roberts hurled at Edrich and Close. 
 It was intimidatory bowling of the worst sort against two brave batsmen who, as it turned out, were both playing their last Test innings. 
 Umpire Alley eventually warned Holding, but there must have been many Lancastrians who were sad to see Lloyd, on his home ground, do nothing about it. 
 He did admit afterwards that they had been carried away by trying to make a quick breakthrough and had bowled badly, but it still left an unpleasant taste. 
 On the Monday they showed how easy it was for top-class bowlers to pitch the ball up and get wickets. 
 Edrich and Close soon went, and on two occasions Roberts found himself on a hat-trick; the second time, Selvey edged to Greenidge at slip &mdash; and he dropped  morning was fine and only one more run was added. 
 The margin of 425 runs was the largest runs victory West Indies have had over England, and for the only time in Test cricket Extras had a bigger match aggregate (44) than any batsman. 
 It was not felt to be a good idea to mention the word &bquo;grovel&equo; in the presence of the England captain, especially as he had scored only 38 runs in five innings. 
 England press for victory at Lord's in 1976. 
 Murray refuses to be intimidated by the ring of fielders. 
 Headingley saw a cracking match, and anyone lucky enough to be there on the first day is unlikely to have forgotten it. 
 Greenidge and Fredericks immediately laid into the bowlers, bringing up 50 in 8.3 overs, 100 in 18.2 overs, and at lunch after 27 overs they were 147 without loss. 
 Fredericks reached his hundred soon after, and when he was out Greenidge and Richards took 95 off twelve overs. 
 Greenidge went for 115, Rowe joined Richards, and at tea the score was 330 for 2. 
 After tea the batsman continued to play their shots and the runs came, but the ball began to move around and wickets fell, too. 
 By the close, the score was 437 for 9 from just 83 overs, surely one of the best days of cricket since the war. 
 The last wicket fell at 450, whereupon England promptly collapsed to 32 for 3.   
 The infamous barrage of bouncers at Close and Edrich, Old Trafford 1976. 
 Close sways away from another one from Michael Holding which Murray takes above his head. 
 Willey and Balderstone, both on debut, stemmed the tide for a while, and then Greig and Knott came together at 169 for 5 with the follow-on a distinct possibility. 
 They put on 152 before they were separated, first attacking well and then being contained. 
 When Greig went for 116, Snow supported Knott, who spent over an hour in the nineties before reaching the same score as his captain, and when the tail went quickly the total was 387. 
 A shower livened up the pitch and the West Indian openers soon fell. 
 On the Monday morning two more wickets went down and, at 72 for 4, the excitement began to mount. 
 The crucial innings then came from King, who hammered 50 off 39 balls to help the score to 196; England needed 260 to win, with time not a problem. 
 Willis's 5 for 42 clearly inspired Roberts, who in his first four overs sent back Steele, Hayes and Balderstone: Woolmer and Willey took the score to 80 before the former departed, and Willey and Greig then looked as though they might turn the  match England's way. 
 But at 140 Willey went to a superb catch by Roberts, and at the close they were on 146 for 5, needing another 114. 
 Clearly much would depend on whether Knott could stay with Greig but, after nightwatchman Underwood went, Knott and Snow both followed quickly, all dismissed by Daniel inside four overs. 
 Greig's response was to throw the bat, and Ward hung on while 46 were added; but, with the score on 204, he was caught behind off Holding and Willis was lbw first ball, leaving Greig unbeaten on 76 and West Indies winners by 55 runs. 
 Greig was gracious in defeat, saying that their play on the first day deserved every credit. 
 Headingley 1976. 
 Holding beat Greig four times in one over and the two faces tell the story. 
 Greig went on to a century but West Indies won the match. 
 Alan Knott has been second only to Les Ames as an England wicket-keeper/batsman. 
 Roy Fredericks's second century helped him pass 500 runs for the series, although Richards and Greenidge still finished above him in the aggregates and averages. 
 Short, left-handed and aggressive, he was an opener who hit the ball extremely hard, played every shot in the book with great relish and was always looking to attack from the first ball. 
 Not only the Headingley crowd would testify to this; Lillee, Thomson and their friends saw him reach his century from 71 balls against them in 1975&ndash;6, and go on to his highest Test score of 169. 
 He came into the Guyana team as a 20 year   runs straight away, and remained a permanent fixture. 
 In all, he played 59 Tests and scored 4,334 runs at 42 with eight centuries, took a handful of very expensive wickets with his left-arm spinners and was a quite brilliant close leg fielder. 
 He played for Glamorgan in 1971 and 1972 (and briefly the following year before joining the touring party), scoring a thousand runs in both seasons and, with Alan Jones, putting on a county record opening stand of 330 against Northamptonshire in 1972. 
 Perhaps the best way to describe him is as a typical West Indian batsman, fundamentally very reliable and dependable yet always looking to attack if possible, always full of attractive stroke-play. 
 He had the occasional run of poor form, but when the runs came they came thick, fast and gloriously. 
 At Headingley in 1976 Deryck Murray took five catches in the second innings. 
 Alan Knott was one of them off Wayne Daniel's bowling. 
 Collis King joins in the appeal. 
 Headingley 1976 and Gordon Greenidge at second slip practises for the high jump. 
 In the first picture he catches John Snow off Daniel's bowling and in the second he celebrates as Murray catches Alan Ward off Holding. 
 Collis King is at first slip. 
 Four players had especial reason to remember the Oval game: two scored double centuries, one took fourteen wickets and one became the leading Test wicket-keeper. 
 Lloyd won his fourth toss and, after Greenidge had gone for a duck, Richards shared in three century stands. 
 Fredericks made 71, and Rowe had reached 70 when he was stumped by   
 He might have been small but Roy Fredericks hit the ball exceptionally hard. 
 Alan Knott is denied the chance to pounce. 
 Knott, overtaking Godfrey Evans with his 220th dismissal. 
 By the end of the first day, Richards was on 200 and the score was 373 for 3. 
 Nothing much changed next morning as 141 were scored, but early in the afternoon Richards was finally out. 
 291 made off 366 balls, with 38 fours, in just under eight hours does rather speak for itself. 
 It meant that he had scored 1,710 Test runs in eleven matches in 1976 at an average of 90, still the record aggregate for a calendar year. 
 Lloyd soon followed for 84, but then King and Murray continued the torment, and, when the declaration came on the second evening, the score was 687 for 8, still the West Indies record against England. 
 Next day it was a question of who would stay with Amiss, playing his first Test of the summer. 
 Steele did for a century partnership and then Willey did the same; but when Greig was out near the close of play, with the board on 303 for 5, there was a pitch invasion by, for the most part, West Indian fans. 
 This caused a delay of nine minutes, but play was able to restart for the last couple of overs. 
 Most of the wickets had been falling to   
 Dennis Amiss on his way to a double century at the Oval in 1976. 
 Cherish the fact that he is wearing a cap; the days of the anonymous helmet were drawing near. 
 Holding, and when he finally bowled Amiss for a splendid 203 it was clear that the follow-on would not be avoided. 
 Knott and Miller, on debut, had a useful stand, but when the innings closed at 435 the deficit was 252. 
 Daniel, though, was injured and Holding, having taken 8 for 92, clearly deserved a rest, so Lloyd decided to bat again. 
 Fredericks and Greenidge thought this an excellent idea and hammered 182 in two hours twenty minutes without being separated, by which time England were just demoralized. 
 They had six hours twenty minutes to survive, but the first hour of the last day saw five wickets crash for 78. 
 Knott did his best with another fifty but it was all over with eighty minutes to spare; all out 203 and victory by 231 runs. 
 Holding's figures this time were 6 for 57 for match figures of 14 for 149, the first West Indian to take more than twelve wickets in a Test. 
 achieved on a batsman's pitch from which no other bowler got any response at all. 
 He did it in the classic manner, by pitching the ball well up and bowling very, very quickly, and the fact that he needed help from his  colleagues for only two of those wickets shows just how accurate he was. 
 Tall and slim, without the usual broad shoulders of the pace man, he had excelled at athletics as a youngster, with the result that he was a fast bowler like virtually no other; his approach to the wicket was so soft and silky that he hardly seemed to touch the ground at all, and several umpires said that they were not able to hear him running in. 
 Until he cut it down in later years, his run-up was extremely long &mdash; and his saunter back to his mark extremely slow &mdash; but the speed that it generated undoubtedly justified the length, and the grace of it all was an aesthetic delight. 
 As the years passed, he sacrificed a little speed for greater control, especially of away-swing, but that run-up never for a moment lost its beauty. 
 &bquo;Whispering Death&equo;. 
 The superbly smooth delivery of Michael Holding, eye fixed on the spot he is going to hit, head steady as a rock. 
 A wonderful athlete in action. 
 His career was not without its less attractive moments, and it is sad that many fans will remember the famous picture in the 1981 Wisden  of him kicking down the stumps after having an appeal refused in New Zealand almost as readily as they will recall his wonderful bowling; yet even in dissent he was physically graceful, and the picture is positively balletic. 
 The fact that he could get such good results by orthodox bowling also left one wondering why he occasionally indulged in a bouncer war, for it obviously did his reputation no good and was not as a rule very productive. 
 His debut in the disastrous series in Australia was not a happy one, but things improved at home to India and then he really came into his own against England, finishing with 28 wickets at under 13. 
 By the time he called it a day, he had played in 60 Tests and taken 249 wickets at 23, and like all of his fast-bowling colleagues had benefited from being one of a quartet as he could operate in short spells and rest more often. 
 Since he did not have the physical strength of most of the others, this was important for him and must have contributed a lot to his effectiveness. 
 On that basis, then, we have a reason to be glad that Clive Lloyd adapted his strategy of all-out pace, for had he not done so perhaps we would have seen less of one of the most watchable of all bowlers. 
 Holding's 28 wickets were equalled by Andy Roberts. 
 The first Antiguan to play Test cricket, Roberts had made his debut during Denness's tour, the first of the unending stream of top-class fast bowlers which has transformed modern cricket. 
 He played only once in that series but was then brought back for the rubber in India and made a big impact, so that when he had Steele's wicket at Headingley he chalked up his hundredth Test wicket in the record time of two years 144 days. 
 Tall and strong, with very broad shoulders, he would go on to claim 202 victims at 25 from his 47 Tests, of which 50 came in a dozen games against England. 
 From a fairly economical run-up he bowled with great pace, usually very  sometimes, as at Old Trafford, he would overdo the bouncers, and he had his share of injured batsmen to his credit &mdash; or rather debit. 
 More often, though, he preferred to pitch the ball up and get his wickets in less intimidating fashion. 
 He played for Hampshire from 1973 to 1978, had a season with New South Wales, and appeared for Leicestershire between 1981 and 1984. 
 For Hampshire he had a very successful first full season, taking 119 wickets at only 13 in 1974, and having some good days in limited-overs cricket as well. 
 Thereafter the relationship became steadily more strained and he left during the 1978 season. 
 He gained a reputation as the Buster Keaton of the cricket world, a man who rarely seemed to have any expression on his face and who was not one for the excited cavortings that greet the fall of a wicket; yet behind the mask a good deal of thought was given to his bowling, and he was liked and respected by his fellow players. 
 In 1985 he was awarded the CBE. 
 During this 1976 tour, West Indies played twenty-six first-class matches and won eighteen of them, losing only to Middlesex, the champions, and T.N. Pearce's XI (which contained eight Middlesex players) at the   
 Perfect balance in the leap before the delivery stride. 
 Andy Roberts set the Caribbean fast bowling conveyor belt in motion. 
 Scarborough festival when they omitted their leading strike bowlers. 
 Clearly they were helped by having hardly any matches affected by the weather, but it was still a wonderfully sustained performance. 
 Perhaps for many of the fans the best moment of all came at the end of the fifth Test, when Tony Greig went out and &bquo;grovelled&equo; before them. 
 Before the teams met again the Great Schism had occurred, as Kerry Packer inserted his spanner into the gently revolving works. 
 For nine Tests against Australia and India, West Indies were led by Alvin Kallicharran, with some names alongside him which now look very unfamiliar. 
 England had lost fewer players than most countries to World Series Cricket and had won a number of rubbers as a result but, when the armistice was signed, England's limitations were soon exposed. 
 To mark the return to normal, a totally abnormal arrangement was made, whereby West Indies and England were both in Australia at the same time, playing alternate Tests against the home team. 
 Since England lost 3&ndash;0 and West Indies won 2&ndash;0, there was not much doubt who was Top Team, though, having said that, West Indies then lost a very bad-tempered series in New Zealand, going down by one wicket in the only Test to see a result. 
 Shortly afterwards, in May 1980, Clive Lloyd and Co. arrived in England with a squad that included Holding, Roberts, Garner, Marshall and Cruft. 
 There was a spinner in the party, Derek Parry, but needless to say he did not play in any of the Tests. 
 After the series in Australia, Mike Brearley announced that he would not be able to tour in 1980&ndash;1 as he wanted to continue his studies in psychoanalysis, and the England selectors decided to appoint a new captain for the start of the 1980 rubber. 
 They chose Ian Botham, their young hero &mdash; he was then twenty-four &mdash; who had already performed great deeds in the twenty-five Tests he had so far played. 
 The feeling among press and public was that he was too young, too inexperienced, and too much was being asked of him too soon. 
 Yet he had been Brearley's choice to succeed him, for he had perceived that Botham was an intelligent, tactically aware player and believed that he offered &bquo;tremendous hope for a new, vital start&equo;. 
 His initial appointment was for just two Tests, a demonstration of lack of faith that cannot have helped his confidence and seemed to many to be ludicrous. 
 In the event, his twelve Tests proved a singularly unhappy period as he lost four and drew eight; he insisted that the responsibility did not affect him but his form declined &mdash; partly at least through a back injury &mdash; and his performances varied from moderate to dismal.  
 Any present-day fan will be familiar with the Botham story, for it has been told too often to need repeating. 
 No one would suggest that he rivals Sobers as the greatest of all-rounders, for, although he has taken more wickets, his batting has been much less consistent and his Test average is some twenty-three points lower than Sobers'. 
 Compared with the other great all-rounders of his time, Imran Khan, Richard Hadlee and Kapil Dev, he is certainly the best batsman and best slip fielder, but Hadlee and Imran are more dangerous bowlers, and much less likely to have a bad day. 
 Perhaps no player has ever been quite as competitive as Botham, and if his combativeness has led him into trouble off the field it has generally worked in his favour on it &mdash; except when he has refused to part with the ball despite not bowling well, or when he has holed out in the deep when a more circumspect approach was required. 
 As a public figure hero-worshipped by countless youngsters, his drug-taking was a sad business, but few people in any field have ever used their fame better than his long-distance walks which have raised vast sums for charity. 
 One of his regrets is that in four series against West Indies his record is very ordinary &mdash; one innings in which he took eight wickets, but little else of note &mdash; and he is aware that not having proved himself against the best team in the world will be held against him when reputations come to be assessed. 
 His captaincy suffered by having to succeed Brearley, for the Middlesex man's wonderful understanding of the psychological needs of each of his players was something that Botham could never hope to emulate. 
 By nature he is very much &bquo;one of the boys&equo;, which must have made it hard to assert himself, he does not find it easy to take advice and is readily upset by criticism. 
 There were times when his own belief in himself as a great player could backfire on him if he failed to realize that he was having an off day, and he could look stubborn and bloody-minded as a result. 
 Since he was not a natural captain he had to lead by example, and when the mighty deeds failed to materialize he was very much up against it. 
 Nor was he helped by being up against the mighty deeds of the West Indies in his first two series, and perhaps if he had been able to cut his teeth on something less difficult the story might have had a happier turn to it. 
 The story came desperately close to beginning with a victory. 
 On a Trent Bridge wicket that saw the ball moving around off the seam and in conditions that helped the swing bowlers, Botham won the toss and batted. 
 Before long England were benefitting from the first of a string of catches dropped by both sides, and their total of 263 was over a hundred more than it would have been had Boycott, Woolmer and Botham not had a second chance. 
 Botham's 57 was top score, so at least his captaincy got  off to a bright start. 
 In reply, Greenidge and Richards hammered 88 in even time, but then only Murray made a substantial score, his 64 being joint top with Richards and 41 more than it should have been had a catch been accepted; 308 all out. 
 By the beginning of the fourth day, England were well placed at 145 for 2, although both Boycott and Woolmer had once again been missed; but they batted slowly and then four wickets fell quickly. 
 Willey held things together for a while and the total reached 252, helped by no fewer than 52 extras since the ball was moving around so much that Murray had a very hard time behind the stumps. 
 West Indies had over eight hours to make 208, but on that pitch it never looked easy.   
 What he lacked in aesthetic grace Bob Willis made up in speed, determination and sheer guts. 
 Despite appearances, umpire David Constant is not asleep. 
 Greenidge soon went, leaving Richards to lay into the bowling. 
 In 56 minutes he made 48 before Botham got him, and by the close of play just 99 were needed with eight wickets left. 
 Next day Bacchus was caught behind off Hendrick's first ball, and suddenly England began to think they might do it. 
 Willis had one of his inspired days and, after taking four wickets in the first innings, went one better this time, with 5 for 65. 
 Kallicharran, Lloyd (with an injured hand), Murray and Marshall all went, and when the seventh wicket fell 28 were still needed. 
 The crucial moments had occurred earlier, though, when Haynes was twice dropped at slip &mdash; first by Tavar&eacute; on 23 and then by Hendrick on 49, both fairly straightforward chances. 
 Haynes was eventually run out for 62 and left the field in tears thinking he had lost his team the match, but by then only three more were needed and Roberts was striking the ball well. 
 He had been dropped off a hard chance when just twelve were needed, but went on to hit the winning four off Botham, and his eight wickets and two useful knocks earned him the Man of the Match award. 
 England were left to reflect on one of the game's oldest sayings, the one about catches winning matches. 
 It is interesting to think that had they snatched &mdash; or preferably caught cleanly &mdash; that victory, the pattern of English Test cricket might have been changed for years ahead, for, as the other four matches were all drawn, a victorious first series might have given Botham's captaincy the shove it needed to get airborne. 
 At Lord's, England were almost certainly saved by the weather. 
 Their innings, though, was marked by a wonderful display from Gooch, his thirty-sixth attempt finally produced a Test century, and it was very much worth waiting for. 
 His 123 came out of 165 off 162 deliveries in 211 minutes; a few months earlier in Australia he had run himself out on 99 in his desperation to reach the magic figure, but one would never have guessed it from the effortless way he swept there now. 
 Unfortunately, his teammates did not provide much support; Tavar&eacute; managed an incredibly laborious 42 but everyone else failed. 
 269 did not look anything like enough; and when West Indies reached 260 for 1 it looked positively minute. 
 For Richards it was another triumph, with 145 coming off just 159 balls, a display even more spectacular than Gooch's &mdash; although the Englishman had had to contend with rather more hostile bowling. 
 Richards also had the benefit of solid support at the other end as Haynes steadily made his way to 184, the highest West Indian innings at Lord's, and with Lloyd chipping in a fifty the total reached 518. 
 By now it was near the close on the third day; Gooch and Boycott made a confident start, but much of the Monday was lost to rain and the game was then abandoned on the last afternoon with  almost ten hours having been lost. 
 At 133 for 2, England might have fought back for an honourable draw; or they might not. 
 The honourable draw had to wait till Old Trafford, although over eleven hours were lost to the weather. 
 Lloyd won the toss and put England in despite the pitch looking good for runs, and before four o'clock had supervised their dismissal for 150. 
 Brian Rose was brought in for his first home Test and promised he would attack the bowling; he was as good as his word and made 70, but 33 from Gatting was the only other contribution as the last seven wickets went for 24 in fifty-two minutes. 
 England soon struck back, though, and had three wickets down for 25, only for Richards to launch into Willis. 
 65 came from 68 balls, with 53 of them debited to the Warwickshire man. 
 Time was lost on the first two days and then the Saturday was washed out altogether, so it was Monday before Lloyd was able to complete his first Test hundred at his adopted home, in what many thought would be his last opportunity. 
 He held the second half of the innings together, passed 5,000 Test runs, and saw the total to 260.   
 Answers on a postcard to&hellip; 
 Desmond Haynes poses for a &bquo;supply your own caption&equo; picture. 
 Haynes in more familiar pose &mdash; on his way to 184 at Lord's in 1980, at the time the highest West Indian Test innings at headquarters. 
 Faced with a deficit of 110, England actually got their heads down and battled. 
 Boycott led the way with 86 and everyone made a contribution of sorts, but soon after lunch on the final day they were 290 for 6 and defeat was still possible. 
 It was Willey, supported by Emburey, who kept it at bay, the final score being 391 for 7; admittedly, Roberts had hardly been able to bowl on the last day, but the home team had shown themselves that they could bat a bit if they tried. 
 There were times at the Oval when both sides had thoughts of winning; at one point the bookmakers quoted 100 to 1 against a West Indies victory, but a day later they were 5 to 4 when England's Pythonesque second innings was at its nadir. 
 Their first innings was marked by an over rate of 12.3 an hour against which Gooch scored 83, Rose and Boycott made fifties, Gatting almost did, and with the help of 57 extras the total reached 370. 
 Once again, the Saturday's play was washed out, but on Monday morning five wickets were down for 100 and, with Lloyd having badly pulled a hamstring while fielding, the follow-on definitely loomed. 
 It  was Bacchus who saved the day with 61, Marshall and Garner both made forties, and the final total reached 265. 
 The Oval 1980 saw one of the more remarkable Test scorecards &mdash; after being 92 for 9 when Bob Willis joined Peter Willey, the innings was declared on 209 when Willey reached his maiden Test century. 
 He is congratulated by partner and fans alike. 
 England then collapsed in wonderfully spectacular fashion; Rose made 41, but until Willis joined Willey everyone else had failed dismally and nine wickets had gone down for 92. 
 Garner and Croft were by now both injured, but West Indies suddenly found themselves up against some determination. 
 When Willis came out, England were 197 ahead with 151 minutes and twenty overs left and there cannot have been many who doubted West Indies would win, but with Willis lunging his left leg forward and Willey protecting him from the strike as much as possible, they began to put together a remarkable stand. 
 By the end of the second Test, Willey's last nine Test innings had produced 90 runs, and, had he been caught when on 13 at Old Trafford, his Test days would almost certainly have been over; as it was, his 62 not out there and his reputation as a battler persuaded the selectors to press on with him, and he justified their faith now. 
 Their unbeaten stand of 117 was only thirteen away from the England tenth-wicket record when, with Willis on 24, he reached his maiden Test century, Botham declared and the match ended. 
 From 92 for 9 to 209 for 9 represented one of the oddest innings in Test cricket. 
 After a fine spring, the summer of 1980 became a big disappointment and the weather reached something of a soggy climax for the fifth Test at Headingley. 
 After two days of almost non-stop rain, the first day was washed out completely, since the lakes dotted around the ground were not thought to be conducive to good cricket. 
 Hard work by the ground staff enabled play to begin on Friday afternoon, whereupon Richards, leading West Indies for the first time because of Lloyd's injury, gleefully put England in. 
 Before long they were 59 for 6; Botham swung the bat for 37 off as many balls, and Bairstow, replacing the runless Knott, made 40 to take the total to 143. 
 Next day, according to Wisden  in poetic mood, &bquo;thick grey cloud hung sullenly over the ground from start to stumps, creating an atmosphere straight out of Wuthering Heights &equo;. 
 In conditions quite alien to them, the West Indies batsmen performed altogether more creditably than their opponents, Greenidge and Haynes producing their best opening stand of the series, 83, and Richards, Kallicharran and Holding all making useful knocks in a score of 245. 
 When the Monday's play was then completely washed out too, England had to accept that they were not going to square the series and could hope only for another draw. 
 Gooch became the only player to score a fifty in the match and put on 95 for the first wicket with Boycott, but when the fifth wicket fell just before tea they were only 72  ahead and could still have lost. 
 Rose had pulled a thigh muscle while fielding but now, batting with a runner, made an unbeaten 43 to steer England to safety. 
 After having lost over fourteen hours to the weather, the game was called off with the score at 227 for 6 declared, and a series that had promised so much with its exciting start fizzled out meaninglessly, with almost seven of the twenty-five playing days lost. 
 Botham did not even have much luck with the weather during his captaincy. 
 years which had seen him play in 62 Tests and make 189 dismissals, at the time the West Indian record by a street. 
 He was only twenty when he made his debut in England in 1963, promptly setting a West Indian record with 24 dismissals in the series. 
 If he did not touch such heights again, he remained a thoroughly reliable keeper right to the end, small, neat and quiet, and rarely given to histrionics. 
 He interrupted his cricketing career to go to Cambridge, whom he captained, and then Nottingham University to take a degree in business studies, playing for the county from 1966 to   
 Deryck Murray, fresh from the shower, celebrates his seven victims in the Headingley Test of 1976. 
 1969 while he was there. 
 A few years later, between 1972 and 1975, he had a spell with Warwickshire, during which time he returned to the Test team against Australia in 1972&ndash;3 &mdash; he had played only one other series in the meantime, against England in 1967&ndash;8 &mdash; and remained a fixture for the rest of the decade. 
 He was a very handy and determined batsman, good enough to score almost 2,000 Test runs at nearly 23, even opening the batting a few times, and over 13,000 during his career, including 1,000 a season three times. 
 For much of the 1970s he was Lloyd's vice-captain and led the team once, against Australia in the first match after Packer's &bquo;circus&equo; had left town. 
 He was also a prime mover in the bid to get better pay for West Indian cricketers, putting in much work as the first secretary of the West Indian Players' Association. 
 Quiet and reserved he may have been, but his determination to succeed has been of great importance to his colleagues, both on and off the field. 
 Although they had recently lost narrowly to New Zealand, there was no question that West Indies were now the outstanding team in the world, and they were to continue that way throughout the 1980s. 
 To paraphrase the last chapter of Sellar and Yeatman's classic 1066 And All That , West Indies were thus clearly top nation, and History came to a. 
 That chapter, incidentally, is entitled &bquo;A Bad Thing&equo;. 
 A few months later, England were in the Caribbean for a tour that, in the problems they encountered, lacked only a riot to round it off. 
 For a start, the weather was atrocious when they most needed to acclimatize, and in their first seven weeks they had only seventeen days of cricket. 
 Finding decent practice facilities was a constant headache, leading to some crazy situations; in St Vincent, for example, Ken Barrington, the assistant manager, hunted all over for a place for Boycott to practise, and eventually found a piece of flat ground near the airport which had ducks waddling around and a donkey at long leg. 
 There was the cancellation of the second Test after the Guyanese government decided to deport Robin Jackman because of his South African connections; and then came the real tragedy, when Ken Barrington had a heart attack and died during the third Test in Barbados. 
 By the end of that Test they were two down with two to play, and it is difficult to think of any England tour where such a low point had been reached. 
 Yet in the last two Tests they fought back well, with some help from the weather which few could have grudged them, to earn draws, several batsmen contributing excellent fighting innings. 
 Botham retained  the England captaincy but, although he topped the bowling averages, his form with the bat was wretched. 
 In contrast Clive Lloyd, back after his injury, had a splendid series with a lowest score of 58 in five innings. 
 England did actually begin with a victory, Miller and Willey rather unexpectedly bowling out the Young West Indies XI on the last afternoon. 
 Thereafter rain restricted them to one-day games and half of a four-day game, so they went into the first Test in Trinidad very under-prepared. 
 It soon showed, even in their team selection, for they left out Gatting and played three spinners. 
 The start was delayed for three hours partly because the bowlers' run-ups were damp and partly because vandals, protesting about the omission of Deryck Murray, the local captain, had left wet patches on the pitch &mdash; and thrown a good few bottles around as well. 
 With this in mind, Botham chose to field first, only for Greenidge and Haynes to put on 168 for the first wicket. 
 On the second day, Emburey bowled forty overs for 81 runs and five wickets, but Lloyd, David Murray and Roberts all batted well. 
 Roberts's fifty included an over from Botham from which he hit twenty-four runs (462660), a new Test record for a six-ball over, and Lloyd finally declared on the third morning at 426 for 9. 
 The rest day, incidentally, was taken after two days for the lovely Caribbean reason of avoiding a clash with a steel-band festival. 
 It was Croft who claimed the bowling honours in England's first innings as only Gooch and Gower passed forty in a total of 178. 
 With time lost to the weather, England were faced with surviving for eight and three-quarter hours to draw the match, but Gooch and Rose fell quickly. 
 Boycott stayed over five hours for 70 but had no lengthy support, Botham holed out in the deep when his responsibility as captain was to put his head down, and England never looked as though they were going to make it. 
 Botham's dismissal was the result of fine captaincy by Lloyd, for when it seemed he was going to bat sensibly Lloyd put on Richards, knowing full well Botham would not be able to resist trying to hit his friend out of the ground, and sure enough the sucker punch worked. 
 Even with more time lost, it was all over before the last hour. 
 169 all out gave West Indies a win by an innings and 79 runs, the first time they had beaten England by an innings at home since 1934&ndash;5; by coincidence, it was the first time an England captain had chosen to field first in the Caribbean since Wyatt did in the same series. 
 While in Trinidad, Bob Willis had been injured and returned home. 
 His replacement was Robin Jackman who arrived in Guyana on 23 February, with the Test scheduled to begin on 28 February. 
 It would seem that the mischief was started by a Jamaican radio commentator, who suggested  that as Jackman had coached in South Africa the Guyanese government was contravening the Gleneagles agreement by admitting him. 
 The British Minister for Sport, Hector Monro, pointed out that the Gleneagles agreement was irrelevant here as it made no reference to actions by one country against the nationals of another, but on 26 February the British High Commissioner in Georgetown was notified that Jackman's visitor's permit had been withdrawn and he must leave the country. 
 At the same time, Alan Smith, the England manager, announced that England would not play the second Test as it was &bquo;no longer possible for the Test team to be chosen without restrictions being imposed&equo;. 
 The following day, the English party left for Barbados and, after lengthy discussions with representatives of the governments of Barbados, Montserrat, Antigua and Jamaica, the other scheduled venues, it was stated on 4 March that the tour would continue. 
 Informed sources in the Caribbean thought it likely that the political maneouvrings behind all this were by way of a reprisal for a report by Lord Avebury criticizing Forbes Burnham's ruling party for election-rigging. 
 The point, though, which takes the whole affair into the realms of the ludicrous is that other members of the England party, such as Boycott and Bairstow, had also played and coached in South Africa but no objection was made to them. 
 There seems to be no logical reason for ignoring some and then picking on one, but one can only suppose that, having missed, for whatever reason, their first opportunity of causing trouble, the authorities were just glad to get a second chance. 
 Much sympathy went Jackman's way as many felt that he had been humiliated; and went also to the cricket fans of Guyana, deprived of a Test match and also, because of the weather, of any game against the tourists apart from a one-day international. 
 On England's next tour in 1985&ndash;6, Guyana was carefully omitted from the itinerary, and it would be nine years before they returned &mdash; only for the Test to be washed out completely. 
 There was a warm welcome from the people of Barbados, but their sympathy did not prevent them from preparing a pitch to suit the fast bowlers when the Test took place. 
 One little piece of history was made when Roland Butcher became the first black man to play for England, and by a neat coincidence it was on the ground just fourteen miles from his birth-place. 
 He did not have an outstanding game but was given the warmest of receptions by the crowd when he batted and was helped on his way by reassuring words from Desmond Haynes, a fellow Barbadian. 
 Once again, Botham won the toss and chose to field as the pitch looked as though it would be most lively on the first morning, and for the second  time his decision could not really be criticized. 
 Jackman had Greenidge caught with his fifth ball in Test cricket, and shortly before lunch the fourth wicket went down for 65. 
 Gomes, on 7, was bowled by Dilley off one of just two no-balls delivered all day and, on 17, was dropped by Bairstow off a straightforward chance. 
 He went on to 58, putting on 154 with Lloyd, the captain batting beautifully for a century to take his team out of trouble. 
 On the second morning, the innings was finished off for 265, only for England to collapse dismally. 
 Holding started it with a blistering over of flat-out speed that accounted for Boycott, after which no one passed 26 and they were all out for 122, with Croft again the leading wicket-taker. 
 Late that evening, Ken Barrington suffered a heart attack and died. 
 It does not take much to imagine the effect of this on a group of already dispirited players, all of whom held him in the warmest affection. 
 Many a tear was shed that night, and after the minute's silence at the beginning of the next day the play had an unreal feel to it. 
 It was dominated by a century from Richards, which on the fourth morning he took in explosive style to 182 not out when Lloyd declared on 379 for 7. 
 Faced with a deficit of 522, Boycott and Gatting fell in successive balls with the score on 2;, Gooch and Gower put on 120, but when Gower went for 54 Gooch found little company. 
 He completed his century next day but the last wicket fell at 224, leaving West Indies victors by 298 runs. 
 It all seemed very irrelevant. 
 Out of these depths the England players fought back well, some of them showing just the qualities that Barrington would have wanted. 
 Led by Geoff Miller as Botham was attending Viv Richards' wedding &mdash; to which fifty people were invited and two thousand turned up &mdash; they beat the Leeward Islands and then moved on to Antigua for the inaugural Test at St John's, West Indies' first new Test ground since the opening series of 1929&ndash;30. 
 When they inspected the wicket, they found it being rolled by some prisoners from the local jail, one of whom looked familiar to Boycott. 
 &bquo;I remember you from seven years ago,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'll still be here in ten years,&equo; replied the man. 
 &bquo;I'm doing life!&equo; 
 On what was described as an old-style West Indian pitch, Botham again won the toss and at last chose to bat; a good start was ended when Gooch ran himself out, and soon wickets were tumbling. 
 135 for 3 became 138 for 6 and the writing was in its usual place on the wall. 
 Enter Peter Willey, determined to take on the bowlers. 
 Downton and Emburey kept him company for a while, and when number eleven Dilley joined him he had 69; when Dilley was out for 2 next morning Willey had completed his  century, a splendid 102 not out that took England to 271, Croft finishing with 6 for 74. 
 West Indies soon lost Haynes, but Richards, on his home ground, and Greenidge set off at an explosive pace with 45 off the first seven overs. 
 This became slower and slower as the day went on, and although Richards reached his hundred after tea he then scored only three in an hour. 
 236 for 2 overnight became 296 for 7 next morning as England bowled themselves back into the game, but Lloyd and Garner put on 83 for the eighth wicket and then Holding and Croft an unbeaten 67 for the tenth as the bowlers tired, enabling Lloyd to declare on 468. 
 With twelve and a half hours left, England were clearly up against it, so when the rain fell on the fourth day they were not too upset. 
 After having had it ruin so much of their practice time, it seemed only fair that it should come to their aid when they needed it. 
 Boycott and Gooch then batted steadily for three hours before Gooch departed for 83, after which Gower and Boycott took their team to safety. 
 Both fell before the end but Boycott had another century under his belt as the score reached 234 for 3. 
 If the people of Antigua had not seen the victory they wanted, they had at least enjoyed some good fighting cricket. 
 The Kingston match had a similar pattern, except that England batted first because they had been put in by Lloyd. 
 The first day belonged very much to Gooch, who made a fine 153 that was to earn him the Man of the Match award. 
 In support, though, only Boycott reached 40 and the overnight score was 278 for 6; next morning they were all out for just another seven runs. 
 The last three West Indian wickets were also to fall cheaply, but before that the batsmen had done rather better; Greenidge and Haynes posted another century partnership and Lloyd and Gomes both reached the nineties. 
 442 all out for a lead of 157, leaving England again with two days to survive. 
 In an hour they were 32 for 3 and that was clearly that, but now it was Gower's turn for the heroics. 
 They were lucky to lose almost three hours to rain, but Gower was still there at the end of the last day, having batted seven and three-quarter hours for 154 not out. 
 He had two principal supporters; Willey made 67 in a stand of 136 for the fourth wicket, but when the sixth wicket fell there were nearly four hours left and the lead was only 58. 
 The man for the crisis proved to be Downton, who stayed with Gower till the end, which came when Botham declared on 302 for 6; they were helped by Marshall not being able to bowl, but it was still a fine piece of concentration of which Ken Barrington would have been proud. 
 In the light of what was to happen in the next few years, defeat by just 2&ndash;0 may be seen as something of a triumph, especially in view of the two  traumas that occurred. 
 One man who emerged from the tour with much credit was Alan Smith, the manager, who had been diplomacy personified during the political crisis and sensitive and supportive at the time of Barrington's death. 
 Of the players, Gooch in particular had had a good tour and was really beginning to fulfil his potential, but the difference between the two bowling attacks seemed just to be increasing. 
 The home bowler of the series was Colin Croft with twenty-four wickets at under 19, and few English batsmen will have been sorry that he played in only two rubbers against them. 
 Tall and strong, he was unusual in regularly bowling from wide of the crease, sometimes even so wide that his hand could not be seen against the sightscreen, which obviously caused the batsman trouble. 
 If this reduced the likelihood of an lbw decision the unfamiliar angle made the batsman's job that much more difficult.     
 Colin croft &mdash; took 8 for 29 against Pakistan in only his second Test, the second-best West Indian Test figures of all. 
 BLACK WASHES BEST 
 We now reach the part of this history where English fans, if they can bear to continue, will really need to grit their teeth. 
 The summer of 1984 was a glorious one, the West Indian team was one of their strongest and had just beaten Australia 3&ndash;0; the England team, with some of the top players banned after going to South Africa, was one of their most ordinary and had just lost series to Pakistan and New Zealand for the first time, and it was all rather one-sided. 
 The tourists lost only one match all season, a one-day international, and England hardly looked convincing in that. 
 Clive Lloyd still had, it appeared, dozens of ultra-fast bowlers to call on, while England s slender resources were entrusted to the charge of a fellow with blond curly hair and a pleasing batting style. 
 As a young man, David Gower prophesied that he would be England captain by the age of 25. 
 He made it, too, taking over against Pakistan in 1982 for one match when Willis was injured &mdash; and, given the most toothless of bowling attacks, losing heavily. 
 In Pakistan in 1983&ndash;4 he took over again when Willis had to return home sick and gained two creditable draws, after which he was officially appointed to lead England against the West Indies in 1984, at the age of 27. 
 With the easy grace and dignity associated with the old amateur tradition there was never any doubt that the job would come to him, and so gifted was he as a batsman that one somehow assumed he would slip easily into it once he had learned the ropes. 
 The fact that many another highly gifted player has not found captaincy easy tended to be overlooked. 
 He arrived on the Test arena in memorable style against Pakistan in 1978, hooking his first ball for four with nonchalant ease. 
 Thereafter he took heed from being dropped once or twice, and soon established a permanent place in the team. 
 As England's leading batsman of the 1980s he has borne a heavy responsibility and perhaps because of this has never completely fulfilled his potential; few batsmen can have been blessed with so much natural ability, yet he often looks vulnerable until he has settled down and even then has succumbed countless times to an infuriating nibble or waft outside the off stump. 
 When things are not right he can be   almost static, but when in full flow his grace, elegance and timing have been beautiful to behold. 
 He is famed for his &bquo;laid-back&equo; attitude, his apparent unconcern about his actions both at the crease and at press conferences, and such an easy-going approach led many people to believe that he had little real commitment. 
 In this they were wrong, for he has shown many times that he can fight as well as anyone. 
 If as a captain he was not authoritarian enough, that was just not his style; given opposition that were not vastly superior he could lead a team well enough, and chalked up two notable series wins against India and Australia. 
 His record is singularly unhappy, though, with five victories and eighteen defeats in his thirty-two games in charge, culminating in the ignominy of the 1989 Ashes series. 
 In anyone's book that is failure of some magnitude, but the fact for English cricket was simply that there were very few players of real Test class around at the time; after all, when Mike Gatting, one of the best of the county captains, got his chance he won only twice in twenty-two Tests. 
 If David Gower's captaincy against West Indies left something to be desired, his batting has given endless pleasure to millions of people. 
 The Test series began at Edgbaston as it was to continue &mdash; with a thumping. 
 After half an hour the first English injury occurred, Andy Lloyd going into the record books as the possessor of the briefest of all Test careers. 
 He ha scored ten in thirty minutes before he was hit on the temple of his helmet by a ball from Marshall that lifted sharply; with his  vision blurred it was several days before he left hospital, and he did not play again all season. 
 Since he had been hailed as the new John Edrich and had already shown himself capable of taking on that mantle, it was a bad blow for England. 
 Four more batsmen had departed without the board showing fifty before Botham, dropped before he had scored, chanced his luck for 64, and 33 from Downton helped the score to 191. 
 Edgbaston 1984 and the shortest career in Test cricket is just ending. 
 After only half an hour Andy Lloyd was felled by Malcolm Marshall bouncer and played no more that season. 
 West Indies soon lost their openers, but then Gomes went glory-chasing; with Richards, he put on 206 for the third wicket and, with Lloyd, 124 for the fifth. 
 By the time the eighth wicket went down the lead was already 264, so perhaps it was unkind of Baptiste and Holding to hammer 150 in 113 minutes for West Indies' ninth wicket record against England. 
 The final total was 606, scored in only ten hours of excellent batsmanship, although it was widely felt that the England selectors had helped them along by omitting Foster and playing two spinners, Cook and Miller, on a  pitch of low bounce. 
 England duly subsided a second time, the honours going to Downton who was promoted to open in place of Andy Lloyd and made a solid 56, but wickets fell steadily and 235 all out meant that the victory margin was an innings and 180 runs. 
 For many people the saddest aspect was the selectors' policy of playing Randall at number three; every fan in the country could have told them that he should have batted down the order and that exposing him so early was almost certain to fail. 
 There was much wrath that he had been meaninglessly sacrificed and a Test career that had given so much pleasure needlessly brought to a premature end. 
 Physiotherapist Bernard Thomas tells Lloyd to touch his nose, and it is soon clear that his vision is impaired. 
 Lord's celebrated its centenary of Test cricket and produced a match worthy of the occasion. 
 England were put in, but Fowler, with a good fighting hundred, and Broad, with 55 on debut, gave England the rare luxury of a century opening stand. 
 Unfortunately, the next biggest contributor was Extras, and 286 all out looked very thin; until, that is, I.T. 
 Botham produced one of his more inspired performances. 
 He captured three quick wickets before Richards and Lloyd (who passed 7,000 Test runs) steadied the ship, but then had Richards lbw, although umpire Meyer later admitted that he may have made a mistake and had  considered recalling the batsman. 
 Botham had the first six wickets before Marshall and Baptiste held him up for while, Marshall being lucky not to be on the wrong end of a legendary catch when Don Topley, a groundstaff boy who went on to play for Essex, brilliantly caught him one-handed on the square leg boundary, only to put one foot over the rope. 
 Even so, Botham took 8 for 103, the second-best return of his Test career, as West Indies were all out for 245. 
 Viv Richards shows his reaction at Gower's exit as the ritual dance begins. 
 England's second innings, after three wickets had gone cheaply, centred on Lamb and Botham. 
 The 128 they made for the fifth wicket actually saw the visitors go on the defensive, although not for long. 
 Botham went for 81, but with less than an hour left of the fourth day Lamb accepted an offer of bad light, which most people thought was a mistake. 
 He had been batting steadily and was well set, and since England, 328 ahead with three wickets left, were apparently in control they should have used all the time available to build up their score. 
 Thus ran the argument. 
 Instead, he was out first thing next morning for 110 and Gower declared at 300 for 9, leaving West Indies to make 342 in four and a half hours and twenty overs. 
 It was a perfectly good declaration, but before long the older spectators were recalling Headingley 1948, when Yardley set Australia over 400 to win and Morris and Bradman saw them home. 
 Now the hero was     
 Another version of the ritual dance at the fall of a wicket. 
 her Milton Small and friends celebrate Gower's exit at Lord's in 1984. 
 Ian Botham's 4,000 Test run came with this boundary off Marshall at Lord's in 1984. 
 In the same match he became the first bowler to take eight wickets in an innings in a Test against West Indies in England. 
 A satisfying way to bring up your double century &mdash; Gordon Greenidge hooks Neil Foster off the end of his nose to move from 197 to 203. 
 His unbeaten 214 at Lord's in 1984 made David Gower's declaration, which had seemed a good one, look rather whimsical. 
 Larry Gomes contributed 92 not out as he and Greenidge made an undefeated 287, a new second-wicket record by either side in these Tests. 
 Gordon Greenidge, very ably assisted by Gomes. 
 How could anyone have guessed that the movement the bowlers had found throughout the game would suddenly disappear? 
 Yet it did, and the batsmen made the most of the conditions. 
 Haynes fell with the score on 57, Gomes was missed immediately and Greenidge was missed when he had 110; apart from that it was batsmanship of the highest quality. 
 When the target was reached with 11.5 overs to spare, Gomes was on 92, while Greenidge, in one of the great pieces of batting, had 214 to his name, the first West Indies double century at Lord's. 
 It took him just five hours, included 29 fours, and took him past 4,000 Test runs (a milestone Botham had passed earlier in the game). 
 344 for 1 meant a nine-wicket victory in a match that England had thought they might win. 
 That proved to be the high point of England's summer. 
 For a while in the third match at Headingley they were in contention, but the possibility of victory never remotely reappeared. 
 The first casualty of the match was, for a change, a West Indian fast bowler, when Marshall fractured his left thumb trying to stop a shot from Broad; yet even this worked against England, for it simply inspired him to his best Test figures when he bowled in the second innings. 
 Once again, the backbone of the innings came from Lamb and Botham, and just before the close on the first day Lamb became the first England batsman since Barrington in 1960 to score centuries in consecutive Test innings against West Indies. 
 He went first thing next morning, though, and the innings closed on 270 as Holding became the fourth West Indian to take 200 Test wickets. 
 By the end of the second day the visitors had reached 239 for 7, only Gomes and Lloyd making an impression as Allott, recalled after a two-year absence, headed for his best Test return or 6 for 61. 
 Near the close, Holding began to lay about him and was dropped off a skyer; next morning he continued in the same vein to ensure his team a first innings lead, and ensure, too, that Bob Willis's Test career would end on an unhappy note as it was he who took most of the stick. 
 His 59 came off only 55 balls, but when he and then Garner departed, Gomes was apparently stranded on 96 since Marshall was not expected to bat. 
 Not only did he do so, one-handed, but he scored a four, and allowed Gomes to reach his century. 
 West Indies reached 302. 
 When his hand was being plastered up Marshall was advised not to play again for ten days. 
 Instead he opened the bowling with Garner and soon had a wicket. 
 Fowler and Gower held him up for a while with 91 for the third wicket, but by the close of play he had two more &mdash; including a caught and bowled &mdash; and on Monday morning, cutting down his run-up, he polished off the tail to finish with 7 for 53. 
 It was mightily impressive    bowling by any standards, and with his left hand in plaster it was quite remarkable. 
 England were all out for 159, leaving West Indies the modest target of 128. 
 Three years before on this ground, of course, Australia had failed to reach something similar, but now there were 106 on the board before the openers were separated, and there were still eight wickets in hand when the victory came. 
 It was the first time since 1921 that England had lost the first three Tests of a home rubber. 
 1984 was Allan Lamb's  annus mirabilis, with three centuries against West Indies and one against Sri Lanka. 
 Here he sends Eldine Baptiste to the rope at Headingley . 
 Bob Willis's Test career came to a sad end at Headingley in 1984, as Michael Holding hit him for five sixes. 
 Willis got him in the end, his last Test wicket. 
 In the same match Malcolm Marshall, having fractured his left thumb, came in to see Larry Gomes, on 96, to his century, and scored a four batting one-handed &mdash; &mdash; with a straighter bat than some of the Englishmen had shown. 
 He then took 7 for 53, including a caught and bowled. 
 Useful commodity, courage. 
 There cannot have been any English fans who had expected their team to win the series, but the manner in which they were just being steam-rollered seemly scarcely credible. 
 The worst thing was that it appeared there was nothing they could do to stop it; the players had hardly a shred of belief left in themselves, and Gower was unable to instil any. 
 And so the procession unfolded. 
 Like Lord's, Old Trafford was celebrating its centenary of Test cricket, and, as before, Gordon Greenidge marked the occasion by scoring a double century. 
 The first morning of the match did actually belong to England, West Indies' lunchtime score being 77 for 4; but then Botham bowled poorly, and Greenidge and Dujon accepted this beneficence grate  fully. 
 Their fifth-wicket stand realized 197 before Dujon went for 101 just before the close, bringing in Winston Davis as nightwatchman, replacing Marshall for his only Test of the series. 
 Next morning Davis laid about himself for 77, his highest first-class score, Botham again bowling poorly and being punished for it. 
 In fact, Botham did have an excuse, in that before the match he had received a death threat. 
 When Greenidge was finally caught behind, he had made 223 in nine and three-quarter hours, a phenomenal effort of concentration on a pitch of uneven bounce, for he gave not one chance throughout. 
 West Indies reached exactly 500, with Pocock, recalled after a gap of 86 Tests, finishing with four wickets. 
 Every picture tells a story. 
 Paul Downton has just failed to reach a snick by Larry Gomes off Derek Pringle, and the response of Botham and Gower says it all. 
 Gomes went on to an unbeaten century, thanks to Malcolm Marshall. 
 Fowler and Broad then got off to a good start with 90 for the first wicket before things began to go wrong. 
 After Fowler went, Davis broke Terry's left arm, the uneven bounce having deceived the batsman, and then once again it was all left to Lamb. 
 Allott supported him for a while, and at 278 for 7, with Lamb on 98, there seemed a chance that the follow-on might be saved. 
 Then Pocock and Cowans departed in one over and the    
 West Indies take the 1984 series 3&ndash;0 after three matches. 
 One young fan shows the world what he thinks of it. 
 Like Marshall in the previous Test, Paul Terry came in at Old Trafford in plaster to help a team-mate reach his century. 
 Allan Lamb duly got there, but Joel Garner produced the perfect yorker to end the innings. 
 West Indians began to troop off, only for Gower to wave them back since Terry, arm in sling beneath sweater, was returning. 
 For the second Test running we were treated to the sight of a batsman in plaster coming out to help a colleague reach his hundred, and both were successful. 
 What was not clear in this case, though, was whether he would attempt to stay there while Lamb got the twenty-three needed to avoid the follow-on. 
 When Lamb played five balls of an over defensively and then ran two off the last, it was clear that he was just settling for his hundred, and since Terry immediately succumbed Lamb was criticized for exposing him, rather than trying to keep the strike. 
 He said afterwards that he had understood Terry had come out just to allow him to reach his goal, but it was an unfortunate end to a splendid innings, which made him the first English batsman since Barrington in 1967 to score three consecutive centuries in a series. 
 The confusion about the ending simply unsettled England even more. 
 Gower at last reached fifty and finished unbeaten on 57, but wickets tumbled steadily and early on the final morning it was all over. 
 156 all out gave West Indies victory by an innings and 64 runs, but at least in this instance England were not blasted out. 
 There was much pleasure that Roger Harper played throughout the series, and here his off-spin received its best reward with 6 for 57. 
 At Lord's Greenidge had to share the Man of the Match award with Botham, but here there was no question of his undisputed right to it. 
 The irony for England was that had he decided differently he would have been playing for them rather than against them, for his parents had brought him from Barbados at the age of twelve to live in Reading, and he had played for England schoolboys. 
 He joined Hampshire in 1970 and a couple of years later the selectors were enquiring after him, but he chose to await his chance with West Indies. 
 It came in India in 1974&ndash;5 when he began with 93 and 107; this proved to be something of a false dawn and he had an unhappy time in Australia in 1975&ndash;6, but he worked on his technique and finally established himself in England in 1976 with 592 runs at 65, including a century in each innings on a poor Old Trafford pitch. 
 Thereafter, he was a fixture in the team apart from the World Series interlude, with these two double centuries in 1984 representing the peak of his career. 
 For some eight years he opened the innings for Hampshire with the great Barry Richards, a daunting prospect for many a young bowler hoping to establish himself &mdash; and many an older one who already had. 
 When he first came into the Hampshire team, Greenidge's natural inclination   was to attack every ball, and it was Richards more than anyone who taught him restraint, taught him to wait for the bad ball. 
 Greenidge was happy to admit that playing alongside the South African was &bquo;an education and an inspiration&equo;, but he also conceded that while they both had many outstanding days individually they did not score as many runs in partnership as they might have done, since they were both attacking players and therefore risk-takers. 
 Naturally, Greenidge tried to emulate Richards which, when things went well, was fine, but when they did not it meant that, for a while, he gained a reputation for not being over-reliable; perhaps he suffered from trying to hit the ball too hard, for there were plenty of people who felt that he would have been a better player had he not tried to &bquo;bury the ball into the wall of some distant building&equo; (his own words) at every opportunity. 
 Yet it was a wonderful pairing, one of the most exciting in the game's history, and it helped Hampshire to the championship in 1973 and the John Player League in 1975 and 1978. 
 Gordon Greenidge gives a perfect demonstration of the square cut, generating power with the right leg as the body goes to met the ball. 
 A fielder with any sense would simply get out of the way. 
 Naturally the passing of the years brought a more responsible approach which made him even more formidable, for he still had all the strokes and all the power but now he was less likely to get out unnecessarily. 
 He also gained the lovely reputation of being particularly dangerous when he was limping, since an injury to his leg simply made him hit more fours to cut down on the running. 
 When he was joined in the Test team by Desmond Haynes, one of the most dependable and successful of all opening partnerships was created, and as the senior member in his late twenties Greenidge matured at just the right time. 
 During England's tour of 1989&ndash;90 he celebrated his hundredth Test by scoring his eighteenth century, passing 7,000 runs in the process, and at the end of the series his total stood at 7,134 at an average of 46. 
 To have continued to be so dependable and at the same time so exciting a batsman for so long, shows him to have been one of the greats of the game. 
 Before the last Test at the Oval, Gower exhorted his troops to &bquo;one last, big effort&equo; to avoid completely ignominy, and for a while it seemed that they might. 
 After Lloyd chose to bat on a pleasant sunny day, Botham somehow managed to get the ball to swing and took 5 for 72, including his three hundredth wicket in Tests. 
 West Indies actually succumbed to 70 for 6 and England were cock-a-hoop. 
 Lloyd spoilt it, of course, with an unbeaten 60 that helped his team to 190 all out, but having dismissed them for their lowest total in years England had to feel confident. 
 By the close of the first day, though, they had lost Broad, and Pat Pocock, going in as nightwatchman, had told the England physiotherapist Bernard Thomas that he had cleaned his teeth and gargled in case Thomas had to give him    the kiss of life. 
 Next morning the humour in this wore decidedly thin, as Marshall in particular sent down bouncer after bouncer, unchecked by umpire Constant and apparently unconcerned at the damage he might do &mdash; such as badly bruising Fowler's arm and causing him to retire for a while. 
 Pocock was not spared the treatment, and he and at least three colleagues fell to balls that flew to throat height. 
 Marshall took 5 for 35 as wickets toppled at regular intervals, and the board reached only 162. 
 Being a West Indian spinner in recent years hasn't been the safest of occupations, but Roger Harper played throughout the 1984 series. 
 Ian Botham's 300th Test wicket, the Oval 1984. 
 Jeff Dujon has tried to take evasive action from a ball that has climbed from just short of a length, but has gloved it. 
 Chris Tavar&eacute; at first slip gets in on a piece of history. 
 A flicker of hope came when three West Indian wickets went down for 69, but then it was Haynes' turn to come good after a disappointing series. 
 Supported by Lloyd and then Dujon, he batted for more than seven hours for 125, helping the total to 346 and leaving England ten hours to survive or score 375. 
 For a while Broad and Tavar&eacute; defended well, but then suddenly Holding, for the first time in over a year, decided to go back to his full-length run-up, without even having told Lloyd what he intended to do. 
 It came like an electric shock. 
 Broad, Gower and Lamb fell in quick succession and then it was just a case of mopping up. 
 Botham delayed the inevitable with a fifty, but Holding finished with 5 for 43 and England were all out for 202. 
 At least defeat by a mere 172 runs represented something of an improvement on earlier games.   
 The Oval 1984. it might be raining but a &bquo;blackwash&equo; is not far away. 
 There was no doubt, though, that the banner proclaiming &bquo;Blackwash&equo; said it all. 
 From these depths, England went to India and pulled off a remarkable triumph after losing the first Test, and then beat Australia 3&ndash;1 in 1985. 
 After the Oval Test David Gower murmured that West Indies must be &bquo;quaking in their boots&equo; at the thought of England's forthcoming visit, a characteristically ironic piece of Gower humour. 
 Faced by the weakest bowling attack ever to leave Australia, the England batsmen had made hay, none more so than the captain, and some people felt that the confidence this built up would give them a lift in the Caribbean. 
 Then they awoke, and behold it was a dream. 
 When Clive Lloyd retired at the end of the 1984&ndash;5 tour of Australia, the captaincy passed to Viv Richards. 
 To an outsider this seemed a quite natural progression, but within the West Indies it was not greeted with unmitigated delight. 
 Even after so much success, the inter-island rivalries are never far from the surface, and other players had their advocates. 
 Lloyd's great achievement had been to weld all the factions into a united team, and doubt was expressed that Richards could maintain the unity. 
 Yet he got off to a good start against New Zealand, and no one in England could have been in any doubt that even without Lloyd around their heroes were in for a tough time. 
 Viv Richards has been rated the world's number one batsman since 1976 when he scored a record 1,710 Test runs in the year. 
 Since then, despite having played cricket almost endlessly, he has been astonishingly consistent, averaging over fifty both in Tests and overall. 
 When he has had quiet periods one simply got the feeling that he was having a rest, a feeling reinforced by his ability to produce a big innings apparently at will, especially on the grand occasion or when his team is struggling. 
 Fundamentally, he is an orthodox batsman who can be totally unorthodox, the possessor of every stroke in the book and an improviser who can create any number of others. 
 His speed at getting into position is breath-taking, almost as breathtaking as the power with which he murders the ball. 
 He walks to the crease with a swagger, totally confident, undoubtedly one of the few batsmen to whom the word &bquo;Unforgettable&equo; could be applied without risk of hyperbole. 
 With his splendid physique and proud, noble head his presence is such as to give him an instant advantage over any bowler, and he has rarely failed to put that advantage to use; spinners in particular have  suffered at his hands, but when he decides that he wants to score runs it is virtually impossible to bowl to him. 
 From the spectators' viewpoint, not only does he provide wonderful entertainment but he does it without encasing himself in a helmet, now so rare as to be a treat in itself. 
 Such disdain for something that has become almost universal in the first-class game clearly helps in his psychological battle with the bowlers; disdain is, in fact, an important part of his armoury, combining with his might and skill to cement his authority. 
 As he is also a useful off-spinner, occasional medium-pacer, and excellent slip fielder, the cumulative result is the most formidable cricketer of the 1970s and '80s. 
 Strangely, his career began with a considerable upset. 
 He came from a cricketing family &mdash; his father was a leading fast bowler in Antigua &mdash; and his great talent was evident very early on, so that he was already popular  with the fans as a youngster. 
 At the age of seventeen he was playing for Antigua in the Leeward Islands tournament when he was given out caught behind. 
 He gestured his dissent at this and in no time the crowd were clamouring for the umpire to reverse the decision, which he did. 
 As a result he was suspended for two years, which of course delayed his entry into first-class cricket; but it taught him a lot. 
 &bquo;The world's greatest batsman&equo; &mdash; Viv Richards demonstrates the on drive. 
 His Test debut came in the same match as Gordon Greenidge against India in 1973&ndash;4, Greenidge totalling 200 runs and Richards 7; in the next game he made 192 not out and was under way. 
 He made 829 runs in four matches (he missed the Lord's Test through illness) in 1976, which was statistically his best performance, and if he has never made quite so many since that must just be because of the demands, physical and psychological, of playing so much top cricket. 
 Two of his most memorable innings came in one-day internationals, the 138 not out in the 1979 World Cup final and the 189 not out at Old Trafford in 1984 which single-handedly transformed a desperate situation into a winning one, and which will surely never be forgotten by anyone who saw it. 
 In 1980&ndash;1, in the first Test to be played on his home ground in Antigua, there was never any doubt that he was going to mark the occasion with a century, and, as we shall see, when England returned five years later he marked that occasion in the most spectacular fashion. 
 At Sydney in 1988 against New South Wales he became the twenty-second batsman and the first West Indian to score a century of centuries. 
 All of this has been achieved with an inevitability which few batsmen since Bradman have been able to suggest, and in 111 Tests at the end of the 1989&ndash;90 series he was just ten runs short of 8,000 at an average of 51. 
 In 1974, at the age of 22, he joined Somerset, and with Joel Garner was to play a very important part in their one-day successes between 1979 and 1983. 
 Helped in the crucial early years by Brian Close, his &mdash; and Garner's &mdash; loyalty to their adopted country became every bit as great as Clive Lloyd's to Lancashire. 
 His colleague Vic Marks wrote that &bquo;we willed opposition fast bowlers to bounce him so that we could witness the majesty of his hooking&equo;, and there can be very few batsmen of whom that could be said. 
 In 1985 his batting reached its peak at Taunton against a Warwickshire team who bowled and fielded well but who could not stop him making 322, the highest first-class innings in England for thirty-six years; after a slightly uncomfortable start, the second and third hundreds came off sixty-seven and sixty-three balls respectively, and only tiredness after a drive from Leeds the evening before caused his downfall. 
 Thus, the decision by the county at the end of the following season not to re-engage him  and Garner came as an enormous surprise and caused a furore; from the emotional angle it was poor reward for years of devoted service, but rationally, since the opportunity to sign up Martin Crowe of New Zealand, who promised so much, had either to be taken or lost, it was a sensible move. 
 It is impossible for the outsider to appreciate what this meant to a man as proud as Richards, but it was noticeable that in the Test series against Pakistan and New Zealand which followed his form was very ordinary. 
 Pride has always been an important part of his make-up. 
 The usual epithet applied to his bearing is patrician, and his batting, as a matter of course, is liberally endowed with arrogance. 
 At the wicket he is a Roman general, unquestioning of his own ability to defeat the barbarians; yet because the pride and haughtiness are justified by having repeatedly proved himself to be the best, one cannot resent them, especially since he usually leaves them on the field of combat. 
 Off the field he is mild-mannered and dismissive of his achievements &mdash; though his verbal attack on an English journalist at the end of the 1989&ndash;90 tour was fulminating stuff &mdash; while at the same time he is intensely proud of his humble background, is very much a man of his people. 
 He was offered enormous sums to go to South Africa but would never contemplate it; it would have meant a betrayal of everything he stood for, a soul-selling of Faustian proportions. 
 Instead, he wanted to meet his final challenge, to take over the West Indies captaincy from Lloyd and continue their triumphal march through the record books. 
 England began their tour in miserable fashion, handing Windward Islands their first ever win over a touring team. 
 They then lost Gatting, who had been in better form than anyone, in the first one-day international when his nose exploded after coming into contact with a ball from Marshall that he failed to hook. 
 The optimists tried to suggest that Garner and Holding might be on the wane; the realists knew better. 
 Home advantage meant that pitches could be prepared especially to suit fast bowlers, and come the first Test in Jamaica it was soon evident this is what had happened. 
 Matters were not helped by the Sabina Park authorities providing one sightscreen that was too low to be of much use if the bowler was over six feet (1.8 metres) tall, and when England complained after the game against Jamaica the reply was that it could not be raised without obscuring the view of some two hundred people who had already bought tickets. 
 Admittedly, as the tour went on England did little to help their own cause, but there were all kinds of things workings against them. 
 The first Test lasted two days and five hours on a pitch that was very  hard, very fast and some way from flat. 
 It was a happy debut for the latest model to drop off the fast-bowling conveyor belt; Patrick Patterson had played for Lancashire the previous summer without making much impression, but now on his home patch with the sun on his back he hit Test cricket with a bang. 
 Gooch and Robinson began carefully after Gower won the toss, but then Patterson got Robinson and the collapse was under way. 
 The best England could offer was 51 from Gooch and 49 from Lamb, and just before tea they were all out for 159. 
 Greg Thomas came close to a wicket three times in his first over in Test cricket, but Greenidge and Haynes survived to give their usual start before Greenidge had to retire with a cut forehead after mishooking Botham. 
 That slowed things down a bit and on the second day England made some progress through the wickets. 
 Greenidge, Gomes and Dujon all made fifties, but Ellison bowled well for 5 for 78, and restricting the total to 307 was hailed as a mini-triumph. 
 On the first day the West Indian bowlers had been sparing with the bouncer, for on such a pitch there was no need for it. 
 On the third day there was no such respite, Patterson in particular giving the impression that he knew, and cared, nothing about Law 42 and the intimidatory bowling of fast short-pitched balls. 
 Only Willey, who seemed to play his best Test innings against West Indian thunderbolts, made a fight of it with 71; Botham hammered a quick 29, but the last wicket went down for 152, leaving West Indies needing five to win. 
 One yearned for Richards to make the romantics smile by sending in two bowlers to polish them off, reflecting that when Percy Chapman did it with fifteen needed against Australia in 1928&ndash;9 (and lost two wickets!), 
 West Indian Test cricket was just six months old. 
 What a hope. 
 Before the second Test in Trinidad, England actually won a one-day international thanks to a superb unbeaten century from Gooch. 
 In the Test, on a less malign pitch than in Kingston, he was out fourth ball, and three wickets were soon down for 30. 
 Gower and Lamb both produced sixties and actually managed a century stand, but no other batsman passed eight and the total was no more than 176. 
 Botham then bowled dismally to allow Greenidge and Haynes to make a good start, after which Richardson clocked up a steady hundred. 
 Emburey and Edmonds, however, made them work for their runs and took wickets as well, Emburey finishing with 5 for 78. 
 It was Marshall who took the game right away from England, holding together the tail for 62 not out and stretching the total to 399. 
 At least England made a slightly more respectable fist of their second innings. 
 Gooch, Gower and Lamb made forties, only for the ball to  start shooting and wickets to fall. 
 When the eighth wicket went down England were still nine behind, only for two unlikely heroes to emerge. 
 Richards took the new ball &mdash; which did not shoot &mdash; and Ellison and Thomas played quite contentedly for two hours, putting on 72 for the last wicket, a new England record in the West Indies, taking the total to 315. 
 This left West Indies to make 93, and early on the fifth morning they duly got there, having lost three wickets to Emburey and Edmonds, both of whom bowled well throughout. 
 The margin was narrower than before; were England turning the corner? 
 At the end of the second day of the Barbados Test, it seemed that perhaps they had. 
 After Gower won the toss and put them in, West Indies had a good first day as Haynes made a patient 84 and Richardson his second successive century; 269 for 2 at the close reflected the lack of life that Botham and Thomas had been able to extract from the pitch and the catches that had gone. 
 Then on the second day, when the pitch should have been easier, only Richards, with 51, looked convincing and the last eight wickets fell steadily. 
 The total was 418, and there was better still to come from England. 
 Robinson soon went, but Gooch and Gower batted well and took the overnight score to 110 for 1; only another 119 to avoid the follow-on and clearly England's best day of the series so far. 
 Soon after two o'clock the next afternoon they were all out for 189, the atmosphere helping the ball to move and swing around. 
 Fifteen wickets were to go down in all that day, and although Gooch and Robinson made a sound start, once they were separated the procession continued as normal. 
 They were 132 for 6 at the close and it was clearly time to pray for rain; but it came on the rest day by mistake, and although Emburey and Downton battled for a while, the end was not long delayed. 
 199 all out meant victory by an innings and 30 runs; it also meant that West Indies had emulated Australia's feat in 1920&ndash;1 and 1921 of recording eight successive Test victories over England. 
 It seemed that only the weather could stop another blackwash. 
 The fourth Test in Trinidad was simply a repeat of the first. 
 On a pitch of uneven bounce England were put in and shot out before the end of the day for 200, David Smith, Lamb and Botham the only ones to make an impression. 
 Next day, Thomas, who had had a good tour so far, bowled poorly and paid the price; Botham, by contrast, had had an awful tour, but now he bowled well and took five wickets as a result. 
 This did not stop West Indies taking a firm grip on the match, as Greenidge reached 5,000 Test runs and Richards 6,000, warming up for his achievement in the next match with 87. 312 all out was hardly the big total they would have  wanted, but it was quite enough. 
 Smith, in his second Test, top-scored in the second innings as well as the first, but it was all totally predictable; 150 all out left West Indies 39 to win, and less than six overs sufficed. 
 As at Kingston, the margin was ten wickets; the only difference was that the match lasted a quarter of an hour less. 
 Before the last Test it seemed that Gooch would return home, annoyed at an article written about his South African connections by Lester Bird, the Deputy Prime Minister of Antigua, and tired of the hostile receptions he had been getting from press and public. 
 Only an appeal by Gower to his loyalty persuaded him to stay, and he was to have his best game of the series. 
 St John's, Antigua did, in fact, see something approaching a Test match, and it was only in the final hour that England lost. 
 Yet even then they did not play particularly well. 
 Gower won the toss and inserted West Indies, only for Haynes to hold the innings together as his partners got in and then out. 
 On the second day, Haynes reached his century and England paid the penalty of having Botham poised one behind Dennis Lillee's 355 Test wickets. 
 Inevitably, he bowled relentlessly on, never looked like getting anywhere, and the last four wickets put on 183 as Marshall, Harper and Holding enjoyed themselves at almost five an over. 
 474 set England a stiff target but the pitch was less malicious than the earlier ones and Gooch and Slack put on 127 for the first wicket. 
 Twice Richards complained about the ball, each time causing a lengthy hold-up to upset the batsmen's concentration, and behaving with such arrogance that after the match he apologized to the umpires for it. 
 When the openers were parted it was Gower who held the innings together with 90, and thanks to 51 Extras the follow-on target was passed with three wickets in hand, and the total made 310. 
 By now it was the morning of the fourth day and West Indies had a lead of 164; clearly quick runs were needed to make sure they had plenty of time to bowl England out again. 
 Haynes and Richardson opened and put on exactly 100, then Richards, on his home ground, marched out, the first time he had batted at number three for some while. 
 English hearts sank even further than they already were, for it would not have needed a weather forecaster to predict that Hurricane Viv was about to strike. 
 Fifty minutes later he had 53 from 35 balls, and thirty-one minutes after that, from another 21 balls, he had 103; the fastest century in terms of balls received in the history of Test cricket, 56 balls to Jack Gregory's 67 against South Africa in 1921&ndash;2, although Gregory took only 70 minutes while Richards took 81 minutes. 
 He hit six sixes and seven fours in his hundred, then one more six to take him to 110 before he declared, and the  scribes were simply stuck for superlatives to convey the majesty of it. 
 The domination of the bowlers was total, put the ball wherever they might. 
 Most striking of all was the sheer inevitability of it: the game was being played in front of his beloved Antiguans, quick runs were needed, King Viv decided he was going to get them, and that was that. 
 The declaration at 246 for 2 left England 410 runs behind, with five hours fifty minutes plus the last twenty overs to survive. 
 Two wickets fell on the fourth evening, but Ellison stayed with Gooch for some time next morning, as did Gower. 
 Wickets fell during the afternoon and, with the final twenty overs approaching, there were three wickets left and it was up to Gower and Downton. 
 The captain bad defended solidly for hours, but now Harper got one to bounce and he was caught behind. 
 That was that, and when the last wicket fell &mdash; to a poor piece of umpiring &mdash; there were 14.5 overs left, England had 170 and the winning margin was 240 runs. 
 So it was another blackwash, another disaster, for England. 
 They went without a hope and they came back, it seemed, without a friend, perilously close to reaching mother-in-law status as the comedians' favourite butt. 
 There were some valid defences, particularly the poor state of most of the pitches and the injuries to Gatting (having returned from getting his nose repaired he promptly had a thumb broken and played in only the final Test), but some of the criticisms were very valid, too. 
 Principal among these was their attitude to practice, which was almost entirely voluntary. 
 It seemed to most onlookers that the first step to take to correct the disparity between the teams was to practise as hard as possible, especially as the West Indians were doing just that themselves; Gower and Tony Brown, the manager, however, enforced no such ruling. 
 Admittedly, the practice facilities were often poor, but the preference for relaxation as an antidote to the cannon-balls suggested that deep down the fighting spirit was lacking. 
 With an authoritarian captain to instil some pep into them, a draw or two may have been salvaged and it would have been just another defeat rather than an abject cave-in, but Gower was not able to pick them up. 
 For all that, the way in which he was publicly rebuked by Peter May, the chairman of Selectors, after returning home, and appointed only for the first Test against India, annoyed many people by its insensitivity and seemed to be about as productive as the shooting of Admiral Byng on his quarterdeck. 
 It was a sad time for English cricket; sadder still was the tact that, apart from one series, things would simply continue to get ever worse. 
 For West Indies, two bowlers, Garner and Marshall, shared the honours at the top of the averages with 27 wickets each, Garner's being slightly the less expensive at just 16 apiece. 
 Joel Garner was, in fact, almost at the end  had begun back in 1976&ndash;7 against Pakistan when he made his debut in the same game as Colin Croft. 
 He was to play 58 Tests in all, taking 259 wickets at just under 21, a lower average than any of the top West Indian bowlers except Marshall. 
 A clue to his role may be found in the fact that only seven times did he take five wickets in an innings and never once ten in a match. 
 For most of the time the &bquo;Big Bird&equo; preferred to sacrifice the flat-out pace of his team-mates for accuracy and control, taking wickets by making the ball swing and cut, and so in Tests was for some years used as first or second change bowler. 
 Only with the retirement of Roberts did he get promotion to the new ball, whereupon he stepped up his speed and took 31 wickets against Australia in 1983&ndash;4, although he then reduced it again. 
 His accuracy and stinginess with runs made him almost without equal as a one-day bowler, for he could both contain and attack at the same time since the bounce he got from his great height and the control he had over the ball gave him the extra penetration that brought wickets. 
 Two of his greatest performances came in 1979, with 5 for 38 in the World Cup final and 6 for 29 in the Gillette final for Somerset, although both times Richards pipped him for the match award.   
 For such a tall man Joel Garner had a beautiful follow-through with a great deal of athletic grace. 
 In many ways Garner was the model professional, totally dedicated and loyal to his teams, an intelligent man who gave much thought to his game. 
 If it is stretching the imagination to describe any West Indian fast bowler as a gentle giant he is nevertheless mild-mannered and easy-going, and it is significant that while the likes of Croft and Marshall were doing unpleasant things to batsmen's heads, the damage that Garner inflicted was mostly confined to arms and hands; obviously any broken bone is bad and obviously he sent down his share of bouncers, but there was never the suggestion that he was using his physical advantages maliciously; six feet eight inches 12 metres) tall and weighing seventeen stones (108 kilograms), the prospect of the carnage he might have caused had he been of an aggressive nature hardly bears thinking about. 
 As it is, he has gone down as a highly skilled bowler who, because he lacked the flamboyance of some of his colleagues, attracted less attention than many of them; but who consistently, almost stealthily, got on with the job of collecting three or four wickets in innings after innings after innings. 
 By 1988 West Indies were going through what England had been going through for as long as anyone could remember: a period of transition. 
 Holding, Garner and Gomes had retired and youngsters such as Ambrose, Hooper, Arthurton and Bishop were on their first tour of England. 
 At the end of 1987 they had failed to reach the semi-finals of the World Cup and then played two drawn series against India and Pakistan, in the latter case coming close to defeat before squeezing a two-wicket victory to square the rubber. 
 England's fortunes under Mike Gatting had been varied, losing relentlessly at home, carrying all before them in a triumphal tour of Australia, narrowly losing a World Cup final they should have won and then having their captain, under great provocation, address naughty words to a Pakistani umpire. 
 Gatting's altercation with Shakoor Rana was to have a considerable effect on the West Indies Test rubber. 
 When England convincingly won all three one-day games, the country was seized with a spasm of excited optimism. 
 Had the mighty champions really reached the end of the road? 
 Was the underdog about to have his day? 
 When, in the first Test at Trent Bridge, Gooch and Broad put on 125 for the first wicket the smiles were widening all the time; when the last wicket fell with just 245 on the board we knew where we really were. 
 When a sound start was then followed by a sparkling 80 from Richards, a classical 84 from Hooper and a thumping 72 from Marshall, with even Ambrose making 43, we knew exactly what was what, and when Richards  declared on the fourth evening at 448 for 9, leaving England with a day plus 51 overs to survive, there were probably not many people who thought they would make it. 
 But the last day belonged to Gooch and Gower, with Gatting also fighting well; Gooch finished with 146 and Gower 88 not out, greatly helped by Marshall having to go off injured. 
 It was a day to reassure English hearts, for not only was the sequence of defeats brought to an end but the fight was sturdily fought and morale given a welcome boost. 
 There had not been a crisis for about six months, though, so it was clearly time for one. 
 The tabloid newspapers decided it was their duty to reveal that Gatting had invited a barmaid to his hotel room during the Test match, and that he and other players had taken part in &bquo;sex romps&equo; with girls from the hotel; though how the newshounds, scrabbling around in the bushes outside, could see what was happening in the rooms was not really clear. 
 Perhaps if it had not been for the Shakoor Rana affair the TCCB might have handled this quietly and sensibly by issuing a non-committal statement and letting the fuss die down. 
 Instead, they got themselves into a thoroughly embarrassing mess, saying they accepted Gatting's statement that nothing improper had taken place but sacking him all the same. 
 Since the logic of this eluded most people, it seemed reasonable to conclude that he was belatedly paying the price for arguing with an umpire. 
 England captains must not do things like that, but they had not been able to sack him at the time because of the provocation he had been under; now that he had stepped out of line again he gave them a heaven-sent opportunity to administer the axe. 
 The rights and wrongs of it were debated for some time and the feeling seemed to be that the TCCB had come out of it in a worse light than Gatting; as the Melbourne newspaper The Age put it, &bquo;Gatting, caught rumour, bowled hypocrisy, 0&equo;. 
 It meant that the Test career of a man aged just 31, who still had a great deal to offer his country, was almost over; true, it would be terminated by his own decision to go to South Africa, but this came about only because of his disillusion with cricket's establishment. 
 So John Emburey was handed the captaincy that could well have been his years earlier if he had not gone to South Africa in 1982, thereby losing the Middlesex captaincy to Gatting after Mike Brearley retired. 
 He had been in and out of the England team for ten years and had played 55 Tests, probably the best off-spinner in the world for much of this time. 
 In the last year or two his wicket-taking ability seemed to have deserted him, and his Test average crept up noticeably, a year later finishing after 60 Tests with 138 wickets at 37. 
 He became especially good as a one-day containing bowler, playing a big part in his county's successes, and contributing many  useful, if very idiosyncratic, lower middle order runs; while his Test bowling average was declining, his batting figure was improving all the time, and reached a handy 21. 
 A very thoughtful cricketer, with a much greater knowledge of the game's history than most players, one had the impression that he could have made a fine Test captain had the chance come earlier. 
 With Gatting dropping out of the Lord's Test at his own request, Emburey could hardly have made a better start. 
 Richards won the toss and took a long time to decide to bat; when he did so Dilley bowled superbly, and five wickets went down for just 54. 
 Could this be true? 
 No, of course not. 
 Logie, on 10, was dropped at slip and went on to put on 130 for the sixth wicket with Dujon, a crucial stand in view of the end result. 
 Still, 209 all out seemed a fair performance by England, or it would have done had more of their batsmen scored some runs. 
 Only Gooch and Gower passed forty, neither by any margin, and, with Marshall taking 6 for 32, the last wicket fell at 165. 
 Here we go again, said everyone, and they were right; on the first two days there had been plenty of cloud to help the bowlers,  but on the Saturday the sun shone and West Indies made the most of it. 
 Greenidge, hit on the knee, began to limp, so making a century inevitable &mdash; and passing 6,000 Test runs in the process &mdash; while Richards hammered 72 from eighty balls. 
 When Hooper went they were 240 for 5 and perhaps just catchable if the rest of the wickets tumbled. 
 Logie and Dujon, once again, had other ideas, and exceeded their first innings partnership by one run. 
 It was the first time two West Indian batsmen had made a century stand for the sixth wicket in each innings of a Test and it took the game right away from England; when the last wicket fell, Logie was left unbeaten on 95, the score was 397, and England had to survive for the best part of two days. 
 Mike Gatting, first of a long line of England captains in 1988. 
 Thanks to an over rate of 11.2 and the time lost to the weather being made up at the end, that fourth day became the longest in Test history, not finishing until 7.40. 
 By then England were 214 for 7, only Allan Lamb, desperately needing a big score to stay in the team, having given the scorers much exercise. 
 Lamb was on 99 and it took him an age next morning to reach the hundred, his first since 1984. 
 The tail showed more application than the top of the order, and when Lamb was run out for 113 Jarvis and Dilley batted well to put on 53 for the last wicket. 
 Had England held a few more catches, that could have won them the match; as it was, an all-out total of 307 meant victory for West Indies by 134 runs. 
 At least the accountants were happy, as for the first time in England match receipts passed the &pound;l million mark. 
 Just for the record, 77,923 people paid &pound;1,031,262.50; twenty-five years earlier 110,287 people had paid &pound;56,300. 
 Marshall took 10 for 92 in that match but arrived at Old Trafford for the third Test reportedly with a rib injury. 
 In a game that went to the fifth day only because many hours were lost to the weather &mdash; the actual playing time was two and two-thirds days &mdash; one was left wondering what he might have done had he been fully fit. 
 On the first morning, England crashed to 55 for 4 and there was never any doubt about the result; by the close, it had become 135 all out, and in three overs West Indies batted, two catches were dropped. 
 Next day, John Childs, nearly 37 and England's oldest Test debutante for over forty years, took a wicket in his third over, but only three were down when the England total was passed. 
 For the third consecutive innings Dujon featured in a substantial sixth-wicket stand, this time putting on 94 with Harper, and, given the vagaries of the weather, Richards' problem was when to declare. 
 He did so when play was about to resume after a stoppage early in the last session of the fourth day, with the score 384 for 7, and he could hardly have  timed it more precisely; 60 for 3 overnight, and, as next morning it looked as though it might rain at any time, Marshall decided to polish the rest off quickly. 
 In just over an hour he took five wickets, Ambrose chipped in with the other two, and England were all out for 93. 
 One was reminded of some hapless Victorian consumptive, fading away and unable to do anything about it. 
 Marshall's figures were 7 for 22 off 15.4 overs, giving him a strike rate of a wicket every 26 balls throughout the series. 
 So West Indies won by an innings and 156 runs; yet had England managed to hold on for just another three or four minutes they would have got a draw, for the heavens opened and further play would have been impossible. 
 Obviously, they deserved to be beaten out of sight, but since the weather had looked almost certain to save them if someone could have stayed there, the collapse became even more abject. 
 Before the next match, the selectors debated long and hard over the England captaincy, the problem being that Emburey's form had declined and his place in the team could hardly be justified; their solution was to drop him and appoint Chris Cowdrey in his place, whose enthusiastic style of leadership had taken an ordinary Kent side to the top of the table. 
 He had played five Tests on the 1984&ndash;5 tour of India without any marked success, leaving the impression that he was not quite up to Test standard. 
 For some people the choice was an imaginative one, for others it was yet another piece of selectoral nonsense, made worse by the fact that he was Peter May's godson. 
 In the event, the most important repercussion of the appointment was to deprive Kent of the championship, for it proved such a traumatic time for Cowdrey that his team lost their way for a few weeks, and missed the title by just one agonizing point. 
 Curiously, his father had also been one of three captains in a series against West Indies; he, though, had not suffered the indignity of being refused admission to the car park at the ground because the attendant did not recognize him. 
 At Headingley, David Gower, thirty-three years old, became the youngest player to reach one hundred Test matches &mdash; or, as Don Mosey put it on the radio, he reached his hundredth Test in fewer games than anyone else. 
 The feat was marked by a drain bursting under the pitch soon after play began and flooding one of the run-ups; inevitably, the umpire concerned was &bquo;Dickie&equo; Bird, famed for his wariness about the weather, and now having to contend with water coming from below as well as above. 
 England were soon losing wickets when play began, four going down for 80; but then Lamb and Robin Smith, on debut, showed what could be done, and on the Friday morning posted a century partnership and looked good for plenty more. 
 Then tragedy: after a quick run Lamb's right calf  muscle seized up and he had to leave the field &mdash; and from 183 for 4 the score suddenly became 185 for 8, then 201 all out. 
 One's heart bled for Cowdrey, for he looked desperately nervous and soon succumbed without scoring. 
 The bowlers, though, did well in favourable conditions and, if they had been better supported at slip, could have made a match of it. 
 As it was, with most of the Saturday lost to rain the total reached 275 thanks to Harper holding the tail together. 
 Gooch and Curtis made a solid start and the deficit was passed for the loss of just one wicket. 
 Then the statutory collapse. 
 Gower needed just two runs to reach 7,000 in his hundredth Test and got them, only to fall immediately to a quite unnecessary flick down the leg side. 
 Only Lamb, coming in at number eight and hitting fours off one leg, averted total disgrace, 138 all out leaving just 65 needed for victory. 
 As so often, the openers, this time Haynes and Dujon, had no problems. 
 The changes that were made for the Oval game took the number of England players used in the series to twenty-three and, as Cowdrey had to withdraw with a bruised foot, Graham Gooch was appointed the fourth captain of the series. 
 For a couple of days or so England were actually in the match. 
 Their first innings made only 205, with 57 from Smith and 43 from debutante Bailey (whose reward, after failing in the second innings, was to be dropped against Sri Lanka, one of the most astonishing pieces of selectoral crassness for years); but on the second morning, in real sunshine for about the first time in the rubber, Foster bowled splendidly to decapitate the order. 
 As at Lord's, it was Logie and Dujon who got the runs, but with Foster taking 5 for 64 they were all out for 183, the first time England had taken a first-innings lead since the Lord's game of 1984. 
 When Gooch and Curtis opened with 50 one began to wonder &mdash; would we see an upset as we had in 1966? 
 Then Curtis fell, and in quick succession so did Bailey and Smith. 
 Foster did well as nightwatchman but otherwise only Gooch, in one of his slowest innings, stood firm; he batted over seven hours with the ball moving around awkwardly and had 84 to his name when he was last out, having seen the total to 202. 
 It set West Indies a target of 225, which everyone knew was about three hundred too low, and inevitably Greenidge and Haynes began with a century partnership. 
 Gooch damaged a finger as soon as the innings began and had to go to hospital, Pringle taking command; but he could work no miracles and victory was gained for the loss of just two wickets. 
 For most English people it was just a case of sighing with relief that it was all over. 
 When Marshall took Curtis's wicket in the second innings he had 35 for the series (the average finishing at 12.65 each), beating Fred Trueman's  much stronger team) and the West Indian record of 33 for most wickets in any Test rubber. 
 No fewer than 19 of those 35 were taken without assistance from his team-mates, and on average he took a wicket every 35 balls. 
 His overall strike rate, in fact, is lower than any other major bowler, confirming his position as number one in the world rankings. 
 Unlike some of his colleagues, he does not have the build or the strength of an American footballer, being under six feet (1.8 metres) tall and weighing twelve stones (76 kilograms). 
 Instead, he has relied on great fitness and stamina to enable him to keep sprinting in at full pace, and speed of arm and perfect balance to capitalize on the momentum; combined with an unrelenting desire to keep on taking more and more wickets, it has all proved irresistible. 
 Like Harold Larwood long before him, he used his relative shortness (in fast bowling terms) to make the ball skid through at great pace, always difficult for a batsman to deal with. 
 Over the years, a good many bouncers have been sent down and several batsmen have been injured, especially around the head; this is because, unlike most of his colleagues, his bouncers usually go through at head height rather than above  it and so are particularly awkward. 
 Thus, it was rather ironic that in this, his best series, he bowled hardly any; instead, he took his wickets by adapting his bowling to the slow conditions of a rainy summer, reducing his pace a fraction and making the ball move around more. 
 The destroyer &mdash; Malcolm Marshall took 35 wickets in the 1988 series. 
 His Test debut had come against India in 1978&ndash;9 aged only twenty, but, with so many other top bowlers in competition, it was a few years before his place was secure. 
 Being signed by Hampshire as replacement for Andy Roberts just a few months after his Test debut gave him the chance to impress Clive Lloyd in county matches and in 1982 he really came good with 134 wickets, the best season's haul since the reduction in championship matches in 1969. 
 This cemented his place in the Test team, although it would be another year or so before he was given the new ball, and then it was just a question of piling up the scalps as the main strike bowler. 
 By the end of the 1989&ndash;90 series against England, he had 329 wickets at under 21, by some way his country's leading bowler. 
 He also had claims to be considered a genuine all-rounder, having played many attacking innings in the lower middle order. 
 Of the great West Indian bowlers from Roberts on, he is the most successful, perhaps because, with the exception of Croft, he has been the most difficult to play. 
 Yet off the pitch he has a reputation as a dressing-room joker, an easy-going character who likes his soul and reggae music and has a smile never far from the surface. 
 just give him a cricket ball and watch the transformation. 
 One of West Indies' other heroes of the summer, and much of the decade, was wicket-keeper Jeffrey Dujon, with over 300 runs and twenty dismissals in the rubber. 
 If he is not the greatest gloveman the game has known, he is a very successful wicket-keeper-batsman; in his first two Tests in Australia in 1981&ndash;2 he appeared solely as a batsman before taking over from David Murray, and by the end of the 1989&ndash;90 series he had played in 68 Tests, made 223 dismissals (a miserly five stumpings tells a sad tale) and scored almost 3,000 runs at an average of 35 with five centuries. 
 If some have found his wicket-keeping style too flashy, others see it as artistic; he is a naturally graceful man who would be hard put to look clumsy. 
 Whatever one's opinion, he has missed remarkably little considering he has had to cope with such an endless barrage of fast bowling. 
 His batting has been a pleasure to watch, elegant, artistic and poised, strong on both sides of the wicket, equally happy using his feet to the spinners or hooking the fast men. 
 In 1983 he took over the captaincy of Jamaica when Rowe went to South Africa but found it a difficult business, perhaps because he is too quiet and introspective for cricket leadership. 
  By and large, the 1980s were a very unhappy time for the England Test team, with only the occasional series victory to relieve the encircling gloom. 
 This culminated in the misery of the 1989 Ashes rubber, after which the tour of the Caribbean early in 1990 seemed to be about to take its place alongside St Bartholomew's Day, Glencoe and other great massacres of history. 
 There was much discussion as to who should captain the ship, and when Graham Gooch was appointed anyone of a cynical disposition found it hard to escape the feeling that it was in the hope that, with his South African connections, at least one government would refuse to let him in, thus avoiding another 5&ndash;0 blackwash. 
 By not only relieving David Gower of the captaincy, which was inevitable, but omitting him altogether the selectors provoked an uproar; they came up with a party that had only two specialist openers, an inexperienced middle order, and some fast bowlers who were virtually untried, injury-prone and had a reputation for speed but not accuracy. 
 The official pronouncement was that they intended to fight fire with fire. 
 It seemed crazy; suicidal, even. 
 But in the weeks before they left they worked extremely hard at their fitness,  were coached by Geoff Boycott to improve their batting technique, and insisted to the press that people back home in England were going to be pleasantly surprised. 
 This series, incidentally, was to introduce English fans to Bishop Ambrose, the most quaintly named fast bowler since Lillian Thomson. 
 Jeff Dujon in action against Worcestershire early in 1984, warming up for a century in the Old Trafford Test. 
 Gooch was the leading run-scorer in first-class cricket for the 1980s, with over 21,000 at 49, and in view of this his Test record -4,724 runs at just under 37 from 73 Tests before the tour began &mdash; is something of a disappointment, and illustrates clearly the difference it makes to a player to belong to a successful side. 
 Tall and powerful, he is naturally an attacking batsman who loves to play his shots, and his Test average has no doubt suffered from having often had to play defensively to shore up the innings. 
 For Essex there have been few such problems, and his batting has been, after Keith Fletcher's captaincy, probably the chief reason for their successes. 
 In 1986 he took over the captaincy from Fletcher and led them to  their third championship in four years, but early in 1987 he suffered a bad loss of form and the team slipped right down the table. 
 Deciding that captaincy was affecting his batting, he stood down in favour of Fletcher for a season, resuming again in 1989 when the county did well but his own form was fairly ordinary. 
 His first taste of Test captaincy came at the Oval in 1988; he was unable to stem the West Indian flood, but produced a battling second innings to make a game of it. 
 He was rewarded with a victory over Sri Lanka, and then chosen to lead the team to India, only for the tour to be cancelled because of the South African connections of himself and several members of the party. 
 When the Australians arrived in 1989, he seemed scarcely to be considered for the leadership, and appeared to have few advocates beyond the purlieus of Chelmsford and Colchester. 
 Yet in February 1990 he pulled off one of cricket's all-time miracles. 
 The creator of the &bquo;miracle&equo; at Sabina Park, 1989&ndash;90, Graham Gooch has four centuries to his name against West Indies. 
 Early in the tour one of the fast bowlers, Ricardo Ellcock, had a recurrence of a back injury and went home. 
 After indifferent form in the early games, the first Test at Sabina Park, where four years earlier they had been annihilated in three days, was upon them. 
 West Indies had lost only one home Test in the previous decade, and had not lost in Kingston since Australia beat them in 1954&ndash;5. 
 The pitch had recently been relaid and proved itself slow but uneven. 
 When Richards won the toss he decided, after some thought, to bat, and Greenidge and Haynes were soon strolling along. 
 They had reached 62 and looked good for 200 when Greenidge played the ball to long leg and, seeing Devon Malcolm fumble his fielding, came back for a second. 
 Malcolm's throw was superb, thundering into Russell's gloves at the top of the stumps, and Greenidge was on his way. 
 And then, against tight bowling and good catching, wickets just slipped away. 
 When Richards was fifth out only 124 were on the board, and immediately after tea the innings collapsed totally. 
 In six overs Fraser took five wickets for six runs for figures of 5 for 28 off twenty overs, and West Indies were all out for 164. 
 People listening in England must have thought there was something wrong with their radios. 
 By the close, England were 80 for 2, and next day came the only big partnership of the match. 
 Lamb, dropped by Dujon on 30, played splendidly thereafter, putting on 172 for the fourth wicket with Robin Smith, reaching his tenth Test century and fifth against West Indies, and finally falling for 132. 
 The score was 288 when Smith departed for 57, and if the last wickets did not pile on the pressure they did enough to give England a lead of exactly 200. 
 It was the third day that clinched it. 
 Malcolm disposed  of Haynes with a very fast, dipping full toss, and then after Greenidge and Richardson seemed to be settling down, wickets began to go. 
 Four were down for 112 before Best and Richards took the score to 192. 
 Then Malcolm bowled Richards, and after Best fell to Small the tail soon went. 
 240 all out left England just 41 to get after the rest day. 
 Since Malcolm, a local boy, and Small, Barbados-born, each took four wickets, the joke in England was that &bquo;our West Indian bowlers are better than your West Indian bowlers&equo;. 
 During the rest day it rained. 
 That night it came down in buckets. 
 The fourth day became one of intense frustration for England as the ground staff, with little of the equipment of their English counterparts, did not fall over themselves to get play started. 
 By next morning, though, the sun was back and England could be denied no longer. 
 It took them all of the pre-lunch session to get the runs as Walsh and Bishop made life difficult, and Gooch fell just before the end; but with three balls left before lunch   
 &bquo;Our West Indian bowlers are better than your West Indian bowlers.&equo; 
 Gladstone Small, Barbados-born, had a successful tour in 1989&ndash;90. 
 Larkins drove the winning run and one of the most remarkable Test victories of all had been achieved. 
 West Indians of a literary turn of mind might have thought of W.B. Yeats: &bquo;Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold; Mere anarchy is loosed upon the world.&equo; 
 Slowly people began to realise it was not a miracle after all, but the reward for an enormous amount of hard work, planning and discipline which ensured they were the fittest and best-prepared England team ever,; a very professional approach which saw them practising endlessly; high-class line and length bowling, backed up by excellent fielding, which had the West Indian batsmen constantly under pressure; sound batsmanship to build on the bowlers' successes; and a crackling team spirit fostered by Gooch which one could not remember seeing in an England team in years. 
 As the series went on, it became clear that the players would happily follow Gooch through fire, flood, armies of tarantulas or anything else he might choose, if at the end of it there was the chance of winning a Test match. 
 For a man who always looks so morose when batting &mdash; &bquo;I know I look a miserable sod out there, but I can't help it,&equo; he once said &mdash; and whose captaincy had previously seemed rather ordinary, it was a revelation. 
 No one could have doubted that West Indies would fight back. 
 Yet England had played so well that, equally, there was no reason to think it would prove to be a flash in the pan. 
 The series was alight &mdash; only for it to be thoroughly dampened in Guyana when relentless rain washed out the second Test completely, for only the fifth time in Test history. 
 Would this mean that England had lost their momentum? 
 Not at all. 
 In Trinidad, West Indies were without Richards and were led for the first time by Desmond Haynes. 
 Gooch won an important toss, put West Indies in, and before long five wickets were down for 29. 
 Logie, however, was dropped on 17 and, with Hooper, set about a rescue. 
 But then more wickets fell, and the eighth was down for 103; only for Logie and Bishop to put on 74 for the ninth wicket, and when Logie was last man out just two short of a well-deserved hundred, the score was 199. 
 In reply, England, against a very slow over rate, scored just 146 in a slightly shortened day, with Gooch and Larkins putting on a century opening stand. 
 When they resumed on the third afternoon after time lost for rain, they lost quick wickets, and at 214 for 6 seemed to have wasted the advantage. 
 Capel and Russell dug in, though, and a total of 288 gave them a handy lead. 
 The next day belonged to Devon Malcolm, a man who came into the Test team a few months earlier against Australia with a reputation for being able to bowl extremely quickly but rarely accurately, who, with  less than perfect eyesight, was a total rabbit with the bat, and who could be a joke as a fielder. 
 After Greenidge and Haynes had put on 96 for the first wicket, Fraser had Greenidge lbw; immediately after the interval Haynes hit Malcolm's second ball for four, only for the next ball to leap up at him and give Lamb an easy catch. 
 Two balls later, Best fell lbw to a shooter, and the next ball clipped Dujon's off-stump. 
 Three wickets in four balls seemed a pretty good response to the unkind things written about Malcolm in the press. 
 Richardson and Logie steadied the ship for a while till Malcolm had Logie caught. 
 At 200 for 6, Malcolm got Moseley and Ambrose ran out Hooper, only to make amends by putting on 34 for the ninth wicket with Bishop which would prove vital. 
 First thing next morning, Malcolm had Walsh lbw, giving him 6 for 77 and match figures of 10 for 137 and leaving England all day to make 151. just before lunch they were 73 for 1 when it began to rain &mdash; hard. 
 Worse, they had lost Gooch after a ball from Moseley had reared up and struck him on the left hand, breaking a bone, although until the match was over even his team thought it was only bruised. 
 On that moment England's whole tour turned. 
 Play resumed just after four o'clock, the pitch having been sweating under the covers in the meantime, and the light decidedly dingy. 
 Stewart, who had been playing well, hammered his first ball down the throat of third man, and with West Indies taking time-wasting tactics to the extreme &mdash; 16.5 overs in around two hours &mdash; England did not really have a hope. 
 Smith and Bailey fell quickly, and when Lamb went with the score on 106 England's last realistic chance went with him. 
 It all ended in something like farce, with Capel and Russell unsure whether to press on or come off, but there were still 31 to get and the light was wretched when Gooch called them in. 
 Since there was no sparing of the short-pitched stuff, and no intervention from the umpires, to continue would probably only have resulted in an injury anyway. 
 It could be argued that had England scored faster on the second day they would have won comfortably, but having controlled the game from the beginning they were desperately unlucky to lose out to the weather; and for the fans listening at home it was especially frustrating that it was a beautiful evening in England. 
 There was also bad feeling that Haynes had resorted to &bquo;sledging&equo; Stewart to upset his concentration, and there would be more bad feeling before long. 
 Desmond Haynes' first taste of Test captaincy was not a very happy experience, going for a duck in the first innings, dropping a catch and demeaning himself with the sledging as the match slipped away. 
 It did little for the image of a man who has been part of the backbone of the  team for so long, and was playing in his eighty-seventh Test. 
 The first came in 1977&ndash;8 against Australia and he began with fifties in his first three innings, only to join the Packer brigade and miss out for a couple of years. 
 Since things returned to normal, he and Gordon Greenidge have formed the most prolific opening partnership Test cricket has known; before the series they had opened the innings over 120 times, about twice as many as any other Test first-wicket partnership, although they had produced only thirteen century partnerships. 
 Since they are both high-class batsmen this comes as quite a surprise, but looking through the records one sees that one of them has failed fairly often; their strength is that when that has happened the other has usually gone on to a big score, thereby relieving the pressure on the middle order. 
 Haynes has tended to be the less adventurous of the two and does not quite have his partner's determination to hammer the ball into a distant wall, but before the series began he had 5,340 runs at 41, with twelve centuries, to his name all the same. 
 England have usually been favoured opponents, and before the series ended he would have two more hundreds against them. 
 Both sides had injury problems during the series, West Indies missing Logie and Ambrose from the first Test, Richards and Marshall from the second, Best, Marshall and Moseley from the fourth. 
 England lost their most important batsman and bowler from the last two Tests, for apart from Gooch's broken hand Fraser pulled a rib muscle, and his accuracy was very sorely missed. 
 Allan Lamb took over the captaincy and did his best, but it soon became clear that without Gooch they were nothing like the same team. 
 Lamb had taken over the Northamptonshire leadership the previous season and had shown himself enthusiastic if inexperienced, but had then missed a good deal of the season through injury. 
 A fine attacking batsman, he had been in the England team for much of the time since making his debut in 1982, but after his four centuries in the summer of 1984 he had disappointed too often and his average scarcely reflected his ability &mdash; in 57 Tests he had made just over 3,000 runs at 34 before the tour began. 
 Always the man of action type rather than the deep thinker, he is a captain who leads by example; if he showed himself rather insensitive to the needs of his bowlers, he showed his batsmen just what to do. 
 David Smith was flown in from England as cover for Gooch, only to have his thumb badly bruised in the one-day international in Barbados and so miss the Bridgetown Test. 
 Lamb won the toss and chose to field, but although Haynes was soon dismissed there was altogether more resistance from the West Indian batsmen than before. 
 Lacking Fraser, the English attack found itself being hit around, and in the afternoon Richards  launched into Malcolm, taking 18 off one over. 
 Yet the bowler could have had him three times, two sixes just clearing the fielder and a top edge over the wicket-keeper falling harmlessly. 
 Lamb immediately took Malcolm off, which one felt Gooch would not have done, and West Indies built up their innings. 
 Richards fell on 70 but Best, on his home ground, soldiered on and was rewarded with his first Test century, going on to 164. 
 A total of 446 gave England plenty to do, and as before it was Lamb and Smith who did the bulk of the work. 
 193 for the fourth wicket, with Lamb equalling Colin Cowdrey's record of six Test centuries against West Indies, ensured a reasonable score, and 358 all out left them with a fair chance of saving the match. 
 On the fourth day, England hardly surprisingly, bowled extremely slowly in an effort to delay the declaration. 
 It was time for Haynes to enjoy himself, though and, aided by some dropped catches, he reached a century as West Indies headed for 267 for 8 declared. 
 Malcolm, incidentally, after being the man of the match in Trinidad, took 0 for 188 here, partly at least because he persisted in bowling short whereas before he had pitched the ball up. 
 The feeling was that Richards should have declared before he did as the last hour's batting produced few runs, but when England set about playing out time, Larkins, having gone first ball in the first innings, lasted only one more this time. 
 This brought in Bailey, who had recorded his own pair in Trinidad. 
 He had reached six when he played at a ball down the leg side which hit him on the thigh, with the bat some inches away, and was taken by Dujon. 
 Umpire Barker made no response to the appeal, whereupon Richards &mdash; who at slip was in precisely the wrong place to see what had happened &mdash; danced down the pitch waving his right hand frantically, giving every appearance that he was about to remonstrate forcefully with the umpire; whereupon Mr Barker raised his finger and Bailey was on his way. 
 The television replay showed clearly that Bailey had not touched the ball, and from the English point of view it was difficult to escape the feeling that Mr Barker &mdash; whose umpiring, and that of his colleagues, had been first-class, with, if anything, England getting the benefit of the doubt in several close decisions &mdash; had been pressurized into giving him out. 
 When Mr Barker heard that Christopher Martin-Jenkins had said in his radio commentary that &bquo;a very good umpire cracked under pressure&equo; he denied it and issued a writ against Martin-Jenkins for defamation. 
 As he suggested that Richards had been less than sporting, Martin-Jenkins found himself banned from the local airwaves and Public Enemy Number One in Barbados; since he is renowned as a courteous, generous-spirited chap, it  brought home to English fans just how fervently Richards is regarded in the Caribbean, although any English supporter who watched the incident on television would have been hard pushed to disagree with Martin-Jenkins's assessment of it. 
 Richards insisted he was not pressurizing the umpire but doing a celebratory dance, which seemed odd since as the umpire had not raised a finger at the time he had nothing to celebrate. 
 In the excitement after Bailey's departure, nightwatchman Small also fell, leaving England 15 for 3 overnight, Stewart and Russell at the crease. 
 The hero next day was Russell, defending for over five hours without giving a chance; not bad for a man whose entry into the Test team was delayed because he supposedly could not bat. 
 Stewart stayed with him for about an hour and a half and Lamb hung around for a while, but Smith was his main ally and, as the day ebbed away, it seemed as though only the new ball stood between England and a draw. 
 Sure enough, when Ambrose took it he did for Russell with a shooter and then disposed of the rest. 
 There was over an hour left when Malcolm came in, and had some of the others defended as well as he did the game might have been saved. 
 He survived about half that time before Ambrose got him, finishing with 8 for 45; all out 191 meant a win by 164 runs. 
 The match finished on a Tuesday. 
 On the Thursday morning another began, everyone having decamped to Antigua. 
 It was an astonishing piece of planning, especially as the Friday, being Good Friday, was the rest day. 
 In theory the teams started equal, with everything to play for &mdash; but the tide was now running West Indies' way. 
 Sure enough, after Lamb had won the toss the batsmen got in only to get out, and the innings ended on the second day for 160. 
 Greenidge, in his hundredth Test, and Haynes then produced an opening stand of 298, beating their own West Indian record by two runs. 
 On that third morning, though, it had been Haynes who led out the home team, since Richards was in the press box breathing fire at Daily Express  journalist James Lawton who had asked him for an explanation of the V-sign he had given to his own crowd. 
 His outburst, it would seem, was the culmination of much anger at press criticism of West Indian bowling, both the excessive use of bouncers and the slow over rate; but it was an astonishing way for a Test captain to behave, and he apologized to his team for not leading them out. 
 It cannot have done his concentration any good, for after the Greenidge-Haynes partnership and a knock from Richardson wickets fell rapidly, Richards being caught off Malcolm for just one. 
 All out 446 meant that England had a lot of batting to do in the last two days, and when Larkins went at the end of the third day to a ball  that he did not see in the shadows, one felt they just were not going to make it. 
 Sure enough, next day saw a procession, only Lamb and Hussain passing thirty, although Smith batted for an hour with a broken finger and it was revealed that Hussain had been playing for five weeks with a broken bone in his wrist and Lamb had a cracked elbow. 
 All the same, 154 all out gave West Indies victory by an innings and 32 runs. 
 If it was a sad end for England, they at least had the knowledge that only the weather deprived them of a draw. 
 Had Gooch not been injured who knows what would have happened in the last two games; but then, West Indies had their share of injuries, too. 
 It was also sad that no English spinner had been seen throughout the rubber, and that both sides blatantly and cynically ignored the ruling about bowling 90 overs in a day, so that play just continued until the light faded every day of the series; those two factors left many people fearful for the game's future. 
 For English fans, though, there was pleasure that their team had begun to show heart and direction and purpose, all of which had been missing since the Ashes tour of 1986&ndash;7; while West Indian fans were just happy that their heroes had shown that, after all, W.B. Yeats had got it wrong and the centre could hold. 
 The steamroller had hit a bump, but for the time being it was back on course.     
 INSTANT ENTERTAINMENT 
 A FAMILIAR STORY 
 When England won the last Test of 1973&ndash;4 the teams had met only twice in one-day internationals. 
 By the time England won another Test they had played a further thirty, plus two that were rain-restricted and one washed out altogether. 
 Not surprisingly, West Indies dominated these, winning seventeen of the first twenty-two played up to the end of 1985&ndash;6. 
 Then a curious thing happened &mdash; England suddenly began to win, with nine of the next ten meetings going their way, and even while their Test form was wretched somehow turned themselves into perhaps the best one-day side in the world. 
 The danger with this was that the longer it went on the more likely it became that both players and fans would get their priorities wrong, so that the feeling of &bquo;we may as well concentrate on what we're good at and not bother too much about Tests&equo; would become steadily more predominant. 
 There were signs, especially in 1988, that the players appeared to be trying harder in the one-day internationals than in the Tests, and the traditionalists &mdash; who of course regard themselves as the real cricket lovers &mdash; feared for the future. 
 Back in 1973 such fears would have seemed absurd. 
 The first limited-overs international, between Australia and England, had taken place only two years earlier, and the Prudential Trophy had then been introduced with great success in 1972. 
 Earlier in 1973, the matches against the New Zealanders had been rather an anti-climax to their tour, with the second spoiled by rain, but no one doubted that they were now a permanent addition to the summer. 
 West Indies had won the three-Test series 2&ndash;0, yet so far had never played a one-day international against anyone, so the balance between form and experience seemed a neat one; and so it proved. 
 The first meeting, at Leeds, was one of the most exciting. 
 West Indies made a good start and with 132 for 3 at lunch looked ready to blossom. 
 Then Willis bowled Lloyd, four more wickets fell cheaply &mdash; Sobers made a duck in his only one-day international &mdash; and the final score was 181. 
 The England selectors, having said goodbye and thank you to Illingworth, had  appointed Denness captain, and he immediately came good with a steady 66 to hold the innings together. 
 When he was out England had ten overs to score 39, with five wickets left, and by the beginning of the penultimate over needed just seven with three wickets left. 
 Then Greig went, having made 48, Hendrick followed next ball, and the last over began with four still required. 
 Sobers bowled to Willis, was clumped back over his head for two then steered to third man for two, and England were home with three balls to spare. 
 If the one-day series was then to prove one-sided for years to come, at least it got off to a good start. 
 There was something of a contrast at the Oval. 
 In good batting conditions England did not distinguish themselves as 63 from Fletcher was the only substantial knock. 
 189 was clearly nowhere near enough, and Fredericks alone accounted for 105 of the reply. 
 With Kallicharran making 53, there were only four more needed when the second wicket fell, and as there were also more than thirteen overs in hand West Indies won the Prudential Trophy on a faster run rate over the two games. 
 It had not been hard to predict that the Caribbean style of attacking play would be greatly suited to one-day cricket. 
 The joys &mdash; and the financial rewards &mdash; of the instant game had not reached the West Indies when Denness led his troops there a few months later and, as the two sides were drawn in separate groups in the 1975 World Cup, it was 1976 before they met again. 
 Tony Greig had already failed in his attempt to make the West Indies &bquo;grovel&equo;, and never looked like doing it now. 
 Indeed, in the first game at Scarborough they lost a wicket first ball and had three down for 23 before Barlow, on his first representative appearance, held the innings together with 80 not out, helping the total to 202. 
 There was one lovely freak occurrence near the end: Knott played the ball down to fine leg and Holding's throw hit the stumps with Barlow well home, whereupon he called Knott for a second run. 
 With both batsmen in the middle of the pitch, the ricochet beat Barlow to the bowler's end and broke the stumps there as well; Lloyd appealed, but umpire Jepson gave &bquo;not out&equo;. 
 When West Indies batted, Richards was soon laying into them, hammering a six and twenty fours in 119 not out. 
 No one else scored very many but no one needed to, and there were still six wickets and fourteen overs in hand when King finished things off with a six. 
 Rain caused delays at Lord's so that the match had to be carried over till Sunday, but it made no difference to Richards. 
 He fell three short of his century this time, and once again no one else got out of the twenties, but 221 still proved too much for England. 
 With six wickets going down for  62 they were never in the hunt, but Randall did his best to keep the game alive, supported by Knott and Jackman. 
 He was to have many fine one-day knocks over the years and now he hit 88; only when he was ninth out was the match definitely lost, West Indies eventually winning by 36 runs. 
 More rain at Edgbaston washed out the Bank Holiday Monday, and when the game was played on Tuesday afternoon it was limited to 32 overs. 
 West Indies duly hammered everything in sight. 
 Richards failed, but Lloyd hit 79 off 57 balls and Greenidge and Rowe made quick forties, taking the total to 223. 
 England never had a chance; Amiss, Randall and Wood scored a few, but in the end they fell 50 short. 
 Barlow followed his good first match with two ducks, but one notable thing about the game was the international debut of I.T. 
 Botham. 
 He was walloped for 31 for 1 in three overs and scored 20. 
 The next meeting was in the dramatic setting of the 1979 World Cup Final at Lord's. 
 Brearley won the toss and put West Indies in, and the England bowlers did well; the fourth wicket went down on 99 and they were clearly on top. 
 They had not yet got Richards, however, and when Collis King joined him they decided it was time to entertain the crowd. 
 With Willis having been injured in the semi-final, England had chosen to play an extra batsman, Larkins, and make up their fifth bowler by combining Gooch, Boycott and Larkins, and it proved ill-judged. 
 Probably they would have lost all the same, but another bowler might have made it much closer. 
 Richards and King put on 139 for the fifth wicket in just seventy-seven minutes, King annihilating the bowlers to the tune of three sixes and ten fours in his 86, most of them from the three part-time bowlers who conceded, by coincidence, 86 between them. 
 After King went, Richards reached his century and was on 138 not out at the close, having seen the total to 286. 
 Inevitably, he won the Man of the Match award. 
 In reply, Boycott and Brearley put on no less than 129 for the first wicket &mdash; jolly good in a Test, but they took thirty-eight overs about it, with Boycott not getting into double figures until the seventeenth over. 
 With 158 still needed from the last twenty-two overs, the later batsmen never had a chance, perishing quickly is they threw the bat. 
 Poor Larkins was one of four ducks as Garner took five for 38, and the innings subsided to 194 all out. 
 Victory by 92 runs meant that Clive Lloyd was holding aloft the Prudential World Cup for the second time. 
 A few months later, both England and West Indies were in Australia, each playing three alternating Tests against the home team to &bquo;celebrate&equo; the armistice drawn up with Kerry Packer. 
 England lost all three of their Tests and West Indies won two of theirs, but neither side liked the  arrangement of interspersing them with one-day games that were part of the new Benson and Hedges World Series Cup. 
 Switching between one-day and five-day mode was unpopular with the players, and the new showbiz-style razzmatazz that accompanied the games seemed specifically designed to cater for the drunken yobbos who turned up by the cartload. 
 The important thing, though, was that they paid their admission fee before  they became totally paralytic and abusive; that seemed to be all that really mattered. 
 The teams played four matches, spread over several weeks, against each of the others, with the top two then going through to a best-of-three final. 
 England's first game, at Sydney, was also their first under floodlights, and they won it. 
 Randall and Brearley made a good start, Gower and Willey pressed on well, and at the end of fifty overs they were on 211. 
 A brief shower reduced West Indies' target to 199 from 47 overs, and Greenidge, Rowe and Kallicharran looked to have this well under control. 
 Then the wickets went, and Croft, the last batsmen, was left needing to score three   
 Collis King &mdash; 86 in 77 minutes in the 1979 World Cup Final. 
 This was one of his three sixes. 
 Bairstow, back to the boundary &mdash; and Botham bowled him. 
 Any English people in Brisbane had rather less to get excited about. 
 England made a decent 217, with 68 from Boycott and 59 from Gower; but after Greenidge and Haynes had got half-way to the target, Richards, who had missed the first match, played as only he can. 
 The second wicket, like the first, produced 109 runs and he made 85 of them off 77 balls. 
 With Greenidge also on 85 not out, the nine-wicket win was rather comprehensive. 
 The third match at Melbourne was then completely washed out, but at Adelaide West Indies produced another drubbing. 
 Richards made another 88, Greenidge and Kallicharran got fifties and 246 was clearly going to be hard for England to beat. 
 In front of a full house they steadily disintegrated, no one passing 24 as Roberts took 5 for 22. 139 all out left West Indies 107 ahead. 
 Remarkably, however, England had won all their matches against Australia, and Australia had won three of theirs against   
 World Cup Final, 1979. 
 Richards, croft, Garner, King, Holding, Kallischarran, Lloyd, Murray and Greenidge display the silverware. 
 West Indies; England therefore finished well clear at the top of the table, with 11 points to West Indies' 7 and Australia's 6. 
 So it was back to Melbourne for the first of the final matches. 
 If England had held any one of the three catches they put down they would have won, since the three top-scoring West Indies batsmen all had a &bquo;life&equo;. 
 Greenidge was dropped on 6 and made a further 74, Kallicharran on 25 and went on to 42, and King was unbeaten on 31 after giving a chance on 5. 215 was the kind of score to promise a close finish, and Boycott, Willey and Larkins saw them well on the way. 
 The innings lost momentum when Willey and Larkins were run out in quick succession, and as the final over began 15 were still needed. 
 Brearley did his best, but four were still needed off the last ball and he could manage only a single. 
 A two-run defeat seemed set fair to demoralize England, but their batsmen did not do badly in the second game at Sydney. 
 Boycott's 63 held the innings together, Gooch and Gower got a few, Botham walloped 37 off 39 balls and 208 seemed a reasonable total on a pitch helpful to bowlers. 
 Yet Greenidge and Haynes found few problems, and when Haynes went Richards merely carried on as before. 
 He and Greenidge made 119 in 27 overs, and although Richards went near the end for 65 Greenidge remained unbeaten on 98. 
 An eight-wicket win meant that Lloyd was hoisting yet another trophy to the heavens. 
 The treadmill ground on. 
 Another few months and West Indies were back in England for a Test series that lost much of its interest to the weather. 
 The one-day games were now held before the Test series rather than after, an hors d'oeuvre  rather than a stodgy pudding served up when everyone was full, but the first game at Headingley was distinctly uninspiring. 
 In poor light and on a tricky pitch, West Indies, put in by Botham, had to work hard to reach 198, with 78 from Greenidge the major contribution and Old's figures being a remarkable 11-4-12-2. 
 Time had been lost to rain and bad light, and by the close England had struggled to 35 for 3; next morning, the conditions were better and Tavar&eacute;, on his international debut, reached 82 not out. 
 The problem was that no one stayed with him, and England subsided to 174 all out. 
 By contrast, Lord's was actually blessed with sunshine. 
 Botham again put them in and all the bowlers did well &mdash; except him. 
 Being carted for 71 off his eleven overs allowed West Indies to reach 235, with most of the batsmen making a useful score. 
 Boycott and Willey opened with 135 off 33 overs, but then the wickets clattered. 
 It was Botham who redeemed his poor bowling and got the crowd going with 42 not out, hitting the winning four off the third ball of the last over. 
 This was one of only two  occasions Botham tasted victory as England captain, the other being in a one-day game against Australia a year later, and each time he was there at the death. 
 West Indies still won the Prudential Trophy on the faster run rate. 
 At this period the players must have been getting sick of the sight of each other, for just another few months and England were playing their first one-day games in the West Indies. 
 The opening encounter took them to the small island of St Vincent, where the pitch was some way from international standard. 
 The home team were without Richards but fielded a young man named Everton Mattis who, on representative debut, accomplished a rare feat: his 62 was more than all the other batsmen put together and, since Haynes got 34, it will be seen that the others had a collective off-day par excellence . 
 A target of 128 should not have been beyond England, but four wickets went down for 15 and it was left to Gower and Botham to make a game of it. 
 When Botham was eighth out the score was 114 and there were more than five overs left. 
 Emburey and Stevenson nudged their singles, but Holding had the last word. 
 He bowled Emburey at 123, and Old two runs later. 
 It was the third time in eight games that the margin of victory had been just two runs. 
 The second one-day game in Guyana was played against a background of uncertainty over whether Robin Jackman was about to be asked to vacate the premises. 
 England simply never got going. 
 Only three batsmen got past twenty and none got to thirty, and a total of 137 was clearly a waste of everyone's time. 
 Greenidge and Richards went cheaply, but only two more wickets were lost in strolling to victory. 
 Jackman did not play in the match, but no sooner was it over than official statements were buzzing, and cricket was staggering through yet another crisis. 
 Happily there was now a break of over three years. 
 Yet little had changed: Richards was still executioner-in-chief and England still seemed mesmerized at the prospect of playing the world champions. 
 By 1984, the Prudential Trophy had metamorphosed into the Texaco Trophy, and the first game at Old Trafford contained the finest dish ever served up in a one-day international. 
 Lloyd won the toss and decided to bat, only to see seven wickets crumble for 102. 
 Richards was not among them. 
 Baptiste kept him company for a while as he blazed away, but when the ninth wicket fell with the score on 166 and fourteen overs still unused, it seemed that his effort would be in vain. 
 Holding, though, stood firm, his share of an unbeaten last wicket stand being 12. 
 Richards's share was rather larger, 93 to be precise, the fourteen overs yielding 106 runs as Richards hammered 21  fours and five sixes &mdash; one of them out of the ground &mdash; in all, for 189 not out off 170 balls. 
 He might have been stumped on 44 but that was the only chance he gave. 
 It was one of the truly marvellous innings, one that no one who saw it could ever forget; since it has been shown on television virtually every time rain has stopped play in any match since, it would be almost impossible to have forgotten it anyway. 
 Faced with a total of 272, England were simply demoralized. 
 Lamb made 75 but there was little from anyone else, and the tourists won by 104 runs. 
 At Trent Bridge, the first part of the story was the same except for one detail &mdash; Richards went for just three. 
 Lloyd made 52 but the rest of the batting disappointed, and, with rain reducing the game to fifty overs each, West Indies managed only 179. 
 Fowler and Andy Lloyd made a good start, Gower chipped in well, and the rest of the batsmen did enough to see England home by three wickets. 
 They hardly looked ready to slug it out in a Test series, but at least they had a victory under their belts. 
 Any euphoria this produced was very short-lived. 
 At Lord's, Fowler and Lloyd and Gower again made some runs, but it took thirty Extras to help their total to 196. 
 Their only chance was to get Richards cheaply; instead he made 84 not out off 65 balls, and, with Gomes also getting fifty, the margin was eight wickets. 
 Another trophy for Clive Lloyd's collection. 
 During 1985&ndash;6 in the Caribbean the script-writer was still West Indian. 
 The centre-piece of the first mini-drama in Kingston was Mike Gatting's  exploding nose as he missed an attempted hook off Marshall. 
 Psychologically this did England no good at all, of course, and the batsmen struggled to 145 off 46 overs, the reduction in the number of overs caused by West Indies bowling so slowly. 
 If any sweat was lost in reaching this target it was not noticeable, and a six-wicket win was duly recorded. 
 Another victory draws near. 
 Gower is caught by wicket-keeper Dujon off Roger Harper at Headingley 1984. 
 Lloyd, Greenidge and Richards close in. 
 Yet after being annihilated in the first Test, England showed they could still fight. 
 The one-day game in Trinidad was, according to Wisden  &bquo;described by many as the best one-day international played in the West Indies&equo;, and England won it off the final ball. 
 Rain reduced it to 37 overs a side and the home team were soon rattling along. 
 Haynes made 53 and Richardson finished unbeaten on 79, but once again it was Richards who dominated. 
 Off just 39 balls he made 82 astonishing runs, and the innings closed on 229, setting England a run rate of 6.2 an over. 
 It proved to be Gooch's day; with Slack he put on 89 for the second wicket in seventeen overs, setting the foundations for the later onslaught. 
 Yet his partners contributed relatively little as the runs were steadily knocked off and his century was passed; come the last over and nine were needed, and it was a leg-bye off the final delivery that earned England their win. 
 Gooch finished on 129 not out, made without a chance, a superb innings. 
 Three days later in the Test he was out fourth ball. 
 Barbados enjoyed no such entertainment. 
 Gower put West Indies in and watched them score 249 in 46 overs, thanks in part to a very fast outfield. 
 Richards was missed when 5 and went on to 62, the same score as Richardson, with all the batsmen making useful contributions. 
 When England batted, Gooch was given out caught behind and it seemed to dispirit his team-mates; without their hero of the previous game they looked lost, and folded for 114 all out. 
 At least the crowd went home happy. 
 Wisden  had some strong words to say about the fourth game, back in Trinidad: &bquo;England put up a performance which exposed to the crowd of 21,000 what depths of incompetence they had reached&hellip; after two days off following the Test defeat, the first practice was made optional &mdash; and Gower himself was one of the six who failed to attend.&equo; 
 They made 165 from their 47 overs, with Robinson top-scoring on 55, and Haynes, Richardson and Richards had no trouble in knocking off the runs for the loss of two wickets. 
 &bquo;England's batting, fielding and &mdash; apart from Emburey and Edmonds &mdash; their bowling proclaimed the lack of practice and resolve on a slow pitch which, had they been in the right frame of mind, would have given them an even chance of levelling the series,&equo; asserted Wisden . 
 In one-day matches England were now just about at rock bottom; within a year they were very much on top.  
 THE MOTHERLAND STRIKES BACK 
 Mike Gatting has proved himself an excellent one-day captain, winning several trophies with Middlesex during the 1980s. 
 He was soon bringing his skills to bear for his country, too, especially in Australia in 1986&ndash;7. 
 Not content with just the interminable Benson and Hedges World Series Cup, the players also had to fit in the Benson and Hedges Challenge between the fourth and fifth Tests, a jamboree dreamed up to latch on to the sporting frenzy which the TV and marketing people had decreed would seize the nation when the America's Cup yacht races were staged off Fremantle. 
 At least there was no travelling as all the games were played in Perth. 
 Australia, England, West Indies and Pakistan would play each other mercifully just once, and the two top teams would then meet in a final. 
 Since Gatting and his troops had retained the Ashes just a few days beforehand, they were ready to take on all comers. 
 By the time they played West Indies, they had already beaten Australia and West Indies had lost to Pakistan. 
 England were put in and saw half their wickets fall for 96 in half their overs before they were rescued by 71 from Lamb and 50 from Jack Richards, with the spinners chipping in as well. 
 228 looked better when three West Indian wickets went for 51 and better still when Richards was caught. 
 Logie and Dujon were steering the game their way when Dujon was bowled as he stepped back for a cover drive, and that was the turning point. 
 The rest of the wickets slipped away, 209 all out gave England a win by 19 runs and, as Pakistan had already beaten Australia, ensured that the final would be between them and England. 
 Good, tight bowling enabled England to do this comfortably, giving them their second trophy in ten days. 
 There was just time for England and Australia to fit in the final Test before getting on with the serious business &mdash; serious to those for whom dollar signs are important &mdash; of dashing round the country playing game after game after game of the Benson and Hedges World Series Cup. 
 Just two days after losing the splendid fifth Test in Sydney, England were in Brisbane playing West Indies, and beating them convincingly. 
 Moisture in the pitch made the toss an important one, and when Gatting won it the bowlers did their stuff beautifully. 
 Only Haynes and Logie put up much resistance and 154 all out, with conditions improving all the time, presented England with few problems; had the situation been reversed, one knew that West Indies would have won by eight or nine wickets, but English fans were happy enough to have six still in hand.  
 The itinerary for this competition appeared to have been worked out with the sole aim of maximizing the profit of the air operators who did the transporting. 
 Australia, for instance, having finished the Test in Sydney on 15 January, played in Brisbane on 18 January, Melbourne on 20 January, Sydney on 22 January, Adelaide on 25 and 26 January, Sydney on 28 January and so on. 
 By any stretch of anyone's imagination it was insane and, coming at the end of a tough Test series, it was extremely tiring for the players. 
 England's second encounter with West Indies was at Adelaide, where they were given a good start of 121 by Broad and Athey. 
 They capitalized on this well enough by reaching 252 in their fifty overs, and then took two quick wickets when West Indies batted. 
 In good batting conditions, the English bowlers performed well, and with some good catches being held the innings never really threatened. 
 When Emburey went through the lower order with four wickets in thirteen balls, England were left winners by 89 runs. 
 Never before had England beaten West Indies in two consecutive one-day games, let alone three, and West Indies went into the next match at Melbourne, clearly determined that it would not be four. 
 On an uneven pitch, English wickets were soon tumbling, Broad not helping the cause by running out Lamb. 
 Only 34 from Emburey gave the bowlers any sort of target to defend, although 147 was obviously nothing like enough. 
 De Freitas and Small were extremely economical and there were only nine balls left when the total was passed, but with Richards on song &mdash; and becoming the first man to score 5,000 runs in one-day internationals &mdash; only four wickets went down. 
 That was as far as their success went, though. 
 The pitch at Devonport was of more interest to bowlers than batsmen, and only a steady 76 from Broad, with some support from Lamb, gave England a reasonable total of 177. 
 Normally that should present no problem to the team batting second, but none of them could dominate the bowling and the low total seemed to spur England to some brilliant fielding; when Botham got Gomes and Richards in successive overs, the game moved England's way, and the rest of the wickets drifted away for a total of just 148. 
 Wisden  records that &bquo;on five of the eight occasions on which Gatting changed the bowling, the man brought on took a wicket in the first over of his spell&equo;. 
 Such inspiration on the captain's part was to help him towards an OBE, for with England then beating Australia in the first two games of the final, their clean sweep of three trophies out of three was accomplished. 
 Gatting made the point that they had to win the final two games as after so much cricket they simply did not have the strength left for a third. 
 It was the most successful tour  England had ever made, all the more satisfying as it began with them being written off as a bunch of no-hopers. 
 Later the same year, the teams were again in opposition in the 1987 Reliance World Cup staged in India and Pakistan. 
 Drawn in the same group, they had to play each other twice, and the first game at Gujranwala produced a memorable finish. 
 The last ten overs of each innings saw over 90 runs scored; West Indies batted first and had made 151 for four from forty overs when Logie and Dujon, and then Harper, swung the bat. 
 243 looked a useful score from fifty overs. 
 England began slowly, and then as Gatting and Gooch were accelerating they both fell in quick succession. 
 Before much longer two more wickets had gone, with the score on 131 for 6 and the game seemingly lost. 
 But Lamb was still there, and with Emburey and then DeFreitas swinging merrily he brought England back in contention. 
 With three overs left 35 were still needed; Walsh was duly hammered for 16, all but one to Lamb, but the penultimate over from Patterson yielded only six. 
 That left 13 from the last; Lamb struck a two and a four, and then Walsh sent down a dreadful ball that shot through for four leg-side wides. 
 Now thoroughly rattled, he bowled a no-ball, from which Lamb curiously took a single and so lost the strike; but when Walsh now sent down a full toss, Foster gleefully walloped it to the rope and England had won. 
 A week later, poor Walsh was involved in another traumatic final over as Pakistan despatched him for 14 to win off the final ball. 
 With Pakistan making the running in the group, the second England-West Indies game was crucial as it virtually assured the winners of a semi-final place. 
 Having put England in, West Indies then bowled poorly and after 30 overs England were happily placed at 131 for 2. 
 It was captain Richards who put the brakes on with some neat off-spin, only for the last ten overs to realize another 83. 
 Gooch was chief hero with 92 and Lamb again showed what a good one-day player he is, but 22 of the total of 269 were wides that West Indies could ill afford. 
 With West Indies on 147 for 2 and Richards and Richardson in full flow, the game had West Indies' name on it; Richards, with 51 from as many balls, had already struck Hemmings for two sixes, but now the Notts man flighted in a superb ball that deceived him completely and took his off-stump. 
 It proved the turning-point. 
 Hemmings took a catch to dismiss Logie, who was beginning to look dangerous, and then the wickets slithered away &mdash; including Harper run out by a fine throw from Hemmings, who was having a wonderful time. 
 Richardson made 93, but with the last six wickets going for just 30 West Indies were all out 235, leaving England winners by 34  runs. 
 They duly disposed of India in the semi-final, only to lose to Australia in a game they should have won. 
 It was a good six months before they had to meet again, this time in the Texaco Trophy matches in England. 
 The home selectors had been ridiculed in the press for the squad they chose, and it hardly seemed a match for the mighty West Indies; yet by steady bowling and sound batting, England won all three games convincingly, and chemists did a good trade in indigestion tablets as much humble pie had to be eaten. 
 They won by applying themselves to the job in hand and, if they had continued to do the same in the Tests, it might have been an interesting summer. 
 At Edgbaston, West Indies got off to a good start as the first wicket produced 34 runs in just six overs, but three fell cheaply and it was left to Logie and Hooper to make fifty apiece and give the innings its backbone. 
 But, on a slow wicket, their partnership of 97 used up 29 overs, and 217 off 55 overs did not look enough. 
 After a sound start from Gooch and Broad, England's response belonged primarily to Gatting, and his 82 not out saw his team home with six wickets in hand. 
 The Headingley game was played on an uneven pitch that made batting difficult. 
 West Indies bowled better this time and at 83 for 5 had England in trouble, with only Gooch having looked confident. 
 Then Richards chose to bowl himself and Simmons (who had begun with two quick wickets) for a long spell and England were let off the hook, Pringle and Downton putting on 66 in thirteen overs. 
 The total reached -186, and West Indies never threatened it. 
 In the face of excellent bowling, wickets fell steadily, and with 31 from Richards the top score they were all out for 139, giving England a 47-run victory. 
 It was their first series win against West Indies in England. 
 The pattern of the Lord's match was similar to the first one. 
 Rain and bad light brought several interruptions, made batting difficult, and took the game into a second day. 
 With West Indies 125 for 6 off fifty overs at the close of the first day, things looked good for England, but next morning Marshall and Dujon threw the bat and took the total to 178, which in the conditions was not that bad. 
 But England only had to bat steadily and they were home, and Gooch, Broad, Gatting and Lamb did just that. 
 Walsh set a record for the most economical bowling in a one-day international between Test-playing countries with just eleven runs off eleven overs, but 21 no-balls and wides sent down by his chums did not help the struggle, especially as Gooch was &bquo;out&equo; twice to no-balls. 
 There were seven wickets and five overs in hand when victory was completed, the word &bquo;whitewash&equo; being gleefully bandied about. 
 Gatting in particular had had a good series, batting well and leading the team excellently; with the first  Test then drawn under his leadership, how different the rest of the summer might have been had he not invited the famous barmaid to his room. 
 England's resurgence could not last. 
 In 1989&ndash;90, while the Test series was producing surprises, the one-day games reverted to type. 
 The first two at Port-of-Spain were spoiled by the weather; in the opening one, West Indies had made 208 and England 26 for 1 when the rain came, while the second got no further than West Indies being 13 without loss. 
 At Kingston, though, after England had won the Test, there was plenty of excitement. 
 England batted first and, thanks mainly to Lamb and Smith, reached 214. 
 Yet the bowlers defended well, and only Richardson mastered them so that the closing overs were tense. 
 Richardson reached his century during which three hard chances were missed, and from Fraser's final ball Bishop needed two to win on fewer wickets lost. 
 He swung it to the extra-cover boundary and Sabina Park, where everyone had been generous in Test defeat, could not have celebrated more had the World Cup been won. 
 In Georgetown, things were more one-sided. 
 On a good pitch, England struggled after Gooch and Larkins had made a solid start, and 188 for 8 was disappointing. 
 When Haynes and Best put on 113 for the first wicket it all became academic, the main interest being whether Best would get his hundred. 
 He did, but ran himself out trying to make it 101; still a six-wicket victory all the same. 
 In Barbados, with Haynes leading West Indies and England led by Lamb, England repeated their Kingston score of 214, though off only 38 overs after morning rain. 
 As so often on this tour, Rubin Smith and Lamb were the main architects, both playing aggressively after David Smith, flown out to replace the injured Gooch, had hung around for some time to get accustomed to the conditions only to get a bruised thumb in the process. 
 When Haynes and Richards on played even more aggressively, and then Best joined in again, the game was heading West Indies' way; falling wickets slowed things down, though, and in the and the target was reached with three balls and four wickets to spare. 
 3&ndash;0 to West Indies set the tour back on its path towards normality after the Test aberrations in Jamaica and Trinidad.   
 SIR FRANK 
 Of all the wonderful cricketers to come from the West Indies, it is fair to say that five have been of outstanding importance. 
 George Headley and Learie Constantine were the giants of the early Test years who did most to establish the team; Garfield Sobers was for twenty years the supreme all-rounder of the game's history; Clive Lloyd devised the concept of a quartet of pace bowlers who would carry all relentlessly before them. 
 Few would argue, though, that the most important person in the history of West Indies cricket was Frank Worrell, for as the first regular black captain it was he who united all the old discordant factions and created one of the most glorious of teams. 
 He is the central, pivotal figure in the story. 
 Because of his death, aged just forty-two, he is also thought of as a tragic figure, a man who was unable to fulfil the important public service to his people that seemed to be his destiny. 
 It is easy to let this feeling of tragedy overshadow his story, but that would be wrong. 
 He must be celebrated as a superb cricketer and one of the great captains. 
 He was born in Barbados on 1 August 1924 into a middle-class family, at a time when class boundaries on the island, having been modelled on the English system, were very rigid. 
 His parents, brother and sister emigrated to the United States when he was a youngster and he was brought up by his grandmother, and it was only the lack of cricket in America which later deterred him from joining them. 
 Because of the better opportunities in the States emigration from the West Indies was common at this time, and one cannot help wondering how many more outstanding players might have graced their cricket had their parents not left. 
 By the age of thirteen, Worrell's ability was obvious and, still in short trousers, he was playing top-grade cricket in his school first team, modelling himself on Derek Sealy, who was one of his masters. 
 Yet he was hardly a budding saint and his success made him unpopular with both masters and boys. 
 He was regarded as a &bquo;big-head&equo;, he played truant, got into trouble for telling a lie, and was lectured by the headmaster in front of the whole school because of the complaints there had been about him. 
 He said this was the worst moment of his life, and the various carpetings he received ultimately  had their effect; years later the memory of them would have a deep effect on his attitude to captaincy. 
 Worrell must be understood against his political background. 
 Barbados was British through and through, and one of his friends said of him many years later: &bquo;He was as English as can be. 
 He always admired the culture, manners and civilization of the better type of Englishman.&equo; 
 The class system was inflexible, though, and the white upper classes held the power, both economic and political. 
 The black middle classes were allowed to become professional people &mdash; doctors, lawyers, civil servants, etc. &mdash; but that was their limit. 
 This created the problem that their English-style education taught them liberal principles, while the system then denied them that same liberal advancement to the higher echelons of power and social prestige. 
 This was more or less the case throughout the West Indies, although attitudes in Barbados were undoubtedly narrower than elsewhere. 
 It was a system that could not endure, and agitations for  greater democracy grew steadily louder. 
 As Worrell's career came at the same period, the stature he acquired both as a man and a leader gave added impetus and credibility to the black independence movement, especially as cricket is such an important part of Caribbean life. 
 Sir Frank Worrell &mdash; his captaincy touched even greater heights than his batsmanship. 
 Early in his career he was thought of primarily as a left-arm spinner, and made his debut for Barbados in 1941&ndash;2 as such. 
 The following season he made 64 not out as nightwatchman against Trinidad, was moved up the order in the second innings, and responded with 188; a year later, in 1943&ndash;4, also against Trinidad, he and John Goddard put on an undefeated 502 for the fourth wicket, at the time the third highest partnership in first-class cricket. 
 Worrell's share was 308, which remained his highest score. 
 Two more years and, in company with Walcott, he would have the first-class record outright, putting on an unbeaten 574 for the fourth wicket in Port-of-Spain, his contribution this time being 255. 
 The record was beaten just a year later, but Worrell is still the only batsman to share in two partnerships of over 500 runs in first-class cricket. 
 By now, though, he was tired of Barbados, particularly its narrowness of spirit; they expressed their appreciation of his runs by refusing to allow him, as a black man, to practise at Kensington Oval, and he believed there were still those who resented his success and thought him the same &bquo;bighead&equo; as at school. 
 In some quarters, of course, he was enormously popular, and it may have been that as a young man in his early twenties he found it difficult to cope with the adulation of the fans. 
 For various reasons, therefore, he moved to Jamaica and, although he returned to Barbados many times, it was never with any great enthusiasm for the place. 
 Ultimately, he came to realize that this persecution complex existed only in his own mind, and that his unpopularity in Barbados arose from his walking out on them. 
 Remarkably, even after he became captain of the Test team, he was booed when he went out to bat at Bridgetown. 
 Test call-up came during England's 1947&ndash;8 tour. 
 He was chosen for the first match but had to drop out with food poisoning. 
 In the second Test at Port-of-Spain, he duly became the third &bquo;W&equo;, Weekes and Walcott having already made their debuts, and scored 97 and 28 not out. 
 He also showed his inexperience by asking Gerry Gomez, his captain, if he could be substituted so that he could go to the airport to meet his sister. 
 He was duly reprimanded for his arrogance, providing him years later with another memory that would help make him a sympathetic captain. 
 The first century was not long delayed, 131 not out in the third Test helping his team to a seven-wicket win, and he ended his first Test series with an average of 147. 
 Obviously, he was now quite a celebrity, and in 1948 was signed up  by Radcliffe in the Central Lancashire League; he stayed with them until the end of 1952, set batting records which have never been beaten, even by Sobers, and was hugely popular, for his personal qualities as much as his cricketing skills. 
 Around this time he was a heavy drinker although, as a conscientious professional, he did not let it affect his game. 
 In the West Indies the incident of wanting to go to the airport, and the fact that he turned up late for matches a number of times, had gained him a reputation for lack of discipline. 
 The next upset came when he was chosen for the 1948&ndash;9 tour of India but asked, as a professional, to be paid &pound;250; the WICBC refused, Worrell declined to back down, and he did not go. 
 He felt that, with a wife and child to support, he should be paid what he was worth, and he made it clear that he was not prepared to give in when he thought he had a good case. 
 It was not the last argument he would have with the authorities over pay, though this was the only series he missed for that reason. 
 (By contrast, he was very generous to people  who had less than he did, and often gave away money and cricket equipment.) 
 He was delighted, therefore, when the following year he was invited to join a Commonwealth team touring India; feeling he had a point to prove he made plenty of runs, and was invited on two similar tours in the coming years. 
 On the second of these, the captain, Leslie Ames, was injured for much of the time and Worrell was appointed his deputy. 
 He took to it like the proverbial fish to water. 
 The unique phenomenon of the three Ws. 
 Left to right: Frank Worrell, Clyde Walcott, Everton Weekes. 
 Just what is it about Barbados that produces so many wonderful cricketers? 
 The triumphant tour of England in 1950 saw Worrell way out on top of the averages, scoring 539 runs in four matches at almost 90, and making his highest Test score of 261 at Nottingham. 
 He played in six series against England and only in the last, in 1963, did he fail with the bat; other big scores included 191 not out, again at Nottingham, carrying his bat to help save the third Test of 1957, and 197 not out at Barbados in the first match of 1959&ndash;60 again to ensure a draw after a big England  innings. 
 This latter was, at 682 minutes, the longest Test innings ever played for West Indies, and he had become so becalmed towards the end that his captain declared before he reached his double century. 
 His overall average against England is a splendid 54.97, with almost 2,000 runs scored in 25 games; before the last series he was even averaging 63, although he was never one to get too bothered about statistics. 
 That last series cost him a Test average over 50 as he dipped to 49.49, finishing with 3,860 runs from his 51 Tests, with nine centuries. 
 Six feet (1.8 metres) tall, slim and athletic, his right-handed batting was less ferocious than that of Walcott and Weekes, relying on superb timing and balance, lightning footwork and an uncanny judgement of where the ball was going to pitch. 
 His coaching had been minimal, but all his strokes came from the textbook and he was never once known to play across the line. 
 His glory was the late cut, rated by C.L.R. James as &bquo;one of the great strokes of our time&equo;, but apart from the hook, which he did not play, all the other strokes were there, elegant, graceful, polished, a joy to watch. 
 He was also the most relaxed of batsmen, often having been asleep in the dressing-room before going out to the middle. 
 Worrell's grace captured against Warwickshire in 1950. 
 Hafeez Kardar at gully watches Fred Gardner miss the ball as Worrell scores off the bowling of Charlie Grove. 
 Don Taylor of New Zealand is at silly mid-on. 
 Having begun as a left-arm spinner he turned himself into a fast-medium bowler who frequently took the new ball and who at times could be decidedly nippy. 
 In reality, he was more of a third seamer than a strike bowler, and did the job only in the absence of a faster man, but he once took 6 for 38 in Australia and at Leeds in 1957 had his best Test figures of 7 for 70. 
 His 69 Test wickets cost 38.72 each, and against England he took 28 wickets at 43 &mdash; expensive, but good enough to put him high on the list of all-rounders. 
 He was also a first-class close fielder, especially in the gully or at short leg, with 43 Test catches to his name. 
 In October 1956, Worrell joined Manchester University as a mature student to read for a BA in Economics, changing in his second year to a BA Administration, which included social anthropology. 
 According to his professor, he was thorough and conscientious rather than brilliant, taking his studies very seriously since he wanted both to improve himself and gain a qualification for when he finished playing. 
 It was during his second year at Manchester that he was offered the West Indies captaincy for the visit by Pakistan, but decided that his studies had to come first; he had a strong sense of predestination and apparently felt that the leadership would be his eventually. 
 Completing his degree would ensure that he was better equipped to do the job, especially as by studying social anthropology he would be better able to understand his players. 
 Yet had the visitors been England or Australia he may well not have been able to resist the  temptation, and this was only partly because they were the leading lights in world cricket; there was also the racial aspect, in that he passionately wanted to prove that a team of black players led by a black captain was the equal of, if not better than, the white teams. 
 No doubt it is difficult for young people now to appreciate the complexities and the rigidities of the social structure in colonial days. 
 Looking back, it seems remarkable that only in the 1950s did white people come to accept &mdash; grudgingly for the most part &mdash; that black people did not need white people in positions of authority to lead and guide them. 
 The situation changed steadily during the 1950s as more and more black men came to high office, and naturally the West Indian people could see no reason why the same should not happen on the cricket field. 
 Worrell had been vice-captain against England in 1953&ndash;4, but when Australia toured a year later the selectors' feet, apparently, had turned cold; Denis Atkinson, who had little captaincy experience, was made Stollmeyer's deputy, and as Stollmeyer then missed three Tests through injury, found himself pitched in at the deep end. 
 There was little support for the white captain among the black players and the series was disaster. 
 Yet a year later Atkinson was appointed again &mdash; with another white man, Bruce Pairaudeau, as his deputy &mdash; to take the team to New Zealand. 
 Worrell did not go on that tour, but when West Indies went to England in 1957 under Goddard he was annoyed that the vice-captaincy went to Clyde Walcott; Worrell and Walcott, while friends, were never all that close, in fact, whereas Worrell and Weekes were. 
 When Worrell declined the captaincy after the 1957 tour, it was given to Gerry Alexander and the series against Pakistan was well won. 
 A year later, as Worrell was still at university, Alexander was appointed to take the team to India and Pakistan, winning the first series but losing the second. 
 One problem during the tour had centred on the young fast bowler Roy Gilchrist, who had been sent home from India for disciplinary reasons; after the tour, opinion was divided as to whether his misdemeanours should mean the end of his Test career or whether he should be helped back into the fold by someone such as Worrell, whom he worshipped. 
 In the end, the WICBC's attitude that they could not accept any individual who did not uphold their tradition of sportsmanship prevailed, and Gilchrist played no more Tests. 
 So far, with Worrell having turned down the chance, no one had been able to complain about the captaincy; but by now Worrell had his degree, was very much available, and Alexander himself expected him to be made captain for the tour by England in 1959&ndash;60. 
 Instead, Alexander was reappointed. 
 Perhaps it was a show of  support for his disciplining of Gilchrist; perhaps there was the feeling that Worrell had drifted away from the hub of West Indies cricket; or perhaps once again the selectors simply could not bring themselves to appoint a black man. 
 The belief that Worrell should have been appointed was extremely strong throughout the Caribbean, and it found its expression through C.L.R. James, then editor of the Trinidad newspaper The Nation . 
 He ran a relentless campaign based on the argument that &bquo;there was not the slightest shadow of justification for Alexander to be captain of a side in which Frank Worrell was playing&equo;. 
 He concentrated on the cricketing angle rather than the racial one, emphasizing Worrell's greater experience and status and highlighting the errors of judgement he felt Alexander had made. 
 He conceded that it was hard on Alexander, and later came to respect him greatly for the way in which he gave Worrell his fullest support as vice-captain. 
 When the WICBC met to discuss the captaincy for the visit to Australia in 1960&ndash;1, it was Alexander himself who pressed Worrell's claims, and in due course the announcement was made that Worrell would lead the team. 
 Everyone, it seemed, joined in the celebrations. 
 That tour has, of course, gone down as the most exciting series of the century. 
 After the drama of the tied first Test, Australia won the second by seven wickets and West Indies the third by 222 runs; as the fourth neared its close, West Indies appeared to have the game in their hands, only for the last Australian pair to survive for an hour and forty minutes and earn a draw; and the final Test was won by Australia with just two wickets left. 
 Cricket in Australia had been declining in popularity for some years, not helped by an abject England team two seasons before, and the excitement that West Indies generated by their enterprising play was unbounded, culminating in a vast ticker-tape send-off when the tour was over. 
 Naturally, Richie Benaud and the home players took their full share of the credit, but it was Worrell who was hero number one. 
 What was it about his captaincy, then, that was so special? 
 For one thing, he was lucky to have some outstanding players under him, and fortunate, too, in the Board's choice of manager for the tour. 
 He had grown close to Gerry Gomez since the day he had asked if he could meet his sister at the airport, and they now worked together admirably. 
 Good public relations were made a priority, so that the atmosphere surrounding the team was always cordial, which obviously had a beneficial effect on the players. 
 He was determined to be thorough in his preparations, and made sure there were plenty of games before the Tests began so that the players could get used to the conditions. 
 He also made sure that  all players were kept informed of decisions about team selection, which had not always happened before. 
 At team meetings anyone was welcome to have his say, thereby building cohesion and a feeling that everyone belonged to the unit. 
 Discussion was encouraged as much as possible, and from this he learned much about each man. 
 Younger players in particular were looked after, since not knowing the ropes on a tour has blighted more than one career. 
 He watched over his players and made sure they knew he was doing so. 
 He looked carefully for antagonisms and smoothed them out as unobtrusively as possible. 
 He was a strict disciplinarian whose word was law and, while players could argue with his views and put their own ideas to him freely, he would tolerate no arguing with umpires; when Sobers once disputed an lbw decision he was reprimanded in front of the team. 
 At the same time, he took great trouble over the team's welfare, even to the extent of helping them when they signed their contracts. 
 In other words, he combined paternalism, very careful attention to detail, and the traditional values of the English public school. 
 His players respected and loved him as a result. 
 They respected him, too, of course, as one of the greatest players since the war, and knew that, as a top-flight batsman and a bowler who could be both slow and fast-medium, he would not be asking them to do things he had not already achieved himself. 
 He was aware that a captain with a record such as his has a big advantage, since any troops will respond better to a leader they know has been through the fire himself, and so he knew just what he could ask of his bowlers. 
 For the most part, the fast men were used in short bursts to conserve their strength and responded well to this; but when the occasion demanded, as on the final day at Lord's in 1963, they could keep going for hour after hour just because the captain asked them to. 
 Hall said afterwards that he had not realized himself capable of such sustained accurate bowling, but kept at it simply because Worrell wanted him to; he also said that he was physically and mentally shattered at the end of it. 
 Similarly, in the Oval Test, Sobers put in a prodigious spell of bowling, keeping at it because his captain felt he was the right bowler for the situation. 
 Worrell had achieved any captain's dream of knowing that his players would give their last drop of sweat just for him. 
 After so many years, there was little about the game that he did not know, and tactically he was a highly skilled operator who, his players knew, would stay calm in a crisis. 
 Undoubtedly, he was a conservative captain rather than an adventurous one &mdash; James records that Worrell once said to him &bquo;In cricket you leave well alone&equo;, which, James felt, went deep  into his method as a captain &mdash; but, for all that, he was not afraid of making changes if he felt they were needed. 
 A famous one was dropping Ramadhin before the third Test in Australia and replacing him with Gibbs, whose Test career thus far had been fairly ordinary; Gibbs took eight wickets in the match to see his team home and was under way as a real Test bowler. 
 James gives an account of one of these wickets which shows Worrell's tactical ability. 
 Chasing 464 in the last innings, O'Neill and Harvey were approaching 200 and looking good. 
 Harvey, though, was suffering from a pulled muscle in his right leg, which Worrell knew could be a handicap against spinners. 
 He therefore brought Sobers close in at cover and told Gibbs to flight the ball at Harvey. 
 Gibbs did so and Harvey went out to drive, but with his injured leg could not get to the pitch and holed out to Sobers. 
 That was the third wicket down; fifty runs later the match was over, Gibbs having taken 5 for 66. 
 When he returned from the tour of Australia, Worrell was offered the position of Warden at Irvine Hall, part of the University of the West Indies in Kingston. 
 This involved helping students with their problems, welfare administration, some tutoring and, in particular, helping in the promotion of sport in the university. 
 It was strange for him at first but he soon came to enjoy it and did his best to improve the sporting standards and attitudes. 
 Soon after this, his name was put forward for the Jamaican Senate and he became a member, but although he attended regularly it was not something he took to. 
 He was altogether too dignified and courteous for the rough and tumble of politics, was not a good debater, and left after less than eighteen months. 
 In 1964, he moved to Trinidad to become Dean of Students, which was a promotion, at the UWI campus there, continuing the work he had begun in Kingston by stressing to the students the importance of discipline, physical fitness, responsibility and such like &mdash; in other words, all the values that had made him such a successful captain. 
 A year after the Australian tour, India visited West Indies and were annihilated, not helped by losing their captain, Contractor, whose skull was fractured by a ball from Griffith in the match before the third Test. 
 Worrell averaged 83 with the bat, leading his team to only the fourth 5&ndash;0 clean sweep in Test history. 
 If it was sad that in England in 1963 his form finally drifted away, he did at least give his last fine Test innings, an unbeaten 74, to the Manchester crowd, a happy choice of venue in view of his connection with Radcliffe and the university. 
 By the end of the tour, his captaincy record was, out of fifteen Tests, nine victories and three defeats, outstanding by any yardstick. 
 In Australia, he had rejuvenated a sport that had been declining for years; in England, he did exactly the same, leaving  people exhilarated by his team's play wherever they went and creating a great new surge of interest in the game. 
 The adulation when it was all over was something that had hardly been seen before in England, even on momentous Ashes-winning occasions, and early in 1964 his efforts were rewarded with a knighthood, conferred by the Queen at Buckingham Palace. 
 At the end of 1966, he was invited by the Indian government to spend six weeks there, visiting universities, watching some of the West Indies tour matches, and receiving an honorary Doctor of Law degree from the University of the Punjab. 
 As the trip went on he began to feel unwell, and when he left he returned to Kingston, rather than Trinidad, as he knew the hospital staff there. 
 He was diagnosed as having leukaemia, his wife was called from Trinidad, and when she arrived was told he had no more than six weeks to live. 
 It was not an uncommon illness in the West Indies at the time, and the variety which Worrell had was particularly virulent. 
 He knew he was dying and retained his dignity to the end; it came on 13 March 1967, and the cricketing world, quite simply, was devastated. 
 Flags were lowered, tributes flooded in, memorial services were held, culminating in the first one ever for a cricketer at Westminster Abbey. 
 It was desperately hard to accept that this serene man, so calm, so dignified, such a majestic cricketer, could have been taken in this way. 
 He had taken a group of talented individuals and moulded them into a superb team, ridding them of their old factions and weaknesses, and showing the disbelievers that black men were every bit as good as white. 
 West Indies had had their triumphs before, of course, but now things were different; they were no longer inferior to whites, they were unified, they were strong and the future was theirs. 
 There would be further set-backs as one lean spell caused the factions to surface again, but now they were truly under way and in due course their supremacy would become complete. 
 Worrell passionately believed in the unity of the West Indian people, and realized that the foundations of such unity could be laid more readily through cricket than any other means. 
 It was the richest legacy he could possibly have bequeathed to his people.  
 AFTERWORD 
 West Indian cricket has been strong for so long principally because it is looked upon almost as a religion in the Caribbean. 
 Nowhere else in the world can match the fervour of it. 
 Children have long played it everywhere, often in dreadful conditions &mdash; on the beaches, in the roads, on any bit of rough ground. 
 The batsmen all attack like Greenidge or Richards, except that they do it virtually all the time and there is little idea of defensive play when the bowling demands it. 
 The bowling, needless to say, is as fast as possible. 
 Few of the youngsters will have been to a big match; what they are emulating is what they have seen on television in shop windows and heard on their transistors. 
 Those transistors are an essential element in West Indian life, keeping everyone who does not have the time or, more likely, the money, to go to a game in touch with what is happening. 
 When Richards is batting people just stop work and listen. 
 In England even when Botham was working one of his miracles people at work did not stop; if they did not have a radio they just rang the Test score, on the works phone of course, a bit more frequently. 
 There is, quite simply, no comparison in the attitudes to the game of British people and Caribbean people. 
 How an area with such a small population could have produced so many world-class cricketers is beyond the comprehension of most Britons. 
 Barbados, which even now has little more than a quarter of a million people, has led the way with a roll of honour of mind-boggling proportions. 
 Trinidad, which now has around a million inhabitants, has also produced far more than its fair share, and it is interesting to note the differences between the two. 
 In Barbados (and other places such as Jamaica and Antigua), the wickets are fast and so the bowlers have traditionally bowled fast, while the batsmen have looked to attack at every opportunity, to hit the ball as hard and as gleefully as possible. 
 Trinidad, on the other hand, used matting wickets for decades, producing batsmen who relied on timing and placing for their runs rather than power, men such as Stollmeyer and, more recently, Gomes, who were closer in style to their English opponents than to some of their team-mates. 
 The bowling has  been more different still; there is a sizeable East Indian population in Trinidad that has produced bowlers with oriental wiles and subtleties unthought-of in Barbados, with Achong and Ramadhin the obvious examples. 
 There have been exceptions, naturally, such as Learie Constantine and George John, but the differences are broadly true. 
 There are no comparable differences in Britain, where any kind of player may turn up just about anywhere. 
 There are signs, though, that cricket may be sliding slowly off its pedestal in the Caribbean. 
 In the past, there were few other sports apart from football and swimming, and neither of these represented much of a challenge. 
 Now, as the British influence wanes, it is replaced by an American one; television has brought along the delights of basketball and its popularity has quickly soared. 
 Easy to play, fast-moving, athletic, it is very much a game for the modern world. 
 And with the brightest students, who would have gone to Britain until the Thatcher government started charging them substantial fees, now studying in the US, it seems likely that the trend away from cricket to American sports will steadily continue. 
 Maybe in twenty or thirty years time England will take a Test series off them. 
 If the last two decades have been just a trifle one-sided, before that the competition was excellent, with first one side holding sway and then the other, which is as it should be. 
 With the racial differences there have inevitably been problems, such as injudicious behaviour by English tourists, racist taunts by English crowds, touchiness by West Indian officials over imagined slights, and the odd riot or three. 
 English fans feel that the emphasis on fast bowling in the last fifteen years has been greatly to the game's detriment, leading to the continuing decline of the spinner, a lack of variety, slow over rates, broken bones and a situation where batting is more about courage than skill. 
 Many English fans even regard West Indian cricket as boring, but it is more impossible to know, as defeat follows defeat follows defeat, to what extent this is an objective judgement or to what extent it is just sour grapes. 
 There was naturally much rejoicing in Britain that the worm was turning in 1989&ndash;90, but there would have been more had there been a spinner or two in the team. 
 West Indies, for their part, are simply playing their own game and, since it has made them the most powerful team in the world, cannot see why they should deprive themselves of their trump cards just because other countries cannot produce trump cards of their own. 
 It has long been the case that the fact of winning is far more important than the manner of doing so, and since they have found a winning formula they have a powerful argument for keeping it, especially now that the financial rewards are  considerable. 
 The whingeing, as they see it, that takes place in the British press angers many West Indians, as Viv Richards demonstrated with his outburst in Antigua during the last Test of 1989&ndash;90. 
 What British people so often fail to understand is that the old inter-island divisions and prejudices that have always dogged Caribbean life are still present, and that a successful cricket team is the one thing that transcends this fragmentation. 
 Jeffrey Dujon, in an interview for a magazine, summed it up: &bquo;We're the only example of Caribbean unity that exists, when the team performs we're the only thing the entire Caribbean focuses on. 
 We're an example of the excellence, as well as the unity, the Caribbean is capable of.&equo; 
 English cricket does not have this capacity for internal strife in the same way, the periodic Yorkshire blood-lettings being of a different order; but West Indian cricket has grown strong precisely because it has risen above its problems, and on that basis England cannot find the same sort of strength since they do not have the same problems to overcome. 
 However passionate a follower of England's fortunes might be, it is unlikely he will be able to match the fervour of the average West Indian. 
 Presumably the well of fast bowlers will one day run dry and then West Indies will have to devise a new strategy; after all, India did not fare too badly in the 1960s and '70s with a quartet of spinners. 
 By the time that happens, England may have her own supply and the roles may become reversed. 
 One hopes not; the best series between the two was that of 1963, and in those days cricket teams had a balanced attack. 
 The game was more enjoyable for everyone that way.  
 STATISTICAL HIGHLIGHTS OF THE TEST MATCHES 
 Backstage by Alex Finer 
 THE GOOD, THE BAD AND PETER COOK 
 An East End doctor in distress, wails and walls in South Africa, the funniest people in Britain, and Milan Kundera with a wave 
 Our cover story this month invites you to meet the one hundred funniest people in Britain. 
 I start, however, by introducing two other features that will have no one laughing. 
 In advance of the April 1 reorganization of the National Health Service, the most comprehensive since its foundation in 1948, we publish a disturbing dispatch &lsqb;The Doctor is Sick, page 100&rsqb; by David Widgery, a general practitioner in London's East End. 
 Widgery lives and works in the front line of community medicine, conducting surgeries and home visits in an area of blight. 
 He details his daily struggle: trying to treat patients as he knows he can, yet unable to find them a hospital bed or specialist referral. 
 He blames chronic NHS underfunding. 
 Widgery's eloquent scream of frustration is born of personal experience. 
 Raised in London, he suffered polio in childhood and endured long spells in hospital. 
 Without the NHS he would have been a cripple. 
 He is highly sceptical of the April 1 reforms, convinced they will increase bureaucracy without guaranteeing better patient care. 
 &bquo;The new arrangements for local health authorities do nothing to ease resource problems,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;In hospitals that &bquo;opt out&equo;, there may be an increase in cold surgery and cardiovascular medicine for the better off &mdash; but it will be to the further detriment of primary care, preventive medicine and local services in poorer areas.&equo; 
 IN OUR SECOND disturbing dispatch &lsqb;Apocalypse Now &mdash; Now, page 110&rsqb;, novelist Christopher Hope reports from suburban Johannesburg, which he describes as the wall-building capital of the world. 
 Behind them, housewives now pack .38s in Gucci handbags, learn to train Rottweilers in close attack work and sign up with security firms such as Armed Response. 
 Christopher Hope grew up a Catholic in Pretoria and went into voluntary exile, aged thirty-one, in 1975. 
 He says: &bquo;Change is unstoppable. 
 Apartheid will be dead, legally speaking, within months. 
 South Africa is undergoing its own form of perestroika. 
 &bquo;When travelling in the country, you sense an enormous fear and anger at the present reforms; in well-healed suburbs, there is approval of the reforms but still a great fear of the random violence they have released.&equo; 
 AS A HEALTHY antidote to our strife-torn, recessionary and under-funded times, we commissioned Kate Garner to photograph the portfolio of comedians in our lead feature &lsqb;Laughing Through Hard Times, page 56&rsqb;. 
 What is it about Peter Cook or John Hegley that predisposes me to smile even before they open their mouths? 
 Kate Garner's brief was to locate the humour in their characters, creating portraits of this select band of people who can trip us into laughter. 
 Garner knows about the challenge of performance art. 
 She was half of the dreadlock duo, Haysi Fantayzee, which notched up a couple of Top Twenty hits in the early Eighties: &bquo;John Wayne is Big Leggy&equo; and &bquo;Shinny Shinny&equo;. 
 Before her brief exposure to pop stardom, she served an apprenticeship to a still-life photographer, and it was to the camera that she eventually returned, specialising in record covers and rock portraits. 
 BILL BRYSON &lsqb;Sweden on Two Herrings a Day, page 67&rsqb; enhances this happier mood with an account of a recent journey to Sweden, retracing the steps he first took as a monoglot student twenty years earlier. 
 Starting life in Des Moines, Iowa, Bryson made England his base nearly fifteen years ago. 
 Now, with a backpack on his shoulders and a tight fist on his wallet, Bryson shows first-class fun is available in the hardest of times on the cheapest of tickets. 
 FURTHER MAINTAINING our promise to publish contemporary writers of quality, we welcome Milan Kundera &lsqb;The Wave, page 92&rsqb; to British Esquire. 
 Born in Czechoslovakia and now teaching in Paris, he receives a fuller introduction on the page by our literary editor, Julian Evans. 
 In this and throughout the rest of the issue, I wish you good reading. 
 Alex Finer is the Editor of Esquire  
 Encounters with Britain by Lee Eisenberg 
 WHAT IS EVERYBODY LAUGHING AT? 
 And among the other questions this month: Is bathroom humour just good clean fun? 
 Would Britain be better off as a theme park? 
 That I am living in Britain in the first place has everything to do with the fact that I came here to start the magazine you are reading, a magazine for men. 
 As the editor in chief of such a magazine, I am obliged to answer a lot of questions about men. 
 I am, depending on circumstances, called on to analyse and defend them, speak and apologize for them. 
 People &mdash; usually women journalists &mdash; are curious to know what makes British men tick, and how they differ from other men. 
 They want to know whether today's men are better fathers, whether men will ever open up at the breakfast table, whether male impotence is on the rise, whether men suffer from their own form of menopause, whether men will cultivate any interest in pastimes more enlightened than football and snooker. 
 I don't always know the answers to the questions but I answer them anyway. 
 In the meantime, I research. 
 For instance, I eavesdrop on men's mumbles in restaurants, as they work out their seductions or deals. 
 I watch how they smooth their hair when enter a room. 
 I note how their shoulders go stiff with tension as they pick out neckties. 
 I pay attention to their excuses when they're playing golf or fishing. 
 And for the past few months, I've been reading Viz. 
 Most of you, I assume, already know what Viz is about. 
 But in the event you washed ashore even more recently than I, you'll be delighted to know that Viz is about farts, tits and gonads. 
 A garish and good-natured bi-monthly magazine, it advertises itself as Britain's &bquo;5TH BEST SELLING MAGAZINE! 
 And you'll never read a bigger pile of shite&equo;. 
 Both claims, so far as I know, are true. 
 Viz, which sells for a pound, consists of cartoons, comic strips and tabloid-style features (&bquo;TRAFFIC WARDENS CAN'T GET IT UP&equo;). 
 It is a monument to the two subjects that are nearest and dearest to a young teenager's heart: sex and scatology. 
 If there is a publication anywhere in the world better suited to the twelve-year-old-boy mentality, I can't imagine what it is. 
 But here is the intriguing part. 
 I've done some checking around and have found out that it isn't just pubescent, pizza-faced boys who have made the magazine the best-selling pile of shite that it is. 
 Viz is also read by a broad cross-section of full-grown, British men: lorry drivers, rubbish collectors, yes; but also a goodly number of marketing execs, barristers, teachers, engineers and other respectables. 
 Apparently they get quite a charge our of Viz's thick-headed puns and lame sexual and excremental allusions which, when they were first heard in burlesque halls a hundred years ago, were already ancient. 
 Here's a typical example of a Viz comic strip: Dad gets a new putter for Christmas and says (to onlooking wife and guffawing son), &bquo;Oh! 
 It's a putter! 
 My old one is broken, you see&hellip; 
 The end came off when your mother was playing a round with me. 
 I wouldn't have minded but I couldn't get it in the hole after that. 
 Hmmm, stainless steel. 
 I like a good hard shaft&hellip; 
 My balls always take a proper hammering.&equo;  
 Or, from Viz's phoney letters column, a reader from Dagenham writes: &bquo;It's true that money can't buy you happiness. 
 Take the Queen, for example. 
 She's got seven million quid, and just look at her face. 
 The miserable old bag.&equo; 
 Or, from the Viz diary of a made-up Hollywood stunt man: &bquo;I was asked to stand in for Mel Gibson in Lethal Weapon II, but I turned it down 'cos Patsy Kensit's got tits like fried eggs.&equo; 
 But hold on, you could be thinking by now, don't impugn all British manhood just because a few sexually (or excrementally) repressed junior accountants get a kick out of shag jokes. 
 Well, then how do you explain the night I put down a copy of Viz, turned on the telly, and settled in for what I thought would be a programme of smart, irreverent comedy? 
 The show was called The Mary Whitehouse Experience (which I later learned was in honour of the blue-nose lady who's always sounding off about too much sex in the media). 
 The Experience consists of four young men who look, talk and act as if they've grown up in good families, graduated from decent schools, and dress as if they shop at just the right places &mdash; Paul Smith, say, or Emporio Armani. 
 They've got asymmetrical haircuts, wire-rimmed specs, an earring or two. 
 The show is hip and happening, dude: the audience looks as if it has just walked in off the King's Road, the post-modernish set is ultra-cool, the show's titles are dazzling, the best I've seen on British television. 
 But while these bright young men obviously read the newspapers and present themselves as iconoclastic political and social satirists, guess what most of their humour is about? 
 That's right! 
 Sex and excrement! 
 Specifically, The Mary Whitehouse Experience is an experience in wankers and turds, which are the boys' two favourite words. 
 Orifice jokes draw gales of laughter from the cultish audience. 
 Perhaps you heard the hoots and the howls that accompanied the skit about John Major's classless society, in which the Princess of Wales is imagined wearing not a hat but&hellip; a&hellip; turd&hellip; on her head! 
 Yuk! 
 Yuk! 
 Indeed, harmless boys' stuff, is this. 
 And, I believe, particularly British. 
 While bathroom humour is certainly not confined to the UK, it certainly seems to thrive here. 
 In America, for instance, doo-doo jokes have been decidedly out of fashion since the Fifties. 
 Which is not to say that popular humour in the States is particularly nice: in recent years there has been a great demand for in-your-face racist, ethnic and misogynist stuff, as typified on the respectable side by Jackie Mason and on the unholy by Andrew Dice Clay. 
 Both of these Brooklyn comics, however, are now growing colder than a rubber chicken. 
 A new comedy wave, I suppose, is waiting in the wings. 
 Whatever it will be about, though, it won't be about doo-doo or wieners. 
 We'll leave that to the over-the-Benny-Hill gang. 
 SOME WEEKS AGO, I opened the paper and noticed a list of walks that were scheduled to take place in Britain. 
 Most were rambles through the countryside, but one or two were organized strolls through historical sections of London. 
 Having nothing better to do on a blustery Sunday, I decided to amble along on one. 
 I was looking forward to a couple of hours of vigorous strolling in the company of what I assumed would be a garrulous, suitably eccentric English guide. 
 The walk was scheduled to depart from Green Park Tube, and when I arrived I found a group of thirty or so walkers already tapping their feet. 
 They were exactly the sort you'd expect to see at this kind of activity: mostly middle-aged or older Americans or Germans in running shoes, with a few earnest Guardian readers thrown in for local colour. 
 The theme of the walk &mdash; which was to take place through the streets of St James's &mdash; was &bquo;royal London&equo;. 
 Our guide was a tall, bespectacled chap in his late thirties, looking properly Anglo with a tweed cap, and a muffler around his neck. 
 He took his position just inside the gates of the park, cleared his throat, and, in a booming baritone voice that implied a spell at drama school, started things off by announcing, with practised shrug, that he wasn't British at all, he was a Yank. 
 And was he ever: his every decibel rang out with the wide-vowelled purity of a native Mid-westerner. 
 He hailed, in fact, from a small town in Wisconsin. 
 I sensed a palpable disappointment run through our little platoon of walkers. 
 I myself was tempted to drop out then and there. 
 But I decided to give my countryman a chance, not that I'd moved four thousand miles to be shown around London by a fellow American, and a hick from the provinces to boot. 
 But a good time wasn't to be. 
 Among the references to the Ritz, for instance, was that Joan Collins was a frequent guest at the hotel, she &bquo;of Dyenasty, Dinnasty, Dysentery, whatever it's called&equo;. 
 Then a few moments later he bemoaned &mdash; at great length &mdash; how London was getting increasingly &bquo;homogenized and pasteurized&equo;, milking the issue for all it was worth. 
 In particular, he lamented the passing of the red telephone kiosk (who doesn't?). 
 Later, as we huddled against the wind behind the Stafford Hotel, he mourned the loss of ancient stables there, which, he assumed, were being turned into &bquo;very swish&equo; accommodations. 
 And so it went: a nice enough American bewailing the passing of London as he wanted it to be. 
 I couldn't help but think he wanted it to be a theme park. 
 He longed for London Land, with gas lamps still flickering in the dusk, horse-drawn cabs clattering across the cobblestones, criminals no scarier than little boys scrounging for their supper. 
 And isn't that what so many of you (the natives) and us (the tourists) want London to be? 
 Because if London were a theme park there'd be no more hassles about modern architecture, no more palaver about Europe, no more worrying about national health (a theme park with socialized medicine?), no more ugly council estates, no more foreign wars. 
 It would be just a user-friendly make-believe with only one minor problem: too many turd jokes.  
 Viz is thick-headed puns and lame sexual and excremental allusions &mdash; geddit? 
 London Land: a lament for the passing of the red telephone kiosk 
 Man At His Best 
 The Esquire guide to quality and style 
 THE KINDEST CUT 
 Ringside cuts man Danny Holland, the Henry Cooper Gym 
 He says: 
 &bquo;The art of patching up a cut fighter is essentially speed. 
 In the one-minute interval between rounds, you have, at most, forty-five seconds to repair the damage. 
 It's a simple formula: clean the wound; stem the bleeding with an iced iron; then apply adrenalin, which coagulates the blood.&equo; 
 They add: 
 &bquo;Danny had Henry Cooper, one of the worst bleeders in boxing, to deal with,&equo; says Bobby Neill, who guided Lloyd Honeyghan to his world title. 
 &bquo;There was very little he could do about the horrendous injuries Cooper suffered in his two fights against Ali, but he saved him on countless other occasions with his quick, methodical work.&equo; 
 We conclude: 
 For more than fifty years, Danny Holland has been one of the premier cuts men in boxing. 
 At eighty-two, he still trains young hopefuls at the Henry Cooper Gym in London's Old Kent Road. 
 His deftness with something as prosaic as a cotton bud and bottle of adrenalin might not be everybody's idea of art, but is certainly artful. 
 First-Rate Bang On 
 Harmony of form and function &mdash; the Beosystem 2500 
 Occupying the increasingly solitary middle ground between the Japanese hi-fi giants and British cottage industries, Bang &amp; Olufsen supplies precision-engineered turntables and valve-driven amplifiers for the price of a small car. 
 For B&amp;O, form has long been as important as function, allowing it to avoid the open-sandwich school of Danish design. 
 No brushed aluminium and rosewood here; its stereo systems are designed with graph-paper severity to put across an austere seriousness. 
 B&amp;O products have redefined consumer electronics. 
 Most recently, the MX television, which sits unobtrusively on the floor tilting back and forth behind a smoked-glass screen, appeared outlandish at first but was quickly copied by the big manufacturers. 
 It is, moreover, the only manufacturer to produce fully integrated home systems &mdash; allowing you to find out who's ringing your door-bell by switching TV channels, for example. 
 That linkage technology was one of the factors behind Philips's investment of thirty-six million pounds in the company last year. 
 Bang &amp; Olufsen's latest launch, the Beosystem 2500 &mdash; combining compact disc, cassette player and radio, with two ultra-slim speakers &mdash; has broken the industry's conventional vertical configuration for such systems; instead you have a sleek sculptural object you can hang on the wall. 
 DEYAN SUDJIC  
 Photograph by Nigel Parry 
 Classics 
 CORDUROY TROUSERS 
 How to achieve that lived-in, Albert Einstein look 
 If I had to name the twentieth-century figure who reminds me most of corduroys, it would have to be Albert Einstein. 
 He wasn't the least bit fashionable, but he certainly had style, the way he shuffled around in sneakers and sweatshirts, hair pointing in all directions, corduroy trousers rumpled and baggy. 
 What university-educated person cannot recall at least one professor who always wore corduroys? 
 Corduroy has a lived-in look and demands very little maintenance. 
 For the first half of this century it was associated with intellectuals, of whom Einstein was the epitome. 
 Corduroy has never had much cachet, despite the derivation of its name &mdash; corde du roi, the king's cord. 
 Corduroy has always been the poor man's velvet; its pile is made of cotton, rather than silk or satin, and by the eighteenth century it was being worn all over Europe, not by kings, but by working men. 
 Although we changed its name to corduroy to give it a touch of class, there is no evidence that the French every called it corde du roi or that kings ever wore it. 
 On the contrary; corduroy and other imitation velvets, like velour and velveteen, were considered all along to be false finery, puffed up and pompous. 
 They belonged to a category of fabric called fustian (derived from the name of the Egyptian town where it originated), and by Shakespeare's time the very word fustian had become synonymous with bombast and pretentiousness. 
 Considerable skill was required in the making of corduroy, working-class fabric or not. 
 Craftsmen painstakingly cut the warp, one rib at a time, with long, knives; then they brushed it to make the pile stand up. 
 Today, of course, the process is mechanized; four hundred razor-sharp cutting discs slice more than a yard of cloth in one swift pass. 
 One advantage of corduroy, aside from its warmth and comfort, is the richness it gives colours. 
 The piled fibres absorb and reflect the light, alternating deep and pale hues and giving the cloth its unique lustre. 
 Brown, tan and olive are the original, classic corduroy colours, and when I say classic I mean specifically trousers, not jackets and certainly not suits. 
 A corduroy suit is a contradiction: suits are dressy; corduroy is not. 
 The width of the wale (ridging) determines the degree of informality. 
 Wide wales (up to nine ribs an inch) are the most casual; midwales and pinwales (ten to eighteen ribs an inch) are slightly more formal, but it depends on your point of view. 
 The head of a smart high-street men's shop attempted to tell me why corduroys are superior to blue jeans. 
 Corduroys, he said, were more refined. 
 &bquo;The better customer wears corduroys, which we carry; the other wears jeans, which we don't.&equo; 
 There may be some truth in that, but it sounded like a bit of the old fustian all the same. 
 John Berendt  
 Corde du roi: despite its name, no regal connection for the poor man's velvet 
 Forty Miles 
 SOCIAL CLIMBER 
 The Land Rover Discovery &mdash; off-road from Ebbw Vale to Crickhowell 
 Would I be courageous enough to try it? 
 That was the great question. 
 Whether to do the sensible thing &mdash; chicken out and run for shelter from the bitter blast of the elements? 
 Or conquer the fog, the ice, the rocks and the precipitous incline, to emerge triumphant out of the clouds at the summit? 
 In the Discovery, we had the perfect vehicle for the task. 
 Born and bred a Land Rover, but crossed with the might and muscle of a Range Rover, it's just the machine for enterprising City types who at the end of the week want to swap Hampstead and Fulham for ambitious adventures to the ends of Britain's motorways. 
 After depositing my faint-hearted photographer at the foot of the craggy slope, I locked the Discovery's transmission into low-ratio first gear for the steep climb, revved the big V8 engine decisively and gingerly eased out the clutch. 
 I'd grappled up the slope on foot just before and knew how steep and icy its surface was and which of the bigger rocks had to be dodged because they would foul the car's underside. 
 I'd also taken stock of just how deep the ravine was a yard or so to my right &mdash; on a previous visit to this rocky Brecon summit I'd looked down on a pair of RAF Tornadoes streaking through on a high-adrenalin exercise. 
 I shifted into second, and the Discovery stormed up the slope with a roar of V8 power, only to slither to a halt halfway up, its front wheels sliding sideways on a sheet of ice and threatening the worst off-road fate of all &mdash; to be stuck across a slope. 
 I had forgotten the Discovery's trump card &mdash; its get-you-out-of-trouble differential lock. 
 A quick sideways prod of the transfer gear-lever was all that I needed to give the big machine the traction of a funicular railway, as if an invisible cable winch was hauling me up. 
 My reward was a spectacular lunar landscape at the top, accessible, I comforted myself, only to hill-walkers and the most capable of off-road vehicles, such as the Discovery. 
 A shame, then, that so few of the Discovery's customers are likely ever to make use of these abilities. 
 Like its big sister, the Range Rover, now twenty-one years old, the Discovery is as much an instrument of upper-crust fashion as a tool for serious cross-country exploits. 
 But unlike the &pound;30,000 Range Rover, the Discovery is financially more accessible: at &pound;17,300 upwards, it's appreciably cheaper than many of the Japanese intruders it is seeking to chase out. 
 Yet the Discovery has a classy, Conran-designed interior, excellent seats and ride-comfort and a wonderful, rumbling V8 engine that emits just the same blue-blooded burble as a Range Rover. 
 Now that fuel injection has been added, there's urgent acceleration on tap, too. 
 Only three things worried me: the prodigious thirst for fuel, the lack of anti-lock on the brakes and a steering system that combined over-sensitivity with vagueness. 
 The steering worried me more on Brecon's narrow tracks than it had on the motorway. 
 But later, as we picked our way along the narrow mountain spine down towards Aberfan, I found the Discovery more reassuring again &mdash; its flexibility, its smoothness, its stability, all signs of its good breeding. 
 The long, fast stretch round to our supper halt at my favourite, the Bear Hotel in Crickhowell, slipped by, hardly noticed; even the long journey home that evening was a doddle. 
 And that, I reflected on the final leg, enveloped in air-conditioned heat and six-speaker stereo sound, is why the Discovery is so uniquely suited, not only to the rough and tumble of off-road riding, but also to the equal rigours of life in Knightsbridge and Notting Hill Gate. 
 Basic price for a five-door, V8i Land Rover Discovery is &pound;20,400. 
 On test, fuel consumption ranged from 10.1 to 18.7 mpg. 
 Its 3.5 litre injection V8 engine, with 164 brake horsepower, enables it to reach a maximum speed of 105 mph, with acceleration from 0&ndash;60 taking 11.2 seconds. 
 Wading depth is 19.7 inches; maximum gradient is 45 degrees.  
 Discovery ascending: a sense of innate superiority 
 Country Matters 
 LAYING DOWN THE LAWN 
 The way to achieve that perfect green sward 
 Making a lawn, as any gardening book or groundsman will tell you, is dead easy. 
 Dig a patch of ground to a depth of two feet or so, if you are dealing with soil. 
 If the site is made of builder's rubble, cover it with a foot of topsoil. 
 Install drains to take the rain off. 
 Crumble the soil to the consistency of breadcrumbs. 
 Firm it with a duck-like waddling movement of your hobnailed boots. 
 Then, using spirit-level and pegs as a builder lays a concrete floor, level it to the flatness of a billiard table. 
 Mop brow. 
 Call one of the men advertising turf for sale in the local paper. 
 If you must. 
 In correct rural circles, having your lawn turfed is regarded in the same light as wearing made-up bow ties. 
 To do the job properly, sow seed. 
 Not just any seed, mind. 
 Only the finest and wiriest of grasses will do; brown-top bent and &bquo;Chewing's Fescue&equo; to form the tufts that give the turf its bounce, and creeping red fescue to knit the whole lot together. 
 The man in the garden centre will say you want rye grass. 
 Ignore the swine. 
 Rye grass is coarse and flat-leaved, and fulfils the same function in a sward as petrol-like grain spirit in cheap Scotch whisky. 
 Scatter the seed evenly about. 
 Clap your hands once every five minutes for a fortnight, to keep hungry birds off. 
 Wait for the green shadow to rise from the brown ground, then get rolling. 
 We have now arrived at one of the great lawn stories. 
 An American is standing in an Oxford quadrangle, jaw dropped. 
 &bquo;What does it take to get grass like this?&equo; he asks a menial. 
 &bquo;Good soil,&equo; he replies. 
 &bquo;Good seed. 
 And five 'undred years.&equo; 
 But, of course, some people do not take lawns seriously. 
 They do not mow lawns. 
 Instead they cut grass &mdash; nasty coarse stuff &mdash; belting over the green in fifth gear, Walkman thundering, leaving pubic tufts in the awkward corner by the concrete nymph, then down to the Beetle for a few lagers. 
 Purists still demand the long trudge with the Atco cylinder-mower, the old one with the heavy roller and the polished-brass gas tank. 
 Sure, you can hook a roller up behind your Mountfield. 
 But can you live with your perfidy? 
 Lawn owners have good reason for keeping clear consciences and generally living each day as through it were their last. 
 Death may lurk among the green blades. 
 If you go fertilizing with unsterilized bonemeal, for instance, hold your breath; the stuff can be crawling with anthrax germs. 
 Mole control can also get you into trouble. 
 One victim having failed to dislodge the vandals by pouring petrol into their tunnels, crept out at dawn and fired a shotgun into a mole then constructing a hill. 
 Unfortunately, the tunnels were still full of gasoline vapour, which was ignited by the gun's muzzle flash. 
 The flame erupted under the fuel tank of the victim's new Vauxhall, parked outside the garage. 
 The tank blew up, hurling the Vauxhall through the closed garage doors, which caused twenty more gallons of petrol to explode, blowing the front off the house. 
 The lawn, though cratered, survived. 
 There used to be worse enemies: moss, for instance, and the emerald hell of clover. 
 Chemical warfare would set in with appalling ferocity, leaving the sward slimy with dead worms. 
 All that has changed. 
 The recent greening of the world means that the first clover of summer is greeted with an enthusiasm previously reserved for the cuckoo. 
 Not by Fast Dickie, though. 
 Dickie does not believe in clover, or mowers, and he would not recognize &bquo;Chewing's Fescue&equo; if you served it to him on a bed of rice. 
 What Dickie likes is no muss, no fuss. 
 Which is why he spoke to a geezer he knows down Battersea, and the geezer down Battersea done him some nice concrete and rolled an acre of Astroturf on top. 
 Pricey, as Dickie will admit. 
 But dead pleasant, and well heavy green. 
 Sam Llewellyn 
 Good Works 
 INSIDE INFORMATION 
 How to feel proud about going to jail 
 What's the difference between a battery hen and a British prison inmate? 
 Not enough. 
 WHY: Bad living conditions and lack of space are facts of British prison life; but for many prisoners the greatest hardship is isolation. 
 They are often abandoned and eager for contact with outsiders. 
 WHO: The largest and longest established organization, the National Association of Prison Visitors, arranges visits by its nine hundred members with local prison governors. 
 Volunteers are interviewed, asked for references and given a three-month trial. 
 To become a &bquo;regular&equo;, you must have Home Office clearance and sign the Official Secrets Act. 
 Two qualifications are essential: an ability to listen, and commitment. 
 &bquo;The most important thing is regular contact. 
 Many of these people have been rejected all their lives. 
 It is essential not to let them down,&equo; says one expert. 
 WHAT: Visits may be weekly or fortnightly and last about an hour, on a one-to-one basis in the prisoner's cell; all conversations are confidential. 
 Visitors must not take in presents, except cigarettes &mdash; which must be smoked there and then. 
 WHEN: Visiting hours vary, but evenings and weekends are popular. 
 HOW: For details contact: The National Association of Prison Visitors, 46b Hartington Street, Bedford MK41 7RL. 
 The New Bridge, 1 Thorpe Close, Ladbroke Grove, London W10 5XL. 
 Society of Voluntary Associates, Brixton Hill Place, London SW2 1HJ. 
 Alison Nadel  
 The Essential Bookshelf 
 THRILLS AND CHILLS 
 Twelve great page-turners in the mystery mould 
 What the following thrillers have in common is that each is a rattling good read, and together they are the cream (1939, as will be seen, being a particularly creamy year) of their genre, leading you on to other delights. 
 I have tried to exclude the legendary detectives for another day, but, despite my best efforts, Sam Spade, Philip Marlowe and James Bond have still managed to insinuate themselves: they used foot-in-the-door tactics, I'm afraid, and who am I to argue? 
 1 The Woman in White Wilkie Collins 1860 
 This is the earliest novel that may reasonably be termed a thriller &mdash; a strongly atmospheric work, replete with midnight encounters, the eponymous mysterious and rather worrying white-clad lady and a highly dislikeable villain in the form of the obese and oleaginous Count Fosco. 
 2 The Four Just Men Edgar Wallace 1905 
 One of the earliest and most famous of more than one hundred and sixty thrillers and mysteries from the phenomenal and rather strange Mr Edgar Wallace, and certainly one of the most accomplished, readable and ingenious of them all. 
 A real page-turner, with a more than satisfying conclusion. 
 3 The Thirty-nine Steps John Buchan 1915 
 Devotees of the Hitchcock film will be gratified to hear that Buchan's book is even more chock-full of incident, cross-country chases, gung-ho and derring-do: a stirring monument to the days when a man of action might still be possessed of a stiff-upper-lipped charm and accomplishment. 
 As every schoolboy knows, Richard Hannay saves the day &mdash; and England. 
 4 The Maltese Falcon Dashiel Hammett 1930 
 The first and best example of the &bquo;hard-boiled&equo; thriller, with private dick Sam Spade chewing off chunks of lousy life in a lousy world, and spitting them right back in your face. 
 A convoluted plot, it must be said, but a really tough-guy read. 
 5 Brighton Rock Graham Greene 1938 
 The murky and seedy, small-time underworld of pre-war Brighton is brilliantly evoked by the Master in this most gripping of his &bquo;entertainments&equo;. 
 The cold-bloodedness of the quirkily named and unforgettable Pinkie remains chilling, and the ending is both climactic and everlastingly poignant: this one is a work of art. 
 6 The Mask of Dimitrios Eric Ambler 1939 
 A detective writer sets out to track down a shadowy and fascinating villain in the Levant, and the intrigue and tension tighten a notch with each passing chapter. 
 Here we have a dry, laconic and completely unsentimental style that spawned hundreds of imitations. 
 7 The Big Sleep Raymond Chandler 1939 
 The first of the Philip Marlowe books sees our hero hanging tough among the broads, bimbos and gorillas &mdash; a hard-smoking bourbon man who eschews armour in favour of a belted mac and a fedora in which to play the down-at-heel knight errant. 
 The action and self-deprecating humour are expertly balanced. 
 8 Rogue Male Geoffrey Household 1939 
 An extraordinarily powerful book &mdash; in many ways reminiscent of Buchan at his best, but the Boy's Own element is tempered by shocking and fear-inducing realism. 
 The plot centres around an aristocratic sportsman who in turn becomes the subject of a manhunt: he is alone against the world, but we are with him through every breathless paragraph. 
 9 Strangers on a Train Patricia Highsmith 1950 
 The first novel by the so-called queen of &bquo;psychological&equo; crime, and &mdash; apart from The Talented Mr Ripley (1955) &mdash; her most memorable. 
 The insidious madness of Bruno (who wants to &bquo;swap murders&equo; with an innocent tennis pro) sneaks up on us slyly, and will not be shaken off. 
 10 Casino Royale Ian Fleming 1953 
 Forget all preconceptions of a wise-cracking booby whose lifestyle resembles a cross between Hugh Hefner and Ghostbusters &mdash; here is the first Bond book (no sequel was planned) that supports with expert plotting, deft characterization and breathtaking cruelty Fleming's claim to be a major exponent of the spy novel genre. 
 Superb. 
 11 Dead Cert Dick Francis 1962 
 This &mdash; Francis's first of more than thirty novels all loosely based on the racing world &mdash; has been picked almost at random, for each of them is masterful. 
 The understated elegance of the build, the sheer unabated enjoyability of the ride and the consummately satisfying conclusions place Francis at the very top: &bquo;thriller&equo; is really too crude a word for his achievement. 
 12 The Day of the Jackal Frederick Forsyth 1971 
 Forsyth is a top-selling and stylish author &mdash; decidedly not a purveyor of great literature, but a man writing for men, with thrills guaranteed. 
 This book is particularly clever, for although we know the outcome (de Gaulle was not assassinated), we are on the edge of our seats until the very last page. 
 Joseph Connolly  
 And Fleming created Bond: the first, cruel classic 
 The Seasoned Cook 
 SURRENDER THE PINK 
 Simple salmon: king of the river cooked to perfection 
 Salmon is the most contrary fish. 
 I have fished some of the best salmon water, giving the damned fish every opportunity to outwit me, and I've caught the odd one here and there. 
 On average it works out at about once every five years and a cost of many hundreds of pounds per fish. 
 Your average salmon hatches in the gravel of the river bed as alevin. 
 When they come out, they are fry; as they grow a little, they become parr; larger still, they turn into smolt and fizz off down to the sea. 
 There they stay, apparently somewhere off Greenland and the Faroes, feeding on shrimp and turning pink. 
 But it doesn't stop there. 
 If a salmon comes back to a river after a year, it is known as a grilse, and &mdash; weighing anything from one to four kilograms &mdash; is ready for the pot or skillet or foil jacket. 
 It stays away for two, three or even four years, it is deemed to be full-grown. 
 That's when it returns to the river of its birth to spawn &mdash; and become a kelt, not really suitable for the pot or skillet. 
 No matter what anyone tells you, wild salmon, at its best, has as much in common with the farmed variety as Caroline Cossey does with Mother Theresa. 
 The question is, what constitutes wild salmon at its best? 
 Not the sexually played-out kelt, nor a fish that has undergone an exhausting twenty minutes or so battling with a master angler. 
 Fighting for its life causes chemical changes in the flesh. 
 That does not render it inedible if you cook it within a few hours &mdash; or freeze it immediately. 
 If you want to eat a salmon at its best, try to find one that has been netted at the river mouth or offshore early in the spring, that has been out of the water for no more than twelve hours and still has sea lice on it. 
 There is no comparison between the firm, delicate flesh of such a natural specimen and the fatty flab of the farmed fish made pink by E160g, washed in Nuvan to minimize lice infestation and packed into a cage so that it gets little or no natural conditioning. 
 Back from the fish counter, what does our angler do with his catch? 
 Hand it to his mate? 
 Certainly not. 
 There are few simpler things than cooking a salmon. 
 If the fish is whole, and the fishmonger has done the decent thing &mdash; removed the guts and gills, which would taint it during cooking &mdash; all you need do is immerse the beast in any container large enough to hold it (ideally a fish kettle), cover it with cold water and bring it gently to the boil. 
 The moment it comes to the boil, turn off the heat. 
 There let your fish rest until you are ready to serve it: warm with a sauce of your own devising &mdash; variations on the hollandaise theme always go down well &mdash; or cold when it has cooled. 
 There is a school &mdash; the old school, you might say &mdash; that advocates the making of a court bouillon, cooling that, immersing your salmon in it, then going through the process just described. 
 I think this both cumbersome and wrong; the flesh of the fish picks up other flavours very easily, particularly those of spices &mdash; pepper, coriander, allspice or whatever else is used to flavour the stock. 
 You could try adding a glass of white wine, an onion and a little celery and leek, if you must, but make sure that the court bouillon is cold before you start. 
 There you have it. 
 A bit of fish, a little sauce, one or two new potatoes boiled and then rolled in butter and parsley, and a frond or two of samphire if you have been lucky enough to find it. 
 Then wait for the plaudits to roll in. 
 Matthew Fort  
 Wild thing: as much in common with farmed salmon as Caroline Cossey with Mother Theresa 
 A Shave in the Life 
 IN THE BUFF WITH ROGER McGOUGH 
 Morning becomes the Liverpool poet 
 Early Morning Poem 1 
 Got up, did my toilet, 
 Washed, shaved, combed hair. 
 My toilet looks much nicer now. 
 Roger McGough's bathroom is not a favourite or particularly inspiring place, but a functional, family-cum-laundry room, in which a washing machine, assorted plastic potties, a tumble-dryer and a pink inflatable dolphin jostle for space. 
 It has a basic white enamel suite, louvred doors and cupboards, varnished cork tiles and an interesting &bquo;Arabic effect&equo; wall with splodges of red and gold. 
 &bquo;The bathroom used to be carpeted, but now we have more practical lino, called &bquo;Rhino flooring&equo; because it's tough, hardwearing and smells of rhino piss,&equo; Roger chuckles. 
 He spends very little time there. 
 &bquo;My morning thing is not really about getting ready for the day, but getting rid of the night. 
 In fact, I don't usually shave in the morning; that would be in the afternoon &mdash; or evening, if I'm going out. 
 The only reason I shave at all is for other people. 
 &bquo;I do have an electric razor, but for me a serious shave is a wet one. 
 It's the only time I feel I've done it properly. 
 I use Palmolive shaving foam (sometimes Ted Lapidus, if I'm feeling extravagant), rather than soap. 
 I leave things like aftershave to my sons, who tend to drink it. 
 I do have some Eau Sauvage by Christian Dior and also Birchwood and Hawthorn Splash-on Cologne from The Body Shop, but I don't buy it myself. 
 &bquo;I tend to shower when I go to the gym, but often I have a bath in the evening with my son. 
 We sing and play in the bath together; he likes that. 
 The soap I use is shared by the whole family, so my wife makes sure that it's that pure white, unperfumed stuff for sensitive skin. 
 My wife is always buying new products, and I find myself happily using them without question. 
 After washing, I put on Boot's non-sting anti-perspirant. 
 &bquo;I'm very good when it comes to my teeth. 
 I clean them in the morning and also after each meal with Sainsbury's Oral Health anti-plaque toothpaste (with fluoride). 
 I use Mentadent P dental floss as well &mdash; in fact, I always have some in my desk. 
 &bquo;I don't regret not having much time to pamper myself in the bathroom, as the inclination isn't there. 
 As a teenager growing up in Liverpool in the Fifties it still makes me feel it's a bit naff to spend too much time on your appearance. 
 Although I do admit to owning a bathrobe with my initials on it &mdash; and wearing green glasses for occasions when I want to draw attention to myself. 
 Linda Kessler 
 Early Morning Poem 2 
 Got up, had a shave, 
 Did Times crossword, 
 Had another shave. 
 Family funtime: Roger and son at play 
 Savoir-Faire 
 MASTA PASTA 
 Using up ties as if they were Kleenex is the downside of not being able to eat spaghetti in the proper manner. 
 But don't opt for the obvious solution: cutting the stuff into stunted threads is practised only by the infantile. 
 It is OK, though, to hitch a napkin round your neck, even if the last time your wore one was when your nanny tied it for you. 
 Crucially, remember to remove it; arriving in Finsbury Park at midnight with a bib round your neck is hazardous to personal safety. 
 Here's how to eat spaghetti properly: 
 1. 
 Put your fork in whatever hand feels comfortable. 
 2. 
 Insert the fork vertically into spaghetti, tilt to thirty degrees. 
 3. 
 Turn the fork until a manageable amount has formed into loops; then lift from the bowl and place in the mouth. 
 4. 
 If ends of the pasta trail from your lips, sucking is allowable, although audible sucking is considered inappropriate. 
 5. 
 Gently dab excess sauce from lips and chin. 
 Miles Blakey  
 Man at his Worst 
 A WING AND A PRAYER 
 The day the Reverend Robin Clark got the bird 
 August 7, 1979. 
 The BBC's attempt to record a guitar recital in the small parish church of St Helen, at Brant Broughton, in Lincolnshire, was interrupted by a sparrow's chirruping from the eaves. 
 Twice, soloist Konrad Ragossnig's attempts to start were thwarted by birdsong, so the Rector &mdash; Robin Clark &mdash; took matters into his own hands. 
 Requesting the congregation to leave, he sent his son to fetch an air rifle. 
 After two shots, his son silenced the bird forever. 
 The rector was asked to explain his actions. 
 &bquo;I was in an impossible situation,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;The guitarist just couldn't start. 
 You know what these BBC chaps are like: we've had them refuse to continue just because a chair squeaks.&equo;  
 Letter from America 
 by Pete Hamill 
 DAY ONE 
 As the bombs dropped on Baghdad, I drove through small-town America, where a Hopperesque light lit a multitude of flags and a forest of yellow ribbons 
 So the war came at last, at exactly 6.35:24 pm on January 16, 1991, when Peter Jennings interrupted a canned piece to announce that explosions and flashes were breaking up the Baghdad night. 
 Like most Americans, I began switching channels. 
 From Baghdad, Bernard Shaw, John Holliman and Peter Arnett described the death-dazzled night, and you could hear in their voices the vibrato of fear. 
 After a while, I walked outside and stood beside the pool in the mild, warm wind of the Florida evening. 
 Nothing seemed less appropriate. 
 I wanted to be in a harder place, hearing the great murmur of shock and argument you hear only when people realize that life has changed forever. 
 I want to argue with my friends and console my secretary, Meri McCall, whose son, Kevin, was with an armoured division in Saudi Arabia. 
 Round midnight, I began to pack. 
 It was time to go home. 
 I drove north on I-95, through flat sawgrass country. 
 The light was fading. 
 On CBS radio, the sense of triumph was general. 
 In the first day of the war, the Americans and their allies had flown hundreds of sorties against Iraq, dropped thousands of pounds of bombs and met virtually no resistance. 
 &bquo;We&equo; owned the skies. 
 A grateful stock market was apparently convinced that the war would be over in a matter of hours, and so the Dow Jones roared to a 114-point gain. 
 Then I heard Dan Rather saying there had been explosions in Israel. 
 In Tel Aviv. 
 Heard him say that sirens were blowing and people were donning gas masks and moving into sealed rooms. 
 There was fear of poison gas, in a nation where Zyklon-B was part of the collective memory. 
 Scud missiles streaked through the sky. 
 With that news, everything changed. 
 Saddam Hussein couldn't make &bquo;linkage&equo; with diplomacy, so he'd established it with missiles. 
 The next morning in all the poor souks of the Muslim world, they would chant his name. 
 The Middle East. 
 The Goddamned Middle East. 
 Later I picked up a station from Orlando, WINS &mdash; I listened to a maudlin piece about the poor families of soldiers and pilots. 
 This was typical of the suety coverage of the War Before the War, that long period of waiting before the January 15 deadline. 
 Even the soldiers in the field must've been thoroughly sick of all those whining pieces about Our Boys and Girls, and their mail, or the endlessly recycled nonsense about how hard it was to be a female soldier in Saudi Arabia. 
 Now that the shooting had finally started, we seemed about to be drowned in a tide of mushy stories about support groups, therapy and shrinks, all delivered in the insincerely intimate tones of psychobabble. 
 I started shouting out loud: &bquo;Stop, for Chrissakes, stop!&equo; 
 In the morning in Jacksonville, I shaved and dressed, listening to the television without looking at the pictures. 
 I couldn't get CNN in the glorious Econo Lodge, but I wondered what had become of Arnett and Shaw and Holliman. 
 The reporters kept sending out the arithmetic of the Goddamned Middle East: sorties flown, bombs dropped, planes lost. 
 A reporter talked gravely about the fabulous success of this &bquo;astonishing high-tech war&equo;. 
 The weapons people were the most triumphant; all those expenditures on weapons were now &bquo;paying off&equo;. 
 I walked around outside the motel. 
 A man with a dog strolled along the edge of a field. 
 Another man washed his car. 
 The sky was clear, the day banal, but it was odd being an American. 
 Most of us were peaceful and decent, but here we go again, in our fifth war of this century. 
 Few Americans could even list the little wars, the invasions of Mexico, Haiti, Nicaragua, Grenada, Panama. 
 The Oil War was costing us a billion dollars a day, and we already had more than four hundred and twenty-five thousand men in Saudi Arabia. 
 I went to a Waffle House diner and bought a newspaper and ordered some breakfast. 
 The headline of the Florida Times-Union said: IRAQ STRIKES ISRAEL. 
 At the bottom of page one, there was a story  about the first American lost in the war: Lieutenant-Commander Michael Scott Speicher. 
 As always, we had an outline of the man's life, not its weight, density, complexity. 
 He was thirty-three, part of two FA-18 squadrons from Cecil Field on the USS Saratoga. 
 He was from Jacksonville, a graduate of Forrest High School in 1975, married with a three-year-old daughter and a one-year-old son. 
 He taught Sunday school at Lake Shore United Methodist Church. 
 The pastor said: &bquo;He was a wonderful husband, father and patriot. 
 He loved his country and he loved flying.&equo; 
 There wasn't much else about his short life. 
 He would be thirty-three forever. 
 I drove north into Georgia and pulled off the road into Brunswick. 
 The air was filled with the sweetish, rotting odour of a paper mill. 
 I drove down Newcastle Street, the town's main street, and parked in front of the Bullard Sewing Center. 
 The buildings were two stories high, sharply defined by the hard Hopperesque light. 
 I got out of the car. 
 American flags lined the street. 
 Across the street, a woman walked out of Oz for Hair and went into Happy Days Health Foods. 
 I say a tall man coming across the street in shirt-sleeves. 
 We talked in front of the Coastal Bank of Georgia, at the corner of Newcastle and Gloucester. 
 &bquo;The War? 
 Oh, we're for it,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We're very stable here, very patriotic. 
 We're for it for patriotic reasons. 
 The day before the war, there was a demonstration.&equo; 
 He laughed. 
 &bquo;A couple of old hippies.&equo; 
 After lunch I sat in the car and listened to a Bush press conference. 
 The Scud attacks on Israel were, of course, &bquo;terrorism&equo;, he said, but the Israelis were to be congratulated for all their restraint. 
 Across the street, a stray dog poked his head into the barber shop, then skittered out again. 
 About the Scud launchers in Iraq, Bush said he would launch &bquo;the darnedest search-and-destroy mission ever seen in those parts&equo;. 
 Or, as someone else once said, war is heck. 
 I drove away slowly and then came to the corner of Union and Gloucester. 
 Across the street was City Hall, with US and Confederate flags flying together. 
 On the corner was a huge oak tree. 
 And tied around the oak tree was the largest yellow ribbon I'd yet seen. 
 I parked and got out. 
 There was a plaque at the base of the tree, dedicated to Fernando Torras, who helped to save the &bquo;lordly oaks&equo; of Glynn County. 
 The ribbon was signed by Victorian Gardens &amp; Gifts and by Wanda's Beauty Shop. 
 I turned and saw a sad-eyed middle-aged man sitting on a bench staring at me. 
 &bquo;Hell of a ribbon,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Hell of a tree,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Nothing good's gonna come from it,&equo; he said. 
 He gave a little wave of the hand and then stared out at the traffic, past the lordly oak and its huge yellow ribbon. 
 Nothing. 
 For the next few hours, I was back on the road, passing flatbed trucks carrying huge, tapering logs like giant carrots with their tips chopped off. 
 I moved fast through South Carolina, the land of fireworks and cigarettes. 
 The hot green South was behind me now; there were no more palm trees, and the land had turned a wintry brown. 
 Fayetteville is the home of Fort Bragg, which pumps three billion dollars into the local economy. 
 In peacetime, more than forty thousand men and women were stationed there; now three-quarters of them were in Saudi Arabia. 
 I drove down Bragg Boulevard, past dark dives and tattoo parlours and the Park &amp; Pawn. 
 I could feel the sad power of disintegration: husbands gone off, wives abandoned, children baffled. 
 At Fort Bragg itself, no gate blocked access to the base, no hard-eyed sentries searched for kef-crazed Iraqis bringing the jihad home. 
 I drove past a housing development called Anzio Acres and the lumpy greens of a golf course and then past buildings reserved for Psy Ops, and the headquarters of Special Forces, with its monument to John F Kennedy and its statue of an old Green Beret. 
 All the old delusions seemed to stain the air. 
 I followed signs past abandoned barracks and empty streets. 
 Any decent terrorist could have levelled most of the base. 
 After a while, I cam to Building C-6841, the 82nd Airborne War Memorial Museum. 
 On a rise above it there were some old aircraft: a C-47, a C-7 Caribou, an old Huey helicopter, a C-119 Flying Boxcar. 
 I thought about all the young men who'd climbed into those machines and the death they'd seen and the death they'd made and the death they'd received. 
 I went into the museum. 
 A sign told visiting gentlemen to remove their hats; it was the kind of sign you'd see in the Duomo in Florence; in some parts of America, war still demands what passes for reverence. 
 Inside the front door was a glass case containing the sword, scabbard, swagger stick, cap and uniform shirt of Manuel Noriega. 
 I couldn't help myself; I laughed out loud. 
 As I moved into the small museum, a male chorus started singing over the sound system: Glory, glory, it's a hell of a way to die&hellip; 
 This was truly nuts. 
 The path through the exhibits led to World War I, a display featuring a talking dummy who reduced that gigantic disaster to an argument over submarines. 
 In another room, there was a smiling, life-sized dummy of a Nazi paratrooper, Nazi guns, Nazi uniforms, a 1942 BMW motorcycle used by the Nazis and material explaining how the Nazi airborne invasion of Crete in  1943  had been an inspiration to the Americans. 
 The music continued: Glory, glory, it's a hell of a way to die&hellip; 
 There was another huge exhibit commemorating the liberation of Grenada. 
 But I had to search for Vietnam. 
 That long agony was reduced to a niche and a wall. 
 I hurried out of the museum, while the ghastly chorus continued its song of death. 
 On the way to the motel, the radio played a Tears for Fears song called &bquo;Everybody Wants to Rule the World&equo;. 
 I didn't want to hear the news for a while, but the music seemed to say it all. 
 As I drove north, the sky turning greyer and darker and more flags at half-mast, I remembered one final moment in Fayetteville. 
 I was in the parking-lot of the Quality Inn. 
 A black cleaning woman backed away from a door, a mop in her hand, and a complete family came outside, moving awkwardly with suitcases, uneasy in a place where they charge you more money if you stay past noon. 
 In the centre of the group was a lanky young paratrooper with a face like Huckleberry Finn's. 
 His father, unable to speak the words of farewell, kept patting him on the back, his face a ruin. 
 An older woman, perhaps a grandmother, squeezed the boy's hand. 
 Squeezed it once, then again, then again, and again and again. 
 A sister wept openly. 
 I slowed down. 
 The young paratrooper turned to look at me, his eyes alarmed, as if he expected somehow to see that his buddies had caught him in a moment of vulnerability. 
 He saw then that I was a stranger, and the anxiety drained out of him. 
 I drove the car under an arch leading to another wing of the motel and parked in front of my own room. 
 I took a fresh notebook from the glove compartment and started back to talk to them. 
 When I got there, they were gone, the American family bound for home, their fine young man almost surely on his way to the war. 
 I stood there for a while in the damp grey afternoon and whispered: &bquo;Godspeed.&equo;  
 Letter from Europe 
 by Michael Walsh 
 Sex, Lies and Capitalism 
 In Warsaw's red light district, workers test the limits of a market economy 
 Standing at the bar on this rainy Friday night in Warsaw is a tall, thin, dark-haired and rather pretty woman of about thirty, who catches my glance as Leszek Kurowski and I enter and, with a darting, fitful gesture, invites me to approach. 
 I do. 
 Her name, she says, is Elena; her dark eyes gleam with gay desperation, an impression fuelled by the way she tosses back glass after glass of sparkling wine. 
 Clad head-to-toe in black, she could be a mourner at a wake, but from her body language one cannot quite make out her precise attitude towards the dear departed. 
 Is she drowning her sorrows? 
 Or is she dancing on his grave? 
 Perched on a stool next to her is her friend Barbara, a fat blond whose ample figure and dumpling smile fit the Slavic stereotype better. 
 From time to time, she too takes a sip of wine, gazing blankly at the bar, the barman and, beyond, the dance-floor, where sharp-featured Polish men and their pleasingly plump girlfriends boogie decorously to the strains of a bored rock trio. 
 I'm not here to dance, however; I'm here to talk. 
 For more than a year, the Poles have been engaged in a brave, almost quixotic attempt to transform a moribund command economy into a lively free market, and they are now suffering the growing pains of a capitalism devoid of capital. 
 There are goods in the stores, but prices are high and getting higher, as is unemployment. 
 It will be a while before there is any light at the end of the tunnel Marx built. 
 The underground economy in every socialist state, however, has always been resolutely capitalist, and so my friend Kurowski and I have come here tonight to find out how the world's oldest profession is adjusting to the new economic realities. 
 At a cost of one hundred and fifty thousand zlotys, about eight pounds, I buy Elena and Barbara a bottle of &bquo;champagne&equo;. 
 That may seem reasonable, but it's a lot for Poland, where a million and a half zlotys a month is considered more or less an average wage. 
 Everything in Kamieniolomy, which means &bquo;The Quarry&equo; in Polish, is expensive. 
 The cover charge for the bar, which is owned by the Europejski Hotel across the street, is forty thousand zlotys, a little more than two pounds, double what it was six months ago. 
 Cognac costs the same, vodka half that &mdash; although if one can get drunk on either, given the proportion of water to alcohol, I have yet to prove it. 
 By comparison, you can have a good meal at Bazyliszek (The Basilisk), for years considered the city's best restaurant, for twelve pounds fifty &mdash; and that includes wine and caviare. 
 But pricey as the drinks at Kamieniolomy are, they are nothing compared to the girls. 
 Their asking price is a hundred quid a night, payable on demand in US currency only; around two hundred dollars. 
 The American greenback &mdash; not the almighty Deutschmark, and certainly not the zloty &mdash; is the specie of choice in the new, improved Poland. 
 At the Marriott Hotel, prices are quoted in zlotys (1,675,805) a night for a single room) but are charged in dollars (about a hundred and eighty). 
 At the hotel's bustling casino, the stakes are in dollars. 
 From a minimum bet of three bucks (nearly twenty thousand zlotys), dreams can come true. 
 These sums, of course, are still beyond the reach of most Varsovians, but, typical Slavs, the Poles are great dreamers. 
 They dreamt of free elections, of a restoration of their republic, of a future without communism. 
 If you worked hard enough, many assumed, the dreams might come true. 
 &bquo;Everybody in Poland has a second job,&equo; Kurowski explains to me. 
 He's a strong, calm, controlled man with a scar down his right cheek and a perpetual half-smile on his lips. 
 During the day, he works a the Polytechnic Institute; at night, he is a minicab driver. 
 I met him last year, when I was coming out of Bazyliszek and needed a ride. 
 Tonight, he is sipping a soft drink, the old Warsaw Pact penalties against drunken driving being in force. 
 &bquo;You noticed that guy I said hello to when we came in, the one on the door?&equo; 
 Kurowski asks. 
 &bquo;During the day, he's a cop; at night, he's a bouncer. 
 He's also a free-lance  taxi driver.&equo; 
 But nobody has enough money, except the rich, the emigrant businessmen and the old Party officials. 
 Every day the split between the rich and the poor gets greater. 
 &bquo;We're beginning to wonder whether capitalism has come too fast,&equo; Kurowski explains. 
 &bquo;Maybe we're not ready for it.&equo; 
 Ready or not, the Poles are putting up a stalwart front, rushing ahead with the same heedless bravery with which their mounted cavalry charged the German tanks in World War II. 
 One of the first signs one sees at the airport challenges, in English: &bquo;Take a chance on success!&equo; 
 Indeed, all the advertisements appear to be in English, trumpeting such anglophonic necessities as the United Colors of Benetton. 
 The Palace of Culture and Science, a Stalinist wedding-cake structure that was a Soviet &bquo;gift&equo; to the Polish people in the mid-Fifties, and now home to yet another casino, is draped with a huge blue sign that proclaims: DIGITAL. 
 The hotel televisions offer CNN, Euro-Sport, MTV and Sky. 
 Aside from the palace, the Russians, like Ozymandias, has left precious little spoor. 
 Except, of course, for the lone and level sands of the wrecked economy, which stretch away in all directions. 
 Warsaw's Old Town, which was reduced to an ankle-high heap of rubble in the war, has been handsomely restored, but beyond its ancient boundary stretch the usual slate-grey apartment blocks that characterized New Socialist Man's living quarters. 
 Landscaping is pretty much limited to weeds and mud. 
 More than a year after the revolution, the euphoria has faded. 
 The new president, the folk-hero Walesa, can sound suspiciously socialist in his calls for greater protection of the working man from harsh economic reality. 
 Some of the old Polish poison is back, too; people mutter that former prime minister Mazowiecki lost the presidential election because he had too many Jewish advisers. 
 Never mind that in the whole country there is only one functioning synagogue, with a congregation so small and old that it sometimes cannot muster a minyan. 
 But I suppose if you can have capitalism without capital, you can have anti-Semitism without Jews. 
 Still, the Poles appear determined to make a go of it. 
 I ask Elena how her business is, and she says it is very good. 
 I invite her to come and sit at a table with Kurowski and me, but she prefers to remain on duty at the bar. 
 Talk may be cheap, but her time is expensive, and, unless I pay her, she prefers to stay right where she is. 
 &bquo;Are you rich?&equo; she asks, and I assure her I am &mdash; which, this being Poland, is pro tempore true. 
 &bquo;You come with me,&equo; she says, &bquo;and I'll give you a night you'll never forget.&equo; 
 I pay, for I want to hear more of Elena's story, to compare it with what I learned earlier in the evening. 
 On the street outside the Marriott, in the rather rum section of town the locals affectionately have dubbed Pigalle Place, we had encountered Malgosia, a twenty-three-year-old prostitute, disembarking from a car. 
 &bquo;How's business?&equo; 
 I asked her. 
 &bquo;Not bad,&equo; she said, &bquo;Times are good.&equo; 
 There were fewer girls on the streets these days, she said, so the prices had risen. 
 Good old capitalistic supply and demand, I pointed out. 
 When I mentioned Aids as a possible reason, she looked blank. 
 &bquo;I get two hundred thousand zlotys for French, four hundred thousand for intercourse,&equo; she told us. 
 &bquo;I never go home with a man. 
 I'm too scared. 
 We look for a quiet, dark place, and we do it in the car.&equo; 
 Since Warsaw abounds in quiet, dark places, one doesn't have to expend much precious petrol to satisfy one's Malgosian urges. 
 Any problems with the police? 
 I asked. 
 Malgosia explained that street prostitution, while not exactly legal, is considered a victimless crime, and carries no penalty. 
 She has a health card, which she produces to the cops on demand. 
 But since nobody wants to be a cop in Poland these days &mdash; the pay stinks, and the people hate you &mdash; those occasions are few. 
 Malgosia, it turned out, is not from Warsaw, but from Lotz, an hundred and twenty kilometres away. 
 She comes into the capital a few nights a week, moonlighting from her day job, which is being a seamstress. 
 Her husband knows all about her vocation, and approves. 
 In Poland, of course, everybody has a second job. 
 Elena, by contrast, is an exception. 
 Hooking is her only business. 
 &bquo;I work two, maybe three, nights a week,&equo; she tells me on the way to the flat she shares professionally with Barbara. 
 &bquo;The rest of the time, I sleep. 
 When I am out all night, the next day I cannot do anything.&equo; 
 Kurowski stops the car at the flat, and the girls invite him upstairs. 
 He declines and asks whether I want him to wait for me. 
 Since my hotel is within sight, I tell him he can go. 
 The flat is rudely a furnished bedroom at the end of a dark hallway on the twenty-second floor of a downtown highrise. 
 The view is great, but the bed is small; no matter how they feel about each other, I wonder how Elena and Barbara sleep, or whatever, together in it. 
 I tell them I want only to talk, but, they &mdash; being dedicated professionals &mdash; think I am joking. 
 Barbara takes off her shirt and wraps a blue chiffon nightie around her waist; while Elena is in the loo, she opens her purse and shows me a picture of her six-year-old daughter. 
 Unlike Elena, Barbara speaks very little English, but she conveys her pride none the less. 
 &bquo;My girl,&equo; she says. 
 She smiles. 
 I tell her I have two little girls of my own. 
 For some reason, this strange conversation does not strike me as at all odd. 
 Elena returns, wearing only her knickers. 
 She sits on my lap, looks at the photograph and tells me her dream. 
 &bquo;I want to have a child too,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;But I had an operation&equo; &mdash; she gestures to her loins &mdash; &bquo;and I can't anymore. 
 So I must adopt. 
 I've gone to the nuns and begged them to let me have a child, but they say &bquo;You are a prostitute. 
 You cannot adopt.&equo; 
 I tell them I am making a good living, that I can support a child, that I want a baby more than anything, but they refuse.&equo; 
 She seems about to cry. 
 &bquo;You told them what you did for a living?&equo; 
 I ask, somewhat incredulously. 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; she replies. 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; 
 Suddenly, the flat-bell sounds. 
 Elena leaps to the intercom, says something in Polish and hits the entrance-buzzer discreetly. 
 The look in her eyes has grown gayer and more desperate. 
 I ask her who it is. 
 &bquo;It's nobody,&equo; she says, laughing. 
 &bquo;You take your clothes off now?&equo; she asks, and tugs at my tie. 
 Alarm bells sound in my head. 
 The reduced police presence in all the former socialist countries has brought with it an increase in crime, and I have no wish to boost the statistics. 
 I judge that in the time it takes the lift to creep the height of the building I have to be out the door and on my way. 
 &bquo;I've got to go,&equo; I tell Elena and rise to leave. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; she asks. 
 &bquo;Please, you stay.&equo; 
 She clutches at my arm. 
 As I leave, I tell the women to keep the money for the kids. 
 I throw on my overcoat and step into the pitch-black hall, take off my shoes and start to trot quietly down the twenty-two flights of steps. 
 On about the eighteenth floor, I hear the elevator doors open and voices cursing in Polish above. 
 Outside, the streets are nearly deserted, the Slavic moon's face nearly full. 
 Elena's parting words are ringing in my ears. 
 &bquo;What do you want?&equo; 
 I had asked her, as I disengaged her hand from mine. 
 Like a true capitalist, she had replied: &bquo;I want&hellip; everything.&equo;  
 Letter from Nowhere 
 by Victor Lewis-Smith 
 LOWESTOFT OR BUST 
 Wretched scenery, warm beer, plastic tumblers, toothless passengers&hellip; are we there yet? 
 I am standing on platform eleven at London's Liverpool Street station, listening to a British Rail Tannoy announcement, delivered as dispassionately and routinely as an abattoir attendant's delivering a bolt through the skull of yet another helpless, terrified, steer: &bquo;British Rail would like to apologize for the late running of the six-thirty to Lowestoft. 
 This is due to&hellip; 
 &equo; What could it be? 
 A single leaf on the line to Colchester? 
 The announcement continues unremarkably, &bquo;&hellip; engine trouble.&equo; 
 When the train eventually pulls in, I notice the name Sir John Betjeman, emblazoned on the side, and everything becomes clear. 
 Parkinson's disease, pernicious and contagious, affected not only the late Poet Laureate's motor functions, but seemingly also those of anything named after him. 
 Significantly, although this train is named after a bard who loved the towns and villages of East Anglia, a thorough search of his complete oeuvre fails to come up with a single reference to Lowestoft. 
 Small English seaside towns rarely receive favourable comment. 
 Brighton, as someone memorably said, looks like a town that is helping police with their inquiries. 
 If that is the case, then Lowestoft is undoubtedly the Blair Peach of coastal resorts. 
 Not only does the battered town seem to have been on the receiving end of a good deal of good, honest, no-nonsense coppering, but it gives the impression that a higher authority, God, must have passed over it in the Fifties, blasting it at close range with His celestial hair-drier, to judge from the universally blistered and leprous paintwork on all the buildings. 
 If I had not discovered through Exchange and Mart that Lowestoft was the home of the leading (and cheapest) breeder of Main Coon kittens in the country, I would not now be mounting the Sir John, clutching a cardboard box riddled with air holes and marked Pac-a-Pet. 
 The prospect of eventually arriving at such a gruesomely underwhelming destination makes me determined to enjoy every moment on the train. 
 Having been told by the gentleman at passenger enquiries that the Lowestoft train is one of the few in Britain to retain six-seater compartments, I am fully prepared to adopt my usual routine for such occasions; I intend to rush on, secure an empty compartment, slide the door behind me, adopt the brazen-hussy-like pose of an Amsterdam whore in her front window (tongue rolling out and knees wide apart, as I slouch across the upholstery), crook my index finger and beckon slowly at any commuters passing along the corridor outside who are considering invading my territory. 
 Such behaviour from an Amsterdam whore is generally regarded as a provocative come-on. 
 My hideous tableau vivant, however, will function as an equally effective go-away. 
 Who in his right mind would come and sit next to me? 
 Anyone would rather stand on one leg, crammed into the unheated guard's van for the entire journey, than spend one minute in my carriage. 
 A single glance and, one after the other, they will scurry away,  leaving me free to place hat, coat, newspaper, boots and Pac-a-Pet box over the remaining five seats and enjoy a journey of uninterrupted solitude. 
 Unfortunately, this is not to be, since it transpires that the gentleman from British Rail was nothing short of a duplicitous cad; there are no small compartments, just open-plan carriages too large to be defended by even the most outrageous behaviour, so I slump sullenly into a corner, wallowing in layers of dust and grime that would easily qualify for a Quentin Crisp kitemark, waiting for the guard to switch on the heat and the lights, preparatory to the departure of the Sir John. 
 A curious misnomer, the British Rail carriage light. 
 Guards should properly refer to &bquo;switching on the darks&equo;, since what they call lights seem expressly designed to suck all traces of illumination out of the carriage, casting shadows into every corner. 
 Through the dingy gloom of this motionless train, I catch a first glimpse of my fellow travellers. 
 At the moment, the train is static in more senses than one, as fifty City office-workers try simultaneously to detach their ninety-per-cent nylon polyamide jackets, which have statically fused to their hundred-per-cent nylon polyamide shirts, resulting in a display of electrostatics that I'm sure would surprise even Mr Van de Graaff himself. 
 People normally commute for one of two reasons: to live somewhere beautiful, or work somewhere glamorous. 
 But consider my fellow passengers, ill-starred wretches who have managed to get hold of a stick with two ends; they have succeeded in working and living in horrific places. 
 They work in the City and they live in Lowestoft; and, further, they spend three hours a day travelling between the two. 
 Lowestoft is a town twinned with nowhere, although it is considering a suicide pact with Basildon. 
 I look around me at the massed ranks of Lowestoftians, their vacant faces bearing mute witness to the devastation the town has wrought on their limbic systems. 
 For these people, the last word in radical chic is Brut Soap-on-a-Rope; they dress as though they have stepped straight from the pages of a Seventies mail-order catalogue; they consider a good night out to be crowding into the only working public telephone box, and, hyperventilating in their over-excitement, taking it in turns to listen to the talking clock. 
 For them a build-up of the primary manifestations of commuters' syndrome &mdash; tertiary dandruff and pyorrhoea of the gums &mdash; is regarded as being just a little bit natty. 
 The train sets off, and soon we are racing past the majestic fa&ccedil;ade of Romford station, gleaming out like Caesar's Palace in the Nevada Desert that is the Essex countryside. 
 Needless to say, the sight of such impressive architecture stimulates me, and I begin to contemplate on how rail travel has been a source of artistic inspiration to passengers for more than a century. 
 Trollope wrote The Barchester Chronicles during journeys; on a trip from Moscow to Paris, Stravinsky sketched The Rite of Spring; Cyril Connolly's The Unquiet Grave was conceived as the author gazed out of a carriage window. 
 In front of me, the noble tradition lives on in the hands of a middle-aged commuter who, peering intently into his 101 Puzzles and Games for Boys, is joining up the dots incorrectly. 
 The Tannoy announces the opening of the buffet, and up we get, not stopping for an instant to reflect that even standing in line for seven hours outside Moscow's GUM department store in pursuit of half a mouldy cabbage would be a more profitable venture than a futile pilgrimage to a British Rail catering outlet. 
 I join the queue that stretches back through three carriages, in pursuit of a warm can of Travellers' Fare lager &mdash; the only substance known to man that leaves the body in exactly the same state as it entered. 
 Thirty miles later, I finally reach the counter and get an opportunity to order my can of warm lager. 
 By now it has sold out, so I opt for a gin and tonic, at a price commensurate with a drink at the Ritz. 
 However, unlike at the Ritz, it is served without ice and a slice and &mdash; worse still &mdash; in a plastic beaker. 
 I ask the steward (who I notice has the words &bquo;Love&equo; and &bquo;Hate&equo; tattooed across the fingers of each hand) for a glass, but am told, &bquo;We don't give out anything sharp here&equo;. 
 I can quite understand his point of view, noticing the volatile ingredients for a riot are rapidly forming (forty miles to go, and only one giant chocolate-chip cookie among the three hundred remaining in the queue). 
 The swing-door dividing the buffet from the kitchen contains a central, circular pink-tinted window and, as I gaze through it at the catering staff, my eyes fall on a cross between Fassbinder's Querelle and one of Hieronymus Bosch's more frightening paintings. 
 Here is the quintessence of Rough Trade, personified by toothless Scottish ex-merchant seamen, clearly chosen not for their specialist knowledge of haute cuisine, but simply because of their sure-footedness on floors that list alternately from port to starboard. 
 But, to judge from the unsureness of their gait, they must have lost their sea legs somewhere between Sheffield and Colchester, perhaps after an incident involving a couple of bottles of Drambuie. 
 Like Querelle, men in tatty soiled uniforms are flexing their muscles, while others stare vacantly into the middle distance. 
 One is doing something with a Mouli not recommended by Prue Leith's School of Food and Wine diploma course; another is bending over a table; a third is spitting on to his palms. 
 Unfortunately a fourth hangs a tea-towel over the window at this point, obscuring my view. 
 The final cookie has been bought. 
 The queue disperses. 
 I find myself alone with the steward who tells me has been working on this line for the past twenty-five years. 
 &bquo;You must have come across some real characters on this train,&equo; I suggest. 
 &bquo;No, not one,&equo; he tells me. 
 A long silence. 
 &bquo;Well&hellip; maybe one,&equo; and he goes on to tell me that in 1967 he once served the Singing Postman (whose career was then in its ascendance, as a result of his seminal work &bquo;Av yew got a light, boy?&equo;) with a vodka and orange juice as he returned from a triumphant evening at the Ipswich Folk Club. 
 When I inform him that I read recently how the estimable gentleman had found the Lord and was living in a Salvation Army hostel in Grimsby, he wonders aloud whether the vodka and orange was not partly to blame. 
 The guilt of that rashly administered vodka, combined with a sense of shame at decades of serving up meals of such a consistency that it is impossible to tell where the food ends and the plate begins, is obviously weighing heavily on his shoulders. 
 I attempt to cheer him up by impersonating a Tannoy and announcing the train now arriving at platforms two, three, four, five and six coming in sideways. 
 He laughs forlornly and, as we pull in to Lowestoft station, tells me, in hushed conspiratorial tones, this riddle, popular among his colleagues on the Aberdeen run: 
 You have breakfast on the train at King's Cross, lunch at Peterborough and High Tea at Durham. 
 Where do you have dinner?&equo; 
 &bquo;Tell me.&equo; 
 &bquo;In hospital.&equo;  
 Laughing through hard times 
 Forget your troubles and just get happy and say hello to the hundred funniest people in Britain 
 OK, the world's not a comedy show at the moment, we admit. 
 The papers are filled with gloom and doom. 
 Companies are swimming in red ink; shop windows are covered with soap; the value of your house is heading towards the basement; unemployment is heading towards the roof. 
 On the High Street, the post-Christmas sales began in November, and they may well continue through to Easter. 
 Easter 1992. 
 The City is as jumpy as a cat. 
 Least funny of all, of course, was that no-laughing matter in the Gulf. 
 No, it's not exactly a joke out there. 
 And as for the future, the economist's forecast is about the same as the weatherman's: cloudy at best, more likely bleak. 
 So let us be serious: our purpose here is not to kid anybody, to try to convince you that things are any better than they seem. 
 They ain't. 
 It is, however, to suggest that we all take heart. 
 To heed the lessons of history. 
 To take comfort in the simple truth about Hard Times: that however rotten things might seem at the moment, they will most assuredly seem altogether quaint fifty years from now. 
 Let's look back, for a moment, at the Hard Times of the Thirties. 
 Unemployed millions. 
 Tent cities. 
 Soup queues. 
 Workers' protests. 
 Bodies jumping out of windows. 
 The sale of pencils on street corners. 
 But we did have fun. 
 Lots of it. 
 We had Fred and Ginger to lighten our load, as we settled our tattered bottoms into seats in grand, new palaces &mdash; the Astoria in Charing Cross, the Regal (now the Odeon) at Marble Arch &mdash; where we forgot our troubles in art-deco hotel suites, aboard cruise ships and in nightclubs, all gleaming and glittery on the silver screen. 
 An if we couldn't afford the price of admission, we found other distractions. 
 Funerals, for example. 
 Back in those Hard Times, funerals offered us the comfort  of knowing that, however tough it was for me and thee, there was always somebody who had it worse. 
 Funerals were free and open to all. 
 One woman back then was heard to say to another old granny, &bquo;There's a lovely funeral round the corner, ducks. 
 Go and cheer yourself up.&equo; 
 Some of us overcame the lethargy of our idleness to learn new skills (this was decades, obviously, before self-improvement became fashionable). 
 Young men formed neighbourhood jazz bands, creating uniforms out of cr&ecirc;pe paper and competing against one another for modest prices. 
 Others did what they could to scrape by. 
 If you think you've got it bad now, how would you like to be paid six shillings a ton to collect pebbles along the cold surf in Norfolk? 
 That, gentle people, was hardly a day at the beach. 
 But pebble-picking was preferable to other jobs. 
 There was one man near Tynemouth who was known as &bquo;Dead Bodies&equo;, so named because he earned seven and sixpence for collecting (by hook) the corpses of suicides who'd jumped from the Tyne Bridge, ten miles up-river. 
 It wasn't much but it was a living. 
 But even the morbid gave way to humour. 
 A joke went around about a passer-by who saw a man drowning in a canal. 
 He asked the victim where he worked, then left him to expire as he raced to the drowned man's place of employment. 
 He told the gaffer that one of his workers had died and asked the boss if he could have his job. 
 &bquo;Nay,&equo; came the reply. 
 &bquo;The man who pushed him in has got it.&equo; 
 And with that slice of humour, we are brought back to the present. 
 Yes, we are living in Hard Times; but no, let us not go gently on to that good ledge. 
 Let us instead sing the praises of those who get us to smile &mdash; the Hundred Funniest (say we) People in Britain: those indomitable men and women who help us to cackle through our tears, and who, while they don't make the bad times any better, certainly make them hurt less.  
 vic reeves: bruce forsyth on acid 
 It isn't easy getting across Vic Reeves' special brand of music-hall humour, but here goes. 
 One night the judge on the show's talent competition &bquo;Novelty Island&equo;, turned out to be the pop star Mick Hucknall's orange hair resting on an oar. 
 Get it? 
 Then there was the time Vic and company decided to detonate a smorgasbord of Spam and boiled sweets. 
 That's right, they blew them up! 
 And then there was this memorable exchange: &bquo;Vic, can I have a couple of words please?&equo; 
 &bquo;Certainly,&equo; he replies, &bquo;rifle and marzipan.&equo; 
 When it comes to Vic Reeves, you have to be there. 
 Martin Amis 
 Clive Anderson 
 Julie Baloo 
 Tony Banks 
 Nancy Banks-Smith 
 Lynn Barber 
 Glen Baxter 
 Steve Bell 
 Alan Bennett 
 Judy Blame 
 victor lewis-smith and paul sparks: absurdists 
 Victor Lewis-Smith has elevated bad taste into an art form. 
 When he &bquo;resigned&equo; as a BBC radio producer in 1986, he may have been pushed, but it was the start of a freelance career guaranteed to outrage the good citizens of Britain with a style of comedy that ranges from the macabre to the indecent. 
 Highlights of Victor's broadcasting career including having a simulated erection on live television while dressed as Batman. 
 He once said of himself and his writing partner Paul Sparks, &bquo;We have almost no shame&equo;. 
 That's true. 
 And forget the almost. 
 Bernard Manning Bernard Mathews Rik Mayall FUNNY, FOR NORTH AMERICANS Jackie Mason Steve Martin Robin Williams Mike McShane John Candy Colin Bostock-Smith Jo Brand Coral Browne Craig Brown Clive Bull Maria Callous Copywriter for the Carling Black Label advertising campaign  
 keith allen: ringsider 
 Allen has no peer when it comes to unmasking the self-delusion and primitive posturing of the modern British dickhead. 
 The best example is Larry &bquo;Ringside&equo; Lewis. 
 Larry covers &bquo;working-class sport for the working classes&equo;, one of his classics being the time he reported on the local-government elections in Westminster. 
 Approaching Dame Shirley Porter, she of the generously ample proboscis, Larry chipped in: &bquo;I think it's absolutely marvellous you bothered to turn up. 
 I tell you this is one of the greatest days for me, as I've been a Barbra Streisand fan for years. 
 Give us a song!&equo; 
 Antoine des Caunes 
 Craig Charles 
 John Cleese 
 Robbie Coltrane 
 Billy Connolly 
 Alan Coren 
 Julian Critchley 
 Richard Curtis 
 Jack Dee 
 Angus Deayton 
 Charles Grodin 
 Robert De Niro 
 FUNNY WHEN DRUNK 
 Oliver Reed 
 Denis Thatcher 
 FUNNY WHEN SOBER 
 Jim and Tammy Baker 
 Jimmy Swaggart 
 The Pope 
 rsm marcham: comic force 
 What do you call a fast-talking, no-nonsense, shoot-from-the-hip regimental sergeant major with a twitching swagger stick in his hand? 
 Sir! 
 RSM Steve Marcham, responsible for discipline at the Guards Depot at Pirbright in Surrey, gets results by quoting Kipling and with bayonet-sharp humour. 
 He also scared the daylights out of us when he said: &bquo;If you put down anything I don't like, I'll hunt you down like a shit-house rat&equo;. 
 Yes, Sir! 
 Chris Donald 
 Jenny Eclair 
 Ben Elton 
 Harry Enfield 
 Fluck and Law 
 Bruce Forsyth's hair 
 Dawn French 
 Stephen Fry 
 Jimmy Greaves 
 Jeremy Hardy 
 FUNNY LOOKING, BUT NOT FUNNY 
 Emo Philips 
 FUNNY, BUT DEAD 
 Tommy Cooper 
 Jackie Gleason 
 Sid James 
 Peter Sellers 
 Kenneth Williams 
 sandi toksvig: nimble wit 
 What she lacks in sartorial sense she makes up in fun. 
 She became a comic because &bquo;I couldn't act&equo;. 
 She practises her craft by saying &bquo;the first funny thing that comes into your head, and if that's not funny you say the second&equo;. 
 Her most ingenious moment on Whose Line Is It Anyway? was one the public never saw: &bquo;We once did the nativity play in which I portrayed a paranoid shepherd convinced I wasn't following a star, it was following me.&equo; 
 peter cook: the godfather 
 Peter Cook says he started making people laugh in order to disarm bigger boys at school. 
 That did not, however, stop Ted Dexter, now chairman of the English cricket selectors, from caning him when Cook was discovered tippling. 
 Cook's impudence sparkled in Private Eye, and he turned language and manners upside down with &bquo;Pete and Dud&equo; and &bquo;Derek and Clive&equo;. 
 It's sobering to ponder that if Cook had followed family tradition and joined the foreign service, he'd be running the country by now. 
 Michael Heath 
 Ian Hislop 
 Jools Holland 
 Frankie Howerd 
 Sean Hughes 
 Barry Humphries 
 Clive James 
 Hanif Kureishi 
 Hugh Laurie 
 john hegley: stand-up poet 
 For a moment you think &bquo;this is going to be serious stuff&equo;. 
 The manner is laconic yet earnest. 
 The poems are delivered with the pompous self-importance of an obscure poet addressing a small band of intellectuals. 
 But Hegley's poetry isn't merely accessible; as the absurdity of the lines builds in counterpoint to the serious manner, it becomes very, very funny indeed. 
 The pop Poet Laureate of the cabaret circuit, Hegley chooses subjects which range from McDonalds to the Gulf War, taking in on the way a whole range of everyday tragedies: 
 The other day I met a bloke 
 Lying on the pavement. 
 He'd just had a stroke 
 And I thought a man in his position 
 Might appreciate a joke. 
 So I said &bquo;Stand back please, 
 I'm a comedian&equo;. 
 Garry Sadowiz Helen Lederer Jim Davidson's Chalkie Joke Michael Barrimore FUNNY FARMERS Benny FUNNY FACIAL HAIR Cilla Black Jimmy Edwards Lucinda Lambton Josie Lawrence Mike Leigh Maureen Lipman John Lloyd David Lodge Jonathan Meades Paul Merton Spike Milligan  
 john walters: raconteur 
 It's frightening to imagine John Walters on ginseng. 
 He is a magpie possessed with singular vision. 
 &bquo;I'm like the man who builds St Paul's Cathedral out of matchsticks,&equo; he says. 
 Good going, we say. 
 His humour is in the Comedy of Manners tradition. 
 &bquo;I was having a pub lunch recently and noticed a thumbprint of food on the edge of the plate. 
 I called the waitress over and told her: &bquo;This plate seems to have some of yesterday's fish-pie on it.&equo; 
 Irate, she scowled and said: &bquo;That's not yesterday's.&equo; 
 Warren Mitchell 
 Bob Mortimer 
 Rob Newman 
 George O'Dowd 
 Michael Palin 
 Pet Shop Boys 
 Danny Peacock 
 John Peel 
 David Profumo 
 Griff Rhys Jones 
 Denis Healey 
 Norman Lamont 
 John McCrirrick 
 the men who know: wise guys 
 There is a terrible secret in the lives of Michael Magenis and Martin Plimmer: they are serious journalists. 
 Not that you would realize that when you hear The Men Who Know. 
 This is the ultimate double act. 
 These two don't just share a routine, they share each sentence, until the mind reels and the laughter explodes. 
 They may be the dual hemispheres of cerebral comedy, but when asked what makes them funny, they replied, &bquo;We don't drink sherry and listen to Texan polkas&equo;. 
 Peter Richardson Roland Rivron Tony Robinson Jennifer Saunders John Sessions Michael Sherrard QC Ned Sherrin Dennis Skinner Tony Slattery Arthur Smith  
 kit hollerbach: loudmouth 
 American Kit Hollerbach's in-your-face humour plays both sides of the pond. 
 Resident in the UK, she's as comfortable mocking the English (&bquo;I'm married to an English guy. 
 He's typical in that he's very reserved. 
 In fact, it wasn't until after we were married I knew he wanted to go out with me&equo;), as she is the Yanks (&bquo;American tourists talk so loudly so they can be heard above their clothes&equo;). 
 Maggie Smith 
 Mel Smith 
 John Sullivan 
 Theo Vidal 
 Julie Walters 
 Auberon Waugh 
 Ruby Wax 
 Paul Whitehouse 
 Kipper Williams 
 Barbara Windsor 
 Victoria Wood 
 Sweden on two herrings a day 
 by Bill Bryson 
 Things could always be worse: your cheap train journey to G&ouml;teborg could be one-way 
 A reddish-brown train was waiting at Helsingborg to take us on to G&ouml;teborg, two hundred and forty-three kilometres north, along the west coast. 
 We travelled through a landscape of low hills, red barns, small towns with mustard-coloured town halls, immense pine forests, scattered lakes dotted with clapboard holiday cottages, jetties upturned rowing boats. 
 Occasionally the train would swing near the coast and give a glimpse through the trees of a cold sea. 
 Rain began to streak the window. 
 I shared a compartment with a tanned young man, blond as only a Swede can be, in wire-rimmed glasses and a pony-tail, who was returning to G&ouml;teborg from Algeciras, where he had been visiting a girlfriend, as he put it. 
 Actually she was a former girlfriend, and he hadn't exactly visited her, because upon arriving he discovered she was living with an Algerian rug merchant &mdash; she had somehow neglected to mention this in her postcards &mdash; who had pulled out a scimitar and threatened to send the Swede home with his goolies in a sandwich bag if he didn't clear off instantly. 
 Considering that he had just made a pointless journey of several thousand miles, the young man seemed remarkably equable and spent almost the entire journey sitting cross-legged, spooning purple yoghurt into his mouth from an enormous jar and reading a novel by Thomas Mann. 
 At &Aring;ngelholm, we were joined by two more people, a grim-looking older woman all in black, who looked as if she hadn't smiled since  1937 and who spent the entire journey watching me as if she had seen my face on a wanted poster, and by a fastidious older man who I guessed to be a recently retired schoolmaster and took an instant dislike to. 
 The young Swede was sitting in the schoolmaster's reserved seat. 
 Not only did the schoolmaster make him move, but he instructed him to transfer all his personal effects from the luggage rack above the seat to the rack on the other side, which takes a particular kind of pettiness, don't you think. 
 The schoolmaster then spent an endless period fussily sorting out his things &mdash; extracting a folded newspaper and a small bag of plums from his case, arranging the case on the rack, examining the seat minutely for anything unpleasant and giving it a brush with the back of his hand, folding his jacket and his jumper with ritualistic care, adjusting the window in consultation with the lady, but without reference to me or to the young Swede, getting his case down again for some forgotten item, checking his hankie, readjusting the window. 
 Every time he bent over, his ass bobbed in my face. 
 How I longed for a Smith &amp; Wesson. 
 And every time I looked round, there would be that old crone watching me like the Daughter of Death. 
 And so the morning passed. 
 I fell into one of those drooly, head-lolling dozes that seem to be more and more a feature of my advancing years. 
 When I awoke, I discovered that my companions were also snoozing. 
 The schoolmaster was snoring raspily, his mouth hugely agape. 
 I noticed that my swaying foot had rubbed against him, leaving a dusty mark on his navy trousers. 
 I further discovered, with cautious movements of my foot, that it was possible to extend the mark from just above his knee almost to his ankle, leaving an interesting streak on the trouser leg. 
 In this way, I amused myself for some minutes until I turned my head a fraction and discovered that the old lady was watching me. 
 Immediately, I pretended to be asleep, knowing that if she uttered a sound I would have to smother her with my jacket. 
 But she said nothing. 
 And so the afternoon passed. 
 I hadn't eaten since my snackette supper the night before and I was so hungry that I would have eaten almost anything, even a plate of my grandmother's famously awful creamed ham and carrots, the only dish I know to have been inspired by vomit. 
 Late in the afternoon, a porter came along with a creaking trolley carrying a coffee urn and snackstuffs, and everyone stirred to a kind of frisky wakefulness and examined the fare keenly. 
 I had twenty-four kronor of Swedish money, which I thought a handsome sum, but it proved sufficient to buy only one hopelessly modest open sandwich, like the bottom half of a hamburger bun with a menopausal piece of lettuce and eight marble-sized meatballs on top. 
 Eating in Sweden is really just a series of heartbreaks. 
 I bought the sandwich and carefully peeled away the Cellophane, but just as I lifted it to my mouth the train lurched violently over a siding, making the bottles clatter in the drinks trolley and causing all the meatballs to jump off the bun, like sailors abandoning a burning ship. 
 I watched with dismay as they hit the floor and bounced to eight dusty oblivions. 
 I'd have scarcely thought it possible, but the lady in black found a look of even deeper contempt for me. 
 The schoolmaster skittishly slid his feet out of the way, lest a meatball come to rest against his glossy brogues. 
 Only the young Swede and the attendant took a sympathetic interest and pointed helpfully as I gathered up the meatballs and deposited them in the ashtray. 
 This done, I nibbled bleakly on my piece of lettuce and dry bun and dreamed of being almost anywhere else in the universe. 
 Only two and a half hours more to go, I told myself, and fixed the old lady with a hard stare that I hoped somehow conveyed to her what pleasure, what deep and lasting pleasure, it would give me to haul her off her seat and push her out the window. 
 We reached G&ouml;teborg just after six. 
 Rain was belting down, drumming like bullets through the gutters. 
 I sprinted across the open square outside the station, jacket over head, dodging tramcars with split-second, if largely inadvertent, precision, skirted a large puddle, feinted between two parked cars, head-faked a lamppost and two startled elderly shoppers (once I start running, I can't stop myself from pretending I'm returning a kick-off for the Chicago Bears; it's a compulsion &mdash; a sort of Tourette's syndrome of the feet). 
 Then I darted breathless and sodden into the first hotel I came to. 
 A vertical puddle, I stood in the lobby, wiped the steam from my glasses with a corner of shirt-tail and realized with a touch of horror, as I hooked my glasses back around my ears, that this was much too grand a place for me. 
 It had potted palms and everything. 
 For a moment I considered bolting, but I noticed that a young reptilian reception-clerk was watching me narrowly, as if he thought I might roll up a carpet and try to carry it out under my arm, and I became instantly obstreperous. 
 I was damned if some nineteen-year-old pipsqueak with zits and a clip-on tie was going to make me feel loathsome. 
 I marched to the front desk and enquired the price of single room for one night. 
 He quoted me the sort of sum that would necessitate a trip to the bank with a wheelbarrow if paid in cash. 
 &bquo;I see,&equo; I said, trying to sound casual. 
 &bquo;I assume the room has a private bath and colour TV?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course.&equo; 
 &bquo;Free shower-cap?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Assortment of complimentary bath gels and unguents in a little wicker basket by the sink?&equo; 
 &bquo;Certainly, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sewing-kit? 
 Trouser-press?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hair-drier?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sir.&equo; 
 I played my trump card. 
 &bquo;Magic-wipe disposable shoe-sponge?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sir.&equo; 
 Shit. 
 I had been counting on his saying no to at least one of those, so that I could issue a hollow guffaw and depart, shaking my head ruefully; but he did not, and I had no choice but to slink away or sign in. 
 I signed in. 
 The room was pleasant and business-like, but small, with a twenty-watt reading light &mdash; when will Europeans learn that this is just not good enough? &mdash; a small TV, a clock radio, a good bath with a shower. 
 I tipped all the lotions from the bathroom into my rucksack, then tossed in the little wicker basket, too &mdash; well, why not? &mdash; and went through the room harvesting matchbooks, stationery and all the other items that were either complimentary or portable. 
 This done, I ventured out into G&ouml;teborg, still famished. 
 The rain was still falling in sheets. 
 I had thought I might stroll out towards the famous Liseberg Gardens, but I got no more than a couple of hundred yards before I was turned back by the pitiless downpour. 
 I trudged back to the city centre and tried to have a look around the main shopping district, forced  to sprint squelchily from doorway to doorway and from one dripping awning to another; but it was hopeless. 
 I wanted a restaurant, one simple wholesome restaurant, but there seemed to be none. 
 I was soaked and shivering and was about to return in a desultory spirit to my hotel to take whatever food was offered there at whatever price, when I noticed an indoor shopping centre and darted in, shaking myself out like a dog. 
 The shops were mostly dreary Woolworth-type places, and they were all shut, but there was a surprising number of people wandering around, as if this were some kind of marvellous place to take an evening stroll. 
 There were a lot of young drunks staggering about, too &mdash; most at that noisy and unattractive stage where they might want to be your pal or pick a fight or just throw up on you, so I gave them a wide berth. 
 In Sweden and Norway you have two countries where you cannot buy a beer without taking a bank loan, yet everywhere you go you see grossly intoxicated people &mdash; in train stations, on park benches, in shopping centres. 
 I don't begin to understand it. 
 They have the highest income-tax and VAT rates, the harshest drinking laws, the dreariest bars, the dullest restaurants and television that makes you feel as if you are warming up for a coma. 
 Everything costs a fortune. 
 Everything. 
 Even the purchase of a bar of chocolate leaves you staring in dismay at your change, and anything larger than that brings tears of pain to your eyes. 
 It's bone-crackingly cold in the winter, and it does nothing but rain for the rest of the year. 
 The most fun thing to do in the whole country is walk around semi-darkened shopping centres after they have closed, looking at the windows of stores selling platoons of wheelbarrows and plastic garden furniture. 
 On top of that, they have shackled themselves with some of the most inane and restrictive laws imaginable, laws that leave you wondering what on earth they were thinking about. 
 In Norway, for instance, it is illegal for a barman to serve you a fresh drink until after you have finished the previous one. 
 Does that sound to you like a matter that needs to be covered by legislation? 
 It is also illegal in Norway for a bakery to bake bread on a Saturday or Sunday. 
 Well, thank God for that, I say. 
 Think of the cataclysmic consequences that could befall the nation if some ruthless Norwegian baker tried to foist fresh bread on people on the weekend. 
 But the most preposterous law of all, a law so pointless as to scamper along the outer margins of the surreal, is the Swedish one that requires motorists to drive with their headlights on during the daytime, even on the sunniest summer afternoon. 
 I should love to meet the guy who thought up that one. 
 He must be head of the Department of Dreariness. 
 It wouldn't surprise me at all if on my next visit to Sweden all the pedestrians were wearing miners' lamps. 
 I ended up dining in a Pizza Hut in the basement of the shopping centre, the only customer in the place. 
 I had forgotten to bring anything to read with me, so I passed the time by staring thoughtfully at the emptiness around me, sipping a glass of water and making up Scandinavian riddles &mdash; 
 Q. How many Swedes does it take to paint a wall? 
 A. Twenty-seven. 
 One to do the painting and twenty-six to organize the spectators. 
 Q. What does a Norwegian do when he wants to get tight? 
 A. He takes the filter off his cigarette. 
 Q. What is the quickest way in Sweden to get the riot police to your house? 
 A. Don't take your library book back on time. 
 Q. There are two staples in the Swedish diet. 
 One is the herring. 
 What is the other? 
 A. The herring. 
 &mdash; and chuckling quietly in the semi-demented manner of someone who is sitting alone in damp clothes in an empty restaurant in a strange country waiting for a twenty-five-dollar pizza. 
 Afterwards, to make an evening of it, I went to the railway station to buy a ticket on the next morning's express to Stockholm. 
 You cannot just hop on a train in Sweden, but must think about it carefully and purchase a ticket in advance. 
 The ticket hall had one of those systems where you take a number from a machine by the door and wait for it to appear above one of the ticket windows. 
 My number was four hundred and fifteen, and the highest number seeing action was three hundred and ninety-one. 
 I waited for twenty minutes, and the numbers advanced only to three hundred and ninety-three, so I wandered off to the station newsagent's to look at girlie magazines. 
 The newsagent's, alas, was closed, so I looked at a couple of travel posters, then wandered back. 
 Not entirely to my surprise, I discovered there had been a frenzy of activity in my absence, and number four hundred and fifteen had come and gone. 
 So I took another &mdash; four hundred and thirty this time &mdash; and a seat and waited for half an hour. 
 When at last my number came, I presented myself at the window and asked for a ticket on the 10.05 to Stockholm the next morning. 
 The man regarded my sadly. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, I do not speak English,&equo; he said. 
 I was taken aback. 
 &bquo;Everybody in Sweden speaks English,&equo; I protested feebly. 
 His sadness grew. 
 &bquo;I don't. 
 Please you must go to window sree.&equo; 
 He indicated a window farther down the line. 
 &bquo;She speaks vair good English.&equo; 
 I went to window three and asked for a ticket to Stockholm the next morning. 
 The woman, seeing the number 430 crumpled in my fist, pointed to the number above her window. 
 &bquo;You have the wrong number. 
 This window is for number four three six.&equo; 
 Even as she spoke, a ferocious-looking lady with grey hair and a dicky hip was hoisting herself out of her chair and charging towards me. 
 I tried to explain my problem with the monoglot at window five, but the ticket lady just shook her head and said: &bquo;You must take another ticket. 
 Then maybe I will call you. 
 Now I must deal with this lady.&equo; 
 &bquo;You are at zer wrong window!&equo; the old lady announced in the bellow of someone whose hearing is going. 
 &bquo;This is my window,&equo; she added and tossed a haughty look to the rest of the room as if to say, &bquo;Are foreigners as stupid as shit, or what?&equo; 
 Forlornly, I shuffled over to the machine and took another number. 
 In fact, I took three &mdash; I figured this would give me some insurance &mdash; then retired to a new seat to watch the board. 
 What a lot of fun I was having! 
 Eventually, my number came around again. 
 It directed me to return to window number five &mdash; home of the only man in Sweden who speaks no English. 
 I crumpled this ticket and waited for the next to be called. 
 But he called the next one, too. 
 I scampered to his window and begged him not to call my remaining number, but he did. 
 I couldn't bear to start the whole thing all over again. 
 &bquo;Please,&equo; I said, speaking carefully, &bquo;I just want a one-way ticket to Stockholm for tomorrow morning at 10.05.&equo; 
 &bquo;Certainly,&equo; he said, as if he had never seen me before, took my money and gave me a ticket. 
 It's no wonder so many Swedes kill themselves.  
 Documentary 
 Seth Morgan's last ride 
 He went from the straight side to the wild side without turning back. 
 He braked for drugs, booze, and hookers, and wrote a good book about a bum existence. 
 Then, with a girl who loved him on the seat of his bike, he came to a bridge he was never to cross. 
 by Mike Capuzzo 
 In his life, as in his art, Seth Morgan created an appealing fiction &mdash; the same appealing fiction. 
 His legacy as an artist is contained in a single novel, Homeboy, the tale of a charming, drug-addicted, dope-dealing, pimping, strip-show barker who finds salvation, gets the girl (the whore with the heart of gold), and rides his motorcycle into the sunset and, presumably, a happy ending. 
 Seth was himself a charming drug-addicted, dope-dealing, pimping, strip-show barker who found what looked like salvation and wrote the novel that won him acclaim and rebirth. 
 Then he got the girl (the bartender with the heart of gold) and rode his motorcycle into&hellip; well, an ending. 
 Only five months after The New York Times anointed him &bquo;an important new novelist&equo;, an heir to William Burroughs and Henry Miller, Seth Morgan &mdash; drunk, fucked up on Percodan and cocaine, bankrupt, his nose newly broken, his face joined by twenty-five fresh stitches, lonesome as hell &mdash; climbed on his Harley and began his final ride. 
 He had been roaming New Orleans, his adopted city, for two days. 
 He aimed his red-and-white bike down Decatur Street, towards a small brick pub in the Quarter, searching for his last friend. 
 The night before, alone and drunk, he turned the Harley the wrong way on to busy St Peter Street downtown and rode awhile through oncoming traffic until a policeman mercifully stopped him. 
 He was arrested and booked into the city jail for driving while intoxicated. 
 There was only one person left for him to call. 
 Suzy Levine and Seth had been lovers when he was writing Homeboy, best friends ever since. 
 She was known to all in the French Quarter for her good looks, her own hard-luck story (two marriages, two troubled kids, a problem with drink) and the soft spot she had for the hard-luck stories of others, poets in particular. 
 &bquo;All he needs is someone to take care of him,&equo; she would always say of Seth, but lately she hadn't been so sure. 
 He'd been on the binge of all time, wrecking cars, hitting her, almost breaking two of her fingers. 
 But she couldn't say no, so somehow she raised the five hundred dollars to bail him out. 
 Now she was winding down another dead shift at the Decatur House bar, four customers on the dregs, drinking a little herself to get through the night. 
 Near the end of the evening, Seth showed up on the Harley, bombed. 
 Grinning, he stumbled towards the bar. 
 She was terrified. 
 He wanted to take her for a ride. 
 No way I'm gettin' on that fuckin' motorcycle with you,&equo; she said. 
 She said it over and over. 
 He went behind the bar, grabbing at her. 
 He could barely stand. 
 Suzy called a couple of friends, hoping to find someone to rescue her. 
 None of them answered. 
 Suzy poured shots for Seth and herself. 
 The other patrons left. 
 At 11.30 pm, a few regulars stopped by to find the door locked. 
 Through the window, they saw empty glasses on the bar, dishes in the sink, the TV on. 
 It looked as if someone had left in a hurry.  
 Not long after that, witnesses near the St Claude Avenue Bridge, eight miles away, reported seeing a man and a woman go by on a motorcycle. 
 The man was driving very fast. 
 The woman was holding on to him with one arm, and with the other she was pounding him on the back, very hard. 
 The tale of salvation begins as all good ones do, with high birth and great promise. 
 Seth Morgan was born in 1949, the son of Frederick Morgan of Park Avenue, poet, a founder of The Hudson Review quarterly, heir to a fortune built on soap. 
 As a boy, Seth listened in as his father chatted philosophy and poetry with friends like e e cummings, Robert Lowell, Dylan Thomas. 
 Seth was a bright child with a genius for wordplay and a talent for trouble; he bounced a devil-may-care swathe through &eacute;lite private academies in New York, Connecticut and Switzerland. 
 Vocational training was not a high priority, thanks to his artistic bent, but also to the trust that would supply, at the very least, his mad money &mdash; between twenty six and thirty thousand dollars a year. 
 Seth was also blessed with good looks and lady-killer charm, which brought many high adventures his way. 
 He commenced one such exploit in 1970, when he dropped out of Berkeley to move in with singer Janis Joplin, whom he had met while making a cocaine delivery to her Marin County house. 
 Joplin was crazy about Seth, and called City Hall to enquire about a marriage licence. 
 According to Buried Alive, the 1973 biography of the singer by Myra Friedman, Joplin pleaded with Seth to force her to stop taking heroin, but he thought it was simply a play for more attention. 
 After Joplin's death, Morgan's notorious appeal won him many hearts, among them that of an unlucky waitress in Sausalito. 
 Drunk one day, driving her on his Harley, he slammed into a house that had once belonged to Jack London. 
 The crash left his girlfriend's face partially paralysed; Seth later said he married her in part so she wouldn't sue him. 
 His descent continued: his job talking rubes into a San Francisco strip-club was his most reputable career during a period in which he also became a heroin addict, a pimp for his next bride and an armed robber (he once pinned a victim's hand to the floor with a knife). 
 In 1977, he pleaded guilty to one caper and was sentenced to jail. 
 In an interview to promote his book, Morgan acknowledged that he had spent years &bquo;under the influence of cocaine, planning the strategic degradation of women&equo;. 
 He blamed his mother, an alcoholic beauty who drank herself to death in 1964, and who, he said, raised her sons with such coldness that Seth's brother leaped to his death off the Oakland Bay Bridge. 
 Middle child Seth called himself &bquo;an addictive personality growing up in an alcoholic household&equo;, honing his skills of deceit and manipulation. 
 He was released from prison after thirty months, returned to his barker's job in San Francisco and took up with a stripper. 
 Life went on that way until 1986, when he moved to New Orleans, where he first received notice for being arrested twice in six months for driving while intoxicated. 
 The second time, he collided with a police wagon. 
 &bquo;He was funny as shit, very polite, always smashed,&equo; says Barbara Cruthirds, the lawyer who represented him. 
 &bquo;He told us he had dated Joplin. 
 He told us he was writing a book. 
 He was always loaded, so I'd say, &bquo;Okay, sure, Seth.&equo; 
 We didn't believe a word he said.&equo; 
 The arrests gave Seth a record of at least nine drink driving incidents, leading the judge to order him into Alcoholics Anonymous and on to two years' probation. 
 &bquo;On my last legs,&equo; Seth wrote later, &bquo;I hied down to New Orleans to drink myself quietly to death, and nearly did, but something awoke in me and I wrote a book instead.&equo; 
 Although writing was to become his new addiction, he had actually started his novel (working title Dead Man Walkin') when he lived in San Francisco. 
 He had even won a writing prize while in prison for a story on Joplin's last days. 
 But it was in New Orleans, when the alcoholic fog lifted for a while, that he wrote eleven hundred pages in a four-month period ending in early 1987. 
 Jason Epstein, the editorial director at Random House and a friend of Seth's father, took an interest, helping Seth to pare the book down to a readable length, then publishing Homeboy. 
 Random House expected a modest d&eacute;but for the novel, even deciding against a publicity tour. 
 Then, on May 6, 1990, Seth was reborn on the front page of The New York Times book review. 
 The reviewer called him a &bquo;Joycean Hell's Angel&equo; who had created from the tawdry San Francisco Tenderloin district &bquo;an unnerving and utterly persuasive rendition of hell&equo;. 
 In April, American GQ published a credulous profile of Morgan &mdash; &bquo;The Degradation and Miraculous Redemption of the Hoodlum Heir&equo; &mdash; and an excerpt from his book, which it described as &bquo;a flamboyant crime novel&hellip; that has New York publishing circles comparing him to Emile Zola, Ken Kesey and Nelson Algren&equo;. 
 Seth's new career earned him a fifty-thousand dollar advance for the paperback edition, and a European version was in the works. 
 His agent was also negotiating a four hundred and twenty-five thousand-dollar movie deal, with Johnny Depp rumoured to star. 
 While all this good fortune unfolded,  Seth said he was hard at work on his next novel, Mambo Mephiste, this one set in New Orleans. 
 He had gone clean and sober with a fury, he swore, up at five-thirty every morning to work out at the Y, at his word processor to write by six-thirty, stopping only to watch CNN during lunch &bquo;to connect with the world&equo;. 
 His relationship with his father was whole again. 
 And in this way the aristocrat who had fallen to the low road returned &mdash; now sober, repentant, well-heeled &mdash; to the world in which he was born. 
 It was an appealing fiction. 
 But had anyone in New York thought to look in New Orleans, it would have been clear that his life was as disorderly as ever. 
 In March he had been sought by police for crashing his '66 Corvette Sting-Ray into a car he was trying to pass and then driving away. 
 A week after the hit-and-run, Seth was so drunk that police were able to determine he was drunk in charge while he sat idling his Vette in front of a friend's house. 
 On the same day the New York Times carried the review that launched his career, the Times-Picayune of New Orleans had Seth calling himself an &bquo;addict alcoholic&equo; and &bquo;a con man&hellip; 
 If I don't create, I destroy. 
 I'll destroy loved ones close to me personally, and once I empty the stage of everyone else, I'll get to work on Seth Morgan.&equo; 
 But the stage was not emptied yet. 
 It was around this time that Seth began a new romance, with Susan Schilling, a preacher's daughter he met at the dentist's. 
 She is an thirty-nine-year-old actress and model with three children from two marriages, a tall blue-eyed blonde. 
 &bquo;I was his good girl, the girl to take to book signings, to introduce to Norman Mailer,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;He'd tell me I was the nicest woman he'd ever been with. 
 I told him that's not saying much &mdash; I'm just not a junkie or an alcoholic or a prostitute. 
 He always presented himself as the redeemed bad boy, but it was a lie, she says. 
 She learned how much of a lie in August, when she went to Seth's house and walked in on what she later called &bquo;a horror show&equo;. 
 &bquo;I was stunned. 
 Seth was paying guys to have sex with junkies or prostitutes. 
 He was shooting cocaine into a woman's vein and watching the women perform sex acts for him. 
 It was really so incredibly humiliating. 
 I called them his sex circuses. 
 &bquo;Of course, when he was on a binge he was in no shape to have sex, so he brought it in. 
 He liked to watch. 
 He'd tell me, &bquo;It's just the drugs.&equo; 
 I'd say, &bquo;Bullshit. 
 I'm your girlfriend. 
 Can't you see how I'd feel so degraded? 
 I'm not so proud he was my boyfriend.&equo; 
 He tried to patch things up by buying her a ten-thousand-dollar light-blue 1984 Cadillac &mdash; the colour of her eyes. 
 Some days later, Seth appeared at her door. 
 &bquo;He told me to look out of the window &mdash; he had stolen my car, the car he bought for me. 
 He was using my car to pick up another girlfriend at the airport. 
 I said, &bquo;Seth, let me help you over this&equo;.&equo; 
 Instead, he drove away in the , ran over a kerb, got a flat tyre and kept going &mdash; to pick up Vicky Vanderford, whom he had flown in from California. 
 word apparently missing 
 Vanderford was the stripper he had lived with for three years in San Francisco, starting in 1980, when he got out of jail. 
 &bquo;Any bit of education or speaking I know I learned from Seth,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;I didn't get much schooling. 
 Books, opera, it was Seth who taught me. 
 I had an addiction to heroin, thanks to Seth, too.&equo; 
 Seth had sent for Vicky four years earlier, when he first came to New Orleans, and they had lived together for six months. 
 &bquo;He wanted to marry me &mdash; he told me I was all he needed to make his life perfect. 
 Now he told me he wanted to end it with Susan, and he begged my help and would I come down to New Orleans.&equo; 
 That Friday night he picked her up at the airport and brought her home, but fifteen minutes after they got there, &bquo;some guys showed up to sell Seth cocaine. 
 And then he started doing coke. 
 That went on all night. 
 He was writing hundred-dollar, two hundred-dollar cheques every hour. 
 All Friday, Saturday and Sunday we were at the house, and he was shooting cocaine all the time &mdash; shooting it.&equo; 
 There was drug paraphernalia all over the house. 
 On Saturday, a drug dealer brought his whole family over to use the pool. 
 Assorted addicts and alcoholics drifted in and out of the place. 
 By Sunday night, Vicky realized Seth wasn't planning to settle down and marry anytime soon. 
 She left the house and visited a friend at a Bourbon Street bar. 
 Before long, Seth showed up, apologetic. 
 He was in the company of his Percodan connection. 
 By Monday morning, Seth's two cocaine suppliers were calling, furious. 
 &bquo;He'd been writing cheques all weekend on a closed account,&equo; Vicky says. 
 &bquo;Between the two of them, he owed between three and a half and four and a half thousand dollars, just for cocaine for that weekend.&equo; 
 That morning, Vicky demanded a bus ticket home to San Francisco. 
 &bquo;I'd seen him like that so many times before, but at least after a couple of days he'd say, &bquo;Vicky, I got to clean up.&equo; 
 This time he didn't plan on getting better. 
 He was spending money like I'd never seen. 
 There was no life left in him.&equo; 
 Vicky searched the house for Seth, to break the news that she was leaving. 
 She found him at his desk, downing vodka, talking on the telephone to Susan, telling her soothingly, &bquo;No, I'm not drinking any more.&equo; 
 So Susan was gone, and Vicky was gone, but still the stage was not emptied. 
 Seth and Suzy Levine had gone through a lot together. 
 He had been the one to persuade  her brother, an alcoholic and addict, to flee New Orleans for the sobriety of the Midwest, where he kicked his bad habit. 
 But Seth was also the kind of boyfriend who would visit Suzy at the bar where she worked, with a prostitute on his arm. 
 That their friendship endured explains why next day Seth showed up at his old friend's house, grinning, freshly showered and dressed, barely able to stand. 
 Suzy's sixteen-year-old son, Joey, answered the door. 
 A dropout with a troubled past of his own, Joey worshipped Seth. 
 Suzy had even let Joey live with Seth for almost a year. 
 She had hoped for a while that Seth could straighten Joey out. 
 Seth read Joey bedtime passages from Huckleberry Finn, a habit learned from his own father. 
 He taught him about literature and opera and encouraged him to write. 
 &bquo;He'd say, &bquo;Listen, Joey, if you want to write a Homeboy, you'd better stay in school.&equo;&equo; 
 But in recent weeks, Joey had seen Seth drunkenly leap off his balcony into his pool. 
 Seth and Joey had fired guns off the balcony into the sky, and Seth had fired his .357 Magnum at a cat inside the house. 
 Now Seth was waving grandly towards the street, slurring, &bquo;What do you think of that?&equo; &mdash; a twenty-six thousand-dollar Chevy van &mdash; a green-orange-white monster complete with its own bar, refrigerator, television, toilet and bed. 
 &bquo;He bought it when he was loaded,&equo; Joey says. 
 &bquo;He was drunk and on pills and he wanted to do something good for himself. 
 He'd always be throwing money around &mdash; a Harley, a Corvette &mdash; the same way. 
 When he bought the Harley, I said, &bquo;You know you just bought your death&equo;.&equo; 
 Seth led Joey to the van, but the teenager, seeing that Seth was too drunk to drive, took the wheel himself. 
 &bquo;The moment I got behind the wheel, he went on a binge, and he was in no shape to drive, so I was his chauffeur for three days, three days without sleep. 
 He was drinking, doing drugs, screaming &bquo;I'm gettin' the fuck outta here!&equo; 
 He was on a rampage. 
 On Friday evening, Seth directed Joey to a car dealer and bought him a maroon 1982 Cutlass Calais for three thousand dollars. 
 Joey turned the van over to Seth, and they both drove for a while, until Seth motioned for Joey to pull over. 
 &bquo;He told me that all his life he was such a shit, and he finally realized he could make someone as happy as he made me,&equo; recalls Joey. 
 Late that night, they returned to Suzy's to show her Joey's gift. 
 She took in the scene and told Seth it was time they straightened out. 
 She said an ex-boyfriend had a house across Lake Pontchartrain they could use for the weekend. 
 Suzy and Seth loaded the van with food and clothes for the country, but on Interstate 10 out of New Orleans, Seth suddenly ordered Suzy to turn around so they could back and buy pain pills. 
 When she refused, Seth fought for the wheel, she won, and for the next fifty miles he fumed. 
 But when they reached the dock and were waiting for the boat to carry them to the camp, Seth snatched the van's keys, nearly breaking two of Suzy's fingers in the struggle. 
 He jumped in the van and left her there. 
 Shortly after midnight, as Joey drove his new car through Metairie, a suburb of New Orleans, he saw police lights and a wreck. 
 He raced to the scene and found the van, its interior sprayed with blood. 
 Seth had ploughed into the back of another van, earning himself a broken nose and twenty-five stitches in his face. 
 Seth's van, which he had owned for four days, was a write-off. 
 &bquo;He told me, &bquo;Joey, I wish faces were disposable. 
 This one is about shot. 
 I wish I could hang it up and put on a new one&equo;.&equo; 
 In the first week of October, Seth momentarily returned to the Spartan ritual that had produced Homeboy: rising at six am, working out at the Y for an hour, sitting down to write by seven. 
 Over the past months, he had completed about three chapters of his second novel. 
 But privately he told friends that he had been cowed by his rave reviews. 
 &bquo;He told me he didn't think he could be the Nelson Algren of his generation,&equo; Vanderford says. 
 &bquo;I didn't think he had another book in him. 
 He made it seem as if he had gone to New Orleans drunk, got sober and wrote a book. 
 But he had been working on that first novel for at least ten years, ever since I've known him. 
 It's all he ever did.&equo; 
 He sent Susan Schilling a chapter, &bquo;Crab Trap&equo;, to prove that he was working. 
 It begins: 
 Dawn slopped like a bucket of blood over the greasy waves of Lake Pontchartrain, splashing the seaside slum of Bucktown in red&hellip; 
 It was possible to imagine that the sun was an expression of a force that was sick already of a day just barely started. 
 On October 6, he wrote her a letter: &bquo;Dear Susan, Never have I known a love so great, nor suffered so greatly love's penalty&hellip; 
 &equo; And two days later: &bquo;Along &mdash; my thoughts of us clarify, and my feelings distil themselves, and I realize that you're doing what you must do and it was probably best for me. 
 I have no right to expect the things I ask &mdash; even a kind word&hellip; &bquo; 
 She refused to see him, she said, until he sought treatment. 
 A few nights later, Susan found a message on her answering machine: it was Seth, but his voice was hoarse, threatening her with &bquo;loathsome&equo; things, sexual violence. 
 The next day, when he had sobered up, she insisted on playing it back to him. 
 He wept. 
 She got another letter the next day: &bquo;Dear Susan&hellip; 
 That voice was mine. 
 It sickens me, but it talks with my words. 
 Try to understand me &mdash; I'm terrorized by that sick motherfucker, too.&equo; 
 Still she would not yield, so in mid-October, Seth entered Riverbend Hospital for his drug and alcohol problems. 
 A day later, though, he called Susan to say he had checked out of the hospital. 
 When she began to protest, he claimed he was getting help on an out-patient basis, and that he had been going to AA. 
 That Friday, Susan Schilling visited Suzy Levine at work at the Decatur House pub. 
 When she walked in, Seth was at the bar with another woman. 
 He had a soda in front of him. 
 &bquo;I said, &bquo;Suzy, what's going on here? 
 Is he drinking?&equo; 
 She said, &bquo;No, it's just Coca-Cola.&equo;&equo; 
 He had spent weeks trying everything to win this woman back. 
 But in a single motion he was about to drive her away again, one final time. 
 Seth turned to Susan, smirking, and opened his leather jacket. 
 From beneath it he pulled a fifth of rum. 
 Now only  Suzy remained by Seth's side, and there, a few days later, is where the story ends. 
 Sergeant Newton Barrios had investigated more than seven hundred traffic fatalities in the city of New Orleans, but this was the worst he'd ever seen on the St Claude Avenue Bridge. 
 The seventy-one-year-old steel cantilever span narrows down to two lanes as it crosses a channel that connects the Gulf to the Mississippi. 
 One hundred feet from the bridge sits an immense piling to protect the bridge's warning gates &mdash; eight telephone poles cabled together, covered with yellow paint and reflectors. 
 On October 17, shortly after midnight, Seth Morgan and Suzy Levine approached the right lane of the bridge at about forty miles an hour. 
 He steered too far to the left and nicked the edge of the median strip. 
 The bike shot up in the air. 
 Seth flew forty miles an hour face first into the piling with such force that he uprooted the eight telephone poles. 
 Seth &bquo;stopped abruptly&equo;, Sergeant Barrios explains, then rolled another twenty-four feet, coming to a halt in the roadway. 
 His rider, Suzy, missed the piling and soared beyond Seth, landing forty-five feet away from the point of impact in a foetal position. 
 Both died instantly. 
 An autopsy found that Seth had cocaine and Percodan in his blood and .3 per cent alcohol &mdash; three times the legal limit. 
 Suzy had .28 per cent alcohol in her blood. 
 &bquo;If she'd been wearing a helmet, she might have lived,&equo; says Officer Carmine Menchel, who visited the scene later. 
 &bquo;If he'd been he'd been wearing one, he might have had an open casket.&equo; 
 A few days later Kiley Puma, Suzy's eighteen-year-old daughter, found two motorcycle helmets in a laundry basket in her mother's apartment, along with an empty vodka bottle and a pair of Seth's pants. 
 Suzy Levine was buried in Carter Cemetery in Springfield, near New Orleans. 
 Her father, Robert Skidmore, says, &bquo;There's a lot of anger in the French Quarter, because felt that Seth had a death wish and took my daughter with him. 
 I believe he killed my daughter.&equo; 
 text apparently missing 
 Seth Morgan was buried in a small private ceremony in Maine. 
 Seth's family hired Susan Neff, a New Orleans attorney, to handle his estate. 
 &bquo;Though he had large sums of money coming in, it appears that Mr Morgan was insolvent,&equo; she says. 
 Susan Bell, Seth's editor at Random House, was tired of talking about him. 
 &bquo;He wasn't a myth, he wasn't a genius. 
 He was a frail human being, he was an incredibly hard-working and talented writer, very nice, and sometimes he was an asshole.&equo; 
 After Seth's death, Suzy's son, Joey, tried repeatedly to call Frederick Morgan, Seth's father, in New York. 
 Mr Morgan hasn't returned his calls. 
 &bquo;I hope he calls me soon,&equo; Joey says. 
 &bquo;We talked a lot of times and got along great. 
 He must be devastated.&equo; 
 Joey plans to return to school and dreams of writing about the wild scenes he witnessed at Seth's house &mdash; &bquo;La Traviata in New Orleans, man,&equo; he says. 
 Seth's brother and one of his sisters travelled to New Orleans to try to understand what happened to their sibling. 
 &bquo;We don't know,&equo; says his sister Veronica, a teacher and unpublished poet living in Massachusetts. 
 &bquo;None of us really knew him.&equo; 
 In New Orleans, his brother and sister met Susan Schilling, who told them the story of her . 
 &bquo;They told me, &bquo;That's good, at least he finally did something nice for somebody.&equo;&equo; 
 text apparently missing 
 Homebody will be published in paperback by Vintage in June, &pound;4.00 
 THE SOUND OF MORGAN 
 Kitty sat nude before the bathroom mirror, knotting a towel turban-style around her head. 
 The mirror was veined with gold and misted with the scented steam of the bath from which she'd just emerged. 
 With the heel of her hand, she wiped a circular space to see her face. 
 She frowned. 
 Not at herself, but at the ornate bathroom. 
 The golden fixtures in the shapes of mythological birds, the fluted blue marble seashell sinks, the sterling silver tub with lapis lazuli clawed feet, everywhere busy mosaics building geometric  migranes . 
 No wonder Dan's wife, Melissa, took the kid and booked. 
 Only a whore could love this Turkish bellyache. 
 Dan must have built it with just that fantasy in focus, to keep some bust-out bimbo with a big ass and chichis in a style befitting Little Freakin' Egypt. 
 &bquo;Shitfire,&equo; she called through the partly closed door. 
 &bquo;It must cost plenty to make a crapper look this cheap.&equo; 
 HOMEBOY 
 Live fast, die faster (from top): Morgan on the Harley; Vicky Vanderford; Suzy Levine, who died on the bike; and a Morgan police mug shot 
 Con artist: Seth subscribed to the cult of the addictive personality 
 Esquire Goes on a Date 
 a night at the pictures with denice lewis 
 She's blonde, she's gorgeous, she's the face of the Nineties. 
 We're plain, we're nervous, we envy the popcorn on her lap 
 It's early evening in Leicester Square and the rain is splashing down. 
 We're waiting to play the dating game with Denice Lewis, the blonde supermodel, the woman David Bailey declared to be the image of the Nineties. 
 As we straighten our tie and suck on a Cloret, we reflect gloomily that the Mail on Sunday categorized Denice's former dates as &bquo;rich, famous and suntanned&equo; and we try to hope that perhaps she feels like a change. 
 We scan the street nervously in both directions. 
 Denice is never late, so we've been told, and she's due to arrive at any moment. 
 We've never met her, but we know what she looks like. 
 We've seen her golden smile on the cover of Tatler and her figure in dozens of fashion glossies. 
 And of course, we've seen her in the gossip columns, stepping out with the rich, the famous and the suntanned. 
 A small woman approaches us. 
 Although she may have many other fine qualities, she is clearly not an international fashion model. 
 She asks us if the cinema in front of which we're standing, the one with the large sign saying &bquo;Odeon Mezzanine&equo;, could in fact by any chance be the Odeon Mezzanine. 
 We confirm that it is. 
 She then proceeds to whinge about how confusing it is that the Odeon Mezzanine, the Odeon Leicester Square and the Odeon West End are all situated within yards of each other. 
 We nod politely and look the other way to discourage further conversation. 
 We have more pressing matters on our mind. 
 We look at our watch and note that Denice is now thirty seconds late. 
 Where on earth can she be? 
 Then we spot a tall, blonde woman striding up the street in our direction. 
 She's wearing faded jeans and a long black coat and has a purposeful air about her. 
 Our heart pumps faster, and we take a firm grip on the large, green-and-white golf umbrella by which Denice has been told to recognize us. 
 As she gets closer, she scans the motley group of no-hopers gathered on the pavement and then suddenly she's looking directly at us. 
 We adopt a warm, welcoming expression, which somehow manages to combine immense charm with just a hint of dangerous animal magnetism. 
 She walks past. 
 We follow her as she continues towards the Odeon Leicester Square. 
 When she stops and turns back, we decide to abandon the low-key approach and we wave our umbrella in the air, pointing at it and grinning dementedly. 
 She recognizes us immediately. 
 We lead her back towards the Odeon Mezzanine and break the ice by saying interestingly how confusing it is that the Odeon Mezzanine, the Odeon Leicester Square and the Odeon West End are all situated within yards of each other. 
 The film we're going to see is Flatliners, and Denice tells us she's been dying to see it for ages. 
 She apologizes for being thirty seconds late and says she's been having her nails done. 
 We buy her a large Coke and an even larger carton of popcorn. 
 As we enter the tiny auditorium, the usher asks to see our tickets. 
 &bquo;Window seat, no smoking,&equo; says Denice. 
 The man seems confused. 
 &bquo;Just kidding!&equo; she says; he smiles thinly. 
 He shows us to our seats, and there's just time for Denice to switch off her portable phone before the lights go down. 
 The film stars Keifer Sutherland and Julia Roberts and concerns a group of unlikely student doctors who take it in turns to have their heartbeat stopped in order to experience the afterlife, which for some reason the director has chosen to portray as a series of rather unimaginative music videos. 
 Denice lets out little yelps of laughter at the occasional humorous moments and squirms and groans during the gory bits. 
 She seems to be enjoying it. 
 For our part, the only time our heart comes close to missing a beat is when Denice wedges the still-full carton of popcorn between her thighs and invites us to help ourselves whenever we feel like it. 
 Unable to trust our sense of direction one hundred per cent in the dark, and aware that misunderstandings might arise, we decide to give the popcorn a miss. 
 After an eternity or two, the film comes to an end. 
 It's time to eat. 
 We suggest a Japanese meal, and Denice agrees. 
 We happen to know a particularly nice little establishment in Soho, only a five-minute walk away. 
 Outside, it's still raining, and as we gallantly struggle to open our umbrella in the wind, we suddenly find we've come to a halt beside a large black car, and a man in a smart suit is opening the door for us to get in. 
 He's Denice's hired chauffeur. 
 Such is the life of the supermodel. 
 During the brief journey to Brewer Street, Denice tells us that she enjoyed the film, particularly the surreal portrait of the afterlife. 
 She asks us if we would agree that Julia Roberts is the most stunning thing we've ever seen, and we have to admit that Julia's extraordinarily wide mouth and upturned nose always remind us of someone with their face pressed against a plate-glass  window. 
 Denice thinks she's absolutely gorgeous. 
 We arrive at the Fuji restaurant. 
 Denice decides it's &bquo;cute&equo; and speaks enthusiastically of the dimmed lighting. 
 &bquo;I'm so fed up with restaurants that have really bright fluorescent lights everywhere that make you look green,&equo; she says. 
 &bquo;I mean, good lighting is so important.&equo; 
 In complete agreement, we tell her we also think the dimmer the lighting the better. 
 Denice hands the waiter her coat (Christian Lacroix), and then we hand over our umbrella (from a sweatshop somewhere in Korea). 
 Once seated, Denice tells us she's only been on a blind date once before, and that was years ago. 
 We ask her what happened. 
 &bquo;I went out with him for a year and a half,&equo; she replies. 
 &bquo;This could be your lucky night,&equo; she adds, laughing. 
 We laugh too. 
 As we try to decide what to eat, we notice that Denice has managed to do a certain amount of major structural damage to her menu, resulting to the pages' coming out of the middle. 
 &bquo;I didn't do it,&equo; she says defensively. 
 Last of the great chevaliers, we tell her that should there be any problem with the restaurant management, she will have to take full responsibility for her actions. 
 &bquo;I'm gonna fix it for them,&equo; she says, and begins trying to stuff the pages back in. 
 She sighs. 
 &bquo;Tearing up the menu, insulting the guy at the cinema. 
 Oh dear, it's not going very well, is it?&equo; 
 The waitress arrives. 
 Denice has already decided she wants chicken, but isn't sure exactly what she wants done to it before it's put on her plate. 
 Then she hears something sizzling on the other side of the restaurant and decides she will have &bquo;sizzling chicken&equo;. 
 The waitress then finds something on the menu that approximates to it. 
 For our own part, we decide on the beef teriyaki, medium rare. 
 We get back to the subject of dating. 
 Denice says nobody ever asks her out, and we say we find this hard to believe. 
 She says she doesn't have boyfriends, and we mention her much-publicized relationship with rich, famous, suntanned George Hamilton last year. 
 She says that was different. 
 And she says that at the moment she's more interested in just having fun than dating. 
 Our chin quivers very slightly. 
 &bquo;Except for this one,&equo; she adds reassuringly. 
 Denice tells us about her first date, when she was seventeen, and talks about her early life in Houston. 
 She mentions that there was another girl in her class at high school who was also called Denice Lewis and also had blonde hair. 
 We wonder if she has ever heard of chronic paranoid schizophrenia, and she tells us to be quiet. 
 The food arrives, and we tuck in. 
 The conversation goes well, and we progress confidently along a tightrope of loose connections, with just the occasional wobble. 
 The chewy nature of our beef teriyaki leads on to Denice's dislike of beef, which in turn inspires her to do an extremely convincing impersonation of a fish, which leads her to mention that her mother's name is Wanda. 
 We talk about the ups and downs of being thirty, about Denice's ambition to become a successful actress, about books and birth signs. 
 We decide we like Denice a lot. 
 She's smart and fun to be with. 
 Yes, Denice is extremely nice. 
 We get on the subject of hobbies, and Denice tells us about her painting. 
 She paints hearts in lots of different colours and says she has no intention of branching out into other organs of the body. 
 She also collects teddy bears and has about fifty of them. 
 What she really wants is a puppy. 
 She tells us about one she came across the other day. 
 &bquo;It was adorable,&equo; she says dreamily. 
 &bquo;I held it and it was biting my lip and kissing my face&hellip; &bquo; 
 About ten minutes later, we decide we've cooled down sufficiently to be able to leave the men's room and go back into the restaurant. 
 When we get back to our table, Denice decides to show us a trick with a toothpick. 
 &bquo;It's something I learned when I was about four,&equo; she tells us. 
 &bquo;You break it in half and just stick it against your skin, and it stays there.&equo; 
 She proceeds to demonstrate, and within no time at all half a toothpick is stuck to her forehead, as if by magic. 
 We congratulate her on this remarkable feat. 
 &bquo;You should try and see if you can do it yourself,&equo; Denice suggests. 
 We snap a toothpick and make a half-hearted attempt to stick it to our chin. 
 &bquo;Push it hard,&equo; says Denice. 
 &bquo;You have to push it a lot harder than that.&equo; 
 We tell her that we are indeed pushing, but it hurts. 
 &bquo;Well I did it,&equo; she says. 
 We try again. 
 &bquo;No, not like that. 
 Here, gimme your forehead.&equo; 
 We lean across the table with a certain amount of apprehension. 
 A split second later, we notice that the piece of wood in her hand looks particularly sharp and jagged. 
 Denice jabs it with considerable force into our forehead. 
 The pain is excruciating. 
 As we check for bleeding, Denice shrieks with laughter. 
 We reflect that this is the loudest she has laughed all evening. 
 &bquo;Let me see your hand,&equo; says Denice, when she finally stopped laughing. 
 We're somewhat reluctant to offer it up, fearing a second stabbing, but she becomes stern, and we acquiesce. 
 &bquo;Now let me read your palm.&equo; 
 She scans our hand for a while and then adopts a worried look. 
 &bquo;You don't have a life line,&equo; she says. 
 We find this slightly worrying. 
 We offer the other hand, and eventually a life line is discovered, although it's so short it appears that we died several years ago. 
 Denice shows us her own life line, which goes about halfway up her arm. 
 She then admits she doesn't know the difference between the head line and the heart line, although she's able to identify the little crinkle at the side of the hand that tells you how many children you're going to have. 
 She shows it to us. 
 &bquo;It says I'm having only one.&equo; 
 Then she examines our own crinkle and discovers it's almost identical. 
 &bquo;Oh God, maybe we're having the same one!&equo; she says excitedly. 
 Naturally this is a very emotional moment, but we try to remain calm. 
 We have to plan for the future. 
 For a start, we have to think of a name for our child. 
 We decide too that the name should be a permanent reminder of our first date. 
 &bquo;Flatliners?&equo; suggests Denice. 
 We say we were thinking more along the lines of Keifer or Julia. 
 This meets with Denice's approval, and she swears solemnly that if she ever has our child, it will be called Keifer or Julia. 
 We shake on it. 
 Our date seems to have reached a kind of conclusion. 
 Outside the chauffeur is waiting patiently. 
 He heads north, and in no time we're outside Denice's impressive town house in St John's Wood. 
 She kisses us goodnight and says she's had fun. 
 We mutter something similar. 
 As the chauffeur drives us home, he tells us what a lovely girl that Denice is, and we tell him that's the truth. 
 Looking out of the car window, we notice that the storm is over and already the streets are dry again.  
 Shock of the New 
 Far from the fitting room 
 La Dolce Vita 
 by Dolce &amp; Gabbana 
 There is good baggy and bad baggy. 
 This is, of course, about the former. 
 The oversized designs of the Italian team Dolce &amp; Gabbana are such a big hit in Britain that the mainstream menswear companies keep them under scrutiny. 
 This means that the baggy peasant look will be widely seen again: roomy, comfy clothes that look best when rumpled. 
 Domenico Dolce and Stefano Gabbana are one of Europe's most innovative design teams, much influenced by their passion for Sicily and Italy's deep south. 
 The pair received a rapturous welcome at the latest Milan collections for continuing to portray the tough masculine image that is their trademark. 
 They create two basic silhouettes &mdash; one voluminous, the other highly tailored. 
 Here, we are concerned with the former, relaxed and floppy, with huge jackets as comfortable as cardigans and roomy trousers designed to be tugged in with a sturdy leather belt. 
 Their impact comes from layers of muted colour and a newly chic sloppiness that is easily imitated by donning any jacket far too big for you. 
 The designer difference lies in the fabrics. 
 The real McCoy is made up in loose linens, which can be relied on to hang stylishly on even the stickiest of summer days. 
 The Manzi brothers, pictured here, are unafraid of clothes that suggest they need ironing. 
 Neither are they worried by sizing that implies the clothes might belong to men of more ample girth. 
 This could be because Carlo (left) has made a career of clothes. 
 He spent eight years as a costume designer for television commercials and now boasts the widest stock of contemporary menswear in Europe at his eponymous clothing-hire company. 
 Carlo is wearing a large, double-breasted linen jacket and non-matching royal blue linen trousers over a slate-grey T-shirt and stone shirt. 
 His brother Eugene (right), the publicity chief for London/FFRR Records, wears an even bigger linen suit over a rayon polo shirt. 
 All clothing from a selection by Dolce &amp; Gabbana, available from Joseph. 
 Marion Hume  
 Esquire Fiction 
 The Wave by Milan Kundera 
 She was three women, whose lives were contained in one bewitching, unforgettable gesture 
 More often condemned to live than die, the characters that people the novels and stories of Milan Kundera are the architects as much as victims of their own fates. 
 In the arbitrariness of their actions, in their trivial comic act of cowardice, lust and vengeance, as much as in the sheer ridiculousness of history, lie the seeds of desperation and heartbreak. 
 Somehow most of them survive. 
 And it is no surprise that the man who first addressed a novel called The Joke to the citizens of a prohibitionist state in the middle of Europe twenty-five years ago should treat them with as much sympathy as harsh lucidity. 
 His own career is an exemplar of survival in the face of absurdity as well as adversity. 
 Born in Brno, Czechoslovakia, in 1929, Kundera worked as a labourer and a jazz musician before turning to writing. 
 Uncensored in his own country until the 1968 invasion (when he was put under an outright ban), he discovered his first novel to be published in the West had been rewritten from start to finish by the publisher. 
 Later, exiled in France, he found his models hailed as &bquo;major indictments of Stalinism&equo;, when what he had written, he maintained, were love stories and chronicles of the human soul. 
 A film of his most recent novel, The Unbearable Lightness of Being, conveys little more than that he a master of the erotic situation. 
 For ten years, Milan Kundera has been a professor at the Ecole des Hautes Etudes en Sciences Sociales in Paris. 
 Far from being his only subject, eroticism &mdash; along with politics, aesthetics and theology &mdash; is a seamless part of life for Kundera. 
 More than fifteen years ago, Philip Roth introduced The Joke and Milan Kundera to awestruck readers of American readers of Esquire. 
 Now, with this exclusive preview from Immortality, his long-awaited new novel, we're delighted to repeat the experience. 
 Immortality will be published by Faber &amp; Faber in May. 
 She might have been sixty or sixty-five. 
 I was watching from a deck chair by the pool of my health club, on the top floor of a highrise that provided a panoramic view of all Paris. 
 I was waiting for Professor Avenarius whom I'd occasionally met here for a chat. 
 But Professor Avenarius was late, and I kept watching the woman; she was alone at the pool, standing waist-deep in the water, and she kept looking up at the young lifeguard in sweatpants who was teaching her to swim. 
 He was giving her orders: she was to hold on to the edge of the pool and breathe deeply in and out. 
 She proceeded to do this earnestly, seriously, and she sounded like an old steam-engine wheezing from the depths of the water (that idyllic sound, now long forgotten, which to those who never knew it can be described in no better way than the wheezing of an old woman breathing in and out by the edge of a pool). 
 I watched her in fascination. 
 She captivated me by her touchingly comic manner (which the lifeguard also noticed, for the corner of his mouth twitched slightly). 
 Then an acquaintance started talking to me and diverted my attention. 
 When I was ready to observe her once again, the lesson was over. 
 She walked around the pool towards the exit. 
 She passed by the lifeguard, and after she had gone some three or four steps past him she turned her head, smiled, and waved to him. 
 At that instant I felt a pang in my heart! 
 That smile and that gesture belonged to a twenty-year-old! 
 Her arm rose with bewitching ease. 
 It was as if she were playfully tossing a brightly coloured ball to her lover. 
 That smile and that gesture had charm and elegance, while the face and the body no longer had any charm. 
 It was the charm of a gesture drowning in the charmlessness of the body. 
 But the woman, though she must, of course, have realized that she was no longer beautiful, forgot that for the moment. 
 In all of us, a certain part of our being lives outside of time. 
 Perhaps we become aware of our age only at exceptional moments, and most of the time we are ageless. 
 In any case, the instant she turned, smiled and waved to the young lifeguard (who couldn't control himself and burst out laughing), she was unaware of her age. 
 The essence of her charm, independent of time, revealed itself for a second in that gesture and dazzled me. 
 I was strangely moved. 
 And then the word Agnes entered my mind. 
 Agnes. 
 I had never known a woman by that name.  
 When I wake up, at almost half past eight, I try to picture Agnes. 
 She is lying, like myself, in a wide bed. 
 The right side of the bed is empty. 
 Who could her husband be? 
 Clearly, somebody who leaves the house early on Saturday mornings. 
 That's why she is alone, sweetly singing between waking and sleeping. 
 Then she gets up. 
 Facing her is a TV set, standing on one long, stork-like leg. 
 She throws her nightgown over the tube, like a white, tasselled theatre-curtain. 
 She stands close to the bed, and for the first time I see her naked: Agnes, the heroine of my novel. 
 I can't take my eyes off this beautiful woman and as if sensing my gaze she hurries off to the adjoining room to get dressed. 
 Who is Agnes? 
 Just as Eve came from Adam's rib, just as Venus was born out of the waves, Agnes sprang from the gesture of that sixty-year-old woman at the pool who waved to the lifeguard and whose features are already fading from my memory. 
 At the time, that gesture aroused in me immense, inexplicable nostalgia, and that nostalgia gave birth to a woman I call Agnes. 
 But isn't a person, and to an even greater extent, a character in a novel, by definition a unique, inimitable being? 
 How then is it possible that a gesture I saw performed by one person, a gesture that was connected to her, that characterized her and was part of her individual charm, could at the same time be the essence of another person and my dreams of her? 
 That's worth some thought. 
 If our planet has seen some eighty billion people, it is difficult to suppose that every individual has had his or her own repertory of gestures. 
 Arithmetically, it is simply impossible. 
 Without the slightest doubt, there are far fewer gestures in the world than there are individuals. 
 That finding leads us to a shocking conclusion: a gesture is more individual than an individual. 
 We could put it in the form of an aphorism: many people, few gestures. 
 I said at the beginning, when I talked about the woman at the pool, that &bquo;the essence of her charm, independent of time revealed itself for a second in that gesture and dazzled me.&equo; 
 Yes, that's how I perceived it at the time, but I was wrong. 
 The gesture revealed nothing of that woman's essence, one could say rather that the woman revealed to me the charm of a gesture. 
 A gesture cannot be regarded as the expression of an individual, as his or her creation (because no individual is capable of creating a fully original gesture, belonging to nobody else), nor can it even be regarded as that person's instrument; on the contrary, it is gestures that use us as their instruments, as their bearers and incarnations. 
 Agnes, now fully dressed, went into the hall. 
 There she stopped and listened. 
 Vague sounds from the adjoining room made her realize that her daughter had just got up. 
 As if to avoid meeting her, Agnes hurried out into the corridor. 
 In the elevator, she pressed the button for the lobby. 
 Instead of going down, the elevator began to twitch like a person afflicted with Saint Vitus's dance. 
 This was not the first time the elevator had startled her with its moods. 
 On one occasion, it began to go up when she wanted to go down; another time, it refused to open and kept her prisoner for half an hour. 
 She had the feeling that it wanted to reach some sort of understanding with her, to tell her something in its rough, mute animal way. 
 She complained several times to the concierge, but because the elevator behaved quite normally and decently towards the other tenants, the concierge considered Agnes's quarrel with it her own private matter and paid no attention. 
 This time, Agnes had no other choice but to get out and take the stairs. 
 The moment the stairway door closed behind her, the elevator regained its composure and followed her down. 
 Saturday was always the most tiring day for Agnes. 
 Paul, her husband, generally left before seven and had lunch out with one of his friends, while she used her free day to take care of a thousand chores more annoying than the duties of her job: she had to go to the post office and fret for half an hour in a queue, go shopping in the supermarket, where she quarrelled with the saleswoman and wasted time waiting at the check-out, telephone the plumber and plead with him to be precisely on time so that she wouldn't have to wait the whole day for him. 
 She tried to find a moment to squeeze in a bit of rest at the sauna, something she could not do during the week; in the late afternoon, she would always find herself with a vacuum cleaner and duster, because the cleaning woman who came on Fridays was becoming more and more careless. 
 But this Saturday differed from other Saturdays: it was exactly five years since her father had died. 
 A particular scene appeared before her eyes: her father is sitting hunched over a pile of torn photographs, and Agnes's sister is shouting at him: &bquo;Why have you torn up Mother's pictures? 
 Agnes takes her father's part, and the sisters quarrel, overtaken with a sudden hatred. 
 She got into the car, which was parked in front of the house. 
 The elevator took her to the top floor of the highrise that housed the health club with its big swimming-pool, Jacuzzi, sauna, Turkish bath and view of Paris. 
 Rock music boomed from speakers in the locker room. 
 Ten years ago, when she first started coming, the club had fewer members and it was quiet. 
 Then, year by year, the club improved: more and more glass, more lights, more artificial flowers and cactuses, more speakers, more music, and also more and more people, further multiplied by the enormous mirrors which the management one day decided to spread across the walls of the gym. 
 She opened a locker and began to undress. 
 Two women were chatting close by. 
 One of them was complaining in a quiet, slow alto voice that her husband was in the habit of leaving everything lying on the floor; books, socks, newspapers, even matches and pipes. 
 The other, in a soprano, spoke twice as fast. 
 The French habit of raising the last syllable of a sentence an octave higher made the flow of her speech sound like the indignant cackling of a hen: &bquo;I'm shocked to hear you say that! 
 I'm disappointed in you! 
 I'm really shocked! 
 You've got to put your foot down! 
 Don't let him get away with it! 
 It's your house after all! 
 You've got to put your foot down! 
 Don't let him walk all over you!&equo; 
 The other woman, as if torn between a friend whose authority she respected and a husband whom she loved, explained with melancholy, &bquo;What can I do, that's how he is! 
 And he's always been like that. 
 Ever since I've known him, leaving things all over the place!&equo; 
 &bquo;So then he's got to stop doing it! 
 It's your house! 
 You can't let him get away with it! 
 You've got to make that crystal clear!&equo; said the soprano voice. 
 Agnes never took part in such conversations; she never spoke badly of Paul, even though she sensed that this alienated her somewhat from other women. 
 She turned her head in the direction of the alto: a young woman with light hair and the face of an angel. 
 &bquo;No, no! 
 You know perfectly well you're in the right! 
 You can't let him act like that!&equo; continued the other woman, and Agnes noticed that as she spoke she kept rapidly shaking her head from left to right and right to left, at the same time lifting her shoulders and eyebrows expressing indignant astonishment that someone had refused to respect her friend's human rights. 
 Agnes knew that gesture: her daughter Brigitte shook her head and lifted her brows in precisely the same way.  
 Agnes undressed, closed the locker and walked through the swing doors into a tiled hall, with showers on one side and a glass enclosed sauna on the other. 
 There, women sat squeezed together on long wooden benches. 
 Some were wrapped in special plastic sheets that formed an airtight cover around their bodies (or certain parts of the body, most often the belly and behind), so that the skin perspired all the more readily and the women, or so they believed, would lose weight more quickly. 
 She climbed to the highest bench, where there was still some room. 
 She leaned against the wall and closed her eyes. 
 The noise of music did not reach this far, but the voices of the women, who chattered away at full blast, were just as loud. 
 An unfamiliar young woman entered the sauna and, the moment she walked through the door, began to order everyone about; she made them all sit closer together, then picked up a pitcher and poured water on the stones. 
 With much hissing, hot steam started to rise upwards, making the woman sitting next to Agnes wince with pain and cover her face. 
 The newcomer noticed it, declared, &bquo;I like hot steam; it gives me that real sauna feeling&equo;, squeezed herself between two naked bodies and at once began to talk about yesterday's television talk show featuring a famous biologist who had just published his memoirs. 
 &bquo;He was terrific,&equo; she said. 
 Another woman nodded in agreement: &bquo;Oh yes! 
 And how modest!&equo; 
 The newcomer said: &bquo;Modest? 
 Don't you realize how extremely proud that man was? 
 But I like that kind of pride! 
 I adore proud people!&equo; 
 She turned to Agnes: &bquo;Did you find him modest? 
 Agnes said that she hadn't seen the program. 
 As if interpreting this remark as veiled disagreement, the newcomer repeated very loudly, looking Agnes straight in the eye: &bquo;I detest modesty! 
 Modesty is hypocrisy!&equo; 
 Agnes shrugged, and the newcomer said: &bquo;In a sauna, I've got to feel real heat. 
 I got to work up a good sweat. 
 But then I must have a cold shower. 
 A cold shower! 
 I adore that! 
 Actually I like my showers cold even in the morning. 
 I find hot showers disgusting.&equo; 
 Soon she declared that the sauna was suffocating; after repeating once more how she hated modesty, she got up and left. 
 As a little girl, Agnes used to go for walks with her father, and once she asked him whether he believed in God. 
 Her father answered: &bquo;I believe in the Creator's computer.&equo; 
 This answer was so peculiar that the child remembered it. 
 The word computer was peculiar, and so was the word Creator, for her father would never say God, but always Creator, as if he wanted to limit God's significance to his engineering activity. 
 The Creator's computer: but how could a person communicate with a computer? 
 So she asked her father whether he ever prayed. 
 He said: that would be like praying to Edison when a lightbulb burns out.&equo; 
 Agnes thought to herself: The Creator loaded a detailed program into the computer and went away. 
 That God created the world and then left it to a forsaken humanity, trying to address Him in an echoless void &mdash; this idea isn't new. 
 Yet it is one thing to be abandoned by the God of our forefathers and another is to be abandoned by God the inventor of a cosmic computer. 
 In His place there is a program that is ceaselessly running in his absence, without anyone's being able to change anything whatever. 
 To load a program into the computer: this does not mean that the future has been planned down to the last detail, that everything is written &bquo;up above&equo;. 
 For example, the program did not specify that in the year 1815 a battle would be fought near Waterloo and that the French would be defeated, but only that man is aggressive by nature, that he is condemned to wage war and that technical progress would make war more and more terrible. 
 Everything else is without importance from the Creator's point of view, and is only a play of permutations and combinations within a general program which is not a prophetic anticipation of the future but merely sets the limits of possibilities within which all power of decision has been left to chance. 
 That was the same with the project we call mankind. 
 The computer did not plan an Agnes or a Paul, but only a prototype known as a human being, giving rise to a large number of specimens which are based on the original model and haven't any individual essence. 
 Just like a Renault car. 
 Its essence is deposited outside, in the archives of the central engineering office. 
 Individual cars differ only in their serial numbers. 
 The serial number of a human specimen is the face, that accidental and unrepeatable combination of features. 
 It reflects neither character or soul, nor what we call the self. 
 The face is only the serial number of a specimen. 
 She recalled the newcomer who had just declared that she hated hot showers. 
 She came in order to inform all the women present that (1) she likes saunas to be hot (2) she adores pride (3) she can't  bear modesty (4) she loves cold showers (5) she hates hot showers. 
 By means of those five strokes, she had drawn her self-portrait; with those five points, she defined her self and presented that self to everyone. 
 And she didn't present it modestly (she said, after all, that she hated modesty), but belligerently. 
 She used passionate verbs such as &bquo;adore&equo; and &bquo;detest&equo;, as if she wished to proclaim her readiness to fight for every one of those five strokes, for every one of those five points. 
 Why all this passion? 
 Agnes asked herself, and she thought: When we thrust out into the world just as we are, we first have to identify with that particular throw of the dice, with that accident organized by the divine computer: to get over our surprise that precisely this (what we see facing us in the mirror) is our self. 
 Without the faith that our face expresses our self, without that basic illusion, that arch-illusion, we cannot live or at least we cannot take life seriously. 
 And it isn't enough for us to identify with our self, it is necessary to do so passionately, to the point of life and death. 
 Because only in this way we regard ourselves not merely as a variant of a human prototype but as a being with its own irreplaceable essence. 
 That's the reason why the needed not only to draw her self-portrait, but also to make it clear to all that it embodied something unique and irreplaceable, something worth fighting or even dying for. 
 After spending a quarter of an hour in the heat of the sauna, Agnes rose and took a dip in a small pool filled with ice-cold water. 
 Then she lay down to rest in the lounge, surrounded by other women who even here never stopped talking. 
 She wondered what kind of existence the computer programmed after death. 
 Two possibilities came to mind. 
 If the computer's field of activity is limited to our planet, and if our fate depends on it alone, then we cannot count on anything after death except some permutation of what we have already experienced in life; we shall again encounter similar landscapes and beings. 
 Shall we be alone or in a crowd? 
 Alas, solitude is not very likely, there is so little of it in life, so what can we expect after death! 
 After all, the dead far outnumber the living! 
 At best, existence after death would resemble the interlude she was now experiencing while reclining in a deckchair: from all sides, she would hear the continuous babble of female voices. 
 Eternity as the sound of endless babble: one could of course imagine worse things, but the idea of hearing women's voices forever, continuously, without end, gave her sufficient incentive to cling seriously to life and to do everything in her power to keep death as far away as possible. 
 But there is a second possibility: beyond our planet's computer, there may be others that are its superior. 
 Then, indeed, existence will not need to resemble our past life, and a person can die with a vague yet justified hope. 
 And Agnes imagined a scene that had lately been often on her mind: a stranger comes to visit her. 
 Likeable, cordial, he sits down in a chair facing her husband and herself and proceeds to converse with them. 
 Under the magic of the peculiar kindliness radiating from the visitor, Paul is in a good mood, chatty, intimate, and fetches an album of family photographs. 
 The guest turns the pages and is perplexed by some of the photos. 
 For example, one of them shows Agnes and Brigitte standing under the Eiffel Tower, and the visitor asks: &bquo;What is that?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's Agnes, of course,&equo; Paul replies. 
 &bquo;And this is our daughter, Brigitte.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know that,&equo; says the guest. 
 &bquo;I'm asking about this structure.&equo; 
 Paul looks at him in surprise: &bquo;Why, that's the Eiffel Tower!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, that's the Eiffel Tower,&equo; and he says it in the same tone of voice as if you had shown him a portrait of Grandpa, and he had said: &bquo;So that's your grandfather I've heard so much about. 
 I'm glad to meet him at last.&equo; 
 Paul is disconcerted, Agnes much less so. 
 She knows who the man is. 
 She knows why he came, and what he was going to ask them about. 
 That's why she is a bit nervous; she would like to be alone with him, without Paul, and she doesn't quite know how to arrange it. 
 I write about Agnes, I try to imagine her, I let her sit on a bench in the sauna, walk around Paris, leaf through a magazine, talk with her husband, but the thing that started it all, the gesture of a woman waving to a lifeguard by the side of a pool, it must seem as if I had forgotten that. 
 Does Agnes any longer wave to anyone in this manner? 
 No. 
 Strange as it seems, I believe that she had not done so for many years. 
 Long ago, when she was very young, yes, in those days she used to wave like that. 
 At that time she was still living in an Alpine town surrounded by mountain-tops silhouetted in the distance. 
 She was sixteen and went to the movies with a schoolfriend. 
 The instant the light went out, he took her hand. 
 Soon their palms became sticky, but the boy did not dare   let go of the hand he had so daringly grasped, for that would have meant admitting that he was perspiring and ashamed of it. 
 And so they sat with clammy hands for an hour and a half and let go only when the lights came back on. 
 He tried to prolong the date, leading her down the streets of the old part of town and then uphill to the courtyard of an old cloister, teeming with tourists. 
 He obviously had thought out everything in advance, because he led her quite briskly to a deserted passage, under the rather trite pretence that he wanted to show her a certain painting. 
 They reached the end of the passage, but instead of a picture there was only a dark brown door, marked with the letters WC. 
 The boy had not noticed the sign and stopped. 
 She knew perfectly well that he was not very interested in paintings and that he was  looking only for a secluded place where he could kiss her. 
 Poor boy, he had found nothing better than a dirty corner next to a lavatory! 
 She burst out laughing, and to make it clear that she wasn't laughing at him she pointed out the sign. 
 He laughed, too, but he was seized by hopelessness. 
 It was impossible to hug and kiss her with those letters in the background (all the more, since this was to be their first, and thus an unforgettable, kiss), and so he had no choice but to turn back with a bitter sense of capitulation. 
 They walked silently, and Agnes was angry. 
 Why didn't he kiss her quite calmly in the middle of the street? 
 Why did he have to lead her instead down an obscure passage to a toilet where generations of old and ugly and smelly monks had been relieving themselves? 
 His embarrassment flattered her, because it was a sign of his bewildered love, but it irritated her even more, because it testified to his immaturity; going with a boy the same age seemed like lowering oneself: she was only interested in older boys. 
 But perhaps because she was thus secretly rejecting him and yet knew at the same time that he was in love with her, a sense of justice prompted her to help him in amorous efforts, to support him, to rid him of childish embarrassment. 
 She resolved that if he couldn't find the necessary courage, she would. 
 He was walking her home, and she planned to throw her arms round him the moment they reached the gate of her house and to kiss him which would no doubt make him stand stock still, completely flabbergasted. 
 But at the last moment she lost the desire to do so, because his face was not merely sad but forbidding, even hostile. 
 And so they merely shook hands, and she walked off down the garden path to her door. 
 She sensed that the boy remained standing motionless, gazing after her. 
 She felt sorry for him once more; she felt for him the compassion of an older sister, and at that point she did something quite unpremeditated: as she kept on walking, she turned her head back towards him, smiled and lifted her right arm out in the air, easily, flowingly, as if she were tossing a brightly coloured ball. 
 That instant when Agnes suddenly, without preparation, lifted her arm in a flowing, easy motion was miraculous. 
 How was it possible that in a single fraction of a second, and for the very first time, she discovered a motion of the arm and body so perfect and polished that it resembled a finished work of art? 
 In those days, a woman of about forty used to come to see Agnes's father. 
 She was the departmental secretary, and she would bring papers for him to sign and take other papers back with her. 
 Even though these visits had no special significance, they were accompanied by mysterious tension (her mother would always turn silent), arousing Agnes's curiosity. 
 Whenever the secretary was leaving, Agnes ran to the window to watch her inconspicuously. 
 Once, as she was heading towards the gate (thus walking in the direction opposite to that which Agnes was to take somewhat later, followed by the gaze of her unfortunate schoolfriend), the secretary turned, smiled and lifted her arm out in the air in an unexpected gesture, easy and flowing. 
 It was an unforgettable moment: the sandy path sparkled in the rays of the sun like a golden stream, and on both sides of the gate jasmine bushes were blooming. 
 It was as if the upward gesture wished to show this golden piece of earth the direction of flight, while the white jasmine bushes were already beginning to turn into wings. 
 Father was not visible, but the woman's gesture indicated that he was standing in the doorway of the villa, gazing after her. 
 That gesture was so unexpected and beautiful that it remained in Agnes's memory like the imprint of a  lightning  bolt; it invited her into the depths of space and time and awakened in the sixteen-year-old girl a vague and immense longing. 
 At the moment when she suddenly needed to say something important to her boy and had no words for it, that gesture came to life and said on her behalf what she herself was unable to say. 
 I don't know how long she kept using it (or more precisely, how long it kept using her), but surely up to the day when she noticed her sister, younger by eight years, tossing up her arm while saying good-bye to a girlfriend. 
 When she saw her gesture performed by a sister who had been admiring and imitating her from earliest childhood, she felt a certain unease: the adult gesture did not fit an eleven-year-old child. 
 But more important, she realized that the gesture was available to all and thus did not really belong to her: when she waved her arm, she was actually committing theft or forgery. 
 From that time on, she began to avoid that gesture (it is not easy to break the habit of gestures altogether). 
 She tried to limit herself to the most important ones (to nod &bquo;yes&equo; or shake her head &bquo;no&equo;, to point at an object her companion had failed to see), to use only gestures that did not pretend to be her original expression. 
 And so it came to be that the bewitching gesture of her father's secretary walking down the golden path (which bewitched me when I saw the woman in the swimsuit take leave of the lifeguard) had completely gone to sleep in her. 
 And then one day it awoke. 
 It happened before her mother's death, when she was staying two weeks in the villa with her father. 
 As she was saying good-bye to him on the last day, she knew that they wouldn't see each other again for a long time. 
 Her mother wasn't at home, and her father wanted to see her to the car, which was parked in the street. 
 She forbade him to accompany her beyond the door and walked alone over the golden sand past the flower-beds to the gate. 
 She had a lump in her throat and an enormous yearning to say something beautiful to her father, something that could not be expressed by words, and so without quite knowing how it happened she suddenly turned her head and with a smile tossed out her arm in the air, easily, flowing, as if to see each other many more times. 
 An instant later she recalled the forty-year-old lady, who twenty-five years earlier had stood in the same place and had waved at her father in the same way. 
 That upset and confused her. 
 It was as if two distant times had suddenly met in a single second and two different women in a single gesture. 
 The thought passed through her head that those two women might have been the only ones he had ever loved. 
 In the salon where they were all sitting after dinner over glasses of brandy and half-finished cups of coffee, the first courageous guest rose to his feet and bowed with a smile to the lady of the house. 
 The others decided to take it as a signal, and along with Paul and Agnes jumped out of their armchairs and hurried to their cars. 
 Paul drove; Agnes sat next to him and absorbed the incessant movement of traffic, the blinking of the lights, the pointless agitation of a metropolitan night. 
 And she once again had the strong, peculiar feeling that was coming over her more and more often: the feeling that she had nothing in common with those two-legged creatures with a head on their shoulders and a mouth in their face. 
 There was a time when she was interested in their politics, their science, their inventions, when she considered herself a small part of the great adventure, until one day the feeling was born in her that she did not belong among them. 
 That feeling was strange, she resisted it, she knew that it was absurd as well as amoral, but in the end she told herself that she could not command her feelings: she was no longer able to torment herself with thoughts of their wars nor to enjoy their celebrations, because she was filled with the conviction that none of it was her concern. 
 Does it mean that she is cold-hearted? 
 No, it had nothing to do with the heart. 
 Anyway, nobody handed out as much money to beggars as she. 
 She could never ignore them as she passed them on the street, and they, as if they sensed it, turned to her, picking her out at once from a throng of a hundred other pedestrians as the one who saw and heard them. 
 Yes, it is true, but I must add the following: even her hand-outs to beggars were based on negation: she gave them money not because beggars, too, belonged to mankind, but because they did not belong to it, because they were excluded from it, and probably like her, felt no solidarity with mankind. 
 No solidarity with mankind: that was her attitude. 
 Only one thing could wrench her out of it: concrete love towards a concrete person. 
 If she truly loved someone, she could not be indifferent to the fate of other people, because her beloved would be dependent on that fate, he would be part of it, and she could no longer feel that mankind's torments, its wars and holidays, were none of her concern. 
 She was frightened by that last thought. 
 Was it true that she didn't love anyone? 
 And what about Paul? 
 She thought of the moment a few hours earlier, before they had left for dinner, when he had taken her in his arms. 
 Yes, something was going on inside her: recently, she was pursued by the idea that her love for Paul was merely a matter of will: merely the will to love him; merely the will to have a happy marriage. 
 If she eased up on this will for just a moment, love would fly away like a bird released from its cage. 
 It is one o'clock at night: Agnes and Paul are undressing. 
 If they were asked to describe their partner's motions at such times, they would be embarrassed. 
 For a long time now, they haven't been looking at each other. 
 Disconnected, their instrument of memory fails to record anything of those common night-time moments that preceded lying down in the marital bed. 
 The marital bed: the altar of marriage; and when one says altar, one implies sacrifice. 
 Here one of them sacrifices for the other: both have trouble falling asleep, and their partner's noisy breath wakes them; so they wriggle towards the edge of the bed, leaving a broad space down the middle; they pretend to be sound asleep, in the hope of making sleep easier for their partner, who will then be able to turn from side to side without disturbing the other. 
 Unfortunately, the partner does not make use of this opportunity, because he, too (and for the same reason), pretends to be asleep and fears to budge. 
 Not being able to fall asleep and not allowing oneself to move in the marital bed. 
 Agnes is stretched out on her back, and images keep passing through her head: that strange, kindly man is visiting them again, the one who knows all about them and yet has not heard of the Eiffel Tower. 
 She would give anything to be able to talk with him in private, but he deliberately chose a time when both of them were a home. 
 In vain, Agnes tried to think of a ruse to get Paul out of the house. 
 The three of them are sitting round a low table with three cups of coffee, and Paul is trying to entertain the visitor. 
 Agnes is only waiting for the guest to start speaking his reason for coming. 
 Actually, she knows the reason. 
 But only she knows, Paul doesn't. 
 At last, the visitor interrupts Paul's conversation and comes to the point: &bquo;You, I believe, have guessed where I'm from.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; says Agnes. 
 She knows that the guest has come from another, distant planet, one with an important status in the universe. 
 And she quickly adds, with a shy smile: &bquo;Is life better over there?&equo; 
 The visitor only shrugs: &bquo;Agnes, surely you know where you are living.&equo; 
 Agnes says: &bquo;Perhaps death must exist. 
 But was there no other way to arrange things? 
 Is it really necessary for a person to leave a body behind, a body that must be buried in the ground or thrown into a fire? 
 It's all so horrible!&equo; 
 &bquo;That's well known all over, that the Earth is horrible,&equo; says the visitor. 
 &bquo;And another thing,&equo; says Agnes. 
 &bquo;Perhaps you'll consider this question silly: those who live in your place, do they have faces?&equo; 
 No. 
 Faces exist nowhere else but here.&equo; 
 &bquo;So then those who love over there, how do they differ from one another?&equo; 
 &bquo;They're all their own creations. 
 Everybody, so to speak, thinks himself up. 
 But it's hard to talk about it. 
 You cannot grasp it. 
 You will, some day. 
 I came to tell you that in the next life you won't return to Earth.&equo; 
 Of course, Agnes knew in advance what the visitor would say to them, and she is hardly surprised. 
 But Paul is amazed. 
 He looks at the visitor, looks at Agnes, and she has no choice but to say: &bquo;And Paul?&equo; 
 &bquo;Paul won't stay here either,&equo; says the visitor. 
 &bquo;I've come to tell you that. 
 We always tell people we have selected. 
 I want to ask you only one question: do you want to stay together in your next life, or never meet again?&equo; 
 Agnes knew the question was coming. 
 That was the reason she wanted to be alone with the visitor. 
 She knew that in Paul's presence she would be incapable of saying: &bquo;I no longer want to be with him.&equo; 
 She could not say it in front of him, nor he in front of her, even though it is probable that he too would prefer to try living the next life differently, without Agnes. 
 Yet saying aloud to each other's face, &bquo;We don't want to remain together in the next life&equo; would amount to saying, &bquo;No love ever existed between us, and no love exists between us now.&equo; 
 And that's precisely what is so impossible to say aloud, for their entire life together (already over twenty years of life together), has been based on the illusion of love, an illusion which both of them have been anxiously guarding and nurturing. 
 And so whenever she imagined this scene, she knew that when it came to the visitor's question she would capitulate and declare against her wishes, against her desire: &bquo;Yes. 
 Of course. 
 I want us to be together in the next life.&equo; 
 But today for the first time she was certain that even in Paul's presence she would find the courage to say what she wanted, what she really wanted, in the depth of her soul; she was certain that she would find this courage even at the price of ruining everything between them. 
 Next to her she heard the sound of loud breathing. 
 Paul had really fallen asleep. 
 As if she were putting the same reel of film back in the projector, she ran through the whole scene once again: she is speaking to the visitor, Paul is watching them with astonishment, and the guest is  saying : &bquo;In your next life, do you want to stay together or never meet again?&equo; 
 (It is strange: even though he has all the necessary information about them, terrestrial psychology is incomprehensible to him &mdash; the concept of love unfamiliar, so that he cannot guess what a difficult situation he would create by his sincere, practical and well-intended question.) 
 Agnes gathers all her inner strength and answers in a firm voice: &bquo;We prefer never to meet again.&equo; 
 These words are like the click of a door shutting on the illusion of love. 
 Next month, exclusively in Esquire: 
 They thought he was an eccentric, a curmudgeon, a man with no time for humanity. 
 And they were right. 
 Uncle Dick, a new short story by Paul Theroux.  
 Real Life 
 the doctor is sick 
 He suffers from overload; he aches with frustration; he's starved of resources. 
 In other words, the system is killing him. 
 It's midnight in the back streets of the East End, hard rain is sluicing down, and I'm trying to locate the abdo pain's front door. 
 This medical day started at 8.30 am, with forty-five patients, many with no English, in two surgeries and an antenatal clinic. 
 This is the fifth home visit, and on-call duty doesn't finish for eight more hours. 
 Carcinoma, methadone, diabetes, depression, miscarriage and angina have poured down as unremittingly as the weather. 
 Tonight I'm the rota doctor on call for thirteen thousand people, all potential patients, and the strain is beginning to produce its familiar bi-temporal headache. 
 There it is at last, a dimly lit porch, the number twenty-one just visible. 
 Bent double, nipping to the car boot to get the drug bag, I see the car's rear window has been bashed in; broken glass shards cover the rear seat. 
 Five minutes spent at the Health Centre looking at the patient's notes, and someone has removed my medical bag with all my portable diagnostic equipment inside it. 
 The Sikh pattern-cutter's abdomen is examined with a distinctly shaky hand that tries to elicit the signs of a possible perforated ulcer as his family of six stare on with fixed incomprehension. 
 There are previous laparotomy scars, and a certain amount of overacting going on too. 
 Still, he'd better go into hospital. 
 One of his daughters takes me to borrow the telephone of a surly neighbour, who insists I pay for the call. 
 The hospital telephonist eventually gets hold of the surgical registrar. 
 He's keeping his last remaining beds for acute admissions and asks, not unreasonably, for the patient's blood pressure. 
 &bquo;Can't help you I'm afraid. 
 I've just had my sphygmomanometer stolen.&equo; 
 If there is a last straw, this is it. 
 The newly opted-out hospital trust is trying to close Casualty and is running down the wards of the Mile End branch of the Royal London Hospital, which has been serving the East End well since 1858. 
 Waiting lists are longer than ever; yet the day-surgery wards designed to cut them have been padlocked until the end of the financial year. 
 Prolonged NHS under-funding causes daily problems, and GPs have had the worst year most of us can remember, trying diligently to make some sense of their government-imposed contracts. 
 Versatility is all very well, but we are now expected to be accountants, personnel managers and lawyers as well as dermatologists, psychiatrists, obstetricians and general physicians. 
 And the prospect of yet another massive reorganization of the NHS has made April 1, 1991 a date in very poor taste. 
 The morale of British doctors is severely eroded, particularly in general practice, which throughout the Eighties, was expansive, innovatory and, increasingly, the most popular career choice for newly qualified young doctors. 
 All this is grim enough. 
 But stealing the  tools of your trade when you are out in the middle of the night is macabre. 
 I drive home, the rain pelting through the window, depressed and angry; musing on what other professional would be doing emergency night-work without uniform, driver, radio or specialist vehicle. 
 And be expected to do a full day's work the next day? 
 Yet I know the hours of the junior hospital doctors are even worse. 
 In the space of four weeks, not only has the car been broken into, but the Health Centre has been robbed of computer hardware for our new cardiovascular screening programme, I have been threatened with violence in my consulting-room for refusing to prescribe opiates and my home has been burgled at 5.00 am by a seventeen-year-old wielding a club hammer. 
 Small beer to the police, but it makes you feel a fraction unwanted. 
 At breakfast my seven-year-old daughter enquires, quite seriously: &bquo;Daddy, do you like being a doctor?&equo; 
 Slightly shocked, I hear myself say, &bquo;No&equo;. 
 Since Aesculapius, doctors have enjoyed complaining. 
 About the hours, the stress, the inadequate resources, the  incomprehending  bureaucrats and, most of all, about the incessant and insatiable demands of patients. 
 Occasionally there have been eruptions, most famously when mass pressure by GPs forced the 1966 reforms in primary care &mdash; the first substantial public investment into what had been the backwater of general practice. 
 More recently, junior hospital doctors took to the streets over their appallingly long hours, up to ninety in a single week. 
 In general, through, postwar morale among British doctors has been high. 
 We don't earn much by international standards, conditions of work are arduous, and chronic underfunding often makes them more so. 
 It is seldom possible, however many hours worked, to provide the quality of care we have been trained to deliver, except at the expense of the non-acute patients on the ever-extending waiting-lists. 
 The paradox exemplified: next day, I'm at Mile End Hospital with a patient who arrived with a pleural effusion, desperately short of breath, the previous night. 
 Lucy Wedderburn, the young medical registrar, has been up all night inserting drains and carefully drawing out bloodstained fluid, and she's still on duty, witty and vivacious through the exhaustion. 
 She finds time to sit down with the patient before she's wheeled off to X-Ray, explaining exactly how the lung will be sealed off, that pain is inevitable and how it will be controlled. 
 She then shows me the various x-rays, and we discuss the discharge arrangements. 
 There is real gratitude in the eyes of the lady whose life has probably been saved that night. 
 But Wedderburn is less thankful. 
 Over coffee and NHS apple crumble in the staff canteen, watching the West Indian cooks quietly stir the carbohydrates, she describes the staff's attitude to the opted-out hospital trust as &bquo;bitter indifference&equo;. 
 &bquo;A lot of people are just worried about having a j 
 The new head of the hospital trust is an avuncular ex-admiral brimming with ill-justified optimism, who told his first meeting with bewildered staff that &bquo;there was a lot in common between the NHS and the Navy&equo;. 
 &bquo;Sinking ships?&equo; 
 Dr Wedderburn suggests as she dashes off the answer her bleep. 
 On my way out, I pass sealed-off wards, under-used equipment and dingy staff accommodation, the shameful &mdash; because unnecessary &mdash; stigmata of the Nineties NHS. 
 This hospital is being forced to transfer its acute services to its overcrowded sister-hospital in Whitechapel because of underfinancing. 
 But, ironically, it has recently opened a wing for old people, one of the most modern in Europe. 
 Unfortunately, instead of being integrated in a general hospital as planned, the wing will now be left high and dry. 
 There is a state-of-the-art cardiac resuscitation unit, much better than the one on the general medical wards. 
 But most of the patients' notes are marked &bquo;Not for Resus&equo;! 
 We went through all this in the late-Seventies with Bethnal Green Hospital &mdash; a much-loved general hospital that was first geriatrified and then closed completely. 
 It used to provide a first-rate local casualty service and routine operating sessions that, especially in hip replacement, really sliced through the waiting lists. 
 The campaign waged by both public and hospital staff  was one of the biggest in east London's political history: over seven hundred people at the York Hall, the old boxing venue, twenty thousand signed petitions, a two-hour protest strike and the first-ever hospital work-in, which kept the hospital running for a month and treated eleven hundred emergencies after its official date of closure. 
 In the eventual settlement, fine promises were made about equivalent facilities' becoming available at Mile End Hospital. 
 And about geriatrics never again being isolated from general medicine and surgery. 
 But now they're doing the whole thing all over again. 
 Would you buy a used 
 It's the patients who suffer, stranded on the waiting-lists, nursing their pain and their justified anxiety till they get to see the specialist. 
 Inevitably, some will have diseases that go undiagnosed and therefore untreated. 
 The culprit is not, on the whole, inefficiency, indolence or excessive private work by hospital consultants. 
 Indeed, small miracles have been achieved in improving efficiency, shortening in-patient stay and improving facilities for day-surgery. 
 The problem is that we as a nation continue to expect a clinical quart out of an economic pint. 
 By all valid international comparisons, the NHS is under-funded by at least two per cent of gross national product. 
 Medicine is highly labour-intensive, and the NHS does not have the money to hold its own with the sheer weight of clinical traffic at present, let alone cope as the population gets older, the drug costs escalate and research brings exciting but expensive new treatments. 
 This prolonged under-funding strikes the GP most dramatically when he tries to admit an acutely ill patient. 
 The London Emergency Bed Service reports that this winter things have been four times as hard as last year, and my experience confirms this. 
 For six months I looked after a valiant clerical worker with cancer of the colon, which had spread to her liver before her condition was diagnosed. 
 When she became too ill and breathless to come to the surgery, I visited her once a week. 
 She was single, had no close relatives and didn't want the neighbours to know the diagnosis. 
 Her massively enlarged liver splinted her diaphragm, making her permanently breathless, and pressed on to her abdominal veins so that her legs became horribly swollen. 
 Yet despite the pain and dyspnoea, she would fuss over me and make tea for me with her best crockery. 
 For a long time, she managed to keep up her little flat herself, maintaining careful arrangements of dried flowers, folding newspapers into tidy piles, even sewing a teddy bear for a local charity raffle. 
 But in the final weeks she began to fall, and I organized a home help and district nurse. 
 I put her name down for the local hospice without her permission, because although she defiantly insisted she didn't want anything to do with it, I thought things might change as she deteriorated. 
 When I was finally called one wintry Monday by the neighbours, she looked quite dreadful; her faced was bruised from several falls the previous night, she was struggling for her breath, her legs and thighs were painful and very swollen. 
 She was incoherent and incapable of unassisted movement. 
 I heard myself saying the line that had been waiting ready for months: &bquo;I think the time has come when you must go in.&equo; 
 She nodded. 
 It then took me an hour as she lay there sobbing to find her a bed. 
 She was nowhere near the top of the hospice waiting-list (a bed was finally offered six days after her death). 
 The general wards were packed with acute cases and, although I received a sympathetic ear, no one really wanted to know. 
 Eventually, I found a young hospital registrar who said, not entirely as a joke: &bquo;I expect we'll find a cupboard for her&equo;. 
 As I hung on the phone, I ingested the  sad evidence of a service which, although well-intentioned, simply hadn't coped. 
 The promised home help hadn't turned up despite several letters, and there'd been no sign of the district nurse over the weekend. 
 The normally immaculate room was a dirty mess, and pus was oozing through a leg ulceration into a bandage that looked several days old. 
 I couldn't be certain how much painkilling medication she had taken, but it was almost certainly not enough. 
 The neighbours, once in the picture, were kindness itself &mdash; though the woman who had rung me, standing smoking on the steps, shouted after me: &bquo;Took your bloody time, didn't you.&equo; 
 Next day, as soon as I'd finished giving a police statement about a drug addict who had threatened me and attempted to steal syringes and prescriptions, I went to see her in hospital. 
 The ward packed with seriously ill patients was in a state of controlled pandemonium. 
 I eventually tracked down the ward sister, who was wrestling with an intravenous drip that had collapsed. 
 The nurses seemed overwhelmed, and when I did find one with a moment to spare, she told me my patient had died half an hour earlier. 
 Her body had already been removed. 
 &bquo;We need the space, I'm afraid.&equo; 
 I wanted to ask if she had died peacefully, whether they had used a syringe driver, if there'd been anyone to comfort her. 
 I refrained because the evidence suggested the answers would all be negative. 
 The last dying patient I'd been to visit in this hospital had been the caretaker of our Health Centre, in much pain from a carcinoma of the pancreas. 
 Normally the mildest of men, Frank had said: &bquo;I'd like some of those bastards who say the NHS is safe in their hands to spend a night in here. 
 Two lasses looking after thirty surgical patients with two admissions on top.&equo; 
 I have very little confidence in the &bquo;reforms&equo; being introduced with such a fanfare this month. 
 Rather than eliminating NHS under-funding and the resulting problems, I think they will increase the bureaucracy, without any guarantee of better patient-care. 
 And I don't believe it provides a strategy for getting to grips with the underlying causes of ill-health. 
 In London's East End, people, especially the elderly, are often ill-fed, ill-housed and ill-clad, as well as being plain ill. 
 These are the people who missed out on the Eighties' boom and who are now being hit hardest by the recession. 
 How can they hope their asthma will get better in a draughty, poorly insulated flat? 
 What price the &bquo;efficiency savings&equo; made by day-surgery and early discharge when the patient leaves hospital with barely controlled pain and becomes infected, or simply can't cope at home and requires re-admission? 
 What do I say when I visit an old Cockney lady with a fractured leg who has been sent home because the orthopaedic surgeons need her bed for the daily influx of trauma, but who can't stand unaided and who lives alone? 
 Increase her painkillers to a dangerous level, make do with the district nurses and hope she doesn't fall again, which is, in fact, her best chance to get back in hospital! 
 The ambulance service in London does an outstanding and poorly rewarded job under horrendous pressure. 
 And sometimes it lets you down. 
 A note is pushed under the surgery door: &bquo;Mr and Mrs Frederick Saposnik. 
 Cramps top leg. 
 Fainted. 
 Just had heart trouble. 
 Job to breathe. 
 Enard House&equo;. 
 I hurry round. 
 Mr Saposnik's dying; Mrs S offers tea. 
 Despite two coronary bypasses, he's now strangled with anoxic pain, face grey, clutching his throat. 
 We wait for the ambulance, window open so they can identify us, doilies neatly heaped on yellowing copies of the local paper, the cat perturbed by my frantic resuscitation efforts. 
 &bquo;Come,&equo; she used to say, &bquo;as long as you don't think he's wasting your time.&equo; 
 That reflex is an old one, prepared to make a tactical retreat, but also courtesy. 
 To advance with charm or a curse. 
 He is dead now. 
 The ambulance is late. 
 I try to comfort Mrs S, while ringing with the other hand to cancel the 999. 
 Somebody else will need it. 
 Despite the planners, people are people and fiercely loyal to their hospitals. 
 Mr Morris, an ex-docker with a waggish humour, is one such. 
 &bquo;Wotcha got this hammer for then?&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;It's not, it's a stethoscope. 
 How's your chest?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sounds like someone's playing the flute down there at night. 
 If I go in, I want to go to Bethnal Green Hospital.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well you can't, you know &mdash; it's for older people now.&equo; 
 His wife was an orderly there when it was still a general hospital. 
 She knows from inside the sadness of a hospital closure. 
 Later his wife calls. 
 &bquo;Quick. 
 Now put your coat on and come quick. 
 He's faintified and sickified.&equo; 
 He's cyanosed, hyperventilating; pneumonia with a possible infarct. 
 &bquo;It's a bit dicky, like. 
 Could you give it a once-over? 
 Maybe I'll go in. 
 Just don't make me a geriatric case, Doc.&equo; 
 I spend a long time with the Emergency Bed Service on the neighbour's phone. 
 They can't get hold of the medical referee. 
 &bquo;No beds anywhere tonight, sir.&equo; 
 The &bquo;sir&equo; is supposed to make me feel better. 
 He eventually dies in the ambulance, on the way to a hospital that isn't closed. 
 And so it goes on. 
 Punks with their dogs piss in the waiting-room and ask for money. 
 Saul the furrier is depressed again. 
 When he's depressed, he stutters. 
 &bquo;I think it's a sin to answer a doctor back,&equo; he says, because he's angry and wants to shout at me, at anyone. 
 But can't. 
 I tell him that in a depression, manners are the first casualties. 
 His liver is enormous, and his liver-function tests will be sky-high. 
 I go to see his wife the next day. 
 She confides, &bquo;He gets a few drinks and wants to wipe everybody out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, how do you feel?&equo; 
 I enquire. 
 &bquo;When you feel happy you can share happiness, but we never are. 
 I tell you straight it's useless. 
 Pills &mdash; what are they supposed to do?&equo; 
 The last visit of the day is to Mr Mercer who has myeloma: &bquo;It's a disease I can recommend to anyone,&equo; he jokes. 
 &bquo;He's the kind that won't give in,&equo; says his wife. 
 He takes his terminal care in the pub: &bquo;Can you make that a large one, Ben, the other one went too quickly.&equo; 
 He dies on Christmas Eve, and they don't come for the body till the day after Boxing Day. 
 Some weeks later, I receive a note of thanks along with an engraved beermug.  
 Home visit: chances are many of Widgery's elderly patients, once hospitalized, will be marked &bquo;Not for Resuscitation&equo; 
 All in a day's work: since Aesculapius, doctors have enjoyed complaining. 
 About the hours, the stress, the resources, the bureaucrats and, most of all, about the incessant and insatiable demands of patients 
 Desolation row: Despite a concerted public campaign, the Bethnal Green Hospital (opposite) was geriatrified, then closed. 
 House-call (above): fear and loathing haunt a Hackney estate. 
 Resource Book 
 the tie 
 The art and anatomy of men's clothing 
 The choice of a tie will not make a dullard shine at work or help him get the girl of his dreams. 
 But don't underestimate the impact of the sartorial noose that hangs around your neck. 
 A wise man will always invest in silk, except in the rare circumstances where cotton or wool will do. 
 Before buying a tie, hold it up by the skinny end, like a fish. 
 If it is cut crosswise, across the bias of the cloth, which gives fluidity and firmness it will hang straight. 
 Purists might also check that the lock-stitch at the skinny end is hand-drawn for elasticity and strength and that the keeper-bar, which crosses the tie at its widest point, has also been stitched by hand. 
 As a rule, a striped tie should never be worn with a striped shirt, although Paul Smith frequently breaks that one with gusto. 
 And wider ties look better against the simplicity of a crisp white shirt. 
 Public schools have had hundreds of years to monopolize the best combinations of stripes, and T M Lewin &amp; Sons will happily sell you anything you request by name &mdash; that you know what to ask for usually being deemed proof enough that you are entitled to it. 
 Colour is, of course, crucial. 
 Yellow sits on the fence between the powerful punches of red and true-blue; curiously, green ties are often associated with failure. 
 Most popular among the rich is the Herm&egrave;s tie, in any of its myriad minuscule equestrian patternings. 
 It is a mark that one has arrived. 
 Fashion designers who include ties in their offerings (as opposed to tie designers like Turnbull &amp; Asser) should be treated with caution. 
 Ties emblazoned with designer logos can spell a lot of money and a lack of confidence in one's own taste. 
 In 1939, Esquire told readers that ties should be &bquo;conservative, muted, an object lesson in restraint&equo;. 
 It's a dictum that largely holds true today, except, of course, for the Pucci tie. 
 Whirligigs of bubblegum-pink and fuchsia, mauve, lime and caf&eacute; au lait look even more fun now than they did back in the Sixties &mdash; when men last loved them. 
 Marion Hume     
 T M LEWIN &amp; SONS Trustworthy deep stripes for the old Rugbeian, &pound;17.50 
 MULBERRY The optimist's tie. 
 Summer's approach spelt out in a breezy spin on Paisley. 
 VALENTINO For the rogue within the establishment. 
 The print is wild, but the colours stay same. 
 Silk twill, &pound;49.50 
 T M LEWIN &amp; SONS The tie for that elder-statesman's occasion. 
 Silvered with silver on heavy woven silk, &pound;24 
 YOHJI YAMAMOTO The fashion-speak tie. 
 Needs care to wear without looking like a nerd, unless one is Japanese. 
 Madras-checked silk, &pound;60 
 Know your tie: what's where and why 
 Looped label with designer's logo 
 Outer shell 
 Hand-stitched keeper-bar 
 Interlining for shape 
 Rolled edge 
 Tipping, the second lining 
 Hemming or margin 
 The two shells of the tie are stitched together 
 HILDITCH &amp; KEY Penny polka dots for the conservative in flamboyant mood. 
 Silk twill, &pound;34.95 
 HERMES Looks fun, spells power. 
 The only joke-tie grown men should play with, &pound;55 
 MOSCHINO For the boy in the man. 
 Safe background and tacky graphics. 
 The office-party tie. 
 In figured silk, &pound;32.50 
 ERMENEGILDO ZEGNA The drinker's tie resonates favourably with the floral wallpaper of the watering-hole, &pound;42.50 
 T M LEWIN &amp; SONS Old School &mdash; the Marlborian navy, claret and slim-white stripe. 
 Heavy woven silk, &pound;17.50 
 SALVATORE FERRAGAMO The refined gambler's tie, patterned in greyhounds on a daring tangerine ground. 
 Silk twill, &pound;48 
 GIANFRANCO FERRE The arriviste's tie, complete with baroque coat-of-arms for the nouveau landowner. 
 Silk, &pound;42.50 
 KENZO The bond-dealer's tie. 
 Traditional Paisley with a gutsy edge, &pound;32.50 
 TURNBULL &amp; ASSER The comeback tie. 
 Whirligig psychedelia from the heart of the establishment. 
 Heavy silk twill, &pound;40 
 HILDITCH &amp; KEY An avenger among ties. 
 A bold Sixties-style graphic for the brave. 
 Silk satin, &pound;24.95 
 TURNBULL &amp; ASSER A salesman's tie &mdash; but would you trust a man in canary yellow? 
 Silk twill, &pound;40 
 T M LEWIN &amp; SONS The convivial powder-blue, gold-and-amber Old Wellingtonian's tie. 
 Heavy woven silk, &pound;17.50 
 T M LEWIN &amp; SONS A monarch among ties. 
 Graphic black-and-silver dog-tooth in Duke of Windsor style, &pound;24 
 PAUL SMITH For the modern medallion man, or those who trust Smith's taste implicitly. 
 A brave boardroom choice in silk twill, &pound;39 
 T M LEWIN &amp; SONS The double-dealer's club tie. 
 Herm&egrave;s-style snaffle pattern without the price tag, &pound;17.50 
 MULBERRY For the traditionalist, a palatable Paisley. 
 Silk twill, &pound;45 
 MICHELSON'S FOR HARRODS The polka-dot standard in monochrome. 
 Silk cr&ecirc;pe de chine, &pound;23.50 
 KENZO For the sensitive soul from a good school. 
 Old Boy stripes meet the flower bed, &pound;39.95 
 PUCCI For those too young to remember them last time, or those too eccentric to care. 
 In silk twill, &pound;45 
 HARRODS Sights of the Seventies, muted blow-up polka dots on a spot-woven ground, &pound;35 
 YVES SAINT LAURENT The talking-head tie for the left-of-centre aesthete. 
 For Malcolm Bradbury or RSC directors, &pound;45 
 TURNBULL &amp; ASSER Dee-groovy &mdash; random graphic spots on respectable navy, &pound;35 
 ERMENEGILDO ZEGNA The early-riser's tie, with the freshness of those best in the morning, &pound;42.50 
 Dispatches 
 apocalypse now now 
 In South Africa, only mad dogs and security guards go out in the last white summer 
 In the car park of Johannesburg's giant Roodepoort Hyperama, around eight every Tuesday night, under the brilliant powder of the southern stars, you can hear music&hellip; big dog music&hellip; nocturnal mastiff choirs. 
 The dogs are excited, and they give voice to their exuberance. 
 But these are dogs in training: they come to heel; they do not attack indiscriminately; but they can barely wait for the big bite. 
 And so they bark. 
 Out there, in the darkness, it is clear that these hounds have friends, sisters, cousins, uncles. 
 All over the suburb of Roosevelt, from its hills and valleys, the dogs of the neighbourhood add their voices. 
 The world is barking mad. 
 All the dogs in the backyards and all the dogs in the gardens of this  pleasant white suburb, all the dogs patrolling factories and shops, join their brothers and sisters in the hypermarket car park, until you begin to believe there must be more dogs here that in all of England. 
 Roodepoort of Hyperama's car park is an arena &mdash; there are others, if you know where to look &mdash; in which are played out the sad, savage realities of modern South Africa. 
 Fear is the key, and it takes many forms. 
 There is no audience tonight; just owners, trainers, biters and the bitten. 
 Tonight, Mr Sherwood of the Sherwood Forest dog-training centre is working his attack group. 
 The owners &mdash; all white &mdash; hang on to his every word, and to their dogs. 
 Three bored black men sit in the back of a mini-van. 
 What is notable about them is not that they are black, but that they do not have dogs. 
 Roodepoort Hyperama may not look like the sort of place where white South Africa bares its heart. 
 But you'd be surprised. 
 The yellow lights on their anorexic columns look mad, like cyclopean triffids, very thin, very tall. 
 But they are one example of white South Africa's debt to Soweto. 
 The township got electric light a few years ago, yet for as long as anyone could remember power-station cooling stacks had blasted out steam day and night; the power went to white Johannesburg a few miles down the road. 
 No one thought it odd, just the way things were in the &bquo;old&equo; South Africa. 
 Today, Soweto has lights &mdash; so you can see who is mugging you, the locals like to observe. 
 And the lights &mdash; you guessed it &mdash; sit high on anorexic columns where they can't be stoned. 
 So in the Hyperama car park, part of the &bquo;new&equo; South Africa, they're taking another leaf from the Sowetan book of the dead. 
 Now it's target time. 
 And that is where the three bored blacks came in. 
 They have been sitting in the back of the mini-van, swapping football scores and smoking cigarettes. 
 In fact these are not really black guys at all. 
 These are meals on heels, moving targets, room service. 
 They are well-known to the dog owners. 
 &bquo;Hullo Brian, welcome back.&equo; 
 Brian doesn't reply. 
 He is putting on his protection, a long mitt made of sacking up to his elbow. 
 All three put on their arms. 
 They pick up sticks. 
 &bquo;Brian,&equo; Mr Sherwood calls, &bquo;they're talking to you.&equo; 
 Brian grins and waves his stick. 
 He doesn't exactly say; he's pleased to be back. 
 &bquo;Peter, shut up!&equo; commands the owner of the overweight Rottweiler. 
 Peter doesn't listen, but goes on lifting his big, heavy head, trying to swallow the moon. 
 &bquo;Praise your dog!&equo; 
 Mr Sherwood commands. 
 Everyone so enjoined slaps his dog around the ears, and they all seem to enjoy it. 
 Stephanie comes forward and lies on the ground. 
 Under the harsh highlights, she  looks like a road-crash victim, stretched out on the tarmac, blonde hair fanning around her. 
 &bquo;Moan like you're in pain,&equo; Mr Sherwood directs. 
 Stephanie does a very big number. 
 Her cries of distress reach across the car park. 
 Jody, her German Shepherd, goes wonderfully mad. 
 Brian and his friends advance on the fallen woman. 
 Mr Sherwood, also wearing an arm, joins the three others. 
 They raise their sticks. 
 They are no longer three black men and a dog-trainer. 
 They are rapists, burglars, muggers &mdash; what all the dogs, guns, armed-response patrols, high walls, razor wire and electrified fencing are all about. 
 They are, quite simply, &bquo;the terror&equo; that stalks white South Africa's beautiful suburbs. 
 Jody the German Shepherd is very, very good. 
 She attacks, but never lets herself be drawn too far away from the recumbent, moaning body of her mistress. 
 She forms a protective snarling circle. 
 Mr Sherwood is pleased. 
 &bquo;Praise your dog,&equo; he tells Stephanie. 
 She dusts herself off and rejoins the group. 
 People get dogs all wrong, says Mr Sherwood. 
 For a start, there are these libels about violent Rottweilers. 
 In South Africa, you might think just about everyone owns a Rottweiler &mdash; especially if you read the small ads in the papers, where owners lament their loss and sign themselves &bquo;Devastated Rotty Lover&equo;. 
 In fact, the most popular dog continues to be the German Shepherd, with the Dobermann a perennial favourite and the Staffordshire Bull Terrier enjoying a surge of support among white householders in search of a bigger bite. 
 The trouble with Rottweilers, Mr Sherwood  maintains, is that people simply don't understand them. 
 For instance, a householder choosing a Rottweiler will usually pick a male &mdash; a bad mistake, because Rottweiler males are quite incapable of taking orders from women. 
 They are canine chauvinists. 
 Mr Sherwood teachers prospective Rotty lovers to go for a female. 
 More amenable. 
 Then there is the cute puppy syndrome. 
 Buyers often choose the most go-ahead pup in a litter. 
 Choose the strong dog in a pack, then fail to discipline it properly, and you're asking for trouble. 
 The dog decides it had better police this family itself, and, next thing you know, it is fastening its jaws on disobedient members of the family, its family. 
 A top dog always wants to be top dog. 
 Contrary to distant impressions, keeping ferocious dogs is not exactly novel in South Africa. 
 The only element that may be called modern, or contemporary, is the training, the direction, the motive. 
 Everyone took out protection before. 
 They lay in bed and worried about the children, the silver, their daughters and themselves. 
 Everyone kept dogs and guns. 
 But the fear was not focused, nor was it terminal. 
 Now, increasingly, there is a feeling that things are hopelessly out of control. 
 A sense of an ending, a millenarian impulse perhaps, a fear that the Last Days are coming. 
 Now, it seems, with apartheid laws dying daily, things are getting worse. 
 And all shades of white opinion turn a little paler. 
 Sit with a right-wing, black-bashing, neo-fascist in a little pub in that great, arid and beautiful semi-desert, the Karoo, a kind of South African outback, and you will be told loudly and often that the blacks are getting ready to rise. 
 Hundreds and thousands of white will die. 
 It will be the old Boer v Black wars again. 
 Thousands will leave their shacks in Soweto and march on Johannesburg, massacring all before them, seizing babies and dashing their heads against the kerbstones. 
 I had this from a bible student named Johan, one of the new doom-mongers, who believes in apocalypse, not &bquo;now&equo; but &bquo;now-now&equo;, as South Africans say, meaning pretty damn soon. 
 Many South Africans deny this. 
 They even get angry and suggest these are lies put about by foreigners who do not understand how deeply attuned they are to Mother Africa. 
 Alas, Mother Africa has always had pretty indifferent maternal instincts. 
 She sees her children die and makes more. 
 She is not given to grieving. 
 Fifteen thousand people were murdered in South Africa last year. 
 The removal of old-style apartheid and the beginnings of a democratic society have brought more bloodshed than ever. 
 But it is not political any longer; it's just that more people seem  to be doing damage to more people, especially old people, single people, those who live alone. 
 In a word, unarmed people. 
 It is a kind of bloody democracy. 
 It is the random nature of the violence that so terrorizes whites. 
 A man driving down a country road is stopped, and a spike is driven into his head. 
 He somehow continues his journey to the next town and dies in somebody's arms. 
 Who did it and why? 
 No one knows. 
 But it keeps the gun shops happy. 
 A locally admired civil servant, known to be gay, is murdered in his home, and the killers flee without their trousers. 
 The police are baffled. 
 Three trouserless murderers fleeing through the night in a quite Cape Town suburb? 
 Everyone registers the terror in his own way. 
 A leading publisher, Hugh Murray, has trouble deciding what scares him most. 
 &bquo;You go to a dinner party and find that three of the guests have had an elderly parent murdered.&equo; 
 Or, if he really wants to worry aloud, he recalls the time not long ago when he woke one morning to find a black man looming over him in his bedroom carrying most of the clothes from wardrobe in one hand and the family carving knife in the other. 
 &bquo;And I've got just about the best security around,&equo; he says. 
 Back in the old days, in the Fifties, before the nights of car-park-training, people kept big dogs, with names like Nero and Saladin, Sakkie and Doris; dogs that roamed the sandy ex-Servicemen's estate where I grew up, on the edge of Johannesburg, a jumble of sandy streets named after English kings and queens. 
 Those dogs bit the neighbours, the dustbin men, visiting aunts and each other. 
 We kept them because of the burglars. 
 Our fathers, who had just been demobbed, struggled to build 
 The burglars lived in the bluegums at the bottom of the estate. 
 They were rumoured to wait until dark and them to cross into the white suburb and steal wallets from trousers draped across bedroom chairs while their white owners slept. 
 They used fishing rods and hooks, those cunning, black, nocturnal anglers, and they were blamed for the disappearance of booze from liquor cabinets and sugar from pantries. 
 Our fathers slept with their Browning Army-issue pistols beside them and sometimes rushed into the starry African night, blazing away at burglars we never saw. 
 But presumably they ran back to the bluegums, carrying in one arm a pair of trousers and in the other a fishing rod. 
 Such images emblazoned on the African night! 
 Most houses had their windows barred as standard; wealthier householders went in for burglar alarms. 
 Dinner parties were given over to discussion of the choices before customers. 
 Did you buy Tarson or Pluto of Reveille? 
 Johannesburg was the burglar-alarm capital of the world. 
 What did you do when you shot a black man running down the road? 
 The answer, passed onto folklore, was you dragged him back into your garden before you called the police. 
 That way you were covered, legally; he was dead, and the police were happy. 
 Now, the fearful buy their guns from guys like John, who has his own shop and also helps out at a suburban shooting school, the Academy of Marksmanship&hellip; 
 &bquo;No hip shooting! 
 No tracer ammunition!&equo; 
 A high-tech place with a video shooting-range. 
 Moving targets and this month's specials are advertised on the board as you enter: &bquo;A Beretta ten-gauge and a six-shot pump action&hellip; 
 &equo; And &bquo;Gun Hire&equo; this week is toting a nice Parabellum. 
 John practises what he preaches. 
 He carries a gun everywhere. 
 &bquo;Even on my lap between traffic lights&hellip; 
 &equo; Up near Alexandra township, bordering on a swish white suburb, there have been seventeen hijackings recently. 
 Hapless drivers draw up at the lights and are yanked from their cars at knife-point. 
 Just another form of the takeaway service some blacks are going in for these days. 
 They don't plan to stand around while Mandela makes up his mind about what they are going to get. 
 &bquo;Question is not if I shoot someone, but when I shoot someone,&equo; says John. 
 He tells me, though, that he dreads the day, and I believe him. 
 John rests his not-inconsiderable front on the glass counter of the gun display which offers a nice little Derringer for the wife, or a thirty-eight special. 
 &bquo;A lot of ladies carry them, in their handbags.&equo; 
 John is a man heavy with fatalism: &bquo;I work with guns and live with fear every day of my life.&equo; 
 The real attraction for the gun-hungry attackers, John observes acutely, is the gun itself. 
 &bquo;They don't want you. 
 It's the weapon they want, and if they have to take you out to get it, what's to lose? 
 Nothing.&equo; 
 They're teaching them to pull the trigger at the Academy of Marksmanship. 
 The beginners, in their red-and-yellow ear protectors, are a mixed lot, truly a sign of the new South Africa. 
 Though most are white, there is a sprinkling of blacks, Indians and &bquo;mixed race&equo; or coloureds. 
 There are figures to shoot on the screen, and the hits light up like splashes of gold. 
 The targets are black men with superimposed concentric circles declining to a solid, black bullseye. 
 A kind of lethal darts. 
 It's democratic. 
 The instructors walk around with weapons on their belts and constantly remind their pupils to don their ear protectors. 
 Two men share a single chair, their arms around each other. 
 Political liberation conveys a degree of sexual freedom. 
 They are being trained in the use of the twenty-two calibre revolver. 
 There is a small difficulty. 
 One of the instructors, Douglas, warns: &bquo;Locally manufactured twenty-two rounds have a failing. 
 The don't always go off. 
 The manufacturers have been alerted and they're working on the problem.&equo; 
 It is, as you can imagine, a serious problem. 
 You've taken your certificate of competence, you can blow holes in the intruder with calm accuracy. 
 You lift your weapon, and nothing happens. 
 This is not the time to think of demanding your money back. 
 &bquo;Best buy the imported rounds,&equo; Douglas advises. 
 &bquo;Work every time.&equo; 
 You don't need to be trained to get a gun licence. 
 But just because you don't need a certificate of competence doesn't mean you'll get a licence even if you have one. 
 It is, needless to say, a question of colour. 
 The new South Africa is not that new. 
 The government shares John's concern about the number of guns in nervous hands. 
 &bquo;So it came up with the idea of an amnesty on illegal weapons.&equo; 
 John raises sceptical eyes to the bomb-display board on the wall over our heads. 
 A common sight in public places, it teaches South Africans to recognize limpet mines. 
 &bquo;What happened? 
 A lot of people started handing in pellet guns and antique muzzle-loaders they've been keeping for years without a licence. 
 But they're not the trouble. 
 Most of the illegal guns are not being bought over the counter, or stolen. 
 What about the heavy stuff coming in from up north? 
 From the borders? 
 I've seen a guy toting an AK-47. 
 With my own eyes! 
 Just three blocks from Alexandra township. 
 You can be sure  those guys won't be toddling down tot he police with their weapons.&equo; 
 Far more than incipient political change, it is the random violence that makes for the sense of dread among whites. 
 That is what stokes their desire to flee (if only the damned rand were not so low, and the idea of settling in Ealing so bloody depressing); what scares the living daylights out of the lovely green suburbs. 
 So what is to be done? 
 Well, fine, you've got your dog trained in close-attack work; a female Rottweiler, number three in the litter, no top dogs for you. 
 And you've taught her not to savage the children. 
 Stephanie advises letting her lie on your tummy when you're pregnant and listen to the life within. 
 You've bought your own twenty-two, or hired a Parabellum, and you're using only imported rounds. 
 You've taken the full course at the Academy of Marksmanship. 
 You know when and how and whom to shoot. 
 The women in the house are all toting thirty-eights in their Gucci bags. 
 You've also built a big wall around your house. 
 Johannesburg is the wall-building capital of the world. 
 There are white walls, straight walls, curved walls; crenellated, spiked or studded; with portholes and peepholes; with grills, bars, gates. 
 And along the top of the wall where once, back in the peaceful times, you set pieces of broken glass, you now run razor wire, each tine designed for maximum snag. 
 The tines are erect, almost beautiful, along the neck of the beautiful walls; short, murderous hairs bristling along the nape of your fortress. 
 Publisher Hugh Murray graphically illustrates the sort of thing you can still expect when you arrive home and take refuge behind the walls. 
 Once you are inside, no one can hear you scream. 
 More and more people in South Africa want to go where they can't hear the screaming. 
 But what if it is your screaming? 
 &bquo;This lady is fetching her kids from school. 
 She opens the electronic gates and drives into her home. 
 Closes the gates. 
 And there is this guy waiting for her 
 So you sign up with one of the many armed and mobile security patrols that operate in the white suburbs. 
 You can try Magnum Security, or Top &bquo;Em or Rent-A-Guard, Abe's Alsatian Patrols of Sandton Sentries. 
 You could do worse than to sign up with Armed Response, which looks after thousands of homes in middle-class Johannesburg North, a rich hunting-ground that Gary Whittaker, a director of Armed Response, calls &bquo;the captured area&equo;. 
 Armed Response is doing wonderful business these days in the captured area. 
 &bquo;Hullo, angel child!&equo; says a buxom blonde to a thin youth who looks like he's in training to become a sales manager. 
 Behind the desk, the receptionist appears to have had a late night. 
 I guess the folks at Armed Response never sleep. 
 This is a twenty-four hour service. 
 The armed guards who ride the patrol vans day and night, a kind of AA service with guns, are dressed in black-and-yellow uniforms and wear black, rubber police boots. 
 They carry pistols, handcuffs, batons and gas-spray guns. 
 The gas is not intended for human consumption &mdash; but to deter the angry dogs not trained to tell the difference between a burglar and a saviour. 
 Having failed to deter the murderer or rapist, these dogs are often eager for a second bite of the cherry. 
 The Armed Response guys are ready for them. 
 &bquo;You get sent to investigate,&equo; says Gray Whittaker happily. 
 &bquo;You bale over the wall. 
 You say hello to the Rottweiler.&equo; 
 He extends a finger &mdash; 
 All the mobile guns working for Armed Response are white. 
 &bquo;Every single person is finger-printed,&equo; Mr Whittaker explains. 
 &bquo;And we pay better than the police.&equo; 
 Looking at the guards in their bumble-bee uniforms and at their guns, I don't know what they do to the burglars, but they scare the hell out of me. 
 If things continue at this rate of terror, the white population of South Africa will one day divide into those cowering behind tall walls and those driving mobile-response vehicles. 
 Whittaker is dismissive of con men climbing on the bandwagon. 
 &bquo;This business of full of camels. 
 So-called security. 
 Blas&eacute; individuals. 
 Put in a big alarm. 
 Goes off. 
 Police don't respond.&equo; 
 Armed Response does things properly. 
 It is going great guns with special lines, the Fortress Alarm and the upgraded, fancy number, the Citadel. 
 Mr Whittaker will wire up your place to one of his alarms. 
 He'll fit you with the latest in Japanese-made static infra-red detectors. 
 His talk is all of pre-programmed key pads, panic buttons and radio relays. 
 Mr Whittaker is keen to emphasize that the rising crime rate is not really a racial affair. 
 It is a first-world v third-world thing. 
 When the economy is bad and unemployment high, crime is rife. 
 As residential restrictions on blacks buying houses in white areas are relaxed, he is beginning to pick up black clients just as anxious as their white neighbours to escape the dark forces prowling the streets. 
 This has led to embarrassing moments among his pure-white mobile guard force. 
 Mr Whittaker warns his men not to assume that the black who answers the door of a heavily guarded fortress  is the maid. 
 &bquo;I had a guy knock on the door and ask: &bquo;Is the madam in? 
 Only to be told &bquo;I am the madam&equo;!&equo; 
 I talked to Whittaker almost a year to the day after Nelson Mandela had been released from his Cape prison. 
 His offices are on Hendrik Verwoerd Drive. 
 Oh, the happy ironies of South African life, the unconscious poetry of its names! 
 When Dr Verwoerd, the ayatollah of apartheid, ruled, South Africa was a policed desert where dissent seldom flourished, and the hangman was very busy indeed. 
 Mandela was in jail forever, and God was in His Heaven. 
 The year since Mandela was freed may have been pretty interesting politically; but for the Armed Response boys, it has been an absolute ball. 
 &bquo;Since our friend from Robben Island was released, the alarm industry has popped!&equo; 
 But if all the dogs and guns and mobile-response patrols cannot guarantee your safety, where do you go? 
 The answer, for numbers of whites, is to move lock, stock and Rottweiler into something called &bquo;cluster housing&equo;. 
 If, as Le Corbusier suggested, a house is a machine for living in, cluster housing is a machine for not being murdered in. 
 For a large down-payment, all your cares dissolve. 
 You move into a group of houses within a walled compound, provided with all the security services you require. 
 Guards on the gates around the clock. 
 Lights that burn all night. 
 These places are reminiscent of medieval walled villages where the night watch called the hours, and the look-out scanned the countryside for invading mercenaries of yet another papal army. 
 Except this is not the Italy of the Middle Ages; this is Johannesburg, South Africa in 1991. 
 Some of these places are walled retirement villages for the elderly. 
 Some are for the young. 
 If the developers of these walled refuges were bold enough to include small industries, perhaps also offering to connect young executives by computer and fax to the outside world, the inhabitants of clusterland would never have to leave home at all. 
 They might indeed come to believe that they were not really living in Africa at all. 
 After all, that is why many whites bought into Africa in the first place. 
 It was on condition no one ever reminding them they were actually living there. 
 That is what Mr Whittaker means by his &bquo;first world, third world&equo; dichotomy. 
 It is just the latest, polite way of saying that whites want to live in Africa, but they can't for the life of them get along with Africans. 
 The trouble is, Africa keeps coming to call. 
 And since, in the words of Mr Whittaker, &bquo;our friend from Robben Island was released&equo;, Africa keeps coming to call in no uncertain fashion. 
 The trek to clusterland seems assured. 
 Johannesburg even has a cluster suburb. 
 Next &mdash; cluster cities? 
 There are already cluster holiday camps. 
 And in the Karoo desert, in the northwestern Cape, a group of whites is trying to build its own homeland. 
 This is the ultimate in cluster thinking, the cluster country. 
 It is not to be imagined that logic assumes whites do not also welcome the political changes in South Africa. 
 Many do; emphatically, aggressively. 
 There is even a game played with the expectations aroused by dreams of the &bquo;new&equo; South Africa. 
 IN the new South Africa, Eugene Terre'Blanche, leader of the neo-fascist wing, will be a dress designer. 
 In the new South Africa, everyone will drive BMWs. 
 In the new South Africa, if you've worked for a white family for more than five years, you get to keep the house&hellip; 
 But, even in cluster housing, Africa will keep on coming to call. 
 Consider, finally and fleetingly, Mrs Rapapis, who owns a nice house inside the walls of Merrow Down. 
 Her husband was in Kuwait when the Iraqis invaded. 
 They held him hostage. 
 He finally flew home to South Africa and put down the money on his cluster house. 
 And left again. 
 Mr Rapapis travels. 
 Not even kidnap deters him for long. 
 But he wants his wife to be safe. 
 She is an invalid, and children are living abroad. 
 Mrs Rapapis wrings her hands in her new cluster house. 
 The trouble is the pipes. 
 A serious leak. 
 She battled for weeks to get the compound manager to fix the leak. 
 &bquo;The trouble here is that there's no supervision.&equo; 
 One day she opened her door, and &bquo;a big bunch of black men marched in&equo;. 
 They were the plumbers &mdash; but how was one to tell? 
 Mrs Rapapis graphically depicts the open door and the black invasion. 
 &bquo;My child,&equo; she says, and wrings her hands again, &bquo;what can I do?&equo;  
 Showbiz 
 Here are 20 good ways to win an Oscar 
 What if on March 25, the envelope were opened and the winner wasn't you? 
 1 ACT YOUR AGE 
 Given movie trends, it is not surprising that women tend to win their Oscars in their late twenties, men in their early forties. 
 Twenty-nine is the average age for nomination for Best Actress, thirty-eight for Best Actor. 
 The youngest Best Actress was the first, Janet Gaynor, at twenty-two; the oldest was the last, Jessica Tandy, at eighty (for Driving Miss Daisy). 
 The oldest Best Actor was George Arliss at sixty-three for Disraeli (1929), the youngest Richard Dreyfuss at twenty-nine for The Goodbye Girl (1977) &mdash; thus upholding the ancient Oscar tradition that the Best Actors tend to be honoured for their worst pictures. 
 2 DON'T ACT YOUR AGE 
 Wear drag (Jack Lemmon in Some Like It Hot, Dustin Hoffman in Tootsie; put on weight (Robert De Niro in Raging Bull, Jack Nicholson in Terms of Endearment); even a sex change (Julie Andrews in Victor/Victoria, John Lithgow in The World According to Garp). 
 In other words, play out of character &lsqb;see 15&rsqb;. 
 Liz Taylor's courage in playing a woman older and (then) fatter than herself in Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? (1966) was enough in itself to win her an Oscar. 
 De-glamorization also won awards for Olivia de Havilland in The Heiress (1949) and Grace Kelly in The Country Girl (1954), and nominations for Bette Davis in Now Voyager (1942) and Lynn Redgrave in Georgy Girl (1966). 
 3 PLAY A CRIPPLE 
 From Ray Milland's alcoholic in Lost Weekend (1945) to Jack Nicholson in One Flew Over The Cuckoo's Nest (1975) and Dustin Hoffman in Rain Man (1988), actors have increased their Oscar chances by portraying physical or mental defectives. 
 Last year's Best Actor contest saw Tom Cruise and Daniel Day Lewis competing wheelchair-to-wheelchair, with Cruise's Ron Kovics (Born on the Fourth of July) just losing out to Day Lewis's Christy Brown (My Left Foot). 
 This year's candidate is Robert De Niro in Awakenings.  
 4 PLAY A HOOKER 
 Julia Roberts's nomination as the happy hooker in Pretty Woman continues a venerable Hollywood tradition. 
 Twelve per cent of women's Oscars have gone to actresses playing prostitutes, with or without hearts of gold. 
 Easy-virtue Oscars went to Jo van Fleet in East of Eden (1955), Dorothy Malone in Written on the Wind (1956), Donna Reed in From Here to Eternity (1953), Shirley Jones in Elmer Gantry (1960), Liz Taylor in Butterfield 8 (1960) and Jane Fonda in Klute (1971). 
 5 APPEAR IN A &bquo;SWEEP&equo; BIGGIE 
 Charlton Heston got lucky in 1959 only because Ben Hur swept eleven of the twelve categories in which it was nominated. 
 How else could Chuck have outdone Jack Lemmon in Some Like It Hot? 
 The same goes for Ben Kingsley in Gandhi (1982), and maybe this year, Kevin Costner in Dances With Wolves. 
 6 DON'T DO COMEDIES, WESTERNS OR MUSICALS 
 The Academy has always been suspicious of comedians, from Charlie Chaplin (three nominations, no Oscars) and Danny Kaye (no nominations) to Robin Williams (two recent no-hope nominations, for Good Morning, Vietnam and Dead Poets Society). 
 Only five per cent of acting Oscars have been won in comedies (Jack Lemmon won Best Actor for the earnest Save The Tiger (1973), not for Some Like it Hot, The Apartment or The Odd Couple). 
 But only four per cent of Oscars have been won in musicals or westerns. 
 And most of those were anomalies, such as consolation prizes to Julie Andrews (Mary Poppins, 1964) for not being cast in the screen version of My Fair Lady; and to John Wayne (True Grit, 1969), whose only other nomination in forty years was for a war movie (Sands of Iwo Jima, 1949). 
 Dances with Wolves would be the first western since Cimarron (1931) to win Best Picture. 
 7 DON'T BE PETER O'TOOLE 
 O'Toole is the Oscars' all-time loser with seven nominations and no wins &mdash; Lawrence of Arabia (1962), Becket (1964), The Lion in Winter (1968), Goodbye, Mr Chips (1969), The Ruling Class (1972), The Stunt Man (1980) and My Favourite Year (1982). 
 Even in a &bquo;sweep&equo; movie &lsqb;see 5&rsqb; like The Last Emperor, O'Toole's Law deprived him of a Best Supporting nomination. 
 At least he is still in there pitching &mdash; unlike his friend Richard Burton, the only other actor with no win despite seven nominations. 
 8 BE KATHARINE HEPBURN 
 La Hepburn is the all-time Oscar champion, with twelve nominations spanning forty-nine years &mdash; and four wins, from Morning Glory in 1932 to On Golden Pond in 1981, without once stepping down into the Best Supporting category. 
 Only Laurence Olivier comes close, with one win (Hamlet, 1948) out of ten acting nominations over thirty-nine years, plus one directing nomination and two honorary Oscars; and Bette Davis with two wins out of ten nominations. 
 9 DON'T PLAY A BAD GUY 
 Two of the screen's toughest tough guys, James Cagney and Humphrey Bogart, each won his only Oscar in one of the few films in which he played a goody: Yankee Doodle Dandy and The African Queen respectively. 
 The Academy, after all, must be seen to be on the side of law and order. 
 If you play a baddy, try to ensure that it's Vito Corleone in the next Godfather remake. 
 That is the only screen role to have won Oscars for two different actors (Marlon Brando and Robert De Niro). 
 10 GET RAPED 
 Jane Wyman in Johnny Belinda (1948), Vivien Leigh in A Streetcar Named Desire (1951) and Jodie Foster in The Accused (1988) are the extreme examples of the Academy's penchant for women as victims. 
 Actresses should otherwise try to suffer from their husband's infidelity (numerous examples from the very first Oscar, to Janet Gaynor for Sunrise).  
 Alternatively they could combine show business with booze or drugs (nominations for both Janet Gaynor again and Judy Garland in A Star Is Born, Diana Ross in A Lady Sings The Blues, Bette Midler in The Rose, Jessica Lange in Frances and this year Meryl Streep for Postcards from the Edge). 
 11 BE AMERICAN &mdash; OR, FAILING THAT, BRITISH 
 In the sixty-two years of the Oscars, Americans have won more than seventy-five percent of them. 
 Next come the British, who have carried off forty-five acting Oscars &mdash; a success rate of eighteen per cent. 
 Almost twenty per cent of all nominees have been British, compared to seventy-five per cent US and a mere five per cent from the rest of the world. 
 Vintage for the Brits were 1964 and 1983, with four of the five Best Actor nominees. 
 In '64, Rex Harrison (My Fair Lady) beat Peter Sellers (Dr Strangelove), Richard Burton and Peter O'Toole (both Becket) and Anthony Quinn (Zorba the Greek); in '83, American Robert Duvall (Tender Mercies) held off Michael Caine (Educating Rita), Tom Conti (Reuben, Reuben), Albert Finney and Tom Courtenay (both The Dresser). 
 G&eacute;rard Depardieu might just be the exception that proves the rule. 
 12 DIE 
 The Academy's rules forbid posthumous nominations. 
 But the only actor to die between the nominations and the awards ceremony &mdash; Peter Finch in 1976 &mdash; wound up winning Best Actor for Network. 
 13 DON'T DIE&hellip; 
 JUST YET 
 In 1960 Liz Taylor was described as &bquo;gravely ill&equo; during the voting period; Melina Mercouri, nominated for Zorba the Greek, said all the other Best Actress nominees ought to stand down. 
 By Oscar night, Taylor had recovered sufficiently to pick up hers for Butterfield 8. 
 In 1981, when he was known to be seriously ill, Henry Fonda was voted Best Actor for On Golden Pond: his daughter and (co-star) Jane picked up the Oscar for him, and he died just five months later. 
 14 PUT ON AN ACCENT 
 Four of Meryl Streep's nine nominations have been won in foreign accents &mdash; British in The French Lieutenant's Woman (1981), Polish in Sophie's Choice (1982), Danish in Out of Africa (1985) and Australian in A Cry in the Dark (1988). 
 See also Spencer Tracy's Portuguese fisherman in Captains Courageous (1937), Vivien Leigh's Southern belle in Gone With The Wind (1939) and such unlikely nominees as Albert Finney's stage-Belgian (Murder on the Orient Express, 1974) and Alan Arkin's manic Russian (The Russians are Coming, 1966). 
 Michael Caine's cockney Alfie (foreign to American ears) won him his first nomination in 1966, but he had to play an American to win at last, twenty years later, in Hannah and Her Sisters. 
 15 HIDE BEHIND LOTS OF MAKEUP 
 It worked for Fredric March in Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde (1932) and for Jos&eacute; Ferrer in Cyrano de Bergerac (1950). 
 Steve Martin tried the hooter again in Roxanne (1987), but he is a comedian &lsqb;see 6&rsqb;; could history come right for G&eacute;rard Depardieu? 
 16 MARRY THE PRODUCER 
 Would Jennifer Jones have won five nominations and one Oscar (The Song of Bernadette, 1943), if she had not been married to David O Selznick? 
 Would anyone but husband/director Blake Edwards have cast Julie Andrews so utterly against type in Victor/Victoria? 
 Some twenty per cent of all Oscar-winning actors, actresses and directors have been married to each other at one time or another. 
 But only one family &mdash; the Hustons &mdash; can claim three generations of Oscar-winners: Walter, John and Angelica, who may win her second this year. 
 17 STAR OPPOSITE BURT LANCASTER 
 Although he has won only one Oscar in four nominations (for Elmer Gantry, 1960), Burt Lancaster holds the record for performing in Oscar-winning films. 
 Stars who have won Oscars opposite him include Barbara Stanwyck in Sorry, Wrong Number (1948), Shirley Booth in Come Back, Little Sheba (1952), Frank Sinatra and Donna Reed in From Here to Eternity (1953), Anna Magnani in The Rose Tattoo (1955) and David Niven and Wendy Hiller in Separate Tables (1958), which Lancaster also produced. 
 Katharine Hepburn won her seventh Oscar nomination as his belle in The Rainmaker (1956), and Thelma Ritter her sixth as his mother in Birdman of Alcatraz (1962). 
 18 PLAY A REAL PERSON 
 Biopic roles have always been popular with the Academy. 
 Witness George Arliss as Disraeli (1929), Charles Laughton as Henry VIII (1932), Gary Cooper as Sergeant York (1941), Paul Scofield as Sir Thomas More (1966), Barbra Streisand as Fanny Brice in Funny Girl (1968), George C Scott as Patton (1970), Robert De Niro as Jake La Motta in Raging Bull (1980), Sissy Spacek as Loretta Lynn in Coal Miner's Daughter (1980), Ben Kingsley as Gandhi (1982), F Murray Abraham as Salieri in Amadeus (1984) and Daniel Day Lewis as Christy Brown (1989). 
 This year's biopic candidate is Jeremy Irons (as Claus von Bulow) in Reversal of Fortune. 
 19 KEEP ON TRUCKING 
 If at first you don't succeed, persistence should ensure that your &bquo;body of work&equo; will finally win you an Oscar, regardless of the merits of the performance in question. 
 Even before the release of their latest movies, there was heavy money this year on &bquo;body of work&equo; Oscars for Al Pacino (Godfather III) and Glenn Close (Hamlet and/or Reversal of Fortune). 
 Each had five previous nominations, but no win. 
 Pacino may pick a consolation Supporting Oscar for his hunchback in Dick Tracy, but this year could see instead &bquo;length of service&equo; Oscars for Richard Harris (first nominated in 1963 for This Sporting Life) and Joanne Woodward (first nominated in 1957 for The Three Faces of Eve). 
 20 IF YOU MISS OUT AGAIN&hellip; 
 Console yourself with the knowledge that the following never won an Oscar: Alfred Hitchcock, Charlie Chaplin, the Marx Brothers, Greta Garbo, Fred Astaire, Lillian Gish, Kirk Douglas, Cary Grant, Mickey Rooney, Maurice Chevalier, Barbary Stanwyck. 
 Most eventually got honorary Lifetime Achievement Awards &mdash; alias the &bquo;Whoops, sorry, we forgot you&equo; Oscars, or even &bquo;Whoops, sorry, we didn't know you were still around&equo;, as happened to Sophia Loren in January, thirty years after she won Best Actress for Two Women.  
 ADVERTISEMENT FEATURE 
 best dressed at L'Esquire 
 Exclusive elegance, quintessential quality, the most stylish new store in Mayfair &mdash; L'ESQUIRE &mdash; with the finest fashions for debonair discerning men about town. 
 5 Dover Street, Mayfair, London W1. 
 Telephone 071&ndash;491 1000. 
 Mayfair boasts a superb new designer store for men, virtually opposite the Ritz hotel, at no. 5 Dover Street &mdash; L'Esquire. 
 The store features Europe's leading design houses across more than 4,500 square feet, with tailoring on the ground floor and chic casuals upstairs. 
 L'Esquire prides itself on its superlative standards of service and relaxed atmosphere. 
 The staff are all expert stylists, accustomed to helping customers create their own individual look from their marvellous range of exclusive labels. 
 Furthermore, for the man in a hurry, they will put together a special selection and take it to his home or office. 
 On the ground floor are immaculate suits from Valentino, d'Avenza, Ungaro, and other major designers, with a resident tailor to ensure perfect fit. 
 There is also a special made-to-measure service from a leading Italian suit company. 
 Designer ties and fine cotton or silk shirts complement the clothes, together with a full range of accessories including handmade Artioli shoes. 
 Upstairs, innovative design is the theme, with the very best international relaxed dressing. 
 Total looks by Byblos, Umberto Ginochetti, Gian Marco Venturi&hellip; great sportswear by Missoni and CP Company&hellip; trendsetting suits from Claudio Lugi and Rene Lezard&hellip; as well as a marvellous selection of designer jeans &mdash; Versace, Gianfranco Ferre, Valentino. 
 Also the hottest beachwear in town.  
 Vintage Esquire 
 great men die twice by Mark Kram 
 the later rounds of muhammad ali 
 There is the feel of a cold offshore mist to the hospital room, a life-is-a-bitch feel, made sharp by the hostile ganglia of medical technology, plasma bags dripping, vile tubing snaking in and out of the body, blinking monitors levelling illusion, muffling existence down to a sort of digital bingo. 
 The Champ, Muhammad Ali, lies there now, propped up slightly, a skim of sweat on his lips and forehead, eyes closed, an almost imperceptible tremor to his arms and head. 
 For all his claims to the contrary, his surface romance with immortality, Ali had a spooky bead on his future; he never saw it sweeping grandly towards him, but bellying quietly along the jungle floor. 
 &bquo;We just flies in a room,&equo; he liked to say, moving quickly across the ruins of daily life, plane crashes, train wrecks, matricide, infanticide; then, after swatting half of humanity, he'd lower his voice and whisper, as if imparting a secret, &bquo;We just flies, that's all. 
 Got nowhere to fly, do we?&equo; 
 Images and echoes fill the room, diffuse and speeding, the glass darkened to a degree no one thought possible; his immense talent, his ring wisdom, his antipathy for chemicals, argued against destructibility; all he would ever do is grow old. 
 For twenty years, while he turned the porn shop of sports into international theatre, attention was paid in a way it never was before or has been since. 
 The crowds were a wonder to behold. 
 Kids scaled the wings of jets to get a glimpse of him; thousands, young and old, tailed him in masses during his roadwork. 
 World leaders marvelled at the spell he cast over the crowds. 
 &bquo;If you were a Filipino,&equo; Ferdinand Marcos joked, &bquo;I'd have to shoot you.&equo; 
 The Pope asked for his autograph; sure, he said, pointing to a picture, by why ain't Jesus black? 
 A young Libyan student in London sat on his bed, kept him up half the night with dithyrambic visions of Muslim revolution. 
 &bquo;Watch, one day you will see,&equo; said Moamar Gaddafi. 
 Half asleep, Ali said: &bquo;Sheeeet, you crazy.&equo; 
 Leonid Brezhnev once dispatched a note to an official at Izvestia: &bquo;I would like to see more on Muhammad Ali. 
 Who is this man?&equo; 
 The Ali Watch: how absurd that it would one day drop down here on a little hospital on Hilton Head Island, South Carolina. 
 The nurse dabs his face dry. 
 What is he thinking? 
 Never has his favourite phrase sounded so dismally precise: My, my, ain't the world strange. 
 If he could root back through the maze of moment and incident, would he find premonitory signs sticking  out like dire figurations of chicken entrails? 
 Does he remember King Levinsky, one of the many heavy bags for Joe Louis, in the corridor after the Miami Beach weigh-in? 
 Boldly coloured ties draped Levinsky's neck (he sold them on the street), his synapses now like two eggs over light, in permanent sizzle, as he tried to move into stride with a young Cassius Clay. 
 Over and over, like a one-man Greek chorus, Levinsky croaked, eyes spinning, spittle bubbling form his lips: &bquo;He's gonna take you, kid. 
 Liston's gonna take you, make you a guy sellin' ties&hellip; 
 Partners with me, kid, ya kin be partners with me.&equo; 
 Does he remember a shadowed evening in his hotel room a day or so after the third Joe Frazier fight, moving to the window, his body still on fire from the assault? 
 He stood there watching the blood-red satin drop into Manila Bay, then took a visitor's hand and guided it over his forehead, each bump sending a vague dread thought through the fingers. 
 &bquo;Why I do this?&equo; he said softly. 
 Does he remember the Bahamian cowbell tinkling the end of his final, pathetic fight, a derisive goodbye sound, stark with omen? 
 What is he thinking? 
 Ali poses a question, his eyes closed, his lips parting as if her were sliding open manhole covers. 
 &bquo;You die here&hellip; they take you home?&equo; he asks. 
 The nurses roll their eyes and smile, struck by his innocence; it has nothing to do, they know, with morbidity. 
 He is not joking either. 
 The practical aftermath of death seems to stimulate his curiosity these days; nothing urgent, mind you, just something that begins to get in your mind when you're watching blood move in and out of your body for half the day. 
 Though he is very much a mystic, there is a part of Ali that has always found security and a skewed understanding of life in the quantifiable: amounts, calibrated outcomes, the creaking, reassuring machinery of living. 
 The might before in the hotel lounge, with his wife, Lonnie, beside him, bemusedly aghast, he grilled a pleasant waitress until he knew how many tips she got each week, how many children she had, the frequency of men hitting on her and the general contour of her reality. 
 &bquo;She had a sad life,&equo; he said later. 
 The nurse now cracks with a deadpan expression: &bquo;You die, we take you home, Muhammad.&equo; 
 Still, a certain chiaroscuro grimness attached to their surreal exchange and cries out for some brainless, comic intervention. 
 He himself had long been a specialist in such relief when he would instantly brighten faces during his favourite tours of prisons, orphanages and nursing homes. 
 When down himself (very seldom), he could count on a pratfall from his hysterical shaman, Drew &bquo;Bundini&equo; Brown, on the latest bizarre news from his scheming court, maybe a straight line from some reporter that he would turn into a ricocheting soliloquy on, say, the disgusting aesthetics of dining on pig. 
 No laughs today, though. 
 &bquo;Don't make him laugh,&equo; a nurse insisted when leading a writer and a photographer into the room. 
 &bquo;Laughing shakes the tubing loose.&equo; 
 The photographer is Howard Bingham, Ali's closest friend; he's been with the Champ from the start, in the face of much abuse from the Black Muslims. 
 Ali calls him &bquo;the enemy&equo; or &bquo;the non-believer&equo;. 
 His natural instinct is to make Ali laugh: today he has to settle for biting his lower lip and gazing warily back and forth between Ali and his nurses. 
 He doesn't know what to do with his hands. 
 Ali had requested that he leave his cameras outside; just one shot of this scene, of Ali on his back, the forbidding purge of progress, of fame and mystique splayed raw, would bring Bingham a minor fortune. 
 &bquo;He doesn't want the world to see him like this,&equo; says Howard. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't take the picture for a million dollars. 
 The process is called plasmapheresis. 
 It lasts five hours and is being conducted by Dr Rajko Medenica. 
 The procedure, popular in Europe, is a cleansing of the blood. 
 Ali is hooked up to an electrocardiograph and a blood-pressure monitor; there is always some risk when blood is not making its customary passage. 
 But the procedure is not dangerous, and he is in no pain, we are told. 
 Two things, though, that he surely can't abide: the injection of those big needles and the ceaseless tedium. 
 When he was a young fighter, a doctor had to chase him around a desk to give him a shot, and chaotic mobility to him is at least as important as breathing. 
 Bingham can't take his eyes off Ali; the still life of his friend, tethered so completely, seems as incomprehensible to him as it would to others who followed the radiated glow of Ali's invulnerability. 
 The nurses cast an eye at his blood pressure and look at each other. 
 His pressure once jumped twelve points while he watched a TV report on Mike Tyson's street fight with Mitch Green in Harlem. 
 It's rising a bit now. 
 &bquo;Ali,&equo; one of them calls. 
 His eyes remain closed, his breathing is hardly audible. 
 The nurse calls to him again; no response. 
 &bquo;Come on now, Ali,&equo; she complains, knowing he likes to feign death. 
 &bquo;Now, stop it, Ali.&equo; 
 He doesn't move, then suddenly his head gives a small jerk forward and his eyes buck wide open, the way they always used to when he'd make some incoherent claim to lineage to the gods. 
 The nurses flinch, or are they in on the joke too? 
 Eyes still wide, with a growing smile, he says to the writer, weakly: &bquo;You thought I dead, tell the truth. 
 You the only one ever here to see this, and I die for ya. 
 You get some scoop, big news round the whole world, won't it be?&equo; 
 He leans his head back on the pillow, saying: &bquo;Got no funny people round me anymore. 
 Have to make myself laugh.&equo; 
 The nurse wants to know if he has to urinate. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he says with a trace of irritation. 
 &bquo;Yes, you do,&equo; the nurse says. 
 &bquo;Your pressure&hellip; &bquo; 
 Ali looks over at Lonnie with mischievous eyes. 
 &bquo;I just thinkin' 'bout a pretty woman.&equo; 
 The nurse asks him what he'd like for lunch. 
 &bquo;Give him some  pork,&equo; cracks Bingham. 
 Ali censures the heretic with a playful stare. 
 Ali requests chicken with some cherry pie with &bquo;two scoops of ice-cream&equo;. 
 He turns to the writer again: &bquo;Abraham Lincoln went on a three-day drunk, and you know what he say when he wake up?&equo; 
 He waits for a beat, then says: &bquo;I freed whooooooo?&equo; 
 His body starts to shake with laughter. 
 The nurse yells: &bquo;Stop it, Muhammad! 
 You'll drive the needles through your veins.&equo; 
 He calms down, rasps, &bquo;I'll never grow up, will I? 
 I'll be fifty in three years. 
 Old age just make you ugly, that's all.&equo; 
 Not all, exactly: getting old is the last display for the bread-and-circuses culture. 
 Legends must suffer for all the gifts and luck and privilege given to them. 
 Great men, it's been noted, die twice &mdash; once as great and once as men. 
 With grace, preferably, which adds an uplifting, stirring, Homeric touch. 
 If the fall is too messy, the national psyche will rush towards it, then recoil; there is no suspense, no example in the mundane. 
 The captivating, aspiring sociopath Sonny Liston had a primitive hold on the equation of greatness. 
 &bquo;Clay &lsqb;he never called him Ali beeg now,&equo; Sonny once said, while gnawing on some ribs. 
 &bquo;He flyin' high now. 
 Like an eagle. 
 So high. 
 Where he gonna land, how he gonna land? 
 He gonna have any wings? 
 I wanna see.&equo; 
 Sonny, of course, never made it for the final show. 
 Soon after, he checked out in Vegas, the suspicion of murder hovering over the coroner's report. 
 Who wanted to ask the question back then, or even be allowed to examine in depth its many possibilities? 
 It was too serious for the carnival, immediately at odds with the cartoon bombast that swirled around Ali, the unassailable appeal of the phenomenon, the breathtaking climb of the arc. 
 Before him, the ring, if not moribund, had been a dark, sombre corner of sports, best described by the sight of then middleweight king Dick Tiger leaving his beat-up hotel wearing a roomy black Homburg and a long pawnshop overcoat, a black satchel in his hand, heading for the subway and title fight at the Garden. 
 But the heavyweight champions &mdash; as they always will &mdash; illuminated the image sent out to the public. 
 There was the stoic, mute Joe Louis, with his cruising menace; the streetfighter Rocky Marciano, with his trade-unionist obedience; the arresting and dogged Floyd Patterson, who would bare his soul to a telephone pole at the sight of a pencil; all unfrivolous men who left no doubt as to the nature of their work. 
 With the emergence of Muhammad Ali, no one would ever see the ring the same way again, nor even the fighters themselves; a TV go, a purse and a sheared lip would never be enough; and a title was just a belt unless you did something with it. 
 A fighter had to be; a product, an event, transcendental. 
 Ali and the new age met stern, early resistance. 
 He was the demon loose at a holy rite. 
 With his preening narcissism, braggard mouth and stylistic quirks, he was viewed as a vandal of ring tenets and etiquette. 
 Besides, they said, he couldn't punch, did not like to get hit and seemed to lack a sufficient amount of killer adrenalin. 
 True, on the latter two counts. 
 &bquo;I git no pleasure from hurtin' another human bein',&equo; he used to say. 
 &bquo;I do what I gotta do, nothin' more, nothin' less.&equo; 
 As far as eating punches, he said, &bquo;Only a fool wanna be hit. 
 Boxin' just today, my face is forever.&equo; 
 Other saw much more. 
 The ballet master Balanchine, for one, showed up at a work-out and gazed in wonder. 
 &bquo;My God,&equo; he said, &bquo;he fights with his legs, he actually fights with his legs. 
 What an astonishing creature.&equo; 
 Ali's jab (more like a straight of jolting electricity) came in triplets, each a thousandth of a second in execution. 
 He'd double up cruelly with a left hook (rarely seen) and razor in a right &mdash; and then he'd be gone. 
 Even so, it took many years for Ali to ascend to a pre-eminent light in the national consciousness. 
 In the Sixties, as a converted Black Muslim, he vilified white people as blond, blue-eyed devils. 
 His position on Vietnam &mdash; &bquo;I ain't got no quarrel with those Vietcong, anyway. 
 They never called me nigger&equo; &mdash; was innocent at first, but then taken up as if he were the provocateur of a national crisis. 
 The politicians, promoters and sweeping sentiment converged to conspire against his constitutional right to work: stated barred him from fighting. 
 He resisted the draft and drifted into exile. 
 Three years later, he returned; heavier, slower, but with a new kind of fire in his belly. 
 Though he had defeated heavyweight champion Sonny Liston and defended his title nine times, Ali never had a dramatic constituency before. 
 Now a huge one awaited him, liberals looking for expression, eager literati to put in sculpture, worn-out hippies, anyone who wanted to see right done for once. 
 The rest is history: the two symphonic conflicts with Joe Frazier; the tingling walk with him into the darkness of George Foreman. 
 Then, the Hegelian &bquo;bad infinite&equo; of repeating diminishing cycles: retiring, unretiring, the torture of losing weight, the oiling of mushy reflexes. 
 The margins of dominance compressed perilously, and the head shots (negligible before exile) mounted. 
 Greatness trickled from the corpus of his image, his career now like a gutshot that was going to take its time before killing. 
 His signing to fight Larry Holmes, after retiring a second time, provoked worried comment. 
 After watching some of Ali's films, a London neurologist said he was convinced Ali had brain damage. 
 Diagnosis by long distance, the promoters scoffed. 
 Yet among those in his camp, the few who cared, there was an edginess. 
 They approached Holmes, saying, &bquo;Don't hurt him, Larry.&equo; 
 Moved, Holmes replied &bquo;No way. 
 I love Ali.&equo; 
 With compassion, he then took Ali apart with the studied carefulness of a diamond cutter; still, not enough to mask the winces at ringside. 
 Ali failed to go the route for the first time in his career. 
 Incredibly, fourteen months later, in 1981, his ego goaded him to the Bahamas and another fight, the fat jellied on his middle, his hand-speed sighing and wheezing like a busted old fan; tropic rot on the trade winds. 
 Trevor Berbick, an earnest plug, outpointed him easily. 
 Afterwards, Angelo Dundee, who had trained Ali from the start and had to be talked into showing up for this one, watched him slumped in the dressing-room, then turned away and rubbed his eyes as certain people tried to convince Ali that he had been robbed and that a fourth title was still possible. 
 The public prefers, indeed seems to insist on, the precedent set by Rocky Marciano, who quit undefeated, kept self-delusion at bay. 
 Ali knew the importance of a clean farewell, not only as a health measure, but as good commercial sense. 
 His ring classicism has always argued so persuasively against excessive physical harm, his pride was beyond anything but a regal exit. 
 But his prolonged decline has been nasty, unseemly. 
 Who or what pressured him to continue? 
 Some blamed his manager, Herbert Muhammad, who had made millions with Ali. 
 Herbert said that his influence wasn't that strong. 
 Two years after that last fight, Ali seemed as mystified as everyone else as to why he hadn't ended his career earlier. 
 He was living with his third wife, the ice goddess Veronica, in an LA mansion, surrounded by the gifts of a lifetime &mdash; a six-foot, hand-carved tiger given to him by Deng Xiaoping, a robe given to him by Elvis Presley. 
 Fatigued, his  hands tremoring badly, he sat in front of the fire and could only say: &bquo;Everybody git lost in life. 
 I just git lost, that's all.&equo; 
 Now, five years later, the question why still lingers, along with the warning of the old aphorism that &bquo;we live beyond what we enact&equo;. 
 The resuscitation of Ali's image has been a sporadic exercise for a long time now, some of it coming from friends who have experienced heartfelt pain over his illness. 
 Other seem to be trying to assuage a guilt known only to themselves, and a few are out to keep Ali a player, a lure to those who might want to use his name in business; though the marketplace turns away from billboards in decline. 
 Not long ago, a piece in the New York Times Magazine pronounced him the Ali of old, just about terminally perky. 
 Then, Ali surfaced in a front-page telephone interview in the Washington Post. 
 He appeared to have a hard grasp on politics, current states' rights issues and federal judgeships being contested &mdash; a scenario that had seemed as likely as the fusillade of laser fire Ali said Muslim spaceships would one day loose on the white devils. 
 Noses began to twitch. 
 What and who was behind the new Ali, the wily Washington lobbyist who had the ear of everyone from Strom Thurmond to Orrin Hatch? 
 The wife of Senator Arlen Specter even baked Ali a double chocolate-mousse pie. 
 For a good while, most of these senators, and others, knew only the voice of Ali on the phone. 
 David Kindred, a columnist for the Atlanta Journal-Constitution who has known Ali since his Louisville days, concluded that is most likely wasn't him. 
 At his farm in Berrien Springs, Michigan, Ali sits at the end of a table in the living-room. 
 The two hundred and forty-seven pounds of weight have made him a bit short of breath. 
 He's battled his appetite (two, three desserts, meals back to back) and sedentary lapses for years. 
 Several months before, he had been almost sleek, thanks to fourteen-mile walks and his wife's efforts to police him at the table. 
 But what is disturbing is the general profile of his condition. 
 For a long time now, he has appeared indifferent to the ravages of his problem. 
 But he dispels that notion when asked how seriously he considered a dangerous brain operation in Mexico before his family talked him out of it. 
 &bquo;Scale of ten,&equo; he says, &bquo;a six.&equo; 
 The answer reflects the terrible frustration that must exist within him, the daily, fierce struggle with a body and mind that will not capitulate to his bidding. 
 He sits there, his hands shaking, his movements robotic, the look on his face similar to what the marines call a thousand-yard stare. 
 Why is it, do you think, that after all these years, the dominant sound around Ali is silence? 
 Look at the cataract of noise caught by TV sound men, look at the verbosity that snared some novelists into thinking he was a primitive intelligence capable of Ciceronian insight. 
 Part of the fever of the times; if the Black Panther Huey Newton, posing with rifle and spear, could be written up as a theoretical genius, and his partner, Bobby Seale, interpreted as a tactical wizard, then how much a symbol was Ali &mdash; the first to tap and manifest glinting black pride, to dispute with vigour erosive self-laceration. 
 The fact was that he was not cerebral; he was a reflex of confusing emotions and instant passions. 
 He did have street cunning, most if it aimed to keeping himself a mystery. 
 &bquo;People like mystery,&equo; he used to say. 
 &bquo;Who is he? 
 What's he all about? 
 Who's he gonna be tomorrow?&equo; 
 To that end, he tossed the media rabble dripping hunks of redundant, rote monologue; his loudness provided a great show and diverted probing questions. 
 By nature, he was a gentle, sensitive man, and even in the throes of angry threats against whites it was hard to hide a smile, for he loved what the blacks call &bquo;selling wolf tickets&equo;, tricking people into fear. 
 The Black Panthers used that gambit well, and the TV crews followed their presence. 
 Thinking of all this, how could someone so alien to ideas and thought, who communicated privately in scraps and remote silences, be capable of fooling Washington politicians? 
 Absurd, of course, but then the question emerges: Did he allow himself to be used? 
 &bquo;How about those phone calls?&equo; he is asked. 
 &bquo;What calls?&equo; he responds, vacantly. 
 &bquo;To politicians this past summer.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't believe that,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;Man wrote that, he's a cracker from way back in Louisville. 
 Always hated blacks.&equo; 
 &bquo;But the piece had the goods.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm signin' my autographs now,&equo; he says. 
 &bquo;This is the only important thing in my life. 
 Keepin' in touch with the people.&equo; 
 &bquo;Were you used?&equo; 
 &bquo;Spend a hundred dollars on stamps every week. 
 Give 'em all my autograph that write me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe you just want to be big again. 
 Remember what you told Elvis. 
 &bquo;Elvis you have to keep singin' or die to stay big. 
 I'm gonna be big forever.'&equo; 
 He smiles thinly: &bquo;I say anything shock the world.&equo; 
 &bquo;You like politics now?&equo; 
 &bquo;Politics put me to sleep.&equo; 
 &bquo;You were at the Republican National Convention.&equo; 
 &bquo;You borin' me, putting me to sleep.&equo; 
 &bquo;Reagan, Hatch, Quayle, they would've clapped you in jail in the old days.&equo; 
 His eyes widen slightly: &bquo;That right?&equo; 
 He adds: &bquo;I'm tired. 
 You better than a sleepin' pill.&equo; 
 But don't let the exchange mislead. 
 Ali is not up to repartee these days, never was, really, unless he was in the mood, and them he'd fade you with one of his standard lines (&bquo;You no as dumb as you look&equo;). 
 He speaks very, very slowly, and you have to lean in to hear him. 
 It takes nearly an hour to negotiate the course of a conversation. 
 But if there was ever any doubt about the staying power of Ali, it is swept aside when you travel with him. 
 His favourite place in the world &mdash; next to his work table at his farm &mdash; is an airport. 
 So he should be in high spirits now; he'll be in three airports before the day's over. 
 But he's a bit petulant with Lonnie, who aims to see that he keeps his date at Hilton Head Island. 
 He can't stand hospitals. 
 They get in the way of life. 
 He found it hard even to visit his old sidekick Bundini when he was dying. 
 Paralysed from the neck down, Bundini could only move his eyes. 
 Ali bent down  close to his ear and whispered: &bquo;You in pain?&equo; 
 The eyes signalled &bquo;Yes&equo;. 
 Ali turned his head away, then came back saying: &bquo;We had some good times, didn't we?&equo; 
 Bundini's eyes went up and down. 
 Ali talks about this in the Chicago airport. 
 He's calmed down now, sits off by himself, ramrod-straight and waiting. 
 He wears a pinstripe suit, red tie, and next to him is his black magician's bag; he never lets it out of his sight. 
 The bag is filled with religious tracts already autographed; the first thing he does every day at six, when he gets up. 
 All he has to do is fill in the person's name. 
 His autograph ritual and travel are his consuming interests. 
 He'll go anywhere at the ring of a phone, and he spends much time on the road. 
 Perhaps the travel buoys him; he certainly gets an energy charge from people. 
 Soon they begin to drop like birds to his side. 
 &bquo;You see,&equo; he says, &bquo;all I gotta do is sit here. 
 Somethin', ain't it? 
 Why they like me?&equo; 
 He is not trying to be humble, he is genuinely perplexed by the chemistry that exists between himself and other people. 
 &bquo;Maybe they just like celebrities,&equo; he says. 
 Maybe, he's told, he's much more than a celebrity. 
 He ponder that for a moment, and says: &bquo;That right?&equo; 
 By now, a hundred people have lined up in front of him and a security guard begins to keep them in line. 
 Ali asks them their name, writes, then gives them his autographed tracts. 
 Some ask him to pose for pictures, others kid him about retiring. 
 He raises his fist: &bquo;Kong &lsqb;Mike Tyson&rsqb;, I'm comin' after you.&equo; 
 Near the end, he does a magic trick for a lady, using a fake thumb. 
 &bquo;Where you going, Muhammad?&equo; she asks. 
 He thinks, and then leans over to the writer and asks &bquo;Where we going?&equo; 
 The lady's eyes fill, she hugs him and says: &bquo;We love you so much.&equo; 
 What is it that so movingly draws so many people &mdash; his innocent, childlike way, the stony visual he projects, set off against his highly visible symptoms? 
 That night over dinner, Ali's eyes open and close between courses. 
 He fades in and out of the conversation, has a hint of trouble lifting the fork to his mouth. 
 His every day includes periods like this, he's in and out like a faraway signal. 
 Sometimes he's full of play. 
 He likes to swing his long arm near a person's ear, then create a friction with a thumb and forefinger to produce a cricket effect in the ear. 
 Then the play is gone, and so is he. 
 &bquo;One day,&equo; Lonnie is saying, &bquo;I want someone to catch his soul, to show what a fine human being he is.&equo; 
 Ali says, head down: &bquo;Nobody know me. 
 I fool 'em all.&equo; 
 Lonnie is Ali's fourth wife. 
 She was a little girl who lived across from Ali's old Louisville home when he was at the top. 
 She is a woman of wit and intelligence, with a master's degree in business administration. 
 She plans his trips, is the tough cop with him and his medicine and generally seems to brighten his life. 
 Ice-cream dribbles down Ali's chin. 
 &bquo;Now, Muhammad,&equo; she says, wiping it away. 
 &bquo;You're a big baby.&equo; 
 He orders another dessert, then says: &bquo;Where are we:&equo; A blade of silence cuts across the table. 
 Bingham says: &bquo;Hilton Head Island.&equo; 
 Ali says: &bquo;Ever wake up and don't know where you are?&equo; 
 Sure, he is told, steady travel can make a person feel like that for an instant; yet it is obvious that short-term memory for him is like a labyrinth. 
 Ali's day at the hospital is nearly over. 
 He will soon be counting down the minutes. 
 Right now he's in high spirits. 
 A nurse has secretly slipped him some strips of paper in his hands. 
 He crumples the paper, pretends to put it in his mouth, then billows his cheeks until he regurgitates tiny pieces all over his chest. 
 &bquo;Ain't magic a happy thing,&equo; he says, trying to contain his giggling. 
 When Dr Medenica comes, Ali jokes with him. 
 The doctor goes about examining the day's results. 
 He looks at the bags of plasma: 15,000 ccs have been moved through Ali. 
 Floyd Patterson has expressed dismay over the current treatment. 
 &bquo;No brain damage?&equo; 
 Floyd has said. 
 &bquo;Next you'll be hearing he was bit by a cockroach. 
 He's gonna kill Clay&hellip; 
 He'll drop dead in a year.&equo; 
 Medenica bridles at the comment. 
 &bquo;He's rather ignorant. 
 I'm going to have to call that man.&equo; 
 Ali wants to know what Patterson said. 
 Nobody wants to tell him. 
 &bquo;Tell me,&equo; says Ali. 
 Everyone looks at each other, and somebody finally says: &bquo;Floyd says you'll drop dead in a year.&equo; 
 Ali shrugs it off: &bquo;Floyd mean well.&equo; 
 It is Medenica; s contention that Ali suffers from pesticide poisoning. 
 Though his work has met with some scepticism in the medical community, Medenica is respected in South Carolina. 
 His desk is rimmed with pictures of prominent people &mdash; a senator, a Saudi prince, an ambassador &mdash; patients for whom he has retarded death by cancer. 
 He is supposed to have done wonders for Marshal Tito of Yugoslavia. 
 Tito was so grateful, he arranged funding for Medenica's clinic in Switzerland. 
 When he died, the funds were cut off. 
 Plasmapheresis is a solid treatment for pesticide poisoning, which occurs more than ever these days. 
 The blood cleaning removes the immune complex, which in turn removes toxins. 
 But how can Medenica be so sure that Ali's problem is not severe brain damage? 
 Dr Dennis Cope, of UCLA, has said that Ali is a victim of &bquo;Parkinson's syndrome secondary to pugilistic brain syndrome&equo;. 
 In short, too many head shots. 
 Medenica, though, is a confident man. 
 He predicts Ali will be completely recovered. 
 &bquo;I find absolutely no brain damage. 
 The magnetic resonator tests show no damage. 
 Before I took him as a patient, I watched many of his fight films. 
 He did not take many head blows.&equo; 
 Is he kidding? 
 &bquo;No, I do not see many head blows. 
 When he came this summer, he was in bad shape. 
 Poor gait. 
 Difficult speech. 
 Vocal-cord syndrome, extended and inflamed. 
 He is much better. 
 His major problem is that he misses taking his medicine, and he travels too much. 
 He should really be here once a month. 
 Finally, Ali is helped out of his medical harness. 
 He dresses slowly. 
 Then, ready to go out, he puts that famous upper-teeth clamp on his bottom lip to show determination and circles the doctor holding up a cocked right fist. 
 His next stop is for an interferon shot. 
 It is used to stimulate the white blood cells. 
 Afterwards, he is weak, and there is a certain sadness in his eyes. 
 On the way to the car, he is asked if the interferon treatment helps. 
 He says: &bquo;Sheeeet, nothin' help.&equo; 
 The Lincoln Town Car moves through the night. 
 Bingham, who is driving, fumbles with the tape-player. 
 Earlier in the day he had searched anxiously for a tape of Whitney Houston doing &bquo;The Greatest Love of All&equo;, a song written especially for Ali years ago. 
 He had sensed that Ali would be quite low when the day was over, and he wanted something to pick him up. 
 The words, beautiful and haunting, fill the car. 
 I decided long ago Never to walk in anyone's shadow; If I fail, if I succeed At least I lived as I believe, And no matter what They take from me, They can't take away my dignity. 
 &bquo;You hear that,&equo; Bingham's voice cracks. 
 &bquo;Everything's gonna be just fine, Ali.&equo; 
 The dark trees spin by. 
 There is no answer. 
 What is he thinking? 
 Esquire, as it has taken form in America, has been an avid chronicler of games and the people who play them for all of its fifty-eight years. 
 As a monthly, the magazine cannot offer its readers the overnight scores, nor preview the week's to matches. 
 But what it can and will do is bring a literary perspective to sport, by encouraging gifted writers to go one-on-one against our most intriguing winners and losers. 
 Muhammad Ali is, without much argument, the towering athlete of this century. 
 An exquisite figure in the ring, he has used his indomitable spirit to capture the imagination of millions everywhere; he was, in his prime, the most famous man in the world. 
 It is appropriate, then, that Ali has been the subject of a great number of pieces in Esquire, most of them written by undisputed literary heavyweights, including Irwin Shaw and Norman Mailer among others. 
 The most recent piece about him &mdash; published in June, 1989 &mdash; could well be the one that will be remembered longest. 
 It shows the great champion in the throes of the toughest bout of his life, depicting his struggle with grace and poignance. 
 In keeping with our desire to acquaint British readers with selected Esquire landmarks, we're proud to present this intimate look at our greatest champion. 
 THE EDITORS  
 The Express Traveller 
 Brussels 
 by Derek Blyth 
 So, the Euro-business capital lacks excitement, but the architecture's good and the food is even better 
 The big decision in Brussels is whether to stay in the Lower Town (historic and lively) or the Upper Town (elegant and leafy). 
 The Brussels &eacute;lite from Count Egmont to the Eurocrats have always kept to the high ground, but the lower quarter has recently turned stylish. 
 HOTELS: 
 BELLE EPOQUE: the fin-de-si&egrave;cle charm of nineteenth-century Brussels is preserved in the glittering halls and clanging lifts of the M&eacute;tropole (Lower Town, 31 Place de Brouck&egrave;re, telephone 02/2172300, cost: 6,000fr). 
 Just a few years younger, the Pullman Astoria still looks as grand as when Churchill stayed there, though the neighbourhood has certainly lost some of its sparkle (Upper Town, 103 Rue Royale, telephone 02/2176290, cost 6,000 fr). 
 TWENTIES: the chic allure of Brussels in the Twenties is echoed is the tastefully restored Albert I (Lower Town, 20 Place Rogier, telephone 02&ndash;2172125, cost: 3,000 fr). 
 INTERNATIONAL: most international hotel chains including Hilton, Sofitel and Novotel, are represented in Europe's capital. 
 The SAS Royal is pricey, but then it's got the only atrium in town (incorporating a stretch of the old city wall) and bedrooms in a choice of four styles (Lower Town, 47 Rue du Foss&eacute;-aux-Loups, telephone 02/5118888, cost: 10,500 fr). 
 BIZARRE: the New Hotel Suru is a must for anyone crazy about comics. 
 The outside is lit by zany neon, and you can spend a day just reading the cartoons in the corridors (Lower Town, 1 Place Rogier, telephone 02/2177580, cost 3,900 fr). 
 SIGHTS 
 ECCENTRIC: wander through reconstructed rooms modelled on Tintin cartoons at the Centre Belge de la Bande Dessin&eacute;e, 20 Rue des Sables, a restored art-nouveau department store that has become Brussels's best-loved museum. 
 The little Mus&eacute;e Wiertz, 62 Rue Vautier, is an eccentric nineteenth-century atelier near the sprawling European quarter, but the strangest building in town is the Atomium, a gleaming symbol of Fifties futurism. 
 ARCHITECTURE NOUVEAU: the art nouveau Mus&eacute;e Horta, 25 Rue Americaine, is a fanciful fin-de-si&egrave;cle town house build by Victor Horta, using exotic African wood and delirious tangles of iron. 
 Wander down to the Etangs d'Ixelles or over to the Square Marie-Louise to admire the lush art-nouveau mansions built from fortunes amassed in the steamy Belgian Congo. 
 GRAND PLANS: the Belgian colony, which Conrad dubbed the Heart of Darkness, gave King Leopold II the resources to build on a colossal scale. 
 The overbearing Palais de Justice is his least-loved legacy, but the Cinquantenaire museum complex is worth a visit. 
 The echoing Mus&eacute;e d'Art et d'Histoire, part of the complex, has Egyptian and Roman relics, Flemish tapestries and altarpieces, while the dusty Mus&eacute;e de l'Arm&eacute;e is crammed with rusted relics of Belgian battles from Waterloo to World War II. 
 In autumn, it is well worth taking tram forty-four through the forest to see the African masks at the Mus&eacute;e d'Afrique Centrale, another of Leopold's pet projects. 
 EATING 
 CLASSIC CUISINE: the innovative Belgian dishes of Pierre Wynants' Comme Chez Soi draw Eurocrats down from the Berlaymont building to a scruffy Lower Town square. 
 The intimate restaurant concealed behind thick curtains is tastefully  decorated in art-nouveau style. 
 Reserve long before hunger pangs hit (23 Place Rouppe, telephone 02/5122921). 
 La Maison du Cygne, an elegant, wood-panelled restaurant in seventeenth century Grand'Place guild house, offers imaginative variations on old Belgian themes such as Sole Ostendaise, Waterzooi (Flemish fish stew) and kidneys with chicory (9 Grand'Place, telephone 02/5118244). 
 SEAFOOD: the old fish market at Place Ste Catherine may have vanished long ago, but the great Brussels fish restaurants have stayed on. 
 La Belle Mara&icirc;ch&egrave;re is a well-run, crowded restaurant preparing elegant dishes using fresh fish from the North Sea (11 Place Ste Catherine, telephone 02/5129759). 
 CHIC: tactful transformation has turned La Manufacture from a vast nineteenth-century industrial building into an artful restaurant. 
 You get sensible, straightforward dishes such as guinea fowl with honey and sesame seeds. 
 Good for an offbeat business lunch, but be sure to book (12 Rue Notre Dame du Sommeil, telephone 02/5022525). 
 OLD BRUSSELS: Chez Jean has been serving steaming pots brimming with mussels and other Brussels specialties since 1931. 
 Locals can't resist the hearty portion of steak and frites served by formidable waitresses (6 Rue des Chapeliers, off Grand'Place, telephone 02/5119815). 
 SHOPPING 
 Souvenir shops don't aspire to much, but Euroline, 55 Boulevard Adolphe Max, sells sturdy Euro-blue brollies and watches studded with the twelve EC stars. 
 Head to Plaizier, 50 Rue des Eperonniers, for artful postcards depicting languorous art-nouveau buildings and wistful Brussels cemeteries. 
 And don't dare go home without a load of Belgian chocs if you want to keep your friends sweet. 
 The glittering Godiva shops, in the Grand'Place and elsewhere, have been producing pralines laced with alcohol since the Twenties, but dedicated chocophiles are seduced by the subtler tastes of Wittamer, 12 Place du Grand Sablon, or Mary, 73 Rue Royale. 
 ENTERTAINMENT 
 Brussels isn't dead after dark if you know where to delve. 
 Locals tend to stick to the pleasures of eating out in the evening, but there are a few spots in town for night revels. 
 Falstaff, Rue Henri Maus, is a bustling art-nouveau caf&eacute; that stays open long after most have dimmed their lights, while Cirio, 18 Rue de la Bourse, is a more demure, late nineteenth-century establishment where elderly Brussels women gather for a glass of Italian wine. 
 A l'Image Nostre Dame, down an alley off Rue du March&eacute; aux Herbes, is a friendly old Flemish tavern, while Kitty O'Shea's, 123 Rue Stevin, is where the local Irish folk and other from Berlaymont go to talk the night away. 
 Brussels is Estudded with jazz caf&eacute;s, of which the Bierodrome, 21 Place Fernand Cocq, is perhaps the most lively. 
 An aria sparked off the Belgian revolution, and the Monnaie , where it all began, is now home to an excellent opera company. 
 Theatre is, of course, mainly in French or Flemish, the two official languages of the capital, but you might find an English classic being staged by one of the expatriate groups. 
 THE ESQUIRE WALK 
 If you've an hour or two to spare, take the tour. 
 Head down to the Grand'Place  (marked by the finger on the map) to look at the glittering gilt-laden guild houses from the age of Rubens. 
 Spot the boatmen's house with its ship-prow gable (number 6) and the bawdy tavern scene on one of the pillars of the Town Hall. 
 Now walk down Rue au Beurre to the Eglise St Nicolas, the merchant's church, hidden behind a cluster of old shops. 
 The shadowy interior is a sensuous baroque mix of gilt and candle wax. 
 Continue along Petite Rue au Beurre, turn right up Rue du March&eacute; aux Herbes and left down Petite Rue des Bouchers. 
 The cobbled lane plunges you into a genial old quarter packed with restaurants. 
 It's fun ambling among the dripping-wet mountains of cod and mullet (or rabbits and pheasants during the hunting season), but the serious eating goes on elsewhere in town. 
 A right-turn up Rue des Bouchers gets you to the stately Galeries Saint-Hubert, a nineteenth-century glass-roofed arcade lined with marble-fronted shops. 
 Stop for an Italian coffee at Mokaf&eacute; or browse through the latest French novels in Tropismes. 
 Turn left out of the gallery, cross the road and head along Rue Montagne aux Herbes, past the splendid, antiquated Caf&eacute; &agrave; la Mort Subite, the best place in Brussels to sample a cherry-flavoured Kriek or a sharp Flemish Gueuze beer. 
 You get a wonderful view of the twin towers of the Cath&eacute;drale St Michel on turning right up Rue d'Assaut. 
 Climb the hill and enter the echoing fifteenth-century Gothic church to peer through glass panels at the medieval foundations. 
 Go up Rue de la Chancellerie, past Hecq Congo (a shop that once clothed the Belgian empire builders) and turn left into Rue Baron Horta. 
 Film fans can put down 20fr in a slot machine outside the Cinema Museum for a current programme. 
 Climb the steps to the Upper Town and stroll through the formal Parc De Bruxelles  with its bandstands and stone cherubs. 
 Turn right towards the royal palace, then right again to reach Place Royale. 
 The uncrowded Mus&eacute;e des Beaux Arts, 3 Rue de la R&eacute;gence, contains paintings by Brue (who lived just down the hill in the Rue Haute), Rubens, Ensor and Magritte. 
 Walking along Rue de la R&eacute;gence to Notre Dame du Sablon, a shadowy fifteen-century church with stained glass in vivid tones of red and blue. 
 Head down Rue Rodebeek, past antique shops crammed with romantic Belgian landscapes and dusty marble busts. 
 Glance down Impasse St Jacques, where there's a cluttered violin workshop and a whole gallery stuffed full with wooden gods from the Congo. 
 Amble down the hill, past Wittamer's chocolate shop, follow Rue Lebeau, then Rue de l'H&ocirc;pital to reach Rue St Jean. 
 Turn left into Galerie Bortier, a forgotten nineteenth-century arcade occupied by second-hand bookshops. 
 A left-turn down Rue de la Madeleine brings you to Rue des Eperonniers. 
 Squeeze past the parked cars to look at the wonderful little shops, which specialize in tin toys, dolls' houses and cinema posters then turn right into March&eacute; aux Fromages to get back to Grand'Place. 
 Derek Blyth moved to Brussels to write travel articles for the The Bulletin, the city's English weekly magazine. 
 He has published books on Amsterdam and Flemish cities.  
 The Town Hall in Grand'Place 
 Museum of Art and History 
 The Grand'Place, heart of the old town 
 Leopold's golden jubilee arch 
 Petite rue des Bouchers 
 The Business Traveller 
 pack up your roubles 
 by Brian Moynahan 
 Take Marlboros to Moscow or Minsk &mdash; and never leave home without a Swiss Army knife 
 Standing on a wet street corner in Moscow with a fistful of roubles, watching the cabs go by, you soon realize that Soviet taxi drivers have lost all interest in the local currency. 
 They will take you half a mile for a packet of Marlboros &mdash; for a carton, they'll fight each other for the privilege of taking you all the way (eighteen miles) out to Sheremtyevo airport. 
 But roubles? 
 Come off it, tovarish. 
 So, smoker or not, drinker or latter-day prohibitionist, be sure to equip yourself with your full duty-free quotas of Marlboros and Bells afore ye go behind the remnants of the Iron Curtain. 
 Marlboros have become the alternative to hard currency &mdash; safer than dollars, which the ordinary citizen is forbidden to have, and more useful than the rouble, so soft that it buys nothing worth having. 
 A packet is guaranteed to get you a taxi driver and other rare commodities &mdash; a waiter who discovers that not everything on the menu is off, a booking clerk who finds you a seat. 
 Those people do not smoke the things themselves. 
 Hence the millions of unopened red packets circulating ceaselessly from Brest to Vladivostok. 
 But drinking is a different, more personal matter, and a bottle of Scotch will get you a friend for life. 
 If you take your allowance in the form of miniatures, you will make a lot of friends &mdash; for a shorter period. 
 Remember that cigarettes or alcohol will lubricate a whole range of transactions. 
 (I recently paid five packs of Marlboro for a charming, framed watercolour of Arbat Street in Moscow; oils start at a carton.) 
 Rubber galoshes are almost as essential. 
 Wherever there is going to be snow-melt (much of North America), without a pair you are going to ruin your Guccis. 
 It's not so much the snow; more the salt that gets strewn around. 
 In milder climes, and Moscow in the autumn (ask Napoleon and the Germans), the problem is deep mud; you need wellies. 
 Nor are Continental cosh-style umbrellas much use; they don't last long; they don't protect as large a surface area of head and suit; and they're useless for hailing cabs. 
 But they do take little space. 
 Easily stowable silk vests and long johns also make sense in galosh-and-windchill territory, and you never know when a pair of swimming trunks will come in handy &mdash; even on business trips. 
 Indoor pools exist, and Moscow boasts a year-round, heated open-air affair between the Kremlin and the Defence Ministry. 
 Besides, swimming-trunks can always be used as reserve underpants. 
 Another necessary reserve is third-country cash &mdash; in a currency other than your own and that of the place you are visiting. 
 Otherwise, when you need it &mdash; wet night on the autobahn, fuel warning-light on &mdash; you'll have spent your local currency, and it's Germany, so the garages won't take credit cards. 
 A hundred dollars or so, in small denominations, you should be OK. 
 Of course, you have your list of international dialling and access codes &mdash; 010 here, 009 in Sweden, 19 in France, 38 in Yugoslavia, for example &mdash; but how about a guide to public holidays? 
 France, for example, has seventeen such breaks, many of them associated with monster traffic-jams and booked-out flights, as well as empty offices. 
 And the French are great pont-builders. 
 If a holiday falls on a Thursday, they build a bridge between it and the weekend. 
 No one shows on Fridays. 
 Ditto Mondays and Tuesdays. 
 And, yes, the cities do close down for August &mdash; and in mid-February. 
 Finally, if you don't already have one, beg, borrow or buy a Swiss Army knife &mdash; with its corkscrew for wine bottles, bottle-opener for beer, can-opener for tins, knife to cut through the seal on metal whisky bottle-tops that revolve instead of snapping when you try to open them, screwdriver and wire-stripper for changing plugs (and for removing insanity-inducing ticking clocks from the headboards of Stockholm hotel beds, etc), even a compass for navigating home in the small hours. 
 As useful, in short, as Marlboros in Minsk.  
 The Way We Live Now 
 Eight pages in the life of the culture 
 The Border Crossing 
 I live in Northern Ireland, with my wife and three children, We like it. 
 Home is the old nursery-quarters at the top of a big house overlooking Lough Erne. 
 We are twelve miles from the border agreed to in 1925 between the British and the Irish. 
 We cross the border once or twice a week. 
 One doesn't need a passport, which is great, but what are irksome are the checkpoints and the queues of traffic waiting to be processed. 
 There are fourteen or fifteen such crossing-points along the hundred-odd-mile border. 
 We know them all, and the one we like to use is Annaghmartin, north of Wattlebridge. 
 And so it was that on the first Monday after New Year, about midnight, we found ourselves on an icy road in County Cavan heading for the checkpoint, having just driven up from Dun Laoghaire, where we had disembarked from the Holyhead ferry. 
 I have lost count how many times we have done this. 
 Suddenly I say one of the &bquo;Stop Checkpoint&equo; signs that are ubiquitous in Ulster, but it was outside the Leggykelly, a pub just five hundred yards south of the border. 
 Coming to a halt, I was confused. 
 The British Army wasn't allowed over, was it? 
 Then I saw that the policeman coming out of the darkness was wearing the blue of a Gardai, rather than the green of an RUC man. 
 It was a southern checkpoint, I realized &mdash; and handed him my licence. 
 &bquo;Is the checkpoint beyond Wattlebridge open?&equo; 
 I asked. 
 &bquo;Oh, yes,&equo; he replied authoritatively. 
 But he was wrong. 
 The gate at the frontier had been pulled over the road and locked shut. 
 I got out of the car and walked over. 
 There was a sign illuminated by spotlight from a pole behind. 
 If I wanted assistance, I was to speak into the intercom. 
 The checkpoint itself &mdash; a hurdle of pillboxes, corrugated iron and aerials &mdash; stretched ahead. 
 The night was dark and still, and there was not a soul in sight. 
 On the boat, I had been reading about the shooting of Fergal Caraher at the South Armagh checkpoint at Cullyhanna and now, in the darkness, as details of the story flooded back, I decided against pressing the buzzer. 
 I would go and find a place that was open for business. 
 A couple of miles up the road, a UDR patrol leaped out of a ditch and stopped us. 
 The sergeant &mdash; his pace blackened with boot polish &mdash; assured me, &bquo;You'll get through at Clones.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are your sure?&equo; 
 I pressed, for I had begun to wonder if we weren't doomed to wander Cavan until dawn. 
 &bquo;Into Clones and turn left,&equo; he said. 
 Well, that was all fine and dandy, except for the fact that there wasn't one sign in clones for the Kilturk checkpoint. 
 Some joker had removed them all. 
 Was this a political act? 
 I wondered, driving round the utterly deserted town. 
 Finally, I saw a young woman. 
 I accelerated towards her, At the same moment, she saw us and darted towards an alley. 
 If I lost her, we would never find our way home. 
 I wound down the window of the car and shouted after the woman, &bquo;Kilturk?&equo; 
 She stopped. 
 Her relief was palpable. 
 We  weren't trouble, just lost. 
 &bquo;Straight on,&equo; she shouted back. 
 She was right. 
 It was just the down the road. 
 But guess what? 
 It was closed. 
 How long had I been driving about? 
 It felt like hours. 
 No, this had to stop. 
 I would use the intercom. 
 We were going through, and I didn't care whom we woke to do it. 
 I got out and walked over to the gate. 
 Now guess what? 
 No intercom, nor any information about what those needing assistance should do. 
 I peered into the dark and deserted-looking checkpoint. 
 More corrugated iron and concrete and an army sign: &bquo;We apologize for the delay Please do not blame us Blame the Terrorists&equo;, with another smaller one beside it: &bquo;Please take your little home with you&equo;. 
 This is unbelievable, I thought, I'm locked out of the country where I live, and they worry about litter. 
 The Army GOC would hear about this. 
 First thing next morning I was going to fire off a letter, I thought, when I heard something. 
 A voice? 
 The creak of a boot? 
 I froze, heart thumping. 
 Then I saw a barrel glinting and realized two soldiers were creeping towards me. 
 &bquo;Dip your lights,&equo; the corporal ordered brusquely, a private soldier behind him clearly terrified. 
 This was hardly surprising. 
 In these forts, the soldiers are sitting targets. 
 Just before Christmas, a man had been seized at gunpoint and made to drive a van loaded with three and a half thousand pounds of explosives into Annaghmartin; the Christmas before, two soldiers had been shot dead at the Derry checkpoint, next door. 
 They might be next. 
 I got into the car and turned off the headlamps. 
 The corporal called out our registration number. 
 I would be fed into the police computer, where it would join the details already stored by the hundreds of other crossings we had made. 
 &bquo;Okay,&equo; the corporal shouted. 
 I turned on the parking lights and drove slowly forward. 
 Men were crouched and waiting everywhere, covering the ones who had come out to meet us. 
 Then I noticed that right beside the checkpoint, in fact touching it, there stood a terrace of houses, and that in the front window of one of them stood a Christmas tree, with lights draped along its branches. 
 It was something I don't think I'll ever be able to forget, the twinkling tree and the boot-polished, worried faces everywhere in the darkness. 
 &bquo;Where are we?&equo; a child called sleepily from the back. 
 &bquo;Are we home yet?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nearly home,&equo; my wife whispered, and we emerged form the checkpoint into a dark landscape, the cold, starry sky arching above us. 
 The April Curve 
 BEHIND 
 Celebrity chefs 
 National Gallery extension 
 Breakfast meetings 
 Karaoke 
 Doing the Lambada 
 Practical jokes 
 Nigel Kennedy 
 The Soho Crop 
 Mel Gibson's rear 
 Visiting eastern Europe 
 British motorcycles 
 Gibraltar 
 The RSC Kingsley Amis 
 AHEAD 
 Gregorian Chant (House Mix) 
 Salome 
 The Oscars 
 Flat racing 
 Emmanuelle B&eacute;art (Oh no) 
 Red Nose Day 
 The Boat Race 
 British Summer Time 
 John Lee Hooker 
 Paisley T-shirts without &bquo;jokes&equo; on them 
 Visiting western Europe 
 The Obsessed 
 Married to the muse 
 ANTHONY GREEN ON HIS WIFE, MARY: &bquo;I've just finished a picture about Mary and me making love on my mother's spare bed. 
 &bquo;I've been painting about being in love with Mary for the past thirty years. 
 She has been my motivation and my subject matter. 
 &bquo;We are more in love now than we've ever been. 
 And it's more fun now than when we were consumed by white-hot passion. 
 We are like a good bottle of claret; we both have sediment in our shoes. 
 &bquo;Mary never poses for me, she is just around. 
 She is like an icon. 
 She has some wonderful features, and the most kissable, male chauvinist mouth. 
 &bquo;I am married to the most perfectly lovely thing in the world. 
 It isn't strange to be madly in love at the age of fifty-one. 
 It's bloody marvellous.&equo; 
 PICTURES PAINTED: 154. 
 TIME TAKEN: 49,280 hours (6,160 days). 
 WHEN STARTED: &bquo;After falling in love with Mary in 1961&equo;. 
 WHEN TO FINISH: &bquo;When I drop dead&equo;.  
 The Black Plague 
 Denis Nilsen Murderer lived and killed here 1981&ndash;83 
 23 Cranley Gardens 
 Although the property is currently for sale and is open to viewing by prospective home-owners, these days the front window of the top flat at 23 Cranley Gardens, Muswell Hill, north London, stays firmly and permanently closed. 
 That was not the case when Denis Nilsen lived there. 
 The unusual thing neighbours noticed about the quiet civil servant who occupied the attic flat was that he kept the window open in all weathers &mdash; to dissipate the smell from the corpses of three of the young men he murdered. 
 Nilsen was finally arrested when pieces of the corpses he was flushing down the toilet blocked the drain. 
 A man from Dyno-Rod was called in, to be followed, shortly afterwards, by a couple of detectives from Hornsey police station. 
 Nilsen began a life sentence in November 1983. 
 He had admitted murdering fifteen young homosexual men. 
 Gary Herman of the Muswell estate agents Tatlers is the man charged with the delicate task of selling the top flat at 23 Cranley Gardens &mdash; a cosy, one-bedroomed apartment with sloping ceilings and magnolia-painted plaster. 
 A rampant cheese-plant stands on the landing; there  are bottles of Czech Budweiser in the wine rack; Highgate Tube is a fifteen-minute, uphill yomp away. 
 The bath in which Nilsen washed his victims is gone; there is now only a shower-room. 
 You'd have trouble swinging a gerbil, let alone a cat, in the kitchen. 
 The present occupants did not realize there had been a famous ex-occupant and were, says Herman, &bquo;not too pleased when they found out&equo;. 
 The flat is priced at &pound;69,950, which Gary Herman thinks may be a little high. 
 Books 
 120 seconds to Gravitas 
 The book report for those too lazy to read 
 THE BOOK Possession, subtitled &bquo;A Romance&equo;. 
 Winner of the 1990 Booker Prize and the Irish Times/Aer Lingus International Fiction prize. 
 Chatto &amp; Windus, &pound;13.95. 
 THE AUTHOR A S Byatt. 
 Known as Antonia to her friends, and as &bquo;that old trout in the blue tent&equo; to members of the general viewing public who tuned into the Booker award ceremony by accident, she is a former English lecturer and author of a study of Wordsworth and Coleridge. 
 Her earlier novels were regarded as &bquo;academic&equo; (which translates as &bquo;not very interesting&equo;). 
 Until last year, she was known best as the less successful sister of Margaret Drabble. 
 She is now known as the more successful sister of Margaret Drabble. 
 THE POOL Byatt, a keen swimmer, announced she would use her twenty-thousand-pound winnings to pay for a swimming-pool at her house in France. 
 The days of John Berger's denouncing what he saw as exploitation of the Caribbean and donating half his winnings to the Black Panthers are clearly gone. 
 THE PLOT Roland Michell, a twenty-nine-year-old research assistant in the London Library, discovers two drafts of a letter written by the fictional mid-Victorian poet Randolph Henry Ash to a fictional fellow poet, Christabel La Motte. 
 The letter suggests the two may have had an affair. 
 Michell embarks upon a spot of literary detective work, which brings about a meeting with flaxen-haired Dr Maud Bailey of Lincoln University. 
 Together they comb through the writings of the two Victorians, and gradually the true facts of the romance are revealed. 
 At the same time, the relationship between the two academics begins to progress in a similar direction. 
 Subsidiary characters run the gamut of weird and wacky academics, familiar from a host of campus novels. 
 The book reaches a melodramatic conclusion in a gale-tossed cemetery, where the final secret lies buried. 
 THE POETRY Having invented two Victorian poets, Byatt also invents their poetry, about seventeen hundred lines of it, in fact, and about a hundred pages of letters and journals in mid-Victorianese. 
 Those represent a considerable achievement on Byatt's part, but for the reader, the temptation to skip them is often hard to resist. 
 THE A S BYATT EXAMINATION FOR ADVANCED READERS Compare and contrast the following pairs of statements: 
 1 (a) Possession is at once a good, old-fashioned Victorian yarn and a post-modernist parody of the same. 
 Its parallel narrative establishes a telling contrast between nineteenth-century romantic sensibility and modern sexual knowingness. (b) One The French Lieutenant's Woman is quite enough, thanks. 
 2 (a) Possession successfully combines intellectual sophistication with the narrative pleasure of a detective story. 
 (b) One Umberto Eco is quite enough, thanks. 
 3 (a) Possession is exactly the sort of book that deserves to win the Booker Prize. 
 (b) Possession is exactly the sort of book you'd expect to win the Booker Prize. 
 THE A S BYATT EXAMINATION FOR READERS IN THE HOME COUNTIES Was the use of the word &bquo;cunt&equo; really necessary? 
 THE A S BYATT EXAMINATION FOR HOLLYWOOD FILM PRODUCERS CONSIDERING BUYING THE SCREEN RIGHTS Consider the following problems: 1 There is no obvious part for Arnold Schwarzenegger. 
 Do you: (a) get him to read the poetry as a voice-over and hope no one notices his accent? (b) make the drippy research assistant Michell a beefy Austrian and get Arnie to wear spectacles? (c) turn the whole thing into an action movie, with Arnie defending the London Library against a mass terrorist attack? 2 The title lacks commercial appeal. 
 Do you change it to: (a) The Poetry Lovers &mdash; their passion for great literature was matched only by their passion for each other! (b) The Austrian Professor &mdash; he wasn't just big, he was smart too! (c) Hardback Attack &mdash; when you mess with great literature, you pay the price! 
 A FASCINATING FACT The book's main character is dull and unappealing. 
 However, Byatt's American publishers, Random House, insisted that she make him sexier. 
 Hence the American edition contains several additional sentences of description, in which we find that Michell now has a &bquo;smile of amused friendliness and pleasure&equo;, which often &bquo;aroused feelings of warmth, and sometimes more, in many women&equo;. 
 As an attempt to make a character more sexy, that seems rather feeble, but an explanation perhaps lies in&hellip; 
 A WORRYING FACT Byatt told the Daily Mail that she considered John Major sexy. 
 &bquo;He really is quite attractive,&equo; she said. 
 She is possibly the only woman in Britain, other than Mrs Major, to hold that view. 
 THE GET-OUT CLAUSE &mdash; HOW TO BRING ANY DISCUSSION CONCERNING POSSESSION OR THE BOOKER PRIZE TO AN ABRUPT END Ask if anyone has read The Bone People by Keri Hulme. 
 Tim Hulse  
 Social Notes 
 Not Coming Soon: the Matt Monro Story 
 In the search for suitable pop biopic material, it's important to remember that sex and drugs are not enough. 
 Much more important is death. 
 And by far the best death, in biopic terms, is untimely. 
 Because a lifetime of debauchery somehow loses its romantic kudos once it winds down to a respectable job and keep-fit classes; it stops being a biopic and starts sounding like a how-I-conquered-my-bad-habits-and-became-a-normal-person telefilm. 
 Ask yourself why, for example, no one has made The Pete Townshend Story, with its denouement in the offices of Faber &amp; Faber publishing, or Jagger!, complete with barnstorming finale in the pavilion at Lord's. 
 (Given the choice between emulating Mick Jagger or, say, Sid Vicious, only a lunatic would plump for the latter, but in terms of films you might conceivably want to sit and watch, Sid and Nancy win hands down with their blood-splattered, smack-snorting Liebestod.) 
 Every society needs its flawed heroes, and we appear to have saddled ourselves with rock singers and movie stars. 
 These pop icons are elevated to the pantheon of public attention and encouraged to Live Fast, Die Even Faster &mdash; preferably within inking distance of the tabloid press and/or Albert Goldman. 
 The reward for this self-sacrifice is to get their mugshot plastered across a million posters and T-shirts, witness Monroe, Dean, Presley, Lennon &mdash; the all-time greats, the Gang of Four. 
 But there are plenty of other second-league heroes and heroines who are available to re-enact the eternal cycles of birth and death, rise and fall, rinse and spin. 
 And plenty of ways for them to check out too, the most popular with the punters being bad driving (James Dean, Marc Bolan), firearms (John Lennon, Marvin Gaye) and taking more pills that it says on the bottle (Jimi Hendrix, Janis Joplin). 
 The plane crash is another favourite deus ex machina; singers and musicians fall like flies from the skies. 
 The most memorable bit of Sweet Dreams was not Jessica Lange's admirable performance as Patsy Cline, it was the lip-smacking tastelessness of her last plane ride: chug-chug, engine failure, oh dear, engine starts up again, phew that was close, oh no, watch out for that mountain. 
 Such untimely celebrity death provides our nice clean ending and saves us having to contend with the natural processes of ageing and decay, for some reason considered more horrific and obscene than going out with a bang. 
 It enable us to dabble in vicarious vice and to sit in smug judgement on the result. 
 It makes us feel better about our own humdrum lives that too much fun is so clearly bad for the health. 
 Even more usefully, from a film-maker's point of view, untimely celebrity death precludes the risk of libel, thus opening up all sorts of opportunities for dramatic license. 
 Of course, biopics still have to pussyfoot around the survivors, hence the Bearded Film Director Who Didn't Look Anything Like John Landis in Wired  who finds John Belushi (honorary rock star), snorting coke in his Winnebago and then says (best line delivered in the film) &bquo;John, this is economically unfeasible&equo;. 
 But the real wonder of pop biopics is that no one has made a movie about Jim Morrison before now (The Doors opens on March 15). 
 The group, after all, were the Los Angeles rock band &mdash; Morrison first met keyboard player Ray Manzarek while they were both attending UCLA's film course. 
 The singer's life contained enough misbehaviour to make director Oliver Stone's job easy (pace that notorious gig in Miami when Jimbo bared more than his soul); his songs are riddled with references to drugs and sex; and &mdash; making the film a dead cert &mdash; he obligingly took an early bath in Paris in '71. 
 He couldn't have picked a better place: laid to rest in P&egrave;re Lachaise alongside such genuine nineteenth-century bohos as G&eacute;rard de Nerval, who took his pet lobster for walks in the Palais Royal and eventually hanged himself with a piece of string he insisted was the Queen of Sheba's garter. 
 Only one disturbing rumour can possibly mar the film's success. 
 It is said in some circles that Morrison is alive and well and living in Des Moines, so perhaps we will one day have to sit through Doors II: the Incognito Years. 
 If so, the public will require another martyr. 
 Queue here for Brian Jones Takes a Dip. 
 Anne Billson  
 The Green Man: Rigmer, Sussex 
 Money 
 Mr MacThrifty Buys a Suit 
 The first time I met my wife, I was wearing a fine blue jacket. 
 It had been tailor-made&hellip; for someone else, unfortunately. 
 It was, in fact, made for my brother, who is blessed with a rather different physique. 
 It is not true I married for a red corduroy jacket belonging to my wife's father; but there is no denying he did pass it on to me, as a sort of dowry I believe. 
 Once again, it was tailor-made. 
 And when I had it customized, I could boast I was wearing something that was made-to-measure &mdash; twice. 
 When family charity fails to clothe you, try a charity shop. 
 Oxfam is the thrifty man's chain-store, and the branch at 202b Kensington High Street is its menswear flagship. 
 Since this shop has the reputation of being the best for designer clothes, its customers tend to pay more than at other branches &mdash; but still only a fraction of the retail price. 
 There for a song clothes from Hugo Boss, Yves Saint Laurent and, more rarely, Cerruti 1881. 
 The record price for a suit was one hundred pounds, and that was brand new, passed on by a lunatic who changed his mind as soon as he had taken it home. 
 Shirts that left Comme des Gar&ccedil;ons with a one-hundred-pound price tag will be knocked down for a bargain price; and a man's shirt that looks good on a woman will cost more than the men-only variety. 
 The time to re-stock your wardrobe is when the fashionable are emptying theirs &mdash; in the spring and autumn. 
 But for a sudden, necessary purchase, it is worth scouring the charity shops at any season. 
 For a tenner, I snapped up a dinner-jacket for an office party, and gave it back afterwards. 
 An everyday grey suit cost me twelve pounds. 
 Does the thrifty buyer never slip into anything new? 
 Certainly. 
 He haunts street markets. 
 Better still, off-street markets in open-plan warehouses, which have a roof, if not much else. 
 My favourite stall, in Peckham, south London, may not have changing-rooms, but modesty is preserved by making a screen of racks of clothes. 
 Here I snap up Levi's for the price of lesser brands, and those for even less. 
 A friend of mine dresses entirely in Harrods, bought in the January sales. 
 Next sales are even cheaper. 
 And, despite the name, Amazon's four outlets in Kensington Church Street also offer menswear, with labels including Nicole Farhi, French Connection and Ciao. 
 This year they had ninety-pound coats for thirty. 
 Now, though, the sartorial saver will have to wait until the early summer sales. 
 You have to work at thrift. 
 Some people, though, are born thrifty. 
 Because there are fewer short than medium-sized men, a suit made to their measurements is less likely to find a buyer, and is knocked down accordingly. 
 The same is true of shoes. 
 I once lived next door to a giant of a man with feet like Yeti slippers. 
 Every pair of shoes he bought was a bargain. 
 Jonathan Sale 
 Inner Sanctum 
 Robert Elms's Fridge 
 The following were recently noted to be its complete contents 
 Pitta bread (half consumed) 
 Allinson's Stoneground brown bread (half consumed) 
 White bread (half consumed) 
 Lemon g&acirc;teaux 
 Hot Indian lime pickle 
 Mango chutney 
 Lemon and mustard-seed pickle 
 Ginger pepper jelly 
 Elderflower jelly 
 Blackcurrant conserve 
 Redcurrant jelly 
 Strawberry conserve 
 Safeway mayonnaise 
 Yoplait Petit fromage frais (cherry, orange and banana) 
 Goat's cheese (very expensive) 
 Smoked applewood cheese 
 +English waxed cheddar 
 Manchego, (hard, Spanish cheese) 
 Grated Parmesan (fresh) 
 Falafels (eight, unopened) 
 After Eight mints (opened) 
 Smoked salmon (manky) 
 Spanish gherkins 
 Spanish Little Gem lettuce 
 Safeway pre-packed cherry tomatoes 
 Fresh bay leaves 
 Fresh rosemary 
 Fresh mint 
 VEGETABLE TRAY 
 Belle de Fontenay potatoes (French and tiny) 
 Romano (pink and new) 
 Cara (big baking potatoes) 
 FRIDGE DOOR 
 Ch&acirc;teau St Jean Californian Chardonnay 
 Manzanilla Spanish sherry &mdash; La Gitana 
 Highland Spring mineral water (flat) 
 Hot taco sauce 
 Fierce chilli peppers 
 Sun-dried tomatoes 
 Anchovy paste 
 Japanese mustard 
 Fresh garlic 
 One egg 
 Tomaro pur&eacute;e 
 The Green Man: Sevenoaks 
 Esquire's first reader event! 
 Join us at Austin Reed in Regent Street, London W1, for our very first readers party on Wednesday April 17, between 6pm-8pm 
 The party is co-hosted by Woolmark and the House of Seagram. 
 Hot jazz and other attractions, both fun and informative, together with Martell VSOP Cognac and Mumm Cordon Rouge Champagne, will make the evening go with a real swing. 
 You will meet the Esquire Editors, and our fashion editor Marion Hume will be there to give you personal advice on how to put your looks together. 
 You can find out how all the key ingredients in your wardrobe are made: demonstrations will encompass silk tie making, shoe making and hand-sewing of Chester Barrie suits. 
 Entertainment will include a surprise celebrity jazz band. 
 There will be an exhibition of early American Esquires, going back to the 1930s. 
 Special offers, just for Esquire's guests, will be available throughout the store. 
 Do join us for a glass of cognac or champagne. 
 To receive your ticket (admits two), please phone Katie Wohlrab, Esquire, 071 439 5306).  
 Social Notes 
 Oh No! 
 Yet Another Book Launch! 
 In today's &bquo;Get Ahead&equo; publishing world, it is considered vastly more glamorous to be a marketing man than an author. 
 As a result, the traditional party outfit of flamboyant cravat and tweed jacket has been replaced by the ninety-nine-pound wool suit. 
 Always grey, it should be purchased at the modishly named &bquo;Suit Company&equo;. 
 Tie 
 Very wide or very narrow, the ideal tie should mark you out as solid, reliable and totally free of any artistic tendencies. 
 Perhaps the dream tie in today's &bquo;hands on&equo; publishing world is that brown one from M&amp;S that came in a set with its own matching handkerchief. 
 The wine 
 Usually white, usually Italian or German and always served at least eight degrees above room temperature, its only merit is as an antidote to&hellip; 
 The food 
 Phileas Fogg's Mexican tortilla chips, Thai chicken satay with peanut dip, French prawn and garlic vol-au-vents, and sundry other delicacies from countries where halitosis has never been a social no-no. 
 These can all be rested on a makeshift tray, which is usually&hellip; 
 The book 
 Always referred to as &bquo;the product&equo;, this item is of minimal importance &mdash; unless accompanied by easily retailable novelties (T-shirts, key rings, inflatables) or recorded on a &bquo;talking book&equo; tape with Paul Eddington and that nice Felicity Kendal doing the voices. 
 Cuff-links 
 These play a vital back-up role to the tie in establishing your credentials. 
 Ideally joined by a bar (less fiddly than a chain), they should feature masonic crests, &bquo;the Royal Antediluvian Order of Buffaloes&equo; perhaps being best, in accordance with the rule that the more eccentric these groups sound, the duller they are. 
 (A prime example is &bquo;the Oddfellows&equo;, actually a group of Rotarians and minor town-hall officials from the Harlow area, whose lifestyle would make Terry and June seem like coke sniffers. 
 Trousers should show signs of Corby pressing. 
 However, as only the bottom two-thirds can fit into one of Corby's otherwise estimable machines, the area from the crotch up should be baggy and creased. 
 A light-brown leatherette belt will nicely &bquo;pick out&equo; the grey material of your suit. 
 Bunch of keys 
 Looped around a belt notch, and resting against the hip, this should include the ignition key for a Ford Sierra Cosworth. 
 Shoes 
 Grey, scuffed, quilted on top and laden with mock-Italian ribbons, &bquo;gold&equo; buckles. 
 Always fake: publishing executives have no interest in fashion and, if pushed, would venture that Gucci opens the batting for England. 
 What to say 
 Refer constantly to the number of dump-bins, shelf-wobblers and spinners you have persuaded W H Smith to take. 
 If asked &bquo;Have you read the book?&equo;, answer &bquo;Yes, but not personally&equo;. 
 Show your dynamism by suggesting a few surefire financial winners, the sort of title that will end up extracted in the Telegraph Magazine. 
 Here are four to be getting along with: Melvyn Bragg's Lake District, John Mortimer's Tuscany, Jilly Cooper's Somerset, Kingsley Amis's Stomach. 
 What not to say 
 &bquo;Perhaps we should encourage young novelists&equo;; &bquo;the Booker Prize is a media junket&equo;; &bquo;actually, I'm here because I wrote the book&equo;. 
 Modern Afflictions: Dial N for Neck 
 On the phone, in fifth and in the fast lane looks and feels better than three months in a surgical neck-support, which is the likely outcome of what is becoming known as &bquo;phone neck&equo;. 
 Shrugging the receiver between cheek and shoulder places an enormous strain on the sternocleido-mastoid muscles, the prominent bulges on each side of your neck, and the splenius capitis, the muscle that runs up to the base of your skull and stops you wearing your head at a jaunty angle. 
 The strain usually results in stiffness and discomfort, but can be quite debilitating, requiring more extensive treatment &mdash; deep massage, heat treatment and sometimes physiotherapy. 
 In short, avoid the horrors of a tell-tale padded dog-collar by investing in a car fax.  
 The Green Man: Harlesden NW10 
 Private Eyes 
 What's that at Three O'Clock 
 How many times has it happened? 
 You're walking down the street during the tourist season and you spot a group of Japanese. 
 They may be crowded up against the window of the tour bus or milling together on the pavement, but one thing is for sure &mdash; they're taking snapshots. 
 You point your eyes in the direction they are pointing their Nikons, only to be baffled by what, if anything, they are photographing. 
 So in an effort to find out whether are blind, or they're just weird, we asked a member of a party of visitors from Tokyo, Miss Takishima, to be kind enough to let us process the film in her camera. 
 Our conclusion? 
 They're just weird. 
 Ten Sure Ways to Keep You in Your Trousers 
 HIS 
 1 A trouser-press 
 2 A Polaroid camera 
 3 Soiled underwear 
 4 Satin sheets 
 5 The K-Tel Love Album 
 6 Nail clippings 
 7 The &bquo;tennis girl&equo; poster 
 8 Novelty condoms 
 9 Kleenex on the bedside table 
 10 Edible underpants 
 HERS 
 1 Teddies, gonks, furry toy animals 
 2 A picture of her Bader Meinhof boyfriend 
 3 Wicked Willy books 
 4 Damart underwear 
 5 A poster of Jason Donovan or any Radio One DJ 
 6 A cot 
 7 The K-Tel Love Album 
 8 Pop socks 
 9 Any ceramic item from the Franklin Mint 
 10 Batteries on the bedside table 
 Esquire Offer 
 Sporting Friends 
 Take a closer look at the Esquire special offer for April. 
 Of all Carl Zeiss Jena binoculars, perhaps the most famous are the Deltrintem 8x30. 
 The perfect union of size and style ensures that the glasses are a worldwide favourite. 
 With a magnification factor of eight and an objective lens diameter of thirty millimetres the binoculars are compact, lightweight and rugged, classic all-purpose glasses. 
 For generations, sportsmen have revelled in Carl Zeiss Jena's marriage of design and performance. 
 In black, the Deltrintem 8x30 come complete with a tough felt-lined mahogany leather case and detachable lanyard. 
 All Carl Zeiss Jena binoculars are covered against manufacturing faults by a lifetime guarantee. 
 Special offer price &pound;79.69 
 The stainless steel hip-flask is perfect for taking a little home comfort with you into the great outdoors. 
 Designed by the Regent Belt Company Ltd, the flask holds six fluid ounces and is beautifully covered in mahogany-coloured leather. 
 Special offer price &pound;18.45 
 This offer is open only to readers living in Great Britain, including Northern Ireland, and remains open until July 14, 1991. 
 To order, please complete the coupon below and send it with a UK cheque/PO (not cash) to: Esquire Hip-flask Offer, Offer Number 5 and/or Esquire Binoculars Offer, Offer Number 6, PO Box 6, Kettering, Northants NN15 5JW. 
 Items should be received within twenty-eight days of receipt of order. 
 If more than one item is ordered, they well be dispatched in separate packs. 
 Coupon not required for repeat orders. 
 If you are not entirely satisfied, please return any item within seven days in the condition in which it was received, with a covering letter; your money will be refunded in full. 
 We cannot be held responsible for returned goods lost in transit. 
 Credit-card holders may order direct by telephoning 0536 723799 (orders only, it is not an enquiry line). 
 Please note that your credit-card account will be debited when your purchase is sent.  
 Post coupon and payment to: Esquire Hip-flask and Binoculars Offer, Offer Numbers 5 and/or 6, PO Box 6, Kettering, Northants NN15 5JW. 
 The National Magazine Company Ltd, Registered Number 112955, National Magazine House, 72 Broadwick Street, London W1V 2BP. 
 Data Protection: as a service to readers, we occasionally make dispatch lists available to carefully screened companies whose products or services we feel may be of interest. 
 If you do not wish to receive such mailings, please send your name and address to The National Magazine Company Ltd, DR Department, Eagle House, 50 Marshall Street, London W1V 1LR.  
 From Toe to Head 
 Richard Boston's Ankles 
 Stage two in the construction of the great British writer. 
 Next month, Pete Davies's knees 
 My ankles are a disaster. 
 The left one's not too bad, but the right one's ridiculous. 
 For years whenever I've got out of bed in the middle of the night &mdash; about whatever pursuit you get out of bed in the night for &mdash; my right ankle has made cracking noises, like kindling being snapped. 
 Nor do they do a lot for me as erogenous zones. 
 I was once photographed at Cap d'Agde sans culotte for the cover of the first issue of the review section of a national newspaper &mdash; in the interests of serious research, you understand, on nudist colonies. 
 (As befits a writer on a broadsheet newspaper, my laptop concealed my&hellip; laptop.) 
 Everyone agreed it was a fine picture, a breezy blend of wit and taste. 
 Until the picture editor saw my ankles. 
 He was right, of course. 
 Skilfully cropped, that picture sold thousands of papers. 
 Uncropped: who knows? 
 The Weekend Guardian might be just another memory. 
 I console myself with the thought that whatever happens to the ankles of others (and there is no doubt that prettily turned item is a tremendous turn-on), mine are contemplated without the libido's charging in with its usual tedious cries of &bquo;Me, me, me&equo;. 
 As Lorelei Lee said  immemorably  in Diamonds Are a Girl's Best Friend, a girl can't go on laughing all the time. 
 To be serious: In German, an ankle is a Fusskn&ouml;chel, a foot knuckle. 
 (The Germans have a direct approach to these things: a nipple is a Brustwarze, a breast wart.) 
 An archaic English word for the ankles is huckle-bones, and these huckle-bones, and knuckle-bones (usually from sheep), were used for playing dice. 
 The medical name for the ankle-bone is the astragalus), the Greek word also for dice. 
 So whatever the ankle has done for sex, its contribution to other games of chance has been incalculable. 
 One summer's day a few years ago, I was about to play a game of tennis. 
 It was quite some time since I had last played and, inhaling huge lungfuls of air as I did so, I looked forward keenly to demolishing my opponent with my supra-sonic service, my cunning topspins, bottomspins, sidespins, every-this-and-thatspins. 
 With such thoughts in my head and lithe grace in my movements, I loped up the grassy knoll to the court. 
 I slipped. 
 On a dog turd. 
 And my ankle gave out a sound like a pistol-shot. 
 It came up like a multi-coloured balloon and was pretty painful for a while. 
 The treatment was quite fun, though. 
 It's called the RICE principle. 
 R is for rest; I is for ice (a bag of frozen peas does nicely) applied to the ankle; C is for compression &mdash; firm bandaging; E for elevation, otherwise known as putting your feet up. 
 What this means is that you're the centre of attention and you're waited on hand and (of course) foot. 
 And since the frozen peas and firm bandaging were applied by the fair hands of a comely maiden, I began to think that perhaps I could reasonably update my views on the ankle, Eros-wise. 
 I was all too soon up and about, hobbling with a stick. 
 This had some value, leading old ladies to get up and give me their seat on public transport. 
 To tell the truth, I continued to use the stick for longer than was strictly necessary. 
 Gradually the ankle got better, but it will never be a hundred per cent. 
 That dog turd, so much more bitterly prosaic than any arrow, gave me my Achilles' heel. 
 But I laugh it off, paraphrasing Beau Brummell, only remarking lightly that the saddest thing is, it was my favourite ankle.  
 Area of detail Alan Coren's feet 
 Family Silver 
 A few months after I joined the Department of Transport in 1979 I was presented with an issue which had baffled governments for well over a hundred years. 
 I had called a meeting in my office, by now decorated with a number of pictures from the Government's own art collection including a marvellous study of the railway cutting at Acton by Lucien Pissarro. 
 The subject of the meeting was the Channel Tunnel. 
 The Channel Tunnel project had first been seriously mooted at the start of the nineteenth century. 
 Over the years since then, the debate on whether it was better to cross the Channel by tunnel, bridge or ferry had raged to and fro. 
 Solutions had ranged from the ingenious to the bizarre. 
 One Victorian scheme was for a tunnel lit by candles, where horses would draw passengers across in special vehicles, pausing only at an artificial island in the middle of the Channel for everyone to come up for air and water. 
 Another project was for a submerged tube. 
 Gothic turrets would provide ventilation shafts and the two ends would be marked by lighthouses. 
 By 1876, planning had reached such a point that France and Britain signed a protocol laying down the basis of a treaty governing the construction of the tunnel and a start was made on either side of the Channel. 
 It was not to be. 
 Public and press opinion turned against the whole concept, with Queen Victoria pronouncing it &bquo;objectionable&equo; and The Times declaring that &bquo;the silver streak is our safety&equo;. 
 For the next eighty years the argument that a tunnel under the silver streak of the Channel would pose a major security problem held sway, although a tunnel would have been of great advantage to Britain during the First World War. 
 As the twentieth century progressed the debate limped on, but it was not until the early 1960s that the tunnel became a serious prospect again. 
 In 1961 the British and French governments agreed to set up a working group to consider the merits of the rival proposals and at the beginning of 1964 Ernest Marples, the British Transport Minister, and his French counterpart announced that the two governments would go ahead with a tunnel. 
 In 1973 a  start was actually made, but the following February the Heath Government fell. 
 Labour inherited three major public spending projects: the third London airport to be built at Maplin, the supersonic Concorde aircraft and the Channel Tunnel. 
 Labour wanted economies and the first project to perish was Maplin. 
 But that was not enough for the new Chancellor, Denis Healey. 
 In effect there was a choice between Concorde and the Channel Tunnel. 
 Concorde (which was to be partly built in Bristol) benefited from a strong local lobby including a local MP, Tony Benn, who had now become a member of the Labour Cabinet. 
 More to the point, it would cost more to cancel Concorde than the relatively paltry &pound;17 million it would cost to go back on the Channel Tunnel. 
 The result was that on 20 January 1975 Harold Wilson's Government, to the dismay of the French, formally cancelled the project and all work on the tunnel stopped. 
 In 1979 the issue came to me. 
 It could scarcely have come at a worse time. 
 No one was under any illusion that Margaret Thatcher was in the business of building expensive prestige projects &mdash; a category into which the Channel Tunnel was wrongly put. 
 Public spending was being reined back and the Cabinet was getting down to the series of bruising public-spending battles which characterized our first few years of office. 
 Nevertheless, Peter Parker and British Rail were anxious to get the project back on track and I strongly sympathized with their position. 
 The tunnel was a long-overdue link with Europe as well as a new opportunity for the railways. 
 But I also realized that I would be exceedingly lucky to keep my existing road and rail budgets, let alone add massive new expenditure. 
 At the first meeting in the department I did what every other Transport Minister appears to have done over the previous ten years: I hired Professor Sir Alec Cairncross to advise me. 
 There was no question that a tunnel was technically feasible, but 1 wanted to know what the economics would be. 
 What would be the likely traffic? 
 What would be a sensible forecast of revenue? 
 I particularly wanted to know Sir Alec's views now that British Rail had submitted a scaled-down plan. 
 Poor old British Rail were between the devil and the deep blue sea. 
 The Labour Government had cancelled their previous and more ambitious scheme for the tunnel and now the next Conservative Government was wondering if their  current one was ambitious enough. 
 Nevertheless, the questions were fundamental. 
 The British Rail scheme would certainly cost less than the old plan as it now proposed a single-track tunnel, not a twin tunnel. 
 This meant obvious limits on capacity and above all it meant no cars and no lorries which were the most lucrative traffic. 
 It seemed too modest to be profitable. 
 What really concerned me was how to finance a tunnel project of any kind. 
 I realized I would get no help from the Treasury and, indeed, I suspected that they could not understand why the department was wasting its time on this issue at all. 
 In my view there was only one hope, and that was to build the tunnel using private venture capital. 
 On Wednesday 5 March 1980, I explored the practicalities of this course at a meeting in the department and on 10 March I minuted the Prime Minister. 
 I said that I believed it would now be right to give some indication of the Government's attitude to the building of a tunnel. 
 I continued: 
 I see no advantage in adopting the Labour Government's negative stance and ruling out all possibility of a link being built. 
 If private capital can be attracted &mdash; and I believe it could to the right project &mdash; it seems to me entirely right that we should do what we can as Government to create the right climate for a successful link to be built. 
 In essence I proposed that rather than having public investment we should substitute private investment without any Government guarantee. 
 That basically meant that Government would not stand behind the project. 
 We would do whatever Government had to do, like negotiate a treaty with the French, but we would not be financially responsible for the project. 
 The policy was cleared over the next few days and on 19 March I told the House of Commons that 
 The cost of any scheme would be very large and I should make clear now that the Government cannot contemplate funding expenditure on this scale from public funds. 
 However, if a scheme is commercially sound I see no reason why private risk capital should not be available. 
 The marks of the Treasury were all over my short statement of  policy. 
 They had conceded that the project could go ahead, but very few bets were being taken in Whitehall that the century-old logjam would be shifted. 
 There was a general belief that our terms would not attract many takers and there was a suspicion that the Government did not really have its heart in the project in any event. 
 Over the next months, rival consortia considered how to finance the new investment while at the Transport Department we could do little more than wait. 
 Then, eighteen months later, we had an exceptional stroke of luck which entirely transformed the position. 
 In September 1981 the newly elected President Mitterrand came to London. 
 He brought with him, among others, the new Communist Transport Minister, Charles Fiterman, whom I had met the previous week. 
 We had talked over transport issues, including the tunnel. 
 All the predictions were that the meeting at Downing Street between newly elected political opposites would be difficult. 
 In fact it proved surprisingly genial and Margaret Thatcher's transparent ability (later to impress another political opposite, Mikhail Gorbachev) had its effect on Fran&ccedil;ois Mitterrand. 
 There was, however, one problem. 
 Pleasant as the round of meetings had been, there was next to nothing that could be agreed as a common objective for the final communiqu&eacute;. 
 It was at this point that the Channel Tunnel at last came into its own. 
 President Mitterrand shared the traditional French enthusiasm for the tunnel and, socialist or not, was prepared to concede private investment. 
 Margaret Thatcher, too, realized the potential of having this major capital project financed by the private sector. 
 It has been claimed that Margaret saw the tunnel as some sort of monument to her and her period of government. 
 I never once heard her even hint at such a view. 
 Her position as expressed to me was that if the private sector wanted to use its own money for the tunnel then we should certainly not stand in the way. 
 The result of the Downing Street meeting was an enthusiastic statement committing the two leaders to the project. 
 It was the crucial turning-point because from that moment on the tunnel had not just the support of the Transport Department but the backing of Number 10. 
 Cabinet ministers may be equal, but Prime Ministers are more equal than others. 
 To get the backing of the British  Prime Minister and the French President was a good day's work. 
 Much of the debate today about the Channel crossing concentrates on the rail link on the British side. 
 My involvement with the tunnel did not extend to the rail link which was decided after I had left the department. 
 But that debate should not obscure the fact that private investment was the key that unlocked the Channel Tunnel door. 
 The project had been cancelled by Labour for lack of public funds. 
 Had we waited for the position to change, so that public investment or private investment with public guarantee could go ahead, we would still be waiting. 
 Yet the conventional wisdom in the transport world of the 1970s was that all progress depended on public investment, public controls and, of course, public ownership. 
 Everywhere I looked the Government was involved. 
 It even had a shot at controlling motorway service areas, provoking a debate which encapsulated many of the attitudes of the time. 
 The service areas, with their awful tea and rubber sandwiches, had become a music hall joke. 
 It seemed to me that although competition on site was difficult, it was at least possible to have competition between sites. 
 To do that, however, you would have to allow the operators to advertise. 
 There were already signs that told the motorist he was approaching, say, the Newport Pagnell or Watford Gap service areas. 
 Surely there could be no objection to telling him in advance which areas were run by Trusthouse Forte and which by Granada? 
 Not a bit of it. 
 One of my civil servants solemnly objected, arguing that such advertisements could present a potential safety risk. 
 The theory was that on seeing the sign motorists would be so surprised that they might drive into the verge or the car in front. 
 That policy was overturned in two minutes flat but it is worth remembering that it had held sway since the inception of the service areas fifteen years earlier. 
 Advertising, however, turned out to be only the tip of the iceberg. 
 Although each site was controlled by the operator, they were supervised and inspected by the Department of Transport. 
 That meant the Minister of Transport was answerable for them in the House of Commons. 
 In Opposition we had had great fun pursuing Bill Rodgers on the standard of the baked beans and the quality of the fried cod. 
 We hounded him to such effect that he responded in the classic 1970s way and set up no less than an official  committee of inquiry to consider the whole position. 
 The committee carried out a range of fascinating research and confirmed what the public knew already, namely that the ham sandwiches available in motorway cafeterias had a tendency to be &bquo;thin, tasteless ham in soggy bread&equo;. 
 Bill Rodgers having set up this committee, it now fell to me to decide what to do with their report. 
 I had no intention of answering a Parliamentary question on soggy ham sandwiches and I could not see why Government was involved in the commercial operation at all. 
 The obvious solution was to sell the leases to the operators and for them to decide what investment was required if they were to attract new business. 
 When I put this to the operators there was an astonished silence. 
 No one had previously considered this proposal and there was therefore no prepared group response. 
 One or two operators immediately saw the attractions, but others still hankered after the old world. 
 The meeting broke up with mixed feelings, but after a few days it became clear that we were in business. 
 I put up for sale the service areas on new long leases, retaining some controls only to ensure that the areas were safe stopping places for motorway travellers. 
 My experience with motorway service areas confirmed my belief that far too much of transport was either in state hands or run under state control. 
 Rather than concluding that I had been too radical in Opposition, I fast came to the view 1 had been too cautious. 
 Everything I saw in Government suggested that the right place for the National Freight Corporation was in the private sector and that deregulation of the bus and coach services could provide great public benefits. 
 But I now saw other opportunities. 
 The nineteen ports owned by the British Transport Docks Board were basically old railway ports and had come into Government control with the nationalization of the railways in 1946. 
 The Docks Board was the biggest company in the ports industry and with its Southampton operations and its Humber and South Wales ports had secured about a quarter of the market. 
 But nationalization had brought the board few obvious advantages. 
 As part of the public sector it was subject to the usual Treasury controls on investment and borrowing, but it was also restricted in another way. 
 Because it was publicly owned, its activities were restricted  so that it did not compete unfairly with the private sector. 
 The result was that the board was confined to the business of handling ships and cargo but required ministerial consent if, for example, it wished to develop the land attached to the sites. 
 The obvious solution was to give the board commercial freedom and control of its own destiny in the private sector. 
 The board itself saw the advantage of this course but the chairman, Humphrey Browne, was worried that privatization would lead to a crippling strike. 
 Personally I thought the fears overdone, but nevertheless I sought to find a way of transferring the operation to the private sector which would minimize the risk of industrial action. 
 I proposed that the Government should initially retain a 51 per cent stake in the new company. 
 In other words, the new company would start life structured in rather the same way as BP, with a Government shareholding but without the Government taking any part in the business. 
 That stake was later sold and the privatization of the ports was completed without any industrial action and with many of the dockers buying shares in the new company. 
 British Rail's subsidiary companies, like the hotels and the cross-Channel ferry company, Sealink, were another area ripe for change. 
 These companies had traditional links with the railways and their raison d'&ecirc;tre had been that they were a natural extension of the business. 
 They were there for the convenience of rail passengers. 
 But times had changed. 
 The railway connection no longer dominated the operation and most of the customers for both hotels and ferries came by road. 
 Both businesses had been starved of investment for more than thirty years. 
 The hotels were dingy and British Transport Hotels had added only one new building to their stock since the end of the Second World War. 
 The ferries were safe but too often they were outdated and uncomfortable. 
 In part this was due to the public-sector controls on investment, but it was also because of the natural priorities that had operated year after year inside British Rail. 
 What the public wanted was a good rail service and not surprisingly successive generations of British Rail managers put their major effort into achieving that. 
 In competition for new investment, hotels and ferries came way behind the main business and these two potentially successful concerns were not getting the  management or main board attention they deserved. 
 Nor was there any reason to believe they would get it over the next thirty years, either. 
 After talks with BR's Chairman, Peter Parker, we agreed that the sensible way forward was for a new company, British Rail Investments, to be formed and for the subsidiaries to be transferred to the private sector, with the proceeds going to British Rail. 
 In transport, then, Margaret Thatcher's first Government extended privatization far beyond what we had thought possible in Opposition, but there was no doubt what was the jewel in the crown. 
 Some commentators and businessmen have suggested that the successful privatization of the National Freight Corporation was a foregone conclusion. 
 It certainly did not seem that way at the time. 
 We were not inundated with offers for the company from the private sector and our financial advisers doubted whether we could sell the business at all. 
 The parcels side was still losing money heavily and by 1980 the world was running into recession. 
 No country was worse hit than Britain, where an economic gale tore through companies which were already dangerously weak. 
 Unemployment went up and investment came down. 
 In the West Midlands you saw factories where the roofs had been removed to avoid rates on the empty building. 
 Among the industries affected, transport was badly hit. 
 There was over-capacity in road haulage as the amount of goods to be transported went down and prices were cut. 
 Even the inner-city property sites of National Carriers did not look very tempting once it became clear there was an abundance of that kind of property on offer. 
 It was against this background that Peter Thompson, the chief executive of NFC, together with his chairman, Bobby Lawrence, came to see me in my small office on the Cabinet floor of the House of Commons on 18 May 1981. 
 At an earlier meeting, Bobby Lawrence had asked me for my initial reaction to the management buying the company. 
 Peter Thompson now explained that he wanted to go beyond the concept of a management buy-out and to involve all the staff who wanted to buy shares. 
 He feared that a management buy-out would leave things on the shop floor very much as before with the &bquo;them&equo; and &bquo;us&equo; of workers and managers. 
 Employee ownership would open the door to involving all the staff in the company. 
 My reaction was,  if anything, more enthusiastic than before. 
 It seemed the ideal way for the NFC to go into the private sector. 
 Bad industrial relations had been the curse of the country for as long as I had taken any interest in politics; although the reform of trade union law was essential, further steps were also needed. 
 I hoped that the NFC would be a pioneer not only in privatization but also in improving employee relations. 
 The 1980 Transport Act took all the action necessary to transfer the National Freight Corporation to the private sector and reform the Traffic Commissioner system so that new inter-city and commuter coach services could develop, together with other new services like car-sharing. 
 With the momentum of privatization established, I was able to argue successfully for further legislation. 
 The 1981 Transport Act enabled private investment to be introduced into the subsidiary companies of British Rail and effectively denationalized the British Transport Docks Board. 
 Of course, critics of privatization in transport abounded. 
 Labour spokesmen competed with wild phrases about &bquo;cut-throat competition&equo; and &bquo;rip-off&equo;. 
 But the most damaging criticism of the privatization process came some years later, and not from a Labour politician but from one of the most distinguished Conservative leaders since the war, Harold Macmillan. 
 Macmillan likened the privatization programme to the reaction of individuals or estates when they run into difficulties. 
 They dispose of &bquo;all the nice furniture that used to be in the saloon and then the candelabra&equo;. 
 In short, they sell the family silver. 
 Macmillan saw privatization as an ideological approach to the problems of industry motivated by a simple desire on the part of Government to make some quick money. 
 I entirely dispute that. 
 The transport companies which have been denationalized are now successful and are trading profitably. 
 This provides the best possible security for their workforces but it means something more in terms of the &bquo;family silver&equo;. 
 Rather than paying out subsidies, the Government now receives substantial annual taxation receipts. 
 Company profits mean income for the Government. 
 Without that income, promises of better public services &mdash; that is, publicly financed services &mdash; are pure fantasy. 
 To take just one example: Associated British Ports (the former British Transport Docks Board) has paid over &pound;60 million in corporation tax over the last  five years. 
 The taxpayer received not only a capital sum when the companies were sold but now also receives a substantial annual dividend. 
 Any estate owner who achieved this might be thought to have made a notable bargain. 
 There is no doubt that investment in the companies which have gone private has increased, sometimes substantially. 
 Total investment in the NFC in the years since privatization has totalled almost &pound;700 million, whereas in state ownership investment never exceeded &pound;25 million a year. 
 In Associated British Ports investment in the business approaches &pound;200 million. 
 In the motorway service areas, Trusthouse Forte alone have invested over &pound;80 million since they were allowed to purchase their leases. 
 The areas have visibly improved, with new restaurants and new hotels. 
 As for employee involvement, it is certainly greater than it ever was in the years of nationalization. 
 The claim for nationalization was that public ownership would mean more commitment to those industries by the people who worked for them. 
 It never worked out that way. 
 Nationalization in the transport industries produced neither outstanding industrial relations nor employee commitment. 
 Privatization has produced much more hopeful results. 
 The NFC has been the outstanding example where for seven years the company was owned entirely by the workforce. 
 Even now that the company has gone public, some 40 per cent of shares remain in the hands of staff or former staff. 
 Annual General Meetings are attended by several thousand employee shareholders and (in contrast to the normally sedate company AGM in some discreet City hall) NFC has to take over the National Exhibition Centre in Birmingham or the Winter Gardens at Blackpool. 
 Privatization has also allowed good managers to manage and succeed. 
 There are the well-known stars like Peter Thompson and James Watson of NFC, and Keith Stuart of Associated British Ports, who came with their companies from the public sector. 
 But the process goes way beyond the top managers. 
 It reaches right down into the companies themselves. 
 As one senior manager said: &bquo;Employees now expect managers to take decisions on a commercial basis and recognize that their interests as employees &mdash; and in many cases shareholders &mdash; demand it. 
 This is in marked contrast to the position prior to privatization when the commercial objective  was accepted by senior management but not by the bulk of employees.&equo; 
 Above all, the result of privatization in transport has been a better service to the public. 
 Coach services have increased and are provided in modern, comfortable vehicles at competitive prices. 
 Commuting by coach has prospered. 
 The hotels which used to belong to British Rail have improved substantially. 
 Gleneagles, for example, is now open all the year round rather than just in summer and autumn following a major investment in all-weather sport and leisure facilities. 
 At the motorway service areas petrol prices are now nearer the off-motorway prices and competition has benefited the motorist. 
 As Rocco Forte said: 
 After the changes the consumer could see what he was buying before committing himself to leave the motorway. 
 There was a real incentive for operators to provide a quality service which built consumer loyalty. 
 In short, the consumer called the tune and the operators who prospered were those who best identified the needs of the consumers and met them at the right price. 
 Privatization has achieved better ways of running the transport industries and there is today no serious movement in any of them to return to state control. 
 A similar position can be found in many of the later privatizations of the Thatcher Government. 
 Certainly some, like British Telecommunications, gas, electricity and water, produced spectacular financial results, but the lasting impact has been on the businesses themselves. 
 Privatization means giving businesses the chance to flourish; the process of deregulation means the Government getting out of the way. 
 The Government provides the opportunity, but it cannot guarantee success. 
 The most ministers can do is to argue the case for change and enable the changes to be made. 
 The eventual success of the venture depends not upon ministers but upon the managers and the workforce in the companies themselves. 
 The significant feature of privatization has been that the transformation has usually been carried out by broadly the same teams that had worked under nationalization. 
 Throughout the privatized businesses, attitudes to the customer have improved and the bureaucracy of State industry  has been removed. 
 It is essentially for reasons like these that the governments of the new democracies of Eastern Europe look to privatization as a way forward. 
 It is for the same reasons that I would now support the denationalization of British Rail. 
 Some argue that this is impossible, given that some rail services will be unprofitable. 
 Yet there is no reason why Government cannot enter into contracts with privatized companies whether privatization is on a regional basis or takes place in some other way. 
 Privatization would not mean the end of support for the railways. 
 It would provide better value for both the taxpayer and the passenger. 
 The potential gain from rail privatization would be a more commercial railway and a better service for the public. 
 When I was at the Transport Department, my aim was a good rail service for the public and as efficient a service as possible. 
 That meant continuing to support British Rail financially while at the same time fighting to make the industry more productive. 
 Manpower had come down over the years from 470,000 in 1960 to 215,000 twenty years later, but the business was still over-staffed. 
 Everyone knew this, but we faced the same problems in increasing efficiency and productivity as in all the other traditional industries like coal and steel. 
 Our challenge on the railways was to win change &mdash; but without, in Peter Parker's words, &bquo;bringing the roof in&equo;. 
 At the time, the two dominant rail union leaders were Sid Weighell of the National Union of Railwaymen and Ray Buckton of the drivers' union, ASLEF (the Associated Society of Locomotive Engineers and Firemen). 
 They were a contrast in styles. 
 Sid Weighell was tense and cautious. 
 Negotiations were long and painful. 
 He was always looking for the catch. 
 When he agreed, however, the agreement stuck. 
 Ray Buckton was a much more extrovert character. 
 He was always available to the press for an instant comment and was a politician in his own right. 
 On the other hand, he was extremely difficult to pin down to any conclusion. 
 He gave the impression that he was constantly looking over his shoulder at his executive which contained some hard and prickly characters. 
 One other point about the two union leaders was abundantly clear. 
 Whenever they came to meetings at the department they sat at opposite ends of the table. 
 Whatever reservations they  had about dealing with me were as nothing compared to the reservations they had about dealing with each other. 
 On one point, however, they were united. 
 They wanted to see a positive statement from the Government which demonstrated our commitment to the future of the railways. 
 With the election of Margaret Thatcher, the assumption among some lobbyists had been that we would institute a new round of &bquo;Beeching cuts&equo;. 
 In the early 1960s Dr Beeching, the chairman of the railways, had cut out some of the most unprofitable rail lines and the fear was that I would do the same. 
 Indeed in November 1979 the Guardian had published a wholly imaginary story about 900 miles of railway being under the axe. 
 For all its note of fantasy, however, the article was widely read and well timed. 
 It appeared on the day that I was answering questions on transport on the floor of the House and there was a question on the future of railway services on the order paper. 
 As I rose to answer there was a roar of laughter from the Labour benches. 
 I looked behind me to see what appeared to be a solid forest of standing Tory MPs from county constituencies anxious to ask questions about their own particular rail lines. 
 I repeated that I saw &bquo;no case for a further round of Beeching cuts&equo; and that there had been no secret talks or plans. 
 The House settled back more or less reassured. 
 The only occasion when rail closures were raised in my time at the Transport Department was in the spring of 1981. 
 The issue arose when I took to Cabinet committee my proposals on railway electrification. 
 British Rail's diesel stock was coming up for replacement and we needed to decide whether to reinvest in diesel equipment or to invest in electrification. 
 The overwhelming advantage of an electric railway was that it was cheaper to run and maintain. 
 It would also reduce dependence on oil, which was a sensible strategic aim, and the regular orders for the British railway manufacturing industry could help to win more export orders for electrified systems overseas. 
 In February 1981 the Transport Department and British Rail published a joint report which concluded that a substantial programme of main-line electrification would be financially worthwhile: it would show a real return on capital of around 11 per cent and it would cut oil consumption. 
 At the end of March, I circulated a paper which enthusiastically backed electrification. 
  A meeting was set for mid-April but, just before it, the whole policy was challenged by an adviser to the Government, Professor Alan Walters. 
 Walters had two main points. 
 First, he argued that the railway system should be reduced. 
 Many experts, he said, believed that we should aim for a smaller, more concentrated and more efficient network. 
 Second, he challenged the forecasts on electrification and said that competition from cars, the newly deregulated coaches and the airlines could all erode rail traffic. 
 The case for widespread electrification was not plausible, he thundered. 
 It was based on assumptions which were not credible. 
 I strongly disagreed with both arguments. 
 I did not believe that there were large savings to be made simply from reducing the size of the rail network. 
 Over two-thirds of the cost of the railways was the cost of labour. 
 The obvious policy to follow was one of improved productivity, and I proposed, with the agreement of British Rail, a reduction in the workforce of 38,000. 
 With electrification I could achieve this goal. 
 If I simply concentrated on reducing the network, I would involve myself in a long and profitless public, political and industrial row. 
 There would be public inquiry after public inquiry &mdash; for the law ensured that no closure could be made without one &mdash; and many areas would be deprived of valued rail services. 
 I believed the case for electrification to be overwhelming. 
 And although my department and British Rail had produced a joint report, this did not mean we automatically accepted BR's views. 
 We needed to be persuaded of the case and we had gone through the BR figures line by line. 
 When the case came to ministerial colleagues, it was these arguments that prevailed. 
 There was no support for reducing the network and the position that I had set out in 1979 remained the Government's policy. 
 The Central Policy Review Staff were asked to examine the case for electrification. 
 In June 1981 the CPRS reported back that there was indeed a commercial case for electrification but that the programme should be endorsed route by route rather than in some all-embracing fashion. 
 As far as I was concerned, that merely represented a different path to the same goal and so on 22 June I told the House of Commons that rail electrification was going ahead. 
 On the same afternoon I met with  the rail unions and (loyally supported by Peter Parker) put the position to them. 
 Both Weighell and Buckton would have preferred more, but the statement persuaded them that the Government did have its heart in the future of the railway system. 
 The scene was set for progress towards a modern network. 
 My chief regret in my stay at Transport was that we were not able to do more in combining private and public investment in partnership projects. 
 In particular, we could have done more to use private investment in the road-building programme. 
 We are all deeply schizophrenic about roads. 
 Held up in a jam on, say, the M25 we curse the planners for not having the foresight to have built a five-lane motorway joining up to other five-lane motorways. 
 Comfortably seated in a television studio or before a television set, we tend to forget that experience and offer pious hopes that public transport will improve to such an extent that in some miraculous way new roads will be unnecessary. 
 At the beginning of the 1980s, road building was not a notably popular cause. 
 You could usually win support for bypasses from unhappy communities who had been pounded by heavy traffic on roads quite inadequate for the purpose. 
 But on some parts of the M25 we were more likely to be met by demonstrators protesting against the road itself. 
 I cannot remember any public movement to get five lanes. 
 At times I reckoned we were lucky to get three. 
 Delay was written into the whole system of road planning. 
 The procedures took so long that much needed links were not built until years after they were required. 
 The M40 motorway was a case in point. 
 A motorway connecting Oxford (and thus London) to Birmingham and the Midlands road network had been needed for at least two decades. 
 I went to see the proposed route of the M40 in my time as Transport Minister, but the full motorway was not opened until 1991. 
 I had another serious battle getting approval for the M54 to Telford &mdash; the only road I know of finally settled at a full meeting of a Cabinet committee. 
 Nor did the Government's means of analysing the need for roads always help very much. 
 The Treasury had a system called COBA &mdash; cost-benefit analysis. 
 Ken Clarke was my minister of roads and I remember him coming back on more than one occasion with steam coming out of his ears. 
 The analysis had shown that the cheapest option was to build a particular road in a straight line. 
  The mere fact that this took the road through a school and a housing estate was of secondary interest. 
 When I took over, it was evident that the need for new roads vastly outstripped the likely supply. 
 Could not private investment fill at least part of the gap? 
 Toll roads were one solution but I was less keen on them than on another idea we developed in the Transport Department. 
 The idea was that the private sector would build and finance a number of roads and the department would pay a rent for them on the basis of how much traffic used them. 
 The Treasury did not like this plan at all. 
 In their view it was nothing more than delayed public spending in instalments. 
 Some might think a little delayed public spending on roads would not have been a bad idea at that time. 
 Nowhere has the failure to build much needed roads been more obvious than in our cities. 
 The result is that the city environment has deteriorated. 
 The number of cars has increased and the roads are all too often inadequate to take them. 
 Birmingham is one of the few cities where any attempt at sensible provision has been made. 
 London, however, is pounded by commuter traffic and the only policy option which promises relief is determined action to exclude or price out the one-driver commuter car. 
 There is now no other course. 
 We face the vastly increased traffic projections for the twenty-first century with roads adequate to deal with the conditions of the nineteenth. 
 No road-building scheme can bring relief to London in the foreseeable future. 
 Almost all of us value the freedom that the car gives, but life is about balancing freedoms. 
 There should be no absolute freedom for any motorist to drive into the middle of already congested cities free of charge. 
 I spent my last months at the Transport Department preparing a third Transport Bill whose aim was to reform the traffic laws and to introduce the &bquo;points&equo; system for disqualification. 
 This followed my 1981 legislation which had introduced the first road-safety measures for fifteen years and was used (as I knew it would be) to introduce compulsory seat-belts. 
 But I now felt the time was coming to move on to another department. 
 At the beginning of 1981 I had been promoted from Minister of Transport to Secretary of State. 
 This meant very little to me apart from a salary increase and a move from my position at the extreme right of the Cabinet table to the extreme left. 
 I took over the chair previously  occupied by Angus Maude, who since 1979 had carried out the impossible job of overseeing Government information. 
 When things are going wrong the Government's supporters call it a failure of presentation and everyone trots out the old excuse that &bquo;we are not getting the message across&equo;. 
 In the wider political world outside transport that excuse was much in use in 1981. 
 Turning Point 
 One of Margaret Thatcher's most famous maxims was &bquo;you don't have problems &mdash; you only have challenges&equo;. 
 In 1981 we had one challenge after another. 
 In 1979 we had won the election with 44 per cent of the poll. 
 By early 1981 our support had fallen to below 30 per cent and as the months went by it plummeted even further to reach 23 per cent at the end of the year. 
 Even in the &bquo;poll-tax&equo; dominated months of 1990 we did not quite reach that point. 
 The Conservative Party was cast in gloom. 
 For much of 1981 we were running not only behind Labour but also behind the alliance formed by the Liberals and the newly created Social Democratic Party of David Owen, Bill Rodgers, Shirley Williams and Roy Jenkins. 
 The SDP's aim was to create a real third force in British politics and their hope was to take votes from both parties. 
 They believed they could win votes in Sunderland just as surely as in Mid-Sussex. 
 We Tory MPs were not so sure. 
 The SDP were likely to be a far greater danger to us, as disgruntled ex-Conservative voters who would never have voted Labour in a million years turned to a cosy middle party. 
 It had to be admitted that there was plenty for the voters to be disgruntled about. 
 The country was in the middle of a world recession with unemployment well above two million and looking set to break the three million mark, a prospect that a few years before would have seemed unthinkable. 
 Inside the Government the gloom was widely shared. 
 Cabinet was an unhappy place. 
 There were leaks everywhere and well-reported battles between the so-called &bquo;dries&equo; who were the outright supporters of the Government's economic policies and the &bquo;wets&equo; who were the sceptics. 
 In fact the grouping was never much more than a rough guide. 
 It was certainly correct to put Jim Prior, Peter Walker and Ian Gilmour firmly in the &bquo;wet&equo; camp and Keith Joseph would go down as an undoubted &bquo;dry&equo;, but for most of the rest of us our opinion depended upon the issue. 
 Nevertheless, no one could claim that it was a united Cabinet and this was made worse as the everyday issues of government started to go wrong. 
 In February 1981 we were badly holed in a dispute with the  National Union of Mineworkers. 
 The National Coal Board wanted to close some uneconomic pits and their advice was that this could be achieved by local talks. 
 Although the NUM executive had decided to recommend a ballot on industrial action, the board thought that there was no need to panic and no prospect of an immediate ballot while local negotiations continued. 
 That was the advice on Monday 16 February. 
 On Tuesday, the NUM was not only threatening strike action but taking it. 
 On Wednesday David Howell, the Energy Secretary, was forced to withdraw the threat of pit closures and on Thursday we woke up to a dreadful press accusing us of ignominious surrender. 
 Clearly there were comparisons with 1974, but the charge that really hurt was that the Government had been caught unawares (which we had) and was not in charge (which we were not). 
 But then the Government does not run the nationalized industries. 
 Any minister must rely on the operational advice he is given by the managers on the ground. 
 The fact was that the board got it wrong and we took the blame. 
 The choice for us was whether to take a strike unprepared or to live to fight another day. 
 Wisely, Margaret Thatcher decided to withdraw. 
 This hardly won instant acclaim, but it was both a wise decision which in 1985 was fully vindicated and the decision of a strong leader. 
 Strength does not mean joining every battle that comes along. 
 As John Biffen remarked on weekend television following the d&eacute;b&acirc;cle, &bquo;I did not come into politics to be a kamikaze pilot.&equo; 
 Swiftly following on from coal there came trouble in the steel industry. 
 Again the issue was how to manage change in a traditional industry. 
 Demand for steel had slumped throughout Europe and there was no way we could sustain the industry at its existing size. 
 The trouble was that to create a slimmer and more efficient industry, the Chairman of British Steel, Ian MacGregor, needed money to help with investment and redundancies. 
 It was a sensible policy, but it looked as if the Thatcher Government had simply executed a U-turn and baled out a loss-making nationalized industry. 
 Labour joy was multiplied when it fell to Keith Joseph, the Trade and Industry Secretary, to make the rescue statement. 
 He was greeted with massive and ironic cheers from the Opposition and listened to in almost total silence by our own benches. 
 The press trumpeted another defeat  for the Government. 
 No one could foresee that over the course of the next few years the steel industry would be successfully reorganized and taken into the private sector. 
 But if February was dreadful, it was as nothing compared with March. 
 On Tuesday 10 March at 10.30 a.m. we trooped into the Cabinet room at Number 10 to be given a summary of that afternoon's Budget. 
 Geoffrey Howe's plan was to increase taxes on petrol, alcohol and cigarettes; to raise national insurance contributions; and, worst of all, not to increase personal tax allowances, so in effect increasing personal taxation. 
 It is always difficult for a Cabinet minister to know just how much to say before a Budget statement. 
 You have the privilege of knowing the contents several hours before everyone else, but at this stage in the proceedings it is too late to influence the outcome. 
 Everyone is aware that the Chancellor has a difficult ordeal to face a few hours later and no one wants to make the occasion even worse. 
 However, there was no such self-denying restraint in 1981. 
 When the summary was finished, virtually everyone around the table at Number 10 gave their view. 
 These were faithfully reported in the press a few days later so that readers knew the position of every member of the Cabinet. 
 Jim Prior considered it a disastrous Budget which would do nothing to reduce unemployment. 
 Ian Gilmour and Peter Walker were deeply unhappy. 
 It was even reported that Humphrey Atkins was the only Cabinet member not to speak. 
 The only point the press reports missed was that Jim Prior was so unhappy that he almost threw in his hand and resigned. 
 To a number of us the crucial omission was any help for industry, which was going through an appalling time. 
 I was not alone in wanting to get private investment into public-sector industries. 
 It was an unhappy and tense discussion and can have done absolutely nothing for Geoffrey Howe's morale as he prepared for the afternoon. 
 Not surprisingly, he came under intense fire in the House of Commons. 
 Michael Foot was not a good Leader of the Opposition. 
 He never had the substance for a leader and Labour would have done much better with Denis Healey. 
 But Michael Foot was a formidable orator and on occasions he could coin a phrase which captured the mood perfectly. 
 It was, he said, a &bquo;No Hope Budget&equo; &mdash; and so it appeared to many Conservative voters.  
 Over the next months we lost just about every election we contested. 
 We lost the Greater London Council to Labour and ultimately to Ken Livingstone, and we managed to lose safe Parliamentary seats at both Crosby and Croydon. 
 There were few predictions of a Tory victory at the next general election and even some concern that the country might topple over into serious civil strife. 
 There were riots in Brixton in April and in Liverpool in July. 
 The inner cities came seriously on to the political agenda and Michael Heseltine made a brave attempt to introduce new policies to tackle the undoubted deprivation. 
 By this stage Labour should have been riding high. 
 However, they were preoccupied with their own internal squabbles and Michael Foot was scoring low personal ratings in the opinion polls. 
 The beneficiary was the SDP-Liberal Alliance. 
 The Warrington by-election was held in mid-July, and that night I went with Neil Kinnock and David Owen to BBC Television Centre to await the result. 
 We talked first about the Toxteth riots and then came the declaration. 
 It was a sensational result with Labour almost losing one of their safest seats to the SDP leader, Roy Jenkins, who from virtually nowhere secured an incredible 44 per cent of the poll. 
 Neil Kinnock advanced the extraordinarily lame and inaccurate excuse that it was always difficult for Oppositions in mid-term, but no one was really deceived. 
 Labour had done very badly, though we were in no position to gloat. 
 Our vote had collapsed to a paltry 7 per cent and the alliance of the centre now seemed capable of taking everything before it. 
 By this stage in the Parliament we were deeply unpopular and had allowed ourselves to be painted as a government forcing through doctrinaire policies. 
 Labour appeared intent upon returning to fundamental socialism with the shadow of Tony Benn hovering over the whole party. 
 The political ground could not have been better for a new middle party and many, including myself, thought that they could well achieve the breakthrough they sought. 
 The political commentator Hugo Young identifies the nadir of our fortunes as the Cabinet meeting on Thursday 23 July 1981 which he describes as &bquo;perhaps the most memorable meeting of the Cabinet in the whole decade of the Thatcher Government&equo;. 
 It was unquestionably the worst Cabinet meeting that took place in our first period of office. 
 A major reason for that was the timing.  
 The oldest rule in the Westminster book is that you do not try to reach difficult decisions in the last week of July. 
 Ministers, Members of Parliament, civil servants are hot, tired and exhausted of argument. 
 They want to get away; they want to forget about politics; they want to reintroduce themselves to their families. 
 If that was the argument in a normal year, it came in spades in 1981. 
 Yet in spite of all this, a Treasury paper was circulated which sought further public spending cuts that would affect every government department. 
 Not surprisingly there was a collective explosion. 
 What would such a policy do for unemployment? 
 What would it do to improve morale inside the party? 
 Whenever these arguments showed signs of running out of steam, we turned to complain about the inadequacy of the supporting papers. 
 Geoffrey Howe wanted public spending economies. 
 Vast subsidies were going to uneconomic nationalized industries and local government was heavily overspending. 
 Far from reducing taxation, as we had been elected to do, we would have to raise it &mdash; and raise it at a time when local councils were already pushing up rates. 
 But there was an additional argument. 
 If the market took the view that the Government's determination to control public spending was weakening, then we would see the pound fall and inflation increase. 
 To have had more public spending rather than less would have been disastrous. 
 Higher taxes and higher inflation would have been a lethal combination both for the country and the Government, given that there was no prospect of improvements in employment either. 
 The real lesson of the 23 July Cabinet meeting was that, in spite of all the doubts expressed, Margaret Thatcher and Geoffrey Howe stood firm and gave not an inch. 
 The partnership between the two was never a comfortable one &mdash; as personalities they were chalk and cheese &mdash; but politically it was immensely successful and entirely crucial to the Government up to 1983. 
 Looking back at that period, the crucial difference in Conservative politicians was between those who thought that the last twenty or thirty years had not been too bad, and who were sceptical that anything better could be achieved, and those who hoped that something better could be won and saw the last quarter of a century as a slow but steady decline. 
 Positions, of course, are never as black and white as that &mdash; consolidators have radical streaks; sensible  reformers know when to consolidate. 
 My own feeling in 1981 was that we should try to achieve something better and that just muddling through was not enough. 
 You only had to go abroad to see how we were regarded. 
 I remembered my five-week trip in 1976 to the United States. 
 The Americans were friendly and polite, but there was no mistaking their view that Britain had gone downhill to the point that we had become an irrelevance. 
 The position had improved slightly since then but there was a massive distance still to travel. 
 There were points of Government policy where I disagreed with the official line. 
 I thought that private investment could have been used more imaginatively in the period of the 1980&ndash;1 recession and was not satisfied with the Treasury's replies. 
 I also thought that our style did not try hard enough to persuade or unite. 
 I have never believed that consensus is to be spurned. 
 Fudge is to be spurned, but consensus can be a good goal. 
 I have always wanted my policies to last. 
 There is no point in making changes if the next government that comes in simply overturns them. 
 Above all, however, I wanted to see change and recovery. 
 My stay in Government had not made me less radical but more so. 
 If agreement cannot be reached, then decisions still need to be taken. 
 No one looking back on 1981 would claim that there was consensus on the correct economic policy either in the Conservative Party or outside. 
 No fewer than 364 economists signed a statement calling for a change of policy and traditional reflation. 
 Their advice was ignored and the tough decisions taken in 1981 were to lead to the much praised Budget of the next year and, even more, to the economic recovery which took us through both the 1983 and 1987 general elections. 
 It was also during 1981 that Margaret Thatcher really showed her style of leadership. 
 It was decisive and at times attracted public support because she seemed to be taking action which the public overwhelmingly thought was right but never thought any government would have the nerve to carry out. 
 In May the SAS were sent in to storm the Iranian Embassy in London which had been taken over by armed gunmen. 
 The following night, I was speaking at a transport dinner in London and found myself sitting two or three down from a general. 
 Before I rose to speak, I was asked by the chairman to express to the general their admiration for the  SAS's action. 
 The reaction from the audience almost took the roof off Grosvenor House. 
 Similarly, Margaret Thatcher's reaction to the Brixton and Toxteth riots captured the public mood far more than the analysis of the Opposition. 
 The first priority was to restore order and she made it plain that she backed the police unequivocally in doing so. 
 The time for examination was after order had been restored and, rightly, she rejected the simplistic connection between high unemployment and rioting. 
 Rightly, because there was no easy link to be made and only a few years previously the best criminologists were explaining the increase in crime as an inevitable consequence of prosperity. 
 Crime rose in line with the golden curve of affluence. 
 At the same time, other features of her style of leadership were becoming clear. 
 None was more evident than her grasp of all the issues of Government as she answered questions twice a week in the House of Commons. 
 It is one of the requirements of any British Prime Minister that every Tuesday and Thursday between 3.15 and 3.30 p.m. he or she should appear at the dispatch box and answer questions from MPs on any subject. 
 No Prime Minister has enjoyed this twice-weekly brains trust &mdash; and Margaret Thatcher was no exception &mdash; but few Prime Ministers did it as well or as consistently. 
 The secret of her approach was care in preparation, and woe betide the department that sent her into battle badly briefed or not briefed at all. 
 This happened once in my early months at the Department of Health and Social Security. 
 During negotiations on public spending with the then Chief Secretary, Leon Brittan, I had agreed to change the way of assessing Housing Benefit. 
 My Minister of State, Hugh Rossi, had announced the change during discussion of a social security bill in standing committee on Tuesday morning change is still unjustly called &bquo;the Rossi Index&equo; &mdash; and the Opposition had protested strongly. 
 At Prime Minister's Questions in the afternoon Margaret Thatcher was challenged by a Labour MP, Jeff Rooker, on the change and although she managed to deflect the question it was clear she had not been briefed. 
 It was entirely our responsibility and that evening to well past midnight Leon and I took her through the changes until she was satisfied that she knew the policy thoroughly. 
 We only broke for the night  on the promise of a further meeting next day together with social security officials. 
 By the next Prime Minister's Questions on Thursday she knew the policy rather better than we did. 
 The feature that came through most clearly, however, even in those early days of government, was Margaret Thatcher's stamina. 
 Even in the worst hours she never gave any public impression that she was on the ropes. 
 At the centre of her life was her family. 
 I remember a few months after my daughter Kate was born in 1981 receiving a call from Number 10. 
 Some problem had blown up and the Prime Minister wanted to see me. 
 It was a Friday evening and untypically I was in London &mdash; and even more untypically I was baby-sitting. 
 My private office helped out on the baby-sitting very effectively but I am sure quite improperly. 
 Eventually I arrived at Number 10 about an hour late. 
 &bquo;Don't worry,&equo; said Margaret, &bquo;when all this is over the only thing that matters is your family.&equo; 
 Those words uttered by some political leaders would sound banal and from one or two others downright phoney. 
 For Margaret Thatcher they were a simple statement of her position. 
 In the glimpses I had of her personal life, one feature always came through. 
 This was the support and affection given to Margaret by her family. 
 Carol and Mark were ever loyal and proud of their mother, while Denis had a role which would have dismayed a weaker man. 
 He was the husband of the first woman Prime Minister, but he will go down in history as a wise adviser and a kind man. 
 Her family gave Margaret Thatcher a security which had an immeasurable impact upon her success and the success of her Governments. 
 On top of the intellectual stamina there was a physical stamina too. 
 July 1981 was by any standards a trying and testing month. 
 In the middle of the month George Thomas, the Speaker, brought all the Cabinet together for dinner. 
 Margaret Thatcher had been up early that morning &mdash; early even by her standards &mdash; to visit Liverpool. 
 She had had a gruelling day on top of a gruelling six months. 
 By rights she should have been exhausted, but not a bit of it. 
 It was only a vote in the Commons at 11 p.m. that brought the evening to an end and then she returned to Downing Street for a few hours' work on her boxes before turning in. 
 In over ten years in her Government, I never heard a complaint that any paper  was held up at Downing Street because the Prime Minister had been too pressed with work to get round to it. 
 July eventually ground to an end and the steam was taken out of that difficult month by an event which had nothing to do with politics. 
 It was the wedding of Prince Charles and Lady Diana Spencer at St Paul's on the last Wednesday. 
 There were memorable pictures: the beautiful Princess with her long train carried by the small page-boys; the debonair Prince; the members of royal families from all over Europe; the world's leaders and statesmen; the small but immaculate figure of Nancy Reagan. 
 Yet by far the most moving part of the whole day was the reaction of the crowds which lined the streets. 
 Fiona and I set off from Fulham in our car at about 9 a.m. 
 By the time we got to Trafalgar Square the crowds were thick on the pavements and cheering anything that moved. 
 You only had to wave to get a reaction. 
 The crowd were good-humoured, enthusiastic and often young. 
 Their spirit stretched right into the Cathedral. 
 Around St Paul's large television screens had been erected. 
 The result was that every crucial move made inside the Cathedral by the bride and groom &mdash; like the placing of the ring on the Princess's finger &mdash; was followed a second or two later by the most enormous cheer from outside. 
 As Parliament went into its long summer recess, it was quite clear that Margaret Thatcher was going to reshuffle the Cabinet and the betting was that the shuffle would be a major one. 
 She felt that the appearance of a divided Cabinet was disastrous politics. 
 And frankly it was. 
 You cannot expect public support if you do not have the support of your own ministers. 
 The assumption was that she would bring in a number of new people whose loyalty she could count on. 
 One night in late July I was taken out to supper by Ian Gow, the Prime Minister's Parliamentary Private Secretary. 
 Ian was later murdered by a terrorist bomb but nothing can destroy the memory of a unique politician and man. 
 He had principle, determination and humour. 
 If you ever asked Ian to keep a debate going in committee (while the front bench caught up) he would do so to order and with a style 1 have never seen equalled. 
 It was altogether typical of him that his unshakeable beliefs should prevent him continuing to serve in the Government once the Anglo-Irish agreement was signed. 
 Personal position would not have entered  into his calculations. 
 Our supper in July 1981, however, was all about the personal positions of other people. 
 I was asked my views on the reshuffle. 
 I was also asked my views on the chairmanship of the party. 
 Peter Thorneycroft had been a notably successful chairman but was now seventy-two. 
 What did I think of the prospect of an up-and-coming Minister of State called Norman Tebbit taking over the job? 
 What about Cecil Parkinson? 
 Had I ever considered the prospect myself? 
 Ian went away, pondering on my replies &mdash; but one thing was certain: major changes were in prospect. 
 In early September I went to the wedding of Geoffrey Howe's daughter, Amanda. 
 Another guest that day was Patrick Jenkin, the Social Services Secretary. 
 As we talked at the reception in the garden behind Downing Street, Patrick told me that, instead of a debate at the Party Conference next month, he and his ministerial team had been asked to answer questions from the floor. 
 Unkindly, I laughed and told him that that sounded just about the worst idea I had heard for a very long time. 
 The hall at Blackpool is ideally suited to rousing speeches but is totally wrong as the setting for a question-and-answer session &mdash; which proved to be just as appalling as I had feared. 
 A week later I was called back to Downing Street by Margaret Thatcher and told that I was taking over the Department of Health and Social Security and also the question-and-answer session. 
 The Cabinet changes of September 1981 were as extensive as any made in the Thatcher years of Government. 
 Norman Tebbit was made Employment Secretary and Nigel Lawson came in as Energy Secretary. 
 Cecil Parkinson took over as Chairman of the Conservative Party in what proved to be an inspired appointment. 
 Mark Carlisle, Christopher Soames and Ian Gilmour left the Cabinet and Jim Prior went to the one job which no politician can refuse, Northern Ireland Secretary. 
 As he left Number 10, Ian Gilmour sourly summed up the changes by saying they were &bquo;not much good if you are steering full-speed ahead for the rocks&equo;. 
 He left unexplained why, if that was his view, he had not gone under his own steam somewhat earlier. 
 As for myself, I was back where I had begun in Opposition. 
 Margaret Thatcher had kept her word given over five years before that I would not lose out by my enforced move to Transport and I was now in charge of the biggest  spender and largest employer in Whitehall. 
 Created in 1968 to give Dick Crossman a new and senior job, the Department of Health and Social Security was responsible for over 40 per cent of all public spending. 
 It employed almost 100,000 staff directly, mainly in our social security offices, and was responsible for the National Health Service &mdash; which with almost a million staff was the largest employer in Europe. 
 Slowly, very slowly, our political position began to improve, but then came the event which was to transform the Government's public standing. 
 On Thursday 1 April 1982, my day started early at the Cabinet Office, just round the corner from Downing Street in Whitehall. 
 A meeting of the Public Sector Pay Committee had been called for 8.45 a.m. &mdash; a sure sign that it had been called by Geoffrey Howe who was consistently the earliest ministerial starter. 
 There was much hilarity when Geoffrey steamed in ten minutes late pleading a mix-up in his diary. 
 At the meeting I reported on the position of the gathering health service dispute and we then looked at a number of other pay issues. 
 The Cabinet committee over, we went through the connecting doors to Number 10 itself and a meeting of the full Cabinet. 
 The main item on the agenda was future policy in Ulster but it soon became clear that another issue had become dominant. 
 The Foreign Secretary, Peter Carrington, reported that the Argentinian fleet was steaming towards the Falkland Islands. 
 Until then, the Falklands had been the concern of the Overseas and Defence Committee and had not featured strongly in discussions in full Cabinet. 
 There had been the curious tale of the Argentinian scrap metal merchants who had landed on the island of South Georgia, where the United Kingdom had exercised sovereignty since it was discovered by Captain Cook in I775. 
 The story was that the party had landed to remove scrap metal from a former whaling station but their action seemed eccentric rather than threatening. 
 It was now clear, however, that the position was becoming deadly serious. 
 The next morning a telephone call came through from Number 10 just before 8.30 a.m. calling a special Cabinet meeting at 9.45 to discuss the Falklands. 
 Caught by surprise, we used whatever means of transport were available. 
 I arrived in the family Metro; Quintin Hailsham by bicycle. 
 Outside Number 10 itself there was  a solitary television camera crew. 
 Inside most of the Cabinet had made it, even though it was a Friday and the day most members made for their constituencies. 
 Only Peter Walker, George Younger and Leon Brittan were absent. 
 We were brought up to date &mdash; or as up to date as it was possible to be. 
 We were told that not only had the Argentinian fleet continued on their route to the Falklands but there was now every reason to believe that Argentinian troops had landed. 
 This was not confirmed by Port Stanley for the good reason that we were no longer in contact with Port Stanley. 
 Humphrey Atkins, who was in effect deputy Foreign Secretary and the chief Foreign Office spokesman in the Commons, was to make a statement at 11 a.m. 
 The question was what should he say? 
 Clearly he would have to tell Parliament as much as was known. 
 When Humphrey Atkins made his statement it was listened to with concern but the response was subdued. 
 The whole proceedings lasted only twenty-three minutes and assurances were given that the House would be kept informed. 
 During the late afternoon I received another call summoning a further Cabinet meeting at 7.30 p.m. 
 It was here that we received confirmation that Argentinian troops had landed and had occupied Port Stanley. 
 The question now was whether a military task force should set sail. 
 It was estimated that it would take them two to three weeks to get to the Falklands and therefore, theoretically, the decision could be rescinded if there were some kind of diplomatic breakthrough. 
 Personally I thought this highly unlikely. 
 Once the task force had been committed, only the withdrawal of the Argentinian troops would justify them carrying out some gigantic U-turn in the middle of the South Atlantic. 
 I confess my fears were elsewhere. 
 My thoughts went back to 1956 and Suez when the shambles of lengthy invasion and precipitate withdrawal had destroyed Anthony Eden's whole political career. 
 That was the kind of crisis the Government and in particular Margaret Thatcher now laced. 
 I thought we had no option but to send the task force. 
 The public at home would have been rightly outraged had we not taken this action, while the lessons that would have been drawn by other countries overseas were incalculable. 
 It was decided that Margaret Thatcher would announce the dispatch of the task force next morning in the House of Commons in a special Saturday morning  debate. 
 As we left Number 10 that evening, Downing Street had become thick with reporters and cameramen. 
 I left with Quintin Hailsham. 
 A brave reporter thrust a microphone under his nose and asked him for his comments. 
 &bquo;I wish you a very good evening,, replied Quintin. 
 The Saturday morning debate on 3 April was the first Saturday debate since Suez and was dreadful in every way. 
 The morning's press without exception had attacked us strongly. 
 Everyone had been caught unawares. 
 There had been no sense of impending crisis and few newspapers were seriously featuring the Falklands situation prior to the invasion. 
 The public mood was one of anger and frustration and that mood was fully reflected in the House of Commons. 
 Margaret Thatcher rose to half-hearted shouts of &bquo;resign&equo; from the Labour benches. 
 Her speech went as well as was possible, given that it was being made on the stickiest of sticky Parliamentary wickets. 
 She was followed by Michael Foot who made a strong attack on the Government and ended with the devastating charge that the Falkland Islanders had been betrayed and &bquo;the whole responsibility for the betrayal rests with the Government&equo;. 
 From that point on the debate went from bad to worse. 
 We were lambasted by a bellicose Labour Party and an impressive SDP in the shape of David Owen. 
 But worst of all we were attacked by our own side. 
 Edward du Cann, Nigel Fisher and Patrick Cormack were just three who inserted the knife. 
 Enoch Powell, who although no longer a Tory MP was closely listened to on the Conservative side, recalled that Margaret Thatcher had been called the &bquo;Iron Lady&equo; and rather liked the description. 
 He added: &bquo;In the next week or two this House, the nation and the Right Honourable Lady herself will learn of what metal she is made.&equo; 
 The one defender of the Government position, Ray Whitney, a former Foreign Office diplomat, was virtually shouted down. 
 But the House reserved its worst treatment for the Defence Secretary, John Nott. 
 Something had gone wrong and the House wanted blood. 
 John Nott was not the Foreign Secretary, and therefore not responsible for reading the international scene, but he was the next best thing. 
 He was one of the most accomplished debaters in the Government but nothing would have saved him from the mauling. 
 He made his speech &mdash; or rather sought to make it &mdash; against a barrage of noise and calls to resign from the Opposition  and was listened to in stony silence by the Government benches. 
 It is one of the unappetizing features of politics that often when things go wrong a minister can find himself entirely isolated and without friends. 
 One Cabinet colleague surveying the scene murmured to me: &bquo;There is no way that I am going to grow old in the service of this House.&equo; 
 Suddenly, amid the noise, the Speaker brought the proceedings to a close. 
 There was no vote and the House of Commons stood adjourned. 
 The agony of the debate was over &mdash; although both John Nott and Peter Carrington next had to appear in a committee room upstairs in front of an unhappy party meeting. 
 At the end of the Saturday debate we were in more disarray than at any stage since either coming to power or Margaret Thatcher taking over the leadership. 
 The weekend press was again appalling. 
 The call for resignations continued both from newspapers and politicians, including Conservative ones. 
 On the Monday I tried to settle down to a meeting at Alexander Fleming House (the DHSS's headquarters at the Elephant and Castle) with Tony Newton who had joined the department as Parliamentary Secretary for Social Security. 
 Tony and I embarked on a consideration of Child Benefit but before many minutes had gone by a note was sent in informing us that Peter Carrington had resigned. 
 After a pause we continued, but in a few more minutes another note came through saying that further resignations were expected. 
 At that point I abandoned the meeting and tried to find out what was happening. 
 It transpired that Peter Carrington and his Foreign Office team of Humphrey Atkins and Richard Luce had all resigned, and a little later it was announced that Francis Pym was to take over as Foreign Secretary. 
 My first reaction to the resignations was that they were tantamount to an admission of guilt when, in fact, the Argentinians could have attacked at any time in the previous fifteen years. 
 Peter Carrington was a major loss, and although I admired the loyalty of Humphrey Atkins and Richard Luce I thought their resignations unnecessary. 
 I was wrong. 
 The resignations defused an extremely difficult political situation. 
 All attention could now be given to negotiation and to preparing for war rather than continuing the sterile debate on how it had all come about. 
 The change of mood was clear for everyone to see. 
 The same  House which had torn into John Nott on the Saturday listened attentively to Francis Pym the following Wednesday. 
 Francis spoke with force and authority and was able to make his speech entirely without interruption. 
 As he ended, there was an enormous cheer on our side and I saw one of our backbenchers who had been particularly critical over the weekend waving his order paper in enthusiastic support. 
 The wind-up speech for the Government was made by John Nott. 
 In thirty minutes he substantially re-established his parliamentary position and announced a 200-mile naval exclusion zone around the Falklands. 
 The immediate political crisis had been averted, but there was still a long, long way to go before we could claim victory. 
 Margaret Thatcher formed a small War Cabinet. 
 It would have been impossible for the Falklands War to be prosecuted successfully with every decision coming to the full Cabinet of twenty-three members, a state of affairs that would have taken every other item off the agenda. 
 Both diplomatically and militarily, it was necessary for the Government to respond speedily. 
 Over the next weeks Alexander Haig, the American Secretary of State, shuttled to and fro seeking compromise. 
 Yet all the signs were that this was going to be a fruitless exercise. 
 In Argentina there appeared to be no one with whom Haig could reach agreement, for behind General Galtieri there was an array of powerful army, navy and air force chiefs. 
 It was in any event difficult to see what compromise could satisfy both Buenos Aires and London. 
 The only question was how long the talking could continue. 
 By the last week of April the task force was nearing the Falklands. 
 The issue now was whether it should attempt to retake South Georgia. 
 There were those who argued that such action would alienate world opinion and sabotage the chances of a diplomatic solution. 
 That view was rejected and after a reconnaissance British forces took the island. 
 Asked for her reaction, Margaret Thatcher gave vent to her feelings about the operation and also, I suspect, about what she saw as ever critical broadcasters who always found something to carp about even after an undoubted success. 
 &bquo;Rejoice,&equo; she said, &bquo;just rejoice.&equo; 
 Again she was nearer the mass of public opinion than the trendy commentators who criticized this old-fashioned way of expressing things. 
 It has to be remembered just how perilous and unprecedented the operation  was. 
 In 1956 the British forces had appeared to take an unconscionable time to get from Cyprus to Port Said. 
 Here was a task force rapidly put together, travelling almost 7,000 miles and successfully taking an island without a casualty. 
 Elation, however, was short lived. 
 On 4 May the news came through that the General Belgrano had been sunk with over 350 Argentine sailors killed. 
 There was no question that the Government's first duty was to preserve the safety of the task force but the loss of life cast an enormous shadow. 
 It had now been demonstrated beyond any doubt that this was real war and that any prospect of retaking the Falklands as an uninterrupted triumphal procession was illusory. 
 This impression was tragically confirmed a few hours later when news came through that HMS Sheffield had been sunk. 
 From then until the final Argentine surrender the story was one of the skill and bravery of the British forces. 
 The San Carlos landing, the Battle of Goose Green and the final taking of Port Stanley have all entered the history books. 
 In purely military terms it was an amazing success reflecting great credit on Britain's small but all-professional armed forces &mdash; which were such a contrast to the much bigger conscript forces I remembered from the 1950s. 
 It was also an undoubted personal and political triumph for Margaret Thatcher. 
 Those who deny that have only to ask themselves who would have taken the responsibility had we failed. 
 She would have been held personally responsible and would almost certainly have fallen from office. 
 The stakes were that high; the pressure on her was that great. 
 The Falklands crisis tested her as few leaders in recent times have been tested. 
 Her success marked an important and dramatic political turning-point for the Government. 
 The conflict also showed features of her approach and style which were later to become familiar. 
 She was a good leader to go to war with. 
 She was decisive and she did not vacillate, and once committed she intended to win. 
 She distrusted the offer of talks which had no other purpose than to string out negotiation. 
 That was her style in the Falklands and it remained her style in a number of the confrontations that she faced over the next years. 
 I believe it is a hundred times better to have a leader who wants to go forward rather than one who retreats towards the hills when the going gets rough. 
 The Falklands established Margaret  Thatcher as a leader of courage. 
 That was clear from the outset, but what was perhaps not so clear was how professional a leader she had become, able to manage not only the immediate crisis but all the other issues of Government. 
 A few days after the Argentinian surrender, I saw her for a meeting on health service pay. 
 I had put a point to the unions concerning long-term pay arrangements on which she had neither been informed nor consulted. 
 My view was that it was enough to clear it with the Chancellor of the Exchequer and that she had a war to fight. 
 After some spirited discussion Margaret agreed with the policy but pointed out with some feeling that she had been in the chair of every meeting of the Economic Committee throughout the Falklands crisis. 
 War or no war, the Government's other business had not come to a halt. 
 At moments of crisis a nation needs a leader able to lead in the way Margaret Thatcher led then. 
 In politics there are some very successful makers of deals and some very skilled negotiators. 
 Those are valuable qualities, but as Enoch Powell suggested a leader needs more than that. 
 The Falklands showed that Margaret Thatcher had the metal that leadership takes. 
 The Health Strike 
 I began 1982 with a series of visits to look at the issues which were facing the health service. 
 I went first to the Children's Hospital in Birmingham. 
 The hospital had been built as a memorial to King Edward VII and it had seen better days. 
 The wards were crowded and even in mid-winter very sick babies had to be wheeled out into the open air to get from one part of the hospital to another. 
 What really shocked me, however, was the sight of the babies in the intensive care unit. 
 They were all about the same age as my daughter Kate, and three were fighting for their lives. 
 They were the victims of whooping cough. 
 Too young to have been inoculated themselves, the babies had caught the disease from their older brothers and sisters who could have been inoculated but had not been. 
 Following newspaper and television coverage of the alleged dangers that went with inoculation, the vaccination rate had fallen sharply. 
 In spite of the best efforts of the health service, we had been unable to persuade the public that by far the bigger danger was of children not being inoculated. 
 The three little babies (one of whom later died) were the tragic proof of unsuccessful health promotion. 
 I went on to Birmingham's All Saints Hospital, which is cheek by jowl with Winston Green Prison. 
 There, many of the patients were old and suffering from dementia. 
 They sat in rows and watched television or simply stared into the distance. 
 One old lady sitting upright, prim and wearing round National Health Service glasses, became agitated as I approached her chair. 
 According to one of the staff, she believed that she was Queen Victoria and did not like anyone encroaching on the space around her throne. 
 All Saints showed one of the major problems that the health service will face over the next years. 
 With the increase in the number of the elderly, our demand for services and above all for devoted staff and volunteers will grow enormously. 
 The following week I went to Rampton Special Hospital which stands isolated in the countryside of north Nottinghamshire. 
 Rampton began life as a criminal lunatic asylum in 1912 and  today takes men and women who require treatment under special security conditions because of their dangerous, violent or criminal tendencies. 
 For the visitor, it is scarcely credible that staff can work day after day with such clearly difficult patients. 
 The noise, the abuse, the grimness are everyday parts of their working life. 
 Many of the nurses are the sons and daughters and even grandsons and granddaughters of Rampton staff. 
 Their role has changed from turnkey to nurse but many grew up with the expectation that Rampton would be their career. 
 An enclosed community guards and cares for an enclosed community and we the public gladly subcontract this duty, hoping that it will be carried out unseen and unheard. 
 What I saw on my visits in 1982 illustrated just some of the health problems we faced. 
 None of them was new. 
 Only a party bigot would claim that they had somehow come in with the Conservative Government three years earlier. 
 Every health minister faces the same central problem: it is not just a matter of putting right the deficiencies of the past; you also need to keep up with the ever-increasing demands of the present. 
 Demand is created by medical advance itself. 
 Hip replacements were once a rarity: now they can be carried out easily and the call for them has escalated. 
 Somehow you have to provide for these additional demands, and many more, within the annual budget voted each year to the service. 
 It would be nice to believe that the Health Secretary spends all his time understanding the very latest developments in heart-lung transplants. 
 Would that this was the case. 
 Faced with a virtual infinity of demand, your role is to seek new resources and ensure that those resources are spent to best effect. 
 You battle with the Treasury in public spending negotiations and you battle with the health service to make best use of the resources that are available. 
 The health service has genuinely noble ideals: it provides excellent treatment irrespective of income. 
 It also contains some of the most dedicated men and women I have ever met. 
 Yet for all that, health provides just about the bloodiest battleground in British politics today. 
 When I took over at the Department of Health and Social Security, I was under no illusion about the difficulty of my job. 
 Every one of my predecessors as Social Services Secretary &mdash; Dick  Crossman, Keith Joseph, Barbara Castle, David Ennals and Patrick Jenkin &mdash; had scars to show for their periods in that office. 
 And the scars of Labour ministers were just as plentiful as the ones on Tory backs. 
 I had watched Barbara Castle go through contortions as she made massive social security savings. 
 I had watched her successor, David Ennals, come under withering union fire for cutting back on the hospital building programme. 
 The central problem of the DHSS is that it is the biggest of the big spenders among government departments. 
 In any dispute about public spending, you are in the front line. 
 I faced an additional problem with the health service. 
 It is an undesirable tradition of the service that complaint provides extra cash and that any change proposed by Government is to be opposed. 
 The theory is that the only thing that has ever been wrong with the health service is a lack of resources. 
 If you demonstrate the need, the Government irrespective of party will be forced to pay up. 
 I do not entirely decry such tactics. 
 Sometimes it is necessary to campaign for more resources by pointing out deficiencies. 
 However, the shame is that for some health service insiders it has become a way of life. 
 They refuse to take credit for the undoubted achievements of the service and retreat into such self-evident absurdities as &bquo;the health service is on the verge of collapse&equo;. 
 But what I objected to most was the all too often blanket opposition to change. 
 Soon after I went to the department I introduced a policy of charging overseas patients for their medical care. 
 If I, a British citizen, fall ill in the United States I will have to pay for treatment. 
 It is important to be insured. 
 I wanted to ensure that foreign visitors who came to this country were also covered by insurance. 
 The policy caused great indignation in the health service. 
 Apparently it was all right to receive money from the Treasury in neat health authority allocations, but not for cheques or, worse still, cash to appear over the hospital counter. 
 Regrettably, this illogical and antediluvian attitude still persists even when we are dealing with nations substantially richer than ourselves. 
 I simply do not understand why Britain should provide a free international health service or why the health service should not benefit from outside contributions. 
 Too often, the health debate takes place amid generalized  allegations of &bquo;cuts&equo;. 
 In reality the argument is all about whether the government has increased the budget enough. 
 The claims that appear endlessly in newspaper columns are about whether the government has taken proper account of the expected increase in demand and costs. 
 Only at times of crisis does the debate turn to the real cause of cuts in patient care. 
 Over the last twenty years the starkest examples of operations cancelled, lives put at danger and waiting lists increased have been the result of industrial disputes. 
 Patients suffered in the Winter of Discontent in 1979. 
 They suffered in the 1989&ndash;90 ambulance dispute. 
 And they were certainly the principal victims of the health dispute of 1982, which proved to be Britain's longest industrial dispute for fifty years. 
 The 1982 dispute was my baptism of fire. 
 About 70 per cent of the costs of the health service are the costs of staff. 
 The health service is given a budget by the taxpayer which covers both the pay of staff and the services provided. 
 Unless some special addition is made, the result of an over-budget pay settlement is a limit on the expansion of new services. 
 The only way to avoid that would be for the Chancellor of the Exchequer to give the health service an open-ended budget. 
 No Chancellor of any party has ever done that in the past and no Chancellor is ever likely to do so in the future. 
 You cannot run any service on the basis that &bquo;it costs what it costs&equo;. 
 At the heart of the 1982 dispute was a so-called pay factor for public services of 4 per cent, which was intended as a marker for pay rises to those working in all public services. 
 I had inherited my position from Patrick Jenkin. 
 He would have preferred a special health-service pay factor, but had to settle for an above-average offer to the nurses, who most certainly were the priority group, having fallen badly behind over the previous ten years. 
 On 8 March 1982 we provided an extra &pound;82 million (mostly from the Government's contingency reserve) and made an offer to the nurses and some other professional groups of 6.4 per cent. 
 The offer made them a special case but by the same token was condemned by other groups such as the ancillary workers, who protested that they were offered only 4 per cent. 
 A popular health-service argument was that every one of the million or so staff should get exactly the same percentage increase in pay &mdash; as though the recruitment and retention position was the same for all.  
 Arrayed against me I had both the TUC-affiliated unions and the Royal College of Nursing, the professional organization representing the nurses. 
 With me I had the two Kens. 
 The first Ken was Ken Clarke whom I had managed to bring over from the Transport Department. 
 He illustrates the difficulty of trying to divide Conservative politicians into &bquo;wets&equo; and &bquo;dries&equo;. 
 Many of his views categorize him as a wet &mdash; a European enthusiast; against capital punishment; and in favour of sensible abortion laws. 
 But just as clearly he is a tough politician who speaks his mind sometimes in a blunt way. 
 Once or twice we put these qualities to good use. 
 An aggressive visiting delegation would be dusted down by Ken in his best James Cagney style, leaving me looking untypically reasonable and friendly in bringing the meeting to a conclusion. 
 Ken Clarke is an exceptional man to have with you in a battle. 
 He will not compromise to get an agreement he does not believe is justified and is not the least put out by demonstrations. 
 In 1982 all these qualities looked as though they were going to be urgently required. 
 The second Ken was my Permanent Secretary, Sir Kenneth Stowe. 
 In background he was very similar to my generation of politicians, although about ten years older. 
 His school was the County High School at Dagenham and from there he had won a scholarship to Oxford. 
 He came down with a First and started his civil service career in the humble surroundings of the National Assistance Board. 
 His ability took him rapidly up the social security tree and to Number 10 as Jim Callaghan's Principal Private Secretary. 
 Downing Street is a sure stepping-stone to becoming head of a department but the price that has to be paid is as exacting a life-style as can be found in Whitehall. 
 With the new Conservative Government in 1979, Ken Stowe moved from Downing Street to become Permanent Secretary in the Northern Ireland Office &mdash; not exactly a rest cure &mdash; and in 1981 came back to the DHSS. 
 He arrived a few weeks before me at the Elephant and retired just a few weeks before I left the department after the 1987 general election. 
 For year after year he worked all hours serving different governments and different ministers. 
 Like so many Permanent Secretaries, Ken was a substantial politician in his own right and knew every byway of Whitehall, in particular how to process decisions through the government machine. 
 In short, he epitomized  the tremendous qualities of the British civil service &mdash; undoubted ability coupled with unstinting hard work and independent judgement. 
 There are not many precedents for the same Secretary of State and the same Permanent Secretary serving together for the best part of six years. 
 In the transient world of politics and government such stability is exceptional, although in the world of business no one would consider unusual such partnerships between a chairman and chief executive. 
 Since 1979 the other Cabinet ministers (Margaret Thatcher excepted) who have exceeded five years in one department are Nicholas Edwards, the Secretary of State for Wales between 1979 and 1987; George Younger, as Scottish Secretary; Nigel Lawson, as Chancellor of the Exchequer; and Geoffrey Howe, as Foreign Secretary. 
 Under Labour, the best example is Denis Healey who was Secretary of State for Defence from 1964 to 1970 and then Chancellor of the Exchequer from 1974 to 1979. 
 But we were very much the exceptions. 
 Government would benefit if, barring accidents, Secretaries of State remained with their departments for longer. 
 The first months of the health dispute of 1982 coincided with the Falklands War, but when the war ended public attention returned to it. 
 During hostilities, the health unions had called three one-day strikes. 
 They had also instituted a ban on anything other than accident and emergency operations. 
 In the hospitals, the action was beginning to bite. 
 Waiting lists started to lengthen as operations were cancelled. 
 The dispute had also moved against us in another way. 
 During the spring the recommendations of the Top Salaries Review Board and the Doctors and Dentists Review Body came to the Prime Minister. 
 They had proposed astonishing increases of 24.3 per cent for the judiciary and 19.4 per cent for senior civil servants. 
 A 9 per cent increase was proposed for doctors and dentists. 
 The review bodies are independent but Government has the option of modifying their recommendations. 
 I believed we should do just that. 
 With help from Norman Tebbit, then Employment Secretary, I managed to get the awards reduced &mdash; but not by enough. 
 The judges still got 18.6 per cent and top civil servants averaged 14.3 per cent. 
 I did, however, manage to get the doctors and dentists award down to 6 per cent. 
 But the total package of  reductions convinced neither the public nor the unions. 
 As we debated the awards in Government, various colleagues told me that my arguments for reductions were &bquo;egalitarian&equo; and that the pay increase for judges would in no way influence the expectations of the nurses and the ancillary workers. 
 The underlying fear was that if we accepted any connection we would be back to the world of incomes policy. 
 I did not want that, but I believed that the top salary awards were so out of line with what we were proposing in the rest of the public sector that in the real world of industrial relations it made my job infinitely more difficult. 
 And so it proved. 
 The judges' pay increase was hung round the Government's neck like a heavy stone. 
 The health unions and the nurses could see that others were doing better, and in addition to the top salaries group the miners and the firemen were settling appreciably above the public sector guideline of 4 per cent. 
 Whatever the position three months earlier, our original offer to the health service could no longer stand. 
 On 22 June we made a revised offer of 7.5 per cent for the nurses and 6 per cent for the ancillaries and administrative staff. 
 The Royal College of Nursing agreed to recommend it to their members, but the health unions rejected it outright. 
 The dispute began to intensify. 
 The unions stepped up their industrial action and the waiting lists lengthened further. 
 By the end of July we estimated that the industrial action had added 65,000 patients to the waiting lists in English hospitals alone. 
 In addition 60,000 operations had been cancelled or postponed and 75,000 outpatient appointments had been cancelled. 
 There tends to be a Vietnam War factor about health strikes. 
 During the Vietnam War the public became hardened and accustomed to the horrific scenes on television. 
 In the health service the initial shock that patients can be denied treatment fades as the public becomes used to the fact that they are. 
 Yet the impact of such action should never be underestimated. 
 During July I went to St Thomas's Hospital in Lambeth. 
 A strike of about twenty-five staff in the sterile supplies stores had dramatically reduced activity, which was already hampered by the union policy of refusing admission to any but emergency cases. 
 About 1,000 operations had been postponed and even cancer patients were being delayed. 
 A picket at the hospital claimed that &bquo;emergency&equo; services were being  maintained. 
 They doubtless were, but &bquo;urgent&equo; cases were being turned away. 
 August was even worse than July. 
 As the dispute hardened, demonstrations became everyday affairs. 
 Whenever I drove to a hospital my question would not be whether there was a demonstration but how big. 
 There were demonstrations at Hammersmith; at Rugby where the most vociferous health worker turned out to be a school caretaker; at Bristol; and at Exeter where the demonstrators appeared to have gathered beforehand in the nearby public house. 
 Throughout the dispute my technique was to go through the front door &mdash; I refused to be smuggled in &mdash; and then ask for a deputation of the demonstrators to come and talk to me. 
 Usually that defused the demonstration and the visit could go ahead uninterrupted. 
 Sometimes the police, however, had other ideas. 
 At Cambridge, NUPE put a picket around the Union building where I was taking part in a debate and the police wanted to take me in by a side entrance. 
 When I protested, they assured me that there would be no question of hiding me from the crowd. 
 A week or two before they had got into trouble when Norman Tebbit had come to Cambridge and in the words of one of the policemen they had not &bquo;shown him&equo; to the demonstrators. 
 They showed me quite successfully but the eggs and tomatoes missed. 
 Sometimes avoiding action did have to be taken. 
 On one occasion I went to a hospital in south London to what the police reckoned would be a very rough demonstration. 
 With a touching faith in our law-abiding qualities the demonstrators had gathered in large numbers with their eggs and tomatoes around the hospital entrance marked IN. 
 Twenty yards down the road, however, there was an exit marked OUT through which we rapidly drove, successfully avoiding the missiles. 
 By the time I got to the Party Conference in October, I was under police guard. 
 One Special Branch man said to me: &bquo;There is only one other minister who has two police guards and that is Mr Tebbit &mdash; but we're armed and they're not.&equo; 
 As Frank Johnson commented in The Times, my appearance on the short walk between the Grand Hotel and the conference centre provoked uproar from the watching demonstrators. 
 &bquo;An ordinary hardworking citizen living quietly in the Cabinet&equo; had become &bquo;an object of hatred&equo;.  
 You cannot entirely make light of such demonstrations. 
 One day, I fear that a demonstration of the kind I faced in 1982 will go wrong and someone will get hurt. 
 There are people out there who will use any excuse to cause trouble. 
 I learned that when I went to a conference at Sheffield. 
 As I left the railway station, the police warned me that there was a small demonstration against Norman Tebbit's recent industrial relations reforms. 
 That was the plan, but the morning's press was full of extravagant reports of the &bquo;cuts&equo; I intended to make in health service manpower. 
 &bquo;Fowler&equo; was inserted for &bquo;Tebbit&equo; on the placards and the demonstration went ahead with a degree of intimidation that made the front page of every national newspaper the next day. 
 It was not just street demonstrators who were assembled against us. 
 The nastiest little attack we endured at this time came from, of all papers, the Lancet. 
 An editorial alleged that the Government would welcome headlines saying that a patient had died because it would swing public opinion against the unions. 
 It is a curiosity of medical politics that any charge, however gross, can be made against you. 
 Unfortunately, not all health professionals take the objective standards of their medical training into their public and political comment. 
 During August I agreed to be interviewed by World in Action in Manchester. 
 The format of the interview was that I was in a single chair placed to the side of a panel of six sitting in two rows. 
 It was a classic Perry Mason prisoner-and-jury setting. 
 In the jury were such well-known &bquo;independent&equo; commentators as Rodney Bickerstaffe of NUPE, a Regional Health Authority Chairman I had just replaced, a nurses' negotiator, a consultant who wanted more money for his hospital and an ancillary health worker. 
 You will be amazed to know that these six good men and true found me guilty, although without the uproar that the producers had rather hoped for. 
 Travelling back to London by train after the programme, I found that Rodney Bickerstaffe was a fellow passenger. 
 We talked quietly together for half an hour but there was no point of contact. 
 Bickerstaffe had taken over as General Secretary of NUPE from Alan Fisher who had been instrumental in the Winter of Discontent. 
 He was determined to win where Fisher had failed and his members came first. 
 I saw no prospect of any sensible compromise.  
 In mid-August I made the great mistake of seeking a four-day break from London to stay with friends in France. 
 That was roundly attacked in the press and particularly the health press, even though I left Ken Clarke in charge. 
 After my four days Ken was to set off on his own curtailed family holiday. 
 As he flew out, I flew in. 
 We changed over at Bordeaux airport. 
 When we met in the lounge it rapidly became clear that he was not in his usual good humour. 
 It transpired that the previous day he had been in Liverpool and given an interview to the Daily Telegraph which had been interpreted to mean that we were about to call in the troops. 
 At the same time the press had been tipped off that the Health Minister was leaving the country on holiday from Heathrow and half a dozen photographers had literally chased on to the runway to photograph him. 
 They were only prevented from boarding the plane when the aircraft's captain refused them permission. 
 Not surprisingly, Ken was apprehensive about the position I might inherit when I touched down. 
 Indeed the next hours after my return were spent explaining that we had no plans to use either troops or tanks and justifying what a BBC interviewer referred to as my &bquo;controversial&equo; four-day summer holiday. 
 Ironically, a few years later Ken Clarke came under attack on the same issue. 
 I have never been able to understand this preoccupation with ministerial holidays. 
 During the month of August ministers cover for other ministers. 
 No one thinks twice if a minister retires to the country because his department can blandly assure all callers that the minister is &bquo;working from home&equo;. 
 But woe betide any minister who does not possess a country seat and sets off across the Channel to &bquo;abroad&equo;. 
 Even though air travel means that he can be rapidly recalled in an emergency, he is likely to be pilloried for dereliction of duty. 
 The press scour whole countries for a sighting of the relaxing politician, and friends who might know where he is are propositioned with both money and arguments such as &bquo;I am sure you will agree that it would be better for us to find him before the Daily Mirror&equo;. 
 There is no advantage in being governed by a collection of exhausted ministers doggedly sitting at their desks making bad decisions. 
 At the end of August, we suffered a major setback when the members of the Royal College of Nursing voted to reject our 7.5 per cent offer, despite their negotiators having initially accepted it.  
 The health unions were given the excuse to call a general one-day strike or &bquo;national day of action&equo; for 22 September. 
 At the Elephant and Castle we looked yet again for a means of bringing the dispute to an end. 
 We had tried talking across the negotiating table and we had tried talking through the medium of Pat Lowry, the Chairman of ACAS. 
 There was only one option left and that was for me to talk directly to Albert Spanswick, the Chairman of the TUC Health Services Committee. 
 Albert Spanswick came from the old school of trade union leaders and I found him a more persuasive advocate for health service workers than Rodney Bickerstaffe. 
 Industrial relations had not been good in the health service for many years and not all of that was the fault of the unions. 
 Managers (where they existed) did too little to involve the workforce and there were often great &bquo;them and us&equo; divisions between the medical staff and the rest. 
 In one demonstration my car was stopped at a hospital entrance but it soon became clear that much of the resentment was directed at what were seen as remote hospital authorities &bquo;up there,. 
 My approach to Albert Spanswick led to a secret meeting at my house in Fulham just before the TUC Conference in September 1982. 
 The meeting was friendly and Albert went off to Brighton where he roundly denounced me and all my works &mdash; without revealing that he was without his customary hat which he had forgotten and was hanging safely on a hook in my hall. 
 The TUC Conference over, we had two further meetings at my home at which Albert agreed that a new two-year deal would be enough to get negotiations going again. 
 I then had dinner with Trevor Clay, who had taken over at the Royal College of Nursing, and he also agreed that such an offer would be enough to bring them back into negotiation. 
 The plan was that I would invite both the unions and the Royal College to the department on Thursday 16 September. 
 On the Thursday morning letters were sent inviting both the TUC and the Royal College in for talks. 
 Trevor Clay immediately accepted but there was silence from the TUC. 
 Eventually, just before 2 p.m., a small delegation arrived at the Elephant and Castle seeking clarification of what would be on offer. 
 Albert as chairman asked me a number of questions to which he already knew the  answers for the good reason that we had already gone over them in Fulham. 
 The delegation left and we continued waiting until 6 p.m. when the news came through that the TUC were holding a press conference. 
 They announced they were not even prepared to come in and talk. 
 In the interviews afterwards I lost my temper for, I think, the first and last time in the dispute. 
 It was clear that Albert had been overruled by his committee who had no intention of being deflected from the TUC's forthcoming national day of action. 
 The day of action on 22 September brought about 60,000 people on to the streets of London and, according to The Times, it was the &bquo;biggest revolt for a decade&equo;. 
 Most of the pits and most of the ports came to a halt and the morning's newspapers also failed to appear. 
 Nevertheless, behind the crowd scenes that so mesmerized television, the day did not prove an overwhelming success for the TUC. 
 The vast majority of industry and of the health service went on working. 
 Even more crucially, the TUC's tactics had turned the press against them and provoked the opposition of the nurses' negotiators. 
 There was now over &pound;1,000 million on the table and the unions had refused to discuss it. 
 That was rightly seen as a ludicrously intransigent position. 
 The unions followed the national day of action with regional days but these were badly supported and attracted little attention. 
 The TUC unions had shot their bolt. 
 The Guardian's cartoonist showed one health official saying to another: &bquo;These regional days of action are so badly organized that Len Murray has to ring up Norman Fowler to ask where they are being held.&equo; 
 The health unions' refusal to return to the negotiating table proved a major mistake. 
 Albert Spanswick had been right on that and the hard men of his committee quite wrong. 
 For the nurses, however, the negotiations proved to be a historic turning-point. 
 For years nurses had wanted special pay arrangements which recognized that they did not take industrial action in pursuit of their pay claims. 
 For years different governments had refused to give them. 
 Inside government we examined a number of options. 
 My first choice had always been a pay review body and the significant breakthrough came when Geoffrey Howe and Leon Brittan at the Treasury also backed this proposal. 
 If the nurses accepted it, their pay would be determined in the same way as the  doctors', by an independent review body. 
 Although Government could alter the proposals, the presumption was that they would not. 
 There was some scepticism about this solution &mdash; given that we had altered the recommendations for doctors and dentists &mdash; but it says a great deal for the good sense of the nurses that they accepted the plan. 
 The result was that they received both a big two-year increase and a pay review body which has since been responsible for a further substantial increase in their salaries. 
 On 15 December 1982 the health dispute collapsed and the unions eventually consented to a two-year agreement which could have been accepted months earlier. 
 Their action had failed. 
 The 1982 dispute was an altogether typical example of industrial action in the health service. 
 Any Health Minister faces a powerful coalition against him. 
 He stands alone &mdash; as Kenneth Clarke or David Ennals will confirm &mdash; and he makes few friends. 
 Nor can he always rely on the help of those who in any other industry or service you might expect to be on his side. 
 I remember in June going to Brighton for a meeting of the National Association of Health Authorities. 
 I was on time but kept waiting for a few minutes so that the assembled Health Authority Chairmen and administrators could pass a motion condemning the Government's offer as divisive. 
 It is at least worth a footnote to any textbook on handling disputes that few employers have to contend with their management arm solemnly sitting down and condemning the negotiating strategy and then publicly relating their views to the press. 
 Even worse, we had the Chairmen of the Whitley Councils publicly giving the same message. 
 The Whitley Councils are the means whereby pay negotiations take place in the health service. 
 The Government may be the paymaster, but the actual negotiations are carried out by a team of health authority representatives who might be industrial relations experts but usually are not. 
 Their concern in 1982 was not what was right but what was easiest. 
 Had we taken their advice the nurses would never have received what has proved for them their biggest breakthrough since the war. 
 From the point of view of the economy, the outcome of the 1982 health dispute was immensely significant. 
 As the Daily Telegraph said in a leader:  
 The Government has won a very important victory. 
 Apart from the huge expense of acceding to the health workers' demands, defeat for the Government would have brought in its train a series of demands from other workers which it would have found hard to resist.&hellip; 
 It was an uncontrolled public sector which brought ruin on the previous two administrations. 
 This judgement was surely right. 
 It was a clear part of the unions' pay tactics that groups with a claim to public sympathy, like the health workers, were put in front to establish a going rate. 
 It was important that this strategy did not succeed and it was also important that the tactics of intimidation seen in 1979 did not win through in 1982. 
 The 1982 health dispute served notice that the Government would not easily give way in a strike. 
 That message was later underlined in the 1984&ndash;5 miners' strike. 
 We had not been prepared to give way to health unions with much public support. 
 The prospect of our surrendering to Mr Scargill and the NUM was remote. 
 Yet for all that, there is an additional conclusion. 
 The health service over the last twenty years has been marred by periodic pay disputes which have disrupted patient services. 
 The result has been to destroy much of the progress in health care over the years preceding each dispute. 
 We should not abandon the search for a better way of determining pay for all health service staff. 
 The best result of the 1982 pay dispute was the nurses' pay review body. 
 Implicit in that arrangement is a non-strike pledge. 
 Government recognized that nurses did not take strike action and believed that it was right to have a system of pay determination which meant that they did not lose by that policy. 
 This arrangement could be extended to any group in the health service prepared to give a similar pledge. 
 I accept, however, that trade unions see their function to negotiate and they (although I suspect not their members) would fight to prevent this function being supplanted and the strike weapon abolished. 
 An alternative course would be to introduce general legislation to protect the public interest when an essential service is threatened. 
 Over the last twenty years in Britain industrial action has affected a whole range of essential services from water, electricity and fire-fighting to the Royal Mail, public transport and health.  
 In many cases a virtual monopoly service has been involved and the direct target has been the public. 
 In many other countries, action has already been taken to provide some protection. 
 In the European Community, minimum periods of notice are often required before a strike in an essential service can take place and a minimum level of service is required during industrial action. 
 In the United States, a ninety-day notice of a strike in health care is required and the President has the power to impose an eighty-day cooling-off period. 
 It would certainly be possible for a cooling-off period to be introduced in Britain. 
 A cooling-off period of, say, six weeks could be imposed by application to the courts and this would allow negotiations and talks to continue. 
 It would allow contingency plans to be made to protect the public and it would apply just as much to a series of one-day strikes as a set-piece conflict. 
 It would allow second thoughts and permit (but not require) the parties to use ACAS or any other means to find a solution. 
 A cooling-off period does not guarantee success, but it offers a degree of public protection which at present is entirely lacking. 
 Clearly if this question was easy to decide it would have been settled in the years of the Thatcher Governments. 
 At various stages over the eleven years, statements were made promising action. 
 The fear must be that if we leave the issue unresolved then there will be other health disputes in the future and, just as certainly, the people who suffer will again be the patients. 
 Safe in Our Hands 
 On Thursday 9 September 1982, a paper from the Central Policy Review Staff, the Government's think-tank, came to Cabinet. 
 Each year there is an annual debate between the Treasury and the different government departments on the size of their budgets, but the aim of this meeting was to go one stage further. 
 Geoffrey Howe, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, and Leon Brittan, the Chief Secretary to the Treasury in overall charge of government spending, wanted to look at the longer-term trends and to see how public expenditure could be successfully controlled in the 1980s. 
 Their fear was that taxes would not only have to remain high but might well have to increase. 
 The CPRS paper argued that if the Government were serious about reducing public expenditure, the time had come to consider some radical solutions. 
 The paper looked at education and social security but the most explosive set of proposals concerned the health service. 
 Basically the paper suggested that we should consider moving away from the tax-financed National Health Service to private health insurance. 
 There would need to be rebates for low-income families and for long-stay patients but the idea was that the working population would be required by law to obtain health insurance. 
 The paper also advocated increased charges for the health service and suggested further savings, like charging patients to visit the doctor. 
 As far as I was concerned the timing of the CPRS paper was disastrous. 
 I was still in the middle of the longest health dispute since the war. 
 By any standards it was a sensitive period and about the worst moment that anyone could have chosen to circulate proposals of this kind. 
 If the proposals leaked they would be dynamite inside the health service, and yet they had come round with only the routine &bquo;confidential&equo; security classification. 
 My guess was that they would find their way into the press and would undermine our efforts to settle the health dispute. 
 My opposition was, however, much more fundamental than this. 
 I did not believe that it was a sensible way of making policy. 
 It may have been the job of the think-tank to think the unthinkable, but  such discussion needed to be on the basis of informed examination. 
 These proposals had come forward without any consultation with any health minister, and indeed without any of us knowing that such a study was taking place. 
 This was entirely the wrong way to make policy and a cavalier way of dealing with a popular and effective service. 
 Worst of all, no one seemed to have remembered that we had already been round this particular course, decided the policy, and rejected compulsory private health insurance. 
 My predecessor Patrick Jenkin had sensibly asked for an examination of the different ways that European countries financed their health care. 
 This had been carried out inside the health department and had come up with findings that were easily predictable. 
 Every country in Europe was facing an explosion in demand for health care; every country in Europe was spending substantial public resources upon health; and in many ways our centrally run, centrally financed system was the most effective in controlling costs. 
 There was no inherent cost advantage in moving over to an entirely new financing system and it was also clear that whatever system was chosen, taxation would still have to finance a giant share of the service. 
 The unemployed, the poor, the chronically sick and disabled and of course children would need to be covered by public money. 
 There were also endless practical questions about private insurance. 
 The assumption was that insurance would be paid only by those who could afford it while those who could not afford to pay would be exempt. 
 But where was the line to be drawn? 
 Would the elderly with the equivalent of average earnings be exempt or not exempt? 
 Everyone over retirement age is exempt from paying prescription charges and any deviation from the provision of free health care for the elderly would be wildly controversial. 
 Would health insurance be income-related like National Insurance or would it be genuine private insurance like life insurance or house insurance? 
 A sensible policy on exemptions and rebates would reduce the possible savings and my guess was that in the end you would achieve surprisingly little in public savings. 
 The potential for a massive row like that over the community charge was immense. 
 Months before the CPRS report came to ministers, therefore, we had reviewed the options and indeed in July 1982 I had set out  the Government's position, after consultation with the Treasury. 
 In a Parliamentary reply I said: &bquo;The Government have no plans to change the present system of financing the National Health Service largely from taxation and will continue to review the scope for introducing more cost consciousness and consumer choice and for increasing private provision which is already expanding.&equo; 
 The agreed position of the Government was that we would not move over to private health insurance but would seek to make the health service as effective as possible. 
 The private sector would remain separate and the public would have the right to be covered by it if they wished &mdash; having first paid their taxes to support the general service. 
 My view (the view of a confirmed industrial privatizer) was that the National Health Service should remain at the centre of our health-care system and that politically we would reap the whirlwind if we could be portrayed as moving away from it. 
 Change was certainly needed, but I favoured change which would improve the service and for which there was public support. 
 It was clear that the public wanted above all the assurance that our system of health care guaranteed the best possible treatment irrespective of income. 
 I did not think much of the CPRS blunderbuss which seemed to be aimed firmly at the Government's feet. 
 A week later my worst fears were confirmed. 
 Some kindly soul leaked the contents of the CPRS report to the Economist. 
 &bquo;Thatcher's Holocaust,&equo; said the Economist, not intending to understate their scoop: &bquo;Thatcher's think-tank takes aim at the Welfare State.&equo; 
 Leaks were a constant hazard of the first 1979&ndash;83 Thatcher Government and none did us more damage than this. 
 Yet the irony was that there was no support in Cabinet for the proposals and they had almost reached the point of rejection when the leak took place. 
 All the leaker managed to do was to provoke a bogus political row. 
 It was useless for me to point out that the proposals were not those of the Government but of a group of advisers whose only power was to suggest. 
 That was, however, the truth of the matter. 
 The CPRS had been set up by Ted Heath to advise on long-term policy issues. 
 Its first director was Lord Rothschild and its staff was drawn both from the civil service and from outside Whitehall. 
 The &bquo;tank&equo; had been continued by the succeeding Labour Government during which they carried out their famous inquiry into the  Foreign Office which proposed fundamental changes in the organization of the Diplomatic Service, and they were retained by Margaret Thatcher when she took power in 1979. 
 Governments were not bound by their proposals and past history &mdash; as when Labour threw out the Foreign Office report &mdash; was ample proof of this. 
 Yet for all that, the charge eagerly made against us was that the Government were set on abolishing the National Health Service and &bquo;privatizing&equo; health care. 
 It was a charge that was to dog us through both the 1983 and 1987 general elections, and which did us more damage than any other health issue. 
 Successive Labour spokesmen tried to establish that the Thatcher Government did not have its heart in the health service. 
 Yet the truth was that the CPRS report was consigned to the dustbin within a couple of weeks of its first appearing. 
 At the Cabinet meeting on 9 September, we did not discuss the CPRS paper in any detail. 
 The general attitude was entirely hostile to the report and we certainly did not agree that on the basis of the report the CPRS should undertake further studies. 
 Outside Cabinet Leon Brittan argued in a speech that the Government must have the right to look at new ideas, although I suspect that both Leon and Geoffrey Howe must have been appalled at the way the issue had been handled. 
 The next day, I countered with a speech arguing that as far as the health service was concerned the issue had been settled and that the Government's policy was to continue to make the service as effective as possible. 
 The issue surfaced again at Cabinet on 30 September when I warned colleagues that the leaking of the CPRS report had caused us damage. 
 I outlined what my message had been over the past two weeks and would be at the Party Conference &mdash; that we stood by the National Health Service and had no intention of moving over to a new system of finance. 
 At that meeting two of the Cabinet heavyweights, Willie Whitelaw and Quintin Hailsham, intervened to give me support. 
 Quintin Hailsham told me later: &bquo;When I first read the report my hair stood on end, and at my age that takes some doing.&equo; 
 At the Conservative Party Conference two weeks later I set out both the Government's position and my own feelings. 
 I told the conference that I had not come into politics to preside over the destruction of the National Health Service and repeated  the Government's commitment to it. 
 I added: &bquo;The Government is committed to the health service because we want to ensure that everyone in need of treatment receives it. 
 Taxation will remain, as now, the predominant way of financing it.&hellip; 
 What this Government wants is partnership, not apartheid, between the private and the public sectors.&equo; 
 At the end of the conference Margaret Thatcher returned to the same theme. 
 She had been on the platform for my speech but used distinctive words of her own. 
 The guiding principle for the Government, she said, was that health care should be provided for all regardless of ability to pay: &bquo;Let me make one thing absolutely clear. 
 The National Health Service is safe with us.&equo; 
 The issue was never raised again in the remaining five years I stayed at the Department of Health. 
 Indeed the real significance of the Welfare State report was that it marked the beginning of the end not for the health service but for the CPRS. 
 They were as much the victims of the leaking of the report as ministers. 
 John Sparrow, the head of the think-tank, led an unquestionably bright team but their abilities were not being best used. 
 They needed to be positioned inside departments' own policy units or inside Number 10 itself rather than stumbling around Whitehall in an unguided way. 
 Immediately after the 1983 general election the CPRS was disbanded and I very much doubt it will ever be resurrected. 
 I see nothing to regret in this, not because new ideas should not be examined, but because it can be done better. 
 Three years later I led a review of social security which was regarded as even more untouchable than the health service. 
 We did it in an entirely different way. 
 We were open about the review itself. 
 We asked the public what they thought. 
 We used independent experts on the review teams. 
 We made it clear that what we wanted was a better social security system and not just a cheaper one. 
 The CPRS way was the wrong way of doing it. 
 The report was not an impressive document. 
 It contained no fresh insights. 
 It simply set out some crude ideas on how public spending could be reduced and suggested that ministers should have six months to come up with more refined views. 
 It was entirely right that this method of policymaking was thrown out. 
 Nevertheless in the public debate on health we were saddled  with the CPRS report. 
 Ministers had rejected the report but politically it took us the next two general elections to repair the damage. 
 In June 1983, Margaret Thatcher went to the polls for the second time. 
 It was almost a year before it was strictly necessary and at the time there were voices advising delay. 
 Unemployment was over three million and one strong view was that we should wait until the autumn when the economic recovery would be more apparent. 
 Like every other Cabinet minister, I was asked for my opinion. 
 Influenced by our strong local-government showing in Birmingham and the Midlands, I advised June and that was clearly the majority view. 
 I do remember, however, another Cabinet minister remarking &bquo;It doesn't matter when you go, Margaret, you will win.&equo; 
 At the time I thought that was particularly unhelpful advice. 
 In retrospect I think it was no more than the truth. 
 Clearly we were helped by the Falklands factor but, even more, we were helped by the Labour Party. 
 Michael Foot had put together a series of policies to keep his party together. 
 The trouble for him was that this manifesto &mdash; &bquo;the longest suicide note in history&equo; &mdash; had also made his party entirely unelectable. 
 Labour candidates found themselves pledged to unilateral disarmament, withdrawal from the European Community and an economic policy that would have brought the country to bankruptcy within weeks. 
 The outcome was never seriously in doubt, although our eventual majority of 144 seats substantially overstated our support. 
 Our total vote actually went down and in areas hit by high unemployment, like my own constituency in the West Midlands, there was a swing to the Alliance of David Steel and David Owen. 
 Many people suspended judgement and throughout the West Midlands reduced polls saw Conservative majorities cut. 
 In the campaign itself there was one awkward moment and that was on the issue of private health. 
 It showed just how powerful the CPRS factor had become. 
 On Saturday 4 June, I came in from a morning's canvassing in Sutton Coldfield to find an urgent message to call Conservative Central Office. 
 I learnt that Roy Hattersley and Gwyneth Dunwoody, who spoke for the Opposition on health, had claimed at Labour's morning press conference that they had a &bquo;leaked&equo; copy of a secret Health Department report planning the privatization of the service. 
 Leaks were  the flavour of the year in 1983, but the trouble was that neither Ken Clarke nor I had the first idea what report this was meant to be as there were no plans, secret or otherwise, for privatization. 
 Slowly it became clear that what Labour had in mind was a circular we had sent out three months earlier to health authority chairmen for comment, entitled Co-operation between the NHS and the private sector at district level. 
 The idea behind the circular was the exact opposite of what Labour alleged. 
 It recognized that there was a National Health Service and a private sector and, rather than arguing that one should be taken over by the other, proposed sensible cooperation between them for the benefit of patients. 
 The document proposed that, to reduce waiting lists, health service patients should have the opportunity of treatment in private hospitals; and that health authorities should explore the potential of placing contracts with private nursing homes for the care of elderly patients, in order to free hospital beds for other patients. 
 We also wanted health service patients to have access to underused &bquo;high technology&equo; equipment in the private sector. 
 The aim was to make use of all available resources whether labelled public or private for the benefit of the patient who wanted treatment. 
 By most standards this was a peculiarly non-threatening document but we were in the middle of a general election. 
 Michael Foot claimed the document established &bquo;the most serious attack on the National Health Service since it was originally started&equo;. 
 Gwyneth Dunwoody stated that we were secretly dismantling the health service and Roy Hattersley muttered about contracting out old people like refuse collection. 
 It was all the greatest nonsense but the scare ran for a couple of days. 
 Once we finally identified the leaked document, we countered in the most conclusive way known in politics: we published it in its entirety. 
 Journalists read it and the clamour quietened. 
 Throughout the election Gwyneth Dunwoody was my opponent. 
 She adopted a hectoring tone and continually interrupted in debates. 
 Our duels were not on the scale of the later Clarke versus Prescott battles, where in the 1987 general election I saw a television chairman leave his chair several times to restore order. 
 Nevertheless I fear our debates were not much more edifying. 
 During one television interview, with Dunwoody in London and myself in Nottingham, she again interrupted my replies. 
 My  patience snapped and I said: &bquo;Do shut up and just listen for a moment.&equo; 
 It did me no good. 
 The next day 1 was canvassing in Sutton Coldfield and a policeman came up to me. 
 &bquo;I am afraid you have lost my wife's vote,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You should never tell a lady to shut up.&equo; 
 In fact my majority was healthy enough at almost 19,000. 
 I was chased mercilessly about the streets by my campaign assistant, Simon Heffer, who is now the chief leader-writer of the Daily Telegraph but whom I knew in those days as a fellow (but younger) old boy from Chelmsford. 
 Four years later there was an important postscript to the CPRS affair. 
 Following the 1987 general election, Margaret Thatcher set up and headed a small committee to examine the health service. 
 It included my successor, John Moore, who early in his term of office made a speech which was interpreted as meaning that he was prepared to take a different stance towards the health service. 
 The press was full of stories about fundamental change. 
 The group also included Treasury ministers, who might be expected to support a change to private insurance if anyone would. 
 The group went round the course for month after month but wisely came to the conclusion yet again that they did not intend to alter the basis of the health service. 
 The changes proposed were the ones that Ken Clarke and later William Waldegrave took through. 
 As I know to my cost, any change in the health service is controversial. 
 However, one charge that cannot reasonably be made against the Government is that they have privatized the service. 
 The policy remains the policy that has been followed by successive health ministers from Iain Macleod and Enoch Powell through to Keith Joseph and myself &mdash; namely to make the health service as effective as possible. 
 This is where the real debate is and where the Government have succeeded in taking the high ground. 
 Labour tend to regard the health service as some enormous trade union. 
 They look at everything from the point of view of the provider and their only discernible policy is that they are against privatization. 
 But that is not the issue. 
 The real issue in health is how to continue to improve a good service for the benefit of the patient. 
 The trouble with some of those who make much of their support for the health service is that they also oppose any measures taken to make it more effective. 
 You can argue about the amount  of resources devoted to health but what you cannot sensibly argue about is that the resources devoted to health care should be used to maximum effect. 
 The history of the past ten years has seen Labour consistently oppose any change inside the health service and, even more regrettably, has often seen groups inside it resist reform on the grounds that their vested interests are being challenged. 
 Hardly ever do such groups consider the public good. 
 My time at the DHSS showed that it was impossible to make any significant change without a fierce public and professional battle &mdash; even when improvement meant more resources for health care or put right long-standing problems. 
 In so many ways the health service of the 1980s was admirable and impressive. 
 Of course there were loud-mouths &mdash; the sophisticated ones patronized you; the less sophisticated simply shouted. 
 But these were the health service politicians and happily they were not typical. 
 The vast majority from the most senior consultant to the most junior nurse worked long hours and responded to daily emergencies in a way that was an object lesson to us all. 
 The question was whether their skill and dedication was matched by organization and management. 
 1 became convinced that with better management and a number of policy changes we could achieve a better service for the patient. 
 Instead of privatizing the health service, I wanted to modernize it so that it could better tackle the problems of the 1980s and 1990s. 
 By 1983 the health budget had increased from &pound;9.5 billion in 1979 to &pound;15.5 billion. 
 I decided to examine some of the services that made up this massive total. 
 One of the areas I looked at first was the so-called ancillary services &mdash; that is cleaning, catering and laundry. 
 By 1983 these services accounted for almost &pound;I billion of the annual budget and any savings made there could be transferred to the main activity of treating patients. 
 It is the kind of argument that any businessman in charge of even a medium-sized company would recognize instantly. 
 In no way did I wish to diminish the importance of these services or the importance of the people who worked in them. 
 Any hospital needs to be kept clean and the patients need good food. 
 Nevertheless, there was no reason why the health service should devote unnecessary resources to these jobs. 
 The first step was to check the cost of the in-house services  against that which could be provided by private contractors. 
 The health service does not have a monopoly in cleaning, catering and laundry skills in the same way that it does in the skills required to treat sick people. 
 There are private companies who specialize in these services and who, incidentally, also have dedicated people working for them. 
 In February 1983 I announced in the House of Commons that health authorities should put their ancillary services out to tender to see whether they would get best value from private or in-house organizations. 
 Six months later, in September, I followed this up with a circular to health authorities requiring them to put their services out to tender. 
 They were not forced to use private contractors but they were required to make a judgement on the best value for their health authority. 
 The policy was met with predictable howls of rage from unions like NUPE, and nor did every Health Authority throw their hats in the air with glee. 
 It was easier for them to demand money from the Government than argue plans past their local unions. 
 The health service has its fair share of people who want a quiet life and perhaps more than its fair share of Authority members who, for political reasons, opposed the policy itself. 
 I suspect that even now there is the potential for greater savings. 
 Nevertheless, this policy has now freed more than &pound;100 million for use elsewhere in the National Health Service. 
 If I had trouble with the health unions on contracting out, it was nothing compared with my problems on manpower numbers. 
 By 1983 the National Health Service was employing more than 800,000 staff &mdash; an increase of a quarter over the total in the early 1970s. 
 With staff costs amounting to about 70 per cent of the annual budget, any moderately competent company would at least ask whether this proportion was justified. 
 As the Public Accounts Committee of the House of Commons had demonstrated, however, neither the Government nor the health authorities had accurate information on the exact numbers employed or any sensible means of controlling numbers. 
 Nevertheless we made a start and asked the Regional Health Authorities to produce manpower plans for the next year. 
 Their plans originally showed an increase of another 7,000 staff. 
 At the beginning of October 1983 I announced that out of a total staff of 817,633 we would ask for a reduction of 4,837, which would save about &pound;40  million. 
 Again there was a furious row. 
 This was the first time that the health service had ever been asked to make staff economies. 
 Both Ken Clarke and my special adviser Nicholas True made it clear that a good speech was &bquo;needed&equo; at the Party Conference in Blackpool. 
 Fortunately my 1983 conference speech went well and the row started to calm down. 
 Perhaps the most intense of my health service battles of the mid-1980s was over the selected list of drugs. 
 For years ministers had been urged to cut the heavy drugs bill. 
 By 1984 the bill had reached &pound;1.4 billion and we were under both political and professional pressure to reduce it. 
 The only question was how. 
 Doctors wished to preserve their clinical freedom to prescribe what drugs they themselves felt were necessary. 
 The pharmaceutical industry had a legitimate interest in seeing that their own branded drugs were prescribed. 
 They had devoted the resources to research and development and they wanted a sensible return on that investment. 
 As a Government, we wanted a good pharmaceutical industry but we also wanted good value for the health service. 
 I found myself in the curious position of being the sponsor minister of the industry and also the minister ultimately answerable for health service spending. 
 It was clear that some economies were possible if more generic drugs were prescribed rather than branded drugs. 
 Generic substitution could be achieved in a number of ways. 
 One suggestion was that discretion should be left to the doctors and that they should tick a box if they wanted the generic drug. 
 This system, however, was uncertain in its effect. 
 1 was attracted by another that I had discussed on a visit to Europe: certain branded drugs would not be prescribed at all when entirely adequate substitute generic drugs existed. 
 We would not leave it to the discretion of the doctors but, acting on the best medical advice, set down what drugs could be prescribed and those that could not. 
 In theory it may sound radical to interfere with a doctor's right to prescribe, although it was not the drug that was being withdrawn, only the branded version. 
 In practice those doubts melt away when you realize just what drugs we had in mind. 
 Prior to the selected list, doctors could prescribe branded drugs as cold remedies, laxatives, ordinary painkillers, antacids, vitamins, bitters and tonics, tranquillizers and sedatives. 
 The drugs in these  areas were not at the frontier of medical science and acceptable generic drugs existed. 
 The new policy meant, however, that popular branded drugs like Mogadon, Valium, Librium, Dalmane and Benylin could not be prescribed under the health service &mdash; not to mention Beecham's Pills, Alka Seltzer, Andrew's Liver Salts, Vick's Vapour Rub and even more exotic preparations like Rock Salmon cough mixture and Male Gland Double Strength Supplement tablets. 
 In retrospect it seems extraordinary that some of these could be prescribed in the first place. 
 On 9 November 1984 I set out for consultation a list of branded drugs which would no longer be prescribed under the health service. 
 The reaction was instant. 
 Predictably enough, the pharmaceutical industry fiercely opposed the proposals but, more surprisingly and entirely to their discredit, so too did the British Medical Association. 
 There followed as fierce and nasty a little campaign as I can remember in the time I spent with the health service. 
 The BMA and its Chairman, John Marks, refused even to come to the department to talk about the details of the scheme and vigorously campaigned against us. 
 The pharmaceutical industry unwisely did the same and instituted an expensive advertising campaign. 
 The free weekly magazines sent to doctors financed by drug advertisements joined in with a vengeance on the lines that &bquo;Fowler's drug list ends prescribing freedom&equo;. 
 Seeing the way the debate was going, the health spokesmen of the Labour Party, Michael Meacher, and of the SDP, Mike Thomas, who had previously been urging me to make economies in the drugs bill, jumped overboard and joined the critics. 
 The result was that we were dangerously isolated with a strong coalition arrayed against us, but fortunately our opponents overplayed their hand. 
 The BMA were criticized for their intransigence and the pharmaceutical industry's advertising was criticized for seeking to frighten patients. 
 One company threatened that replies from MPs to their standard letter would be posted on surgery notice-boards in their constituencies. 
 I am glad to say that these tactics backfired. 
 Even in these days of lobbying, Members of Parliament will not be bullied in this way. 
 When the issue was put to the vote in the House of Commons we had a majority of 127 and the campaign against us was left in ruins. 
 These, then, were some of the issues that took my time. 
  However, as month after month went by, I became more and more convinced that the real problem with the health service was a lack of management. 
 Over the previous twenty years we had become preoccupied with structural arguments about regions and areas when we should have been concerned about how the service was run. 
 Compared with any major industry our methods appeared amateurish. 
 Although we were the biggest employer in Britain, we had no serious employee-involvement policies. 
 There was certainly a multitude of advisers but all too few people who took responsibility for action and for failure. 
 In early 1983, Roy Griffiths, the Chief Executive of Sainsbury's and one of the most successful managers in the country, agreed to head an inquiry into management in the health service. 
 His report came six months later in an altogether typical form. 
 Rather than some forbidding official document, his report consisted of a letter to me with the disclaimer that it was not intended to be a major addition to the already considerable library of the National Health Service. 
 It was a plan of action. 
 His diagnosis was clear: 
 If Florence Nightingale were carrying her lamp through the corridors of the National Health Service today, she would almost certainly be searching for the people in charge. 
 His solution was also plain. 
 It was to push responsibility downwards so that, for example, day-to-day decisions in hospitals were taken in the hospitals themselves and not forever referred upwards to some &bquo;higher authority&equo;. 
 For this to be effective there was a need for managers. 
 The managers could be appointed from inside the service or taken in from outside. 
 They could be professional managers or they could be doctors or nurses. 
 The point was that they should be managers who took responsibility for securing the best service to the patient and could be held to account if there was failure. 
 In the summer of 1984 there was an event that tragically illustrated the Griffiths case. 
 An outbreak of food poisoning at the Stanley Royd Hospital near Wakefield affected over half the 800 elderly patients and caused nineteen deaths. 
 I appointed a public inquiry into the outbreak. 
 The crucial message that came back was that we needed more hands-on management. 
 In the hospital  kitchen there was a gulf between those who were meant to be in charge and those who actually carried out the work. 
 According to the report, the managers &bquo;passed through rather than spent time in the kitchen&equo;. 
 They were punctilious in ensuring that new staff read the hygiene regulations, but the running of the kitchen itself was entirely left to those working there. 
 Yet in spite of its overwhelming logic, the Griffiths case was hotly disputed. 
 The most infuriating charge was that the health service was different from business and therefore did not need the benefit of the techniques that had been developed in business and industry. 
 Of course the delivery of health care is different from producing cars or selling food, but there are a large number of common problems that any manager shares. 
 He must be concerned with the quality of service, the quality of the product and the productivity of his workforce. 
 He must motivate and involve all his staff and he must live within and meet his budget. 
 Regrettably, even today, there are a number of health service insiders who feel that they are an exception to these general rules and look down on the ways of industry with the patronizing assurance of those who know that &bquo;we are different&equo;. 
 It goes without saying that the Labour front bench supported all of the most reactionary arguments that could be found to oppose the management reforms. 
 Yet today no serious figure inside or outside the health service would argue that we should return to the old system. 
 The management of the health service is now infinitely better than it was and the trend to devolving responsibility downwards has continued apace. 
 Even so, I found that a curious structure remained at the service's centre. 
 It was rather like an old-fashioned nationalized industry where all lines led to the Secretary of State. 
 It was as if the Secretary of State were directly running the railways himself, with no chairman or managing director between him and the service. 
 We tried to solve this with management and supervisory boards based in the department but they were a long way from the boards of industry. 
 When Victor Paige became the first general manager of the health service he found himself in a very different job from any that he or anyone else had occupied before. 
 He was not the chief executive of a big corporation but in an uneasy no man's land between the department and the service. 
 I regret that he resigned in 1986 but I have to admit that he had a point.  
 Since then the position has slowly improved but very much the same dilemma still remains. 
 The health service is financed almost entirely by the taxpayer and will remain so. 
 The Secretary of State is accountable to Parliament for that enormous budget &mdash; currently running at over &pound;30 billion a year &mdash; and must remain so. 
 The question is whether he can discharge that responsibility to Parliament without being in day-to-day charge. 
 By the end of my stay in health, I had become convinced that it would be possible to create a health commission with its own chief executive or chairman. 
 Such a commission would have substantial advantages. 
 Nothing will now take health out of politics but a commission could produce a more efficient service with the potential for advances in training, employee involvement and swifter decision-making. 
 The advantage would be that ministers and civil servants would not be involved in day-to-day management. 
 The commission would be given its objectives by the Government and would be accountable to it. 
 I believe that this would lead to a better service and improved facilities for the public. 
 Our reforms to the health service in the 1980s went beyond the hospitals. 
 The primary services &mdash; family doctors, dentists, pharmacists &mdash; are very much the front line of health care and in 1986 we published a Green Paper which was the first comprehensive review of the services for forty years. 
 We estimated that on an average working day about 650,000 people saw their family doctor and another 300,000 went to the dentist. 
 I approached the service from the point of view of the consumer, as we had already done to good effect with the opticians. 
 In 1984 we had ended the opticians' monopoly and taken off the ridiculous restrictions on advertising which prevented the public from shopping around for the best value. 
 The changes had met with howls of rage from the profession; a host of cartoons in the press; but above all a reduction in price for the consumer. 
 We now went further, proposing changes in the way that doctors were paid so that the remuneration system much more clearly recognized the good doctors and the good practices. 
 We also wanted to give the public more information about local health care and an easier means of changing doctors. 
 These proposals and many more formed the basis of legislation following the 1987 general election &mdash; as too did the model report  from Dame Mary Warnock that I commissioned into human fertilization and embryology. 
 So was the health service safe in our hands? 
 My aim was to modernize the health service and I believe that the Government had significant success. 
 We made better use of NHS resources than ever before. 
 We raised extra resources for health from common-sense policies like contracting-out, selling surplus land (which alone raised over &pound;1 billion) and controlling the drugs budget. 
 We introduced modern management, probably the major advance during the 1980s. 
 We built more hospitals and moved decisively away from the terrible stop-go years of the 1970s when capital budgets were slashed. 
 Above all, we provided more care. 
 It is always difficult to measure the exact outcome of health policy but some indicators give the picture. 
 Between 1979 and 1987 the number of inpatients treated in English hospitals went up by a quarter and day cases by almost 60 per cent. 
 Another figure I was delighted to see increase was the vaccination rate for whooping cough, which went up from 31 per cent to 73 per cent. 
 So, yes, I believe the health service was safe with us. 
 But that cannot mean that the process of change has ended. 
 Commitment to the health service means constantly striving for better ways forward. 
 Reforming the Welfare State 
 Margaret Thatcher reshuffled the Cabinet in June 1983. 
 After our election victory, Willie Whitelaw moved from the Home Office to become Leader of the House of Lords and his place was taken by Leon Brittan, who in a notable promotion became the youngest Home Secretary since Robert Peel. 
 The Foreign Secretary, Francis Pym, who had always appeared a rather reluctant supporter of Thatcherite policies, was sacked and his place was taken by Geoffrey Howe. 
 This left a crucial vacancy at the Treasury. 
 Press speculation ran Patrick Jenkin as Howe's likeliest heir and not without reason. 
 Patrick had been Chief Secretary to the Treasury in Ted Heath's Government and had been successful as Secretary of State for both Social Services and Trade and Industry. 
 His dubious reward was to be given the Department of the Environment. 
 The post of Chancellor of the Exchequer went to one of the most junior members of the previous Cabinet, the Energy Secretary Nigel Lawson. 
 According to his critics, Nigel was blunt in argument and had all the subtlety of a Chieftain tank. 
 If he could roll you over he would. 
 If he lost an engagement, he would simply regroup and try again. 
 But such critics (of whom there were many both inside and outside Government) underestimated the new Chancellor. 
 He was an undoubted intellectual heavyweight; he was a creative minister interested in political ideas; and, above all, he was entirely his own man. 
 He invariably believed completely in his own case and pursued it relentlessly to the end. 
 But there was no personal edge to his arguments. 
 He was neither a plotter nor a courtier. 
 As I was soon to find, he was a man you could like even when you were joined in battle with him. 
 From the start of his Chancellorship, Nigel Lawson made no secret of the fact that his ambitions were tax reform and lower taxes. 
 Almost his first action was a post-election dawn raid in July 1983 on departmental budgets. 
 The raid netted him &pound;500 million and over the next few weeks he made his strategy clear. 
 He believed that lower taxes were the route to higher growth and more jobs. 
 His ambition was to reduce the standard rate of tax to 25p  in the pound by the next election. 
 But if this was to be achieved then public spending &mdash; as a proportion of national wealth &mdash; had to come down. 
 Not surprisingly, given the increase in unemployment and the various crises in nationalized industries, public spending had increased between 1979 and 1983. 
 Nigel was determined to have none of that during the next Parliament. 
 All departments would be under close scrutiny, but none more than the Department of Health and Social Security, which was by far the biggest spender in Whitehall. 
 It needed no great powers of prophecy to realize that Nigel and I were on a collision course. 
 At a meeting on 21 July the Cabinet approved the Chancellor's strategy. 
 In the days following, press reports started to appear that I, and indeed Ken Clarke who as Minister of State for Health was still outside the Cabinet, were very unhappy about the new emphasis of policy. 
 Both the Daily Mail and the Daily Mirror said that we might take our opposition to the point of resignation. 
 I doubt if Ken's position was much different from my own but he must speak for himself. 
 My position was this. 
 I supported the move to reduce taxation. 
 I shared the view that personal taxation was too high and that one way we could help industry was to reduce the tax burden upon it. 
 It was, after all, only if this was done that there would be any wealth to distribute to services like health. 
 But we needed a balanced approach. 
 The reduction of taxation was not our only objective. 
 We had other social policy commitments and we also needed to keep to those. 
 The difficulty of imposing spending cuts across the board was shown by social security. 
 Benefits were divided into &bquo;pledged&equo; benefits like the retirement pension which the Government was committed to uprating each year according to inflation; and &bquo;unpledged&equo; benefits, like child benefit and supplementary benefit, where there was no such commitment and the Government decided each year whether to increase them or not. 
 If we reduced by 5 per cent every unpledged benefit we would still, in 1984, have saved only &pound;200 million. 
 However, we would have provoked a huge political fracas and affected some of the poorest in the land. 
 I did not threaten to resign but I did make it clear that I would not endorse changes I could not justify. 
 I took the view that the Cabinet and the Prime Minister should know my position. 
 I was glad I did. 
 There were hard fights over the next four years which  I do not resent. 
 But the result was the balance I argued for. 
 The Government did manage to bring down the rate of income tax, but at the same time we increased the annual budget for health between 1983 and 1987 from &pound;15.5 billion to &pound;20.7 billion and for social security from &pound;36.7 billion to &pound;48.7 billion. 
 Yet securing a realistic budget was only one part of making policy in the DHSS. 
 It was also important to ensure that the money was well spent. 
 By the autumn of 1983 my plans for health were well under way. 
 I next decided to set up a complete examination of the social security system. 
 My first step was the reform of pensions. 
 In 1963 my father died at the age of sixty-one, four years short of his pensionable age. 
 He had worked for the same engineering firm for thirty years and he had always set great store by the company pension. 
 However, he made the great mistake of not living to collect it. 
 There was no widow's pension &mdash; only a return of contributions. 
 Fortunately my mother was able to return to teaching and to complete the final two or three years which qualified her for a pension of her own. 
 In 1970 I left The Times on being elected to the House of Commons. 
 I also had a company pension but I was what, in the pensions trade, is called an &bquo;early leaver&equo;. 
 I was given a choice. 
 I could have my own contributions returned or I could leave my pension where it was and draw it at the age of sixty-five. 
 The only snag with this last course was that when the pension was paid out in 2003 it would still be at its 1970 value. 
 It would have been frozen for over thirty years. 
 In the bustle of adapting to the new life of an MP at Westminster, it had occurred to me that I should look further at pensions. 
 The only occasions on which I had seen them in operation they had failed lamentably. 
 Like many people, however, I decided to leave it for another day. 
 Pensions are hard to understand and surrounded by impenetrable jargon. 
 Above all, a pension seems so far away when you are in your twenties and thirties. 
 It is easy to postpone settling down to understand them. 
 It is perhaps for that reason that the pensions industry had been able to get away with such arrangements for so long. 
 When I went to the DHSS I vowed to make time for a serious investigation into company pensions. 
 The more I looked, the more concerned I became. 
 The kind of company pensions then being  offered were fine for those who joined a company in their twenties and worked through to the age of sixty-five. 
 They were seriously deficient for people who moved jobs and, often, inadequate for widows. 
 This was an area which cried out for reform. 
 In September 1983 I called a conference on pensions at the DHSS headquarters. 
 I invited the pensions establishment but I also brought in some of those who wanted change. 
 I opened the conference to the press and the large room was packed. 
 When I spoke I made it clear that I intended to do something about the position of the &bquo;early leavers&equo; and that I thought it right that people should not suffer if they transferred their pension from one job to another. 
 Some of the industry recognized that change was due and with various degrees of enthusiasm were prepared to go along with such proposals. 
 What, however, caused almost universal consternation was my suggestion that we should go a stage further and see whether it was possible to introduce &bquo;portable&equo; pensions &mdash; pensions which you could take from one job to another. 
 The industry was horrified. 
 They saw this as a direct threat to their conventional final-salary pension schemes and a challenge to their whole way of life. 
 Reform was one thing &mdash; but this was revolution. 
 They were right. 
 Company pensions were the golden handcuffs which chained staff to a company. 
 Portable pensions could give the individual more freedom and end the penalty on changing jobs. 
 At the end of November 1983, I announced that I was going to head an inquiry into occupational pensions. 
 We faced a two-nation position. 
 One nation had their own pension. 
 The other nation relied entirely on the State. 
 My view was that people wanted what they regarded as their own pension and my aim was to ensure an expansion in provision. 
 Pensions, however, were not the only area which cried out for reform. 
 The social security system was the legacy of Lord Beveridge and the post-war Attlee Government. 
 No one had carried out any overall review of the system since then. 
 But that was not because anyone was very happy with it. 
 In spite of the vast expenditure on pensions and benefits, the complaints flooded in. 
 The system was seen as bureaucratic and ramshackle. 
 It was certainly an improvement on the pre-war system, but I doubted whether the money was always reaching the people who most needed it. 
 An outstanding example was the Death Grant. 
 The Death Grant  had been introduced before the war to help families who did not have enough money to bury their dead. 
 But it was a universal grant, which meant that it went equally to the millionaire's widow and to the widow who had very little. 
 Because it was universal, the cost of increasing it was very great. 
 The result was that it had been increased only twice and now stood at the princely sum of &pound;30. 
 It was pathetically inadequate for the poor and totally irrelevant for everyone else. 
 In terms of spending, it now cost &pound;12 million to administer an annual expenditure of only &pound;17 million on the grant. 
 Why then had nothing been done to change this long-standing nonsense? 
 Both Labour and Conservative Governments had taken the view that change would cause a fierce political storm, so no one did anything. 
 At the outset of my investigation one of my civil servants said to me: &bquo;My test of the review is whether you do anything about the Death Grant.&equo; 
 I knew what she meant. 
 Like so much of the social security system it had become regarded as politically untouchable. 
 My experience with the pensions inquiry had already taught me one invaluable lesson. 
 It is simply not necessary to make all policy behind closed doors. 
 Indeed, obsessive secrecy can be entirely counterproductive for policy-makers. 
 It creates suspicion and alienates the public. 
 With pensions we had been open about holding an inquiry. 
 We had taken evidence in public and given all the interested parties the chance to have their say. 
 We had brought in respected experts from outside Whitehall like Mark Weinberg, Professor Alan Peacock, and Marshall Field of the Life Offices' Association to act as assessors. 
 Our approach had changed the tone of the whole debate. 
 It was next to impossible for even the most reactionary supporter of the status quo to claim that Government should not even examine the pensions system. 
 It meant that the industry had to justify, under cross-examination, its policies. 
 Opponents of changing the rules on early leavers found it difficult to sustain their case. 
 Rather than having the whole of the public and the press against us, we gained support. 
 Letters flooded in from people who had often been cruelly affected by the system we were examining. 
 Journalists like my old colleague Christopher Fildes became notable allies. 
 Surely, I thought, if we can do this with pensions can we not do the same with social security? 
 If the absurdity of the present  position of the Death Grant were exposed to the public gaze, would not reform become easier? 
 I recognized that all would not be plain sailing. 
 Changing supplementary and housing benefit would be more contentious than reforming occupational pensions. 
 Nevertheless, I felt that an open inquiry should be the aim. 
 My resolve to set up an inquiry into the social security system was strengthened by one other important factor. 
 Like every other Secretary of State who has ever been in charge of social security, I was under pressure from the Treasury. 
 The department took the largest slice of the Government's budget and each year the Treasury demanded economies. 
 There was nothing remotely new in this. 
 My predecessor, Patrick Jenkin, had been pressed for savings and so too had his Labour predecessors, David Ennals and Barbara Castle. 
 The man in charge of controlling public spending is the Chief Secretary to the Treasury. 
 In the time of the Labour Government the Chief Secretary had been Joel Barnett and it was he who had forced Barbara Castle into her major and controversial changes. 
 During my time at the DHSS I met over the table with three Chief Secretaries and, I have to admit, had battles with them all. 
 My baptism of fire had been with Leon Brittan who was Chief Secretary until the 1983 general election. 
 Friendship, I fear, counts for very little when the fur really begins to fly. 
 Ken Clarke, having listened to one of our more heated exchanges, wondered if we would ever speak to each other again. 
 I also had fierce battles with Peter Rees, while Peter's successor, John MacGregor, maintained that I was the only minister who almost walked out of one of his &bquo;bilaterals&equo;. 
 I cannot remember that particular meeting &mdash; nor am I very proud of it &mdash; but the point illustrates the sometimes passionate disputes which can erupt during the annual public-spending negotiations. 
 No one should be too surprised at these clashes. 
 It is an inevitable fact of ministerial life. 
 The Treasury has responsibility for the health of the economy; the Social Services Department has responsibility for some of the poorest and most vulnerable people in the country. 
 Certainly I did not regard it as my job to defend the departmental budget just because it was the departmental budget. 
 On the other hand it most certainly was my job to prevent  indefensible cuts. 
 No one is going to thank you if you end up making changes which either cause real hardship or bring the political roof in &mdash; or manage to do both. 
 It is, of course, a matter of judgement and your viewpoint will depend on what Cabinet seat you occupy. 
 Former Chief Secretaries have been known to make spirited claims for additional resources when they move to a departmental job. 
 Colleagues who one year lecture you at the Star Chamber on how you have more than enough money turn up the next asking for extra themselves. 
 It is, nevertheless, crucial that such debates should take place. 
 A similar process happens each year in industry. 
 No manager, in any half-decent company, is able to get away with claiming that he has made all the improvements it is possible to make. 
 In the public-spending round of Government it is certainly true that departments overbid on the basis that when it comes to the crunch they can bring the bid down without damage. 
 Yet it is equally true that the Treasury just as consistently suggest economies that they do not expect to achieve but which concentrate the minister's mind and preferably chill his blood. 
 It is possible to make light of the process but, be under no illusion, it is a deadly serious affair. 
 If as Secretary of State you get it wrong, then you &mdash; and crucially the people you are serving &mdash; live with the consequences for the next twelve months and beyond. 
 And once changes are agreed, they cease to be the adjustments of the Government. 
 They become quite plainly your cuts &mdash; &bquo;Fowler's cuts&equo;. 
 You are virtually on your own in defending them, so you had better be convinced of the case before you agree to them. 
 It is for reasons like these that I crossed out the best part of two months each autumn to devote to the public-spending discussions. 
 Almost invariably, I ended up each year in front of the Star Chamber of ministers who were set up under the chairmanship of Willie Whitelaw to try to sort out the differences which remained between ministers and the Chief Secretary. 
 * 
 I announced the review of social security on Monday 2 April 1984. 
 Most attention concentrated on the last sentence of my  statement which I had inserted just before I stood up in the House of Commons: 
 Taken together the various reviews and studies I have set in hand constitute the most substantial examination of the social security system since the Beveridge report forty years ago. 
 It was no more than the truth. 
 Since the war, governments had by and large ducked the issue. 
 There had been a great deal of tinkering but no overall review. 
 But equally it was true that the circumstances of my review were very different from those of Lord Beveridge. 
 Beveridge had presented his report in 1942 at a time when it was overwhelmingly agreed that there should be no return to the conditions of the 1930s. 
 Yet for all their persuasiveness, the Beveridge proposals had not been implemented. 
 Beveridge wanted a system based on insurance, with the public making insurance contributions to finance benefits like the state pension. 
 But Beveridge was not a member of the post-war Labour Government. 
 No one was content to wait for insurance. 
 Instead, the new system was introduced on the pay-as-you-go basis which has bedevilled social security finance ever since. 
 Pay-as-you-go means that today s contributors pay for the pension of today's retired people &mdash; on the basis that the next generation will pick up the bill for today's contributors when they retire. 
 There is no invested fund, only promises of how much future contributors will be prepared to pay. 
 I was reporting in a cold public-spending climate. 
 Everywhere in the Western world social security budgets were under scrutiny, not to see if they were too meagre but to see if they could be reduced. 
 British ministers returned from trips to other countries with tales (usually apocryphal) about how budgets were being trimmed. 
 I had, however, one advantage that was denied to Beveridge. 
 I was not only able to review social security, I had the opportunity as a politician of implementing the changes &mdash; always provided I could get the support of my colleagues, of course, and that was not going to be easy. 
 Right from the start, there were tensions with Nigel Lawson's Treasury team. 
 What I wanted to do was to ensure that the social security budget was being spent to best effect. 
 It was easy to become mesmerized by the size of the budget, but when you looked  at it in detail you found that almost half went on pensions and other payments to the elderly; that 20 per cent went to families with children; 17 per cent went to the unemployed; and that 13 per cent went to the sick and disabled. 
 The spending may have been great but it was not being devoted to thousands upon thousands of undeserving and feckless claimants. 
 My view was that we should examine whether the money was reaching those that most needed it and whether the priorities of the system laid down in 1945 were still the same. 
 In the 1940s the elderly, often totally without pensions, were the first concern. 
 More and more, 1 became convinced that the priority for the 1990s should be families with children. 
 I believed that we should assess the future cost of the whole social security system, and make any necessary changes now. 
 My immediate aim, however, was a cost-neutral reform &mdash; and that was going to be difficult enough. 
 For if priorities are reordered without extra resources then inevitably there are losers as well as gainers. 
 The conventional political wisdom is that you hear from the losers, not the gainers. 
 Nevertheless, the Treasury were going to take some convincing that major savings in public spending were impossible. 
 Their concern was that we should save money. 
 Of even greater strategic importance to the review was a condition set down by the Chancellor at the very beginning. 
 Nigel Lawson was not prepared to contemplate any examination of the tax system. 
 Tax policy may have a profound effect on those on low incomes, but constitutionally any changes are a matter for the Chancellor of the Exchequer. 
 Hence the bulk of the Cabinet know only on the day of the Budget what changes are to be proposed in the afternoon. 
 Nigel had absolutely no intention of giving up any of his rights, and thus an examination of social security and tax together was impossible. 
 Inevitably this meant that the tax-credit system proposed by the Heath Government was not on the agenda and nor were some of the more ambitious income-guarantee schemes which inevitably required reform of taxation and social security being taken together. 
 By excluding taxation we missed an undoubted opportunity. 
 Only if tax is taken into account can the overall position of any individual be seen. 
 It is also not easy to say where social security begins and taxation ends. 
 National Insurance is both a tax to  finance current social-security spending and an entitlement to future benefit. 
 Yet even without tax, a review of social security was eminently justified on its own account and long overdue. 
 We paid out pensions to ten million people and Child Benefit to every family in the land. 
 We employed over 90,000 staff. 
 Whether tax was covered by the review or not, there were still decisions to be taken on such fundamental issues as the future of the pensions system, support for low-income families, and the special payments system which was breaking down. 
 There was a mountain of work to be done. 
 For the next nine months my review teams took evidence. 
 I continued to chair the inquiry into pensions and later took over family policy when the much liked Minister of State for Social Security, Rhodes Boyson, went off to be the number two in Northern Ireland. 
 His place was taken by promoting Tony Newton, who was already in charge of the group looking at supplementary benefit. 
 Tony was one of the undoubted stars of the review and became my invaluable right-hand man. 
 No one knows social security better and no one has a greater social commitment. 
 As with the pensions inquiry, we recruited outside experts into the review teams like Jeremy Rowe, the deputy chairman of Abbey National, who took on Housing Benefit. 
 The whole process was serviced and kept running by as exceptional a staff of civil servants as I ever worked with in over ten years as a Cabinet minister. 
 We took evidence in public and this went without interruption or serious demonstration. 
 It proved an invaluable way of putting issues on the table and encouraging serious debate. 
 When a review of the health service was set up following the 1987 general election, it was claimed that our kind of public review would be too slow. 
 In fact there was not much to choose between them. 
 Our advantage, however, was that we allowed the public to have their say on possible changes before proposals were published. 
 My immediate personal priority was pensions. 
 By June we had made sufficient progress for me to tell the House of Commons that we intended to move against the &bquo;frozen&equo; pension. 
 We would require by law that the pension left behind by the early leaver should be either revalued each year or transferable to the leaver's new scheme. 
 By July I was able to set out my proposals on personal pensions. 
 The case put forward by the pensions industry was less  than persuasive. 
 I certainly did not want existing company schemes to collapse and saw no reason why this should happen. 
 I did, however, want to provide the public with new options. 
 Some people covered by the conventional company scheme might prefer a personal pension. 
 Even more to the point, a new opportunity should be given to over 10 million people who were covered only by state provision. 
 The essence of personal pensions was that it extended choice and encouraged personal saving. 
 In the autumn of 1984 I introduced a bill to bring the first pension reforms into effect. 
 So far so good &mdash; but this still left me with what was to prove the most controversial part of the whole social security review. 
 No sensible review of social security could avoid the fact that the State Earnings Related Pension Scheme (known by its unlovely acronym, SERPS) was stacking up an enormous future bill for the public. 
 There were no funds building up. 
 Everything depended on contributors picking up the bill in ten, twenty or thirty years. 
 We had, in effect, written a post-dated cheque. 
 Between 1985 and 2025 the number of pensioners was set to rise from 9 million to over 12 million; and the total cost of pensions for the public would rise from &pound;17 billion a year to almost &pound;36 billion if pensions were linked with prices and to a colossal &pound;50 billion if they were linked, as Labour wanted, to the higher of either prices or earnings. 
 The bill for the retired population would be borne by the working population, but the ratio of contributors to pensioners would slowly worsen so that by 2025 there would be only 1.8 contributors for each pensioner. 
 Nor was this simply speculation. 
 The higher number of births from the mid-1950s and through the 1960s inevitably meant more pensioners sixty years on. 
 That was one side of the case against SERPS. 
 But there was also another. 
 There was an overwhelming case for the State providing a basic pension but less of one for the State providing an additional pension as well. 
 The second pension could be provided by an expanded pensions industry. 
 My view was that most people would prefer a pension that was theirs by right rather than being dependent on the decisions of government. 
 &bquo;A pension of your own&equo; could have the same kind of appeal as &bquo;a house of your own&equo;. 
 The role of Government should be to ensure that such pensions met sensible regulation so that the public interest was protected.  
 These ideas were confirmed by a special Gallup Opinion Poll we commissioned for the review. 
 Half those questioned had not heard of SERPS &mdash; which might not have been surprising had it not been that most were members of it. 
 But the crucial finding was this. 
 The sample was asked about the importance of having an occupational pension additional to the state provision. 
 Almost 90 per cent who were in schemes, and two-thirds of those not in schemes, said it was important or &bquo;very important&equo;. 
 As far as the industry was concerned, the case for SERPS was very simple. 
 They had experienced the uncertainties of the 1960s and 1970s and they now wanted stability. 
 Stability had not provided an increase in the number of occupational pensioners, but it had provided a secure environment for the lucky half of the nation who were covered. 
 As for Labour, they liked SERPS mainly because it was state provision and they could see no reason to allow future governments the freedom to devote public spending to other areas. 
 In January 1985 all the review teams, the advisers and the civil servants withdrew for a snow-bound week at Wilton Park, a Foreign Office mansion deep in the Sussex countryside. 
 Everybody was encouraged to have their say and the discussion was both productive and frank. 
 But in the final analysis the decisions &mdash; and the responsibility &mdash; were mine. 
 I still have a note of the objectives for the review I set out at Wilton Park: 
 First I want to achieve a twin-pillar system &mdash; that is, explicit recognition that social security is not just the State alone. 
 It also means individual contribution. 
 Second I want to encourage employment. 
 Nothing is more important than that we should take down the barriers &mdash; like National Insurance and pensions &mdash; which stand in the way of new employment and job mobility. 
 Third I want to tackle real need. 
 Our diagnosis of want shows that it is low-income families with children &mdash; the unemployed and low-wage earners &mdash; who are worst off. 
 Fourth I want to eliminate some of the complexity. 
 The case is self-evident. 
 Fifth I want to achieve a better delivery system &mdash; more cooperation with the tax system and better management. 
 It was against this background that the debate took place. 
 By the end of the week the threads had been brought together and the outline of the report decided. 
 Our proposals were that SERPS should be abolished and that the second pension should come from a variety of new options in the private sector which we would make available. 
 Child Benefit was to stay and a new benefit, Family Credit, was to be introduced for low-income families in work so that people could no longer be worse off in work than on the dole. 
 Supplementary Benefit was to give way to Income Support and the much-abused system of single payment was to be replaced by a Social Fund; Housing Benefit was to be reformed so that it did not discriminate against the low-paid in work; and the whole social security system was to be simplified. 
 Among the benefits to be abolished was the Death Grant, to be replaced by a system which gave full help to families who needed it and none to those who did not. 
 Public spending savings mostly came from the abolition of SERPS. 
 There were some comparatively small reductions to the Housing Benefit budget but the major savings &mdash; which ran into billions of pounds &mdash; were for the 1990s and the next century. 
 They would allow invaluable policy options for future governments; they demonstrated that our Government looked much further ahead than the next two or three years. 
 We had devised a new social security system which was intended to last. 
 On leaving Wilton Park, I went to Sutton Coldfield to write up the Green Paper. 
 Back in London I had a foretaste of the conflicts that were to come. 
 A special Cabinet committee under the chairmanship of Margaret Thatcher had been set up to review my proposals and effectively to decide whether they would become Government policy. 
 Although the final decision was with Cabinet, it would be most unlikely that they would overturn the views of a committee which had spent a number of weeks going through the proposals almost line by line &mdash; particularly given that half the Cabinet were on the committee and the Prime Minister was in the chair. 
 The decisions of the committee would be crucial in determining whether my proposals would be enacted.  
 Every paper to a Cabinet committee must be cleared by the Treasury. 
 This is for the sensible reason that the last thing ministers want to do is to listen to an argument about figures being wrong. 
 If the figures or the financial consequences are in dispute then that must be stated. 
 The first meeting of the Social Security Committee was set for Wednesday 6 February. 
 I needed to get my papers round before the weekend so that colleagues would have the opportunity to read them &mdash; the usual rule is that papers should be circulated to ministers seven days before a meeting. 
 For a variety of reasons the rule is often breached, but there would be no excuse for missing the deadline with a report which had taken so long to prepare. 
 First, however, I needed the Treasury to clear my paper &mdash; that is, to agree that it was an accurate description of the issues before the Government. 
 The draft went to the Treasury and on Thursday 31 January I went over to Downing Street for Cabinet. 
 Both Norman Tebbit and John Wakeham were now back after the Grand Hotel blast and the opportunity had been taken to arrange a Cabinet photograph. 
 Just before we were to go upstairs to be photographed, an agitated Nigel Lawson came up to me saying that he wanted a word. 
 He had seen the draft. 
 &bquo;It won't do,&equo; he said. 
 I had made proposals on National Insurance but that, said Nigel, was a Budget matter. 
 &bquo;You have no authority to make proposals on National Insurance.&equo; 
 It was a head-on clash. 
 There was no attempt to persuade and the result was that I blew up. 
 I had, after all, been working on the review for the last year. 
 I said that I had never heard anything more extraordinary. 
 How could I make proposals on social security without mentioning National Insurance for which I had ministerial responsibility? 
 No, said Nigel, it was not in the terms of reference. 
 I replied that if colleagues agreed with him then we could forget about the whole review. 
 The argument continued up the stairs to Downing Street's reception rooms &mdash; where we paused to smile and be photographed &mdash; and all the way down again. 
 As we sat down for Cabinet I told Nigel that we must meet afterwards. 
 This we did &mdash; by which time we had both calmed down a little. 
 Nigel changed tack and his tone became more accommodating. 
 He said that he did not mind discussing changes to National Insurance with me, but he did not want to involve the whole Cabinet committee. 
 I still found the  argument extraordinary, but I also had to take into account the fact that if Nigel retained this stance then the committee meeting would have to be postponed and the whole exercise would get off to a terrible start. 
 In the end we compromised and deferred the issue for later discussion between us. 
 As it happened that could not have worked out better. 
 The aim of my proposals was to reduce the burden on the low paid. 
 A few weeks later when it came to the 1985 Budget, Nigel set himself the same goal. 
 We each had different schemes, but we shared a common purpose. 
 It showed what could be achieved when the Treasury and the DHSS worked together. 
 The Cabinet's Social Security Committee met in the Downing Street Cabinet room for the first time on Wednesday 6 February 1985. 
 Margaret Thatcher was in the chair. 
 Nigel was conciliatory:. 
 although he would want to return to the question of public spending savings, he said that the report was a very thorough examination and also exceptionally well written. 
 Even at this early stage it was clear that there was general sympathy for the proposition that SERPS should be phased out. 
 The only question was what, if anything, should replace it. 
 We here came to a central issue in all our discussions. 
 As SERPS was a pay-as-you-go scheme there were no immediate savings from its abolition. 
 This is the essential dilemma (some would say dishonesty) of pay-as-you-go. 
 SERPS consists of no more than a promise that future generations will pick up the bill. 
 There are no reserves or investments to back these promises. 
 If SERPS is abolished, future generations will certainly be relieved of a burden. 
 The present generation, however, still has to finance the promises already made. 
 The savings build up slowly &mdash; although over the years their total is immense. 
 There is no altogether painless way of escaping from a pay-as-you-go scheme, particularly if you want people to make substitute provision. 
 The one certainty, however, that confronted the Cabinet committee was demographic: if you left SERPS as it was then the eventual bill would become greater and greater as the proportion of contributors to pensioners declined. 
 My view was that we should bite the bullet, abolish SERPS and encourage substitute private pensions. 
 In this I had the enthusiastic support of the Prime Minister who believed that the state scheme  should be replaced by individual private pension provision with a minimum compulsory requirement. 
 This took the issue a giant step forward. 
 During the review I had been to Switzerland where I had seen a compulsory occupational scheme successfully in operation. 
 On Wednesday 13 February, we met for the second time with pensions as the agenda item. 
 The only opposition to replacing SERPS with occupational or personal pension provision came from the Treasury on the grounds of cost. 
 They were concerned about the cost of the increased tax relief which would inevitably result if the whole working population were covered by occupational pensions. 
 The savings were major but they were in the future; the costs would arise now. 
 The prize, however, was that the whole working population would have a pension of their own. 
 Personal savings would be increased and personal commitment improved. 
 We had the opportunity to make a fundamental change, and I could not believe that we would allow that opportunity to slip away. 
 That too was the conclusion of the special Cabinet committee and the decision was taken that SERPS should be replaced. 
 I now faced difficulties on another front. 
 On Thursday 14 February the Cabinet had had its annual pre-Budget meeting when Nigel Lawson warned that public spending was still too high. 
 Several voices were raised on the potential for savings in social security but no decision was taken. 
 On 25 February, the special Cabinet committee turned its attention to the reform of supplementary benefit but the meeting was inconclusive. 
 The next day I found out why. 
 On 22 February the Chief Secretary to the Treasury, Peter Rees, had minuted the Prime Minister saying that the Chancellor and he had come to the conclusion that the Government should aim to save &pound;2 billion from the social security review by 1987&ndash;8. 
 The minute stopped the Cabinet committee dead in its tracks &mdash; for the good reason that I was not prepared to go on. 
 The disagreement was fundamental. 
 The Chancellor wanted a promise of &pound;2 billion in savings. 
 1 was not prepared to give it. 
 If such a total were set down, it would blow the whole review out of the water. 
 I saw no point in continuing until the point was settled. 
 I spent the next few days talking to Cabinet colleagues &mdash; all of whom  shared my view that the demand was preposterous &mdash; and then went to see the Prime Minister. 
 My case was simple. 
 If we accepted this entirely arbitrary target, the review would be seen merely as a cost-cutting exercise and not about the reform of social security. 
 All our work of the last eighteen months would be destroyed. 
 As at other stages of the review, Margaret Thatcher acted as mediator and the result of the meeting was that no &pound;2 billion target was set down. 
 The way was open for the Cabinet committee to get back to work. 
 Our next meeting did not take place until after the Budget in mid-March, but from then on the committee ran reasonably smoothly through to its seventh and last meeting at the start of April. 
 At the end of this meeting I was where I wanted to be. 
 The major changes &mdash; the replacement of SERPS, the introduction of Family Credit, Income Support and the Social Fund, and the reform of Housing Benefit &mdash; were all intact. 
 The structure for the new social security system was there. 
 It was as near a cost-neutral reform as was practical. 
 We had certainly made some fully justified savings in Housing Benefit but these were a very long way from the &pound;2 billion ambitions of the Treasury. 
 Outside Whitehall there was now intense speculation about what was to happen. 
 In spite of the best endeavours of a range of correspondents, practically none of our plans had been leaked. 
 Some of the speculation had been self-cancelling with newspapers predicting that the Government would take quite opposite courses. 
 Much had been wrong. 
 Our luck finally ran out on Thursday 18 April when the Daily Telegraph ran a lead story, not from their Social Services or Political Correspondent, but from their Economics Correspondent, Frances Williams. 
 This predicted with remarkable accuracy that the Government had decided to scrap SERPS and that the task would be transferred to private schemes and companies. 
 It is idle to speculate on the source of leaks &mdash; that I did learn in my years in Government &mdash; but what was certain was that the Telegraph story could not have appeared at a worse time. 
 The proposals were due to be considered by Cabinet ten days later and ministers do not like seeing what they are to discuss plastered all over the press beforehand. 
 Even more to the point, a leak of this kind simply hands to the Opposition a weapon on a silver plate  and raises fears on your own benches. 
 And so it was. 
 Over the next few days the press was busy reporting doubts about the political wisdom of abolishing SERPS among &bquo;ministers and Conservative MPs&equo; while the Opposition tabled a censure motion calling on the Government to withdraw its plans to abolish SERPS and its &bquo;callous dismantling of the Welfare State&equo;. 
 I was in a hole. 
 The leak was accurate and I was being forced to the floor of the House of Commons to defend a policy before it had been to Cabinet. 
 I was also under no illusion that some backbenchers on our side were nervous about the policy. 
 The forthcoming debate promised to be a highly uncomfortable occasion with my defence alternating between &bquo;no decisions have been taken&equo; and &bquo;wait and see&equo;. 
 Neither defence was likely to go down conspicuously well in a crowded House. 
 At this crucial point I was thrown a lifeline by, of all people, the Opposition Spokesman on Social Services, Michael Meacher. 
 Michael Meacher had entered the House with me in 1970 and, early on, earned a reputation as a conscientious, if rather dull, expert in the social policy area. 
 As the years had gone by, however, his style had changed. 
 He was forever denouncing me during Parliamentary Questions in the most lurid terms but the denunciations were invariably so protracted that even his own side lost interest. 
 Perhaps conscious that he had gained a megaphone reputation, Meacher had settled down to his own social security review. 
 His plan was to pre-empt my own and it is true that he was first to publish some of his proposals. 
 The only trouble was that under questioning it became clear that one of his central aims was to abolish mortgage tax relief. 
 What was more, it was far from clear whether the Shadow Cabinet actually supported, or indeed had been consulted on, this proposal. 
 The result was the Commons debate became a debate on the Meacher proposals, not the Fowler ones. 
 Demonstrating that it is not just Government ministers who get neurotic about the media, Meacher desperately blamed &bquo;malicious and fabricated press reporting&equo;. 
 But the headlines the day after the debate said it all: &bquo;Meacher defends benefit proposal.&equo; 
 &equo; Meacher gets a grilling.&equo; 
 And even: &bquo;Meacher says document is election winner.&equo; 
 This last headline did not seem fully to express the collective view of the Shadow Cabinet and the next instalments of the Meacher plans  for social security never appeared &mdash; much to our disappointment. 
 But seeing off Michael Meacher proved substantially easier than seeing off the Chancellor of the Exchequer. 
 Cabinet consideration of the social security review was set for Thursday 25 April. 
 The papers had been cleared by the Treasury and gone round to ministers. 
 I had reported the results of the committee discussions and, unless an unexpected point was raised at the meeting, the outcome looked set fair. 
 On the Tuesday night, however, my Private Secretary, Steve Godber, rang me at a dinner to tell me that at the eleventh hour Nigel Lawson had put round a minute which sought to reopen the whole issue of the replacement for SERPS. 
 It was scarcely credible that this should happen at so late a stage and I asked the department to get the minute to me at once. 
 The Chancellor's minute maintained that the abolition of SERPS and the introduction of a new scheme would add to public spending. 
 There would be the cost of additional tax relief and the extra costs for private industry and the public sector. 
 If we made the scheme cover the self-employed, then their costs would increase too. 
 Nigel Lawson then proposed we should either scrap SERPS and put nothing in its place or leave the whole issue until the next Parliament. 
 But what most angered me was the last-minute timing of the intervention. 
 Most of the points had been raised before and those which had not been raised most certainly could have been. 
 With less than forty-eight hours before the crucial Cabinet meeting, the Chancellor of the Exchequer and the Social Services Secretary were in fundamental disagreement. 
 On Wednesday morning I did two things. 
 First, I told the Cabinet Office I was not prepared to have my paper discussed with this division outstanding. 
 Whatever the difficulties, I wanted the social security review off Thursday's Cabinet agenda. 
 To continue would only mean chaos at the Cabinet meeting itself. 
 Next I went to see Nigel. 
 I have rarely been angrier than I was that day. 
 I said that his action was indefensible and even &bquo;unconstitutional&equo;. 
 By that I meant that the Treasury had cleared the papers for Cabinet and that agreement on the policy went back several months. 
 Nigel saw my anger and was obviously surprised that I had taken the review off the Cabinet agenda. 
 He nevertheless maintained that it would have been irresponsible of him to have gone forward without  warning colleagues of his reservations. 
 We had reached a position of stalemate &mdash; but a position which for the sake of the Government had to be settled. 
 This time the postponement of the ministerial discussion well and truly made the press. 
 Accurately enough, the papers portrayed the battle as The Great Lawson v Fowler Row. 
 The following Monday we met at Downing Street in an attempt to sort it all out. 
 By this meeting Nigel had come up with a further solution: rather than abolish SERPS, he suggested that we modify it to the point that it could be afforded. 
 This had always been the fall-back position, but at this late stage in the argument it cut no ice. 
 The last person to reopen decisions already taken was Margaret Thatcher. 
 Over the next days we fine-tuned the scheme and made some useful improvements. 
 The only basic concession we made to the Chancellor was to exclude the self-employed on the grounds that they were not covered by SERPS in any event. 
 For the rest, the only changes were ones that made the scheme easier to introduce. 
 Thus we agreed a way of phasing it in that reduced the cost of introduction but provided no disruption for those nearest retirement. 
 The social security review went to Cabinet in two instalments. 
 On Thursday 2 May, I opened with a slide show which took the Cabinet through all the changes and complexities of the subject. 
 Following this we approved most of the detailed proposals. 
 The next Thursday, after still more work on pensions, we took the abolition of SERPS and its replacement by a compulsory occupational scheme to Cabinet. 
 That was also agreed. 
 The only thing that remained was to complete the writing of the Green Paper and the small matter of explaining the proposals to the House of Commons and the public. 
 The debate in Government had taken longer than we anticipated. 
 Nevertheless, I was determined that we would publish our Green Paper in time for a proper consultation and the preparation of legislation in the autumn. 
 Over Whitsun we were on holiday on the Isle of Wight and I dictated the very last corrections to the Green Paper to one of my overworked social security team from a public phone box in Seaview. 
 Publication was set for Monday 3 June. 
 The House was crowded for my statement. 
 The atmosphere was more like the Budget than an announcement on social security.  
 Most of the Labour front bench, including Neil Kinnock, were in their places and the predictions were that I was in for a stormy time. 
 Even stout warriors like Ken Clarke felt that all the rows, the leaks and the speculation were going to make my task difficult. 
 Yet, as often happens in the House of Commons, the predictions of a major confrontation proved false. 
 Making the statement, I was conscious of the silence in the House as it listened to the proposals. 
 Then I heard the growls of support coming from our own side for proposals like Family Credit and the ending of SERPS. 
 I sat down to a great Conservative cheer and then Michael Meacher had his opportunity. 
 If ever a politician lost his audience with his first sentence it was Meacher. 
 It was, he said, a &bquo;new Victorian Poor Law&equo; which would pave the way for the election of a Labour Government at the next election. 
 From my side there were hoots of derision while the embarrassment on his own side was clear as Labour members found a sudden fascination in the detail of the Chamber's roof. 
 It was game and set if not yet match. 
 For the next few weeks the debate on the reforms rolled on. 
 Labour demanded that we publish illustrative figures on the effect of the changes on pensioners and claimants. 
 This we did and, of course, the figures showed losers as well as gainers. 
 There was nothing in the structure of the new scheme that meant there had to be losers. 
 But dividing up the existing budget to reflect new priorities meant giving more in some areas and less in others. 
 We could only have avoided that had we devoted some extra resources to the social security budget. 
 I had not asked for that and, even if I had, my chances of obtaining them would have been zero. 
 The consultation period came to an end on 16 September and we then got down to work assessing the reaction. 
 It is no weakness to take notice of what is being said in such a consultation. 
 The press always urge you to do so &mdash; and then, when you do, immediately write it up as a U-turn. 
 But there is every reason to try to get as much support for change as possible. 
 For example, our original proposal was that Family Credit should be paid through the pay-packet. 
 This had a number of advantages. 
 It brought tax and benefit closer together, and putting family credit explicitly on the pay-slip showed total new earnings &mdash; demonstrating, among other things, the gap between take-home wages and unemployment pay. 
 But a range of people inside and outside the House of Commons,  deliver. 
 I had to get an already highly controversial bill through both Houses of Parliament and then introduce the new system without serious accident. 
 It was going to be a major battle and there were plenty of press predictions that the radical changes would cost us the next general election. 
 It is a good rule for a government entering a battle of that kind to be united. 
 We were not. 
 To have taken on the world in that state would have been political suicide. 
 I was not paid to preside over disasters &mdash; however noble the cause. 
 I had to think again. 
 One advantage of the Green-Paper debate was that the discussion had moved on. 
 When I had started to examine pensions, many in the industry were opposed to any change in SERPS and almost everyone was opposed to personal pensions. 
 Eighteen months later, personal pensions were accepted and the new consensus was that the Government should save money by reducing the benefits of SERPS rather than abolishing it. 
 Just before Christmas 1985, I published the White Paper which set out the Government's new proposals for legislation. 
 By a number of changes we reduced the emerging cost of SERPS by an eventual &pound;13 billion, but the crucial part of the proposals were the new options we gave to the public. 
 It was made easier for companies to set up their own schemes and for the first time everyone would be given the right of a personal pension of their own. 
 Unit trusts, building societies and banks would be able to provide personal pensions and Nigel Lawson agreed that a 2 per cent National Insurance incentive should be given to those who joined the new schemes. 
 The expansion of occupational and personal pensions remained a firm objective of the reforms. 
 The compromise was accepted by industry and the opposition melted away. 
 There were fierce fights along the way &mdash; particularly in the House of Lords &mdash; but the concession on pensions took much of the wind out of the Opposition's sails. 
 The legislation went on to the statute book in July 1986 and the new system was finally introduced in April 1988. 
 And what has been the effect of the reforms? 
 Family Credit now provides double the spending power for low-income families than its predecessor scheme and more help is provided for children through the Income Support system. 
 The Social Fund has been successfully introduced without all the problems nervously  predicted by some of the experts. 
 The unemployment trap has been substantially eased and the simplification of social security has had major effects. 
 The whole system is now operating more efficiently. 
 The time taken to process claims has been reduced; the error rate is down; and claimants are spending less time waiting. 
 Social security is no longer a jungle of files and paper where only the skilled claimant triumphs. 
 Yet in many ways the most spectacular success has been the new pension options. 
 Over four million people have taken out personal pensions. 
 Over 800,000 people are now covered by new occupational pension schemes. 
 Contrary to the industry's predictions, existing company schemes have not collapsed. 
 The public have been provided with more choices, and have shown that they want a pension which is theirs by right. 
 The social security review made some fundamental improvements, but that should not be the end of reform in this area. 
 Very rarely can you finish the process of change in one step. 
 The progressive stage-by-stage reform of trade union legislation shows a more useful model for modern government. 
 The case for abolishing SERPS altogether and for second pensions to be provided by funded schemes in the private sector remains powerful. 
 We need to make more progress in achieving a decade of retirement between the ages of sixty and seventy with men and women deciding for themselves when they want to retire. 
 We need to provide a basic income guarantee for pensioners which will benefit existing pensioners who have retired without the benefit of today's occupational schemes. 
 Above all, a new review should build on the improvements we made but correct the mistake of 1985 and consider social security and tax together. 
 According to Beveridge there were five giants on the road of national reconstruction in 1942: Disease, Ignorance, Squalor, Idleness and Want. 
 By providing income, social security is the most effective means of tackling want. 
 It may be technical and difficult to understand but no policy area is more important for poor people. 
 Regular &mdash; and open &mdash; reviews of how we are meeting the challenge of want should be a feature of modern government. 
 THE CHURCH'S YEAR 
 Justification by Faith and Christian Living To East Midlands Diocesan Evangelical Fellowship, 25 January 1986 
 &bquo;Justification by faith&equo; is hardly a common expression these days, even in the Church, and we can very easily misunderstand what it means. 
 In Galatians 2 Paul tackles the theme of the Law and explores the nature of salvation. 
 He tells us that God's salvation is not dependent on our good acts, or obedience to any man-made or even God-given law. 
 &bquo;We&hellip; know&equo;, says Paul, &bquo;that a man is not justified by works of the law but through faith in Jesus Christ&hellip; because by works of the law shall no one be justified&equo; (Galatians 2.16). 
 Paul is declaring that none of the things we boast about, or trust in &mdash; intellect, upbringing, orthodoxy, good life, and so on &mdash; are vehicles of salvation. 
 Each is tarnished by sin and, clothed in these acts of righteousness, I am clothed in rags before Almighty God. 
 Yet, says Paul, what the Law could not do, Christ did: he identified himself with my sin and took my place. 
 So we have that remarkable verse, Galatians 3.13: &bquo;Christ redeemed us from the curse of the law, having become a curse for us.&equo; 
 Here we have a wonderful insight. 
 Christ, in some mysterious way, takes upon himself our folly and failure and makes it his own, so that we may go free. 
 I say &bquo;mysterious&equo;, and so it must remain. 
 Paul Zahl in his book Deliver us from Evil  gives a graphic illustration of a bush fire sweeping towards two duck hunters. 
 The roar of the crackling fire drew near and doom seemed inevitable. 
 Then the more experienced hunter struck a match and, lighting another fire, they stood on the leeward side of the new fire. 
 That, too, roared away. 
 Then the pair of them returned to the place of the burnt-out patch and in the relative safety of that refuge huddled there as the bush fire swept  down on them. 
 They escaped because where fire had passed fire could not come. 
 It is a useful illustration as long as we remember that no illustration is exact. 
 God's judgement is not impersonal. 
 Nevertheless, Paul is saying that Jesus' death affected him so profoundly that by standing in his shadow he is forgiven and justified. 
 Paul now adds another element. 
 Justification &bquo;by grace through faith&equo; means that Christ's righteousness is &bquo;imputed&equo; to me. 
 &bquo;Abraham &bquo;believed God, and it was reckoned to him as righteousness&equo; (Galatians 3.6). 
 Now, how can it be that believing can be &bquo;reckoned&equo; as righteousness? 
 It seems as improbable as a foodless meal! 
 However, our error is to think of God's Law as though it were a legal system. 
 Israel's great sin wasn't that it did not do good things &mdash; but that it did not obey  the Law, the Torah. 
 It wasn't committed to its God and wasn't therefore committed to his way of doing things. 
 The point about the story of Abraham, which is a key paradigm in Galatians, is that he obeyed God and committed himself, his family and his future to God. 
 He left home on the word of promise; he was prepared to sacrifice his son because God said so; and his trust in God was estimated in terms of relationship to God. 
 God was saying in so many words: &bquo;Because he trusted in me and put me first I will honour him. 
 He is my son.&equo; 
 God's righteousness was, therefore, imputed to him; reckoned as if he were the most holy person of all. 
 Finally, justification means a new relationship has begun. 
 We are redeemed, made new. 
 Christ now takes possession of us. 
 Galatians 2.20 must be among the most marvellous words of the Bible: &bquo;I have been crucified with Christ; it is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me; and the life I now live in the flesh I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.&equo; 
 That is, the person who is justified is now under new ownership. 
 A new relationship has begun, with the most momentous consequences for life, and we are going to look at some of those consequences soon. 
 First we must pull this together. 
 Justification by faith means that Christ's righteousness is ours; it has been imputed to us. 
 It does not mean that we have been made righteous as if we are perfect and free from sin, because our daily experience will tell us of the power of sin; but it does mean that we are declared   righteous. 
 God says to us, &bquo;Yes, you are guilty, unworthy and deserving of punishment but I have provided for your forgiveness.&equo; 
 That was Martin Luther's great discovery, that salvation comes from God's grace and it is made available through faith. 
 Luther saw that it was not a matter of his own work but God's work. 
 &bquo;God so loved the world that he gave his only Son that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life&equo; (John 3.16). 
 &bquo;When I saw that the Law meant one thing and the Gospel another&equo;, said Luther, &bquo;I broke through.&equo; 
 Now this idea came under tremendous attack because the Church of Luther's day thought that he was denying good works and asserting personal experience. 
 This doctrine of justification subsequently broke the Western Church in two. 
 Speaking in the Week of Prayer for Christian Unity, it would be all too tempting for Protestants to say to Catholics: &bquo;This is the doctrine which still divides, and unless you accept this doctrine too, you cannot be saved.&equo; 
 Let me say a few things about this. 
 First, there is no denying the tragedy of separated Christians, and I for one long for the Church to be one. 
 It is a great joy to report that on this doctrine a growing convergence is coming about between Catholics and Protestants as we have begun the demanding task of doing theology together. 
 Second, no one is saved by a doctrine. 
 Justification by faith does not save us. 
 Only Christ does and can. 
 Justification is a descriptive doctrine; it is a way of explaining what God does for us in Christ. 
 Third, many will point out that justification is conspicuous in the New Testament by its absence. 
 It is essentially a Pauline concept. 
 It is not found on the lips of Jesus, rarely in the Acts of the Apostles and never in John. 
 Why, some might question, is there such an emphasis on something which is so peripheral to the New Testament? 
 The answer we readily give is that it is significant because it sums up the gospel. 
 The word &bquo;Trinity&equo; is not a biblical word, but no Christian will want to say that it is insignificant. 
 It describes God to us. 
 Justification by faith, similarly, is important only because it goes to the heart of what it is to be a follower of Christ. 
 We see then that the idea introduces us to a radical gospel which brings an uncomfortable message to our hearts. 
 It says: &bquo;You are dead in trespasses and sins, but God is on your side. 
  He wants you back with him. 
 Turn to him and the gospel will declare, &bquo;You are accepted.&equo; 
 A radical gospel has radical implications, however, and to these we turn. 
 A radical personal life 
 One of Luther's great statements about justification was that of our standing before God as simul justus et peccator  &mdash; that we are sinful and yet righteous before God at the same time. 
 It was one of those very profound observations which was misunderstood at the time but is now widely accepted by Roman Catholic scholars among others. 
 Being &bquo;sinful&equo; and &bquo;just&equo; is not the equivalent of having your cake and eating it, but an existential awareness of what it is to be a human being in a sinful and fallen world. 
 By grace I am saved and therefore Christ's righteousness is attributed to me. 
 That means, Luther said, God sees me as holy in Christ. 
 Nevertheless, as long as I am in this world I remain a sinner, still capable of letting him down. 
 Let me give two illustrations that might unpack this a little more. 
 When I was a student one of my fellow students was a fairly rude, arrogant young man. 
 One day after a very difficult time with him, I exploded and said to him: &bquo;I can't say that the Christian faith has made much difference to your life!&equo; 
 To this he calmly replied, with more charity than I deserved: &bquo;Well, you should have seen what I was like before I became one!&equo; 
 There is a verse from a hymn, attributed to John Newton: 
 I am not what I ought to be, 
 I am not what one day I hope to be, 
 But, praise God, I am not what I used to be, 
 And I am what I am by the grace of God. 
 A rather convoluted verse, but how right it is! 
 The first radical lesson is to stop pretending: you are accepted! 
 The second illustration came from my parish ministry in Durham. 
 Tony and Margaret were childless and they befriended Stephen, a boy in a Barnardo's home. 
 Stephen was a normal boy of seven, full of life and fun and pranks. 
 Eventually he moved into their home and they prepared to adopt him. 
 They told him they were going to do this, the papers were  signed and he became their son. 
 Then one day &bquo;Margaret came to see me. 
 They were worried. 
 It wasn't working out as they had hoped. 
 Stephen was strung up about something, and was behaving unnaturally. 
 Margaret explained: &bquo;Stephen seems to be trying too hard. 
 He is so anxious about being accepted that he is trying to be extra good and even perfect.&equo; 
 Stephen's problem, in short, was that he was not living as a son but as a slave in bondage to fear. 
 So after talking it over with me, Tony and Margaret sat down with him and said: &bquo;Stephen, look, here are the adoption papers. 
 You are our son, our child. 
 We chose you, you belong to us. 
 We will never send you back. 
 However naughty you are we will still love you.&equo; 
 It was as if a great load fell from his shoulders. 
 In many ways we Christians also need to be reminded of our position before God. 
 I think it was Professor Thomas Torrance who replied to a question concerning his &bquo;conversion &bquo;with the reply: &bquo;I have been converted three times. 
 First I was saved in eternity in the plan of God the Father, next I was saved at Calvary through the atoning work of God the Son, finally I was saved on Monday 30 June 19&mdash; through the converting work of God the Holy Spirit.&equo; 
 Here we see the work of the Trinity in our lives. 
 The equivalent of Stephen &bquo;s adoption papers is the cross of Christ which blazons abroad &bquo;This is the place where your pardon was sealed&equo;. 
 Calvary declares that you are &bquo;ransomed, healed, restored, forgiven &bquo;. 
 The joy of knowing forgiveness 
 God's intention is that everyone should enjoy the birthright of assurance. 
 There is no escaping the note of joy in the New Testament about the Christian life. 
 Read Acts and you will see it appearing again and again. 
 It wasn't emotionalism; it was the joy of knowing that they were forgiven people, made new through the gift of salvation and the gift of the Spirit. 
 James Denney wrote: 
 Nothing is more characteristic of churches than their attitude to assurance and the place they give to it in their preaching and systems of doctrine. 
 Speaking broadly, we may say that in the Roman church it is regarded as presumption, in the Protestant churches it is a privilege or a duty, but in the New Testament it is simply a fact. 
 This  explains the joy which side by side with the sense of infinite obligation is the characteristic note of apostolic Christianity. 
 In a biography about the godly E.B. Pusey, one of the Tractarians of the last century, this is written: 
 The absence of joy in his religious life was only the inevitable effect of his conception of God's method of saving man; in parting with the Lutheran truth concerning justification he parted with the springs of gladness. 
 Whether or not the biographer was right, it is true that once you can exclaim &bquo;Abba, Father!&equo;, joy is the accompanying fruit of the Spirit and it sheds its radiance over life and death. 
 Indeed it transforms death and gives hope where there was darkness. 
 A transformed emotional life 
 Justification by faith means that once I am accepted I can begin to live with myself. 
 I never cease to be amazed at the damage human beings do to one another. 
 In my pastoral ministry I have met so many people, some of them convinced Evangelicals, who believe in justification by faith with their heads, yet are condemned by their hearts. 
 Peter was a very successful academic with an enormous salary, a lovely family and supportive wife. 
 Yet at the age of forty he still regarded himself a failure because his mother had projected on to him her anxieties to such an extent that he never felt he matched up to her expectation of him. 
 He was only able to shed that bondage through a charismatic experience which reassured him that he was a child of God. 
 I would not be surprised if today there are a number of people who, though fully Christian, have never allowed justification by faith to be an experiential reality in their life. 
 To put it another way, they have never really allowed its truth to blossom into fullness of life. 
 Certainly Paul's experience expressed in Galatians 2.20 is that of Christ's life and love possessing him fully.  
 The outworking of the Spirit in our lives 
 In Galatians 3.2, Paul asks: &bquo;Did you receive the Spirit by works of the law, or by hearing with faith?&equo; 
 He concludes that it is by faith. 
 Now Paul only mentions this incidentally, but it certainly corroborates the testimony of Acts to the working of the Spirit in the early Church. 
 In Scripture the Holy Spirit works in a twofold way in our lives. 
 First, he is the Spirit of holiness . 
 Many have scoffed at justification by faith, believing that it is a fiction only, a make-believe doctrine that has no reality in fact. 
 But justification is never merely a doctrine. 
 If it does not result in a changed life, a holy life, there is no reality about it &mdash; there is, in short, no justification. 
 There is, I want to argue, a direct correlation between justification by faith and a holy life. 
 If you are going to preach conversion &mdash; and I hope we shall in many different ways and, skilfully, with many different nuances &mdash; you cannot avoid the consequences: it is going to lead to transformed lives. 
 A girl who became a Christian at university went back home to her sceptical parents. 
 Before she returned to her college her father said to her: &bquo;Well, I don &bquo;t know what to make of your religion &mdash; but I will say this, it's made you easier to live with.&equo; 
 That is a testimony which is often heard. 
 Christianity affects our lives. 
 It has a practical outworking in the way we live. 
 Then, the second work of the Holy Spirit is to make weak people strong . 
 For too long we have lived with no expectation of renewal, or growth, or power. 
 The person who is justified, the church which believes this, Christians who believe in a God who changes lives, cannot just simply go through the motions. 
 The faith not only has an experiential reality, it has dynamic consequences as well. 
 So, it is not at all surprising that the church which launches out in faith will find the power of God at hand. 
 I pray that the Church will learn to live adventurously on the frontier of faith. 
 A radical effect on church life 
 Just as we individually are simul justus et peccator  so is the Church &mdash; holy in Christ, yet sinful in itself. 
 Spurgeon was right to say to that lady who left his church to join a church she felt was perfect: &bquo;Well, Madam, when you find your perfect church don't join it &mdash; you'll only spoil it!&equo; 
 When we get  fed up with the worship, the vicar, the organist, or other elements of church life, we should remember that justification by faith in the fellowship means accepting that our differences are as important to God as our similarities. 
 I would like to see justification by faith working its way through our fellowships, enabling us to accept one another on the basis of our fellowship in Christ. 
 Be on the look-out when Pelagianism sets in: &bquo;Thou shalt be justified by good works&equo;, by doing the vicar's mall, by the way you read the lessons, by the work you do towards the Christmas bazaar! 
 Be on the look-out when ordinary people are despised because they don't speak the way you do, or because they come from the council estate. 
 We have to ask of our church life: Do our structures and our services proclaim this doctrine of acceptance and freedom in Christ? 
 We have considered a topic which is, perhaps regrettably, not at the centre of Anglican attention. 
 I don't want to get it out of proportion with other great doctrines of the faith, but this subject goes to the very heart of the gospel and has radical implications for everyday life. 
 I want to say in conclusion that it has as many consequences for the devout Evangelical as it does for the hardened Catholic. 
 We have to confess that Evangelicalism has sometimes, perhaps even often, expressed itself in a hard, legalistic framework leading to a dull and often joyless form of Christianity. 
 This ought not to be the case. 
 Justification is, as I have said, a declarative doctrine that we are sons and daughters of a heavenly Father. 
 As Paul says in Romans 5.15&ndash;17: &bquo;When we cry, &bquo;Abba! 
 Father!&equo;&equo; it is the Spirit himself bearing witness with our spirit that we are children of God, and if children, then heirs.&equo; 
 What a wonderful truth! 
 Isn't it about time we started living off our inheritance?  
 fundamentalism &mdash; Friend of Foe? 
 York Minster, I May 1987 
 It may seem rather surprising to some that the Principal of Trinity College should be giving a lecture on fundamentalism and subjecting it to some criticism. 
 After all, did not a distinguished predecessor of mine write an important book in the 1950s entitled Fundamentalism and the Word of God ? 
 I ought to explain that in this talk I am not attacking fundamentalism as such &mdash; I am in fact asking what are its strengths, weaknesses and challenges. 
 Perhaps most importantly of all, I am asking what Anglicanism can learn from this trend in church life. 
 What is fundamentalism? 
 I need not tell you how topical this subject is. 
 Perhaps you saw the two TV programmes on American fundamentalism recently which put the ghastly and unacceptable face of that form of fundamentalism before us. 
 It is a fundamentalism which imposes an edifice of avarice, deception and patriotism on the claims of Jesus Christ. 
 We must remember &bquo;of course, that many fundamentalists wholeheartedly reject that type of Christian behaviour. 
 It is not typical of fundamentalism. 
 Fundamentalism at its simplest is the reduction of a faith, a political creed or a way of life to an extreme and recognizable core which dominates that faith. 
 This core is elevated to the position of an absolute which is inviolable, sacred and undisputed &mdash; undisputed, that is, by the faithful. 
 No criticism is allowed to touch this Mount Olympus of belief; unquestioning faith and obedience is required to keep the believer within the fold of the faith. 
 This kind of fundamentalism is easily identifiable in the world today. 
 We see it in the fundamentalism of Shiite Islam, where blind faith sends thousands of people to a pointless war. 
 We may see it even in political fundamentalism &mdash; where the teachings of a reformer are still seen as the crystal  clear teachings which are the pure source of revelation, and from which deviation is heresy. 
 There is, of course, the fundamentalism of tradition. 
 When certain assumptions are challenged, such as the ordination of women to the priesthood, suddenly tradition is seen as an inviolable and fixed form of living truth which compels the Church for ever to say &bquo;no&equo; to the ordination of women. 
 When the Alternative Service Book was threatening the absolutism of the Book of Common Prayer a few years ago, the Book of Common Prayer was being spoken of as if it were on a par with Holy Writ. 
 The story goes that when the House of Commons was discussing this issue, a leading politician was heard to exclaim: &bquo;If the Book of Common prayer was good enough for St Paul, it is good enough for me! &bquo; 
 Fundamentalism, then, is a simple expression of a faith which is said to enshrine the sacred tenets of a belief-structure. 
 It resists criticism and usually stands over against the culture of its day. 
 Let me now go on from this point to comment on the so-called death of biblical fundamentalism. 
 The story of biblical criticism has been so well documented and so often told that I will not recount it. 
 Suffice it to say that after two centuries of higher and lower criticism we just cannot approach the Bible in the way that former Christians did. 
 This conclusion, I want to argue, does not lead to a rejection of the Bible or to a diminution of its claims or, necessarily, to a weakening of its authority. 
 I have found criticism to be a deeply enriching, but not always comfortable exploration of the text of Scripture. 
 Let me share with you two illustrations. 
 First, I recall that when I was a theological student, having come from a fairly conservative church, I could not square up I Kings with I Chronicles. 
 They cover the same period of history and yet talk about it in completely different ways. 
 It seemed to me at the time that this fact did not square with claims that the Bible was inerrant. 
 I went to see a leading Evangelical Bible teacher. 
 He listened to my question and said: &bquo;The difference is easily explained: imagine Kings to be a photograph and Chronicles to be a portrait &mdash; both are true.&equo; 
 He thought that this solved the problem, but it did not &mdash; it was a silly, thoughtless and trivial glossing over of the essential differences in the text. 
  These differences are better explained not by that kind of analogy, but by a recognition of the complex history of the text within the history of an ancient tribe &mdash; a history that is sometimes romanticized, sometimes idealized, and in which past and present are sometimes confusingly mixed. 
 Let me develop that with my second illustration. 
 In 2 Samuel 24 the account is given of God prompting David to hold a census. 
 David is consequently punished for this action. 
 David is compelled to choose between three classical punishments &mdash; disasters, famine or pestilence. 
 He chooses the latter. 
 While the pestilence is raging, he buys the threshing floor of Araunah for 50 shekels, an altar is built and, after he has made a sacrifice, the pestilence ceases. 
 If we look, however, at 1 Chronicles 21 where the same story occurs, we will notice some remarkable differences. 
 It is not God, but Satan who prompts David to his perverse deed. 
 David, at the end of the story, does not buy the threshing floor, but gives the owner 600 shekels. 
 The sacrifice is not consumed by the fire David has built, but by lightning from heaven. 
 Now, how does one handle that kind of difference? 
 You can, of course, say the stories are not identical &mdash; and this is the device of fundamentalist theologians. 
 To my mind, however, the stories are clearly the same. 
 The only realistic interpretation is to recognize that the differences are theological. 
 For the writer of I Samuel, the story is to explain why the temple was built on the threshing floor of Araunah. 
 David bought the place and his sacrifice was well pleasing to God. 
 For the writer of Chronicles, it is now impossible for this later Jewish community to say that God sent this punishment &mdash; it must have been the devil. 
 God nonetheless confirms the choice for the temple by the lightning. 
 This, I think, is a clear example of the way Bible writers filled out the past quite boldly, introducing modifications from their own time. 
 Now I acknowledge that this kind of exegesis might be disturbing for some, but I believe that it is important for us as modern Christians to feel the force of this criticism which has thrown fresh light on the Scriptures as we have received them. 
 Fundamentalism, however, refuses to hear this sort of criticism. 
 It has already made up its mind what kind of literature the Bible is. 
 Its conclusion is that there are no mistakes  whatever in it, and, if any apparent mistakes are found, this must be due to our interpretation and not to problems in the text. 
 After all, what the Bible says, God  says. 
 Perhaps that last phrase gives us a clue as to why fundamentalism holds on so tenaciously to life. 
 It is in essence a theological position which has already decided in advance that the Bible is the pure undistilled fountain of God's clear revelation and that to doubt its veracity in just one particular is to bring the entire edifice to the ground. 
 The point I am making is that, from the viewpoint of scholarship, fundamentalism is dead, but it won't lie down at the grass roots level. 
 We still find Christian undergraduates entering universities, and ordinands coming into theological colleges, who have no idea of the tremendous advances that have been made in biblical scholarship and whose first contact with historical criticism is a dismaying and frightening experience instead of, as I think it ought to be, a liberating and wholly enhancing experience. 
 In the Christian Church, fundamentalism sweeps on. 
 We see the resurgence in the new nonconformism of the house churches and sometimes in the charismatic movement. 
 It often appears in General Synod with some unspoken assumptions about the text of the Bible. 
 For example, without wishing to go into the debate about the Bishop of Durham s well-known views &mdash; and I want to say here that on the resurrection and virgin birth I take the traditional teaching of the Church &mdash; I am concerned when speakers are ignorant of some of the critical insights which have given rise to the Bishop's well thought-out views. 
 David Jenkins, on both issues, is giving expression to conclusions widely held by some contemporary New Testament scholars. 
 By simply shouting him down, the issues will not go away; they have to be faced maturely and rationally, within the context, of course, of faith. 
 Why, I ask again, do we hear the strident voices of fundamentalism? 
 Clearly it is a searching for security . 
 We live in a world of uncertainty, where the politicians, church leaders and others have failed. 
 &bquo;Let us return again&equo;, they cry, &bquo;to the source of the faith&equo; &mdash; to the purity of Shiite Islam, to a Bible which is safe and secure or to the creed which made our nation great. 
 The &bquo;Moral Majority&equo; in the United States is precisely that kind of quest for security. 
 The moral decline of the West cries out for a return to the morals of protestant Christianity  which will tell the nation what they must do to be strong once more. 
 We want to know what to believe, what to do, how to live the godly life. 
 As well as being a cry for security, however, it is also an assumption that liberalism has failed . 
 I shall be elaborating upon this point in a short while, but for the moment let us observe that fundamentalism has flowered because it has concluded that liberalism is effete, ineffectual and impoverished. 
 A return to scriptural authority is the only answer. 
 Putting these answers together we can see that at the heart of fundamentalism is a longing for a faith which is secure, tangible, successful, simple. 
 Indeed, one of the strengths of fundamentalism is that its apologetics are within the reach of the average man and woman. 
 It offers an apparently rational faith which is plausible and coherent. 
 Let us look now at some problems of this neo-fundamentalism as I have observed them in modern church life. 
 First, it has an irrational and anti-intellectual basis . 
 The fundamentalist is afraid to live with questions. 
 The intellectual exploration of the Christian faith, the careful critical examination of the Bible (however reverently the task is carried out) is not for the &bquo;true&equo; Bible student. 
 Thus, the only way to understand Scripture is to submit to what it is saying at face value. 
 This means, of course, that the kind of contradiction I mentioned earlier is rarely discovered by the average fundamentalist because their one-dimensional way of tackling the text, a few verses at a time, will not lead them to make these uncomfortable and, I think, liberating discoveries. 
 They will not be led by preachers at their church to face up to the fact that there are four Gospels, that John is significantly different from the Synoptics, that the New Testament writers do not always speak with the same voice even on essential matters of faith. 
 Second, fundamentalism is a ghetto-like escape from the world . 
 I heard a few weeks ago of the formation of an American group called &bquo;Fundamentalists Anonymous&equo;. 
 It is an equivalent of Alcoholics Anonymous, that is, those who were trying to escape from frightening fundamentalism which had destroyed their lives. 
 One girl shared her story of a fringe group, which for ten years had dominated her life. 
 It had told her what to believe, how to live. 
 She had to submit the control of  her ambitions, career and money to a group over her who &bquo;shepherded&equo; her. 
 What led her to make the break? 
 She replied &bquo;simply: &bquo;One day reading the Bible I was struck by the simple and loving demands of Jesus on his disciples and the intolerable demands of those who claimed to be Christ for me. 
 Perhaps over a period of months, even years, the yearning grew to escape. 
 One day I walked out of the house, leaving all my possessions. 
 I cannot go back, I know they would reclaim me.&equo; 
 Groups like that have tremendous power in the United States but they are marginalized on the culture of America, having formidable influence but not respected or trusted. 
 As a ghetto they create their own lifestyles and moral values and often express theologies that are anti-Christian as well as anti-human &mdash; pelagian, Arminian and gnostic. 
 Third, fundamentalist structures can be demonic in their influence and power . 
 I have already spoken of the term &bquo;shepherding&equo;, which is well known in house churches, even in our own country. 
 I am sure that in the majority of instances the shepherding done by leaders is done very responsibly, but this need not be the case. 
 You see, the structure of authority is often set up to consolidate the position of the leader. 
 The Bible, they claim, is authoritative. 
 It is our only inspired authority, but it is interpreted through our leadership. 
 No pope in history has ever had as much power over the lives of his flock as some of these self-styled leaders in the Western fellowships. 
 Again, the two TV programmes I mentioned give plenty of evidence of the power they exercise over the lives of thousands upon thousands. 
 What is the challenge of fundamentalism? 
 This is my real concern. 
 It is a challenge as well as a threat. 
 Some of you may have read James Barr's books on fundamentalism. 
 They do not reach the true fundamentalist, because even if he read them, he would be left quite unmoved because James Barr's theology does not give a viable and positive alternative to fundamentalism. 
 Let me present some of the challenges to us. 
 The challenge of enthusiasm , Fundamentalists believe in the reality of their message and of the Jesus they preach. 
 They give time and money to their faith and such giving often shames those of us who claim to be orthodox believers. 
 The challenge of expectancy . 
 Fundamentalists believe so  totally in the reality of their message and of the Jesus they preach that they expect lives to be touched and changed. 
 They expect and they grow. 
 The challenge of simplicity . 
 Fundamentalists believe so confidently in the reality of their message and of the Jesus they preach that it is within the reach of the average person. 
 Of course, as I have already remarked, there is much that is wrong with their approach. 
 Their very simplicity contains the seeds of its own weakness, because once the intelligent fundamentalist begins to enter into a true dialogue with his faith, he is remorselessly swept away from the simple truths which once satisfied him. 
 So what is the task of the Church in refuting fundamentalism? 
 The essence of Anglicanism is that the basis of our authority is located within the nexus of three sources &mdash; Bible, Church and reason. 
 The Bible is for us the primary source of authority but not the only source. 
 Here is the heart of Anglican comprehensiveness &mdash; this is why Evangelical, Catholic and liberal can all claim to have equal shares in the treasures of Anglicanism. 
 I think, therefore, that as Anglicans we ought to be affirming more confidently than we usually do the freedom this gives to the mind, the heart and the body to be an integrated whole. 
 Firmness of faith and tolerance of expression is a genuine virtue to offer the Christian. 
 Others do not often see this as a genuine option, however, so how may we present a more positive image? 
 We should, I think, show the reality of a godly, reflective yet positively critical approach to the Bible. 
 We cannot deny the reality of biblical scholarship and this has to be expressed clearly. 
 Rari Barth once said that &bquo;the best apologetic is a good dogmatic&equo;. 
 He meant by this that people are more likely to be convinced of the reality of the faith if our expression of it is coherent, sensible and entire. 
 I long for Anglican churches to be more confident in their expression of the Good News. 
 Instead, we squander our unique position in society and nation by often giving the impression that it does not matter what we believe or how we behave. 
 It is little wonder that fundamentalist sects have a field day welcoming in disillusioned people who have been put off Christianity by forms of Anglicanism which offer so little and demand nothing. 
 Now, it is important to say that an intelligent expression of  faith will still convey some sense of uncertainty. 
 That is inevitable and &mdash; I repeat &mdash; exciting and disturbing. 
 It is inevitable because we cannot deny what we discover in Scripture. 
 Let me give a few illustrations. 
 First, homosexuality . 
 It is easy to go to the odd verse or two in the Bible and conclude triumphantly that homosexuality is a great evil and homosexual practices can never be condoned. 
 That argument, by the way, I am not rejecting; it is a perfectly valid response. 
 The careful exegete, however, will also be troubled by the fact that the Bible hardly majors on this issue, that we do not know the context of Paul's two references to the subject, and that a strong anti-homosexual line is only possible if one has already assumed that such statements are immediately transferable into our situation straight from the biblical period. 
 Second, divorce and remarriage . 
 The New Testament is hardly unequivocal on this matter. 
 Mark, the earliest Gospel, makes it sound as if Jesus does not allow divorce under any circumstance; but Matthew modifies it to allow that some circumstances may make remarriage legitimate. 
 Paul in 1 Corinthians 7 seems to put another slant on this from the perspective of Roman life in the first century. 
 Third, ordination of women and the issue of headship . 
 Paul seems to teach clearly that women should keep silent in church, and should not have authority over men in any shape or form. 
 When we approach the text, however, the problems mount and the issues become more complicated. 
 For example, headship is usually used in the context of marriage. 
 How does this affect ministry? 
 When Paul (or the writer) in I Timothy 2 tails about women not teaching men he makes this an absolute because he was reflecting Jewish society at the time. 
 To follow the logic of his thought would mean banning any form of contact between men and women where women have authority over men. 
 A more fundamental question is: to what extent do we allow cultural elements of the first century to be transferred to our day? 
 Such things may be seen by some as the inevitable watering down of the faith; that the alternative to fundamentalism is a blurring of the lines and the inability of the Church to address the world. 
 On the contrary! 
 I want to submit that it means that we do not go to the world with a watertight  message which demands &bquo;take it or leave it&equo;. 
 Rather we go with a gospel of love which invites others to meet a Lord who is merciful, compassionate, and whose yoke is easy. 
 A friend of mine met up with a keen Christian woman whose life was a mess. 
 Her marriage was on the rocks, she had had a breakdown, her social life was in ruins and yet when she came to ask for his help she was wearing a sweatshirt which had the slogan on it, &bquo;Christ is the answer&equo;. 
 He took one look at it and said to her, &bquo;Jean, I think you should scrap the idea that Christ is the answer. 
 He never said that. 
 He said, &bquo;I am the way&equo;. 
 I think that with him you must seek the answer to your problem.&equo; 
 That man put his finger on something very important. 
 The Christian life is not a tidy, ready-made road which leads directly, simply and painlessly to the gates of heaven. 
 Sometimes the road seems to go away from it, sometimes we cannot see where it is going, even if there is a purpose to it. 
 Sometimes, perhaps often, on that road we have many encouragements; there come signs of God's grace. 
 Yet it is all so provisional and incomplete. 
 On the other hand, as we travel on we find that the road does appear to be leading somewhere. 
 We find it a hard, yet meaningful road to travel because it fits in with our experience of life &mdash; the disappointments as well as the joys. 
 Such an open faith, I believe, has much to commend it. 
 It holds together in tension the reality of Christ in his Church, but the Christ who is real is not only risen but is crucified as well. 
 The Church and the Christian live both sides of the resurrection, and woe betide us if we forget that fact. 
 Fundamentalism &mdash; friend or foe? 
 As you will have picked up, in my opinion fundamentalism is a dangerous enemy which has to be attacked at the level of the mind and of the heart. 
 It is comparatively easy to put it down intellectually. 
 It is much more difficult to show that it is a spiritual dead-end which will only end in disappointment, superficiality and naivety. 
 We must combat it with the weapons of faith by showing that it is possible to have a balanced, intelligent faith which offers hope and healing. 
 The Anglican Church is being challenged today to put its own house in order, to show that its portrayal of truth need not end in a sterile liberalism or empty liturgical forms, but in a faith &bquo;Catholic and Reformed&equo; which, to misquote  Gregory the Great slightly, is &bquo;a faith large enough for elephants to swim in and little lambs to paddle with safety&equo;.  
 Is God Green? 
 To the Green party, Wells Town hall, 20 march 1990 
 I must begin by rejecting a notion that is circulating at the moment that Christianity has only recently discovered the importance of green issues and has simply jumped on a topical band-wagon. 
 When the Archbishop of Canterbury made a strong statement last autumn on this subject, voicing his concern for our reckless disregard for nature, The Times  ran an editorial entitled &bquo;The Greening of the Archbishop&equo;. 
 However, my predecessor, Bishop John Bickersteth, who for many years had been an advocate for issues of conservation, quite rightly protested that the Archbishop was saying no more than the biblical tradition states! 
 The idea still persists that organized Christianity has only recently stumbled upon these truths. 
 I will be arguing in this address that we have been as guilty as many other sections of our community in treating it too lightly, or in putting it lower down in our order of priorities than it ought to be; but it has never been entirely absent from Christian thought or theology. 
 Indeed, as long ago as 1958 the Lambeth Conference of Bishops issued this Resolution: 
 In relation to God's creation, over which he seems to exercise control, man is in danger of failing to recognize that he is a trustee, a steward, who must render account. 
 This may be seen in his pollution of air, soil and ocean and in his scant disregard for the balance of nature or the needs of future generations and his tendency, without restraint, to use animal creation for his own ends. 
 Furthermore, as some of you here know, the diocese of Bath and Wells set up a working party in 1986 to set out our own  policy. 
 This was published in a useful report, Our Relationship with the whole of Creation  (1987). 
 This has been studied in many parishes and has led to some changes of heart and attitudes. 
 It is clear despite this that not enough is being done, and the seriousness of the position is still not fully realized by the average person. 
 Groups in our society such as Friends of the Earth, Greenpeace and the Green party are to be congratulated for the energetic way they are drawing our attention to the issues involved. 
 Yes, leading politicians may talk about the &bquo;airy-fairy&equo; Greens and seek to marginalize groups by such dismissive statements. 
 Nonetheless, the very fact that no less a person than the prime Minister speaks in such a way is a confession that green issues have intruded upon political life to such an extent that they can no longer be ignored! 
 Let me now build up my argument. 
 First, let us look at the Christian idea of creation . 
 The Christian faith has a very clear ideology of the created order. 
 It is of nature created and hallowed by a personal God who pours into it his creativity and love. 
 It is wholly hallowed and consecrated. 
 The biblical tradition, while taking sin and the Fall seriously, does not consider the universe and the world as things to be exploited, but rather to be treated with respect. 
 Mankind is charged with responsibility for the care of creation as a steward is given charge over the property of another. 
 There are, for example, passages in the Old Testament which speak of a &bquo;sabbath rest&equo; for nature. 
 I commend the book God is Green  by Ian Bradley which sets out a useful outline of Christian thought on this subject. 
 It is a mistake, I submit, to go along with the Dominican Matthew Fox in denying the concepts of the Fall and sin. 
 This appealing and influential writer condemns Augustinian spirituality &mdash; with what he believes is its over-concentration on the Fall and sinfulness &mdash; in favour of what he calls &bquo;creation spirituality&equo;. 
 He believes that Augustinian thought is largely to be blamed for the split between Christian morality and nature. 
 There is truth in what he argues, but not the whole truth. 
 We create a wider chasm if the Christian view of humanity's sinfulness, wilfulness and downright evil is ever ignored. 
 It is all too self-evident that organized Christianity has not always followed the splendid theology which is there at the  centre. 
 There are probably many reasons for this and I shall mention only a few of the important ones. 
 First was, no doubt, the over-spiritualizing of life with its assumption that the natural order was of trivial importance to our spiritual relationship with God. 
 This world with all its concerns was thus seen as but an &bquo;ante-room&equo; of heaven. 
 Thus physical and natural things were denigrated. 
 A second reason was closely related to this, namely an anthropocentrism which came close to asserting that man could do whatever he liked with creation. 
 It was tacitly assumed by everyone that every single thing existed for the benefit of humankind &mdash; nature was man's convenient larder or leisure bowl. 
 It was there to be exploited. 
 Here are some illustrations of that attitude. 
 Henry Moore argued that God created garden weeds to exercise the industry of man to dig them out! 
 You may recall that in 1976 a Church of Scotland minister, defending his action in shooting two of Gavin Maxwell's adopted otter cubs as they were playing on the shore, argued that &bquo;the Lord gave man control over the beasts of the field&equo;. 
 This anthropocentric attitude is not confined to protestants alone. 
 Even John Henry Newman wrote this about animals: &bquo;We may use them, we may destroy them at our pleasure. 
 For our own end, for our benefit or satisfaction.&equo; 
 We may well express our enlightened horror at such ideas. 
 For my part I am not condemning, I am illustrating the fact that the Christian symbiosis between nature and humankind, expressed so well in the Bible, has from time to time been replaced by man's domination of nature with disastrous consequences for both. 
 This moves me to my second point, the desecration of creation . 
 We have to face the fact that we are not a nice species. 
 I recall years ago visiting a nature trail with my then young family. 
 We saw a sign saying, &bquo;To the most dangerous creature of all&equo;. 
 We were curious. 
 How exciting! 
 So we followed the sign, and with some amusement found ourselves confronting a huge mirror! 
 Yes, we are predators; we are consumers on an unprecedented scale in history. 
 In nature, the numbers of the predator are always fewer than their prey, thus giving nature time and space to maintain control between species. 
 Human life has achieved such a high density of population, however, and has such domination, that the structure of our environment is  in danger of breaking down under the relentless punishment we are giving our habitat. 
 The problem comes in many forms, but for the sake of brevity let me concentrate on pollution . 
 First, pollution caused by combustion. 
 In spite of the fact that since the Clean Air Act of 1956, pollution caused by smoke has been greatly reduced to the benefit of those who live in the cities, we must not fool ourselves into thinking that there is no longer any problem. 
 The facts point in the other direction. 
 The effect of sulphur dioxide emissions by power stations and industrial concerns is a major environmental threat, causing acidification and what is called &bquo;die-back&equo; in trees. 
 Last year, walking in a forest above Lake Geneva, I saw terrible evidence of this as acre after acre of trees seemed to be dying from the top down. 
 Then we can think of water pollution. 
 Rivers have always been a dumping ground for man's unwanted waste. 
 Nature has, of course, tremendous resilience in coping with abuse; even great quantities of waste can be broken down by the bacteria in the water. 
 But there are limits, and we are told by scientists that those limits are being reached in our own time. 
 We can easily understand why. 
 High levels of waste will make it difficult for a river to absorb the quantities involved, reducing its ability to recycle waste, with the result that aquatic life dies and human life is threatened with disease. 
 Other types of pollution could be illustrated. 
 In each case the same serious message is coming through &mdash; we are poisoning our environment, we are disrupting the interrelating ecosystems that form the background to human existence, we are endangering God's creation. 
 Now no one pretends that solutions are easy to find. 
 The intention of this paper is not to blame, but to understand. 
 I am not saying to the politician, &bquo;You must get your act together.&equo; 
 I am not saying to the farmer, &bquo;You must use fewer insecticides.&equo; 
 I am not saying to the consumer in all of us, &bquo;You must eat less, drive less, enjoy life less.&equo; 
 To quote that well-known politician again, I am not interested in &bquo;airy-fairy&equo; solutions; but I am interested in promoting responsible attitudes to life. 
 So what can we do? 
 There are people who are convinced that the problem is so acute that lasting damage has already been done. 
 One well-known thinker is the German theologian J&uuml;rgen Moltmann  whose writings on this subject are of importance to anyone interested in issues of creation. 
 He argues that the danger of an ecological collapse of the earth &mdash; what he calls &bquo;ecological death&equo; &mdash; is greater than the danger of a nuclear catastrophe. 
 He cites in support of this the population explosion. 
 In 1926, the year of his birth, 2 billion people inhabited this planet. 
 By the year 2020 there will be 8 billion people living here. 
 That is to say, within 100 years the human population will have quadrupled. 
 The needs and waste of humanity have multiplied accordingly. 
 Whatever we do, argues Moltmann, damage has been caused because of the irreversibility of the development of humanity. 
 However, while I believe Moltmann's case is unanswerable, it makes no difference to my contention that we are given certain responsibilities to ensure that we do something positive. 
 The predator must become a repentant steward. 
 How are we going to start this act of &bquo;reformation&equo;? 
 We need to rediscover our symbiotic relationship with the rest of creation. 
 The key word is co-operation . 
 The human species is part of nature and apart from it. 
 The idea that the rest of creation is here for our benefit makes no sense biologically, but the idea is so widespread in society and so deeply ingrained in our approach to life, that it gives rise to an arrogant and destructive &bquo;hubris&equo;. 
 This &bquo;separation from&equo; approach is the root of such destructiveness because it is of the nature of the &bquo;outsider&equo; not to care. 
 Why should he, is the shrugged reaction &mdash; I don't belong here, this is not my home. 
 It may be the approach of the atheist for whom the whole of life is meaningless; it may be the approach of the over-spiritualizing theist for whom this world is irrelevant. 
 No responsible Christian or, dare I say, responsible humanist could possibly endorse that view, however. 
 From the Christian perspective we are &bquo;insiders&equo;, part and parcel of God's design, and woe betide us if we take the position of the Creator. 
 Yet how do we co-operate? 
 It is a great idea, we may think, but very hard to implement. 
 We have to face the fact that economic factors and, all too often, short-term economic factors, shape attitudes to the environment. 
 The factory, faced by demands from minority groups that it should not discharge its waste into the local river, will be unmoved by such considerations if its productivity and its economic survival  depend upon keeping costs down. 
 This takes me into another key word and it is education . 
 I am convinced that it should be the goal of every concerned person to share in that task of educating people to think and behave ecologically. 
 This is beginning to happen through the exhortation as well as education received from Friends of the Earth and Greenpeace. 
 I am delighted that our Government has taken this seriously enough to have a minister devoted to environmental issues. 
 I am glad that universities are running courses on environmental biology. 
 I am grateful to the BBC and independent TV stations for regular broadcasts which highlight conservation matters. 
 More can and ought to be done, however. 
 The educative process has to begin sufficiently early in a person's life for it to have any real effect on attitudes, and I believe the challenge has to have the response of both parents and schools. 
 The task of parents is to &bquo;mentor&equo; their children so that by example and instruction their children may capture a glimpse of the true values of life. 
 The task of the school is to educate and to influence the growing mind of the child through knowledge. 
 Frankly, I believe that It begins in an attitude to life which is almost mystical, if not religious, in its orientation and approach. 
 I mean by this attitudes of wonder, reverence and awe, as we contemplate the beauty of the universe and note the fragility of its life-systems. 
 &bquo;Knowledge&equo; is often associated with external forms of knowledge: of objective, dispassionate study which leads to theoretical commitment. 
 I am arguing for something far more significant than that, and we might call it a case for ecological morality . 
 Yes, we have all heard of personal morality and social moralities &mdash; but this is one that embraces the whole of reality. 
 Its basis is that all life is to be valued and treated with respect; that the rhythm of life is something implanted by the Creator; that the different ecosystems have to be treasured, even when we regard them as hostile to human life itself. 
 Their utilitarian contribution to our welfare should not, in other words, be our criterion as to whether they survive or not. 
 An important element of such an ecological morality will include a style of ecological justice which is vigilant for a symbiosis of humanity and nature. 
 An ecological reform of our societies will need to take into account, therefore, the compatibility of  our innovations as much for our habitat as for ourselves. 
 We need a healthy recognition of the fact that we are a rather big-headed little species in a vast cosmos that can do without us, thank you very much! 
 God did not depend upon us for his creation; indeed, I have heard it expressed rather forcefully that humankind is not one of God's better experiments! 
 Time may well tell us whether that judgement is correct or not. 
 For myself, I remain convinced that private morality cannot be divorced from public and environmental moralities and I predict that the politics of the future will have to lay greater stress on this area of life. 
 Robert Paehlke's recent book Environmentalism and the Future of Progressive Politics  is, I believe, an important and real contribution to this. 
 Finally, this leads me into green disciplining . 
 This means bringing our behaviour into line with our theories, or, in Christian terms, it means making theology and disciplining one. 
 I have no hesitation in saying that this implies all of us seeking a simpler lifestyle and making appropriate changes to the way we live, the things we eat, the way we travel, and so on. 
 We should not assume that this means a retreat from the world into a monastery or a desert &mdash; not at all. 
 But it will mean some form of acceptable lifestyle that will subject us to the discipline of God's world and the needs of his creation. 
 Now why should we do that? 
 I have already mentioned the principal reason &mdash; that we are predators and our ravishing of the earth's resources, if continued at its present rate, will lead to disaster for our patient planet. 
 There is also another reason. 
 We live in a world in which one third of the population consumes two thirds of the world's resources. 
 The Christian and the caring humanist cannot remain unconcerned for the plight of the people of the Third World who live so close to starvation. 
 Among them are millions of our fellow Christians; but whether they are Christian or Muslim or whatever, they are fellow human beings and made in the image and likeness of God &mdash; and we have a responsibility for them. 
 So to the question: Is God green? 
 The answer must be an emphatic and joyful &bquo;yes&equo;; Greener than you or I will ever be! 
 He calls us all to that relationship of stewardship which has been our calling ever since homo sapiens  tended that first field. 
 A mature Christian is in no doubt that God's concern for this world is greater than ours. 
 He who valued life so much to  enter it in the form of a human person must be committed to its survival. 
 It is in the life and fragrance of that person, Jesus of Nazareth, that we have a pattern of care and love for all things which can be the basis for a discipleship that takes in a holistic approach to life.  
 Prayer &mdash; a Two-Way Conversation Stoke Bishop, 15 February 1987 
 I have in my hand a wonderful book called Children's Letters to God . 
 Here are some of the short prayers and letters addressed to God from small children: 
 Dear God, Are you real? 
 Some people don't believe it. 
 If you are, you better do something quick. 
 Harriet Ann  
 Dear God, I love you God. 
 During arithmetic a dog came in. 
 Krista  
 Dear God, Are boys better than girls? 
 I know you are one, but try to be fair. 
 Sylvia  
 Dear God, We got a lot of religion in our house. 
 So don't worry about us. 
 Teddy  
 Although the authors call them letters they are in fact a form of communication we call prayer. 
 They reflect different types of prayer: praising, thanking, accusing, talking, asking. 
 In this sermon on prayer, I want us to think about prayer as a two-way conversation in which we talk to God and in which we listen to him as well. 
 I think it will help us to hold on to what I am going to say if we keep in mind two pictures: a  hallway of a house, and a telephone. 
 Let us look first at prayer as a hallway . 
 Have you ever considered how important the hallway of your home is? 
 It is far more than just an accidental entrance to your home. 
 It is the place where you greet people who have the right to step over the doormat but no right to go any further. 
 It is the place which our neighbours find so fascinating that, in spite of our invitation to enter the living room, they say, &bquo;I won't stay a moment&equo;, but find that they stay thirty minutes! 
 I am sure you have neighbours like that, too. 
 The main thing about a hallway, however, is that you cannot go anywhere in the house without passing through it. 
 It gathers up the movement of the house as we pass from kitchen to living room or dining room, or kitchen to bedrooms. 
 I find this an illuminating analogy of the real purpose of prayer. 
 Prayer is far more than a shopping list, or an incidental five minutes at the end of a busy day. 
 In the life of a maturing Christian it is that space I give in quiet thought, reflection and meditation. 
 It is that time when I gather up all that has happened in my day, and all that is going to happen today. 
 Understood in this way, then, prayer is not something I do but something I am. 
 Just as a hallway has no meaning on its own &mdash; after all, you cannot buy hallways without the rest of the building (&bquo;nice hallway to sell, hardly ever used&equo;) &mdash; so prayer has no meaning on its own. 
 Prayer, you see, in this sense, is what we are . 
 It does not stand alone. 
 It is the innermost centre of what we are, the place where we are most authentically ourselves. 
 This form of prayer, then, gathers up all our experiences and takes them to the King of Kings, and we think about them in his presence &mdash; all the hurts, all the joys, all that stops us becoming the kind of persons we feel called to be. 
 I would urge anyone to find space in a busy day to pray in this kind of way. 
 For some, the morning is the best time; for others perhaps late evening. 
 Perhaps it is as you travel to work, or as you take the dog out for a walk, or as you walk on the Downs, or when you have that quiet morning cup of coffee. 
 Perhaps it is when you drive your car &mdash; as long as you don't close your eyes! 
 It is &bquo;space to be&equo;, when you gather up everything that crosses the threshold of your life and where it is interpreted in the light of your walk with God.  
 It may be that in your hallway is my second image of prayer, the telephone , that irritating friend whose shrill cry has to be answered. 
 Perhaps you have had telephone problems of late and you are waiting for the Telecom engineer. 
 It is good to know that God's telephone never breaks down. 
 He is always available. 
 The telephone is my link with the outside world. 
 We may complain about it many times, but think of its wonderful facility of allowing us to phone that relative in the United States, or a friend a few miles away, or the butcher, or our business, and so on. 
 On the phone we talk and we listen. 
 Sometimes our teenagers talk to their boyfriends and girlfriends for hours on the phone. 
 Mystified parents, who ought to know better, ask: &bquo;What took you so long? 
 Surely you didn't have that much to say to one another? 
 After all, you are seeing him in ten minutes.&equo; 
 Then they smile because they know you really ought to have known better. 
 &bquo;Can't you remember, Mum and Dad, what it was like to just talk, and gossip, and say sweet things without saying really anything , and yet saying all the important things?&equo; 
 Isn't that going to the very heart of prayer &mdash; a two-way conversation in which we talk and in which we do some listening as well? 
 &bquo;Well!&equo; says someone, &bquo;I know what you mean by talking to God but what do you mean by listening to him? 
 Quite frankly, I need a guide because otherwise all I'll be listening to are my hopes and fears and desires.&equo; 
 Yes, I understand that point of view. 
 God, however, has given two very important guides to help the Christian as he or she listens. 
 The first is the Holy Spirit, and the second is the Bible which is his tool. 
 You see, each of us has to make sure that we are listening to God's voice and not our own fantasies. 
 So how do we do it? 
 To some degree we must all find the system best for ourselves, but let me tell you what I do. 
 I find my listening springs best out of reading a few verses from Scripture. 
 It does not have to be a long passage, it may only be a verse. 
 Let me take one from the passage read to us: Philippians 4. 
 Let us imagine that you are studying this in your room and you read verse 6: &bquo;Have no anxiety about anything, but in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving let your requests be made known to God.&equo; 
 As you start to think about the things that  make you anxious you realize that the passage is telling you not to be anxious but to pray with thanksgiving! 
 Now what is God saying to me through this passage?&hellip; and you find yourself ruminating on the things you are anxious about, and you start to relate this to the person you are. 
 Is there something here in this passage that should influence your behaviour today? 
 Let me give you a personal illustration. 
 About six months ago I was very cross with a colleague who had, in my opinion, acted irresponsibly. 
 I remember approaching the theological college quite determined to &bquo;sort him out&equo;. 
 As I approached the college the phrase from this passage: &bquo;in everything by prayer and supplication with thanksgiving&equo; flashed through my mind. 
 I started to meditate on that verse in relation to my argument with my colleague. 
 I imagined God saying something like this: &bquo;So you are going to sort him out, are you? 
 Begin with thanking me for him; look at him as a person as important to me as you are.&equo; 
 I did so. 
 I started to thank God for this colleague of mine and his gifts and commitment. 
 As you will have guessed, my attitude towards him changed, so that when the frank speaking happened that day it was in the context of love and acceptance of him as a person. 
 So prayer as talking  and listening  needs to be an important element in our daily walk with God. 
 Don't skimp on it, because the experience of great Christians has been that without it we cannot grow into Christian maturity. 
 Francis de Sales, a great Christian writer, used to say: &bquo;Half an hour's daily listening is essential except when you are very busy and then a full hour is necessary.&equo; 
 An interesting thought, because he turns on its head our usual temptation to crowd prayer out when we are busy. 
 Now the consequences of seeing prayer as a hallway and as a telephone are momentous. 
 First, we will see prayer as a natural way of talking with God. 
 It is the language of the heart in tune with its Maker. 
 It is the place where we gather up all the experiences of life and think about them. 
 As a hallway, it is the place where I invite the good Lord to step over the threshold and talk with me. 
 &bquo;Come on in and help me make sense of this life I live.&equo; 
 In a very real way, I have found, it is the only place where things have been really understood for the first time.  
 Second, when prayer is seen as a conversation with a very dear friend, we begin to understand prayer as far, far more than just asking God for a hand-out. 
 We begin to understand Jesus' prayer in the Garden of Gethsemane, &bquo;Not my will, but thine, be done&equo; (Luke 22.42). 
 As that little poem puts it: 
 He answered prayer not in the way I sought, Nor in the way that I thought he ought, But in his own good way, and I could see, He answered in the fashion best for me. 
 Third, prayer in the light of the Bible and guided by the Holy Spirit will change me: change my attitudes, make me more like the person God wants me to be. 
 That, surely, ought to be our ambition.  
 Sacraments in the Spiritual Life To the Irish School of Ecumenics, the Corrymeela Community, Northern Ireland. 
 Seventh Clergy Conference, 10 May 1988 
 You will notice no definite article before the word &bquo;sacraments&equo; and this gives me a little liberty to begin my address reasonably broadly. 
 When we use the word &bquo;sacrament&equo;, what do we mean? 
 Within the tradition I represent, the classic definition is that of &bquo;outward and visible sign of an inward and spiritual grace&equo;. 
 The word &bquo;sign&equo;, however, needs careful thought. 
 Do we mean a symbol which only &bquo;represents&equo; a reality &mdash; like a road sign &mdash; or do we mean a sign which actually embodies or conveys, in some shape or form, the reality to which it points? 
 Paul Tillich was in no doubt, and in a famous phrase remarked: &bquo;A sacrament partakes of the reality it conveys.&equo; 
 I have been asked to speak on this subject from the viewpoint of the Evangelical tradition and I am glad to do so, but with the following cautionary note. 
 While I owe much to that tradition and trust that I am still persona grata  within it, in many respects I have gone beyond Evangelical thought on matters to do with the Church and sacraments. 
 Others, then, will have to judge whether my views expressed here are consonant with that tradition. 
 I trust they are. 
 At any rate I am aware that a rising generation of Evangelical students and scholars are in general sympathy with the views I espouse, 
 My starting point is Christ. 
 For Christians there is only one primordial and basic sacrament, and that is Christ himself. 
 In speaking of Christ as &bquo;sacrament&equo; I am endorsing the witness of the Church in history which has seen, in the incarnation of God's Son, the sacramental manifestation of God the Father himself. 
 &bquo;He that has seen me&equo;, Jesus said to Philip, &bquo;has seen  the father.&equo; 
 I suggest that all our sacraments are derivative sacraments, because they all originate from the source of God's life in and through his Son. 
 Our response is, of course, twofold &mdash; encounter and worship &mdash; and these are inseparably connected. 
 Let us explore the first of these words &mdash; &bquo;encounter&equo;. 
 How do I encounter God in such a way that I can call the meeting sacramental? 
 First, I must recall that Christ has first encountered us as Saviour and Lord. 
 In his life, death and resurrection we are made right with God. 
 We cannot love God with our whole hearts, souls and minds. 
 Christ, however, has and does. 
 It is therefore Christ who presents us to the Father, and our salvation derives from him. 
 Salvation is not, though, a past event. 
 Our total experience of life is a firm refutation of that; we know the reality within us of failure, of sinfulness and consequently of the need for forgiveness and restoration. 
 That is why within the Evangelical tradition there is the emphasis on the believer being simul justus et peccator , simultaneously made right with God but still sinful. 
 Second, encounter with God never takes place in a vacuum. 
 In our case it takes place in the family of Christ's body, the Church, the location in which the sacramental is normally expressed. 
 Now this may sound an anathema to some Evangelical ears because for some the Church is but a secondary fact in Christian truth, coming a long way after personal faith and experience. 
 For myself I have to reject this way of contemplating the Church because of its individualistic bias. 
 The New Testament knows nothing of a separation of the individual from the Church; to be a Christian is to belong to the body; to be baptized into Christ is to be incorporated into his people. 
 I have no hesitation, therefore, in speaking of the Church itself as &bquo;sacrament&equo; in the sense that here is this broken body which is called by his name, I meet him and he indwells it. 
 He is present in its ministry, in its preaching, in its sacraments, in its prayers and in its witness. 
 Let us now come to the second response, namely worship. 
 In this Church where I encounter the Triune God I am called to worship with my whole being. 
 I have a strong feeling that in all our communities our worship falls a long way short of New Testament and patristic practice. 
 Let me mention just one aspect of worship which I call worship as rehearsal . 
 For us,  worship is merely our duty to respond to God's love by a discipline which, for most Christians, amounts to one visit to the local church a week. 
 There, in predictable manner, we sing our hymns and say our prayers. 
 Good; but, I submit, it is not good enough. 
 Is not worship more than that? 
 Should it not be in a vital and vivid way a recital and rehearsal of God's plan of salvation? 
 Should not worship set forth the gospel and proclaim the faith of the Church? 
 In ecumenical circles of late we have been reminded that &bquo;remembering&equo; in the biblical context was far more than simply recalling to mind what God had done in the past. 
 This word anamnesis  meant the past invading the present, so that here the past was relived and appropriated. 
 Worship, you see, is the action of the entire congregation who together proclaim what God has done and what he continues to do; we feed on his word &mdash; sacrament and Scripture &mdash; and are strengthened by his Spirit and sustained by mutual fellowship. 
 Furthermore, although this action takes place in a local congregation, it is the worship of the whole people of God &mdash; the living and the dead, the Church militant and triumphant, for together they constitute the body of Christ. 
 It is in this context of anamnesis  (of &bquo;recalling&equo; and &bquo;reliving&equo; the events of Christ's victory) that I wish to talk about the role of the sacraments in the spiritual life. 
 In its broadest sense, we can talk of the &bquo;sacramentality&equo; of life, in that God may be seen, experienced and discovered in the normality of life. 
 We should be suspicious of any school of thought which separates spirituality from the natural and human as if God comes to people independent of this context. 
 While it is the Catholic Christian who will most naturally speak in this way, it is not unknown for the Evangelical Christian to make statements which come fairly close to that. 
 Listen to him talking about his moment of conversion when at a certain event he &bquo;asked Jesus into his heart&equo;. 
 That moment and place can never be expunged from his memory. 
 Similarly, the Evangelical can speak of an encounter with the words of the text of Scripture as though God has spoken directly to him. 
 On a broader canvas, many of us can think of moments of encounter, of blessing, of poetry, of art, of music, of sunsets and dawns which were to us deeply sacramental. 
 for us all, however, the two dominical sacraments stand out  from all the rest &mdash; namely baptism and Holy Communion. 
 The former represents the once-for-all giving of spiritual life, and the latter the regular repetition of the saving events of the cross and resurrection. 
 It is this last sacrament which, by its very nature, is deeply significant to the Christian. 
 For the rest of this address I will describe its role for me in my spiritual journey. 
 Hopefully I will be speaking on behalf of Evangelicals and many Anglicans. 
 First, it is the focal point of forgiveness . 
 The Eucharist is the sacrament of salvation and, as such, it declares the work of Christ as he fulfils the Father's will and draws all people to God. 
 Sadly, this representation of our salvation has been the source of the rift between two historic Communions as both have misheard or misunderstood what the other has been trying to say. 
 The protestant Christian has too quickly jumped to the conclusion that Catholicism regards the Holy Communion service as a work of salvation whereby the priest offers afresh the offering of Christ and pleads for salvation. 
 The Catholic Christian has perhaps decided that the protestant sees the sacrament merely as a memorial service, witnessing to an event in the past. 
 Both views, of course, are distortions and we need to listen again to what the other is really trying to say. 
 In this, the statement by the Anglican-Roman Catholic International Commission (ARCIC) II, &bquo;Salvation and the Church&equo;, is a major breakthrough because theologians from the Roman Catholic and Anglican Communions were able to state together the &bquo;once-for-all&equo; offering of Christ on the cross, and that we are not saved by  good works but for  good works. 
 Section 27 expresses it well: &bquo;This once-for-all atoning work of Christ, realized and experienced in the life of the Church and celebrated in the Eucharist, continues the free gift of God which is proclaimed in the gospel.&equo; 
 I speak personally when I say that for me the Eucharist represents God's powerful declaration that I am &bquo;ransomed, healed, restored and forgiven&equo;. 
 It does not of itself  forgive, rather it sets forth what God has done in Christ. 
 However, since it is more than a mere sign, it partakes of the reality it signifies and is a means of grace through which the atoning work of Christ is made effective in the life of the Christian. 
 Second, for me the sacrament of Holy Communion is a focal  point of feeding . 
 I must deny a &bquo;real absence&equo;. 
 It is common for Evangelicals to speak as if they are denying a &bquo;real presence&equo; but this is far from the case. 
 Having taught many generations of Evangelical students, I am aware that many come to theological colleges with inchoate views concerning the nature of the Eucharist. 
 However most of them have a strong sense that in this celebration of the Church, Christ himself is present and feeds with Word and Sacrament those who come to him through faith. 
 This is the reality for me. 
 In this sacrament I meet the risen Christ; I feed on him and rely on his promise that, as the people of God meet to recall him in his death and passion, so we are able to take the elements and say &bquo;This is my body&hellip; 
 This is my blood of the new covenant&equo;. 
 I don't wish to reopen sterile arguments about the meaning of &bquo;is-ness&equo;. 
 Surely, five hundred years of argument have convinced most reasonable people of the vacuity of this debate. 
 Many of us from experience wish to say something like this: &bquo;Lord, I do not have the ability to comprehend how you feed me through such simple gifts as this piece of bread or wafer or that sip of wine &mdash; but I know you do!&equo; 
 As the ARCIC I statement on Eucharistic doctrine puts it so well: 
 The sacramental body and blood of the Saviour are present as an offering to the believer awaiting his welcome. 
 When this offering is met by faith, a life-giving encounter results. 
 Through faith Christ's presence &mdash; which does not depend on the individual's faith in order to be the Lord's real gift of himself to his Church &mdash; becomes no longer just a presence for the believer, but also a presence with him. 
 (Section 8) 
 I am aware that there will be those, Catholics and Evangelicals, who will regret the vagueness of such language. 
 They would prefer the vigour of language which either asserted the fact of &bquo;real presence&equo; in words which clothed the mode of his coming with an unmistakable reality, or which spoke of a &bquo;real absence&equo; in order to preserve the purity of Christ &bquo;s coming to the heart of the believer in faith. 
 For myself, both these extremes are unsatisfactory. 
 Not only because both are unbiblical but because both misunderstand the way language is used  when we grope to make sense of experiencing God. 
 The theological term for this is analogia fidei ; that is to say, when we talk of eternal verities we have to resort to pictures, stories and other analogical expressions. 
 The Bible is full of such analogies and pictorial expressions which point beyond themselves. 
 Yet I must resist both the temptation of identifying word with reality and that of separating word from reality. 
 All our language is a groping after a reality which we already possess in part. 
 Perhaps it is in this context that Evangelicals and Catholics have to look afresh at the troublesome problem of speaking of the sacrament as a &bquo;sacrifice&equo;. 
 Historically and theologically, of course, it is not and can never be. 
 As &bquo;sacrament&equo; it stands for  the sacrifice of the cross through which we were brought near to God. 
 Analogically the sacrament can certainly be understood as &bquo;sacrifice&equo; in the sense that if it partakes of the reality it represents, the &bquo;once-for-all&equo; sacrifice of Calvary is applied to us as we celebrate the victory as well as the mystery of the cross. 
 Third, the Eucharist is the focal point of fellowship . 
 When we come together for worship it is as the body of Christ, to be  the body of Christ and to feed on  the body of Christ. 
 In the light of this awesome fact, how can we treat our membership of that body so lightly? 
 Yet our koinonia  (fellowship) so often falls short of the unity Christ desires. 
 I think of this with particular reference to the local community and the wider community. 
 The application to the local community is one that I put as a challenge to all: How can we help people to take seriously membership in the Eucharistic community of faith? 
 If the Eucharist is essential for our spiritual growth, how may we all integrate this most solemn and sacred of sacraments with other vital elements in our experience? 
 For example, how may Evangelicals integrate it with their emphasis on the word expressed in preaching and Bible study? 
 How may Catholics ensure that the Eucharist does not become separated from the salvation it witnesses to in Christ? 
 If the Eucharist is that important, a second question follows: How can we help others to understand its theological significance as well as its mystery to which we subject ourselves in humility? 
 The application to the wider community brings us to the  purpose of our gathering in this place dedicated to unity. 
 If the sacrament of Holy Communion is the sacrament of reconciliation, of unity, of God making peace through the blood of his cross, then we must face the fact that this sacrament witnesses to our deep divisions, our brokenness and hurt. 
 None of our Churches is therefore a &bquo;whole&equo; Communion as a result. 
 We may secretly take pride in our traditions and truth, but we are deficient as long as others are left outside in the cold and unable to share with us the sacrament of the Lord. 
 I am nonetheless a man of hope. 
 J&uuml;rgen Moltmann once said so memorably: &bquo;The nearer we come to Christ, the nearer we come together. 
 &bquo;It is my hope and conviction that as we journey closer to him we shall find ourselves travelling with others and imperceptibly growing together into his beauty and likeness, and away from the ugliness and bitterness which has dogged the history of our Communions.  
 A Pilgrim at Walsingham in 1988 the Bishop led a diocesan pilgrimage to Walsingham, Norfolk. 
 He gave the following three talks. 
 A Home that is Always Open 
 Here in Walsingham is commemorated the home of Jesus. 
 In this church we have a striking and unusual likeness of a home. 
 Are we not being reminded in a very distinctive yet emphatic way that this ought to be the nature of the Church? 
 A home is the very heart of life. 
 Nothing can be finer, greater and more influential than a loving home. 
 However, nothing can be crueller and more oppressive than one without love. 
 Many of our blessings and our scars emanate from our homes. 
 Here in this place we are being encouraged to come home to God's dwelling place. 
 The actual context in which we meet is not important; it is only a symbol of God's dwelling among his people. 
 Having said that, this place has been made &bquo;valid through prayer&equo; and can be seen as a sacrament of God's coming to us through the demands of human life. 
 God chose Mary to create a home for his Son. 
 Why Mary? 
 We don't know; but God never does things accidentally. 
 He plans and prepares people to receive his grace and love. 
 I want to let you in on a somewhat embarrassing secret, which is now a secret no longer! 
 I had been something like eighteen years in the ordained ministry before I preached my first sermon on Mary. 
 Somehow the protestant part of me could not find it right to speak of her place in God's order of salvation because I was afraid of her obscuring the central place of Jesus Christ in his Church. 
 What changed my way of approaching things? 
 Above all, it was the Bible. 
 If we take Scripture seriously, Mary is there as part of the story. 
 Without her, or someone like her, the story would have been completely different.  
 First, I saw that she was chosen , and that for all time &bquo;all generations will call &lsqb;her&rsqb; blessed&equo; (Luke 1.48). 
 Indeed, the angel hails her, &bquo;O favoured one!&equo; 
 (Luke 1.28), and later in the birth narratives Elizabeth salutes her: &bquo;Blessed are you among women&equo; (Luke 1.42). 
 It would be wrong, then, to push Mary to the circumference of the Christian story. 
 Her place is in the centre. 
 Second, I began to see why she was honoured in this way. 
 I saw her humility . 
 She entered into the shame of bearing God's Son and even ran the risk of being called a loose woman. 
 She entered upon the slow crucifixion of seeing her son take the lonely, sad and inevitable road to his cross. 
 As the hand-maid of the Lord, most of the time she could only be there, watching helplessly. 
 I began to see that my fear about Mary obscuring Christ was not soundly based as long as I keep to the parameters of Scripture. 
 The advice recorded in John's Gospel is always worth following: &bquo;Do whatever he tells you&equo; (John 2.5). 
 True Marian theology is truly Christ-centred. 
 Third, I saw her availability . 
 She gave her consent to God's will. 
 She was willing to be used by him and the outrageous request received the obedient, &bquo;Let it be to me according to your word&equo; (Luke 1.38). 
 Fourth, I saw her as an example of God's grace . 
 There is nothing in the biblical account to suggest that Mary was extraordinary in any way. 
 There is nothing to suggest that she was very clever, very holy, very gifted or very beautiful. 
 Although tradition has assumed that she was some if not all of those things, we have no way of knowing. 
 But that only adds to the wonder of the story that God took a willing young woman and poured into her his grace and love. 
 The best definition I know of grace is: God's Riches At Christ's Expense. 
 The One who took up his abode in Mary was the One who sustained her, kept her and made her holy. 
 It was Mary who, with her husband Joseph &mdash; also a striking and impressive example of God's grace &mdash; made of a simple house in Nazareth a home for the King of Kings. 
 What does a home signify to you? 
 Belonging 
 Observe the difference between the behaviour of children in their own home and that of friends who enter. 
 Even though  we may say, &bquo;Make yourself at home&equo;, we might be a little taken aback if they took us at our word and kicked off their shoes, lounged around on the settee, helped themselves to our coffee, tea, larder and even our wine! 
 There is a real difference between those who belong to the home because they have a natural relationship with the parents, and those who don't. 
 What does that say to us who are Christians, who belong to God by reason of our baptism and our confession? 
 Let me illustrate this by introducing to you a man whom I shall call Tom, who was a member of my congregation in Durham. 
 Tom was a very able businessman and a very keen Evangelical Christian. 
 He was always zealous in good works, always regular at worship and a key member of the church. 
 At work he was a high flier and his salary was commensurate with his ability. 
 One day Tom came to see me and poured out a story which told me the other side of his ambitious, over-achieving self. 
 He was the product of a broken home and therefore a single-parent child. 
 His mother was ambitious for her boy, and her ambition took the form of constantly encouraging, rebuking and endlessly telling him how he could improve. 
 As time went on the comments became less encouraging and more accusing, so that at the age of forty-five, in my study, he told me how he felt a failure and as a Christian unable to understand God as a God of love. 
 God to him was a figure of terror, of impossible standards. 
 How extraordinary, I thought as we talked together, that this man's theological understanding of justification by faith &mdash; in which he believed passionately &mdash; had no echo whatsoever in his life. 
 Then I began to see Tom's sad plight. 
 The shadow side of his success was that of failure, watered by the constant accusing refrain that &bquo;You are not good enough; you could do better; you will never get on if you don't try; God will not accept you if you don't try harder&hellip; &bquo; 
 There was no easy solution to Tom's problem. 
 That meeting was only the beginning of a long series of meetings, retreats and counselling sessions which formed the stepping stones for a return to an authentic Christian experience. 
 He began to see that God was not a tyrant but a loving Father; he began to see that the Christian life was not a series of impossible demands to satisfy the whims of an unreasonable employer; he began to see that he was welcome because of who he was, and not  on the basis of what he could achieve. 
 I happen to know that there are many Toms in the Christian Church. 
 If you would count yourself as one of them, can I suggest that you reflect on the fact that as Christians we are not only welcome in this home but we belong here. 
 Freedom and discipline 
 God has no favourites. 
 We are all special to him, and he longs for each of us to enter into the space and privileges of his home. 
 The mention of privileges, however, brings together two seeming opposites: freedom and discipline. 
 We have freedom to enjoy the space that God gives to us in his family. 
 He gives us that space to grow into the maturity he wants from each of us: freedom to think, freedom to pray in our own way, freedom to worship according to our temperament and inclination. 
 We must remember, however, that God is never indulgent. 
 He does not misuse freedom, and he does not expect us to either. 
 The right use of freedom leads to the Christian discipline that we call &bquo;holiness&equo;. 
 Although this is often construed as &bquo;thou shalt not do this&equo;, or &bquo;thou shalt not do that&equo;, holiness is really Christian discipline for the service of Christ. 
 It is accepting the lifestyle of Christ so that we may be usable for God's glory. 
 It is using our time, our talents and our money for God and his mission. 
 There is very much a pattern of &bquo;holy worldliness&equo; about Christian discipline. 
 Well did Dag Hammarskj&oslash;ld say that &bquo;the road to holiness necessarily passes through the world of action&equo;. 
 Well did the Book of Common prayer put it succinctly when it spoke of the relationship between us and God: &bquo;Whose service is perfect freedom&equo;. 
 This is a perfect picture of responsible parenthood, whether we are talking about human or divine parenthood. 
 A good parent does not let his or her child do anything; there have to be proper guidelines, firm but loving admonition at times and clear but gentle encouragement. 
 That is God's way with us, too. 
 Let us return to our pilgrimage. 
 What might this theme, &bquo;a home that is always open&equo; mean to us? 
 Because God's home is always open, it means that we are always welcome and there is always forgiveness, God is  giving us space to present himself to our hearts as a God of love but at the same time as a God who wants us to grow into his likeness. 
 There are things in all our lives that displease him: misplaced ambition, wrong relationships, lack of prayerfulness, slackness in spiritual things, and so on. 
 We all have a great deal of business to do with our heavenly Father and it is in the security of God's home that we can know that we belong and are special. 
 Max Warren, the great Christian leader and General Secretary of the Church Missionary Society, wrote of the home in this way: 
 A home is the treasury of God where purity, beauty and joy are shared, for his purposes, inviolate. 
 For a home is in itself the triumph of God banishing night and chaos and necessity, indwelling this lifeless clay with the Spirit divine of freedom and joy. 
 A Well that Never Runs Dry 
 If you ever get the chance to go to Nazareth you will be shown a well with the sign over it, &bquo;St Mary's Well&equo;. 
 It was very possibly from that actual spring that Mary would have made daily journeys to fetch water. 
 Perhaps, also, as a young boy Jesus himself might have been sent on errands to fill the pitcher. 
 We might speculate further and say that they probably lived very close to the well because of the importance of water in the life of a Middle Eastern family. 
 Here at Walsingham there is a well. 
 Today's theme will serve us satisfactorily as a basis for our meditation, because water has had a long association with such images of healing, blessing and anointing. 
 Let me tell you of the images that spring to my mind when we talk about water. 
 The reality of God's blessing 
 We are not surprised that water became the symbol of baptism  because of its associations with ordinary things like washing and refreshment. 
 For the early Church, however, water was not just an image, but a dramatic and essential element in the blessing that God was going to give. 
 Water for the Eastern mind was a very precious gift of God because it spelt the difference between life and death. 
 Abundance of it represented laughter and joy; scarcity represented suffering and even death. 
 So here is a good place for us to begin. 
 Water to you and me is so ordinary. 
 We take it for granted. 
 Yet that is where we begin with God: his providential care for each of us and his provision for each of our lives. 
 I gave you yesterday the analogy of the home, and now we can imagine Mary bustling about the home with water for washing, for cooking and for cleaning. 
 Each of these is a symbol of a deeper reality for us in the home of Christ. 
 An aspect of this is found in John 2.1&ndash;11. 
 This familiar story about the wedding feast at Cana of Galilee points to the deeper reality there is to be found in Christ. 
 Three significant things are to be seen in the story. 
 First, there is the embarrassment about the wine. 
 Half way through the feast the wine runs out. 
 We can all imagine the disgrace this would have caused. 
 Whatever the reason, it was a most serious problem. 
 Second, Mary was there of her own right, and the fact that she is mentioned first probably indicates that she knew the family very well. 
 She it is who mentions the embarrassment to Jesus. 
 The conversation is curious and rather contrived and, like most of the conversations in John's Gospel, is Christocentric &mdash; that is, it points to the mystery and glory of Christ. 
 &bquo;They have no wine,&equo; Mary said to Jesus. 
 &bquo;O woman, what have you to do with me?&equo; retorted Jesus. 
 &bquo;My hour has not yet come&equo; (John 2.3&ndash;4). 
 We could paraphrase it to read: &bquo;Mother, can't you see that this is not the time for my mission and nature to be revealed?&equo; 
 Like many a mother faced with the apparent intransigence of her child, she ignored the rebuff and gave the servants the best advice any of us could receive: &bquo;Do whatever he tells you&equo; (John 2.5). 
 The third significant thing in the story is, of course, the miracle itself. 
 Jesus takes the water jars, wine is drawn from the village well and the water is changed.  
 So water for me represents the ordinariness of life which Jesus can take and make very special. 
 Never despise ordinary things &mdash; the ordinary in yourself or in others. 
 Never cheapen the wonder of the commonplace in life. 
 God is able to take the common in you and me and make it a sacrament of blessing for others. 
 Indeed, sacrament is the key word because it is a symbol of the reality to which it points but of which it also partakes. 
 In a wonderful and mysterious way, when God's grace touches a person's life, the ordinary is irradiated with the glory of Christ making us &bquo;grace-full&equo;. 
 God's presence with his people 
 Our theme is &bquo;A well that never runs dry&equo; &mdash; and it never runs dry because it represents God's presence with us. 
 When we use the phrase &bquo;God with us&equo; we mean, of course, the incarnation . 
 I want to develop this theme for a while because it is central within this place of Walsingham. 
 Incarnation means God becoming one of us, born of Mary; but there are some disconcerting features in the story which we need to observe and reflect upon. 
 First, it is a real incarnation. 
 This is no pretend story, but one that stresses real earthiness &mdash; God's coming to the profane and ending the separation between sacred and secular. 
 As I have reminded groups before now, the reality of incarnation has been central to Catholic spirituality and practice; that is not so true of other traditions. 
 As one born a &bquo;Cockney&equo; I can tell you of the great Catholic priests who lived among the poor of the East End of London &mdash; and loved them into the Kingdom of God. 
 Like that lovely story about Brother Andrew among tramps and vagrants, leading the singing and picking fleas off his cassock as they sang quite innocently: &bquo;Count your blessings, name them one by one!&equo; 
 Even if our ministries do not take that form of living as radically as that, incarnation does challenge each of us to apply the message of Christ. 
 &bquo;Connect,&equo; screams the gospel, &bquo;don't just talk about the faith, live it and die for it!&equo; 
 Second, incarnation stresses the pathway of weakness and even failure that is the pattern of discipleship. 
 The incarnational model of Mary and Jesus stresses that it is our very weakness which may become a tool for the Kingdom. 
 Paul says in I Corinthians 1.27 that &bquo;God chose what is foolish in  the world to shame the wise&equo;. 
 While no doubt Paul was thinking of the uncomplicated Christian message compared with the sophisticated philosophies of his day, and of the simple slaves and ordinary people who were joining the Christian family, he might have had the Lord's background in mind as well. 
 How strange that God chose the Jews, and how extraordinary that he placed the Messiah in an ordinary Jewish home in a backwater place among the yokels of Galilee of the Gentiles! 
 Between ourselves, I sometimes find myself struggling with the reality of living in a Church which patently does not live out the implications of all this. 
 Our Church often measures things in terms of worldly success, and not in terms of the humility of weakness and failure. 
 Acceptance so often seems to rest with what we are and our place in society. 
 &bquo;Are you a success and with a healthy bank balance? 
 Welcome!&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you energetic with lots of ideas? 
 Welcome!&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you able to become a youth leader? 
 Churchwarden? 
 Then come on in!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I see, you are poor, weak, you don't have many GCSEs. 
 I note you are getting on a bit. 
 Sorry, we cannot find a place for you in the Christian ministry.&equo; 
 How that contrasts with the message we preach! 
 Now I am not, of course, challenging the excellence that God requires from us all but I am challenging a tendency to overthrow the radical message of incarnation. 
 The famous Cur&eacute; d'Ars would have failed an ACCM on academic grounds and St Paul would have been rejected for other reasons. 
 Yet I see from Church history the many glorious illustrations of God's weak people. 
 Take some of the Lord's disciples &mdash; Andrew, James, John, and even Peter himself. 
 Take such people as Gladys Aylward, D.L. Moody, Mother Teresa and many other &bquo;average&equo; people whose lives were made remarkable through the grace of God. 
 John Henry Newman knew his Church history when he wrote: 
 Few tho' the faithful and fierce the foe, 
 Yet weakness is aye Heaven's might. 
 Fellow pilgrims, the wonderful reality of incarnation is a message to us all that God can take the foolish things of this life and make us rich vessels for his use. 
 The water can still be changed into the wine of his presence.  
 In my garden at Wells I have a wonderful well &mdash; indeed, there are five of them and the city of Wells derives its name from the five springs in the palace grounds. 
 The extraordinary thing about the place is its ordinariness. 
 If you were to visit it you would be struck by the quietness of the small pool. 
 No great torrents of water, no spectacular waterfalls, no deafening roars of waters disgorging their immense might. 
 Indeed, if you are lucky, on a clear day you might just be able to see the spring bubbling up at the bottom of the pond. 
 Yet from that very still place immense power emerges. 
 Thousands of gallons of water per minute flow from underground streams which pour from the tranquil pool to form the moat and run into the gutters of Wells and into the many little streams around, irrigating the fields with their dancing life and wonderful presence. 
 Surely that is a picture of what God longs to do with your life and mine. 
 We think of the desert of modern life with the concentration on material possessions and its resultant poverty. 
 We consider the dryness of the Church as it tends to be too often a shadow image of that world. 
 Our God can still take the ordinary and make it extraordinary. 
 He is able to take the weakness of our present experience and say to our hearts: &bquo;Look, don't despise yourself. 
 You are special, you are made in my image and likeness. 
 Let me take hold of that weakness of yours and let me change your water into wine.&equo; 
 A Fire that will Never Go Out 
 I don't know about you, but I cannot conceive of a home without a fire. 
 Even in these days of gas and electric fires it is quite unusual for a living room to be bereft of a fireplace. 
 It is normally the central point of a home and around it gather the family as we meet for fellowship, fun and general chit-chat. 
 Although we are not told it, Mary's home would certainly have had a fire in the one and only downstairs room, and there the Holy Family would have met to eat and to share together. 
 What images spring to your mind when you think of fire? 
 In the New Testament, fire is a principal symbol of the Holy Spirit, and that is what I want to talk about now. 
 To begin with, let me remind you that there is a very  profound link between the Virgin Mary and the Holy Spirit. 
 Right from the beginning of the Christian story we can see the Spirit at work. 
 He came upon Mary and anointed her to be the mother of the Lord. 
 There could be no miracle of the virginal conception without the work of the Third person of the Trinity. 
 He is the unsung and unseen dynamic in the infancy narratives. 
 That same Spirit, of course, empowered Jesus for his rich ministry and led John the Baptist to tell others of the One who would baptize people with the Holy Spirit and with &bquo;fire&equo;. 
 And, as we know so well, the Holy Spirit fell on the day of pentecost with tongues as of fire. 
 For Mary, however, the coming of the Spirit was not a comfortable experience! 
 Anyone who has romantic ideas of what it must have been like for great women and men to be filled with God's Spirit should think again if the story of Mary is anything to go by. 
 The empowering of the Spirit for her took the form of risk, misunderstandings and downright difficulties. 
 &bquo;The Comforter&equo;, once remarked Cardinal Suenens, &bquo;is given, not to make us comfortable, but to make us disciples.&equo; 
 What aspects of the Spirit's work do we see when we explore the image of fire? 
 Holiness and clarity of truth 
 I wonder if I may offer some thoughts on this theme as I reflect on the situation facing Catholic Christians in our Church today. 
 I am keenly aware, as you know, of the many Catholics whose faith and commitment have been badly shaken and disturbed in recent days, particularly over the ordination of women to the priesthood. 
 I can say this with sympathy and love even though I am, as many know, entirely supportive of the ordination of women. 
 This stand does not make me blind to the distress others feel or to the disillusionment that this issue causes. 
 The recent nomination of a woman as Assistant Bishop of Massachusetts, and the remarks of one diocesan bishop that &bquo;the ordination of women to the priesthood must be achieved at practically any cost&equo; will cause great despair and lead to grave questioning of all that the Church of England has stood for. 
 What is going on? 
 What can be done? 
 Is the fire going out in Catholicism generally? 
 It is important to have a wide backcloth when considering these problems. 
 We in the Church of England are not alone  among Christians in having daunting questions to resolve. 
 The Roman Catholic Communion has many issues that it seeks to resolve: the urgent problem of falling vocations for the priesthood, the problem of a celibate priesthood, the Lefebvre schism, the tension between local churches and the Roman See, and so on. 
 Other denominations, too, are wrestling with similar problems, but all of us are, in reality, dealing with the same central problem: What is, in essence, the kernel of Christian truth that is non-negotiable, and what is expendable? 
 What is a &bquo;first-order&equo; issue and what are &bquo;second-&equo; and even &bquo;third-order&equo; questions? 
 There is something about a fire that reminds me of holiness and truth. 
 A fire burns away the dross; the dirt and old paint are burnt away leaving the sharpness and clarity of the original metal. 
 Similarly, on retreats such as this one, the fire of the Holy Spirit has an opportunity to burn away the dross of the Church and even of doctrine that may obscure the faith that is central to all we believe and hope for. 
 The ecclesiasticism that so often gets in the way of the gospel; the temporal concerns of church politics that take up so much time; the fussiness of much of church life; our obsession with &bquo;churchy&equo; things &mdash; all these and more are aspects of additions that are really secondary concerns. 
 God has a way on retreats such as this of bringing home to us the challenge of a first-order question: &bquo;Do you love me in the way Mary loved me and allowed herself to be used for my mission?&equo; 
 I hope we shall leave here with a deeper love and, if I dare suggest it, a more confident love. 
 We might say, however: &bquo;If the fire burns away the dross and leaves the real thing behind, what is the nature of that original?&equo; 
 I am prepared to answer at once: &bquo;Why Christ, of course, and our love for him which is fed and watered by the prayers of his people in his Church.&equo; 
 This has been central to the Catholic tradition as we well know. 
 Take the famous Cur&eacute; d'Ars, Jean-Baptiste Vianney. 
 His is the remarkable story of a young man with hardly any academic ability. 
 Today we might say that he was a little &bquo;thick&equo;. 
 There is simply no way he would have been accepted for training in our Church &mdash; and that is perhaps a tragedy. 
 God nonetheless blessed him and used him. 
 He made the priesthood and exercised a distinguished ministry. 
 His secret? 
 He was a man for whom  Catholicity was reduced to its Evangelical essentials &mdash; the love of God, a burning desire that people should know and love his Saviour, and a great belief in the power of prayer. 
 Although a faithful man of his own Church, everything was subsumed under these Evangelical essentials. 
 The crisis of Catholicism today is a question of direction: Where is Catholic renewal to go from here? 
 In spite of the many things it has achieved over the last hundred years &mdash; and we have all been shaped by that &mdash; it has got itself boxed in by one issue. 
 As I find myself an outsider at this point, I can only put to you another question: Are you really sure that the issue of the ordination of women is so fundamental to the gospel that you would leave your Church and, in some cases, surrender your ministries on that point? 
 Is that in essence a central datum of Catholicity? 
 So where is Catholic renewal to go from here? 
 Only you can answer that. 
 I would hope that you would see beyond that, and issues like it, the primary claims of Christ in his Church, to love him and to promote him as Lord of the Church. 
 Confidence in that truth is the seed-bed of growth. 
 Warmth and enthusiasm 
 The second thing a fire does is to warm the house and make it inviting. 
 How does this apply to the life of the Church? 
 I mentioned at the start of this address that around the fire Joseph and Mary and their children would have gathered for fun and fellowship. 
 As a matter of fact, from the physical realities of heat and cold have come many of our everyday analogies. 
 We talk of being &bquo;cold as ice&equo;, &bquo;hot blooded&equo;, &bquo;cold blooded&equo;, &bquo;on fire&equo;, and so on. 
 When the fire of the Holy Spirit falls, he warms our hearts for the things of God. 
 In a word, he enthuses  us. 
 The word enthusiasm comes from a root meaning &bquo;God-intoxicated&equo;. 
 Sadly, in some parishes I find more apathy than enthusiasm. 
 Enthusiasm usually leads to growth, when coupled with sensitivity and knowledge. 
 Apathy, whatever it is linked with &bquo;declines into death. 
 I love the opening words of the Magnificat: &bquo;My soul magnifies the Lord, and my spirit rejoices in God my Saviour&equo; (Luke 1.46&ndash;47). 
 Mary's heart was enlarged with a great vision of God who comes to overthrow the oppressor and rescue the poor. 
 Service begins with praise. 
 You priests &mdash;  let your service for Christ arise from the warmth of your praise. 
 You fellow Christians &mdash; never lose the warm love for your Lord, because that is the very centre of your service for him. 
 I'd love to see the warmth and enthusiasm of the Spirit spilling over into our worship on Sundays. 
 Yes, let there be dignity, colour, light and majesty in our worship. 
 Yes, let there be solemnity and reverence at the high points of our celebration. 
 Does that have to mean coldness, reserve and a frowning aloofness that drives ordinary people away? 
 Of course not! 
 These characteristics have no real place in vibrant Christian worship, whether of Catholic or Evangelical variety. 
 Let us have warmth as well as dignity, smiles alongside the serious, and joy at the heart of it all. 
 Power and conviction 
 Finally, there is something about fire when it is small and controllable that is lovely, but uncontrolled it is unpredictable and rather frightening. 
 Think of the might of a forest fire or the burning heat of the sun. 
 There is, we have to say, something unpredictable about the work of the Holy Spirit. 
 Mary was to find that out as time went on. 
 She was sent out on an adventure which took her from the Annunciation to pentecost, and the questions and uncertainties built up. 
 There were times when the ministry of her Son left her feeling cut out of the action, and she was amazed and perhaps frightened at what she had unleashed on the world. 
 The questions led up to the cross and even beyond it. 
 On that cross her dying Son said to John: &bquo;Behold, your mother!&equo; 
 (John 19.27) There she lost everything that really mattered. 
 Surely there could not have been a more destructive fire than Calvary; but more was to come. 
 Through the resurrection the fire scorched forth at pentecost and to the foundation of the Church. 
 The fire, burning its way through the structures of old Israel, created a new community of faith and love. 
 I would like to enlarge on this theme, but I dare not because our experience falls far short of what we dimly perceive in the pages of Scripture. 
 Much as we love our Church, we know it falls far short of its inheritance of faith. 
 Listen to Alec Vidler:  
 A great book, a bell-ringing book about the Holy Spirit could be written, though it might be in the form of a poem or a novel rather than a theological treatise. 
 The reason why this book has not yet been written is that conscious experience of the presence and life of the Spirit among contemporary Christians is so thin and weak and hampered that conditions do not exist in which anyone can write with full-blooded conviction on the subject. 
 (Christian Belief , SCM 1957). 
 How may we change those conditions so that the book may be written, or, more importantly, that lives may be changed through that same Spirit of power? 
 We know that &bquo;theologically&equo; only he can do it, but we can play our part. 
 I dream, I hope and I pray that in our diocese we shall see God &bquo;s Spirit, the Spirit that fell on Mary, coming to us and doing great things for God. 
 Won't it be wonderful when it happens that you and I will be able to share a little secret that, in the womb of Walsingham, on our diocesan retreat &bquo;a prayer was uttered and a commitment determined. 
 There in 1988 a little vision of God was seen; there we were strengthened by the Spirit of God to go back to our deaneries and parishes more confident &bquo;more convinced of the truths of our faith, to share him with others in the way that Mary did.  
 THE CHURCH'S YEAR 
 Advent: &bquo;Now is the Acceptable Time&equo; Mark parish church, Advent Sunday, 3 December 1990 
 Quite a few years ago now I was at a Family Service on an Advent Sunday, and the young curate began his talk with a question addressed to the children. 
 &bquo;Can anyone tell me&equo;, he asked, &bquo;what is the special name for today?&equo; 
 The answer given by one little boy will always remain with me. 
 &bquo;Sir,&equo; he said, &bquo;today is Adventure Sunday.&equo; 
 What a good answer! 
 Of course, that is what Advent is all about &mdash; God's adventure in breaking into our history and making it &bquo;his-story&equo;. 
 What does Advent mean for us today? 
 How can we make sense of it? 
 Let me first introduce you to my text: 2 Corinthians 6.2. 
 &bquo;Now is the acceptable time; behold, now is the day of salvation.&equo; 
 In this passage Paul, writing quite soon after the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ, is quite emphatic in stating that, because of Jesus Christ, God's time has invaded ours, and this is the moment of decision. 
 Advent reminds us of the significance of God's time . 
 I wonder if you are aware that in the Bible there are two words for time and that, generally speaking, they refer to two quite different ideas. 
 The first word is used to describe ordinary time &mdash; past, present and future. 
 The word used is chronos , from which comes our word &bquo;chronology&equo;. 
 So dates like 1066 or Aunt Ethel's birthday all belong to chronos  time. 
 The other word, kairos , is a word that is used a great deal to describe God's breaking into our time and history to bring his salvation. 
 Through Christ, God has made sense of time, and the moment of his &bquo;breaking in&equo; becomes the moment of discovery, hope and salvation. 
 It was with this meaning in mind that Paul told his readers: &bquo;Now is the acceptable time ( kairos );  behold, now is the day of salvation.&equo; 
 In a limited way we can understand this, because for all of us certain dates stand out with striking significance. 
 Let me ask some members of the congregation a few questions: 
 First, the Vicar: Why is 12 August special for you? 
 Reply: It's the anniversary of my wedding. 
 To Susan: Why is 12 December a day you will never forget? 
 Reply: It was the day my child was born. 
 To Andy: 12 July is important to you. 
 Why? 
 Reply: It was the day I passed my exam. 
 Days like that are very important to us. 
 We measure happiness and sadness by momentous things that happened on occasions such as these. 
 A day passes from being merely ordinary ( chronos ) into one irradiated with a special significance ( kairos ) because of the event with which it is permanently associated. 
 Let me give you another example. 
 I still recall the day John Kennedy died. 
 I was sitting on the top deck of a London bus when the news travelled from passenger to passenger: &bquo;The president of the United States has been shot.&equo; 
 The bus pulled over to the side of the road and the driver rushed into a newsagent's shop to get the facts. 
 It was terrible news. 
 This was not the shooting of an ordinary man, but that of the president of the United States. 
 We were all caught up in the shock and wondered what the significance was. 
 For the Christian, God's time is Jesus-time: his coming. 
 By his coming to us as a human being and by his suffering, dying and rising for us, our lives have meaning and hope. 
 Kairos  time has invaded chronos  time. 
 This takes me into my second point: Advent means that through Christ this world has a destiny because God has poured into it his hope . 
 As we approach Christmas the real tragedy is that the vast majority of our friends &mdash; good, sincere people, most of them &mdash; will not get within a mile of the real meaning of Christmas. 
 There will be rejoicing &mdash; but at what? 
 There will be feasting &mdash; but for what? 
 There will be drinking and revelling &mdash; but to what end? 
 Our friends will still be thinking of Christmas as chronos  time &mdash; just another festival. 
 The German philosopher Ernst Bloch, who incidentally was a communist, once analysed modern society as suffering from a disease he called &bquo;death by bread alone&equo;. 
 He wrote: &bquo;It is like  a vast supermarket in which absentmindedly, yet intent on what we are doing, we push our shopping trolleys up one aisle and down the other, while death and alienation have the run of the place.&equo; 
 This &bquo;death by bread alone&equo; concept means that people in the West have lost sight of spiritual and eternal values and now only perceive material and temporal aims. 
 We are like Hans Christian Anderson's tale of the Emperor who believed he was clothed in the finest garments &mdash; but all the time he was naked. 
 For the Christian who is living in the shadow of Advent, this life is no longer a &bquo;cul-de-sac&equo; but a road of hope, because God has taken up residence here. 
 Gerard Manley Hopkins' great poem &bquo;God's Grandeur&equo; puts it so well: 
 The world is charged with the grandeur of God. 
 It will flame out, like shining from shook foil;&hellip; 
 Hopkins goes on: 
 And for all this &bquo;nature is never spent; 
 There lives the dearest freshness deep down things; 
 The Christian agrees. 
 We look at life, we look at the values that Christ has introduced, we look at the unity between the worlds of spirit and matter and we are in no doubt that we abide in God's eternal love. 
 &bquo;There lives the dearest freshness deep down things.&equo; 
 Advent signals values: that God loved us so much that he was willing to enter upon an adventure that cost him the death of his Son. 
 That love continues, and one day will be the reason for his coming as Saviour and, yes, as Judge. 
 What is our response? 
 Let me give you two quite different answers. 
 The first, alas, is all too common. 
 It is told by Tony Hancock in &bquo;The Blood Donor&equo;, a classic episode in his wonderful TV series. 
 In it he boasts of his gifts to charity, all written down in his little black book: 
 Half a crown to Arab refugees, one shilling and threepence for the lifeboats, sixpence to Christian Aid, five bob to Help the Aged, self-denial week &mdash; ninepence. 
 When the great Audit Day comes and the Great Accountant says to  me, &bquo;And what did you do?&equo;, 
 I shall hand him my little black book and say, &bquo;Ere you are, Mate. 
 Add that little lot up!&equo; 
 It's a good story but the ending is wrong, because you and I have nothing to contribute except our brokenness, our helplessness and weakness. 
 The story speaks as though the Great Auditor is a total stranger. 
 A far better story and, dare I say it, a more Christian understanding &bquo;comes from my second illustration. 
 It happened to me in Watford many years ago. 
 I was returning from a hospital where I had been visiting someone, and I was last in a bus queue. 
 It was a very foggy evening and extremely cold. 
 The other people in the queue had obviously been waiting longer than I and were moaning and groaning. 
 The bus was so late. 
 Then we heard the sound of a vehicle. 
 Excitement changed to despair as people realized it wasn't the bus &mdash; only a car, which crawled past us. 
 Suddenly it stopped, and reversed until it was level with me. 
 Out of the fog came a voice: &bquo;George? 
 George Carey? 
 Is that you?&equo; 
 I recognized the voice! 
 It was a close friend. 
 Thankfully I accepted his invitation to &bquo;jump in the back&equo;, and home we sped. 
 Let's continue the story for just a moment in a ridiculous way. 
 Let us imagine that, back at the bus stop &bquo;the other people were furious. 
 &bquo;What right had he to accept that lift?&equo; cries one lady. 
 &bquo;I was in the queue before him. 
 It's not fair!&equo; 
 But it was fair. 
 You see, she did not know the driver. 
 I did. 
 That made all the difference. 
 The story, I believe, goes to the heart of what Advent is all about. 
 It is about a relationship that changes the way we look at life; it is about a friendship that will take us through life, facing the black moments as well as the good; it is about God &bquo;s time breaking into our lives, giving them hope and meaning and joy. 
 &bquo;Now is the acceptable time; behold, now&hellip;,  
 Christmas: a sign of God with Us Wells Cathedral, Christmas 1988 
 In December 1859 the editorial of a leading scientific journal concluded its survey of scientific achievements with the statement: &bquo;No significant piece of research or outstanding discovery happened this year.&equo; 
 What an academic gaffe &mdash; that was the year that saw the publication of Charles Darwin's The Origin of Species , a book that was to shake the very foundations of Western thought! 
 In a similar way, a Roman soldier writing from Palestine to his parents in about 4 BC might well have written: &bquo;This is an out-of-the-way dump. 
 Fancy getting posted to this land of war-crazy illiterates.&equo; 
 And yet, that land of &bquo;war-crazy illiterates&equo; was to be the birthplace of Jesus Christ: the person whose words and actions have inspired millions of people down the centuries. 
 Christmas is for most of us a magical moment in the year when we gather with our families, sing familiar carols and see the delight in the eyes of the children as they open their stockings and presents. 
 But what makes it most special for the Christian is the celebration of the coming of God's Son into our troubled world. 
 There can be no disputing the word &bquo;troubled&equo; either. 
 We celebrate this Christmas in the shadow of three awful human tragedies &mdash; the earthquake in Armenia in the Soviet Union; the train crash in north London and now, this week, the air disaster in Lockerbie. 
 How dreadful. 
 It could also be that for some of you 1988 has also seen some trouble, a bereavement perhaps, that has shaken you to the foundations. 
 You will be wondering, what is the message of Christmas for me this year in the face of this or that problem? 
 Listen then to the message of the angel in Luke 2.10,12: &bquo;I bring you good news of a great  joy which will come to all the people&hellip; 
 And this will be a sign for you: you will find a babe wrapped in swaddling cloths and lying in a manger.&equo; 
 A sign  &mdash; and it is important to remember that Christmas itself is only a sign. 
 A sign speaks of something beyond itself. 
 All the trappings of Christmas &mdash; the decorated tree, lights, the presents we give, the crib, tinsel, crackers, the eating and drinking which make up our celebrations &mdash; are only &bquo;signs&equo;. 
 The sign or the symbol, however, can be ignored and treated as an end in itself. 
 For many people, Christmas is a time to have an apocalyptic hangover or binge; the Christian bit is an unnecessary encumbrance to them. 
 For others, Christmas is a welcome relief from the pressure of work and a time to recuperate. 
 For busy housewives, Christmas can present itself with other problems &mdash; over-excited children and a million and one things to do. 
 Little wonder then that at this festive season of good will to all people, arguments and friction mock our pretence at peace and sometimes split the family. 
 So, we have to ask again: What, please, is Christmas a sign of? 
 It is a sign of God's presence with us. 
 You see, even at the time it was only a sign. 
 The baby did not open its eyes and start preaching a sermon. 
 He did not hand out sayings of Jesus in a little red book, or give them Christmas presents. 
 The baby was only a sign and could only have been understood later in the light of the life of the person who was to be the Saviour of the world. 
 Indeed, here is a reminder that Christmas can only be understood in the light of later events, can only be discovered in all its wonderful freshness and life when we discover for ourselves that Jesus is the human face of God. 
 We also discover at this point the reality of love at the heart of the sign. 
 Just think for a moment of the way love is expressed in our giving. 
 All right, I know that one of us will get the inevitable bottle of aftershave, or talcum powder. 
 There was a time when I could have stocked a chemist's shop with male toiletries! 
 Yet leaving that aside, our gifts are signs of our love or respect for one another. 
 Parents know what their children are longing for and will give them what they want, even if every piggy bank in the house has to be broken open. 
 Love gives. 
 You see, there are many talkers about: politicians  who want to change society but have not got time to help their next door neighbour; Christians who want to sing their hymns but can't be bothered to get involved in their local church. 
 It is not love if it is locked up in the vaults of our dreams for a better world and a happier life. 
 Love has to move from idea to reality, and that is always God's way &mdash; the way of incarnation. 
 That theological word is a wonderful word describing God's action of becoming human for each one of us. 
 No faith is more materialistic than God's surprising action of sending Jesus into our world for us. 
 In one of his books, David Jenkins speaks of a cartoon which shows God sitting on a cloud looking very cross and saying: &bquo;You love one another or I'll come down there and thump you.&equo; 
 Well, he does come down &mdash; not to thump us but to love us in Jesus, to teach us the Christian way, and to take our sins and failures to the cross and to rise again in triumph for us all. 
 A sign of God with us. 
 But a sign also of God's commitment to his world. 
 You see, Christmas is linked with the season of Advent &mdash; the season of hope which sets before us the hope of his coming to restore all things and bring all things to a glorious conclusion. 
 So the angels sang the Gloria : &bquo;Glory to God in the highest, and on earth peace among men with whom he is pleased!&equo; 
 (Luke 2.14) 
 Yes, we grieve when tragedy strikes in such awful forms as we have seen recently. 
 We are heartbroken when death comes in its ugly presence into our homes, and we dislike the unpalatable fact of impermanence. 
 But the message of Christmas is that God will never leave us and his love will endure for ever, which makes Christmas a real celebration of God's commitment to our world and makes sense of all our hopes and dreams. 
 This can only be fully understood, however, when we as individuals make our own personal and spiritual visit to Bethlehem. 
 You may know the delightful story of G.K. Chesterton who was always getting lost. 
 One day he found himself at Market Harborough but with no idea where he was going. 
 So he sent a telegram to his wife saying: &bquo;Am in Market Harborough &mdash; where ought I to be?&equo; and she, being a practical woman, sent a terse telegram with one word: &bquo;Home&equo;.  
 That is the message of Christmas: come home. 
 Come home to his love. 
 Come home to an understanding of the world which puts God back at the centre of it. 
 Christmas is not the reality of the Christian faith: it is a sign of God's gracious invitation to celebrate his love personally by welcoming him into our hearts and lives, not just once a year but every day we live. 
 In the words of the poem by Angelus Silesius: 
 Tho' Christ a thousand times in Bethlehem is born 
 If he's not born in thee, thou art still forlorn. 
 May God bless us all this Christmas time as we make our way to the manger and celebrate the gift of his love and life.  
 the Epiphany: Strangers Discover Christ The Bishop's farewell address to the Cathedral of Bath and Wells, Epiphany Sunday, 6 January 1991 
 I am going to talk about the familiar and rich story of the visit of the Magi, the wise men, to the infant Christ, from Matthew 2.1&ndash;12. 
 Epiphany is one of the oldest festivals in the Church, far Older than Christmas. 
 It introduces a wonderful idea, that strangers from afar find the Christ and discover him to be the Saviour of the world. 
 Let me mention three things very briefly this morning. 
 A puzzling question 
 &bquo;Where is he who has been born king of the Jews?&equo; 
 (Matthew 2.2) This is an ancient question, but as up to date as the latest computer. 
 Of course, we might put it a different way today: &bquo;Can God be known, and is the Christian faith the answer to human needs?&equo; 
 This, I want to submit, is far more important than many of the material questions and issues that fill our waking hours &mdash; questions of food, jobs, ambition and human happiness. 
 If God is, then it makes all these other things worthwhile. 
 In other words, if in Jesus Christ I find the answer to the question &bquo;Where is he?&equo; then all the transitory questions of life find genuine meaning around this wonderful centre. 
 So we find these men &mdash; were they three in number? 
 Who knows? &mdash; making a long journey. 
 I saw on a church bill-board recently the familiar statement, &bquo;Wise men still seek Christ&equo;. 
 They do, and it is still a quest worth becoming a question: &bquo;Where is he?&equo; 
 The firm answer given by the Christian faith is, look no further than Jesus Christ. 
 He can meet the longings of the human heart. 
 Go to him, abide in him, trust in him, look to him. 
 Some of you may have heard me say before that when I was  a young ordinand I met up with a marvellous Canadian bishop, Ralph Dean. 
 There he stood in the college chapel, grizzled and weather-beaten by harsh Canadian winters. 
 He came out with a wonderful phrase which has stayed with me over the years. 
 &bquo;If you feel that God is far, far away, remember this &mdash; he has not moved.&equo; 
 A peculiar place 
 God pops up in the most surprising of places. 
 Fancy him turning up in a snivelling little place like Bethlehem. 
 Of course, today it has romantic overtones. 
 Go to Bethlehem today, and in spite of the unrest there, it has that undeniable atmosphere of prayer and sanctity poured into it by millions of pilgrims and visitors. 
 What a holy place &mdash; but only insofar as in that place the Saviour became a human person and started his adventure of faith. 
 Bethlehem means &bquo;house of bread&equo;, and the One born there became the &bquo;bread of life&equo; who becomes our spiritual food today. 
 Yet Bethlehem the place is no more special, really, than any other place now: because the coming of Christ into our world has sanctified every place, every place becomes holy, where he may be found: your homes, your places of work, and, yes, in a special way, churches like this glorious Cathedral of Wells. 
 Sometimes bishops get ridiculous letters. 
 I received a few not so long ago complaining about this place, saying that it does not speak of God; that it is a monument to a man-made religion; that it ought to be pulled down and a block of flats built here instead, and the money spent on missionary work abroad. 
 Well, the Dean and I took great joy in disabusing that person of that mistaken view. 
 Indeed, not so long ago I received another letter from an American woman who came to Wells two years ago. 
 Her marriage was in ruins but here in this place she found peace. 
 She prayed here and thought about her marriage; she vowed to do something about it. 
 She lit a candle over there as a silent prayer for her estranged husband and went home. 
 She wrote to me saying that in this place she found it possible to forgive for the first time and then return home to seek reconciliation. 
 It is my desire that this lovely place, made valid with all the prayers and hopes of generations of worshippers, will continue to be open, friendly, worshipful, adaptable and meaningful to us all.  
 A hazardous journey 
 The Magi had found the answer to their question in a simple child and, in T.S. 
 Eliot's words: &bquo;no longer at home in the old dispensation&equo;, they returned home having found and having been found. 
 No doubt the journey back was as hazardous as it was coming. 
 That is also a parable of life. 
 We cannot say that having faith in Christ makes life easy. 
 Of course not. 
 Faith is always an adventure of trust and hope. 
 It is not an easy, cost-free ride, but it is the constant working out of our hopes and fears. 
 For myself and Eileen as we move on to a ministry which will have its own surprises in the days ahead, we hope that we can lead our beloved Church on. 
 In spite of the obvious gains in recent years &mdash; and no one could be more grateful than I to Robert Runcie and all he achieved &mdash; we now need a period of calmness, of peace, to grow and get on with the real work of caring for others and serving Christ in and through others. 
 The real work of the Church is not done, as anyone in his or her sane mind knows, at General Synod. 
 The real work of the Church is done in every ordinary place of worship. 
 You and I have this wonderful mission to share Christ with others, this mysterious treasure who alone can make sense of it all. 
 I love the rabbinic story of Rabbi Schmelke who lived in Russia. 
 One day a very poor man came begging at his door. 
 &bquo;I have nothing and I have five children to feed,&equo; he pleaded. 
 Now Rabbi Schmelke and his wife were as poor as the beggar. 
 But the rabbi was a very kind man and his heart went out to the poor man. 
 He remembered that his wife had one precious jewel, and he did what no man should ever do &mdash; he went and gave his wife's only jewel to the beggar. 
 No sooner had he shut the door than his wife found him out. 
 &bquo;But that was a very precious jewel!&equo; she stormed. 
 So the rabbi ran after the man and said: &bquo;I have just found out that the jewel I gave you is more precious than I thought &mdash; don't sell it for too little.&equo; 
 I think there is a parable in that for you and me as we seek to share Christ today.  
 Lent: The Glory of the Cross Five talks given in Wells Cathedral during lent, march-April 1988 
 In these addresses we are going to contemplate the cross of Jesus from five different angles. 
 We will consider its mystery as well as its glory. 
 Before we begin, we need to take on board the mystery, a word which will follow us through the five sessions. 
 I do not claim to be able to unravel the complexities of atonement. 
 If I am able to offer a small flicker of light, that will give me great joy! 
 The cross is a mystery. 
 Indeed, I will go further. 
 In the New Testament period it was obviously an embarrassment. 
 For the Romans, crucifixion was a penalty reserved for criminals and for outcasts. 
 For the first Christians to claim this as the heart of their faith was a scandal of the first order. 
 Now it has to be said that the people of that period could at least understand such notions as &bquo;sacrifice&equo;, &bquo;propitiation&equo; and &bquo;atonement&equo;. 
 For us that entire world-view has disappeared. 
 We are not used to such notions and there are few world religions that still offer &bquo;sacrifices&equo;. 
 We do not believe that it is necessary to placate God in such a way. 
 Indeed, it may be argued that the success of Christianity in establishing the finality of the cross in dealing with sin &bquo;once and for all&equo; has removed from our minds its roots in the common experience of our lives. 
 So our problem is understanding why  it should have ever occurred to God that we needed redeeming, saving, restoring, in such a radical way. 
 Why  was it necessary? 
 Why  couldn't God let bygones be bygones? 
 Why  did God choose that particular form? 
 Not all the notions concerning sacrifice are entirely absent from our lives. 
 We speak of the &bquo;sacrifices&equo; we make for one another &mdash; that notion rings many bells. 
 We speak of a mother  sacrificing her life for her children. 
 We are used to evil men demanding a ransom before their victim can be released. 
 Terry Waite languishes in Lebanon &mdash; but it is possible to believe that if our Government came up with a suitably attractive offer, he would be released. 
 So the ideas are still very meaningful in our world, but what we are saying about the cross is this: that in this particular way and through this particular person, God chose to redeem humankind.  
 It was final, it was full and it was free . 
 Let us distinguish between the two words &bquo;atonement&equo; and &bquo;salvation&equo;: atonement refers to a past event, but salvation speaks of it continuing into the future. 
 We might like to have that distinction in mind as these lectures continue. 
 The problem is clear. 
 Christians claim that what happened on Good Friday was decisive for humankind &mdash; it was of such a definitive, absolute nature that it split world history in two and it declares that the many strands of human experience (hope, joy, peace, human fulfilment) run through the crossroads of the cross. 
 That is quite a claim! 
 I am now going to offer you five ways of interpreting the cross. 
 Towards the end of each I will describe a recent example of a person who lived and suffered in such a way. 
 Jesus &mdash; Our Example 
 In I Peter 2, the writer looks at Jesus from the viewpoint of suffering Christians and says: &bquo;Yes, I know all that you are enduring&hellip; look at Jesus&hellip; follow him.&equo; 
 It was certainly the case that in the first centuries the example of Jesus must have been a tremendous model for living and for dying. 
 Consider Jesus; keep him before you as your icon. 
 He suffered for you, so suffer for him. 
 In life, no doubt all of us have been inspired by the example of others &mdash; parents, teachers, friends. 
 Sometimes it has been a case of seeing something done really well and it inspires us to do it even better. 
 An artist friend once remarked: &bquo;I saw this chap make something out of an ordinary piece of wood &mdash; he fashioned it into an exquisite work of art.&equo; 
 He was so inspired that he became an artist too. 
 Yet the idea of Jesus as our example did not become a theory of atonement until the twelfth and thirteenth centuries, and I  want to introduce you now to our first theologian &mdash; Peter Abelard. 
 That particular period of history saw the rise of some wonderful thinkers &mdash; Bernard of Clairvaux, Thomas &agrave; Kempis, Meister Eckhart. 
 It was an age dominated by new ideas, new discoveries and particularly by mysticism based on love. 
 Peter Abelard himself was a fascinating and unusual man. 
 Some of you may have read the book by Helen Waddell about him and his love for H&eacute;lo&iuml;se. 
 Peter was a monk, a scholar with a brilliant, innovative mind. 
 There was a tragic, brief love affair which was doomed to fail, and it is not our concern here. 
 What is our concern, though, is the notion of love which he saw was at the centre of understanding the work of Christ. 
 He had inherited a view of the cross which saw it as the place where Christ did something which changed God's mind about human beings. 
 It satisfied God's honour &mdash; a price had to be paid and Christ paid it. 
 The analogies at the time were very crude and based upon feudal understandings of barons and servants and themes of honour, respect and dignity. 
 Peter Abelard rejected these crude and often absurd ideas which seemed to lower the dignity of God. 
 In their place he substituted a psychological theory which is almost modern in its understanding and penetration. 
 He saw the power of love to inspire and transform. 
 In his opinion, the cross of Christ did not change God, or our relationship  with God at all, but it changes us. 
 The cross does not affect God because he has always been loving and desiring our repentance; it affects us by presenting us with an example of love and sacrifice which overwhelms us because of its outrageous generosity. 
 Let us now dig a little deeper into this theory and try to appreciate Abelard's thought from within. 
 For him the power of love is paramount. 
 For Abelard there is a transforming energy in love which can change people. 
 Perhaps that came from his own experience of human love &mdash; we don't really know. 
 We have all seen love change things. 
 Look what the love of another human being does to human behaviour. 
 Look at what the love of literature, art, sport, does to people's attitudes and patterns of life. 
 For Abelard, then, the cross was an act of love which, though past, still has immense capacity to create. 
 Listen to him writing to H&eacute;lo&iuml;se about the power of the story of love:  
 Put yourself in the position of one of the bystanders on the path of Christ's passion: Are you not moved to tears of remorse by the only Begotten Son of God, who for you and all mankind, in his innocence, was seized, dragged along, blindfolded, mocked, spat upon, crowned with thorns, finally hanged between thieves on the cross?&hellip; 
 Keep him in mind. 
 Look at him going to be crucified for your sake. 
 Be one of the crowd, one of the women who wept and lamented over him&hellip; 
 In your mind be always present at his tomb, weep and wail with the faithful women&hellip; 
 Prepare with them the perfumes for his burial. 
 Let me now mention two particular ideas in Abelard's theory of the power of love. 
 First, the one I have already drawn attention to &mdash; love is infused in us  by revealing love. 
 The cross, in his view, is like a gigantic visual aid which shocks, horrifies and draws our pity and our concern. 
 So, Abelard says, consider, look, keep him in mind. 
 Second, Abelard concentrates upon the action of salvation. 
 He does not narrowly concentrate on the last week of Jesus' life; the entire life of Jesus was an example of sacrificial love. 
 Christ &bquo;illuminates&equo; us by his teaching, by his prayer life and all the deeds of his incarnation. 
 The death of Jesus was its tremendous climax. 
 So what do you and I make of this theory? 
 Does it not make a lot of sense because it rings true to our experience? 
 Love has that effect on us. 
 But this theory, which is sometimes called &bquo;the moral influence&equo; theory, is considered to have a number of weaknesses that we should look at. 
 First, does it underestimate the power of sinfulness in us all? 
 Let me give some very basic illustrations. 
 Suppose I am a very heavy smoker and I am anxious to break the habit, and you say to me: &bquo;What a wonderful man is the Bishop of Bristol; he never smoked a cigarette in his life. 
 Make him your example. 
 Consider him.&equo; 
 Suppose you are on drugs and you know what they are doing to your body but you can't break the habit. 
 You are a slave, you are weak and it is no good for someone to say to you, &bquo;Just follow my example&equo;, because at moments like that the intrinsic goodness of another person becomes an impossible dream. 
 They are who they are, and I am who I am &mdash; the gulf appears unbridgeable. 
 The example  may be inspiring, but I need a new &bquo;me&equo; to get to where I want to go. 
 So Abelard's theory seems to present me with a challenge as formidable as climbing Mount Everest. 
 Some thinkers have gone further and have even said that Abelard's idea of sin is superficial and inadequate. 
 Perhaps it is. 
 Experience of life suggests that evil does ravage our capacity to listen to God and hear him; it does lead to deterioration of character and to further separation from God. 
 If people are unwilling to consider the suffering of Christ, how can it ever have power to change them? 
 The theory seems then rather intellectual and remote from everyday experience. 
 A second criticism is that the theory assumes that all emotional response is the same. 
 Dr Kenneth Kirk offered this criticism years ago, that some people are moved more easily than others by suffering and death. 
 There are emotional types and there are some who are matter-of-fact and fairly cold in their emotional response. 
 This idea does leave out in the cold some of us who are not moved that much by emotion. 
 Then there is another point that I have just touched upon: if sin degrades and hardens us, then this will affect our emotional response anyway and make it even harder for the cross to be effective in inspiring us to change our way of living. 
 Third, it has been argued that Abelard's theory is too subjective. 
 We have already seen that it rejects any notion that God is changed. 
 For this reason the theory has been called a subjective theory of atonement because it insists that the cross changes us, not God; that he is always forgiving. 
 Does not this make forgiveness cheap grace and God himself a rather indulgent parent who is never put out by anything we do? 
 If it is true that humankind is fallen, that we are separated from the presence of God by our failure and helplessness and are in need of God's forgiveness, Abelard's views do not reflect sufficiently well the seriousness of our predicament. 
 They make it all too easy and cheap. 
 Yet Abelard's theory cannot be rejected totally. 
 It has to start with other ideas, offering us a clue or two as to why God chose this particular route for his Son and for us. 
 Let me pick out three aspects that may help to guide us. 
 The way of love . 
 When we look at the cross it does tell us how much God loves us. 
 Love is only fully understood by what it does. 
 We only really know love when it is expressed in action;  when people demonstrate it. 
 Do you recall the story of Jesus at the house of Simon the Pharisee? 
 A woman came and poured ointment over his feet. 
 When Simon despised Jesus in his heart, Jesus replied: &bquo;Her sins, which are many, are forgiven, for she loved much; but he who is forgiven little, loves little&equo; (Luke 7.47). 
 Her love showed in what she gave. 
 In what way is the life and death of Jesus an example of God's love? 
 This is the Achilles' heel of Abelard's theory, because Christ's death is only explicable if it saves us from a serious and dreadful predicament which is of eternal significance. 
 Christ's example is not that of helping us across a road, or showing us what good neighbours we must be &mdash; but costly, redemptive, self-emptying love; love which lays down its life for others so that they might be restored to God. 
 The way of sacrifice . 
 Love and sacrifice, of course, belong together because love is never wholly platonic. 
 Love is a sacrifice that comes in the willingness to be emptied out in selfless giving. 
 The sacrifice comes in dying for that valued person or thing. 
 Yet, for love, it is never called or named sacrifice. 
 Any parent knows that. 
 We pour much time, money, anxiety and effort into our children simply for the pleasure of seeing them grow into the kind of people we long for them to be. 
 Yet it is sacrifice which is offered in delight. 
 We only start to talk about sacrifice with our children when something seriously wrong has happened in the relationship, when the mother or father says bitterly: &bquo;Don't you understand what I have given up for you? 
 My career, my ambition &bquo;my dreams &mdash; and all that does not mean a fig to you!&equo; 
 The way of understanding . 
 Human love can also be misunderstood. 
 We sometimes ask about a person: &bquo;Why has she chosen that course of action? 
 What on earth do they see in one another? 
 Why has he thrown up that promising career in politics to become a vicar?&equo; 
 The point about love is its unpredictability; it has the capacity to surprise and even scandalize. 
 So it was with Jesus: he scandalized people by the company he kept, by the overturning of values which had become the cement of his society but which he saw as being barriers for people. 
 He chose a way of loving which was so outrageous and costly that only a few friends could follow him into his dark night of the soul. 
  Let me now illustrate some of these things by introducing you to a twentieth-century saint who lived a life of love in a radical way. 
 Her name was Lisa Skobtsova, and she was born in Riga in 1891, and studied in Russia. 
 Her father's death when she was eighteen destroyed her faith. 
 How could she believe in God in such a world as this? 
 &bquo;There is no God, only sorrow, wickedness and injustice in the world.&equo; 
 She poured herself into self-sacrifice now for another cause &mdash; the people. 
 She married another student and together they joined the communist party. 
 Lisa was a close friend of Tolstoy and Berdyaev but rejected their Christian ideas. 
 She joined a plot to assassinate Trotsky and had to flee to France. 
 In exile she expected their first child, having left her husband in Russia; he was later killed, and she suffered the blow of another death &mdash; her own child. 
 Yet this death led her back to God and restored her faith. 
 She found Christian friends and found a Cause more wonderful to die for. 
 Her great ability was to get through to the outcasts of society &mdash; the drunks, the crazed, the depressed. 
 She would go into seamy dives, sitting there, listening, consoling. 
 Orthodox Christian eyebrows were raised. 
 How could she go around with such undesirables? 
 In 1932 she became a nun and was given the name Maria &bquo;in memory of St Maria of Egypt who lived a life of penitence in the desert&equo;. 
 Maria saw her mission to go out to act and speak in the desert of human hearts. 
 For her, the life of a conventional nun, a safe and comfortable existence separate from the misery and filth of the world was just not possible. 
 That was not the example of the Lord. 
 The war came, she was swept up with many others by the Germans and ended up in Ravensbr&uuml;ck concentration camp. 
 There she served others sacrificially. 
 She was given the chance to leave the camp on a number of occasions, but she waived the right so that others might go. 
 She died on Easter Eve, 1945. 
 The following day, Easter Day, the Red Cross entered the camp. 
 Maria followed Christ to the end; he was her inspiring Lord, he had changed her life and she knew he could change others. 
 Her job was to live the cross. 
 Let me give a brief application. 
 Abelard's theory, coming out of the experiences and theology of his day, presents a challenge to modern Christians who, all too easily, overintellectualize their faith. 
 Abelard encourages us to see the cross as a moving force for change. 
 Perhaps this is a challenge  to put it at the centre of our lives, to think about it and, this Lent, to read the story as if we were there. 
 Perhaps it is a challenge to our Church to be a more cross-oriented fellowship, living it, and working out what it means. 
 Jesus &mdash; Our Pioneer 
 If there is a hymn that encapsulates the example theory embraced by Peter Abelard it must be that well-known verse from C.F. Alexander's hymn, &bquo;There is a green hill far away&equo;: 
 O dearly, dearly has he loved, 
 And we must love him too, 
 And trust in his redeeming blood, 
 And try his works to do. 
 Of course, Alexander would not in the slightest deny the more traditional view. 
 You will remember she wrote: 
 There was no other good enough 
 To pay the price of sin; 
 He only could unlock the gate 
 Of heaven, and let us in. 
 In this second talk I want to mention a view which has a long history in the Church, far longer than my previous subject. 
 I call the subject &bquo;Jesus &mdash; our pioneer&equo; because that seems to sum up the thrust of the idea. 
 The word &bquo;pioneer&equo; only occurs three times in the New Testament and the most important occurrence is found in Hebrews 12.2. 
 The idea of a pioneer was a very important one for the early Christians. 
 They were aware that in a deep way Jesus had dealt a death blow to sin and death, but they believed there was more to it than that. 
 They saw him also as a trail-blazer, someone who goes ahead of others and prepares the way. 
 Neil Armstrong is a good example, as the first man to walk on the moon: &bquo;One small step for man, one giant leap for mankind.&equo; 
 We might think of a pioneer as someone who goes into the wilderness to prepare a home for others. 
 The first theologian I want to introduce you to now is a  second-century Christian called Irenaeus. 
 Irenaeus was bishop of a tiny Christian community in Lyons towards the end of the second century. 
 The Christians faced fierce persecution and opposition, especially from a more numerous religious group known as the Gnostics. 
 This group's theory of salvation attempted to incorporate Christ into their concept of God, but it was at a formidable price &mdash; he was just one of a number of divine beings in the pantheon. 
 Against this, Irenaeus asserted the primacy of Jesus for God's plan of salvation and, in opposition to a formidable heresy, developed the first Christian theology outside of the New Testament. 
 Irenaeus begins with Adam. 
 In his view Adam was not a fully developed being when he transgressed God's Law. 
 He was young and vulnerable and was thus easy prey for the wiles of the Evil One. 
 A key passage of Scripture for Irenaeus was Ephesians 1, where God's plan for humankind is mentioned. 
 Irenaeus saw a key word in this &mdash; anakepbalaiosis  &mdash; which in the English translation means &bquo;to unite all things&equo;. 
 However, the word can equally be translated &bquo;to recapitulate&equo;, meaning that Christ summed up all things in himself. 
 There is a line from a familiar hymn which captures this idea very well: &bquo;A second Adam to the fight and to the rescue came.&equo; 
 We can easily see what Irenaeus was exploring. 
 Adam and Eve were created by God for a glorious destiny with him. 
 They were not fully developed human beings; they had just begun. 
 The Evil One saw his chance and robbed them of their destiny. 
 The second Adam came, however, not only to save humankind, but to take us on to the destiny that should have been ours in the first place. 
 We can see then that Irenaeus's idea was very optimistic. 
 Christ recapitulated all of Adam's sin and restored us to God. 
 Indeed, God made of it something more wonderful than anybody could have thought. 
 There is a snatch of this in the Roman Mass for Easter Day which talks in terms of &bquo; O felix culpa &equo; &mdash; &bquo;O blessed sin which wrought man's redemption&equo;. 
 Without the sin of Adam we would have been deprived of the wonder of our salvation. 
 A second element in this theory is that Jesus entered into every aspect of human life and sanctifies it with his presence and love. 
 I must confess that I find this deeply attractive, and I want to draw attention to a few Bible passages where I think this idea is being worked out. 
 We see it, for example, in the  birth of Jesus. 
 Of course the infancy narratives stress the divinity of Christ, but they are also emphasizing the incarnation of Christ as he shares our nature in his human growth and development. 
 We see him depicted as a young boy in Luke 2, obedient to his parents, going up to the Temple and spending time with the learned men asking questions. 
 Hebrews 5.8&ndash;9 tells us that: &bquo;Although he was a Son, he learned obedience through what he suffered; and being made perfect he became the source of eternal salvation to all who obey him.&equo; 
 Why do I find that attractive? 
 I am suspicious of gods who dwell benignly in heavens, immutable and supreme. 
 Here is a Messiah who by becoming one of us knows all about human weakness, about human life and development. 
 He knows all about sadness, temptation and the grubby facts of life. 
 I can take comfort in this, knowing that my Lord has entered into our humanity and brought it home to God. 
 You see, this view takes incarnation seriously. 
 It is so easy for Western protestantism to fall into the trap of thinking that the last week of Jesus' life is all-important. 
 Well, it is important. 
 Without it there would be no Christianity! 
 But all that preceded it was very important too. 
 We must never separate incarnation and atonement. 
 The whole of Christ's life was atoning. 
 He entered deeply into our pain and grief. 
 &bquo;Surely he has borne our griefs and carried our sorrows&equo;, says Isaiah 53.4. 
 Let me go on now and tease out three aspects of this &bquo;pioneer&equo; idea. 
 Jesus our pioneer overcomes death . 
 Hebrews 2 contains a fascinating idea that Jesus had to be made human in order to overcome death for us; that is to say, he pioneered our way through the deep waters of death. 
 In Hebrews 2.9 we read: &bquo;But we see Jesus, who for a little while was made lower than the angels, crowned with glory and honour because of the suffering of death, so that by the grace of God he might taste death for every one.&equo; 
 Jesus became a trail-blazer through the darkness of death and overcame it. 
 This is a familiar idea in the New Testament. 
 The New Testament writers were in no doubt that Jesus, through his resurrection, dealt a mortal blow to death and freed us from its influence and power. 
 Most of us will remember John Donn's wonderful lines:  
 Death, be not proud, though some have call&egrave;d thee 
 Mighty and dreadful, for thou art not so, 
 For those whom thou think &bquo;st thou dost overthrow 
 Die not, poor Death; nor yet canst thou kill me&hellip; 
 Why swell'st thou then? 
 One short sleep past, we wake eternally, 
 And Death shall be no more: Death, thou shalt die! 
 It is a wonderful comfort to know that Jesus has entered into our dying and will deliver us from it. 
 Fear of dying still grips our hearts. 
 Perhaps some of us here tonight are still gripped by fear of death. 
 One person said to me a year or two ago: &bquo;I'm scared of dying. 
 Yes, I believe in Jesus, but sometimes I wake up in the night just petrified.&equo; 
 Let us face up to the reality of these fears and face them in the power of the cross. 
 Jesus our pioneer overcomes apparent failure . 
 Let's go back to the Greek idea of Jesus entering into our sinfulness and weakness. 
 If you ever get the chance of going to the catacombs in Rome you will see on the walls a very popular image of the cross shaped as an anchor. 
 Sometimes the anchor will be fashioned as a fish-hook. 
 The fish-hook image had an interesting story behind it. 
 Some of the later Greek thinkers developed Irenaeus's idea of Jesus defeating the power of evil, and they created a very vivid image of the defeat of Satan. 
 The picture was that of Christ impaled on a cross shaped like a fish-hook. 
 Satan, visualized as a great fish seeing his enemy in such distress, swoops to devour but gets more than he bargains for. 
 He is hooked. 
 We can quickly dispense with the crude mythology, but I like the concept of apparent failure. 
 It is clear that in the eyes of Jesus' contemporaries the cross was a contemptuous symbol. 
 Indeed, the cross was such an enormous stumbling block that we have in it a rather surprising proof of the genuineness of primitive Christianity. 
 If you were going to invent a brand new religion you would not start with a cross. 
 The cross denoted that the mission of Jesus had failed. 
 It was over. 
 The resurrection is God's vindication of the apparent failure. 
 I want to suggest to you that God has a far more positive attitude to failure than most of us. 
 We don't like failing; it hurts our pride; it brings us down to the dust. 
 God, however,  sees the opportunity to recreate something new out of the failure we see. 
 Some years ago I saw on TV a most splendid series by a marvellous writer called Brian Clark. 
 Called &bquo;The Late Starter&equo;, it is the story of a retired professor, Edward Brett. 
 Unknown to him, his wife is a gambler, who over the years has been secretly gambling away his money and assets. 
 The discovery is made on the day he retires. 
 He returns home to find she has left and he is bankrupt. 
 The series narrates his attempts to find employment. 
 Though he wants and needs work, no one wants a man of his age; furthermore, he realizes that his academic talents are not needed either. 
 His growing disillusionment is revealed &bquo;his gathering despair and feelings of hopelessness. 
 One episode ends with the proud man broken, humiliated and in tears. 
 Yet, from that terrible experience, hope is born &mdash; the late starter rises to new life. 
 The programme summed up for me all the human frustrations, hopelessness and despair. 
 I imagine most of us have entered that deep valley, and maybe some of us are in it now. 
 The cross declares: &bquo;I've been there. 
 I know.&equo; 
 &bquo;My God &bquo;my God, why hast thou forsaken me?&equo; 
 That cry was a real cry of despair from the cross &mdash; not make-believe. 
 What about us? 
 I have a hunch that true life starts at the point of recognizing our failure. 
 That is the point when new life begins. 
 &bquo;Unless a grain of wheat falls into the earth and dies&hellip; 
 &equo; (John 12.24) The importance of death is that for God it is the commencement of resurrection. 
 The cross takes us into death and failure, but the Greeks had another beautiful idea which is called &bquo;deification&equo;. 
 Irenaeus puts it so splendidly: &bquo;He became human that we might become divine.&equo; 
 He entered into our world to redeem it and restore it. 
 Jesus our pioneer restores all things and will bring them to a glorious fulfilment . 
 The third aspect shows a connection between this life and the one to come. 
 True Christianity never treats this world with contempt. 
 Beware of any form of faith which says: &bquo;Well, you know this life is unimportant; the real one is the one with God.&equo; 
 No! 
 This life is sacred and is a gift. 
 Of course, the life with God will be glorious, but it will be a fulfilment of all the hopes and dreams here. 
 That is why Irenaeus hit the Gnostics so hard, because they rejected this  life as unimportant. 
 You and I will want to affirm this world and its beauty and its sadness and all the colours of life &mdash; the greens and golds, the greys and the blacks &mdash; as part of the tapestry which is God's gift to us all. 
 What about today? 
 How can we weave this theory into our theology and practice? 
 Let me take you to one twentieth-century Christian who seems to me to express this so vividly. 
 The man I have in mind is Oscar Romero, who was assassinated the year Robert Runcie was enthroned as Archbishop &mdash; 1980. 
 Romero was the unlikeliest of heroes and this is an encouragement to us. 
 As a priest and bishop he was not marked by revolutionary fervour &mdash; on the contrary, he was deeply conservative and disapproved of &bquo;political&equo; priests. 
 Hold that description of him in your mind for a moment. 
 Now turn to the country. 
 El Salvador is a poor country of just five million people; a place where the gulf between rich and poor could not be greater. 
 Because the clergy were on the whole ministering to the poor, many of them could not avoid being caught up in the unrest, violence and fear. 
 Some identified with a form of theology called &bquo;liberation theology &bquo;. 
 Romero disapproved of this theology; he did not believe that the way of Christ called anybody to overthrow governments. 
 As he saw it, the job of the Church was to get on with the task of proclaiming the gospel and ministering the sacraments. 
 When he was appointed Archbishop, the Government sighed with relief. 
 Here was an Archbishop after their own hearts. 
 Yet soon after his enthronement, Romero's close friend Fr Grande and two parishioners were callously shot in cold blood by security forces. 
 Fr Grande's crime? 
 He had preached a sermon in which he had said these words: &bquo;It is dangerous to be a Christian in our nation. 
 In fact it is practically illegal to be an authentic Christian, because the world which surrounds us is founded radically on an established disorder before which the mere proclamation of the gospel is subversive.&equo; 
 The death of his friend became Romero's conversion. 
 He was outraged and demanded an explanation. 
 He closed all Catholic schools and colleges for three days and cancelled all services for the following Sunday, except for a single Mass in the Cathedral Church, to which 100,000 people came. 
 Events  swiftly followed. 
 Romero was caught up in denouncing policies which engulfed the poor in further misery and exploitation. 
 He saw that it was necessary to take sides. 
 There was escalating violence against the Church. 
 Romero became a symbol of hope to people. 
 When asked: &bquo;Why have you decided to take such a stand?&equo; he replied simply: &bquo;I felt it necessary to put feet on the gospel.&equo; 
 The climax came when, on 24 March 1980, as he celebrated Mass, a shot rang out. 
 His blood mingled with the red wine of the Mass. 
 But it was a death in line with the pioneering Lord he followed; a fitting martyr's death for a very courageous man who found that God could be trusted with his weakness and fear. 
 Jesus &mdash; Who identifies wit Us 
 We are now faced with the question: From what did Jesus save us? 
 Let me now go to a number of scriptural passages to see how the New Testament sees the death of Jesus. 
 Common to all these verses is the idea that Jesus' death in some way removed our sin. 
 He became sin for us. 
 This idea developed in the Church and became linked with a theology which is known as &bquo;penal substitution&equo;, the idea that Christ paid the penalty for you and me. 
 In the divine tribunal he became a sin offering. 
 In the post-Reformation world the doctrine of penal substitution gathered around it a very hard edge, especially north of the border in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. 
 Let us now go in our imaginations to Dunbartonshire and visit the town of Rhu in 1829 where the young minister of just twenty-nine was preaching. 
 He had been at this cure for a mere four years but his reputation was growing fast. 
 He was known for his brilliance, for his razor-sharp mind and for being a wonderful preacher. 
 His elders were becoming more than a little worried because people were saying his teaching was heretical. 
 For a start he was preaching that assurance was essential for salvation; that is, you could know within you that you were well and truly saved. 
 He was not saying merely that you believed it, but that you could know it as certainty! 
 Furthermore he was preaching against Calvinism. 
 He rejected John  Calvin's idea that Jesus paid a penalty to God. 
 So on this summer's evening, to an expectant and full congregation, we hear him saying something like this: 
 Now I hear some of you saying this: &bquo;Jesus saved me from my sins by taking my burdens himself; he came to this earth to save me and to redeem me.&equo; 
 Oh, yes, we can all agree with that. 
 But how did he redeem you? 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; you reply, &bquo;he took the penalty for me.&equo; 
 But what do you mean &mdash; he took the penalty for you? 
 &bquo;I mean that I should have died that afternoon, but the matchless Son of God took my place, God visited all his wrath, judgement and curses upon Jesus and therefore I can go scot-free.&equo; 
 But I want to put another point of view. 
 How can it be that Jesus could become sin for you and me? 
 How is it possible for someone to take my or anybody's sin upon himself? 
 You simply cannot switch moral  qualities. 
 Of course he came to rescue us, of course he came to die for us, but he was not a sin offering to God because he was sinless. 
 So you ask me: &bquo;How are we redeemed therefore?&equo; 
 I will tell you: He identified with our distress, our despair and our lostness. 
 He became so identified with us that he was the perfect penitent  and made the perfect confession  to the Father for us. 
 The sermon that evening was the last straw. 
 The minister, Dr McLeod Campbell, was accused of heresy and two years later deposed from his office. 
 His theology, nonetheless, was to have a major influence upon atonement thinking, and helped to shape modern thought. 
 Now, before we look at Campbell's teaching more closely, let me mention another thinker who probably had some influence on him. 
 Socinus was a radical Reformation thinker who saw Rome as the great harlot of Revelation 17. 
 He was a forerunner of Unitarianism. 
 He viewed Jesus as one who revealed God, but who was only a human being and no more than that. 
 For our purposes we must note one thing: he rejected any connection between our sinfulness and Jesus' death. 
 Moral qualities, he argued, cannot be transferred. 
 God can no more transfer his  sinlessness to us than we can transfer our rights or wrongs to one another. 
 So how did Socinus see God's forgiveness operating? 
 Simply in terms of God's free gift. 
 Salvation is not won by Christ but given by God. 
 In Socinus's theology, therefore, there was no room for Christ except as a voice proclaiming salvation. 
 In technical terms we say that Socinus rejected the &bquo;forensic&equo; idea of salvation. 
 So did Campbell, although he came close to it with his emphasis upon Christ as the perfect penitent who makes the perfect confession. 
 What does this mean for us? 
 Campbell is arguing that Christ shows God's love by identifying with us in our guilt and sinfulness and by standing before God as a perfect penitent. 
 Campbell is not saying that Christ takes our sin upon himself but he identifies so closely with us that it is as if  he makes our confession and is thus separated from the presence of God for us. 
 Let us look at this more closely. 
 Is Dr Campbell saying that Christ did not really take our sin upon himself but acted as if he did? 
 That is the crux of the problem. 
 How can Christ be a perfect penitent if he is really  sinless? putting it in ordinary terms: if you are completely innocent of a crime, no one is going to make much sense of it if you say: &bquo;I am not guilty of this offence, but I confess on behalf of others and wish to represent their guilt.&equo; 
 Now, I happen to think that Campbell's idea is flawed because he wants to have his cake and eat it. 
 He wishes to reject the idea that Christ took upon himself our guilt but he wishes to say that Christ identified with our sin and weaknesses. 
 There is, nonetheless, a positive side to his teaching. 
 Let us think about the word &bquo;identification&equo;. 
 The more you belong, the closer you identify, Think of children. 
 When we moved from Durham to Bristol our youngest daughter was ten. 
 By then she had acquired a distinctive Geordie accent and she was upset when her friends at school teased her about her rounded vowels and up and down, sing-song voice. 
 She felt excluded. 
 How did she react? 
 By acquiring a Bristol accent! 
 Think of teenagers. 
 It has been said of them that &bquo;in order to be different they dress exactly alike&equo;! 
 In fact, you cannot find more conformity than among young people. 
 They are anxious to belong, and it shows in their tastes, dress and habits. 
 But it is true of us all &mdash; it is hard to break from the herd, it is hard to  be a rebel, it is hard to be a heretic. 
 Identification is part of our survival kit; it is the way we are. 
 To belong is to identify. 
 Think of missionaries who attempt to reach another group of people. 
 In order to have any remote chance of effective work they must learn the language, understand the culture and customs and identify in all kinds of ways with the people they wish to influence. 
 At the 1988 Lambeth Conference the Bishop of Hyderabad told an apt and amusing story about this. 
 When the troops pulled out of North Pakistan at the end of the last century, the Church Missionary Society sent a missionary doctor to the region to speak to the people of God's love. 
 The fierce Pathans saw this missionary in his little wooden home about a mile away and they said: &bquo;The British sent troops to kill us and they failed. 
 They now send a doctor to poison us.&equo; 
 So they did not go anywhere near the doctor. 
 Months passed and the doctor despaired of ever reaching them. 
 Although he dressed as they did and walked among them, sullen glances were all he got. 
 He even learnt their language. 
 Still no breakthrough came. 
 One day, the missionary was awakened by the sound of scratching at the door, and the noise of whining. 
 He opened it and there was a village dog with a broken limb. 
 The doctor treated his first patient. 
 Washed and bandaged, the dog limped into the village. 
 &bquo;Who did that?&equo; 
 It could only be the doctor &mdash; and the breakthrough came. 
 Then, said the Bishop to the assembled Conference, &bquo;Who was the missionary &mdash; the dog or the doctor?&equo; 
 In fact they both were. 
 The doctor with his presence and the dog as the witness to what the doctor had done. 
 Turning to Campbell's contribution, two ways are mentioned by which Christ identified with us. 
 First, Christ identified with our loneliness . 
 Campbell had no doubt that sin was essentially a form of loneliness; being cut off from God and his presence. 
 The consequence of sin is that it cuts us off from others. 
 It issues in forms of alienation or separation. 
 Christ, said Campbell, accepted a cutting off from his Father in order to unite us to God. 
 Let us think about this idea for a moment. 
 We live in a society riddled with loneliness: loneliness in offices, in our comfortable homes, on our estates and in our flats. 
 It is a loneliness caused by having no one to talk with. 
  Perhaps one or two of you have had keen personal experience of the frightening and destructive power of loneliness. 
 Now, by loneliness I am not talking about the absence of friends and occasional breaks from people. 
 In my busy life there are times when I dream of long periods away from people. 
 Oh, to be quiet; oh, to be on a desert island with no one to talk to! 
 But the reality is far, far different, and few of us can take that much reality. 
 I am not talking about that kind of quietness; rather the loneliness of people who feel quite cut off from God, from others, from society. 
 They feel estranged; they feel as if they don't belong; they cannot identify. 
 Two years ago on BBC television there was a moving programme called &bquo;The Boy David Trilogy&equo;. 
 It was the story of a Peruvian boy from the jungle with almost no face. 
 The programme described David's condition and the sixty operations he had in order to have anything like a face &mdash; and there were still plenty to come. 
 But the love that surrounds that boy is having a marvellous effect in giving him a life. 
 His face is still deformed, but it is a face. 
 When Desmond Wilcox teased him and said: &bquo;You're a pickle!&equo; he replied: &bquo;I'm not a pickle, I'm a person.&equo; 
 I was reminded of C.S. Lewis's great book Till We Have Faces , which makes the point that each human being is on the way to his or her full development in Christ. 
 Loneliness is being cut off from God, ourselves, our destiny, our hopes and dreams. 
 Christ identifies with us, and in the garden of Gethsemane he cries out of loneliness fur us. 
 Campbell also speaks of a form of loneliness which was a special feature of Jesus' ministry: the loneliness of the leader . 
 All of us in leadership know something of that. 
 &bquo;The buck stops here.&equo; 
 The leader may delegate a great deal of work but cannot delegate the responsibility for that work. 
 The leader carries that alone and carries too the anxieties, ambitions and the fear of failure that leadership brings. 
 Perhaps some of you are experiencing the pressures of leadership. 
 There are times, of course, when all goes well and we actually enjoy it, but at other times the cost seems too heavy and we have few people we can share the job with or who can understand. 
 So the anxiety mounts and the stress develops. 
 We wake in the night with a churning mind and it seems that nothing will settle the anxiety. 
 Campbell links our problems of leadership with that of Jesus' loneliness, and  comments: &bquo;See, he has been there too and because he identifies with it, he can handle it. 
 Don't pretend.&equo; 
 The second very useful contribution from Campbell is that he saw how Christ identified with our suffering . 
 I have used the word &bquo;mystery&equo; of the cross, but let us never forget that suffering is a mystery too. 
 We must never have a simplistic view of suffering. 
 We have all had experiences of life in which the suffering of others has led us to ask questions of God and about God. 
 &bquo;Why are you doing this to me? 
 Where are you in the midst of pain?&equo; 
 Suffering and the cross nonetheless come together in Jesus' prayer of suffering love: &bquo;Why hast thou forsaken me?&equo; 
 (Matthew 27.46) 
 Indeed, the Christian faith takes very seriously the presence of suffering and says that the life and death of Jesus encourage us to endure. 
 Hebrews 12.3: &bquo;Consider him who endured from sinners such hostility against himself, so that you may not grow weary or fainthearted.&equo; 
 The story of Joni Eareckson is well known. 
 In 1967, as a result of a diving accident, Joni was made a quadriplegic. 
 Bitterness, anger and rebellion became her reaction. 
 One night, Cindy, her friend, spoke to her of the cross of Jesus and said: &bquo;He was paralysed too.&equo; 
 It had never occurred to Joni that on the cross Jesus was unable to move, virtually paralysed. 
 She found that deeply comforting and was mentally able to see that he was carrying her pain and helplessness. 
 Christianity also takes seriously the fact of redemptive  suffering. 
 Now we have to be careful with the word &bquo;redemptive&equo; because in a final way only Christ's sufferings can be deemed truly redemptive; but I feel that we can make guarded use of the term. 
 Jesus' sufferings draw us into the love of God and show us how much he loved us. 
 Campbell points out that Jesus' sufferings, far from being heroic, are far more wonderful than that; all our wounds and pains are taken up in his and are redeemed. 
 Some of you may have read Mary Craig's book Blessings . 
 In it she recounts trying to come to terms with the fact that two of her four sons had been born with severe abnormalities. 
 In the last chapter she meditates on the meaning of suffering. 
 She writes:  
 In the teeth of the evidence I do not believe that any suffering is ultimately absurd or pointless&hellip; the value of suffering does not lie in the pain of it but in what the sufferer makes of it. 
 It is in suffering that we discover the things that matter; in sorrow we discover ourselves. 
 So identification is a rich word. 
 Let me try to illustrate this from the career of one notable Christian. 
 His name was Father Damien of Belgium. 
 In 1864 he unexpectedly took his brother's place as a missionary priest and was sent to Hawaii. 
 His Superintendent asked for a priest to go to the island of Molokai where a colony of lepers lived in appalling conditions. 
 Joseph Damien, without hesitation, volunteered, and for the rest of his life lived among the lepers. 
 The colony increased to over a thousand people. 
 Joseph laboured as builder, nurse, superintendent as well as priest. 
 But the moment of deepest ministry came when ugly spots appeared on his hands and face. 
 One day at Mass Father Damien addressed the community and said simply: &bquo;We lepers.&equo; 
 Damien, no doubt, would not have considered this particularly heroic &mdash; all he was doing was following his Master in identifying totally with those he had come to save. 
 Jesus &mdash; Our Reconciler 
 In this talk I want us to consider an image which I believe takes us a little closer to the meaning of the cross &mdash; the image of reconciliation and representation. 
 Let us glance at a familiar passage of Scripture: 2 Corinthians 5.16&ndash;21. 
 You will note that the verb &bquo;reconcile&equo; occurs five times &mdash; that in some mysterious way God reconciled the world to himself and that Christ was the means and the focus of reconciliation. 
 In what way was he for us the focus? 
 Some years ago now, a famous Methodist scholar, Vincent Taylor, wrote a trilogy on the atonement. 
 In it he expressed the view that Jesus was our representative  who reconciled us to God. 
 Vincent Taylor was particularly concerned to avoid crude ideas that Jesus was a sin offering, one who somehow bore the penalty of our wrongdoing and placated an angry deity. 
 He correctly drew attention to the fact that the action  was God's &mdash; God was in Christ; that is to say, he was doing it. 
 Let us first look at the word &bquo;representative&equo;. 
 It is a familiar and attractive idea. 
 Recently there has been a long ambulance drivers' strike. 
 Leaving aside the rights and wrongs of that dispute, we all know the importance of representatives. 
 Five thousand ambulance drivers cannot do their own negotiating &mdash; they need representatives to do it for them. 
 Indeed, in this country we have a conciliation service, known by its initials as ACAS, which is a forum whereby representatives can get together and make demands, counter demands and eventually &mdash; and hopefully &mdash; reach solutions. 
 Let me point out some of the weaknesses in the idea that Jesus is our representative. 
 First, we did not choose him. 
 We normally elect our representatives and say: &bquo;He belongs to us. 
 He can speak up for us.&equo; 
 In the case of Jesus it might be thought that he represents the management, not the workers. 
 Second, can he really represent me and you unless, in some real way, he participates in our sin and weakness? 
 So we need to ask: Does Vincent Taylor's idea go far enough? 
 I am not rejecting the idea of Jesus being my representative &mdash; all I am doing at the moment is to point out some difficulties with it when it is considered as the central idea in the atonement theory. 
 Now let us consider the concept of reconciliation and note the elements that stand out. 
 Reconciliation needs someone to take the initiative . 
 The atonement may seem an irrelevant idea these days, but here is an image which is always topical, because the need for reconciliation is a lifelong occupation. 
 One thing I can be certain of is that we have all been involved in rows, misunderstandings and quarrels. 
 Perhaps something like that happened today and you wonder how reconciliation can take place. 
 Often the problems are only storms in teacups, and all that is needed is a gentle &bquo;sorry&equo;, a laugh, a hug, a cup of tea, and all is well. 
 Sometimes, however, bitter feuds may last for years. 
 In the course of my pastoral visiting, before I took a funeral service, I called on the dead man's son, who told me that he fell out with his father at his wedding twenty years previously and that he was not going to the funeral service now! 
 We feel the shock and sadness of unreconciled behaviour that can follow people like that to the grave. 
 It is a fact that  the more serious the crime, and the more awful the act, the more costly the nature of reconciliation. 
 Let me offer another illustration. 
 At the end of the last war, the Allied Forces did not say to Germany: &bquo;War is over, let's forget it all. 
 We all made mistakes. 
 Build your country and let's live in peace again.&equo; 
 No, you cannot do things like that. 
 Awful crimes had been committed by a civilized nation because Nazism had put to death over nine million people. 
 Evil men had ruled with terror and evil. 
 The Nuremburg trials were the trial of evil and resulted in judgement. 
 It had to happen before there could be true reconciliation of nations and before countries could begin to live and forget. 
 Now, what the New Testament says is striking. 
 God is never spoken of as if he needs to be reconciled to us. 
 God does the reconciling. 
 He says: &bquo;The door is always open. 
 I love you so much that Christ is the means of reconciliation.&equo; 
 This is where we must challenge the idea that forgiveness is a costless thing; that all God needed to do was forgive. 
 He will forgive, people say cheerfully. 
 That is his business. 
 Some theologians have suggested that the essence of the gospel is nothing more than forgiveness as it is enshrined in the story of the prodigal Son. 
 The father sees the son coming home after all the bingeing &mdash; the wine, women and song &mdash; and runs out with love and says: &bquo;How good it is to have you home! 
 Kill the fatted calf!&equo; 
 That is the gospel, they say. 
 It is, however, only one half of the gospel. 
 Forgiveness is a killing business; it has a habit of crucifying people. 
 We must not minimize the cost of reconciliation; forgiveness is never cheap. 
 But let us ask again: Is it the case that moral qualities cannot be transferred? 
 If a son or daughter commits a crime and is sentenced to imprisonment, the court will not allow an anxious father or mother to take their place, so how can it be that my sin can be taken by another? 
 How is it possible for Christ's death to affect me? 
 Let me give you a partial answer for the moment. 
 First, we cannot allow human factors to limit God's goodness. 
 God's wonderful grace and power can be made available for us. 
 Therefore his goodness and grace are  transferable. 
 Second, it is a deficient view of sin which speaks lightly of it. 
 We are of a generation which is in dreadful danger of being anaesthetized morally. 
 People who are blind cannot judge the colour of light, people who are totally deaf cannot assess the  wonder of a Mendelssohn sonata, and people whose whole experience of life has been lived in the darkness of materialism cannot fully appreciate the holiness and perfection of God who dwells in light unapproachable. 
 We have lost our sense of holiness and we shift in the shadows; little wonder we fail to understand the significance of atonement! 
 So the cross proceeds from a forgiving God who wants people to be reconciled to him. 
 He does the reconciling, he sees the sin, the hurts, the enormous chasm of unreconciled conflict, and he takes it all to a lonely cross. 
 Doesn't that say something amazing about God's love? 
 He who is the blameless party takes the initiative in running towards us to forgive. 
 Reconciliation involves repentance . 
 We have to say &bquo;sorry&equo;. 
 Imagine a married couple who are estranged from one another, yet who both wistfully long for reconciliation. 
 Let us imagine that they meet and the man begins: &bquo;Darling, it's awful to be apart from you. 
 I miss you so much. 
 Can we make a fresh start?&equo; 
 She agrees &mdash; she too wants the past to be healed. 
 But the husband continues: &bquo;&hellip; but let us get one thing clear &mdash; I haven't done anything wrong!&equo; 
 No human relationship can recommence with such an attitude; there has to be the admission of failure. 
 So it is with the cross. 
 In a sense we now live in a forgiven world. 
 When Christ died, &bquo;atonement&equo; was made between God and man. 
 At-one. 
 That is still the reality of the Christian message, but that forgiveness only becomes a reality, efficacious, when I make it mine. 
 The implications of this are awesome, because the Christian life is a continuation of atonement. 
 That is why the Lord's Prayer demands that the Christian community becomes a forgiving, reconciling community. 
 &bquo;Forgive us our sins, for we ourselves forgive&hellip; 
 &equo; (Luke 11.4) Think of the implications of that! 
 If we are reconciled to God, it affects others. 
 It means that we accept others. 
 Surely we need to work this out in our daily living. 
 Next time you catch yourself thinking uncharitably of another, criticizing another, say to yourself: &bquo;Reconciliation &mdash; what does that have to say to my relationship with that person?&equo; 
 I would like to apply that to other relationships. 
 Think of the fact that there are over three hundred member churches in  the World Council of Churches! 
 Think of all the division in the Christian family which mocks the idea of us as a reconciled body. 
 How dare we say with St Paul, &bquo;be reconciled to God&equo; (2 Corinthians 5.20), when we are so unreconciled? 
 Isn't that a terrible contradiction of the message of the cross? 
 We Anglicans have made our fair contribution of hurts to the unreconciled body of Christ. 
 You see, the cross preaches a radical message to us all &mdash; it proclaims that the ground is level at the foot of the cross. 
 What about our Church with all the opportunities and challenges before us? 
 Our Archbishop has just announced his retirement, and whoever is chosen to succeed him will lead us into the Decade of Evangelism. 
 Among other things, he will also have to handle with great sensitivity the issue of women's ministry. 
 Have we the capacity to remain together even though there may be real theological differences among us? 
 I hope that the reconciliation achieved by the cross will provide the basis for us all to say that we have no grounds for making fresh divisions which make a witness to a needy world more difficult than it is already. 
 Reconciliation implies a contract . 
 When two parties meet at ACAS and an agreement is reached it is normally expressed in terms of some contractual agreement which satisfies both sides. 
 In the Bible such an agreement is called a &bquo;covenant&equo;. 
 We notice this about the covenants of the Bible; they are usually established with the signs of sacrifice and blood. 
 Abraham's willingness to offer his only son Isaac has the innocent Isaac saying in Genesis 22.7. 
 But where is the lamb? 
 Abraham replies, &bquo;God will provide himself the lamb for a burnt offering, my son&equo; (Genesis 22.8). 
 The Egyptian deliverance has the sprinkling of blood on the lintels of the doors so that the avenging angel can see the blood and &bquo;pass over&equo; it (Exodus 12.13). 
 At Sinai blood is sprinkled on the altar and the people. 
 Barbaric, we might exclaim, how awful! 
 Maybe, but the point the Bible is making is that &bquo;without the shedding of blood there is no forgiveness of sins&equo; (Hebrews 9.22). 
 God's way of reconciliation is harshest for himself in his Son. 
 The new covenant is commemorated every time we celebrate the Eucharist; and we have a vivid image of the covenant every time we hold out empty hands to receive the sacrament, because we have nothing to offer. 
 Indeed, there is no point in offering anything because we are &bquo;ransomed, healed, restored, forgiven&equo;.  
 Vincent Taylor draws attention to two striking contrasts in God's method of reconciling. 
 First, he considers the contrast between power and weakness. 
 In the covenant established between God and humankind, God is all-powerful and we are weak. 
 The powerful have a way of establishing contracts that suit them. 
 We have often heard our prime Minister say: &bquo;We must negotiate from a position of strength.&equo; 
 That has plausibility in the world of political bargaining. 
 God could so easily say that, too, but he does not; he negotiates from a basis of weakness which becomes for us the power of God unto salvation. 
 In the cross God allows his weakness to be our strength. 
 I have already drawn attention to the power there is in weakness and it is often the case that God is able to take ordinary weak things of this world and make them powerful for him. 
 The other striking contrast is between holiness and sinfulness. 
 Jesus, our holy representative, takes our sin upon himself and identifies with it. 
 You can now see why Christianity is so radical and so down to earth. 
 You can also see why we cannot play at being Christians &mdash; because God became human for us and took our humanity up to the throne of God. 
 This does not suggest, I must warn you, that we must dwell on our sinfulness and the holiness of God. 
 While we must take sin lightly we must not live as if we are unforgiven and unreconciled. 
 It is also a fact that very few people actually come into the Christian faith with a deep burden of sin. 
 It is as we travel into the faith of Christ that we grow in our appreciation of his love and of our own deep unworthiness. 
 Anything we do must be prefaced with: &bquo;We are unprofitable servants.&equo; 
 Reconciliation cost Christ everything and sometimes it will cost us no less. 
 Let me in conclusion just remark on one of this century's Christian heroes: Dietrich Bonhoeffer. 
 One of the great theologians of this century, Dietrich was a loyal German who had a deep affection for his country. 
 In his travels before the war he came into contact with a French student, Jean Lass&egrave;re, a pacifist, who encouraged Bonhoeffer to take the Sermon on the Mount seriously, and to live it out fully. 
 Bonhoeffer returned to Germany, but found himself in conflict with the mood of the times when identified with Hitler's arrogance and brutality. 
 He identified with the Barmen Declaration that: &bquo;Jesus Christ is the one Word of God  which we are required to hear&hellip; we repudiate the false teachings that the Church must recognize other teachings and other personalities alongside this one Word of God.&equo; 
 This was fighting talk. 
 The confessing Church became the persecuted Church. 
 Bonhoeffer, increasingly uneasy with all he was observing, eventually talked with his brother-in-law, who was on the staff of Military Intelligence. 
 His horror was profound when he discovered the extent and depth of the evil perpetrated by Hitler. 
 With great reluctance, Bonhoeffer came to the conclusion that Hitler had to be removed from office and he became party to a plot to assassinate the country's F&uuml;hrer. 
 But the plot was discovered, and Bonhoeffer was imprisoned and hanged on Low Sunday, 1945. 
 In a letter to Bishop George Bell he wrote: &bquo;This is the end, but for me, the beginning of life.&equo; 
 Jesus &mdash; Our Substitute 
 The idea of substitution must be the very oldest of theories that attempts to deal with the question of why Jesus died. 
 It still has its power to fascinate and impress. 
 This theory takes us first to the theme of sacrifice. 
 It is a theme that still means a great deal to modern people even though we have lost the background of a sacrificial system. 
 Consider any gift; I would wager that the gift that means most would not necessarily be the most expensive present but the one bought with sacrifice, expressing care and love. 
 The point about sacrifice is that it represents slog, sweat and tears. 
 So the Old Testament people were commanded to give a proportion of their talents and money to God as love offerings, thank offerings, sin offerings. 
 The gift could vary from pigeons, to cereal offerings, to first fruits of the harvest, to very expensive sacrifices like a goat, a lamb or a bull. 
 Not all sacrifices were sin offerings. 
 For example, the lamb in the passover celebration was not a sin offering; it was a communion offering. 
 It represented God's deliverance and was closer to our Eucharist than to a sacrifice. 
 If we are really looking for an archetypal sin offering, we must turn in our Bibles to Leviticus 16, where Aaron presents two male goats before the Tent of the presence. 
 One is said to be for the Lord  and the other for Azazel. 
 Upon the head of the latter goat the sins of the people are placed. 
 Who was this Azazel? 
 Who knows? perhaps a figure for evil or the place of sinfulness and evil. 
 As my deliberate intention in these lectures is to remind you of theology and introduce you to theological terms, however, let me do so now. 
 Here is the first theological word: vicarious . 
 Vicarious means a &bquo;standin&equo;, someone who replaces you. 
 So, in the old days, a vicar was a clergyman who did not receive the tithes and proper dues of a parish. 
 He would merely do the job and get a pittance. 
 Someone else would get the perks of office; whereas a rector received the full tithes. 
 These days we have dealt very satisfactorily with the problem; we have made the rector as poor as the vicar! 
 But you understand now what the term &bquo;vicarious sacrifice&equo; means &mdash; it means that someone else, or, in the Old Testament, something  else &mdash; a goat, a bull &mdash; took your sin for you. 
 The idea of &bquo;scapegoat&equo; comes from this passage (Leviticus 16.20 following). 
 The idea of sacrifice was part and parcel of the ancient world, and familiar to both Greek and Jew. 
 This is clear from a number of New Testament passages: Mark 10.45; John 3.14,16; 15.13; Romans 3.23&ndash;25; 5.8&ndash;9; 8.32; 2 Corinthians 5.21; Galatians 3.13; Ephesians 2.15&ndash;16; Hebrews 9.26&ndash;28. 
 In these verses, and I could have easily quadrupled them, we are presented with the idea of Christ dying for us. 
 Sometimes the word is for us  and at other times instead of us ; but whatever the word, the New Testament writers were in no doubt that Jesus was Saviour of the world, and that his death was the crucial victory of God. 
 There are quite a few hymns which take up this notion of Jesus bearing my sin as a substitute. 
 There is, for example: 
 There was no other good enough 
 To pay the price of sin; 
 He only could unlock the gate 
 Of heaven, and let us in. 
 Or a verse from one of St Bernard of Clairvaux' hymns:  
 Jesus, who gave himself for you 
 Upon the cross to die, 
 Opens to you his sacred heart. 
 O to that heart draw nigh. 
 Look at the words of the hymns, glance at the dates and link them in with the theories we have discussed, and I can promise you that it will all make a little more sense and make it even more evident how our hymn-writers wrestled with the meaning of the cross. 
 The next question is: If Jesus died for me and paid the &bquo;price of sin&equo;, to whom was the penalty paid? 
 I challenge anyone to show me anywhere in the New Testament a verse that says Christ pays a penalty. 
 His death is a sin offering, he gives his life for us, he dies for us, but, as far as I can tell, the New Testament never answers this question: To whom is the sin offering given? 
 I wonder why this is? 
 It is later Christians who will answer the question absolutely and thoroughly. 
 Some of the Fathers of the Church believed that Jesus paid the penalty to the Father. 
 He placated God. 
 Others of the Fathers were in no doubt that Jesus paid the penalty to the devil. 
 Yet stay with the problem: how could Jesus pay the price to the Father when the Father was involved so directly in the work of the Son? 
 Don't you see now why the substitutionary atonement must not be forced, because it separates the Father from the work of the Son? 
 Taken to an extreme, it makes the Father sadistic and the Son a Saviour who dies to placate an unforgiving Father. 
 That is surely wrong, and we must never adopt any theory which severs the Father's will from the work of the Son. 
 In any case, the words of Scripture contradict such ideas. 
 &bquo;God so loved the world that he gave&hellip; 
 &equo; (John 3.16), &bquo;God was in Christ reconciling the world&hellip;&equo; (2 Corinthians 5.19). 
 So here is mystery with a vengeance &mdash; we seem to have the attractive idea that Christ died for you and me, he went to the utmost limit for us, he gave everything away, and in some mysterious and tantalizing fashion he took my sin and yours upon himself, but we cannot say to whom the price was paid! 
 Have we any clues? 
 Let me offer some. 
 The first clue we have lies in the concept of participation. 
 The theologian R.C. Moberly's Atonement and Personality  helps us, I believe, with the analogy of a human family. 
 Think of a child who is alienated from you. 
 I am sensitive to the fact that some of you will understand the problem more powerfully than any illustration, but I will press on. 
 We might imagine a young person very defiantly rejecting the family, taking drugs and living with someone. 
 Yet there is not total rejection; the young person feels shame, guilt and bewilderment. 
 The problem, suggests Moberly, is how to create a change of attitude in the child to bring them back again. 
 It would be no good to wave the law at them; it would be no good to whisper &bquo;there, there&equo;. 
 There is only one way, and it is a costly way. 
 You have to bear the punishment by standing with them, taking the shame with them, and bearing the cost with them. 
 This, says Moberly, is what Father and Son do for us: they enter into the pain of human sin and lostness and suffer with us and for us. 
 The writer D.E. 
 Whitely has in his book The Theology of the New Testament  a powerful image of an officer in the war who had to lead his troops across a dangerous minefield. 
 He knew he would lose many of his men in the dangerous, slow pathway across. 
 There was one way, however, only one way he could make sure no life was lost apart from his own. 
 Deliberately he walked into the minefield, triggering off every mine and thus absorbing in his own body the entire explosion. 
 Like every illustration, of course, it only goes part of the way in satisfying our minds. 
 I want to go further. 
 This takes me into atonement as vicarious love. 
 Our problem is that we always separate love from justice and love from holiness. 
 Going back to the family problem just mentioned, much as we love that child in spite of his problems, we would not let ourselves be completely taken over. 
 The idea of our homes being smashed by drugs, by prostitution, by evil of whatever kind, would most surely be unacceptable to us. 
 We would say: &bquo;Much as I love you, I cannot condone this behaviour. 
 This is wrong.&equo; 
 Here we are at the heart of the problem: holy love. 
 Love which wants redemption, healing, forgiveness and reconciliation knows that the demands of justice have to be met. 
 There is an eternal law which reduces in utter simplicity to: &bquo;You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your mind&hellip; and you shall love your neighbour as yourself&equo; (Matthew 22.37,39). 
 I heard someone say the other day that modern people treat  the Ten Commandments like examination questions: only four need be attempted. 
 The Ten Commandments nonetheless stand as the expression of God's holy Law and of the purity and goodness he demands. 
 How we fail it, time and again! 
 It is in holy love that we glimpse the meaning of the cross because &bquo;God so loved the world that he gave his only Son&equo; (John 3.16). 
 God's love is outgoing, outpouring love. 
 It is a love which redeems sinful people, not by saying: &bquo;We'll let bygones be bygones&equo;, but by saying: &bquo;I'll bear that load for you; you won't need it again.&equo; 
 It seems impossible, then, to avoid the New Testament message that Jesus' death was planned by God to be the means of reconciliation and peace. 
 God, who does not need reconciling, becomes the Reconciler; God, who does not need appeasing, becomes our peace; God, who knows no sin, becomes sin for us &mdash; by whose stripes and wounds we are healed. 
 In the death and resurrection of Jesus the two gardens of Eden and eternal life are joined. 
 What are the implications for us today? 
 Let me mention just two. 
 The Church must put the cross back into its preaching . 
 Over the last fifteen years, preaching has moved, by and large, from preaching the truths of the Christian faith to the experiences of the Christian faith. 
 The Holy Spirit and his power has been a favourite theme, or &bquo;You too can build a splendid church, or be an excellent minister, if you buy this book or follow these ten lessons.&equo; 
 A &bquo;cross theology&equo;, not on its own, let me add, but central to our preaching, will take us back to the central verity of our faith. 
 We are not in the business of popularity; it is too bad if others do not like the cross. 
 But ignore the cross and you ignore true Christianity. 
 Yesterday I and a few of my colleagues spent a day's retreat at Compton Durrville, a Franciscan retreat centre in this diocese. 
 You cannot go to a Franciscan centre without coming face to face with Francis' emphasis on the cross. 
 You who exercise a ministry of preaching and teaching, do preach the cross as the starting point of hope and peace. 
 Don't be ashamed of its offence to the proud hearts and minds of self-sufficient men and women. 
 They need its message of hope, pardon and peace. 
 I don't think we will talk sensibly about a Decade of Evangelism if we give a cross theology  second or third place in our preaching. 
 We must put the cross back into our spirituality . 
 Bonhoeffer, the theologian to whom I have previously referred, once remarked in one of his books: &bquo;When Christ calls a person, he bids him come and die.&equo; 
 That goes to the centre of our faith. 
 We are dead in Christ. 
 Paul describes it vividly in Romans 6 in the theology of baptism. 
 Enter the waters, and you die with Christ and rise to newness of life. 
 In a wonderful way that is a thrilling thing to take on board. 
 From a Christian perspective, you and I will never face death. 
 Christ faced it for us and was victorious. 
 Our mortal bodies may die but we will never die. 
 We are already enjoying eternal life, and physical death will merely mean the passing from life, in which we see through a glass darkly, to life when we shall see and know as we are known. 
 If I am already dead and alive in Christ, then I must embrace the cross with a greater vigour and commitment. 
 I must try to live under the cross daily. 
 I must put my Saviour always before me as my example, friend and guide. 
 I must live a life that pleases him. 
 The problem is that it is hard. 
 A friend once remarked: &bquo;We are expected to be living sacrifices, but the problem is we keep crawling off the altar.&equo; 
 How right he was! 
 How necessary it is for each one of us to apply the cross to our daily lives &mdash; to our giving to one another and to God of our money, our time, our talents. 
 Skin-deep Christianity will not endure, but heart Christianity will, because it is marked with a cross. 
 A cross spirituality will ensure that you and I are never tempted to follow fashions and fads in church life which, attractive though they may seem, ignore the cross or push it to one side. 
 Recently I have been reading the writings of Matthew Fox, a Dominican who is very popular for his creation spirituality and love of the environment. 
 I agree with a great deal of his concerns. 
 But I notice this: he exaggerates creation above redemption; sin is treated as a rather tiresome preoccupation of the Church, and what matters is the sin and fallenness of mankind's abuse of creation. 
 This is a distortion of Christianity which never separates creation and salvation in that way. 
 True Christianity believes that creation itself is fallen and awaits its redemption; that it also will benefit from the perfection that Christ offers and achieves.  
 A cross spirituality is, however, far from miserable and world-rejecting. 
 Christ was never that. 
 Just as he moved with grace, strength and love among men and women, so the Christian under the cross and the Church under the cross will have an effective, attractive and powerful ministry if we show his grace and live in his strength. 
 In this series I have been introducing twentieth-century martyrs to illustrate the points I have been making. 
 The theme of substitution is graphically revealed in the story of Father Maximilian Kolbe, a Roman Catholic priest who died in Auschwitz. 
 A prisoner had escaped from Auschwitz and ten prisoners were required to die in the starvation bunker &mdash; block 13. 
 Names were read out. 
 The tenth person cried: &bquo;Oh, my God, my wife and children.&equo; 
 Suddenly Father Kolbe stepped forward, a small emaciated man with round glasses, and addressed the Commandant. 
 &bquo;Let me take his place.&equo; 
 The other prisoners gasped because they expected him to be shot on the spot. 
 The Commandant, equally surprised, asked: &bquo;Who are you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I am of no consequence, only a Catholic priest, doing my duty. 
 Let me take that man's place, please.&equo; 
 He nodded, and the condemned men were sent away to the starvation bunker. 
 One man who was attendant to the condemned men said that cell 13 became like a church. 
 Instead of the screams of starving men, there were prayers, and the prayers passed into silence as one by one they died of starvation a few yards away from food. 
 Only Father Kolbe remained alive until a bored guard gave him a fatal injection of carbolic acid. 
 It would not serve my purpose to make that an illustration of Jesus taking my place or yours, because God the Father is clearly not like a Nazi war criminal. 
 Yet there are two points of contact. 
 First, Kolbe's death brought meaning and hope to dying men. 
 It showed the importance of human dignity and love. 
 Christ's death was that to an immeasurably greater degree. 
 Second, it was an amazing act of faith. 
 It could have been such a futile act. 
 The man whose place he took could have died the following week, or the next month. 
 It seemed such a pointless act of heroism. 
 But it wasn't. 
 The man survived the war and told the tale and has lived a purposeful life ever since, seeking to carry on Kolbe's work of reconciliation. 
 I  sometimes wonder if there was that kind of risk when God planned the cross from the beginning of time. 
 I think there was and is. 
 R.S. Thomas has a lovely poem, &bquo;The Coming&equo;, which seems to suggest that. 
 And God held in his hand 
 A small globe. 
 Look, he said. 
 The son looked. 
 Far off, 
 As through water, he saw 
 A scorched land of fierce 
 Colour. 
 The light burned 
 There; crusted buildings 
 Cast their shadows: a bright 
 Serpent, a river 
 Uncoiled itself, radiant 
 With slime. 
 On a bare 
 Hill a bare tree saddened 
 The sky. 
 Many people 
 Held out their thin arms 
 To it, as though waiting 
 For a vanished April 
 To return to its crossed 
 Boughs. 
 The son watched 
 Them. 
 Let me go there, he said. 
 Conclusion 
 Kolbe died for his friend and Christ died for us &mdash; as an example for us to follow, as a pioneer who goes before us, as one who identifies with us, as our reconciler, as our sacrifice, and as our substitute. 
 As such he demands our response and our commitment. 
 That is why I keep saying that I am not only interested in our knowing more about our faith but also in our putting more faith into our lives. 
 May we all say with St Paul in Galatians 2.20: &bquo;I have been crucified with Christ; it is no longer I who live, but Christ who lives in me; and the life I now live in the flesh I live by faith in the Son of God, who loved me and gave himself for me.&equo;  
 Easter Day: The Challenge of the Resurrection Wells Cathedral, Easter Day 1988 
 Karl Heim, German Lutheran theologian, scientist and writer, recounts an incident which occurred in Moscow shortly after the Russian Revolution. 
 One of the frequent mass meetings attended by workers was taking place. 
 The leader announced at the beginning that complete freedom of speech was allowed but speeches must be kept short. 
 Many speeches were delivered expounding the glories of communism. 
 When all had finished the leader asked if any wished to represent the other side, since they had promised freedom of speech. 
 A little under-nourished priest climbed the steps. 
 As he did so the chairman called out &bquo;Five minutes, please!&equo; 
 He replied: &bquo;I won't need five minutes for what I have to say.&equo; 
 Then he began: &bquo;My friends, you have heard all the arguments that have been brought forward to prove the new world-view. 
 But, my friends, Christ is risen!&equo; 
 You might have expected a howl of derision to greet this cry, but it did not come. 
 The workers had heard those words many times before at the Russian Easter night service. 
 So on this occasion when the priest set forth this ancient cry, it was as if a sleeping volcano erupted. 
 From a thousand voices came back the response: &bquo;He is risen indeed, Alleluia!&equo; 
 Now was that priest simply playing cleverly on the emotions of the crowd? 
 I don't think so. 
 He was challenging the so-called &bquo;newness&equo; of the Revolution with the &bquo;newness&equo; of the resurrection. 
 He was, of course, touching a nerve deep within the Russian psyche, but he was saying something like this, that &bquo;if Christ is risen, every argument for atheism is flawed&equo;. 
 Now I personally have every sympathy with the man who says sceptically: &bquo;Dead men don't rise!&equo; 
 Of course they don't! 
 But what we find in the resurrection of Jesus is not  something that originates from the natural processes of life, but something that constitutes a unique event. 
 It is a breaking in of something wholly new: it is an act of creation which parallels the story of creation in Genesis 1. 
 Years ago I read a sentence which has remained with me through the years. 
 &bquo;The resurrection of Jesus Christ is the first article of the Christian faith and the demonstration of all the rest.&equo; 
 Now this may not be characteristic of modern Christianity &mdash; more the pity for it &mdash; but I do believe that it is a just reflection of New Testament Christianity, because in the earliest preaching the emphasis falls on his resurrection. 
 The last act of Jesus was the starting point of the preaching. 
 For years I found it very odd that the disciples spent very little time talking about the significance of the death of Jesus or even the person of Jesus. 
 The emphasis falls instead upon the resurrection. 
 The reason seems to be that the gospel story was formed backwards. 
 Instead of starting with the birth of Jesus and going on to his ministry, death and resurrection, the first disciples began with the resurrection and showed how it made sense of the rest. 
 The notes of excitement and joy pervade the pages of the Acts of the Apostles. 
 Here we find the ring of truth because if you were one of the disciples and Jesus had appeared to you, what would you have told your friends? 
 You would not have gone to them with a theory of the death of Jesus &mdash; you would have gone to them with great wonder saying: &bquo;It is incredible, but our Lord is alive. 
 He lives and all is well!, 
 This great event is the foundation stone of the Christian Church. 
 It stands or falls on this one event. 
 While, of course, the universal symbol of the Christian Church is a cross and rightly so, the cross is part One of the Easter story. 
 When Jesus died, faith in his message died as well and his movement, which had begun with such promise, collapsed. 
 If the figure on the cross had been the last sight of him, we would have heard nothing more of him and there would have been no Church. 
 But from this broken and scattered group of men and women came the startling message of the cross and resurrection with a conviction and power that neither the Jewish authorities nor the Roman rulers could stem. 
 Well did one writer say: &bquo;The evidence for the resurrection is the existence of the Church in that spiritual vitality which confronts us in  the New Testament.&equo; 
 This is so. 
 If you were to take a pencil and cross out every verse in the New Testament which refers to the resurrection or to the idea that Jesus Christ is alive, you would not have much of the New Testament left. 
 It throbs with the conviction that Jesus was raised by God and is alive for evermore. 
 What does it mean for us today? 
 Let us consider two ways in which the resurrection of Jesus challenges us today. 
 First, it challenges our world-view. 
 That priest was right. 
 The cry &bquo;Christ is risen&equo; is a challenge to secularism and materialism. 
 It proclaims that this is God's world and that his values are all that matter. 
 But it is not only the atheism of communism that is challenged by the resurrection, the materialism and secularism of our own culture comes under attack as well. 
 Even we as practising Christians find it extremely difficult to avoid the acid of materialism. 
 The delights of a secular society seem so appealing; technology appears to deliver the goods. 
 Indeed, for many of us, we have never had it so good. 
 That is, until we start to look at the reality of our society. 
 The erosion of values and moral standards, the relativism of life, the shocking things that happen, reveal that our civilization is but a veneer that hides a viciousness and rottenness that frighten us all. 
 The Easter story calls the Christian Church back to identify uncompromisingly with the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ. 
 Of course we shall get howls of laughter. 
 The death and resurrection of Jesus Christ is an uncomfortable message. 
 It is still foolishness and a stumbling block. 
 Lose the resurrection hope, though, and we lose our way. 
 Even this great cathedral will become a museum and mausoleum the day we lose our confidence in the resurrection. 
 Second, we are reminded that while the evidence for the resurrection is impressive, first Christians did not merely believe in the resurrection. 
 They did not simply see an empty tomb and say: &bquo;Coo, he must have risen!&equo; 
 They did not go out giving intellectual addresses saying: &bquo;Come to our seminar and we'll discuss the epistemological significance of the empty tomb. 
 &bquo;They rushed out with a testimony: &bquo;Christ has appeared to me! 
 He is alive! 
 I know it for myself!&equo; 
 You can't keep good news in. 
 I remember years ago being amused when a young man given to very few words came to our vicarage  and burst in with the news: &bquo;Jane had a baby boy this morning!&equo; still with his bedroom slippers on. 
 He could not keep the good news in. 
 It had to be shared. 
 Some years ago I saw Sister Gemmell of the Church Army on television. 
 She was then working among &bquo;down and outs&equo; and prostitutes in London. 
 She was asked if she believed there was life after death. 
 She replied: &bquo;No.&equo; 
 When the interviewer leaned forward open mouthed, she went on: &bquo;I don't believe, I know  there is life with Jesus, after death takes my mortal body.&equo; 
 She had experienced the risen Christ and she knew. 
 In a similar way the famous psychiatrist Carl Jung, when asked about his belief, said: &bquo;I don't believe &mdash; I know, I know.&equo; 
 I believe that for some of us there's the need to possess for ourselves that inner conviction and excitement that is a mark of New Testament Christianity. 
 That conviction came very late in life to the Victorian writer and theologian R.W. Dale. 
 It was said of him that he was preparing his Easter sermon early one Easter Day when the significance of the resurrection dawned on him. 
 For years he had preached it, he had believed it intellectually, but never had it become personal to him. 
 This eminent theologian rushed out into the streets to greet the astonished passers-by with the words: &bquo;Christ is risen, he is risen indeed!&equo; 
 It makes all the difference. 
 If Christ has not risen from the grave of our lives, from our doubts, fears, from our personal deaths, then all the so-called evidences of the resurrection are of no consequence except as props. 
 Jesus Christ's resurrection has to become our  resurrection if it is to mean anything at all. 
 This morning I would like to invite everyone to face up to the challenge of the resurrection. 
 It calls us to identify with a Christ who through the horror of the crucifixion leads us, his people, to new life and hope. 
 It will make a difference to our world-view, to the way we see people, to the way we view God. 
 With the countless multitude of saints down the centuries we will be able to unite in exclaiming: &bquo;He is risen indeed &mdash; Alleluia!&equo;  
 At twelve Jane was taken to England to be educated and encountered her indelible railway wagon. 
 The school was large and famous and she hated the institutionalised life &mdash; but what to do? 
 If she ran away she would only cause worry to her parents, and anyway, where could she run to, on this island? 
 She was brainy, except for maths, but was blessed with a maths mistress of infinite patience called Miss Walden, who gave her extra lessons. 
 Jane would never forget her unselfish devotion. 
 Jane was not popular: in order to be popular, you had to be good at games, and Jane was useless at all of them &mdash; and they played everything &mdash; netball, rounders, tennis, lacrosse, hockey &mdash; even cricket &mdash; every afternoon, rain or shine, exams or no exams. 
 In cricket they used to put her at &bquo;long leg&equo; where the ball hardly ever penetrated, and she would take a book and lie down to read in the long grass. 
 Then on the rare occasion that the ball did come, of course, she missed it. 
 She loved the country surrounding the school, however. 
 The South Downs with the short springy turf decorated with harebells and scabious, and the deceptively gentle slopes, the horizon constantly moving ahead of you, as you puffed after it. 
 And then at last, the summit, with the cloud shadows scudding across the huge curved expanse and a band of sea which was always surprisingly broad &bquo;and above the sea the line of the Downs, so noble and so bare&equo;. 
 In those days she had likened the climb to life: she had dared to hope that there might be wonderful things over the horizon. 
 Now she knew that there was probably nothing on  the other side. 
 It might be quite bare. 
 But it was still imperative to look to the horizon hopefully, or quit. 
 The Sussex coast was best seen at a distance, though, for proximity to the sea causes human beings to create great ugliness. 
 India certainly got its own back for the British Raj by imposing this horrific version of the bungalow upon us. 
 Still, as Jane belonged nowhere, Sussex became the nearest thing to home. 
 Then suddenly, just before the exams, she became popular, and was at a loss to know why. 
 A kind, serene girl called June told her the reason. 
 June was one of those characters who don't develop. 
 At fourteen or forty they are constant, dependable, consistently dispensing happiness wherever they go. 
 &bquo;It's because you and Irene are the cleverest,&equo; she explained. 
 &bquo;And they want you to come top.&equo; 
 &bquo;But why?&equo; asked Jane, who was totally non-competitive. 
 &bquo;Because Irene's Jewish.&equo; 
 For the first time, Jane became aware of anti-Semitism, and it horrified her. 
 She remembered her father's good-humoured jokes about his Jewish friend, but this was different, evil. 
 It made her want to escape from the world. 
 From then on she discovered many things about the human race, but could find no explanations for them. 
 She did come top, though she did not try and hoped she wouldn't. 
 The congratulations sickened her. 
 The headmistress, who had always ridiculed her for being bad at games, now referred to her as &bquo;our best pupil&equo; and gave her a set of Shakespeare, duly inscribed. 
 University was better, less claustrophobic, more cosmopolitan. 
 There were undisciplined Welsh, well-mannered Iraquis, English slobs, beautiful Norwegians. 
 One of the Norwegian girls, Riborg, was the daughter of a ship owner, but had attended a folk high school, along with children whose parents were cobblers and other manual labourers. 
 How much more civilised, Jane thought, than her own segregated education. 
 Riborg approved of the Iraquis because they wore clean shirts every day, but disapproved of the Welsh because they were dirty and noisy and went round in droves. 
 &bquo;They have no dignity and no manners,&equo; she observed severely. 
 Once, at school, the girls had amused themselves by putting together the perfect woman, and Jane  had been surprised when they chose her eyes, which were large and brown. 
 She had always hankered to be tall and fair, like Riborg. 
 Riborg showed her a photograph album, with herself by a fjord in a miniscule bikini. 
 &bquo;What do you think of me appearing like that in front of the men?&equo; she asked in her slow, earnest, Germanic accent, gazing at Jane with steady blue eyes. 
 Then answered her own question. 
 &bquo;You see &mdash; Norwegian men are very &mdash; slow. 
 They need to drink very much spirits to get them going!&equo; 
 Jane had a fleeting affair with a tall, rangy Scottish lecturer, whose main pleasure was to walk for miles. 
 Sometimes she went with him, but found it hard to keep up. 
 Later she met his wife, a flirtatious, self-centred Latvian whom she was sure must be a Gemini. 
 She told Jane, laughing: &bquo;Hamish was a lecturer at Riga University and we were all determined to marry him to get out of Latvia. 
 And I won! 
 It was because I sat at his feet with my blouse undone.&equo; 
 Jane understood then why Hamish was so lonely and sad. 
 Latvia's loss had not been his &mdash; or Britain's &mdash; gain. 
 The same goes for certain other immigrants, such as newspaper proprietors. 
 Shortly afterwards Jane went to a friend's house in Kensington to a musical party where a famous quartet was playing and, sitting on the stairs, talked to someone whom she took to be one of the players. 
 He turned out to be a friend of the musicians and, within a year, she was launched on her disastrous marriage. 
 She, too, had found her immigrant. 
 In the difficult job of getting through one's life happily, she had made a bad start. 
 Not all bad, though. 
 It brought her four children who opened up the world for her and unlocked her own narrow viewpoint &mdash; though not enough, as events were to show. 
 And it introduced her to Budapest, a jewel of a city. 
 It was as if some artistic giant at the making of the world had arranged it &mdash; with the perfect placing of Buda Hill in a curve of the Danube on an otherwise flat landscape. 
 The spectacular Danube! 
 Yet Karl Marx probably never saw it. 
 He had picnics on Hampstead Heath. 
 And, despite everything, the citizens of Budapest knew how to live. 
 Not like Londoners, rushing home to their dormitories. 
 They  enjoyed their city as the eighteenth-century Londoners must have done, before the delightful town houses had been raped and turned into offices. 
 In Budapest, they still strolled around for the sheer pleasure of it. 
 They played chess on the park benches, and on Buda Hill there was a mega-chessboard, with the men almost human size. 
 Their humour did not consist of mere jokes (though they could make those too) but in their whole attitude to life, as the violin runs through the Benedictus  of the Missa Solemnis  like a golden thread from which all else rises and falls; an unforced humour which has known tragedy, and learnt to surmount it. 
 Jane saw it in the smallest things, all impossible in self-conscious Britain. 
 At dinner in the garden one evening, for instance, two perfectly ordinary businessmen suddenly burst into a Verdi duet. 
 Her host, Laszlo, an ex-accountant, used to take action directe  by tossing down the remains from his dinner plate of fish to the cats waiting beneath the balcony. 
 Another day there was an impromptu competition between Laszlo, his wife, and mother, to see who could crack most eggs between their knees &mdash; an extraordinarily difficult feat to achieve. 
 Laszlo was  indomitably  trying to learn English, and when Jane saw him again, ten years later, he had still not progressed beyond the first book, now old and tattered. 
 Then there was Rubletsky, an old friend of the family, a true Bohemian of the old school and still, at eighty, with as sure a touch in his sculpture and drawings as ever Titian had. 
 He was the complete, unashamed opportunist, with immense charm, and took nothing seriously except his art. 
 He completely changed when he was working. 
 When at play, Jane watched him with delight as he rolled about on the floor with mirth at the English &bquo;W&equo;. 
 Despite an indigestible plethora of consonants in the Hungarian language, they have no W. &bquo;Zee shop &mdash; how you call eet? 
 Woll &mdash; wort!&equo; 
 He shrieked with uncontrollable glee. 
 He was a spare aquiline man, who had once been court sculptor (and perhaps unofficial jester!) to a mythical-sounding Ring Zog. 
 Nevertheless, the Communist government had awarded him a life pension, so he had no worries. 
 In the summer, he lived in a little house surrounded by sunflowers higher than it was, beside a village with a pale  blue pump in the centre, with geese marching around, pigeons gurgling (they have a different accent on the Continent) and people sitting on walls gossiping in the evening. 
 Coming back to England from one of these school-holiday visits to Hungary, Jane was more than ever struck by the contrast. 
 Was this the land of Shakespeare, with his spontaneous carnival of images? 
 What had  gone wrong, and when? 
 With all their virtues and even (perhaps especially) when they were trying to enjoy themselves, they were stiff, awkward and apologetic. 
 At New Year, compare the joyous skating in Moscow, the balletic conducting of Carlos Kleiber in Vienna (whose grace shone through his shapeless suit!) &mdash; with the Trafalgar Square mob! 
 Britain had no style, though it once had. 
 Who had killed it? 
 Had it been Cromwell? 
 Perhaps. 
 The Restoration lacked the spontaneity of the Elizabethan age. 
 But no, she was sure it was Queen Victoria, personally, who had spread this grey fog over Britain from which we've never recovered. 
 Great Victorians like Trollope and the Pre-Raphaelites had been fully aware of what was happening. 
 Perhaps, Jane mused, we should never get over it. 
 The despair in the air was particularly dense at the present time, though its monetarist perpetrators were now fighting a rearguard action against the rest of Europe. 
 But hopelessness, like the class system, had now become so ingrained in the soul, she feared that it could be removed neither by stimuli nor legislation. 
 The English character puzzled her, so must totally confuse foreigners. 
 &bquo;You never know what the English are thinking, because they're always so polite,&equo; Riborg had told her. 
 &bquo;You don't say &bquo;no&equo;, but &bquo;I will if I can.&equo;&equo; 
 But tiny Britain, uniquely among countries, is many nations. 
 We have to watch television to see how the others live. 
 And the weather, from one part of this diminutive island to another, is as varied as the people. 
 There are some general characteristics, however. 
 We are docile and lethargic and much easier to govern than the French. 
 We let off steam in graffiti, vandalism and football  hooliganism . 
 Again, unlike the French, we are guilt-ridden. 
 That's why we say &bquo;sorry&equo; so often. 
 And we do not take ourselves seriously like the French: we can demolish everything with our humour. 
  We've got a wider lunatic fringe than other nations. 
 We re an odd mixture of tolerance and prejudice, of the apologetic and the arrogant. 
 Nobody understands us: we don't even understand ourselves. 
 But we are fascinated by ourselves &mdash; which is why Jane's thoughts rabbited on so long about her country. 
 After the glimpse of Scandinavia through Riborg, and later the experience of Hungary, Jane was so far carried away by her enthusiasm for classless freedom, the beauty of northern landscapes, plus the humorous awareness of the central European people, that when a Finn crossed her path, she was fair game. 
 A Finn represented the fusion of Scandinavia and Hungary (to which country they were first cousins) so no doubt she expected too much of Erkki. 
 Anyway, he looked like an ageing Nordic god. 
 He invited her to lunch at his club for international journalists in Carlton House Terrace. 
 They went to hear the Sibelius Violin Concerto superlatively played by Isaac Stern. 
 But then slowly, unwillingly, she had to admit that he was cold and conventional, and his lovemaking was nasty, brutish and short. 
 A sheep in wolf's clothing. 
 A timid, pathetic creature disguised by a big, manly body. 
 &bquo;Outers&equo; can be so misleading! 
 The vistas of fir forests, islands and lakes disintegrated into an outer London suburb and a mundane wife called Letitia. 
 She was, he said, bad-tempered, a snob, and he seemed afraid of her &mdash; she had obviously married him! 
 Perhaps because of fear, his latest book &mdash; a life of Nelson &mdash; bore the placating dedication &bquo;To Letitia, in gratitude for her sweet company&equo;. 
 Sanctimonious fool! 
 So they kissed, for what Jane knew would be the last time, in Belgrave Square. 
 Goodbye to another dream that had died. 
 She felt angry with herself for getting carried away by the ideas in her head, for turning her back on reality. 
 She deserved to pay the price. 
 All the same, she could not bear to listen to the Sibelius concerto for some time afterwards. 
 True, they had not suited each other, but supposing the chemistry had  been right, should such a relationship have been ruined by the wretched man-made social system? 
 There is nothing a woman wants so much as to be in love, and the odds are very much against two &bquo;right&equo; people ever  finding each other. 
 The whole of human life is a matter of chance, and we only live once! 
 Jane knew from bitter experience that love is a rare thing, so she felt very strongly that nothing should be allowed to come in its way, that nobody should be condemned to endure the rest of life with those two small, sad words: &bquo;if only&hellip;.&equo; 
 Jane had played her cards, and played them wrong. 
 She had married too soon and was married too long. 
 She was resigned never to meet the right man. 
 She had to let imagination take over. 
 Her namesake, Jane Austen, she supposed, had found the same, so she invented Darcy and Mr Knightley. 
 The same went for the Bront&euml;s (Charlotte's late marriage being irrelevant), so in a perfect world, we should certainly have been deprived of these characters.  
 No doubt the past was just the same to the people who lived in it as the present is to us. 
 Nevertheless we tend to think times used to be rosier. 
 Thus &bquo;olde&equo; journalistic memories acquire something of the patina of antiques, ordinary at the time, but with hindsight, quaint and even charming. 
 Jane had &bquo;missed her first&equo; and went down from university with only a two-one in English Language and Literature, thus deprived of the academic career she had coveted with cowardice. 
 She &bquo;got onto&equo; a newspaper. 
 It was the old Daily Herald , in Endell Street, Covent Garden, then dominated by Odhams Press, in turn reigned over by the benevolent Lord Southwood. 
 The cosy status quo  seemed as secure as the Austro-Hungarian Empire. 
 But all regimes must end, just as surely as we will die: though we don't like to face it, any more than we like to face death. 
 How fortunate for the denizens of The Daily Herald , then, that they could not see into the future &mdash; even the immediate future! 
 Jane's appointment was quick and unceremonial. 
 &bquo;I like you, I like your personality, you're on,&equo; said the maverick editor before she had uttered one well-prepared word. 
 At lunchtime she was taken across the road to the paper's local, The Cross Keys, to meet the gang, at which initiation she remembered in particular a short, genial, Punch-like &bquo;ex-RAF type&equo; (as he liked to call himself) named Arthur Eperon, who later became a well-known travel writer. 
 She never forgot his name as she connected it with heraldry. 
 She did forget the name of the other most memorable character,  bearded and effusive. 
 He was the television critic who shortly afterwards unfortunately wrote up a programme which had been cancelled, and got the sack. 
 Hannen Swaffer &mdash; revered almost as the Bernard Shaw of left-wing journalism &mdash; used to blow in and write his piece on the corner of someone else's desk. 
 He never had his own desk on principle, as he said all desks had chains attached. 
 Too true. 
 The feature editor had a bad stutter, and Hannen Swaffer was deaf, so to watch them trying to communicate was hilarious. 
 But the halcyon days were short-lived. 
 A takeover was under way by the grey men and the only ones who survived it were the grey people. 
 The old Herald , moral and earnest, was metamorphosed, with supreme irony, into the unspeakable Sun . 
 Being obliged to earn a living without intermission, Jane had no time to pick and choose, but snapped up the first offer &mdash; on a woman's magazine. 
 Now this, to outsiders, is an unbelievable world, totally severed from the outside world, utterly divorced from reality. 
 The only analogy was St Trinian's, but this was dead serious. 
 No spark of humour (even of sanity) was allowed to invade the hallowed Mixture as Before: Beauty, Knitting, Fashion, Cookery, Short Story, in embalmed vacuity, delivered from that pinnacle of self-righteousness which only the mediocre could sustain. 
 The editor, Pamela Hellebore, was fat. 
 Perhaps it was puppy-fat because she always said she was very young, though she didn't look it. 
 She had a habit of shrieking. 
 When the magazine folded she specialised in dried flowers which had the virtue of not being able to shriek back. 
 Her aide, Fiona Shurll, the ex-editor of an obscure knitting magazine, was unbelievably like an owl. 
 She had a round face, round eyes which she rolled and raised to the ceiling while she spake (spoke was too mundane a term for her pronouncements) and she invariably began these pronouncements with &bquo;Whooo &mdash;&equo; to which Jane mentally added &bquo;To-whit-too-whoo&equo;, and concluded that there must  be an owl species called Shurll. 
 Whatever happened to Shurll, Jane wondered &mdash; did she go and live in a hollow tree? 
 The chief sub lived with her brother in Clapham and used Epsom Salts in her bath. 
 &bquo;I think that's a good idea &mdash; don't you?&equo; was her leitmotif . 
 It reminded Jane of one of the  Professor Branestawm stories she had read as a child in which the characters were photographs come alive, each repeating, over and over again, the sentence he or she had been saying at the moment the photograph was taken. 
 Another weird species which Jane encountered in magazineland was the Public Relations Woman. 
 She took various forms, but was usually overdressed and over voluble. 
 The job was looked upon as glamorous and attracted some deb-types. 
 Jane came across one called Georgina, whom she had been at school with. 
 Georgina, whose Pekinese accompanied her everywhere, took Jane up to her office in the lunch hour, while the head &bquo;image-maker&equo; was out. 
 There were a number of plastic heads &mdash; wig holders &mdash; and on each was stuck a label &bquo;out to &mdash;&equo; (with the name of a well-known hairdresser). 
 &bquo;The wigs are in the cupboard really,&equo; said Georgina. 
 &bquo;That's just a ploy &mdash; done to impress a prospective client who's coming this afternoon., 
 A second deb-type took Jane out to lunch at The Hyde Park Hotel. 
 &bquo;Red or white? 
 Let's settle for ros&eacute;.&equo; 
 They always said that: it was somehow symptomatic of PR: sit on the fence &mdash; never upset anybody. 
 Halfway through lunch, this blonde, baby-faced girl started to kill herself with anxiety because she saw someone she knew but could not remember their name. 
 She flapped and fretted for the remainder of the meal. 
 What the hell does it matter? 
 Jane wondered. 
 But at that time the PR mentality (one could not call it mind) was new to her. 
 Later this rosebud spent a weekend at the stately home of a young lord. 
 She instructed all her friends to keep their fingers crossed, played her cards right, and married him. 
 It didn't last, but at least she acquired a title. 
 At the other end of the spectrum was an obese one-eyed woman who wore scarlet heart-shaped specs and looked like a brothel madame. 
 She had a toy-boy in tow whom she called her &bquo;animal&equo;. 
 &bquo;Where's my Animal? 
 I like to enjoy  my Animal,&equo; she roared predatorily, smacking her lips. 
 It's amazing what some men will do for a meal ticket. 
 Some twenty years previously she had produced a son, who was prematurely middle-aged, bald and overweight. 
 &bquo;He's full of decent sex,&equo; she confided to Jane. 
 Jane escaped as soon as she could and never went back, though she once saw  &bquo;madame&equo; tango at a press party. 
 It reminded her irresistably of a scene in Fantasia . 
 What mystified her was how any firm could employ such a gorgon to promote their products. 
 On the magazine, Jane's main task was to wrestle with the anglicising of indifferent American short stories, while the particular harpy who was her boss gazed out of the window for ninety per cent of the time. 
 Eventually, about six weeks after joining, Jane was indiscreet enough to ask why they could not use English writers, and promptly got the sack. 
 She appealed to the Father of the Chapel on the grounds of wrongful dismissal, but he shook his head sadly. 
 &bquo;I could have resolved it for you,&equo; he said, &bquo;if only you'd come to see me earlier. 
 Your editor, you know, is notoriously devious, so I always take my secretary in as witness. 
 She (Jane's editor) is so jittery it's said she wriggles about on her chair to such an extent that she wears out several pairs of knickers a week!&equo; 
 However, the NUJ man managed to squeeze a month's money out of the management and Jane crossed Blackfriars Bridge back into the real world in a thunderstorm but with a light heart, passing the inevitable drunk Irishman proclaiming to the heavens: &bquo;Jasus, Mary and Joseph &mdash; a bludy hurricane!&equo; 
 For Jane, that slice of life evaporated as if it had never existed. 
 She never looked at a woman's magazine after that, though she saw from their covers, displayed beside the supermarket till, that they had not changed, but went on churning out the same old stuff. 
 Jane continued her career &mdash; if you can dignify it with such a name &mdash; on Vogue , where the personnel manager fiercely shot at her the rhetorical question: &bquo;You've got a private income, of course ?&equo; 
 Where the editor rattled her half dozen strings of large beads and remarked with a toothy grin: &bquo;They say it's the fashion  &mdash;&equo; Where Gerald, the art editor &mdash; who was reputed to have a fabulous house on the Chelsea Embankment full of priceless works of art &mdash; was so sensitive that he had to have a soundproof office specially built for him, while his assistant Jeremy padded along like his superior's spaniel, and if Gerald wore a shirt of subtle pink on Monday, his minion would appear in the same shade on Tuesday. 
 Where top photographer &bquo;Parks&equo; was  utterly unable to take photographs unless he wore an ornamental skull cap. 
 Jane was surprised at the ferocity of gay rows. 
 &bquo;I'll be sick on the floor if he comes near me&equo; &mdash; a photographer loaned from American Vogue  threatened if Gerald should intrude once more  on his studio photo sessions. 
 It was all over a Brazilian boy who looked after the props. 
 Jane found it highly amusing. 
 Jane was invariably caught out by Cecil Beaton on the telephone, thinking it was his housekeeper. 
 &bquo;Cecil Beaton here,&equo;  he trilled. 
 Then she would go down to his cluttered little house in South Kensington with his hundreds of contacts (for he was clever enough never to leave anything to chance) and he would pronounce them all &bquo;Absolutely Divine,&equo; but at last succeed, with supreme anguish, in selecting one or two which were even more divine than the others. 
 The &bquo;abominable army&equo; of fashion editors (trailing clouds of Benenden they came) who could not write, nipped over to Deauville for the weekend, often wearing dark specs to hide the bags under their eyes, while Jane converted their illegible notes into copy. 
 She stood it for a year. 
 It was funny, in a Lewis Carroll sort of way, and at least the result was passable, if only as a trade magazine, whereas the woman's magazine had been beyond a joke and she could not bear to look at the end product. 
 Her next editor was a man. 
 She was pregnant and it was just starting to show. 
 He was terrified that she might &bquo;drop it&equo; in the corridor, and so, to put his mind at rest, she told him she was only three months on, whereas in fact she was six, but carried her offspring high, so that it didn't show too much. 
 &bquo;There can be NO QUESTION of you staying on.&equo; 
 He issued the command like a Roman edict, raising his voice to a querulous crescendo. 
 He was an old, stooping, emaciated bachelor, aghast at the facts of life; he never smiled, but glowered defensively at the world from under his eyebrows, and she felt a certain sympathy for him. 
 He was a rotten journalist. 
 it was only the stress of the job that kept him anything like upright at all. 
 He was just there because he'd always been there. 
 All the same, Jane stayed on to within a month of the birth because they couldn't do  without her and she needed the money. 
 But he never knew.  
 &bquo;Three twelve,&equo; said the auctioneer's girl, and disappeared into an inner office. 
 Jane brightened. 
 &bquo;&pound;312!&equo; she thought, &bquo;All my problems solved!&equo; 
 Then the girl came back and gave Jane&hellip; &pound;3&ndash;12p in cash. 
 Emotional troubles pale before financial ones. 
 Jane had run out of money. 
 She had sent her younger son to a private school because the switch to comprehensives was such a mess and because he had a horror of a huge education factory after his primary school where everybody was known by their first name. 
 The trouble was, the private school fees had suddenly doubled. 
 Running out of money is most educative. 
 When Jane asked for an overdraft, the bank manager (slogan: &bquo;We Like to Say &bquo;Yes&equo;&equo;), a pompous Dad's Army look-alike, after conferring with some nasty men in suits who turned their backs to her, had shown her the door. 
 So she had &bquo;cried all the way from the bank&equo;. 
 No matter whether it's the &bquo;Yes&equo; bank, the action bank, the thoroughbred bank, the listening bank, or the bank to which all points, you can't make a friend of your bank manager unless you've got loadsamoney. 
 They're all bastards. 
 The real villians of our society are the money men. 
 With a mortgage, you have to run very fast to stay in the same place &mdash; like the Red queen. 
 Jane dreamt she was clinging to the edge of a cliff, and her bank manager was hammering at her fingers. 
 She then, most unwillingly, asked her sole surviving relative &mdash; her uncle-in-law, Arpad, for a loan. 
 He was the younger brother of Lajos' father, and had been a successful export &mdash; a businessman who owned a factory. 
 In his dress,  he out-Englished the English, wearing tweeds with huge checks, or blazers with outsize badges. 
 He was very limited in mind and interests but had not altogether lost his native humour. 
 &bquo;I can't speak any  language any more &mdash; not even Hungarian,&equo; he would say. 
 He was a hard worker, but Jane marvelled at how he had been able to build up a business while remaining practically unintelligible. 
 He had an expensive &bquo;bijou&equo; residence with fluorescent tubes running under the banisters and a Music Centre with a huge bank of switches and buttons which he had no idea how to use. 
 Mantovani was his favourite &bquo;composer&equo;. 
 And he had a status-symbol mega car which he drove very slowly in the middle lane, his knuckles white with the strength of his grip on the steering wheel. 
 He had been stopped by the police several times for driving too slowly. 
 How he and many others ever get through their driving test in Britain is a recurring nightmare. 
 He had no friends, only business contacts, like his bank manager who was quite willing, together with his boring wife, to be entertained by the little foreigner. 
 Jane had once invited a bank manager to Christmas Eve drinks, which he had loftily declined. 
 She was in credit at the time too. 
 &mdash; but was obviously on the wrong side of the finance barrier. 
 She never repeated the goodwill gesture. 
 Money was Arpad's lifeblood. 
 He needed it to give him security, because he had none within himself. 
 He was possessed by his possessions, and had two topics of conversation: age and money. 
 How old: and how much? 
 He was seventy and continually engaged in frenetic schemes to bolster up his old age. 
 He made himself ill with the worry. 
 &bquo;When I was hungry I hadn't money. 
 Now I have money, I can't eat!&equo; 
 So when Jane asked him for a loan, he snapped back: &bquo;I think my first duty is to look after myself!&equo; 
 Jane was angry, not just because he had refused, but because it was unbearable that such a worm could be so successful. 
 The illiterate, inarticulate businessman, the exportable type, the survivor! 
 The most likely to inherit the earth. 
 With the spiders. 
 So now Jane was selling the family antiques. 
 Maybe they weren't antique, or weren't in fashion: anyway, as usual, she had no luck.  
 Bills are never late, nor lost (payment cheques often are). 
 Problems come by every post. 
 The postman becomes the Daily Dread. 
 Nothing was going her way, but she did not panic. 
 When you have a lot of trouble, you learn to live with it. 
 It's the people with easy lives who make heavy weather. 
 Difficulties, she told herself, like the wind, will fan a strong flame, but put a weak one out. 
 Still, she had a sneaking hope that as she'd reached her lowest ebb, the tide might turn. 
 She had to try in every direction. 
 Trouble was, she had run out of directions. 
 Except one. 
 Advertising. 
 The Grovel Industry, where you get paid danger money because it's so insecure. 
 There was nothing for it. 
 It was easy for journalists to get jobs as copywriters. 
 Advertising was a large tatty lino-floored room crammed with people who all wore faded jeans de rigueur , with a smell of spray mount, and magic markers littered everywhere. 
 And a great deal of noise: people continually shouting across the room. 
 The posh agency was terribly ashamed of its creative department, and never took clients up there. 
 They were shut away like lunatics and made to use the back lift. 
 There was a breathless hush in the executive floor all day, perfumed by smart secretaries, softened by deep carpets, cultured by pictures on the wall &mdash; not advertising, but Art. 
 Advertisements were only admitted into the reception area. 
 On the floor above the loony bin, nobody quite knew what took place. 
 It was called Market Research. 
 Yet all research projects seemed to be expensively commissioned from outside firms. 
 Towards the end of her time in advertising, Jane was actually offered a job in the mystery department. 
 She said jokingly: &bquo;If I moved up here, I'd lose my tenuous grip on reality altogether!&equo; 
 But the marketing director was not amused. 
 She knew by then that the only bearable department in the agency was the creative &mdash; the Bin. 
 When Jane first entered the Bin, Rod, a diminutive Scot, was engaged in trying to climb round the walls of the room without touching the floor, loudly cheered by all on his way. 
 Later, there was frenzied activity in the creation of a spoof campaign for Tunnel Vision, a &bquo;new&equo; TV channel. 
 Soon visuals with clever captions were pinned all round the room. 
 Jane had struck an &bquo;off&equo; period, for advertising goes in  fits and starts. 
 Relieved of the dead hand of the client and his shadow, the account executive, the creative department ran riot and produced some brilliant stuff. 
 Their masterpieces were witty birthday and leaving cards. 
 Jane kept hers for years. 
 It was in the Bin that Jane worked alongside Salad (as they called him) Rushdie, who was a part-time copywriter. 
 He was also busy campaigning for racial equality. 
 &bquo;You will never do anything on your own?&equo; he told Jane, &bquo;you must always collaborate with like-minded people.&equo; 
 All the same, novel-writing is a lonely business, and English-educated Rushdie was perhaps too trusting. 
 Novelists can hardly be expected to be au fait  with international law and religion. 
 Surely there should be legal experts to advise them? 
 Her first job was to produce ideas and scripts for a TV commercial. 
 The clients chose the dullest and safest of the half dozen submitted, as was their wont. 
 And this, only after a series of killing meetings in which Jane invariably nodded off, to be kicked into consciousness under the table by jean, her art director. 
 When the day of the shoot came, she was astounded by the transformation in the appearance of the creative director, who took the day off to attend. 
 He was completely kitted out in film director's gear &mdash; cap, dark specs, cigar, baggy casuals, replacing his usual natty suit &mdash; for faded jeans stopped short of him &mdash; he had a separate office, complete with pretty secretary. 
 Unfortunately the commercials company had omitted to provide a Director's Chair, so he had to make do with a low wall. 
 His presence was not necessary. 
 On the other hand, the most important person, the cameraman, wore jeans and a Micky Mouse T-shirt, over which his mournful, deadpan moon face shone incongruously. 
 Jane had the opportunity &mdash; or rather, misfortune &mdash; of an adman's view of two foreign countries. 
 The first was Switzerland: safe Switzerland, protected by mountains and international banking. 
 The scenery was beautiful, but it had not entered into the soul of the people. 
 Did not two of history's greatest villains come from beautiful surroundings? 
 Hitler from Austria. 
 Stalin from Georgia.  
 She travelled with a boring ad-team of account director and illiterate art director, called Clive. 
 She thought that breed was extinct, but he, fat, bearded, boss-eyed, aged thirty-six but looking fifty &mdash; an effigy of dissipation &mdash; was unfortunately very much alive. 
 He was useless at his job, but indefatigable at imposing his presence on contacts in pubs. 
 It seemed to Jane very fitting that he should come from Cleethorpes. 
 Surely England must outdo any other country in ugly place-names &mdash; Scunthorpe, Skegness, Biggleswade&hellip; how did they happen? 
 Clive's favourite, perfectly serious, leitmotif  was: &bquo;We're a top team, aren't we!&equo; until Jane felt she'd scream if he said it once more, and ordered breakfast in her room so as to avoid him first thing in the morning, at least. 
 The account director, Bogg, was a short, square ginger-haired man with a very large head, but not much in it. 
 His leitmotif  was: &bquo;How much will it cost? 
 Double it! 
 Simple!&equo; 
 Their venue was a multinational with huge plate glass windows overlooking Lake Geneva. 
 It was manned by zombies who not only clocked in and out of work, but for lunch also. 
 There was a &bquo;clock&equo; beside every lift. 
 The governing board included, as always, a representative from the Swiss government, to give operations a veneer of official approval. 
 Jane was amused, however, to see that a whole large room was devoted to &bquo;activist&equo; (said with a sort of spitting intonation) literature: Friends of the Earth, Greenpeace and other unmentionables. 
 The company made a large profit exporting wholly unsuitable milk powder to Africa, where there was no pure water to mix it with. 
 Babies died. 
 Never mind, play on ignorance. 
 It's good for business. 
 She was chuffed to observe, however, how nervous these well-tailored industrialists were of the &bquo;activists&equo;. 
 The English representative on the board asked her whether she'd like to work for the company in Switzerland, as resident copywriter (for Jane was bright, though she despised the &bquo;profession&equo;). 
 She replied: &bquo;No, thank you. 
 I'd rather be a street sweeper.&equo; 
 At least the Swiss were very clean. 
 Later, in the &bquo;eighties, that same high-ranking sartorial executive &mdash; by then with another company &mdash; was hauled before the Serious Fraud Squad in London. 
 Jane  was not surprised. 
 The air in Switzerland was polluted by money. 
 When they went out to dinner (for they were a &bquo;top team,!) she was incredulous at the Great Gatsby look of the other diners &mdash; all middle-aged. 
 She never remembered seeing any young people.  
 The second, even greater and more prolonged misfortune, was to go to the USA, where the agency she worked for had their head office. 
 First to New York, which she thought was the ugliest, filthiest town she'd ever seen, typified by their slouching, smoking mounted police. 
 A spade should be substituted for the heart on the car sticker. 
 Broadway, Times Square, Greenwich Village (their pathetic Chelsea) made her belligerently European. 
 But on reflection, she fancied she was too late for New York. 
 Places have their Time. 
 They then went south by Amtrak (the railway fast disappearing, like BR). 
 She remembered only two things about New York with affection: the man at Pennsylvania Station, perched high in a little glass box, who announced the trains in the rhythm of a square dance, and the man who returned her purse which she'd dropped on the platform &mdash; a black man. 
 And she recalled one thing with amusement: God and Mammon, side by side at the hotel: a Bible and  an American Express application leaflet in her bedroom. 
 South, they dropped in at New Orleans, where again she found the reputation was far superior to the reality. 
 The &bquo;old&equo; Orleans was like a museum: streets, balconies, blues saloons, street musicians, carefully preserved in aspic specially for tourists. 
 She noticed that the horses drawing the &bquo;olde&equo; cabs were not all that well cared for, and several clinked along with loose shoes. 
 Why travel thousands of miles to visit a spoof Paris? 
 It was inevitable, she supposed, when America was seen by most through a haze created by  its films &mdash; the greatest publicity stunt ever. 
 The journey through Louisiana was more down to earth. 
 The train's arrival was an Event and whole families gathered on the station platforms to see their travelling members off. 
 Jane was squeezed beside the fattest black woman she'd ever seen, shaking like a jelly with continual mirth. 
 But Louisiana was at least real and human. 
 The worst was to come. 
 Texas. 
 Why did Sam Houston ever reclaim it? 
 It was only fit for crocodiles, not even for the abysmal species of human life she found there. 
 They lived in luxurious misery in sub-divisions , like an army encampment (which subdivision do you  come from?) 
 They travelled in cars proudly called &bquo;Suburban&equo;. 
 They inhabited houses which, in the building boom organised under the strict and uncontrolled power of the Mafia, laughably resembled English houses, with pitched roofs and fireplaces &mdash; in a temperature which rarely fell below thirty degrees and a humidity comparable to Brazil's. 
 Jane took early morning walks and watched the building operations. 
 Designs ranged from one to six. 
 When they reached six, they began at one again. 
 Here and there they charged extra for &bquo;landscaping&equo;, which equalled one or two flowerbeds in the front &bquo;yards&equo;. 
 Nobody walked. 
 She was often offered lifts, but when she said, thank you, but she was going for a walk, a pitying expression spread over the faces of the drivers. 
 &bquo;The accent &mdash; English. 
 Mad English. 
 Poor thing. 
 She can't help it.&equo; 
 The vacancy &mdash; mental and physical &mdash; was claustrophobic. 
 Never &mdash; even in South America with all its faults &mdash; had she seen human life like this. 
 It was like another planet, and the rest of the world was indeed another planet to these people. 
 Few had been abroad, despite the frequent German and Hungarian names displayed Texas-fashion outside their houses. 
 These belonged to their forbears. 
 This generation fed on the advertisement-ridden local paper, thick as a book, which was tossed daily onto their front yards. 
 Worse even than English local papers, which are thin and at least read by a minority. 
 These had the news crammed onto the back page, and very little of it. 
 News from another planet. 
 Washington Post?  
 New York Times ? 
 Not here. 
 America as a  whole might be drunk with self-congratulation, but the Texans went further: they were totally unaware even of the other States. 
 And Houston was, as the television reminded one every other second, &bquo;the greatest town on earth&equo;. 
 With a murder a minute. 
 The Texans were a very unhealthy race. 
 They suffered from bronchial diseases &mdash; even the children &mdash; and Jane made herself unpopular by suggesting it might be something to do with the ubiquitous air conditioning. 
 In the houses &mdash; never a window opened &mdash; in the cars, in the gruesome, echoing hypermarkets set in the middle of nowhere (where they wished you a &bquo;nice day&equo; at 10 pm). 
 Even to get money from the bank, you didn't have to leave your car. 
 Your cheque went, and the money came back, through the car window (opened ever so little) &mdash; on a conveyor belt. 
 The endemic hypochondria of the Texans was milked by a plethora of expensive clinics which most of them attended. 
 Jane accompanied her hostess, who had taken her ten-year-old bronchial, backward (&bquo;France is the capital of Paris&equo;) overactive child to one, and while waiting was confided in by a fashionable, staring-eyed woman. 
 &bquo;I'm being poisoned by my saucepans,&equo; she whispered darkly. 
 &bquo;Then why don't you get a new set?&equo; asked Jane. 
 English. 
 Steely silence. 
 Another patient filled the gap: &bquo;I think Mrs Thatcher an&equo; yer King and queen are jus' wunnerful!&equo; she said. 
 Jane's host inhabited magnified suburban house, Style No 3, and there was a whole tree growing in a tub in his hall. 
 He was an uncomplicated, well-meaning Organisation Man and was always called &bquo;JC&equo;, which stood either for Jesus Christ or Julius Caesar. 
 Jane could never remember which, but it was one or the other. 
 God's air was not good enough even for the Methodist chapel. 
 It too was air-conditioned. 
 It was clinical white with a spotless red carpet, and full on Sundays. 
 Even the children were obliged to wear their best clothes, and obviously uncomfortable &mdash; the boys in suits, collars and ties, like a 1930s movie. 
 The God who hovered above was doubtless white and all-American. 
 There was not an Indian or Mexican to be seen. 
 Surely they can't all  be white and holy? 
 Jane looked around for some other inhabitants. 
 The Indians had been hived off into reserves like national parks  for endangered species, where they made plastic souvenirs for tourists. 
 But the white-and-holy showed them off like prized exhibits, for they liked to make the most of their scanty history. 
 The Mexicans crossed the border to sell fruit and vegetables very cheap to the over-fed Americans, though Jane noticed that her overweight hosts made a great ceremony of using tablets instead of sugar in their coffee. 
 The food these suburban Texans threw away would have been enough to feed the whole of Latin America. 
 Jane saw only one black man, driving a &bquo;garbage&equo; cart. 
 And she glimpsed the flip side of the coin: clusters of caravans where the &bquo;poor whites&equo; lived. 
 No joke in the Texan climate. 
 One rainy morning, she did see some cowboys, though no horses. 
 They were breakfasting in a highway caf&eacute; &mdash; eggs sunny side up. 
 And to her amazement she saw that they were all wearing their stetsons. 
 A friend had told her that they never took them off, but she had thought that he was pulling her leg. 
 In the loo, the graffiti on the wall said: &bquo;Texans are living proof that a bull can  copulate with a human.&equo; 
 Another disgruntled traveller, no doubt. 
 The only memorable &bquo;in the round&equo; person she met was her host's eighty-year-old mother, quick, intelligent and agile with, moreover, a sense of humour. 
 &bquo;Ma mother &mdash; &bquo;she told Jane, &bquo;came from Tennessee in a covered wagon. 
 She didn't like it here, so back she went home again.&equo; 
 Jane realised then that she had never really believed in covered wagons, other than as a vehicle for John Wayne. 
 (Just as she has never believed Christ existed until she read about him in Tacitus &mdash; an independent witness.) 
 How depressed those tough pioneers would be to see their descendants, who had not only lost their pioneer spirit, but the ability to walk! 
 It's through the intrepidity of our ancestors that any of us are here at all, but this was an extreme case of decadence. 
 Most depressingly of all, there seemed no hope, even among the young people. 
 Jane was in a junk food caf&eacute; trying to eat chips off a floppy paper plate and drink red wine three-quarters full of ice, when a young man with long hair entered carrying a guitar, &bquo;Ugh &mdash; don't like him,&equo; said her host's son, aged sixteen. 
 &bquo;Why not? &mdash; you don't know  him.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's dirdy.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's not&equo;. 
 &bquo;Well, he's different anyway. 
 He ain't one of us.&equo; 
 Britain, the alleged home of &bquo;not one of us&equo;, seemed to be wearing a halo to Jane at that moment. 
 After she got home, Jane received a letter from the United States. 
 There was a candle on the stamp with the words: &bquo;The light of America, fueled by Reason and Truth.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, on the radio, there was news from El Salvador.  
 Jane came out of the tube station and walked along the road. 
 An outer tentacle of London stretched before her in all its identical horror, a ribbon of living units on each side, a mock Tudor pub at every roundabout, fragmented countryside surviving amidst the sprawl of buildings. 
 She had been offered a job called &bquo;copy chief at one of the agency's clients on the strength of the work she had done for this client at the agency. 
 As the money was better, all the children still at home, and moreover as the bank had begun to play ball-games again, she had felt constrained to accept. 
 Misery acquaints one with strange employment. 
 That is how Jane entered British Industry. 
 The first thing she noticed was the car park. 
 It was hierarchical. 
 A big oblong for the managing director, six medium ones for the directors, a dozen small ones for the salesmen. 
 The first person she met was the Manager of Managers, a man nearing retiring age. 
 (&bquo;I'd give them six months, survival when they leave here,&equo; the doorman had told her.) 
 The Manager of Managers had been there thirty years. 
 &bquo;He went far because he's so correct he never upset anybody,&equo; was the general opinion she heard later. 
 What will you do without this place? 
 Jane wondered, what have you got it in  you to do? 
 No, probably, six months of idleness and he'd have had it. 
 Outwardly, she took his proferred hand. 
 &bquo;Pleased to meet you,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Glad you're joining us.&equo; 
 (Oh! thought Jane, because I'm good at my work?) 
 But he continued: &bquo;Because you won't be getting pregnant. 
 Got all that behind you.&equo;  
 He sat down behind his middle-sized desk (eighteen inches smaller than the directors') and placed the tips of his fingers together. 
 His voice took on a well-rehearsed tone. 
 He was at once timid and status-conscious. 
 His friends called him an easy-going chap; his enemies called him weak. 
 &bquo;The other lady here &mdash;&equo; there was only one other female executive, though plenty of secretaries mincing about &mdash; &bquo;Phyllis &mdash; she's brand manager for one of our OTC (over the counter) products &mdash; Bitewell Baby Rusks. 
 The factory's moved to Southampton &mdash; part of our diversification. 
 And Phyllis put her skates on &mdash; off she went &mdash; bought a house down there &mdash; she moved in before the factory opened. 
 There's keenness for you!&equo; he concluded admiringly. 
 (Shortly after the rusks were banned for having bits of metal in them, the factory closed &mdash; and what did dear Phyllis do then, poor thing?) 
 Jane had removed her specs for a short myopic rest, but now put them on again, quickly. 
 Was he? 
 Yes he was! 
 Crying!! 
 &bquo;My managers,&equo; he sobbed, embracing the air. 
 &bquo;My managers!&equo; 
 Overcome with emotion, he led her out to meet some of the other prisoners in Algox' gilded cage: first, he mistily introduced her to a tall, thin nervy man with black brows knitted in a permanent frown. 
 His voice was tragic, the words bubbled out rapidly on top of a sigh. 
 &bquo;In a perfect world,&equo; he whispered, making little darting gestures with his hands, &bquo;everything would go smoothly, silently, on oiled wheels&hellip;.&equo; 
 His voice tailed away. 
 Apparently he had been devising procedural systems for years, but nobody used them and everybody laughed at him. 
 Now computers had been added to natural incompetence, and Cyril the Systems was on the edge of a nervous breakdown. 
 Jane met no more people then because there was a Meeting. 
 Life at Algox existed within a framework of Meetings (I go to Meetings, therefore I am). 
 Unfortunately, nothing sent her to sleep like the human voice, and, struggle as she might, she kept dropping off, then waking with a start. 
 She heard, as if from afar, the meeting-spiel: &bquo;Basically&hellip; at this point in time&hellip; credibility&hellip; rationalisation&hellip; realistic&hellip; restructuring&hellip; 
 I've got a lot of time for&hellip; personnel&hellip; track record&hellip;.&equo; 
 She became desperate to break into this institutional twaddle, so when asked what  she thought, she agreed enthusiastically, in order to keep them quiet and terminate the interminable. 
 As they rose, she noticed the man sitting next to her: ebullient, extrovert and coarse. 
 &bquo;Didn't you feel it?&equo; 
 He leered. 
 &bquo;Feel what?&equo; 
 &bquo;I was rubbing your leg.&equo; 
 Then he looked under the table, &bquo;Oh no &mdash; it was the table leg. 
 And there I was, rubbing away!! 
 But come, let me show you my office,&equo; he held out his hand, &bquo;Ray Shallows, Promotions Manager.&equo; 
 He had a loud metallic voice and a loud metallic laugh. 
 He was very assertive, but had nothing worth asserting. 
 They passed a line of doors to his particular pigeon-hole. 
 Jane was nearly knocked over by his aftershave, then noted all the details she would have expected: his exactly filled expensive/cheapo suit, his red tie and pocket handkerchief, his shiny shoes, the leather folded at an angle to form a point, the artificial orchids on his desk, and she remembered the untidy Bin and faded jeans with nostalgia. 
 He then showed her with great pride some utterly appalling objects which were used to persuade customers to buy their products. 
 Incentives, they were called. 
 Vases, ornaments, vanity cases &bquo;for the wife&equo; &mdash; all complete kitsch. 
 But this was Ray Shallows' kingdom and it was hard to escape from his flood of ecstasy. 
 By a supreme effort, however, Jane managed to remain polite, and to get away. 
 Now it was lunch time and she rushed out before anyone could ask her to join them. 
 A very straight military-type man was waiting for her when she reached her own pigeon-hole, which she shared with her assistant (off sick). 
 She almost expected him to salute. 
 &bquo;Evelyn's often off sick,&equo; he announced, &bquo;high-strung girl.&equo; 
 He took a deep breath before he spoke as if to keep himself calm. 
 &bquo;I'm Jim, supplies manager. 
 Office supplies. 
 What'll you be needing?&equo; 
 Jane mentioned a typewriter, paper, carbon &mdash; when asked for anything, Jim had a habit of drawing in his breath even more sharply, as if he'd been wounded. 
 He never said &bquo;yes&equo;, but &bquo;I'll see what can be done&equo; &mdash; and went off bravely, as if to battle. 
 At three o'clock she heard the banging of car doors. 
 Looking out, she saw men in suits getting into the medium-sized cars. 
 The large car was already gone. 
 These were the managers going home. 
 Then she realised why the meeting had dragged on, when the matter under discussion could  have been finalised in ten minutes: it was the morning's work. 
 Their days went like this: a) dictate letters b) meeting c) lunch d) sign letters e) go home. 
 Anything &mdash; or nothing &mdash; can be bloated into a full-time job. 
 That's Parkinson's Law. 
 The real workers &mdash; the producers &mdash; kept things going. 
 But a lot of &bquo;desk&equo; activity is invented to give people importance and provide them with something to do. 
 People like the managers. 
 Never was so little done by so many. 
 Jane found Algox the hardest job to bear of any that she'd ever had. 
 The church clock, slowly and deliberately striking seven in the morning, was like a knell to that day's death. 
 On Saturdays and Sundays she grew more sanguine, but the mood was dispersed on Monday morning with the prospect of enduring that place for another week &mdash; right through till Friday when all the managers wore tweeds. 
 Evelyn, her assistant, reappeared after her flu (she never had colds, only flu). 
 She had a white puffy panicky face and prominent eyes accentuated by pink eyeshadow. 
 Although she was scrawny, she still managed to have a double chin. 
 Her hair needed washing and her legwarmers were in concertinas round her ankles. 
 Jane found her an exhausting girl (she was twenty-six) and yet she was sorry for her. 
 Evelyn was just about the most self-deluded person she had ever met, a vociferous pseudo-feminist. 
 In fact, most of her energy went in talk (on an intellectual level, mind you) so she had very little left to use on work. 
 Women who talk a lot about independence are often the most dependent. 
 Evelyn was very voluble on the rights of women, was, she said, a Committed Feminist, yet Jane had never met anyone so utterly dependent. 
 But the contradiction had never, apparently, occurred to her. 
 She had trapped a fellow-student at Cambridge &mdash; &bquo;Brian had the longest  hair in college,&equo; she chirped admiringly, &bquo;and as soon as we'd graduated, we got married &mdash; for fun.&equo; 
 (Funny thing to do for fun, thought Jane.) 
 It was Evelyn's idea, as Jane had guessed. 
 Brian was so thoroughly weak that marriage to Evelyn, dire as it was, was better than no  framework to his life, since his working-class parents were children of a lesser god. 
 Evelyn was weak and yet strong, like bindweed. 
 Her incessant chatter was mainly of feminism, she referred pointedly to her &bquo;walk Person &equo;, yet when her typewriter went  wrong, she bleated: &bquo;Is there a man around?, 
 She was incapable of taking any action without seeking justification from her compliant husband. 
 But she ruled the roost: &bquo;I don't like the heat. 
 Poor Brian can never have the holiday he wants. 
 I am  awful, aren't I!&equo; 
 Yet if she was asked out, she exclaimed: &bquo;Oh &mdash; but I can't go without Brian!&equo; 
 Brian, his famous hair cut by now, used to fetch her dutifully every evening. 
 He walked with a peculiar goose step, though there was apparently nothing wrong with his legs. 
 Jane instinctively disliked anyone who marched or strutted. 
 She had never met anyone who expressed her opinions so convincingly and who was so unfailingly wrong about everything as Evelyn. 
 She absorbed influences around her indiscriminately, like blotting paper, and was so busy, strident and involved that she could never draw back to see things as they really were. 
 Her high-pitched voice, rapid speech and stabbing at the telephone betrayed her lack of balance and control. 
 She had already had one nervous breakdown, which was no doubt a great nuisance to everybody, and now she was heading for something worse: agoraphobia. 
 This enabled her to opt out of active life and become totally dependent. 
 Jane suspected that she had brought it on herself. 
 A psychotic person would  enjoy it. 
 Also, it was a way of holding Brian in an even tighter noose. 
 In a way, her departure was a relief. 
 Things going out of control had been the spice of life to Evelyn, but upset Jane, with her love of order. 
 Looking back, it seemed inevitable that Evelyn would go down with some sort of psychological trouble. 
 She had been continually up the spout, or over the moon, about someone or something. 
 Yet it was a pity, for she was not stupid, and could be friendly and generous. 
 But she could not, would not, control her emotions. 
 Jane's immediate boss was called Bertram Tinker. 
 &bquo;You'll like Bertie,&equo; Evelyn had promised her with characteristic misjudgement, &bquo;he's very with it&equo;. 
 Bertie was the director of publicity at Algox. 
 He had been Away on a Course when she first joined, and when she met him it was &mdash; as far as she was concerned &mdash; hate at first sight. 
 His pate was bald, encircled by a monk-like fringe of hair. 
 This he grew long and combed up, due north. 
 As compensation for not being  able to grow hair on his head, he achieved monstrously long sideboards. 
 His eyes were high, small close together and calculating. 
 He had no abilities, but made up for this drawback with sharp elbows. 
 He was a highly tuned machine for using people. 
 Like many untalented people, he was full of futile energy. 
 He constantly fiddled with that badge of office, a ready-made, multicoloured, bow tie, as he talked to Jane. 
 &bquo;Like most creative people,&equo; he said affectedly, &bquo;I'm very easily bored.&equo; 
 He was a non-starter, but didn't realise it and was excessively pleased with himself. 
 Organisations like Algox insulate such people from the world. 
 He liked to refer to his &bquo;abrasive&equo; personality and Jane noticed that his colleagues all gave in to him. 
 It was depressing that arrogance paid off so well. 
 But in truth he was a tatty little man with a furtive walk. 
 You have to get people out from behind their desks to see them clearly. 
 Algox prospered despite the ludicrous management. 
 Its wealth depended on the scientists who worked in a large lab behind the administrative block. 
 There was minimal communication between the two, but Jane breached the divide as &mdash; partly to get away from Evelyn's chatter, gossip and telephones, she took to working for part of each day in the scientific library. 
 She felt more at home with the scientists. 
 They were at an opposite pole from the self-important, vacuous management. 
 They wandered about, apparently aimlessly, in white coats. 
 The drinks machine was in the passage leading to the library and sometimes one or other of them would sit down for a break, and she found it a relief to talk to a real human being. 
 One such was Simon, whose vague manner concealed an agile and acute mind. 
 He was one of their most brilliant scientists, his research having led to some of Algox' bestselling products. 
 He was tall, thin, dark haired, slightly stooped, with a dry sense of humour &mdash; a pleasant change from the humourless ciphers in the other block. 
 He was as unable to bounce the ball of small talk as Jane, and had the quietness of a man absorbed in his thoughts. 
 He was under no illusion about the management types: &bquo;They act a part and in the end the part becomes them!&equo; 
 And he was totally unconscious of money.  
 He was unmarried and lived in a superlatively untidy one-room flat quite near the lab, to which he travelled by bicycle. 
 &bquo;I couldn't live in this mess if I had a woman,&equo; he said. 
 He found the research interesting, which was the only thing which made him stay, but the firm didn't own him. 
 Now and again he appeared in a new/secondhand tweed jacket or a new/old pair of shoes, duly noted by his companions who said: &bquo;Ah! 
 Simon's been down Oxfam again.&equo; 
 Talking to him gave Jane the idea (obvious, as most good ideas seem, once they're thought of) of producing a guide to the firm's products, loose-leaf for updating, to be distributed to doctors and clinics. 
 Simon thought it sensible and practical &bquo;which is more than can be said for most of their gimmicks, but&equo; he warned her, &bquo;if they like it they'll take it over as their own. 
 It's not so much what people are  that matters, as what they think  they are, and they&equo; &mdash; waving his hand towards the admin block, &bquo;are all on an ego trip.&equo; 
 Jane did not really care, and told Bertram &mdash; he was offended if you called him Bertie to his face &mdash; about it. 
 He paled slightly, was heavily non-committal and barked: &bquo;Thank you&equo;. 
 She was dismissed. 
 For the next few weeks she ploughed on, doing her normal writing, extolling the virtues of the firm's products. 
 Then one day, Evelyn came in waving what looked like a handsome dark green ring file. 
 Evelyn chatted to everyone. 
 &bquo;Good isn't it! 
 This is the plastic one. 
 They've got them in leather too &mdash; for special customers. 
 Bertie's idea!&equo; 
 And she slammed it down on the desk. 
 Jane gave nothing away. 
 &bquo;Never mind,&equo; she told herself, &bquo;keep in good terms with them. 
 It's their whole existence. 
 But it's only a tiny part of my life.&equo; 
 Simon said she should have put her idea into a memo for Bertie. 
 &bquo;What difference would it have made?&equo; 
 Jane shrugged. 
 &bquo;I'm not after promotion. 
 Nor more money. 
 I wouldn't get it anyway. 
 Let them play their games.&equo; 
 But then she was confronted with a game she could not play. 
 Bertie buzzed for her. 
 He greeted her with a thick-lipped smile. 
 &bquo;How about a spot of dinner tonight &mdash; and then back to my place &mdash; I've got a flat at &mdash;&equo; he named a nearby location. 
 She knew he had the proverbial wife and  two kids at Camberley. 
 He told enough boring stories about them and ended each office day with: &bquo;I must go or my children will be afraid I've got lost.&equo; 
 (If I were them, I'd be glad, thought Jane.) 
 But his domestic situation wouldn't have mattered if she had fancied him, but she didn't. 
 She pleaded a prior engagement. 
 &bquo;Next week?&equo; 
 She shook her head. 
 &bquo;Not ever?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 In obvious anger he dismissed her with a wave. 
 Two weeks passed during which she didn't see him. 
 Then she was summoned again. 
 &bquo;I want a word with you,&equo; he said, scowling. 
 &bquo;All right. 
 Choose your word.&equo; 
 &bquo;We're rationalising our staff. 
 I'm sorry, we're discontinuing the post of copy chief.&equo; 
 There was a pause, filled by the voice of a brand manager on the other side of the partition extolling the virtues of &bquo;our new product guide&equo; on the telephone. 
 Bertie felt the need to say something else. 
 &bquo;All the copywriting will be done by the agency.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're giving me the sack &mdash; Sir ?&equo; she said with contempt. 
 He wilted. 
 &bquo;Er &mdash; we have to discontinue your services &mdash; it's the cuts, you see. 
 Rationalisation.&equo; 
 &bquo;But it is  the sack, Sir , even though it's dressed up in fine words.&equo; 
 &bquo;Er &mdash; yes &mdash; I'm&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you&equo;, she interrupted, and left the room. 
 This was at once a problem and a happy release. 
 She could not bear the claustrophobia of the place, which magnified the smallest incidents or most trivial remarks into giant horrors. 
 Everybody over-reacted. 
 It was an infectious disease. 
 All businessmen are dull, whatever their age. 
 The rot of what they do invades their brains. 
 What Jane could never understand, looking back, was: if this was a successful example of British industry (Queen's Award for Export and all that), whatever could the unsuccessful ones be like?  
 Jane was in a state of high excitement. 
 She knew she had been dismissed from Algox because she had not been up for grabs. 
 She also knew that Bertie had been lying to her over &bquo;discontinuing&equo; the post. 
 She heard shortly after that they had appointed someone else. 
 She felt very strongly that now was the time to start a new phase, when at last her life would be her own. 
 For years, she had nurtured an ambition to set up a conservation centre and nature trail in the country; she would need a house and some land. 
 So, only three days after she had got the sack, she caught a train &mdash; drawn by a diesel called Peter Pan  &mdash; from Liverpool Street into Suffolk. 
 She said nothing to her family, she wanted it to be a surprise. 
 She left early, bought a day return, and sat back to enjoy the journey. 
 Her spirits rose as they left the ugliness of London behind. 
 It was September, when the days take a long time to wake up and the green of the trees is brushed with gold. 
 She had never been to Suffolk, but had chosen it because she had found out that property there was cheapest and the rates lowest, of all the counties within reach of London. 
 Her information came from a huge list &mdash; as thick as a book &mdash; published free by the Department of the Environment, which gave details of old and interesting properties (including lighthouses, watch towers and windmills) throughout England. 
 Just right for mad people like her. 
 This was 1983, when the Department of the Environment was still a helpful body. 
 The train was going slower now. 
 &bquo;Sorry for the delay but there's a preceding train in front,&equo; called the driver through  his intercom. 
 As they neared the little town the guard went through the train saying: &bquo;Move to the front &mdash; you've gotta look quick for the platform there, &bquo;cos there ain't much of it! 
 She alighted at the &bquo;unmanned&equo; station with its empty flowerbeds: it was one of those magic spring days in the midst of autumn and there was a tangy scent of wood in the air from the sawmill beside the railway line. 
 She took a taxi outside the station and the driver promptly launched into his life history: he had worked hard all his life for one of the big oil companies, inspecting petrol pumps all over Suffolk and had been made redundant in his early fifties with the very minimum of redundancy money. 
 So now he worked for a taxi firm. 
 He knew every lane in Suffolk. 
 The first house Jane looked at was moated and she was shown over by an ex-policeman who seemed happy to be working for an estate agent. 
 &bquo;Meet a better class of people!&equo; he said. 
 But the house was too remote. 
 The second, however, seemed ideal, and was cheaper, though unfortunately it only had a small section of moat left, which had been suburbanised into a rock garden. 
 The people who were selling it consisted of a very large woman, her parchment face frozen in a permanent &bquo;bad smell&equo; look, and a small man (like female and male spiders, thought Jane). 
 The woman showed her over, making clipped comments. 
 The place was full of antiques, exhibited rather than used. 
 Her husband appeared to have something wrong with him &mdash; he was shaking as if shell-shocked and propped himself up with a walking stick in his right hand. 
 Jane thought she'd better not offer to shake hands in case he let go of the stick and fell over. 
 The place was run down, but Jane decided on it because it was beautiful and a bargain. 
 Buddleias were growing out of the gutters and doves watched her stone-still, looking like part of the masonry. 
 The long grass of the front lawns was luminous with golden bars of sunlight. 
 Behind the house, the ground sloped down to the river and the waving tasselled heads of the rushes gleamed with a light that was between silver and gold. 
 A slice of original Suffolk! 
 Untouched for thirty years, ideal for a nature trail &mdash; the undisturbed habitat of birds and animals.  
 She asked the driver to take her to the estate agent. 
 He was interested in her decision. 
 &bquo;Those,&equo; he said significantly, &bquo;were the Pyglings.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes?&equo; 
 &bquo;Very well connected,&equo; he informed her. 
 &bquo;No doubt you know of them?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh no,&equo; said Jane, &bquo;I'm not connected at all.&equo; 
 She put in an offer to the oily estate agent and just caught a train to London, which was lucky, for there was not another for two hours. 
 She was in high spirits; the idea which had been growing in her with increasing, undeniable force was now going to become a reality. 
 She had never become acclimatised to city life. 
 She wanted to see a night sky unsullied by a red glare from the ground, to breathe air which did not turn one's nose into a sooty chimney; above all, to escape from thraldom and belong to herself. 
 It was more than a conscious and detailed decision: it was like a force of nature. 
 She would spin off, like a Texan tornado, and establish her centre of gravity in paradise! 
 This was an unfamiliar feeling. 
 Few outward things had occurred in her life to cause her happiness. 
 She still said nothing to her family when she got home, but the next day she put her London house on the market. 
 This meant a brush with solicitors &mdash; a strange breed, but at least not monotonous. 
 She turned away from the clinical whiteness of one successful firm with its forbidding elderly receptionist, to the old-fashioned chaos of another with its smell of coffee and everyone being informal and helpful. 
 But she was fascinated by their names: Cadge, Perks, Wily, Quarrell. 
 Did people with names like that automatically become solicitors? 
 Of course she sold her house at the wrong time. 
 If she'd waited another year she would have garnered twice the price, as the yuppie age was dawning, but unfortunately for herself and her family, Jane had no financial sense whatsoever, except, thanks perhaps to her Scottish ancestry, she always spent as little as possible. 
 (She was in exalted company. 
 &bquo;I wish,&equo; Mrs Marx had said, &bquo;that Karl could make  some capital, not just write about it.&equo;) 
 Still, it did not take long to sell, and as soon as people started to look over it, she told her family. 
 Hell comes unexpectedly. 
 You're full of apprehension, and it doesn't come. 
 You're sure everything will go  smoothly, and it suddenly hits you. 
 Jane's &bquo;good news&equo; died in her throat as she saw their faces. 
 They did not share her enthusiasm for peace and space and wide skies. 
 They were, after all, Londoners. 
 She had felt fortunate in being able to please herself where she lived. 
 She . 
 What about them ? 
 Why had she not consulted them? 
 They were grown up now, after all. 
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; I waited till you'd finished with your schools&hellip; her voice tailed off. 
 Her dream was their nightmare. 
 &bquo;You're whipping the rug from under our feet,&equo; she was told, &bquo;We'll be cut off from all our friends. 
 We've lived in the city all our lives and we don't want to be buried in the country, however nice the house. 
 And what about work? 
 We'd have a better chance to find reasonably paid jobs in London. 
 But now &mdash; where are we going to live? 
 And what about transport? 
 How are we going to get around?&equo; 
 (This latter point had  occurred to Jane, as a nagging worry.) 
 Her spirits had come down from the heights to the abyss. 
 She had to go through with it now, as she had exchanged contracts on the house. 
 How could she have been so blind? 
 She, who prided herself on her intelligence! 
 She realised with a shock what a mystery her children were to her, and what a mystery she must seem to them. 
 She had made the mistake of assuming they would think as she did. 
 But she had never really known them. 
 She had allowed her personality to get in the way. 
 It was not the first time, but it was the worst. 
 She had not wanted to impose her ideas on her family, nor run their lives for them. 
 Always, always, she came a cropper over people. 
 Of all her mistakes, this was the most gargantuan. 
 They were not selfish, and were genuinely sorry for her disappointment. 
 In the end it was decided that they'd &bquo;give it a go&equo;. 
 They would move in by Christmas and bring as many friends as they could. 
 And Jane would pay for everything.  
 Jane's family went away to stay with friends before moving day and she travelled down to Suffolk first to make the place habitable. 
 She felt she could never forgive herself, but when she got there, the beauty of the place overcame her again. 
 The weather smiled as though it could never frown. 
 A bunch of bright pink roses tapped the window, like a last gesture of summer. 
 She had hung up a Breughel pint, and the golden patterns on the wall brought it to life &mdash; the Elizabethan diamond panes casting shafts of light and designs which would have been impossible through a modern window. 
 Huge amber clouds &mdash; &bquo;symbols of a high romance&equo; &mdash; floated across a brilliant blue sky, and the sun went down dramatically with vertical shafts of crimson, fake flames behind the pine trees, the birds &mdash; many of them new to her &mdash; still shouting after dark. 
 Then she went for a walk. 
 She loved the night sky, brilliant with stars, which to her town dweller's eyes, seemed much nearer to earth here in East Anglia. 
 She found the stars companionable. 
 It would be lonely and awesome to be the only &bquo;heavenly body&equo;! 
 And to complete her new-found golden age, the bells rang out, for this was bell-ringing night in the nearby little town. 
 No matter what disasters in the world, no matter what the weather, the dedicated company of campanologists assembled every Wednesday night and the bells of the Norman tower rang out over the Suffolk fields, ceasing promptly at nine lest they should disturb the local population. 
 How much pleasanter they sounded, she thought, than the clang of old iron of the Catholic bells. 
  There were charming carillons on the Continent, but something dreadful seemed to happen to Catholic bells when they crossed the Channel. 
 These sounds and sights of East Anglia, she felt, would remain with her for the rest of her life. 
 But she hadn't reckoned with how the people would see her. 
 The remnants of feudalism still survived. 
 The new occupant of the only surviving manor house was a matter of extreme interest to the local population. 
 Jane was fond of history and old houses, but was not guilty of folie de grandeur . 
 Others, however, were. 
 Especially the &bquo;ancient&equo; family who had sold her the house and now, pathologically, could not forgive her for buying it, since they had lost caste by moving away &mdash; unfortunately for Jane, only a mile away. 
 Mrs Pygling, leader of the pack, was, as Jane had noticed, a lady large in size and personality. 
 (Jane could never imagine these upper class women making love at all). 
 Mrs Pyg lost no time in reappearing, her bulk accentuated by an excessively wide-shouldered coat. 
 She bore down on the surprised Jane like a galleon in full sail and demanded, imperiously, what she intended to &bquo;do&equo; with the house. 
 Jane restrained herself from inquiring what she  had done with it, for she sensed a field telegraph situation, so forced herself to be polite. 
 The ancestral lady was not, however, to be put off, and hardly a week went by when she did not telephone or call on some pretext, bringing her gardener in tow to take cuttings or dig up bulbs, and keeping up her barrage of accusing questions, inquiring, for instance, in her peremptory manner, what Jane was going to &bquo;do about&equo; the long-neglected yew hedge. 
 Mrs Pygling was, in fact, a lonely and embittered woman. 
 So often flawed vision results from people not having enough to occupy their minds. 
 Her husband was an invalid and she had but one friend, or rather, vassal, referred to jokingly by the local people as &bquo;yon auld witch&equo;. 
 The monkey connection was very apparent in this creature. 
 She was short and square, with a small head poked forward, long swinging arms and a bent-kneed running walk. 
 Her scrunched up face made her look as if she was wearing a perpetual mirthless grin. 
 No one knew how old she was, but she looked as though she was made of leather and would  last forever. 
 She had tremendous will-power, and the locals reckoned she would outlive everyone just to spite them, yet she was so senile she was practically imb  -senile! 
 Mrs Pygling sent her in to spy on Jane and she prowled about with a cordless telephone, through which she had to talk very loud, so that her cracked voice and cackling laugh could be heard in every corner of the estate. 
 It was as if she had a hot line to the Devil. 
 All this was so ludicrous that Jane could only laugh in disbelief, until, by accident, she found out the reason for the hostility of the erstwhile &bquo;noble&equo; family. 
 In the course of her research into the history of the house, she discovered that the male Pygling line had in fact died out, and that the present bearer of the hallowed name &mdash; the pathetic husband of the overbearing Mrs Pygling &mdash; came in fact through the female line and had adopted the name of Pygling. 
 No one is more vicious than a person who has something to hide, so this made their strange behaviour more understandable to Jane. 
 The fraud is always more menacing than the real thing. 
 The pitiable Mr Pygling, who jerked through the little town with a stick &mdash; it turned out he had Parkinson's disease &mdash; doffed his check cap to Jane and even held the door open for her when they ran into each other at a shop until  she opened the house to the public (having restored it sufficiently) on Sundays. 
 After that he cut her dead and let shop doors bang in her face. 
 After all, it cut across class. 
 She was a traitor. 
 It seemed that people were often worse than even Jane thought they could be. 
 On top of all this, her family arrived with their imports. 
 In the interim, she had become a bit &bquo;bolshie&equo;. 
 After all, she told herself in extenuation, this was the first thing she had ever  done to please herself&hellip; but , said a small voice &mdash; &bquo;but&equo; is surely the most miserable little word in the English language &mdash; but &hellip; they hadn't asked to come into this vale of tears&hellip;. 
 Her family she could stand, and even regarded some of them as having qualities superior to her own, arrogant as she knew she was. 
 A few things nettled her: she did not relish being a clearing house for family complaints, for instance, and was carefully reticent on such occasions. 
 But  their &bquo;friends!&equo;. 
 As luck would have it, a furious wind was blowing on the day of their arrival, by hired minibus. 
 A wind such as East Anglia only knows, cruel, &bquo;lazy&equo; (too lazy to go round you, going through  you instead), a wind which made the old ladies in the town say: &bquo;Oi've got me thermals on&equo;. 
 It was as if autumn could not wait to get rid of summer. 
 Jane found it cold, but her visitors found it freezing , so she turned up the thermostat to seventy. 
 She had just come in, having staggered round with the dogs, and she and they were covered with &bquo;sweethearts&equo; as the locals accurately called burrs &mdash; hard to get rid of. 
 She settled everybody round the fire, took them hot drinks, and then set to work on her sweet-hearted retriever with a comb, during which she got her guests into perspective. 
 Most conspicuous was a short, dark girl dressed in scarlet who had a big head, big eyes (her best feature), a big nose and a very big voice, which could be heard above all the other bleating, twanging, cackling, warbling, conspiratorial voices. 
 Jane withdrew, not her presence, but her mind, as a tortoise withdraws its head. 
 The owner of the loud voice was called Fatima, and although immature was no teenager, being twenty-seven years old. 
 She had come over from the east with her Arab mother, who, once in Britain, had married a stranger in order to stay &mdash; rather like buying a spare part to save one's life. 
 Fatima was lazy, stupid, self-centred and hysterical. 
 She shattered the opalesque, birdsong-studded peace with her unpleasant rasping voice for, like most people with awful voices, she used it constantly and loudly. 
 For unfortunately, very stupid people have the most to say. 
 She did everything loudly: loud sneeze, loud blowing of the nose, loud banging of doors when she was in a temper; she would march (she always marched) into the kitchen, clattering all the saucepan lids to see what was for supper, saying &bquo;brrr&equo; and turning up the heater, turning on the telly, tapping her foot to the music. 
 Without an audience she three-quarters died. 
 She needed to be the centre of attention and her clothes showed her love of display. 
 Everything was fancy; even her wellies were decorated. 
 She lived for occasions and would not miss one  for the world. 
 If something did not go right, such as missing a train &mdash; even if it was her own fault &mdash; she flew into a rage. 
 She could scream blue murder, but half an hour later would be the life of a dinner party, for she was very vain and never missed a chance to show herself off. 
 Unfortunately, some of the guests had arrived early, before she perked up with a smile, and witnessed the other side of the sweetness and light. 
 Fatima was very concerned about her health, but Jane was amused to note that there was nothing wrong with her lungs. 
 She would sleep till two in the afternoon, then come downstairs, very bright, very quick, ready for a meal. 
 She attacked her food with ferocity, using her fork like a harpoon, scraping noisily, then wiping the plate with her finger, which annoyed Jane intensely. 
 Her body was constantly on her mind. 
 &bquo;Ah!&equo; 
 She would cry, &bquo;the sun! 
 You can feel  the vitamins going into your body!&equo; 
 She was in her element with doctors, hospitals, osteopaths, chiropractors, acupuncture (health by a thousand pricks) and was never able to do very much because (she said) of her &bquo;small bones&equo;. 
 The final irony was when she took to psychology. 
 People who study psychology never seem able to apply it to real life. 
 Fatima was as insufferable as ever. 
 &bquo;She needs a course on child psychology,&equo; thought Jane, &bquo;to apply to herself. 
 But the neurotic person can never see him or herself, and wears everyone else out. 
 &bquo;The atmosphere here's as thick as mud,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I haven't said anything,&equo; said Jane. 
 &bquo;No that's the trouble: you don't  say anything&equo; &mdash; and she rushed out slamming the door. 
 She didn't like to be deprived of her drama. 
 &bquo;She could do with a bit of growing up,&equo; observed Davyd, the shrewd Welsh gardener. 
 &bquo;I suppose she can't help it,&equo; Alan, Jane's neighbour, philosophised, &bquo;it's all a matter of how the genes, or the DNA or whatever it is, falls. 
 One must try to see the good in her &mdash; but I must say, it's a hard job!&equo; 
 &bquo;When she behaves like a Sharina, she blames people's dislike of her on being a foreigner,&equo; sighed Jane. 
 But the fact remained that Fatima was a drag, and would drag everyone around down if you let her. 
 She had brought with her two friends, Giselle and Rodney, also prize idiots. 
 Incongruously, Giselle was a flabby girl (parents should  think!)  who couldn't screw the top of the coffee jar on straight, couldn't put the milk back in the fridge, couldn't shut the door. 
 But she could  reel out pages of verbal textbook at the mention of any subject. 
 She had a very good memory and had passed many exams on the strength of it. 
 In the end one dared not mention any topic at all. 
 She wore her knowledge like an ill-fitting coat. 
 She was brainy &mdash; that is, she had her head stuffed with facts, but she had neither the intelligence nor judgement to interpret their significance and relate them to the world. 
 In person she was gauche and jerky. 
 &bquo;Nice bit of fish,&equo; she remarked of one of Jane's painstaking recipes, &bquo;very tasty,&equo; and gobbled it up, holding her knife like a pencil. 
 She was only twenty-two, so had at least fifty years of boring other people before her. 
 Rodney was like a whirlwind and upset both people and animals (cats, dogs and horses do not like sudden movements). 
 He did everything at breakneck speed and was insatiably sociable, always turning up when Jane was particularly busy, crashing into the room and asking jauntily: &bquo;What's everyone doing? &equo; 
 Then crashing out, whistling. 
 He tried Jane's tenuous tolerance to the limit. 
 He had very little ability, but immense energy. 
 He was taut like a coiled spring, compact and pugnacious, both in physique and character. 
 He had taken a &bquo;Development&equo; course at the local university. 
 This was meant to prepare people to do useful work in the Third World. 
 Jane asked him whether he'd settled on anything yet. 
 &bquo;Yes!&equo; he cried proudly, &bquo;I've got a very exciting  job!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh?&equo; said Jane, South America and Africa looming before her. 
 &bquo;I'm going to work in Renaissance!&equo; 
 He proclaimed triumphantly, pulling himself up to his full five foot six inches, his face aglow. 
 &bquo;Renaissance?&equo; 
 &bquo;A whole-food shop!&equo; 
 It was unfortunately impossible to ignore the Renaissance Man. 
 He was banging non-stop around the house all day, bellowing &bquo;TELEPHONE&equo; when everyone could hear it ring, sitting at the piano without even looking at the keys, and making an excruciating racket. 
 He turned every conversation round to himself. 
 &bquo;If he tells me once more  that his parents met at midnight on Hallowe'en and live in a riverside pub which is his and his brother's &mdash; I don't know  what I'll do!&equo; thought Jane. 
 &bquo;As is only too obvious, he thinks he's charming. 
 Well, he'd better have another think.&equo; 
 This perennial pest was top of her list of people pollution. 
 Jane had had wide imaginings of everybody's abilities coming together to a common end, but fortunately she had kept her thoughts to herself. 
 Her elder son, who had done a conservation course, would have been warden, her elder daughter &mdash; a very good journalist &mdash; would do the publicity, her younger daughter, an artist and photographer, would design the field centre and set up exhibitions, and her younger son, an excellent communicator of great charm, would show the schoolchildren round. 
 She had never envisaged that they would all be solidly against it. 
 But she soon realised that they had come down to the manor only as a duty (perish the word!) and courtesy to her, and regarded the house as a white elephant, being too far away and too cold for weekend breaks. 
 And she had to admit they were right. 
 Yet another dream was dying. 
 Their departure was hastened by an abnormally cold winter: one shudderingly cold day succeeded another. 
 And then it snowed. 
 The dawn came up like a fire behind the white roofs. 
 Every leaf was picked out in golden radiance. 
 The sky was gold and blue in the east, purple in the west. 
 All sounds were muffled except the song of the birds and the pigeons were puffed up, looking as if they were wearing greatcoats, as they waited for the generous breakfast which they knew Jane would bring out to them. 
 But the others saw none of this: they were all in bed. 
 Jane would light the fire, turn the heating on, put the horses and donkey out and do the shopping. 
 The roads were all scrubbed clean by the frost and the snow. 
 When she got back they were getting up, having baths, shivering and grumbling. 
 She would be almost glad when they were gone &mdash; some of them at any rate. 
 Fatima had an emotional outburst and stormed out first with Giselle and the Renaissance Man in tow, taking all her sound and fury and phobias elsewhere, and everyone was profoundly relieved. 
 &bquo;And she shall make trouble wherever she goes,&equo; thought Jane. 
 Later she heard that her virulent hypochondria had turned into real illness. 
 Then the others thinned out, and there was the sort of  forced conversation which takes place when people are seeing each other off. 
 Jane was glad when it was over. 
 With her family she remained on excellent terms. 
 And then, when only the stalwart Rosamund was left, the weather suddenly changed. 
 They woke to one of those balmy days you get in midwinter when the frost has lost its grip and before the rains begin. 
 A day when &bquo;Winter, slumbering in the open air, Wears on his smiling face a dream of Spring!&equo;  
 Jane had not wanted them to stay against their will, and once they were gone, she plunged into work. 
 She'd got to paddle her own canoe, as she always had done. 
 &bquo;It's not what happens to you, but how you cope with it, that's important,&equo; she told herself, as she tackled the cobwebs in the lofty rooms. 
 If the pursuers of Robert the Bruce had been women, they'd have known that cobwebs come overnight. 
 She had an almost Germanic regard for order, and set about repairing the house, the stables, the outbuildings and conservatory with the willing and cheerful help of a small, dedicated band of local people, with whom she could relax and be herself, without putting up defences as she'd had to do with the false Pyglings. 
 The derelict gardens were rescued by Davyd, who had moved down from the mountains of Wales to the plains of East Anglia, but remained very Welsh, his accent giving authority to everything he said. 
 He was slow and deliberate in every way, from his voice to his walk. 
 Jane was reassured by the very look of him, with his long stride, his careful, unhurried rolling of a cigarette &mdash; his &bquo;thinking time&equo;. 
 He had developed co-operation with nature, and hence the economical use of time, to a fine art. 
 While others dashed about and fussed and worried, he achieved enviable results with the minimum of effort. 
 &bquo;Don't shake the tree: let the wind do the work.&equo; 
 He prefaced each pronouncement with an apologetic twitch of the head to the left, but lesser mortals hung on every word &mdash; and he knew it. 
 He was of farming stock, the product of many generations  of common sense. 
 He never drank till the evening, but then he indulged in beer and gossip. 
 He loved scandal and intrigue and made his contribution in low, conspiratorial tones. 
 But he was close about himself: he knew that where two or three are gathered together&hellip; what they don't know, they'll make up. 
 Drink never loosened his tongue, though it did have an effect on his sizable nose which, like Bardolph's, was a beacon in the dark. 
 He was slightly deaf and it was only natural that when Jane asked him if he liked Dylan Thomas, he replied: &bquo;Gin and tonic? 
 Yes &mdash; very much indeed&equo;. 
 Then there was Mervyn: tall, dark and monosyllabic, with a slow but sure sense of humour which had to circle through his brain. 
 &bquo;Huh!&equo; he would chuckle down his shirt several minutes later when the funny side struck him, long after everyone else had forgotten the joke. 
 His greeting was always the same (and would have been, Jane was sure, in the middle of an earthquake): &bquo;YOU AU ROIGHT?&equo; 
 Suffolk, having no Hardy, has an accent which is less well known, but no less unintelligible, than that of Wessex. 
 Suffolk people hiccup half their words away. 
 At first Jane could hardly understand a word Mervyn said, but he was too good-humoured to be offended. 
 He was a quiet man, so his sudden bellowed opinions made one jump. 
 &bquo;YER STILL IN YER NOITE KLASS THEN?&equo; 
 (To Jane's son, Jack, who found the manor cold after his London flat, so wore a dressing gown all the time). 
 &bquo;A'LL'AV A STANES BAER&equo; (Stone's beer.) 
 &bquo;THA KEAY'S UP MY &bquo;ASS&equo; (This startled Jane until she realised he was saying: &bquo;The key's at my house&equo;.) 
 &bquo;YER'LL'AV TA FILL YER CUPS LAOW&equo; (to two po-faced caravanners who were fussily clamping a magnetic spirit level onto their trailer in an unsuccessful attempt to get it to stand even &mdash; and to think caravans originated with gipsies!). 
 Mervyn had to repeat his observation three times before they understood, but he was determined that they should get the message. 
 Jane was cheered by his sagacity and quick eye for the ridiculous &mdash; a welcome change from pompous people like the Pyglings. 
 Mervyn liked best to work alone, in the open air, and was very observant. 
 He delighted in the blue tits which hung  upside down on the peanuts Jane put out, yet his job was killing chickens &mdash; just because there was no other work. 
 He grumbled all the time, but was really quite happy because he did not allow himself to worry. 
 Jane envied him, for she was beseiged by worries. 
 &bquo;Well, we've had a nice day and no one can take it away from us,&equo; he would remark contentedly. 
 Every day was like a hurdle in a steeplechase for her. 
 She fought through the days with relentless activity, aiming to get thoroughly tired, so that she could sleep. 
 She dreaded going to bed, because then several swords of Damocles quivered above her. 
 She must face up to facts: her original project of family co-operation had fallen through because of her misjudgement. 
 She had improved the property. 
 She had wanted to share the house for, after all, history belongs to everybody. 
 People enjoyed visiting it, so she enjoyed having them. 
 But it was not a source of income; it was a source of loss. 
 She was becoming increasingly despondent about the way things were going. 
 Despite hard work and iron determination, she had to admit she was nowhere near establishing a conservation centre on her own. 
 She was merely coping with one thing after another, not achieving. 
 She battled against depression, especially in the evening. 
 She told herself not to let negative thoughts take over, but, night after night, her will-power dissolved into helplessness, and when at last she slept, her past life rose before her like a grotesque apparition. 
 The beatings, the escapes, the fear which were still in her came out in her dreams. 
 We cannot eradicate what we have been through. 
 Eventually she would climb out of the deep pit of the subconscious, exhausted. 
 She felt, every morning, like wilting and recoiling. 
 She had hoped for a new freedom, but had found a trap. 
 She went to her doctor for sleeping pills and a tonic, though he himself was a better tonic than anything in a bottle. 
 The doctor, universally known as &bquo;Hubert&equo;, was rotund, but it was a jolly bouncing roundness, not like the disgusting pot-bellied men who don't know whether to wear their trousers above or below their pots. 
 The perfectly symmetrical large football was crowned by a smaller one:  his head. 
 And that in turn was crowned, incongruously, by a mop of unruly brown curls, giving him the appearance of an inflated schoolboy &mdash; Billy Bunter, in fact. 
 Hubert was a lone GP, and a very good one. 
 Partnership would have been unthinkable, for he was so expansive, both physically and in personality, that there was no room left for anyone else. 
 He had a deafening voice and a still more deafening laugh. 
 His consultations were conducted fortissimo and his guffaws echoed through the hall which was his waiting room, lined with an interested audience, and out into the street: &bquo;BEEN TO ITALY? 
 HAVE YOU? 
 AND HOW MANY BRONZED LATIN LOVERS DID YOU FIND, EH?&equo; 
 The waiting patients pricked their ears and tried not to smile and then the surgery door would burst open and eject&hellip; a little old lady, pink with pleasure! 
 While Hubert roared: &bquo; Next !&equo; 
 There was nothing clinical about his surgery. 
 Under his large untidy desk he would keep several bottles of champagne, and on the shelves above were lines of very explicit African phallic carvings. 
 People would stare and look away, but he didn't let them off with that. 
 &bquo;GOOD, AREN'T THEY!&equo; he would roar, and take one down, pushing it under the nose of the confused patient, &bquo;MARVELLOUS WORKMANSHIP!&equo; 
 He was the kindest, most generous of men, and spread great happiness (Jane had only to think of him to cheer herself up) &mdash; but was himself a tragic figure, tied to a wife he did not love. 
 She was a small, emaciated mouse who wore a perpetually martyred expression. 
 She was often ill, and Hubert spared no effort to make her well again. 
 He was an ebullient, larger than life denial of all that was Right: he chain-smoked and drank too much. 
 He had discovered that you were allowed to be drunk in charge of a boat, so he pub-crawled on the river. 
 &bquo;It's great,&equo; he said, &bquo;to have an obsession &mdash; keeps me going!&equo; 
 Jane accompanied him on one of his forays one evening. 
 The whole world must have known that Hubert was on the river. 
 He hailed everyone. 
 He saluted a little man in tight trousers and a yachting cap, standing by a boat pulled up on the bank. 
 &bquo;The River Rat!&equo; he boomed, laughing heartily at his own joke, &bquo;never takes his hat off because he's BALD and never  puts his boat in the river because he CAN'T SAIL!&equo; 
 Later, when he and even his customary buttonhole of Michaelmas daisies were drooping, he confided his deep despair. 
 He did not hint, but was characteristically outspoken. 
 &bquo;I had to work my way through medical school,&equo; he told her. 
 &bquo;In the vacs I loaded fish at Yarmouth and we lived on fish and chips. 
 That's why I'm so fat. 
 Soon after I qualified I got married &mdash; knew it was a mistake straight away. 
 Not poor Lena's fault; my fault. 
 And soon after that  I was ill &mdash; something with the liver &mdash; and went to Italy to recuperate &mdash; by myself. 
 And I had the most divine young Italian girl to look after me. 
 In fact she did everything  for me. 
 It was the happiest time of my life. 
 Then I had to come back &mdash; and into this &mdash; and do you know &mdash;&equo; (he leant towards her) &bquo;even now I close my eyes and think of her, otherwise I can't make love &mdash;&equo; He was still living on that charmed island of experience in the past. 
 His present life was, and would be, making the best of things. 
 He had been hurt so much by life that he had to laugh at it and there was not a trace of bitterness in him. 
 But Jane was profoundly sad.  
 The apparent peace of the countryside disguises great activity and relentless watchfulness. 
 Nothing you do goes unnoticed, especially if you live in a big house, as Jane discovered to her cost. 
 And even if you keep &bquo;yourself to yourself, you cannot escape. 
 You become the source of endless speculation. 
 This insatiable hunger to know other people's business alarmed her, for she was the least inquisitive of mortals. 
 In the fight to make ends meet, she was obliged to surround herself with people. 
 She ran a caravan site and rented out grazing and stables at the lowest rate in the neighbourhood &mdash; naturally! 
 First to take advantage of this were Les Nouveaux, who, because of Jane's foolish undercharging, had plenty of money left to transform themselves overnight  into Horsey People. 
 First on the scene, a showy horse, a Palomino &mdash; the locals called it the cardboard horse. 
 Then, expensive accessories of dazzling fluorescence. 
 Pink riding hats, turquoise waistcoats, stetsons (Jane just stopped herself from asking where the corks were) and they wore all these glories even when they were mucking out. 
 This modern Jorrocks, who wore earrings, was an uncouth, awkward man, with an ungainly walk, rowing himself along with his arms. 
 The Potter's hand certainly slipped when it made him. 
 He was a truly gruesome sight on a horse. 
 A good rider, like a good ballet dancer, needs to be the right shape. 
 About a week after he had taken the stable, a Land Rover swept round the drive at high speed and disgorged its chamber of horrors &mdash; his family. 
 Le Nouveau had part traded in his mere Ford for this summit  of status symbols, which gave him a new occupation. 
 With their male love of machines, he and his friends (especially rounded up for the occasion) spent hours tinkering with it, heads down in worship under the bonnet. 
 Jane could not get worked up about any car. 
 She was glad she had not got one; it wasn't worth the trauma. 
 To her it was just a means of getting from A to B, but she welcomed its invention because it lessened cruelty to horses. 
 Jane had also done up and let the cottage at a low rent. 
 Cottage dwellers were either authentic or immigrant &mdash; but mostly the latter. 
 Local people on the whole preferred a modern bungalow to a picturesque cottage. 
 So Jane's tenant, Alan, was an immigrant from the Home Counties, but like Les Nouveaux (who were locals, though originally non-horsey) he lost no time in countryfying himself. 
 In his case, it was a farming image, though he was incapable of cultivating the smallest back garden. 
 He had a head start, in that he was already a self-made eccentric. 
 He was the odd one out in a gifted family. 
 Yet he was endlessly intrigued with himself, and he decided early on that the only way he could make his mark was to be Decidedly Different. 
 Here he had much greater scope than in London's country. 
 Within days of moving up he assumed a Farmer Giles accent, extra-shapeless trousers (nothing is so sexless as an Englishman's trousers), broken boots (&bquo;They don't just let water in, they suck  it in,&equo; he said proudly), and most important, a bucket hat, of which he had a whole series. 
 His favourite was in bright print patchwork, and he wore it dead straight, one inch above his eyebrows. 
 Alan not only created himself, but also his own world in which to live. 
 On the walls of his &bquo;with-drawing&equo; room, as he called it, he had hung an important reminder, a notice carefully lettered by himself: &bquo;Stop doing, start thinking&equo;. 
 Jane found him a source of constant amusement. 
 &bquo;What is AIDS?&equo; he asked her one day. 
 &bquo;Is it some sort of insurance policy?&equo; 
 He was indeed another contender for &bquo;the wisest fool in Christendom&equo;. 
 The sight of him also had her in stitches. 
 To see him passing by the window in his bucket hat holding a slice of bread and butter in his hand like the Mad Hatter, then hitting his forehead with his palm and rushing back in again. 
 She had seen him in the little town  so immersed in looking up at the old buildings, that he ran into a lamppost. 
 He had a spot-on, though unconscious, sense of timing. 
 A serious discussion was taking place in the kitchen (the hub of the house). 
 In the middle of this solemn crisis, Alan burst in: &bquo;Have you a book on insect identification?&equo; &mdash; which effectively deflated the solemn mood. 
 He also had a soporific gift. 
 His voice was foggy and droning, and, once he got going, would not cease for hours unless drastic action was taken. 
 Jane often saw Mervyn beginning to fall asleep, defenceless against the monotonous sound. 
 But at least she could escape. 
 His family were a captive audience, especially at meal times, which were central to their day. 
 She had never put her own family into meal thraldom. 
 There had been a running buffet in the kitchen and they helped themselves when they were hungry, like gauchos on an Argentine estancia , but meals glued life together for Alan's family and he could be heard intoning, intoning, instructing, instructing in his foggy monotone with never a word in reply, until the children were able to &bquo;get down&equo;. 
 He was not without humour, but completely impervious to Jane's irony. 
 Lazy people develop great cunning in ways of getting by without working. 
 Staying in bed was &bquo;recharging one's batteries&equo;. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; said Jane one afternoon as he emerged for the first time, blinking in the sun, &bquo;how's life in Lotus land?&equo; 
 Alan shook his head and his jowls quivered. 
 &bquo;Not good &mdash; not good at all!&equo; 
 He was the Permanently Interrupted man, the man who, willy nilly, Got Involved, busying himself with trifles to avoid doing what really mattered. 
 &bquo;I've got to go to a Fatherhood Class,&equo; he told Jane gloomily. 
 &bquo;Dear me! 
 However has the world survived without Fatherhood Classes!&equo; she laughed. 
 &bquo;No number of classes or courses or theories about bringing up kids replaces common sense&equo;. 
 He did not reply, but got into the car glumly, with a martyred air. 
 His wife seemed dumb in both the American sense (undoubtedly) and the English (apparently, since she never spoke to anyone). 
 Alan, however, would now and again treat his audience of Jane, Davyd and Mervyn to purported nuggets of wisdom which she had uttered. 
 Her existence certainly saved him from making decisions: &bquo;I've got to consult my wife&equo; always let  him off the hook and annoyed the independent Jane. 
 Sometimes, however, he emerged wearing an unmistakably henpecked look, muttering something about having had to do some &bquo;domestic engineering&equo; &mdash; his name for housework. 
 With his wife, he had taken on a ready-made family for, although a Catholic, she was divorced, with two lolloping sons. 
 So he was either a man of great courage, or a great masochist. 
 The dividing line is thin. 
 Alan's only skill was in playing the system, and DHSS benefit pay days were always obvious as he was unrecognizable. 
 First he had to sustain the shock of getting up at eight am, then he had to wash and transform his carefully arranged untidy hair into real tidiness, for on this day, the bucket hat was taboo. 
 Then he would don his man-made fibre flared trousers of airforce blue and a clean, ironed shirt and drive into the neighbouring town for the opening of the office. 
 This four-weekly experience always sent him to bed with a migraine for the rest of the day. 
 Of course, he was forever the victim of circumstances. 
 He lived in a cocoon of self justification. 
 &bquo;Today's eccentrics are tomorrow's establishment,&equo; he would say. 
 Maybe, but born, not intentional ones. 
 Jane prospected for conservation help. 
 The District Council actively opposed her plans. 
 The County Council were sympathetic. 
 A nature trail was needed, they said, it would certainly benefit the community, they said, but  (that sad little word again) they could not help because of the cuts. 
 Locally, conservation was known about, but it appeared in some rather odd guises. 
 Two old ladies let half their garden go wild and put up a notice &bquo;Conservation Area&equo;. 
 The conservation corps of the YTS were clearing a nearby churchyard, and every lunchtime, the foreman pulled out an armchair which he kept in the church specially for the purpose, and had an hour's sleep in the churchyard. 
 Jane thought she had gained the co-operation of a local ornithologist. 
 He had a limp, walked round importantly with a stick and talked big, blinding her with science. 
 He chose a site for an aviary and gave very exact and imperious directions as to the materials and measurements. 
 He could not help, because he had a limp. 
 The aviary was  for injured birds before releasing them into the wild. 
 Then, when it was all ready and Jane was several hundred pounds poorer, he backed out arrogantly and without apology, making the excuse that his game leg was playing him up. 
 He had turned out to be a lame duck and limped out of her life. 
 Then there was the very earnest, dedicated &bquo;alternative&equo; coterie, with a &bquo;no smoking&equo; sign on their front door. 
 The leader of the clan was Erica, half German and a dedicated do-gooder who always greeted Jane with an unnerving &bquo;How are  you, Jane?&equo; delivered with a look of such worried concern that Jane felt there ought, or must, be something wrong with her. 
 Erica was a born teacher. 
 She taught all  the time. 
 Her conversations, especially with the children, became lessons, and remembering the way she had &bquo;brought up&equo; her children &mdash; she made Jane feel disturbingly inadequate. 
 She kept bees in Jane's orchard and would appear regularly swathed in black net with her eleven-year-old son in tow. 
 One hot day, Jane was gardening on the other side of the hedge and one of the bees stung her on the head. 
 She rushed indoors, using her choicest language, not realising that Erica was in the orchard. 
 With German tenacity she followed Jane in and explained: &bquo;They're working very hard and become angry if anyone gets in their way&equo;. 
 Small comfort for Jane. 
 But Erica, with all her virtue, was a dangerous woman. 
 She was a great roper-inner, and Jane, having some land, became a prime target. 
 It's hard to refuse a neighbour, as you have to go on living near them, so she agreed to lend the front lawns for a folklore festival, attended by &bquo;ethnic&equo; people with flowing skirts and hair. 
 They imported bales of straw to sit on, and a recalcitrant mess of straw had to be raked up after their departure. 
 But that was nothing compared with what was to follow. 
 In her insistent way she asked Jane for the loan of a field in which to hold a charity fair. 
 It meant moving horses, but Jane agreed. 
 Soon, one field was not enough, and the request &bquo;all in a good cause&equo; &mdash; spread to Jane's two other fields, so the horses, most of which did not belong to her, had to be moved to a farm, and she had to cope with angry owners. 
 But she was really deep in it now. 
 &bquo;You shouldn't give these people an inch,&equo;  Davyd had warned her. 
 The hippies, of Stonehenge fame, moved in, and parked on Council land, making a mess. 
 Extra police were called in, and Jane was held responsible for everything. 
 Angry letters appeared in the local paper. 
 &bquo;I won't let my wife and daughter look out of the window,&equo; wrote an irate resident &mdash; because the &bquo;travellers&equo; were peeing against the trees (1985 &mdash; or 1885?). 
 A fussy neighbour broke his collar bone building barricades against the hippies. 
 But the local publican told Jane that these maligned outsiders behaved much better than drunk Councillors. 
 At long last, it was all over, and Jane was glad to hear that people, and especially children, had at least enjoyed themselves. 
 There was one incident however that, even with hindsight, she could not laugh at. 
 Erica herself was entirely honest, and worked hard for her causes, but the same could not be said of some of her associates. 
 There was a very affected couple, Erwin and Pam, who were expert at creaming off the best for themselves &mdash; and as they were in their mid-thirties, they had had time for some practice. 
 They were a sham in every detail, from their studied breezy tones to their carefully casual clothes. 
 Jane was horrified when Erwin drove up in a Land Rover which had been given to the charity by a large company, and which he had appropriated. 
 Posters for the fair still adorned its sides. 
 &bquo;Shouldn't that be in Africa by now?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Oh it's no good for Africa because it's petrol. 
 They need diesel!&equo; he replied with his &bquo;winning&equo; smile. 
 He had unashamedly pinched it. 
 Moreover, he was just back from holiday in France. 
 He and Pam had taken off on the very day the fair ended &mdash; a fact that did not go unnoticed by the locals. 
 Jane found solace in the humour and support of the local people: Davyd, Meryvn, the clever Henry, aged sixty-eight but very spry, who had run away to sea at fifteen, and did everything so well and systematically &mdash; shipshape, in fact. 
 He could solve every practical problem, and made Jane some superlative furniture, just out of odd pieces of wood which were lying about the estate. 
 &bquo;You could have been a great cabinet maker,&equo; she told him. 
 &bquo;It's too late now,&equo; he said. 
 It was so sad. 
 He was a prime example of self-disparagement. 
 The trouble was that they got married too  young and had too many children. 
 Henry had eight. 
 One of them, Neil, could &mdash; like his father &mdash; turn his hand to anything, and also had the same sense of humour, which nothing could quench. 
 He would pitch a dead tree over the front fence. 
 &bquo;Let the Council clear it up,&equo; he said, and doubled up in silent mirth at the thought of flouting authority. 
 He had a happy turn of phrase. 
 A car going up a dead end at speed was &bquo;going nowhere fast&equo;; a &bquo;cock and bull story&equo; was more often, in his opinion, a &bquo;hen and cow story&equo;. 
 His observations were concise and to the point: &bquo;The Ministry of Agriculture wants feral minks to hang up in its pests display. 
 We could hang up a few politicians too., &bquo;There's that farmer who used a plough with horses. 
 First time he got on a tractor &mdash; when he reached the end of the field he shouted &bquo;Whoa!&equo;&equo; 
 Tim the blacksmith was another true friend to Jane. 
 He shared her natural ability to understand horses, her insight into how their minds worked. 
 And she had rarely met anyone with a sharper eye, or a truer judgement on people. 
 He brought his considerable intelligence to bear on the tiny village where he lived. 
 Not that he was unconscious of his sagacity. 
 He loved to tell stories of how he had given advice, how it had been disregarded, and how he had been proved right. 
 But he told them in a straightforward way. 
 There was no arrogance in him. 
 If Tim had been Czar of Russia he'd have made a better job of it than the nincompoops that were. 
 Yet he had never been further from his native village than the horse and carriage festival forty miles away, where he competed every year. 
 After all, Bach never set a foot outside Germany, but he has the universe in his music. 
 The difference is in kind, but not in degree.  
 Having drawn a blank with the local councils, and having been used instead of helped by nearby &bquo;conservationists&equo;, Jane now wrote dozens of letters to banks, charities, environmental societies, corporations, official bodies, in search of sponsorship, or even a loan. 
 But there was no money in conservation as far as the business people were concerned and the charities and voluntary bodies were well-meaning but lacked resources. 
 Even the government bodies were starved of money. 
 So the field centre and nature trail were not to be. 
 And without them, there was no point in keeping the house. 
 It was too big and expensive to run. 
 However hard she worked, she could not run the conservation projects on her own, and she could not afford to employ any qualified person. 
 The only answer was to sell. 
 She had few regrets in leaving the house. 
 She had not been able to come to terms with her &bquo;public position&equo;. 
 She was inherently an observer, and in order to observe you have to be incognito. 
 But she was &bquo;known&equo;. 
 It clung to her as surely as her shadow. 
 And the little town was rich ground for observation. 
 London had been too crowded, and the suburbs too typecast. 
 Here, individuals stood out in sharp focus and Jane's walks were always enlivened by the indomitable characters she saw and the wry humour of the remarks she overheard. 
 Age was the great enemy to be laughed away. 
 An old man came out of the baker's and his young dog greeted him. 
 A girl ran out with his buns which he'd forgotten. 
 &bquo;Don't ever get old,&equo; he said to Jane. 
 &bquo;Enjoy life  while you're young,&equo; said a man to a woman sitting on a bench. 
 &bquo;I'm going to!&equo; 
 They were both about eighty. 
 &bquo;Happy days!&equo; another octogenarian greeted her. 
 When he got out of the shop she saw that he could hardly walk. 
 Then there was Whistler, who strode doggedly on in a frayed tweed overcoat, summer and winter, always with his head down as if he were in the teeth of a gale, shrilly whistling &mdash; in perfect tune &mdash; a repertoire which extended from old music hall to Elgar. 
 People shouted requests to him: &bquo;Give us Britannia Rules the Waves , Whistler!&equo; 
 Jane caught the little town just before it was &bquo;improved&equo; and standardised. 
 There was still an old-fashioned fishmongers where they wore caps and wellies, as if the river ran just at the back of the shop. 
 There was an exclusive feeling of community. 
 &bquo;Tea for Posty!&equo; the baker would shout to the back of the shop. 
 (In France there would have been more of a flourish: &bquo;Monsieur le Facteur&equo;.) 
 Outsiders were frowned on. 
 &bquo;They're foreigners &mdash; they come from Bury St Edmunds!&equo; 
 It was muttered darkly about the vegetable stall in the market. 
 Christmas was acknowledged in various ways. 
 The butcher &mdash; a distinguished-looking man who could have served as a model for Mr Micawber and had, also, his turn of phrase. 
 &bquo;The atmospheric conditions are not exactly propitious&equo; &mdash; wore a bright red cloth cap from December 22nd. 
 His elderly assistant, a tiny Tyrolean hat with a feather (he had been to Austria for nine guineas in 1956), and the rather poker-faced greengrocer lady sported a tinsel crown. 
 &bquo;Ah nearly sobered up on Boxing Day, but ah caught it just in time,&equo; a doleful customer told her. 
 Whistler stuck red and green feathers into his cloth cap and then forgot to take them off. 
 Not all the old cottages were inhabited by &bquo;escapees&equo;. 
 An exception was an early seventeenth-century black and white cottage (slightly askew, like the crooked man's in the nursery rhyme) which was the pride and joy of an old man who had lived there ever since anyone could remember. 
 He was so bent, that when you walked behind him, you could not see his head. 
 His black and white cat surveyed the world contentedly from the doorstep. 
 His two front windows were a permanent exhibition for the benefit of passers-by. 
  Sometimes his collection of gnomes would be on display, and every anniversary was commemorated by faded buff photographs and artefacts. 
 A royal occasion &mdash; such as the Queen Mother's birthday &mdash; caused the cottage to be decked with red, white and blue bunting. 
 The Post Office was a great centre for gossip as there was usually a queue there. 
 &bquo;Of course, he's got to have his tea now, they've just opened!&equo; 
 &bquo;Good people, you know, they give me money every four weeks.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lost weight? 
 Never! 
 What with all those steaks I get with the money they give me here!&equo; 
 It was in the Post Office that the Improvements started. 
 The appearance of a high-tech advertising board &mdash; red on black &mdash; caused some anger. 
 &bquo;Better if they paid for some more staff. 
 Millions of unemployed, and they spend money on useless things like that. 
 I reckon the Scots will get &bquo;em out, with the Poll Tax.&equo; 
 Next, queue-control bars appeared overnight. 
 &bquo;That's where you tether your horses,&equo; said the cleaner, with the unerring British humour which demolishes all absurdities. 
 Authority tries to make people uniform, categorizes them, gives them numbers; but Nature, with splendid abandon, persists in making them all different. 
 Jane's neighbour, Alfred, for instance, was reputedly a millionaire, having been successful in scrap and demolition. 
 His slippers were famous. 
 He was so fond of them that he'd stuck them together with Sellotape. 
 The Oxfam man took pity on him and brought him a pair from stock. 
 Then there was the ex-train guard who lost his job when the countryside lifelines &mdash; the local railways &mdash; were abolished. 
 He rejoiced in the name of Blossom, and continued to live in the converted station. 
 &bquo;My grandfather built it, my father ran it &mdash; and I had to dismantle it.&equo; 
 Blossom would have been a suitable name for the large oilman who arrived in a huge lorry to deliver the central heating oil. 
 The first time Jane saw him, he got out and proceeded to release some pigeons from a basket. 
 His other hobby was home-made wine. 
 After the delivery, he would always have a cup of tea. 
 He was so ample that he  completely filled one side of the table, and a heavenly smile suffused his round pink face as he said: &bquo;My favourite of all the wines is &mdash; rose petal.&equo; 
 He was also a thinking man, of opinions. 
 &bquo;The EEC time clock on the lorry means we can't do anyone a favour. 
 Stops you being human.&equo; 
 And &bquo;Why can't influential people like Mary Whitehouse back things that matter, like Greenpeace?&equo; 
 People everywhere thrive on gossip: the world has a village mentality. 
 Jane knew it was unfair to blame the place for her misfortunes. 
 And yet&hellip; the sun might shine, but it did not shine in her life. 
 Here she sat amidst all the beauty she had created &mdash; miserable as hell. 
 She had tried to fly over experience, to slough off all that unpleasant part of her life as a snake sloughs off its old skin, but always misery reasserted itself. 
 Dwelling on the past drags one down, she told herself &mdash; don't let it . 
 But still her mind looked back, of its own accord, to Lajos, the harpies of the women's magazine, Algox, and it seemed she had always been got at, and &bquo;they&equo; were still  getting at her. 
 She was dangerously near to self-pity. 
 But no. 
 Others &mdash; better people &mdash; had suffered much more. 
 &bquo;One's whole life is just a perpetual traffic between the grimness of reality and one's fleeting dream of happiness,&equo; Tchaikovsky had said, who had perished by being shopped by a forgotten grey jurist, who considered him a disgrace to the Legal Profession (because he was gay), Tchaikovsky having made a false start in law. 
 They ordered him to commit suicide by taking poison, and his 6th Symphony &mdash; the Path&eacute;tique &mdash; was his farewell. 
 Life's hard enough to bear if you're not  a genius. 
 Jane didn't know how he &mdash; or Mozart, Schubert, Monet, Van Gogh &mdash; had lived, let alone created. 
 And in a society ruled by money and false morals, these grey people still often win, in the ceaseless struggle between personal profit and the common good: the ignorant, illiterate, hypocritical Town Council, the blinkered planning officers, the successful local speculators (nicknamed the Mafia) who flew their own flag over their local headquarters, as if they were a private army &mdash; all the Holier than Thou brigade. 
 They were the enemy, not any foreign power.  
 Events, at last, seemed to be taking on a constructive momentum of their own. 
 That spring, Jane put the house on the market. 
 She went over the place with the country gent estate agent, who wore a check cap, cavalry twill trousers, had a limp handshake and permanently narrowed blue eyes. 
 She nearly slipped into a ditch and he pulled her out, giving her that &bquo;I'd like to fuck you&equo; look. 
 Back at the house he said: &bquo;We will now go into the cawsts&equo; &mdash; which were tremendous. 
 He was so stiff upper-lipped he could hardly speak. 
 It struck her that they made their money very easily. 
 She had to pay for the lavish colour brochure (the details of which contained many mistakes), she provided the historical background and ran her feet off showing people over: all they did was make appointments (underpaid girls did that) and yet she had to pay them thousands. 
 They even got the transparency of the house the wrong way round in their &bquo;Country Homes&equo; magazine, but their name and reputation insulated them against such elementary errors. 
 All estate agents ought to be called Spiders' Parlours. 
 But, having made up her mind, Jane was determined to sell, and didn't let the grass grow under her feet; in fact, the ground under her feet was bare! 
 At last &mdash; in March &mdash; it was sold and she was exhausted. 
 The winter, like her troubles, never seemed to end. 
 But the spring, when it came, was beautiful. 
 The air was full of petals. 
 Hawthorn, horse chestnut and cow parsley (which has one of the most wonderful scents in the world) were all out at the same time. 
 She awoke from worried dreams to  soothing, luminous mornings and the comfortable, reassuring cooing of the wood pigeon from deep in the foliage &mdash; &bquo;It's all right, you know&equo;. 
 Often she went out to see the sky complete, unfettered by any window-frame. 
 The sun, like a pearl through the mist, turned the cobwebs into jewelled tracery. 
 It was that moment when the owl was still calling and the day birds began to sing. 
 One was telling her to &bquo;cheer-up, cheer-up! 
 That was the thrush (&bquo;he sings each song twice over&equo;) and she could also recognise the thoughtful song of the robin, a loner like herself, the virtuoso blackbird (why had so few poems been written in praise of him?) and the starling, with its one sweet note on a flute. 
 Ring-doves like Chinese paintings with their fanned tails flew all around and resplendent pheasants rose from their nests. 
 But the morning faded into the light of common day and the sun was contending with a missle (mist/drizzle). 
 She shivered and turned to go in. 
 &bquo;East Anglia is one layer of clothes colder than the south,&equo; remarked Davyd who was getting out of his car, &bquo;but look &mdash;&equo; he pointed at the sky &mdash; and there was a rainbow &mdash; that magic circumference of the world. 
 Davyd's voice lowered confidentially. 
 &bquo;Seen your new neighbour yet?&equo; 
 He had asked her this before, apparently interested in such a meeting, but Jane had had to disappoint him. 
 She had not seen her nearest &bquo;big house&equo; neighbour, though she had been hearing about him for some time. 
 He was something of a mystery, which intrigued the locals. 
 He was more talked about than if he had been open and obvious. 
 &bquo;He keeps hisself to hisself,&equo; she was told several times, though Davyd, who always had superior knowledge, added &bquo;cut him in half and you'd find pure gold, all through.&equo; 
 He was evidently much more successful in the art of privacy than she had been. 
 Nevertheless, there were certain facts which he could not conceal. 
 He had bought the 1815 house four years previously, when it was a mere shell. 
 All the lead from the roof had been stolen by official vandals, and bushes were growing through the floor of the entrance hall. 
 It had been unoccupied since the war. 
 In the mid-thirties a very charming German gentleman, known as Herr  Knapp, had lived there, had participated in the local social life and charmed everybody. 
 From time to time he would visit his family in Germany and when he left in July 1939 everyone assumed he would return. 
 But he did not. 
 War was declared, and his real name was later revealed by the national press: Herr Ribbentrop. 
 He left behind a butler and a cellar full of the highest quality drink. 
 The butler, being a hospitable fellow, threw a huge party to which practically the whole population of the small town (then even smaller) was invited. 
 This was the &bquo;phoney war&equo; period and everyone drank to peace in a few weeks. 
 The butler then went in for breeding dogs which he kept in large wire enclosures. 
 One day he was found mysteriously dead in one of these enclosures, killed, not by the dogs, but by a human hand. 
 The murderer was never found. 
 The house proved unsaleable: first, because it was too big to run during the war; second, on account of its unfortunate recent history. 
 And then, later, because of its increasing dilapidation. 
 Nothing was done to arrest this by the local council, which had discretionary powers to do so. 
 They were quite content to let it fall down. 
 It became a sorry sight: a ghost of grandeur. 
 The outlines of its circular hall, the sweep of its symmetrical staircases (the banisters surviving because they were metal), the gallery and the great dome were still apparent. 
 Even the stables were in perfect balance. 
 In the eighteenth century it seemed impossible to build a barn without creating a work of art. 
 Now, no number of &bquo;top&equo; architects can create anything of beauty at all. 
 The real reason may lie in the clients: eighteenth century clients were men of taste and education, unlike the corporations of today. 
 Private societies and official bodies dedicated to preservation tut-tutted and said: &bquo;what a shame&equo; but did nothing. 
 It seemed a lost cause. 
 Locals predicted that it would be allowed to fall down and then the property developing Mafia would move in and build a housing estate on the fourteen acres, by means of a considerable backhander to the Council. 
 &bquo;Public interest&equo; (local jobs and executive homes) would be pleaded, though if caught in time, the house could have been converted into a dozen flats for local  people instead of second homes for outsiders, and the landscaped grounds adapted for the public benefit. 
 Then, suddenly, it was sold. 
 Highly professional renovators and restorers moved in and gradually the house resumed its former glory. 
 Curiosity ran high as to who this purchaser &mdash; obviously someone of wealth and taste &mdash; could be. 
 But the builders and craftsmen came from outside and talked to nobody. 
 Would it become a school? 
 A nursing home? 
 A conference centre? 
 Surely, it must have been bought by a company. 
 No clues. 
 Then a sighting was reported. 
 A dark man, hatless, in a dark overcoat, driving a BMW. 
 The builders and decorators moved out and he moved in. 
 Furniture vans arrived bearing the finest antiques (binoculars had been brought into use by now). 
 Then, secrecy shut down again. 
 The local postman reported that the name was Petrie &mdash; plain Mister. 
 The enigma took no part in local social life. 
 He called on nobody. 
 His telephone number was ex-directory. 
 He was in residence mainly only at weekends, but entertained no guests. 
 Sometimes classical music was heard. 
 Early on Monday mornings he would drive north. 
 That was all. 
 But speculation ran rife. 
 He was a diplomat, an arms dealer, a spy (he did look a bit foreign). 
 But no hard facts emerged to back up any theories. 
 Jane was amused by the energy of the unassuaged curiosity. 
 Of course, she was often questioned, but had no intention of intruding on privacy &mdash; a commodity which she herself prized so highly, and which she knew was difficult to attain. 
 The nights were still cold, and Jane lit a log fire in the evening. 
 At about nine pm one dark evening, a log fell out of the fire onto a floor cushion where the cat was washing herself. 
 Smoke billowed up. 
 Jane snatched the cat up (still obliviously and intently washing a leg she had forgotten) and threw some rugs on the cushion, then opened the windows. 
 But the smoke was rapidly seeping through again. 
 Fortunately she had a chaise longue which opened and was full of rugs which they used in the garden in the summer. 
 She whipped these out to try and smother the blaze, her eyes smarting with the smoke. 
 Suddenly she realised that another pair of hands was piling rugs on and a pair of feet  treading them down. 
 She looked up and saw through the smoke &mdash; Mr Petrie! 
 &bquo;Quick,&equo; he said, &bquo;get a wheelbarrow &mdash; a metal one &mdash; and a spade. 
 I'll see to this.&equo; 
 She rushed down the corridor, through the kitchen, out of the back door to the shed and ran back with the barrow and the spade clattering on top. 
 Mr Petrie deftly shovelled the smouldering contents of the cushion into the barrow and wheeled it out of the front door, round to the back of the house, and left it. 
 Jane met him at the front door. 
 &bquo;Thank you! 
 Would you like to come to the kitchen and wash?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll just go and check the front room first.&equo; 
 His voice was dry and calm. 
 He joined her in the kitchen, and she saw that the descriptions which had reached her through the field telegraph and by which she had recognised him, were accurate. 
 He was of middle height, well built, possibly in his mid-forties (though Jane was not much good on ages) with dark curly hair and slanting eyes which gave him a slightly Slavonic look, though there was not a trace of accent in his speech. 
 He was wearing a dark Russian-style overcoat. 
 &bquo;That foam rubber's lethal,&equo; he remarked as he washed his hands, &bquo;it will smoulder all night.&equo; 
 (He was right.) 
 Jane poured two whiskies which they both drank neat, at the kitchen table. 
 &bquo;Why did you not call the fire brigade?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;Because &mdash; living in a house like this &mdash; one's so public. 
 Everything's news. 
 They even reported a bonfire that went out of control in the local rag!&equo; 
 He nodded. 
 &bquo;I understand.&equo; 
 He finished his drink. 
 &bquo;I can't thank you enough &mdash;&equo; said Jane. 
 &bquo;Don't mention it. 
 I was just passing and saw the smoke.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lucky for me!&equo; said Jane. 
 He almost smiled, and took his leave. 
 She heard him drive off. 
 What a strange appearance! 
 And how perfectly timed &mdash; for her. 
 That, of all people, the most elusive one should suddenly materialise to help her. 
 She, who refused help swiftly and automatically as someone accustomed to live alone does. 
 But he had not even asked &mdash; she had found him a little unnerving. 
 He was dry and lacked spontaneity. 
 He had a hard edge to his voice. 
 Perhaps it was shyness. 
 However, he was certainly not cast in a common mould. 
 She had never met anyone like him before. 
 Pondering these matters, she went through to the front  room to clear up the mess.  
 With the sale of the manor off her mind, Jane set the wheels in motion to find somewhere small to live, and treated herself to many walks with the dogs &mdash; more carefree, perhaps, than she had ever been. 
 She felt a certain poignancy though. 
 She wanted to fix this countryside, in all its detail, in her mind's eye and never lose it. 
 She wanted to remember the colours &mdash; even on a morning when the old walls and stones were damp, with dark, rich colours after rain, and everything looked very clear in the waterlogged air, the trees etched in all their variety. 
 And the flowers &mdash; all miracles: first the aconites, with their Elizabethan collars, then the snowdrops, with green designs on each petal, the ubiquitous daisies, some with bright pink undersides which showed when they were closed, the plantains with their frou-frous. 
 Nature was a tireless artist. 
 In the walled garden, the foxglove boldly pointing skyward, like a cathedral spire. 
 Honesty, that confident, cheerful plant with its brave brilliant flowers and beautiful silver-gold glistening seeds, which grew where nothing else would. 
 And the cool, blue, soothing delphiniums: drink in their colour for peace! 
 Tulips like red satin which closed up &mdash; even in a vase &mdash; when it was pouring with rain. 
 Forget-me-nots (woody &mdash; the tall East Anglian variety) &mdash; like little bits of heaven, and golden rod &mdash; the last burst of sun. 
 And above all &mdash; literally &mdash; giant hogweed, symbol of survival. 
 She remembered the vetch, clover, wild roses, flowering grasses and blackberry flowers of early July. 
 And the  long-suffering elder, which always looks beautiful, graceful, however much you cut it, with its lacy plates held out to the sun. 
 Jane stopped the chainsaw-happy men from cutting down the trees. 
 There's a dreadful finality about cutting down a tree. 
 Like death. 
 She saved an old apple tree which the gale of 1987 had blown horizontal, but which sprouted again in the spring. 
 A lesson not to give up! 
 There were no conifer plantations growing in serried ranks (like battery hens) on Jane's land. 
 They grew unofficially, here and there, interspersed with beech &mdash; which shed its leaves like autumn in the spring, willows, the ballerinas of the forest in a permanent static pirouette, their white seeds drifting down in a slow shower against the blue sky, and the tireless gorse, the popping of its seeds breaking the silence of high summer. 
 Jane loved the serenity of green: the sun through leaves, and later, golden trees visually warming the chill air, with giant puffballs like fallen moons at her feet. 
 &bquo;You'd think,&equo; she said to herself, &bquo;that the larger the tree, the larger the seed, like eggs &mdash; but a chestnut is larger than an acorn., 
 One of the cats came to meet her in the wood and accompanied her back into the house. 
 Another leapt off the ironing-board where there was a warm blanket and both went with her into the sitting-room where they settled expectantly in front of the unlit fire. 
 Cats were a calming influence. 
 Unlike dogs, they had composure. 
 They were in control of life and never let it buffet them about. 
 They guarded their privacy jealously, and treated human beings as equals, yet responded to kindness and sympathy. 
 Once you gained their trust, they became affectionate when they were in the mood, and were capable of gratitude. 
 Jane had found that when she rescued a stray, Fluff: he displayed far more confidence in her than in anyone else. 
 He was a long-haired tabby she had found in the kitchen garden, old and nearly dead from starvation. 
 After he recovered, he took great care of his health, finding every ray of sunshine to sit in and when it rained, still resolutely taking the air, under the porch. 
 Nothing perturbed him, and he had a sphinx-like face, with amber eyes which seemed to look into your soul. 
 Later, Jane saved Titch, a black and white kitten who was going to be put down. 
 She was very nervous at first and  would not come out from behind the piano. 
 Then she disappeared, until Jane opened the airing cupboard and met the unblinking gaze of Fluff and Titch side by side on the blankets. 
 Fluff continued to look after Titch, and even when she grew and became Big Titch, she never forgot her first friend, and they shared a basket, though she persecuted everyone else &mdash; feline and human &mdash; giving them no peace until she fell asleep, having worn out herself and everyone else. 
 She was the Becky Sharp of the cat world. 
 Jane found animals a great prop to sanity. 
 They got on with their lives, didn't interfere, knew nothing of human quarrels, obeyed natural laws without any chicanery. 
 Each animal is an individual within the species &mdash; after all, each was a unique mixture of genes, the same as a human being. 
 Jane valued their presence, and their sounds, even the discordant ones, like the donkey's mournful honking &mdash; as though it had an amplifier &mdash; and the desperate strangled cry of the vixen. 
 And she enjoyed the humour: the comic dignity of goats, with their vacant, pale, wide-angle eyes (reminiscent of a well-known soap star), the retriever who collapsed in an untidy heap (dogs were becoming outcasts, like smokers) &mdash; in contrast to the neat pool of sleeping cat. 
 Exact Nature! which designs and makes both plants and animals so carefully &mdash; each animal with precisely the amount and type of intelligence it needs to survive &mdash; and then squanders them so carelessly. 
 Life, not lives. 
 It had been a gloomy day which suddenly burst into splendour in the evening, the clouds rising behind the fields in the setting sun like mountains (if only they had been!) and above, a darkening amethyst sky with &mdash; the finishing touch &mdash; a rose pink filigree disc of a moon foreshadowing the peace and perfection of a moonlit night. 
 As she walked, it seemed to Jane that the stars looked down, calmly and mockingly, at this speck in the universe, crawling with ants fighting each other. 
 Ants which were unimportant in the history of Earth: Earth which itself was unimportant in the context of the universe. 
 Many more ants would need to go up into space for them to see themselves in perspective. 
 Meanwhile they fought, in the name of the politics and  religions they had invented (inventions which divide, whereas art unites). 
 All through their brief history, the ants had got into the habit of deceiving themselves that there must be an Enemy. 
 It made them Feel big, boosted their egos. 
 There they were, crawling on one tiny planet, not knowing why they were there: all in the same boat &mdash; why did they need to defend themselves against each other? 
 Earth was littered with the corpses of those who had done no wrong, whereas those who caused great torment to others rarely got their deserts. 
 And they pillaged Earth because their lives were based not on co-operation with Nature, but on money. 
 One did not need to go up into space to see that Earth's resources should be used (though not used up) for all  its inhabitants. 
 It was on a moonless night, fortunately, that the little town held its firework display, the culmination of its week-long yearly carnival. 
 Once it was dark, Jane went out to sit on a low wall where she could have a good view. 
 Suddenly the dogs scampered off, and she saw them jumping up to greet a dark figure. 
 &bquo;Good evening,&equo; said a dry voice out of the gloom. 
 Mr Petrie! 
 He came and sat on the wall beside her, still dressed the same. 
 She wondered whether he had  any other clothes! 
 &bquo;I thought you only had one dog,&equo; he remarked, &bquo;the other one's invisible.&equo; 
 Jane had a tan whippet and a black retriever. 
 She laughed and wondered what she could say. 
 He wasn't an easy man to talk to. 
 &bquo;I didn't hear your car,&equo; she said, rather lamely. 
 &bquo;No &mdash; I walked over. 
 Oh&hellip; a better sort of fire this time, she said, as the sky was momentarily lit with pink and green light, punctuated by golden falling stars. 
 &bquo;Yes!&equo; he answered with a half laugh. 
 They watched in silence for a time. 
 She sensed that he had something to say to her. 
 At last he observed drily: &bquo;I understand you're selling.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have sold.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh. 
 Fixed on anywhere else yet?&equo; 
 &bquo;No &mdash; I'm still looking., 
 &bquo;I've had the stables converted into a cottage. 
 Thought you might like to have a look.&equo; 
 She was taken by surprise. 
 &bquo;Why yes &mdash; thank you &mdash; I would.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've had a rough ride here, haven't you? 
 One way  and another.&equo; 
 &bquo;Er &mdash; yes. 
 I sometimes feel I'm a magnet for trouble. 
 I must make  it happen to myself! 
 My fault.&equo; 
 &bquo;No perhaps you just lack judgement. 
 Trust people too much.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm also blind. 
 I always think I'm right.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sometimes you are.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not allowing shooting here, for instance.&equo; 
 &bquo;How did you know?&equo; she asked, startled. 
 &bquo;I know. 
 I don't allow it either. 
 They think we're mad. 
 People are willing to pay high for the privilege of killing,&equo; he said, grimly. 
 His hand closed over hers on the wall, and his voice was less dry, more relaxed. 
 &bquo;Never mind. 
 Fate does work things out, you know &mdash; but never in the way you expect.&equo; 
 And at that moment their feeling for each other made all previous connections irrelevant.  
 Christopher Petrie and Jane lived for a year as neighbours: he in the manor and she in the stables-converted cottage, which she made much cosier and more inviting than the manor &mdash; one reason perhaps why Christopher spent so much time there. 
 But it was not the only reason. 
 Visiting rights have the great advantage of being optional, not obligatory, so Christopher and Jane were only together because they wanted to be. 
 Jane had rationalised her past life: she was a loner; she was better alone. 
 It was a hedge against disappointment. 
 But now, unconsciously, her prejudices were being overturned. 
 She was beginning to acclimatise to not being alone, to look forward to seeing Christopher: to eating with him, listening to music with him, being silent with him, talking to him, walking with him, occasionally sleeping with him. 
 She took a lot of convincing: distrust was deeply ingrained in her, she dared not believe in good fortune; she was conditioned to thinking in terms of Lajos and adjustment took some time. 
 But the realisation gradually came unawares, that here was someone who was kind, generous and manly, who considered her &mdash; unthinkable after the everyone-for-himself world she had inhabited. 
 She did not expect him to be &bquo;faithful&equo;, but he was. 
 He was the opposite to Lajos: Hyperion to a satyr. 
 Before, she lived in negative, now in positive. 
 Would it last? 
 Yes &mdash; it deepened. 
 Her vision of life grew stronger. 
 She felt that nothing could destroy it now. 
 You can know everything about a person, and know them for years, and still be miles away from them. 
 Or you can know next to nothing and still be close. 
 Her central  happiness irradiated the rest of her life, from important happenings, down to her mood when she was doing trivial things. 
 She no longer woke up wondering why she was alive, wondering how she would get through the day. 
 I've got one life, she told herself: I refuse to be unhappy any more. 
 I've paid my debt in unhappiness. 
 I'm positive now, not merely Teflon. 
 Christopher was reserved: a fellow-loner. 
 He only opened out to her slowly. 
 She never pressed him and he appreciated that. 
 But Jane had always respected the privacy of others. 
 Like the visits themselves, the confidences were optional, not obligatory. 
 Obligation destroys all pleasure, all romance. 
 That's why marriage, or even a relationship when it becomes heavy, is a bad idea. 
 Brought up in the ethic of duty, this was hard for Jane to get used to, but when she broke out into the sunshine, it was all the more joyous, and she thanked God, or Nature, or Fate, or whatever power there is, that it had happened for her in her lifetime. 
 The greatest test, of course, were her family. 
 There came the brass tacks: how old was he? 
 Was he married? 
 How did he make his money? 
 When she said she did not know (which was true, for a long time) they did not believe her. 
 This was only natural as she had a reputation for secrecy. 
 But no, she told them, she would not be pigeon-holed. 
 They were not a couple. 
 Just friends. 
 Neighbours. 
 With visiting rights. 
 The whole basis of her life was different, becoming progressively transformed. 
 But ghosts from the past still intruded. 
 Sheer will-power cannot banish them. 
 Despite her determination to be happy, she still suffered from chaotic dreams, and quickly plunged into everyday activity to save herself from the terrors of her own mind. 
 Influenced by these dreams, beautiful mornings seemed to mock her waking despair, but once she had shaken herself free from their shades, sun, sky, trees and birds enveloped her like a benediction. 
 Christopher was fully aware of her transitional problems. 
 He wanted her to relax into happiness &mdash; physically, mentally, spiritually &mdash; but he knew it would take time. 
 There was never any need to explain things to him (even if she had wanted to). 
 Equally, it was impossible to hide  anything from him. 
 He was the most perceptive person she had ever met. 
 Regarding himself, one fact emerged, in a roundabout way and with a purpose. 
 They were sitting on the terrace outside her curved stables-cottage, watching the sun go down over Capability Brown's vista, uninterrupted because of the ha-ha (however did it get that name?) &mdash; and they were talking, over glasses of wine, about poetry. 
 He asked her whether she liked The Rubaiyat of Omar Khayyam . 
 &bquo;Yes! 
 When I'm reading it I feel you can't fault the philosophy. 
 It's foolproof, watertight, totally convincing. 
 Away from the poem, of course, I begin to have doubts &mdash; it's too  clear cut, too  perfect.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was thinking more about the pottery,&equo; said Christopher. 
 &bquo;The Pottery ?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; the passage about the Potter's shop with its clay population.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know.&equo; 
 &bquo;I read that when I was sixteen &mdash; and it had, well, an almost mystic effect on me.&equo; 
 This was the first time he had ever talked about himself, so she knew it must be very important and felt flattered that he was confiding in her. 
 &bquo;Such belief as I have &mdash; I see in those symbols.&equo; 
 Jane resolved to re-read the passage that evening. 
 He gave a half laugh. 
 &bquo;To cut a long story short &mdash; I became a potter.&equo; 
 &bquo;Still?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, yes. 
 I still enjoy doing it. 
 It concentrates the mind better than anything I know. 
 Concentration means lowering one's eyes from the past and the future &mdash; especially the future. 
 I'm thinking of setting up a kiln here, just for my own amusement.&equo; 
 &bquo;Great!&equo; 
 &bquo;But &mdash; I'm into it in a bigger way now.&equo; 
 He fumbled and brought out his wallet from an inner pocket, opened It and passed it to her. 
 There was a picture of an early nineteenth-century mill, with water in the foreground reflecting its reassuring squareness and symmetrical windows. 
 &bquo;My mill,&equo; he said, his face glowing akin to a blush. 
 He  carried a colour photograph of his mill in the same way that others carry their wives and children. 
 He volunteered some further information. 
 &bquo;It's in Cheshire. 
 I restored it. 
 We make ceramics there.&equo; 
 So that  was why he drove north early every Monday morning! 
 But he had not finished. 
 He still had not reached his point. 
 &bquo;We don't design everything ourselves. 
 I have some outside help. 
 Special people. 
 Particularly one lad in France.&equo; 
 Jane nodded, afraid to speak for fear of damming the flow. 
 &bquo;Anyway, I go over and see him now and again. 
 I'm due to go next week. 
 Wondered if you'd like to come?&equo; 
 &bquo;Love to.&equo; 
 She strove to keep her amazement and joy out of her voice, to be as laconic as he was also struggling to be. 
 He finished his wine and stood up. 
 It was almost dark. 
 &bquo;Good &mdash; early Tuesday morning then &mdash; we'll drive. 
 It's a nice trip. 
 That'll give you time to arrange about the animals?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes!&equo; 
 His matter of factness suddenly evaporated, and he took her in his arms and gave her a passionate kiss which said: &bquo;I'm glad you're coming.&equo; 
 Despite appearance, he was a man of impulse, not premeditation. 
 The way to the marvellous boy led through the flat, lush green pasturelands of western France, peopled with huge milk-white cows, and alternating with the serried rows of vines. 
 Here and there a creeper-covered country house with a pitched roof which the French dignified with the name of &bquo;ch&acirc;teau&equo;, here and there a little town with broad tree-lined avenues, the inevitable &bquo;Place Napol&eacute;on&equo;, and the lyc&eacute;e in a prime position. 
 They stopped at a roadside caf&eacute; for something to eat and were wished bon appetit , without a trace of sarcasm, by the lorry drivers. 
 Jane was not over-enamoured of the French: they were continually expressing themselves ( discuter , they called it) which was rather tiring, and she had less than happy memories of a French au pair . 
 Still, they had achieved a class system which was far less awkward and  agonised than our own. 
 And their country was not claustrophobic. 
 She could feel herself relaxing. 
 A lot has to do with one's travelling companion. 
 Christopher was quite at home. 
 He did not stick out like a sore thumb &mdash; the drawback of most Englishmen, and he spoke French fluently. 
 Their destination was an unfashionable part of France called Tarn et Garonne &mdash; gently rolling green hills and farmland. 
 Christopher made for his favourite restaurant in his favourite town &mdash; Agen. 
 It was early September so getting dark with the street lights already lit, and the restaurant stood under some arches. 
 He was given a great welcome by the waiters and Jane was introduced to the Ma&icirc;tre  in person. 
 Christopher had obviously been going there for some years. 
 He recommended a regional speciality and local wine &mdash; both delicious. 
 Jane could not even remember what her worries were. 
 She'd always had to have an imaginary life simultaneously, as the real one was inadequate. 
 Now the imaginary one was becoming the real one. 
 &bquo;They've a very fine church here,&equo; said Christopher, &bquo;painted in shades of gold. 
 Moorish influence. 
 We'll come back and see it.&equo; 
 They said little of importance during the meal, but Jane had the feeling that he was watching her, though in a kindly, not a critical way. 
 She longed to probe his mind. 
 She felt that here at last was a man who saw things clearly and saw them whole. 
 She also felt that, without realising it, she had become very set in her ways. 
 Rigid. 
 That had been to strengthen her for all the troubles and problems she'd had to deal with. 
 This was not so much an escape as a therapy. 
 Christopher's potter friend lived in a farmhouse and the nearest village was called Bourg de Visa. 
 He stopped at the P&acirc;tisserie  and emerged with an elegant box bearing the insignia of the French Federation of Master Bakers. 
 A miniature Fortnums in the remote French countryside! 
 &bquo;Thought I'd take them a cake,&equo; he remarked. 
 Jane wondered who &bquo;they&equo; referred to. 
 She'd soon see. 
 On the top of a steep rocky hill there appeared to be a fortress, with every window lit. 
 This was the farmhouse, with walls of stone, three feet thick. 
 Jane wondered what  attack the original inhabitants had been expecting. 
 English, perhaps? 
 They were greeted by the inspired potter &mdash; Francis in person, with a flood of effusive French. 
 He was thin, boyish (looking even younger than perhaps he was), maskless, full of joie de vivre . 
 The men embraced and Jane suddenly felt very foreign. 
 Then Francis turned and greeted her in perfect English. 
 So she wouldn't have to struggle on in her fractured French! 
 &bquo;I'm half English,&equo; Francis explained, &bquo;my father &mdash; &bquo;. 
 The fortress-farm was full of people, all young and wearing tattered jeans and T-shirts with &bquo;green&equo; slogans. 
 Apparently there was always a flood of people flowing through the farmhouse: friends, friends of friends, friends of friends of friends. 
 Francis took no notice of them, but led Christopher and Jane straight out to the kiln which was housed in a huge barn, with brown squirrels perching on the rafters. 
 Shelves lined the walls on which stood magical pots &mdash; organic, looking as if they'd grown rather than been made, with the colours of the trees, the earth and the sea merging in the glaze. 
 No formal, added, decoration. 
 Jane could understand Christopher's enthusiasm. 
 The kiln was very large, fine, up-to-date and valuable. 
 There were several potter's wheels. 
 A lazily good-looking young man with longish hair sat cross-legged at one. 
 &bquo;My brother Marc,&equo; introduced Francis. 
 &bquo;Marc with a &bquo;c&equo;&equo;, added the young man pointedly. 
 Older than Francis and a poseur, he smiled languidly. 
 &bquo;I'm just back from India,&equo; he announced importantly. 
 Back, complete with Buddhism and so on, thought Jane. 
 He sat cross-legged all over the place, even at the dinner table. 
 He had none of Francis' directness and none of his talent. 
 Francis was the driving force and wore himself out. 
 Didn't eat enough, nor sleep enough. 
 Marc was the one who hitched a lift. 
 The young people played tapes until late, and Christopher, Francis, Jane and Marc (cross-legged on the ground) sat on the terrace with wine. 
 A dark girl with long straight hair and a fringe, obviously pregnant, joined them and sat silently beside Marc. 
 Christopher and Francis were deep in conversation about pottery, speaking French. 
 Francis apologised to Jane: &bquo;French is faster, you can say more in  less time. 
 She was glad, however, being tired and not inclined to speak to anyone. 
 The girl addressed her once. 
 &bquo;You are English?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;I speak a little. 
 My name is Martine.&equo; 
 &bquo;And mine is Jane.&equo; 
 They relapsed into silence. 
 Marc seemed to be in a state of meditation. 
 The full moon now blazed down and the countryside looked limitless. 
 Jane dozed off, having travelled, eaten and wined. 
 She awoke to a matter which had crossed her mind. 
 Where would they sleep? 
 As she imagined, Christopher, characteristically, had not enlightened Francis as to their relationship. 
 Francis therefore showed her into his mother's bedroom &mdash; scattered jewellery and Chanel all covered in cobwebs, and Christopher, she presumed, occupied one of the rooms facing onto the semicircular gallery, which was now becoming covered by bodies in sleeping bags. 
 The pop tapes went on and on. 
 Jane put in ear plugs (she never travelled without them) and collapsed into bed exhausted. 
 At least the bedclothes were clean. 
 But her ear plugs were not impregnable and &mdash; the music having stopped at last &mdash; she did hear a tap on the door. 
 She opened it. 
 Christopher. 
 &bquo;Oh God!&equo; she thought, &bquo;the pattern. 
 Holiday abroad&hellip;. 
 But chided herself the next moment. 
 Christopher did not run to pattern. 
 She held the door open but he did not enter. 
 &bquo;This lot,&equo; he said, &bquo;will be blotto till midday. 
 I like the mornings. 
 I think you do too. 
 Shall we go for a walk?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes!&equo; 
 &bquo;Right &mdash; I'll come for you about seven.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good night.&equo; 
 She returned to bed and went out like a light. 
 The farmhouse by day looked even more like a fortress. 
 Grey and impregnable. 
 &bquo;Why did they build them on the top  of hills?&equo; she asked Christopher. 
 He shrugged. 
 &bquo;Mad. 
 You find the same thing in Yorkshire, here and there.&equo; 
 She discovered he had a Plan. 
 &bquo;The drawback to this place,&equo; he said, &bquo;is food &mdash; or lack of it. 
 Despite the French reputation for gastronomic prowess, none of these girls can cook. 
 If we want a decent meal, we'll have to do it ourselves. 
 Otherwise poor Francis, and he already has to feed the chickens and the cat, milk the goat, herd the sheep. 
 Nobody else lifts a finger. 
 So  &mdash; unless you want baked  beans (and I know I  don't) let's set to work.&equo; 
 They had crossed the dusty lane into an orchard. 
 There were masses of good apples on the ground, and Christopher produced two carrier bags. 
 &bquo;Apple pie,&equo; he said, and they set to work. 
 Jane was no great cook, and didn't even enjoy it, but she had brought up a family of four, so quickly got her bearings in the kitchen, which was off the main circular room. 
 In this room, below the gallery, stood the dining table with about twenty chairs and a large decorative closed stove on one side, all of which increased the impression of a castle with a baronial hall. 
 The kitchen had windows on three sides and the cat &mdash; only kitten-sized, though it was full grown &mdash; appeared. 
 Jane gave it a tin of meat which she had found plus &mdash; with great relief &mdash; the tin opener. 
 &bquo;They'll all wake up hungry,&equo; Christopher had said grimly, and went outside on the terrace with the carrier bags and a bowl to peel and core the apples in the early morning sunlight. 
 Jane was glad. 
 She preferred to be on her own in a kitchen. 
 She marshalled the troops: flour, sugar, eggs, milk, vanilla essence. 
 First, make the pies and put them in the oven. 
 No cream, but perhaps Francis could solve. 
 Then , she thought, having found a small canister of mild English curry powder, a vegetable curry, while the pies were doing. 
 She set about preparing the vegetables. 
 The flour was in an open sack on the floor. 
 All very primitive. 
 Like in a film. 
 Never mind. 
 L'esprit Anglais ! 
 By the time Christopher had peeled all the apples, she had the oven heating and the pastry rolled. 
 She made four big pies, and with the trimmed-off pastry designed some crude Picasso doves as decoration for the tops. 
 Meanwhile a huge cauldron of vegetables was simmering for the curry. 
 Francis was up by now and had tethered the goat &mdash; a huge brown animal with fearsome horns called Brunette. 
 He was the only one who could manage her. 
 Marc couldn't, even though he was bigger than Francis. 
 Christopher went with him to feed the chickens and let out the sheep which were used as &bquo;mowers&equo; for the steep lawns. 
 People were stirring now, yelling French in unison, splashing, exclaiming, swearing, someone put on a tape. 
 It was already 11.45. 
 Martine came into the kitchen. 
 &bquo;Can I  &bquo;elp you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes please, Martine &mdash; to set the table.&equo; 
 Martine was obviously a frequent visitor and knew where everything was kept. 
 She flung mats, knives, forks, spoons, salt and pepper containers onto the table. 
 Christopher and Francis appeared to announce that they were going down into Bourg to fetch some wine. 
 Christopher's BMW had become the farmhouse taxi. 
 Otherwise it was a tiny Citro&euml;n or a moped, both clapped out, and having to be run with at high speed down the hill and then jumped on with alacrity. 
 Getting to the village was always a highly dramatic event witnessed by a yelling, clapping audience. 
 Jane had decreed bowls rather than plates for the curry and spooned it out in the kitchen whence it was ferried by Christopher, Francis and Martine (Jane's mind darted back involuntarily to Puchero  and gauchos in Argentina). 
 But the next minute there were shrieks. 
 People covered their mouths in agony. 
 Jane had forgotten that the French have no connection with India and are therefore unacquainted&hellip;. 
 And it was only a mild  curry! 
 She felt rather riled. 
 It was all over-dramatised. 
 An unnecessary fuss. 
 Francis and Christopher dissolved in laughter, lapped theirs up and declared it very good. 
 Marc, sitting cross-legged, fresh from India, felt constrained to consume his. 
 The rest could go to hell! 
 There was noting else to eat. 
 Then the active ones cleared the plates from the jabbering throng and the pies were produced with many oos and aahs. 
 Cream had been purchased in Bourg. 
 The pudding went down like a dream, in blessed silence, and Christopher and Francis disappeared to brew coffee. 
 At the end Christopher took matters in hand and commanded Francis to instruct his guests that some of them must  volunteer to wash up. 
 The cook had done enough. 
 There were groans, but a reluctant few drifted to the kitchen. 
 &bquo; Leave them !&equo; 
 Christopher ordered Jane, so while he and Francis went to the pottery barn, she stretched out on the grass and the cat came and lay, purring, on top of her. 
 From a half doze Jane saw Christopher and Francis emerge from the barn, go to the kitchen and re-emerge with the sack of flour, which they took to the barn! 
 Was  it flour &mdash; or something they used in pottery? 
 Jane's mind writhed in  agony, but she said nothing. 
 Any damage that had been done, was done. 
 Nobody died. 
 Nobody even complained of stomach ache. 
 The explanation lay forever hidden in mystery. 
 It was warm for early September. 
 Francis, having concluded his business with Christopher, took command. 
 &bquo;Everyone to the river!&equo; he cried. 
 And they all seized their swimming trunks and towels and piled into the BMW. 
 Those who couldn't get in pushed the Citro&euml;n, and three managed to get onto the moped. 
 The river was clear and rushing and fringed by trees. 
 There was a bridge, and the village children were already jumping in from it. 
 Jane sat on the bank and marvelled at their courage. 
 She didn't swim and wasn't sure that she could , despite relentless tuition at school. 
 Christopher came and sat beside her. 
 &bquo;Am I stopping you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ugh no &mdash; I'm a fire sign &mdash; I hate water!&equo; 
 He believed in astrology. 
 &bquo;Thanks for the meal,&equo; he said, unbeknowing. 
 She shivered in horror. 
 &bquo;It made a real holiday for Francis. 
 He wears himself out with these people. 
 Unfortunately he's very gregarious. 
 Not to have a companion is for him like lacking a limb. 
 But it drains him &mdash; mentally and physically. 
 And he's so  gifted!&equo; 
 He lapsed into silence. 
 Jane had never heard him speak with such enthusiasm about anybody before. 
 It was getting chilly and the novelty of the river palled. 
 People were coming out, wrapping themselves in towels, shivering and complaining. 
 Time to go home. 
 Christopher did his bit by cramming about a dozen in his car, then, having dumped them, said to Jane with some asperity:. 
 &bquo;Let's get away from it all!&equo; 
 So they escaped down into the village. 
 There was the very up-market P&acirc;tisserie , a very down-market haberdashers which hadn't changed since the 1930s, and the priest playing boules with a friend in front of the church. 
 &bquo;How different &mdash;&equo; said Jane. 
 How different from England, she meant, and of course Christopher understood. 
 &bquo;Let's go on into Agen,&equo; he said. 
 This time they saw the church in all its Moorish exuberance. 
 &bquo;Francis had a pottery exhibition in the cloisters,&equo; said Christopher proudly. 
 And then &mdash; of course &mdash; back to the welcome and excellent food of the favourite restaurant. 
 &bquo;You deserve this,&equo; said Christopher raising his glass, &bquo;after  the lunch marathon! 
 &bquo;Do I?&equo; said Jane still a mite worried. 
 &bquo;Christopher,&equo; said Francis to Jane, who was helping him with the sheep the next morning, &bquo;has been like a father to me.&equo; 
 Jane pricked her ears. 
 Christopher was reticent about himself, especially his good points. 
 These she would learn of only through other people. 
 &bquo;My own father,&equo; Francis continued, &bquo;failed in business and drove himself over a cliff in full view of us all, five years ago. 
 Christopher knew him and came straight down. 
 Has never withdrawn his support since. 
 My brother ebbs and flows. 
 Just now, he's overboard for India. 
 When we were in England, at school, he was overboard for England. 
 Now  he's overboard for France, and spells his name with a &bquo;c&equo; instead of a &bquo;k&equo;. 
 Can you beat it! 
 So petty!&equo; 
 (Jane had deduced he was somewhat superficial.) 
 &bquo;My father went to English public school: so did we. 
 My mother, I'm afraid, went quite to pieces after his death. 
 She's with a boy our age &mdash; a toy boy &mdash; and though he deserts her for young girls and even beats her up &mdash; she's such a sucker for punishment, she goes back for more. 
 It's hard to understand people even &mdash; perhaps especially &mdash; one's own family. 
 But Father &mdash; an apparently unemotional Englishman &mdash; left the farmhouse to me and Mark only , so we have a roof. 
 Christopher, who was a friend of my father's, had the kiln brought here from my father's workplace miles away, and said he'd buy whatever I produced. 
 I love pottery &mdash; and so it's gone on. 
 But Christopher won't be thanked&hellip;. 
 &bquo;His name isn't really Christopher, you know. 
 It's Stefan &mdash; Stefan Petrovitch. 
 His parents were Ukrainian, and he was born in Germany. 
 He speaks five languages, but doesn't use them much &mdash; in speech, that is, though he reads a lot. 
 He talks more to me than anyone, I think. 
 But his actions are what count. 
 They're always good &mdash; and speak louder than hundreds of bloody words!&equo; 
 And that wasn't the only eye-opener which Jane had that day. 
 A little later Martine buttonholed her. 
 &bquo;Excuse me &mdash; I want to talk. 
 You are English &mdash; you don't belong here, so it's easier to talk to you. 
 You don't talk to anyone else &mdash; you don't know  anyone else. 
 Marc went to India six months ago, and before he went &mdash; I got  his baby. 
 Now I don't know what to do. 
 He has no money. 
 I can't work for much longer. 
 He says it's my business &mdash; he can't help. 
 And I am trapped. 
 But I want my baby to have a father &mdash;&equo; and she started to cry. 
 Jane was at a loss. 
 It was too late for an abortion, and as for Marc, she hardly knew him, and didn't much like what she knew. 
 She mentioned the matter to Christopher, who showed some anger. 
 &bquo;Useless bloke!&equo; he exclaimed, &bquo;use- less  to himself and everyone else. 
 And you know what will happen? 
 He'll move the girl in here, so Francis will be further burdened. 
 Francis &mdash; who's worth the whole of the rest of the family put together!&equo; 
 And, she knew, Christopher would help Francis. 
 The world seemed to consist of spongers like Marc, supporters like Christopher, and victims like Francis. 
 Sure enough, Martine did move in, and had two more kids, and the wild old farmhouse became a bourgeois habitat.  
 The fact that Christopher turned out to be an east European too hardly caused a ripple in Jane. 
 The two men were so different &mdash; opposites even: Lajos acting out his tragedy to the world Christopher-Stefan self-contained, self-reliant, intensely private, yet looking out rather than in. 
 And &mdash; not having a big ego to get in the way &mdash; viewing the world and its inhabitants with a penetrating intelligence. 
 No sham could take him in. 
 Just behind the estate which he had saved, the land had not been so lucky. 
 The developers and their henchmen, the Council, had tricked an old lady into parting with her cottage and twelve acres of &bquo;agricultural&equo; land at a knockdown price. 
 Planning permission was sought and granted at breakneck speed and the foundations were already being excavated for twenty-four executive-type four to five bedroom &bquo;dwelling units&equo; with two garages apiece but no gardens. 
 Asking price &mdash; around &pound;200,000. 
 Christopher swiftly arranged for a six foot wall to be built along his boundary, and angrily muttered that it was going to have to be the Scottish islands. 
 The government was lavishing money on roads instead of railways and the developers were cashing in on a projected &bquo;up-grading&equo; of the existing A road to a motorway, thus bringing Suffolk into the commuter zone. 
 &bquo;Your house will be worth a lot more now,&equo; people remarked brightly, which observation &mdash; if it brought forth a reply at all &mdash; was countered by a snapped: &bquo;I didn't buy it as an investment&equo;. 
 But mostly he responded with an angry grunt. 
 He had only bought the land to keep people away.  
 &bquo;Despite the wall, the atmosphere will change. 
 I shall become a refugee all over again.&equo; 
 Jane had never seen him so depressed, his anger frequently spilling over into words to her, as the dwellings went up with hideous and indecent haste, flaunting a flag: &bquo;Waterloo Homes&equo; right next to his drive. 
 &bquo;To come out all this way, to live in the country at immense cost! 
 And have a tiny back yard because otherwise they couldn't cram so many boxes onto the site. 
 &bquo;Country&equo; houses six feet from each other! 
 Might at well stay in town. 
 But the cars &mdash; ah! 
 God the Car &mdash; they're  catered for: one for the yuppie commuter and one for wifey at home.&equo; 
 Jane, who only rode a bicycle, fully concurred. 
 And yet felt uneasy. 
 He was so deeply disturbed! 
 She analysed her feelings and had to admit that she feared there was a danger of his leaving. 
 And she did not want him to go. 
 While all went well she could maintain a fine independence, but when the order threatened to change, she was more affected than she would have believed possible. 
 The unknown is always the most fearsome, opening out into wide areas of conjecture. 
 The new inhabitants would be zombies. 
 But would  they? 
 All of them? 
 Christopher hated them in advance. 
 He was away all week and now arrived back on Friday evenings in a ready-made bad mood. 
 The builders worked throughout the weekend, so with their hammering and concrete mixing and loud radios, it was impossible to ignore their presence. 
 Fuming, Christopher shut himself in the house. 
 There were no more relaxed, refreshing weekends. 
 About half the houses were now finished, the turfs laid, the flower beds cut, looking like fresh graves &mdash; all in the front, of course. 
 There was hardly room for a washing line in the back. 
 One weekday, braving the &bquo;Keep Out&equo; and &bquo;Guard Dogs&equo; notices, Jane took the dogs and invaded the pitch. 
 She had decided to have a look at the human face of the bogey, and there is nothing like a dog (the only animal which trusts humans!) for starting a conversation. 
 A slim, smart, but friendly woman was just getting out of her car and smiled at Jane. 
 She resembled Jackie Kennedy, but &mdash; surprisingly &mdash; had a strong Scottish accent. 
 &bquo;Would your dogs like some bones?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;I haven't a dog to give  them to at the moment. 
 Only a rabbit &mdash; Flopsy. 
 Come in and meet her.&equo; 
 The house was close-carpeted in turquoise, but there was some antique furniture, obviously passed down through the family. 
 A large lop-eared white rabbit was in a pen in the tiny back yard. 
 &bquo;She's having a run. 
 We bring her in at night. 
 We've had her for eight years.&equo; 
 &bquo;We&equo; turned out to be a husband who worked at the London HQ of an oil company and two children, a boy of twelve and a girl of fifteen, both at boarding school. 
 Mrs Fletcher was extremely chic, but her accent gave her a reality. 
 She was very hospitable, made Jane sit down, was friendly to the dogs, brought coffee, then sat down herself, obviously overjoyed to have found a neighbour. 
 &bquo;We've come from Weybridge,&equo; she said, &bquo;for the cleaner air.&equo; 
 (Now polluted by two extra cars, thought Jane), &bquo;but&equo; she went on, &bquo;originally from Scotland. 
 (As if that  wasn't obvious!) 
 &bquo;Orkney, in fact &mdash; my mother was the only schoolteacher there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Quite a change,&equo; said Jane, wondering what mother would have thought of this fashion plate. 
 &bquo;Alastair &mdash; my husband &mdash; is Scottish too, born and bred, like me. 
 I went to the school in Edinburgh where Miss Jean Brodie had her prime! 
 It's the job that dictates where we live now, I'm afraid. 
 Alastair is based in London, but goes abroad now and again. 
 He speaks Arabic.&equo; 
 Jane, as the nearest thing to a next-door neighbour, asked them to drinks that weekend. 
 She didn't dislike Flora, who wasn't as brittle as she seemed, and was knowing enough to play down her fashionable side to Jane. 
 She realised that this was not a woman to whom one chatted about shops or clothes. 
 Jane had not visited her on impulse, nor yet as a premeditated plan. 
 She was activated by something in between. 
 To show Christopher the human face of the dreaded development. 
 IF she could persuade him to come, which she doubted. 
 &bquo;Oh! the bones!&equo; said Flora, and brought them from the kitchen &mdash; in a Harrods' bag. 
 Jane dreaded broaching the subject to Christopher. 
 He'd think. 
 Oh! 
 Becoming suburbanised, are we!&equo; 
 But it was easier than she expected. 
 &bquo;Oh yes, Alastair Fletcher &mdash; Scottish bloke.&equo; 
 &bquo;You've met him?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well yes. 
 I was taking out my fury on a bit of practical work last Saturday &mdash;  painting the front gate posts &mdash; and he stopped, and got out of the car and introduced himself. 
 And you know, he insisted on shaking hands, even though mine were covered in black paint.&equo; 
 Christopher seemed impressed by this. 
 So he agreed to come. 
 Wine and cheese: one up from sweet sherry. 
 They weren't in Weybridge now. 
 A sad event intervened, however. 
 Flora appeared on Jane s doorstep with a distraught face. 
 Flopsy had died. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; said Jane, &bquo;they do  only live about eight years, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; but not to see her lolloping from room to room any more &mdash; &bquo;. 
 &bquo;I know, I understand: one lays oneself open to this sort of thing with animals. 
 My orchard was a veritable graveyard of cats: poison, old age, flu. 
 It's what's called an &bquo;occupational hazard&equo;.&equo; 
 &bquo;But will you come round? 
 I'm all on my own&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, of course.&equo; 
 (Surprised, though; one expected a Swede to be neurotic &mdash; but a Scot!) 
 When she arrived, minus dogs this time, as they would have destroyed the solemnity &mdash; Flora showed her into the back room. 
 There she had arranged a little altar, flowers and candles. 
 Jane was fearful for a moment that Flopsy might be lying in state. 
 She could not bear dead bodies of any breed. 
 It was, however, only a memorial chapel. 
 She felt she ought to have bought a card. 
 Flora had put one on the altar inscribed: &bquo;To darling Flopsy. 
 I hope you'll be happy in spirit.&equo; 
 She did not, however, think it any more ridiculous than any other memorial chapel, but she was glad Christopher had not seen it, and hoped Flora would not mention it when they came round. 
 Alastair was a tall, handsome man, who would have looked very good striding over the heather in a kilt. 
 He and Christopher got on well, and Jane heaved an inward sigh of relief. 
 She did not find Flora any strain either. 
 She confided in Jane about her children. 
 &bquo;Jeanette&equo; (Jane had noticed a photograph of a very pretty girl on their unplayed piano) &bquo;doesn't seem to want to do anything beyond getting married. 
 She could have been a top model. 
 And James has just announced he doesn't want a career. 
 In fact &mdash; he wants to leave school after O-levels. &pound;6,000 a year down the drain!&equo;  rather a loud voice) &bquo;If he wants to be a sheep farmer in Australia? 
 Better than a poky little office in a characterless building on the South Bank &mdash; and meeting after meaningless meeting!&equo; 
 &bquo;I still think they should take advantage of their education,&equo; retorted Flora. 
 &bquo;They'll only realise it later,&equo; said Christopher, smiling. 
 &bquo;As Wilde said: &bquo;Youth is a wonderful thing. 
 What a shame to waste it on children!&equo;&equo; 
 Jane tried to comfort Flora by telling her that her own two younger children had got itchy feet at sixteen too, and left school: her son had gone on to a sixth form college which he found highly satisfying &mdash; &bquo;One's treated like an adult,&equo; and her daughter to do a foundation course in art. 
 &bquo;Things have turned out all right for them, though at the time I felt like you, and thought they ought to have stayed till eighteen, as I did, and the two elder ones did. 
 But things change, even within one generation.&equo; 
 &bquo;All these conflicting views &mdash; it's like a soap opera, living in my family,&equo; said Alastair. 
 Jane appreciated Flora's style and &bquo;game for anything&equo; attitude which she knew she herself lacked. 
 Christopher meanwhile walked back with them, as they had left their car at home: they had not lost their legs. 
 He came back elated and poured some wine for Jane and himself. 
 He touched his glass to hers. 
 &bquo;Next weekend I'm going north instead of south. 
 Alastair will be in Aberdeen and I'm going to join him there. 
 He's going to show me a bit of Scotland. 
 Why don't you drink to it?&equo; 
 Jane did, while she mused, ruefully, on how one's intentions can boomerang.  
 Jane, the supreme example of self-control, did not know what was happening to her! 
 She, who had always prided herself on total moral and material independence. 
 She, the great advocate of the Freedom of the Individual. 
 She, who had never demeaned herself by falling in love (which she considered a weakness). 
 She, who had been forced to be her own person: first, by circumstances; second, by temperament; third (as she fiercely told herself) by inclination&hellip; and yet she, Jane, could not get him, Christopher, out of her mind. 
 She had to capitulate and admit to herself that she missed him terribly. 
 But he had only been away for three days. 
 No-one had penetrated her proud defences like this since her father. 
 Yet Christopher was no father-figure &mdash; he was a friend, a companion, a lover. 
 Without him, the world was incomplete. 
 His absences, and an impending change, forced her to face her own feelings. 
 His neat, slant-eyed Slavonic face was always before her. 
 She tried, angrily, to brush it aside. 
 Even music, which had always been her ultimate solace, failed to take her mind off him. 
 On Sunday evening she put on Beethoven's Ninth. 
 If this wouldn't do it, nothing would. 
 &bquo;Pull yourself together!&equo; she shouted at herself, mentally, like a true public schoolgirl (one's education never leaves one: even the religion stays stubbornly in the core of one's being). 
 The second movement was just ending, and had succeeded in stabilising her to a certain extent. 
 She was sitting on the floor, surrounded by dogs and cats &mdash; when Christopher came in, and lay on the sofa, without a word &mdash; as he always did &mdash; and listened to the music with her. 
 She restrained herself  from reacting, except with a smile, which he returned. 
 She could tell that he was relaxed and happy. 
 For once, she longed for the symphony to end. 
 At last it did. 
 After a decent pause, she made the very English enquiry: 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; how was Scotland?&equo; 
 &bquo;Inexplicable.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; feelings can't be put into words.&equo; 
 He came and sat beside her on the hearthrug. 
 His face was more animated than she had ever seen before. 
 At last he said, with a helpless shrug, &bquo;I feel I've been let out of prison.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about the weather?&equo; 
 She knew at once this was a trite remark. 
 He got up abruptly and walked impatiently about the room. 
 &bquo;Please don't debunk everything,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Sorry &mdash; habit &mdash; Alastair took you around?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; mountains &mdash; heather &mdash; space. 
 It's Britain's last frontier. 
 All petty fears fell away from me, up there. 
 Human beings can't live on grey areas for ever &mdash; unless it enters their soul. 
 And, except for a few Teflon exceptions, it does!&equo; 
 The irony of the whole situation made her dumb. 
 That she'd introduced him to the Fletchers to keep  him there&hellip; well, she deserved it. 
 &bquo;What's next?&equo; she asked, lamely. 
 &bquo;I went to an estate agent.&equo; 
 He bent down to his briefcase which he'd left on the floor, took out a folder, turned back the pages, and handed it to her. 
 It showed an old cottage, with woods behind and a sandy beach in front. 
 She read the description. 
 &bquo;Thirty miles from Edinburgh; good golf courses within easy reach. 
 Own private beach. 
 Originally a smugglers&equo; cottage.&equo; 
 She felt dizzy. 
 What the hell was wrong  with her? 
 &bquo;I've bought it,&equo; said Christopher with cruel finality. 
 &bquo;That was quick! 
 The east coast's the cold side, you know. 
 No Gulf Stream. 
 My father came from there.&equo; 
 He knelt beside her on the hearthrug. 
 &bquo;Why are you trying to put me off?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not &mdash; if it's what you want.&equo; 
 &bquo;It is. 
 And it's time you stopped being afraid of life.&equo; 
 Yes &mdash; that was the heart of the problem. 
 She'd spent the  whole of her adult life in a state of dread. 
 However, it was irrelevant to discuss her frame of mind now. 
 &bquo;You'll &mdash; give this up?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've decided to give it to the Royal Horticultural Society as an eastern centre. 
 Keep the bastards&equo; claws off it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Splendid!&equo; she exclaimed with genuine enthusiasm. 
 &bquo;A woman did the same in the west country.&equo; 
 She had a lot of questions she wanted to ask him &mdash; his pottery &mdash; his plans, but she felt too filled with emotion at the moment. 
 So all she said was, &bquo;Hungry?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 Alastair and I had a six-course breakfast in Edinburgh.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I'll go to bed then. 
 I'm exhausted &mdash; one way and another.&equo; 
 &bquo;Okay!&equo; 
 He spoke sharply and looked disappointed, but she couldn't take any more, just then. 
 It was a cold goodnight, and yet she had never felt so warm towards him. 
 Needless to say, Jane slept badly: all her past life rose before her and condemned her present feelings. 
 Yet what was  her past? 
 Had it been happy? 
 No &mdash; drab, dutiful, with occasional rare flashes and centrally &mdash; she'd always known, but never before admitted &mdash; a fearful void. 
 There was a note put through her letterbox. 
 It was Monday and Christopher had driven off early. 
 &bquo;If you feel inclined,&equo; it said non-committally, &bquo;join me at the Station Hotel, Edinburgh on Friday, then I'll show you the smugglers&equo; den. 
 Love C.&equo; He appended the time of the best train. 
 This was make or break. 
 Or maybe not. 
 It's so hard to separate emotions from facts. 
 Still, she would  go. 
 She hadn't been to Scotland for years. 
 After a lifetime of analysing herself and other people, she gave up. 
 Christopher cut through her much-vaunted intelligence and she degenerated into passivity. 
 It was only a temporary phase though, she told herself &mdash; just for a change. 
 After all, she was not now responsible for anyone else, so she could throw good sense and caution to the winds. 
 Anyway, she was only going to look at a cottage. 
 He was sitting at a carefully chosen table with the magnificence of Princes Street stretching out through the window behind him. 
 He rose and kissed her with  spontaneous pleasure. 
 The waiter brought best malt whisky straight away. 
 &bquo;Here's to our first drink together,&equo; said Christopher. 
 &bquo;The night of the fire!&equo; 
 &bquo;You've a good memory &mdash; even in duress!&equo; 
 &bquo;I remember everything. &equo; 
 The meal followed. 
 He had ordered the things that Scotland did best, just as he had chosen the best French courses in Agen. 
 What a difference, though, Jane thought, as she looked round the room. 
 Lofty ceilings, highly polished dark wood, ancestral crests, chandeliers. 
 Nowhere was history &bquo;done&equo; more convincingly than in the British Isles. 
 Christopher &mdash; more talkative than usual &mdash; was animated in his description of the Highlands, where he had taken several long walks with Alastair. 
 &bquo;I'll keep in touch with that &bquo;laddie&equo;&equo;, he said. 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; he's your neighbour &mdash;&equo; &bquo;Not for long. 
 But he'll enjoy coming up here. 
 He misses his homeland.&equo; 
 Jane nodded, wishing she belonged somewhere. 
 Once she had been proud of being rootless, but now she was beginning to feel like a boat without a rudder. 
 She shivered through her whole being. 
 They then cruised at seventy mph to the cottage, thirty miles along the coast. 
 The scenery was full and free, though not as grand as the west coast. 
 Cottages, however, were hard to find on that side. 
 Christopher had enquired. 
 It was squat and solid, in a cove, with outbuildings, some land and its own sandy bay. 
 Jane noticed that it was fairly sheltered &mdash; she was already imagining the winter. 
 It had been left in beautiful order &mdash; carpets, central heating, furniture, thick curtains. 
 &bquo;They had all the appurtenances,&equo; said Christopher. 
 &bquo;It just remained for them to find happiness &mdash; and in that they failed.&equo; 
 &bquo;No dinner parties or near neighbours to keep them going,&equo; smiled Jane. 
 &bquo;No &mdash; that's it. 
 It's a severe test, for two people to be just on their own. 
 Very few can stand it.&equo; 
 They went out on the beach. 
 There was quite a warm offshore breeze. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; said Christopher. 
 (Well &mdash; what did she think of it?) 
 &bquo;Of course, I love it. 
 It's like something out of a fairy story. 
 But &mdash; &bquo;  
 &bquo;Go on.&equo; 
 &bquo;I hope you're not romanticising Scotland. 
 They're not a charmed race, or even a charming one. 
 Scottish businessmen and advertising men are just as horrible as any others. 
 I've experienced them,&equo; &mdash; remembering, with a shudder, a crappy little agency in Clapham where there had lurked a loud gritty third-rate Scottish horror she'd had the misfortune to run across in her Algox days. 
 Was he still rushing up and down stairs shouting at the top of his voice in case anyone had missed his presence? 
 Christopher's voice broke into her thoughts: &bquo;You're trying to put me off.&equo; 
 &bquo;No &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;I think you are. 
 Why?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not &mdash; really. 
 I just wonder whether you realise what you're taking on &mdash; what it would really be like to live up here.&equo; 
 &bquo;You think I'm being carried away by enthusiasm.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps.&equo; 
 &bquo;Am I the type?&equo; 
 &bquo;We all have our lapses.&equo; 
 He kicked a pebble into the sea in exasperation. 
 &bquo;I'm disappointed in your opinion of me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Does my opinion matter so much? 
 I'm often wrong.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes it does,&equo; he snapped. 
 She was both taken aback and flattered. 
 But she could not tell him her real reason for trying to dissuade him. 
 Couldn't he guess? 
 Men are so slow! 
 Even the best of them. 
 But having got so far, she could not leave it there. 
 She heard herself say, as if it were someone else: &bquo;What is it you want from life, Christopher? 
 It seems to me you're continually running away. 
 What would you do if they came and built a hotel on this stretch of coast? 
 Move up to Fair Isle?&equo; 
 There was a long pause. 
 So long, she thought he wasn't going to answer. 
 He frowned and looked fixedly out to sea. 
 In the end he said: &bquo;Yes. 
 You've put your finger on it. 
 I hate the human race. 
 They've put everything under threat. 
 It fills me with loathing. 
 I've been escaping all my life. 
 It's a coward's way to live, I know.&equo; 
 She had no difficulty in entering into his feeling. 
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; it's sickening. 
 All greed and power and pettiness. 
 I've often felt desperate too, but I've never been able to talk about it  because people think you're being superior: holier than human. 
 But it's nevertheless real &mdash; for me, and I think for you. 
 I get terrible depressions.&equo; 
 He swung round and looked at her hard. 
 &bquo;You do?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes &mdash; but I'm careful not to wear them on my sleeve!&equo; 
 &bquo;I wasn't sure. 
 I was wondering a long time. 
 But now I think I know. 
 The two misfits have found each other!&equo; 
 &bquo;Through hell and high water!&equo; 
 &bquo;That makes it all the more precious.&equo; 
 He held her close, beside the grey Scottish sea. 
 &bquo;No swimming against the tide any more for either of us.&equo; 
 They slept together that night, and as the spiritual chemistry was right, so was the physical. 
 They had &bquo;had sex&equo; before, but each had been guarded. 
 Now the barriers were down, and Jane had never felt happier, nor more complete. 
 It's funny, she mused, how one feels incomplete on one's own. 
 It shouldn't be, but it is. 
 So Christopher &bquo;donated&equo; his north Suffolk estate to the Royal Horticultural Society and he and Jane moved out &mdash; their tastes in common now strengthened by a deeper understanding &mdash; to the Scottish smugglers' cove.  
 Their first visitors were, of course, Flora and Alastair. 
 Fond of the good life, they came armed with salmon, whisky and champagne. 
 &bquo; We'll  do the cooking!&equo; cried Alastair, donning an apron which reached half way to his knees. 
 &bquo;You lassies go for a turn on the moors.&equo; 
 Unlike Jane's father, who was bilingual, his accent was always as broad, whether he was in Suffolk or Scotland. 
 So Flora put on her green wellies and Jane her black ones, and they marched out over the hills. 
 They had things in common and, in this environment, found more. 
 To begin with, they were of a similar age: Jane's children were older because she had started to breed younger. 
 And now, surrounded by hills and sky, they shared that glorious, harmonious feeling that makes one at peace, at one with the world. 
 So Jane found it easy to ask Flora &mdash; whom she found honest and direct &mdash; how she and Alastair had got together. 
 Normally she was not inquisitive, but now she had Christopher greatly on her mind, and felt the need for parallel examples. 
 Flora laughed. 
 &bquo;On my part &mdash; by missing a train!&equo; 
 &bquo;That's not like you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wasn't like me at that moment. 
 I was in such a tizz &mdash; in love, I must admit.&equo; 
 &bquo;Alastair?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes &mdash; I was to meet him at Glasgow and I was late. 
 But a taxi driver &mdash; his taxi was ah old London cab &mdash; swore he'd beat the train to Kilmarnock, and off we went, hell for leather along the road beside the railway track. 
 It was the  most exciting drive I've ever had in my life. 
 The taxi was clattering away and I thought it would fall apart at any moment. 
 But he made it, and got to the station just before the train did. 
 Alastair waved from the window and I collapsed into the compartment excited and laughing. 
 There was no time for any formalities. 
 Our friendship was just jolted  forward. 
 That taxi was the catalyst. 
 Just the job for defeating everyday protocol!&equo; 
 &bquo;A pity it's necessary &mdash; unexpected drama, I mean,&equo; said Jane, thinking of the stories she had heard of the bonhomie  of the war, in contrast with the stiff, glib cult of the eighties. 
 Flora went on: &bquo;Yes &mdash; well &mdash; the inherited playacting dies hard. 
 We may be very liberated and all that but &mdash; &bquo;Oh &mdash; I must ask my husband&equo;&equo; She put on a high-pitched imbecile voice like a detergent or wash-up liquid ad. 
 Jane was startled to hear this. 
 She had found it hard to reconcile Flora's intelligence with her old-fashioned wifey-at-home role, retrograde from her schoolmistress mother. 
 Flora seemed to read her thoughts. 
 &bquo;I admit I've been spoilt. 
 I was lazy. 
 I shouldn't have been content to be just a wife.&equo; 
 &bquo;I think that, maybe, your beliefs have not been reflected in your life,&equo; Jane ventured. 
 &bquo;Too true. 
 It's because of having too good a husband.&equo; 
 &bquo;The opposite from mine!&equo; 
 &bquo;I really admire you, bringing up four from the time the youngest was only five and  working full time. 
 &bquo;No bravery. 
 Circumstances dictated it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; there's nothing like adversity &mdash; &bquo;sweet are the uses of adversity&equo;&equo; &mdash; for bringing out the best in you. 
 Dickens, W H Davies, Gorky, Dostoevsky &mdash; there are loads of examples!&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm no genius, so I can do without it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Still, I'm sure it brought out hidden strengths you never knew you had.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe. 
 Never thought about it really.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I  can see it. 
 I'm quite the armchair feminist! 
 Not the frightening kind. 
 My sister's one of those. 
 Formidable. 
 She's a psychiatrist. 
 You'd need a psychiatrist to help you recover from her.&equo; 
 Like Jane, Flora had the gift of demolishing characters with a few swift shafts, but at the same time with  wit and good humour. 
 &bquo;But you're a lovely example to prove one of my pet theories: that women can always cope.&equo; 
 &bquo;Some women,&equo; Jane interposed, thinking of Evelyn, Fatima and others she'd come across. 
 &bquo;Oh of course there are always exceptions, but mainly I think romantic novelists are quite wrong. 
 They still  try to portray us as vulnerable and weak, but in reality we're very tough &mdash; not just the enormous butch ones, but small ones like us.&equo; 
 Jane reflected that if she'd been enormous, with masses of stomach and bust up front, Lajos might have thought twice about bashing her. 
 Flora had really got going now. 
 &bquo;Still, men have achieved their superior position because they literally have it, in sex, and because mainly they have got greater physical strength.&equo; 
 &bquo;Also, they're the greatest creatively,&equo; Jane interrupted. 
 &bquo;There's no female Shakespeare or Beethoven.&equo; 
 &bquo;Circumstances,&equo; Flora brushed that aside: &bquo;what they could do, they did do &mdash; novels &mdash; Jane Austen, the Bront&euml;s, Virginia Woolf&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;But no great composers or painters, even now,&equo; Jane persisted. 
 &bquo;Pah &mdash; there aren't any male ones either &mdash; not since Sibelius and C&eacute;zanne &mdash; however  &mdash; as I was saying (among ordinary people) physical strength used to matter, but now most of the hard work is done by machines, so it doesn't wash any more. 
 Women can drive cars, taxis, buses, trucks, diggers, lawn-mowers &mdash; that sort of thing, though in the West they mostly don't (except cars) because of tradition.&equo; 
 (And because they're spoilt, like you, thought Jane). 
 Flora darted a glance at her. 
 &bquo;Though you  only ride a bicycle, don't you. 
 I suppose that's because of the environment?&equo; 
 &bquo;No &mdash; I was riding one long before the environment was heard of. 
 I'm a throw-back. 
 I just don't like machines with a mind of their own &mdash; not even a moped! 
 Also, a car's very expensive to buy and to run. 
 As they say, what you don't have, you don't miss. 
 I do mind about the environment thing too. 
 A bike's healthier for the person and the air. 
 I think private cars should be limited to the infirm, really.&equo;  
 &bquo;I don't know how I'd live without mine. 
 But I expect that goes for millions of unnecessary car owners! 
 Still, I confess I'm a wee bit disappointed in your reasons. 
 I liked to think you were ahead of your time in everything !&equo; 
 We're all walking viewpoints! thought Jane, then she laughed. 
 &bquo;I've never thought of myself as avant-garde . 
 As I said, what I did was dictated by necessity. 
 But I still appreciate good manners in men. 
 Even a touch of chivalry. 
 Especially now. 
 I expect it's hard for them to find their feet on these shifting sands.&equo; 
 Christopher's thoughtfulness was in her mind. 
 &bquo;Ah yes &mdash; it's becoming more difficult than ever to achieve a balance. 
 We've still got to let them believe  they're a bit macho.&equo; 
 Flora took her arm. 
 &bquo;We're lucky in Christopher and Alastair at any rate,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Let's go back to this fantastic meal!&equo;  
 Of course, there is no such thing as living happily ever after. 
 Unhappy human nature precludes that. 
 In Jane's case, she could not snap out of a lifetime of worry overnight. 
 She did not relish all those dishes which memory served up. 
 She loved the present, but the past intervened, especially when Christopher was away. 
 There was no escape: &bquo;I am a part of all that I have met.&equo; 
 Too true, but Tennyson goes on: 
 &bquo;Yet all experience is an arch wherethro&equo; 
 Gleams that untravell'd world, whose margin fades 
 For ever and for ever when I move.&equo; 
 Between her and Christopher there had been no euphoria to fade into the light of common day. 
 There had been no mad paroxysm of love, with the inevitable bathos. 
 They had been wary, and had resolved many of the doubts of two suspicious, confirmed loners already. 
 The groundwork had been achieved. 
 But Jane still dreaded the threatening disease of daily life. 
 Boredom and routine were less of a menace because Christopher was not a nine-to-fiver. 
 He ran his own business, and worked almost round the clock, so was away for days at a time. 
 At these times Jane was assailed by self-doubt; by fears as to whether their relationship would decline &mdash; for nothing human remains static. 
 Then, when he returned &mdash; which he always did, as quickly as possible, for Smugglers' Cove (and its occupant) were so strong a magnet that he often drove home through the night &mdash; then  she was unfailingly reassured. 
 But what a boring person I am, she thought, to need constant  reassurance! 
 To be always afraid of confusing imagination with reality. 
 Away from his business, Christopher craved only peace and solitude, now shared with her &mdash; the first person ever to share it. 
 His greatest pleasure was to walk with her along the seashore. 
 He wanted no parties, and few visitors. 
 Alastair and Flora came quite often and the four of them enjoyed the luxury of being totally at ease. 
 Occasionally Jane's family dragged themselves away from their busy life in the south and arrived with boyfriends and girlfriends. 
 They were sage  young people and got on with Christopher. 
 He himself had no family and Jane never questioned him. 
 Until now, he had always been solitary. 
 He had never thought he could share his life with anyone. 
 She had always been surrounded by people &mdash; and was still haunted by memories and bad dreams &mdash; but essentially had been just as solitary. 
 She had never come to terms with her old life, but, inch by inch, she was coming to terms with this one: her first reality. 
 The worst time of day had always been the morning blues &mdash; another day to get rid of &mdash; please God, help me through. 
 The people she would have to deal with in the London offices, paved with razor wire, rose up before her grotesquely and she would pull the sheets over her head and moan: &bquo;I don't want to get up &mdash; ever again!&equo; 
 But she did  get up. 
 It was her relentless sense of order which had scaffolded her life. 
 So different now, even on dark mornings. 
 To think that she and Christopher &mdash; two such hopeless, ingrained loners &mdash; had found each other! 
 It was a million-to-one chance. 
 And the still, small voice which persisted in whispering &bquo; too  good to be true&equo; gradually, very  gradually, became fainter. 
 It had never occurred to her that Christopher had been thinking of these things too. 
 They never went in for small talk (&bquo;Had a nice day at the office, darling?&equo; complete with obligatory peck. 
 &bquo;I was talking to Mrs Jones today and she  said &mdash; &bquo;) Neither felt the need of talking, for the sake of talking. 
 They were walking along the shore, arms linked against the wind, when he said. 
 &bquo;Is it all right here for you, Jane?&equo; 
 You're never bored I know, but do you get lonely?&equo;  
 &bquo;Lonely!&equo; 
 &bquo;I've been wondering &mdash; trying to see the place from your point of view. 
 &bquo;No &mdash; I love it. 
 I've never been so happy. 
 &bquo;I love the place &mdash; and &mdash; I love you. 
 Oh dear &mdash; not in that order!&equo; 
 She'd never said that to him before &mdash; nor indeed to anyone in her whole life. 
 They stopped and kissed, under their sou'westers. 
 &bquo;And how I love you! 
 Thank you for being here.&equo; 
 And he'd never said that  to her before. 
 (Nor, we think, to anyone else.) 
 Now, they turned and walked back to the cottage, with the wind behind them. 
 &bquo;You're the breeze and I'm like the aspen tree,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, the breeze that ignores all the other trees, but plays its tune on the aspen, rustling its leaves, only on the aspen!&equo; 
 He laughed. 
 &bquo;The things you say!&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't know I had it in me &mdash; aspen tree similes &mdash; let alone love!&equo; 
 He stopped and looked into her face with those dark penetrating eyes which she had noticed so vividly on the night of the fire. 
 &bquo;There's a lot more in you that you don't know about &mdash; yet,&equo; he said gently. 
 Philip stared, hardly believing what he saw. 
 It was the shock of it. 
 He'd never seen anyone in Jubilee Wood in all the months he'd been coming up here. 
 And now, here was this boy standing by the big pool, as cool as a cucumber and wearing his helmet. 
 The boy looked round behind him up at the cliff. 
 Philip stepped back quickly into the cover of the trees. 
 The boy was stooping now, searching for something on the bank. 
 The helmet had tipped forward and the boy pushed it back. 
 Like Philip he wore glasses. 
 Then he picked up a rock from the shallow water at the edge of the pool and threw it out into the middle, making a huge splash; the rings of the splash spread nearly to the edge of the pool. 
 A pheasant squawked and birds burst out of the trees. 
 Keeping himself hidden, Philip watched him as he looked for another stone. 
 If the boy carried on like that, he'd scare off everything: the birds, the fish, the lot. 
 Close by Philip's foot was a rotten log. 
 He broke a piece off carefully, so it came away without any noise, just crumbling. 
 He waited till the boy turned away from the edge of the pool again and was looking into the trees behind him. 
 Then Philip sent the piece of rotten log spinning over the pool. 
 It landed in the water just in front of where the boy was standing. 
 Philip, crouched behind one of the big beeches that grew right down close to the pool, watched the boy for his reaction. 
 He'd scared him, you could see that. 
 You could tell because he was looking all round, nervous. 
 Then he put his fingers in his mouth and let out a shrill whistle. 
 Philip hadn't expected that and it unnerved him. 
 Maybe the boy was signalling to his mates and any moment there'd be an  ambush. 
 It could be that the boy had got the whole thing planned, luring Philip out, then having him surrounded. 
 Philip waited, crouched on the wet leaves listening, staring into the trees, looking for movement, shadowy figures. 
 But there was no one except the boy &mdash; and him. 
 And it was deathly quiet except for an aeroplane overhead. 
 The boy looked up at the plane, then threw himself to the ground. 
 He stayed there till the plane had gone over. 
 Maybe the boy was on the run and they had planes out searching for him. 
 No, that was stupid; the plane was too high. 
 Besides he did that himself sometimes when they new over, if they were enemy planes. 
 The boy got up and you could see he was still nervous. 
 He broke himself off a thick stick from a tree behind him and looked all round again. 
 Philip worked a flat stone out of the earth by the roots of the beech tree. 
 Then, when the boy wasn't looking in his direction he hurled it towards the pool. 
 The stone was heavier than he'd thought and he bungled the throw. 
 The stone fell very short, landing not far from his hiding-place. 
 The boy looked over in his direction at once. 
 You could see he'd spotted where the stone had landed. 
 Philip, pressed so close to the tree he could feel the knobbles in the bark, watched him. 
 The boy was making straight for the stone, holding his stick up and making little darting glances all round him. 
 He wasn't very big. 
 Philip reckoned he wasn't as big as him but you couldn't have told what age he was. 
 He had sandy red hair. 
 As he jumped the ditch that joined the two pools the helmet fell off. 
 He stopped to put it back on again, clamping it on his head and holding it there. 
 He was quite near Philip now and was climbing up the bank towards the spot where Philip had thrown the stone. 
 When he reached the stone he stood looking at it, shifting it with his foot. 
 Then he came on towards Philip, scrambling the last bit of the slope. 
 Philip thought he must have seen him but he  hadn't, because he stopped and whistled again, looking up towards the cliffs. 
 Philip didn't run. 
 He'd hold his ground; he was higher up than him and at an advantage. 
 But he didn't fancy him getting too close. 
 He'd lose what advantage he had. 
 There was nothing of any size to throw, so he flung a handful of beech-mast. 
 It did the trick. 
 The boy looked right at him and stopped, the stick held above his head, threatening. 
 With his other hand he took the helmet off. 
 His glasses were too big for him. 
 &bquo;That's mine,&equo; said Philip. 
 The boy stared at Philip. 
 &bquo;That helmet's mine,&equo; said Philip again. 
 &bquo;Where did you get it?&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't get it anywhere. 
 It's left over from the War. 
 My great-uncle gave it me. 
 So you give it me back.&equo; 
 The boy stood there twisting the helmet in his hands, inspecting it. 
 &bquo;I can't see any bullet holes.&equo; 
 &bquo;He was in the Home Guard,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;What's that?&equo; 
 &bquo;They didn't go to war, not abroad.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're having me on,&equo; said the boy looking at Philip. 
 &bquo;Nobody had it in the War.&equo; 
 He flung the helmet on the ground and Philip grabbed it. 
 He inspected it, looking to see if the boy had damaged it. 
 It looked all right. 
 The boy waved his stick round his head and threw it into the pool. 
 &bquo;Don't,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;There's fish in there.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;I've seen them. 
 Tiddlers.&equo; 
 &bquo;If they catch you up here,&equo; said Philip, &bquo;you'll get into trouble.&equo; 
 The boy was still looking round him as if he expected someone to come. 
 Philip wondered again about the ambush, but he didn't look the kind that would set up something. 
 Barry organized ambushes at school between the portakabin class-room and the main school building.  
 &bquo;You seen my dog?&equo; he said. 
 Philip shook his head. 
 &bquo;What colour is it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Black,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;I saw a black dog last night,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It wasn't him,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;My Dad locked him up last night.&equo; 
 He whistled again. 
 &bquo;I &bquo;d better go and look for him,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I expect he's gone home.&equo; 
 And he ran off into the trees. 
 Philip waited till he couldn't see him any more, then went back to his hide. 
 Who was the boy? 
 Where had he sprung from? 
 Philip hadn't set eyes on him before that he was aware of. 
 He sat down now in the hide and put the helmet on. 
 It was damp from being buried in the leaves. 
 He took it off again, inspecting the inside. 
 A hair was stuck to it, a red one, the boy's. 
 Philip picked it off. 
 He wiped the inside of the helmet with his anorak sleeve and put the helmet down beside him. 
 The boy couldn't have come from Thirkett surely; it was too far. 
 Unless he'd biked. 
 It was worrying, very worrying indeed. 
 Philip picked up the carrier bag. 
 Strange boy or not, he had to get on. 
 He crawled out of the hide and laid the wire, the plan that he'd drawn and his Dad's wire-cutters on the ground. 
 It wasn't just today the boy had come up to the wood but yesterday as well. 
 Of course it was him that had messed up his diary, drawing those stupid pictures in it. 
 Philip pulled at the end of the wire to loosen it. 
 If he caught him up here again he'd see him off, scare him to death. 
 He looked at the plan for the pheasant trap. 
 What he needed were sticks, thick ones. 
 You wired them together to make a kind of pyramid. 
 Then you propped it up on a twig, attached to a piece of string that you pulled when the bird walked into the trap. 
 The framework fell on the bird, so it couldn't escape. 
 He looked round the clearing. 
 The sticks wouldn't be too difficult to find, not here in the wood, especially after  the gale. 
 Finding them the right length would be more of a problem. 
 He knew he could really have done with a saw. 
 But he hadn't dared bring his Dad's saw. 
 His Dad kept it hanging on a nail in the shed and he'd have noticed right away if it was missing. 
 He found plenty of thickish sticks and picked up far more than he needed. 
 He'd sod them by the hide and arrange them into lengths. 
 He needed four about a metre long, then four more shorter than that, and four more shorter still. 
 Twigs or thin bits wouldn't do. 
 They had to be strong. 
 The wind had dropped right down and it was warm in the wood, so warm that Philip took his anorak off. 
 It was very pleasant and peaceful and he almost forgot about the boy. 
 He stopped worrying about him anyway. 
 He'd most likely go back to Thirkett or wherever he'd come from and stay there. 
 Philip picked up the armful of sticks he'd gathered and walked across to his hide. 
 Then he nearly dropped the lot. 
 From out of the trees on the cliff side appeared a big black dog. 
 He recognized it at once. 
 It was the same dog he'd seen outside Mrs Wright's hen-house. 
 For all he knew, the one Mrs Wright had shot at. 
 It snatched one of the sticks that Philip was holding and dragged it to the far side of the feeding-place, barking. 
 Behind the dog in the trees stood the boy. 
 &bquo;Here, Caspar,&equo; he shouted. 
 The dog bounded up to him and he took the stick out of the dog's mouth. 
 He threw it deep into the wood and the dog chased after it. 
 &bquo;Is that your dog?&equo; said Philip. 
 The boy nodded. 
 &bquo;You should have it on a lead.&equo; 
 The dog had brought the stick back and the boy threw it again. 
 This time the dog didn't come back. 
 &bquo;Jack who does the shepherding, he'll shoot him,&equo; said Philip, &bquo;if he worries the ewes. 
 Or Mrs Wright will if he goes near her hens.&equo;  
 &bquo;He won't touch sheep or hens,&equo; said the boy, walking over towards the hide. 
 He stopped in front of it, tugging at the camouflage netting. 
 &bquo;Leave that,&equo; said Philip, following him. 
 He dropped his sticks on the ground. 
 The boy shook one of the branches that made the framework of the hide. 
 &bquo;Don't you touch that,&equo; said Philip. 
 The boy took hold of the net again, tweaking it. 
 &bquo;Did you get that from the War too?&equo; 
 &bquo;Course not,&equo; said Philip. 
 The boy bent double and disappeared inside the hide. 
 He came out with Philip's note-book. 
 &bquo;You draw good pictures,&equo; said the boy, turning over the pages of the note-book till he came to the whole page drawing of a pheasant, the cock pheasant that Philip had coloured in at home. 
 &bquo;Where's mine, my bombers?&equo; 
 Philip snatched the book from him. 
 &bquo;You'd no right to draw those pictures in my book,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Where are they?&equo; the boy said. 
 &bquo;Here,&equo; said Philip, taking the crunched-up ball of paper out of his jeans pocket and throwing it at the boy. 
 The boy picked it up and carefully unravelled the pages, smoothing them on his leg. 
 Then he folded the pages neatly and put them in his pocket. 
 &bquo;I know what they call you,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Anybody knows that,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's written at the front of my note-book and it says &bquo;Private&equo; in case you hadn't noticed.&equo; 
 Somewhere quite close a pheasant called. 
 Philip imitated it. 
 The boy stared at him. 
 &bquo;How d'you do that, then?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It's a gift I got,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Do it again.&equo; 
 Philip did it again. 
 There was an answering call from the far side of the wood.  
 &bquo;What's that bird?&equo; said the boy pointing. 
 &bquo;It's a pheasant,&equo; whispered Philip. 
 &bquo;Sh!&equo; 
 The hen pheasant had appeared on the other side of the feeding-ground. 
 So she'd come back again. 
 Philip put his finger to his lips. 
 But to his horror he saw the boy cup his hands round his mouth and make a crude and earsplittingly loud imitation of a pheasant's call. 
 The hen pheasant flew off. 
 &bquo;Now look what you've done,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;You've scared off my hen pheasant.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's only a bird,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;A stupid bird.&equo; 
 And he made another appalling imitation of the pheasant call. 
 &bquo;Get out,&equo; yelled Philip. 
 &bquo;No one asked you to come up here. 
 It's private property.&equo; 
 He hurled himself at the boy. 
 &bquo;Get off, I haven't done anything.&equo; 
 Even as Philip pushed the boy to the ground he couldn't believe it was him that was doing it. 
 He'd never started a fight in his life. 
 It was asking for trouble especially if you wore glasses like him. 
 But he didn't think about that now. 
 He was angry, really angry. 
 The boy was kicking like crazy to get free of him but Philip held on. 
 His glasses fell off but he didn't care. 
 He could see close up, couldn't he? 
 He could see enough. 
 The boy elbowed him trying to get him off. 
 Philip thumped him. 
 Hadn't done anything? 
 He'd messed up his note-book, scared off the hen pheasant that he'd waited ages to lure to the feeding ground, nicked his helmet, that was all. 
 He could kill him. 
 &bquo;Leave off, can't you,&equo; gasped the boy. 
 &bquo;Get out, then,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Get back to Thirkett or wherever you come from.&equo; 
 The boy stared at him. 
 His lip was bleeding. 
 &bquo;Thirkett? 
 What for?&equo; 
 &bquo;I bet that's where you live.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't,&equo; said the boy licking his lip where Philip had hit him.  
 &bquo;Tell us where you do live, then.&equo; 
 &bquo;Down there&equo; said the boy pointing. 
 &bquo;Where?&equo; said Philip. 
 Little Knoll,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;Beech Place.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;How do you know I don't?&equo; said the boy sitting up. 
 Philip had loosened his grip. 
 &bquo;Because you don't go to Thirkett School, that's why. 
 You don't get on the school bus.&equo; 
 Philip picked up his glasses. 
 &bquo;Got you there, didn't I?&equo; 
 &bquo;I go to a different school,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;What school?, 
 &bquo;Garth House.&equo; 
 Philip put his glasses on and stared at the boy. 
 It could be true. 
 He'd heard of the place. 
 It was a special school, he didn't know what for. 
 The boy, free of Philip, rolled over and sat up. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; he said pointing. 
 &bquo;There's another one of those birds.&equo; 
 On the bank by the beech-tree that Philip had hidden behind was a cock pheasant. 
 The boy crooked one arm and stuck out the other as if he were holding a gun. 
 &bquo;Bang, bang,&equo; he shouted. 
 &bquo;BANG, BANG.&equo; 
 The pheasant flew off, squawking its alarm call. 
 Philip lunged at the boy. 
 He hit him with his clenched fist with every bit of strength in him. 
 The boy was as good as a murderer. 
 How dared he come to his, Philip's place, and act like a bird shooter. 
 The boy fell to the ground and lay there with his eyes shut. 
 He lay quite still, not moving.  
 Philip was scared. 
 He'd never hit anyone that hard before. 
 The boy lay there, not moving. 
 But he was breathing. 
 You could see that. 
 Philip bent over the boy, looking down at him. 
 There was no blood coming out of his mouth or anything. 
 It was only his nose. 
 Philip knelt down beside him. 
 The other boy had a white face and freckles. 
 He could have had a fit. 
 There was a boy at school had fits. 
 Maybe the special school he went to was a kind of hospital. 
 Probably right now there were people out looking for him. 
 Philip heard a noise behind him in the trees. 
 That could be them now. 
 He reached for one of the sticks he'd collected for the pheasant trap. 
 As he picked it up, the boy opened his eyes. 
 &bquo;Did you think I was dead?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Course not,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I bet you did,&equo; said the boy, sitting up. 
 He didn't seem angry with Philip for having hit him. 
 &bquo;This is my place,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's private.&equo; 
 The boy pulled a handkerchief out of his pocket and wiped his nose. 
 The handkerchief was full of little holes. 
 &bquo;Where do you go to school, then?&equo; said the boy. 
 Philip put the stick back on the pile. 
 &bquo;Thirkett Middle,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Now clear off, will you.&equo; 
 It looked as though something had chewed the handkerchief, or it had been destroyed by acid or something. 
 &bquo;What's it like, your school?&equo; said the boy. 
 Philip thought of Mrs Mills and Barry Butler. 
 &bquo;I don't like it,&equo; he said pushing the sticks with his foot. 
 &bquo;Me neither,&equo; said the boy rolling on his back. 
 &bquo;Sometimes I don't go. 
 They think I do, but I don't. 
 I write notes,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Absence notes.&equo;  
 Philip looked at the boy, who was mashing the leaves up with his heels. 
 Philip had spent the whole of one night thinking of faking an absence note for Mrs Mills. 
 But he hadn't had the guts to do it. 
 He'd tried several, imitating his Mum's signature but he'd scrumpled them up and put them in the waste paper basket. 
 He couldn't do it. 
 &bquo;I can't go to your school,&equo; the boy went on. 
 &bquo;The classes are too big. 
 I couldn't manage.&equo; 
 Philip thought he wouldn't have minded going to his school. 
 He fancied a class half the size especially if he could have picked who was in it. 
 He wouldn't have Barry and his mates for a start. 
 &bquo;I might be able to come to your school for two days a week,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;So I can get used to it.&equo; 
 &bquo;How do you get to go to your school?&equo; said Philip. 
 The boy sat up. 
 &bquo;My Mum and Dad can't handle me, right?&equo; 
 Philip laughed. 
 Anyone could handle him. 
 He was just trying to make himself sound big. 
 He turned his back on 
 him and began sorting his sticks into lengths. 
 &bquo;What are those for?&equo; said the boy, turning over on to his stomach and poking at the pile of sticks. 
 Philip didn't answer. 
 &bquo;Are they for your camp?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Philip picked up the roll of wire and nipped off a length with the cutters. 
 He placed two of the sticks at right angles overlapping and began to twist the wire to fix the two sticks together. 
 &bquo;I can make things,&equo; said the boy, picking up the wirecutters and nicking at bits of grass with them. 
 &bquo;I made the cage for my mice.&equo; 
 Philip stopped twisting the wire. 
 He wondered if the mice were white. 
 When they said he couldn't have a parrot he'd said &bquo;Well, mice, then, white ones,&equo; but his Dad had said he couldn't have them either. 
 No reason. 
 &bquo;I've got four of them, white ones,&equo; said the boy holding  up his handkerchief and showing Philip the holes. 
 &bquo;They made them. 
 I put them in my pocket sometimes. 
 My Dad gets mad.&equo; 
 Philip clipped off another piece of wire. 
 &bquo;That bit's too short,&equo; said the boy looking at the piece of wire that Philip had just cut. 
 It was. 
 He wasn't making a very good job of fixing the sticks together. 
 The boy was distracting him. 
 &bquo;I'll be off, then,&equo; said the boy and disappeared again into the trees. 
 He heard him whistling for his dog. 
 Philip hoped he'd find his dog and the pair of them would clear off. 
 With luck, with his whistling that loud Jack would catch him and see him off. 
 Philip began the second join, placing another length of wood at right angles. 
 Maybe he'd tell Jack about him anyway, then Mr Hyde would go and see the boy's Dad and tell him to keep off private land. 
 But it wasn't that easy. 
 It would put him, Philip, in a difficult position. 
 He wasn't supposed to be in Jubilee Wood either. 
 Philip persevered with his trap. 
 He was finding the wire hard to bend. 
 It was thicker than he would have liked and the sticks were too long. 
 He could have done with a saw. 
 And the pieces of wire he'd cut were too short. 
 The boy was right. 
 He'd start again with longer pieces. 
 He looked round for his wire-cutters. 
 He couldn't see them. 
 They'd gone. 
 And he remembered that the boy had been fiddling with them. 
 That was the last time he'd seen them. 
 The boy must have gone off with them. 
 Philip ran into the ride, looking in both directions along it. 
 There was no sign of the boy. 
 He'd most likely be out of the wood by now. 
 Philip was mad at himself for not taking the cutters off the boy. 
 Now it was too late. 
 He'd gone. 
 Philip had to get them back. 
 His Dad would kill him if he found that he'd taken them. 
 It was one of the worst things. 
 He stood in the ride. 
 Maybe he should go back down through the wood. 
 He daren't call out; someone might hear him. 
 Then he looked again down the ride. 
 The branch  he'd climbed over this morning that had been tom down in the wind was moving, shaking violently. 
 Philip ran towards it and as he came round the slight bend in the wide path he saw the boy tugging at it. 
 He was trying to move it off the path. 
 &bquo;I can't shift it,&equo; he said to Philip. 
 &bquo;Where's my Dad's wire-cutters?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I haven't got them,&equo; said the boy. 
 Philip didn't believe him. 
 He'd got them all right. 
 &bquo;They're my Dad's. 
 He'll kill me if he finds out I took them.&equo; 
 &bquo;Here you are then,&equo; said the boy, taking the wire-cutters out of his pocket and giving them to Philip. 
 &bquo;What did you take them for?&equo; said Philip. 
 The boy didn't answer. 
 He was still tugging at the branch. 
 &bquo;I know the person who owns this place,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;And if you don't get out of here I'll tell him you've been up in the woods with a dog. 
 He'll tell your Dad.&equo; 
 Philip walked back up the ride not turning round till he got to his hide. 
 He couldn't see the boy any more. 
 Threatening him like that had most likely scared him off. 
 He picked up the lop-sided contraption that was meant to be his pheasant trap. 
 It didn't look anything like the diagram. 
 It was no good. 
 It wasn't working out like he'd thought and it was going to take him a lot longer than he'd planned. 
 It was the boy's fault, he'd spoilt everything. 
 He was a thief and a liar. 
 He bet he hadn't got any white mice either. 
 He probably just said that. 
 You could never tell if what people told you was true. 
 Barry had told them at school that his Dad had bought him a tarantula. 
 It had been a lie and the whole class had laughed when Philip had asked him how much it had cost, even Mrs Mills. 
 She'd known it was a lie too. 
 Even up here in the wood miles away from the class-room Philip felt his face burn at the way he'd made a fool of himself. 
 &bquo;You mustn't believe everything you're told,&equo; Mrs Mills had said.  
 Philip kicked at the pile of sticks he'd gathered for his trap, scattering them. 
 He wouldn't believe the boy or anyone. 
 They all told lies: Barry, Mrs Mills, his Mum and Dad, all of them. 
 The sheep were making a racket, more than usual. 
 He wondered what it was that could be upsetting them. 
 Maybe Jack was rounding them up and moving them to another field. 
 Or it could be the boy going down through the field and scaring them. 
 He was that stupid he could do anything. 
 &bquo;What's it for? 
 Rabbits?&equo; 
 He couldn't believe it. 
 Not again. 
 The boy had crept up behind him and was standing, staring down at Philip's diagram of the trap. 
 Seeing him again was like a bad dream. 
 He picked up his diagram. 
 Fancy him thinking you could get rabbits with that. 
 You needed snares for rabbits. 
 The boy knelt down by Philip's wreck of a trap. 
 He looked carefully at the sticks of uneven length and thickness that Philip had fixed together, too loosely. 
 &bquo;You need a saw,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;I know that,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;But I haven't got one, have I?&equo; 
 &bquo;We've got plenty,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;Plenty,&equo; said Philip scornfully. 
 &bquo;People don't have plenty of saws.&equo; 
 &bquo;My Dad does,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;He's a builder.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, yes?&equo; said Philip. 
 That was probably another of his lies. 
 A plane flew over. 
 &bquo;Enemy plane,&equo; said the boy. 
 &bquo;Those are from the base,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;R.A.F.,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Here,&equo; said the boy pulling his pictures out of his pocket and laying one on the ground in front of Philip. 
 &bquo;That's a German one,&equo; he said pointing to a large drawing that took up nearly all the page. 
 &bquo;I know that,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Messerschmitt.&equo; 
 He saw that the boy had initialled the picture at the bottom. 
 &bquo;L.D.&equo; The boy saw him looking. 
 &bquo;Lee Dent,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That's my name.&equo;  
 Philip didn't say anything. 
 He wasn't interested in his name. 
 He wished more than anything he'd go. 
 Didn't he ever stop talking, poking his nose in? 
 And now it was the planes. 
 When Philip was alone in the wood he imagined all sorts of things about the planes, that they were enemy planes bombing Thirkett, that they were on reconnaissance flights spying, that they were looking for him: a crashed pilot hiding out in the wood. 
 He didn't want this boy taking his planes, pretending about them. 
 The sheep had gone strangely quiet and there was a queer thundering noise that he'd never heard before. 
 It took him a second to work out what it was, that it was the sheep galloping. 
 Something must have scared them. 
 Philip ran across to the far side of the feeding-place. 
 He knew a quick way to the field through the top of the wood. 
 It was quicker than going along the ride. 
 It was rough, but you could get through easy enough before the new bracken grew. 
 He knew that Lee was following him. 
 He didn't care. 
 He had to see what was up with the sheep. 
 &bquo;What's the hurry?&equo; called Lee. 
 &bquo;Can't you hear the ewes?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;There's something scared them.&equo; 
 The noise of the sheep pounding across the field was loud, like horses in a film. 
 It must be the whole lot of them, the whole flock and there were hundreds in the field. 
 He clambered up the bank to the top where the trees ended. 
 The fence ran in front of him. 
 The sheep were tearing across the field all bunched up together. 
 After them was a black dog. 
 A ewe and two lambs were trailing and the dog had got them marked. 
 It was the worst thing &mdash; unless the old ewe turned on the dog and went for it. 
 If the dog got one of the lambs and drew blood there'd be no stopping it. 
 He heard Lee come up beside him. 
 &bquo;Call it off,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Call your dog off.&equo; 
 But Lee just stood there holding the fence. 
 Philip  couldn't believe it. 
 Here was his dog about to kill a lamb and he just stood there doing nothing. 
 &bquo;I'm going, then,&equo; said Philip beginning to climb the fence. 
 He felt Lee pull his arm. 
 &bquo;There's a man,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;With a gun.&equo; 
 Jack was coming through the gate from the other field. 
 He was shouting at the dog. 
 Both boys dived for the cover of the trees. 
 Jack fired into the air and the dog left off chasing the sheep and ran towards the wood. 
 It jumped the fence lower down and disappeared from sight. 
 Jack was coming straight for them, up towards the gate with Floss at his heels. 
 &bquo;I told you you should have had him on a lead,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;He was going to kill those lambs. 
 Couldn't you see? 
 Don't you know anything?&equo; 
 &bquo;It wasn't Caspar,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;You're a liar,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Of course it was your dog. 
 I've seen it, haven't I?, 
 He looked witheringly at Lee. 
 &bquo;And you were going to let it kill those lambs.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's coming this way,&equo; said Lee who was still looking at Jack as he came up to the gate, his eyes fixed on the gun. 
 Philip knew what Jack was doing. 
 He was on the warpath looking for the killer dog. 
 And if he caught him, Philip, and Lee in the wood there'd be real trouble. 
 He ran down the bank, Lee following him. 
 He heard Jack open the gate. 
 Philip dropped down in the old bracken. 
 Lee beside him. 
 &bquo;Is he going to shoot us?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Not if you shut up,&equo; whispered Philip. 
 Suddenly they heard a noise behind them. 
 Philip turned quickly and saw the boy's dog bounding over the bracken towards them. 
 &bquo;Caspar,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Caspar, where've you been?&equo; 
 Lee got hold of him by the collar. 
 &bquo;Shut up, will you,&equo; hissed Philip. 
 He was watching Jack and Floss go down the ride  towards the feeding-ground. 
 Caspar had seen Floss too. 
 He was straining to be off. 
 &bquo;Help me,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I can't hold him.&equo; 
 Philip thought of Caspar chasing the lambs. 
 He wasn't going to hold him. 
 The dog was leaping about now, trying to wrench himself free of Lee. 
 Lee was being dragged down the bank. 
 Caspar was a big dog. 
 Philip watched Lee's fingers loosen on the studded collar and the dog break away. 
 He disappeared in the direction of Jack and Floss. 
 The next thing they heard the report of a gun, really loud. 
 Every bird in the wood seemed to fly up into the air.  
 Lee looked at Philip, stricken. 
 &bquo;He's shot Caspar,&equo; he said getting up out of the bracken. 
 &bquo;Wait,&equo; said Philip holding on to him. 
 &bquo;I got to go and see if Caspar's 0. 
 K.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't want to walk straight into the barrel of Jack's gun, do you.&equo; 
 Philip kept his voice down. 
 Jack was still most likely in the wood. 
 &bquo;I got to go,&equo; said Lee. 
 His face was white. 
 All they could hear was one of the spy planes. 
 As its noisy buzzing faded they heard Jack whistling to Floss, far away. 
 &bquo;He's going out of the wood,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;The far end. 
 He's most likely going down to tell Mr Hyde.&equo; 
 He let go Lee's arm and Lee ran down to the ride. 
 &bquo;Caspar,&equo; he called. 
 &bquo;Caspar.&equo; 
 &bquo;Shut up,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Jack'll hear you.&equo; 
 The boy was mad rushing out into the open like that. 
 He had crossed the ride and was looking for his dog the other side. 
 &bquo;Not that way,&equo; said Philip, still keeping in the trees. 
 It had sounded to him as if the shot had come from somewhere near the pools. 
 Lee ran back to him. 
 &bquo;It wasn't Caspar in the field. 
 It was another dog, a black dog but it wasn't Caspar.&equo; 
 Philip looked at him disbelieving. 
 &bquo;I'd know, wouldn't I?, 
 &bquo;Jack wouldn't,&equo; said Philip drily. 
 They had almost reached the feeding-place walking in the trees beside the ride carefully, trying not to step on sticks. 
 &bquo;If he's hurt I'll have to get him to the vet,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;He hates the vet's.&equo;  
 &bquo;If Jack shot him he'll be dead,&equo; said Philip. 
 Then he wished he hadn't said that. 
 Lee was crying. 
 Philip tried not to look at him. 
 He, Philip, hardly ever cried. 
 As they reached the edge of the clearing Philip saw the dead magpie. 
 He walked over to it. 
 &bquo;There,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That's what he shot. 
 Not your dog.&equo; 
 Philip was relieved. 
 He hadn't wanted to find Caspar dead even if it was Jack's right to shoot him. 
 But he wasn't going to tell Lee that. 
 Lee had gone over towards the pools and was whistling. 
 Caspar came bounding out of the tangle of fallen trees below the cliff. 
 Lee flung himself on to the dog. 
 &bquo;He's all right,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Get hold of him,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;And keep hold.&equo; 
 Lee got hold of the dog by its collar. 
 Philip picked up the roll of wire from beside the hide and clipped off a good length of wire. 
 &bquo;Twist that round his collar and make a loop the other end,&equo; said Philip, throwing Lee the wire. 
 It would have to be the right length as he wasn't giving Lee the cutters again. 
 Lee picked the wire up. 
 He'd stopped crying. 
 &bquo;Shall I make him a lead, then?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;That's what I said,&equo; said Philip, picking up the dead magpie. 
 &bquo;What did he shoot that bird for?&equo; said Lee, struggling to get the end of the wire fixed to Caspar's collar. 
 Caspar wasn't keeping still. 
 They re killers, magpies, said Philip. 
 &bquo;What d'you mean?, 
 Lee had managed to make the wire into some sort of makeshift lead. 
 Philip put his finger on the blue feathers that had other colours in, like petrol. 
 &bquo;They take baby birds out of their nests,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;That's cruel,&equo; said Lee, holding on to Caspar with two hands through the loop he'd made in the end of the wire. 
 Caspar was trying to get at the dead magpie that Philip was still holding.  
 It was cruel. 
 Last spring there'd been a blackbird's nest in the tree by the goal-post in the school playing-fields. 
 When he was supposed to be playing football he used to watch the parent birds taking stuff to the nest. 
 Then one day he heard the birds making a frightful racket and this huge magpie flew out of the tree. 
 Philip had shouted to the others and they'd all come running up. 
 The magpie had dropped the skinny pink baby bird at Philip's feet. 
 It was dead, or nearly. 
 Barry had flung it into the hedge. 
 Caspar was sniffing at the dead magpie. 
 Philip hoisted it with a stick so it hung over the branch of a tree. 
 Caspar leapt up, trying to get it. 
 &bquo;He's vicious,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It wasn't Caspar chasing those lambs,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;It was a dog like him, but it wasn't him.&equo; 
 &bquo;It won't do any good saying that,&equo; said Philip. 
 He couldn't make the boy out. 
 Was he stupid or was he lying? 
 It was hard to tell with someone like him. 
 Philip looked at him now holding Caspar with one hand and throwing bits of stick at the dead magpie to knock it off the branch. 
 What had he come up to Jubilee Wood for? 
 He had a feeling he'd never get rid of him. 
 He'd never get the message. 
 He was thick, thick between the ears. 
 Even Jack on the look-out with his gun wouldn't keep him away. 
 Look at him now. 
 Most people if their dog had nearly got shot would have gone, cleared off, but not him. 
 Philip walked back across the feeding-ground towards the ride. 
 There were still a few grains of corn left. 
 &bquo;Where are you going?&equo; said Lee coming after him. 
 Philip carried on. 
 &bquo;You going back home?&equo; 
 Philip turned suddenly, facing the boy and his dog. 
 &bquo;Look, it's none of your business where I go,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You coming back up here?&equo; 
 He walked on along the ride. 
 The boy ran after him. 
 &bquo;Where d'you live?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not telling you,&equo; said Philip.  
 He'd reached the place where the broken branch lay across the ride. 
 He began to climb over it. 
 Lee couldn't with the dog. 
 &bquo;If you don't stop following me I'll send Jack right round to your place. 
 I know where you live.&equo; 
 Lee stood there on the other side of the branch, holding Caspar with the lead made with his Dad's wire. 
 &bquo;That dog wasn't Caspar.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're a liar,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;And stupid.&equo; 
 Philip jumped off the branch and pushed it. 
 Lee, who'd begun to climb it, trying to pull Caspar over with him, lost his balance and fell. 
 He wasn't hurt and he didn't let go of Caspar but he howled, an awful wailing with his mouth open. 
 He didn't try to follow Philip, he turned and went off howling back along the ride. 
 Philip was disconcerted. 
 He wasn't expecting that. 
 He could hear him as he walked on towards the gate. 
 He could still hear him when he got there. 
 It was an awful noise like little kids you heard in the street when they fell down and their Mums dragged them along the pavement. 
 But Lee wasn't a little kid. 
 He was quite old, as old as him most likely. 
 Philip ran down through the field so he couldn't hear the noise any more. 
 It scared Philip. 
 It wasn't right. 
 He didn't understand it. 
 When he was upset the noise was all inside him. 
 Philip pulled his bike out of the ditch. 
 He'd better get a move on. 
 It was nearly dinner-time. 
 His Mum had dinner on the table. 
 &bquo;Didn't you get any more books then?&equo; she said. 
 Philip stopped dead in the kitchen. 
 He'd completely forgotten he was supposed to have been to the library. 
 Everything that had happened up in the wood had put it out of his head. 
 Even now as he stood there by the kitchen table he could see Caspar closing in on the weaker lamb, and he could hear that weird and terrible wailing of Lee's. 
 &bquo;I just took the others back,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'll get some more next time.&equo;  
 &bquo;Sit down, then. 
 Your sausages are getting cold.&equo; 
 Philip sat down at the table. 
 &bquo;Did you see anyone from school, any of your class?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip. 
 He hoped Lee would leave his books alone and his notebook. 
 And the helmet, he'd probably take that. 
 Then what would he say to Uncle Walter? 
 &bquo;I've told you,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;You're very welcome to bring your friends home to tea &mdash; if it's a day I don't work.&equo; 
 Not likely, thought Philip. 
 That was one of the reasons he liked living out at Little Knoll, so he could have his own life, his own place that none of them at school knew about. 
 Ask them home to tea. 
 His Mum must be mad. 
 He stuck his fork in his sausage. 
 Anyway they wouldn't come. 
 They didn't like him. 
 His Mum helped him to mash and peas. 
 He'd once tried to explain to her that he wasn't popular, that people didn't like him, but she wouldn't have it, so he'd given up. 
 &bquo;There's nothing wrong with you,&equo; she'd said. 
 But she would say that. 
 She was his Mum. 
 Barry saw plenty wrong with him. 
 Philip split his sausage down the middle. 
 He didn't care; he had his own life in his own place &mdash; or had. 
 He suddenly had a vision of Lee tearing up his note-book and wearing his helmet. 
 He put his knife and fork down. 
 &bquo;You all right?&equo; said his Mum. 
 She had that envelope out again, the one that his Dad had been looking at last night. 
 &bquo;Fine,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;And while we're talking of friends,&equo; said his Mum, sitting down beside him with her tea. 
 &bquo;I've been hearing a few things about this boy that s come to live at Beech Place. 
 I don't want you to have anything to do with him.&equo; 
 &bquo;What things?&equo; 
 &bquo;He goes to Garth House for a start.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's it for, that school?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Difficult children.&equo; 
 &bquo;Difficult how?&equo;  
 &bquo;What are you so interested for?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not. 
 I just asked a question. 
 Difficult how?&equo; 
 His Mum helped herself to peas and poured him lemonade. 
 &bquo;He's violent.&equo; 
 Philip speared his peas. 
 Lee hadn't seemed violent to him. 
 It was him, Philip, that had been violent. 
 It was Lee that had the bleeding nose, not him. 
 &bquo;Anyway your Dad and I don't want you to have anything to do with him, and that's it.&equo; 
 Philip trailed his fork through his mash, making a track. 
 Then there was a knock at the door and he jerked the fork, spoiling his pattern. 
 &bquo;Whoever's that?&equo; said his Mum going through to the front door. 
 It was Jack and she brought him into the kitchen. 
 &bquo;Ask him,&equo; she said pointing at Philip. 
 &bquo;I've been in all morning.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have you seen owt of a black dog?&equo; said Jack to Philip. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip, making the pattern in his potato more elaborate. 
 &bquo;Up in't far field by Jubilee Wood?&equo; 
 Philip shook his head. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I haven't seen any dogs.&equo; 
 He didn't know what he was lying for. 
 He had a chance now to tell on Lee, to get him off his back, out of Jubilee Wood. 
 And he wasn't taking it. 
 He didn't know why. 
 He didn't care about Caspar, not if he was going to kill lambs, and he didn't care about Lee. 
 &bquo;Philip's been to the library,&equo; said his Mum. 
 She didn't like Jack because of the way he spoke, broad Yorkshire. 
 She said she couldn't understand him but she could. 
 &bquo;Aye,&equo; said Jack. 
 Philip knew he was looking at him but Philip kept looking down. 
 He'd made a regular spaghetti junction of his potato.  
 His Mum saw Jack out. 
 She didn't come back right away because the phone rang. 
 Philip looked at the clock. 
 If she didn't hurry she'd be late for work. 
 Philip wanted her to go. 
 He wanted to go up to Jubilee Wood again. 
 He had all his stuff to fetch down. 
 Apart from Lee messing with it Jack could go up again looking for Caspar. 
 He wouldn't give up. 
 If a dog was worrying his sheep he wouldn't rest. 
 Philip could hear his Mum on the phone. 
 She was on a long time. 
 He wondered who it was. 
 And Lee. 
 He didn't trust him up there in the wood on his own. 
 He could do anything. 
 He was most likely still in the wood. 
 He hadn't said anything about going home for tea. 
 Philip scraped up his potato and swallowed it fast. 
 Then he put on his anorak. 
 His Mum was still on the phone. 
 He looked at his plate. 
 He'd left his sausage and the square of treacle tart she'd put out for his pudding. 
 He put the cold sausage and the slice of tart in his pocket. 
 He often got hungry up in the wood and he'd most likely want them later. 
 &bquo;Come on, then,&equo; said his Mum, coming back into the kitchen. 
 &bquo;Get that garage door open.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; said Philip, staring at her. 
 &bquo;Because you're coming to Thirkett with me, that's why.&equo; 
 Philip's hand closed round the greasy sausage in his pocket and the treacle tart. 
 The pastry crumbled. 
 &bquo;Why? 
 You never said.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't know, did I.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why do I have to come?&equo; 
 His Mum hadn't taken him to work with her since last year. 
 &bquo;Your Dad and me's got something to show you.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll know soon enough.&equo;  
 Philip went out and opened the garage door. 
 He'd have to leave Lee now; up there in the wood on his own. 
 He was convinced he'd take the helmet. 
 It was obvious. 
 He was only waiting for a chance. 
 If Philip had had any sense he'd have brought it down with him, that and the other stuff. 
 He'd most likely nick his Dad's wire and cutters too. 
 There was nothing to stop him. 
 His Mum backed the car out and he got in. 
 &bquo;What are we going for, Mum?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wait and see.&equo; 
 She sounded as if it was something he was going to be pleased about. 
 But there wasn't anything. 
 The only thing he wanted right now was to go back to Jubilee Wood. 
 They were passing Mrs Wright's. 
 Philip glanced quickly through the gates. 
 Mrs Wright had her car out. 
 She was most likely going to fix up about someone shutting the hens up for her instead of him, going to see the other boy. 
 Philip opened the car window. 
 It was stifling. 
 He knew who the other boy was. 
 It was Lee. 
 He was the only other boy living near the village. 
 It was him she must have been thinking of. 
 Well, she wouldn't find him at home. 
 And good luck to her with Lee. 
 He wouldn't ask Lee to do anything. 
 You couldn't trust him. 
 And there was Caspar. 
 He'd seen Caspar down at Mrs Wright's, hadn't he. 
 The arrangement wouldn't work out. 
 Philip shut the window. 
 He didn't want it to work out. 
 He didn't want Lee to lock the hens up instead of him. 
 &bquo;She shouldn't drive a car,&equo; said his Mum, who'd seen the car out too. 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; said Philip.  
 &bquo;She's too old. 
 She's a danger on the roads. 
 People like her should live near the shops.&equo; 
 &bquo;What if she doesn't want to?&equo; 
 &bquo;She'd be better off in a house in Thirkett than stuck out here in that great barn of a place. 
 As likely as not, she'll get burgled one of these fine days.&equo; 
 The dental surgery where his Mum worked was on the outskirts of Thirkett. 
 It was just an ordinary house with the waiting-room and surgery downstairs and a flat above. 
 Philip hated coming here. 
 He hated the smell and the noise of the drill you could hear from the treatment room. 
 His Mum made him sit on one of the chairs that were all round the walls and look at the magazines. 
 Everyone thought he was a patient and kept looking at him when his Mum called names out. 
 He knew they were wondering why there wasn't anyone with him. 
 He used to feel himself going red every time. 
 Once Barry's Mum had brought Barry with her and Mr Field, the dentist, had said they could go into the garden at the back. 
 Barry had pulled all the yellow tulips up and blamed him. 
 He'd never been in the garden again, though Mr Field said he could. 
 Barry's Mum got up from the desk as they went into the waiting-room, and put her coat on. 
 Philip's Mum took over from her at two. 
 &bquo;Hello, Philip,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I haven't seen you in a long time.&equo; 
 She waited before she put her arm into her coat. 
 &bquo;You don't grow much.&equo; 
 Philip didn't say anything. 
 He had grown a lot in the last few months. 
 His Dad measured it. 
 Philip didn't like her. 
 She thought Barry was the best. 
 She looked at her watch. 
 &bquo;I'd better be going,&equo; she said. 
 Philip supposed she didn't know about Barry breaking his watch-strap. 
 She wouldn't believe it anyway. 
 &bquo;See you later,&equo; she said to Philip's Mum and went out. 
 Philip sat down on the chair near the desk. 
 There weren't many people waiting. 
 He was pleased.  
 &bquo;What did she mean?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;See you later.&equo; 
 But his Mum didn't answer. 
 She picked up the phone. 
 &bquo;I'll ring your Dad now.&equo; 
 &bquo;What for?&equo; said Philip. 
 But his Mum was dialling. 
 His Dad worked not far away. 
 He was an electrician. 
 &bquo;He won't be there,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;He's taking a late dinner hour,&equo; said his Mum. 
 Philip slipped down his chair, stretching his feet out. 
 The woman opposite stuck her feet out too, so Philip pulled his in under his chair. 
 His Mum had acted like this before, all secretive, he remembered now, when they'd taken him to choose his bike, his last birthday. 
 It had been all whispers and lies till they got to the shop. 
 But it wasn't his birthday now. 
 Philip stared at the picture on the wall opposite. 
 It was for children, rabbits having a picnic in a wood with toadstools, birds. 
 The birds weren't anything he knew and he'd never seen toadstools like that with spots on. 
 &bquo;Yes, I've brought Philip,&equo; his Mum was saying. 
 &bquo;No, I haven't told him. 
 See you in ten minutes, then.&equo; 
 She put down the phone. 
 Philip looked sideways at the girl sitting next to him. 
 He could see the name-tape on her sock. 
 Polly Scott. 
 Polly. 
 That was a stupid name for a girl. 
 It was what they called parrots. 
 Philip sat up straight suddenly, knocking the daffodils on the desk. 
 A parrot. 
 Of course. 
 That was it. 
 They'd relented, his Mum and Dad, and they were going to give him a parrot for Easter. 
 They were keeping it a secret and they were going to take him some place where they sold parrots. 
 There wasn't a pet shop in Thirkett. 
 &bquo;Great,&equo; he said half aloud. 
 The girl beside him thought he was saying something to her and looked away. 
 &bquo;There's your Dad now,&equo; said his Mum looking out of the window. 
 Philip lifted a corner of the net curtain in the window.  
 His Dad had pulled up on the other side of the road. 
 He was in his work van. 
 Philip watched him cross the road. 
 He looked quite cheerful. 
 His Mum must have persuaded him about the parrot. 
 &bquo;You've checked it's all right for us to go?&equo; said his Mum to his Dad as he carne into the waiting-room. 
 &bquo;Two-thirty,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;Right, then,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Moira'll take over till I get back, I've asked her.&equo; 
 Moira was Mr Field's assistant. 
 &bquo;Come on then, Philip,&equo; said his Dad. 
 And something about his voice made Philip think perhaps it wasn't to be a parrot after all. 
 &bquo;Where are we going?&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll see.&equo; 
 He didn't see, not even when they got in the car and his Dad drove off. 
 They weren't going in the direction of the shops or the Sports Centre, he knew that. 
 It was more like in the direction of the school. 
 But they wouldn't be going there. 
 It was holidays. 
 His Dad turned off the road they were in, into one lined with trees. 
 He knew where they were now. 
 They were near Barry's house. 
 Barry lived on an estate on the side of Thirkett farthest away from Little Knoll. 
 Philip had been to Barry's house once with his Mum. 
 Luckily for him Barry hadn't been there. 
 Now his Dad was turning right into the estate. 
 &bquo;It's in the same road as the Butlers,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;Number forty-five, Hill View Road.&equo; 
 &bquo;They're number forty-eight,&equo; said his Mum. 
 Philip looked out at the houses, some of the front gardens still had pockets of dirty snow in them. 
 There were no fences between the gardens. 
 By one path was the remains of a snowman. 
 There were children everywhere. 
 Philip looked straight ahead. 
 &bquo;What have we come here for?&equo; he said.  
 A boy looked out of a toy wigwam and fired an arrow with a rubber end at the car. 
 He missed. 
 &bquo;You'll see in a minute,&equo; said his Mum. 
 His Dad parked the car near the end of the road. 
 Philip saw a woman's hand with rings lift the lacy white curtain of one of the houses. 
 &bquo;Number forty-five,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;That's it.&equo; 
 Philip leant back in the car. 
 He'd seen Barry on his BMX. 
 He was doing wheelies on a steep bank with a wire fence at the top. 
 The other side of the fence was the recreation ground. 
 &bquo;Come on, then,&equo; said his Mum, putting the envelope back in her bag. 
 Philip looked at number forty-five. 
 In the other downstairs window of the house, not the one with the lacy curtains, was a bird-cage. 
 In it was a blue budgie. 
 Philip thought again of the parrot. 
 Maybe someone had one for sale and they'd advertized in the papers. 
 He tried to see through the net curtain but he could see nothing. 
 perhaps the house was full of caged birds owned by the lady with the rings. 
 He glanced at the bank. 
 Barry had gone off up the road on his bike. 
 He wasn't there any more. 
 That was something. 
 They got out of the car and his Dad rang the door-bell of number forty-five. 
 It was chimes. 
 The daffodils by the path weren't anything like out. 
 Some hadn't even got buds. 
 They were blind. 
 The woman with the rings opened the door. 
 &bquo;Come on in,&equo; she said. 
 Philip stepped into the hall. 
 The stairs were the kind you could see through. 
 Barry's house had had those kind of stairs. 
 At the bottom was a huge cheese plant. 
 &bquo;Where's the parrot?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;The parrot?&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Who said anything about a parrot?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's a budgerigar,&equo; said the woman. 
 &bquo;Would he like to see that?&equo;  
 &bquo;No, thanks,&equo; said Philip. 
 Why were they all treating him as if he was five years old. 
 He felt like screaming, screaming at them all. 
 But of course he didn't and none of them could see what he felt like. 
 He looked perfectly normal to them. 
 He wasn't feeling it. 
 And suddenly with the woman's cheese plant tickling his ear he thought of Lee up in Jubilee Wood, running down the ride howling. 
 &bquo;I'll show you upstairs first,&equo; said the woman. 
 &bquo;I've some more people coming at three.&equo; 
 Philip followed them up the open staircase and into the woman's bedroom. 
 &bquo;What do you think of the house, then?&equo; said his Mum. 
 His Dad was opening the door of a built-in cupboard. 
 Philip didn't know. 
 He didn't think much about houses. 
 &bquo;What are we going to buy?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;This house,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Maybe. 
 If we can afford it and they don't put up the price.&equo; 
 Philip stared at her. 
 He thought he couldn't have heard right. 
 &bquo;What for?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;To live in, what do you think.&equo; 
 &bquo;But what about our other house in Little Knoll?, 
 &bquo;We'd sell that. 
 To get the money.&equo; 
 Philip moved towards the window. 
 Out of it he could see Barry, his bike propped up against his house, mending his chain. 
 And they'd never told him. 
 They'd got it all planned behind his back. 
 His Mum came and put her arm round him. 
 He stood rigid. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; she said pointing out of the window at the toy wigwam. 
 Further up the street, some boys he recognized from his class were playing football. 
 &bquo;You'd have plenty of friends here.&equo; 
 Philip looked away in case they saw him. 
 On the dressing-table was a white china hand. 
 On each finger was a ring. 
 For some reason the hand reminded him of Mrs  Wright, though her hands weren't white. 
 They were brown and blotchy. 
 He looked out of the window again. 
 Out of the wigwam crawled the boy who d shot the arrow. 
 He was wearing a Red Indian suit. 
 &bquo;Well, what do you think of it?&equo; said his Mum. 
 He turned to go out of the room. 
 He didn't think anything of it. 
 Opposite was another room, smaller, that looked out the back. 
 It was dead tidy as if no one slept in it, though there was a bed. 
 Propped on the window-sill was a postcard of blue praying hands. 
 &bquo;There's only two bedrooms,&equo; said the woman. 
 &bquo;But they're a good size,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;And we don't need more than two.&equo; 
 &bquo;This one will be yours, son,&equo; said his Dad. 
 Philip saw the garden. 
 The daffodils were out here. 
 In the garden next door there was a climbing frame. 
 &bquo;The garden's not very big, I'm afraid,&equo; said the woman. 
 &bquo;It's bigger than the one we've got,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;We've only a yard and a bit out the front. 
 There's nowhere for Philip to play.&equo; 
 Philip couldn't believe it. 
 Nowhere for him to play. 
 He thought of Jubilee Wood, his hide, the pools. 
 &bquo;There's no children of his age in Little knoll. 
 It's lonely for him.&equo; 
 &bquo;And for you too,&equo; said the woman. 
 &bquo;There can't be much going on there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I'm all right,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;It's Philip we're thinking of.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, he'll have plenty of friends here,&equo; said the woman leading them downstairs again. 
 &bquo;The road's full of children.&equo; 
 The budgerigar was in the kitchen and Philip stayed in there when the rest went back into the living-room. 
 Through the window he could see Barry still fixing his chain. 
 Philip pushed the bell in the cage with his finger. 
 Why hadn't they told him? 
 He didn't want to move. 
 He didn't want to live here right opposite Barry. 
 He wanted to  stay where he was. 
 They'd never asked him. 
 They'd picked this house without saying a word to him. 
 Philip opened the cage door. 
 The bird shuffled along its perch. 
 He put his finger in but it wouldn't hop on to it. 
 Stupid thing. 
 He shut the cage door. 
 And jumped. 
 He heard a noise at the window. 
 There was Barry, his face like a monster mask, his nose and lips flattened against the glass. 
 Philip walked quickly out into the hall. 
 &bquo;What did you think of Joey, then?&equo; said the woman. 
 &bquo;He's all right,&equo; said Philip. 
 Through the glass in the door he saw Barry running across the road. 
 &bquo;Goodbye, then,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;We'll be in touch.&equo; 
 The woman opened the door and they went out. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; said his Mum looking back at the house. 
 &bquo;There's one of those arrows sticking to the door.&equo; 
 And she laughed. 
 His Dad pulled the arrow off the door and gave it to him. 
 &bquo;You can take that back,&equo; he said. 
 Philip shook his head. 
 He was looking down at the pavement outside the house. 
 Someone had marked it with chalk. 
 &bquo;That's nice,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Hopscotch.&equo; 
 Philip looked at the chalking again. 
 It wasn't squares for hopscotch. 
 It was writing: NUTCASE. 
 &bquo;Well, what did you think of it?&equo; said his Mum as they drove off. 
 &bquo;I don't want to live there,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Yes you do,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;You're just saying that.&equo; 
 Philip pulled the rubber suction disc off the arrow. 
 Then he broke the arrow in half. 
 Winding down the window, he threw the bits out into the road. 
 A big new car, driven by a woman in a fur coat, ran over them. 
 What was the use of saying anything if it wasn't what they wanted? 
 They wanted him to like this house but he didn't, and he wasn't saying so just so they'd feel better. 
 &bquo;Your Mum and me like it,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;And it looks like we'll be moving there, if she sticks to the asking price, so you'd better get used to the idea. 
 I've had enough of your stubbornness.&equo; 
 Philip knew he was thinking about the swimming, the way he objected to spending all his time training and how he tried to get out of it. 
 He didn't mind. 
 Maybe his Dad would get the message one day. 
 Of course his Dad liked the house in Hill View Road; it was only ten minutes walk from the Sports Centre. 
 He wasn't stupid. 
 He saw his plan and his Mum's too. 
 She thought that if there were loads of other kids around he'd be forced to play with them. 
 And she'd like that. 
 She'd think it was natural. 
 She'd be happy. 
 Philip watched as the wigwam boy kicked a football at the snowman. 
 He hit it and its head dropped off. 
 His Mum turned to look at the car that had crushed the arrow bits. 
 &bquo;Did you see her, Dennis? 
 I reckon that's the other person, the one she said was coming, to view the house at three. 
 It is. 
 She's stopped outside and she's looking at it. 
 What'll we do, Den?&equo;  
 &bquo;There's nothing we can do. 
 I've told you, we can't afford a penny more than the asking price.&equo; 
 &bquo;She looks made of money,&equo; said Philip's Mum, waving to Barry's Mum who was in her garden. 
 &bquo;Stop a minute,&equo; she said to his Dad. 
 His Dad pulled up by the fence and wound his window down. 
 &bquo;Did you like it?&equo; said Barry's Mum. 
 &bquo;It's nice,&equo; said Philip's Mum. 
 &bquo;There's lots of people interested,&equo; said Barry's Mum. 
 She looked at Philip. 
 &bquo;You taking Philip back with you to work?&equo; 
 &bquo;No choice,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Barry will be back in a minute. 
 He's only off looking for Rebel. 
 He's the devil for going off. 
 Why don't you leave Philip here and collect him when you finish?&equo; 
 &bquo;Philip,&equo; said his Mum, turning round in the car so she could see him, &bquo;Joyce is asking if you'd like to stop here with Barry instead of coming back to work with me.&equo; 
 He'd heard, hadn't he? 
 He wasn't deaf. 
 She didn't have to repeat everything. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; 
 His Mum was looking at him. 
 She wanted him to stay. 
 There was no way he was going to. 
 He hunched up against the back of the car. 
 &bquo;I've got a headache.&equo; 
 He had. 
 That house had given him a headache. 
 &bquo;Gets a lot of headaches, doesn't he?&equo; said Barry's Mum. 
 And he knew that she didn't believe him. 
 He was off school quite often with headaches. 
 Barry had most likely told her he was skiving. 
 And she'd believe him. 
 &bquo;It's his eyes,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;What a pity he has to wear specs,&equo; said Barry's Mum. 
 &bquo;Can't be helped,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;He gets it from my side. 
 His Uncle Walter's always been short-sighted.&equo; 
 His Dad started the car. 
 &bquo;See you next week,&equo; said his Mum and his Dad drove on.  
 &bquo;At least there's normal people in this place,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Not like in Little Knoll.&equo; 
 Philip didn't think there was much normal about Barry's Mum, the way she thought Barry was perfect. 
 And the woman in the house. 
 She wasn't normal either. 
 Not with all those hands everywhere. 
 It gave you the creeps. 
 He reckoned Mrs Wright was more normal than her. 
 Out of the window he saw not Barry but Barry's dog. 
 It crossed the road and his Dad had to brake to avoid it. 
 &bquo;That's Butlers&equo; dog, isn't it?&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;It's no collar,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;They should put a collar on it.&equo; 
 Philip twisted round so he could see the dog better. 
 It was the same kind of dog as Caspar. 
 You could say it was identical except for the collar. 
 Then he remembered. 
 The dog that had jumped over the fence into Jubilee Wood hadn't been wearing a collar. 
 He was sure of it. 
 He'd seen it quite clearly. 
 Caspar had had a collar. 
 Lee had been right. 
 It wasn't Caspar that had been after the lambs. 
 It had been a dog just like him, a dog like Rebel. 
 But it couldn't have been Rebel. 
 Dogs didn't wander that far. 
 Back at the dentist's the waiting-room was packed. 
 His Dad came in with them into the entrance lobby. 
 &bquo;You'll phone the Agents, then,&equo; he said to his Mum. 
 &bquo;Right now,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I'll phone them right now. 
 I didn't like what Joyce said about lots of people being interested in the house. 
 It's got me worried.&equo; 
 Philip followed her into the waiting-room. 
 A house. 
 A house in Hill View Road. 
 And he thought they were going to buy him a parrot. 
 You had to laugh. 
 But he didn't feel like laughing. 
 Not at all he didn't. 
 His Mum didn't phone right away. 
 She couldn't because she was too busy. 
 Philip leant against the wall as there wasn't a chair for him. 
 Two hours he'd have to wait. 
 His Mum didn't finish till half-five. 
 And Lee would most likely be all that time in Jubilee Wood, him and Caspar.  
 His Mum was phoning now; no one was answering at the other end. 
 She put her hand over the receiver. 
 &bquo;That helmet,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;The one your Uncle Walter gave you, where is it? 
 I didn't see it this morning when I was turning out your room.&equo; 
 Philip, his legs tired with standing and his head throbbing, slid down on the floor. 
 He knew where his helmet was. 
 Lee would be wearing it. 
 He saw him in his mind's eye, running through the wood wearing Uncle Walter's helmet and firing a make-believe gun at the spy planes. 
 &bquo;You haven't gone and lost it, have you?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 &bquo;You didn't take it to school?&equo; 
 He shook his head. 
 She must be joking. 
 He wouldn't take it to school for Barry and his mates to kick round the playground. 
 &bquo;Well, you'd better find it. 
 Uncle Walter won't be too pleased if you've lost it.&equo; 
 She was right about that. 
 Uncle Walter hadn't really wanted to part with it. 
 &bquo;How's your headache?&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Bad,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Can't I go back home?&equo; 
 &bquo;How?&equo; said his Mum, flicking through the line of records in the drawer. 
 He couldn't. 
 There was no bus. 
 More people came in, a whole family. 
 Philip squeezed against the wall. 
 &bquo;Can I go to the library?&equo; 
 Any place would be better than this. 
 He couldn't stand it. 
 &bquo;What, again?&equo; 
 &bquo;There's things I can look at.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right, then, I'll pick you up when I finish.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll go home with Dad,&equo; said Philip. 
 His Dad sometimes finished at five. 
 &bquo;All right, then. 
 Take care.&equo;  
 Philip was thankful to get out of the crowded waiting-room. 
 It was quite cold outside. 
 There was a wind. 
 But he didn't mind that. 
 His head felt better already. 
 He thought about walking home. 
 But it was too far. 
 The library was over the other side of the town. 
 He had to go through the shopping centre to get there, and the market-place. 
 The market-place was used as a car-park. 
 As he walked between the lines of cars he saw that one of them was parked so it was sticking out. 
 Looking at it he saw that it was Mrs Wright's. 
 He looked in. 
 On the back seat was a sack of grain and a box of cartridges. 
 He was curious about them. 
 Was it rats or dogs she was going to shoot? 
 Or both. 
 &bquo;Hello, Philip.&equo; 
 He jumped, feeling guilty about staring into the car. 
 &bquo;So you've got some more hen-food then,&equo; he said for something to say. 
 He thought of the grain he'd pinched yesterday, spilt and lost. 
 &bquo;If you come back with me you can help me take it out the other end.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've got to go to the library,&equo; said Philip, walking on. 
 He felt bad. 
 She'd most likely think it was because he didn't want to help her. 
 He'd never thought how she got the sacks out of her car. 
 They were very heavy. 
 He pressed the button at the pelican crossing and waited. 
 The lights changed and he was pushed by someone behind him. 
 But he didn't cross. 
 He just stood there and the lights changed again. 
 Why didn't he go back with Mrs Wright? 
 There was nothing stopping him. 
 If he went back with Mrs Wright he could nip up to Jubilee Wood, check his hide and maybe get his helmet back off Lee. 
 His Mum and Dad wouldn't worry. 
 They'd each think the other was taking him home. 
 He'd have to take the flak for having a lift with Mrs Wright. 
 Right now he didn't care. 
 He turned and went back up the rows of cars. 
 She hadn't gone. 
 She was still trying to get out of the parking space.  
 He went to the driver's side and shouted through the window. 
 She wound it down. 
 &bquo;I've changed my mind,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;About the library.&equo; 
 &bquo;Get in, then,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 She'd got the car out of the space. 
 Philip ran round the other side and got in beside her. 
 They bumped off over the cobbles. 
 Philip didn't know much about driving but he thought that maybe she was in the wrong gear. 
 He didn't mind. 
 He'd be back home in ten or fifteen minutes. 
 He couldn't believe his luck. 
 &bquo;There were two eggs today,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;What will you do with them?&equo; said Philip. 
 He remembered what she'd said about not being able to eat eggs. 
 Then he felt embarrassed. 
 Maybe she would think that he wanted them. 
 &bquo;The other boy can have them,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I called at his house on the way in. 
 He was out, but his mother says she'll tell him, and that he will shut the hens up for me when I have to go out to visit my friend. 
 She's no objection. 
 It's a great relief to me,&equo; she added. 
 Philip looked at the floor of the car again. 
 She needn't go on making him feel guilty. 
 It wasn't his fault. 
 &bquo;He's got a dog,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;I heard it. 
 It was locked up somewhere round at the back. 
 It barked when I drove in.&equo; 
 That was something. 
 Caspar wasn't still out loose. 
 &bquo;I hope you're not in too much hurry to get home,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; said Philip. 
 He was. 
 He was in a hurry. 
 &bquo;Because I'm not going straight back to Little Knoll.&equo; 
 Philip looked at her. 
 She wasn't. 
 She was going out of Thirkett on the Atherton Road. 
 &bquo;Where are you going?&equo; said Philip. 
 This wasn't what he'd planned at all, a detour. 
 &bquo;To my friend's,&equo; said Mrs Wright, wandering over the road a bit. 
 A car sounded its horn at her.  
 &bquo;Where does your friend live?&equo; asked Philip, dreading the answer. 
 If it was Atherton he'd never get up into the wood and back before his Dad carne home. 
 &bquo;It's not far,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 Philip looked out of the window. 
 That didn't tell him much. 
 He hated seeing the fields slipping past, the wrong ones. 
 They must have gone at least three miles along the Atherton Road already. 
 And she was going faster, a lot faster. 
 She didn't drive at a steady speed like his Mum. 
 He looked at her hands on the steering-wheel. 
 Like the woman in the house in Hill View Road, her hands were covered in rings. 
 He bet they were valuable. 
 He wondered if she hung them on a china hand at night when she went to bed. 
 &bquo;There'll be three eggs tomorrow, you see,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 They were a long way out of Thirkett now. 
 They'd be in Atherton soon at this rate. 
 &bquo;Where does your friend live?&equo; said Philip again. 
 &bquo;The other side of Atherton,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 Philip opened his mouth in horror, then turned it quickly into a yawn when Mrs Wright looked at him. 
 That was it, then. 
 He wouldn't get up to Jubilee Wood before his Mum and Dad got back from work. 
 He didn't dare ask how far the other side of Atherton. 
 He wished he'd had more sense than to get a lift with Mrs Wright. 
 But it was too late now. 
 There was nothing he could do about it. 
 He wished she'd told him she was going to see her friend before he got into the car. 
 After Atherton they turned left, then left again up a lane. 
 It was full of pot-holes and the car lurched. 
 The cartridges on the back seat fell on to the floor. 
 Philip leant back and picked them up. 
 He hadn't known the box would be so heavy. 
 There must be masses in there. 
 &bquo;Here we are,&equo; said Mrs Wright stopping by an isolated house with a large untidy garden. 
 &bquo;I'll wait in the car, shall I?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;You can come in,&equo; said Mrs Wright.  
 Philip didn't want to. 
 He was shy with people. 
 He didn't want to meet Mrs Wright's friend. 
 And his Mum wouldn't approve. 
 If she didn't like him talking to Mrs Wright, she wouldn't like him meeting her friend and going into her house. 
 &bquo;No, it's all right,&equo; said Philip. 
 There was a wood on one side. 
 He heard a pheasant call and almost called back from habit. 
 He only just stopped himself in time. 
 &bquo;Out you get,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 So he got out of the car. 
 He didn't reckon he had much choice. 
 He followed Mrs Wright through the gate, up a path full of grass to the front door. 
 Mrs Wright didn't ring the bell or knock, she took a key out of her pocket and opened it. 
 Philip thought that maybe Mrs Wright's friend was an invalid and couldn't come to the door to open it. 
 He imagined an old white lady like a ghost in a wheel-chair. 
 Aunt Edith, Uncle Walter's wife, had been like that before she died. 
 There was a pile of letters on the floor inside the door. 
 &bquo;Pick those up, will you,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 Philip picked them up and followed Mrs Wright down a long, flagged passage. 
 He looked at the letters. 
 They were addressed to a Mrs Dorothy Soper. 
 He was still looking at the envelopes as they went into a sitting-room at the end of the passage. 
 It was a big room and looked out the back. 
 The grass in the garden was nose-high. 
 There was bright pink blossom on a tree. 
 The room was empty. 
 &bquo;Where is she?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Your friend?&equo; 
 He was still holding the letters. 
 &bquo;Is she away?&equo; 
 Mrs Wright took the letters from him and tore them. 
 She dropped the bits into a waste paper basket. 
 &bquo;She's dead,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;She died two months ago.&equo;  
 Philip gaped at her. 
 So his Mum and Dad were right after all. 
 She was mad. 
 When she said she'd been going to visit her friend, there'd been no friend. 
 Her friend was dead. 
 Philip looked around him uneasily. 
 He noticed, looking out of the window that there was a lot of snow left in the garden, white, not dirtied at all, piled up against the fence. 
 Mrs Wright lifted a vase of flowers that was on a small table by the door so that she could see how much water was in. 
 Who had put the flowers there? 
 Her? 
 And Philip remembered how he'd seen her go out two weeks ago with yellow flowers in the back seat of the car. 
 These were they now, shrivelled and dropping petals on to the carpet. 
 &bquo;They're going to sell the house,&equo; she said, leaving the room with the dying forsythia. 
 She was still saying something but Philip couldn't hear what. 
 He had to go after her. 
 He found her in a small kitchen. 
 A door led out into the garden. 
 Mrs Wright put the flowers down on the draining-board, took a key out of her pocket, and unlocked the door. 
 &bquo;Get some more,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Some more of that blossom.&equo; 
 It didn't occur to Philip not to do what she said. 
 He'd been a bit scared of her before, but he was even more so now she was acting as if she wasn't right in the head. 
 He looked at her more closely as she poured the stale brownish water from the vase down the sink. 
 She didn't look any different. 
 She looked the same as usual; untidy, a hole in her coat where she'd caught it on a hook in the yard. 
 He remembered her ripping it the day she'd taken him to see the hens for the first time. 
 &bquo;What are you waiting for?&equo; she said. 
 He wasn't waiting for anything. 
 It had just taken him by  surprise, her wanting to put flowers in an empty house. 
 His Mum only put flowers if people were coming. 
 She always picked flowers for Uncle Walter, for instance. 
 &bquo;It's not dead, you know,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;The house.&equo; 
 Philip opened the door. 
 &bquo;Take these,&equo; she said, opening a drawer and taking out a pair of kitchen scissors. 
 Philip went out into the garden, stepping into a patch of snow that lay by the step. 
 He jumped up, pulling the lower branches of the tree down and clipped off stems, letting them fall to the ground. 
 How much did she want? 
 He didn't know. 
 He cut a lot to be on the safe side. 
 But he felt guilty. 
 His Dad didn't approve of picking blossom; you didn't get the fruit. 
 His Dad would be back from work soon, then his Mum. 
 When they discovered he wasn't home, they'd phone the police. 
 He gathered up the blossom and took it back into the house. 
 Mrs Wright put it in the vase that she'd filled with fresh water. 
 &bquo;You can put it in there,&equo; she said, pointing to the sitting-room. 
 Philip took the vase and put it on the table where it had been before, wiping off some of the dust with his elbow. 
 Mrs Wright wiped the rest with her handkerchief. 
 He thought they'd be going now but he was wrong. 
 Mrs Wright sat down on one of the chairs and took out her cigarettes. 
 &bquo;Sit down,&equo; she said. 
 Philip knew that she was irritated by his being there, that she wanted to be on her own. 
 He sat on a chair that was embroidered, like the thing you knelt on in church. 
 He wished he knew what the time was. 
 There were two clocks in the room but they had both stopped. 
 &bquo;I have to get back,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;My Mum and Dad'll be worried about me.&equo; 
 She nodded and lit her cigarette with a lighter. 
 Philip had never seen her smoke before.  
 &bquo;I shan't keep you long,&equo; she said. 
 There was silence. 
 Philip watched her smoking her cigarette. 
 Most likely when she'd finished that, they'd go. 
 But she was slow letting it burn. 
 Philip watched the lengthening tail of ash. 
 He could, because Mrs Wright wasn't looking at him. 
 She was staring out of the window. 
 Suddenly she jumped up and the ash dropped to the floor. 
 In the garden was a huge magpie. 
 Philip thought of Jack shooting the magpie up in Jubilee Wood while he and Lee hid in the bracken. 
 It had been a close thing. 
 &bquo;I'll bring my gun next time,&equo; said Mrs Wright putting her cigarette down in an ash-tray. 
 She banged on the glass and the magpie flew up into the blossom-tree. 
 &bquo;Come on, then,&equo; she said. 
 Philip looked at the half-smoked cigarette in the ashtray. 
 &bquo;Put it in the fire-place,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 Philip went over to the fire-place and emptied out the cigarette. 
 In the fire-place were masses of cigarette stubs. 
 He stared at them. 
 Did she come to this empty house and smoke? 
 It was a queer going on, as his Uncle Walter would say. 
 He shivered. 
 He wouldn't be sorry to get out of this house. 
 It was cold like all empty houses were. 
 As they came out of the house Philip saw two girls, quite old. 
 One of them was trying the gate. 
 &bquo;Here,&equo; said Mrs Wright, giving him the front door key. 
 &bquo;Lock it, will you, while I have a word with those two.&equo; 
 But though she walked quickly towards the gate the two girls ran off up the lane. 
 Philip saw what he hadn't seen before, a &bquo;For Sale&equo; notice stuck in a holly bush by the corner of the house. 
 He wished he hadn't spotted it as it made him think of this morning and going round the house in Hill View Road, and the idea his Mum and Dad had about moving. 
 He ran quickly to the car, not looking at the sign again. 
 Would they put one of those outside his house? 
 Where? 
 In  the lilac. 
 He'd pull it down if they did. 
 There was a blackbird's nest in there. 
 Mrs Wright opened the car door for him. 
 Then she turned the car and drove off down the lane. 
 There was no sign of the girls. 
 Philip wished she'd drive a bit faster. 
 He kept thinking of how his Mum and Dad would be when they found out he wasn't back, that he hadn't come home with either of them. 
 They'd think it was like the things you heard on the television news, about children going missing. 
 They were always on at him not to go with strangers. 
 Philip looked at the speedometer. 
 Forty-five miles an hour, he couldn't believe it. 
 Well, he hadn't gone with a stranger. 
 Mrs Wright wasn't a stranger. 
 He couldn't help it if Mrs Wright had taken him to visit her friend who wasn't there, who was dead. 
 It wasn't his fault. 
 He glanced sideways at Mrs Wright. 
 He saw that her coat was buttoned up wrong. 
 He would like to have told her but he didn't dare. 
 She always wore the same coat, to feed the hens, to go out, to go to church even. 
 But she couldn't be poor. 
 She could always sell those rings if she wanted money. 
 His Mum and Dad said she was rich. 
 He wouldn't tell them that the friend didn't exist, that she was dead, and that there was only the house that Mrs Wright visited and put flowers in. 
 They'd say she ought to be put away. 
 And he didn't want them saying that. 
 It was true what she said; the house wasn't dead. 
 It was empty and all locked up but it wasn't dead. 
 All locked up? 
 It wasn't. 
 Philip put his hand over his mouth. 
 Mrs Wright looked at him. 
 He took it away and tried to look normal but he felt awful. 
 Mrs Wright had given him the key to lock the door but he hadn't locked it. 
 Seeing the &bquo;For Sale&equo; sign had put it right out of his head. 
 He tried to persuade himself that he'd locked it but he knew he hadn't. 
 &bquo;Not far now,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 The speedometer swung to fifty and she overtook a tractor. 
 He should tell her. 
 People would get in, those girls maybe. 
 But he was only a mile and a half from Little Knoll. 
  If he told her she might go straight back and he wouldn't be home for hours. 
 By the time he got back there'd be search parties out looking for him. 
 He felt the key in his pocket. 
 He'd give it back to her when he got out of the car. 
 They were in Little Knoll now. 
 Philip could see the 
 church clock. 
 It was twenty-five to six. 
 And he could see his Mum and Dad outside the house talking to Jack. 
 They'd most likely be asking him if he'd seen him. 
 They turned and saw the car. 
 &bquo;Could you drop me off here?&equo; he said. 
 He didn't want Mrs Wright driving right up to his house. 
 But Mrs Wright turned in through her entrance. 
 &bquo;Here's the key,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;And Mrs Wright, I'm very sorry but I've just remembered I didn't lock the door. 
 I forgot.&equo; 
 He stumbled out of the car. 
 &bquo;Wait,&equo; she said. 
 He waited. 
 &bquo;I'll have to go straight back and lock it. 
 I can't leave it unlocked. 
 All sods of people walk up that lane.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sorry,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;So am I,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;I had thought you were reliable.&equo; 
 He was. 
 He was reliable. 
 He'd never once forgotten to lock up the hens when she'd asked him. 
 &bquo;Listen,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;That other boy who is going to do the hens for me is coming at six for me to show him what to do. 
 I arranged it with his mother. 
 As I've got to go back to Atherton, I want you to do it. 
 Will you?&equo; 
 She began coughing and put her hand to her chest, wheezing. 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; said Philip. 
 There wasn't anything else he could say. 
 It was his fault she had to go all the way back to the house. 
 She was still having trouble getting her breath. 
 &bquo;Are you all right?&equo; said Philip, scared. 
 She didn't look too good. 
 &bquo;I'm all right,&equo; she said. 
 She didn't look it. 
 Mrs Wright reversed out into the road again and drove off past the church.  
 Philip ran up the village. 
 His Mum and Dad came to meet him. 
 &bquo;Philip,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;Your Mum and I were just about to phone the police.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm all right,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Where have you been?&equo; 
 &bquo;To the library like I said. 
 Mrs Wright came in and she said she'd give me a lift home. 
 What's wrong?&equo; 
 &bquo;You told me you were going home with your Dad,&equo; said his Mum. 
 She wasn't pleased to see him any more. 
 She was angry. 
 They took him into the house and shut the door. 
 &bquo;You didn't go to the library,&equo; said his Mum. 
 Philip looked down. 
 He knew the pattern of the carpet by heart but now it was as if he were looking at it for the first time, taking it all in, the design of orange and black squares. 
 &bquo;I finished early and I called at the library for you. 
 I asked Miss Lofthouse if she'd seen you and she said you hadn't been in this afternoon.&equo; 
 That was stupid of him. 
 He avoided the library Friday afternoons, the day Miss Lofthouse helped out. 
 Still looking down, it seemed as if the pattern of squares was moving. 
 Philip tried to hold them steady. 
 &bquo;I changed my mind,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Where did you go, Philip?&equo; said his Dad, his hand heavy on Philip's shoulder. 
 &bquo;I met Mrs Wright on my way to the library,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;She was going back here so I came with her.&equo; 
 &bquo;So how come you weren't here when we got back? 
 You'll have to do better than that, son.&equo; 
 &bquo;Her car broke down,&equo; said Philip. 
 He'd got the pattern of the carpet under control now. 
 His Mum and Dad were always saying Mrs Wright would have trouble with her car the way she drove it. 
 &bquo;That's not true, is it?&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;If her car had broken down your Dad or me would have passed it on the road.&equo;  
 &bquo;Where did she take you?&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;Tell us, son.&equo; 
 &bquo;She had to see her friend,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;She had to take her some flowers.&equo; 
 &bquo;She hasn't got any friends,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;And she's not safe in a car.&equo; 
 &bquo;Philip,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;Tell us where you've been. 
 That's all we want to know.&equo; 
 &bquo;I told you,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I went with Mrs Wright to visit her friend Mrs Dorothy Soper.&equo; 
 He remembered the name on the letters that Mrs Wright had torn up. 
 &bquo;Mrs Dorothy Soper, Greystones, Quarry Lane, Atherton.&equo; 
 &bquo;No one lives there,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;It's empty, up for sale. 
 We had the details about it.&equo; 
 His Mum went to the drawer in his Dad's bureau and took out some papers, leafing through them. 
 &bquo;Here it is,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Greystones, Quarry Lane, Atherton.&equo; 
 Philip saw a photograph of the house he'd been to with Mrs Wright, only it was a different time of year. 
 There were holly berries on the holly tree. 
 &bquo;So don't try that one,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;A liar is what I won't have.&equo; 
 &bquo;Go to your room, Philip,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I've a good mind to go down to Mrs Wright's now and get to the bottom of this,&equo; said his Dad as Philip went upstairs. 
 &bquo;You won't find her,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;She's gone out.&equo;  
 Philip went into his room and shut the door, leaning against it. 
 He could hear them talking downstairs, not what they were saying, just their voices. 
 They were talking about him, he was sure of that. 
 Then he heard the noise of the phone being put down. 
 That was most likely his Dad phoning Mrs Wright. 
 Much good that would do him. 
 She'd be halfway to Atherton by now. 
 He wondered what the time was. 
 In his desk drawer was his watch with the broken strap. 
 It was six o'clock. 
 Lee would be down at Mrs Wright's now, waiting for her. 
 When she didn't come he'd go away again. 
 He wouldn't lock the hens up. 
 He wouldn't know what to do. 
 And Mrs Wright wouldn't check when she got back. 
 Why should she? 
 She'd asked Philip to help Lee and he'd said he would. 
 She'd discover he hadn't locked the hen-house when she went to let the hens out in the morning. 
 Philip sat down on his bed. 
 He was hot in his anorak. 
 As he took it off he remembered the sausage and treacle tart in his pocket. 
 He didn't feel like them now. 
 Anyway they'd be pretty disgusting, mixed with the bits in his pocket. 
 He could hear someone coming upstairs, his Mum. 
 She picked his anorak up off the floor and stood there with it over her arm, leaning against his chair. 
 &bquo;Why don't you tell us, Philip?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;What's the point of all this lying?&equo; 
 She came over and sat on the bed beside him. 
 &bquo;Did you go to the recreation ground, or to the shops, or back to Hill View to play with Barry?&equo; 
 Philip shook his head. 
 She must be mad if she thought he'd do that, go anywhere near Barry. 
 He hadn't forgotten what Barry had chalked on the pavement.  
 &bquo;I would have let you if you'd asked,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I told you what happened,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Mrs Wright asked if I wanted a lift home, then she went to that house, the one in the photograph.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you said you went to see her friend.&equo; 
 His Mum took him by the shoulders and turned him to face her. 
 &bquo;That house is empty, Philip. 
 It came on the market two months ago. 
 The estate agent said if we wanted to see it, we'd have to get the key from them.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can go to see empty houses,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;She did.&equo; 
 &bquo;Whatever for? 
 She's surely not thinking of moving there, is she?&equo; 
 Philip fiddled with the remaining strap of his watch. 
 &bquo;Her friend lived there.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's that got to do with it?&equo; 
 His Mum got up off his bed and went and opened his cupboard. 
 &bquo;Maybe the helmet your Uncle Walter gave you is in here.&equo; 
 She felt to the back of the shelf. 
 Philip was glad he'd left the wire and cutters up in the wood. 
 Not that it would make much difference if Lee got hold of them. 
 &bquo;If Uncle Walter died, I'd like to go to his house,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;What an idea,&equo; said his Mum shutting the cupboard door. 
 &bquo;No, it's not in there.&equo; 
 Of course it wasn't there. 
 It was up in Jubilee Wood, or on Lee's head. 
 &bquo;If I went to his house, I might see him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not if he was dead, you wouldn't,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Really, the things you do say. 
 Your Uncle Walter'll go on a long time yet, you see.&equo; 
 &bquo;I might,&equo; said Philip, &bquo;I might see his ghost.&equo; 
 His Mum came and sat down beside him again, smoothing his anorak. 
 He hoped she wouldn't find the sausage and the treacle tart. 
 He wished he'd eaten them now. 
 &bquo;Come down and have your tea.&equo; 
 &bquo;My headache's come back,&equo; said Philip.  
 &bquo;Pop into bed, then, and I'll bring it up,&equo; said his Mum, stroking his hair. 
 She did that quite often. 
 He wished she wouldn't. 
 &bquo;And no more about ghosts. 
 You don't want to think about things like that.&equo; 
 But he did. 
 Ghosts didn't scare him. 
 He wouldn't mind being haunted by Uncle Walter. 
 He'd quite like it. 
 Ghosts didn't have to be stupid and scary like in stories Mrs Mills read them. 
 He undressed and got into bed. 
 It was true; his headache had come back again but it wasn't that bad, not as bad as he got them in term-time. 
 It was his Dad who came up with his tea. 
 Philip hoped his Mum was following. 
 He didn't like being alone with his Dad. 
 But she wasn't. 
 &bquo;Well, son, how about it?&equo; he asked, giving Philip the tray. 
 Philip didn't know what that meant, so he didn't say anything. 
 He shook the sauce bottle and that was all the noise there was. 
 His Dad didn't go. 
 He was looking at the board at the end of Philip's bed that had his swimming certificates pinned to it. 
 &bquo;There's one missing,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Your five hundred metres.&equo; 
 &bquo;It fell off,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's in the drawer of my desk.&equo; 
 His Dad found the certificate and pinned it on the board, levelling the pins in the corners. 
 &bquo;Your thousand metres next,&equo; he said. 
 Philip trickled a line of sauce on each of his fish fingers. 
 &bquo;It will be a lot easier if we move to Thirkett. 
 Morning sessions.&equo; 
 Philip had always dreaded that, morning sessions. 
 Even with goggles, the chlorine in the water made his eyes red. 
 They'd take the mickey out of him at school for that. 
 &bquo;I don't want to move to Thirkett,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;There'd be no more gallivanting with nutcases like Mrs Wright,&equo; said his Dad and went out. 
 After his Mum had been up to say goodnight to him,  Philip lay a long time thinking and he couldn't keep out of his mind the thin chalk letters on the pavement in Hill View. 
 Nutcase. 
 That meant mad, a weirdo. 
 His Mum and Dad thought Mrs Wright was a nutcase, Barry thought he, Philip, was one. 
 He'd written it, hadn't he, on the pavement? 
 And Philip thought if anyone was a nutcase it was that boy in the wood. 
 Lee or whatever he was called. 
 He turned over, pushing his head under his pillow. 
 It didn't make sense. 
 When Philip woke, the first thing he thought of was the pheasants. 
 That was what he'd thought of every morning since he'd first started feeding them with Mrs Wright's grain. 
 There wouldn't be any for them today. 
 They'd come to the feeding-place and there'd be nothing there. 
 He wondered how long it would be before they gave up going to the clearing altogether. 
 Somehow he'd have to get up to the wood today to fetch down his Dad's clippers and wire. 
 He'd be mending the fence by the garage tomorrow, Saturday. 
 His Mum went to work this afternoon. 
 He'd have to somehow work it so he stayed behind. 
 He swallowed, checking for a sore throat, his ears. 
 There was nothing. 
 It would have to be a headache again. 
 If he didn't wear his glasses, he could bring one on. 
 Only thing was his Mum would take him to the opticians again. 
 Well, he didn't mind that except that it wasted time, time he could have used making his trap. 
 Philip dressed slowly. 
 He wasn't sure he wanted to make the trap now. 
 The whole idea that he'd been thinking about since Christmas seemed pointless all of a sudden. 
 It had begun to seem like the ideas he'd had when he was younger, that you worked out in school and at night in bed, that seemed so easy, then when it carne to it didn't work out. 
 He thought of his dam that had been to make a lake. 
 He tied his shoe laces, his feet on the chair. 
 A lake! 
 A muddy pond was all that he'd achieved. 
 Then the water had gradually seeped through, so it was normal again. 
 Now someone, most likely Lee, had bust it. 
 As he finished dressing he heard a knock on the front  door. 
 His Mum went to open it and then he heard it close again. 
 It was probably the milkman. 
 He'd taken to calling on Fridays for his money. 
 But it hadn't sounded like the milkman somehow. 
 His knock was different. 
 This had been more of a thump. 
 Philip went downstairs to the living-room where his Mum was vacuuming. 
 She switched off. 
 &bquo;Who do you think that was?&equo; 
 &bquo;Who?&equo; 
 &bquo;The boy that's come to live at Beech Place.&equo; 
 &bquo;What did he want?, 
 &bquo;He didn't say. 
 He just ran off. 
 That's all we need in this place &mdash; boys that knock on doors, then run off. 
 I told you he would be up to no good.&equo; 
 She looked at Philip. 
 &bquo;I don't want you to have anything to do with him, d'you hear.&equo; 
 Philip thought of him meeting Lee up in the wood. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Philip wondered why Lee had come to his house. 
 He didn't believe like his Mum, that Lee had been making trouble, knocking and then running off. 
 He made trouble all right but not like that. 
 He'd most likely wanted to tell Philip something. 
 He probably had a message from Mrs Wright, something about the hens. 
 Philip followed his Mum into the kitchen. 
 He wasn't sure he wanted to hear that message. 
 &bquo;Your Dad says I'm to take you to work again,&equo; said his Mum, putting the vacuum cleaner away. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; 
 &bquo;You know why, Philip. 
 After yesterday.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll be all right here.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what I said to your Dad but he wouldn't hear of it.&equo; 
 She pushed his feet out of the way with her broom. 
 &bquo;Look what trouble you've got yourself in telling those lies.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've got a headache,&equo; he said. 
 He had. 
 He hadn't put his glasses on when he got up. 
 &bquo;I'll have to take you to the optician's,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You get too many headaches.&equo;  
 &bquo;Can't I stay, Mum. 
 I'll be all right.&equo; 
 His Mum looked at him. 
 He knew she didn't want to take him with her. 
 &bquo;Oh, all right, then.&equo; 
 His Mum had finished sweeping and was wiping the cooker. 
 &bquo;But you're not to go out. 
 You're to stay indoors.&equo; 
 Philip hardly heard her. 
 On the broken fence by the garage was Lee, his sandy head bright in the sun. 
 He was making signs at Philip, mouthing something. 
 Philip went close to the glass door, standing between his Mum and it. 
 He waved at Lee to go away, but Lee climbed from the fence on to the garage roof, something Philip's Dad had forbidden him to do. 
 Then he ran his finger round his neck and held up three fingers of his left hand. 
 Just in time before his Mum turned from the cooker, he jumped off the roof. 
 &bquo;I'm going now,&equo; said his Mum putting on her coat. 
 &bquo;Why are you going so early?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I'm going to have a look at wall-papers. 
 We'll do all the rooms up fresh in that house in Hill View. 
 Is there anything you fancy in your room? 
 I've got my eye on some nice paper with birds on. 
 I thought you might like that, seeing as you're so keen on birds and that. 
 Birds of Paradise they were.&equo; 
 Philip remembered the room he'd seen yesterday, empty and dead, shaped like a shoe-box. 
 Birds of paradise would look ridiculous in there. 
 He watched his Mum go from the window, waving. 
 Then he went into the living-room and switched on the television. 
 She'd let him stay on his own at any rate. 
 She was never as strict as his Dad and she didn't like him getting in the way in the waiting-room. 
 Friday was always a busy day. 
 But it wouldn't be as easy as all that to get out. 
 She'd phone to see if he was all right and if he didn't answer the phone there'd be trouble. 
 There was nothing worth watching on television, so he went back into the kitchen. 
 He put three slices of bread and  some sultanas into a polythene bag. 
 It would be better than nothing for the pheasants. 
 He guessed his Mum would phone when she got to work and then maybe again when she took her break at half-three. 
 He was closing the bag up when there was another thump at the door. 
 On the door-step stood Lee. 
 &bquo;What are you doing here?&equo; 
 &bquo;I got something to tell you.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'd better come in, then.&equo; 
 Lee stepped into the living-room and Philip closed the door. 
 &bquo;They're dead,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Her hens.&equo; 
 Philip felt sick. 
 &bquo;What, all of them?, 
 &bquo;Three of them,&equo; said Lee. 
 Three. 
 There were eight altogether. 
 &bquo;It was a fox,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;She said so.&equo; 
 Philip thumped down on the settee. 
 Lee stood in the middle of the room. 
 Philip saw him staring at his Dad's swimming trophies. 
 For the first time he was proud of them. 
 &bquo;You seen her, then?&equo; 
 Lee nodded. 
 He picked up one of his Dad's cups and read the inscription. 
 &bquo;She phoned up. 
 She asked me to come round and I told her about you not showing up. 
 She was real cut-up about the hens. 
 She said she was going to shoot the fox that killed them. 
 She didn't care what people said. 
 She was going to shoot it.&equo; 
 Lee put the cup down. 
 &bquo;She was bad,&equo; he said, &bquo;coughing and that. 
 Who won these? 
 You?&equo; 
 &bquo;My Dad. 
 I just got certificates.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can I see them?, 
 &bquo;They're in my room.&equo; 
 Three hens. 
 That was dreadful and it was all his fault. 
 He went up the stairs with Lee after him. 
 &bquo;Their heads were bitten off,&equo; said Lee as they went into Philip's bedroom.  
 &bquo;That's foxes for you,&equo; said Philip. 
 Everybody knew that, what foxes did. 
 &bquo;This is a nice room,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip pointed at the display board with his certificates on. 
 &bquo;You got a lot of these,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip could see he was impressed. 
 He looked at the other things on Philip's wall, the pictures from the nature calendar, the photograph of Uncle Walter's brother, his Uncle John with his platoon in the War. 
 Uncle John had been killed in the War. 
 Uncle Walter had given him the photograph. 
 &bquo;Who are all of them?&equo; said Lee running his finger along the rows of heads. 
 &bquo;I don't know,&equo; said Philip. 
 He was beginning to wish he hadn't brought Lee up to his room. 
 He'd knocked the pictures crooked and now he was fiddling with the things on Philip's desk, his pens and Sellotape. 
 Philip put the picture straight and shut the cupboard that Lee had opened. 
 When he turned round, Lee was closing the drawer in his desk. 
 Then Lee went to the window. 
 &bquo;Shall we go to that place again?&equo; he said looking up towards Jubilee Wood. 
 &bquo;It's my place,&equo; said Philip. 
 He wished Lee would get out of his room. 
 He pushed his desk drawer in. 
 It was all his fault for wanting to show off about his swimming certificates. 
 &bquo;I'll be off, then,&equo; said Lee. 
 They went downstairs again and before Philip could stop him Lee had gone into the kitchen. 
 He found the bag of bread and sultanas that Philip had filled for the pheasants. 
 &bquo;What's this for?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I know, those birds.&equo; 
 &bquo;Give it here,&equo; said Philip, snatching the bag back. 
 &bquo;She's got corn,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;That Mrs Wright.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Why don't you nick some? 
 She's not at home. 
 She's  gone out.&equo; 
 He looked at the bag Philip was holding. 
 &bquo;It would be better than that stuff.&equo; 
 Philip looked at the white bread and the sultanas. 
 He knew it would. 
 He ran back into the living-room and took the phone off the hook. 
 Then he went with Lee down the village.  
 &bquo;You sure she's out?&equo; said Philip as they ran through Mrs Wright's gate. 
 Lee pointed to the empty garage, the doors swinging. 
 &bquo;She keeps the corn in here,&equo; said Lee, opening the door of the shed. 
 Philip pushed Lee out of the way and went in first. 
 The new sack was on its side across the door. 
 &bquo;It wasn't half heavy,&equo; said Lee kicking it. 
 Philip looked at Lee. 
 So that's how he knew about the grain. 
 Mrs Wright must have got Lee to help her out of the car with the sack. 
 &bquo;Don't do that,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;You'll make a hole in it.&equo; 
 &bquo;So what?&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip hoisted the sack so it was neat against the wall by the opened one. 
 &bquo;There's rats in here,&equo; he said. 
 Lee was poking about, knocking dusty packets of seeds off the shelf and moving flower pots. 
 He hadn't scared him. 
 He wanted to. 
 &bquo;She shoots them,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;And foxes. 
 She's going to shoot that fox.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't shoot foxes. 
 They're hard to hit,&equo; said Philip. 
 But Lee wasn't listening. 
 He was piling the flower pots up. 
 Philip began to scoop grain from the opened sack into his polythene bag quickly. 
 He wanted to get out of the shed. 
 Mrs Wright could be back any time. 
 &bquo;You can take your time,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;She's gone to see a friend.&equo; 
 &bquo;Her friend's dead,&equo; he said. 
 Lee didn't know everything. 
 Lee was fiddling with the bag, opening it again and knocking grain caught in the folds of the sack on to the floor.  
 &bquo;My Dad's dead.&equo; 
 &bquo;You said your Dad was a builder,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;He's my stepdad,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;What d'you call him your Dad for then?&equo; 
 Philip knotted the bag. 
 &bquo;Come on, I'm going.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can I come back to your house?&equo; said Lee. 
 He looked stupid, a cobweb with bits in was caught in his hair, his glasses were crooked. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip, going out of the shed. 
 What if his Mum came back unexpectedly and found Lee in the house? 
 Besides he didn't want him. 
 &bquo;D'you want to see the hens, the dead ones?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;They're still there.&equo; 
 He pointed to the orchard. 
 &bquo;No, thanks,&equo; said Philip. 
 He wanted to go back home. 
 His Mum might phone. 
 &bquo;Don't you like dead things?&equo; said Lee. 
 The way he was looking at him, Philip knew he was testing him. 
 They did that at school. 
 They asked you to cut worms in half, watch them wriggling off in two halves, made you draw blood with a compass, and watch it oozing out. 
 Mostly they knew he didn't want to. 
 That's why they asked him. 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; he said. 
 They went through the gate into the orchard. 
 The rest of the hens were roaming as if nothing had happened. 
 What was left of the three dead ones was by the fence. 
 The two boys stood looking down at the heaps of feathers. 
 Where the heads had been bitten off it was disgusting. 
 But Philip kept on looking. 
 One of them was the hen with the neck feathers missing. 
 &bquo;They can run about without their heads,&equo; said Lee. 
 The cobweb was above his eye now. 
 &bquo;Just after they're dead,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Not now.&equo; 
 He went on looking at the disgusting bits. 
 Lee didn't know much. 
 &bquo;You going to touch them?&equo; said Lee.  
 &bquo;You going to?&equo; 
 Lee picked up a stick from by the broken wire fence and poked the feathers of one of the dead hens, then the bloody bit by the neck. 
 Philip saw he had his eyes shut. 
 He was scared of it. 
 Philip didn't bother touching the dead hen. 
 He knew he didn't have to. 
 Lee was scared. 
 &bquo;Where's Caspar?&equo; 
 &bquo;Locked up,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I told my Dad to keep him locked up or on his lead. 
 He'd better not let him loose.&equo; 
 Philip put his anorak hood up. 
 It was raining. 
 &bquo;It wasn't Caspar chasing the sheep,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;That dog hadn't got a collar on.&equo; 
 &bquo;I told you,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;You must keep him locked up. 
 Jack won't know the difference.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know that,&equo; said Lee, and they ran back into Mrs Wright's yard. 
 &bquo;I'll be off home, then,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Wait,&equo; said Lee. 
 He pulled a Marathon out of his pocket and gave it to Philip. 
 &bquo;Thanks,&equo; said Philip. 
 He tore the wrapper off. 
 &bquo;You going home?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not likely,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;My Dad's got the week off.&equo; 
 &bquo;What difference does that make?&equo; 
 Lee hadn't got a hood and his hair was flat to his head with the wet. 
 &bquo;I don't get on with my Dad.&equo; 
 &bquo;You said he wasn't your Dad.&equo; 
 &bquo;He isn't.&equo; 
 Philip finished the chocolate bar. 
 He gave up. 
 If Lee didn't know if his Dad was his Dad or not, he must be a hopeless case. 
 Lee untwisted the wire that fastened the shed door and pocketed it. 
 &bquo;Give me that,&equo; said Philip. 
 If they didn't leave the shed door properly shut, Mrs Wright would know someone had been in.  
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Lee. 
 And he pushed Philip, knocking the polythene bag of grain out of his hand. 
 Then he ran off with the wire, not out of the gate, but round to the front of the house. 
 Philip picked up the bag, checking for holes. 
 He was lucky. 
 It was still O.K. No grain was spilling out. 
 It wasn't thanks to Lee, though. 
 Some of the things he did were stupid, really childish, like the way he'd gone off howling in Jubilee Wood. 
 He'd have to go after him now, get the wire off him and fix the door. 
 He ran round the corner of the house. 
 Lee had disappeared. 
 He couldn't see him by the house or in the trees at the bottom of the big lawn. 
 He was scared to call out because of the noise. 
 He walked quickly past the windows with the drawn curtains to the far end of the house. 
 Round the end with some shrubs poking over it was a small window with frosted glass. 
 It was open. 
 He looked along this end of Mrs Wright's house that he'd never seen before. 
 There was no sign of Lee. 
 He'd vanished. 
 The window looked as if it belonged to a toilet. 
 She'd most likely left the window open to air it. 
 His Mum did, and it made the place freezing. 
 At this rate it was more than an airing it was getting, it was a soaking. 
 It was pouring with rain. 
 Then he jumped. 
 Someone had flushed the toilet. 
 The next thing, he saw Lee looking out of the window. 
 &bquo;What are you doing in there?, 
 &bquo;It's a toilet,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I'm not deaf,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;You'd better get out, quick.&equo; 
 Lee disappeared from the window. 
 He reappeared, waving a walking-stick. 
 &bquo;Where's that wire?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I don't know. 
 I lost it.&equo; 
 And he disappeared again. 
 &bquo;Lee,&equo; said Philip. 
 But there was no answer, no noise. 
 Philip jumped up to see if he could get a look in through the window. 
 He  couldn't; it was too high. 
 Lee must have got in by standing on a stone vase thing on the path. 
 Philip stood on the vase, trying not to crush the flowers that were in it. 
 The vase wobbled, so he hung on to the window ledge to steady himself. 
 He could see in now. 
 Immediately below him was the toilet. 
 By the door that Lee had left open were walking-sticks of all sorts, and umbrellas. 
 Philip hung on, waiting for Lee to come back. 
 But he didn't. 
 There was dead silence. 
 What was he doing? 
 The rain came on harder. 
 Then he heard a crash like something had dropped. 
 &bquo;Lee,&equo; he called, his head right in the window. 
 There was no sound except for the rain. 
 &bquo;Phil,&equo; He heard him calling now. 
 &bquo;Phil.&equo; 
 Phil? 
 No one called him Phil except sometimes his Uncle Walter. 
 But his Mum didn't like it. 
 Philip they'd called him, she said, and Philip was his name. 
 &bquo;What are you doing?&equo; called Philip, one foot slipping off the vase. 
 There was no answer, only silence again, followed a few seconds later by the crashing sound. 
 Philip put his foot on the ledge and his hands on the window and wriggled through. 
 He lowered himself on to the toilet seat and jumped down on to the floor. 
 He slipped through the open toilet door and saw Lee standing half way down the long, flagged passage. 
 He was wearing a tin helmet and staring at something on the wall, a picture. 
 Lee, startled to see Philip, moved and the helmet which he had on the back of his head fell off on to the flagged floor. 
 So that's what the crashing noise had been. 
 &bquo;Where did you find that?&equo; he whispered. 
 &bquo;In the toilet,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Behind the door.&equo; 
 The helmet was identical to the one Uncle Walter had given him. 
 &bquo;It's a Spitfire,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip stood beside him, looking at the picture. 
 It was a  photograph of a fighter plane with the pilot standing beside it. 
 It was a Spitfire. 
 Lee was right. 
 It was a good photograph. 
 The pilot was smiling, his foot up, ready to get into the plane. 
 &bquo;D'you reckon he made it?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Course not,&equo; said Philip. 
 He knew. 
 His Aunt Edith, Uncle Walter's wife, had worked in a factory that made Spitfire bits. 
 &bquo;I mean, d'you think he got back from the mission he was on,&equo; said Lee, putting his face right up close to the picture. 
 &bquo;Probably,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Lots of them didn't,&equo; said Lee, running down the passage and into the kitchen that Philip had been in yesterday morning where Mrs Wright had given him a cup of tea. 
 He followed Lee. 
 On the table in the milk bottle was the daffodil he'd picked. 
 Beside it was the box of cartridges she'd bought yesterday. 
 There was a radio on, but not tuned, giving out a strange, crackling noise. 
 &bquo;Give us that piece of wire,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I'm getting out of here.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's upstairs?&equo; said Lee, leaving the kitchen. 
 &bquo;How should I know?&equo; said Philip. 
 Lee, the helmet once more on his head, went up the dark staircase. 
 Philip stayed at the bottom by the photo of the Spitfire and the pilot. 
 Maybe he had made it back. 
 Maybe he had medals. 
 He wasn't wearing any, just his flying-suit. 
 &bquo;Come up here, Phil,&equo; called Lee. 
 &bquo;What is there?, 
 &bquo;Lots.&equo; 
 So Philip went upstairs. 
 Lee was in a bedroom opposite the top of the stairs. 
 It was hers, Mrs Wright's. 
 The curtains were drawn and it was crowded with heavy brown furniture. 
 Lee switched on the light and the bulb went, like the one in the kitchen yesterday. 
 On a chest of drawers on a white cloth was another photo. 
 Lee picked it up and they looked  at it. 
 It was of the pilot, this time without the plane. 
 He was in a different uniform, not in his flying-suit. 
 &bquo;It's him again,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;He s got a moustache, said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's still him,&equo; said Lee. 
 And he went out of the room, his arms angled like a plane. 
 He rushed down the stairs and Philip ran after him, his arms out like a plane too. 
 He did that sometimes on his own up in Jubilee Wood but never so anyone could see him. 
 &bquo;What's in here?&equo; said Lee, opening the door of the room that Mrs Wright had taken him into, to see the birds' eggs. 
 &bquo;We should go,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;She'll be back soon.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why's she gone to see her friend if her friend's dead?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Stop touching things,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;She'll know we've been in.&equo; 
 He'd never known anyone for touching things like Lee. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; said Lee, pulling open the drawers of the egg cabinet. 
 &bquo;Why does she go to see this lady if she's dead?&equo; 
 &bquo;She likes going to her house. 
 She smokes cigarettes,&equo; said Philip. 
 He didn't say about the flowers. 
 &bquo;Does she think her friend's still alive?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Does she see her ghost?&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe,&equo; said Philip. 
 He hadn't thought about it. 
 &bquo;I'd like to see my Dad's ghost,&equo; said Lee. 
 He opened the drawer that had the pheasant's egg in. 
 Philip lifted it out. 
 It felt light, empty. 
 &bquo;What's that?&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip didn't let him touch it. 
 &bquo;A pheasant's egg,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's not much,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip, putting the egg back and closing the drawer. 
 Lee had slipped out of the room. 
 He called Philip. 
 Philip found him by the door into the yard. 
 Mrs Wright's gun was leaning against the wall. 
 Lee was staring at it.  
 &bquo;If someone shot that other dog,&equo; said Lee, &bquo;Caspar wouldn't have to be locked up all the time.&equo; 
 He walked down the passage and sat on the bottom of the stairs. 
 Philip sat down beside him. 
 &bquo;Jack'll get it,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If it comes again.&equo; 
 &bquo;But what if he gets Caspar first by mistake.&equo; 
 &bquo;He can't, if you keep Caspar locked up.&equo; 
 &bquo;But my Dad'll let him out, you see.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; 
 Lee was staring at the picture of the Spitfire on the wall. 
 &bquo;I think he wants Caspar to get killed.&equo; 
 &bquo;Course he doesn't.&equo; 
 &bquo;He never wanted us to bring him when we moved. 
 He says he's nothing but a nuisance. 
 Mum got him when she was on her own after my Dad died.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is he your real Dad or isn't he?, 
 &bquo;He's my stepdad.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then why do you call him your Dad then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Because I do, see.&equo; 
 Lee got up and ran back to the toilet, picking up the helmet that was on the floor. 
 &bquo;You can't take that,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I'm keeping it,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;You can't,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's hers, Mrs Wright's.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm keeping it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Give it here.&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Lee flung the helmet on the floor and kicked it again and again against the toilet.  
 &bquo;Stop it,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Stop it, will you.&equo; 
 But Lee didn't stop. 
 He kept on, and it was worse because he'd got hold of the helmet now and was smashing it against the toilet. 
 Philip was scared. 
 He wondered if Lee had gone mad. 
 &bquo;You'll break the toilet if you don't look out,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Break it, d'you hear.&equo; 
 He was shouting now. 
 But Lee didn't leave off. 
 The din was awful. 
 Philip, desperate to stop Lee, made a grab for the helmet. 
 He got hold of it and hung on. 
 Now they both had hold, crouched on the floor by the toilet. 
 &bquo;Leave it,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;She'll come back, you dumbo. 
 She'll catch us.&equo; 
 Lee was trying to prise Philip's fingers off the helmet. 
 It was as if the only thing he cared about was the stupid thing. 
 He wasn't letting it go, not for anybody. 
 &bquo;You can have my helmet,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I'll give it to you.&equo; 
 Lee loosened his grip and sat back on the floor. 
 Philip hung the helmet on the hook behind the door. 
 He wasn't giving him Uncle Walter's helmet. 
 He'd only said that to get him out of Mrs Wright's house. 
 They'd no right to be there. 
 They'd broken in and they'd better get out. 
 &bquo;Come on, then,&equo; he said. 
 Lee was just sitting on the floor. 
 Philip pulled him up. 
 He was limp like a puppet. 
 Philip pushed him towards the toilet and the window. 
 &bquo;What about that?&equo; said Lee pointing to the bag of grain that Philip had left on the cistern. 
 Philip took it. 
 At least Lee was acting normally again. 
 He climbed out and Philip followed him.  
 &bquo;How was the window?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Like that,&equo; said Lee pushing it up a bit. 
 &bquo;You sure?, 
 Lee nodded. 
 They ran back round the front of the house. 
 Philip stopped in front of the shed. 
 &bquo;That wire for fixing the door,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Where is it?, 
 Lee took it out of his pocket and gave it to Philip. 
 So he'd had it all the time. 
 Philip slipped the wire through the staple and began to twist it. 
 He'd only made two twists when he stopped, listening. 
 &bquo;Is it her?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip. 
 It was shots, a series of them in the distance. 
 &bquo;Caspar,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I'm going back to see if Caspar's still locked up.&equo; 
 Without waiting for Philip who was still securing the wire he ran across the yard and out of the gate. 
 Philip saw him go down the village towards the church. 
 There was no one about except Miss Lofthouse taking the dead heads off the daffodils in the churchyard by the War Memorial. 
 And she was stooping; she didn't see them. 
 Philip walked back home, only running when he reached his own gate. 
 The phone was still off the hook. 
 He'd just remembered. 
 He rushed into the house and put the receiver back. 
 Then he flung himself down on the settee. 
 He couldn't believe what he'd done, that he'd been into Mrs Wright's house, into her bedroom even, when she was out. 
 If his Mum and Dad found out they'd kill him. 
 And Lee too. 
 But they hadn't done any harm. 
 He straightened the cushions where Lee had moved them. 
 Then he jumped as the phone rang. 
 He grabbed the receiver. 
 &bquo;Philip, whoever's been on the phone? 
 It's been engaged for ten minutes at least. 
 If I hadn't got through this time I was going to phone them to check a fault.&equo;  
 &bquo;It was Uncle Walter,&equo; said Philip. 
 It was the only person he could think of. 
 No one else phoned much. 
 &bquo;Uncle Walter? 
 What's he doing phoning this time of day?&equo; 
 Uncle Walter always phoned in the evening. 
 &bquo;Just for a chat.&equo; 
 &bquo;A chat? 
 What did he say?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's got something on his chest. 
 He's not well.&equo; 
 &bquo;That makes two of you, then. 
 How's your headache?&equo; 
 &bquo;A lot better.&equo; 
 Philip had forgotten all about his headache. 
 Anyway she seemed to have swallowed all that about Uncle Walter. 
 &bquo;You had your dinner?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not yet.&equo; 
 &bquo;What have you been doing? 
 It's past one o'clock.&equo; 
 Philip had no idea what time it was. 
 It seemed like only half an hour since his Mum had gone. 
 He must have been in Mrs Wright's house with Lee much longer than he'd thought. 
 &bquo;I'll have my dinner now. 
 Bye, Mum.&equo; 
 He put the receiver down. 
 His Mum had left him ham and salad in the kitchen. 
 He helped himself. 
 Twenty past one. 
 He'd plenty of time to go up to Jubilee Wood. 
 He'd scatter some of the grain he'd nicked, and fetch down the wire and cutters, and his books. 
 The library wouldn't think much of them all wet from the wood. 
 Besides, he wasn't interested in that type of trap any more. 
 Or any type of trap for that matter. 
 What was the point if they were moving from Little Knoll? 
 He wondered if his Mum had fixed on the wallpaper with the Birds of Paradise for his new room. 
 She could choose what she liked. 
 He didn't care. 
 Philip rinsed his plate and went out again. 
 He looked down the road but there was no sign of Lee. 
 He was glad. 
 He didn't want Lee coming up with him. 
 He was all right was Lee. 
 But you couldn't trust him if something upset  him not to act up. 
 He'd never forget that senseless smashing at Mrs Wright's toilet with the helmet. 
 He took the short cut through the farm buildings. 
 He'd be safe from Jack. 
 It was still his dinner=time. 
 He ran up through the quarry and climbed over the gate into the field with the ewes and the new lambs, then up the side of the wood till he reached the gate into it. 
 He vaulted the gate and landed in the wood. 
 It had stopped raining but the wood was sopping. 
 You could hear the rain dropping off the trees. 
 He skirted the branch that lay across the path and carried on till he reached the feeding-place. 
 The first thing he saw was his helmet hanging from the branch of a tree near his hide. 
 That must have been Lee who'd put it there. 
 He took it and crawled into the hide. 
 His note-book and the library books were piled neatly on the stone with the wire and cutters. 
 He was relieved. 
 For all he knew, Lee could have done anything stupid with them. 
 Philip pulled the camouflage net over the entrance. 
 He shivered. 
 The hide wasn't anything like waterproof. 
 Outside, he could still hear the popping and dripping of the wet wood. 
 He opened the note-book and filled in the date. 
 He didn't know what to write. 
 Things had changed. 
 And for some reason he found himself drawing a Spitfire. 
 He tore the page out. 
 Lee drew Spitfires better than him. 
 He flipped back through the book looking at his entries, neat, and pages of notes about the pheasants and the weather and the times he'd been up there. 
 Way back, he found the sketch he'd made of the hide. 
 He made a face. 
 It didn't look much like it. 
 He shut the note-book. 
 There wasn't much point in it now if they were going to live in Thirkett. 
 Still holding the note-book, he crawled out of the hide and made his way down to the edge of the bigger of the two pools. 
 He dropped the note-book in the mud just where the water came and stamped on it, grinding it in to the soft mess of leaves.  
 Overhead a plane flew over. 
 It was the one that pulled gliders. 
 The glider was still on the wire. 
 Philip ran to the scree at the bottom of the cliff to get a better view. 
 He watched the plane release the glider and the glider shoot up silently above him. 
 Last year one had come down not far from Little Knoll. 
 There'd been a photograph of it in the paper, across someone's hedge, its wings in a tree. 
 The pilot was all right. 
 They'd used them in the war, gliders. 
 Quiet, flying at night, they dropped troops behind the enemy lines. 
 Maybe that's what Uncle John had got his medals for. 
 He didn't know what the medals were for. 
 Uncle Walter hadn't told him. 
 He'd get him to tell him next time he saw him. 
 He wished he saw more of Uncle Walter. 
 But Uncle Walter liked his independence, so he never stopped with them long. 
 Philip sat down on the wet scree thinking about the War, and Arnhem where Great Uncle John had been killed. 
 He'd seen a film about it and he could remember it very well. 
 Thinking so hard about it, he thought for a moment he was hearing guns. 
 He stood up. 
 No, it was real shots. 
 It must be Jack again, shooting pigeons. 
 Philip ran down the slope. 
 Or the dog. 
 He couldn't be shooting at Caspar. 
 Caspar was shut up. 
 That's what Lee had gone home to check, that Caspar was locked up. 
 Philip took the path that he and Lee had taken yesterday to get to the edge of the field. 
 As he was scrambling up the steepest bit, pulling himself up by the bracken, he heard something. 
 It wasn't Jack. 
 It was some sort of animal. 
 He could hear it panting. 
 He turned quickly and saw it coming up the slope behind him. 
 It was Caspar. 
 There was no doubt of it, he recognized the collar. 
 Caspar took no notice of him and carried on through the wood towards the field. 
 If he went that way, he'd go right into the range of Jack's gun. 
 &bquo;Caspar,&equo; called Philip. 
 &bquo;Caspar.&equo; 
 Caspar stopped sniffing in a bracken tunnel and came bounding back towards Philip. 
 Philip held out the paper  that the chocolate bar Lee had given him had been wrapped in. 
 Caspar sniffed it, then licked it. 
 Philip put out his other hand and took hold of his collar. 
 &bquo;Come on,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Unless you want to be shot.&equo; 
 He tried to pull Caspar back down the slope. 
 Caspar growled. 
 &bquo;Come on,&equo; said Philip as encouragingly as he could. 
 And slowly, luring him with the chocolate wrapping, he led him back towards the feeding-place. 
 Until he heard someone in the wood. 
 Jack, he wondered? 
 Instead of crossing over to the hide as he'd intended, he stopped in the trees by the pool. 
 He tried to pull Caspar with him so that they would be hidden by a tree, but Caspar hung back barking. 
 &bquo;please,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;please shut up.&equo; 
 He managed somehow to get Caspar near the tree and by giving him the wrapping to chew he got him to stop barking. 
 But if it was Jack, it would be too late. 
 He would have heard him. 
 Philip crouched, his fingers round Caspar's collar. 
 Jack wouldn't shoot so long as he'd got hold of him. 
 From where he was he could see the ride. 
 And it wasn't Jack coming along it with his gun, it was Mrs Wright, with hers. 
 What was she doing up here in Jubilee Wood? 
 He'd never seen her up here before. 
 Dressed in the old coat she always wore, she was walking fast. 
 At that rate she'd soon be through the wood and gone. 
 What was it Jack had said about her wandering, that she was losing her mind. 
 It didn't look like it. 
 He bet she was looking for the fox. 
 Philip gripped tight hold of Caspar's collar. 
 Mrs Wright had stopped by the feeding-ground. 
 She was staring at something, the magpie that Lee had thrown up into the tree. 
 She walked across the clearing and prodded it with the gun till it fell to the ground. 
 Caspar, the chocolate wrapper licked clean, was pulling to get away. 
 Philip willed him not to bark again. 
 Mrs Wright had stopped now by the hide. 
 With the barrel of  the gun she lifted the camouflage net. 
 Then she let it drop again. 
 Caspar, straining to get at the dead magpie, leapt forward and the collar snapped. 
 He went tearing across the clearing. 
 Mrs Wright waved her gun at him and Caspar charged past her, picked up the dead magpie and disappeared. 
 Philip held the collar in his hand. 
 It hadn't come undone. 
 It had snapped all right. 
 There was a place where it was very worn. 
 It had gone there. 
 It was Lee's fault. 
 He should have a proper collar for the dog. 
 From behind the tree he watched Mrs Wright who was still in the clearing. 
 She looked clumsy and old. 
 Her coat was wet with bits sticking to it. 
 Slowly she lowered herself on to a dead log and sat there. 
 Overhead was a plane. 
 She looked up at it and lit a cigarette. 
 When she'd finished it she moved on more slowly this time, stopping twice for a fit of coughing. 
 He waited a long while, looking out all the time for Caspar. 
 But there was neither sight nor sound of him. 
 He'd gone. 
 Philip was sick with himself for letting him go. 
 He should have seen the collar was no good. 
 He threw it now into the bushes. 
 He dreaded hearing a shot. 
 But there were no more. 
 He hoped Caspar had gone home. 
 It was stupid of Lee to let him escape. 
 Philip didn't believe what Lee had said about his stepdad letting him out on purpose, wanting him to get killed. 
 Philip knew it was time he was getting back. 
 He wouldn't put it past his Mum to leave work early. 
 He ran across to the hide and fetched his things, the books and the wire and cutters. 
 Then he hurried back through the wood, down the field and along the road past the stream. 
 The phone was ringing as he went into the house. 
 Not his Mum again. 
 &bquo;Is that Mrs Hartley?&equo; 
 It was a woman. 
 &bquo;No, it's Philip Hartley, her son. 
 She's out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Could you give her a message?&equo;  
 &bquo;All right.&equo; 
 &bquo;Could you tell her that Mr Warden's neighbour phoned to say that her uncle's been taken to hospital?&equo; 
 Philip felt sick. 
 It was Uncle Walter. 
 &bquo;Have you got a pencil handy?&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll give you my phone number, so your mother can ring when she gets in.&equo; 
 Philip scrawled the number on the pad by the phone. 
 The woman put the receiver down. 
 Philip ran upstairs. 
 She hadn't told him what was the matter. 
 Was that because it was really serious. 
 Was Uncle Walter going to die? 
 He didn't know what to do. 
 Maybe he should phone his Mum. 
 He had her work number. 
 But the woman hadn't said it was urgent, that his Mum should go to the hospital right away or anything. 
 He looked at his watch that was beside his bed. 
 It was five to four. 
 Even if she took it into her head to come back early, she wouldn't be back till half four at the earliest. 
 He sat down at his desk, straightening his things that Lee had moved, putting them where they had been before, in the exact spot. 
 What if Uncle Walter were really ill? 
 He arranged all his pencils in the holder with the points the same way. 
 It was uncanny what he'd said to his Mum about Uncle Walter phoning up about his bad chest and now him being in hospital for real. 
 Philip sharpened one of his pencils that Lee must have broken, sharpened it too much and the lead broke again. 
 Somehow him telling that lie that turned out to be nearly true made him feel that it was his fault. 
 He turned the sharpener slowly, keeping his eye on the lead. 
 But you didn't die just because you were taken to hospital &mdash; unless you were old. 
 And Uncle Walter was old. 
 He'd been in the War, him and Uncle John. 
 The last time Philip had seen him was when he'd given him Uncle John's medals. 
 It had been just as he was leaving on a Sunday evening. 
 His Mum hadn't been able to persuade him to stay, though she was worried about his cough. 
 She'd gone back into the house to fetch something and his Dad was all ready in the car waiting to drive Uncle Walter back to his house. 
 Uncle Walter had walked down the road a bit with Philip. 
 &bquo;I've been meaning to give you these of Uncle John's,  Phil,&equo; he'd said taking the medals out of his pocket. 
 &bquo;Seeing as you're interested in that sort of thing. 
 I've no use for them. 
 They're mine by rights, mind, so don't go losing them.&equo; 
 Philip had promised to take great care of them. 
 &bquo;That's all right, then,&equo; Uncle Walter had said as his Mum 
 had come out of the house. 
 Philip opened his desk drawer to take the medals out and look at them again. 
 He put his hand in the drawer. 
 He knew just where the medals were. 
 He didn't need to look. 
 There were three of them with ribbons and pins, in the back left-hand corner of his drawer. 
 But his fingers only felt the lining paper of the drawer. 
 There were no medals. 
 He pulled the drawer fully open. 
 The medals had gone. 
 He pulled the drawer right out so that it was on his knee. 
 He looked under his drawing paper. 
 They weren't there. 
 He opened the other drawer but he knew he hadn't put them in there. 
 He couldn't understand it. 
 Maybe his Mum had taken them out when she was clearing out his room. 
 But why? 
 What would she want them for? 
 He fitted the drawer he'd taken out back in. 
 It was either her or Lee. 
 They were the only people who'd been in his room except for his Dad last night. 
 And his Dad wouldn't touch them. 
 The swimming certificates were all he was interested in. 
 No, it was either his Mum or Lee. 
 He pushed the drawer in, knocking his desk crooked. 
 And he knew which of them it was. 
 It was Lee. 
 He'd been fiddling with his desk, hadn't he? 
 It had been him that had wanted to nick Mrs Wright's helmet. 
 Philip ran downstairs. 
 He was getting them back. 
 Lee had no right to them. 
 Uncle Walter had given them to him, Philip. 
 He'd go straight down to Lee's house, force him to give the medals back. 
 He had time if he went on his bike. 
 He hauled his bike out of the shed and raced down the village. 
 Lee's house was left and up the hill, about a mile out of Little Knoll. 
 He'd never been there. 
 It was an elderly couple that had lived there before, retired.  
 When he reached the house, he leant his bike against the fence and opened the gate. 
 He was scared. 
 Most likely Lee's Mum and Dad would be there. 
 His mouth was dry. 
 He didn't know what he'd say. 
 There was a lot of gravel to walk across with troughs and wheelbarrows with snowdrops and crocuses in. 
 Nobody looked at him from the windows. 
 Maybe they were out. 
 He pressed the bell and waited, half hoping that it wouldn't ring or no one would come. 
 From somewhere round the back he heard Caspar barking. 
 He was safely back, then, and locked up. 
 Philip could hear someone coming now. 
 A man opened the door. 
 &bquo;What do you want? he said. 
 &bquo;I've no jobs.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is Lee in?&equo; said Philip, taken aback by the man's hostility. 
 &bquo;Lee,&equo; shouted the man. 
 &bquo;It's someone for you.&equo; 
 Over the man's shoulder Philip saw Lee come downstairs. 
 They were open stairs like the ones in the house his Mum and Dad were buying. 
 &bquo;You'd better come in,&equo; said the man. 
 &bquo;Who is it?&equo; called a woman from inside. 
 &bquo;What's your name?, said the man. 
 &bquo;Philip Hartley.&equo; 
 They shut the door behind him. 
 &bquo;Phil,&equo; said Lee. 
 He looked pleased to see Philip. 
 He wouldn't be when he knew what he'd come about. 
 He could still hear Caspar barking. 
 A woman, Lee's Mum, appeared. 
 &bquo;Go and let Caspar out, Lee,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;He's already been out,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;He let him out.&equo; 
 He looked accusingly at the man. 
 &bquo;Let him out again, then. 
 It's not fair to keep him in like that. 
 He's not used to it.&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you want?&equo; said Lee to Philip. 
 Philip didn't say anything. 
 He couldn't, not in front of Lee's Mum and Dad. 
 He wished he'd never come right into the house.  
 &bquo;Are you going to let that dog out or aren't you?&equo; said the man, taking Lee by the shoulder. 
 &bquo;He's not to,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;There's someone in the village that'll shoot him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Stop that,&equo; said the man. 
 &bquo;Ask him,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Ask him.&equo; 
 And he pointed at Philip. 
 &bquo;Lee's got this idea,&equo; said Lee's Mum, &bquo;that if he lets Caspar out, someone down at the farm in the village will shoot him.&equo; 
 Lee had a camouflage jacket on and Philip had this feeling that Uncle Walter's medals were in his pocket. 
 &bquo;There's no one down there'll shoot dogs,&equo; lied Philip. 
 If Lee had damaged the medals or lost them he'd kill him. 
 &bquo;I told you,&equo; said the man to Lee's Mum. 
 &bquo;He was just having you on.&equo; 
 Caspar was barking non-stop. 
 Philip's coming had set him off. 
 &bquo;I'm letting him out,&equo; said the man. 
 &bquo;I've had enough of that racket.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, don't,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;He hasn't got his collar on.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where is it?, 
 &bquo;He's lost it. 
 It's come off.&equo; 
 Philip kept his eyes on the fish tank in the corner of the living-room. 
 He knew where Caspar's collar was. 
 Up in Jubilee Wood. 
 &bquo;He won't come to any harm,&equo; said the man. 
 &bquo;No, please,&equo; said Lee, taking hold of the man's arm. 
 &bquo;No, who?&equo; said the man. 
 &bquo;No, Dad,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;There's no danger to Caspar, Lee,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;There is,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;You don't understand. 
 There's this other black dog, nearly Caspar's double, scaring the sheep and Caspar'll get shot instead if he's let out. 
 You know we can't stop him wandering. 
 He knows,&equo; he said looking at Philip. 
 &bquo;But he's not saying.&equo; 
 Philip looked round the room. 
 It was a big room with the stone and bricks showing in places, and long curtains  on a pole, like hospital curtains. 
 He thought of Uncle Walter in hospital with the curtains pulled round his bed. 
 When Philip had been in hospital when he'd had croup that's what he hated worst, the pulling of the curtains. 
 &bquo;Let's take a look for this collar,&equo; said the man and took Lee out. 
 Philip watched them from the window. 
 They went into a shed. 
 &bquo;They won't be long,&equo; said Lee's Mum. 
 &bquo;Brian thinks Lee's taken Caspar's collar off on purpose.&equo; 
 Philip didn't care about the collar. 
 He wanted the medals back. 
 That's what he'd come for. 
 &bquo;Lee hasn't told me about you,&equo; said Lee's Mum. 
 &bquo;Do you go to his school?&equo; 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 Lee and his stepdad had come out of the shed. 
 It was Caspar's shed and he was still barking. 
 &bquo;Lee thinks the world of that dog,&equo; said Lee's Mum. 
 &bquo;The trouble is Brian doesn't. 
 He's right really. 
 We got him from the Dogs&equo; Home and he's never been very obedient.&equo; 
 She sighed. 
 &bquo;Brian says they're two of a kind. 
 Sometimes I don't know what to do between them.&equo; 
 Philip felt awkward. 
 She was talking to him as if he was grown-up and it made him feel uncomfortable. 
 He looked past her beyond the stairs into a kitchen. 
 On the table was a cage with two white mice clinging to the top. 
 So he hadn't lied about them. 
 He did have white mice. 
 &bquo;I'll go and see Lee,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Lee's Mum. 
 &bquo;You do that. 
 I'm glad he's found a friend. 
 I was worried about him with us moving. 
 And with him going to a different school. 
 We're hoping he won't be there long but they thought he mightn't be able to manage in big classes. 
 Hyperactive he is. 
 But he's been a lot better, especially since we got Caspar.&equo; 
 Philip went quickly out the way Lee and his stepdad had gone. 
 Lee wasn't his friend. 
 She'd got it wrong, and he didn't know what she was on about. 
 Hyperwhatsit&hellip; 
  He'd never heard of it. 
 There was a builder's van in the yard but Lee's stepdad had gone. 
 Lee stood in the doorway of a shed which was full of old furniture and carpets. 
 &bquo;Where's my medals?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;How should I know?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;You nicked them from my desk.&equo; 
 Lee shook his head. 
 &bquo;What's in your pockets?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Show me.&equo; 
 Lee pulled out the linings of his pockets. 
 He didn't have the medals. 
 &bquo;They belong to my Uncle Walter, see. 
 And now he's in hospital.&equo; 
 Philip looked at Lee. 
 &bquo;He's probably dead by now.&equo; 
 &bquo;I haven't got them.&equo; 
 &bquo;Haven't got what?&equo; 
 Lee's stepdad suddenly appeared behind Philip. 
 &bquo;You been taking things again?&equo; 
 Lee kicked at a roll of carpet. 
 He didn't say anything. 
 &bquo;Has he?&equo; he said to Philip. 
 &bquo;Is he in trouble again?&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip. 
 He wasn't telling him. 
 This was between him and Lee. 
 &bquo;That's all right, then.&equo; 
 And he went off again. 
 &bquo;You've got them,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I know you've got them.&equo; 
 Lee went right into the shed to the back of it. 
 He beckoned Philip. 
 &bquo;What, then?&equo; 
 The shed was really a garage but there was no car, just the carpets, two old cookers, and some broken chairs. 
 Lee opened the door of one of the cookers. 
 Inside was a tiny blue egg with a pin-prick at the end, three biros, a ruler, and Uncle Walter's medals. 
 Philip took them. 
 &bquo;You nicked that?&equo; he said, pointing to the egg. 
 &bquo;From out of that cabinet.&equo; 
 Lee nodded.  
 &bquo;What for?&equo; 
 Lee shrugged his shoulders. 
 &bquo;You'll catch it,&equo; said Philip, examining the medals. 
 They'd come to no harm. 
 Then he saw Lee put his finger to his lips. 
 But it was too late. 
 His stepdad came into the shed. 
 &bquo;So that's it,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;He pinched them off you, didn't he?&equo; 
 Philip was silent. 
 Caspar was barking. 
 Lee was standing in front of the cooker. 
 &bquo;Is that it? 
 Is that all?&equo; said his stepdad. 
 Philip nodded. 
 Caspar was barking on and on. 
 Lee's stepdad strode out of the garage. 
 Lee ran after him. 
 &bquo;Where are you going?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;To let that flaming dog out,&equo; said his stepdad. 
 He went across to the shed where Caspar was. 
 He opened the door and Caspar rushed out. 
 Lee made a dive to try and stop him but it was no good without the collar and he fell sprawling on the gravel. 
 His stepdad got into the van and drove off, gravel spitting from under the wheels. 
 &bquo;I told you,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;That's him for you.&equo; 
 His hand was grazed from falling. 
 &bquo;I'm going after Caspar,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;You won't catch him,&equo; said Philip but he ran after Lee. 
 He grabbed his bike. 
 &bquo;Get on the crossbar,&equo; he said. 
 Caspar was way down the road. 
 Lee sat sideways on the crossbar and Philip freewheeled down the hill. 
 &bquo;He's gone through the hedge,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip put his brakes on and skidded. 
 They could see Caspar tearing across towards Mrs Wright's orchard. 
 &bquo;I'm going after him,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;She's got a gun.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know that, stupid,&equo; said Philip. 
 Lee slipped off the bike and Philip wheeled it over to the other side of the road. 
 Lee was already over the fence. 
 &bquo;Help us over with the bike,&equo; said Philip, lifting it. 
 Lee took hold of the bike and pulled it over the fence. 
  He let it fall and they ran down through the field after Caspar. 
 &bquo;He's going to her place,&equo; said Lee, unbuckling his belt. 
 &bquo;I'll get hold of him with this.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll not catch him,&equo; said Philip. 
 Caspar was way down the bottom of the field near the wood at the foot of Mrs Wright's lawn. 
 &bquo;Is she at home?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;How should I know?&equo; said Philip. 
 She could be at home or she could be up in the wood still. 
 Caspar was in the trees, zig-zagging among them. 
 &bquo;I'll get him now,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;He's stopped.&equo; 
 They reached the fence at the bottom of Mrs Wright's garden. 
 Lee made his belt into a loop. 
 &bquo;Wait,&equo; said Philip pulling Lee back. 
 He couldn't go like that. 
 He'd be in full view of the windows. 
 Lee turned to face Philip and Philip knew immediately what was going to happen. 
 Because he'd pulled him back like that, stopped him from doing what he wanted, he was going to have one of his screaming fits. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip, looking straight down into Lee's open mouth. 
 It was horrible. 
 &bquo;Don't start that stupid yelling. 
 Here.&equo; 
 And he took the medals out of his pocket and gave them to him. 
 Lee didn't take them but he closed his mouth and there was no sound. 
 He was quiet. 
 Then they both heard the window opening. 
 Philip pulled Lee down beside him and put his hand over his mouth. 
 In the window stood Mrs Wright, pointing the gun. 
 &bquo;Lie flat,&equo; said Philip. 
 One of the pellets from the gun hit a tree to their left. 
 The second embedded itself in the ground near Lee's foot.  
 &bquo;Wow, that was close,&equo; said Philip, raising himself on his elbows. 
 He heard Mrs Wright shut the window. 
 &bquo;She shouldn't go shooting people,&equo; said Lee, sitting up. 
 He was covered in wet leaves. 
 &bquo;She was scaring Caspar off,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's the hens she's worried about.&equo; 
 &bquo;Caspar,&equo; said Lee, jumping up and looking through the trees. 
 &bquo;Where's he gone?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's miles away,&equo; said Philip, pointing to the field by Mr Hyde's house. 
 &bquo;Quick, after him, then,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip shook his head. 
 &bquo;I've got to get back. 
 My Mum'll be home soon. 
 I'm not supposed to be out. 
 I'm supposed to have a headache.&equo; 
 Lee took hold of Philip. 
 &bquo;Come on,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We've got to find Caspar.&equo; 
 Philip pulled free of him. 
 &bquo;I've told you. 
 I've got to go.&equo; 
 Philip watched Lee run off after Caspar, keeping close into the hedge. 
 He looked back once and beckoned. 
 Philip set off back up the field towards the road. 
 Good luck to him. 
 He hadn't much chance of catching Caspar, not at the rate the dog was going. 
 Philip hurried back to his bike. 
 He hoiked it back over the fence and pelted down the hill. 
 He was in luck. 
 His Mum wasn't back yet. 
 The car wasn't outside. 
 But there was something strange in the garden by the fence: a &bquo;For Sale&equo; sign. 
 The people must have come and put it there while he was out. 
 He leant his bike against the gate and shook the sign. 
 It was firm, knocked right in. 
 He wheeled his bike round to  the back. 
 That was it, then. 
 They were dead serious, his Mum and Dad, about moving. 
 He threw his bike in the shed and shut the door. 
 His Dad insisted he locked his bike, but he didn't this time. 
 He didn't care about it. 
 He wouldn't be riding it in Hill View Road. 
 They'd destroy it, those kids. 
 He knew them. 
 He was only just back in the house when he heard his Mum draw up in the car. 
 She waved at him but he didn't wave back. 
 She must have known about that sign, about the people coming to put it up. 
 She'd most likely arranged it. 
 He felt a hard lump of anger in him. 
 They should tell him things. 
 His Mum came in, her arms full of parcels. 
 It looked like she'd been Christmas shopping. 
 &bquo;Here,&equo; she said, giving him one of the parcels. 
 &bquo;I couldn't 
 resist it.&equo; 
 Philip pulled off the paper. 
 It was a bedside lamp in the shape of an owl, except it wasn't like any owl he knew about. 
 &bquo;It's for your new room,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I just took a fancy to it. 
 What a queer thing, Uncle Walter phoning like that out of the blue,&equo; she said, taking off her coat. 
 &bquo;He's in hospital,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Somebody phoned. 
 Here.&equo; 
 He gave her the bit of paper with the phone number on. 
 He put the owl lamp down. 
 It was gross. 
 He hated it. 
 She should ask him first before getting him things. 
 His Mum was dialling already. 
 Then she was talking to the woman. 
 She put the phone down. 
 &bquo;Is he all right?&equo; 
 &bquo;He's fallen again and he's broken his leg this time. 
 I'll have to go and see him tomorrow.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's not going to die, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Course he's not. 
 He's broken his leg, that's all. 
 It'll take a long time at his age but it'll mend. 
 You're really morbid, you are. 
 I bet there's no other boys your age thinking about things like that.&equo; 
 She looked at him. 
 &bquo;It was his chest he phoned you about, was it?,  
 Philip nodded. 
 It wasn't surprising him thinking about people dying, what with Mrs Wright's friend and Lee's Dad, his proper Dad. 
 And that Spitfire pilot in the photograph in Mrs Wright's house. 
 He bet he hadn't survived the raids. 
 There wouldn't be photos of him if he had. 
 In Uncle Walter's house there were photos of Uncle John but not of Uncle Walter. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;You haven't got much to say for yourself. 
 How's your headache?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's better.&equo; 
 Somewhere he could hear a dog barking. 
 He listened. 
 &bquo;Can you hear a dog?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I can't hear anything except your Dad's van.&equo; 
 His Dad came in. 
 &bquo;Uncle Walter's broken his leg,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;It seems he fell in the kitchen. 
 Mrs Carter heard him shouting. 
 They had to get the police to break the door down.&equo; 
 She moved some of the parcels off his Dad's chair. 
 &bquo;It's what I've always said &mdash; he shouldn't live on his own, not at his age.&equo; 
 &bquo;You try and move him,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;He's as obstinate as they come, your Uncle Walter.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll go to the hospital tomorrow,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I'll go early so I can see the Social Services.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can't come with you,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;I've said I'll stand in as coach for the under-fifteens. 
 Alan can't make it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll be all right,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;But what about Philip?&equo; 
 &bquo;Can I come and see Uncle Walter?, 
 &bquo;Not tomorrow, another time. 
 I'll have too many things to see to.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll stay here, then,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I'll be all right on my own.&equo; 
 He could still hear that dog barking. 
 It worried him. 
 His Dad sat down at the kitchen table with the paper. 
 &bquo;It'll be a long job at his age,&equo; said his Mum. 
 She was still thinking about Uncle Walter. 
 &bquo;He'll not sell up and go into a Home, that's for sure,&equo; said his Dad.  
 &bquo;He might,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I might be able to persuade him.&equo; 
 &bquo;You won't,&equo; said his Dad. 
 Philip could still hear the dog. 
 It sounded as if it was somewhere up in the farm buildings. 
 It was just possible that Floss had got shut in one of them. 
 Or was it Caspar? 
 Had Caspar got himself shut in one of the sheds? 
 He moved towards the door. 
 Maybe if Lee was still out, he'd hear him. 
 &bquo;Look at this,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;There's a dog round these parts killing lambs.&equo; 
 He put the paper down on the table and his Mum looked over his shoulder. 
 Philip came away from the door and looked at the paper too. 
 The headline was thick black letters. 
 &bquo;Killer Dog&equo; it said and there was a picture of a dead lamb with the farmer beside it. 
 &bquo;It's a shame. 
 People shouldn't let their dogs roam,&equo; said Philip's Mum. 
 &bquo;It's irresponsible, that's what I call it.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's somebody'll shoot it,&equo; said Philip's Dad. 
 The dog was still barking. 
 Philip was almost sure now it was Caspar. 
 Where was Lee? 
 Why didn't he let him out? 
 &bquo;I saw Jack,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;He stopped me down the village.&equo; 
 &bquo;What did he want?&equo; 
 &bquo;He was wanting to know if Philip had been up in Mr Hyde's woods.&equo; 
 &bquo;What did you tell him?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, of course. 
 I said he'd better things to do than roam about up there.&equo; 
 Philip looked through the glass of the door. 
 It was almost dark and raining. 
 &bquo;There's someone who has,&equo; said his Mum, taking some oven chips out of the fridge. 
 &bquo;I saw Miss Lofthouse in Thirkett and she told me. 
 Apparently this person's been going out all hours of the day and night.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't tell me,&equo; said Philip's Dad. 
 &bquo;Mrs Wright. 
 Senility, that's what it is.&equo;  
 &bquo;What's senility?&equo; said Philip. 
 He thought of Mrs Wright up in Jubilee Wood, looking for the fox. 
 &bquo;Old age,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;Your mind wanders.&equo; 
 &bquo;Her mind doesn't wander,&equo; said Philip. 
 She was sharp, Mrs Wright, in her own way. 
 She never forgot to get the hen-food and she could shoot straight, even with her knobbled hands. 
 There were no flies on her. 
 She'd get that fox if she could. 
 &bquo;Her legs do,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Parks that car of hers on the roadside and just roams. 
 A patient saw her wandering in Atherton quarry. 
 She'll come to some harm if she doesn't look out.&equo; 
 Philip's Mum scattered the oven chips on the baking tray. 
 &bquo;This place, it gives me the creeps. 
 If there was just one person I could talk to it wouldn't be so bad.&equo; 
 &bquo;Wait till we're in Thirkett,&equo; said Philip's Dad. 
 &bquo;You'll be all right then.&equo; 
 Philip looked at her. 
 She would be. 
 He wouldn't. 
 Philip pressed his face against the glass of the door and stared out. 
 The rain was splashing on the concrete, and the hole in it that he used to pretend was the way to Australia had filled up. 
 Uncle Walter had told him you could get to Australia by digging. 
 He hadn't really believed him but he'd dug all the same and his Dad had been angry. 
 He'd never got round to mending the hole. 
 Philip rubbed the mist off the glass where he'd been breathing on it. 
 Uncle Walter wouldn't like it in Hill View. 
 He knew that. 
 He rubbed the glass again. 
 There was something moving out there, by the broken fence. 
 A cat maybe. 
 He strained his eyes peering into the gloom. 
 He was wrong. 
 It wasn't a cat. 
 It was a person. 
 It was Lee. 
 What was he doing? 
 He was mad. 
 His Mum and Dad would see him. 
 Quickly Philip pulled the curtain across the door. 
 &bquo;What's out there, then?&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Nothing,&equo; said Philip.  
 Still looking out, the curtain behind him, he could see Lee quite clearly by the shed. 
 What did he want? 
 He shouldn't come here. 
 Philip jumped as a tiny stone bounced on the concrete and hit the door. 
 &bquo;What is it, cats?&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;My bike,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I never locked it. 
 I just remembered.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be long, then. 
 Tea's nearly ready.&equo; 
 Philip opened the door and stepped out into the yard. 
 It was cold after the house, and still raining. 
 There was no sign of Lee. 
 Had he gone? 
 He went to where he'd seen him by the fence and looked down towards the woodpile. 
 &bquo;Phil.&equo; 
 He turned and a figure appeared from behind the shed. 
 It was Lee. 
 &bquo;What d'you want?&equo; whispered Philip. 
 Lee was soaked, his hair dark and flat with the rain. 
 &bquo;Caspar,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Caspar's shut in one of those buildings and I can't get him out.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; whispered Philip. 
 If he whispered, maybe Lee would too. 
 &bquo;I can't open the door. 
 It's locked.&equo; 
 &bquo;Which shed is it?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;The one with the big door.&equo; 
 They both listened, as above the noise of the rain they could hear Caspar barking. 
 &bquo;That's the tractor-shed,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Jack must have caught him and locked him in there.&equo; 
 &bquo;How'll I get him out?&equo; said Lee. 
 He was shivering, and his teeth were chattering like Philip's did when his Dad had kept him in the swimming bath too long. 
 Philip didn't answer. 
 A light spread across the yard. 
 Lee darted back behind the shed. 
 Philip saw his Mum standing in the doorway. 
 &bquo;Philip, what on earth are you doing out there?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm just coming.&equo;  
 His Mum shut the door and there was darkness again. 
 &bquo;Lee.&equo; 
 Lee was beside him again. 
 &bquo;I've got to get him out,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There's another door at the back, off the old cow byre,&equo; said Philip. 
 It was the way he'd got out the time Barry had locked him in the tractor-shed. 
 &bquo;How'll I find it?&equo; 
 Caspar was howling now, long howls like they said wolves did to the moon. 
 &bquo;I'll show you,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Now?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;No. 
 Not now. 
 Later. 
 I'll have to have my tea first.&equo; 
 He knew as soon as he'd said it that he was in trouble. 
 &bquo;No. 
 Now, now,&equo; said Lee, nearly shouting and banging his head against the shed so hard that the whole thing shook. 
 &bquo;Stop it,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Stop it. 
 Mum and Dad will hear you. 
 But Lee banged his head against the shed even harder. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Banging your head like that's stupid. 
 It doesn't help anyone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Now,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Now,&equo; and carried on banging his head. 
 It was hopeless. 
 It was as if he was three years old. 
 &bquo;I'll come. 
 I promise,&equo; said Philip. 
 Lee stopped his head banging and looked at him. 
 &bquo;You wait here and I'll come as soon as I can. 
 promise.&equo; 
 Philip held out his hand like they did in films. 
 Lee didn't shake it like they did in the films but he didn't carry on with his tantrum. 
 He'd calmed down. 
 &bquo;You wait in here,&equo; said Philip opening the shed door. 
 &bquo;Till I come.&equo; 
 And he pushed him into the shed just as light filled the yard again.  
 &bquo;Philip.&equo; 
 It was his Mum again. 
 She'd come out of the house and was standing outside the door. 
 As Philip ran across to her 
 he heard a crash. 
 It sounded like his bike falling over. 
 Lee must have banged into it in the dark. 
 It had better be that and not him having another of his scenes. 
 Philip looked quickly at his Mum. 
 But she didn't seem to have heard. 
 &bquo;Your tea's getting cold, Philip. 
 What on earth have you been doing out there?&equo; 
 His Mum shut the door, pulling the curtain across. 
 &bquo;There wasn't anybody out there, was there?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I thought I saw someone.&equo; 
 &bquo;No one,&equo; lied Philip. 
 &bquo;That's all right, then.&equo; 
 His Dad had already started his tea. 
 Philip sat down beside him. 
 His Mum passed him his chips and crispy pancakes. 
 All the time he was eating he was thinking how he could get out again. 
 He'd promised Lee he'd go with him to get Caspar out. 
 If he didn't keep his promise there was no knowing what Lee would do. 
 Besides, it wasn't right for Jack to lock Caspar up. 
 It wasn't him that was worrying the sheep. 
 Philip put his knife and fork down. 
 What would Jack do to him now he'd caught him? 
 Take him to a dog's home, shoot him? 
 Philip carried on with his tea. 
 Every now and then he heard Caspar barking. 
 He had to go. 
 He had no choice. 
 If he didn't, Lee would most likely start banging his head against the shed wall or smashing things up. 
 Philip looked at his Dad. 
 And there was plenty to smash up in the shed. 
 His Dad kept all his tools in there.  
 &bquo;That dog,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I can still hear it barking.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's Jack's dog,&equo; said his Dad, who was reading the paper. 
 His Mum shook her head. 
 But she didn't say anything. 
 She didn't argue with his Dad. 
 Philip finished his tea, refusing the ice cream his Mum offered him. 
 He hadn't time. 
 He kept thinking of Lee out in the shed fiddling with his Dad's tools, nicking nails, messing with his bike. 
 &bquo;You all right?&equo; asked his Mum. 
 He always had his ice cream. 
 &bquo;Fine,&equo; said Philip. 
 He'd thought of a way, how he could get out without his Mum and Dad knowing. 
 He'd nip out while they were watching television. 
 His Dad was addicted to the News and watched all of it. 
 It bored Philip, so he usually stayed in the kitchen or went up to his room. 
 &bquo;How's the bike, son?&equo; said his Dad. 
 His Dad was really interested in his bike. 
 &bquo;I need to fix the chain,&equo; said Philip. 
 The bike most likely would need fixing if Lee got his hands on it. 
 &bquo;I'll do it,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;It's not much,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I can mend it.&equo; 
 That was the last thing he wanted, his Dad coming out to the shed. 
 &bquo;All right, then,&equo; said his Dad, putting his hand on Philip's shoulder as he got up from the table. 
 His Mum had gone to switch the television on. 
 &bquo;We'll have you a mechanic yet.&equo; 
 Philip was pleased when his Dad had taken his hand off him. 
 He didn't want his Dad to think that he was interested in fixing his bike. 
 But it was better him thinking that, than finding Lee in the shed. 
 &bquo;Don't get cold out there,&equo; called his Mum. 
 &bquo;Put your anorak on.&equo; 
 She came back through the kitchen and gave him the  torch. 
 Philip took it and went out. 
 He hadn't long, half an hour maybe. 
 He shut the door, making sure the curtain was drawn across behind him. 
 Then he switched on the torch and splashed through the puddle in the concrete to the shed. 
 He opened the door, switching off the torch and closing the door behind him. 
 He couldn't see a thing. 
 &bquo;Lee,&equo; he said. 
 There was no answer. 
 Philip peered into the darkness. 
 What was up with him? 
 It wasn't the time to be playing silly games. 
 He turned on the torch and shone it round the shed. 
 His bike was over on its side. 
 There was no sign of Lee. 
 He'd done a bunk. 
 Philip picked up his bike, propping it up against the wall so it half slipped again. 
 He was angry. 
 He'd told Lee he would come, hadn't he? 
 He couldn't have been more than quarter of an hour having his tea. 
 Philip straightened his bike. 
 Caspar was still barking. 
 So he hadn't let him out. 
 Lee was stupid, going off like that on his own. 
 He couldn't let Caspar out without him, Philip, to help him. 
 He didn't know where the other door was. 
 He'd never find it, in the dark and without a torch. 
 Philip came out of the shed and slipped out the back where the fence was broken. 
 He ran. 
 He hadn't much time. 
 It would be halfway through the News now. 
 There was a light in the lambing-shed. 
 But that was nothing unusual. 
 Jack was most likely in there, or somewhere about. 
 He'd have to be careful. 
 In the dark he cut across the grass by the tractor-shed, then back behind a row of buildings where there was an old cow-byre that they didn't use any more except for storing stuff. 
 The door in the back end of the tractor-shed was off this. 
 He'd never been through it since the time Barry had locked him in. 
 Now he ran along the concrete passage that edged the stack-yard. 
 Then he stopped and listened. 
 He could hear nothing except the corner of the tin roof blowing. 
 &bquo;Lee,&equo; he whispered.  
 He jumped as a dark shape detached itself from the wall. 
 It was Lee. 
 &bquo;You didn't come,&equo; Lee whispered accusingly. 
 &bquo;You didn't wait.&equo; 
 &bquo;I was scared.&equo; 
 Lee was close to him and was standing on Philip's shoelace that had come undone as he ran. 
 Philip pushed him away and gave him the torch to hold while he did up his lace. 
 Lee switched on the torch and the beam lit up the stack-yard like a searchlight. 
 &bquo;Turn it off,&equo; he hissed, grabbing the torch off Lee and 
 switching it off. 
 Lee tried to get it back off him. 
 &bquo;Give it to me,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I want to find Caspar.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be stupid,&equo; said Philip. 
 If he gave Lee the torch, he'd let Jack and everyone else know where they were by mucking around with it, and if he didn't let him have it, he'd most likely give them both away by having a scene. 
 He was mad, Lee was. 
 It was his dog they were rescuing but he was clueless like a little kid. 
 Philip wished he'd never promised to help him. 
 He wasn't worth it. 
 &bquo;I want the torch.&equo; 
 Philip knew what he would do. 
 He'd trick him. 
 Turning round he took the battery out of the torch. 
 &bquo;What are you doing?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing.&equo; 
 He handed Lee the torch, which was now dud without the battery. 
 He heard Lee flicking the switch backwards and forwards. 
 &bquo;The battery's run out,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip let out his breath slowly. 
 &bquo;It was nearly done,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Now come on. 
 I haven't time to waste.&equo; 
 The door that opened into the tractor-shed was three doors along. 
 The bolt was on this side, the stack-yard side. 
 They'd be able to get in unless Jack or Tom had put a  padlock on since he'd last been there. 
 It was hard to see and he touched the stones as he walked along by the wall. 
 Lee was behind him, holding on to the back of his anorak and bumping him with the torch. 
 Philip paused by the door, feeling for the bolt. 
 There was no padlock. 
 From inside the shed came a dull rolling thudding noise. 
 Caspar had stopped barking. 
 He'd heard them. 
 &bquo;What's that?&equo; said Lee, pulling Philip back. 
 &bquo;Only the beet,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's stacked against the door.&equo; 
 Lee was still pulling at his anorak. 
 Then he dropped the torch. 
 &bquo;Shut up, will you,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;My Mum and Dad'll kill me if they catch me out here.&equo; 
 Lee didn't say anything. 
 He was tugging at a length of chain that was hanging from a hook in the wall. 
 A thought struck Philip. 
 &bquo;Where's your Mum and Dad?&equo; 
 Fine, there was no padlock, but the bolt was jammed. 
 He couldn't pull it back. 
 &bquo;They've gone out,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;They do, Fridays.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do they leave you on your own?&equo; said Philip. 
 The bolt was shifting a bit now. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;There's Mandy, a girl, she comes. 
 But she's gone to the pub. 
 I don't tell Mum. 
 I don't mind.&equo; 
 Philip had got the bolt back. 
 He could hear Caspar behind the door, whining. 
 &bquo;Have you got something to get hold of him with?, whispered Philip. 
 &bquo;I've got no lead.&equo; 
 Philip unbuckled his belt. 
 &bquo;You grab him,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'll shut the door.&equo; 
 It was pitch-dark in the shed. 
 Caspar had gone mad, leaping all over the beet and sending it rolling. 
 He jumped up on Lee. 
 &bquo;Quick,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Get the belt on him.&equo;  
 &bquo;There aren't enough holes,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;It'll slip off.&equo; 
 &bquo;Just get hold of him,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I haven't all day. 
 I've got to get back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hang on,&equo; said Lee, taking something out of his pocket. 
 &bquo;I've a nail.&equo; 
 Philip didn't need two guesses to know where that had come from. 
 His Dad's shed. 
 Lee pushed the nail through, working it round to make a hole. 
 &bquo;You sure it's O.K.?&equo; said Philip. 
 He didn't want things bungled now. 
 Feeling in the dark, he checked that Lee had got the belt on tight enough. 
 It would do. 
 They hadn't time to make another hole. 
 &bquo;Right,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Let's go.&equo; 
 They slipped out of the shed. 
 Lee held on to Caspar who was pulling, while Philip bolted the door, forcing it, and picked up the torch that Lee had dropped. 
 Then he ran back towards the stack-yard gate. 
 The News on TV must have nearly finished. 
 Caspar was jumping about like a mad thing. 
 &bquo;Get him home,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Before Jack comes.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not taking him home,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip didn't think he'd heard him right. 
 &bquo;Not taking him home,&equo; he said stupidly. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I'm not having my Dad let him out again. 
 I'm not having him shot.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where you taking him, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Up there,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Where?&equo; said Philip. 
 How did Lee think he could see where he was pointing to in the dark? 
 &bquo;I'm taking him up to that wood.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;You can't leave him up there all on his own.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm going with him,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I'm staying up there.&equo; 
 &bquo;You can't,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Want to bet,&equo; said Lee. 
 He disappeared into the dark with Caspar. 
 Philip ran  back down to the bit of broken fencing, climbed through and got back into the kitchen as the local news ended. 
 He recognized the music. 
 &bquo;That you, Philip?&equo; called his Dad. 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Philip pulled the curtain. 
 His Dad came into the kitchen. 
 &bquo;I was just coming to give you a hand, son.&equo; 
 &bquo;The chain's fine,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;You got enough oil on yourself,&equo; said his Dad. 
 Philip looked at his hand. 
 It was sticky and brown with oil. 
 He must have got that off the bolt. 
 He wiped his hand on the cloth his Dad gave him and went into the living-room. 
 He sat on the bean-bag beside his Mum. 
 There was a tiny hole in it and it was spilling white blobs of polystyrene like grain. 
 He wondered how long it would take Lee to get up to the feeding-ground. 
 A long time in the dark and he d have to go a long way round if he wasn't to upset the sheep and alert Jack. 
 &bquo;Thank goodness that barking's stopped,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;It was getting on my nerves.&equo; 
 She scooped up the bits of spilt polystyrene in her hand and dropped them into the waste-paper basket. 
 &bquo;I'll get a new one of these when we move.&equo; 
 Philip had forgotten temporarily about them moving from Little Knoll, what with getting Caspar out of the tractor-shed and thinking of Lee making his way up to Jubilee Wood. 
 He got up. 
 &bquo;Where are you going?&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Upstairs,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Don't you like our company, then?&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I've things to do.&equo; 
 &bquo;Like what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just things.&equo; 
 He was going to put the medals back in his drawer and listen out of the window for Lee going up the field, listen for the sheep. 
 The phone rang. 
 His Mum answered it. 
 Philip waited. 
 It  might be about Uncle Walter. 
 But it wasn't. 
 &bquo;That was Joyce Butler,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Rebel's gone missing. 
 She wants to know if we've seen him. 
 I said of course we hadn't. 
 What would he come right out our way for?&equo; 
 Philip went to the door as his Dad came in. 
 &bquo;Where are you off?&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;To my room.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's got things to do,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;Secrets.&equo; 
 Philip saw her catch his Dad's eye. 
 That did it. 
 He ran to the bureau. 
 He pulled out the bottom drawer, grabbed all the leaflets from the estate agents, all the newspaper cuttings of houses for sale, and threw them on the floor. 
 They scattered everywhere. 
 &bquo;What about them, then? 
 You never told me. 
 That's secrets.&equo; 
 And he pushed his foot through them. 
 &bquo;Pick them up, son,&equo; said his Dad, not shouting but angry. 
 When his Dad was really angry, he was quiet. 
 &bquo;Pick them up, there's a good boy,&equo; said his Mum, picking up the cutting nearest to her, a half page of photos of houses for sale. 
 &bquo;Leave it,&equo; said his Dad. 
 &bquo;Let him do it.&equo; 
 And he stood over him while Philip picked them all up and packed them back in the drawer. 
 Philip saw the date on one of the letters: May the fifteenth. 
 He stared at his Mum and Dad. 
 They'd been planning it, moving, for a year. 
 And he hadn't known one thing about it. 
 &bquo;Goodnight, Philip,&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;I won't look in before I go to see your Uncle Walter in the morning. 
 It'll be early.&equo; 
 Philip went up to his room. 
 Out of the front window he saw the &bquo;For Sale&equo; sign, the white paint of the board showing up in the light that shone from between the curtains of Tom's cottage. 
 He wasn't going. 
 They couldn't make him. 
 He crossed to the other window. 
 The sheep were quiet. 
 Lee must have got safely up to Jubilee Wood. 
 He opened  the window, letting in the cold wind. 
 He'd go up there too and if he died of exposure, too bad. 
 He didn't care. 
 They could come to his funeral.  
 Philip waited, sitting on his bed till he heard the noise of the television stop, and his Mum and Dad come upstairs. 
 He still had the window open, though it made him shiver. 
 He might as well get used to it, the cold. 
 It probably wouldn't be too bad. 
 Lots of things lived in the woods, all weathers. 
 They survived. 
 And there were boys in films who lived with the animals. 
 The wind shook the window-frame. 
 But they lived in jungles, Tarzan and Mowgli. 
 Jubilee Wood wasn't a jungle. 
 And he wouldn't be on his own with the pheasants and shrews and things. 
 There was Lee. 
 And Caspar. 
 Thinking of Lee made him remember Uncle Walter's medals that he still had in his pocket. 
 He didn't know whether to leave them here with all the other stuff that he was leaving behind or take them with him. 
 He didn't know whether he could trust Lee not to nick them. 
 Lee wasn't like Barry who you couldn't trust, full stop. 
 You just never knew with Lee. 
 Philip kept the medals in his pocket. 
 When he could hear no more sounds from his Mum's and Dad's room, he opened his door. 
 He crept downstairs, hardly making any noise. 
 Luckily the stairs were carpeted. 
 In the kitchen he switched the light on. 
 He'd forgotten about the way it flickered before it came on properly and made a noise. 
 He listened, but there was no sound from upstairs except for his own bedroom door banging. 
 That was his own stupid fault for leaving the window open. 
 The torch was still on the shelf where he'd put it when he came in. 
 He put the battery back in. 
 Then he took two packets of his swimming biscuits and a carton of orange from the back of the fridge, so his Mum wouldn't notice. 
  His bedroom door banged again and the curtain in front of the door moved in the draught. 
 A blanket. 
 He'd need a blanket for the cold nights. 
 There was one on the back of the settee in the living-room. 
 But his Mum would notice right away if that was missing. 
 He'd be better off with one off his bed. 
 But that would mean going upstairs again. 
 Still, he'd have to go back up and shut his door. 
 Banging like that, it would waken his Mum and Dad. 
 He put the biscuits and carton down on the table and turned off the light. 
 He was all right going up the stairs till half-way. 
 Then feeling for the window-sill that was part way up, he knocked the owl lamp that his Mum had put there for him to take up to his room. 
 It fell on the stairs, knocking against the wall. 
 &bquo;Is that you, Philip?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm going to the bathroom,&equo; said Philip, putting the stupid lamp that his Mum had bought him back on the window-sill. 
 Then he went to the bathroom. 
 Fancy her thinking that getting him that lamp would make him feel any different about moving. 
 He could just see it in that box bedroom in Hill View Close, its eyes full of light like some weird toy. 
 Then he put Hill View Close out of his mind. 
 He wasn't going. 
 Back in his bedroom he pulled off his under-blanket. 
 For a second he was in two minds about it. 
 It was pink, one he'd had from a baby. 
 He folded it and smoothed back the sheet. 
 What did it matter what colour it was? 
 There'd be no one to see it up there in the wood, except Lee. 
 And he wouldn't say anything. 
 Philip didn't mind if he did. 
 He wouldn't pick on him like Barry. 
 Philip shut the window and took the camouflage jacket his Mum had been going to throw out. 
 Then with it and the blanket he slipped out of the room, shutting the door quietly and letting the knob go back slowly without a sound. 
 He had to be careful. 
 He couldn't use the bathroom as an excuse this time. 
 If he went to the toilet twice in five  minutes his Mum would think he was ill and she'd be out like a shot. 
 In the kitchen he put on the combat jacket under his anorak. 
 Off the back of the door he took an old net shopping-bag that his Mum hardly ever used and stuffed the carton and biscuits into it. 
 Also hanging on the back of the door was the hot water-bottle that his Mum filled for him when he had tonsilitis. 
 He had a brainwave. 
 He'd fill it and carry it up to the wood in the blanket. 
 Then he'd be warm all right. 
 The only problem was the kettle, the noise he would make filling it. 
 He shut the kitchen door. 
 He'd have to risk the pipes making that queer noise they sometimes did when you turned on the tap. 
 He wasn't in luck. 
 As soon as he turned the tap on it started. 
 Bang, bang, bang, in the pipes. 
 He'd woken his Mum and Dad. 
 He knew he had. 
 One of them went to the toilet. 
 Quickly while the toilet was still flushing, Philip filled the kettle. 
 When he heard the bedroom door shut again he switched on the kettle. 
 He wondered about making himself a hot drink but he'd have to wait too long to drink it. 
 Those pipes banging like that had made him nervous. 
 But he could fill a flask with coffee. 
 His Mum had about four flasks she kept on top of the fridge. 
 A couple of them she never used. 
 Philip took one, spooned in some coffee, and poured in a bit of milk. 
 The kettle was getting too noisy by half. 
 He switched it off and half filled the hot water-bottle. 
 He poured the rest of the water into the flask. 
 Then he put it in the bag and wrapped the blanket round the bottle. 
 He was set. 
 For a moment he wondered about taking food for the pheasants. 
 But he had a lot to carry and it was time he went. 
 He could hear his Dad coughing. 
 He might go to the bathroom, or come downstairs even. 
 Philip turned off the light. 
 With the blanket under one arm and carrying the bag with the other, he unlocked the  door. 
 His Mum and Dad would wonder why it was open but they'd most likely think that they had forgotten to lock it. 
 It wouldn't be the first time. 
 It happened when each thought that the other had locked it. 
 They'd probably have a row about it. 
 Outside in the yard he reorganized his load, so he had a free hand for the torch. 
 He wondered if he'd been sensible to bring so much. 
 It wouldn't be too easy climbing the fence with this lot. 
 By the shed he jumped as he heard what sounded like the dust-bin lid being pushed off. 
 Cats most likely, or maybe the fox. 
 He shone the torch and saw by the bin not a fox but a dog. 
 Oh no, not Caspar. 
 Surely Lee hadn't let him get loose. 
 Still shining the torch, Philip went closer to the dog. 
 It jumped away snarling, barring his way through the fence. 
 In a mess by the bin were papers and the end of a loaf his Mum had chucked away. 
 It wasn't Caspar. 
 It was Rebel. 
 Philip swung the bag at him and the dog ran off down towards the wood-shed. 
 The sheep, thought Philip. 
 It's Rebel that's worrying the sheep. 
 He had come that far from Thirkett after all. 
 He'd warn Lee when he got up to the wood. 
 He switched off the torch. 
 He'd better not switch it on till he was in the wood. 
 Jack could be out in the field with a ewe and Philip would be a good target, a bobbing torch across the field. 
 It was a good thing he knew the way so well. 
 He didn't envy Lee going up with Caspar pulling, and not knowing the way like Philip did. 
 There was no light in the lambing-shed now. 
 That was a good sign, but Jack could still come out at any time. 
 Philip hurried past the shed to the gate. 
 He dropped the bag over and then climbed with the blanket and the torch. 
 He was glad Rebel had gone off towards the road, though he had probably run back by now for the loaf. 
 So much for Barry boasting at school that Rebel only ate the best.  
 Safely over the other side of the gate and out of the farm precincts, he ran up the hill towards the quarry. 
 It was very dark with no stars. 
 By now his eyes were used to the darkness but he could make out very little. 
 He fell over things he avoided in daytime like stones and bushes. 
 He couldn't see the sheep. 
 It was bitterly cold and it was raining. 
 No, snowing. 
 Snow settled on the blanket and he could feel it on the back of his neck. 
 He ran the few yards to the fence. 
 panicked by the snow which he hadn't been expecting, he threw everything over and he had a job finding it all on the other side. 
 In the end he switched the torch on. 
 There was less snow in the wood but he had difficulty walking. 
 Carrying so much, he hadn't a hand to push the branches away. 
 All the time he'd imagined Lee up in the wood, with Caspar most probably sheltering in the hide, but now, as he climbed through the wood in the gulley, he wasn't so sure that Lee would be there. 
 Maybe he'd been scared off by the snow and taken Caspar home. 
 A branch whipped him in the face. 
 He struggled on, dragging the bag as he half-crawled up the steep bits. 
 The blanket had come unrolled and twice he brought himself down with it. 
 He thought of his Mum and Dad at home. 
 Maybe he should go back, but inside him was still the lump of anger against them. 
 They'd be sorry, come looking for him. 
 But he'd probably be dead, frozen, lying under a pile of leaves, dead from starvation. 
 The biscuits wouldn't last him long. 
 He'd most likely end up eating the grain he'd nicked from Mrs Wright for the pheasants. 
 He was nearly at the feeding-ground now. 
 He'd come out onto the ride. 
 He shone the torch round the clearing. 
 It didn't light up much. 
 &bquo;Who's that?, 
 &bquo;It's me, Philip.&equo; 
 He saw Lee now, crouching by the hide. 
 Caspar was tied to a tree with wire fixed to Philip's belt. 
 &bquo;What are you doing?&equo; said Lee.  
 &bquo;What d'you think?&equo; said Philip. 
 He dropped the bag on the ground and the blanket with the bottle inside. 
 He didn't care about the blanket on the ground. 
 It was wet enough already. 
 Lee had grabbed the bag and was pulling things out of it. 
 &bquo;Leave that,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I'm thirsty,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Have some of the juice, then. 
 Only a little of it, mind.&equo; 
 Lee scrabbled in the bag, found the carton and opened it. 
 He took a few gulps, then passed it to Philip. 
 Philip propped it carefully by the hide. 
 &bquo;It's ever so cold,&equo; said Lee. 
 He was shivering. 
 &bquo;Let's go in the hide,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It'll be warmer in there.&equo; 
 &bquo;She's in there,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Who?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;The old lady.&equo; 
 &bquo;What, Mrs Wright?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, her, her with the chickens and those eggs in little drawers.&equo; 
 The snow was thick now, covering them both, settling. 
 It showed up white. 
 Philip looked down at Lee where he was crouching on the ground by Caspar. 
 Maybe he'd gone mad. 
 Snow did make people mad. 
 &bquo;Have you gone crazy or something?&equo; said Philip, scared. 
 &bquo;She's in there all right, you see.&equo; 
 Philip knelt by the hide entrance, shining in the torch. 
 &bquo;Is that you, boy? 
 Hasn't anyone ever told you not to shine a torch in someone's eyes. 
 It's like a gun. 
 Never point it anyone.&equo; 
 Philip lowered the torch. 
 Lee was right. 
 It was her, Mrs Wright. 
 She was sitting in Philip's hide, wearing her old coat. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry,&equo; said Philip. 
 He went back to Lee. 
 &bquo;What's she doing here?&equo; he whispered.  
 &bquo;I found her,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;In the camp. 
 She asked me what the time was. 
 I think she'd been asleep.&equo; 
 Suddenly Caspar barked. 
 Lee tugged the wire. 
 &bquo;I saw the other dog,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;The one that's worrying the sheep. 
 It belongs to a boy at school.&equo; 
 &bquo;You should tell him,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Tell him,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;You must be joking. 
 He'd never believe me.&equo; 
 He looked away. 
 &bquo;Anyway I hate him.&equo; 
 He'd never told anyone that before. 
 It made him feel a lot better. 
 &bquo;Barry can't control Rebel,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;He doesn't bother with him. 
 He said he was taking him to obedience classes but he wasn't. 
 He lies to everyone.&equo; 
 Caspar barked again. 
 Philip jumped. 
 &bquo;You shouldn't let him bark like that.&equo; 
 &bquo;I give him sweets,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Every so often. 
 I've only three left. 
 I gave her two.&equo; 
 He nodded towards the hide. 
 &bquo;Why doesn't she go home?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I don't know,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;You ask her.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm scared to,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;But she should go back home. 
 She's old.&equo; 
 &bquo;She's freezing,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;She said so.&equo; 
 Philip looked at the pink blanket where it lay on the ground. 
 He picked it up and the hot water-bottle fell out. 
 He'd forgotten about that. 
 &bquo;Go on,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Give her them. 
 She might die if she's old. 
 I don't want her to die. 
 I'd be scared.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right, then.&equo; 
 Philip took the bottle and the blanket to the entrance of the hide. 
 &bquo;Here,&equo; he said, pushing them inside. 
 &bquo;A blanket and a hot water-bottle,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;Just what the doctor ordered.&equo; 
 Philip went back to Lee. 
 &bquo;Did she say she wanted the doctor?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I don't think so.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's this?&equo; said Lee who was fiddling with the bag again.  
 &bquo;Coffee and biscuits,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;D'you want some?, 
 &bquo;I'm starving,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Me too,&equo; said Philip. 
 He opened one of the packets of biscuits and unscrewed the lid of the flask. 
 Then he poured the coffee. 
 Lee held the torch. 
 He had half, then passed the cup to Lee. 
 &bquo;I forgot the sugar,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's disgusting.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all right,&equo; said Lee, tipping out the dregs and wiping his mouth with his sleeve. 
 &bquo;What time have you got to be back?&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip screwed the top on the flask. 
 &bquo;I'm not going back.&equo; 
 Lee gave Caspar a biscuit. 
 Philip poured more coffee and held the cup in his hands to warm them. 
 &bquo;Why not?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Lots of reasons,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Anyway, I like it up here.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what she said, Mrs Wright,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;That she liked being in the wood.&equo; 
 &bquo;What else did she say?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not much,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;She kept going on about the fox and coughing.&equo; 
 Philip shone the torch round the clearing. 
 He saw something lying beside the log. 
 &bquo;What's that?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Her scarf,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;No, the other side.&equo; 
 Lee got to the log first. 
 &bquo;It's a gun,&equo; he said, bending to pick it up. 
 &bquo;Don't touch it,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's her gun. 
 It's most likely loaded.&equo;  
 Lee crouched down beside the gun, running his hand along it. 
 &bquo;It's a shot-gun, isn't it,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip knew he shouldn't be touching it. 
 &bquo;Here,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Take this coffee to her.&equo; 
 Lee took the coffee from his hand and Philip switched the torch off. 
 Quickly he pulled the gun round to the other side of the log, hiding it. 
 He didn't trust Lee not to mess about with it. 
 The thought of Lee with a loaded gun made him feel nearly sick. 
 &bquo;What did you have to switch the torch off for?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I've spilt it now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Get some more coffee. 
 There's plenty,&equo; said Philip, turning the torch on again. 
 Lee poured more coffee from the flask with Philip holding the torch. 
 &bquo;I'll take them too,&equo; said Lee, taking the biscuits. 
 &bquo;You might as well take the whole lot, the orange and all,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It's getting wet.&equo; 
 The snow was turning to sleet. 
 They ran over to the hide and Lee crawled half in. 
 &bquo;We've got some coffee,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;No sugar.&equo; 
 &bquo;How lovely,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 She was sitting there with the pink blanket spread over her, the hot water-bottle on her ankles. 
 She took the cup Lee held out to her in her knobbly hands. 
 Philip knew it was arthritis. 
 Uncle Walter had that. 
 &bquo;Is this something to do with the Boy Scouts?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip, crouching, only his head in the hide. 
 It was pouring down now, rain not sleet.  
 &bquo;You look like a couple of drowned rats,&equo; said Mrs Wright, looking at them in the light of Philip's torch. 
 &bquo;Come on in.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right, then,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip crawled in after him and they sat close up against the side. 
 &bquo;I was fortunate to find this shelter,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;I felt quite ill. 
 I couldn't walk back.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's his,&equo; said Lee, prodding Philip. 
 &bquo;He built it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is it your camp?&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;No, it's a hide,&equo; said Philip. 
 He hoped she wasn't going to ask any more questions. 
 He hated answering questions. 
 &bquo;He watches those coloured birds,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;The ones like big parrots.&equo; 
 &bquo;Pheasants,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;And he feeds them,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;He's going to catch one.&equo; 
 &bquo;Shut up, can't you,&equo; said Philip. 
 Why couldn't Lee keep his mouth shut? 
 &bquo;Ah,&equo; said Mrs Wright, pulling something from behind her. 
 &bquo;Is this what you give the pheasants to eat?&equo; 
 She held up the polythene bag that was half full of grain, her grain. 
 Philip nodded. 
 &bquo;And I thought it was those rats or my silly old brain and all the time it was you, young man.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't take much,&equo; muttered Philip. 
 &bquo;But we must feed the birds,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 She put her hand in her pocket as if she'd suddenly remembered something. 
 &bquo;You shoot them,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;We saw your gun.&equo; 
 &bquo;Vermin,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;I only shoot vermin. 
 And I sometimes use the gun to frighten dogs away from the hens.&equo; 
 Yes, thought Philip, she did that all right. 
 Outside Caspar was giving short barks and whining. 
 &bquo;They're going to shoot my dog,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;They think  it's him that's killing the sheep. 
 It isn't him. 
 It's another dog like him.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've seen that one,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;It's a black monster.&equo; 
 Caspar whined again. 
 Out of her pocket Mrs Wright took a revolting bone covered in fat. 
 &bquo;Give it to him,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I forgot to put it out for the birds yesterday morning.&equo; 
 Philip shone the torch on the bone. 
 Had she had that in her pocket since yesterday morning? 
 What would his Mum and Dad say if they knew she kept meat as good as rotten in her pocket? 
 Lee took the bone and crawled over Philip. 
 Mrs Wright had a coughing fit, holding her chest and her eyes watering. 
 Lee went out of the hide, letting rain in through the opening. 
 Mrs Wright had stopped coughing. 
 She closed her eyes. 
 Philip switched off the torch. 
 &bquo;He liked that,&equo; said Lee, crawling back in again. 
 &bquo;You can hear him chewing it. 
 Listen.&equo; 
 But Mrs Wright couldn't hear anything. 
 She was asleep, her head flopped over. 
 Lee pointed at her. 
 &bquo;We could go somewhere else,&equo; whispered Philip. 
 &bquo;Where?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;It's pelting down out there. 
 I'm not going anywhere.&equo; 
 And he curled up, pulling some of the blanket over him. 
 Philip shivered. 
 He was cold and uncomfortable. 
 Uncle Walter's helmet was sticking into him. 
 He put it on and leant back against Lee. 
 Lee grunted. 
 Mrs Wright was snoring a bit. 
 &bquo;You awake?&equo; he said to Lee. 
 There was no answer. 
 He'd gone to sleep too. 
 Philip tried to stay awake. 
 Someone should be on watch. 
 But what he was thinking turned more and more into bits of dream and finally he slept too. 
 He woke with pins and needles in his foot and Lee poking him. 
 He must have slept nearly all night. 
 It was getting light. 
 He wriggled his foot. 
 He was wet and cold. 
  He wasn't sure that he could stand many more nights up in the wood. 
 Lee seemed quite cheerful. 
 &bquo;I'm going out to see if Caspar's all right,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Give us the hat, it's still raining.&equo; 
 Philip looked at Mrs Wright. 
 She was still asleep &mdash; or dead. 
 Lee came back into the hide. 
 &bquo;He's finished the bone,&equo; he said. 
 Philip pointed at Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;Is she dead?&equo; 
 Lee shook his head. 
 &bquo;She's still breathing.&equo; 
 Lee passed Philip a biscuit. 
 &bquo;What will they do if they find us,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;My Mum and Dad'll be really angry,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Mine too,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I wonder what they'll do if they find her up here?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Put her in a madhouse,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Or a hospital.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh no, they won't,&equo; said Mrs Wright sitting up. 
 &bquo;They'll put me in a home for the elderly. 
 And they'll sell my house.&equo; 
 &bquo;My Mum and Dad are selling ours,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;The people have been and put a sign up.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh dear,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;It's trouble for all of us, then.&equo; 
 Philip looked at her. 
 She didn't seem very bothered. 
 Maybe it didn't matter so much if you were old. 
 They none of them said anything for a long time. 
 Lee was pulling bits of twig through the camouflage net and going to the entrance all the time to look at Caspar. 
 At least he hadn't insisted on bringing him inside. 
 Mrs Wright had dropped off to sleep again, making a kind of whistling noise through her mouth. 
 It was getting noisy in the wood. 
 Philip could hear pheasants calling. 
 And a plane. 
 &bquo;Spy plane already,&equo; said Lee leaning out of the hide and shooting down the plane with an imaginary machine gun. 
 Mrs Wright opened her eyes.  
 &bquo;Were you in the War?&equo; asked Lee. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;I was in the War.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you shoot down planes?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Women made guns and drove ambulances and things,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;They didn't shoot down planes.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know someone who did,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;I know who,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;It was him in the photo. 
 By the Spitfire, wasn't it.&equo; 
 He leant forward and the helmet fell over his face. 
 Philip pinched him. 
 They weren't supposed to have seen the photos. 
 It was a secret they'd been in the house. 
 He looked anxiously at Mrs Wright, waiting for her to ask questions. 
 But she pulled at the pink blanket and didn't say anything. 
 &bquo;Did he make it back home?&equo; said Lee, pushing the helmet up so he could see. 
 But Mrs Wright didn't answer. 
 She was looking for her cigarettes. 
 Philip passed them to her. 
 Lee crawled out of the hide. 
 &bquo;It's stopped raining,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It sounds like thunder,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;How odd at this time of year.&equo; 
 Philip stuck his head out of the hide. 
 It did sound like thunder. 
 &bquo;Lee,&equo; he called. 
 There was no answer. 
 He crawled right out into the open. 
 He couldn't see Lee. 
 He wasn't with Caspar. 
 &bquo;Lee,&equo; he called again. 
 Caspar jumped up at him, pulling at his makeshift lead. 
 &bquo;Where is he, then?&equo; he said to the dog. 
 He looked up at the sky. 
 It was grey, still spotting with rain. 
 The noise was louder. 
 And it wasn't thunder. 
 He knew what it was. 
 It was the sheep running. 
 It was the noise he'd heard before. 
 Caspar began to whine. 
 Something had scared the sheep. 
 Rebel most likely. 
 And Jack wasn't there. 
 This was the time of day he went to Mr Hyde's farm to fetch the milk. 
 Philip ran to the edge of the feeding-ground and stood  on the log. 
 He looked along the ride both ways. 
 There was no Lee. 
 And no gun either. 
 It had gone. 
 He knew at once Lee had taken it. 
 Philip felt sick. 
 There was no knowing what he'd do with it. 
 If he got into one of his queer moods he could do anything. 
 He could point it at someone, shoot even. 
 If he started fiddling with it the way he fiddled with everything it could go off in his own face. 
 Philip ran down the ride. 
 He should never have let Lee go out on his own. 
 You had to watch him. 
 It was his fault. 
 Philip ran down the ride towards the field, shouting for Lee. 
 He didn't care who heard him. 
 His feet splashed in the pools that had formed in the night. 
 He scrambled over the fallen branch and saw Lee by the gate with the gun. 
 &bquo;Put the gun down,&equo; shouted Philip. 
 &bquo;It's loaded.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's the killer dog,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Come quick. 
 It's after the lambs.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't touch the gun,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;It'll go off.&equo; 
 Lee raised the gun clumsily to his shoulder. 
 &bquo;What are you doing?&equo; shouted Philip. 
 The ground was shaking with the galloping of the sheep. 
 &bquo;I'm going to shoot him,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Shoot him dead.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Philip, coming up to him and holding his hand out for the gun. 
 &bquo;I am, I am,&equo; said Lee. 
 And he banged the gun up and down on the gate. 
 Philip looked at where Rebel had separated one of the lambs from the flock. 
 It hadn't a chance. 
 Lee raised the gun, aiming it. 
 He fired, missing by miles. 
 &bquo;I can't,&equo; he said, turning to Philip. 
 &bquo;I can't see. 
 My glasses are all steamed up.&equo; 
 He was shaking from the shock of the recoil of the gun, which had sent him flying backwards. 
 &bquo;You do it.&equo; 
 Philip shook his head. 
 He couldn't do it. 
 &bquo;Kill it,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;If you don't, they'll shoot Caspar. 
 That's him barking now. 
 They'll find him and shoot him. 
  They will, they will.&equo; 
 He tugged Philip's arm. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; he shouted. 
 &bquo;It's getting the lamb.&equo; 
 Philip saw Rebel reach the lamb and begin to savage it. 
 The ewe couldn't save it. 
 &bquo;Give it here, then,&equo; said Philip. 
 Lee pushed the gun along the gate. 
 Philip raised the gun to his shoulder and sited it on Rebel and the lamb. 
 He pulled the trigger and the report was deafening. 
 The recoil flung them both back. 
 &bquo;You missed,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Have another go.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's only two cartridges in,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;We've fired them.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's killed it,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;It isn't moving any more.&equo; 
 Then they both heard a shout. 
 They turned round. 
 Mrs Wright was coming slowly along the ride towards them. 
 She seemed out of breath. 
 &bquo;Is it that dog?&equo; she said, coming up to the gate. 
 &bquo;It's killed a lamb,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;There'll be no stopping it now, then,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;Here, give me that gun.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's no cartridges,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;We've fired them.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've got some,&equo; said Lee. 
 He started pulling things out of his pocket. 
 Nails, screws, staples. 
 &bquo;You nicked those from my Dad,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Hang on,&equo; said Lee. 
 And he took two cartridges out of his pocket. 
 Philip knew where he'd got them, from Mrs Wright's, the time they'd sneaked into her house. 
 &bquo;You'll have to load it,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;I'm too slow with my old hands.&equo; 
 Philip broke the gun and fitted the cartridges in. 
 Rebel was racing after another lamb he'd steered away from the main flock. 
 &bquo;He's coming this way,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Quick.&equo; 
 Mrs Wright raised the gun and aimed. 
 Philip shut his eyes and prayed that she would hit Rebel. 
 The lamb he was  after he saw now was a black and white one that had been sickly and Jack had kept in the lambing-shed a long time. 
 It was a triplet and small. 
 &bquo;Go on,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Now.&equo; 
 There was a loud report. 
 &bquo;Missed him,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;But you got him scared.&equo; 
 Rebel was tearing away from them now. 
 &bquo;You've got one more shot,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Hurry.&equo; 
 There was a bang as he spoke. 
 &bquo;Got him that time,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 She had. 
 Somehow she had hit him when he was running at full speed and almost out of range. 
 Rebel lay motionless on the ground. 
 The triplet, reunited with its mother, was heading back towards the flock that was bunched up against the top fence. 
 &bquo;You got him all right,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;About time too,&equo; said Mrs Wright, flexing her fingers. 
 &bquo;I shan't be able to do that for much longer. 
 With these old fingers.&equo; 
 Lee took the stump of a tube of sweets out of his pocket. 
 &bquo;Have one,&equo; he said. 
 Mrs Wright took a sweet. 
 He offered one to Philip. 
 &bquo;No, thanks.&equo; 
 What would Barry do to him if he knew that he Philip had tried to shoot Rebel? 
 &bquo;What'll they do with him?&equo; he said, turning away from the sight of the dead dog lying in the field. 
 &bquo;If he's got no owner, they'll just bury him,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;I know the people that own him,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Will they come for him?&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;It depends whether they want to own up to it.&equo; 
 &bquo;They won't,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Barry never owns up to anything.&equo;  
 &bquo;Well, that's that,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;perhaps we should go home. 
 I feel better now, much better.&equo; 
 Philip thought she didn't look it. 
 And her breathing was queer. 
 &bquo;Caspar,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I'll have to get Caspar.&equo; 
 Mrs Wright was sitting down on the bank, the gun across her knees. 
 Philip ran back along the ride with Lee. 
 &bquo;What do you reckon the time is?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I don't know,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Morning, at any rate.&equo; 
 They skirted the fallen branch. 
 &bquo;What about your Mum and Dad?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Won't they be worried?&equo; 
 &bquo;They sleep late Saturdays.&equo; 
 They reached the feeding-ground and Lee untied Caspar. 
 &bquo;That's my belt,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;You can have it back,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;You come to my house.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not coming back down,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I'm stopping up in the wood.&equo; 
 Lee stared at him. 
 &bquo;What for?&equo; 
 &bquo;I feel like it.&equo; 
 Philip looked round the clearing. 
 It was a mess. 
 There was the carton of juice tipped over outside the hide and the paper from the biscuits. 
 From out of the hide trailed the pink blanket. 
 The bone Mrs Wright had given Caspar lay by the tree. 
 &bquo;What, are you stopping up here nights?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;All on your own?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't mind being on my own,&equo; said Philip. 
 That's what he wanted, to be on his own. 
 The  feeding-ground, his place, looked like a tip. 
 Lee was fiddling with the helmet which lay near the log. 
 &bquo;And you can give that back,&equo; said Philip. 
 Lee threw the helmet across the ground towards him. 
 &bquo;Want a sweet?&equo; he said, holding out the last one in the packet. 
 &bquo;No, thanks.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't you like them?, 
 &bquo;Look, get out, will you. 
 Leave me alone.&equo; 
 Lee was prodding at the hide with a stick, Caspar leaping about like a mad thing. 
 &bquo;It's collapsing,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;There were too many inside.&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't ask you to come, or her,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;This is my place. 
 D'you hear?&equo; 
 He was shouting. 
 &bquo;My place, and you and your stupid dog and her had no right up here.&equo; 
 Lee screwed the top on the flask 
 &bquo;Why are you stopping up here?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Is it your Mum and Dad?&equo; 
 &bquo;And don't you nick that,&equo; said Philip, ignoring the question and pointing to the flask. 
 &bquo;I know why you're at that school. 
 Because you nick things.&equo; 
 Lee disappeared into the hide and came out waving the polythene bag with the grain in. 
 &bquo;I'm not taking any more of that,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;No point.&equo; 
 &bquo;Here,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;You can have these back. 
 I don't want them.&equo; 
 He held out the handful of nails and stuff he'd taken out of his Dad's shed. 
 Cupping his hand, he put the things in his hand into the empty carton. 
 &bquo;They might come in handy for making your trap,&equo; he said. 
 Lee picked up the helmet and put it on Philip's head. 
 &bquo;So long, then,&equo; he said and ran off with Caspar. 
 Philip didn't move. 
 Two planes went over but he didn't look up. 
 He heard Lee shooting them down, then him whistling. 
 From the sound of it he was still around. 
 A pheasant called and he heard Lee try to answer it. 
 Philip crept through the trees at the edge of the ride. 
 Lee  was sitting on the fallen branch. 
 He was peeling the bark off a stick. 
 Then he jumped off, grabbed Caspar who was trailing his lead, and ran off towards the gate. 
 He climbed over it and disappeared. 
 Philip ran down the bracken bank to the gate and watched him run down the field to Mrs Wright who was walking slowly down the field. 
 The two of them made their way together towards the road with Caspar. 
 Philip shivered. 
 It was cold. 
 The sun had shone briefly, then gone. 
 It looked like it could rain again or even snow. 
 It was cold enough for snow. 
 A pair of pheasants, a cock and a hen, flew over the ride calling. 
 They'd be nesting somewhere. 
 &bquo;Wait,&equo; he shouted. 
 &bquo;I'm coming.&equo; 
 And he ran full speed down the hill, by-passing the bodies of Rebel and the lamb and scattering the sheep that had almost settled again. 
 Lee and Mrs Wright who'd nearly reached the gate by the road turned and waited. 
 &bquo;Here,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Take Caspar.&equo; 
 Philip took the lead. 
 And Lee opened the gate for Mrs Wright. 
 The three of them walked back to the village. 
 At the school they stopped. 
 There was no one about. 
 &bquo;Caspar and me'll be off home, then,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I think I'll go and see my friend,&equo; said Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;I'll take her some daffodils.&equo; 
 She coughed, leaning on the gun. 
 &bquo;It's heavy,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'll carry it down for you,&equo; said Philip. 
 She looked all in. 
 &bquo;What about your Mum and Dad?&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;They're out. 
 They won't be back for a while. 
 My Mum's gone to see my Uncle Walter in hospital and my Dad's got a coaching session at the swimming baths.&equo; 
 They walked down to the Old Rectory gates. 
 &bquo;So long,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;See you.&equo; 
 Philip looked after him as he and Caspar ran off past the church. 
 See him? 
 When? 
 Because Lee went to Garth House his Mum took objection to him, and anyway he was moving to Thirkett, wasn't he?  
 He gave the gun to Mrs Wright. 
 &bquo;If I were you,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'd leave off feeding those pheasants till winter-time.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right, then. 
 Thanks.&equo; 
 Mrs Wright went into the house and Philip went out into the road. 
 Miss Lofthouse had taken the wreaths from the Memorial. 
 He leant over the church wall and Uncle Walter's helmet tipped forward. 
 He straightened it. 
 He'd forgotten he was wearing it. 
 While he fixed the strap, he read the names on the Memorial. 
 There were five and he knew them all. 
 Denis Atkinson, Charles Hyde, George Lofthouse, Thomas Lofthouse, and Anthony Richard Wright. 
 Anthony Richard Wright. 
 That must be the man in the photograph in Mrs Wright's bedroom. 
 Philip put the helmet back on. 
 So he hadn't come back. 
 Philip went back up the village. 
 He wondered about Uncle Walter, what his Mum would say when she got back. 
 Philip hoped Uncle Walter wouldn't be in hospital a long time. 
 He wouldn't like that. 
 Back at the house Philip made himself some tea and ate some cereal. 
 Then he had a shower and changed. 
 His Mum had left him a note on the kitchen table. 
 &bquo;Clear your room. 
 Dad's coming with me to see Uncle Walter. 
 Back about two. 
 Mum.&equo; 
 That's what he'd do, clear his room. 
 He unpinned all his pictures and posters from the wall. 
 He took down everything except the photo of Uncle John's platoon. 
 Then he went through his desk drawers, pulling out all his cuttings and notes, plans and magazines, everything to do with Jubilee Wood and the pheasants. 
 He stopped himself from looking at any of them and stuffed them into his waste-paper basket. 
 Then he took it out to the back and burnt every bit of paper in his Dad's incinerator. 
 When there was nothing but ash he could crumble with a stick he went back up to his room. 
 He took down the picture of Uncle John and put it in the drawer of his desk. 
  The room was quite bare like a hospital. 
 Suddenly he remembered the owl lamp that he'd knocked in the night. 
 He fitted on a plug and tried it out in his room, closing the curtains. 
 The two eyes glowed. 
 He was in his room when he heard his Mum and Dad come back. 
 He ran downstairs. 
 &bquo;How's Uncle Walter?&equo; he said, touching the medals in his pocket for a charm. 
 &bquo;He'll mend,&equo; said his Mum, switching the kettle on. 
 &bquo;But they say he mustn't go home and live on his own, not for a long while at any rate.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where'll he go, then?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;He won't go into a Home and that's flat. 
 Even temporary. 
 I don't know what to do for the best. 
 It's a real worry with him being so far away. 
 I can't keep going over there.&equo; 
 The phone rang. 
 &bquo;Now who is it?&equo; said his Dad, going into the living-room to answer it. 
 &bquo;Couldn't Uncle Walter come here till his leg's mended?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;We won't be here, Philip,&equo; said his Mum. 
 His Dad came back into the kitchen. 
 &bquo;I'm really sorry, love,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; said his Mum. 
 &bquo;It's not Uncle Walter, is it?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 The house in Hill View. 
 It's been sold.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sold? 
 How d'you mean? 
 We only looked at it yesterday?, 
 &bquo;It seems someone's offered more than the asking price and they've accepted it. 
 There's no chance.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll bet it was that woman who went to see the house after us yesterday. 
 I didn't like the look of her. 
 I said she looked made of money, didn't I?&equo; 
 Philip looked at his Mum, then at his Dad. 
 &bquo;So we're not moving, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;It doesn't look like it,&equo; said his Mum, slumping down on the settee. 
 &bquo;Not for the moment, anyway.&equo;  
 &bquo;So Uncle Walter can stay here till his leg's mended?&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose so.&equo; 
 Philip straightened his Dad's trophies where Lee had moved them. 
 He'd like that, his Uncle Walter, stopping in Little Knoll. 
 Maybe he'd persuade his Mum not to move. 
 You never knew. 
 He had an image of Uncle Walter throwing his crutches away and Philip giving him a pheasant chick. 
 He'd have to make a better trap though. 
 Then he remembered something. 
 &bquo;I've just burnt all my stuff.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, there was no call to do that,&equo; said his Mum. 
 There was a thump at the door. 
 &bquo;Answer it, will you, Philip.&equo; 
 Philip opened the door. 
 It was Lee, standing there with the pink blanket, the string bag and the hot water bottle. 
 &bquo;I've fetched these down,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I went back up to the wood. 
 And my Mum's had a letter. 
 I'm going to your school next term. 
 Three days.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who's that?&equo; called Philip's Mum. 
 Philip took the things and whipped past his Mum into the kitchen. 
 She didn't notice the things. 
 She was looking at Lee. 
 &bquo;I've a note from my Mum,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;She says, can you come to coffee and tell her about what I'll need for school.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought you went to Garth House,&equo; said Philip's Mum. 
 &bquo;Not any more,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;Not much anyway. 
 Only two days. 
 They're trying me out at the school Phil goes to &mdash; to see if I can manage. 
 My Mum's had a letter.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's called Philip, not Phil,&equo; said Philip's Mum. 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;He's my friend.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'd better come in, then,&equo; said Philip's Mum. 
 Lee wiped his feet on the mat. 
 Philip was pleased. 
 You could see she liked that. 
 She took the note from Lee's Mum. 
 Through the open door Philip saw Jack drive up and stop outside the gate. 
 &bquo;I've a dog,&equo; he shouted. 
 &bquo;Shot dead. 
 Do you know it?&equo;  
 He jumped out of the van and pulled off a sack that was hiding something in the back of the truck. 
 It was Rebel's body. 
 Philip's Mum went up to it. 
 &bquo;That's Butlers&equo; dog,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;It's killed one of t'lambs,&equo; said Jack. 
 &bquo;I'd better go and phone Joyce,&equo; said Philip's Mum. 
 &bquo;She'll be upset.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who shot it?&equo; said Philip's Dad. 
 &bquo;I don't know owt about it,&equo; said Jack. 
 &bquo;Dead in t'field it was. 
 It weren't the dog I locked in the tractor-shed, that's all I know.&equo; 
 &bquo;She shot it,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;The old lady.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mrs Wright, d'you mean?&equo; said Jack. 
 Lee nodded. 
 &bquo;That caps it, that does,&equo; said Jack, moving the pick-up so Tom who was coming up on his tractor could get past. 
 Tom stopped by Jack and turned the engine off. 
 &bquo;I met the doctor,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;He's had old Mrs Wright taken into Atherton hospital.&equo; 
 &bquo;What for?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;What's the matter with her?&equo; 
 &bquo;Pneumonia,&equo; said Tom. 
 He leaned out of the cab window. 
 &bquo;There was a message for one of you boys.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;She said to look after her hens.&equo; 
 &bquo;Will she die?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Of pneumonia?&equo; 
 &bquo;She'll be all right,&equo; said Tom. 
 &bquo;You see.&equo; 
 &bquo;The likes of her'll go on for a bit yet,&equo; said Jack. 
 &bquo;Anyone'd get pneumonia living in that draughty old house,&equo; said Philip's Dad. 
 &bquo;She was all right in the wood,&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip stood on Lee's foot and Lee's voice trailed away. 
 That was their secret, the three of them, the night in Jubilee Wood. 
 Philip's Mum came out of the house. 
 &bquo;A lot of thanks I get for doing a good deed,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I wish I'd never told Joyce,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;She said it couldn't be Rebel that had killed the lamb. 
 She called me all sorts of  names, said I was a liar. 
 I told her Barry should have kept him in, and she said if I started criticizing him, she'd get Don to the phone.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll fettle her,&equo; said Jack. 
 &bquo;Where is it she lives?, 
 &bquo;Forty-eight Hill View,&equo; said Philip's Mum, turning to Philip's Dad. 
 &bquo;It's a good job the sale has fallen through. 
 I don't want her shouting names at me over the fence.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll be taking him, then,&equo; said Jack nodding at the sack in the truck. 
 He leaned out of the cab window. 
 &bquo;You'd best be getting down to those hens of the old lady's,&equo; he said to Philip. 
 &bquo;She'll not likely be doing them for a while.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can I?&equo; said Philip, looking at his Dad. 
 &bquo;All right, son,&equo; he said. 
 Philip and Lee ran down to the Old Rectory. 
 They let the hens out. 
 &bquo;There's four eggs,&equo; shouted Philip. 
 They took two each. 
 &bquo;She said there'd be eggs come the longer days,&equo; said Philip. 
 He looked at Lee. 
 &bquo;What about the one you nicked?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll give it her back,&equo; said Lee, running off to the far side of the orchard. 
 He was pulling something out of the hedge. 
 &bquo;What are you doing?&equo; shouted Philip. 
 &bquo;I got some wire,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;What for?&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;What d'you want wire for?&equo; 
 &bquo;That trap,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I've burnt all the plans and that,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;I can make it,&equo; said Lee. 
 &bquo;I know how. 
 I don't need plans.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right, then.&equo; 
 They tugged at the wire. 
 &bquo;Will we mend the fence?&equo; said Lee. 
 Philip nodded. 
 He knew Mrs Wright wanted the fence fixing. 
 A plane flew over. 
 They both looked up at it. 
 &bquo;He didn't come back,&equo; said Philip. 
 &bquo;Who?&equo;  
 Lee was looking for the bits of the fence that were buried in the grass. 
 &bquo;Him with the Spitfire.&equo; 
 They both faced each other and saluted. 
 Labour's Northern Ireland membership ban RUNNING OUT OF EXCUSES CAMPAIGN FOR LABOUR REPRESENTATION IN NORTHERN IRELAND 
 Running out of excuses 
 The Labour Party's boycott of Northern Ireland is fundamentally undemocratic. 
 It is undemocratic to govern an area without an electoral mandate. 
 It is undemocratic to rule over people without seeking their votes. 
 A Government which is not accountable through the ballot box is not a democratic Government. 
 And the next Labour administration will be an undemocratic charade in Northern Ireland if the party continues with its refusal to organise and contest elections in the province. 
 Each year, Labour Party Conference debates and votes on a whole range of policies; policies which will be implemented when Labour comes to power; policies which will have a massive impact on the day to day lives of every citizen of the state. 
 They cover such areas as taxation, health care, personal social services, social security, economic investment, education, housing, defence and the European Community. 
 The next Labour Government's policies in these areas will affect Northern Ireland just as much as anywhere else in the UK. 
 But no one from Northern Ireland can have any say in the formulation of Labour Party policy. 
 Everyone from the province is banned from the party's ranks. 
 No one from Northern Ireland can take part in conference debates or vote on conference resolutions. 
 Moreover, the Labour Party does not seek a mandate for its policies from the Northern Ireland electorate. 
 Key decisions are taken which will affect people's lives, but no one from the province has any say. 
 That is a fundamental denial of democracy. 
 And apologists for Labour's refusal to organise in Northern Ireland cannot in all conscience describe themselves as democrats. 
 TORIES 
 As well as flouting basic democratic principles in regard to Northern Ireland, Labour is now in the process of giving the Tories a free run in the province. 
 Leaving the Conservative Party unchallenged in 17 constituencies does not make political sense. 
 It also condemns Labour-minded people in the North to acute political frustration. 
 The next election will see a wave of Tory propaganda hit the province and, unless things change, there will be no one there to challenge it. 
 Conservative candidates with Saatchi style slogans and sober suits will tell the province's electorate about the &bquo;Thatcher economic miracle&equo; and will sing the praises of the Government's record on the NHS. 
 Leading Tories in Northern Ireland have already called for the extension of the poll tax to the province. 
 And all their propaganda goes unanswered because the Labour Party has thrown in the towel before the fight has even started. 
 Until recently, the Labour and Tory Parties had a cosy understanding about Northern Ireland. 
 Neither party involved themselves in the messy business of seeking votes in the province, democracy wasn't mentioned. 
 Neither party thought too much about the place at all. 
 Ritual statements were made after atrocities, with party spokesmen ironically condemning &bquo;evil men of violence&equo; for subverting the democratic process. 
 In November 1989, however, the Conservative Party, under pressure from its grassroots, decided to accept members and fight elections in Northern Ireland. 
 In May 1990, the party threw its weight into a Westminster by-election in the province in the Upper Bann constituency even though the area was certainly not natural Tory territory. 
 A message of support from Thatcher for the Conservative candidate was delivered through the voters' letter-boxes and several leading Tories, including Party Chairman Kenneth Baker, visited the constituency to support the election campaign. 
 Predictably, the Conservative candidate Colette Jones was well beaten and lost her deposit. 
 Nonetheless, the Conservatives are still pressing on with their plans to stand in all 17 constituencies in Northern Ireland and to give the electorate the chance to accept or reject their programme for governing the country. 
 But the Labour Party is still nowhere to be seen. 
 This unprincipled position was sharply attacked by the Irish News, the nationalist newspaper which has been standard reading for the Catholic community in the North for the best part of a century. 
 Commenting on the hiding the Tory candidate took in  the  Upper Bann election, the Irish News stated: 
 &bquo;It was a pitiful performance which clearly demonstrated that the people of Northern Ireland have very little time for Mrs Thatcher and her party. 
 The Tories, to their credit, submitted themselves to a democratic election in a part of the territory which they govern &mdash; and they were routed. 
 &bquo;There was, however, an irritating smugness about the statements being issued from the British Labour Party yesterday.  
 &bquo;One spokeswoman is credited  as  saying: &bquo;The result demonstrates the realities of Northern Ireland politics. 
 No magic wand can resolve the problems.&equo; 
 &bquo;Such complacent nonsense really sticks in the craw. 
 It is a fact that for a time last year, there were no statements at all being issued about Northern Ireland by the Labour Party headquarters. 
 &bquo;The reason was that in re-structuring the press office, party chiefs had simply forgotten to allocate any special responsibility for Northern Ireland to any of its press officers. 
 &bquo;This has obviously now been rectified but it is symptomatic of Labour's reluctance to be drawn on the issue&hellip; 
 &bquo;&hellip; 
 Not many Nationalists would applaud Mrs Thatcher to the echo: her intransigence and belligerence have been a source of conflict. 
 But at least she has been prepared for her party to stand in elections here. 
 &bquo;The fact that the Labour Party is standing aloof looks ominous.&equo; 
 (Irish News Editorial 19/5/90) 
 OVERSEAS MEMBERSHIP 
 The extension of the Tory Party to Northern Ireland starkly highlights Labour's unprincipled behaviour. 
 But there is another vivid illustration of the discrimination practised by the Labour Party against people who live  in  the province. 
 Put simply, Northern Ireland is now the only place on the globe where people cannot vote for or join the Labour Party. 
 It is Labour's only no-go area in the entire world. 
 Party members can leave Britain, set up home on the other side of the world and retain their membership cards under Walworth Road's overseas membership arrangements. 
 But if they move to Northern Ireland they will be expelled from the party. 
 What is more, people who move to the other side of the world can continue to vote for the Labour Party in UK elections: recent Tory legislation allows people living abroad to vote in elections back home. 
 But if anyone moves to Belfast they will be unable to vote Labour because the party does not put up candidates there. 
 So you can vote for and join the Labour Party in Bangkok or Belgrade but not in Belfast. 
 In Detroit but not in Derry. 
 In Tokyo but not Toomebridge. 
 In Baghdad but not Ballymena. 
 As we said, Northern Ireland is the Labour Party's only no go area anywhere in the world. 
 Now we would humbly suggest that there is something slightly wrong here. 
 People resident in Northern Ireland will be governed by the Labour Party when it comes to power. 
 The party's policies and programme for power will affect them directly. 
 The next Labour Government will set their taxes, for example. 
 But they are   banned from party membership and cannot vote for the party at election time. 
 Conversely, people living outside the UK (and who have recently been resident in the UK) can continue to join and vote for the party even though the next Labour Government's policies will have little direct impact on their lives. 
 The Labour Party is currently establishing Labour groups overseas in order to mobilise support for the forthcoming general election. 
 But Northern Ireland remains a Labour free zone. 
 LABOUR'S CONSTITUTION 
 On top of this indefensible and increasingly absurd situation, it is also clear that the Labour Party is obliged by its own Constitution to organise in Northern Ireland. 
 That is the commonsense conclusion to be drawn from a reading of Clause IV and IX of the Labour Party Constitution. 
 The first party object expressed in Clause IV(1) of the Labour Party's Constitution is: 
 &bquo;To organise and maintain in Parliament and in the country a Political Labour Party.&equo; 
 The &bquo;Parliament&equo; referred to there is obviously the Westminster Parliament and by implication the &bquo;country&equo; must be the whole territory legislated for by that Parliament, that is, the UK as a whole including Northern Ireland. 
 There is nothing in that Clause or in any other part of the Constitution to suggest otherwise. 
 Furthermore, Clause IX which is concerned with the constitution and responsibilities of the NEC lays down in Section 2 as one of the &bquo;duties&equo; of the NEC: 
 &bquo;To ensure the establishment of, and to keep in active operation, a Constituency Labour Party in every Constituency,&hellip;&equo; 
 There is no suggestion there that the NEC's &bquo;duty&equo; does not extend to the 17 constituencies in Northern Ireland. 
 A plain reading of these two clauses of the Constitution supports the view that the rules of the Labour Party do require it to organise in Northern Ireland. 
 But the Party continues to flout its own rules and the basic principles of parliamentary democracy.  
 LABOUR'S EXCUSES 
 Refreshingly, the party's current front bench spokesman on Northern Ireland, Kevin McNamara, has been disarmingly frank about Labour's behaviour. 
 Shortly after taking up his post, he addressed a Parliamentary Labour Party fringe meeting on Northern Ireland at the 1987 conference in Brighton. 
 When questioned about his support for Labour's membership ban, Mr. McNamara said: &bquo;I don't pretend to take a democratic position on this.&equo; 
 Kevin McNamara is a passionate defender of his party's undemocratic stance and his blunt honesty is to be admired. 
 Not surprisingly, however, the more image-conscious members of Labour's front bench have not spoken in such candid terms. 
 But Neil Kinnock has endorsed the McNamara line on this issue and he has endorsed the main arguments used to justify it. 
 As things stand at present, the Labour Party uses three spurious reasons to justify its unprincipled boycott of Northern Ireland: 
 that there would be no support for the Labour Party in Northern Ireland 
 that the people of the province already have Labour's &bquo;sister party&equo;, the SDLP, to vote for and join. 
 that party organisation in the North would be incompatible with Labour's &bquo;united Ireland by consent&equo; policy. 
 The &bquo;no support&equo; excuse was made most recently by junior party spokesman on Northern Ireland, Roger Stott, in an article for a trade union journal. 
 The other two excuses are regularly voiced by Kevin McNamara. 
 For instance, in September 1989, with the Tory Party set to extend its organisation into Northern Ireland, he was asked if Labour was also going to move into the 17 &bquo;missing constituencies&equo;. 
 McNamara told the press bluntly: &bquo;It is Labour Party policy to achieve a united Ireland by consent and, therefore, it would be foolish to create a further obstacle. 
 In any event, the Labour Party has a sister party in the Socialist International in Northern Ireland &mdash; the SDLP.&equo; 
 (Belfast Telegraph 26/9/90) 
 All three of these excuses are simply that &mdash; excuses. 
 They do not stand up to even the briefest of scrutinies. 
 We will deal with each of them in turn. 
 NO SUPPORT? 
 The argument that Labour should not organise in Northern Ireland because there would be little support for it is particularly unprincipled. 
 If Labour were to stand only in areas where it has a chance of doing well, it would have to withdraw from a swathe of constituencies in Tory heartlands. 
 CLPs in places like Sussex, Fareham, Folkestone and Hythe and Worthing would have to be wound up. 
 Labour members in those constituencies would have to be expelled from the party because they had little chance of ousting the sitting Tory MP. 
 There would quite rightly be an outcry if Labour took this course of action. 
 And there would be an outcry because it is now a basic principle of parliamentary democracy that parties of government stand in all constituencies across the state. 
 Parties seeking to rule a country should be accountable to all the people of the country. 
 They should present their policies to every member of the electorate. 
 And all the voters should have the opportunity to mark their approval or disapproval of these policies. 
 That is why Labour and the Tories stand in areas where they know they will lose their deposits. 
 That is why the Tory Party always contests the  Rhondda , for example. 
 And that is why the SDP was declared to be a spent force the instant David Owen said that it would not be contesting every seat at the next election. 
 It is by no means clear that the Labour Party would receive little support in Northern Ireland. 
 But even if this was the case, it would be no justification for the party's boycott of the province. 
 If the principle of contesting every seat holds good in England, Scotland and Wales it should hold good in Northern Ireland as well. 
 For the province will be affected by the next Labour government's policies just as much as the rest of the UK. 
 The &bquo;no support&equo; excuse has been coming more to the fore recently. 
 Party spokesman Roger Stott gave a fairly standard rendition of the excuse in the August/September 1990 issue of the NCU journal. 
 But it was a rather confused piece of reasoning as his article began by conceding that there is strong support for the development of labour policies in the North. 
 Stott stated: 
 &bquo;I know from my visits to Northern Ireland and discussions with members of the trade union movement, that there is a real and genuine desire for the Labour Party to organise in Northern Ireland.&equo; 
 But then Mr. Stott added patronisingly: &bquo;But as one of the Labour Party's Shadow Northern Ireland Team, I would like to put the opposite view.&equo;  
 In other words: &bquo;As an important chap from England, I know better.&equo; 
 Having admitted that substantial support existed, the party spokesman went on to argue that there was no support worth talking about! 
 In defence of his claim that  there was  &bquo;no evidence to suggest that people are prepared to abandon their traditional party allegiances&equo;, Stott pointed out that in two recent elections, candidates supported by the Campaign for Labour Representation polled badly: 
 &bquo;Experience shows that electoral mould-breaking has been a vain exercise. 
 One indicator is the fact that a mere 3,660 votes were cast for the candidate of the Campaign for Labour Representation in the 1989 European elections out of a total of 560,026 votes cast (0.7 per cent) and out of an electorate of 1,120,517 (0.3 per cent). 
 The Right to Vote Labour candidate in the recent Upper Bann by-election obtained 0.66 per cent.&equo; 
 This is a nonsensical argument. 
 The CLR is not the Labour Party. 
 The CLR is not in a position to replace the Tory Government. 
 It cannot offer voters a policy programme which will be implemented when it comes to power. 
 Nor can it promise to spend more on health, improve education standards or increase pensions. 
 It is therefore ridiculous to draw any conclusions for Labour's potential level of support from the Upper Bann and European elections. 
 The CLR has no apologies to make for backing candidates in those elections. 
 And it is in no way ashamed of the number of votes received. 
 Those candidates stood to draw attention to the fact that Northern Ireland residents cannot vote for or join a party which will govern them when it comes to power. 
 That was successfully done and the Labour Party can rest assured that its undemocratic behaviour will continue to be exposed in a variety of ways. 
 But it was never expected that voters would forsake their loyalties in large numbers for an abstract principle. 
 There can be no way of knowing how Labour will fare in the province until it stands there. 
 It is simply the case that the party should be there while it intends to govern Northern Ireland and it should be exerting itself to offer the voters a real alternative to sectarian politics. 
 No one has ever argued that the Labour Party will be a panacea for Northern Ireland's problems. 
 But it would at least offer a chance of a positive political development. 
 With the Tories also there, attention could eventually be shifted away from the old disputes and onto the business of who governs the state and in whose interest. 
 No one believes that there will  be  an overnight switch away from old voting habits. 
 Nevertheless, those people who want to develop Labour politics in the province and to change things for the better should at least be given the chance to try. 
 Moreover, if the Labour Party really threw its energies into the task of winning support in Northern Ireland there is no telling what might happen. 
 Certainly, it will need to work hard to make up for lost time; the party has neglected the cause of democratic socialism in the North for far too long and it has allowed would-be Labour activists to become demoralised. 
 This criminal neglect has been particularly indefensible over the past couple of decades. 
 In the 1960s the Northern Ireland Labour Party (NILP) was on the verge of becoming a significant political force, despite the fact that it had been left to fend for itself in very difficult circumstances. 
 (In the 1964 Westminster election, the NILP gained 103,000 votes in the province which, to put it into perspective, is more than Provisional Sinn Fein has ever received). 
 With the outbreak of the Troubles in the late 60s, the NILP came under increasing pressure from the rival sectarian political camps. 
 At this stage, the NILP sought to become incorporated within the wider Labour Party and to play a full role in the state-wide struggle against the Tories. 
 After   some initial encouraging noises from Jim Callaghan, the Labour Party turned this request down and the NILP was allowed to go to the wall in the near-war situation that the province had become by the early '70s. 
 Labour continues to neglect the cause of socialism to this day and it can justifiably be accused of undermining its natural supporters in the province. 
 Given the demoralisation caused by this neglect, it is somewhat galling to hear Labour spokesmen smugly declare that there is no support for socialism in Northern Ireland. 
 THE SDLP? 
 The &bquo;no support&equo; excuse may have grown in popularity recently, but the most common argument still concerns Labour's so-called sister-party, the SDLP (a nationalist party organised only in the six counties and invariably described by the media as a &bquo;mainly Catholic party&equo;). 
 The SDLP-sister-party line is a particular favourite of Kevin McNamara's. 
 Within weeks of being handed the Northern Ireland portfolio by Neil Kinnock in the summer of 1987, McNamara was telling a radio interviewer: 
 &bquo;We have over there a sister party in the Socialist International, the SDLP, which would welcome into its ranks great numbers of non-Catholic socialists.&equo; 
 (Radio Solent 22/7/87) 
 The Labour Party leadership has stuck rigidly to this line ever since. 
 But what evidence has been produced to justify the claim that the SDLP is a socialist party? 
 None. 
 And evidence has not been produced because there simply is none. 
 The SDLP has no trade union affiliates in the North. 
 It has no connection at all with the labour movement in the society. 
 And the Labour Party has been remarkably silent about this lack of trade union affiliation. 
 If the Labour Party genuinely believe that the SDLP is the Labour Party in Northern Ireland, then it should be advising the major unions to affiliate to the SDLP in Northern Ireland. 
 And Neil Kinnock and Kevin McNamara should be making a special effort to affiliate their own union, the TGWU, to the SDLP. 
 They have not done this for one simple reason: the unions know the truth about the SDLP and they would quickly tell them where to put their advice. 
 During the last year, the GMB's Irish Advisory Committee held a special meeting to discuss the issue of Labour Representation in the North. 
 The local trade unionists were quick to give their verdict on the SDLP and the document drawn up after the meeting stated: 
 &bquo;The IAC consider it damaging for the Labour Party to regard the SDLP as their equivalent in Northern Ireland and the IAC believe the Party should distance itself from the SDLP.&equo; 
 Trade unionists in Northern Ireland know that the SDLP is not an adequate substitute for the Labour Party. 
 And even a quick glance at the SDLP's history shows that the Labour interest is not its number one priority. 
 Most damningly, it was the SDLP which brought down the last Labour Government. 
 The party's leader, Gerry Fitt (now Lord Fitt), abstained in the vital vote of confidence which finished off the Callaghan Government in March 1979. 
 Labour lost the vital division by one vote. 
 And not only did Gerry Fitt, the SDLP's only MP at the time, abstain in the vote, he persuaded Independent Nationalist MP, Frank Maguire to abstain as well. 
 Fitt's decision not to back Labour at the moment of crisis received the full backing of his SDLP colleagues. 
 And by allowing the Tories to win the vote of confidence, the SDLP opened the door for Thatcherism. 
 This can hardly be described as sisterly behaviour. 
 Fitt brought down the Labour Government because Labour had increased Northern Ireland's representation at Westminster from 12 to 17 seats. 
 Although this corrected a chronic under-representation, the SDLP were furious ,  interpreting it as an integrationist measure in favour of Protestants. 
 And so, to punish Labour, Fitt refused to back them in the vote of confidence. 
 In other words, the ex-civil righters and so-called socialists of the SDLP ushered in Thatcherism because a Labour Government democratically reformed Northern Ireland's representation at Westminster. 
 It was irony indeed! 
 In fact, it was doubly ironic, as the SDLP now owe almost everything to Labour's democratic reform. 
 The SDLP currently holds three Westminster seats but if Northern Ireland still had only 12 seats, the SDLP would have no MPs at all. 
 The West Belfast constituency, once held by Gerry Fitt, now elects Sinn Fein President, Gerry Adams, as its MP. 
 Nevertheless, the decision was enough to make Labour's &bquo;sister party&equo; bring down the last Labour Government and the working class throughout the UK is still paying for the SDLP's pettiness. 
 Gerry Fitt with the full support of his party brought down the last Labour government over a decision which greatly enhanced the SDLP's standing. 
 That is the extent of its loyalty to the Labour cause. 
 Fitt was the closest thing to a socialist in the party. 
 But when it really mattered, other priorities came first. 
 Fitt left the SDLP soon afterwards claiming it had become too right-wing and middle class for him. 
 By 1987, the SDLP was making no secret of its desire to see Thatcher re-elected for a third term. 
 Austin Currie, one of the founders of the SDLP, wrote in the Belfast magazine &bquo;Fortnight&equo; of June 1987: 
 &bquo;From the point of view of nationalist Ireland &mdash; a continuation of Maggie Thatcher in power, for a limited period of time, would be to our advantage&hellip; 
 I believe that, while we have a strong Conservative Government, that is reason for optimism for the immediate future.&equo; 
 Currie was still very much a leading figure within the SDLP when he made those remarks. 
 In 1988, he was chosen by the SDLP leader, John Hume, to represent the Party in the high-level talks with Provisional Sinn Fein. 
 Nobody from the SDLP uttered a word of criticism over Currie's endorsement of a Thatcher victory in 1987. 
 Other leading figures of the party made it clear that they share his sentiments. 
 (The deputy leader, Seamus Mallon described the Labour Party as &bquo;Cromwellian&equo; which is certainly not a term of endearment.) 
 The SDLP's public support for the Tories in the 1987 General Election caused its former leader, Gerry Fitt to comment: &bquo;I would not vote for the SDLP because it is not a socialist party&hellip; 
 Both they and the Dublin government want to see Mrs. Thatcher re-elected&hellip;&equo; 
  (Belfast News Letter, 2/6/87) 
 Later in the election campaign, he was driven to comment again: &bquo;I wish to point out that the SDLP were only admitted to the Socialist International by my credentials. 
 Now their support for a reactionary government brands them as class traitors.&equo; 
 (Irish Times 10/6/87) 
 Despite these developments, the Labour Party leadership stuck to its public position that the SDLP is a &bquo;sister party&equo;. 
 It is a strange sister party which wants to see Labour's sworn enemies back in power. 
 And it is a strange type of socialism which sees the prospect of five more years of Thatcherism as &bquo;reason for optimism for the immediate future&equo;. 
 In May 1989, Austin Currie took his commitment to Thatcherism a stage further. 
 He joined the right-wing Fine Gael party in the Irish Republic and was elected to the Dail for the Dublin West constituency. 
 The move was, to say the least, bizarre. 
 One day, Currie was the SDLP's spokesman on the economy, the next he was a Parliamentary candidate for a Party whose economic policies are more Thatcherite than Thatcher herself. 
 Nobody in the SDLP criticised Currie for his espousal of Thatcherism or for the fact that he stood against and defeated a Labour candidate to get into the Dail. 
 Further proof of the SDLP's true nature (if it were needed) was provided in the Irish Times report of the Party's 1989 annual conference in Newcastle, Co. 
 Down. 
 Here's how the paper described the welcome given to Austin Currie who attended the conference as a fraternal delegate from Fine Gael: 
 &bquo;A Familiar Name,&equo; the chairman said, and everyone laughed. 
 There had been applause for all the &bquo;fraternal delegates and distinguished visitors&equo; including Fianna Fail, Fine Gael and Labour. 
 &bquo;But the smiles and the applause became prolonged when the familiar face stood up to acknowledge his reception like a conquering hero. 
 Arms and fists raised like a footballer who's just scored a goal, Austin Currie took his kudos, from the audience of 500 in the packed conference hall of the Slieve Donard Hotel. 
 &bquo;Nice to see you back,&equo; said chairman, Alban Maginness to his former party colleague as Austin Currie went through his 18th or 19th conference, this time though, from the unfamiliar position of looking at the rostrum rather than being on it.&equo; 
 (Irish Times 6/11/89) 
 This is very strange behaviour for a supposedly left-wing party. 
 Fine Gael is anything but left-wing: its roots can be traced back to General Duffy and the Blueshirts who sent a division of soldiers from Ireland to fight for Franco in the Spanish Civil War. 
 So what were SDLP delegates doing welcoming Currie to their conference? 
 Would a traitor to the socialist cause ever have received such a welcome at a Labour Party Conference? 
 Imagine the reaction if David Owen had appeared at Labour's 1989 conference. 
 Would he have   been cheered &bquo;like a conquering hero&equo;? 
 Would the Conference chairman, Dennis Skinner, have said: &bquo;Nice to see you back&equo;? 
 Or imagine the scene at a Labour Conference about fifty years ago if a certain Oswald Mosley had turned up to see his former party colleagues. 
 In September 1990, Austin Currie was selected as Fine Gael's candidate for the Irish Presidential election. 
 Needless to say, he is running against the Irish Labour Party candidate, Mary Robinson. 
 But the twists and turns of Currie's political career are simply a graphic illustration of the fact the SDLP cannot be regarded as the Labour Party in Northern Ireland. 
 Other leading figures in the party are also unlikely class warriors. 
 The socialist credentials of its present leader, John Hume, have been the subject of derision ever since the formation of the SDLP in 1970. 
 Hume, himself, recently admitted in an interview that he never wanted the word &bquo;Labour&equo; in the Party's name. 
 He &bquo;wanted to call the new party the Social Democratic Party&equo;. 
 (Irish News, 12/9/88) 
 A slightly amended version of Labour's SDLP excuse concerns the rules of the Socialist International. 
 It has been suggested that sister parties within the Socialist International are not allowed to compete with one another. 
 Thus it is claimed that, under Socialist International rules, the Labour Party is forbidden to enter the SDLP's territory and engage in electoral competition with it in Northern Ireland. 
 This is simply nonsense but, nevertheless, it has been used within the Labour Party to block discussion of organisation in Northern Ireland. 
 The fact is that in some countries there is more than one party affiliated to the Socialist International. 
 In these countries, sister parties in the Socialist International already compete with each other electorally. 
 In short, there is no reason whatsoever under the rules of the Socialist International why the Labour Party shouldn't put up candidates against the SDLP in Northern Ireland. 
 For example, the Democratic Socialist Party of Italy and the Italian Socialist Party are both affiliated to the Socialist International. 
 This is confirmed by the Socialist International itself in its Council Circular No C1/88 (dated 20/1/88) where these two Italian parties appear in the list of &bquo;member parties&equo; (pages 6&ndash;21). 
 In addition, two Israeli parties &mdash; the Israeli Labour Party and the United Worker's Party MAPAM &mdash; and two Japanese parties &mdash; the Japan Democratic Socialist Party DSP and the Socialist Party of Japan SPJ &mdash; are &bquo;member parties&equo; of the International and compete with one another electorally. 
 So whatever is stopping the Labour Party organising and contesting elections in Northern Ireland it is not the rules of the Socialist International.  
 Given the SDLP's track record, it is inconceivable that Labour-minded people in Northern Ireland would ever give it their support. 
 And most Labour MPs are well aware of this fact. 
 (Roger Stott, a junior Labour spokesman on Northern Ireland told a meeting in Bangor, County Down in June 1990 that the SDLP-sister-party line was &bquo;one big joke&equo;.) 
 More importantly, as long ago as 1981 the Labour Party itself acknowledged in a major Policy Statement that the SDLP is &bquo;a moderate nationalist party with very little support outside of the catholic community, and no trade union affiliation&equo;. 
 That remains the official Labour Party position on the SDLP. 
 The Policy Statement also concluded: &bquo;No working class party exists, which is capable of bringing Catholics and Protestants together inside a single political organisation to further their interests as workers.&equo; 
 Perhaps Labour's leadership could explain what has happened to the SDLP since 1981 to make it capable of bringing Catholic and Protestant workers together. 
 Or is Labour just using the SDLP as an excuse to avoid facing up to its democratic responsibilities to the people of Northern Ireland? 
 IRISH UNITY? 
 The Labour Party's &bquo;Irish unity&equo; excuse is a logical nonsense and it is usually tagged on as an afterthought to the comradely talk about the SDLP. 
 But no one from the Labour Party has ever explained how the development of non-sectarian Labour politics in the North would be an &bquo;obstacle&equo; to Irish unity. 
 According to official Labour Party policy, any change in the status of Northern Ireland will require the consent of the majority of people in the province. 
 So how would the mere existence of Labour Party membership cards in the North prevent the electorate voting themselves into a United Ireland if they so desired? 
 The membership ban would make sense if it was Labour Party policy to expel Northern Ireland from the UK immediately after coming to power. 
 It would obviously be daft to organise in an area which is about to be kicked out of the state. 
 But that is not Labour Party policy. 
 Anyone who has any doubts on this matter should read the new policy document, &bquo;Looking to the Future&equo; which will form the basis of the party's election manifesto. 
 It clearly states: 
 &bquo;For Northern Ireland, the long term solution  lies in a united Ireland achieved by consensus and without violence. 
 The continued operation of the Anglo Irish Agreement is important &mdash; not only in the fight against terrorism, but also in maintaining consistently close links at every level between the UK and the Republic of Ireland. 
 We support the commitment in that Agreement that &bquo;any change in the status of Northern Ireland would only come about with the consent of the majority of the people of Northern Ireland.&equo; 
 If, in the future, the majority in Northern Ireland formally consent to a united Ireland, we will introduce the necessary legislation.&equo; 
 (Our emphasis) 
 Few would argue with the goal of achieving Irish unity by consent. 
 Every strand of political opinion in Ireland, North and South, with the exception of the Provisional IRA, accepts that any change in the present set-up will require majority support in both parts of the island. 
 But there can be little doubt that such change is not going to happen overnight. 
 After the Brighton bombing in 1984, Neil Kinnock predicted that it would be &bquo;many many decades&equo; before consent came about (Newsnight BBC2, 12/10/84). 
 The following year he went even further, saying on a visit to the North: 
 &bquo;Modern economics, as well as the geography of the whole of Ireland means that ultimately &mdash; and ultimately can be a very long way away &mdash; our Labour Party policy on reunification is the one that will be endorsed. 
 &bquo;But unless and until it is endorsed by consent by all the communities in Northern Ireland there can be no significant move forward in that direction.&equo; 
 (Irish Times 1/2/85) 
 Mr. Kinnock is not alone in thinking that a united Ireland may be &bquo;a long way away&equo;. 
 A recent opinion poll on the subject South of the border found that 49% of the people in the Irish Republic believed that there will never be a united Ireland. 
 Only 40% thought that there will be a united Ireland one day but few expected it in the short term &mdash; 16% expected it to come about in 25 years, 13% in 50 years and 11% in 100 years.  
 The poll, conducted by the Market Research Bureau of Ireland (MRBI) and published in the latter half of 1987, also found that 67% of the people in the Irish Republic saw Irish unity as &bquo;something to be hoped for&equo;. 
 But only 39% said they would pay extra taxes in order to facilitate unification (Irish Times 1/9/87). 
 Opinion polls in the North also find little enthusiasm for Irish unity at the moment. 
 Successive opinion polls in recent years have found only around 10% overall in favour of a united Ireland under present circumstances. 
 And only around 25&ndash;30% of the Catholic community express support for this option. 
 (See, for example, the poll published in the Belfast Telegraph on October 4 and 5 1988. 
 It found 9% support for Irish unity within the Northern Ireland electorate while support among Catholics stood at just 22%). 
 Clearly then the Labour Party's goal of Irish unity by consent is not going to be achieved overnight. 
 So what are the voters in the North supposed to do in the meantime? 
 Remain in their rival sectarian ghettos? 
 If Labour's boycott of the province continues, the one certainty is that politics will remain a question of Protestants versus Catholics. 
 And sectarian politics will continue to breed sectarian violence. 
 Imagine what Liverpool would be like if the Labour Party had refused to organise there over the past century. 
 How would sectarian bitterness have been eroded if the workers had been excluded from the Labour movement? 
 And would politics based on religion have disappeared in Glasgow if not for the rise of the Labour Party? 
 And what about today's inner cities in Great Britain? 
 If Labour withdrew from Bradford or Birmingham, would a multitude of parties not spring up based on rival religious and racial identities? 
 Would the development of this sort of politics not heighten racial tension and conflict? 
 It is time the Labour Party explained how it sees non-sectarian politics developing in Northern Ireland. 
 The party leadership presumably wants working class unity in the North. 
 We believe that Labour is best placed to develop that unity by bringing Catholics and Protestants together in the struggle against the Tories. 
 But if Labour's leadership genuinely believe that their party is irrelevant to the task of developing non-sectarian politics, they should explain just how they see this task being accomplished. 
 And if they are serious about securing Irish unity, they should also explain how they envisage it coming about while the sectarian political blocs remain unchallenged. 
 It is our view that any political development will  only  be possible once communal politics is broken down. 
 The supporters of the status quo within the Labour Party seem to think that a united Ireland will somehow develop by some inconceivable means out of the current sectarian stalemate. 
 But the status quo of Unionist versus Nationalist in the North leaves Unionism in a permanent position of superiority. 
 And while the stalemate continues, progressive political development is impossible. 
 CONCLUSION 
 The Labour Party has run out of excuses for its undemocratic treatment of Northern Ireland. 
 Its excuses concerning the SDLP and Irish unity have been exposed as totally spurious. 
 And they will continue to be exposed until they become too embarrassing to even mention. 
 The time has come for the party to choose and, in the final analysis, it has two coherent policies to choose from. 
 One is to accept Ken Livingstone's position and set about expelling the province from the UK, whatever the consequences. 
 The other is to open the way for the development of working-class unity in Northern Ireland by organising the Party there. 
 The latter option is the more likely to produce a stable, peaceful and united Ireland in the long-term. 
 For the only Irish unity worth having must begin with unity between the Catholic and Protestant working-class in Northern Ireland. 
 These two options should be the starting-point for any real debate about Northern Ireland, a debate that is long overdue. 
 Above all, the Labour Party should abandon its current stance on Northern Ireland if it wants to remain true to the principles of its founders. 
 The present stance involves banning the people of the province from its ranks yet drawing up policies for them which will radically affect their lives. 
 It means abandoning the working class to sectarian politics and violence and insulting their intelligence by telling them to join the SDLP. 
 And letting the Tories go unchallenged in all 17 constituencies. 
 It means keeping Northern Ireland in the UK state for the foreseeable future while banning its citizens from the politics of the state. 
 And it involves planning to rule over the people of the province without seeking their votes. 
 Such behaviour is not suited to a democratic socialist party of the 1990s. 
 OTHER PUBLICATIONS 
 McNamara's ban  (75p): Kevin McNamara's &bquo;refreshingly frank&equo; reasons for the ban on Northern Ireland membership. 
 Is the SDLP Socialist?  (50p): The truth about Labour's &bquo;sister-party&equo;. 
 The Forgotten Conference  (50p): Labour's first conference in Belfast in 1907. 
 Twenty years of criminal neglect  (60p): How Labour has abdicated responsibility for Northern Ireland.  
 Published by CAMPAIGN FOR LABOUR REPRESENTATION IN NORTHERN IRELAND  
 Mark picked up another car at the London plant and drove up the M1 to his home in north Buckinghamshire. 
 Turning off the motorway at the service station he entered a different world. 
 Driving very slowly over the narrow bridges spanning the fast flowing streams which stemmed from the River Ouse, he noticed that a massive flock of coots had flown in while he had been away. 
 There must have been two or three thousand on the river banks and the water. 
 Pulling the car off the narrow country lane, Mark pressed the button which activated the power-operated windows. 
 It was early evening and very still. 
 Soft white clouds remained motionless against an azure blue sky. 
 Between the many breaks in the cloud the rays of a thin evening sun shafted down at an acute angle to spotlight the pastoral scene. 
 Away to the west a flock of Canada geese was heading home to descend on one of the larger lakes in the distance. 
 In the foreground another smaller flock was taking off from the little lake on the south side. 
 Squawking madly in what appeared to be a family squabble over the direction they should take, they suddenly closed ranks, as if by order, and formed a perfect vee behind their leader. 
 They then wheeled in unison into a shaft of light which held them for a second or so before they soared over the car and away. 
 Standing in shallow water amongst the tall reeds on the banks of the river, Mark counted eight herons, all motionless, their necks inclined upwards at precisely the same angle, as if in silent prayer. 
 On the river banks to the east, mallard and teal were pecking away at their undercarriages and, in the meadow flanking the lane, two hares were squaring up. 
 High overhead, barely visible or audible, a jumbo jet began its gentle descent to Heathrow. 
 Mark looked up at the tiny speck in the stratosphere and imagined he could hear the air  hostess requesting passengers to fasten their seat belts. 
 He looked again at the beautifully unspoiled Buckinghamshire countryside. 
 It was great to be home again. 
 He drove leisurely up the country lane and ascended the hill, before bearing left along the escarpment. 
 Away in the distance, tucked between a fold in the surrounding hills, was home. 
 Mark always experienced the same feelings of contentment when entering the home straight. 
 Today he felt particularly pleased to be back. 
 Gently nosing the car down the hill into the village, he turned off the road into the gravelled drive which led to the eighteenth-century stone barn. 
 Hearing the wheels of the car on the gravel the two young golden retriever bitches, Honey and the pick of the litter, Harriet, bounded through the hall to get a better view of the intruder from the dining-room window. 
 Standing on their hind legs with front paws resting on the deep window sills, they saw Mark getting out of his car and went berserk. 
 Racing back into the hall with tails wagging furiously, they almost knocked Georgina over. 
 She had also heard a car come up the drive, and was heading through the hall to the porch. 
 She opened the heavy oak doors and the dogs swept past her bounding across the drive to their master who was opening up the car boot to remove his luggage. 
 Mark turned, just as the dogs took off together in a huge leap which struck him in the chest, knocking him backwards into the boot where he sat, legs dangling, with both arms wrapped around the excited dogs. 
 Looking up, he saw Georgina standing at the open door with a welcoming smile. 
 &bquo;Hello, darling,&equo; he called waving with his right hand while trying to keep the dogs at bay with his left. 
 &bquo;Welcome home, sweetheart!&equo; 
 She flung her arms around him. 
 &bquo;Such a long time!&equo; she gasped in his ear as they hugged each other tightly, the dogs retiring a respectful distance to sit and watch the homecoming with tails swishing excitedly over the gravel. 
 &bquo;I've missed you so much, this time,&equo; she told him breathlessly. 
 &bquo;Can't think why. 
 Really forgotten what you look like. 
 Let's have a look at you. 
 Hum, not bad, considering your age and everything I suppose&hellip;.&equo;  
 &bquo;It s great to be home, darling. 
 I've missed you too,&equo; he whispered in her ear. 
 &bquo;Don't know why I feel this way. 
 Must be Spring!&equo; 
 During Mark's absence in Spain, &bquo;the mole&equo; Fred Klepner had spent countless hours going over the Ten Year Business plan which was to be the subject of the presentation Mark was to give to Nate Cocello at the next Planning Committee meeting. 
 Klepner had studied the plan with a sense of shock. 
 He had arrived in Europe knowing nothing about the European motor industry or the Continent's political and economic environment, except from what he had read on the subject at Harvard Business School and in Detroit Central Office reports. 
 He had been under the erroneous impression that Europe was just one big common market, similar in size to the United States, operating under free trade concepts, and with common laws, rules and regulations. 
 He had therefore assumed that the preparation of a European plan would be broadly similar to the planning practices normally followed in the United States. 
 In consequence, he had read the two hundred page European Plan with open-mouthed incredulity. 
 It was a totally different planning world from the United States. 
 The plan was also prepared in a different way from those drafted by the US divisions, as it had to be to give proper consideration to the problems and needs of a totally different planning environment. 
 For the first time since leaving the Harvard Business School of Management Klepner now began to have a glimmer of understanding of the many important practical differences between Europe and the United States. 
 The first section of the plan developed all the major assumptions upon which it was based. 
 These assumptions detailed the principal factors under separate headings, such as Political, Economic, Technical, Commercial, Environmental, Energy and so on. 
 These headings were then broken down to test the assumptions by critical analysis, country by country identifying the common European factors and the variables.  
 In developing the short list of manufacturing locations he proposed to establish to produce the new products which would incorporate all the latest technologies, he had detailed the comparative costs of manufacture per country and identified the economic and commercial advantages and disadvantages of selling components into specific European countries from single and dual manufacturing sources. 
 It was patently obvious to Klepner, now that he had read the plan, that the European trade environment was not as he had been led to believe. 
 He spent the entire first week reading the plan over and over again. 
 Two days before Mark returned to England, Klepner spent a whole day with Muldoon going over the plan. 
 The upshot of this meeting was that Muldoon phoned Mueller and Klepner was on the next plane to Detroit with photostat copies of Mark's plan, for Mueller's eyes only. 
 Mark arrived at his office expecting to have a few clear days ahead to finalise the European Business Plan and prepare his presentation to Cocello. 
 But it didn't happen that way. 
 He received an internal phone call from Muldoon, who told him that McGillicuddy wanted him to go on to Dublin immediately. 
 The Irish Prime Minister had evidently made a personal approach to his compatriot, the Chairman of United Motors, Tom O'Reilly, pleading for more American investment to help the &bquo;auld counthrie&equo;. 
 The Irish never allowed their expatriates to forget the debt they owed the Emerald Isle. 
 United Motors had already built a component plant in Dublin a few years before, at the specific request of the Chairman, but it had never operated profitably. 
 It had been plagued by excessive absenteeism, restrictive practices, inter-union demarcation lines and poor product quality. 
 Mark's quarterly reports which highlighted the plant problems were not well received by the Chairman &mdash; according to his personal staff. 
 &bquo;You don't win any medals by questioning the Chairman's  judgement, Mark&equo; said his personal assistant, advising him to &bquo;tone it down a bit&equo; in future Dublin plant reports. 
 Notwithstanding the plant's poor track record, Tom O'Reilly considered it to be his bounden duty to respond to the call for help from his compatriot, the Irish Prime Minister, and so he phoned McGillicuddy, who readily agreed, and Mark was instructed to contact the PM's office. 
 There were, in fact, many Irish Americans in United Motors at high management levels, all of whom had a nostalgic affection for the &bquo;auld counthrie&equo;, and indeed for anything Irish; but that was because most of them had never actually been there. 
 The majority preferred to believe the picturesque stories passed down by parents and grandparents, which were, of course, accepted as the gospel truth. 
 The Chairman, for example, was one of no fewer than five Irish Americans to have held the top job in UM. 
 Tom O'Reilly was an ascetic former Treasurer of the Corporation who had been never known to smile even when the company's blue chip shares soared to dizzy peaks on Wall Street. 
 It was, however, reported by his personal staff that he did manage a smirk when he had been told the story of how his arch rival and competitor had been conned by his countrymen on a flag-flying visit to the auld counthrie. 
 He had agreed to make a financial contribution of &dollar;50,000 from the family trust to help finance a social club to be named after him. 
 The local paper made a front page headline of &bquo;Henry's magnificent &dollar;590,000 gift. 
 The motor magnate was furious and rang the Editor to say so, whereupon the latter apologised profusely adding that he would make a front page correction in the next day's edition. 
 Henry surrendered. 
 Some two years later, on completion of the social club, the magnate was asked if he would like something suitable inscribed over the portal. 
 &bquo;Yeah,&equo; replied the motor man irritably, &bquo;you can say &bquo;I came amongst you and you took me in&equo;.&equo; 
 Tom O'Reilly liked that story. 
 It actually made him smirk&hellip; so it was said. 
 The UM Chairman was cast from a similar mould but with coarser ingredients. 
 O'Reilly was impossible to please and suspicious of everybody and everything. 
 He trusted nobody,  not even fellow Catholics on the Board. 
 But if it could be said that he did have a weakness for something, it was for Ireland and the Irish. 
 Mark could ill-afford to be away from his office with the presentation to Cocello looming large on the horizon, but the next day he was on his way to Dublin. 
 The taxi crossed the Liffey and made its way down O'Connell Street to Government House. 
 The talkative driver hadn't stopped chatting from the moment Mark had entered the cab. 
 He was better than a music-hall turn. 
 There was no question of doubt but that the Irish had been blessed with the gift of the Blarney. 
 Most of them could express themselves with a lilting eloquence which left the English spellbound. 
 Who was it who said that the Irish took the English language and threw the words up in the air just to see how they all sparkled as they came tumbling down? 
 Mark's meeting with the Irish Minister of Industry and his loquacious officials was pure theatre. 
 The problems experienced by United Motors at its Dublin plant, which the Englishman advised were the major factors which would influence future investment decisions in Ireland, simply melted away into insignificance under their mellifluous tongues. 
 They had excuses, or as they preferred to describe them, fair and reasonable explanations, for all the problems which had beset the Dublin plant. 
 The exceptionally high absenteeism on Mondays and Fridays, which necessitated employing thirty per cent more workers than was economically justified, was not so much caused by the demon drink; but because&hellip; etcetera, etcetera&hellip;. 
 The reason why timekeeping was particularly bad on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays, when employees did turn up for work, was because the buses were so unreliable. 
 The local transport authority simply couldn't get spare parts from the British to keep the buses on the roads. 
 If only the British would pull their socks up things would be different.  
 The reason why absenteeism was non-existent on Thursdays was not just because it happened to be pay day. 
 Ah ha, no; it wasn't quite as simple as all that, don't you know, although of course it was an incentive day, and the Irish loved incentives. 
 Regarding the strikes, disputes and restrictive practices which had plagued the Dublin plant, these were all unfortunate legacies of the British system which had been foisted upon the Irish since before the First World War. 
 The Irish Government was resolutely determined to rid itself of the British system which had done so much harm to the economy. 
 When Mark reminded them that the plant was relatively new and that with the exception of the American Managing Director and Treasurer, was manned throughout by Irish men and women, they countered with, &bquo;Ah yes, but it's the Trade unions, you see.&equo; 
 And when he pointed out that these were Irish, not British Trade unions they were talking about, it was sadly admitted that the English disease had poisoned the minds of many impressionable Irish trade unionists and that it would of course take time entirely to eradicate malign English influences from the land of Saints and Scholars. 
 To be sure, unemployment was a mortal sin to shame all good Christians and the Government was appealing to international companies to help solve the problem. 
 Meantime, it would greatly help if United Motors could see its way clear to build another factory in Ireland, particularly if it could be built in the South West, where the Prime Minister was having to face re-election in a year's time. 
 Very generous financial assistance would be given by the Government, in the form of a grant of up to thirty per cent of capital and remission of all taxation on export sales for ten years. 
 The fact that in the whole of South West Ireland there was not sufficient labour to man a new United Motors plant was not seen by the Minister as any kind of problem; simply as a little local difficulty. 
 Later that morning he was flown to the South West and shown a beautiful industrial site with excellent access to the adjacent  port facilities. 
 Unfortunately it had just been earmarked for housing. 
 There was, however, another very similar site in the area, which was really better than the site they had already seen. 
 The trouble was that nobody could quite remember where it was exactly, but everybody knew it was around there somewhere, that's for sure. 
 So they all went off to lunch with the mayor, while a messenger was sent to the Registrar of Births, Marriages and Deaths to get the necessary information. 
 Mark had often said to his American colleagues in Detroit and New York that the  sales'  promotion literature put out by the Irish Development Authority to attract internationally mobile inward investment was superior to anything produced by any other European country. 
 Unfortunately the practical problems of operating a large plant in Ireland were totally unrelated to the glowing words in the glossy literature, and to the enchanting phrases which slid so eloquently off the honeyed tongues of Ministers and officials. 
 In reality, the unhappy experiences of United Motors at its Dublin plant had effectively ensured that no major future expansion would be undertaken in that enigmatic country for many years. 
 Cocello would effectively see to that, whatever Chairman Tom O'Reilly might think. 
 When the Minister had ended the meeting with the words, &bquo;Now, Mr Sanders, what can we do to persuade you to put more investment in Ireland?&equo; the Englishman had replied, &bquo;The best advocate you could have, Minister, to influence more investment in your country, is a local plant manager who consistently turns in good results, year after year. 
 &bquo;Such a man, with a good track record can fight for his plant and his people on the very strong grounds that investment in his region has been proven to be successful. 
 &bquo;Our Dublin plant has consistently failed to produce the expected results, and it is this unfortunate experience which will weigh heavily against any further investment in Eire; in much the same way as it has weighed heavily against the UK. 
 The most eloquent advocates in United Motors, Minister, are those with beautiful bottom lines,&equo; said the Englishman.  
 The executive jet took off from Cork airport and landed at Dublin in the late afternoon. 
 Mark was driven to the Gresham Hotel by the head of the development authority. 
 On the way he stopped the car in the city centre to point out dozens of parking meters, all capped with hooded covers. 
 &bquo;Now I'd like to show you sometin' which I'm sure you would appreciate,&equo; he said pleasantly, wagging a finger at the objects ahead. 
 &bquo;Now you see all dose little parking meters dere, snoozing under dose little black sleeping caps? 
 Well a few weeks ago the city fathers installed dose nasty little tings at a cost, believe it or not, sir, of some turty tree tousand pounds, and the day atterwards dey declared the whole area a no waiting zone.&equo; 
 He threw back his head and roared with laughter. 
 &bquo;Now isn't dat Irish, Mr Sanders?&equo; he exclaimed enjoying the joke on himself, which was one of the more agreeable characteristics the Irish had in common with the English. 
 Mark then told him of the occasion when he had been driving down O'Connell Street some twenty or so years before, when he had inadvertently misunderstood the hand signals of the policeman on traffic duty, and had moved off before he had been cleared to do so. 
 The policeman had ordered him to stop by his foot. 
 &bquo;You are English, are you not, Sor?&equo; he had asked with haughty disdain. 
 &bquo;Sure, I taut so,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;Now sor, is dis your first rime in Dublin? 
 Ah it is. 
 For sure dat explains it all!&equo; 
 Then pulling himself up to a great height, he went on. 
 &bquo;Now sor, I'm goin' to be tellin' yer sometin'. 
 If you'se happen to be comin' here to Dublin at some time or other in the future &mdash; which praise the Lord you will be, for tis God's own city &mdash; and you happen to be driving down O'Connell Street and you see me standin' here like dis, with me arms up; then whether I'm here or not, you stop.&equo; 
 He had stood there with left arm aloft and right arm horizontal and remained in that statuesque position for some thirty seconds. 
 &bquo;Now, is dat understood, sor? 
 Fine, then be off with you and may God give you a good day.&equo;  
 The other Ireland raised its ugly head at Dublin airport. 
 Mark's name had been called over the loudspeaker system. 
 He answered the phone to be told by an anonymous member of the IRA that he shouldn't attempt to return to Ireland if United Motors decided against further investment in that country. 
 Once again the sharp contrast was drawn between the charming and friendly people one came across in everyday life and the murdering hate of the evil terrorist minority who eagerly blew innocent men, women and children to Kingdom come.  
 While Mark was in Dublin the head of the French Development Authority DATAR paid a courtesy visit to Detroit to make the point to Nate Cocello, and Chairman, Tom O'Reilly that France was keen to attract very much more United Motors investment. 
 The fact that France had already received the lion's share of new European component investment over the previous five years was beside the point. 
 That was past. 
 France wanted the lion's share of all future European investment too, and was most concerned to hear that the Corporation was also considering investment in Spain, Portugal, Austria, Ireland and the UK. 
 It was put to the two top men and to the Vice President in charge of  Overseas'  Operations that the interests of France could only be adequately served by Frenchmen, and not by Americans or Englishmen. 
 The fact that Sanders, an Englishman, had produced the plan which had changed French plants from ailing and unprofitable operations in the sixties, into expanding and profitable divisions in the seventies was discreetly overlooked. 
 Mark had actually transferred certain expanding and profitable product lines and manufacturing facilities from the UK to France to consolidate a new range of components at French locations. 
 All hell would have been let loose by the French plants and the French Government if the boot had been on the other foot and anyone had attempted to transfer products and facilities from France to the UK. 
 The top men had listened courteously to their visitor's observations and requests without reaction. 
 Under his breath, the Vice President was telling him to get stuffed. 
 The French Government would object to Jesus Christ being head of European Operations, on the grounds that He wasn't a Frenchman.  
 In his capacity as world-wide planning coordinator, Mueller had been invited by Nate Cocello to attend the meeting as an observer. 
 He had listened to DATAR &bquo;s views with great interest, and from a totally different viewpoint to that of the Vice President. 
 Mueller wanted to bring world planning under his personal direction and control from Detroit. 
 He could understand &mdash; so he said to the top brass after the Frenchman had departed &mdash; why the French took exception to an Englishman holding such a key position in Europe. 
 He could also understand why they objected to London being the European headquarters of United Motors. 
 Chairman Tom O'Reilly took a similar view but for different reasons. 
 He had been against the choice of London as the location for European Headquarters when he had been Treasurer. 
 As an active supporter of the &bquo;Irish cause&equo; he hated Britain and the British. 
 &bquo;I guess those European Government bastards would object wherever we located European headquarters,&equo; said Cocello. 
 &bquo;The French hate London, but they would also object to Bonn, Rome, Brussels&hellip; you name it. 
 It would still be wrong until you mentioned Paris. 
 Then it would be right.&equo; 
 &bquo;The same goes, I guess, for other Governments,, said the Chairman. 
 &bquo;There is no single acceptable location, as they see it, unless it is in their own country. 
 The French hate London and the British, but then, who doesn't?&equo; he added maliciously. 
 &bquo;Waal,, rejoined Cocello. 
 &bquo;If the Europeans fight like hell over new investment and where European headquarters should be, maybe we should consider running everything from here in Detroit, the way it used to be. 
 We could do it, of course.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure could,&equo; added Mueller eagerly, and received a look of cold disapproval from the Vice President in charge of  Overseas'  Operations for his unwarranted opinion. 
 &bquo;Well, why don't we chew on it a bit?&equo; asked the ageing Chairman. 
 &bquo;Maybe we should,&equo; replied the President and Chief Executive Officer. 
 &bquo;Randy, would you put down something for discussion by the Executive Committee?&equo;  
 &bquo;Yes sir, Will do.&equo; 
 Mark Sanders spent the next few days in his office, working late into the night to finalise the ten year European Business Plan and to summarise the massive document into a sixty minute presentation illustrated by thirty slides. 
 Fred Klepner had been in and out of both Mark's and Pat Muldoon's offices, which were only a few yards apart, like an eager beaver. 
 He would grab a completed section of the overall plan from Mark's private secretary just as soon as she had typed it, and dash off to his own office down the corridor to study it carefully many times over, before taking it along to Muldoon to keep him in the picture. 
 Klepner played the usual corporate cat and mouse game of making at least one or two word changes on each and every page so that his own secretary could re-type each page under her initials and the initials &bquo;FK&equo;. 
 This practice achieved twin objectives. 
 It gave the European plan anonymity by not identifying the author of the plan, while his own copy under his own initials and those of his secretary would tell Mueller and his Detroit colleagues that he had a hand in its formulation, which is what Mueller and Muldoon wanted people to think. 
 As presentation day grew closer with Mark racing against time to complete the plan and finalise the slide illustrations, so Klepner read and re-read it until he had almost learnt it off by heart. 
 So complete was his total immersion in the subject that he actually began to believe that he had assisted Sanders in the plan's preparation. 
 His delusions were those of a messenger boy who assumes that because he takes the Chief Architect's drawings to the print room, he has played a leading role in the design of the building. 
 A few days before the European Planning Committee was due to meet, Mueller decided to go for the jugular. 
 His suggestion that United Motors should progressively wind up its European, South American and Asian regional headquarters and plan, direct and control world operations from its home base in Detroit, had been well-received by most of the top brass who liked the big bold approach of running  the world the way it used to be&hellip; from Detroit. 
 They were under no illusions that they could do a better job from Detroit, but they had become increasingly concerned that they were getting out of touch with what was happening around the world, and that the tail was beginning to wag the dog. 
 The European zone, for example, was growing twice as fast as the United  States'  zone, and now employed a quarter of a million people. 
 This situation went against the grain, as the top brass always needed to be on top of every situation and on top of every executive if they were to do their jobs to their own satisfaction; not necessarily in the best interests of the Corporation, that is to say, but in their own best interests. 
 Mueller's proposals appeared to be more in tune with their own thoughts at that particular time. 
 For this reason he was given the green light to prepare more detailed proposals for further consideration. 
 Confident in the knowledge that he now had the general support of most of the top brass to his world control plan, Mueller considered that he was now in a much stronger position to start pulling the rug out from under the Regional Area Managers. 
 And, as the biggest zone by far was Europe, he would begin there. 
 His plan to appoint Klepner to succeed Sanders as European Planning Manager, based on Detroit rather than London, was working out to perfection. 
 Klepner had been doing everything that was expected of him acting as Mueller's eyes and ears in Europe. 
 It was now necessary to give Klepner visibility in front of Cocello and the top brass. 
 Muldoon was no problem. 
 He wouldn't mind taking early retirement. 
 He was over sixty and a relatively wealthy man, with a wife who was financially independent. 
 He would welcome the chance of retiring to his yachts. 
 McGillicuddy wouldn't relish the idea of giving up the General Director's job as European overlord, but he was also sixty and could be kicked upstairs for a year or so before taking early retirement. 
 H e certainly wouldn't be short of a dollar or two. 
 Sanders was a bit of a problem. 
 He was in his early fifties  and couldn't be retired early, except on a very much reduced company pension. 
 But&hellip; so what? 
 He could count himself lucky to have got where he had got in an all-American company. 
 He could be offered an MD job in one of the UK divisions which he would obviously turn down; but so what! 
 From now on the locals would do what they were told to do by Detroit, and if they didn't like it they could take the option of either getting out of their own free will, or being booted out. 
 He'd had enough of all that European political crap about overseas subsidiaries also having to represent the interests of the local host country where United Motors had a manufacturing presence. 
 Bullshit. 
 Their one and only interest was to serve the interest of the Corporation in the US of A and anyone in a top position overseas who didn't understand that number one lesson would soon have his nose put out of joint. 
 From here on in, Randy Mueller was going to start calling the shots. 
 He reckoned that his chances of making the Presidency before he was sixty were now better than ever. 
 He should make a Vice Presidency within five, the Presidency within ten. 
 President Randy Mueller, the all-American boy who had made it from right here in his little ole home town of Detroit. 
 He rose from his enormous desk and lit a big cigar &mdash; it couldn't have been a Havana &mdash; and strutted around his vast office like a peacock, admiring his reflection in the long mirror. 
 Randy loved himself and everything he stood for. 
 It was surely great to be an American going up in the greatest company in the world and in the greatest country in the world. 
 God bless America, and piss on the rest. 
 He walked to the phone, pausing on the way to take another admiring look at himself in the mirror. 
 &bquo;Miss Kopensky,&equo; he barked. 
 &bquo;Yes, Mr Mueller, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Get me Muldoon.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes sir, right away, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;And Miss Kopensky.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have a nice day, Miss Kopensky.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you, sir; have a nice day yourself, sir.&equo; 
 &bquo;I will, Miss Kopensky, I will.&equo;  
 &bquo;Mr Muldoon on the line, sir. 
 &bquo;Hi ya Pat buddy boy. 
 Happy Thanksgiving.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're a bit earl Randy You puttin' the clock forward?, 
 &bquo;You could put it that way. 
 A long way forward.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't get it.&equo; 
 &bquo;No buster, but you will, you will.&equo; 
 &bquo;Quit stallin around Randy, will ya. 
 What is it?&equo; 
 &bquo;We got ourselves a new ball park,&equo; said the man from Detroit. 
 &bquo;Nate and the Executive Committee have agreed in principle to phase-out all regional activities and bring the whole god-damned shootin' match right back here to Detroit, where I always said it should be.&equo; 
 &bquo;You gotta be kiddin'.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nope. 
 I'm deadly serious. 
 I produced some option plans and they took to it like a duck takes to water.&equo; 
 &bquo;What, Nate and the Executive Committee?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yep. 
 Well&hellip; with a few exceptions.&equo; 
 &bquo;You serious?&equo; 
 &bquo;Course I'm serious.&equo; 
 &bquo;You amaze me. 
 That's a major organisational change. 
 Fundamental policies.&equo; 
 &bquo;Too damned right it is. 
 And yours truly is in the drivin' seat. 
 So hang on for the ride, Pat. 
 It's all systems go.&equo; 
 &bquo;And where do I fit in under the new organisation?&equo; 
 Muldoon asked. 
 &bquo;Do I get early retirement on full pension?, 
 &bquo;Sure do. 
 Yes, siree. 
 Just what you wanted. 
 Now you can quit the heat of the kitchen and swan around on those yachts of yours you got stashed around the world.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, guess you're right. 
 It's gotta be better than work.&equo; 
 &bquo;At your age. 
 You better believe it.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about McGillicuddy?&equo; 
 &bquo;He'll be all right. 
 He'll be kicked upstairs for a year or so before taking early retirement.&equo; 
 &bquo;And Sanders? 
 What about him? 
 He's only in his early fifties.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, well. 
 We ain't gonna have no limey runnin' Europe from Detroit, that's for sure. 
 It's got to be an American. 
 You  and I are gonna recommend Klepner. 
 He's been doin' what he's been told to do, and feedin' me back all the inside information I need. 
 I can trust him. 
 He's the kind of guy I'm lookin' for to head up regional planning. 
 Someone who will carry out Detroit instructions. 
 I don't want Mister smart arse 
 Sanders on my Detroit team.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, what's gonna happen to him?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't know for sure yet, but there won't be any European corporate jobs left after we centralise everything in Detroit. 
 He can be offered a divisional job in one of the UK divisions I suppose.&equo; 
 &bquo;Come off it, Randy. 
 He won't go back to divisional work after ten years at corporate level. 
 He couldn't possibly accept such a demotion.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, he ain't comin' here to Detroit, that's for sure. 
 And I can tell you, buddy boy, that he's Persona non grata  with the US vehicle divisions after his comments about the future European trend toward smaller fuel economy vehicles at the EPC meeting.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well that's the way things are goin' over here, and that's the way he sees it goin' in the future, under the Government constraints he outlined at that meetin'.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well all I'm tellin' you, Pat, is that he's made a lot of enemies. 
 Those guys don't like being questioned by Europeans. 
 We run this business&hellip; not Europeans.&equo; 
 Muldoon stared into space, his face expressionless. 
 &bquo;Hey Patrick. 
 You still there?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, Randy,&equo; Muldoon sighed forlornly. 
 &bquo;I'm here.&equo; 
 &bquo;I want you to get Sanders out of the country just before next week's EPC meeting and keep him out until after the meetin's over. 
 I want you to give the European components presentation to Klepner.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's that?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, correction. 
 I want you to introduce the plan and then hand over the presentation to Klepner. 
 You can introduce him as the guy you and I appointed some months back to work with Sanders on the preparation of the Business Plan. 
 That way we can see that he gets the credit. 
 It will also make it easier  when you and I recommend him to take over from Sanders when we pull it back to Detroit. 
 If Klepner's gonna get his job he may as well do the spiel. 
 We can go easy on him with the questions, but I want Nate to be impressed. 
 Get it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah&hellip; 
 I guess so, Randy&hellip; if you say so. 
 But I gotta tell you that I don't like it. 
 It stinks.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, yeah. 
 But before you can make an omelette you gotta break a few eggs, ain't that so?&equo; 
 &bquo;But the Business Plan is his baby, Randy. 
 He's put that whole damn thing together, almost single-handed. 
 And it's not gonna be easy to get him outta the country&hellip;. 
 He'll fight like hell to present it. 
 I just don't like it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aw come on, Pat. 
 You're making me cry. 
 OK, so you lose some and you win some. 
 Sanders loses. 
 We can't all be winners. 
 Anyway, don't you worry none. 
 You'll be all right. 
 Just do what I say, will ya? 
 There s no point in you tryin to swim against the tide now, is there? 
 At your age, you'd drown!&equo; 
 Muldoon winced visibly at the younger man's cruel analogy. 
 But he was right. 
 There was no point in swimming against the tide. 
 At his age he really would drown and nobody in the Corporation would give a damn. 
 &bquo;Are you sure, Randy, that Nate and the executive committee agree with your proposals?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course I'm sure. 
 What the hell do you think I've been talkin' about the last few minutes? 
 Hey and listen, Pat, I don't want to see or hear any reference to that part of the plan which shows that we can save up to a billion dollars a year by supplying components from the European plants to fit US manufactured vehicles. 
 That's not on. 
 The US components divisions would hit the goddamned roof if that proposal was ever given the light of day. 
 Is that understood?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I hear what you're sayin' Randy, but I don't necessarily agree with ya. 
 Mark was asked by McGillicuddy for some ideas by which European plants could reduce corporate operating costs on a world wide basis. 
 Mark's right. 
 European component manufacturing costs are lower than in the States, and we could save the Corporation around a billion dollars a year by purchasin' components from our European plants. 
 So what's wrong with puttin' it up for discussion?&equo; 
 &bquo;Because the US components divisions ain't gonna like it, that's why! 
 We'd have a full scale fight on our hands with those  guys if we went ahead with that proposal!&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, but hang on a minute, Randy. 
 Isn't that exactly what you are proposing to do in reverse? 
 You and the Corporation have been telling us to purchase from our new subsidiaries in Taiwan, Korea, Singapore and even from Japan, for God's sake. 
 Mark has told you guys many times that European Governments and European plant people ain't gonna like that one little bit, particularly when their own Far East markets are heavily protected. 
 So what's different about Mark's plan to sell components from our European plants into the United States, if we can save the Corporation a billion dollars a year by doin' so?, 
 &bquo;Whose side are you on, Pat?&equo; 
 &bquo;The Corporation's, Randy. 
 Whose side are you on?&equo; 
 &bquo;The Corporation's and Uncle Sam's. 
 Aren't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;My responsibilities are European, so are Mark's. 
 If the Corporation wants to turn our suggestions down, so be it. 
 But we represent the interests of our European plants, as well as the overall interests of the Corporation. 
 How else do we explain to Plant Managers and to Governments that it's right for the Corporation to purchase products from non-European sources, but it's wrong to supply European components to the United States because the US divisions wouldn't like it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Since when has the interest of the United States come second, Pat?&equo; 
 &bquo;Since when have we had a Corporation plan which is not truly multi-national, Randy?&equo; 
 &bquo;Since the year dot,&equo; said the younger American with finality. 
 Muldoon was beginning to get an uncomfortable feeling that he was pushing his opinions too far, something he had never done in his life. 
 He sensed the danger and eased back. 
 &bquo;Guess you're right, Randy,&equo; he said submissively. 
 &bquo;Sure I'm right, Pat. 
 You know that. 
 Look, I'm simply tellin' ya to drop it out of the presentation, that's all. 
 The executive committee won't go along with something which doesn't have the support of the US divisions. 
 You know that. 
 So why don't you do as I say and drop it? 
 We will amend the plan from this end when we pull it all together. 
 Just don't include it in the  presentation, that's all. 
 Sanders has already got the US vehicle divisions lined up against him. 
 No point you adding the component divisions as well. 
 Be smart. 
 Do as I say.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 I suppose you are right, Randy. 
 It's a no-win situation. 
 &bquo;Attaboy. 
 Now you're talkin'.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I don't like it, Randy. 
 It's dirty.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah sure. 
 But you'll do it?&equo; 
 &bquo;What choice is there?&equo; 
 &bquo;None, I guess, if you're still interested in your own future.&equo; 
 &bquo;How do I get him out of the country? 
 As I say, he'll fight like hell to give the presentation.&equo; 
 Don't worry. 
 We'll cook somethin' up from this end. 
 We got Government bastards crawlin' all over us out here with their beggin' bowls at the ready. 
 How does he fancy Iran or Turkey? 
 They are the two latest to join the beggin' bowl line. 
 They'd love to see him down there. 
 Lambs' eyes and bulls' bollocks for dinner. 
 He'd just love that. 
 I'll be in touch shortly to tell you what we've cooked up. 
 Must go Pat. 
 Nice talkin' to ya. 
 Have a nice day.&equo; 
 Muldoon lowered the phone slowly, shaking his head sadly. 
 My God, what was the Corporation coming to when unscrupulous people like Mueller were influencing its future and the destinies of countless loyal, hardworking and respected executives on overseas operations? 
 What in the world would the company be like in a few years' time if such people were in the driving seat? 
 Well the answer to that question, he supposed, was that there wouldn't be an overseas Corporation to worry about. 
 What would be the world reaction when the full implications of the new World Car Plan under the new centralised organisation became more obvious? 
 What would be the reaction of local managers, of Governments, of the employees and the unions? 
 He shuddered at the thought of all the potential conflict situations ahead. 
 He was glad he was getting out.  
 Mark could hardly believe his ears when, two days before the EPC meeting, Muldoon told him that Nate wanted him to fly out to Istanbul right away. 
 It was true that a major problem had just cropped up which demanded immediate attention. 
 The Corporation's major vehicle assembler in Turkey was in serious difficulties, due to the fact that the new Government had slapped an embargo on the importation of components to conserve its diminishing currency reserves. 
 United Motors had received two urgent requests for assistance; one from the local Managing Director, who needed help to resolve his serious plant problems, and the other from the Turkish Prime Minister requesting UM investment support to reduce the country's massive trade imbalance. 
 All this was fact. 
 The fiction was that Nate had instructed Mueller to arrange to get Sanders down there quickly, when he had done no such thing. 
 Muldoon spun the line that the deteriorating situation in Turkey was clearly more important right now than the EPC meeting. 
 Events there were taking much the same course as they had in Portugal, and as Mark had resolved that problem in double quick time, he was considered the best man to deal with this new problem situation. 
 All very flattering, but&hellip;. 
 The Englishman sensed that the big personal build-up was a blind to hide Muldoon's real reason for wanting him out of the country. 
 He knew full well that the only circumstances in which a regional planning manager would not be expected personally to present his Ten Year Business Plan to the President of the Corporation was if he was already earmarked for promotion and it was desired to give visibility to his successor, or if he was on his way out. 
 Mark knew that he would never be promoted after the Steiner incident so he concluded he must indeed be on his way out, or being moved sideways. 
 Sensing the  game which was being played, he decided to throw several balls in the air for Muldoon to catch, if he could. 
 So he said that he would take the next available flight to Turkey immediately after the EPC meeting. 
 No, that was no good. 
 Istanbul was expecting him. 
 Meetings had been set up. 
 Nate wanted him there straight away; like today; tomorrow at the latest. 
 &bquo;Well, give me a few minutes,&equo; Mark said, &bquo;and I'll ring the Prime Minister's office in Istanbul, to see if they'll agree to a short postponement.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, you can't do that,&equo; Muldoon replied hurriedly. 
 &bquo;It was Nate himself who had the meetings fixed up, and he wouldn't want them changed.&equo; 
 &bquo;But nothing can be more important than the Business Plan,&equo; Mark insisted. 
 &bquo;Nothing, but nothing, is ever allowed to take precedence over that meeting. 
 Dammit, it's the future of the European components business I'll be talking about.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, I know that, Mark,&equo; the American countered. 
 &bquo;But Nate has specifically said that you are the man he wants to fly out to Turkey. 
 I'll have to give the presentation on your behalf. 
 After all, I am the Regional Manager.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you never give the planning presentations. 
 That s my bailiwick,&equo; countered the Englishman, with growing resentment in his voice and manner. 
 &bquo;Yes, I know that, Mark, but&hellip;.&equo; 
 The American couldn't continue the charade any longer. 
 Lowering his head, he said, &bquo;I'm sorry, Mark, but that's the way they want it, and that's the way it's got to be. 
 Klepner can check out the slides for me. 
 They are all done, aren't they, and the text?&equo; 
 Mark nodded his head. 
 &bquo;Yes, sure. 
 Everything's finished.&equo; 
 He only realised the finality of the phrase a second or so later. 
 Muldoon didn't know quite what to say. 
 &bquo;I know you have worked your arse off to produce the plan, Mark, and it's a great one. 
 No doubt about that. 
 But if Detroit has its reasons, it has its reasons. 
 It's as simple as that. 
 I'll hold the fort and fill you in when you get back.&equo; 
 Mark turned towards the door. 
 It was pointless to argue further. 
 Muldoon was simply carrying out instructions.  
 &bquo;Fill me in&hellip; that's just about it, Pat, nice choice of words.&equo; 
 He opened the door and turned toward the American. 
 Who are you going to hand the presentation over to, after you have given the introduction?&equo; he asked quietly. 
 They both said the name together &mdash; &bquo;Klepner.&equo; 
 Mark was sick at heart as he drove home that evening. 
 He had a blinding headache and simply wasn't thinking of what he was doing as he swung the car off the slip road to enter the motorway. 
 His thoughts were fiercely occupied elsewhere. 
 Without even glancing in the mirror, he crossed the inner and middle lanes into the fast lane and, in fewer than ten seconds the speedometer needle was registering one hundred and fifteen miles an hour, but Mark was oblivious of the fact. 
 Suddenly conscious that he was flashing past vehicles which appeared to be dawdling, he glanced at the speedometer. 
 He was doing one hundred and twenty! 
 He jerked his foot off the accelerator and glanced in the mirror, heaving a sigh of relief that nobody was on his tail. 
 Slowing to seventy, he made his way home. 
 He very rarely spoke about business matters to Georgina and decided on reflection against recounting the day's events except to say that he was leaving for Istanbul in the morning, and would be away for three or four days. 
 The Tri-star jet was two hours late on take-off from Heathrow, and then had to abort on the runway at lift-off point due to a sudden failure of one of the engines. 
 The pilot slammed the powerful jets into reverse thrust, bringing the giant plane to a halt just before he ran out of runway. 
 In a very matter-of-fact voice he apologised for the shut down, due to engine failure, adding laconically that he had left ten thousand pounds worth of tyres on the runway.  
 &bquo;British Airways will not be at all pleased with me.&equo; 
 he remarked casually. 
 &bquo;There goes another Brownie point.&equo; 
 By the time the plane approached Istanbul in the late afternoon, Mark had put away several large measures of single malt Scotch. 
 Mechanically he had taken each drink offered without thinking, for the simple reason that he had spent the entire journey staring out of the cabin window into the infinity of space. 
 His meeting was not until the next morning, so he could switch off for a few hours. 
 He needed to do just that, for he was tired, morose and bitter and, for the first time in his life, feeling very insecure. 
 Gazing out into the blue, he asked himself if this assignment was his swan song. 
 Must be, he concluded. 
 Nate would never have taken him off the presentation if he wasn't being moved sideways or demoted. 
 But why? 
 To make way for Klepner, Mueller's pet poodle? 
 It had happened before, to make way for Muldoon. 
 Why shouldn't it happen again? 
 If you couldn't trust the bastards then, why should you trust them now? 
 He closed his eyes. 
 What made Nate and the executive committee think that guys like Klepner and Mueller knew more about the European components&equo; business than the Europeans? 
 What the hell would the US component divisions say if the executive committee was stupid enough to appoint Europeans to manage components operations in the United States? 
 No prizes for guessing the answer to that question. 
 The blonde hostess leaned across him to re-charge his glass for the umpteenth time. 
 His favourite Scotch, Glenlivet. 
 Good old George and James Smith. 
 Now there were two characters you could trust! 
 So easy to relax and forget your troubles when you had a glass of their malt in your hand&hellip;. 
 He jerked forward with a start to find the hostess fingering with his seat-belt clasp. 
 &bquo;Just arriving at Istanbul sir. 
 Please fasten your seat belt.&equo;  
 Fred Clasper, the militant Merseyside convener, was a desperately worried man. 
 Things weren't going at all well within the UK vehicle Division. 
 Even his own notorious plant, which had consistently gone downhill for ten years under his active leadership, had been steadily increasing efficiency and output for several weeks without interruption. 
 Morale on the shop floor was higher than it had been for a long year and an unhealthy atmosphere of optimism and hope pervaded the plant. 
 Union members were openly expressing the view that there was a real chance that the ailing division would now pull out of its dive with the  Peters'  Plan, which had been fully supported by Bunker and a two-thirds majority at the plant. 
 To Clasper's disgust, the majority had voted against his recommended call for strike action and he now sensed all too painfully that he was beginning to lose control of his members. 
 Management was once again managing, something which he had never allowed to happen during his ten years as convener. 
 Arising from Clem Bunker's endorsement of the plan, new methods had been introduced which were greatly increasing earnings through higher productivity. 
 Restrictive practices, which Clasper had fought so hard to introduce, were being discarded at a rate of knots in the quest to increase efficiency, output and earnings. 
 As a lifelong Communist, Clasper knew that it was absolutely essential to wrest control of the workers away from the plant management. 
 He had exercised effective control of the labour force for ten years at the giant plant and had been able to bring the workers out on strike at the drop of a hat. 
 It was he, Clasper, who dictated to management the size of the labour force they would require to produce a given number of products, regardless of any figure which management might arrive at by employing accurately measured work standards. 
 If in effect, Clasper said that three men must be employed to do two men's work, then that was it. 
 On those occasions when he had felt the need to demonstrate his power to management, he would create an instant departmental dispute which always had the immediate effect of lowering that day's efficiency to below fifty per cent. 
 Since the plant manager was never able to make up a day's loss of output which pulled down his monthly overall efficiency figures on which he was judged, it was never difficult for  Clasper to prove his point. 
 As he had always succeeded in getting his own way, the workers had been inclined to go along with him, even when their instincts told them that he was wrong. 
 They really had no choice in the matter for he had always been able to threaten any dissenters, or strays, with the loss of their union cards. 
 Successive personnel managers had always caved in to his demands as they knew full well that Clasper would win a stand-up fight. 
 Yet an uneasy feeling had been steadily growing among the ten thousand workers employed at the plant that the benefits which Clasper's militancy had achieved were illusory. 
 Increased earnings, grabbed as a result of strike action rather than earned by increased productivity and profitability had always been subsequently eaten away by inflation. 
 The Corporation was also no longer expanding its British operations, in marked contrast to the frequent expansion of its plants in Germany, Belgium and France. 
 Every long service worker employed at the plant and within the division knew that union restrictive practices had lowered productivity to below the levels achieved on the continent. 
 These more loyal long service employees had an intuitive feeling that the division would ultimately go out of business in the UK if it continued to operate in the way it had behaved over the previous ten years. 
 Even the notoriously militant workers at the Merseyside plant were now beginning to recognise that distinct possibility. 
 It was generally recognised that Clasper was not the man to dismantle restrictive practices, nor to co-operate with management to make the necessary improvements in labour relations if they were to keep their jobs in future. 
 The majority now believed that Bunker's more realistic approach made more sense. 
 Clasper was beginning to be seen by his own members for what he really was: a born agitator and troublemaker who was great to have around when plant managements behaved like bastards because he was one too and would give as good as he got in a stand-up fight. 
 But he certainly wasn't the man to have in the driving seat on the union side when both management and workers were striving for the sheer survival of the company, and needed to work together if they were to pull through.  
 It was being said quite openly on the factory floor that the only place Clasper would lead them to was the end of the dole queue. 
 The Communist convener could both feel and see that he was losing control. 
 Fewer workers bothered to listen to him when he called meetings to protest against the  Peters'  Plan. 
 He was also being subjected to cat-calls and ridicule. 
 At one such meeting a heckler had got a great round of cheers from the assembled throng when he had told Clasper to get off his bloody soap-box and do a day's work for a bloody change. 
 To his disgust he found that the workers would no longer respond to his call for mass meetings during working hours. 
 They now told him, in no uncertain terms, that if he had something important to communicate, he could do it in the plant car park during the lunch break, or after working hours. 
 They were not disposed to lose both output and earnings by downing tools. 
 In desperation Clasper called a private meeting of the hard core left-wing stewards under his convenership, who could always be relied upon to fight against management and the capitalist system. 
 The British people had just elected a Conservative Government, headed by Britain's first ever woman Prime Minister, who had already earned the reputation of being &bquo;the best man for the job&equo; in the Conservative Party. 
 Within days of taking office, she had invited Don Peters to explain the problems which had bedevilled the British vehicle plants during the sixties and seventies and to outline his company's plan for the future. 
 Living up to her reputation, Peters found that she had done her homework thoroughly. 
 She was tough and uncompromising. 
 She noted, she said with a pained expression, that output from the UK Vehicle Division of United Motors had been falling steadily over the previous ten years. 
 At the same time, UM imports had been steadily rising, including very substantial imports from UM Vehicle Divisions on the Continent which had greatly expanded their total output and exports over the  same period. 
 &bquo;United Motors used to make a very healthy contribution to Britain's export drive. 
 Now you are the biggest single contributor to our balance of payments deficit,&equo; she said acidly. 
 &bquo;Trends of this nature don't simply happen, do they?&equo; she asked with feigned innocence. 
 &bquo;It has to be planned that way, does it not?&equo; 
 She wanted to know what the UK Vehicle Division was doing to correct its appalling track record of recent years, particularly when compared with its Continental plants. 
 She then ticked off several points she wished to make. 
 Don Peters had been pleasantly surprised to find the Prime Minister's forthright manner lived up to her advance publicity. 
 The United Kingdom had a serious balance of payments problem in manufactured goods, which was only partly disguised by the revenue beginning to flood in from North Sea oil, which had a limited life. 
 The problem had been seriously aggravated by the poor performances of UK vehicle producers &mdash; his own company foremost among them &mdash; and the Prime Minister naturally wanted to know what he was doing to correct the adverse trend. 
 It was a straightforward and most pertinent question. 
 He would have posed the same question if he had been sitting in her position. 
 For nearly half an hour, the American explained the plan which the Corporation had recently approved. 
 He then answered the many penetrating questions put to him. 
 In answer to one such question, he replied that he was pleased to say that he was now being given full support by the unions which drew the sharp retort&hellip;. 
 &bquo;NOT BEFORE TIME!&equo; 
 Before she dismissed him she said unequivocally that it was the Government's intention to rebuild Britain's weakened manufacturing base and reduce the ever-growing importation of manufactured products. 
 &bquo;If industry doesn't help me to achieve the objectives of the Government, we will have to take appropriate alternative steps,&equo; she had said with a steely smile. 
 &bquo;But I hope that won't be necessary. 
 Thank you so much, Mr Peters for the chat. 
 Most helpful. 
 I will invite you to dinner when you correct your trade imbalance.&equo; 
 Mark booked into The Istanbul Hilton in the mid-evening and, after a shower, returned to the lobby where he purchased a thriller before retiring to the comfort of an easy chair in the lounge. 
 He continued to drink quietly for another hour before going in to dinner. 
 Afterwards he adjourned to the cocktail bar for a nightcap. 
 He was now feeling pleasantly intoxicated from the effects of a steady supply of alcohol, which had lifted his flagging spirits. 
 He was now more at peace with the world of United Motors. 
 Sipping a large Armagnac and enjoying the heady aroma of a Havana cigar, he had come to terms with the fact that life could, and would go on. 
 Whatever lay ahead, maybe it was for the best. 
 All is for the best in this best of all possible worlds, he mused, blowing a great cloud of smoke into the air above him. 
 That's what Voltaire's Pangloss had said, wasn't it? 
 And just look at the problems which had faced poor Candide. 
 Maybe it was time for a change, anyway. 
 Thirty years was a long time to stay with one company. 
 Should have got out after the Steiner incident. 
 Fool not to have done so. 
 Early fifties is leaving it a bit late. 
 Over fifty policy comes into effect. 
 Fate perhaps. 
 Do I believe in Fate? 
 Really don't know. 
 &bquo;There is a tide in the affairs of man, which taken at the flood, leads on to&hellip;&equo; heaven knows what and where. 
 A voluptuous blonde hooker in a long white gown entered the spacious bar. 
 The front was slashed all the way down to her navel to reveal rounded breasts, which rose and fell temptingly like a couple of ripe peaches. 
 Just inside the entrance, she turned to survey the client&egrave;le , making sure as she did so that all the men got a tantalising glimpse of a very long and elegant leg exposed through a side slit. 
 The bar was fairly full, with groups of local worthies and their wives and a clutch of broody businessmen. 
 From the attention which focused on her, it was obvious that the blonde would make a sale in no time at all. 
 Eyes turned as she walked slowly across the room, brushing by this man and that. 
 To his  surprise, she stopped when she reached Mark's chair and took the vacant seat beside him, nodding casually in his direction and flashing a devastating smile as she carefully arranged herself on display. 
 She crossed her slender legs very slowly so that the panel of her dress fell away to reveal long, shapely limbs plus a glimpse of white satin briefs. 
 Mark smiled the appreciative smile of a man who was just looking, not buying. 
 Must be too expensive for the locals, he mused. 
 Perhaps the fiddle sheet didn't run to outside entertainment more than once a month. 
 Soaring inflation, perhaps. 
 Up sixty per cent this year in Turkey, he'd read in The Financial Times . 
 No&hellip; wait a minute. 
 Devaluation of the Turkish lira. 
 Down forty per cent. 
 That's it! 
 She's after the export business. 
 She gives a much better exchange rate and gets forty per cent more lira for every pound, deutschmark or dollar she takes. 
 Not bad, eh, when you're giving your all for your country? 
 She smiled again, which Mark again returned, even though he was not in the running. 
 Just an interested bystander, studying the form in the paddock and placing bets on who would be the jockey who would saddle her up. 
 Chap at the far end of the bar in a grey pin-stripe clearly fancied his chances. 
 Been ogling her up and down ever since she'd entered the room. 
 Down boy, down! 
 She's too expensive for you, even after allowing for devaluation. 
 Where on earth were the Germans? 
 They could afford her. 
 God only knows how many lira there were to the deutschmark these days. 
 Must be bloody millions. 
 He watched her fumble for an intentionally long time in her handbag for the means of lighting the Turkish cigarette she held aloft in her left hand, only a foot or so away from Mark's head. 
 He was an ungallant swine for deliberately not coming to her aid, but in truth he really wanted to see which of the likely lads, would dash forward. 
 Surprisingly, there were no punters. 
 At long last she looked up imploringly from the depths of her tiny handbag, which prompted Mark to produce his lighter. 
 Thank you,&equo; she said, blowing a thin wisp of smoke in the air.  
 &bquo;I thought you'd never respond. 
 Are you waiting for someone?, 
 Her voice was cultured and unmistakably English. 
 &bquo;No, not really,&equo; he replied. 
 &bquo;Just enjoying the parade in the paddock,&equo; he added casually. 
 &bquo;So you ARE English,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I thought so. 
 Always give yourselves away, you chaps.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that so?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;Do tell me, and what gives a destitute Englishman away in a foreign land? 
 Decadence?&equo; 
 &bquo;Style,&equo; she replied, throwing her long fair hair over her shoulders and flashing him the toothpaste smile again. 
 &bquo;Style?&equo; 
 &bquo;Style.&equo; 
 He raised his eyebrows in surprise and softly sang the words of the song. 
 &bquo;So you've got, or you haven't got&hellip; style.&equo; 
 She finished the next line, &bquo;If you've got it, it stands out&hellip; a mile.&equo; 
 They laughed together. 
 &bquo;Sanders. 
 Mark Sanders,&equo; he said, introducing himself. 
 &bquo;Will you have a drink?&equo; 
 &bquo;Love one. 
 White lady,&equo; she replied. 
 &bquo;Destitute Englishman,&equo; she scoffed dismissively. 
 &bquo;My eye. 
 With those shoes? 
 British and Harrods to the last. 
 Name's Virginia, believe it or not. 
 But my friends call me Ginny. 
 More appropriate.&equo; 
 &bquo;So that's what gave me away. 
 My shoes. 
 Well, bless my soul,&equo; he said, with an air of exaggerated surprise. 
 &bquo;They haven't got holes in have they?&equo; he asked in mock horror, glancing at the sole. 
 &bquo;I wondered why you sat next to me, when you obviously had the field to play. 
 Why pick on me?&equo; 
 &bquo;I've told you. 
 Style.&equo; 
 she replied, with her winning smile. 
 &bquo;And yes, I do like the company of my compatriots. 
 Miss home quite a lot. 
 Daddy fell from grace, poor dear. 
 Lost everything, so I came out here. 
 Well, a girl's got to live, hasn't she?&equo; 
 She added brightly, &bquo;Much easier to be a fallen woman when you're miles from home. 
 Must keep up the family tradition you know. 
 Daddy always did say to do what you do best, and I am very good at it&hellip; so they say.&equo;  
 &bquo;Are you now&hellip;?&equo; he replied. 
 &bquo;Excellent references.&equo; 
 She took the cocktail which the waiter had just brought. 
 &bquo;Cheers,&equo; she said, raising her glass to him. 
 &bquo;Happy nights to happy days.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bottoms up,&equo; Mark said, raising his glass in return. 
 &bquo;Of course. 
 Bottoms up. 
 Now that's an English expression I haven't heard in a long time. 
 Must use it in the future. 
 Very English and most apt.&equo; 
 Mark glanced round the room. 
 &bquo;Look, sweetheart, mustn't keep you away from the punters. 
 By the looks of 'em, they are all champing at the bit to place their bets. 
 And you are the hot favourite, bonny lass. 
 No doubt about that. 
 The others haven't a look in. 
 Not in your class.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aren't you a gambling man?&equo; she asked provocatively. 
 &bquo;No, not me. 
 Not any more. 
 With my luck, Ginny, I'd lose if I backed the only filly in a one horse race,&equo; Mark told her, suddenly conscious of the fact that his speech was beginning to slur. 
 &bquo;You couldn't lose with me,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I'd give you a very good run for your money.&equo; 
 &bquo;I bet you would. 
 But it's not your performance I'm worried about, sweetheart. 
 It's mine.&equo; 
 &bquo;Never lost a rider yet&equo; 
 &bquo;Always a first time,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Bit out of practice,&equo; 
 They laughed together at the sexy banter. 
 &bquo;I like you,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I like men who make me laugh. 
 Especially in bed. 
 I give encores, you know, when I'm happy.&equo; 
 &bquo;At no extra charge?&equo; 
 &bquo;No extra charge.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bully for you,&equo; said Mark approvingly. 
 &bquo;Always satisfy the customer if you are looking for repeat business. 
 Reminds me of a piece of graffiti outside Saint Martin-in the-Fields. 
 The poster said: &bquo;All ye who have sinned, enter here&equo; and a bright girl had written underneath: &bquo;All ye who have not sinned, ring Maida Vale 123456&equo;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Must remember that,&equo; she laughed. 
 &bquo;Free advertising.&equo; 
 &bquo;Smart girl. 
 You'll go far.&equo; 
 &bquo;How far do you want me to go?&equo;  
 &bquo;I'm not sure I'm physically in good enough shape to take the excitement of the ride,&equo; he said, raising his glass to her. 
 &bquo;Maybe you ought to find yourself a younger jockey.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nonsense. 
 You look in good shape to me, and anyway, I prefer more mature riders. 
 They pace the race so much better.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, the filly who prefers the leisurely canter to the short-lived gallop,&equo; he said  appreciatively . 
 &bquo;How eminently considerate. 
 So what odds do you lay me finishing the course on the bookie's favourite?&equo; 
 &bquo;Fifty,&equo; she said promptly. 
 &bquo;Fifty to win is a lot of money to lay out on an untried filly.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not this one, I promise you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dollars, or pounds?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;Pounds of course. 
 What do you take me for?&equo; she asked in mock surprise. 
 &bquo;My dear Ginny, that's not in question. 
 We've already established what you are. 
 We are simply negotiating the price&hellip;! 
 As I think George Bernard Shaw once said.&equo; 
 &bquo;You beast. 
 Hardly the way to win friends and influence people,&equo; she replied, pouting prettily. 
 &bquo;You can soon go off someone, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorry. 
 My mistake. 
 Mosht ungallant.&equo; 
 He blinked and shook his head to bring the room back into focus. 
 His speech really was slurred now. 
 &bquo;So let's have a stirrup cup before that happens.&equo; 
 He signalled the waiter. 
 &bquo;Great idea.&equo; 
 she said. 
 &bquo;Bottoms up!&equo; 
 A few minutes later, feeling decidedly the worse for wear after the last Armagnac had been downed, Mark moved unsteadily into the lift with his voluptuous mate. 
 As they entered his room, she reversed against the door, closing it with her bottom. 
 Draping her arms over his shoulders, she cradled his head in the palms of her hands, pulling him toward her to close a hungry, wet open mouth on his. 
 Restlessly exploring with an eager tongue, she eased his  jacket from his shoulders. 
 It fell noiselessly to the thick carpeted floor. 
 He tugged at the zip on the back of her dress while she unbuttoned his shirt and removed his tie. 
 She let the dress fall, pushing him away gently to slip out of tiny white satin briefs. 
 She was naked as she drew him towards her. 
 Her hands slid under his shirt, unbuckling, unzipping, thrusting on downwards. 
 She kissed him again on the lips before mouth followed the path her hands were taking. 
 &bquo;Do you like me?&equo; she whispered. 
 &bquo;Ask a silly question,&equo; he gasped. 
 &bquo;Fantastic!&equo; 
 And then, suddenly, without warning, a bomb-burst of excruciating pain exploded inside his skull and sent him reeling. 
 Head clasped in hands, he sprawled on the bed, gasping for air, as the room swayed crazily from side to side. 
 It was sheer hell. 
 Frightened by what had happened, the girl bent nervously over him. 
 &bquo;Are you all right?&equo; she asked tremulously, taking care not to touch him. 
 He struggled breathlessly to find the words. 
 &bquo;Yes&hellip; be all right&hellip; terrible pain&hellip; give me a few minutes&hellip; be OK.&equo; 
 She looked at the crumpled figure who was fighting for breath on the pillow, perspiration pouring down his anguished face. 
 &bquo;Shall I get you a drink?&equo; she asked. 
 He nodded. 
 &bquo;Scotch&hellip; on table.&equo; 
 &bquo;Cigarette?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;No.&equo; 
 She poured two glasses and gave him one. 
 In the semi-darkness Mark could see her movements. 
 She had a most beautiful body which looked opalescent in the half light. 
 He took a gulp at the Scotch and gave a wry smile at the injustices of this world which caused him to be smitten with another one of those blinding attacks just when he was about to make it. 
 Well, they always said it was the only way to go and he believed it. 
 He was perspiring heavily as he sipped his drink, gazing  wistfully at the voluptuous creature who stood naked before him in the half light with a look of scared concern on her young face. 
 &bquo;Shall I get a doctor?&equo; she asked, at length. 
 &bquo;No. 
 I'll be OK.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you sure?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 Feeling a lot better already. 
 Thanks.&equo; 
 He moved himself into a reclining position, head against the padded headrest. 
 The room started to sway again and the pains in his head intensified. 
 &bquo;Told you I was too old a jockey,&equo; he joked. 
 &bquo;Fell at the first fence.&equo; 
 He was about to say &bquo;game to the last&equo; but thought again. 
 She smiled at his efforts to be funny. 
 &bquo;I was looking forward to the ride. 
 Frustrated filly. 
 Entered then scratched. 
 What a palaver.&equo; 
 &bquo;Have to be a stewards&equo; enquiry,&equo; he said painfully. 
 &bquo;Lot of money went on the favourite.&equo; 
 &bquo;Under starter's orders, so I'm afraid no stake money refunded.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Jockey to blame.&equo; 
 She walked to the bathroom and returned with a towel to mop his sweating face. 
 &bquo;That feels good. 
 Thanks,&equo; he said. 
 She sat on the bed, mopping his brow. 
 He closed his eyes. 
 Not a bad looking devil, she thought. 
 More than just a few grey hairs here and there. 
 Plenty of lines on his face, which she hadn't really noticed before, but which were particularly noticeable now. 
 No matter. 
 They gave him character and sex appeal. 
 About fifty, she thought. 
 Why was it that she always found herself attracted to older men? 
 More interesting, she supposed. 
 She liked a man with a sense of humour. 
 Had a good figure. 
 quite looked forward to his love-making. 
 Pity. 
 She continued to pat his face with the towel. 
 Wonder who he is? she thought. 
 International business man, that's for sure. 
 Written all over him. 
 Married. 
 No doubt. 
 They all were. 
 Wife who loves him, but who has gone off sex. 
 How often had they said that. 
 No ring on his hand, but that was nothing to go by. 
 Very few married men wore rings these days. 
 Can't blame them. 
 Better chance to play the field.  
 He was breathing less heavily now. 
 Perhaps he was asleep. 
 She dabbed his forehead. 
 &bquo;Are you asleep?&equo; she whispered. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; he whispered back. 
 He wanted to say: &bquo;With a girl like you in the room?&equo; but was too exhausted to make the effort. 
 She kissed him lightly on the lips and rose from the bed to get dressed. 
 Taking his jacket from the floor she opened his wallet and took out two twenties and a ten before returning the wallet to the inside pocket. 
 Putting the money in her bag she checked her face in the mirror and walked back to the bed. 
 Are you asleep now?&equo; she whispered. 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; he whispered back, with the faintest of faint smiles. 
 &bquo;I've taken the stake money,&equo; she said. 
 He nodded imperceptibly. 
 &bquo;Sorry you&hellip; but it wasn't my fault, was it?&equo; she said. 
 He gave a slow shake of his head. 
 She pulled the bed cover over him. 
 &bquo;'Bye darling. 
 Feel better soon. 
 Look me up again when you are next in town, won't you? 
 We must complete the course.&equo; 
 Mark woke to the strangely sad and beautiful cry of the Muezzin, whose plaintive voice drifted across the ancient city to greet another dawn. 
 The pains in his head had subsided, but he felt dizzy and sick, which he concluded was not surprising, considering the amount of alcohol he had drunk the day before. 
 He attempted to go to the bathroom, but found that his left leg wouldn't respond. 
 It felt heavy and lifeless, in much the same way as it had felt that day in Spain when he had gone off the road. 
 He rolled on to his side and rubbed the leg vigorously with his right hand. 
 After a few minutes he heaved himself out of bed, but his leg let him down and he fell backwards. 
 From a sitting position he rubbed and thumped the leg until it responded sufficiently for him to drag himself to the bathroom.  
 It was five o'clock. 
 Hauling himself back to bed he lay awake for some time, before falling asleep. 
 When he awoke again it was seven. 
 To his great relief he found that the pains in his head had almost gone and that he could now move his left leg, albeit with some difficulty. 
 After a while he was able to stand. 
 He then walked slowly and gingerly towards the bathroom, keeping as much weight as possible on his right leg. 
 A hot bath, followed by a cold shower worked wonders for his circulation, and he was now able to move more freely, though still with a pronounced limp. 
 He shaved, got dressed and took the elevator to the breakfast-room. 
 He felt in reasonable shape, as he entered the local MDs office.  
 Nate Cocello, President of United Motors, had flown into London from Detroit with a posse of Vice Presidents to attend the bi-monthly meeting of the European Planning committee. 
 Chauffeurs had met them at their Inn on the Park hotel, at seven o'clock sharp; and at five minutes to eight they had taken their seats around the long elliptical table at European headquarters to ensure the meeting began on time, at precisely eight o'clock. 
 Randy Mueller was darting from one Vice President to another like an agitated blue-bottle. 
 He was first on with his presentation, and had been there since six-thirty to make sure there were no slip-ups with his slide presentation. 
 He began by saying how glad he was to be in Europe again, which gave him an opportunity to outline some of the developments taking place in other regions of the world, and to describe the next phase in the development of the world car. 
 He highlighted the different approaches being made by the regions, putting sufficient emphasis on the distinctions and duplications to enable the assembled company to draw their own conclusions: namely, that the international business was getting too big for the regions to handle, and that the variations would lead to unnecessary proliferation if they weren't effectively controlled and directed by Detroit. 
 European General Director Clancy McGillicuddy coughed and spluttered at the innuendo and the local European Managing Directors weren't exactly overjoyed. 
 They cast furtive glances at one another. 
 Nate Cocello allowed a knowing smile to cross his face at what he knew would be the natural reactions of line managers. 
 He had been one himself. 
 Mueller strode through the presentation aggressively. 
 Was there any other way? 
 Throwing up slides to make a point here,  and stepping aside from the podium to develop a theme there, he exuded great confidence in the future of the great corporation. 
 He ended his presentation of forty-five minutes precisely, with the words, &bquo;We have been the number one in the United States for many years, now we aim to be the number one in Europe, in South America, the Middle East&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;And all stations west of downtown Detroit,&equo; whispered Don Peters under his breath. 
 The President and Chief Executive Officer looked around the table. 
 Spotting Muldoon, he asked, &bquo;Any comments, Pat, from a components viewpoint?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not at this stage,&equo; Muldoon replied nervously. 
 &bquo;How about you, Mark&hellip;.&equo; began the top man, his eyes searching the long table for the Englishman. 
 &bquo;Say, where is Mark?&equo; he asked, not being able to spot him. 
 &bquo;He's here, isn't he?, 
 There was an uncomfortable and meaningful silence. 
 Other executives had already asked themselves the same question. 
 The main item on the agenda was the Components&equo; Business Plan. 
 It was really Mark's show. 
 Where the hell was he? 
 &bquo;Ah&hellip;. 
 He couldn't make it,&equo; Muldoon replied breathlessly. 
 &bquo;Fred Klepner here is standing in. 
 That's right, Randy, isn't it?&equo; he asked, calling across the table to get the question off his back. 
 &bquo;Yeah, Nate,&equo; Mueller interjected confidently. 
 &bquo;We got problems in Turkey. 
 Mark was out there at the time, so we asked him to help us sort it out. 
 He's taking a few days&equo; vacation out there, right now, so Pat and I thought it would be a good idea to let Fred Klepner stand in. 
 He's been helping Mark put together the Business Plan and the presentation. 
 That's right Pat, isn't it?&equo; he asked, getting the tricky subject off his shoulders. 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 That's right, Randy,&equo; the nervous American replied, almost choking on the words. 
 The top man was both amazed and damned angry that Mark wasn't there. 
 Dammit, the Components Plan was the main subject on the agenda. 
 He himself had specifically told Mark and Muldoon that he proposed to attend the meeting. 
  What was more important than that? 
 And surely, nobody in his right mind would take a few days' vacation and miss out on the opportunity of selling his own plans and proposals to the President of the Corporation? 
 He shrugged his shoulders, his face expressing his thoughts. 
 Every executive around the table could see that he was visibly annoyed by the Englishman's absence. 
 They were under no illusions. 
 If the Englishman hadn't blotted his copybook before, he certainly had now. 
 &bquo;O K. Let's move on,&equo; said the President after a long and pregnant pause. 
 &bquo;Ye Gods!&equo; he muttered, loud enough for all to hear. 
 &bquo;Can you beat it!&equo; 
 The components presentation came on after lunch. 
 Muldoon nervously introduced the plan, saying that as Fred Klepner had been over on special assignment from Detroit to help Mark in the final preparation of the Plan and the presentation, he would hand over to Fred and let him take the committee through the proposals. 
 Klepner's big moment had arrived and the ex-Harvard Business School man strode confidently to the podium. 
 He had worked long hours to acquire a complete understanding of the Plan and to learn Mark's presentation word for word. 
 He proceeded to explain the Plan, starting with a brief review of the world components market which positioned Europe to the rest of the world and led straight into the Plan. 
 The political and economic background and outlook was described, country by country, together with the principal assumptions on which the Plan was based. 
 This led into a technical and commercial appraisal of European competition and the anticipated market changes over the next ten years. 
 Existing low profit products were to be corrected with a cost reduction and profit improvement plan, or chased out where such improvements were not economically feasible. 
 New products were to be introduced with new plants to be located from a short list of low cost countries: namely Spain, Austria,  France, Portugal and the United Kingdom. 
 A manpower  resources'  plan summarised the personnel requirements by skill category and headcount, together with the required training programme. 
 The financial plan showed the investment impact on sales, profit and return on investment per year over the next ten years, while the financing plan described how the investment was to be financed: namely, from borrowings in the early years until the plan became self-financing from funds accrued from current operations, in year four. 
 The forty-five minute presentation concluded with a summary of the overall effect of the Plan on total European operations. 
 It appeared to roll forward and unfold under its own natural momentum, to reach its clearly defined objectives. 
 It came across to Cocello and the committee in such a way that the presenter couldn't help but benefit from being associated with it. 
 Klepner stepped down from the podium and waited for questions and observations. 
 &bquo;Fine plan you have there, Pat,&equo; said the President approvingly. 
 &bquo;I like it.&equo; 
 Turning toward Klepner he nodded his approval. 
 &bquo;Excellent presentation, Fred. 
 Obviously a lot of thought has gone into the plan. 
 It's good. 
 Fine job.&equo; 
 Klepner kept a straight face, but was overjoyed at the top man's response. 
 &bquo;Thank you, sir.&equo; 
 Randy Mueller put the first question but, before doing so, added his congratulations to those of the President. 
 &bquo;Good show, Fred. 
 You've done a fine job over here,&equo; he said, omnisciently, with the air of a superior conferring praise on a subordinate. 
 &bquo;Would you care to explain to the committee why you are considering the UK in your short list of countries to be considered for the new investment proposals. 
 I thought we'd all agreed at previous meetings that, with minor exceptions, all the major new plants would be located on the continent?&equo; 
 The question was simply a put-up job, Mueller having previously primed both Klepner and Muldoon. 
 The question was designed to give Klepner the opportunity to express a  contrary view to Sanders, which, in effect, was that there should be no further new investment in the United Kingdom. 
 &bquo;We've included the UK on the short list, at this stage,&equo; said Klepner, &bquo;because Mark says that when the task force teams come to prepare the comparative cost studies in detail they will find that the economics of manufacturing certain new products will almost certainly favour production in the UK. 
 Mark takes the view that if the UK is not to be considered for other than economic reasons, then that's a matter for the committee and the Corporation to decide. 
 But he wants all the facts to be presented to the committee before a corporate decision is made not to invest in the UK.&equo; 
 What do you, personally, think about that approach, Fred?&equo; 
 Mueller asked. 
 &bquo;Well, I guess I agree with the committee's original view that we should not put any major new investment in the UK,&equo; Klepner replied, knowing full well that this line would be supported by Mueller and most of the Americans around the table. 
 Mueller turned to Muldoon. 
 &bquo;What do you think, Pat?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;Muldoon coughed nervously 
 &bquo;I tend to agree with Fred,&equo; he replied. 
 Mueller then turned to the American Managing Director in charge of the British  Components'  Division, who was due for another assignment after nearly two years in the UK. 
 He too knew the score. 
 &bquo;What do you think, Hal?&equo; asked Mueller. 
 &bquo;Waal, based on the UK track record in recent years, I guess I gotta go along with Pat and Fred,&equo; he replied, shaking his head slowly. 
 Cocello had listened without interruption. 
 He addressed Muldoon. 
 &bquo;Let me get this straight, Pat,&equo; he said, shaking his head in disbelief. 
 &bquo;You gotta European plan which includes certain major new investment proposals in the UK subject to detailed economic justification by the special task force teams. 
 But you and Fred and Hal don't go along with UK investment. 
 Is that right? 
 Is that what you're sayin'?&equo; 
 Muldoon shuffled his papers nervously.  
 &bquo;Waal, I guess I am and I ain't,&equo; he replied. 
 &bquo;What the hell does that mean?&equo; asked Cocello irritably. 
 Muldoon looked to Mueller for support. 
 &bquo;Waal, I guess I'm all in favour of the European plan,&equo; he stuttered. 
 &bquo;I agree with you Nate&hellip; 
 I think it's a good one, a damned good one. 
 But I also agree with Randy here, and with Fred and Hal, that I'm not so sure about the UK side of the plan.&equo; 
 &bquo;The President grunted and turned his attention to McGillicuddy. 
 &bquo;Sounds to me, Clancy, that you European guys ain't quite made up your minds about the UK,&equo; he said. 
 Turning to Don Peters, he added, &bquo;How about you, Don? 
 They tell me that your proposals tomorrow will show the UK coming good&hellip; is that right?&equo; 
 Don Peters smiled and nodded his head. 
 &bquo;That's right, Nate,&equo; he replied confidently. 
 &bquo;You'll hear our proposals tomorrow but we are now beginning to see real signs of a big improvement at our UK vehicle plants. 
 All the indications are that we are now forging ahead. 
 We think that the UK is bullish in the years ahead and we are backing our judgement with further investment proposals.&equo; 
 Several Americans around the long table, including Mueller and the head of the British Components division, were shaking their heads slowly. 
 Peters saw their reactions and knew instinctively that he was going to have one hell of a fight on his hands the next day to convince the committee of his vehicle division proposals. 
 Fred Clasper's disruptive plan had been well prepared. 
 In addition to the work of a small but dedicated group of left wing militants who held shop stewardships at the Merseyside plant, he had received expert academic advice from two university lecturers who were sympathetic to the Communist international cause. 
 One was a lecturer at Oxford, the other at Liverpool University. 
 Like all such schemes prepared by left-wing militants, this plan was aimed at putting the company in a &bquo;Catch 22&equo; situation. 
 Namely, whatever action the company took, it would be  blamed for the ensuing conflict. 
 To this end, one of the younger Communist shop stewards in the plot had agreed to be the fall guy. 
 It was not a particularly difficult decision for him to come to, since he was going to emigrate to Australia anyway. 
 Company rules stated that, before a person could be dismissed for misconduct, two previous warning notes had to be formally given to the offender, placing on record the gravity of the offence. 
 Dismissal following automatically if a third serious offence was committed. 
 The young Communist shop steward had no difficulty in obtaining the first two warning notes. 
 He had switched-off the assembly track one Friday afternoon, half an hour before finishing time, ostensibly on the grounds that the overhead conveyor was unsafe and a danger to line operators working below. 
 The foreman had naturally hit the roof over the loss of thirty minutes' production, which would pull down his departmental output and efficiency target and had roundly reprimanded the shop steward for taking such unauthorised action without first bringing the alleged safety hazard to his attention, in line with normal company standard practice. 
 There was, of course, no such safety problem, as the safety inspector subsequently confirmed, and the steward was given the first of the warning notes, as planned. 
 He obtained the second by pretending to trip over an unseen obstacle, which inadvertently threw him against the foreman, knocking him to the ground and depositing his daily schedule papers all over the floor. 
 Both men had leapt to their feet and had been restrained from using violence by the mates of the shop steward, who just happened to be on hand. 
 One of the two witnesses, who also just happened to be the convener, Fred Clasper, claimed that a second warning note was unjustified as the foreman had been knocked down unintentionally. 
 Nevertheless, as planned, a second warning note was issued. 
 After both incidents, Clasper had made it known, throughout the plant, that the young shop steward was being victimised and harassed by the foreman while on legitimate union business. 
 It was alleged by Clasper that the foreman had his knife in the young kid who was only doing his job. 
 &bquo;The foreman is out to get him&equo; was the expression making the  departmental rounds. 
 Clasper and the conspirators timed the third offence to coincide with the visit to the UK of the President and Chief Executive Officer of United Motors, Nate Cocello, as this would provide maximum publicity to the planned strike. 
 An attempt would then be made to drag Cocello into the dispute by Clasper making a public appeal to the President to reinstate the sacked shop steward over the heads of plant and divisional management. 
 Either way, Clasper would win. 
 The strike would once again demonstrate the power of the unions and would also restore Clasper's own flagging personal influence and power over the workers. 
 While Don Peters was on his feet on the second day of the meeting of the European Planning Committee, explaining his plan to rejuvenate the ailing British vehicle division, Fred Clasper was also on his feet setting in motion his scheme to put the final nail in its coffin. 
 Don Peters knew when he went to the podium that the odds were stacked heavily against him gaining the support of Nate Cocello and the committee. 
 The American's performance at the podium was masterly. 
 He began by saying that with the UK vehicle division's track record over recent years, he couldn't really expect to receive any support to the plan he was about to describe. 
 He then went on to identify each and every major problem which affected cost and profit performance, quantifying each problem area and finally consolidating the total cost penalty at no less than four hundred million dollars. 
 He then described his proposals to reduce that cost penalty and turn the division from an operating loss into a satisfactory profit and return on investment. 
 Finally, he threw up slides showing the improvements which had already been achieved over the last three months. 
 What came across to Nate and the committee, most of all, was Peters the leader. 
 He had been given a tough assignment and he was in there fighting like hell on behalf of the British vehicle division. 
 He gave credit to local management and to the unions, singling out the name of Clem Bunker for most of  the industrial relations improvements coming through. 
 He ended his hour-long presentation with the words, &bquo;We are on our way toward making the division one of the best goddamned outfits in overseas operations, and I just want to be given the chance to prove that the plan which I have outlined to you today is the right one for the British operation, for Europe and for the Corporation.&equo; 
 Even Americans round the table, who didn't give him a snowball in hell's chance of getting approval to his plan, had to admit that he was still in there, fighting like a demon for a lost cause. 
 He handled the many questions in masterly fashion, particularly the probing questions from Cocello. 
 He was in the hot seat for more than three hours. 
 He had gone to the podium at eight o &bquo;clock. 
 By noon he had obtained Nate's approval and had won the day. 
 The Merseyside convener was aware that President Nate Cocello was coming to the UK for talks with British and European management. 
 The grapevine always flashed advance notice of such events, though it was never hard to guess when a VIP visit was imminent because of the frenzied housekeeping activity at each plant which always preceded it. 
 Clasper saw Cocello's arrival at Heathrow on television. 
 When asked by an interviewer if he was pleased with the performance of the British plants, the President had replied that although past performance had been bad by traditional British standards, he was now happy to say that in recent months a marked improvement had taken place. 
 This enabled him to look forward with confidence to continued improvements which would put the British plants back at the top of the performance league, where they used to be, and where they belonged. 
 Clasper had other ideas, however. 
 On the day that Don Peters was on his feet at the EPC meeting, fighting for the survival of the British Vehicle Division and the jobs of the fifty thousand people it employed, Fred Clasper was setting in motion the third and final stage of his scheme to sabotage any possible chance of the company's recovery.  
 It had been arranged by the conspirators that the young shop steward, who had already collected two warning notes as planned, would take out a set of spark plugs in his lunch box at the mid-day break. 
 One of the conspirators would ring the foreman to tip him off that the shop steward could be caught red-handed stealing company property if they searched him at the gate. 
 The foreman would naturally advise the security men on the gate, and Personnel Department, which would result in the steward being apprehended and instantly dismissed. 
 He would plead that the plugs had been planted by someone who bore a grudge against him, and the story would be quickly put round the plant that it was the foreman himself who had fixed it, to settle an old score. 
 Credibility would be given to the shop steward's story by having his lunch box placed in an unauthorised position on the assembly track from which the foreman would have to remove it, and be seen doing so. 
 Everything went according to plan and at noon the steward was stopped at the gate. 
 The spark plugs were found in the lunch box as arranged and he was immediately dismissed in accordance with company practice. 
 In itself, the offence justified instant dismissal under company rules. 
 The two previous warnings received by the steward made it inevitable. 
 Clasper was present in the Personnel Manager s office when the offence was read and the dismissal notice formally handed out. 
 That afternoon the convener communicated his version of the story to the shop steward's committee and within an hour every department was buzzing with the news. 
 It was well known that the foreman and the shop steward in question were always in dispute, and it appeared to the majority that the foreman had, in fact, set him up to get rid of him and to settle an old account. 
 Production was severely disrupted in all departments during the afternoon as the shop stewards spread the message. 
 At four o'clock they fed back the feelings of the workers to the convener, and at five minutes past four, Clasper took the giant plant out on strike, advising the Personnel and Plant Managers that they wouldn't return until the sacked shop steward had been re-instated. 
 The majority had no wish to stop work, particularly after the great strides which had been made in recent months, but they  weren't going to be sat on either. 
 To them it sounded like a straight forward case of victimisation by the foreman. 
 The message that the big Merseyside plant was out on strike was conveyed to Don Peters at the EPC meeting. 
 One of the secretaries entered the conference room with a message to ring the Plant Manager urgently. 
 &bquo;The plant has stopped work,&equo; she added. 
 The pain on the American's face was clear for all to see as he rose from his chair and left the meeting to make the call. 
 On his return, he immediately communicated the bad news to his boss, Clancy McGillicuddy, and to Nate Cocello, by handing them a copy of the statement put out by the Plant Manager. 
 Nate closed his eyes and shook his head in disbelief. 
 Clancy McGillicuddy was furious. 
 What in God's name had happened to the British? 
 Peters nodded his agreement. 
 &bquo;Yeah,&equo; he sighed. 
 &bquo;Yeah, Nate. 
 I know. 
 I know.&equo; 
 The President shook his head. 
 &bquo;I'm not blaming you, Don. 
 You've worked your arse off to solve this problem. 
 But they ain't gonna let anyone help 'em. 
 Those Merseyside bastards are hellbent on destroyin' themselves and every poor management sod unlucky enough to be involved with the plant. 
 It's a bloody graveyard of top talent.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 Yeah, Nate,&equo; Peters sighed again. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid it looks that way. 
 But the plan is a good one, and it would work, if only they'd give it a chance.&equo; 
 All the infectious enthusiasm had gone out of his voice and manner. 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 But they won't,&equo; the top man replied. 
 &bquo;So we'll have to change direction. 
 I'll tell Mueller to get a team down here from Detroit to get things started. 
 The locals ain't gonna like it, but they've ballsed-up their chances. 
 From here on in, we go back to the original plan to phase-out vehicle manufacture in the UK and import instead. 
 Passenger cars from Germany, Belgium and the proposed Spanish plant, and commercial vehicles from our new joint venture operation in Japan. 
 We just can't take any more risks by manufacturing in the UK. 
 It&equo; s  too damned unreliable. 
 Don't you agree, Clancy?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wish I could disagree with you, Nate, but I can't,&equo; replied the European General Director. 
 After dinner that evening, Cocello instructed Randy Mueller to set up a task force team from Detroit to come up with a phase-out plan for vehicle manufacture, and a phase-in plan for supplying the UK market from imports, 
 &bquo;It's gotta be the right thing to do,&equo; agreed Mueller readily. 
 &bquo;Today's events only confirmed what we already knew.&equo; 
 Cocello nodded sadly. 
 As an afterthought, Mueller added, &bquo;What about the Components&equo; Plan? 
 Do we go ahead with the UK side of that? 
 Or do we phase that out, too?&equo; 
 He hurried on. 
 &bquo;Guess we should be consistent, shouldn't we? 
 We can hardly tell the Finance and Executive Committee that the British are unreliable at the vehicle plants, but as solid as the Rock of Gibraltar when it comes to components.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, we can't,, Cocello agreed. 
 &bquo;Though for some totally inexplicable reason that seems to be the truth. 
 But you're right, Randy. 
 The Components&equo; Plan would lose all credibility if we included the UK. 
 Better tell Muldoon to make the necessary changes.&equo; 
 Mueller immediately saw his opportunity. 
 &bquo;Why don't I get the Detroit task force team to co-ordinate both the vehicle and components&equo; phase-out plans in the UK?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;Sure as hell the locals ain't gonna like doing it themselves. 
 We'd be fightin' a never-ending rearguard battle with those guys. 
 Sanders also ain't gonna like it, that's for sure. 
 He'll be fightin' for his European Plan as submitted; including the UK element.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 Perhaps you're right Randy,&equo; said the top man. 
 &bquo;Maybe you should take both plans on board and control them from Detroit. 
 At least that means that we can do it our way. 
 Sanders can't be all that interested in the Plan if he takes a few days vacation rather than give the presentation. 
 Jeez, that amazes me, as well as riles me.&equo; 
 he added, shaking his head in disbelief.  
 &bquo;What makes a guy like that behave that way? 
 I just don't understand it.&equo; 
 Mueller never turned a hair, or felt a twinge of remorse. 
 As far as he was concerned, he had just knocked another competitor out of the promotion stakes. 
 &bquo;It's gotta be right, chief,&equo; he replied enthusiastically. 
 &bquo;I don't think we can really plan overseas&equo; operations effectively, until we get full planning control from Detroit. 
 The European operation is too damned big a slice of the corporate business to be left to the locals. 
 Today's events only confirm what we've been sayin'.&equo; 
 The President and Chief Executive officer gazed into his Scotch. 
 He was still uneasy about Mueller. 
 He remembered what he had put on his personal  qualities'  file: &bquo;Judgement not always reliable in the political and commercial area&equo;. 
 He looked long and hard at the younger executive as if trying to sum him up. 
 &bquo;OK, Randy,&equo; he said after a long pause. 
 &bquo;Go ahead. 
 The Committee agreed in principle to your initial proposals. 
 Not unanimously, mark you, but the majority. 
 Put up a detailed proposal for consideration when we get back, and we'll see if they buy the specifics.&equo;  
 That same evening Mark Sanders was dining alone in Istanbul after a satisfactory series of meetings with the local Managing Director and the Turkish Minister of Economic Affairs. 
 He had declined an invitation to dinner, as the stabbing pains in his head had been getting steadily worse throughout the day. 
 They were now blindingly bad. 
 He placed his unfinished cigar in the ash tray and rose from the table, leaving his brandy untouched. 
 He had decided to go to bed early. 
 After lying in a hot bath for an unusually long time, he stretched out on the bed, eyes closed, hoping that the pains would go away. 
 But he couldn't get the thought out of his head that in London, that very day, Muldoon and Klepner had given HIS Ten Year Plan to Cocello. 
 The more he thought of the two carpet-baggers standing up at the podium, the more intense the pains in his head became. 
 He put a hand to his forehead to ease the pressure. 
 Nate couldn't possibly have believed that the Turkish problem was more important than the European Plan. 
 Not in a million years. 
 In which case the reason was blindingly obvious. 
 Muldoon had more than hinted at what was happening. 
 Detroit was paving the way for Mueller to take over and run the whole bloody show from America. 
 That's what he had always wanted to do, and Klepner was his advance guard. 
 His mole. 
 His trained pet poodle who had been sent to Europe to reconnoitre the scene and steal Mark's clothes. 
 He would then take over the European  Components'  planning activity when everything was centralised in Detroit. 
 He thumped his pillow with his fist. 
 The bastards are at it again, he said to himself, vividly recalling the Steiner incident in New York. 
 Only this time it's curtains. 
 He was finished. 
 This had got to be the end of the road. 
 He stared at the ceiling. 
 How would he and Georgina change their lifestyle after all  those years as a corporate executive? 
 How would they live? 
 What would happen when the monthly cheque was no longer paid into the bank? 
 What about the mortgage and the school fees? 
 They go on for ever. 
 Well, until sixty-five, and that's a hell of a long way away. 
 What would they do in the interim? 
 They'd have to move to a smaller house, that's for sure. 
 My God, how would he tell Georgina? 
 It would break her heart to leave the lovely old stone barn in Buckinghamshire. 
 How could he keep Andrew at Agricultural college? 
 Well they would, somehow or other. 
 They'd done it for Adam and Christopher and they'd do it for him. 
 But how would he break the news to Georgina that he'd let her down after all these years? 
 He fell asleep, but the pains in his head were still there when he awoke in the morning. 
 Clem Bunker was in a rare-rage. 
 He had completely lost his temper when he had heard the news that Clasper had taken the giant Merseyside plant out on strike. 
 Bunker had received the message from a convener at one of the Midlands plants, who was also hopping mad. 
 And so, he said, were all the shop stewards at his plant, who were expressing the view that, once again, the Merseysiders were taking the law into their own hands, breaking national agreements and overturning official union policy. 
 The  Midlands'  shop stewards knew it was only a question of time before the strike affected supplies to their own plants and those in the South, jeopardising the recovery plan which had been producing such vast improvements in performance. 
 Morale had been at its highest for years, up to the moment that the news had reached them that Merseyside was out. 
 &bquo;Clasper's behind this!&equo; 
 Bunker was furious. 
 &bquo;He was dead against the plan and now he's doing his damnedest to wreck it.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's what everyone round here is saying as well,&equo; the convener agreed. 
 &bquo;It's his Commie mate who got the chop. 
 And nobody believes Clasper's version of the story. 
 It's all too bloody coincidental.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that really the majority view at your plant?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, it's not often the majority express themselves without  some prompting from the shop stewards,&equo; the convener replied, &bquo;but in this instance the reaction was instantaneous. 
 We heard the news over the radio at lunch break and I tell you, Clem, my lads are really up in arms. 
 Nobody believes this cock and bull story about the sacking incident. 
 They all know that Clasper's behind it. 
 Who the hell does he think he's kiddin'? 
 He's certainly not kiddin' my blokes.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that what the majority are really saying at your plant?&equo; asked Bunker. 
 &bquo;Loud and clear,&equo; replied the convener. 
 &bquo;They are sick to the eyeballs with Clasper and his bloody political conscience strikes. 
 A hell of a roar went up in the canteen at lunch break when one of the shop stewards said that Clasper would go on fighting on behalf of the workers until every bloody one of them had lost their jobs. 
 That's what my lads think about Mister bloody Clasper. 
 The question is, Clem, what are you going to do about it?&equo; 
 &bquo;I&equo; m going to contact all the plant conveners, when I put this phone down, and call an emergency meeting, Bunker told him. 
 &bquo;In the meantime, get the shop stewards at your plant to take an accurate reading of the majority viewpoint without influencing the men either way. 
 Initially, I want the gut feel of the members. 
 We can take final readings and decide on an official union line when we know all the facts. 
 I'm going to ask the other plant conveners to do the same.&equo; 
 &bquo;OK, Clem,, the convener said quickly. 
 &bquo;Will do.&equo; 
 That evening, Bunker phoned Peters at The Inn on the Park to tell him that he had called an emergency meeting of plant conveners to help resolve the Merseyside problem. 
 He was dismayed by the American's response. 
 There was more than a hint of weary resignation in his reply. 
 All the old fighting spirit and enthusiasm had gone. 
 &bquo;Yeah. 
 OK Clem. 
 Thanks for ringing. 
 and thanks for all the effort that you have put in personally. 
 Just sorry it has turned out this way.&equo; 
 He sounded like a beaten man. 
 News of the strike made headlines in all the British newspapers. 
 It was also given in-depth coverage on television and radio that evening, with News at Ten  running it as the lead story in the first half of the programme and coming back to it again in the second.  
 Clasper was interviewed outside the giant Merseyside plant and predictably blamed management for deliberately provoking the strike. 
 &bquo;Are you really saying that the company is to blame for the strike?&equo; the man with the microphone asked, thrusting it under Clasper's chin. 
 &bquo;Well you don't think my lads would be out here just for the bloody exercise, do you?&equo; 
 Clasper demanded sarcastically. 
 &bquo;Course they're to blame. 
 Stands to reason. 
 And my lads are staying out until Management reinstates the innocent victim.&equo; 
 And is that the only thing which would influence you to call off this strike, which is obviously doing great harm to the company and the country?&equo; the interviewer asked. 
 &bquo;Nothing more and nothing less,&equo; replied Clasper. 
 &bquo;I'm already havin' to ask the lads to exercise great restraint over this particular issue. 
 They want me to insist that the company sacks the foreman before they go back, but I've told 'em I won't be a party to victimisation either way.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thank you, Mr Clasper,&equo; said the interviewer. 
 &bquo;Now back to the studio.&equo; 
 And there the newsreader told the British people that efforts had been made to obtain an interview with the local Plant Manager, who had declined to comment. 
 The President of United Motors &mdash; who was in London at that moment &mdash; had also declined to comment on a local issue which, he had said was a matter for local management. 
 The inference viewers gained was that management was to blame in one way or another. 
 When he returned to the States, Mueller lost no time in carrying out Cocello's instructions to direct the phase-out of UK vehicle operations from Detroit, and to prepare detail plans to centralise European and world planning activities. 
 His first step was to request that all copies of the European Vehicle and Components&equo; Plan be withdrawn from circulation. 
 Having thus effectively stopped the Plans dead in their tracks, he then proceeded, in the name of the President, to dry  up the outward flow of all planning information from Detroit, so that, from that moment on, only he and members of the world planning group would be aware of what was going on, worldwide, at the planning stage. 
 Mueller thus gained immediate planning control of world wide operations, even before he had formally received top management approval to proceed. 
 The President had given Mueller an inch, but he had already taken a mile. 
 This tactic was not unusual in the Corporation. 
 Mueller had simply used his privileged position to advise the General Directors that he was operating on the instructions of the President. 
 He would use that authority to his own personal advantage.  
 Mark Sanders returned from Istanbul feeling exhausted, depressed and ill. 
 The blinding headaches he had been experiencing in recent weeks were taking their toll, and he looked grey and drawn when he arrived home. 
 Lately, Georgina had been worried by the general deterioration in his appearance. 
 But now she was visibly shocked by the drained and haggard-looking face which kissed her. 
 She wanted to say, &bquo;You look awful, darling,&equo; but decided against it. 
 &bquo;What kind of a trip have you had?&equo; she asked instead. 
 &bquo;Oh, not too bad,&equo; he replied wearily. 
 She took his suitcase and placed it at the bottom of the stairs. 
 &bquo;Come into the kitchen, and we will have a cup of tea. 
 I've so much news to tell you. 
 All sorts of things seem to have happened while you have been away this time.&equo; 
 Mark smiled thinly and kissed her affectionately on the cheek. 
 &bquo;Tell me about it,&equo; he replied. 
 &bquo;I could do with a good laugh.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why darling? 
 What's the matter? 
 Trouble at t'mill?&equo; 
 Mark slipped an arm around her slim waist as they walked from the hall into the kitchen. 
 &bquo;Perhaps it's old Montezuma's revenge,&equo; he replied. 
 &bquo;Must be getting too old for this globe-trotting lark, or else my mis-spent youth is catching up on me. 
 I'm rapidly coming to the conclusion that this is a young man's game.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nonsense, Mark. 
 You're still a young man&hellip; well, youngish.&equo; she said, trying to tease him out of his apparent lethargy and depression. 
 &bquo;Let's have that cup of tea and you'll feel better.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, fill the cup, what boots it to repeat, how time is slipping underneath our feet,&equo; he quoted with a sigh.  
 &bquo;Oh darling. 
 What a sad sack we are today. 
 Is that how you feel? 
 Shall I accompany you on the violin? 
 Now let me tell you all the news.&equo; 
 She poured the tea. 
 &bquo;Christopher has been promoted after only one year. 
 The Chairman of the company told him he was most impressed with the contribution he's made to the business, and that he could go right to the top if he keeps it up. 
 I knew you'd be delighted to hear that.&equo; 
 She sipped her tea. 
 &bquo;Next&hellip; 
 I've found a super husband for Harriet. 
 Champion of the breed at Crufts last year. 
 Lives in the next village, believe it or not. 
 Absolutely magnificent dog.&equo; 
 &bquo;Lucky Harriet,&equo; said Mark. 
 &bquo;What else? 
 Ah yes; a Secretary at the Ministry of Industry wants you to ring him. 
 Seems they want you to address the European Commission on European industrial development. 
 In Dublin, I think she said. 
 Something about the factors which influence multi-nat location decisions. 
 Anyway, you'll know what it means when you see it. 
 I've written it all down. 
 Oh and yes&hellip; a chap from Conservative Central Office rang up to say they'd like to know if you would be prepared to stand for the European Parliament. 
 He sounded somewhat to the right of Genghis Khan. 
 I said I didn't think so, as you were rather busy, but I'd pass the message on. 
 Hope I did the right thing. 
 I said you never knew where you were from one week to the next. 
 He said that would do nicely. 
 Just like the American Express advertisement. 
 Perfect credentials apparently, for European parliamentarians. 
 &bquo;Now what next? 
 The Chicheley-Smythes have bought an absolutely super villa in Sardinia and say we could rent it if we'd like to. 
 I've seen the photographs. 
 Gorgeous location overlooking a quiet bay. 
 It sleeps ten with a permanent staff of three. 
 Only a thousand pounds a week, yacht included. 
 I'd love that for two or three weeks, wouldn't you?&equo; 
 &bquo;We wouldn't want to stint ourselves,&equo; Mark said facetiously, &bquo;four or five, I should think&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;And we could take the family,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;We haven't had a family holiday for years. 
 I'd like that. 
 But we can talk about that later. 
 And I've decided to take up riding again. 
 Don't ask me why. 
 Just got the urge, that's all.&equo;  
 She gave him a beautiful smile, which lit her lovely face. 
 &bquo;Well, how's that for starters?&equo; she asked. 
 He had heard that expression before. 
 &bquo;Is there more?, 
 &bquo;Now let me see. 
 Ah, yes&hellip; 
 Andrew's coming home for the weekend so I thought it would be nice to have a drinks party. 
 I've invited the Bunkers, if that's all right. 
 I like Clem and Gwen and the girls would be nicer company for Andrew.&equo; 
 &bquo;Fine,&equo; agreed Mark without much enthusiasm. 
 &bquo;If Clem can make it, that is. 
 I heard about this latest Merseyside strike in Istanbul. 
 Could finish off the UK vehicle division,&equo; he said forlornly, &bquo;and Don Peters,&equo; he added, shaking his head. 
 Some of the stupid bastards won't be satisfied until we no longer make a single vehicle in the UK. 
 Then I suppose they'll say it's all management's fault, and people will believe them. 
 And who the hell IS management?&equo; he demanded, his voice rising. 
 &bquo;People like me, who've worked their guts out to expand the business while the militant bastards have been working their guts out to destroy it.&equo; 
 Georgina was nodding agreement. 
 She patted his wrist. 
 &bquo;I'm quite sure you're right, dear. 
 But we weren't talking about the motor industry and the never-ending management-union saga. 
 We were talking about Andrew coming home for the weekend and having the Bunkers round for drinks. 
 And I do wish you wouldn't swear like that when you talk about business. 
 You never used to swear, you know. 
 At least, you didn't when you were with me. 
 But you do now, darling, and I do wish you wouldn't. 
 You are becoming so hard and bitter and it's not really like you.&equo; 
 Mark sighed. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry. 
 It's just&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's just that there really is trouble at t'mill,&equo; she said quietly. 
 &bquo;That's it, isn't it? 
 You weren't going to tell me. 
 You were just going to worry about it alone. 
 You let me go rabitting on&hellip;. 
 He hugged her; kissed her cheek. 
 &bquo;I'm not sure yet that there really is something to worry about.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you think there is.&equo; 
 He nodded. 
 &bquo;I have a horrible feeling that UM is about to reorganise  world-wide planning operations and, if that happens, it's curtains for the European organisation and for me.&equo; 
 &bquo;Curtains?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;What exactly would that mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;Early retirement.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mark, you're not serious!, 
 &bquo;I think it could be on the cards. 
 They could transfer me to Detroit, or somewhere. 
 I don't know, but I don't like the signs.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Mark,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;They wouldn't do that to you. 
 They just couldn't. 
 Not after all you've done for the Corporation. 
 They couldn't be that unfair and ruthless.&equo; 
 His expression was wry. 
 &bquo;My dear, they'll do whatever they feel is necessary to do. 
 Sentiment, loyalty, service and track record, none of these things will come into it.&equo; 
 Georgina took him in her arms and kissed him on the lips. 
 &bquo;It's all so ridiculous that we're not going to even think about it any more,&equo; she said firmly, hiding her fears. 
 &bquo;Now come into the garden,&equo; she added, smiling. 
 &bquo;I want to show you the clematis. 
 It's a mass of colour.&equo; 
 Lying in bed that evening, they talked a lot about their life together. 
 They recalled their first days. 
 The county ball. 
 The Paul Jones and the emotional somersaults when the music stopped and they came face to face for the very first time. 
 The wedding. 
 The birth of their first son, Adam, and then Christopher and Andrew. 
 The children growing up with all the laughter and tears. 
 Schooldays and the void they both felt when the boys went off to boarding school, followed by the joy unconfined when they came home at the end of term. 
 Mark's promotions and progress up the company ladder. 
 New and changing homes. 
 Friends lost and friends gained. 
 Family achievements and disappointments. 
 Notwithstanding current problems which they discussed lightly, it had all been wonderful. 
 They fell asleep in the early hours of the morning, holding hands.  
 The next day Mark arrived back at UM's European headquarters in London and received an early call from Muldoon. 
 He went down the airless corridor to his Boss's office, said hello to the secretary, and walked into the large oak-panelled room which was as big as the lobby of many a sizeable hotel. 
 Muldoon rose immediately from his enormous black leather chair to greet him, coming from behind the vast desk with hand outstretched. 
 &bquo;Hello Mark. 
 Have a good trip?&equo; 
 He took the Englishman by the arm and ushered him toward the easy chairs arranged around a long rectangular coffee table. 
 Instinctively, Mark felt uneasy. 
 Why the hand on the arm and the over-friendly approach? 
 Muldoon never emerged from behind his desk to greet colleagues. 
 Only visitors and VIPs got that special reception. 
 Muldoon poured the coffee. 
 &bquo;How did the Planning meeting go?&equo; 
 Mark asked him. 
 &bquo;What was Nate's reaction? 
 Did he and the Committee go along with my proposals?&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;It went fine,&equo; Muldoon said. 
 He seemed somewhat uneasy. 
 &bquo;Klepner did a good job.&equo; 
 &bquo;How did he handle the questions?&equo; 
 Mark asked. 
 &bquo;He doesn't have the inside knowledge to deal with questions.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, OK really. 
 I handled some and so did Mueller. 
 But Klepner did OK. 
 He didn't let the side down.&equo; 
 Mark nodded. 
 &bquo;What was Mueller doing answering questions. 
 He was there to ASK them. 
 He doesn't know the inside track any more than Klepner.&equo; 
 &bquo;Maybe not, but he soon will,&equo; Muldoon replied quietly. 
 &bquo;And what does that mean?&equo; 
 Muldoon seemed to be taking a long time over his coffee. 
 He evaded Mark's eyes. 
 &bquo;He's goin' to head-up world planning operations from Detroit.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's already co-ordinating the regional plans to provide a world picture. 
 So what's changed?&equo; 
 Deep down he knew. 
 &bquo;He's not going to just co-ordinate and consolidate any longer,&equo; Muldoon said, with increasing nervousness. 
 &bquo;He's gonna  plan, direct and control worldwide planning operations from Detroit, including the regional planning functions.&equo; 
 Mark's expression was one of faked incredulity. 
 His gut feelings had been right. 
 &bquo;You've got to be joking!&equo; he scoffed. 
 &bquo;I know that's what Mueller's always wanted, but Nate and the Executive Committee would never fall for that bloody empire-building game! 
 The regions are far too big and complex to be handled from Detroit and even if they were foolish enough to believe that they could do it more effectively &mdash; which they can't &mdash; they would be crazy to try.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know, Mark, I know,&equo; Muldoon said. 
 &bquo;But that's what they're gonna do.&equo; 
 &bquo;It will boomerang,&equo; the Englishman said heatedly. 
 &bquo;Overseas Governments and local nationals just won't stand for it, particularly when they get to know what's going on. 
 That's one corporate plan that can't win, not in the long term. 
 &bquo;I know, Mark. 
 But they think they can run everything from Detroit and that's the way the organisation is going to be restructured. 
 They are working on it right now. 
 We will know the details in a few weeks&equo; time. 
 Couple of months at the latest.&equo; 
 Mark said quietly: 
 &bquo;And how does that affect the European organisation? 
 &bquo;The organisation will be wound up. 
 I'm taking early retirement.&equo; 
 &bquo;And me?&equo; 
 Muldoon shrugged. 
 &bquo;Not certain yet. 
 But my guess is early retirement too, unless you're prepared to go back to divisional work. 
 Local MD perhaps?&equo; 
 The Englishman snorted. 
 &bquo;You know I can't go back. 
 Who the hell can? 
 In any case, you know as well as I do that the MDs are always American.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, there won't be any European job functions, that's for sure,&equo; Muldoon said. 
 &bquo;There'll be a direct link between Detroit and the line managers in each country, with Detroit calling the shots.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't they realise they're playing with political dynamite?  
 Mark demanded. 
 &bquo;Mueller won't give a damn about the effect of a corporate plan on Europe and on individual countries. 
 If he wants to import vehicles or components from Taiwan or Singapore or Hong Kong into Europe, he'll go ahead and do it, regardless of the economic consequences for the European countries concerned. 
 The only thing you can be sure of is that US interest will always come first. 
 Oh, and there's one more thing you can be sure of,&equo; he added sourly. 
 &bquo;They won't plan to supply the US market from imports. 
 You can bet your bottom dollar on that! 
 Jesus wept!&equo; he continued, hackles rising. 
 &bquo;Mueller will have the power to make or break whole areas of Europe. 
 He's the last guy in the world who should be given such power. 
 The bloody man's power drunk already.&equo; 
 He was angry and bitter. 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; Muldoon agreed sadly. 
 &bquo;Then what are you and Clancy doing about it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Look, Mark,&equo; Muldoon said forlornly &bquo;What's the point? 
 The wheels have already been set in motion. 
 We're not gonna change anyone's mind. 
 You know that.&equo; 
 His tone was abject. 
 &bquo;Sorry you're takin' it so bad,&equo; he added miserably. 
 &bquo;How else should I take it?&equo; 
 Mark demanded. 
 &bquo;It's my life which is about to go down the plughole. 
 I'm not an American on a brief overseas assignment. 
 I've spent my entire working life in the European components&equo; business. 
 I've grown up in it. 
 It's in my blood. 
 I've built plants and managed them. 
 Designed products and marketed and sold them. 
 When I was an apprentice there were two component plants in Europe, and now there are seventeen, and I've had a hand in establishing the last twelve. 
 What the hell do you expect me to say? 
 Oh, is that what they are proposing to do? 
 Well bully for Mueller and the Corporation? 
 I'll go and collect my hat and coat!&equo; 
 &bquo;I know how you feel, Mark,&equo; Muldoon said sadly. 
 &bquo;Do you, Pat? 
 Do you? 
 You're sixty-one and have been looking forward to retirement. 
 I'm fifty and have a long way to go. 
 I don't think you can see things the way I see them. 
 &bquo;Well, perhaps not,&equo; Muldoon agreed. 
 &bquo;But I can understand how you feel.&equo; 
 The Englishman nodded and poured himself more coffee. 
 &bquo;So what's going to happen to the European Plan?&equo; he asked.  
 &bquo;Mueller will drive it from Detroit, with one or two amendments agreed at the EPC meeting,&equo; Muldoon told him. 
 &bquo;What amendments?&equo; 
 &bquo;No further plant investment in the UK.&equo; 
 &bquo;I suppose Mueller saw to that,&equo; Mark said sarcastically. 
 &bquo;He really hates our guts! 
 God help the British plants under the new regime!&equo; 
 Muldoon shook his head. 
 &bquo;No, it wasn't that. 
 It was the strike at Merseyside. 
 That was the last straw as far as Nate was concerned. 
 Up until that news hit the Committee, Don had won the day with his UK Vehicle Division proposals. 
 But as soon as Nate heard about the latest strike, that was it. 
 End of story. 
 He instructed Mueller to phase-out vehicle manufacture in the UK.&equo; 
 Mark nodded. 
 &bquo;How did Don take it? 
 He was beginning to win through.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's very upset. 
 Naturally. 
 It's the first time in his career he hasn't come out on top. 
 Mueller is taking over the plan, and Don is being transferred back to the States. 
 Public relations job or something similar. 
 Just think of it, a man of his talent and ability stooging around the media.&equo; 
 &bquo;So when's he going back to the States?&equo; 
 Mark said. 
 &bquo;It won't be announced for a week or so, but he's already been told. 
 He'll fly out inside the month.&equo; 
 &bquo;And what do you and I do now? 
 Mark enquired. 
 &bquo;Start emptying the files?&equo; 
 Muldoon made a face. 
 &bquo;Afraid so. 
 Klepner will take over the files and ship them back to the States. 
 He'll be Mueller's European components&equo; Planning Manager in Detroit.&equo; 
 &bquo;Klepner?&equo; 
 Mark uttered in mock astonishment. 
 &bquo;The man knows nothing about Europe. 
 He's a novice. 
 A bloody charlatan!&equo; 
 &bquo;I know it sounds crazy, Mark,&equo; Muldoon said. 
 &bquo;But there it is. 
 We have no choice in the matter. 
 I was instructed to tell you, and I have. 
 New York and Detroit will come up with an attractive separation package, you can be sure of that. 
 They've already told me you'll get the maximum terms permitted under British law. 
 The Corporation wants to do the right thing by you.&equo;  
 The two men rose from the table together. 
 &bquo;Sure. 
 We have no choice in the matter,&equo; said the Englishman. 
 &bquo;There has to be losers as well as winners,, said the American. 
 &bquo;I guess we're both losers, Mark.&equo; 
 The Englishman returned to his own palatial office and sat with his head in hands. 
 Another of his blinding headaches had developed and he felt a tight sensation in his chest, which made breathing very painful and difficult. 
 His secretary entered the room. 
 Can I get you a coffee, Mr Sanders? 
 You don't look at all well. 
 Shall I get the doctor?&equo; 
 He looked up and smiled. 
 &bquo;No thank you Millie. 
 I'm all right. 
 Just a headache. 
 Be OK in a minute. 
 Would love a cup of coffee though. 
 &bquo;Are you sure I shouldn't get a doctor?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;No thank you. 
 I'll be OK. 
 It's only a headache.&equo; 
 Millie had her reasons for being concerned. 
 The petticoat Mafia at the top of the organisation always knew what was going on, often before the top executives themselves. 
 Millie and the secretaries of Pat Muldoon and Clancy McGillicuddy were all close friends. 
 They had got together over the weekend to discuss the implications of the confidential letter the two Americans had received from Randy Mueller on behalf of Nate Cocello. 
 Major changes were afoot which affected their respective bosses. 
 By the time Mark reached home that evening, the pains in his head were excruciating. 
 He decided against telling Georgina about his meeting with Muldoon. 
 He would wait for the right moment. 
 This wasn't it.  
 Mark had a very full fortnight ahead, for which he was grateful. 
 It gave him little time to think of his own problems. 
 First, there was a meeting in Whitehall of the Economic Planning Council, followed by the conference at Trinity College Dublin, at which he had been invited to speak on the subject of European investment. 
 He had accepted the invitation gladly, knowing full well that it would be his last opportunity to speak in public as a European executive of United Motors. 
 He hoped to make it a fitting swan-song. 
 At the Economic Planning Council he had expected to see Clem Bunker, but he was absent, holding his own meeting with the vehicle plant conveners in an attempt to determine the truth about the sacking incident and to resolve the dispute. 
 What he didn't know, couldn't know, was that nothing he could now do would make any difference. 
 There had been trouble on Merseyside just once too often, and muddleheaded militants who believed that revolution was spawned in deprivation and poverty would be able to hold a little holiday in their hearts, secure in the knowledge that several more thousand British workers had been gulled into inflicting poverty and deprivation upon themselves. 
 Opening the meeting of the Economic Planning Council, the Chairman, Lord Hampshire, surprised members by announcing that the Prime Minister intended to sit in on the transport debate, which was the subject of a White Paper about to be discussed on the floor of the House. 
 As this was the first item on the agenda, the Prime Minister made her  appearance at ten thirty-three, immediately after the Chairman had made his announcement. 
 After the usual preliminaries and courtesies from the Chair, the Minister of Transport outlined the Government's proposals before the Chairman threw the subject open for discussion. 
 But, before doing so, he asked the Prime Minister if she wished to say a few words. 
 The &bquo;Iron Lady&equo; as she was called, smiled the steely smile which was so familiar on the television screen and in the press. 
 &bquo;I am here to listen and learn, my Lord Chairman,&equo; she said in her clear and authoritative voice. 
 &bquo;But I am particularly interested to know if the United Kingdom incurs a significant transportation cost penalty on its exports to Europe which puts this country at a commercial and economic disadvantage to the rest of the Community. 
 I am also keen to know,&equo; she continued, &bquo;if any such cost penalties operate to our disadvantage when European investment decisions are made, in particular those international mobile investment decisions which are made by the multinationals. 
 I understand that Mr Sanders has accepted an invitation to address the European Commission on the subject in Dublin, and I look forward to hearing his observations.&equo; 
 Lord Hampshire had folded a piece of paper which was being passed around the table. 
 It arrived in front of Mark with his name on it. 
 He unfolded the paper. 
 &bquo;Don't put your pads on, just yet,&equo; it said. 
 &bquo;Want you to come in lower down the batting order.&equo; 
 It was signed &bquo;H&equo;. 
 The Chairman of the National  Docks'  Authority opened the batting by reviewing plans to meet the ever-growing volume of  docks'  traffic, particularly the substantial growth in roll-on, roll-off between Britain and the continent. 
 The Chief Highways Planner followed, outlining the Government's intentions to provide further motorway links between industrial centres and the ports. 
 He also described the various channel tunnel options currently being studied by the Ministry. 
 The rail, airways and waterways chiefs then outlined their plans, before the Chairman threw the subject open to the Council members. 
 Several members then questioned the planning assumption  of the Chief Planning Officers, making pertinent observations based on their own particular knowledge and experience. 
 Mark Sanders was called by the Chairman after an hour's discussion. 
 &bquo;Now let's have a multi-national view point,&equo; he said cheerfully. 
 &bquo;Particularly on the points raised by the Prime Minister. 
 Mark would you like to face the next ball?&equo; 
 Mark smiled and nodded. 
 &bquo;Before we begin, Mr Sanders,&equo; the Prime Minister said, warmly, &bquo;will you tell me which hat you will be wearing today? 
 Your European hat, or the British one?&equo; she smiled a thin smile. 
 The Chairman smiled. 
 Mark smiled. 
 Everyone smiled. 
 &bquo;Whichever one you wish me to wear, Prime Minister,&equo; he replied. 
 &bquo;Can we see you in both?&equo; she rejoined. 
 &bquo;Then we can judge which one we prefer.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm afraid I don't look particularly good in either,&equo; Mark said, &bquo;but, putting on my British hat first: yes, Prime Minister, the United Kingdom is at a considerable disadvantage when multi-nationals consider investment locations in Europe. 
 The transport cost penalty, to which you referred, varies of course with the nature of the product being manufactured, and ranges from two per cent to twenty per cent in the motor industry.&equo; 
 &bquo;So why is it called a penalty?&equo; the Prime Minister asked. 
 &bquo;That's right, isn't it? 
 Transport cost penalty?&equo; she added with a pained expression. 
 &bquo;Yes, Prime Minister.&equo; 
 &bquo;But why? 
 Surely the expression suggests that we are being penalised into paying more than our EEC partners. 
 How can this be? 
 We ship exports to Europe and it costs X pounds. 
 Our partners in the EEC ship their exports to us, and again it costs the same X pounds. 
 So where does the penalty come in? 
 &bquo;It comes in,&equo; said Mark, &bquo;when you consider exports as a proportion of total output. 
 A European plant will probably sell around four fifths of its total output on the European mainland, principally within the so-called Golden Triangle countries of West Germany, France, Belgium and Holland at the centre of the market. 
 The remaining one fifth of output will be exported to the long-distance peripheral markets of  the United Kingdom and Italy, etcetera, so when you export from a UK manufacturing base you ship four fifths of the output over relatively longer distances, hence the UK transport cost penalty.&equo; 
 The Prime Minister was nodding agreement long before Mark had finished. 
 &bquo;Yes, I see. 
 But doesn't that mean that most of the European investment will always tend to go to the centrally placed Golden Triangle countries who occupy this privileged position rather than to the United Kingdom and other peripheral countries who are in less favoured areas? 
 &bquo;Yes, it does mean just that,&equo; Mark said. 
 &bquo;But such a situation simply strengthens the strong, and weakens the weak, doesn't it?&equo; the Prime Minister said, eyebrows raised. 
 &bquo;How does a large industrial country, such as the UK rebuild and expand its industrial base, and correct a worsening balance of trade in manufactured products, if investment location decisions by the multi-nationals go against it on such grounds?, 
 &bquo;I am afraid, Prime Minister, the answer is that we have to be more efficient than our European competitors.&equo; 
 Mark answered in a matter of fact voice. 
 Transport costs do impose a penalty. 
 We've got to live with it. 
 And beat it. 
 We've got to absorb these costs by being super-efficient.&equo; 
 Again the Prime Minister was nodding her agreement. 
 &bquo;But,&equo; Mark continued, transport costs are only one of the factors which have placed British industry at a disadvantage in recent years.&equo; 
 &bquo;And what are the others, Mr Sanders?&equo; 
 &bquo;If you'll forgive me saying so, Prime Minister,&equo; Mark replied cautiously, &bquo;successive British Governments and the trade unions haven't exactly helped.&equo; 
 The steely smile was glimpsed briefly. 
 &bquo;I think that's something you are really going to have to explain, Mr Sanders,&equo; she said quizzically in a pained expression. 
 &bquo;If you will allow me to say so, Prime Minister,&equo; he continued, &bquo;Britain has consistently lost out because&hellip;.&equo;  
 He had been speaking for some five minutes or more with force and conviction, carried away by the things which concerned him greatly. 
 Now, suddenly, he had an uneasy feeling that he had allowed himself to go a little &bquo;over the top&equo;. 
 At these meetings viewpoints were expressed in a suitably detached manner. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid I've gone on a bit, My Lord Chairman,&equo; he said apologetically. 
 &bquo;I think I've said enough. 
 Probably too much.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not at all,&equo; put in the Prime Minister, reassuringly. 
 &bquo;It's only when you let your hair down that others can see the real person hiding under the hat. 
 I personally have found your candour very refreshing. 
 It's such a change to hear someone say what he really believes&hellip;.&equo; and a warm smile blazed. 
 &bquo;Almost never happens in politics.&equo; 
 The laughter was general. 
 &bquo;Now Mr Sanders,&equo; she continued, &bquo;can we ask you to wear your European hat? 
 Spain and Austria are peripheral countries aren't they? 
 So why is it that your company, and certain other major multi-nationals, plan to invest heavily in those countries?, 
 She cocked her head to one side after she had posed the question. 
 &bquo;Spain erects huge barriers which make it difficult, if not impossible, for vehicle and component imports to enter that country,&equo; Mark said. 
 &bquo;So if my company wishes to supply the domestic market of this large and expanding population, it has no alternative but to manufacture from within the country itself. 
 Spanish rules and regulations then determine what percentage of total output will be exported and what the local component content will be. 
 &bquo;Similarly, the Austrian Government has made it clear that unless multi-nationals manufacture vehicles or components within the country to correct its trade deficit, then it will be obliged to take appropriate steps to close its domestic markets to their products.&equo; 
 The Prime Minister clasped her hands together. 
 &bquo;How very interesting. 
 And pray do tell me which countries will have to accept the exports of motor vehicles or  components from Spain, say, as a result of anything which might be agreed between United Motors and the Spanish Government?&equo; 
 As Mark began to reply, she said the first name with him, nodding her head the while. 
 &bquo;Great Britain&hellip; of course, of course. 
 And is that free and fair European trade, Mr Sanders?&equo; 
 She asked with more than a hint of sarcasm in her voice. 
 &bquo;My company doesn't make Government rules and regulations, Prime Minister,&equo; he replied. 
 &bquo;We comply with them or we are excluded from these markets.&equo; 
 &bquo;Quite so. 
 But would you accept that such discriminatory rules and regulations operate to this country's clear disadvantage?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course,&equo; Mark agreed. 
 &bquo;Without question.&equo; 
 The first lady nodded and went on nodding for several seconds in quiet contemplation before putting two further questions to him concerning European regional incentives, Government grants and subsidies and their cost distorting influence on investment location decisions. 
 Mark answered in the traditional matter-of-fact manner, parading all the relevant factors and letting the facts speak for themselves. 
 The Prime Minister departed a short time later with the Ministers of Transport and Energy escorted by Lord Hampshire. 
 In all, she had spent ninety minutes at the meeting. 
 During the lunch break, the Chairman took Mark to one side. 
 &bquo;Before she left, the PM told me how pleased she was that you were so frank. 
 And she's delighted that you have accepted the invitation to address the European Commission on the subject in Dublin. 
 She's looking for ways and means of redressing Britain's excessive contribution to the European budget which, as you know, is the highest in the community. 
 She believes that with your practical experience at the sharp end in Europe you will be able to provide much needed ammunition to support her appeal which is to be submitted to the Commission and the Council of Ministers.  
 The next day, Mark told Millie, his secretary, that the Corporation's plans for reorganisation would involve the elimination of regional management. 
 She had been expecting the news, because of her privileged position in the &bquo;Petticoat Mafia&equo; but it none-the-less visibly upset her. 
 She had what was generally regarded by other top secretaries as the most interesting job in European component operations, and took a great personal interest in her work. 
 As a long-service employee she knew from first-hand experience the contribution Mark had made to the expansion of the Corporation over the years. 
 &bquo;It isn't fair!&equo; she exclaimed angrily. 
 &bquo;Fair or not,&equo; Mark said, trying to speak lightly, &bquo;it's what's going to happen. 
 The parting of the ways, I'm afraid, after all these years. 
 But don't worry. 
 It has already been agreed that you'll be offered another position within the Corporation at the same salary.&equo; 
 The classically attractive forty-year-old secretary smiled uncertainly. 
 Her eyes brimmed. 
 &bquo;I'm not really concerned about myself. 
 It's so heartless and unfair after all you've done.&equo; 
 &bquo;That, as the Americans say,&equo; Mark told her wryly, &bquo;is how the cookie crumbles. 
 I suppose I'm going to miss the old firm after all these years. 
 And I'm going to miss you too,&equo; he added with a smile. 
 &bquo;We've worked together for a very long time.&equo; 
 She blinked and touched the corners of her eyes. 
 &bquo;Certainly have.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've really enjoyed working with you, Millie. 
 Thank you,&equo; Mark said with sincerity. 
 &bquo;And I've enjoyed working with you too. 
 I really have,&equo; she blurted, and hurried from the room into her own adjacent office. 
 And there, privately, she cried. 
 It was a demoralised Don Peters who drove away from The London Hilton and the all-American farewell party that had been laid on for him by Clancy McGillicuddy. 
 In response to the many toasts from his American colleagues he had made a light-hearted speech at dinner, which belied his deep disappointment at being sent back to  the States on a Public Relations assignment. 
 Sure, the newly created position with its impressive job title sounded important, but that was only to impress the media and the public. 
 It impressed no-one at corporate management level. 
 Don Peters had failed in his UK assignment and had effectively blown his chances of being moved further up the corporate ladder to a Vice Presidency and, maybe, to the Presidency itself. 
 He turned the car into Park Lane and drove quickly and skilfully through the maze of traffic converging on Marble Arch to emerge in the correct lane for the  Edgware  Road. 
 By his side, the magnificent cosmetically-engineered Eleanor graphically expressed what she thought of the farewell party through blazing eyes which darted alarmingly under false eyelashes. 
 She wasn't demoralised. 
 She was absolutely livid. 
 &bquo;Don't you ever put me through that situation again,&equo; she snarled through clenched teeth, tugging irritably at the sleeve of her mink jacket. 
 &bquo;I've never been so uncomfortable in all my life. 
 It was utter humiliation.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aw, come on now honey&hellip; it wasn't that bad,&equo; he replied dismally, pulling over to allow a wailing police car through the heavy late night traffic. 
 &bquo;Huh,&equo; she scoffed dismissively. 
 &bquo;Who's kiddin' who? 
 It was sheer bloody hell listening to all those fatuous nincompoops saying what a great guy you are. 
 Bullshit! 
 Sure you're a great guy in their eyes&hellip; you've done 'em all a favour by writing yourself off the promotion list. 
 Jeez, they couldn't conceal how pleased they were. 
 It made me want to throw up!&equo; 
 He screwed up his eyes with pain. 
 She was right of course, he knew that, but her words hurt just the same. 
 For the first time in his career he had failed to produce the goods and that hurt his pride. 
 He was also finished as a rising executive. 
 He had been shunted into a side-line and was now out of the mainstream traffic for good. 
 He knew that. 
 Trance-like he drove down the Edgware Road, responding to the multitudinous traffic lights with mechanical movements, while the agitated Eleanor continued to lash his unreceptive ear with a never-ending stream of abuse. 
 He reflected on the options which had been open to him,  one of which had led to his downfall. 
 Eleanor was right when she had said at the very beginning that he should have gone along with the corporate planning proposals to phase-out the UK Vehicle Division as a manufacturing operation. 
 He would have survived if he had accepted the plan in the first place and done what the Corporation had wanted him to do instead of putting forward his own counter proposals. 
 But that was easier said than done. 
 How could he have accepted such a proposal without letting down the fifty thousand people who worked for him? 
 He was their leader. 
 If he didn't fight on their behalf, who the hell would? 
 He switched on the headlights as the car entered the M1 at Brent Cross. 
 Eleanor's waspish voice ranted on and on. 
 &bquo;You should have seen the smug self satisfaction on the faces of those bitches as they lined up to kiss me,&equo; she rasped. 
 &bquo;So sorry, darling&equo;,&equo; she mimicked. 
 &bquo;We're really goin' to miss you both, we really are&hellip;.&equo; 
 The lousy hypocritical bastards! 
 I could have spit in their eyes!&equo; 
 She swung her head in his direction. 
 &bquo;Well for God's sake say something,&equo; she yelled. 
 &bquo;Even if it's only &bquo;Goodbye&equo;. 
 Don't you have any feelings for what I'm goin' through?&equo; 
 &bquo;Waal, I don't exactly feel too good myself,&equo; he replied morosely. 
 &bquo;Then, why did you do it?&equo; she cried bitterly. 
 &bquo;I said you were crazy not to go along with the Corporation's proposals, didn't I? 
 But you wouldn't listen to me. 
 Oh no! 
 Not you, you had to be the good guy. 
 You had to do a Custer. 
 Well, look where it's got you. 
 And do you think for one minute they care a damn about you? 
 You've got to be joking. 
 And what about me? 
 Do I go back to modelling for a living?&equo; 
 &bquo;What choice did I have?&equo; 
 Don Peters asked with a shrug. 
 &bquo;I couldn't have lived with myself if I hadn't put up a fight on behalf of the men.&equo; 
 &bquo;Waal, how are you gonna live with the Corporation execs from here on in?&equo; she asked caustically. 
 &bquo;And how am I gonna live with those two-faced blue-rinsed bitches back home? 
 We're both losers, Don, and everybody knows it. 
 How do we stomach that without choking?&equo; 
 He winced visibly. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry honey&hellip; 
 I know I've let you down&hellip; but we'll  get by.&equo; 
 &bquo;Get by&hellip;! 
 Get by!&equo; she yelled. 
 &bquo;I don't wanna get by, Don, I wanna get on. 
 You and I have always been winners. 
 I wanted you to make it to that goddamned fourteenth floor just as much as you did! 
 You could have made it too, if you hadn't been so stupid.&equo; 
 &bquo;How do you think I feel?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;But I had to make the effort, on behalf of the Division. 
 It would have worked too, if I'd been supported.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you weren't supported and it didn't work&hellip; so what have you achieved?&equo; she asked sarcastically. 
 &bquo;The Corporation isn't interested in effort&hellip; it's only interested in results. 
 You know that. 
 So where do we go from here?&equo; 
 &bquo;You tell me,&equo; he said flatly, with the air of a tired and unhappy man who has had enough. 
 And she did. 
 Over and over again. 
 It is said that nothing so concentrates a man's mind as the knowledge that he is to be hanged in the morning. 
 It was Sunday and Mark was working on the address he was to give at Trinity College, Dublin. 
 To his pleasant surprise he discovered that he was now able to think with an objective clarity which stemmed from the knowledge that he was now free for the first time in his life to speak his mind without fear or favour. 
 He had touched on some of the reasons why the United Kingdom had been outsmarted and disadvantaged when he had spoken before the Prime Minister at the meeting of the Economic Planning Council. 
 Now he would debate the subject in depth before a cosmopolitan audience of European and international politicians, bureaucrats, academic advisers and international managers. 
 Having dined &bquo;not wisely, but too well&equo; on one of Georgina's extra-special Sunday lunches, they were relaxing in the garden of their Buckinghamshire home when Mark broke the news.  
 In a very low-key, matter-of-fact way he described the meeting in Muldoon's office and explained Detroit's decision to eliminate regional management. 
 Throughout, Georgina remained calm and expressionless. 
 &bquo;Does that mean we shall see a great deal more of each other than we have in the past?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;I should think so,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Much more.&equo; 
 She smiled. 
 &bquo;I think I would like that.&equo; 
 Mark returned her smile. 
 &bquo;But what about our standard of living?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That will have to change if I don't land a job with much the same salary, and jobs like that don't exactly grow on trees, you know, particularly when you're over fifty.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nonsense, my dear,&equo; Georgina told him. 
 &bquo;You'll be snapped up in no time.&equo; 
 &bquo;But what if I'm not? 
 We're still faced with the mortgage and school fees. 
 They won't go away.&equo; 
 &bquo;In that event, we'll just have to lower our standard of living, won't we?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;It doesn't particularly bother me. 
 I don't crave all those materialistic things we used to crave when we were young. 
 Not any more. 
 Oh, I don't deny that it was all great fun striving to get to the top,&equo; she went on, &bquo;but we've done it, haven't we? 
 We've made the effort together. 
 And if we didn't get to the very top, well, it was near enough, wasn't it? 
 And what do we have to prove? 
 That we're both getting older? 
 That you still want to compete in a young man's race, even though it might kill you?&equo; 
 She gripped his hand. 
 &bquo;We've had a lot, and we've got a lot,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;We've lived good and bad times together and, no doubt, we'll share more. 
 I'm not afraid of the future and, knowing you as I do, nor should you be. 
 You'll win through. 
 You'll show them all!&equo; 
 She stood up and kissed him lightly on the lips. 
 &bquo;Now if you'd like me to tell you what I really think of United Motors after all these years, I'll do so.&equo; 
 she said. 
 And her voice took on a keener edge. 
 &bquo;But I don't really like swearing, and I'm sure you've already sworn quite enough for both of us. 
 So, for the moment, we'll just leave it at that shall we?&equo; 
 She linked an arm through his.  
 &bquo;Now let's take a walk over the fields with Honey and Harriet. 
 The countryside is looking beautiful right now.&equo;  
 The drinks party was evaporating slowly as guests said their goodbyes. 
 Clem Bunker was talking to Mark in the garden. 
 &bquo;Lovely home, Mark,&equo; said the union man. 
 &bquo;Will you be able to keep it?&equo; 
 Mark stopped in his tracks. 
 &bquo;So you've heard already,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Bush telegraph still as reliable as ever.&equo; 
 &bquo;Never fails,&equo; Clem replied, adding, &bquo;Don Peters told me. 
 He shook his head sadly. 
 &bquo;I really am sorry, Mark. 
 Do you know who is replacing Peters?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not a clue. 
 Hasn't been announced yet.&equo; 
 &bquo;Another American, I suppose?&equo; said the union man. 
 &bquo;Bound to be.&equo; 
 They sat at a circular wrought iron table shaded by a willow. 
 &bquo;Do you really think the Division could go out as a result of this latest strike? 
 Or is it just another &bquo;Cry Wolf situation?, asked Bunker after a long pause. 
 &bquo;The Division's been going out for the last fifteen years; slowly but surely.&equo; 
 said the ex-management man. 
 &bquo;This is the last straw.&equo; 
 The union man winced. 
 &bquo;To be honest, Clem, it started to go out twenty years ago when we failed to join the Common Market at the outset. 
 All the new industrial investment was switched to the continent. 
 The UK was effectively a back number from that moment. 
 The new plants on the continent then did a better productivity job, and that was that. 
 The more the UK Vehicle Division  restricted output, the more sure it headed for the final chop.&equo; 
 Clem Bunker was shaking his head, sadly. 
 &bquo;You know, Clem,&equo; Mark continued, &bquo;if we ARE going to fight our way back to the top again we are going to have to do it by our own collective efforts. 
 Nobody else is going to help us. 
 The Americans? 
 Ha&hellip;. 
 That's a laugh&hellip;. 
 The Russians? 
 Now there's an alternative for you. 
 The Workers&equo; Paradise that still can't feed its own people.&equo; 
 Mark raised his glass in salute. 
 &bquo;We've been fighting each other like spoilt kids instead of fighting the real enemy, our international competitors. 
 That&equo; s our stupidity,&equo; he said sadly as if unburdening himself of a great guilt. 
 &bquo;People like you and me,&equo; Clem replied with a smile, raising his glass. 
 Mark nodded and smiled back. 
 &bquo;Yes, I suppose so, Clem. 
 People like you and me. 
 At least we are builders, not bloody wreckers,&equo; he added in mitigation. 
 Bully for us. 
 Let s drink to that, Clem said. 
 &bquo;To the builders of this world.&equo; 
 Andrew and Vicky appeared on the terrace. 
 &bquo;Don't tell me that you two are talking shop,&equo; Andrew said. 
 &bquo;Don't you ever switch off?&equo; 
 &bquo;Andrew, my dear boy, your father and I are talking matters of great pith and moment,&equo; replied Clem. 
 &bquo;Ask your mother and Gwen to join us in the garden, will you Andrew?&equo; 
 Mark said. 
 &bquo;And bring another bottle with you. 
 This stuff is very more-ish. 
 Clem and I are getting addicted.&equo; 
 &bquo;Daddy tells me that you were apprentices together at United Motors,&equo; Vicky said. 
 She half-turned as her mother and Georgina joined them. 
 &bquo;Amazing isn't it, Mummy? 
 They even look alike, don't you think?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, I suppose they do&hellip;.&equo; 
 Gwen Bunker looked from one  man to the other, cocking her head to one side as she appraised the merchandise. 
 &bquo;Do tell us about your apprentice days, Daddy,&equo; said Vicky. 
 &bquo;What was it like? 
 Did you fight over the same girl friends? 
 &bquo;No&equo; said her Mother. 
 &bquo;They kept the fighting till later when they sat on the management-union joint negotiation committee. 
 I used to hear all about it. 
 Mark said this and I said that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nostalgia ain't what it used to be,&equo; interjected Andrew, quoting the latest college graffiti. 
 Clem grinned. 
 &bquo;Do you remember, Mark when you had to strip naked and tie that sack around your waist?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;Do I remember! 
 How could I ever forget!&equo; said Mark, holding a hand over his eyes. 
 &bquo;Whatever happened?&equo; asked Vicky. 
 Punctuated by interjections from Mark, Clem told the story of how Mark had fallen into a barrel of high viscosity oil while standing on the lid to get at another barrel with his hand pump. 
 He had been stripped naked in the oil store, where the incident had occurred during their very first month as apprentices, and his clothes triumphantly borne aloft to the plating shop to be washed in one of the hot water tanks. 
 When the news hit the factory floor, young girls were sent off to the stores with requisitions to get a good look at the loincloth apprentice. 
 One young girl who had stood giggling at the hapless Mark for more than ten minutes was told that she could go back to her department as she'd waited long enough. 
 When she objected that she shouldn't be sent back empty handed, she was shown what had been written on her requisition. 
 &bquo;Please supply: ONE LONG WEIGHT&equo;. 
 &bquo;But how did you come to go your separate ways?&equo; 
 Vicky asked as the laughter subsided. 
 &bquo;What influenced you both?, 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; said Clem. 
 &bquo;I know what influenced me. 
 It was a man named Arthur Billstock. 
 A toolmaker. 
 I was put to work with him on the same bench and he not only taught me toolmaking, he also taught me about the trade union movement and the kind of society he wanted to see.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, the local militant,&equo; said Andrew. 
 &bquo;No, not at all,&equo; Clem replied.  
 &bquo;In fact he was really a very quiet and rather reserved man, who preferred to keep in the background rather than hog the limelight. 
 We talked a lot during those months on the same bench together, and it was his influence which set me on the trade union path. 
 If it hadn't been for Arthur Billstock, I would probably have taken the same road as Mark. 
 That was the road we apprentices were expected to take. 
 Must have been crazy not to do so. 
 Might have ended up with a house like this,&equo; he added with a laugh. 
 &bquo;He's always been a bit funny in the head,&equo; joked Gwen. 
 How about you, Mark? 
 What influenced you? she added. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; said Mark, topping up their glasses. 
 &bquo;I suppose I should have followed Clem into the trade union movement. 
 We apprentices were never short of advice on what was wrong with society and the system. 
 But I found it all too negative and depressing. 
 Success was supposed to be reserved for those with silver spoons in their mouths. 
 I well remember the words of an old foreman who said to me, Son, even if you have the talent and ability to take you to the top, there is still no guarantee that you will ever get there, or even half way. 
 But as sure as God made little apples, you certainly won't get there if you don't make the effort.&equo; 
 That clinched it for me. 
 I suppose that simple precept from that old foreman stood me in good stead for thirty odd years, until now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why until now, Dad?&equo; enquired Andrew, unaware of his father's predicament. 
 &bquo;I suppose I should have said up to now,&equo; Mark replied disarmingly. 
 &bquo;Perhaps it will help me over the next thirty,&equo; he added as an afterthought. 
 &bquo;But you are both very similar men, from similar backgrounds and with the same basic objectives in society,&equo; Vicky said, with the air of a very puzzled young lady. 
 &bquo;Don't you still want the same things? 
 &bquo;Oh, but we do,&equo; her father told her. 
 &bquo;We both want to improve things; to build a better world. 
 I thought that I could make my contribution by joining the Trade Union movement, and improve things from there.&equo; 
 &bquo;And I thought I could make mine by designing and making better products, and selling them to the world,&equo; said Mark.  
 &bquo;Now how about something to eat? 
 I'm starving.&equo; 
 A few days later the national press carried the headlines that the UM plants in the Midlands had now been made idle as a consequence of the Merseyside strike. 
 The flow of supplies into the Midlands from the Merseyside works had dried up completely and with no apparent end to the stoppage in sight, lay-offs took immediate effect. 
 Feelings were running high at all plants, but for different reasons. 
 The news that Don Peters was being replaced had been received with great disappointment and alarm throughout the Midlands by management, unions and employees alike. 
 Disappointment that they were losing the best American M D they had ever had, after less than one year, and alarm in the knowledge that his demotion almost certainly meant the end of the recovery and expansion plans, and possibly the end of vehicle manufacture in the UK. 
 Such was the state of concern at the Midlands plants that conveners and local members of Parliament were demanding intervention at Government level. 
 Some of the thirty thousand workers employed at the Midlands plants, incensed by the idleness forced on them by the Merseysiders and alarmed at the bleak prospect ahead, stormed through the streets to Clem Bunker's regional office demanding action to get the Merseyside plants back to work. 
 Bunker was jostled, heckled, spat upon and sworn at as he tried to keep some semblance of order to explain the action he had already taken. 
 After two very noisy and unruly hours, with the local police trying to keep law and order, the angry mob reluctantly dispersed. 
 On Merseyside, the plant had split into two factions over the strike; those who supported Clasper in his demand that the strike be continued until the sacked shop steward had been reinstated, and those who took the view that Clasper was playing power politics with their jobs at stake. 
 The latter demanded that the strike be called off to avoid even worse news. 
 This view represented the thoughts of an ever-growing majority whose intuitive feeling was that the Merseyside plant was heading for total and irreversible closure with the loss of  ten thousand jobs. 
 Clasper was becoming more isolated, with his dwindling support coming from a small core of left-wingers who considered the fight to be a question of principle, namely union solidarity against management. 
 Bunker's early efforts to bring about a settlement had been angrily brushed aside by Clasper, who told the regional officer in no uncertain terms that his help was not needed. 
 The Merseyside members would resolve the dispute in their own way without his help. 
 Bunker knew instinctively that Clasper could not, and would not, resolve the dispute himself and that the effects of the stoppage would very soon be felt far beyond the confines of United Motors as one supply industry after another experienced a precipitous drop in demand. 
 He also knew that if Clasper was to be toppled from his influential position as plant convener &mdash; which was essential to the long term recovery of the plant &mdash; he would have to be seen to be toppled by his own members, acting in their own interests. 
 He therefore resolved to keep out of the way and let Clasper hang himself. 
 The  Midlands'  plants had been putting great pressure on the Merseysiders to call off the strike, as a result of which a mass meeting at Pier Head, Liverpool, had been demanded to vote on the question of a return to work. 
 Although this had initially been rejected out of hand by Clasper, he had been left in no doubt that his members would hold their own mass meeting without him if he chose not to call it. 
 At the same time, hundreds of workers in the Midlands plants who had heard about the Pier Head meeting on the grapevine now decided to drive up to Liverpool to influence the return to work vote. 
 Confident that Clasper would be brought down by his own members without any interference from him, Bunker concluded that his best course of action would be to emulate Brer Rabbit on this occasion, and &bquo;lie low and say nuffin'.&equo; 
 Mark's address to an international audience at Trinity College, Dublin, came as a shock to European Commissioners, Government Ministers and their academic  advisers. 
 He had been invited to speak on the factors which influenced investment location decisions as seen from the viewpoint of a European Industrial Planning Manager. 
 He was the fourth of twelve speakers over the three day conference, the others being Ministers, Commissioners, Economists and Academics, and had been introduced by the Chairman as &bquo;The Man at the Sharp End&equo;. 
 He had based his paper strictly on his own practical experiences, working within the labyrinth of conflicting laws, rules and regulations imposed by individual Governments within the EEC, EFTA and East Europe. 
 He sought to show how the laws imposed by certain countries to attract internationally mobile inward investment could only operate to the detriment of other states. 
 He exposed the many devious ways in which Governments bent the rules of free trade in their favour, while flying the free trade banner. 
 He described how the Japanese used a laser beam strategy within a poorly drafted law to penetrate the European market while protecting their own domestic market behind a dynastic organisational structure which only permitted import access when the dynasty deemed it politically expedient to do so. 
 He itemised the steps by which East European Governments gained access to the free markets of West Europe, while denying the same freedom of access to West European manufacturers, and revealed how reciprocal trade deals negotiated with the multi-nationals resulted in unsuspecting third party EEC Governments being saddled with the import bill. 
 He then went on to describe the very considerable commercial and economic disadvantages experienced by peripheral industrial countries compared with the enormous advantages enjoyed by the privileged centrally placed Golden Triangle countries and called to question the entire concept of a European budget which incredibly penalised the poorer peripheral countries instead of applying the penalty the other way round. 
 He concluded his forty-five minute address by commenting on the political factors which influenced investment location decisions and emphasised that future multi-national planners would do well to have a much more sensitive appreciation of the social and political implications of their  actions. 
 Government intervention would inevitably follow if Governments had reason to believe that their interests were not being fairly served. 
 He sat down, knowing in his heart of hearts that for as long as Randy Mueller had a major part to play in UM's corporate planning, his basic criteria would be: &bquo;Is it good for the Corporation? 
 Is it good for the United States? 
 And, above all, is it good for Randy Mueller?&equo; 
 Delegate after delegate during the three day conference subsequently referred to his address to confess that the real world of the International Planning Manager was a totally different world from that perceived by politicians and their academic advisers. 
 One distinguished-looking delegate, who Mark recognised as the Chairman of the British Conservative party, introduced himself to say that people with his experience should put themselves forward to serve in the European Parliament. 
 &bquo;I am going to put your name on the list we are drawing up,&equo; he said grandiloquently. 
 &bquo;I feel sure that one of the industrial constituencies would be interested in a chap with your industrial background.&equo;  
 Shortly after his return to England, Mark received an invitation to address an all-party Committee of Members of Parliament. 
 He was invited to develop his Dublin address with particular reference to the economic and commercial disadvantages of peripheral industrial countries, such as the United Kingdom, within the EEC. 
 He was also specifically asked to speak not as an executive of United Motors, but as an Englishman. 
 As he had been invited to dine with Members afterwards, his secretary had booked him into The Howard Hotel, a few hundred yards from Parliament Square on the Victoria Embankment, overlooking the Tower of London to the east and the Houses of Parliament to the west. 
 As Mark strolled from the hotel and crossed the road to the riverside walk, he had a strange feeling that the evening ahead would re-shape his future. 
 Outwardly he was calm and composed as he walked in the warm evening sunshine towards the House, but like the swans gliding serenely across the water, he too was paddling like hell underneath. 
 Big Ben struck the quarter hour and he checked his watch. 
 Ahead of him, the tail-end stragglers of the daily rush hour traffic scurried across Westminster Bridge. 
 The House of Parliament loomed up and his heart began to thump. 
 He recalled the first time he had seen the impressive building as a schoolboy on a day's outing to see the sights of London. 
 He could picture the scene as if it were yesterday. 
 The history master had gathered up his flock and had paused outside the source of power in the Commonwealth and Empire to eulogize on the great men of the past who had entered the hallowed portals. 
 Mark was one of twelve young boys and girls clustered around him to lap up his words of wisdom.  
 &bquo;Through these portals passed such illustrious men as Pitt, Walpole, Disraeli and Gladstone, to carve their names on the glorious history of England,&equo; he had said to his young and captive audience. 
 At the mention of the name Disraeli, Mark had been transported into a world of his own. 
 His grandfather had been a master baker and, in one of the many family stories Mark had heard at his grandfather's knee, he had been told of how his great-grandfather had served Benjamin Disraeli with a standing daily order of twelve French loaves, burnt and rasped. 
 It was the burning and rasping bit which had fascinated Mark. 
 His grandfather had explained that the only true way to bake bread was to burn it black and then rasp off the burnt extremities with a coarse file. 
 Mark had adored his grandparents and would listen spellbound to their stories for hours on end. 
 The history master had interrupted his reverie with a smart clip round the ear. 
 &bquo;Stop daydreaming, Sanders, will you boy? 
 Give us, pray, the benefit of your undivided attention. 
 Now sir, he had continued acidly, gripping Mark by the ear, &bquo;tell me, if I may be so bold as to ask, precisely what I have been talking about.&equo; 
 &bquo;Disraeli, sir. 
 Twelve French loaves, burnt and rasped, sir.&equo; 
 blurted the surprised boy, and the other children giggled hysterically. 
 &bquo;You stupid boy,&equo; cried the master. 
 &bquo;What in the world are you talking about? 
 If it's not cricket and Frank Woolley it's something else. 
 Now it's twelve French loaves, burnt and rasped, whatever that means. 
 I despair of you, boy. 
 One thing for certain, Sanders, you won't be coming here to the Mother of Parliaments to give us all the benefit of your profound wisdom. 
 It'll be some factory workbench for you boy, where, if you continue to dream your stupid little daydreams, you'll end up chopping your fingers off. 
 Is that understood?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sir.&equo; 
 Mark had been twelve at the time and beset by emotional turmoil. 
 His parents had recently parted. 
 Now he recalled how, on the second night after his mother had left home, he had climbed out of bed in the late evening and slipped unnoticed from the house to run over a mile to Bournemouth Central Railway Station to catch a train to nearby  Christchurch, where his mother had gone to live with her sister. 
 It was a cold night in late autumn and the rain had lashed down unremittingly. 
 By the time he had reached the shelter of the station he was soaked to the skin. 
 He had paid three pence at the booking office for his ticket and, after waiting ten minutes or so on the cold and draughty platform for the next London-bound train, he had arrived at Christchurch some ten minutes later to run through torrential rain toward the group of cottages which flanked the open park in the town centre. 
 He was not certain which cottage his aunt rented during the winter. 
 In the spring and summer she lived in a cottage on the banks of the river Stour just below Tuckton bridge. 
 Mark had spent many idyllic summer days sailing and fishing with his brothers and his aunt on the beautiful river, but had never been to her winter cottage. 
 The rain continued to beat down upon him as he ran across the dark and sodden park just before midnight. 
 With the exception of one cottage, where a light still shone in the window, all the others were in total darkness. 
 Mark ran to the one and only cottage with the light and was as surprised as his aunt when she opened the door. 
 She gave a great gasp of anguished amazement at the sight of the drowned rat of a boy standing before her, the rain pouring off his sodden hair to run in rivulets down his pale face. 
 Oh my God, Mark sweetheart,&equo; she cried, pulling the soaked boy to her  bosom . 
 &bquo;Grace,&equo; she called out to his mother, &bquo;it's Mark.&equo; 
 His beautiful and adored mother quickly appeared from the sitting-room and hugged him nearly to death on the doorstep. 
 But despite his repeated and heartfelt pleas to his mother to come home, she steadfastly refused to do so, and she never did. 
 The divorce was made absolute two years later. 
 Mark stood for a few moments at the corner of Parliament Street and Bridge Street. 
 It was nearly forty years since the history master had bawled him out on the pavement over there,  in front of the House of Commons. 
 &bquo;One thing is certain Sanders&hellip;&equo; he had said, &bquo;you won't be coming here&hellip;.&equo; 
 Mark crossed Parliament Square and even the statue of Churchill appeared to be growling at the sorry state of affairs in the land where a pettifogging ex-apprentice was invited to address Right Honourable Members of both Houses. 
 He climbed the steps leading to the central lobby and was stopped by a burly policeman who asked the nature of his business. 
 &bquo;Name's Sanders. 
 I am addressing an all-party committee,&equo; Mark replied, feeling rather important as he uttered the words. 
 &bquo;Bully for you, sir,&equo; replied the policeman with a smile. 
 &bquo;Go ahead sir.&equo; 
 Mark passed through a security screen to make his way to the impressive central lobby where the Chairman of the Committee was already waiting to receive him. 
 It was six twenty-seven. 
 After the usual pleasantries he took Mark along one of the labyrinth of corridors flanked with busts of the famous, and stopped before a heavy oak-panelled door attended by a liveried usher. 
 After exchanging a few words, the usher opened the door and Mark was escorted into a debating chamber shaped in the form of a horseshoe, with a raised dais at the open end upon which were two heavy oak chairs, one for the Chairman and the other for the speaker. 
 The room had seating capacity for about eighty and Mark saw that it was about half full. 
 Before being taken to the platform, he was introduced to those members of the Committee who happened to be milling around the entrance. 
 He recognised familiar names and faces from all parties, and also noticed that everybody carried copies of his Dublin paper. 
 He was then escorted to the dais, where the Chairman launched into a brief introduction. 
 &bquo;Your Dublin paper whetted our appetite, Mr Sanders,&equo; he said in conclusion. 
 &bquo;We now look forward to the main course this evening.&equo; 
 Mark rose from his chair fully aware that politicians believed themselves to be the best informed people in the world, which made them a very sceptical audience for any  speaker. 
 They sprawled across the padded benches before him with the somewhat jaded air of men who expected to hear nothing new. 
 He began jocularly by saying that he rose to address them with some apprehension, reminded of a piece of graffiti he had seen on a Whitehall notice board which had read, &bquo;I used to be indecisive&hellip; but now I'm not so sure,, which brought a few chuckles from the floor. 
 &bquo;I propose to describe the very considerable commercial and economic disadvantages incurred by the United Kingdom by comparison with other European countries when investment locations&equo; decisions are taken by multi-nationals,, Mark continued. 
 &bquo;And also to offer some suggestions as to how the UK handicap could be reduced and its disadvantages turned to its advantage.&equo; 
 A few eyebrows were raised at such unequivocal presumptions. 
 &bquo;You have also invited me to wear a British hat,&equo; Mark continued. 
 &bquo;It will be a pleasant change to do so.&equo; 
 He began by giving several examples of how Governments in both West and East Europe had obtained major United Motors' investment projects by highly discriminatory and blatantly unfair means, which had operated to the detriment of the UK. 
 He was suddenly thrown off balance by the hurried departure of a Minister. 
 He was aware that Members had to come and go at irregular intervals at the behest of their lords and masters when the House was in session, but he feared the worst. 
 He faltered, cleared his throat, drank liberally from the glass before him, and continued. 
 His morale was uplifted a few minutes later when the same Minister returned with a gaggle of additional members evidently called from the floor of the House. 
 Mark warmed to the task and continued with renewed confidence. 
 &bquo;There are many instances where UK investment and product costs have been up to twenty per cent below other European countries, but the investment has still been located on the continent because of unfair political pressures and highly discriminatory practices,&equo; he added to gasps of pained surprise.  
 &bquo;The Treaty of Rome rules on competitive costs and prices have been blatantly disregarded by certain countries and the multi-nationals,&equo; he added. 
 &bquo;Just consider, for example, the adverse economic effect on Britain of Ford's highly discriminatory investment plan agreed with the Spanish Government&hellip;.&equo; 
 For the best part of an hour he exposed what was really going on in the international motor industry. 
 His audience was very quiet. 
 Hardly a muscle moved. 
 &bquo;Corporate plans of the Fords, UMs and Chryslers of this world influence and shape our destiny. 
 They determine whether Britain is to be a winner or loser country. 
 Sadly for Britain they have already made the decision that Britain is to be a loser country,&equo; he said dramatically. 
 Pained expressions crossed the faces of the now alarmed politicians. 
 &bquo;For example,&equo; he went on, &bquo;The corporate plan of United Motors is to phase-out vehicle and component manufacture in the UK and import its requirements from new plants on the continent, from East Europe, the Far East &mdash; including Japan &mdash; and from the United States itself, with the loss of fifty thousand UK jobs, one hundred and fifty thousand if one includes jobs lost in the UK supplier chain.&equo; 
 he added. 
 There was a gasp at this disclosure. 
 Constituency problems now loomed large. 
 &bquo;By the late eighties the global plans of the major US multinationals will have created a massive UK trade deficit of around seven billion pounds which will go on increasing with the growth of the number of vehicles in use. 
 These companies have been Britain's top exporters in the past. 
 Seven years from now they will be Britain's top importers. 
 What will be the effect on the pound sterling and on Britain's economic standing in the world as the trade gap widens? 
 What will be the employment?&equo; he asked ominously. 
 &bquo;And yet, this frightening scenario I outline to you this evening is precisely what will happen arising from the global plans of these major American-owned multi-nationals.&equo; 
 Mark's voice had trailed away to a whisper. 
 His words had produced group paralysis. 
 Not a muscle moved. 
 Mark was now speaking out with a vengeance. 
 For the first time in his life he was free from corporate restraints, to say  what he really thought. 
 He had no qualms in doing so. 
 If those with inside knowledge of the facts didn't speak up for Britain, who the hell would? 
 That was his justification. 
 His eyes ranged the room. 
 &bquo;The Prime Minister has clearly stated her intention to bring about the industrial regeneration of Britain to correct the decline of the last few years,&equo; he said vigorously. 
 &bquo;She has appealed to industrial leaders to help her redress the trade imbalance.&equo; 
 &bquo;What price the American contribution toward that objective?&equo; he asked in a hushed tone. 
 &bquo;How can the Prime Minister achieve her national targets when US corporate plans move in a diametrically opposite direction to compound Britain's trade problems. 
 What would the American Government say if the roles were reversed?&equo; he added to nods from all quarters. 
 Mark paused again to take a very long drink. 
 &bquo;Fortunately Britain can win if we learn from past mistakes, and I would now like to conclude by outlining certain strategic proposals for your consideration, which would put Britain firmly on the upward path to meet the Prime Minister's long-term objectives.&equo; 
 Mark then described a ten point plan and summarised its resultant effect. 
 The UK vehicle and component industry sectors alone would progressively benefit to the value of eight billion pounds sterling by year five. 
 This would correct the Motor industry trade imbalance without the need to export one additional unit. 
 Unemployment in the sector would be reduced by two hundred thousand, and existing manufacturing capacity, previously made idle by imports, would once more be fully utilised, thus improving operating profit and return on investment. 
 Mark ended his address by saying, &bquo;The European and international trade war is really between those Governments who fix the rules of the game to suit themselves, and those who play the game according to Treaty of Rome rules. 
 Britain has been a loser country in a manifestly unfair trade environment. 
 It has allowed itself to be outsmarted by governments who are not afraid to bend the rules in their favour, aided and abetted by American multi-nationals whose allegiance is to the United States, naturally. 
 Britain is expendable.&equo;  
 He looked around him. 
 &bquo;Why not think and act as Great Britain Incorporate?&equo;. he asked. 
 Unbeknown to Mark, one of the titled politicians present also happened to be an international banker and financial advisor to several US corporations. 
 He phoned New York immediately after the Westminster meeting. 
 A voice at the other end said wearily in a faintly Irish accent. 
 &bquo;Ah well. 
 I suppose we will have to take appropriate action will we not&hellip;. 
 Thanks for putting me in the picture, Patrick.&equo; 
 The magnate placed the phone back on the receiver&hellip; slowly. 
 &bquo;Thorns left to fester&hellip;&equo; he mused. 
 &bquo;Maybe we should contact the special outside Agency.&equo; 
 He thought very, very carefully for a minute or more and then picked up his private phone and dialled a number. 
 Two days later, Mark received a phone call from 10, Downing Street, asking for permission to publish the Dublin paper, and his submission to the House Select Committee, as an appendix to the Government's proposed White Paper shortly to go before the House. 
 He readily gave his approval. 
 At Question Time in the House, the Prime Minister agreed that a paper submitted by a European Planning Manager, now being studied by the Government and the European Commission appeared to offer real solutions to Britain's excessive contribution to the European budget. 
 Mark received several letters and phone calls from Members of Parliament, all but one in support of his two papers and proposals. 
 The Member who wrote to express his disagreement invited Mark to the House to discuss his reasons for taking the opposite viewpoint. 
 He received Mark in the central lobby and took him to the Members' tea room for a chat over a pot of tea. 
 He was a young lawyer of about thirty in his first year in  Parliament, who had sufficiently impressed someone in Government to have been given the job of Junior Minister at the Trade office. 
 He came straight to the point in a rather superior manner, saying that he was a European federalist and that, in his opinion, it didn't matter a tuppeny damn whether industrial investments took place in Germany, France or the UK. 
 He went on to say that it was irrelevant whether Britain had an industrial base at all if it could be shown that it would be more sensible, from a European point of view, for Britain to become a service nation importing its manufactured product requirements. 
 Mark listened aghast at the naive and dangerous idealism of the young, starry-eyed politician, who was light years away from knowing what really went on at the sharp end of European and international trade. 
 &bquo;If you believe that, sir,&equo; said Mark with as much politeness as he could muster, &bquo;you will naturally not share the concern I have expressed in my papers. 
 We are obviously poles apart. 
 Do you wish to discuss the subject further, or would we both be wasting our time?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wasting our time, I think.&equo; 
 said the young Minister, forcing a laugh. 
 &bquo;But as I have invited you here, let's discuss the subject a little further at least.&equo; 
 Mark asked him how he could reconcile his views with what was clearly Britain s basic needs; the need to maintain a strong manufacturing base as a defence capability; the need to correct a massive and worsening trade deficit on manufactured products; and the need to provide talented school-leavers with creative career opportunities in the manufacturing sector as designers, physicists, chemists and engineers as opposed to the more mundane jobs in the service sector as warehousemen and handlers of other countries' goods. 
 The young politician shrugged his shoulders. 
 &bquo;Irrelevancies,&equo; he said dismissively. 
 &bquo;Top talent will always be in demand where the jobs are, and if the jobs are on the continent, so be it. 
 National trade deficits will become meaningless under a European monetary system with a common currency. 
 And as for defence,&equo; he went on, &bquo;Britain would be defended by arms manufactured in Germany or France just as well as by arms manufactured in  Britain, if this were necessary for good economic reasons.&equo; 
 Mark raised an eyebrow. 
 &bquo;Your belief that Germany or France would unfailingly defend Britain and British interests against an aggressor is not one that I share. 
 Does the Minister of Defence share your views?, 
 &bquo;No, he does not!&equo; snapped the Junior Minister of Trade. 
 &bquo;Thank God for that,&equo; Mark declaimed. 
 &bquo;Your views are too simplistic for me,&equo; said the young politician loftily. 
 &bquo;As you say, we are poles apart. 
 Let's leave it at that.&equo; 
 He rose to leave and Mark followed. 
 &bquo;Before you entered Parliament, what did you do?&equo; 
 Mark asked. 
 The young man's head went up. 
 &bquo;I was&hellip; 
 I am&hellip; a barrister.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you are a Junior Minister of Trade. 
 You're not attached to the Attorney General's office,&equo; said Mark with an air of feigned surprise. 
 The Junior Minister pulled himself up to his full height of five foot three, and in a plummy voice rich with haughty disdain said, &bquo;What difference does that make?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, you wouldn't expect an industrial manager to be made Attorney General, would you?&equo; 
 Mark asked. 
 The young politician tugged at an ear lobe and eyed him narrowly. 
 &bquo;By that remark, I take it you mean that I know little or nothing about industrial or trade matters?&equo; 
 Mark looked him straight in the eye. 
 &bquo;I think it would be a great presumption on your part if you thought you did,&equo; he replied firmly, putting the young man down. 
 The self-important politician smiled coldly. 
 &bquo;You have a nice way of expressing yourself which, I suppose, reflects your industrial background.&equo; 
 The word &bquo;industrial&equo; came out like a swearword. 
 &bquo;Good day to you, sir,&equo; the Junior Minister said formally. 
 &bquo;Thank you for responding to my invitation.&equo; 
 They shook hands, but it was clearly on the unspoken understanding that they could still come out fighting. 
 They went their separate ways: the young politician to the floor of  the House to promote new industrial and commercial legislation which would, no doubt, exercise his legal mind, and the industrial manager to the central lobby, and the way out. 
 Mark drove home along the M1 reflecting that the French and Germans in particular would be pleased to erect monuments to the idealistic young English politician who had said all the things that Britain's trade competitors wanted to hear. 
 The Germans had got their priorities right. 
 Unlike Britain, they put national industrial supremacy first and foremost. 
 European interests were secondary to national objectives, except where European political unity carried more clout in the international political scene. 
 The British had been taken to the cleaners because foolish politicians in post-war Britain had elected to produce sociologists instead of engineers, and the predictable end result was that Britain had been short on wealth creators and long on spenders. 
 The creative and talented nation that gave birth to the Industrial Revolution and produced more inventions and patents per head of population than any other country in the world, had turned its back on industry and commerce. 
 Mark felt bitter and sad. 
 Sad that his country had fallen from the top of the European industrial league, to joint eighth out of nine, and bitter toward the foolish leaders who had been largely responsible for its decline. 
 The supercilious young Minister of Trade was a typical product of the British post-war school of Parliamentarians whose motto should have been &bquo;words not deeds&equo;. 
 In the eyes of such politicians, industrial managers were not seen as the creators of the nation's wealth, and the providers of job opportunities for the people, but as despoilers of the environment; obsolete men, peddling obsolete views, who didn't really fit in with the new social scheme of things. 
 They were yesterday's men. 
 In their eyes, Mark Sanders was such a man.  
 When Mark arrived home there were two letters, postmarked Detroit, waiting for him. 
 One was a personal letter from the President of United Motors, Nate Cocello, thanking him for his services to the Corporation. 
 The other was from the Vice President in charge of  Overseas'  Operations, thanking him for his personal contribution to the expansion of European Component Operations. 
 Mark read the letters twice. 
 He presumed they had been written for him to use as references for his next employer, but he tore them up angrily. 
 The next day Muldoon told him that he was returning to the States at the end of the month to take his enforced early retirement, after a short holiday on the Hamble. 
 Mark's compensation and pension terms would be spelt out to him by New York within the next two weeks, after they had checked out the maximum terms permissible under British law. 
 &bquo;It has already been agreed that the company will be as generous as British law allows,&equo; Muldoon said reassuringly. 
 &bquo;The company wish you to know, Mark, from Nate Cocello down, that your work over the years is sincerely appreciated. 
 I know that the organisational change has come as a shock to you, as it has for me, but we want to part company after all these years, on the best and friendliest of terms. 
 I am assured that you will be well looked after,&equo; he reiterated. 
 &bquo;In the meantime you are free to do whatever you wish to do over the next few weeks. 
 If we can be of any assistance to you in finding another job, please don't hesitate to shout. 
 No doubt you will wish to say &bquo;Goodbye&equo; to all your many friends and colleagues in industry and Government, so please feel free to do so in whatever way you feel appropriate.&equo; 
 Mark nodded. 
 &bquo;Yes, sure. 
 Thanks.&equo; 
 he replied indifferently. 
 The big, soft and pliable American smiled nervously.  
 &bquo;Oh, incidentally Mark, I understand they want to use your office and mine for a couple of visiting Americans on assignment over here for a couple of months. 
 Hope you haven't any objection. 
 You can use the Treasurer's office until you leave, if that's OK by you? 
 He's on vacation.&equo; 
 Mark nodded. 
 &bquo;Do I have any choice in the matter?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sure you do,&equo; the American replied. 
 But he didn't sound certain. 
 &bquo;If you'd rather not move, OK. 
 I'll tell 'em to make other arrangements in the interim.&equo; 
 Mark shook his head. 
 &bquo;No. 
 I'll use the Treasurer's office. 
 As you say, I won't be around much over the next few weeks anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo;OK, Mark. 
 I'll tell 'em to go ahead.&equo; 
 Mark never saw Pat Muldoon again. 
 The American cruised the Solent for a few days while Mark was tying up the loose ends, and returned to the States without paying another visit to his office. 
 He slipped into the obscurity of retirement, after more than thirty years in the Corporation, in much the same way as he had operated during his entire working life: unobtrusively. 
 He was particularly anxious to return to the States before Mark left the company, as he simply couldn't face the prospect of having to spell out to the Englishman the compensation terms and pension proposals which New York had worked out. 
 Just one glance had told Muldoon that they were very far from being as generous as he had encouraged Mark to believe. 
 They certainly bore no relationship to the eminently satisfactory compensation and pension which he himself would receive. 
 It would have been very painful for Muldoon to have to pass on the bad news, so he decided to leave for the States and let the Detroit executive personnel Director handle Mark's affairs. 
 True to form, Muldoon simply did as he was told to do irrespective of the rights or wrongs of the decision. 
 To the end of his career, he had complete faith in the Corporation and in  the infallibility of his superiors. 
 The following Sunday Pat Muldoon stood in what had formerly been his local church at Gross Pointe, Michigan, and sang to the heavens, &bquo;If I can help somebody, as I go along, then my living will not be in vain&hellip;.&equo; without paying the slightest attention to the meaning of the words. 
 He had always been a very religious man, which had helped him a lot in the Corporation. 
 He looked around the congregation and saw many old and familiar friends and colleagues. 
 They smiled as they caught his eye. 
 He smiled back. 
 The word had already got around that Pat Muldoon had decided to take retirement in his old familiar surroundings, after a lifetime s dedicated service to the great American Corporation. 
 People liked that. 
 Pat Muldoon had come home. 
 The Director of Personnel responsible for the personal affairs of overseas executives rang Mark from Detroit to say that compensation terms had now been worked out, and that he would be visiting England the following week to discuss the subject with him. 
 &bquo;Pat sends his best wishes, Mark, and says he's sorry that he won't be there to say &bquo;Goodbye&equo; and wish you luck. 
 See you next week.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, sure. 
 Next week then,&equo; said the Englishman. 
 The union meeting at the Pier Head in Liverpool was in uproar. 
 Fred Clasper had shouted himself hoarse in his frenzied efforts to persuade the vociferous gathering of several thousand employees from the strike-bound Merseyside vehicle plant to continue the strike until management climbed down and re-instated the sacked shop steward. 
 He was being heckled, jeered and booed by the vast majority, which included several hundred workers who had driven up from the  Midlands'  plants to influence the vote. 
 Clasper's small hard core of left-wing supporters, which included a phalanx of students from Liverpool University, had formed a noisy group immediately in front of the  improvised platform, which consisted of a large wooden CKD crate with the Vehicle Divisions' name stencilled in large black letters on each surface. 
 Clasper stood alone on the box, clasping a hand microphone to his ranting mouth. 
 The vituperative messages which poured forth in a veritable torrent of abuse were repeatedly drowned by the dissenting majority who kept up an incessant chant: &bquo;Return to work. 
 Return to work. 
 Return to work.&equo; 
 Clasper screamed back at the chanting mob that they were management lackeys who had been conned by Peters, and sold down the river by Bunker. 
 He yelled for union solidarity to support the strike and to bring management to their knees, but to no avail. 
 His members had had enough. 
 He knew that he was now powerless to influence the way they would vote. 
 He had underestimated the new mood of his members who had become sick and tired of the never-ending series of disputes, which they knew in their consciences had been driving the Division ever closer to bankruptcy. 
 Clasper was stranded. 
 He had missed the ebb tide. 
 Faced with the stark reality of a choice between jobs or no jobs, the majority had elected to work. 
 It wasn't a straight management versus union dispute; it was job preservation. 
 The unions didn't pay their weekly wages; the company did. 
 They would support the union if they thought it to be in their interest to do so. 
 They would not back the union in a political fight with the company, or allow themselves to be used by Clasper in a power struggle between the convener and management. 
 If it was a question of company survival, or union survival, the company would always win. 
 &bquo;Piss off, Clasper, you've had your day!&equo; yelled a burly figure at the back of the crowd, who was cheered to the echo for his advice. 
 &bquo;Go home, you bum, go home, you bum, go home, you bum, go home,&equo; sang another to the tune of Auld Lang Syne . 
 Within seconds, the sing-song chant had been taken up by the vast majority. 
 &bquo;Go home, you bum, go home, you bum, go home, you bum, go home; go home, you bum, go home you bum, go home you bum, go home.&equo; 
 Clasper looked out at the sea of open mouths which  chorused against him. 
 The chants were now accompanied by signs as one member after another thrust a right arm in the air to stab a pointing finger at the man on the platform. 
 &bquo;Go home, you bum, go home you bum, go home you bum, go home; go home you bum, go home you bum, go home you bum, go home.&equo; 
 Clasper yelled back at the chanting mob. 
 &bquo;You bloody stupid gits! 
 You bloody sheep! 
 You arse lickin' lackeys! 
 You servile scum! 
 You bloody shits&hellip;.&equo; 
 He was shouting at the top of his voice into the microphone but save for a few at the front of the crowd, nobody could hear a word because someone had cut the amplifier cable. 
 A new chant was now taken up. 
 &bquo;Clasper out. 
 Clasper out. 
 Clasper out&hellip;.&equo; followed by &bquo;Return to work. 
 Return to work. 
 Return to work.&equo; 
 Clasper threw the useless microphone to the ground and thrust a rolled up newspaper aloft, which he brandished furiously in his left hand. 
 Thumping the paper with his other hand he continued to yell at the chanting mob, but couldn't be heard above the din. 
 In disgust he threw the paper into the crowd. 
 Almost by return, he was hit by a missile which looked like a rotting cabbage. 
 Other miscellaneous missiles rained in on him as he clambered down from the improvised platform with the help of his small band of left-wing brothers. 
 &bquo;Dump the bastard in the Mersey!&equo; yelled a high pitched voice which rose above the chanting mob. 
 Within seconds a new cry was taken up. 
 &bquo;Dump the bastard in the Mersey! 
 Dump the bastard in the Mersey! 
 Dump the bastard in the Mersey&hellip;.&equo; 
 Hands grasped the now frightened convener as his mates fought to keep the pressing mob at bay. 
 Overwhelmed by the sheer size and strength of the surging crowd, Clasper's supporters suddenly got the message and broke rank, dispersing into the milling throng. 
 Police helmets could be seen bobbing above the crowd as a small corps of police officers attempted to force their way through to rescue Clasper from the hands of the mob. 
 Before they could reach him, however, he was borne aloft like a javelin and carried to the quayside a few yards away where he was dumped unceremoniously into the murky waters to a great cheer from those who were close enough to witness the event.  
 Then as if by magic the crowd melted away to let the struggling policemen through. 
 Clasper was soon hauled out of the water by the forces of law and order, something he had never bargained for in a lifetime's fight against them. 
 Within two minutes the mob had completely dispersed, with the exception of the odd copper or two and a few stragglers who were loth to leave the scene of all the fun. 
 One of them picked up the rolled newspaper which Clasper had flung into the crowd. 
 &bquo;I wouldn't have thought The Times  was Clasper's favourite paper, exactly,&equo; he muttered to his mate. 
 &bquo;Must have a good racing correspondent,&equo; came the reply. 
 &bquo;The bastard likes the nags.&equo; 
 &bquo;That figures wack. 
 Bloody nagger by nature, etcetera.&equo; 
 His attention was drawn to a red circle which had been drawn in the Business Section with the name JUDAS scrawled in large block capitals. 
 He read out loud, &bquo;Mr Clem Bunker, regional officer of the Amalgamated Union of Engineering Workers, has been invited to serve on the social affair's directorate of the European Commission. 
 The appointment has been approved by the Prime Minister.&equo; 
 He cuffed his mate's ear with the paper. 
 &bquo;Well, stone me, wack,&equo; he chuckled. 
 &bquo;The bastard's even against that.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's against every bloody thing,&equo; replied his mate. 
 &bquo;Never 'appy unless he's miserable.&equo; 
 Back at cell number 102 in Kirkby New Town, Fred Clasper made a momentous decision to emigrate to Australia. 
 Well it's fairly obvious that you can't go back to the plant, innit?&equo; agreed his platinum blonde flatmate Deirdre. 
 &bquo;Well I mean to say&hellip; it stands to reason like&hellip; don't it?&equo; she added. 
 You couldn't do that now, could yer? 
 No of course not&hellip; but I ain't leavin' Liverpool to chase bloody wallabies. 
 I like it &bquo;ere. 
 Well, it's 'ome like, where all yer friends are, innit?, 
 She put her nose in the air and sniffed.  
 &bquo;Give over, will yer,&equo; pleaded the disconsolate convener, slapping jam on his butty. 
 &bquo;Don't you ever leave off?&equo; 
 &bquo;No well&hellip; 
 I shouldn't 'ave said that I suppose cos you ain't got no friends any more, 'ave yer? 
 Not now you 'aven't&hellip; even if you 'ad some before they dumped you in the Mersey, which I suppose you did 'ave&hellip; at some time or other like&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aw for gawd's sake give that bloody tongue of yours a rest will yer?&equo; 
 Clasper sighed. 
 &bquo;I'm tryin' to think&hellip; believe it or not.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, don't try too hard, luvvie, or you'll burst a blood vessel,&equo; she called above the noise of the open tap as she filled the kettle for more tea. 
 She sniffed again. 
 Fred Clasper was a malcontent by nature, one of the curious breed who are never happy unless they are miserable. 
 But discontent was one thing. 
 Helpless misery was another. 
 Now, briefly, possibly for the very first time in his life, he felt helpless and miserable at one and the same time. 
 The death of his beloved grandfather had brought him misery but, at the same time, it had also given him strength. 
 It was as if, gasping out his last breath, that battered, bitter and vindictive old man had somehow injected him with some small portion of his own bitter resolve. 
 That was both why and how he had fought all his working life for what his grandfather had believed in &mdash; worker control of the means of production and distribution, and the establishment of a Communist society where means were related to needs. 
 Now after twelve years as convener at the huge Merseyside plant where he had effectively established shop-floor control after a long and bitter struggle, he had been thrown out by his own union members. 
 He shook his head sadly at the cruel injustices of this world. 
 &bquo;Bloody management-brainwashed gits,&equo; he muttered. 
 &bquo;What's that, Fred luvvie?&equo; she called from the stove. 
 &bquo;Stupid bastards,&equo; he mumbled on. 
 &bquo;Come again, Fred?&equo; 
 &bquo;I said stupid bastards!&equo; 
 &bquo;Well I like that&hellip; that's rich that is after all I do for you. 
 I really appreciate that, Fred&hellip; 
 I really do. 
 I cook for yer and I  keep house for yer and all that&hellip; and that's the thanks I get, well thank you, mate.&equo; 
 She sniffed several times. 
 Deirdre was plainly upset and would have droned on indefinitely if Fred hadn't shut her up. 
 &bquo;Aw for gawd's sake shut that bloody trap of yours, will yer? 
 I wasn't talkin' to you. 
 I was thinkin' out loud.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh well, that's different, she agreed, after having her faith restored in human nature. 
 &bquo;But you might apologise.&equo; 
 &bquo;Apologise! 
 Apologise! 
 What the bloody hell is there to apologise for? 
 I didn't call you a stupid bastard, did I?&equo; he yelled in exasperation. 
 &bquo;I was talkin' about those bloody stupid gits at the plant, wasn't I?, 
 &bquo;Well, yeah, but they don't exactly consider you to be the greatest thing since sliced bread, now do they?&equo; she opined. 
 &bquo;I don't care what they bloody well think. 
 Bloody management lackeys&hellip; that's what they are&hellip; scum of the earth&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, let's have another cuppa tea, luvvie, and forget all about it&hellip; it's not worth it. 
 You ain't gonna change the world no matter what you do.&equo; 
 She sniffed again. 
 He took the steaming beaker from his flatmate. 
 &bquo;Well, are yer comin' or ain't yer?&equo; he asked after a long and noisy sip at the cup that cheers. 
 &bquo;Coming where?&equo; she asked. 
 &bquo;Bloody Australia, of course. 
 Where the hell do you think?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Australia&hellip;. 
 Do you really want me to come?, 
 &bquo;Course I do or I wouldn't have bloody well asked yer, would I?&equo; 
 &bquo;Why Australia?&equo; she asked, breathing on her recently painted nails. 
 &bquo;Cause that's where the bloody new action is gonna be,&equo; he replied testily. 
 &bquo;How do you know that?&equo; she asked with an air of surprise. 
 &bquo;Cause I bloody well know. 
 I'm in the movement, ain't I?, 
 &bquo;Well yes I know&hellip; but Aussie land is on the other side of the world ain't it?&equo;  
 &bquo;So what! 
 Bloody United Motors is not the only one to have a bloody world-wide corporate plan.&equo; 
 &bquo;Australia&hellip;.&equo; she toyed with the name. 
 &bquo;Well&hellip; be a change I suppose&hellip; and we do get along very well, don't we, Fred?&equo; 
 She sniffed and went on sniffing. 
 The Pier Head incident proved to be the turning point which led to a new period of industrial peace within the giant Vehicle Division, unfortunately too late to avoid the massive investment switch to the Continent which was already under way with the newly approved corporate plan. 
 Wholesale changes took place within the management and trade union organisations, with the good going out with the bad. 
 The convener who replaced Clasper, for example, at the Merseyside plant, was elected because he had stressed to the union membership that the best way he could serve their interest was to help make sure that the Merseyside plant became the most efficient plant in Europe. 
 &bquo;We know from past experience where the other route takes us,&equo; he said to loud applause. 
 &bquo;Downhill to the Labour Exchange at the bottom. 
 From here on in we are going to be winners, not losers. 
 For years we have been a low productivity low-wage plant and we have ended up losing our jobs and all the new investment opportunities. 
 From here on we aim to be a high-productivity high-wage plant. 
 That's the best way I know to protect the jobs of our members.&equo; 
 Sadly for Britain, sadly for industrial peace on Merseyside, the change-of-heart had come too late. 
 Plants closed, men were sacked, industrial decay and unemployment spread like a leprous blight across the whole of the region and insidiously crept down into the Midlands. 
 Fred Clasper may have moved on to a new fighting ground but he, and men like him, left behind their destructive trade-mark on Britain for more than a decade.  
 Mark couldn't believe his eyes and ears when the American Director of  Overseas'  Executive Personnel spelt out the compensation terms under the early retirement deal. 
 He was to be given two weeks salary for each year of service. 
 This would give him eighteen months' salary as compensation for loss of office, and his pension was not to begin until the eighteen month period had elapsed. 
 Mark's face hardened into an expression of bitter hatred. 
 He had been deeply hurt twice before by the Corporation, but this last kick in the stomach on final departure was the last straw. 
 He flung the contract at the feet of the American. 
 &bquo;You call these terms generous?&equo; he demanded angrily. 
 &bquo;I call it a bloody insult!, 
 The American was visibly shaken by the Englishman's angry response. 
 &bquo;Sorry you feel that way about it, Mark. 
 You can keep the company car,&equo; he added quickly. 
 &bquo;You sure the Corporation can afford it?&equo; 
 Mark asked sarcastically. 
 &bquo;What did Muldoon say?&equo; he added sharply. 
 &bquo;Waal,&equo; said the American, &bquo;there was nothing much he could say, was there? 
 Rules is rules, after all.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right, isn't it?&equo; 
 Mark scoffed. 
 &bquo;He wouldn't say much would he! 
 He's all right Jack! 
 He's got two thirds of a bloody great American salary four times greater than mine for doing similar work. 
 That gives him a pension nearly ten times greater than the one I've got. 
 I'm not surprised he didn't say much. 
 Who the hell would want to rock the boat on a deal like that! 
 Do YOU think that's fair?&equo; he shouted angrily. 
 &bquo;But you're not an American, Mark. 
 You're an Englishman&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;So&hellip;.&equo; 
 &bquo;So bullshit!&equo; 
 Mark exploded. 
 &bquo;I've been an Overseas&equo; Corporation Executive for the last ten years and I've always been told that the reason the Corporation couldn't pay me the salary it paid to Americans doing similar work was because my salary had to be related to British salary scales.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, that's right. 
 That's Corporation rules.&equo; 
 &bquo;So why am I not being compensated for loss of office  according to British scales?, 
 &bquo;What's that?&equo; 
 Mark said clearly, &bquo;Accepted British practice is at least one month's salary for each year of service. 
 And pension rights begin immediately, not at the end of any bloody eighteen month period. 
 And that's for run-of-the-mill managers. 
 For executives there is virtually no limit.&equo; 
 The American shook his head worriedly. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry, Mark, but Corporation rules are rules. 
 The Corporation can't make an exception in your case.&equo; 
 Mark smashed a fist on the desk in a defiant gesture. 
 &bquo;You've been making a bloody exception in my case ever since I've been on the corporate payroll&equo; he yelled. 
 &bquo;Some bloody rules! 
 One for Americans. 
 Another for the rest of us.&equo; 
 Mark moved angrily toward the door. 
 He had had enough. 
 &bquo;I'll take it up with higher authority, if that's what you want,&equo; said the American nervously. 
 &bquo;I could bring your views to the attention of the Vice President in charge of Overseas Operations&equo; he added placatingly. 
 Mark threw back his head and laughed sarcastically. 
 &bquo;You'd never keep Jupe awake long enough to listen to the arguments. 
 Ye gods, even when he is awake all he ever says is let's sleep on it&hellip;.&equo; 
 The American smiled at the accurate description of the Vice President whose reputation for always falling asleep at meetings had earned him the nickname of Mogadon Man. 
 &bquo;But I will speak to Jupe if you would like me to do so,&equo; he replied. 
 &bquo;Can't do any harm. 
 But I don't think it would do any good.&equo; 
 Mark jerked the door open and turned to face the American eyes hardened with anger. 
 &bquo;Yes, maybe that's not a bad suggestion,&equo; he said slowly and deliberately. 
 &bquo;Speak to Jupe by all means on my behalf. 
 Tell him to stuff it up his arse.&equo;  
 On returning to his office the following Monday, Mark was surprised to find that it was now occupied by visiting American auditors. 
 &bquo;Couldn't you wait for the body to be removed?&equo; he said quietly. 
 The two Americans leapt to their feet. 
 &bquo;Sorry, Mr Sanders.&equo; 
 It was the older man, who had been occupying Mark's large black leather chair, who spoke. 
 &bquo;We weren't expecting you back. 
 We were told you were using the Treasurer s office. 
 Do you want us to leave?, 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Mark said with a sigh. 
 &bquo;No, don't bother. 
 I knew you were coming. 
 Sooner than I thought.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your secretary organised the transfer of files and your personal things,&equo; the other American said. 
 Mark nodded. 
 &bquo;Fine&equo; he said, reflecting on the finality of the situation. 
 &bquo;Then I'll leave you to it.&equo; 
 And he walked out of his office for the very last time. 
 The Treasurer's room was all dark teak furniture and the walls were hung with portraits of the top men in the Corporation, unlike the walls of Mark's office which were covered with coloured aerial photographs of the many European component plants which had come within his planning responsibility. 
 Flanking the portrait of the Chairman, Tom O'Reilly, were those of the President and Chief Executive officer, Nate Cocello, the Head of  Overseas'  Operations, Mogadon Man, the General Director, Europe, Clancy McGillicuddy, and Pat Muldoon as Regional Manager of European Component Operations. 
 Mark was one level below Muldoon, so his portrait didn't make it among the VIPs. 
 &bquo;Thanks, Pat,&equo; he said sardonically, nodding at Muldoon's picture. 
 &bquo;Hope I can do the same for you some day.&equo; 
 He sat on the top of the large expanse of teak desk and stared coldly at the men who had made it to the top of one of  the biggest corporations in the world, employing nearly one million people. 
 A bitter smile crossed his face as his eyes ranged over the top men in the giant corporation. 
 He picked up the correspondence and miscellaneous papers in the in-tray and quickly scanned the contents. 
 OECD reports, technical journals, but no reports of future European Planning Committee meetings in Geneva, or Paris, Lisbon, Rome or Madrid, and no minutes of previous Planning meetings with resolutions which called for immediate action. 
 Nor were there file copies of his reports to the top brass on the European Business Plan, or copies of the vehicle divisions, plan for the private and confidential attention of Mark Sanders. 
 He was already struck off the circulation list and would soon be off the payroll. 
 He looked around the room. 
 None of the four phones would ring if he remained at the desk all day. 
 The white, hot line certainly wouldn't. 
 He was a redundant executive and nobody rang a redundant executive, except to say &bquo;Goodbye&equo;. 
 He opened the door which led to the secretary's annex. 
 Her chair was empty and would remain empty until he left the company. 
 The electric typewriter was covered by its hood and would remain covered while he was still there. 
 There was just no point in remaining on the premises when you knew you had to go, as Muldoon had said. 
 It was too painful. 
 &bquo;Use the remaining few weeks to say your goodbyes and to find another job,&equo; he had said. 
 Mark smiled the bitter smile of a disillusioned corporate executive and walked out of the office, closing the door slowly and carefully behind him. 
 Two days later, Mark arrived back at his temporary office to check the in-tray and tie up any loose ends. 
 To his annoyance he found that the Treasurer's office was now completely empty except for the four telephones set down in a row on the bare boards of the floor. 
 Even the carpet had been removed. 
 He shook his head sadly. 
 Couldn't they have waited just another couple of weeks until he had officially retired at the  end of the month? 
 Nothing surprised him any more. 
 He closed the door behind him and walked slowly down the corridor until he reached the top of the marble staircase, passing his own office and Pat Muldoon's without wishing to take a last look. 
 For one brief moment he paused to reflect on the finality of this his last visit which closed a thirty year chapter of his life; then with a wry smile he descended the impressive stairway. 
 He was glad he was getting out. 
 Glad, glad, glad. 
 For the first time in years he felt what it was like to be a truly free man. 
 Mark crossed the imposing entrance hall and went out for the last time. 
 At home that evening, Georgina asked Mark if he had any future plans he wished to discuss with her. 
 &bquo;What will you do, darling?&equo; she asked affectionately. 
 &bquo;No, sweetheart. 
 It's not what will I do. 
 It's what will WE do?&equo; he replied, rising from his chair to kiss her lightly on the forehead on his way to the Scotch decanter. 
 &bquo;Yes, of course, darling. 
 That's what I meant to say. 
 &bquo;What will WE do?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, I thought we might take a holiday in Canada,&equo; Mark said. 
 &bquo;Vancouver Island and the Rockies. 
 We don't have to rush. 
 We've got all the time in the world.&equo; 
 &bquo;That would be marvellous. 
 Just the two of us with nothing else to think about but each other for a few weeks. 
 Can't think of anything nicer. 
 But what about after that?&equo; 
 &bquo;We'll talk about that later,&equo; Mark said, sipping his Scotch thoughtfully. 
 &bquo;Maybe I'll write a book and then take up that offer to have a go for the European Parliament.&equo; 
 SOON THEY BECAME VERY MUCH AS IT HAD BEEN BEFORE THEIR separation, except that Gina was a little more violent. 
 Nigel needed more money now he had a mortgage and a wife again, so he started holding workshops in his own home. 
 Often, he had to hide the marks Gina had given him from his pupils. 
 He sat by the window, against the light. 
 He believed they might not be able to see the scratches on his face or the vestiges of a black eye that way. 
 On the other hand, he thought, if they did see them, most of the girls were too tactful to say anything. 
 They all fancied him and would think his wife must be a monster. 
 Gina almost always kept out of the way when he had anyone in. 
 He did the same when she had friends there. 
 It was a small house so they had to share a bed. 
 Anthony had the other bedroom. 
 Occasionally Gina invited circus friends. 
 If Nigel was there she gave them blankets and told them to use the sofa. 
 They were not as obliging as she was about disappearing before the weekly workshop. 
 Sometimes a pupil would arrive just as one of them was waking up. 
 The girl then had to sit nervously on the edge of the sofa &mdash; there weren't many chairs &mdash; while the guest stretched himself, yawning, naked and sweaty. 
 There began to be a great fall-off in attendance. 
 Nigel's lessons were flagging. 
 He was slightly anti-semitic, so he called the girls, who were from an exclusive private school, &bquo;little Jewish princesses&equo; behind their backs. 
 He told his literary friends that their stories and poems were so awful he didn't know what to say about them or how to get through the scheduled hour. 
 Often he made them criticize each other's work. 
 It saved him the effort. 
 On one of these occasions, one of Gina's old friends came in useful. 
 The  tattooed man sat up in the middle of the lesson, his blankets draped like a toga and barely concealing &bquo;Jane&equo; and &bquo;King Kong&equo; on his chest. 
 Nigel was flagging, but much to his relief the man took over and delivered an admirable lecture on French surrealist poetry. 
 The pupils thought he'd been brought in specially for their benefit and turned up the next week with more surrealistic pieces. 
 Nigel couldn't stand poetry of any sort &mdash; well, perhaps limericks or his own early efforts. 
 Surrealism was definitely the last straw. 
 Nigel pretended a relative had just died and managed to get out of most of the remaining classes of the term. 
 At first he had liked the thought of bringing in a lot of women to make Gina jealous. 
 The trouble was she didn't seem to care tuppence. 
 He might as well not bother. 
 It was all too much like hard work. 
 He would make the extra money by giving similar classes away from home. 
 Then Gina might worry more about what he was doing. 
 He got a residency for the next year at the University of Kent and spent half the week in Canterbury. 
 He could easily have commuted, but liked the ambiguity of living in two places. 
 He exhorted Gina not to use too much heat or light while he was away. 
 Every weekend, Anthony was bursting with news for him. 
 Sometimes it was just stuff from school. 
 Other times it was about Gina. 
 &bquo;Mummy had a photographer last week,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;She told me he'd come to take pictures of her throwing knives in the bedroom. 
 Someone interviewed her for an Italian magazine &mdash; they're doing a piece about her family, or so she says. 
 When I looked in your bedroom she had him in there with her and he'd left his camera downstairs. 
 I've taken the film out of it.&equo; 
 Nigel took the pictures to be developed. 
 Sure enough there were several of Gina throwing knives in their bedroom. 
 She had a target with a blown-up colour photo of him on it. 
 The earlier prints on the film were of men who were being rolled across canvases covered in paint. 
 &bquo;You see, Anthony,&equo; Nigel said. 
 &bquo;You had it all wrong &mdash; your mother was just doing her silly act, like these avant-garde artists. 
 It's men who are unfaithful to women, not  vice versa. 
 You'll know that when you're a bit older. 
 Women her age usually give up sex &mdash; she's a few months older than me, you know. 
 It was a waste of three quid getting these developed, so no more of your bright ideas, messing with people's cameras. 
 I'd probably have had to compensate that bloke if you'd broken it, and professional photographic equipment costs a devil of a lot, you know.&equo; 
 The next week Nigel was regaled with similar tales. 
 Anthony even claimed to have discovered &bquo;maps of Ireland&equo; on the sheets when he stuffed them into the machine in the local Launderette. 
 When Nigel was at home, Gina usually made him take them to the Launderette in a black dust bag. 
 &bquo;Here are your filthy sheets,&equo; she used to say. 
 He'd put his elbow up slightly as he took the bag from her because sometimes she would clout him with it. 
 It didn't really hurt as long as she didn't get his face. 
 He had the sort of sensitive nose that made him instantly burst into tears if it got the slightest knock. 
 There were more tales about the photographer in the following months. 
 When he thought about it, Nigel did find it a little odd that a photographer should return after he'd finished a job. 
 He ought to have been off somewhere else on a shoot by now. 
 On the other hand, Gina had assured him that he was doing publicity photographs for her. 
 Why should she bother to lie? 
 Gina was very proud of the photographs. 
 She had an artist friend print up some material for her, using a picture that showed her in profile. 
 She was proud of her long, flexible nose. 
 She had the unusual skill of being able to pull the end down like a tapir when she was angry. 
 (Nigel reckoned she would make an exceptionally good girner when she lost all her teeth.) 
 Soon, her beak was silhouetted on everything &mdash; curtains, cushions and upholstery. 
 She didn't sew herself, so she had an acquaintance from a theatrical costumiers run them up in his spare time. 
 It cost rather a lot, Nigel discovered when he looked at the bills he was expected to pay. 
 He agreed to pay them but told Gina she must give some Italian lessons or something in future if she wanted to  treat herself to things like that. 
 He had heavy commitments on the house. 
 Gina did indeed start giving lessons of a kind. 
 Sometimes she would disappear for days. 
 She had a room the other side of London &mdash; it was years, though, before Nigel discovered that. 
 When he checked in the new phone book to see that his entry was there he did not, of course, look through all the Hugheses. 
 When Gina was not smacking him with the laundry bag or scratching his face, they lived a life of complete indifference to one another. 
 That was why he preferred the violence &mdash; it showed she felt something for him. 
 He took to picking up pretty young girls just so that he could complain about her. 
 It made it all worthwhile. 
 His technique was to go up to one at a literary party and ask her for a cigarette. 
 To Nigel's disappointment, nothing ever came of these pick-ups. 
 He often invited the girls back to his house, but most of them came only once. 
 Some piece of rudeness from Gina would put them off. 
 If any of them hinted afterwards that his wife might not be thrilled at seeing them again, he'd say, &bquo;You can tell her to bugger off any time.&equo; 
 But they were the ones who buggered off. 
 If they'd really cared for him, Nigel reasoned, they'd have stayed.  
 NIGEL HAD NOT SEEN KAREN IN ABOUT SIX MONTHS AND WHEN HE finally called on her she was cold. 
 She had assumed that everything was over. 
 He tried to start things up in a halfhearted sort of way, but she gave him an ultimatum. 
 If there was to be any relationship, she wanted to see his head on the pillow most mornings. 
 She needed someone there. 
 Nigel of course didn't give in to blackmail. 
 He felt she was after entrapping him. 
 She had told him a tale, looking slyly at him while she played with his left hand. 
 &bquo;A friend of mine who's a florist got married the other day and she had a really lovely do and it cost almost nothing. 
 She used the roses from the last wedding she'd handled. 
 She just put a dash of bleach in the water and they came up lovely. 
 And she got all the rest of the stuff cost price because she was used to liaising with the caterers and photographers before other people's weddings. 
 They made an agreement that she would give them her left-over flowers for their shops. 
 Oh, and she got a lovely video made of her wedding day.&equo; 
 It all sounded so romantic, Nigel nearly threw up. 
 He mistrusted stories about &bquo;friends&equo;. 
 people often say &bquo;a friend&equo; did this when they mean themselves. 
 He'd used the same technique sometimes as a prelude to complaining about his marriage. 
 Karen went on. 
 &bquo;It's marvellous how good second-hand flowers can be. 
 I often clean them out of the church after the wedding. 
 The brides usually keep their bouquets, or rather whoever caught them does. 
 I caught one at my friend's wedding last week. 
 You know what that means, don't you?&equo; 
 She nudged him meaningfully. 
 &bquo;I was able to sell it again, too, with a renewed frill round the edge. 
 We used to use a sort of doily to go round them, but now you  can get washable plastic lace by the yard, which lasts much better. 
 Some miserable registry-office job wanted a bouquet in a hurry. 
 She was getting married in a plain cream suit, too. 
 Can you imagine?&equo; 
 At least he hadn't had to bother with flowers for Gina. 
 Their wedding, mercifully, had been the sort of rushed job that Karen was busy despising. 
 He began to appreciate his wife a little for her lack of romance and her low cost. 
 No, Karen was definitely getting ideas above her station. 
 He prided himself that he never dropped people &mdash; he was too chivalrous for that &mdash; on the other hand, if he poked fun at her she would probably drop him. 
 In practice, however, he found that Karen couldn't be provoked easily. 
 She didn't even notice he was making fun of her. 
 She regularly boasted about not having a sense of humour. 
 If he made a joke and she realized it was one, she used to butt him in the chest &mdash; she was much shorter &mdash; and say &bquo;You're silly!&equo; 
 For a little while it had amused him. 
 It seemed fresh and charming compared with some of the bawdy, world-weary journalists he had to deal with. 
 They always saw his jokes before he got to the punch line. 
 Yet the thought of being tied to Karen permanently made him sick. 
 Small doses of non-sophistication were amusing as a break from other things, but he wouldn't have been able to bear all that romance day in, day out. 
 Gina was at least unpredictable. 
 &bquo;Only uneducated women who've got nothing else to think about like show-off white weddings,&equo; Nigel said. 
 &bquo;They think having their picture in the paper's everything. 
 I get my picture in the paper &mdash; just a little one &mdash; with every article I write. 
 I don't need to dress up and spend thousands to get my  picture taken.&equo; 
 It was cruel but effective. 
 He could see a hurt, misunderstood look spreading across Karen's face. 
 She usually assumed that look just before he succeeded in reducing her to tears. 
 &bquo;But a girl's wedding's the greatest day of her life. 
 Everybody says so. 
 I'm not uneducated, anyway. 
 I've got four CSEs and I spent a year on day release, learning  about making wreaths and business management. 
 I won the Best Floral Tribute section in my class that year. 
 That bowl on the mantelpiece was what I won and a voucher for Stoner's &mdash; the undertaker's on Lavender Hill that also sells furniture. 
 We could get something together if you like. 
 We could put it towards a new bed head. 
 I like those padded ones, don't you? 
 I like the bowl best, though &mdash; it's lovely &mdash; cut glass, you know.&equo; 
 Nigel meditated on whether smashing her trophy might be the best way to make a clean break. 
 He lacked Gina's panache for throwing things. 
 He had been brought up with a lot of fine furniture and had always been conscious of its value. 
 Kicking the Sheraton cabinet quietly had been as far as he had ever gone in destructiveness. 
 (His parents had never even noticed the faint scratches. 
 They had a French polisher in occasionally to deal with things like that.) 
 Perhaps he could bring himself to back into Karen's bowl? 
 On the other hand, if it was accidental she might even forgive him. 
 He opted for smashing her china dog instead. 
 It was obviously very cheap, so she wouldn't expect compensation. 
 He hated its silly expression. 
 A past boyfriend had brought it back from a holiday near Genoa. 
 It had horrible china curls all over its head like a lousy perm and a red-silk bow round its throat. 
 The rest of the body was yellow. 
 It made nodding dogs seem in good taste. 
 &bquo;Why don't you give that piece of rubbish to Oxfam?&equo; he said, picking it off the mantelpiece roughly. 
 &bquo;But it's got sentimental value, as they say. 
 In any case, Darren might notice if he came round.&equo; 
 &bquo;He won't come round,&equo; Nigel said maliciously. 
 &bquo;Didn't you say he had a wife and a couple of kids now and worked in Basingstoke? 
 Oh no, he won't come round. 
 He's got shut of you. 
 He wouldn't be stupid enough to come back.&equo; 
 He could see that Karen was pondering whether to let one of her tears fall. 
 She cried fairly easily and it usually had some kind of effect. 
 He thought she would probably hold them back this time, as she had mascara on. 
 Black tears generally lose all sympathy.  
 Karen decided to arouse his jealousy instead. 
 &bquo;I've got plenty of other boyfriends, you know,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;And they're not old like you.&equo; 
 Nigel was stunned. 
 He'd never seen himself as old. 
 He wasn't really old, he reasoned &mdash; the mid-thirties weren't even middle-aged. 
 Men were different &mdash; thirty-six was only old for a woman. 
 He had kept his shape. 
 &bquo;At least I'm old  enough to know better than to buy a crappy kitsch china schweinhund like this,&equo; he retorted. 
 He knew she wasn't up enough in foreign words to understand him. 
 He suspected she would think that kitsch was something you ate in a wine bar. 
 Karen watched in puzzled amazement as he dropped the thing into the wastepaper basket. 
 Its long neck hit the metal rim and the head was severed. 
 Nigel thought it looked very much like that of a French aristocrat, with all those curls. 
 It rolled bumpily under the bed. 
 Karen bustled round with a pan looking for pieces. 
 &bquo;There might be bits in the luxury pile,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;What do you think of me now?&equo; 
 Nigel retorted. 
 He was terribly disappointed she hadn't flown at him or reacted more strongly. 
 He hated women who bustled around doing housework. 
 He always wanted to be the most important thing in the room. 
 &bquo;Well, I won't cry over spilt milk,&equo; Karen said as she finally recovered the last smithereen of dog. 
 &bquo;But I think you ought to see a psychiatrist. 
 I think you're having what they call a nervous breakdown. 
 I'll come and see you in the mental hospital if you promise not to cause a scene. 
 I might bring you some flowers, even., 
 &bquo;Oh, yes, second-hand ones you'd resuscitated with bleach, you mean bitch!&equo; 
 Nigel was shown out with Karen muttering &bquo;Well!&equo; behind him. 
 He realized, then, that a little professional criticism was all that was needed to finish their relationship. 
 It usually does the trick with anyone who loves their job. 
 He reckoned he had done her a service, smashing her dog. 
 Her place looked in better taste already. 
 If only he'd been able to finish off the plastic swan and the weeping-kid picture  there'd have been some hope for the flat. 
 He wondered if he'd have made a good interior designer. 
 He imagined himself in people's homes, earning money by displaying his natural taste. 
 Then he remembered the one designer he'd met &mdash; gay &mdash; and had second thoughts. 
 Besides, Carl had told him that it was a terrible job for a man of taste. 
 He had complained of having to include people's disgusting favourite items &mdash; the photographs on kidney-shaped dressing tables, the vile pictures and ornaments. 
 The only way to design tastefully was to start from scratch, he had said.  
 NUISANCES AS ISOBEL AND KAREN HAD BEEN, NIGEL FELT DEPRIVED at being left with only his wife. 
 There were times when he suspected he was just a meal ticket to her. 
 After all, she had not given up any of her friends for him. 
 The only answer was to find himself someone new. 
 He could tell that several of his students at Kent fancied him. 
 He was certainly the most personable lecturer there. 
 All the other lecturers were at least as married as he was and he, at any rate, had all his hair. 
 Nigel's novel was not doing quite as well as he had hoped. 
 It had sold a respectable few thousand &mdash; mostly to the literary and those who hoped to be part of that world. 
 Being an occasional reviewer himself he was praised by other reviewers who were also creative writers on the old &bquo;you scratch me&equo; principle. 
 But his book did not win any prizes. 
 Writing, Nigel had always felt, was quite a woman-pulling profession. 
 It definitely had more charisma to it than the Civil Service or teaching. 
 Nigel was proud of his reviews and would have liked another woman to show them to. 
 Gina had never had the slightest bit of interest in his writing. 
 Whenever he mentioned his novel she told him that only her  work was &bquo;true art&equo;. 
 &bquo;The artist&equo;, she said, &bquo;is never accepted in her time.&equo; 
 Nigel had slight doubts as to what her work actually was. 
 He didn't think she threw knives these days and mercifully she hadn't sung &bquo;The Cowboys' Christmas party&equo; since their time in Chelsea. 
 Occasionally he came in on her while she was engaged in odd projects &mdash; dressing up and prancing round their small bedroom, or reciting. 
 Sometimes she had an audience, sometimes not. 
 Sometimes she was directing others while someone held a  Super-8 camera. 
 One day he found her being rolled across canvas by two women in overalls. 
 She was naked except for a tampax and a lot of acrylic paint. 
 She sprawled awkwardly as one of the women lost control of her legs. 
 Nigel remembered he had never liked her body. 
 He rarely saw her naked, which was a relief to him. 
 He had once summed her up to a female student, after several lagers, as &bquo;no tits to speak of and even less bum&equo;. 
 Gina usually wore old dresses and woollies when in bed with him and always locked the bathroom door tightly when she took a bath. 
 He looked at the canvas, trying to track out the familiar hated form. 
 The print of her body was vague and abstract like those blots psychologists want people to interpret, only this one was cabbage green. 
 There was a central mark somewhere in the splurge that might have been the impression of a nipple, but he couldn't be sure. 
 Gina's friends told him that this was a &bquo;personal canvas&equo; and that it had more integrity than conventional beautified portraiture. 
 Gina forced him to staple it to the living-room wall behind the settee and opposite the television. 
 A lot of her friends dropped by to see it. 
 Occasionally, in the interim period while he was still unattached on the side, he talked of consolidating his marriage. 
 It was a good subject, he found, when he was chatting up his students. 
 He liked to hint that his relationship with Gina was some sort of grande passion  and that she was the love of his life. 
 One or two of the girls were impressed and imagined some dark, passionate, beautiful, Sophia-Loren type lurking in the background. 
 He had said that he was &bquo;married with one son&equo; on his book jacket, too, as if it was some unusual career. 
 In a way, it was. 
 It took a lot of effort and explanations. 
 It had something of the quality of a full-time job &mdash; a rather unpleasant one. 
 Nigel also told every journalist proudly that he was &bquo;married with one son&equo;, although he made damn sure they didn't interview him at home, where they might meet his wife, or worse still, her friends. 
 Anthony stayed happily normal through everything. 
 Gina  had wanted him sent away to school. 
 She had never liked looking after him. 
 Nigel dared to disagree with her &mdash; he had hated his own school and he thought he divined Gina's reason for wanting Anthony out of the way. 
 Perhaps she felt she might look old with a gangling adolescent son round the place. 
 After they had quarrelled, Gina lurked at a bend of the stairs and trod hard on Nigel's foot as he came up. 
 One of his toes was broken as a result. 
 He didn't care. 
 He just limped around gaining more sympathy from his students by hinting what a brute his wife was. 
 Nigel wanted a male ally at home in the shape of Anthony. 
 It made him feel less vulnerable. 
 Anthony sometimes dared to do the things that Nigel only thought of. 
 He could be encouraged into drawing moustaches on the profiles on the curtains or adding to the green nude in the living room. 
 Anthony could be quite inventive. 
 He even forged a plan for growing cress pubic hair at a point in the canvas. 
 They both spent a little time concealing a wad of wet blotting paper and seeds, then cutting small nicks for the cress to grow out of. 
 Anthony tended the canvas for weeks, watering the relevant spot discreetly with a sponge. 
 The paint surface grew a little cracked and mouldy, but nothing else seemed to be happening. 
 Eventually Anthony took the pad away and found a few albino strands growing behind. 
 He replaced the pad and teased these out through the slits. 
 Gina remained in blissful ignorance, while Anthony reduced his father to a state of helpless laughter every lunch time by demanding egg-and-cress sandwiches. 
 &bquo;We have no cress,&equo; Gina would storm. 
 &bquo;You are old enough to get your own food, like your fool of a father.&equo; 
 Nigel sometimes saw that he was a fool to have put up with everything. 
 It was not something that he could admit to the outside world, though. 
 Better to go on as before than do that. 
 He told various stories when journalists interviewed him about the book and pryed into his background. 
 Sometimes he talked of marrying Gina in the sixties to give her citizenship. 
 She was a &bquo;stateless person&equo;, he pretended,  one of the children of the war. 
 It seemed more romantic than the truth. 
 However, Nigel enjoyed whingeing more than lying. 
 He saved all his problems up for sympathetic women who were not about to write a piece on him. 
 He liked to keep the story of his life ambiguous. 
 The substance of one interview always conflicted with the next. 
 People got tired of interviewing him because they felt they were being made fools of. 
 Nigel went on for years basking in the glory of his first book. 
 He made jibes at the expense of more energetic writers, saying that they were cheap and did not rewrite enough. 
 He decided to go for the label of being a careful writer. 
 He could get more literary respect that way. 
 If he produced a book about once every five years, he could pretend to have been working on it all that time, even it he had cobbled it together only in the last two or three months. 
 Anthony was now away at the university where his father had taught. 
 Inevitably, he was studying English and Italian. 
 Nigel and Gina were left to each other's tender mercies. 
 There had been no other woman in his life for quite a time.  
 THE BIG FOUR-0 GAVE NIGEL A BIT OF A JOG. 
 HE WAS OFFICIALLY middle-aged now. 
 But then, what did he have to worry about? 
 Men were &bquo;distinguished&equo; at forty; it was only women who turned into old bags. 
 He celebrated his birthday by going out and getting drunk. 
 He was bought a few drinks by workmates then took off on his own, round various bars, to finish the job properly. 
 &bquo;I'm gonna be stinking pissed when I get home,&equo; he muttered. 
 &bquo;That'll serve Gina right.&equo; 
 Four Bacardis, three gins and two lagers later &mdash; he'd bought the lagers himself &mdash; he was stinking pissed. 
 The barman even told him he'd had enough &mdash; something they rarely do unless they think a client's about to throw up over the upholstery or start taking his clothes off. 
 A young tart took charge of Nigel. 
 She was semi-amateur. 
 Trade had been bad that night so she thought he'd be her last trick. 
 She took him back to her Streatham pad by taxi, paying for it out of his wallet. 
 He was too limp to argue. 
 The taxi driver helped him upstairs; he'd been tipped most generously. 
 In the morning Nigel tried faintly to argue about money. 
 Caroline claimed she'd bathed him, massaged him and that he'd had her several times dressed in school uniform. 
 He wasn't sure which of them was meant to have been in school uniform. 
 He still seemed to be wearing his favourite shirt and jeans. 
 His clothes looked undisturbed, if a little rumpled, apart from a sort of embossing of vomit on the front breast pocket of his blue silk shirt. 
 He rather doubted Caroline's story, but it was flattering that any woman should think she'd had him. 
 Besides, his head ached too much to argue. 
 She had to take all the money in his wallet, she explained, because her &bquo;business manager&equo; would beat  her up if she didn't turn in the profits. 
 He would be coming round to collect in a few minutes' time. 
 He was a very big ex-boxing and judo champion, apparently. 
 Perhaps Caroline didn't actually have a business manager, but had found that the mention of one proved effective. 
 Nigel did not risk arguing in case she was telling the truth. 
 He still owed her a fiver more than he had on him, she complained. 
 &bquo;I'll make the cash up for you, though,&equo; she went on. 
 &bquo;You can pay me next time you see me. 
 Maybe I'll give you a discount, too. 
 I always do that for my regular customers.&equo; 
 The word &bquo;customer&equo; was a turn-off to Nigel. 
 He did not need to pay for it. 
 He was an attractive man. 
 He determined not to give Gina any housekeeping this week to make up for his losses. 
 He cadged fivers off various old school friends and workmates to tide him over until he could get to the bank. 
 After a week or two's good behaviour Nigel began to feel the need to prove to himself that he could pick up a genuine, bona-fide amateur about the same age as Caroline &mdash; someone young enough to be his daughter, in other words. 
 This time he decided to take very little in his wallet. 
 He didn't want anyone mercenary. 
 He would go to a bar late and sip a long drink very slowly. 
 He would sit down next to a woman who already had her own full glass in front of her. 
 Alison was a travel agent's clerk, although she didn't express it to Nigel like that. 
 She was involved, she said, in fixing up tours for VIPs and high-powered executives. 
 Many of her gentleman clients were foreign and even the odd Arab prince had come to her office. 
 Nigel liked the sound of all that &mdash; he thought parts of her story might be an exaggeration &mdash; the Arab princes &mdash; but he recognized a good PR job when he heard one. 
 He wished that one of the journalists who'd interviewed him had expressed the substance of his life and work in such up-market, romantic terms. 
 Alison was greatly impressed when she heard Nigel was a writer. 
 She evidently had no concept of books other than  best sellers. 
 She wondered if he might be Jeffrey Archer in disguise doing his research. 
 Nigel said &bquo;Your place or mine?&equo; when they'd both duly impressed each other with lies. 
 He had forgotten all about Gina, as he usually did when he chatted up pretty girls. 
 Luckily for him Alison didn't say &bquo;Yours&equo;. 
 Instead, she let him know that she never took guys home on a first date. 
 He liked her Americanese. 
 She let him know also that she was a virgin and wanted to save it for someone special. 
 She was tired of younger men: &bquo;They only think about one thing.&equo; 
 Nigel determined to impress her by his abstinence and sensible qualities. 
 He told her that he respected her. 
 They fixed a date for the weekend and he kissed her goodbye. 
 He was reminded of Karen. 
 Alison had that same sweet naivety and the same hard, pursed mouth. 
 He would have liked something a bit more yielding. 
 He couldn't help being reminded of a cat's tight, shell-pink rectum. 
 But he supposed yielding mouths belonged to fast women who might be more risky. 
 He slapped on a little of a new musk aftershave that was supposed to make him irresistible &mdash; not too much, he hated obviousness in men. 
 He also combed a little Grecian 2000 into his hair for several days before his date with Alison. 
 He was careful not to do too complete a job &mdash; that kind of thing was noticeable. 
 He'd often despised older men for hasty, inept dying operations. 
 He left a sprinkling of grey at the sides. 
 He had read an article on Mills and Boon books, which said that young girls liked the distinguished professional older man. 
 Alison met him in the same bar. 
 Unfortunately, he soon realized, she saw her Pernod as a prelude to an evening somewhere else. 
 Nigel had never thought of a drink like that. 
 He usually drank a half of lager unless someone bought for him. 
 He had perfected the knack of making one really last, for which he was known and hated by several West-End barmen. 
 He wanted to find a woman of Alison's age, but one who'd be content, like the journalist old bags he knew, with one drink and a few quiet complaints about his wife and related problems. 
 He hankered after the  cheapness of Isobel and Fran. 
 They were too old for him, though &mdash; both well past thirty. 
 Nigel had once made himself unpopular at the office by writing in his column that women past thirty should shoot themselves. 
 &bquo;In fact,&equo; he'd gone on, &bquo;it would be most convenient if they did it on their birthdays. 
 Without all those old bags the world would be a much prettier place. 
 There would be just young women for men to compete for.&equo; 
 A host of angry letters from women over thirty who thought themselves beautiful had arrived at the office. 
 He had to write a tiny snippet insisting that it was irony and the editor printed a token letter by a woman who had pointed out that if only young girls were left &mdash; and not enough of them to go round &mdash; only rich old men would have any chance of sex. 
 &bquo;No woman&equo;, she had written, &bquo;genuinely fancies a man old enough to be her father. 
 The mercenary ones simply put up with them and pretend that they love them for what they can get out of them. 
 If the old fool doesn't die soon enough, or they get the chance of a better deal, it usually ends in divorce., 
 &bquo;Bloody feminist,&equo; Nigel had muttered. 
 He didn't take that copy of the paper home. 
 He didn't want Gina using those arguments next time he told her how much better he could have done for himself. 
 Apart from the expense of taking Alison to the cinema, Nigel's evening out was all he could have hoped for. 
 He was seen with a pretty young woman, was able to paw her a little without having the effort or commitment of doing more and had also enjoyed himself complaining about his wife. 
 Alison had shown enough respectable horror on discovering that he was married to prove she was a nice girl. 
 He assured her that he was unhappily married, never had sex with his wife though they slept in the same bed, and that they often thought of divorce. 
 (He wasn't really lying &mdash; they did often think of it even if they didn't get down to it.) 
 Alison's eyes had brightened at the word &bquo;divorce&equo; and she said that she would go on seeing him. 
 Nigel got taken home to meet her parents next. 
 He wasn't  entirely happy about that. 
 They lived in a council house in Wembley, which was a little off-putting. 
 They had gnomes in the garden, which was even more off-putting. 
 Alison looked quite like her mother &mdash; only the mother was over the top and wore too much make-up. 
 She was definitely an old bag. 
 She told Nigel proudly that Alison could have been anything she wanted, even an air hostess. 
 On his way home Nigel began to have doubts. 
 Alison was already becoming too much of a fixture in his life. 
 Nigel went out regularly, picking up girls. 
 If there were enough of them, none of them would dare to pin him down, none of them could claim she was anything special. 
 It proved expensive, though. 
 He still had not mastered the art of picking up a girl half his age who was not after his money, but he had found ways to avoid spending too much. 
 He regularly forgot his wallet and credit cards and got them to pay for him or be content with what could be bought on a little small change. 
 He made great promises for future dates but failed to ring the numbers they gave him. 
 Still, even operating in small change every night was expensive. 
 He told himself it was all good copy for his next novel. 
 He showed his editor, Jo, a few chapters, but her firm would not offer such a good advance as on the previous book. 
 These affairs, she complained, were even less real than the last lot. 
 Being a mere woman she objected to phrases like &bquo;twinkling nipples&equo;. 
 &bquo;Nipples don't twinkle &mdash; you must have fallen asleep looking at the fairy lights on the Christmas tree,&equo; she scoffed. 
 &bquo;Why don't you include some women who can talk sensibly &mdash; some who've heard of feminism and can spell it? 
 All the pick-ups you've mentioned are daft as a brush. 
 They're not even colourful, Dickensian daft. 
 Insipid daft doesn't make good copy. 
 You're definitely not the thinking woman's crumpet, are you?&equo; 
 He was tempted to tell her to hire someone from the gutter press if she wanted more earthy writing, or some bloody feminist if she wanted a sensitive novel. 
 He turned red up his right side while she was speaking. 
 He found that  only his right side could react. 
 It was a strange physical peculiarity of his. 
 He continued with the book in a half-hearted way. 
 Early criticism makes writing difficult. 
 If only he'd finished his new masterpiece before he'd submitted it to her critical eye. 
 The problem was that he needed money. 
 Maybe someone else would like the look of these few chapters. 
 A male editor might better appreciate the merits of his style: &bquo;twinkling nipples&equo; was the kind of phrase that would appeal to a real man. 
 What did Jo know? 
 Nigel began to think of other ways to finance his &bquo;research&equo;, since a large advance was not forthcoming. 
 He stopped giving Gina housekeeping. 
 He usually ate out &mdash; there was rarely any food in the house. 
 Gina was anorexically thin, more through meanness than design; she only ate when other people provided. 
 Her diet was mostly handfuls of peanuts and crisps from private views she had attended. 
 She had several artist friends who invited her and it was easy enough to crash into other ones if you knew when and where. 
 People rarely asked for your invitation card. 
 She used to cycle to them to save money. 
 She had taken over Nigel's old bike. 
 (He had always used a lady's bike as a teenager because he thought the middle bar on a man's one might do him a mischief if he cocked his leg over it carelessly.) 
 Once inside a gallery, Gina would sidle up to the bowls and shovel large handfuls of nuts or crisps into the pockets of the loose Chinese quilted jacket that she usually wore. 
 (In the first few, more romantic months after her return she had shared these with Nigel.) 
 Occasionally there were canap&eacute;s, too. 
 She preferred to eat as many of these as she could on the spot, as they were too messy to take away. 
 Afterwards she'd have a glass or two of wine to wash it all down. 
 She liked to save any money she got off Nigel and had her own private account in a building society the other side of London. 
 She didn't spend the money on clothes &mdash; he suspected she just liked to see it mounting up as an escape fund. 
 Nigel had found the pass book, but Gina tore it from his hands before he could see how much was in  her account. 
 He was used to her going through his pockets while he was asleep and taking what she could. 
 He made sure that he never had much on him. 
 He didn't like to risk her rage by challenging her directly. 
 Other men's wives did proper jobs once the children were off their hands. 
 He sometimes wondered why she hadn't thought of that. 
 Yet, poorer as it made him, he took a certain pride in keeping his wife. 
 He could pretend she was a good housewife, cook and mother to other men who were disgruntled at their wives, brilliant careers. 
 Not giving Gina housekeeping didn't seem to solve Nigel's financial problems. 
 He had never given her a vast amount, anyway. 
 It had been the same sum for years. 
 Gina got nastier and nastier when she didn't have money; she hit him much more than before. 
 &bquo;You are no good to me,&equo; she used to say. 
 &bquo;You do not give me things like other men and you cannot do sex.&equo; 
 Her English was still slightly odd. 
 &bquo;I don't want to,&equo; Nigel would retort. 
 &bquo;You're too old for sex at forty, or is it forty-one?&equo; 
 (He had always had difficulty remembering exactly when her birthday or any other girl's was.) 
 The interchange would usually end with Gina kicking Nigel on the shin, clawing him or hitting him if she had something in her hands. 
 Sometimes she would stay away for a day or two. 
 He never knew quite where she went. 
 When she came back she would say, &bquo;You think I am too old for sex, eh?&equo; 
 He was so convinced that she was, he just assumed she had stayed with some girlfriend to try to make him jealous. 
 He had quite enjoyed that kind of jealousy for the first few months of their marriage. 
 Now, though, he couldn't care tuppence. 
 Nigel began selling review copies &mdash; his own and any others he could cadge &mdash; to give a little boost to his income. 
 He had been too lordly to do this at one time, preferring to give them as Christmas presents. 
 While the booksellers were looking at his books he would quietly nick a few of theirs to sell to another shop. 
 It was a good little earner,  it paid the grocery bills for the week &mdash; his own, anyway. 
 He had keen eyes and quick hands, so it was a long time before he got caught. 
 Nigel ran through more and more young girls. 
 The youngest he managed to pull was just seventeen. 
 He was very proud of that. 
 He mentioned it to several of his male colleagues. 
 &bquo;You mind she doesn't shag you to death,&equo; one of them said. 
 &bquo;These young girls wear an old man's heart out. 
 Look at that sports editor over there &mdash; he's had four marriages and as many heart attacks. 
 Best way to go, though.&equo; 
 When he heard this, Nigel felt rather funny. 
 He knew he wasn't old, of course, so there was nothing to worry about. 
 Besides, shagging had not come into it. 
 He sometimes had sex with girls when drunk, he believed, but not otherwise. 
 There was a lot to be said for flirtation and mutual admiration. 
 It was more reassuring than anything committed. 
 His young girls didn't really give him erections. 
 He just felt pleased when he thought about the kudos of pulling someone half his age or less. 
 The curious truth about his erection was that he could never remember having a very full one. 
 As far as his cock was concerned he felt somewhat in the position of a toddler trying to fly a kite. 
 He'd see it raise slightly, but he couldn't quite get it up. 
 Some of his male colleagues boasted about how they'd felt with various women, raising an arm to show what they'd been like. 
 That was all alien and too coarse for Nigel. 
 He couldn't recollect anything similar having happened to him. 
 He reckoned that gentlemen didn't have such experiences. 
 Although he liked to be admired for his prowess, he didn't like male-talk of that kind. 
 He never peed in front of other men. 
 He used to flee into a cubicle at the sound of approaching feet. 
 He had never joined in the masturbation rites at school, either. 
 For a while he had thought that his masturbating friends all had VD and that it was a dollop of pus coming out when they pulled at themselves. 
 He didn't want anything like that to happen to him. 
 Some of his school friends had thought he was a cissie. 
 One or two had tried to see if he was interested in  other things, but he wasn't. 
 There were occasions when Nigel had wondered himself whether he was homosexual. 
 He certainly liked men more, but then he liked manly men not &bquo;bloody queers&equo;, so he had to be all right. 
 Besides, some of the women Nigel got drunk with told him he'd had sex with them, so he knew he was normal.  
 THE COARSENESS OF THE MEN AROUND HIM AND THE ANTAGONISM of feminists made Nigel decide to adopt a more cynical pose. 
 While he went on picking up young girls, he talked in a blas&eacute; way of lust being &bquo;expense of spirit in a waste of shame&equo;. 
 &bquo;I expect you don't expend much spirit if you're still the old Nigel we all know and love,&equo; Fran said. 
 &bquo;The most you ever bought me was a lager.&equo; 
 Nigel didn't mind her joke about the spirits. 
 It was quite a good one; he must remember to use it himself. 
 He didn't like her calling him old, though. 
 There was a time when he wouldn't have noticed it, but these days he was a little touchy about things like that, especially as Fran was now living with a man fourteen years younger. 
 He'd thought her a little too old for his own purposes, but always assumed she was there for the taking. 
 He comforted himself by assuming that she was just a mother-figure to the young man and there couldn't possibly be any sex in it. 
 Nigel knew that he would be the choice of any thinking woman, in spite of Jo's remarks. 
 He hadn't aged much in the last twenty years. 
 The mirror told him he still had his youthful figure, and the grey was all covered now. 
 His supple skin had no lines to speak of; he preserved it with various expensive creams and face masks. 
 He would flirt with the girls who sold them to him and pretend they were a present for his mother. 
 Although he believed thoroughly in the ability of these products to fill out the tiny character lines around the eyes and mouth, and to smooth his neck, he did not want to admit he was buying them for himself. 
 He resented the price of all these things and toyed with the idea of starting a relationship  with a beautician with a view to getting free samples. 
 But beauticians might be greedy financially, he reckoned, so that idea was discarded together with that of shoplifting. 
 Beauty counters and salons kept a tight watch, so it would be impossible. 
 He did however manage to shoplift vitamins and minerals galore from his local health store. 
 Zinc, he had been told, did wonders for the older man. 
 They had a few creams, too &mdash; aloe-vera gel and wheat-germ oil; these could be used as an alternative to the more expensive big-brand names. 
 He began to despise other men who did not look after themselves. 
 The care he took, as well as his natural good looks, continued to provide him with plenty of pick-ups in his early forties. 
 One day while he was in his favourite bar, busy impressing a young temp, his wife walked in. 
 He turned away and fiddled with his nails, hoping she wouldn't notice him. 
 The girl asked what the matter was. 
 Then Gina came over to their table. 
 Nigel looked up apprehensively. 
 He wondered if he should make introductions. 
 Would Gina cause a scene? 
 Would she hit him in public as she did at home? 
 Much to his surprise she chatted to him quite amicably for a change. 
 She even said &bquo;Hello!&equo; to the girl. 
 She had not mentioned being married to him, so he didn't mention it either. 
 &bquo;Who's that?&equo; the girl asked. 
 &bquo;Oh, just an old acquaintance,&equo; Nigel answered. 
 He felt that was true in a way. 
 Nigel's wife often appeared to haunt him after that. 
 He didn't see any reason to mind it, but he wondered how she had developed such a good instinct for discovering his whereabouts. 
 There was a sort of uneasy complaisance in their relationship now. 
 While he talked to a girl, she would sit at the bar and talk to the nearest man. 
 He felt the whole thing was turning into a game in which each watched the other and paralleled their next move. 
 If he went off with one of his girls he felt sure she would find someone to disappear with. 
 He despised her looks now, so he scoffed at the idea that it could be for sex. 
 Presumably she would just go and  have a coffee with some old, lonely man. 
 That was about her level. 
 The thing that perturbed him slightly, though, was that most of the men she talked to were young rather than old. 
 In fact they were extremely young. 
 He felt she was stepping out of her class, in a sense. 
 Yet they weren't attractive men; she seemed to have a line in short, greasy misfits. 
 None of them were up to him in looks. 
 Nigel got cross only when she brought the short, greasy misfits home. 
 His house was his workplace. 
 Gina shouldn't interfere with that. 
 She had never helped with any of the bills, so he felt that the house was his alone. 
 Gina's latest pick-ups were even worse than her circus friends. 
 Nigel also resented the expense of entertaining. 
 He did it once a year, on Boxing Day. 
 He used to buy in a lot of delicacies to pretend to his family that Gina could cook. 
 The delicatessen was owned by a most enterprising Indian who opened at all the times when other places were shut. 
 It was worth the expense of ready-roasted game and home-made puddings and cakes, Nigel felt, to cover up. 
 Gina didn't agree. 
 She often quarrelled with him after these family occasions and threw the remains of the feast at him. 
 She couldn't bear it if he spent money on anything consumable. 
 &bquo;Your family is not worth this &pound;81.84 you have spent.&equo; 
 (She always found and inspected till receipts from the bottom of his carrier bags.) 
 &bquo;Your family are just English pigs &mdash; they eat too much! 
 They have no culture like the Buffons. 
 My great-grandmother was from Paris.&equo; 
 &bquo;The Paris sewers,&equo; Nigel muttered inaudibly as she cracked the Stilton dish over his head. 
 The only times Gina brought food in were those when she was entertaining. 
 Nigel would try to find out when, so that he could invite one of his pick-ups as a counterblast. 
 He would provide food for his visitor and Gina did the same for hers. 
 But she'd let him have a slice of the cake she'd brought in if he gave her and her friend fruit or ice cream &mdash; whatever he'd bought. 
 Gina often produced a cake from the pocket of her useful jacket. 
 He suspected she'd shoplifted it,  as she usually had some small item in a plastic bag, too. 
 He felt she was definitely too mean to spend her own money on entertaining. 
 After all, she even resented him spending his. 
 He theorized that she went into a shop and lashed out a bob or two on something like a tin of baked beans. 
 While she was going round she would collar some dearer item off the shelves, slipping it into one of her capacious pockets. 
 He didn't care as long as she didn't get caught and ask him to pay the fine. 
 He was all in favour of anything that kept their costs down. 
 Once tea with their guests was over, Gina would put away her cake. 
 He never found where she hid her food. 
 He took to hiding some secret supplies of his own in his desk. 
 She usually found those, though, just as she usually found any cash or letters that he'd hidden from her. 
 When the food had been safely put away, the symbolism would start. 
 Sometimes she claimed that the wine her friend had brought was &bquo;sweeter than any you have given me&equo;. 
 In winter when she entertained she would send him outside to chop more wood for their open fire. 
 As he staggered back with some misshapen logs, she would hand the bellows to her latest friend and say, &bquo;You blow up my fire. 
 You are better at that than Nigel. 
 You are younger.&equo; 
 He didn't really like the way she called him Nigel &mdash; it was as if he was a stranger. 
 Symbolism had been fun in his early days with her, but it was something that had turned very sour in a live-in situation. 
 Occasionally he retaliated with his own efforts about the relative sweetness of something his guest had brought, but he usually said it in an unconvinced, muddled way. 
 The English are too down to earth for successful symbolism. 
 Gina's Italian and French ancestry made it come more naturally. 
 Sometimes Nigel wondered why he had got married. 
 He didn't seem to have the comforts of other men. 
 Occasionally he dropped hints on this matter to Gina. 
 She told him he was lucky to be married to a &bquo;beautiful, intelligent artiste&equo;. 
 Sometimes he quoted this phrase to others in a dazed sort of way.  
 NIGEL WAS COASTING THROUGH LIFE CONTENTEDLY ENOUGH. 
 HE HAD found a new publisher and his second novel was out. 
 He still wrote articles and gave workshops. 
 And he still picked up bits of stuff. 
 The new publishers were giving him a launch party and wanted names for the guest list. 
 Nigel's sympathetic male editor agreed to ask all the good-looking women writers he could think of. 
 &bquo;Won't be a long list, old man,&equo; he said to Nigel and they both laughed. 
 The do was at the home of one of the female directors of the firm. 
 Nigel didn't approve of her. 
 He thought she had too much power for a woman. 
 The old cow was nearly fifty. 
 He looked around for someone attractive to talk to. 
 One of the guests was a rather fey romantic novelist. 
 She had come dressed in pink, inevitably. 
 She reminded him a little of an older Karen, but he wasn't tempted. 
 After all, apart from being all of thirty-two, she was the wife of one of the editors and no woman was worth getting into trouble for. 
 Two others were journalists he knew already. 
 They were a bit tough and masculine in his opinion. 
 Worse still, both were also in their thirties. 
 &bquo;So where are all these good-looking women you were going to invite?&equo; he asked his editor. 
 Then he saw the newcomer. 
 She looked young enough in her skintight, royal-blue jersey dress. 
 Figures like that don't come on oldies, Nigel thought. 
 He cut in on a man who was starting to chat her up &mdash; someone who had once given him a bad review. 
 &bquo;Have you got a cigarette?&equo; he asked. 
 Eleanor, it turned out, was a writer too. 
 She had some modest successes behind her with short stories. 
 He vaguely remembered her name from the literary magazines, where  she was quite well thought of. 
 He got a little tired of her complaints that male chauvinism had stopped her getting a book out. 
 He agreed with it all, of course, to ingratiate himself, looking deep into her large, green eyes all the while. 
 He could feel a slight erection coming on &mdash; the sort he had in bars when he met good-time girls. 
 He was a little surprised. 
 He thought he had programmed his body not to go for intellectual types &mdash; that is, if any woman could be described as intellectual. 
 He went to pee to compose himself. 
 When he came back, Eleanor had gone, so he wasn't able to get her phone number. 
 He thought he'd like to see her again as long as she didn't whinge too much about sexism. 
 She'd be good to be seen with and she had a sense of humour. 
 Looks, youth and professional success &mdash; she'd be perfect for upsetting Gina. 
 His wife, much as she might boast of the intellect of her pick-ups, couldn't pretend they were pleasing to the eye. 
 Compared to them, Eleanor had everything. 
 Nigel could be quite persistent when he had thought of something to make Gina miserable. 
 He wrote to Eleanor. 
 He got her address from his editor, who handed it to him with a nudge and a wink. 
 &bquo;Sounds like a bit of a raver from her stories,&equo; he said. 
 Nigel sent her a nice little note inviting her for a drink. 
 Eleanor wrote back wittily and they struck up a friendship. 
 Eleanor had just been photographed for one of the supplements and it pleased him to be seen with someone in the news. 
 He was very honest with her about his wife. 
 He told her he was married at once. 
 He also told her in great detail what kind of a woman Gina was. 
 By the second meeting Eleanor knew that Gina's friends walked into their bedroom. 
 By the third she knew how knocked around he was. 
 By the fourth she had heard that Gina was frigid. 
 Eleanor wasn't a particularly moral type. 
 By the time she's thirty &mdash; and Eleanor was thirty in spite of appearances &mdash; a woman has usually picked up her share of married men. 
 Nigel's wife was obviously such a monster, too, that it had to be any good woman's Christian duty to  save him from a fate worse than death, or at the very least to give him a little light relief. 
 Nigel seemed willing on the surface to receive this. 
 He kept asking her to ring whenever she was in London &mdash; she lived in Brighton &mdash; so that they could get together. 
 Yet he showed a certain reluctance to touch her, just giving her a few social kisses, one or two, on meeting or parting. 
 Sometimes he forgot and gave them again, which she took to be a good sign. 
 They got on remarkably well as friends. 
 They shared the same sense of humour as long as they kept off delicate subjects like sexism. 
 Nigel gave her a little useful advice on publishers too. 
 When they were not meeting they wrote long letters. 
 They wrote freely as if they had known each other for years. 
 Eleanor felt they were the funniest letters she'd ever written; Nigel brought out the best in her writing. 
 She had never found any friend before who liked exactly the same jokes about sexuality and the same bitchings about other writers. 
 With every letter she tried to top her last efforts and woo him with wit. 
 Nigel sensed all this and basked in it. 
 As long as she didn't get too serious it was all right. 
 He knew he was good-looking and ought to be admired. 
 For the time being she was useful to annoy Gina, but if she got too possessive he would have to drop her. 
 He liked her to phone him for two reasons &mdash; it kept his phone bills down and if Gina answered it proved that he was fancied. 
 Gina used to snarl &bquo; Allo !&equo; down the phone. 
 She was a little uneasy with the letter H and put it in other words, which was confusing; &bquo;hungry&equo; and &bquo;angry&equo; were often made to sound the same. 
 Sometimes she called Nigel to the phone, sometimes not. 
 Sometimes she said simply that she did not know when he would be back and dropped the phone. 
 Eleanor had discussed this reaction with Nigel, hoping that he'd volunteer to do all the phoning in future, but he just assured her that his marriage was an open one. 
 A few months on in their friendship Nigel began to be sick of the hints of affection dropped by Eleanor. 
 She had the cheek to think he might come to Brighton to see her. 
  (Why should he spend the fare?) 
 If he had a reading nearby he might of course be able to use her place and still claim hotel expenses, so it would not pay to fall out. 
 On the other hand, Brighton was near enough to get back to London the same night, so that wasn't really necessary. 
 He invented a serious accident for his wife as an excuse not to see Eleanor for a while. 
 She was most solicitous (scheming bitch!) so he told her that his wife was cured and they went back to the same old routine. 
 When Eleanor's book of short stories was accepted by a publisher he had suggested, Nigel found that he had mixed feelings. 
 He was pleased in a way that his advice had been proved good, but he didn't like the thought that a woman was catching up with him. 
 Eleanor wrote too fast in his opinion. 
 She looked all set to be a book-a-year person once she had the initial break. 
 He toyed with the idea of creating a little angst in her life to slow her down. 
 A writer should suffer and all that &mdash; it would be for her own good in the long run. 
 He started to pick the odd quarrel and cancel dates. 
 Eleanor just abused him thoroughly, which wasn't very womanly in his opinion. 
 Perhaps involving Gina more would add a new dimension. 
 The next time Eleanor rang him he would ask her to tea.  
 NIGEL BOUGHT SOME CHERRIES AS A ROMANTIC GESTURE. 
 GINA'S French blood would make her appreciate the similarity between the words &bquo;cherry&equo; and &bquo;ch&eacute;rie&equo;, even if Eleanor didn't understand. 
 Besides, he fancied some. 
 He was a bit bird-like, a picky eater (especially when he was paying), fast in his movements and very thin in the sort of way that brings out the motherly best in women. 
 He cultivated the image. 
 Eleanor came wearing a red suit, and he felt so turned on that he forgot to put the water in the teapot. 
 His psyche was telling him not to put something wet and warm in something else for her. 
 He had a kind of inbuilt guilt that saved him from most affairs, but also occasionally made a fool of him. 
 He called to Eleanor to come into the kitchen. 
 He could tell his wife afterwards that another woman had been in there. 
 Maybe she would even smell a whiff of perfume. 
 He wished he could instruct Eleanor to leave a hair grip, but she didn't use any. 
 Perhaps it would be worth buying a few feminine trifles to leave lying around? 
 Why, oh why, wasn't Gina there? 
 He hated it when she was tactful and allowed him space to meet women. 
 They went back upstairs and he talked dirty to Eleanor. 
 He could never resist doing that with an attractive woman. 
 But he avoided sitting on the sofa next to her although she'd left space. 
 He kept himself diagonally across the room as far away as he could. 
 He made periodic dives at the bowl of cherries poised on a coffee table by the sofa. 
 After twenty minutes, they heard Gina come in noisily, scraping her bike against the paintwork in the hall. 
 (How Nigel hated that habit of hers!) 
 He had a brainwave and called her in and introduced her. 
 She ignored Eleanor completely and  wouldn't even say &bquo; Allo &equo;. 
 To punish her, he ordered her to go downstairs and get Eleanor something to eat. 
 He half hoped she'd bring back a burnt-offering, the way she had so often in their first few months of marriage, when she had deigned to cook for him. 
 He wanted to see what Eleanor would do. 
 He had always had doubts about his own past reactions to Gina's behaviour. 
 Part of him wanted to take lessons from people of more decided character. 
 Gina returned, bearing a decent-looking slice from a Victoria sponge, much to his surprise. 
 Perhaps she was getting civilized in her old age. 
 Eleanor ate it slowly. 
 Perhaps it had even been home-cooked. 
 He couldn't really see without his glasses on. 
 Then Nigel had the bright idea of taking the two women for a drink at his local. 
 He fancied being seen with two women who were at each other's throats. 
 When he and Eleanor got into the hall, he called up the stairs to Gina but she wouldn't come. 
 &bquo;Perhaps you can bring me something back!&equo; she said sarcastically. 
 Nigel rather admired her talent for symbolism. 
 To turn the knife in the wound, he had mentioned to her the name of a local pub that had refused her singing act. 
 He did not take Eleanor there in the end, though, as there was one that was even nearer and cheaper. 
 He was rather cool with her, since drinking wasn't much fun if he couldn't stir it between the two women. 
 He made an excuse and went home early &mdash; there was a review he had to write. 
 He felt deeply disappointed in Eleanor's visit. 
 He had figured from her stories that she had a more passionate temperament and had hoped she'd shout and scream at his wife. 
 It had all been very tame. 
 Now he would have to face Gina's displeasure. 
 He did not bring anything back. 
 Gina was in one of her moods. 
 In fact she hardly spoke for days. 
 After a weekend of brooding silence and no service, Nigel began to think it had all been worth it. 
 When they eventually spoke it was to quarrel. 
 Gina ripped up one of his articles. 
 Luckily he had photocopied it before he provoked her into doing this. 
 &bquo;Your mistress&equo;, she said, &bquo;will not be  so happy when she gets home. 
 In fact she is probably ill or dying already.&equo; 
 He felt a bit worried at this and started to question her. 
 It was another day before she'd say, &bquo;You made me bring food for your tart so I poisoned it. 
 I sprinkled a little household cleaner on it.&equo; 
 &bquo;You never use household cleaner!&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Look at this place. 
 I'd be ashamed to bring my boss here or any influential person from work. 
 You never use household anything!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, yes I do &mdash; to poison your whores. 
 I am too good to serve food to them. 
 The carton I took from the supermarket said &bquo;POISON&equo; in big letters, and &bquo;Not to be taken internally&equo;, so she will be dead by now. 
 I do not care. 
 You are such a bad man bringing women home for me to cook for that the courts would acquit me.&equo; 
 Nigel went silent and white. 
 He didn't know whether to believe her or not. 
 But why should she lie? 
 He searched the kitchen and found the household cleaner standing by the tea caddy, a sprinkling of white powder beside it on the formica. 
 He went down there only to make tea or hide something in the fridge. 
 Neither of them ever cleaned up. 
 It could well be true, he decided and went to ring Eleanor. 
 At times like these he wished he had married an Englishwoman. 
 &bquo;Oh, is that you, Nigel?&equo; 
 Eleanor answered. 
 &bquo;What a nice surprise. 
 I've only just got up &mdash; I'm not feeling too brilliant. 
 I think I've got gastric flu. 
 I had a terrible time last Friday &mdash; your paper sent me proofs to correct the same day so I had to struggle up with them. 
 There were so many mistakes I couldn't do it over the telephone. 
 I was sick three times as I was trying to get ready. 
 I had to wash my hair too, before I went out, I looked such a mess. 
 I felt really faint so I went to the pub at the end of the road where your office is &mdash; can't remember its name. 
 Anyway, I fell through the door as they opened up. 
 My voice had nearly gone when I tried to order a brandy. 
 I think they thought they had an alcoholic on their hands.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I am sorry,&equo; Nigel said guiltily. 
 It wouldn't do any  good to tell her the truth &mdash; if it was the truth. 
 Perhaps it was  just gastric flu. 
 There was a nasty strain of it doing the rounds at the moment, and she didn't sound that unwell now. 
 It was probably a mercy that she'd been sick. 
 If his wife had put anything on the cake it would be long gone by now. 
 &bquo;Well, give me a ring when you're up in London, or rather before &mdash; when you're better, that is. 
 You must come to tea again. 
 I'll ring you.&equo; 
 He hadn't meant to say that. 
 It just slipped out. 
 Eleanor's warm, inviting voice had that effect on him. 
 Oh well, if she was unwise enough to come to tea, Gina was unlikely to try the same thing again. 
 In his experience she rarely did anything twice. 
 She was not even reliably cruel. 
 On the plus side, if she saw Eleanor alive and well it might frighten her into some sort of submission. 
 People who could live through poisonings, like Rasputin, had to be respected for their vital force. 
 Nigel decided to leave things a few weeks then issue an invitation to dinner. 
 Dinner would annoy Gina even more than tea. 
 He had often had tea with girls from his workshop. 
 She was used to that. 
 He couldn't fathom why she'd taken such exception to Eleanor. 
 He had never invited anyone to dinner at the house, for the simple reason that they never had anything he could honestly call dinner. 
 When he rang Eleanor he would explain that it was only to be a simple snack. 
 If the worst came to the worst he could cook it himself. 
 He was a mean hand at fry-ups; he'd learnt that at his public school. 
 There were electric rings in most of the studies, and the official meals were somewhat Spartan and not to every boy's taste. 
 With a bit of luck Eleanor might lend a hand. 
 His fried eggs were a bit scrappy: they needed a woman's touch. 
 Sausages, however, he could do to a turn. 
 If he added a bottle of wine, the occasion would be quite festive. 
 He wondered whether to call the invitation dinner or supper. 
 Supper was becoming a fashionable word and could cover a snacky situation better. 
 On the other hand, supper sounded too close to bedtime for his liking. 
 It would be easier to get rid of Eleanor after dinner.  
 Nigel hadn't heard from Eleanor for several weeks. 
 He felt sure he'd have been told of it at literary do's if she was really ill. 
 Although she wasn't popular with most literary men, they talked about her a lot. 
 It was often said that her new-found reputation was a bubble that would burst once people realized it was just the raunchiness of her work that got her a wide readership. 
 Nigel was inclined to agree. 
 After all, women can't write good classical prose. 
 That, like poetry, his friends said, has always been the prerogative of men. 
 Eventually, Eleanor rang. 
 Nigel was glad as it saved him breaking his own rules about using the phone. 
 He liked never to call from home; that way he could check up on Gina. 
 He used to pop out and use a pay phone, ringing publishers at awkward times like lunch time so that they had to ring him back. 
 If he knew that none of the call charges on his bill were his, it proved just how often Gina phoned her friends, in spite of any pretences she might make. 
 He could reproach her with it. 
 In the holidays, Anthony sometimes used the phone, of course, but he wasn't there much now. 
 He seemed to prefer to go travelling with his fellow students. 
 He should have finished at university long ago, but he kept taking extra courses, changing subjects and things. 
 Nigel had lost track of it all. 
 To his surprise, Eleanor was not bowled over by the dinner invitation. 
 She had the cheek to say that she felt his wife wouldn't like it. 
 &bquo;She wouldn't speak to me last time I was in your home,&equo; she complained. 
 Evidently she hadn't suspected anything else. 
 &bquo;You've got it all wrong,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;She's just gauche.&equo; 
 &bquo;Gauche at forty-five?&equo; 
 Eleanor laughed. 
 &bquo;Well, her English isn't any good.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I suppose I wouldn't be too polite in Italian,&equo; Eleanor gave in graciously. 
 &bquo;I do feel she doesn't want me there, though.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't even know whether she'll be there,&equo; Nigel went on. 
 &bquo;She doesn't tell me what she's doing. 
 Anyway, if she  does turn up, you can tell her to bugger off for all I care!&equo; 
 Nigel felt very brave shooting his old bugger-off line. 
 He rather hoped that Eleanor would say this, even though other girls hadn't. 
 She might be the only one brave enough. 
 She would do it if she really cared for him, he believed. 
 Eleanor accepted the invitation in the end, but opted to come to tea. 
 Nigel was looking forward to the occasion and Gina had promised to be especially nice and polite as long as she could have one of her friends there to make up a foursome.  
 GINA WAS INDEED PERFECTLY NICE AND POLITE WHEN ELEANOR came to tea. 
 Disappointingly so, from Nigel's point of view. 
 This time, Eleanor had brought a cake of her own &mdash; she was good at making them. 
 It was an odd gesture, but one he appreciated. 
 He would have preferred a showdown with Gina, but it was fun to watch Eleanor fighting her by stealth. 
 He wondered, as he enjoyed a slice of cherry cake, if he would be able to exploit Eleanor into further baking. 
 This time, Gina's &bquo;small, greasy artist friend&equo; annoyed Nigel to the point that he had to take Eleanor into his study to talk about them. 
 They weren't doing anything &mdash; they were just being polite &mdash; but Nigel was slightly afraid that the artist was trying to get off with Eleanor. 
 He had shown interest in her work and talked as if he took it seriously. 
 That was something men rarely did to women unless they had an ulterior motive, Nigel believed. 
 In the end he preferred to leave the man alone with his wife rather than risk losing his latest conquest to him. 
 They chatted about the artist. 
 Nigel was relieved to hear Eleanor run him down even more than he had. 
 Just to make certain she believed the man was having an affair with his wife, he assured her that, despite his penchant for painting boys, the artist wasn't gay. 
 Gina and Michel, the artist, had gone off together to some exhibition by the time Eleanor left. 
 Nigel accompanied her, as he was on his way to see his mother. 
 She was throwing a party and had invited him but, as usual, not his wife. 
 She was still trying to get him off with a nice society type. 
 He quite enjoyed the process although he never fancied the women concerned. 
 His mother would introduce him as &bquo;my  darling son, Nigel &mdash; he's such a talented writer, you know, and his marriage is on the rocks, poor dear. 
 His marriage had been officially &bquo;on the rocks&equo; for nearly twenty-three years. 
 Sadly, the old bitches his mother lined up were only a few years younger than him. 
 He had once questioned her on this point, saying that a man of his age preferred younger women to be seen out with. 
 She was offended and took it all personally. 
 &bquo;Young girls who go out with men your age are just gold-diggers! 
 When do you ever see a poor man with someone twenty years younger?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not rich!&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, and you don't have anyone twenty years younger.&equo; 
 &bquo;I've had a good few of them, Mummy.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, but they pissed off once they found out what your bank balance was, I'll be bound.&equo; 
 Nigel thought his mother was rather crude as well as not versed in the ways of the world and in what men want. 
 Maybe he would show Eleanor to her as a sample of the younger woman who was not a gold-digger. 
 Eleanor could be presented to his mother, even if Karen and Caroline and all the others couldn't. 
 She wasn't really young enough, though. 
 She was a mere twelve years his junior. 
 He needed some nice girl of Anthony's age to prove his point. 
 He broached the idea of bringing Anthony to his mother's next party, hinting his son needed help in getting a girlfriend, too. 
 &bquo;You get some of your friends to bring their young daughters,&equo; he said to his mother. 
 &bquo;Doesn't matter if they're still at school, as long as they're over the age of consent and on the Pill. 
 I don't want him getting into a mess.&equo; 
 Nigel had often thought of stealing a girlfriend off his son, but didn't have quite the same tastes. 
 Unfortunately Anthony usually chose college friends and Nigel didn't really take to bluestocking women. 
 Eleanor was a bit of a trial to him at times. 
 He preferred the sort of woman who put her foot in it with grammar and things; that way he could feel superior by correcting her at the time and having a laugh at her expense later with his male colleagues. 
 He speculated on the bevy of beauties his mother would  line up next time. 
 Perhaps he could arrange for Anthony to go sick at the last minute. 
 The more he thought about schoolgirls, the more distasteful became the forty-year-old debs that his mother had lined up for him. 
 He still turned on the charm, however. 
 It was all practice, after all. 
 He was able to do a good impression of a struggling young writer, as he looked more late thirties than early forties. 
 He had been careful with his hair. 
 As the women talked and asked stupid questions about his novels he imagined putting them in the next one. 
 It would be nice to be totally irresponsible, he felt, and get so stinking drunk that he could say what he liked to them. 
 As he shook hands and tolerated all the small-talk, he thought of saying, I don't think much of you, you old trout. 
 You've got jowls. 
 Just because you've bleached your moustache, don't think it doesn't show. 
 If you've got a daughter half your age I'd rather screw her instead. 
 He dared himself to say it to each new person. 
 By the time he got to the oldest, a tiresome socialite friend of his mother's, he started: &bquo;I don't think much&hellip;.&equo; 
 His voice quavered as he heard the silence around him. 
 He looked at them all and knew he couldn't. 
 &bquo;I don't think much of T.S. 
 Eliot,&equo; he faltered. 
 That would have made an impression at a literary party, but the old trout just replied, &bquo;Silly boy, I don't think you've been listening to a word I said!&equo; 
 Nigel got back to an empty house with no Gina. 
 She was still off with Michel, presumably, trying to make him jealous. 
 He wasn't. 
 He was pretty sure that Michel was gay, whatever he had said to Eleanor. 
 And his wife was definitely frigid and old. 
 She wouldn't enjoy sex with another man when she had never enjoyed it with him. 
 After all, he was better-looking than any man he had ever come across. 
 He took more care of himself and he had great natural style. 
 She was damn lucky to have pulled him as a husband. 
 And Eleanor was damn lucky to have him as an escort once in a blue moon. 
 They didn't know how lucky they were. 
 And there were all the other women he'd made lucky too &mdash; all the hairdressers he'd flirted  with, all the travel agents, florists and girls in bars. 
 They had all been lucky to be seen out with him. 
 When he was a famous, rich, literary-establishment figure living in Antibes or somewhere they would all realize it.  
 IT WAS THE SUMMER HOLIDAYS AND ANTHONY HAD COME HOME FOR good, or rather until he found a job. 
 The house felt overcrowded and lacking in privacy with him there. 
 It was big enough for two but not really for three, especially when one of them was a great big lout. 
 Anthony was always on the phone, rushing about like a bull in a china shop, or lying in bed till twelve with one or other of his girlfriends. 
 Nigel liked to lecture Anthony occasionally about getting girls into trouble. 
 It made him feel superior and worldly wise. 
 He liked to quote other men on the subject too. 
 &bquo;My headmaster always used to say: &bquo;Never sleep with a woman unless you're prepared to marry her!'&equo; 
 &bquo;Your headmaster was gay, wasn't he? 
 Anyway, you can bloody talk. 
 Mum got you into trouble all right with me, didn't she? 
 That's what you've often said. 
 Maybe you're not my dad, even. 
 I think of you as my father, of course, when it comes to Christmas presents and topping up my grant, but I'm not sure you've got a blood right to lecture me.&equo; 
 &bquo;All I mean is, you should be a bit more careful,&equo; Nigel said primly. 
 He didn't appreciate slurs on his manhood &mdash; even jokey ones. 
 If Anthony was somebody else's he could at least have the decency to shut up about it like his mother had. 
 &bquo;Oh, you think I should have a kept woman like Ma &mdash; not very modern, that. 
 I'm young and beautiful, I  ought to be kept if anybody. 
 I expect I could get some nice older woman to do just that. 
 Perhaps I'll learn to drive and be some film star's chauffeur.&equo; 
 Nigel looked at his son. 
 No, he wasn't beautiful &mdash; his skin was burnt a little pink and his elbows and feet were too big. 
  Although not unattractive, he was cut in a rougher mould than his father. 
 He lacked his elegance and finesse. 
 Nigel wondered if any film star would be discerning enough to employ him  if he  applied for a chauffeur's job. 
 He reckoned he'd fit much better into Hollywood and high society. 
 He had had a gentleman's upbringing. 
 The local grammar school had put too much of a gawky human edge on his son's image. 
 The thing that worried Nigel most about his son's affairs was that they made him feel randy. 
 He wanted to have a succession of girls to show off, too. 
 As it was, he just sat in the room below, hearing those sounds and trying to write. 
 Everything he wrote on those days seemed prurient. 
 There were even more twinkling nipples per square inch of prose. 
 He would have liked to have a girl of his own in there, instead of all the dull books to review, and the first scribblings of the rough draft of his new novel. 
 It would have been nice to have had somebody so that they could have been turned on together by the faint giggles and murmured conversation coming from upstairs. 
 Gina was not turned on by these sounds. 
 She used to get angry and go and pull the bedclothes off Anthony and his friends to make them get up and get out. 
 She screamed and swore at them. 
 She was especially angry if the girls dared to eat any of her food or drink her coffee. 
 She even hid the toilet paper so that guests could not use any. 
 Nigel asked Eleanor round once more and they were left on their own for a while. 
 He played soft romantic music, hinted about the goings-on upstairs, which had temporarily gone silent, and gazed into her eyes. 
 His wife was lurking in the basement all the time Eleanor was there, so that he did not feel safe getting close. 
 Otherwise, he told himself, he would have suggested a dance and gradually manoeuvred her closer to him until nature took its course. 
 He liked the phrase &bquo;nature took its course&equo; &mdash; he often used it in his novels. 
 He didn't like actual descriptions of penetration. 
 He used his best prose on the earlier stuff about tongues meeting and breasts being cupped. 
 He had a laugh after Eleanor had gone. 
 &bquo;The poor cow's  brought me another cake,&equo; he said to Gina. 
 &bquo;She really must be smitten.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps she was only trying not to get poisoned,&equo; Gina said. 
 They giggled and poked fun at Eleanor as they ate piece after piece of the cake. 
 &bquo;We would never &bquo;ave to buy food for ourselves if I half-poisoned all your stupid little fans,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Not that she is little. 
 She has a big bottom.&equo; 
 Nigel felt they were close for a few moments before the customary iciness set in. 
 He enjoyed the brief flash of jealousy and the home comforts. 
 Eleanor was just a stupid fan, of course. 
 His wife was often right in her perceptions of people. 
 Even if she wasn't attractive or sexy, Gina had some uses as a friend and confidante. 
 He always told her about his affairs. 
 He valued advice because he found it almost impossible to make decisions. 
 Or rather, he could make  them, but just didn't feel like abiding by them a few hours later. 
 &bquo;Eleanor&equo;, Gina had said, &bquo;is not an equal. 
 She isn't a fellow professional &mdash; a woman can't be. 
 You told me so.&equo; 
 Eleanor wasn't much of a woman, either; Gina had pointed that out to him, too. 
 If she had been, she would have married and had babies by now. 
 What a lucky escape! 
 He had nearly saddled himself with a desperate, thirty-one-year-old fan. 
 He deserved better than that. 
 Eleanor rang him a few days later and he was remarkably cool. 
 He toyed with the idea of telling her she wasn't woman enough for him, but decided not to. 
 After all, she was all right to flirt with at parties and escort him occasionally. 
 All the other literary women he knew were old bags of whom he would be bitterly ashamed. 
 He would keep Eleanor on tap for these occasions by writing the odd letter and by making the odd phone call too, when he could quietly use an office phone. 
 He would drop her, of course, sooner or later &mdash; or rather, he would engineer it so that she dropped him. 
 That was the gentlemanly way. 
 Gentlemen don't jilt ladies. 
 They just behave like absolute pricks so that the ladies have no choice but to drop them if they have any self-respect.  
 Nigel's usual way of putting women off had always been to cancel dates with ineffectual excuses. 
 He'd say that he'd suddenly remembered he had to go to the theatre with his family, or to a friend's engagement party. 
 He tried both of these old tricks on Eleanor and got thoroughly told off. 
 She had the cheek to say he ought to cancel meetings only because of ill-health or for work opportunities, not because he'd decided to go out with someone else. 
 If she'd been more of a woman, he believed, she would have meekly accepted his word and left it at that. 
 Others had. 
 She even hinted that he had been bullied into it by his wife. 
 He had told her that he had to be quick on the phone because his literary editor was listening to him. 
 It was the truth, but in the sarcastic letter that followed Eleanor put &bquo;literary editor&equo; in inverted commas. 
 Presumably she thought he was phoning from home &mdash; something he'd never do. 
 She seemed to be washing her hands of him. 
 It was what Nigel wanted in theory, but in practice he couldn't bear the whole thing ending acrimoniously, especially with her getting the last word. 
 She'd probably have the bad taste to put him in one of her cynical, satirical stories. 
 Perhaps she wouldn't get another book published if she had enough bad reviews, he hoped. 
 They had been very mixed so far. 
 When they met at parties Nigel continued to keep up a surface friendship. 
 There was no doubt that he was drawn to her; he would greet her before anyone else in the room, and kiss her, sometimes once, sometimes twice, sometimes cupping her face in his hands. 
 But afterwards his conversation was distant. 
 He often asked if she was leaving. 
 &bquo;I suppose you've got to catch a train back to Brighton now?&equo; he'd say hopefully. 
 The fact was that talking to her either in person or on the phone gave him a sort of erection. 
 It wasn't a full one, but it was enough to give him a little pain. 
 Erections had always done that to him. 
 He never saw sex as a relief to this pain. 
 He usually sneaked off to the lavatory and relieved himself by peeing and thinking of funerals. 
 Masturbation only seemed to make things worse. 
 He had found in school that he didn't seem to have the knack of  making himself come. 
 He got more and more tense as he pulled at himself. 
 It was partly guilt and partly a fear that he would not succeed. 
 He could feel his shoulder blades sticking out and a powerful migraine beginning. 
 He always had to leave off before he came, feeling sure his head would burst otherwise. 
 Neither was sex a relief. 
 He only seemed to have had it when he was drunk; he couldn't remember surges of relief, or anything else, for that matter. 
 All he knew was that he had always woken up with a splitting headache afterwards, and often wished he'd had the headache instead the night before. 
 When he was a child Nigel had thought of peeing as sex. 
 Someone had told him, &bquo;Daddy peed into Mummy on their honeymoon and that was how you were born.&equo; 
 The one pee, he supposed, had been enough to produce three sons at two-yearly intervals. 
 Of course, Nigel had acquired the technical facts at school, but they always felt less true to him. 
 Sex seemed an unnecessary thing in life. 
 You had to pee a few times a day to survive. 
 The other act was like some unsavoury childhood ritual. 
 He sometimes believed that whoever had invented it was insane. 
 Sticking your willy up strange holes had to be riskier than standing over a lavatory basin. 
 There was relief in peeing, that was different. 
 It was nice to fill up with Perrier till your bladder was bursting, then go in the gents and let forth a good stream. 
 Losing your erection is easy enough if you store up the right anti-erotic thoughts. 
 Nigel secretly wished that there was the equivalent to a girlie mag for men who wanted to be turned off. 
 He felt like starting one for like-minded gentlemen. 
 There must be many thousands of them scattered round Britain. 
 Nigel had a series of personal images &mdash; some from his past, some from fantasy. 
 He would remember every time he had been humiliated at school or home, exaggerating the feeling and circumstances involved. 
 If these didn't work it was on to the funerals &mdash; huge fantasy ones. 
 He would imagine the dead bodies of some pop stars he had admired, his mother, and a few pets  he had owned as a boy. 
 There would be hordes of mourners in very unfashionable black. 
 The bodies would look sordid and ugly, dressed in old, rather soiled nightshirts and laid in open-topped coffins, slightly tilted so that everyone could see the contents. 
 There were piles of bad-taste wreaths around and sickly tremolo organ music. 
 That image almost always worked. 
 It combined several emotions. 
 He'd feel a little bit of pity for his mother and the labrador he'd owned at eight, awe at the dead pop stars and disgust at the lack of fashion and the bad music played for the occasion. 
 That usually brought him down to earth. 
 Of late, though, after his meetings with Eleanor, he had had to go on to his third level of fantasy. 
 He sometimes had to disappear to the lavatory several times when they met in a pub or caf&eacute;. 
 He was afraid she might see him sticking out and start taking him for granted or make unwomanly advances. 
 It didn't pay to let a woman know you cared, or rather that your body did. 
 The third level of fantasy also involved a funeral &mdash; his wife's. 
 He would imagine Gina dead. 
 He would see her in the old holey woollies she wore to bed, rather than an old-fashioned nightshirt. 
 He imagined her screwed into some impossible position in her last spasm, her face looking grey and ugly on the pillow. 
 Then he would think of the undertaker forcing that convoluted form into a cheap coffin and the lid being screwed on. 
 Then came the funeral &mdash; another bad-taste affair. 
 Nigel found nothing less erotic than bad taste. 
 There would be the same tremolo electric organ, but this time there would be no crowds of mourners &mdash; only a straggle of Buffons doing their circus tricks. 
 When they had all left and her father, the grave-digger, had filled up the grave, Nigel would be alone. 
 Then he would stand and pee copiously on the trodden earth. 
 This trick always worked. 
 He would stand in the gents' cubicle and work his way through the fantasy, peeing in synchronization with the finale. 
 He always felt much better after, but he never dared tell the dream to his wife.  
 NIGEL AND ELEANOR HAD THEIR FIRST SERIOUS QUARREL A FEW months later. 
 Their friendship had straggled on in a passive sort of way; he'd been to see her in Brighton and played the romantic flirt, talking of Brief Encounter  in the pub and putting his hand on her knee. 
 He knew he could get away safely because he had a reading back in London that evening, and it couldn't lead to further meetings because he was going away soon. 
 He was taking one or two workshops and creative-writing courses abroad. 
 Then there would be the family holiday to save him. 
 Gina always insisted on one a year, somewhere in Europe &mdash; wherever her obnoxious family was performing. 
 He promised to send Eleanor a postcard, but didn't. 
 He promised to ring when he got back, but didn't. 
 Instead she got in touch with him as he knew she would. 
 She sent him a rather touching little note saying she needed cheering up. 
 Her flat had suffered a lot of damage in the autumn gales and some of her recent writing had been totally destroyed at the first-draft stage. 
 Nigel rallied round and asked her out for a drink. 
 She would be on her way back from a reading at the weekend and passing through London. 
 She had travelled somewhere way up north &mdash; Newcastle or something. 
 He arranged to meet her in his local. 
 It was easiest for him, he explained. 
 Nonetheless, he felt annoyed at Eleanor for trying to wring sympathy out of him in this way. 
 Saturday was an awkward day, too, for a married man. 
 His wife liked to keep track of him then. 
 He couldn't pretend he was delivering articles anywhere. 
 By the time he met Eleanor he was in a really bad temper. 
 Gina had nagged him and Anthony since they  had got up. 
 It was worse in his case, because he was a reasonably early riser. 
 He decided to get shut of Eleanor as quickly as possible. 
 He looked at his watch pointedly as they met. 
 He did the courteous thing, of course, and asked how her reading had gone. 
 She was full of it. 
 She'd had a really good, receptive, large audience. 
 He hadn't on the one occasion he'd been there &mdash; in fact they'd treated him rather badly, although he didn't like to admit as much. 
 They talked a little about his &bquo;troubles back home&equo;. 
 He told her again how cold his wife had always been. 
 Eleanor started hinting at an affair. 
 She had done that before. 
 Nigel liked to be loved and admired; he believed he deserved that, but he resented her thinking that she &mdash; a thirty-one-year-old &mdash; could pull anyone of his calibre. 
 He changed the subject sharply back to home troubles of another kind. 
 There was no peace there now, he said. 
 Anthony had just left university and was hanging round, not trying very hard for a job. 
 It was disrupting his own writing. 
 &bquo;Oh, you mustn't let anything spoil that,&equo; Eleanor said. 
 Nigel enjoyed her admiration of his writing. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry to have to say that Anthony is turning into an absolute bastard. 
 He treats women like rubbish,&equo; he went on, feeling envious of the quantities of them his son seemed able to pull. 
 &bquo;Oh, most men are shits,&equo; Eleanor said. 
 Perhaps she was meaning to be sympathetic. 
 Perhaps she rather hoped he would say, &bquo;I'm not a shit, am I?&equo; and hold her hand. 
 Her right hand was lying casually on the table. 
 He liked her hands. 
 They were slim, pale and elegant, and she wore colourless or pearl nail varnish. 
 There was nothing vulgar about these hands, not like his wife's plebeian paws with their chilblains and chipped red enamel. 
 He toyed with the idea of holding Eleanor's hand and getting romantic. 
 Instead he used her remark as the perfect occasion for a quarrel. 
 He remembered Gina's summing-up of Eleanor's character and told her that she only saw people as shits because she wasn't woman enough to hold a  man. 
 The phrase had rather a stylish ring to it he'd decided. 
 Eleanor immediately pointed out that he hadn't exactly held his wife, who was thoroughly unfaithful if half the tales he'd told were true. 
 &bquo;She can't be,&equo; Nigel said. 
 &bquo;You've got it all wrong. 
 She's frigid. 
 There's never been much between us in that way. 
 Besides, she's too old for it at forty-five. 
 We're just good friends.&equo; 
 &bquo;Friends!&equo; 
 Eleanor laughed sarcastically. 
 &bquo;By your own admission she's knocked you around and treated you badly. 
 I wouldn't wish a friend like that on my worst enemy. 
 You don't even look like friends when you're together. 
 Ordinary couples get to resemble each other. 
 You seem like strangers when you meet. 
 You talk as if you haven't seen each other for months, can't stand each other and can't wait to get away&equo;. 
 In his heart, Nigel knew there was some truth in what she was saying. 
 He did always want to get away when he was with Gina. 
 On the other hand, he realized that if he did, there would be financial penalties. 
 He was also cynical enough to believe that any other woman might be as unpleasant to live with. 
 Better the devil you know&hellip;. 
 Eleanor wouldn't be much better than Gina &mdash; she was nearly as rude as his wife. 
 When she was talking about Gina's marital infidelities she had called her &bquo;your old French stick&equo;. 
 &bquo;She's not French, she's Italian &mdash; well, mostly,&equo; he'd replied piously. 
 The conversation went from bad to worse. 
 Nigel told Eleanor that he despised her for making a pass at him. 
 He really was shocked at her. 
 Women were not supposed to do things like that. 
 They should always leave it up to the man. 
 He might have made a pass given time. 
 Or he might not. 
 Eleanor was nearly twice the age he felt he deserved, and it had been his ambition for a long time to have a girl just at the point when it became legal. 
 He would do all the foreplay while she was fifteen, then celebrate her sixteenth birthday &mdash; to the hour &mdash; in style. 
 But he didn't  want a virgin as such &mdash; they frightened him. 
 He wanted somebody else to have done the persuasion and taught her a thing or two first. 
 Much as he admired schoolgirls, flouting the law was too much of a risk for someone with a public image. 
 The sixteenth-birthday fantasy was a cherished one, but he hadn't found any takers yet. 
 After a particularly good dinner he had once dreamt that Eleanor had a younger sister of that age. 
 She had turned into Eleanor, in fact. 
 They were doing it in a large double bed in the middle of Westminster Abbey with choir and priests looking on. 
 That was the only real wet dream he could remember having. 
 When he woke up he found a little stain, which he thought must be a map of Ireland, on the sheet. 
 Usually with erotic dreams he woke before the end with a leg half over Gina. 
 The sight of her in the old tatty jumpers she slept in always brought him back to reality. 
 He didn't even have to think about funerals. 
 Nigel pondered his dream about Eleanor. 
 What did it mean? 
 In the end, he decided that it was more of a metaphysical thing. 
 The centre of Westminster Abbey stood for Poets' Corner. 
 He had fancied being a poet when he was a boy &mdash; before he'd been thrust out into the real world to try to earn a living. 
 Eleanor was mainly just a red herring, he decided. 
 The only meaning to that part was that he was on top of &mdash; i.e., surpassing &mdash; her in public. 
 Still, the dream had felt so real that he couldn't resist ringing her from the office to ask if she had a sixteen-year-old sister he could meet. 
 She had sounded rather puzzled and insulted. 
 The quarrel was the end of his friendship with Eleanor. 
 She had accused him of leading her on. 
 In his opinion, complaining a little about his wife and talking dirty or romantic by turns did not add up to that. 
 It was normal social behaviour. 
 Eleanor was wrong to try and pretend otherwise. 
 He usually talked and behaved like that with women. 
 It was his way. 
 He couldn't go on seeing her in the circumstances. 
 It was all going to cease to be fun if she wanted any action out of him. 
 By this stage Eleanor  was in tears. 
 He muttered &bquo;For Christ's sake!&equo; impatiently and offered her his used hanky. 
 She made do with Kleenex and blotted the black mascara off her face. 
 She still looked attractive, even with black rings round her eyes, he decided. 
 It was rather nice to have a woman crying over him. 
 Still, he had to do the honourable thing&hellip;. 
 If she couldn't take hints he would tell her he had somebody else. 
 Karen was the one he'd stuck with longest, so he told her about his &bquo;little florist&equo;. 
 &bquo;She has an important job,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;She makes wreaths and bouquets for VIPs. 
 Embassies sometimes call her.&equo; 
 It sounded better that way. 
 He even told Eleanor her age and name to add credibility. 
 He walked Eleanor to the station in silence and gave her a parting hug. 
 She might think he was a little coarse doing that after saying he despised her, but so what? 
 He fancied doing it. 
 After all, she was the only woman to have cried properly for him.  
 NIGEL WAS GLAD ON ONE LEVEL TO HAVE SAVED HIMSELF TROUBLE by finishing with Eleanor. 
 He realized soon, though, that there was a problem. 
 He hadn't seen Karen for years. 
 That had been easier to finish. 
 You rarely run into people you know in London; there are too many millions. 
 But he and Eleanor moved in the same set socially. 
 He met her at a literary dinner a couple of weeks later. 
 He half wondered if she'd arranged it; women don't get invited to these things as often as men. 
 They were not sitting next to each other, luckily, but he found himself opposite her accusing face over drinks and remembered the things he'd last said to her. 
 He thought it best to give her a quick kiss and talk as if nothing had happened. 
 He hoped she would be civilized enough not to make a scene. 
 He could see her lip trembling and hoped she would not cry in public again. 
 He didn't want to be made to look a bastard to his friends. 
 He hoped also that she wouldn't do anything to him. 
 She had rather an athletic body. 
 It seemed possible that she might be into chucking men over her shoulder and spifflicating them. 
 He said &bquo;Hello&equo; nervously. 
 He saw her eyes flicker between his face and his balls. 
 Either it was passionate lust, or she was considering pouring her Perrier full of ice cubes down the front of his trousers. 
 He'd seen that done in a film and had always wondered how it might feel. 
 The moment passed. 
 Eleanor had obviously decided to drink her Perrier, bite back any reproaches and put a civilized veneer on the occasion. 
 He didn't see her again for quite a while. 
 By the time he did, her new book was out and her publishers had sent him an advance copy. 
 He was on their list of possible reviewers. 
 He read the stories  carefully. 
 Rather than carrying the usual disclaimer about the characters bearing no relation to living persons, the introduction said that these were real stories from Eleanor's life. 
 Perhaps her publishers had good libel insurance. 
 He was amazed and shocked at the contents of her ten stories. 
 In each one she had an affair with a different man. 
 Why, oh why hadn't she had an affair with him? 
 He recognized the symptoms of jealousy. 
 If only she had been less direct in her approach, he might have managed something. 
 He would have enjoyed the odd weekend in Brighton away from the pressures of London life, if only she'd had a bigger flat. 
 The problem was that she had only one bedroom. 
 If he'd stayed when he went to see her, he would have shown he wanted an affair. 
 He preferred more ambiguity and liked the idea of one or other of them sleepwalking accidentally into the other's room; that would have been less crude than prior agreements. 
 He didn't like women who arranged things. 
 Or if she had come to his place and told Gina to bugger off, obeying his instructions, he might have rewarded her and let her move in with him permanently. 
 The men in Eleanor's stories sounded much cruder than him. 
 They had accepted her situation as it was without these sensitive doubts. 
 When Nigel went into the Left Arts Review  he found that a good review of Eleanor's book was ready and waiting. 
 An admirer of hers had written it to ensure some early coverage, having got a proof copy from her publishers. 
 It had to be stopped. 
 Nigel couldn't really review the stories himself &mdash; that would look too obvious. 
 But he was temporary books editor while his boss was on holiday, so he could manage to fix something. 
 He handed Eleanor's book to a moralistic old bag he had once done a writing workshop with. 
 He disliked her because she had no sense of humour and was into Rudolf Steiner and spiritualism &mdash; she was a trained medium. 
 He had despised her thoroughly ever since she had given him some dire warnings about the state of his aura, and he felt she would be perfect for this review. 
 She was flattered to be asked. 
 She made little money from  journalism, having criticized too many auras for her own good. 
 If the literary establishment had thought to compare notes they would have realized that every male aura on and off Fleet Street had come in for a bashing. 
 Nigel gave Margaret Dulally several other books by people he hated as well, while his editor was away, saying that a line or two on each would be enough. 
 The favourable, half-page review of Eleanor's book was scrapped and the two lines by Miss Dulally inserted instead: &bquo;Her prose has all the lyricism of the tabloids. 
 It is a sad document of a young woman's promiscuity in an age when AIDS has made most thinking members of the public chaste.&equo; 
 Nigel laughed maliciously, but hoped that the old medium never got the chance to review his books. 
 What would she think of his twinkling nipples? 
 If he ran into Eleanor he planned to blame the general editor and make soothing noises. 
 She would probably be quite prepared to believe someone else was responsible as she was so besotted with him. 
 Life without Eleanor was quieter but less fun. 
 He wouldn't have to bear her quips about the unfaithfulness of his wife, but then he didn't have her delightful, amusing letters, either. 
 He missed her physical presence too, and dreamed of her oftener now he did not see her. 
 He thought of patching things up, but felt she would try to force him to an affair in some unwomanly way. 
 Young girls seemed short on the ground. 
 He believed he was as beautiful as ever when he looked into the glass, but perhaps the AIDS scare had stopped them picking up older men in bars. 
 There didn't seem to be any good-time girls left except, maybe, Eleanor. 
 She seemed a bright, unthinking product of the sixties, intent on enjoying herself when everybody else had settled down. 
 He had asked her about that. 
 She had said, &bquo;Well, I was only a child in the sixties, so I've got to have my sixties now.&equo; 
 If only they hadn't become so friendly, he was sure he would have enjoyed having a relationship with her; but he had a rule about not mixing sex with friendship. 
 That could lead to tiresome complications.  
 Gina read Eleanor's stories in bed every night for weeks. 
 She was rather a slow reader as English wasn't her first language. 
 After the first two stories she said, &bquo;She is a whore. 
 You had a lucky escape, my Nigel. 
 You must always take my advice. 
 I am a woman of the world. 
 I know a whore when I see one.&equo; 
 He muttered, &bquo;When you look in the glass.&equo; 
 He altered that to, &bquo;Can you put the light out, dear?&equo; when she bashed him with the book and asked him to repeat what he had said. 
 Life never seemed to change.  
 NIGEL'S LIFE BECAME AN UNRELIEVED SUCCESSION OF BOOK REVIEWS. 
 His regular column on the London Literary Times  had been axed, but the editor still chucked scraps of work his way. 
 Other papers did too. 
 He hated reviewing. 
 It was too much work for too little money, especially when it was a short review. 
 Editors often cut a vital sentence, too, and made the whole thing unbalanced. 
 It was a corrupt world. 
 Often they axed the only approving comments, so that he looked a complete bastard. 
 Still, he quite liked making jokes at the expense of other authors. 
 That was the one consolation. 
 It was nice to home in on the one naive sentence in a book and quote it, making the author look like a prat. 
 Nigel made many enemies and no friends with these pieces, but he prided himself on his integrity. 
 He never wrote entirely admiring reviews: &bquo;It's the essence of a book never to be perfect,&equo; he said, &bquo;so its writer must expect to come in for a little criticism.&equo; 
 They always came in for more than a little if they had offended him in the past. 
 It was a great way to get revenge for various slights, lost jobs, bad reviews or even undeserved success. 
 Nigel resented the attention that each and every author he reviewed was getting. 
 It ought to have been his  work out there getting a full half page. 
 He always brought his reviews into offices personally and sometimes got taken out to lunch. 
 It was nice not to have to buy food. 
 He always ate heartily on these occasions. 
 He would have liked to have taken a doggy bag to restaurants and collar extras he couldn't quite fit in, like garlic bread, crusty granary rolls and After Eights. 
 He longed to take away enough for breakfast or make a quick sandwich of the hors d'oeuvres for later. 
 Regretfully, he had to let it  all pass; he knew such behaviour would have created a bad impression with editors and got him laughed at &mdash; the thing he most feared. 
 He had stopped bringing groceries home, so the extras would have been useful. 
 He never brought in anything unless he had plans to eat it right away. 
 Then it was usually delicatessen, a filled roll or some cheese or fruit, anything that could be gobbled up quickly. 
 Sometimes he went to his mother's for dinner. 
 She fed him well, but he was not comfortable there, as she nearly always had a younger man around. 
 Some of them were even younger than he. 
 Gina and Nigel had had no guests for a year now. 
 Even Anthony was staying away. 
 He was busy &bquo;bumming his way round Europe&equo; in imitation of his father. 
 Nigel sometimes felt he didn't deserve such imitative admiration. 
 He didn't tell Anthony that his parents had paid for his travels. 
 Anthony was doing things the hard way. 
 He had a manual of casual jobs &mdash; things like grape-picking, which had got him through the summer. 
 He had even saved a little. 
 It was harder to work casually in the winter, though. 
 The pay is usually appalling for those who don't speak much of any language but their own and want cash in hand with few questions asked. 
 The last Nigel heard, Anthony was working on an archaeological site in northern Italy. 
 It wasn't a paid job. 
 He just got dormitory accommodation and as much food as he could eat. 
 Knowing Anthony's appetite that was probably a very fair deal, Nigel thought. 
 He had always resented the amount his son ate. 
 It seemed superhuman at times. 
 Anthony would probably move on sooner or later; his bosses, two Anglo-Italian academics, had already warned him about the carelessness of his work. 
 Anthony was fine with a pick, apparently, but when it came to scraping away layers of earth with a trowel and saving small pieces of pottery, he simply did not have the patience. 
 Nigel was fond enough of him in his way, but he didn't want him coming home too soon. 
 The house felt packed to overflowing with Anthony and his friends. 
 Gina was even nastier to him when their son was there.  
 Nigel saw little of Gina these days. 
 She was out every evening, sometimes staying away all night and coming back in the afternoon only to tart herself up for the next evening away. 
 He didn't ask where she went. 
 He had ceased to give her any money. 
 Why should he keep her? 
 She wasn't a proper wife to him any more. 
 She could make a small amount singing, or whatever. 
 She could get by on that. 
 That was her business. 
 She didn't eat much anyway, and looked thin and anorexic, even through her baggy clothes. 
 He had hardly ever seen her naked since the first days of their marriage, and she hadn't been anxious to show herself even then. 
 From the glimpses he'd caught he believed she'd had slight curves &mdash; he wouldn't have fancied her otherwise. 
 He hadn't seen her eat anything for a long time. 
 The last meal they'd had together was perhaps on holiday, or was it Eleanor's cake? 
 But then she was out such a lot. 
 He couldn't tell what she put away at her private views. 
 He remembered, from the one or two he'd gone to with her, that she was in the habit of pocketing things and crunching large handfuls of crisps. 
 She owned the packet of tea bags in the kitchen. 
 They were going down gradually, so presumably she made herself tea when he wasn't around. 
 Like him she never left food in the kitchen. 
 Apart from the mess of dirty clothes in the bathroom, their house hardly looked lived in any longer. 
 Nigel sometimes wondered if Gina was well to be as thin as that. 
 Maybe he should tell her to see a doctor. 
 But then, he reasoned that was her business too. 
 Perhaps she had already been to one. 
 She wouldn't tell him anyway. 
 He said &bquo;You don't look well,&equo; to her once, meaning to be sympathetic, but she clouted him and said, &bquo;It is living with an old man that makes me not well. 
 You do not look so well either.&equo; 
 He left her alone after that. 
 If she was well enough to be nasty, there couldn't be much wrong at all. 
 Life grew greyer by the day, but Gina could always surprise him with new horrors. 
 The latest was her glasses. 
 She didn't need them badly. 
 In fact, he believed she ought to have done without them for vanity's sake, as  he did. 
 No, instead she had got herself fitted with a big, bossy secretary's pair. 
 When she was being important and rushing around she would push them up into her hair. 
 At other times she would hold her scribblings at arm's length and let the glasses slide down her nose. 
 The darned things never seemed to stay where they were meant to. 
 Gina had ditched her performing side. 
 &bquo;Too old,&equo; Nigel had chuckled. 
 But now, much worse than that, she was taking up writing. 
 Her English was accurate enough, but there were slight awkwardnesses. 
 He offered, in one of his kinder moods, to smooth these out for her. 
 He would have liked her to be indebted to him for something. 
 He could have stood the writing as long as she had looked up to him for guidance like one of his young workshop pupils. 
 But her motives for writing seemed phoney &mdash; he believed it was just a form of competing with him and also imitation of Eleanor. 
 She had seen how deep his admiration had gone. 
 Gina was writing stories to be like Eleanor and also poetry, in imitation of Nigel's youthful ambitions. 
 She had even had some published in a horrible feminist magazine. 
 Nigel figured they'd take any old crap by a woman. 
 It was very embarrassing because she talked about the pain and degradation of sex and what a trap her marriage was. 
 He couldn't remember ever being given much chance to degrade her. 
 She hadn't complained about pain after that first night when she insisted on moving in and living with him permanently. 
 He was the one who got degraded, there was no doubt about that. 
 He was the one who'd been thumped, after all. 
 He was far too much of a gentleman to degrade any woman. 
 There were times, though, when he rather hoped a working-class bloke would take a shine to his wife and beat the hell out of her. 
 He would have enjoyed being solicitous after &mdash; handing her the Vaseline, witch hazel and bandages with a pious lecture thrown in. 
 Unfortunately, working-class blokes were far too sensible to take up with Gina. 
 They had enough real problems. 
 Gina and Nigel had a big scene after the feminist publication came out. 
 Nigel had got her measure enough by now  to know that he would never be allowed to insist on anything, so he approached the subject carefully. 
 &bquo;You are a married woman,&equo; he said in his best imitation of an authoritarian voice. 
 &bquo;If you must write &mdash; you don't need to by the way, I can earn enough to support my family &mdash; but if you really must, you should always write &bquo;Mrs Nigel Hughes&equo; at the end of it and tell the editor you are married to me.&equo; 
 &bquo;I do not want your stinking name,&equo; Gina said. 
 &bquo;It has brought me nothing but trouble. 
 It is common. 
 It is common Welsh. 
 There are hundreds and thousands of men and women called Hughes in your nasty cold country. 
 I will use my own name. 
 It is much more aristocratic. 
 There were Buffons in the courts of the Bourbons and Catherine the Great. 
 My grandmother told me so.&equo; 
 &bquo;What as? 
 Court jesters?&equo; 
 Nigel muttered sarcastically. 
 Gina pretended not to hear. 
 &bquo;Oh yes, my family is much better than yours. 
 I do not want my new friends to know I am connected to a boring man like you. 
 From now on I will publish everything as Gina Buffon. 
 I do not want to take your silly name any longer. 
 If I had a wedding ring I would give it back. 
 I do not want your emblems of slavery.&equo; 
 Gina had once owned a wedding ring, but had chucked it at him in an early quarrel before disappearing for days. 
 He had hidden it, thinking it would come in useful if he persuaded any girls to go away for the weekend with him. 
 He had visions of booking in to the same hotel several weeks running and a knowing clerk saying, &bquo;Ah, I see sir has a new Mrs Smith this weekend&hellip;&equo; as his latest girl flashed her ring on the desk. 
 He could feel the pride, but it was only a fantasy. 
 When Nigel got brochures from country hotels, the prices &mdash; even the special offers &mdash; looked far from what he thought reasonable. 
 No, if any girl wanted him she would have to provide the pad. 
 She would if she really cared. 
 That was what being a modern woman was all about. 
 Nigel still hung on to the wedding ring. 
 He told Gina he had sold it. 
 Perhaps he would do so one day. 
 He kept it, he told himself,  to give back to her when she was kind and behaved like a proper wire. 
 It was more tolerable that his wife should write her horrible effusions as Gina Buffon (not many people knew his wife's name) but it was still more than he could bear. 
 He tried to discourage her in every way. 
 He played loud music if she was writing in the house. 
 He made fun of any scraps of her work he came across. 
 When these things didn't work, he got her fixed up with a particularly incompetent agent who had ruined some of his friends' contracts through laziness. 
 If she still managed to get anything in the way of a book published he would persuade some friends to provide bad reviews. 
 He was a man of influence in the literary world. 
 He felt caught between the frying pan and the fire with the literary women in his life. 
 Eleanor's stories had made him jealous; his wife's effusions angered him. 
 Now Eleanor had gone one step further. 
 A colour supplement had published one of her stories in a series by new authors. 
 He recognized himself in the main character. 
 She had misunderstood the subtleties of their relationship and cast him as an ineffectual married man, always complaining of his wife, always on the chat-up, but never getting any further than that. 
 He picked up the phone &mdash; his own for a change &mdash; and rang her in a state of anger. 
 He pretended not to have read the piece. 
 He didn't want to have to comment too much. 
 &bquo;Oh, Eleanor,&equo; he faltered, &bquo;it's Nigel. 
 Something rather odd's happened. 
 A friend has told me that you've satirized me thoroughly in a story and spilled some confidences about my wife. 
 You wouldn't let out things I've told you in confidence, would you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes I would,&equo; Eleanor said. 
 &bquo;We're not friends any longer. 
 You dropped me, remember, and in such a cruel way. 
 Anyway,&equo; she went on, softening slightly, &bquo;that story's only fiction even if the James character is remarkably like you. 
 Do you know, the editor of the Observer  has had six married men ringing him this morning, threatening to sue  for libel? 
 Obviously they don't think it's you, if that's what you're worried about.&equo; 
 Nigel assumed she was lying, but it made him feel better. 
 He was sorry he had made a fool of himself by ringing. 
 &bquo;You understand the relationship's over?&equo; he said primly. 
 &bquo;Oh yes,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;You've made yourself an enemy for life instead of a friend for life &mdash; very clever, that. 
 I'd have done anything for you once upon a time. 
 Now, I'm only interested in revenge. 
 You told me all that stuff about your wife being unfaithful. 
 You've given me a heck of a lot of ammunition.&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know what makes you think she's unfaithful,&equo; Nigel said weakly. 
 The conversation wasn't going the way he'd intended it to. 
 He had hoped to make her apologize humbly and promise never to use him in a story again. 
 &bquo;I never actually told you she was unfaithful,&equo; he said, truthfully enough. 
 &bquo;I only told you about her staying away a lot and men turning up looking for her and things like that. 
 That doesn't really prove anything.&equo; 
 &bquo;But what about the other address she keeps?&equo; 
 Eleanor asked. 
 &bquo;What do you mean?&equo; 
 Nigel asked. 
 He was nonplussed. 
 &bquo;Don't you know?&equo; 
 Eleanor laughed scornfully. 
 &bquo;Look in the phone book. 
 It's under Gina Hughes. 
 I was looking for your number once. 
 You wrote and told me to ring &mdash; presumably you were too mean to ring me &mdash; but you hadn't given me the number. 
 Anyway, the Hugheses are all out of order in the book. 
 British Telecom hasn't quite learnt the alphabet. 
 Her name was there, in the wrong place. 
 Don't pretend it's another Gina Hughes, because I'll tell you something more. 
 Back in the bad old days when I was infatuated with you, I rang that number twice to find out. 
 The first time I just heard a sort of brassy actor's voice with a bit of Northern in it, so I apologized and said it was a wrong number. 
 I tried again a week later. 
 I had worked out what I was going to say. 
 I asked to speak to Gina Buffon. 
 I told the man that I was a friend of hers before she married Nigel Hughes. 
 He didn't deny any of that. 
 He just said  that she wasn't always at that address. 
 Could I leave my number for her to ring me? 
 I gave a phoney number and said my name was Claudia. 
 It was the only Italian name I could think of in a hurry and I didn't have the nerve to put on the right accent to go with it.&equo; 
 Nigel was disgusted but intrigued by the lengths Eleanor had gone to. 
 &bquo;You're barking up the wrong tree about the other address,&equo; he bluffed. 
 &bquo;I did know about it, of course. 
 It was just a bedsit she had early in our marriage when we parted for a while. 
 We've been back together for so long I'd almost forgotten about it. 
 We decided to keep it on and sub-let it as the rent was so low.&equo; 
 Nigel was not quite sure Eleanor believed him, but he knew he had presented a plausible explanation. 
 That was the most he could do. 
 He said goodbye to Eleanor coolly, then looked in the phone book for the other number. 
 He found it and rang it, giving exactly the same sort of excuse as Eleanor's. 
 He left his own number, calling himself Alain &mdash; the name of her Malaysian-French &bquo;business manager&equo;. 
 The next day Gina rang. 
 She had obviously not noticed that it was her own number. 
 &bquo;Alain?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;No, Nigel!&equo; he replied with satisfaction. 
 He felt a certain gratitude to Eleanor for giving him this idea. 
 &bquo;Oh, it is you, you lying pig,&equo; Gina screamed. 
 &bquo;So, you have discovered my little secret!&equo; 
 She dropped the phone. 
 Nigel tried to confront her with her little secret that evening. 
 But she just spat in his face and went out, slamming the door so hard that a picture of herself fell off the wall. 
 He looked in the mirror and could see a gout of her smoker's phlegm on his cheek. 
 She disgusted him more every day. 
 There was nothing more he could say in the way of argument, so he decided to plague her other address with mail. 
 He searched through the free papers in the office when he took his article in, completing every possible coupon. 
 He fitted her out with catalogues galore. 
 He even sent &pound;1.00 (refundable on order) for her to have a brochure  of rubber rainwear and a free vibrator. 
 That was all she was good for, he figured. 
 Then there were free samples of pile ointment, Bob Martin's for constipated dogs (she was a bitch, he reasoned) and contraceptives. 
 He phoned in her name and number in response to various job ads &mdash; masseuses, escorts and a lavatory cleaner. 
 She would be inundated with calls. 
 Then he sat down and typed a letter to every agony aunt he had ever heard of. 
 He had worked out a basic form for this and photocopied it, leaving blanks to type in the appropriate names. 
 Dear 
 I have been married for nearly twenty-five years to a very nice kind Englishman. 
 He is of a much better class than myself. 
 I have been unfaithful throughout our marriage. 
 I also hit him whenever I can and spit in his face. 
 He is a famous writer, so I also tear up his manuscripts and books. 
 I haven't had sex with him since the beginning of our marriage. 
 I never cook for him and I am totally undomesticated. 
 The only cleaning the house gets is when I force him to put the Hoover round on pain of a black eye. 
 I don't have a proper job so I don't earn much money. 
 Any money I earn I spend on myself or my lovers. 
 When they visit I expect my husband to be polite to them. 
 My husband feels he ought to have someone else on the side. 
 I would like to know two things: (1) What you think of the way I have handled him? (2) Is he entitled to a loving relationship with another woman? 
 Gina Buffon 
 That letter would really show her if it appeared in a magazine. 
 It took him all day to find addresses and write the envelopes, as there are so many agony aunts in national newspapers, teenage and women's magazines. 
 Some would of course reply personally (he had included postage). 
 Those  letters would be bound to point out to Gina how badly she'd treated him, telling her to reform and to save her marriage if they were religious, or else saying that she deserved it if he got someone else. 
 That would put her in her place. 
 He went out that evening to his nearest post office. 
 It was after hours, but he noted with pleasure that the letters would catch the 5.30 post the next morning. 
 In the middle of the night he had second thoughts and put on his clothes over his pyjamas. 
 He wore silk ones &mdash; he liked to treat himself well. 
 Part of the long top hung out beneath his short leather jacket and the material caught in the zip of his tight jeans. 
 Still, no one would notice at 8 a.m. 
 He went to the postbox. 
 He had remembered it was nearly full with all the Christmas mail. 
 He reached in carefully and pulled out a handful of letters. 
 He took them to the nearest streetlamp to read the addresses. 
 None of them were his. 
 He left them on the road and went and tried again. 
 As he fished, twisting his wrist back and forth, trying to get hold of more, a policeman came up and handed him the pile off the pavement. 
 &bquo;Haven't you forgotten these? 
 Bit late posting our Christmas mail, aren't we sir?&equo; 
 Nigel didn't like the sarcastic tone of modern policemen. 
 They watched too many things like Miami Vice  and had an exaggerated idea of their own importance. 
 Gone were the days of the humble bobby. 
 To put the man in his place, Nigel said that he was a writer who got his best ideas in the small hours. 
 Unfortunately, PC Dickens happened to be a writer too. 
 Although he was no relation to Charles, his surname had inspired him to pick up the pen. 
 He insisted on sending some of his &bquo;character sketches&equo; about life in the Force to Nigel. 
 He didn't need help placing them &mdash; the police have so many interesting in-house magazines with pictures of stolen objets d'art  and jokes and stories in the back. 
 All he wanted, he said, was a little constructive criticism. 
 Nigel went back home empty-handed and downhearted. 
 He really hated literary wankers who sent him stuff to criticize. 
 He'd never done that to anybody. 
 What had he  done in his last incarnation to deserve it? 
 What sheer bad luck to meet a literary policeman when he was trying to do something nefarious but necessary. 
 If any of those letters were published, and especially if they printed his initials at the end, someone &mdash; Eleanor for instance &mdash; might recognize Gina and himself. 
 The story would spread. 
 He decided to have flu.  
 NIGEL'S FLU DIDN'T EARN HIM ANY SYMPATHY FROM GINA. 
 SHE SEEMED rather happier than usual in fact. 
 He spent the first day in bed, after going to the Chinese takeaway to make sure he didn't starve. 
 He had an electric kettle, some lemons, a pot of honey and a bottle of whisky beside the bed, to make himself soothing drinks. 
 The kettle and glass left rings on Gina's magazines. 
 He was glad about that. 
 It was rather nice being ill &mdash; he could get away with not clearing up his dishes. 
 At 1 a.m. 
 Gina came in, switched the light on and woke him up. 
 She bustled around, chucking her tights in the corner and putting on old ballet leggings and socks with holes in to keep warm. 
 She went to the bathroom next and peed loudly. 
 He thought she should have been a little quieter under the circumstances. 
 &bquo;Draw it mild,&equo; he shouted. 
 &bquo;I'm ill!&equo; 
 She came back dressed in her old sweaters, all her war paint still intact, and climbed in beside him. 
 &bquo;You're not ill, you're sick,&equo; she said. 
 It was a phrase of his she'd picked up. 
 He'd used it about a lot of his friends behind their backs, particularly if they were homosexuals or had other sexual tastes he considered unusual. 
 He comforted himself that his wife, being foreign, had just repeated the phrase parrot-fashion and didn't mean by it what he would have meant. 
 &bquo;You ought to wash all that stuff off, you'll damage your skin,&equo; he told her, looking with distaste at her stale, badly applied make-up. 
 &bquo;You British wash too much,&equo; Gina said. 
 &bquo;My father told me that a woman's body odour was the sexiest smell in the world.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is that why your mother went round smelling like an  old goat?&equo; 
 Nigel quipped. 
 He relished the usual kick in the shins. 
 She didn't seem to be as strong as in her young days, and the socks stopped her catching him with her toenails. 
 The next day he went down unshaven to gather up his mail. 
 He could see there were no cheques, alas. 
 Most of it was just bumph, bills and Christmas cards, except for a bulky, strange-looking package which had been delivered by hand. 
 He put that by for later. 
 It might be a nice little present from a fan. 
 Women occasionally sent him things, at least they used to &mdash; alcohol, aftershave or their knickers. 
 There hadn't been so much of that though the last few years. 
 Later Nigel popped out to get some food, throwing a few clothes over his pyjamas. 
 It was the weekend sell-by date in his local Holland and Barrett's, he'd remembered. 
 There were usually some vegetarian pasties and things going cheap. 
 He wasn't vegetarian, but he liked saving money when dining at home. 
 Roast beef was for literary lunches. 
 He collared a chilli-bean pie, a couple of samosas and an almond slice at 15p each. 
 If Gina was pleasant to him she could share; if not, he would make them last for two meals. 
 The old cow at the counter popped them in the microwave to warm them for him. 
 He knew he could get away with asking her to do this &mdash; she had a bit of a weakness for him. 
 He rushed home with his hot food, mixed a lemon and honey with a large dash of whisky and proceeded to open his parcel. 
 Gina was downstairs, pretending to write. 
 The parcel was very well wrapped. 
 He tore all the wrappings off like a child at Christmas and out gushed a welter of handwritten scripts. 
 &bquo;PC Motherfucking Plodding Dickens!&equo; 
 Nigel groaned. 
 He dropped the lot into a shoe box and pushed them under the bed. 
 He couldn't face it. 
 It was enough to kill a writer who had flu. 
 The top one was called &bquo;A Modern Christmas Carol&equo;. 
 They probably did it at the policeman's ball. 
 What on earth was he going to do? 
 PC Dickens would probably find something to arrest him for if he wasn't nice about all this rubbish. 
 The next time he was found drunk and disorderly he'd have had it. 
 Or else  he'd catch him shoplifting books, or catch Gina down the supermarket. 
 Nigel was glad he'd sold the car years ago and not got another. 
 Motoring offences are the traditional area for police revenge. 
 They are very subjective, unlike shoplifting. 
 Even if you're not parked on a yellow line, the police can imagine you're travelling at forty when you're just doing thirty and so on. 
 Perhaps PC Dickens would arrest his wife for being drunk in charge of a bike with bald tyres? 
 Now that might not be such a bad thing. 
 In the end Nigel decided to deal with the shoe boxful quickly. 
 Fans hang over you if you don't do that. 
 He said a few kind but ambiguous words about the pieces enclosed being &bquo;eminently suitable for the audience they were aimed at&equo; and left it at that. 
 He would drop it off at the police station when he was well enough. 
 It would save him postage. 
 He would leave the packet open so that the desk sergeant saw they were not getting a parcel bomb. 
 By the third day Nigel realized it was boring staying in bed. 
 He had panicked unnecessarily. 
 Letters often took weeks to go into print, and the replies should teach Gina a thing or two. 
 He went downstairs, finished his column, then shaved and bathed and went out to the office ripe for conquest. 
 He could always have a relapse later if necessary. 
 There were only a few old women in the office. 
 They seemed to be everywhere. 
 Women lived too long these days. 
 Part of him hankered after the poetic Victorian times when women died in childbirth at twenty leaving their partner free to get another young girl. 
 Nigel had a quick look through the free papers, left his column on the editor's desk &mdash; he was still out for lunch &mdash; and shot off before any of the old women got any ideas. 
 There were older women on the tube too. 
 In fact they were everywhere. 
 Perhaps he had run into a pensioners' outing. 
 When he got home he was confronted by another older woman &mdash; his wife. 
 He liked to rub in her few months extra from time to time. 
 She was in a foul mood.  
 &bquo;Have you been to eleven Creffield Road?&equo; he asked smugly. 
 &bquo;That is not your business!&equo; she shouted and went upstairs to dress for the evening. 
 He believed she must have received some of his mailings by now as she was in an even worse temper than usual. 
 He quietly filled in a few more forms while she was changing. 
 There were market-research questionnaires, trial subscriptions and a free assessment of your perfect man from a computer agency. 
 He filled out all the forms making her older than she was and as uninteresting as possible. 
 He wanted Gina to see herself as other people would see her. 
 The perfect man the computer turned out would almost certainly be an extremely common old-age pensioner. 
 She'd be lucky to get anyone in fact. 
 Maybe the agency would write back telling her they had no one foul enough on their books. 
 He hoped so. 
 He had rigged the form that way. 
 Perhaps he could drive Gina insane with a little more work. 
 He fantasized about having her certified and getting a lot of sympathy. 
 Then he realized that people would simply say, &bquo;No wonder she went mad, living with that Nigel Hughes.&equo; 
 What he really needed to come out of this marriage smelling of roses was a lucky accident. 
 Then Gina could become a beautiful memory. 
 She was not sensitive enough to have died in childbirth like the women in nineteenth-century novels. 
 Anything but a lucky accident might well make him look an idiot. 
 Lucky accidents never come to those who need them. 
 Nigel was only a bit of a bastard and far too squeamish to stoop to murder. 
 He and Gina went on living together and nagging each other quietly. 
 He longed to ask her if she'd had anything nice in the post, but didn't quite dare. 
 She was spending more and more time out &mdash; presumably she was at her other place. 
 He would have liked her home more, because it made him feel in control. 
 She was a poor companion &mdash; they had nothing in common &mdash; but he hated her being absent and was afraid that, one day, a friend of his would come to see him and ask where she was. 
 Or perhaps somebody would phone, desperate to get in touch with her. 
  He imagined deaths in her family &mdash; some emergency. 
 He would look such a fool if he had to tell someone on the end of the line that he didn't know where she was and had no idea when she was coming back. 
 Most of Nigel's worries proved groundless. 
 There were no visitors to the house. 
 His friends had stopped coming and the workshops he took these days were in colleges far afield. 
 All the phone calls they received were for him, and Gina never had any mail. 
 Perhaps she had given the other place as her address? 
 He resented that and was determined that she should receive some mail at their address, under their married name. 
 He filled in most of the coupons again and got a further selection of condoms, Bob Martin's and catalogues. 
 As they arrived he would take them up to her in bed. 
 &bquo;Some post for you, Gina.&equo; 
 To his disappointment Gina never opened any of her mail in front of him. 
 She never brought back her correspondence from the other place, either. 
 She simply got up, scrambled some old jeans on, pinched one of his shirts and went off on her bike. 
 She packed her mail in the saddlebag. 
 She rarely even stopped for tea. 
 Sometimes he reproved her weakly about the shirts. 
 She always spoiled them, getting indelible make-up stains on the collar and wearing them to a state of greyness for a week at least. 
 He usually took his own washing to the laundry. 
 He liked the service. 
 Launderettes were for common people with common synthetic clothing. 
 Most of his shirts were fine Sea-Island cotton. 
 He hated having to hand in any that Gina had worn. 
 When he did, the prim man who worked at the counter often inspected them and said, &bquo;I doubt if this will come out, sir, but we'll do our best.&equo; 
 He believed the man must think he was gay and filthy, wearing shirts for a week and getting make-up on them. 
 He hated life even more with Gina away. 
 He wrote one or two nostalgic short stories about the pangs of love, drawing on past memories and exaggerating them. 
 These won him some critical praise. 
 Women reviewers  found them more sensitive than the stuff about his conquests. 
 The only time he saw Gina was in bed. 
 He wondered why she bothered to come back at all. 
 He hated her for making it impossible for him to bring women home. 
 He fantasized about all the ones he could have had if only he'd been sure that a gnarled form in holey sweaters wouldn't join them at 1 a.m. 
 He tried to tackle Gina about it, hinting that a young man like him needed sex from someone if he couldn't get it at home. 
 &bquo;I will lie back and think of the old circus days if you insist,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;But I will not enjoy it and I have an infection.&equo; 
 He didn't like to ask what the infection was. 
 Perhaps she was misusing English. 
 She had often done that in the early days of their marriage, and he had found it quite charming. 
 Perhaps she only meant she didn't want to give him her cold. 
 That was rather considerate of her. 
 Just in case it was anything venereal &mdash; though he didn't see what opportunities a woman of her age could have had for picking it up &mdash; he made sure that there was a larger gap than usual between them in bed. 
 He showed concern for her and gave her an old, baggy sweater of his to put over the other garments. 
 She had asked to borrow his pyjama bottoms but he drew the line at that. 
 Christmas was coming and Nigel hoped for a card from Eleanor. 
 She had done him a beautiful hand-painted one the year before with &bquo;Lots of love&equo; on it. 
 He thought hours of work must have gone into it. 
 It had made Gina furious with jealousy. 
 None of her admirers were as talented. 
 &bquo;Poor cow,&equo; he'd said to her about Eleanor, &bquo;she thinks she's going to get something out of me. 
 She must be really desperate.&equo; 
 He had looked in the mirror after the card arrived. 
 Yes, he was still as beautiful as ever. 
 He didn't seem to age like other men. 
 This year's card would relieve the monotony. 
 He was beginning to think it would not have been such a bad thing if he had had an affair with Eleanor. 
 His life seemed stuck in limbo with no sex and, worse still, no admiration. 
  Admiration was something he seemed to need most of all. 
 He had no books on the agenda and most of the pupils in his workshops were men. 
 Homosexual admiration was something he mistrusted. 
 In any case, he didn't even get that now. 
 Homosexuals seemed to have gone off him once he turned thirty.  
 CHRISTMAS CAME AND WENT WITH NO CARD FROM ELEANOR. 
 NIGEL realized then, for the first time, that his words had ruined their friendship for good. 
 He regretted that. 
 He was not one for burning his boats. 
 He had always like to dangle women as long as he possibly could. 
 He had reasoned that, like him, Eleanor would want to continue their friendship and sweep the quarrel under the carpet. 
 She had seemed so smitten, he assumed there was nothing he could do that would really offend her. 
 Nigel was left with just one woman in his life to torment, which was only half the fun. 
 His invention was flagging, too, torment-wise. 
 His mailings were falling singularly flat with Gina. 
 She was always in a terrible temper, it was true, but she never said anything directly about them. 
 If only she had come in shouting &bquo;What's this?&equo; and chucked the lot at him, he would have felt something had been achieved. 
 He was curious to know what had happened to the condoms, the Bob Martin's and the vibrator. 
 He tried to visualize what he would have done with them. 
 Being a man, he would have used the condoms and quietly dropped the other things through some charity shop's letter box. 
 If it was an animal charity the Bob Martin's would come in useful. 
 The vibrator, too, might well have some other application like soothing a dog's or an old lady's rheumatic shoulder. 
 He figured that the women in those shops were too innocent to know what it was really used for. 
 It was most infuriating not to know what Gina had done with all the free loot. 
 Even if she hadn't sussed out who had ordered the stuff, she should have asked for his advice and help in disposing of it. 
 He supposed that the man with the Northern actorish accent had given her all the advice she  needed. 
 Perhaps he was selling it all off a stall or using the condoms on some young woman. 
 Gina of course would be far too old to need things like that. 
 Nor had Nigel yet heard anything about the agony aunts' replies. 
 He had not seen any of them in the papers, so some had probably replied personally. 
 He'd have liked to have seen Gina reading one of their notes with a penitent expression. 
 It was all extremely frustrating. 
 He would have to think of some more immediate way of annoying Gina. 
 He was writing an article on &bquo;A Man's View of Women's Magazines&equo;. 
 It was the first time he'd bothered to read through them and he found much useful material for his hobby of persecuting Gina. 
 He found them enjoyable too and full of good advice on skin care. 
 He took to cleansing, toning and moisturizing his face once he found that soap was bad for it. 
 He was too conventional to use make-up but had no objection to skin-care products, eyelash or hair dye. 
 He had to buy a lot of different numbers of magazines to do his research. 
 It was to be a big article. 
 Whenever possible he selected ones that contained pieces on the menopause and left them lying around where his wife could see them. 
 He underlined passages about hot flushes and stress. 
 Gina tackled him eventually. 
 &bquo;I am too young for this,&equo; she said and handed him an article in return on the male menopause. 
 &bquo;Men in their mid-forties often seek reassurance with younger girls&equo;, it said. 
 Nigel was not amused. 
 He countered by leaving other articles around on pre-menstrual tension. 
 She couldn't have it both ways. 
 There were better quotes he could underline here. 
 There were incredible stories of battered, scratched husbands who sounded remarkably like himself. 
 He began to be convinced that this might be Gina's problem until he monitored her nastiness. 
 He kept a bedside diary giving her up to five stars a day for it. 
 He wrote girls' phone numbers in the back of the book so that she would think the stars were for something else if she snooped around. 
 By the end of two months, Nigel realized that his wife had permanent PMT. 
 Only poison, not evening primrose oil, could cure that.  
 Nigel was getting bored with Gina's lack of reaction to anything he did. 
 She hardly even spoke to him these days. 
 He read another article which said: &bquo;The average British couple watches television together for five hours every night and speaks about 150 words per person in conversation.&equo; 
 He wondered just how that had been assessed. 
 Having a nosy reporter around might well make a difference. 
 Still, it was another thing he could reproach Gina with that night in bed. 
 &bquo;We never watch television together and only say about fifty words a night, if that.&equo; 
 &bquo;You are a boring shit,&equo; she retorted, turning her back on him. 
 &bquo;You are a boring shit,&equo; he mimicked, counting up the words on his fingers. 
 &bquo;Stop reading and put out the light. 
 That was twelve &mdash; we are having a talkative day, aren't we?&equo; 
 The article on women's magazines was spiked. 
 A new female editor found it sexist. 
 Nigel was paid for his work, but he hated not seeing his piece in print. 
 He had worked so long on it and filled it full of malicious remarks at Gina's expense. 
 He had been looking forward to showing it all to her. 
 The bills were mounting up and Nigel seemed to be earning less and less. 
 He knew he could always go to his mother for help, but pride stopped him. 
 Gina never contributed a penny of anything she earned. 
 She wouldn't tell him about her income, even when he was trying to fill in his tax forms. 
 It had been an exceptionally lean year, all in all. 
 He hadn't had a book out. 
 His old royalties were down. 
 The education cutbacks meant that most of his workshops and readings in universities had gone. 
 With unsympathetic editors on the magazines he usually worked for, half of what he did was found fault with or refused. 
 He sometimes wondered if Eleanor had put a curse on him. 
 She looked a bit of a witch. 
 He sometimes thought about ringing her and asking her to take it off, but common sense prevailed and he did nothing. 
 Nigel began to believe, if it wasn't Eleanor, it must be  his health that was at fault. 
 He had been feeling depressed and lacking in energy. 
 The novel he was supposed to be working on hardly progressed a few hundred words in a week. 
 Something had to be done to get his energy level back to normal. 
 He was not an old man. 
 He started by reviewing his diet. 
 Everything with additives had to go. 
 On the one occasion that week that Gina brought home something, he complained about it. 
 It was sausages &mdash; an old favourite. 
 She seemed to have managed to collar a whole plate of them still on their sticks. 
 In the old days he would have been amused and asked her how she'd done it. 
 Had she pretended to wait on everybody at some private view, then walked out through the door? 
 But now, sausages were a hidden enemy full of things like E-additives and monosodium glutamate. 
 &bquo;You're trying to kill me with cholesterol and all that E rubbish,&equo; he said and stormed out. 
 He went straight up to Oxford Street and bought a tracksuit. 
 He had decided to take up jogging too. 
 He was slim and attractive, certainly, but his body was not quite as tense and muscular as he felt it ought to be. 
 A few weeks of this would set him up. 
 All the young girls would be queuing then. 
 The first jog round the block got his heart racing and gave him an appetite. 
 He was still supplementing his diet with various pills from his health shop. 
 He added pumpkin-seed oil, ginseng, royal jelly and a herbal complex to boost his libido. 
 Nigel also took up aerobics at his local sports centre. 
 He was the only man in the class, which meant he got a lot of attention. 
 He believed it must be doing him good, and he could certainly feel the burn afterwards. 
 By the third week the novelty had worn off, though. 
 He had learnt as much as he could from the silly young woman teacher. 
 All his classmates were either married with brats or disgustingly overweight. 
 Some were both, in fact. 
 He was horrified that women like that should think they were fit to be seen in leotards and striped leggings. 
 When one of the fattest hailed him when he was out shopping he decided he must disassociate himself  from that crowd. 
 Jogging was more of a man's sport. 
 He would stick to that. 
 In the weeks that followed, he found that the food supplements seemed to be making him put on weight, which was slightly worrying. 
 The young health correspondent on a new glossy mag he was freelancing for said it could be one of three things. 
 Perhaps his fat was turning to muscle. 
 Perhaps the ginseng had altered the balance of his Yin and Yang, which can do absolutely anything to a man. 
 Perhaps, on the other hand, he had a growth. 
 Nigel felt sure it must be a growth. 
 He didn't know where it could be as he felt no pain except a slight stitch when he did aerobics. 
 After three visits to his doctor, he was sent to hospital for various check-ups. 
 He was so certain something was wrong with him that the doctor had to arrange an appointment to shut him up. 
 Hospital was more comfortable than home, Nigel decided. 
 You got fed regularly and women waited on you and asked you how you felt. 
 One of the nurses seemed to fancy him. 
 It wasn't every day she got such a good-looking patient. 
 When his tests were all through, he decided to ask her out. 
 He was wearing his new pyjamas and he lay back seductively. 
 He had put a little bronze foundation on his face &mdash; a sample from one of the magazines. 
 One look in the mirror he kept tucked away amongst his things by the bed told him that he was looking decidedly well. 
 Perhaps he would take the nurse out on his way home from hospital. 
 It would save him the fare. 
 He was a little surprised when she said no and even more so when she told him that he was wasting the doctor's time &mdash; there were sick people waiting for these beds. 
 &bquo;Must be frustrated lust,&equo; he quipped to the man in the next bed. 
 &bquo;Bloody nurses, think they're God's gift with their sexy stockings and belts.&equo; 
 When he got home he started up his exercise routine again. 
 He would stand in front of the bathroom mirror in his boxer shorts and expand his chest a few times, breathing deeply. 
 Then he would touch his toes twenty times. 
 Sometimes Gina sat on the lavatory watching him  and making a bad smell or laughing. 
 It was very off-putting. 
 He didn't do any lying-down exercises because the floor was too filthy. 
 &bquo;If I get unhealthy because I can't do any sit-ups,&equo; he told Gina, &bquo;it's all your fault. 
 You really ought to give the place a going-over with the Hoover once in a while.&equo; 
 As soon as he was out of the bathroom he put on his tracksuit and hit the road. 
 He soon got to know the other joggers of the district. 
 Most of them were so seedy he began to have doubts about the efficacy of his chosen sport. 
 Half of them were old, bald men who nearly lost their elastic-waisted pants as they trotted round corners, puffing and blowing. 
 They'd left it too late, poor sods. 
 If only they'd started when they were young like himself, there might have been some hope for them. 
 They were disgusting. 
 They'd really let themselves go. 
 They had probably never had his good looks, either. 
 He came from a strikingly beautiful family, after all. 
 When he got too puffed to run, Nigel would put one foot on someone's wall and retie his shoelace slowly. 
 Then he'd bounce a little with his other leg out straight behind him to stretch his hamstrings and look like a proper athlete. 
 The jogging didn't really help his writing. 
 When Nigel came back he usually spent some time checking his pulse rate. 
 Often he lost count or forgot to multiply his fifteen seconds' worth by four to get the rate per minute. 
 He was worried by the results, and thought he must be dying to have as feeble a pulse as that. 
 He had believed after all the jogging that he would have the rate denoted as an athlete's on his chart. 
 Sometimes he looked in the mirror and pulled. 
 his lower eyelids down to see if he had anaemia. 
 He usually thought he did. 
 Of course it might even be something more dramatic like leukaemia. 
 He put this to Gina but she was not very sympathetic. 
 She never had been when he was ill; that was one of the things he disliked about her &mdash; unwomanly, he called it. 
 Gina was annoyed by his jogging, though, that was one comfort. 
 She had found the price tag off the tracksuit. 
 It had been rather an expensive one as he had gone for a  fleecy-lined designer number with flashes of blue, to match his eyes, on the shoulders and down the legs. 
 &bquo;You are a silly old man,&equo; she told him, &bquo;running along the road with everything jumping up and down. 
 It is not attractive.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about your lean old arse &mdash; I couldn't call it a bum in all conscience &mdash; grinding away on the saddle of your bike?&equo; 
 Nigel realized his verbal subtleties were probably lost on Gina. 
 &bquo;Arse&equo; to him was purely functional &mdash; a container for an arsehole. 
 &bquo;Bum&equo;, on the other hand, sounded a more curved word. 
 It was something that could be felt or pinched. 
 &bquo;You always leave your hair hanging down like a hippy too,&equo; he continued. 
 &bquo;It's not the days of flower power now, whatever you may think. 
 Next thing you'll be wearing a cow bell or painting daisies on yourself. 
 Don't expect to be seen out with me if you do. 
 And what about those shorts you wore last summer? 
 You've got no meat on you. 
 You shouldn't expose your lack of curves to the world. 
 You could get arrested for cruelty.&equo; 
 Nigel always felt he won hands down in a verbal fight. 
 Being a man, he couldn't hit back when she started on him physically. 
 Gina ran her bike over his foot viciously as she went out through the narrow hall. 
 The handlebar caught him in the groin. 
 It didn't hurt that much, but he pretended she'd got him in the balls, hoping for a little wifely penitence. 
 &bquo;I am so sorry,&equo; she said, then went out shrieking with laughter.  
 WHILE HE WAS STILL FEELING THE BRUISES FROM THE HANDLEBARS, Nigel sat down and wrote a story called &bquo;The Illegal Divorce,. 
 It was only about a thousand words long but of a high quality. 
 It concerned a man who did not believe in real divorces. 
 He was a very strong, patient, virile bloke who went on living with an awful woman because he had committed himself to a marriage. 
 They had agreed to live as if they were divorced, but continue in the same house together. 
 &bquo;Sharing the same bed when the spark between you has gone has a particular pathos&equo;, he wrote. 
 It was a subtle piece. 
 He even put the woman's view to a certain extent: &bquo;Miriam knew that their marriage was dead, but took comfort in the old rituals of going to bed together and getting up in the morning.&equo; 
 Even his feminist anti-fans couldn't quibble with that kind of sensitivity. 
 Evidently the jogging was working. 
 He was having new ideas at last. 
 He entered &bquo;The Illegal Divorce&equo; for a short story competition and won third prize. 
 He would have been happy with that if only he hadn't been placed behind Eleanor. 
 He avoided going to the prize-giving so that he wouldn't have to meet her. 
 Nigel always worked best when he drew on his own life. 
 His articles on his childhood and schooldays had won praise from time to time from all but the most dour Communists, who resented his privileged background. 
 There was no doubt that he could write well about high society, but the market for that sort of thing was dwindling. 
 Most of today's moneyed people were jumped-up and took no interest in the old way of life. 
 Nigel started to talk more about class in his new novel and less about twinkling nipples. 
 He was beginning to realize he didn't have popular  appeal, so he thought he would try to mould his work into the sort of thing bought by a small book-buying elite. 
 He would send notices of the book to his old school magazine and quietly pin up adverts for it in all the gentlemen's clubs in London. 
 He didn't belong to any of them, but he knew the doormen wouldn't challenge a man with his distinguished appearance and well-tailored clothes. 
 As Nigel became class-conscious again, he resented Gina more and more. 
 He had often told her that it was a social disadvantage having the sort of wife he couldn't take anywhere, but he dropped this line when she started appearing beside him at literary lunches and old school do's. 
 Yet she might almost have passed, being foreign. 
 A foreign accent is an unknown quantity; you have to be rather good at languages to tell whether it's common or not, and most of Nigel's acquaintances didn't speak any other language well. 
 The main problem these days, however, was Gina's appearance, especially the clothes she wore. 
 She now had a young designer friend who lent &mdash; Nigel sincerely hoped it wasn't sold &mdash; her a wide variety of sixties and seventies gear of the cheaper kind. 
 She had smelly white plastic miniskirts with heavy steel chain belts that must have belonged to some fetishist, and acrylic ribbed halter-tops clinging to her almost concave tits. 
 Often she wore platform heels and flared trousers. 
 Worse still, after she had made a little money from the publication of a pamphlet containing her beastly poems about him, she commissioned a rubber dress from &bquo;her designer&equo;. 
 She had it done cheap, promising to wear it in all the right places. 
 It clung to all the wrong places. 
 It was a sort of burnt orange colour with a large hole cut at the back so that the lean old arse Nigel hated so much could be shown to its full advantage. 
 She got someone &mdash; he was glad it was not him &mdash; to apply orangey sun-tan make-up to her bare skin to match the dress. 
 The first time she wore it, Nigel kept his coat on at a party so that he could hold the side out and cover the vision.  
 &bquo;Can't you have the decency to stand against a wall?&equo; he hissed. 
 &bquo;That is not the point of Helmut's creation!&equo; she said loudly, stamping on his foot and turning her bum out of range of his enveloping coat. 
 She walked across the room slowly on her platform heels and joined the woman from her new feminist publishers. 
 &bquo;You see that over there?&equo; she said loudly. 
 &bquo;It is my husband. 
 The man in the poems.&equo; 
 Nigel hoped his friends hadn't realized she meant him. 
 He hoped too that she would alienate her feminist editor, Jess. 
 A dress like that would certainly not appeal to the average feminist. 
 Jess had short hair, no make-up and wore trousers. 
 She would never wear rubber unless she became incontinent or was taking a course in scuba diving for women. 
 Gina's rubber number was more suitable, he thought, for a pornographers' ball &mdash; if there is any such event in London's social calendar. 
 On the way home in the taxi (Nigel was indulging them for once &mdash; he couldn't let Gina use her bike under the circumstances) he took delight in telling her she had a spot on her backside. 
 &bquo;I will squeeze it when we get home,&equo; she said, unabashed. 
 He vowed he'd put that line in his next book. 
 Nigel was unsure whether he hated the indecent rubber &mdash; which was at least up to date &mdash; or the flares most of all. 
 He had offered to take them to the local dressmaker's to have them seamed in to a more fashionable line, but Gina wouldn't even let him do that. 
 Nigel was very fashion-conscious. 
 He believed if only his parents had given him more confidence and the right backing, he would have made a very good male model. 
 He liked the fashion world and its reliance on youth. 
 He liked the way female models were thrown on the scrapheap by their late twenties. 
 Fashion knew a woman's place. 
 Nigel liked looking at glossy magazines. 
 There weren't really any proper ones for men, so he contented himself with Vogue, Marie Claire  and Harpers . 
 Luckily the local hairdresser's took them all so he didn't have to buy them. 
 He preferred having his hair cut and blow-dried in a unisex salon, even if  it was dearer. 
 Sometimes he managed to abstract a page he particularly liked and take it home, He had a whole article on a young actress who had been asked to model some clothes. 
 He pinned the photos inside his writing desk. 
 (He had a school-type one &mdash; it seemed to suit him.) 
 Every now and again, when he was writing, he would stop and lift the lid to gaze at Viola lounging in classic embroidered silks against the background of Hong Kong. 
 She was remarkably like Eleanor, he thought, but better. 
 She had that kind of gloss that only studio make-up and the last touches by a hairdresser can add. 
 Better still, she was only twenty-two, not in her bloody thirties. 
 After a week of feeling lovelorn and dreamy he decided to contact her. 
 His balls ached at the thought of her. 
 He was mystified by this phenomenon; it had never happened to him before, so he took it as a kind of omen. 
 After the first exchange of letters, he would tell Viola about it to impress her of his need and, indeed, his right to her. 
 Nigel's first note had to be sent through the offices of Vogue . 
 He knew that the office staff might open it and read it so he had to make it impersonal. 
 He respected her talent as a model, he said, and would she tell him where she was performing? 
 He would like to meet her. 
 There was no reply for a week or two. 
 He comforted himself by watching her on television. 
 There was a brief interview on Wogan . 
 She was all charm, all woman, he thought. 
 Eventually, he got his reply &mdash; a theatre bill. 
 She was playing the girl in Equus . 
 He believed she must have sent him the bill personally, wanting to meet him as much as he wanted to meet her. 
 He would treat himself to a seat in the front row. 
 Nigel went along on his own with a nice little pair of mother-of-pearl binoculars that had been in the family for generations. 
 He wore his best suit, a clean silk shirt and shaved extra close. 
 Actresses could see the faces in the first row. 
 He tried to assume an amorous but handsome expression throughout the whole. 
 It was hard, though. 
 He had not realized that it would be the sort of modern play where people strip off and simulate the beginnings of a  sexual encounter. 
 Viola certainly had a nice body. 
 He could see the texture of the skin &mdash; almost the down on it &mdash; through his powerful glasses. 
 Still, he was shocked that she should have chosen to play such a part. 
 She had talked of a sex scene when she was on Wogan , but he assumed it would be something more romantic &mdash; a magnolia bud of a tit peeping from beneath bed linen as she held out her arms to her lover and the lights went down at the end of the play. 
 Getting her jeans off in two seconds flat in a stable was not what he had visualized for her. 
 It had never occurred as a scenario in his fantasies. 
 He had already dreamt about her often, but usually she was fully dressed and smiling enigmatically as she waited on him, bringing him food and wine. 
 He went round to the stage door afterwards and asked the man on duty to send up his name. 
 Viola could not see him, the message came back. 
 It was all a mistake of course. 
 She must have remembered his name from the letter he had sent her. 
 Probably she would know his books. 
 She must have been gratified to hear from a famous person like himself. 
 He realized that she already had fans, but the others were almost certainly complete wankers. 
 As the doorman was unreasonable he would have to write another letter. 
 He asked permission to leave it for her the following day. 
 He could be more personal now that he didn't have to go through a nosy newspaper office. 
 His first letter was just a simple out-of-season Valentine with his name and number on it to remind her. 
 A few days passed and he heard nothing. 
 Obviously he must write at greater length. 
 That was what she expected of him. 
 She must be trying to lure him to it, the naughty girl. 
 Poor Viola, she had just taken that indecent part for the money. 
 He had to be charitable. 
 Life was hard for actresses sometimes. 
 His next letter offered her marriage to save her from the dreadful future of stripping off that she would be subjected to otherwise. 
 He also told her about what she'd done to his balls. 
 It was a twenty-page letter this time &mdash; in ink. 
 Typing would have seemed too formal. 
 It took him  till nearly four o'clock in the morning. 
 Gina lay beside him; she had nodded off and was snoring loudly. 
 He despised her coarseness in being able to sleep with the light on. 
 By the second page he had decided not to tell Viola he was married already. 
 When they had met and exchanged a few kisses, that would be time enough. 
 He would go through the pain of divorce then if she really required it of him. 
 That is, unless he was lucky enough to lose his wife in the near future. 
 He had thought she was looking very old lately, and could pass for his mother when they were out together. 
 If they both ran into Viola, he would introduce her as that, and if he waited awhile, fate might save him the trouble of a divorce, anyway. 
 Then he could have Viola without resorting to sordid legal settlements. 
 Gina had never contributed &mdash; why should she gain anything from him now? 
 But, there again, actresses were known to be broad-minded. 
 With a bit of luck, Viola might accept the existence of Gina and ignore her as he did. 
 He would even be willing for Viola to move in and share their bed. 
 They were all thin people &mdash; there'd almost have been room for a fourth person in the double his parents had bought him as a wedding present, so getting three people in it was certainly not an impossibility. 
 He thought with disdain of the average British couple filling a bed with their protuberances. 
 If Viola were willing to come and live with him, they could have romantic evenings alone without Gina. 
 He visualized simple dinners by the light of two candles with a single, long-stemmed rose in a glass between them. 
 She would have rustled up a little casserole or coq au vin  while he laid the table beautifully. 
 Then they could have sex on a tiger skin by an open fire; actresses always owned things like tiger skins. 
 All the sex would be over by the time Gina came back. 
 At twelve or one, they would be sleeping idyllically, locked in a lovers' embrace. 
 Gina could crawl in beside them or sleep on the sofa downstairs if she preferred. 
 Viola would have to give up her career, of course &mdash; otherwise she would be coming home the same time as Gina, which would not do at all. 
 If she wanted, she could  do a little daytime television work in one of the London studios. 
 If she was tired when she came back, he might even cook for her &mdash; a few artfully scrambled eggs with a sprinkling of fines herbes . 
 He didn't really approve of women earning a living, but the extra income would come in useful. 
 She would have to be very selective, of course, and just do the odd, fully clothed, tasteful commercial for perfume or something. 
 He put all this in his letter. 
 He felt he was being particularly generous offering marriage to someone he had not yet met. 
 He mused on how different his life would have been if he had met Viola when he was twenty-two, or rather someone like her, for she would not even have been a twinkle in her parents' eyes at that stage. 
 A cruel fate had separated them. 
 He went to an Indian fortune-teller and asked for advice. 
 The man talked a lot about karma and said that they had obviously been together in a previous incarnation, but now their birthdates were not synchronized. 
 Perhaps they would come together in a future incarnation &mdash; not the next, probably, but perhaps the one after. 
 Nigel gave up all belief in things occult after that and asked for his money back. 
 The man told him in sarcastic tones that he could have his &pound;9 back at any time if he brought in the young lady in the photograph. 
 Indeed, he would even be glad to tell her fortune gratis if Nigel did that. 
 He already had many clients from the world of showbusiness. 
 The fortune-teller had obviously not appreciated his good looks, Nigel thought. 
 The man wore thick glasses. 
 Nigel muttered, &bquo;You're as blind as a bat,&equo; as he went out. 
 He knew he was bound to pull any girl he set his mind on &mdash; he always had. 
 Besides, the Evening Standard's  horoscope had said that tomorrow would be the start of a new phase of his romantic life. 
 The envelope he found that morning looked like a reply from Viola. 
 He knew it instinctively. 
 There was no letter inside, only a signed photograph. 
 For a day, Nigel resented this, but then the photograph looked so beautiful and vulnerable that his heart melted. 
 She wouldn't have sent it if she hadn't meant to encourage  him. 
 Perhaps she wasn't good at letter-writing. 
 He could teach her. 
 He left letter after letter at the stage door with no reply. 
 Then he took to phoning. 
 Her home number was not listed in the directory so it had to be the stage door. 
 He had read the number off the old-fashioned dial phone as he handed his last letter in. 
 He had a good head for numbers, and recited it all the way down St Martin's Lane and into Monmouth Street; then he went in a shop for a coffee and wrote it down on one of the paper napkins. 
 He put this in the breast pocket of his leather jacket, next to his heart. 
 He kept it there for weeks, later transferring the number to his Filofax. 
 After a few days' dialling he knew it by heart. 
 Day after day, he was given the same old put-off by the stage doorman about Viola not being there. 
 It was not a likely story when she was due on stage in half an hour. 
 He caught her once on the way in. 
 She looked pudgier and more ordinary without make-up, and he wasn't entirely sure she was the same girl. 
 Perhaps it was just someone pretending to be Viola for security reasons. 
 She was polite but cool. 
 If it was Viola, she was obviously playing hard to get. 
 When he finally got her on the phone, she only asked him how he was then said she had to rush, and put the receiver down before he had time to tell her. 
 Obviously he had to put it in a letter. 
 He thought very carefully, this time, about what he was going to write, then decided to use the incident with the fortune-teller. 
 He told her that he was going to continue writing to her, nothing deterred by her cold reply or rather lack of a reply. 
 He had been to see a palmist and shown him her photo. 
 He knew that their karma dictated that they would be together in various incarnations. 
 If she did not believe him they could go together to the man. 
 He practised just down the road from her theatre, above an occult shop in Monmouth Street. 
 He had offered to tell her fortune for nothing if she went there with him. 
 Nigel felt that was a good touch with which to end his loving letter. 
 Actors were very superstitious, so surely she wouldn't be able to resist bait like that? 
 He delivered the letter, together  with a few flowers he'd nicked from a cemetery. 
 They were large, impressive white chrysanthemums. 
 He knew women couldn't resist flowers &mdash; Karen had once told him so. 
 He had been almost tempted to buy some from her at a discount until he remembered her prices. 
 Highgate Cemetery was more or less on his way to the theatre, and although it was almost all old graves without flowers, he had seen some being left regularly by some nutty Communist at the grave of Karl Marx. 
 The woman would probably think it was kids who had stolen them. 
 He left a token bloom behind, abstracting it carefully from the centre of the cellophane-wrapped bunch. 
 He tucked his letter inside the pink bow. 
 At last there was a proper reply. 
 He received it the next morning when he took his usual letter to the stage door. 
 The flowers must have done something. 
 It was rather hard to understand, though: 
 Dear Mr Hughes, 
 Thank you for the beautiful flowers. 
 It was a kind thought. 
 I must refuse the offer of a fortune, however. 
 I have my own clairvoyant. 
 I was a bit puzzled by the card inside the flowers &mdash; &bquo;To the greatest man who ever lived. 
 Up the revolution.&equo; 
 Sorry, I don't get the joke. 
 I'd better ask you to stop writing. 
 My boyfriend is getting rather jealous. 
 All the best, Viola 
 &bquo;I'm the only boyfriend she's going to have,&equo; Nigel said bitterly as he read her note.  
 IN THE DAYS THAT FOLLOWED, NIGEL KICKED HIMSELF FOR NOT untying the bunch of flowers and looking to see if there was a card inside. 
 A week later, while he was out jogging, he encountered the Commy old bat who had put the card in the flowers and made him look a fool to Viola. 
 He deliberately ran against her, knocking her shoulder. 
 He said &bquo;Bitch!&equo; audibly, then sprinted off leaving her in a state of stunned surprise. 
 He had felt like beating her up, so it seemed a mild enough rebuke for the trouble she'd caused him. 
 He didn't know what to do to straighten things out with Viola. 
 He felt he had made a fool of himself. 
 With Eleanor it would have been easy. 
 He could have told the whole thing against himself as a joke. 
 He wrote to Viola again, saying that a spiteful florist he had once been kind to had put the card in the flowers. 
 The card had really been intended for those regularly bought by a mad old lady to be laid beside the bust of Karl Marx in his local cemetery. 
 It sounded quite plausible written down, and swapping cards was the sort of spiteful thing Karen might have done. 
 &bquo;Karl Marx must have had &bquo;To the most beautiful actress in the world and the one I love&equo;&equo;, he lied. 
 Again there was no reply from Viola. 
 Although he felt sure he would win her in the end, he was annoyed at her continuing coyness. 
 It didn't come well from a girl who took her clothes off every night in front of an audience of five hundred, at least half of whom must be men. 
 He continued posting his daily letters at the stage door, using his wife's bike to get there. 
 He was a bit long in the legs for it so he sometimes knocked his knees painfully. 
 He savoured the element of penance.  
 In the autumn there was to be a break in his usual routine. 
 He had agreed to taking on a reading tour in Scotland. 
 Someone from the publicity department of his publishers had set it up. 
 The fees were ludicrously small, but it would be a good idea to get away from Viola. 
 If she missed his letters for a few days, she would probably stop taking him for granted. 
 With a bit of luck, she would be begging for it by the time he came back. 
 Absence is supposed to make the heart grow fonder. 
 Nigel was really unwell at the last minute with a bad bout of flu, but decided not to cancel. 
 He left one passionate goodbye note at the stage door on his way to the station. 
 He promised to bring her back some Edinburgh rock &mdash; &bquo;sweets to the sweet&equo;. 
 He arrived in Edinburgh that evening and was ferried by the organizer to his first reading at the university. 
 The reading was well attended by the students, but the occasion was short on material comforts. 
 The air was thick with smoke and he was not offered dinner afterwards, merely driven back to the organizer's home many miles away. 
 He had already christened his guide, who was from the local tourist board, Uncle Ebenezer. 
 He felt sure the man had been paid some sort of allowance for putting him up, but it didn't look as if any of it was going to be spent on food. 
 They stopped off for drinks in the country and it was about one o'clock in the morning before they were home. 
 He could have done with something, fish and chips even, but the place was so goddamn countrified they probably didn't rise to things like that. 
 He had to get up early to go on local radio, which meant another journey back into Edinburgh in the morning. 
 From there it was on to more readings. 
 The organizer seemed to eat nothing and offer nothing. 
 Perhaps he popped out for a quick sandwich while Nigel read? 
 By the evening of the second day, Nigel was fainting. 
 He began to ask for orange juice when offered drinks, hoping for a little nourishment before he passed out. 
 He eagerly grabbed any crisps that he found. 
 In the middle of the night he rose and, after eating about half a jar of honey, felt a lot better. 
 It was  the only edible thing in the pantry. 
 All his host's homemade pickles and stock showed an inch of blue mould. 
 There were some joints in the depths of the freezer, but he didn't like to attack these. 
 He also took a stick out of the packet of Edinburgh rock he had bought on the first day. 
 He felt sure Viola wouldn't begrudge him that. 
 Mercifully, by the third day Nigel got some time on his own and was able to go out and buy a meal. 
 He had had no key to the organizer's flat before so hadn't had this option. 
 He spent the morning and afternoon looking round Edinburgh. 
 Opting for a vast lunch in a pub, he ordered the dish of the day &mdash; haggis &mdash; then topped it off with a ploughman's lunch and the landlady's home-made black bun, much to the amazement of the proprietors. 
 They asked him if he was English, then exchanged looks with each other. 
 He also stocked up at a local health shop with various things he could nibble discreetly en route. 
 The fourth day it was on to Stirling and a literary society. 
 He agreed to an impromptu reading in the evening only to find later that he would not be paid for it. 
 It was an old folks' home. 
 The old folks were not amused by his twinkling nipples and London escapades. 
 One of them, with a yard of snot hanging from his nose, insisted on showing him some manuscripts he kept under his well-peed mattress. 
 The old man said they were love songs he had written when young, but they seemed to be by Robert Burns as far as Nigel could remember. 
 He admired them duly and was forced to join in with a chorus of auld lang syne downstairs. 
 He felt like telling the old folk it was not New Year's Eve, but he doubted if they would believe him. 
 He had only two more readings the next day, in Perth, before his release. 
 He was driven by the local poet to a large school in the centre of the town. 
 The man recited all the way and they were nearly late, with no time to stop for lunch. 
 Nigel suddenly remembered Viola. 
 All thoughts of her had vanished in the midst of his hunger pangs and coughing fits. 
 He had taken a bottle of cough mixture with him but it hadn't helped much. 
 Not  one of the organizers had thought fit to provide a carafe of wine. 
 &bquo;Could I possibly ring home?&equo; he asked the headmaster. 
 &bquo;I'll pay for the call of course.&equo; 
 He was ushered into the headmaster's study and allowed a free call in privacy. 
 He rang the stage door. 
 There was a matin&eacute;e, he'd remembered. 
 He insisted peremptorily on speaking to Viola and she was called. 
 He heard the stage doorman say, &bquo;I'm sorry, Miss, but it's that old git who's horny about you. 
 He just won't take no for an answer.&equo; 
 Viola was cold and distant and seemed determined to get rid of him. 
 He put the phone down and had a violent coughing fit. 
 He spat what looked like bloody phlegm into his paper hanky. 
 &bquo;TB,&equo; he muttered, &bquo;I must be dying of love.&equo; 
 Then he remembered the red lozenges he'd sucked all the way in the car. 
 At twenty-two, it seemed, Viola was too set in her ways for him. 
 She looked like a beautiful young girl, but she had the hardness of an old woman. 
 He wouldn't bother with her any more. 
 She wasn't worth the effort, he decided. 
 Perhaps he could pick up someone new today. 
 He didn't often have the chance of meeting schoolgirls. 
 They would be a better bet &mdash; you could see what you were getting. 
 They weren't all covered in paint like actresses. 
 Besides, he rather liked the uniforms. 
 Nigel read his sexier bits to the sixth form and they loved it. 
 He felt sure the girls were creaming their pants for him. 
 There was a blonde one with dark mascaraed lashes and a large bosom. 
 She looked young but experienced, the sort that wouldn't waste too much of his time. 
 He had decided to get away from his chaperons and ask her to his hotel for the night. 
 He was being put up in a pub-turned-hotel in the centre of town. 
 He thought he would phrase the invitation as &bquo;a drink&equo; &mdash; a knowing girl like that would take his meaning. 
 He caught Moira when he was signing copies for the children. 
 Several of them had bought his books, bringing out fivers like so much small change. 
 Children nowadays were given too much pocket money. 
 He had never let Anthony carry that much around.  
 Moira said she would ask her parents if she could have a drink with him. 
 He didn't like the sound of that much, so he changed his mind and said he might not have time, anyway, after his other reading in a church hall. 
 Moira went over to her friends and he saw them looking back at him and sniggering. 
 The headmaster walked him across to his hotel and he was alone till evening. 
 He had brought his tracksuit and trainers with him to try to keep up his jogging. 
 He had not been able to in Edinburgh, but now seemed the ideal time. 
 A quick mile round the town, a shower and it would be time for the evening reading. 
 He wouldn't eat in the hotel just yet in case the locals were feeling generous. 
 It was a fine bright day and he felt sure he had made the right decision. 
 He pounded along the street and round two corners, losing his way. 
 At the next turning he ran into Moira on her way home from school. 
 He'd show the bitch. 
 He lowered his tracksuit bottoms slightly as he slowed down. 
 &bquo;Hello,&equo; he said as he stopped opposite her, dropping them below his prick. 
 He liked to wear his fleecy tracksuit next to bare skin. 
 He felt it would be a good idea to show her what she was missing by taking that &bquo;I'll ask my parents&equo; line. 
 He was rather proud of his prick. 
 It was long, thin, pale and sensitive &mdash; just like its owner. 
 Moira screamed and ran away from him, dropping several books and a protractor. 
 He gathered these up and sprinted after her. 
 She screamed the more. 
 He didn't mean any harm, he just wanted to give them back. 
 As she turned into her house he threw her things into the doorway. 
 He didn't know why she was screaming &mdash; he'd pulled his trousers up long ago. 
 You can't run with your pants at half mast. 
 He put his hand up her tunic &mdash; serve her right for having it so short &mdash; just as she got the door open and staggered screaming into her mother's arms. 
 &bquo;It's all a mistake,&equo; he said, trying to follow, as the mother slammed the door. 
 He half expected that the police would be waiting for him when he got back to the pub. 
 He ordered a pot of coffee to fortify himself and stepped into his shower. 
 When he was  dressed he sat on the bed wondering what to do. 
 Maybe he could feign amnesia, or just cut the reading and head for home. 
 It was unlikely that he'd get connections at this time, though. 
 He thought about destroying his lovely tracksuit, but that would be a bit difficult when there was only a radiator in his room. 
 Instead he opted for getting his penknife out and fraying the elastic in the waistband. 
 If he could prove that it had too much give in it he would at least have a line of defence if he was summoned to court. 
 He practised running on the spot. 
 With a slight wiggle of the hips he could get his pants to descend below his buttocks after about twenty steps. 
 He would go to his evening reading in his most respectable suit and brazen it out. 
 Who would believe the word of a girl against his? 
 The reading came and went. 
 By the end, although there weren't many in the audience, Nigel was feeling remarkably cocky. 
 He'd got away with it completely. 
 He had read some of the more discreet passages for the evening audience, having had a last-minute change of plan. 
 Instead of the sexy bits he'd opted for poetic descriptions of London at night and the philosophic chapter from his last book about the beauties of a relationship between a young girl and an older man. 
 The girl in the chapter was under-age, but the sex was so ambiguous and romantic that none but a prude could find it objectionable. 
 Besides, age is in the eye of the beholder. 
 He had pointed out as much to the audience. 
 At nine the headmaster, who had introduced him, escorted him back to his hotel and up to his room. 
 Nigel assumed that he would lay on dinner. 
 He tried to make small talk but got no replies. 
 His bags were packed and waiting on the bed. 
 The headmaster said, &bquo;I think we'd better have a little talk. 
 Young Moira McReady's parents have lodged a complaint.&equo; 
 &bquo;They've got it all wrong. 
 It was the elastic in my trousers. 
 It could happen to any man.&equo; 
 Nigel pulled the offending tracksuit out of his case and demonstrated, pinging the elastic till it finally broke. 
 &bquo;These young girls, they're  always seeing things. 
 Wishful thinking, you know,&equo; he said and nudged the headmaster. 
 &bquo;I know whom I believe,&equo; Dr Kingsley said. 
 &bquo;I've told Moira to take tomorrow off to recover from her dreadful experience. 
 The McReady family are all fine, upright townsfolk. 
 Her father has been an elder of the kirk for the last twenty years. 
 Moira's a fine girl too. 
 We have great hopes for her.&equo; 
 Nigel sat in depressed silence for a while. 
 &bquo;Well, get on with it &mdash; whatever you intend doing. 
 You Scots are a miserable lot. 
 I've had a hell of a time on this tour, you know. 
 I'm not well either.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, you're not at all well. 
 I think that's the kindest interpretation we can put on it. 
 I've phoned my friend at the hospital &mdash; a Dr Mackintosh. 
 You can admit yourself as a patient tonight. 
 If you won't do that, then the police will be called. 
 We don't take kindly to perverts in Perth.&equo; 
 Nigel decided to go to the hospital. 
 The local magistrate might not believe in the frayed elastic, either, if the McReady family were pillars of the kirk. 
 He thought he could talk his way out of this easily enough surrounded by educated people of a less prejudiced kind than Dr Kingsley. 
 A mini-breakdown was less of a black mark than a criminal record if he should ever choose to emigrate. 
 He only had one tiny conviction for shoplifting so far, and felt sure that wouldn't be held against him. 
 He sometimes fantasized about emigrating, starting again in Hollywood where his looks and talent might be better appreciated. 
 Besides, apart of him had always enjoyed hospitals.  
 NIGEL FILLED OUT THE REQUISITE FORMS AT THE HOSPITAL DESK WITH Dr Kingsley standing over him. 
 He was reminded of his own headmaster back at school. 
 As he ticked &bquo;married&equo; the woman behind the desk asked if his wife knew he was coming in. 
 &bquo;It doesn't matter,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;We've been apart for a long time. 
 If you like I'll give you the addresses of a few girlfriends. 
 You can have my mother's address for next of kin.&equo; 
 The Queen Victoria Memorial Hospital looked comfortable enough. 
 It felt warmer than the pub. 
 Nigel was given a sleeping pill and some cocoa before he went to bed. 
 In spite of the pill he kept waking and hearing the old men around him coughing or mumbling in their sleep. 
 The nurse on duty the next morning was pretty and obviously fancied him. 
 Well, she would, wouldn't she? 
 Even if he hadn't been such a good-looking chap, he was, by any standards, the only eligible man around. 
 Everybody else there seemed to have Alzheimer's. 
 Most were even older than the old folks of Stirling. 
 He started to ask Flora, the nurse, for a relief massage. 
 He'd seen a bit of that kind of thing going on in the last hospital he was in. 
 Some of the nurses found it a nice little earner on top of their poor weekly pay. 
 The man next to him there used to pretend to be in pain and put the nurse's hand on it. 
 He tried the same with Flora but she only told him to save it for his interview with Dr Mackintosh that morning. 
 &bquo;We've heard all about you,&equo; she said. 
 Dr Mackintosh was a red-faced Scot with mousy greying hair parted in the middle and tiny gold-rimmed glasses on the tip of his rather short nose. 
 He studied Nigel's particulars and started to read them out slowly, looking  up to query various points and making notes on a pad in front of him. 
 &bquo;You say you're divorced, or is it separated? 
 It might help us to get the full picture if we could talk to your wife. 
 Perhaps you could give us her phone number. 
 Did she remarry?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, no, no! 
 You've got it all wrong. 
 We're still married but living apart in the same house, if you see what I mean. 
 No, don't write down &bquo;no sexual relations&equo;.&equo; 
 Nigel couldn't actually see what the doctor was writing on the other side of his desk, but he could guess. 
 Medical men were so unsubtle they usually jumped to conclusions like that. 
 &bquo;I'm a young man,&equo; he went on. 
 &bquo;I have plenty of sexual relations with other people. 
 My wife and I are just good friends. 
 We live together, that's all. 
 Anyway, I don't want to talk about that. 
 It's all water under the bridge. 
 I'm not a bloody American, you know &mdash; rushing to a shrink is not my idea of a hobby or a good day out. 
 I'm a writer. 
 We creative people live on a higher plane. 
 We're all over-sexed like Picasso. 
 That young girl yesterday led me on, whatever she says. 
 It was an accident, anyway. 
 I can show you the broken elastic in my tracksuit if you like. 
 And I don't want to talk about yesterday either. 
 I'm only here under duress because I didn't want to go to court over this nonsense. 
 You can put down that I'm here under duress because your friend , Dr Kingsley, forced me to it. 
 I bet he's not even a medical doctor either.&equo; 
 &bquo;You're quite right. 
 He got his PhD from St Andrews &mdash; a thesis on the poetry of T.S. 
 Eliot with particular reference to The Waste Land  as I recall.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ruddy bank clerk &mdash; he would like Eliot!&equo; 
 Nigel muttered. 
 Dr Mackintosh went on, &bquo;I don't take much pleasure in modern poetry myself. 
 The only modern poems I enjoy are by Kipling. 
 Now, you don't want to talk about your wife or about yesterday&hellip; 
 &bquo;And I don't want to talk about my childhood,&equo; Nigel cut in. 
 &bquo;I'm going to give you the score on that once and for all. 
 I don't want to fuck my mother or murder my father. 
  He's dead already. 
 You psychologists all have dirty minds. 
 Who'd fancy their mother anyway? 
 Mothers are too bloody old. 
 Most wives are too bloody old, let alone mothers. 
 I know mine is.&equo; 
 &bquo;I see you gave your mother's name as next of kin,&equo; the doctor went on unperturbed. 
 &bquo;Well, why not? 
 The old girl should do her duty and send me a postcard if she can take the time off from her toy-boys. 
 I've asked the nurse to ring my girlfriends too. 
 It's nice to have a bit of attention when you're in hospital. 
 The wife won't miss me. 
 I'm an irrelevance as far as she's concerned. 
 If she looks round one day for someone to borrow a fiver off she might, just might, notice I'm not there.&equo; 
 Nigel didn't get any attention to speak of for the rest of that day. 
 He just sat for a while in a sort of communal TV room with a few old loons. 
 Some were knitting. 
 Nigel had been offered wool and large blunt needles by an elderly nurse. 
 The man on his left had been doing a scarf for a year, she said. 
 He was very proud of it. 
 It went all round the room and had ten different colours in it. 
 One man was whimpering in the corner and two others were playing a bizarre version of dominoes, in which none of the numbers matched. 
 Only they seemed to understand the rules; one of them turned round and stroked Nigel's knee. 
 &bquo;Piss off you old queer,&equo; Nigel shouted. 
 &bquo;I can tell why you're in here.&equo; 
 The old loon looked puzzled and might have retaliated, but things were defused by a nurse bringing in the trolley of books that constituted the hospital library. 
 The old man chose an Enid Blyton. 
 Nigel leafed through a few large-print Agatha Christies but was put off by the noxious inexplicable stains on the pages. 
 The next morning brought a worried phone call from Nigel's mother, but nothing from either of his girlfriends. 
 There was a local schoolteacher coming round to give art therapy; that at least should provide some light relief. 
 She told him to call her Sheila, so she probably fancied him. 
 She had wavy blond hair and was rather attractive apart from the beginnings of a moustache. 
 He pondered on what  kissing a woman with a moustache would be like. 
 No, he didn't really fancy her, he just wanted to be praised and feel top of the class and get a little attention. 
 He had been quite good at drawing when he was at school. 
 He decided to do her a pastel sketch of himself having sex with Viola. 
 That should grab her attention. 
 He kept pulling his own and Viola's photographs from his pocket to check details. 
 He always carried both photographs next to his heart. 
 He got the facial resemblances easily enough, having a certain gift for hazy romantic portraiture. 
 He had drawn his own face many times and Viola's once or twice before. 
 He didn't like to make Viola completely naked &mdash; it seemed too prurient. 
 Instead he did her in Eleanor's blue dress rucked up at the front to make entry possible. 
 At the genital area he encountered graphical problems. 
 It's hard to draw a prick in the act; they tend to be covered from sight in this position unless they are superhumanly long. 
 In the end he settled for a rather Egyptian standing pose with both their faces front on and the bodies half turned away. 
 He was naked except for a bow tie &mdash; a nice touch, that. 
 Viola's right leg (stockinged) and a frizz of her pubic hair next to his would show the discerning viewer what was going on. 
 He was rather proud of himself for being able to visualize and draw such a convoluted position. 
 The smudginess of the pastels had helped him cover up early errors. 
 To his disappointment Sheila didn't praise him. 
 She saved all her encouragement for a septuagenarian who had painstakingly completed a picture of a fishing boat with a peculiar figure like a tadpole standing next to it. 
 &bquo;Scottish Mafia, I expect,&equo; Nigel said to her meaningfully. 
 She looked puzzled. 
 The sunniest pictures were pinned up on a board at the end of the ward. 
 A few of the others were taken away, much to Nigel's annoyance. 
 He saw now that they only wanted the darned things for analysis. 
 He had really put both his feet in it. 
 Next time he'd do them a bloody bunch of daffodils. 
 &bquo;A lot of blue in this picture of yours,&equo; Mackintosh said the next day.  
 &bquo;I only put that dress on to cover up some bad drawing. 
 Why doesn't this place provide models if they want us to get these things right?&equo; 
 Nigel replied defensively. 
 He hedged at every new question. 
 When the doctor opened a large book, he countered, &bquo;I bet you're going to show me some bloody ink blots. 
 My wife had a green one done of her body once. 
 I've had it up to here with this naivety. 
 Anybody who's not a shrink (or my wife) only sees an ink blot when they look at one. 
 This is an absolute nuthouse. 
 If I said I saw sex organs when I looked at your rotten ink blots that would really get you going, wouldn't it? 
 I'm not going to please you by doing that. 
 You can keep them and your art therapy. 
 Yes, I know depressed people put blue in their pictures. 
 But I'm not depressed. 
 I counted up all the unbroken sticks of pastel and you cunning so-and-sos had put twice the number of pieces of blue there to catch us out. 
 If I'd wanted to do red nipples there wasn't a decent whole stick of red left. 
 That bloke who keeps pulling his double set of teeth out had pinched the lot. 
 If I hadn't put that frock on the lady &mdash; she's my girlfriend by the way &mdash; I'd have had to give her blue nipples. 
 I had to give myself grey ones as it was. 
 You're just setting us all up to behave like nuts. 
 I bet you go to the zoo with your kids and give the monkeys bananas, then complain when they jump around &mdash; the monkeys I mean. 
 I suppose you're going to give me one of those American colour tests next. 
 I know all about those. 
 My son gave me one of them years ago. 
 He was going out with a silly cow of an art student and she lent him the book. 
 OK, I'll tell you what I got. 
 I chose grey and black top of all, which meant I was a psychopath. 
 I said to my son, &bquo;Well, I couldn't quite decide what to put first. 
 Can I have another go?'&equo; 
 I did and I chose black and grey that time round. 
 That made me manic depressive. 
 The bloke who made up those tests was the real loony if you ask me. 
 Men and women have been choosing and wearing black for donkey's years. 
 It must be about the most popular colour of all. 
 Anyone interested in fashion and elegance would put black first. 
 I certainly did.&equo;  
 &bquo;You didn't tell me you had a son,&equo; Mackintosh went on. 
 &bquo;Is he living with you?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh no, he buggered off to Australia on some scholarship. 
 He can't stand his mother. 
 Can't say I blame him. 
 You wouldn't believe what I have to put up with. 
 But then, you're too conventional to know anything about the sort of relationships that a literary man can have.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm going to suggest that you talk to one of my colleagues in future,&equo; Dr Mackintosh said, keeping his temper. 
 &bquo;He is very interested in modern writing. 
 Perhaps you might have something in common.&equo; 
 Nigel was getting profoundly bored in hospital. 
 He believed the nurses all fancied him, but none of them seemed willing to do anything about it. 
 A couple of old ladies had raised their skirts and shown their NHS regulation knickers, but he wasn't tempted. 
 The Cockney porter who had smuggled in a bottle of booze for him said that one of them liked to satisfy herself with the aid of bottle necks. 
 He had hinted that it might be kind to pass the empty bottle of Scotch over when he'd drunk it. 
 Nigel supposed it was just Cockney humour. 
 Women wanted men not bottles. 
 &bquo;The doctors don't encourage sex between you lot,&equo; Terry, the porter, went on. 
 &bquo;It's very unfair if you ask me. 
 People have got to get their kicks somehow. 
 I reckon it would stop a lot of trouble if they issued sex dolls in prisons and hospitals on the NHS.&equo; 
 Nigel didn't like being lumped in with prisoners and mad women in this way. 
 The man should have seen that he was a different sort of case and wouldn't be there for long. 
 He thought about cutting him in future, but he was short of people to talk to. 
 Instead he asked, &bquo;How did a Cockney end up in this godforsaken spot?&equo; 
 &bquo;Had to get as far as possible from the wife,&equo; the man answered. 
 Nigel could empathize with that. 
 There was remarkably little to do in the hospital if you didn't want to read Agatha Christie or knit half-mile scarves. 
 Nigel decided to take up jogging again in the  grounds and got Flora to lend him a sewing kit to mend his trousers. 
 &bquo;You will swear to the state of these before I mended them?&equo; he said to her. 
 &bquo;I might have to go to court.&equo; 
 The food was his only consolation. 
 It was a bland, filling diet of the sort he liked and remembered from his prep school. 
 He was sick of living on delicatessen from paper bags or literary lunches where nouvelle cuisine  seemed to be the order of the day. 
 He hated avocado, kiwis and limes, and everything in those circles seemed to have little snippets of these on top of it. 
 Here things were much more to his taste. 
 He liked the plain chops and boiled potatoes and greens; most of all he liked the rice puddings with a well of red jam in the centre and evaporated milk poured on to cool it all. 
 The whole place was remarkably like school, only better. 
 He had a little more respect here. 
 On the fourth day he received a long chatty letter from Eleanor. 
 He had thought she'd rally round even though he hadn't been in touch for nearly a year. 
 She was a sucker for his charm. 
 She said she would visit; she was giving a talk in Newcastle and reckoned it wasn't that much further to come. 
 She planned to stay for a couple of days in the Arts Club in Edinburgh, as she belonged to a London club that had a reciprocal arrangement. 
 Nigel tarted himself up for the two days before her visit. 
 He got the porter to buy him aftershave, but they didn't sell his musky expensive brand in Perth so he had to make do with a cheaper one from the tourist shop. 
 It came in a tartan cardboard box and was labelled Highland Pea. 
 Still, it didn't smell as bad as it sounded. 
 It had a certain peaty resonance. 
 Nigel donned his navy silk pyjamas and paisley dressing gown on the great day and prayed that nobody would be sick over him. 
 He believed he looked ill bodily rather than mentally in his bed things. 
 He didn't really want outsiders to know why he was there. 
 Nigel asked Eleanor into the TV lounge and they drank weak coffee from the machine. 
 Tom and Jerry  was on, but with the sound turned down. 
 Nigel's mother had  sent him some After Eights so he offered Eleanor one. 
 She had brought some fruit. 
 Remembering he didn't like grapes, she had lined up more exotic things like dates, kumquats and some out-of-season strawberries. 
 He ate the strawberries quickly before anyone could ask him for one. 
 He did not want Eleanor to talk to any of his fellow patients and suss out what sort of hospital he was in. 
 The outside of the place looked innocent enough. 
 &bquo;I'm just in for a few tests,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;They don't think it's anything serious, but one has to be on the safe side.&equo; 
 He told her the whimpering man had cancer and had had his tongue amputated. 
 It was a safe lie because the man never spoke. 
 Eleanor would think he was in a cancer ward and be impressed by his bravery and pity him. 
 Part of him longed to tell her the true tale, though, sending up the dour moralistic headmaster and the schoolgirl's screams at the sight of a perfectly natural part of his body. 
 Eleanor had once joked that it was sexist that men were called criminals for flashing, while women were treated under the Mental Health Act. 
 Come to think of it, he was almost being treated as a woman. 
 Maybe Scottish law was different on this point, although, of course, the law as such had not been brought in. 
 It had all been settled between gentlemen. 
 It's hard to know where you stand when that happens. 
 Eleanor would have been broad-minded enough to laugh at the whole tale. 
 She called flashers &bquo;failed comics&equo;. 
 On the other hand she might tell all afterwards when she got back to literary London. 
 No, it was better to play for sympathy. 
 He sat back, as smug as a cat that has licked the cream, while Eleanor held his hand and looked concerned. 
 She had obviously forgiven him now for all those cruel but necessary things he had said when he dropped her the year before. 
 He was glad he had got the hospital to contact her. 
 She could stay in Edinburgh for a few days longer, she said, until he was ready to go back. 
 If it was only tests it shouldn't take too long. 
 He felt proud when nurses passed and saw him with his girlfriend. 
 They had to believe he was desirable now.  
 Nigel would have liked to discharge himself and travel back with Eleanor right away. 
 He was only a voluntary patient, he supposed, and could leave at any time. 
 Part of him yearned to start again. 
 Perhaps Eleanor was strong enough to force Gina out of his life and house, and help him to a new beginning. 
 &bquo;I'll see what can be done,&equo; he said. 
 Visiting time was over and Eleanor left, promising to come back the following afternoon. 
 He changed into his tracksuit when she had gone and went to talk to his doctors. 
 Dr Mackintosh had left for the weekend, but Dr Lange, the literary one, would be free to see him in the morning.  
 &bquo;I SAW YOUR GIRLFRIEND,&equo; FLORA SAID WHEN THE EARLY-MORNING tea came round. 
 &bquo;Very pretty. 
 Is she the one in the picture?&equo; she went on, smirking slightly. 
 Nigel said that she was, assuming Flora had seen his pastel effort. 
 Why disgrace Viola? 
 Then he remembered the photograph that he left on his bedside table every night. 
 &bquo;My girlfriend's coming again today,&equo; he said proudly. 
 He was glad she thought Eleanor pretty. 
 He had never been too sure as, technically, she was too old to come under the heading of pretty. 
 Sometimes he believed that Eleanor was the love of his life. 
 She was too old for him, it was true, but at least she was there. 
 She noticed him, unlike his wife, and she had bothered to find out how he was. 
 He wished he had a photograph of her. 
 He couldn't keep pretending that Viola and Eleanor were the same person because Viola's photo was signed. 
 Yet they were alike: Viola was a shade darker in skin and hair but the features were similar enough for there to be little difference between the two women in a picture. 
 Perhaps he could obliterate the signature? 
 But then, what would he do if Viola got time off from her play and came to see him, as she was surely bound to do sooner or later? 
 As soon as he was dressed, Nigel went to the main desk to ask if there was any post. 
 It would be brought round if he waited, but he liked to have things as soon as they came. 
 There were some Guernsey carnations from his mum and a card from Viola saying &bquo;Get well soon&equo;. 
 He tried to read some deeper personal message into it. 
 Why did she want him well? 
 She must be after his body. 
 He began to have slight doubts about going back with Eleanor. 
 He rather liked Dr Lange. 
 He was a tall German who  spoke perfect English with only a slight trace of accent. 
 He wondered how a German had ended up there. 
 The nuthouse was turning out to be quite cosmopolitan with a Cockney and a German as well as the locals. 
 The doctor was too young to have come over in the last war. 
 He was only about Nigel's age, which meant that he'd have been a toddler then. 
 He was the kind of man Nigel would have liked to have gone on the pick-up with. 
 He had never in his life paired off to do this. 
 He felt he would have been let down by his fellow journalists. 
 They were all worse-looking and less refined than him and some were revoltingly overweight. 
 His nights out looking for girls had always been insecure, lonely operations. 
 With Dr Lange he would have had more confidence. 
 Perhaps he would propose a night painting Perth red if there were any suitable local opportunities. 
 Dr Lange did at least pay him respect. 
 He had read his first book, Soho Nights , and praised it knowledgeably. 
 He also referred to Nigel's articles. 
 Loath as Nigel was to cut into the flow of praise, he felt he ought to broach the subject of going home. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; Dr Lange said, &bquo;you are of course free to leave. 
 I wouldn't advise it, however. 
 The brain of a writer is a particularly delicate instrument like the inner workings of a fine Swiss watch. 
 While I was in Germany I took a special interest in the treatment of creative men and women who had lost direction and in some way broken down. 
 I feel that you need a complete rest before you can resume normal life. 
 In some cases, where the family is prepared to take special care of their loved ones, I would happily agree to a patient, or rather a writer, going home. 
 But your case is different. 
 If you were back in your own house and subject to the same old strains you might end up getting into the same sort of scrape again. 
 What do you think?&equo; 
 Nigel agreed that he might be tempted to behave in that way again. 
 He was glad he had at last found someone who believed in his natural superiority. 
 This doctor obviously had much more acumen than the locals. 
 Nigel had begun  to hate the Scots since being starved and caught flashing by them, but Dr Lange was different. 
 Nigel could believe in him, and hinted as much. 
 Perhaps resting there would not be such a bad thing for a week or two longer? 
 He liked to think of the problems their unpaid bills might cause Gina. 
 &bquo;My colleague, Dr Mackintosh, has told me that you will not talk to him,&equo; Lange went on. 
 &bquo;Now I have a suggestion to make. 
 I believe that doctors and patients can have a friendly relationship. 
 I would like you to think of me as a friend. 
 If you feel like talking, talk. 
 If not, fine. 
 Now you are a very good writer. 
 I would like to see some more of your work. 
 In particular I would like to know about your own background rather than having to guess at this while reading about a set of fictional characters. 
 I feel sure that you and your family are more interesting than some of these people you write about. 
 After all, you are a creative genius and these characters are mere socialites. 
 If you could see your way to writing the first chapters of an autobiography I would be honoured to read it and give you my thoughts on the subject. 
 I think this might stop you feeling too bored while you're here. 
 You must have found our library sadly deficient. 
 In time, perhaps, you might like to borrow some of my books. 
 I have most of the English classics. 
 I am particularly fond of Dickens. 
 Think about what I've said, anyway. 
 If you feel like showing me a few pages in a day or two, I would be pleased, and I'm sure your other readers out there would be fascinated by a full autobiography. 
 If you prefer to type, there's an old portable in the office that the staff never use. 
 I'll tell them you can borrow it at any time. 
 These hospitals all have computers now.&equo; 
 Nigel was flattered and tempted. 
 It was becoming harder to write at home with various thoughtless interruptions from Gina. 
 A short spell of hard work in quiet surroundings would not be a bad thing. 
 When he got back to London, he could perhaps pretend that he had been spending a few weeks in Hawthornden Castle on one of their writers' scholarships. 
 He had given Gina a column to take in to his  paper while he was away. 
 His only regular commitment was a fortnightly diary, so he wouldn't be missed for another week or two. 
 With access to a typewriter he could even knock off another column about the lighter side of his literary tour, not mentioning any of the events at Perth. 
 Nigel was installed in the office with a blank sheet of paper in front of him when Eleanor arrived. 
 Flora or somebody had told her where to find him. 
 He had almost forgotten she was coming. 
 She hadn't brought anything with her this time. 
 He had hoped for some more kumquats, the man in the bed next to him having peeled them all. 
 &bquo;Are you feeling any better?&equo; 
 Eleanor said, bending over him and kissing him. 
 There were no other chairs in the office so he couldn't ask her to sit down. 
 &bquo;Can we go somewhere and talk?&equo; 
 Suddenly, Nigel felt annoyed by her manner and by the fact that she had brought him nothing. 
 He liked to feel pampered not smothered. 
 Eleanor was assuming too much in taking on the role of possessive girlfriend. 
 &bquo;Can't you leave me alone?&equo; he said, brushing her hand off his shoulder. 
 &bquo;I'm trying to write. 
 Can't you see that?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm sorry,&equo; she said, her lip quivering. 
 Oh dear, he thought, she's going to cry and make me look a bastard in front of all the doctors and nurses. 
 They might stop me having visitors if they think I reduce them to tears. 
 What if Viola came and they turned her away? 
 &bquo;I suppose you're not coming back then?&equo; 
 Eleanor went on sadly. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Nigel said. 
 &bquo;I'm not coming back for a while. 
 Look, I'd appreciate it if you'd do something for me.&equo; 
 He took her hand and looked at her winningly. 
 She always fell for things like that; she was easy to manage. 
 He knew he'd get his own way, although he was careful to use only his right hand. 
 He had started wearing Gina's wedding ring on the other, wanting to show the nurses he was married. 
 &bquo;Be a darling,&equo; he went on, &bquo;don't mention I'm here to anybody. 
 Maybe the tests will show it's all clear, maybe not. 
 Anyway, I don't want their pity. 
 I'd rather face up to  things alone. 
 I'll get in touch when I'm back in London. 
 I'll phone you then, or something.&equo; 
 He didn't really mean it, but his request sounded more gracious put that way. 
 He imagined her waiting pathetically by the phone. 
 She obviously wouldn't have anyone else at her time of life, in spite of all the men in her stories. 
 &bquo;You can send me the odd card if you like. 
 You won't worry if I don't reply, will you? 
 I would if I were my old healthy self. 
 You know that, don t you?&equo; 
 Eleanor told him she understood, kissed him and then left to start the long journey home. 
 Nigel believed she would assume he had something incurable with a shade of film glamour to it &mdash; leukaemia, perhaps. 
 He felt a weight lifted when she had gone &mdash; he had so nearly fallen into her trap. 
 If he had allowed her to take him back to London, he might have been stuck for life with a woman in her thirties (and getting older by the day). 
 She would have had a sort of power over him. 
 Now, he was truly free for Viola. 
 She was bound to come to see him sooner or later. 
 He would take his ring off then. 
 Maybe, if she was good, he would give it to her. 
 In the meantime he was free to write. 
 He started typing and found himself enjoying it for the first time for years. 
 This would be his masterpiece. 
 He read through his first paragraph &mdash; after years of novel-writing he found it easier to put it all in the third person. 
 &bquo;Once upon a time,&equo; he had written. 
 He was going to change that start later, but for now it was an easy lead in. 
 &bquo;Once upon a time, there was a boy called Nigel Charles Hughes. 
 He came from a rich family and was very good-looking. 
 He had a remarkable power over women. 
 They all fancied him and thought he was the handsomest boy they had ever seen&hellip;.&equo; 
 Day Five &mdash; Thursday 11th August 
 6.30am 
 &bquo;Where are you off to?&equo; 
 Joe shot out of the milking house as Jinny came past. 
 Even in wellingtons, he could move as lightly as a squirrel. 
 Jinny looked down guiltily. 
 &bquo;Just thought I'd have a walk.&equo; 
 Joe watched her for a second, his long finger delicately turning the gold ring in his ear. 
 Then he shrugged. 
 &bquo;You can get in and do the milking. 
 Then I should be able to get the roots hoed before breakfast. 
 That'll put me half a morning ahead, and I could do with that.&equo; 
 It wasn't fair . 
 She had forced herself out of bed especially early, without waking Oz, just so that she could have a spare half-hour or so to take a walk up Back Clough Dale. 
 And here was Joe, brushing her plans aside like cobwebs with the dew still on them, not even knowing what he was doing. 
 He stood in the door of the milking house, holding out the buckets for her to take. 
 And she took them, of course. 
 That was how she had been brought up. 
 If there was work to do, you did it, with no lounging about. 
 She went over to the big, old, white sink in the corner and Joe fetched out the hoe and vanished towards the vegetable field. 
 Jinny rubbed the cake of scratchy, home-made soap between the palms of her hands and scrubbed her fingernails carefully. 
 Behind her, in the shadows, she could hear Florence making odd, bad-tempered cow-noises as she shifted about on the hard floor. 
 When Jinny went over with a bowl of water to wash her udder, she stirred restlessly, flicking her tail. 
 &bquo;Oh, keep still !&equo; 
 Jinny slapped the big, golden rump.  
 &bquo;You've got nothing to moan about, you stupid cow. 
 No work to do. 
 Nothing but eat and sleep.&equo; 
 She dried the udder and pulled the three-legged stool across, jamming the first bucket between her knees as she sat down, so that Florence could not kick it over. 
 Then she buried her face in the warm flank and began to squeeze the teats rhythmically, talking to the cow in an undertone, as Joe did. 
 &bquo;Glorious to be a cow in the summer! 
 Knee-deep in lovely cool grass. 
 No call to move fast. 
 No worries. 
 And slaves to milk you when you get too full up. 
 Mmm?&equo; 
 &bquo;Moo-oo!&equo; 
 said Florence balefully, looking round. 
 She was only half Jersey, and that half did not include her temper, which was chancy and morose. 
 In that moo, Jinny caught an echo of the bellowing noise Florence had made earlier in the year when they took her calf away. 
 She had kept everyone awake for a whole night and Oz had cried into his pillow. 
 And yet here Florence was now, munching away with her usual bad temper. 
 The calf was sold long ago, and she would not even recognize it now if it ambled into the yard. 
 How restful , thought Jinny. 
 If only people were the same, Harriet Shakespeare would not be staring up at a house where terrorists were holding her son. 
 All that crying and fear would be saved and she would long ago have wandered off, swishing her tail, to find a better patch of grass. 
 As Jinny milked on, her thoughts floated vaguely, in the way that was one of the pleasures of the job. 
 The thought of Harriet Shakespeare slipped into the thought of poor Keith standing awkward and miserable among his mess of papers, while his mother screamed at him for not being neat and ordinary, like Rachel. 
 From there, by natural progression, Jinny moved to the memory of herself, crying into Keith's comfortable jumper. 
 Choking out the puzzle of that other mother and son. 
 The boy in the attic who had cried, &bquo; Help !&equo; and the lovely, lying Hare-woman. 
 That stopped the pleasant floating. 
 She came up against the  unsolved riddle with a horrible jerk. 
 If Joe had not caught her, she would be there now, walking up the dale to look down on the sleeping cottage. 
 Wondering. 
 Watching. 
 Only here she was instead, working as usual. 
 Her bad temper came back. 
 She was too well trained to take it out on Florence and she finished milking her, but she scowled as she lifted the heavy pails and carried them outside, lifting them into the water trough to cool. 
 She turned Florence into the field and stood over the milk pails, stirring them slowly with a hazel stick. 
 Round and round went the rich, creamy milk, as the cool spring water flowed past, down through the three sloping troughs and away out of the yard. 
 Fragments of Jinny's face stared back from the broken surface of the water. 
 A skinny, cross face with freckles and a thin, sandy plait. 
 Joe found her there when he came back from the vegetable field. 
 He looked at her face, but he did not say anything, except, &bquo;Get those pails into the dairy now. 
 Otherwise you'll be late for breakfast and miss the Planning.&equo; 
 Jinny sighed. 
 If there was anything worse than being cross, she thought, it was being cross and having it ignored. 
 But Joe was never one for thinking about what people felt. 
 Only what they did. 
 He would never ask her why she was pulling faces, in case it encouraged her to pull worse ones. 
 Just for her own satisfaction she pulled the very worst one she could think of &mdash; worse than any of Oz's &mdash; with her cheeks blown out, her eyes crossed and the tip of her tongue protruding. 
 Then she heaved the pails out of the trough and carried them into the dairy, pouring some of the milk carefully into wide pans for the cream to rise. 
 Good, obedient Jinny. 
 Doing as she was told. 
 All the same, she was late for breakfast. 
 The others were there already in a circle round the kitchen table, munching their way through slices of wholemeal bread and thick collops of bacon. 
 She slipped into the seat beside Oz and picked up her knife and fork. 
 &bquo;Good,&equo; said Joe. 
 He wiped his fingers on his piece of bread. 
 &bquo;Let's plan.&equo;  
 It was their daily ritual. 
 Every morning, rain or shine, school or holidays, they sat round at breakfast deciding what work had to be done that day and sharing it out. 
 Normally, Jinny loved the Planning. 
 She had a neat, methodical mind and it pleased her to hunt around for an odd half-hour or so to fill with planting lettuces or doing the mending. 
 But today was different. 
 Today she had something of her own that she wanted to do and she felt trapped. 
 Joe was quietly listing the day's tasks on his fingers. 
 &bquo;&hellip; someone'll have to go up to Top Piece, too, and have a go at that wall. 
 It won't wait any longer.&equo; 
 &bquo;Me!&equo; said Oz. 
 He liked walling. 
 But Joe did not take any notice. 
 They had not reached the time for sharing out. 
 He just carried on. 
 &bquo;&hellip; and some time today I'll have to go into the village. 
 See about getting some people to come up and help with the harvest next week. 
 Tuesday'd be a good day, I think. 
 If it's fine. 
 That means you'd better sort out the hams and cheeses, Bella. 
 Decide what you'll give them.&equo; 
 Bella nodded. 
 &bquo;I'll make the extra bread on Monday, then.&equo; 
 &bquo;How about cakes? 
 You usually do cakes. 
 They ought to be baked today.&equo; 
 &bquo;Today?&equo; 
 Bella shrieked. 
 &bquo;But it's my butter day. 
 And there's beans to be sliced. 
 And if we want any bilberries bottled this year someone'll have to go out and pick them soon. 
 And &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;O.K.&equo; Joe lifted his hand to stop her speaking. 
 Bella always started each day in a frenzy of horror at how much had to be done. 
 Then he stared down at the floor, gathering together the threads of the day. 
 When he looks up , thought Jinny, he'll tell us all what to do and the day will be gone before it's properly started.  
 Like yesterday . 
 All the day before, she had waited for half an hour to go off walking by herself and it had never come. 
 Now it seemed that today would be the same. 
 She wondered what it was like to wake in the morning and plan things for yourself. 
 To choose.  
 &bquo;Right.&equo; 
 Joe looked up. 
 &bquo;Oz can do the chickens today. 
 And when Jinny's finished the pigs she can do the butter. 
 She's helped you often enough. 
 It's time she did it by herself. 
 And Oz can come walling with me.&equo; 
 &bquo; Good !&equo; said Oz, with his mouth full. 
 Jinny sat resentfully, mopping round and round her plate with the last piece of bread as Joe's voice went on and on. 
 &bquo;&hellip; and the bilberries can wait till tomorrow,&equo; he finished. 
 &bquo;Then, if we're forward enough, Jinny and Oz can go off for the day with a couple of baskets. 
 How's that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Too much!&equo; 
 Jinny said, before she could stop herself. 
 &bquo;You've filled every minute I've got. 
 Don't I get any  time off?&equo; 
 Joe was not smiling as he looked at her. 
 &bquo;You know it's busy getting things straight before harvest. 
 Would you want to be lounging about while the rest of us are working?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, but &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;I'll tell you what.&equo; 
 He tugged gently at her plait. 
 &bquo;If you get through all right, I'll take you with me when I go down to the village after evening milking. 
 You can drop in on Keith while I go round and see people. 
 Yes?&equo; 
 Jinny felt like shouting at him. 
 Couldn't he see  that he was just organizing her even more? 
 But before she could say anything, Bella interrupted. 
 &bquo;When you two have finished, perhaps someone'll listen to me. 
 I've got problems too.&equo; 
 She coughed and looked down at the floor. 
 &bquo;I've run out of sugar. 
 I'll need to buy some if I'm making cakes and bottling bilberries.&equo; 
 There was a horrible silence. 
 Jinny picked up her mug and drank, to hide her face. 
 It happened every time. 
 Why wouldn't Bella learn? 
 Joe hated people not to plan ahead. 
 Especially when it meant spending money. 
 His long, narrow face was tight and angry. 
 &bquo;How much?&equo; 
 She shrugged. 
 &bquo;Depends on how many berries they pick. 
 Three or four kilos ought to be enough, but I'll need some dried fruit as well if you want fruit cakes &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 How much money ?&equo;  
 Even Oz was quiet, his eyes flickering from face to face. 
 Bella avoided looking at Joe. 
 &bquo;Give me five pounds?&equo; 
 He pushed his chair back from the table and walked over to the drawer in the dresser where they kept the cash-box. 
 Counting out seven pound notes, he laid them carefully on the table. 
 Then he counted the rest of the money in the box and frowned. 
 &bquo;Well, that's my work settled for tomorrow. 
 I'll have to be in the workshop finishing that brooch. 
 To see if I can get the money for it before the end of the month. 
 Jinny'll have to do all the milking and start planting out the cabbages.&equo; 
 Slam. 
 Thanks a lot , Jinny thought. 
 That's right. 
 Start getting rid of tomorrow as well. 
 Why did she have to be born into a mad, slave-driving family? 
 Everyone else in her class would be spending the holidays riding or playing in the hills or lying in bed until midday. 
 Even the people who lived on farms did not have to work like she did. 
 Those farms were businesses, not monsters that devoured you. 
 Joe was already out of the kitchen and half-way across the yard and Bella began to put the dishes together. 
 Now that she had the money she needed, she was singing happily.  
 &bquo;That's what I  feel like,&equo; Jinny said bitterly as she lifted the pan of pigswill off the range. 
 &bquo;Way-hey!&equo; 
 Bella gave a squawk and grinned. 
 &bquo;Got the black sulks? 
 What's the matter? 
 Scared of making the butter by yourself?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, of course not. 
 It's everything .&equo; 
 Jinny put the bucket down ready to pour in the swill and began to tip the pan with steady hands. 
 &bquo;Honestly, Mum, don't you feel it too? 
 We work and work and work &mdash; and what's it all for ? 
 We're  horribly poor. 
 All that fuss about money! 
 Other people spend that much on newspapers and magazines. 
 I've seen them at the shop, paying their bills. 
 They buy books and nice clothes and shop cakes and &mdash; &bquo; 
 Bella stopped in the middle of the kitchen with a huge pile of plates and said quietly, &bquo;Is that what you really  want? 
 Lots of money to buy trash &mdash; and not work? 
 Because we could  have that, you know. 
 All we've got to do is go back to London and get Joe to set up a workshop there and work himself silly. 
 Like he was doing before. 
 The rest of us could just sit and twiddle our thumbs and drink iced coffee. 
 But perhaps you don't remember how he hated that life, and what a state it got him into. 
 It was like a huge machine running away with him.&equo; 
 Jinny was still not ready to stop sulking. 
 &bquo;So we all have to live like beggars so that Dad can have what he wants?&equo; 
 &bquo;We're not beggars,&equo; Bella said calmly. 
 &bquo;I could go upstairs this minute and drape myself in gold chains and beautiful bracelets.&equo; 
 &bquo;But that's different .&equo; 
 &bquo;No it's not.&equo; 
 Bella reached out a lazy hand and prodded at Oz. 
 &bquo;Go on, goggle-eyes. 
 No need to neglect the chickens just because I'm talking to Jin.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right,&equo; Oz moaned cheerfully. 
 &bquo;Force me out to work. 
 There's laws against it, you know.&equo; 
 He ducked, as Bella aimed a swipe at him, and went out into the yard. 
 Putting the plates down, Bella sat in a chair and pulled Jinny towards her. 
 &bquo;Look Jin, what's up? 
 It's not like you to moan. 
 And you know why we're here as well as I do. 
 Joe nearly had a nervous breakdown in London. 
 I couldn't get him away from his bench. 
 Even at midnight, he was still working. 
 There was too much pressure. 
 Too many other people were involved and he felt he was losing his grip. 
 We came here so that we could be in control of our own lives and not tangled up with anyone else. 
 We chose  this life.&equo; 
 &bquo; You two  chose it, you mean,&equo; said Jinny. 
 &bquo;No one asked me.  
 Bella shook her head. 
 &bquo;You're like all children. 
 You get the kind of life your parents choose until you're old enough to choose for yourself. 
 And when you are, you'll be well-grown and independent. 
 Twice as independent as most girls of your age. 
 Jinny scowled and shuffled her feet. 
 &bquo;But what I want is a bit of time to myself. 
 Now .&equo; 
 &bquo;I know you do, love,&equo; Bella said, patting her arm. 
 &bquo;And you've deserved it, too. 
 But I don't think there'll be any to spare for a day or two. 
 I'll tell you what, though. 
 I'll try and wangle you out of the cabbages tomorrow &mdash; so you can go bilberrying all day. 
 You'll have Oz, of course, but at least you'll be able to choose where you go. 
 How's that?&equo; 
 She smiled, but Jinny still felt wretched. 
 She kicked at the chair-leg and the black, angry words burst out of her. 
 &bquo;It's always Dad ! 
 I don't want him to be unhappy and have a breakdown. 
 Of course I don't. 
 But whenever I try to lead a normal life, like anyone else of my age, he comes along with another  job and more  work. 
 If he weren't there &mdash; &bquo; 
 She stopped, horrified at what she had been about to say. 
 Waiting for Bella to be furious and upset. 
 But there was no fury. 
 Just a long, sad pause. 
 Then Bella said gently. 
 &bquo;It's always the people you love who trap you like that, Jinny. 
 If you didn't care about him, you'd just walk off and lead your own life. 
 Do whatever you wanted to. 
 It's because you love him that you feel like killing him and wiping him out of your life. 
 But it's the wrong answer. 
 If you kill the people you love &mdash; or run away from them &mdash; you only smash yourself in the end. 
 You have to grow round  them. 
 Make space for how they are.&equo; 
 Suddenly Jinny was calm. 
 Because she saw that it Was true. 
 And, more than that, she saw that Bella was really talking about herself. 
 This life was harder on her than on anyone else. 
 She was totally unsuited to anything where she had to organize herself. 
 Jinny swallowed her rage and tried to forget that she had wanted to go up to Back Clough Dale today . 
 After all, they were all in it together. 
 family life.  
 This time, when Bella smiled and said, &bquo;So &mdash; bilberrying tomorrow?&equo; 
 Jinny smiled back. 
 &bquo;Thanks, Mum. 
 That'll be great.&equo; 
 5.30 p.m. 
 Doyle looked at his watch and then up at Tug. 
 When he spoke, his voice was raised just loud enough to carry over the low-pitched brass rumbles. 
 &bquo;Time to go downstairs.&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 Tug gaped at him. 
 He had got used to being in this room, shut in by the four scrawled walls, the sloping ceiling and the unrelenting noise. 
 With someone watching him all the time except when one of Them let the other out to fetch the papers. 
 Was it really possible  to go out? 
 Doyle did not repeat himself. 
 Instead, he pulled the chair away and opened the door, gesturing with his gun for Tug to go through it. 
 Sliding off the bed, Tug pushed his feet into his trainers and laced them up. 
 Then, nervously and slowly, he walked to the doorway. 
 As he passed Doyle, he looked up at him. 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; 
 &bquo;Can't keep you cooped up all the time,&equo; Doyle said, sounding amused. 
 &bquo;What sort of parents do you think we are?&equo; 
 You're not my parents . 
 Tug opened his mouth automatically, but for the first time since he had been there, he let the words go unsaid. 
 Because he wanted to go downstairs. 
 Looking up, he saw Doyle's small smile, and knew that the gap had been noticed. 
 For a moment he was afraid. 
 He had let something slide. 
 Only a little thing, but he was frightened of where it might lead. 
 Then his feet were on the stairs and he was walking down the narrow, dark steps, which twisted  sharply to the right. 
 Bracing himself, ready for whatever he might find at the bottom. 
 The stairs ended in a latched door. 
 Tug pushed it open. 
 At the same moment, at the top of the stairs, Doyle turned off the music. 
 It had not stopped, even for a second, over the two days. 
 Now, in the sudden silence, Tug felt as though he had been stripped naked and pushed out into a football crowd. 
 The tormenting music and the attic room were horrible &mdash; but this was more frightening. 
 &bquo;Go on,&equo; Doyle said softly, coming down behind him. 
 Tug stared into a big kitchen/living-room full of old, heavy furniture that did not quite match. 
 Facing him was the main front door, the door that led to the outside world. 
 Beside it, a large window showed the first view that Tug had seen for five days. 
 Close to the house, a narrow track ran up a slight slope. 
 Beyond, in the distance, a great ridge rose high, running from one side of the window to the other. 
 It looked massive and majestic in the evening light and Tug stood quite still for a second, imagining the wind blowing across its top. 
 The free, cold wind. 
 Then Doyle pushed him and he stepped meekly into the room, noticing the heavy key in the front door and the two large bolts that were firmly shot at the top and bottom. 
 They were not taking any chances. 
 It was obvious that his visit had been planned and was not merely a sudden idea of Doyle's. 
 The Woman was sitting round to the right, beside a television, and as soon as she saw Tug she waved at a chair. 
 &bquo;Sit down. 
 We thought we'd have a nice family evening in front of the television.&equo; 
 They were both watching him. 
 Big, hazel eyes and cold, blue ones. 
 Watching him and waiting for something. 
 Settling himself in one of the big, shabby armchairs, Tug gazed suspiciously at the television screen and waited for a picture to appear. 
 Even then, he had not got as far as thinking what would be  the music that introduced the News and all at once the screen was filled with a picture of his own house, a picture that nearly jolted him out of his skin. 
 Of course! 
 He was News! 
 People must be hunting all over the country for him. 
 As the news-reader began to speak, he leaned forward eagerly, not caring about Doyle and the Woman. 
 &bquo;Good evening.&equo; 
 The television was not very good and the voice crackled and faded from time to time. 
 &bquo;The terrorists who are holding thirteen-year-old Liam Shakespeare hostage in his home in Shelley Grove have announced that they are members of Free People, the left-wing revolutionary group that aims to &bquo;break the tyranny of the blood tie and abolish the out-dated family unit. ''&equo; 
 It was nonsense. 
 Tug's eyes and ears blurred. 
 Not one word of it made any sense at all to him. 
 He must have gone mad or deaf. 
 But the news-reader's voice went on, crackling but unmistakable, saying extraordinary things. 
 &bquo;The group has issued a communiqu&eacute; setting out its general aims, but has not as yet made any specific demands. 
 Liam's mother, Harriet Shakespeare, was interviewed at a friend's house today.&equo; 
 Tug's eyes snapped back into focus and there was Hank, sitting in Mrs Mallory's front room. 
 Her squashed-pekinese face looked peculiar, as though someone had smudged dusty shadows under the eyes and in the hollows of the cheeks. 
 Her mouth was stiff in a familiar way, so that Tug knew she was trying not to cry. 
 He wanted to be with her so much that he could hardly breathe. 
 Hank, Hank, come and get me out of here . 
 &bquo;Have you been able to contact Liam directly at all?&equo; said the invisible interviewer. 
 Hank shook her head. 
 Her mouth was still tense, but her voice came out quite steady, as Tug had known it would. 
 &bquo;Not yet. 
 There's a telephone link, of course, but we haven't managed to persuade the group to let Liam speak.&equo;  
 &bquo;But you know that he is alive and unhurt?&equo; 
 &bquo;We've glimpsed him moving around. 
 Not very clearly, but he's certainly alive.&equo; 
 Tug felt like a ghost, mouthing and gesturing on the outside of a window, in the darkness. 
 Everything seemed to slip and slither round him &mdash; Doyle and the Woman, the dirty plates heaped round the sink, the vast, open view through the window. 
 They swirled together as though they had been stirred with a spoon. 
 But he gripped hard at the arms of his chair and forced himself to attend. 
 He did not want to miss a word. 
 Not while he could see Hank. 
 &bquo;Mrs Shakespeare, you are well-known for your investigations into extreme left-wing groups and terrorist organizations. 
 Do you know much about free People?&equo; 
 The tough little face looked suddenly alert. 
 &bquo;I first noticed them when they carried out the hospital nursery raid about three years ago. 
 Remember it? 
 They swapped all the babies round and removed the name bands on their wrists. 
 That's a typical Free People stunt. 
 Not necessarily blood-thirsty, but making a point. 
 They didn't injure anyone that time &mdash; not physically, at any rate &mdash; but there must be mothers in Yorkshire who are still wondering if the babies were really sorted out correctly.&equo; 
 &bquo;But the group can  be dangerous? 
 There is real reason to be afraid for Liam's safety?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course there is!&equo; snapped Harriet Shakespeare. 
 &bquo;You know that as well as I do, after the Beach Bombings.&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course, of course.&equo; 
 The interviewer hesitated, and when he asked the next question he sounded faintly embarrassed. 
 &bquo;You have always insisted that groups like this should not be encouraged to take hostages. 
 That no one should give in to their demands. 
 Do you still feel the same now that your own son is involved?&equo; 
 Harriet Shakespeare turned to face the camera directly. 
 &bquo;I hope I shall be strong enough to stick by my principles,&equo; she said. 
 Her voice was less controlled now. 
 Tug could tell that she was desperately in earnest by the way she opened her  eyes wide and by the little sudden lift of her eyebrows. 
 It was a characteristic movement. 
 &bquo;But I also hope that people will understand what it's like standing outside your own house, knowing that your son is a prisoner in there and not being able to get in. 
 It's very hard to bear.&equo; 
 &bquo;And of course you don't yet know what the terrorists ' demands will be, do you?&equo; 
 The pause before Harriet Shakespeare spoke again was very, very short. 
 Only someone who knew her very well would have noticed it. 
 &bquo;That's right. 
 I haven't got any idea what they're going to ask for. 
 We'll just have to wait and see.&equo; 
 She gave a tiny smile, brave but near tears, and then vanished from the screen. 
 It had been a moving interview. 
 Touching. 
 Intelligent. 
 Courageous. 
 And ending up with a thumping great lie. 
 Tug knew  that that last bit about the terrorists' demands was a lie. 
 He could tell, from the way she had hesitated and from the smile she had given. 
 He went on staring at the television screen, not listening to the next item, but trying to work out the puzzle. 
 All through the first part of the interview &mdash; the crazy part, when she had been talking about seeing her son in the house &mdash; Hank had been telling the straight truth. 
 No doubt about it. 
 She believed every word she was saying. 
 And when she was talking about the clash between her feelings and her principles, she had been desperately serious. 
 But then suddenly &mdash; a lie. 
 It was a hopeless jumble. 
 And the eyes were still there. 
 Watching him. 
 Waiting to see what he had made of it all. 
 Tug stared down at his shoes. 
 &bquo;Why did you bring me down to watch that?&equo; he said gruffly. 
 The Woman leaned forward, her face eager, but it was Doyle who answered, dropping every word slowly so that it rippled like a stone in a pond. 
 &bquo;We thought you would be interested to hear about your friend.&equo; 
 &bquo;My &mdash; friend?&equo;  
 &bquo;Liam Shakespeare.&equo; 
 &bquo;He's not a friend  of mine &mdash;&equo; began Tug. 
 Then he stopped. 
 He saw Hank's face saying, We've glimpsed him moving around . 
 All at once, he felt devastatingly weary. 
 A thought slid into his mind. 
 I have been blotted out from the world . 
 He was too weak and confused and unhappy to fight it. 
 Ridiculously, he longed for the attic room and the sound of &bquo;The Keel Row&equo;, as if they were home. 
 As if he had no place anywhere else. 
 He stood up. 
 &bquo;I want to go back upstairs.&equo; 
 The eyes stared. 
 Then Doyle stood up too. 
 &bquo;I'll take you.&equo; 
 He put an arm round Tug's shoulders and the bare skin of his wrist lay warm and dry against Tug's upper arm, the crisp hairs tickling slightly. 
 Tug found it repulsive, but he had not the energy to resist and he let Doyle lead him upstairs as a father leads a child. 
 8.00 p.m. 
 &bquo;I haven't got any idea what they're going to ask for. 
 We'll just have to wait and see.&equo; 
 Harriet Shakespeare gave a wavering smile and Keith reached forward and switched off the video recorder. 
 Then he looked at Jinny. 
 &bquo;There you are. 
 You've seen my cuttings and you've seen what's been on the News the last couple of days. 
 What do you think?&equo; 
 Jinny was flummoxed. 
 Only an hour ago she had been finishing the evening milking, peaceful in the milking house with Florence. 
 But as soon as she walked in to see Keith he had faced her with a heap of newspaper and snippets of video-recordings. 
 Dropped her knee-deep into the Harriet Shakespeare business and asked her to think . 
 She looked round at the cuttings strewn on the floor and then back at the blank screen. 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; I don't know &mdash; it's sad. 
 You have to feel sorry for  her. 
 That bit about her son and her principles &mdash; you know exactly how she feels. 
 And you've got to admire her for not collapsing.&equo; 
 &bquo;In fact, she's the picture of a brave, devoted mother,&equo; Keith said in an odd voice. 
 Jinny thought he was laughing at her. 
 &bquo;Yes!&equo; she said fiercely. 
 &bquo;I know it sounds corny. 
 You gripe about your mother and I gripe about mine. 
 But mothers are  wonderful, and it's something like this that makes you realize it.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right ,&equo; said Keith. 
 He rubbed his chin and Jinny noticed that he needed a shave. 
 &bquo;These terrorists have really made a lovely picture by kidnapping Liam Shakespeare, haven't they? 
 A picture of mother-love and devoted families. 
 Let's all wipe our eyes.&equo; 
 He frowned. 
 &bquo;It's very, very peculiar. 
 How can they have got it so wrong?&equo; 
 &bquo;What do you mean wrong ?&equo; 
 Jinny was too tired to try and work it out. 
 &bquo;Why should terrorists care what it looks like &mdash; as long as they get their money, or whatever they're after?&equo; 
 &bquo;Terrorists hardly ever  get what they're after.&equo; 
 Keith rubbed at his sweaty forehead, leaving a black smear from the newsprint on his hands. 
 &bquo;That's not what they're really doing.&equo; 
 It sounded like one of his clever ideas. 
 Jinny sighed. 
 &bquo;Come on then, genius. 
 What are  they really doing?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, they're not usually powerful enough to change things by themselves, see. 
 Not directly. 
 So they try to make pictures that will change people's minds. 
 Like &mdash; let me see &mdash; like when the Palestinians once injected Israeli oranges with mercury in a supermarket. 
 They told people there were thousands of poisoned oranges about. 
 That they'd better stop buying Israeli. 
 I don't suppose it damaged the Israeli economy much, but it put across just the picture the Palestinians were after. 
 Israel is poison. , 
 &bquo;So?&equo; said Jinny. 
 She hated it when he made her feel stupid. 
 &bquo;So these terrorists are making a picture that says Mothers are wonderful .&equo;  
 &bquo;What's wrong with that?&equo; 
 &bquo; Jinny !&equo; 
 Keith pulled a face at her and tugged his hair despairingly. 
 &bquo;Why don't you oil your brains? 
 Think what sort of group Free People are. 
 They  don't want to say Mothers are wonderful . 
 They want to say Smash the family . 
 Like they did in the Beach Bombings.&equo; 
 &bquo;Beach Bombings?&equo; 
 Jinny felt weary. 
 Was there no end to the things she hadn't heard of? 
 Keith sighed. 
 &bquo;It was last summer,&equo; he said patiently. 
 &bquo;Crowded beaches, full of families sunning themselves. 
 Then suddenly &mdash; POW! 
 Bombs went off on six beaches at once. 
 Blew about twenty families to bits and sent a shocking number of people scurrying away without their parents or their children. 
 Free People claimed they had been &bquo;exploding the myth of the happy family&equo;. 
 So you see the sort of people they are? 
 Remember the communiqu&eacute; they put out a couple of days ago? 
 Look, here.&equo; 
 Jinny remembered seeing it and slipping past it because it looked complicated and she was tired. 
 Now she spread it on her knee and read it properly. 
 A Message from the free People to their Comrades Still in Prison 
 Comrades, it is time to wake and see your chains. 
 WOMEN open your eyes and see how you are chained to husbands and children. 
 All the equal opportunities in the world cannot save you from the demands of your families. 
 THERE MUST BE A DIFFERENT PATTERN. 
 MEN open your eyes and see how you are chained to the capitalist system by the needs of your wives and children. 
 As long as men have families, capitalists will be able to exploit them. 
 THERE MUST BE A DIFFERENT PATTERN. 
 CHILDREN open your eyes and see how you are chained to the needs and desires of your parents. 
 And while they force you to be what you do not want to be, they are also teaching you how to be parents. 
 Shudder when you understand that you, in your turn, will humiliate your aged parents and bully and deform your children. 
 THERE MUST BE A DIFFERENT PATTERN. 
 The family is a primitive institution that gives the rich an excuse to exploit the poor and prevents the poor from resisting. 
 There will be no justice and no liberation until the vicious circle is broken and the tyranny of the family is smashed. 
 The blood tie strangles the true brotherhood of mankind. 
 It is time for men to come out of the nursery. 
 The doors of the prison stand open. 
 The free People will free people. 
 In a few days we shall announce our exact demands which must be fulfilled before we release Liam Shakespeare. 
 Be prepared to support these demands! 
 Help build the revolution NOW. 
 Jinny read it three times. 
 Then, at random almost, she picked up one of the other cuttings, which showed Harriet Shakespeare's plain, squashed face looking white and distraught and pitiful as she leaned against a friend's arm. 
 &bquo;You're right,&equo; she said slowly. 
 &bquo;It makes no sense. 
 Why have they done it?&equo; 
 Keith leaned back in his chair and waggled his bare feet, looking very pleased with himself. 
 &bquo;That's what I'm waiting to find out. 
 You know, it's turning out to be a brilliant story  to do. 
 Thanks for thinking of it, Jin. 
 I was amazed you'd even heard of it, to tell the truth.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought of it?&equo; 
 Jinny said. 
 Then she remembered. 
 Those big, golden eyes turned towards the radio, ignoring Mrs Hollins. 
 &bquo;Oh yes. 
 The Hare-woman.&equo; 
 &bquo;The what ?&equo; 
 Keith sat up straight and stared at her. 
 She had not meant to say it out loud, but now that she had, she almost explained. 
 Because she always had told Keith everything. 
 Then it came back to her. 
 Find another fact or two , he had said. 
 And Aha!  
 It is the handsome stranger . 
 She tossed her plait over her shoulder and looked round at all the mess. 
 &bquo;Why don't we tidy up instead of yacketing on? 
 Unless you want  your mother to spend the rest of the evening raging at you.&equo; 
 It was the first time she had ever warned him off anything private and for a moment he looked puzzled and embarrassed. 
 But he was not a person who would ferret for secrets. 
 With a meekness that made her feel mean, he knelt down on the floor and started to gather his cuttings together.  
 Day Six &mdash; Friday 12th August 
 2.00 a.m. 
 Tug woke suddenly in the dark, out of a nightmare of falling, of rushing water and ground that slipped away beneath his feet. 
 He opened his eyes and was instantly aware of utter, spine-chilling silence. 
 Everything was dark except for a single patch where the moon shone through the skylight on to the wall. 
 A single pale, bright patch, from which two black skeletons leered down at him. 
 He caught his breath. 
 At once, away to the side of the skeletons, a dark hump reared. 
 A shadow moved across the brightness, coming towards his bed. 
 Tug screamed. 
 In mid-scream, he was choked into silence by a hand that came over his face, forcing his jaw shut. 
 It was so dark that he could not see who was bending over him. 
 Let it be Doyle , he thought frantically. 
 Not Her . 
 He could just imagine the Woman hitting him, smashing at his face in the dark with the butt of her gun. 
 At least Doyle would not do that. 
 The dark figure bent nearer, too close for Tug to see the face. 
 But he could feel its breath on his cheek. 
 Thank  God, he thought, it  is Doyle . 
 And then he was doubly frightened, because he had known without seeing the face or hearing the voice, from small familiarities of feel and smell. 
 As if he had known Doyle all his life. 
 &bquo;Quiet,&equo; whispered the voice, very low. 
 &bquo;Daddy's going to tell you a bedtime story.&equo; 
 Tug lay very still and concentrated on breathing and the voice went on, so softly that it was only just possible to hear  it, even though Doyle's face was right up against his ear. 
 &bquo;Once upon a time, when Daddy was a little boy, he used to wake in the night and cry. 
 Because he was afraid of the dark. 
 Like you. 
 Crying in the dark.&equo; 
 I wasn't , Tug wanted to say. 
 But there was something about Doyle's voice that made it impossible to interrupt. 
 Something tense and hypnotic and terrifying. 
 He lay there and listened as the voice whispered on. 
 &bquo;And when he cried, his  Daddy would come. 
 Always his Daddy. 
 If his Mummy tried to come, she was sent away. 
 And his Daddy used to bring things with him.&equo; 
 Tug swallowed hard. 
 The voice was calm and soft and the words were ordinary, but he knew he was being told a horror story. 
 &bquo;Sometimes it was a belt. 
 Sometimes it was a lighted cigarette. 
 Once &mdash;&equo; the voice shook and hesitated for a moment &bquo; &mdash; once it was a pair of pliers. 
 But whatever it was, it had the same effect. 
 Your Daddy learnt never, never  to cry in the dark. 
 Because his Daddy didn't like it.&equo; 
 Tug's head was being forced backwards so that his throat was stretched almost unbearably. 
 Just as he started to feel that he could not endure it any longer, that he would have to struggle, Doyle's fingers relaxed slightly. 
 But his voice continued in the same frightful hiss. 
 &bquo;I've inherited that from my father. 
 I don't like crying in the dark. 
 What a pity you  seem to have inherited that  from me.&equo; 
 Pain and choking and rage all came together at once and Tug twisted his head aside. 
 &bquo;I haven't inherited that from you!&equo; 
 he shouted. 
 &bquo;I haven't inherited anything from you. 
 You're not my father . 
 My father's dead!&equo; 
 &bquo;You've inherited my fear of the dark,&equo; Doyle hissed again, as though Tug had not spoken, &bquo;But that's not the worst part. 
 You'll have inherited the other thing, too. 
 The hatred of crying in the dark. 
 I'll beat you, just as my father beat me. 
 And you'll beat your own children. 
 And they'll beat theirs. 
 On and on and on for ever, with no way out &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;No! 
 No !&equo; 
 Tug shrieked and struggled, trying to sit up.  
 &bquo;You're not my father! 
 My father was Frank Shakespeare!&equo; 
 But even while he was saying it, it did not sound true. 
 How could father  be any blurred shape on a photograph, too faded and far away to remember properly? 
 Father  was a huge figure bending over him in the dark. 
 A deep voice. 
 A rough chin brushing his cheek. 
 And any minute, any second now, it would happen. 
 Doyle would start to hit him and he would not be able to stop. 
 Nor would Tug be able to stop shrieking. 
 And it would go on and on and on &mdash; 
 Without any warning, the light flashed on. 
 &bquo;What the hell's happening?&equo; 
 It was the Woman. 
 She stood in the doorway with a man's night-shirt on and her hair in a plait. 
 When no one answered her, she came stamping into the room with a scowl on her face. 
 &bquo;I said what's happening ? 
 I thought it was my turn for a kip. 
 But as soon as I get into bed and shut my eyes, this racket starts up. 
 Can't you keep the kid quiet?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just telling him a little story.&equo; 
 Doyle smiled slowly. 
 &bquo;About family life.&equo; 
 He looked across at the Woman, so that she could share his smile, but she did not smile. 
 She was staring at Tug. 
 Suddenly she came across the room, the night-shirt flapping round her long, brown legs, and seized his shoulder. 
 &bquo;What's been getting to you?&equo; 
 &bquo;I &mdash;&equo; Tug looked up at Doyle. 
 &bquo;I woke up,&equo; he said weakly. 
 &bquo;I saw the skeletons and &mdash;&equo; To his surprise, he had to stop, in case he burst into tears. 
 And he could feel himself shaking. 
 The Woman nodded. 
 &bquo;Yes, they're pretty gruesome. 
 I thought you'd got a bit carried away when you were drawing them.&equo; 
 She gripped his shoulder harder and pulled him up, out of bed. 
 &bquo;Come downstairs. 
 I'll make you a hot drink.&equo; 
 As they reached the door, she looked back at Doyle. 
 &bquo;Get some Blu-Tack and put up those posters I bought. 
 Cover the scribbles over.&equo; 
 She did not speak again until she and Tug were down in the  big kitchen. 
 Then, as she bent over the stove, heating milk, she said casually, &bquo;So, what was Doyle telling you, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;He &mdash;&equo; Tug breathed harder. 
 &bquo;About his father.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah.&equo; 
 The Woman nodded, still with her back to him. 
 &bquo;And he frightened you?&equo; 
 Tug was still cold with the shock of it, but all he said was, &bquo;I didn't know. 
 That he was like that. 
 I thought he was &mdash; safe.&equo; 
 She turned, laughing softly, as she put the cup of hot milk into his hands. 
 &bquo;That's not how I'd describe Doyle. 
 Not safe .&equo; 
 &bquo;But he doesn't get angry and rage like &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Like me?&equo; 
 the Woman said. 
 for a moment she was very quiet, staring over his head, and her throat moved as she swallowed hard. 
 Then she sat down beside Tug, put her elbows on the table and rested her chin in the palms of her hands. 
 &bquo;Oh no, Doyle's not like me. 
 He never, never, never  loses control. 
 But don't kid yourself. 
 That's a very  angry man. 
 And dangerous.&equo; 
 Tug lowered his head and sipped. 
 The milk was hot on the roof of his mouth and he was sharply aware of the Woman sitting there, the sleeves of the night-shirt falling away from her strong, brown forearms. 
 Her eyes travelled from his face down to the mug which he held in his two hands. 
 The surface of the milk shivered treacherously, betraying his trembling. 
 Slowly she stretched out and cupped her own hands firmly round his, steadying and warming them. 
 Tug felt his hectic heartbeat slow down and his pulse grow calm, as if he were a little child being comforted after a nightmare. 
 And, like a little child, he stopped being careful and tense for a moment and said what was in his head, quite simply. 
 &bquo;Ma, what's going on? 
 The really frightening thing is not understanding.&equo; 
 Her eyes flickered. 
 Then she reached up a hand and stroked his hair gently. 
 &bquo;I know it's hard,&equo; she murmured. 
 &bquo;But it will be all right, I'm sure it will. 
 And you will  understand. 
 In the end.&equo; 
 The next moment she jumped up, almost angrily, as though  she had been trapped into a softness that she did not mean. 
 &bquo;Come on. 
 Drink up and get back to bed.&equo; 
 It was not until he was climbing the stairs in front of her that Tug realized suddenly, cold and clear, why her eyes had flickered before she answered. 
 He had called her Ma , without being asked to. 
 The thought appalled him so much that he went into the attic and slid back into bed without saying anything more to either of them. 
 Without even looking at the posters which now covered the walls, hiding the crayoned pictures. 
 The Woman gave him one look and then switched off the light and Doyle settled himself in the chair and sat silently in the shadows. 
 I called her Ma . 
 The thought ran through Tug's head, over and over again. 
 And it was worse than that. 
 Sitting there in the kitchen, he had actually felt  as though she were his mother. 
 He could imagine sitting on her lap when he was smaller. 
 Racing up in tears and clutching at her when he was hurt. 
 Waking in the night to find her bending over him. 
 Rolling over, he buried his face in the pillow and tried to get back his old picture of her &mdash; hard and tough and violent, the same all the way through. 
 But a tiny, treacherous crack of doubt had opened in his mind. 
 Until then, he had been sure of his memories, certain that he could not have forgotten his parents and everything that had happened to him and reinvented the whole of his life before he woke in the attic. 
 Only &mdash; was it really reasonable to think that the rest of the world was in league against him? 
 It wasn't just Doyle and the Woman, after all, who were telling him that he was wrong. 
 The television news-readers and the police and Hank &mdash; even Hank &mdash; were saying that Liam Shakespeare was shut up in his own home. 
 What was it they said about people who were convinced that the rest of the world was plotting against them? 
 Then, uncannily, Doyle spoke in the darkness. 
 The only words he said before morning. 
 He planted them in the silence with eerie precision, as though he had read Tug's mind.  
 &bquo;D'you realize how many people believe they're called Shakespeare ? 
 &mdash; In lunatic asylums, all over the country.&equo; 
 5.00 p.m. 
 &bquo;Aw, Jin, that's enough ,&equo; Oz said. 
 He was tired and crotchety, heaving his basket along with two hands. 
 &bquo;Mum'll faint if we pick any more.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be such a mardy-baby.&equo; 
 Jinny knew that she was being mean. 
 They had been out picking bilberries all day, stooping over the little tough bushes among the heather and separating the branches to find the fat, black berries with their bluish-misty sheen. 
 All along the Great Edge, from the Castle Rock northwards, they had worked in the sun, with bent backs and aching arms. 
 And Oz had worked just as hard as she had, not stopping to gaze down into the dale, but picking and picking until his fingers were stained blue-purple. 
 But now that they had reached the road at the dale head, he wanted to turn down it and go home. 
 He was right, really. 
 They had plenty of berries and there would be jobs ready and waiting for them. 
 Only &mdash; that was not what Jinny had planned. 
 At least you'll be able to choose where you go , Mum had said, giving her the day as a treat. 
 Well, she chose to go on, up along the hump of moorland that looked down on Back Clough Dale. 
 She shifted the basket on her arm and crossed the road. 
 &bquo;Come on,&equo; she called over her shoulder. 
 &bquo;You know there's more up behind Mrs Hollins's cottage. 
 No one'll pick them unless we do. 
 It's waste  to leave them.&equo; 
 Waste  was a magic word in the Slattery family. 
 It made Bella shriek and wave her arms about and it set Joe drumming his fingers on the table with that quiet disapproval that was worse than anything Bella could do. 
 Oz gave in straight away and started to follow Jinny up the slope. 
 Looking back and seeing him trudging so patiently and  you catch up, I can show you where Dad and I took the hare.&equo; 
 &bquo;And tell us how you did it?&equo; 
 Oz said quickly. 
 &bquo;If you promise not to go splitting all round the village.&equo; 
 Oz formed his face into a solemn mask that would have been funny if Jinny had not been trying to keep him happy. 
 As it was, she forced down her sense of humour and began to explain what Joe had done, how he had blocked the holes and netted the gate and chased the hare out with Ferry. 
 There was nothing Oz liked better than finding out how to do some new thing. 
 He attended without wavering as she took him round to the head of the little dale, above the cottage, pointing out the hare's field below them as they went. 
 When they were level with the trees behind the cottage, she gave Oz a little push. 
 &bquo;I'll do up here. 
 You go lower down, in the trees. 
 Be quicker if we split up.&equo; 
 Oz edged carefully down the slope, crouching every now and then as he reached a little bilberry bush. 
 Jinny found some nearer the top, in the open, where she could stand and peer down at the cottage. 
 It lay in its hollow, drowsy in the afternoon sun, its grey gritstone walls casting a short, black shadow. 
 There was no movement, not even a twitch of the curtains, and no sound breaking the sleepy summer silence. 
 Discouraged, Jinny bent to her picking, telling herself that she was stupid to expect faces at the window or dramatic voices calling. 
 At that moment, a voice did call, so that she jerked with shock. 
 But it was only Oz. 
 He shouted from the slope below her, sounding shrill and puzzled. 
 &bquo;Hey! 
 Jin!&equo; 
 She spun round, but she could not quite see him. 
 He was somewhere a little to the left, in a cluster of small, scrubby trees. 
 &bquo;Ssh!&equo; 
 she hissed, as loudly as she dared. 
 &bquo;Don't forget there's visitors in the cottage. 
 Don't go annoying them.&equo; 
 It seemed that he had heard her, because there was silence again and Jinny turned back towards the little patch of  bushes she was picking over. 
 But before she could settle to it, there was a sudden scrambling and slithering at the bottom of the slope. 
 Then Oz's voice again, sounding quite different. 
 &bquo; JIN !&equo; 
 She knew that panicky, rising note. 
 Laying her basket down, she ran towards the shriek, her feet slipping on the loose ground as she came under the trees, until she finished with an uncontrollable slide that landed her almost on top of Oz. 
 And the Hare-woman. 
 She had Oz by the shoulder and Jinny, tumbling nearly into her arms, said the first thing that came into her head. 
 &bquo;Mrs Doyle!&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 The woman looked up, puzzled. 
 Then she looked closer studying Jinny's face. 
 &bquo;Oh yes, I remember. 
 The self-sufficiency girl.&equo; 
 And she grinned. 
 Jinny began to speak idiotically fast. 
 &bquo;This is my little brother. 
 I hope he's not been annoying you. 
 He's not bad considering he's only eight and &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Thanks!&equo; 
 said Oz. 
 He wriggled his shoulder free and stepped backwards, away from the Hare-woman and closer to Jinny. 
 &bquo;What have you been doing?&equo; 
 Reluctantly, Jinny looked away from the woman so that she could inspect him. 
 There did not seem to be any wounds or any broken bones. 
 &bquo;That was a terrific yell.&equo; 
 &bquo;I heard the first one,&equo; said the Hare-woman, watching them both. 
 &bquo;Thought he might have hurt himself or something so I came out to have a look. 
 And I guess I frightened him.&equo; 
 Jinny looked at Oz again. 
 He didn't seem  frightened. 
 He was gazing at the woman with the strange, unblinking stare which meant he was working something out. 
 &bquo;What did you yell for, Oz?&equo; 
 He let his breath out and said solemnly, &bquo;I found some mushrooms. 
 Look.&equo; 
 He pointed at the top of his basket. 
 On top of the bilberries lay a few rather scrubby chanterelles,  slightly battered. 
 Quite an ordinary haul. 
 Nothing to get excited about. 
 &bquo;You want to be careful with those,&equo; the Hare-woman said. 
 &bquo;Don't want to land up in hospital.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, Oz is good at fungi,&equo; muttered Jinny absently, wondering. 
 Why make such a fuss about a few miserable chanterelles? 
 &bquo;They're grand.&equo; 
 Earnestly, Oz scooped them out of the basket and held them towards the woman. 
 &bquo;Here. 
 You have them. 
 Because I disturbed you.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh no. 
 That's O.K.&equo; 
 &bquo;Please. 
 I want  you to have them.&equo; 
 He was doing his winsome act, almost fluttering his eyelashes at her. 
 The Harewoman looked sharply at him and then shrugged, taking the chanterelles into her hand too roughly, so that Jinny smelt the faint apricot smell they gave off. 
 &bquo;O.K. Thanks. 
 Now &mdash; are you going on looking for more?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh no,&equo; Oz said, before Jinny could answer. 
 &bquo;My basket's full of bilberries. 
 We're going home now. 
 Come on, Jin.&equo; 
 He hauled the basket up the slope, towards the place where Jinny had been, so that she could retrieve hers, but he did not stop there. 
 He walked straight back round the top of the little dale until they came down the slope to the road, well out of sight of the cottage. 
 Then he sat down with a thump, his legs sticking straight out in front of him. 
 Jinny squatted beside him. 
 &bquo;And what was all that  about?&equo; 
 she said sharply. 
 &bquo;All that fuss about a few miserable mushrooms. 
 And then you forced them on her . 
 She obviously didn't want them. 
 They'll go straight in the bin.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh &mdash; them,&equo; Oz sounded scornful. 
 &bquo;Did you really think I was shouting about them ? 
 Mingy little things. 
 No, I only said that to shut her up. 
 Because I thought she was peculiar.&equo; 
 &bquo;What d'you mean peculiar ?&equo; 
 said Jinny angrily. 
 But the hair on the back of her neck prickled to hear him saying it so  calmly. 
 Because the Hare-woman was lovely, but she was  peculiar. 
 &bquo;She jumped me,&equo; Oz said. 
 &bquo;Bounced out as soon as she heard me call you and came scrabbling up the slope. 
 That's why I yelled the second time. 
 I wanted you.&equo; 
 &bquo;And what about the first time? 
 The one that started all this off? 
 If it wasn't the mushrooms, what set you shrieking?&equo; 
 She could see that she had got to it at last. 
 Oz looked important and mysterious, settling himself as though to tell a long story. 
 &bquo;I saw a flash of white through the bushes. 
 Thought it might be a puff-ball. 
 Remember when Dad found that puffball up there and Mum did it with bacon &mdash;?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, yes,&equo; Jinny said impatiently. 
 &bquo;Go on.&equo; 
 &bquo; Well , it wasn't a puff-ball.&equo; 
 He rummaged in his pocket and pulled out something damp and crumpled. 
 &bquo;Look!&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh OZ ! 
 It's only a rotten paper dart.&equo; 
 &bquo;You open it and look inside.&equo; 
 Oz sounded impressive and serious. 
 Silly little boy. 
 He was too old for stories like that and &mdash; 
 Then she opened the dart and saw the smudgy letters inside: 
 HELP I AM A PRISONER HERE. 
 She stared down at it for a long time. 
 That's just what you wanted , half her mind was saying excitedly. 
 But the other half was remembering how the Hare-woman had stood on the slope, staring with those wild, watchful eyes and saying The self-sufficiency girl , with that direct, lop-sided grin. 
 Oz tugged at her sleeve. 
 &bquo;What d'you think it's for?&equo; 
 &bquo;Mmm?&equo; 
 &bquo; Jin ! 
 Are you going to do anything about it?&equo; 
 All of a sudden she decided. 
 She stood up. 
 &bquo;Come on. 
 We're going down to the village. 
 We're going to see Keith's Dad.&equo;  
 5.40 p.m. 
 Tug was suffocating. 
 His head was jammed up against the back of the sofa, his cheek on the carpet and Doyle's hand clamped over his mouth. 
 His whole body felt bruised from the speed at which Doyle had dragged him round and thrown him on to the floor when they heard the shout outside. 
 The television news-reader's voice still rang across the room, sounding forlorn now that no one was listening. 
 &bquo;&hellip; free People today announced what they are demanding in exchange for the release of Liam Shakespeare. 
 They want the Government to abolish Child Benefit and all tax allowances for parents and use the money to set up full-time Community Homes for everyone under the age of sixteen. 
 They claim that this will &bquo;break the harmful power of the nuclear family&equo; and they have given the Government until next Friday to agree.&equo; 
 Weird , thought Tug. 
 He knew that he had been brought down specially to hear that, but it seemed to have nothing to do with him. 
 Could have been a million miles away. 
 All he could think of was that he wanted to sneeze. 
 His nose was full of dust and he could not help himself. 
 &bquo;A &mdash; a &mdash; TCHOO!&equo; 
 He spluttered into Doyle's hand. 
 &bquo;Filthy beast,&equo; said Doyle. 
 He did not move his fingers a millimetre. 
 Then they heard the front door open. 
 &bquo;It's O.K.&equo;&equo; the Woman's voice called. 
 Her hands were full of queer yellow mushroom things. 
 She threw them on to the table and looked down at Doyle and Tug. 
 &bquo;You two having a wrestling match?&equo; 
 Doyle smiled smoothly as he got to his feet. 
 &bquo;Part of growing up. 
 Trying your strength against your Dad. 
 Philip's got quite a way to go yet before he can beat me.&equo; 
 His fingers were still round Tug's wrists as he looked the Woman sharply up and down. 
 &bquo;So?&equo;  
 She shrugged. 
 &bquo;Nothing. 
 Only a couple of kids larking about. 
 I've seen the girl before. 
 She's local.&equo; 
 &bquo;A girl?&equo; 
 Doyle suddenly went very still. 
 &bquo;About fourteen? 
 Skinny and ginger, with a plait?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; yes.&equo; 
 The Woman frowned and Tug could almost feel her muscles tense. 
 &bquo;You've seen her too?&equo; 
 &bquo;Exactly.&equo; 
 Doyle jerked at Tug's arms to bring him round to the table. 
 &bquo;It was her, last time. 
 I think the three of us should sit down and have a little talk.&equo; 
 Tug slumped into a chair and looked first to one side and then to the other. 
 On his left, the Woman sat biting her thumb-nail, with eyes flickering warily. 
 On his right, Doyle's pale blue eyes were steady under the black hair, his face doubly familiar and hated because Tug saw something very like it every time he looked into the mirror. 
 &bquo;Right,&equo; said Doyle. 
 &bquo;Let's talk about visitors.&equo; 
 The two of them leaned closer, across the table, and Tug found himself leaning forward too, as though he were helping to make their plan. 
 As though the three of them were a group, defending itself against the outside world. 
 6.30 p.m. 
 &bquo;I see,&equo; said Mr Hollins slowly. 
 &bquo;And what is it you want then, Jinny?&equo; 
 He refolded the paper dart neatly and sent it skimming across the tea-table. 
 Mrs Hollins tutted fussily and Keith bent to pick it up. 
 &bquo;She wants you to go up there of course, Dad,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;To see what's afoot.&equo; 
 He spoke a little impatiently, and his mother rounded on him. 
 &bquo;I won't have you speak to your father like that. 
 And as for him going up Back Clough Dale and mithering the folk up there, and all for nothing &mdash; well, I reckon you've lost your brains, my lad, to think of such a thing. 
 And  you can get your  elbows off the table. 
 I don't know what Jinny must think.&equo; 
 You don't care a straw what I think , Jinny said inside her head. 
 But she pressed her lips together and kept it in. 
 No point in riling Mrs Hollins any further. 
 That  wouldn't help Keith. 
 She fixed her eyes on Mr Hollins's face and waited for his answer. 
 But she had forgotten that Rachel would have to put her two pennorth in first. 
 It was done with a scornful glance at Keith and then a grin of agreement at Mrs Hollins. 
 &bquo;Dad'll make himself look a great idiot if he goes up there, won't he, Mum? 
 Keith's gone out of his wits bringing Jinny in with a tale like that.&equo; 
 Jinny clutched hard at Oz's hand, biting her tongue. 
 But she had no way of signalling to Keith, and she saw him frown ominously. 
 &bquo;That's rude, Rachel,&equo; he said, firmly but softly. 
 &bquo;You'll make Jinny feel bad, and she's done no harm.&equo; 
 &bquo; And  I'll thank you not to tell your sister what to do!&equo; 
 Mrs Hollins jumped to her feet. 
 &bquo;Come on. 
 Upstairs. 
 I will not have you two bickering.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I wasn't &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo; Upstairs !&equo; 
 Red-faced, Keith pushed his chair back, looking large and ridiculous. 
 Jinny saw Oz gaping in amazement and she kicked his foot. 
 No point in making Keith feel worse. 
 She stared down at her plate, embarrassed and angry. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry,&equo; she said as Keith went out of the room. 
 &bquo;I had no call to come bursting into your tea like this. 
 Disturbing you all. 
 Only &mdash; when I found the note &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;When I  found the note &mdash;&equo; Oz interrupted her. 
 &bquo;Oh yes. 
 When Oz found the note, we reckoned it might be &mdash; it might mean &mdash;&equo; She doubled her fists and looked frantically up at Mr Hollins. 
 &bquo;I'm not fooling, I promise. 
 And there was the shout the other day, as well.&equo; 
 Mr Hollins grinned suddenly. 
 &bquo;Calm down, girl. 
 I  know you're not fooling. 
 Know you better than that. 
 You're pure Slattery, to the bone, with never a joke in your body.&equo;  
 &bquo;Well then?&equo; 
 Jinny looked hopeful. 
 &bquo; Please !&equo; 
 Oz said. 
 He was sitting next to Mr Hollins and he looked solemnly at him. 
 &bquo;You should have been there when that woman came leaping out at me. 
 Horrid it was.&equo; 
 Mr Hollins rubbed a large hand over his large face. 
 &bquo;You're never going to listen to them?&equo; 
 said Mrs Hollins. 
 &bquo;We-ell,&equo; he rubbed harder. 
 &bquo;It could be &mdash; just could be &mdash; Jinny's right and there is  something queer going on up there. 
 I'd best take a look, just to be on the safe side.&equo; 
 &bquo;But they're our tenants,&equo; Mrs Hollins snapped. 
 &bquo; My  tenants. 
 I'll not have them put out.&equo; 
 Her husband stood up to fetch his helmet. 
 &bquo;Tenants or no tenants, I've got my job to do. 
 Come on, Jinny. 
 I'll use you for an excuse. 
 Then you can see if you've made a fuss for nothing.&equo; 
 &bquo;And me!&equo; 
 Oz said quickly. 
 Mr Hollins rumpled his hair. 
 &bquo;I'm not running a Sunday School outing. 
 You can stop here with Rachel.&equo; 
 Oz pulled a terrible face. 
 &bquo;But I was the one who &mdash; &bquo; 
 Bending down quickly, Jinny whispered in his ear. 
 &bquo;It's no good going on. 
 He won't take you. 
 But you don't have to stop with Rachel and Mrs Hollins. 
 Take yourself up to Keith and tell him I'll be back to say what happened.&equo; 
 To her relief, Oz nodded and, as soon as they all took their eyes off him, he slid away from the tea-table and out of the room. 
 Jinny followed Mr Hollins to his car. 
 He grinned at her as he switched the engine on. 
 &bquo;Do we need the siren? 
 Blue lights flashing?&equo; 
 He was much jollier when Mrs Hollins was not there. 
 Jinny grinned back. 
 &bquo;Like a proper policeman, you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;Cheeky young chip!&equo; 
 But he was teasing her absentmindedly. 
 His real thoughts were on something else and he fell silent as they pulled away from the post Office and up the dale. 
 He did not speak again until they were bumping up the track towards the cottage. 
 Then he said suddenly. 
 &bquo;There's no call to go stirring folk for nothing. 
 I think we'd best not speak about paper darts and cries for help. 
 Eh?&equo;  
 &bquo;But how will you &mdash;?&equo; 
 &bquo;Leave it to me, lass. 
 Just keep your wits about you.&equo; 
 As they got out of the car and walked across the yard, their feet scrunching on the stones, Jinny had a queer feeling that they were being watched. 
 There was nothing to support it, no face at a window, no movement of a curtain, but when Mr Hollins knocked on the front door it opened immediately. 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 said the Hare-woman. 
 Then she caught sight of Jinny and their eyes met. 
 &bquo;Oh, hallo.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hallo,&equo; Jinny said. 
 She felt that she had given the whole thing away, that the Hare-woman's eyes would be able to read all her thoughts from her face and that single word. 
 But if it was so, the woman gave no sign. 
 She simply looked back at Mr Hollins, polite and expectant. 
 &bquo;Good evening, Mrs Doyle.&equo; 
 Mr Hollins stood square on the doorstep. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry to trouble you. 
 Perhaps we might come in a minute?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course.&equo; 
 There was no hesitation. 
 Not even the second's surprised pause that anyone might have made. 
 Jinny and Mr Hollins stepped through the door straight into the big kitchen. 
 The room was full of the cheerful clutter of a family on holiday &mdash; books, maps and a camera flung on to the table. 
 There was a faint stale smell, as though everything might not be as fanatically clean as Mrs Hollins liked it, but there was nothing odd to see. 
 The other two people in the room were sitting side by side on the old sofa. 
 There was the man Jinny had seen before, with the cold blue eyes that almost made her shudder as she met them again, and there was a boy. 
 A boy with black hair and ice-blue eyes. 
 &bquo;I think you've met my husband before,&equo; said the Harewoman. 
 &bquo;And this is my son, Philip.&equo; 
 They're like as twin lambs , was Jinny's first thought. 
 Then she saw that that was not quite right, because their features were very different. 
 Especially the mouths. 
 The man's lips were narrow and pale where the boy's were full &mdash; almost  swollen. 
 But that extraordinary colouring, the pale, pale eyes and the black hair, clearly marked out the two of them as father and son. 
 All her images of a tiny waif locked in the attic seemed suddenly foolish and fantastic. 
 This boy was sitting in a room with his parents, like anyone else. 
 And no sign of chains or a whip or iron bars. 
 She stared at the floor, turning pink and feeling so confused that she almost missed what Mr Hollins was saying. 
 &bquo;&hellip; embarrassing to have to trouble you like this, but we've had a bit of bother with the sheep hereabouts. 
 There's been a strange dog out chasing them. 
 Young Jinny here reckons she saw it heading up here yesterday. 
 That right, Jinny?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes.&equo; 
 Jinny looked up, gathering her wits. 
 &bquo;A little terrier. 
 Like a Jack Russell. 
 With a tattered ear.&equo; 
 (Was that overdoing it? 
 Why was the boy staring at her so?) 
 &bquo;No dog here,&equo; said the man. 
 The question seemed to amuse him in some way. 
 &bquo;But perhaps you'd like to look over the house. 
 Just to be on the safe side?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; thank you.&equo; 
 Mr Hollins looked surprised, but he was not ruffled. 
 &bquo;I reckon I will.&equo; 
 He got heavily to his feet. 
 &bquo;Save a lot of bother in the long run.&equo; 
 The woman opened the door at the bottom of the stairs. 
 &bquo;I'll come with you. 
 Not that you need showing the way, of course.&equo; 
 As they began to climb, Jinny looked back towards the sofa and met the boy's eyes again. 
 He was still gazing straight at her, without smiling or speaking. 
 And there was something odd about his face. 
 Something unexpected, but almost familiar. 
 Was it that he looked so much like his father? 
 Jinny tried to track it down, but it eluded her. 
 His father prodded him. 
 &bquo;Go on, Phil. 
 The girl'll think you're thick. 
 Talk to her. 
 Make conversation.&equo; 
 He said it with an odd, teasing leer, as though he were asking for something very difficult, and when the boy spoke he sounded awkward, his voice high and polite. 
 &bquo;Do you live in the village?&equo;  
 &bquo;Not to say in  the village,&equo; Jinny said. 
 &bquo;We're up the dale a bit. 
 We've got a little farm &mdash; more of a smallholding, really.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh?&equo; 
 With a visible effort, he tried again. 
 &bquo;You live there with your parents?&equo; 
 Jinny nodded. 
 &bquo;And my brother Oz and my baby sister Louise.&equo; 
 The conversation was heavy, like a choking weight, and she plunged on, trying to get some reaction from the boy, to make it easier. 
 &bquo;We're cranks, you know. 
 Grow all our own food and make our own clothes. 
 We'd have our own generator too, only there's not a big enough head of water to our spring. 
 My Dad s always talking about trying a windmill, but he's never managed it yet, so it's home-made tallow candles in the winter, to save the electricity. 
 And they stink .&equo; 
 What was wrong with the boy? 
 He did not even force a grin. 
 He seemed to have not the slightest interest in what she was saying. 
 And yet he stared and stared and stared. 
 Jinny rattled on, less from politeness than just to try and cover the terrible, wooden silence. 
 &bquo;We need a bit of money, of course. 
 There's always rates and suchlike. 
 So my Dad has a workshop. 
 He's a jeweller by trade and &mdash; &bquo; 
 And then it happened. 
 Feet sounded on the stairs. 
 Mr Hollins and the Hare-woman coming down again. 
 For a split second the man on the sofa glanced away, towards the noise. 
 In that second, while Jinny was babbling on about Joe, the boy looked her straight in the eyes and spoke soundlessly, his lips shaping a single word. 
 Help . 
 There was no mistaking it. 
 And he was obviously serious. 
 His eyes were desperate. 
 They widened even more and his eyebrows went up and down, with an odd little flicker, as though with the effort of forcing his message silently across the air to Jinny. 
 &bquo; &mdash; at the moment he's making a beautiful chain for a Mayoress down south.&equo; 
 Miraculously, her voice went on in a steady stream, without a quiver, while her mind tried to take in what had happened. 
 What did he mean? 
 And then the  Hare-woman was coming through the door at the bottom of the stairs and the man with the cold eyes was watching again. 
 &bquo;&hellip; very sorry to have troubled you,&equo; Mr Hollins was saying. 
 The man shook his head. 
 &bquo;No trouble. 
 Come again. 
 Come every day, if you like.&equo; 
 He still sounded amused. 
 &bquo;Perhaps Philip'd like to come over to us,&equo; Jinny broke in quickly, finding courage from somewhere. 
 &bquo;It's grand fun with the pigs and the chickens and the cow and that. 
 Not to count my sister Louise. 
 She's the noisiest of all. 
 But he'd be welcome to come. 
 My brother Oz is desperate to have someone to play with, on account of the rest of us being girls. 
 He says &mdash; &bquo; 
 It was Mr Hollins who stopped her. 
 To her astonishment, he suddenly prodded her in the ribs. 
 &bquo;We'd best be going, Jinny.&equo; 
 The warning in his voice was clear. 
 Jinny was so amazed that she stopped speaking in the middle of a sentence and let him say goodbye and make their apologies all over again. 
 She did not understand what he had meant until they were getting into the car. 
 &bquo;Sorry to haul you off, girl,&equo; Mr Hollins said in a low voice, &bquo;But I reckoned it would be more comfortable for everyone if I got you out afore they had to start making excuses. 
 You weren't to know, but the boy's simple. 
 Has fits, as well. 
 That's why they keep themselves to themselves up there.&equo; 
 Jinny hesitated. 
 &bquo;You mean he's mad?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh no.&equo; 
 Mr Hollins sounded shocked. 
 &bquo;Not mad. 
 Just a bit simple, like a little child.&equo; 
 He clipped his seat-belt and turned on the engine. 
 &bquo;Had posters of Peter Rabbit and suchlike up in his room. 
 And a thick cloth across the skylight, to help him sleep. 
 Seems to need a deal of mollycoddling. 
 His mother explained it all.&equo; 
 He put the car into gear and they slid away from the cottage. 
 &bquo;So that's the way of it, you see,&equo; he finished kindly. 
 &bquo;It's often like that. 
 Go to investigate one thing and you turn up another that you didn't expect, like as not. 
 That's one thing I've learnt in the police force.&equo; 
 &bquo;But &mdash;&equo; Jinny frowned, not quite ready yet to tell him  what had happened to her. 
 &bquo;Didn't you think they were a peculiar  family?&equo; 
 Before she could explain what she meant, Mr Hollins was laughing at her. 
 &bquo;Live in a box, don't you, up at that farm of yours? 
 Want to get down into the world, lass. 
 See how it is. 
 All  families are peculiar.&equo; 
 &bquo;But that boy &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Come on, now. 
 I told you the way of that.&equo; 
 Jinny looked down at her feet and spoke very quickly, so that he could not interrupt her. 
 &bquo;He said &bquo;Help&equo;. 
 When you were upstairs. 
 And he said it secretly, so that his father didn't see.&equo; 
 Mr Hollins steered round a pot-hole. 
 &bquo;There's no more I can do, Jinny. 
 I'm not a psychiatrist or a social worker. 
 Don't ask for miracles. 
 I've come on your wild-goose chase and that's all I can do for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;But &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;But they're queer? 
 So? 
 That's a family. 
 I've told you. 
 Prod any family and you'll find queer happenings. 
 That's another thing I've learnt in the police.&equo; 
 His voice was quite kind, but it forbade any more questions and Jinny fell silent, looking back over her shoulder as they reached the lip of the little hollow. 
 There were the three figures, standing in the doorway of the cottage, watching them go. 
 Philip stood between his parents. 
 His father's arm was round his shoulders and his mother was ruffling his black hair. 
 Dimly Jinny supposed that Mr Hollins was right. 
 A family. 
 That was what they were. 
 And who was to know what went on in anyone else's family? 
 It was just as Joe had been telling her all her life. 
 Not her business. 
 7.15 p.m. 
 Tug watched the back of the police car bump its way up the  track. 
 Gone. 
 They'd gone, the policeman and the girl, and he felt miserable and confused. 
 Part of him was coldly aware of the bulge in Doyle's pocket &mdash; the gun which had made sure he would not scream and beg for help. 
 Coward! 
 I'm a coward. 
 I could have been free if I weren't a coward. 
 But it wasn't that simple. 
 The policeman and the girl had come on an ordinary routine visit. 
 To the Doyle family. 
 They had talked politely and gone away without noticing anything. 
 Because they believed  in the Doyle family. 
 And somehow that made it more real. 
 Tug shuddered. 
 I am Tug , he said fiercely to himself, struggling to drag his memories closer around him. 
 But they were ragged and insubstantial, with the lurid colours of fancy dress. 
 How could they cover the sensible, everyday clothes of Philip Doyle?  
 He shuddered again, and Doyle's arm tightened round his shoulders. 
 &bquo;Well, well.&equo; 
 The soft murmur echoed Tug's unhappiest thoughts. 
 &bquo;And what do you suppose Mr Pig and skinny Miss Ginger made of our happy family?&equo; 
 The Woman turned, pulling the whole of the little group round with her so that they faced the house, towards the mirror which hung over the sofa. 
 &bquo;Look,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;That's what they saw.&equo; 
 Tug looked. 
 Their faces were reflected back, two black heads and one brown, close together. 
 Doyle smiled slowly. 
 &bquo;A lovely composition.&equo; 
 He walked to the table and picked up the big Polaroid camera in its leather case. 
 &bquo;Stay there, looking out of the door. 
 This thing's got a time-switch.&equo; 
 Taking a chair, he set the camera up in the yard outside, bending over for a moment to fiddle with it. 
 &bquo;What's he doing?&equo; 
 Tug said tensely. 
 &bquo;You know Doyle and his holiday snaps,&equo; said the Woman, her eyes grave.  
 Then he was back, sliding his arm nonchalantly round Tug's shoulders and smiling into the evening light. 
 &bquo;Say cheese, you two.&equo; 
 &bquo;I won't &mdash;&equo; Tug started to protest. 
 But before he could move there was a click and Doyle was starting back towards the camera. 
 With a wrench, Tug wriggled free of the Woman's arm and ran. 
 Not out of the cottage &mdash; that would have been pointless, because Doyle barred the way &mdash; but back into the kitchen. 
 Flinging himself on the carpet, he buried his head wretchedly in the sofa cushions. 
 After a moment, Doyle said, &bquo;Don't you want to see it?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I don't.&equo; 
 Tug pushed his head deeper into the soft, musty cushions. 
 Doyle chuckled. 
 &bquo;Scared?&equo; 
 Defiantly Tug raised his head. 
 &bquo;Of course I'm not scared. 
 It's just &mdash; &bquo; 
 But he did not know himself what it was and the impossibility of explaining made him turn his head at last and look across at the bright, rectangular picture Doyle was holding out. 
 There they were, the three of them, in the doorway of the cottage, rather shadowy but plain enough. 
 The Woman loomed over the group, tall and brown and smiling down at the two mops of black hair &mdash; one over a quizzical smile and the other over a scowl. 
 It was a classic holiday picture. 
 The two parents with their rebellious adolescent son. 
 Anyone could have guessed the relationship without a caption. 
 Tug shut his eyes, screwing them up hard. 
 &bquo;It's a lie,&equo; he said frantically, trying to convince himself. 
 Doyle smiled. 
 &bquo;The camera can't lie.&equo; 
 &bquo;It can. 
 It has .&equo; 
 &bquo;Why?&equo; 
 The Woman's voice was cool and intelligent, not teasing like Doyle's. 
 &bquo;Tell us why.&equo; 
 &bquo;The whole thing,&equo; choked Tug, opening his eyes. 
 &bquo;The whole stinking happy family. 
 It's a lie !&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course it's a lie.&equo; 
 She sounded pleased to say it and Tug  stared at her, with a wild hope that she was going to explain everything to him. 
 &bquo;Of course it's a lie,&equo; she said again. 
 &bquo;The whole idea  of a happy family. 
 All families are parasitic and destructive. 
 I've told you. 
 The family is a prison. 
 It was like being given an ice-cube when you needed hot soup. 
 Tug could have screamed. 
 &bquo;I didn't mean that rubbish.&equo; 
 Her smile faded. 
 &bquo;Oh Tug ! 
 Haven't you understood anything?&equo; 
 A sour, thick fear eddied in his throat. 
 A fear beside which the fear of the gun was nothing &mdash; a game. 
 &bquo;What did you say?&equo; 
 He spoke very slowly. 
 &bquo;I said you haven't understood a thing. 
 I've been struggling away, trying to help you &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;No, not that .&equo; 
 He brushed it away impatiently. 
 &bquo;What did you call  me?&equo; 
 She hesitated, searching back to remember what she had said, and then she laughed. 
 &bquo;What? 
 Oh, I called you Tug.&equo; 
 Her eyes shifted, glancing at Doyle and then flickering back. 
 &bquo;Don't you remember? 
 It's the name I had for you when you were a baby.&equo; 
 &bquo;No,&equo; said Tug, in a low, horrified voice. 
 A dense blackness swirled round him. 
 Tug, I am Tug . 
 It had been his defence against them. 
 His secret self. 
 &bquo;No!&equo; 
 &bquo; Yes ,&equo; said Doyle. 
 &bquo;Look.&equo; 
 The Woman suddenly reached for her big, shabby handbag. 
 Doyle watched her riffle through a wad of papers as though she had taken him by surprise, and when she held up something for Tug to see he craned sideways so that he could glimpse it too. 
 It was another photograph. 
 Old. 
 It must have been old, because she was in the centre of it, the lines of her face less formed, the shape of her bones softer. 
 Her hair was cut aggressively short, accentuating the sharp point of her jaw and she was cradling a very small baby. 
 Her smile, as she gazed into the camera, was wry and mocking, as though it amused her to find herself in the traditional pose of a mother. 
 &bquo;Really?&equo; 
 murmured Doyle. 
 &bquo;Well, well, well.&equo;  
 &bquo;Six weeks old,&equo; said the Woman, watching Tug. 
 &bquo;No,&equo; Tug said again. 
 But it was a blind, wild reply. 
 As though he had lashed out with both fists to keep off an attack. 
 He wouldn't let  it be true. 
 Suddenly he reached across and snatched the photograph out of the Woman's hand, ripping it in half and dropping the pieces on the floor. 
 As though, ridiculously, he could blot out the misery in his mind by destroying a picture. 
 Then he looked up and for a moment he was so amazed that he forgot the misery. 
 He saw that he had really hurt the Woman. 
 Hurt her beyond all pretending. 
 She went rigid, her eyes wide and the blood sucked out of her face. 
 &bquo;How interesting ,&equo; crooned Doyle. 
 &bquo;It's not &mdash; it doesn't matter,&equo; the Woman said harshly. 
 &bquo;It was only a photograph, for God's sake.&equo; 
 But she was not looking at it. 
 She was looking resolutely away, so that Tug could feel what an effort it took her not to bend down and pick up the pieces. 
 &bquo;How touching ,&equo; Doyle said coldly. 
 He stooped and picked up the torn halves himself. 
 &bquo;Been cherishing this, have you?&equo; 
 &bquo;It was only a photograph ,&equo; the Woman said again, as though she were defending herself. 
 They seemed to have forgotten Tug. 
 Whatever the point of the conversation was, it held them both tense, their eyes staring until there seemed almost to be an invisible bond. 
 Then, very slowly and deliberately, Doyle tore the two halves of the photograph across and across, into a shower of tiny pieces that fell through his fingers on to the floor. 
 The Woman said nothing, but her face was white and her eyes glittered terribly. 
 Tug found that his fury had gone and he was feeling sorry for her. 
 Nervously, he touched her hand. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry.&equo; 
 And then, because he thought she would like it, &bquo;I'm sorry, Ma.&equo; 
 But she turned away without looking at him and the next moment Doyle had him by the arm and was hauling him upstairs. 
 Tug went miserably, without resisting. 
 The struggle in his  head was so fierce that he had no energy left to fight Doyle. 
 Images appeared in his brain, one overlaying another, confusing him. 
 The Woman smashing him to the ground and beating at his face. 
 In the kitchen, with her hands cradling his. 
 As he had just left her. 
 How did you put all those pictures together to make a whole person? 
 And &mdash; worse &mdash; how did you ever decide what you felt about that person or what she meant to you? 
 Doyle thrust him into the attic and locked the door, not bothering to stay and guard him. 
 The room was darkened by the cloth they had pinned over the skylight, to hide the bars, and Peter Rabbit and Mrs Tiggywinkle and Jemima Puddleduck stared down from the posters on the walls. 
 But Tug did not even look at them. 
 He walked across to the bed and flung himself on it. 
 Oh Hank , he thought, what would you do now?  
 Could  you understand what's going on ? 
 But Hank would not come. 
 He strained to conjure up her face and her voice, but they had vanished, as completely as though the memory had been cut out of his brain. 
 And the more he tried to visualise her, the more he saw another face. 
 With brown hair, scragged back into an elastic band, and huge, golden eyes.  
 Day Eight &mdash; Sunday 14th August 
 10.00 a.m. 
 Jinny would have been quite all right. 
 Back to normal and ready to forget about the Hare-woman and the Back Clough Dale cottage. 
 Ready to concentrate on milking and hoeing and clearing away the broad beans and planting out the rest of the cabbages, so that everything was done before the harvest on Tuesday. 
 Only she could not stop seeing the strange boy's face. 
 All through Saturday, she worked on it, telling herself that it was none of her business. 
 That the boy was just simple and given to playing stupid jokes. 
 But it did not work. 
 Wherever she looked, the face stared back at her. 
 The pale blue eyes gazed from the bottom of the milk pan she was scrubbing, piercing the clouds of steam from the boiling water with the quick, earnest flicker of their eyebrows. 
 They danced in front of her as she went up Long Field, following Joe and the horse and heaving old broad bean haulms into the cart. 
 They glimmered reproachfully out of Florence's golden face when Jinny sat down to do the evening milking. 
 And it was not the memory of their silent, desperate appeal that worried her. 
 That could  have been a game, after all. 
 Just possibly. 
 What disturbed her was the feeling, at the back of her mind, that there was something she ought to have understood. 
 Something that she would have grasped, if it weren't for her own stupidity. 
 She fought the feeling all through Saturday, but by Sunday she had had enough. 
 She was sweeping out the yard while Bella cooked the lunch and sang to the baby. 
 Joe was up in Long Field with Oz and the cabbage plants, expecting Jinny  to join him. 
 And she would have gone. 
 But as she swept, gritting her teeth and ignoring thoughts of the Doyle family, a rich, delicious smell floated out over the yard. 
 A rare, special smell that should have had her licking her lips and counting the hours until lunch. 
 Bella was cooking the hare. 
 For some reason that Jinny did not quite understand, it was the last straw. 
 Marching across the yard, she put the broom in the tool-house and simply went on walking, towards the village and Keith. 
 As she went round to the back of the Post Office, she could hear Mrs Hollins and Rachel in the kitchen, giggling and chattering while they cooked their  Sunday lunch. 
 They sounded quite pleasant when they were alone together, without Keith to nag at, but Jinny still did not want to meet them. 
 She could see Keith, crouched over his papers, and she rapped on the living-room window to tell him to let her in. 
 When he opened the door, he was grinning with surprise and delight. 
 &bquo;Jinny, you're psychic! 
 I was just wondering if there would be time to fetch you down here before lunch. 
 I need to ask you about something.&equo; 
 &bquo;And I want &mdash;&equo; began Jinny. 
 But Keith was already pushing her into the living-room, bubbling with what he had to say. 
 &bquo;Sit there, where you can see the television. 
 I want to play you a recording I made last night. 
 See if you think it's as peculiar as I do.&equo; 
 Oh no , Jinny thought as he bent down to fiddle with the controls of the video recorder. 
 Not more of this Harriet Shakespeare stuff . 
 &bquo;Look I've not got long, and I want to &mdash;&equo; 
 &bquo;Won't take a minute ,&equo; Keith said firmly. 
 &bquo;Listen &mdash; you know how worried she sounded when she was interviewed the other day? 
 When she didn't know about the terrorists ' demands?&equo; 
 He didn't bother to say who he was talking about now, Jinny noticed. 
 It was just She. 
 He was obsessed. 
 Then she remembered, with grudging fairness, that it was  an obsession of her own that had brought her down there. 
 Keith must be as bored with the Hare-woman and her family as she with Harriet Shakespeare. 
 She would have to listen to him first. 
 Dragging up her last shreds of interest, she nodded. 
 &bquo;Well, the terrorists have announced their demands now.&equo; 
 Keith looked round at her. 
 &bquo;I don't suppose the news has got up your hillside though.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be snide,&equo; Jinny said primly. 
 Keith grinned. 
 &bquo;I thought not.&equo; 
 Then he looked serious. 
 &bquo;Well, I can tell you what they've asked for. 
 They want Community Homes to be set up for everyone under sixteen. 
 So children don't have to live with their families. 
 And the whole system's supposed to be funded by abolishing Child Benefit and the tax allowances people get for their children.&equo; 
 Jinny shrugged. 
 &bquo;So? 
 That's just crazy.&equo; 
 &bquo;No it's not.&equo; 
 Keith shook his head. 
 &bquo;It's exactly the kind of demand I expected. 
 Very definite and precise and practical.&equo; 
 &bquo;But they must know they'll never get it,&equo; Jinny said. 
 &bquo;It's too much .&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course they'll not get it,&equo; said Keith. 
 &bquo;This time. 
 But they're making dead sure people think seriously about the idea. 
 By saying they'll shoot Liam Shakespeare if the Government don't agree by Friday. 
 And that makes him as good as dead now. 
 So &mdash;&equo; He stopped and took a deep breath. 
 Thank goodness , thought Jinny. 
 We're getting to the point . 
 &bquo; &mdash; so how would you expect Harriet Shakespeare to feel now?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, worse, of course.&equo; 
 Jinny could not understand why he was asking something so obvious. 
 &bquo;She must  have been hoping they'd ask for something she could give. 
 Even though she doesn't approve of giving in. 
 If they've asked for really impossible things, it means the whole siege has been done for publicity &mdash; and they'll probably kill Liam whatever happens. 
 And she can't do anything to stop them, because she's not the Government.&equo; 
 &bquo; Exactly .&equo; 
 Keith beamed at her, as though she had passed  an exam. 
 &bquo;Now, have a look at this interview that was on the News last night.&equo; 
 He pressed a switch. 
 The recording started with the news-reader announcing that Harriet Shakespeare had replied to Free People's demands. 
 Then her fair, tough face appeared on the screen. 
 (&bquo;She doesn't look  any different,&equo; muttered Jinny. 
 &bquo;Ssh! 
 Listen!&equo;) 
 &bquo;Mrs Shakespeare,&equo; said the interviewer, &bquo;now that we know what the terrorists are asking in return for your son's life, has your view of the situation changed?&equo; 
 &bquo;The demands are what I would have expected,&equo; Harriet Shakespeare said steadily. 
 &bquo;I have spent the last six months investigating Free People, and what they have asked for constitutes the first stage of their long-term programme.&equo; 
 &bquo;And are they a violent group? 
 Do you expect them to kill Liam, as they threaten, if they don't get what they ask for?&equo; 
 (&bquo;That's an insensitive question if you like,&equo; hissed Keith. 
 &bquo;Perhaps they think she can take it because she's an interviewer herself.&equo; 
 &bquo; Sssh !&equo;) 
 &bquo;&hellip; not really wise for me to comment,&equo; Harriet Shakespeare was saying. 
 &bquo;But there's one thing I do want to say. 
 I'm told that the television is on most of the time in my house &mdash; the police can detect it &mdash; and I want to say something to Liam, if he's watching.&equo; 
 Her pale blue eyes turned away from the interviewer and towards the camera. 
 Jinny's skin seemed to twitch all over her body, but she did not know why. 
 Harriet Shakespeare went on speaking, very slowly and emphatically. 
 &bquo;Don't give in. 
 It's going to be all right. 
 If it's in my power, you'll be quite safe on Friday, wherever you are. 
 I'll do everything in my power to get you out . 
 Just keep on being brave, that's all.&equo; 
 Keith switched off. 
 &bquo;What do you think?&equo; 
 &bquo;She was serious, wasn't she?&equo; 
 Jinny blinked. 
 &bquo;Not just saying that to cheer him up. 
 She really believes she can get him out.&equo; 
 There was no mistaking the earnestness of those  pale blue eyes and the curious, characteristic flicker of the eyebrows. 
 &hellip; the curious, characteristic flicker of the eyebrows&hellip;. 
 Jinny sat back in her chair and swallowed hard. 
 I am going mad , she thought. 
 She swallowed harder. 
 &bquo;Please will you run it again?&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 said Keith. 
 &bquo;Why &mdash;?&equo; 
 &bquo; Run it again !&equo; 
 He gave her a puzzled glance and then shrugged and pressed the right switches. 
 This time Jinny watched carefully. 
 And she caught it twice. 
 Harriet Shakespeare's desperately serious expression, with the eyes widening and the eyebrows flickering up and down. 
 The expression that had been haunting her for nearly two days. 
 There seemed to be a block in her chest so that she could not breathe properly. 
 As Keith switched off the video recorder, she said, &bquo;You've got a picture of Liam Shakespeare, haven't you?&equo; 
 She was so short of breath that it was an effort to speak. 
 &bquo;Jin, are you all right?&equo; 
 &bquo; Please . 
 A picture. 
 No, not one of those.&equo; 
 He had reached for the file of grey newspaper photographs. 
 One or two of them, taken through the windows of Harriet Shakespeare's house, showed a blurred back view of a fair-haired boy. 
 &bquo;I want a proper one, that show his face. 
 Didn't you have something from before the kidnap?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, you mean the magazine article that Mam found. 
 The one you spluttered over like an old colonel.&equo; 
 Keith grinned as he selected another file. 
 &bquo;Jinny, why not tell me what you're after? 
 You look really peculiar. 
 As though you're going to be sick.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll tell you in a minute,&equo; Jinny said shortly. 
 &bquo;And I shall  be sick unless you hurry up.&equo; 
 It's impossible , her mind was saying. 
 You're mad, you're mad, you're mad . 
 &bquo;There you are, then.&equo; 
 Keith tossed the article across to her. 
 Three shiny pages folded together. 
 Jinny remembered it clearly because it had been quite different from all the solemn newspaper cuttings  Keith had shown her, and she had stopped to make fun of one or two of Harriet Shakespeare's more nauseating remarks. 
 Like &mdash; It takes a lot of nerve to become a writer when your name's Shakespeare  and In the sort of job I do, courage and truth are essential . 
 As she unfolded the pages this time, looking for the picture of Harriet Shakespeare with her son, Jinny's hands were trembling. 
 She had not really examined the boy's face before, because she was too busy making fun of the article. 
 But she knew he was there, because she remembered thinking how mean his mother was to talk about him. 
 Now she was praying that her idea was wrong, that she would find herself looking at someone totally unfamiliar. 
 Because she had not the faintest idea what she would do if she were right. 
 There was the picture. 
 Harriet Shakespeare with her son Liam . 
 And the boy's face was not unfamiliar. 
 It was different, because the hair was fair and the mouth was smiling, but the same pale blue eyes looked out at her. 
 The same features. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; 
 Keith said gently. 
 Jinny shut her eyes. 
 Opened them again. 
 &bquo;Have you got a black felt pen? 
 A fine one?&equo; 
 He handed it to her, with a piece of paper. 
 Jinny let the paper fall to the ground and, very carefully, began to colour in the fair hair around Liam Shakespeare's face. 
 &bquo;What are you doing? 
 You've ruined it!&equo; 
 Keith tried to snatch the pen away from her and she slapped his hand so that he did not jog her. 
 &bquo;Shut up!&equo; she hissed. 
 Then she went on colouring very slowly and carefully, wondering all the time what she was going to do next. 
 When she had finished, she put the top on the pen and laid it down. 
 Then she stared at the picture for a full minute. 
 She could feel Keith watching her. 
 Waiting. 
 &bquo;Liam Shakespeare's not in that house in London,&equo; she said at last, in a small, level voice. 
 &bquo;He's here. 
 In your Mam's cottage in Back Clough Dale.&equo;  
 10.45 a.m. 
 Tug had forgotten what day it was until he heard the bells. 
 He had been lying on his back, looking at the ceiling with his eyes out of focus, taking his pulse over and over again to keep his mind empty. 
 Because there was no music now to fill it. 
 Doyle and the Woman had left him in silence, watching him but not talking. 
 Letting the questions fill his mind. 
 The questions he could not answer and could not ignore. 
 Looking back, he saw that, for almost a week, he had kept himself going with little schemes and plots. 
 Shouting to attract attention. 
 Making paper darts. 
 Trying to signal to the girl and the policeman. 
 Like a baby, playing with plastic beakers on the edge of a volcano, or shuddering at tales of the Big Bad Wolf while monstrous murderers sharpened their knives at the door. 
 And all the time he had been asking &bquo;When can I go home?&equo; 
 But all that seemed almost like a simple happy life, now that he knew the real questions. 
 The questions that everything around him was asking. 
 Doyle, the Woman, the television news-readers, Hank, the girl and the policeman &mdash; even his own face in the mirror &mdash; all told him that he was Philip Doyle. 
 That Liam Shakespeare was a hostage in a house in Shelley Grove. 
 And did he really believe that they were all  wrong? 
 Or all trying to trick him? 
 Was the whole world mad? 
 Could he be the only one who had got it right? 
 The questions had chased each other round and round, finding terrible answers, until he knew he would start to scream if he did not shut them out. 
 So now he lay on his back and thought of nothing and took his pulse from time to time. 
 Because that  was true. 
 That was the only thing he knew for certain about himself. 
 He wasn't dead. 
 Then the bells started. 
 Church bells, tumbling over each other in the peculiar, timeless, mathematical jumble that means Sunday . 
 They caught him unprepared, before he could blank out his mind, making him remember the last time he had heard that sort of ringing, last Sunday.  
 He had been running, running as hard as he could to break his record for the five miles. 
 And he had nearly given up. 
 But then the sound of the church bells had lifted him, flooded him with a glorious, fierce determination, and his aching legs had flown along, pumped by some extra force, some last strength that he had never tapped before. 
 He closed his eyes. 
 The memory was staggeringly clear, as though he had just heard those other bells, as though he were just surging forward in his final spurt, kicking for home. 
 I remember &hellip;. 
 No! 
 The cautious part of his mind froze. 
 It was a trick, leading him back into the same old treadmill. 
 Hank, Ma, Doyle, Shelley Grove&hellip;. 
 Memories tumbled together. 
 Last Sunday I went running, expecting Hank home in the evening. 
 She'd been investigating one of her peculiar groups and she said there was about to be a break-through. 
 We were going to have a special meal&hellip;. 
 No! 
 No! 
 Last Sunday I drove here in the car with Ma and Doyle. 
 When I got here, I fell over outside and knocked myself out. 
 That's why I have to rest&hellip;. 
 No! 
 He gripped the sides of the bed and struggled to clear his mind again, to push out every memory, even the sharp, physical memory of the running. 
 Running was a delusion, just like everything else. 
 He couldn't trust it. 
 He couldn't afford to believe that he had ever run like that, with such aching legs and such a flood of strength. 
 It might not have happened. 
 It might not have happened. 
 It might not have happened it might not&hellip;. 
 Of course it did . 
 The voice in his mind was small and cool, above the struggle. 
 And suddenly he saw that it was right. 
 It had to be right. 
 He sat up sharply. 
 So did Doyle, on his chair by the door. 
 Tug grinned feebly at him, shrugged and rolled over, turning his back so that Doyle could not watch his expression. 
 Then he started to think hard.  
 There was no way he could be remembering that experience of running &mdash; of the joy and the pain and the total, ultimate effort &mdash; unless it had actually happened to him. 
 Perhaps not last Sunday, and perhaps not on the way to Liam Shakespeare's front door, but it had happened. 
 It was a part of him, as sure and certain as his pulse-beat. 
 And if he could be sure of that, there must be other things that he knew about himself. 
 Other memories that were too sharp and real to be invented. 
 He could build up a knowledge of who he was, piece by piece. 
 Slowly, testing every thought and every memory, he began to think about himself. 
 And what he could be certain of. 
 He was fairly fit. 
 He could tell that from his pulse-beat, which was only fifty-four when he was lying like this, on the bed, and from the hardness of his biceps when he bent his arm. 
 He hated bananas. 
 Even thinking about their blotched yellow and black skins and their squidgy, floury middles made him want to throw up. 
 And he hated desiccated coconut. 
 And winkles. 
 He knew how to change the washer on a tap, and make pastry, and mend a bicycle puncture. 
 He was sure, not only because he could have written out a set of instructions there and then, if he had had any paper, but because he could imagine all the minute details of doing those things. 
 The soft, perished feel of the old washer which rubbed black on your fingers as you took it out of the tap. 
 The way the pastry mixture clung to your hands if you mixed it with too much water. 
 The lovely, tell-tale trail of bubbles that showed where the puncture was. 
 He probably learnt French at school (je m'appelle Je-Ne-Sais-Quoi) and possibly Spanish (no s&eacute; donde me encuentro) but not Russian (  ). 
 He must have spent a lot of time out in the sun &mdash; running? 
 training? 
 &mdash; because his watch had left a clear, sharp-edged mark on his tanned arm.  
 Ideas bombed at him from all directions. 
 His heart thudded and he realized that he had begun to breathe faster, with excitement. 
 He took his pulse again to calm himself (it had gone up to sixty-five) and then began to concentrate hard on gathering up the bits of himself. 
 Bits that didn't depend on who he was or what family he belonged to. 
 He was still doing it over an hour later, frantically trying to remember everything and wishing he had somewhere to write it all down, when there was a sound of feet running up the stairs. 
 The Woman pushed at the door, behind Doyle's chair, and when he moved sideways she stepped in. 
 Doyle looked at his watch. 
 &bquo;Not your turn yet. 
 Another hour to go.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know. 
 Came to tell you I've cooked some lunch, and &mdash; &bquo;she hesitated. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; 
 Doyle did not sound pleased. 
 The Woman put her chin up defiantly. 
 &bquo;Well, I'm sick of heaving trays up and down the stairs. 
 And I bet you are too. 
 Why don't you just bring Tug down and we'll all eat together?&equo; 
 Doyle gave her a long stare. 
 &bquo;All right,&equo; he said at last. 
 &bquo;Get up, Philip.&equo; 
 Tug slid off the bed, watching them. 
 Doyle seemed wary and the Woman had started to fidget with her long tail of hair, holding it in one hand and drawing it through the fingers of the other. 
 She led the way downstairs and Tug followed her, feeling Doyle close behind him. 
 &bquo;I see,&equo; said Doyle softly as they came out at the bottom of the stairs. 
 The big table had been covered with a checked table-cloth and set out tidily with cutlery and mats and glasses. 
 There were two large vegetable dishes with lids on in the centre of the table and, beyond them, on an oval plate, was a roasted chicken, brown and shiny with stuffing oozing from one end. 
 Tug sat down where the Woman pointed, but Doyle began to walk round the room, peering at the table from all angles. 
 &bquo; Very  elegant. 
 Do we say grace?&equo;  
 &bquo;Shut up, Doyle,&equo; the Woman snapped. 
 He wandered over to the draining-board and looked into a jug. 
 &bquo;Custard!&equo; he said in disgust. 
 &bquo;How bourgeois can you get?&equo; 
 &bquo;For God's sake!&equo; 
 The Woman thumped the table with her fist and shouted. 
 &bquo;It's only a bloody meal . 
 Not a political statement.&equo; 
 Doyle looked at her coldly. 
 &bquo;Nothing is only  itself. 
 Everything has political overtones. 
 As you very well know.&equo; 
 Picking up the jug of custard, he walked across to the table and tipped it, steadily and deliberately. 
 A thick, yellow stream ran on to the chicken and trickled down its sides, until it lay in a pool of custard. 
 Tug gasped. 
 He glanced up at Doyle to see if it was meant to be a joke, but Doyle was not smiling. 
 &bquo;What's the matter, Philip?&equo; he said evenly. 
 &bquo;Surprised? 
 You shouldn't be. 
 This is the traditional family Sunday lunch, and we're having the traditional family Sunday lunch-time row.&equo; 
 The Woman stood up and faced him across the table. 
 &bquo;You're just making an idiot of yourself. 
 Lousing up good food.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm reminding you of what family life is really like,&equo; Doyle said. 
 His eyes did not waver from her face. 
 &bquo;Before you get too sentimental about it. 
 Sunday dinners were hell in my family. 
 My father grilled us about what we had been doing all week. 
 Worked himself into a frenzy and gave himself indigestion. 
 We were dead lucky to get to bed without a belting on a Sunday.&equo; 
 &bquo;Great,&equo; the Woman said sarcastically. 
 &bquo;I really enjoy your happy childhood memories, Doyle.&equo; 
 They were leaning forward facing each other, one on either side of Tug, looming over him. 
 The Woman was breathing faster, but Doyle was cold and still. 
 &bquo;They're happier than some  childhood memories,&equo; he murmured. 
 &bquo;Better than one story I know, about a baby who cried at every  meal. 
 Even Sunday lunch. 
 A baby who landed up with five broken ribs and a cracked skull and &mdash; &bquo;  
 The Woman leaned forward further and punched him hard, in the mouth. 
 Her face had gone white and very pinched. 
 Doyle's eyes narrowed and as he put one hand to his face the other slid dangerously to his jacket pocket. 
 Before he had time to think, Tug began to talk, quickly and nervously. 
 &bquo;Ma, I'm hungry . 
 And when we've eaten &mdash; whatever's left to eat &mdash; I'd like to have a pen and some paper. 
 There are some things I'd like to write down &mdash; &bquo; 
 For a second he thought the two of them were going to turn on him and hit him. 
 Then slowly the tension began to seep away. 
 The Woman unclenched her fists, gave a short laugh and sat down again. 
 Doyle looked at Tug almost sadly and spoke not to him, but over his head, to the Woman. 
 &bquo;You see? 
 Make a pattern and people step into it. 
 As long as the pattern lasts. 
 Don't you  remember interrupting like that to stop your parents quarrelling?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, sit down Doyle.&equo; 
 The Woman was busy peeling the custard-covered skin off the chicken. 
 &bquo;I've got what you mean. 
 I'm not thick. 
 But we might as well eat the food anyway.&equo; 
 &bquo; Delicious  chicken and custard,&equo; murmured Doyle, pulling his chair out. 
 &bquo;What have I got afterwards, to go with my gravy?&equo; 
 &bquo;Baked bananas.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh Ma !&equo; 
 Tug said it without thinking. 
 Annoyed. 
 &bquo;You know I hate bananas. 
 I'll be sick.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't be silly,&equo; the Woman said briskly. 
 &bquo;Of course I haven't forgotten. 
 There's a yogurt for you.&equo; 
 Her knife sliced down into the breast of the chicken. 
 1.00 p.m. 
 &bquo;But you must  listen, Mr Hollins.&equo; 
 Desperately, Jinny dragged at his arm. 
 &bquo;That boy was exactly like Liam Shakespeare except for the colour of his hair &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;And you're just the spit of Queen Victoria,&equo; Mr Hollins  said heavily. 
 &bquo;Or would be if you had white hair and put on a bit of weight. 
 Oh, there's no use flapping that picture under my nose.&equo; 
 He pushed away the photograph of Liam Shakespeare that Jinny was holding out. 
 &bquo;It's all scribbled over.&equo; 
 &bquo;But think when they came here &mdash; just at the time Liam Shakespeare disappeared &mdash; and &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Liam Shakespeare's not disappeared.&equo; 
 Mr Hollins's voice was still kind, but he was not budging at all. 
 &bquo;He's where all the world knows, in his own house with a couple of armed terrorists. 
 Now leave me be, Jinny. 
 I've come home to my dinner and I've not a lot of time to spare.&equo; 
 Shaking her hand off his arm, he looked at Keith as he went into the dining-room. 
 &bquo;See her out, lad. 
 Then come in to your meal.&equo; 
 Jinny stood very quiet for a moment, with a fist pressed to her mouth. 
 When she was sure she could talk without her voice cracking, she said, &bquo;What can I do, Keith?&equo; 
 &bquo;I know what most folk'd do,&equo; he said quietly. 
 &bquo;Go home and forget it all.&equo; 
 &bquo;So you  don't properly believe me either?&equo; 
 He waved his hands at her, to warn her to keep her voice down. 
 &bquo;That's not what I said. 
 I know you're  sure, and you're good at using your eyes. 
 You wouldn't dream a likeness.&equo; 
 &bquo;And no one's really seen that boy in Harriet Shakespeare's house,&equo; Jinny said eagerly. 
 &bquo;Only a back view in the shadows.&equo; 
 Keith nodded. 
 But he still looked doubtful. 
 &bquo;But where's the point? 
 Why pretend you're holding someone hostage when you've really carried him off?&equo; 
 Jinny thought quickly. 
 There must  be a reason. 
 Because she was certain that that was what had happened. 
 &bquo;Well, there's lots of publicity to a siege, isn't there? 
 Pictures on television every night and headlines in the papers. 
 But do they work ? 
 Do the terrorists get what they want?&equo; 
 Keith chewed his lip, trying to remember. 
 &bquo;I think &mdash; there's a lot of pressure. 
 Quite often they persuade them to give up the hostages. 
 And sometimes they storm the place.&equo; 
  He looked very thoughtful, his brows heavy over his eyes. 
 &bquo;You mean they get the best of both worlds this way.&equo; 
 He nodded slowly. 
 &bquo;Could be. 
 And Harriet Shakespeare was definitely strange in that interview, wasn't she? 
 What was it she said? 
 You'll be quite safe on Friday, wherever you are . 
 Do you think she knows ? 
 That he's not really there?&equo; 
 &bquo;But wouldn't that make her &mdash;?&equo; began Jinny. 
 Then stopped. 
 Why argue? 
 She wanted Keith to agree with her. 
 Instead, she said, &bquo;So what do we do? 
 Phone up the London police?&equo; 
 &bquo;No use doing that.&equo; 
 Keith shook his head. 
 &bquo;They'd just be straight through to Dad, if they took any notice of you. 
 And we know what Dad would say.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well what?&equo; 
 Jinny looked fiercely at him. 
 &bquo;You're not expecting me to go home and wait till they shoot that boy on Friday?&equo; 
 Before Keith had time to answer, Mrs Hollins stuck her head round the dining-room door. 
 &bquo;Keith! 
 What're you doing mooching about out there when the dinner's on the table?&equo; 
 &bquo;My fault,&equo; said Jinny. 
 &bquo;I'd best be gone.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes Mam,&equo; muttered Keith. 
 &bquo;I'll be in in a second.&equo; 
 But when Jinny stepped towards the back door, he pushed her into the sitting-room instead. 
 &bquo;Not yet!&equo; he hissed. 
 &bquo;I've got an idea. 
 How we could get a message through about the boy here. 
 Without bringing in the police.&equo; 
 Jinny frowned down at him as he fell to his knees and started to root about in his files of cuttings. 
 &bquo;You mean &mdash; write to Harriet Shakespeare? 
 Something like that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course not!&equo; 
 Keith sounded shocked. 
 &bquo;Be terrible to go troubling her if we were wrong. 
 No, I thought &mdash; her friend.&equo; 
 He took out the biggest picture of all, the one that showed a distraught Harriet Shakespeare supported by another woman. 
 &bquo;Read that and see what you think.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I can't stop here. 
 You'll get in a row, and &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;There'll be a row anyway. 
 Read  it.&equo; 
 Jinny looked down at the cutting. 
 A Mother's Grief ,  screamed the big, crude headline. 
 Beneath it, Harriet Shakespeare's face was huge and haggard and she was leaning hard against the woman beside her. 
 In spite of the sensational, unfeeling way it had been used, the picture was moving. 
 Jinny stared at it. 
 How could she go home and forget what she knew, when it mattered so much to someone else? 
 As much as life and death. 
 Then she read the caption. 
 A mother in agony , it gloated. 
 Shut out of her home and frantic with worry about her son, Harriet Shakespeare collapses in the arms of friend and neighbour Lucy Mallory . 
 &bquo;It's foul.&equo; 
 Jinny shuddered. 
 &bquo;Just so their beastly readers can feel sorry for her.&equo; 
 &bquo;Better than not caring at all,&equo; said Keith. 
 &bquo;Anyway, I didn't give it to you so you could go drippy on me. 
 Think. 
 Friend and neighbour . 
 This Lucy Mallory must live near Shelley Grove.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; 
 Keith rumpled his hair despairingly. 
 &bquo;Well, dumbo, if we had a London street map and telephone directory, we could probably work out where she lives. 
 Can't be that many Mallorys in the roads round there. 
 All we need is a trip to the library in Matlock tomorrow.&equo; 
 &bquo;But that'd take all day!&equo; wailed Jinny. 
 &bquo;I can't possibly &mdash; &bquo; 
 The door opened suddenly and Rachel's coy face peered round it. 
 &bquo; Don't  want to intrude on you two, but Mam's nearly purple. 
 You'll be doing all the washing-up on your own, Keith, I can tell you. 
 And  getting half of it chucked back because it's not clean enough. 
 She's in that  sort of mold. 
 You'll have to tear yourselves apart, you two. 
 So  sorry.&equo; 
 Jinny went bright red and started towards the door so fast that Keith did not catch her up until she was outside on the path. 
 &bquo;Look!&equo; 
 he hissed. 
 &bquo; I'll  go back to Matlock. 
 But I won't make the phone call. 
 If you want that done, you'll have to come down and do it yourself. 
 Tomorrow night. 
 Half-past nine?&equo;  
 Jinny calculated quickly. 
 &bquo;Say ten.&equo; 
 She would have a good chance of sneaking out unnoticed by then. 
 Keith nodded and darted back to the house and Jinny walked on down the path, trying to ignore Rachel, who was in the doorway. 
 But Rachel hated not to have the last word. 
 &bquo;Honest, Jin,&equo; she called, &bquo;I can't think what you see in that great lummock. 
 Did you know he cuts his toe-nails in the bath?&equo; 
 &bquo;Better than having claws like some people!&equo; 
 Jinny flung over her shoulder and ran. 
 But she knew that no amount of speed would save her. 
 As she walked up the track towards her own house, she braced herself, ready for a row of her own. 
 And the rich, savoury smell of the hare drifted down to meet her, turning her stomach.  
 Day Nine &mdash; Monday 15th August 
 4.00 p.m. 
 &bquo;You'd better hurry up with those exercises.&equo; 
 The Woman looked at her watch. 
 &bquo;Doyle said there'd be a meal at four.&equo; 
 Tug swung his arms like windmills. 
 &bquo;Great. 
 What is it? 
 Jelly and chips? 
 Porridge pic?&equo; 
 The Woman's mouth twitched. 
 &bquo;Spaghetti and treacle.&equo; 
 &bquo;Tomato soup sandwiches.&equo; 
 Tug's arms stopped and began to whirl the other way. 
 &bquo;Beefburger ice cream.&equo; 
 For a second it looked as though she would go on with the game, but then she stopped smiling and her eyes slid away from his. 
 &bquo;It wasn't a joke yesterday, you know. 
 It was serious.&equo; 
 Did she think he was an idiot? 
 As though anyone could have thought it was a joke, with Doyle's face set foul as a thunderstorm and the disgusting stream of custard ruining the meat. 
 Tug looked at her scornfully. 
 &bquo;I'm not a baby, you know.&equo; 
 Sitting down on the edge of the bed, he began to draw circles in the air with the toes of his left foot. 
 &bquo;He was furious with you for making a special lunch. 
 But why couldn't he say  that? 
 Why be so &mdash; so extravagant?&equo; 
 &bquo;Because &mdash; oh, because you know what he's like . 
 He doesn't think it's any use just telling people things. 
 Because they can only see what's straight ahead of them. 
 The things they've always  seen. 
 If you want to get them to look at something new, you've got to make  them see.&equo; 
 &bquo;Make them see what?&equo; 
 Tug said, puzzled. 
 It did not seem to have much to do with custard. 
 &bquo;Oh &mdash; everything. 
 The whole world.&equo; 
 The Woman waved her arms wide. 
 &bquo;Look, think of Doyle. 
 For years he hated his  father &mdash; and he believed, deep down, that he was wicked himself, because even his own father hated him . 
 And then, one day, he understood, and the whole world opened out. 
 He was free. 
 He said it was the most joyful moment of his life.&equo; 
 Tug tried to imagine Doyle having a joyful moment. 
 Difficult. 
 And yet he could almost see it reflected in the Woman's wide eyes and her glowing, excited face. 
 Certainly that moment of Doyle's was real to her. 
 &bquo; What  had he understood?&equo; 
 Tug said. 
 &bquo;That it wasn't his fault. 
 Nor his father's. 
 That it's unnatural  for people to be tied up together in families for years and years. 
 All those jealousies and demands and pressures &mdash; the stress is too much. 
 That's what happened to me. 
 That's why I &mdash; &bquo; 
 She broke off abruptly, but that did not make her silent. 
 Swept on the flood of her own excitement, she simply changed course, banging her fist against the side of her chair in her eagerness to make him understand. 
 &bquo; Animals  don't stay in families for ever, do they? 
 And people don't need to either. 
 But the system is encouraged by big business and governments, because if you've got a family you've got something to lose. 
 It stops people fighting against capitalism and repression. 
 That's what we've got to make people see!&equo; 
 She had been gesturing with one hand, to emphasize what she said. 
 Now she stood up and began to march restlessly round the room, swinging her long gun by its handle. 
 &bquo;We've got to rip off the blinkers! 
 Let in the light!&equo; 
 There was something glorious about her &mdash; almost Viking &mdash; as she stood in the centre of the room, tall and thin and fierce. 
 There should have been shouting and huge double-edged swords slicing the air, and giant bonfires with wild, roaring flames. 
 Tug felt the call to join her, to leap to his feet and let himself be carried up on the tide, into a high and heroic world. 
 But, instead, he drew back, repelled and almost frightened by the flooding, uncontrolled wildness of the emotion. 
 And  another voice spoke to him, in his head. 
 Familiar and wry, but just as fierce in its own way. 
 If a speaker excites you &mdash; distrust him. 
 And if he excites himself &mdash; distrust him a hundred times more. 
 Hank's voice. 
 His whole nature answered to the warning. 
 Yes. 
 That was what he felt. 
 He was a cautious, unheroic person, and Hank spoke for him. 
 Of course she did. 
 That was what she was for . 
 The thoughts dropped small and icy, into the very centre of him, paralysing all his senses. 
 He did not hear what the Woman said next. 
 He did not even see her face. 
 Suddenly, all he was aware of was one single, frozen thought: 
 Hank was someone he had made up. 
 Oh sure, Harriet Shakespeare  was a real person. 
 He had seen her on television. 
 But the Hank in his mind, the one who calmed him down and cheered him up and got him going in a sensible way &mdash; she was just the sort of fantasy mother you'd make up if your own mother was too strong, too passionate, too overwhelming. 
 Like Ma. 
 If she tried to squash out your cautious, unheroic side. 
 Harriet Shakespeare was a real person, but perhaps Hank was only a part of himself, given a famous face. 
 Perhaps he was like the people who think they're Napoleon, or that they're in love with the Queen. 
 Mad Philip Doyle. 
 &bquo;Tug, are you all right?&equo; 
 The Woman's voice came swimming out of a great blankness, forcing itself on him. 
 She was sitting on the bed beside him, clutching his shoulders and looking almost frightened. 
 &bquo;What's the matter?&equo; 
 He felt weak and shaking, as though he had just had a huge shock. 
 For a moment he could not speak. 
 She shook at his shoulders. 
 &bquo;Look, don't break down. 
 Not now. 
 Everything'll be all right. 
 After tomorrow.&equo; 
 But he did not take in the words. 
 Could not begin to  understand them. 
 Tomorrow? 
 Tuesday? 
 What had that got to do with anything? 
 Her face loomed huge and strong and worried and he struggled with the dryness in his throat, trying to ask a question without knowing what it was. 
 &bquo;Ma &mdash; &bquo; 
 While he was still searching for the right question to ask, the sound of a key in the padlock made them both jump. 
 The next second, the door swung open and Doyle was standing in the doorway, with a tray in his hands, looking at them both. 
 &bquo;What a pretty  picture,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;A nice bit of mothering going on.&equo; 
 The Woman had let go of Tug's shoulders as soon as the door opened. 
 Now she stood up and pushed both hands into the pockets of her jeans. 
 &bquo;Don't be stupid. 
 We were just talking.&equo; 
 &bquo;I think,&equo; Doyle murmured, &bquo;that you have forgotten what you were meant to be doing.&equo; 
 &bquo;Rubbish!&equo; 
 &bquo;Then why &mdash;&equo; his voice was level and unpleasant &bquo; &mdash; have you left the Kalashnikov on the bed? 
 Where Philip can reach it?&equo; 
 He was right. 
 The gun lay on the covers, where she had put it down while they were talking. 
 Tug had not even noticed. 
 Her arms jerked out immediately to scoop it up. 
 &bquo;There's no harm done.&equo; 
 &bquo;You know very well that it was extremely dangerous,&equo; Doyle said coldly. 
 &bquo;I was only being a little bit kind &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;You weren't being kind. 
 You were being sentimental.&equo; 
 They seemed to be trying to outstare each other. 
 If that was so, Doyle won, because the Woman suddenly crossed the room, pushed past him and ran down the stairs. 
 &bquo;Here,&equo; said Doyle. 
 &bquo;Have some food.&equo; 
 He held the tray out. 
 On it was a perfectly ordinary meal of beefburgers, mashed potato and peas, with a cup of tea and an apple.  
 &bquo;Thanks,&equo; Tug said. 
 &bquo;Thanks &mdash; what?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh.&equo; 
 He had simply forgotten. 
 Thanks Doyle. 
 Sitting on the edge of the bed, Tug balanced the tray on his knees and began to cut up the first beefburger. 
 But his hands were shaking so much that he could hardly stop himself knocking the food off the plate. 
 9.50 p.m. 
 Jinny slid out of bed, pulled on a jersey and a pair of jeans and stood listening in the dark. 
 From the next room came the sound of Oz, snoring. 
 He always lay flat on his back, with his arms flung out, making a noise that drowned out Louise's snufflings. 
 Quite enough noise to cover the sound of Jinny's feet creeping out of her own room and across the landing. 
 Good old Oz. 
 There were no voices coming from Joe and Bella's room. 
 Usually, at this time, they were lying in bed talking. 
 Asleep already , thought Jinny. 
 Better and better. 
 Very slowly, she began to go down the stairs, step by step, wincing every time one creaked and glancing over her shoulder every ten seconds or so. 
 She was so busy thinking about the people upstairs that she did not see the figure standing in the shadows of the kitchen doorway. 
 Not until it stepped forward and Bella's voice said, &bquo;Jinny!&equo; 
 &bquo;Mum! 
 You're still up!&equo; 
 Jinny stopped, trapped, and thought quickly. 
 Then she went on down the stairs. 
 &bquo; 
 Look, Mum,&equo; she whispered, &bquo;I have to go out. 
 I have  to. 
 Just for about half an hour. 
 Please don't stop me.&equo; 
 &bquo;More strange sneakings?&equo; 
 Bella peered at her through the dark. 
 &bquo;And you're not going to tell me why?&equo; 
 &bquo;It would take too long, honestly.&equo; 
 If she stopped to explain, Keith would be gone before she got to the  telephone-box. 
 &bquo;But if you did know, you wouldn't stop me. 
 You'd say it was all right. 
 I promise.&equo; 
 &bquo;I see.&equo; 
 Bella hesitated. 
 &bquo;And what about Dad?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah.&equo; 
 Jinny could not bring herself to tell the lie. 
 She hung her head. 
 &bquo;You're right. 
 He would stop me. 
 Because &mdash; oh, because I'm trying to help someone outside the family. 
 He'd say I'm snooping and interfering.&equo; 
 Blast it , she thought. 
 Now I've had it . 
 She wished she could see Bella's face properly, but the shadows were thick and all she could make out was the outline of a head. 
 Suddenly the head gave a brisk nod. 
 &bquo;All right. 
 If you're not just doing something stupid. 
 You have to do what you think is right, even if Joe and I don't always agree with you.&equo; 
 Bella stepped aside. 
 &bquo;But be careful. 
 And come back quickly. 
 I shan't sleep until you're in.&equo; 
 &bquo;And you'll not tell Dad?&equo; 
 &bquo;I didn't say that.&equo; 
 There was a soft chuckle in the darkness. 
 &bquo;Let's hope he's asleep.&equo; 
 &bquo;Thanks Mum.&equo; 
 Jinny leaned across and kissed her lightly on the cheek. 
 Then she let herself out of the door and walked through the yard, muttering quietly to Ferry, so that he would know who it was. 
 As she ran along the track to the road, she had an eerie sense that she was acting out something she had done before, but she could not pin it down until she reached the road and turned right, towards the village. 
 Last time it was left . 
 Then she remembered. 
 Last time she had slipped out in the dark like this was on the night the Doyles had come, the night that had ended with a mystery and a death. 
 For a second she could almost feel the warm slump of the hare's body, and its weight when it swung from her hand, heavy and loose, as she carried it home by the ears. 
 She shuddered. 
 Then she was running towards the village, ignoring the small scutterings on the bank beside the road, her old sandals almost soundless on the tarmac. 
 The village windows were bright behind their curtains,  cosy and alive beneath the cold, black shadow of the Edge. 
 Jinny wondered for the hundredth time what it was like to be in a family which sat up and watched the television of an evening. 
 Played games and records and telephoned people, without feeling guilty about the electricity. 
 Keith was standing by the lighted telephone-box. 
 Jinny saw him move his head and look at his watch and she called softly, &bquo;Sorry I'm late. 
 I got caught.&equo; 
 &bquo;Caught?&equo; 
 Keith sounded puzzled. 
 &bquo;You mean you couldn't just say you were going for a walk?&equo; 
 She passed it off as a joke, furious that she had given herself away. 
 &bquo;Don't forget it's the middle of the night to a Slattery. 
 Come on. 
 Let's get on with it before I fall asleep. 
 Did you get the number?&equo; 
 &bquo;Sort of.&equo; 
 They squeezed into the little, bright cubicle and Keith put a piece of paper down on the shelf. 
 &bquo;Here you are. 
 There were two Mallorys nearby, I'm afraid. 
 You'll have to try them both. 
 I've lots of change. 
 I went into the bank while I was in Matlock.&equo; 
 He dropped a bank bag full of silver on to the shelf and Jinny stared, momentarily distracted. 
 &bquo;But that's pounds .&equo; 
 &bquo;Only a fiver. 
 There's no use in running out of money at the crucial moment.&equo; 
 Only  a fiver. 
 Jinny remembered Bella and the sugar. 
 What would Keith say if he really knew what it was like to be a Slattery? 
 &bquo;Come on, girl. 
 Get going if you're going to do it.&equo; 
 She lifted the receiver and dialled the first number with great care. 
 Out in the darkness, she saw the Post Office door open and Mrs Hollins poke her head out. 
 Nosy . 
 Jinny smiled politely at her, listening to the ringing tone. 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 It was a man's voice, brisk and well-bred. 
 Jinny was paralysed until Keith prodded her and she choked out the first words. 
 &bquo;Mr Mallory?&equo; 
 &bquo;Speaking.&equo;  
 &bquo;Could I &mdash; I mean &mdash; please can I give you a message for Harriet Shakespeare?&equo; 
 &bquo;No you can't.&equo; 
 Suddenly the man on the phone was furious. 
 &bquo;For the last time, Harriet Shakespeare is not here ! 
 Good night .&equo; 
 He banged the phone down and Jinny turned to Keith, shaking. 
 &bquo;He was &mdash; awful. 
 Why did he have to be so rude?&equo; 
 Keith grinned. 
 He was near enough to hear everything. 
 &bquo;Looks like we're not the only people to work out this Mallory thing.&equo; 
 He took the receiver firmly out of her hand, listened for the dialling tone and dialled the second number. 
 &bquo;You going to do it then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 She took the receiver and Keith put his face close again, so that he would not miss anything. 
 The ringing seemed to go on and on and when at last a voice answered it took Jinny by surprise. 
 &bquo;What number are you calling?&equo; 
 &bquo;What?&equo; 
 She looked stupidly at the telephone. 
 &bquo;This is the exchange,&equo; said the voice. 
 &bquo;What number are you calling?&equo; 
 Keith put his finger on the paper, beside the right one, and Jinny read it out. 
 &bquo;And who do you want to speak to?&equo; 
 &bquo;Lucy Mallory.&equo; 
 &bquo;What is your name?&equo; 
 &bquo;Imogen Slattery.&equo; 
 &bquo;And what number are you calling from?&equo; 
 &bquo;Er &mdash;&equo; Jinny looked down at the dial. 
 &bquo; &mdash; Ashdale 623X&equo; 
 &bquo;Hold the line, please.&equo; 
 The ringing began again and Jinny covered the mouthpiece. 
 &bquo;What is it? 
 What's going on?&equo; 
 &bquo;Must have had their calls re-routed through the exchange,&equo; Keith whispered back. 
 &bquo;To put off cranks and keep a record of who telephones. 
 Looks like we've got the right number.&equo; 
 He pushed a couple more coins into the slot. 
 Then there was another voice. 
 A woman's. 
 &bquo;Lucy Mallory.&equo;  
 Jinny took a deep breath and felt her heart thud. 
 &bquo;Please &mdash; I want to give you a message for Harriet Shakespeare.&equo; 
 At once the woman's voice went cold. 
 &bquo;Who is that speaking?&equo; 
 &bquo; Please ,&equo; said Jinny desperately. 
 &bquo;I'm not a crank. 
 It's important. 
 It's about Liam. 
 I want to tell you &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Wait a moment.&equo; 
 The woman did not sound any friendlier and the pause was a long one. 
 Once they heard her say, &bquo;But Harry, you can't keep on &mdash;&equo; And then she must have put a hand over the mouthpiece, because they did not hear anything else until, suddenly, another voice spoke. 
 &bquo;Hallo.&equo; 
 A different voice. 
 Deeper, and very clear. 
 A voice that they had heard over and over again as they sat in Keith's sitting-room. 
 Jinny gulped. 
 &bquo;You &mdash; you're Harriet Shakespeare!&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right.&equo; 
 &bquo;Look &mdash;&equo; There did not seem to be any way of wrapping it up. 
 The words came bursting out anyhow. 
 &bquo;I know where Liam is.&equo; 
 On the other end of the line, the voice hesitated and then went steely-hard. 
 &bquo;Everyone knows where Liam is.&equo; 
 &bquo;But he's not.&equo; 
 Jinny gabbled it, trying to get it in before she was cut off. 
 &bquo;He's not in your house. 
 He's in my village. 
 Being kept a prisoner. 
 I've seen him, only he's got black hair and &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Listen!&equo; 
 Harriet Shakespeare broke in, so fiercely that Jinny could imagine the fury on her face. 
 &bquo;You're the fourteenth  person who's worked out I'm staying with Lucy and phoned me up with crazy stories about Liam. 
 I suppose you must get a thrill out of it, but if you really knew anything you'd go to the police.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's not fair!&equo; 
 Jinny shouted it. 
 &bquo;I've tried telling the police, but they  still think Liam's in your house. 
 It's no use talking to them.&equo; 
 There was a silence. 
 Then Harriet Shakespeare said, more  softly and sounding puzzled, &bquo;So why is it any use talking to me? 
 &bquo;Well &mdash; we saw your last interview. 
 You seemed &mdash; that is we thought &mdash; that you knew something &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Yes?&equo; 
 The word was clipped short. 
 Jinny hunted for what she wanted to say and then let it out in a rush. 
 &bquo;We thought you wouldn't have been like you were in that interview unless you knew something that &mdash; that you weren't telling people. 
 We thought you might have guessed that all those announcements by the terrorists were a lie and really &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;And?&equo; 
 Harriet Shakespeare said. 
 All at once her voice was very low. 
 Not angry, but quiet and tense. 
 &bquo; What  do I know that I'm not telling people?&equo; 
 &bquo;That they're only pretending to have Liam in your house. 
 &bquo;That really he's somewhere else.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh.&equo; 
 It was long drawn out. 
 Almost, Jinny could have sworn, on a breath of relief. 
 And then she was angry again. 
 &bquo;You're wrong. 
 You're quite wrong. 
 Now why don't you just forget the whole thing? 
 And stop imagining things about me!&equo; 
 A click. 
 And then the dialling tone. 
 Very carefully, Jinny put the receiver back into its cradle. 
 &bquo;Well,&equo; she said, and her voice came out high and cracking, &bquo;we were wrong. 
 She didn't know anything. 
 She didn't understand at all. 
 She was horrible .&equo; 
 Keith patted her absent-mindedly on the shoulder. 
 But he was not looking at her. 
 He was staring out at the great dark sweep of the Edge, above the dale. 
 &bquo;I don't think we were wrong,&equo; he said slowly. 
 &bquo;We were wrong about what  she knew, I'll give you that. 
 But she didn't like the idea that we knew she was hiding something, did she? 
 I wonder what &mdash;?&equo; 
 And he went on gazing out of the window, drawing on it with his finger until Mrs Hollins came out and rapped on the glass.  
 Day Ten &mdash; Tuesday 16th August 
 2.55 a.m. 
 &bquo;Tug!&equo; 
 The whisper made him stir in his sleep, turning and thrusting one arm under the pillow. 
 &bquo; Tug !&equo; 
 This time the hiss was louder and strong fingers gripped his shoulder and shook it, jerking him awake. 
 He opened his eyes in darkness and for a horrific moment he was completely adrift, not knowing what was happening or where &mdash; or who &mdash; he was. 
 Nothing but blackness. 
 Then, under his pillow, his hand touched paper. 
 The small, folded sheets on which he was writing down the things he knew about himself. 
 The feel of them brought him back into the attic room, to the confusion that made a few words on a piece of paper into a lifeline. 
 He lifted his head. 
 &bquo;Tug?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ma? 
 What's up? 
 What time is it?&equo; 
 She leaned closer, her mouth almost on his ear. 
 &bquo;Ssh. 
 Don't wake Doyle. 
 I thought you'd want to hear this.&equo; 
 Dimly he saw that she was holding something, but he did not realize what it was until she spoke again. 
 &bquo;Come on. 
 Wake up properly. 
 The next News is in a minute or two.&equo; 
 Of course. 
 It was the little radio that they listened to while they were on guard. 
 But the Woman did not offer him the ear-piece that she and Doyle used. 
 Instead, she turned it on so low that at first Tug could not make out anything except a faint crackling and hissing. 
 He sat up and lifted the radio so that  it was close to his ear. 
 Even so, the first words took him by surprise. 
 &bquo;Good morning.&equo; 
 It was soft, but as brisk and clear as it would have been in the middle of the day. 
 And then it went on and Tug stopped thinking about the quality of the sound. 
 Because of what the news-reader was saying. 
 &bquo;There has been an extraordinary development in the Shelley Grove siege. 
 Just before midnight last night, a special unit of police stormed the house, taking control of it and capturing the terrorists inside, without loss of life. 
 However, they found no trace of Liam Shakespeare, whom the terrorists had claimed to be holding hostage.&equo; 
 Tug's throat made a strange, clicking noise and the Woman's shadowy hand clutched at his. 
 The voice of the news-reader flowed smoothly on. 
 &bquo;The terrorist group included a youth of about fifteen with bleached hair and it is thought that glimpses of this boy were used skilfully to support the terrorists' claims. 
 No further information is available at present, but it is understood that police are interviewing the five people arrested.&equo; 
 &bquo;Poor devils!&equo; 
 said the Woman. 
 She clicked the radio off and sat quite still on the bed while Tug wondered what to say. 
 &bquo;What does it mean?&equo; 
 he said stupidly. 
 She snorted softly and he could imagine her smiling in the darkness. 
 &bquo;It means that they're beginning to realize that Free People are not just a bunch of dumb bomb-chuckers.&equo; 
 &bquo;But what about me?&equo; 
 She squeezed his hand again. 
 &bquo;You're all right. 
 You're safe on holiday with your family. 
 Harriet Shakespeare can't &mdash; &bquo; 
 She stopped. 
 Tug shook at her hand. 
 &bquo;What? 
 What were you going to say?&equo; 
 But she would not go on. 
 Pushing him back down into bed, she stood up, looming over him like the shadows of a nightmare. 
 &bquo;Listen, forget about Harriet Shakespeare. 
 She's a hundred  and sixty miles away, in a different box. 
 All we  have to do is wait until this day is over.&equo; 
 Today. 
 Tuesday. 
 &bquo;Aren't you going to tell me &mdash;?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 Shut up now, or you'll wake Doyle.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you can't just &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo; Shut up .&equo; 
 There was something in her voice that reminded Tug that she was the one who had beaten him round the face. 
 He rolled over, thinking resentfully that it was impossible to go to sleep. 
 His head was jammed with questions &mdash; about Free People, about the siege, about Harriet Shakespeare. 
 About today. 
 How could he just &mdash; 
 The questions linked, separated, twisted themselves into fantastic jumbles and finally slid over into his sleeping mind, so that he dreamed, terrifyingly, that he was opening a never-ending stream of boxes. 
 Some of them were beautiful, delicately lacquered or intricately carved, and some were rough old cardboard, stamped with code numbers. 
 But inside each one was another and another and another&hellip;. 
 The dream grew faster and faster and more and more desperate, because he knew that he had to reach the last box before the end of the day. 
 But he was hindered by two things. 
 One was Hank, who stood at his side, pulling his sleeve to make him stop. 
 The other was the knowledge, inexplicable and certain, like all knowledge in dreams, that he would find something deadly inside the last box. 
 When he woke, sweating and exhausted, with his heart thudding as though he had been running, it was properly morning. 
 The cloth over the skylight had been pulled aside, so that the room was bright. 
 Blinking in the sunshine that fell on his face, Tug swam up out of the horrors of the darkness. 
 All the happenings of the night had mixed together so that he no longer knew whether he had really been woken and heard the Woman's hushed, hissing voice and the faint News from the radio. 
 They seemed part of his dream, as unreal as the terrifying boxes. 
 Was it really true that the house in Shelley Grove had been stormed? 
 That Liam Shakespeare was  missing? 
 Perhaps he might be Liam Shakespeare after all. 
 But &mdash; 
 But he could be Lord Lucan. 
 Or the crew of the Marie Celeste . 
 Or anyone else who had disappeared mysteriously. 
 What he really felt was that Liam Shakespeare had been vaporized. 
 Obliterated. 
 That he &mdash; Tug &mdash; was left bare and unprotected, with nothing to prove who he was. 
 Except the little bundle of Papers folded together under his pillow. 
 6.45 a.m. 
 Jinny's head ached and her eyes were heavy and sore as though someone had punched them. 
 I didn't sleep a wink . 
 She had heard people say it often enough &mdash; she had even said it herself &mdash; but she had not realized what it would really be like. 
 To lie hour after hour in the same hot, crumpled bed, looking at the same crack of sky between the curtains. 
 Watching the stars dim as it turned first grey and then pink. 
 Hearing all the time, over and over again, the words of that disastrous, shaming telephone conversation. 
 I suppose you must get a thrill out of it&hellip; stop imagining things about me . 
 She buried her head in Florence's flank and groaned. 
 The old cow turned and licked her with a huge, wet tongue until her blouse was damp all over the right shoulder, but it was not comforting. 
 It did not stop her knowing that she had made an idiot of herself and upset Harriet Shakespeare, who had enough trouble without that. 
 Or that there was no way left of convincing anyone that she was right about that boy. 
 It did not occur to her for a moment that she might not  be right. 
 Ever since the first time she had seen the Hare-woman standing in the Post Office, staring with her luminous eyes as she told one lie after another, she had known that there was  something wrong about her. 
 Beautiful, but wrong. 
 And ever since she had realized who the Doyle boy reminded her of, she had thought she knew what kind of thing was wrong. 
 But she had bungled every single attempt to help. 
 Groaning again, she closed her eyes as her fingers squeezed and relaxed, and wondered why Florence was so hard to milk this morning. 
 And Florence lowed reproachfully and flicked her tail, restless because her milker was tense. 
 Stopping at last to move the full bucket and reach for another, Jinny heard a car come bumping up the track towards the farm. 
 Normally she would have wandered out to see who it was. 
 Cars were rare on their track, especially at seven o'clock in the morning. 
 And anyone who came calling at that time today must have more time than sense, because today was Tuesday. 
 And all the village knew that the Slatterys were harvesting this Tuesday. 
 The place would be in a rush and a turmoil until they were all out in the field and Joe was sure enough of the neighbours who had come to help. 
 But Jinny simply did not have the energy to investigate the car. 
 If she stopped milking, she would never start again. 
 So she kept her eyes closed, humming a little tune to try and make Florence let her milk down faster and barely listening to the sound of voices out in the yard. 
 &bquo;Still milking?&equo; 
 That was Joe. 
 He appeared suddenly in the door of the milking house looking long and sallow and disapproving. 
 &bquo;It's not my fault. 
 I started on time but I can't &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Oh, never mind.&equo; 
 His fingers flicked, brushing her excuses away. 
 &bquo;You've got a visitor.&equo; 
 So that was why he was so bad-tempered. 
 Jinny supposed it was Keith and she looked round, ready to make sure he knew how stupid he was to come now. 
 Only it was not Keith. 
 It was a woman in sun-glasses, the collar of her short, smart coat turned up against the morning mist. 
 She nodded dismissively at Joe, who glared and stamped back to the pigs, and then she came into the milking  house and leaned against the far wall, looking across at Jinny. 
 And still Jinny did not guess right. 
 She thought it must be some busybody inspector-of-something-or-other. 
 Giving her a polite, mechanical smile she went on milking, waiting for an explanation. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry I was foul to you last night,&equo; the woman said. 
 Jinny was so startled that she nearly kicked the bucket over. 
 There was no mistaking that deep, clear voice. 
 &bquo;You're &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;No, don't stop milking.&equo; 
 Harriet Shakespeare waved an impatient hand. 
 &bquo;I expect you've got to finish it before you can do anything else.&equo; 
 She took off her glasses and turned down the collar. 
 Her pudgy face was very pale and her eyes looked as bad as Jinny's felt. 
 She knew it, too. 
 As she ran a hand over her short hair, she pulled a face. 
 &bquo;I must look like death. 
 But I've been up all night. 
 You can imagine. 
 I was on to the exchange for your name and number as soon as the news came through, but it took me an hour and a half to bully someone into looking up where the phone-box was. 
 And ever since then, more or less, I've been driving. 
 I had to knock up the girl in the Post Office to find out where you lived and &mdash; here I am. 
 I feel like a warmed Up corpse, but I wanted to get to you before the police thought of it. 
 Or before you went to them again.&equo; 
 She tapped the arm of her glasses against her teeth and watched Jinny with sharp, pale blue eyes. 
 In an odd way she seemed too solid, too highly coloured. 
 More real than other people because her face was so familiar, although she was a stranger. 
 And totally incomprehensible. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry,&equo; Jinny said, &bquo;but I don't understand. 
 Have you changed your mind since last night?&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't know!&equo; 
 Eyebrows rose above the blue eyes and the pale, squashed face frowned, with impatience very close below the surface. 
 &bquo;You haven't heard any News ?&equo; 
 Jinny stood up and lifted one of the buckets. 
 Immediately,  out to the trough, talking all the time. 
 &bquo;Look &mdash; it's hard to explain clearly when you're shattered but yesterday I thought you were a ghoul. 
 Having me on. 
 Or a crank. 
 I knew  where Liam was. 
 Then, last night, I discovered I was wrong.&equo; 
 Copying Jinny's example, she hoisted the bucket into the trough. 
 Then she bent over and, with a flick of her hand splashed cold water and smoothed it over her face. 
 &bquo;That's better. 
 Dammit, if only I could keep awake .&equo; 
 She caught at Jinny's wrist. 
 &bquo;I came to find you because you were the only person who told  me that Liam wouldn't be in that house. 
 You're my only hope. 
 Where is he? 
 How do I get him out?&equo; 
 Her fingers tightened, bending the wrist back painfully, and at last Jinny understood. 
 She had spent so many hours last night thinking about a pathetic, grief-stricken Harriet Shakespeare that this small, tough woman had taken her by surprise, almost annoyed her. 
 But she was just as desperate, as grief-stricken as Jinny had imagined. 
 Not pathetic, but certainly panicking. 
 At least I can deal with that , thought Jinny. 
 The Imogen Slattery special. 
 Calming people down. 
 She took a deep breath and made herself speak slowly. 
 &bquo;Look, I can show you where he is if you like. 
 But there's no use in that. 
 You can't just knock on the door and ask for him. 
 We need to sit down and talk about what to do.&equo; 
 The fingers on her wrist squeezed harder. 
 &bquo;Don't you understand? 
 There's almost no time left. 
 We can't lounge about chatting.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I thought we had until Fridays,&equo; Jinny said, puzzled. 
 &bquo;The newspapers said the deadline was Friday.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh That !&equo; 
 Harriet Shakespeare brushed the idea away. 
 &bquo;That's a decoy. 
 The real deadline is today. 
 At two o'clock.&equo; 
 Aha , thought Jinny. 
 There's one up for you, Keith. 
 She has got a secret. 
 And then she almost panicked herself. 
 Seven  hours. 
 Only seven hours. 
 And suppose she was wrong, after all? 
 She swallowed. 
 &bquo;What &mdash; what's got to be done by two o'clock? 
 What's the ransom? 
 Not all that Community Home business by the Government?&equo; 
 &bquo;That? 
 No. 
 That is &mdash;&equo; Harriet Shakespeare wavered. 
 Stopped and shook her head as though to clear it. 
 The action seemed to calm her slightly, and when she spoke again her voice had dropped half a tone. 
 &bquo;Look, I haven't got to do anything by two o'clock except get Liam out. 
 So please  let's find somewhere we can sit down and make a plan.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'll just turn the cow out,&equo; Jinny muttered. 
 She wanted a few moments to think. 
 Wrenching her wrist free, she walked back to the milking house with her mind a complete blank. 
 And then, miraculously, through the gap in the outbuildings, she saw a familiar, reassuring figure galloping up the track, with his clothes all huddled on anyhow and his hair unbrushed. 
 Jinny waved frantically. 
 &bquo;Keith!&equo; 
 He burst into the yard, tripped over a duck and nearly fell over. 
 &bquo;Jinny! 
 Rachel's got the most peculiar story &mdash; &bquo; 
 Then he saw the figure standing by the water trough and his voice faded away, with an apologetic, lop-sided grin. 
 &bquo;Oh,&equo; he said softly. 
 &bquo;So Rachel was right. 
 I thought she was teasing me.&equo; 
 Jinny turned back to Harriet Shakespeare. 
 &bquo;This is my friend Keith Hollins. 
 The brother of the girl you spoke to at the Post Office.&equo; 
 With Keith behind her, she felt much more confident and determined and she held out a hand to each of them. 
 &bquo;We'll go indoors. 
 There's always breakfast and Planning here at this time. 
 Looks like all of us could do with a bit of both.&equo; 
 She led them towards the kitchen, certain that Bella would make them welcome and throw another three or four collops of bacon into the pan. 
 Incredibly, it was not until she pushed open the kitchen  door that she remembered just what day it was and what they were all supposed to be doing. 
 7.15 a.m. 
 Very carefully, without looking right or left, Tug punctured the top of his egg with his fork. 
 Then he speared a square of fried bread and dipped it in, turning it about until it was yellow all over. 
 Very carefully, concentrating on what he was doing. 
 Now, he asked himself as he chewed the bread, do I always do it like that?  
 He fixed his mind deliberately on the question, not letting it wander. 
 Yes, he probably did. 
 He liked to eat methodically and tidily, not picking and leaving bits on his plate. 
 Eating was part of the serious business of training your body and keeping it fit. 
 Still, he could not be quite  sure that he always did that with his bread. 
 Not sure enough to write it on his precious list. 
 Still staring down, he began to cut another square of bread. 
 Neatly. 
 Forcing himself not to think about anything else. 
 It was not really any use. 
 All the time, whatever he did, he was aware of Doyle and the Woman. 
 They sat one on either side of him, at the ends of the table, each with a cup of coffee and a half-eaten slice of toast. 
 Doyle was frowning down at yesterday's paper, pretending to do the crossword. 
 He liked to finish it each morning before he fetched the new day's papers. 
 But today he was only doodling in the margin, leaving the black and white diagram empty. 
 The Woman was gazing out of the window, picking at the hem of the tablecloth. 
 They were both jumpy and alert. 
 Their guns were on the table by their hands, out of Tug's reach, and from both of them came a feeling of expectant tension. 
 Ever since Tug opened his eyes and saw Doyle in front of the door, things had been different from the other mornings. 
  Doyle had barked at him. 
 Ordered him out of bed and impatiently interrupted his exercises to bring him downstairs for breakfast. 
 Normally they ate late and Tug was kept in the attic. 
 But today it was as though Doyle and the Woman needed to be together, even though they were not talking. 
 Today was not like any other day of his captivity, and Tug was afraid of it. 
 Which was why he dipped the second piece of fried bread carefully in the egg and turned it about, concentrating on making it yellow all over. 
 &bquo;If you don't stop playing with your food, I'll take it away,&equo; Doyle said quietly. 
 &bquo;If I have to watch you any longer I'll throw up all over the table.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sorry.&equo; 
 Tug thrust the bread into his mouth and began to eat faster. 
 But it seemed that he had sparked something off. 
 Doyle looked from him to the Woman and back again and his face twisted into an expression of complete scorn. 
 &bquo;What a way to spend a day! 
 Watching a kid fiddling around with fried bread. 
 What sort of life is that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Doyle &mdash;&equo; said the Woman. 
 &bquo;Shut up!&equo; 
 Doyle turned to Tug and his eyes narrowed. 
 &bquo;Are you really contented? 
 Just sitting there and pushing food into your face? 
 Suppose you knew that this was going to be the last day of your life. 
 What would you choose to be doing?&equo; 
 &bquo; Doyle !&equo; 
 The Woman glared at him and put her hand on Tug's arm. 
 &bquo;He doesn't mean what you think. 
 It's a question we all got &mdash; that always gets asked when &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Quiet.&equo; 
 Doyle did not raise his voice, but it silenced her. 
 He had not even looked towards her again. 
 He was watching Tug steadily, almost unblinking. 
 &bquo;Come on,&equo; he said softly. 
 &bquo;If you don't know what you'd choose to do on the last day of your life, you don't know what's really important to you. 
 What matters when parents stop pushing and other people's eyes stop looking and you're alone with yourself. 
 No one else to be afraid of. 
 No one else to please.&equo; 
 His voice was low, but he was breathing harder and his eyes gleamed as though he  held Tug in a trap. 
 &bquo;Only free people know the answer to that question.&equo; 
 Did he mean free people or Free People? 
 Tug blinked at him. 
 &bquo;Come on,&equo; crooned Doyle. 
 The Woman suddenly sat up straighter. 
 &bquo;We both did it once. 
 For a test. 
 We faced the barrel of a gun and chose the last thing we would do. 
 I  said I would drive into the country, lie in the long grass and watch the sun go down until it was quite dark. 
 But I was wrong. 
 It wasn't enough. 
 Not for the last day of my life. 
 It wasn't what I really wanted.&equo; 
 Doyle's eyes slid towards her contemptuously. 
 &bquo;Of course it wasn't. 
 Only a sentimental, middle-class idiot would have thought of it. 
 Sunset!&equo; 
 &bquo;What about you?&equo; 
 Tug said. 
 He did not really understand the conversation, but he knew that the Woman was being attacked. 
 Turning the attack back on Doyle was a way of defending her &mdash; and of putting off the moment when he had to answer the question himself. 
 &bquo;What would you  do?&equo; 
 Doyle's mouth curved upwards as though he were smiling, but with no humour. 
 &bquo;I said I would gather together everything connected with my father &mdash; every photograph, every piece of clothing, his books, his certificates, his stamp collection &mdash; everything. 
 I made a great bonfire of it and stood and watched it burn until every trace of him was wiped off the face of the earth.&equo; 
 &bquo;And?&equo; murmured the Woman. 
 &bquo;Was that  enough?&equo; 
 For a second the icy eyes were distant, remembering something pleasurable. 
 Then they snapped back to attention and Doyle shook his head. 
 &bquo;No. 
 It was very good, but it wasn't good enough.&equo; 
 &bquo;So you see,&equo; the Woman said to Tug, &bquo;it's not easy to know what you want. 
 Because to do that, you have to know who you are . 
 Who you really  are. 
 And how many people can be sure of things about themselves when they've been brought up to please other people? 
 Forced into jobs they don't like. 
 Trained to conform to the million tiny rules that each family makes for itself.&equo;  
 &bquo;You think you're Liam Shakespeare,&equo; Doyle said softly. 
 &bquo;We say you're Philip Doyle. 
 Without one name or the other, you're lost. 
 You don't know how to be a person without a family to prop you up. 
 And you can't answer my question, can you? 
 You don't know who you are!&equo; 
 They were both staring at him. 
 Fierce eyes. 
 Mad eyes , thought Tug. 
 Mad questions. 
 Why should I play their games? 
 and yet &mdash; he slid his hand into his pocket and fingered the folded sheets of paper, hastily bundled together. 
 &bquo;Yes I do know who I am.&equo; 
 His voice came out perfectly steady, not defiant, but certain. 
 It was obvious from the way the staring eyes blinked, both Pairs together, that they had not been expecting an answer. 
 Not any answer. 
 Tug brushed his thumb along the edge of the paper and thought of everything that was written on it. 
 The food he liked. 
 The things he could do. 
 His pulse rate and the number of his teeth and his daily exercise plan. 
 His secret fears and his even more secret hopes. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; said Doyle. 
 &bquo;If you're so sure, what would you  do on the last day of your life?&equo; 
 Tug gazed out of the window at the mist lying in the bottom of the dale and the indistinct grey ridges stretching away from the cottage. 
 What could he do that would sum up everything he knew about himself? 
 What would satisfy every Part of him &mdash; body and mind and will? 
 What would use all his feelings and skills and understanding? 
 For a whole minute he stared out of the window and wondered. 
 And then he knew the answer. 
 It came into his head, clear and beautiful and complete. 
 Standing up, he gazed through the window at the massive gritstone ridge which stood against the sky on the other side of the main dale. 
 It ran, high and level and almost straight, from the north, where its Precipitous crags dropped sheer from the edge, black against the pale, early morning light, to the south, where a jagged lump stood up, breaking its smooth run. 
 &bquo;What's that?&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;That long hill?&equo; 
 Doyle smiled, with sneering triumph, thinking he had given  up. 
 &bquo;That's Ashdale Great Edge. 
 The famous  local feature that families come miles to gawp at. 
 On their lovely family holidays. 
 And the lump at the far end is the Castle Rock.&equo; 
 Tug took a calm, deep breath. 
 &bquo;I can tell you what I'd do on the last day of my life,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'd run.&equo; 
 He could almost feel the hard unevenness of the ground under his feet as he spoke. 
 &bquo;I'd run the length of Ashdale Great Edge, from this end to the Castle Rock, as fast as I could.&equo; 
 &bquo;Another idyllic, bourgeois idea,&equo; Doyle said sarcastically. 
 Tug shook his head. 
 He was remembering the strength that came gloriously from nowhere when your body seemed to be finished. 
 The triumphant feeling that it was impossible to try any harder. 
 That was what he wanted. 
 Not people to applaud him. 
 Not a beautiful picture of himself running into the sunset. 
 Not even a world-beating time. 
 Just to run to the end of his endurance &mdash; and then to go on. 
 Once more. 
 That's what I'd do , he thought. 
 I know that's what I want, and no one can take that away from me. 
 Whoever I am. 
 &bquo;Finish your breakfast, Tug,&equo; the Woman said. 
 &bquo;It's getting cold.&equo; 
 As he sat down, he looked sideways at her. 
 He wanted her to understand that the running was not just a pretty fancy, that he had been serious. 
 Somehow, whatever she was to him, it was important for her to believe that. 
 But her face startled him. 
 She was staring at him, with her great golden eyes, and her expression was so sad and apprehensive that the sight of it shocked him into asking the question he had been trying to ignore. 
 The question that had lurked under the surface of the whole conversation. 
 &bquo;So &mdash; is this going to be the last day of my life?&equo; 
 It was Doyle who answered, thoughtfully, as though it had been any ordinary question. 
 &bquo;I think perhaps &mdash; not. 
 It will be the last day of someone's life, but not yours, I think.&equo;  
 7.35 a.m. 
 Joe Slattery flicked his long, straight hair back behind his ears and rubbed his chin. 
 &bquo;Oz,&equo; Bella said, &bquo;go and let the chickens out. 
 Then walk down to Far Field and wait. 
 If people start arriving, tell them Joe's on his way.&equo; 
 Oz stuck out his bottom lip. 
 &bquo;I want to stay and &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Oz,&equo; Joe interrupted, &bquo;this is the only day in the year when I need to ask for help from my neighbours. 
 I will  have them treated politely.&equo; 
 His voice was low, but Oz slid off his chair immediately and made for the door. 
 &bquo;And Oz &mdash; not a word, eh?&equo; 
 Glancing over his shoulder with a huge wink, Oz banged the door after him and went whooping across the yard. 
 Joe looked down at the table. 
 &bquo;Let me get this straight, Mrs Shakespeare,&equo; he said slowly. 
 &bquo;This boy &mdash; who you think  is your son &mdash; is staying up in Back Clough Dale with a couple who may &mdash; or may not &mdash; be armed terrorists. 
 You don't want to go to the police, because you're afraid they'll simply get involved in another siege &mdash; if  you can make them believe you in time, which seems doubtful. 
 So you want me to help you to produce a plan to solve the whole thing in the next five or six hours. 
 On harvest day.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Harriet Shakespeare. 
 She had not eaten or drunk anything since she walked in. 
 She had not even spoken much, leaving the explanations to Keith and Jinny. 
 She had just sat still, next to Bella, and stared at Joe, with fierce, desperate eyes. 
 Joe tapped his fingertips together and looked from face to face. 
 &bquo;Do they ever go out, these Doyle people?&equo; he said abruptly. 
 &bquo;I've not seen them out all together.&equo; 
 It was Keith who answered, stumbling over the words because he was so eager to help. 
 &bquo;One of the &mdash; the adults turns up at the shop every day, I think. 
 Mam said they'd ordered two  daily  papers, and they must come down to collect those.&equo; 
 Joe gazed at the ceiling and tapped his fingers for a little longer. 
 Then he sat up straight. 
 &bquo;The plan's simple,&equo; he said briskly. 
 &bquo;You'll never get that boy out of the house. 
 Not if everyone in the village joins in an attack. 
 It's too easy for the others to put a gun to his head.&equo; 
 In Back Clough Dale ? thought Jinny. 
 Then she imagined the Hare-woman with a gun in her hand &mdash; and changed her mind. 
 The picture was easy to make. 
 Too easy. 
 &bquo;So,&equo; Joe continued, &bquo;we've got to lure the others out and lock the boy in . 
 That will give us a breathing space to sort things out. 
 And if it's all a mistake, there'll be no harm done and no shooting. 
 Cottage door's got a bolt, hasn't it, Keith?&equo; 
 Keith hesitated and the rest of them watched him anxiously, holding their breath. 
 &bquo;Ye&mdash;es,&equo; he said. 
 Then &bquo;Oh yes. 
 Now I remember. 
 There's two. 
 Top and bottom.&equo; 
 &bquo;Right,&equo; said Joe. 
 &bquo;This is how it would work. 
 A couple of you get down there as fast as you can and watch the cottage. 
 As soon as one of the adults goes for the paper, we'll send in a Trojan Horse. 
 Have to be Jinny, I think. 
 She's the only one who's small enough not to worry anyone.&equo; 
 Bella opened her mouth to disagree, glanced at Harriet Shakespeare and shut it again. 
 &bquo;Jinny gets inside the cottage with some excuse or other,&equo; Joe waved his hand, not bothering about details. 
 &bquo;Meanwhile, the other watcher races down to Far Field and tells me. 
 I'll come up with two or three of the other men and knock on the door. 
 We should have fifteen or twenty minutes clear before the other Doyle gets back. 
 As soon as the door's opened, we grab the person who opens it and haul him outside. 
 Or her. 
 Only got to do it for a second. 
 Just long enough for Jinny to bolt the door. 
 Then we ask our questions.&equo; 
 &bquo;Suppose I can't get in?&equo; 
 Jinny said. 
 &bquo;Still no harm done.&equo; 
 Joe shrugged. 
 &bquo;They're not going to shoot you just for trying. 
 We'll have to make other plans, that's all.&equo;  
 &bquo;Who goes with Jinny? 
 To watch?&equo; said Keith. 
 Joe nodded. 
 &bquo;You, of course. 
 Mrs Shakespeare can go too, if she likes, but she must not be seen . 
 This plan's only going to be successful if they don't suspect anything, and if they see her around they'll suspect lots. 
 Got any more questions?&equo; 
 Nobody spoke for a second. 
 Then Harriet Shakespeare said briskly, It's a good plan. 
 The best we're going to get. 
 Keith, Jinny &mdash; are you coming?&equo; 
 She had begun to push back her chair when Joe spoke suddenly. 
 &bquo;Wait. 
 I  have a question.&equo; 
 He was very pale. 
 As everyone turned to look at him, Jinny realized that he had been waiting for this moment all the time he was explaining his plan. 
 She had been surprised when he seemed to join in so easily. 
 She knew how much he hated relying on other people or being involved in their affairs. 
 Now she saw that he had just been dealing with the easy, practical part first. 
 Before he got to the real problem. 
 Harriet Shakespeare caught the idea as well. 
 She went as pale as he was and clenched her fists. 
 &bquo;What question?&equo; 
 &bquo;The most basic question of all,&equo; murmured Joe. 
 &bquo;Why? 
 We're racing round and cobbling up a makeshift plan. 
 On the most inconvenient day of the whole year for me. 
 You want me to disrupt my harvest and put my daughter in danger &mdash; and yet, according to Keith, the terrorists in your house were saying that their deadline was Friday. 
 It's only Tuesday today. 
 Why the desperate hurry?&equo; 
 &bquo;I told  you,&equo; Harriet Shakespeare said. 
 &bquo;The real deadline is  today. 
 At two o'clock.&equo; 
 Joe shook his head. 
 &bquo;That's nonsense. 
 People don't bring deadlines closer . 
 Not unless they're sure of getting what they have demanded.&equo; 
 &bquo;Or unless those demands are a blind,&equo; said Keith. 
 He had sat almost silently up till then, but his face was intent. 
 &bquo;Free People like to play mind games, don't they? 
 What if they're using the public  demands and the public   deadline to distract attention from &mdash; something else?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh what a genius you are,&equo; Harriet Shakespeare said wearily. 
 &bquo;Yes, of course you're right. 
 The siege has given them publicity for their ideas, of course, but what they really  want, to save Liam's life, is something quite different. 
 Only I know what that is &mdash; and that's all I can say.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's not good enough.&equo; 
 Joe was relentless. 
 &bquo;I have  to know what you're being asked for. 
 Why should I put myself to a lot of trouble and difficulty when &mdash; perhaps &mdash; you could just give the terrorists what they ask and save all the bother?&equo; 
 &bquo;But if I tell you,&equo; Harriet Shakespeare said, as though she were talking to an idiot, &bquo;I'm putting Liam's life in worse danger. 
 Just by telling you.&equo; 
 Joe did not even hesitate. 
 &bquo;You're asking me to put my daughter  in danger. 
 My first duty is to my family.&equo; 
 Suddenly, startlingly, Harriet Shakespeare's mouth twisted. 
 She gave a loud, bitter shout of laughter that made them all stare. 
 Then she sat, very straight-backed, and looked hard at Joe. 
 &bquo;Listen, then. 
 Understand what Free People have been doing to me. 
 They're not like any other group I've ever investigated. 
 They're clever and devious and dramatic. 
 Oh, they're as violent as any other terrorists, and they like to shock. 
 But they like to puzzle and tease and make people think , as well. 
 Playing mind games, like Keith said.&equo; 
 &bquo;A siege that's not a siege in London,&equo; murmured Keith. 
 &bquo;A family that's not a family in Derbyshire. 
 A fake siege hiding a kidnapping and fake demands that camouflage something else.&equo; 
 Harriet Shakespeare nodded. 
 &bquo;You're getting the idea. 
 But you haven't seen how all this ties in with their long-term aims. 
 You haven't seen the moral. 
 They want to turn people against the family as a system. 
 Because &mdash; oh, I guess you know most of the reasons already.&equo; 
 She had been talking very fast, as though it made her impatient to explain. 
 But suddenly her voice slowed and she looked down at her  hands. 
 &bquo;If you were Free People and you wanted to strike a shocking, symbolic blow at the family &mdash; something that everyone in the country would feel &mdash; which family would you bomb?&equo; 
 Bella got it first. 
 She gasped. 
 &bquo;But that's impossible . 
 What about security?&equo; 
 &bquo;It only takes one fanatic,&equo; Harriet Shakespeare said heavily. 
 &bquo;A fanatic with a bomb in the right crowd at the right time. 
 At two o'clock this afternoon.&equo; 
 &bquo;He'd need  to be a fanatic,&equo; Keith said grimly. 
 &bquo;It could be the end of his  life as well.&equo; 
 &bquo;But that's another of their little games,&equo; said Harriet Shakespeare. 
 Her voice was stretched very tight, as though it might snap at any moment and tumble her into tears. 
 &bquo;To get into the group at all, you have to say what you'd do if you knew you were going to die tomorrow. 
 And then they make you do it &mdash; with a gun pointed at the back of your neck. 
 You don't find out that the gun's not loaded until after  you've heard the trigger click. 
 They're used to the idea of dying, you see.&equo; 
 &bquo;You know a lot about them.&equo; 
 Jinny ran a finger along the edge of the table. 
 &bquo;You must have spent ages investigating.&equo; 
 She could see the whole thing now, crystal-clear. 
 &bquo;And when you found out about this new plan of theirs, they kidnapped Liam to stop you telling.&equo; 
 &bquo; Oh !&equo; 
 Impulsively, Bella put a warm, soft arm round Harriet Shakespeare's shoulders, but the shoulders did not droop. 
 They stayed rigid and determined, like their owner's voice. 
 &bquo;It's a very pretty problem, isn't it?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;If I tell &mdash; they will kill Liam and point out that he's had to suffer for my stubborn principles. 
 And that's what being in a family does for you. 
 If I don't  tell,&equo; she gripped the edge of the table, &bquo;there will be several deaths this afternoon, less important to me, but much more sensational. 
 And Free People will be able to announce that being in a family is corrupting. 
 That my love for my son has interfered with my passion for truth and  justice. 
 The passion that I have foolishly boasted so much about. 
 Very neat. 
 Either way, Free People get their moral. 
 And lots of free publicity.&equo; 
 She put her head in her hands and sat very still. 
 It was Keith who spoke first, looking red-faced and embarrassed. 
 &bquo;I don't want to sound awkward, but &mdash; you said Free People were devious. 
 Don't you think it might be a hoax? 
 No bomb, no fanatic. 
 Just a trick to find out what you would do? 
 That way they still get their moral.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't you think I've been trying to believe that?&equo; 
 Harriet Shakespeare said thickly. 
 &bquo;That would let me nicely off the hook. 
 And it's the sort of thing they could do. 
 Just like their initiation ceremony. 
 But &mdash; they have  got bombs. 
 We know that. 
 And &mdash; have I got the right to take the risk?&equo; 
 She looked up and her face was only just under control, balanced on the edge of screaming. 
 It's always the people you love who trap you like that . 
 Jinny remembered Bella's words and understood them properly for the first time. 
 How could Harriet Shakespeare choose what to do &mdash; how could she face making the choice &mdash; when her own son was involved? 
 Joe stood up and came down the table towards Harriet Shakespeare. 
 &bquo;It's all right,&equo; he said, looking down at her bent back. 
 &bquo;I understand now. 
 There's nothing you can do except stand up for your own and try and get Liam out before two o'clock. 
 We'll just have to pray it's him in there.&equo; 
 At last she raised her head. 
 &bquo;You'll help, then?&equo; 
 Joe did not answer directly. 
 Instead, he looked across the table. 
 &bquo;I haven't got the most dangerous part. 
 What about you, Jinny? 
 Will you do it?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, of course .&equo; 
 She jumped up. 
 It would be such a relief to be doing something practical, after all this talk. 
 &bquo;Let's get up there quickly and start watching. 
 I'm sure  we can do it. 
 Are you coming, Mrs Shakespeare?&equo; 
 Harriet Shakespeare stood up. 
 &bquo;Yes. 
 I know I can't help, but just to be there  will make me feel I'm fighting to get Liam back. 
 Better than dripping around here.&equo; 
 They were half-way to the door before Jinny realized that  the third person was missing. 
 She turned and saw him still sitting at the table. 
 &bquo;Keith?&equo; 
 His face was heavy and miserable. 
 &bquo;Look &mdash; I don't want to blight the whole thing before we start, but &mdash; suppose we fail? 
 Suppose it's not  Liam in there? 
 We've got  to do something about the bomb before we start. 
 Tell Dad or something, so the police know. 
 I don't think &mdash;&equo; he looked even more distressed &bquo; &mdash; that it's fair to gamble with people's lives.&equo; 
 &bquo;What about Liam's life &mdash;?&equo; 
 began Jinny. 
 But Harriet Shakespeare put a finger on her wrist to stop her. 
 Then she looked at Keith, every muscle in her face drawn tight. 
 &bquo;Do you think I haven't been over every inch  of that argument a million times? 
 And you're right. 
 Of course. 
 I had to change my mind.&equo; 
 She gulped for breath, as though she could hardly bear what she was saying. 
 &bquo;Yesterday I phoned the police and now, if we don't get Liam out by two o'clock, he'll die for certain.&equo; 
 11.00 a.m. 
 The Woman shut the door and turned the key in the lock. 
 From outside came the noise of Doyle starting the car. 
 All morning he had been in a strange, erratic mood and as the car began to bump its way off down the track Tug felt a great lightening of his spirits. 
 &bquo;Whee!&equo; he said softly. 
 The Woman turned and, for a second, he saw a reflection of the same feeling on her face. 
 They grinned at each other like conspirators. 
 &bquo;Ma &mdash; &bquo; 
 Her smile vanished. 
 &bquo;Come on. 
 He'll be back soon. 
 How about getting the breakfast cleared up?&equo; 
 Tug started to stack the dirty plates. 
 &bquo;I was better off when  I was eating upstairs, wasn't I? 
 Waited on hand and foot up there. 
 Down here I'm a slave.&equo; 
 He leaned across the table to reach the last cup and suddenly froze. 
 There, lying on the Woman's chair, where she had left it, was her gun. 
 The long Kalashnikov. 
 Within his grasp. 
 For a moment his fingers trembled, hovering over it, and then he gripped it firmly with both hands. 
 When he looked up, the Woman was watching him. 
 &bquo;Well?&equo; 
 she said quietly. 
 &bquo;Doyle was right. 
 I am  careless with that gun. 
 You can shoot me now, can't you? 
 And then escape.&equo; 
 Tug made the pictures in his head. 
 Aiming. 
 No need to be particularly careful at such short range. 
 A jerk of the finger on the trigger. 
 He had a feeling there would be something complicated about a safety catch, but he might be able to work it out. 
 A burst of gun-fire and then &mdash; what? 
 He would have to heave her blood-stained body away from the door and then scramble over it before he could race out and lose himself in the hills. 
 Somehow the pictures were not quite real enough. 
 They were story-book pictures. 
 Holding the gun very still and steady, pointed at her, he said, &bquo;Could you  shoot me ? 
 Really, I mean?&equo; 
 She did not answer at once, but she went very pale. 
 As she hesitated, Tug found that he desperately wanted to know what she would say. 
 He stared hard at her face as, at last, her lips began to move. 
 &bquo;I &mdash; &bquo; 
 Then came the knock on the door. 
 Both of them stopped, stiffening, and the Woman glanced sharply at Tug. 
 &bquo;Don't mind me.&equo; 
 Gently he put the gun down on the table and carried the pile of plates over to the sink. 
 &bquo;I'm just the kitchen-maid round here.&equo; 
 But his blood seemed to be flowing at twice the normal Speed and he stood carefully, so that he could see the doorway. 
 The Woman slipped Doyle's gun into her bag and slid the  Kalashnikov under a cushion. 
 Then she turned the key, slowly and quietly, and opened the door. 
 &bquo;Hallo,&equo; said a familiar voice, a little fast and breathless. 
 &bquo;My Dad sent me up here. 
 He said we owed you a favour, because of all that fuss and bother about the dog that was chasing sheep. 
 He doesn't like to owe things.&equo; 
 It was the girl who had come with the policeman. 
 She looked very small and slight standing there with her skinny plait and her pale, freckled face. 
 Disappointed, Tug turned back to the sink, listening vaguely to what she said as he began to wash up. 
 &bquo;I'm sorry  about the dog thing. 
 We'd like to ask you all down to the Harvest, to make up. 
 Oh &mdash; that must sound funny to you. 
 As if we're asking you to do our work. 
 It's not like that. 
 There's so many folk it's more like a party. 
 With lots of beer and home-made bread and cheese and ham and some of my mother's special cakes and &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;What a pity,&equo; interrupted the Woman. 
 &bquo;You've just missed my husband. 
 How funny you didn't see him.&equo; 
 Tug heard the suspicion in her voice, but it did not seem to worry the girl. 
 &bquo;I must confess,&equo; she said cheerily. 
 &bquo;I waited till he was gone. 
 He scares me stupid.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, we'll have to consult him,&equo; said the Woman. 
 But she sounded amused now. 
 Amused and relaxed. 
 &bquo;Oh, do come!&equo; 
 Suddenly, the girl darted past her, into the kitchen, and ran across to the sink, catching at Tug's sleeve. 
 &bquo;Philip, do persuade her. 
 It's real fun. 
 Special !&equo; 
 Tug was so surprised that he dropped the cloth he was holding. 
 She had grabbed his arm, hard enough to bruise it, and she was staring wildly at him, as though she meant something quite different. 
 But before he could answer her, there was a noise outside. 
 A car was coming up the track at high speed, creaking and groaning as it went over the bumps. 
 The Woman looked out. 
 &bquo;Doyle's back,&equo; she said, sounding puzzled. 
 Tug had just one glimpse of the girl's horror as her mouth and her eyes opened wide. 
 The next moment she had her face  under control, turning towards the door with a polite smile. 
 The car-door slammed. 
 Feet raced across the yard, scattering gravel, and Doyle burst through the door. 
 He was breathless and moving at high speed, but there was nothing agitated or uncontrolled about him. 
 He had begun to give orders before he was properly inside. 
 &bquo;Come on!&equo; he yelled at the Woman. 
 &bquo;And bring the boy. 
 We've got to get out of here. 
 Harriet Shakespeare's around!&equo; 
 &bquo; What ?&equo; said the Woman. 
 Tug caught his breath and his head spun. 
 Hank! 
 But was it Hank? 
 But there was no time to think about that. 
 Doyle had seen the girl. 
 &bquo;Bring her too!&equo; 
 he snapped. 
 &bquo;And the guns. 
 And the radio .&equo; 
 Then they were being hustled towards the car. 
 It had only two doors and by the time they had been pushed roughly into the back, with the Woman leaning round in the front seat to point the small gun at them, they hardly dared to breathe. 
 The Woman was pale. 
 Her eyes seemed to have grown even larger and they stared grimly at Tug and the girl, barely blinking as she watched every movement. 
 It seemed incredible to Tug that only five minutes before he had been calling her Ma and they had been grinning at each other. 
 &bquo;So &mdash; how did you find out?&equo; she said to Doyle, without turning her head. 
 &bquo;Did you see her?&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 I picked up that silly, mincing girl from the Post Office. 
 She was walking that way, and I could hardly ignore her. 
 Natural chatterer. 
 All the gossip.&equo; 
 He imitated a shrill, foolish voice and Tug could tell that it was a good imitation because the girl next to him looked up sharply. 
 &bquo;You'll never guess  who knocked on our door this morning. 
 At half past six ! 
 It gave me a real shock  to see her. 
 It was Harriet Shakespeare !&equo; 
 It  must mean something that she was here , thought Tug. 
 But he had stopped trusting his thoughts. 
 The Woman smiled dryly. 
 &bquo;So you pushed her out of the car and gave the whole game away?&equo; 
 &bquo;Think I'm a fool?&equo; 
 Doyle said scornfully. 
 &bquo;I said I'd  forgotten my wallet. 
 Dropped her off and came screeching back here.&equo; 
 He was driving even faster now. 
 Tug looked into the barrel of the gun and prayed. 
 Gradually everything else faded out of his mind. 
 All he could think of was the small, dark, murderous hole. 
 Please don't let it go off by accident. 
 Please don't let her finger jerk by mistake. 
 He was more frightened than he had been in all the time he had been with them, and he could tell that the girl was frightened too, by her quick, shallow breathing. 
 &bquo;So you came crashing in,&equo; the Woman said, still sounding unimpressed. 
 &bquo;Saddled us with another kid and raced off without any plan.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't you understand?&equo; 
 Doyle shouted. 
 &bquo;That place was a trap once they knew we were there. 
 No proper view round and only one exit. 
 We need somewhere safe to sit out the last two or three hours.&equo; 
 &bquo;So you have  got a plan?&equo; 
 &bquo;Of course I've got a plan, and you'll see what it is in a few moments, if you're too stupid to guess before that &mdash;&equo; They swung round a bend and he swore suddenly and loudly. 
 Tug had a sharp, split-second picture of people walking on the track. 
 Three or four men. 
 He had never seen any of them before, but the girl knocked on the window and shouted to them. 
 &bquo;Shut up!&equo; 
 With a single, sharp blow, the Woman knocked her sideways, into Tug's lap. 
 Doyle put his foot down and drove straight at the men. 
 There was a terrifying moment of confusion when faces loomed round the windows, voices bellowed and hands banged and battered at the roof of the car. 
 But the men gave way, because they had no choice, and the next minute the car had bounced out on to the road, turning left, away from the village and up towards the dale head. 
 &bquo; Oh !&equo; said the Woman suddenly. 
 She's guessed where we're going , thought Tug. 
 But he could not guess himself. 
 His mind seemed to have gone into a  paralysing panic. 
 All he could take in was the muzzle of the gun the silent terror of the girl next to him and the Woman's stony face. 
 The car climbed the steep, twisting road at brake-squealing speed, until it reached the crest, where the fields stopped and the open moor began. 
 Doyle swerved, running the car on to the right hand verge, and braked hard. 
 Then he snatched the gun from the Woman's hand, opened the car door and slid out, tilting his seat forward. 
 &bquo;Out, you two!&equo; 
 Tug and the girl slithered out and Doyle jerked the gun towards the narrow squeeze-stile in the drystone wall beside them. 
 &bquo;Get going.&equo; 
 Edging between the two tall, upright stones, Tug heard him mutter at the Woman, &bquo;Lock up the car and bring the Kalashnikov. 
 And the radio .&equo; 
 Then, louder, &bquo;Go on, you kids. 
 Get walking. 
 And don't forget there's a gun behind you. 
 &bquo;But &mdash; we can't get anywhere this way,&equo; the girl said. 
 &bquo;Shut up! 
 Walk!&equo; 
 They stepped out across the moorland and the wind caught them, strong and cold, once they were out of the shelter of the wall. 
 Tug looked sideways, towards the valley on the right, and recognized where they were. 
 They were walking on to the long ridge they had been able to see from the cottage window. 
 Ashdale Great Edge. 
 And he had the strange feeling that he was moving in a dream. 
 Past and future were wiped out, and there was nothing real except the wind on his face and the springy heather and the small, tough bushes under his feet. 
 Beside him, the girl walked at the same pace, just out of step with him. 
 Like a person who walks beside you in a dream, she did not speak except once. 
 Then, in a strange, high voice, she said, &bquo;The Edge is good for bilberries.&equo; 
 &bquo;Good for wind too,&equo; said Tug. 
 And his voice sounded high and strange as well. 
 They walked like robots until Doyle yelled, &bquo;Stop!&equo; with half his voice whirled away by the wind so that it came to them as  a little thread of sound. 
 They had just reached the path that ran the length of the Edge, the barren ridge stretching in front of them, flat and clear all the way to the Castle Rock. 
 On their left it sloped gently away and on the right it fell sheer, in steep crags. 
 They had an uninterrupted view of all the directions in which people might approach. 
 &bquo;What now?&equo; said the Woman. 
 &bquo;End of the world?&equo; 
 Doyle did not waste time smiling. 
 &bquo;We watch for visitors.&equo; 
 They did not have long to wait. 
 It was only a moment or two before a couple of cars came up the hill and screeched into the side of the road. 
 Tug watched the people get out. 
 The three or four men that Doyle had driven at, a tall, ungainly boy of about eighteen &mdash; and Hank. 
 But he was still in the remote coldness of his dream. 
 As he watched her squeeze through the stile and walk forward with the others, she seemed strange and unreal, like something he had imagined when he was a very little boy. 
 So much had happened since he last saw her. 
 Doyle let the little group of people walk on until it was only about two hundred metres away. 
 Then he caught hold of the girl, roughly, by her plait, and dragged her round in front of him. 
 With a deliberate, unmistakable gesture, he put the gun to her head. 
 &bquo;Stay there!&equo; he yelled, at the top of his voice. 
 The wind blew his words at the men and they stopped, glancing at each other. 
 Doyle did not let go of the girl's plait, but he jerked at it, to make her sit down. 
 &bquo;And now?&equo; said the Woman. 
 Doyle smiled, almost beautifully, as though everything had come right, and handed her the small gun. 
 &bquo;Keep guard. 
 I'm going to put on the radio.&equo; 
 He squatted down and propped it against a clump of little bushes, pulling up the aerial as far as it would go. 
 Then he fiddled with the controls until he had produced a clear sound that was audible even over the wind. 
 He glanced over his shoulder at the crowd of people. 
 They were still standing two hundred metres away, afraid to come any nearer, and he smiled. 
 &bquo;Sit down everyone,&equo; he said softly.  
 &bquo;There's plenty of time. 
 We're going to wait and listen to the News.&equo; 
 Of course , thought Tug. 
 Why not ? 
 In its frosty, stunned isolation, his mind found it quite natural to be out in the wind in this remote place, waiting for a disembodied voice. 
 He sat cross-legged on the ground and stared into the black grid on the front of the radio. 
 2.25 p.m. 
 The wind was blowing over the top of Jinny's head, fluttering the loose, short hairs round her forehead. 
 It's an important wind , she thought dully. 
 It'll probably be the last wind I shall ever feel. 
 I should be enjoying it. 
 But she could not make herself care. 
 When she knocked on the door of Back Clough Dale Cottage, she had been afraid but in control. 
 That was less than three and a half hours ago, but it might have been years. 
 It might have been a different person. 
 Ever since Doyle burst through the door, furious and shouting and shoving, she had stiffened into ice. 
 She did not feel  afraid, but when she looked down at her hands she saw that they were shaking. 
 Her moment of complete despair had come when Doyle switched on the radio and sat down to wait and see what happened. 
 We're waiting to hear the News . 
 And only Jinny knew that the news he wanted would never come. 
 Could not come. 
 She sat and stared along the Edge, down into the dale, not bothering to strain her ears and listen to the radio, because she knew it was pointless. 
 Not looking back the way they had come, because she could not bear to watch Joe. 
 She imagined him haggard and afraid, even though she was too far away to see his face clearly. 
 People had come and gone in the little crowd. 
 The blue uniforms of policemen had appeared and marksmen had fanned out, hunting for good positions to aim from. 
 But no one was any nearer. 
 Every time anyone made a threatening move, the Hare-woman hauled  Jinny to her feet and pointed the gun at her head until the person gave way and retreated. 
 And always she and Doyle made sure that their bodies were shielded by the other two. 
 The worst thing of all was that no one was talking. 
 Jinny had made one attempt to say something to the boy, but Doyle stopped her immediately, catching hold of her chin and jerking her head away. 
 Now they sat avoiding each other's eyes. 
 Jinny avoided the Hare-woman's eyes too. 
 It was almost unbearable to look into them. 
 All the time those steady, golden eyes had fascinated her &mdash; and now they were looking steadily at her along the barrel of a gun. 
 If she moved, the Hare-woman would kill her. 
 And the terrible, disturbing thing was that there was nothing different. 
 It was just this power and seriousness that had fascinated her in the first place. 
 &bquo;Listen!&equo; said Doyle suddenly. 
 His voice was quiet, but the effect, after their long silence, was as though he had shouted. 
 The other three swivelled round to look at him. 
 &bquo;Listen carefully to this News,&equo; he said, with no expression in his face. 
 &bquo;All of you, but especially Tug. 
 This is the one that really matters. 
 We're waiting to hear of deaths. 
 Of certain important deaths that were due to occur at two o'clock. 
 If the news comes, all your worries are over.&equo; 
 &bquo;And if not?&equo; the boy said, almost defiantly. 
 &bquo;If not,&equo; murmured Doyle, &bquo;you will know that Harriet Shakespeare has chosen to save those important lives &mdash; instead of saving her son's. 
 Presumably because he  is less important.&equo; 
 Not true , Jinny wanted to say, watching the boy's face go white. 
 It's not like that at all. 
 I've seen how much she loves you. 
 But she dared not say anything. 
 Instead, she crouched over the radio, listening, like all the others, as the news bulletin began. 
 Riots in a South American country.  
 Reports that the economy might improve in six months' time. 
 Cross-channel ferries held up by a bomb scare&hellip;. 
 It was too late already. 
 They all knew it. 
 Important deaths come in special news flashes, or as the first item, not at the end. 
 If the deaths had taken place, they would know it by now. 
 But Doyle listened right to the last word of the News. 
 Right up to the moment when the news-reader said, &bquo;And that's the end of the News. 
 The next News will be at &mdash; &bquo; 
 Then he switched off. 
 &bquo;Now,&equo; he said, &bquo;we talk.&equo; 
 &bquo;What is there to talk about?&equo; said the boy, still in that funny, cold, high-pitched voice. 
 &bquo;You're going to kill me, aren't you?&equo; 
 Jinny clenched her fists, digging the nails into the palms of her hands. 
 But no one looked at her. 
 Doyle and the Harewoman were both staring at the boy. 
 Doyle nodded. 
 &bquo;Oh, we're going to kill you all right. 
 Don't start kidding yourself that there's any way out of that. 
 But first &mdash; you've got a choice to make. 
 The last one you'll ever have, and the most significant.&equo; 
 He was speaking very slowly and clearly, as if he wanted to make sure that the boy understood. 
 Now he gestured backwards, towards the group by the wall. 
 &bquo;Harriet Shakespeare's over there. 
 I can't imagine what brought her, but I'm certain you've seen her.&equo; 
 &bquo; I  brought her,&equo; Jinny interrupted frantically. 
 &bquo;I telephoned her and said I was sure he &mdash; Philip &mdash; was Liam Shakespeare, and she came racing here from London.&equo; 
 She clutched at the boy's arm. 
 &bquo;Don't listen to them. 
 Of course  she loves you. 
 She's desperate.&equo; 
 Doyle smiled scornfully, as though she had somehow missed the point. 
 But it was still the boy he spoke to. 
 &bquo;Of course she loves Liam Shakespeare . 
 But she can't be sure you're Liam, can she Tug? 
 She's too far away to see you properly. 
 And until she's  sure, you can't be absolutely sure yourself. 
 Can you?&equo;  
 His voice had dropped lower and lower, until he was almost whispering, and he let the last question hang in the silence. 
 It sounded nonsense to Jinny, but she saw the boy's face go pale. 
 &bquo;This is what I'm going to do,&equo; crooned Doyle, in the same, soft voice. 
 &bquo;I'm going to signal to Harriet Shakespeare to walk across here. 
 Slowly, so that we can watch her face. 
 So that we can wait for the moment when she sees you well enough to be sure whether you are Liam or not. 
 The moment when her expression changes. 
 One way or the other.&equo; 
 &bquo;And then,&equo; said the boy, his eyes on Doyle's face, &bquo;then you'll shoot me. 
 Whoever I am.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, I  shan't shoot you,&equo; Doyle murmured lightly. 
 &bquo;Your mother will do that.&equo; 
 Jinny did not understand, but the boy's head turned and he stared at the Hare-woman. 
 &bquo;Ma? 
 You would really &mdash;?&equo; 
 Doyle laughed before he had even finished. 
 &bquo;You don't believe she would do it? 
 Don't know her very well, do you? 
 She hasn't got a very good record as a mother. 
 They took her last baby away from her twelve years ago. 
 It had five broken ribs and a cracked skull, and it was brain-damaged for life.&equo; 
 Jinny felt her breath stop as her eyes swivelled automatically to look at the Hare-woman. 
 She saw the long, strong face go deliberately stiff. 
 So that's what's chasing you , she thought. 
 But she could not speak. 
 Neither could the boy. 
 He went on staring at the Hare-woman. 
 &bquo;Not lucky with your mothers, are you, Tug?&equo; 
 Doyle said. 
 &bquo;Neither of them fits the picture of a proper  mother.&equo; 
 For a minute more, the boy went on gazing at the Harewoman. 
 At last he muttered stiffly, &bquo;You told me I had a choice.&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right,&equo; said Doyle. 
 &bquo;It's very simple. 
 You can do what I've described. 
 Wait for the look on Harriet Shakespeare's face to tell you who you are. 
 Wait meekly for her to put you in a box and label you &mdash; give you a face to shelter behind, whether it fits or not. 
 Or &mdash; &bquo;  
 &bquo;Or?&equo; 
 whispered the boy. 
 But Jinny could tell from his voice that he knew the answer already, and when Doyle replied it was with a nod. 
 &bquo;Exactly. 
 Or you can dare to be alone with yourself. 
 Dare to do the thing you chose as being the most important. 
 To find out whether it really is  important to you.&equo; 
 &bquo;What we're offering you,&equo; the Hare-woman said &mdash; and her voice was almost gentle &mdash; &bquo;is a choice between knowing who other people think  you are and knowing who you really are, inside yourself. 
 You can have one of those things before you die. 
 But not both.&equo; 
 Suddenly Jinny was furiously, recklessly angry. 
 The boy looked sick and white and terrified and the other two were staring at him almost without blinking, as though they were sucking out his life through his eyes. 
 &bquo;You're as bad as Harriet Shakespeare said you were!&equo; she yelled. 
 &bquo;You don't care about people at all. 
 You're just playing mind games!&equo; 
 But she did not break that concentrated stare. 
 &bquo;It's not a game,&equo; Doyle said calmly. 
 &bquo;Is it, Tug?&equo; 
 The boy shook his head. 
 Picking up the long gun, Doyle ran his finger along the barrel and then held it out to the Hare-woman. 
 She dropped the other gun &mdash; the little one &mdash; into the pocket of her jacket and reached for the wooden grip of the Kalashnikov. 
 &bquo;There you are,&equo; Doyle said. 
 &bquo;We're ready, Tug. 
 Don't go thinking you can outrun the bullets. 
 This gun's got a range of about three hundred metres and your mother's a very good shot. 
 So there's no way out. 
 Just the choice to make.&equo; 
 The wind suddenly seemed to have grown much colder, striking so fiercely against Jinny's cheek that it numbed it. 
 For a second there was no sound except the swish of that wind across the hillside. 
 &bquo;Well, Tug?&equo; 
 Doyle said. 
 Tug's first reaction was to look towards the Woman. 
 She had hit him and fed him, shouted at him for being idle and  comforted him when he woke in the night and was afraid. 
 If she was not his mother, she had still crammed a lot of mothering, good and bad, into the last few days. 
 Could she really be going to kill him now? 
 &bquo;Ma &mdash; &bquo; 
 But there was no point in continuing. 
 She stared at him with a stiff, expressionless face. 
 For a moment he was horribly, surprisingly hurt, as though she had disowned him. 
 Then he understood that she was not going to help him, because she wanted him to make the choice. 
 He glanced to his right, towards the distant mass of the Castle Rock. 
 If he ran in that direction, would he be able to dodge? 
 Briefly he imagined himself jinking and swerving, avoiding the bullets until he was out of range. 
 Then his common sense took over. 
 There was no shelter to make for, anywhere on the long, wide ridge, and the heather and the little bushes would tangle his feet and trip him as soon as he strayed from the straight path. 
 There was no way to escape. 
 He was going to die whatever happened. 
 Thinking about anything else was just a way of avoiding the choice. 
 The choice. 
 He let his eyes slip the other way, towards the little group of waiting people, hunting along the front line until he picked out Harriet Shakespeare. 
 He was sure &mdash; or almost sure &mdash; that he wasn't mad. 
 That she was Hank, and his mother. 
 But she seemed small and remote and somehow two-dimensional, like a picture. 
 It was not only space which separated them. 
 It was the whole complicated, confusing tangle of his life with Ma and Doyle. 
 He had grown without her. 
 Now, even if she did say, &bquo;You are my son,&equo; what would that mean? 
 She could not know the things he had discovered about himself in the last few days. 
 To wait for her would be like walking backwards. 
 And yet &mdash; what kind of a monster would he be if he ran off in the opposite direction? 
 If she were  his mother, and he let himself be shot without giving her a last chance of looking into his eyes? 
 Into her little boy's eyes.  
 Her &mdash; little &mdash; boy. 
 Oh Hank ! 
 &mdash; and he knew, this time, that he was appealing to a part of his mind and not to another person at all &mdash; What would you choose ? 
 Suddenly, without trying, he knew what the real  Harriet Shakespeare would say. 
 With a fierce look on her tough, plain face. 
 For Heaven's sake, Tug, do I have to decide everything for you? 
 You've got to rely on yourself. 
 Be a person of your own. 
 The picture of her in his head was so clear that he actually smiled. 
 Of course she was his mother! 
 He knew it now, without question. 
 He loved her and trusted her understanding &mdash; and that made the choice perfectly simple after all. 
 He stood up. 
 &bquo;Ready,&equo; he said. 
 Turning his back on Hank, he began to run away from her, along the path towards the Castle Rock. 
 Jinny jerked as though someone had pulled at her. 
 That was the last thing she had expected. 
 She did not understand what could have made the boy run off in the opposite direction. 
 Nor did she understand the expression that leapt on to the Hare-woman's face, lighting her eyes with a fierce, proud joy. 
 All that was mysterious. 
 What Jinny could  understand was the slow, careful way the Hare-woman settled her hands round the long gun. 
 &bquo;You can't!&equo; 
 Jinny shouted. 
 &bquo;You can't !&equo; 
 She would have rushed forward to knock the gun aside, but she was not fast enough. 
 Doyle gripped her closely from behind, pinning her arms to her sides and holding her motionless. 
 &bquo;Wait!&equo; 
 he hissed. 
 &bquo;Wait and see what happens!&equo; 
 Too fast ! 
 Too fast ! thought Tug, willing himself to slow down. 
 There was no point in going off like a stone from a catapult. 
 He couldn't outrun the bullets. 
 He would just sprint  himself to a standstill in a couple of hundred metres. 
 His fear screamed at him to bolt, but he forced his mind into action, to plan the run sensibly. 
 Ahead of him was the Castle Rock. 
 Two miles away? 
 Something like that. 
 That was his finishing line. 
 That was what he had to concentrate on. 
 The wind was much more powerful than he had realized. 
 Bracing his body against it, he battered forwards, with his head down, and it ate away at his strength. 
 He was out of training, too. 
 Exercises in a room were all very well, but they were no substitute for running every day. 
 Distantly, muffled by the wind, he heard shouts from behind, but he bullied himself to ignore them. 
 Concentrate. 
 Concentrate . 
 Forget Ma. 
 Forget Hank. 
 Forget everything except the pace and the effort of keeping your feet pounding steadily, the effort of keeping your body moving forward towards the pain. 
 Jinny was screaming now. 
 Flinging her voice into the wind in a last, desperate attempt to make the Hare-woman put down the gun. 
 &bquo;It's not fair! 
 It's not fair ! 
 You both did this sort of test, I know you did. 
 But no one shot you . 
 You got away with it. 
 How can you shoot Tug? 
 He hasn't done anything to you. 
 It's wicked ! 
 You're both crazy! 
 All your ideas are mad and &mdash; &bquo; 
 Doyle's hand suddenly clamped over her mouth, cutting off her voice and nearly stopping her breath. 
 &bquo;Get on with it, you stupid cow,&equo; he said harshly to the Hare-woman. 
 &bquo;Stop dithering about, or it'll be too late. 
 They're coming.&equo; 
 And, out of the corner of her eye, Jinny saw that it was true. 
 Harriet Shakespeare and the policemen had begun to creep closer, ready to run as soon as the first shot was fired. 
 The Hare-woman's hands steadied the gun and she started to lift it, taking aim. 
 Tug was suffering already from the lack of training and the  stupid way he had begun the run. 
 His breathing was frightful and the unrelenting ache in his legs grew harsher with every stride. 
 He started to be afraid that he would have to slow down, even to walk. 
 Had he really chosen this pain  as the way to spend his last minutes? 
 He must be mad! 
 His legs thudded on and on, but the movement was mechanical, with no spirit in it. 
 What was the point of dying with your lungs gasping for breath? 
 What was the point of running to the Castle Rock anyway? 
 What was the point of doing anything, when you were going to die? 
 Standing dumb and immobilized in Doyle's hands, Jinny felt the last grains of fight trickle out of her. 
 All her thinking and watching and planning, from the first sound of the car on the track while she and Joe crouched by the netted gate to that last desperate shout that Doyle had cut short, all that worrying and puzzling had ended up like this. 
 Any moment now, one burst of shooting would make Harriet Shakespeare childless and turn the Hare-woman into a murderess. 
 And she was not strong enough to stop what was going to happen. 
 All she could do was stand there, a passive witness. 
 It was all going to end wrong after all. 
 Closing her eyes, she let her whole body droop, limp in Doyle's hands. 
 Then, with his legs like dough and his breath tearing out of his chest, Tug raised his head and saw the jagged, ungainly outline of the Castle Rock, sharp against the sky. 
 Dimly, he knew that somewhere inside him was the power to reach it. 
 Because that was what he had decided to do. 
 Dragging the last remnants of his determination together, he fixed his eyes on the dark, looming rock and thought, I will . 
 And suddenly, like a miracle, the extra strength came to him, and he was running . 
 Hundreds of metres up in the sky above Ashdale, he was running along the Edge with every last fibre of his body. 
 Every thread of will-power, every cell, all of himself.  
 At the same moment, Jinny heard Doyle shout, &bquo;What are you waiting for?&equo; 
 There was something in his voice that made her open her eyes. 
 As her eyelids flickered up, she saw the expression on the Hare-woman's face. 
 Only just under control. 
 Balanced on the edge of screaming. 
 And she knew that she had seen that expression before, and very recently. 
 But where? 
 She nearly did not remember in time, because the similarity was such an unlikely one and she was hunting for pictures of hatred. 
 But, in the last fraction of a second, it came to her. 
 As the Hare-woman's golden eyes narrowed and hardened and her finger moved towards the trigger. 
 It was Harriet Shakespeare  who had looked like that. 
 Harriet Shakespeare, in anguish because of her love for her son. 
 Without fully understanding, Jinny moved instinctively. 
 She bit Doyle's fingers and jerked her mouth free of them, shouting the words that came into her head. 
 Bella's words. 
 &bquo;It's because you love him that you feel like killing him! 
 But if you kill him, you'll only smash yourself !&equo; 
 the huge eyes widened again, startled, and Harewoman looked around, lowering the gun. 
 As she did so, a shot cracked across the ridge, from one of the police marksmen. 
 Putting a hand to her side, she staggered. 
 Instantly, Doyle let go of Jinny and started forward, his arms outstretched to take the Kalashnikov. 
 But the Harewoman was too quick for him. 
 Whirling her long, powerful arms, with the last of her strength, she flung the gun in a great arc, so that it sailed up, high above Doyle's head. 
 For a second it was only a black silhouette against the sky. 
 Then it fell out of sight, over Ashdale Great Edge. 
 As she crumpled, the Hare-woman called into the wind, &bquo;Run, Tug, run! 
 You're free!&equo; 
 And Harriet Shakespeare, stumbling over the rough ground towards them, raised her voice at the same moment and yelled, &bquo;Tug darling, it's all right. 
 You're safe!&equo; 
 The sound of the shot blew to Tug on the wind, and then  he heard the shouts. 
 Somewhere in the back of his mind he registered that they were both calling to him, Hank and Ma together. 
 But he did not turn, he did not even falter, because his head was up and his feet were pounding. 
 The pain and the wind and the shouts from behind were all nothing. 
 All that mattered was the running, and the voice in his head which sang triumphantly, This is me.  
 Here I am, Hank. 
 Here I am, Ma. 
 This is me. 
 This is who I am. 
 The Day the Peace Began 
 In the afternoon, the landlady hung a line of coloured bunting along the fence outside her house. 
 Gloria and Dot rented a room in the basement. 
 Gloria lead Dot up the outside steps from the basement to look at the cotton flags flapping in the sun. 
 Women from along the street came out of their front doors too. 
 Gloria gave Dot a hug and said, &bquo;Take a peek at that, Dot. 
 So you won't never forget today. 
 Today's ever so special.&equo; 
 Then she took a little tin brooch from her pocket. 
 It was in the same colours as the bunting, red, white and blue. 
 &bquo;There you are, ducks. 
 That's a victory token, V for victory.&equo; 
 One of the grown-ups from along the street noticed the brooch and said to Gloria, &bquo;You're in luck! 
 Where d'you find that? 
 We went up Derry and Tom's yesterday. 
 They was sold clean out. 
 Not as much as a secondhand Union Jack left.&equo; 
 &bquo;Got it for her week before. 
 Last one they had in,&equo; said Gloria, and she pinned the tin brooch on to Dot's cardigan. 
 &bquo;So you mind you keep it safe as houses, Dot, then you'll always remember.&equo; 
 &bquo;Is it over then?&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;'Course it's over, you silly goose,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Over now,&equo; Dot repeated, but she wasn't sure what it meant and if she even wanted it over. 
 It sounded insecure. 
 One of the grown-ups said, &bquo;I was hoping for a bit of a fly-past.&equo; 
 Another said, &bquo;I'd a thought you'd had enough of that by now!&equo; 
 They stood around hopefully, occasionally glancing up  into the sky or peering down the road as though expecting something to happen. 
 When nothing -did, they drifted indoors again. 
 So Gloria and Dot went back down the area steps to their room, leaving the sunshine behind. 
 It was always dim down here but Gloria didn't switch the light on because of being told to save electricity. 
 There was always a faint smell, too, of something rotting. 
 &bquo;Just the gas,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Escaping. 
 It won't do us no harm.&equo; 
 They hadn't had gas in their last room. 
 Gloria lay on the bed and thumbed through the pages of her magazine. 
 Picturegoer  was about film stars. 
 Gloria liked reading about the stars. 
 She knew all their names. 
 Sometimes she tried to do her hair like some of them in the photographs. 
 Dot could hear the landlady listening to her radio next door in the kitchen. 
 After that, nothing happened for hours till Gloria suddenly said, &bquo;Listen, ducky, I'm going to pop up the West End. 
 Just see what's going on. 
 Mrs Parvis'll keep an eye on you. 
 Won't be back late, promise. 
 All right, love?&equo; 
 She took her best outfit from the paper carrier on the mantleshelf, shook it to get rid of the creases, and soon was all dressed up and ready to go with her red lipstick, her pretty pinned-up hair and her fancy black peep-toe shoes. 
 &bquo;You look nice,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;Like a real star.&equo; 
 Gloria was pleased. 
 She wanted to be like a star. 
 She never wore slacks because she said stars didn't. 
 She said they mostly wore silky slips and dressing-gowns. 
 Gloria tucked the blanket around Dot and kissed the tip of her nose. 
 Dot said, &bquo;But what about Baby?&equo; 
 They hadn't been to see him today. 
 Would it matter? 
 &bquo;Not one day won't make no difference to him,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Today's ever so special. 
 Maybe you don't understand. 
 You will one day.&equo; 
 Of course Dot understood. 
 She'd heard the landlady say  how it was all over now bar the shouting. 
 &bquo;He'll be right as rain, pet,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;And we'll be seeing him tomorrow.&equo; 
 Dot tried not to mind being left on her own in the basement. 
 With their two paper carriers on the shelf, the scrappet of carpet on the concrete floor, and the gas fire in the corner it was almost beginning to feel like home. 
 The last place they were in they didn't even have a proper bed. 
 As she lay listening to the sound of the grown-ups&equo; laughter coming through the wall, Dot felt round the sharp tin edges of her victory brooch still pinned to her cardigan front and remembered how Gloria had once said you'd always be safe in a place like this. 
 &bquo;Even if the whole house collapsed on top of you. 
 They'd never get you down here.&equo; 
 There was more noise than usual coming through from the landlady's kitchen. 
 Then they began singing. 
 Dot remembered how sometimes there used to be singing down in the shelters in the dark. 
 But this singing was different, not quiet holy hymns but loud and impassioned. 
 They must be having a party in there. 
 Dot wished, after all, that Gloria hadn't gone out because Gloria liked parties and now she was missing it. 
 Dot was hungry. 
 There hadn't been a proper tea. 
 They hadn't been to visit Baby in hospital either. 
 What a strange unsettling day. 
 She knew she wouldn't forget it, even without her victory token. 
 Dot woke when she heard Gloria coming down the clanky metal steps outside, heard her stumble her way across the room, and then felt herself being pushed to the far side of the bed. 
 &bquo;Shove over there,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Make a bit of room. 
 Age before beauty.&equo; 
 When Gloria climbed in beside her, they both rolled down into the dip in the middle of the bed. 
 Dot felt Gloria snuggling up close. 
 &bquo;You're nice and warm, pet,&equo; Gloria said. 
 &bquo;Ooh, Dot, I do wish I'd took you. 
 It was wonderful! 
 You don't know the half of it. 
 There was thousands of us!&equo;  
 Dot put her arm round her mother's neck and hugged to show she was still awake and listening. 
 &bquo;We saw the King. 
 And the Queen. 
 And the princesses. 
 We shouted for them till they came out on their balcony. 
 Then we danced, right there in front of the palace. 
 And we sang. 
 And there was the searchlights up in the sky. 
 And down King Edward's docks all them boats was letting off their hooters.&equo; 
 Dot tried hard to imagine it. 
 She said, &bquo;I think they had a party here too. 
 In Mrs Parvis's kitchen.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did they? 
 I'm glad of that. 
 So you weren't lonely? 
 I would've come back sooner. 
 But all the roads were that crowded. 
 I couldn't find a bus nowhere. 
 Drivers must've been celebrating too. 
 So I had to walk all the way.&equo; 
 &bquo;Was it a long way?&equo; 
 Dot wondered. 
 &bquo;Not too far when you're having a good time. 
 You know, pet, I been thinking. 
 From now on everything's going to be all right. 
 I just know it. 
 Like they said. 
 We've won ourselves a new world. 
 Well, better get some shut-eye. 
 Nighty-night, pet. 
 God bless.&equo; 
 When Dot heard the deep slow breathing of her mother sleeping, she was alone again and she was frightened. 
 People had been saying that once the war was over, things would change. 
 Dot didn't want anything to change. 
 She'd had enough of that. 
 Change was unsettling. 
 It meant brick dust and disorder. 
 The war was over and she was afraid.  
 Dot's Baby 
 The next day things were back to normal. 
 Gloria tied on her red headscarf, Dot buttoned up her pink cardigan and they went to wait for the bus to take them down to the hospital to see how Baby was doing. 
 The only difference from usual was the tin brooch. 
 And they saw quite a lot more flags hanging out of windows. 
 It was always a long wait at the bus stop, followed by a long ride. 
 Gloria said it wasn't half as bad as the last place. 
 When he'd first been taken poorly, Baby had been driven in an ambulance from one hospital to another. 
 They never seemed to be near where Gloria and Dot were. 
 It was like cat and mouse trying to keep up with him. 
 &bquo;He's more like a little sparrow, ain't he?&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Always hopping around, never stopping put in one spot.&equo; 
 One time, the people at the hospital didn't even tell Gloria that Baby had been moved. 
 When she and Dot turned up to visit, he just wasn't there any more. 
 &bquo;Oh, but he's been transferred,&equo; said the nurse. 
 &bquo;You must have known.&equo; 
 She didn't seem at all bothered that Gloria and Dot would have to go trudging off to another hospital somewhere else to find him. 
 Gloria became angry. 
 &bquo;We come up all this way to visit. 
 Now you tell me he ain't even here!&equo; 
 The nurse just said, &bquo;Well what d'you expect me  to do about it? 
 Burst into flames for you?&equo; 
 The latest hospital was built tall, of blackish-red bricks, with rows of dark windows reaching upwards towards the sky. 
 &bquo;What d'you think it's like in a ward right up top?&equo; 
 Dot said. 
 &bquo;D'you think it's like flying? 
 D'you think it's frightening? 
  They could get you more easy up there, couldn't they?&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't drag. 
 Keep up with me,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;You're more bear than squirrel today. 
 I don't want to go losing you in here.&equo; 
 Dot knew there must be people up there in the vulnerable places on the top floor because on their way through the draughty corridors they passed the lift-shafts, each with its rattling metal cage and fearful loops of cable and black rope dangling beneath like greasy snakes. 
 The lifts were for transporting patients too sick to protest to departments on higher floors. 
 Luckily, they didn't have to get into the cage for the children's ward was on the ground floor. 
 Gloria went in. 
 Dot stood outside the double swing doors. 
 She wasn't allowed any further. 
 Children couldn't go into the children's ward unless they themselves were poorly. 
 The corridor was dark brown. 
 Gloria had said it was painted like that so it wouldn't show the blood. 
 But when Dot said, &bquo;What blood?&equo; 
 Gloria laughed and said, &bquo;No, not really, pet. 
 Just pulling your leg.&equo; 
 The ground floor windows were barred like a prison, so nobody could climb in or out. 
 And they were glazed with opaque white glass so that the patients couldn't see out either, nor passers-by see in. 
 Dot hoped it was nice for Baby in there. 
 Visiting him the day after the peace began, everything was the same as always. 
 Dot waited and waited in the long brown corridor with nowhere to sit. 
 Once some nurses bustled along. 
 Then an empty bed was wheeled by. 
 When it was time to go home again, at the hospital gates the friendly porter was on duty, sitting inside the cosy little wooden porters' hut. 
 It would have made a compact little home except it was painted dark brown like the corridors. 
 The porter recognized Gloria and leaned out of his hut. 
 &bquo;Hello there, dear. 
 And how's the little laddie doing today?&equo; 
 Gloria half nodded her head and shrugged. 
 &bquo;No change,&equo;  she said, giving an elusive and empty smile. 
 &bquo;Not so you'd notice.&equo; 
 Dot was glad. 
 She felt safe. 
 Changes were always bad. 
 No change must be good. 
 The nearly worst thing that could happen would be her father coming back. 
 It had to happen one day, but not yet. 
 And the very worst thing would be having to move again. 
 But she didn't tell Gloria. 
 They were back at Mrs Parvis's just in time for the evening meal. 
 &bquo;By the skin of our teeth!&equo; said Gloria as they scurried for their places at table. 
 It was called High Tea. 
 Here too, there were still no changes that Dot could see. 
 Always toast and dripping followed by a good hot dish. 
 Today's main dish was cabbage and swede stew with dumplings. 
 Dot liked the reassuring look of those dumplings, plump and pale, floating amongst the shreds of yellowish green in the huge pan. 
 &bquo;Now that it's over, you'd expect they'd start getting things right at last, wouldn't you?&equo; said Mrs Parvis, standing up at the end of the table to ladle out to her assembled household. 
 &bquo;Well, things are bound to start looking up soon,&equo; said one of the lodgers. 
 &bquo;I mean, they Promised , didn't they?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm glad it's finished. 
 But I still got that feeling that we lost  something. 
 Know what I mean?&equo; 
 Dot listened as the grown-ups continued to grumble along as they had done for as long as she could remember, like the harmless rumble of gunfire faraway. 
 &bquo;For myself,&equo; Mrs Parvis went on, &bquo;I'd have felt more excited like, if it'd finished lost  summer. 
 When we all thought it would. 
 Somehow I can't feel so interested in the peace now. 
 I feel sort of, &bquo;So what?&equo; 
 Don't you agree, Mr Brown?&equo; 
 Mr Brown gazed down at his plate and nodded. 
 Mrs Parvis always made him agree with whatever she said. 
 Gloria said he only went along with her because of the housing shortages, because he knew he was lucky to have a room at all, even if it was only half a room at Mrs Parvis's. 
 Mr Brown's room, first landing, back, was tall and  narrow like a thin passage. 
 It was a sliver of a larger room that had been partitioned off. 
 Dot peeked in when he was out at work. 
 She wanted to see what there was out of that lanky half-window. 
 Downstairs in the basement, all they had to look at was the brick wall of the coal-hole with Mrs Parvis's aluminium meat-safe hanging on it, and a line of smelly bins. 
 Mr Brown's half-room turned out to be nearly as dark as the basement because of the cardboard panes stuck in the window where the glass had been blown out. 
 That was ages ago. 
 They'd still not been replaced. 
 Dot didn't hear Mrs Parvis come creeping up behind her. 
 &bquo;Prying! 
 I've warned you before, you young hoyden,&equo; Mrs Parvis scolded. 
 &bquo;I will not tolerate children wandering around wherever their fancy takes them! 
 Whatever will Mr Brown think!&equo; 
 Dot knew that Mrs Parvis couldn't care less what Mr Brown thought because Mr Brown didn't count for anything, because poor Mr Brown had never been in uniform. 
 Dot had heard Mrs Parvis say that it was a crying shame, a young fit man like that. 
 He was a steel-cutter in the aircraft factory. 
 He was missing two fingers from his right hand. 
 They would never grow again. 
 Dot didn't like watching that two-fingered hand as it grasped the knife to cut the dumplings. 
 Mr Brown did not like to show it either. 
 At High Tea, Dot was glad when he saw her staring and tidied the strange hand out of sight beneath the table. 
 Using only his whole hand, he had to dissect his dumpling with the edge of the fork. 
 Cutting steel to make aeroplane bodies was a dangerous job. 
 &bquo;There's over a million homeless in London,&equo; Mrs Parvis grumbled on. 
 &bquo;It's gonna take years to put that right.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you'll pardon the correction, not so much as a million,&equo; said one of the lady lodgers. 
 &bquo;I saw the official figures released last week by the Ministry of Information. 
 A hundred and thirty thousand London homes destroyed, so the precise number of homeless is now estimated to be around only a quarter of a million.&equo;  
 Mrs Parvis ignored the interruption and carried on. 
 &bquo;Single men won't come top of the list for rehousing, not by a long chalk.&equo; 
 She eyed Mr Brown meaningfully over her hot cauldron of cabbage before going on with her set piece. 
 &bquo;First they let us have this great feeling of elation. 
 It's over, we thought. 
 But that only lasted a week or two, didn't it? 
 Now it's like they're saying the party's finished. 
 It seems to me, everything's going on just the same as it was before. 
 Except there's less of this and less of that. 
 Which is why I'll be obliged if you don't ask for bread unless you really want it. 
 I queued a long time for that loaf. 
 And I've no doubt it's the last we'll be seeing till Thursday.&equo; 
 Dot waited for her share of the hot dish. 
 She was served last. 
 Mrs Parvis gave her a reduced portion. 
 Dot watched half a dumpling sliding on to her plate. 
 As Mrs Parvis had explained to Gloria when they first arrived, &bquo;I'm in no position to go showing no favouritisms to some and not to others. 
 If you ask me, that's the first step to black market. 
 What if everybody was demanding lull portions for their children? 
 There's been people starved to death in Stalingrad, so don't you go thinking you're something special.&equo; 
 While Gloria helped dry the dishes after tea, Mrs Parvis continued to find fault with the people who ran the country. 
 &bquo;They'll nag us now about winning the peace , just like they nagged us about winning the war . 
 And I don't suppose my old man'll be home for months. 
 Heard from your hubby? 
 Does he know about the poor little kiddy?&equo; 
 Gloria shrugged. 
 &bquo;R.A.F. isn't it? 
 Not expected back for quite a while yet, I suppose? 
 Something very hush-hush, didn't you say?&equo; 
 Dot knew that her father was at a place that Gloria rarely talked to other people about, but kept like some kind of secret. 
 Some days, Dot couldn't remember what his face was like. 
 She looked at the snapshot of him in Gloria's handbag, but still couldn't seem to see him properly. 
 &bquo;Oh, but it'll be good to have them back, won't it?&equo; said Mrs Parvis. 
 &bquo;Not that one likes to mention too much of that sort of thing in front of poor Mr Brown. 
 Of course, one  can't hold it against him. 
 It's just, he must have felt so out of  it, stuck here while all our brave boys have been doing their bit for us.&equo; 
 Dot thought of Mr Brown's two missing fingers. 
 Sometimes in her memory, it was her faceless father who was two fingers short instead. 
 She wondered, if Mr Brown were  able to get them back, would he want them, or had he now grown too accustomed to his hand the way it was?  
 A New Tweed Coat 
 &bquo;She's a scrappy little thing, isn't she?&equo; said Mrs Parvis. 
 &bquo;Takes after her father, does she?&equo; 
 She was discussing Dot. 
 Gloria shrugged. 
 Dot fingered her victory badge and tried not to listen in case it seemed like prying. 
 &bquo;If you want my advice, lovie, you'll pop her down the Town Hall and find her a decent coat to wear. 
 When you go to fetch her rations.&equo; 
 Gloria and Dot went down to the Town Hall once a fortnight to collect Dot's vitamin ration. 
 Two bottles of orange juice, opaque and brilliantly coloured, one of cod liver oil, translucent and greenish-gold. 
 Before the tin victory brooch, these bottles of liquid strength were the only goods that Dot knew were hers alone, belonging to no grown-up. 
 Gloria poured her a spoonful from each bottle every day and said that's why she was tough as old boots, because she always swallowed it down like a good girl. 
 A previous landlady had tried to help herself to the orange juice to put in her gin. 
 When Gloria complained, there'd been a tiff and they'd had to leave. 
 &bquo;You know I can't go buying her nothing!&equo; 
 Gloria said now about the coat. 
 &bquo;They won't ask for no clothing coupons down there,&equo; said Mrs Parvis. 
 &bquo;It's not coupons I'm short of. 
 They gave me all them extra ones for Baby's nappies what I never used.&equo; 
 &bquo;Didn't you even get him a proper layette, the poor wee mite?&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm not made of money, Mrs Parvis. 
 I told you I got coupons coming out of my ears. 
 It's cash we're stuck on.&equo;  
 &bquo;At the Clothes Exchange, dear, you don't need no money down there. 
 Nor coupons. 
 It's meant for people like you what haven't got nothing left.&equo; 
 Dot didn't like it when Mrs Parvis spoke in this way, as though they were dusty victims from under the rubble. 
 Maybe they hadn't got any clothes, and they couldn't afford one of the nice rooms, and they didn't belong anywhere, but they had each other and they had Baby to visit each day. 
 &bquo;Women's Voluntary running it.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know all about them,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Busybodies, the lot of them. 
 Worse than Air Raid Wardens.&equo; 
 &bquo;Beggars can't be choosers. 
 Anyway, you never know, you might find something there. 
 You want her to look as though you care, don't you? 
 Besides she'll catch her death with just that little woolly cardy.&equo; 
 &bquo;If you say so, Mrs Parvis. 
 Try any dodge once,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;By the by, you giving her her vitamins? 
 Don't want her to go the way of Baby, do you now?&equo; 
 &bquo;Interfering old bag,&equo; muttered Gloria so that Mrs Parvis probably heard. 
 But they set out for the Town Hall none the less. 
 &bquo;Matter of fact, Dot, what I really fancy you in is one of them nice Scottish tartan kilts like the princesses had when they was little. 
 Remember them on their summer holiday? 
 Matching check kilts, playing in the purple heather. 
 With a nice fluffy jumper. 
 Fair Isle, that's what they called it.&equo; 
 The clerk behind the hatch asked for their empties before she'd hand over the new bottles but they hadn't got them. 
 They were still half full back at their room. 
 &bquo;Try and remember next time,&equo; the clerk snapped. 
 &bquo;We can't go wasting glass. 
 Remember, we've all got to fight for the future now.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't say!&equo; 
 Sometimes Dot wished Gloria wouldn't answer back to people in authority because then they noticed them more. 
 The hall where the Children's Clothes Exchange was  taking place was organized by another bossy lady in green uniform, sitting importantly behind a desk in the doorway. 
 &bquo;This is an exchange , not a rummage sale,&equo; she said when she saw that Gloria had brought along no clothes to swap. 
 &bquo;Well I haven't got nothing to hand in, have I? 
 And if I had she'd be wearing it. 
 Then I wouldn't need to bring her up here, would I?&equo; 
 The lady in green pursed up her lips. 
 &bquo;Oh, all right, in you go, but don't go taking too much. 
 I know what some of you lot are up to.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ta ever so,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;She's got to look nice for when we go up the hospital to see my little boy.&equo; 
 In a huge bare hall, trestle tables were heaped with children's garments and there was a thick, stifling smell in the air. 
 Women in headscarves were sifting through the untidy muddle like rescue workers scrabbling in rubble for survivors while children stood by, waiting for the emergence of something to look at. 
 Sometimes children grizzled, sometimes they wailed. 
 Dot didn't like the smell of old clothes nor of brick dust and escaping gas but she rarely wailed. 
 &bquo;Are they clean?&equo; one woman asked, picking out a little coloured dress to measure up against her own child. 
 &bquo;I should think so too!&equo; snapped the lady keeping order behind the table. 
 &bquo;They've all been fumigated quite properly under Ministry supervision.&equo; 
 But Dot could see how the lady herself wore white cotton gloves to handle the clothing, so as not to touch it directly. 
 Dot waited quietly till Gloria emerged from the jostling crowd holding up a fawn coat, triumphant like the A.R.P. 
 men when they'd retrieved a live person, or even a dead one. 
 Once Dot had seen a canary in a bent cage pulled out, black like a little sparrow from the ashes and soot, yet still singing even though its owner was gone. 
 &bquo;Real tweed. 
 And look at that label!&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Daniel Neal. 
 That means it's quality. 
 The princesses used to have their clothes from there. 
 By Appointment to Her Majesty , it says.&equo;  
 The coat smelled musty and the cuffs felt greasy. 
 Dot didn't think the princesses had ever had greasy cuffs. 
 &bquo;I'd have preferred it pink, that's more feminine like, but them dull colours, that's just like the Princesses used to wear.&equo; 
 It was double-breasted with two rows of pearl buttons up the front. 
 Gloria buttoned Dot up. 
 &bquo;Well aren't you the one! 
 All dressed Up like the cat's dinner.&equo; 
 Gloria seemed so pleased that Dot didn't like to say how constricting the coat felt round the neck. 
 &bquo;Here, I got you these too.&equo; 
 Gloria had two white woollen socks. 
 &bquo;Don't quite match, but near as makes no difference.&equo; 
 One was longer than the other and a different, more yellowy, shade of white. 
 &bquo;You're going to look a proper little madam. 
 Nice white socks and a proper little coat. 
 See, it's got velvet on it just like the princesses used to have when they was little. 
 You're going to look too Posh to go walking with me. 
 People'll think I'm your nanny.&equo; 
 Dot felt in the pockets. 
 They had velvet flaps over them like letterboxes. 
 She found a used tram ticket to Holborn in one and a little hanky scrumpled up in the bottom of the other. 
 She smoothed it over with her hand. 
 It was trimmed with a border of lace and printed with a pattern of flowers. 
 &bquo;Ooh, violets! 
 Isn't that lucky! 
 A hanky for you too. 
 That's fine Swiss cotton, that is. 
 When we get back I'll rinse it through. 
 Then you can keep it in there so you've always got it.&equo; 
 Gloria was always telling Dot she should try to hold on to things so she'd have them as keepsakes for ever. 
 Yet Gloria herself never seemed to hold on to more than the bare essentials that they had in their two paper carriers. 
 The only keepsakes Gloria had were her best peep-toe shoes and her little black hat with the veil. 
 &bquo;Funny, isn't it, how things just slip away without you noticing? 
 Someone once gave me ever such a lovely little china cup when you was born, with pictures on it. 
 Flowers and that. 
 That was gone before you'd even learned to sit Up by yourself.&equo;  
 The violet-patterned handkerchief had some writing in the corner. 
 Dot asked, &bquo;What's that say?&equo; 
 &bquo;Henrietta&equo;,&equo; Gloria read it out for Dot. 
 &bquo;Forbes-Read&equo;.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's it mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's a name tape. 
 Though you'd have thought they'd have taken it off before bringing in their things. 
 It's not very nice, leaving it on there, is it? 
 Never mind, I'll unpick it when I wash it through for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, leave it, please,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;I like it.&equo; 
 She wondered what the coat's first owner was wearing now. 
 Or perhaps it belonged to a child who was under rubble. 
 &bquo;Sent away to America more like,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Still, maybe she's left some of her luck behind in her pockets.&equo; 
 When Dot went to bed that night, Gloria laid the fawn coat over the top of the blanket. 
 It felt heavy. 
 &bquo;So as some of the luck'll spill out on you when you're asleep,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Really?&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;'Course not, silly billy! 
 Just having you on. 
 It's to keep the cold out of your bones.&equo; 
 As she waited for sleep, Dot thought she saw the face of the coat-owner gazing out of the dark with a complexion as pale and refined as tissue-paper.  
 The Day That Baby Went 
 Visiting Ward 3-South was built into Dot's life. 
 Gloria disappearing between the double swing doors with the round port-hole windows too high to see through, and Dot in the dark brown corridor standing, standing, waiting, for however long it took. 
 Apart from that one time when Gloria went off instead to cheer the King, Dot couldn't remember a day when they hadn't been to visit whatever hospital he was in. 
 But today Gloria blundered out through the swing doors when she'd hardly been in there any time at all and looked like she was groping along in her sleep. 
 Dot had seen people like that before, long ago. 
 They hadn't been hurt, not so much as a graze on them, yet when the all-clear sounded, they came out of their buildings and stood on their street with blank eyes that seemed to stare inwards. 
 &bquo;That's him, then, all gone,&equo; Gloria said, before a nurse came scurrying out through the doors, took her by the arm and led her back into the ward. 
 The long corridor was empty. 
 Dot took a chance peek in through the crack between where the two doors met. 
 It looked nice and peaceful in there. 
 The floor was dark green and shiny like a sheet of still water, and everything else was white. 
 The metal bedsteads were white, the cotton covers on them white, and the children lying straight and still wore white gowns. 
 Every child had a bed or a cot to themselves. 
 No sharing and rolling down into the dip in the middle. 
 Another nurse, older-looking and in blue, marched along the corridor. 
 She snapped at Dot, &bquo;What are you  doing, hanging around here?&equo;  
 &bquo;Waiting for my Mum,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;In there.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are you indeed,&equo; said the navy-blue nurse. 
 Then, &bquo;Ah, I  see,&equo; as though she knew something special. 
 She hurried away through the swing doors, then out again to tell Dot, more kindly, that her brother had gone on a journey. 
 &bquo;A long journey. 
 He won't be coming back.&equo; 
 Dot thought that he must have been moved to a different hospital. 
 She said, &bquo;How far?&equo; 
 She wondered what number bus they'd have to get. 
 If it was too far, they'd have to move lodgings again. 
 Dot didn't want that. 
 &bquo;Why can't he stay in this hospital? 
 He likes it here.&equo; 
 The nurse said, &bquo;Never mind, hen.&equo; 
 Then Dot understood what she'd meant. 
 And Dot had a sinking feeling because she realized she'd known all along even though she hadn't wanted to. 
 That's what always happened to people you knew. 
 Away they went and never came back. 
 But Dot had thought it wouldn't ever happen to their baby. 
 She'd hoped he was too young. 
 They left the hospital and went to wait for the bus. 
 Gloria didn't pause to say anything to the cheery porter at the gates, nor did he call out to them. 
 He was looking the other way, sorting mail. 
 Dot knew that Gloria was sad. 
 She wasn't chatting to other people in the queue. 
 Her red lipstick was smudged and she hadn't bothered to pin up her hair properly at the sides. 
 Dot wanted to make Gloria feel happy. 
 She tugged at her hand. 
 &bquo;Shall we play princesses?&equo; she whispered. 
 They would be young girls growing up at the palace, the princesses Elizabeth and Margaret. 
 Gloria took the part of the elder princess. 
 &bquo;Main thing is,&equo; she used to explain, &bquo;we have to act natural, because that's what they done, none of your fancy airs and graces. 
 Just natural and nice, and ever so ladylike.&equo; 
 Dot liked it when Gloria wanted to play. 
 It felt like seeing a film happening round you. 
 All Dot had to do was smile pleasantly and stand a little behind because, as Gloria  pointed out, Princess Margaret wasn't nearly as important as Princess Elizabeth and would never become a queen. 
 &bquo;And you watch out for the royal governess!&equo; 
 Gloria used to warn. 
 &bquo;Or you'll catch the sharp end of her tongue! 
 She taught 'em how to behave, made 'em do their lessons at high desks. 
 That's so they'd get used to the standing. 
 Specially Princess Elizabeth. 
 She has to do a lot of standing.&equo; 
 &bquo;I wouldn't. ever want to be a princess,&equo; Dot sometimes said, because she wanted so much to be one. 
 &bquo;Well that's all right, then, ain't it?&equo; 
 Gloria sometimes replied. 
 &bquo;Because you ain't never gonna have to be.&equo; 
 But now she said, &bquo;No, not just now, ducks.&equo; 
 &bquo;D'you wanna play Stars , then?&equo; 
 Dot asked. 
 That was the other game Gloria liked. 
 She chose the film and the parts they were to play. 
 Sometimes she said she was Gloria Swanson. 
 Sometimes Loretta Young. 
 Or Ginger Rogers. 
 Or Barbara Stanwyck. 
 They had lovely exotic names. 
 Gloria knew them all. 
 But the films had strange names which didn't seem to Dot to mean anything. 
 And Now Tomorrow, Forever Young, Till Midnight Comes . 
 What sense was there in that? 
 Gloria had taken Dot to the cinema a few times. 
 It was very dark. 
 And when the stars' faces filled the whole screen so that you saw their huge lips close up like big pillows moving and their great teeth and their smooth matt skin filling the whole screen, it was frightening. 
 The films Gloria liked were about love and people singing to each other. 
 Sometimes though, there was just talking. 
 Then Dot couldn't understand what was going on. 
 Sometimes Gloria explained. 
 &bquo;See, she's lost her memory in a terrible storm. 
 He's a stranger from out of town.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who's that other lady?&equo; 
 &bquo;She's pretending to love him. 
 Really she's after him for his money.&equo; 
 &bquo;What's going to happen?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ssh, I don't know. 
 That's why we're here. 
 To find out.&equo;  
 &bquo;When will it be over?&equo; 
 &bquo;I said, ssh.&equo; 
 The bus was a long time coming and Gloria wouldn't play anything, just stood there staring at nothing until finally she said, &bquo;Now I ain't got him no more.&equo; 
 &bquo;You got me,&equo; said Dot. 
 Gloria blinked. 
 &bquo;That coat didn't have no luck left in it after all, did it?&equo; 
 Dot gave her the violet-patterned hanky that used to belong to Henrietta Forbes-Read to wipe her eyes. 
 &bquo;What are we going to do?&equo; said Dot. 
 If they stopped visiting the hospital every day, there wouldn't be anything left in life except a gaping crater of nothingness and broken bricks. 
 Dot wanted to be back in their room at Mrs Parvis's. 
 That was where they both felt safe. 
 Gloria had always said so. 
 &bquo;You're always safe in a basement. 
 They can't get you down there. 
 Not unless it's a direct hit, then you've had it anyway. 
 So long as someone knows you're down there and comes to dig you out, then a basement's always best, even if the rest goes down like a pack of cards.&equo; 
 They didn't wait any longer for the bus. 
 They walked all the way. 
 Dot's legs ached. 
 She wanted to sit down. 
 Her shoelace came undone. 
 She wanted to be carried. 
 &bquo;You're too old for all that now,&equo; Gloria snapped. 
 &bquo;Don't push your luck.&equo; 
 Being back in the basement didn't turn out to be any good after all. 
 No sooner were they there than Gloria announced, &bquo;We can't stay down here any more. 
 It's got bad feelings for me, this room. 
 And just when I thought everything was changing for the better. 
 We'll tell her we're going away for a breather.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why have we got to go?&equo; 
 Dot didn't want to have to go away somewhere. 
 &bquo;We're always having to move.&equo; 
 &bquo;On a trip. 
 There's this place I know,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;She always said I could keep in touch.&equo; 
 Dot wondered what sort of a trip, what sort of a place. 
 &bquo;Where? 
 Why? 
 What? 
 Just don't ask me no more  questions, Dot. 
 Can't you see, I've got to have time to get myself straight inside.&equo; 
 Dot heard Gloria tell Mrs Parvis about what had happened. 
 &bquo;He was took quite sudden.&equo; 
 &bquo;Pneumonia, I dare say,&equo; said Mrs Parvis. 
 &bquo;Usually is. 
 Don't suppose he had the strength left in that little body to fight back no more, though you'd have thought they could've saved him with these new pills they got. 
 M and B, they're called. 
 My sister's boy was saved with them. 
 Did him a power of good. 
 He had middle ear. 
 His drum was pierced.&equo; 
 &bquo;They said it was for the best,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;And I dare say it was too,&equo; said Mrs Parvis. 
 &bquo;From what you told me. 
 Didn't stand a chance from the start. 
 They don't, kids like that.&equo; 
 &bquo;They gave him the oxygen, to help him breathe. 
 But then they took it away, said it was blinding him. 
 I wouldn't have minded him blind. 
 Better than not at all.&equo; 
 Mrs Parvis gave Gloria a pat on the shoulder and for once seemed almost friendly. 
 &bquo;You go off now and forget all about it. 
 Don't bother about the rent if you haven't got it now, just so long as you pay me as soon as you get back. 
 Dot didn't want to forget all about it. 
 She wondered if it was all right for her to go on thinking about Baby. 
 She wondered what the hospital would do with him. 
 Where did dead babies go? 
 But she knew she couldn't ask while Gloria was still getting herself straight inside. 
 Gloria put on her stockings, one coupon each, two for the pair and always kept for best, straightened the seams up the back, Vase lined her eyebrows, and put on her suede peeptoe shoes and her little black hat with the veil which usually lived in one of the paper carrier bags on the top of the shelf. 
 She'd been married in that hat. 
 &bquo;Cost me my last five bob. 
 Because I said to myself, even if you can't afford no frock, can't afford no party, can't afford no bouquet, at least you can have a new hat.&equo; 
 By the time they reached the railway station, Dot realized she must have had time to get herself straight  inside, for she seemed almost cheery again. 
 But she was frightened of the station. 
 It was too big, a great covered space where people strode backwards and forwards in a hurry. 
 The space rattled with loud disconnecting sounds which echoed about so you couldn't tell which direction they were coming from. 
 &bquo;It's too big here,&equo; said Dot. 
 She looked up at the curved glass roof overhead, so high and with pigeons on the inside, fluttering amongst the iron girders, trapped inside. 
 The roof was too high and was partly made of glass. 
 Dot didn't like the glass. 
 Some of it was broken. 
 When glass shatters it leaves jagged edges. 
 &bquo;They're trying to get out,&equo; Dot said. 
 &bquo;They can't.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who can't?&equo; 
 &bquo;Them birds up there. 
 They'll cut themselves.&equo; 
 &bquo;'Course they won't. 
 They like it up there, it's cosy for them. 
 That's their home, where they live.&equo; 
 &bquo;Let's go back,&equo; said Dot, tugging at Gloria's hand. 
 Crouching by the gas fire in the basement, staring into the redness of the flame until your cheeks burned and the shilling ran out, was safe. 
 Listening to noises outside, yet not being part of them was safe too. 
 Here was not safe. 
 &bquo;But we're going on a trip, lovie. 
 You'll like it when you get there, honest. 
 Come on, big smile now, give your face a joy-ride.&equo; 
 Dot tried to smile but it wouldn't come. 
 &bquo;I don't like it here,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;But we ain't even there yet. 
 It's only a railway station, pet,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;That's just the noise of the loudspeakers.&equo; 
 Dot knew about Underground stations. 
 Once or twice they'd had to sleep down there, though not often because Gloria said it wasn't nice to be all pressed up against people you didn't know. 
 And you might catch tuberculosis from their breath. 
 But Dot couldn't remember ever being in a place like this. 
 So high. 
 So noisy. 
 So much confused rushing about. 
 Dot knew that when grown-ups started scurrying purposefully, something bad was about to happen, specially if you hadn't heard the siren.  
 &bquo;'Course you have, pet,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;That time we came down from Winfarthing-Fersfield, after seeing your old man.&equo; 
 &bquo;Wasn't like this,&equo; said Dot. 
 She couldn't remember it at all. 
 She just knew that a basement room was for sitting in, a children's ward for visiting, and railway stations had been prime targets for being bombed. 
 She held more tightly to Gloria's hand. 
 &bquo;There's nothing to be frightened of, ducks. 
 Not when there's all these nice people about.&equo; 
 So long as they weren't too close and breathing their germs on her, Gloria liked there to be people about. 
 &bquo;And she's ever such a nice lady we're going to see.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who?&equo; 
 &bquo;I told you. 
 Mrs Hollidaye. 
 Where I used to live, when they evacuated me the first time.&equo; 
 Dot couldn't remember her. 
 &bquo;'Course you can't remember, you was hardly even born when we was there. 
 But you remember me telling you about it.&equo; 
 Dot shook her head. 
 &bquo;Her husband was a real gentleman, ever so brave. 
 I liked him. 
 But then he went and jumped out of a plane in France. 
 He hadn't never even done it before. 
 Got a medal for it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did he have his gas mask on?&equo; 
 &bquo;How should I know? 
 What kind of question is that?&equo; 
 Dot wondered why it was braver to jump out of a plane than to lose two fingers in a factory. 
 &bquo;Mr Brown must have been quite brave,&equo; she said. 
 Why hadn't he been given a medal? 
 &bquo;Who's Mr Brown?&equo; 
 &bquo;He didn't have to do it, did he?&equo; 
 &bquo;'Course not. 
 He done it because he wanted to. 
 He done it for his soldiers, to show them what they had to do. 
 He was their padre like. 
 Had a parachute on his back just like the rest, and holding out the holy cross in his hand. 
 But the Germans went and got him.&equo;  
 Dot wondered. 
 Perhaps it was dying that was the bravest thing a person could do? 
 So was Baby brave when he died? 
 Or could dying only be brave if you were shot at? 
 &bquo;Derek's brave, isn't he?&equo; she said. 
 But Gloria didn't hear, or anyhow didn't answer. 
 When Dot began to cry she wasn't sure if it was because of thinking about poor Mr Brown's two missing fingers or because she couldn't remember what her father's face looked like, or merely because of the alarming new orders about train departures cackling from the loudspeakers. 
 &bquo;I tell you what, pet, let's pop into the Buffet and get a nice cup of tea before the train goes. 
 How about that, then?&equo; 
 Dot liked sharing a cup of tea. 
 Gloria drank first, from the top where it was scalding hot. 
 Dot spooned up the bottom from where it was cool and milky.  
 A Trip on a Train 
 The compartment was fitted out with everything they would need to live there for ever. 
 It was like having a perfect home of their own. 
 They had their own windows with dark blue oil-cloth roller-blinds through which Dot could see into the compartment of the train alongside just like looking over at a next-door house. 
 Beneath the window was a useful fold-out table. 
 There were brass ashtrays, coat-hooks, a mirror where Gloria would be able to do her hair, an overhead net to store things. 
 The two rows of upholstered seats facing each other were like a pair of matching beds, one for each so they would not again need to share except when they wanted to. 
 &bquo;I like it here,&equo; said Dot, stretching out along her bed while Gloria took off her hat and placed it carefully on the luggage rack. 
 &bquo;It's comfy.&equo; 
 &bquo;We ain't there yet, pet. 
 We ain't even started.&equo; 
 Just as the train began to move, a soldier with a kit bag slung like a khaki corpse over his shoulder glanced into their compartment. 
 &bquo;Ooops-a-daisy,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;No smoker.&equo; 
 Gloria pretended not to notice him. 
 Usually she loved a good chat, specially with people from the services. 
 Overhead Dot noticed a row of shaded lamps each with its own switch. 
 Gloria would be able to read her Picturegoer  as late as she wanted without keeping Dot awake. 
 Between the lamps, just as in a proper home, was a pair of framed photographs. 
 Mrs Parvis had photographs in her parlour. 
 Hers hung on picture hooks. 
 These ones were screwed to the wall. 
 &bquo; Brighton and Hove Southern Railway &equo;,&equo; Gloria read out. 
  &bquo; The Royal Promenade, Eastbourne .&equo;&equo; 
 That's at the seaside. 
 I'll take you there. 
 One day. 
 Maybe. 
 Other one's Brighton. 
 I never been to Brighton. 
 Now sit still and stop hopping about, will you. 
 Anyone'd think you was a flea on the organ-grinder's monkey.&equo; 
 The windows were streaky like at the basement. 
 &bquo;We'd clean them windows,&equo; Dot said. 
 &bquo;If this was our home, wouldn't we?&equo; 
 First thing we'd do she thought, with a cloth and a big bucket of soapy water. 
 So they'd sparkle. 
 So you could see out any time you wanted. 
 Gloria closed the sliding door, pulled down the blinds, and switched off the six lamps which Dot had just put on. 
 &bquo;Can't see!&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;I need to look out my windows!&equo; 
 She lifted the bottom corner of one of the blinds. 
 &bquo;Oi, don't lean out or you'll get smuts in your eye! 
 You don't understand, it's better this way, love. 
 You will  behave proper when we get there, won't you? 
 You won't go letting me down. 
 Oh, I do hope you don't. 
 Look at your face! 
 You still got that hanky?&equo; 
 It was in Dot's pocket, still scrumpled up, still waiting for its rinse through. 
 Gloria wrapped a corner of it round her index finger, spat to make it wet, then dabbed at Dot's cheeks till they were sore. 
 &bquo;See, ducks, this Mrs Hollidaye what we're going to see, her clothes are that shabby, but she's like a real lady. 
 She has these pearls round her neck. 
 Wears them all the time, even when she's out digging. 
 So I really want you to be like a proper sort of little girl. 
 She's ever so posh, but she's ever so kind too. 
 I want her to think we're nice  people.&equo; 
 &bquo;You are  a nice person,&equo; said Dot, though she was beginning to feel unsure about it. 
 Nothing in the world was ever certain or fixed, things changed easily and when least expected. 
 She thought she'd found the perfect place to live, yet already it was slipping away and this cosy compartment was only a stage on to something else. 
 So who were the nice people? 
 Was the King a nice person and the princesses? 
 &bquo;'Course royalty is!&equo; said Gloria, shocked. 
 &bquo;Goes without  saying. 
 Now your socks.&equo; 
 She reached down to take off Dot's shoes, then her socks, one long, one not so long, one greyish white, the other a different kind of fawnish white. 
 She turned them inside out, returned them to Dot to put on with the insides now on the outside. 
 White socks never stayed clean. 
 It was all very well for the princesses. 
 There probably hadn't been much dust lying around in a palace. 
 &bquo;Grey socks are better,&equo; said Dot. 
 They didn't show scuff marks at all. 
 &bquo;See, I don't want Mrs Hollidaye to go thinking you're riff-raff. 
 I don't want her to go getting any wrong ideas about what's become of me.&equo; 
 The train was moving fast. 
 Gloria said, &bquo;Come over here now. 
 Lay in my lap. 
 Suck your thumb, there's a love.&equo; 
 Dot looked at it and was surprised to see how dirty it had become. 
 She inspected the fingers and thumb on her other hand. 
 These too had become smudged with dirt, and the velvet cuffs of her coat, and everything in the compartment was flecked with specks of greasy black which came off on to you the moment you touched them. 
 She wondered if this coat had ever been on a train before, when it had belonged to the other child. 
 &bquo;Yes, Please  do,&equo; said Gloria. 
 She pulled Dot onto her knee. 
 Being cradled against her mother's soft warm body, Dot tried to feel like a baby, to remember what she had seen through the crack in the double doors as Gloria had cradled Baby against her while the nurses gathered round with protective outstretched arms. 
 Sometimes Gloria was so strange. 
 First she wanted Dot to be nice, next she wanted her to put a filthy thumb in her mouth and suck it. 
 Obediently, Dot did as Gloria asked, gripping her thumb between her front teeth to prevent it slipping out. 
 &bquo;Where we going?&equo; 
 Dot asked, her thumb still lying firmly on her tongue like Gloria wanted it. 
 &bquo;And don't talk no more.&equo; 
 So Dot whispered it.  
 &bquo;Sssh. 
 You gotta be like my baby.&equo; 
 Dot sat bolt upright. 
 &bquo;I can't be your baby! 
 You said I was too big to be carried. 
 I don't want to be no baby! 
 I 
 &bquo;Please, ducky. 
 Be a baby for Mum. 
 Just on the train, till the man's been past. 
 See, I didn't have the money to get no ticket for you.&equo; 
 Gloria took from her bag a little blanket made of coloured squares that a long-ago lady in a shelter had knitted for Baby before he was born. 
 &bquo;Baby's blanket!&equo; said Dot in surprise. 
 &bquo;You brought it!&equo; 
 Gloria wrapped it gently around Dot's head and shoulders, pulling it well forward over her face. 
 &bquo;Now I can't even see,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;Just till after the bloke's been along. 
 I told you, I haven't got no ticket for you.&equo; 
 Although not exactly dark, nor scary because Gloria was holding her tenderly, it was stuffy under the blanket and irritating to be covered over when you wanted to look out. 
 Dot sucked away on her thumb. 
 &bquo;Can I come out yet?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, ssh. 
 He's just coming.&equo; 
 Dot heard the compartment door open. 
 A draught of cold air blew in. 
 Dot heard the man ask for Gloria's ticket, felt the movement as Gloria reached for her purse. 
 &bquo;Taking me little one down to the country to see her Nan,&equo; she heard Gloria say, then the click-clack of the ticket-clipper before the man closed the door and they were alone again. 
 Dot said, &bquo;Who's my Nan?&equo; 
 &bquo;Your Nan died years ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;But you said we're going to see my Nan.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, that. 
 That was to stop him asking nosy questions, like how old you was. 
 But it's all right. 
 I don't think he was that bothered. 
 You look small enough.&equo; 
 Dot pushed back the blanket, slid off Gloria's lap and moved back to sit by her window. 
 She lifted the bottom of the blind.  
 &bquo;That's right. 
 You take a peek. 
 That's the real countryside out there. 
 Ain't it lovely? 
 Full of animals and that.&equo; 
 &bquo;What kind of animals?&equo; 
 &bquo;Aw, I dunno,&equo; Gloria said vaguely. 
 &bquo;Cows and bulls. 
 That sort of thing.&equo; 
 The next-door train had been left far behind. 
 The houses had all gone too. 
 There was nothing out there now. 
 No walls, no roads, no buildings. 
 No red buses, no red letterboxes, no red telephone boxes. 
 No iron railings. 
 No pavements, no front doors, no streets, no nothing and it was growing dark as the black nothingness dashed past the window. 
 &bquo;I want to go back. 
 I changed my mind. 
 I don't like it no more.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do stop that crying!&equo; 
 Gloria snapped. 
 &bquo;It makes your eyes all red. 
 And now look at your face. 
 All messed up again after I just cleaned you up! 
 Take a look at it!&equo; 
 She held Dot up to the mirror and Dot saw the greyish rivulets where tears had run down her cheeks and been smudged to grey by her hands. 
 She wondered how clean tears could make a person's skin go dirty. 
 &bquo;I told you you'd got to try and keep yourself looking nice for Mrs Hollidaye,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;You wash clean and dry dirty, that's always been your trouble.&equo;  
 A Walk in the Night 
 &bquo;Wakey-wakey! 
 Come on, pet, you're holding up production!&equo; 
 Dot felt herself being nudged awake, saw Gloria seize their two paper carriers, and they scrambled off the train at a dark station in the countryside. 
 Then they started walking. 
 The track felt soft and slithery but in the dark she couldn't see what it was she was stepping on. 
 &bquo;Come on, pet. 
 Keep up. 
 Or I'll lose you.&equo; 
 There were traps to catch them along the way. 
 The heel of Gloria's peep-toe shoe caught in a hole. 
 Then the sleeve of Dot's coat was clawed at by a long briar. 
 Dot knew it was more dangerous than anything in London, even during blackout and raids. 
 Dot had heard often enough how careless talk costs lives, how even walls have ears. 
 &bquo;It's ever so dark round here,&equo; she whispered. 
 Somebody in the blackness around them was bound to be listening. 
 &bquo;You can say that again,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;You said it'd be nice .&equo; 
 &bquo;Well I was wrong, weren't I? 
 I must have forgot.&equo; 
 In London, the big plane tree stuck in the pavement outside Mrs Parvis's house had three white rings painted round its black trunk so people could see it even in the dark. 
 Here you couldn't tell if there were any obstacles in the way, and there were no pavements either. 
 Instead they were surrounded by ambiguous smells of unrecognizable growing things that had rotted and died, of living creatures that were scarcely human, hairy and fleshy. 
 There were unknown sounds of subhuman things proceeding relentlessly forward, stopping, retrenching, to proceed onward again.  
 Dot knew it must be tanks. 
 She had never seen a tank close to. 
 But she had seen them on the newsreel before the big film, creaking and groaning across the land, their great limbless, legless form crushing and grinding all that was in their way. 
 Gloria said, &bquo;That's never tanks. 
 That's trees making a noise. 
 Or maybe the hedges.&equo; 
 But now she was whispering too and Dot knew that she didn't know what was out there with them either. 
 Dot tried not to think of Hitler, nor of Dick Barton Special Agent, nor of the Fifth Columnists, nor of those giant nuns with rifles and huge booted feet beneath their long black skirts who were enemy soldiers in disguise. 
 Yet all the most unspeakably wicked men in the world, who caused havoc and lurked in dim places ready to pounce again, came surging into her mind. 
 Mrs Parvis said Hitler hadn't really taken the poison in his bunker. 
 She said that had been his double and he'd got away scot-free to come to live in the last country in the world where people would think of looking for him. 
 &bquo;Don't be silly, ducks, that's all over now.&equo; 
 People were always saying things were over. 
 But as Dot knew, it sometimes turned out they weren't. 
 And in a way one didn't want things to be over, for the uncertain future was more unsettling than the unexplained past. 
 Dot wished that the metal caps on Gloria's high-heels wouldn't make such a tapping as they walked. 
 She wondered what had been the use of all that trying to get clean on the train if they were now lost in a place where nobody would ever find them, not even when something happened and they disappeared for ever. 
 If only they'd stayed in the little home on the train. 
 If only they'd never left the basement with the empty meat-safe hanging outside the window. 
 She heard heavy breathing like panting. 
 It seemed to follow her like Hitler, Himmler, and the marching white faces of all the dead men. 
 &bquo;Just an animal, I expect,&equo; Gloria whispered. 
 &bquo;You get all  sorts. 
 That's what it's for the country. 
 They live in the fields.&equo; 
 &bquo;What are they doing?&equo; 
 &bquo;How should I know? 
 You'll be the death of me with all your questions.&equo; 
 &bquo;They'll have finished tea by now, won't they?&equo; 
 Dot said. 
 &bquo;Who?&equo; 
 &bquo;Back at Mrs Parvis's.&equo; 
 By now Dot would have had her dab with the damp corner of a towel at the sink on the landing. 
 She'd be tucked beneath the blanket and the heavy coat and watching Gloria put on her make-up before she went out. 
 Once in a while she went to a social club for air pilots who'd been in hospital. 
 She didn't take Dot. 
 &bquo;You wouldn't like it, pet. 
 Some of them don't look too good, not after they been burned like that, specially when it's their features what have gone. 
 That's worse than legs.&equo; 
 &bquo;Are we nearly there?&equo; 
 The thin string handles of the carrier bag cut deep into the palm of Dot's hand. 
 Gloria kissed it better and carried both bags. 
 When Dot began to stumble and fall over with tiredness, Gloria gathered her up and carried her too. 
 Clinging piggy-back to her mother's back, Dot felt the curtain of bunchy black net on the side of Gloria's hat flick at her face. 
 She felt the two paper carriers swinging where Gloria had put them over her wrists. 
 Dot's eyes were growing used to the dark just like they had to in the shelter when the warden's lamp went out. 
 Now Dot could see the shapes of trees beside the track, of fences, of a white gate. 
 There were no tanks, no Fifth Columnists disguised as Sisters of Charity. 
 They were going up a stony drive. 
 Gloria was walking faster, almost striding on her high heels as though she had finally refound her way. 
 &bquo;Here it is, then,&equo; said Gloria, setting Dot down. 
 &bquo;What's this, then? 
 Another blooming hospital?&equo; 
 She saw the dark looming bulk of a large building. 
 &bquo;'Course it's not.&equo;  
 &bquo;Looks like it. 
 It s got windows all over. 
 She didn't want to be left to stand alone in some dark night-time corridor. 
 &bquo;You got hospitals on the brain. 
 Come on, follow me. 
 Round the back.&equo; 
 Dot clutched tight to Gloria's coat as they made their way through the dark rustling leaves of some tall shrubs. 
 Across silent grass, showed the faint light from a downstairs window. 
 &bquo;That's her in her drawing-room,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;This way now. 
 Side door'll be open.&equo; 
 Gloria led them along a brick path, across a cobbled courtyard, past outhouses and a dripping water butt, then into the big house and along many passages. 
 Dot knew what was going to happen. 
 She was going to be left in the care of a woman she didn't know, just as she'd been left with them before. 
 &bquo;Only an hour,&equo; Gloria would say. 
 &bquo;She won't be no trouble to you. 
 She's ever so good. 
 Shan't be gone long.&equo; 
 And then the hour would turn into a long space of empty time, then into a whole evening, once even into an entire night before Gloria came back. 
 Now that they hadn't Baby to visit any more, all that was bound to start again. 
 Dot thought, I won't let her. 
 I'll stick with her. 
 I'm all she's got now. 
 Gloria knocked on a panelled door before pushing it open. 
 &bquo;Here we are, then, Mrs Hollidaye. 
 Dot and me, come to visit you,&equo; she said brightly. 
 &bquo;Come on, come in. 
 And who have we here?&equo; 
 &bquo;It's me, Gloria.&equo; 
 The large room was lit by a paraffin lamp on a table. 
 Two grey-haired ladies sat either side of a fire eating green soup from wide dishes on their knees. 
 The fire was burning large branches of wood, some still with twigs attached like fingers. 
 &bquo;Don't they have no gas?&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;Them's trees they're burning in there.&equo;  
 &bquo;Ssh,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Why, Gloria, my dear!&equo; said one of the ladies, putting aside her soup-dish and hurrying across the wide room to welcome them almost, but not quite, as though she had been expecting them. 
 &bquo;There, see, Dot,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;What did I say? 
 Told you she'd be pleased, didn't I?&equo; 
 &bquo;Why it's a delightful surprise! 
 We were only thinking of you the other week. 
 Weren't we, Lilian?&equo; 
 The other lady went on spooning up her soup and Dot noticed how frequently she missed her mouth. 
 She had a brow so low that her hair seemed to begin sprouting from just above her eyes which moved independently. 
 She appeared to be looking in two directions at once and Dot couldn't tell whether or not she was being stared at. 
 She remembered Hitler's eyes which Mrs Parvis had once said were hypnotic. 
 &bquo;Must have been, otherwise why would all them nice Germans have done all them wicked things what he told them?&equo; 
 Dot avoided the danger of the swivelling eyes in case they had the same compelling powers. 
 She looked down at the patterned rugs on the floor and edged in more closely behind Gloria, gripping her skirt. 
 &bquo;So this is your little Dorothy?&equo; 
 &bquo;That's right.&equo; 
 Gloria pushed Dot forward. 
 &bquo;This is her. 
 Large as life and twice as natural.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye bent down and held out her hand. 
 &bquo;Why, how do  you do, my dear,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Shake hands nicely,&equo; Gloria hissed in Dot's ear. 
 &bquo;Show her you're pleased to be here.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I ain't.&equo; 
 &bquo;My poor dears, come and warm yourselves by the fire. 
 You must be most awfully tired. 
 Why, Gloria my dear, you should have called from the station. 
 We could have harnessed up the goat-cart and come and fetched you. 
 At least the little girl could have ridden. 
 Never mind, the main thing is you're here now.&equo; 
 She pushed two dogs off an armchair.  
 &bquo;Come, darlings, make room for our visitors while I go and fetch them some supper.&equo; 
 Dot remembered how Mrs Parvis had said dogs were insanitary vermin and had no place in the war effort and the Chinese were quite right to eat them. 
 &bquo;I believe there's a little soup left. 
 Runner bean. 
 All our own. 
 We salted down simply pounds and pounds. 
 And Lilian, look sharp. 
 Help the little girl out of her coat. 
 Poor child, looks more dead than alive.&equo; 
 Dot felt herself freeze with fear as the swivel-eyed Lilian lurched towards her, arms outstretched, to try to remove her coat. 
 &bquo;Don't mind her,&equo; Gloria hissed in Dot's ear. 
 &bquo;She's just a bit mental. 
 Always has been. 
 Don't mean no harm.&equo; 
 Dot held her arms stiff as bayonets, for she knew it would be safer to keep her coat on, then they might not have to stay so long. 
 In the night, Dot heard the low thudding of explosions on the ground somewhere in the faraway distance and knew there must be a raid on. 
 She had a sinking feeling. 
 The grown-ups were wrong as usual. 
 The war had come back, just like she knew it would. 
 Yet she wasn't afraid and didn't even bother to open her eyes to find out if she would have to get up and run with Gloria for the shelters. 
 She couldn't remember where she was, nor why, yet for some reason which she didn't understand, she felt they were safe here.  
 A Morning in the Country 
 Dot was surprised to find herself wearing a large pink woollen nightgown with embroidered collar whose gathered sleeves were so long that her hands were lost. 
 Somebody must have undressed her the night before. 
 It couldn't have been Gloria, for Gloria knew that Dot always slept in her vest and knickers. 
 Dot was in a wide high bed with white sheets, two pillows, two blankets and an eiderdown. 
 Dot saw the curly mass of Gloria's dark hair lying on the pillow of a similar but separate bed alongside. 
 The room was like the train compartment again, their two matching beds, windows on two sides, blinds and  curtains, pictures on the walls, a mirror and a place to hang clothes, but everything bigger, and they weren't travelling, and there was more light in the room. 
 Blue light, and silver and bronze, streamed and bounced and danced through tall windows. 
 Across the gap between the beds, Dot whispered her mother's name. 
 &bquo;All present and correct,&equo; Gloria mumbled, then rolled back to sleep. 
 A soft animal noise like gargling Dot thought at first must be Gloria's breathing. 
 Then she saw that it was a grey bird like a station pigeon, yet not trapped beneath a glass roof but sitting freely outside amongst fluttering leaves. 
 In London colours were red and black. 
 Here Dot saw that green and blue were the colours of the outside world. 
 Green leaves festooned the window, green trees, green ground beyond, giving way to the blue. 
 Blue distant trees, blue faraway hedges, rounded blue hills of the horizon  millions of miles away. 
 Dot thought, if only noble eight-fingered Mr Brown could have this outside his window. 
 Better than a view of cardboard panes and the next-door privies. 
 There were toys in one corner of the big bedroom. 
 Whose toys? 
 Dot slid down from the high bed and sat on the carpet and looked at a wooden dolls' house, a painted rocking horse, but she didn't touch. 
 They weren't hers and she knew there was always a danger in wanting other peoples' things for oneself. 
 Like looters after a big raid who tried to steal the mangled possessions of shattered houses. 
 Like Hitler who wanted all the countries of the world for himself. 
 Even when the first owners were crushed and dead, their things were not for you. 
 Dot peered in through the tiny curtained windows of the dolls' house and saw quiet furnished rooms, the playroom, kitchen, parlour, waiting to be lived in, a table set for tea, beds to be slept in, armchairs to be sat on. 
 She hoped that the child to whom this home belonged would let her stay and watch him playing. 
 But a thump at the door made her scramble back up on to the bed for safety. 
 Gloria from under her covers, mumbled sleepily, &bquo;That's only Loopy Lil, pet. 
 Not to worry.&equo; 
 The lady with the upright hair who Gloria said had a screw loose, clattered into the bedroom holding out a steaming jug on a tray. 
 Dot thought it must be tea. 
 She'd have liked a nice cup of milky tea. 
 But they had no cups to drink from. 
 So she shook her head. 
 &bquo;No, thanks,&equo; she said. 
 But Gloria said, &bquo;That'll be the hot water, pet. 
 For washing yourself.&equo; 
 &bquo;We don't do that,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;Well, you do here.&equo; 
 Reluctantly, Dot slid down from the bed while Loopy Lil beamed kindly, eyes swivelling in all directions and tried to help wash Dot's face at the wash-stand and brush her hair. 
 &bquo;Don't usually,&equo; Dot muttered to Gloria. 
 &bquo;Thursdays. 
  That's our day.&equo; 
 Thursdays, half past five until six o'clock, was when they had the use of Mrs Parvis's bathroom and as much warm water as trickled from the gas geyser into the tub. 
 Usually enough for Gloria to shampoo her hair, for both of them to swish around in shallow tepid water, followed by their underclothes. 
 &bquo;Well you ain't at Mrs P's now, are you?&equo; said Gloria crossly. 
 &bquo;Washing hands, face, and behind your ears, that's what Mrs Hollidaye likes so you'll just do it. 
 Right?&equo; 
 She pummelled the two soft pillows into shape and lay down to sleep again. 
 &bquo;I'm keeping my coat on,&equo; said Dot. 
 A person felt safer if they kept their possessions close by them. 
 &bquo;And I won't stay,&equo; she added as Loopy Lil reached out to take her hand and lead her downstairs. 
 &bquo;Nobody says you got to stay. 
 But right now, you can just trot along and leave me a bit of peace to get some kip while I got the chance. 
 I tell you, it's no laugh sharing with a kid what kicks and turns in her sleep week after week.&equo; 
 Gloria rolled over, pulling the covers up to her head. 
 &bquo;I tell you, you ain't leaving me here!&equo; 
 Dot shouted at the hump in the pink satin eiderdown. 
 &bquo;And I ain't leaving you neither!&equo; 
 &bquo;Nobody's leaving nobody,&equo; said Gloria from under the covers. 
 &bquo;You dig in and fill your boots while you can. 
 And you don't forget to mind your blooming manners while you're at it.&equo; 
 So Dot kept her coat on at breakfast-time but Mrs Hollidaye didn't seem to mind. 
 She was busy stirring the porridge over an open wood range. 
 &bquo;Ah, Dorothy, my dear,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;I hope you've a good country appetite. 
 What do you like best of all for your breakfast?&equo; 
 Dot had no idea. 
 At Mrs Parvis's you didn't choose. 
 It was always the same &mdash; bread and dripping or, when the bread was very old, blackish toast and dripping. 
 Mrs Hollidaye said, &bquo;Today, Miss Lilian is starting off with porridge and honey, aren't you, my dear?&equo;  
 On the table was a vase of flowers, a square honeycomb oozing liquid honey from its wax holes onto the dish, three jars of jam, each one a different colour of dark red, and a jug with a muslin cloth over the top. 
 The cloth was sewn with coloured glass beads round the edge. 
 &bquo;That's to stop the flies falling into the milk,&equo; Mrs Hollidaye explained. 
 Loopy Lil grinned and Dot saw she didn't understand much of anything that other people said. 
 &bquo;Miss Lilian has an appetite fit for the good trooper that she is. 
 Lilian, as you can see, was not gifted by our dear Lord, with either beauty or brains, but with a willing heart. 
 Weren't you, Lilian?&equo; 
 Loopy Lil beamed with pleasure but said nothing as she watched Mrs Hollidaye fill her bowl to the brim. 
 Dot said, &bquo;In London, where I live, we don't have flies.&equo; 
 She was going to explain, too, how the milk came in glass bottles on a cart pulled by a brown horse, and how sometimes the horse left steaming heaps of brown, oval-shaped droppings in the road which people ran out to scoop up with coal shovels and take for their vegetable plots. 
 But she remembered in time that Gloria had warned her to mind her P's and Q's, so she said nothing. 
 &bquo;And Lilian is my right-hand man. 
 I don't know what we'd have done without her in those dark years. 
 Always here to keep up our spirits, weren't you, my dear? 
 She came with the rest of the evacuees, didn't you, Lilian? 
 Will you try a little porridge with some honey, Dorothy, my dear? 
 It's from our own bees. 
 Some people say you can actually taste the clover in it. 
 Or cream? 
 They're not really allowed to make it down at the farm. 
 Agricultural emergency committee still haven't lifted the ban. 
 But this little bit they don't know about. 
 Your mother was among the first batch of evacuees, too, like Lilian. 
 But she just couldn't take to it. 
 Village life is rather different from London. 
 Newly wed she was and pretty as a picture.&equo; 
 Lil swirled her eyes across the table before tucking in. 
 &bquo;And you mustn't mind if I take mine standing up, and  with a pinch of salt. 
 Because of my Scottish blood. 
 Then I can keep an eye on the eggs.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye was unlike Mrs Parvis or any of the other people Dot had been left with. 
 Although sometimes Mrs Parvis talked about  Dot, she rarely spoke to  her, except to scold or reprimand, whereas Mrs Hollidaye went on talking cheerfully to Loopy Lil and to Dot even though neither replied. 
 &bquo;Or if you don't care for the porridge, there's some of these new Post Toasties . 
 Such a nice young American brought them for us. 
 Though I'm afraid Miss Lilian and 1 didn't think a lot of them, did we, Lilian? 
 But do try them if you'd like. 
 It says they don't need any cooking but I rather wonder. 
 Perhaps with a little fruit?&equo; 
 She passed a dish of scarlet berries in scarlet juice to Dot. 
 &bquo;Only bottled. 
 The fresh ones are long since gone. 
 But they're from the garden and they really are rather good. 
 And then when all the others went,&equo; Mrs Hollidaye carried on talking as she removed Loopy Lil's empty porridge bowl and replaced it with a plate piled high with toast, &bquo;Lilian was the only one who stayed. 
 You were from the institution weren't you? 
 For people of diminished responsibility. 
 They tried to put some of them into the Land Army, but Lilian wasn't quite up to it, were you, my dear?&equo; 
 Dot wondered what an institution was. 
 She said, &bquo;Up London, we have the national orange juice on a teaspoon.&equo; 
 She didn't mention the cod liver oil. 
 &bquo;So how would you like your egg, my dear? 
 Boiled, poached, scrambled. 
 Lilian's having hers soft-boiled today, aren't you, dear? 
 The hens have been doing frightfully well. 
 I rather think they must have known you were coming. 
 I don't suppose you have many eggs.&equo; 
 Loopy Lil's cooked egg sat, still in its shell, in a small china cup with a spoon lying beside it. 
 Dot had not seen an egg served up like that before. 
 &bquo;Up London,&equo; she said, &bquo;we get eggs all the time. 
 But we do them different.&equo; 
 Dot wasn't allowed into Mrs Parvis's kitchen except at the regulation meal-times and she wasn't sure about how  food was prepared, but she was pretty certain that when Mrs Parvis cooked what was called a nice egg-dish, it was made from an orange coloured powder spooned up from a deep cylindrical tin. 
 Dot wondered how Loopy Lil was going to eat this kind of egg. 
 &bquo;Hit him!&equo; 
 Loopy Lil cried suddenly, attacking the brown rounded shell with the tiny Spoon. 
 Dot was surprised. 
 It was the first time she'd heard her speak. 
 &bquo;She used to pretend her egg was Adolf Hitler,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;Specially when we had those dreadful incendiary bombs dropping on the roof. 
 It made Lilian feel a lot better in the morning, didn't it, dear?&equo; 
 &bquo;Hit him, hit him!&equo; 
 Loopy Lil repeated till the top of her egg was open and yellow yolk pouring down the side. 
 Dot was pleased. 
 Next time she had a nightmare, she would try imagining smashing, like eggs, the faceless looters and killers of her dreams. 
 &bquo;Maybe you could manage a little bit of bread and butter?&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye, cutting and spreading a small slice. 
 But Dot couldn't. 
 &bquo;Lovely fresh butter from the herd down at Mrs Elphinstone's. 
 We'll walk over later, shall we, and catch a look at the milking? 
 Can you taste the clover in it? 
 And a nice little bit of our plum jam? 
 We managed to get some sugar last month, didn't we, Lilian?&equo; 
 Loopy Lil smiled and nodded. 
 Loopy Lil, even if she was mental, seemed a good safe person to be near. 
 &bquo;Though do watch out for the stones, won't you, my dear? 
 They're rather dangerous if swallowed. 
 And you don't want a plum tree growing up inside you, do you now?&equo; 
 There were some things about the country that were difficult to get used to. 
 Flies in the milk, clover in the butter, stones in the jam. 
 Why should people in the country have these in their food? 
 Perhaps it was for the same reason that Mrs Parvis, so Gloria claimed, put crushed up egg-shells into powdered  egg so that the lodgers would think they were eating something which they weren't. 
 &bquo;Never mind, my dear,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;It takes time to build a country appetite. 
 But we'll see if we can't lend you one before too long.&equo; 
 Gloria had told Dot she was to fill her boots. 
 Here was all this food on the table and Dot unable to swallow it down. 
 She didn't want Gloria to be angry. 
 &bquo;Up London, where I live,&equo; she said, &bquo;we have bananas.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why, do you now. 
 Fancy that!&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 Dot didn't know what a banana tasted like, though she'd heard Mrs Parvis talk about them often enough. 
 &bquo;D'you know, my dear,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;Down here we haven't set eyes on a banana for years! 
 I must say I've almost forgotten what they look like. 
 Though my son, that's my eldest, in the Royal Navy, wrote that he has them in the Pacific.&equo; 
 &bquo;Up London,&equo; said Dot, &bquo;we have them any time. 
 Ain't even on ration coupons. 
 Bananas is so cheap, Mrs Parvis says, they're giving them away with a pound of tea.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why, isn't that splendid of them!&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye.  
 Country Appetites 
 Halfway through the morning, once the hens had been fed, and the tomatoes in the greenhouse watered, it was time for another meal. 
 Mrs Hollidaye called it elevenses. 
 Dot sat in her coat at the kitchen table and watched Mrs Hollidaye heaping thick slices of bread spread with yellow butter on to a plate while Loopy Lil set out pretty teacups Patterned with roses on to matching saucers. 
 &bquo;You get ever such a lot of meals out here, don't you?&equo; 
 Dot said. 
 &bquo;Up London, we don't do this one.&equo; 
 All things were done differently in London. 
 &bquo;Up London,&equo; Dot explained, &bquo;we waits for our High Tea what Mrs Parvis makes till evening when the real people get back from their work. 
 And Mr Brown has to have his straight off, no hanging about, because he wants to be an engineer, so he goes to night school. 
 Mrs Parvis says he'll never make it. 
 I know he will. 
 He's ever so nice.&equo; 
 On the dresser, Dot noticed a framed picture of a man in uniform. 
 It was a black and white photograph which had been partially tinted with pastel colours so that though the young man's face was paper-white, his eyes were sky-blue and his medal ribbons bright as a rainbow. 
 Dot said, &bquo;Your husband was ever so brave, weren't he? 
 That's what Gloria says. 
 That him, up there?&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you know, it almost could be? 
 Actually, that's another of my sons. 
 In the Merchant Navy. 
 Though people do say he's very like my husband.&equo; 
 &bquo;Has he had it too, your boy there?&equo; 
 &bquo;Not as far as I know, my dear. 
 Though I must admit, we'll be glad when it's all over in the Far East and they can come back safe and sound.&equo;  
 So it wasn't over yet. 
 Dot had been right all along and Mrs Parvis wrong when she'd insisted that it was all over bar the shouting. 
 &bquo;Is he brave too?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well there's so many different and wonderful ways of being brave, aren't there, my dear? 
 That's the admirable way our good Lord arranged it, didn't he? 
 So that everybody can have a stab at it. 
 Even Miss Lilian has shown great fortitude in her own way.&equo; 
 Loopy Lil was arranging and rearranging the teacups on their matching saucers. 
 &bquo;And your mother too is a most courageous young woman, isn't she? 
 The way she's carried on.&equo; 
 Dot wished she knew what it felt like to be brave, and wondered if she'd ever get the chance to find out. 
 She wondered if eating when you didn't feel hungry was brave. 
 She wondered if her father was brave. 
 Was he a secret hero and was that why Gloria never talked about him? 
 She said, &bquo;I think maybe my old man had a stab at it.&equo; 
 The pale young sailor in the silver frame stared serenely out across the wide spaces of the kitchen with faraway forget-me-not eyes. 
 Dot tried to remember her father's face from the brownish photo which Gloria kept in her handbag. 
 She wished she could recall it more clearly. 
 Even when she had the picture in front of her, she seemed only to see the flat bloodless paper. 
 She wished her father was like this young man who sat in his own shrine on a country kitchen dresser amongst used OHMS envelopes and sprigs of dried white heather. 
 She said, &bquo;We don't ever talk about my old man. 
 But I think he liked bananas.&equo; 
 A group of men and women came in to share the meal called elevenses. 
 They had muddy boots which they kicked against the kitchen step, and muddy hands which they washed at the sink. 
 One wore a sack round his shoulders like a shawl, another had it round her waist as an apron. 
 They didn't sit but stood around the table. 
 The china teacups seemed too dainty in their dark working hands. 
 There  wasn't much talking between them, apart from pleases and thankyous when Dot heard how two of them spoke awkwardly with unfluent foreign accents. 
 The huge kitchen suddenly seemed too crowded. 
 Dot felt the room lurch away, while the milk jug with its bead-decorated muslin cover, the fly-paper dangling from the lamp above the table, the rosy faces of the gathered people flew round through the air. 
 Dot knew from their voices that those two young men who'd been working in the fields must be prisoners. 
 &bquo;You all right, my dear?&equo; she heard Mrs Hollidaye say. 
 Them's Germans, Dot wanted to say but the words wouldn't come out. 
 &bquo;She's too hot, poor little scrap, in that tight coat,&equo; said the woman in the sacking apron. 
 Loopy Lil clucked anxiously around like a pigeon. 
 Mrs Hollidaye led Dot outside. 
 &bquo;Of course it's not your coat. 
 You keep your coat on if you want to. 
 It's eating. 
 That's the trouble. 
 We've got all the wrong food for you and you're just not used to it, are you? 
 But I dare say you like apples. 
 Come along, we'll go and find the very nicest apple there is for you.&equo; 
 &bquo;I ain't never met a German before,&equo; Dot said. 
 &bquo;Not close to.&equo; 
 &bquo;Poor boys. 
 Little more than children when they first arrived. 
 They're just yearning to be home.&equo; 
 This wasn't how Mrs Parvis used to speak of the enemy. 
 &bquo;One of them plays the piano most beautifully. 
 They used to let him up here to practise from time to time.&equo; 
 The apple room was dim and scented with a mysterious sweetness like the breakfast honey. 
 Apples of many shades of yellow and red, brown and gold were laid out on yellowed newspaper, line after line, row upon row, on broad slatted shelves. 
 &bquo;Don't they give such a lovely smell!&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;They seem to get better and better.&equo; 
 She picked over the nearest of the apples, taking out three which had small brown marks.  
 &bquo;Those'll do nicely for the compost,&equo; she said, then chose a dark gold one for Dot. 
 &bquo;We call this one a Russet. 
 Have a try. 
 They do seem to be lasting awfully well. 
 Even better this year than last, though maybe that's just an illusion. 
 For I heard such  an interesting talk on the wireless. 
 It seems we're all losing our taste for sweet things because of the shortages. 
 What do you think?&equo; 
 Dot bit through the taut and burnished skin of the apple into juicy flesh. 
 The crunchy texture was like a raw potato she had once stolen from Mrs Parvis's vegetable rack. 
 But the taste was refreshingly sweet. 
 She wondered if this might be anything like the bananas that Mrs Parvis said were so exceptional. 
 But when she swallowed, the first mouthful of crisp apple hurt her throat so much she almost cried. 
 Mrs Hollidaye had already warned about plum trees growing inside you. 
 Could the same thing happen with a single bite from an apple?  
 St Michael and the Angels 
 Mrs Hollidaye said, &bquo;Would you like to come with me, Dorothy, to help with the flowers?&equo; 
 What did she mean by that? 
 Flowers didn't need helping. 
 They just were. 
 &bquo;For a little run in the Ford.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dunno about that,&equo; said Dot. 
 She was used enough to being left behind while Gloria went off, but it seemed more dangerous to do it the other way around, for her to leave Gloria behind. 
 &bquo;Sleep,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;That's the best thing for her.&equo; 
 Dot clutched at the cuffs of her coat but even the familiar softness of worn velvet was not reassuring. 
 &bquo;Dunno if I'm allowed. 
 See, we don't go about in cars, not up London.&equo; 
 Then in case she had given an impression that London was not as good as here, she added, &bquo;But there's plenty of cabs.&equo; 
 She couldn't remember having actually been in one and anyway, they rarely came Past Mrs Parvis's lodgings. 
 &bquo;Buses too. 
 We have lots of buses up London. 
 And Shanks's pony. 
 &bquo;It isn't far, just down to the village and back. 
 I have to take Mrs Squirrel. 
 For her legs. 
 Nurse Willow, that's our district nurse, lovely lady, member of our Mother's Union, holds surgery in the village hall. 
 We have a special petrol allowance for that. 
 It's not unlike a Red Cross run. 
 So I always take my flowers for the altar at the same time. 
 And pick up the groceries. 
 Saves Mr Bob making the trip with the cart.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I ain't leaving her behind all on her own,&equo; said Dot.  
 &bquo;You got to understand, if anything went wrong, then my name's mud.&equo; 
 &bquo;We shan't be gone long. 
 And Miss Lilian will be here to take her a nice little something on a tray if she wakes before we're back. 
 Won't you, Lilian?&equo; 
 Loopy Lil clattered at the sink in the back scullery. 
 &bquo;Oh, heck. 
 Might as well.&equo; 
 &bquo;Splendid, my dear. 
 Then you hop in the back to keep the dogs company for me.&equo; 
 It was more exciting and comfortable to travel in the back of a Ford car than on any part of a bus, even top front. 
 Dot sat with the yapping dogs on either side licking at her hands. 
 The basket of flowers was on the shelf behind them. 
 Not made of coloured cr&ecirc;pe paper, faded, dusty and crinkled on bent wire stems like Mrs Parvis had in her parlour. 
 But alive and dark and greenish, fragile and fragrant, dew on the petals and the crushed stems dripping with sap. 
 &bquo;Those long ones have a lovely scent, don't they?&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye over her shoulder. 
 &bquo;I'm not sure if the purple ones are my favourite, or the more blue colour.&equo; 
 She drove to a cottage where she helped an old woman bent in half like a crooked stump into the front passenger seat. 
 Dot tried to imagine that the two women in front were her footmen and she was one of the royal princesses, preferably Margaret because she wouldn't have to be queen which would be quite a responsibility if you thought about it, going for a drive in a carriage with her regal dogs and her regal flowers. 
 Then she realized she didn't have to pretend to be anyone going anywhere when she already was herself going for a real drive in a car with two dogs beside her and fresh flowers behind. 
 It wasn't far. 
 The bent lady with the bad legs was helped out. 
 Mrs Hollidaye parked beside a stone cross, under which lay a brown dog sleeping. 
 Mrs Hollidaye adjusted her hat-pin, gathered up the flowers and took Dot's hand firmly in hers. 
 She paused by the brown dog on the ground.  
 &bquo;Why, here's Mr Honeysett's old Bess,&equo; she said, bending down to stroke the dog's muzzle. 
 Dot thought how strange it was to be able to recognize a person's dog even when the person wasn't there, and then to know the dog's name. 
 It wasn't like that in London. 
 People didn't even know most other people's names let alone their dogs'. 
 In fact, Dot wasn't at all sure if the dogs in London had names. 
 Dogs' names wasn't something Mrs Parvis had yet spoken about. 
 &bquo;Dear old thing. 
 She must be thirteen at least. 
 That's about eighty in dog years.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye's dogs were left inside the car bobbing up at the rear window. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid their noses are a little out of joint,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;Never mind. 
 They'll just have to learn.&equo; 
 The old dog on the ground yawned and seemed almost to smile at them. 
 &bquo;Up London,&equo; said Dot, &bquo;we don't have dogs so much.&equo; 
 She wished they did. 
 It would be good to be greeted as you walked along by smiling creatures lying along the pavements. 
 It would give Mr Brown a surprise when he went to night school. 
 In the village shop, Mrs Hollidaye introduced Dot to the man in a brown overall who stood behind the wooden counter. 
 &bquo;Good morning, Mr Bob,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;This is a young friend, Dorothy. 
 She's come to visit us from London.&equo; 
 &bquo;From London!&equo; said the grocer. 
 He made it seem important and Special. 
 &bquo;Well, just fancy that. 
 She must have seen a few sights in her time.&equo; 
 A lady in a black straw hat, who was being weighed out a Pound of grits by the grocer's assistant, overheard. 
 &bquo;A tiny child from London!&equo; she repeated. 
 &bquo;Why, the poor creature! 
 Oh, you little angel!&equo; 
 She darted over to embrace Dot so tightly that she couldn't breathe. 
 Dot had never been hugged by a stranger. 
 Mrs Parvis gave no sign of being interested in her, let alone liking her enough to want to touch her.  
 &bquo;What can  we give the little child?&equo; said the lady. 
 &bquo;Just think what she must have been through! 
 If only there were a little chocolate bar we could give her. 
 Do you remember those peppermint creams we used to be able to get? 
 Mr Bob, you must have something  under the counter?&equo; 
 &bquo;What Dorothy needs is a breath or two of good fresh air,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye sharply. 
 &bquo;And that's exactly what we can give her. 
 To put a few roses back in her cheeks.&equo; 
 &bquo;The little lamb,&equo; said the lady. 
 After the shop, Mrs Hollidaye took Dot down a shady footpath, moist with ferns and ivy, heavy hedge-tops meeting overhead. 
 At the end, in sunlight, was a large building with high windows and a big main door. 
 Mrs Hollidaye put her flowers in a tin bucket of water in the porch where other bunches of flowers were being collected. 
 &bquo;Is it a hospital?&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;We had the flowers where my baby was.&equo; 
 &bquo;St Michael and All Angels, dear,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;It's our parish church. 
 Though I dare say, long long ago, sick people probably came here to seek a cure.&equo; 
 Dot liked the sound of the name, Michael. 
 She wished that Baby had been a Michael. 
 And all angels. 
 &bquo;At Baby's hospital, you could buy a bunch from the flower-lady near the gate. 
 People took them in for them other people what was sick but we didn't never have no dosh.&equo; 
 Dot wanted to Point out that Baby had died anyway but remembered Gloria's warning to mind her P's and Q's. 
 Inside St Michael and All Angels, women were arranging the flowers in golden tubs. 
 There were tall gleaming candlesticks, a glittering cross so bright it seemed to burn, and an enormous golden eagle with hooked beak and shiny dangerous eye. 
 &bquo;Gold!&equo; whispered Dot. 
 &bquo;I ain't never seen so much real gold before! 
 Bet they ain't got this much even up the palace.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, not gold. 
 Brass. 
 But it's all awfully nicely polished,  isn't it? 
 Mrs Buss and Mrs Cheese, that's our two brass ladies, come in and see to it on Fridays. 
 Provided they can get hold of the Brasso. 
 We'll say a little prayer for your baby, shall we?&equo; 
 Dot didn't know. 
 So she grinned vaguely in a way that could have meant yes or could have meant no. 
 &bquo;He died and all,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Yes, my dear, that's why I thought it would be nice to say a little prayer, to remind our dear Lord to take care of him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Them nurses took care of him,&equo; said Dot. 
 But perhaps they hadn't cared enough? 
 Perhaps our dear Lord would have a better chance. 
 &bquo;Anyway, I think it was a bit our fault, like. 
 See, we used to visit him every day. 
 But then there was that day she gave me the brooch what she said I wasn't never to forget. 
 And we didn't go to see him. 
 That's what done for him.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nonsense, my dear, that's just superstition. 
 He died of pneumonia. 
 There was nothing anyone could have done.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye took off her leather gloves and laid them neatly on top of her handbag on the pew beside her, straightened her hat and unhooked a cushion which hung from a brass hook beneath the shelf. 
 The cushion was embroidered with a pattern of golden keys. 
 She knelt down on the cushion, placed her ungloved hands together, closed her eyes and appeared to be either thinking or sleeping in an upright kneeling position. 
 Dot decided she had better copy Mrs Hollidaye. 
 She found a similar cushion hanging in front of her place, sewn in neat wool stitches. 
 Hers had an embroidered picture of a lamb standing in a field of flowers with yellow light sprouting out from around its head. 
 The lamb had a nice expression rather like a kitten's. 
 Dot didn't want to hurt its face so she placed her knees carefully to one side of the lamb so that they pressed into the sewn field of flowers on the edge. 
 Dot closed her eyes. 
 She could see nothing except a vivid scarlet blur, the colour of a London bus. 
 So she thought  about Baby, not sad thoughts but ordinary ones. 
 She remembered him propped up by the nurses, waving his little hands about. 
 That was before he became too ill even to be propped. 
 She remembered one time when a nurse had beckoned Dot into a side room, pulled over a metal chair for Dot, and brought the bundle to her wrapped in a bulky scratchy blanket. 
 She had laid him in Dot's arms and let her hold him on her own. 
 Even though he was small, he'd felt heavy. 
 He had seemed to be sleeping, yet even in sleep his closed eyelids quivered and his tiny fists were half-clenched. 
 When he woke he gazed up at Dot almost as though he knew her, yet she couldn't be sure if he really saw her, for his eyes had a distant faraway look like a sailor in the Navy staring across the Pacific seas. 
 After that, the other nurses always made her wait in the corridor. 
 Perhaps they'd known all along what was going to happen to him. 
 Perhaps they hadn't wanted her to see. 
 Dot Opened her eyes to glance sideways at Mrs Hollidaye but she was still in the same position, kneeling, so Dot lowered her lids and, though she hadn't meant to she found herself thinking about Gloria, still asleep in that high bed with the soft eiderdown. 
 Poor Gloria who hadn't had breakfast. 
 No cooked egg inside its shell and served on a plate patterned with a picture of cauliflowers, no rich fruit lying in sweet juice, no butter, no bread, no yellow cream. 
 And no coming to this gold place to see the green and multi-coloured flowers. 
 When Mrs Hollidaye had finished her praying and they were leaving the church, she stopped at the back and showed Dot a book with writing in it. 
 &bquo;It's very sad when a baby dies,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;But at least when they are so very young, they have no chance to sin and bring more wickedness into this world. 
 Well, that's how I comforted myself. 
 We could put your little brother's name in here. 
 It's our parish record of who is specially in need of prayer each week. 
 The sick and the departed. 
 What was his name?&equo;  
 Dot found to her surprise that, just as she often could no longer remember what her father's face looked like, now she couldn't remember Baby's name. 
 How could it go so quickly? 
 She said, &bquo;He didn't have no name. 
 He did have something official because the nurses, like, said he had to. 
 That's the law, they said. 
 But me Mum weren't there, so them nurses had to invent it themselves. 
 Anything they could think of.&equo; 
 &bquo;I expect they wanted to make sure he was baptized,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;Me and Gloria, we always called him Baby.&equo; 
 &bquo;Baby&equo;&equo;. 
 That's lovely.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye handed the pen to Dot. 
 &bquo;Would you like to write it?&equo; 
 She pointed to the place on the open page of the book. 
 Dot thought it was the loveliest book she'd ever seen. 
 Around the edge of each page, was a pattern of angels' heads with blue wings. 
 St Michael and All Angels. 
 It would have been nice if Baby's name could have been Michael. 
 Dot shook her head. 
 &bquo;Can't do writing,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Very well. 
 I'll do it.&equo; 
 &bquo;Can you write his name &bquo;Michael&equo; as well as &bquo;Baby&equo;. 
 I just remembered. 
 I think that was his name what the nurses give him.&equo; 
 She knew that writing his name was never going to get him back, even if they wrote it hundreds of times in the most beautiful book in the world. 
 But she liked Mrs Hollidaye. 
 She didn't want to upset her. 
 &bquo;So me and Gloria, we won't be seeing Baby no more,&equo; Dot said firmly. 
 &bquo;That's right, my dear. 
 He's in heaven now. 
 Quite safe for always. 
 Better than being sad and sick.&equo; 
 &bquo;He weren't sad,&equo; Dot said, though she liked the sound of &bquo;quite safe for always&equo;. 
 She'd have liked that for herself and Gloria. 
 It sounded better than burning in those fires of hell that Mrs Parvis once mentioned. 
 &bquo;We had better be on our way to pick up Mrs Squirrel now.&equo; 
 On their way across the churchyard Mrs Hollidaye  pointed down to something on the ground. 
 &bquo;That's my baby, there,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Oh, yes, I had some fine sons. 
 But this one was my little girl. 
 She lived six hours. 
 Such a fleeting while.&equo; 
 Dot looked down and saw only the tussocky grass and a flat square stone. 
 &bquo;There's writing on it,&equo; she said, touching the letters carved in the stone. 
 &bquo;What's it say?&equo; 
 &bquo;Rose Davenport Hollidaye. 
 Underneath it says when she was born. 
 And then, Gone to be with Jesus .&equo; 
 &bquo;Rose,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;That's nice. 
 Like a flower. 
 Gloria give me my name like one of them stars. 
 My Mum lives for the films. 
 Dorothy Lamour. 
 She been writ up in all the cinemas. 
 But I ain't writ up nowhere. 
 It's good having it writ up like that. 
 Then you can't forget. 
 Our Baby ain't got one of these. 
 Wish he had though. 
 See, where we live up London, there ain't no grass or garden places you could do this.&equo; 
 &bquo;They have graveyards in London too. 
 People have to be buried in consecrated ground.&equo; 
 &bquo;Don't think so,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;Not round about where we live.&equo; 
 She knew where London people were buried. 
 Under rubble in bomb-sites and they didn't get any nice flat stone with writing either. 
 They just got a wooden notice saying LOOTERS WILL BE SHOT.  
 The End of an Afternoon 
 At lunchtime Dot's ears began hurting inside her head as though they were filling with hot fire. 
 She found she still couldn't eat. 
 Mrs Hollidaye didn't force her. 
 Dot wondered about the apple tree growing from a pip. 
 Perhaps it was the branches that were spiking inside her ears, grating against the back of her throat? 
 Afterwards, while Loopy Lil cleared the meal, Mrs Hollidaye put on her galoshes and took Dot round the walled kitchen garden. 
 &bquo;To show you something my dear, very Special. 
 And well worth the waiting for. 
 Till you're really hungry.&equo; 
 She bent down to lift a domed glass lid lying on a heap of earth. 
 Green leaves and curling tendrils were escaping under the edge of the dome like curly hair from beneath a helmet. 
 &bquo;Take a peek under the cloche, my dear. 
 And you'll see my babies.&equo; 
 Snuggled in the mass of leaves lay five growing objects, round and green, streaked with yellow. 
 And there was that strange smell again which Dot recognized from the darkness of the night before of things dying and rotting and growing again. 
 Now, in daylight, she knew it was not something to fear. 
 &bquo;There's my little dears,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye, speaking to the fruits. 
 &bquo;Melons. 
 And coming along nicely. 
 Just like children. 
 All they need is a warm corner, a nice bit of sun, careful feeding &mdash; that's splendid pig manure we put in &mdash; and plenty of interest. 
 Then they grow and grow. 
 Ooh, they are  going to be such a treat! 
 So long as the frost doesn't get to them first. 
 Or the mice. 
 If the frost comes early, I'll just  have to bring them into the airing cupboard won't I?&equo; 
 Dot wondered what melon tasted like. 
 It looked so green and hard. 
 &bquo;Sweet and juicy when they're at perfection. 
 The nearest taste to heaven, I'd say,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;Though perhaps not quite as good as the banana.&equo; 
 Dot wished she'd never made that claim about eating bananas. 
 &bquo;D'you know, the first time I tasted melon wasn't till I was well over twenty? 
 A long time ago. 
 I went on a tour with my sisters to see the frescoes in Florence. 
 At our pensione , they gave us melon every day! 
 A whole one each with the top cut off. 
 And what a lovely time that was. 
 With all those beautiful paintings to see. 
 Italy's a really wonderful country, I wonder if I'll ever get a chance to go back. 
 &bquo;Italy!&equo; said Dot with surprise. 
 &bquo;But them's enemy!&equo; 
 Perhaps down here in the countryside the people hadn't ever known who the enemy was. 
 Perhaps they didn't know that several of the wickedest men had escaped from Germany and were even now pretending to be other people. 
 Yet in spite of her unusual ideas about Germans and other foreigners, Dot felt that Mrs Hollidaye was a reliable person. 
 You could talk to her knowing she wouldn't twist what you said like Mrs Parvis, nor fail to understand what you meant like Gloria. 
 Dot said, &bquo;There was a raid in the night, weren't there?&equo; 
 &bquo;A raid ? 
 Last night?&equo; 
 &bquo;I heard it. 
 Exploding and that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, that! 
 Why, you Poor dear!&equo; 
 &bquo;I woke up. 
 There weren't no siren. 
 But I heard explodings and that. 
 I knew it'd all started up again.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, it was the men clearing the marshes. 
 To make it safe. 
 Though goodness knows why they think they have to do it so early in the morning. 
 Oh, dear, I should've warned you, so you wouldn't be alarmed.&equo; 
 &bquo;I weren't afraid.&equo; 
 &bquo;Sound does travel a long way, doesn't it? 
 It must be  seven miles off. 
 It's these unexploded shells, quite a number littered about and we haven't been allowed down there for so long, it's all barbed wire, I believe. 
 There used to be such wonderful blackberries! 
 Maybe they'll finish soon and we can go blackberrying. 
 It would  be fun, wouldn't it, with a picnic?&equo; 
 There were so many new things, blackberrying, tasting melon, a picnic, all waiting to be done. 
 And Baby was never going to get to know about any of them. 
 &bquo;The planes used to drop them off over the marshes.&equo; 
 Dot realized she meant the bombs not the blackberries. 
 &bquo;Sometimes on their way in to London. 
 Sometimes on their way back. 
 People said it was because they weren't any good at finding their way. 
 That's rubbish of course. 
 They had maps. 
 And the Germans have always been excellent at map-reading. 
 No, I believe those nice young men up there did it on purpose. 
 They didn't want  to go and kill a lot of people they didn't know. 
 So they looked for somewhere else. 
 Like our marshes. 
 Though I do believe a cow once was maimed. 
 Anyway, the farmer claimed the war damage. 
 And a woman died. 
 Though that wasn't a bomb. 
 Drowned herself in a dyke, poor soul. 
 Unhinged in her mind when her fianc&eacute; went down with the Wessex , poor dear.&equo; 
 When Mrs Hollidaye said that she and Miss Lilian had to walk over to fetch the milk from the home farm, she suggested that Dot should stay and rest by the fire. 
 But Dot said she wanted to come too. 
 &bquo;My dear, you are looking too tired. 
 We simply can't use the Ford again today. 
 Because if Mr Bodger found out, that's our warden, he'd be so upset. 
 I gave his wife some mulberries last autumn and I know he trusts us with the petrol allowance and anyway this beastly rationing should be over soon, so I know I shouldn't complain when some people have had it much worse up in town. 
 My dear! 
 I've an idea! 
 We'll harness the goat. 
 Wouldn't that be splendid, Miss Lilian? 
 Then, Dorothy, you can ride in the cart.&equo; 
 When the goat was made ready, Loopy Lil helped Dot up onto the little red-painted cart with the empty milk cans  clattering on the wooden seat beside her, while Mrs Hollidaye took the leading-rein at the front. 
 There were pictures in one of Gloria's magazines of the decorated carriage Pulled by plumed horses that Her Majesty had travelled in before she became Her Majesty the Queen, when she was still just a Lady, on her way to be married. 
 Dot thought how it had probably felt like this, jolting yet stately. 
 Then she thought of the blackberrying and the melon, of the feathered hens that laid eggs, and of the church eagle of glinting metal that glowed like gold. 
 She was finding out many new things that Baby would never know of. 
 &bquo;Would you say,&equo; Dot asked, &bquo;it's more like London, or more like round about here?&equo; 
 &bquo;Where, dear?&equo; 
 &bquo;At heaven.&equo; 
 The goat stopped abruptly and tried to chew at the hem of Mrs Hollidaye's brown jacket. 
 &bquo;You know, my dear, the gospels are not at all  clear on that point. 
 Personally I would like to believe it to be peacefully verdant. 
 As it says so clearly in the Psalms. 
 Walking in green pastures. 
 Beside still waters.&equo; 
 Dot did not know what Psalms were, but she felt she was beginning to understand about quiet and gentle greenness because she saw it all around her. 
 This seemed to be a place where, despite noises in the night and a few dangers like trees that grew inside you and made your throat choke, a person might feel sale for always. 
 The goat suddenly trotted eagerly forward and Mrs Hollidaye had to run to keep hold of the leather strap. 
 They passed down the lane between high hedges. 
 Dot said, &bquo;That's all right, then. 
 I'm glad he's at a nice place like this.&equo; 
 Better than burning in Mrs Parvis's hot red fires of hell. 
 The goat stopped again and leaned over to take a bite of springy grass beside the road. 
 &bquo;I think he's  gone there too,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;What, dear?&equo;  
 &bquo;Him. 
 My old man.&equo; 
 &bquo;Derek? 
 Not to heaven, dear!&equo; 
 So he had  gone to that other place where, so Mrs Parvis said, red and orange fires burned day and night, so hot that glass and brick and even solid rock melted to liquid. 
 &bquo;Gloria and me went to see him once,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;I don't reckon he's there no more. 
 She don't talk about it. 
 We had to go on the Green Line bus.&equo; 
 It had been a long ride to an enclosure full of low single-storeyed huts of corrugated iron with cinder paths around, and all set in a large flat field of sparse greying grass. 
 &bquo;It was military, Gloria said. 
 She was blinking right. 
 There was soldiers everywhere. 
 They was at the gate, so we couldn't go in. 
 Gloria had to show this special letter what she had about him before they'd even look at us.&equo; 
 Dot wasn't used to talking so much about her father. 
 Usually Gloria told her to shut her trap. 
 Mrs Hollidaye didn't. 
 Some of the men inside the hut had peered out like timid ghosts. 
 She hadn't seen what her father looked like. 
 He hadn't come out and she hadn't been allowed in. 
 Gloria had gone in and a person at a window had waved once but Dot hadn't known if it was him. 
 She'd sat on the stubby grass, cut short as the back of a soldier's head. 
 Afterwards, Gloria had said, &bquo;That grass were clipped flat so there weren't nowhere for a running man to hide.&equo; 
 They reached the big white gate at the entrance to Mrs Hollidaye's driveway. 
 The goat twisted its neck to make a grab at a fallen twig on the ground. 
 &bquo;No one never comes back from there, do they?&equo; 
 Dot said. 
 &bquo;From heaven, dear? 
 No, I'm afraid you won't see the baby again. 
 Not till you reach heaven. 
 But you never know, maybe your mother will be able to have another one later.&equo; 
 Dot hadn't meant where Baby was. 
 She knew she'd never see him  again. 
 She meant that place where her father was, wherever that was. 
 She'd begun to guess he was probably dead too and they'd forgotten to tell her, just like nobody told her straight when Baby died.  
 She was glad. 
 She didn't ever want to have to see him. 
 Gloria came down, bright and freshly lipsticked, in time for tea. 
 They were in the glass-roofed, glass-sided room which Mrs Hollidaye called the conservatory. 
 The conservatory was warm, light and moist, filled with growing plants in pots. 
 Through the glass and the vines overhead could be seen the blue sky and the white clouds, so that it was like being both indoors and out at the same time. 
 At teatime, there was honey, sour-milk scones and plum jam where you had to mind out for the stones. 
 The bread and butter was served not in huge chunks like at elevenses, but on a pretty dish with a golden edge, in thinly-cut slices. 
 Gloria was hungry. 
 &bquo;I'm telling you,&equo; she said, &bquo;when I heard that big clock in the hall striking the five, you could've knocked me down with a feather! 
 Seems like I been dead to the world for weeks! 
 I'm telling you, Mrs Hollidaye, you'll get plenty of work out of me tomorrow. 
 Anything you need doing around the place. 
 And that's a promise. 
 Come on, pet, put that where the flies won't get it.&equo; 
 She urged Dot to drink a glassful of fresh milk. 
 &bquo;Does you good, that does. 
 Oh well, please yourself, ducky. 
 Me and Lil, at least we know how to trough up good and proper, don't we, Lil?&equo; 
 Loopy Lil, with plum jam already streaked like blood round her mouth, grinned cheerfully and went on tucking in. 
 By the end of that first day, Dot knew, despite her throbbing head, her painful neck and throat, that this was a good place. 
 She didn't mind how long they had to stay. 
 She wouldn't even mind if Gloria went away and left her. 
 Loopy Lil began piling the tea-things on to the tray to carry back to the kitchen, and Mrs Hollidaye suggested Gloria should go and help bring in the vegetables from the shed for supper, when an insistent bell began ringing out somewhere within the house. 
 It clanged urgently, like a fire-engine dashing towards a disaster, like the ambulance thundering along behind to retrieve the bodies. 
 It would not stop.  
 &bquo;Oh, bother!&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye, calmly putting another teacup on the tray, not at all upset by the persistent clamour. 
 &bquo;Telephone. 
 It's Nurse River, I'll be bound, someone needs to be driven somewhere. 
 And I did so want to dig up a few artichokes this evening. 
 Jerusalem artichokes, they make a lovely cream soup so long as you don't mind the flatulence.&equo; 
 The telephone was in her hall. 
 Mrs Hollidaye got up and went to it. 
 Then Gloria was called. 
 After that, everything changed and everything that had seemed to Dot to be all right disappeared. 
 Just when she thought they'd got away from it, change and disruption had caught up with them again. 
 Dot sat rigid and shivering on the wicker armchair in the conservatory. 
 Loopy Lil went on piling more and more things haphazardly on to the tray.  
 In the Hen-house 
 Dot could hear them just inside the house. 
 Mrs Hollidaye was doing most of the speaking. 
 &bquo;Yes, my dear, I do understand how it must seem hard to you.&equo; 
 Dot knew it was something to do with her father. 
 &bquo;But you've got to try. 
 For yourself. 
 For the child. 
 For him too.&equo; 
 And Dot knew that Gloria was crying. 
 &bquo;My dear, he's going to need you more than ever before.&equo; 
 Dot could hear Gloria saying she wouldn't and she couldn't. 
 Then Mrs Hollidaye said, &bquo;My dear girl, you have to start making a home. 
 And you know that you will always be welcome back here on another occasion. 
 Now, while you go and dry those eyes, I'll look up the trains.&equo; 
 Dot in the conservatory watched as Loopy Lil slowly tried to pick up the unsteady tray of china. 
 Dot knew what was going to happen. 
 The wobbling teacup on the top fell first, the rest followed. 
 Cups, saucers, teapot, milk jug with its little muslin cloth, plates and splattered jam. 
 The crashing seemed to go on forever as tiny broken fragments bounced with a dainty tinkle across the brick floor. 
 Loopy Lil stared round at the destruction with a look of hopelessness as though she did not understand how it had happened. 
 Dot knew that Mrs Hollidaye would come to comfort her, to reassure her that it wasn't her fault. 
 Poor Loopy Lil, she had a screw loose. 
 She'd only been trying to help. 
 But Dot couldn't do anything for her because she had to  escape. 
 She must hide before Gloria found her. 
 She darted for the open doors and down the stone step to the garden. 
 She ran round the outside of the house, barging past bushes and shrubs. 
 She found her way to the kitchen. 
 She wanted to go along the side passage and up the back stairs to the bedroom with the toys where she could safely hide. 
 But the house was too big and she lost her way. 
 Instead, she was in a dark lobby full of musty boots. 
 She ran out again through a side entrance. 
 She recognized where she was. 
 This was the yard where Mrs Hollidaye fed the hens, throwing down the corn for them to peck up. 
 She could hear Gloria behind calling for her. 
 She ran back across the yard to the hen-house, through the netting gate, across the muddy enclosure, scattering hens at each step. 
 Then crouching low, she squeezed herself through the hens' low archway, and into the dark warm gloom of their hut. 
 More hens sat clucking on their roosts. 
 The hens were all right. 
 They didn't have to go anywhere. 
 This was their home and they could stay here always. 
 &bquo;Going time, Dot,&equo; said Gloria outside. 
 &bquo;Come on out.&equo; 
 Dot kept still and quiet, head down and hunched like a bird sleeping, hoping Gloria wouldn't know she was in there. 
 But the fowl were irritated by this invasion of their hut and their clucking gave her away. 
 &bquo;Come on, pet. 
 We know you're in there.&equo; 
 &bquo;We only just got here!&equo; 
 Dot yelled, not coming out. 
 &bquo;Where we going, anyway?&equo; 
 &bquo;Home now, duckypet. 
 Got to catch the train. 
 Last one leaves at twenty-past.&equo; 
 &bquo;No!&equo; said Dot, though she knew she'd have to do what Gloria wanted, go where Gloria went. 
 &bquo;Not coming!&equo; she shouted in the dusty gloom. 
 &bquo;Going to stay here.&equo; 
 And when she heard Gloria outside rattling the hen-house door, she screamed it again and again till Gloria managed to get the latch undone and came in and dragged her yelling through the droppings and feathers and washed her face under the water pump and dried it on her hanky.  
 Mrs Hollidaye was there too, and more gently than Gloria asked, &bquo;Were there any more eggs in there, did you notice? 
 I collected earlier. 
 But sometimes there's an extra egg or two. 
 Come, we must choose some for you to take back with you. 
 The speckledy brown ones are best.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye found Gloria a blue suitcase with proper metal clips to pack their things in. 
 &bquo;It's a spare. 
 I shan't be going anywhere for a while. 
 You can bring it back next time you come. 
 Then you can use your paper carriers for these, can't you?&equo; 
 She gave Gloria two jars of jam, and six fresh eggs packed in a special cardboard box with separate soft spaces to keep each one safe. 
 She gave Gloria money so that she wouldn't have to pretend Dot was a babe-in-arms. 
 On the train ride home, the compartment no longer seemed like a compact travelling home. 
 It was just a train with lumpy seats and smuts. 
 Dot sat hunched in her corner, Gloria in another, each far from the other. 
 Eventually Dot asked, &bquo;Was he a brave man?&equo; 
 &bquo;Reverend Hollidaye? 
 I'll say, I told you about him.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I mean him . 
 The other one.&equo; 
 &bquo;Who's that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Him. 
 My father, was he like some kind of hero?&equo; 
 &bquo;Your old man a hero? 
 Don't make me laugh! 
 Your Dad couldn't have knocked the skin off a rice pudding.&equo; 
 Dot tried not to look at Gloria's face. 
 Why would anyone want to go and see a man who was a coward? 
 Dot remembered one of the things she'd overheard Mrs Hollidaye telling Gloria just before Loopy Lil crashed the tray. 
 &bquo;You know, my dear, love's a funny thing. 
 If you want it, you'll find it can grow in the most unexpected places.&equo; 
 Dot hadn't known what it meant. 
 It made her think of green melons growing under glass lids. 
 That was an unexpected place. 
 Perhaps it could also mean loving a man who wasn't there and didn't deserve to be loved. 
 Dot thought about that place where they'd visited him long ago, with soldiers guarding the main gate, and long low buildings surrounded by grass clipped so flat there was  nowhere for a running man to hide. 
 Then she thought about those other long low huts she'd seen in the fenced-off meadow beyond St Michael and All Angels. 
 Mrs Hollidaye said that's where the prisoners of war were housed. 
 The buildings were the same kind as where her faceless father had been. 
 It was a tiny hope. 
 But if he was a war prisoner, soon they'd be sending him back. 
 That's what Mrs Hollidaye said was happening. 
 &bquo;Repatriation. 
 It's a slow old business, putting everybody in the country they started from. 
 But in the end they should all be home with their mothers. 
 Poor boys. 
 That's where they belong. 
 Or with their sisters, or their sweethearts.&equo; 
 If he was one of them , that's why they were hurrying back to London, so Gloria could say goodbye before he was put on a ship and Dot wouldn't ever have to see him again. 
 The train rumbled through the dark. 
 Dot tried again. 
 &bquo;Is he one of them foreigners, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Foreigners? 
 How d'you mean?&equo; 
 &bquo;I saw some where we just been. 
 In the big kitchen. 
 They was working in the fields. 
 But they gonna get took home soon.&equo; 
 &bquo;Them's prisoners of war.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know. 
 Germans. 
 Is my old man one of them?&equo; 
 &bquo;What kind of thing to say is that!&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;All that good food you been getting, it's gone to your head, I'd say. 
 In fact I'm darn sure it has, the way you behaved. 
 What made you want to crawl in with them mucky birds like that? 
 I've never been so ashamed in my life. 
 You don't get that kind of behaviour from me.&equo; 
 &bquo;I just wanted to know about him,&equo; said Dot, crying now because she had made Gloria angry. 
 &bquo;Sorry, honest. 
 Won't never say it again.&equo; 
 As the train drew into Victoria Station, Gloria softened. 
 &bquo;There, there. 
 Don't take on so.&equo; 
 She crossed over to sit beside Dot. 
 She put her arm round her.  
 &bquo;Come now, pet, let's kiss and make up and I'll tell you about him. 
 Biggin Hill, I met him, Empire Air Day. 
 Oh, he was beautiful. 
 In them days we could really go for a man in uniform. 
 We was married real quick. 
 Well in them days you never knew what might happen next. 
 Then you come along not so long after.&equo; 
 She gave Dot a peck on the cheek. 
 &bquo;Oh, my, you're warm as toast, aren't you? 
 You took a chill? 
 Ooh, ducky, I do hope you haven't gone and caught something nasty from them birds.&equo;  
 Bad Germs 
 &bquo;So you're back, then!&equo; said Mrs Parvis. 
 She didn't seem too pleased even when Gloria gave her both pots of jam. 
 &bquo;So you wasn't gone away long, the pair of you, was you?&equo; 
 Dot tugged at Gloria's sleeve. 
 She wanted to get in off the doorstep. 
 She wanted to lie down. 
 &bquo;A nervy little thing, isn't she? 
 Fat lot of good the countryside done her . 
 Couldn't you have left her down there with that woman friend?&equo; 
 Gloria began to edge along the hallway. 
 &bquo;So you got the message all right? 
 About hubby, was it? 
 Anything to oblige. 
 Though you know being telegraph-boy isn't in my normal line of business. 
 Still, I said to myself, so she has  got a husband after all, because I was beginning to put two and two together and ask myself a few questions. 
 We keep a respectable house here as well you know. 
 So he's being demobbed at last, is he?&equo; 
 &bquo;We got some eggs too, Mrs Parvis,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Would you like a couple?&equo; 
 &bquo;Ooh ta, ever so. 
 Well I hope you sort yourselves out nice and quick. 
 Because I shan't do with him lodging here long. 
 That's only a single room. 
 At that rent it has to be.&equo; 
 &bquo;Hold your horses, Mrs Parvis. 
 You won't get him  stopping here, not for all the tea in China. 
 He's fixing us up in a flat, with kitchenette, out Godalming way, a live-in maintenance job.&equo; 
 Dot knew it was all dreams. 
 She could tell with Gloria. 
 There was the way her lips moved when she was lying. 
 &bquo;Glad to hear it. 
 I was pushing it, letting the child in. 
 So now I've got to be cruel to be kind. 
 Because you know that  you won't get on that priority housing list if I'm soft on you.&equo; 
 Dot preferred Mrs Hollidaye's way of talking, always trying to see the good side of things. 
 Even when it was something bad, like the mice-damage in the apple room, or the wasps' nest in the orchard, or even your husband jumping off a plane and dying, she managed to see the good part of it. 
 Mr Brown was a bit like that too. 
 Dot said, &bquo;In the country, where we just been, there's this lady where we stayed what hasn't eaten a banana so long she's forgotten the taste, and what's growing these melons in her garden. 
 Under a lid.&equo; 
 &bquo;In the country, in the country. 
 I'm not sure I can stand that kind of talk,&equo; snapped Mrs Parvis. 
 &bquo;If it was all so blooming wonderful, I dunno why your Mum didn't let you stay put.&equo; 
 That night the air in the basement room became so thick it was like inhaling the black tar they put on the road. 
 Dot knew it must be the enemy had dropped their gas canisters to suffocate women and children in a gas-attack. 
 She saw how the dark room had filled with transparent figures who marched along the walls singing and mocking, who wrapped themselves around her so that she was suffocated in their embrace, then turned to broken bricks and choking mortar dust which cascaded in torrents on to her, flattening her to the bed so that her limbs ached with pain and she couldn't move. 
 Each breath was fire and splinters of ice. 
 Her throat was filled with coils of barbed wire. 
 Towards morning she woke limp and exhausted, shivering with cold. 
 As delirium receded, she knew it had all been dreams. 
 &bquo;My throat hurts,&equo; she whispered. 
 But Gloria wasn't there. 
 Her black hat with the little veil had gone from the shelf, and her best peep-toe shoes. 
 Dot realized she'd already left to visit the man who was a gutless jink. 
 Dot guessed by the papery men lurking inside the walls that she must be ill. 
 But if so, how had it happened? 
 Was it  in some way her own fault? 
 And how ill did you have to be before you died? 
 She put on her coat and got back into the bed. 
 During the day it came again, the shadows falling off the walls. 
 And Gloria wouldn't be back for hours. 
 It was a long bus-ride to reach those low huts standing behind the high fence. 
 Dot got up and went along to the kitchen for Mrs Parvis's High Tea. 
 Two wet floury potatoes were dished on to her plate but she couldn't eat them. 
 Mrs Parvis scraped them back into the pot. 
 &bquo;Waste not, want not,&equo; she said with a frown of disapproval. 
 The table lurched up at Dot. 
 &bquo;That child don't look any too well, do she?&equo; she heard Mrs Parvis's voice, far away at the end of the table. 
 &bquo;Say, Dotty, you all right?&equo; 
 Dot's throat was so swollen she couldn't speak. 
 She wanted to drink. 
 As she held the cup of tea to her mouth, she felt herself tumble down into a deep well. 
 She began sliding from the chair towards the gaping hole in the floor. 
 There was nothing she could do to save herself. 
 She tried to remember what Mrs Hollidaye had said about the many different ways of being brave. 
 She clutched at the slithery sides but there was no grip. 
 Way up above in the light at the top of the well Mrs Parvis was speaking but Dot knew it was nothing to do with her. 
 &bquo;Said I'd keep an eye on the kiddy for an hour or two. 
 Now look what's happened! 
 It's a disgrace.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's hardly her fault if the child falls ill,&equo; said one of the lodgers. 
 &bquo;That's as maybe. 
 But I can't go having my place turned into a fever ward. 
 All them germs. 
 Where'll that lead us? 
 Before we know where we are we'll all be down with it like flies. 
 As if I don't have enough on my plate already.&equo; 
 Dot felt herself gathered up from the kitchen floor and Mr Brown's face came into view, kindly and familiar. 
 She reached out for his hand. 
 Benign Mr Brown.  
 &bquo;Now, then,&equo; said Mrs Parvis sternly and pushed Mr Brown out of the way. 
 &bquo;That'll be all for now, Mr Brown. 
 Everything under control and we can manage on our own.&equo; 
 When she was laid on the bed Dot felt the room spin. 
 &bquo;Did you ever play cloud pictures?&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye had asked when they went over the fields to fetch the creamy milk from Home Farm. 
 &bquo;Don't know,&equo; said Dot and wondered if it was anything like princesses. 
 Mrs Hollidaye explained. 
 &bquo;We have to lie down on our backs. 
 Springy moss is best, here on this bank. 
 We look up into the sky, we watch the shapes of the clouds changing till we recognize a picture. 
 Do you see, my dear, up there now? 
 A clown with a laughing face?&equo; 
 Dot looked upwards and saw the smiling clown. 
 &bquo;And now he's changing into a little dog, d'you see, my dear?&equo; 
 Dot saw the little dog too, dancing. 
 Then it was her turn. 
 &bquo;I can see fire,&equo; she had said. 
 &bquo;Flames.&equo; 
 She saw them swirling and licking across the sky burning up everything. 
 She pointed them out to Mrs Hollidaye. 
 Dot tried to find beautiful pictures like Mrs Hollidaye did, of meadow flowers, and laughing children, cathedrals and fairy coaches. 
 A long time later, or perhaps only a few seconds, she thought she saw her father's face white as paper, floating among the clouds, then it dissolved into the face of an elderly stranger bending over her. 
 If only Gloria was here. 
 He wrapped her in a scarlet blanket, and carried her up the outside area steps. 
 It was already dark outside. 
 The ambulance stood in the road. 
 &bquo;Gloria!&equo; 
 Dot croaked. 
 She knew she shouldn't cause trouble to people. 
 Mrs Parvis was always telling her so. 
 She wanted to cry. 
 &bquo;That's all right, sunshine,&equo; said the ambulance man. 
 &bquo;We're taking care of you.&equo; 
 Dot turned to see Mrs Parvis, arms folded akimbo across her floral apron, rigid on her front steps.  
 They slammed the ambulance doors. 
 The windows were like the windows of the children's ward where Baby used to be, of white glass which you couldn't see through. 
 One of the lodgers was travelling with her. 
 The woman saw Dot staring and smiled. 
 &bquo;There you are. 
 Everything all right now?&equo; 
 What on earth was she  doing in the ambulance? 
 Was she ill too? 
 At the hospital, in a cold tiled room, they asked questions and wrote down answers. 
 &bquo;Mother's name? 
 Father's name?&equo; 
 Dot struggled to sit up. 
 &bquo;Airman,&equo; she croaked. 
 &bquo;Dead now.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ssh, dear, don't try to talk,&equo; said the woman lodger, and the nurse made her lie down. 
 &bquo;Has she ever been admitted to this hospital before?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes,&equo; said Dot, sitting up again. 
 &bquo;Every day. 
 To see Baby.&equo; 
 But they didn't mean it like that. 
 Name? 
 Age? 
 Date of birth? 
 Address? 
 Religion? 
 How long ill? 
 Any fever yesterday? 
 Immunized against diptheria? 
 Opened her bowels today? 
 Ever been in contact with any person carrying typhoid? 
 Any family history of rheumatic fever? 
 After that Dot couldn't be bothered. 
 She let the woman lodger answer since that's what they seemed to want. 
 After the questions, the woman lodger went away and they took off Dot's clothes and touched and prodded at her neck, her ears and her throat. 
 But she knew she mustn't make a fuss. 
 Finally they wheeled her on a trolley down the draughty brown corridor, through the swing doors, into Ward 3-South where a dim light showed the children lying down. 
 Dot was put into a bed with high sides. 
 She wanted to explain that she wasn't a baby and didn't need a cot. 
 &bquo;Haven't had no tea,&equo; Dot croaked. 
 &bquo;Didn't get no dinner neither.&equo; 
 The nurse pulled up the metal sides and closed them  with a clang so that Dot was like a caged prisoner. 
 &bquo;It's too late for that now,&equo; said the nurse. 
 &bquo;You'll have to wait for morning. 
 You'll find that comes soon enough.&equo; 
 A child in a bed nearby began to whimper and Dot wondered if not crying when you wanted to counted as being brave. 
 Later that night one of Dot's teeth came out. 
 She thought at first that it was an apple pip in her mouth. 
 She touched the jellied space in her mouth and found a drop of blood like a shiny ladybird resting on her finger. 
 She felt with her tongue. 
 Other teeth moved freely in a way that they had never moved before. 
 She was breaking into pieces. 
 Maybe more teeth would come out. 
 Maybe her arms, then her legs, her hair, her arms, her fingers, her thumbs till there would be nothing left of her for Gloria to find. 
 She called out to the night-nurse who scurried over when she saw the red smear on the stiff white pillowcase. 
 But as soon as she saw the tooth, she lost interest. 
 &bquo;Is that all it was?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Thought you were bleeding to death? 
 Thought the sky was falling in on your head? 
 Ssh now, and go back to sleep. 
 Or d'you want the whole ward to wake up just for one milk tooth?&equo;  
 War 3-South 
 When Baby had been here, Dot remembered how she had yearned to be with him, amongst those quiet children so calm in their tidy beds. 
 But the ward was no longer shining with peaceful light. 
 What had appeared then to be contentment turned out now to be cold loneliness. 
 And once in, there was no way through the blank windows. 
 It came and went in swirling waves that rushed down from the ceiling and swallowed her up. 
 She forgot who she was, how long she had been here. 
 They told her she was lucky, but Dot couldn't understand how. 
 Four times a day the nurse came towards her across the wide spaces of lino with the shiny basin containing the rattling metal syringe. 
 Four times a day, the nurse pulled back the white cover, turned Dot on her side, pulled up the gown and thrust the needle in with the savage pain of a bayonet. 
 The first time, Dot cried out at this new kind of hurt. 
 Later she knew not to make any sound, otherwise the nurse said, &bquo;Don't you want  to get better?&equo; 
 Then she told Dot, &bquo;You're a lucky little scallywag! 
 Ten years ago and you'd have died!&equo; 
 Sometimes she saw nurses whispering about her and wanted to hide. 
 When Gloria came, pattering across the ward in all her best, Dot couldn't bear to see her pretty face and turned away on the pillow with shut eyes. 
 Why did you let them bring me here? 
 What have I done? she wanted to say. 
 When can I get out? 
 Each bed had a locker beside it. 
 On top of some were  displayed heavy glass bottles of fizzy pop, or coloured postcards, or jig-saws or ragdolls with floppy arms. 
 Dot didn't mind about the toys and she knew she couldn't ask for ginger pop because that cost money but she would have liked to have had her victory token back. 
 Gloria had told her she'd got to keep it for ever. 
 It had been in her coat pocket when they took her clothes away. 
 Now it was gone for ever. 
 Dot managed to attract the attention of the girl lying in the next bed. 
 &bquo;Want to play a game? 
 Film stars?&equo; 
 The sick girl nodded. 
 &bquo;You start, then,&equo; said Dot. 
 But the girl didn't know how to play and Dot hadn't enough voice to explain. 
 By the time she had, they'd moved the girl away to another ward. 
 Dot didn't see her again. 
 Gloria came every day, just as she had for Baby. 
 &bquo;Mustn't stay long,&equo; she said, giving Dot's hand a little squeeze. 
 &bquo;I've started this little job see, pet. 
 Ooh, your hand, it ain't half skinny. 
 I'll have to call you spindle-shanks if you let yourself get any thinner!&equo; 
 She was usherette at the Essoldo cinema, showing people to their seats. 
 &bquo;Matin&eacute;es only. 
 I get to see all the films. 
 Well, it helps pass the time. 
 I'm saving a bit up for when your old man gets home. 
 To Have and Have Not , that's showing now. 
 Ooh, it's a lovely one!&equo; 
 Gloria's lipstick was brighter than ever, and she had a fitted red two-piece with Essoldo  embroidered in cream on the top pocket. 
 &bquo;Being a good girl, aren't you, ducky? 
 Saying please and thank you? 
 Don't want to hear no tales told about you from them nice nurses. 
 You eat up your dinners, too.&equo; 
 Where her tooth had fallen nut a sturdy new one was forcing its way up, with frilled edges and ridged from top to bottom. 
 Dot asked Gloria for the powder compact she kept in her bag. 
 When she looked in the little round mirror, she saw that she wasn't falling to pieces. 
 She was turning into a different person with a different face.  
 After Gloria had gone, lying in her cot with nothing to do, nothing to look at, Dot told herself about the hens laying in the country. 
 She went into the hen-house and looked at their eggs. 
 She thought she saw the Germans still working in the fields, and now they were picking up potatoes from the muddy ground. 
 But perhaps she'd never really been there at all. 
 Perhaps she'd just imagined it, like she'd imagined the pallid papery men buried in the walls. 
 Since she no longer had her own victory brooch to hold, she thought about Mrs Hollidaye's, pinned to the lapel of her hairy jacket. 
 Its design, like Dot's, was of crossed flags but wasn't made of scratchy tin with rusting edges. 
 Hers was shiny jewels, blue, red and diamond bright which twinkled when they caught the light. 
 &bquo;Gloria said you was ever so posh, bit like our king and queen. 
 You don't look that posh. 
 Except you got them jewels. 
 I ain't never seen jewels like that before.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, they are rather grand, aren't they, my dear? 
 The red duster, the white ensign and the Union Jack.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye glanced down at her brooch and touched it like Dot used to touch her token. 
 &bquo;My sons gave it to me. 
 And d'you know, I've worn it every day since. 
 It helps me think of them.&equo; 
 &bquo;I knew Gloria got it wrong. 
 I never thought you was that posh. 
 You ain't got no servants.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, my dear, we can all be servants, one to another, depending on the need, can't we?&equo; 
 What strange things she said. 
 But now, lying in a cot while a nurse washed her all over and patted her dry, she saw what Mrs Hollidaye might have meant. 
 A brown paper parcel arrived by special delivery. 
 The other children on the ward didn't get parcels by post. 
 &bquo;It's for that little slip of a thing at the end.&equo; 
 A nurse sat on Dot's bed and unwrapped it and Dot knew it was from Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;What in lawks name is this!&equo; said the nurse holding it up. 
 Dot wanted to say, &bquo;It's one of Mrs Hollidaye's babies!&equo; but because of her throat, the words stuck like plum stones. 
  Instead, she managed to croak, &bquo;Eat it. 
 Vegetable.&equo; 
 Or had it been a fruit? 
 The melon was boiled and brought to Dot next dinner time with her chicken broth all around like a shattered building surrounded by deep trenches full of murky rainwater. 
 Mrs Hollidaye hadn't said anything about cooking it. 
 Slice the top off, scoop out the seeds, and a drop of Oporto  is what she'd said. 
 The doctors gathered round her bed. 
 They measured Dot's legs with wooden measuring sticks, and they prodded her ribs while a nurse stood by and held her hand. 
 They didn't usually speak to her, only about her. 
 They told Gloria, &bquo;This child is malnourished. 
 She has anaemia and first stage rickets.&equo; 
 An old man in a dark suit with a light strapped round his forehead like a rescue worker's lamp came next and pushed wooden sticks down Dot's throat. 
 He told Gloria, &bquo;The sooner we get them out the better. 
 But she's got to be Al. 
 So we're sending her home to fatten up. 
 Liver, spinach, cheese, green leaf vegetables.&equo; 
 &bquo;They want to do an operation, pet,&equo; Gloria explained at visiting time. 
 &bquo;Make you fighting fit again. 
 Get rid of them nasty things down your throat what's harbouring the germs. 
 When you're asleep.&equo; 
 When Dot was asleep was when the dreams came with limbless, fingerless, thumbless, faceless men marching through her head. 
 She didn't want them to do anything then. 
 They must do things when she was awake. 
 &bquo;They can't do that, ducky. 
 That's not how the doctors like it. 
 It would hurt you too much. 
 You have to be asleep.&equo; 
 Gloria brought some clothes in a carrier. 
 But Dot had changed and so had the skirt and cardigan. 
 They hung strangely, too loose, yet too short as well. 
 Her wrists stuck out. 
 Her legs were bare to way above her knees and her legs felt cold and so thin they'd hardly support her weight. 
 She had to clutch on to Gloria's arm. 
 &bquo;Here, put this on too,&equo; said Gloria. 
 It was a pixie bonnet. 
 &bquo;One of them nice ladies at Mrs P's, middle floor, knitted it  up. 
 Said I was to take extra care to keep your ears warm, specially with this wind. 
 Unravelled one of her own woollies specially.&equo; 
 It was a mixture of strange colours and the knitted ties felt scratchy where Gloria knotted them under Dot's chin. 
 &bquo;You'll have to say thank you.&equo; 
 At first, Mrs Parvis pretended to be pleased to see Dot. 
 &bquo;Oh my! 
 And hasn't she grown tall! 
 So that's what lying in bed all day does for you. 
 I should try it myself if only I had the time.&equo; 
 But to Gloria she said, &bquo;She's all skin and bone. 
 If you looked at her sideways, you wouldn't never see her at all.&equo; 
 After that, everything was just the same with Mrs Parvis still complaining as much as ever. 
 &bquo;They gave us that big build-up. 
 The new Britain, that's what our boys been fighting for. 
 Work for all, health for all, that&equo; s what they promised.&equo; 
 &bquo;And a good home for everybody,&equo; Gloria agreed. 
 Mrs Parvis glared at her and carried on. 
 &bquo;And now look at us! 
 Right back where we was. 
 Noses to the grindstone. 
 In fact I'd say we're worse off than what we was at the start of it. 
 They can't even tell us what to do with our gas-masks. 
 I'm sick to death of them cluttering up my hall like that. 
 Reminding us of things we don't want to think about.&equo; 
 The gas-masks hung on their pegs in the narrow hall. 
 Inside each brown case waited the empty skull-face, folded flat, with a flappy rubber nose and hard cylindrical snout, though they frightened Dot less now than they used to. 
 &bquo;At least we never had to wear them,&equo; said Mr Brown quietly. 
 &bquo;We can be thankful for that.&equo; 
 Dot had worn hers once during a practice. 
 It was smelly inside, made you feel as though you were choking to death and the eye-holes so small you couldn't see out properly. 
 They'd issued one for Baby too, a gas-bag like a cradle, with a port-hole on the top. 
 It was too cumbersome to hang on a peg in the hall with the others. 
 So Gloria had shoved it out of the way under the bed. 
 When Gloria went off to the Essoldo, Dot couldn't go  with her. 
 She wasn't allowed in crowded places where there might be germs. 
 She wasn't allowed to get cold. 
 She wasn't allowed to mix with other children. 
 &bquo;They say she's very susceptible,&equo; Gloria explained to Mrs Parvis when she went to borrow an extra shilling for the meter to light the gas fire in the basement room. 
 &bquo;She could catch anything that's around.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mollycoddling,&equo; said Mrs Parvis under her breath. 
 &bquo;That's what it is, she ought to be back in school, a big girl like that. 
 Besides, what if all my lodgers was asking for favours? 
 I'm not a lending bank.&equo; 
 In the afternoon, when Gloria had left for work, Dot pulled out Baby's gas-mask to look at it again. 
 It was covered in grey dust. 
 Seeing it, and thinking of him safely in heaven with no risk now of being zipped into this airless rubber gas-bag made Dot start to cry. 
 She didn't understand why. 
 She hadn't cried about him before. 
 She sobbed so much that Mrs Parvis heard through the wall and came in and told her off. 
 She made her get into bed and said she was sending for the blue ladies right away. 
 She must have told Gloria off too, for the very next day, Gloria said, &bquo;You got to go off to the country, ducks, health visitor says. 
 For your convalescence.&equo; 
 Dot didn't know what her convalescence was. 
 &bquo;To get you in the pink. 
 For your operation. 
 Like the nice man said. 
 We don't want you hopping the twig.&equo; 
 &bquo;I am in the pink,&equo; said Dot, though she knew she wasn't or she wouldn't have allowed herself to weep the day before. 
 &bquo;Can't you come too?&equo; 
 &bquo;I dunno, pet. 
 It's dull down there. 
 There ain't nothing 
 &bquo;What if it's all changed and they don't know me no more?&equo; 
 &bquo;Listen, pet, she's said she'll have you. 
 So what more d'you want? 
 Jam on both  sides? 
 I'll put you in charge of the guard and you'll be as right as rain.&equo; 
 Dot felt she was an unwanted item of luggage being sent away.  
 Miss Spindle-Spanks 
 Mrs Hollidaye met Dot at the train with the Ford drawn right up to the station exit. 
 &bquo;My dear, I won't kiss you. 
 Just in case of the germs. 
 We've got to treat you like best bone china. 
 But don't mind the dogs. 
 They're just longing to see you. 
 Dogs have different germs, can't possibly harm you.&equo; 
 She was wearing her felt hat and her tweed jacket with the jewelled brooch pinned to the lapel. 
 Everything was just as it should be. 
 &bquo;I decided I really must  bring the motor. 
 And if that nosy old constable asks about petrol, I shall tell him it's an emergency. 
 And if he doesn't believe me, well, we shall have to see what we shall see, won't we?&equo; 
 She bundled Dot on to the front seat with rugs up to the chin. 
 The wool gave off a friendly smell of the dogs who had been lying on it. 
 &bquo;And here's the hot water bottle for your feet, my dear,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;And there's a flask of tea if you need it. 
 Though we'll be home before you can say Jack Robinson. 
 And Dorothy dear, I must warn you, you're hardly going to recognize  Miss Lilian! 
 All new teeth! 
 Top and bottom. 
 That's the new welfare. 
 Do  tell her how nice she looks, won't you? 
 Of course you will. 
 Only she's rather selfconscious at the moment.&equo; 
 Loopy Lil's new smile of regular gleaming teeth was the only change. 
 Otherwise everything was reassuringly the same. 
 The yapping of the small dogs, the smells of musty dampness, of jam and paraffin, and welcoming woodsmoke, the vase of flowers on a polished table in the hall. 
 &bquo;Now you're not to lift a finger, my dear, is she, Lilian? 
 Until you're quite better.&equo;  
 &bquo;I am . 
 I'm fit as a fiddle!&equo; 
 Dot said. 
 &bquo;Skinny as a whipping post, that's what Gloria says, and sound as a roach.&equo; 
 But the journey in the guard's van like lost luggage had exhausted her, so she didn't protest about going straight up with Loopy Lil, being changed into one of Mrs Hollidaye's pink flannel nightgowns and tucked into a cocoon of pillows with a hot stone bottle wrapped in a worn silk vest at her feet. 
 There was a fire burning in the grate and a china chamber-pot painted with birds and flowers beneath the bed. 
 Her supper was on a tray, a plate of yellow buttered eggs, pink rhubarb with cream, a glass of milk and a tiny glass vase of flowers. 
 &bquo;I'll put the snowdrops just here,&equo; Mrs Hollidaye said. 
 &bquo;So you can see them. 
 I do like a person who likes flowers. 
 I believe, my dear, that seeing beautiful things around does so help a soul to feel strong, wouldn't you say? 
 The Ministry did tell us not to waste effort growing flowers, but somehow one always felt they were not quite as right as they might have been on that one. 
 Now you've found the chamber haven't you, under the bed, so you won't have to go far in the night.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye and Loopy Lil settled on either side of the bedroom fire with the dogs on the carpet between them. 
 Loopy Lil gently smiled her new even welfare smile while Mrs Hollidaye darned lisle stockings. 
 The wind was getting up, rattling against the wooden shutters, and forcing twigs to scratch against the window panes. 
 &bquo;My dear, aren't we glad  we're not on the high seas tonight! '  said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;Just think of those poor brave souls out there.&equo; 
 Dot knew that she had everything she used so much to long for. 
 If only she could will herself strong as a roach. 
 But her legs hurt, So did her neck. 
 A single spoonful of buttered eggs made her feel sick. 
 The clotted cream on the rhubarb had curdled. 
 Her disappointment turned to tears which dripped into the congealing eggs.  
 Mrs Hollidaye heard the sniffing. 
 &bquo;My dear, she said, &bquo;limited grey matter Miss Lilian may have, yet still she rejoices to be alive. 
 Sore eyes I may have, but at least I am not blind and can still darn my own stockings. 
 Aching head you may have, but at least you have a head to have aches in. 
 She put aside her darning basket, and picked up a book whose dark blue cover was patterned with gold leaves. 
 &bquo;In addition, my dear, you still have ears for listening, I trust?&equo; 
 She began to read aloud. 
 Dot saw how the gold patterns on the cover caught the flicker from the fire and flared like Very lights. 
 Mrs Hollidaye's voice was comforting as it rose and fell like the wind. 
 By listening to the story, Dot found she had become brave. 
 On the breakfast tray the next day, was a different flower, a single brilliant pink blossom with dark leaves so glossy they seemed to have been polished. 
 &bquo;A camellia, my dear. 
 D'you know, the tree hasn't flowered properly for six years. 
 Now it's such  a sight! 
 Pink all over like an apple tree in May! 
 They seem to shine out like lamps, specially on these grey days. 
 I do wish you could come out and see. 
 Maybe soon. 
 In fact, my dear, we've looked out the old bath chair. 
 From the back of the stables. 
 Lilian's given it a really good dusting down. 
 We've oiled the wheels. 
 And just as soon as you feel up to it, we'll be taking you round the garden for some good lungfuls of God's air.&equo; 
 Meanwhile, Mrs Hollidaye revealed to Dot how many things were to be done without even having to move from bed. 
 She hung a piece of mutton fat threaded on to string across the window for the blue tits. 
 She showed where Dot must watch across the ragged grass for when the fox came slinking through the bracken towards the hen-house. 
 She had shown Dot before how to find pictures in the clouds. 
 Now she pointed out how there were pictures in the trees.  
 The twigs of the beeches drew black pencil lines against the sky in which were hiding animals, and flowers, faces and places. 
 When the breeze rustled the branches, the pictures changed. 
 With a reel of linen thread and a hooked needle, Mrs Hollidaye showed how to work a crochet collar. 
 With two needles and a ball of wool, she showed how to knit. 
 She gave her books to look at and explained how the printed letters beneath each picture made words which summarized the illustration. 
 She gave her paper and coloured crayons and showed her how she could draw. 
 She taught her how to write her name, how to put the paper in an envelope to be posted to Gloria. 
 &bquo;That's it, my dear. 
 And she'll be so pleased to have it. 
 And put the X's along the bottom and that tells her that you love her and you're thinking of her.&equo; 
 Dot hadn't been thinking of her. 
 If she thought about Gloria, then she'd have to start thinking about him too. 
 It was better that she thought of neither. 
 One evening Mrs Hollidaye brought to the bedroom a long wooden box. 
 &bquo;A companion for you, my dear,&equo; she said sliding back the lid. 
 &bquo;I had her when I was a girl.&equo; 
 In the box under layers of tissue paper lay a doll which Mrs Hollidaye lifted out and placed in Dot's arms. 
 It had long white skirts. 
 &bquo;Ooh, it's beautiful! 
 I ain't never played with a proper doll before. 
 I had some paper dolls one time, but me landlady got rid of them, said they were messing the place up. 
 &bquo;She's rather old, so one has to be frightfully careful, but I know you will be. 
 She's made from wax. 
 Just the face and hands.&equo; 
 Beneath the long lacy petticoats was a stuffed cotton body wearing a lace camisole. 
 &bquo;I was given two, and I was told by my nurse never to let them near the fire or they'd melt. 
 Oh, what a naughty child I was! 
 I wanted to see if it was true. 
 So I placed one of them up against the fender, to see what would happen. 
 And then  her poor face melted like a candle into nothing and how I cried at what I had done to make her lose all her features.&equo; 
 Dot looked at the doll and thought of its lost companion with a face of dripping wax. 
 Melting cheeks and disappearing noses was what had happened to brave airmen when they caught fire. 
 Their skin burned, their features dissolved and they were left faceless. 
 Gloria met men like that at the airmen's social club. 
 Dot hugged this doll whose face was still whole. 
 She said, &bquo;It's ever so real-looking, like a person, except it's so titchy.&equo; 
 Baby had looked like this doll, as though nearly real, yet not quite, with a waxy pale skin, yellow-tinged, bright glassy eyes and a dainty pink mouth. 
 She remembered how she hadn't been allowed to hold him for more than a moment before he had to go back behind the bars of his crib. 
 &bquo;Don't sleep with her, my dear, will you, for though she would not melt, she would crack if she fell. 
 Real mothers don't sleep with their babies. 
 They might overlay them. 
 There was a village woman overlaid her baby last summer, such a terrible thing for everyone. 
 Nurse Willow had already warned her to put it in the crib.&equo; 
 Dot wondered, did Baby now look like this doll's melted companion, face and hands gone, only his white clothes left? 
 &bquo;When it's time to sleep, why not set her here on the chair to watch over you?&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye propped the doll on the chair. 
 So the wax doll sat all night with its eyes wide open staring ahead like a small dead child. 
 And Dot considered her pigeon-hearted father and wondered why she could never recall his face. 
 Dot began to eat a little more each day. 
 She dressed, she went downstairs to sit in an armchair. 
 In the evening, Mrs Hollidaye taught her to play Up Jenkins and dominoes and spillikins on a low table by the fire. 
 Loopy Lil hadn't a steady enough hand for spillikins and she couldn't count up to  more than three for the dominoes but she seemed happy to watch and smile. 
 In the morning when the sun was shining through the mist, Dot was wrapped up to go out. 
 She was surprised how bare the gardens had become, except for the lopsided apple tree in the lower orchard whose branches still carried a crop of apples shimmering like tiny brassy moons. 
 &bquo;I like to leave that one unpicked. 
 For the birds, otherwise what will they have to see them through till spring? 
 I call it my bird tree.&equo; 
 The prisoners of war had left the fields and there were different people who now gathered for elevenses round the kitchen range. 
 There was the man demobbed from his regiment who came to do the garden just as he had before he was called to war. 
 There was the young woman and her baby who had moved into the space above the coach-house, and there was the noisy couple from Luton who had taken over the empty servants' quarters up the back stairs. 
 &bquo;Poor dears, bombed out three times, didn't know which way to turn. 
 But at least they're together now.&equo; 
 The young woman from the coach-house came in and helped Loopy Lil wash dishes in the scullery while her baby sat on the floor chewing on a bone. 
 The baby was fat and red-faced. 
 It roared if anyone went near it. 
 Dot didn't go near. 
 But she went everywhere else, and wherever she went in house or gardens, the grown-ups smiled and said, &bquo;Good day!&equo;, and asked how she was. 
 Nobody told her to be off, or lay off, or push off, or not to touch, or to be careful. 
 I'm getting sound as a roach, Dot told herself. 
 The gardener found her a length of binding twine in a shed so that she could learn to skip. 
 And the young woman let her tie the grizzling baby into the bath-chair and wheel it around the courtyard to look at the hens. 
 Dot had lived like this for ever. 
 The days of reading and resting, of sewing and eating and growing, merged one into the next. 
 She didn't miss Gloria. 
 This was where she lived now. 
 It would be like this for ever, no change, the pattern was fixed. 
 She was stronger than a roach, as strong as an  ox. 
 No one would ever cut pieces off her while she slept. 
 Then came the snow and she had to stay in and watch from the window how it piled up against the water butt, how it lay like a blanket along the sills, how it changed the distance from bluey brown to white as far as you could see. 
 Her finger tips turned white as bone, her lips became chapped, and the air was so cold it hurt to breathe. 
 The baby went back to its yelling on the scullery floor. 
 &bquo;My dear! 
 Have you ever seen such a fall as this!&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye as she carried the tea-tray through to the drawing-room. 
 &bquo;I've just measured it with my knitting tape. 
 Six and a half inches! 
 The poor dogs hardly know what to make of it. 
 And the postman says he only just made it through.&equo; 
 Loopy Lil got stuck in a drift on her way back from the farm with the milk. 
 &bquo;So now, my dears, there's two of you to warm up by the fire!&equo; 
 Through the snow strode a visitor. 
 He came in at the side door as though he knew his own way. 
 &bquo;You'll find her in the drawing-room,&equo; Dot heard Mrs Hollidaye say. 
 &bquo;Yes, she's simply full of beans now.&equo; 
 He didn't wear a white jacket like hospital doctors but a heavy greatcoat with the collar turned up and boots dampened with slush. 
 But Dot knew he was a doctor because his hands smelled clean and soapy. 
 First he sat on the sofa and talked to the dogs. 
 He knew them both by name. 
 Dot took no notice of him. 
 But then he asked her what she was knitting, so she had to answer him, and after that she agreed to let him tap her chest with his rubber hammer, peer into her ears with his pencil light, and press the back of her tongue with one of Mrs Hollidaye's silver apostle teaspoons. 
 &bquo;Say aah!&equo; he said. 
 Then he said, &bquo;Aaha, definitely harvesting time. 
 Ripe and ready for removal, I'd say and not a minute too soon. 
 Miss Dorothy, you've done very well.&equo; 
 When the doctor had gone, Dot said, &bquo;I got to go back in the hospital, ain't I, Mrs H?&equo;  
 &bquo;Yes, my dear. 
 Dr Trees thinks you're ready.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well you want to know something? 
 I were just pretending to him, because I ain't really full of beans. 
 Truth is, I'm still ever so peaky. 
 And them other doctors said I weren't to go back up London for no operation not till I was Al, else I'd be dead as a herring.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye seemed not to have heard. 
 She merely suggested there'd be time for a game of spillikins before supper. 
 After Dot had won two rounds, Mrs Hollidaye said, &bquo;We'll have supper early this evening. 
 You'll need to take a bath tonight, won't you, my dear, so as to be clean as a new pin for tomorrow.&equo; 
 &bquo;Tomorrow! 
 Ain't I going back up London then?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, dear. 
 Dr Trees has most kindly arranged your admission to our local hospital.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, no! 
 I ain't going there. 
 Not on your life.&equo; 
 To have to submit to having a part of one's body removed while one slept was going to be bad. 
 But to have to allow it to be done in a strange place was impossible. 
 Dot knew she couldn't be brave enough for that. 
 &bquo;If I got to have it done, I'll go back to the place I was before, back down the Duke's Ferry Road. 
 Where Baby was and all.&equo; 
 &bquo;You'll find they're very good. 
 Miss Lilian had her teeth done there.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye steadily poured tea. 
 &bquo;You're booked into what we call the Princess Elizabeth Children's Annexe. 
 We had a silver subscription for the bedspreads and curtains. 
 That's Elizabeth, after our royal princess, you know.&equo; 
 &bquo;'Course I know,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;She lives at Buckingham Palace.&equo; 
 &bquo;Then I dare say you also know, my dear, what Princess Elizabeth said during the blitz? 
 How splendidly full of cheerfulness and courage all you young London children are. 
 So that's why they've named the new wing after her. 
 To remind you. 
 For that is exactly how you are going to face tomorrow, aren't you? 
 Full of courage!&equo;  
 It was all so planned. 
 Dot could see no way out. 
 Only a raid could save her now. 
 Or perhaps there was something else? 
 She ran from the room and up to her bedroom where the windows were kept open all day to destroy the germs. 
 It was as cold as an old grave. 
 Dot stood by the open window. 
 &bquo;God in heaven,&equo; she said, for Mrs Hollidaye had explained how you could speak to the good Lord and sometimes the good Lord spoke back. 
 &bquo;God in heaven, let it snow. 
 And snow and always snow and block up all the paths and roads, fields and ditches.&equo;  
 At the Princess Elizabeth 
 The snow stayed. 
 It was her friend. 
 Dot woke on that morning that could have been the last morning of her life and knew by the brightness reflected across the ceiling that she was safe, for the roads would still be blocked. 
 She slid joyfully down from the bed and hopped across the cold carpet to the window. 
 The lawns were as smooth and white as yesterday, and the meadow as white, and a 1 the fields away to the marshes on the faraway horizon. 
 And even beyond would be snowbound, perhaps right as far as the sea. 
 The snow had made the gardens silent, though not inactive. 
 Mrs Hollidaye had pointed out how one could see creatures even more clearly when they were silhouetted as in a shadow cut-out. 
 A blackbird with its beak gleaming golden against the white, scuttled out from under the rhododendron bushes making a flurry of snow slither off the broad leaves. 
 Then the brownish scurrying of a hare across the top of spiky snow-blown grass. 
 Overhead a seagull circled the treetops, pale feathers shining against the dark grey of a flat sky. 
 And Dot saw something else alive and moving out there too, brown yet larger than a hare. 
 The huddled figure shambled alongside the yew hedge towards the wicket gate. 
 A curious tramplike person wrapped against the weather in an old shawl. 
 Mrs Hollidaye's shawl. 
 But it was not Mrs Hollidaye. 
 It was Loopy Lil. 
 What was she doing? 
 Where was she off to before her breakfast? 
 After Loopy Lil's lurching figure had disappeared, her footprints were left behind in the lawn, not soft white marks  like all week, but brownish foot-shaped prints. 
 Plod, plod, spoiling the tidiness. 
 Downstairs the range was blazing, porridge steaming, eggs coddling. 
 &bquo;Snow's still here!&equo; said Dot cheerfully. 
 &bquo;And I seen two gulls. 
 Black-heads. 
 Long way from home, ain't they?&equo; 
 &bquo;I expect they're hungry,&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye. 
 &bquo;And searching for food, the poor mites. 
 There you are, my dear.&equo; 
 She placed the porridge bowl in front of Dot with a dollop of honey in the middle and some cream on the edge. 
 Dot watched the honey and cream dissolve and trickle like two rivers to join in a silver and golden spreading lake. 
 &bquo;That's the way, a good breakfast. 
 We'll need it today. 
 Long drive.&equo; 
 The porridge changed. 
 The honey and the cream disappeared into a mess of grey. 
 &bquo;That snow, it don't look no better,&equo; Dot said. 
 &bquo;Still blinking bad.&equo; 
 &bquo;I believe it is  relenting, my dear, just an iota and the forecast is certainly more optimistic. 
 We should be fine on the road if we leave plenty of time. 
 I've sent Miss Lilian to do a recce.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye, supping porridge with her back to the flaming range and her face towards the window exclaimed, &bquo;Why do look, Dorothy! 
 Here's our friend Mister Coal Tit back again. 
 Now I do wonder where he's been.&equo; 
 The small birds clustered tightly on the swinging coconut were fighting for a firm grip. 
 And beneath their feeding place where yesterday had been snowy white, was today damp and brown with mud and warm droppings. 
 &bquo;Ready for your eggs now, my dear?&equo; 
 But a distant sickness, a mild headache, had taken Dot's appetite. 
 The pain in her jaw had come back. 
 Or was it in her ear? 
 Or in her throat? 
 She never could locate it. 
 Her spoon dropped listlessly back into the dull porridge lake. 
 &bquo;Never mind, Dorothy. 
 You sit cosily by the range till we're ready. 
 Ah, and here's Miss Lilian back now like the angel of good tidings.&equo;  
 Loopy Lil blew in through the side door like a bundle of old rags with tiny crystals of white on her woollen hood. 
 &bquo;What's that if it ain't snow?&equo; 
 Dot demanded. 
 &bquo;Sleet. 
 Yes, the weather's definitely taking a turn for the better. 
 Well, don't just stand there, Lilian dear. 
 Come on in. 
 We need that door closed.&equo; 
 The bearer of bad tidings fumbled with her layers of damp shawls and Dot felt fear on all sides till she was suffocated, as though lying beneath collapsed building rubble. 
 She was trapped. 
 She could do nothing to help herself. 
 The driveway was still snowed up, but once they reached the road there was a narrow track between high mounds on each side. 
 Loopy Lil came too. 
 Someone had to wipe the inside of the windscreen clear of condensation and clear the outside of the build-up of brown slush. 
 The journey began but wouldn't end. 
 Dot pulled the tartan rug up over her face to breathe the smell of dogs. 
 She had to have something to hold on to when she disappeared into the black hospital pit. 
 Mrs Hollidaye was not her next-of-kin so she wasn't allowed to take Dot further than the main entrance where she handed her briskly over to the care of a nurse. 
 Dot would have liked to have had a hand to hold. 
 Instead, she clutched tightly to the handle of the suitcase Mrs Hollidaye had lent her and followed the nurse along broad passages to a bright room where a group of children, all with suitcases and well wrapped in outdoor clothing, stood huddled like refugees from a foreign land waiting to be told where to go next. 
 &bquo;Come along, children, we can't stand around like lost dogs all day. 
 We've got work to do! 
 Come now, coats off!&equo; 
 Two were giggling together and seemed to know each other. 
 Dot envied them. 
 She glanced towards the window to catch a glimpse of Mrs Hollidaye's car but the windows, though clear glass, gave on to an enclosed garden with bare rose bushes poking up like black twigs through the slush.  
 Dot was shown to her bed where a notice was taped with pink sticking plaster to the end rail. 
 She recognized her name but not the other word. 
 &bquo;What's it say?&equo; she asked the nurse who was smoothing out fresh sheets. 
 &bquo;Tonsillectomy&equo;,&equo; said the nurse. 
 &bquo;It's what you're in for, isn't it?&equo; 
 Dot looked at the other children's beds. 
 They all had this word. 
 Everybody was here for the same thing to be done to them. 
 &bquo;What time?&equo; 
 Dot asked the nurse. 
 &bquo;There's a clock up there on the wall, can't you see?&equo; 
 Dot tried again. 
 &bquo;I mean, what time is the time they do it. 
 When they put us to sleep. 
 I got to know.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, not today! 
 The docs have all gone off long ago.&equo; 
 &bquo;Tomorrow, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;I dare say. 
 All depends. 
 Can you help tuck in that sheet your side? 
 Thanks. 
 You have to be under observation, all of you, for twelve hours beforehand. 
 Didn't they tell you? 
 Then you have to have twelve hours fasting too.&equo; 
 Dot didn't know what fasting was. 
 &bquo;Not eating nor drinking anything, not even so much as a crumb. 
 Else you may choke.&equo; 
 Dot wished someone had told Mrs Hollidaye this before, then she wouldn't have wasted all that food feeding her up. 
 &bquo;They wheel you down in batches, two at a time, throughout ops day. 
 All right?&equo; 
 How? 
 Dot wondered. 
 In pairs marching side by side, or one behind the other? 
 Who would be paired with who? 
 Would the two who already knew each other be together? 
 &bquo;Don't look so worried. 
 It may never happen!&equo; 
 &bquo;Why wouldn't it?&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I don't mean it like that. 
 I mean it's not as bad as you think. 
 You won't know a thing about it. 
 You'll be Harry flatters, out like a light.&equo; 
 Dot already knew about hospitals. 
 Everything you feared might happen, did happen, only worse. 
 Now that she was back in one, it felt as though she'd never been outside.  
 Soon, all twenty children were in their beds, stiff in their laundered nightgowns, without having been offered any supper, nor even as much as a sly sip of water. 
 The hands of the clock on the wall dragged round. 
 Dot had time to worry. 
 What if she died like Baby? 
 She didn't mind about that so long as she got a lovely little grave like Mrs Hollidaye's baby daughter. 
 But she knew that Gloria wouldn't think to give her one. 
 Out of sight, out of mind, is what Gloria would say. 
 Dot wished she'd been given a bed nearer one of the windows so she could see out, or at least by the door. 
 A great big boy was in the bed by the door. 
 When the lights were turned out he began crying. 
 &bquo;I want my Mummy,&equo; he wailed. 
 &bquo;Don't worry, you'll be seeing her again soon,&equo; said a nurse. 
 Not if he dies, he won't, Dot thought and felt better to realize that at least she wasn't frightened by that. 
 Next day, Dot was made to lie on a high hard bed in a glittery room without windows and they pressed a black rubber bowl over her face which smelled like the inside of her gas-mask. 
 But instead of protecting her from attack, this mask forced the gas at her, rushing it up into her face with a sinister hissing. 
 As she began to choke she kicked and struggled for breath before tumbling down into nowhere. 
 But after that, life began again and it was easy to feel full of courage and cheerfulness. 
 They gave the children white ice-cream and red jelly, and brightly coloured drinks clinking with chunks of ice. 
 They let them slide around on the polished floor and listen to music on the ward radio. 
 There was a cupboard full of toys and a shelf of books. 
 It wasn't at all like staying in hospital.  
 Marrow Jam for Tea 
 After Mrs Hollidaye had fetched Dot from the Princess Elizabeth, she told her, &bquo;Your mother telephoned, my dear. 
 She would like you home with her now. 
 Isn't that simply grand?&equo; 
 &bquo;Home?&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;I explained it was a bit of a flap to go for the train this afternoon. 
 So we'll pop you on the first one tomorrow.&equo; 
 Tomorrow was too soon. 
 &bquo;What if I don't want to go?&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;Yes, I do know, my dear, it's always difficult, isn't it? 
 Having to do things one doesn't want.&equo; 
 &bquo;I can't go back,&equo; Dot said. 
 &bquo; Please , Mrs H, I want to be here, stay with you. 
 And the dogs. 
 And Miss Lilian.&equo; 
 She thought, I don't belong there any more. 
 Mrs Hollidaye said, &bquo;Yes, wouldn't that be splendid?&equo; 
 The conversation was over. 
 She said, &bquo;High time to start a new pot of jam. 
 Let's see what we have left. 
 Come, will you, my dear, and help choose?&equo; 
 Dot followed Mrs Hollidaye into the larder. 
 How could she be concerned about the choice of jam? 
 &bquo;Mrs Parvis hates me. 
 I heard her say I ain't worth the air I breathe.&equo; 
 &bquo;So which is it to be? 
 Quince, cranberry jelly, mulberry? 
 What a decision.&equo; 
 &bquo;And anyway Gloria don't want me neither.&equo; 
 Gloria still wanted Baby, the apple of her eye. 
 &bquo;See, she's an usherette now, so she don't have time for me no more.&equo; 
 &bquo;My dear, it's probably hard for you to understand, but your mother is very young. 
 And confused. 
 And she needs you.&equo;  
 While Loopy Lil and Mrs Hollidaye were organizing tea, Dot walked slowly round the gardens, dragging her shoes through crunchy heaps of left-behind snow. 
 Mrs Hollidaye was incapable of understanding how the thought of having to leave tomorrow hung on Dot's shoulders like a heavy woollen cloak of despair. 
 Leaving, said the rooks cawing, leaving, said the trees, leaving, said the pigeons, to leave, leave, leave, said the hens behind their wire enclosure. 
 It gave her a dull all-over pain more acute than any kind of real pain. 
 In the fading light, she began to see things she'd not noticed before. 
 How 
 the bark of the oaks was not brown but pale gold; how primroses were nestling safely amongst tussocks of bristly dry grass. 
 How the leaves which still clung to the branches of the pear tree were silvered on their undersides. 
 There was nothing like this back at Mrs Parvis's. 
 Back at Mrs Parvis's was an indoor world. 
 Dot remembered how the bowl of each spoon at Mrs Parvis's was stained a streaky brown, and bent crooked at the shaft, with NAAFI stamped on the handle. 
 She remembered how the table around which they sat at High Tea, was covered with a sheet of speckled grey lino which had a strange stickiness. 
 When you touched it with the edge of your hand, your skin felt as though it had become attached so that you were in danger of becoming a part of Mrs Parvis's table for ever. 
 In Mrs Parvis's parlour there were greasy patches on the chairs which she covered with little cloths. 
 Along the narrow landing at Mrs Parvis's were laid pieces of carpet to cover the cracks in the lino. 
 At Mrs Parvis's the metal meat-safe hanging from its nail outside the basement room never contained meat, only sausages and suet, with bluebottles buzzing round. 
 How could Mrs Hollidaye consider allowing Dot to return to that unsafe place where the air robbed your cheeks of their roses, where buildings collapsed though the bombs had long since stopped, where there was no glass in half the windows, no water in the taps, where nothing was  quite what it seemed to be. 
 At Mrs Parvis's, things were often pretending to be other things, like Mrs Parvis saying one thing when she meant another, things were hiding other things, like scraps of rug concealing cracks, white glass windows concealing sick children. 
 &bquo;And nobody don't want me there anyhow,&equo; Dot finished out loud. 
 She would stay, here where things were what they seemed to be, where trees were trees, hens were hens. 
 She went indoors and sat hunched in her coat and mittens on the sofa by the drawing-room fire. 
 &bquo;I ain't going, Mrs H,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;A million horses ain't going to drag me back there. 
 And there's him  too. 
 When he  turns up, he  ain't going to want me neither. 
 I don't even know what he looks like.&equo; 
 &bquo;Bread and jam, my dear?&equo; said Mrs Hollidaye as though she still had her cloth-ears on. 
 &bquo;Lilian dear, what about you? 
 It's the new marrow and ginger, Dorothy and I chose it this afternoon. 
 Or there's just a little honey left? 
 But we'll save the fresh comb for Dorothy to take back tomorrow.&equo; 
 &bquo;What if I go and don't never get to come back?&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;You'll miss me. 
 Then you'll be sorry.&equo; 
 She sounded like Mrs Parvis, saying one thing yet meaning another. 
 &bquo;Nonsense. 
 Of course you'll come back. 
 Everybody always comes back. 
 It's going to be exciting to see your mother again. 
 You'll be able to tell her all the news.&equo; 
 What news would interest Gloria? 
 Would she want to know about the flowering of the pink camellia and its glossy leaves, about the goat running away, about the double-yolked egg? 
 She might pretend to listen but she wouldn't hear. 
 The two places were quite separate. 
 News of one didn't transmit to the other. 
 Mrs Hollidaye spooned some chunks of marrow on to a slice of bread, cut it in half, and put it gently into Dot's hand. 
 &bquo;Eat up, there's a good girl. 
 I know, leaving is always hard.&equo;  
 Dot took the bread and sniffed. 
 &bquo;It hurts. 
 Like real hurt. 
 Much worse than being ill.&equo; 
 &bquo;My dear, that's good. 
 You must hold on to the hurt. 
 It s a sign of growing up.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I don't want it like this. 
 I want it to be like it was before.&equo; 
 Lying in bed and being looked after and enveloped in love, by day and by night. 
 &bquo;Like I was your little girl. 
 Like the one what died.&equo; 
 She flung herself crying on to Mrs Hollidaye's lap, knocking Mrs Hollidaye's afternoon hat sideways. 
 Mrs Hollidaye straightened it, but let Dot stay. 
 &bquo;You have to remember, Dorothy, that I am your friend. 
 I am not your mother. 
 Why, I'm old enough to be your grandmother! 
 I cannot keep you here when your mother wants and needs you. 
 However, even when you're faraway, this place will still remain, you'll still see it. 
 That way, you have the benefit of both.&equo; 
 &bquo;How?&equo; 
 &bquo;Wipe your nose first, and then I'll tell you something that happened to me. 
 A long time ago. 
 About leaving a place when I felt torn between two people I loved. 
 You see, unlike you who has lived in so many places and seen so much, I had never lived anywhere except at my parents&equo; home. 
 I knew every corner and I loved that house so much. 
 I loved him so much too. 
 I was so excited to be a young bride going off on tour to Europe. 
 Then to a new home waiting for me. 
 But after the marriage and the party, when it was time, the brougham was already waiting for us at the front door, I couldn't bear to leave. 
 Like you now, I felt that I might never come back. 
 Or, even if I did, that things would be different.&equo; 
 &bquo;Did you cry?&equo; 
 &bquo;Goodness gracious me, no! 
 That would never have done. 
 Why, it would have made everyone else so sad. 
 I had to keep the hurt to myself. 
 But my nurse knew.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your nurse ? 
 If you were ill, why did they make you go away?&equo;  
 &bquo;Not a sick-nurse. 
 My nursemaid, the servant who looked after me. 
 She helped me dress in my new going-away outfit before I went down to say goodbye to my parents. 
 She must have known about the hurt of leaving, for she said, Don't worry, Miss Charlotte. 
 You'll be taking this whole place with you. 
 Whenever you miss it, you close your eyes and you'll find it right there in front of you. 
 You'll see, Miss Charlotte, she told me, how you can walk into every room, check in every cupboard, count the books in your father's library, just as though you were really there.&equo; 
 &bquo;So what did you do?&equo; 
 &bquo;I straightened my back, and I walked down the stairs to my parents and I said goodbye to them and to the servants lined up on the front steps. 
 I still didn't entirely believe my nursie. 
 She was up at the window looking out. 
 But I found 
 Dot found that she had stopped crying and was sitting upright, eating the slice of bread and marrow jam. 
 That evening, when Mrs Hollidaye crept into Dot's bedroom to damp down the fire for the night and check that the guard was securely in place, she had filled a trug basket with garden produce. 
 &bquo;For tomorrow, my dear,&equo; she whispered. 
 &bquo;I'll put it here by the chair so we don't forget.&equo; 
 There was a posy of pale spring flowers wrapped in damp newspaper to keep them fresh, a bag of potatoes tied with bristly twine, six eggs in a carton, carrots unearthed from the sandheap in which they had lain stored against invasion of the wire-worm, and a selection of dessert apples, no mere windfalls but blemish-free bests, each polished to a rosy sheen by Loopy Lil. 
 &bquo;You know, my dear,&equo; Mrs Hollidaye said, sitting on the edge of the bed and taking Dot's hand. 
 &bquo;I've often thought that each person is rather like a different vessel out at sea. 
 Some are little dinghys, others great ocean liners. 
 Or paddle steamers, or cork rafts.&equo; 
 &bquo;You mean, like we're all boats? '  said Dot, surprised. 
 &bquo;That's it. 
 Or ships. 
 Once out on the big seas of life, we  each have to do the best we can, whether we have sails, or engines, or nothing but a wooden paddle. 
 I daresay your brother was like my daughter, a pretty little flower petal bobbing along. 
 He wasn't meant to keep afloat for ever. 
 While you, Dorothy my dear, started out as a small tub, straight into deep choppy waters, with quite a few holes in the bottom, no rudder, no sails. 
 You were scarcely seaworthy. 
 But somehow you were unsinkable. 
 Then you were towed into harbour. 
 Now you've been patched up, your hull's been scraped, a lick of paint and you're ready to get back into the great sea of life. 
 Well, goodnight, my dear.&equo; 
 She bent and kissed Dot on her forehead.  
 Coming Home 
 The train rattled through the suburbs, then slid between the brick backs of tall tenement blocks where Dot could look right in the windows at women standing by their kitchen sinks. 
 Then it rumbled along a bridge, so Dot could see into the friendly clutter of people's back yards, down into bomb-sites to view the mystery of chaos. 
 They said there was a fuel shortage. 
 But Dot saw plenty of coal heaped up beside the tracks in so many different shades of black. 
 Big shiny chunks, thin pale nuggets, dull velvety dust, huge rocks like slippery ice. 
 At home in the country, Dot thought, we burn wood, chestnut limbs that spit and hiss in the drawing-room, neat oak logs in the bedrooms that quietly glow through the night. 
 The train passed a fire station, a brewery, and over the wide murky river. 
 Gloria was late. 
 But the station felt safer than it used to, though nothing had changed except Dot herself. 
 She saw the same high empty space between the ground and the broken glass roof, she recognized the air which smelled of soot and coal-smoke and was thick as grey soup, and the mottled pigeon-droppings and the grey suits of men, the black hats. 
 She staggered with the laden trug to where the buffers stood up like huge metal pennies on their sides preventing the train from going any further. 
 London was not on the way to somewhere else. 
 London was the centre to which all tracks, all travellers, all patched-up dinghy boats, were lead. 
 Dot had been away and now she had come back.  
 Patiently she waited beside the ticket collector till Gloria came running breathlessly across the station towards her. 
 She had her best shoes on, and a new hat. 
 She had her hair in a new way too, short and brushed upwards. 
 It made her look different, almost like a stranger. 
 &bquo;Hello, duckie, so here we are large as life and twice as handsome. 
 That train must have been in ever so early.&equo; 
 She smiled at the ticket collector. 
 &bquo;Here pet, better let me take some of your things.&equo; 
 She took Dot's carriers and Dot carried the trug basket. 
 Dot said, &bquo;Mrs Hollidaye gave me the money for a cab.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ooh, just hark at you, speaking all lah-de-dah!&equo; 
 Gloria giggled. 
 &bquo;You gone and got yourself a posh accent, just like Mrs H herself.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, I haven't,&equo; said Dot, wondering if she had. 
 &bquo;Anyway, you've gone and changed yourself too. 
 Your hair's gone yellow.&equo; 
 &bquo;Had it bleached. 
 Does it suit? 
 Incendiary blonde,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;So how much she give you, then?&equo; 
 &bquo;Five bob.&equo; 
 &bquo;You don't want to go wasting that on a taxi. 
 We can get a number nine easy enough. 
 Split the difference on a cuppa, shall we? 
 Let's pop into the Corner House.&equo; 
 She lead the way through swirling traffic. 
 &bquo;All right by you, duckie? 
 You'd like a nice sticky bun and some tea, wouldn't you?&equo; 
 In the spacious tea-rooms, a sparkling light was suspended from the ceiling, a man in a suit played the piano and most customers wore hats even daintier than Gloria's new one. 
 But nobody was encumbered with the bounty of the countryside tied up with old newspaper and garden string. 
 Dot shoved the trug out of sight under their table before the waitress saw. 
 &bquo;I got the afternoon off,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;So there's no hurry on us to get back quick. 
 Since we're in town, we might as well enjoy ourselves while we got the chance. 
 What d'you say to taking in a picture after?&equo; 
 A waitress scuttled past carrying a cake-stand stacked  with glistening and brightly coloured cakes and pastries. 
 &bquo;Haven't seen the like of that for a while then, have we?&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Ooh and listen, he's playing the melody from that new film. 
 Ooh, did I cry at the end!&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye was right. 
 Dot did still have the garden with her. 
 The dark shape of the yew silhouetted against the corner of the window was quite clear. 
 She could even see a thrush pecking out a scarlet yew berry, swallowing the scarlet flesh and spitting out the poisonous pip. 
 And she could hear the rooks cawing too. 
 She didn't tell Gloria about it. 
 Gloria was busy tapping her feet in time to the music. 
 &bquo;Just like old times, ain't it, before you was took so poorly,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Hey, what's pecking at you, pet, giving that long face? 
 You ain't gone and got yourself worked up into a glum mood, have you now?&equo; 
 Dot thought how she belonged in the country. 
 Now she had to belong here too. 
 &bquo;No, 'course not,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;I'm glad to be back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, that's something anyhow. 
 Though you look as though you could do with something to perk you up. 
 Bit of frolic, that's what you been missing.&equo; 
 The waitress came to take their order. 
 &bquo;Go on then, duckie,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;Which one d'you fancy? 
 Don't hold back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ta,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;I'll have one of them with the pink on top.&equo;  
 The Fathers 
 Dot was pleased when the Children's Officer called at the basement and said she was strong enough to start school. 
 She remembered things from when she'd been to school before. 
 But she found it was a different school with different faces. 
 Many of these children had been attending for a long time, so they already knew many things, specially the important things like how to stand in line and what to do when your pen-nib broke. 
 There were good things at school too, cooked dinners every day and milk if you took your own mug. 
 Dot didn't have a milk-mug but the teacher lent her one. 
 The dinners came by van in metal tins. 
 The milk came in a can and the teacher shared it out with a ladle. 
 Certain children, whose names were on a list, were called up once a day to be given yellow capsules which had to be swallowed in front of the teacher. 
 Dot was among them. 
 She chewed hers and found it contained cod liver oil. 
 At first, Gloria took Dot along the road to school but it was often difficult for Gloria to get out of bed in time, so they arrived late. 
 &bquo;Miss don't like me being late,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;She says I got a lot of catching up to do. 
 I think I'll go on me own.&equo; 
 Gloria, under the blanket, agreed. 
 &bquo;Watch your P's and Q's, then,&equo; she mumbled. 
 A plumber came and installed a row of six washbasins in the cloakroom with running water, hot and cold at each, though they still had to run across the playground in all weathers to reach the outside lavatories. 
 The bars of new yellow soap and the new white linen roller-towels placed  beside the washbasins were marked, LCC. 
 Dot found she could read the letters and was surprised. 
 The desks had these same letters stamped into the metal brackets. 
 So did each sheet of lavatory paper which the teacher gave them if they asked, and the box of wax tapers for lighting the gas mantle. 
 Dot asked the teacher what LCC meant since it was written on so many things. 
 &bquo;London County Council, dear,&equo; said the teacher. 
 &bquo;That's good. 
 So you have been taught to read?&equo; 
 Dot said No, she didn't think so. 
 But then she found that she must have been without noticing, for she discovered that there was writing everywhere which she could read without even trying. 
 The coal-hole covers along the pavements had words on them. 
 So did the milk-float. 
 A whole sentence was painted on its side. 
 Express Dairies, the oldest dairy in London , it said. 
 There was a lot to look at, so she took a long time coming back after school, stopping to watch the men mending holes in the roads, to watch the demolition team with their mighty metal ball swinging on its chain from the crane clearing the bomb-site, to watch carpenters erecting wooden hoardings around the cleared sites to keep the people out, to see bill-stickers on ladders pasting huge coloured pictures on to the hoardings. 
 She could read them all, Oxo , Rinso, O-Cedar , and Aero , even if she didn't always understand what they meant. 
 Then she dawdled through the mews where the milk-horses were shod, and the blacksmith made new railings to put in front of the houses. 
 But she had given up telling Gloria about what went on each day. 
 Gloria wasn't interested. 
 &bquo;I got things on me mind just now, ducks,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Can't you see?&equo; 
 She was always rushing off to the Housing Applicant Office and the interviews took a long time. 
 &bquo;There's a lot of other people after the same thing,&equo; Gloria explained. 
 Then one afternoon she came in smiling.  
 &bquo;They're giving us the extra points! 
 Because of your health, pet, they're putting us on the priority list, say we didn't ought to be below-ground, nor too high. 
 Ground floor, they say on account of your chest. 
 They're going to start building lots of new flats. 
 Over the river, near the stray dogs&equo; home. 
 They say we might get to have one. 
 Two bedrooms, indoor toilets, hot and cold running to kitchen, so you'll be able to wash your hands whenever you want.&equo; 
 Dot didn't tell her that at school they already had hot and cold water and she could wash her hands and face at any time. 
 &bquo;Sixteen and sixpence a week. 
 Mind you, I don't know where we'll find that.&equo; 
 The rent to Mrs Parvis was only ten shillings. 
 &bquo;But once your father comes home, things'll start perking up, won't they?&equo; 
 But being on a priority list didn't, after all, seem to make any difference. 
 They went on waiting. 
 &bquo;Fat lot of use that office is. 
 All hot air and not much more,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;There's hundreds of us on priority. 
 They ain't got nothing for us. 
 D'you know, me and your Dad, we had a lovely home out at the start. 
 A beautiful room, all our own. 
 Pink curtains we had there and ever such a nice tea service. 
 Then there I was come back from ante-natal and it was blown clean away. 
 Funny how you forget things when you ain't got them no more.&equo; 
 Dot thought, I've forgotten his face. 
 But I haven't forgotten he's coming back. 
 At the school, there were two other girls whose fathers had not yet returned. 
 Then, in the playground, one of them whispered, &bquo;Mine ain't coming back. 
 Ever. 
 My Nan told me last night.&equo; 
 Dot envied her. 
 Viv didn't seem upset about it either. 
 She just shrugged. 
 &bquo;He died or something, I don't know.&equo; 
 Then a few days later, the other girl, Sally, came dancing across the playground and said she'd just got hers back. 
 &bquo;He was in a camp. 
 He's a bit thin, though.&equo; 
 &bquo;Where he been?&equo; 
 Dot asked. 
 She had seen pictures in the newspaper that Mrs Parvis had delivered every day of men  and women who'd been kept locked up in a camp till the Americans came and found them. 
 They were thin. 
 Had Sally's father been in one of those places too, in striped pyjamas with shaven head? 
 &bquo;No, not him. 
 Them's the Jews you're thinking of. 
 Mine was in Burma,&equo; said Sally. 
 &bquo;That's ever such a long way off,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;I expect.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yeah, it was hot over there and he didn't have nothing to eat except rats. 
 That's what he says. 
 I dunno if he's making it up. 
 You can't eat rats. 
 D'you want to come and have a look at him?&equo; 
 She was so proud of this father. 
 She talked about him all day. 
 Then she invited Dot and three others to walk home with her after school. 
 She lived in a big old tenement block. 
 They climbed up to the top floor and stood around in the corridor while Sally went in to fetch him out. 
 &bquo;Here he is!&equo; she said at last. 
 &bquo;My Daddy!&equo; 
 A thing appeared in the doorway beside her. 
 It looked to Dot more like a skeleton in clothes than a father. 
 He had heavy army trousers held up with a huge leather belt and a thick army shirt. 
 Inside the clothes there was nothing. 
 Brown sticks stuck out of the sleeves where there should have been wrists and his head was like a hard dry acorn, sun-burned and bald, no hair. 
 The children backed away. 
 They didn't know what to do. 
 Then the mouth opened and the father's skull smiled. 
 That was the worst bit. 
 The other three turned and bolted off down the stairs. 
 Dot stayed just long enough to smile back. 
 He was so thin he looked like even the birds wouldn't want to peck at him. 
 He looked as though he'd crack if you touched him. 
 &bquo;See you tomorrow,&equo; she called to Sally but couldn't think of anything to say to the man, so she ran off after the others. 
 Next morning, Dot was surprised when Gloria got up early and left for the Housing Applicant Office the same time as she went to school. 
 &bquo;They're running a draw for the houses,&equo; Gloria explained. 
 &bquo;A draw?&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;A lucky dip like. 
 They ain't got enough homes. 
 They  want to make it fair. 
 We're each going to get a ticket. 
 I just know it's me lucky day.&equo; 
 In the evening Gloria cried a bit when she came home. 
 Dot comforted her. 
 She had waited all day in a hall with her lottery number. 
 But it hadn't been her lucky day after all. 
 Her name wasn't picked from the hat. 
 &bquo;All I wanted was to get moved in somewhere nice before he comes back.&equo; 
 Dot wanted to tell her how they were much better staying just as they were. 
 No home. 
 No father. 
 Gloria had missed High Tea. 
 Wearily she took off her stockings and hung them on the back of the chair to get ready for bed. 
 She inspected her bare feet and started to paint the toe-nails. 
 Dot watched as her mother applied the shiny flame-red lacquer to each toe-nail. 
 &bquo;You're getting yourself ready for him coming back, ain't you!&equo; 
 Dot said. 
 She had decided what must have happened to him, why he was taking so long to return, and why she could never recall his face. 
 &bquo;He were a pilot, weren't he?&equo; she said. 
 A fuel tank had exploded. 
 He had caught alight. 
 &bquo;Got his face all burned up. 
 Like them men we saw on the newsreel, ain't he?&equo; 
 Gloria snapped back, &bquo;No, I told you before, he weren't never a pilot. 
 Never went up in the air. 
 Though don't you go thinking, just because a fellow don't get airborne, didn't stop me liking him. 
 In my own way.&equo; 
 And she went back to her painting. 
 Dot stroked her mother's other white leg stretched out along the bed, with the varnish drying on the toes now like five scarlet flames. 
 &bquo;You got ever such nice legs,&equo; Dot said. 
 &bquo;Hope I get legs like yours when I grow up.&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh, leave me alone with your silly talk, can't you!&equo; said Gloria, then softened and gave Dot's cheek a gentle pinch. 
 &bquo;Your Dad once said how I had legs like Betty Grable. 
 So you'll have to put on a bit more flesh if you want filmstar legs. 
 Still, you're coming along, aren't you now?&equo; 
 Dot wanted to know, if he wasn't a pilot, what did he do?  
 &bquo;He were a rigger, supposed to be.&equo; 
 Dot didn't know what a rigger was. 
 &bquo;Important job. 
 Planes can't take off without the rigger there to pull away the chocks. 
 Maybe he'll tell you about it himself some time.&equo; 
 Dot hoped not.  
 The Dancer in the Street 
 Next day there was music outside school. 
 After the register, the evening prayer, the curtsies and bows to teachers, and the let-out bell, Dot ran with the others across the playground, through the iron gate, towards the jangling sounds. 
 Clustered on the narrow pavement were the waiting mothers with outstretched hands, the mothers with prams, the mothers with toddlers attached to their skirts. 
 Children surged forward to find the music. 
 Some mothers held their children tightly, letting them watch from a safe distance but not too close. 
 The dancing man was standing out in the middle of the road as though unaware of the scarlet double-decker which might trundle down the High Street at any moment to knock him down. 
 He had a monkey and a performing cat. 
 The monkey in a waistcoat was on a chain attached to the dancing man's belt. 
 The cat wore a jewelled collar. 
 He didn't seem to see the crowd of mothers and children watching him. 
 He ignored everything except his music-making, his monkey, and his cat. 
 He was a misshapen giant, hunch-backed by the drum attached to his shoulders which seemed to beat by itself. 
 His knees were distorted by brass cymbals attached on the inner leg. 
 Brass bells hung like bunches of ripe grapes to each thigh. 
 He played first a whistle, then a mouth organ, then a trumpet. 
 He seemed to have a score of hands and a hundred musical fingers. 
 His toes danced, his elbows danced. 
 His monkey skipped and pulled on its lead and held out a tin cup to the crowd.  
 He was the most beautiful creature Dot had ever seen, a creation of this city which was the centre of the world. 
 You'd never in a million years see a dancing man in a field in the country. 
 Yet when he trilled on the water-whistle, he seemed to create birds singing in the branches of invisible trees overhead. 
 &bquo;Well, fancy that!&equo; said one of the mothers. 
 &bquo;Haven't seen a one-man band since way back. 
 Times must be getting better.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's cruel,&equo; said another. 
 Dot thought at first she meant it was unkind for the man to be so constricted by the many instruments strapped to all parts of his body. 
 But she must have meant the monkey, for another mother said: 
 &bquo;It's only an animal. 
 It doesn't mind. 
 My brother saw monkeys when he was coming back through Gibraltar. 
 They were quite tame he said. 
 Look, it's smiling. 
 And I once saw a dancing bear when I was little. 
 It liked it, you could tell. 
 It really liked dancing.&equo; 
 Some of the mothers let their children dart forward to drop a penny in the monkey's mug, though none let their children too close. 
 Dot had no meeting mother to restrain her. 
 She was free to go as close to the man's music as she dared, to stare as long as she wanted, to dance on the kerb right beside him where he seemed so tall he almost blacked out the sky, and the music so overwhelming you could hear nothing else. 
 The others drifted away. 
 Dot stayed. 
 She longed to ask what was his monkey's name, though she knew she mustn't speak to strangers. 
 So, when still playing, still marking time with the great drum strapped to his back and clashing the cymbals, still rattling the bells, and making the melody with his mouth organ, he began to half-dance, half-walk down the middle of the road, she followed a few paces behind and safely on the pavement. 
 He never looked round. 
 He never asked for money. 
 Where would he go next? 
 Nobody stopped her following. 
 Perhaps they thought she was part of his troupe?  
 Where was he going? 
 Where were they now? 
 His music so changed the streets that the gas lamps looked brighter, the spiked railings more friendly, the painted front doors more brightly coloured than where she lived. 
 Then she saw how the Oxo boy on the advertisement hoarding smiled and she realized that they had come a different way by a different route and that she was nearly at Mrs Parvis's boarding house. 
 The dancing man stopped playing and as he turned to unbuckle the strap of his cymbals, he saw Dot was still behind him. 
 &bquo;You'd best go home now, lassie,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;Back to your Mum and Dad before they start to miss you.&equo; 
 Dot wanted to tell him that she hadn't got a dad. 
 But she knew that telling things the way you wanted them to be rather than the way they were didn't change anything for longer than the moment of the lie. 
 She said, &bquo;My Dad's not home from the war yet.&equo; 
 &bquo;He will be. 
 So you better be ready for him,&equo; said the dancing man. 
 Then he picked up his monkey and the cat and strode away with the bells on his knees jangling.  
 The man who Went to War 
 Dot was glad she'd been warned by the dancing man because there was no warning from Gloria. 
 In the morning Dot went off to school and he wasn't there. 
 In the afternoon, she came home and he was. 
 Mrs Parvis was standing out on the front doorstep, pretending to watch out for something in the sky. 
 Dot knew what she was really up to, waiting to be first with bad news. 
 She didn't like it when Dot slipped in unseen and with Mr Brown gone off to college, she hadn't so many people who would listen to her. 
 &bquo;He's back, then,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;What?&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;Not &bquo;what&equo;. 
 &bquo;Who&equo;.&equo; 
 Dot's heart began pounding, first with anxiety, then with an irrational hope that it just might be Mr Brown who was back. 
 &bquo;Downstairs. 
 Your Ma went to pick him up this morning.&equo; 
 Dot tried to edge by. 
 &bquo;So he'll be popping up to the palace with the rest of them, to pick up his medals.&equo; 
 But she said it as though she already knew different, for then, as though speaking to another invisible adult, she added, &bquo;I don't  think. 
 If there's one thing I've learned out of the past six years, it's that anybody can get out of anything if they try hard enough.&equo; 
 Dot managed to wriggle past and down the stairs, and there in the basement room sat the man in the drab, illfitting, demob suit. 
 He wasn't a smiling skullman, he wasn't a melted airman. 
 He had a blank sort of face, and that was about all there was to him. 
 No twinkling sky-blue eyes to match a  sky-blue uniform. 
 No bright rainbow of medal ribbons on his breast. 
 Dot knew from just looking at him that he was no hero, no villain either. 
 He wasn't anything much. 
 He was a nothing. 
 She felt almost relieved. 
 Maybe she'd known it all along. 
 There was that thing Mrs Hollidaye said, about how each person could only be brave in their own way and there wasn't room on earth for everybody to be a hero. 
 She'd told Dot there'd got to be the ordinary people too so that the few could be visibly valiant. 
 He was one of the ordinary ones. 
 Dot sat herself cross-legged on the bed and watched him perched on the chair by the window, blinking and twitching and fidgeting but never looking her way, then seeming to fall asleep and looking quite young, younger than Mr Brown anyhow, and certainly not at all like Sally's dad who'd been to Burma and eaten rats. 
 Gloria was next door making a pot of tea in Mrs Parvis's kitchen. 
 When she came in carrying the tin tea-tray with a scratched picture of Buckingham Palace, she whispered, &bquo;Don't stare like that. 
 It's not nice. 
 Haven't you no manners?&equo; 
 &bquo;Just trying to get used to him, ain't I? 
 He don't look too well, do he?&equo; 
 People used always to be saying that about her. 
 Now she could say it about someone else. 
 Slowly, he took off the jacket and folded it neatly into a rectangle which he placed on his knee. 
 Gloria took it from him to hang on the back of the door. 
 He sat down again on the very edge of the chair and they drank the tea in silence. 
 He moved slowly, like a tired man wading through cold water. 
 He didn't look at Dot. 
 He didn't look at Gloria either. 
 &bquo;We don't have much sugar left,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;D'you take sugar?&equo; 
 Then, &bquo;Mrs Parvis says she'd be obliged to have your ration book as soon as possible if you please.&equo; 
 Dot wanted to ask, He hasn't got a wooden leg has he? 
 But she knew he hadn't. 
 Some of those boisterous brave men with stretched paper faces, with stumpy two-pincered  hands, and tiny lidless eyes, had lost legs as well. 
 This one had both legs and all his fingers, yet you still felt there was something missing. 
 &bquo;And you better start calling me Mum,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;It'd be more natural like, now we're a family.&equo; 
 It didn't feel natural. 
 &bquo;And you call him Dad.&equo; 
 Dot wasn't going to call him anything. 
 That night, Dot was to sleep on two extra blankets folded over to make a thin mattress for he, the man, would be in the bed where Dot used to sleep. 
 It was not uncomfortable down on the floor, just lonely. 
 Dot used to have Gloria to snuggle up to in the dark. 
 Not any more. 
 Gloria had to belong with him now. 
 She tried not to wish he could go away even though the room was cramping them. 
 After school, she took as long as she could dawdling back. 
 He was still there lying down with his eyes shut. 
 Dot guessed he might have been only pretending. 
 Dot wondered if they'd been arguing. 
 She beckoned Gloria into the dark passage outside the room. 
 &bquo;You got to tell me,&equo; she whispered. 
 &bquo;Where's he been ? 
 Why's he like  that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Who's &bquo;He&equo;? 
 The cat's father? 
 I can't hear if you don't talk proper,&equo; said Gloria in a low voice. 
 &bquo;Speak nice and call him Dad.&equo; 
 &bquo;But what's wrong  with him?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh heck, ducks, you might as well know. 
 He was a nutter. 
 Went barmy in the army you might say!&equo; 
 She laughed, but it wasn't a real laugh. 
 &bquo;That place I took you, run by the military, that was like a sort of special asylum.&equo; 
 Dot didn't know what an asylum was. 
 She thought it was a kind of prison. 
 So had he done something wrong? 
 &bquo;Nervous collapse they called it. 
 He was a mental, couldn't even speak a threepenny bit.&equo; 
 Dot thought of Loopy Lil. 
 She was a mental. 
 She was also a safe and kind person to be with. 
 If her father got like that, then it might be all right.  
 &bquo;Loopy Lil's different,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;She were born that way. 
 Your old man started out OK. 
 When he got called up he was good as the best of them. 
 First time I see him in his uniform, he looked that lovely I could've eaten him alive. 
 It was thinking too much, about the fighting, what did for him, got him all confused. 
 It was a kind of illness, in the head.&equo; 
 Dot remembered what it was like when she had felt so ill and confused. 
 &bquo;He didn't like none of it, so he sort of copped out, gave up eating one fine day, till he couldn't stand up no more, couldn't do what he was told on the airfield. 
 Last war, men who did what he done, they called them deserters. 
 Used to take them out and shoot them in the head. 
 That cured their problems darn quick.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm glad they don't do that no more,&equo; Dot said. 
 She wondered, did Gloria still love him? 
 &bquo;What kind of funny question is that?&equo; 
 &bquo;Was it like when I was ill and couldn't eat? 
 Maybe he needs to get a breath of fresh air. 
 Maybe you should take him down to Mrs Hollidaye's. 
 Get some roses in his cheeks. 
 I got better, didn't I?&equo; 
 &bquo;Can't do that, ducks. 
 He's been discharged. 
 He ought to start looking for work now.&equo; 
 He wasn't really sleeping. 
 He heard them whispering by the door. 
 He rolled over and opened his eyes though he didn't look at Dot any more than she looked at him. 
 He looked over at Gloria. 
 &bquo;It's her what should go away and stay,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It's not right her having to be cooped up in here with me. 
 She don't like me. 
 She's scared.&equo; 
 &bquo;Am not!&equo; 
 Dot wanted to explain it was more that she just didn't know him yet, and she was sorry about him being ill. 
 &bquo;That woman who's been good to you, would she have her if you asked?&equo; 
 Gloria nodded. 
 He took a ten shilling note from his trouser pocket and gave it to Gloria. 
 &bquo;She'd be all right on the train?&equo;  
 &bquo;Oh, yes,&equo; said Gloria. 
 &bquo;She's a sensible kid, aren't you, duckie? 
 And she likes it down there.&equo; 
 He took four pennies from his other pocket. 
 &bquo;She know how to use the phone?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;'Course I do,&equo; Dot said. 
 &bquo;She got the lady's number?&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes.&equo; 
 Gloria said, &bquo;All right then, love. 
 You do as your Dad says. 
 Hop on over to the end of the road and give her a tinkle. 
 Ask if you can come down for a day or two. 
 I can tell school you been took poorly again.&equo; 
 Dot walked down the road slowly to give herself time to think what to say. 
 She wanted so much to go to Mrs Hollidaye's, for a long time. 
 Yet she sensed that it might be like telling things the way you wanted them to be rather than the way they really were. 
 It would be like running away from him back at the basement. 
 Dot decided she wouldn't invite herself to stay but would wait till Mrs Hollidaye asked her. 
 She dialled the number carefully and heard the distant ringing tone. 
 She could imagine it clanging across the hall, up the stairway, along the draughty corridors, around the drawing-room and out through the open windows. 
 She wanted to go and yet didn't want to go both at once. 
 She heard Mrs Hollidaye's voice answer and she pressed Button A to let the pennies clatter through and they were connected. 
 &bquo;Hello, there, Mrs H. It's me, Dorothy here. 
 How's yourself, then?&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye sounded pleased. 
 She asked Dot about whether the sun was shining in London, about the school, and about Gloria. 
 Dot said they were all Al and tip-top. 
 Then Mrs Hollidaye told Dot about Loopy Lil, about the dogs and the hens, and about her son whose ship was due home from the Pacific any day now. 
 Dot kept expecting Mrs Hollidaye to ask her to come down and stay. 
 Why didn't she?  
 Dot said, &bquo;We didn't get the flat we was after. 
 So Gloria's put in for one of them new pre-fabs.&equo; 
 Mrs Hollidaye said she had read about them. 
 &bquo;Prefabricated temporary emergency housing. 
 How perfectly champion.&equo; 
 &bquo;If we get one, we'll have two bedrooms, so I'll have me own window to look out of. 
 I've always wanted me own window. 
 But they don't build them,&equo; Dot explained. 
 &bquo;The walls come on this lorry, all ready made, in pieces with the windows stuck in. 
 Ours ain't arrived yet.&equo; 
 Still Mrs Hollidaye didn't mention Dot going to stay. 
 So Dot said, &bquo;And Derek's back too.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your father? 
 Why this is excellent news too, my dear.&equo; 
 &bquo;But he don't look too hot. 
 It's because he's been ill like, in the head.&equo; 
 &bquo;Another casualty of the conflict. 
 But he'll win through.&equo; 
 &bquo;I feel like he's the child, and I've got to be the adult.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know you and your mother will be doing your very best for him. 
 A loving family is the best medicine till he's on his feet again.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'm going to buy him some flower seeds,&equo; said Dot. 
 &bquo;For him to plant. 
 See, when we get the pre-fab, we get this little titchy bit of space round the edge, so I was thinking of us having a garden.&equo; 
 &bquo;Why, that really is simply splendid news, my dear. 
 Nasturtiums would be good if you want something quick. 
 Or sweet peas. 
 They don't take up much space. 
 You must let me know as soon as you know when you're moving, won't you? 
 And we've quite a few bits and bobs of furnishing that your mother might find useful. 
 And of course I'll send you up some cuttings. 
 How exciting. 
 I do like to hear about a new garden in the planning. 
 Hostas do well, in sun or shade, spring bulbs of course, maybe a few montbretia? 
 Any soil, and they multiply so easily. 
 Gardening&equo; s a wonderful medicine too.&equo; 
 Dot started to say, &bquo;I hope I can bring my Dad down to visit you some day.&equo; 
 But the money ran out, so she was cutoff in mid-sentence. 
 She wasn't sure if Mrs Hollidaye had  heard. 
 She hoped she hadn't heard any of it. 
 Like the dancing man said, she had to get back to her Mum and Dad. 
 They had to stick together and be a family. 
 Dot unrolled her piece of twine and began to skip slowly along the pavement over the coal-hole covers towards the basement. 
 She was glad she wasn't going away again just now. 
 This was the world where she belonged. 
 &bquo;We have to live where we live,&equo; Dot said out loud to the dusty street. 
 Then she began to think to herself about which would be best, nasturtiums or sweet peas. 
 IN A POLICE STATE 
 Fear has many eyes, and can see things underground. 
 Cervantes  
 In me the need to talk is a primary impulse, and I can't help saying right off what comes to my tongue. 
 Don Quixote  
 There are but two families in the world, as my old grandmother used to say, the Haves and the Have-nots. 
 Don Quixote  
 The Sud Express to Lisbon leaves Paris Austerlitz at nine o'clock every morning. 
 But it does not arrive in Salamanca until about one-thirty the next day. 
 This was not how I wished to catch my first sight of the fabled city of Lazarillo de Tormes and of Gil Blas, who in Le Sage's novel made the journey to Salamanca only from Oviedo in the north. 
 So I decided to travel to Salamanca &mdash; by way of Valladolid and Jordi of course &mdash; through Andorra and Barcelona. 
 I knew something about Catalonia but nothing about Andorra, except that it was a tiny independent principality, one of the world's smallest countries, set high in the eastern Pyrenees. 
 I took an early morning train from Paris to Toulouse, where I changed to a small local train for Ax-les-Thermes. 
 There I got on a bus that took me to Le Hospitalet pr&egrave;s l'Andorre, and through the frontier post at Pas de la Casa, over the Envalira pass and down into a land whose mountainous beauty at once put me under a spell I shall never forget. 
 In those days Andorra was still a rather primitive country, the resort of contrebandiers . 
 Accommodation was pretty rough-and-ready but the people were friendly and warm-hearted, and I took endless delight in exploring on foot the wild landscapes of lakes and forest, mountain waterfalls and paths as rich with alpine flowers as a medieval tapestry. 
 On that first brief visit I made up my mind that one day I would  return there. 
 I started learning Catalan and reading fine modern Catalan poets, whom I intended to translate &mdash; Foix, Espriu, Bartra and many others of the emergent Catalan school whose work, and whose very language, were banned by Franco. 
 To be forbidden to speak and write one's own native tongue is one of the greatest punishments a cruel dictator can inflict upon a proudly independent people: it was one of the Franco regime's most despicable crimes against humanity. 
 Today, fortunately, that dictatorship, like so many others, has crumbled into dust, and Catalan literature and culture are flourishing. 
 At the end of summer there were still patches of old snow on the sheltered slopes of the Cirque des Pessons, and I wrote my first poem about Andorra: 
 The dark flanks of mountains 
 patched with the tawny white 
 of old snows, the harsh peaks 
 packed with golden ice 
 against a blue and amber sunset 
 that stains the plaited waterfalls 
 with leaping rainbow trout of light. 
 From Andorra la Veila, the capital with its lovely small cathedral and fortress-like Parliament House, la Casa de la Vall, I took a bus to Barcelona through stark, barren landscapes by way of Lerida and Manresa. 
 There is a fantastic intensity and wildness, almost savagery, in the landscapes of Spain, and Catalonia, delivered from the Arabs by Charlemagne, is no exception. 
 I travelled among grotesque rock formations, past gorges and canyons, weird spectres of fanes and fortresses on distant isolated heights, small villages strung along spines of haggard cliffs. 
 In the Goya wail paintings today fittingly displayed in the Prado, and in many of his other works, one sees again and again these formidable elephantine rocks lowering over a cringing humanity trying to find shelter in a bandit landscape. 
 The piercing brilliance of the late afternoon sunlight seems to intensify the surrealism of the constantly changing scenery. 
 The first glimpse of Montserrat is always deeply moving as it begins to rise like a vast ragged curtain on the evening horizon, mysterious and slightly sinister in its grandeur as it looms ever nearer in Goya-like menace, shifting from side to side of the bus until it vanishes behind us. 
 Night had fallen by the time we reached the centre of Barcelona. 
 I stayed two nights at the Hotel Manila on the Rambla Liceu, in a side-street named after the painter Fortuny, father of the great  dressmaker. 
 This hotel was at that time a sort of private dwelling crammed with the owner's collection of Catalan works of art and pastel portraits of the great singers who appeared at the nearby Opera. 
 In this respect it resembled another favourite hotel of mine, the Quirinale in Rome, where I like to stay in the room where Ronald Firbank died. 
 The Hotel Manila has now been transformed into a Ramada Renaissance Hotel, with correspondingly high prices, so I prefer to stay at the Hotel Gaudi, still unspoilt, which has the advantage of being right opposite the enchanting Theatre Museum. 
 I'm pretty sure Firbank must have stayed there, and also probably at the Hotel Manila, so convenient for the sumptuous Opera, now restored to its full glory. 
 I attended a Wagner performance that evening, high in the gallery, and spent the next day clambering around Gaudi's towers of the Sagrada Familia. 
 At the Parque G&uuml;ell, at the terminus of the 24 tram (&bquo;Origin y final de los servicios&equo;), after mounting the billy Calle de Larrad, I again experienced the peculiar pleasures of this fantastic Gaudi park, the subject of one of my best poems in The Descent into the Cave . 
 Next morning, from the Paseo de Gracias station, I took the first express to Zaragoza, passing through the small seaside town of Sitges, which was in later years to become a British hooligan holiday playground. 
 Zaragoza is the city where Bu&ntilde;uel was born. 
 Bu&ntilde;uel, the creator of a film that deeply impressed my youth, Los olvidados , gives a love-hate description of his Zaragoza childhood in his autobiography, Mi ultimo sospiro  (My Last Gasp). 
 I stopped there only to change trains. 
 I took the mid-afternoon express to Valladolid that goes on to Salamanca. 
 It was after nine o'clock when I reached Valladolid, and I took a taxi to the Hotel Moderno. 
 Jordi was waiting for me outside after I had a bath and changed my clothes for dinner. 
 We did not speak, just smiled, shook hands and set off walking along those dim back streets where Jordi felt fairly safe. 
 Again we took dinner in a cheap workmen's restaurant. 
 We were sad because he could not come to my room and I could not go to his home, where it would have been difficult to explain our relationship. 
 So we had to go to the park where we had met under the protective shade of a friendly tree. 
 We were both trembling with desire, afraid to make the first move. 
 In the end we just stood holding each other close, as the tears coursed down our faces. 
 The noises of the evening streets seemed very far away. 
 The shouting voices did not belong to our little world of passionate love. 
 We stayed there a long time, until well after midnight. 
 We had to keep drawing apart as occasional couples, and sometimes prowling single men, passed nearby. 
 We were conscious of the insecurity of our  situation. 
 I felt that hidden eyes must be observing us from behind bushes and tree-trunks. 
 And we had to keep an eye open for police patrols. 
 From rime to time we strolled hand in hand, with lighted cigarettes to give warning of our presence, for we did not talk. 
 If we did see some figure approaching, or standing in the distance, we would release our tense handclasp, fingers intertwined, and walk apart, puffing idly at our cigarettes or lighting new ones from Pablo's box of fosforos , as if we were just friends out for a casual stroll. 
 Who those single men were who sometimes crossed our path I do not know. 
 They did not give any sign of interest in us. 
 Perhaps, I thought, they were peeping Toms, voyeurs on the hunt for indiscreet novios  and novias  embracing in the shadows, as we did, at the mercy of every intruder. 
 Perhaps they were exhibitionists &mdash; flashers. 
 I was quite interested in flashers and their psychology, and often wished they would &bquo;flash&equo; me; but they always looked at me with the utmost contempt as I stood waiting hopefully for a revelation. 
 It was girls and women they were after. 
 &bquo;Piss off, will you?&equo; one of them hissed at me once on Wimbledon Common. 
 &bquo;Have some common decency! 
 Mind your own business, whatever it is!&equo; 
 He insinuated that my &bquo;business&equo; must be something utterly depraved, far worse than anything he might be going to do. 
 Or were those men simply other lonely hunters of other men? 
 I felt a cold thrill in my bones when I realized the implications of the word &bquo;hunters&equo; &mdash; perhaps those men were Franco's secret police? 
 At one point on the next night Jordi drew me into the shadows and to my astonishment produced a vicious-looking switch-blade knife, warning me never to look at another man in his presence. 
 &bquo;I use this for sticking pigs,&equo; he said, giving me a mysterious smile, gesturing with the ugly blade across his uncovered throat, then laughing, flicking it shut and thrusting it into a long pocket in the side of his dusty black corduroys. 
 Then he kissed me, playfully. 
 Afterwards we went to a bar and had some cognac. 
 Jordi seemed frightened, and we did not stay for long. 
 As we left, we were followed out by two men. 
 In the street they stopped us and asked for our papers. 
 In such a situation in a foreign country I am never able to speak the language, so when they asked for my passport I just said &bquo;Hotel&equo;, because Spanish hotels always kept visitors' passports, at any rate for the first night. 
 (They still do, in fact.) 
 The men motioned me to go away, and after they had looked at Jordi's papers I saw them escort him to a car. 
 The last I saw of Jordi was when he turned his head towards me before getting into the car, smiled, and gave a shrug. 
 I was unable to find out what had happened to him. 
 I dared not go to his house, fearing  that it might cause further trouble for him. 
 I left Valladolid for Salamanca the next day. 
 I was frightened, too. 
 I did not see Jordi again, except for one brief encounter in Salamanca. 
 I was never to return to Valladolid, a place of fear and heartbreak, until long after the death of Franco and the end of his regime. 
 Towards sunset I was travelling towards Salamanca from Medina del Campo. 
 In that pure evening light of late summer the plains were brown and golden, with here a crumbling village with women nearly always in black, and here a straggling group of toylike, stunted umbrella pines. 
 No birds. 
 A shepherd with his stick, solitary, was already wrapped up to the eyes in his striped poncho, the only true centre of his eccentric flock. 
 There is an unutterable sadness around Medina del Campo, where I had to change trains for Salamanca. 
 It was the perfect moment to arrive in the city where I was to spend the next year. 
 I first saw Salamanca at a certain moment of dusk when the setting sun still casts a deep red glow over the city's rosy stone. 
 At the station there were several little buses. 
 I entered one full of nuns, their winged white coifs illuminating the dim interior, making it like a candle-lit church. 
 They sat silently. 
 When the bus started, they all crossed themselves, as I had seen nuns do in Ireland when setting out on a journey, however short. 
 I think they noticed that I did not follow their example. 
 They were so different from the lively Irish nuns, who, when they were passing some workmen unloading crates of beer into a pavement hatch in Nassau Street, Dublin, burst out laughing when the jovial brewery workers called out to them: &bquo;Now, girls, steady up!&equo; 
 There was something faintly sinister about these speechless nuns; but perhaps they belonged to a silent order. 
 Yet if so, whey weren't they cloistered? 
 The driver and conductor made up for them by shouting and singing, and the little bus itself was extremely noisy as it rattled along the bumpy streets. 
 We had started off in grand style, rattling right round the station plaza with a great tooting of horns. 
 Now we were rumbling and petarding up a steep brown-earth road with long, high convent walls on each side, towards a little square with a few dimly lit small shops and pollarded trees like headless ostriches perched on one knobbly leg. 
 There were a few houses whose wrought-iron balconies were crammed with plants: great pots of geraniums, full and dark, the flowers looking down at me like tiny faces, intently. 
 At various stops nun after nun silently descended. 
 The RENFE train  station must be a long way from the centre, I thought, just as we began to enter the acid neon groves of the darkening city, through a narrow glade of brightly lit shops, the Corrielo, then through a vast archway &mdash; a policeman's shrill whistle &mdash; and the bus was rolling and swinging right into the grand Plaza Mayor, which it circled slowly, triumphantly hooting. 
 The sight of the noble stone arcades with hanging lanterns, caf&eacute; tables, people sitting smoking and drinking, waiters wearing long white aprons balancing trays of bottles and glasses and highly coloured liqueurs, the busy shops, a glimpse of a sombre church &mdash; it was ail enchantment. 
 The bus trundled out into the Avenida Generalissimo Franco, a name that made my heart sink &mdash; again the sharp, imperious police whistle &mdash; faces looking in on us from outside, where the slow-moving crowds were talking and laughing. 
 The bus shuddered to a stop. 
 I hauled my luggage to the nearest small hotel and took a cheap room. 
 Before term started I wanted to live anonymously in this city where no one knew me, just for a few days. 
 Then I would announce my arrival to the university authorities. 
 And I would have to meet the head of the English Department, Professor Ruiperez, who had sent me kind letters of invitation and welcome, in faultless English. 
 After a fashionably elevenish dinner at my hostal-Pension , in a small green dining-room lit by blinding neon, I strolled out into the streets where the sellers of lottery tickets were still in full cry &mdash; &bquo;Para hoy! 
 Para hoy!&equo; &mdash; and the blind beggars and cripples crouched and complained, some of them small children left squatting on a bit of cardboard and bawling their heads off. 
 I tried not to let this interfere with les tr&egrave;s riches heures de  James Kirkup, but the wretchedness and misery were overwhelming. 
 Some of the beggars knelt in the middle of the pavement, arms raised in an attitude of crucifixion, their rheumy eyes lifted heavenwards like the imploring ecstasies of El Greco saints. 
 But people just walked round them. 
 There was a legless young man on a cushioned board to which roller-skates had been fitted, and he propelled himself along with hands encased in old cigar-boxes. 
 He had developed a fine pair of shoulders, and his biceps bulged under his short-sleeved singlet: his arms seemed to have grown unnaturally long and appeared simian. 
 He held a metal cup in his teeth, which were perfect in his bearded face and glittered as brilliantly as his big, dark eyes under the street lamps. 
 Occasionally a small coin clattered in his tin. 
 There were blind men begging, selling lottery tickets. 
 I left these agonizing streets of beggars behind and entered the Plaza Mayor, a magnificent example of eighteenth-century Spanish baroque, dominated by the superb fa&ccedil;ade of the Churrigueresque Town Hail or Ayuntamiento. 
 There are spacious arcades and galleries on all sides of  the square, and on these I could see nobly sculpted medallions of famous Spaniards. 
 On its eastern side stands the grand Pabell&oacute;n Real (Royal Pavilion), facing the Ayuntamiento. 
 The whole Plaza was ablaze with floodlighting, and big globes of pearly lamps hung in every arcade. 
 The fine statues on the topmost balconies of the Ayuntamiento and framing the moonlike clock-face gestured against the midnight skies, and at once I was under the spell of the past. 
 All this dazzling illumination was in honour of my arrival? 
 No. 
 It was for the great annual festa of 3 September, with its cattle fairs, bullfights and zarzuelas . 
 There was dancing and singing at various points &mdash; the chatter and whir of castanets, the hoarse yelps and anguished arias of flamenco, the pistol-like crepitations of zapateado , the sharp slow hand-claps of caf&eacute; patrons calling waiters. 
 Gerald Brennan, writing just two or three years after the war, says in The Face of Spain  that the slow hand-clap to attract the attention of waiters had died out, but I heard it in several places in the north. 
 As his book is mainly about the south, perhaps it had died out in Andalusia, though even there I remember being startled by its male authority as I walked past a caf&eacute; in Seville. 
 The hand-claps sometimes seemed to be keeping time with my leisurely steps as I wandered under the arcades in the hot night, but that was just a coincidence. 
 I slightly lengthened my stride, feeling self-conscious as I always do if I find myself marching in step with martial music, when I deliberately break step and try to walk between the beats, as it were, in as unmilitary a way as possible. 
 After a while I sat down at a pavement caf&eacute; table and rather shamefacedly clapped my hands, but produced such a ladylike patter that no one heard me. 
 So I just sat watching the passing scene until I caught the eye of a waiter and ordered some wine. 
 As I sat there and sipped my Valdepe&ntilde;as I observed the ladies in their flounced festival attire, plying elegant fans, escorted by dignified caballeros wearing black sombreros. 
 There were small girls selling roasted melon seeds, shoeblacks clacking their cloths over hand-tooled Spanish leather boots. 
 Extremely pretty young women, still in their teens, advanced from table to table, offering baskets of roses and carnations to couples. 
 As I did not have a woman companion, they tended to ignore me, but I called to one and bought a little bouquet to put in my hotel bedroom's tooth-glass. 
 There were fewer beggars under the arcades, perhaps scared away by the patrolling police, and by the awe-inspiring Civil Guards in their black-lacquered headgear and solemnly swinging capes. 
 The constant presence of police I found rather intimidating. 
 I was also depressed by the sight of rich, elderly couples strolling along laden with jewellery, the man's arm laid lightly round his spouse's shoulder. 
 But always at the  back of my mind there was the memory of Jordi, his knife, his smile, his helpless shrug. 
 Why could he not be walking with me here? 
 I saw there were some middle-aged men, single or in small groups, who all wore very dark glasses and pencil-thin moustaches, light raincoats hanging effetely from their shoulders in that Spanish fashion of male superiority that is elsewhere considered the mark of a homosexual. 
 Younger people, because of the unseasonal heat, were wearing sweaters tied round the hips, another typically Spanish style that has been imitated by the Irish. 
 I was once or twice approached by stony-faced nuns begging for charities, but I gave nothing because I felt sure that some of those nuns were fakes, possibly men in drag, for their big, dark, hollow eyes, dyspeptic noses bright red in chalk-white faces, compressed, colourless lips and faint moustaches were hardly the signs of religious penance, and they were all wearing rather large boots. 
 I glimpsed a pair of shimmering transvestites in a back-street bar. 
 Despite all the illuminations, the thrilling flamenco and the shrill life of the streets, there was a sense of menace, a feeling of insecurity. 
 I was made uneasy by those parading men in smart suits and dark glasses, who appeared to be a kind of confraternity of Falangists, ardent nationalists and supporters of Franco, whose picture was everywhere. 
 Life here, I could see, was going to be on an even more perilous tightrope than it was in Britain. 
 As I expected, there was no evidence of an alternative culture, and there were no obvious homosexuals, though I received a few long looks from passers-by which I was careful not to return. 
 My mood was briefly lightened by the arrival of a tuna  group of university students in traditional academic robes decorated with flying coloured ribbons who played guitars and mandolines and sang cheerful folksongs, accompanied by the antics of a virtuoso tambourine player. 
 These strolling minstrels are very popular in Spain, and the tuna  in Salamanca is one of the best. 
 I was often to meet these apparently carefree young men parading the streets and lanes of the city well after midnight, or serenading pretty girls beneath their lighted windows, their only reward a thrown rose or carnation. 
 Their music was both charming and professional. 
 I returned to my hotel around 3 a.m. 
 My sadness over and fear for Jordi would not go away. 
 The front door was locked, and that was when I made my first acquaintance with a venerable traditional figure, the sereno , an old man with a stick, a big brass badge and a large bunch of keys. 
 These serenos  patrol the streets at night, acting as watchmen and guardians of the peace. 
 But they are also authorized to open street doors for people who have neglected to carry their often very ornate and heavy antique front-door keys with them. 
 Here again the slow hand-clap  is the signal one gives for a sereno's  help. 
 He would usually appear in answer to the signal within a few minutes, for each sereno  has a certain section to patrol. 
 Their name is derived from the &bquo;all quiet&equo; or &bquo;all's well, cry (&bquo;sereno&equo;) that the men used to give after calling the hours, just like our old English tradition &mdash; &bquo;Two o'clock and all's well&equo; &mdash; which has unfortunately died out. 
 The serenos  receive a small salary from the shopkeepers and private houses they keep an eye on, but it is considered proper to give them a tip each time they open a door for one. 
 I found them to be cheerful, reassuring old men, and delightful conversationalists. 
 They were a contrast to the ever-present police and Civil Guards. 
 But they are all old men, and theirs is a dying profession. 
 (They were still patrolling the streets of Madrid as late as 1973, when they were officially retired.) 
 As I turned to say good-night to my sereno , and to press a tip into his palm, the deep-blue sky held a brimming star &mdash; Orion. 
 Breakfast was a bowl of weak, milky coffee and a tasteless roll of bread. 
 The small block of semi-refined sugar, like cement, took a long time to dissolve. 
 Outside, at eight o'clock, the streets were already busy with sweepers, a watering-cart, shop assistants, police blowing whistles, bicycles, scooters, not many cars, the voices of the lottery ticket vendors, schoolchildren screaming as they ran to school, carts pulled by donkeys braying, trucks hooting, an ambulance siren &mdash; it all added up to utter confusion. 
 But it was an early-morning bedlam that soon died down. 
 The Spaniards are by nature noisy and vociferous, especially in the mornings when, like cocks crowing, they have to announce to the world that they are alive and doing. 
 The stout, middle-aged men in black glasses do not appear until ten o'clock, with brief-cases or small leather bags. 
 They were smoking cigars, hawking and spitting and shaking hands with friends or associates. 
 There is some kind of conspiracy of bureaucrats: they all have their fingers in the same profitable pie. 
 Their thin black moustaches were glossy with cologne, which wafted sickeningly behind them as they strolled to their offices. 
 It was a heavenly morning, not too hot yet. 
 I wandered ail over the city, getting lost then finding myself again where I had started. 
 I saw some of the places that were to play an important part in the later dramas of my life: the great Clerecia church where I was to be sitting one momentous morning, and beside it the lovely Casa de las Conchas, its walls decorated with rows of carved scallop shells &mdash; seven rows adorn the upper storeys. 
 I admired the main door of the Catedral Nueva &mdash;  comparatively new, that is, for it was started in 1513. 
 The splendidly ornate style and the wealth of carvings in the soft-tinted stone were to be the subject of a poem. 
 For the moment I kept away from the university. 
 I strolled down to the Tormes and its Roman bridge: in the Plaza del Puente at its northern end stands an ancient, battered statue of the Roman lion mentioned in Lazarillo de Tormes . 
 The bridge was constructed in the first century BC and is attributed to Trajan. 
 Its many arches reminded me of the perfection of the Roman aqueduct at Segovia. 
 I walked along the banks of the Tormes, sucking a native sweetmeat called Piedras del Tormes  &mdash; pastel-tinted boiled sweets imitating the pebbles of that great river. 
 Here and there were crowds of men bargaining over cattle and horses. 
 These were magnificent, but in my eyes the men were even finer, with their dark, hollow cheeks, taut, slim bodies in tight-fitting black corduroys that vividly outlined their considerable sexual equipment. 
 Some of the men, when they saw me looking at them, smiled shyly, and as if automatically scratched their swollen codpieces. 
 This I knew was not a sexual invitation but a protection against the evil eye. 
 Their warm Spanish eyes in luxuriant black eyelashes melted my heart which had been chilled by the dark-glassed fascists in the city streets. 
 They sported knives like Jordi's. 
 They all reminded me of him. 
 All the churches are closed for lunch and siesta. 
 But I can hear nuns singing quietly, sweetly, invisible behind thick wooden grilles. 
 There are little street altars, devotional carvings in the most unexpected places. 
 Inside the churches I could feel intense devoutness, and recalled the ejaculations shouted after La Macarena in Seville, so truly reverent yet passionate, reminiscent of medieval mystery plays' earthy realism and at the same time resembling the way men call after girls in the street. 
 Yet there is a firm respect for women and for the relations between men and women in daily life. 
 Behind the reserve of the Spaniards there is warmth and passion. 
 As in Ireland, there are many frustrated bachelors and spinsters, and there are frequent late marriages. 
 Sometimes in the parks I see sweethearts, novios  and novias , showing one another great respect, walking sedately together, not even holding hands. 
 During the evening paseo  the atmosphere is more relaxed, but still quite formal. 
 They have a frank and friendly interest in foreigners, in machinery, in clothes. 
 They ask me how much I paid for everything I was wearing, how much I pay for my room at the pension , how much salary I shall be getting at the university &mdash; a salary to me ridiculously small, little more than pocket-money, but for the majority of working-class Spaniards a fortune. 
 There is such volubility I find it hard to follow what some people are saying, and they make no compromises for non-native  speakers. 
 Like the French, they expect everyone to understand their language. 
 Even when I can understand all they are saying, they give me little opportunity to reply, so anxious are they to keep up the headlong momentum of their own speech; then they complain that I say nothing! 
 They are great gossips, the men as much as the women, whispering behind raised hands, then bursting into sudden excesses of rage with wildly waving hands, flashing eyes, curled lips spitting torrents of invective. 
 Then it is changed in a moment, and they are all sunny smiles and playful pats on the arm. 
 A few determinedly modern young women eat snacks in the street, but no girl or woman in Spain dares wear trousers or skimpy bathing-suits. 
 In the Franco era Spain is the least modern of all European countries. 
 This may be partly due to its isolated geographical position, which has helped to give the country its intense feeling of national uniqueness, and its deep conservatism. 
 George Borrow, in The Bible in Spain , called it &bquo;the genuine spirit of localism,. 
 Although the country is one of astonishing variety in landscape, climate and speech, it is everywhere itself, unmistakably Spanish. 
 In his work on Spanish cathedrals John Harvey comments on the Spaniard's national pride, often so abrasive, so aggressive and disdainful of foreign ways, modern ideas of internationalism. 
 But without that pride the Spaniard would not be Spanish, as Harvey writes: &bquo;It is profoundly to be hoped that he will never allow these sharp angles to be smoothed off by the modern cult of &bquo;all things to all men'&equo;, and a false catholicity of taste which is no taste at all. 
 Spain is the last country of discrimination; long may she retain this priceless gift.&equo; 
 The woman who sells you a ticket at the bus office crosses herself for you as she makes it out. 
 Beggars, when you give them money, bless you and wish you good luck, a gold tooth flashing surprisingly in a dusky smile suddenly lighting a dirty face. 
 There is something medieval in the way the Spaniard can reconcile earthy realism and practical common sense with soaring fantasy and spiritual exaltation. 
 To most Englishmen such a conjunction will be unbelievable; but, on returning to England, he may find himself wondering how he has finally accepted the Spanish view. 
 It is impossible to live in Spain and not be radically changed, not to discover profound truths about life, and about oneself.  
 A FATAL ENCOUNTER 
 The Poem in the Pencil  
 This pencil has a poem I could write. 
 It lies asleep within its woody shade, 
 A fountain that the forest leafs to light 
 And thins to nothing but the wish I made 
 To cast a shadow down the page. 
 The pattern is disguised within a cage. 
 I cannot bring its meaning to escape 
 Although I tease it with a tender rage 
 And pledge with love its naked shape. 
 - It will not lie down by my side. 
 Because I call it out of pride, 
 Its veins run cold within my hand 
 And leave the narrow page too wide. 
 - When will it let me understand 
 My wish to share the words we hide? 
 Salamanca had been Franco's headquarters in 1937. 
 Something of the secret terror of that period in the Civil War remained. 
 The beautiful tawny stone of the great churches and university buildings seemed to me stained with the blood of Republican idealists in the British battalion of the 15th International Brigade. 
 They were fighting for justice for the workers, a fine cause but one that had already proved useless in Russia, where the same old bureaucratic hierarchy held sway as it did in Spain. 
 There was another iron dictatorship in Germany, whose Condor Legion bombed the working classes in Guernica on 26 April 1937. 
 Kim Philby had been a war correspondent in Salamanca, sending dispatches to The Times . 
 As the newspaper's special correspondent with Franco and his troops, Philby had a watertight cover for his clandestine operations. 
 Guy Burgess had told my Gateshead chorus-boy friend, Jack Hewit, that Philby must have had very good reasons for going to Franco in Salamanca. 
 Pablo Merry del Val, whose father had been Spanish Ambassador in London, conducted briefings for the correspondents and  censored their dispatches. 
 Their briefings were held in the airy first-floor gallery of the university quadrangle. 
 This was where the offices of the English Department and several lecture-rooms were situated when I arrived in 1957, twenty years after Philby. 
 The beautiful old building in neoclassical style is called the Palacio de Anaya, situated on the square of that name, and it was built in 1760. 
 There was a bust of Miguel de Unamuno at the bottom of the staircase, and it seemed to have been defaced. 
 He was a fine writer, essayist and philosopher who wrote The Tragic Sense of Life  and who was persecuted by Franco and put under house arrest by Primo de Rivera because of his liberal views expressed fearlessly while he was the Rector of the University. 
 He died in 1936, and despite the Franco oppression he was venerated by many of the university staff. 
 Professor Ruiperez of the Faculty of Letters spoke to me quite openly of his admiration for the man and the writer. 
 He died under house arrest in Salamanca, uncompromising to the end. 
 It was Unamuno who wrote: &bquo;Only in solitude do we find ourselves; and in finding ourselves, we find in ourselves all our brothers in solitude.&equo; 
 This was an idea that appealed strongly to me, though Unamuno had not been thinking of some of the &bquo;brothers in solitude&equo; &mdash; the outcasts from social and sexual &bquo;normality&equo; &mdash; who were the brothers that first sprang to my mind on reading that sentence in Corsham. 
 But I was one with the solitaries of the spirit, too: with St Teresa and St John of the Cross as well as with humbler dissidents like Jordi and one or two other men of the working class I had known in Spain, the young bank clerk I had met in Cordoba the previous spring, among the orange and lilac blossom of Las Tendillas, where we walked and whispered, hardly daring to look at one another, and separating at the sight of police. 
 My own solitude was as nothing compared with their constantly patrolled loneliness, without hope of escape. 
 Unamuno also wrote: &bquo;Love is the child of illusion and the parent of disillusion&equo; &mdash; a very Zen Buddhist concept of which I was to learn the truth in Salamanca. 
 Nothing had prepared me for the overwhelming architectural beauty of Salamanca, and in particular for the grandeur of the university, the oldest in Spain and one of the oldest in Europe, with its noble fa&ccedil;ade in plateresque style. 
 Some of the ancient lecture theatres had been well preserved, like the Aula de Fray Luis de Leon, named after one of the many notable scholars who have graced its pulpit-lectern. 
 Founded in the thirteenth century, Salamanca was the equal of Paris, Bologna and Oxford, became internationally famous and attracted students from all over the world. 
 It fell into intellectual decay during the eighteenth and  nineteenth centuries, from which it was rescued by its famous rector, Miguel de Unamuno. 
 The great library contains one of the best collections of ancient manuscripts of the Hispanic civilizations, including the most complete copy of an extraordinary medieval poem, El libro de buen amor  (The Book of Good Love) by Juan Ruiz, dated 1343 in its second version, which Menendez Pelayo praises thus: &bquo;Juan Ruiz, Archpriest of Hita, wrote the comic epic of an entire epoch in his multiform book, the Human Comedy of the 14th Century. 
 He managed to reduce the variegated and picturesque spectacle of the Middle Ages to the unity of a humoristic concept at the very moment it began to dissolve and crumble.&equo; 
 The university chapel and the grand stone stairways with carved reliefs on the ornamental balustrades are extremely fine. 
 I was deeply imbued with the historic and cultural spells of this monumental structure when I took my first walk round the cloisters of the inner courtyard, whose first-floor gallery, open to the sky, is beautifully panelled and wainscoted. 
 I had called Professor Ruiperez from my hostal , and at once he came to take me out to lunch at an expensive restaurant featuring all the local dishes, including a hearty paella and fine Rioja wines. 
 He was a very kind, youngish, amiable scholar of great distinction, and a power in the university. 
 I think he was shocked to find his new Professor of English staying in a cheap pension . 
 But the place he took me to after lunch, the Colegio Ponce de Leon, where I was supposed to have rooms, was a rather stark student hostel, and my little room was very small, with just a narrow bed, a table and a chair. 
 But my windows commanded charming views of the city. 
 I stayed there only a few days, and then for some reason I was removed to the Colegio Fray Luis de Leon, where I was given a somewhat larger and more comfortable room. 
 The toilets and bathrooms and showers were at the end of the hall on the second floor, and from my window I had a splendid view of the cathedral, whose Gothic, Renaissance and baroque styles mingled perfectly in the dark-rose-and-amber stone to give it almost the appearance of some natural rock formation. 
 There was a multitude of bells &mdash; solemn, melodious, hasty, irritable, angry, tinny, noble, girlish &mdash; an infinite variety of calls to worship and memorials of passing time. 
 The students had not yet arrived, but I took meals in the refectory with a few of the college authorities and professors who had already started the new term's work. 
 They seemed to me very distant, almost suspicious. 
 There was no kind of social life. 
 Indeed, all the time I was at Salamanca, I was never once invited to anyone's house. 
 One by one the students returned, filling the corridors and the public rooms with cheerful noise. 
 They were male students. 
 It would have been  unthinkable in the Spain of those days to have male and female students living under the same roof. 
 The majority were Spaniards, but there were many from South America, particularly Venezuela, and these were better dressed and better off than the other students, a fact that caused some resentment. 
 Some of them were mature students studying medicine, dentistry, law, engineering. 
 They were in their early thirties, so 1 did not feel too out of place from the point of view of age, and at first no one took any notice of me, as if they thought I was just another mature student. 
 I intended to study, and registered for courses on Spanish language and literature. 
 It was on the morning when registration began that I had my fatal encounter. 
 I had registered for my classes, and Professor Ruiperez had shown me my lecture-rooms, where I had introduced myself to large classes of students, mixed men and women, with a preponderance of women, as is usual in foreign arts faculties. 
 They seemed quite pleasant young people, who listened intently to my greetings, my introductions and my little jokes. 
 I announced the titles of the textbooks we would be using. 
 These included Jespersen's Primer of the English Language , a book I had not opened since my student days, and then only to shut it immediately, never in the intervening years opening it again. 
 Now I should have to study the English language in earnest, keeping one chapter ahead of the students each week. 
 I expected to hate it, but in fact I enjoyed my lectures on English language history and became an enthusiastic advocate of exercises in parsing, syntax and dictation &mdash; the very best test of listening comprehension. 
 In literature I was going to offer both British and American authors, both prose and poetry, so that was no problem, though it did mean that I should have to read authors I disliked &mdash; Conrad, Hemingway, Woolf, Graham Greene, C.P. Snow &mdash; but I leavened this stodgy bunch with those I felt more in sympathy with, though they were not officially on the syllabus &mdash; Waugh, Firbank and Forster at their head. 
 Between two classes I went out into the beautiful gallery on the first floor, open to the cloisters and the courtyard below. 
 I leant back against the stone balustrade and lit a cigarette. 
 What happened next is something I shall never forget, and I have thought of that moment incessantly ever since it happened. 
 Jordi was still very much on my mind. 
 He knew my address at the university but had not written. 
 His long silence worried me and made me frightened. 
 Among the throngs of passing students I was thinking fondly of Jordi when someone who was obviously an American passed by, and our eyes met for a split second. 
 He was a little shorter than myself, rather stocky with broad shoulders and that slightly duck-toed walk I find so attractive in athletic young men. 
  He was dressed casually in jeans and T-shirt and sweater, and his eyes in his sun-tanned face were very blue. 
 He had not shaved for a day or two, and there was fair stubble on his cheeks and jaw. 
 But the most remark able thing about him was his hair, unusually long for those days, and abundant &mdash; of the palest, curly blond, exactly the moonlight platinum colour of my own hair when I was a little boy. 
 I thought I detected a faint smile on his lips, but I did not smile back because my heart was in a turmoil. 
 I thought he was the most beautiful creature I had ever seen certainly the most beautiful male. 
 On the Waterfront  and Rebel without a Cause  had appeared in 1954 and 1955, starring Marlon Brando and James Dean respectively, and I had fallen for them both. 
 The person I saw that morning in the sunny gallery of the Palacio de Anaya reminded me of James Dean, not so much in physical appearance, though they were alike in presenting the essence of a certain youthful American type of the period, as in an instant personal magnetism, a cocksure and irresistible sexual charm. 
 I was stunned. 
 It was almost as if I had received a blow to the heart. 
 He was the ideal of all the friends I had ever longed for, the elder brother that, as an only child, I could never hope for &mdash; though he was at least fifteen years younger than I, his assurance and absolute maleness made me feel like a younger brother by contrast. 
 I returned to face my next class with wildly beating heart and in a state of utter confusion, of mingled joy, misery, hope and despair. 
 Fortunately it was the first class in English literature, so I did no more than introduce myself and give the reading assignment for the next week. 
 Then I dismissed the students and turned myself loose on the streets of Salamanca, under the burning sun of an Indian summer, trying to get my emotions under control. 
 Who was he? 
 Why had he come to Salamanca? 
 As far as I knew, he was the only American student in the Arts Faculty. 
 At least I had seen no others. 
 These were foolish and unnecessary questions anyhow, because I was sure such a divinity would never have anything to do with someone so much older and so much less good-looking than himself. 
 All my life I have seen that type of person, handsome and self-assured, who knew he could have me just by crooking a finger and beckoning me to follow. 
 They had caused me many heartaches and disillusions, and I was determined that it should never happen again. 
 My readings in Zen, too, had shown me the folly of love, analysed it as an illusion among all the other illusions of this floating and temporary world, an emotion that by its very nature created suffering. 
 For Zen teaches us that love breeds fear, and fear breeds hatred, and hatred breeds violence, in a neve-rending, vicious circle. 
 I was certainly not going to allow myself to suffer all that hell again. 
 In any case there would be no occasion for that to  happen. 
 The person I had seen could have not the slightest interest in a beat-up old poet like me. 
 Or so I thought&hellip;. 
 A day or two later I had a free morning, in which I intended to follow a class in Spanish language. 
 When I got to the classroom, I found there were only about six students in the class, and we chatted idly until the lecturer arrived. 
 The class started, and I was in the middle of reading aloud a prose passage from Gald&oacute;s when the door opened and in walked the fair-haired god I had glimpsed in the gallery. 
 My heart lurched and seemed to miss a beat, but I went on reading calmly, though the print was blurred. 
 At the end of my reading, the lecturer asked the newcomer his name, and I heard his voice for the first time &mdash; a soft, warm American accent, with the rich, furry tone the English find so attractive. 
 I stole a quick sidelong glance, and saw him turn his head at the same instant to look at me and give a faint smile. 
 I turned my head away quickly, but I had had time to take in another feature &mdash; his rather sharp, small nose that looked as if it might have been broken in a boxing match. 
 Then he gave his name, one of those Midwest American names, I guessed, probably originally Ukrainian, from Kansas or Montana. 
 The class dragged to its end. 
 The other students stayed seated, all turned towards the newcomer, anxious to make his acquaintance, and I knew only too well that he could have any one of them he liked as his friend. 
 He was one of those people who are instantly popular, and I felt sure he must know and relish his power over others, the power that only exceptional physical beauty can give, especially when it is allied with intelligence and strong animal magnetism. 
 I felt very much the wallflower as I crept out of the room without speaking to anyone, my books held tightly against my chest in a way which, I was to learn, was feminine and wrong for a man. 
 Something made me linger at the bottom of the grand staircase, near the bust of Unamuno, pretending to read some notices about student societies. 
 After about five minutes I heard a voice behind me say: &bquo;Hi, there! 
 I'm Dana.&equo; 
 I turned round, knowing already who it was, with sinking heart. 
 Yes, it was he, with a broad, sunny grin revealing perfectly white, rather small teeth in a friendly smile. 
 I was British enough not to want to reveal my name to a stranger, so I just said, rather coldly: &bquo;How are you?&equo; 
 A slight cloud on his smile, then it passed, and he asked: &bquo;Where can you get a cup of coffee in this place?&equo; 
 I took him to a nearby caf&eacute;. 
 I knew I was hooked. 
 And I knew he knew it. 
 But I was determined not to allow myself to be hauled in like a helpless fish as he reeled in his capable line. 
 On that day we became friends, yet for a long time I kept my distance, afraid even to shake hands with him. 
  About twelve years later, when I was looking back on that meeting with Dana, I wrote the following poem: 
 Christ Rejected  
 In the life of the ugly, 
 the plain, the lonely, sometimes 
 a stranger of great beauty comes 
 with an ease almost holy. 
 They who were never loved, 
 who worshipped from afar with scorn 
 the beauty of the nobly-born 
 for a moment felt themselves moved. 
 How can it be? 
 Who is he? 
 A stranger of great beauty, 
 with limbs perfect, smile all purity, 
 comes, and gives his love to me? 
 ft is as they tell us of 
 Jesus, loving the halt and the dumb, 
 who, laying his hands upon lepers, did come 
 on earth, to give us of God's love. 
 How beautiful are thy feet with shoes, 
 the joints of thy thighs are as jewels, 
 the smell of thy nose like apples. 
 His legs are pillars of marble, his lips lilies&hellip; 
 The ugly believe, and know 
 that this is the love of Christ. 
 - But put an arm about the stranger's waist, 
 he melts away like snow. 
 The stranger of great beauty comes 
 and goes in lives that are plain, 
 bringing love, but also fear; hope, but pain. 
 Ours are the hearts, but his the drums. 
 None can resist him, who are not 
 as perfect as he, but those sad fools 
 who turn away as he comes with smiles, 
 and seek the comfort of the brothers he forgot. 
 (from White Shadows, Black Shadows.: Poems of Peace and War ) 
 I did indeed see him as a kind of Christ figure, perhaps as someone who had come to save me from myself, from my ineradicable loneliness of mind and soul. 
 For despite all the passing lovers and the casual one-night stands or five-minute fantasies, I was always essentially alone, a solitary. 
 Because of them, perhaps. 
 Each fevered quest for a true love left me more adrift than ever. 
 And long after Dana had left me, I still thought of him every day, and from time to time wrote poems about him, like this one which came to me after several viewings of a film that greatly disturbed and fascinated me, Pasolini's Teorema : 
 On Pasolini's  Teorema 
 Glimpsed in a courtyard, a gallery, a cloister, a garden &mdash; 
 yes, we know him all too well, 
 that plausible young male demon, 
 unscrupulous messenger of hell, fair angel of our fate, 
 handsome, mysterious, understanding, 
 and inexplicably loving, 
 who comes one day from nowhere 
 and takes our hearts, our minds, our souls, 
 in exchange for &mdash; what? 
 For loneliness and desolation worse than anything we knew 
 before his coming; for a persistent sense of loss, 
 an ache of separation, a bitter, loveless isolation 
 in a world to which he brought 
 a temporary joy, a passing sweetness. 
 - But was it worth it? 
 A brief time 
 of unforgettable pleasure in a life of pain? 
 For now the pain grows worse, 
 the isolation more intense, 
 and he who came and took our souls 
 when we least needed him 
 does not come now, now that we need him most. 
 Instead, a hollow shadow walks beside us 
 and haunts us day and night 
 with visions, madness, dreams 
 of impossible and unimaginable love 
 that, even if we knew it once again, 
 we should reject, knowing it untrue 
 and foul: and unavailing, hollow 
 as the words and smiles with which 
 he first approached us, come from nowhere, 
 to take us back there with him, and leave us there alone. 
 (from Ecce Homo &mdash; My Pasolini: Poems and Translations ) 
 The star of that upsetting movie, Terence Stamp, reminded me of Dana at his most perverse and enigmatic, half-god, half-demon, lover and destroyer. 
 Yet he was a kind of Christ figure, who entered the lives of ordinary people in a rich, bored, bourgeois family, made love to them all indifferently, both male and female, inexplicably, then left as mysteriously as he had come, deserting them in the hours of their greatest need. 
 Sad to say, I had learnt to be suspicious of good-looking young men who for no particular reason seemed to take a sudden interest in me. 
 I knew I was not attractive. 
 Yet I had such a deep longing for the romantic friendship, for the ami amant , for that &bquo;someone to watch over me&equo;, that I was often half tempted to succumb to the wiles of youths I felt pretty sure were plain-clothes detectives from the Vice Squad or undercover agents for MI5. 
 In that cold war atmosphere that was mingled with the chill dictatorship of Franco, I felt that the American &bquo;innocents&equo; of Henry James's novels had become the sophisticated manipulators his Europeans had once appeared to be. 
 So Dana was my European exploiter; I was his Daisy Miller. 
 This was how I regarded Dana from the start. 
 What was behind his apparent friendliness? 
 At that first meeting he told me something about himself. 
 He had been a student of D.J. 
 Enright at the Freie Universit&auml;t in West Berlin, and that information immediately put me on my guard. 
 Were the British literary mafia on my tracks again? 
 Had Enright told him about my appointment to Salamanca, and instructed his student to infiltrate my literary and private life? 
 There is always such intense jealousy among members of the British literary establishment when someone who is not &bquo;one of us&equo; is favoured by an appointment, a prize. 
 A few years later Enright came to see me when I was working in Kuala Lumpur and he was Professor in Singapore. 
 We met in the old Majestic Hotel, where I was staying, and I asked him about his former student in Berlin. 
 Oh yes, Enright remembered him very well, and when I mentioned the name a puzzled look fleetingly crossed his face. 
 Dana had travelled from Berlin to Salamanca on an old motor bike that was to play a large part in our lives both in Spain and in England. 
 He had put up at a cheap pension , the Hospedaje Lisboa (&bquo;Camas,  Comidas&equo; &mdash; Rooms, Meals), where he had an even smaller room than the one assigned to me at the Colegio. 
 He told me he had been studying poetry with Enright, and that he wrote poetry too. 
 One of his poems had been published, he said, in The New Yorker  by Howard Moss, the Poetry Editor, who &mdash; though I did not know it until Dana told me later &mdash; was a well-known homosexual. 
 When I told him that Howard Moss &mdash; whom I never met but whose poetry I greatly admired &mdash; had already published several of my poems, Dana appeared surprised and a little put out. 
 I could not remember ever having seen one of his poems in The New Yorker , but it was a magazine I saw only occasionally in those days. 
 We started talking about poetry and about our favourite modern poets. 
 We neither of us had much interest in contemporary British poets, but were united in our enthusiasm for Elizabeth Bishop, Marianne Moore, W. S. Merwin, Wallace Stevens, William Carios Williams, Charles Reznikoff, Theodore Roethke and Richard Wilbur. 
 He did not share my passion for Frank O'Hara, Robert Duncan, Denise Levertov (whom I had met in London and Paris), James Merrill and the early Pound; nor did I agree with his high estimate of Robert Lowell, Howard Nemerov and T.S. 
 Eliot. 
 But we both agreed that Robed Frost, Allen Ginsberg, Kenneth Rexroth and the rising ride of repetitive Beat poets were not worthy of consideration. 
 Dana did not ask to see my own poems, which at once made me suspect that he had some knowledge of them already. 
 But he seemed anxious to show me his own poetry, with which he had filled several notebooks. 
 I agreed to take a look at these efforts, and we arranged to meet next day after my morning lectures. 
 The first thing that struck me about Dana's poems was his incredibly tiny script, an almost minuscule handwriting that was often difficult to decipher. 
 This queer way of writing filled me with foreboding, because it seemed to indicate a cold, self-centred nature, the reverse of the outgoing geniality he displayed to one and all. 
 His writing looked crabbed. 
 At the time I was interested in graphology, and had experimented with various styles of handwriting. 
 My usual script looks like demented knitting, but among my manuscripts I am still surprised to find poem drafts and diary entries in neat italic calligraphy, painstakingly produced with a special calligraphic pen, or &bquo;disguised&equo; and back-sloping hands, or the &bquo;progressive&equo; styles I had copied from my art students in Corsham. 
 My multiple personality required multiple scripts, and from my study of graphology I tried to create individual scripts that conformed to the analyses of heavy down-strokes, &bquo;pasty&equo; loops and uncrossed &bquo;ts&equo;: I was especially interested in &bquo;pasty&equo; strokes, which are supposed to indicate a rich sexuality, and disconnected letters, indicative  of &bquo;inspiration&equo;. 
 By adopting various graphological forms I hoped to fool the editors to whom I submitted my poems with a covering note, often under a false name. 
 I was particularly keen to give my handwritten lines an upward slope &mdash; a sign of success, according to graphologists. 
 But I also remembered that Andr&eacute; Gide's letters to me had shown this tendency very clearly. 
 As for Dana's poems, at first I thought they were pretty feeble. 
 We sat down together at a caf&eacute; table and went through some of them together. 
 As we sat there in that noisy, smoke-filled place I was deeply conscious of his physical presence, so close and so disturbingly animal, almost electric in its restrained, pulsing sexuality. 
 I tried to keep my eyes off his muscular thighs in their tight blue jeans, but as we bent over the caf&eacute; table it was easy to cast occasional surreptitious glances at his powerfully outlined sexual equipment under the much-rubbed fly, which seemed to be almost bursting at the seams. 
 I was conscious, too, of his fine, tanned hand holding the pencil, and of the occasional play of warm breath from his mouth, wholesome as home-baked bread, though he was a heavy smoker &mdash; much heavier than I. ft was I who introduced him to the Bisontes brand, a Spanish version of Lucky Strike, with a similar &bquo;toasted&equo; flavour. 
 Today, having given up smoking about twenty years ago, I find it unbelievable that I should have smoked as many as ten cigarettes a day; but they were one of the things that helped to create a bond with Dana, something we could share. 
 We would each bring out a packet of Bisontes with the bold bison emblem and a little box of those peculiarly Spanish waxed matches called cerillos . 
 I remember the first time I offered Dana one of these cigarettes: he accepted one, and I then took one myself. 
 But by the time I had got it out of the packet and placed it between my lips, he had lighted a cerillo  and was holding it out to me in cupped hands, smiling above the soft yellow flame whose elvish reflection danced in his blue eyes. 
 As we pored over his crippled handwriting I felt a steady heat coming from his body like an aura which slowly enveloped me and seemed to penetrate the very marrow of my bones. 
 I knew I was being bewitched, laid under a spell so intensely personal, so thrilling, I did not have the power to resist it, or to judge if it were good or evil. 
 From time to time I took in little details of his face: his small, neat ears round which the moonlight-blond locks curled; the light golden stubble round his laughing mouth; the rather dry, sensuous yet slightly cruel lips; the perfect column of the neck and throat emerging from his open shirt, unbuttoned to give me &mdash; was it deliberate? &mdash; a shadowy glimpse of a dark nipple in a hairless chest, the beautifully smooth breast of an ancient god. 
 I felt myself falling, falling, as if for the first time, deeper and deeper into mysterious pits of passion and anxiety,  longing and despair. 
 He moved a leg to scratch &mdash; innocently? &mdash; his bulging crotch, and the knee just touched mine beneath the table, as if accidentally, and I felt as if I had been touched by lightning. 
 And all the time, in this turmoil of sexual ambiguities, we were talking about words, about poetry. 
 I was trying my best to correct his style without imposing my own upon it, and he seemed genuinely grateful when I pointed out what I thought was a weakness in rhythm, a word to be changed, an image to be further developed, a form to be tightened or relaxed&hellip;. 
 Yes, in poetry I felt I could stand at least as his equal, and indeed what started off that day as a sort of master-pupil relationship soon became a strange kind of poetic collaboration, in which we played equal parts. 
 We would work on one of his poems, then turn to one of mine and work together on it. 
 Then we started finding our common subjects and composing poems together, a double authorship. 
 I stopped writing my own poems. 
 He had taken them away from me and was making them his own. 
 Our voices were mingled in poetry. 
 But though he had taken all my poetic power, and gave me some of his in return, he still remained himself, his own man, his own poet. 
 At times I felt I was just a kind of palimpsest, or a blackboard that could always be wiped clean to make room for his own work. 
 Even my handwriting changed, and started to become small and stunted, like his. 
 Yes, I was possessed, but happy to be so, if it allowed me to be with him, to feel him near me for a few hours every day. 
 We became inseparable, and I was so proud to be seen walking with him, to enter a concert hall with him and let others see us sit down together at caf&eacute; and restaurant tables. 
 His Spanish was almost non-existent, and he did not know how to study a foreign language, so I gave him lessons. 
 I, too, was studying Spanish; but soon I had abandoned the classes for foreigners in the university and was studying on my own. 
 The classes were so slow for me. 
 Dana soon dropped out and came to study with me. 
 All this time I was trying to make a little money by doing hack-work translations of French and German children's stories. 
 I translated Schiller's Don Carlos  and revised my version of Heinrich von Kleist's Prinz von Homburg  for Eric Bentley's anthology of classic German theatre, for which I was paid a pittance. 
 Dana got an allowance from home: his father was a government official; his mother worked as a teacher &mdash; she sent him wads of onion-skin typing paper that were then unobtainable in Europe, and also drugs, bottles of Dexedrine. 
 Because the caf&eacute;s were so noisy and crowded, we had started working on our poems in my room at the Colegio. 
 And because I had only one chair, we used to sit on the edge of the hard, narrow bed and draw up the table so that we could write on it together. 
 One day, after we had  been working together all afternoon without much success, Dana without warning lay back on the bed, his head on the pillow. 
 &bquo;Lie down and relax,&equo; he told me. 
 In absolute terror, I lay down beside him. 
 On that narrow bed we were so close together. 
 I did not dare move, and yet I did: I put my hand on his thigh, and slowly moved it up towards the centre of my desire. 
 After a moment he gently took my hand and moved it away, saying nothing. 
 We lay there silently, then he got up and left the room, leaving me lying there in an agony of frustration and guilt, furious with myself for having given way, yet curiously glad I had finally done so. 
 Dana did not reappear for a few days, and during that time I felt I was going mad. 
 I wandered the streets of Salamanca, hoping to run into him. 
 I went to our favourite caf&eacute;s, but no one had seen him. 
 At night I would stand on the pavement opposite the Hospedaje Lisboa and look up at his window. 
 Sometimes it was lighted, and I would wait there, watching until the light went off, usually long past midnight. 
 Then I knew he was writing poetry alone, without me, and that hurt me to the depths of my being. 
 Among the unpublished poems I wrote at that time there is one that tries to express my feelings of loneliness and abandonment by my beautiful god. 
 I wrote it one late evening, sitting at my window, looking out into the rainy darkness of autumn and at the great black bulk of the cathedral: 
 The rain beats on the window 
 As the bells beat down the dark. 
 I wonder where you are, and if 
 You walk in rain, or under stars. 
 The bells beat into my memory 
 The days and nights we knew 
 In this one room, among the city's 
 Mysteries of stone. 
 To you 
 I send this whispered message 
 Through the fastnesses of wind and rain &mdash; 
 To you, whose face begins to fade, 
 And hear your voice again. 
 Stay true to our belief 
 In one another and our singular art. 
 If the rain beats for me, it beats 
 For both of us. 
 I hear it falling in your heart. 
 The bell-laden streets were haunted by the fume of roasting chestnuts. 
 Now whenever I smell roasted chestnuts in Shijo-dori in Kyoto, or in Z&uuml;rich Hauptbahnhof, I remember that aching void in my life. 
 But after all you came back one day, and it all started again. 
 You were unchanged. 
 You made no reference to what had happened. 
 You did not tell me what you had been doing, or where you had been, and you were not interested in whatever I might have been doing. 
 You were joyous and friendly and warm, and full of your own poems. 
 You had come back to me in order to show me your poems: there was no one else to whom you could show them. 
 That at least was something, something I could cling to, something I could use to keep you close to me. 
 My poetry had never been of so much practical use to me before. 
 I was half proud, half ashamed to be using it in this way. 
 No wonder it kept deserting me! 
 But just to have you near me I was willing to give it all to you. 
 Your second-hand motor bike was always breaking down. 
 One day, with me clinging to you &mdash; what rapture! &mdash; on the pillion, we made a trip to Zamora, a small medieval city to the north of Salamanca. ft was one of those heavenly, crisp autumn days, all sunny chills and skies of broken clouds whose grotesque shadows went moving slowly over the bare brown earth of the fields and hills. 
 You were always a late riser, quite unlike me, so we did not start on this little adventure until after lunch. 
 So we were late in returning, and night fell when we were only half-way home. 
 The road was deserted and we were throbbing along at a moderate pace when suddenly the engine sputtered and stopped. 
 I had not the first notion of mechanics, but you with your capable hands worked on the machine until, after running with it, pushing it along, we were able to make the engine tick over again. 
 We got on, and started off again through the lonely night, in pitch darkness, not a house or a lantern to be seen. 
 Then after a few miles the engine stopped again. 
 Again we worked on it and pushed hard, and again got it to start, jumped on before it changed its mind and sped away. 
 This happened about a dozen times. 
 Finally the engine gave up the ghost completely and nothing could persuade it to start again. 
 We were left in the middle of nowhere. 
 So we took turns in pushing the bike along. 
 You wanted to abandon it by the side of the road, but I made you push it on, with myself taking short spells of pushing. 
 I was no match for your proud, muscular strength: after a few yards I was exhausted, and you would take over, shoving the burden along with tireless energy. 
 At last, in the  far distance, we glimpsed the first lights of Salamanca. 
 From there the road was downhill, so we were able to coast noiselessly down into the sleeping suburbs, then dismount and push the bike into the city centre. 
 It was an experience that bound us more closely than ever. 
 I had been studying a guide-book to Zamora before we left. 
 (Dana would never dream of doing such a thing &mdash; he would just take off into the void and somehow find his way around.) 
 In the book I found a Spanish proverb that runs, No se gan&oacute; Zamora en una hora  &mdash; &bquo;Zamora isn't reached in an hour&equo;, which is the equivalent of our &bquo;Rome wasn't built in a day&equo;. 
 We learnt that by our own experience. 
 Our friendship had been noticed, as I had hoped it would be, for I was so proud of having a friend. 
 The atmosphere in the college was becoming strained, and mealtimes in the refectory were agony. 
 One Sunday afternoon, when Dana and I were sitting on the edge of the bed working over versions of various poems, the door, which we always left unlocked, suddenly burst open and a group of surly-looking students entered, led by a big bully who was not Spanish but Venezuelan. 
 We looked up from our papers in surprise. 
 I felt afraid. 
 The group strode over to our table in a menacing way, and the Venezuelan growled: &bquo;Why are you always together? 
 What are you doing? 
 Why is he here? 
 He does not belong to this college!&equo; 
 I replied that we were studying and writing, a fact that was obvious from the books, dictionaries and papers scattered over the table and the bed. 
 With sulky faces, the students turned to go. 
 But the Venezuelan turned at the door and ordered us to come downstairs and drink with them. 
 I did not want to go, but Dana said we had better do as they asked. 
 So we spent the whole afternoon in aimless beer-drinking and student ragging, singing student songs to stamping feet and clapping hands. 
 It was not at all my idea of pleasure, but I did it for Dana's sake. 
 Unlike me, he at once felt at home in that charged, aggressive, almost militaristic atmosphere, joined heartily in the drinking and singing, and soon had all the students on his side, which was fortunate for me, because el Americano's  prestige deflected a terrible submerged violence and hatred that might well have done me harm. 
 I was astonished, and a little dismayed, by the ease with which Dana entered into the spirit of things, giving Indian war-whoops and clowning and laughing in a way I thought was rather contemptible. 
 But perhaps he was doing it to save me? 
 Or was it just another side of his character I had not seen before, but that I may have suspected was always there? 
 Those students were all right-wing, fascist bullies, ardent supporters of Franco and his regime. 
 They were out to destroy me, I was sure. 
 So a few days later I moved to an hotel, the Hotel Espa&ntilde;a (solo apartamentos ) on the Plaza Espa&ntilde;ia. 
 I  had an apartment on the third floor, overlooking the square and the end of the Avenida Jose Antonio de Rivera round which I would watch Dana coming to join me for another afternoon of poetry. 
 Day after day, night after night, we spent sitting together at my table in that apartment. 
 Now we did not have to sit on the edge of the bed &mdash; a much wider bed &mdash; because there were two chairs, and I had my own shower and facilities for making coffee and snacks. 
 Now that I had left the college dormitory I used to look fearfully from rime to time out of my window, expecting to see that gang of fascist students coming to beat me up. 
 One day when I went to give my language class at the university I found the word maricone  (queer) chalked in large Gothic letters on the blackboard. 
 I pretended not to notice it, and, as the students listened with bated breath, instructed them to turn to page thirty in Jespersen. 
 I gave a good class: there is nothing like teaching well for making one forget oneself and one's petty troubles. 
 I did not wipe the offending word off the blackboard, but as I was packing up my books and papers at the end of the class, a girl got up and without a word erased it, to a scattering of applause. 
 I did not tell Dana about it. 
 But I did tell him about Jordi. 
 I do not remember now how or why I did so, because despite my infatuation I still sometimes thought Dana was a Franco spy, or from the FBI or the CIA or even the CID or the KGB. 
 Then I would tell myself such ideas were unreasonable: why would an American half-poet want to betray me to any government agency? 
 It was absurd. 
 But I knew that absurder things had happened in America and Britain &mdash; and in Spain. 
 When I told Dana about Jordi, he said something I found revealing: &bquo;I like working men too.&equo; 
 What exactly did that imply? 
 Was he, too, after all, as I half suspected, a bisexual? 
 He had already told me about his girl-friend, an American student of modern dance in West Berlin. 
 But he had also hinted at a sexual relationship with one of his American university professors, and with the editor of a certain American music magazine, with whom he had spent a vacation in Hairi. 
 He showed me photographs of them together in a boat there, on a beach, in a restaurant. 
 But as far as I knew, he had no other friends in Salamanca, though he had only to lift his little finger and both men and women would have come running at his bidding. 
 He was unfailingly modest in behaviour and appearance, though his luxuriant hair used to excite the cupidity of the two hairdressers in the little barber-shop opposite the entrance to the Hospidaje Lisboa. 
 I was letting my own hair grow too. 
 The barbers would playfully wave to us as we went by, motioning towards their empty chairs. 
 I wished I had said nothing about Jordi. 
 At times I would wake up in the night, streaming with sweat, from a nightmare in which I relived that  terrifying night in Valladolid. 
 I shall never forget Jordi's face, his rueful smile, his fatalistic shrug as he was pushed into the car. 
 At times of the greatest mental stress I would wander into some cool church and try to pray in the dimness scented by peasant sweat, cold candle-grease and stale incense. 
 Sometimes Dana would come and sit with me on the hard little chairs. 
 Sometimes I would sit in the deserted church of San Madin, a small twelfth-century romanesque building just off the Plaza Mayor, on the Plaza Poeta Iglesias. 
 At other times I went into the much larger, colder Clerecia and watched the glib little gilt pendulum of an old-fashioned wall-clock next to the altar silently swinging my pain away. 
 I gave alms to all the blind beggars, lit candles without believing at all in their efficacy. 
 I just wanted to add a little light to illuminate the darkness of my soul. 
 When we came out of the Clerecia, after dipping hands in the holy water stoup and placing a drop on each other's brows, as we had seen the novios  and novias  do (the boy on entering a church would dip his hand in the water and transfer a drop to his fianc&eacute;e's fingertip so that they could cross themselves in unison), we would go into La Casa de las Conchas next to the Clerecia, with elaborate wrought-iron window-grilles and its tranquil courtyard, and sit there quietly for a while, thinking of the next poem, or of the one we were working on. 
 It was in this splendid fifteenth-century monument to the high architectural taste of the Catholic sovereigns that I read a message written by a fifteenth-century schoolboy on his classroom wall: Aqu&iacute; supo lo que es bueno, y lo que es malo, / Lo que es dulce, y lo que es amaro  (Here I had knowledge of what is good, and of what is bad, / Of what is sweet, and of what is bitter). 
 It seemed to apply to my life in Spain. 
 The ornately decorated and sculptured churches were parables and sermons in honey-coloured stone, miraculously preserved. 
 Like the French cathedrals, they were Bibles for those who could not read. 
 One of our poems was about the great carved tympanum over the main door of the Catedral Nueva, an incredibly detailed, deeply undercarved Nativity in two tall arched panels. 
 A typed version tells me the poem was written in December 1957. 
 I had written to Joe Ackerley about Dana, and how we were writing poems together, and he asked to see some examples of this unusual collaboration. 
 I sent him our Christmas poem, &bquo;Adoration of the Shepherds and the Kings&equo; (Puerta del Perd&oacute;n, Salamanca), which he printed in the 19 December issue, his 1957 Christmas number: 
 Under the cathedral's leaning cliff, the caves 
 Of darkness slam their doors. 
 Above, in high relief, 
 Twin arches, flocked with angels, open up their graves 
 Of rosy stone upon the gospel's double leaf, 
 Where kings and shepherds offer gifts to their belief. 
 Below some angels carolling an arch, the star 
 Steps out in front of formal clouds, 
 To light a tardy shepherd down the stable's far, 
 Rooftopping hill into the other panel's night &mdash; 
 With a curly dog, two camels and three trees in sight. 
 Off to the manger &mdash; to the boy whose little sleep 
 Is carved of brighter stone that leaves the starlight dim &mdash; 
 The shepherds run: one brings a basket, one a sheep 
 That tumbles round the wicker cot; one in the brim 
 Of his dumpled hat is kneeling; another kneels with him. 
 Behind them, dumbstruck in a wattled stall, 
 A donkey breathes into their frosted hair;, 
 A baffled ox has horned in through the wall. 
 The mother kneels and tends the infant air 
 That He has warmed by lying naked there. 
 Inside the other arch, three wise, outlandish kings, 
 Extravagantly groomed, are kneeling to adore 
 A child, the lodestone of their wanderings, 
 With gold and frankincense and myrrh. 
 They cast a crown before him on the briared floor. 
 Joseph to the background lends an honest charm. 
 A page is peeping round his master at the Son 
 Of Man, whose mother stands Him in her arm. 
 - Michael, geared for battle, guards the little one, 
 Whose clouds of angels blaze his star into a sun. 
 It was something we could barely understand, but I had a growing feeling that without my love the whole project would collapse. 
 It was love that kept me going; it was ambition to be a poet that fuelled Dana's labour and yoked it with mine. 
 At the same time I think there was a certain kind of love &mdash; detached but concerned &mdash; in the background of all he did, a love that steadily grew, without display, without spoken devotion; and I, too, never spoke of &bquo;love&equo;. 
 I realized I just had to accept him for what he was, and when I learnt to do that, he did the same to me  - accepted me without question, in all my imperfection, in all that made me unworthy of him. 
 Another poem that I have dated in the typescript &bquo;December, 1957, Plaza de Anaya, Salamanca&equo;, is one I was able to write for myself, and that I never showed to Dana. 
 ft was just about the last poem I wrote on my own for the next six months or so; it is called &bquo;Believing Is Seeing&equo;, and it was also about a carving, the sculpture illustrating the miracle of Christ healing the blind man: 
 In this little park, beneath the blind man's door 
 That made our separate vision; one, 
 I walk again alone, and all is dark. 
 I am afraid to find belief has gone. 
 In this moment, I try to see, 
 But cannot. 
 Light is set apart 
 From the reality we both restored 
 To one another. 
 I am blinded to the heart. 
 Each moment that once brought me 
 To yourself abstracts me more and more. 
 I stare dumbly from behind a glass 
 At snow falling down the blinded door. 
 Pray now no more for you and me, 
 But only for that one identity 
 We give each other. 
 Let us believe 
 Its miracle will always make us see. 
 In the little park beneath the blind man's door 
 That blessed us with the vision faith had won, 
 The day now is wrapped in snow, 
 And it is brighter than the sun. 
 I still recognize that poem as being utterly my own. 
 In our Nativity poem, I can still, thirty years later, recognize the contributions made by Dana to the poem, and those that are mine. 
 Dana's words and phrases are unmistakable; they have that slightly cute, American ring: &bquo;Twin arches, flocked with angels&equo;, &bquo;some angels carolling an arch&equo;, &bquo;a tardy shepherd&equo;, &bquo;the star steps out&equo;, &bquo;a curly dog&equo;, and so on. 
 The inherent American way with words is everywhere evident. 
 That poem, &bquo;Believing Is Seeing,&equo; refers to one of the first poems we wrote together. 
 It was one about another exquisitely detailed carving on a cathedral door, the Portada de Ramos &mdash; the Palm Sunday Doorway. 
 I  did not date the typed copy I made &mdash; for Dana could not or would not type, and after we had finished a poem to our common satisfaction, I had to type it out while he rested on the bed &mdash; but I am fairly certain it was written soon after I met Dana in that Spanish class for foreigners, which I have noted in my 1957 Letts Diary: &bquo;Wednesday, October 16. 
 Moon's last quarter. 
 Met Dana in class.&equo; 
 So here is our first poem written in collaboration: 
 Portada de Ramos  
 Here in a country where so many men are blind, 
 We pass a daily miracle performed in stone: 
 Followed by the three disciples he loved best, 
 And bridling his ass beneath a wall and by a bridge, 
 Christ gentles out of stone into the arc of sight. 
 Two palm trees frond the background of the day. 
 A halo rich with rust is lofted round the heads 
 Of James and John and Peter. 
 Thinned by time, the rings 
 Still dip and float above their brows, with grace 
 That perfectly restores their master's perished crown. 
 His robes are loosely folded in the clouding stone. 
 His missing hand is lifted and its blessing stays. 
 A crowd of two or three lay down their cloaks 
 And strew palm branches beneath the donkey's hooves. 
 In a corner by a bridge, Zacchaeus climbs a tree 
 To match the fame of Jesus with his face. 
 Two boys, perched upon a wall, surprise 
 A gesture and believe the miracle. 
 A shaft of metal weaves the light of Jesus' eyes 
 Into the blind man's stony gaze and makes it His, 
 A sight that lets the others see across the dark 
 Their faces lifted to the light. 
 Their arms are stayed 
 Between the questioning and answering of faith 
 That still projects itself along the rusting shaft. 
 The blind may never see this proof of hope. 
 They cannot find it here in stone as soft as sand 
 Whose dusty roses shroud the scene and shell their eyes. 
 They count their steps along the darkened streets, 
 Fumbling a lottery of falling leaves, and crying to the stones 
 Their message for the day, which is today. 
 That last line was a memory of all the blind lottery-ticket sellers we had heard crying &bquo;Para hoy! 
 Para hoy!&equo; 
 Our ideas about faith were taken from my readings of Unamuno, and in this poem from one of the essays, &bquo;Faith, Hope and Charity&equo;, from The Tragic Sense of Life : &bquo;A faith that does not doubt is a dead faith.&equo; 
 This was one of the unequivocal statements that aroused in 1913 the ire of the traditionalist clergy of Spain. 
 I preferred Paul Delvaux's macabre vision of the Crucifixion. 
 In my diary, some time after our first meeting, I wrote the date of Dana's birthday. 
 He was a Libra, or the Balance, the seventh sign of the Zodiac whose name indicates that day and night, being of equal length, are being weighed &bquo;in the balance&equo;. 
 It is an autumnal sign and one in which the &bquo;balance&equo; might be tipped one way or another, and in sexuality could hover between male and female, with one sexual scale dipping then the other rising obediently and almost passively, distantly, independently, in an alternation of identities and desires that I knew so well. 
 Dana was always balanced between the two, whereas I would fluctuate for long periods &mdash; a year or two in the male, a year or two in the female scale, with often sharp and distressing adjustments of behaviour and character. 
 I always thought that my Taurean nature &mdash; though on the cusp with Aries, looking forward towards another double-image sign, Gemini, which made for imbalance &mdash; was far from typical; but certainly the bull was well and truly there in my strong sexuality. 
 Dana was steadily centred right in the middle of Libra, and so could be regarded as a perfectly balanced human being, with a true equivalence of male and female, physical and intellectual, animal and spiritual, and I think it was from this delicate balance, never upset, that his magnetic force of personality derived. 
 I secretly longed to upset his balance but never succeeded, except in the making of poetry, in which he was compelled to tilt towards me. 
 Another diary entry, in the same black ink, written with my calligraphic pen, was for 2 November: &bquo;Day of the poem &bquo;Fall, a Flock of Sheep, a Roman Bridge&equo;.&equo; 
 This was the first poem Dana showed me, and one of the first I reworked with him. 
 My typed version is signed with our pseudonym. 
 In the &bquo;Notes&equo; under the same date I have written something I always wanted to remember: &bquo;The walk at night. 
 Dana. 
 Viva! 
 Todos Diffuntos (All Saints).&equo; 
 There is also the name Angel Kirvor, which was the first pseudonym we thought of for our combined poems. 
 After we finished that poem, late in the evening of 2 November, we went walking through the streets of Salamanca for most of the night, for the poem had persuaded us that something remarkable was really happening to us, that some kind of poetic grace had been bestowed upon us. 
 We had been careful until then not to think that way. 
 But this  poem seemed to us incontrovertible proof of our poetic twinship. 
 And we went on writing poems, in that luxuriant air of mingled spirituality and sexual anguish. 
 Dana always sat with his legs wide apart, as if inviting the touch of eyes, if not hands. 
 I was sure he knew I could barely contain myself or restrain my trembling fingers that longed to run their tips along the insides of those meaty thighs that were spreadeagled enticingly over the edge of his seat. 
 He had few clothes &mdash; a &bquo;good suit&equo; of dark-blue lightweight dacron that was the badge of every American in those days, a couple of shirts, a long, shapeless tweed overcoat of German origin he wore when it got colder. 
 Then there were those brown corduroys and blue jeans: the very seams of his old, faded pants enraptured me, seeming to underscore the seductive outlines of his lower frame, running from the back of his thick leather belt down along that mysterious, rich intercrural channel, and coming out at the other end of the tunnel at the tense crossroads orienting the scrotum's heavy bag with its blissful raphe, or subtly defining and underlining the inside and outside of the long, smooth thighs and the stocky, bulgy, athletic calves. 
 He had been a very successful amateur boxer, and sometimes would try to relieve our tension by sparring with me, teaching me basic moves of a sport I knew nothing about and instinctively detested. 
 But as I tried to follow his instructions, keeping my fists up and my chin tucked in and learning a new kind of dance on the balls of my feet, the sight of his bare, hairless chest, so brown and muscular, would suddenly fill me with more than muscular weakness, and I felt I would collapse, not under the playful blows he landed on my discombobulated body, but under the sheer spell of his magnificence. 
 I never landed a single blow on those perfect shoulders, that sun-tanned thorax, that laughing, mocking, taunting face; but I was only too happy when he slipped through my feeble defences and gently pummelled me all over with his bare hands, until my all-too-vulnerable defence degenerated into a giggling slapping match. 
 He was fully aware, I now realize, of my absorbed interest in his loose-limbed, perfectly proportioned body, its stocky compactness, and exploited my obsession, my helpless longing to touch the untouchable. 
 As we spent hour after hour sitting at our work-table, all curtains drawn to intensify our concentration beneath the old-fashioned fringed standard lamp, he would from time to time ease his buttocks and balls, pulling and tugging on the firm seams of the taut, well-worn jeans or the  well-rubbed brown needle cords, scratching and stroking himself idly, as if unselfconsciously in the most private places with those delicate fingers with the bitten nails and his big, warm palms. 
 Was he just a common cock-tease, I would wonder as I suggested a new word, broke an overlong line, or did he sometimes really desire a more intimate contact? 
 If so, he never gave any definite sign of it. 
 All through that October and November, in my claustrophobic college room or in my dark-curtained hotel apartment, I grew to desire more of him than just his presence at my side as we wrote. 
 Sometimes 1 would try to withhold my gift of words as the only way I could convey to him that he was withholding something I needed as badly as he needed my poetic ability. 
 At once he would sense my withdrawal, and was sad and silent for a while. 
 He would go out for a walk, leaving me alone for an hour, then return full of high spirits, shouting from the doorway:. 
 &bquo;Back on form now?&equo; 
 Was he taking drugs? 
 If so, he concealed it from me. 
 But sometimes he seemed unnaturally flushed and lively &mdash; and it was not with drink. 
 Was it marijuana, which he told me he had smoked? 
 Or something more sinister? 
 The very idea of taking drugs disgusted me. 
 As I had told Dr Grey Walter, a poet is born &bquo;high&equo;. 
 He needs at all rimes to be in full possession of his faculties, or that extra, unpredictable poetic thrust would never declare itself &mdash; that heart-lifting boost that rockets mere words into the outer spaces of true poetry. 
 I loved working with Dana, and yet as time went by and we produced more and more collaborative poems I began to long to get my own poetic and personal identities back. 
 From the very first day I saw him I began writing poems to him that later grouped themselves into the sequence entitled &bquo;Suite Salmantina&equo; which, with other poems about Spain, forms the central part of my collection called The Prodigal Son: Poems  1956&ndash;1959. 
 They were not all written at the same time, or in that order: I had to keep struggling to write my own work as Dana's poetic demands became more and more insistent.  
 TURNING IT ALL TO POETRY 
 The satisfied, the happy, do not love; they fall asleep in habit, near neighbour to annihilation. 
 Miguel de Unamuno , THE TRAGIC SENSE OF LIFE 
 &bquo;I'll turn it all to poetry!&equo; 
 Myself, when threatened with arrest by the British police 
 Like Unamuno, I am all contradictions. 
 Poetry is my only defence against a world I detest and celebrate, my only weapon against a life I love and abominate. 
 Being bisexual is a simple duality. 
 But to have a multiple personality, in which one self may suddenly be overthrown by another and one mind may be torn in several different directions is sometimes so intolerable, I long for extinction. 
 But would even physical evaporation bring peace to warring souls and contradictory afterlives? 
 I doubt it. 
 My infatuation with Dana did, however, bring a certain simplicity to my existence. 
 As I became more and more obsessed by him, and as he absorbed more and more of my being, all else seemed to start retreating into a permanent, one-dimensional background, against which only he and I stood out as more than stick figures. 
 We had made our own Garden of Eden. 
 I wrote dutifully to my parents every week. 
 I kept in touch with Joe &mdash; there were no other friends. 
 But they appeared to me as if seen through the wrong end of a telescope, muted and unreal. 
 Students, colleagues, passers-by all faded into deceptive distances. 
 Even Jordi and his knife withdrew slowly from my consciousness. 
 All was excluded by this all-exclusive passion. 
 All those I had loved in the past &mdash; Richard, Marjorie, Alain, Madeleine, Leo, Muriel, Alan, Sandro, Erich, Jordi &mdash; all loved more or less in vain, hopelessly &mdash; were now without substance or meaning. 
 I could see this condition coming upon me relentlessly from the first moment Dana cast his eyes upon me: he was another who knew how to use the power of the evil eye, almost casually, to enchant total strangers. 
 Against his magnetic forces, my own &bquo;evil&equo; eye, which had anyhow long  since started to abandon me, could put up no resistance. 
 After my first sight of him that sunny autumn morning in the gallery of the courtyard in the Palacio de Anaya, his face haunted me all day, and I dreamt of him during the night &mdash; a long, ecstatic dream of such acute sensual pleasure I woke up aching and exhausted by too much bliss. 
 The dawn was just breaking. 
 I got up and, sitting at my window, looked out over the still-sleeping city, and wrote my first poem to this unknown god: 
 The dawn strikes up its music in the dark. 
 Behind the black cathedrals of the square 
 Cocks shout, and wake the grumbling dogs. 
 Great domes compose their masses on the air. 
 A flock of doves, cast from the breeze's hand, 
 Crockets a pinnacle with wings on wings. 
 Bells beat at the morning stars like fans, 
 And in between their silence rings. 
 Street-lamps still illuminate 
 Each level, long fa&ccedil;ade. 
 But the roofs' inventive arabesques 
 Turn black against a sky of jade. 
 Translucencies are brushed with clouds 
 And furred with feathers, with the bloom 
 Of dark and fronded trees. 
 The city breathes, and flows into my room. 
 I lean from a window like a statue from a wall, 
 And dip my face into the fountains of the east. 
 A chimney slowly hangs out smoke. 
 My eyes are brimmed with the horizon's feast. 
 Now jade is blue: grey distances are slashed with red; 
 The fretted spires are pierced with white. 
 - I look towards these preparations for the sun, 
 And see your face lift from its dream of night. 
 The night before, I had gone for a long, lonely walk along the banks of the Tormes, crossing and recrossing the Roman bridge, hoping against hope that I might somehow find you also walking there. 
 But all was deserted, and I took comfort from a star:  
 The first star, liquid Sirius, 
 Drips in the river's glass its slender 
 Chandelier. 
 Its lustre, long as light, 
 Drops brimming candles deep 
 Into the melting mirrors of the night. 
 A swimming creature undulates across the sky, and shakes 
 The limpid evening to a pulse of cool desire, 
 A weeping star that mends itself in time 
 With lost light that trembles round 
 The bend of space, and barely breaks. 
 The next day the unbelievable happened, and you entered the Spanish class for foreigners. 
 I heard your name for the first time. 
 And at the end of the class, near the bust of Unamuno, I heard your voice calling to me for the first time. 
 We went to that caf&eacute; with the tourist postcards rattling on their metal lattices in the dusty wind, on the street called Libreros. 
 We talked for the first time about poetry, poets and our own poems: 
 Your eyes first looked into these words 
 With that steady honesty you give 
 To cats and ballads, food and birds, 
 To fields and faces, sticks and stones, 
 And only then they seemed to live: 
 I felt your body in my flesh and bones. 
 Was it a case of demonic possession? 
 I began to think it must be, for every hour of my waking and sleeping was occupied by thoughts and images of you, in every expected and unexpected situation and attitude. 
 In my day-dreams and nightmares you were always clothed in those washed-out jeans: I can still see their frayed, ravelled seams with their bleached, raggy threads softened by countless abrasions and grindings, the frazzled button-holes, the worn buttons showing the cheap metal underneath. 
 I often saw you sprawling on the floor or on a park bench, a joyous sunburst of creases radiating from your abandoned crotch, your jumping fly. 
 But mostly I imagined you asleep, left utterly to yourself in a situation where my own absence from your life did not matter: 
 I dream of you asleep: 
 A contained sweetness, 
 Warm, and full, and deep. 
 I think of your completeness, 
 And the way you place 
 A gentle strength, a neatness 
 In a line that orders grace 
 With wildness; the unexpected break 
 Of phrase that lights your face, 
 The seafarer's eyes that shake 
 Their pale blue fires on the prow 
 Of poetry, your sparkling wake. 
 We were looking forward to the vacation, to Christmas, to what you called &bquo;New Year's&equo;. 
 Secretly I was planning to take you home with me to show to my parents. 
 I had already written to them about you, in guarded terms, and their lack of response to my enthusiasms in the way of friends never discouraged me. 
 I had learnt, however, never to tell them much, to keep the best parts hidden, as indeed I often had to. 
 But with you, there was nothing to hide &mdash; at least so far. 
 We were &bquo;just good friends&equo;, however much I wished we could be more than that. 
 The closest I ever got to you was when we went for a spin on your motor bike, with me like a ravished flapper on the pillion, legitimately clinging to your lissom waist, to those two wonderful hip-bones I loved to hold, as if they were the very hinges of heaven, whose wind blew your hair back into my ecstatic face: 
 Each day now is Christmas, 
 With the present of the day before 
 Still with me, past being broken, 
 And the present day's own gift 
 Still to be given and received. 
 Love gives each morning's air, 
 Cleansed by the sun's wide sweeps of blue, 
 A breath of celebration, spicy 
 As the wind-thrown fragrance of your hair, 
 The very essence that is only you. 
 The &bquo;presents&equo; and the &bquo;gifts&equo; were those we exchanged daily when we were writing poetry together &mdash; presents which, unlike those of my childhood, did not break as soon as touched. 
 Life had become spiced by my longing, by the sheer happiness of knowing I would see you that morning, that night, next day:  
 At five of the stars I wake 
 On a rare October morning, 
 And a poem overflows 
 My candid dark. 
 I keep my eyes closed, 
 Happy, pretending sleep, 
 With a gift in my head for you, 
 Another in my heart. 
 Suddenly both are one. 
 I am writing with open eyes 
 The words I dreamed for you, 
 As if the familiar were new. 
 The paper warms to them 
 And to my flowing hand 
 With the untidy fire 
 Of the bed I burned to leave. 
 Looking to where the dark 
 Shelters the house in which you lie, 
 I feel my heart beat like a boy's 
 On Christmas morning, in a house of toys. 
 After I moved to my apartment in the Hotel Espa&ntilde;a I kept hoping I might be able to persuade you to come and share it, or at least to take the one next to mine, which was empty. 
 But you always evaded this question, saying your allowance from home would not stretch to paying the extra rent. 
 And you seemed to have become attached to that awful little room in the Hospedaje Lisboa. 
 I think I obscurely felt relief that I would continue to live alone, to have at least a few hours of the day and night when I could try to regain one of my mixed-up selves. 
 For I was still struggling in the web you had woven, like a helpless insect wanting to escape, yet hypnotized into acquiescence and adoration by the spider's malefic eyes and enveloping threads, wound slowly one by one round my resistless mind: 
 Love blinds, but makes me see 
 Life's folly clear as day. 
 My self has gone away from me 
 And nothing come to stay. 
 Only the love I flee 
 Is true, and will not go away. 
 I was convinced of one thing: of the purity and truth of my love for you. 
 Then why did I want to run away from it? 
 There were bitter memories of broken love for Alan, a good-looking Londoner I had fallen for while I was still at Madame Sheba's. 
 With her penetrating instinct she did not like him, and was so angry with me for, as she said, &bquo;wasting myself upon such rubbish&equo;, that in the end she turned me out of my room and I went to live in a tiny, freezing attic in a house in Morningside Crescent owned by a friend of hers, a white woman. 
 I was very unhappy there, away from the love and warmth Madame had always given me, and the love affair that accompanied the change soon turned cold: Alan exhibited a certain kind of treachery, casually throwing me over for someone else who &bquo;was better in bed&equo;. 
 It was a common experience for me to fall in love with love and then be led up the garden path, only to be rejected and mocked. 
 That affair left a permanent scar on my heart and I was afraid of reopening it. 
 So I clung to the concept of ideal love for you, at the same time hoping for the even more impossibly ideal physical fulfilment and completion that would seal our closeness for ever. 
 Each time I saw you coming dancing towards me along a sunny street, moving lightly on your toes like a boxer, with your slightly duck-toed run that I, a turned-out-toes walker, found so male and so sexy, my heart jumped in my throat and I wanted to run towards you and throw myself into your arms. 
 But we never even walked arm-in-arm, as was the accepted way for conventional Spanish male friends or accomplices like the black-glassed Falangists. 
 I struggled to keep my love pure, remembering at the same time something Madeleine had told me and that Rena was to repeat: &bquo;What you need, Jimi, is the love of a bad woman.&equo; 
 Well, I did find that, and the love of bad men, too, but it made no difference. 
 I was an incurable romantic and yearned for a romantic friendship before it would be too late, for I believed in those days that romantic friendship was possible only in youth. 
 So I strove to keep our relationship &bquo;true&equo; &mdash; on a true course: 
 True love alone can write 
 Because it asks no more 
 Than its undemanding light 
 To burn out passion's core 
 Of self, with care for others' sight. 
 A pure flame burns my snow. 
 I melt and freeze, 
 But I am water, too, and flow, 
 To give my driven spirit ease, 
 In a single tear, that is the joy I know. 
 My hand runs like a delta through 
 These maps my soundings make. 
 Although I draw them all for you, 
 And keep a lighthouse for your sake, 
 All men may use them, for my love is true. 
 From time to time, walking in the crowded arcades of the Plaza Mayor, my heart would miss a beat as I fancied I saw Jordi mingling with all those similar dark heads and slender figures. 
 Something about the back of a man's neck would remind me of him. 
 I have always felt that character is most clearly expressed in the back of a person's head, and especially in the nape. 
 From a swift glance at the back of a person's head I can at once estimate the intelligence and sexuality of that person. 
 For me, intelligence and sexuality go together, and it is usually with the intelligence in a person's eyes that I first fall in love. 
 Jordi's head was set beautifully on his broad shoulders, and there was something in the way he held his neck to support that head which was unmistakably intelligent and sexy. 
 I like big heads that are flat at the back, not pointed, and for that reason in recent years it is Korean males who have attracted me most, with their rich, straight black hair laid perpendicularly on that square-backed skull &mdash; always, to me, the sign of a male good at mathematics, the sexiest science. 
 There were many heads like that in Spain, and I would follow outstanding examples gazing in admiration at that nape, that neck, that flat-backed skull, until the head turned and let me glimpse the face, which was never disappointing. 
 But each time my heart stood still, expecting to find Jordi: yet it was never he. 
 One short poem in &bquo;Suite Salmantina&equo; applies to both you and Jordi: 
 Instead of a despair, believe 
 True love is never lost. 
 Though no hand will receive 
 Its foolish gift, its ghost 
 Will not go wandering without release 
 Along the rivers of the midnight air. 
 Although the body finds no peace, 
 True love is in the spirit's care, 
 And is not wasted in a selfish sigh. 
 - This one truth I find in you 
 Is gathered by the waters and the sky, 
 And is not lost, because my love is true. 
 Most of the square-skulled men I followed in this way in the streets turned out to have very macho faces, conventionally handsome, proud, even disdainful, as if they felt they alone were the lords and masters of the earth. 
 That always disappointed me. 
 I have never cared much for men who are all man: they are the ones who smugly believe they must be irresistible to me, and take elaborately cautious steps to protect their priceless male virginity from what they seem to imagine will be my marauding hands. 
 I can understand so well what women feel when they are subjected to a male-dominated society &mdash; an almost intolerable urge to scream at those smirking, swanking Don Juans who think no woman can resist them. 
 I prefer men who have some feminine tact and delicacy and sensitivity, and women who have some of the better masculine qualities &mdash; tenderness, protectiveness, a good brain and a humorous way of dealing with all the practical impossibilities of life. 
 And I could sense this feminine quality in you. 
 Sometimes I even thought of you as one of my favourite fictional heroines, Maggie Tulliver in The Mill on the Floss , while I was Philip Waken, though not such a limp type. 
 It was the sort of relationship I had with my earliest girl-love, the tomboy Isa, when I was about three or four years old, described in The Only Child . 
 Then our relationship to each other would change, and you would be a more boyish Philip Waken, and I a less hoydenish Maggie. 
 Willa Cather's My Antonia , which along with her other novels I was absorbing with great delight at this period, provided another couple with whom to identify, Antonia and Jim Burden, and I kept switching sides with these characters also. 
 I wanted so much to put into words, in a novel or a play, all that you and I felt for one another, not just to love love but to inscribe it as George Eliot and Willa Cather had done. 
 So I felt inexpressible gratitude to you for giving me the support and care of that relationship, however attenuated it appeared to me at times: 
 You are the only ghost 
 I ever truly loved, 
 Because your presence moved 
 My heart with more than lust. 
 With not a single touch 
 And with no human kiss 
 You brought my life to this 
 Wild calm that holds so much. 
 Not only gaiety and trust 
 I learnt from your repose, 
 But that true passion grows, 
 Like art, because it must. 
 O, with a single look 
 I felt the darkness change. 
 And it was nothing strange: 
 The opening of a book. 
 In the brightness of the sun 
 You bring a moonlit air. 
 - No ghost had ever gifts as rare, 
 Or love more substance, than this only one. 
 And always, when we were apart, I kept bringing you beside me in my imagination, in the poems I was writing all alone, writing for you as well as for myself: 
 I seem to hear you stir, as if 
 You were only in the other room. 
 Distance has paper walls. 
 The air between us 
 Is your breath and mine. 
 Though you are close, 
 You are most far away. 
 But because you are so dear 
 I bring you through the paper wall 
 That is neither there, nor here. 
 And often, as I sat writing such poems that helped me cling to the last shreds of my many identities, I would suddenly sense that you were indeed approaching. 
 You could not be in the room next to mine, but you were in the same city, coming towards me, turning the corner of the square, entering the same street! 
 And I would rush to the window and look down and see you turning the corner to cross the square below, or walk round it to the hotel door. 
 I never went down to meet you, for I was always afraid those right-wing student bullies might be waiting for me &mdash; you they could not touch, but I was an easy prey. 
 It was only when I felt safe with you, and after we had spent some hours working on our poems, that we would go down to the restaurant for late dinner, which always ended with either banana or &bquo;flan&equo;. 
 Then, when it had grown dark, we would go out to join the paseo : 
 I wait for the drown 
 Of evening, when we go, 
 Together and together, through 
 The sinking town, 
 A meeting that is not a rendezvous 
 With loneliness and dark, 
 And stiff knives thicketing a naked park. 
 Slowly the roofs go down, 
 Releasing buoyant stars 
 To mark the watered sky with spars 
 Of light, a splintering crown 
 That binds our hidden scars 
 With stone, and keeps our heads above 
 The wrecks of solitude and love. 
 Yet as our relationship deepened, you seemed to abstract yourself, and sometimes I would not see you for days on end. 
 Then when we met again, you would be full of all you had done &mdash; a ride on your motor bike to Alba de Tormes or Ledesma, a strange church you had discovered, or a new book someone had sent you from the States. 
 Even worse, you would tell me about new poems you had started to write, and it was like a dagger in my heart when you described working on them without my help &mdash; though the real reason you had come back to see me was to labour over them with me, adding my suggestions and excisions in the margins in your minuscule script. 
 When you stayed away from me, I would try in vain to will you back beside me: then, long after the dinner I waited for you to share but had to eat alone, I would wander out into the stony streets, hoping to bump into you, to glimpse you sitting in a bar or on a park bench: 
 Wandering alone at midnight 
 Along the streets we walked together, 
 I was a stranger once again, 
 For everything was unfamiliar, 
 Changed by the loneliness as much 
 As by your presence at my side. 
 Even the stars were altered. 
 The fixed positions that I saw with you 
 Now seemed obscure. 
 I could not find my orient, 
 Or the pole that keeps its compass in your hand 
 At meeting and parting, night and day. 
 - Then I found myself beneath 
 Your window lighted from within, 
 And for a moment watched 
 Your shadow move across the glass. 
 I gave a shout: but as I looked, 
 Even that last star went out. 
 Still, I waited patiently, and wished you well. 
 I wanted your poetry to be better, wanted to show you the way into a wider perspective of words and feelings. 
 After long days and nights alone I would wake in the mornings wondering if this new day would bring a new poem from you, a new smile as you ran dancing towards me on your boxer's turned-in toes. 
 When I awoke and started getting ready for my classes, which now passed mechanically, as if in a vacuum, the students suspended in time and space, and my own voice seeming to come from somewhere a long, long way away, I would write a poem for you as a kind of incantation to bring you back that day: 
 Now you are waking to our common air 
 That is the same for sleepers and their mates, 
 For those who watch and wonder at the rare 
 Bright morning that combines our separate fates. 
 Let this long day be full for you, 
 Filled with your working sun 
 That makes the heavens white and blue 
 Above the brown horizons where your poems run. 
 Although you always came to me brimming with news of where you had been and what you had done, I do not think you told me everything. 
 And you never asked me what I had been doing. 
 And suddenly so much was happening to you and, by extension, to me. 
 You got letters from home, from your father asking when you were going to settle down and get a proper job, or were you going to be an &bquo;eternal student&equo;? 
 Packages of that rare onion-skin typing paper which made my erasures of mistypings so easy came from your mother, who also sent you boxes of drugs, chiefly Dexedrine, those shocking-pink amphetamines which, I later discovered, are bad for the heart. 
 The Spanish laws against drug use in those days were exceptionally severe,  and I was terrified in case you should be found out by the police or the drug squad. 
 I had heard awful tales of Spanish prisons. 
 You persuaded me to experiment with Dexedrine. 
 I still remember the night we started, sitting in the brasserie on the ground floor of my hotel, downing Dexedrine with San Miguel beer. 
 They were supposed to heighten our perceptions, but really I could see little difference between my ordinary vision of life, which was fantastic enough, and what the pills apparently produced, mainly a nervous sleeplessness shot through with incoherent babblings and bursts of laughter alternating with floods of tears. 
 They also made me extremely randy, an effect I pointed out to you, who seemed unaffected in that department and were astonished that they should stimulate my already overwrought sexuality &mdash; &bquo;oversexed and under seventy&equo; is how I still think of myself. 
 Under the influence of the drugs we exchanged a few playful cuddles and kisses, just for a lark. 
 It went no further, despite my insistence: you always gently repulsed me. 
 But our complicity in taking those dreadful little uppers, of which I thoroughly disapproved, as I do of all narcotic stimulants, drew us closer together, so I submitted to their influence. 
 You rarely received letters yourself. 
 I never received one from you, though you had many from me, of course. 
 That you did not write letters to me I sometimes attributed to the fact that you must indeed be a secret agent, unwilling to commit himself in writing. 
 I think the postman would never have been able to decipher your scribble, your own version of Walser's MS, Bleistiftgebiet  or Kingdom of the Pencil, which we were to describe in a later poem, &bquo;The Poem in the Pencil&equo;. 
 But you certainly received some letters. 
 There was one from an American girl in Berlin. 
 I believe she was studying modern dance and had been a pupil of Mary Wigman, or of one of her disciples. 
 She announced, to my dismay, that she was coming to Salamanca for a week or so. 
 I could so clearly see her coming between you and me, between us and our poetry, and I felt furiously jealous and unhappy but tried not to show it. 
 After all, I had no real claim upon your attention, and I knew I meant so little to you I could be dropped at any moment without a second thought. 
 The young woman arrived late one evening after having driven all the way from Berlin in her Volkswagen Beetle, at that time the &bquo;in&equo; means of transport for young Americans. 
 To my surprise, I liked her very much. 
 She was tall and dark and pale, and looked very mysterious and romantic. 
 She had a beautiful figure which she used in subtle movements of unparalleled grace. 
 The only thing I did not like about her was the flat ballerina-style slippers she always wore, to reduce her height I think, because she was taller than you. 
 We all three had dinner  together, then you went off with her to your room, where she was to stay, though how you managed to accommodate yourselves in that tiny room with its narrow bed was something I preferred not to think about. 
 I suffered agonies of suspense in silence, for I never knew when or where I would see you again, or whether she would be with you. 
 One morning, to my intense embarrassment, you brought her to my poetry appreciation class &mdash; which you had never bothered to attend yourself. 
 You came without warning and without asking my permission and sat with her at the back of the lecture theatre, exchanging glances and comments. 
 My poems that day were Hopkins's &bquo;Heaven-Haven&equo; and &bquo;The Habit of Perfection&equo;. 
 You ruined them for me, and I have hated them ever since. 
 In Japan I refuse admittance to the many foreigners who try to barnstorm my classes. 
 I inform them that my classes are intended &bquo;for Japanese only&equo;. 
 For native English speakers I would give a quite different kind of lecture, and I did not want to be judged by the standards of my lectures to the Japanese, which were nearly always basic and very simple in expression. 
 Yet &bquo;The Habit of Perfection&equo; was once my private vision of our own poetic relationship. 
 And as Hopkins writes in a letter to Bridges: &bquo;Now it is the virtue of design, pattern, or inscape to be distinctive and it is the vice of distinctiveness to become queer.&equo; 
 I was already queer, and had known too long the vice of distinctiveness in my personal life as well as in my poetry. 
 The young dancer put a stop to our writing, as I had expected. 
 You went for rides with her in her VW, and made an extended trip to Lisbon - to Madrid also, I believe. 
 I behaved with great dignity and showed none of the resentment I may have felt. 
 But it was a relief to me when she left and, I was thankful to discover, it was even more of a relief to you. 
 We took up the lost threads of our writing together with even greater dedication. 
 After that long interval it was hard to get started again. 
 But as soon as we had found our voice again, we were once more interrupted by visits from Berlin. 
 A group of your former fellow-students at the university, all Germans, and all extreme radicals, arrived on the scene in Salamanca and proceeded to disrupt our lives and shock the Spaniards with their outrageous behaviour, in which you joined. 
 One of the things we were involved in remains in my memory with shocking force. 
 It all started out as a silly student prank, but it was to mark me for life. 
 We had been conducting the German youths on tours of our favourite places in the city &mdash; to the bullring, the restaurants, the bars, the River Tormes, the Casa de Santa Teresa, the Antiguo Colegio Mayor de Iriandeses, San Martin (where we were nearly locked in for the night)  and to the conventual church of San Esteban. 
 The Convento de San Esteban is a magnificent plateresque sixteenth-century edifice on the Plaza Santo Domingo, approached by a small arched bridge which provides an impressive forefront to that immense carved fa&ccedil;ade, with the arcaded convent standing at right angles to it on the right. 
 It was one of my favourite churches, because the interior was so vast, so gloriously ornamented, and nearly always empty. 
 That altar is one of the greatest works of Jos&eacute; Churriguera. 
 As usual when we entered a church together, I dipped my finger in the holy water and gave you a drop from my fingertips, so that we could cross ourselves together, like a novio  and novia . 
 Our gesture was not really a religious one, for neither of us believed in the Roman Catholic faith and detested its oppressive hold on the Spanish people, particularly the poor. 
 We used to do it almost as a social thing, a conventional Spanish gesture which for us had a special meaning &mdash; or at least it did for me, because I looked upon it as a seal on our friendship. 
 I think you did it just to please me, or perhaps to satisfy your own deep-seated urge to be conventional in outward things. 
 But when your German friends saw us doing this, they hooted with derision. 
 Fortunately, the church was empty: there were no priests, no sacristans, no black-mantillaed old ladies worshipping in front of the gorgeously gilded altar with its six twisted baroque pillars framing the blue heaven of the inner sanctuary. 
 It is one of the most imposing interiors in Salamanca, and the atmosphere of utter devoutness that informs every inch of stone and ornament is overpoweringly strange and haunting. 
 We all trooped up to the altar, behind which your Berlin friends discovered a mysterious opening. 
 I think it must have been left by workmen who had been preparing the crypt for the disposal of some saintly relic or the body of a recently deceased priest. 
 The young Germans went down into the crypt, pulling you after them. 
 You looked back at me, and I knew I had to follow you. 
 When we got inside the dimly lit space beneath the main altar, we found an open coffin, in which a partially decomposed skeleton was lying. 
 The robes were stained and torn, but there still seemed to be some blood on the bones. 
 There was what may have been a bishop's mitre on the skull, which grinned amiably up at us. 
 We gazed at the figure in the utmost fascination. 
 Then you cried: &bquo;Anyone who doesn't touch the bones is chicken!&equo; 
 Immediately you touched those bones, and all the others did the same, laughing and jostling to get at the coffin. 
 Again you just looked at me, and I knew I had to do as you had done, so I stretched out my right  hand and touched the bones, which were slightly sticky. 
 But in touching them I tried to bless them, in a spirit of reverence. 
 I prayed silently for peace to those venerable remains. 
 We left the church without being seen. 
 After a few more days in Salamanca, during which you and I could do no work in common, your friends left in a great uproar of drunken invective, shouting political slogans &mdash; which fortunately were in German &mdash; against the Franco regime. 
 Though I agreed with their political views, I could not condone the way they acted and was glad to see them go at last. 
 So, I am sure, were you. 
 But the memory of those sacred bones remained engraved upon my memory for the rest of my life. 
 They had been defiled, and I expected punishment. 
 There was a curious incident when a man from the British Council in Madrid came to see me. 
 This was to be the third of my many run-ins with that typically British authoritarian institution, which is never happy unless making trouble. 
 The British Council abroad is bent on getting everything connected with British education and culture under its tyrannical control, and outsiders like myself who found their own positions without passing through the old-boy network and the rigid screening system of the Council were always given a hard time. 
 I don't know why our man in Madrid came to see me; just idle curiosity, perhaps &mdash; so few people have ever met me, so many seem anxious to do so. 
 Or perhaps he had heard rumours of my goings-on, and had come personally to find out &bquo;what Kirkup's up to now&equo; &mdash; the traditional BC phrase wherever they have the misfortune to discover my presence. 
 He was a typical British Council smoothie, with a fatuous grin and an ingratiating manner. 
 To my surprise, he invited me to give a poetry reading in Madrid. 
 I agreed, provided Dana were allowed to go with me and share the reading. 
 He was rather taken aback but said he would report to head office and let me know about it in the New Year. 
 Dana and I had already spent a few weekends in Madrid, travelling by bus via Avila through wonderful country. 
 On our first trip together we had visited a caf&eacute; of a very old-fashioned kind, called Cafeteria Varela Reposteria in Preciados, and I had noted an inscription saying En este lugar escribi&otilde; sus mejores versos el gran poeta Emilio Carrere 1881&ndash;1947.  
 Homenaje de los poetas espa&ntilde;oles, Madrid MCMLII . 
 An  ancient waiter had come to take our order. 
 I wanted to introduce Dana to Pernod, so I asked the old man for &bquo;dos Pernod&equo;. 
 I was expecting the usual French style of service, with an ice-bucket and a carafe of chilled water, and two glasses containing a small amount of Pernod at the bottom. 
 Instead, the waiter brought us two full glasses of the &bquo;green fairy&equo;. 
 It was probably the first time he had been asked for such a drink, despite his long years of service. 
 I should have sent the drinks back, but instead looked upon them as a windfall in our rather straitened circumstances. 
 After calling for some ice-cubes which we popped into the straight Pernod, we drank them down, with predictably weird results (we had already had Dexedrine). 
 We staggered out into the Madrid evening &bquo;full of piss and vinegar&equo;, as Dana said later, and somehow made our way to the Puerta del Sol, where there is a large circular fountain. 
 Its waters proved irresistibly attractive to us, and we playfully started splashing one another. 
 We grew more and more excited. 
 Then I saw a stem policeman standing nearby with suspicious and disapproving stare. 
 He looked so miserable I decided to cheer him up by inviting him to join our little game, and started throwing handfuls of water over him. 
 But he considered this an unforgivable insult to his dignity and marched us both to an underground lavatory on the edge of the square, followed by a curious and gleeful crowd waiting for the extranjeros  to get their come-uppance. 
 In my elevated state I was afraid only that the cop might search us and discover the Dexedrine in Dana's pocket. 
 We were both carrying packets of condoms, too, as an extra precaution, should we be granted the favours of some fair se&ntilde;orita  or visit the red-light district, the barrio chino . 
 However, after haranguing us and making me mop up his uniform, the outraged policeman indicated a couple of wash-basins. 
 I had tried to excuse our conduct by telling him we had just needed a wash. 
 He turned on the taps and thrust my face and head into the water and completely soaked my shirt and jacket. 
 &bquo;If you want a wash, that's the way to do it!&equo; he shouted, his face contorted with fury. 
 I have since learnt that this kind of treatment is known as the &bquo;water torture&equo; in Spanish prisons. 
 Then we were allowed to go, to the disappointment of the crowd. 
 That lavatory is still there&hellip;. 
 But once outside, Dana and I became quarrelsome and started to fight with one another, releasing heaven knows what accumulated stores of fury and resentment. 
 I was knocked to the ground, and a kind passer-by picked me up and dusted down my soaking clothes as 1 watched Dana walking away into the night. 
 I was too proud to follow him and beg forgiveness. 
 Anyhow, we were both at fault. 
 After trudging disconsolately round a few bars, I went back to our cheap hostel, where to my relief I found Dana snoring in the double bed we were to share. 
 I  crept in beside him and lay for some time with throbbing head. 
 Then I felt Dana squeeze my hand, and he said: &bquo;Buenas noches, amigo Jim.&equo; 
 That was all. 
 We drifted into sleep. 
 I was up early next morning with a clanging hangover, and as I sat beside the bed watching Dana sleep, I wrote one of the several poems of that period about insomnia and my vigil over my sleeping friend's form, &bquo;The Lonely Insomniac&equo;: 
 While you enjoy sound sleep, 
 I the insomniac am deep in light. 
 My head is full of blazing night 
 That mocks the vigil I must keep. 
 I wrap myself in lamps and fires, 
 And the four walls are a shining jail. 
 The blinded windows rattle in my pale 
 Bones, the skeleton that never tires. 
 The dark is lit as bright as day. 
 I watch your dreams with open eyes. 
 The planes are heavy in my hanging skies. 
 My love's asleep and far away. 
 Late risers always exasperate early risers like myself, who hate to miss what they know is the best part of the day. 
 As soon as it was light, I crept out of the room and went downstairs for a coffee at a nearby caf&eacute;. 
 Then I strolled around the city for a couple of hours, knowing that Dana would not be awake before noon. 
 When I got back to our hostel, our bags were in the hallway and Dana was waiting for me. 
 Apparently we had made so much noise when we returned separately the night before that we had wakened everyone and we were being thrown out. 
 Dana was pale and still half asleep. 
 We trudged around for an hour or so, unable to face the thought of lunch, and found another small hotel near Chamartin (we were going back by train the next day by the last evening train). 
 Dana felt so sick, he went straight back to bed, but had been there only a few seconds before he leapt out with a scream of agony: an autumnal, sleepy wasp had been brought in by the chambermaid among the bedclothes which had been airing at the window and had stung my friend on the bottom! 
 The sting proved a lightning cure for his hangover, for he stood rubbing his arse while I rushed to the farmacia  for a remedy. 
 Then he allowed me to rub it into his injured posterior, a great thrill for me. 
 But I was even more thrilled by the fact that our little tiff had been meaningless and that we were still good friends. 
 We went out  for a lunch that was late even by Madrid standards, then went to a zarzueia . 
 That night, before we fell asleep &mdash; stone sober this time &mdash; Dana again gave my hand a squeeze. 
 I was in heaven. 
 But we were to have several more arguments in the months to come, and not all of them about poetry. 
 That weekend is also memorable for something Dana said to me in the train on the way back to Salamanca: &bquo;I knew you were gay as soon as I saw you that morning in the galleria .&equo; 
 Then, in response to my crestfallen look, he added kindly: &bquo;Of course you did not look  gay &mdash; you're no screaming queen &mdash; but nevertheless I just knew.&equo; 
 Then I realized he must have known many bisexuals before me, and many homosexuals too. 
 I think at times he found his own handsomeness an awful burden: people just wouldn't let him alone. 
 He told me he sometimes hated his face, hated his body because of the ease with which they helped him to dominate others. 
 He told me he was also in revolt against his strict puritan upbringing, a fairly common case in the sons of God-fearing Americans. 
 People were always taking him in hand, hoping to reform him, to make him conform to their own self-centred ideal of what he should be. 
 I was the first person to take him simply as he was, and for that he showed his gratitude by giving me a light kiss on the cheek in the darkened carriage. 
 November. 
 We sang together those heart-rending popular songs about the season: &bquo;The Autumn Leaves&equo; and Trenet's French version from which it was taken. 
 We also sang &bquo;Longtemps, longtemps, longtemps, apr&egrave;s que les po&egrave;tes sont disparus&hellip; &bquo;, also by Trenet, one of the most beautifully upsetting songs for poets. 
 And we were finding poets everywhere. 
 In Salamanca we often smiled at each other as we passed along a street called Street of the Two Poets &mdash; or was it a little plaza? 
 We fatuously wondered if a street or a square would ever be named after us - &bquo;two spooky old Villons,&equo; as Dana once described us. 
 Then came December. 
 The dancer, on her way back to the United States, took Dana in her VW to Lisbon, Porto and Bilbao, where I met them, then we drove all the way to Paris. 
 Dana went on with his friend to see her off at Le Havre, while I made my way to London, where I was joined by Dana a few days later. 
 We were in Bath to stay for a couple of weeks with my parents, in time for Christmas and &bquo;New Year's&equo;. 
 So far, I had behaved with great restraint. 
 But in Britain things were to take a new and not unexpected turn.  
 WELCOME TO BATH 
 Oh! who can ever be tired of Bath?. 
 Jane Austen , NORTHANGER ABBEY 
 We stayed a couple of nights in London, in a small hotel situated in the street extending from the top of St Martin's Lane. 
 Again we had a double bed, and I made one or two tentative sexual advances, to no effect. 
 But we would fall asleep in one another's arms &mdash; that romantic image which is in reality so uncomfortable and painful. 
 Dana would fall asleep immediately he put his head on the pillow, and after a while I had to try to extract myself from his embrace. 
 I thought of us as the little princes in the Tower, and of the city of London as the cruel torturer Hubert who at any moment might come and put out our poetic eyes. 
 While we were in London I took Dana to meet Joe Ackerley in his office in Marylebone High Street. 
 Joe looked on us both with quizzical amusement, no doubt savouring the incongruity of our companionship. 
 He also looked rather envious. 
 I could see that he was wondering just how far we had gone in our relationship, and how long it might last. 
 Would it, he was thinking, be like the ending of Forster's as yet unpublished Maurice , a somewhat tame homo novel of which he was to say, commenting on the male lovers setting up house at the end, &bquo;I give it three weeks?&equo; 
 Well, we had already lasted three months, and I was keeping my fingers crossed for our relationship to continue for ever. 
 Joe invited us out to lunch, which was what I had been hoping for, because we were both more or less on our uppers. 
 He conducted us to a new restaurant, the Hungry Horse, which was pronouncedly &bquo;gay&equo;, with all the young waiters in tight-fitting cotton trousers of small blue-and-white checks. 
 Joe obviously thought it was all very daring and suitable for us both. 
 When the waiter came to take our orders, I could not help noticing the massive sexual equipment outlined by his soft cotton pants. 
 We were sitting on rather low chairs, and he was very tall, so that when he placed himself at my corner his impedimenta were almost on a level with my nose. 
 He caught my astonished stare, and paused as he was jotting down the orders, glancing down at himself in apparent wonder at what I could be looking at.  
 Joe was in good form, though the time for his retirement was drawing near, and he was already beginning to feel a bit lost and abandoned by people who once fawned on him. 
 Now that they knew he would be leaving, the literary confraternity had already started to turn their backs on him, and had begun to scan the possible replacements in the current British intellectual mafia. 
 Joe was trying to be bright and cheerful, but there was a deep undercurrent of sadness, and later, when he had gone back to his office, Dana said: &bquo;I think he's terribly lonely.&equo; 
 During lunch Joe kept us entertained with anecdotes about his friends and contributors &mdash; old Wyndham Lewis, half blind, who was one of his art critics, and who, when taken to eat at L'Escargot, just pushed his gourmet food around on his plate. 
 He was concerned, as always, about Morgan Forster's health and his own sister Nancy's extravagance. 
 He talked about Elizabeth Bowen, a dear friend whose unhappy marriage had upset him. 
 &bquo;All the people I know who have married, have ended up unhappy,&equo; he told us. 
 Then, laying his hands on our shoulders, he added: &bquo;Never get married, dears. 
 Marriage is the death of art and freedom and self-respect.&equo; 
 I wondered if he thought Dana and I were about to tie the knot, or whether he was thinking of us individually &mdash; the latter, I think, because he had warned me against marriage once or twice before when I had shown what he regarded as too much interest in a woman friend. 
 In this he resembled Bonamy Dobr&eacute;e at Leeds, who reacted with the utmost dismay when his pet student, Robin Skelton, announced his engagement to a fellow-student. 
 &bquo;Marriage will be the end of his talent,&equo; Bonamy predicted, though I had not seen much talent in the poems Robin had so far shown me. 
 They showed promise and were not as mediocre as all the other stuff inflicted upon me at Leeds, but I could not see any real future for Robin as a poet. 
 He has proved to be an excellent literary scholar. 
 Yes, Joe must have been desperately lonely at that time, because he asked us to dinner the following evening at Chez Victor's, one of his favourite restaurants. 
 After dinner he took us to the Royal College of Art, where he seemed proud to be an honorary member of the faculty club and students' union. 
 He took us up to see the students, and the very first ones I saw were Sonia Lawson, already a highly gifted artist, daughter of my friends Fred and Muriel in Redmire; and one of my best students from Corsham, the vivacious, beautiful and witty Helen Dear, the shining light of my so-called &bquo;duds&equo;. 
 She was far from being so, and I always remember her with affection for the way she enlivened my drama classes. 
 Sonia and Helen flung themselves into my arms, to Joe's great astonishment. 
 But the girls had eyes only for Dana's beauty and sexy demeanour, which that night was particularly James Deanish.  
 Next day we were off in the train to Bath. 
 I had borrowed ten quid from Joe &mdash; later repaid, and the only interest he demanded was a chaste kiss in front of the BBC in Langham Place. 
 The Thames at Maidenhead - a name that provoked Dana's hilarity &mdash; looked wintry, and there was snow obliterating the white horse at Uffingham. 
 But Chippenham and Bath were milder, free of snow. 
 We gazed enraptured at the city of Bath from the train as it drew in to the station &mdash; it was all laid out on the slopes of Lansdown like an aerial map of a moon landscape. 
 &bquo;How very different from Spain' was Dana's first comment as the bus took us from the station to Avondale Buildings. 
 My mother and father seemed glad to see me, and they welcomed Dana warmly. 
 My Aunt Lyallie was also spending Christmas with us, so our little house was rather crowded. 
 Dana and I slept together in the double bed in my bedroom, next to my parents&equo; room, where my mother was sleeping with Aunt Lyallie. 
 My father put up on the sofa in the big living-room next to my bedroom, which I had claimed as my study. 
 It was the first time Dana had stayed in an English house, and I think he was delighted with the difference between it and his home in the United States. 
 He said we were much more Spartan. 
 It was perhaps the small electric heater in my bedroom which made him say that. 
 The cold was intense, but I welcomed it because it gave us an excuse to lie close together for warmth. 
 And on that first night at home we had our first real sexual encounter, a rather one-sided one, with Dana quite passive. 
 Trying not to make a sound, I achieved a long and delicious orgasm, a heavenly mixture of sheer physical bliss, emotional release and satisfyingly agitating anxiety. 
 I was &bquo;over the moon&equo;, as Joe liked to say in imitation of his working-class friends' picturesquely idiomatic Cockney. 
 But was Dana? 
 I could see at once that my parents and Aunt Lyallie had taken to him. 
 He was so attentive, and so polite, and we loved the way he addressed them as &bquo;Sir&equo; and &bquo;Ma'am&equo;. 
 They were happy, I think, that I had found such a good friend, and did everything they could to make him feel at home. 
 My aunt and my mother were particularly fond of him, and when he had a stomach upset they fussed over him all the time, preparing special bland food for him, making him swallow Milk of Magnesia and advising him not to drink too much Christmas sherry. 
 Under their ministrations he soon recovered. 
 They loved to &bquo;baby&equo; him in a way they could never do with me. 
 I sensed that they approved of him whole-heartedly, and that by comparison I was no longer the blue-eyed boy of the family: I did not come up to scratch. 
 I did not mind. 
 I had no desire to change anything as long as Dana was around. 
 I was happy with him just as he was, without affectation. 
 &bquo;He has no  &bquo;side&equo;, &bquo;my Aunt Lyallie said approvingly for she had always thought Americans were a stuck-up, boastful lot. 
 My father and mother perhaps saw in him the son they would have liked to have, not the peculiar failure they had produced in me. 
 Just to look at Dana fully clothed was enough to give me an erection. 
 When I was with him I was in a more or less permanent state of sexual excitement, and I could bring myself to orgasm just by looking at him, without the aid of hands. 
 In my love-making I simply held him close and let the rest take over, rounded off with a simple kiss. 
 That was always enough for me in my homosexual role. 
 I could prolong the ecstasy as long as I liked, even after he had fallen asleep in my arms and continued sleeping right through my climaxes. 
 It was that simple. 
 The purity of my love was something that to me remained undefiled. 
 But did Dana see it the same way? 
 Did he, too, feel undefiled? 
 On the morning after that first sexual experience we walked after breakfast up the street, past gossiping garden gates and twitching lace curtains to the fields at the top. 
 We walked in silence for a long time. 
 Then we sat down for a rest under a hedge, and Dana asked that typically American question: &bquo;Do you want to talk about it?&equo; 
 This came out without any warning, so I answered, with fake innocence: &bquo;Talk about what?&equo; 
 A pause. 
 &bquo;Last night,&equo; Dana replied, with a rather grim note in his voice. 
 &bquo;I'm not blaming you,&equo; he went on. 
 &bquo;But I'd just like to know where we stand.&equo; 
 I hardly knew what to say to this, so remained silent. 
 &bquo;If we are going to continue to be friends and write our poetry, we must come to some kind of arrangement,&equo; Dana said. 
 &bquo;I don't find you unattractive, but I think you might consider my feelings as well as your own., 
 Another pause. 
 &bquo;The only important thing&equo;, he continued, &bquo;is for us to go on writing our poems. 
 That's all I care about. 
 If it brings us closer together, and helps us to write better poems, I would be willing to trade some sex with you. 
 You help me, and I'll help you. 
 And let us help each other get this thing into perspective or it's going to ruin our collaboration.&equo; 
 It was an unusually long speech for Dana. 
 I was speechless with a mixture of fear and embarrassment. 
 I did not want to &bquo;talk about it&equo;. 
 That seemed to me unnecessary. 
 Then he gave me a smile and a playful punch on the arm: &bquo;You were pretty good last night, you old sex maniac.&equo; 
 Thankful to hear the change in his tone, I responded with a less playful punch, and soon we were on our feet slapping at each other with a wild hilarity, a contest in which inevitably I was the loser. 
 But we had saved the day, and our long friendship. 
 And from then on, Dana  became increasingly responsive to my love-making. 
 Months later he was to admit: &bquo;Don't you realize, Jim, I was just egging you on all the time? 
 Why were you so slow? 
 And: &bquo;You are the purest  person I've ever known.&equo; 
 But on that morning my happiness was clouded by something he said to me as we were walking home to lunch: &bquo;Your parents know about you, Jim &mdash; you know that, don't you?&equo; 
 It was something I had never admitted to myself. 
 Of course, deep inside me, I knew all along that they knew. 
 But we would never have dreamt of talking about it. 
 Dana's words struck at my heart, as he had done, quite deliberately, when he had told me: &bquo;The very first time I saw you, I knew you were gay.&equo; 
 At lunch I was sad and subdued, and I could hardly face my mother's and father's happy faces, or the rather more knowing glances of Aunt Lyallie, who I later discovered had put my mother wise to many things. 
 After lunch we went up to my study to work on our poems. 
 But we did not create much poetry: we held each other tenderly, and he comforted me with kisses. 
 &bquo;Just wait, Jim. 
 Don't let's do it here in this house with your mother and father watching and perhaps listening&hellip;.&equo; 
 I nodded in agreement, saying: &bquo;We'll keep it for our New Year's present.&equo; 
 He hugged me in consent. 
 My Christmas happiness was complete. 
 We all went to the carol service in Bath Abbey, where I had difficulty restraining my tears. 
 I was too choked with emotion to sing the carols of my childhood in that glorious fane. 
 Though I had always disliked Christmas, because I knew it made my mother unhappy for some reason, that was one Christmas when I was happy, and I have never forgotten it. 
 After a week at home I began to get restless, as always in the company of my parents. 
 I felt ashamed of feeling so bored with them. 
 But I knew that it was time to leave, and we said goodbye to them on New Year's Eve. 
 That morning I met my father on the middle landing of the stairs, and we were alone together for the first time in the holidays. 
 We stopped and looked at each other, then shook hands. 
 &bquo;Well, goodbye, then, Jim,&equo; he said, with a little smile. 
 &bquo;Goodbye, Daddy.&equo; 
 It was the last time I saw him alive. 
 Dana and I spent a few days in London again before travelling to Spain. 
 We spent a lot of time in the National Gallery and at the Tate, and wrote some poems about the pictures there, including Verrocchio's Tobias and the Angel , Piero di Cosima's Mythological Subject  and Titian's Christ Appearing to the Magdalen &mdash; Noli me Tangere , whose theme had a special significance for me now: Dana was Christ, and I was the Magdalen. 
 &bquo;Or can it be the other way round?&equo; he asked. 
 &bquo;ft can be  either,&equo; I replied, &bquo;now that we know who we are and where we are with one another.&equo; 
 It is one of our best collaborations, so here it is: 
 On the distant ocean, burnished 
 To a passionate blue, the tree is bent, 
 And in the kindling sky, whose benison 
 Of green and golden leaf transcends 
 The sepulchres of dark, the winds of light 
 Now wash the living wood. 
 The tree leans patiently away 
 From habitations on a dusky hill, 
 Whose pathway lights a shepherd and his dog 
 To a greening valley white with sheep. 
 - The foreground of the quickening day 
 Confronts the Magdalen with her risen Lord. 
 She kneels to him along the leaning 
 Tree of her desire, and reaches out 
 A hand whose hesitations beg to touch 
 The gardener's unearthly robes. 
 Tenderly his perfect body fends 
 Her gesture nth the faith of love. 
 He leans above her like a leafy bough 
 That frees its gentle body from the grave 
 Rhythm of a bitter tree. 
 &mdash; Touch me  
 Not . 
 &mdash; His face makes sweet 
 This quiet admonition, and his hand, 
 In blessing, hangs above her head its dove. 
 I remember we sat there all afternoon looking at that wonderful picture and planning our poem in our heads. 
 After an early dinner we went straight back to our hotel and wrote it. 
 Then we undressed each other, lay down on the bed, and made our first, fully reciprocal, passionate love.  
 MY DISTRACTED WINTER 
 Nur an den beiden Poien menschlicher Verbindung, dort, wo es noch keine oder keine Worte mehr gibt, im Blick und in der Umamung, it eigentlich Gl&uuml;ck zu finden, denn nur dort ist Unbedingtheit, Freiheit, Geheimnis und tiefe R&uuml;cksichglosigkeit . 
 (Only at the two poles of human relationship, where there are no words, or no more words, in the looking and the embracing, is happiness really to be found, for only there lie unconditional surrender, freedom, mystery and profound irresponsibility.) 
 On the back of a piece of paper where we had worked on a poem called &bquo;The Word&equo; I found the quotation that begins this chapter. 
 I do not remember now who wrote it, but it is no doubt from a modern German author, perhaps a philosopher, and it expresses exactly my state of mind at the beginning of 1958. 
 As if in answer to the prophecy I had written in Amsterdam in the Hotel Brabant after visiting the exhibition of Picasso's Guernica , I was now in the very presence of love itself, in the form of the hero imagined there and then. 
 The poem we were working on was one of several left unfinished, but I can quote here the first three verses, for their expression of our condition at that time, our sense of being so close together that we were utterly apart from all else: 
 A cool, real thing, 
 The object of our art, 
 Has the unsounded life 
 Of all that is apart. 
 We look into its heart, 
 And see a meaning there. 
 We take its strangeness in &mdash; 
 The familiar, too, is rare. 
 We whisper it across 
 The table of our looks; 
 A kiss exchanged in time 
 Is the seed of books&hellip;. 
 Our love had become completely exclusive, in its lookings, embracings, kissings, from all but &bquo;the word&equo; of whatever poem we were writing together. 
 It was a strange, hothouse life in my shuttered and curtained room at the Hotel Espa&ntilde;ia. 
 I rarely went out. 
 The weather was bitterly cold, and because there was no heating in Dana's little room he used to spend all day, and nearly every night, in my warm apartment. 
 We would sit hour after hour on either side of my table, exchanging glances, kisses, embraces, smiles &mdash; and the words of our poems. 
 I was always conscious now of the mocking presence of those fascist student bullies in the streets, following me with laughter and taunts. 
 Sometimes they would come and lunch or dine in my hotel, sitting at a table next to ours. 
 These goons did not attack Dana &mdash; it was me they were after. 
 Sometimes they broke into my classes at the university, carrying pictures of Franco and Primo de Rivera and chanting Falangist slogans or singing army songs, and shouting maricone! maricone ! 
 There were some students, mainly girls, who protested. 
 In particular, Manuela, the girl who had wiped the word maricone  from the blackboard, stood up to the rowdies and lashed them with her tongue. 
 This girl seemed as if she wanted to become our friend. 
 We sometimes met her in the street on her way from classes, and she always stopped to talk to us. 
 But we were beyond friendship. 
 We were totally absorbed in one another and in our work. 
 We used to take showers together in my apartment and then wander around naked until we were dry. 
 We were still writing our own separate poems, and one I did started: 
 The naked body turns a room 
 To jungles where the panther prowls 
 In black and green and yellow gloom 
 And blood in walls of darkness growls. 
 Within the hunter's furry loins 
 The sun-flexed muscles play. 
 Showered with movement's leafy coins, 
 The level haunches lightly sway&hellip;. 
 Sometimes the shutters of my room, raised slightly to let in streaks of sunlight between their horizontal slats, made our winter room seem tropical. 
 Then we would fling ourselves upon each other at all hours of the day and night make love upon the unmade bed, for often we refused to let the maid in to make up the room:  
 I love your nakedness displayed 
 In bored abandon on the tangled bed, 
 The dark nipples starring the wide, smooth chest, 
 The rough lips parted in your sun-tanned face, 
 The strong and slender hips, 
 The navel's little cup of bitterness, 
 The blond-tinselled thighs, 
 The well-set neck's warm spoon, 
 The feet's long fans, 
 The arms curved round your radiant head, 
 And the dark treasure at your body's heart 
 That beats and leaps for pleasure&hellip;. 
 Reading Unamuno, I found this passage which gave me comfort among all the mockery: &bquo;The greatest height of heroism to which an individual, like a people, can attain is to know how to face ridicule.&equo; 
 I hardly knew how I was able to face it, either then or at any other time of my life in this mocking world, but I did, though it did not seem to me that I was in any way heroic &mdash; just the opposite, in fact. 
 I sometimes felt degraded and cowardly to be so different, and the object of so much taunting and discrimination. 
 When the life of that one room became too oppressive, we would go for a spin on the motor bike to Bejar, Miranda del Castanar, Sequeros &mdash; places where no one knew us. 
 We also went to Madrid again and saw a performance by the famous travelling circus, the Circo Price, about whose clowns I wrote a poem in The Prodigal Son . 
 I was in a very black and negative mood, I remember, and waited for the trapeze artists to fall and kill themselves, for the female contortionist to twist herself into such a knot of meat that she would never get disentangled. 
 Dana was shocked by my attitude, but I was not in my right mind. 
 The Circus Price, the oldest in Europe, was a marvellous popular institution. 
 It was founded in the mid-1850s by an Englishman, Thomas Price. 
 The elegant old Price building stood in the Plaza del Rey, right at the heart of Madrid's banking and commercial district. 
 It was a family show. 
 One of the stars was the trapeze artist, Se&ntilde;orita Pinito del Oro, a gypsy who learnt her art on a clothes-line strung between two Madrid apartment buildings. 
 Josephine Baker and such well-known and beloved clowns as Grock, Ramper and Charlie Rivel appeared regularly with the circus. 
 The tyrant Primo de Rivera loved circuses, and loved big cigars, which he smoked during the performance, though it was forbidden. 
 On being reproved by a humble usher, Primo de Rivera had a law passed making  the Circo Price the only theatre in Madrid where smoking was allowed. 
 And that law was still in effect when the building finally had to close in 1972, on the expiry of the lease, after which it was transformed into a bank. 
 Naturally I was sleeping badly. 
 My insomnia became chronic whenever Dana stayed the night, simply because I could not take my eyes away from his sleeping form beneath the bedside lamps. 
 There are several poems I wrote about this fixation, and some unfinished ones like this: 
 I who cannot get a wink of sleep 
 Sit by the night's large window watching you, naked, 
 Adrift in the moonlight on the bed, 
 Your tanned face drowned in the dew, the foam 
 Of pillows, and brown arms cornering your head 
 Like wreaths of sand about your hair's blond sheaf. 
 How can I ever drop my eyes as deep 
 Into the swimming dark as you&hellip;? 
 Our love-making was of the purest, simplest kind, without extreme erotic refinements and recherch&eacute;  positions. 
 We would hold each other in an embrace, exchanging long kisses, and rock our bodies together until they overflowed. 
 Dana was much more experienced than I: he taught me a form of carezza  by which we could indefinitely prolong erection and contain ejaculation. 
 We were like a couple of shamans. 
 It was utterly delightful. 
 I wanted nothing more, though I think Dana must have wanted other things that I never thought of offering him; with him alone I would have been happy to do what I had always denied others. 
 I got some insight into this when I was telling him about my readings in Zen, and trying to explain the principles of yin and yan. 
 I drew a small diagram of the interlocking male and female principles in their embracing circle. 
 I saw that next to it Dana wrote &bquo;Sixtynine&equo; (the amatory position the French call soixante-neuf ) and changed the &bquo;comma&equo; shapes into &bquo;69&equo;. 
 It was only towards the end of my time in Spain, when we were in Ciudad Rodrigo for the Festival Taurino, that we once, quite by accident, found ourselves in the 69 position and went through with it successfully. 
 I had no desire to try it again. 
 From time to time we visited the old barrio chino , the red-light district, which formed a kind of everyman's land at the heart of the bell-haunted, church-loaded city. 
 I am not sure why this quarter was called &bquo;Chinese&equo; except that perhaps its apartness from the regular  secular and religious life of Salamanca made it seem like another country, and a far-off, exotic one at that. 
 The place was all tawdry bars, dance-halls and flop-houses that were also houses of assignation. 
 Besides the &bquo;straight&equo; prostitutes, there were a few transvestites, heavily made up, trying to swallow their Adam's apples and speak in wheedling, fluty voices. 
 They deceived no one, but I felt a bond with their strange sisterhood. 
 Indeed, I had always, since living in the red-light district of Leeds, Brunswick Place, had a fondness and respect for prostitutes. 
 It was the prostitutes in Douai and Lille and Paris who gave me my first induction into their ways and wiles. 
 In the sixties my heroines were not Bardot or Monroe or Vivien Leigh, but Christine Keeler and Mandy Rice-Davies. 
 I admired them for doing openly what many women do in secret or under the respectable cover of marriage. 
 I felt like those women and men who openly sold their favours. 
 Why should not people do as they pleased with their own bodies? 
 And I thought some of the girls were extraordinarily attractive in their outrageous costumes and theatrical make-up. 
 I envied them their sexual freedom and their self-assured dignity, and I despised the British vice squads that ran them in and were not above enjoying their charms for a consideration. 
 Since I hated the police, it was natural that I should feel myself aligned with the prostitutes. 
 The girls in the barrio chino  of Spanish cities were of all ages, sizes and nationalities. 
 We used to go to a certain bar and sit at our favourite table, where we would be joined by a pair of bedizened harridans with dyed orange hair and chipped scarlet fingernails. 
 In their almost dead-white, overpowdered faces, the mean little eyes looked red and sore in their crusted pits of mascara; their great painted mouths with lipstick smearing over the fuzzy edges gave them a touchingly clownish look. 
 They wore over their sagging, wrinkled breasts flimsy, lace-up bodices with nothing underneath, and from those cleavages arose a fume of mingled sweat, baby powder and cheap scent. 
 They were always smoking. 
 Every five minutes they would cadge a Bisonte from me, or a Lucky Strike from Dana. 
 They did not seem very interested in business, though they ran up big drinks bills for us and would occasionally ruffle our hair or squeeze our balls with an experienced touch, weighing us up, as it were. 
 I'm afraid we did not measure up to the standards set by the well-hung Spanish men who drifted around with flies bulging to the point of bursting their buttons. 
 But the women liked to talk to us, as we were foreigners, laughing uproariously at our accents and our mistakes in Spanish. 
 Sometimes they would read our palms, finishing by giving them a little scratch that signified they were available &mdash; one scratch twenty douros, two scratches fifty douros and so on up the scale from an  &bquo;in and out&equo; in the toilets or a &bquo;short time&equo; in a back room to a whole night in the brothel, with champagne and bath. 
 I remember well what one of these old hags told us. 
 They were great judges of character, and her analysis of Dana was: &bquo;You are good enough to be a film star.&equo; 
 Then, turning to me: &bquo;And you  &mdash; you think much, too much&hellip;.&equo; 
 I think we were both put out, for Dana, though certainly James Dean material, hated to be valued for his looks alone, while I resented the ease with which he attracted praise and disliked being thought of as an intellectual with nothing else to recommend me. 
 We left in a strange, silent huff, the women running after us into the street and trying to pull us back inside. 
 It was always a Toulouse Lautrec evening in the barrio chino : grotesque, horrible, funny, depressing, exciting and often pleasantly relaxing. 
 I never forgot those women, their hard lives with their superficial glitter and laughter concealing untold tragedies and disillusions. 
 I felt respect as well as affection for them. 
 But we could never bring ourselves to be bedded by them, though there was a little gypsy flower-girl with her gilded basket of faded carnations, stolen from a grave, who announced a sudden passion for Dana. 
 As she was only about fourteen, we always bought a few dark-red carnations from her, but that was as far as we would go, to her surprise and indignation. 
 She had lost her virginity when she was ten, so she told us, and she was popular with some of the Spanish men who would perch her on their knees and allow her to fondle their private parts as a joke. 
 But everyone took care of her, from the brassy madames to the scruffy young page-boys and the sinister young bartenders. 
 The barrio  was a place where I felt freer than anywhere else in Salamanca, for it was really a land outside the law, where outcasts at last could feel at home. 
 All the time, we were making love as we wrote our poems, in a great wave of inspiration and tenderness that seemed as if it could never end. 
 Then one night towards the end of January we had had too much Dexedrine and San Miguel, and we started exchanging acrimonious words. 
 We did not exactly quarrel, but we started unloading pent-up resentments and frustrations. 
 Poetry was forgotten. 
 Dana went back to his room at the Hospedaje Lisboa, leaving me in tears on my bed, sunk in despair. 
 That evening, before dinner, we had sat together in the Clerecia, watching the glib little gilded pendulum of the antique wall-clock wagging away. 
 It was while we were sitting there that my father must have died of a heart attack in Bath. 
 The hotel manager woke me at 10 a.m. with a telegram from my mother, which had been delayed. 
 It simply said that my father had died: it asked me to come home. 
 I dressed and rushed through the streets to Dana's place, and after prolonged hammering on his door managed to wake him and tell him  the news. 
 It reconciled us: he took me in his arms and comforted me. 
 Then I hurried back to pack my things. 
 There was some kind of festa  that day, for the narrow streets and the Corillo were dense with merry throngs of students and the tuna  was playing in the Plaza Mayor. 
 The manager of the Hotel Espa&ntilde;a was very kind and thoughtful: he would have to let my apartment while I was away, should anyone want it, but promised to let me have it back when I returned after the funeral. 
 Dana saw me off at the station. 
 I reached Bath next morning, after travelling all day and night. 
 My poor mother was grief-stricken and all alone. 
 She managed to tell me what had happened. 
 There had been a heavy fall of snow, and my father, clearing the path in front of our house, had suddenly felt a terrible pain in his chest. 
 He lay down on the bed, with my mother beside him, and he died in her arms, saying: &bquo;You've been a good wife to me, Mary.&equo; 
 We had no telephone, and in any case there was no time to call a doctor. 
 She took me into the first-floor front room, where my father had already been laid out in his coffin. 
 The room was filled with a strange, sweet smell. 
 He looked so dignified, so calm, so thankful to be gone from this world and from his troublesome son. 
 I remembered the last time I had seen him, on the half-landing on the stairs, and how we looked at one another &mdash; as if he had sensed it would be our last encounter &mdash; and had shaken hands and said goodbye. 
 My mother smoothed his perfect brow, so broad and noble, and I laid a final kiss upon it. 
 &bquo;It was really Corsham that did it,&equo; my mother said. 
 &bquo;He never recovered from the way people treated us there, all that spite and unkindness and the way they spoke of you, Jim.&equo; 
 Then she told me that during the last winter, while I was in Sweden, my father had already had an attack, but they had not told me. 
 Years later, after my mother's death, I found out what had caused that first attack and precipitated the fatal one. 
 There were anonymous letters to my parents, postmarked Chippenham, Corsham, Bath and London, telling them to watch out and do something about their son or there would be trouble for them. 
 But they had never mentioned these despicable attacks to me; they had kept cheerful faces and shown me all the love and care they had always given me, their prodigal son. 
 A few months after his death I finally was able to write an elegy for my father, &bquo;died 21st January, 1958&equo;, which is the final poem in The Prodigal Son . 
 The shameful outrage committed by the German students in the crypt of San Esteban inevitably was echoed in the conclusion of the poem. 
 I had to return to my classes in Salamanca. 
 My Aunt Lyallie came to  keep my mother company until she recovered a little from the shock, which seemed to have worsened the condition of her eyes, for she was slowly going blind. 
 I often thought her blindness was not entirely physical: she wanted finally to shut her eyes to the sorrows and miseries of the son she still adored, for she could not bear to see me suffering. 
 Before I left, I bought a large-screen television set for her and Aunt Lyallie. 
 Television was then just becoming very popular, though the screens were still only black and white. 
 My father would not even allow a radio in the house, and when I suggested getting a TV set for him and my mother he adamantly refused, saying that the wireless had been the death of good conversation, and that TV would be the death of the family. 
 The first programme we watched after it was installed was one my father would have loved, about old sailing-ships and the life of our ancestor, the poet-sailor William Falconer, who wrote a long poem, The Shipwreck , which was popular in its day. 
 My mother sighed as she peered at those crowding white sails and topgallants: &bquo;If only he were here to see that!&equo; 
 And our tears flowed again. 
 Here are the first two verses of my elegy for my father.: 
 In a cold season you suddenly left our home 
 When I was far away, and sick in mind. 
 Those harsh days in my distracted winter 
 Must have touched you, too, and the heart 
 That failed you as my own gave up the ghost. 
 My dark nights blazed with sleepless candles 
 In my drugged room shuttered tight against the bells, 
 The stars, the snow, the people thin as burnt-out sticks, 
 The black and iron-frosted gardens of a city that was once 
 A rose of stone, and now was only stone&hellip;. 
 My father's favourite flowers were dark-red carnations. 
 The night before his death I had bought a big bunch of red carnations to put in my room with the lighted candles we were now writing by, to please Dana. 
 I must have been arranging those flowers, and setting the lighted candles round them, at the very moment my father was dying. 
 &bquo;O, Father, let my last touch rest your ashes, love&hellip;.&equo;  
 My Father's Rule 
 Brass-bound boxwood 
 with the two triple brass hinges 
 and, on the eighteenth inch, 
 the big brass sun, 
 the folding centre. 
 &bquo;Rabone Warranted Boxwood 
 Made in England 
 No. 1380.&equo; 
 At the tenth and fourteenth inches 
 brass points fit into holes 
 at the twenty-second and twenty-sixth inches. 
 On the inner seventeenth and nineteenth inches, 
 two tiny brass pins protrude, 
 linking with holes on the thirty-fifth inch and the first, 
 the holes worn with use 
 into slits that cannot hold. 
 The four nine-inch lengths 
 smooth and neat 
 folding together, opening 
 like a fan: the noble numbers and 
 the halves, quarters, tenths &mdash; 
 dark on the outside, 
 dark with the labour and sweat 
 of my father's hands, 
 the inside numbers clearer, 
 the wood paler, like his palms. 
 When I was a boy 
 often I played for hours 
 with this rule &mdash; 
 opening it and shutting it, 
 folding it, extending it. 
 The rule became so many things to me &mdash; 
 the holding centre was a crown of gold, 
 a coin of undiscovered realms: 
 the steel rivet at its heart 
 was the hub of every thought and act. 
 Sometimes, a solitary child, 
 I unfolded it to make 
 the oriental zigzag fence 
 of our Willow Pattern plates. 
 Sometimes, opened upright 
 and covered with a duster 
 borrowed from my mother Mary 
 it became an American native wigwam. 
 Or it grew into a tree 
 of angled branches like an ancient plum &mdash; 
 in my imagination 
 I could make anything 
 of its flexible inflexibility. 
 Three feet of honesty and pride 
 in decent workmanship &mdash; 
 thirty-six inches divided into four 
 stained, worn wooden slats 
 that measured more than wood. 
 The hands of the carpenter have blessed them, 
 and the skill of the craftsman hallowed them 
 all the days of his life. 
 For every time he used them 
 he gave them grace, his touch 
 each day was left upon them, 
 part of his very self &mdash; 
 in work and out of it. 
 I see still 
 the way he used to slide his folded rule 
 into the long side pocket of his dungarees, 
 and how, as he strode along, 
 it knocked against his thigh. 
 I see him draw it out to measure 
 my height, marked on the door-jamb each birthday 
 by his flat carpenter's pencil with its chisel point. 
 Now, a lost child, 
 and more alone than ever, 
 I hold my father's rule 
 in helpless hands, holding it for dear life, 
 and holding on to it, like grim death, 
 a last plank in 
 the wreck of a drowning world. 
 - And where is his spirit level now? 
 On another of our jaunts to Avila and Madrid we admired the Velasquezes and Goyas in the Prado. 
 But we were not moved to write about them, possibly because they were so very much themselves, any personal comment of ours might seem an intrusion. 
 And the complex, ever-absorbing detail of Las Meninas  was really beyond words &mdash; pure art underlying mysteriously the brilliant surface, where literature has no place. 
 But we loved Los Borrachos , those working men drunk on the ambiguous beauty of Bacchus as well as on the wine. 
 It was on this visit that Dana did something I found surprising and at first puzzling. 
 I had always believed everything he did and said to be sincere and genuinely personal, but gradually small cracks began appearing in his carefully constructed persona and well-tended integrity. 
 On this occasion we were sitting late at night in a small park somewhere in Madrid. 
 We were the only people there. 
 I forget what we had been talking and arguing about, but probably it was something connected with our continuing confusions about poetry and sex. 
 He may have been genuinely distressed by the pain he was causing me &mdash; something he later confessed he had deliberately provoked, with subtle sadism masquerading as friendly frankness. 
 Now he was starting to cry, and I had never seen him cry before. 
 Were these real tears, or was he just squeezing them out after too much cognac? 
 I observed him quite coldly but with my usual hapless concern. 
 He looked really wretched and crestfallen. 
 So I said: &bquo;It would have been better if we had never met.&equo; 
 And he answered: &bquo;Yes, I have been waiting a long time, waiting to hear you say that. 
 It's what they all say to me in the end. 
 They always say that.&equo; 
 Who, I wondered, were &bquo;they&equo;? 
 Then, out of his overcoat pocket he produced a safety razor-blade, with which he sharpened the pencil he always used for his often indecipherable, cramped little scribbles &mdash; a sign, a psychiatrist later told me, of someone wanting to attract as little attention as possible, as in the case of Robert Walser. 
 My own feeling is that Walser's microscript was a symptom of abnormal modesty and self-effacement or self-depreciation  in an unbearable modern world where, rather than seek fame, he preferred to be a servant. 
 In Dana's case, as in my own, there was a withdrawal from normal or so-called normal society. 
 Dana was often embarrassed by his good looks and their power over everyone who met him, so his tiny writing may have been a kind of Walserian camouflage. 
 With that dulled little blade in his right hand, he began drawing it slowly across the inside of his left wrist. 
 His tears dropped on the blade. 
 Beads of blood appeared along the cuts, which alarmed me, though at the same time I could see that the wounds were superficial. 
 Nevertheless, I rushed him back to our nearby hotel, where I cleaned the wounds and fixed three or four large Band-Aids on them. 
 I remember the helpless, almost childlike way he submitted himself to my ministrations. 
 He, too, needed someone to watch over him. 
 At that moment my feelings of love for him became somewhat abstract, like a mother bandaging her little boy's playground cuts and sores. 
 I gave him some aspirin, undressed him and put him to bed. 
 Next day, when he awoke at noon, he was as bright and cheerful as if nothing at all had happened. 
 And indeed nothing had happened. 
 It was all play-acting, a bluff to get attention, but he never admitted it nor apologized for anything he had done or said. 
 I wonder how many times I was taken in by his Yankee sincerity, his B-movie honesty. 
 How many times had my heart sunk when I asked if we could go somewhere or try something new in our poems and he had answered with the excusing phrase &bquo;I guess not&equo;? 
 Perhaps unconsciously I willingly let myself be fooled, just in order to please him and keep our relationship going. 
 I was so terrified of losing him, for I sensed there would never be another love like this in my life. 
 But he always wanted to be the one in control, the top dog, to be the one who could take off on a whim and relate his volatility to democratic individual freedom to do as one pleased &mdash; a special privilege to which only Americans were supposed to be entitled. 
 But I needed his love so much, and he knew it. 
 Always at the end of any love affair I had wondered if there would ever be another, and there always had been. 
 But now I feared I was getting too old for romantic friendships. 
 If Dana left me, I knew I would never love anyone again &mdash; or at least, not in the same way, with the same intensity. 
 So I clung to him through the poetry I went on helping him to write. 
 If only he had started to write in a larger script, I might have felt I had succeeded with him, made him a poet. 
 There was only one thing I was ashamed of in my love for Dana, which had sprung from poetry, and from sources I knew were pure. 
 After all, it was he who seduced me. 
 But then I tried to seduce him with  poetry. 
 I wanted our collaboration, strange as it was, to continue for eve;, just so long as it kept him beside me. 
 I think that he, who could have had as many friends as he wished, never realized how much it meant to a lonely and friendless person to have a friend, to be seen walking with him in the rose-red streets of Salamanca, to be able to go to a concert or an art museum with him, to have him opposite me at dinner in even the meanest, cheapest restaurant. 
 So I used to encourage his own poetry, and his ideas for poetic themes, even when I knew they were poor or did not interest me. 
 I was terrified that if I criticized him he would take offence and leave me, if not permanently, then for a few days, without giving me a sign of life, and so leaving me in anguish. 
 We discussed my pacifism, and on one occasion I denied my convictions, just to be on his side. 
 He had been just too young for the Korean War, and one day he told me that it was one of the experiences he regretted having missed. 
 He said he could understand my hatred of war, and why I rejected all involvement in war and the governments that perpetrated it. 
 But he added that in the case of the Korean War the Allies were justified in fighting against the communists. 
 I cravenly agreed, simply in order not to antagonize and perhaps lose him. 
 But immediately my heart was suffused with shame. 
 Now I am never ashamed of anything, for I consider shame to be a bourgeois and petty emotion, but this was the one occasion when I felt ashamed of myself, and I have never forgotten how sad it made me to have denied my principles for the sake of friendship and love &mdash; or what I imagined to be love. 
 Was it not infatuation, rather? 
 But this incident gave me an insight into Dana's mind. 
 If he was an anti-communist, could he not be some kind of spy or agent of the American government? 
 The dread Pentagon&hellip;? 
 That possibility, always present in my mind, became, I must admit, an added thrill. 
 Dana was opinionated and liked to have the last word in an argument. 
 As I have never been interested in argument, he must often have felt frustrated by my silences, my refusal to rise to the bait. 
 Sometimes he immediately pounced upon whatever I said and showed me in a psychoanalytical way how wrong I was, and how right he was. 
 He could always find fault with something, either in my writing or in my personality &mdash; something not difficult to achieve because I have always laid myself open to easy attack. 
 I remember one instance, after we had been making love, when he took my hands very tenderly and turned them this way and that, pressing them gently, kissing the palms and the wrists. 
 Then, out of the blue, he pronounced &bquo;Jim, the backs of your hands are very ugly &mdash; did you know that?&equo; in a tone that suggested I  might be surprised and hurt. 
 I was silent, for I could not understand in what way he meant that my hands were ugly: I had never considered whether they were beautiful or not. 
 But at once I saw that perhaps he was right, that perhaps the backs of my hands were indeed hideous and strange. 
 But after turning them over to reveal the palms, he declared: &bquo;But the palms are so beautiful, the lines so clear and simple, the shape so pure.&equo; 
 Was I supposed to be pleased by these comments? 
 I did not know what to say in reply, so I took his hands and held them beside my own, showing first the backs, then the palms, then measuring them one against the other, palm to palm &mdash; something the Japanese would often do in comparing their smaller, lighter hands with my grosser ones. 
 Dana's hands were strong and sun-tanned, with long, spatulate fingers and firm, dry palms &mdash; the hands of an athlete, the fists of a boxer. 
 I thought they were beautiful in their male hardness and power, so I told him: &bquo;Dana, your hands are perfect, front and back.&equo; 
 He rewarded me with a puzzled smile, as if he wanted to show he did not quite believe me, then with a kiss from sun-blistered lips, dry and firm. 
 Dana once said that the real proof of love was the sharing of a single toothbrush by lovers. 
 Like many of his pronouncements, I thought this was facile. 
 But as always I was wary of contradicting him, not wanting to antagonize him by even the slightest show of disagreement in case he left me. 
 He did not like to be contradicted. 
 On the few occasions when I had ventured a criticism, he always picked on some word or expression I used to prove his point, claiming that it was a subconscious betrayal of my true nature and my real thought. 
 I always found this kind of slick psychoanalytic one-upmanship irritating, but I never attempted to defend myself, because I am bored by argument and discussion of any kind. 
 It was easier just to let him have his way. 
 After all, he was fifteen years or so younger than I, and presumably still intellectually immature, despite all his literary and philosophical name-dropping. 
 That I myself was hardly any more mature than he, was beside the point: I had no very high opinion of people who claimed to be mature adults. 
 But I went along with him, and from time to time we shared a toothbrush, either his or mine. 
 I quite enjoyed using Dana's toothbrush. 
 The thought that it had been inside his mouth, touching his tongue and gums and those rather small but perfect teeth, that it had been drenched in some of his most intimate fluids gave me an erotic thrill. 
 I often wondered if he enjoyed using my toothbrush as much as I enjoyed using his. 
 It was a new slant on the eternal problem of the one who kisses and the one who is kissed. 
 I was usually the active partner, or rather it was usually I who initiated a kiss or an embrace. 
 He was my Rimbaud, certainly: I was the Vierge Folle. 
 But I could be both Verlaine and  Rimbaud. 
 He was always Rimbaud. 
 Today, of course, the test of love between men would be their willingness to share not just a toothbrush but also a razor. 
 Dana did not shave as often as I did. 
 His blond stubble was silky and made his mouth as exciting as an adolescent boy's. 
 And I envied his smooth, hairless chest, with its peachy tan. 
 A hairless chest would have been a great advantage for a bisexual like myself. 
 For bisexual Dana, it was something to be proud of, and he looked down upon my inferior condition. 
 He always had to be number one. 
 The only person I ever felt I might fall in love with again in the same way was a Japanese, the poet Takahashi Mutsuo. 
 I met him briefly in 1963 at a poetry reading given in Tokyo at the American Center by James Dickey. 
 He was sitting on a sofa outside the lecture-room, smoking a cigarette. 
 He was wearing chinos, and looked almost American, and there was something sexually magnetic about him that at once reminded me of Dana. 
 I was introduced to him but did not linger to prolong our acquaintance. 
 I was too afraid of falling hopelessly in love with this prot&eacute;g&eacute; of Yukio Mishima, whose marvellous homoerotic poems I translated. 
 Once when I was leaving for Europe, he came to see me off at the airport, bringing a parting gift. 
 It was quite unexpected. 
 But again I held myself warily at a certain distance, not daring to make contact with him for fear of falling into the kind of trap Dana had prepared for me. 
 I often see his picture in literary magazines. 
 Now that he is wearing a beard, he looks just like Dana &mdash; the square-shaped face, the mouth, the nose. 
 Only the eyes are different, but they are a poet's eyes. 
 Takahashi is one of those people I loved on sight, or with whom I just wanted to go to bed, but denied myself the opportunity, thus leaving them forever desirable in my memory. 
 Another Japanese who attracts me today is the unattainable sumo wrestler Kirishima, from Kagoshima in Kyushu, who is one of the most beautiful males I have ever seen. 
 My Japanese friends wonder at my passion, because he is not very well known and not very successful, though when he visited Paris with his fellow sumotori  he was at once called &bquo;the Japanese Alain Delon&equo; &mdash; to my mind, an insult to my hero, but for a while that kind of adulation seemed to give him a little of the confidence he needed, and on his return to Japan he delighted me by winning an unusually high number of contests. 
 The success soon faded, but my adoration lives on. 
 Kirishima is nothing like Dana, but he has that male charisma which makes me want to lie in his arms &mdash; I feel safer just gloating over his superb body on the television screen. 
 No one will ever take Dana's place.  
 WINTER'S END 
 &hellip; the hounds of spring are on winter's traces&hellip; 
 ( Algernon Charles Swinburne , ATALANTA IN CALYDON) 
 Sing if you're Glad to be Gay &mdash; Sing if you like it that way&hellip; 
 Tom Robinson Band  
 I was utterly devastated by my father's death. 
 But on my return to Salamanca Dana gave me strong support, a spiritual courage that entered our love and our poetry. 
 I felt as if a huge gap had appeared in my existence, because one who had always been there was there no longer, and I should never see him again. 
 When I gave my first class, Manuela stood up as soon as I entered, and in beautiful English, then in Spanish, expressed the sympathies of the whole class. 
 I was moved, and the tears fell on the pages of Jespersen. 
 Everyone was so kind at the university. 
 Professor Ruiperez told me I need not start my classes until I was quite recovered, and the women in the office and the library spoke friendly words to me for the first time. 
 I had lost a father, &bquo;someone to watch over me&equo; who had done his best to do so, though he had failed. 
 I did not hold that against him. 
 Nor did I bear any ill-will against my poor mother, though she had brought me up in error, innocently ignorant of what she was doing to my psyche. 
 I knew that she now expected me to live with her for the rest of her days. 
 But I also knew I could not; it would have been the death of me. 
 Yet I vowed to do as much as possible for her comfort and happiness, to write to her and see her regularly, too. 
 But could I live with Dana? 
 Could I live with anyone? 
 I was beginning to think that I was a person with whom no one could live. 
 The trouble was, other people. 
 They wanted me to be different from what I was. 
 They wanted me to &bquo;put down roots&equo;. 
 But all things in this impermanent world are essentially rootless. 
 The desire to put down roots is a recognition of human rootlessness. 
 I am like the leaves and flowers of ikebana , with roots cut off, stuck in a spiked metal holder (kenzan ) instead of in the earth. 
 Their ground is water, renewed every day, as the  leaves and flowers are renewed in accordance with mood and season, even with the hour of the day. 
 My hydroponic life was the only kind with which I was happy, a gypsy trait from my Viking ancestry. 
 The true value of a lifetime's loneliness is then seen as Nothingness, Emptiness, perfectly expressed in the minimal art of traditional ikebana , and in the minimal, marginal existence of the person without ties, without permanent position, situation, family, roots. 
 It is a transient death alive in art, in which all natural will-to-live has been severed. 
 Such limitations are not deficiencies but modes of behaviour that are essences of reduction, to be valued for their essential selves. 
 This was how I valued other people, too &mdash; how I valued Dana, as someone who did not need to be improved but allowed to flourish in his own right, with all the confusions and contradictions of which he was capable. 
 I gave myself to him completely, both as a human being and as an artist. 
 But I began to see limitations in the amount I could give. 
 I wanted to get back to myself and to my own work, to all that he had robbed me of &mdash; even my own name. 
 Yet I could not let him go: his love was too precious to me, and I knew I would never find its like again. 
 It could be kept only by giving my entire self, roots and all. 
 I knew that I should have to make a decision. 
 I must choose between Dana's love and my own identity as a person and as a poet. 
 Perhaps I knew already what the answer would be &mdash; that I must cut myself free from him. 
 It would be painful for both of us, but more for me than for him, for he was young and beautiful and gifted, with the whole world before him. 
 I was neither young nor beautiful, and now I doubted my gifts. 
 Would they survive the surgical cut I was contemplating? 
 It must come. 
 The only question for me was, when? 
 I began to see one way out of our dilemma. 
 Joe had written to me suggesting that there was a post for me in Japan (available through the good offices of Stephen Spender, who had just returned from there with a commission from the Dean of the Faculty of Letters at Tohoku University) to go and teach English, in the poet-teacher tradition for which it was famous. 
 The last poet they had had, had been Ralph Hodgson, before the war. 
 George Barker had taken his place in 1940 but had escaped to the United States before Pearl Harbor, for he had been followed everywhere by the &bquo;thought police&equo;, the sinister kempeitai , who suspected him of being a communist spy. 
 But I knew nothing at all about Tohoku University, or about the city of Sendai. 
 I pushed Joe's letter into the back of my mind. 
 One evening, towards midnight, I was walking back to my hotel from Dana's place along a deserted street. 
 Suddenly, out of a dark doorway, a figure stepped and stood in front of me with open arms. 
 It was Jordi! 
 We embraced. 
 I was bewildered. 
 Where had he been? 
 Why hadn't he  written to me? 
 He had been in prison for three months. 
 When he was released, he sold up his home and moved to Barcelona, where he now had a job in a printing press. 
 We entered a caf&eacute; for a drink. 
 Why had he been imprisoned? 
 He would not tell me, or could not explain. 
 But I gathered that it was because of some kind of political dissent, his being a member of an unauthorized group that had held secret meetings. 
 He had aged: his hair was touched with grey, and his face was haggard. 
 Jordi had been in Salamanca only one day but he had found out where I was living. 
 And he had seen me walking from my hotel apartment with Dana &mdash; Americano , he said disdainfully. 
 Who was he? 
 I told him he was a student. 
 &bquo;Is he your lover?&equo; 
 Remembering the knife he had displayed on our last night in Valladolid, I took fright and denied it. 
 Jordi gave a bitter smile. 
 Not only his face had changed; imprisonment and hardship had changed his sweet good nature, too. 
 He had been brutalized in prison and become cynical. 
 He was leaving on the early morning train for Zaragoza, then on to Barcelona. 
 He could not take more time off. 
 I knew he could not stay at my hotel. 
 It was all right for Dana, because he was just another foreigner, but for Jordi it was impossible. 
 Again we were confronted by that vengeful force which stood in the way of same-sex lovers in Spain &mdash; especially if one was a foreigner, and one a Spaniard. 
 We wandered round the streets until dawn. 
 There was no love left in Jordi. 
 But he had remembered me and come to say goodbye to me. 
 It was the only way he could let me know what had happened to him. 
 As we were sitting in the station waiting-room, waiting for the train to Zaragoza, he took my hand and wept. 
 He would not give me his address in Barcelona &mdash; it would be too dangerous for us to meet again. 
 I thought of the refugees whose turmoil was invading the whole of Europe. 
 We, too, were refugees &mdash; the refugees of a forbidden love. 
 I felt this was a rehearsal for my parting from Dana. 
 The train entered the station. 
 As he was getting into the train, Jordi smiled and shrugged as he had done that night in Valladolid when the secret police had led him away. 
 But this time he drew out his knife and showed it to me with a meaningful glance. 
 My blood froze. 
 &bquo;No, Jordi, no!&equo; was all I could say as the train slowly carried him away into the dawn. 
 He was standing at the window of an empty compartment, laughing, as he made the gesture of slitting his throat. 
 I never saw him again, never heard from him. 
 Whenever I am in Barcelona I expect to run into Jordi, even today, thirty years later, in a totally different, freer, happier Spain. 
 But something tells me he is no longer alive. 
 I carry with me the memory of that knife's sharp flash in the rising sun.  
 I never told Dana of this encounter. 
 The first step was to leave Salamanca. 
 I told Dana I could no longer bear the atmosphere of the city, the right-wing bullies, the Falangists, the deadening work of teaching mostly bored and resentful students. 
 He said he would stay on until the vacation. 
 Then what? 
 Probably return to the United States&hellip;. 
 It was Easter again. 
 I left for Bath. 
 As soon as the train started, I drew a long breath of relief. 
 I was not running away from anything &mdash; I was running towards something, my old self, my old talent, and &mdash; for a while &mdash; my own home. 
 Of course my mother thought I had returned in order to live with her. 
 She was very lonely, though she had some friends and visits from relatives from time to time. 
 But her whole life had been my father and myself; without us, she was lost. 
 She had no other interests in life, nothing to fall back on. 
 And her eyesight was getting worse. 
 I had arranged for her to see a specialist, and he told me the condition was irreversible, that she would never lose her sight completely but that she would be almost totally blind within a year. 
 It was around this time that &bquo;queer-bashing&equo; began in Bath, as in the rest of Britain. 
 Down by the bus station I was followed by a gang of youths chanting &bquo;Puff, the Magic Dragon&equo;. 
 I escaped only by jumping on a bus to Warminster. 
 If Dana had been with me, they would never have dared. 
 Without Dana I was suffering the agonies of hell. 
 Perhaps sex had become for me a habit-forming drug. 
 I was suffering severe and painful withdrawal symptoms, and my mother was alarmed by my fits of weeping, my chronic insomnia, my thinness. 
 She had started attending classes at the Blind Club, and was being prepared for her further loss of sight. 
 She now had a collapsible white metal stick she used quite defensively when out walking. 
 In later years she would hit the shins of passers-by with it if they got in her way. 
 We went for walks in the enchanting gardens of Bath. 
 In particular the special garden for the blind was her favourite, where she would gently rub the sweet-scented leaves and herbs and flowers between her fingers and recall their names &mdash; the names she knew so well from the allotment we had had in South Shields. 
 Those daily walks with her helped to calm my mind a little, but I could not bear the thought of writing poems again, not without Dana. 
 I was so sure I would fail, 
 My mother went on an outing for a few days with the Blind Club. 
  Left all alone, I was in despair. 
 I wrote to Dana but got no reply. 
 I did not really expect one. 
 Yet his presence was everywhere in the house, like my father's, and in all the places we had known in London and Bath and Bristol. 
 While my mother was away I decided to take a trip myself, and took refuge in my old home town, South Shields, now changed almost unrecognizably. 
 But the old market square was still there, the ferry to North Shields; Ocean Road, the Town Hall, the Library, Trow Rocks, the sands, the pier&hellip;. ft was on the pier that I made my first stumbling attempts to start writing poetry on my own again; my very own poetry: 
 I walk the long dark pier that bends 
 Out of the seaport's lonely streets into 
 The unlit centre of the northern seas. 
 Slowly I leave the land's hard lights behind, 
 And turn to the deadly power of the stars, 
 The full moon's malignance racked in clouds. 
 The sea runs on each side of me, 
 Banging the stone defences of an endless sleep 
 With bitter tons that die in fits of spray. 
 Only the lighthouse at the end is true. 
 To touch its burning tip will give love life. 
 I shall not reach it if the gates are shut 
 Against the storm that hoists the lunging sea. 
 - But though the gates are shut, it reaches me. 
 In my utter loneliness I had only one resource: several times I took the ferry to North Shields, and walked up the steep bank to a certain public lavatory beside a roaring pub. 
 The lavatory was below ground, and in the white brick walls between the two cubicles a hole had been hacked, one of the best glory-holes in existence at that time. 
 There was usually some man waiting on the other side of the hole, like some sea creature waiting to grab its prey, and after I had settled on the seat, there would be a significant pause. 
 We would start to make movements that suggested masturbation. 
 Then a horny pit-lad's hand, coal-dust under the fingernails, would insinuate itself through the hole, just wide enough for his big, warm, tender hand. 
 Already I would be in what Nabokov calls &bquo;a manly condition&equo;, and the release was sharp and sweet. 
 Then it was the turn for my own hand to explore the anonymous member beyond the missing brick. 
 It was a pleasure of the utmost, basic simplicity, convenient and hidden, yet profoundly human and tender in  its mutual concern. 
 We never tried to see one another's faces: that would perhaps have spoiled the purity of the experience. 
 Yet when I emerged from that heaven-haven of sexual absolution, I would feel guilty, frightened, torn between happiness at being liberated from overwhelming sexual tension and the scared wonder of the events, as if they had been rituals in a half-remembered primitive religion. 
 At night the place was jumping, the whistling urinals were all occupied, and then the smell of piss and semen was the smell of ecstatic terror, for we never knew when the place would be raided by the cops, and the person standing at the next stall playing with himself might be a copper's nark, an informer or an agent provocateur . 
 How on earth I came through all those perils unscathed, unarrested, is one of the miracles of my early life. 
 There was an angel watching over me, as someone had once predicted in my childhood when she read my fortune in the tea-leaves, in my cup of white china with the gilt shamrock on the rim and in the centre of the saucer. 
 No one knew me now in South Shields. 
 Occasionally I felt that a policeman or a plain-clothes dick was looking rather too intently into my face. 
 But as usual I affected a supreme unconcern, and floated past them with a sway of the hips that was a touch exaggerated. 
 Wolfenden had come and gone, but persecution was still abroad in the streets and back lanes of Tyneside. 
 I paid surreptitious trips to our old homes in Ada Street and West Avenue, where the fences my father had put up for Granny Kirkup before the war &mdash; in 1934, I believe &mdash; were still standing round the long garden of &bquo;Mundesley&equo;, named after my grandmother's birthplace. 
 I felt so proud of my father for having been such a fine craftsman. 
 I had a letter about him from the Amalgamated Society of Joiners and Carpenters, of which he had been a prominent member. 
 It said they all stood with bowed heads at the start of the meeting after they had heard of his death, &bquo;and there was a silence that could be felt&hellip;.&equo; 
 Who would not be proud of such a father? 
 And yet I had failed him, and he had failed me. 
 Those psychic scars would never heal. 
 Now I could not even write my own poems to my satisfaction: I felt crippled. 
 Furtive but fulfilling sex was the only consolation. 
 I was back home before my mother returned from her little holiday. 
 She seemed much more cheerful and was full of chatter about her new friends and about the wonderful workers at the Blind Club, where she was learning to write using a metal board with black elastic stretched  across it for lines. 
 She practised writing letters to me, though I was still at home. 
 She must have sensed that one day I would be leaving her again, and that nearly broke my heart, knowing the sadness she must feel all too well in my experiences with lovers who never stayed long but left me feeling as if part of me had been torn from my body. 
 Aunt Lyallie must have been needling my mother while I was away, because one day she suddenly asked me, with tremulous anxiety: &bquo;Why don't you get married, Jim? 
 Don't you want to get married?&equo; 
 Unconsciously she put a note of hope into those half-scandalized questionings, because she knew I knew she would never be happy if I married. 
 She wanted me to stay as I was, the way she had created me. 
 All I could say in reply was: &bquo;What for?&equo; 
 And she gave a faint smile, reassured. 
 A few years later, when a Japanese professor on holiday in England visited her in our other house in Bath, Hill House in Sion Road, he said to her, in the usual Japanese joky way: &bquo;I'm sure your son will be marrying some nice Japanese lady, Mrs Kirkup.&equo; 
 She at once sent me a terrified letter, accusing me of concealing my marriage plans from her. 
 I had to send her a greetings telegram, so that she would not be alarmed at the sight of the envelope, saying: DARLING MUM I AM MARRIED TO MY MUSE AND HAVE NO INTENTION OF SEEKING A DIVORCE SO DON'T WORRY I'LL BE A BACHELOR GAY FOR ME REST OF MY LIFE LOVE JIM. 
 Her reply was an almost audible sigh of relief. 
 Occasionally I spent a day in London, always returning at night to keep my mother company. 
 I saw Joe, of course, and remember laughing at his description of how Morgan Forster had been interviewed by Alfred C. Kinsey for his researches into Sexual Behaviour in the Human Male . 
 Joe had once taken Rose Macaulay to a Billy Graham revivalist, fundamentalist mass meeting and been utterly revolted by all the rabid emotionalism and the militant Christianity, and he reminded me what Graham had said about Kinsey: &bquo;It is impossible to estimate the damage this book will do to the already deteriorating morals of America.&equo; 
 On May Day I got a shock that was half pleasant, half sad: Joe had printed, over our pseudonym, one of the last poems Dana and I had composed, &bquo;Winter's End&equo;: 
 We shall not watch the long delay 
 Of snow, nor feel its sudden flight 
 Alarm our sleeping eyes, and play 
 Its rosy waterfalls across the white 
 Suspensions of the rising day. 
 Nor shall we hear its airy flakes 
 Feather the quiet as they fall 
 Their massive winds upon the lakes, 
 Nor shiver through their leaning wall 
 That always mends what nothing breaks. 
 - If winter wreathes our breath again 
 Upon a branch where summer blew, 
 Will it recall the season when 
 We made one weather out of two, 
 And snow its secrets on us then? 
 I was on the bus from the centre of Bath to the end of our street, Avondale Buildings (we lived at No. 5), when I casually opened The Listener  and saw this May Day poem. 
 My heart always jumped with fright whenever I saw one of my poems in print, because I was sure it would contain one of the misprints whose steady drizzle has haunted my work all my life. 
 But this was all-correct. 
 My heart kept jumping as I read it, remembering Dana and our many days and nights together. 
 When I had left him for Bath, he had said, sadly, seeing me off at Salamanca station: &bquo;I should have come with you when your father died. 
 I'm sorry. 
 Then this parting need never have happened.&equo; 
 I had felt his absence keenly at my father's funeral, among the little group of family mourners at the Bristol Crematorium. 
 I wanted to have Dana beside me as his coffin slid so smoothly into the flames and my mother clutched my arm, not daring to watch something she felt was horrible &mdash; and was to happen to her one day, at the new crematorium in Bath, high up in those verdant hills. 
 Now, as I read our poem over and over again, I longed to see him, to share it with him, to show him I still loved him, however impossible my love might be. 
 I remembered our last days in my hotel room, their fevered, unhappy intensity, with the already-hot Spanish sun blazing down outside the shutters. 
 I remembered also the time we finally accepted that British Council invitation and went to give a poetry reading in Madrid. 
 Dana read a group of modern Americans, which must have annoyed the British, starting with Elizabeth Bishop's &bquo;The Fish&equo; &mdash; I can still hear his voice, the faint American accent and the hushed astonishment he put into the first line: &bquo;I caught a tremendous fish&hellip;.&equo; 
 Then I think I read some of my favourite English poems &mdash; Hardy, Hopkins, Housman, Blake, Yeats, Edward Thomas, Wilfred Owen, and I think one each by Ted Hughes and Thom Gunn, the only contemporaries I could stand at that time. 
 We ended with a group of our own poems. 
 In Salamanca we had taken to living by candlelight in my shuttered hotel room, and those candles  crept into two or three of our last poems written there. 
 We finished our reading with all the lights in the hall turned out, and candles burning on our reading-desk. 
 The poem was about hypnotism, and contained verses like: 
 The room is growing darker with my voice. 
 You see the candle shine and slowly weep 
 Into the dark that listens to my voice. 
 Look at the light that sends your eyes asleep&hellip;. 
 At the end of each of the five verses, one of us blew out a candle, and it was very effective, dramatically. 
 We could feel the tension among the large audience of Spaniards and British and Americans, a tension that relaxed into applause as I blew the last candle out and the room lamps came on. 
 People came up to us to congratulate us on the reading. 
 We were exhausted. 
 There was to be a reception, and later we were invited to dinner at the house of the British Council representative. 
 But we refused both invitations. 
 The representative seemed stunned. 
 He sent his young daughter over to try to persuade us to stay. 
 &bquo;People always do, you know,&equo; she told us, as if that were incontrovertible proof that we had to conform. 
 We rushed out of the building and started running along the street, hardly knowing where we were or where we were going, until we felt we had put enough distance between us and the reception. 
 I had our fee in my pocket &mdash; enough for us to have a magnificent seafood dinner at a place just off the Gran Via, with a couple of bottles of wine. 
 The enormous relief at being released from that obligation made us light-headed with happiness. 
 I used to like giving poetry readings, but in the end I had to give up, for I could not stand the socializing afterwards, as if my poetry had just been the excuse for a drinking spree &agrave; la  Dylan Thomas. 
 I could not stand the ridiculous questions people came and posed about my work: &bquo;But how do you find such interesting subjects for your poems, Mr Kirkup?&equo; 
 Or: &bquo;I don't understand all this modern poetry at all, but I know what I like, and for some reason your poems manage to penetrate even my thick head. 
 How do you do it?&equo; 
 Or the many awful questions beginning: &bquo;Did you ever read&hellip;.&equo; 
 Or the dismaying prospect of endless explanations of my unusual background in reply to: &bquo;Nice to meet you. 
 I really enjoyed your reading. 
 Where you from?&equo; 
 Our escape from that hellish occasion was an act of liberation. 
 The agonies of reading one's most intimate feelings and thoughts aloud to a roomful of strangers, and then being expected to talk about them and explain them in an acceptably relaxed and humorous manner were more than I  could bear. 
 It would not be so bad if I could just stand up, read my poems and leave, but that was apparently unthinkable. 
 It was as if poets owed an explanation to the audience for being what they were, to bring creatures apart down to the level of ordinary folks; as if the poet might be indulged his little failings and eccentricities as long as he allowed himself to be democratically mauled in public by thoughtless questioners or &mdash; even worse, much worse &mdash; by fellow-poets or by those who had poetic pretensions and who found in &bquo;question time&equo; an opportunity to assuage their jealousy or seek revenge for their own incompetence and mediocrity. 
 Thanks, but &mdash; no thanks! 
 Poets will do anything to put one another down. 
 I remember the pleasant surprise I had when Olivia Manning, sitting next to me on some poetry-reading platform (the ICA?) turned to her husband after my reading and remarked to him &mdash; a BBC radio producer &mdash; &bquo;Now there's  a poet who knows how to read poetry. 
 Why don't you&hellip;?&equo; 
 But before she could finish, he retorted: &bquo;He's not a member of Equity.&equo; 
 As if that had anything to do with the ability of a poet to read his own poems! 
 That is the sort of thing poets either have to learn to put up with, or retire from the scene in order to retain their sanity. 
 And that is precisely what we had done in Madrid. 
 One morning the unbelievable happened: there was a letter from Dana. 
 ft informed us that he was leaving Salamanca for England on his motor bike, via Cherbourg, and that we could expect him in Bath on a certain day. 
 My heart leapt, then sank, then leapt. 
 My mother was guarded, but she said how nice it would be to have Dana stay with us again. 
 Day after day we waited for his arrival. 
 Then late one night, around eleven o'clock, there was a ring at the doorbell. 
 My mother had already gone to bed. 
 I went to open it, and there was Dana, travel-stained and weary but with a beaming smile on his sun-tanned face. 
 I looked past him and saw the old motor bike, which he parked in our front garden. 
 I made him some tea and supper while he bathed and changed and unpacked his things in my bedroom. 
 There was much to talk about, and we were awake until after four. 
 Incredibly, he had taken up with those student thugs, and they had taken him out drinking until they were all blind drunk &mdash; &bquo;So drunk, nobody remembered what had happened next day.&equo; 
 I could guess what that standard excuse for sexual orgies might mean. 
 So, after that, he had decided to leave Salamanca for good and return to the United States by way of England, to say a final goodbye to me and my mother in the house where we had all been so happy at Christmas. 
 &bquo;There's someone missing,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;You can feel his absence. 
 I  liked your father so much.&equo; 
 We slept together, in one another's arms. 
 Next morning I let him sleep until midday. 
 He had left some notebooks on my study table. 
 I picked one of them up and was struck to the heart, for it was obvious that he had been writing a lot of poetry, all of it, so it seemed to me, very good. 
 And I had been dumb so long! 
 I felt a furious jealousy. 
 I felt our situation had been reversed: now I was the halting beginner, he was the fluent expert. 
 Now I needed his help in order to get started again, and we took up once more our old collaborative writing habits. 
 I realized that all I wanted was to stop him from writing on his own, and that this was possibly his own motive for working with me in Salamanca - to keep my true poetic self silent, subservient to his. 
 It was a slow and painful realization, as when he had told me that he had been deliberately tempting me to have sex with him all along&hellip;. 
 But our poetry started to flow again, though now it was he who distributed the favours: there was no call for him now to bribe me with sex, so this aspect of our relationship was something he kept under tight control, allowing sexual contact only when he felt like it and not just when I wanted it, as in the past. 
 Nevertheless, I was quite happy. 
 Bath was more beautiful than ever in the early summer. 
 We took my mother to some of the events and concerts of the Bath Festival, among them a wonderful performance by Hepzibah and Yehudi Menuhin. 
 One day as we were going to a choral concert in Bath Abbey, we were all three walking along the Parade when my mother stopped Dana and said, pointing across the road: &bquo;That's the police station. 
 So you had better be careful.&equo; 
 ft was said as a joke, and Dana and I laughed, but it left me frightened. 
 Perhaps my mother had received another anonymous letter which she had successfully concealed from me? 
 On the motor bike we rode all over the countryside, to Bathampton, Bradford-on-Avon to see the old tithe barn, to Bristol to visit the Llandoger Trow, and as far as Cheltenham Spa, Leamington and Gloucester. 
 We even paid a surprise visit to Corsham, where Rosemary and Clifford Ellis welcomed us warmly and invited me to give a series of lectures and classes. 
 We were broke, so I accepted, and Dana took me on his bike to and fro from Bath to Corsham throughout the next six weeks. 
 But I was thankful when the summer holiday started and I could be released from duties I was finding it harder and harder to cope with. 
 In Salamanca, as a parting present, Dana had given me two of his most beloved treasures, two books of Chinese prints and ink drawings. 
 They now inspired us to write a poem, &bquo;Chinese Print&equo;:  
 He lies on rocks 
 As though they were a bank of clouds, 
 And reads a book. 
 He lifts the leaves 
 In one small hand to fan the light 
 Under his lids. 
 He reads the air: 
 Its empty pages are the wings 
 Of painted birds. 
 They fly with him 
 Across another turning page &mdash; 
 Clean out of sight. 
 How far will he 
 Go floating in his robe of mist 
 With lifted wrist? 
 This poem helped me to find a way back into my own poetry. 
 Unknown to Dana, I began writing a series of free-verse poems about the pictures. 
 They later appeared in The Prodigal Son  as &bquo;Seven Pictures from China&equo;, and have since proved popular with anthologists. 
 Unwisely, I let Dana see my drafts of these poems, and at once I could sense his disapproval, his jealousy even, that I had written the poems myself. 
 (When he finally left us for the United States, he took these gifts back from me, with the excuse that as he had bought them in Berlin he wanted to show them to the dancer. 
 But the true reason was that he wanted to prevent me from writing any more good poems about them.) 
 He could see that I was slowly but surely getting back to my old self, and to my own poetry. 
 A number of tentative poems took shape, and five of them form the first section of The Prodigal Son . 
 I could not finish them until after Dana had left for the States, when I would sit day after day beside my desk, trying to write, while on the other side of Avondale Buildings the children screamed and shrieked in the playground. 
 I wrote lines like this: &bquo;I wait with a pencil in my hand/ Beside the morning's empty page&hellip; 
 &bquo;, &bquo;The dumb words are fastened in my throat, / And will not come&hellip;.&equo; 
 And, in &bquo;The Lost Poem&equo;: 
 Will what I now begin to write 
 Become the poem I have lost 
 So long, and did not wish 
 To find again?&hellip; 
 This period of inarticulate waiting began to end with &bquo;After Pentecost&equo;: 
 The wonder is that I write 
 This, when I cannot find a word. 
 Once, everything came to my hand, 
 The farthest phrases, and the closest calls, 
 And I drew my meaning lightly 
 From the waters of a page&hellip; 
 Yet for the first time now, 
 As if I learned to speak 
 Again, after a long dumbness, 
 I seek the wind of a word. 
 The wonder is that I write 
 This, upon the waters of a page. 
 In the weeks before he left, Dana and I sometimes quarrelled bitterly. 
 I think we were both wanting to be free, to write our own work, yet we were afraid to relinquish the relationship that had kept us writing together so long. 
 I had gained a poet but was losing a lover, perhaps the last I would ever know. 
 We had our little mock boxing-matches, in my study, circling round the table as if it were a ring. 
 Sometimes the slaps and punches were for real now, and my mother would cry up the stairs in alarm whenever she heard a sudden thump as I fell on the floor or bumped into the furniture. 
 Then I had to reassure her that we were &bquo;just having fun&equo;. 
 She did not believe me. 
 &bquo;Queer sort of fun,&equo; she would comment, her eyes, so gentle, so nearly sightless, filling with fear. 
 She sensed the tensions we were suffering before we finally parted. 
 I stood at the front door of No. 5, watching Dana straddle his bike, adjust his backpack and wave cheerily to me as he roared off down the road. 
 I watched him until he turned the corner. 
 He never looked back. 
 That was something I could understand, and approve of &mdash; to make a clean cut. 
 I got on the bus at the terminus at the bottom of Avondale Buildings and rode it back and forth to the other end of the line, sitting on the top deck, not knowing where I was or what I was doing, until the conductor came up to me at the other terminus, after my fifth trip, and asked: &bquo;You all right, mate?&equo; 
 So I got off and walked around for an hour or so, unseeing, my mind a total blank. 
 I kept weeping. 
 Trying to compose myself, I got back home in time to make tea, but could do nothing except collapse sobbing in my mother's arms. 
 She held me tenderly and stroked my hair, and said nothing until I was calm again. 
 Then we switched on the TV and had a cup of tea. 
 &bquo;Don't worry,&equo; she  told me as she went to bed that night. 
 &bquo;It's all over now.&equo; 
 But it was not. 
 Our love affair was over. 
 But it lives on in the poems we wrote together, and in the poems I wrote myself in Salamanca and Bath. 
 Though we had parted for ever, I did not believe our love was lost. 
 Mine, at any rate, after the initial angers and resentments, has lingered on to this day, and I think there has never been a rime when I did not remember that love and think of Dana. 
 I sometimes dream of him: at times he enters my dreams with loving smiles, at times he is cold and indifferent, but we are always friends. 
 One of the last poems we wrote together in Bath expresses perfectly the state of our love at that time. 
 It was about two skeletons discovered in a stone coffin in Bath. 
 We called it &bquo;The Anatomy of Love&equo;: 
 How comfortable they look, 
 Laid out together in a bed of stone 
 Whose rocky coverlet was rolled 
 Away, stripping these sweethearts to the bone. 
 No chance encounter has composed 
 Their double genders in a single birth; 
 Nor is it accident completes 
 Their pleasure in the lively earth. 
 Two skulls repose upon the same 
 Worn pillow in their dusty mine. 
 Their tangled joints are slung upon 
 The cable of one common spine. 
 Now those two contracted hearts 
 Have wept each other's dust away, 
 Their cages' interlocking ribs 
 Do there embrace till judgment day. 
 Among the innocent exchange of limbs 
 The knees are capped with skipping stones. 
 The fists have rattled down the shins 
 To shake the footloose fans of bones. 
 These chalky relics of the flesh 
 Have danced beyond, and clean above 
 Boneless tongue, and melting eye, 
 And parts that want the whole of love. 
 The coffin is displayed in the museum attached to the Roman Baths. 
 Today, since my mother's death in that beautiful city, I cannot bear to 
 return. 
 There are too many memories, all sad, in Bath and its environs. 
 But one day I must take my courage in both hands and go back to visit 
 all the places we knew &mdash; to Beckford's Tower on Lansdowne Hill, to 
 Corsham Court, to Brunel's great suspension bridge at Clifton, to the 
 ancient tithe barn at Bradford-on-Avon. 
 Perhaps the best poem about the ending of our love was one we 
 wrote in my apartment at the Hotel Espa&ntilde;a in Salamanca, just before I 
 returned to England. 
 We called it &bquo;The Last of Love&equo;, and it 
 commemorates the last time we made love in Salamanca: 
 Behind the shutters' bended shafts 
 That slake our bodies with the lime of light, 
 We take our last of love; then float 
 The battens open to the ends of night. 
 Calming bewildered flesh, we coax 
 The spirit back into the haunts of breath 
 And catch the drift of loneliness 
 Whose wide confusions flank desire with death. 
 Here, in each other's arms, we end 
 A love that left no gentle wish to true 
 The compass of a common star, 
 No I to take the strangeness out of you. 
 What double weathers in our hands 
 Cause them to flutter in the air, and sneak 
 A flame through which to drag the time? 
 The morning is a wound that will not speak. 
 As time bends out before us through 
 A window that turns in upon the pane, 
 We draw unending parallels 
 Of light through eyes that cannot meet again. 
 The parallels with that coffin poem are evident. 
 If we had gone on, our love would have brought us the death we secretly called up every time we embraced. 
 We were like those skeletons still embracing in the dust of their vanished flesh and dead desires. 
 The flame of the cigarette we used  to light and share after making love was the last symbol of warmth we had when the fires of passion were quenched. 
 And even after Dana had left, there was something of him that remained in Bath, as we were to find out. 
 A presence lived on in his absence. 
 Dana had wanted to take his old bike with him on the ship back to the States. 
 We had gone to the Council Offices to obtain permission for him to take it with him. 
 But for some reason I cannot remember, it was impossible to get permission to ship the motor bike. 
 He said he might sell it in Southampton if he could not get it on board. 
 I had been away in London for the day, about three or four days after Dana's departure. 
 When I got home, my mother's face was white with shock. 
 A policeman had come while I was out and had asked her to tell me to call at his house as soon as I got back. 
 &bquo;What have you done now, Jim?&equo; she whispered in a shaking voice. 
 I did not know what it could be, but I tried to reassure her and went up the road to where the policeman lived. 
 I was quite calm. 
 If I was to be arrested, I would be arrested with dignity. 
 But the tall policeman who came to the door was quite amiable. 
 It turned out that Dana had simply left his old motor bike on the quayside before embarking on the ship. 
 The police at Southampton had got in touch with Bath, asking what was to be done with the bike, as it had apparently been abandoned. 
 I explained everything to the policeman. 
 He asked if it would be all right if the Southampton police were to sell the bike and give the proceeds to one of their charities, and I readily agreed. 
 And that was that. 
 I returned home for a late tea and carefully explained to my mother what Dana had done, and tried to excuse the thoughtlessness that had caused her such a shock. 
 &bquo;I thought he had come to take you away, Jim,&equo; she said, breaking into tears. 
 Then we both had a good cry together, and felt a lot better after a good strong cup of tea. 
 About fifteen years later I saw Dana again. 
 It was when I was living in New York, in Greenwich Village, in 1974, after completing a semester of &bquo;creative writing workshops&equo; at Ohio University, where I had been very happy. 
 I found a directory of poets in a famous West Side bookstore, the Gotham Book Mart, and idly turned the pages of American names. 
 Suddenly one name seemed to leap off the page from among the hundreds of unknowns &mdash; it was Dana's, and it was followed by his  address and telephone number. 
 So he was now living in Washington, DC! 
 The entry specified that he had Spanish as a foreign language, which made me smile, for his Spanish had never been more than rudimentary, though of course it might have improved since he was in Salamanca. 
 He had vaguely mentioned that he was hoping to join the Peace Corps. 
 I knew Washington quite well, having visited it two or three times while I was at Amherst in 1969. 
 I had been intending to return there to visit again the marvellous art galleries, in particular to see the Whistlers and the oriental art in the Freer Gallery. 
 So I got on the Greyhound Bus for a six-hour ride to Washington and checked in at a cheap hotel opposite the bus depot. 
 It was quite a respectable place, occupied mainly by blacks, and transients, and there was the unmistakable sweet smell of marijuana in the elevator. 
 I looked up Dana's name in the telephone book, and, with wildly beating heart called the number. 
 Almost immediately a woman's rather rough voice answered, and I said: &bquo;Could I speak to Dana, please?&equo; 
 She put down the receiver and roared &bquo;Dana!&equo; 
 I had the impression that she was shouting upstairs, and I seemed to hear footsteps tripping lightly down to the phone. 
 Then was his voice, saying: &bquo;Yes, hello? 
 Who's this?&equo; 
 I could not answer. 
 I put down the receiver, overcome by emotion at hearing that voice again, unchanged. 
 But I felt I could not possibly meet him again. 
 The next day, after visiting the Freer, I went to inspect the brand-new modern art museum, the Hirshhorn Museum and Sculpture Garden. 
 As I entered, I saw an unmistakable figure in front of me &mdash; Dana. 
 He had his back to me, and he had grown a beard, but his hair was still thick and blond. 
 He was with a group of friends whom he had apparently met in the gallery, and they were all standing around him admiringly, talking and laughing in that exaggeratedly animated way only Americans have, reacting and demanding reactions. 
 One of Dana's reactions was very characteristic: he bent double with laughter at something he had said that made all the others laugh, too. 
 He was wearing a dark suit. 
 I was more casually dressed in corduroys and a black leather jacket. 
 I did not want him to see me. 
 I managed to pass behind some tall screens on which those ridiculously huge contemporary paintings, works of the utmost nullity, were hung, and crept cautiously round a group of cranky statues. 
 I looked carefully about me, hiding behind one of those contorted shapes, and glimpsed Dana in the distance, walking away from the group of friends and joining a young woman, tall, pale, dark, distinguished-looking &mdash; could it be that dancer of his? 
 They walked slowly along one wall, laughing and talking and only incidentally looking at the eccentric  pictures. 
 They disappeared from sight, and I was about to advance into another part of the gallery from behind some screens when I stopped dead: Dana was there, alone, right in front of me. 
 He looked at me as if he could not believe his eyes, and a faint, doubtful smile began to move his lips. 
 I just stared back at him as if I did not recognize him, then moved away out of sight behind another screen. 
 When I emerged on the other side, our little game of hide-and-seek was over: he had vanished, taking the girl with him. 
 I got the impression that he was frightened, as if he had seen a ghost. 
 The next day I took the first bus back to New York. 
 But ever since then I have often wondered why he was in Washington. 
 Was he, as I originally suspected in Salamanca, an FBI agent or working for the CIA? ft was a mystery I had no longer any wish to clear up. 
 About ten years later, in 1980 I think, I revisited Salamanca, on my way back from Lisbon. 
 I stayed at the Gran Hotel on the Plaza del Poeta Iglesias, more mortuary than El Escorial. 
 What bothered me most after my long absence were the forests of TV aerials on even the humblest dwellings. 
 The shallow, red-tile roofs of the Plaza Mayor, once so touching in their simple irregularities, now glitter with armies of metal rods, antennae. 
 Trying to take pictures of the buildings without those intrusive TV aerials is almost impossible. 
 And surely the Plaza was not the crowded car-park it is now? 
 Perhaps it was just the effect of the tourist season, but Spain seemed very much more prosperous, and the construction companies and property developers had their giant cranes everywhere, their crude colours looming garishly over the old amber-rose stone of the city's most ancient monuments. 
 People seem better dressed, and there are more cars in the streets, and fewer beggars and blind men selling lottery tickets. 
 There are huge new blocks of flats, some of them with swimming-pools. 
 The young people now seem much freer, and there are young girls drinking with their boy-friends in the bars of the Plaza Mayor. 
 I went to the university on the Plaza de Anaya and climbed the familiar stairway in the Palacio de Anaya. 
 The bust of Unamuno is still there, and again it looks as if someone has attempted to defile it, perhaps in some would-be funny student jape. 
 I stood in that upper gallery where I first saw Dana and he cast that look upon me which was to make me his slave. 
 The beautiful old university buildings are unchanged &mdash; the Fray Luis de Leon lecture hall, with that scholar's statue outside, the ancient library, the delicately carved plateresque fa&ccedil;ades. 
 Next I went to the Clerecia, where I had been sitting with Dana  watching that wall-clock's gift pendulum busily wagging away on the wall in front of the great baroque gilt altar. 
 The clock had been removed for repairs and only a small hook remained in the wall. 
 I prayed a little and wept for my dear father, and for myself, my unhappy passion. 
 I visited the Casa de las Conchas where that lonely schoolboy, so many centuries ago, had inscribed his sad and bitter thoughts. 
 They are still there. 
 At the Hospedaje Lisboa where Dana stayed &mdash; &bquo;Camas, Comidas&equo; &mdash; I looked up at his window as I had so often done on those lonely days and nights he spent away from me. 
 At night, sometimes the window was lighted, sometimes it was dark &mdash; either eventuality filled me with foreboding and sorrow. 
 Then I ascended the narrow stairs to his doorway. 
 There was a notice on the entrance: No hay habitaciones.  
 Gracias por su visita . 
 Down the twisting stone stairs again and out through the front door opposite the barber-shop where the barbers used to look so longingly at our flowing locks &mdash; later on, the regulation hair-style for most young men. 
 Summoning up all my courage, I entered San Esteban and its overpowering gilded Churriguera altar seemed to welcome me like a long-lost friend as I dipped my hand in the holy-water stoup at the door and knelt to pray in front of Claudio Coello's heavenly blue painting. 
 The place where we had entered the crypt below the altar had been bricked up. 
 I prayed for forgiveness. 
 Again the tears flowed unchecked, and I was sobbing loudly in the empty church. 
 At San Martin the wall to the gallery had also been bricked in. 
 Once we had sat together in that &bquo;condemned&equo; gallery until evening, and the sacristan, not knowing we were there, had nearly locked us in for the night. 
 I prayed for us both before the altar, then lit two fat little night-light candles, one for Dana, one for myself, the larger one for him. 
 As I prayed for the peace of our souls and for forgiveness for both of us, I was startled to see the wick on his candle fall over and almost go out, while mine remained upright and brightly shining. 
 It was the sort of omen, one of the signatures of destiny, for which we were always watching. 
 All my anger and envy and resentment were gone. 
 It only remained for us to forgive one another, and for my part I gladly forgave him for anything that might still need forgiveness. 
 It was a pilgrimage I had had to make, and I was glad I had made it. 
 I made no pilgrimage to Valladolid, where it had all begun. 
 But whenever I am in the United States, or near an American Center in Kyoto, Paris or Seoul, I always look at the Washington, DC telephone directory and seek out Dana's name, address and number. 
 I gaze at the entry for a long time, tom between a longing to hear his voice  again and the terror of becoming in thrall to even his disembodied form. 
 But in my heart of hearts I know I cannot telephone him. 
 My deep love for him still remains. 
 But I cannot abandon my identity now as I did so freely in those days of my youth. 
 Yet I still dream about him, and write poems about him like the one that follows. 
 Photo Robot &mdash; Identikit Portrait  
 It was over thirty years ago. 
 But 
 let me try again to get it right. 
 His face, front or profile, 
 how was it then &mdash; how exactly 
 was the hair? 
 Am I making it 
 too thick, too wavy, too blond? 
 The nose, I'm almost certain, was &mdash; 
 No. 
 Was it not rather more 
 flat, almost broken, a boxer's? 
 How sharp? 
 The tip slightly tilted? 
 Was the mouth so full, that warm 
 memory of smiles and kisses, rough &mdash; 
 the tongue, rich hive of words, 
 the teeth even, white, rather small? 
 I'm sure the eyes were deep blue. 
 Or were they rather lighter, almost 
 grey, changing with his moods? 
 Were they so wide-spaced, in brows 
 so smooth, pale brown, and level 
 as the way he looked at me &mdash; that look 
 I now can barely remember, though 
 it has left its mark on me. 
 His body perfect, peach-sunned. 
 Its gold has rubbed off on me a little. 
 I loved it. 
 Yet more than all 
 it was that face, that look I loved 
 and now lie long nights awake 
 trying vainly to recapture. 
 The Reluctant Samaritan  
 IF one could be sure of having access to the book of the Recording Angel, heaven would indeed be something worth striving for. 
 To know with certainty whether one's life had been considered good or bad would be a comfort, but even more satisfying would be to find there in the book the answers to the little unsolved mysteries of everyday life; to read what really happened clearly and truly, like a watchmaker who opens the little door in the front of a grandfather clock and looks inside. 
 For the first time in my life I was having breakfast in my dressing-gown. 
 It was a summer morning, the birds were singing and the sun shining. 
 I had been looking through Situations Vacant in the local newspaper: &bquo;Secretarial assistance required&hellip; 
 &equo;, &bquo;Comfortable woman needed, good with children&hellip;&equo;, when the thought came to me that, with a roof over my head and just about enough money to live on, there was no real need for me to work at all. 
 For the first time I was free of obligation or responsibility. 
 My time was my own; I could do anything in the world I liked. 
 As I turned  this thought over in my mind it became as sparkling and as beautiful as the morning itself. 
 And then, to add to my pleasure, I saw the postman coming up the path. 
 The letter he brought was addressed in a large, childish handwriting unfamiliar to me, and the postmark was that of a town in Suffolk. 
 The contents were simple; so simple that the letter seemed to look up at me and to say, &bquo;I am in code, you know. 
 See what you can make of me.&equo; 
 Dear Madam, 
 Your aunt, Mrs Louise Ross, has asked me to write to you, as her eyes are bad. 
 I cannot keep her any longer for what she can afford to pay, and she would like you to find her accommodation near where you live. 
 I should be glad to hear what you are going to do about her as soon as possible. 
 Yours faithfully, Lily Girdlestone (Mrs) PS She is spotlessly clean. 
 Aunt Louise was the last survivor of the family of which my mother had been a member. 
 Lively and headstrong, considered beautiful in her day (and there had been something proud about her &mdash; the way she held her head), she had married well and had lived abroad for almost all my life. 
 Before she married, my father, who had rescued his parentless sister-in-law from a succession of scrapes, once remarked (not unkindly), &bquo;She has been a nuisance  all her life and always will be.&equo; 
 Others of the family said of her, &bquo;You can't believe a word she says! 
 She makes trouble wherever she goes.&equo; 
 Also, &bquo;Louise is a coward; she always retreats in an argument.&equo; 
 But Louise was not a coward, even as a little girl I had understood this. 
 Nor, I realize now, was she exactly what one would call a liar:. 
 it was just that her imagination, so strong and enticing, was apt to sweep away the barrier between itself and reality. 
 Over the years she had become a stranger to us, her sisters tending to avoid her; all but my mother, who still wrote to her at Christmas-time. 
 I had found Aunt Louise's address when my mother died, and had written to her; writing again when my father, then living with me, had died also. 
 It seemed that she, now a widow, lived in Scotland with her only child, Celia, her son-in-law, and their two little boys. 
 How did Aunt Louise now come to be living in Suffolk? 
 And how could she, always so proud, have come to ask a stranger to write for her a private letter, even if her sight was becoming bad? 
 And that PS, &bquo;She is spotlessly clean&equo; &mdash; why did it startle me so? 
 I knew there was no hope at all of my finding lodgings for Aunt Louise, and put the letter aside; only when bedtime came could I no longer hide from myself its implications. 
 The next day I wrote to Mrs Girdlestone; a nice letter, explaining that Mrs Ross had a daughter living in Scotland, and giving the address. 
 She would be the right person with whom to get in touch concerning her mother.  
 A reply came almost by return of post. 
 Mrs Ross's daughter had gone from Scotland. 
 She had left her mother in Suffolk knowing that the rooms were only available for three months. 
 She had written to her mother giving no address, saying that she had left her husband and was going abroad, that she could do nothing more for her mother and had her own life to live. 
 Mrs Ross, Mrs Girdlestone added, had only her pension to live on, and she repeated that she would be glad if I could do something about her as soon as possible. 
 As in Miss Austen's day it was universally accepted that a young unmarried man with a house and fortune was in need of a wife, so Mrs Girdlestone might have been beguiled into accepting a somewhat similar assumption that one elderly lady living alone is in need of an even more elderly lady to live with her (prudently stipulating, however, the three months only, in case she should wish to draw back). 
 On more than one occasion I, too, had been approached. 
 Once my brother had warned me. 
 &bquo;Don't do it. 
 I know of someone who took in an old lady and she turned out to be well-known for being difficult. 
 She fastened on to the person whose house it was like the Old Man of the Sea in &bquo;Sinbad the Sailor&equo;.&equo; 
 &bquo;But surely if there was difficulty and she had relations, they would have taken her back.&equo; 
 &bquo;Not they. 
 They disappeared, and the old lady drove the one whose house it was dotty. 
 The one whose  house it was got taken away and the other one lived on in the house. 
 They couldn't get her out. 
 Don't do it.&equo; 
 On another occasion I had received a letter from my mother &mdash; not usually given to handing out advice: 
 Last night, while sitting doing my ration of embroidery, I thought of what we had been talking about &mdash; the paying guest, and have come to the conclusion that you ought not to undertake such a responsibility as you have had such a difficult time in one way and another with sickness and trouble. 
 You should look after yourself for your children's sake. 
 Mothers are often needed unexpectedly. 
 Once with you, the old lady might be difficult to get rid of. 
 She may fall ill, or have an accident while you were out, or set the house on fire and herself, so that you would not want to leave her even to go shopping. 
 Once with you, you would not get rid of her easily, I feel it in my bones. 
 Neither of us has talked about it and I had not said I was writing until I have now started, but your father says he lay awake nearly all night thinking about it. 
 There must be a strong reason why no one of her family will have her and it is not as if she had no money. 
 I hope I do not sound unkind, but I am sure it is not right for you to have her. 
 I had my own experience years ago with your cousin's Uncle Merritt, and he was not even a relation of ours. 
 We agreed to have him for a fortnight but when the time came he refused to go, and would be with us yet if it had not been for the First World War and your father having to go&hellip; 
 PS Read, mark, learn, and inwardly digest. 
 (But was there not a difference here? 
 Aunt Louise was a relation, and if she were going to drive anyone dotty  should it be the trusting stranger with whom Celia had left her &bquo;for three months only&equo;?) 
 That evening I went to see an old friend (that is, old in years) in case out of the experience of a long life she might bring forth words of wisdom. 
 I stood at the door and looked up, but the windows were dark; she had gone to bed. 
 I had once given a few lessons to a nun at a convent not far from where I lived, so that I was slightly known there. 
 They did, in fact, take in a small number of elderly people. 
 Nuns, I thought, would understand the troubles of the old and homeless, and would give balanced advice. 
 And nuns, I thought, would probably go to bed fairly late, so I rang the convent, asked to speak to the Mother Superior and explained my problem. 
 &bquo;Have you children?&equo; asked the disembodied voice of the nun. 
 &bquo;Yes, I have, but they are almost grown-up.&equo; 
 &bquo;Your duty is to your children,&equo; said the nun, and rang off. 
 Because of a vague feeling of loyalty, a need to repay someone or something who had seemed to walk with me through the burning fiery furnace of my husband's last illness, I had started now and then to go to church. 
 I went the next evening, and because for some reason  
 there was rather a large congregation, and I was late, I found myself sitting more to the front than usual, in fact opposite the lectern. 
 Incredibly the lesson was the parable of the Good Samaritan. 
 From school I knew this parable by heart, and I think the reader must have known it too, because as he reached the concluding sentences, his frail hands were already feeling for the embroidered marker and preparing to close the great heavy book, so that his eyes were not on the page but were gazing unseeing into mine as he spoke the final well-worn words, &bquo;Then said Jesus unto him, &bquo;Go, and do thou likewise.&equo;&equo; 
 That evening I wrote again to Mrs Girdlestone and said I would come and see how things were with my aunt, and if possible arrange for something to be done. 
 The relief of having made a decision did not last. 
 A picture had begun to form in my mind. 
 It was of all those in heaven who had ever loved me, gazing down horrified, and saying, &bquo;Look at her! 
 Look what she's doing now! 
 She'll never get out of this. 
 She'll never be a match for those two old women. 
 She'll have Louise on her back for the rest of her life, and she'll never be able to manage her. 
 Louise will drive her dotty! &equo; 
 And another picture. 
 Once I had seen a rabbit snare fixed between the palings of a fence, and now my mind's eye saw a rabbit hopping slowly towards this remembered snare as if hypnotized, and the rabbit was me.  
 That last evening, as unable to settle I wandered round the house, the computer within which insists on running hither and thither matching like with like (laying its finds before us like a cat presenting a dead mouse) now threw up the words of a hymn from long ago. 
 Miserably I looked up the hymn. 
 Yes, it was rather apt, and going into the cold little room where the piano stood, I played it over &mdash; stiffly, and with many mistakes &mdash; the words, nevertheless, bringing their own gloomy comfort. 
 What if Thou call'st me to resign 
 That which I prized, it ne'er was mine; 
 I only yield Thee what is Thine. 
 Thy will be done. 
 And now the train was taking me to Aunt Louise through the quiet countryside, and in spite of my preoccupation I could not help enjoying the journey. 
 The year seemed more advanced here, and very slightly the leaves were beginning to turn. 
 There was a bus connection at the other end, and lonely narrow lanes, and the cottage in which Aunt Louise was living with her unwilling hostess was like a little house in a fairy tale, with small lattice windows of endearing shapes and sizes, and a mossy garden path. 
 Aunt Louise greeted me with a kiss, and there was a feeling that I was the guest of some great lady in exile. 
 Although upright and looking much younger than her years, she seemed to have changed a great deal from when I had seen her last, and she wore a slightly dazed expression  (as well she might, I told myself, considering her age and the difficulty of her situation). 
 I hardly remember what Mrs Girdlestone looked like, other than that she was plump and elderly, and gave an impression of being prepared for battle; but I was touched when I saw the tea that had been laid out ready for me, imagining the two ladies conferring about the slices of bought ham, the thin bread-and-butter, and the bought cake. 
 They ate nothing themselves, but watched me eat with a sort of respectful deference which made me uneasy, it being, I felt, inappropriate and therefore dangerous. 
 When tea was done and cleared away, Aunt Louise withdrew, her demeanour portraying a dignified acceptance of what Mrs Girdlestone and I should decide for her. 
 I had seen that look somewhere before, and memory suggested two pictures: one was from an old history book and showed Marie Antoinette on her way to the guillotine &mdash; &bquo;The Queen went forth, stately and calm&equo;;, the other (&bquo;Tales from over the Border&equo;) showed a beautiful girl withdrawing modestly while a Highland chief petitioned her father for her hand in marriage. 
 Neither picture seemed to me to be appropriate, and I could not quite understand why it was necessary for Aunt Louise to retire at all. 
 Now that Mrs Girdlestone and I were alone together she appeared ill at ease, and there was a difficult silence; then angry words began to flow. 
 &bquo;I told her daughter three months. 
 It was not long  after my husband died. 
 I've heard since that people can do silly things then. 
 She ought to be in a home! 
 More than once she has unbolted the front door in the night and gone out in her nightdress. 
 And sometimes I have heard her crying for her mother &mdash; you know what that  means.&equo; 
 (I did not.) 
 &bquo;Crying for her mother, how dreadfully sad.&equo; 
 My heart went out to poor Aunt Louise. 
 Mrs Girdlestone eyed me sharply. 
 &bquo;&hellip; but strange,&equo; I said, &bquo;because I believe she never got on with her mother.&equo; 
 &bquo;There you are, then,&equo; said Mrs Girdlestone. 
 &bquo;And another thing, she won't be able to get into a home here. 
 She has no claim at all on a place. 
 She is a stranger, and doesn't belong here, and there are long waiting lists already &mdash; people who have lived here and paid their rates all their lives.&equo; 
 &bquo;I'd thought of that.&equo; 
 &bquo;And there are very very few women willing to take old people in these days, not with the pension. 
 They don't have to give up their best rooms and their freedom and not be mistress in their own house, and wait on people like that any more.&equo; 
 &bquo;It is the same where I live. 
 I don't think I can find her lodgings, but I could try to get her into a home. 
 I could enquire and let you know.&equo; 
 But I saw at once that this was not what Mrs Girdlestone wanted to hear. 
 It was too indefinite, and suddenly I felt very sorry for her.  
 &bquo;There is this&equo; I said putting my head firmly into the noose, &bquo;I won't let you down. 
 I will see to it that you are not left with Mrs Ross on your hands. 
 Whoever's responsibility she is, she is not yours.&equo; 
 Mrs Girdlestone's face changed: brightening and softening, transformed by an expression of immense relief. 
 &bquo;Well, in that case,&equo; she said, &bquo;I'll keep her a little longer while you look round.&equo; 
 Afterwards Aunt Louise came and took me to her room, leading the way up a strange little creaking curving staircase. 
 Halfway up was a landing lighted by a small Gothic-shaped window with leaded panes &mdash; a window fit for a witch's gingerbread house. 
 Aunt Louise's glance slid back over her shoulder to see if I had appreciated the window; I nodded and smiled back. 
 Her room was pleasant and airy; a front room, probably the best in the house, and Aunt Louise's possessions gave it quite an air. 
 &bquo;You are going to miss this room,&equo; I said, &bquo;I can't think you will be able to find anything as nice as this anywhere.&equo; 
 &bquo;It is not only the room that matters,&equo; said Aunt Louise, &bquo;it is the people. 
 Mrs Girdlestone is a nice woman but she is old.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought what we were worrying about was a roof over your head,&equo; I said, feeling that Aunt Louise needed bringing down to earth. 
 She laughed, and showed me how one of the windows  led on to a tiny balcony and a view over ancient pasture-land; across the lane spread the branches of a great oak tree. 
 She laughed again. 
 &bquo;A balcony,&equo; she said, &bquo;but no Romeo.&equo; 
 She took me to a corner where a miniature chest stood on a table. 
 One by one she slid out the drawers, then taking a necklace from its bed she held it up. 
 It was a string of crystals. 
 &bquo;For you,&equo; she said. 
 Until that moment Aunt Louise had seemed almost a stranger, her mannerisms and glances unfamiliar, and I had had no real feeling of kinship. 
 Now, while as if bestowing some order of merit she fastened the beads round my neck, her face wore a motherly expression and for the first time I was with the Aunt Louise of my childhood. 
 It was then that she said something which later I remembered and understood: &bquo;I'm sorry to have to do this to you, dear&hellip; 
 And what has been arranged for me?, 
 &bquo;Mrs Girdlestone has agreed to let you stay on while I try to find somewhere near where I live. 
 But it is no good; I don't know if you could even get into a home.&equo; 
 &bquo;I could never go into a home,&equo; said Aunt Louise quickly, and with such authority and finality that I dismissed homes from my mind. 
 &bquo;The only thing I can think of is that there is a convent near where I live, and they take a few elderly people.&equo; 
 &bquo;A convent&hellip; nuns&hellip; &bquo;  
 I could see that Aunt Louise did not altogether rule out nuns. 
 &bquo;And what if you can't get me in there?&equo; 
 &bquo;I have promised Mrs Girdlestone that I will do something,&equo; I said. 
 Later Aunt Louise opened her bag and showed me a letter. 
 &bquo;From Celia,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;Read it.&equo; 
 This was, I thought, the letter  &mdash; the letter which had brought me on my journey and which seemed about to change my life. 
 Like the first letter from Mrs Girdlestone it was short and simple, and like that letter (but now the feeling was stronger) it seemed to look up at me and to say, &bquo;I am in code, you know. 
 See what you can make of me. 
 There was one word of address (the name of a town in Yorkshire), the date, and then, 
 Dear Mother, 
 I have left Geoffrey and the children. 
 I have got someone else and we are going abroad. 
 You must understand  that I can do nothing further for you. 
 I have my own life to live. 
 Celia. 
 Beneath the word &bquo;Mother&equo; and beneath the name &bquo;Celia&equo; were what appeared to be two tiny letters. 
 But I did not think at the time to ask what they were, or their significance.  
 Aunt Louise came to me at the end of the summer. 
 Surprisingly businesslike, she had seemed disappointed with her bedroom. 
 It was the second-best of three: mine was the best, and the third was very small indeed. 
 I had to mention one thing then, that if my children came home for Christmas, or for a holiday, or for a little visit, we should all have to squeeze up. 
 It was something that had to be said but I could see that Aunt Louise did not like it, or even accept the idea. 
 One's bedroom, I suppose, is one's little kingdom, especially in a strange place. 
 &bquo;Couldn't that great bookcase thing be done away with? 
 It seems to press in on me.&equo; 
 Her hand went to her throat. 
 The bookcase was the top half of a big old-fashioned dresser. 
 &bquo;Surely there is no need now for all those children's books.&equo; 
 &bquo;There's nowhere downstairs; I could put them in my bedroom, I suppose.&equo; 
 &bquo;And I shall need a bigger wardrobe; I think I saw one in that other bedroom.&equo; 
 (I had not provided nearly enough space for her clothes. 
 The wardrobe in the other room was full, but I could perhaps get them in with mine.) 
 &bquo;I notice you keep your bedroom window open. 
 It's very unwise. 
 I wish you would close it now I am living here. 
 In a place like this we could scream for hours and no one would hear us.&equo; 
 With a slight change of posture &mdash; a lift of the head, a straightening of the already straight  back, that little proud look &mdash; she seemed to transform herself into a great lady of some kind. 
 &bquo;I have some rather good jewellery&equo; (and it was as if somewhere among her assortment of boxes was a very special one &mdash; but there was not &mdash; a mysterious Ali Baba store of necklaces, bracelets, rings, even a tiara); &bquo;I don't think my insurers would be very pleased to know that a window was left open at night.&equo; 
 It was strange with Aunt Louise in the house, she and I alone together, our relationship a delicate bubble which must at all costs be kept floating intact. 
 It had to be done. 
 There was no going back. 
 It could be accomplished, I thought, by not worrying about the future, by taking things day by day, and our being perfectly honest with one another so that we knew where we were; and loving. 
 (Yet some instinct told me that I must be careful to give her no cause for having a grievance. 
 Living alone with an Aunt Louise who was acting someone with a grievance might, I thought, be rather difficult.) 
 While the early days of autumn lasted, it seemed as if she might settle down. 
 She began to look well, and plump. 
 The dazed expression had almost left her face and I wondered if she might not have had a slight stroke when Celia abandoned her, and was now recovering. 
 It was when the novelty had worn off, when the days grew short, when earlier and earlier the curtains were drawn against the dark silence outside, that she  became restless. 
 And she was cold; it was a small house and caught the wind. 
 &bquo;I think perhaps we could have this curtain permanently drawn.&equo; 
 It was the curtain to a single French window leading to the garden and right to the side of her chair. 
 &bquo;There is always a draught through glass.&equo; 
 This was reasonable; there was a draught, and I should soon get used to the room being a little darker and my not being able to see the sunset and the lights of the town shining in the darkness below like a handful of diamonds. 
 She had brought her own armchair, and I had put it in my place &mdash; the best place &mdash; near the fire. 
 It seemed to me that each person living in a house needed his or her special place, a sort of perch. 
 It seemed also that in justice Aunt Louise, being old and a visitor, should have the best place. 
 (Secretly, however, I longed for my own perch back; I could not seem to settle anywhere. 
 The room was small, and if a chair stood on the other side of the fireplace from where Aunt Louise sat, it was in the way of anyone passing through the door leading into the kitchen, or that leading to the stairs. 
 One could sit in front of the fire, but there the lighting was difficult and it was too scorchingly hot.) 
 Nevertheless, I told myself, the success of Aunt Louise and me living together hung on such fragile things as unselfishness and the making of adjustments; and with shame I led my thoughts towards all those people living squashed together in real discomfort and privation. 
 I must learn to sublimate my desire for  my own perch by feeling happy for Aunt Louise sitting there. 
 So I told myself. 
 In any case it would be better if I sat at the table, the light was better there and I should not get lazy. 
 It was so much more businesslike to spread out needlework or write letters sitting at a table. 
 Sometimes, indeed, we both sat at the table doing our mending or writing letters. 
 I noticed that Aunt Louise could thread her needle without too much trouble and even write a few letters, but I had heard that sight is often impaired by poor health, and prided myself that this improvement might be due to good food and peace of mind. 
 Aunt Louise was always telling me to put more coal on the fire &mdash; higher and higher up the chimney which, as I knew, needed sweeping. 
 Chimney sweeps are few, and are not always willing to come so far out for a couple of chimneys. 
 Aunt Louise did not seem to understand this. 
 Poor Aunt Louise! 
 I had not realized just how cold my house might seem, she having no need to be working about the place. 
 Then I had expected to feel cold in winter, both indoors and out of doors, all my life. 
 She had known warmer climes and situations more civilized and now, in her old age, needed and expected to be warm. 
 (I reflected also that elderly people seldom feel warm in other people's houses. 
 One hears bitter complaints even where there is central heating and every comfort. 
 &bquo;They are always turning the heating up and down. 
 One is never really warm .&equo;) 
 I had given her my electric blanket. 
 It was of the  kind that one is warned against sleeping upon, but I knew she did sleep upon it. 
 The smell of scorch came floating down the stairs, very strong. 
 It was no good explaining. 
 I learned quickly that she did not like being &bquo;told&equo;. 
 She felt, it seemed to me, that a middle-aged aunt (herself), had to maintain a certain dignity, even authority, over her young niece (me). 
 It was the same with the bath taps. 
 There was something wrong with the ballcock, and if both taps were turned on to capacity at the same time there was an overflow outside. 
 I had asked the plumber to come and had reminded him several times and no doubt he would come in the end. 
 Meanwhile, I had to go up into the roof and push down the ballcock when things went wrong. 
 I had explained this to Aunt Louise, who enjoyed her bath and filled it almost to the top; but she took no notice, becoming affronted and resentful if I reminded her. 
 But there were evenings when the fire burned brightly and Aunt Louise sat in her winged chair, her skirt turned back to toast her knees; while having made up the fire I knelt on the hearthrug, loath to leave the fierce heat of the flames. 
 &bquo;We had a Rolls, of course&hellip; 
 &equo; (The worst of it was one never knew what to believe and what to leave out; sometimes the most outrageous things proved to be true.) &bquo;&hellip; and the cruises! 
 You should go for a cruise if you ever get the chance. 
 If I win a prize with my Premium Bond we will go together. 
 &bquo;Afterwards, when I came to London, I was never  really well, although the work I was doing was not hard.&equo; 
 She glanced across at me. 
 &bquo;I was at Harrods, you know, modelling hats for the older woman. 
 I had to go to the doctor in the end and he told me I was suffering from malnutrition. 
 He made me give him Celia's address, and he wrote to her and said I should not be working and living alone at my age. 
 I had to tell him my age, of course, although doctors can usually tell. 
 It was a little different from the age I had given to my employers! 
 I have always been able to knock off twenty years. 
 I have been told&equo; she smoothed the black lace across her knees, &bquo;that my legs are the legs of a woman of thirty; white all over &mdash; not a mark. 
 Of course I take care of myself; massage, you have to work towards the heart.&equo; 
 Her manner implied associations with the medical profession. 
 &bquo;The same with my arms. 
 I have no patience with women who let themselves go.&equo; 
 She broke off. 
 &bquo;That person I was living with,&equo; she chuckled, &bquo;she thought a lot of you when you came to see us. 
 I told her you were in a very good position.&equo; 
 &bquo;Aunt Louise! 
 How could you.&equo; 
 But it was of Celia that she spoke most, and with bitterness. 
 &bquo;She had not the spirit to stand up for her own mother. 
 He said, &bquo;Either your mother goes or I go.&equo; 
 Of course it was me. 
 Things were different when I was young. 
 Grandmothers were looked up to and respected then. 
 A friend of mine had their grandmother living with them &mdash; I remember her sitting in her special chair, her  feet on a footstool, with people getting her this and that. 
 She never moved a finger.&equo; 
 &bquo;But in those days there was always someone in the house, and when were you ever content to sit with your feet on a footstool never moving a finger?&equo; 
 &bquo;Never. 
 I've got too much spirit. 
 All I want is a little cottage. 
 It's not much to ask for, at the end of a long life.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's all anyone wants, and the time to have thought of it was when you were rich.&equo; 
 &bquo;Ah, but how were we to know about the crash? 
 In any case the richer you are the less likely you are to realize how cold-hearted the world can be when you are old and penniless &mdash; even one's own relations.&equo; 
 She eyed me speculatively but I was hardening up and met glance with innocent glance. 
 &bquo;&hellip; a little cottage, and perhaps a few chickens. 
 I've always liked chickens &mdash; the way they hold their heads on one side and look up at you with one eye. 
 Cackle, cackle, cackle, cackle, 
 Such a lot I've got to say. 
 Mr Hennypenny quarrelled 
 With his wife the other day. 
 She's quite gone off, 'tis such a pity; 
 Once I used to think her sweet; 
 Now she's getting like her mother. 
 Dear, these dainties are  a treat. 
 Her eggs all taken by a hedgehog! 
 Stupid ninny, think of that. 
 Dear, this cup of tea is lovely, 
 How I do enjoy a chat.' 
 There was a long pause. 
 Aunt Louise was seeking in her mind for the next verse, but it had gone. 
 &bquo;When I went to live with Celia I asked her to find me work &mdash; voluntary work; I have always wanted to help others.&equo; 
 For a moment it was Florence Nightingale speaking. 
 &bquo;She arranged for me to be companion to an old lady, the mother of a friend of theirs, for an hour or two a day. 
 The woman was dreadfully greedy. 
 She was always  eating. 
 She lived to eat. 
 I really thought sometimes that she was going to burst.&equo; 
 Aunt Louise seemed to swell up like a bullfrog, her eyes about to pop out of her head. 
 &bquo;One day, I warned her that she would burst if she were not careful; someone had to say it. 
 And that was the end of my companionship.&equo; 
 She folded pensive, Dorcas-like hands upon her knees. 
 &bquo;Then Oxfam; have you ever heard of anyone getting the sack from Oxfam? 
 I did.&equo; 
 &bquo;Whatever had you done?&equo; 
 &bquo;Nothing at all. 
 Jealousy I expect. 
 Little did the other helpers know that I had had real experience in the world of commerce outside. 
 &bquo;And there was a lot of trouble when I wanted to help the Vicar. 
 He was a very nice sympathetic man, not all that old  &mdash; about sixty, I suppose. 
 I could see how things were with him at home; his wife was no good at her job. 
 A man in that position needs support from his  wife. 
 She seemed to take no interest at all in his work and didn't even take care of him. 
 I saw a hole in one of his socks at the back as big as a potato, and offered to do some mending for him.&equo; 
 Her eyes twinkled. 
 &bquo;I could see that he was touched by my offer, but of course his wife would not have allowed that. 
 In the end, would you believe it, my own daughter accused me of trying to get off with him; a woman of my experience! 
 I began to realize that the absent Celia had not had an altogether easy time with Aunt Louise in her care. 
 No wonder her marriage had foundered. 
 &bquo;Aunt Louise, that letter of Celia's, what was the little bit of writing beneath &bquo;Dear Mother&equo;, and the bit after her name at the end?&equo; 
 Her face softened. 
 Now it was the real Aunt Louise. 
 &bquo;It was when she was a little girl. 
 I used to sing to her, &bquo;All things bright and beautiful, All creatures great and small&hellip; 
 &bquo;'. One day she said, &bquo;You are creature great, and I am creature small.&equo; 
 Then, years later &mdash; and she takes after the tall side of the family &mdash; she said, &bquo;Now I am creature great, and you are creature small.&equo; 
 That's what the letters stand for &mdash; C.S. at the beginning, and C.G. at the end.&equo; 
 I thought of Celia. 
 How could a person have written as off-handedly, as cruelly, as she had done, yet still be able to add those cryptic letters, relic of a loving bond? 
 Was it possible that the letter had been written simply that Aunt Louise might use it as use it she had? 
 For the first time I realized that Celia would know  all about me from my letters to Aunt Louise. 
 She would understand that since my father's death there had been, as it were, a vacancy in my home which, with careful management, her wayward mother might come to fill, secure within the bonds of kinship. 
 Worse, might not Aunt Louise herself have known of the plan and have colluded in it, so that Celia might escape, freed of responsibility, into a new life abroad? 
 The bubble, that frail bubble which had seemed to float above us, invisible symbol of the understanding and trust which was to have helped us to live together, shuddered and sank; then bravely rose again into the air, though not now quite as high as before. 
 Every week we went shopping to the town, taking a bus from the bottom of the hill: it did not seem quite safe to leave Aunt Louise and the fire together alone. 
 In any case, although the outing was not easy for her she enjoyed it, and stepped out manfully. 
 One evening we went to a play &mdash; a stage production of an Agatha Christie thriller performed by a local concert group. 
 It was cold that night and Aunt Louise wore her fur coat and fur hat. 
 &bquo;You look lovely,&equo; I said. 
 She did, glowing with anticipation as she was. 
 Approaching the village hall we saw quite a crowd  outside, and while we waited more and more people joined us. 
 &bquo;Oh dear,&equo; whispered Aunt Louise. 
 &bquo;Will there be enough room do you think? 
 Suppose we can't get in.&equo; 
 She looked up at me out of the corner of her eye and lowered her voice. 
 &bquo;Shall I faint, dear? 
 Shall I scream?&equo; 
 &bquo;They are good to old people here; we  shall probably get in if no one else does. 
 We  shall probably be put in front.&equo; 
 &bquo;Old? 
 I am only sixty-four! 
 Sixty-four isn't old.&equo; 
 &bquo;Nearer eighty-four; eighty-four is.&equo; 
 &bquo;Eighty-four!&equo; she giggled. 
 &bquo;How time flies. 
 One forgets.&equo; 
 In fact we were put right in the front row, and Aunt Louise graced her position perfectly; her evident enjoyment and generous (though ladylike) applause could not, I felt, have been without its encouragement to the players. 
 &bquo;Did you like it?&equo; 
 I asked, as we plodded back up the hill, she clinging to my arm, pausing now and then for breath. 
 &bquo;Did you think it worth the effort?&equo; 
 &bquo;Oh yes . 
 That man&hellip; who took the lead&hellip; how old do you think he was?&hellip; 
 I would say&hellip; he was about sixty-four, wouldn't you?&equo; 
 We stopped for her to regain her breath, then, &bquo;I ask because there seemed a sort of affinity between us. 
 It almost&hellip; seemed to me&hellip; in the end, that he was&hellip; playing just for me.&equo; 
 Again we paused, although now we were over the worst stretch of hill. 
 &bquo;Did you notice how his eyes were on me almost  right through the performance? 
 Is he a local man?&hellip; 
 Do you know him?&equo; 
 &bquo;I don't know him, but I expect he comes from somewhere round here,&equo; I said. 
 After this she began paying even more attention than usual to her appearance. 
 She had always taken a long time over her toilet: a review of her clothes; a long-drawn-out bath; massage; manicure; then her hair and make-up. 
 Now these routines seemed to take most of the morning, and after lunch and a little rest she sallied forth for a walk. 
 At first I had suggested that I should keep her company but she dismissed the idea at once: &bquo;I am not a child, and I refuse to be treated as one&equo;, and I guessed she wanted to be alone rather as a young girl might who sets out to post an imaginary letter, hoping to meet on the way the person for whom she has made herself beautiful. 
 She did seem to meet quite a number of people on her walks; people whom I knew a little, so that fragments of conversation pursued me. 
 &bquo;We hope you don't mind our saying this, but do you think it wise to let Mrs Ross go out alone at her age when she is not used to living in the country? 
 We wondered if you realized that she walks right in the middle of the road; some visitors do, you know, thinking there is no traffic here. 
 When we see her we are so afraid she might get run over or lost.&equo; 
 I wanted to say that it was not a question of &bquo;letting&equo; Aunt Louise do anything; I wanted to say I should like to  see anyone trying to stop her from doing anything she had set her heart on. 
 All I could think of was to give a sickly smile and to murmur, &bquo;I think you are probably right.&equo; 
 And then (with a curious scrutiny of my face), &bquo;Mrs Ross and I had quite a long chat the other afternoon. 
 She has had a very  interesting life, hasn't she?&equo; 
 And, &bquo;I said to Mrs Ross, &bquo;but it is your niece's house &equo;&hellip; 
 ' Whatever could Aunt Louise have been saying? 
 Was the speaker trying to tell me something or was I in the first stages of paranoia? 
 It was particularly cold that winter; snow was whipped into drifts by a biting wind, making Aunt Louise's walks impossible. 
 Soon the curtains were drawn by four o'clock and there were days when the mist and rain so muffled the sounds of the world outside that there was almost complete silence. 
 And as the feeling of isolation deepened, so did Aunt Louise grow more and more irritable and hard-done-by. 
 &bquo;Which is the coldest room in the house, would you say?&equo; 
 &bquo;The bathroom; it faces north and east.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, my bedroom! 
 I hung my thermometer on the wall, and do you know what it registered?&equo; 
 (It was indeed a very low reading.) 
 &bquo;I did say you would be cold if you came to live with me, but you said you wouldn't mind. 
 You said all you wanted was a roof over your head.&equo; 
 She had also said she  would not be lonely and dull, but I knew she was; far from shops and with no companionship but mine. 
 I had invited everyone I could think of to tea, and we had been invited back, but it was not her style, and when she complained that it was not right for her &bquo;to be living among all these old people&equo; I understood very well what she meant. 
 &bquo;&hellip; and why can't you make the fire up properly!&equo; 
 She turned on me a look so cold, so calculating, that I almost shrank from her. 
 &bquo;It wouldn't be very nice, would it, if I had to tell people that I had a mean niece.&equo; 
 Mean! 
 Was I really mean? 
 How did one know. 
 A mean niece. 
 How could she have brought herself to think such a thing, let alone put it into words &mdash; let alone threaten me! 
 Did she not understand that she had no need to fight me, to defend herself from me ? 
 Did she not understand that I would look after her, that 1 would see to it that she was safe and well? 
 That I was her friend, not her enemy. 
 (I remembered an evening, almost bedtime, when the coal in the scuttle had been very low. 
 She had suggested that I should go and fill it, but there had been ice and snow outside, and darkness, and to reach the coal I should have to climb down into the concrete bunker. 
 &bquo;I'm afraid of slipping in the dark and cracking my head on the edge of the bunker,&equo; I had said. 
 &bquo;I did it once and it has made me afraid. 
 It is better if I wait until the morning when I can see what I am doing.&equo; 
 But she had insisted, and although the room was warm, and the kitchen stove had already been made up for the night, I had gone &mdash; yet  it was a strange experience to me, and rather a frightening one, to have been persuaded by someone near to me into doing even so small a thing I felt to be hazardous.) 
 Meanwhile, something had happened. 
 The delicate bubble which had seemed to my fanciful mind to float above us, had burst. 
 I woke one night to hear noises downstairs. 
 A cold draught of air was coming from the kitchen and I found the back door to be wide open &mdash; and then my horrified glance fell upon Aunt Louise. 
 She was standing outside, quite still, dressed only in her nightdress; her feet, misshapen with age, standing unprotected upon the frost-rimed path. 
 When I tried to lead her indoors she became indignant, shaking me off, &bquo;Do you call yourself my niece, trying to get me into a burning house!&equo; and it took me some time to persuade her that all was well. 
 From then on I began to interpret each nocturnal sound as a footstep or as a bolt sliding back, and in the misery of the night I turned round and round in bed, my nightdress winding itself tighter and tighter about me, while a little voice inside me complained, &bquo;I tried to do right, and now look what you've done to me. 
 She'll drive me dotty, and that won't help anybody.&equo;  
 Early one Sunday morning I decided to go to church. 
 Before I set out, I took Aunt Louise her usual breakfast cup full of hot tea. 
 I did not switch on the light in case it should dazzle her. 
 She came of a family whose heads felt cold in the night (their father had worn a nightcap) and now she rose to a sitting position looking, in the gloom, like some eastern potentate, her beautiful nose and high forehead all surmounted by what seemed to be a turban but was actually some sort of woolly garment skilfully disposed about her head. 
 I put the cup on the little table by the bed. 
 &bquo;I shan't be long,&equo; I whispered, &bquo;but if you want to start breakfast I have put it all ready and I have lit the fire.&equo; 
 &bquo;All right, dear.&equo; 
 &bquo;Goodbye, then.&equo; 
 As I dropped down the hill my spirits rose. 
 I felt so free! 
 The cold air (I thought) is like wine. 
 With fresh eyes I surveyed the familiar landscape. 
 How beautiful it was, how dear. 
 From outside, the church looked very old, and deserted, and I began to wonder why I had come; and I must have been a little late, because in the perfect stillness within, the members of the congregation already knelt &mdash; like statues, some caught in a swath of rainbow  light where the rising sun shone through a stained-glass window, splashing the bowed heads and bent shoulders with crimson, royal blue, emerald and gold. 
 Finding a seat to the back of the church I took a prayer book, and kneeling down began to find the place. 
 &bquo;Q. What meanest thou by this word Sacrament?&equo; 
 I read. 
 &bquo;A. I mean an outward and visible sign of an inward and spiritual grace&hellip; 
 &equo; It was not the Communion Service, it was the Catechism. 
 I turned the pages; but the top of the pew in front of me, upon which I was balancing the book, was narrow and my fingers cold. 
 The book fell to the floor with a loud bang. 
 At once the kneeling statues came to life. 
 Every head turned. 
 But quickly I retrieved the book, opened it anywhere, and balancing it firmly with both hands began industriously to read. 
 But no amount of reading from the prayer book gave me the comfort I sought. 
 Even when the clergyman appeared from the vestry and began the service, the prayers he intoned brought me no help. 
 Yet it was then that I knew why I had come, for just distinguishable to me against the background of reciting voices, I heard my own voice. 
 &bquo;O God,&equo; I was groaning, &bquo;deliver me from my aunt!&equo; 
 Then I saw Aunt Louise's body lying dead in the middle of the road. 
 No, not that! 
 There was nothing wrong with her that she was not born like.  
 A home? 
 But she wouldn't go, and in any case might she not be misunderstood, ill-treated, and all my fault? 
 &bquo;&hellip; with honour,&equo; I added (they were not, I realized, quite the right words but they were the nearest I could find in the urgency of the moment). 
 And then there came a nasty little uninvited unspoken voice which added wickedly, &bquo;If you can.&equo; 
 I had supposed that Aunt Louise would be in bed, but she met me at the door; opened it, in fact, and held it ready for me to come in, because there was something she was bursting to tell me: &bquo; I'm not staying in this cold place a day longer .&equo; 
 After I had left her she had spilt her cup of tea all over the bedclothes, which had soon become not only wet but cold and wet. 
 The fire in the living-room had gone out, and the kitchen stove was burning low. 
 Had not the echo of my prayer been upon me still, I should not have been ready. 
 I should have tried to comfort her, saying it would only be a month or two before spring came. 
 As it was, I answered promptly, &bquo;I think you are right. 
 If we could find a good home, you would at least be warm.&equo; 
 &bquo;I could never go into a home,&equo; she said. 
 But later I returned to the subject.  
 &bquo;I shall get used to it here in time,&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;No, things will get worse. 
 You will feel the cold even more when you can't get about as you do now, and you will be even more bored and lonely. 
 We should both be unhappy. 
 Tomorrow I will ring up and see how we should set about it.&equo; 
 A week later someone from the social services came to see us. 
 His manner was kind but official, and I could see that for some reason Aunt Louise distrusted him and was even a little afraid of him. 
 (Could she be worrying about her habit of giving her age as twenty years younger than it was?) 
 Whatever the cause, she answered his questions evasively and it seemed to me that she was making an impression she did not deserve. 
 (Look at your poor Little auntie. 
 What does she remind you of? 
 She reminds me of a small animal at bay. 
 And who is responsible for putting her into this position? 
 I am.) 
 But it made no difference. 
 After a while Aunt Louise retired and our visitor tidied his papers together and looked across at me. 
 &bquo;I am afraid there is no hope at all of your aunt getting into one of our homes,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;There are many old people much worse off. 
 Of course we should like to find room for everyone, but we just haven't the places. 
 I suppose, technically speaking,&equo; he paused, &bquo;if you put her out into the road she would have no roof over her  head and we should have to take her in.&equo; 
 ( Was he serious !) 
 &bquo;I could never do that to her,&equo; I said, &bquo;or perhaps I mean I could never do it to myself. 
 You don't know her. 
 She has a terrific sense of humour. 
 She would be in her element. 
 Her screams would be heard for miles around. 
 I should never live it down.&equo; 
 He rose from his chair, walked to the window, looked out, then came back to the table. 
 &bquo;I understand your difficulty well enough,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;It is the strain of living alone with someone who is no longer predictable. 
 But it is no good my holding out any hope that Mrs Ross can be found a place in one of our homes.&equo; 
 He began to put the papers into his case. 
 &bquo;Would it be possible, if I could get a job, to pay for her in a private home, with part of her pension added on? 
 Only I don't know how I should set about finding a home, let alone one that she would be happy in.&equo; 
 He came back to the table and sat down. 
 &bquo;There I might be able to help you. 
 We are always in touch with the private homes. 
 I could send you a list of vacancies, and mark any I thought might suit Mrs Ross and which I could vouch for. 
 &bquo;But you wouldn't have to hang about. 
 You would have to go and see the home right away. 
 I might give you a name one day and the next day the vacancy would be filled. 
 &bquo;There is another thing. 
 It is no good shilly-shallying. 
 Assuming that you have found a place, and that you  are both satisfied; has your aunt a key to your door? 
 If she has, you must have the lock changed. 
 Otherwise she might have some little upset, jump into a taxi, and you would find her here when you got home from work. 
 Things might be even more difficult then than they are now.&equo; 
 He picked up his case and walked towards the door. 
 &bquo;Don't worry,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;If you can get a job and we can find Mrs Ross a suitable home, I think she will probably be happier where there is more life going on around her.&equo; 
 Looking back, I realize how fortunate we were in finding the place we did. 
 It was in a small town which had once enjoyed fame as the home of a well-known poet and his friends but which, because of its geographical position, time seemed to have passed by. 
 Now the caf&eacute;s in the quiet, tree-lined High Street were a little shabby, and the handsome Georgian houses taken over as bank premises, solicitors, offices, and old people's homes. 
 But the home looked directly out upon the life of the High Street and seemed clean and well-run, although its appointments and furnishings by no means matched the magnificent brass door-knocker or the gracious proportions of the house itself. 
 Later, when I came to ask Aunt Louise about the food, she had seemed satisfied: &bquo;Country food; good plain country food.&equo;  
 The vacancy must be filled within three days, and for those three days Aunt Louise berated me almost without pause. 
 I try now to remember what that outpouring of words was about, it must have been about something. 
 At the time all I could think was, three days &mdash; anyone can put up with anything for three days. 
 Then it was only two days, then just one day more. 
 It was with the end in sight, the last evening, as we were sorting out which of her possessions she should take and which I should try to sell for her, that I started to cry; and cried and cried and cried. 
 It is strange how we struggle to hold back tears as if our very lives depended upon it; yet there is nothing like tears &mdash; that is, genuine tears, genuinely struggled against &mdash; to bring people down to earth; for now, and at once, Aunt Louise became real: a motherly, rational, human being. 
 &bquo;Don't cry, dear,&equo; she said, putting an arm round my shoulders, &bquo;it is not your fault. 
 You have been a good friend to me when there was no one else; and you have given me back my health. 
 I shan't forget that. 
 Now I'm going to be a good girl. 
 Let's go to bed, and finish this in the morning.&equo; 
 I was not accompanying her to the home but was treating her to a taxi all the way. 
 It would have been too chancy and too tiring a journey for her to have taken by the complicated network of bus connections, with its many waits, and there was her luggage. 
 As I followed her up the pathway, every inch of her  breathed that she was being a good girl, and as the driver settled her in the front seat beside him she gave him a happy smile; almost, one felt &mdash; seeing the hat-boxes and cases piled up behind them &mdash; they might have been starting out on their honeymoon. 
 Rather to the surprise of my new employers, since I had been so eager to work for them, I told them I should not be able to start for a fortnight (I needed to recover, being exhausted by my burden of guilt). 
 More than a year passed. 
 When I visited Aunt Louise there was just time for us to have a meal in one of the High Street caf&eacute;s before I caught the bus home. 
 She looked well but was somewhat on her dignity. 
 (I learned later that she had thought I had put her into some kind of charitable institution &mdash; a sort of workhouse. 
 I had forgotten to tell her it was a &bquo;paid for&equo; home.) 
 She told me she made a point of taking a walk each day to get out of the way of all the old people, but I was reassured when I saw that she was well-known at the caf&eacute; and seemed to have several friends among its patrons. 
 About this time it was announced that pensioners whose means were insufficient to pay their rent were to have the amount made up by social security allowances even if they were living in a private home, so with a light heart I set about making application. 
 I had been paying the fees of the home a month in advance, but when explaining about the social security payments, I sent two months' fees in advance to cover, as  I thought, any delay. 
 It seems to me now that I must have been more than a little simple, because I received a telephone call from the home the very next day. 
 They were, they said, returning Aunt Louise at once. 
 They had in any case been considering asking me to remove her, as she had caused them quite a lot of trouble in one way and another. 
 I think I was then as near to hysteria as I have been in the whole of my life. 
 I put down the receiver and sat on the stairs trembling with panic, and I think I must have become pale, because I remember that my face felt very cold. 
 I would run away. 
 I would lock my door and go right away and tell no one where I was. 
 After a while I became calmer; then the postman came, and the milkman, and life became more normal. 
 At last, I picked up the directory and began to look for the telephone number of a solicitor. 
 During the next few days I lived in terror, doors locked, ready to fly &mdash; to leave through the front door if Aunt Louise came to the back, or out of the back door if I saw her coming down the path. 
 Then the telephone rang. 
 It was the social security man, and recognizing his voice I braced myself for what he might say. 
 But he told me of a new home just completed, where Aunt Louise had been offered a place. 
 &bquo;You have  behaved marvellously,&equo; he said, &bquo;and now we are taking the responsibility for Mrs Ross off your hands.&equo; 
 You have behaved marvellously . 
 Afterwards I indulged myself by repeating the words several times. 
 You have behaved marvellously . 
 Then, although I did not believe them for a moment, I stored them away in my memory against a rainy day. 
 As soon as I could I went to see Aunt Louise in her new home. 
 She was delighted with it. 
 She had a room to herself, and showed me her built-in dressing-table, wardrobe, and cupboards. 
 She said it was like living in a good hotel. 
 &bquo;It is a council home,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;It was the other one which was a private home.&equo; 
 &bquo;I know, dear, they told me. 
 I had been doing you an injustice; but I am going to make a will leaving you all I have. 
 &bquo;Do you know, three times a week a nurse comes, and helps me to bath myself! 
 I don't mind; it is rather like being a little girl again. 
 &bquo;And now, there is something I haven't shown you &mdash; the best of all.&equo; 
 She drew aside the curtain of a small window and stood back for me to see the picture thus revealed. 
 In the distance, above the offices and blocks of flats, soared Windsor Castle, silver-grey in the sunshine which was about to dispel the morning mist. 
 And from the round tower floated a standard. 
 &bquo;The  Queen,&equo; said Aunt Louise proudly. 
 &bquo;She's in residence today, I see.&equo; 
 All the way home I was so happy; everything had been worth while, everything was going to be all right. 
 However, less than a month later, I received a telephone call from the home. 
 Mrs Ross&equo; s condition had deteriorated; she had fallen out of bed and it seemed she might have suffered a further stroke. 
 It had been necessary to transfer her to hospital, the home being equipped only for residents able to look after themselves. 
 The hospital was a vast conglomeration of grim buildings, some Victorian, some additions of a later date, surrounded by well-trodden grass, conventional flowerbeds, and the usual dusty evergreen shrubs. 
 Later, habit was to help me to find Aunt Louise with the assurance of a homing pigeon; now, hesitant of asking the way (being unable to read on the faces of those I encountered whether they were patients or helpers), I had great difficulty in finding the right building; and then &mdash; up ill-lit stone staircases and along corridors &mdash; in finding the ward to which I had been directed. 
 I found her in a large day-room where groups of elderly ladies sat in plastic-covered armchairs. 
 Along one side of the room was a row of doors where nurses and helpers appeared and disappeared like actors on a stage  set. 
 There was a dining area, with small tables, and beyond I glimpsed a further ward; and through an open door a dormitory where there were rows of beds, each with its flowered nylon eiderdown. 
 I looked along a line of patients and recognized a back still straight and a head still proudly held. 
 Aunt Louise's eyes were over-bright and she tried to pass her hand across them as if to brush away a cobweb. 
 &bquo;I saw Celia on the other side of the road and ran across to her. 
 I think I must have been knocked down by a car.&equo; 
 Because of the distance of my journey I had been given permission to come during the morning, and there were no other visitors. 
 My signal to go was when a helper began to lay the tables with cutlery. 
 Usually Aunt Louise would seem to be asleep, or not to realize I was there. 
 Then I would sit beside her putting into her mouth one by one the marshmallows I had brought. 
 She accepted them without opening her eyes. 
 When I asked if there was anything she would like me to bring, she shook her head. 
 In all the time she was there she asked for only two things, and in both cases I had to disappoint her. 
 One was acid drops. 
 I knew the ones she meant; she meant the square transparent boiled sweets which when she was a child would have been weighed out in pennyworths from a tall glass jar, but although I searched in grocers&equo; shops and sweet shops high and low, all I could find were wrapped oval-shaped acid drops. 
 These I knew  well were not what her whim had remembered, and when I brought them to her she said nothing, but put them aside, sadly shaking her head. 
 On another day when I asked the question, she began slowly and with difficulty to lift the skirts of her dress, revealing bare knees. 
 Higher and higher the shaking hand pushed the skirts until I saw that she was wearing a pair of white calico drawers, and remembering the black lace French knickers with their little rosebud trimmings, I understood. 
 But it was hopeless. 
 The white calico drawers would be standard wear, laundered all together, and I knew, having realized that none of the patients wore their dental plates, that there was no place here for black lace with rosebuds &mdash; nor if I brought them would they be long in her possession. 
 Her companions did not always remain seated. 
 Sometimes one or other would roam round the room picking things up, examining them and putting them down again; or looking with unfocused eyes at nothing at all. 
 One of them would come and talk to me as I sat beside Aunt Louise, and discuss her with me as if she were a child. 
 &bquo;Here, have a mouthful of this.&equo; 
 She was holding a can of lemonade and pushed the straw into Aunt Louise's mouth. 
 Politely Aunt Louise took a mouthful and inclined her head in thanks. 
 &bquo;She thinks you are my little girl,&equo; I said as the patient wandered off.  
 &bquo;I know; sometimes I feel as if I should like to knock all their heads together.&equo; 
 But her voice was tolerant, almost sisterly. 
 On a wet day, eyeing the lanes of traffic before crossing to the hospital, I caught my toe in a paving-stone and fell fiat. 
 From my audience (a solid queue of cars waiting bumper to bumper at a side road) there came a sort of gasp or groan. 
 Clumsily, like a fallen horse righting itself, I scrambled to my feet, gathered up the bananas, marshmallows, umbrella, thermos, handbag, and other possessions which had fallen or rolled around me and, waving reassuringly, I walked briskly away (ignoring a warm stream which was beginning to flow from an enormous hole in one knee of my tights). 
 &bquo;Whatever's that!&equo; 
 A passing nurse had noticed the blood as I sat at Aunt Louise's side. 
 &bquo;It's just one of those grazes children get,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I tripped on a paving-stone. 
 It is quite all right; it is hardly noticeable under my mac.&equo; 
 &bquo;I shall have to get some water and clean it up; it is not the look of the thing, it is the infections.&equo; 
 She sat beside me and bathed and bandaged my knee but Aunt Louise made no sign that she realized what was going on. 
 &bquo;Their minds are like trains going along a track which here and there has a broken connection,&equo; said the nurse. 
 &bquo;Have you tried holding her hand?&equo;  
 &bquo;No, I don't think she would like that. 
 I think in her day people were more reserved, and she is rather proud.&equo; 
 &bquo;Try.&equo; 
 Gingerly I took one of Aunt Louise's hands and held it in mine. 
 &bquo; Take your clammy hands off me !&equo; growled a surprisingly wide-awake voice. 
 My hand sprang away as if electrified. 
 I felt rather hurt. 
 My hands are never clammy, and something told me that Aunt Louise knew very well who had touched her. 
 Soon the balding brown lawns seemed to decide that they had been brave long enough, and every dahlia in the flower-beds needed dead-heading. 
 In a little while the cold rains of winter would come; a few Christmas cards would appear on the window-sills in the ward, and there would be a token show of paper-chains. 
 Then the grass would recover and the flower-beds would be full of daffodils. 
 So the seasons passed, and Aunt Louise grew more sleepy and conversation almost impossible; it had been a limited conversation at best. 
 Every subject I could think of could be painful to her and in any case would be hard to sustain as a monologue. 
 Yet, I thought, it was necessary to speak, so that she could hear my voice &mdash; the family voice. 
 Might not some echo of it reach her mind, so that she would know someone of hers had been near; that she had not been deserted?  
 There was a drowsiness and calm about the ward, which I guessed was not the case at all times of the day. 
 The patients had all been washed and set up in their chairs and most of them seemed to be almost asleep. 
 I wondered sometimes if the effects of some sedative given perhaps the night before had not worn off completely by the time I came. 
 I had at my command a whole hour and a quarter, and I had my voice; but the words&hellip; 
 &bquo;It was very dark when I got up today,&equo; I began, trying to speak distinctly but without raising my voice. 
 &bquo;I thought I would wear my thick coat because it might be cold waiting for the bus and it would stand up to the rain. 
 I was a little late, so I ran all down the hill&hellip; &bquo; 
 Aunt Louise sat impassive, eyes closed, mind apparently far away, but the area of the ward surrounding us had become very quiet, my voice superseding with ease that of the television which, as usual, was droning away unnoticed in its corner. 
 Everyone within earshot was listening, eyes concentrated on mine, heads bent forward &mdash; but what did it matter in this little world of shadows where all barriers were down. 
 So I continued. 
 &bquo;There is a man halfway down the hill who catches the bus to go to work. 
 When he saw me running he thought he must be late, and he started to run, too. 
 We both got there in plenty of time. 
 &bquo;I found a good place on the bus, on the top deck, right at the front, where you can feel the warmth coming up through a grating&equo; (here and there a head nodded  understandingly) &bquo;and see the view. 
 When I changed buses there was just time to get the sweets and bananas &mdash; the bananas were very good today; and on the other bus there was a nice driver who said that if I sat near the front he would let me off at the crossing if he was held up in the traffic, instead of my going on to the bus stop and having to walk back; because of the rain.&equo; 
 The listening faces were attentive, but I was beginning to run out of words&hellip; 
 &bquo;All the people waiting at the bus stops were shrivelled up with the cold; they looked so miserable standing there but cheered up when they saw us coming along. 
 They got on the bus puffing and blowing but happy to be inside in the warm, and sat in their own special places. 
 They are nearly always the same people and they nearly always sit in the same places. 
 Probably when I am on the bus I am sitting in someone's special place. 
 &bquo;Every single passenger on the bus was dressed differently: Marks &amp; Spencer's hats, head-scarves, hoods, old felt hats, caps, but all different. 
 Boots, high-heeled shoes, trousers, long skirts, short skirts, macs, anoraks &mdash; everyone dressed up to keep warm and every one different.&equo; 
 The faces were thoughtful, but I was getting desperate. 
 &bquo;A man sat next to me,&equo; I said. 
 My audience stiffened, and I paused. 
 &bquo;He tried to make conversation but I just smiled and went on reading my book.&equo;  
 &bquo;Quite right.&equo; 
 Aunt Louise had the vocal range of the born actress and was now using a deep (though soft) organ note. 
 &bquo;Kind, yes; kind always. 
 But firm!&equo; 
 Perhaps the train in Aunt Louise's mind had jumped back on to the rail for a while because it was then, in quite a conversational voice, that she began to speak of her daughter. 
 &bquo;It's a pity about Celia, isn't it,&equo; she said, opening her eyes. 
 A pity? 
 &bquo;Would you like me to try to get in touch with her?&equo; 
 She shook her head. 
 &bquo;It would be no good.&equo; 
 &bquo;I could try.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, it would be no good.&equo; 
 &bquo;Perhaps she will be happier with this new man.&equo; 
 Aunt Louise peered at me from almost sightless eyes. 
 &bquo;New man?&equo; she said. 
 &bquo;What new man? 
 She's perfectly happy with the man she's got.&equo; 
 &bquo;I thought&hellip; 
 &equo; But Aunt Louise had closed her eyes and was pretending to be asleep. 
 Visiting her had become part of my life but I knew it would not always be so; twice I had been summoned to the hospital when she had seemed to be failing. 
 In the absence of anyone more nearly related I had been designated next-of-kin, and now I wrote to the Court of Protection who had been dealing with her affairs, asking what my responsibilities would be if she died. 
 I was surprised to hear that their involvement would end with her  death. 
 I was also surprised to hear that during the last few days her Premium Bond had won &pound;5,000. 
 Running on again, my thoughts paused at Aunt Louise's grave. 
 Not here, surely, among strangers: yet where now was she not a stranger? 
 Where she had been born? 
 Where she had grown up? 
 There, I learned, the churchyard was closed to burials, although her ashes might be interred &mdash; not in her parents' grave as I had asked &mdash; but in the church's garden of remembrance. 
 Now my mind's eye saw Aunt Louise's little resting place: but the inscription? 
 Laura Louise Ross Born: Died: 
 &bquo;All things bright and beautiful; 
 All creatures great and small; 
 All things wise and wonderful; 
 The Lord God made them all.&equo; 
 Then I saw another picture: a very old woman (it was Celia) searching for the grave of the mother she had abandoned, and coming upon that inscription. 
 It would not do&hellip; 
 Aunt Louise died early one morning having, as people say, passed away in her sleep. 
 I was called to the administration block of the hospital and later went to register  the death, and to make an appointment with an undertaker &mdash; this was for ten o'clock the next morning. 
 I arrived in good time and was shown into a small living-room where a clothes-horse, hung with baby clothes, stood steaming before an electric fire. 
 The undertaker, his wife said, had been called out. 
 Time went by until a whole hour had passed but it was restful sitting there in the homely room with its smell of damp wool. 
 A second hour went by, while little by little I abandoned hope first of one bus connection, and then of another, until there were footsteps and a small thin man hurried in, pushing back the strands of hair which had plastered themselves across his forehead. 
 &bquo;Sorry, sorry to be late.&equo; 
 He sank into a chair. 
 He looked absolutely exhausted. 
 &bquo;I've had a terrible morning. 
 A whole family, five of them, killed in a car crash.&equo; 
 &bquo;How dreadful !&equo; 
 He looked up, studying my face, &bquo;All black,&equo; he said, as if to comfort me. 
 Then quickly, again reading my expression, &bquo;All God's children, of course, just the same as we all are, but travelling on the wrong side of the road &mdash; not used to the traffic.&equo; 
 It was a still, autumn day when the cremation took place. 
 Leaves were falling but the sun shone, and I could not help enjoying the ride, so stately in the funeral limousine. 
 Nor could I shake off a feeling that Aunt Louise was sitting beside me, enjoying it too.  
 After the ceremony the clergyman came out and shook hands with me, offering sympathy. 
 &bquo;Had she no children?&equo; 
 &bquo;She had a daughter and two grandsons, but they were estranged.&equo; 
 &bquo;How sad. 
 How very sad.&equo; 
 I think he meant it, he seemed a kind man. 
 &bquo;Perhaps in the end she was not sorry to go.&equo; 
 I thought of Aunt Louise as I had seen her last, sitting upright in her plastic-covered armchair. 
 &bquo;I don't think it would have occurred to her to want to die,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;She had not had an easy life, especially towards the end, but the impression she always gave was of courage. 
 He nodded. 
 &bquo;I have wondered sometimes whether the strength we gain while fighting our troubles is not given to aid us when our time comes.&equo; 
 He stood, looking thoughtfully at the ground; then, coming to himself, he shook hands once again. 
 &bquo;Well, I must say goodbye, Mrs&hellip; 
 Mrs&hellip;&equo;, and he hurried away. 
 The solicitor I had consulted talked of power of attorney. 
 &bquo;Before we begin, do everything you can to trace the daughter. 
 Perhaps there is an old address book. 
 Work through every address, however unlikely. 
 It may be necessary to advertise but it is my experience that relatives have a way of surfacing after a death.&equo; 
 I began with Celia's old address in Scotland. 
 A pleasant, man's voice answered the telephone.  
 &bquo;I wonder if you could help me,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;Does a Mr Elmore still live at that address, please?&equo; 
 &bquo;Speaking.&equo; 
 Celia's husband. 
 I could hardly believe it, and said the first thing that came into my head. 
 &bquo;The Mr Elmore who had a lot of difficulty with his mother-in-law some time ago?, 
 &bquo;Yes, indeed.&equo; 
 &bquo;Mrs Ross has died. 
 I am her niece, and there is the question of a small sum of money. 
 Have you any idea at all, can you give me even the slightest clue, as to where her daughter might be?&equo; 
 &bquo;She is in the garden,&equo; said the voice. 
 &bquo;Shall I get her for you?, 
 &bquo; In the garden ? 
 In your garden? 
 I understood she was missing. 
 I understood she had remarried and had gone abroad.&equo; 
 There was a silence, then: &bquo;I think there must be some misunderstanding.&equo; 
 &bquo;But I understood she had left you and her children and had gone abroad.&equo; 
 He laughed. 
 &bquo;You have been misinformed.&equo; 
 &bquo;No. 
 I have Mrs Ross's papers before me, including a letter from her daughter saying she had left you and her children, had found another man, and was going abroad. 
 She gave no address and said she could do nothing more to help her mother. 
 And I understood from the hospital where Mrs Ross has been a patient that before she was admitted enquiries were made and you wrote back &mdash;  supposedly in your wife's absence &mdash; saying you had no idea where your wife was and you did not want to hear about her mother or to see her.&equo; 
 There was a long silence. 
 Then, at last, &bquo;Oh that.&equo; 
 &bquo;Do you mean to say that Mrs Ross's daughter never left you and her children? &mdash; that she has been with you all the time and is still your wife?&equo; 
 &bquo;Well, yes&hellip; but let me get Celia.&equo; 
 &bquo;It is not necessary. 
 She will hear from Mrs Ross's solicitor. 
 There is enough money to cover the cremation and any other expenses. 
 There is no need for me to speak to Celia,&equo; and I rang off. 
 Afterwards I sat for a long time trying to reconcile myself to these new ideas. 
 How like Aunt Louise, and how like her daughter. 
 They had run circles round me. 
 All my moilings and toilings over Aunt Louise! 
 During the next few weeks the thoughts continued to come and go. 
 How much of the plan had Aunt Louise understood? 
 Had even Mrs Girdlestone known about it? 
 It might have been easy for Celia to persuade herself that it would all make little difference to me. 
 Even if she could not have so persuaded herself it would have made no difference . 
 Who should understand that better than I. 
 At least Celia's marriage seemed to have been saved. 
 She could not have had an easy childhood. 
 It would have been sad if her marriage, also, had been sacrificed. 
 One thing I could do, and I did it. 
 I sent Celia a bill for everything, as far as I could remember, Aunt Louise had  cost in money. 
 There would be change enough from her &pound;5,000 after the funeral expenses had been paid, and I felt a little better after that. 
 Christmas was coming round again, and one morning two little girls stood on my doorstep. 
 They handed me a cardboard plate on which was an apple, a slice of cake, and some homemade toffee. 
 They wished me a happy Christmas then stood waiting, eyeing me curiously, till I understood. 
 Without noticing it, while I was looking the other way, I had become old; so old that I was an &bquo;old lady&equo;, known as such at the village school. 
 Under their teacher's guidance little hands had struggled &mdash; arranging, rearranging, fingering &mdash; plates such as this, to remember, and to show love for, the aged at Christmas-time. 
 The little girls were still watching me, now rather doubtfully, I thought, so with a mighty effort I changed my whole concept of what I was, in order to respond. 
 I was an old lady, a very old lady. 
 I smiled, benignly I hoped, wondering about laying a hand on head or shoulder but fearing I might not be able to carry it off. 
 Then, more naturally, I smiled again, thanked them, admired the present &mdash; asking if they had made the toffee themselves &mdash; and wished them, too, a very happy Christmas. 
 Perhaps I had managed to fulfil their expectations, because their faces became less watchful and they smiled, and said goodbye before walking primly up the path &mdash; to  burst out into the sunshine and race each other down the hill. 
 Such is the power of suggestion that that night as I neared the top of the staircase, my foot stumbled on the last step but one. 
 It is old age, I thought. 
 It is no good pretending. 
 I have got old while I was not looking. 
 I will grow old gracefully, as we are advised; and as I made ready for the night I tried to see myself as the little girls must have seen me. 
 The next morning, about nine o'clock, there came another knock at the door. 
 It was the taxi-man. 
 &bquo;It's all right, my dear,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;I'm a bit early. 
 Take your time, don't hurry yourself.&equo; 
 I thanked him but with some embarrassment. 
 I had not, in fact, ordered a taxi. 
 &bquo;It was your name. 
 Nine o'clock for someone to be taken to &mdash;&equo; (It was the day-care centre for the very old &mdash; those no longer able to manage for themselves.) 
 I was horrified, and must have shown it. 
 &bquo;But you know me,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;You can't, you can't  think&hellip; &bquo; 
 He looked down and shuffled his feet. 
 &bquo;Well, it was your name. 
 I thought you might have someone staying here. 
 It was your name.&equo; 
 &bquo; It must have been the other one! 
 The one who lives at the end of the village. 
 It must have been the other one.&equo; 
 We were both immensely relieved. 
 When he had gone I remembered the Christmas plate. 
 The cake I had eaten (thoughtfully, and in the true spirit) had been meant for someone no longer able to  make cake for herself; the apple for someone who no longer had a garden. 
 The toffee, too, had been intended for another. 
 And that night I fairly bounded up the stairs. 
 There was still time.  
 The Councillor  
 HAVE noticed that any old grandad who can prop himself up on a spade can dig better than I can, and it does seem that although women have virtues not given to men, men also have their gifts. 
 I think my brother-in-law was summoned to the help of Mrs McLaren, when she fell into the brook one dark morning, because he was a parish councillor. 
 It was known, also, that the old lady had been friendly with his mother; and anyway, being a bachelor and retired, he could usually be counted on to take sufferers to hospital in emergency, or bring them home; as well as visiting murderers in prison, and other tasks (often called do-gooding by people who have never been remotely in need of that particular little world). 
 I learned afterwards that Mrs McLaren was in the habit of getting up and going to bed so early that night was confused with day; and having an idea that she must get a message to the man who did her garden, she had gone out before it was light, lost her way, and fallen into the brook, where she was found by a man walking to work. 
 When from the kitchen window I had seen my brother-in-law the councillor walking slowly down the path arm-in-arm with Mrs McLaren, it was the strangest, the most unlikely sight I could possibly have imagined.  
 Strange, because he, an elderly bachelor, dry and very conventional, seemed perfectly composed, as if it were the most natural thing in the world that Mrs McLaren's white hair should be hanging about her shoulders, and that she was naked to the waist, showing all her poor sad bosom, her clothes hanging from her sodden with water. 
 Unlikely, because Mrs McLaren had taught in school for many years &mdash; the school at which her husband, when alive, had been headmaster. 
 (&bquo;You children are very lucky,&equo; he would say, &bquo;having two certificated teachers in one school.&equo;) 
 Handing her over to me, all my brother-in-law had said was, &bquo;I will try to be back by six o'clock. 
 I will ring you.&equo; 
 It was then about half-past eight. 
 I found it helpful that Mrs McLaren behaved as naturally (or perhaps as unnaturally) as her companion had done. 
 She talked cheerfully in her usual bright, slightly authoritative teacher's way about the weather, without the slightest loss of dignity. 
 I led her upstairs, took off her wet clothes, bathed and dried her; she accepting my ministrations automatically, as if she were a child and I her mother. 
 Then I dressed her up in some things of my own (oh, so much too big!). 
 The tights, very long in the leg, were quite a problem, hanging round her ankles in great folds however hard I tried to keep them up, and settling into the enormous-seeming bedroom slippers to make walking dangerous. 
 Her hair was difficult to get right; there were hairpins and little  nets, but I managed somehow, and downstairs we went. 
 I had lit a fire, and the room was very cheerful with the sun shining in. 
 We had coffee, talked of the gardens and of plants difficult to grow in chalky soil &mdash; but nothing personal was said on either side, nor any thought of how she happened to be with me. 
 Afterwards she came into the kitchen while I washed her clothes and hung them on a bush in the garden to dry &mdash; and there was nothing in our words or manner to suggest that all this was not quite ordinary and everyday. 
 I showed her the garden, and we chose and cut a cabbage, which I cooked, and we had lunch. 
 It was such a bright sunny day that there was quite a holiday feeling in the air. 
 By that time her clothes were dry, and we brought them in and I ironed them and hung them in the sun again, this time to air. 
 Then I undressed her, and dressed her up in her own clothes, she acquiescent as a little child, talking all the time about the snowdrops, and how the days were beginning to draw out &mdash; and everything except people, and the circumstances in which we found ourselves. 
 Soon it was tea-time. 
 We had both had quite a happy day; but as the sun began to creep round to the west and to decline, I had a feeling of unease. 
 Conversation was lagging, and it seemed to me that Mrs McLaren was tiring and might lose confidence.  
 Almost to the minute, the telephone rang. 
 My brother-in-law had managed to fix things up, he said, and would come right away. 
 Was Mrs McLaren ready? 
 He came in and stood waiting, hat in one hand, the other arm crooked ready for Mrs McLaren. 
 He had done well that day &mdash; almost performed miracles &mdash; having located Mrs McLaren's Scottish relations; persuaded a most excellent and locally well-known lady to come at short notice and be in the house to stay with her; and had seen to it that the house itself was tidied, and cleaned ready, and supplied with food. 
 Now, however, for the first time, Mrs McLaren asserted herself. 
 She smiled, shook her head, and in a voice which gave no room for argument said, &bquo;Oh no. 
 I am staying here .&equo; 
 Left to myself I might have tried to persuade, to plead, to wheedle, to say how nice it was going to be at home. 
 My brother-in-law the councillor said nothing, just stood looking down at her; and in his eyes was just the right mixture of kindliness and a sort of authority; and something else &mdash; a twinkle, a you-and-me-having-a-little-joke-together look. 
 Did she see then, in that look, the son she never had? 
 Or her dead husband? 
 Or even her father? 
 Whoever it was she saw, she smiled up at him, rising to her feet without a word and taking his arm. 
 Then together they walked out into the garden and up the path.  
 the Kiss  
 SOME families are more given to kissing than others; one sees them at railway stations kissing a whole carriage-full of friends as they prepare to say goodbye. 
 Ours is not a kissing family &mdash; that is, what one might call social kissing; but there was one person I always kissed, my husband's Aunt Nesta. 
 I kissed her for the last time as she lay in her hospital bed: the bedclothes were crisp and undisturbed, and she looked very clean, just as she would have wanted to; and very small, because she was so old, and having started life none too big had ended up, at the age of ninety-one, not much bigger than a child. 
 Her face was still something of the colour of a ripe apple, and her silvery hair shone with cleanliness as did the pink scalp beneath it. 
 Two people sat at her bedside in the little cubicle contained by the screens. 
 I had never seen them before; relatives summoned from the north of the country, perhaps. 
 They greeted me without enthusiasm &mdash; even with suspicion, I thought &mdash; and the woman said, &bquo;She's well away, as you can see.&equo; 
 Yes, I could tell from Aunt Nessy's breathing that she would not recover consciousness; nevertheless,  before I crept out I did kiss her, just in case some little part of her, still aware, should feel it. 
 In fact, in this moment of her departing I was irrelevant, the couple sitting beside her even more so. 
 The one person who should have been with her was absent, having (as Aunt Nessy had told me some years before in bewilderment, and with a valiantly suppressed trembling of the lip) written to say that she never wanted to see her again. 
 &bquo;Could Beatrice perhaps be getting a bit old in herself,&equo; I had suggested, &bquo;or could it perhaps be something to do with the accident she had as a child?&equo; 
 Aunt Nessy had been one of those children who, in the days of large families, had been given away to elderly childless relatives to be brought up as a kind of maid-of-all-work and as an insurance against old age; and what had upset her most when the parting came was having to leave her youngest sister, Beatrice, on whom she had lavished the mother-love within her &mdash; birthright of the children she was destined never to conceive. 
 &bquo;She was such a beautiful little baby; and because things were a bit easier by the time she came along she was always dressed in pretty clothes, not second-hand things and hand-me-downs as we were. 
 &bquo;Then one day my mother dropped her! 
 She fell on her head and was unconscious for a long time. 
 My mother was beside herself and after that, although she  still almost worshipped her, she was afraid even to hold her up or lift her, so I had all the care of her. 
 &bquo;She was a beautiful child, too, and tall &mdash; not like the rest of us. 
 She was like a little princess in the family; my mother gave in to her in everything and she had whatever she fancied. 
 People thought her spoilt, I know, but it was not her fault.&equo; 
 In the course of time Aunt Nessy, having looked after her adoptive parents until they died, was left a small sum of money. 
 She rented shop premises &mdash; run-down, and modest in size, but in a handy position &mdash; and opened a sweet shop. 
 Unable at first to afford even a bed, she slept behind the shop on a sack filled with paper straw from the empty sweet boxes. 
 Perhaps because she was a bright, good-hearted little person, her business prospered. 
 Once a year she went to Scarborough for a week. 
 &bquo;I was so tired by that time that all I could do was sit in a deck-chair on the sea-front and sleep all day, but it was enough.&equo; 
 After the First World War she added ice-cream to her stock-in-trade, and soon she was able to buy the shop outright. 
 Later she branched out, taking on another carefully chosen establishment, with two assistants, and a penny-in-the-slot music machine &mdash; forerunner of the juke box. 
 By the time she was fifty she was in a position to fulfil her life's ambition: to sell up, go south, and buy a little house about ten miles from Beatrice (&bquo;near, but not  too near&equo;). 
 Beatrice was married now, with a family of her own, and because times were hard her sister helped her with surreptitious gifts of money; and with clothes, toys, and treats for the children. 
 Meanwhile she lived the life of which she had dreamed. 
 She went to church, and cultivated herbs among the vegetables in her garden. 
 She planted the fruit trees and bushes she had always wanted, made her own bread, and experimented with such things as parsley jelly and mint tea, all to her heart's content. 
 Sometimes Beatrice would come to see her, bringing the children; and afterwards, when they had grown up, they would visit her still. 
 Later, my husband had taken me with him. 
 Then I went to see her alone. 
 Her house was always freezing cold in winter, although she did not seem to notice it. 
 She moved very lightly, and was always cheerful and very clean, with a rosy, deeply wrinkled face and big brown eyes. 
 One day as she tripped forward to greet me I had, without pausing to wonder if my embrace would be acceptable to her, bent down and kissed her. 
 I need not have worried. 
 Her response &mdash; such a lighting up of her face &mdash; made me remember how few times it was likely she had been kissed in her whole life: not as a child, by the parents who had given her away; not by her old foster parents; not often, I guessed, even by Beatrice and her boys. 
 So it was that every time I went to see her, she  would run forward and stand, head on one side, looking like a little robin, waiting for her kiss. 
 Sometimes she would be invited to her sister's house, but not too often now, because it must be admitted that with the passing of the years Aunt Nessy had come to look a little eccentric. 
 Indoors she wore a long black pinafore-like garment, sleeveless and reaching almost to the ground, which she had made from a cotton material used later during the war for black-out curtains and called, I think, sateen. 
 The folds of this pinafore fell amply from a short yoke, and beneath it she wore a succession of woollen jumpers. 
 Her coat, also, was black and very long, and winter and summer she wore the same comfortable black straw hat. 
 Her shoes were of the kind then called ward shoes, with low heels, one strap, and a little metal star on the front for ornamentation. 
 Then, as in the nature of things Beatrice's lot had improved, so Aunt Nessy's had declined, and her little house had come to look very small and pinched. 
 It happened that I called at Beatrice's house the last time Aunt Nessy visited there &mdash; the time before she was banished. 
 I had always found visiting my mother-in-law difficult; it had never been an easy relationship. 
 Perhaps I could have tried harder to be what she wanted in a daughter-in-law. 
 She had been a mother of sons only and I think now that she would have liked me to call her mother; but then, such an idea never entered my head. 
 Again, although I visited her regularly, taking little presents; remembered her birthday and saw to it that her  sons did the same; looked after her once when she was ill; and respected my husband's love for her, I did not take much notice of her suggestions: &bquo;My mother seems to think&hellip; 
 &equo;, &bquo;My mother would like&hellip; 
 &equo;, &bquo;My mother would prefer the name to be&hellip; 
 &equo;. I listened, looking vague I expect, but did nothing &mdash; not from ill-will but because it just did not occur to me to change. 
 Sometimes she would compare me unfavourably with her ideal daughter-in-law: &bquo;So-and-so asks her husband's mother for recipes.&equo; 
 Again I listened but said nothing. 
 I did not like recipes; in any case I knew how to cook what my husband liked perfectly well without them. 
 One's mind is occupied so much when one is young, but I wonder now if I could not have thought more about Beatrice. 
 (Only now do I realize how strong the desire in her for a daughter must have been to cause her to dress her youngest son as a little girl almost until the day he went to school, his fair hair nearly reaching his waist; yet he had grown up a man.) 
 Perhaps then I might have come to understand her, and instead of just doing my duty (as I thought), to love her&hellip; 
 Perhaps now, but not then with my mind brim-full of other more immediate concerns. 
 Then I could not forgive how (she said) she would often hit my husband when he was a little boy and naughty, on his bare bottom, with the bristles of a hairbrush. 
 (What a thing to do to a loving little boy! 
 He adored her.) 
 Worse, he had helped the baker in some  way (held his horse?) every Saturday morning, although he wanted to play football or marbles so much, being gifted in that direction. 
 (&bquo;He wanted more to earn enough money to buy me a present,&equo; she said.) 
 Every day on his way to school he had seen a brooch in the jeweller's window, the price showing on a card beside it. 
 It was the sort of brooch only a very little boy could admire. 
 &bquo;You don't think I am going to wear that trash, do you?&equo; she had said when the great day came; and wondered why he had &bquo;got into one of his passionate tempers&equo; ( poor little disappointed boy !) 
 In the end she had taken the brooch back to the shop and exchanged it for a plain silver cross on a chain. 
 For these things I did not forgive her. 
 Aunt Nessy had been upstairs, but hearing voices she came down, and seeing me ran towards me, as lightly and softly as a little bouncing ball, her eyes full of love and welcome. 
 Only now have I come to understand what it was my sixth sense was trying to tell me then; in any case it would have been too late, Aunt Nessy was waiting, and bending down, I put my arms round her, and kissed her.  
 Wilson  
 EVERY day people passed by our house taking their dogs for a walk. 
 There were very old dogs, taken gently to the nearest suitable spot then straight home; dogs who bounded ahead, to wait for a moment, look round, eyes shining, mouth dripping, before dashing off once more; dogs on the lead, who would drag their owner slowly from one thoughtfully sniffed-over site to the next; and there were some, like Wilson, who trotted to heel &mdash; alert, brisk, responsible &mdash; although Wilson was not a dog, only so much like an Aberdeen terrier in bearing and gait that his picture sometimes became confused in my mind. 
 Wilson had to trot briskly, to keep up with his wife; and he trotted responsibly, because there was no doubt that he was proud of his charge &mdash; tall and upright as a Grenadier Guard as she was, and issuing instructions in the way that I imagine a Grenadier might, so that when they were at home her voice would sometimes float right up the road and into our garden, &bquo;Wilson! 
 Wilson!&equo; 
 Mrs Wilson dressed quietly and respectably in floating grey or black, the large hat which covered her coils of iron-grey hair complementing her height. 
 Her husband, who had a bristly white moustache, wore in winter a hand-knitted Balaclava helmet, a long cloth  coat, and boots; in summer, a cap took the place of the helmet, and a light jacket the coat. 
 When he had retired, not long before, he had still owned a small car, and he and his wife could do their shopping in style, and go for outings: Wilson in goggles, because the roof was usually open, and his wife carefully tucked in, and veiled. 
 But that was before their accident. 
 Now they walked to the shops; Mrs Wilson painfully, with a stick, her face scarred. 
 In the same way that he now helped his wife to dress, and waited upon her all day long, Wilson sought out people to keep her company. 
 &bquo;Come and see my wife; she enjoys a chat. 
 Gets a bit lonely since our accident, you know. 
 Can't get about quite as much. 
 Come to tea. 
 Shall we make it tomorrow? 
 Perhaps three o'clock would suit you.&equo; 
 But her energy gnawed at her so; her nature was so strong and vigorous, and her loneliness and boredom so intense, that she almost ate visitors up, so that they seldom went again. 
 She who could have managed twelve great sons, and trained a staff of servants with one hand, had only Wilson. 
 For all her gruffness and trying to hide that she loved Wilson, I knew she did. 
 It was touching to me to see how she would sometimes act helpless because she loved him being, as he often was, masterful with her, as well as tender; and for his part it was easy to see that he thought her a wonderful woman and admired every inch of her.  
 As for me, I liked going to tea with Mr and Mrs Wilson. 
 I loved the orderliness of their little bungalow, and their well-kept garden. 
 It was a pleasure to me to see the housewifely way in which Mr Wilson set about everything. 
 For some reason it was restful to watch him lay the crochet-bordered cloth cornerwise on the polished table just so; arrange the tea-tray, and bring in delicate, perfectly symmetrical sandwiches, and the Victoria sponge which, under his wife's direction, he had made so beautifully and had set upon a spotless lace doily precisely in the centre of the dish. 
 And then, I liked having nice little teas served to me for a change; to have Wilson taking care of me and treating me like a lady &mdash; because there was a little something between us. 
 There is an expression, &bquo;the unassailable complacency of the mother of eight&equo;, and with Wilson I had the unassailable confidence of someone five feet eight inches high in the presence of a man she knows instinctively to admire tall women. 
 (I would even catch myself, sometimes, drawing myself up and standing extra straight and tall for his benefit.) 
 So Wilson and I were quite chummy together, and he looked at me approvingly through his thick-lensed glasses as I sat talking with his wife about, for instance, winter tasks. 
 Mrs Wilson had usually done all her winter tasks &mdash; turning sheets sides to middle, washing and mending loose covers and curtains, going through her wardrobe &mdash; by the end of January, and was left raring for more.  
 After tea we would sometimes walk round their garden, and she gave me tips on gardening which have since stood me in good stead; and cuttings, which still bring her to my mind. 
 She had the countrywoman's natural, in-built knowledge, also its little boasts: Our relations will be eating their peas next Sunday.&equo; 
 I learned a lot from her, and when she and Wilson came to tea with me and we walked round my garden, she gave me a lot of good advice, evidently amazed at the poverty of my crops &mdash; &bquo;These are not&hellip; your Brussels ?&equo; 
 I had an old air-raid shelter, partly dug into the ground because of the slope: there was a load of stones on top, waiting to turn the shelter into an apple store disguised as a rockery, and when Mrs Wilson saw this she stood for a long time looking at the hump in the ground and the pile of stones. 
 At last she turned to me. 
 &bquo;How I should love to do that rockery for you!&equo; she said sadly. 
 &bquo;I know just how I would set about it. 
 But it's no good, no good. 
 I can't bend my leg.&equo; 
 And it was as if she had glimpsed the celestial city knowing that she could never enter in. 
 (The rockery, left to my care, degenerated into a mass of elephants' ears and clumps of coarse grass.) 
 Yes, I could see by the way she grumbled about Wilson that she loved him and, although he was over eighty at the time, still saw him in a romantic light. 
 &bquo;He's so slow! 
 Sometimes, when he has been working in the garden, he will come in and sit down, then out again and does a bit more. 
 And after dinner sometimes he will sit down in that chair and go to sleep! 
 I say to him, if he did  more gardening, more real  gardening, more digging , he would keep more lissom.&equo; 
 There was something else that baffled Mrs Wilson. 
 Although he so obviously loved her, waited on her hand and foot, thought almost entirely of and for her, there was a tiny part of him which eluded her. 
 It was as if he were a sheet of paper torn into many little pieces which she felt she had to cover entirely with her hand, but could not, however hard she tried, because the wind always blew a few of the pieces from between her fingers or from the edge of her palm. 
 In other words, there was a side to him that worried her, because she could not understand it. 
 Sometimes, when Wilson had gone into the garden to smoke his pipe, she almost confided in me. 
 &bquo;He gets up at six every morning. 
 I don't get up till nine. 
 He brings me a cup of tea about eight. 
 He sits in the kitchen all that time. 
 What does he do? 
 There's not a sound.&equo; 
 &bquo;Some people need to be alone sometimes,&equo; I said. 
 She shook her head impatiently. 
 &bquo;Then I have always kept to making the Ovaltine last thing, and on Friday night I forgot to put the sugar in for him and went to get the bowl. 
 What do you think he said? 
 He said it didn't matter, he had never liked sugar in Ovaltine. 
 Why couldn't he have told me before! 
 There's me been putting sugar in his Ovaltine for the last fifty years. 
 &bquo;Do you know what I found in his trunk some time ago, right at the bottom? 
 Paintings! 
 His mother had done them &mdash; her name was in the corner. 
 He never told me anything about his mother painting in all our  married life. 
 Why should he keep a thing like that to himself?&equo; 
 One thing she never mentioned, and it remained a mystery to me. 
 There was a legend, and goodness only knows where these tales come from, that Mr Wilson had once taken savings from the post office and gone to Brighton for the week-end. 
 Was it possible? 
 Could it be true! 
 Why all by himself? 
 Had Mrs Wilson refused to go? 
 The story was, that unused to concealing money about his person, he had been robbed on the train and had had to return home. 
 Although I was sceptical as to the Brighton affair, I could not help seeing that there was rather a look about Mr Wilson sometimes; for instance when, as occasionally happened, his wife's leg was too bad for her to go shopping and he went alone. 
 There was something in his walk &mdash; his whole aspect &mdash; as if, instead of having come out through the front gate, he had squeezed through a secret hole in the fence. 
 It was quite a shock to everyone when it was known that Mr Wilson had died; he who had always seemed so solid and enduring. 
 He had gone to the sideboard cupboard where a bottle of whisky was kept for medicinal purposes, drunk what was there, and died. 
 &bquo;When I saw that he had drunk it all, I knew he must have felt bad. 
 If he had not felt really bad he would never have drunk it all, he would have saved some for me.&equo; 
 There had been rather a mystery as to why he should have died at that particular time. 
 He had been in  good health, and had been subjected to no particular strain or exertion. 
 But it was his heart, and as everyone said, you can never tell with hearts. 
 A few weeks later, Mrs Wilson discovered for herself what she felt must have been the reason for the heart attack. 
 She had arranged to go and live with a niece, whose husband was out of work; the couple would look after the old lady together. 
 When it came to her last day at home, she had gone out into the garden for a final look round. 
 The earth was dry, and there, among the cabbages, lay Mr Wilson's spectacles. 
 &bquo;He couldn't have seen without them. 
 He wouldn't have been able to see well enough even to lock for them. 
 He was almost blind without his glasses. 
 He must have died of worry. 
 Why couldn't he have told me! 
 He had only to tell me and I would have found them for him. 
 My eyes were always better than his. 
 He must have worried himself to death just because he was afraid to tell me.&equo; 
 Her voice was gruff, and sounded contemptuous, but in her eyes were bewilderment and pain. 
 I saw his grave when I took a short cut through the churchyard &mdash; a modest, friendly, even jolly little grave, where in summer moon-daisies and red clover grew, and quaking grass which little children call shivery-shakes. 
 It was a small grave, and at its head was a low wooden cross inscribed with his name, date of birth, and date of death; and as I passed, I had a vision of a little Aberdeen terrier  who had gone off for a run by himself, and was now sporting in the fields of Paradise. 
 It was some years before I went that way again, and something had happened. 
 The wooden cross had been dug up and a new large memorial stone had been erected in its place. 
 Had Mrs Wilson died? 
 Surely I should have heard. 
 There was an inscription on the stone, and I paused to read it: &bquo;Sacred to the memory of John Wetherby Wilson of this Parish&equo;, then the date of his birth, and of his death, and then a long empty blank. 
 Mrs Wilson had not died, but it was said she was very ill and was expected to die. 
 And die she did. 
 The grave was opened and her coffin was placed upon that of her husband. 
 And there she will rest for ever, securely weighted down by good Portland stone and a covering of granite chippings. 
 O Wilson! 
 You didn't escape after all.  
 The Duke of Wellington, and Jane  
 I SYMPATHIZE with the Duke of Wellington who, towards the end of his life it is said, grieved continually over all the brave men killed at the Battle of Waterloo. 
 I sympathize because in my little way I grieve too, but over the people in my life I have allowed to die without ever having shown them any particular affection. 
 Yet, I always conclude, it might have seemed strange and unnatural to have shown too much feeling; strange, and perhaps embarrassing and out of order, I being somewhat far down in the family hierarchy. 
 At least, as a child, I was helpful, and perhaps that was something. 
 In those days I think I must have regarded many of the people dotted about my landscape more as bushes than as the human beings I now see them to have been: some dull and uninteresting like laurel bushes; some like lavender sweetly scented; some thorny, to be avoided; and then rose bushes, gooseberry bushes, fuchsia bushes &mdash; but all just part of the scenery, and I withdrawn from them into my dreams. 
 There was Jane, my mother's stepmother. 
 I wish I had shown her more affection, although I did spend a lot  of time collecting scraps of sheep's wool off the barbed wire for her to put round her corns. 
 (&bquo;It is the oils!&equo; she would say.) 
 And ran errands for her willingly and without complaint; but no, I cannot remember ever having behaved particularly lovingly. 
 We children called her Grandma, although my mother and the aunts called her Jane. 
 She could not have been very old when I first knew her, but I thought of her as old, partly because her hair was pure white. 
 (She kept the combings and sold them to a wig-maker when there was a suitable quantity, because the texture of her hair and its being pure white made it especially suitable for his work.) 
 Jane was a Welsh woman from the Gower Peninsula, and there was something about her that my grandfather had not realized when he married her after my grandmother died so young: she came of very inbred stock, and had periodic mental lapses. 
 I do not think he married her particularly for love, but for the sake of his daughters, as people did in those days; and it might have seemed that she was ideally suited for this, with her quiet, dignified manner, and she having been a housekeeper. 
 She had once shown me, at some distance from the train in which we were travelling, a high brick wall enclosing the park of a great house: in this wall could clearly be seen a door, and through that door, Grandma told me, she had always passed when going off duty. 
 Her family were farmers, but she had been sent by her employer to learn the finer points of cuisine and household  management from the master chef and the housekeeper at the Savoy. 
 It must have seemed strange to have found herself keeping house for my grandfather and his daughters. 
 Perhaps she loved him &mdash; there is every reason to suppose he was attractive to women: quiet-voiced, good-looking with fine eyes, well-educated, witty, and musical. 
 When he was sixty years old he retired, and for Jane's sake, she being a country person at heart, and thinking she would be happy there, bought a cottage in Hampshire. 
 I have the page from his diary where he records &bquo;House, &pound;125.&equo; 
 We all went to see them once; it was quite a nice little place, in a village truly rural. 
 He was not a country man himself, and I think must have suffered torments of loneliness and boredom. 
 (There had always been a certain lifelessness about Jane &mdash; I felt it even as a child. 
 Something about her nature which was without structure; something which, if one put out a hand to touch, to join, simply dissolved.) 
 I found among my mother's papers when she died a letter from my grandfather which must have wrung her heart for years after his death: &bquo;&hellip; can't you spare a moment to write to your poor old Dad&hellip; &bquo; 
 At the bottom of the garden of their cottage ran a deep stream of fast-flowing water. 
 My grandfather had a weak heart, and he died in this way. 
 He had gone for a short walk over some fields &mdash; his constitutional &mdash; and had met a woman pushing a bicycle. 
 She asked him if he would lift the bicycle over a stile for her, she not having realized there was a stile to be crossed  when she had embarked over the fields by herself. 
 Like most people with a weak heart, especially men, he had not liked to own up, and had lifted the bicycle over the stile, gone home, and died. 
 Jane had come to us for the time being. 
 We had a very full household: grown-ups, big children, small children, a baby, and a shop, as well as our father going to work each day. 
 We all helped with whatever jobs came to hand &mdash; cleaning the children's shoes, peeling potatoes, washing nappies, bathing the children, washing up, taking the children for walks, putting them to bed, reading to them, running errands, shopping, and a little slap-dash cookery here and there. 
 My father always did the fires, the garden, and cleaning the gas stove, as well as the usual maintenance jobs and the accounts; and my mother always did the washing and ironing &mdash; among other things &mdash; and, of course, the shop. 
 (Before I went to work in the morning I would take a bucket of water and a scrubbing brush and deal with the black-and-white chequered marble shop doorstep &mdash; in my memory it is a glittering affair, although cold on frosty mornings &mdash; because at that time of the day the rising sun often shone full down the High Street where we lived and on me, as I knelt on the cobbled pavement plying my scrubbing-brush.) 
 There were always things to be done, and Grandma joined in with the rest of us in her quiet, dreamy, unobtrusive way. 
 Occasionally she made rolled-up pancakes, and stuffed omelettes, and steak pies with lovely  gravy:I have in my mind's eye a picture of her, sitting in a corner with some child on her lap, and the usual dreamy expression on her face. 
 For my father's part, he accepted Jane's presence without question; and she had consideration for his duodenal ulcer, and looked up to him as head of the household, and fitted in like the rest of us. 
 I think I knew, even then, that she needed not only my mother, but my father, and all the rest of us, to fix her bearings and to keep her world in focus. 
 Grandma was always nice to me in her vague way. 
 (I can at least remember that I was helpful about the sheep's wool for her corns, and being willing about errands. 
 But no! 
 I cannot remember ever having behaved particularly lovingly.) 
 She liked going for slow, rather stately walks in the summer evenings when the shop was closed and the children in bed, and I usually escorted her. 
 Sometimes, when we got back rather later than usual, my father was already preparing to send out a search party in &mdash; as I thought then, not knowing about Grandma's lapses &mdash; his usual agitated way. 
 Once I urged on her a walk which I had taken with children I knew and which had seemed very easy to me. 
 But at the time I took her, the bushes had grown across the path, and we got stuck, with her widow's weeds entangled in branches and thorns until she could move no more. 
 I remember how her country beginnings showed themselves then: she made no fuss about seeming to be lost, nor did she work herself up into a state as the aunts would have done, just  stood there patiently and quietly while I untangled her and found the way; and did not even grumble, although after that I let her decide where we should go, which was usually across a field near the sewage plant, and along a road near the gasworks. 
 She had little private sides to her life. 
 Sometimes the postman would bring her a strange soggy parcel, with no letter inside. 
 It was laver bread (made with seaweed) from an old friend in Wales. 
 &bquo; Lovely !&equo; she would say as she cooked and ate it, with the little pursing of her lips and narrowing of her grey eyes which was the nearest she ever came to a smile or a laugh. 
 To us, the black laver bread looked dreadful, poisonous, but we understood and respected that it was something Welsh, something special. 
 Very occasionally, on our walks, Grandma would tell me things about Wales: about the great cart-horses who died of heart trouble from toiling to and fro up the steep cliff road all their lives; and how, as a child, she had walked to church along the sands. 
 And she told me about her relations, of one young cousin in particular, who had never thrived but sat by the fire instead of going to school with the other children, not growing an inch. 
 There was nothing the matter with him, simply that he did not thrive. 
 In the end, the mother had sent for an old lady from the Isle of Anglesey, thought to be a witch. 
 She came, and with her little instrument (which in my imagination took the form of a ticket-collector's punch) nipped the lobe of the boy's ear. 
 Then she returned  home. 
 From that day on, the bewitched one had begun to grow, and was now (said Grandma) a fine man with a family. 
 She told me, too, of the mines, and how some of the young boys were terrified of going down the pit for the first time, but had to go, as there was no other work for them; and how at first they had been put to work beside their father, loading the coal he cut, until they had overcome their fear. 
 And how the mine at the bottom of the shaft was not always dark, but lofty, like a cathedral, and lit up, but with dark tunnels running out from it on all sides. 
 Then of an old lady known, because of her big stomach, as &bquo;Mrs Jones the Bol&equo;, who after an operation for gall-stones boasted so much of their number and size that she was called thereafter &bquo;Mrs Jones the Pebbly Beach&equo;. 
 But the thing which must have been nearest to her heart, because she returned to it so often, was how as a child she had walked to church along the sands. 
 She made a little rite of soaking her feet in a corn cure called &bquo;Reudel&equo;, and as she lowered her feet into the bowl of steaming water there was again that little look, that narrowing of the eyes and pursing of the lips, which said so much with so little disturbance of her features. 
 Sometimes the look would come when my mother broke into wild extravagance, such as ordering dozens of hot cross buns on Good Friday. 
 Then Grandma would raise her hands in mock horror: &bquo;How the poor do live!&equo; 
 And so she settled down quietly into our family  life for over a year, until one of the aunts, Aunt Kate, came to see us, and after that there was talk between our parents &mdash; children always know these things, having good ears &mdash; about it perhaps being best now for Grandma to be going back to her little house in Hampshire. 
 The aunt had told Grandma (or Jane, as they always called her) that she was being &bquo;used&equo;. 
 I do not know whether poor, dreamy Grandma knew what it was all about, or whether she just gathered, in a vague way, the drift of things. 
 I expect my aunt meant well; I guess it might just have been one of her spasmodic assumptions of authority in the family &mdash; out of character and dramatic as these assumptions usually were. 
 Perhaps, being so very different from Grandma herself, she did not understand her needs. 
 Perhaps she really did think Grandma was being used. 
 Perhaps she even got Grandma thinking the same, not realizing that Grandma was a person who needed the near-replica of her childhood to make a background for her life; and that although she gave, she also received. 
 So Grandma went home, my parents making the journey to help her to settle in. 
 Some months later, in a spell of beautiful summer weather, a telegram &mdash; always a thing of dread &mdash; arrived. 
 Grandma had been found floating in the stream at the bottom of the garden &mdash; that lovely little stream, so sparkling and full of life.  
 The event was not much talked about in the family; it was too dreadful; and I don't suppose for a moment that Aunt Kate, then living abroad, would have wondered whether she, herself, might not have played a part in the sequence of events; nor do I remember any such theory ever having been put forward or even thought of at the time. 
 But now, looking back, I think that such must have been the case. 
 I never did believe that, as the coroner seemed to think, because of one of her mental lapses Grandma had gone out into the garden in her nightie and just fallen into the stream by mistake. 
 I guessed, as everyone else must have done, that at some point she could not manage her life any longer and had gone out and stepped into the stream as a way of escape. 
 Perhaps the end would have been the same in any case. 
 Only, I wish I had ever shown some sign of affection; I wish I had perhaps written to her &mdash; even if only a card (and even though I was rather far down in the family hierarchy).  
 Doctor's Orders  
 I WAS really only a bystander in the tragedy of young Mr and Mrs McLeod; it was not really my business, although it could be said that I had known them both &mdash; had seen them about &mdash; for most of their lives. 
 I remember passing the church just after they were married. 
 It was a summer day, and they were posing in front of the porch for the photographer. 
 The bridegroom was a very tall young man with reddish hair, a very big man altogether, and as so often happens then, the bride was very small. 
 Her head did not nearly reach his shoulder, and even from where I stood I could sense the gentleness, the protectiveness, which were to be her portion. 
 She was dressed all in white, with a veil; she was an only child, and this was her big day. 
 An elderly verger once confided to me that he felt happier at a good funeral than at a wedding. 
 If the deceased had led a reasonable life and had died at a good age without too much trouble, leaving a reasonably good family behind him, what was there to be miserable about? 
 It was no worse than leaves falling from the trees in autumn. 
 You knew where you were. 
 But a wedding&hellip; 
 The bride always looked so happy. 
 Sometimes (he said) he was almost afraid to look into the young couple's  faces. 
 Little did they know! 
 Whereas a good funeral&hellip; 
 I, being about the verger's age, was inclined to understand what he felt. 
 When next I saw the young couple together it was winter. 
 They told me they had a little house not far away from where I lived, and that Dorothy was expecting a baby &mdash; twins, the doctor had said. 
 And then, not much later as it seemed, there they were, father pushing the pram, a very happy little family. 
 It was nice to see people happy, I thought. 
 It was how things were meant to be. 
 I always enquired about Dorothy's parents when we met. 
 They were a kindly couple, rather older than one would have expected, although there had always been a suggestion of old-fashionedness about Dorothy as a child. 
 Her father had been an invalid from the First World War &mdash; some kind of nervous trouble, I believe. 
 I suppose one would call him a hypochondriac, because Dorothy had once told me that her earliest memory was of her father standing in front of the looking-glass saying, &bquo;I am a dying man&equo;; her mother's face had that bearing-up look one sees on the faces of those suffering with their feet. 
 &bquo;All right, thank you,&equo; Dorothy would say when I asked how they were keeping. 
 &bquo;Mum gets a bit tired; I go to see them as often as I can: it cheers Dad up, and Mum loves the children.&equo; 
 She smiled proudly. 
 &bquo;Mum  says she always looked forward to her grandchildren, because of me being an only child. 
 Dad won't hold the babies &mdash; he's afraid of dropping them!&equo; 
 A little, impatient look showed for a moment in her eyes. 
 Before one could turn round, the twins were riding bicycles &mdash; and then, University. 
 It was about this time that their grandmother died of a sudden heart attack. 
 I was not surprised when I heard that the old man had gone to live with Dorothy. 
 There had never been any doubt in her mind that she would look after her parents in their old age: they had given up a lot for her, she said, and that was how she could repay them. 
 (Her aunts had been saying much the same kind of thing to her all her life, I believe.) 
 If she had ever thought much about the future, I think she would have seen her mother sitting in a chair by the fire, knitting; after all, her father had been dying all her life. 
 It was not until a few weeks after her father had been installed that Dorothy began to realize the fortitude with which her mother had cared for him over the years. 
 Perhaps Dorothy had been shielded too much, and again in her marriage she had been protected, so that there had been nothing in her life to prepare her for what was happening now. 
 It was not the extra work &mdash; she did it willingly, willingly. 
 It was not being more tied to the house. 
 It was that for the first time something illogical had crept into her world. 
 She was looking after her father in his old  age as she had always said she would, but instead of satisfaction she felt only guilt &mdash; guilt at her own impatience when he behaved not as her father but like a disobedient child. 
 These things I gathered from what Dorothy's husband Leo told me when I met him in the chemist's shop one day. 
 He had been trying to get something for Dorothy's headaches. 
 &bquo;It is difficult for both of you,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;What about a home? 
 He can't be particularly happy as things are.&equo; 
 &bquo;Dorothy would never hear of it, and it is her decision. 
 &bquo;When I go off to work each day,&equo; he said slowly, &bquo;Dorothy comes out to the car with me to say goodbye. 
 It is a little time when we can talk together, and I encourage her to talk about her father. 
 I think it helps her to get it out. 
 She is so loyal; but she knows she can speak to me. 
 When I drive off, I am so churned up inside that I find myself hoping I shan't make things worse by having a coronary on the way to work.&equo; 
 Watching him speak, and seeing the man he was, I realized the distress that allowed him to reveal his feelings to me. 
 He was not, I knew, a person to talk about himself and his emotions. 
 So I was not surprised when he rang me a few weeks later to say that Dorothy was in hospital. 
 She had had what seemed to be flu, but it had left her breathless, he said. 
  They didn't seem to know what it was, so had taken her into hospital for observation &mdash; or so I understood. 
 The old man had gone to stay with relatives for a few days, and Dorothy wondered if I would water her houseplants, because he (Leo) wanted to spend all the time he could with her at the hospital. 
 I was amazed at the number of plants: I counted 147 &mdash; all along the window-sills, on tables, everywhere. 
 Then there was a little conservatory; but those plants I was supposed to leave for Leo, because they were Dorothy's special plants and he had special directions. 
 I was able to go to see her in hospital. 
 I thought it was rather a bad sign that I was told I could, as a family friend, go in at any time. 
 She looked very sweet propped up there on the pillows; and very clean and tidy, as seriously ill patients often do. 
 Although the breathlessness was noticeable, I could not understand what was the matter with her. 
 She hadn't a cough; it was not, it seemed, her heart &mdash; that would be mentioned, I felt. 
 She did not look feverish. 
 I did not like to ask; I had not even liked to ask Leo. 
 In any case, he did not seem to know. 
 &bquo;It's Dad that's made me ill,&equo; she said. 
 There was nothing I could think of to say, so I said nothing.  
 &bquo;It isn't the work I mind&hellip; it isn't even having to clean him up&hellip;&equo; 
 &bquo;I know,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;You don't have to tell me.&equo; 
 &bquo;It's the baiting&hellip; calling me upstairs when he's down, and down when he's up&hellip; and then thinking it's a bit of&hellip; a joke&hellip; and that kind of thing.&equo; 
 After a time I said, &bquo;You don't think that if he had an outside person looking after him, who he didn't mind telling him what to do because it was their job&hellip; &bquo; 
 &bquo;I could never put him into a home.&equo; 
 &bquo;No, but Leo would see to it for you, while you were here. 
 You know you could trust him to do everything properly.&equo; 
 &bquo;I could never put Dad into a home.&equo; 
 She smiled proudly. 
 &bquo;And Leo would never go against my decision. 
 He knows how I feel, me being an only child&hellip; he's a wonderful husband, I couldn't have a better husband. 
 He's been a wonderful husband in every way&hellip; it's been the same all&hellip; our married life.&equo; 
 I blinked. 
 It was no time for me to be getting weepy. 
 There was something wrong about the plants. 
 There were too many. 
 In spite of some of them being mere cuttings, there were too many of them. 
 I must do the watering carefully, I told myself each day &mdash; not make a mess. 
 It was silent in the house, and rather airless. 
 How had Dorothy found patience to look after all these  plants! 
 Slowly I went from pot to pot, pot to pot, giving each flower its drink of water. 
 They stood waiting. 
 They were very beautiful when you looked into them, the colours, the shapes. 
 After a while I began to feel a little like Dorothy myself. 
 Lovingly she tended them, and lovingly they responded. 
 She looked after them, and they behaved in a natural, foretellable way. 
 They would thrive, and obediently they would unfold into their familiar selves. 
 And their colours! 
 It was as if I could see Dorothy looking at them, looking at them, trying to draw something from them to help her to hold on. 
 She couldn't get enough. 
 One day Leo came to see to the plants in the conservatory. 
 I went with him to the glass door and stopped. 
 &bquo;Whatever's that! 
 Whatever's that dreadful creature! 
 It was standing, without a flutter, on some branch or piece of wood, watching us coldly. 
 &bquo;Dreadful? 
 It's a pigeon! 
 It's Dorothy's pet pigeon!&equo; 
 He looked surprised. 
 &bquo;Surely you know a pigeon?&equo; 
 &bquo;They usually rise. 
 I have never seen one so close before, and it looks so bold, and bossy. 
 Whatever is it doing here?&equo; 
 &bquo;Dorothy found it in the garden a few weeks ago. 
 It was ill, and she brought it in and nursed it back to health. 
 I think it helped her having something like that to do. 
 The bird got so attached to her that it would take food from between her lips. 
 She had been going to set it loose  in case it got too tame to fend for itself. 
 Perhaps I had better do it now.&equo; 
 The next time I went to see Dorothy I was not allowed to stay for long. 
 She was to have an operation (a biopsy?) the next day. 
 I remember walking through the bus station on my way home. 
 Whatever happened, I thought, Dorothy was not going to get better while her father was with them. 
 She might get over this present illness but would only fall victim to the first virus that came along. 
 But it was no good talking to her, she was too ill, and it was no good talking to Leo, he would never go against her decision. 
 There must be an answer; and my mind started running hither and thither putting forward suggestions, quotations, ideas&hellip; 
 &bquo;Who shall we send, and who will go for us?&equo; 
 Then said I, &bquo;Lo, here am I. Send me.&equo; 
 Then, &bquo;Old Busybody! 
 Nosy old so-and-so!&equo; 
 Then another voice (the devil?). 
 And now it was as if I were sinking blissfully into a warm bath and lying there perfectly relaxed&hellip; 
 &bquo;It's not your business, is it.&equo; 
 (Only, no one else seemed to realize.) 
 This was all happening while I was walking through the bus station and taking my place in the queue; and when I gained my seat I began looking in my bag for a piece of paper and a biro, and then, on the inside of  a chocolate-bar wrapping I wrote what I must memorize and recite if I were to get the message over to the doctor &mdash; I, who even made heavy weather of describing a sore throat; I, who after a period in the waiting-room could dry up so as to be virtually dumb. 
 It was almost at the end of surgery and it was almost as if the doctor were expecting me; and later, I could hardly wait to tell Leo what had happened. 
 Leo had promised to ring me that evening in case there had been any news from the hospital; and I told him my own news. 
 It fell quite flat. 
 It was a terrible disappointment, my heart sank as for the first time I detected a stiffness in Leo's voice. 
 &bquo;It is Dorothy's decision,&equo; he said. 
 &bquo;But Leo, she is in no state to make decisions. 
 It is the doctor's decision. 
 It is Doctor's Orders. 
 She will obey Doctor's Orders. 
 Leo, you must tell her that it is Doctor's Orders that she must not look after her father any more &mdash; that it is too much for her &mdash; that she need not even see her father until she is quite well enough, and the doctor has himself offered to find a suitable place, so that she will know her father will be well looked after. 
 Leo, you must tell her. 
 It will help her. 
 It may make all the difference.&equo; 
 As it was, she died under the anaesthetic. 
 When Leo told me, I asked if he had been able to give the message. 
 He said he had, and when he told her, he said, she seemed to  relax all over. 
 &bquo;We were very happy together until it was time for the operation.&equo; 
 There was something else I had to say, and it was no good getting wobbly-voiced about it either. 
 &bquo;While I was with her,&equo; I said, &bquo;she told me what a wonderful husband you had always been to her &mdash; always, in every way, all your married life.&equo;  
 Adult Education  
 I ONCE read a book by Bertrand Russell in which he said that at the age of seven years (as I remember) he got up one night to see whether there were, in fact, four angels round his bed: 
 Four corners to my bed; 
 Four angels round my head; 
 One to watch, one to pray; 
 And two to carry my soul away. 
 He must have thought there was some likelihood of angels being there, because he describes how he put out his arms in the darkness and made a grab, at thin air as it turned out. 
 In his book he seems rather proud of this episode, and I suppose it did foretell the scientist to be. 
 Yet, when I was seven years old, I should have thought him a very silly little boy indeed not to have understood about metaphorically speaking, even if he had never heard of it, and it does seem that what he possessed in the way of scientific approach he lacked in common sense. 
 All the same, he grew up to be a famous philosopher as well as a famous scientist, while I&hellip; 
 I puzzled over this little problem for years, right into old age in fact, picking it up when it happened to float into my mind, and putting it down again unsolved. 
  What had happened to us could not, I thought, have been due entirely to education &mdash; not even to the idea that girls develop more quickly than boys to a certain point and then slow down; but as I still clung loyally to my little world where all clergymen were good, all solicitors honest, and all philosophers and experts different from ordinary people and unquestionably right, I struggled hard against any idea that I might still be wiser than Bertrand Russell in some respects. 
 The problem came to a crisis after I had been going to evening classes (Workers' Educational Association), the subject being psychology. 
 I had attended WEA classes many years before, when they first started in the town. 
 Our teacher then was R. H. S. Crossman, and the subject, &bquo;If Plato Lived Today&equo;. 
 I do not think I knew who Plato was at the time, but I enjoyed hearing Mr Crossman speak, and seeing the other pupils, although they were mostly people thought of in the town as being particularly well-educated already. 
 When I married I left the classes but now, all these years later, I joined them again. 
 There was something rather reckless in my attending the present lectures at all, because it was in the depths of winter, and from where I now lived it was rather a long walk to the town &mdash; over a mile, at any rate. 
 The classes started at eight o'clock and were supposed to end at ten, but with the usual chatting afterwards it was almost eleven o'clock before I reached home. 
 I would not do it again; it is too dangerous as things are today; but the  night on which I decided this to be the case was the night on which I leaned enough at my classes to decide me about Bertrand Russell, so it was well worth going. 
 It was a very cold frosty night in December, and because the snow on the footpath was hard and uneven, and as slippery as ice, I walked along the edge of the road. 
 I walked fast, to keep warm, so it may have been that I was a little above myself by the time I reached the school where the classes were held, because that night, try as I would, I could not believe anything our teacher was telling us. 
 We sat before him looking at him with respectful eyes (that is, all but one of us, who usually went to sleep as soon as the class started; she was not just closing her eyes, she was fast asleep). 
 The talk that night was about experiments carried out to explain why people behaved as they did, and we were told of different types of neurotic people and how they could be classified. 
 It would not have mattered so much if the experiments described all held water, but when (as we were encouraged to do) I put up my hand and ventured that one experiment was not consistent, the lecturer acknowledged that this was so in the particular I questioned, but said that the results were usually found to be as would have been expected. 
 And then he said something which, entering the realms of my own modest experience, I knew to be wrong. 
 He spoke of &bquo;the type of person who always offers to wash up after a party; the type of person who, winning a prize in a raffle, will give it back to be re-raffled&equo;. 
  And this, he said, was because that person had a martyrdom complex. 
 (I saw a party of friends &mdash; all knowing that their host and hostess must either clear up before retiring, or rise early before going to work the next day &mdash; whisking round to help before they left. 
 Surely it was kindness of heart and had nothing to do with complexes. 
 I saw an elderly lady with half a lifetime of raffles behind her and half a dozen tea cosies in her drawer, winning yet another tea cosy and, smiling, handing it back to be re-raffled. 
 She was not suffering from a complex, it was just common sense; in any case, prizes could be symbolic only, appearing regularly at sales of work, bring-and-buy mornings, f&ecirc;tes and tombolas, before finally coming to rest.) 
 That night I walked part of my way home with one of the other pupils, who lived in a group of houses a short distance from the school. 
 (She seemed to me to be about eighteen years old, although as we walked along she told me she had five children, all happily married.) 
 Then I was alone, and had a choice of two routes. 
 One took me rather out of my way, before turning at last, at right angles, up the hill and home; but it was the main road and was lit. 
 The other was a much shorter way, a footpath stretching diagonally across a very large ploughed field, this path making the third side of a triangle.  
 In my rather disgruntled frame of mind I rebelled that night against the long way round. 
 Surely I should be over the field in no time. 
 I thought of hypothetical dangers &mdash; murderers, rapists; and I have no doubt that such are abroad at night in the most unlikely of places at the most unlikely of times. 
 (Yet surely a murderer would not stand in the middle of an enormous snow-covered, frost-bitten field in the dark on such a night, just on the off-chance that someone would be silly enough to cross it alone!) 
 There was danger, too, underfoot: the path had been ploughed over in many places and here and there were lumps of frozen earth covered with snow, and slippery. 
 Yet if I concentrated on each footstep, I should soon be safely home. 
 On the other hand, if I did slip and break my hip I should no doubt be dead by the morning. 
 Along the main road, though lit, it was a long way; across the seemingly vast open field, pitch dark, might lie rape, and murder, or freezing to death. 
 But, I told myself again, I should soon be home. 
 And so I set off across the field. 
 I still remember that walk with pleasure. 
 Although it was dark where I was walking, the blackness stretching away on all sides, it was also, unexpectedly, ringed by lights. 
 There were the lights of the town behind me, lights along the distant main road, lights up the hill from an occasional house, continuing with the lights of my own road. 
 They gave a spurious reassurance: so friendly, so warm, so protective (&bquo;&hellip; but God is round about me, and shall I be afraid?&equo; the computer within suggested  doubtfully, but I rejected the idea at once. 
 Why should God bother with someone who chose deliberately to do something foolish?), so I concentrated on every step, placing my feet carefully among the slippery clods and only enjoying the prospect and the blanket of stillness when pausing for breath. 
 (And all the time, at the back of my mind, the pedestals of famous philosophers, teachers, and experts were falling, until by the time I reached my own road they were just ordinary human beings.) 
 Soon I had come out of the field and was walking along the path opposite where my home would be. 
 A few paces ahead, on my left, was a five-barred gate &mdash; access to a paddock which ran along the back walls of some cottages, ending in the grounds of a large house. 
 Some faint glow of light from the direction of the town below caught the angle of a new padlock, the gate being chained as well as shut. 
 How bright the padlock was! 
 And how interesting was the way in which it took advantage of so little light as to shine enough for me to see it so clearly. 
 And then, by its light, I saw something else &mdash; a leg. 
 A leg in trousers, with a plimsoll at the end, frozen in the act of crossing the gate, perfectly immobile. 
 And still without needing to turn my head, but looking straight to the front, and walking at the same even pace along the path, I was conscious of a man perched motionless on the top bar of the gate, one leg over, so still that he might have been part of the gate itself. 
 There was not far to go; I only had to keep my eyes  straight ahead and my pace unhurried. 
 Home was almost opposite. 
 Only a few more yards, and soon I was inside with the door locked after me. 
 What had the man been doing there? 
 Why had he not continued climbing over the gate, said good-night, and gone off down the hill? 
 Why, thinking I was not aware of him, did he stay frozen? 
 What could he have been doing in that little field but reconnoitring the back premises of the house at the far end &mdash; even breaking in, there had been burglaries lately. 
 So still in the adventurous mood of my walk across the field, and my fright at seeing that leg, I rang the police. 
 They telephoned a little later. 
 They had picked up the man at the bottom of the hill. 
 It had looked suspicious, I had done right to inform them, they said kindly, but the man had nothing on his person at all, and said he had been after rabbits. 
 Automatically I began trying to accommodate my ideas to those of the police, the experts; trying to find some reason why a man after rabbits should have no gun, not even a piece of wire or string about him. 
 Before that evening's lecture and the fall of the experts, I should have managed it I know, but the spell had broken, it was no good. 
 It was after myxomatosis; there had not been a rabbit in that field or anywhere around for years. 
 Rabbits indeed!  
 The Murderer in the Bushes by the Gate  
 WE came to know Mrs Browning when we were first married and knew no one else in the road. 
 She lived in a small house near ours and seemed very old to me; but that was many years ago. 
 She was so much a daughter of the vicarage in accent, manner, and appearance (her father had been a clergyman) that without being told I had assumed, seeing evidence in Mrs Browning's home that someone at some time had lived in a hot country, that her husband had been a missionary. 
 To cut a long story short, Mrs Browning was exactly like one of the old ladies in Arsenic and Old Lace . 
 There were very few houses in the road at that time; it was just a lane, leading to nowhere, and Mrs Browning was the first to acknowledge our presence by formally inviting us to tea. 
 Then one day she rang to ask if I would go to see her; she wanted my advice. 
 I felt proud and grown-up as I made my way down the road, concentrating my mind for what might be required of me. 
 Mrs Browning was bothered, she said, by a man who at night hid in the bushes by her gate. 
 She felt he  must have a grudge of some kind against her and she felt very frightened. 
 &bquo;But surely you should go to the police.&equo; 
 &bquo;I have, and they are most kind, but that is all.&equo; 
 I told my husband when he came home. 
 &bquo;I'll go down and keep watch one night if she likes.&equo; 
 &bquo;But not by yourself.&equo; 
 &bquo;Well I should need a sort of chaperon in any case, I suppose. 
 I could ask the chap at the top of the road.&equo; 
 These neighbours had lived there for a number of years; they knew Mrs Browning well, and what they told my husband made us feel rather small, and very inexperienced. 
 It seemed that the man hiding in the bushes by the gate existed only in the mind of Mrs Browning, although she was quite genuinely afraid. 
 She would phone the police and they would go out of their way to search her garden and reassure her of their vigilance, but it had been going on for years. 
 Although the subject was something not discussed, almost everyone in the road had at one time or another been confided in and had helped Mrs Browning as far as they could, although she seemed to feel she should not worry any particular neighbour too much so went from one to another, as it were in turn. 
 Looking back I think she could hardly have lived anywhere more suited to the containment of her difficulty. 
 Many years later, my husband by then having died and my children being away from home, Mrs Browning lived on. 
 She was well over ninety by that time. 
 Sometimes she would ask me to go blackberrying with her or,  as she would say, to open a tin of tangerines with her. 
 The man in the bushes by the gate still worried her but I found it easy to isolate him from our friendship, although she felt now that he was trying to gas her; the fumes from someone's central heating outlet, discernible on the otherwise pure air, had inspired and confirmed her in this idea. 
 But when darkness fell, he was always in the bushes by the gate; and waking in the night I would sometimes hear a shrill cry, &bquo;Come out then! 
 Come out! 
 I'm not afraid of you,&equo; and would marvel at the strength of her voice. 
 On a night in early winter, one of those wild exciting nights with a brilliant moon sliding in and out of the racing clouds, Mrs Browning rang, and asked if I would go down. 
 When I arrived, she urged me inside and closed the door, and I could see that she was breathless with fear. 
 She asked me if I would speak to the police for her. 
 &bquo;They are so good, but perhaps someone else&hellip; &bquo; 
 Obediently I rang the police station. 
 &bquo;I am speaking from the home of Mrs Browning,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;I am a neighbour, and she is being troubled again by&hellip; yes, yes, thank you very much. 
 I will tell her what you say. 
 &bquo;He says he will look round your garden when he comes this way tonight. 
 He says don't be frightened, he's keeping an eye on things for you.&equo; 
 Mrs Browning was still pale and shaky as we settled  ourselves by the fire (and what the moon saw, or what it might have seen if its beams could have penetrated the closely-drawn curtains supplemented by plastic sheeting to foil the poison gas, might have seemed a little unusual; but who can tell what strange sights are enclosed within the cheerful light of a curtained window?). 
 The fire by which we sat, Mrs Browning in front, I to one side, consisted mainly of a branch of beech which she had brought in from the woods: the thick end was in the fireplace, surrounded by burning twigs cosseted into flame by Mrs Browning, who puffed upon them with a pair of leather bellows when they faltered, and the other end, in shape and size rather like the antlers of a deer, reached out into the room. 
 (I was well aware that the man in the bushes was not Mrs Browning's only worry, and that she lived on interest from a small amount of capital fast diminishing in value. 
 &bquo;Could you not perhaps raise a mortgage on your house? 
 Or use a little of your capital?&equo; 
 I could not bring myself to suggest that she was not likely to live much longer, certainly not long enough to make either course imprudent. 
 As it was she was outraged. 
 &bquo;A mortgage! 
 Break into capital! 
 Shame on you. 
 Is that the advice of a friend?&equo;) 
 I was dressed in a heavy winter coat and still wore my gloves. 
 Mrs Browning had a felt hat tied on with a scarf knotted under the chin, a thick tweed suit, woollen gloves, and fleecy-lined suede boots. 
 Round her shoulders was a crocheted shawl, and over her knees the familiar little cover made from knitted woollen squares. 
  Behind, and on two sides, she was protected from cold and poison gas by the leaves of a high screen decorated with scraps by a hand long since dead. 
 Faded photographs, familiar as wallpaper, looked down upon us; and water-colours she had painted when a girl holidaying in Switzerland. 
 On countless little tables and shelves were books and ornaments, photographs in silver frames, and mementoes of that life spent in a hot country far away. 
 In the corner was Mrs Browning's bed. 
 Meticulously she enquired about my health, and we discussed the weather, and a small item of politics. 
 And then we talked of more interesting things, things by now as familiar to me as legend, in a sort of litany, each speaking in turn. 
 First, however, Mrs Browning rose, and gave the branch of wood a good push, making it spark into life; then built a little edifice of twigs, and applied the bellows. 
 Soon there was an exciting blaze. 
 &bquo;A fire always reminds me of my brother Charlie. 
 We two were the youngest in the family and had lovely times together. 
 Fire fascinated him. 
 One day we were crouching by the gardener's bonfire (his pride was that the fire smouldered day and night and never went out). 
 It was a great mound of leaves and garden rubbish nearly as tall as we were &mdash; cabbage stalks, I can smell them now.&equo; 
 (So could I.) 
 &bquo;Charlie had managed to kindle a little fire of dry grass and was adding twigs one by one and I was squatting beside him. 
 It was a hot day, and I think I must have  been half asleep when I noticed something very strange. 
 Little flames were breaking through the brim of Charlie's straw hat. 
 I was so bemused that at first I could do nothing but stare. 
 Then, of course, I came to myself and tore the hat off. 
 Charlie was not at all worried: he was the happiest, sunniest child, and my parents&equo; favourite I think, although they would not have admitted to having favourites. 
 &bquo;In those days the boys went into the church, the army, and so on down the family, and it fell to Charlie to go to the colonies. 
 &bquo;One day a letter came from him asking permission to come home. 
 It was a terrible place, he said. 
 The men were dying like flies, of fever. 
 If he could not come home he knew he would die, too. 
 &bquo;Our father and mother wrote back &mdash; kindly and understandingly I am sure &mdash; but advising him to stick it out like a man. 
 Within a fortnight he was dead. 
 &bquo;We come of a very long-lived family on both sides, but soon after Charlie's death my father died, and then my mother, also.&equo; 
 Mrs Browning was silent. 
 &bquo;They blamed themselves,&equo; I said. 
 &bquo;They died of a broken heart. 
 It doesn't bear thinking about.&equo; 
 And we gazed into the little flickering fire, grieving once more for the parents brought face to face with reality.  
 Her father, like so many country parsons of his day, had interested himself, among other homely pursuits, in keeping chickens. 
 Once he put a broody hen on a clutch of eggs and ten little chicks hatched out. 
 The&ndash;e be put with their mother into the greenhouse, but visiting them the next day found that only five chicks still had legs. 
 He watched. 
 Soon the cat appeared, and enchanted anew by the sight beneath the door of little legs running hither and thither, began expertly to grope. 
 &bquo;My father never could stand the sight of that cat afterwards,&equo; said Mrs Browning. 
 &bquo;He gave it to a farmer. 
 The nursemaid and I took it to him. 
 I sat on our old pony with the cat in a basket, and the nursemaid held the leading rein. 
 It was quite a long way, and coming home she let the pony trot while she ran beside me. 
 She was a jolly sort of girl but I don't think our parents would have kept her if they had known the way she talked to us, and the things she told us. 
 &bquo;About that time there was a notorious murderer at large. 
 If we were naughty or disobedient the nursemaid would threaten us with this man who, she said, hid at night in the high bushes by the gate, and would know what we had done and come and get us. 
 I tried so hard to be good but a lot was expected of children in those days, and I often had nightmares thinking the man would know about me and would come and get me. 
 He was never recaptured.&equo;  
 Tonight it seemed to me that Mrs Browning had still not recovered from her fear, and I suggested that I should perhaps stay and see her into bed. 
 While I made sure the fire was safe she drank a sort of gruel which her home help had left for her in a Thermos. 
 &bquo;I am so lucky,&equo; she said, &bquo;the water in these two hot-water bottles will still be warm enough by the morning for my bath.&equo; 
 So I left her alone, locking the door behind me, and did not see her again (she developed bronchitis, was taken into the cottage hospital and died soon afterwards). 
 The clouds had thickened and the moon had gone when I left her house and made my way cautiously down the slippery brick path. 
 I reached the gate and looked back. 
 There was a faint glimmer of light from her window; it was from the night-light which she kept burning. 
 The house, in outline, looked quite snug, she might even be asleep by this time. 
 &bquo;So boo to you,&equo; I said to the murderer as I went through the gate &mdash; and noticed for the first time that there were no bushes there, just a little hedge of lavender.  
 Forebodings  
 NO one seems to take forebodings seriously, but they do happen, and they do come true, although how they work and from where they come it is hard to say. 
 My friend had a foreboding. 
 She was about nineteen years old at the time, as I was. 
 We had been childhood friends, not from deep affection, or even from admiration, but because we were the same sort of person and trusted one another. 
 We could say anything to each other &mdash; trying out ideas, talking over the happenings in our small world &mdash; and know that we were safe: there would be no teasing in public, no knowing glances, no betrayals. 
 Without having to say anything about it, we trusted one another. 
 We did not always agree. 
 For instance, the Count of Monte Cristo: my friend thought he must be egotistical, because he scratched on the wall of his dungeon, &bquo;Lord, keep my memory green!&equo; 
 Why egotistical? 
 Surely he was only afraid his memories might fade, leaving him dispossessed. 
 But my friend thought that &bquo;Lord, keep my memory green!&equo; meant that he was afraid his name might be forgotten. 
 (Even now I am not sure which of us was right.) 
 Then, when I remarked it was strange that when a person was in trouble, one forgot at once any little  grudge one had against them, so that bearing grudges must be only skin-deep, my friend disagreed: she thought the change of heart was because one was willing to be magnanimous when at advantage, having the upper hand. 
 (There again, I still do not know which of us was right; a little of each, perhaps.) 
 But we knew that nothing we said to each other in private would be laughed at in public. 
 It was in this way that my friend confided in me when she dreamed, with great clarity, that she had been present at her own funeral gathering. 
 There had been a room full of people, and she knew she was dead and it was her own funeral. 
 That was all. 
 She herself was somewhere in the region of the ceiling, looking down. 
 We were both strong healthy girls at the time, and thought nothing of the dream; it was just a curiosity; but she did in fact die two years later &mdash; very suddenly, very unexpectedly, of an infection. 
 I do not feel that I myself am at all psychic and I rarely dream &mdash; at least to know clearly on awakening what I have dreamed; yet I have had in my life two dreams of foreboding. 
 One was strange, because it was about an old lady who meant nothing to me at all; I hardly knew her and only saw her on the rare occasions when I went into her family shop two or three hundred yards from us. 
 She had not been ill. 
 She was a wiry little person one would have expected to live on and on. 
 Nor had there been any talk of her &mdash; that she looked ill, or had been ill &mdash; nothing  at all. 
 But one night I had a vivid dream of her, that she had died. 
 About two days later she did die, without having been ill or, I understand, having shown any sign of failing. 
 I just dreamed out of the blue that she had died, and then she did die. 
 The other dream was much nearer the bone. 
 I dreamed that Elm Cottage, my father's old home (and his father's and grandmother's home before him), was in terrible distress. 
 Not the people in it, just the house. 
 In my dream I was overwhelmed by grief; it woke me, and I had quite a difficulty in getting the horror out of my system. 
 Yet, in any case, I thought, it was nonsense. 
 Nothing at all was happening there, nor was anything likely to happen. 
 It was many years later that my foreboding dream came true. 
 At that time the house belonged to my father's youngest sister. 
 Unmarried, she had lived at Elm Cottage all her life, looking after her parents until they died well into old age. 
 She had been letting the house to my father and mother, but they had now died also, and the whole property was to be sold: the house, yard, outbuildings, flower garden, kitchen garden, and a small meadow. 
 It had come to my grandfather through his great-uncle William Farmborough, on the understanding that he would be looked after in his old age. 
 To my brother and me had fallen the task of disentangling our parents' possessions from the original contents of the house. 
 After that, the solicitors would take over.  
 I happened to be the last person of my family there. 
 I went through the whole place from top to bottom, cleaning it, polishing the furniture, and making everything just so, as my parents would have left it. 
 Then I made one last journey through the house, the precincts, and the gardens, to see that all was as it should be, and to say goodbye. 
 I was not particularly sad that the house was to be sold. 
 It is no good hanging on to the past. 
 I had never lived there, although in my early childhood I had stayed for short periods (but then my mind was occupied in forming pictures; the time had not yet come for looking at those pictures, for interpreting them). 
 Yet I did, in some small way, feel that the house was part of me, and I liked its creaking bouncing floors and its spartan coldness (it was no place for lolling about); its medley of doors &mdash; some Norfolk latch, some brass door-knobbed; the ancient cloudy glass in its leaded windows; the odd corners, shelves and cupboards; its air of fragility, of dignity &mdash; for it was indeed very old; and above all, its village shop smell, of paraffin, strong kitchen soap, cough sweets and aniseed balls, prunes, string, and tobacco. 
 Nevertheless, for me the house had always seemed to stand a little aloof, and as well as a respectful reserve I felt still the restriction of a child in the company of old people: &bquo;Not too much noise, dear, because&hellip; 
 &equo;, &bquo;Careful, careful, you might&hellip; 
 &equo;, &bquo;Don't touch, dear, Grandpa&hellip; 
 &equo;.  I was never perfectly at ease. 
 It had never been my home. 
 So when I went creaking up the winding back staircase to the two attics and looked in through their respective doors (&bquo;Don't touch, dear&hellip; 
 &equo;, &bquo;Gently, gently, the floor&hellip;&equo;), seeing that all was well I did not go right in or disturb the piles of old magazines, wormy furniture, books, and china lying there; after all, they belonged to the house. 
 Below the attics was a back bedroom looking out over the flower garden, and so on to the main road beyond. 
 I had once found two names scratched on one of the window-panes, &bquo;perhaps two soldiers billeted here for a time at the beginning of the 1914 War&hellip;&equo; (or perhaps soldiers in hiding at the time of the Reformation?) 
 I had slept in the bedroom myself not so many years before, and in the first light of morning had got up to see what the village might have looked like before the traffic came and before the stone walls had been breached. 
 It was misty, and there was not a soul in sight, and I had the same eerie feeling which came over me sometimes in other parts of the village. 
 My second uncle must have slept in this room. 
 There was a large framed certificate on the wall, inscribed with his name; he had been awarded a scholarship to the Imperial College to learn wood-carving, being  artistically inclined. 
 My father was taken from his clerking job at Flatford Mill to go to London and look after his brother, a local merchant with interests in the City providing him with a post. 
 My grandfather, for his part, had found lodgings for the two boys through an advertisement in a church magazine. 
 That the advertisement had been in a church magazine was, for my grandfather, sufficient guarantee of respectability, but when the boys arrived in the great city even their inexperience could not hide from them the fact that the respectable lodging was nothing more nor less than a brothel. 
 In spite of the simplicity of their upbringing, however, they were resourceful, and found other rooms, though poor and the food not good. 
 They survived, and for entertainment would buy themselves hot potatoes from a stall for their pockets, and explore London, enjoying particularly the spectacle of the horse-drawn fire-engines thundering out of Cripplegate, often six at a time. 
 Across the landing which interrupted the downward curve of the stairs was a front bedroom where my youngest aunt slept until my grandmother took to her bed &mdash; and afterwards when left alone. 
 At night the room would be full of sounds: the bell of the church clock, so near, so harsh, suddenly striking the hour or half-hour; the chattering of the windows; and always the soughing of the pine trees in the churchyard. 
 There was a bookcase, one row all the work of  &bquo;Amy le Fevre&equo;. 
 I could imagine my aunt as a young girl asking for the latest of the books for birthday or Christmas until she had them all. 
 It is often an effort to read certain books of that period now, and curiously I opened one here and there &mdash; and winced. 
 It was as if all the heroines were cast in circumstances where duty forbade them to marry. 
 Fortunately, it usually happened that the rejected lover did not go away, and when at last the heroine was free, there he was, waiting still. 
 It was not clear whether by this time children were possible for the couple; it was not apparent that the author knew much about that kind of thing. 
 Nor was there any instance, as far as I could see, of the faithful lover dying before his long wait was rewarded; or thought of how the heroine might have felt in such a case, with brothers and sisters flown the nest, father and mother dead, hero dead, the house empty, and the mind, so long attuned and subjected to the needs of other minds, no longer able to recognize and adapt to its own needs. 
 Of my aunt herself has been said, &bquo;She was always so patient; and so kind to the little ones; the kindest, sweetest person I ever knew.&equo; 
 I do remember a little girl called Lucy, a classmate of mine then. 
 We were both about seven years old, and she had not yet developed the ability to pronounce the sounds &bquo;ck&equo; and &bquo;th&equo;. 
 There was a lesson at school I should have loved if it had not been for poor Lucy. 
 It was  called &bquo;In the picture I depict&equo;. 
 A large map, or picture, was unrolled and hung over the blackboard. 
 It was dark with age and looked as if it had been coated with treacle. 
 It showed an imaginary country liberally endowed with features: rivers, mountains, bays, promontories&hellip; 
 The teacher's ruler would point first to a pupil and then to a particular feature on the map. 
 The pupil would then rise, and say, &bquo;In the picture I depict&hellip; a mountain.&equo; 
 How I longed for the ruler to point to me! 
 How I longed to be able to reveal to the world that in the picture I depicted&hellip; a lighthouse. 
 It was such a jolly little lighthouse, white, and standing at the very end of a promontory. 
 Wriggling in our seats we gazed dumbly at the teacher, as dogs will whose owner is eating a slice of cake (Miss! 
 Miss!), all except Lucy, and it was so often Lucy that the ruler sought &mdash; pointing then to the map. 
 An isthmus. 
 Obediently the little girl would rise to her feet, blushing, tears already beginning to gather in her eyes. 
 &bquo;In the pitcher I depit&hellip;&equo; she faltered. 
 &bquo;Speak up, girl!&equo; 
 &bquo;In the pitcher I depit&hellip; an&hellip; 
 &equo; There was a long painful silence, interrupted at last by the teacher's impatient voice. 
 &bquo;Cry! 
 Now cry! 
 That's the next thing to do.&equo; 
 And Lucy lifted her pinafore to her face and collapsed into a heaving, sobbing little bundle. 
 Not so when she went into the shop, carrying the family chicken-feed tin, to whisper, &bquo;Pet-a-torn, please.&equo; 
  My kind aunty knew at once what she meant, but first she would invite Lucy to choose a sweet from the box on the counter. 
 Then, hand in hand they would cross the yard to the shed where there were two great bins, one of mixed corn and one of maize. 
 Here Lucy was lifted up, and allowed to measure her own corn, using a round wooden pottle measure filled to the brim each time and carefully smoothed off. 
 Then back to the shop, with Lucy now taking the money from her pinafore pocket where it had been tied in her handkerchief, and paying for the corn; to go on her way feeling quite a little woman of the world. 
 But there was the Wild Wood. 
 It must have felt solitary sometimes at night alone in that old house now in decline, undermanned, vulnerable. 
 It must have felt lonely when a respected customer (whose name was not exposed even to me) dropped from under her coat the bag of flour she had been concealing there. 
 A bag of flour! 
 It must have made one feel somehow disregarded, almost apart when, thinking to have a small lending library, one sees all the books gradually disappear. 
 It was so pitifully easy for the customers: the temptation so hard to resist, to pick up a bar or two of chocolate from the counter, a packet of tea from the shelf, even a bag of flour, as my aunt came from behind the counter, passed through to the kitchen, down  the steps into the old still-room to draw vinegar from the cask, or paraffin from the tank (its pump rattling up-down, up-down), or across the yard for corn or toppings, or up the back stairs for some item kept on the little landing; so that the shop began to make small profit or none at all. 
 Perhaps it was only natural, only to be expected; but with no one left to share these thoughts, the familiar presence gone, one might in the small hours come to wonder whether, being no longer needed, life was really worth living any more. 
 Through the door, to the big bedroom. 
 On one side was the flower-garden view; on the other, one window had been bricked up at the time when windows were taxed, and I walked over to the remaining window. 
 As I opened it, and looked out, I realized that it was the first time I had consciously looked out:  before, I had always been hurrying by. 
 Now I realized how over the centuries this window must have provided an incomparable panorama of the goings-on in the village. 
 Even in these latter years, &bquo;Only three old women at church yesterday,&equo; my father would greet me hopefully, as cars streamed past in all directions. 
 &bquo;How can you be sure? 
 It is not the only gate.&equo; 
 His eyes would return to his book; so virtuous, so innocent. 
 &bquo;Well, we won't argue,&equo; he would say piously. 
 The house stood at the junction of five roads, and  with its precincts formed one side of a triangle, the second side being the pond, and the third the wide steep steps up to the churchyard. 
 In the centre of this triangle, beneath the spreading branches of the Stocks Tree &mdash; now just a huge hollow stump with a green fringe of leaves sprouting like hair from its crown &mdash; had been the stocks. 
 From medieval times there must have been some kind of dwelling on the slight rise in the ground upon which the house stood. 
 Long, long before that, long before even the church &mdash; and the stone wall half-encircling the primitive source of water &mdash; had been built, cattle would have been brought to drink. 
 I saw the pond as it must have looked then, the converging tracks, and the grassy ascent to the foundations of the church. 
 I tried to see the people, but no picture would come, although among the shadowy figures might well have been a Peter de Fernborough, later Farmborough, who about that time made his appearance somewhere in the village. 
 At least, I thought, their eyes would have looked on that same pond, the pond which now my own eyes saw. 
 The wind stirred the leaves of the willows, and ruffled the water. 
 (The tide was coming in, as my mother would have said.) 
 Then there was the Wild Wood. 
 My father worried, as old people will. 
 When he and my mother came to live at the house he bought five Aylesbury ducks to swim on the pond and clear it of weed. 
 For a whiff the  strong white birds floated proudly there, diving, clearing the weed, and waddling over to the house when my father summoned them, for food and to be shut up for the night. 
 Then, one by one, they were stoned to death. 
 The house was in decline, under-manned, vulnerable. 
 When darkness fell and cavortings could be heard round the edge of the pond within the wall, and on top of and within the hollow shell of the Stocks Tree, my father worried, as old people will. 
 &bquo;Did they know of the deep place in the pond? 
 Could they swim?&equo; 
 And he reserved a ladder and a coil of rope, always to be ready. 
 Then might not the rotting stump of the tree split under their weight and they come to grief? 
 So in winter he kept a large torch to hand, in case. 
 With advancing years, and after the birth of his eighth child, my grandfather left the marriage bed and moved into a bedroom across the landing of the main staircase. 
 Here he had slept as a young boy and until his marriage. 
 When he had been given to Uncle Farmborough to be his heir and to look after him in his old age, he was considered fortunate &mdash; but how could a child reconcile itself to such a strange state of affairs that he had been given away, to the fact that his own father and mother, brother and sister, lived quite near in the village but, as it were, in a different camp? 
 He seems to have grown up rather a solitary boy, and afterwards not by nature a businessman &mdash;  unlike his brother, who quickly outstripped him in enterprise, property, and prosperity. 
 By the time I was born he seems to have become set in his ways. 
 He was not a tall man and was soon almost dwarfed by his five lively, wryly humorous sons, who avoided him as far as possible and could not leave home soon enough. 
 Thus was he deprived of the free manpower which had been his and without which began a slow decline in the market gardening business, the hay and straw, and then even the bakery. 
 Meal times were silent: everyone at the table in time for grace to be said; everyone eating what was set before him. 
 (And yet I remember one morning &mdash; when confronted by a preliminary plate of very sour, very cold slices of orange I could not stop a few tears trickling miserably down my cheeks &mdash; a gruff voice coming from the other end of the table. 
 &bquo;She can leave it if she likes.&equo; 
 I do not forget. 
 Only now, in my old age, I wish I had got down from the table and put my arms round his neck and kissed him. 
 He would have been terribly embarrassed but it might have made him feel &bquo;one of us&equo; for a change.) 
 Not many years after this my grandmother took to her bed, retiring to the room below that in which her husband slept. 
 Over the fireplace was a print of the picture, &bquo;When did you last see your father?&equo;, a present from the  son who had made the beautifully and lavishly carved frame. 
 I have heard her called a professional invalid, but I think by the time she retired to bed she must have been genuinely worn out, and duty done, how seductive must have been the temptation to escape into that room at the end of the house, with its garden door, and warm fire; to write poetry, like Elizabeth Barrett Browning, and to be waited on by her daughter (&bquo;Coming, Mother!&equo;) who would, and did, cope with the house and the shop and even my grandfather. 
 It was not only that my grandmother had given birth to and brought up eight children, and with the help of a Mrs Pipkin (whose wages were ten shillings a week and an egg) run a large house for many years; there was the shop, and shops in those days were by no means labour-saving. 
 For instance, sugar came in huge blocks, so that before weighing it out, sufficient must be chipped off with a knife; and black treacle must be ladled out spoonful by spoonful into the customer's jar. 
 (In summer there were many wasps, encouraged by the plums and pears outside.) 
 On a nest of cotton wool, in a little box, my grandmother kept the two wedding rings which had worn thin, then broken, during her married life, because of her handling of corn. 
 There were babies and there were children to be looked after, also Uncle Farmborough, who must in the end have become old in himself, since there was talk of my grandmother having to change his trousers. 
 On sunny days, when she had washed and dressed him, his  chair would be taken out and placed under the Stocks Tree where he could watch the people come and go. 
 I never remember her dressed other than what in those days would have been considered &bquo;ladylike&equo;, with a touch of white at the high neck, and her hair drawn back, which suited her hairline and the shape of her head. 
 She had pretty hair and must have been nice-looking when she was young. 
 She was meticulous, and kept high standards (&bquo;Surely not millions , dear&equo;), which in itself, I think, must be a wear on a person. 
 There was a game she played with me when I was a very little girl which roused in me a discomfort I identify now as irritation. 
 She would tie a knot in two of the four corners of a handkerchief and fix one knot on each of her forefingers, to form puppets. 
 One puppet was a priest, and the other a penitent: 
 &bquo;Father Confessor,&equo; (bowing) &bquo;I've come to confess my sins.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, my child, yes.&equo; 
 (nodding) 
 &bquo;Last night I filled a dish with cream&hellip; &bquo; 
 &bquo;Yes, my child, yes.&equo; 
 &bquo;But in the night, puss stole my cream&hellip; &bquo; 
 &bquo; Yes, my child, yes  &mdash; &bquo; 
 &bquo;And I said, &bquo;BLOW the cat!&equo;&equo; 
 She taught me little songs, always with a moral: 
 Old John had an apple tree, spreading and green, 
 Which bore the best apples that ever were seen; 
 So rosy, and mellow, and red. 
 And as the years passed, Old John he grew poor, 
 And sold them to children who passed by his door 
 To buy him a morsel of bread. 
 Little boy, little boy, take your hand from that tree ! 
 Remember there's someone who always can see 
 As well in the dark as the light. 
 She died of bronchitis at the age of seventy-seven. 
 &bquo;I blame myself,&equo; my aunt had said. 
 &bquo;I had gone Outside to empty the bedpan&hellip; 
 &equo; (&bquo;Outside&equo; was quite a sumptuous place in its little way; a good walk from the house, along a winding path between yew and box trees and down some artistically rounded white steps, to a trellised porch with chequered black and red tiled floor, where an escort might wait on a dark night. 
 The inside was lime-washed white, with colour supplement pictures from magazines on the walls; and there were two well-scrubbed seats, one large for grown-ups and one small for children.) 
 &bquo;When I got back I found I had left the garden door a little ajar; she must have taken a chill. 
 I blame myself !&equo; 
 Directly beneath my grandmother's room was the cellar, approached through a white-painted door in the sitting-room. 
 On the wall of that room was a patch where the barometer had hung &mdash; so familiar a face that I had hardly realized it was there. 
 When the meter man came for the last time he spoke of my aunt, and of the many years he had been to the house, so that he felt himself to be almost  an old friend. 
 He said how he had noticed the barometer as he passed through the sitting-room on his way to the kitchen where the meters were. 
 It had always been his ambition to own a barometer; could he buy this one? 
 I said there was to be a sale, but I would ask the solicitor; and afterwards, when he came to take the barometer away, he took it down from the wall very, very gently. 
 He said this kind needed gentle handling; he seemed to know a lot about barometers, and to be delighted with his purchase. 
 He said he had a friend who had a great interest in grandfather clocks. 
 It was his hobby. 
 He himself had always noticed the one in the corner as he passed through, and his friend&hellip; 
 Was there a whiff of the Wild Wood! 
 Soon after my mother had died, I had noticed a gap in the familiar contours of the furniture in the room leading out of the sitting-room &mdash; it was where the shop had once been, entered then via the yard gate and a large open porch. 
 The table! 
 The round mahogany table, friend of my childhood, under whose shelter I had lain and read; whose clawed brass feet I had cleaned every Saturday morning when young, and then later, admiring them all the time &mdash; never having seen any other claws as fine or as lifelike as these. 
 My father (my poor father!) was trying to look unconcerned. 
 &bquo;There's a chap &mdash; he's been coming round for  years going on and on at me about buying the table. 
 I let him have it to get rid of him. 
 He had a good look at it and said part of the pedestal had been mended at some time which took away a lot of the value. 
 He gave me twenty pounds.&equo; 
 I said no more about the table, not a word. 
 My poor father! 
 Even when, halfway through the morning he broke out with, &bquo;Well, there's no need for you to keep on and on about the table,&equo; I did not point out that I had said nothing, that it was he who was &bquo;going on and on about it&equo; inside himself. 
 Then the kitchen; and the small scullery, bathroom, and lavatory, which had taken the place of the older, larger scullery. 
 Everything was in order. 
 Then the pantry &mdash; the old still-room &mdash; and up into the yard, with its pigsties, stables, cart sheds, barn, bakehouse, and wash-house, soon to be bulldozed&hellip; 
 And again, &bquo;Don't touch, dear&hellip; 
 &equo;. So that I disturbed nothing, but went out through a door into the walled kitchen garden &mdash; the garden with its crumbly black soil enriched by centuries of pigs, pails, and poultry, where soon houses would stand. 
 Along almost the whole of one wall was trained a cultivated blackberry bush. 
 (Many years before, an uncle of mine had run along the top of that wall carrying a doormat which he had placed carefully on top of the chimney of the little building adjacent called the  Reading Room. 
 Within the room a meeting of the Coal Club was in progress, while in the shadows, others of my uncles crouched, waiting to see what would happen.) 
 Of late my father had lent the greater part of this ground to a retired gardener and his wife, who had little garden of their own. 
 At first my mother had found it difficult to remember their name, which was rather an unusual one: &bquo;Praise-my-soul-the-King-of-Heaven-to-His-feet-thy-TRIBUTE&hellip; 
 Mr Tribute &hellip; 
 &equo;. They were what my father called &bquo;house-proud gardeners&equo; &mdash; that is, they kept the garden tended immaculately. 
 There was a seat against a sunny back wall, and I would come upon the couple sitting there looking out over the garden and their handiwork, planning in quiet voices what should be done next, the next moves. 
 He was bent with arthritis but was the master spirit, the source of garden wisdom. 
 She did the bending and the kneeling, and they worked together hand in glove. 
 I can see them there as in a picture when, for the last time, arthritis having finally prevailed, they sat quietly together in the sun contemplating a magnificent crop of potatoes spread out to dry &mdash; the final gift of that bounteous old garden. 
 I came out of the front door and fitted the key into the familiar lock. 
 It seemed rather an historic moment, but I put the thought aside; one must not get sentimental,  and everything had been done properly, had been left in order and as it should be. 
 So I walked away, breaking my journey home to leave the key with the solicitors. 
 A few days later, the house was ruthlessly, mercilessly, vandalized. 
 I heard of it indirectly, and from different sources: &bquo;even the telephone torn from its moorings!&equo;, &bquo;chamber-pots smashed, windows smashed, doors kicked in!&equo;, &bquo;things thrown about, things broken, things taken away &mdash; there was hardly a house in the village that did not get something!&equo; 
 To some extent there was a rational explanation. 
 A short time before, estate agents' men had put up a board to say that five houses were to be built &mdash; but they had erected it in the flower garden of the house instead of in the field as they had been instructed. 
 I had, in fact, noticed this and had reported it, asking that the board should be moved at once in case the impression was given that the house was about to be demolished. 
 There was a rational explanation; but there seems no explanation as to why, thirty years before, the violation of the house should have disturbed my sleep.  
 &bquo; Milkmaid's Rest &equo; 
 THERE was a small piece of spare ground on the other side of the hedge at the end of our garden, and on it, newly arrived, a caravan. 
 It was an old-fashioned caravan with a single room, not one of the modern kind which are really almost like little houses. 
 Outside, driven into the ground, was a painted name-board which read, &bquo;Milkmaid's Rest&equo;. 
 The word &bquo;milkmaid&equo; brings to my mind a picture implanted there perhaps by a song we used to sing at school: 
 And as I walked farther, 
 I chanc&egrave;d to see; 
 A cow and a pretty maid 
 Under a tree. 
 It was not like that at &bquo;Milkmaid's Rest&equo;. 
 Instead of a cow, there was a goat, tethered by a long chain; and the milkmaid herself had, I believe, been a lecturer at one of the German universities until war came. 
 She was elderly, short, and rather stout, with iron-grey hair closely cropped. 
 Her eyes were crookedly set, which gave her a humorous, quizzical expression quite in keeping with her manner and disposition. 
 They were blue eyes, which one would guess might have been quite piercingly blue when she was younger. 
 I could well imagine her lecturing:  she would be wearing a mortar-board and gown perhaps, her head on one side as she usually held it when talking; and her eyes would be twinkling, as she held forth in that clear, incisive, &bquo;educated&equo; voice of hers. 
 While pottering about her domain she wore old-fashioned riding breeches ending just below the knee, followed by surprisingly pink, surprisingly chubby, bare legs. 
 (As I write, I hesitate &mdash; I would not like to be disrespectful &mdash; but continue, because the picture would not otherwise be true, and I think that she, above all people, would agree that a description should be true.) 
 Next came a pair of thick socks wrinkling about the ankles, and then what seemed to be a pair of men's shoes. 
 She had a variety of cardigans and other woollies. 
 When she went shopping to the town she wore a long, voluminous, dark-grey cloak of which she was very proud. 
 It had been made in Austria, I believe, of wool so densely woven as to be impervious to rain. 
 She was an intellectual and an eccentric, and anyone less like the poetic image of a milkmaid it would be hard to find. 
 After a time the goat disappeared, and its place was taken by some hens, and these hens I looked after when, as quite often happened, their mistress went away for a few days. 
 In return, she offered to look after my own birds when I went away for one weekend (it was after the war but rationing was still in force, and most people who could, kept chickens). 
 I held back a little before leaving them in her care, because as well as the hens there were eleven chicks; she was a person full of goodwill and  theories, but not practical. 
 When I returned, six of my eleven chicks had died, but I said nothing. 
 I still had five, and I had rather expected something of the kind might happen. 
 When I took my children to bed at night they would pause to look through a little knee-high window which lit the stairs. 
 In winter, some way down into the darkness outside, there shone a square of light, and outlined within this square was a head. 
 It was our neighbour, playing patience. 
 That was a particularly cold winter. 
 I went down to the caravan one day to take some apples, and was startled to see a continuous ripple of ice on the inside of the caravan wall just by my friend's plump, inviting-looking pillow. 
 She disregarded such things altogether, rather relished them, in fact; and she must have been very strong, because I never knew her to show any weakness, nor to be other than her usual cheerful, robust-spirited self. 
 Eventually she moved down the hill to live in more conventional quarters, and I would meet her sometimes, she dressed, as usual, in her cloak. 
 She subscribed to a sort of education-orientated noblesse oblige  which prevailed at the time, and would organize plays, and patronize enthusiastically any local concert party or visiting production, especially of Shakespeare; and she invited me to her poetry readings, where members of the circle read poems on a prepared subject, in turn. 
 I refrained, saying that I could never in any circumstances read poetry aloud in public. 
 Bach time we  met she invited me, and each time I declined. 
 In the end she suggested that I should just come and listen, and for politeness' sake I agreed. 
 There was one member whose sight was so bad that when she read she not only had to prop a second pair of spectacles on top of the pair already resting on her nose, but also had to stand under the standard lamp almost pressed against the light bulb. 
 As I watched her reading, with such difficulty but with so much pleasure, a poem she evidently loved, something inside me said, &bquo; Be ashamed !&equo; 
 I was ashamed; and thenceforward I took my turn with the rest &mdash; to my benefit. 
 There was an impression that my milkmaid friend was what is called well-connected, and I am glad to say that as she grew old she was, as it were, gathered in, to be near her relatives. 
 In this way she lived to be a hundred years old, more or less. 
 Towards the end of that time she sent me a letter (not entirely personal, being printed, in facsimile handwriting): 
 Both my mind and my eyesight are becoming very worn and I can no longer write and answer letters as I should wish. 
 But I want all my friends to know that there is not any weakening of affection. 
 As the physical brain gets worn out it loses the power to record and express the action of the spirit. 
 But the spirit is immortal and will recover its powers when it is freed from the physical brain. 
 So please keep our friendship as strong as ever, though I am losing the power to give it outward expression. 
 Metalwork: Artifice and artistry Michael Cowell and Susan la Niece 
 Even after overcoming the tremendous technical difficulties of mining and smelting metals, the end result of all this endeavour was a raw material that still required the considerable skills of the metalsmith to turn it into artefacts, whether practical, artistic or both. 
 These skills are perhaps no better illustrated than by the finds from the ship-burial at Sutton Hoo. 
 This burial mound, probably for the Anglo-Saxon King Redwald, contained a rich treasure which gives a startling insight into the wealth of the ruling classes in seventh-century East Anglia. 
 It includes, amongst other objects, drinking vessels, iron weapons and chain mail, huge silver dishes imported from the eastern Mediterranean, a lyre, ivory gaming pieces, fine gold personal jewellery and regalia, and coins. 
 Understandably, the splendour of the goldwork &mdash; inlaid with garnets backed by gold foil to enhance their appearance &mdash; attracts immediate attention (plate 5.1). 
 But the skills involved are at least equalled by those lavished on some of the base metal objects, such as the iron sword with its complex design of pattern welding (see p. 88) and the intricately cast and decorated escutcheons on the hanging bowls. 
 The study of metalwork such as that from Sutton Hoo provides a variety of information about an individual site and the technical competence of the culture which created the artefacts: for example, suggesting the source of materials used, establishing the technology employed to prepare and alloy (mix) the metals, and determining how the artefacts were fabricated and decorated. 
 In some cases this involves experimental work to test particular theories of how certain processes were carried out and the ways that artefacts were constructed. 
 The quality or many of the individual objects makes the site of Sutton Hoo exceptional. 
 However, their archaeological importance is enhanced compared with that of equally fine stray finds because of the association with other artefacts from an excavated context. 
 The humble iron rivets, for example. 
 were all that remained of the boat at Sutton Hoo. 
 Individually they are of little importance, but collectively. 
 and excavated in their original positions, they are fundamental in establishing the ships lines. 
 The amazing variety of metal artefacts in the ancient world was created with only a few different metals: copper, tin, lead, silver, gold, iron, arsenic and zinc. 
 Initially the latter two metals only occur in alloys as they were not generally isolated in metallic form until the medieval period. 
 Copper and iron were most commonly used as both are tough and easily shaped. 
 Silver and gold are rare and were prized for their monetary value, appearance  and resistance to corrosion. 
 The remaining metals were mainly used to modify the properties of the others by alloying and for specialised functions in construction such as joining by soldering. 
 All of these metals were already in widespread use in their own right or in alloys over two thousand years ago and some have much earlier origins. 
 Native (natural metallic) copper was probably first used about the eighth millennium BC. and the earliest smelted metals, copper and lead, date from the fifth or sixth millennium BC. 
 Perhaps surprisingly, even today most of these metals are still of considerable importance and few &bquo;new&equo; metals have superseded them except for certain specialised uses; one metal unknown to the ancients which is used in large quantities today is aluminium. 
 Metal is one of the most versatile materials known; it can be melted and poured into a mould of almost any shape, hammered into thin sheets, drawn into fine wires and extruded as rods and pipes. 
 Most importantly, when a metal artefact is damaged or becomes redundant, the metal can easily be melted down and recycled into another artefact. 
 Furthermore, any number of metal components can be joined together to make complex shapes, leading to an almost limitless variety of products. 
 Some of these basic shaping methods were used to manufacture artefacts in metal from the very beginnings of metallurgy, when only native metals were available. 
 However, the quantity of metal available from native sources was limited in most parts of the world and consequently the major use of metals and alloys for artefacts was dependent on developments in smelting (see also Chapter 4). 
 Developments in alloying 
 Copper alloys 
 Copper was the first metal to become available in quantity for general use and the metal and its alloys have retained their importance to the present day. 
 Much early copper contains a small percentage of arsenic and this, arsenical copper, was the first alloy to be put to practical use throughout the ancient world. 
 Initially the manufacture of arsenical copper was accidental. 
 Arsenic is very volatile and was unobtainable by ancient smelting techniques, but arsenic minerals commonly occur in association with copper ores and an alloy with a few per cent can be obtained by smelting these. 
 However, once the properties of the alloy were appreciated, the ores were no doubt deliberately selected, or arsenic minerals may have been added to molten copper. 
 Arsenical copper could never have been easy to make or work with; during smelting, clouds of poisonous arsenious oxide are produced and in re-melting the alloy some of the arsenic may be lost. 
 It is not surprising, therefore. 
 that tin bronze replaced it. 
 Although tin sources are rarer than those of arsenic (or arsenic-rich copper), the metal is much easier to smelt and can be added in precisely controlled amounts to the copper. 
 Tin bronze had almost completely superseded arsenical copper by the end of the second millennium BC although the scale of this change varied considerably throughout the Old World.  
 Brass is another important alloy of copper (made with zinc), which first appears during the latter half of the first millennium BC and was widely used from the Roman period onwards. 
 It has an attractive yellow colour and in certain properties, such as its ductility, it is superior to bronze. 
 As with arsenical copper, there were difficulties in the manufacture of brass, because zinc metal is also highly reactive and volatile and was not isolated in quantity until the fifteenth century AD in India. 
 The alloy was produced by a process called cementation. 
 This involved heating zinc ore and charcoal with metallic copper in a closed vessel to about 1000&deg;C. 
 The zinc, which at this temperature is liberated as a gas, is absorbed by the copper to form the alloy. 
 A process essentially the same as this was used for brass-making in Europe until the nineteenth century, when it became more economical to alloy metallic zinc directly with copper. 
 Iron Towards the end of the second millennium BC, but particularly during the first millennium BC, developments in smelting technology meant that iron became available. 
 Because of their superior strength and durability, iron and ultimately steel (the alloy with carbon) largely replaced copper-based alloys as the preferred materials for the manufacture of many functional items such as tools and weapons. 
 The greater abundance of iron ores over those of copper also meant that iron was more readily obtainable and cheaper. 
 Gold, silver and lead 
 Many other metals and alloys were of course discovered and used throughout the ancient world. 
 though few could rival iron and those based on copper for the sheer amounts used in artefact manufacture. 
 Gold and silver have attracted particular attention because they were used to make prestige items such as jewellery and regalia. 
 As a native metal, gold required no extraction by smelting. 
 However, it commonly occurs as a natural alloy with silver, and methods were therefore developed to purify the gold. 
 This was done by reacting the silver in the alloy with salt at high temperatures, leaving the gold unaffected. 
 Metalworking remains at Sardis in Turkey suggest that this process, called &bquo;parting&equo;, was employed there in the sixth century BC to refine gold from the river Pactolus. 
 Most ancient silver was extracted from argentiferous (silver-rich) lead by cupellation, a process dating back to at least the second millennium BC, which involved oxidising the lead to molten litharge (lead oxide), leaving the relatively unreactive silver as the metal. 
 Lead was first used at about the same time as copper, though it was seldom used to make artefacts in its own right. 
 Lead was far more important as a metal added to bronze to modify its properties and to alloy with tin to form pewter and soft solder. 
 Soft solder is of course an aid to artefact manufacture as opposed to a raw material for overall construction, and is one of a whole range of alloys with more specialised applications in metalwork.  
 Metal properties and selection 
 Depending on the materials available, the choice of what metal or alloy to use for a particular artefact would be influenced mainly by its intended function and how it was to be manufactured. 
 Although many artefacts are made of pure metals, rather more are made of alloys. 
 The main reason for using alloys is to modify the mechanical and physical properties of metals to suit the item being manufactured. 
 By mixing metals it is possible to make alloys which are tougher, more ductile, have a different colour, a lower melting point, or flow more easily when molten than the individual component metals. 
 Bronze 
 Bronze illustrates the variety which is possible with copper-based alloys. 
 By alloying tin with copper to make bronze we obtain a metal which is much tougher than copper alone. 
 It is also more suitable for casting because its melting point is lower and the tin reacts with gases dissolved in the molten alloy, preventing porosity. 
 The precise properties of the alloy depend on the amount of tin added. 
 Up to about 10 per cent of tin gives an alloy that is red to gold in colour and ductile enough for easy shaping by hammering, provided that the alloy is annealed (heated to remove internal stresses). 
 Working without annealing increases the hardness but also makes the alloy brittle and ultimately liable to crack. 
 By selective working, though, part of an object such as a cutting edge could be made harder. 
 With 15 to 20 per cent of tin or more, the alloy becomes brittle and almost unworkable, although it can still be cast to shape, and as more tin is added it becomes whiter in colour. 
 The alloy is nevertheless still useful for a variety of purposes. 
 It is sonorous and therefore very suitable for making bells. 
 When polished it is also highly reflective and was thus widely used for mirrors. 
 The decorative properties of high-tin bronze were also exploited, for example in the surrounds to the escutcheons on the Sutton Hoo hanging bowl (fig. 5.1).  
 The properties of bronze can be further modified by introducing other metals such as lead. 
 Adding lead makes the alloy easier to cast because the melting point is reduced and the fluidity is increased. 
 The molten alloy will penetrate all parts of the mould more quickly before solidifying, thus allowing the craftsman to make more detailed and intricate castings. 
 However, lead is only slightly soluble in copper and forms a separate metallic phase in the alloy. 
 This means that leaded bronze is relatively weak and may explain why the statuette in Figure 5.2, which has a particularly high lead content of about 30 per cent, was broken at the neck. 
 Heavily leaded alloys were therefore not generally used for artefacts which required high mechanical strength. 
 In addition, too much lead spoils the finish of mercury- or fire-gilding (see page 90), so leaded alloys were avoided if this particular decoration was to be applied. 
 Iron 
 Although the mechanical properties of copper-based alloys are readily modified by working and heat treatment, they are not as versatile as iron in this respect. 
 Provided that iron contains some carbon, introduced by carburisation (heating under charcoal), it can be hardened by quenching, that is by cooling rapidly in oil or water. 
 The metal may be somewhat brittle after this but a final tempering process (heating to a moderate temperature, followed by slow cooling) relieves the internal stresses, leaving a hard and durable finished product which is mechanically stronger than bronze. 
 The whole process produces characteristic structural changes in the metal which can be detected by microscopic study of sections through the artefact. 
 The first known use of carburisation and quenching of iron dates back to the eleventh and tenth centuries BC in Cyprus and  Palestine. 
 Although the processes were used spasmodically after that, they were not applied consistently and effectively until the Dark Ages and the medieval period. 
 The study of metal use 
 The vast majority of functional objects and many prestigious artefacts have long been manufactured from copper and its alloys. 
 The analysis of these metal objects can range from simply identifying the composition of an individual item or its component parts to studying the general development of metal use. 
 The technique of atomic absorption spectrophotometry (AAS) (see glossary) is often used to analyse copper-based metals. 
 Apart from quantifying the alloying metals, it also measures trace metals which can sometimes be used to &bquo;finger-print&equo; an individual supply of metal (fig. 5.2). 
 The applications of copper-based metals were extensive, and as new alloys became available through developments in smelting they were exploited in new ways. 
 Evidence of how the properties of these metals were manipulated can indicate the technical level of a society at any given time. 
 To build up an impression of how metal use developed, many and various artefacts covering a long time span need to be examined. 
 The chronological introduction of different alloys can then be compared between different cultures and geographical areas. 
 A typical study of ancient Egyptian tools and weapons, particularly axes, shows that four copper-based metals or alloys were used from the early third millennium BC to the middle of the first millennium BC: &bquo;pure&equo; copper; arsenical copper (an alloy of copper with up to h per cent of arsenic); tin bronze or leaded tin bronze; and iron. 
 In a study of metal development such as this it is essential to examine datable or chronologically ordered artefacts. 
 Some Egyptian axes can be dated by association with datable material in excavation contexts and occasionally by an inscription. 
 However, the principal indicator is often typology, the way axe shapes changed over time to accommodate different methods of hafting and specialisation in use (fig. 5.3).  
 When the proportions of the dated axes made from the four copper-based metals are arranged chronologically (fig. 5.4), a trend is evident. 
 During the third millennium BC most axes were made of unalloyed copper and few were of arsenical copper, but by the middle of the third millennium arsenical copper gradually supplanted copper and this, in turn, was replaced by tin bronze and also some leaded tin bronze. 
 This development was of course gradual and there were long periods when several alloys were in use. 
 The alloys are entirely typical of other cultures in the Near East and elsewhere, but the Egyptians were rather slower to adopt tin bronze. 
 This may have been as much due to tradition as to limited supplies or tin. 
 Consistent with its fluidity and lack of strength, leaded bronze is mainly confined to decorative axes requiring detailed casting which were probably not produced for functional use. 
 Similar studies have been carried out on axes from the British Isles and, whilst the same alloys were used, the time scale of their introduction and use was quite different. 
 The advent of copper began much later, in the middle of the third millennium BC; whilst arsenical copper was used, it was replaced by tin bronze at a much earlier date. 
 by the beginning of the second millennium. 
 Arsenical copper use was therefore very shortlived in Britain, compared with Egypt. 
 Admittedly, the British Isles had substantial tin deposits, a resource which Egypt does not seem to have possessed. 
 As well as charting chronological developments in alloying, it is also possible to examine those changes dictated by the specialised use of artefacts. 
 We know, from representations of Egyptian axes on wall paintings, that initially the same type of axe was used as both tool and weapon. 
 Gradually, however, different shapes developed to suit the respective functions, and the visual appearance of the separate tool and weapon types suggests that different alloys were used for each. 
 In fact, the tools turn out to be either simply copper or arsenical copper (none are made of bronze), whereas weapons are never made of copper alone and most are tin bronze. 
 The few weapons that are made of arsenical copper contain more arsenic than the tools, thus making them potentially harder. 
 The weapons were therefore a superior product at the forefront of developments in alloying. 
  The extra cost of a harder and more lasting cutting edge was a wise investment &mdash; warriors would have had little time to re-sharpen their blades in the heat of battle! 
 An alloy which was not available to the ancient Egyptians because the required technology had not been developed was brass ( oreichalcum  or oreichalkos  to the ancient writers), the alloy of copper with zinc. 
 The Romans produced coins from this alloy which, in the first century AD, contained about 25 per cent zinc. 
 They did not have to isolate zinc metal to do this but used the cementation process described on page 76. 
 Artefacts made of brass before the Roman period (that is, before the end of the first millennium BC) are rare, although there are numerous historical references to oreichalcum  before this. 
 Many of these references indicate that the process originated in Asia Minor, in particular the region of Phrygia, near zinc ore deposits which are known to have been worked in antiquity. 
 This association was confirmed by analysis of early first-century BC Greek coins (fig. 5.5) from the region; some of these coins proved to be made of brass typical of the cementation process and they thus pre-date Roman use of the alloy. 
 They are probably the earliest reliably dated brass artefacts known. 
 A major restriction in the cementation brass-making process was the limited amount of zinc which could be introduced into the alloy. 
 Using the ancient method, the maximum zinc content was about 28 per cent, but as the process developed this increased to about 33 per cent. 
 To make brass containing more zinc than this required access to zinc metal. 
 Another disadvantage of the cementation process was that impurities from the zinc ore, such as iron, became incorporated into the alloy and had a detrimental effect on its mechanical and corrosion-resistant properties. 
 Such features enable us to recognise brass made using metallic zinc as opposed to cementation. 
 Analyses of Chinese statues and coins show that they did not make much use of brass until about the sixteenth century AD. 
 When they did make extensive use of it for coinage, however, the high zinc and low iron content of the coins indicates that they must have used metallic zinc rather than cementation.  
 Precious metals 
 In antiquity all metal was a valuable commodity and rarely wasted. 
 Metal extraction was difficult, sources of non-ferrous ores are particularly scarce and these, and the smelting sites, were often far removed from where the majority of the artefacts were eventually used. 
 Even base metals were probably recycled, as evidenced by finds of non-ferrous scrap metal hoards from, for example, the Late Bronze Age in Britain. 
 Traditionally, gold and silver were the most highly prized metals although occasionally other metals or alloys were equally in demand. 
 For example, Plato, writing in the first century AD, says that some regarded oreichalkos  (brass) as being above silver, and more recently, in the nineteenth century, when aluminium first became available as an expensive novelty it was used in place of silver for prestige items. 
 As one would expect, the composition of precious metal artefacts has always been heavily influenced by economic factors and it became common practice to modify their value by alloying them with baser metals. 
 However, this also has a desirable practical side-effect. 
 Pure gold and silver are soft metals but, when alloyed together or with copper, a harder alloy is produced that is more resistant to wear and distortion. 
 This is clearly an essential attribute for articles of jewellery and functional items such as tableware. 
 Roman silver dishes, for example, are usually made of high purity silver, typically over 94 per cent, but also contain a small percentage of copper (about 3 per cent). 
 The Roman refining techniques were such that they could easily have produced silver containing only traces of copper (under 1 per cent). 
 Therefore, the small amounts of copper were almost certainly added deliberately to harden the alloy without significantly debasing the silver. 
 The chemical analysis of precious metal artefacts can be difficult because their value and decorative finish usually prevent sampling. 
 The technique of X-ray fluorescence (XRF) (see glossary) is often used for these because of its non-destructive capabilities (fig. 5.6).  
 Alloys of gold and silver with baser metals have long been controlled by established standards, first for coinage and then for plate, such as the English sterling standard guaranteed by a hallmark. 
 Items were tested for compliance with such standards by assaying, a method of analysis, and by the use of a touchstone, a dark-coloured stone on which the colour of a streak of the alloy indicates its quality. 
 The sterling standard for silver (925 parts per thousand of silver with the remainder being mainly copper) has its origins in the fourteenth century and has continued virtually without interruption to the present day. 
 During the period from 1697 to 1720, however, the higher Britannia standard became the legal requirement. 
 Silver of this period should conform to the Britannia standard but does not always do so. 
 The maker's marks on some English watchcases suggest that some manufacturers continued to make their cases from sterling silver and this has been confirmed by analysis. 
 Occasionally the inner and outer cases of the same watch were made of silver of different standards. 
 Although the using up of old stock may be one reason for this practice, watchcase-makers were probably also reluctant to use Britannia silver because it is a softer alloy than sterling. 
 Apart from the increased likelihood of abrasion on an item being constantly handled, it was also important that the case did not become distorted, thus preventing precise closure. 
 A guarantee of the quality and quantity of precious metals for the purposes of exchange is coinage. 
 Until the last hundred years or so, the purchasing value of coins was closely related to the intrinsic value of the metal they were made from. 
 The value of this precious metal could be modified by alloying with baser materials. 
 The most direct way of revealing a society's economic state is therefore to study the quality. 
 or fineness, of its currency. 
 The most common pattern is one of debasement, that is, increasing amounts of base metal in the alloy (possibly coupled with a decrease in the weight of the coin), followed by occasional reforms. 
 A classic example of this was the debasement of the English silver coinage by Henry VIII to raise additional money for his treasury. 
 The systematic reduction in the standard from sterling (92. 5 per cent silver) to one containing only 33.3 per cent silver caused widespread inflation. 
 The coinage standard was subsequently reformed under Edward VI and Elizabeth I. 
 Although we are now familiar with coins bearing precise dates. 
 this was not usually the case with ancient coin series. 
 Trends in coin fineness can therefore often help to place an otherwise undatable series in chronological order. 
 For example, a study of the debasement trends of sixth-to seventh-century AD European gold coinage provided a basis for dating the Sutton Hoo ship burial. 
 The thirty-seven Frankish gold coins. 
 three coin blanks and two ingots found in the Sutton Hoo purse (plate 5.1) belong to the Merovingian series. 
 Unfortunately Merovingian coins do not carry explicit dates although some examples can be dated by, for example, association with other coins in hoards. 
 When these dated issues were analysed a fairly steady debasement trend was discovered and this allowed the approximate fineness of the coinage at any particular time to be charted. 
 By comparing  the fineness of the Sutton Hoo coins themselves with this trend, it was possible to say that the basest and therefore latest coins in the purse were made in the 620s AD, thus defining the earliest probable date for the ship burial. 
 Manufacturing techniques 
 The choice of manufacturing technique is to some extent governed by the metal or alloy used and by the intended finished shape. 
 For objects which need some thickness of metal, like ingots or axes, casting is the obvious method, while others, like fine wire or thin sheet metal, need extensive working. 
 In many cases, however, the method used is not immediately obvious. 
 For example, a bowl may be formed by casting, by hammering up the sides from a fiat disc, or by a combination of casting (for the basic dish shape) and working up details, like the rim. 
 In rare instances, there is still evidence of manufacturing methods, for example the clay moulds used for casting bronze bridle bits and other equestrian equipment found at the Iron Age site of Gussage All Saints or stone moulds for weapons (fig. 5.7). 
 Other clues to the manufacturing process might be found by examining the object itself. 
 In casting, the molten metal may have squeezed between the joins of a mould, solidifying as a seam-like ridge known as a casting flash. 
 Casting flashes can often be seen running down the sides of objects such as bronze palstaves (fig. 5.8), which were cast in two-part moulds. 
 The ends of the chaplets (metal pins used to hold a clay core in position inside the mould of a hollow statue or vessel during casting) may show up as small patches of a different alloy on the surface of the finished piece.  
 The clay core is usually removed after casting but the chaplets, which are made of an alloy with a higher melting temperature so that they will not melt during the casting process, become embedded in the metal. 
 Similarly, concentric lines radiating from the central pip on the base of a Roman silver dish reveal that it was finished on a lathe (fig. 5.9), and the impressions left by the craftsman's hammer can be seen on the sides of a brass Islamic jug. 
 Where none of these clues are apparent, the answer may sometimes be found by examining the internal structure of the metal itself. 
 Polished metal looks as smooth and featureless as glass to the naked eye but, unlike glass, it is a crystalline material; it solidifies as a network of tiny grains which can be seen if the metal is etched with a dilute acid and examined under a microscope (fig. 5.11a). 
 If a lump of cast metal is hammered and annealed, the structure will be modified (fig. 5.1 lb). 
 The microstructure seen is influenced by the composition of the metal and the treatment it has received. 
 It was this characteristic of metal which revealed the manufacturing history of a bronze stand of the Italian Late Bronze Age (1250&ndash;900 BC). 
 It belongs to a group of stands and tripods made in Cyprus and Sardinia which were probably used to support round-bottomed ceramic vessels. 
 The stands are composed of a series of metal rods (fig. 5.10), and two possible methods of construction had been proposed. 
 Either they were made up of a large number of bronze rods, hammered to shape and soldered together. 
 or they were cast by the lost wax process from a model made of wax rods. 
 There was no decisive evidence from examination of the surface, from analysis or from radiography, of which technique had been used. 
 However, examination of the microstructure of the metal at a convenient break provided conclusive proof that the stands had been made by casting: the structure is typical of a cast bronze, with 15 per cent lead in the alloy (fig. 511c).  
 Joining techniques 
 Many metal objects are made of more than one component. 
 Mechanical joins such as rivets are easily recognised but, from as early as 2500 BC in Sumer, smiths developed methods of joining one metal with another of a lower melting point. 
 Soldering alloys are usually categorised as either &bquo;soft&equo; or &bquo;hard&equo;. 
 The main difference between the two is the melting point of the solder. 
 A temperature of 450&dollar;C is usually accepted as the upper limit for soft solders, whereas hard solders have a higher melting point. 
 In antiquity, regardless of the metal being joined, soft solder was generally tin or lead or an alloy of the two. 
 Soft solder joins like a glue, without significant interdiffusion (or exchange) with the metals it bonds, leaving the composition of metal and solder essentially unchanged. 
 Hard solders, on the other hand, were usually of the same metal as the object they were used on, but alloyed with a few per cent of another metal in order to reduce the melting point. 
 For example, the ideal composition for a solder to attach a silver handle to a silver jug would be 28 per cent copper and 72 per cent silver. 
 This is the silver copper alloy with the lowest melting point (780&dollar;C). 
 known as the eutectic composition. 
 Hard solders join by interdiffusion at  high temperatures with the metals being bonded, so that composition at the join will be somewhere between that of the solder and that of the object. 
 Soldered joints are often difficult to spot visually, but radiography is helpful for detecting them if the solder is denser than the rest of the object or if there is a cavity at the joint. 
 The technique used is much the same as that used in hospitals to find fractures in bones; where the metal is broken the film is blackened by the X-rays which pass unhindered through the break; where the metal is densest, more of the X-rays are stopped and the film remains pale. 
 The image in Figure 5.12 of an inlaid Islamic brass ewer is formed by X-rays passing through the ewer and on to a sheet of film beneath it. 
 Unlike a conventional photograph, an image of both sides of the ewer is produced on the radiographic film. 
 The silver inlays show up as pale areas because they are denser than brass to X-rays. 
 What the X-rays reveal, which cannot be seen on the surface, are the soldered joins at the neck, handle and base as well as around the hole for the missing spout. 
 The tin lead soft solder used on the ewer is very dense to X-rays and appears as white patches on the radiograph. 
 Radiography can reveal the original construction of an object even when it is so corroded that no external evidence is left. 
 The great ship mound of Sutton Hoo. 
 which was probably the burial place of the East Anglian King Redwald who died in the seventh century AD. contained a wealth of fine metalwork including a sword. 
 Its hilt was decorated with fine garnet work but the blade was broken and rusted. 
 However. 
 a radiograph of the pieces revealed that it had not been made from just one piece of iron,  but from many welded together. 
 Using the radiographic evidence, an experimental replica of the blade was made by a modern smith from eighteen laminated rods of twisted wrought iron welded in the same way. 
 The result, when polished, was a beautiful interwoven pattern on the surface of the blade (fig. 5.13). 
 In most cases metal is joined with metal, whether it is riveted, soldered or welded. 
 However, radiography of the fine pair of Celtic bronze wine flagons from the site of Basse Yutz in France seemed to show that the bottoms of the flagons were not attached to the sides. 
 further investigations disclosed that they were in fact glued on with a resinous adhesive which appeared transparent to the X-rays. 
 Indeed, use of organic adhesives in metalwork may have been more common than would appear from the surviving archaeological record.  
 Joins on silver or gold objects made with silver and gold solders cannot usually be distinguished by radiography because they are approximately the same density as the metals they join, although they can sometimes be identified by colour difference or porosity when seen at high magnification. 
 Some joins. 
 such as the fine solder work required for gold filigree and granulation, cannot be seen even at high magnification. 
 Spot analysis by microprobe or EDX analysis (see glossary) in a scanning electron microscope (SEM) (see glossary) can detect the solder points by the minor changes in composition. 
 Figure 5.14 shows a panel of gold filigree work from an eighth-century Irish paten as seen in a scanning electron microscope. 
 Etruscan goldsmiths used minute granules of gold. 
 less than 0.5 mm in diameter. 
 The use of conventional solders to attach minute granules of gold presented great difficulties to the goldsmith who had to keep them in position during soldering and avoid flooding the delicate work with solder. 
 These difficulties could be overcome by using finely ground copper carbonate rather than metal, and mixing it with an organic glue. 
 The glue held the granulation in place and turned to carbon when heated. 
 reducing the copper carbonate to metal. 
 The copper metal reacted with the gold to form a bond. 
 There was no surplus solder to spoil the work, but this makes it very difficult to detect. 
 The most important factor in choosing a solder is that it must have a lower melting point than the pieces to be joined. 
 Where several components had to be soldered together it was vital that the heating for the last piece to be attached did not melt the solder already in place. 
 If the heat could not be sufficiently localised to avoid this, then the first solders had to have a higher melting point than the subsequent ones. 
 X-ray fluorescence (XRE) analysis (see glossary) of solders used on Roman silver suggests that the Roman silversmith did indeed use several different solders which could have given him a working temperature range from the melting point of silver (960&dollar;C), down to 180&dollar;C. 
 It has to be remembered that the analysis of a soldered joint will not be identical to the composition of the original solder alloy because, unlike adhesives, hard solders bond with other metals by diffusion. 
 This means there will be some exchange between the solder and the metal which will alter the composition of both.  
 Decoration and finishing 
 Metal lends itself to a wider range of decorative techniques than most other materials because of its physical properties, particularly its ductility, which allows it to be twisted into wire or inlaid with other metals and even other materials such as gemstones. 
 It can be engraved, embossed, covered with filigree wire, enamelled, patinated and plated. 
 The range of decorative techniques which have been at some time applied to metalwork is a subject for many books, not just a few pages. 
 This section will therefore only touch on some of the techniques which have become better understood as the result of scientific research. 
 There are several approaches, the first being study at high magnification using an optical microscope or scanning electron microscope (SEM) (see glossary). 
 The second is analysis, for which the method will be dictated by the material, potential sample size and the information needed. 
 Replication experiments are another possible approach. 
 Attempting to copy a decorative technique can confirm or disprove that it produces the same appearance and microstructure observed on the original item. 
 and it is also useful to assess the practical difficulties of the technique. 
 In practice, a combination of scientific approaches is usually needed. 
 Plating 
 Gilding, silvering and tinning (all involving the application of a thin layer of metal on to another metal) have been used since the third millennium BC for decorative or practical purposes and also for deception. 
 The earliest examples involved simple mechanical attachment, but it was not long before more permanent and more economical methods of gilding and silvering were developed. 
 In the Roman Imperial period copper and bronze statues and silver and bronze jewellery were commonly gilded. 
 Significant levels of mercury can be detected in the gilding of many but not all these artefacts. 
 The presence of mercury indicates the use of a technique known as mercury- or fire-gilding. 
 Gold dissolves in mercury at room temperature to make an amalgam (an amalgam is an alloy of mercury). 
 This property allows the gold to be applied in semi-liquid form over all or part of the object. 
 The object is then heated to drive off the mercury (which boils at 357&dollar;C). 
 leaving a thin surface plating of gold. 
 Because over-heating the gilding will ruin the finish, this stage is not carried to the extent of driving off every trace of mercury, so some evidence of the plating technique is left. 
 However, analysis shows that not all Roman gilding contained mercury. 
 Pure gold can be beaten out to form very thin sheets; according to Pliny, writing in the first century AD, 25 g of gold could be beaten into 750 leaves each 10 cm square. 
 Burnishing alone can cause gold leaf to adhere to a clean metal surface, but adhesives like egg white were also used. 
 Unlike mercury-gilding, there is no positive analytical evidence which can identify gold leaf, but it can often be recognised when viewed in cross-section at high magnification. 
 Leaf-gilding usually shows only minor variations in thickness and a superficial bonding to the metal below. 
 The overlapping  edges of the sheets of gold leaf are very characteristic (figs. 5.15a and b). 
 Analysis of a large number of gilded Roman &bquo;bronzes&equo; has revealed that most of those which are mercury-gilded are in fact made of copper. 
 They contain very low levels of alloying elements, particularly lead, which can dissolve in the amalgam layer and leave unsightly grey patches in the plating. 
 It was found that gold leaf was generally used by the Romans to plate high-lead bronzes, although at later periods the choice of gilding method was not governed by the metal composition. 
 To identify the method used. 
 it is necessary to see how the plating layer is bonded. 
 This is usually impossible from surface examination of the object. 
 If the edge of the plating does not provide enough information, a minute flake of plating, as small as 1 sq mm, can be mounted on its end in an epoxy resin for easy handling. 
 Once the resin has set hard, the block and sample are ground flat, then polished with fine diamond paste. 
 When viewed at high magnification with an optical microscope or scanning electron microscope, much is revealed about the plating technique which is simply not visible on the surface of the object. 
 This examination technique is illustrated by a pair of micrographs of silver plating (figs. 5.15c and d), both of which are sections through ancient silver coin forgeries. 
 In each case there is a copper core with a plating of silver which superficially appears to be identical on the two coins. 
 But when the cross-section is viewed at high magnification, it becomes clear that different plating methods have been used. 
 In the first example there is a white outer skin of pure silver, with overlapping joins at each end. 
 Between this and the core is an alloy of copper and silver (light grey in the photo). 
 This is a solder attaching two discs of silver foil cupped around the copper core like the foil wrappers around a chocolate penny. 
 The second example has no joins in the outer skin, only a copper-silver alloy coating, indicating that it was plated with molten metal rather than foils. 
 The mercury method, so popular in the Roman period for gilding, can also be used for silvering bronze and brass. 
 Mercury silvering was certainly practised in the medieval period, but the Romans silvered jewellery,  tableware and horse trappings by coating the copper alloy with soft solder (tin and lead), wrapping it with silver foil, then heating until the solder melted and secured the foil. 
 The reasons for the difference in treatment of gilding and silvering by the Romans is not clear. 
 Unlike gold, silver needs regular polishing to keep it bright. 
 As the foil plating was thicker it may have been found more durable than mercury plating. 
 Not all plating was of precious metal. 
 Tin has a low melting point (232&dollar;C), and tinning simply involves wiping a thin layer of molten tin over the surface of copper, bronze or brass. 
 It dates back to at least the fifth century BC and is still carried out today at the roadside in parts of Asia. 
 Tinning was used either for decorative purposes, for example on Merovingian jewellery, or for more practical purposes, such as providing a reflecting face on Roman bronze mirrors. 
 Analysis of these mirrors shows high levels of tin on the reflecting surface, but although all these mirrors are superficially similar, there are in fact two quite different types. 
 Many are bronze mirrors with a normal tin content of approximately 10 per cent, which have been tinned to produce a silvery reflecting surface. 
 The second type has no separately applied coating; instead the whole mirror is cast in a high-tin bronze alloy containing about 25 per cent tin. 
 This alloy is naturally silvery in colour and is much more hard-wearing than a thin layer of tinning, but it requires a high degree of skill to control the casting conditions. 
 The two types of mirror look much the same after being  buried for centuries, but when the microstructure is examined at high magnification, as in Figures 5.15e and f, it is possible to distinguish between tinned bronze and the high-tin alloy. 
 Niello inlay 
 The scientific research into the history of plating technology relies almost entirely on microscopy and element analysis, but these techniques cannot provide a complete picture of many of the non-metallic inlays used by the ancient metalworkers. 
 One example of this is a black inlay material known as niello, which is found on gold. 
 silver, bronze and brass items from as far apart as first-century AD Rome and nineteenth-century AD Moscow, ninth-century AD Persia and thirteenth-century AD England (fig. 5.16). 
 We know that niello is a metal sulphide, made by heating metal filings with sulphur, but could there be a continuity of tradition amongst the metalworkers of cultures so widely separated by time and geography? 
 Certainly there are visual differences; first-century Roman niello is often poorly preserved but fifteenth-century Italian niello, even in badly damaged pieces, still fills every detail of a finely engraved design. 
 To study such inlays, the method of analysis must identify any differences without damaging the object. 
 Inlays may be very small in area and are often closely mixed with corrosion products from the metal into which the niello was set, so the analysis technique also has to distinguish the niello inlay from corrosion and the metal of the inlaid object itself. 
 X-ray diffraction (XRD) analysis (see glossary) is ideally suited to this sort of problem as it requires only a minute sample and, most important, it identifies the mineral or compound present. 
 XRD is able to identify the metal sulphide used to make the niello and to distinguish it from the metal and from the oxide, chloride and carbonate corrosion products which contaminate the sample. 
 Thus, where element analysis by X-ray fluorescence of the inlays on two silver Anglo-Saxon disc brooches shows both to have a major component of silver, with some copper and sulphur. 
 XRD analysis identifies one inlay as silver-copper-sulphide (AgCuS) and the other as silver-sulphide (Ag 2  S) contaminated with copper carbonate (CuCO 3 . 
 Cu(OH) 2 ) from the corroding base silver alloy of the brooch.  
 A survey of niello composition, from the Roman period to the twentieth century, has identified the beginnings of a change in composition in the sixth century in Northern Europe when, perhaps for economic reasons, copper as well as silver was added to the crucible with the sulphur. 
 A second and more fundamental change occurred in the tenth and eleventh centuries in Europe and in the Islamic world, when lead was added to the ingredients for the inlay. 
 This had the effect of significantly lowering the melting point of the niello, allowing it to be melted into finely engraved designs. 
 Niello produced according to the Roman niello recipe decomposes before it melts. 
 It therefore had to be applied as a paste, not a liquid, and did not bond well to the metal; hence the observed differences in preservation between Roman and later medieval niello. 
 paint and patination 
 Pigment identification is another field to which XRD analysis is well suited. 
 Many early pigments are naturally occurring and brightly coloured minerals, usually metal salts, and often only minute traces remain. 
 We do not necessarily think of pigments in the context of metalwork, but there are traditions of painted metal statues. 
 For example a study of the Buddhist statuettes of Tibet and the Himalayas has identified the blue copper mineral azurite, red lead and cinnabar (red mercury sulphide) on the head-dresses. 
 The blues are normally found on the &bquo;peaceful&equo; deities and the reds on the head-dresses of the &bquo;angry&equo; deities. 
 A more durable method of colouring metals is to patinate them. 
 This is usually done by chemically inducing a thin surface coating of corrosion. 
  Metal is easily corroded, but the skill lies in producing an attractive colour which is even in tone and texture. 
 Japanese metalworkers have made the skill of patination into a sophisticated art form, producing naturalistic scenes with flowers, animals and people, using different-coloured inlays (plate 5.2). 
 The best known in the West is probably shakudo , which is a copper alloy with a deep black patina, but other copper alloys were patinated to produce colours ranging from shades of grey and brown through to green. 
 From as early as the 1860s, Western scientists have been interested in how these colours were produced. 
 Analysis has shown that it is not just the recipe for the pickling solution which affects the colour but, more fundamentally, low levels of alloying elements added to the copper. 
 The shakudo alloy contains 1 to 5 per cent of gold in copper. 
 The greys and browns are produced by varying the proportions of silver added to the copper, often with traces of gold and arsenic. 
 Patinated metalwork is not just confined to Japan. 
 Pliny describes a much sought-after metal called Corinthian bronze, an alloy of copper with gold and silver, which took on a purplish hue. 
 It has been argued that this is a description of a patinated alloy. 
 Analysis of a small Roman plaque with a black patina and gold inlays proved it to be largely copper with traces of silver, gold and arsenic, adding weight to the view that this patination technique was practised in the West as well as the East. 
 Another distinctive type of patinated metalwork, known as bidri , has been made since the seventeenth century or earlier and is produced in India to this day (fig. 5.17). 
 Again the patina is a deep black and contrasts with brightly polished silver, brass and gold inlay decoration. 
 However, in this case the patinated metal is zinc, which would not be expected to turn black on pickling as zinc has no black corrosion products. 
 This has been explained by analysis of the metal which reveals that copper is also present in the alloy. 
 Experiments in pickling different alloys of copper and zinc have shown that only alloys with between 2 and 10 per cent of copper in the zinc will take on the black patina, and the silver and brass inlays are unaffected by the pickling solution. 
 Conclusion 
 These are only a few examples of the applications of scientific research to metal artefacts. 
 Clearly one cannot hope to give a comprehensive survey of the history of metals and metalworking in a single chapter. 
 Rather we have attempted to show the potential of analysis and technical studies to increase our knowledge of the past. 
 Such research provides a means of tracing the progress of technological change: for example the development from the early exploitation of native metal to the alloying of copper with arsenic or tin to make bronze and then to the large-scale manufacture of brass (copper-zinc alloy) by the Romans. 
 Metal analysis can reveal fluctuations of economic prosperity, through evidence of coinage debasement, the imposition of gold and silver standards, or scarcity of precious metals for prestige items. 
 Study of manufacturing and decorative techniques can provide an insight into contacts between cultures. 
 New trade  routes may be traced by the spread of metalworking skills and the import of rare and exotic materials such as gemstones and ivory for jewellery. 
 The study of metalwork from an archaeological site, whether a burial site like Sutton Hoo or a major settlement like York, which has a whole range of artefacts and materials, provides an opportunity to build a picture of the place of technology and metals in the context of the economic prosperity and social hierarchy of the society. 
 The potential information which can be extracted from a metal artefact by analytical and technological study extends far beyond providing accurate factual information for museum labels and excavation reports.   
 6.1 left  Hispano-Moresque dish in lustre and blue (MLA G5170). 
 This dish has a Valencian shape but the crowded design is Malagan; neutron activation analysis shows it to be Valencian. 
 Diameter 420 mm. 
 6.3 right  Two medieval floor tiles: (a) from the chapel of Leo X in Castel Sant' Angelo, Rome (MLA 1883.11&ndash;6.9), of Genoese or Spanish origin (140 mm square), and (b) far right  made in Seville (MLA 1900.7 -18.1), one of a group analysed for comparison. 
 115 mm square. 
 6.2 Discriminant analysis results of neutron activation data for Spanish tin-glazed pottery known to be from Malaga, Valencia and Seville. 
 Each symbol represents the analysis of an individual object; samples of unknown origin can be assigned to their source by their position on such a diagram. 
 6.4 Italian maiolica pharmacy bottle of &bquo;Orsini-Colonna&equo; style showing a bear hugging a column (MLA 1852.11&ndash;29.2). 
 Neutron activation analysis has shown that this series of pieces was made at Castilli in southern Italy. 
 height 450 mm. 
 6.5 The distribution of flint axes from the source of mines in southern Britain. 
 Each pie chart shows the proportion of axes found in three areas, classified as to whether they came from the south Downs, Wessex, East Anglia or other mines (after Craddock et al, 1983). 
 6.6 Interior of typical flint mine gallery at Grimes Graves, Norfolk, showing the black flint seam at the foot of the wall. 
 6.7 below  Marble horse from the Mausoleum at Halicarnassus, about 350 BC (GR S1002). 
 Height 2.4 m. 
 Identified as pemtelic marble by stable isotope analysis. 
 6.8 above  Stable isotope analysis for carbon and oxygen of the marble sculptures from the Mausoleum at Halicarnassus, including the horse indicated by H (fig 6.7), superimposed on the data for Classical marble quarries. 
 The ellipsis represent 90 per cent coincidence limits for the samples from named quarries. 
 6.9 Large Igbo-Ukwu roped vessel of leaded bronze in the form of a water pot (now in the National Museum of Nigeria, Lagos). 
 Analysis of this unique vessel suggests it was made from local Nigerian copper. 
 height 320 mm. 
 Tracing to Source Michael Hughes 
 The first question one tends to ask about any object in a museum is where did it come from? 
 In many cases, pinpointing provenance, where an object of a particular type was made, enables us to identify it quite specifically. 
 For example, the tin-glazed pottery made in Europe from the Renaissance onwards was produced in many styles: that made in the Low Countries (known as Delftware) is of a specific range and type which varies from one production centre to another and is different again from the maiolica of Italy and the lustreware of Spain. 
 An object's appearance is the first way we recognise where it comes from: a Volkswagen &bquo;Beetle&equo; is an instantly recognisable shape even if the VW badge has fallen off the car; likewise we recognise a Rolls Royce. 
 Much of the expertise of a museum curator or an archaeologist lies in being able to offer a reasonably accurate identification of an object just on the basis of looking at it and handling it. 
 From experience and familiarity he or she builds up a mental pictorial encyclopaedia based on study of museum collections, information from archaeological research and accumulated knowledge from books and papers describing objects of particular periods and cultures. 
 However, from time to time the curator's instinct for identification comes up against scholarly puzzles. 
 Differences of opinion exist among scholars; sometimes the appearance gives very little to go on &mdash; details may have been rubbed off or we may only have a small fragment of a large object to examine; two or more origins may be possible contenders and it may be impossible to decide which on stylistic grounds alone. 
 All such cases need an alternative approach to the problem of origin and it is natural to turn to scientific techniques to see if they have something to offer. 
 The problem then needs to be formulated in scientific terms and this requires the object to have some property which is unique to its origin, but which varies from place to place and is not significantly modified by manufacture; the property must also be scientifically detectable. 
 Either the composition of the object or its microstructure are the obvious candidates. 
 For metal objects, as we have seen in Chapter 5, the bulk composition was very much under the control of the metalsmith rather than being unique to origin. 
 Hence most provenance studies are of ceramic and stone materials, where the composition and microstructure of the basic raw materials is relatively unaffected by the manufacturing process, although we will see that metals too can be provenanced in some circumstances. 
 If an object is to be sourced, the first step is to determine the composition of  the raw materials of the most probable sources. 
 More usually for ceramics, the scientist examines the composition of groups of similar objects of known origin to build up a comparative database. 
 An appropriate scientific technique has to be chosen for this task, and experience of analysing antiquities suggests that there are certain requirements of such a technique. 
 For example, in most cases only small amounts of material can be removed from an object: the analysis technique must therefore be quite sensitive. 
 The differences in composition are sometimes quite subtle so the technique must also be accurate and precise. 
 Identifications need to be made clearly, which requires us to investigate as many features of the object as possible. 
 This is like forensic science, where the more &bquo;matches&equo; one finds between two fingerprints, the greater the certainty that they belong to the same person. 
 Normally we need to look at large numbers of objects (tens, or perhaps hundreds): the analytical technique must therefore give results in a reasonable amount of time per sample and cope with large numbers of objects. 
 This requirement eliminates a lot of the older classical chemical techniques and indeed some of the ultra-modern high-tech instruments which can only handle a few objects per day. 
 Different techniques are chosen for different materials. 
 The aim is always to select an appropriate method, one which answers the question as clearly as possible. 
 There is no reason to use a difficult and probably expensive analytical method if a much simpler and quicker visual examination under a microscope provides the same answer. 
 Some materials still resist easy answers &mdash; gold is an example. 
 There is a continual need to appraise existing techniques, to seek refinements and to search out new instrumental methods of examination which have more to offer in speed, accuracy or range of elements found. 
 In ten years' time we shall no doubt still be using the techniques discussed in this chapter but we may also have opened up new avenues of research by widening the range of materials examined and by using other scientific techniques which at present are only at the development stage. 
 Ceramics 
 Two general approaches have been much used: thin-section petrography and chemical analysis of the body fabric or composition. 
 Petrography 
 Thin-section petrography is a standard geological technique, fundamental to determining the mineralogical and textural characteristics of rocks; it can be applied in just the same way to ceramic materials. 
 First, a small fragment of material is removed and stuck to a glass slide; it is then carefully ground away until it is only 0.03 mm thick. 
 At this thickness most rock-forming silicate minerals are translucent and the thin section can be viewed in transmitted light using a polarising microscope. 
 Particular minerals can be recognised by their characteristic optical properties  so that individual grains and rock fragments can be identified. 
 Textural characteristics &mdash; such as the size, shape and orientation of grains &mdash; can also be observed. 
 Although clay minerals are generally too fine-grained to be reliably identified, features such as clay pellets and parallel alignment of the platy clay particles, which may result from forming processes such as wheel-throwing, can be recognised. 
 Examination of thin sections of ceramic materials may yield information about ancient technology (e.g. type and amount of added temper, mixing of clays, and method of forming). 
 Such examination may also help us to determine provenance by revealing inclusions characteristic of particular geological sources. 
 Textural analysis, which involves studying the size, shape and proportion of the inclusions, can be useful when the inclusions are not distinctive in other respects. 
 It may sometimes be possible to associate together vessels which have inclusions with similar textural characteristics, and even to suggest possible sources. 
 The following example from Iron Age Britain shows how scientists use thin-section petrography to decide whether pottery found at a site is local or imported. 
 Hengistbury Head is a low sandy promontory jutting out into the English Channel near Bournemouth. 
 Evidence of human occupation here goes back to the Upper Paleolithic and Mesolithic periods (Early and Middle Stone Ages) but its period of greatest activity was in the Late Iron Age, from roughly 100 BC to 50 AD, when it became a trading centre and port for people and goods from the Continent. 
 Today, it is being slowly eroded on the south face by the sea. 
 It was excavated by Bushe-Fox in 1911&ndash;12, and has been excavated more extensively within the last ten years by Barry Cunliffe, using the latest archaeological techniques. 
 During the excavations, the Iron Age settlement yielded large amounts of pottery. 
 Because Hengistbury was a port, we were especially interested in identifying which pieces of pottery were local and which imported, and in trying to find their sources. 
 To do this, a selection of the Late Iron Age pottery (c.100&ndash;50 BC) was studied. 
 In thin section a Dorset-based type of hand-made pottery known as Durotrigian ware (named after the Iron Age tribe, the Durotriges) shows a very sand-rich fabric (plate 6.1a: left-hand side). 
 The white or greyish grains embedded in the dark clay matrix are composed of the common mineral quartz. 
 This was probably deliberately added by the potter as sand temper, to &bquo;open up&equo; the clay fabric, allowing water vapour to escape so that the pot would be less liable to crack during firing (see Chapter 2 for further discussion). 
 Most of the hand-made Durotrigian pottery analysed in thin section had the distinctive appearance of Plate 6. 1a, with a fairly coarse sand temper. 
 On the grounds of petrology. this sandy ware seemed to be locally produced Dorset pottery, made from the local Tertiary clays of the Poole-Wareham region. 
 In contrast to these local pottery types, there were also wheel-made vessels decorated with raised cordons or bands on the body. 
 In thin section these have a dramatically different appearance (plate 6.1b). 
 Under the polarising microscope they contain coarse grains which show multicoloured areas, corresponding to interference colours caused by the presence of particular minerals. 
 While quartz gives grey and white interference  colours, the bright colours of Plate 6.1b are produced by an amphibole mineral (pale colour to yellow to red) and the black and white stripey pattern by the feldspar mineral plagioclase. 
 (These two minerals form a rock type known as an amphibolite.) 
 Other very distinctive thin sections were found for vessels with a distinctive rilled decoration which contain the minerals feldspar, mica and quartz: these are fragments of a granite. 
 Both the amphibolitic and granitic minerals can be matched with the rock types found in northern Brittany but not in Dorset. 
 Taken together, the petrological analysis of the black cordoned and rilled micaceous wares recovered at Hengistbury Head and the known geology of the region leave no doubt that these wares were imported to southern Britain in the Late Iron Age. 
 chemical composition 
 The provenance study of ceramics is one of the most active research fields involving chemical analysis. 
 This is partly because we need to understand and classify the vast amounts of pottery recovered from excavations at archaeological sites, and partly because of the high success rate of such analytical projects. 
 But the real explanation is found in the nature of pottery. 
 On the one hand it is made from clay which, after being extracted and processed, is a durable material which outlives other materials in aggressive soil conditions. 
 On the other hand numerous studies have shown that clay from one locality, if not always of a single composition, has at least a reasonably uniform and limited compositional range, whereas clays from different locations (towns, countries, continents) have different chemical compositions because they reflect differences in the underlying geology. 
 The chemical composition of clay may differ in major elements, like aluminium, iron, sodium or calcium, or in the minor or trace elements present at very low concentrations, such as chromium, uranium, barium or lanthanum (one of the rare earths). 
 Fashioning and firing a pot does not affect the clay composition but care must be taken, since potters frequently mix additives into clay to prepare it, and burial of pottery in the ground has some slight effects on its composition. 
 In ancient times the most common additive, or temper, was quartz sand, which simply dilutes the concentrations of the chemical elements. 
 The chemical effects of burial on the pottery are few and generally well known. 
 Neutron activation analysis 
 Neutron activation analysis (see glossary) was developed in the mid-1940s, following the introduction of nuclear reactors. 
 It remains one of the most sensitive methods for chemical analysis ever developed. 
 At present it is also the most popular method of analysis for provenance studies in archaeology, but it may not always be so, since scientists are continually looking for new instrumental methods of obtaining a comprehensive chemical analysis of a material. 
 Mass-spectrometry techniques (see glossary) are currently receiving attention because they are superior to other  methods in sensitivity and the range of chemical elements to which they can be applied. 
 However, routine chemical analyses of large batches of samples has yet to be achieved. 
 Instrumental neutron activation is still selected most frequently because of its sensitivity, accuracy and the wide range of elements which can be measured in a single sample. 
 For ceramic provenance studies, a sample of the ceramic body fabric is taken, using a non-contaminating drill such as synthetic sapphire. 
 This produces a powdered sample of the interior body fabric of the ceramic (about 50 mg are needed). 
 Batches of about sixty samples, each sealed in a pure silica tube, are irradiated, together with six samples of a standard clay of already known chemical composition. 
 Typically, the chemical analysis for each sample yields results on over twenty elements. 
 Laboratories located next to a reactor can increase the number of elements to between thirty and thirty-five. 
 This is because they can include additional short irradiations for elements with isotopes of very short half-lives, from a few minutes to a few hours, although this increases the analyst's work. 
 A typical provenance project could involve analysis of a hundred to two hundred samples of pottery and it would clearly be impossible to make sense of all two thousand to four thousand quantitative elemental analyses without the use of modern multivariate statistical computer programs. 
 Such programs take a comprehensive analysis (more than twenty elements) on each sample in turn, and compare it with perhaps a hundred to two hundred other samples to try to find a close &bquo;match&equo;. 
 Essentially it is like the forensic scientist trying to find two chemical &bquo;fingerprints&equo; which match for as many elements as possible. 
 Eventually the program will organise all the samples into groups having the same or similar &bquo;fingerprints&equo;. 
 Each of these pottery composition groups represents the same clay. 
 Working out why these different groups have emerged then becomes a matter of closely integrating the archaeological and scientific information: the key to understanding the results is close co-operation between the archaeologist and scientist, who need to work together in order to extract all the latent information in the analyses. 
 The use of neutron activation analysis is best explained by the following case study. 
 Medieval Spain had a vigorous ceramic industry with many local potters producing ceramics with a galaxy of brightly coloured and lustred designs on a white background. 
 This is tin-glazed pottery and it was exported widely. 
 For example it was packed into the holds of ships sailing to the New World, to satisfy the expatriates' desire for Spanish tableware in their overseas posting. 
 Sherds of such pottery have been found on sites along the eastern seaboard of the United States, including Florida, the Caribbean islands and parts of South America such as Venezuela. 
 The most famous tin-glazed pottery of Spain was lustre pottery; it was also exported and found its way into the wealthy households of medieval Europe. 
 The first lustre pottery produced in Europe was made by Arab potters working in Spain. 
 The Muslim potters of Malaga in the Kingdom of Granada became justly famous for their wares and lustre pottery was subsequently made by both Muslim and Christian potters in the Christian town of Valencia. 
 Both lustre and blue-on-white wares were made  from the mid-thirteenth century to the late fifteenth century at Malaga and a typical example of a wide dish decorated in lustre and blue is shown in Figure 6.1. 
 The designs fill the surface of the ceramics almost completely. 
 From the late fourteenth century onwards, however, very similar pottery was produced at Valencia, a long-established pottery-making centre. 
 It is thought that the potters had migrated from Malaga in response to the increasing pressure of the sea blockade of southern Spain by Christian ships. 
 Later, Valencia came to dominate as the major lustreware centre. 
 But before this both centres produced very similar ranges of designs and there are considerable difficulties in distinguishing on stylistic grounds alone between late Malaga and early Valencia lustre pottery. 
 This is where neutron activation analysis enables us to source them with certainty. 
 As a first step, sherds of known origin from the two centres were analysed. 
 The results were then evaluated using several statistical techniques mentioned in Chapter 9 (see page 158). 
 A preliminary test with principal components analysis was followed by cluster analysis using the program CLUSTAN and finally discriminant analysis to test For chemical differences between the products of the two sites. 
 Figure 6.2 shows the results of discriminant analysis in graph form: the compositions of the pieces of pottery from Malaga, Valencia and Seville can be clearly differentiated from each other. 
 There are also composition sub-groups which for Valencia at least are related to quality of the wares. 
 The splendid lustreware dish shown in Figure 6.1 has already been referred to. 
 From a purely art-historical viewpoint it presents a puzzle: the shape is Valencian but the style of decoration is Malagan. 
 Analysis showed it to have a definite Valencian chemical composition: in Figure 6.2 it is part of the Valencian sub-group with black filled circles. 
 From this one can infer that it belongs chronologically to that transition period in Spanish  ceramics when the displaced potters of Malaga had set up afresh in Valencia but were still using the traditional designs of Andalusia in their new environment. 
 Analysis has also helped to ascertain the origin of the tiles in the chapel of Leo X in the Castel Sant' Angelo in Rome (fig. 6.3a). 
 It was recently suggested that these might be the products of an Italian maiolica workshop rather than Spanish as has long been believed. 
 Maiolica made in Renaissance Italy was also tin-glazed and painted with such vibrant colours that the ceramics seem to glow with a Mediterranean light. 
 A neutron activation analysis study of these ceramics (such as the  pharmacy bottle in Figure 6.4) has so far tested pieces known to be local products from over twenty maiolica centres in Italy. 
 The composition of the Leo X tiles does not compare with any of these, including those from the postulated source at Genoa, but they are almost identical to the composition of contemporary tiles definitely known to have been made at Seville, such as the example in Figure 6.3b. 
 In the discriminant analysis diagram (fig. 6.2), these Seville tiles form a compact group into which the Leo X tiles closely fit; this demonstrates that the Leo X tiles are Sevillian. 
 Anthony Ray has recently reached the same conclusion on art-historical grounds and we know that Seville was an important centre for the manufacture and export of tin-glazed pottery. 
 Among the Italian maiolica ceramics analysed was the pharmacy jar of Figure 6.4, which is one of a number in the same style. 
 Their origin has been disputed but analysis has now shown that their compositions are consistent with being made at Castelli in southern Italy. 
 Stone 
 The parallel approaches of petrology (or thin-section petrography) and chemical analysis, which have been so successfully applied to ceramics. 
 have also solved some questions about stone objects. 
 In addition another technique, stable isotope analysis. 
 has been used to identify the sources of white marble used in the Classical world. 
 Microscope study of stone axes 
 Petrology has been particularly helpful in identifying Neolithic stone axes made from the hard rocks which predominate in western Britain from Cornwall to Scotland. 
 From the seventeenth century onwards antiquarians recognised that the polished stone axes found at numerous sites in Britain were made of stone that was not available locally. 
 They speculated on how far it would have been necessary to travel to obtain the stone, and whether one could precisely locate its origin. 
 Modern petrological studies have gone a long way towards answering this question: polished hard-rock axes seem to have been made from stone obtained from a limited number of outcrops. 
 Sometimes there is actual evidence of extensive roughly prepared axeheads (as in the great outcrops towering above the Langdale Valley in the Lake District). 
 while in other cases the geological sources have been identified fairly exactly by petrology even though there is little archaeological evidence of working at the outcrops themselves. 
 Just how far the raw material travelled from source to customer is illustrated by the outcrop of greenstone rock in Mounts Bay, Cornwall: many axeheads made from this rock are actually found in East Anglia on the Essex coast (some 5 50 km from Cornwall) and in south-eastern England along the Kent and Sussex coasts. 
 We therefore know that there was long-distance transport of stone axes in prehistoric Britain, which may have begun with carriage of axes from the axe factory to a secondary distribution centre, from where they were traded out into the surrounding area.  
 Our knowledge of the identification and distribution of stone axes in Britain has been gained from a very long-running co-operative research effort involving archaeologists and petrologists: over the last fifty years more than 7500 axes have been examined petrologically. 
 Well over thirty distinct hard-rock types, each representing a different rock outcrop, were utilised for artefacts in the prehistoric period. 
 Some of these rock types are quite exotic &mdash; for example the rare porcellanite from Northern Ireland &mdash; whereas others, such as the granite type known as dolerite, occur in many different areas of upland Britain including Wales. 
 Chemical analysis of flint axes 
 The most enduring and widespread artefacts from the earliest times are made of flint, a hard rock which fractures to give sharp edges ideally suited for making knives, axeheads and arrowheads. 
 In Great Britain such artefacts are particularly common from the Paleolithic through to the Bronze Age. 
 An astonishing variety of artefacts was made from flint, requiring a craftsman's skill to chip the blocks of flint to the required shape. 
 How and where were the raw materials obtained and transformed into useful items for hunting, food production, woodland clearance and so on during the Neolithic and Early Bronze Age (roughly 4000&ndash;1500 BC)? 
 Enough is known from archaeology to realise that in many cases chance finds of flint nodules or fragments provided the raw material for small tools. 
 On the other hand, archaeological study has also shown that in specific locations across southern Britain (and elsewhere in Europe) there were large-scale exploitations of flint resources, in effect flint mines. 
 Attention has been focused on the composition of these deposits to see if we can link implements to specific mines.  
 Flint is regarded by geologists as a particular form of chert, a chalcedony: that is, a material which is almost pure silica with small inclusions of water. 
 The chemical properties of flint at first seem very unpromising since so much of its chemical make-up is a silicon-oxygen network, and is the same in flint found anywhere. 
 But there are trace amounts of other elements entrapped within the flint. 
 Because it forms slowly over geological time in the Cretaceous chalk, minute amounts of clay dispersed in the chalk are incorporated within the flint. 
 These trace amounts of clay can be analysed chemically and research has shown that the flint taken from the major flint mines scattered across southern Britain (fig. 6.5) has a particular chemical composition for each mine. 
 This composition &bquo;fingerprint&equo; is consistently found for flint from the same mine but differs between mines. 
 As the amounts of these chemical elements trapped in the flint are so small, it is necessary to use a sensitive analytical technique, namely atomic absorption spectrometry (see glossary). 
 This technique has been used to find the amounts of elements such as iron, sodium, potassium, aluminium, calcium, magnesium, lithium and phosphorus in the flint, and it was the concentrations of these elements which were different for different mines. 
 Neutron activation was not chosen because those elements which it can measure in flint (as compared to pottery) are more erratically distributed than those measured by atomic absorption (the major elements in clay), and this makes it harder to distinguish the products of any two mines. 
 Recently inductively coupled plasma spectrometry (see glossary),  which is related to atomic absorption, has also been successfully applied to flint analysis. 
 In this project over a thousand flints from across southern Britain, including unworked flint nodules collected from the known mines, were analysed. 
 All flint mines in southern Britain are located on the Chalk (fig. 6. 5). 
 A typical Neolithic mine is not very different from our contemporary idea of a mine even though these are over 4000 years old and the interior of the mine at Grimes Graves is shown in Figure 6.6. 
 Raw flint from the mines as well as finished artefacts were analysed, mainly hoards of flint axeheads found far from the mines, and there were some unexpected results (fig. 6.5). 
 The pie charts in the diagram show the proportion of flint artefacts which originated from the major flint mining areas of the South Downs, Wessex and East Anglia. 
 In the South-East, as one would expect, the South Downs mines supplied the raw material for more than half the axeheads analysed from that region. 
 However in East Anglia the South Downs group still supplied a large proportion (this time somewhat under 50 per cent of the axeheads), whereas East Anglian sources, such as Grimes Graves, had apparently cornered only a small proportion of the market. 
 Many of the analysed axeheads are datable stylistically to an early period, before mining operations began at Grimes Graves. 
 However there is still the slightly bizarre picture of flint being carefully transported from the South Downs northwards over 350 km, along the Icknield Way into East Anglia on the Chalk ridge which contains countless tonnes of flint nodules perhaps 1 0 m below the surface. 
 As well as showing how far flint was traded in prehistoric times in Britain, the analyses have shown that the largest proportion of the flint used to make axeheads was deliberately mined, in many ways like the hard rocks used for axes (see page 106). 
 Stable isotope analysis of white marble 
 Sculptures in white marble from the Classical world of ancient Greece and Rome have for centuries delighted and inspired the ordinary observer as well as other sculptors, painters, architects and art historians (fig. 6.7). 
  That a range of quarries was exploited in the Mediterranean area is not in doubt, but particular sculpted pieces cannot always be attributed to particular quarries on purely visual grounds. 
 Some alternative method of assigning sculpture in white marble to its quarry source has been long sought. 
 Petrographic methods have provided some indications because the grain-size of the white marble from some quarries is very distinctive, but not all quarries can be distinguished in this way. 
 In 1972 a research paper by American scientists showed that the stable isotope ratios for oxygen and carbon in white marble varied from quarry to quarry, and more extensive research since then has confirmed that such measurements provide a &bquo;signature&equo; for the marble quarries of Italy, Greece and Turkey, which were the main sources of Classical marble. 
 For convenience the patterns can be shown on graphs (fig.6.8) as a series of statistical ellipses which represent 90 per cent of the results from each quarry. 
 If a measurement on an &bquo;unknown&equo; marble fragment is then plotted on this graph and it falls within one of the ellipses, the fragment can probably be assigned to that quarry. 
 However the picture is not absolutely clear, as will be obvious from Figure 6.8, since some of the ellipses are rather large and some overlap: without additional information it would not be possible to say which of the pair (or more) of overlapping quarries was the true source. 
 In practice when items of archaeological information, such as the date of the sculpture and its style, are taken into account, we can eliminate some quarries because they are not operational  at that date or because we know the sculptors were working in certain places and it is highly improbable that they were using distant rather than local sources. 
 Each case has to be considered on its merits where an ambiguous answer emerges from the stable isotope data. 
 In the last few years trace element analysis of the marble has been introduced as an additional aspect of characterisation. 
 Because marble is ultra-pure calcium carbonate, the technique for trace analysis has to be very sensitive and instrumental neutron activation analysis has proved ideal for this. 
 Quarried blocks of marble and finished sculptures have been analysed by neutron activation and the results have been very encouraging. 
 By a happy coincidence, those quarries which have proved difficult to separate by stable isotope analysis have very different trace element compositions, and some with very different stable isotopes are rather similar in trace elements. 
 Several research groups have concluded that the combined use of visual examination of grain size, stable isotopic analysis and trace element analysis may successfully distinguish all the major quarries of the Mediterranean region. 
 The application of stable isotopes to white marble is exemplified by the programme of analysis of the sculptures from the Mausoleum at Halicarnassus dating to about 350 BC. 
 (Halicarnassus, modern Bodrum, lies on a peninsula in south-western Turkey.) 
 The Mausoleum was a major structure commissioned by the Mausolus dynasty, consisting of a white marble building surmounted by a series of large sculptured figures and with extensive use of decorative sculpted friezes in the architecture. 
 It was an impressive monument and, as the local area lacks high-quality building or sculptural marble, the white marble used in its construction had to be imported. 
 The aim of the project was to identify the types of marble used for specific functions and to associate unidentified fragments with known parts of the building. 
 The most outstanding decorative element of the Mausoleum was the series of massive free-standing sculptures arranged high up on the podium of the monument, executed in fine marble. 
 At the apex stood a chariot with a four-horse team: one of the horses is shown in Figure 6.7. 
 Samples from the horse were analysed, and the isotope results showed that quarries high up on Mount Pentelikon were the source, rather than the more numerous and better-known quarries at the foot of the mountain. 
 Penteli was an important quarry near Athens in Greece and recent research has distinguished between the products of the upper and lower quarries. 
 Two fragments of the chariot were also tested: one, a wheel, was also of Pentelic marble but the axle was of Ephesian marble (Ephesus was a major port on the west coast of Turkey, north of Halicarnassus). 
 The impressive free-standing sculptures on the podium of the building were shown to be made of two types of Pentelic marble. 
 However, the marble used for the building came from these two sources. 
 Analysis has shown that the figureheads are of Parian marble (from the Aegean island of Paros), a particularly fine-quality marble, which was expensive because it was mined from underground. 
 However, the less important constructional blocks with carved decoration were from quarries  in the Dokimeion-Iasos region of Turkey. 
 Two different sources of marble within this same quarry group were exploited for the roof and the wall blocks. 
 The overall picture which has emerged from the analyses is of more or less consistent use of the same marble quarry for the same elements of the monument, but that a variety of marble types were selected for different purposes. 
 Finer grades (such as Parian or Pentelic) were used for the most important statuary, and lower-quality and more local marble, mainly from south-western Turkey, was used for the main architectural building blocks of the monument. 
 The analyses have also shown much interesting detail: sub-groups have emerged when marble fragments have been found to have extremely similar isotope ratios, which suggests they came not only from the same quarry but from the same part of the quarry. 
 Metals 
 Finding the provenance of metal objects presents a more difficult problem for archaeological science. 
 Unlike stone, flint or ceramics, the raw material has to undergo drastic changes before it is made into the finished artefact. 
 Metals do not, with the exception of gold, a limited amount of copper, and meteoric iron, occur as the free metal in nature: they usually occur as metallic minerals which have to be smelted. 
 The smelting process alters the chemical composition of the original ore so that there is usually no simple chemical correlation between ore and metal. 
 Re-melting and alloying further complicate the situation. 
 However, there are occasions when the trace element pattern of a metal object bears some traces of the elements in the original ore. 
 The trace elements in Sassanian silver provide one example, copper from the Hartz mountains has a very distinctive pattern of high concentrations of arsenic, cobalt, nickel and antimony, and there are a significant number of similar studies. 
 However, generally speaking, of the numerous ancient metallic artefacts still in existence, relatively few can be provenanced purely through elemental analysis. 
 Can any other approach help? 
 In the early 1970s geological research highlighted the fact that lead ores carried distinctive isotope ratio signatures', depending upon the geological period when they were laid down as deposits. 
 The discovery of the usefulness of lead isotope ratios was quickly applied to archaeology and has proved highly successful in provenancing lead-containing objects from antiquity. 
 Research began on lead objects from the Roman era, lead ingots, and so on. 
 But the technique was soon applied to objects which contain substantial amounts of lead, particular glazes and glasses rich in lead, such as enamels.The search for other materials to analyse has now progressed to copper alloys. 
 Heavily leaded bronzes are obvious candidates for analysis. 
 However research has shown that even in copper objects containing no deliberately added lead, the small amounts of lead present in the original ore (and transferred to the finished metal during smelting) contain a &bquo;signature&equo; in lead isotope ratios of the copper  ore body. 
 The situation can be complicated if the metalworkers added small amounts of lead, or added pieces of scrap at the  casting stage, because the &bquo;signature&equo; of the lead will no longer be that of a single source and sorting this out seems well-nigh impossible. 
 One recent example is the research on the bronzes excavated in the 1950s at Igbo-Ukwu in south-eastern Nigeria and dated around the tenth century AD (fig. 6.9). 
 These splendid and intricate bronze castings are enigmatic: they appear on the scene without apparent precursors and with no obvious descendants. 
 This, the technical skills required to make them, and the apparent lack of copper resources in Nigeria have prompted many scholars to conclude that they were made away from sub-Saharan Africa, although no convincing stylistic links with other cultures, including those of the Mediterranean, have emerged. 
 Chemical analysis and technical study of these bronzes have shown that they have an unusually high silver content (up to 1.2 per cent silver) which, by comparison with analyses of other ancient bronzes, suggests that one principal source of metal was involved. 
 Considerable technical skills were needed to make the bronzes, but the metalworkers used a very small range of techniques. 
 Thus, where one would expect a large basin to have been made from sheet metal, it was instead cast with walls of amazing thinness. 
 (Such aspects also suggest technical isolation of the metalworkers.) 
 Recently lead-zinc-copper deposits have been noted in the Benue Rift some 100 km from Igbo-Ukwu, raising the possibility of ancient exploitation of these local copper resources. 
 For some of the bronzes, lead isotope ratios have now been obtained on lead extracted from the samples, and from two lead ore samples from the Benue Rift. 
 This research showed  that one group of bronzes had very similar lead isotope ratios to the Benue Rift ores, while others had isotope ratios which, although different to the ores, could result from Benue Rift material being mixed with another (and geologically younger) source. 
 The Benue Rift deposits are spread out along 600 km, so they cannot yet be said to have been adequately characterised, but the technical, stylistic, compositional and lead isotope evidence now points to the Igbo-Ukwu bronzes originating within Nigeria. 
 Conclusion 
 This chapter has outlined the range of materials to which scientific techniques have been applied in order to discover a particular object's provenance. 
 Even for the materials described here, all the combined scientific efforts have still only made comparatively small inroads into the accumulating list of unsolved questions. 
 Other materials continue to present challenges to the scientist, including many of organic origin such as tars, waxes and oils. 
 So far virtually only those organic materials with structures visible to the microscope (e.g. pollen) have received detailed attention. 
 However, the range of scientific techniques will also grow, no doubt enabling us to provenance materials with greater speed and accuracy in the future.   
 7.1 In radioactive decay, after each half-life (T1/2) the number of atoms remaining is halved: if there are A to begin with, after one half-life there will be A/2 atoms remaining; after two half-lives, A/4 remain; after three A/8, and so on. 
 This time axis shown is for radiation. 
 7.2 Whalebone plaque dated to 1480 plus/minus 80 BP (see p.122); however; the whale could have had an apparent radiocarbon &bquo;age&equo; at death of several centuries (MLA 1987.10&ndash;5.1; OxA-1164). 
 Height 320 mm. 
 Marine environments show a reservoir effect due to slow mixing of carbon through ocean waters and upwelling of deep ocean water depleted in 14C. 
 7.3 Horse mandible from Kendrick's Cave (Great Orme's head, Llandudno, Wales), AMS dated to the late Upper Palaeolithic or very early Mesolithic (PRB 1959.12&ndash;3.1). 
 If dated by conventional radiocarbon, it would have been totally destroyed during measurement. 
 It is one of the few examples of mobiliary art of the period from Britain. 
 7.4 High-precision radiocarbon calibration curve based on Irish oak (courtesy of Gordon Pearson). 
 7.5 Section of Stuiver and Pearson's high-precision calibration curve for the recent past (courtesy of the authors). 
 the highest and lowest lines show the error term on the curve (centre line) at each point. 
 Large wiggles mean that a single radiocarbon result can correspond to more than one calendar result (see fig. 7.8); distinguishing between the different calendar possibilities cannot then be achieved by radiocarbon alone. 
 7.6 above left  Polished section of the trunk of an oak showing the well-defined rings (courtesy Jonathan Pilcher). 
 7.7 above  In dendrochronology a master curve is produced, starting with a living tree and extending the timescale using timbers with overlapping patterns (courtesy of Ulster Museum, Belfast). 
 7.8 The intercept method of calibration: the calibration is shown schematically without its error limits; these are incorporated in the overall error, &thgr;. 
 Note the effect of the shape of the curve on the size of the calibrated date range; more than one range is possible. 
 7.9 Beaker period burial from Barnack, Cambridgeshire. 
 Here the body is accompanied by a Beaker, a copper dagger, an archer's wrist guard and other items. 
 7.10 Natural TL glow curve (N) from a sample of pottery, and one produced by addition of a beta radiation dose in the laboratory to an identical sample (N + &Bgr;). 
 The additional TL produced by the laboratory dose enables the TL sensitivity of the pottery to radiation to be determined. 
 The thermal glow from the sample, due to heat alone, is curve B. 
 7.11 Pontnewydd Cave under excavation (courtesy National Museum of Wales). 
 Questions of Chronology Sheridan Bowman 
 Most people wear watches, some keep diaries: we continually monitor the passage of time and keep records of the sequence of events. 
 Public buildings such as libraries house less personal records in the form of newspapers, parliamentary accounts and other documents. 
 We live in a historical period; written records are kept and we tend to assume that our records are correct and that we can accurately reconstruct the events of the past. 
 However, historical documents are not always true records of the past. 
 For example the so-called &bquo;Dark Age&equo; of European history, following the decline of the Roman Empire, has a dearth of written records, and those that do survive are questionable. 
 In Britain, for instance, unravelling any facts from the many legends associated with King Arthur is no easy task. 
 In this case it is open to question whether the authors of the limited number of extant documents were writing about contemporary events or were recording what they believed to have happened, based on oral tradition. 
 Indeed, the documents themselves could have been transcribed many times through the ages. 
 Inevitably scribes would have corrected what they perceived to be &bquo;mistakes&equo; and undoubtedly the story would also have been embellished on occasion. 
 Nor were records necessarily kept with the intention of providing a precise calendar of events. 
 For example, the tens of thousands of cuneiform tablets found at Kanesh (modern K&uuml;ltepe in Turkey) are largely monetary accounts (lists of goods transported and letters regarding merchandise). 
 It is obviously difficult to infer the chronological framework of a town from its stocklists alone. 
 If history is potentially unreliable and incomplete, what of the prehistoric period for which we have no written records at all? 
 Here archaeology is usually the sole source of information. 
 As in geology. 
 the ordering of the strata (layers) of sediment on an archaeological site provides us with a relative dating technique. 
 A layer high in the sequence will have been deposited later than a lower one, and, provided there has been no disturbance, the artefacts in the higher level will be younger than those underlying. 
 But how much younger, and how do the artefacts on one site relate temporally to those on another? 
 Similarity of style could suggest similar age, but dissimilarity does not necessarily imply the opposite. 
 The style of an artefact does not inherently tell us its age &mdash; independent dating techniques are required. 
 Dating techniques are many and varied, with similarly diverse applications. 
 Some are based upon the effects of seasonal change and are  therefore directly related to the orbit of the earth about the sun, which provides us with a useful unit of time, the year. 
 Dendrochronology, varves and ice core dating are such techniques, based respectively on the annual formation of tree rings, lake sediment layers and polar ice-cap layers. 
 Each ring or layer must be differentiable from the adjacent ones and be formed annually. 
 Thus tree rings are differentiated by the types, density and size of cell laid down at different times of the year; varves by the gradation in particle size resulting from sedimentation of debris released into rivers and carried to lakes by the annual melt of glaciers; and ice core layers by differences in dust content and acidity. 
 Dendrochronology is the most directly useful for dating archaeological sites, but, perhaps surprisingly, even polar ice core dating can occasionally be very useful. 
 Ice cores record events, such as major volcanic eruptions, which affect global dust and acidity levels. 
 Thus they have provided evidence that helps to date the eruption of Thera (modern Santorini) which virtually destroyed the Minoan town of Akrotiri in the seventeenth century BC. 
 Less frequent rhythms in the earth's orbit produce more dramatic climatic changes and form the basis of some of the relative dating techniques. 
 Thus evidence of glacial and interglacial periods, such as the type of flora and fauna present, can sometimes be used to assign a sequence to events, but, as with any relative dating technique, events are only set in order. 
 To assign them to a calendar scale and determine the sizes of the intervals between them requires absolute dating methods, such as those described above or those based on radioactive decay. 
 A radioactive isotope of a specific element decays in a defined way (see fig.7.1). 
 Knowing how much was there to start with and how much remains determines how much time has passed. 
 The simplest radioactive methods are based on decay of a radioactive isotope into a stable one. 
 Radiocarbon and potassium-argon dating fall into this category. 
 In the former, to a first approximation, the initial amount of radiocarbon in an organic sample is taken to be that in the atmosphere now, but many adjustments are made to this assumption as will be seen below. 
 In potassium-argon dating of volcanic rocks, the radioactive potassium isotope is in a known proportion to the non-radioactive one and decays to argon. 
 The radioactive potassium has a very long half-life (1250 million years) so that the amount lost is extremely small relative to the total amount of potassium present and cannot be measured. 
 However, argon, being a gas, is at zero concentration when the rock solidifies from the molten state, so the amount of argon produced is measured. 
 Some radioactive methods, like uranium series dating, involve a chain of decay: one radioactive element decays into another which in turn decays. 
 Uranium series dating is particularly used for dating stalagmitic calcite. 
 When the calcite forms it incorporates uranium dissolved in the ground water. 
 The various decay products in the uranium chain are not present as they are not soluble in water, but they build up in a defined way, according to the decay rates of the individual isotopes in the chain. 
 From this brief summary of a small proportion of the scientific dating techniques, some common principles of their application emerge. 
 The  dating method itself must have a definable &bquo;zero time point&equo;: for example, the tree ring formed this year in dendrochronology; the solidification of a volcanic rock in potassium-argon dating; or the formation of a calcite layer for uranium series. 
 This definable zero-point must have some relevance to the archaeological site being dated: potassium-argon dating of a piece of volcanic rock will date the formation of the rock, but it does not necessarily provide any useful information for the archaeologist; the rock may simply be part of the geological environment of the site. 
 On the other hand, if archaeological finds are sandwiched between two volcanic rock layers, then the dates for them will bracket the date of the archaeology. 
 Whether upper and lower date limits ( terminus  results) such as these provide the archaeologist with a sufficiently detailed chronological picture will depend on a number of factors &mdash; the nature of the site and sequence to be interpreted, the archaeological questions being posed, and the samples available for dating &mdash; and the relevant dating methods would then need to be assessed. 
 As the general reading list at the end of this chapter testifies. 
 a whole book could be written on any one of the scientific dating techniques, so selectivity must be exercised when covering the subject in a single chapter. 
 Only radiocarbon and thermoluminescence, the techniques which the British Museum has &bquo;in house&equo;, will be discussed in any detail. 
 But this is not simply a parochial choice. 
 Radiocarbon was developed forty years  ago and is still the scientific dating method most commonly used by archaeologists. 
 Thermoluminescence is a complementary technique in the material and date range to which it is applicable; it also enables the authenticity of ceramics to be tested. 
 Any mention of radiocarbon dating necessarily involves at least a reference to dendrochronology, and the basic principles of this powerful technique are therefore also outlined (see p.125). 
 Radiocarbon dating 
 Basic principles 
 Radiocarbon dating is based on carbon &mdash; a common yet remarkable element. 
 Together with hydrogen, it is a component of all organic compounds and is fundamental to life. 
 Carbon has three naturally occurring isotopes, that is, atoms of the same atomic number but different atomic weights. 
 These are designated &dollar;sup12; C, &dollar;sup13; C and &dollar;sup14; C in scientific notation, the letter C being the symbol for elemental carbon and the isotopes having atomic weights 12, 13 and 14 respectively. 
 They do not occur equally; modern carbon consists of 99 per cent of &dollar;sup12; C and 1 per cent of &dollar;sup13; C, whereas &dollar;sup14; C is present at the level of only one part in a million million. 
 Unlike &dollar;sup12; C and &dollar;sup13; C, &dollar;sup14; C is unstable and therefore radioactive: hence the name &bquo;radiocarbon&equo; is used for this isotope which, because of its scientific designation, is also called &bquo;carbon fourteen&equo;. 
 Both here and in Chapter 8, the scientific notation (&dollar;sup14; C) will be used when referring to the isotope itself, and the word &bquo;radiocarbon&equo; when discussing the dating technique generally. 
 The rather unusual characteristic of &dollar;sup14; C is that it is continually being formed. 
 This occurs in the upper atmosphere when neutrons produced by cosmic rays interact with nitrogen atoms. 
 As soon as they are formed, the &dollar;sup14; C atoms rapidly combine with oxygen to form carbon dioxide which is chemically indistinguishable from carbon dioxide containing either of the other carbon isotopes. 
 This carbon dioxide mixes throughout the atmosphere, dissolves in the oceans and, via the photosynthesis process and the food chain, enters all plant and animal life known collectively as the biosphere. 
 Under certain circumstances, in particular if the production rate is constant, there is a balance between formation and decay, and the &dollar;sup14; C concentration in the atmosphere therefore remains constant. 
 Thus, in principle, all living organisms have the same level of &dollar;sup14; C relative to &dollar;sup12; C. 
 When a plant or animal dies it ceases to participate in carbon exchange with the biosphere and no longer takes in &dollar;sup14; C. If &dollar;sup14; C were stable, its concentration relative to &dollar;sup12; C would remain constant after death, but, since it is not. 
 the level falls at a rate determined by the radioactive decay law. 
 This law states that the number of atoms of a radioactive element is halved after a given amount of time has elapsed. 
 This amount of time is naturally enough called the half-life (T&dollar;sub1/2;). 
 The relationship between the number of atoms remaining and time is shown in Figure 7.1. 
 In principle, therefore, if the concentration of &dollar;sup14; C atoms remaining and the initial, or equilibrium, concentration can be evaluated by experiment, then one can determine  the amount of time which has elapsed since death. 
 For &dollar;sup14; C, the best estimate of T&dollar;sub1/2; is 5730 years. 
 In general, the materials which can be dated by radiocarbon are those which once formed part of the biosphere, and hence are organic. 
 For example, the most commonly preserved sample types occurring on British sites are bone, shell and charcoal, but on some sites &mdash; or in other areas of the world &mdash; a different range of materials might remain. 
 Wood and other plant remains such as ropes, cloth, reeds and seeds may be well preserved in arid environments or if waterlogged. 
 Many other materials, such as antler, horn, tooth, ivory, hair, blood residues, wool, silk, leather, paper, parchment, insects and coral, are also datable by radiocarbon. 
 The principles of radiocarbon dating are fairly straightforward, but in practice there are many problems. 
 One fundamental assumption is that the atmosphere has had the same &dollar;sup14; C concentration in the past as now, and this in turn assumes, amongst other things, that the production rate of &dollar;sup14; C has remained constant. 
 In fact there have been considerable variations in the atmospheric &dollar;sup14; C production rate. 
 Radiocarbon results cannot therefore give a true measure of age and we need some method by which to convert them to calendar dates: this is the process of calibration (seep.124). 
 Nor can it be assumed that all parts of the biosphere have the same &dollar;sup14; C concentration. 
 Firstly, in any biological pathway, differential uptake (fractionation) of the lighter isotopes of carbon occurs. 
 In addition, some of the carbon available to an organism may come from a source that is not in equilibrium with the atmosphere; the problems caused by this are called the &bquo;reservoir effects&equo;. 
 For example, carbon in fresh water can have a variety of sources, including atmospheric carbon dioxide, but also soil humic material and limestone (calcium carbonate). 
 Thus freshwater shells and aquatic plants may not give true radiocarbon ages (see also fig. 7.2). 
 Whereas fractionation can be accurately corrected for, reservoir effects cannot. 
 Another factor is whether or not the death of a plant or animal necessarily coincided with the point at which it ceased to exchange carbon with the environment. 
 The outstanding example of radiocarbon age at &bquo;death&equo; (or more usually felling) is wood. 
 It is well known that trees grow by the addition of rings, usually (though not always) annually. 
 Once formed, rings soon cease to exchange with the biosphere. 
 Hence, if one considers a long-lived tree, say a three-hundred-year-old oak, the innermost heartwood will give a radiocarbon result three hundred years older than the sapwood. 
 Indeed, this is as it should be. 
 However, if part of that heartwood were found on an archaeological site, the radiocarbon result would not provide the date of usage of the wood, but rather a date three hundred radiocarbon years earlier, and more if it has been seasoned before use or re-used. 
 This is the &bquo;old wood effect&equo;.  
 Measuring radiocarbon 
 Once a sample is accepted for dating, the first task in the laboratory is to remove any likely sources of carbon contamination, such as carbonates and humic acids from the burial environment. 
 After this pretreatment, the sample is converted to a form suitable for the particular method of radiocarbon dating to be used. 
 These methods for detecting &dollar;sup14; C are based on two fundamentally different principles. 
 The nucleus of a &dollar;sup14; C atom is unstable so there is a finite probability at any instant in time that it will decay. 
 When it does, it reverts to nitrogen (&dollar;sup14; N) and a beta particle is emitted. 
 Because it is electrically charged, the beta particle can be detected fairly easily. 
 This is the basis of conventional radiocarbon dating. 
 A more efficient method for detecting &dollar;sup14; C is to measure the number of atoms present, or a proportion of them, by mass spectrometry. 
 In a magnetic field, a moving charged particle is deflected from the straight path along which it was travelling. 
 When charged particles are travelling at the same velocity, and are subject to the same magnetic field, the heavier particles are deflected the least. 
 Detectors at different angles of deflection then receive particles of different mass. 
 However, normal mass spectrometers are not sensitive enough to detect &dollar;sup14; C and to reject all other elements or molecules of very nearly the same weight, such as &dollar;sup14; N. As this nitrogen isotope makes up some 80 per cent of the atmosphere it is very common relative to &dollar;sup14; C. The techniques of nuclear physics were brought to bear on this problem in the late 1970s, and it was shown that &dollar;sup14; C could be detected using what is now referred to as accelerator mass spectrometry, AMS. 
 In AMS the charged particles are subjected to large voltage differences so that they travel at very high speeds. 
 This enables various devices to be used in order to discriminate against the much more abundant elements and molecules which would otherwise swamp the &dollar;sup14; C signal. 
 The disadvantage of AMS is the high cost of establishing such a facility (around a million pounds sterling, nearly two million dollars) and of running it. 
 Its great advantage over conventional techniques is the small sample size needed: typically 1000 times smaller. 
 Most conventional radiocarbon laboratories require a sample that will yield about 5 g of carbon. 
 This is equivalent to about 10 g of charcoal, 50 g of wood or 200 g of bone, but depends on the state of preservation of the sample and degree of sample pretreatment to be undertaken. 
 Small objects (fig. 7.3) that would have been totally destroyed if dated by conventional &dollar;sup14; C can now be sampled for AMS, &dollar;sup5; and the benefits in dating art objects are obvious. 
 Likewise in archaeology AMS has enabled us to date samples as minute as individual seeds, which can tell us a great deal about the origins of agriculture and the domestication of cereals. 
 Whatever the technique, radiocarbon results are given in uncalibrated years BP, where 0 BP is defined as AD 1950 and the half-life used to calculate a radiocarbon result is not the more accurate value of 5730, but the Libby half-life of 5568 years (named after Willard Libby, the founder of the technique). 
 Use of the wrong half-life is automatically taken care of in the  calibration of a conventionally calculated date. 
 In addition to determining the radiocarbon &bquo;age&equo;, the laboratory must estimate the uncertainty on the experimental measurement. 
 For radiocarbon &bquo;ages&equo; below about 10,000 years, the error term is typically plus/minus 50&ndash;100 years (at the 68 per cent confidence level: see glossary). 
 High-precision laboratories can produce results with error terms of less than plus/minus 20 years; they employ very carefully controlled measurement procedures, but they also require samples three to four times the size of those used by normal-precision, conventional laboratories. 
 In conventional radiocarbon dating the maximum age that can be measured is determined by the count rate, additional to that from &dollar;sup14; C, caused by radiation in the environment. 
 It therefore varies from laboratory to laboratory, but is typically in the region of 40,000 years. 
 For AMS, the upper age limit is determined by other factors such as machine stability and the degree of modern contamination introduced in the processing of very small samples; the values tend to be similar to those for conventional radiocarbon laboratories. 
 The lower limit for both techniques is determined by the mutual interference of the fossil fuel and bomb effects. 
 In the early half of the twentieth century, the burning of fossil fuel such as coal, in which the &dollar;sup14; C had totally decayed away, diluted the atmospheric &dollar;sup14; C concentration relative to &dollar;sup13; C and &dollar;sup12; C. Nuclear weapons testing had an even more dramatic effect on atmospheric &dollar;sup14; C content. 
 The neutrons thereby produced in turn produced &dollar;sup14; C by interaction with &dollar;sup14; N. This simulated natural cosmogenic production, albeit in large bursts, and roughly doubled the atmospheric &dollar;sup14; C content as measured in about 1965. 
 Radiocarbon results of less than two hundred years are therefore usually described as &bquo;modern&equo;.  
 Calibration of radiocarbon results 
 The existence of radiocarbon in nature was predicted before it was detected, and this prediction was sufficient for an American scientist called Willard Libby to perceive the basis of a dating method. 
 The theoretical aspects were formulated in the mid-1940s and the first dates were published in December 1949. 
 During the 1950s, with advances in techniques for detecting &dollar;sup14; C, discrepancies of several centuries began to emerge between radiocarbon ages and historical ages for the Egyptian Old Kingdom. 
 Of course, the validity of the historical ages was not proven beyond doubt, but it was realised that tree rings could provide the truly &bquo;known-age&equo; material needed to test the accuracy of the new technique. 
 The radiocarbon discrepancy was confirmed and it became clear that radiocarbon results would need to be calibrated to convert them to calendar ages. 
 Since there is no theoretical way of predicting the correction factor, empirical calibration curves were needed to link radiocarbon &bquo;age&equo; with known age. 
 In the 1960s, a continuous tree-ring sequence stretching back some eight thousand years was established by Wesley Ferguson, an American dendrochronologist. 
 The first calibration curve using this was published by an American scientist, Hans Suess. 
 High-precision calibration curves now exist which confirm the two features apparent in Suess's curve. 
 First there is a long-term trend caused by fluctuations in the earth's magnetic field strength. 
 This trend has a maximum deviation from true age of about nine hundred years too recent at the beginning of the fourth millennium BC. 
 On the other hand, in the middle of the first millennium AD, radiocarbon produces &bquo;ages&equo; that are too old by a century or so (fig. 7.4). 
 The second  feature takes the form of &bquo;wiggles&equo;. 
 These are superimposed on the main curve, and only last a few decades, but can have deviations on the radiocarbon axis of a century or so (fig. 7.5). 
 They are probably produced by variations in sunspot activity. 
 Any variations in production of &dollar;sup14; C are rapidly distributed throughout the atmosphere, so a calibration curve of radiocarbon &bquo;age&equo; versus calendar age for one material and one geographical region will serve as a global calibration curve. 
 Once the calendar timescale has been produced using dendrochronology, groups of ten or twenty tree rings are dated by radiocarbon to provide the y-axis of the calibration curve. 
 The basis of dendrochronology lies in the fact that, in temperature climates where there is a contrast between the seasons, trees grow by the addition of an annual ring. 
 The growth region is a thin band of cells called the cambium, which lies between the bark and the sapwood. 
 Division of these cells adds new bark to the outer side of the cambium and new sapwood to the inside. 
 The well-defined rings (fig. 7.6) are due to the difference in the cells produced at different times of the year. 
 For some species, the width of each ring depends on prevailing climatic conditions, such as temperature and rainfall. 
 Thus, for a living tree, counting backwards from the cambium layer gives the age of a particular ring, and its relative thickness indicates whether the growing season was good or bad in that year and locality. 
 Trees of a single species growing in the same locality should have a similar pattern of ring widths, uniquely defined by their common history. 
 This is the basis of cross-dating: being able to associate a tree-ring sequence of unknown age with one of known age by matching one pattern with another. 
 Long chronologies (&bquo;master curves&equo;)  are established starting with living trees, or timbers where the &bquo;zero age, ring is present and the year of felling known (fig. 7.7). 
 The timescale is then extended by using large felled timbers with patterns sufficiently overlapping the existing chronology to be certain of a unique match. 
 In dendrochronology the timescale of the master chronology is accurate to within one year. 
 It is therefore a very powerful dating technique making it possible to date the right archaeological samples (see p. 144) to the year of felling, as well as providing the accurate calendar timescale necessary for radiocarbon calibration. 
 In converting radiocarbon results to calendar dates, the wiggles in the calibration curve are the real problem. 
 One consequence is that calibrated dates are not central dates with an error term, but a range or ranges of dates. 
 In fact, there is currently no consensus on exactly how to calibrate a radiocarbon result. 
 Essentially there are two approaches: the intercept and probability methods. 
 A brief description of the intercept method should provide a flavour of what happens when a radiocarbon result is calibrated. 
 As shown in Figure 7.8, the calendar dates corresponding to t+&dollar; and t-&dollar; are found (where t is the radiocarbon result and &dollar; is the error term, which includes the laboratory's estimate of the experimental error on the result and the error on the calibration curve, combined statistically). 
 Using the values t+&dollar; and t-&dollar; gives 68 per cent confidence ranges (see glossary); for 95 per cent confidence, t + 2&dollar; and t &mdash; 2&dollar; must be used. 
 If the calibration curve is &bquo;wiggly&equo;, there will be multiple ranges. 
 Note also the increased size of the calibrated range relative to the uncalibrated one where the slope of the curve is effectively less than 45 degrees, and the decreased size where the slope is steep. 
 It must not be assumed that the most likely date is in the centre of the range; to quantify the distribution of the calendar dates, one of the probability methods (which require computerisation) must be used. 
 Although calibration complicates the process of interpreting the radiocarbon results, it is essential. 
 There are several periods in the calibration curve where events that are separated in calendar time by several centuries appear approximately contemporaneous from their radiocarbon results. 
  The worst of these is for the period corresponding to the British Early Iron Age (c.800&ndash;400 BC). 
 There are also periods where the curve is so steep that apparently large differences in radiocarbon results arise from events separated by relatively small amounts of real time. 
 Only after calibration can we begin to assess the true temporal relationship of events dated by radiocarbon. 
 To distinguish calibrated dates from true historical dates, the conventions cal BC, cal AD and cal BP (where 0 BP is AD 1950) are used. 
 Using radiocarbon dating 
 When radiocarbon dating was developed and first used in the late 1940s and 1950s, the complexities of the technique were not fully appreciated. 
 For the best results in a given situation, archaeologists and radiocarbon scientists must work together, from the planning of a sampling strategy to the interpretation of the results. 
 As we have seen, the interpretation is complicated by the need for calibration, and the involvement of statisticians is increasingly valuable. 
 Once the archaeological problem has been formulated, whether or not radiocarbon can be used to resolve issues of chronology will depend on a number of factors, such as the type of samples available, the nature of the contexts and events to be dated and the likely age range once the radiocarbon results are calibrated. 
 The interplay of these factors is illustrated by the following case studies. 
 British Beaker chronology 
 The second half of the third millennium BC saw the introduction of the first metalworking into Britain. 
 This very early phase of the Bronze Age was also marked by the appearance of a distinctive ceramic form called the Beaker, which also lends its name to this period of transition from the Neolithic to the Early Bronze Age. 
 Beaker pottery is characterised by often skilfully made vessels with an S-shaped profile and zones of geometric decoration produced by impressing twisted cords, stamps or combs into  the clay. 
 Much time would have been invested in making these fine vessels, and many were apparently viewed as prestige items fit to be placed with burials of the period (fig. 7.9). 
 Often only a Beaker accompanies the body, but occasionally other grave goods occur. 
 such as copper-alloy knives, archers' wristguards of stone and, in some instances, even personal ornaments made of gold. 
 Beaker pottery is very widespread in Europe and there is little doubt that the style was initially introduced to Britain from the Continent. 
 However, the chronological development of Beaker styles and the possibility of further Continental influence were open to conjecture. 
 Through past study a broadly accepted relative chronology for Beaker pottery had been developed. 
 This was based on classification of the proportions of the bodies of the vessels and the decorative motifs employed. 
 Until recently, there were few radiocarbon results for material directly associated with Beaker pottery. 
 Furthermore, of these few results, a substantial number were for charcoal, with all the attendant problems of possible age offset due to &bquo;old wood&equo; (see p. 121). 
 Hence neither the relative nor the existing absolute dates were totally satisfactory. 
 To remedy this situation, the British Museum initiated a research programme of radiocarbon dating. 
 The aim was to locate forty to fifty samples well associated with Beaker pottery in a variety of styles. 
 The obvious choice of sample was the skeletal material in the Beaker burials themselves, because for bone there is no time delay between death and cessation of &dollar;sup14; C exchange with the biosphere. 
 Also, the association is good between sample and context (bone and grave), and between context and event to be dated (grave and the act of burial). 
 The theoretical basis of the project was  therefore straightforward, but in practice it proved significantly less so. 
 Museums and archaeological collections throughout Britain were contacted and, although many were willing to help by providing samples for dating, problems emerged. 
 Much of our knowledge of Beaker burials derives from excavations conducted in the last century, when the principles of good archaeological practice were only just beginning to be formulated. 
 Where bone from burials had been retained, the frequent lack of adequate documentation made it impossible to associate definitively one particular skeleton with a given Beaker pot. 
 Many frustrating searches and months later, the total number of samples collected was only twenty-eight and, worse still, nearly half of these had to be rejected, either because of carbon contamination introduced during conservation treatments, or because the sample was too small to give a reasonably precise result. 
 Fortunately, samples from recent excavations have subsequently become available, and the project has now produced twenty radiocarbon results: more than doubling the previous total for actual skeletons from British Beaker burials. 
 What of the results? 
 As always, the need to calibrate the radiocarbon &bquo;dates&equo; means that normal statistical tests cannot be applied. 
 It is therefore impossible to test statistically whether samples associated with a particular type of Beaker pot are earlier or later than those linked to another. 
 However, graphical plots of the date ranges show no clear chronological pattern. 
 The foundation of many theories of Beaker pottery development and the effects of Continental influence must therefore be re-examined. 
 Early mining in Wales 
 Trying to be highly selective in the type of sample submitted for radiocarbon dating can be very frustrating, as illustrated by the Beaker project outlined above. 
 It is nevertheless essential in the majority of situations where there is a specific question on the chronology requiring an accurate and reasonably precise answer. 
 Not all contexts allow such careful choice, however, and it has to be decided whether a set of radiocarbon results using less than ideal samples provides better dating evidence than the archaeology alone. 
 One such case is the search for evidence of early mining in Britain. 
 Much is known about the metal artefacts produced in the British Bronze Age, but until recently very little was known of the copper sources exploited (see Chapter 4). 
 Mines have very few chronologically distinctive features. 
 Unlike habitation sites, they have little domestic refuse and, unlike cemetery sites, they do not normally contain burials. 
 Consequently, there are rarely any really diagnostic ceramic or metal artefacts that can provide any clue as to their age. 
 On the other hand, there are two recurring characteristics of certain copper mines: the use of firesetting and pebble-stone hammers. 
 Some would argue that these provide clear evidence of prehistoric exploitation, whilst others see them as highly practical, and therefore long-lived, mining methods. 
 The problem boils down to a lack of independent dating evidence. 
 Like other debris, there is a limited amount of organic refuse suitable for radiocarbon dating, and what there is tends to be charcoal from mature oak. 
 Although the wood is presumed to have been used for  firesetting. the association between mining activity and the sample is rarely certain. 
 Thus, when there were only one or two dates for supposedly early mine sites, their relevance had to be interpreted with care. 
 Now, however, for Welsh copper mine sites alone there are fifteen radiocarbon results. 
 all of which calibrate to the Early or Middle Bronze Age; such a body of evidence cannot be chance. 
 Thus the long and laborious process of collecting anything that might conceivably be datable has paid dividends, placing several Bronze Age mines firmly on the map. 
 Thermoluminescence dating 
 Basic principles 
 The principles of thermoluminescence (TL) dating are reasonably straightforward, but the details of the TL mechanism are not fully understood &mdash; even by solid state physicists! 
 The principles of TL dating are here outlined for pottery, for which it was first developed; its extension to other materials is discussed later. 
 Thermoluminescence is a property of crystalline materials, such as quartz and feldspars, which are found in pottery. 
 These minerals receive radiation both internally, from the ceramic, and externally, from the burial environment and cosmic rays. 
 The ceramic and soil contain minute quantities of uranium, thorium and potassium which are radioactive, and when these decay they produce alpha, beta and gamma radiation (potassium contributes only to the beta and gamma components). 
 These radioactive elements have very long half-lives, so the flux of radiation is effectively constant for the archaeological periods of interest in TL dating. 
 Alpha, beta and gamma radiation, together with cosmic rays, are referred to as ionising radiation because they interact with atoms, removing electrons from them, and the atoms then became ions. 
 In this way the radiation loses energy, which is imparted to the electrons of the material. 
 The amount of energy lost to the material per unit weight is referred to as the &bquo;radiation dose&equo;. 
 When minerals such as quartz and feldspars have received a radiation dose and are then heated, they emit light. 
 This is thermoluminescence (&bquo;heat-light&equo;); it is produced because of the radiation dose, and is additional to any red-hot glow produced by heat alone. 
 Thermoluminescence is emitted because crystal lattices contain defects, and electrons produced by the ionising radiation may become trapped at one type of defect (a &bquo;trap&equo;). 
 This is only one of the things that can happen to the electrons, but it is the one which is of interest in the production of TL. 
 Depending on the nature of the defect, electrons may remain trapped for long periods of time; such a trap would be referred to as &bquo;deep&equo;. 
 If heat is applied, the electron may be able to escape from the deep trap. 
 Again, however, many things can then happen to it; if it is to produce TL, the electron must recombine with another type of defect, and the recombination process must produce energy in the form of light. 
 This type of defect is referred to as a &bquo;luminescence centre&equo;. 
 The intensity of the TL produced by the deep traps is roughly proportional  to three factors: the amount of radiation received per year; the TL sensitivity of the sample (i.e. the amount of TL produced per unit of radiation dose); and the time, in years, that has elapsed since the sample was last heated. 
 The last of these factors is the age of the pot, because its initial firing by the potter in antiquity would have ejected all the trapped electrons (thus &bquo;zeroing the TL clock&equo;), from which time the electron population in deep traps would have steadily built up. 
 The basic age equation is:  where the &bquo;natural TL signal&equo; is the TL measured on the first heating of a sample in the laboratory. 
 In principle, therefore, if the three factors on the right-hand side of the equation can be measured, then the pot can be dated. 
 In practice the situation is not quite so simple, and many measurements and checks must be made by the TL scientist, only a few of which will be mentioned here. 
 The upper age limit of TL dating depends on the stability of the signal, on the saturation level of the TL material and on the annual radiation dose. 
 The stability of the signal is usually determined by the depth of the trap: the deeper it is, the more stable the signal. 
 However, other factors can also affect stability (see, for example, anomalous fading, p. 1 33). 
 Saturation occurs when the TL signal no longer increases significantly with the addition of further radiation; this is due to the filling of the traps with time. 
 The radiation dose which produces saturation is related to the concentration of defects in the crystal. 
 However, the time at which this level of radiation dose is reached depends on how quickly the radiation dose is received; the lower the dose rate, the longer it will take to reach saturation. 
 In consequence, it is not possible to attach a single number to the upper age limit of TL; rather it is specific to each type of sample and each archaeological site. 
 The few generalisations that can be made are discussed at appropriate points below. 
 Determining TL age 
 The TL produced by archaeological samples such as pottery is weak and its measurement therefore requires sensitive light-detecting equipment such as a photomultiplier, which converts the light signal to an electrical one. 
 The signal is plotted as the temperature of the sample is increased, up to 500&deg;C typically, and the output is referred to as a glow curve (fig. 7.10). 
 So-called &bquo;artificial&equo; glow curves can be induced in the laboratory using alpha and beta radiation sources. 
 Thus the TL sensitivity of the sample to radiation can be determined. 
 In fact, this involves taking a large number of TL measurements to check or correct for changes of TL sensitivity and non-linear growth of TL with dose. 
 Some of the checks for stability of TL signal involve the use of the plateau test. 
 This compares the shape of  the natural TL glow curve (see fig. 7.10) with that induced by a laboratory dose: at low temperature the signal is not stable and the ratio of the TL signals varies, but at temperatures above about 300&dollar;C there should be a plateau. 
 The radioactive components in the pottery and the soil are uranium, thorium and potassium, which can be readily detected by analytical techniques such as neutron activation analysis (see glossary), and their contributions to the dose rate then calculated from knowledge of how they decay radioactively. 
 However, particularly for the gamma-ray contribution, more direct measurement of the radiation dose is usually employed. 
 The gamma radiation has a range of about 30 cm, and for a typical sherd of pottery, this means that the soil contributes the majority of the gamma dose. 
 If this contribution is to be representative of the burial environment within a 30 cm radius, it is best measured in situ , either using small metal capsules containing a highly TL-sensitive material buried for about one year, or using a calibrated gamma ray spectrometer. 
 There are many measurements involved in evaluating a TL age, each of which is subject to measurement errors. 
 To improve precision, it is usual to date several samples from the same archaeological level to determine the mean age. 
 Even so, the resulting error term is still typically plus/minus 5&ndash;10 per cent of the age, at the 68 per cent confidence level (see glossary). 
 However, occasionally, if it proves impossible to measure any one of the factors in the age equation accurately, no TL date for a site may be obtained at all. 
 Other TL-datable materials 
 For a sample to be datable by TL it has to be crystalline but non-metallic. 
 It also has to have some mechanism by which the latent TL signal is zeroed  that can be related to an archaeological or geological event of interest. 
 Thus, for pottery dating, quartz and feldspars satisfy the initial criteria, and the zeroing mechanism is the firing of the ceramic. 
 Heat also resets the TL clock in a range of other materials: 
 volcanic minerals and sediments underlying a lava flow 
 clay, other than pottery, which has been deliberately subjected to heat (e.g. walls and bases of kilns and hearths, metal-production debris such as tuyeres and furnaces, core material remaining in bronzes after casting on a clay core), or heated accidentally (e.g. daub from a house burnt down in a fire) 
 stones, such as flint, heated either deliberately (e.g. cooking stones heated in a fire, then used to boil water) or accidentally 
 vitrified materials, such as glass itself or slag from metallurgical processes. 
 At first sight the last category might not seem to fit the dating criteria since glass is strictly speaking amorphous rather than crystalline, but it can have a sufficiently crystalline structure for TL to be produced. 
 However, even if the natural TL signal can be measured, the dating of both glass and slags is rarely satisfactory: glass gives problems because of its transparency, which allows the TL signal to be bleached by light (see below), and slag can be very inhomogenous in its radioactivity content. 
 The feldspars in volcanic lava flows can also be problematic. 
 Indeed, it was the initial attempt to date these which led to the discovery of anomalous fading. 
 This is the name given to rapid loss of the TL signal from that part of the glow curve normally thought to be stable. 
 A safer approach is to date quartz within the flow, or from the underlying sediment heated by the flow. 
 Dating baked clay and burnt stone are perhaps the most interesting archaeological applications of TL, because these &mdash; in particular burnt flint &mdash; allow the dating of sites older than about ten thousand years, when the first pottery began to appear. 
 Because of its low internal radioactivity, flint is especially good for dating the Palaeolithic back to at least 250 ka (1 ka = 1000 years). 
 Apart from heat, there are two other main zeroing mechanisms: crystal formation and exposure to sunlight. 
 Without a crystal structure, there can be no TL; hence, the formation of a crystal such as calcite is &bquo;time zero&equo; for TL dating. 
 It is important to date stalagmites or flow stones, rather than stalactites, since the formation of the latter is not readily relatable to any archaeological event. 
 With stalagmitic calcite, the position of the calcite in relation to the archaeological levels will provide at least a terminus  result, and in some cases the archaeology may fortuitously be sandwiched between two datable calcite layers. 
 If there is detrital material in the stalagmite, such as clay and limestone, it will not have a zero TL signal at the time of the stalagmite's formation. 
 The amount of detrital material determines the lower  level of TL dating of calcite. 
 The useful age range may therefore be 20&ndash;300 ka, although its true limits have not been adequately explored.  
 In some of the early work on TL dating of ocean sediments, it was thought that the TL observed was produced by foraminifera or radiolaria and that the zeroing mechanism was the formation of their shells. 
 In fact it was the sediment particles attached to the shells which were producing the TL. 
 These were most likely to have been zeroed by the action of sunlight prior to their deposition on the sea bed. 
 In recent years, TL has increasingly been applied to the dating of terrestrial sediments. 
 Loess, in particular, is an obvious sediment for TL dating since it is fine-grained. 
 Also, while being transported by wind, it will have been exposed to sunlight for a considerable time prior to deposition. 
 Perhaps more than any other application of TL, sediment dating has fired the most interest. 
 This is largely because of its enormous potential for dating geological processes and sedimentary sequences. 
 The lower limit of TL dating of sediment is closely linked with uncertainty about how far the sediment was bleached in antiquity, and this led to development of the optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) technique. 
 On the other hand, the apparent upper limit of TL dating of sediment seems to depend on the methodology used, and there is currently no consensus on the matter other than that this limit is at least 100 ka: many dates are being produced well in excess of this value, but there are rarely independent and reliable age estimates against which to compare them. 
 Having ranged rapidly through the materials that are datable by TL, we must not forget that it is also widely used in authenticity testing of both ceramics and the casting cores of bronzes. 
 These applications are discussed in Chapter 8. 
 Using TL dating 
 Pontnewydd Cave 
 Pontnewydd Cave (fig. 7.11) is situated near Rhyl in North Wales and is one of only two British sites having hominid remains of the Middle Pleistocene period. 
 It also exemplifies the potential, and some of the problems,  of TL dating beyond the range of radiocarbon. 
 Continued involvement of TL scientists through the different seasons of excavation has enabled them to collect samples and bury capsules to measure the associated gamma radiation dose rate, burying a capsule one summer and retrieving it the next. 
 For calcite dating by TL, the use of TL capsules is essential. 
 A gamma spectrometer cannot be used because a hole about 5 cm in diameter is required for the probe; it is extremely hard work to drill the 1 cm hole needed for a capsule, and anything larger would be impossible! 
 Also, many calcite layers are relatively thin and surrounded by non-calcite levels; removal of a 5 cm diameter part of the layer could well result in an unrepresentative measurement of the gamma dose rate. 
 The chief difficulty in dating Pontnewydd Cave arose because the gamma dose rates varied locally within the cave deposits. 
 The infill of the cave is made up of a wide variety of materials, from silts to large stones, and the radioactive content of these materials is similarly variable. 
 Those which are datable, the stalagmites and burnt flints, have low concentrations of the radioactive elements uranium, thorium and potassium, as does the limestone which is also found within the deposits. 
 However, other stones and sediments interspersed with these contain far greater amounts of radioactivity. 
 It is not always possible to measure the gamma dose rate at exactly the spot where a sample for dating is found, since the excavation of the sample will have removed much of the material surrounding it. 
 Capsules have to be buried as near as possible, but there is no guarantee that the measurement will be truly representative. 
 The burning of flint samples should be directly associated with the date of occupation of the site. 
 TL dates of three burnt flints have been measured at the British Museum, and these straddle a mean of 190.000 years BP, but there is a large variation about this mean because of the inhomogeneity of the radiation environment in the cave outlined above. 
 Measurements on a single burnt flint, carried out in Oxford. 
 also indicated an age of about 200,000 years. 
 Some of the deposits from which the burnt flints derived were overlain by an undisturbed stalagmitic floor. 
 The dating of this floor, which has been carried out using both TL and uranium series dating (see p. 118), generally confirms the occupation dates obtained from the burnt flints. 
 By the TL method, the stalagmitic floor is dated to around 170,000 years BP. 
 The uranium series measurements give a slightly older date of 205,000 years BP, but given that the uncertainties in each of these figures are typically 20 per cent, the two techniques can be said to agree with each other. 
 Such margins of error and variation in results may seem large, but they have to be viewed against the alternative: no independent dates at all. 
 The picture of the history of Pontnewydd Cave that emerges from these and other date measurements is now fairly well established. 
 The occupation of the site, at the cave mouth, occurred around 200,000 years ago. 
 Within a few thousand years, the debris left by the occupants &mdash; including some of their remains, their artefacts and the burnt flints &mdash; was incorporated in a deposit which was forced into the cave from the outside by water. 
 Upon  the upper surface of this deposit, stalagmitic floors formed, and continued to do so intermittently and in different parts of the cave, until a further inflow of material entered the cave between 80,000 and 30,000 years ago. 
 The growth of stalagmites resumed on top of this fresh deposit when the climate warmed up around 18,000 years ago. 
 Bermondsey Abbey 
 Although TL really only comes into its own beyond the range of radiocarbon dating, it can also provide answers to specific archaeological problems where no suitable radiocarbon samples exist. 
 Excavations at Bermondsey Abbey in south-east London uncovered a large drain. 
 Not a prepossessing feature in isolation but, to the archaeologist, understanding the origin of the contents of the backfill of this drain could play an essential part in unravelling the history of activities on the site as a whole. 
 The backfill material contained a considerable amount of pottery, which was stylistically attributable to the second half of the eleventh century AD, along with much burnt clay or daub thought to derive from wattle walls. 
 Stratigraphically the ditch was backfilled before the construction of the first phase of the priory church and was thus before AD 1090. 
 The mystery was the origin of the large quantities of daub. 
 This daub could have come from one of three distinct periods. 
 One possibility was that it was Roman material introduced when the drain walls had collapsed, for the drain had been cut through Roman deposits. 
 A second possibility was an origin in the Middle Saxon period in the first half of the eighth century AD: evidence for this occupation comes from both documentary sources and finds from the site. 
 The third alternative, and the most straightforward interpretation, was that the daub was contemporary with the backfilling of the drain. 
 Given the possible mixed origins of the backfill, dating the daub by other associated material such as charcoal could not solve the problem. 
 Provided the gamma dose rate, which had possibly changed at some point in the history of the daub, was not a dominant contribution to the TL age, TL could solve the mystery. 
 The gamma dose rate proved to be only about 20 per cent &mdash; reasonably typical for clay materials. 
 Three pieces of daub were dated and provided an average age and standard error of 830 plus/minus 40 years. 
 In other words, the true date lies between TL 1080 and 1240, with 95 per cent confidence, clearly demonstrating that the third alternative holds: the daub is broadly contemporary with the backfilling of the drain and coincides with clearance of buildings in the eleventh century AD to make way for the building of the priory church. 
 Radiocarbon or thermoluminescence? 
 For a particular archaeological site, the choice of dating method depends largely on the materials available and the age of the site. 
 If we had to choose between radiocarbon and TL dating, then we would have to take into account that radiocarbon is used for organic materials and has an upper age limit of about forty thousand years, whereas TL is applied to  inorganic samples and can be used beyond the range of radiocarbon. 
 Another factor to bear in mind is that, unlike TL dating, radiocarbon is independent of the archaeological burial environment, provided that potential contaminants have been removed in the pretreatment process. 
 In situations where both methods could be used, the choice depends on the association between the sample and the event to be dated, as well as on the likely error terms. 
 TL typically produces an error term of plus/minus 5&ndash;10 per cent of the age, i.e. plus/minus 50&ndash;100 years for a TL age of 1000 years, plus/minus 100-200 years for 2000 years, and so on. 
 In contrast, radiocarbon typically produces error terms of plus/minus 50&ndash;100 years, independent of age, for ages less than about 10,000 years, after which the error increases. 
 However, unlike TL dates, radiocarbon results have to be calibrated and the size of the resulting age range depends on the form of the calibration curve in that period (fig. 7.8), although the radiocarbon age range will generally be smaller than the corresponding TL one. 
 Hence TL is normally used in the following situations: beyond the range of radiocarbon: when no organic material has been preserved on the site: when the association between the event to be dated and the radiocarbon content of the organic samples is poor; or for the few periods where the age range on a calibrated radiocarbon age is larger than the corresponding TL error term. 
 Whatever the technique &mdash; be it radiocarbon, TL, or one of the many others &mdash; there are optimal circumstances under which it works best. 
 Occasionally there are situations where two techniques can be used, and there may be good reason to apply both so that they provide supporting evidence for each other (for example, see p. 134 for the use of TL and uranium series dating at Pontnewydd Cave). 
 Concluding remarks 
 Scientific dating techniques, and none more than radiocarbon, have revolutionised the archaeologist's understanding of human cultural development. 
 Before the advent of radiocarbon, chronologies for later prehistory in Western Europe were often based on presumed linkages, however tenuous, with those civilisations of the Near and Middle East which had historical calendars. 
 The chronological extrapolation to Western Europe then required the postulation of models about the rate of diffusion of ideas. 
 Thus Stonehenge was presumed to postdate the tholoi of Mycenae, and the time taken for agriculture to spread to Britain was thought to be so great that the inception of the Neolithic was placed at about 2500 BC. 
 Radiocarbon, particularly once the need to calibrate was accepted, has shown that the development of Stonehenge lasted several centuries with Mycenae being only contemporary with the final phase; thus the independent invention of megalithic monuments had to be accepted. 
 Just as dramatically, radiocarbon dating has shown that the Neolithic was introduced to Britain at least 1500 years earlier than previously believed. 
 Radiocarbon alone cannot provide the absolute dates that archaeologists require. 
 Calibration of radiocarbon results relies totally on the provision by dendrochronology of a reliable calendar timescale. 
 precise to the year. 
  The origins of dendrochronology lie in climate studies and it was then applied to dating. 
 But the benefits have come full circle, for the long master chronologies subsequently established for archaeological dating and calibration of radiocarbon results are now of just as much value to climatologists studying cycles in weather patterns associated with factors like sunspot activity and variations in the earth's orbital parameters. 
 Beyond radiocarbon, other techniques such as TL are providing dates that can aid in the understanding of human evolution. 
 For example, it is now known that in Israel anatomically modern humans were present some 90,000 years ago and that there was human occupation of Australia 50,000 years ago. 
 Much earlier still, potassium-argon dating has provided a chronological framework for the early hominid finds in East Africa. 
 Between them, the scientific techniques available thus span very wide time ranges and are indispensable in the continuing search for answers to questions of chronology. 
 Further reading   
 Spotting the Fakes Paul Craddock and Sheridan Bowman 
 A wide range of scientific methods can be usefully employed to unmask fakes and fraudulent restorations, in much the same way that forensic methods are used in criminal investigations. 
 However there is one obvious question to ask about authenticity testing: if scientific dating methods can be used, why bother with any other techniques? 
 It is, after all, the date of the object that is in question. 
 The simple answer is that not all materials lend themselves to scientific dating. 
 We must therefore resort to more indirect methods, such as the variation with time of copper-alloy composition or technology of production. 
 Indirect methods require the establishment of appropriate databases against which to compare the composition, or other characteristic, of the questionable object. 
 Here, the value of well-documented museum collections or excavated finds cannot be overstated. 
 In contrast, dating techniques do not require this comparative material; they tell us immediately whether or not the object is genuine &mdash; at least, they do in theory! 
 There is another less obvious reason why other techniques might be applied in an authenticity study, even when a dating method can be used. 
 The material with which a major museum has to deal, both within its own collections and on offer to it, will have come from a wide variety of sources. 
 Very often the history of an object is not known at all and there may be reason to believe that it is not all that it purports to be. 
 The problem is often not just whether it is genuine or fake, but rather how much is original, and what has subsequently been done to the object, when, by whom and why. 
 A badly damaged object may have been repaired, or the whole object may be a confection of previously unassociated fragments. 
 A genuine but mundane antiquity can have its value increased enormously by the addition of a unique feature, or of a historical association such as a royal cipher. 
 Given the complexity of many of the objects, and the almost endless possibilities of treatment that could have befallen them, the scientist needs the collaboration of the art historian, in addition to a very wide experience of antiquities and knowledge of the technical processes of the past, in order to reconstruct as much as possible of a particular object's background history. 
 Some of the scientific methods and problems encountered are exemplified below by specific case histories. 
 The main approaches to the scientific detection of fakes are: the study of composition and methods of construction to see if they match the supposed age of the object; examination for evidence of aging, such as the formation of a patina; and the application  of archaeological dating techniques, which can at least give an indication of age and in some cases an actual date. 
 Scientific dating techniques 
 The most widely used dating techniques for authenticity testing are thermoluminescence, radiocarbon and dendrochronology: how they work is outlined in Chapter 7. 
 In their application to authenticity testing the first consideration is whether the sample size required is likely to inflict unacceptable damage. 
 The object may prove to be genuine, but this is little consolation to the owner if it has been largely destroyed during the authentication process. 
 Radiocarbon dating 
 Until relatively recently, radiocarbon dating would have fallen into the largely destructive category. 
 Conventional radiocarbon dating normally requires sample sizes which will yield a minimum  of 1 g of carbon. 
 This may not sound much but it is equivalent, for example, to about 400 sq cm of cloth or 50 g of bone. 
 The advent of small sample systems, in particular accelerator mass spectrometry (AMS, see p. 122) has placed all but the very smallest objects within reach of radiocarbon: AMS only requires about 1 milligram  of carbon. 
 The sample preparation procedures are the same as those used for radiocarbon dating, care being taken to avoid contamination. 
 The range of objects tested covers the whole spectrum of datable materials found on archaeological sites but also encompasses more exotic items such as embroidered silk and carved ivory. 
 All of the caveats that apply to radiocarbon dating apply to its use in authentication. 
 One might even have to be careful about possible re-use of materials which would produce a radiocarbon result older than the true age of manufacture of the artefact. 
 It was, for example, quite common in the last century for ivory objects to be carved from mammoth tusk that had been preserved in the permafrost of the Siberian tundra since the last Ice Age! 
 The application of radiocarbon dating is usually relatively straightforward, and the dating process will produce a result with an error term that is just as good as for any archaeological sample. 
 In many authenticity studies there is rarely a problem in distinguishing very recent from ancient. 
 Indeed, an artefact made since about 1955 will give an apparent radiocarbon age that is some time into the future because of the excess radiocarbon produced in the atmosphere by nuclear weapons testing (the &bquo;bomb effect&equo;, see p. 123). 
 To interpret a radiocarbon result in terms of calendar age requires that it be calibrated (see p. 124). 
 Where problems can arise is in distinguishing between possible dates in the last few centuries, but prior to the bomb effect. 
 A canvas may be perfectly genuine if shown to date to the seventeenth century, but be a fake if it is nineteenth century. 
 Here radiocarbon cannot help. 
 The calibration curve is so wiggly in this region that the possible alternative date ranges encompass both periods (see figs 7.5 and 7.8).  
 The most well-known application of radiocarbon must be the dating of the Shroud of Turin. 
 This linen cloth, some 4.25 m in length, bears the shadowy image of the front and back of a man who appears to have been scourged and crucified, and it is therefore believed to have been Christ's burial shroud. 
 Its history is known with certainty back to about AD 1350, when it was in the possession of the de Charny family in France. 
 Even then it appears to have caused something of a religious furore, being declared by some to be a fake and by others to be the true Shroud. 
 In 1898, the first ever photograph of the Shroud showed that the image, when seen in negative, is strikingly life-like (fig. 8.1). 
 This discovery and subsequent medical findings fuelled suggestions that the cloth could conceivably be genuine. 
 Despite the large size of the Shroud, removal of the area of cloth needed for normal radiocarbon dating would have inflicted unacceptable damage. 
 Thus it was not until the AMS technique had been perfected that a fragment of the linen could be removed for dating. 
 This fragment, measuring only a few square centimetres, was divided up and samples, the equivalent of about 50 mg in weight, were given to three accelerator laboratories in Oxford, Zurich and Tucson. 
 The British Museum was asked to participate in the certification of the sampling and the statistical analysis of the results. 
 The calibrated radiocarbon result was AD 1260&ndash;1390 (at the 95 per cent confidence level: see glossary); this accords well with the Shroud's first appearance in France. 
 However, until it can be properly established how this striking image came into being, the mystery will not be completely solved. 
 Indeed, the controversy raised in the fourteenth century over the authenticity of the Shroud has been revived rather than settled by the radiocarbon date. 
 Thermoluminescence dating 
 If AMS is used, there is no fundamental difference between radiocarbon as applied to authenticity testing and archaeological dating. 
 This is not the case with thermoluminescence (TL) dating, which requires several grams of pottery. 
 This is rarely a problem for dating an archaeological site where fragments of broken pottery tend to abound, and it is usual to date several sherds from the same context to provide an average age and better precision. 
 Clearly, however, one cannot remove such a large sample from a fine ceramic artefact on offer to a museum. 
 The other problem is that part of the radiation dose which induces the TL signal is from the environment the object has been kept in, and the precise storage history over the lifetime of most antiquities is not known. 
 These two problems can be overcome but at a price in terms of the overall precision and accuracy of the result. 
 A sample weighing about 30 mg is drilled from an inconspicuous area of the object, usually the base. 
 This sample size is just sufficient to allow a limited number of measurements to be done. 
 From dating studies on archaeological ceramics, we know that the environment does not make the largest contribution to the annual radiation dose of ceramics, and a  likely range of environmental radiation values can be assumed in estimating the TL age. 
 This is normally adequate to distinguish recently made objects &mdash; fakes &mdash; from those genuinely manufactured in antiquity. 
 In addition to pottery, the core material from bronzes that have been cast using a clay core (see p. 84) can also be tested by TL, since this ceramic material has normally been fired to a sufficiently high temperature to &bquo;zero the TL clock&equo;. 
 Porcelain can also be TL tested, but it is such a hard ceramic that a drill cannot be used to take the sample because of the heat generated and the spurious luminescence signals produced. 
 Samples can, however, be taken by using a diamond-impregnated coring bit. 
 The small cylinder of sample removed is then sliced, like a loaf of bread, and the slices are used for the TL measurements. 
 Thermoluminescence has had a major impact on the antiquities market starting from about 1970 when the first tests were made in Oxford. 
 No longer does evidence of authenticity have to rely solely on stylistic criteria, which can be unreliable. 
 Museum collections worldwide have also been shown to have their share of fakes, as the TL testing of the British Museum's collection of seventy Zapotec ceramics can demonstrate. 
 The Zapotec culture flourished in Oaxaca in southern Mexico between about AD 200 and 800. 
 It produced distinctive pottery vessels in human or animal form, which are now found in large numbers in collections throughout the world. 
 Many Zapotec pottery vessels, however, have long been suspected of being forgeries. 
 The British Museum's collection, much of which was collected last century or in the early half of this century, was shown by TL to contain some twenty forgeries, most of which had, in recent years, been suspected to be modern. 
 That so many museum curators have been deceived by these fakes is less surprising when seen in the context of both the style itself and the history of archaeology in Oaxaca. 
 Relatively little was really known of Zapotec culture until the excavations at the Monte Alban and other sites in the 1930s. 
 Except for the earliest styles, Zapotec pottery was largely mould-made and decorated with applied decorative motifs often cut from flat sheets of clay and easily copied. 
 The use of genuine pre-Hispanic moulds has also caused confusion. 
 The &bquo;basket&equo; with rodents included in Figure 8.2 would attract suspicion because the form itself is not within the canon of Zapotec work. 
 However, the animal figures which decorate the body of the vessel are from a genuine figurine mould and therefore in perfect Zapotec style. 
 There is good evidence that a flourishing trade in false antiquities existed at the turn of the century, and its products filtered through to the United States and Europe. 
 In the 1920s and 1930s a large percentage of the so-called ancient material which would have been familiar to interested collectors was the product of this well-established manufacture. 
 Dendrochronology 
 As the name implies, dendrochronology is specific to the dating of wood. 
 This technique is highly precise, to the year or even season of felling, if the sample is adequate. 
 Herein lies the problem: the wood needs to be of a  species for which there is a &bquo;master chronology&equo; (see p. 125) and there must normally be at least a hundred tree rings in the sample to be dated to ensure a unique match with the master pattern. 
 If the date is to be precise to the year of felling, the bark must also be present, otherwise an estimate must be made of the number of missing rings corresponding to likely wastage by the carpenter. 
 Furthermore, to determine the date of actual usage, allowance must be made for seasoning of the timber. 
 Dendrochronology is most commonly used in the art world to test the authenticity of panel paintings. 
 This is feasible because the panels were prepared from radial sections of the timber rather than tangential ones, since the latter would warp. 
 Many panels have more than enough rings to be datable, and the most popular timber was oak, for which long master chronologies exist. 
 If the date of felling of the tree can be determined and shown to postdate the death of the artist, the painting is clearly a fake. 
 Indeed, if only heartwood is present but the last ring itself post-dates the artist's death, this too condemns the piece. 
 Interestingly, dendrochronology can also demonstrate when the panels are taken from the same tree because of the close similarity of the ring patterns. 
 It can therefore be used to associate paintings, if not to the same artist, at least geographically. 
 Other methods of detecting fakes 
 Anachronistic use of materials 
 Through the ages, the composition of synthetic materials, such as metals, ceramics and glass, has changed as the sources of raw materials have changed and new processes have been discovered. 
 As already described in  Chapter 5, we are beginning to define the range of composition of materials used by many of the principal civilisations of the past, and to discover when and where particular materials, such as brass, were first used. 
 This information is extremely useful in authentication studies. 
 One can compare the composition of the suspect piece with the range of composition of genuine pieces of comparable period. 
 This applies to both the major components which the craftsman deliberately mixed together to form the final product, and also to the trace elements of which he was probably ignorant, but which can indicate the likely source of some of the materials, thus enabling us to distinguish the genuine from the spurious. 
 One must be careful to differentiate between compositions which are unusual and those which are plainly impossible. 
 Thus, if one had a bronze with, say, 2 per cent of tin, where the tin content of the comparable genuine bronzes lay between 5 and 10 per cent, this would be unusual and would count against the piece but it certainly would not condemn it. 
 If, however, the suspect piece turned out to be an aluminium bronze (as was recently the case with some coins purporting to be Anglo-Saxon), then one could reject it straight away because aluminium, and thus aluminium bronze, was not known before the nineteenth century. 
 Sometimes the analysis can be quick and quite definitive. 
 For example, two very similar copper-alloy statuettes both purport to be Etruscan of the sixth century BC (fig. 8.3). 
 Both are technically very fine castings and well finished. 
 But surface analysis by X-ray fluorescence (see glossary) shows that one is a leaded tin bronze, quite appropriate for the period, whereas the other is of brass, the alloy of copper and zinc, which did not become common until the Roman period over five hundred years later. 
 Thus, on these grounds alone, the second figure is most unlikely to be ancient. 
 In all probability it was made as an innocent copy in the nineteenth century. 
 However, one has to beware of jumping too rapidly to conclusions on the basis of a single surface analysis without considering all the possibilities. 
 For instance, when one of the British Museum's most magnificent Etruscan bronze vessels was similarly analysed on the surface and found to contain zinc, there was understandably some consternation. 
 Subsequent analysis of a sample drilled from the interior showed it was of bronze with no zinc present at all. 
 The explanation was that the vessel had been  electrochemically cleaned to remove the worst of the corrosion at some time after its excavation in the nineteenth century. 
 In this treatment the vessel would have been wrapped in a zinc foil, placed in a solution of weak acid and then an electric current applied. 
 During the process the bronze was bathed in a solution of zinc salts and, unless it was carefully washed afterwards, some of these zinc salts could persist in the remaining patina on the surface. 
 This example illustrates well that one has to be aware of the range of possible treatments and restorations to which even perfectly genuine objects could have been subjected. 
 The composition of glass also changed through the ages: most glass from the early civilisations of the Middle East were soda glasses with relatively high sodium contents, and low lime and lead contents compared with modern glass (see Chapter 3). 
 Modem glass also tends to contain a greater range of other metals such as arsenic and zinc. 
 Thus, when a series of Egyptian canopic jars of blue glass purporting to belong to the New Kingdom of the second millennium BC came under suspicion stylistically, they were analysed and found to contain high levels of lead and some arsenic, thereby confirming the doubts of the Egyptologists. 
 Trace elements can also be diagnostic. 
 For example, almost all sources of silver naturally contain a little gold, and ancient silver artefacts typically have gold contents in the range of 0.1 to 1.0 per cent. 
 Not until after the medieval period was it economically viable to recover amounts as small as this, and so the gold content of silver artefacts can be a useful indicator of their antiquity. 
 A number of supposedly late Roman silver ingots, of the type distributed to the army on special occasions such as the accession of an emperor, appeared on the market fairly recently. 
 All were in perfect condition, and the inscriptions seemed rather unusual: analysis failed to detect any gold at all, strongly suggesting the ingots were made from modern refined silver. 
 Sometimes the composition of the solders used to hold together the components of the objects can themselves be indicators of age. 
 Modern gold solders often contain several per cent of cadmium, small amounts of which significantly lower the melting point of the alloy without affecting the colour of the metal too badly. 
 Cadmium is a very volatile metal that has to be prepared by distillation; as this was not achieved until 1818, solders containing cadmium cannot be ancient. 
 A whole series of quite spectacular pieces of supposedly Dark Age jewellery and belt fittings, including the well-known Lombard Treasure, appeared on the art market at the beginning of this century (fig. 8.4). 
 Quite apart from unusual stylistic characteristics, cadmium-containing solders had been used extensively. 
 The British Museum acquired some of these pieces knowingly, as examples of modern fakes, and by examining the pieces in the scanning electron microscope (see glossary) using microanalysis and digital-mapping techniques it has been possible to plot the concentration of the cadmium over the soldered surfaces. 
 It has recently been suggested that some ancient solders did contain cadmium, using the cadmium sulphide mineral greenockite as source of the metal. 
 However, in many years of examination of ancient jewellery, cadmium has never  been found in pieces from excavation, or from otherwise unimpeachable sources, but only in pieces that were suspect on other grounds. 
 So far we have considered man-made materials where the composition reflects the processing, but the composition of materials such as stones and gems, which were used without chemical modification, can also sometimes indicate their source, and thereby the authenticity of artefacts made from them. 
 An example of this is a jackal's head, purportedly ancient Egyptian, and carved from the semi-precious stone lapis lazuli (fig. 8.5). 
 X-ray diffraction (see glossary) revealed the presence of the calcium silicate mineral, wollastonite, in the lapis. 
 We know that all the lapis lazuli used in the ancient Middle East came from a single source in the Badakshan Valley, Afghanistan, but this source does not contain wollastonite. 
 However, lapis from the region of Lake Baikal in Siberia does contain wollastonite, although this source was not worked until the nineteenth century. 
 The lapis in the jackal's head is therefore unlikely to be ancient. 
 The ratio of stable isotopes in marble (see glossary) can also be used to determine provenance, and has been particularly useful in checking the integrity of statuary recomposed from fragments (see p. 109). 
 Anachronistic technology 
 The way in which things are made has changed slowly through the millennia and much more rapidly during the last two centuries. 
 Thus the techniques used to manufacture and decorate an object are indicative of its authenticity. 
 To the trained observer, careful study under a binocular  microscope can reveal how an object was made and decorated, and also reveal any discrepancies or anachronisms in a fake antiquity. 
 For example, since the medieval period, wire has been made by drawing thin metal rods through progressively thinner holes. 
 This leaves long parallel striations running along the wire. 
 In antiquity a variety of methods were used, including strip twisting and block twisting. 
 Both these methods leave very characteristic helical seams which can be seen on examples of wires made by the two methods in Figure 8.6a and b, taken from genuine antiquities. 
 A modern drawn wire from a fake is shown for comparison (fig. 8.6c). 
 The methods used to cut stone and gems can also be indicative of age. 
 For instance, the teeth on the famous supposedly Pre-Columbian crystal skull, said to be from Mexico (fig. 8.7), have been cut with an abrasive wheel. 
 Although this technique has a long ancestry in the Old World it was unknown in the Americas until the Spanish conquest in the sixteenth century. 
 This would seem to suggest that the head cannot belong to the Aztec civilisation. 
 But this remarkable object may not be a completely modern fake. 
 It could have been made by the indigenous people immediately after the conquest, or alternatively features such as the teeth could have been cut much later on the head.  
 Artificial aging 
 Having produced the fake, there is then the problem of making it look old. 
 This is a two-fold process: first the wear that the object could have received during normal usage must be replicated, and then the decay and corrosion of centuries of neglect or burial must be induced. 
 Real wear is the cumulative result of a vast number of very minor rubs and abrasions from a variety of preferred angles concentrated at a number of areas such as extremities or where one component rubs against another, such as on the links of a chain or the catch of a clasp. 
 Wear cannot therefore be simulated by just sand-blasting the whole object, nor even by concentrating on the vulnerable parts with a coarse file. 
 On one fake astrolabe examined recently the faker had clearly got bored and resorted to an angle grinder to wear down the edges, leaving very characteristic scratches; unfortunately most fakers are much more painstaking! 
 Patination 
 After long exposure to the air or burial in the ground most materials corrode. 
 Thus, over a long period of time, stone, glass and metals acquire a distinctive patina which the faker must try and imitate. 
 The patinas on copper alloys were often appreciated in their own right and a study of the patination is central to all authenticity studies. 
 It is essential to have a good appreciation of the possibilities of recent treatments, such as over-restoration or repatination, so a brief history of patination is given here. 
 As far as we know, the ancients intended their metalwork, both artistic and utilitarian, to be kept in a brightly polished metallic state, with the possible exception of special alloys such as Corinthian bronze. 
 We tend now to think of Classical bronze statuary, for example, as being covered with a fine green or deep brown patina, and moreover that this was their original state. 
 But, on the contrary, the evidence suggests that these statues were kept bright. 
 For example, contracts survive to pay for the regular cleaning of the bronzes in Roman temples and where statues are depicted as part of landscapes or street scenes on contemporary wall paintings they are always shown as bronze-coloured, never patinated (plate 8.1). 
 The first people to have appreciated and replicated patinas seem to have been the Chinese. 
 This is perhaps not unexpected, given their reverence for the past and their long tradition of scholarship and collecting stretching back over several millennia. 
 The bronzes that the Chinese so eagerly collected came from burials and were usually covered in a fine green patina. 
 Supply of ancient bronzes exceeded demand and forgeries were very prevalent. 
 Over a thousand years ago bronzes were being produced in the style of the early pieces and given an artificial patina. 
 This was done by applying a mixture of ground-up malachite and other minerals to the bronze (plate 8.2). 
 The result is superficially quite convincing, but would not deceive anyone with experience of genuine patinas. 
 Very probably at least some of these patinated bronzes should be regarded as legitimate copies rather than as fakes, rather as today the British Museum produces and sells resin copies of some of the more famous antiquities.  
 Serious study and collecting of antique metalwork only began in Europe during the Renaissance. 
 The patina the bronzes had acquired during burial was much admired, and people assumed that they had originally been patinated. 
 The belief grew that the original patination had been black, possibly based on some rather oblique remarks in Pliny's Natural History  on treating bronzes with bitumen. 
 Some dealers and collectors were not above altering or even removing the genuine patina and treating the surface to give the appearance they felt it should have had. 
 The collector Richard Payne Knight is a prime example. 
 His superb collection of mainly Classical antiquities passed to the British Museum in the early nineteenth century and includes hundreds of small bronzes. 
 Almost all of these are now covered in a spurious black patina (plate 8.3); indeed one can go through the sculpture galleries of the Greek and Roman Department and pick out the Payne Knight pieces from a distance, before checking against the registration number which invariably begins with 1824. 
 More seriously, the possible repatination of an otherwise quite genuine piece has to be carefully considered in authenticity studies, and demonstrates again the importance of a close acquaintance with antiquities generally, and an especial awareness of the potential vicissitudes that could have befallen them. 
 Throughout the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries there was a steady increase i-n the number and sophistication of methods for chemically patinating copper alloys. 
 These techniques were developed for the perfectly legitimate &bquo;bronzing&equo; and &bquo;antiquing&equo; of patently modern metalwork, but could also be used by the faker with less honest motives. 
 Changes in taste, coupled with a general decline in craft techniques, have meant that the use and range of chemical treatments has declined in this century, although in the Far East the beautiful patinated Shakudo alloys (see p. 95) are still produced by the traditional chemical treatments. 
 Partly inspired by this continuing tradition, there has been a recent revival of interest in Europe and North America emanating from art schools, where the subtle nuances of colour and texture of a chemically patinated surface are more appreciated. 
 The faker has more immediate problems: the false patina must simultaneously look attractive, stay firmly in place, and appear genuine. 
 One method is to grind up a suitable mixture of the correct minerals and stick it to the surface. 
 Alternatively a patina can be induced on the surface of the metal, either by treatment with suitable chemical concoctions or by rapid weathering in an extreme environment. 
 Italian fakers traditionally encouraged the rapid development of a patina by such measures as exposing the bronze on the workshop roof for some months, or by burying the piece in a dunghill. 
 Fortunately these approaches create difficulties for the faker and also leave clues for the scientific investigator. 
 If the patina has been stuck on, then it is often possible to detect the organic binder or glue quite easily, either by application of various solvents, or by exposure to ultra-violet radiation. 
 Many organic binders contain molecules which fluoresce when excited by ultra-violet radiation. 
 This is well exemplified by the ancient  Chinese fang ding  vessel, shown in Figure 8.8a. 
 In Figure 8.8b the makeup used to disguise repairs fluoresces under ultra-violet radiation. 
 Also the junction between the uncorroded metal and the applied patina is very sharp, whereas a patina which has developed over a long period of time will have eaten into the metal in a very irregular and quite characteristic manner that is very difficult to imitate. 
 One problem for the faker trying to develop a patina in situ  is that the chemicals which give the most attractive patinas also give totally the wrong minerals, which can be detected quite easily by X-ray diffraction. 
 In addition, rapidly developed patinas tend to be rather loose and powdery. 
 This section has concentrated so far on metals, reflecting the interest in metal patinas, but other materials also develop distinctive surfaces over time and some work has been done both by fakers to replicate them and investigators to differentiate the fake from the genuine. 
 The early fakers of marble statuary used a variety of treatments to tone down the too obvious freshly carved surfaces, ranging from cold tea to the more sophisticated repeated acid bath treatments used by more recent fakers. 
 However, as with their metal counterparts, the false patinas on stone may look convincing but when viewed under high magnification and analysed are petrologically and chemically quite distinct. 
 Another branch of stone patina faking is to be found in a very different area of collecting. 
 In the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries there was a passion for collecting prehistoric flint implements, and quite  high prices were paid for prize specimens; not perhaps in the same league as the prices paid for Classical sculpture, but quite enough to encourage the fakers. 
 The products of their industry were of course quite fresh and unpatinated, whereas the genuine flint artefacts had a white or brown patination especially if buried in chalky soil. 
 This could be replicated, at least superficially, by boiling in a concentrated caustic soda solution to give a white patination; the addition of a few rusty nails would then turn the patina brown. 
 However the texture of these patinas is not very convincing as they tend to be rather matt and powdery, and are quite easily recognised under the microscope. 
 Glass that has been buried usually develops a distinctive iridescence and onion-skin texture. 
 This is caused by the slow leaching of elements from the unstable early soda glasses, and has so far proved impossible to replicate. 
 This patination is very difficult to induce artificially. 
 At best the faker can try and render the surface somewhat weathered and pitted by treatment with hydrofluoric acid, but the presence of fluorides in the surface can be easily detected. 
 Restoration 
 Deceptive restoration or alteration and embellishment of antiquities is another area of faking. 
 Scientific examination can be used to assess the extent of repairs or new work, and to pick up the joins and fillers used to disguise them. 
 Where an object has been heavily restored, radiography can frequently &bquo;see&equo; through the carefully applied make-up. 
 This is clearly illustrated by the small Islamic jug in Figure 8.9. 
 To the unaided eye, the  jug does appear slightly restored, but the true extent of the restoration is starkly revealed by the X-rays, which pass more easily through the relatively light plaster make-up than through the denser ceramic. 
 Similarly, damage to the ancient Chinese fang ding  and the lead solder used to repair it are clearly visible on the radiograph (fig. 8.8c), in which the X-rays pass easily through the restorer's plaster and false patina. 
 Additions and embellishments can be more difficult to detect, and here of course the cooperation of the art historian is essential. 
 It would be of no great help to pronounce the body of an object genuine if the interest, and hence the value, lay in the inscription. 
 For example, a small Egyptian gold pendant in the form of a shell (now in the Egyptian Department of the British Museum, EA 65281) is very probably ancient, but it bears an engraved cartouche purporting to be of the Twelfth Dynasty in the early second millennium BC. 
 The crudity of the cartouche and various internal anachronisms raised suspicion. 
 On careful examination it became clear that the cartouche had been engraved. 
 In this technique a V-profile chisel, the graver, is pushed over the surface of the metal in order to remove a sliver of metal. 
 To do this the graver must be very hard and strong. 
 The technique of engraving was therefore not really feasible until iron and steel tools came into use at the end of the second millennium BC, yet this piece purports to be many hundreds of years older. 
 Where it is suspected that a piece is made up of unrelated fragments, the composition can sometimes be studied to sort out which fragments are original, or at least which ones belong together. 
 This problem is especially common with Classical marble statuary which in the past was often highly restored before being sold. 
 Stable isotope analysis (see glossary) can be used both to provenance the marble used and to solve some particularly knotty problems caused by over-enthusiastic restoration, where fragmentary pieces were re-assembled, frequently incorporating new pieces of marble, to make the statue appear whole. 
 The British Museum has in its collections a marble panel, recomposed from fragments, belonging to a Roman sarcophagus (GR 1805.7&ndash;13.135). 
 The fragments have a long and complex history since their discovery, dating back to at least the sixteenth century. 
 Some earlier drawings show the panel as considerably less complete than it is now, suggesting that pieces were added in the eighteenth century, as was the common practice with fragmentary works. 
 However stable isotope analysis shows that all the fragments belong to one piece of marble, demonstrating the overall integrity of the piece, and also that the marble is likely to have come from the quarries at Carrara in Tuscany. 
 The limits of scientific expertise 
 The examples used above to demonstrate particular approaches or methods tend to suggest that each problem has a neat and unequivocal solution. 
 Usually the situation is much less clear-cut. 
 Scientific examination adds another dimension of evidence to authenticity studies which, taken together with the art historical evidence, can allow us to make an attribution with much more confidence. 
 There are the rare cases, as with the  bronze and brass Etruscan statuettes described above, where a few moments spent performing a surface analysis can unequivocally solve a problem, which might have remained a stylistic conundrum for ever. 
 But more often scientific examination will add to the store of information without finally solving the basic problem. 
 The following example, although not strictly an authenticity examination, uses the same approaches and shows the application of scientific detection in a related sphere of the British Museum's activities. 
 A number of small bronze figurines have been found in several locations in southern Britain. 
 They bear some resemblance to figurines of the Italic culture of central Italy of the mid-first millennium BC. 
 If they were genuine imports into prehistoric Britain then they would be of some importance in suggesting trade networks. 
 However, none of them has been found in an archaeological context and they have aroused considerable suspicion: they could be relatively modern copies loosely based on Italic originals; they could be genuine prehistoric imports; or they could be perfectly genuine figures brought to Britain relatively recently as curios and since discarded or lost. 
 Scientific examination has shown that they are made of bronze similar to that used in genuine Italic figures from Italy and the patination appears to have developed over a long period, suggesting that they are not modern copies. 
 Useful though this information is, however, it still leaves the central question open of whether the figures came to Britain in antiquity or more recently. 
 This particular problem is likely to remain unsolved until a similar figure is recovered from an excavation site. 
 Usually the art historical and scientific approaches to the same problem reach broadly the same conclusion, even though it may be necessary to rely heavily on one of the approaches to make sense of the other. 
 However, just occasionally, the evidence of the two disciplines is in apparent contradiction. 
 A good example is provided by the famous life-size bronze statue of a youth, found at Magdalensberg (fig. 8.10). 
 It is, or more correctly, was  the most important antiquity to have been found in Austria and has pride of place in the Kunst Historiche Museum in Vienna. 
 The piece has an apparently unassailable history. 
 It was dug up in the sixteenth century and achieved fame almost immediately, entering the imperial collections, and being drawn by artists such as Apianus in 1534. 
 Only in the nineteenth century did excavations reveal a major Roman temple to Mercury at Magdalensberg, and the youth was almost certainly the cult statue. 
 Further, the statue has an inscription on one leg mentioning a specific family and once again only much later was this name encountered on Roman pottery as an important family firm of merchants in that region. 
 Thus the archaeological evidence would seem to establish the authenticity of the statue beyond all reasonable question, but some stylistic doubts were raised and the statue was examined scientifically by an international panel of scientists, including members of the British Museum Research Laboratory. 
 Their findings were equally unequivocal. 
 Thermoluminescence dating of the clay core suggested that the statue was only a few centuries old, and this was supported by technical examination and analysis which showed that the casting technology and the metal used were quite typical of the Renaissance, and equally unlike those used by the Romans. 
 Examination of the metal showed that it had always been in a clean condition with no evidence of corrosion, suggesting that it had never been buried. 
 The apparent conflict of evidence is still not completely resolved, but there is a possible explanation. 
 It is known that shortly after its discovery, a copy, now lost, was made and sent to Spain. 
 Is it possible that the statue which was scientifically examined was actually the copy, and the original &mdash; the only complete Roman bronze statue to have been discovered north of the Alps &mdash; was sent off to Spain, never to be seen again?   
 8.1 The facial image of the Shroud of Turin, viewed in negative (courtesy British Society of the Turin shroud). 
 8.2 Zapotec ceramics tested by TL. 
 From left to right: genuine figure of a deity (ETH 1849.6&ndash;27.20), height 320 mm; fake &bquo;basket&equo; of rodents (ETH 1940 Am 2.43), diameter 355 mm; and fake figure of a deity (ETH 1946 Am.16&ndash;7), height 400 mm. 
 8.3 below left  Two Etruscan banqueteers; the statuette at the back is bronze (GR 1813.12&ndash;1.1) but the other is brass (GR 1918.1&ndash;1.113). 
 Length 330 mm. 
 8.4 left  Fake &bquo;Lombardic&equo; brooch (MLA 1930.11&ndash;6.1), one of a number of pieces made at the beginning of the century. 
 The brooch purports to belong to the Dark Ages, but uses a modern cadmium gold solder to hold together the components. 
 Diameter 57 mm. 
 8.6 Three methods of making wire: (a) above  and (b) right  are ancient, (c) far right  is modern. 
 In (a) a thin strip of metal is tightly twisted to produce a hollow tube rather like a very thin drinking straw. 
 In (b) a thin rod of square section is twisted and then rolled. 
 In (c) a thin rod is passed progressively narrower draw plates. 
 The very characteristic marks left on the mire show how it was made and this can indicate the likely age of a piece. 
 8.5 left  Fake Egyptian jackal's head of lapis lazuli (EA 64075). 
 All ancient lapis came from a single source in Badakshan in Afghanistan. 
 However, the composition of this piece shows it came from Lake Baikal in Siberia, a source not exploited until the nineteenth century. 
 length 98 mm. 
 8.7 Crystal skull (ETH 1898&ndash;1), said to be from Mexico. 
 The striking head is difficult to parallel stylistically, and the teeth seem to have been cut with an abrasive wheel which would not have been available in the Americas before the Spanish conquest. 
 Height 210 mm. 
 8.8 Three images of a Chinese fang ding vessel (OA 1973.7&ndash;26.4) probably made in the eleventh century BC. 
 It was subsequently badly damaged but the clumsy repair is skilfully disguised by deceptive restoration. 
 height 222 mm. 
 (a) left  By ordinary light the fang ding appears intact. 
 (b) above  Under ultraviolet radiation the make-up disguising the repairs fluoresces. 
 (c) left  X-rays pierce right through the object, revealing the massive breaks. 
 The very white areas in the cracks are lead solder. 
 8.9 Restoration revealed by radiography. 
 This small Islamic jug (OA 1952.2-14.1) of the ninth century AD appears intact below  when viewed by ordinary light, but X-rays show that it is extensively repaired right , especially around the rim. 
 height 116 mm. 
 8.10 Life-size bronze figure of a youth. 
 This statue, now in Kunst Historishche Museum in Vienna, was until recently believed to be the Roman statue found at Magdalensberg in the sixteenth century and as such the only complete Roman statue ever found north of the Alps. 
 However, recent scientific examination by an international team of scientists suggests that his is an early copy of the original now lost. 
 Height 1.7 m. 
 Computing and mathematics: Putting two and two together Peter Main 
 Centuries ago, mathematics was dubbed &bquo;handmaiden of the Sciences&equo;, and with good reason. 
 The earliest discoveries in mathematics were made by the great physicists and astronomers in the course of their work, and in those days great scientists had to be great mathematicians. 
 The power and wide-ranging applications of mathematics quickly gave it recognition as a discipline in its own right, whose theorems have now been brought to bear on problems in every field of knowledge. 
 Computers, and the programs that control them, rely no less on the past creativity of mathematicians. 
 The youngster of today who comes to grips for the first time with a personal computer little imagines the wealth of mathematical inventiveness invested in the design of the software and in the electronic circuitry itself. 
 Statistics, a multi-faceted sub-discipline of mathematics, has its own long and proud history, boasting such famous exponents as Isaac Newton, Edmund Halley and Florence Nightingale. 
 Statistics grapples with the quantification of such nebulous concepts as probability, certainty and error. 
 Computer science, though one of the younger disciplines, relies like so many others on mathematics, and this happy relationship works both ways. 
 Increasingly, the practical application of many mathematical techniques depends on the computer's ability to carry out calculations with faultless accuracy at ever more extraordinary speeds. 
 Applied mathematics and computer science are distinct disciplines, but they are now locked for ever in an inseparable embrace. 
 Together, they underpin rather than oversee the disciplines they serve, and reliance upon them can be so complete that procedures simply cannot be carried out without their aid. 
 For example, neutron activation analysis (see glossary), one of the techniques used to determine the composition of ancient ceramics, would be impossible without a computer program, since the calculations required are so complex and extensive that not even the most resilient individual armed with a pocket calculator could possibly complete them in a single lifetime. 
 A less obvious aspect of the power of mathematics and computer science derives from the abstract, or generalised, nature of the procedures they employ; in solving one problem one is often, perhaps unwittingly, solving another apparently unrelated problem. 
 We will see some instances of this fascinating phenomenon in the following sections, as we take a brief look at applications of mathematics and computing to the study of museum collections and the wider spheres of archaeology and prehistory.  
 In the service of the museums 
 Counting loose change 
 It is standard practice in museums to &bquo;register&equo; objects as they are acquired, and the register is the primary record of a museum's holdings. 
 A small collection can be monitored regularly by carrying out a check of all objects against the register, but in the case of a very large collection this may well be impracticable. 
 The British Museum has (or is believed to have) some 5 or 6 million objects, so that a conventional stock-take of the entire collection could occupy all the qualified staff for five or six years and could be exhaustive only if all other duties were suspended for the duration. 
 However, a branch of statistics called &bquo;sampling theory&equo; can be applied, which will allow conclusions about the entire collection to be inferred (to within a known degree of certainty) by checking on a small percentage of it. 
 Statistical sampling is widely used in scientific experiments and market surveys. 
 It also has applications in field archaeology where financial or time constraints preclude excavation of more than part of a site, and where it is therefore important that the excavated part yields as much information as possible. 
 Sampling theory has been of value in various areas of museum work, from assessing the long-term resources required for conservation treatment of the British Museum's large collection of Babylonian clay tablets, to ensuring that a given &bquo;kill rate&equo; in insecticides used for paper conservation will provide effective treatment. 
 A sampling programme carried out in the Coins and Medals Department in 1979 checked some 10,000 of the estimated 600,000 objects in the collections. 
 The results indicated that, with a high degree of probability, more than 99.8 per cent of the total collection could be accounted for. 
 Of course, this can only be verified by a complete inventory, but the important point is that the sampling methods used, and the way in which the results were extrapolated to apply to the whole collection, are based on a sound mathematical theory which is widely used and tested in other fields, and therefore carried sufficient weight to satisfy the Museum and its auditors. 
 Good housekeeping 
 A long-term solution to the management of huge collections of material is to enter details of all objects and their whereabouts into a computer database and to keep the information up to date thereafter. 
 Such a project began in the British Museum in 1978, using a computer originally purchased for scientific work, but now transferred to a &bquo;super-minicomputer&equo; which runs powerful database software. 
 The main objectives of the documentation project are threefold. 
 Firstly, and most importantly, it will eventually form a complete inventory of the collections. 
 Secondly, it will enable us to locate each object more quickly and easily. 
 Finally, much extra information is being recorded, such as provenance, cultural associations and so on, which will allow the database to be used as a powerful research tool. 
 To record such information for over five million objects is  clearly an immense undertaking which will continue well into the future, and entails considerable staff costs, powerful computer hardware and highly sophisticated software (see Chapter 1 0). 
 It is the software that is of most interest here since that is where the &bquo;intelligence&equo; of the facility resides. 
 To give but one example, it allows us to search a database of tens of thousands of objects looking for &bquo;wooden bowls from Ghana which are greater than 12cm wide&equo;, and to get an answer within seconds of posing the question. 
 It will even take account of the fact that some relevant objects may not be described as &bquo;wooden&equo; at all, but as being made of &bquo;beech&equo;, &bquo;mahogany&equo;, &bquo;deal&equo; or the like. 
 All the information about an object is stored on the computer within what is called a hierarchical database, meaning simply that the information is broken down from broad categories such as &bquo;geography&equo; into more specific ones such as &bquo;continent&equo;, &bquo;country&equo;, &bquo;region&equo; and so on. 
 One can visualise this as a tree-like structure with broad categories branching out into narrower ones. 
 Such structures are indeed referred to in computer science jargon as trees, and the technical literature abounds with pleasing arboreal metaphors such as roots, branches and leaves. 
 To retrieve our wooden bowls, two other tree-like structures are necessary: an index to the database allowing us to find all wooden objects quickly without checking every one, and a thesaurus which remembers that &bquo;beech&equo;, &bquo;mahogany&equo; and so on are all forms of wood. 
 These three types of tree, although slightly different in form, have abstract mathematical properties in common which are embodied in the theorems of a rather obscure branch of mathematics called graph theory. 
 By progressing from the sampling of collections to storing details of every object in a computer database, we have therefore simply transferred our allegiance from sampling theory to graph theory. 
 From words to pictures 
 Words are not the only type of information we may wish to include in a computerised record of museum collections. 
 What about pictures? 
 Modern technology allows us to use lasers to record images from photographs or video cameras on to videodiscs, and to access each picture or frame instantly by quoting its frame number. 
 Although this may well be a valuable facility, it really forms no more than an appendage to the database, since we cannot search a videodisc image for details within it in the way we can search text. 
 If we know the frame number corresponding to an object's picture, we can display the picture, and that is that. 
 The possibilities become more interesting when we begin to ask questions such as &bquo;What objects in this database are similar in shape to this one?&equo;. 
 In fact this is a commonly asked question, since shape is of great significance in the study of certain classes of ancient artefacts. 
 It plays an important role in defining typologies which can be then be used to help date or provenance new examples. 
 It should be emphasised that the shape discrimination required is usually much more subtle than could ever be achieved by verbal shape descriptions, and that the heavier tools of mathematics need to be applied. 
 We are in fact attempting to persuade a high-powered  calculating machine to imitate the process of human shape perception. 
 While the human eye is extraordinarily good at doing this, the process by which it does so is not well understood and hence can be only imperfectly imitated. 
 If the human eye can do better, why even try? 
 In practical situations, the problem is one of quantity of information. 
 Although it is quite reasonable to ask a human being to search by eye through a moderate number of drawings of artefacts it is not reasonable where thousands are involved. 
 From this point of view, the capacity of an electronic computer for tireless number-crunching should have something to offer. 
 By attempting to imitate a human cognitive process, however, we are straying into the notoriously difficult sub-discipline of computer science known as artificial intelligence, and anyone working in this field would agree that many of its problems have yet to be solved. 
 It is nevertheless of interest to look at one approach to such problems, since this area of research demonstrates, perhaps as well as any, how a close liaison between mathematics and computer science can be of service to the museum archaeologist. 
 As an example of a class of artefact whose outline shapes are of particular interest to the expert, let us turn to bronze axes dating from the Early Bronze Age of southern Britain (fig. 9.1). 
 The outline of such an axe can be measured very precisely and processed by various techniques of  coordinate geometry (including, incidentally, one originally invented by marine engineers to measure the shape of ship hulls) to give a final mathematical &bquo;fingerprint&equo; of the axe's shape. 
 These fingerprints are in such a form that they can be easily compared one with another; that is to say the computer can calculate a measure of &bquo;shape difference&equo; between any two axes. 
 This shape difference measure is the fundamental building block by which we can create large databases of outline shapes that can be searched efficiently. 
 Trees return once more to help us in this endeavour. 
 Figure 9.2 shows what a very small part of a large database of axe shapes might look like. 
 The whole should be imagined as a huge and intricate multi-branched tree which has been designed so that axes similar in shape (as determined by the shape difference measure) lie in branches near each other. 
 Suppose now that we wish to search the database for axes similar in shape to some given axe. 
 Since the relevant ones will be concentrated in one area of the inverted tree they can be quickly located by moving from the root downwards and along the correct branches, without ever having to search the whole database. 
 Shuffling things about 
 Imagine now a slightly different problem. 
 Suppose we are given some outline drawings of axes. 
 Can we use a shape difference measure to classify the axes into groups of similar types on the basis of their shapes? 
 In other words, can a computer imitate the process the archaeological expert carries out by eye when he constructs his standard typologies? 
 There is more than one way to tackle this problem, but a very widely used and mathematically elegant technique called multi-dimensional scaling can help us. 
 It was invented in the 1950s by psychologists, and solves a more general problem than the one we have posed. 
 Given any group of objects, and the ability to measure difference (or dissimilarity) between any pair of the objects, how can we position the objects in two dimensions in such a way that their physical separation reflects the measure of dissimilarity between them? 
 In other words, we want dissimilar objects to be far apart and similar ones to be close together. 
 If we can achieve this, we have gone a long way towards solving the axe typology problem since groups of similarly shaped  axes would appear as distinct clusters on the page and could be easily identified by eye. 
 Two points about multi-dimensional scaling should be stressed. 
 Firstly, it is perhaps surprising that the procedure is very difficult to do by hand, even for a small number of objects, and is quite impossible for a large number. 
 To appreciate this, imagine that you ask a friend to mark thirty numbered points randomly on graph paper (unseen by you) and that you are required to discover their positions, with no information other than the distances between any pairs you request. 
 The problem can be solved, but quite complex mathematics and a computer are required to solve it. 
 Secondly, the technique can be used for any type of dissimilarity; shape difference is just one example. 
 This means that multi-dimensional scaling has applications in many areas of work, as we can see from the following examples. 
 When petrological thin-sectioning (see glossary) is carried out, many separate items of data may be collected from each artefact studied, making it difficult to see those groupings of artefacts that have features in common. 
 Multi-dimensional scaling can help to clear the murky waters. 
 The process of examining thin sections is a painstaking and laborious one, since each slide has to be viewed individually under a microscope and various aspects of appearance judged and recorded. 
 The scientist has to remember a great deal of information before he can even begin to look for patterns in the data. 
 The burden can be eased by introducing the following procedure. 
 For each thin section, the scientist makes a decision on what he regards as its significant features (such as size or shape of particular mineral inclusions) and then scores each feature, for each thin section, on a simple scale from one to five, without giving any thought at this stage to similarities and differences. 
 These scores are then combined to give overall measures of dissimilarity between each possible pairing of artefacts &mdash; exactly the form of information required for multi-dimensional scaling. 
 The computer then does the hard mathematics and produces a diagram showing broad groupings of similar material (fig. 9.3).  
 An imaginative application of multi-dimensional scaling by the statistician David Kendall serves to illustrate how widely the technique can be applied. 
 It is known that many medieval villages in England became deserted through decline and shift of population, and the ravages of disease. 
 It is perhaps less well known that a number of them became &bquo;lost&equo; as building stone was re-used and land ploughed over. 
 The lost villages are known to have existed mainly through references in medieval parish records of births, marriages and deaths, but their location is unknown beyond the parish in which they lay. 
 It was common practice for marriage registers to record the places of abode of the newly-weds, and what Kendall did was to use this information to construct a crude measure of dissimilarity between villages based on frequency of intermarriage over a long period. 
 The underlying assumption was that the likelihood of marriage between people from different villages drops off with increase in geographical distance between the villages. 
 The multi-dimensional scaling configuration resulting from processing the &bquo;degree of intermarriage&equo; values might therefore be expected to reflect geographical location of the villages. 
 Kendall was able to check his results to an extent, since much of his data related to villages whose location was known, and this gave him some confidence in suggesting the locations of the lost villages. 
 Kendall never claimed, of course, that this method could ever be accurate enough to pinpoint where the archaeologist should sink his spade, but rather that it could help in choosing between a number of possible locations to which the search had been restricted on other grounds. 
 Weights and measures 
 Let us now turn to another example of how mathematics, through the breadth of its applications, allows us to attack more than one problem  with a single weapon. 
 Quantum analysis is a branch of statistics designed to test a very specific hypothesis, namely that a set of measurements is &bquo;quantised&equo;, and thus occurs in multiples of some basic measurement unit. 
 The method concerns itself both with what the underlying unit actually is, and also with how likely it is that we are observing a real effect rather than some random one. 
 In the early 1960s, Alexander Thom, a retired Scottish professor of engineering, sparked off a great deal of interest and controversy in the archaeological community through his claims for the existence of a &bquo;megalithic yard&equo;, an ancient unit of measurement used by the builders of megalithic monuments. 
 Such claims in fact go back as far as 1926, but it was with Thom's careful measurement of many stone circles and alignments in Britain and Brittany that a scientific analysis of the problem could be attempted. 
 Thom's theoretical analysis was based on the work of S.R. Broadbent, a statistician whose quantum hypothesis allows the extent to which data are quantised to be assessed objectively. 
 There is still some disagreement among experts about whether the methods Thom used were appropriate. 
 The arguments surrounding the issue, important in assessing Thom's work, were also vital to an investigation of gold-weights made by the Ashanti people of Ghana. 
 These objects are actually made of brass, but are believed to have been used for the weighing of gold dust (fig. 9.4). 
 Like the dimensions of stone circles, the weights of these objects seemed to peak in definite weight bands, suggesting that they were made to preset weight specifications. 
 This observation was the starting point for a study of a large sample of gold-weights from three museums. 
 This study showed up some fascinating differences: the figurative pieces &mdash; small models of porcupines, antelopes and so on &mdash; showed no convincing evidence for quantisation, but the geometric pieces did, as can be seen in the frequency charts of the weights (fig.9.5). 
 The geometric pieces were clearly made as utilitarian  objects, and in fact were designed to weigh in multiples of 1.46 g. 
 Another conclusion that emerged from this study was that around one thousand objects would need to be sampled to be able to detect the sort of peaks which were actually present. 
 In the gold-weight study there was no problem: by gathering data from the British Museum, the Museum f&uuml;r V&ouml;lkerkunde in Berlin, and the Pitt Rivers Museum in Oxford, over 2,500 objects were studied. 
 This leads us to one of the main problems in this sort of computer-based study. 
 The computer allows us to make almost unlimited calculations, and indeed the larger the sample the better for statistical applications. 
 But the labour involved in studying the objects and producing the data, be it weighing, chemical analysis or whatever, means that the scope of investigations has to be limited in some way. 
 So the need to record sufficient data to enable definite conclusions to be reached has to be balanced against the requirement to make the best use of staff time and resources. 
 This is an area where the concepts of sampling theory, mentioned at the start of this chapter, can again prove useful: sampling schemes can balance these two objectives by determining the minimum labour that must be invested to be satisfied that the correct conclusions have been reached. 
 In the service of archaeology 
 Rank and position 
 Let us now move away from the store-rooms of museums to the wider world of archaeology in the field. 
 What do computers and mathematics have to offer us here? 
 Our first example comes from a cemetery complex in Humberside dating from the Iron Age. 
 Computer studies of cemeteries abound, and range from surveys of a number of cemeteries and their geographical distribution to very detailed studies of an individual one. 
 Our site is actually two separate but contiguous cemeteries at the neighbouring villages of Rudston and Burton Fleming (fig. 9.6). 
 These graves and their contents had been studied long before computers became commonplace, and gave indications of two different burial rites: one involving burial with pig bones and metal goods but no pottery, and the other involving sheep bones and pottery. 
 Surprisingly, the &bquo;pig&equo; graves tended to lie with the long axis pointing north-south and the &bquo;sheep&equo; graves east-west. 
 When features are as obvious as this, one hardly needs a computer to detect them. 
 In this project, however, we wished to go further and to investigate whether the pig graves differed from the sheep graves in terms of the age, sex or apparent wealth of the incumbents. 
 The number of cross-tabulations involved is very large, and significant trends are easily lost. 
 If all the data are initially entered into a computer database, the power of a database management system makes it easy to present different views of the data to the researcher, allowing more subtle and complex associations to emerge. 
 At a more sophisticated level, computerised methods of a technique known as discriminant analysis can be invoked. 
 This is particularly useful where the bodies have to be grouped into categories such as male/female,  child/adult, or even into groups with different racial or familial origins. 
 Sometimes it is obvious to which group an individual should be assigned, but where it is not. 
 information such as basic measurements of bone dimensions can be added to the computer's database and discriminant analysis can then predict the group that is most probably correct. 
 This procedure is akin to the methods now being used for computerised medical diagnosis, where the symptoms are fed in to the computer and the most likely illness is predicted. 
 Indeed we hope it may be possible to predict some of the medical problems our Iron Age ancestors were subject to, using just these methods. 
 We can see, then, how computers help to develop and extend information, as well as merely acting as the storage medium. 
 The investigation has now entered a new phase where demographic characteristics of the Iron Age population are being modelled (albeit crudely, since the information available from the Iron Age is very sparse). 
 Perhaps surprisingly, the methods of modern-day actuarial statistics, where &bquo;lifetables&equo; are constructed on behalf of insurance companies to help them estimate the probable lifespans of various classes of individual, have come to our aid in this project. 
 Getting below the surface 
 The application of computer technology in the excavation process itself has been a major area of growth over the last decade. 
 Personal computers  are now commonly found in site huts, even in remote locations where they can be powered by car batteries. 
 Modern scientific excavation techniques yield prodigious quantities of data, and the abilities of even quite simple personal computer database programs to organise, tabulate and sort this information offer the archaeologist very obvious benefits. 
 Such computer software is rapidly becoming the archaeologist's workhorse, both during the excavation process in circumstances where immediate feedback is desirable, and afterwards to help in preparing the final published report. 
 Invaluable as this sort of computing may be, the archaeologist's spade reveals more interesting and mathematically challenging problems. 
 Much archaeology involves looking for underlying patterns within a jumble of visual detail. 
 In extreme cases the search for order among the chaos can become too difficult for the human eye alone. 
 At sites such as Petters Sports Field in Surrey, archaeologists have uncovered large numbers of post-holes (remains in the soil showing where wooden posts once supported structures). 
 Such configurations (fig.9.7) can be difficult to interpret for two reasons. 
 Firstly, the marks one sees in the ground at any particular level may in fact result from many successive building phases, since the holes will commonly have been dug through earlier material and to varying depths. 
 Secondly, an individual post-hole  cannot easily be assigned to any particular building phase, since any datable artefact found within it could either pre-date or post-date the structure for which the hole was dug. 
 Nevertheless, provided that it is possible to make informed assumptions about the likely shapes and sizes of buildings at particular periods, a computer can be programmed to search for particular configurations of post-holes that might result from such a structure and &bquo;peel them off&equo;, to reveal a simplified picture of earlier building phases. 
 The mathematical techniques for doing this were invented fairly recently, and, unlike most of those we have so far mentioned, were developed from scratch to solve a particular archaeological problem. 
 At sites where a number of periods of occupation overlie one another, the archaeologist has to identify and record very large numbers of what are referred to as contexts &mdash; divisions of the excavated material that can be distinguished in some way from their neighbours. 
 At Runnymede Bridge, the computer has been brought in to record and check relationships between contexts and to sort them into continuous sequences, thus ultimately helping the archaeologist interpret the sequences as a record of past human activity. 
 Accurate surveying of contexts in three dimensions is clearly a major part of the excavation process. 
 Modern surveying equipment such as Electronic Distance Measurement devices greatly facilitate this, not least because of their ability to store survey readings on data loggers, small electronic devices that record a large number of readings in a form that can later be easily transferred to a personal computer (fig. 9.8). 
 Clearly there are few barriers to filling the site's personal computer with survey data, but what can be done with it? 
 The excavation process is destructive. 
 After a site has been filled in again only artefacts, notebooks and the photographic record remain to aid the archaeologist in the long post-excavation period when he or she has to decide what it all meant, and publish details of what was found. 
 How valuable it would be to be  able to reconstruct what the site looked like while excavation was in progress. 
 Provided that enough information was recorded at the time, we can indeed use the techniques of three-dimensional computer graphics to achieve this. 
 A particular excavated level (corresponding, for example, to a bronze Age occupation floor) can be &bquo;modelled&equo; on a computer screen and the power of coordinate geometry embodied in a sophisticated computer program allows us to view it from any angle and at any elevation. 
 Distributions of artefacts of particular types can be superimposed exactly where they were found, to help in the search for significant patterns. 
 Furthermore, a digital graph plotter can reproduce the whole visual image on paper, with pinpoint accuracy, in a minute or two. 
 Figure 9.9 shows a computer reconstruction of an ancient land surface. 
 What does the future hold 
 This brief survey has provided at least a taste of current applications of mathematics and computers in the service of museums and archaeology. 
 What does the future hold? 
 Museums and archaeology both suffer from chronic under-funding, and at present there seems to be no cause for optimism that this situation will change. 
 Constrained resources will inevitably act as a brake on research and new developments, but there are other factors which work against this, and give us reason to be encouraged. 
 Field archaeology attracts a great deal of interdisciplinary interest since it offers so many varied and interesting problems. 
 There is greater incentive in archaeology than in many other disciplines for applied mathematicians and statisticians to develop new techniques, or to apply existing ones in novel situations. 
 Since 1973, an annual conference devoted to the applications of computing and mathematics to archaeology has been held at varying locations in Britain. 
 It provides a forum for the sharing of ideas among archaeologists, computer specialists and mathematicians. 
 During the conferences floppy disks containing home-grown software are exchanged like coinage, and between conferences software and messages continue to be exchanged by electronic mail. 
 The attendance has increased steadily over the years and the conference attracts more and more international participants. 
 The will and skill to move forward are therefore not in short supply. 
 Another major factor offsets the impoverished state of museums and archaeology and in the long term this will have a far more profound effect. 
 Quite simply, computers are becoming cheaper and more powerful all the time. 
 Archaeology and museums have not, of course, contributed to the massive commercial pressures underlying this trend, but to a large extent they can sit back and reap the benefits. 
 Nowhere is the pace of development more apparent than in computer graphics. 
 Software and hardware that allow us to display reconstructions of scenes in three dimensions are, as we have seen, already available, but are steadily increasing in sophistication and falling in price. 
 True integration of text and graphical information within databases is an area of major development effort among  computer manufacturers, and offers great potential benefits for the curation of museum collections. 
 Desk-top publishing already promises exciting possibilities for reducing the cost of publishing excavation reports. 
 Archaeological units are also being tempted by the impressive capabilities of geographic information systems, which in essence allow maps to be stored, displayed, overlaid and updated on a computer screen. 
 Laser light can now give us more than just music in our ears. 
 Compact discs can store data too, and act as a superb archiving medium for large databases, while videodiscs give instant access to thousands of high-quality photographic images on one 14-inch disc. 
 Further in the future, laser light looks set to replace electricity itself, driving computers a hundred times faster than the fastest now available. 
 Developments in the world of computing move close to the speed of light. 
 The challenge for museum curators and archaeologists in the 1990s is to keep abreast of them, and to exploit them to the full.   
 9.1 An artist's impression of an Early Bronze Age bronze axe from Devon. 
 Measurements taken from such a drawing allow a computer to compare axe shapes, and so also draw smooth and accurate reconstructions. 
 (The axe outlines in fig. 9.2 were drawn by computer in this way.) 
 9.2 left  A schematic impression of part of a computer database of axe shapes, structured as an inverted &bquo;tree&equo;. 
 The database is searched by following the &bquo;branches&equo; of the tree downwards. 
 9.3 right  A multi-dimensional scaling configuration of thin sections from Roman tiles, showing six groups of similar tiles. 
 Each spot represents one thin section, and a typical thin section from each group is shown alongside. 
 9.4 Brass gold-weights made by the Ashanti people of Ghana: (a) far right  shows a &bquo;figurative&equo; type (length 106 mm), and (b) above  shows a selection of six &bquo;geometric&equo; types. 
 9.5 Distribution chart of the weights of 1208 geometric-types Ashanti gold-weights from the collections of the British Museum. 
 The arrowed peaks show clearly how weights tend to concentrate around multiples of a basic weight unit. 
 No evidence was found of similar quantisation with figurative gold-weights. 
 9.6 A group of north-south oriented graves within barrows excavated by the British Museum at the village of Burton Fleming in Humberside (courtesy Tony Pacitto). 
 9.7 Distribution of post-holes: (a) found during excavations at Petters Sports Field in Surrey; (b) and (c) show an archaeologist's interpretation of the structures that gave rise to medium depth and deep post-holes, respectively. 
 9.8 Electronic Distance Measurement device in use at the British Museum's excavation at Torbryan Caves in Devon. 
 As the operator takes readings they are recorded automatically on the attached &bquo;datalogger&equo;, to be transferred later to a personal computer (courtesy Cath Price). 
 9.9 A computer with graphics software installed can process the data from a surveying instrument and reconstruct a three-dimensional impression of the land surface. 
 Computing the Collections: The art of successful flea handling Lea Jones 
 The British Museum's collections contain a pair of dressed fleas from Mexico. 
 Sceptics may baulk at such an idea, but given the attested presence of such equally implausible-sounding objects as a block of portable eighteenth-century soup (ex Captain Cook), Inuit seal-gut underwear, African cobweb hats and other equally exotic objects, the concept of dressed fleas may seem more acceptable. 
 This chapter addresses the problem of handling these fleas, not as extraordinary ideas, nor even as physical entities, but as units of information. 
 Each object in a museum comprises a potential body of information, of both administrative and academic significance. 
 These units may be every bit as difficult to define and handle, conceptually at least, as the fleas themselves. 
 The role of documentation and the devices for handling information in a museum context often remain hidden to visitors, who are nonetheless  bombarded with information from the moment they enter any large museum or art gallery &mdash; in the form of signs indicating the way to the cafeteria, ground-plans of the premises, or, more obviously, labels and information panels associated with the gallery displays. 
 Few people, however, are aware of how object-related information is generated, gathered, structured and subsequently applied. 
 The processes that generate information about an object within a museum are many and varied, raising problems of both theory and practice, particularly when a major institution considers computerising this information. 
 The art of information handling is complex. 
 There are no absolutely right or wrong ways to apply it, only good or bad practices. 
 The diversity of museum collections in general requires that these practices be sufficiently flexible to accommodate the unusual object or set of circumstances, and yet sufficiently disciplined to ensure that realistic standards can be established and maintained. 
 Within every institution (and indeed, individual) may be found the polarised views of the pedant and the pragmatist. 
 The former will cling rigidly to formulae regardless of the situation, nit-picking over tiny detail but sometimes unwittingly missing the larger issues. 
 The pragmatist is more flexible, recognising that exceptions do arise and must be practically catered for. 
 Both attitudes have a valuable role to play when considering an issue such as how to computerise a major corpus of information which exists in a variety of document types of varying degrees of complexity and intelligibility. 
 The British Museum has a sound history in the field of documentation, even if our predecessors were on occasions less rigorous in their practices than are current staff. 
 In 1756 the Museum was compiling records of its acquisitions in bound ledgers called &bquo;The Book of Presents&equo; and in 1836 the then single Department of Antiquities began to complete bound Acquisition Registers of a type still in use today (fig. 10.1). 
 There are now ten curatorial departments, and a project of ten years standing, systematically computerising data about the collections, offers the means of sophisticated information retrieval. 
 There is now a general awareness of the desirability of providing accurate and well-maintained inventories of the holdings of all major publicly funded institutions in order to guard against the loss of objects. 
 However, it has also been recognised that it is impractical to impose a universal method of inventory control across all  museums and art galleries. 
 The diversity of collections even within a single museum demands instead a flexible series of management devices. 
 These typically comprise the registration of objects, location of the items, stock-taking and auditing processes, as well as the longer-term creation of catalogues and other adjuncts to research. 
 General collections management processes (i.e. the formal documentation of an object on acquisition &mdash; or &bquo;accessioning&equo;, monitoring object condition, recording of object movement, loan processing, storage environment, etc.) are, however, becoming more generally standardised as a result of the work and influence of bodies such as the Museum Documentation Association. 
 All these processes generate and use  documentation. 
 The mere presence of an object on museum premises entails some form of associated documentation. 
 Not surprisingly, many museums experience difficulty keeping pace with such large-scale demands for recording and, latterly and increasingly, retrieval of this information. 
 However, with recent advances in information technology it has been shown that automation of all or some of these processes will provide an effective way forward. 
 A major problem facing established museums is the natural variation in recording practices that have developed with time. 
 It may be, for example, that the attribution of inventory numbers follows not one but many forms, each with its own idiosyncratic syntax. 
 Objects may move between departments, as new departments are formed either by evolving from existing ones or merging with others (fig. 10.2). 
 When this happens, items may not be re-registered but will retain their original identity. 
 The original documentation similarly remains with the original department that created it. 
 There are practical reasons for this arrangement: any  manual system of record-keeping relies either on heavy duplication of information, sited wherever that information may be routinely required, or on a complex system of cross-referenced card-indexes which provide guides to relevant documentation. 
 In either case, the time, expertise and sustained communication required to make this system work place heavy demands on staff who normally have other priorities. 
 Automation of an information system provides an effective solution to these problems if only by centralising the information concerned. 
 Centralised records provide the means by which many people may have access to the same body of information, regardless of their physical situation. 
 It may also be argued that, provided a computer record is sympathetically laid out, it is more readable than many handwritten entries found in registers, where handwriting, variations in content and idiosyncrasies of style may conspire to confuse the reader. 
 As a preliminary to automation, a major process of review is necessary in order to establish the nature, content and application of the information categories and of the documents containing them. 
 Without such a review there is a serious danger that existing documentation problems may simply be automated along with the data, thus perpetuating rather than resolving them. 
 Equally, this important preliminary is vital to the success of choosing a suitable computer system. 
 Along with the review of existing data, a clearly defined set of objectives needs to be defined. 
 At the most basic level, major museums must satisfy a requirement to produce inventories, regardless of any additional or subsequent developments. 
 &bquo;Great fleas have little fleas&hellip;&equo;: 
 What is an inventory? 
 An inventory should contain sufficient information to enable the unequivocal identification of an object. 
 The object name, its identification number, and its location are the very minimum categories of information that may usefully be called an inventory. 
 The creation of an inventory and an audit trail addresses various problems, both of theory and practice. 
 To be genuinely useful, it is essential to include some reference to the number of elements involved in any one &bquo;object&equo; described as a single item. 
 Without a clear understanding of &bquo;how many&equo; as well as &bquo;what&equo; and &bquo;where&equo;, there cannot be a confident system of collections management. 
 This prompts a further question: how should this indication be expressed? 
 How, for example, should one handle the dressed fleas and their garments in terms of a computer record? 
 The pedant might create a separate physical record for each item: the fleas, plus the individual garments. 
 Theoretically (it would be argued) these items may become detached from the flea and be lost in the collections. 
 Should they be found, it would be necessary to have a physically separate record to enable specific identification of this object to be made. 
 The pragmatist might acknowledge this point but would offer the further thought that, under normal circumstances, it is unlikely that a flea's stray garment could be mistaken for anything else, and that the flea. its garments and any other intimately associated paraphernalia would be more sensibly and  helpfully handled as a single record. 
 A text description of the item(s) covered by the record should allow the information to be both recorded and retrieved without having to split it between several records. 
 In this way all the fleas and their items of clothing may be recalled successfully. 
 Furthermore, they would be viewed as a single entity from a collections point of view. 
 But (the pedant may pursue the point), what if the flea and its garments were housed in separate locations? 
 Then say so in the record, the pragmatist would counter. 
 In this way the flea gets to keep its clothes on &mdash; at least in the records, if not the collections. 
 It is indeed possible for a theoretically single item to have more than one location simultaneously, typically the case with temporary locations and compound objects. 
 A bowl may require conservation, or need to be photographed, but its associated pedestal may not. 
 Thus the bowl will change its location, whilst that for the pedestal remains the same (i.e. the permanent location for both the bowl and pedestal). 
 However, the true condition and nature of an object can only really be judged by physically checking it. 
 This, too, is a major element in an inventory. 
 &bquo;&hellip; upon their backs to bite 'em&equo;: Hazards of locating the collections 
 The collectors of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries evidently had few qualms about braving remote and inhospitable peoples and places, and their donations to the Museum collections occasionally reflect the intimidations and perils they faced in acquiring them &mdash; precisely what Museum staff experience when confronted with some of these legacies. 
 Darts that are literally &bquo;dressed to kill&equo;, with curare and other nerve poisons, can be particularly difficult to handle, psychologically as well as physically. 
 Gloves do not provide total protection against accidental nicks. 
 The darts, the lumps of poison and the raw materials from which it is extracted all provide a challenge for others with a taste (figuratively speaking) for excitement. 
 (It should be made clear that, in the vast majority of cases, the poison is so aged that its potency is thought to be negligible.) 
 A frisson of concern ran through the staff when it was discovered that items have only been routinely fumigated against pathogens since the 1950s. 
 Anthrax, it appears, is a remote but potential hazard. 
 Parts of people present another unusual challenge (fig. 10.3). 
 The Egyptian department's assorted examples of the embalmer's art extend from the full body to three lone penises (gilded). 
 These examples vie with other reminders of some of the more arcane uses to which human technical ingenuity has been applied: the production of shrunken human heads from South America, or indeed dressed fleas from Mexico. 
 In all cases, the challenge to the documentation specialist remains the same: how to do justice to the objects in order to create an accurate and sufficiently detailed record of the object to allow it to be identified with confidence. 
 Possibly more terrifying than the prospect of being run through with poisoned weapons, gassed by noxious organic exhalations from embalmed bodies, or turning black with anthrax, is the very real prospect of an object  disintegrating in (or falling from) one's hands. 
 Museum staff are trained in the handling and care of objects and are well aware of some of the obvious dangers. 
 For example, a crispy one-hundred-year-old nest of leaf boxes that snugly fit their storage device is best left snugly fitted in their storage device and observed in situ  during inventory checks. 
 Handling objects of this sort may well result in extensive (and expensive) damage. 
 The awful prospect of dropping a priceless Ming vase, everyone's idea of a nightmare, is minimised by working in pairs, with one person observing the necessary details from a safe distance and the other handling the object. 
 A more recent development in information technology, that of interactive videodisc, may provide the means of avoiding some of these hazards. 
 If an image can be provided of the more inaccessible, fragile or minute objects, students and visitors may view the record and image simultaneously without anyone having to handle the items. 
 This has several advantages: fragile items will be spared the cumulative damage resulting from repeated handling and removal from storage facilities. 
 In addition, museum assistants or other personnel whose task it is to prepare the objects for visitors and to supervise their access to the collections may have more time for other tasks. 
 &bquo;And little fleas have lesser fleas&equo;: What price detail? 
 A limited inventory is exactly that. 
 It cannot offer any greater insight into the object, the circumstances of its manufacture, or the cultural framework  from which it derived. 
 The inventory does not constitute &bquo;information&equo; but &bquo;data&equo;. 
 There is no automatic association, for example, between the object's name, its provenance and its physical location within the Museum. 
 Thus, a list of object names from such a database will only be a list of names, not a list of names according to country of origin or date of manufacture. 
 This would constitute information &mdash; data plus a contextual framework allowing a larger picture to be revealed. 
 But how detailed should (or can) this information be? 
 Clearly much will depend on the availability of information in the first place. 
 Some register entries are so rudimentary that they are unable to support anything more than a basic inventory. 
 Other registers and sources, such as departmental file cards and reports, can be used to enhance a basic level of data so that it truly constitutes information and, as such, is useful for the production of books, catalogues and as a research tool. 
 Different departments require a different degree of detail for different research applications. 
 The quantity of detail and the resultant record size will also affect the amount of time involved in the creation of a single record. 
 In a perfect world, where resources are unlimited, all available data could be accommodated. 
 Sadly, this is not possible. 
 Constraints of finance, manpower and time all conspire to limit what may be achieved, and compromises are inevitable. 
 The enhancement of records into research tools must remain secondary if the primary objective is producing an inventory. 
 However, some middle way between a basic inventory and a fully detailed record is possible. 
 Information about materials and techniques of manufacture, geography of find-spot and manufacture, and a short free-text description of the object are examples of the information categories currently included in the British Museum's inventory. 
 However, the enormous diversity of objects within and between the collections does mean that a degree of flexibility is necessary to provide a sensible selection of fields that reflect the variation in object type. 
 For example, different aspects of a picture, a coin and an Egyptian mummy would need to be emphasised if they are to be distinguished from other objects of the same sort. 
 Despite limitations imposed upon the quantity  of information recorded, there are ways to guarantee quality  and to maximise the usefulness of the available information. 
 How data are input is directly relevant to the way the same information is retrieved from the system. 
 Control of the quality of data can be vitally important. 
 In most systems, if a word is misspelt or miskeyed, that piece of data can only be retrieved if the same format is used during the retrieval process. 
 One means of controlling the way data are typed into a record is by a so-called &bquo;authority list&equo;. 
 This can be useful in situations where a set number of allowable words or phrases may be used when adding data to a specific part of the record. 
 Any word or phrase not recognised by the computer as being on the authority list will cause the list of available choices to be displayed. 
 The person entering the details must then choose an option from this list and the computer will then add the choice to the record automatically. 
 An example of how this might be applied to an  inventory record would be to control the format of named collections, e.g. &bquo;Sloane Bequest, Miscellanea&equo;. 
 Without controlling the way in which this collection name is entered. 
 it is possible that the retrieval of records bearing such information might be wholly or partially unsuccessful. 
 Another similar but more sophisticated device for use in record systems is a &bquo;thesaurus&equo; (fig. 10.4). 
 A thesaurus (see Chapter 9) is essentially a database in its own right, with each word constituting a record, cross-referenced to other records or terms through a series of relationships which can be broad, narrow or related (e.g. &bquo;metal&equo; is a narrower term of &bquo;inorganic&equo;, but it is a broad term of &bquo;iron&equo;. 
 In turn, iron is a related term to &bquo;steel&equo;.) 
 Each term is also designated as either &bquo;preferred&equo; or  &bquo;non-preferred&equo;, i.e. deemed suitable for inclusion in a record, or not. 
 Non-preferred terms are not absolutely forbidden  for use in the records, but no relationships are attached to them, and this has implications during information retrieval. 
 Supposing someone requires a list of all the metal items in a large collection. 
 Without a thesaurus, the records would need to be searched by naming all the metals individually, but without knowing which metals have actually been recorded in the records. 
 This is clearly cumbersome and possibly unsatisfactory and many users might be tempted to abandon the process before achieving their ends. 
 In contrast, use of a thesaurus would require only the broad term (in this case, &bquo;metal&equo;) to be stated, plus the relationship to be investigated (in this case the narrower terms). 
 In this way all records with named metals will be retrieved, as well as those that only possess the term &bquo;metal&equo;. 
 An additional element found in the thesaurus is a &bquo;scope note&equo;. 
 These offer the opportunity to record additional insights into the content or application of a term, particularly if there is some ambiguity involved. 
 This is especially useful in a museum context, where vast numbers and types of objects representing different specialisms may be united by the thesaurus. 
 A particular problem requiring resolution concerns the status given to scientific names for plants and animals. 
 The problem arises when more common, everyday names are available. 
 Take the human flea, or Pulex irritans . 
 The pedant's argument might be that Pulex irritans  is a very specific term for an otherwise undistinguished little insect. 
 It provides precision, &bquo;flea&equo; being too vague and potentially confused with other types of flea, such as the dog flea, or (disaster!) the water flea. 
 The pragmatist might suggest that precision is fine only so long as everyone understands the term: in fact, Pulex irritans  is less obviously a flea, than &bquo;flea&equo;. 
 The pedant, persistent as ever, could insist that Pulex irritans  is the proper term for a flea and it therefore ought to be provided for those who understand it. 
 The pragmatist could agree, pointing out that the scope notes for each term could be used for precisely this purpose, adding that, unless a scientific name has no more common alternative, it should remain non-preferred, with an alternative preferred term supplied. 
 The thesaurus functions not only as a retrieval aid, but also as a reference facility. 
 People are often uncertain as to the exact nature of the enquiry they wish to make concerning the Museum collections. 
 Sometimes this uncertainty is due to ignorance of the contents of the records and the way in which objects are referred to, particularly in large and varied collections. 
 Browsing through the thesaurus allows the user to move between ideas and concepts, on the one hand, and individual terms &mdash; either as an alphabetical list, or as separate records in which all the terms that are related in any way are displayed, along with the scope notes. 
 The user is then able to make a detailed search of the database, armed with the knowledge of its potential contents and the spelling of the terms involved. 
 This aspect of information handling in museums is a lexicographic task, involving the definition, refinement and structuring of the terms employed in a computerised record.  
 &bquo;&hellip; 
 And so ad infinitum&equo;: Where will it all end? 
 The task of computerising the collections of an institution like the British Museum is a substantial one, but the day will come, some years hence, when all departments have had all their documentation computerised and all their objects checked. 
 However, there will still be the ongoing task of maintaining the system that has been created. 
 A database requires maintenance, not merely because new records will have to have their content assessed and controlled, but because when new ideas permeate the academic disciplines, this too should properly be reflected in the terminology used in the construction of records. 
 A database should be as dynamic as the institution that creates it. 
 Its production is not a once-and-for-all process but a tool in its own right, complementing the many other processes that contribute to the Museum's development.   
 10.1 Page from an old British Museum register dating from 1908. 
 10.2 diagram showing the evolution of the curatorial departments within the British Museum since its foundation in 1753. 
 10.3 Mummified head from the Egyptian collections. 
 10.4 Example of a thesaurus display. 
 INTRODUCTION 
 &bquo;Thou know'st 'tis common, all that lives must die, 
 Passing through nature to eternity.&equo; 
 Hamlet  
 When we are going on a journey to a strange country, our state of mind and the nature of our preparations are determined by what we think we shall find there and, in particular, by whether we have friends and relations living there. 
 It cannot be otherwise with the approach of death; whether we go on pilgrimage with Raleigh or put out to sea with Tennyson, the metaphor of travel is one with which the poets have made us familiar. 
 This book, therefore, is not only about how men and women in the nineteenth century faced the hour of death; it is also about what they expected to encounter on the further shore. 
 It is a subject that historians and sociologists, stressing the activities of men's lives, have been inclined to overlook. 
 Scant attention has been given to the way in which man's attitude to death feeds back into his life and so exerts an influence upon society. 
 For this is a link that cannot be uncoupled; &bquo;in my end is my beginning&equo;. 
 How we live is inescapably linked to what we think about our origin and our destiny, even if we only discuss these mysteries late at night in the company of a few friends. 
 Those hardy souls in the present century who ignore the mysteries and regard themselves as random atoms, moving purposelessly in a world of blind chance, must necessarily behave differently from those who, like so many in the nineteenth century, believed that they inhabited an ordered world in which they had moral duties to perform, even if these  were obscurely glimpsed and seldom accomplished. 
 The contrasting attitudes become more vivid if we try to envisage men and women of the two epochs as they lie (as all must) on their death-beds. 
 There is probably no such thing as a typical death-bed in any century; but it is not difficult to take two representative scenarios, separated from one another by about one hundred years. 
 In the first, the friends and relatives of the dying man, frequently accompanied by young children, are standing within earshot of his bed, listening either to his last words or, if he has already fallen silent, to the prayers of the pastor, who is celebrating the triumph of Christian immortality over death and the devil. 
 The beneficiary of their prayers dies in his own home; his relations, or servants, lay out the body and watch beside it until it is placed in the coffin and taken for interment in accordance with the rites of the Church. 
 An account of the last hours and words is written for the edification of those unable to be present. 
 In our day there is little of the earlier resignation in the face of death; we resist it to the limits of medical technology, and our obituaries speak of our &bquo;gallant struggle&equo;. 
 Death, for us, is the sorry end of the human story, not the mysterious prelude to a new one. 
 A high proportion of us die not at home, but in hospitals, clinics and special institutions for the terminally ill. 
 There our friends and relatives sometimes come to visit us and speak resolutely of trivial matters; children seldom come, because that might seem &bquo;morbid&equo;, especially if the illness is known to be terminal. 
 When the end is coming, screens are placed round the bed; in any case there are unlikely to be any &bquo;last words&equo;, because most of us die under some form of sedation. 
 The undertaker then takes over, makes up our faces and carries the coffin to the crematorium. 
 There a hybrid service takes place, to which even a confirmed atheist could hardly object. 
 If there is an address, it is often given by a layman, who commends what we did in life and skims discreetly over the question of survival, if any. 
 As the coffin slides into the furnace, we try to restrict our emotional involvement &mdash; sometimes at considerable psychological cost.  
 The contrast is striking, and cannot be dismissed as irrelevant to the social and other problems that we confront in the last decade of our century. 
 It is not the purpose of this book to study these problems, but rather the changes that in an earlier century began to alter our attitude towards death. 
 It is not enough to assume that all that has happened is that we no longer believe in hell, and that mutes, carrying black ostrich plumes, are out of favour. 
 The changes have been more fundamental and some of them may have affected us in ways that we do not immediately recognise. 
 All centuries, of course, have been centuries of change; but few would deny that in the nineteenth century change was greatly accelerated; that much was apparent to the more perceptive of those living at that time. 
 Some felt that they were hurrying into an epoch of unprecedented enlightenment, in which better education and beneficent technology would ensure wealth and leisure for all. 
 This was Herbert Spencer's view, namely that an upward evolutionary process was inherent in the human condition. 
 To others, including Tennyson and Arnold, it seemed as if &bquo;the ringing grooves of change&equo; were carrying them at break-neck speed into a future full of uncertainty and alarm. 
 Browning was more hopeful, but he, too, was impressed by the transiency of the world, flashing past the carriage windows: &bquo;Must the rose sigh &bquo;Pluck &mdash; I perish!&equo; 
 Must the eve weep &bquo;Gaze &mdash; I fade!&equo;&equo; 
 The Impressionist painters caught the contagion, and the new race of photographers tried to seize the fleeting moment and make it stay. 
 Cultures and historical periods differ greatly in their concepts of time and the continuity of life. 
 We live in a century imprinted on the present, which regards the past as little more than the springboard from which we were launched on our way. 
 Ours, for better or for worse, is the century of youth. 
 Earlier centuries, in contrast, had an appreciation of the past that embodied more than nostalgia or antiquarian interest. 
 Age and experience were valued in the belief that length of days had provided some guidance on how to live and what to expect in the life to come. 
 For the life on earth of each individual was not a finite entity, complete in itself, but a transition to  another mode of existence; the gateway to that unknown land was death &mdash; Mors Janna Vitae , as the memorial tablets had it. 
 This belief was fostered by the churches, the floors and walls of which were incised with the records of those who had gone before, but it was expressed positively in the family. 
 Families cherished their forbears, whether these had lived in humble cottages or in manor houses. 
 Sons aspired to follow in their fathers' trades or professions. 
 The landed gentry planted for their grandchildren avenues of hardwood that they themselves would never see. 
 In the nineteenth century this leisurely view of the pageant of time began to speed up. 
 People became more mobile, both physically and socially; men wished to rise in the world. 
 Young men with feet on the ladder, provided by the Industrial Revolution, looked askance at the old-fashioned ways of their fathers. 
 Growing more acquisitive in the present, they prepared to disown the past; the future was to be different, both for themselves and their children, and they had to run to catch up with it. 
 Improving life expectancy gave them every hope of doing so, especially if they belonged to the rising middle-class. 
 For the middle-class was both the agent and product of these changes. 
 The rise of the middle-class was not, on the whole, predicated on an aspiration to join the aristocracy, whose way of life, especially during the Regency, met with a good deal of disapprobation; but it was determined by the resolute intention of the new men to distance themselves in every possible way from the working-class, out of which so many of them had raised themselves. 
 Their rise during the Industrial Revolution was expressed in capital accumulation; the status of the aristocracy still derived from birth and ownership of land. 
 The new men were not aping the landed gentry; they were basing their careers upon the infrastructure provided by urban Britain. 
 There was no coherent ideology embracing the entire middle-class, but there were two ideologies that subsumed its more active sectors. 
 The older one was that of the Evangelicals and Dissenters, of whom more will be written in chapter three. 
 The newer ideology was that of the  followers of Jeremy Bentham (1745&ndash;1832), the so-called Utilitarians; it was far from sharing a common world view with the Evangelicals, but there were certain social issues, such as abolition of slavery, on which concerted action was possible. 
 Macaulay was one of those who had a foot in both camps. 
 Before we consider how these ideologies affected attitudes to death, we must glance at the social and economic changes that provided the context within which they operated. 
 In 1801 the population of England and Wales was under nine million, of whom the great majority lived in rural communities outside London. 
 Seventy years later the population had risen to 22.7 million, of whom 62% lived in towns and cities. 
 The legislative measures corresponding to this change had been the Reform Act of 1832 and the repeal of the Corn Laws in 1846, which recognised that the price of bread could no longer be controlled in the interest of British grain producers. 
 Another, and less welcome change was the restructuring of the traditional parochial system for the relief of poverty. 
 In 1834 Parliament, largely under Benthamite influence, adopted the new Poor Law, which grouped workhouses for the indigent into regional Unions, and imposed harsh discipline designed to deter &bquo;able-bodied vagabonds&equo; from exploiting the charitable instincts of the locality. 
 Poor people's hostility to this measure was redoubled by their realisation of its relationship to another, adopted two years earlier under Benthamite influence, namely the Anatomy Act. 
 The ostensible purposes of this Act were to ensure that an adequate supply of bodies was available for dissection in the teaching hospitals and anatomy schools, whilst eliminating the nefarious activities of the body-snatchers, whose commerce had nourished the medical profession. 
 The Act stipulated that &bquo;unclaimed&equo; corpses should in future be used. 
 It was clearly foreseen, though not stated, that these would be drawn mainly from the workhouses, either because the relatives of the dead could not pay for interment, or because they had not been notified of death. 
 The terrors of the workhouse were thus extended beyond the portals of death; for the least  favoured section of the population there waited the ultimate humiliation of dissection by medical students, a fate hitherto reserved for convicted murderers. 
 In an impressive study of the Anatomy Act, Ruth Richardson had deduced &bquo;the existence of distinct class-bound death cultures in Victorian Britain &mdash; an important aspect of the cultural gap which divided the &bquo;two nations&equo; of rich and poor&equo;. 
 More about the odious practice of body-snatching will be found in chapter five. 
 In this introductory chapter the aim is, rather, to stress the emergence of these two death cultures, characterising the relevant literature of the nineteenth century. 
 The aristocracy had long chosen to immure its dead in church vaults or specially constructed mausoleums, and this practice reached its peak in the royal mausoleum at Frogmore, built by Victoria after the death of Albert. 
 At the opposite extreme, paupers' graves had long been unmarked; but in between, death had been the metaphorical leveller. 
 This ceased to be the case as the middle-class, finding vaults overcrowded, erected miniature fortresses in the new necropolises and encased their dead in double, and even triple, coffins against the depredations of body-snatchers. 
 Elaborate funerary rites, strenuously promoted by the emergent trade of the undertakers, ensured that the social pretensions of the middle-class would extend as far into the next world as money could take them. 
 It was a hard act to follow, but the poor did what they could to provide respectable funerals for their dead. 
 This was a major objective of burial societies and other forms of insurance; irreplaceable possessions were often pawned or sold to pay for a funeral. 
 Other factors widened the gulf that in death separated rich from poor and also separated the poor from their dead. 
 As villages grew into towns and towns into cities, the lack of churchyards was felt at least as much as the lack of churches. 
 No custom was more deeply rooted than that of visiting the graves of the dead and arranging to be laid beside them when the time came. 
 At Stoke Poges as elsewhere, &bquo;the rude forefathers of the hamlet&equo; had slept beside their ancestors in the shadow of the church in  which they had worshipped. 
 Where congestion made this impossible, the estrangement was severely felt. 
 Only the traditional resting-place would do. 
 What held good for Stoke Poges held good for the Western Isles; Kathleen Raine has given us a description, worthy of Thomas Gray, of the burial of an old Scotswoman: 
 &bquo;&hellip; poor, almost illiterate&hellip; her pride was that she was of the Clanranald. 
 In the small, square grave-yard, tangled with bramble and escalonia and overgrown with rank grass and nettles, a hole was dug for her among the bones of former generations; bones of old women and men scarcely yet forgotten were turned up to make a place for her among them. 
 A piece of pastureland adjoining had been given by the Laird, so dense was the population of the dead in that rank square; but the people would not use it, they would rather return to the hallowed earth of the dead from whose collective and immortal life they had themselves briefly emerged&hellip; &bquo; 
 In the new cities, where there was scant room for the living, there was even less room for the dead. 
 During the great epidemics, such as the successive invasions of cholera, there was neither space nor time to bury the dead with decency; the degradation of human beings continued in death as in life. 
 In time, each city constructed its necropolis; but this was situated in the outskirts. 
 Carriagefolk might drive there, but poor people, immigrants from the countryside, could no longer visit the graves of their dead and at Easter place flowers on them. 
 They had dropped out of the human chain of ancestors and descendants that had formerly bound them all together. 
 As a factor in the atomisation of society, this alienation from the dead has been underestimated. 
 E. P. Thompson is no doubt right to insist that a distinctive working-class culture was being formed at this period. 
 Nonetheless it was the aspiration of most of those living above subsistence level that they, or their sons, should be absorbed into the expanding middle-class.  
 There were indeed frontiers between the classes, but these were constantly shifting. 
 Both Evangelicals and Utilitarians wished to impose the middle-class way of life upon their thriftless fellow men, whose poverty, they believed, was in great measure attributable to improvident and ungodly habits, such as addiction to drink and raising illegitimate children. 
 The Evangelicals recommend &bquo;Ragged Schools&equo;, Sunday schools, and regular churchgoing as the cure; they agreed with the Benthamites that education was the ladder leading up the economic scale. 
 Compulsory primary education had not yet been introduced by the state, and the educational system, from church school to university, was still dominated by the clergy and their middle-class values. 
 These were also powerfully promoted by domestic service at a time when even the meanest clerk expected to employ at least a resident maid-of-all-work. 
 In pious families it was the rule that the servants attended family prayers. 
 All these reasons serve to explain why this study concentrates mainly upon the attitudes to death that prevailed in the middle-class, whose irresistible rise was so prominent a feature of the nineteenth century. 
 An additional reason is to be found in the relative paucity of working-class sources. 
 Those members of the working-class who rejected or had sunk below the influence of the class above them, remained largely illiterate and inarticulate. 
 It was the middle-class that kept and circulated family letters, especially those recounting saintly death-beds. 
 It was the middle-class, and especially Dissenters and Evangelicals, who wrote regular diaries as an aid to daily reviews of conduct and repentance for sin. 
 By comparison, the working-class has left only meagre traces of itself. 
 If we turn to literature for corroboration, the story is the same; the great Victorian novelists, such as Charles Dickens and George Eliot, were middle-class authors, writing for middle-class readers. 
 Even philanthropists, like Henry Mayhew and Charles Booth, who penetrated into the slums to record how the very poor lived, were reproducing their findings through the filter of their own middle-class minds. 
 Those whom they encountered were for the most part leading precarious lives; they lacked the  leisure, the mental energy, even the vocabulary, for speculation about the great issues of heaven and hell, death and judgement. 
 Death, with which they lived so intimately, could not be detached from their lives as an object of contemplation. 
 Hugh McLeod has summed it up: 
 &bquo;Preoccupation with keeping afloat in a cruel environment produced an indifference to questions about the meaning of the world and a good deal of scepticism about most schemes for changing it.&equo; 
 The representative middle-class institution was the family, which reached its apotheosis in the nineteenth century. 
 As our death-bed scenario illustrated, the family was at its most cohesive at the times when the rites of passage were celebrated. 
 Scorn has been poured upon the excessive mourning practised by Victorians, to which even their children and servants were subjected; but it should be recalled that the badge of mourning was like the tartan of a Highland clan: it symbolised solidarity. 
 The family was at one in its grief, and grief shared was suffering alleviated. 
 Abortive attempts in our time to shuffle off the whole experience and make light of its impact have only begun comparatively recently to attract the attention of psycho-analysts. 
 Mourning can have a therapeutic function that we ignore at our peril. 
 There is no doubt that family ties were knotted with great intensity; indeed, well before the end of the century there was criticism of this intensity, directed chiefly against the dominant paterfamilias. 
 One reason for this, which might at first sight seem paradoxical, was that, except in the aristocracy, the family unit had contracted. 
 In the rural communities of previous centuries most families included more than two generations &mdash; the extended family &mdash; and the families of land-owners were further extended to include the indoor and sometimes the outdoor servants. 
 The benevolent influence of a family, such as that depicted in the first chapter of Tom Brown's Schooldays , reached out to the tenants and other members  of the local community; the girls from the cottages came into the big house as dairy or nursery-maids; the boys were taken on as under-gardeners or grooms. 
 With the urbanisation and expansion of the middle-class the pattern began to change. 
 The new class was mobile, following where the opportunities of trade or profession might lead, and leaving behind the communities in which its older members had been rooted. 
 The city or suburban dwellings of the new class were at first too small to accommodate the extended family. 
 Moreover, aspiring members of this new class were not only moving about the country; they were also moving upward, abandoning grandparents who could not keep up, or did not wish to do so. 
 Within this nuclear family, the hopes and affections of its members were concentrated and the emotional level could rise dangerously high. 
 In this small inward-looking world, the intrusion of death could be dreadfully destructive; the damage could be limited partly by sharing the loss and partly by belief that it would be made good in the afterlife. 
 Religion and the nuclear family went hand in hand. 
 The expansion of the middle-class was one aspect of the great increase in population marking the nineteenth century. 
 The chief reason for this was that people were living longer. 
 At first sight, it might seem that this trend should have restored the feeling of stability and counteracted the sensation of transience, to which reference has been made. 
 In practice, this did not prove to be the case. 
 There were no reliable statistics before 1838 and, even after that date, demographers did not agree on how the data should be interpreted. 
 At one time it was widely believed that there had been a great rise in the birth-rate; there was, in fact, a slow rise to the end of the 1861&ndash;70 decade, after which the rate began to fall. 
 Moreover, until the end of the century infant mortality remained at the deplorably high rate of 150 deaths per 1,000 live births. 
 For those surviving the first year of life, however, the chances were improving; death-rate fell from 23 per 1,000 (living) in 1841 to 18 per 1,000 in 1901. 
 It is now widely accepted that this was the main cause of the rise in population.  
 It was by no means clear at first, however, that this was a constant trend, nor that permanent improvement in life expectancy was possible. 
 On the contrary, many followed Malthus in believing that availability of food would always tend to limit population growth, and that the &bquo;iron law of wages&equo; would prevent the poor from achieving a standard of living allowing diseases of malnutrition to be banished. 
 Karl Marx was not the only economist who died holding this belief. 
 It was not until the 1880s that a number of new factors operating together began to change the prospect for the better. 
 Leaving aside social legislation, the most important of these factors was the opening up of the grain-bearing areas of North America, refrigeration, and acceleration of maritime transport. 
 At home, improvements in urban sanitation and hygiene in hospitals were gradually raising health standards. 
 Even so, dark areas remained. 
 Death was a respecter of persons, and chances of survival were better in the upper and middle-classes than in the working-class. 
 Although women were living longer than men on average, there remained throughout the century an &bquo;accident blackspot&equo; for women who bore children. 
 The advances of medical science were slow to alleviate diseases associated with childbirth, such as puerperal fever; midwives were untrained. 
 The London School of Medicine for Women opened its doors in 1874 to the accompaniment of much ridicule of &bquo;lady doctors&equo;; despite the efforts of Florence Nightingale, the profession continued to be male-dominated. 
 This may well have been a contributory factor in the prevalence of death in child-birth. 
 In the decade 1855&ndash;65 the death-rate for delivery at home was 5 per 1,000; but the rate in hospital was substantially worse. 
 In the days when contraception was still a rarity, every husband knew, if he chose to think of it, that by sleeping with his wife he might imperil her life. 
 This awareness was undoubtedly one of the elements promoting prostitution, which pious Victorians often referred to as &bquo;the great social evil&equo;. 
 It also throws light on the guilt-feeling associated with sex, which is a distinguishing mark of nineteenth century morality. 
 Love and death have always been themes exciting the  imagination of poets; but in the last century they figured in works of art and literature to an extent that was almost obsessional. 
 Woman, whether as wife, mother or mistress or &bquo;fallen woman&equo;, is depicted as victim of man. 
 This might seem inconsistent with the fact that women were living longer, were it not that longer life brought no immediate improvement in their prospects; it remained a man's world. 
 According to the census of 1851, nearly one quarter of all women over 30 were unmarried; between 1851 and 1871 the number of single females above the age of 15 rose from 2,765,000 to 3,229,000. 
 Domestic service or the mills were the main openings for single women of the working-class; if they married and outlived their husbands, there were no old age pensions available. 
 For single middle-class women without dowries there was only the prospect of becoming a governess or companion. 
 Even married women, before the enactment of the Married Women's Property Act of 1882, might find themselves trapped in dependence upon their husbands in a loveless marriage. 
 It is in such conditions that we should look for an explanation of the outcrop in the 1860s of sensational popular fiction, replete with desertion, adultery, bigamy and sudden death; much of it was written from the woman's point of view by women writers, such as Mary Braddon, Rhoda Broughton and Mrs Henry Wood. 
 We emphasised religion in connection with education and the family, but we should not overlook the importance of the secularisation of society. 
 The term &bquo;secularisation&equo;, as its distinguished chronicler has pointed out, was coming into use in the period 1865&ndash;70. 
 The process, however, had begun long since. 
 Any date would be arbitrary, but two deserve to be mentioned. 
 One is the founding of the South Place Society in 1795; the other is the initiation in 1817 of Robert Owen's anti-religious campaign. 
 The aim in both cases was to substitute Man for God in a new temple of humanity. 
 The agents of this substitution would be education and the discoveries of science, which would sweep away not only the authority of revealed religion, but indeed all metaphysical ideas. 
 Reason and utility were the pass-words to the new heaven  on earth, and Jeremy Bentham was its prophet. 
 He regarded posterity as the only afterlife worth contemplating and, to show his contempt for the resurrection of the body, he left his to be dissected &mdash; a bold gesture that his contemporaries were slow to follow &mdash; and his reconstituted skeleton was exhibited in University College, London. 
 Later, the influence of Saint-Simon and Comte was introduced into English humanism through the efforts of John Stuart Mill (1806&ndash;73). 
 These philosophers and reformers believed that promotion of happiness could safely be entrusted to men and women themselves, without divine intervention, since they were innately good; but some had misgivings about how to hold onto Christian charity. 
 Could they jettison Christian faith and hope, without loss of moral standards? 
 Their aspiration to hold everyone at the ethical level of the enlightened bourgeoisie encountered the strong disapproval of Friedrich Nietzsche, who wrote under the heading: G. Eliot  &mdash; 
 &bquo;They have got rid of the Christian God, and now feel obliged to cling all the more firmly to Christian morality: that is english  consistency, let us not blame it on little blue-stockings &agrave; la Eliot. 
 In England, in response to every little emancipation from theology one has to reassert one's position in a fear-inspiring manner as a moral fanatic&equo; 
 The moral fanaticism, as we have long seen around us, proved scarcely more durable than the theology. 
 There were, however, some immediate gains; one of these was the decline of belief in hell, which gradually ceased to resound in the sermons of Ministers of God other than Calvinists. 
 Many death-beds were thus relieved of one of their terrors. 
 In a poll of Anglican Clergy undertaken in 1864 only 40% expressed the view that the damned would suffer everlasting torment; it may be assumed that a poll of laity would have disclosed a substantially lower percentage.ii. 
 One consideration that was coming to influence the more perceptive minds was a  realisation of the immensity of the populated globe. 
 In an age of imperial expansion and active missionary endeavour, it became harder to believe that everywhere the heathen were damned for their ignorance. 
 In the first decade of the century the Rev. Richard Cecil (1748&ndash;1810), a leading Evangelical preacher and one of the founders of the Church Missionary Society, had expressed doubt on this score: 
 &bquo;Were a benighted inhabitant of Otaheite to feel the wretchedness of his present life, and lift up his soul to the god he worshipped as a supreme being&hellip; no doubt God would hear such a prayer.&equo; 
 At the Reformation, Protestants had incautiously narrowed their options by throwing out limbo and purgatory, leaving themselves no mid-point between heaven and hell. 
 Though no-one was prepared to admit that Roman Catholics had got the better of the argument, some Protestants felt a certain dissatisfaction with an afterlife in which all earnest endeavour, for better or worse, was at an end. 
 Under the influence of Quakers, Benthamites and others the savage penal code had been amended to give it a reformative, as well as a retributive, purpose. 
 If men could feel some compassion for their fellow sinners, what were they to think of an all-merciful Father, who conceded to his children no ultimate hope of forgiveness? 
 If men were beginning to abandon their fear of hell, they were clinging with some tenacity to their hopes of heaven, as we shall see in chapter nine. 
 Those who thought otherwise relied upon the observation that attendance at church was declining. 
 One authority on the evolution of the working-class quotes Friedrich Engels to the effect that, 
 &bquo;The workers are not religious, and do not attend church&hellip; 
 Among the masses there prevails almost universally a total indifference to religion, or at the utmost, some trace of Deism&hellip;&equo; 
 This view would seem to be supported by the Sunday census of March 1851, when it was found that in London only 37% of the inhabitants attended any form of divine service, whilst in eight other cities with populations in excess of 100,000 the figure was only 42%. 
 It must be understood, however, that church attendance is a very uncertain guide to what people think about the great mystery of life and death. 
 In the days of pastoral England, country people had gone to church under the stern eye of squire and parson, one of whom was almost certain to be the local magistrate. 
 When in the new urban conglomerates this pressure was removed, it was natural that attendance should decline. 
 Squires, parsons and magistrates were associated with tithes and the administration of the Poor Law, in an era when the workhouse represented many poor men's idea of hell. 
 The reaction of the urban proletariat was natural; one cannot safely deduce from it any decisive change in attitude towards death and survival. 
 Even to this day, many who have never been inside a church since their baptism expect to be buried in consecrated ground after some form of religious service. 
 Engels, whose observations were based on life in urban Lancashire, was obliged to make an exception in favour of the Irish immigrants, who in 1841 already constituted 10% or the population of Manchester. 
 The exception is an instructive one, because the Irish priests lived at much the same social and economic level as their flock; they held their communities together and sustained their faith in a way that only Dissenting ministers in Wales and remoter parts of England were able to do. 
 After the Irish famine more immigrants came south, and by 1851 they made up 4.6% of the population of London. 
 Hugh McLeod writes: 
 &bquo;The Catholic Church&hellip; was unique among the larger religious bodies by the fact that so many of the most devout were drawn from the working-class and even from the poor.&equo; 
 If the secularisation of the working-class had gone ahead as rapidly as Engels wished to believe, one would  expect to see some reflection of this in figures showing the growth of Rationalist and Secularist Societies. 
 It has been estimated, however, that at no point in the century did membership of such Societies exceed 6,000, a figure roughly comparable to the number of adherents of the New Jerusalem Church of the Swedenborgians. 
 Some of those, predominantly of the middle-class who had declined from religious orthodoxy, turned to cults such as spiritualism and Theosophy, which insisted upon survival in some form. 
 These cults are dealt with in chapter ten. 
 The leading British convert to Theosophy was Annie Besant (1847&ndash;1933), herself a renegade from Secularism. 
 One of the most significant areas in which secularisation operated was the indefinable one of shared responsibility, human and divine, for life and death; this is studied in chapter two. 
 Dietrich Bonhoeffer once commented that &bquo;religious people speak of God when human knowledge has come to an end, or when human resources fail&hellip; 
 . It is certainly true that as men came to understand the natural world and thus to control it, they began to banish God from it. 
 This applied with special force to the discoveries of medical science; life and death were no longer defined in terms of &bquo;the Lord giveth, the Lord taketh away&equo;. 
 By the end of the century the advocates of Neo-Malthusianism, as it was called, were aiming to bring child-bearing under control; life, except in strict Catholic families, was not regarded as the gift of God. 
 At the other end of the human time-scale, the idea that life could be, and was being, prolonged through man's skill and foresight had taken a powerful hold. 
 God might have oversight over the destinies of nations, for example, in times of war; but individuals would do better to rely on their own foresight, and on such pressure on the state as could be exerted by groups organised to sustain collective interests. 
 In our day this has degenerated into the assumption that virtually every personal misfortune can be blamed upon some authority or institution &mdash; usually the government of the day. 
 No attempt can be made in a work of this scope to relate the full story of how nineteenth century attitudes to death evolved during the present century into those now  prevailing. 
 Such a task would require separate volumes dealing with the different religious denominations. 
 It would also need to pay attention to regional variations, since it is true, even in these days of mass mobility and the mass media, that to travel to a place remote from a major centre of population is to move back in time and rediscover the traditions and practices of an earlier period. 
 Nonetheless an effort has been made in the final chapter to draw some conclusions about the contemporary impact of changes that have occurred. 
 This book does not have a polemical purpose, but the author has not been able to escape the conclusion that at least some of the customs and habits of mind of the earlier period tended to induce healthier attitudes, both among those on their death-beds and those left behind to mourn. 
 The earlier death-bed was at once more solemn and more familiar; the tears at the bedside and the liturgy of the church were well adjusted to the sufferings of the dying and of the bereaved. 
 Scepticism and an attitude of indifference to the prospect of final extinction have proved, as a matter of practical experience, no adequate substitute for the doctrine of immortality, however illusory one may hold it to be. 
 The tranquiliser and the bottle are poor comforters when the time comes to part for ever from those we love. 
 The hospice movement, in its care of the terminally ill, is the living recognition of these sombre facts. 
 A traditional anecdote may be said to sum up the change that has taken place in our attitude. 
 The Sufi sage, Hadrat Uwais el-Qarni, a contemporary of Mohammed, was once asked how he was feeling. 
 He replied, &bquo;Like one who has risen in the morning and does not know whether he will be dead in the evening.&equo; 
 &bquo;But this is the situation of all men.&equo; 
 &bquo;Yes, but how many of them feel  it?&equo; 
 In the nineteenth century a comparatively high proportion of the population was aware of its own mortality; today this sense has almost vanished from everyday life. 
 It recurs only at isolated moments in the lives of those who suffer and, by this very experience, become more isolated from their fellows. 
 This would be all very well if we were on the high road to eliminating  death altogether; but this is a claim that not even the boldest scientist can make. 
 This being so, there is a case for casting a backward glance at attitudes of men and women of an earlier generation, whose lives had a limited span &mdash; like ours.   
 THE CONCEPT OF PROVIDENCE 
 &bquo;There's a special providence in the fall of a sparrow&equo;. 
 Hamlet  
 The transition from the Old Testament of Jahweh to the New Testament of Jesus Christ consisted in great measure in the abandonment of Job's sombre belief that, when he died, he would go: 
 &bquo;whence I shall not return, even to the land of darkness and the shadow of death&hellip; without any order, and where the light is as darkness.&equo; 
 This vision of a featureless future was not only dreadful in itself, but appeared to mock the efforts of those who, like Job, tried to do God's will, but had fallen on evil days. 
 The point was emphasised in Ecclesiastes by the Preacher: 
 &bquo;All things I have seen in the days of my vanity: there is a just man that perisheth in his righteousness, and there is a wicked man that prolongeth his life in his wickedness.&equo; 
 No people in human history have so consistently encountered so terrible a fate as that of the Jews, whose compact with Jahweh should have preserved them. 
 As George Steiner has written: 
 &bquo;To the strong believer the torture and massacre of six million is one chapter &mdash; one only &mdash; in the  millennial dialogue between God and the people He has so terribly chosen.&equo; 
 It was the Jewish people who first conceived of a single God, who was all-powerful and, in return for worship and obedience, could be expected to reward virtue and punish vice. 
 As often as not, He has done nothing of the kind. 
 The laws of cause and effect, which appear to operate so consistently in the physical world, seem to have no such application in the world of metaphysics. 
 A Sufi has written: 
 &bquo;Trust in God&hellip; is not taught to human beings by God. 
 On the contrary, God gives men so many reasons to have lack of trust (calamities, uncertainties, loss of hope) that it could be said that God actually illustrates that trust in something or someone beneficial is not to be erected on happiness or good experiences alone.&equo; 
 To reach such a conclusion necessarily requires a longer perspective than that allowed by brief life on earth, followed by eternal night. 
 Just such a perspective was provided by the New Testament, the gospel of good news, with its doctrines of incarnation, resurrection and atonement, which separated Christians from Jews and in the process did away with the shadow-land of Sheol, except for the heathen and the damned. 
 The Christian view of life, death and afterlife as a continuum not only supplied a happy ending to the human story, but could also &bquo;justify God's ways to man&equo;, in so far as the good man would be rewarded for a well-spent life, even if it seemed to have been dogged by misfortune. 
 Atheists, who have destroyed the continuum by insisting that death is the end, have failed to take into account that this arid conclusion must feed back into life as it is lived, making it seem haphazard and futile and emphasising its injustices. 
 No atheist need be surprised that the twentieth century has seen so massive an increase in greed, social disorder and mass violence. 
 If the Christian continuum provided hope for the regenerate individual, it offered a much less satisfying answer to the more general question that had perplexed  Job and so many others: why was there so much evil in the world that the Lord had made and seen to be good? 
 It was a question that troubled Saint Augustine: &bquo;Whence is evil? 
 Why then doth the soul err which God created?&equo; 
 The Bible supplied part of the answer: man sinned and became mortal, hence the incarnation and crucifixion. 
 &bquo;Since by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead.&equo; 
 But death, in itself, was only part of the problem; for many people, an even more terrifying part was the uncertainty when and how death would come. 
 The manner in which death came to men, including those innocent of any offence, could be so appalling that the final stroke could only be regarded as a merciful relief. 
 The problem of evil was rooted in Christian monotheism, which obliged the word &bquo;God&equo; to do duty for two functions, between which some other creeds had drawn a distinction. 
 The Greek and Roman pantheon honoured gods who, if adequately propitiated, could bring good fortune; Jove could make jovial; but these were not gods of last resort. 
 In the background, overriding the powers of all the gods, was the supreme authority of fate, or necessity, against which no petition nor sacrifice could prevail. 
 I his was the Providence that, in the eyes of the Stoics, directed the world order. 
 The gods could, up to a point, be merciful; but it was fate that was all-powerful. 
 Christian theologians, lacking this differentiation, find themselves in a predicament. 
 Dietrich Bonhoeffer, after emphasising that the German word for fate ( Schicksal ) is neuter, wrote of: 
 &bquo;God meeting us no longer as &bquo;Thou&equo;, but also disguised in the &bquo;It&equo;; so in the last resort my question is how we are to find the &bquo;Thou&equo; in this &bquo;It,&equo; (i.e., fate). 
 In other words how does fate become providence.&equo; 
 Both in peace and in war death came to man in every guise of terror, so that insurance companies declined to provide against acts of God or the King s enemies, as if these formed a single category. 
 Men were appalled by the sudden onset, which allowed no time for the deathbed repentance so dear to the hearts of pious Victorians. 
  Providence, in its benevolent aspect, was a power to foresee what dangers might be averted or, if that were not granted, how one might prepare to meet one's Maker. 
 &bquo;Lord, make me to know mine end and the measure of my days what it is&hellip; 
 &equo; God was both cause and cure of affliction. 
 An epitaph on two brothers in Old Radnor reads: 
 &bquo;Afflictions sore long time two brothers bore 
 Physicians strove in vain 
 Till God was pleased their lives to cease 
 And ease them of their pain.&equo; 
 Almost to the end of the nineteenth century, even educated men made no distinction between the merciful hand of God and the merciless grasp of death. 
 When in 1895 Sir Ronald Ross discovered the cause of malaria, he commemorated the event in a verse inscribed on a plaque in the Memorial Hospital in Calcutta: 
 &bquo;This day relenting God 
 Hath placed within my hand 
 A wondrous thing; and God 
 Be praised. 
 At his command 
 Seeking his secret deeds 
 With tears and toiling breath, 
 I find thy cunning seeds, 
 O million-murdering death.&equo; 
 For Sir Ronald Ross, the Christian God was barely distinguishable from the Hindu Shiva, who was at once preserver and destroyer. 
 Traditional Christians had long struggled to escape this identification. 
 Richard Cecil, like a good Evangelical, appealed to the Bible to support his view that evil had no independent existence, but conformed to God's masterplan: 
 &bquo;A great part of the Bible is to show us that all creatures are in God's hand, and that He will either make our afflictions work together for good, or remove them. 
 But the believer must wait for God's time of deliverance; he may think it long  in coming &mdash; forgetting that God's time is the best time.&equo; 
 Later in the nineteenth century George MacDonald took a similar line: 
 &bquo;All pains, indeed, and all sorrows, all demons, yea, all sins themselves, under the suffering care of the highest minister, are but the ministers of truth and righteousness.&equo; 
 This fundamentally optimistic interpretation of the world and its mysterious working was contested by the heirs of the Enlightenment of the previous century, who were looking for rational explanations and practical methods of applying them. 
 Their search was increasingly fuelled by the discoveries of science, especially medical science. 
 The tendency for earlier generations to lean so heavily on providence had been connected with the brevity and insecurity of life. 
 In the mid-nineteenth century life expectation was rising, especially for the new middle class, and central and regional authorities were coming to terms with the urban influx, which had changed the face of Britain. 
 Industrial labour was at last being regulated, water supplies purified, hospitals sanitised and prisons reformed. 
 Confidence was increasing that men, through foresight and effective action, could ameliorate their existence and even prolong their lives. 
 For the new generation, providence meant looking ahead in this progressive sense; those who would not do so were classed as improvident. 
 Provident societies, often connected with home buying, had existed since the end of the eighteenth century; in 1872 a Provident Knowledge Society was established &bquo;for the promotion of thrift among the lower classes&equo;, who were encouraged to contribute to penny banks and post-office savings. 
 It was the age of self-help and Samuel Smiles. 
 As men expanded the field of responsibility for their own existence, the field formerly assigned to Providence, in the traditional sense, contracted. 
 We can illustrate this point by drawing on the novels of Charlotte Yonge (1823&ndash;1901) who was deeply religious and  much concerned by human suffering. 
 One of her best loved characters was Dick May, the pious, but innately conservative, doctor of &bquo;Stoneborough&equo;, where an epidemic strikes, causing many deaths. 
 May's instinctive reaction is to blame the feckless poor of unhygienic slums: 
 &bquo;Those wretched Martins, in Lower Pond Buildings are the worst. 
 No wonder, living in voluntary filth; but it is all over the street &mdash; will be all over the town unless there's some special mercy on the place&equo; 
 But May's friend and colleague, Dr Spencer, ascribes the epidemic not to &bquo;voluntary filth&equo;, but to defects in the drainage system. 
 More and more people were looking to the drains, rather than to providence. 
 In a churchyard at Bilston in Staffordshire stands a memorial to a mother and her two infant children, who all died within a period of three weeks in the winter of 1847; they are described as &bquo;all victims to the neglect of sanitary regulations specially referred to in a recent lecture on Health in this town.&equo; 
 In mid-November 1849, as a cholera epidemic was in decline, Sunday services of thanksgiving were ordered to be held in churches. 
 Lady Edisbury, who had lost an infant in the epidemic, wrote to her husband: 
 &bquo;I believe this is the only country in which there has been a national acknowledgment of God's directing Providence in the cholera, and I believe it is not a mere outward form but that more and more are becoming every day religious.&equo; 
 Sadly she deceived herself: as the sanitary authorities became convinced that cholera was water-borne and could be checked by means more immediately effective than prayer, public attention became focussed more on the sanitary inspector than on the parson. 
 In these transitional years of fluctuating opinion some continued to adopt a passive attitude towards fatalities, in which they sought to trace the hand of God, whilst others favoured active remedies for what they held to be primarily human failings. 
 The judgement of observers of the  misfortunes of others were influenced by numerous factors, such as the scale of the calamity and its proximity or remoteness, as well as by prejudices arising from class and privilege. 
 Those who were safely beached on the shore of prosperity had the option of giving the credit to Providence, or arrogating it to themselves; as they regarded those less fortunate ones who were struggling in the water, they could see them as victims of their own improvidence or of God's ineluctable decree. 
 Charles Trevelyan, who was Chief Secretary of the Treasury at the time of the famine in Ireland, regarded the tragedy as due to &bquo;the operation of natural causes&equo;; the unhappy Irish were victims of Providence, as expressed in the laws of supply and demand. 
 After reading a report of his Relief Inspector, Trevelyan sympathised with his being exposed daily to: 
 &bquo;Scenes of heart-rending misery, without being able to give effectual relief&hellip; 
 But, as justly observed by you, we must do all we can and leave the rest to God.&equo; 
 There remained one category of great natural calamities that, because of its scale and random impact, still seemed to be the work of a wrathful deity. 
 This was the category of volcanos and earthquakes. 
 The famous Lisbon earthquake of 1755, which had faint reverberations as far north as Scotland, led George II to issue a solemn admonition to his people to the effect that &bquo;the manifold Sins and Wickedness of these Kingdoms have most justly deserved heavy and severe Punishments from the Hand of Heaven.&equo; 
 John Wesley drew a similar conclusion and published his Serious Thoughts on the Earthquake at Lisbon . 
 When in 1777 there were minor tremors in Manchester, he observed &mdash; not without a certain satisfaction &mdash; &bquo;There is no divine visitation which is likely to have so general an influence upon sinners as an earthquake.&equo; 
 He included accounts of the eruptions of Etna and Vesuvius in his Compendium of Natural Philosophy . 
 In the nineteenth century men began to regard these phenomena with more composure, especially if they lived in northern climes where the earth's crust was relatively  secure. 
 In 1855, when there was another cholera epidemic, Charles Kingsley approved of the refusal of Palmerston to order a national day of fasting and repentance. 
 Kingsley denied that God should be held responsible for evils attributable to &bquo;man's selfishness, laziness and ignorance.&equo; 
 Yet when he came to write the chapters on earthquakes and volcanos in Madam How and Lady Why  (1869), he could not dismiss from his mind the notion that, underlying the scientific explanation of how these disasters occurred, God must have had a reason for permitting them. 
 In August 1868 there had been terrible earthquakes in the Andean foothills of Peru and Ecuador, which were estimated to have cost some 25,000 lives; these events made some stir in London and &pound;11,000 was collected to relieve suffering. 
 &bquo;We may guess at something like a good reason for the terrible earthquakes in South America,&equo; observed Kingsley. 
 &bquo;I do not wish to be hard upon poor people in great affliction; but I cannot help thinking that they have been doing for hundreds of years past something very like what the Bible calls &bquo;tempting God'&equo; &mdash; staking their property and their lives upon the chances or no earthquakes coming, while they ought to have known that an earthquake might come an day.&equo; 
 Among the forward-looking theologians who were trying to come to terms with the new scientific data was the Dean of St Paul's, Canon H.L. Mansel, who gave the Bampton Lectures in 1858. 
 He began by distinguishing between destructive mass phenomena, such as we have been discussing, and the destinies of individuals: &bquo;Divine Providence&hellip; under the twofold aspect of General Law and Special Interposition.&equo; 
 He then continued: 
 &bquo;However much analogy may lead us to conjecture the universal prevalence of law and orderly sequence, it has been acutely remarked that the phenomena which are most immediately important to the life and welfare of man are precisely those which he has never been, and probably  never will be, able to reduce to a scientific calculation. 
 The astronomer, who can predict the exact position of a planet in the heavens one thousand years hence, knows not what may be his own state of health tomorrow&hellip;&equo; 
 It was a shrewd thrust, bringing home to the sceptics the Pascalian contrast between the littleness of man, for all his ingenuity, and the immensity of the universe. 
 It also confronted them with the disagreeable fact that at any moment some disorder in their own sensory apparatus would cause that universe, ostensibly so orderly and so stable, to disappear. 
 In short, Mansel was leading the argument back from the generalities of science to the particularities of individual destiny, which constitute the essence of religion. 
 It had been a conspicuous feature of the Wesleyan and Evangelical revival to illustrate the operation of God's grace by drawing attention to divine intervention in the lives of the elect. 
 Richard Cecil frequently insisted on this &bquo;doctrine of a particular providence&equo;, writing in his sermon notes: 
 &bquo;Oh that we regarded not only the God who governs the stars, but the God of minute providences &mdash; the Overruler of moments! 
 So that not even a sparrow shall fall to the ground unnoticed by Him&equo;. 
 Cecil's most popular publication was his life of his friend the Rev.John Newton (1725&ndash;1807); in the preface he writes that his decision to undertake this work arose 
 &bquo;when I considered how striking a display such a life affords of the nature of true religion &mdash; of the power of divine grace &mdash; of the mysterious but all-wise course of Divine Providence &mdash; and of the encouragement afforded for our dependance upon that Providence in the most trying circumstances&hellip; &bquo; 
 Newton was one of the great heroes of the Evangelical movement, partly because of his friendship with the poet Cowper, and partly because the vagaries of his career presented so striking an example of a sinner saved. 
 It was common form for converts who had led relatively blameless lives to condemn, as Newton did, &bquo;the impiety and profaneness&equo; of their unregenerate days; but in his case there were the hard facts of his voyages in slave ships to the West Coast of Africa, on one of which he had been abandoned to his fate and only rescued through a combination of circumstances that indeed seemed to be almost miraculous. 
 After he had given up the slave trade and was already hoping to be ordained, he was appointed tide-surveyor in the port of Liverpool with duties that included the inspection of incoming vessels. 
 On one occasion he was about to go on board a ship that had just anchored when unforeseen business detained him. 
 When he eventually embarked to be rowed out to the ship, &bquo;it blew up just before he reached her, it appears that, if he had left the shore a few minutes sooner, he must have perished with the rest on board&equo; 
 The annals of war were combed for accounts of the near-miraculous escapes of pious persons. 
 The Rev H.P. Wright, who was a chaplain in the Crimea, always carried in his breast-pocket a prayer-book given to him by a devout family nurse. 
 At the battle of the Alma, he came under fire at close range but survived. 
 He afterwards &bquo;found the ball flattened that would otherwise have passed through his heart&equo;; the prayer-book had saved him. 
 Would one of the Waverley novels have served the same purpose? 
 No religious person would have thought so. 
 In October 1881 fearful storms swept the coasts of Britain, and thirty-one fishing vessels from Eyemouth, near Berwick, went down with the loss of 129 lives. 
 George Collins of Eyemouth steered White Star  into the eye of the storm, singing &bquo;Jesu, Lover of my soul&equo;, and forty hours later brought her safely into the Tyne. 
 Would the ship's company have been saved if he had been singing a hit from the music-halls? 
 For those in desperate straits the line between superstition and saving faith is finely drawn. 
